question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>Let $\mathbf{X}=(X_1,X_2,\ldots,X_{2k})$ be a sample from normal distribution $\mathcal{N}(0,1)$.</p> <p>Prove that distribution of sample median (for even sample) is symmetric around 0.</p> <p>$me(\mathbf{X}) = \frac{X_{k:2k}+X_{(k+1):2k}}{2}$, where $X_{i:2k}$ is $i$-th order statistic.</p> <p>I was trying to use formula $f_{X_{k:n}}(x) =\frac{n!}{(k-1)!(n-k)!}[F_X(x)]^{k-1}[1-F_X(x)]^{n-k} f_X(x)$, but without any success (maybe there is a way to do it differently than finding $me(\mathbf{X})$ distribution?</p>
74,468
[ -0.04690239578485489, -0.01116158813238144, 0.0024389871396124363, 0.0080667519941926, 0.04112715646624565, 0.03334137797355652, -0.014286230318248272, 0.010863245464861393, -0.0015636312309652567, -0.06564974039793015, 0.03026849776506424, 0.014728142879903316, 0.028059281408786774, 0.02460741624236107, 0.02609276957809925, 0.0072181811556220055, -0.03360407426953316, 0.04091024026274681, -0.009599997662007809, -0.03161139786243439, 0.019683614373207092, 0.03708556294441223, 0.03902837261557579, -0.0010208457242697477, -0.036765262484550476, 0.02602403238415718, 0.008808627724647522, -0.031246712431311607, 0.030544325709342957, 0.06015711650252342, -0.041480619460344315, -0.010730484500527382, 0.020435314625501633, 0.04276498034596443, 0.03189162537455559, 0.03915330395102501, 0.008066875860095024, -0.025049496442079544, 0.021449128165841103, -0.0023622652515769005, -0.027711771428585052, -0.01858239434659481, 0.027522405609488487, -0.010933849029242992, -0.004851217847317457, 0.007071829866617918, -0.008783475495874882, -0.05547047033905983, 0.040192652493715286, -0.03747376799583435, 0.07992776483297348, -0.017200341448187828, 0.044346798211336136, -0.0005132323130965233, -0.02446361817419529, -0.023412497714161873, 0.031185131520032883, 0.058051496744155884, 0.019121112301945686, -0.02544250898063183, -0.00023982911079656333, -0.04760078340768814, -0.010614681988954544, -0.020185763016343117, -0.05510103330016136, 0.007776107173413038, 0.000788210250902921, 0.012978260405361652, 0.02502158097922802, -0.0006868496420793235, 0.0038892298471182585, 0.0407789908349514, 0.023070890456438065, -0.03368886560201645, -0.008758279494941235, -0.021157030016183853, 0.03327399864792824, -0.022482896223664284, 0.03468458727002144, 0.012156227603554726, 0.01548340916633606, 0.017933350056409836, 0.04047110304236412, 0.024879753589630127, 0.0023661255836486816, -0.012605894356966019, 0.07347849756479263, -0.00452843401581049, 0.04549144580960274, 0.01888852007687092, 0.006073504686355591, -0.005392271094024181, 0.06648990511894226, -0.054156553000211716, -0.04174051061272621, 0.02943243645131588, -0.022179700434207916, 0.024717193096876144, -0.018434345722198486, 0.0039028108585625887, -0.012950100004673004, -0.06593137234449387, 0.007804912980645895, 0.06870412081480026, -0.02213253453373909, 0.004177660681307316, -0.03350190818309784, -0.0012393241049721837, 0.004302693996578455, 0.00024440139532089233, -0.0030862160492688417, 0.011800172738730907, -0.00007260909478645772, -0.015032586641609669, 0.018201906234025955, -0.006385522428900003, 0.0014076420338824391, -0.021476535126566887, 0.045559655874967575, 0.04871506989002228, 0.030101915821433067, -0.0013676544185727835, 0.054023198783397675, -0.04260844737291336, -0.015743045136332512, -0.009882453829050064, 0.022047480568289757, -0.011276737786829472, -0.03711112216114998, 0.028184298425912857, 0.023187221959233284, 0.017056280747056007, 0.042405471205711365, 0.02468973398208618, 0.039437610656023026, 0.0017671011155471206, -0.06779846549034119, -0.022076742723584175, 0.054032351821660995, -0.025884240865707397, -0.000992743531242013, -0.05875494331121445, -0.0025259405374526978, 0.05546578764915466, 0.02112250216305256, 0.030127916485071182, 0.039988767355680466, -0.031025301665067673, 0.0302454624325037, 0.020755542442202568, -0.006857987027615309, -0.04024866223335266, 0.01802126131951809, -0.04338428005576134, -0.008343130350112915, -0.06537316739559174, 0.022684577852487564, -0.004117940552532673, -0.01994611695408821, -0.04948985204100609, 0.07497323304414749, 0.028623368591070175, -0.01597880758345127, -0.03482865169644356, 0.028052762150764465, -0.021475479006767273, 0.07463749498128891, 0.013715531677007675, 0.034852899610996246, -0.0036456710658967495, -0.03267756849527359, 0.03845269978046417, 0.011297610588371754, 0.01658397540450096, 0.036488551646471024, -0.056798774749040604, -0.015439965762197971, -0.02930646948516369, 0.03483196347951889, 0.0408329963684082, -0.017941387370228767, 0.011454526335000992, -0.022015327587723732, -0.015134971588850021, 0.026953278109431267, 0.0023086383007466793, 0.00403386726975441, 0.008828339166939259, 0.04577222838997841, -0.04422512277960777, 0.0011536338133737445, -0.03617190197110176, -0.025658491998910904, -0.002328649163246155, -0.08582144230604172, 0.013538992963731289, 0.00010296834079781547, 0.030953150242567062, -0.007554676383733749, -0.01629861444234848, 0.01110415905714035, -0.0263945534825325, 0.050863415002822876, -0.046390630304813385, 0.01814444549381733, 0.05121349170804024, 0.028304750099778175, -0.019174644723534584, 0.03290873020887375, -0.021310152485966682, -0.036818452179431915, 0.00794418714940548, -0.04181872680783272, 0.010076578706502914, -0.00001859551775851287, 0.017413092777132988, 0.015872955322265625, -0.007332861889153719, -0.004186403471976519, 0.047555409371852875, -0.037472087889909744, 0.06799973547458649, 0.0813731849193573, 0.028523331508040428, 0.009176579304039478, -0.02359367348253727, 0.035588767379522324, -0.005863163620233536, 0.0035441170912235975, -0.04113009199500084, -0.03911632299423218, -0.02549758180975914, 0.01656792312860489, 0.023325851187109947, -0.066105917096138, 0.016580164432525635, 0.05317584052681923, 0.000048130055802175775, 0.026876626536250114, 0.01821129582822323, -0.00946261826902628, -0.04346078261733055, 0.0021796412765979767, 0.013871006667613983, 0.013684184290468693, 0.010754496790468693, 0.0031744297593832016, -0.008349345996975899, 0.03250270336866379, 0.002754101762548089, 0.011329731903970242, 0.039520181715488434, 0.01218683086335659, 0.030413992702960968, 0.010065300390124321, -0.002950555644929409, 0.005911414511501789, 0.008370614610612392, -0.019179068505764008, 0.0406591035425663, -0.0045627267099916935, 0.04139254614710808, 0.010426039807498455, -0.018707741051912308, 0.013372331857681274, 0.0007307745981961489, -0.031036624684929848, -0.02432948537170887, 0.028772247955203056, -0.030864981934428215, -0.015255616046488285, -0.019652748480439186, -0.038419317454099655, 0.006609947420656681, -0.038940299302339554, 0.04189199581742287, 0.0074937716126441956, -0.0163734033703804, 0.026175448670983315, 0.016675397753715515, 0.003031231928616762, 0.021988244727253914, 0.008903839625418186, -0.017381243407726288, -0.060919471085071564, 0.006572717800736427, -0.009194501675665379, -0.023801520466804504, 0.018198270350694656, 0.021475899964571, -0.006203033495694399, 0.030290625989437103, 0.022663261741399765, -0.06875580549240112, -0.00941437017172575, -0.014831917360424995, 0.0034451643005013466, -0.05360517278313637, -0.03419142961502075, 0.04882799834012985, 0.011989823542535305, -0.05479181185364723, 0.04938695207238197, 0.004856042563915253, -0.03301934152841568, -0.06296941637992859, 0.007061876356601715, 0.017460428178310394, -0.00659544812515378, 0.016458731144666672, 0.004050275776535273, 0.020565012469887733, -0.015816837549209595, -0.07774022966623306, -0.036105506122112274, -0.013359424658119678, -0.006796711590141058, 0.04803330823779106, 0.024257488548755646, -0.0305222999304533, 0.07161418348550797, 0.07327300310134888, 0.02122536301612854, -0.017947746440768242, -0.025637220591306686, -0.022789089009165764, -0.029122978448867798, 0.03401463106274605, 0.012332092970609665, 0.007983890362083912, 0.028630660846829414, 0.005459640175104141, 0.03526049107313156, 0.06148083880543709, -0.03311317041516304, -0.031294841319322586, 0.021037476137280464, 0.0021091594826430082, -0.0026590232737362385, 0.04798656329512596, 0.003790693823248148, -0.00878372136503458, 0.002810955746099353, 0.04422561824321747, 0.014516771771013737, 0.015470695681869984, -0.02372226119041443, 0.04077133163809776, -0.02908965013921261, -0.02090650610625744, -0.03768652677536011, 0.016873963177204132, 0.019416509196162224, -0.02864973619580269, -0.00695654284209013, -0.004342176485806704, 0.003194131888449192, -0.02576996013522148, 0.002735012909397483, 0.03532474860548973, 0.04237861931324005, -0.016732698306441307, -0.014414137229323387, -0.029284294694662094, -0.02419843152165413, 0.003071459010243416, -0.013427656143903732, 0.0023501249961555004, 0.019716694951057434, 0.05861680582165718, 0.013453680090606213, -0.017437798902392387, -0.006883728783577681, -0.004574518650770187, -0.014359548687934875, 0.013077087700366974, 0.006814478896558285, 0.045161765068769455, 0.008562149479985237, 0.02994447760283947, 0.02304747700691223, -0.009349067695438862, -0.019183995202183723, 0.017333611845970154, -0.02042120322585106, 0.015093282796442509, -0.043368637561798096, 0.01950507052242756, -0.04373735189437866, -0.024967340752482414, -0.015025012195110321, 0.007232148200273514, 0.02127724140882492, 0.008719762787222862, 0.017750415951013565, -0.01644452102482319, -0.018228013068437576, -0.019456323236227036, -0.032129839062690735, 0.0004878560430370271, 0.032997433096170425, 0.025149719789624214, -0.029065264388918877, 0.02046128176152706, 0.014983370900154114, 0.012873093597590923, -0.0172884464263916, -0.03576846793293953, 0.00321632856503129, 0.020097341388463974, 0.018296603113412857, 0.009937402792274952, 0.003616115776821971, -0.049052849411964417, 0.038220785558223724, -0.025583315640687943, 0.07171068340539932, 0.04996223375201225, -0.012000064365565777, 0.0010620944667607546, -0.0182513315230608, -0.036986034363508224, -0.005348509643226862, 0.012285709381103516, -0.018731357529759407, 0.01215618010610342, 0.043010611087083817, 0.031247418373823166, -0.05056598782539368, 0.004178181756287813, 0.05460653454065323, 0.016039298847317696, 0.03114350698888302, -0.03258945047855377, 0.011371767148375511, -0.04096358269453049, -0.004817213397473097, 0.007663787342607975, -0.007299643941223621, 0.022925054654479027, 0.0028449404053390026, 0.04030299559235573, 0.017713116481900215, -0.0055660055950284, -0.018757261335849762, 0.012533635832369328, 0.04307473078370094, 0.00031651544850319624, -0.022625818848609924, 0.0032787614036351442, 0.030085112899541855, 0.016239503398537636, 0.02363685704767704, 0.01756277121603489, -0.04647163674235344, -0.00008518576942151412, 0.004058117046952248, 0.03340993821620941, -0.013592788018286228, 0.032101403921842575, -0.05266159027814865, -0.0018902502488344908, 0.03488137200474739, -0.02325505204498768, 0.03171463683247566, -0.03833889961242676, 0.012295407243072987, -0.036520443856716156, 0.017763487994670868, -0.05495463311672211, 0.015353460796177387, -0.009530109353363514, 0.0030730068683624268, -0.0009822171414270997, 0.0126293720677495, -0.07882990688085556, -0.0015307706780731678, -0.007349018007516861, 0.06900016218423843, 0.006611044052988291, -0.02813604287803173, 0.009628282859921455, 0.0037376955151557922, -0.03470643609762192, -0.0915311649441719, 0.015285578556358814, -0.015676090493798256, 0.023695621639490128, 0.05207127332687378, -0.031471651047468185, -0.031854644417762756, 0.04732354357838631, 0.030267124995589256, -0.01556421723216772, 0.014287610538303852, -0.03047991544008255, 0.018841439858078957, 0.04544495418667793, -0.012678047642111778, 0.06420645117759705, 0.040609948337078094, 0.009716028347611427, 0.014330746605992317, 0.008534937165677547, 0.013910145498812199, -0.026249747723340988, -0.026867948472499847, -0.04001459851861, 0.022331759333610535, -0.05248245596885681, -0.001915777800604701, -0.009247283451259136, 0.04163310304284096, 0.0039117480628192425, -0.005358225665986538, 0.01317757647484541, 0.026680395007133484, 0.02419137954711914, 0.01411682739853859, -0.009113811887800694, 0.0281598549336195, 0.012628791853785515, -0.016155485063791275, 0.027649689465761185, -0.017388995736837387, -0.010350187309086323, 0.0011036705691367388, -0.00694608548656106, 0.02332546003162861, -0.047806914895772934, -0.03857305645942688, -0.025101372972130775, 0.020223155617713928, 0.012982509098947048, -0.010684410110116005, 0.010431057773530483, 0.04754750803112984, -0.02900066040456295, -0.009582417085766792, 0.057007256895303726, 0.009145905263721943, 0.024099962785840034, -0.03373030945658684, 0.01734151318669319, 0.02778230980038643, -0.017363166436553, -0.11577171832323074, -0.03627615422010422, -0.0040620313957333565, -0.016780169680714607, -0.006007425021380186, -0.05780482292175293, -0.011756131425499916, 0.031175067648291588, -0.009708695113658905, 0.03583783656358719, 0.041977401822805405, 0.01899178884923458, -0.05713743343949318, -0.022904489189386368, -0.007418997585773468, 0.07591608911752701, -0.024665703997015953, -0.03683220595121384, 0.02462349273264408, -0.037478383630514145, -0.03335185348987579, 0.012363262474536896, 0.0036046630702912807, -0.017698725685477257, 0.028151117265224457, -0.024164637550711632, -0.01713705249130726, -0.003210746916010976, 0.008270827122032642, -0.07071340084075928, 0.01954525150358677, 0.026687659323215485, 0.011676828376948833, -0.0430544950067997, -0.04549715295433998, 0.014889487996697426, -0.00663869408890605, -0.019451206550002098, -0.00081327382940799, -0.013499324209988117, -0.0039229197427630424, 0.036573950201272964, 0.0007591962930746377, -0.011516169644892216, -0.00048100959975272417, 0.05855759605765343, -0.0014387500705197453, 0.009207449853420258, 0.009577500633895397, -0.04753497615456581, 0.012520329095423222, 0.01831652596592903, -0.03687238320708275, -0.03228635713458061, 0.009903145022690296, -0.02203664556145668, -0.019225509837269783, -0.03757009282708168, 0.05067262426018715, 0.03597424551844597, -0.021125303581357002, 0.0273443516343832, 0.03485897183418274, 0.011817201040685177, -0.012364834547042847, -0.010643130168318748, -0.03257462754845619, -0.03089756704866886, -0.0019549818243831396, 0.058479566127061844, -0.007501052692532539, 0.029517201706767082, 0.03818051517009735, 0.04016260802745819, -0.013095189817249775, 0.010400835424661636, 0.04448125138878822, -0.015524023212492466, 0.031811248511075974, -0.009720331989228725, -0.026819268241524696, 0.048047371208667755, -0.027508016675710678, 0.03261078521609306, -0.008700854144990444, -0.030809303745627403, 0.03931000083684921, 0.013724093325436115, 0.009729618206620216, -0.024067150428891182, -0.04303921386599541, -0.014778439886868, -0.0023196283727884293, -0.0018020464340224862, 0.015766868367791176, 0.04701114073395729, 0.016732752323150635, 0.04492952302098274, -0.03153223171830177, 0.02211950160562992, -0.00006300431414274499, -0.031946707516908646, -0.036354515701532364, -0.0002671009860932827, -0.0694960281252861, 0.014235293492674828, -0.02442387118935585, -0.026162924244999886, 0.023943163454532623, -0.010974331758916378, 0.016707144677639008, 0.007006700150668621, 0.004001382272690535, -0.007665748242288828, 0.07972521334886551, 0.027190081775188446, 0.012434995733201504, 0.034956369549036026, -0.02928888611495495, 0.11063840985298157, 0.022383438423275948, 0.042550090700387955, -0.06892336159944534, 0.02920457161962986, -0.009754479862749577, -0.012750969268381596, -0.03112955018877983, 0.003136951709166169, -0.0008012019679881632, 0.014475693926215172, 0.035542502999305725, 0.06005563586950302, 0.015786267817020416, -0.017702016979455948, 0.044945456087589264, -0.03064682148396969, -0.05153261870145798, -0.012932184152305126, 0.010546303354203701, 0.011243010871112347, -0.011482245288789272, -0.05851501226425171, 0.037420134991407394, -0.008261101320385933, -0.009275581687688828, -0.027419572696089745, -0.014030439779162407, -0.01488024927675724, -0.026899022981524467, -0.00688358535990119, 0.0010809178929775953, 0.04965194687247276, -0.02358640916645527, 0.004610468167811632, -0.04625263437628746, 0.003492142539471388, -0.0439409576356411, 0.04356139898300171, 0.03390035778284073, 0.013861633837223053, 0.01685194857418537, 0.050677765160799026, -0.010281508788466454, -0.058880556374788284, -0.019559672102332115, -0.03342627361416817, 0.006089096888899803, 0.001364438678137958, 0.0020466619171202183, -0.014147334732115269, -0.0176992304623127, -0.016183994710445404, -0.054398659616708755, -0.005440559238195419, 0.02800857648253441, 0.05276819318532944, -0.051183901727199554, -0.021334432065486908, -0.02530135028064251, 0.025094985961914062, 0.011288595385849476, -0.004184185527265072, 0.034414853900671005, -0.024747803807258606, -0.009030807763338089, -0.02508554980158806, 0.046766314655542374, 0.01784387044608593, -0.018398184329271317, -0.0377773754298687, -0.047681838274002075, -0.01211964525282383, 0.00800721812993288, -0.013062085956335068, -0.03578507900238037, 0.057940077036619186, 0.005025485996156931, -0.017190244048833847, 0.004563492257148027, -0.03503844141960144, 0.015238536521792412, -0.033547159284353256, 0.01674460992217064, -0.05244032293558121, -0.01506776548922062, 0.011816739104688168, 0.03307424858212471, 0.05495716258883476, 0.018793588504195213, 0.014726651832461357, 0.038867224007844925, 0.0089747728779912, -0.04544046148657799, -0.02111652120947838, 0.005825825966894627, -0.02043672651052475, 0.02563520520925522, -0.029380956664681435, 0.05351756140589714, 0.03021387569606304, 0.010768203064799309, 0.02269354835152626, 0.010055982507765293, -0.015218086540699005, 0.01220838725566864, 0.006288578733801842, -0.04110346734523773, 0.04717296361923218, 0.029920252040028572, 0.0030246926471590996, -0.05768100544810295, -0.03381578251719475, -0.007689375896006823, -0.03700124844908714, 0.02565920725464821, -0.0032442964147776365, -0.03701075166463852, -0.030317556113004684, -0.04706582799553871, -0.001426661154255271, -0.026309851557016373, -0.029047343879938126, 0.005103034898638725, -0.00895953644067049, -0.0357111394405365, 0.002643803833052516, -0.015972524881362915, 0.020368654280900955, 0.004539831541478634, -0.0113981319591403, 0.07253393530845642, 0.032396432012319565, 0.0291568785905838, 0.0076527283526957035, 0.022692423313856125, -0.010584828443825245, 0.03657184913754463, -0.017414450645446777, 0.030707944184541702, 0.06623206287622452, -0.03758974373340607, -0.03426281735301018, -0.011857911944389343, 0.04989760369062424, 0.009946384467184544, -0.0047265165485441685, 0.009110735729336739, -0.03741356357932091, 0.01872355490922928, -0.055726971477270126, -0.01999717950820923, -0.03531680256128311, 0.011888490058481693, 0.022096332162618637, -0.032911233603954315, -0.03439931944012642, -0.044068556278944016, -0.01804463565349579, 0.022696547210216522, 0.03221437335014343, 0.0044281985610723495, -0.02823241986334324, 0.05018645524978638, 0.013108349405229092, 0.006785112898796797, -0.011653082445263863, -0.001238577300682664, 0.02547699399292469, 0.042621079832315445, -0.010695207864046097, 0.042619336396455765, -0.06132473796606064, -0.0027734702453017235, -0.10412736237049103, -0.03529640659689903, 0.01471304427832365, -0.0019080115016549826, 0.05575039982795715, -0.02964269369840622, -0.05033130198717117, 0.0005578789860010147, -0.03526012599468231, 0.039516422897577286, 0.008153572678565979, -0.03515567258000374, -0.038929443806409836, 0.003692966653034091, -0.035475533455610275, 0.050679925829172134, 0.02487770840525627, 0.05423887446522713, 0.050597723573446274, 0.02984309382736683, -0.006030248012393713, 0.01581970416009426, 0.006330893840640783, 0.005544350482523441, 0.03272218257188797, -0.06388912349939346, 0.035775478929281235, -0.0038957830984145403, -0.01901526190340519, 0.045701101422309875, -0.012381467036902905, -0.028718948364257812, 0.03339601680636406, 0.018273262307047844, -0.0035145895089954138, 0.057327061891555786, -0.009584487415850163, 0.03518322855234146, 0.007571975234895945, 0.010750954039394855, 0.061439644545316696, 0.03254656121134758, -0.032065704464912415, 0.005191632080823183, 0.0724320337176323, -0.01089882105588913, -0.03325394541025162, 0.02348901890218258, -0.007119395770132542, -0.05895335599780083, 0.005319333169609308, -0.03185061737895012, -0.004280305001884699, -0.0051355427131056786, 0.08237981796264648, -0.0243636853992939, -0.016484541818499565, 0.014242789708077908, 0.03435361385345459, -0.027400605380535126, 0.00499309366568923, 0.02041282132267952, -0.02639869414269924, 0.017278777435421944, -0.0022260595578700304, -0.007912357337772846, -0.049887798726558685, -0.024700507521629333, 0.006036560516804457, 0.023062890395522118, -0.048190899193286896, -0.028606737032532692, -0.03915482014417648, 0.036211706697940826, -0.015445368364453316, 0.0036731644067913294, 0.013388584367930889, 0.0015516381245106459, -0.00016324564057867974, -0.0671515017747879, 0.03542857989668846, 0.029793787747621536, 0.0031566699035465717, -0.0312577448785305, -0.006218246649950743, -0.028793612495064735, 0.010768218897283077, 0.05714782327413559, 0.03231731057167053, 0.000628691806923598, -0.00628427742049098, 0.030499743297696114, 0.033239010721445084, -0.07965022325515747, 0.025486964732408524, -0.0184073094278574, -0.05486924573779106, -0.0023225885815918446, -0.015472677536308765, -0.013267917558550835, 0.019727732986211777, -0.016975827515125275, 0.006863967049866915, 0.020320549607276917, -0.0067117358557879925, -0.01995699480175972, 0.02760602906346321, -0.016883106902241707, -0.03906501457095146, 0.04476846382021904, -0.031670235097408295, 0.02812311425805092, -0.01897536963224411, 0.018233230337500572, -0.09790123254060745, 0.004724627826362848, -0.07374563068151474, -0.06003239378333092, -0.030279289931058884, -0.011591124348342419, -0.0014335948508232832, -0.01957533322274685, -0.06146370247006416, 0.00428058160468936, -0.07174587994813919, -0.005977228283882141, 0.043239086866378784, 0.021921539679169655, 0.020113732665777206, 0.01558692753314972, 0.00040742248529568315, -0.0019808728247880936, -0.01055182609707117, 0.027111435309052467, -0.007184222806245089, -0.021214652806520462, -0.01512504369020462, 0.011547164060175419, 0.007640916854143143, -0.02416570484638214, 0.03953026235103607, 0.027067406103014946, 0.022347314283251762, 0.007278522476553917, -0.03231855854392052, 0.032333604991436005, -0.014492524787783623, 0.0373808816075325, -0.007499355357140303, 0.015412220731377602, 0.05074351280927658, -0.004772462882101536, 0.03599889203906059, -0.020037613809108734, -0.012632603757083416, -0.0537092350423336, -0.033845629543066025, 0.012585701420903206, 0.006202850490808487, -0.05198286846280098, 0.017917172983288765, 0.017551157623529434, 0.02984164096415043, 0.056483056396245956, -0.033044155687093735, 0.0359901487827301, 0.015035351738333702, -0.016809333115816116, -0.01805001311004162, -0.024844789877533913, -0.02768351137638092, -0.05992606654763222, 0.011325857602059841, 0.0328415222465992, 0.01692209392786026, 0.012652408331632614, 0.008478428237140179, -0.013278183527290821, 0.10078892111778259, -0.08161895722150803, -0.05091981217265129, -0.045243848115205765, -0.0014256727881729603, -0.02704324759542942, -0.014578988775610924 ]
<p>In a multiple regression analysis (with 4 continuous predictors and 2 categorical factors), we mean centered the data (for each continuous variable) due to issues of multicollinearity when the interaction terms are included. </p> <p>My question is whether I can center the response variable too. </p> <p>More specifically, the response variable and the 4 continuous predictors are all averaged survey responses (using scales of 1 to 5). I originally thought that if I were centering the explanatory variables, I might as well center the response.. but I realize that most references to centering seem to only apply to the predictor variables. </p> <p>Any help is much appreciated.</p> <p><strong>Update</strong>: as I mentioned in an earlier comment, I questioned the validity of centering my response variable due to having different ANOVA results using centered versus non-centered response. My interpretation is that the linear model for a non-centered response (using the lm() in R) uses the mean of the 'reference level' of my two factors for computing the intercept. When I centered the response variable, it's being subtracted from the grand mean of this variable, rather than the mean of the reference level. Now I've verified that by 'centering' using the reference level mean and it does indeed yield identical results for p-values as the non-centered response model. I hope I am interpreting this issue correctly. IF someone could further confirm/clarify this I would really appreciate that. </p>
74,469
[ -0.06099410355091095, 0.013843012973666191, 0.0033397849183529615, 0.037811875343322754, 0.05539417266845703, -0.010138661600649357, -0.003120514564216137, -0.019651835784316063, 0.022373095154762268, -0.06237810105085373, 0.021361378952860832, 0.019264282658696175, 0.04734252020716667, -0.01957225799560547, -0.0032117555383592844, 0.006019479129463434, -0.002579338615760207, 0.018735118210315704, 0.013527272269129753, -0.016693713143467903, -0.014506526291370392, 0.016533469781279564, -0.01257762685418129, -0.0019837485160678625, -0.040694065392017365, 0.07604517787694931, 0.01280253566801548, -0.027362197637557983, -0.010218135081231594, 0.024029411375522614, -0.016380183398723602, -0.011834627017378807, -0.009499563835561275, 0.02898145467042923, 0.0051317643374204636, 0.017739443108439445, -0.009757602587342262, 0.004730753600597382, -0.010813797824084759, 0.05622455105185509, -0.001816146308556199, -0.034855619072914124, -0.00594370299950242, 0.03707614913582802, -0.011104959063231945, -0.023754850029945374, -0.01639486476778984, -0.00002028025483014062, 0.04571612924337387, -0.030703140422701836, 0.08523452281951904, 0.012337179854512215, 0.012367512099444866, 0.032272566109895706, -0.039321307092905045, -0.025777865201234818, 0.05913450941443443, 0.05800300091505051, 0.010227187536656857, -0.04187493026256561, 0.00017668270447757095, -0.0021983615588396788, 0.02090507373213768, -0.0016375285340473056, -0.026450516656041145, 0.0005887695006094873, 0.00407949136570096, -0.011904457584023476, 0.030343515798449516, -0.01221061684191227, -0.006669234950095415, 0.020820070058107376, 0.07625705003738403, -0.013609157875180244, 0.022551361471414566, -0.02084193378686905, 0.02408248744904995, 0.018027527257800102, 0.031960826367139816, 0.03372056782245636, -0.017401637509465218, 0.00696767121553421, 0.0008422813843935728, 0.042300641536712646, 0.01779128611087799, 0.005010712891817093, 0.05250343680381775, -0.012956258840858936, 0.016008319333195686, 0.03773846477270126, -0.0300555769354105, -0.012712731026113033, 0.04488274082541466, -0.0038318131119012833, -0.0451575331389904, 0.04205946624279022, -0.0047977217473089695, 0.05261578783392906, 0.019856419414281845, 0.01711915247142315, -0.0005812107119709253, -0.005853715818375349, -0.013937427662312984, 0.012055352330207825, -0.015146386809647083, 0.014457290060818195, -0.06488598883152008, -0.004142811056226492, 0.017232928425073624, -0.0515621118247509, -0.029425090178847313, 0.007145287934690714, -0.023404419422149658, -0.023567620664834976, 0.033242225646972656, -0.02673862874507904, -0.015387449413537979, -0.015832213684916496, 0.060606930404901505, 0.03793738782405853, 0.012952861376106739, -0.05576040968298912, 0.007085378281772137, -0.026375120505690575, -0.020357033237814903, -0.013552478514611721, 0.013260205276310444, 0.002136767143383622, -0.004841788671910763, 0.054732080549001694, 0.033118318766355515, -0.00022434671700466424, 0.02177516184747219, 0.03587978705763817, 0.012712357565760612, 0.01551109366118908, -0.0779646784067154, -0.059080928564071655, 0.022344442084431648, -0.012321103364229202, -0.015761569142341614, -0.07466977834701538, -0.03553616255521774, 0.013374891132116318, 0.03309525549411774, 0.00653949286788702, 0.010725251398980618, 0.016302119940519333, 0.044181495904922485, 0.023421434685587883, -0.04570912569761276, -0.02824135310947895, -0.049749668687582016, -0.03982924297451973, -0.05512576177716255, -0.09018336236476898, 0.003189122537150979, -0.014623300172388554, 0.013019540347158909, 0.03532426804304123, 0.04178515449166298, -0.0025160303339362144, -0.035113733261823654, 0.007106256205588579, 0.019946902990341187, 0.0076999845914542675, 0.05832407996058464, -0.02454671449959278, 0.016839168965816498, 0.013404886238276958, 0.016382068395614624, 0.022702181711792946, -0.01620742678642273, 0.069283626973629, 0.042360562831163406, -0.03903402388095856, 0.017302045598626137, -0.008277061395347118, 0.025831803679466248, 0.006963671650737524, -0.059052422642707825, -0.01403499674052, -0.024988412857055664, -0.015707382932305336, 0.021323248744010925, 0.06646821647882462, -0.023616017773747444, -0.032585855573415756, 0.01432784553617239, -0.02502288483083248, -0.04134668409824371, -0.0576145201921463, 0.03223121538758278, 0.003057563677430153, -0.04046350345015526, 0.049711648374795914, -0.017836041748523712, 0.022548384964466095, -0.016051670536398888, -0.015018893405795097, -0.0013983689714223146, 0.014734482392668724, 0.040275610983371735, -0.048563141375780106, 0.033655136823654175, 0.03810209035873413, 0.05202155560255051, -0.01866072416305542, 0.030649861320853233, -0.02306709811091423, -0.07177142053842545, 0.027177471667528152, -0.027695035561919212, 0.023994997143745422, -0.037207577377557755, -0.01919202320277691, -0.0021474913228303194, 0.0167299285531044, -0.018226372078061104, 0.07206802815198898, -0.07013744115829468, 0.09435279667377472, 0.026439417153596878, -0.0338621512055397, 0.012325804680585861, 0.03796406090259552, 0.013879586011171341, 0.04710138589143753, -0.04555966332554817, -0.007171941455453634, -0.025765733793377876, -0.0470205694437027, 0.026670880615711212, -0.02424926683306694, -0.02157314494252205, -0.007360684219747782, 0.05941249057650566, 0.031124750152230263, 0.034148745238780975, 0.016102006658911705, 0.021439459174871445, -0.03344949707388878, 0.021851660683751106, 0.04085957258939743, -0.01716269738972187, 0.018498778343200684, 0.007730966899544001, -0.010168401524424553, 0.06301126629114151, 0.008382552303373814, 0.02885924093425274, 0.038877326995134354, 0.004522356670349836, 0.002786901080980897, -0.01200297474861145, 0.0001445107045583427, 0.04041066765785217, -0.022871989756822586, 0.019103791564702988, 0.05173933506011963, 0.00003943263800465502, -0.030550558120012283, 0.006161711644381285, -0.03078247793018818, -0.004480123985558748, 0.015390189364552498, -0.0727718397974968, 0.0054162247106432915, 0.008666416630148888, -0.02547946199774742, 0.014933236874639988, -0.02519909478724003, -0.011675538495182991, -0.016087058931589127, 0.006968016270548105, 0.01976143755018711, 0.004181568045169115, -0.008926695212721825, -0.03688270226120949, 0.012032078579068184, -0.022656532004475594, 0.005698857828974724, 0.013672455213963985, 0.015340208075940609, -0.05053909495472908, -0.05727898329496384, -0.04561864957213402, 0.004048794042319059, 0.0092564532533288, -0.0007737394189462066, -0.014962281100451946, 0.03272506222128868, -0.008416171185672283, -0.07289794832468033, -0.020029185339808464, -0.021542638540267944, 0.0032031224109232426, -0.004273693077266216, -0.01556455623358488, 0.0270678848028183, 0.0175698883831501, -0.015362635254859924, 0.04305317625403404, -0.007234199438244104, -0.026240482926368713, -0.017196638509631157, -0.007532636169344187, 0.020966501906514168, 0.005352404434233904, 0.03445344790816307, 0.017933031544089317, -0.03774305805563927, -0.01956634409725666, -0.06063796579837799, -0.03422832489013672, 0.020749937742948532, -0.009383846074342728, 0.03718798980116844, 0.002583960769698024, 0.000034660053643165156, 0.07171984016895294, 0.0358009859919548, -0.01046786829829216, -0.050808411091566086, -0.00542904669418931, -0.027384469285607338, -0.020665496587753296, 0.00696922279894352, 0.024054642766714096, 0.008871074765920639, -0.009804559871554375, -0.02854263037443161, 0.02611757256090641, 0.02176433801651001, 0.022618599236011505, 0.022410016506910324, 0.01787298545241356, 0.0009742124238982797, 0.009286794811487198, 0.0398905947804451, 0.013792644254863262, 0.01949460618197918, -0.0009788906900212169, 0.033802978694438934, 0.024697063490748405, -0.034597717225551605, -0.03130379691720009, 0.018771694973111153, -0.03306567668914795, 0.011326710693538189, -0.03637214004993439, 0.01731068827211857, 0.04133240133523941, -0.034047987312078476, -0.04528127983212471, 0.024331919848918915, 0.038371048867702484, -0.0002249500248581171, 0.023600179702043533, 0.05293988436460495, 0.03206593170762062, 0.011478241533041, -0.004390006884932518, 0.022782009094953537, -0.026089642196893692, 0.04973601922392845, -0.03974677622318268, -0.02516128309071064, 0.06679146736860275, 0.04422109201550484, 0.007593617308884859, -0.007518000900745392, -0.06224970892071724, 0.03064291551709175, -0.07608825713396072, 0.046181753277778625, -0.04147307947278023, 0.01876491867005825, 0.019346795976161957, 0.024877160787582397, 0.02730127051472664, -0.020571788772940636, -0.005888884421437979, 0.014047158882021904, -0.0489015206694603, -0.003778790356591344, -0.013627471402287483, 0.013960737735033035, 0.009943666867911816, -0.025515740737318993, 0.030510736629366875, 0.005377591121941805, 0.03781389817595482, -0.0017823847010731697, 0.028690453618764877, 0.012143154628574848, -0.015759669244289398, -0.0058654663152992725, -0.029882874339818954, -0.018274273723363876, -0.009835234843194485, 0.024891719222068787, -0.02480476163327694, 0.0357678048312664, 0.04531015455722809, -0.04426143690943718, -0.015800565481185913, -0.031069183722138405, -0.007089957129210234, 0.030458735302090645, 0.047829460352659225, 0.06889066100120544, 0.014811208471655846, -0.05807431414723396, 0.02626531943678856, 0.0047769504599273205, 0.03137915953993797, 0.005725931841880083, -0.012402505613863468, -0.0329267755150795, -0.03295545652508736, -0.05319610983133316, 0.00460013747215271, 0.0019015718717128038, -0.01619824394583702, -0.007461534813046455, 0.0887412577867508, 0.028265254572033882, -0.04867153614759445, 0.055273424834012985, 0.025656092911958694, 0.026701943948864937, 0.011921589262783527, -0.06331894546747208, -0.007148985285311937, -0.003425432136282325, -0.00370059534907341, 0.0567811094224453, -0.03884861618280411, 0.006115232594311237, -0.030852006748318672, 0.052370037883520126, -0.02187793143093586, -0.006507177837193012, -0.027706705033779144, 0.008788427338004112, 0.03360436111688614, 0.0038748933002352715, -0.02588612213730812, -0.010267938487231731, 0.035240378230810165, 0.026344001293182373, 0.004103869199752808, -0.0014200835721567273, -0.06182398274540901, -0.005932201165705919, 0.0005094367079436779, 0.03309604525566101, -0.030365221202373505, -0.006493689492344856, 0.0011617017444223166, -0.013365404680371284, 0.01819702982902527, -0.025327324867248535, 0.05015863850712776, -0.017237884923815727, 0.020296765491366386, 0.02323088049888611, -0.014000235125422478, -0.07253418862819672, -0.022935105487704277, -0.03555211424827576, 0.026379527524113655, 0.018815603107213974, -0.029113544151186943, -0.07138121128082275, 0.007398218382149935, -0.007629225496202707, 0.04531735181808472, -0.014111075550317764, -0.027585167437791824, 0.031201539561152458, 0.03073963150382042, 0.014240093529224396, -0.04549191892147064, -0.011881379410624504, -0.0002694348222576082, -0.0010468695545569062, 0.07416030019521713, 0.018996484577655792, -0.023204650729894638, 0.0071442448534071445, 0.03247795253992081, 0.004241252318024635, -0.01536461804062128, -0.01889766752719879, 0.04329094663262367, 0.01350453868508339, -0.024522602558135986, 0.08399650454521179, 0.011334056966006756, 0.013840015046298504, -0.039315786212682724, -0.03657004237174988, 0.018922438845038414, -0.024675648659467697, -0.044416580349206924, 0.003991754725575447, 0.013015336357057095, -0.008757312782108784, 0.033265966922044754, -0.001955384621396661, 0.01928330585360527, -0.04130629822611809, -0.021019810810685158, 0.04433361440896988, -0.0018831713823601604, 0.0021957196295261383, 0.004534546285867691, 0.028264399617910385, -0.0012639688793569803, 0.010606291703879833, -0.03354114666581154, -0.002382235834375024, -0.03043237328529358, 0.004872020799666643, 0.008712575770914555, -0.005197669379413128, -0.008752881549298763, -0.0051579042337834835, -0.02960333041846752, -0.019118811935186386, 0.009965079836547375, 0.014910257421433926, -0.004526734352111816, 0.021607376635074615, -0.01723066158592701, -0.053506895899772644, -0.042545586824417114, 0.03112538903951645, -0.021977944299578667, 0.04862784594297409, -0.032825764268636703, 0.04377654194831848, -0.0037222113460302353, 0.01837170124053955, -0.059277575463056564, -0.04315175488591194, -0.0038626817986369133, 0.005577603355050087, 0.017585044726729393, -0.04469127953052521, -0.03703043609857559, -0.03912942111492157, -0.028938744217157364, -0.00304876989684999, 0.04012810438871384, -0.016002554446458817, -0.03513520583510399, -0.00003071945684496313, 0.033958740532398224, 0.060375019907951355, -0.011620353907346725, -0.014828379265964031, -0.0022188639268279076, 0.002107692649587989, -0.03093547560274601, -0.02221468649804592, 0.02531268820166588, -0.03385872766375542, 0.012736578471958637, -0.005363136064261198, -0.011338047683238983, 0.06316935271024704, -0.0036158370785415173, -0.055184584110975266, 0.010463638231158257, -0.017530985176563263, 0.012152507901191711, -0.03509116917848587, -0.017446137964725494, -0.018396791070699692, -0.02592695690691471, -0.012313207611441612, 0.030769217759370804, -0.03616767376661301, -0.00015952263493090868, 0.02711273729801178, -0.016209309920668602, -0.05819767713546753, 0.025592990219593048, 0.0967601090669632, 0.024383245036005974, 0.06110675632953644, -0.00925629585981369, -0.01900751329958439, 0.048527851700782776, -0.0077985855750739574, -0.005428348667919636, 0.029723187908530235, 0.025684457272291183, -0.015586689114570618, -0.02050827629864216, -0.010434153489768505, 0.007123236078768969, 0.04145904630422592, -0.004412814509123564, 0.045425981283187866, 0.020594438537955284, -0.004831116180866957, -0.004309662617743015, -0.04563411697745323, 0.01860286295413971, 0.0012252794113010168, 0.026082724332809448, 0.08131617307662964, -0.040542617440223694, 0.010859493166208267, 0.03972923383116722, 0.020945372059941292, 0.0033523577731102705, 0.049817852675914764, 0.03951900452375412, 0.015347430482506752, 0.02616008184850216, -0.022365085780620575, -0.05043794587254524, 0.04779234156012535, -0.030370105057954788, 0.009090572595596313, -0.030666939914226532, -0.04997587203979492, 0.018391704186797142, 0.03211260214447975, 0.010694248601794243, -0.0464310422539711, 0.00018641067435964942, 0.004531010054051876, 0.023638900369405746, 0.015688572078943253, -0.00988403707742691, -0.005632041022181511, -0.02229706011712551, 0.04112386703491211, 0.018474407494068146, 0.015430795960128307, -0.04610151797533035, -0.04819934442639351, -0.0390554815530777, -0.03890307992696762, -0.021505534648895264, 0.04027782380580902, -0.021880462765693665, -0.03987807035446167, 0.03798845410346985, -0.06474865227937698, -0.005166081711649895, -0.00038127400330267847, 0.01647266373038292, 0.002252088626846671, 0.049969423562288284, 0.004725801292806864, -0.01660439372062683, -0.006103208288550377, -0.013303183950483799, 0.11673753708600998, 0.10610795766115189, 0.026627222076058388, -0.08634132146835327, 0.016569221392273903, 0.0025866758078336716, 0.022989541292190552, -0.021843193098902702, -0.01587669923901558, -0.039337001740932465, -0.04810497909784317, 0.0479855090379715, 0.07263053208589554, 0.03287666290998459, 0.023465018719434738, 0.057802438735961914, 0.0008539347909390926, 0.003547637490555644, 0.03240785375237465, -0.006937421392649412, 0.011643171310424805, -0.021122831851243973, -0.006536856293678284, 0.016569143161177635, -0.016690487042069435, 0.015013480558991432, -0.05101830139756203, 0.01750200241804123, -0.03318829461932182, 0.002402039710432291, 0.006886223331093788, 0.008601763285696507, -0.0068916152231395245, -0.003536116098985076, -0.032628659158945084, -0.01903458498418331, 0.015183152630925179, -0.03139302134513855, 0.007945285178720951, 0.036634884774684906, -0.03877432271838188, 0.026958489790558815, 0.0007014785660430789, 0.017930813133716583, -0.06568426638841629, -0.029519246891140938, -0.038698960095644, 0.021212803199887276, -0.008305116556584835, -0.031166434288024902, 0.007511766627430916, 0.006113522686064243, 0.013746023178100586, 0.004554782062768936, -0.01602536253631115, 0.03464465215802193, 0.006572984158992767, -0.05131029710173607, -0.014010029844939709, -0.009799876250326633, -0.004464472644031048, 0.00534112099558115, 0.011990685947239399, 0.01613137125968933, -0.034016724675893784, -0.006226635072380304, -0.04956217110157013, 0.04956550896167755, -0.013065540231764317, -0.008869952522218227, 0.012868181802332401, 0.00995852705091238, -0.04772712662816048, -0.010770606808364391, 0.01455097459256649, 0.012657834216952324, 0.037032146006822586, -0.0005392433959059417, 0.008021046407520771, -0.05470398813486099, -0.06724756956100464, -0.009169376455247402, -0.04033150151371956, -0.009710099548101425, -0.03777707368135452, -0.025539608672261238, 0.0041409386321902275, 0.042401932179927826, -0.0052808672189712524, 0.018751731142401695, 0.007093464024364948, 0.027183759957551956, 0.0009082559845410287, -0.05940883979201317, -0.0009752684272825718, 0.0063156140968203545, -0.021673347800970078, 0.014837517403066158, -0.015845652669668198, 0.060086868703365326, 0.006067735143005848, 0.034516166895627975, 0.01611875556409359, 0.025055184960365295, -0.023507898673415184, 0.0057374294847249985, 0.02610383927822113, -0.03748149797320366, 0.013362760655581951, 0.045829638838768005, 0.008119435980916023, 0.0033696668688207865, -0.018445629626512527, -0.04513442888855934, -0.04947935789823532, 0.006560811772942543, -0.03472160920500755, -0.016306065022945404, 0.014665420167148113, -0.03205413371324539, 0.011968963779509068, -0.05019780993461609, -0.04828208312392235, -0.09062789380550385, 0.01144601684063673, -0.0008649802184663713, -0.030498124659061432, 0.028090525418519974, 0.013688459992408752, 0.002750591840595007, 0.027307169511914253, 0.05457678809762001, 0.010373740456998348, 0.009928739629685879, -0.011331675574183464, 0.0007666070596314967, 0.03762401267886162, 0.06203429400920868, -0.014146130532026291, -0.03705557808279991, 0.03651972860097885, -0.0170823372900486, -0.03524612635374069, -0.002986528445035219, 0.021334825083613396, 0.02018042467534542, 0.04529120773077011, 0.04527519270777702, -0.01106708962470293, 0.0589645691215992, -0.010803157463669777, -0.003970998339354992, -0.01951208896934986, -0.01621795818209648, 0.022887298837304115, 0.007440377026796341, 0.015104642137885094, 0.026240944862365723, 0.0020292410627007484, 0.024070510640740395, 0.053388264030218124, -0.0005560471909120679, -0.0004042246728204191, 0.008313319645822048, -0.030103761702775955, -0.005014373920857906, 0.007344363257288933, 0.005596840288490057, -0.0020021426025778055, 0.03030085563659668, -0.028201734647154808, 0.04462195932865143, -0.006488549988716841, 0.018453966826200485, -0.09084217250347137, -0.03843783959746361, -0.00021332732285372913, 0.01762770302593708, 0.03113691695034504, -0.05261656269431114, -0.03049602173268795, 0.02020924724638462, -0.06097770854830742, -0.0023009362630546093, 0.008182166144251823, -0.022816462442278862, -0.030690757557749748, -0.0431993342936039, -0.013354482129216194, 0.020831706002354622, 0.031034784391522408, 0.019131243228912354, 0.003632688894867897, 0.018609685823321342, -0.0036627366207540035, -0.004463515244424343, 0.02787439152598381, 0.02031888999044895, 0.02995358221232891, -0.06349226832389832, 0.024577289819717407, -0.040565840899944305, -0.03714771568775177, 0.04396896809339523, -0.01392727717757225, 0.011326040141284466, 0.02078734152019024, 0.020484905689954758, 0.009616918861865997, 0.06361544132232666, 0.03135545551776886, -0.0013208682648837566, 0.024009060114622116, 0.028934737667441368, 0.00859815813601017, 0.03794657066464424, -0.03412129357457161, -0.012048075906932354, 0.0079634515568614, -0.018435729667544365, -0.016157688573002815, 0.013495256192982197, -0.018692275509238243, -0.005677250679582357, -0.017302269116044044, 0.019755447283387184, 0.016404451802372932, -0.04111701622605324, 0.03720182552933693, -0.044877126812934875, -0.011014390736818314, 0.03557752072811127, 0.007364237681031227, -0.0476112924516201, -0.004962513223290443, 0.007153445854783058, -0.017742108553647995, 0.017503652721643448, 0.0015017224941402674, 0.0066631692461669445, -0.05172062665224075, 0.010481176897883415, -0.01216830499470234, -0.015207720920443535, -0.04283168539404869, -0.04337817803025246, -0.039637818932533264, 0.010572806000709534, -0.031487010419368744, 0.008938267827033997, 0.0059097204357385635, -0.016310490667819977, 0.014810862019658089, -0.08988921344280243, 0.05503528565168381, 0.0171376820653677, -0.006289476994425058, -0.023815307766199112, 0.02236625738441944, -0.07207570225000381, 0.01099124364554882, 0.07281948626041412, 0.02841508947312832, -0.011442159302532673, 0.03928434103727341, 0.02727579139173031, -0.014563963748514652, -0.05147456005215645, 0.01242752280086279, 0.02708384394645691, -0.008083236403763294, -0.011940374039113522, -0.013166218064725399, 0.0052773295901715755, 0.022996937856078148, 0.01624823920428753, -0.00645927619189024, 0.02671571634709835, -0.01108614169061184, 0.014120446518063545, 0.024268148466944695, -0.0038428804837167263, -0.02918202430009842, 0.06277351081371307, 0.01604194939136505, -0.003649455960839987, 0.03190820664167404, -0.0007990828016772866, -0.05177541449666023, 0.01754000596702099, -0.01558377593755722, -0.0004992234171368182, -0.010055463761091232, 0.0514591783285141, 0.0054242885671556, -0.05156921595335007, 0.01493368111550808, 0.019292563199996948, -0.05594426020979881, -0.008932794444262981, 0.03774875029921532, 0.04814789071679115, 0.03798798844218254, 0.002079425612464547, 0.0489821657538414, 0.01190098188817501, -0.03985480219125748, 0.038464464247226715, 0.03366139531135559, 0.047037020325660706, 0.026881283149123192, -0.01576998457312584, 0.026068786159157753, -0.013821393251419067, 0.03254339471459389, -0.04559928551316261, 0.03853357955813408, -0.015934478491544724, -0.02951965667307377, 0.005764493253082037, -0.007691876497119665, 0.02009461261332035, -0.019192054867744446, 0.03423137217760086, 0.03839268535375595, -0.029292095452547073, -0.043795857578516006, -0.014649108052253723, 0.00723686721175909, -0.019526341930031776, -0.005754397250711918, 0.00770003255456686, 0.015090645290911198, 0.013377108611166477, -0.0036113702226430178, 0.0020878217183053493, -0.04932449758052826, 0.007453491911292076, 0.0040678055956959724, 0.021004922688007355, -0.00705815851688385, -0.0018116156570613384, -0.028341718018054962, -0.041776396334171295, -0.0204475000500679, -0.06456194072961807, 0.006582517642527819, 0.04472266882658005, 0.02954600565135479, -0.031691983342170715, 0.008723613806068897, 0.010983902029693127, 0.07210628688335419, -0.050820931792259216, -0.031812265515327454, -0.034017909318208694, -0.011488174088299274, 0.02044420875608921, 0.0011081693228334188 ]
<p>I am studying disturbance caused by ship traffic to a small seabird. I observed focal animals for a set amount of time and record whether or not they fly from the water during the observation. This particular bird does not fly at high probabilities when not disturbed (about 10% of the time). Post hoc, I have appended the distance to the nearest ship to every observation (ships of interest had GPS locators recording a point every 5 sec).</p> <p>I have plotted the cumulative distribution function for ALL observations and for observations where the bird flew from the water as a function of distance to nearest ship. As expected, the majority of the observations in which the bird flew were observed when the ship was close.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/0X3MY.jpg" alt="ecdf plot, fly, did not fly, all obs"></p> <p>Can I use the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test to test if there is a statistical difference in the distribution of the flight observations and the total observations? My thought is if these two distributions are different it would suggest that ship distance has an influence on flight. I worry as these distribution functions are not independent as the flight observations are a subset of the total observations.</p> <p>Thoughts? </p> <p>Having read a bit further on this site I think I can test the distribution of the observations in which flight occurred (F) against the distribution of the observations in which it did not (NF) as these are independent. If these distributions are the same F=NF, then we can assume that the distribution of (F) and (TOT = all observations) are the same as we know that the distribution of (F) is equal to itself and (F)+(T) = (TOT). Right?</p> <p><strong>UPDATE: 2/12/14</strong></p> <p>Following the suggestions from @Scortchi I investigated the relationship of the incidence of flight vs distance to the nearest ship in a logistic regression framework. There was slight relationship present (negative slope) but the p-value was non-significant suggesting that the true slope could be zero. Based on the desciptive statistics (including the ecdf plots) I suspected that the effect of close ships was being drowned out by the many observations when the ship was not affecting behavior. I then used the R package segmented (<a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/segmented/segmented.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/segmented/segmented.pdf</a>) to try and find a break-point in the model. The program found that breaking the data at 2.6 km from the ship and fitting two separate coefficients was better than the single coefficient model. The coefficient for the slope of the close ship approaches was negative and suggests that ships affect the flight response until about 2.6 km (p-value &lt; 0.001). The coefficient for the second slope was slightly positive but the p-value was non-significant at the 0.05 alpha level (p-value = 0.11). So in summary, the segmented regression line was able to detect a threshold difference at which flight probability increases. The estimate for the probability of flight when the ship is further than 2.6 km is 0.11. Fittingly, I observed 79 birds in when no ships were even in the study bay (> 100 km away) and 9 of these individuals flew from the water during the observation (0.113 probability).</p> <p>Thanks for all the suggestions. I hope this question along with the suggestions and answers helps others. </p>
37,358
[ -0.04111388325691223, -0.01693102903664112, 0.005712646525353193, 0.0030949367210268974, 0.06252431124448776, 0.02096419781446457, -0.023023877292871475, 0.018138129264116287, 0.025456344708800316, -0.05766504257917404, 0.018520541489124298, 0.08155578374862671, 0.034960124641656876, 0.021548207849264145, 0.01697508804500103, -0.012473169714212418, -0.05030360072851181, 0.004228140227496624, 0.004279345273971558, -0.0393722839653492, 0.01350129023194313, 0.01633404567837715, 0.031148290261626244, -0.022697826847434044, -0.042556822299957275, 0.03849463164806366, 0.012441080994904041, -0.027699215337634087, -0.008322500623762608, 0.05294079706072807, -0.026299865916371346, -0.004356541205197573, -0.01771278865635395, 0.040420033037662506, 0.014151022769510746, 0.030369102954864502, -0.02441195771098137, -0.0002446745056658983, -0.023303337395191193, 0.03830211982131004, -0.006706994492560625, -0.021956387907266617, 0.0241773072630167, 0.05441952496767044, -0.023745913058519363, 0.012149722315371037, 0.020407002419233322, -0.03652944043278694, 0.04702170938253403, -0.024211544543504715, 0.05622415244579315, -0.014679784886538982, 0.010290111415088177, -0.007196557242423296, 0.01622958667576313, -0.02441536635160446, 0.05693220719695091, 0.06385606527328491, -0.025528697296977043, -0.03927493467926979, 0.010106165893375874, -0.011116530746221542, -0.02270808443427086, -0.014117743819952011, 0.005215396173298359, -0.01664883643388748, 0.013760030269622803, -0.05196211114525795, 0.05686083436012268, -0.05094131827354431, 0.002114463597536087, 0.015474716201424599, 0.05573161691427231, -0.0044923569075763226, 0.01081673800945282, -0.01470133289694786, 0.018660973757505417, 0.02662535384297371, 0.030400265008211136, 0.009931255131959915, -0.010805254802107811, 0.01322215236723423, 0.044512830674648285, 0.04644790664315224, 0.058606307953596115, -0.05145296826958656, 0.048326317220926285, -0.03929365426301956, 0.007839285768568516, -0.0029426435939967632, -0.027027005329728127, -0.003942690324038267, 0.04830467700958252, 0.004138265270739794, -0.04413313791155815, 0.03633468225598335, -0.006079123355448246, -0.004345684312283993, 0.004721243400126696, -0.0026941506657749414, -0.03065892681479454, -0.07724139839410782, 0.01766573265194893, 0.07629726082086563, -0.039354030042886734, 0.0023515059147030115, -0.03405967354774475, -0.01326865516602993, -0.04955669492483139, -0.02237430401146412, -0.03018072247505188, 0.05461778864264488, 0.029378872364759445, -0.009824373759329319, -0.006284333299845457, 0.042373087257146835, -0.000985447783023119, -0.029767325147986412, 0.0674998089671135, 0.0729248896241188, 0.056795649230480194, -0.015133073553442955, -0.0020911761093884706, -0.019229823723435402, -0.04241374507546425, 0.010105603374540806, 0.008485143072903156, -0.012484762817621231, 0.015794796869158745, 0.0552663579583168, -0.013710206374526024, -0.0009114528656937182, 0.04410368576645851, 0.00585100008174777, 0.008024320006370544, -0.00041420821798965335, -0.07665076851844788, -0.039602264761924744, 0.060341231524944305, -0.005684619769454002, 0.01603434607386589, -0.029433052986860275, -0.01951383799314499, 0.010713738389313221, 0.04134492203593254, 0.03126851096749306, 0.025860538706183434, -0.05080195888876915, 0.03561430796980858, 0.0032599931582808495, 0.007239013910293579, 0.005187323782593012, -0.030892055481672287, -0.049009401351213455, -0.03796371445059776, -0.05932137370109558, 0.031051043421030045, 0.0070192995481193066, 0.01225017849355936, -0.014944825321435928, 0.08199924975633621, 0.013260191306471825, 0.00815390795469284, -0.020327763631939888, 0.019826721400022507, -0.04049699008464813, 0.09948651492595673, -0.0005788465496152639, 0.008874036371707916, -0.01006136555224657, 0.017736215144395828, 0.01884380355477333, -0.03451972454786301, 0.034137364476919174, 0.04108622297644615, -0.05127102881669998, 0.00877001415938139, -0.015880700200796127, 0.018184803426265717, -0.010941335000097752, -0.020657766610383987, 0.0036037836689502, -0.03688359260559082, -0.018616069108247757, 0.02721022069454193, 0.058454446494579315, 0.010318075306713581, -0.007971866987645626, 0.04984890669584274, -0.04072719067335129, -0.045167531818151474, -0.010937809944152832, -0.00651355879381299, -0.036969609558582306, -0.045397087931632996, 0.04170149937272072, -0.023611435666680336, 0.01582936942577362, -0.017770810052752495, -0.013152765110135078, -0.010505630634725094, -0.046914540231227875, 0.030429286882281303, -0.029327793046832085, 0.0174721572548151, 0.04504575580358505, 0.026002267375588417, 0.04044812172651291, 0.014099162071943283, -0.038747046142816544, -0.07900471240282059, -0.017936404794454575, -0.0689815804362297, -0.018755538389086723, 0.03390173241496086, 0.005921946372836828, 0.02772519551217556, 0.03099357709288597, -0.04684211313724518, 0.012635283172130585, -0.08099163323640823, 0.043302569538354874, 0.07017993927001953, 0.008151313289999962, 0.010561643168330193, 0.004893166944384575, 0.011682171374559402, -0.015800096094608307, -0.010919302701950073, -0.018867582082748413, -0.0658714696764946, -0.015478655695915222, 0.03770185634493828, 0.0124216852709651, -0.005960745271295309, -0.0004603254492394626, 0.05812084302306175, -0.012142700143158436, 0.005632472690194845, 0.010315166786313057, 0.0212770476937294, -0.028939951211214066, -0.005861435551196337, 0.026318565011024475, 0.013854524120688438, -0.0342448465526104, 0.029518181458115578, -0.016605546697974205, 0.011835303157567978, -0.031060148030519485, -0.02962702140212059, -0.0006423781160265207, -0.010926936753094196, 0.019171861931681633, -0.029112860560417175, 0.02617753855884075, 0.06685841083526611, -0.007359732408076525, 0.016441477462649345, 0.019858118146657944, -0.0025716868694871664, 0.010107256472110748, 0.020554546266794205, 0.005537712946534157, 0.05185737460851669, 0.023131610825657845, -0.04993370547890663, -0.011304868385195732, 0.03344101458787918, -0.039231881499290466, -0.00032579616527073085, -0.030113015323877335, -0.05012153461575508, 0.0094075258821249, 0.007539644371718168, 0.04737750440835953, 0.022419549524784088, 0.01927618309855461, -0.01248843502253294, -0.0029236869886517525, -0.008666371926665306, 0.008493505418300629, -0.008131288923323154, 0.027170328423380852, -0.03437940031290054, 0.005543539300560951, -0.015763012692332268, 0.005272272042930126, 0.02214045263826847, -0.04381832480430603, 0.0043800026178359985, 0.004745801445096731, -0.017941731959581375, -0.08672501891851425, -0.03462383896112442, -0.05415717884898186, -0.01924007758498192, -0.052449919283390045, -0.023513540625572205, 0.0294189490377903, 0.04938887804746628, -0.02424524538218975, 0.03516640514135361, -0.06538064032793045, -0.011798419989645481, -0.03962279111146927, -0.004018655978143215, 0.012028675526380539, -0.019557328894734383, -0.0013834955170750618, -0.02253270149230957, -0.033932797610759735, -0.036264825612306595, -0.09617621451616287, -0.04995549097657204, 0.023085657507181168, -0.009623563848435879, 0.0426446907222271, -0.028441296890378, -0.019350657239556313, 0.05264797434210777, 0.035012535750865936, -0.006020806729793549, -0.012664610520005226, 0.024069342762231827, -0.06734400987625122, 0.006622812710702419, -0.010396312922239304, -0.008123991079628468, 0.008006686344742775, 0.0506671704351902, -0.016140706837177277, 0.03025786206126213, 0.017393426969647408, 0.020577743649482727, 0.0073188431560993195, 0.034959159791469574, 0.01614641584455967, 0.010571681894361973, 0.045760199427604675, 0.043705012649297714, -0.025607546791434288, 0.00673204381018877, -0.009900535456836224, 0.02060668170452118, 0.05393295735120773, -0.048198726028203964, -0.003993102349340916, 0.014977293089032173, 0.02686297334730625, -0.0051343441009521484, 0.026894867420196533, 0.035453420132398605, -0.027548406273126602, -0.009319447912275791, 0.022380217909812927, 0.06381823867559433, -0.004626496694982052, 0.009989242069423199, 0.06035584211349487, 0.04265910014510155, 0.01767125353217125, -0.03174024447798729, -0.036794599145650864, 0.01815173774957657, -0.0014641002053394914, -0.026799198240041733, -0.0024406942538917065, -0.017287421971559525, 0.03297068923711777, 0.022142941132187843, -0.02192765474319458, -0.03154520317912102, -0.018742229789495468, -0.048986874520778656, -0.017180856317281723, -0.041090600192546844, 0.04635271057486534, 0.03367690369486809, -0.004862395115196705, -0.029128344729542732, 0.0018906487384811044, -0.008151128888130188, 0.055334482342004776, -0.0759875476360321, -0.006168499123305082, -0.005502926651388407, -0.03863826394081116, -0.00046229411964304745, -0.03267301619052887, 0.013539182022213936, -0.04203119874000549, 0.02887568064033985, 0.012603934854269028, 0.02669268473982811, -0.055954478681087494, -0.010158482007682323, -0.009765435010194778, -0.05620476230978966, -0.01391057763248682, -0.03932709991931915, 0.03589155897498131, -0.02551974356174469, 0.052652757614851, 0.008662255480885506, 0.0038764833007007837, -0.022695770487189293, -0.02507469616830349, -0.011151580139994621, 0.01629417948424816, 0.01960504613816738, -0.015448793768882751, -0.004833436571061611, -0.04925280809402466, 0.025458667427301407, 0.0040260120294988155, 0.021675214171409607, 0.04833480715751648, 0.00287821632809937, -0.04340341314673424, -0.02424798160791397, -0.01775115542113781, 0.05379395931959152, 0.02052011340856552, 0.030911371111869812, -0.01707807183265686, 0.041848015040159225, 0.014445418491959572, 0.002045342465862632, -0.004581020213663578, 0.018529126420617104, 0.021755622699856758, 0.0252760611474514, -0.004484108183532953, -0.015555860474705696, -0.008283108472824097, 0.014701595529913902, 0.028929706662893295, 0.019304081797599792, 0.03003539890050888, -0.008972372859716415, 0.03794344887137413, 0.023164473474025726, 0.014180525206029415, 0.002789807738736272, -0.015641052275896072, -0.005654541775584221, -0.015989234670996666, -0.027132369577884674, 0.04020962491631508, 0.004543853458017111, 0.055305127054452896, 0.02134726010262966, 0.00859004259109497, -0.05634307116270065, -0.021254437044262886, 0.04868176579475403, 0.0095668975263834, -0.0030349527951329947, 0.004887238144874573, -0.03653644397854805, -0.004163479898124933, 0.0019543813541531563, -0.011782723478972912, -0.009726687334477901, 0.0024347095750272274, 0.019846122711896896, -0.02040978893637657, -0.07485879212617874, -0.0576791875064373, 0.03072529472410679, -0.016346318647265434, 0.0262428168207407, -0.009548141621053219, -0.021539846435189247, -0.013066032901406288, -0.001472290139645338, 0.04211825504899025, 0.054181233048439026, 0.041298769414424896, -0.0506863035261631, -0.0032166566234081984, -0.020971737802028656, -0.013295115903019905, -0.040247831493616104, 0.03829892724752426, -0.0014401058433577418, 0.02830878272652626, 0.06495510041713715, 0.024349885061383247, -0.008610481396317482, 0.06079893186688423, 0.020015448331832886, -0.024943681433796883, 0.0067711323499679565, -0.022432543337345123, 0.039102695882320404, 0.024268168956041336, 0.023438632488250732, 0.03969509154558182, 0.05818121135234833, -0.0034389120992273092, 0.015269623138010502, -0.014667914249002934, 0.012922120280563831, -0.02450379729270935, -0.037710629403591156, -0.007051780354231596, -0.008626437745988369, -0.01564229652285576, -0.008195692673325539, -0.0022009252570569515, 0.021678829565644264, -0.032877374440431595, 0.0014192701783031225, 0.007469431962817907, 0.023434467613697052, -0.003304357873275876, 0.023866649717092514, -0.020264053717255592, 0.04931515082716942, 0.018459968268871307, 0.011480920016765594, 0.013893643394112587, -0.004858088679611683, 0.014384880661964417, 0.0028338360134512186, -0.021463822573423386, -0.010048150084912777, -0.03700397536158562, -0.007172825746238232, 0.005470380652695894, -0.02026159130036831, 0.026419442147016525, -0.006846068426966667, -0.0032200098503381014, 0.04605485126376152, -0.039459194988012314, -0.045452773571014404, 0.032330140471458435, -0.00971921719610691, 0.008286281488835812, -0.014342287555336952, 0.0008371181902475655, -0.006096709053963423, 0.012841067276895046, -0.07112642377614975, -0.03160012140870094, 0.031168151646852493, -0.013790854252874851, -0.022104758769273758, -0.02888994850218296, -0.006127367727458477, -0.03300230950117111, -0.019908009096980095, 0.002337584039196372, 0.0530671700835228, -0.04427766054868698, -0.018508194014430046, -0.019788362085819244, 0.003202203195542097, 0.08986224234104156, 0.0020763676147907972, -0.031130844727158546, 0.028407985344529152, -0.017439473420381546, -0.0014734705910086632, 0.013436014764010906, 0.008952023461461067, -0.024528684094548225, -0.02424304559826851, -0.016485199332237244, 0.008589347824454308, -0.006572412792593241, -0.044031061232089996, -0.021022850647568703, 0.001337297260761261, 0.003850174369290471, 0.01664230041205883, 0.029368452727794647, 0.0071266996674239635, 0.015928104519844055, -0.02046770229935646, -0.024297036230564117, 0.004769297782331705, 0.02743915282189846, -0.018807364627718925, 0.025766588747501373, 0.020253103226423264, 0.0060013895854353905, 0.029116883873939514, 0.04257472977042198, -0.017150746658444405, -0.04372188821434975, -0.001128415809944272, 0.03376714885234833, 0.007082886062562466, -0.05800369009375572, -0.014265166595578194, -0.021067265421152115, 0.053871314972639084, -0.024706682190299034, 0.012438769452273846, -0.049862779676914215, 0.005906249396502972, 0.0499754436314106, 0.03301651403307915, 0.05463844910264015, 0.0012265960685908794, 0.02367750182747841, 0.00765087129548192, -0.006840487010776997, -0.009118643589317799, -0.018241070210933685, 0.009138238616287708, 0.04721452668309212, -0.048964597284793854, -0.02204263210296631, 0.03271511197090149, 0.038161780685186386, -0.0002457457303535193, 0.023954268544912338, 0.018018053844571114, 0.020824607461690903, 0.0673428624868393, -0.034016311168670654, -0.059814948588609695, 0.01610533893108368, -0.071534663438797, 0.036838334053754807, -0.02209797129034996, 0.006207729689776897, 0.034958574920892715, 0.06816649436950684, 0.004664401989430189, -0.07752075791358948, -0.015203242190182209, -0.03247921168804169, -0.0018831739434972405, 0.000010342993846279569, -0.007050373591482639, 0.019030779600143433, 0.003326650243252516, 0.053061842918395996, -0.032228436321020126, -0.0014895889908075333, -0.0034127142280340195, -0.07073431462049484, -0.022316955029964447, -0.008605988696217537, -0.009516065940260887, 0.046002041548490524, -0.028861286118626595, -0.06087667495012283, 0.007724691182374954, -0.020873233675956726, 0.02305380441248417, 0.042376693338155746, 0.0039311065338552, 0.012251291424036026, 0.061065707355737686, -0.011178867891430855, 0.015651676803827286, -0.012842925265431404, -0.00571664422750473, 0.1507788598537445, 0.03795924410223961, 0.025682974606752396, -0.016661429777741432, -0.011577144265174866, 0.01404488179832697, 0.02885347604751587, -0.03996967151761055, -0.014602335169911385, 0.031274452805519104, -0.04524993896484375, 0.05234653130173683, 0.00925508700311184, 0.024812767282128334, -0.06764613837003708, 0.0583631657063961, -0.03360879048705101, 0.00499675702303648, -0.022588860243558884, -0.013025129213929176, -0.009009900502860546, 0.00561648840084672, -0.019445274025201797, -0.003384145675227046, 0.0023107773158699274, -0.0011698069283738732, 0.013523736037313938, -0.020702946931123734, -0.014243003912270069, 0.02427378110587597, -0.021685302257537842, -0.005620758980512619, 0.06375854462385178, 0.00039180219755508006, -0.02919980324804783, -0.0020502579864114523, -0.008326968178153038, -0.011271670460700989, 0.003224803600460291, 0.06360173970460892, 0.007566402200609446, 0.002603946253657341, 0.03937913849949837, 0.001894981018267572, -0.024962125346064568, -0.030479678884148598, -0.059886470437049866, 0.05288153141736984, 0.006338534411042929, 0.011156406253576279, -0.025444936007261276, 0.006450617220252752, 0.01492469385266304, -0.04194750264286995, 0.005881180055439472, -0.000702011224348098, 0.0051531619392335415, -0.031361404806375504, -0.016454260796308517, -0.01348069217056036, 0.0203433558344841, 0.033369939774274826, -0.021446390077471733, 0.04207425191998482, 0.011354713700711727, -0.05999594181776047, 0.010463996790349483, 0.07909709215164185, 0.0022773004602640867, -0.012588507495820522, 0.022428667172789574, -0.018474258482456207, -0.030539412051439285, 0.0034380259457975626, 0.005910145118832588, 0.004672409500926733, 0.0017870069714263082, 0.014174265787005424, -0.020368855446577072, -0.007975278422236443, -0.03199617564678192, 0.0011510738404467702, -0.06491217017173767, -0.012745195999741554, -0.03929515555500984, 0.010847913101315498, 0.0006923997425474226, 0.04893498122692108, 0.04527614638209343, 0.06792818009853363, -0.007997208274900913, 0.09993212670087814, -0.004744186066091061, -0.049223218113183975, -0.03345934674143791, -0.0077723064459860325, 0.0033872099593281746, -0.0017527731833979487, 0.016097664833068848, 0.029412472620606422, 0.014733904041349888, -0.0003787079476751387, -0.0021428666077554226, 0.027135176584124565, 0.012283840216696262, 0.011900787241756916, 0.0329851359128952, -0.05722063407301903, -0.010841889306902885, 0.0032657445408403873, 0.008569925092160702, -0.01842571422457695, -0.02423909679055214, -0.025802820920944214, -0.014614459127187729, -0.038570817559957504, -0.002513348823413253, -0.0421503521502018, -0.03459501266479492, -0.021829502657055855, 0.032437920570373535, -0.012533772736787796, 0.010830593295395374, -0.03346804901957512, -0.03044595941901207, -0.046386223286390305, -0.01307719573378563, -0.008513656444847584, 0.018394991755485535, -0.026251260191202164, 0.009497697465121746, 0.025737518444657326, -0.005026642698794603, 0.02099017985165119, -0.002218061126768589, 0.04668392613530159, -0.006349100265651941, 0.057332150638103485, -0.00280059315264225, -0.015642967075109482, 0.030739275738596916, -0.0020162698347121477, -0.02996591292321682, 0.02659444510936737, 0.011086353100836277, 0.017964355647563934, -0.02587302029132843, 0.04502519592642784, -0.03083040565252304, 0.0604095421731472, -0.01037987694144249, 0.00819640327244997, -0.017745815217494965, 0.016100283712148666, 0.015090248547494411, -0.018673012033104897, 0.025128988549113274, 0.002022224012762308, -0.012422962114214897, 0.017897948622703552, 0.01577647030353546, 0.010632907040417194, 0.035956885665655136, -0.004519358277320862, -0.021481726318597794, -0.013523142784833908, -0.021642670035362244, 0.005542445927858353, 0.046239182353019714, 0.06423040479421616, -0.028419790789484978, 0.037113312631845474, 0.004689107649028301, 0.015049535781145096, -0.09400711953639984, -0.0183827243745327, 0.03393328934907913, 0.012897023931145668, 0.03475978970527649, -0.020538363605737686, -0.005136266816407442, 0.018449271097779274, -0.07899076491594315, -0.0024459799751639366, 0.002046841662377119, -0.00688566779717803, -0.05093966796994209, -0.023700999096035957, -0.029125429689884186, 0.03404228389263153, -0.004435736685991287, -0.026034919545054436, 0.04280150681734085, 0.08408724516630173, 0.02673596888780594, 0.0027590945828706026, -0.0031204931437969208, 0.01681046187877655, 0.025227418169379234, -0.008389676921069622, 0.04468921571969986, -0.02410741336643696, 0.001888176891952753, 0.014634722843766212, -0.01719917729496956, 0.016741935163736343, -0.03274494782090187, 0.008920291438698769, 0.06303900480270386, 0.04185221716761589, 0.04490366205573082, 0.012688661925494671, 0.011218391358852386, -0.01213103998452425, -0.019780736416578293, 0.018261047080159187, -0.032376665621995926, -0.0095443744212389, 0.031943295150995255, -0.041427403688430786, -0.033577289432287216, -0.014692655764520168, 0.0005289910477586091, -0.0014823180390521884, 0.01198454201221466, -0.01795826107263565, -0.039468422532081604, 0.0170570258051157, -0.006836392916738987, -0.07432553172111511, -0.008791561238467693, -0.006234009750187397, 0.014566296711564064, -0.06992581486701965, 0.00048229910316877067, -0.02114045061171055, -0.06042809784412384, -0.016527194529771805, -0.03105287067592144, 0.009048261679708958, -0.04178333654999733, -0.010517560876905918, -0.05197352543473244, 0.008654151111841202, -0.0031511415727436543, 0.0022745318710803986, -0.04148612916469574, 0.03189314529299736, -0.011462114751338959, 0.006582924164831638, 0.04020741581916809, 0.014470010995864868, 0.021984374150633812, -0.10295483469963074, 0.06533625721931458, 0.005061640404164791, -0.004198229871690273, -0.021551355719566345, -0.017431745305657387, -0.012974790297448635, 0.010988153517246246, 0.02894735336303711, 0.011273265816271305, 0.013334942981600761, 0.003960790112614632, 0.02420295774936676, -0.02274443209171295, -0.052804991602897644, 0.02814633958041668, -0.03795388340950012, -0.03382827341556549, 0.020011261105537415, -0.02184334769845009, -0.024867845699191093, -0.012376917526125908, 0.011921451427042484, -0.0020581367425620556, 0.02454066276550293, 0.015281721949577332, -0.013101142831146717, 0.05635148659348488, -0.003146534552797675, 0.020290445536375046, 0.004529292695224285, 0.005852056667208672, 0.00011753704166039824, 0.012067532166838646, -0.03643498197197914, -0.09036853909492493, 0.05202115327119827, -0.048100925981998444, -0.010071121156215668, 0.03364807739853859, 0.007964279502630234, 0.022628068923950195, -0.040085386484861374, -0.003647831967100501, -0.009477389976382256, -0.007455167826265097, -0.006419932935386896, 0.017634330317378044, 0.016038216650485992, 0.0298051405698061, -0.030259784311056137, 0.025879425927996635, -0.017529601231217384, 0.0015111856628209352, 0.026175551116466522, -0.003826155560091138, 0.028796305879950523, -0.01901819184422493, -0.005453529767692089, -0.006904982030391693, 0.008434613235294819, 0.05467784032225609, -0.010477832518517971, 0.021280372515320778, -0.015259566716849804, 0.0018025839235633612, 0.048889804631471634, 0.01481244433671236, -0.002442308235913515, 0.012202922254800797, -0.0017773829167708755, 0.04463834688067436, -0.015207448974251747, -0.008639848791062832, 0.0012967680813744664, -0.03200985863804817, -0.006381578277796507, 0.048954010009765625, 0.042006395757198334, 0.010548639111220837, -0.0032514361664652824, -0.018233690410852432, -0.00022253690985962749, 0.017159385606646538, 0.0002137707342626527, -0.008057995699346066, 0.00654901098459959, 0.006547375116497278, 0.021792713552713394, -0.013227778486907482, -0.0044288658536970615, 0.014639375731348991, -0.019515378400683403, 0.018633704632520676, 0.04619012773036957, 0.0065857479348778725, -0.0353006087243557, -0.04700590670108795, -0.010641846805810928, 0.04309640824794769, -0.043283190578222275, -0.016728948801755905, -0.02448948659002781, 0.03724204748868942, 0.012761426158249378, -0.05766446515917778 ]
<p>How do you check ergodicity of a wide-sense stationary stochastic processes from its sample path(s)? </p> <p>Can we check ergodicity from a single sample path? Or do we need multiple sample paths? </p> <p>One motivation of checking ergodicity is in time series to ensure that you could safely use the average of a sample path over time as estimate for the population mean?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
74,470
[ -0.027067355811595917, -0.010571167804300785, 0.0025555596221238375, 0.011923450045287609, 0.028946273028850555, -0.00818698201328516, 0.00974657665938139, -0.012071198783814907, 0.0024719792418181896, -0.007969038560986519, 0.007927356287837029, 0.016070451587438583, 0.04417891800403595, 0.017717279493808746, 0.01094447448849678, -0.00029725005151703954, 0.008748162537813187, 0.02795657329261303, -0.0002930942864622921, -0.04319119080901146, -0.011322593316435814, -0.01093045249581337, 0.03559688478708267, -0.04207287356257439, -0.02932724915444851, 0.0070943450555205345, 0.018113406375050545, 0.015060937963426113, 0.014237566851079464, 0.049030546098947525, -0.04393883794546127, -0.02646433375775814, 0.019865531474351883, 0.09389292448759079, 0.017085108906030655, 0.009925893507897854, -0.04523833468556404, -0.037974145263433456, 0.018432369455695152, 0.026707300916314125, -0.06338115781545639, -0.011297014541924, 0.003571790875867009, 0.022119194269180298, -0.02711404301226139, 0.017542624846100807, -0.028607839718461037, -0.02395194210112095, 0.05738501250743866, -0.0005609606741927564, 0.08075565844774246, -0.021404290571808815, 0.013644056394696236, 0.011421389877796173, -0.018900949507951736, -0.0043650721199810505, 0.027754906564950943, 0.038190245628356934, 0.0017996770329773426, -0.037934962660074234, -0.0053922440856695175, -0.026012413203716278, 0.02069648914039135, -0.034905120730400085, -0.05007840692996979, 0.019250106066465378, 0.013731769286096096, -0.017149748280644417, 0.0022032796405255795, -0.0007711069192737341, -0.004929877817630768, -0.02379527874290943, 0.03403530269861221, 0.009889806620776653, 0.01964736171066761, 0.0015621095662936568, 0.01027706265449524, 0.042924657464027405, 0.035868722945451736, 0.04767445847392082, -0.006282809656113386, 0.0265648253262043, 0.017412353307008743, 0.017149552702903748, 0.04454038292169571, -0.032832760363817215, 0.06192474439740181, -0.01661473885178566, 0.01760474219918251, -0.007353669032454491, 0.007308132015168667, -0.004792732186615467, 0.041991882026195526, 0.0024746607523411512, -0.0376831479370594, -0.006640173494815826, -0.03368965536355972, 0.030630003660917282, -0.01018223911523819, 0.0056177969090640545, 0.0007278466946445405, -0.07331299781799316, 0.04572528228163719, 0.0399533286690712, -0.012725104577839375, 0.034789614379405975, -0.01574995182454586, -0.011281966231763363, -0.01731107197701931, -0.02015451341867447, -0.05025453492999077, 0.0033630854450166225, 0.019492190331220627, 0.022632937878370285, 0.027842499315738678, 0.03530752286314964, -0.035272933542728424, -0.0021705476101487875, 0.030576853081583977, 0.0861857533454895, 0.07637645304203033, -0.03170870989561081, 0.012751352973282337, -0.03087601624429226, -0.06995145976543427, 0.013506987132132053, 0.000013555899386119563, -0.00103791244328022, -0.03862127289175987, 0.03111981227993965, 0.009056697599589825, -0.029036305844783783, 0.02374897710978985, 0.0004745148471556604, 0.06655597686767578, -0.004076868761330843, -0.11265024542808533, -0.03731223940849304, 0.04825187101960182, 0.012017273344099522, -0.018805483356118202, -0.05939236655831337, 0.044444046914577484, 0.015190813690423965, 0.041230060160160065, -0.019338788464665413, 0.03973980247974396, 0.019982805475592613, 0.029295261949300766, -0.003450611373409629, -0.04118982329964638, 0.0031489571556448936, -0.03366183489561081, 0.014360664412379265, 0.016655191779136658, -0.06797274947166443, 0.02703693136572838, 0.01975982077419758, -0.035044290125370026, -0.033048465847969055, 0.03718869760632515, 0.012331747449934483, -0.02530805952847004, 0.002647376386448741, 0.02143864892423153, -0.01944626122713089, 0.07494107633829117, -0.004844222217798233, 0.01807340979576111, -0.027810510247945786, 0.014861591160297394, 0.027461599558591843, 0.009158629924058914, 0.0418875589966774, 0.06474002450704575, -0.020272767171263695, -0.011234768666327, -0.0007332537788897753, 0.022605331614613533, -0.0005550353671424091, -0.03881702944636345, -0.026661278679966927, -0.022583236917853355, -0.02015928365290165, 0.02973164990544319, 0.023822449147701263, -0.0040284120477736, -0.021710682660341263, 0.012925810180604458, -0.09422194212675095, -0.027272004634141922, -0.06281200796365738, 0.024596428498625755, -0.0031389377545565367, -0.020801857113838196, 0.023656100034713745, -0.0016333216335624456, 0.03665190935134888, -0.043207280337810516, -0.029447099193930626, -0.03424297273159027, 0.006403202656656504, 0.01173454150557518, -0.06244334951043129, -0.03718239441514015, 0.04243190214037895, 0.054057832807302475, -0.015066240914165974, 0.029385097324848175, -0.039060078561306, -0.028988340869545937, 0.004064429085701704, -0.04308765381574631, -0.005459771957248449, -0.027013564482331276, -0.02263425663113594, 0.0023905676789581776, 0.012019108049571514, -0.016189690679311752, 0.030853906646370888, -0.03992066904902458, 0.037890657782554626, 0.07344994693994522, 0.004858130589127541, 0.0011378285707905889, 0.002824435941874981, 0.017577599734067917, -0.013108561746776104, 0.0009027494234032929, -0.0026657020207494497, -0.04451848194003105, -0.025844309478998184, 0.05240444466471672, 0.02825622819364071, -0.03183864429593086, -0.023238876834511757, 0.07971096783876419, 0.008028845302760601, -0.012106041423976421, 0.05954640358686447, 0.010405754670500755, -0.018867071717977524, -0.008939563296735287, 0.014597858302295208, 0.00983529444783926, -0.005144221242517233, 0.0024378206580877304, -0.009042083285748959, 0.00465224077925086, -0.007865033112466335, -0.026381254196166992, 0.017656126990914345, -0.012701311148703098, 0.002834862796589732, 0.025032540783286095, -0.01576172187924385, 0.017020663246512413, 0.013114792294800282, -0.019108030945062637, -0.01948750950396061, 0.00488209119066596, 0.02585102804005146, 0.00573750538751483, -0.02395910769701004, 0.000663057784549892, 0.007798486854881048, -0.01553622167557478, -0.0034466725774109364, 0.04333627223968506, -0.040472887456417084, 0.014075974933803082, -0.033800993114709854, -0.0061005535535514355, 0.003694548737257719, 0.013054425828158855, 0.07241173833608627, -0.019697096198797226, -0.0016598220681771636, -0.028242556378245354, -0.019413460046052933, 0.007075227331370115, -0.01762370951473713, -0.004932638257741928, 0.010790714994072914, -0.05706968531012535, 0.03185516968369484, -0.005929124541580677, -0.011741537600755692, -0.0032901742961257696, -0.01288609765470028, 0.0007404889911413193, 0.05133581906557083, 0.01875518448650837, -0.06801725178956985, 0.02979634329676628, -0.012209811247885227, 0.015736937522888184, -0.031938374042510986, 0.006983690895140171, 0.07572415471076965, 0.004736569710075855, -0.061835892498493195, 0.011868302710354328, -0.012178195640444756, -0.02027794159948826, -0.020407097414135933, -0.021368233487010002, 0.0152165237814188, -0.019252825528383255, 0.0418936088681221, 0.054639723151922226, -0.05339391529560089, -0.0035363556817173958, -0.03652721643447876, -0.055396270006895065, 0.024056456983089447, -0.020261583849787712, 0.06819813698530197, 0.025694988667964935, -0.043252360075712204, 0.04823090136051178, 0.05427116900682449, -0.029629670083522797, -0.008157014846801758, -0.017684802412986755, -0.009020050056278706, -0.03920271620154381, 0.013404635712504387, -0.013812427408993244, -0.021337898448109627, 0.010090969502925873, 0.02986195869743824, 0.027499446645379066, 0.05512913316488266, 0.015618943609297276, 0.005140406545251608, 0.020959723740816116, -0.008515155874192715, 0.013228167779743671, 0.02431098185479641, -0.011072131805121899, -0.04490594565868378, 0.0053894552402198315, -0.002841594396159053, 0.02304159849882126, 0.018307771533727646, -0.013726609759032726, 0.0414031520485878, -0.008993808180093765, 0.016892986372113228, -0.04748138040304184, 0.02012377791106701, 0.01211270596832037, -0.01791476085782051, -0.01225289236754179, 0.02289183810353279, 0.016093742102384567, 0.011931081302464008, 0.026039643213152885, 0.024197334423661232, 0.02746269851922989, -0.03807849809527397, -0.010085245594382286, -0.011407115496695042, -0.04292887821793556, 0.024517925456166267, -0.006222434341907501, -0.045650240033864975, 0.026195432990789413, 0.024153204634785652, 0.0166619885712862, -0.044448982924222946, -0.024818582460284233, -0.03712707757949829, -0.07819553464651108, 0.011115683242678642, -0.03190340846776962, 0.009895099326968193, -0.024093136191368103, 0.003902246244251728, 0.006860018707811832, -0.008107146248221397, 0.008866057731211185, 0.016732458025217056, -0.08470200002193451, 0.04497505724430084, -0.02907973900437355, -0.013999721966683865, 0.002697399817407131, -0.04424886405467987, 0.060466717928647995, -0.02933812141418457, 0.0249058548361063, -0.00827377662062645, 0.04105055332183838, -0.06214998662471771, -0.02114040218293667, -0.03764728084206581, 0.00011349752458045259, -0.023908553645014763, 0.02162276580929756, 0.062474943697452545, -0.01787627302110195, 0.02851192280650139, 0.021338779479265213, -0.0063232360407710075, -0.03220926225185394, 0.006805415265262127, 0.03950449079275131, -0.0010476734023541212, 0.017385749146342278, 0.02802063152194023, 0.01939847134053707, -0.0160966869443655, 0.036212194710969925, 0.0030819724779576063, 0.04569132998585701, 0.0207341518253088, -0.022574063390493393, -0.010298779234290123, -0.04108671098947525, 0.005297647789120674, 0.04123900458216667, 0.03819526731967926, 0.03389883413910866, -0.0036876313388347626, 0.0496789813041687, 0.027726585045456886, -0.058811794966459274, 0.016670990735292435, 0.04315212741494179, -0.005654677748680115, 0.002628021640703082, -0.03274302929639816, -0.021299201995134354, 0.03246186673641205, 0.008027917705476284, 0.024878283962607384, 0.010696339420974255, 0.005150382872670889, 0.02111351490020752, 0.00043469914817251265, -0.0023746443912386894, -0.006549607962369919, 0.007153004873543978, -0.018703505396842957, 0.05332961305975914, -0.0005972199724055827, -0.03804503381252289, 0.04064827039837837, 0.04143355041742325, 0.0019190778257325292, 0.04783497005701065, -0.017008498311042786, -0.050641246140003204, 0.03228093683719635, 0.045312557369470596, 0.00478710513561964, -0.031241707503795624, 0.02504536509513855, -0.06307488679885864, -0.015623094514012337, 0.058343689888715744, -0.008351849392056465, 0.04169989749789238, 0.0007200130494311452, 0.023963188752532005, -0.029447680339217186, -0.021308835595846176, -0.014022555202245712, 0.0011294780997559428, -0.01680244691669941, -0.006690270267426968, -0.0183634664863348, -0.009052004665136337, -0.0832766592502594, -0.007997622713446617, 0.009745841845870018, 0.06194988638162613, -0.0156369898468256, 0.057382915169000626, -0.02340659685432911, 0.046467773616313934, 0.004099293611943722, -0.09803324192762375, 0.01918048784136772, -0.0068939197808504105, 0.016643071547150612, 0.012872418388724327, -0.020504271611571312, -0.06843825429677963, 0.03856179863214493, 0.0038408541586250067, -0.01590805873274803, 0.016997719183564186, -0.004851015284657478, 0.03176446631550789, 0.01906404457986355, 0.034396231174468994, 0.07595649361610413, 0.02889174036681652, 0.030412714928388596, 0.01688830554485321, 0.003456965321674943, 0.004664700943976641, -0.05311538279056549, 0.008379030972719193, -0.03613913804292679, 0.00855142343789339, -0.050855811685323715, 0.02246888168156147, 0.0027155927382409573, 0.01130255963653326, 0.012637599371373653, -0.014419029466807842, -0.02736622281372547, 0.03285671025514603, 0.01674463041126728, -0.001368710771203041, -0.011358416639268398, 0.050899144262075424, -0.04902509227395058, -0.03365539386868477, 0.022637877613306046, -0.019320962950587273, -0.007031971123069525, 0.014838107861578465, -0.004806890618056059, 0.002660168334841728, -0.052718326449394226, -0.006260593421757221, -0.007642487064003944, -0.02814318798482418, 0.05259424448013306, 0.00479518948122859, 0.06281759589910507, 0.007850981317460537, -0.02003149315714836, 0.006309937685728073, 0.010133766569197178, 0.00705657247453928, 0.02593643218278885, -0.04179562255740166, 0.023445453494787216, 0.010667524300515652, -0.002696042647585273, -0.08716411143541336, -0.07153958827257156, 0.014339543879032135, 0.02492436394095421, -0.03547130152583122, -0.07360301166772842, 0.016253704205155373, -0.02587849460542202, -0.00907081551849842, -0.03860343247652054, 0.03164173290133476, 0.013586325570940971, -0.010704903863370419, 0.015502534806728363, 0.015957212075591087, 0.09242792427539825, -0.00469435378909111, -0.006356825120747089, 0.032076843082904816, -0.02852441370487213, -0.02589942142367363, -0.022327646613121033, 0.03668700531125069, -0.029430927708745003, -0.01189353782683611, -0.01611076109111309, 0.015002550557255745, 0.01276338566094637, -0.00044541151146404445, -0.03229178115725517, -0.003214741824194789, -0.030369367450475693, 0.008620481938123703, -0.02286466211080551, -0.010826634243130684, -0.0011822879314422607, 0.04262714087963104, 0.00025879425811581314, -0.007044660858809948, 0.035998787730932236, -0.04666348174214363, 0.013715011067688465, 0.0010388673981651664, -0.009464450180530548, 0.049233101308345795, 0.020434221252799034, -0.010944786481559277, -0.002634525066241622, 0.0018297829665243626, -0.02840396761894226, 0.01283896341919899, -0.04472154751420021, 0.009900908917188644, -0.0374557264149189, -0.007077873218804598, -0.04417969286441803, -0.049302831292152405, -0.033753328025341034, -0.013977797701954842, 0.04942319169640541, 0.03417065367102623, 0.03171832114458084, 0.049020566046237946, -0.013430402614176273, -0.013689815066754818, -0.0033792571630328894, -0.00896728876978159, -0.021204320713877678, -0.01200803741812706, 0.06257271766662598, -0.007656679023057222, 0.0243820883333683, 0.03456663712859154, -0.006470079999417067, 0.01144778449088335, -0.008507348597049713, 0.014311538077890873, 0.0018070766236633062, 0.03345290571451187, 0.01586524397134781, -0.03549028933048248, 0.03292904421687126, -0.08185475319623947, 0.01431270595639944, -0.037066370248794556, -0.004086593631654978, 0.033982209861278534, 0.049758318811655045, -0.013555986806750298, 0.0005977097316645086, -0.002769626909866929, -0.048215411603450775, 0.015592188574373722, -0.0035796319134533405, 0.03286479413509369, 0.05900733545422554, 0.020026259124279022, 0.05318581312894821, -0.011233912780880928, -0.008438198827207088, -0.003592593129724264, -0.03810939937829971, -0.0052982717752456665, -0.03501112386584282, -0.04756540805101395, 0.04399053007364273, 0.0160937812179327, -0.034428879618644714, -0.002113404916599393, -0.02299436368048191, 0.03330995514988899, 0.024933060631155968, 0.08690406382083893, -0.02351382002234459, 0.05741700902581215, -0.012921989895403385, 0.03298095613718033, -0.011784784495830536, -0.008820386603474617, 0.10439906269311905, 0.08265819400548935, 0.01881396770477295, -0.07883667200803757, -0.0018797351513057947, 0.004931265022605658, 0.01798482984304428, -0.030874166637659073, 0.030377425253391266, 0.03545922785997391, 0.03393099084496498, 0.01638816110789776, 0.023172277957201004, -0.005164198577404022, -0.02550041861832142, 0.04156898334622383, -0.020606519654393196, 0.006133352871984243, 0.03147184103727341, 0.020042454823851585, -0.021480387076735497, 0.02355801872909069, -0.055199287831783295, 0.04784877225756645, -0.03143421187996864, -0.043327540159225464, -0.0005107964971102774, -0.057995110750198364, -0.012988414615392685, -0.007055221125483513, 0.004982054699212313, -0.018458062782883644, 0.050662580877542496, 0.01317704189568758, -0.03162745386362076, 0.020674651488661766, -0.005048735532909632, -0.02912278100848198, 0.046161700040102005, 0.046461571007966995, 0.003015505615621805, -0.004671868868172169, 0.011388488113880157, 0.008658083155751228, -0.03646693378686905, -0.01193135604262352, -0.013668074272572994, 0.010161546990275383, 0.020255902782082558, 0.0070778303779661655, -0.024282757192850113, 0.008820552378892899, 0.03933991491794586, -0.04788362979888916, 0.03427397459745407, -0.0030783286783844233, 0.045988112688064575, -0.03208541497588158, -0.04722073674201965, -0.06095343083143234, -0.030625637620687485, 0.004435703624039888, 0.0014329123077914119, 0.023394137620925903, -0.03218789026141167, -0.04048174247145653, -0.02914685569703579, 0.022631341591477394, 0.024749239906668663, -0.030381856486201286, -0.004455693531781435, 0.005159742198884487, -0.06205662712454796, 0.0009568437235429883, 0.04512298107147217, -0.018162762746214867, 0.040672626346349716, 0.016407793387770653, -0.02142389491200447, 0.010877161286771297, -0.06297613680362701, 0.004597694147378206, -0.05699188634753227, -0.02028670720756054, -0.019038358703255653, -0.03139132633805275, 0.036276139318943024, 0.05442517623305321, 0.042591363191604614, -0.020387718454003334, -0.0070934840478003025, 0.03582118824124336, 0.025520432740449905, -0.0378757119178772, 0.020620062947273254, -0.011767328716814518, 0.0036915976088494062, -0.008433753624558449, 0.004294312559068203, 0.06447749584913254, 0.03093036450445652, 0.03136870265007019, -0.02257414534687996, -0.008925219066441059, -0.013207141309976578, -0.00006847253098385409, 0.004085870459675789, -0.026288798078894615, -0.023677853867411613, 0.04155319184064865, 0.010867469944059849, -0.012335717678070068, -0.04955994337797165, -0.017474284395575523, 0.023688064888119698, 0.0005393708124756813, -0.0040531763806939125, -0.04924096539616585, 0.013725312426686287, -0.017678365111351013, 0.0511210635304451, -0.052777789533138275, 0.0022581852972507477, -0.031914371997117996, -0.01869909092783928, -0.014711575582623482, -0.004274405539035797, 0.007535742130130529, 0.004515340551733971, 0.005182637367397547, -0.02831754833459854, 0.03809010237455368, 0.02072848565876484, 0.01889769174158573, 0.015821531414985657, 0.04487811401486397, -0.009360581636428833, 0.06075017899274826, -0.008506323210895061, -0.01856960542500019, 0.033275630325078964, -0.025867735967040062, -0.023518433794379234, 0.022456878796219826, -0.0071844859048724174, 0.028769351541996002, 0.02488420531153679, -0.03082677163183689, 0.019219160079956055, 0.012178969569504261, -0.015400835312902927, 0.006709099281579256, -0.01944226212799549, 0.010205361992120743, -0.0027911383658647537, 0.027747012674808502, 0.030342448502779007, 0.0035912678577005863, -0.008569449186325073, 0.0357024148106575, 0.02987857162952423, -0.013121401891112328, -0.0020781303755939007, 0.021659210324287415, -0.02190868742763996, 0.039800770580768585, 0.008030700497329235, 0.01176740787923336, 0.04509984329342842, 0.06041038781404495, -0.008985900320112705, 0.003144229995086789, -0.029970841482281685, -0.030424414202570915, -0.06072812154889107, 0.012865293771028519, -0.011846248991787434, 0.005316102411597967, 0.04401641711592674, -0.04463281109929085, -0.0013742626179009676, 0.06983404606580734, -0.01063298899680376, -0.0045612831600010395, 0.004437100142240524, 0.004731403663754463, -0.06038665771484375, 0.008092038333415985, -0.023139648139476776, 0.03321193531155586, 0.050684183835983276, 0.023241696879267693, 0.012406942434608936, 0.014045163989067078, -0.023126929998397827, 0.01138345431536436, -0.0036718195769935846, 0.034310147166252136, -0.005493089556694031, -0.03294520080089569, 0.017160901799798012, -0.03172626718878746, -0.03836829960346222, 0.026474302634596825, -0.015177602879703045, 0.019620785489678383, -0.004471417982131243, 0.02643992006778717, 0.006264800205826759, 0.004921136423945427, 0.01563495211303234, -0.03721201792359352, -0.01358823198825121, 0.004369070287793875, -0.015486184507608414, 0.028921110555529594, -0.028794100508093834, -0.002538962522521615, 0.02466670423746109, -0.012121452018618584, -0.03210731968283653, 0.00044992612674832344, -0.015255547128617764, -0.00553524773567915, -0.015511102974414825, -0.01982325129210949, -0.02149999514222145, -0.0003559050674084574, 0.045959215611219406, -0.004157486837357283, 0.00656310236081481, 0.059725821018218994, 0.00010101107909576967, -0.016904162243008614, -0.034483280032873154, 0.018135182559490204, -0.04808809235692024, 0.061216603964567184, 0.002809314290061593, -0.04338490590453148, -0.0743250697851181, -0.0676548108458519, -0.0149935157969594, -0.011608517728745937, -0.03692365065217018, -0.010255595669150352, -0.022615836933255196, 0.020141402259469032, 0.001600935123860836, 0.00721278740093112, -0.01669015921652317, 0.0016044833464547992, -0.00430893711745739, -0.015693578869104385, 0.046394944190979004, -0.0024619202595204115, -0.011184720322489738, -0.05478750169277191, -0.021534062922000885, -0.014331885613501072, -0.03413943201303482, 0.06579906493425369, -0.0005889782914891839, 0.025705596432089806, 0.015637826174497604, 0.043929699808359146, 0.0337786003947258, -0.09001636505126953, 0.03274952992796898, -0.07409649342298508, -0.027009526267647743, 0.003119152272120118, -0.04382473975419998, 0.022961333394050598, 0.04276176542043686, 0.022525375708937645, -0.008607941679656506, 0.008226851001381874, 0.01696283556520939, -0.02140916883945465, 0.06769996136426926, 0.03292109817266464, 0.010665174573659897, 0.037229135632514954, -0.038811083883047104, 0.002450396539643407, 0.011854876764118671, -0.03829578310251236, -0.030042121186852455, 0.01347116194665432, -0.024100789800286293, -0.05822702497243881, -0.000010932628356385976, 0.007121225818991661, -0.010721689090132713, -0.04902724176645279, -0.023379791527986526, 0.01504157017916441, -0.051118362694978714, 0.022419342771172523, 0.0406980887055397, 0.012382096610963345, 0.04474448785185814, 0.000995464506559074, -0.00522893900051713, 0.027692211791872978, 0.018649935722351074, -0.0064887674525380135, 0.024476030841469765, 0.019809527322649956, -0.015113203786313534, 0.029862400144338608, 0.00457237521186471, -0.021670054644346237, 0.018465004861354828, -0.02352778986096382, 0.03268870711326599, -0.041262101382017136, -0.04014280065894127, 0.04245423153042793, 0.0009066031780093908, -0.0011362259974703193, -0.007272462360560894, -0.007103643845766783, 0.07527615875005722, -0.04363417625427246, -0.002168438397347927, 0.014402470551431179, -0.01066838949918747, -0.02135143242776394, 0.022027207538485527, 0.011537800543010235, -0.031404584646224976, -0.00240612355992198, 0.026971524581313133, 0.005741454660892487, 0.02545097842812538, 0.03837614133954048, -0.06796416640281677, 0.03568345680832863, 0.024053087458014488, -0.0046807872131466866, -0.028268825262784958, 0.0011774093145504594, -0.035052504390478134, -0.05129193142056465, -0.01680254563689232, 0.04496077820658684, 0.0018811261979863048, 0.028166892006993294, -0.004707045387476683, -0.010760133154690266, 0.035326097160577774, -0.06793791055679321, -0.043536651879549026, -0.0527898333966732, 0.02095947414636612, 0.006065575871616602, 0.021942393854260445 ]
<p>A new treatment for strokes is put on trial. There are two equal size groups,one group is given a drug, and one a placebo. The 95% confidence interval for the difference between the two proportion of subjects having strokes was (0.07,0.12). What can we infer:</p> <p>1) not enough info to infer</p> <p>2)at most 12% of the people had strokes</p> <p>3) at least 4% had strokes</p> <p>I'm not sure on this. I think it might be 1). Can anyone help out?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
74,471
[ -0.01770368218421936, -0.03931853920221329, -0.0037470771931111813, -0.008202704600989819, 0.024291375651955605, 0.003809286281466484, -0.021141616627573967, -0.02142837829887867, 0.02380353957414627, -0.0066046323627233505, 0.048024699091911316, 0.03573492169380188, 0.03431083261966705, 0.023748256266117096, -0.018197275698184967, 0.016915105283260345, 0.0025937394239008427, 0.01974477991461754, 0.008492166176438332, -0.011240414343774319, 0.008605709299445152, -0.018337998539209366, -0.004409509710967541, -0.002640612656250596, -0.03777645528316498, 0.02931259386241436, 0.0309004969894886, -0.03977770730853081, 0.0006245837430469692, 0.048719268292188644, -0.019443020224571228, -0.048841819167137146, -0.0120536582544446, 0.021989334374666214, 0.023525012657046318, 0.023899627849459648, -0.03841904550790787, -0.039448849856853485, 0.029395882040262222, 0.050380948930978775, -0.0429769903421402, 0.00525834271684289, -0.015791557729244232, 0.01740231178700924, -0.041648149490356445, 0.03647477179765701, 0.0279434435069561, -0.06200025603175163, 0.026492895558476448, -0.01783280074596405, 0.08100526034832001, -0.01845032162964344, 0.03182227164506912, 0.0033572176471352577, -0.021413950249552727, -0.00618679728358984, 0.045503754168748856, 0.10751021653413773, -0.023112863302230835, -0.03752870112657547, -0.027075111865997314, -0.011384813115000725, 0.014180251397192478, -0.022241374477744102, -0.047032713890075684, 0.00605679489672184, -0.03740578517317772, -0.038208723068237305, 0.04269082471728325, -0.014670207165181637, 0.022351626306772232, 0.03907567262649536, 0.011069012805819511, 0.02533632516860962, 0.0026393497828394175, -0.01539015956223011, 0.0029646335169672966, 0.02611798606812954, 0.03343013674020767, 0.009884534403681755, -0.011279893107712269, -0.022010046988725662, 0.030358150601387024, 0.06467363238334656, 0.02146146073937416, 0.013027223758399487, 0.05378568917512894, -0.022178053855895996, 0.05942615494132042, 0.06335239112377167, -0.013096710667014122, 0.007094839122146368, 0.030514316633343697, -0.012757888995110989, -0.04264988377690315, 0.025930747389793396, -0.012223138473927975, 0.03456525132060051, 0.0010742924641817808, 0.025305479764938354, 0.012414587661623955, -0.01943250745534897, 0.0007333057001233101, 0.01828453317284584, -0.017634836956858635, -0.02915002405643463, -0.03053555265069008, 0.0023076555225998163, -0.019072726368904114, -0.0028918397147208452, 0.013405140489339828, 0.047824881970882416, 0.005260307341814041, 0.0009554261923767626, 0.021313486620783806, -0.013245837762951851, -0.027009621262550354, -0.0024509800132364035, 0.035176537930965424, 0.03232762590050697, 0.021984603255987167, 0.004660923033952713, -0.005750816781073809, -0.003938869573175907, 0.00009885538747766986, 0.0037971700076013803, 0.009340091608464718, -0.019372498616576195, -0.021636806428432465, 0.043772757053375244, -0.009946147911250591, -0.001960499444976449, 0.029600515961647034, 0.041059721261262894, 0.03381071984767914, -0.03218573331832886, -0.08624617010354996, -0.029160579666495323, 0.07251264154911041, 0.018823206424713135, -0.011532391421496868, -0.048334021121263504, 0.023820767179131508, 0.03178258240222931, 0.07357574254274368, -0.0030809377785772085, 0.055003393441438675, -0.01515326276421547, 0.00321695557795465, 0.01711081527173519, 0.0036535959225147963, 0.013890134170651436, -0.004473285749554634, -0.010934164747595787, -0.040121544152498245, -0.05447123199701309, -0.0059743900783360004, 0.010173104703426361, -0.016777293756604195, -0.040476586669683456, 0.013137961737811565, 0.004848479758948088, 0.0035962606780231, -0.013936487957835197, 0.005214313976466656, 0.006927597336471081, 0.06122634559869766, -0.0051369317807257175, 0.006239687092602253, -0.005372627638280392, 0.026455553248524666, 0.04442434012889862, 0.016812747344374657, 0.03636792674660683, 0.06836457550525665, -0.02137952297925949, -0.014564920216798782, 0.008438065648078918, -0.0007553021423518658, -0.004405822604894638, -0.03964788839221001, -0.0044863480143249035, -0.022368568927049637, -0.019224071875214577, 0.035811249166727066, 0.03149251267313957, 0.018564937636256218, -0.02067698910832405, 0.02142992615699768, -0.0264237429946661, -0.03230469301342964, -0.06893550604581833, -0.0299276951700449, -0.015473834238946438, -0.03835127130150795, -0.014889026060700417, -0.003217090154066682, 0.01258358545601368, -0.008268484845757484, 0.005335609428584576, -0.02395671233534813, -0.029585523530840874, 0.04799827188253403, -0.0013241675915196538, 0.034711360931396484, 0.0855092704296112, 0.05754715949296951, -0.0578782856464386, 0.03158457949757576, -0.021236537024378777, -0.0357525609433651, -0.011807199567556381, -0.006752451881766319, 0.03184868022799492, -0.007255455944687128, -0.021144473925232887, 0.00926114059984684, -0.0028357375413179398, -0.002747396705672145, 0.030964313074946404, -0.05914383754134178, 0.10246744751930237, 0.03295107185840607, -0.01926707848906517, 0.025782594457268715, -0.02661191299557686, 0.008502882905304432, 0.043878912925720215, 0.009534239768981934, -0.05469343811273575, -0.06435270607471466, -0.008972162380814552, 0.030968323349952698, -0.03185875341296196, -0.017243966460227966, 0.01741400733590126, 0.07052445411682129, -0.011400983668863773, -0.006029109936207533, 0.015491343103349209, 0.040550537407398224, -0.010219584219157696, -0.0022613711189478636, 0.03320519998669624, -0.0027419773396104574, 0.025151537731289864, 0.022533422335982323, 0.007774767465889454, 0.03725343942642212, 0.0006012811791151762, -0.01957600936293602, 0.04485451430082321, 0.009978954680263996, 0.021595662459731102, -0.03344137594103813, 0.01712561771273613, 0.04798583313822746, -0.016259726136922836, -0.011512639932334423, 0.012528255581855774, 0.009376423433423042, 0.020783904939889908, 0.006120862904936075, -0.03137942776083946, 0.017056522890925407, 0.06010393798351288, -0.044114015996456146, -0.007922153919935226, 0.01130901649594307, -0.06455835700035095, -0.014048976823687553, -0.015717407688498497, -0.02829558402299881, -0.021395547315478325, 0.04054886847734451, 0.05870223045349121, 0.002679856726899743, 0.051502127200365067, -0.005345007870346308, -0.0035470305010676384, 0.020785503089427948, -0.00987920630723238, 0.03337794914841652, -0.0018765038112178445, -0.08390626311302185, 0.0050462218932807446, -0.048148129135370255, -0.004480869974941015, -0.003713835496455431, 0.00805999618023634, -0.0027659244369715452, 0.02177397347986698, -0.007321241777390242, -0.044174276292324066, -0.025446932762861252, -0.035742148756980896, 0.013533689081668854, -0.021277500316500664, -0.0261263158172369, 0.013170239515602589, 0.0017209650250151753, -0.02005128562450409, 0.010507962666451931, 0.0005709818797186017, -0.0022678079549223185, -0.01421000063419342, 0.045559998601675034, 0.010026253759860992, 0.0015492492821067572, 0.050416044890880585, 0.017710164189338684, 0.027976879850029945, -0.027138255536556244, -0.08393559604883194, -0.06088251620531082, 0.047276780009269714, 0.004641423467546701, 0.030496325343847275, -0.0010528118582442403, -0.014222378842532635, 0.0818246603012085, -0.010817236267030239, -0.03491177037358284, -0.008782745338976383, 0.004769939463585615, -0.015675777569413185, 0.02174883522093296, 0.01158961746841669, 0.03739235922694206, -0.01119172666221857, 0.026295600458979607, 0.015876155346632004, 0.0716458335518837, 0.020418087020516396, 0.008208585903048515, -0.012672383338212967, 0.04039657488465309, -0.006425804924219847, -0.031186584383249283, 0.026619071140885353, 0.025750689208507538, -0.04492988809943199, 0.01712615229189396, -0.05084895342588425, 0.0041580055840313435, 0.029378611594438553, -0.05499931797385216, 0.0038254845421761274, -0.0012728888541460037, -0.027451440691947937, -0.01826302520930767, 0.025269243866205215, -0.003585775615647435, 0.0021771981846541166, 0.006507134530693293, 0.020262103527784348, 0.04792042449116707, -0.017073985189199448, 0.011641081422567368, 0.043308161199092865, 0.022095857188105583, -0.021897362545132637, -0.015497107990086079, -0.03181735426187515, -0.004731221590191126, -0.0101812444627285, -0.011293314397335052, -0.0324728786945343, 0.01983393356204033, 0.06770674139261246, 0.02295762114226818, -0.005941499024629593, 0.013249211013317108, 0.004039327148348093, -0.06005532294511795, 0.005384983494877815, -0.0423784963786602, 0.030686598271131516, -0.022379107773303986, 0.03974054008722305, 0.026072509586811066, -0.01785452663898468, -0.009397457353770733, 0.03404534235596657, -0.050521619617938995, 0.02576155588030815, -0.0037233892362564802, -0.015286150388419628, 0.0022423402406275272, -0.005484601482748985, 0.032648053020238876, -0.01364972349256277, -0.027727335691452026, -0.028310056775808334, -0.0038055586628615856, -0.03609512373805046, 0.039393506944179535, -0.016497721895575523, -0.00202088407240808, -0.01110289990901947, 0.004441084805876017, 0.003892430104315281, 0.024665573611855507, 0.024766823276877403, 0.029004864394664764, 0.014889889396727085, -0.018162477761507034, -0.015647433698177338, 0.016605904325842857, 0.062326204031705856, 0.04724293202161789, 0.02763155661523342, 0.002502803923562169, -0.052312493324279785, 0.03371777758002281, -0.027615027502179146, 0.03202527016401291, 0.04236709326505661, 0.020596856251358986, -0.014772479422390461, -0.045163318514823914, 0.0017554047517478466, 0.0035355754662305117, 0.00023193978995550424, 0.014443988911807537, -0.007155491970479488, 0.03206724673509598, 0.016966562718153, -0.057507798075675964, -0.029206855222582817, 0.046326033771038055, 0.0011127442121505737, 0.009241710416972637, -0.08417771011590958, -0.03479563072323799, 0.018358098343014717, -0.027481291443109512, 0.04781895875930786, 0.014843177981674671, -0.01028857659548521, -0.015119073912501335, 0.04789085313677788, -0.004115857649594545, -0.07380524277687073, -0.028790628537535667, -0.026870420202612877, 0.03772794082760811, 0.00415872922167182, 0.00006140069308457896, 0.014298299327492714, -0.002511846600100398, 0.03993064537644386, 0.03445027023553848, -0.005981027148663998, -0.09349102526903152, 0.015949107706546783, 0.013264203444123268, 0.07208775728940964, -0.024657592177391052, 0.013272455893456936, -0.0567830428481102, 0.016062742099165916, 0.027152007445693016, -0.07546235620975494, -0.003960061818361282, -0.012093239463865757, -0.0008256849250756204, -0.021408017724752426, -0.06764520704746246, -0.04736245796084404, -0.015866706147789955, -0.041216399520635605, 0.006657709367573261, -0.008624965324997902, -0.017137443646788597, -0.027237609028816223, -0.027897000312805176, 0.06422331929206848, 0.057094354182481766, -0.02162903919816017, -0.006984923034906387, -0.013686384074389935, 0.015014606527984142, -0.03795323893427849, -0.0492226667702198, 0.036880575120449066, -0.026348954066634178, -0.0054779136553406715, 0.053123269230127335, -0.05697793886065483, -0.03031085804104805, 0.019914425909519196, -0.014896775595843792, -0.05676640570163727, 0.012782720848917961, -0.03981347009539604, 0.015209822915494442, 0.03443259745836258, 0.01378978043794632, 0.07024888694286346, 0.01578335650265217, -0.0007372694672085345, 0.012439814396202564, -0.05955926328897476, -0.005731592886149883, -0.023728247731924057, 0.0060591627843678, -0.0322687141597271, -0.01187420915812254, -0.006477838382124901, 0.003588930005207658, 0.0013085182290524244, 0.05058146268129349, 0.007203008979558945, -0.04293009638786316, -0.004892118740826845, -0.012193791568279266, 0.030326304957270622, 0.0023605036549270153, -0.027226140722632408, 0.025302620604634285, 0.020232947543263435, 0.0007586513529531658, 0.023470992222428322, -0.03862280771136284, 0.029729872941970825, 0.006641765125095844, -0.048652030527591705, 0.025239907205104828, -0.013700641691684723, -0.016662003472447395, 0.04211536422371864, -0.06002459302544594, 0.015222079120576382, -0.032567430287599564, 0.020983481779694557, 0.005727377254515886, -0.024764249101281166, -0.02136356011033058, -0.003430197248235345, 0.01892063021659851, 0.08237267285585403, 0.01676706224679947, 0.02980114333331585, -0.013638048432767391, -0.00240798550657928, -0.059104423969984055, -0.06587278097867966, 0.08616386353969574, 0.05751414597034454, -0.019441260024905205, -0.01948566548526287, -0.019384201616048813, -0.01763337291777134, -0.02481897920370102, -0.024533089250326157, 0.04497106373310089, -0.005254157818853855, -0.04774758964776993, 0.0024975077249109745, -0.009030453860759735, 0.046541981399059296, -0.0006921038730069995, -0.03795311227440834, 0.03162491321563721, -0.04378124326467514, -0.025655830278992653, 0.012210648506879807, 0.004767905920743942, -0.03989381343126297, -0.005626283120363951, -0.05555204302072525, 0.013493863865733147, 0.032282836735248566, -0.009961885400116444, 0.00840575248003006, 0.0009590602130629122, 0.01864004135131836, 0.0027469161432236433, -0.05769772827625275, -0.01790730655193329, -0.002263592090457678, 0.016057796776294708, 0.003735056146979332, 0.00391807034611702, 0.010265177115797997, -0.001318474649451673, 0.023844972252845764, 0.016725625842809677, -0.050836045295000076, -0.014507877640426159, 0.06526203453540802, -0.00023375963792204857, 0.016065292060375214, 0.028593258932232857, -0.014987977221608162, 0.01320936530828476, 0.018844807520508766, 0.005182250402867794, 0.008862340822815895, 0.04717264324426651, -0.0493118092417717, -0.02780582197010517, -0.03339609503746033, 0.03907845541834831, 0.058645110577344894, 0.0031840847805142403, 0.04590711370110512, 0.05098717287182808, -0.004087285604327917, -0.01685304008424282, -0.005508895963430405, -0.003508463501930237, -0.02423044852912426, -0.020395861938595772, 0.022802583873271942, -0.03980351984500885, -0.00886958185583353, 0.07078021764755249, 0.03583097085356712, -0.008071338757872581, 0.05844733119010925, 0.02073202095925808, -0.0030117188580334187, 0.03142262622714043, -0.019115343689918518, -0.02124524861574173, 0.03295142948627472, -0.02715305984020233, 0.023109998553991318, -0.03955909237265587, 0.010786465369164944, 0.08602868765592575, 0.010130911134183407, 0.01300352718681097, -0.012628321535885334, 0.01133766956627369, -0.042345114052295685, -0.004252757411450148, -0.00977467279881239, 0.003223540261387825, 0.016120918095111847, 0.006478386465460062, 0.024126186966896057, 0.01328464224934578, 0.030752550810575485, -0.046756722033023834, -0.11024311929941177, -0.00034313241485506296, 0.017038030549883842, -0.039772506803274155, 0.039160050451755524, 0.0017943993443623185, -0.023363418877124786, 0.011224205605685711, -0.0285897608846426, 0.009047253988683224, -0.0030484646558761597, 0.05584920942783356, -0.009743827395141125, 0.03986813500523567, 0.050659168511629105, 0.016408002004027367, 0.006733606103807688, -0.004071488045156002, 0.10680970549583435, 0.07934735715389252, 0.027746453881263733, -0.05373777449131012, 0.05388369411230087, 0.01723976992070675, 0.020396236330270767, -0.0016703590517863631, 0.01475159265100956, 0.014550256542861462, 0.024139491841197014, 0.028124365955591202, 0.02646196074783802, 0.01214547362178564, -0.013211051933467388, 0.07865053415298462, -0.019429346546530724, -0.055896297097206116, -0.004769166465848684, 0.016389258205890656, 0.003863685065880418, -0.032142918556928635, -0.0399794839322567, 0.03924444317817688, 0.014134882017970085, 0.012695991434156895, 0.002624659100547433, -0.04785364866256714, 0.018629908561706543, -0.018622875213623047, -0.009943905286490917, -0.00009278176730731502, 0.016428399831056595, 0.012938047759234905, -0.05473822355270386, -0.030464312061667442, 0.04605073109269142, -0.03459698706865311, -0.013951694592833519, 0.03971151262521744, 0.0014976626262068748, 0.013296962715685368, -0.00807120930403471, 0.03774382174015045, -0.049172159284353256, -0.037487030029296875, -0.033175498247146606, 0.03150051459670067, -0.005107419099658728, -0.0205999705940485, -0.0298884566873312, -0.02927670069038868, -0.01856309548020363, -0.056132227182388306, -0.005964282434433699, -0.008662546053528786, 0.010350935161113739, -0.015588812530040741, -0.025082262232899666, -0.026280228048563004, 0.031012600287795067, -0.03534957766532898, 0.006626383867114782, 0.04469909518957138, -0.0069212159141898155, -0.02136974036693573, -0.020741857588291168, 0.004813460633158684, 0.020589126273989677, -0.006733717396855354, 0.024760855361819267, -0.028433091938495636, -0.05906703695654869, 0.009253211319446564, -0.03188972547650337, -0.0052050999365746975, 0.04701234772801399, -0.028543392196297646, 0.016823623329401016, 0.010238148272037506, -0.001613836968317628, -0.0015374186914414167, -0.03556448966264725, 0.022766485810279846, 0.012648235075175762, 0.030153164640069008, -0.002086802152916789, 0.018816117197275162, -0.019364669919013977, 0.020345652475953102, 0.0185623150318861, 0.0037838227581232786, 0.005000118166208267, -0.055146533995866776, -0.02471700869500637, -0.02071785181760788, -0.04528585076332092, 0.0033517470583319664, -0.04462376609444618, 0.09319499135017395, 0.01687328703701496, 0.0007372518302872777, 0.03495138883590698, -0.00633567851036787, 0.010977430269122124, 0.01137977372854948, -0.010206099599599838, -0.0838201642036438, -0.021063100546598434, 0.02427564188838005, -0.0026392231229692698, -0.03204645588994026, 0.007487409748136997, -0.03773661330342293, -0.023527126759290695, -0.001886040554381907, 0.012278580106794834, -0.0386694110929966, 0.014298615045845509, 0.012643540278077126, 0.0166966263204813, 0.003815737320110202, 0.01544939260929823, -0.019516129046678543, -0.02866852469742298, 0.031228432431817055, -0.016135241836309433, 0.010912364348769188, 0.003700678236782551, -0.025845741853117943, 0.03757299855351448, 0.010840357281267643, -0.017663389444351196, -0.001979299122467637, 0.01698140986263752, 0.02628593146800995, 0.028238652274012566, -0.00672152079641819, -0.0028508768882602453, -0.03460201248526573, 0.051472026854753494, -0.06913235038518906, -0.04162732511758804, 0.023288799449801445, -0.01318461261689663, 0.048722658306360245, 0.020476166158914566, 0.003005395643413067, -0.013775489293038845, 0.05394405499100685, -0.033653177320957184, -0.023005716502666473, -0.012316575273871422, -0.01826419122517109, 0.017711887136101723, 0.0019154924666509032, -0.017918704077601433, -0.0017074134666472673, -0.013508257456123829, 0.025907065719366074, 0.044449206441640854, 0.014776305295526981, -0.02090516686439514, -0.01717694103717804, 0.015482606366276741, -0.009851458482444286, 0.013328825123608112, -0.0033557035494595766, 0.015420760028064251, 0.060033053159713745, -0.050673339515924454, 0.0333033949136734, -0.046354323625564575, 0.02253788337111473, -0.05512700974941254, -0.05757782235741615, -0.009904489852488041, 0.040568795055150986, 0.00636147428303957, -0.028476502746343613, 0.02309449575841427, 0.019523896276950836, -0.061303239315748215, 0.023585982620716095, -0.013766135089099407, -0.012218927033245564, -0.023282935842871666, 0.014863191172480583, -0.014529525302350521, 0.002877210034057498, 0.0502745658159256, 0.03763806074857712, 0.040278609842061996, 0.03344807028770447, 0.016272684559226036, -0.004675875883549452, -0.010462271049618721, 0.040828730911016464, 0.007678827736526728, -0.06285982578992844, -0.0041130236349999905, -0.04589324817061424, -0.04614109545946121, 0.038669511675834656, 0.01233246736228466, 0.031715475022792816, 0.021269001066684723, 0.007361000869423151, -0.010481077246367931, 0.021945476531982422, 0.021616941317915916, 0.018007392063736916, -0.01419935654848814, -0.05245376005768776, 0.0033950635697692633, 0.020588016137480736, 0.000840263906866312, 0.030118128284811974, 0.05949234962463379, -0.0017139057163149118, -0.01398099772632122, -0.006740120705217123, -0.02039976231753826, -0.019716914743185043, 0.025604410097002983, -0.014532161876559258, 0.0006239082431420684, -0.0487675815820694, 0.03235667571425438, -0.042474281042814255, -0.009959716349840164, 0.03410198166966438, 0.010039879940450191, -0.03156157582998276, 0.023591777309775352, -0.035870037972927094, 0.02124355174601078, 0.006000708322972059, -0.03787306696176529, -0.010920567438006401, -0.05314622446894646, 0.00408581318333745, -0.016198916360735893, 0.029660452157258987, -0.044022753834724426, -0.036329615861177444, -0.023962369188666344, 0.03206150606274605, 0.0027622084598988295, -0.04852437227964401, -0.007472312077879906, 0.0319855622947216, 0.014414348639547825, -0.09655103832483292, 0.013252189382910728, 0.0062081473879516125, -0.029432671144604683, -0.04040825366973877, 0.0065083494409918785, -0.014937357045710087, 0.0006822681752964854, 0.039683252573013306, 0.06366044282913208, -0.026062361896038055, 0.006920539774000645, 0.009377360343933105, 0.020305633544921875, -0.06088720262050629, 0.04424695670604706, -0.015865420922636986, 0.003090052166953683, -0.035864610224962234, 0.005575204733759165, 0.0029453637544065714, -0.005646660923957825, 0.00822141207754612, -0.003763887332752347, 0.03150498494505882, -0.022161897271871567, 0.01650025136768818, 0.01799526996910572, 0.013012770563364029, 0.0023420134093612432, 0.05108293518424034, 0.006998833734542131, 0.0032861207146197557, 0.001190582406707108, -0.05154334008693695, -0.067039854824543, 0.035244882106781006, -0.010405942797660828, -0.015193200670182705, -0.003784871194511652, -0.03270867094397545, 0.025126038119196892, -0.046456996351480484, -0.0008663145126774907, 0.02202179655432701, -0.008657731115818024, 0.018940579146146774, 0.05380340293049812, 0.07653689384460449, 0.02590637095272541, -0.02320968732237816, 0.0013699388364329934, -0.0189996175467968, -0.032729484140872955, -0.011369843035936356, 0.0006629372364841402, 0.018237454816699028, -0.009045877493917942, -0.008169467560946941, 0.021742191165685654, -0.03751833736896515, 0.01035629864782095, -0.00514190411195159, 0.018576577305793762, -0.04351751133799553, -0.03897126764059067, -0.020555861294269562, -0.019893191754817963, 0.017771020531654358, 0.015785083174705505, 0.04080677777528763, 0.035463038831949234, -0.0015932092210277915, 0.008038141764700413, -0.05081312358379364, 0.006015260703861713, -0.02397060953080654, -0.0006806431338191032, 0.04354061931371689, 0.0026849752757698298, 0.017432544380426407, -0.008969436399638653, 0.003760614199563861, -0.005042605567723513, 0.030836038291454315, -0.012530253268778324, 0.022468864917755127, -0.05693425238132477, -0.05148286744952202, -0.019475353881716728, 0.020616309717297554, 0.0051014297641813755, -0.006416474003344774, 0.0376935750246048, 0.0525469072163105, 0.030170053243637085, -0.013299108482897282, -0.04569035768508911, 0.00044925595284439623, 0.05051235854625702, -0.044536955654621124, -0.02015611343085766, -0.048854127526283264, 0.03750021383166313, 0.003977322019636631, -0.034174878150224686 ]
<p>Is it possible to apply hurdle models (like the Craggit, probit and truncated models) to panel data, preferably with fixed effects to control for unobserved heterogeneity? </p> <p>In Stata, the user-written command <code>craggit</code> only allows to use pooled panel data, but not to control for unobserved heterogeneity... In general, the hurdle model is quite simple to estimate: probit model on the binary outcome variable, truncated (or lognormal) on the (positive values of the) outcome variable. Is it possible to just estimate a RE probit (or even FE logit) in a first step, and a fixed effects model in the second – and to actually call that a hurdle model? Thanks.</p>
37,360
[ -0.019637590274214745, 0.008933041244745255, 0.036212459206581116, 0.025890985503792763, 0.013979526236653328, 0.04827054589986801, -0.03375692293047905, -0.02929297462105751, 0.04854423180222511, -0.010147791355848312, 0.037277769297361374, 0.010116957128047943, 0.05483922362327576, -0.02003960683941841, 0.03418537974357605, 0.012145567685365677, 0.0015955534763634205, 0.004356903489679098, -0.03152177110314369, 0.011637345887720585, -0.013857387006282806, 0.056096307933330536, -0.012456494383513927, 0.007086331956088543, 0.007380681578069925, 0.013423359021544456, 0.004993248265236616, -0.017385117709636688, -0.0008590944344177842, 0.09557688981294632, -0.015605184249579906, -0.020390650257468224, -0.021478725597262383, -0.023115918040275574, -0.03549419716000557, 0.001983723836019635, 0.00012485253682825714, -0.04694860801100731, -0.04883672669529915, 0.006534887012094259, -0.04634406417608261, 0.01796058565378189, -0.025318805128335953, 0.05087367445230484, -0.00126857019495219, 0.011272638104856014, 0.009113329462707043, -0.01382560282945633, 0.026269979774951935, -0.024115310981869698, 0.06191248446702957, -0.0032737257424741983, 0.05276215821504593, 0.01933209039270878, -0.021159138530492783, -0.009178373962640762, 0.05933912843465805, 0.08641750365495682, -0.011784366331994534, -0.01937435008585453, -0.012630211189389229, -0.03736221790313721, 0.026608053594827652, -0.053988266736269, -0.0536935031414032, 0.010416273958981037, -0.018404213711619377, -0.02874942123889923, 0.02748415246605873, -0.020560000091791153, 0.007872452028095722, 0.017309481278061867, -0.0001859272742876783, 0.04033954069018364, 0.033265043050050735, -0.0690762922167778, 0.0054300036281347275, -0.002007503528147936, 0.018049269914627075, 0.08495438098907471, -0.001210202812217176, -0.0020228263456374407, 0.03281058743596077, 0.022649317979812622, 0.039725810289382935, -0.02882404997944832, 0.0317719392478466, -0.04057999327778816, 0.02026909589767456, -0.028342340141534805, -0.045774076133966446, -0.008056429214775562, 0.047970689833164215, 0.004293991718441248, -0.02661050111055374, 0.037396565079689026, -0.004217891488224268, 0.049621451646089554, 0.02747430093586445, -0.0030995365232229233, -0.027933435514569283, -0.021355731412768364, -0.018204936757683754, 0.06317950785160065, 0.0037744578439742327, 0.059614989906549454, -0.013140717521309853, 0.0018870242638513446, 0.01086005661636591, -0.030889764428138733, -0.011793223209679127, -0.008640042506158352, -0.02405715174973011, -0.024586554616689682, 0.03212832286953926, -0.011849694885313511, -0.011143360286951065, -0.013068058528006077, 0.06240919977426529, 0.08543524891138077, 0.05088043585419655, -0.025242414325475693, 0.019667912274599075, -0.02591300755739212, -0.09655894339084625, 0.013617811724543571, 0.007715306244790554, -0.018291648477315903, -0.05163778364658356, 0.015601985156536102, -0.004676169250160456, -0.03624277561903, 0.04933450371026993, -0.00009346322622150183, 0.03113153576850891, 0.009427962824702263, -0.04128890857100487, -0.0880519449710846, 0.0020705354399979115, 0.011680022813379765, 0.010267985984683037, -0.033905234187841415, -0.0005167818744666874, -0.027399227023124695, 0.06135685369372368, 0.004737030249089003, 0.04819294810295105, 0.023504259064793587, 0.01310169231146574, 0.011090206913650036, 0.014001886360347271, -0.029241768643260002, -0.019663263112306595, 0.0011705512879416347, -0.017274437472224236, -0.10053534805774689, 0.0457027405500412, 0.003240669844672084, 0.0015113831032067537, -0.00759316748008132, 0.07659554481506348, 0.02329072169959545, -0.005615563597530127, 0.001764139742590487, -0.008326306007802486, -0.009165673516690731, 0.057965658605098724, -0.010234732180833817, 0.027128471061587334, 0.05464322119951248, 0.013624103739857674, -0.0076132360845804214, 0.025734249502420425, 0.05243828520178795, 0.026466209441423416, -0.00534087372943759, -0.010667236521840096, -0.012096852995455265, 0.028439080342650414, -0.00395052507519722, -0.07509928196668625, 0.010309143923223019, -0.0037931466940790415, -0.053379517048597336, -0.007092828396707773, 0.03240428492426872, 0.010506863705813885, -0.0062612188048660755, 0.022432181984186172, -0.027697745710611343, -0.039611540734767914, -0.09811148792505264, -0.006085927132517099, -0.009356868453323841, 0.02512834034860134, 0.027469687163829803, 0.01234618853777647, 0.05564694106578827, 0.013534681871533394, 0.0029321089386940002, -0.013998638838529587, -0.01492072269320488, 0.04142159968614578, -0.048633478581905365, -0.0006353692733682692, 0.01200051698833704, 0.08605518937110901, -0.003110895399004221, 0.07406587153673172, -0.018565859645605087, -0.03585454821586609, 0.007395326625555754, -0.029732385650277138, 0.028138967230916023, -0.024001186713576317, -0.004916698671877384, -0.012318491004407406, 0.006280724890530109, -0.022310268133878708, 0.013187255710363388, -0.05019155144691467, 0.021224236115813255, 0.05355023220181465, 0.010111863724887371, 0.018569286912679672, 0.005041615571826696, 0.012389648705720901, 0.02356458082795143, -0.026204122230410576, -0.05671440809965134, 0.009511221200227737, 0.01518427487462759, 0.029999149963259697, 0.006437164731323719, -0.035215824842453, 0.014581096358597279, 0.06546654552221298, -0.01748533733189106, -0.005063538905233145, 0.026003828272223473, -0.01802295632660389, 0.0110630476847291, 0.02596709318459034, 0.004378604702651501, 0.010051640681922436, 0.018437156453728676, 0.005902400705963373, -0.008162656798958778, 0.019617119804024696, -0.0457359179854393, 0.02920069545507431, 0.03230539336800575, 0.028245452791452408, 0.017360208556056023, 0.0018683018861338496, -0.03654465451836586, 0.05001990124583244, -0.0026901133824139833, 0.04228813946247101, 0.01759953610599041, 0.03965648263692856, -0.0032624131999909878, 0.00714179826900363, -0.01981968618929386, 0.04910685867071152, 0.02928827330470085, -0.0022645089775323868, 0.00045716570457443595, 0.0028231616597622633, -0.0022855051793158054, 0.02082129567861557, -0.019911136478185654, 0.0014947688905522227, -0.012900492176413536, 0.0057023572735488415, 0.03423263505101204, -0.011175683699548244, 0.03255900368094444, -0.02551598660647869, -0.005936637986451387, 0.022957639768719673, 0.004234757274389267, 0.03635653108358383, 0.01991131342947483, -0.03054225817322731, -0.004533912055194378, -0.015594379045069218, -0.03796255588531494, 0.036827970296144485, 0.00774584012106061, -0.031051218509674072, 0.03940153867006302, -0.0016451620031148195, 0.03088100627064705, -0.013344568200409412, -0.02757939323782921, 0.005921854171901941, -0.05122175067663193, -0.014902818948030472, 0.01116989180445671, -0.006323348265141249, -0.006674126256257296, 0.0331292487680912, -0.0582023449242115, -0.019934745505452156, -0.011123435571789742, 0.03488672152161598, 0.00003205009124940261, -0.004210946150124073, 0.03337591513991356, 0.018317319452762604, -0.00811900943517685, 0.0015562931075692177, -0.05680682510137558, -0.0576624795794487, 0.018002988770604134, -0.007882002741098404, 0.009853992611169815, 0.009218991734087467, -0.008526138961315155, 0.049539610743522644, 0.007864147424697876, -0.002665748819708824, -0.05128360167145729, -0.008343898691236973, 0.003118426539003849, 0.01615152508020401, -0.009991657920181751, -0.00443101255223155, -0.0036543384194374084, 0.015200368128716946, -0.03329210728406906, 0.04940211400389671, 0.051688577979803085, 0.04232754185795784, -0.0028225204441696405, 0.0001921909279190004, 0.004163110628724098, -0.05881819501519203, 0.0005412009195424616, 0.011112400330603123, 0.002945543732494116, -0.00680634006857872, -0.04182187467813492, 0.019795238971710205, 0.005929887760430574, -0.02238195389509201, 0.011205515824258327, 0.008412904106080532, -0.022390587255358696, -0.032830610871315, 0.023100856691598892, 0.020790768787264824, -0.025060145184397697, -0.003038521157577634, 0.016614820808172226, 0.01434960588812828, -0.026477640494704247, 0.005622521508485079, 0.012939224019646645, 0.027455516159534454, -0.002463364275172353, -0.02157749980688095, 0.0075181289575994015, -0.009687516838312149, 0.04717019572854042, 0.006287377327680588, -0.005710223224014044, 0.02019522711634636, 0.03645149618387222, -0.008033182471990585, 0.007658666931092739, -0.0413665734231472, 0.0031941516790539026, -0.059073738753795624, -0.011727270670235157, -0.0350266769528389, 0.04191455990076065, -0.011892027221620083, 0.0019183886470273137, -0.019413772970438004, -0.003136861138045788, -0.040465474128723145, 0.009697589091956615, -0.07739292830228806, 0.01563502475619316, -0.023399636149406433, 0.0309969000518322, 0.014869866892695427, -0.03610160946846008, 0.02223501354455948, 0.0019435510039329529, -0.024648752063512802, -0.01026180014014244, 0.019054878503084183, -0.01828562095761299, 0.000389845110476017, 0.009313546121120453, -0.05186384543776512, 0.0008150370558723807, -0.013954224064946175, -0.002889019437134266, -0.007608334068208933, -0.021830415353178978, 0.010381435044109821, -0.006486291065812111, -0.015460889786481857, -0.0221116840839386, -0.0031018622685223818, -0.032891277223825455, 0.04165470227599144, 0.03547379747033119, 0.02793852612376213, -0.04842529818415642, 0.017552604898810387, 0.009300168603658676, 0.08950208127498627, 0.03239021450281143, 0.027710387483239174, -0.004721225239336491, -0.0222295131534338, -0.029915325343608856, 0.039491768926382065, -0.00985077116638422, 0.009509637020528316, -0.004727988038212061, 0.061696749180555344, 0.03040309064090252, -0.08660022914409637, -0.02716393955051899, 0.04035442695021629, 0.055549491196870804, -0.015217840671539307, -0.048258427530527115, -0.028106532990932465, -0.002412215806543827, -0.015190047211945057, 0.014477208256721497, 0.022185154259204865, -0.01720353774726391, 0.01811840943992138, 0.08763809502124786, 0.0005376290646381676, -0.06238620728254318, 0.018238386139273643, 0.030085500329732895, 0.029972758144140244, -0.0080780740827322, -0.03714650496840477, 0.04609521105885506, 0.04109887033700943, -0.009078633971512318, 0.026332316920161247, -0.01488696038722992, -0.08847960084676743, 0.04041096940636635, 0.012718770653009415, 0.009736073203384876, -0.03385911136865616, 0.025960508733987808, 0.011124974116683006, 0.012347624637186527, 0.0032350942492485046, -0.03122841566801071, 0.004419735167175531, -0.02457517385482788, 0.009214038960635662, -0.01481412909924984, -0.006637788377702236, -0.0074273524805903435, 0.037699900567531586, 0.012168697081506252, -0.0041319094598293304, -0.014283022843301296, -0.038674090057611465, -0.004464391618967056, 0.0432702973484993, 0.01425221562385559, 0.07966926693916321, -0.019015459343791008, 0.0023248554207384586, 0.030740007758140564, 0.009849419817328453, -0.05986098200082779, -0.06939864158630371, -0.015790332108736038, 0.00843251496553421, -0.015119659714400768, 0.056536369025707245, 0.016051623970270157, -0.01657296158373356, 0.02541966550052166, 0.00888276007026434, 0.020053314045071602, 0.03154102340340614, -0.03488539531826973, 0.05259869247674942, -0.006011512130498886, 0.008911637589335442, 0.06931494176387787, 0.055174119770526886, -0.017818327993154526, 0.02951628901064396, -0.019139211624860764, 0.03625379130244255, -0.054303787648677826, -0.019389057531952858, -0.03499643877148628, 0.008124410174787045, -0.0019381266320124269, 0.011082006618380547, -0.0016514580929651856, 0.02969452738761902, -0.03657342121005058, -0.04076175019145012, -0.029678260907530785, -0.0072293635457754135, -0.010797101072967052, -0.03296114131808281, 0.006847325712442398, 0.05268673971295357, 0.006944717839360237, -0.05347532033920288, -0.011535079218447208, -0.008011531084775925, 0.03123677335679531, -0.023788483813405037, -0.03341049328446388, 0.00748440483585, -0.020370056852698326, -0.032001055777072906, 0.02770601026713848, 0.009798518382012844, 0.009136843495070934, -0.02197636105120182, 0.012215464375913143, -0.06350911408662796, -0.05910017713904381, 0.0009473345126025379, 0.026899104937911034, 0.01666044443845749, 0.008960152976214886, -0.00785346794873476, 0.04501671716570854, 0.03990686684846878, -0.04427992179989815, -0.10088557004928589, -0.00394852738827467, -0.001871589687652886, -0.018252376466989517, 0.0016540463548153639, -0.03586185723543167, 0.001478769350796938, -0.02791399322450161, -0.06557174026966095, 0.0009928550571203232, 0.08743011951446533, -0.026806868612766266, 0.009066556580364704, -0.061177778989076614, 0.02073647268116474, 0.06436096131801605, 0.021802285686135292, -0.031181711703538895, 0.02755342237651348, -0.047462813556194305, -0.005864473059773445, 0.005430249962955713, -0.026395192369818687, -0.003461170243099332, 0.018477339297533035, -0.029915347695350647, -0.005592997185885906, 0.022519242018461227, -0.005999953486025333, -0.007925285957753658, 0.03134438022971153, -0.02110227942466736, 0.007175541948527098, -0.022145377472043037, 0.016744719818234444, -0.002754860557615757, 0.03706915304064751, -0.02255716361105442, 0.02743481658399105, -0.03567919880151749, -0.011272888630628586, 0.0650750994682312, -0.03536447510123253, -0.010270527563989162, 0.01226444449275732, 0.07706144452095032, -0.007688968908041716, 0.00848151370882988, 0.02991906926035881, -0.0034824737813323736, 0.0709948018193245, -0.008932485245168209, -0.02687123231589794, 0.024465354159474373, -0.002020598156377673, 0.010405739769339561, -0.05787862837314606, -0.042618244886398315, 0.013554024510085583, 0.03224463760852814, -0.02141440100967884, 0.03519453853368759, 0.025860456749796867, -0.03087540529668331, -0.023294983431696892, -0.02465151436626911, 0.020746631547808647, -0.008335630409419537, 0.016706129536032677, 0.0756462812423706, -0.001470272778533399, -0.018994389101862907, 0.05180812627077103, 0.025426067411899567, 0.034651681780815125, 0.03983528912067413, 0.02364974655210972, 0.046496231108903885, 0.0011768578551709652, -0.029682347550988197, -0.017152836546301842, 0.030560964718461037, -0.04077932983636856, 0.021220652386546135, -0.020795442163944244, -0.05009884014725685, 0.022807013243436813, 0.03614306077361107, -0.0018883944721892476, -0.041556671261787415, -0.0035042772069573402, -0.07056590169668198, 0.06768301129341125, 0.01689975894987583, -0.02085038460791111, 0.029208805412054062, -0.016793563961982727, 0.04814674332737923, -0.02752259187400341, 0.007581606972962618, -0.0032648316118866205, -0.09088464826345444, -0.004127058200538158, -0.012191789224743843, -0.010820894502103329, -0.023491978645324707, 0.020687172189354897, -0.020822610706090927, -0.006891991943120956, -0.02958614192903042, -0.016910957172513008, -0.03146590664982796, 0.03837379068136215, -0.02027958817780018, 0.04166800528764725, -0.032821014523506165, 0.03456106036901474, 0.005509553011506796, -0.02951839379966259, 0.12044309079647064, 0.08547163009643555, 0.0560174286365509, -0.05116421356797218, 0.021920006722211838, 0.04148153215646744, 0.02169562689960003, -0.011604363098740578, -0.023774178698658943, 0.025979382917284966, -0.03526052460074425, 0.03502877056598663, 0.0663873553276062, 0.016232497990131378, 0.021671583876013756, 0.06303536146879196, -0.025877246633172035, -0.027161847800016403, 0.005166938062757254, 0.017908621579408646, 0.014377412386238575, -0.024084636941552162, -0.028609497472643852, -0.0011491688201203942, 0.004131122957915068, -0.021903540939092636, -0.014137421734631062, 0.02051040343940258, -0.028958359733223915, 0.04289964959025383, -0.014652306213974953, -0.02548694610595703, -0.005212283693253994, 0.03759192302823067, -0.008256065659224987, -0.01600673235952854, -0.01950100250542164, -0.006156932096928358, 0.0133809270337224, 0.015044046565890312, -0.007177081890404224, -0.013873856514692307, 0.003069695085287094, 0.020105674862861633, -0.03538040816783905, -0.02298460155725479, -0.0227028988301754, 0.016097450628876686, -0.018702883273363113, 0.01921061985194683, 0.008889826014637947, -0.014604506082832813, 0.005020168609917164, -0.0085047148168087, -0.04080914333462715, 0.03109276480972767, 0.014344314113259315, -0.013424801640212536, -0.021820619702339172, -0.04730210825800896, 0.011611795984208584, -0.02384450100362301, 0.03372842073440552, 0.038198355585336685, -0.07004640996456146, -0.0009061272721737623, -0.018115468323230743, 0.06615059077739716, -0.027066977694630623, -0.020017830654978752, -0.0024699890054762363, -0.031167812645435333, -0.023376649245619774, -0.027889778837561607, 0.014383897185325623, 0.03313537687063217, 0.021510090678930283, -0.001377614913508296, 0.019142232835292816, -0.014902128838002682, -0.02220817655324936, -0.005395808257162571, -0.035653579980134964, -0.02017500251531601, -0.08010920882225037, 0.03237718343734741, 0.03887275606393814, -0.0007067223195917904, -0.017975743860006332, 0.009645973332226276, -0.01900276355445385, 0.05313101038336754, 0.0126471733674407, -0.05156862363219261, -0.024740904569625854, -0.014608172699809074, -0.04286739602684975, -0.0017427444690838456, 0.010116104036569595, 0.03597412258386612, -0.022608404979109764, 0.015091157518327236, -0.04533141851425171, 0.043022409081459045, -0.006660833489149809, 0.043994855135679245, 0.04746246337890625, -0.07722635567188263, -0.015444589778780937, 0.0003255950869061053, 0.029250048100948334, -0.027783939614892006, 0.012950767762959003, -0.01655661314725876, -0.03715968504548073, 0.04672178253531456, -0.020260831341147423, -0.040472716093063354, 0.013594137504696846, -0.0324280820786953, 0.03575795888900757, -0.01973007060587406, -0.024887416511774063, -0.02435624971985817, -0.043730299919843674, 0.00037562675424851477, -0.017356649041175842, 0.02389407530426979, 0.03169563412666321, -0.012094269506633282, 0.00867183692753315, 0.0064490800723433495, -0.002145474310964346, -0.00021962668688502163, 0.01912641152739525, 0.020990800112485886, -0.002881186781451106, -0.006751586217433214, -0.008465767838060856, -0.006399739068001509, 0.03008904680609703, -0.027293942868709564, -0.028951890766620636, -0.008100949227809906, 0.002677659736946225, 0.05827994644641876, 0.02184063382446766, -0.013706834055483341, -0.00634040730074048, 0.038120560348033905, -0.03824098780751228, -0.017447998747229576, 0.009567351080477238, 0.011573048308491707, -0.006369519513100386, -0.006232174579054117, -0.03413449972867966, 0.03555629402399063, -0.04155736416578293, 0.05722539871931076, 0.052816733717918396, 0.014182248152792454, -0.028536779806017876, 0.015078946948051453, 0.00042405558633618057, 0.019091686233878136, -0.003118208609521389, -0.006729301530867815, -0.020886056125164032, 0.035286687314510345, -0.013324483297765255, 0.03457404300570488, -0.012175553478300571, -0.004702907055616379, -0.03812067583203316, -0.028897270560264587, 0.029143447056412697, 0.03425297513604164, 0.01502840407192707, -0.008106119930744171, 0.02971719019114971, -0.0011401301017031074, -0.02661777287721634, -0.019821012392640114, 0.0020361021161079407, 0.002908033551648259, -0.05317533388733864, 0.02245050109922886, -0.03773953393101692, 0.0003571470733731985, -0.0023589211050421, 0.016232183203101158, 0.000008754381269682199, 0.04199618846178055, 0.004695425741374493, -0.0330103375017643, -0.003194256220012903, 0.0006946545909158885, 0.013271525502204895, -0.06659349799156189, 0.03830324113368988, -0.06273940950632095, -0.042849935591220856, 0.04100984334945679, -0.016803745180368423, 0.043682608753442764, 0.009393985383212566, 0.01210971549153328, 0.0002511554630473256, 0.03046296536922455, 0.01725824922323227, 0.048018116503953934, -0.0026371765416115522, 0.0126020647585392, -0.007573521696031094, 0.013523492030799389, -0.0019859136082232, 0.0161872748285532, 0.04025682434439659, 0.02276492305099964, -0.024054447188973427, 0.0331554114818573, -0.03457169607281685, -0.001679788576439023, -0.02129991352558136, -0.053955379873514175, -0.015029141679406166, -0.013992193154990673, 0.03527436777949333, -0.014577898196876049, -0.014426961541175842, 0.04905427619814873, -0.0033645944204181433, -0.025045549497008324, 0.027954770252108574, -0.039442576467990875, -0.010828578844666481, 0.0076172188855707645, 0.037829238921403885, -0.023618202656507492, -0.04964400455355644, -0.012394591234624386, 0.027887118980288506, -0.03193977475166321, -0.028793497011065483, 0.017388010397553444, -0.009334185160696507, 0.03076229989528656, -0.0828082263469696, -0.004902673419564962, 0.011186745949089527, 0.018325820565223694, -0.0016975727630779147, -0.08149877935647964, 0.07284469902515411, 0.014300254173576832, -0.011416321620345116, -0.01359457615762949, -0.026694748550653458, -0.026067323982715607, -0.0031433324329555035, 0.03358078375458717, -0.03471546992659569, -0.007236726116389036, 0.012736039236187935, 0.030357424169778824, -0.009506831876933575, -0.0005972962244413793, 0.031272947788238525, 0.003033698070794344, -0.04237530753016472, -0.022913949564099312, -0.015826374292373657, -0.000613576325122267, -0.018706129863858223, 0.02877248078584671, -0.017238717526197433, -0.014714401215314865, 0.035520076751708984, -0.020904365926980972, 0.008920769207179546, 0.038119763135910034, 0.002130771754309535, 0.03376322239637375, -0.03734110668301582, 0.02053936757147312, 0.04458506032824516, 0.001981665613129735, -0.013499585911631584, 0.028336912393569946, -0.03249821066856384, -0.06680803000926971, 0.007138374727219343, 0.012869054451584816, -0.016293207183480263, -0.06990104168653488, 0.043840061873197556, 0.023403625935316086, -0.03786342591047287, 0.033662158995866776, 0.05060605704784393, 0.012284542433917522, 0.018204940482974052, 0.01573931984603405, -0.025631165131926537, 0.013486983254551888, -0.004880231339484453, 0.021093986928462982, -0.0067161815240979195, 0.07690595835447311, 0.0145682692527771, -0.027866996824741364, 0.0018935907864943147, -0.0439898855984211, 0.05444726720452309, -0.03384270519018173, 0.053593482822179794, -0.011122806929051876, -0.050732485949993134, -0.012766117230057716, 0.010018127039074898, 0.01928490772843361, -0.00792615208774805, -0.003718800377100706, 0.03537798300385475, -0.004280181135982275, 0.02757369913160801, -0.007153764832764864, -0.022357450798153877, -0.030640579760074615, 0.02319273166358471, 0.01473486702889204, 0.027398904785513878, 0.010413999669253826, -0.00344861694611609, -0.00022988095588516444, -0.03492945805191994, -0.0015714378096163273, -0.003995909821242094, 0.027700714766979218, -0.01920691877603531, -0.02363235503435135, -0.018073048442602158, -0.01138345431536436, -0.04239022359251976, -0.019610827788710594, 0.005172832868993282, 0.012471513822674751, -0.022668156772851944, -0.02182653732597828, -0.02105538360774517, 0.040290579199790955, 0.05378809943795204, -0.07138911634683609, -0.005140090826898813, -0.02458876557648182, -0.00036031357012689114, -0.034031979739665985, 0.025713568553328514 ]
<p>Asked a version of this question before but realized it needed some clarification.</p> <p>I have a dataset with identical twin pairs and fraternal twin pairs. I want to examine the relationship between an outcome variable ("DEPENDENT") and a number of other variables ("INDEPENDENT"). However, I can't run a normal OLS regression because each twin's dependent variable is correlated with their co-twin's (for my purposes, this is a nuisance). </p> <p>The way I have been dealing with this is to use SAS PROC MIXED and include a random intercept defined by twin cluster (FAMILYID). Here is my syntax: </p> <pre><code>proc mixed method=ml covtest noclprint; class FAMILYID; model DEPENDENT = INDEPENDENT/solution; random intercept/sub=FAMILYID type=un gcorr; run; </code></pre> <p>When I do this, I get a covariance parameter estimate for the "FAMILYID" as well as a residual term. My understanding is that this decomposes the variability into "within-cluster" variability (residual estimate) and "between-cluster" variability (FAMILYID estimate). I get the intraclass correlation coefficient for the family clusters by computing: (FAMILYID estimate) divided by (FAMILYID estimate + residual estimate). </p> <p>However! I realized that I probably have a heteroskedasticity issue, because fraternal twin pair members are likely to be markedly less similar to each other than identical twin pair members are. </p> <p>I revised my syntax to this: </p> <pre><code>proc mixed method=ml covtest noclprint; class FAMILYID; model DEPENDENT = INDEPENDENT/solution; random intercept/sub=FAMILYID group=TWINTYPE type=un gcorr; run; </code></pre> <p>Where TWINTYPE signifies whether the twin pair is identical or fraternal. When I do this, I get one FAMILYID estimate for fraternal twins, one FAMILYID estimate for identical twins, and one residual term. So -- this means that I have told my model to make different "between-cluster" estimates for identical and fraternal twins -- but isn't it still disregarding twin type when it calculates the residual term? And if the residual term reflects the "within-cluster" variability, isn't it a problem that it doesn't take into consideration that there is likely to be LESS variability within an identical twin pair on the outcome variable and MORE variability within a fraternal twin pair? </p> <p>So I guess my question is one of two things: </p> <ol> <li>is there syntax that would leave me with a between-cluster estimate for identical twins and fraternal twins, and then a residual term for identical twins and fraternal twins? or </li> <li>Am I fundamentally confused about how all of this works, and if so, what am I missing?</li> </ol> <p>Help/clarification much much appreciated. </p>
74,472
[ -0.008276846259832382, 0.008324189111590385, 0.01797834038734436, -0.011319447308778763, 0.032724007964134216, 0.007323819678276777, -0.04999926686286926, -0.03787555173039436, 0.04411502182483673, -0.02179594337940216, 0.04550803080201149, 0.027807412669062614, 0.07063522934913635, -0.0009030638611875474, 0.04643620178103447, -0.021345818415284157, 0.005902386736124754, 0.008875110186636448, 0.005072503350675106, 0.007699221838265657, -0.04973917081952095, 0.009488411247730255, 0.003914284519851208, -0.029496807605028152, 0.00431887386366725, 0.046875961124897, 0.021364612504839897, -0.054376959800720215, 0.023872746154665947, 0.03084167279303074, -0.04831630736589432, -0.01738114096224308, 0.001544702216051519, -0.002978342352434993, 0.008138701319694519, 0.007532844319939613, -0.01637532003223896, 0.005198031198233366, 0.007536374963819981, 0.060753628611564636, -0.035938236862421036, 0.0055456911213696, -0.027887562289834023, 0.03996596485376358, -0.01891508884727955, 0.001190390670672059, -0.004422921221703291, 0.017406517639756203, 0.05387967824935913, -0.021240519359707832, 0.07422862946987152, -0.03937061131000519, 0.046964701265096664, 0.05609939247369766, -0.048207979649305344, 0.014225490391254425, 0.06649915128946304, 0.03204534202814102, -0.005651889834553003, -0.015273057855665684, -0.020305238664150238, -0.021487293764948845, 0.018461596220731735, -0.00942351296544075, -0.034648507833480835, -0.01598409004509449, 0.012282307259738445, -0.02563178911805153, 0.01213070098310709, -0.02346613258123398, 0.03849352151155472, 0.0006417553522624075, 0.029477499425411224, -0.02235979400575161, 0.03299702703952789, -0.05113629996776581, -0.022198554128408432, 0.0002909228205680847, 0.04127146303653717, -0.004274845588952303, -0.018795980140566826, 0.03483401611447334, 0.006747310049831867, -0.006287877913564444, 0.007938661612570286, -0.025596432387828827, 0.023400479927659035, -0.021781859919428825, 0.011280111037194729, 0.055963266640901566, 0.012534905225038528, 0.041852593421936035, 0.06288618594408035, 0.027785977348685265, -0.03603183850646019, 0.07788583636283875, -0.015475559048354626, 0.02679373510181904, 0.017996104434132576, 0.02305391989648342, -0.03757939115166664, -0.07240273058414459, 0.017455214634537697, 0.03980664536356926, -0.020338909700512886, -0.01472296379506588, -0.017151206731796265, -0.018333515152335167, 0.014403964392840862, -0.034560427069664, 0.009929300285875797, 0.002760146977379918, -0.01085742563009262, -0.008235902525484562, 0.05446900054812431, -0.04352018982172012, -0.009475142695009708, 0.02844744361937046, 0.027993252500891685, 0.046018291264772415, 0.02922510728240013, -0.040142517536878586, -0.002576709957793355, -0.023058157414197922, -0.015708351507782936, -0.008358493447303772, 0.01728578470647335, -0.0036984465550631285, -0.011789653450250626, 0.03144685551524162, 0.015070868656039238, -0.013976692222058773, 0.01310331467539072, -0.027854273095726967, 0.0011491801124066114, -0.005431243684142828, -0.05074922367930412, -0.05958188325166702, -0.005866028368473053, 0.009968044236302376, 0.027849921956658363, -0.048547182232141495, -0.008509673178195953, -0.0042335460893809795, 0.08410529792308807, -0.015328975394368172, 0.02987927384674549, 0.015092480927705765, 0.03575922176241875, 0.017106058076024055, 0.016774093732237816, -0.038424547761678696, -0.013728414662182331, -0.019371014088392258, -0.04524872824549675, -0.10542722046375275, 0.034131698310375214, -0.007182343862950802, -0.020824233070015907, 0.028515169396996498, 0.026006383821368217, -0.005375265143811703, 0.008304920978844166, -0.010121846571564674, 0.014496330171823502, -0.03143317252397537, 0.0527082234621048, -0.040074557065963745, 0.0366385355591774, 0.028928915038704872, -0.019844479858875275, 0.011359553784132004, 0.014721549116075039, 0.055429842323064804, 0.020760053768754005, 0.005022713448852301, -0.0039043391589075327, 0.02716207504272461, 0.01230792235583067, 0.018754784017801285, -0.03166167438030243, -0.04354119673371315, -0.006217338144779205, 0.01736726239323616, 0.008551526814699173, -0.02495964616537094, 0.010977599769830704, -0.008830148726701736, 0.06545247882604599, -0.014944124035537243, -0.061982836574316025, -0.06336697190999985, -0.007919940166175365, 0.012713933363556862, -0.03949819505214691, 0.01226869784295559, -0.018409574404358864, 0.04496031627058983, 0.04293723776936531, -0.048153478652238846, -0.06466871500015259, 0.02128174901008606, 0.05291847139596939, -0.030570432543754578, 0.0339222215116024, 0.024564657360315323, 0.023837953805923462, -0.024018218740820885, 0.044713400304317474, -0.008218329399824142, -0.01623990200459957, 0.04176396131515503, -0.030592747032642365, -0.007103686220943928, 0.022025762125849724, -0.00795829575508833, 0.002689479384571314, 0.012003536336123943, -0.0367252454161644, 0.029755404219031334, -0.035806965082883835, 0.020439986139535904, 0.06569366902112961, 0.0003549211542122066, -0.008101468905806541, -0.00905388593673706, -0.018368510529398918, 0.007868385873734951, -0.02984924241900444, -0.007732816971838474, 0.003903417382389307, -0.028800996020436287, 0.030668549239635468, 0.004517917521297932, -0.03673882409930229, -0.01436641439795494, 0.06953185796737671, 0.017032461240887642, 0.010983307845890522, 0.01633385196328163, -0.0014211252564564347, -0.0456511452794075, 0.018292831256985664, 0.009400730021297932, 0.0358198806643486, 0.004386168904602528, 0.0077036903239786625, 0.0047059752978384495, 0.016820723190903664, 0.006056149024516344, -0.001903171418234706, 0.05991003289818764, 0.008073479868471622, -0.007240715436637402, -0.001860185177065432, -0.01396860834211111, 0.0477541945874691, 0.025306642055511475, 0.03443099558353424, 0.026827143505215645, 0.005471713840961456, -0.01887362264096737, 0.026325680315494537, -0.012246022932231426, 0.025119591504335403, 0.032968804240226746, -0.006203235127031803, -0.00033343108952976763, 0.0061538792215287685, -0.03364747762680054, 0.025793464854359627, -0.01631847769021988, -0.010891159065067768, -0.045228246599435806, 0.018501536920666695, -0.018563279882073402, 0.01295512169599533, 0.028908083215355873, -0.04245387017726898, -0.01699797809123993, -0.011050262488424778, -0.027525488287210464, 0.028031598776578903, -0.032261922955513, -0.06682803481817245, -0.013176282867789268, -0.040815964341163635, 0.04172028601169586, -0.009392965584993362, 0.01995948515832424, -0.06555207073688507, 0.03148909658193588, 0.01317985262721777, -0.03886419162154198, -0.06219358369708061, -0.029009243473410606, -0.015783362090587616, -0.04363400489091873, -0.013905848376452923, 0.02998577430844307, 0.004070672672241926, -0.0463431179523468, 0.012374799698591232, -0.046669840812683105, 0.01831960305571556, -0.003583206795156002, -0.006844580639153719, 0.029085563495755196, 0.009778848849236965, 0.01408770028501749, 0.03959575667977333, -0.015419768169522285, -0.04462115466594696, -0.05144144967198372, -0.0648278295993805, 0.008519385010004044, -0.012170014902949333, -0.005713669117540121, -0.016605278477072716, -0.010143095627427101, 0.04659757390618324, 0.010545218363404274, 0.0038391943089663982, -0.035672884434461594, -0.013357299380004406, -0.022309470921754837, -0.03424690663814545, 0.04286783188581467, 0.0086800092831254, 0.0216003879904747, 0.010033879429101944, -0.01414045225828886, 0.017071090638637543, 0.058110516518354416, 0.022483661770820618, 0.016223957762122154, 0.026947898790240288, -0.011351628229022026, 0.006770854350179434, 0.04820537939667702, 0.03331410512328148, -0.030426394194364548, 0.02561141736805439, -0.002027630340307951, -0.004170830827206373, -0.0035835308954119682, -0.05402624234557152, -0.008805494755506516, -0.008131911978125572, -0.009197237901389599, -0.03701392933726311, 0.027154093608260155, 0.022871365770697594, -0.025230269879102707, -0.015182407572865486, -0.004986610263586044, 0.030702531337738037, -0.01183188147842884, -0.006946298759430647, 0.05413297563791275, 0.008563956245779991, 0.03662103787064552, 0.006009742617607117, -0.005486386828124523, -0.03671717643737793, 0.012181144207715988, -0.035160575062036514, -0.012428825721144676, 0.03720732033252716, 0.043177127838134766, 0.016831597313284874, -0.029467742890119553, -0.046771787106990814, -0.015950996428728104, -0.05727405846118927, 0.02139400690793991, -0.038908183574676514, 0.060233209282159805, -0.011014346033334732, 0.047522809356451035, 0.02145126834511757, -0.0031616464257240295, 0.012824072502553463, -0.0035220186691731215, -0.047136470675468445, 0.029207346960902214, 0.003091322025284171, -0.026448914781212807, -0.0011025560088455677, -0.06511019170284271, 0.021337203681468964, 0.0004837143642362207, -0.0018549723317846656, 0.014950832352042198, -0.015324640087783337, -0.017567511647939682, 0.033659543842077255, 0.001199263264425099, -0.006293120793998241, -0.025299260392785072, 0.041466936469078064, -0.005321180447936058, -0.019373886287212372, 0.011084134690463543, 0.035351309925317764, 0.013479663990437984, 0.007112327963113785, -0.05157114565372467, 0.004346718080341816, 0.006570026744157076, 0.040995270013809204, 0.002863400150090456, 0.03297646716237068, -0.02926282025873661, 0.02417256496846676, -0.012223228812217712, 0.05793362855911255, 0.07429718226194382, 0.017483703792095184, 0.01709667406976223, -0.0018000493291765451, -0.03043743595480919, 0.019666479900479317, 0.03333226591348648, -0.03267974779009819, 0.018831048160791397, 0.04103158786892891, 0.03680400550365448, -0.03502989187836647, 0.02845167927443981, 0.07752575725317001, 0.013947555795311928, -0.01705235429108143, -0.021458229050040245, -0.022325828671455383, 0.0023292198311537504, -0.011297153308987617, 0.03713687136769295, 0.005208643618971109, -0.010212071239948273, -0.01808260753750801, 0.03952116146683693, -0.03737596422433853, -0.013100204057991505, 0.020167790353298187, 0.012549176812171936, 0.015280556865036488, 0.00062177813379094, -0.058293431997299194, 0.010604508221149445, 0.03291758522391319, 0.0023591588251292706, 0.08151990175247192, 0.043371640145778656, -0.07182460278272629, -0.008328333497047424, 0.018085813149809837, 0.035485245287418365, -0.049094490706920624, 0.017401572316884995, -0.018482405692338943, -0.018331777304410934, 0.021956270560622215, -0.034255966544151306, 0.043924059718847275, 0.005614488385617733, 0.005768562667071819, -0.00032653260859660804, -0.004182683303952217, -0.07361499220132828, 0.008764146827161312, 0.026101676747202873, 0.010825217701494694, 0.005292100831866264, -0.003653926309198141, 0.0012578233145177364, -0.002409127773717046, 0.0023475289344787598, 0.031401243060827255, -0.06676354259252548, -0.044455867260694504, 0.001006531179882586, 0.04906729608774185, 0.001984222559258342, -0.03996870294213295, 0.0165792815387249, -0.00773788383230567, -0.04608448967337608, 0.05692161247134209, 0.014081006869673729, -0.04133506491780281, 0.011096872389316559, -0.018351422622799873, -0.03415082395076752, -0.01321566291153431, -0.021720027551054955, 0.08238667994737625, 0.018378648906946182, -0.018950318917632103, 0.03496213257312775, 0.0524868406355381, -0.010445721447467804, -0.0016351918457075953, -0.09622704982757568, -0.013190078549087048, -0.06652869284152985, -0.051459960639476776, -0.05289975553750992, -0.0004363120533525944, -0.016718432307243347, 0.009642831049859524, -0.03354724496603012, 0.0103391008451581, -0.052425090223550797, -0.024873578920960426, 0.023741750046610832, 0.05638492852449417, -0.03960759565234184, 0.04079779237508774, -0.020212192088365555, -0.032281193882226944, -0.023041848093271255, -0.005775386467576027, 0.005169317126274109, -0.01808580383658409, -0.025490153580904007, 0.010180613026022911, -0.030889492481946945, 0.007693527266383171, 0.013012159615755081, 0.0034797850530594587, -0.008447721600532532, -0.002852632664144039, -0.027468692511320114, 0.028045514598488808, 0.05781346186995506, 0.01647176966071129, -0.03862101212143898, -0.0032219772692769766, 0.014698280952870846, -0.009581818245351315, 0.047689519822597504, -0.03614706173539162, 0.05224774032831192, -0.007281795144081116, -0.026052743196487427, -0.07065120339393616, -0.030480971559882164, 0.01974479667842388, -0.01802990399301052, -0.02339775860309601, -0.009151626378297806, -0.015627725049853325, 0.0041986871510744095, -0.00035214179661124945, -0.03404223546385765, 0.07749548554420471, -0.01469779759645462, -0.021629029884934425, -0.024378249421715736, 0.015838617458939552, 0.07986662536859512, -0.02876300737261772, 0.012865803204476833, 0.03659605234861374, -0.0544147789478302, -0.021864980459213257, 0.04884537681937218, 0.005506003741174936, -0.04242123290896416, -0.015126937068998814, -0.04282441735267639, 0.01238531619310379, 0.07298421114683151, -0.005611559841781855, -0.032965678721666336, -0.0008664094493724406, -0.021535687148571014, 0.01899821124970913, -0.020556630566716194, 0.010698282159864902, 0.00040219409856945276, 0.03925506770610809, -0.02797597274184227, 0.02708602324128151, -0.027184955775737762, 0.005621596239507198, 0.0007892037974670529, 0.0015709251165390015, -0.03310114145278931, 0.03699028864502907, 0.07969047874212265, -0.008208220824599266, -0.008367655798792839, 0.03283580020070076, -0.025229452177882195, 0.038618698716163635, 0.005015547852963209, 0.022170299664139748, -0.024404574185609818, 0.03572194650769234, -0.018908530473709106, -0.005732083227485418, -0.012830852530896664, 0.015106165781617165, 0.0635581761598587, -0.005726220086216927, 0.028634795919060707, 0.0589982345700264, -0.03355370834469795, 0.00035954589839093387, -0.06508708000183105, 0.011083762161433697, -0.03736254945397377, -0.0030671083368360996, 0.06566683202981949, -0.014535103924572468, -0.03349604830145836, 0.04170633479952812, 0.028710877522826195, 0.0012347406009212136, 0.045123547315597534, -0.01640201173722744, 0.019108999520540237, -0.020069953054189682, -0.007505347952246666, -0.04342218115925789, 0.015481074340641499, -0.014083333313465118, 0.007384388707578182, -0.016667043790221214, -0.015374114736914635, 0.06391701847314835, 0.05462298169732094, 0.03498407080769539, -0.07006662338972092, 0.0012308272998780012, -0.04048041254281998, 0.04085659608244896, 0.004465711303055286, -0.02591092139482498, 0.025903481990098953, 0.0010658795945346355, 0.05797508731484413, 0.001154435216449201, 0.02840271219611168, -0.06153702363371849, -0.0714709535241127, -0.018328260630369186, 0.004395834170281887, -0.027747096493840218, 0.018345454707741737, -0.03114033117890358, -0.03164336457848549, 0.017097746953368187, -0.03565619885921478, 0.038259223103523254, 0.02041424810886383, 0.04865463450551033, 0.014453726820647717, 0.0925767570734024, 0.02006356045603752, 0.018866047263145447, -0.015657762065529823, -0.009010612033307552, 0.1483866274356842, 0.049448490142822266, 0.03775256872177124, -0.04334168881177902, 0.013415019027888775, -0.0007940152427181602, -0.011033927090466022, -0.01956624537706375, -0.027924805879592896, 0.004196243826299906, -0.036715276539325714, 0.07511192560195923, 0.07069215923547745, 0.037188149988651276, -0.014682024717330933, 0.02845793589949608, -0.0144013911485672, -0.020390544086694717, -0.023822104558348656, 0.006784946657717228, -0.001565568963997066, -0.009023849852383137, -0.014177015982568264, 0.003564094891771674, 0.03458961471915245, 0.0049729435704648495, -0.06432957202196121, -0.017620394006371498, -0.0006418608827516437, -0.0032993010245263577, -0.03727895766496658, -0.00040704928687773645, 0.01708429679274559, 0.03763580694794655, -0.020023560151457787, -0.023581858724355698, 0.0186662208288908, -0.03223947435617447, 0.0010897989850491285, 0.03376267850399017, -0.0169999860227108, -0.04510951414704323, 0.022952301427721977, -0.002841671695932746, -0.007289976812899113, -0.016028495505452156, -0.02191811613738537, 0.06938537210226059, 0.0014541695127263665, -0.04236221686005592, -0.014276828616857529, -0.022073378786444664, 0.049676232039928436, -0.058431852608919144, -0.013156301341950893, 0.0184079110622406, -0.00543578527867794, 0.00017561469576321542, -0.01009458489716053, -0.007229199167340994, 0.011534573510289192, -0.00006370995834004134, 0.014239922165870667, -0.009856155142188072, -0.022109996527433395, -0.021875709295272827, -0.07590825855731964, 0.049334824085235596, 0.010479174554347992, 0.005182909779250622, 0.007305383216589689, -0.010401519015431404, -0.026630200445652008, -0.004117670934647322, 0.013574115000665188, -0.014959652908146381, 0.02905893325805664, -0.006565087474882603, 0.0035380215849727392, -0.000940683064982295, -0.013742556795477867, -0.0008231678511947393, -0.006414525210857391, 0.0019176679197698832, -0.03409191966056824, -0.000037951813283143565, 0.03530384972691536, 0.04553263261914253, 0.011058472096920013, 0.039606526494026184, -0.03074309416115284, 0.08531076461076736, -0.02168717421591282, -0.054595910012722015, -0.04437333717942238, 0.01781330443918705, -0.020900320261716843, -0.003137596882879734, 0.0003905788471456617, 0.029628951102495193, 0.016744710505008698, 0.04352125898003578, -0.04307055100798607, 0.029662450775504112, 0.005011879839003086, 0.03764626383781433, 0.009741576388478279, -0.030959410592913628, -0.010641300119459629, -0.050367359071969986, 0.003607749240472913, 0.0026756965089589357, 0.005966849159449339, -0.02564004808664322, -0.052190639078617096, -0.006246692966669798, -0.017083317041397095, -0.05935186520218849, 0.018349751830101013, -0.040587157011032104, 0.019512617960572243, -0.03659530729055405, 0.00007872725109336898, 0.007042570039629936, 0.002769516548141837, 0.015760354697704315, 0.00817017536610365, -0.005991845391690731, 0.015464751049876213, -0.0319850891828537, 0.00878937728703022, 0.03650486469268799, 0.004365724511444569, 0.03820038586854935, -0.0007238270482048392, 0.008811956271529198, 0.0012391099007800221, 0.016516733914613724, -0.010602300055325031, 0.011089361272752285, 0.013732252642512321, -0.021445509046316147, -0.04259289801120758, -0.007928270846605301, -0.012602207250893116, 0.02830345556139946, 0.02075384557247162, 0.011761536821722984, -0.05860654264688492, 0.03789522498846054, -0.02734200470149517, -0.002550841076299548, -0.036361780017614365, 0.03092290833592415, 0.007336253300309181, -0.008269775658845901, -0.01866794377565384, 0.05995054170489311, -0.009334397502243519, 0.006121438927948475, 0.05243938788771629, 0.011060422286391258, 0.0006664913380518556, -0.0036517158150672913, 0.010719260200858116, -0.004370645619928837, -0.0008715266012586653, -0.011937590315937996, 0.016683991998434067, 0.06142726540565491, -0.040558651089668274, 0.027804462239146233, 0.00801643542945385, 0.015228810720145702, -0.07696495950222015, -0.046342842280864716, -0.01555684208869934, 0.03817509114742279, 0.007185673341155052, -0.013211582787334919, -0.013501899316906929, 0.01696186326444149, -0.02063828706741333, -0.010314781218767166, 0.0019283415749669075, 0.021078135818243027, -0.0376317985355854, 0.03487153723835945, -0.050640951842069626, -0.0017672644462436438, 0.010915666818618774, 0.007234108168631792, 0.017698582261800766, 0.0222355704754591, 0.013962788507342339, -0.01733732596039772, -0.007871747948229313, -0.03815963491797447, 0.026026632636785507, -0.02778247371315956, 0.02932649292051792, -0.026927204802632332, -0.0013133418979123235, 0.005746851675212383, -0.011828018352389336, 0.005613000597804785, 0.02118087001144886, 0.0286592748016119, 0.012882503680884838, 0.02310212142765522, 0.00035882953670807183, 0.0025541845243424177, 0.030914414674043655, 0.019031044095754623, 0.020853420719504356, 0.019970355555415154, -0.008618124760687351, -0.0021523030009120703, -0.011007577180862427, 0.007869386114180088, 0.006700006313621998, 0.05043207108974457, -0.017260443419218063, -0.021316133439540863, -0.031980931758880615, 0.00808153860270977, 0.026219595223665237, -0.020734548568725586, 0.01901874504983425, -0.036190539598464966, 0.023769710212945938, 0.07822957634925842, 0.052997369319200516, 0.0008264621719717979, 0.008710998110473156, -0.04963110759854317, -0.03639582172036171, -0.003832300193607807, -0.003281473182141781, -0.026088794693350792, -0.017495231702923775, -0.04605463892221451, -0.017962872982025146, -0.01433427445590496, 0.00815233401954174, 0.028431368991732597, -0.018144099041819572, 0.05838804319500923, -0.023256221786141396, -0.014529267325997353, -0.008833471685647964, 0.021334800869226456, 0.012935085222125053, -0.0967755913734436, 0.0325792133808136, 0.011347438208758831, -0.008123832754790783, -0.06745562702417374, 0.0022242406848818064, -0.014669716358184814, 0.04971665143966675, 0.03246055915951729, 0.00988533440977335, 0.013464641757309437, 0.010411709547042847, 0.016763929277658463, -0.01330541167408228, -0.03560398146510124, 0.09220695495605469, 0.014658925123512745, -0.004791284445673227, -0.022710977122187614, -0.00996407587081194, -0.0011900962563231587, 0.009672218933701515, 0.020321069285273552, -0.03907304257154465, -0.00629519484937191, 0.008714438416063786, -0.020771874114871025, -0.00037863681791350245, 0.010730786249041557, -0.017037248238921165, 0.01595277711749077, -0.024178730323910713, -0.007906884886324406, 0.05501946806907654, 0.018865182995796204, -0.056973181664943695, 0.0005315126036293805, -0.041654206812381744, -0.026685409247875214, -0.019609251990914345, 0.03207775205373764, -0.009463110007345676, -0.057335227727890015, 0.034916650503873825, -0.021007051691412926, -0.04609590768814087, -0.004356449004262686, 0.05409659445285797, 0.021438194438815117, 0.03721759840846062, -0.0011064916616305709, 0.034004949033260345, -0.01198603492230177, -0.007909443229436874, 0.03311096876859665, 0.05069005489349365, 0.037976041436195374, 0.017446111887693405, -0.02461632341146469, 0.024813229218125343, -0.008644038811326027, 0.01571560464799404, -0.06154736503958702, 0.03347185254096985, -0.015766900032758713, -0.016915321350097656, 0.011767910793423653, -0.03393713757395744, 0.04781775176525116, 0.03637801483273506, 0.02263876609504223, 0.03950061276555061, -0.038298871368169785, -0.015588403679430485, -0.05324855074286461, 0.006752451881766319, -0.008166346698999405, -0.007716466672718525, 0.01955900527536869, 0.04302592575550079, 0.001366544864140451, 0.022985059767961502, -0.035808563232421875, -0.0507868267595768, 0.03603324666619301, -0.038354456424713135, 0.03486640378832817, -0.005717973690479994, -0.000041598614188842475, -0.023135187104344368, -0.013030973263084888, -0.07806271314620972, -0.01664547063410282, 0.019012736156582832, 0.03175121918320656, 0.017752358689904213, -0.05370161309838295, -0.026018936187028885, 0.021483227610588074, 0.05104382708668709, -0.06082313880324364, 0.00690723629668355, -0.018287895247340202, 0.00823122076690197, -0.006284988019615412, 0.0029064875561743975 ]
<p>Suppose that we have two data sets, <code>R</code> and <code>P</code>. <code>R</code> is larger than or equal to <code>P</code>. <code>R</code> can be negative or positive. <code>P</code> can be negative or positive. So in all cases <code>(R-P)</code> is positive or zero. the <code>R</code>and <code>P</code> are dollars and the scale of them is high likes <code>1,000,000,0</code> or <code>500,000,000</code>. Now I want create a criterion looks like :</p> <pre><code>E = 1 - ( 1 / 1+(R-P) ) </code></pre> <p>So I have <code>E</code> that is between <code>0</code> and <code>1</code>. I want <code>E</code> scale between <code>0</code> and <code>1</code>. But the problem is this. <code>(R-P)</code> is has high values,so all outputs of this criterion is near <code>1</code>. I revise this function, Now i have this :</p> <pre><code>E = 1 - ( 1 / 1+ ( (R-P)/mean(R-P) ) ) </code></pre> <p>Now because of <code>mean(R-P)</code> we have better scaling between <code>0</code> and <code>1</code>. This is distribution of <code>R-P</code> for more help : </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/2XOxM.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>After doing that I want classify data with this <code>E</code> . For example samples that have a <code>E</code> greater than <code>0.7</code> are in <code>class 1</code> and samples with <code>E</code> lower than <code>0.7</code> are in <code>class 2</code> (In a binary classification problem). For a better distribution in final version of this criterion i will remove outliers of <code>(R-P)</code> with this function to have more robust criterion :</p> <pre><code>abs(X-mean(X)) &gt;=2*std(X) </code></pre> <p><code>(X here is (R-P)</code></p> <p>After removing outliers in <code>R-P</code> i will calculate <code>mean(R-P)</code>what is your recommendations for better transformation of this problem? I have a theoretical problem with using <code>mean</code> in this criterion so i need comments about this.</p> <p><strong>PS.</strong> We should have this behavior in this criterion:</p> <ul> <li>if <code>P=constant</code> and <code>R=increase</code> >> <code>E=increase</code></li> <li>if <code>R=constant</code> and <code>P=increase (towards negative)</code> >> <code>E=increase</code></li> <li>if <code>P=constant</code> and <code>R=decrease</code> >> <code>E=decrease</code></li> <li><p>if <code>R=constant</code> and <code>P=decrease(towards positive)</code> >> <code>E=decrease</code></p></li> <li><p>a sample that have highest <code>(R-P)</code> should have highest <code>E</code> (<code>1</code> or near <code>1</code>)</p></li> <li>a sample that have lowest <code>(R-P)</code> should have lowest <code>E</code> (<code>1</code> or near <code>1</code>)</li> </ul>
7,030
[ -0.037570565938949585, -0.026366405189037323, 0.014300254173576832, 0.01640980690717697, -0.013387618586421013, 0.005194887053221464, -0.01377766765654087, 0.006056917365640402, 0.011539651080965996, -0.016235068440437317, 0.04105594754219055, 0.017375383526086807, 0.025382939726114273, 0.037098050117492676, 0.013096749782562256, 0.016852041706442833, -0.034000977873802185, -0.0005083513096906245, -0.018034668639302254, -0.025226883590221405, -0.029736926779150963, 0.010628915391862392, 0.04297979548573494, -0.004729450214654207, -0.015086107887327671, 0.017560714855790138, 0.07061406970024109, 0.00833786092698574, 0.00024595155264250934, 0.04239083454012871, -0.022453200072050095, -0.021005162969231606, 0.005206483416259289, 0.025204624980688095, 0.03607124090194702, 0.033109791576862335, -0.0226338729262352, -0.0309999231249094, -0.03536636009812355, -0.01417644415050745, 0.03732960298657417, 0.008179331198334694, 0.04664107784628868, 0.029708392918109894, 0.007701833266764879, 0.028691332787275314, 0.006457501091063023, -0.03665412962436676, 0.037158846855163574, -0.07216489315032959, 0.07775457948446274, 0.0037452310789376497, 0.021489597856998444, 0.009934425354003906, -0.018427511677145958, -0.023454835638403893, 0.04898823797702789, 0.06862831860780716, -0.013841703534126282, -0.04801219329237938, -0.01306287944316864, -0.0035788519307971, -0.022001011297106743, -0.022768722847104073, -0.002254504943266511, 0.01930781826376915, 0.006351622752845287, 0.0020106113515794277, 0.04499535635113716, -0.0038583523128181696, 0.01533795427531004, 0.02179262600839138, 0.016909562051296234, 0.014927566982805729, 0.014361418783664703, -0.02435213141143322, -0.013574929907917976, -0.017563458532094955, 0.051972370594739914, 0.05312274023890495, 0.020271750167012215, 0.03429685905575752, -0.030524378642439842, 0.03653370216488838, 0.04562435671687126, -0.04274491220712662, 0.06947612762451172, -0.017643271014094353, 0.003094722516834736, 0.03796376287937164, -0.016646893694996834, -0.018422985449433327, 0.05340476334095001, -0.008660511113703251, -0.01526247151196003, 0.047788068652153015, 0.00660764379426837, -0.0006836822140030563, 0.008704010397195816, -0.040601685643196106, -0.04821799695491791, -0.08390000462532043, -0.005089204758405685, 0.034328609704971313, -0.024834221228957176, -0.024165146052837372, -0.0389254167675972, -0.04955626651644707, 0.015217584557831287, 0.019698049873113632, 0.022076349705457687, -0.008014343678951263, 0.039015356451272964, -0.017543356865644455, 0.020021015778183937, -0.009831272065639496, 0.004323021974414587, -0.04802174121141434, 0.026904188096523285, 0.011651330627501011, 0.06951764971017838, -0.0004467677790671587, 0.017788289114832878, -0.003439821070060134, -0.03953712806105614, 0.01061574462801218, 0.022318564355373383, 0.029381228610873222, 0.00450905691832304, 0.06358512490987778, -0.014993106946349144, 0.01451888307929039, 0.025693532079458237, -0.004248807206749916, 0.018106505274772644, 0.02574213780462742, -0.04601963981986046, -0.020424148067831993, 0.038713160902261734, -0.02341330423951149, 0.014704588800668716, -0.02507353574037552, -0.03443650156259537, 0.03484857827425003, -0.0009619688498787582, 0.04523574188351631, 0.005071423482149839, 0.015964021906256676, 0.0025702733546495438, 0.022275494411587715, -0.013907132670283318, -0.011864479631185532, -0.029317064210772514, 0.006732121109962463, -0.011352847330272198, -0.050962310284376144, 0.0005231171380728483, -0.015592302195727825, -0.062104981392621994, 0.0178116075694561, 0.01845565252006054, -0.018844803795218468, -0.025422532111406326, -0.024171052500605583, -0.018382877111434937, 0.006219316273927689, 0.050552163273096085, 0.028743848204612732, 0.03624264523386955, -0.002347867237403989, -0.009769332595169544, 0.023888349533081055, 0.008359279483556747, -0.00813313014805317, 0.029247913509607315, 0.0074400268495082855, 0.014455217868089676, -0.05834002420306206, 0.035378292202949524, 0.0297608133405447, -0.03398822247982025, -0.0449000746011734, -0.04351305589079857, 0.006545439828187227, 0.018844138830900192, 0.02095692791044712, 0.005146669689565897, -0.009640981443226337, 0.028194379061460495, -0.04298285394906998, -0.04909118264913559, -0.06759779900312424, -0.013194086961448193, 0.028896046802401543, -0.0642397403717041, -0.012890763580799103, 0.016457917168736458, -0.002799044596031308, 0.017525501549243927, 0.01906822808086872, -0.02619709074497223, -0.01235225610435009, 0.06040966883301735, -0.046034034341573715, -0.012011288665235043, 0.0558641292154789, 0.040565576404333115, -0.03640391677618027, 0.057463083416223526, -0.023122116923332214, -0.027118436992168427, 0.004107586108148098, -0.020400099456310272, 0.008116782642900944, 0.0022523279767483473, -0.026038669049739838, 0.023947643116116524, 0.024542590603232384, 0.00279048434458673, 0.00508838938549161, -0.05340898782014847, 0.03932912275195122, 0.07242035120725632, 0.005381462164223194, 0.027280442416667938, -0.030748004093766212, -0.0049835494719445705, 0.04118837043642998, -0.048247676342725754, -0.022710323333740234, -0.059651367366313934, -0.013603506609797478, 0.007056447211652994, 0.06221707537770271, -0.05090147256851196, -0.0030444441363215446, 0.05649003013968468, 0.011686871759593487, 0.019673539325594902, 0.0478690005838871, 0.023277580738067627, 0.010776610113680363, 0.03982516750693321, 0.024945927783846855, 0.028496790677309036, -0.007114210166037083, -0.003629867220297456, 0.03496770188212395, 0.03298003226518631, 0.005813837517052889, -0.003862998681142926, 0.020325150340795517, 0.01597137190401554, -0.007001736667007208, -0.0048706503584980965, 0.013757126405835152, -0.00304243597202003, -0.017387796193361282, -0.022411853075027466, 0.05421542376279831, 0.0021740037482231855, -0.016708344221115112, 0.022153586149215698, -0.02812354452908039, 0.009449434466660023, 0.06620825827121735, 0.034603461623191833, 0.01702425628900528, 0.01900092512369156, -0.02463008463382721, -0.011749370023608208, 0.009227641858160496, -0.03763878718018532, -0.06486349552869797, 0.015123645775020123, 0.04034067317843437, 0.023740850389003754, -0.009212858974933624, -0.010630692355334759, 0.016379809007048607, -0.004283448215574026, 0.010671175085008144, 0.016344493255019188, -0.01202818937599659, -0.027958691120147705, -0.018485799431800842, -0.02496509626507759, -0.024310709908604622, 0.042363137006759644, 0.009321304038167, -0.05196395888924599, 0.002268590498715639, 0.009519568644464016, -0.027277765795588493, 0.00917006004601717, -0.0335112139582634, 0.015377424657344818, 0.001521195867098868, -0.02723194845020771, 0.05850747227668762, 0.032180897891521454, -0.07559733092784882, 0.036976512521505356, -0.046067975461483, -0.042931415140628815, -0.05411436781287193, -0.010019938461482525, 0.014831996522843838, 0.01315070129930973, 0.017917092889547348, -0.003951032180339098, 0.009931609034538269, 0.008936695754528046, -0.05955268070101738, -0.046481966972351074, 0.018120061606168747, -0.0009191473363898695, 0.03379964455962181, -0.011546525172889233, -0.00016130096628330648, 0.06645788252353668, 0.05492972582578659, 0.002513400511816144, -0.07595160603523254, 0.01901254616677761, -0.04240434616804123, 0.00444946950301528, 0.016362490132451057, 0.0196943748742342, -0.013041493482887745, -0.0019665395375341177, 0.0055509950034320354, 0.007568845059722662, 0.03829849138855934, -0.018754910677671432, -0.033754006028175354, 0.02178448997437954, -0.03874559700489044, -0.034992147237062454, 0.045999787747859955, 0.05723002925515175, -0.005999580025672913, 0.0425148606300354, 0.024734865874052048, 0.0382467545568943, 0.0038956976495683193, -0.01835944876074791, -0.036624275147914886, 0.002424377016723156, 0.0260532908141613, -0.03956141322851181, 0.02710035815834999, 0.024391116574406624, -0.052959833294153214, -0.03551795706152916, -0.016622284427285194, 0.056480929255485535, -0.0133277028799057, 0.0006391695351339877, 0.060904789716005325, 0.05006204545497894, -0.027594754472374916, -0.0051600332371890545, -0.01805718243122101, -0.012132732197642326, 0.020378634333610535, -0.03277405723929405, 0.014598935842514038, 0.03683368116617203, 0.03717333450913429, 0.03051040880382061, 0.02666645310819149, -0.011194382794201374, -0.01528601162135601, -0.04225161671638489, -0.012473193928599358, -0.027041500434279442, 0.09402468800544739, 0.015519722364842892, 0.08173945546150208, 0.03901475667953491, -0.018798070028424263, 0.02162621170282364, 0.009387919679284096, -0.05720817297697067, 0.061043739318847656, -0.02029884234070778, 0.0015070996014401317, 0.0043374765664339066, -0.031044943258166313, 0.03728945553302765, -0.029864393174648285, 0.01129880826920271, -0.0035917756613343954, 0.01972990669310093, -0.010673003271222115, -0.022872719913721085, 0.009793112985789776, 0.008866035379469395, -0.037375494837760925, -0.008735889568924904, 0.018832188099622726, -0.0023982205893844366, 0.05952400714159012, 0.01938837394118309, -0.006444208323955536, 0.010712315328419209, -0.03278404846787453, 0.012728719040751457, 0.022223765030503273, 0.05928943678736687, -0.01004417147487402, 0.014959181658923626, -0.02417503483593464, 0.021230343729257584, 0.0067469957284629345, 0.04945480078458786, 0.04716814309358597, -0.03478851169347763, -0.021659310907125473, -0.04723269119858742, -0.025590429082512856, 0.006424993276596069, 0.027390286326408386, -0.010457415133714676, -0.05671875551342964, 0.012085853144526482, 0.005052656400948763, -0.0423102006316185, 0.0174556914716959, 0.11407473683357239, 0.024200214073061943, -0.012908518314361572, -0.04324128106236458, -0.03853869065642357, -0.010766667313873768, 0.0029667431954294443, 0.03457055240869522, 0.06129820644855499, -0.016617950052022934, 0.017672089859843254, 0.03920160233974457, 0.005513480398803949, -0.06958384066820145, -0.009006738662719727, 0.008242446929216385, 0.011447030119597912, -0.060054317116737366, -0.03309817239642143, -0.024872275069355965, 0.026553696021437645, 0.028914140537381172, -0.0203613992780447, -0.025930648669600487, -0.10535845905542374, -0.011311955749988556, 0.02120693027973175, 0.052929624915122986, -0.031026484444737434, -0.017645230516791344, -0.06283189356327057, -0.03542918711900711, 0.03421948477625847, -0.05670849606394768, 0.02446902170777321, -0.024904334917664528, 0.016402043402194977, -0.003682668786495924, -0.024952534586191177, -0.05299343913793564, 0.022621896117925644, -0.06678418815135956, -0.00045227757073007524, -0.025675220414996147, -0.041742559522390366, -0.05390464514493942, -0.003119772532954812, 0.013656361028552055, 0.046880293637514114, -0.06628433614969254, -0.017079303041100502, 0.010270209982991219, -0.0237304475158453, 0.002916982863098383, -0.0450003445148468, 0.02938918024301529, -0.0034591357689350843, 0.03495010733604431, 0.06573407351970673, 0.01701999083161354, 0.0012221059296280146, 0.009498844854533672, 0.01851777359843254, -0.020251018926501274, -0.008633477613329887, 0.004632893018424511, 0.06610129773616791, 0.04313432797789574, 0.0006739977397955954, 0.029165351763367653, 0.04947582259774208, 0.013573185540735722, -0.007858811877667904, -0.053020816296339035, -0.00809775572270155, 0.011940639466047287, -0.02553490735590458, -0.06419918686151505, -0.010509525425732136, -0.038101572543382645, -0.020378923043608665, -0.00951352808624506, 0.040467310696840286, -0.04736688733100891, -0.014904002659022808, 0.03926711156964302, 0.029603302478790283, -0.026003243401646614, -0.034782394766807556, 0.028408287093043327, -0.005953451152890921, 0.010937179438769817, 0.0032996993977576494, 0.03547815978527069, -0.009723996743559837, -0.006510621402412653, 0.024203799664974213, -0.04439406841993332, 0.013480529189109802, -0.03719610348343849, -0.012824061326682568, -0.00279515259899199, -0.019895581528544426, 0.06407429277896881, -0.0026262777391821146, 0.030208533629775047, 0.008622768335044384, -0.023859532549977303, -0.003481263294816017, 0.0350445918738842, -0.004119159188121557, -0.006401931867003441, -0.030058830976486206, 0.060042232275009155, 0.008769804611802101, -0.0321919247508049, -0.05130678042769432, -0.01861821673810482, 0.010855427011847496, -0.0006461458979174495, -0.01029894594103098, -0.021760443225502968, -0.03488927707076073, 0.021879643201828003, 0.009178334847092628, 0.0015578995225951076, 0.03319976106286049, -0.00658221123740077, -0.011313816532492638, 0.006895066238939762, -0.00037266247090883553, 0.09145209193229675, 0.005256930831819773, -0.0025491472333669662, 0.0377056859433651, 0.01776065118610859, -0.02412797510623932, 0.018832961097359657, 0.009567069821059704, -0.053323350846767426, -0.022689079865813255, -0.04343034327030182, 0.00804754439741373, 0.006449857261031866, 0.015236158855259418, -0.005124405957758427, -0.016578614711761475, 0.013233938254415989, 0.022005323320627213, -0.013196001760661602, 0.01831958070397377, 0.008016462437808514, -0.04611150175333023, -0.014094224199652672, -0.0407000333070755, -0.030258959159255028, -0.022088227793574333, 0.020833445712924004, -0.008884288370609283, -0.0027890095952898264, 0.016557222232222557, 0.06750781834125519, 0.008809758350253105, 0.008826134726405144, -0.018248900771141052, -0.055495474487543106, 0.06106788292527199, 0.005970914848148823, -0.021537544205784798, -0.00029937774525023997, 0.019051138311624527, -0.04739968478679657, 0.03729347884654999, -0.053416114300489426, -0.03928648307919502, 0.026223426684737206, 0.041154827922582626, 0.07204392552375793, 0.01609872095286846, -0.011194923892617226, -0.0024962876923382282, -0.04401624575257301, -0.0016863946802914143, 0.0056320782750844955, 0.008841324597597122, 0.07592972368001938, -0.008141005411744118, 0.0010805224301293492, 0.032556530088186264, 0.016448574140667915, 0.0642804503440857, 0.05928085744380951, 0.01610884629189968, 0.0031688243616372347, 0.008078482933342457, -0.08795526623725891, 0.0020672990940511227, 0.03083556704223156, -0.033288829028606415, 0.00026425349642522633, -0.01087211538106203, -0.05493103340268135, -0.009559918195009232, 0.023645363748073578, -0.025646524503827095, -0.052726808935403824, -0.025579538196325302, -0.060929615050554276, 0.031142013147473335, 0.01809578761458397, -0.04235310107469559, -0.0046942285262048244, -0.019323639571666718, 0.014631188474595547, -0.031192537397146225, 0.041850678622722626, -0.003646864090114832, -0.03313599154353142, -0.018628358840942383, -0.05825740098953247, -0.04106589034199715, 0.019844677299261093, 0.05035461485385895, 0.00028327558538876474, 0.02784559316933155, -0.059171296656131744, 0.025076501071453094, 0.041674692183732986, -0.013493143953382969, -0.001314064022153616, 0.03457760065793991, -0.0017950328765437007, 0.012098567560315132, 0.0016316801775246859, -0.006473312620073557, 0.15909934043884277, 0.06225146725773811, -0.002533691469579935, -0.004680911544710398, 0.015369962900876999, 0.02329421229660511, -0.001181378262117505, -0.02852850966155529, 0.00977309886366129, -0.0006481373566202819, 0.022229842841625214, 0.017019476741552353, 0.021339554339647293, 0.04440879076719284, 0.002415379509329796, 0.050221048295497894, -0.02100527659058571, -0.022481996566057205, 0.011726328171789646, 0.0292572770267725, -0.0077261170372366905, 0.020912501960992813, -0.05542761832475662, 0.0010130093432962894, -0.01006325613707304, -0.010156815871596336, -0.04228866100311279, -0.003470991039648652, -0.00020970938203390688, 0.006542898248881102, 0.02209656871855259, 0.003631977364420891, -0.010433871299028397, -0.0033954435493797064, 0.031048541888594627, -0.046219874173402786, 0.010700708255171776, -0.04877940192818642, -0.016189107671380043, 0.0273848008364439, 0.013036489486694336, -0.02324301190674305, -0.021094124764204025, 0.01636510156095028, -0.04057314619421959, 0.0032983876299113035, -0.06907141953706741, 0.006626742891967297, 0.015356992371380329, -0.0035595502704381943, 0.010974196717143059, 0.0021005072630941868, -0.04589928686618805, -0.028464440256357193, -0.016163785010576248, 0.021724572405219078, 0.002177927643060684, 0.022189022973179817, -0.02221507951617241, -0.020135004073381424, 0.027738241478800774, 0.007139866705983877, -0.009645658545196056, 0.027549607679247856, -0.010686831548810005, -0.03504973277449608, -0.035540007054805756, 0.06438421458005905, -0.022108126431703568, 0.005294445436447859, 0.02558252215385437, -0.045236434787511826, -0.023606879636645317, 0.014019678346812725, -0.008022402413189411, 0.013310224749147892, -0.009245321154594421, 0.03645079955458641, -0.011819089762866497, -0.054772596806287766, -0.0017086677253246307, 0.027061007916927338, -0.03776184096932411, -0.007455364800989628, -0.015822121873497963, -0.013457641005516052, -0.0011974222725257277, 0.041647769510746, 0.03027357906103134, -0.034617286175489426, 0.02667958289384842, 0.05886346101760864, 0.03830285742878914, -0.043461158871650696, -0.03296605125069618, 0.008008182980120182, -0.04583340883255005, 0.020070262253284454, 0.03418511524796486, 0.0705522671341896, 0.018868228420615196, -0.005425005219876766, 0.01755286194384098, 0.012272004969418049, -0.043564796447753906, 0.004981015808880329, 0.014418935403227806, -0.007894632406532764, -0.02602820098400116, -0.017527960240840912, -0.015069859102368355, -0.03224243223667145, 0.015818258747458458, -0.03509308770298958, -0.04321650415658951, -0.013283146545290947, 0.009252669289708138, -0.011225730180740356, 0.01277519203722477, -0.035887233912944794, 0.030502386391162872, -0.013304030522704124, -0.00007631039625266567, -0.01835815981030464, 0.012456456199288368, -0.05330232158303261, -0.022615239024162292, -0.013566509820520878, 0.024350209161639214, 0.0031532917637377977, 0.026496289297938347, -0.001168374321423471, 0.010518119670450687, 0.0119028864428401, 0.016918841749429703, 0.03166330233216286, -0.03660576045513153, 0.045078229159116745, -0.038557231426239014, 0.0012341755209490657, 0.022840280085802078, -0.08005750179290771, -0.012253834865987301, -0.008658871054649353, 0.024775102734565735, 0.03160380199551582, -0.006063319742679596, -0.03166501596570015, 0.007128557655960321, 0.04542229697108269, -0.002860242733731866, -0.049113884568214417, -0.019176656380295753, -0.013207785785198212, 0.01779371127486229, 0.0307846050709486, 0.010788087733089924, -0.02708273194730282, -0.002740590600296855, 0.009850451722741127, 0.015237432904541492, -0.031114865094423294, -0.04393557086586952, 0.0037536255549639463, -0.0401109978556633, 0.031910330057144165, 0.004242472350597382, 0.0008172513917088509, 0.04881143569946289, -0.004399442113935947, -0.01737600937485695, -0.01673761196434498, -0.0421002171933651, -0.016723504289984703, -0.06771757453680038, -0.020965969190001488, 0.02314809337258339, -0.023937346413731575, 0.040824588388204575, -0.04471108689904213, -0.006141398102045059, 0.010329416953027248, -0.02541247569024563, 0.022418571636080742, -0.01293626893311739, 0.01378975622355938, -0.03594299405813217, 0.020489297807216644, -0.03680966794490814, 0.0069755869917571545, 0.015050296671688557, 0.05280061066150665, 0.03031950443983078, 0.0273775402456522, -0.016097182407975197, -0.007974761538207531, -0.03244788572192192, 0.002876885700970888, -0.00601891940459609, -0.03231290727853775, 0.00609967764467001, -0.03082854673266411, 0.03686901181936264, 0.037986285984516144, -0.03540749475359917, -0.009426617063581944, 0.034081459045410156, 0.03792637959122658, 0.017975222319364548, 0.06370678544044495, 0.016895977780222893, 0.011557812802493572, -0.0308698657900095, 0.007649507373571396, 0.021577030420303345, 0.02898767776787281, 0.018369050696492195, 0.023637624457478523, 0.02166849374771118, -0.020010072737932205, 0.01670107990503311, 0.052529118955135345, -0.020035475492477417, -0.0517863854765892, 0.02956222929060459, 0.005960872862488031, 0.011709421873092651, -0.025583824142813683, -0.0019765000324696302, -0.018996210768818855, 0.022202521562576294, 0.008488859981298447, 0.0012494523543864489, -0.013040424324572086, 0.017896311357617378, -0.006525465287268162, -0.059696465730667114, -0.005163659807294607, 0.009035364724695683, -0.013378583826124668, -0.0338355116546154, 0.016127046197652817, -0.0052851405926048756, 0.019223719835281372, 0.009016802534461021, -0.012162351049482822, -0.019238268956542015, 0.02063503861427307, -0.01983782649040222, 0.029051214456558228, 0.052786700427532196, -0.009421971626579762, 0.009892964735627174, -0.10775446146726608, 0.05572517588734627, -0.007793243043124676, -0.013903051614761353, -0.007957300171256065, -0.031557776033878326, -0.0653730034828186, 0.031651489436626434, 0.051850512623786926, 0.022393930703401566, -0.026864364743232727, -0.03829682245850563, 0.01623808592557907, 0.006939650047570467, -0.06161890923976898, 0.06710654497146606, 0.004876867402344942, -0.027227116748690605, 0.010696007870137691, 0.015765348449349403, 0.01645381562411785, 0.029321731999516487, 0.0009392143110744655, -0.008512737229466438, -0.005128274671733379, 0.008792390115559101, -0.0484236441552639, 0.023654472082853317, 0.007392444182187319, -0.0035153678618371487, 0.04146966338157654, -0.02195183001458645, -0.011636928655207157, -0.02553056925535202, 0.020213520154356956, -0.03232680261135101, 0.018267670646309853, -0.06482718139886856, -0.03848516568541527, 0.013582898303866386, -0.004959128797054291, 0.010237087495625019, -0.048664119094610214, -0.0043641445226967335, 0.03572322055697441, -0.030872268602252007, -0.03172052651643753, 0.02817729115486145, 0.02544233947992325, 0.052793778479099274, -0.04464104771614075, 0.0075331032276153564, -0.0500783734023571, -0.03325818106532097, 0.02747948095202446, -0.0006350401090458035, -0.008193707093596458, -0.012086701579391956, 0.04170059412717819, 0.03486255928874016, 0.02593192644417286, 0.02596844732761383, 0.018566366285085678, 0.0363311804831028, 0.010492217727005482, -0.007816990837454796, 0.01902306266129017, 0.010996729135513306, 0.02601184882223606, 0.004910563584417105, 0.00252845068462193, 0.0436982698738575, -0.01303850207477808, 0.025938263162970543, -0.03738413006067276, -0.019001929089426994, -0.041124168783426285, 0.033410124480724335, -0.0030276686884462833, 0.01697317510843277, -0.02182738110423088, 0.014287731610238552, 0.0160211268812418, 0.016008153557777405, -0.0031094953883439302, 0.012250635772943497, 0.04072720557451248, 0.026760650798678398, -0.023559069260954857, 0.01837221346795559, 0.017552858218550682, -0.005002643447369337, 0.0026154022198170424, -0.024181392043828964, 0.019971154630184174, 0.025229724124073982, -0.0138118676841259, 0.017118720337748528, 0.02058536931872368, 0.01185490284115076, -0.06278140842914581, -0.031209388747811317, -0.04460018128156662, 0.0004921107902191579, 0.008180477656424046, -0.022323012351989746 ]
<p>I am new to this area of machine learning. I am just walking myself through <code>UCB1</code> algorithm which seems to assume that the payoff can be learnt only for action that is taken. What I am curious about is if there is already analysis of the multi-armed bandit problem to the cases where the payoff can also be learnt for actions not taken (may be the term for this is "full reward vector"?), and that information used in subsequent steps. </p> <p>I could modify <code>UCB1</code> algorithm to update payoff for actions not taken as well. But, I would like to know if there are any drawbacks/pitfalls for doing this. I haven't done closed-form analysis of the regret bounds when reward vector is fully available.</p> <p>I don't know what the terminology is for such cases. So, I have a hard time finding work on such cases. I understand that when full reward vector is available, it is a supervised reinforcement learning problem. What I am curious about is if multi-armed bandit work can be used well in supervised reinforcement learning problem or not. And whether it makes sense to do this or not. I will very much appreciate pointers to work/paper in this area.</p>
74,473
[ 0.0025961429346352816, -0.040014393627643585, -0.011704164557158947, 0.02030162699520588, 0.01760062761604786, 0.021632039919495583, -0.022480469197034836, -0.011715245433151722, 0.05009828135371208, -0.053043581545352936, 0.009819884784519672, 0.025155512616038322, 0.03931684419512749, 0.04714507609605789, -0.017445620149374008, -0.021235818043351173, -0.0015862028812989593, -0.06307988613843918, -0.0007404451025649905, 0.035768602043390274, -0.02863071858882904, 0.02707398310303688, 0.03285644203424454, -0.03337149694561958, -0.0030139919836074114, 0.029109438881278038, 0.013433514162898064, -0.007491727359592915, 0.011946792714297771, 0.057239118963479996, -0.03767813369631767, -0.0028498948086053133, -0.021245328709483147, 0.03819853439927101, 0.0318804569542408, 0.00003324165300000459, -0.05210737884044647, -0.056826502084732056, -0.006277736742049456, 0.020064420998096466, -0.020518667995929718, -0.0061390940099954605, 0.021038681268692017, 0.049089498817920685, 0.0068123419769108295, 0.03493659570813179, -0.028943300247192383, 0.0010748435743153095, 0.025487881153821945, -0.02870149351656437, 0.04350832849740982, -0.004841447342187166, -0.0008041594992391765, -0.009439410641789436, -0.022322718054056168, -0.004920717794448137, 0.06985750794410706, 0.0868329405784607, 0.016359036788344383, -0.018105443567037582, -0.01166537031531334, -0.03385579213500023, 0.032086942344903946, -0.026493415236473083, -0.03522936999797821, 0.060175225138664246, -0.011695506051182747, -0.0194903165102005, 0.038456544280052185, -0.02086295373737812, 0.011396024376153946, -0.015079287812113762, 0.0019444047939032316, -0.002578397747129202, -0.006779117975383997, 0.03531171754002571, 0.02442024275660515, 0.06431078165769577, 0.038011129945516586, 0.0601237416267395, 0.008450987748801708, 0.004337945953011513, 0.05789690837264061, 0.06430313736200333, 0.04129989445209503, -0.006862204521894455, 0.041716087609529495, -0.013859519734978676, 0.04503990709781647, 0.0035975035279989243, 0.004660946317017078, 0.03131747245788574, 0.03104257956147194, -0.011084108613431454, -0.08045334368944168, 0.03411244601011276, 0.006274612620472908, 0.02513972669839859, 0.011598385870456696, -0.07261262089014053, 0.0031033854465931654, -0.028085356578230858, -0.011443179100751877, 0.042926106601953506, -0.032219938933849335, -0.0059697129763662815, -0.037722762674093246, 0.04156263545155525, 0.007407615426927805, 0.00547044537961483, -0.057116925716400146, 0.048813603818416595, -0.004001343157142401, -0.0034578570630401373, 0.006780390162020922, -0.04763087257742882, 0.002508015837520361, 0.011994405649602413, 0.045158568769693375, 0.09462122619152069, 0.04475846886634827, -0.014668671414256096, 0.037304315716028214, -0.02721649594604969, -0.07348780333995819, -0.009358888491988182, 0.031341202557086945, -0.023083867505192757, -0.045370180159807205, 0.04008788615465164, -0.01981530338525772, -0.0416422039270401, 0.00592568377032876, 0.01038261130452156, 0.003413075115531683, -0.04878855496644974, -0.07668943703174591, -0.03489585593342781, 0.01996190845966339, -0.004109203349798918, -0.002090977504849434, -0.034767813980579376, -0.027703015133738518, 0.04149606078863144, 0.07463271170854568, 0.03627512603998184, 0.035256776958703995, 0.04287537932395935, 0.005810254719108343, 0.017944620922207832, -0.03190136328339577, 0.02080213837325573, -0.007601409684866667, -0.016187159344553947, -0.022615481168031693, -0.08442901074886322, 0.03631961718201637, -0.0025742442812770605, 0.022379515692591667, 0.01838858239352703, 0.05661828815937042, 0.0054754032753407955, -0.027146900072693825, -0.03251667693257332, -0.019017294049263, -0.002108599292114377, 0.10120097547769547, 0.025465521961450577, 0.04013139382004738, 0.0033827025908976793, 0.008698960766196251, -0.007528028450906277, 0.012173015624284744, 0.027229486033320427, 0.03144585341215134, -0.039770662784576416, -0.040804456919431686, -0.020270127803087234, 0.021679989993572235, -0.010361512191593647, -0.001296380185522139, -0.028305813670158386, -0.0485849529504776, 0.017527896910905838, -0.0121798450127244, 0.0392734631896019, 0.051103584468364716, -0.018745215609669685, 0.028275392949581146, -0.03596146032214165, -0.01588554121553898, -0.07546677440404892, -0.007840944454073906, 0.0010547684505581856, -0.025458401069045067, 0.016662102192640305, -0.00588863855227828, 0.004869109019637108, -0.012514887377619743, -0.048301536589860916, -0.017215194180607796, -0.004367982968688011, 0.014297817833721638, -0.03491051867604256, 0.008483681827783585, 0.01854088343679905, -0.0006354666547849774, -0.005354754161089659, 0.03192374110221863, -0.054158661514520645, -0.09155718237161636, -0.004524093586951494, -0.01476320531219244, 0.03962624818086624, 0.014253877103328705, 0.010320845060050488, 0.03080756589770317, -0.02637999877333641, -0.023770343512296677, -0.02729128673672676, -0.04253951087594032, 0.07695580273866653, 0.08579010516405106, 0.025615327060222626, 0.009364604018628597, 0.0414264090359211, 0.0355147160589695, -0.005598073825240135, -0.03921162709593773, -0.009963327087461948, -0.06016751751303673, -0.015128985047340393, 0.0330611877143383, -0.020975131541490555, -0.03683846816420555, 0.050011832267045975, 0.06377244740724564, 0.018272658810019493, 0.02533877082169056, 0.013082652352750301, 0.0015554758720099926, 0.011185883544385433, 0.04162142425775528, 0.052272409200668335, 0.00657021626830101, 0.009594526141881943, 0.009643158875405788, -0.004660012200474739, 0.00225166161544621, 0.007496630307286978, -0.022142132744193077, 0.04580887034535408, -0.022660816088318825, -0.008756294846534729, 0.013414199464023113, -0.05440867692232132, 0.02931547723710537, -0.052774637937545776, 0.02824396826326847, 0.0515449196100235, 0.029629381373524666, -0.007533816155046225, -0.013611382804811, -0.027607806026935577, 0.012124711647629738, 0.03838201239705086, -0.012662282213568687, 0.0025556618347764015, 0.008035542443394661, -0.030225666239857674, 0.008201894350349903, -0.026761403307318687, -0.006953452713787556, -0.04162216931581497, 0.012918510474264622, 0.03367602452635765, -0.013823697343468666, -0.014292625710368156, -0.029392629861831665, -0.018623584881424904, -0.003113002283498645, -0.031058020889759064, 0.06424146145582199, -0.0012640089262276888, -0.05152784660458565, 0.02215966023504734, -0.020139360800385475, -0.00897313468158245, 0.0478944405913353, 0.03926090523600578, 0.020486440509557724, 0.03215019404888153, -0.0078444117680192, -0.04542367160320282, -0.008681186474859715, -0.010708390735089779, 0.004827110096812248, 0.0038975696079432964, -0.0015797680243849754, 0.06651520729064941, -0.002423979341983795, -0.06220554560422897, -0.0018727078568190336, 0.02072402462363243, -0.018701672554016113, -0.026261623948812485, -0.02681279182434082, -0.0014815285103395581, 0.01659161038696766, 0.02055681124329567, 0.04132019355893135, 0.003782948711887002, 0.013866995461285114, -0.07966350018978119, -0.06751283258199692, 0.014776400290429592, 0.01812458597123623, -0.016312023624777794, 0.012646811082959175, 0.028924742713570595, 0.053441282361745834, 0.005496065132319927, -0.022068042308092117, -0.02763422392308712, 0.005469484254717827, 0.0004917492624372244, 0.027976414188742638, -0.01726638898253441, -0.018820255994796753, -0.015553383156657219, 0.007214006502181292, -0.025660449638962746, 0.02829630859196186, 0.05569986626505852, 0.017339276149868965, 0.010111002251505852, -0.022246889770030975, 0.017494915053248405, -0.015359600074589252, 0.01236447598785162, 0.035368822515010834, 0.004778249189257622, 0.009105018340051174, -0.0019602796528488398, 0.0500565767288208, 0.011895300820469856, -0.015359834767878056, 0.028286850079894066, -0.03633851557970047, 0.0024006569292396307, -0.004647057503461838, 0.02335027977824211, -0.014961396344006062, -0.0023124217987060547, -0.02897157333791256, -0.01000259444117546, 0.07229781150817871, -0.061594683676958084, 0.012012768536806107, 0.013584486208856106, 0.014374937862157822, 0.0035610655322670937, -0.03845828026533127, -0.011926986277103424, -0.021880971267819405, 0.0015847055474296212, -0.05037664249539375, 0.0030703048687428236, 0.006176673341542482, 0.04442799463868141, 0.014663135632872581, 0.0516066811978817, -0.04205631464719772, 0.00890166126191616, -0.05867374688386917, -0.00030805051210336387, -0.038424909114837646, 0.046570952981710434, -0.000230564852245152, 0.015607931651175022, 0.004588348791003227, -0.017512399703264236, 0.007622812408953905, 0.013336633332073689, -0.09003196656703949, 0.04299158602952957, 0.008222632110118866, -0.004006871487945318, 0.021283665671944618, -0.002483627526089549, 0.025130966678261757, 0.003662948729470372, -0.01425662636756897, -0.0311953816562891, 0.010105901397764683, -0.054671648889780045, 0.05338990315794945, -0.010293138213455677, -0.006985133048146963, -0.039719946682453156, -0.0177901703864336, 0.017368849366903305, 0.0059542725794017315, 0.027511196210980415, 0.025055136531591415, -0.010483991354703903, -0.0028912266716361046, -0.01609557867050171, 0.013293394818902016, 0.032481543719768524, 0.04112590476870537, 0.004590344615280628, 0.023509392514824867, -0.007434606086462736, 0.035198092460632324, -0.00436747632920742, 0.05083434656262398, 0.019796356558799744, -0.023922024294734, 0.0030806472059339285, -0.05849801376461983, -0.03044353798031807, 0.02065003290772438, -0.014551157131791115, -0.003223604056984186, 0.0030167214572429657, 0.032273609191179276, 0.011268598027527332, -0.03796772658824921, -0.01659262739121914, 0.09137239307165146, 0.0040543717332184315, -0.004643779247999191, -0.05396050587296486, 0.02923269383609295, 0.007741504814475775, -0.0005443398258648813, 0.017446894198656082, -0.011576550081372261, -0.013456851243972778, 0.012881763279438019, 0.03502736613154411, -0.01712058298289776, -0.019500216469168663, -0.020830422639846802, 0.021561790257692337, 0.04994108900427818, 0.027531111612915993, -0.00878528319299221, 0.009694461710751057, 0.013617411255836487, 0.05429452285170555, 0.0014417567290365696, 0.011530712246894836, -0.049523986876010895, -0.032274749130010605, 0.04471847042441368, 0.08135192841291428, -0.028484882786870003, 0.016456004232168198, -0.015078137628734112, -0.004607826936990023, 0.04566148668527603, -0.021712470799684525, 0.036430418491363525, -0.02510846219956875, -0.010254651308059692, -0.021138841286301613, -0.048660945147275925, -0.03025221824645996, -0.022795751690864563, -0.034523479640483856, 0.0524628721177578, -0.0028534838929772377, 0.002976497868075967, 0.004125926643610001, -0.0007330318330787122, 0.018159592524170876, 0.06716015934944153, -0.012413964606821537, -0.027377942577004433, 0.016409309580922127, 0.010479141026735306, -0.016426540911197662, -0.07910291105508804, -0.0013707292964681983, -0.027034364640712738, -0.02635342627763748, 0.026925036683678627, -0.035888124257326126, -0.03775131329894066, 0.02632059156894684, 0.023156262934207916, -0.05047309771180153, -0.03937098756432533, -0.019255541265010834, 0.011384875513613224, 0.03280426561832428, -0.03186000511050224, 0.0641380175948143, 0.008716436102986336, 0.026403697207570076, -0.008025631308555603, -0.005479336716234684, 0.015048716217279434, -0.03620901703834534, -0.017252542078495026, -0.028042443096637726, -0.02228480763733387, 0.010514650493860245, 0.042807210236787796, 0.03286060690879822, 0.0393746979534626, -0.026065021753311157, -0.023166991770267487, -0.043984223157167435, 0.02328674867749214, 0.006433512549847364, -0.02149759605526924, -0.0028759283013641834, 0.02011837624013424, 0.0008299953187815845, 0.003912812098860741, -0.004754168912768364, -0.037386927753686905, 0.014756903983652592, 0.03299780935049057, -0.04677589237689972, 0.008187254890799522, -0.01937377266585827, -0.004387475550174713, -0.004368927795439959, -0.02906058356165886, 0.033068083226680756, -0.009475518018007278, 0.032360732555389404, -0.013449124991893768, -0.021801389753818512, -0.010786915197968483, 0.004811661317944527, -0.05373780429363251, -0.017624665051698685, -0.0462280698120594, 0.026910796761512756, -0.022556327283382416, 0.01881319098174572, -0.050715550780296326, -0.03659720718860626, 0.02249644137918949, 0.020788555964827538, -0.025355501100420952, 0.021168623119592667, 0.007965893484652042, -0.02838762290775776, -0.03607535734772682, 0.003540719160810113, 0.01933637261390686, -0.04786365106701851, 0.010935748927295208, 0.0020332110580056906, 0.010998360812664032, 0.039951808750629425, 0.028378618881106377, 0.005391839891672134, 0.001984346890822053, -0.029555412009358406, -0.02704952284693718, -0.0061363112181425095, 0.020657584071159363, -0.024288235232234, -0.014819754287600517, -0.03713478893041611, 0.0413854718208313, 0.028375284746289253, 0.008042941801249981, 0.0016160857630893588, 0.02188282459974289, -0.02409910224378109, 0.010777903720736504, -0.030795348808169365, -0.03544269874691963, 0.024173319339752197, -0.04426641762256622, 0.026012059301137924, 0.012007112614810467, 0.01526076253503561, -0.0006124968058429658, 0.015340804122388363, 0.0018009424675256014, 0.016767967492341995, -0.017520001158118248, 0.04156733676791191, -0.024119731038808823, -0.008897298015654087, 0.011807171627879143, -0.04560418054461479, -0.019662046805024147, -0.03822869434952736, 0.018600614741444588, 0.0111653171479702, -0.007144445087760687, -0.05856151133775711, -0.03411802276968956, -0.017693262547254562, 0.03494412079453468, 0.025943078100681305, 0.0007053438457660377, -0.0004463123041205108, 0.020086519420146942, 0.012778881937265396, -0.014012390747666359, -0.02961227297782898, -0.02337907999753952, -0.00946525763720274, 0.023323507979512215, 0.011425524950027466, 0.014842741191387177, -0.008267028257250786, 0.04658319801092148, -0.02441721223294735, 0.0294216088950634, 0.014940409921109676, 0.028251396492123604, 0.03691251575946808, 0.030910033732652664, -0.02887749671936035, -0.0654083639383316, 0.007414080668240786, -0.027005786076188087, 0.001617282279767096, -0.0056088948622345924, -0.03718426451086998, 0.05795109644532204, 0.02861223928630352, 0.026776136830449104, -0.020685194060206413, -0.00839401874691248, -0.04710768908262253, 0.025816479697823524, 0.009399743750691414, 0.001408231328241527, 0.06202438846230507, -0.012050855904817581, 0.037250686436891556, -0.031137358397245407, 0.031164715066552162, -0.002300603548064828, -0.08522474765777588, -0.054852165281772614, -0.0451534278690815, -0.03695247694849968, 0.025921830907464027, -0.01166207529604435, 0.005939537659287453, 0.023237360641360283, 0.0072783553041517735, 0.02165599912405014, 0.008495806716382504, 0.05860580876469612, 0.012186197564005852, 0.05556066334247589, -0.021560098975896835, 0.03798351436853409, -0.0021201695781201124, 0.010998893529176712, 0.13592754304409027, 0.05128913000226021, 0.02351384609937668, -0.07386405766010284, 0.003956452012062073, -0.04136588051915169, -0.011319989338517189, -0.025619838386774063, 0.012792247347533703, 0.03886337950825691, -0.034043531864881516, 0.0163787379860878, -0.014865926466882229, -0.006733201909810305, -0.01000772975385189, 0.03405638784170151, -0.04511411115527153, -0.04499553143978119, 0.028441578149795532, 0.018577875569462776, 0.0033695490565150976, -0.03089578077197075, -0.037594664841890335, 0.000051577790145529434, 0.01744118705391884, -0.02490573562681675, 0.028363142162561417, -0.027392776682972908, 0.01154310628771782, 0.014412576332688332, 0.02720571495592594, -0.013989429920911789, -0.012401001527905464, 0.0032276371493935585, 0.022875407710671425, 0.01834307610988617, 0.01369665190577507, -0.02207297272980213, -0.006633888464421034, 0.03717547282576561, 0.04175128787755966, -0.000110815824882593, -0.0018620400223881006, 0.021752482280135155, -0.04585804417729378, -0.026169538497924805, -0.0353073850274086, 0.06608343869447708, -0.039557863026857376, 0.015713177621364594, 0.0003954728599637747, 0.015395994298160076, 0.01980743557214737, -0.029345493763685226, -0.030951082706451416, 0.014017417095601559, 0.03092361055314541, -0.022574178874492645, -0.027440348640084267, -0.021453257650136948, 0.003272591857239604, 0.01186868455260992, 0.019075369462370872, -0.028012484312057495, -0.011477913707494736, -0.028770646080374718, -0.03937733545899391, 0.013364736922085285, 0.03823188692331314, 0.006835714913904667, 0.0028648097068071365, -0.004135367460548878, -0.02394190989434719, 0.0031265991274267435, -0.026279162615537643, -0.005021555349230766, 0.017048556357622147, -0.03837388753890991, -0.026593225076794624, -0.016903137788176537, -0.055148541927337646, 0.005224940832704306, -0.07248509675264359, -0.0025417900178581476, -0.03796955198049545, 0.032897938042879105, 0.02756255492568016, 0.00564524345099926, 0.033448778092861176, 0.016191566362977028, 0.007361314725130796, 0.03810518607497215, 0.004859830718487501, -0.015193676576018333, -0.024527665227651596, -0.03330901637673378, -0.08477625995874405, 0.007829796522855759, -0.02400791458785534, 0.0581880584359169, 0.019943775609135628, 0.028926702216267586, -0.017154814675450325, 0.003847373416647315, 0.02145393379032612, -0.005938425660133362, 0.023062774911522865, -0.04401366785168648, -0.020467856898903847, -0.0256830845028162, 0.03134310990571976, -0.059044066816568375, -0.024099357426166534, -0.059345368295907974, -0.01973317563533783, -0.003192056203261018, -0.023055657744407654, -0.015161116607487202, 0.005859046708792448, -0.014934766106307507, 0.04033605754375458, -0.02832476794719696, -0.017915159463882446, -0.026579348370432854, 0.008892307989299297, -0.03432588651776314, -0.05220063403248787, 0.008907501585781574, -0.029641423374414444, -0.023110652342438698, -0.013286377303302288, 0.0006212328444235027, 0.017943430691957474, -0.004960782825946808, -0.008219596929848194, 0.020458536222577095, -0.0012236509937793016, 0.049326591193675995, -0.013571984134614468, -0.009911051951348782, 0.031126242130994797, -0.029414720833301544, 0.01950777880847454, -0.00004405089930514805, 0.01852910779416561, 0.04420128092169762, 0.004972741473466158, -0.048679985105991364, -0.0075566270388662815, 0.023507893085479736, -0.00968207512050867, -0.02397410199046135, 0.041083112359046936, 0.0009428227785974741, -0.01928071305155754, 0.022945160046219826, -0.0040572271682322025, -0.0015519612934440374, 0.0047577135264873505, 0.0018064837204292417, 0.011115310713648796, 0.05159083381295204, -0.033581800758838654, 0.044627826660871506, -0.029276417568325996, 0.038798362016677856, 0.00129832758102566, 0.0024120791349560022, 0.016170168295502663, 0.03227758780121803, -0.0048578837886452675, 0.03507162630558014, 0.004302941728383303, 0.04432615265250206, -0.07356519252061844, -0.03177260234951973, 0.005292659625411034, 0.013344145379960537, 0.028746403753757477, -0.04398910328745842, 0.03993600979447365, 0.050113409757614136, -0.031932052224874496, 0.01112714596092701, -0.022384867072105408, -0.031491611152887344, -0.02018098719418049, 0.03448858857154846, -0.040895987302064896, -0.026120921596884727, 0.028524674475193024, -0.015264547429978848, 0.050371598452329636, 0.032999180257320404, -0.013387386687099934, -0.036827195435762405, -0.02811700478196144, 0.031195208430290222, -0.020268917083740234, -0.02511989325284958, 0.058052558451890945, -0.03448428586125374, -0.05517878755927086, 0.01721262000501156, 0.0009663120144978166, 0.018355615437030792, 0.008811896666884422, 0.0408736951649189, 0.012438876554369926, 0.07997819036245346, 0.014424551278352737, -0.020127587020397186, 0.023826396092772484, -0.0040344493463635445, 0.03783929720520973, 0.015221034176647663, -0.012555074878036976, 0.02872939221560955, 0.027869462966918945, -0.015747662633657455, -0.034856874495744705, 0.012237146496772766, -0.014596148394048214, -0.04122157767415047, 0.011445117183029652, -0.006850990932434797, -0.004999527242034674, -0.031138751655817032, -0.014655527658760548, -0.015091956593096256, -0.04457620158791542, 0.0063879345543682575, 0.015737922862172127, -0.008908022195100784, -0.028206996619701385, -0.01679544895887375, -0.048033494502305984, 0.03490244597196579, 0.003969656769186258, -0.022982368245720863, -0.044979456812143326, 0.027819998562335968, -0.0018611507257446647, -0.03396257758140564, -0.043207816779613495, -0.014828297309577465, 0.0239567831158638, 0.01637994311749935, -0.013535086996853352, 0.03878450393676758, 0.01632469892501831, 0.01693977601826191, -0.03151032328605652, -0.07468517124652863, 0.062837153673172, -0.0018411737401038408, -0.01831161230802536, -0.016086220741271973, -0.014383839443325996, -0.018259547650814056, -0.04166221618652344, 0.07190675288438797, -0.026730868965387344, -0.012527037411928177, -0.011681023985147476, -0.007370294537395239, 0.008782255463302135, -0.007478540763258934, 0.03720353916287422, -0.0272164698690176, 0.010572831146419048, -0.02397233434021473, -0.005353748332709074, 0.002059606136754155, 0.016952548176050186, 0.044589292258024216, 0.006870208773761988, -0.0085148885846138, -0.017594601958990097, 0.02438979409635067, 0.05192679911851883, 0.03181121125817299, -0.0030249375849962234, 0.05338602513074875, 0.015552700497210026, 0.04211576282978058, 0.009659966453909874, -0.015928437933325768, -0.05137183517217636, 0.029048454016447067, -0.0270154420286417, -0.009983327239751816, 0.008273225277662277, -0.014146107248961926, 0.010995857417583466, -0.07589171081781387, -0.020890165120363235, 0.052853796631097794, -0.0006041181623004377, 0.04884565621614456, 0.0476408451795578, -0.01194994430989027, 0.037699200212955475, -0.009204630739986897, 0.04498456045985222, 0.013403459452092648, 0.017793593928217888, 0.01897154189646244, 0.02540796995162964, 0.009320992976427078, 0.0013972396263852715, 0.06557506322860718, 0.047283634543418884, -0.030761996284127235, 0.03241860866546631, -0.03328842297196388, 0.04537171497941017, -0.04361118748784065, 0.003471523756161332, 0.012764214538037777, -0.0031226775608956814, -0.023862741887569427, -0.010526561178267002, -0.04577525332570076, 0.04018913581967354, -0.01782040484249592, 0.006837774068117142, -0.004885904490947723, 0.0025747516192495823, -0.017107822000980377, -0.012796049006283283, -0.04458272457122803, 0.06836584210395813, 0.0497923269867897, 0.013508502393960953, 0.017645081505179405, 0.016502799466252327, 0.05768685042858124, -0.024818193167448044, 0.04503399506211281, -0.009477715007960796, -0.005212580319494009, -0.024340800940990448, -0.037775520235300064, -0.013397498056292534, -0.027701549232006073, 0.03380555659532547, 0.0775676965713501, -0.0017327131936326623, -0.0325351357460022, -0.01731964945793152, -0.013221913948655128, 0.08138634264469147, -0.0586344338953495, 0.00936811976134777, -0.04909785836935043, -0.00022174633340910077, 0.007651067338883877, -0.0021328891161829233 ]
<p>Given $n$ samples from a (continuous) distribution X, the obvious thing to do is sort them, and distribute them equally across $[0,1]$ by taking $(x_{(k)}, (k-1/2)/n)$ as estimates of particular points on the CDF, and doing some sort of interpolation between points, as necessary.</p> <p>Is this the "right" way to make this estimate? How do I get error bars for the estimated points? It doesn't seem like they'd necessarily be symmetric.</p>
74,474
[ -0.022003738209605217, 0.0015103751793503761, -0.006695149932056665, -0.022739259526133537, 0.03140292689204216, 0.011874501593410969, -0.006276846397668123, 0.004803921561688185, 0.02368079125881195, -0.040858782827854156, 0.05836576595902443, 0.04887274652719498, 0.0680614709854126, 0.02460256591439247, 0.002630270551890135, 0.00940836500376463, -0.014166380278766155, 0.0168040469288826, -0.020033081993460655, -0.030003221705555916, 0.025700485333800316, 0.06871431320905685, 0.006190846674144268, -0.02346491999924183, -0.055727049708366394, 0.01959841698408127, 0.037661291658878326, -0.015651414170861244, 0.01214236207306385, 0.0796431228518486, -0.06806902587413788, -0.046459294855594635, 0.045945100486278534, 0.051464829593896866, 0.007331969682127237, 0.010541584342718124, -0.03585538640618324, -0.05349430441856384, -0.0032178175169974566, 0.02865477092564106, -0.07166309654712677, -0.028600215911865234, -0.013811017386615276, -0.0031346394680440426, -0.0002790012222249061, 0.04263422638177872, 0.009251692332327366, -0.0499659888446331, 0.01755392923951149, -0.038195040076971054, 0.0787828266620636, -0.006255433429032564, 0.009472638368606567, 0.007528082467615604, -0.02117975801229477, 0.003278847550973296, 0.01539954636245966, 0.029372084885835648, -0.0066652907989919186, -0.013370291329920292, 0.010948513634502888, -0.036477528512477875, -0.002012555254623294, 0.0013490457786247134, 0.016083423048257828, 0.0005720268236473203, 0.009603449143469334, 0.009247946552932262, -0.02975047379732132, -0.013132031075656414, -0.009059982374310493, 0.04198763892054558, 0.03723117336630821, -0.007904335856437683, -0.005308086518198252, -0.02840663120150566, 0.01262905914336443, -0.007916048169136047, 0.06802909076213837, -0.013380695134401321, 0.027239516377449036, 0.01901150494813919, 0.042938679456710815, 0.026420559734106064, 0.006735052913427353, 0.003478932660073042, 0.07048354297876358, -0.03176607936620712, 0.05240660160779953, 0.023103982210159302, 0.008336869068443775, -0.0015697549097239971, 0.05107802525162697, -0.03251795470714569, -0.03735056892037392, 0.006643371190875769, -0.027146214619278908, 0.0014676410937681794, -0.02426428161561489, -0.018507804721593857, -0.020429659634828568, -0.04280553758144379, 0.0000799981935415417, 0.05713299289345741, -0.02735651098191738, 0.0009380531846545637, -0.010963034816086292, 0.014047075994312763, -0.006784119177609682, 0.015391470864415169, -0.0121053671464324, 0.021495502442121506, 0.015501567162573338, 0.018270425498485565, 0.028004959225654602, 0.03363575413823128, 0.006679532118141651, -0.015569603070616722, 0.030262384563684464, 0.05163853242993355, 0.03901807218790054, -0.03344196826219559, 0.05288178473711014, -0.003766195848584175, -0.0563412643969059, 0.004852884449064732, 0.015179087407886982, -0.021393703296780586, -0.049192480742931366, 0.009133637882769108, -0.004311532713472843, -0.020136967301368713, 0.0652068555355072, 0.04365062341094017, 0.004104614723473787, 0.028850656002759933, -0.08786750584840775, -0.0647309347987175, 0.01731080189347267, 0.003768937662243843, 0.009873044677078724, -0.052036698907613754, 0.012681207619607449, 0.016047345474362373, 0.02997833490371704, 0.011827022768557072, 0.06647856533527374, -0.0005769814015366137, 0.018029524013400078, 0.0007052572327665985, -0.010000673122704029, -0.015393426641821861, -0.012081306427717209, -0.05154003947973251, -0.06113709509372711, -0.04378216713666916, 0.057084158062934875, 0.03288716822862625, 0.006794824730604887, -0.03587155044078827, 0.022077541798353195, 0.019206920638680458, -0.01645289920270443, -0.03351326659321785, 0.0009018225246109068, -0.007226430810987949, 0.04828726872801781, 0.0011965614976361394, 0.014105943962931633, -0.005761085078120232, -0.04618034139275551, 0.00994450505822897, 0.006849152501672506, -0.002954075811430812, 0.06223040446639061, -0.01983548328280449, 0.007245927583426237, -0.03697028383612633, 0.03392051160335541, 0.014307865872979164, -0.013296200893819332, -0.007755758706480265, 0.007518921513110399, 0.003581018652766943, 0.041397687047719955, 0.018806112930178642, 0.017551947385072708, -0.04262198880314827, 0.022673070430755615, -0.03444243595004082, -0.01127654779702425, -0.04587770625948906, -0.015569058246910572, 0.023676494136452675, -0.02706773579120636, 0.03949235752224922, 0.012302754446864128, -0.005887843202799559, -0.018500439822673798, -0.015140203759074211, 0.0023600009735673666, -0.021239468827843666, 0.02604854293167591, -0.04156093671917915, -0.0005269802059046924, 0.08710981905460358, 0.041630566120147705, 0.0015751781174913049, 0.07856794446706772, -0.03437560424208641, -0.03627881780266762, -0.02861081063747406, -0.06334074586629868, 0.020775863900780678, 0.000050997485232073814, 0.014301955699920654, 0.01947111263871193, 0.004157239105552435, 0.015178488567471504, 0.008375619538128376, -0.05893031507730484, 0.06957663595676422, 0.07469861209392548, -0.02106422744691372, 0.0075779203325510025, 0.011657272465527058, 0.04210084676742554, 0.0026691975072026253, -0.0026789947878569365, -0.05015506595373154, -0.05739537253975868, -0.010030846111476421, 0.06279735267162323, 0.027702223509550095, -0.05866524204611778, -0.025651440024375916, 0.052301075309515, 0.013203106820583344, 0.0029248397331684828, -0.008734744042158127, -0.024314668029546738, -0.015065380372107029, 0.02791508287191391, -0.013791674748063087, 0.011724275536835194, 0.011466290801763535, 0.004795090761035681, -0.006480121519416571, 0.034758929163217545, -0.022671613842248917, 0.026372434571385384, 0.035888977348804474, -0.011438503861427307, 0.04282594844698906, 0.008977227844297886, -0.011169475503265858, 0.029723070561885834, -0.014030011370778084, -0.0001348335645161569, 0.023050135001540184, -0.01879796013236046, 0.047437235713005066, 0.04225733131170273, -0.010763534344732761, 0.022767001762986183, 0.028359096497297287, -0.0735592171549797, 0.015076467767357826, 0.044514790177345276, -0.023836655542254448, 0.010580754838883877, -0.03917808085680008, -0.05766884610056877, 0.011938226409256458, -0.03059677593410015, 0.011528380215168, 0.025815432891249657, -0.009865488857030869, -0.027909278869628906, 0.037171706557273865, -0.01985115557909012, 0.02200356312096119, 0.05103938654065132, 0.03574046865105629, -0.03325013816356659, -0.022179072722792625, 0.0019078971818089485, -0.012925492599606514, 0.030065493658185005, 0.01265446562319994, -0.011216536164283752, 0.015854481607675552, -0.0010267659090459347, -0.04835418984293938, 0.0036752212326973677, -0.020166639238595963, 0.009745986200869083, -0.069756880402565, -0.00681280018761754, 0.04527731239795685, 0.022839749231934547, -0.021671241149306297, 0.04880867153406143, -0.026589559391140938, 0.021675458177924156, -0.06262361258268356, 0.02922649122774601, 0.01772170141339302, -0.012834319844841957, -0.0067340605892241, 0.029365742579102516, 0.028731824830174446, -0.02891172468662262, -0.06817863881587982, -0.057931505143642426, -0.0025632150936871767, -0.022414717823266983, 0.0252939835190773, 0.0301531795412302, 0.0035820442717522383, 0.10453958809375763, 0.03359520807862282, -0.03063558042049408, 0.010643715038895607, -0.031155459582805634, -0.01590665429830551, 0.014499091543257236, 0.03364130109548569, 0.002204924589022994, -0.009397733956575394, 0.02386818267405033, -0.0036035377997905016, 0.02383837290108204, 0.054199978709220886, -0.04138745367527008, -0.0025386421475559473, 0.04531092196702957, -0.016942253336310387, -0.005018897820264101, 0.0450725331902504, 0.02872227132320404, -0.02919142320752144, -0.00547473318874836, 0.012778693810105324, -0.022389192134141922, 0.06076936423778534, -0.018494559451937675, 0.014970156364142895, -0.034390632063150406, -0.03099866956472397, -0.026000382378697395, 0.045724041759967804, 0.033208344131708145, -0.027810990810394287, -0.017316214740276337, 0.015546818263828754, 0.03726210445165634, -0.02534290961921215, 0.007312450557947159, 0.022566260769963264, 0.07688683271408081, -0.021227937191724777, -0.013120420277118683, -0.005163625814020634, -0.003097244305536151, -0.005281110759824514, -0.01732928678393364, -0.015237762592732906, 0.029185187071561813, 0.07239384949207306, -0.022191796451807022, -0.026003984734416008, -0.04157974198460579, 0.020572585985064507, -0.03369549661874771, 0.01628410816192627, -0.008481503464281559, 0.051941316574811935, 0.012964919209480286, 0.06436818838119507, -0.006543843075633049, -0.028808243572711945, 0.009200863540172577, 0.03219754248857498, -0.05012200027704239, -0.01200240571051836, 0.0013789815129712224, 0.002560438122600317, -0.051717787981033325, -0.03759826719760895, 0.03898070380091667, -0.015369105152785778, 0.007553431671112776, -0.022735929116606712, 0.0111381895840168, -0.017655614763498306, -0.03936489671468735, -0.022563345730304718, -0.04600508511066437, 0.021552132442593575, 0.046940743923187256, 0.058685850352048874, -0.060949113219976425, 0.014402530156075954, 0.014307455159723759, 0.0022917366586625576, -0.03584103286266327, -0.013757315464317799, 0.023508645594120026, -0.008886512368917465, 0.05706459656357765, -0.0327371247112751, 0.017945127561688423, -0.017207486554980278, 0.022663259878754616, -0.02047540433704853, 0.0815657302737236, 0.05291995033621788, -0.031077681109309196, 0.0021746631246060133, -0.006876938045024872, -0.025824055075645447, -0.024695416912436485, 0.016795702278614044, -0.015902429819107056, 0.002175423549488187, 0.06908079981803894, 0.03623530641198158, -0.07967465370893478, -0.01236556563526392, 0.04012903943657875, 0.01923094503581524, 0.002400332596153021, -0.03053169883787632, -0.012918112799525261, 0.010237311944365501, -0.00553170358762145, -0.004692070186138153, -0.002057256642729044, 0.00978631991893053, 0.029418570920825005, 0.04300963133573532, 0.012153666466474533, -0.010741116479039192, -0.02387525700032711, 0.025183016434311867, 0.05391605570912361, 0.016178473830223083, -0.030622852966189384, 0.04530615359544754, 0.027946440503001213, 0.06716476380825043, 0.035851962864398956, -0.005119360983371735, -0.08668821305036545, 0.009405200369656086, 0.04864351078867912, 0.009452225640416145, -0.02351471595466137, -0.017174363136291504, -0.05752762779593468, 0.004113745875656605, 0.06539689004421234, -0.013087544590234756, 0.014778773300349712, -0.029000740498304367, 0.02682812139391899, -0.04502510279417038, -0.014263790100812912, -0.06216862052679062, 0.0016867576632648706, -0.02192617766559124, 0.04930954426527023, -0.04656757786870003, 0.0009087423095479608, -0.03423526883125305, 0.030528752133250237, 0.05482348054647446, 0.10104085505008698, 0.001370171899907291, -0.018612133339047432, -0.012759856879711151, -0.00004199284012429416, -0.013048132881522179, -0.030936330556869507, 0.015547463670372963, 0.001245653023943305, 0.007811484858393669, 0.045584022998809814, 0.008661809377372265, -0.028579507023096085, 0.041494451463222504, -0.0028004683554172516, -0.012119770050048828, 0.021565141156315804, -0.007888325490057468, 0.034823715686798096, 0.04121784865856171, 0.024227391928434372, 0.06843501329421997, 0.03533095866441727, -0.018267659470438957, 0.026353763416409492, -0.005896387621760368, 0.013415060006082058, -0.014448493719100952, -0.020881449803709984, -0.018620524555444717, -0.025089312344789505, -0.03334774076938629, -0.033633388578891754, 0.015103342942893505, 0.08086832612752914, -0.0037777351681143045, -0.01397057343274355, 0.012630351819097996, 0.004208501428365707, 0.03765696659684181, 0.004560338333249092, -0.025841064751148224, 0.052675534039735794, 0.024870095774531364, -0.005328179337084293, 0.020030366256833076, 0.0167999267578125, -0.00027045380556955934, 0.02257061004638672, -0.030332738533616066, -0.0010318092536181211, -0.09200076013803482, -0.02112553082406521, -0.0030959625728428364, -0.007637467235326767, 0.05119642615318298, -0.023571208119392395, 0.042655982077121735, 0.01000813115388155, -0.0444217212498188, -0.006549868732690811, 0.024539010599255562, -0.0033528292551636696, 0.0507374070584774, -0.04760294780135155, 0.010423978790640831, -0.009627672843635082, 0.022119397297501564, -0.097110316157341, -0.04557313024997711, 0.03916504606604576, -0.02508336305618286, -0.017902914434671402, -0.05896586924791336, 0.013910533860325813, 0.027027077972888947, -0.013533912599086761, -0.0006876324769109488, 0.037876684218645096, 0.013202968053519726, -0.007055789232254028, -0.035613398998975754, -0.007872619666159153, 0.06010908633470535, -0.0072753229178488255, -0.006047895178198814, 0.04401838779449463, -0.024083776399493217, -0.048195648938417435, -0.015801239758729935, -0.017412219196558, -0.03612983599305153, 0.019157087430357933, -0.01724376156926155, -0.013838187791407108, 0.0030384159181267023, -0.02267468348145485, -0.037839822471141815, 0.039076756685972214, -0.0034644303377717733, -0.007153273094445467, -0.03448512777686119, -0.017557723447680473, -0.023531503975391388, -0.015449936501681805, -0.043876513838768005, -0.018202614039182663, 0.014940000139176846, -0.00281193177215755, 0.013805513270199299, 0.01416835468262434, -0.01677699014544487, 0.03332075849175453, 0.05978567525744438, -0.04514173045754433, -0.04508938267827034, 0.038788802921772, -0.041285913437604904, 0.028544561937451363, 0.006329684983938932, -0.016198040917515755, -0.002978188218548894, 0.02401779592037201, -0.03609210252761841, -0.009149564430117607, -0.04037386551499367, 0.0022321317810565233, 0.053935591131448746, 0.0029842001385986805, 0.01409749872982502, 0.05835224315524101, 0.02456400729715824, 0.013151049613952637, -0.002957340329885483, -0.01736687310039997, -0.01358275767415762, -0.009654112160205841, 0.05283766984939575, -0.007855436764657497, 0.009716999717056751, -0.003601883538067341, 0.02517385222017765, -0.01345212385058403, 0.0058321463875472546, -0.029503341764211655, -0.0027360194362699986, 0.011720444075763226, -0.022501440718770027, -0.02916177548468113, 0.03303492069244385, -0.05067400634288788, 0.0011214117985218763, -0.02832602523267269, -0.038461051881313324, 0.05621752887964249, 0.017423102632164955, -0.02396162785589695, -0.01877228543162346, -0.02419833466410637, -0.030055077746510506, -0.01706524007022381, -0.03301206976175308, 0.005853946786373854, 0.020894743502140045, -0.01283869706094265, 0.027438903227448463, -0.006975934840738773, 0.01097901351749897, -0.022839566692709923, -0.07621686905622482, -0.03579339385032654, -0.0252128466963768, -0.08662987500429153, 0.01748228818178177, -0.010780410841107368, -0.06758220493793488, 0.021936284378170967, 0.007105469703674316, 0.04200286418199539, -0.0073771970346570015, 0.009997811168432236, -0.025370735675096512, 0.055800605565309525, -0.007975492626428604, 0.025498272851109505, -0.02939358539879322, -0.016530735418200493, 0.11400100588798523, 0.07548461854457855, 0.04009554162621498, -0.04106811061501503, 0.012651607394218445, -0.0021591985132545233, 0.0032550375908613205, 0.027925068512558937, 0.008828317746520042, 0.027415310963988304, -0.007278388366103172, -0.0034708387684077024, 0.02490244060754776, 0.004920987877994776, -0.021277882158756256, 0.025120891630649567, -0.009753978811204433, 0.02084207907319069, -0.0001956048799911514, 0.034616101533174515, 0.02739770896732807, 0.013170023448765278, -0.051035016775131226, 0.025924839079380035, 0.001774069620296359, -0.014904006384313107, -0.043930914252996445, -0.03890124335885048, -0.014813156798481941, -0.013909931294620037, -0.03854214772582054, 0.01946350187063217, 0.02686946839094162, -0.02123160846531391, -0.03389866650104523, -0.016725115478038788, -0.01886722818017006, -0.015072958543896675, 0.039096567779779434, 0.012691058218479156, 0.013317274861037731, 0.03741289675235748, -0.0042600748129189014, -0.012852284125983715, -0.041361644864082336, -0.04983871430158615, -0.0479428730905056, 0.013956763781607151, -0.02804545685648918, -0.018149564042687416, -0.020416731014847755, 0.006310070864856243, 0.011594724841415882, -0.061996687203645706, 0.005765030160546303, 0.03440108895301819, -0.0014739931793883443, -0.007201939355581999, -0.01969701237976551, -0.023467445746064186, 0.023053549230098724, -0.015562484972178936, -0.019220979884266853, 0.0033980715088546276, -0.05425381287932396, -0.01748613640666008, 0.00190083181951195, 0.03969201445579529, 0.004161236807703972, -0.024304121732711792, 0.00618200795724988, -0.015981322154402733, -0.014123592525720596, 0.008241411298513412, 0.014027769677340984, -0.03314681723713875, 0.06168517470359802, 0.017601508647203445, 0.0006799870752729475, -0.004690586589276791, -0.02773091569542885, 0.015849249437451363, -0.036478761583566666, 0.003891399595886469, -0.042578283697366714, 0.008150415495038033, 0.014369860291481018, 0.005013234913349152, 0.07263849675655365, 0.008373698219656944, 0.00165521667804569, 0.045678187161684036, 0.007827475666999817, -0.03430560976266861, 0.01206714753061533, -0.010372743010520935, 0.015814291313290596, 0.015188793651759624, 0.006517765577882528, 0.06607523560523987, 0.007546294014900923, 0.032268621027469635, 0.0068325744941830635, 0.041793011128902435, 0.003990803845226765, 0.029519956558942795, -0.019612159579992294, -0.06266419589519501, 0.01923905871808529, 0.018736695870757103, -0.00713723711669445, -0.04378501698374748, -0.003600281896069646, -0.023531418293714523, -0.020630307495594025, -0.03317228704690933, -0.00918284896761179, 0.0007806942448951304, -0.0005893807974644005, -0.038570817559957504, 0.012721368111670017, -0.031969621777534485, -0.005964933894574642, 0.009278329089283943, -0.009048808366060257, -0.052405644208192825, 0.048178382217884064, -0.0042138537392020226, -0.023770181462168694, -0.013740328140556812, -0.00038145799771882594, 0.039148326963186264, -0.013140550814568996, 0.005608036182820797, -0.004947541747242212, 0.024133339524269104, -0.004242077469825745, -0.005279849283397198, -0.014185684733092785, -0.011960846371948719, 0.022353051230311394, -0.043132003396749496, -0.04664381965994835, 0.001316953101195395, 0.01918056234717369, 0.043614424765110016, 0.008360955864191055, -0.013590693473815918, -0.03910182788968086, 0.015571621246635914, -0.049578290432691574, -0.00643909489735961, -0.01823677308857441, 0.01864178106188774, 0.029544157907366753, -0.020024169236421585, 0.01439773291349411, -0.01875571720302105, 0.0204900074750185, 0.03352520242333412, -0.01892124116420746, 0.002788304816931486, -0.0125359445810318, 0.04544064402580261, -0.04049830511212349, -0.0053232889622449875, 0.0053474479354918, 0.0052275084890425205, 0.03181525692343712, 0.041294146329164505, -0.03590185567736626, 0.03195343166589737, -0.013712557032704353, 0.027552586048841476, -0.0643911212682724, -0.020992042496800423, 0.03809686750173569, -0.02548094093799591, 0.03609536215662956, -0.05340928956866264, -0.018846092745661736, 0.008997112512588501, -0.04045014828443527, 0.04396280273795128, 0.006427541840821505, -0.009908372536301613, -0.06828650832176208, 0.04157257825136185, -0.05679299682378769, 0.015365163795650005, 0.04351057484745979, 0.020116206258535385, 0.03187821805477142, 0.04833736643195152, -0.016178054735064507, -0.0427512601017952, 0.001742519554682076, 0.020037736743688583, 0.03985196352005005, -0.06359618902206421, 0.06283753365278244, -0.020447488874197006, -0.01602410338819027, 0.027434252202510834, -0.01420388650149107, -0.0015679687494412065, 0.017202289775013924, -0.0029831468127667904, 0.00403155293315649, 0.0516628734767437, -0.0022646929137408733, -0.028205493465065956, 0.013085905462503433, 0.0011904888087883592, 0.0586872398853302, -0.006072407588362694, -0.027326133102178574, 0.01318569015711546, 0.04754350706934929, -0.00017088736058212817, -0.04909590631723404, 0.02267490327358246, 0.025886738672852516, -0.03610203415155411, 0.0023863050155341625, 0.02005264349281788, 0.008020132780075073, 0.006812969222664833, 0.07344841957092285, -0.033774666488170624, 0.0050322688184678555, 0.016025548800826073, -0.004138734191656113, -0.026475554332137108, 0.019204361364245415, 0.00984022207558155, -0.04018986225128174, 0.008691241964697838, 0.014824132435023785, -0.008429000154137611, -0.04718833416700363, -0.017346907407045364, -0.004699137527495623, -0.004177197348326445, -0.029074545949697495, -0.011946683749556541, -0.01114120427519083, 0.01443456020206213, -0.0004937663325108588, -0.02348383143544197, 0.034277454018592834, -0.00104439165443182, -0.013842993415892124, -0.08210510015487671, 0.059423334896564484, -0.002057249192148447, -0.012030325829982758, -0.0022789661306887865, 0.0026191642973572016, 0.003236685646697879, 0.0055030169896781445, 0.048310767859220505, 0.021400846540927887, 0.0019988121930509806, 0.0030752599705010653, 0.012820268981158733, 0.022877095267176628, -0.07744864374399185, 0.010589844547212124, -0.04841596260666847, -0.014804508537054062, -0.026003398001194, -0.01090849656611681, -0.022057216614484787, 0.025609344244003296, -0.01056742575019598, -0.014676743187010288, 0.019440509378910065, -0.014685467816889286, 0.031624797731637955, 0.022691018879413605, -0.0013326373882591724, -0.014749628491699696, 0.03316529467701912, 0.016217272728681564, 0.021291254088282585, 0.029690656810998917, -0.020671801641583443, -0.09330692142248154, -0.0013979863142594695, -0.028315281495451927, -0.03970763459801674, -0.014655890874564648, 0.03374795988202095, -0.010821637697517872, -0.044942378997802734, -0.014722433872520924, 0.03328053280711174, -0.055125705897808075, -0.0018304727273061872, 0.020753314718604088, 0.02090194821357727, 0.03885535150766373, 0.0028929614927619696, 0.007211227435618639, 0.01952848583459854, -0.023216916248202324, 0.020262274891138077, -0.0031624187249690294, 0.02393844537436962, 0.0033128561917692423, 0.013771536760032177, -0.010471386834979057, -0.017261696979403496, 0.029973268508911133, -0.0006779107498005033, 0.03394550457596779, -0.030441507697105408, -0.005893251392990351, 0.01902908645570278, -0.004380298778414726, 0.015355116687715054, -0.00853511318564415, -0.040167998522520065, 0.051393259316682816, 0.013073936104774475, -0.006479062605649233, -0.05210953205823898, -0.017063498497009277, -0.00034310240880586207, -0.021307457238435745, -0.011468139477074146, 0.03937479853630066, -0.011661315336823463, 0.002980833873152733, -0.012220720760524273, 0.04069221392273903, -0.0019053189316764474, -0.02459532395005226, 0.024947451427578926, -0.006384433247148991, 0.03339707478880882, -0.005073562264442444, -0.030968304723501205, -0.005583428777754307, -0.024653038010001183, 0.022450588643550873, 0.029650552198290825, 0.0041800797916948795, 0.026880541816353798, 0.003987326752394438, 0.0024073156528174877, 0.03241879865527153, -0.06307779252529144, -0.029827473685145378, -0.017104918137192726, 0.01886366307735443, 0.001458887942135334, -0.014794898219406605 ]
<p>I'm doing a meta-analysis of some studies that report results variously as odds ratios, hazards ratios or rate ratios (all with confidence intervals). Is there any way to combine these together/convert between them so that I can do a meta-analysis of all the studies?</p>
49,202
[ -0.03787945210933685, -0.006367272697389126, -0.011385388672351837, 0.0168998334556818, 0.010813320055603981, 0.03519340604543686, -0.0012260511284694076, -0.024935899302363396, 0.051030464470386505, -0.022062627598643303, 0.02813906781375408, 0.06613614410161972, 0.022938251495361328, 0.0076427944004535675, 0.01722242869436741, 0.023451171815395355, 0.005002790596336126, 0.03584982454776764, 0.022912731394171715, -0.02712278440594673, 0.01848752424120903, 0.0020537707023322582, 0.00003927029320038855, 0.024935390800237656, -0.005587603431195021, 0.03341884911060333, 0.05959083512425423, -0.046403076499700546, -0.008209786377847195, 0.040852420032024384, -0.018114594742655754, -0.015861347317695618, 0.030910588800907135, 0.05595092847943306, -0.01843319647014141, -0.0034090247936546803, 0.00020580437558237463, -0.014054916799068451, -0.02429743856191635, 0.04139699786901474, -0.02499714121222496, 0.009972118772566319, -0.011414420790970325, 0.028593940660357475, -0.009086119011044502, 0.015064001083374023, -0.03973788022994995, -0.047476544976234436, -0.03279125690460205, -0.04841439425945282, 0.07987964153289795, -0.03943915665149689, 0.044376395642757416, 0.03405073657631874, -0.0036218685563653708, 0.04276740178465843, 0.049878425896167755, 0.05670196935534477, 0.023480040952563286, -0.052629679441452026, -0.02012750133872032, -0.04385223239660263, 0.008883176371455193, -0.022636812180280685, -0.02252720296382904, 0.0039154114201664925, -0.012531359679996967, -0.030998609960079193, 0.06179596856236458, 0.0018777619116008282, 0.008147346787154675, 0.004565038252621889, 0.041169796139001846, -0.017233753576874733, -0.0021298492792993784, -0.0351511612534523, 0.007237951271235943, 0.01770397275686264, 0.04799690842628479, 0.02340339496731758, -0.031137701123952866, 0.009377888403832912, 0.058060020208358765, 0.010982167907059193, 0.006232116371393204, 0.016157153993844986, 0.07230854034423828, -0.020040810108184814, 0.0390523262321949, 0.026728568598628044, -0.01750258356332779, -0.019263971596956253, 0.039296261966228485, -0.006563462782651186, -0.03216012939810753, 0.006035043392330408, 0.01986009068787098, 0.05508523806929588, -0.011493280529975891, -0.007380399387329817, 0.008073589764535427, -0.016102133318781853, 0.00649229995906353, 0.025368139147758484, -0.00033521070145070553, -0.02935490384697914, -0.027648013085126877, 0.008345653302967548, 0.003997760824859142, -0.010295595973730087, 0.012119246646761894, 0.018556751310825348, -0.011401638388633728, 0.01982863061130047, -0.004212846979498863, -0.023594267666339874, -0.013059215620160103, -0.024612808600068092, 0.05454559251666069, 0.06717132031917572, 0.05745216831564903, -0.05544951930642128, 0.037639886140823364, -0.0199428778141737, -0.03948502242565155, -0.02081788331270218, -0.001470542629249394, -0.014892674051225185, -0.018771372735500336, 0.06451597064733505, 0.0029641289729624987, -0.07425351440906525, 0.056627508252859116, 0.004119561985135078, 0.03373493254184723, -0.016726497560739517, -0.03688677027821541, -0.045099422335624695, 0.02554049901664257, -0.0025583836250007153, -0.033171284943819046, -0.04997735098004341, 0.037042759358882904, 0.03030659258365631, 0.05865909904241562, 0.0718003660440445, 0.040636006742715836, -0.00408118637278676, 0.030093790963292122, 0.03428848832845688, 0.01526485662907362, -0.003761045169085264, 0.008389090187847614, 0.009281020611524582, -0.005275847855955362, -0.09887820482254028, 0.036035601049661636, -0.007627751212567091, 0.008166665211319923, -0.00019141582015436143, 0.02504541166126728, -0.031526271253824234, -0.017872000113129616, 0.004990761633962393, 0.042351119220256805, -0.0035865441896021366, 0.054756488651037216, 0.007415658328682184, -0.025561116635799408, 0.006645278073847294, 0.005198995117098093, -0.0108861168846488, 0.03389554098248482, 0.058412618935108185, 0.04406731203198433, -0.02573028765618801, -0.008325955830514431, -0.03128192573785782, -0.006424607243388891, 0.024111559614539146, -0.001088725752197206, -0.015014618635177612, -0.004297058098018169, -0.015260818414390087, 0.033811114728450775, 0.02520097605884075, -0.006968551781028509, -0.04534270241856575, 0.038597263395786285, -0.03631158173084259, -0.023647824302315712, -0.07124155759811401, -0.0335773266851902, -0.013329219073057175, -0.011872295290231705, 0.018885288387537003, 0.030710887163877487, 0.04700522497296333, -0.06785804033279419, -0.023905515670776367, -0.015760308131575584, -0.04127883166074753, 0.022217264398932457, -0.030842052772641182, -0.01651780679821968, 0.04143992438912392, 0.041080281138420105, -0.043979618698358536, 0.045142870396375656, -0.040858715772628784, -0.03683251515030861, -0.01876852847635746, -0.028626589104533195, -0.010268334299325943, 0.005454970058053732, -0.03940263390541077, -0.021935245022177696, -0.0017972601344808936, -0.00226865173317492, -0.0020113596692681313, -0.050977569073438644, 0.08397505432367325, 0.07337012887001038, 0.013805492781102657, 0.0039038669783622026, 0.00460297055542469, 0.068720743060112, 0.0012692904565483332, -0.0290490984916687, -0.00690385652706027, -0.030992457643151283, 0.02983645722270012, 0.04555569589138031, -0.018720928579568863, -0.07006809860467911, 0.041574083268642426, 0.046729326248168945, 0.03207317367196083, 0.004877349361777306, 0.06431037187576294, -0.010640503838658333, -0.02868860587477684, -0.02849404700100422, 0.013132663443684578, 0.027031444013118744, -0.00324067915789783, -0.005995186977088451, 0.023880042135715485, 0.030368434265255928, 0.034835442900657654, -0.007519187871366739, 0.017789795994758606, -0.007277322933077812, 0.006888777017593384, 0.016393905505537987, -0.04025303199887276, 0.02358487993478775, -0.03140344098210335, 0.027365775778889656, 0.027666687965393066, 0.013780288398265839, 0.00604972243309021, 0.027206720784306526, -0.0010134137701243162, 0.032184112817049026, 0.018003245815634727, -0.05861686170101166, 0.022898387163877487, 0.025452353060245514, -0.023704657331109047, -0.030895467847585678, -0.015311318449676037, -0.02211960032582283, -0.04931264370679855, -0.011260567232966423, -0.010553337633609772, -0.01325175166130066, 0.06811058521270752, -0.014601816423237324, -0.020727451890707016, 0.016800440847873688, -0.037963733077049255, 0.010485098697245121, -0.005418815184384584, -0.026052918285131454, 0.019453715533018112, -0.03506140783429146, -0.051851049065589905, 0.033201370388269424, -0.016843287274241447, -0.019207891076803207, 0.019327739253640175, 0.016674399375915527, -0.047337234020233154, -0.016141701489686966, 0.0025726815219968557, 0.025181010365486145, -0.025456896051764488, 0.014045551419258118, 0.02055938169360161, 0.00015525032358709723, -0.054094962775707245, 0.017255114391446114, -0.018298575654625893, -0.009400904178619385, -0.02051158808171749, 0.021109599620103836, 0.011518187820911407, -0.004769325256347656, 0.004490495193749666, 0.0332111120223999, -0.023315099999308586, 0.00013185561692807823, -0.06155771017074585, -0.04402291029691696, 0.030561476945877075, 0.0399932786822319, 0.009105686098337173, 0.022886618971824646, 0.006526178680360317, 0.06993992626667023, 0.017111029475927353, -0.007553235627710819, -0.043109241873025894, 0.018165748566389084, -0.0018842489225789905, -0.01636526919901371, -0.009762458503246307, -0.004159050527960062, 0.005269390996545553, 0.03182666003704071, 0.003775395452976227, 0.030086839571595192, 0.06865762174129486, 0.02746310830116272, 0.0056766606867313385, 0.03339690342545509, 0.01833789050579071, -0.01184135302901268, 0.005403899122029543, 0.023955343291163445, -0.005490314681082964, 0.014227076433598995, 0.012832267209887505, 0.04177888110280037, -0.01275710854679346, -0.07008051127195358, 0.01364995539188385, 0.02811572514474392, -0.02967541106045246, -0.02150040678679943, 0.012178080156445503, 0.009494096972048283, 0.013103260658681393, 0.005732424557209015, 0.03908142074942589, 0.057627689093351364, -0.027245931327342987, 0.030139684677124023, 0.029507704079151154, 0.06164303794503212, 0.0008128253975883126, -0.03734329715371132, 0.008559707552194595, -0.024427976459264755, 0.01970360428094864, -0.020634081214666367, 0.004600364714860916, 0.039539966732263565, 0.04520481824874878, 0.026718923822045326, 0.015595410950481892, -0.04468085989356041, 0.05656896531581879, -0.04848873242735863, 0.0019266946474090219, -0.0226678978651762, 0.017893588170409203, 0.01070716604590416, 0.05617186427116394, 0.02397046983242035, -0.034222230315208435, 0.009536448866128922, 0.0042233821004629135, -0.041699256747961044, 0.04606249928474426, -0.025063352659344673, -0.01791761815547943, -0.003994271159172058, 0.0074776215478777885, 0.016545960679650307, -0.021773191168904305, -0.04243318364024162, 0.0019895671866834164, -0.005430041346698999, -0.012674725614488125, 0.030361386016011238, -0.02630471996963024, -0.029591770842671394, 0.001024971716105938, 0.02234918810427189, -0.005322585813701153, -0.009700236842036247, 0.004635350313037634, 0.031217873096466064, 0.024287637323141098, -0.01102758850902319, -0.009401210583746433, 0.021359790116548538, 0.02551553025841713, 0.025438936427235603, 0.03838267922401428, 0.035271696746349335, -0.04076508805155754, 0.04052768275141716, -0.009655079804360867, 0.028592461720108986, 0.038275253027677536, -0.0513404943048954, -0.02322969399392605, -0.0009805804584175348, 0.00007946793630253524, -0.0024117478169500828, -0.002614755881950259, 0.012449041940271854, 0.01043230015784502, 0.05481041967868805, 0.022229792550206184, -0.05713576450943947, 0.01220935583114624, 0.050171900540590286, 0.0013467142125591636, -0.011317259632050991, -0.02005647122859955, -0.02393975295126438, 0.016337411478161812, -0.036281805485486984, 0.003971467260271311, 0.03797987103462219, -0.02033625729382038, -0.01156228594481945, 0.0423860177397728, -0.025429029017686844, -0.03259434923529625, 0.006471400614827871, 0.011663062497973442, 0.03707180172204971, 0.04428692162036896, -0.03302319347858429, 0.020066753029823303, 0.02784649282693863, 0.04676293954253197, 0.04892886430025101, 0.019438249990344048, -0.08489429205656052, 0.038067419081926346, 0.05951539799571037, 0.05967574939131737, -0.04126004874706268, -0.018522338941693306, -0.00034265810973010957, 0.01307070255279541, 0.057103097438812256, -0.037805575877428055, -0.02351386286318302, -0.009338482283055782, 0.0061483317986130714, -0.023266136646270752, -0.028518788516521454, -0.014950592070817947, 0.033261530101299286, -0.009177173487842083, -0.0032171718776226044, -0.009934453293681145, -0.011607978492975235, -0.04272470250725746, 0.010487762279808521, 0.016707152128219604, 0.04650093615055084, -0.025586266070604324, -0.012637768872082233, -0.0016413620905950665, 0.0271578561514616, -0.04454980790615082, -0.07746047526597977, 0.012112801894545555, 0.0020609109196811914, 0.00979987345635891, 0.06540117412805557, -0.00008804829849395901, 0.005718346685171127, 0.0519522950053215, -0.004494139924645424, -0.046007223427295685, 0.015016966499388218, -0.024904659017920494, 0.013644385151565075, 0.03607521206140518, 0.01802864857017994, 0.07408934086561203, 0.007468030788004398, -0.01297964621335268, -0.00041264062747359276, -0.04941464588046074, 0.03132488951086998, -0.041983336210250854, -0.009312150999903679, -0.027424704283475876, -0.02447483129799366, -0.004613714758306742, -0.026005107909440994, -0.01660386100411415, 0.01904771849513054, 0.017929047346115112, 0.006581378635019064, -0.009186076931655407, -0.012391111813485622, 0.005623921286314726, -0.044142480939626694, 0.026325112208724022, 0.009254580363631248, -0.012788238003849983, -0.03493957594037056, 0.03023715503513813, -0.021090617403388023, -0.0022739425767213106, 0.00795169360935688, -0.07001752406358719, -0.001986527116969228, -0.03778737783432007, -0.01758764684200287, 0.0018395311199128628, -0.026974009349942207, 0.058861274272203445, -0.04120226204395294, -0.012316354550421238, -0.01922900602221489, -0.02630978263914585, -0.030318522825837135, 0.0344914086163044, 0.0023833289742469788, 0.02831106074154377, -0.050500281155109406, 0.06801073998212814, -0.012980359606444836, -0.027235746383666992, -0.07936400175094604, -0.0368427112698555, 0.04360711947083473, 0.03145395219326019, -0.0403144545853138, -0.03919077292084694, 0.01820765994489193, -0.010997068136930466, -0.029420195147395134, -0.0036308204289525747, 0.044562339782714844, -0.04145825654268265, -0.004871821962296963, -0.024092312902212143, 0.019802004098892212, 0.04770819842815399, -0.0050790514796972275, -0.009252590127289295, 0.022783644497394562, -0.03530284762382507, 0.015348738059401512, 0.0005629659863188863, -0.00047437893226742744, -0.03513889014720917, 0.0010290832724422216, -0.032032907009124756, -0.015040965750813484, 0.03261380270123482, -0.005605143494904041, 0.00714299688115716, 0.04215294495224953, 0.020671626552939415, 0.036559950560331345, -0.033184535801410675, 0.021660538390278816, 0.002011739183217287, 0.035368043929338455, -0.019048720598220825, 0.0491635836660862, -0.006776035763323307, 0.02060619555413723, 0.012279217131435871, 0.004403948318213224, -0.002760970266535878, 0.030972879379987717, 0.06187691166996956, -0.039739180356264114, -0.002016377868130803, -0.005264377221465111, -0.01949865184724331, 0.00480922544375062, 0.026869188994169235, 0.0014659875305369496, 0.03178321570158005, 0.00003127086893073283, -0.03269985690712929, -0.04476683959364891, -0.019122084602713585, -0.011995199136435986, 0.07282276451587677, -0.0351705402135849, 0.03696289286017418, 0.0409979410469532, 0.017513036727905273, 0.010881911031901836, -0.006691301707178354, -0.0016110794385895133, 0.003127698553726077, 0.0043280282989144325, 0.06913020461797714, -0.006837715860456228, -0.014403999783098698, 0.03923622891306877, 0.04639174044132233, -0.012466110289096832, 0.05499901622533798, -0.01688252203166485, 0.006247281096875668, 0.016158826649188995, 0.014144510962069035, -0.02787698060274124, 0.035771775990724564, -0.06852814555168152, 0.020131397992372513, -0.06440529227256775, -0.04227781295776367, 0.06988877058029175, 0.015028420835733414, -0.007247935514897108, -0.013099889270961285, -0.033647119998931885, -0.053938571363687515, 0.02167658880352974, -0.004297362640500069, -0.016772253438830376, 0.03156095743179321, 0.015387161634862423, 0.04694214463233948, -0.0200277641415596, 0.010122491046786308, -0.03851107507944107, -0.09401155263185501, -0.017113039270043373, -0.019542764872312546, -0.04722229763865471, 0.004985820967704058, -0.009410866536200047, -0.028742598369717598, 0.01648845337331295, -0.0052441819570958614, -0.02675677090883255, -0.011934669688344002, 0.030901096761226654, 0.0014148942427709699, 0.06396844238042831, 0.047308217734098434, 0.007931698113679886, 0.03443411365151405, -0.0056916228495538235, 0.11258542537689209, 0.08135420083999634, 0.04702843725681305, -0.08422107249498367, 0.03399381414055824, 0.007671714294701815, 0.01783961057662964, -0.001954580657184124, 0.009113898500800133, 0.016495518386363983, -0.020576871931552887, 0.05516790598630905, 0.0772031620144844, -0.007558868732303381, -0.053744927048683167, 0.05682837590575218, -0.007496018894016743, -0.026538383215665817, -0.040593624114990234, 0.015370821580290794, -0.013981068506836891, -0.0021431848872452974, -0.023215826600790024, -0.003340272232890129, 0.0052753170020878315, -0.011374499648809433, -0.020992927253246307, -0.03281562402844429, 0.00569458631798625, 0.027706198394298553, -0.016773708164691925, -0.0347575806081295, 0.0340556874871254, 0.011601106263697147, 0.0002513419894967228, -0.010616491548717022, 0.03670556843280792, 0.006788461934775114, -0.020035110414028168, -0.006091907620429993, 0.01781942881643772, 0.014885957352817059, 0.006318176165223122, 0.003448383416980505, -0.05385204032063484, -0.024704821407794952, -0.026388749480247498, -0.00551414443179965, -0.013718309812247753, 0.020204611122608185, -0.029131870716810226, -0.003233534749597311, 0.010767586529254913, -0.03967246040701866, -0.0027579276356846094, 0.0014737980673089623, 0.022623524069786072, -0.02336559258401394, -0.0022166043054312468, -0.0471150167286396, 0.04947029799222946, -0.03357066586613655, 0.07217677682638168, 0.05606503784656525, -0.024888256564736366, -0.02074798196554184, -0.06960979849100113, 0.0021769143640995026, -0.020345719531178474, -0.019038308411836624, 0.015827713534235954, 0.010538862086832523, -0.02063979208469391, -0.004769433755427599, 0.00011410488514229655, -0.0008719866746105254, 0.04333905130624771, 0.007074687164276838, -0.012797780334949493, -0.0134479571133852, -0.05436132848262787, 0.011629224754869938, -0.01595929265022278, -0.03541301190853119, -0.04470253363251686, -0.012567473575472832, 0.04402228072285652, 0.017387986183166504, -0.019186722114682198, 0.04633845388889313, -0.059514857828617096, 0.0364956296980381, 0.0221139844506979, -0.05204051733016968, -0.026792233809828758, -0.0066619617864489555, -0.01778431236743927, -0.02580573596060276, -0.018906785175204277, 0.057754818350076675, 0.008778823539614677, 0.01511580590158701, 0.02648235484957695, 0.007301937323063612, 0.009930514730513096, -0.004990046378225088, -0.014204317703843117, -0.055275920778512955, 0.018442615866661072, 0.01410327572375536, 0.011878766119480133, 0.005875796545296907, -0.011435805819928646, -0.03405225649476051, -0.029839303344488144, 0.010852053761482239, -0.009539752267301083, -0.011194460093975067, 0.009428715333342552, -0.044419363141059875, 0.021558528766036034, 0.004082586150616407, -0.009307222440838814, -0.056642401963472366, -0.03545492887496948, 0.00594170019030571, -0.024854257702827454, -0.004270207602530718, 0.004339154809713364, 0.03110322915017605, 0.009761667810380459, 0.02287895791232586, 0.031990695744752884, -0.008425677195191383, -0.01076401025056839, 0.009361138567328453, -0.01154363714158535, 0.029560841619968414, -0.020308341830968857, -0.011714771389961243, 0.02070084773004055, -0.05061709135770798, 0.008193857967853546, 0.025710396468639374, 0.005219999235123396, 0.026263462379574776, 0.010523537173867226, -0.017803998664021492, -0.024230176582932472, 0.06786413490772247, -0.054470278322696686, -0.04618591070175171, -0.025798050686717033, -0.022908348590135574, -0.014878450892865658, 0.0071058934554457664, -0.007422303780913353, 0.024579662829637527, -0.01498430036008358, 0.009605658240616322, 0.041829805821180344, 0.013485068455338478, 0.02652217075228691, 0.0335092768073082, 0.026371657848358154, 0.05727212131023407, -0.003413112834095955, -0.01480716373771429, 0.03617760166525841, 0.03425683453679085, -0.03870781883597374, 0.05701281502842903, -0.0012926898198202252, 0.024369873106479645, -0.05719815194606781, -0.01454551238566637, -0.021368807181715965, -0.01750100962817669, 0.02780921570956707, -0.05260569229722023, 0.024023743346333504, -0.008639330044388771, -0.03251247480511665, 0.0005232467083260417, -0.0038303330074995756, -0.037747371941804886, -0.04120045527815819, 0.00778262410312891, 0.01146765612065792, 0.008368616923689842, 0.02677113190293312, 0.027693655341863632, -0.0017131476197391748, 0.015287640504539013, -0.035747576504945755, -0.013385610654950142, -0.0270612183958292, -0.01333316694945097, 0.023697717115283012, -0.07932841032743454, 0.026961660012602806, -0.051982779055833817, -0.06135247275233269, 0.04255543649196625, 0.028301935642957687, 0.03692445158958435, 0.054128047078847885, 0.011609463952481747, -0.016603436321020126, 0.028487833216786385, -0.0029089427553117275, 0.002348867245018482, -0.04487202316522598, -0.007796763442456722, 0.03154168650507927, 0.015996798872947693, -0.04999035224318504, 0.04236995428800583, 0.03349129855632782, -0.021902423352003098, -0.040138643234968185, 0.01813020370900631, -0.023091286420822144, -0.0334489606320858, -0.01663215458393097, -0.037839073687791824, 0.05109221860766411, -0.03474274277687073, 0.03109380602836609, -0.038854002952575684, 0.01016470231115818, 0.07703234255313873, -0.00263489899225533, 0.0015582903288304806, 0.03734273463487625, -0.027419304475188255, -0.017935242503881454, -0.047074466943740845, 0.00573342852294445, -0.02610100246965885, -0.01182557176798582, 0.029549159109592438, 0.012832735665142536, -0.012506641447544098, -0.04105231165885925, -0.010956470854580402, -0.014194905757904053, 0.04270649701356888, -0.031902920454740524, 0.00712283980101347, 0.04199783876538277, -0.008548830635845661, 0.01778528094291687, -0.047739844769239426, 0.0387563481926918, 0.022870609536767006, -0.02497175894677639, -0.07003232091665268, -0.027173710986971855, 0.0012160363839939237, -0.005096486769616604, 0.06831493228673935, -0.014083372429013252, 0.031579937785863876, -0.03695385158061981, 0.06751962006092072, 0.0037322051357477903, -0.044753558933734894, 0.02204173244535923, -0.009311459958553314, -0.051466770470142365, -0.019037459045648575, -0.004136569797992706, -0.003227874869480729, -0.03101038560271263, -0.004887161310762167, -0.04099449887871742, 0.0018658756744116545, 0.024137169122695923, 0.008212328888475895, 0.033218953758478165, 0.003406910225749016, -0.03862927481532097, 0.05136556923389435, -0.03779912367463112, -0.012423026375472546, 0.052389077842235565, -0.018611405044794083, -0.04586213082075119, 0.05656953155994415, -0.025822358205914497, -0.0244667399674654, 0.01502031460404396, -0.02561028115451336, -0.019332630559802055, -0.032983437180519104, 0.010802098549902439, 0.022903703153133392, -0.06489922851324081, 0.01958945393562317, 0.03535405173897743, 0.022610023617744446, 0.018514566123485565, -0.033547498285770416, -0.0059464420191943645, 0.0013613112969323993, -0.03317691758275032, -0.0025767029728740454, -0.020649192854762077, 0.0251254104077816, -0.014363069087266922, -0.013331713154911995, 0.0011374985333532095, -0.027325596660375595, 0.01326507143676281, -0.014627819880843163, 0.012265571393072605, -0.0337686687707901, -0.0039030369371175766, -0.0033184108324348927, -0.03513067960739136, 0.015772046521306038, 0.011776784434914589, -0.02151053212583065, 0.03666125610470772, -0.016698548570275307, 0.037944354116916656, -0.016952911391854286, -0.052153345197439194, -0.030365193262696266, -0.030524330213665962, 0.01772058568894863, 0.005968431942164898, 0.0021683303639292717, -0.002253621816635132, -0.00007085537072271109, -0.012922693975269794, 0.04713338240981102, -0.037824295461177826, 0.04646683111786842, -0.024746060371398926, -0.01864805445075035, -0.003059055656194687, -0.02467636577785015, -0.01704820618033409, -0.027265720069408417, 0.0011816129554063082, 0.009409986436367035, 0.019121304154396057, -0.023640967905521393, -0.030227290466427803, 0.014462128281593323, 0.011231696233153343, -0.059396062046289444, -0.05311356484889984, -0.025529645383358, 0.036546044051647186, 0.025385281071066856, 0.010764325968921185 ]
<h3>Overview:</h3> <p>I want to test if "emotional numbing" is a significantly better predictor of "lower intimate relationship functioning" than "reexperiencing" or "hyperarousal"</p> <p>It was suggested to me to use stepwise regression to analyze the data. However, one of my dissertation committee members suggested Hotelling's T. </p> <h3>My hypothesis:</h3> <ul> <li>Hypothesis 1: Emotional numbing will be a better predictor of lower relationship functioning than re-experiencing or hyperarousal symptoms. </li> <li>Hypothesis 1a: Emotional numbing will be a better predictor of lower dyadic adjustment than re-experiencing or hyperarousal symptoms. </li> <li>Hypothesis 1b: Emotional numbing will be a better predictor of intimacy than re-experiencing or hyperarousal symptoms. </li> <li>Hypothesis 1c: Emotional numbing will be a better predictor of communication than re-experiencing or hyperarousal symptoms.</li> </ul> <h3>Questions:</h3> <ul> <li>Is Hotelling's T the most appropriate way to determine whether emotional numbing is a significantly better predictor than the other 2 variables?</li> <li>Or is there is a better statistical test for this task?</li> </ul>
293
[ -0.0526602640748024, -0.037162140011787415, -0.027024483308196068, 0.007054053246974945, -0.014089132659137249, 0.014909990131855011, 0.005310960579663515, -0.02245042286813259, 0.05563744157552719, -0.001994333229959011, 0.001520271529443562, 0.02578575164079666, -0.0034145554527640343, -0.01971963420510292, 0.011271675117313862, 0.0006785906734876335, 0.003051038831472397, 0.005042675416916609, 0.003318933304399252, -0.007995176129043102, 0.01863337866961956, 0.012981678359210491, -0.024172155186533928, 0.01990073174238205, -0.002750635612756014, 0.02907313033938408, 0.024500403553247452, -0.027066633105278015, -0.0020437058992683887, 0.030201809480786324, -0.003537692129611969, -0.0030087826307862997, -0.026581648737192154, 0.0316135548055172, -0.0019603613764047623, -0.004801034927368164, -0.010407092981040478, 0.02570369467139244, -0.03041486255824566, 0.05547286197543144, 0.017160147428512573, 0.005701493006199598, -0.0027117691934108734, 0.06915415078401566, -0.015655500814318657, -0.027914931997656822, -0.032394926995038986, -0.02740892581641674, -0.005639298353344202, -0.024545274674892426, 0.01938018389046192, 0.004681211896240711, -0.016652097925543785, -0.005617889575660229, 0.013945531100034714, -0.016843652352690697, 0.06298145651817322, 0.06827246397733688, -0.030656185001134872, -0.05717362090945244, -0.013416341505944729, -0.039354827255010605, -0.002266077557578683, -0.006147759035229683, -0.013521943241357803, 0.04939185827970505, 0.011949628591537476, -0.00270061194896698, 0.03368090093135834, -0.029780814424157143, -0.008817031979560852, 0.0035028220154345036, 0.04174134135246277, -0.020264582708477974, 0.006746038794517517, -0.025287572294473648, 0.0004802329058293253, 0.030448248609900475, 0.04087551310658455, 0.07053256034851074, 0.011926899664103985, -0.04760836064815521, 0.02294004149734974, 0.10570665448904037, 0.015379746444523335, 0.003983377479016781, 0.06490445137023926, -0.014832922257483006, -0.001335818669758737, 0.02677221968770027, -0.0036384041886776686, 0.02697525918483734, 0.02781960368156433, -0.0056533608585596085, -0.02934815175831318, 0.015436594374477863, -0.017850063741207123, 0.0717160701751709, -0.0006502973265014589, -0.010625640861690044, -0.03899524360895157, -0.017423981800675392, 0.0007234452059492469, 0.04970498010516167, -0.006207498721778393, 0.0064919013530015945, -0.0029145183507353067, -0.00550927734002471, 0.006728256121277809, -0.024746323004364967, -0.005390661768615246, 0.023111799731850624, 0.020073240622878075, -0.004916459321975708, 0.028570938855409622, 0.0009579385514371097, -0.03180612251162529, -0.03983139246702194, 0.05181775242090225, 0.09228122234344482, 0.02086019329726696, -0.03621351718902588, 0.02039378322660923, -0.005075087305158377, -0.008349906653165817, 0.0014554534573107958, 0.007545195985585451, 0.004736226052045822, -0.02263159304857254, 0.02294621244072914, 0.02284197136759758, 0.010270772501826286, 0.037582553923130035, 0.012742109596729279, 0.036158546805381775, 0.041683558374643326, -0.058292798697948456, -0.06419122964143753, 0.02852288819849491, 0.01798863895237446, 0.027518725022673607, -0.046206939965486526, -0.02140102908015251, 0.04174259305000305, 0.03905718773603439, 0.01981884241104126, 0.01038188673555851, 0.04214544594287872, 0.040939535945653915, 0.06476955860853195, -0.06140345707535744, -0.024283334612846375, -0.0462707094848156, -0.04589127376675606, -0.04701337590813637, -0.061903711408376694, -0.01641438715159893, 0.04188539832830429, -0.022772837430238724, 0.023671481758356094, 0.05042117461562157, 0.016863444820046425, -0.06461438536643982, 0.030093509703874588, 0.009781280532479286, -0.003922085743397474, 0.06813313066959381, -0.018090633675456047, 0.020142963156104088, 0.021720709279179573, 0.019950831308960915, 0.046604327857494354, 0.00786806084215641, 0.026706717908382416, -0.01567934639751911, -0.032560933381319046, 0.03303837776184082, -0.006540826056152582, -0.01643497310578823, 0.02654874324798584, -0.07540097087621689, -0.018405113369226456, 0.01540654432028532, -0.0351775698363781, 0.00012622366193681955, 0.04043533653020859, 0.010394752956926823, -0.011283496394753456, 0.031544920057058334, -0.055628735572099686, -0.06905749440193176, -0.044653426855802536, 0.0063927993178367615, -0.02229432947933674, -0.009411650709807873, 0.04082068055868149, -0.015412875451147556, 0.0505705326795578, 0.000022694348444929346, -0.015959812328219414, 0.015605363994836807, -0.010409112088382244, 0.06519076973199844, -0.0386526882648468, 0.03653182089328766, 0.0695153996348381, 0.06382741034030914, -0.036552559584379196, 0.01795857399702072, -0.09857113659381866, -0.06713899970054626, -0.00416987482458353, -0.006449978332966566, 0.06400333344936371, -0.004177437163889408, -0.015467715449631214, 0.025381097570061684, -0.008752333000302315, -0.015756433829665184, 0.03755766525864601, -0.03739170730113983, 0.06925120949745178, 0.02004721388220787, 0.048665404319763184, 0.03261323273181915, -0.0010806334903463721, 0.023039136081933975, -0.0005898825475014746, -0.004092422779649496, -0.0005975545500405133, -0.014925902709364891, 0.0010969022987410426, 0.027595821768045425, -0.02398933656513691, -0.03972364217042923, 0.025199221447110176, -0.006878542713820934, 0.015140150673687458, 0.002475655172020197, 0.029033107683062553, -0.02193775400519371, -0.05578424781560898, 0.0013731983490288258, 0.025562947615981102, 0.01644997112452984, 0.02551404759287834, 0.013522492721676826, -0.0017040091333910823, 0.021677836775779724, -0.009615670889616013, 0.02329820767045021, 0.05810312181711197, 0.010225018486380577, 0.02626687102019787, 0.0025693271309137344, -0.016554657369852066, 0.021880080923438072, -0.03929832950234413, -0.007332363165915012, 0.012835875153541565, -0.006723657716065645, 0.0005373629974201322, 0.008592846803367138, -0.005887975450605154, -0.004263992886990309, 0.03307163342833519, 0.01104914303869009, 0.026534372940659523, 0.01391537208110094, -0.012192650698125362, 0.022034015506505966, -0.02753729745745659, -0.0286934245377779, -0.042405445128679276, -0.016254449263215065, 0.02745574526488781, -0.011798876337707043, -0.009693008847534657, -0.013675296679139137, 0.02386528253555298, -0.020113540813326836, -0.01573490910232067, -0.02878623642027378, 0.011795680038630962, -0.03056221827864647, -0.04534977674484253, -0.024150211364030838, -0.011370643973350525, 0.011869508773088455, 0.001253414899110794, -0.012442197650671005, 0.03591899201273918, 0.006899241358041763, -0.07858820259571075, -0.036927856504917145, -0.0033901820424944162, 0.002173143671825528, 0.015016801655292511, -0.014200711622834206, 0.06253954023122787, 0.008032433688640594, -0.014955425634980202, -0.002936418168246746, -0.015240496024489403, -0.015299945138394833, 0.010983644053339958, -0.03972144424915314, -0.013346759602427483, 0.0026181628927588463, -0.02159149944782257, -0.024922186508774757, -0.030669791623950005, 0.005997749511152506, -0.08631524443626404, -0.08554846048355103, 0.032726190984249115, 0.021343380212783813, 0.05666957423090935, 0.043277863413095474, -0.015566762536764145, 0.03965698555111885, 0.004632588475942612, -0.011046435683965683, -0.027311725541949272, -0.02636358141899109, -0.03205897659063339, 0.01849508285522461, 0.01721830852329731, 0.02615486830472946, 0.034491971135139465, 0.0021211225539445877, -0.016800010576844215, 0.008584603667259216, 0.014751537702977657, 0.021818218752741814, -0.01436960231512785, 0.0146865826100111, 0.024439197033643723, -0.053220078349113464, 0.037410296499729156, 0.006157406140118837, -0.024183889850974083, 0.012040391564369202, -0.02900009974837303, 0.041032709181308746, 0.04251331835985184, -0.04930378869175911, -0.008529432117938995, -0.010871728882193565, -0.009303990751504898, 0.0011079981923103333, -0.014024150557816029, -0.030747195705771446, -0.030496597290039062, -0.05209721252322197, 0.03160230070352554, 0.018462631851434708, -0.006928892806172371, 0.007108302786946297, 0.05894898995757103, 0.04168316721916199, 0.014846660196781158, -0.0018137790029868484, -0.028488285839557648, -0.028691207990050316, 0.04929421842098236, -0.014504344202578068, -0.022028427571058273, 0.033147089183330536, 0.014018861576914787, 0.055844083428382874, 0.027820225805044174, -0.05104915425181389, 0.023753797635436058, -0.04473528638482094, -0.03041255660355091, -0.020846357569098473, 0.05003146082162857, -0.006999976001679897, 0.022638648748397827, 0.0030931972432881594, 0.03582184761762619, 0.0012584141222760081, 0.015455870889127254, -0.022908948361873627, 0.005284826271235943, -0.009977121837437153, -0.000056614127970533445, 0.03545607626438141, -0.009823080152273178, 0.028360817581415176, -0.03591081127524376, 0.005294566974043846, 0.020097531378269196, 0.04619916155934334, -0.052847422659397125, -0.0001602826378075406, -0.03292585909366608, 0.014613094739615917, -0.025425128638744354, 0.037987880408763885, 0.018066907301545143, 0.016104020178318024, 0.043430399149656296, 0.047945696860551834, -0.005061169620603323, -0.021794196218252182, -0.04547852650284767, 0.0076913717202842236, 0.0332791693508625, 0.03382391110062599, 0.015543930232524872, 0.03046293929219246, -0.04501776769757271, -0.005298742558807135, 0.024221984669566154, -0.014692356809973717, 0.018024364486336708, 0.002052801428362727, -0.019738683477044106, -0.007609765976667404, -0.013634421862661839, -0.0027615532744675875, 0.06568262726068497, 0.0333421416580677, 0.01596146635711193, 0.018325775861740112, -0.001593444962054491, -0.02200203947722912, 0.002028027083724737, 0.005100616253912449, 0.03018321841955185, -0.00143846170976758, -0.060874175280332565, -0.012649324722588062, 0.02082747034728527, 0.011712868697941303, 0.062235359102487564, 0.013777336105704308, -0.013445674441754818, -0.015303341671824455, 0.030846383422613144, 0.014658128842711449, -0.0719824805855751, -0.027089616283774376, -0.028103597462177277, 0.010602517984807491, 0.007888047024607658, -0.016442757099866867, 0.030054626986384392, 0.03392879292368889, 0.020915428176522255, 0.013806069269776344, 0.00495970668271184, -0.09033503383398056, 0.023160599172115326, 0.03623250871896744, 0.0488462969660759, -0.017280088737607002, -0.0368509478867054, 0.001868332619778812, 0.034766457974910736, 0.024544715881347656, -0.04893891513347626, 0.011052807793021202, -0.03188133239746094, 0.029907623305916786, -0.0758676528930664, -0.03485329449176788, -0.05728774145245552, 0.03254277631640434, 0.01741051860153675, 0.023533927276730537, -0.013150578364729881, -0.013041164726018906, 0.005763734690845013, 0.005376629065722227, 0.02322765439748764, 0.06177661567926407, -0.005803210660815239, -0.026883399114012718, 0.02046179585158825, -0.04130282625555992, -0.056400611996650696, -0.014465301297605038, 0.004078323021531105, 0.029726216569542885, -0.009173881262540817, 0.03738170489668846, -0.031016230583190918, 0.019717581570148468, -0.0053946031257510185, 0.010080941021442413, -0.02476385235786438, -0.004697788506746292, 0.0032364046201109886, 0.04606204107403755, 0.03585750237107277, -0.03296908736228943, 0.09385538846254349, 0.04844572767615318, 0.017520468682050705, 0.017975274473428726, -0.022432850673794746, 0.0078186159953475, -0.06447502225637436, 0.011069685220718384, -0.04509302228689194, 0.0071199871599674225, -0.00019889039685949683, 0.023860743269324303, -0.0012649078853428364, -0.006058200262486935, -0.04136836528778076, 0.008047124370932579, 0.03210486099123955, -0.008060661144554615, -0.03506213799118996, 0.043671369552612305, 0.007151268422603607, -0.007603045087307692, -0.010603565722703934, 0.010423952713608742, -0.0003984793438576162, -0.029863813892006874, 0.026113994419574738, 0.05780405178666115, -0.049163904041051865, 0.032109878957271576, -0.013893986120820045, -0.03895118460059166, 0.016370538622140884, -0.017577318474650383, 0.014749007299542427, -0.05616900697350502, -0.02601524442434311, 0.04691142216324806, -0.01833639107644558, 0.0454234778881073, 0.004667522851377726, -0.0033313962630927563, 0.05213911086320877, 0.006311705801635981, 0.024109279736876488, -0.00759356701746583, -0.011078749783337116, -0.06631017476320267, -0.04451146721839905, 0.0158268790692091, -0.00888660829514265, -0.06356842815876007, -0.010434215888381004, 0.01019428763538599, -0.03540749102830887, -0.03339415043592453, -0.0280999094247818, 0.08877215534448624, 0.00925912894308567, -0.015349236316978931, -0.001340855727903545, 0.009326660074293613, 0.04262448474764824, 0.053150467574596405, 0.00788706075400114, 0.02319910004734993, -0.01551927998661995, -0.0016537390183657408, -0.03081870824098587, 0.012401022017002106, -0.019077708944678307, -0.009186476469039917, -0.03267945349216461, -0.01900787651538849, 0.07276827841997147, 0.013909666799008846, -0.024148445576429367, -0.016680363565683365, 0.010857811197638512, 0.00855997297912836, -0.07652445882558823, 0.000910733942873776, -0.035932742059230804, 0.008428801782429218, 0.014643365517258644, 0.057030048221349716, -0.004956651013344526, -0.028018053621053696, 0.022881366312503815, 0.012181596830487251, -0.055392976850271225, 0.028858136385679245, 0.06519324332475662, 0.0421014279127121, 0.03828004002571106, 0.026687337085604668, -0.022186918184161186, 0.031497929245233536, 0.0007943864911794662, 0.0036672239657491446, -0.0003466788330115378, 0.0433495007455349, -0.04292716458439827, -0.054974209517240524, -0.03280554711818695, 0.02062039263546467, 0.048676736652851105, -0.006394929718226194, 0.0341169498860836, 0.02958567999303341, -0.004778384231030941, -0.028392517939209938, -0.052475228905677795, 0.0016788971843197942, 0.003370207268744707, 0.03054564632475376, 0.039615169167518616, 0.014245196245610714, -0.01442074403166771, 0.017798323184251785, 0.04972907900810242, 0.0075580524280667305, 0.041113778948783875, 0.03141377493739128, 0.03201878443360329, 0.04819685220718384, -0.09147913008928299, 0.00769845861941576, 0.019901813939213753, -0.052721332758665085, 0.021564142778515816, -0.016442453488707542, -0.008677189238369465, 0.007806333247572184, 0.07516229897737503, 0.005492317955940962, -0.062029533088207245, -0.031211134046316147, -0.040262140333652496, 0.0021811453625559807, 0.01138588972389698, -0.011870425194501877, 0.03521088883280754, -0.0008245683275163174, 0.019695458933711052, 0.009089172817766666, 0.03790675476193428, 0.0027664874214679003, -0.052473798394203186, -0.007337687071412802, 0.026232760399580002, -0.011433904990553856, 0.032202571630477905, -0.027715442702174187, -0.03216523304581642, 0.010541317984461784, -0.04900777339935303, 0.01843496598303318, -0.04537796974182129, 0.010962092317640781, -0.007196401245892048, 0.03493480384349823, -0.015206568874418736, 0.0007109869620762765, 0.014599046669900417, 0.009891058318316936, 0.11791639775037766, 0.07326029986143112, 0.02786318212747574, -0.027387607842683792, 0.04016692936420441, 0.017382027581334114, -0.008568266406655312, -0.04353925958275795, 0.029356174170970917, 0.0012387761380523443, -0.010040400549769402, 0.0618121363222599, 0.04177255555987358, -0.01465673465281725, -0.029103532433509827, 0.09756585210561752, -0.005237736739218235, -0.01500461995601654, -0.012573075480759144, -0.027126353234052658, 0.023093251511454582, -0.049192093312740326, 0.0018566168146207929, -0.020910216495394707, -0.0011479934910312295, 0.006185128353536129, -0.019716961309313774, 0.018505357205867767, 0.0016868463717401028, 0.006683042738586664, -0.003917044028639793, 0.010514792054891586, 0.00825143326073885, 0.03374568372964859, -0.014363842085003853, -0.01597631350159645, 0.042040206491947174, -0.030462102964520454, -0.0014833785826340318, 0.05366188660264015, 0.005550953559577465, -0.017456557601690292, 0.025235725566744804, 0.043246980756521225, -0.06241825222969055, -0.03881315141916275, -0.023656919598579407, 0.01570567861199379, 0.01503437478095293, -0.034163203090429306, -0.017207186669111252, -0.006766899023205042, 0.005710550118237734, -0.010568277910351753, 0.013317777775228024, 0.014217391610145569, 0.01522295456379652, -0.02203829400241375, -0.006461872719228268, -0.043501731008291245, 0.025350047275424004, 0.03440246358513832, 0.030145609751343727, 0.00018395198276266456, -0.02200533077120781, -0.05721942335367203, 0.003476992715150118, 0.018596995621919632, 0.0029858017805963755, 0.0015868556220084429, -0.013294669799506664, -0.011103377677500248, -0.013237283565104008, -0.006173744332045317, 0.01094841118901968, 0.020560121163725853, 0.055355269461870193, 0.0019404706545174122, -0.009031093679368496, -0.04867679998278618, -0.029831038787961006, 0.019933253526687622, -0.008316927589476109, -0.03546677529811859, -0.04197359085083008, -0.024761956185102463, -0.02304944582283497, 0.01887604035437107, 0.020527442917227745, -0.008569889701902866, 0.027638500556349754, 0.03774883225560188, 0.030567580834031105, -0.024535907432436943, 0.0027596966829150915, -0.017166867852211, -0.0285850428044796, -0.028234902769327164, -0.040432922542095184, 0.038208890706300735, -0.017003171145915985, 0.030119217932224274, -0.0037180075887590647, -0.003209635615348816, -0.012256450019776821, 0.0006733117043040693, 0.04812817648053169, -0.04590505734086037, -0.0163723211735487, 0.03768672049045563, 0.004058238118886948, -0.0014400570653378963, -0.009287790395319462, -0.06414353102445602, -0.009101697243750095, -0.00013961928198114038, -0.01890413835644722, -0.01745559275150299, 0.003028998151421547, 0.007639204617589712, 0.025853492319583893, -0.07012929022312164, -0.04031382501125336, -0.0377044640481472, -0.009751160629093647, -0.006083848420530558, -0.009989849291741848, 0.01955297589302063, 0.010004924610257149, -0.022241827100515366, 0.002209611004218459, 0.035233624279499054, -0.0298154316842556, -0.020600570365786552, -0.003319230629131198, -0.005448689218610525, -0.019605986773967743, 0.026582514867186546, -0.037121132016181946, -0.028626559302210808, 0.008309385739266872, -0.033948030322790146, 0.005664797965437174, -0.015791328623890877, 0.0024362951517105103, -0.00686422735452652, 0.04962221160531044, 0.005277222953736782, -0.016267461702227592, 0.035307541489601135, 0.012884791940450668, -0.01829303428530693, -0.02376520074903965, -0.04323380067944527, 0.021408189088106155, -0.009172134101390839, -0.025550365447998047, 0.02863410674035549, -0.004423249047249556, 0.002646032255142927, 0.05645537003874779, 0.032658714801073074, 0.04580626264214516, -0.036688823252916336, -0.03944418206810951, -0.010825679637491703, -0.016733089461922646, -0.027872683480381966, 0.020312322303652763, 0.0462806299328804, -0.001960578141734004, 0.04602724686264992, -0.008094677701592445, -0.007618317846208811, -0.07796496152877808, 0.0010954189347103238, 0.004330548457801342, -0.021781357005238533, 0.019093690440058708, -0.03624468669295311, 0.014777068048715591, 0.012005501426756382, -0.020890220999717712, 0.02572910487651825, 0.010067771188914776, -0.011066803708672523, -0.029673125594854355, 0.019434913992881775, -0.010601656511425972, 0.016229383647441864, 0.01908431574702263, 0.01100101787596941, -0.03252992779016495, 0.03430160880088806, 0.022668035700917244, -0.0032382586505264044, -0.021127918735146523, 0.01866556890308857, -0.018393954262137413, -0.031242776662111282, 0.016831528395414352, -0.050625741481781006, -0.04157804325222969, 0.009083527140319347, -0.01386827602982521, 0.05572748929262161, 0.0028660858515650034, 0.045232970267534256, 0.018249474465847015, 0.010679918341338634, 0.017655039206147194, -0.014081419445574284, -0.0011547062313184142, 0.025486424565315247, -0.031277135014534, 0.074677973985672, -0.051259610801935196, 0.001566686318255961, 0.01781163364648819, -0.013158072717487812, -0.018829798325896263, 0.019961215555667877, -0.011926923878490925, 0.014562352560460567, -0.0414547361433506, -0.0389791838824749, 0.03711158037185669, 0.030452057719230652, -0.030352246016263962, -0.014696521684527397, 0.012570087797939777, 0.04280509799718857, 0.0015897151315584779, -0.033312179148197174, 0.01544728223234415, -0.007309305015951395, -0.049824755638837814, -0.0050217388197779655, -0.002521897666156292, 0.03186539560556412, -0.05431906133890152, -0.046307798475027084, 0.01197521947324276, 0.009241359308362007, -0.05489484593272209, -0.0012650034623220563, -0.03444652631878853, 0.0587305948138237, -0.05685436353087425, 0.02443883568048477, 0.012959078885614872, -0.00814556609839201, 0.006871607154607773, -0.05664054676890373, 0.049107279628515244, -0.035394057631492615, -0.05844029784202576, -0.042216770350933075, -0.016226593405008316, -0.019912036135792732, -0.005734684411436319, 0.09573843330144882, -0.013336487114429474, -0.004561235662549734, -0.020282847806811333, 0.023437250405550003, -0.028447609394788742, -0.03550615906715393, 0.03054284118115902, -0.020598029717803, 0.024078674614429474, -0.03283004090189934, -0.0006488412036560476, -0.029577217996120453, 0.005610793828964233, 0.040685348212718964, 0.008110045455396175, 0.032168544828891754, 0.0028873891569674015, -0.029291929677128792, -0.011160803027451038, -0.013442878611385822, -0.01340494304895401, 0.056325819343328476, -0.007790332660079002, 0.03807077184319496, -0.019036127254366875, -0.04293692484498024, -0.029424861073493958, 0.05067596584558487, -0.03141411021351814, 0.026213640347123146, 0.0018099789740517735, -0.0352928526699543, -0.004586821887642145, -0.06664860993623734, 0.016148647293448448, 0.028026502579450607, -0.07181950658559799, 0.00493469787761569, 0.01645389385521412, 0.030388621613383293, 0.030500030145049095, -0.020669974386692047, 0.017793286591768265, 0.026575762778520584, -0.03583915904164314, 0.030915582552552223, 0.02985111065208912, 0.010513568297028542, 0.0425838828086853, -0.022023068740963936, -0.01578674279153347, -0.03714975342154503, 0.04035162553191185, 0.021448509767651558, 0.022695627063512802, -0.005500376224517822, -0.019221261143684387, 0.029993748292326927, 0.013362854719161987, 0.011475766077637672, -0.028109420090913773, 0.028703663498163223, 0.05087662488222122, -0.04026937112212181, -0.03838943690061569, -0.05421019345521927, -0.026834316551685333, -0.03377115726470947, 0.014875346794724464, 0.027871668338775635, -0.01805444248020649, 0.03225930035114288, 0.04581398144364357, -0.007321424316614866, -0.008989247493445873, -0.0012871276121586561, 0.041749149560928345, 0.006392274051904678, -0.04803789407014847, -0.0037661457899957895, -0.026320772245526314, -0.022313278168439865, -0.026695597916841507, -0.02827802300453186, 0.03278582915663719, 0.041279349476099014, 0.01462508924305439, -0.03572407364845276, -0.00023356474412139505, 0.02293161302804947, 0.04288971424102783, -0.03316532447934151, -0.047277044504880905, -0.04460715875029564, 0.004658812191337347, 0.02279365435242653, -0.046913549304008484 ]
<p>I am looking for a thesis topic for my Applied Economics degree where I can use Data Mining/Machine Learning for some kind of prediction.</p> <p>Do you guys have any good ideas about what I could do?</p> <p>My first thought was credit scoring, but that seems a little boring considering the number of papers out there and the lack of available data.</p> <p>I don't want to write about stock market forecasting because that's what I did for my mathematician thesis.</p> <p>A good topic would be predicting some sort of an economical indicator but I don't really have any good ideas so far.</p> <p>Thank you!</p>
74,475
[ -0.036074649542570114, -0.04871568828821182, -0.017260754480957985, -0.0218826811760664, 0.010135202668607235, 0.00473666051402688, -0.005930939223617315, 0.01781379245221615, 0.037182074040174484, -0.02801513858139515, 0.01780308596789837, 0.04445967450737953, 0.022827070206403732, 0.03403550758957863, -0.007235387340188026, 0.013726008124649525, 0.001984234666451812, -0.014032398350536823, -0.009976973757147789, 0.008829924277961254, 0.012708841823041439, 0.018984977155923843, 0.009112964384257793, 0.036925144493579865, -0.04670169577002525, 0.024067973718047142, 0.00264682131819427, 0.0023591439239680767, 0.001396234380081296, 0.026323579251766205, -0.021445054560899734, 0.005226538050919771, 0.025647616013884544, 0.023418767377734184, 0.0029457982163876295, 0.0010499118361622095, -0.05715400353074074, -0.0194015521556139, -0.004375551827251911, 0.016165338456630707, -0.04142992943525314, -0.020233795046806335, 0.009760377928614616, 0.02545049972832203, -0.026797829195857048, -0.01134437508881092, 0.007523724343627691, -0.04737959802150726, 0.024499336257576942, -0.05955991521477699, 0.06021159887313843, -0.015465689823031425, 0.0033594875130802393, 0.01891165040433407, 0.0036303794477134943, -0.019598716869950294, 0.01212581992149353, 0.09959807246923447, -0.00037670493475161493, -0.047503117471933365, -0.008227363228797913, 0.022645778954029083, -0.009095151908695698, -0.047653257846832275, -0.03722330182790756, 0.05781690403819084, -0.02550923265516758, -0.021455267444252968, 0.040781307965517044, -0.019707465544342995, 0.013161169365048409, 0.016976818442344666, 0.0035010704305022955, 0.004777849651873112, 0.0006084605702199042, -0.025269409641623497, -0.023366102948784828, -0.0003946930228266865, 0.041611287742853165, 0.01217228826135397, 0.02551325410604477, 0.005014241673052311, 0.003641200950369239, 0.05814725160598755, -0.008689476177096367, -0.002273612655699253, 0.050150614231824875, -0.04185083135962486, 0.0029749206732958555, 0.02864551730453968, -0.005155044142156839, -0.017318440601229668, 0.0546078085899353, -0.022970447316765785, -0.05441700294613838, 0.025165580213069916, -0.024229060858488083, 0.03305581212043762, 0.019895099103450775, -0.022763635963201523, -0.011770923621952534, -0.00016303456504829228, -0.02086838148534298, 0.0783514678478241, -0.026681236922740936, -0.055805809795856476, -0.018725818023085594, 0.0013054198352620006, 0.010482613928616047, -0.01893635280430317, -0.016991788521409035, 0.03482145071029663, 0.036528974771499634, -0.039584241807460785, 0.03396935015916824, -0.004684582352638245, -0.0032734423875808716, -0.034672193229198456, -0.008906588889658451, 0.06895370781421661, 0.01508190855383873, -0.034290749579668045, 0.038101110607385635, 0.0028666360303759575, -0.04936758056282997, -0.0004829757090192288, 0.04225478693842888, -0.05093155801296234, -0.02949114330112934, 0.047873519361019135, -0.028138212859630585, 0.014027366414666176, 0.00020562969439197332, -0.04616319388151169, 0.0345134511590004, 0.008349139243364334, -0.06700412929058075, -0.04265505447983742, 0.03934678062796593, 0.013826566748321056, 0.017168845981359482, -0.0065205213613808155, -0.010975879617035389, 0.021884655579924583, 0.0696776807308197, 0.04092365503311157, 0.04922819510102272, 0.024042965844273567, 0.05663424730300903, 0.04671508073806763, -0.028516365215182304, -0.018898364156484604, 0.0011681087780743837, 0.0026681385934352875, 0.01195492036640644, -0.05383126437664032, -0.018445413559675217, 0.022335054352879524, -0.003625354031100869, -0.01858450658619404, 0.04720194637775421, -0.0078452592715621, -0.021451056003570557, -0.01850438304245472, -0.015319449827075005, -0.023869888857007027, 0.053697969764471054, 0.02411545254290104, 0.05367085710167885, -0.01738501526415348, 0.01347210630774498, 0.047441139817237854, 0.013715900480747223, 0.03416699171066284, 0.04352489113807678, 0.0012992381816729903, -0.017968839034438133, -0.005433789454400539, 0.014265756122767925, -0.028518659994006157, -0.017269132658839226, -0.05038640275597572, 0.006321988068521023, -0.019614433869719505, -0.003845266764983535, 0.048314619809389114, -0.014678100124001503, -0.018240343779325485, 0.02329784631729126, -0.033001530915498734, -0.044636256992816925, -0.056934427469968796, 0.008019845932722092, -0.05317879095673561, 0.00006832825602032244, 0.019600974395871162, -0.010802176780998707, 0.001341216848231852, -0.044802870601415634, -0.022410999983549118, -0.0149883097037673, 0.005022677592933178, 0.02779940888285637, -0.011336728930473328, 0.0141337551176548, 0.014993288554251194, -0.00028445341740734875, -0.011561867780983448, 0.027515437453985214, -0.04678476229310036, -0.04988594725728035, 0.0066345143131911755, -0.022400716319680214, 0.0264960378408432, -0.03623780608177185, 0.0049656108021736145, 0.04051921144127846, 0.0020864722318947315, -0.016493435949087143, 0.024829469621181488, -0.02893633022904396, 0.07971754670143127, 0.06354949623346329, 0.02251512184739113, 0.024030961096286774, 0.006289366167038679, 0.024336153641343117, 0.019306769594550133, -0.028031401336193085, 0.006227655801922083, -0.04532096907496452, 0.016480153426527977, 0.043573010712862015, 0.04991287738084793, -0.04486249387264252, 0.04362171143293381, 0.062431491911411285, 0.03732820972800255, 0.027526328340172768, 0.032294172793626785, -0.011159171350300312, 0.011533884331583977, 0.03665904700756073, 0.006060935091227293, -0.015011582523584366, -0.022767838090658188, 0.05811776965856552, 0.02693297155201435, 0.026771198958158493, -0.023566819727420807, -0.016740454360842705, 0.07106906920671463, -0.0022557631600648165, 0.02453761361539364, 0.00489399116486311, -0.044476255774497986, 0.028999613597989082, -0.0483926497399807, 0.010272180661559105, 0.011594385839998722, 0.01024805847555399, 0.01966153457760811, 0.036469291895627975, -0.036911897361278534, -0.010780463926494122, 0.04698871076107025, -0.017169775441288948, 0.04476327821612358, 0.025939801707863808, -0.044652778655290604, 0.033557452261447906, 0.03131523355841637, -0.031925905495882034, -0.03384624794125557, 0.024659432470798492, 0.02391524612903595, -0.0024067340418696404, -0.017227470874786377, 0.03715049475431442, -0.03859731927514076, 0.05710819736123085, -0.03680386394262314, 0.015673968940973282, 0.03245006874203682, -0.027196312323212624, -0.004976798314601183, 0.016153300181031227, -0.022171882912516594, 0.0743853971362114, 0.008964253589510918, 0.015891773626208305, 0.012601214461028576, -0.009148987010121346, -0.05104197561740875, -0.021163148805499077, -0.019124794751405716, 0.024517787620425224, -0.026154018938541412, -0.02756008878350258, 0.002179558854550123, -0.011695394292473793, -0.028285019099712372, 0.0025943296495825052, -0.019598616287112236, -0.014769386500120163, -0.007016971707344055, -0.009711586870253086, -0.012424725107848644, -0.020549245178699493, 0.03607463464140892, 0.014918952248990536, 0.005186659749597311, -0.013812767341732979, -0.06968113034963608, -0.06398636102676392, 0.03676038980484009, -0.00466421851888299, -0.011091239750385284, 0.010679574683308601, -0.010666340589523315, 0.05418511852622032, 0.001641837996430695, -0.031638018786907196, -0.02036990225315094, -0.04333570599555969, -0.025915315374732018, -0.029894258826971054, 0.004645513836294413, 0.013568495400249958, -0.0009284492116421461, 0.002149138366803527, 0.014718176797032356, 0.009273875504732132, 0.03412449359893799, -0.007559436839073896, 0.0000010296939763065893, 0.019952526316046715, -0.02481868676841259, -0.001296206028200686, 0.025037461891770363, -0.010490559972822666, -0.04058452323079109, 0.035900961607694626, 0.009811686351895332, 0.0038707146886736155, 0.0295124314725399, -0.048265114426612854, 0.009663705714046955, -0.03788153827190399, 0.008945041336119175, -0.05404281988739967, -0.003446941962465644, -0.0034097370225936174, -0.00989433191716671, -0.03031829185783863, -0.011380795389413834, -0.004031110089272261, -0.014575082808732986, 0.02454075962305069, 0.04339416325092316, 0.03289947658777237, -0.017514849081635475, 0.0051942868158221245, -0.05512632802128792, 0.001299503375776112, 0.013874306343495846, -0.01650100015103817, 0.02285497635602951, 0.03243739902973175, 0.033263880759477615, 0.0005311558488756418, 0.006689288653433323, -0.025495240464806557, 0.006093362811952829, -0.08582691103219986, 0.0008909491007216275, -0.038004547357559204, 0.09579064697027206, 0.012116266414523125, 0.021676357835531235, 0.007777828257530928, -0.0033561079762876034, 0.024499323219060898, 0.0058190831914544106, -0.07903952896595001, 0.0354260578751564, -0.03291352465748787, 0.027262086048722267, 0.01661718636751175, 0.006971096619963646, 0.03405618667602539, -0.02173183113336563, -0.002663055434823036, -0.010280516929924488, 0.03189945966005325, -0.04496753215789795, -0.03072800301015377, -0.012388440780341625, -0.03278227150440216, 0.004557856824249029, -0.03191683068871498, 0.003093876177445054, -0.0035667854826897383, 0.020529095083475113, 0.042565591633319855, -0.02752292901277542, -0.0577114000916481, -0.01515429187566042, 0.02280866540968418, -0.002832982921972871, 0.05813540890812874, 0.013323849998414516, -0.008392894640564919, -0.038573574274778366, 0.030975164845585823, 0.03514183312654495, 0.030746599659323692, -0.016979007050395012, 0.0016341337468475103, -0.013813835568726063, -0.05806659907102585, -0.030054114758968353, 0.012509430758655071, 0.0027631702832877636, 0.030899448320269585, -0.019058652222156525, 0.03282243013381958, 0.008693447336554527, -0.05335395038127899, -0.00555767584592104, 0.08739777654409409, 0.03774241730570793, 0.008717970922589302, -0.007014031056314707, -0.034872476011514664, -0.0007575841736979783, -0.004524690099060535, 0.0281829871237278, -0.005267467349767685, -0.014036414213478565, -0.012445338070392609, 0.004620269872248173, -0.02956879511475563, -0.024410171434283257, -0.019673485308885574, 0.017826329916715622, 0.08134934306144714, 0.0381120890378952, -0.0379488505423069, 0.022678297013044357, 0.061913713812828064, 0.05218205600976944, 0.04978801682591438, 0.008393796160817146, -0.12488506734371185, 0.019919242709875107, 0.051944706588983536, 0.045386072248220444, -0.06371474266052246, -0.037634748965501785, -0.05031921714544296, 0.005951976403594017, 0.03180386498570442, -0.04082152992486954, 0.03352084010839462, -0.0063988626934587955, -0.009133771993219852, -0.016111230477690697, 0.006047061178833246, -0.04116244986653328, -0.0007274942472577095, 0.014394919387996197, 0.0824076235294342, -0.019546696916222572, -0.04018743708729744, -0.07164442539215088, 0.0065198191441595554, 0.053084876388311386, 0.02092031016945839, 0.01869315840303898, -0.007534224074333906, -0.000037802830775035545, 0.030558623373508453, -0.031620755791664124, -0.07707742601633072, -0.0012771900510415435, 0.023573705926537514, -0.015553157776594162, 0.03926960378885269, -0.005062161944806576, -0.04124036058783531, 0.01583683304488659, -0.04197919741272926, -0.038460873067379, -0.014704365283250809, -0.0029753718990832567, -0.0038546775467693806, 0.019179506227374077, 0.022696876898407936, 0.022027352824807167, 0.051181990653276443, 0.015543757006525993, 0.010756554082036018, 0.00681710708886385, -0.011822707019746304, -0.026065820828080177, -0.02143240161240101, -0.01160125806927681, -0.03070034831762314, -0.03715626522898674, 0.019482025876641273, 0.003918444737792015, 0.0414692647755146, -0.06093686446547508, -0.004888372495770454, -0.015491744503378868, -0.004130766727030277, 0.000683971622493118, -0.051770467311143875, 0.013782128691673279, -0.0068924641236662865, -0.013599126599729061, 0.020253991708159447, 0.013873698189854622, -0.006444890517741442, -0.013110301457345486, 0.008373758755624294, -0.041276730597019196, 0.001689560478553176, -0.028015870600938797, -0.008889107033610344, 0.013877865858376026, 0.03764756768941879, 0.06107243895530701, -0.005780679173767567, 0.02321097068488598, 0.02445531077682972, -0.0527617372572422, -0.028620455414056778, 0.019623376429080963, 0.02564128302037716, 0.04580944776535034, -0.04254482686519623, 0.03099624626338482, -0.015195122919976711, -0.025327742099761963, -0.052230242639780045, -0.03174459934234619, 0.03275303170084953, 0.00769005948677659, -0.07020989060401917, -0.035729583352804184, 0.04158826172351837, 0.00016340399452019483, -0.02683895453810692, -0.019771452993154526, 0.03589644283056259, -0.021946484223008156, -0.029144078493118286, 0.006313042249530554, -0.029532616958022118, 0.08112458139657974, -0.0049047889187932014, -0.01484267134219408, 0.021839739754796028, -0.0007401787443086505, -0.0015119118615984917, -0.016263650730252266, -0.003164619905874133, -0.02692457288503647, 0.00950681697577238, -0.02731231227517128, 0.00420152023434639, 0.01626225747168064, -0.025064243003726006, 0.03722893074154854, 0.014031433500349522, 0.020564697682857513, -0.016527140513062477, -0.02374020591378212, 0.04367504268884659, -0.0026384005323052406, -0.02615455910563469, -0.004139574710279703, 0.0045598032884299755, 0.008122422732412815, -0.00939152855426073, -0.009693045169115067, 0.008090496994554996, -0.03742670640349388, 0.023266291245818138, 0.05469579994678497, 0.008979257196187973, -0.034371983259916306, 0.020135892555117607, -0.021488158032298088, 0.014288235455751419, 0.01976904645562172, 0.0173575971275568, -0.024239556863904, 0.03826535493135452, -0.07133623957633972, -0.0738108903169632, -0.0017954178620129824, -0.028660865500569344, 0.05026848986744881, -0.0017086623702198267, 0.05316605046391487, 0.04280724748969078, 0.014566288329660892, -0.012302813120186329, -0.031695686280727386, 0.009009268134832382, -0.00831523071974516, -0.006417522206902504, 0.02892494760453701, 0.008046598173677921, 0.01490105502307415, 0.023942865431308746, -0.0003979059692937881, 0.000783661613240838, 0.019682059064507484, 0.0481366366147995, 0.03962862119078636, 0.05015113577246666, -0.04391752928495407, -0.03853997960686684, 0.04886956512928009, -0.062492549419403076, 0.012668999843299389, -0.0342707596719265, 0.0053279707208275795, 0.05664702132344246, 0.04251141473650932, 0.0000841946603031829, -0.05110064521431923, -0.010736233554780483, -0.0492226742208004, 0.01239856705069542, 0.02546316385269165, -0.03541249781847, 0.061675235629081726, 0.020430786535143852, 0.03474867343902588, 0.020260866731405258, 0.011780356988310814, -0.007203566376119852, -0.06634271889925003, -0.014921115711331367, -0.05546540766954422, -0.03515100106596947, 0.034144461154937744, 0.027062254026532173, -0.01908065378665924, 0.04363255947828293, -0.02435748092830181, 0.03226354718208313, -0.0207071416079998, 0.012547416612505913, -0.008589647710323334, 0.07198640704154968, -0.01915060169994831, 0.02696933224797249, 0.005344809498637915, -0.005015449598431587, 0.1185530498623848, 0.040504951030015945, 0.03216461092233658, -0.056507743895053864, 0.03597710281610489, -0.0008521776762790978, 0.008545342832803726, -0.03445904701948166, -0.003924358636140823, -0.025424737483263016, 0.007849453017115593, 0.030804390087723732, 0.023879842832684517, -0.0021637147292494774, 0.01350979320704937, 0.060556940734386444, -0.03524605184793472, 0.002858645049855113, 0.009525079280138016, -0.021229419857263565, 0.0207228846848011, 0.0016695986269041896, -0.05198899656534195, 0.048605989664793015, -0.029475241899490356, -0.0687689483165741, -0.013318050652742386, -0.019842686131596565, 0.03521111607551575, -0.0032796983141452074, 0.02939036674797535, -0.008855135180056095, 0.020063545554876328, 0.02570740133523941, -0.017509570345282555, -0.004473322071135044, 0.00835965946316719, 0.0034175736363977194, 0.018096359446644783, -0.0037153104785829782, 0.03085433505475521, -0.025725826621055603, -0.00884875189512968, -0.0027057756669819355, -0.05816078931093216, -0.014066755771636963, -0.010240644216537476, 0.02986724302172661, 0.01138287503272295, -0.020853348076343536, -0.04215245321393013, 0.02881753258407116, 0.013809957541525364, -0.02232266589999199, -0.020420771092176437, -0.005730113014578819, 0.0070935869589447975, -0.043193623423576355, -0.01425175927579403, -0.016581185162067413, 0.017682500183582306, -0.016330312937498093, 0.023736411705613136, 0.007268134504556656, -0.026357250288128853, -0.026899224147200584, -0.026057861745357513, 0.02245214208960533, -0.019571678712964058, -0.035152867436409, -0.002621110761538148, 0.0005618606810458004, -0.020082250237464905, -0.0055536990985274315, -0.021511511877179146, -0.023075206205248833, -0.006799603346735239, -0.0012812153436243534, 0.012105859816074371, -0.03687673434615135, 0.011321437545120716, 0.03215418756008148, -0.04541017860174179, 0.01732526160776615, -0.058309171348810196, 0.02479279227554798, 0.015368280932307243, 0.022421635687351227, 0.04377416893839836, -0.013308480381965637, 0.017169566825032234, 0.0005163986352272332, 0.02301529049873352, -0.020976224914193153, 0.010927784256637096, -0.041549209505319595, -0.029368046671152115, 0.02322033978998661, -0.009085413999855518, 0.07455214112997055, 0.03514432534575462, -0.00549151748418808, -0.008059978485107422, -0.01720542088150978, -0.0444144532084465, 0.009565469808876514, 0.04101153090596199, -0.0465996153652668, -0.0175442174077034, -0.005672790110111237, 0.014177373610436916, -0.02807411551475525, -0.026716096326708794, 0.0035537618678063154, -0.013694651424884796, -0.017025157809257507, 0.000446653546532616, -0.022066941484808922, 0.05415119230747223, -0.005053217522799969, 0.07081043720245361, -0.05023999884724617, 0.004754096735268831, -0.04420356824994087, -0.031581755727529526, -0.015047476626932621, -0.06517808139324188, 0.003512223716825247, -0.00215774099342525, 0.009454154409468174, 0.005356036126613617, 0.03191627934575081, 0.04127757251262665, -0.002919638529419899, 0.011783071793615818, 0.030486447736620903, -0.03237810358405113, 0.0380876362323761, -0.038861747831106186, -0.015020792372524738, 0.02875828742980957, -0.04040949419140816, -0.013524128124117851, -0.011206015013158321, -0.040872495621442795, 0.03161230310797691, 0.004613726865500212, 0.0005023209378123283, -0.0018428971525281668, 0.02905508130788803, -0.008592595346271992, -0.008908918127417564, -0.02583387866616249, 0.007920813746750355, 0.009226270020008087, 0.030199550092220306, 0.0016439820174127817, -0.027508223429322243, -0.032474637031555176, -0.012640729546546936, 0.036327339708805084, 0.04098445922136307, -0.01553935557603836, 0.029552852734923363, 0.004342083353549242, 0.014383940026164055, 0.01107819378376007, 0.019661638885736465, 0.046055033802986145, 0.017644844949245453, -0.023591244593262672, 0.014707616530358791, -0.0025466065853834152, 0.003192397765815258, -0.07661531865596771, 0.004081943072378635, 0.050533492118120193, -0.05234220251441002, 0.038595423102378845, -0.03310753032565117, 0.005928155034780502, 0.03029060550034046, -0.0564742274582386, 0.037168197333812714, 0.012884474359452724, -0.021399229764938354, 0.004946315661072731, 0.000725794758182019, -0.009060652926564217, 0.036848731338977814, 0.019494889304041862, 0.029020804911851883, 0.0514979213476181, 0.0322142131626606, 0.014567267149686813, 0.0047653852961957455, 0.003921874798834324, 0.015715520828962326, -0.02690042369067669, -0.031064355745911598, 0.03144676610827446, -0.06660031527280807, -0.03000529110431671, 0.04256559908390045, 0.0008185610640794039, 0.01744111441075802, 0.043137867003679276, 0.0016167339636012912, -0.011181230656802654, 0.062083739787340164, 0.029690265655517578, 0.003492046380415559, -0.0015494985273107886, -0.014606901444494724, 0.04593438655138016, 0.036442793905735016, 0.029036061838269234, 0.03348483890295029, 0.006416710559278727, -0.015930544584989548, 0.0006706737913191319, 0.0002611230593174696, 0.001812625559978187, 0.004358871374279261, -0.00272405706346035, -0.0005267687956802547, -0.009564819745719433, -0.01518226321786642, 0.0228948425501585, -0.004445200320333242, -0.018824879080057144, 0.05843600258231163, 0.007873822934925556, 0.017920350655913353, -0.005475402344018221, 0.005749889649450779, -0.06552339345216751, 0.05213966593146324, -0.012420873157680035, -0.02710285410284996, -0.06203703582286835, -0.01789521984755993, 0.021780550479888916, 0.002748303348198533, -0.07070068269968033, -0.014358637854456902, -0.02422741986811161, 0.04478833079338074, -0.016191920265555382, 0.0202481672167778, 0.04953654110431671, -0.04304182901978493, 0.019653363153338432, -0.08048386126756668, 0.08149391412734985, 0.005341444164514542, 0.0003291216562502086, 0.00810806080698967, -0.01848207414150238, -0.03940027579665184, -0.03439568728208542, 0.05987207591533661, -0.05831645801663399, 0.01926678791642189, -0.02926107682287693, -0.039224572479724884, 0.00411967420950532, -0.044798415154218674, 0.05086905136704445, -0.01728334277868271, -0.018158743157982826, -0.02691643126308918, -0.01888214237987995, 0.003548160893842578, -0.017282377928495407, 0.02489195391535759, 0.03307359665632248, -0.011324248276650906, 0.011488724499940872, 0.01767546497285366, 0.025060029700398445, 0.014576802030205727, -0.012091509997844696, 0.03683774918317795, -0.006997330114245415, 0.01535697840154171, -0.029774684458971024, -0.037885233759880066, -0.06786087155342102, 0.044836945831775665, -0.02814970165491104, -0.031048929318785667, -0.03810751065611839, 0.016282612457871437, 0.005340906325727701, -0.0652688667178154, 0.017620090395212173, 0.030592335388064384, -0.004259567707777023, 0.009501748718321323, 0.0319090336561203, 0.014966840855777264, 0.018223203718662262, -0.03166746348142624, 0.015722019597887993, 0.005672905594110489, -0.019103648141026497, -0.014425615780055523, 0.023968303576111794, 0.05789376050233841, 0.021142445504665375, 0.019291557371616364, 0.04393267259001732, -0.0016560570802539587, 0.012595506384968758, 0.004214106593281031, 0.005953049287199974, -0.05726677179336548, -0.015696048736572266, 0.010383437387645245, -0.0030586402863264084, 0.03276822715997696, 0.03612883388996124, -0.009760892018675804, 0.07012239098548889, -0.021962080150842667, -0.01346294954419136, -0.020660577341914177, -0.022463001310825348, -0.023242274299263954, -0.015539325773715973, -0.025493444874882698, 0.07087431848049164, 0.01479498390108347, 0.017883574590086937, 0.029402095824480057, 0.021681129932403564, 0.04542865604162216, 0.004785540513694286, 0.032719023525714874, -0.010836713016033173, -0.01627194508910179, -0.028768077492713928, 0.012874262407422066, -0.037593450397253036, -0.025239139795303345, 0.04973659664392471, 0.02791302464902401, 0.05539986491203308, 0.02406420186161995, -0.013867632485926151, -0.008662713691592216, 0.02372463420033455, -0.07190968841314316, 0.031005937606096268, -0.06471529603004456, -0.00489404983818531, -0.01901162788271904, -0.02294185198843479 ]
<p>Suppose that there is a Cricket match scheduled on Sunday, this weekend. We know that people do not arrive at the stadium at constant rate. Few hours before scheduled start of the match, people start arriving at very slow rate. This rate then, in general, keeps on increasing. A large number of people arrive just before start of the match.</p> <p>I would like to know which distribution should I use to model this, so that I could tell <strong>What is the probability of arrival of x number of people in a particular time interval?</strong></p>
37,366
[ -0.03945651650428772, -0.06169385835528374, -0.004323694854974747, -0.012149157002568245, 0.03406396508216858, 0.016923604533076286, 0.03794869780540466, 0.006982437800616026, 0.007010295987129211, 0.004570030141621828, 0.04365651309490204, 0.06418786197900772, 0.03998759388923645, 0.027652548626065254, 0.0403788723051548, 0.0013293864903971553, 0.0014797141775488853, -0.0045147729106247425, -0.018836548551917076, -0.004934204276651144, -0.007127121556550264, -0.019010387361049652, 0.007667955011129379, -0.01701004058122635, -0.0647539272904396, 0.04072568565607071, 0.03896234557032585, -0.013370109722018242, -0.02141568250954151, 0.08054211735725403, -0.06240038573741913, -0.01988029107451439, 0.011026576161384583, 0.0776420310139656, 0.020957214757800102, 0.03203011304140091, -0.021394023671746254, -0.07187341153621674, -0.02264302596449852, -0.009580970741808414, -0.01125405915081501, -0.014286909252405167, 0.03379591554403305, 0.02119404450058937, -0.001001435797661543, 0.07064948976039886, 0.01277122087776661, -0.03595902398228645, 0.04293133690953255, -0.04022804647684097, 0.06326849013566971, -0.029258089140057564, 0.02536814659833908, 0.012322008609771729, -0.022609161213040352, -0.04394366219639778, 0.04353336617350578, 0.07686688005924225, 0.013673228211700916, -0.07560857385396957, 0.009118595160543919, -0.018111558631062508, -0.03679861128330231, -0.06570520251989365, 0.013521550223231316, 0.050688736140728, 0.003977637272328138, -0.025019606575369835, 0.04225003719329834, -0.00008634658297523856, 0.009141175076365471, -0.006850781384855509, 0.04876858368515968, -0.022563587874174118, 0.010890708304941654, 0.0019242973066866398, 0.0324622318148613, 0.009635637514293194, 0.029472591355443, 0.023114711046218872, -0.00900997780263424, 0.010337050072848797, 0.04531668871641159, 0.019930871203541756, 0.027219396084547043, -0.022429559379816055, 0.07681462913751602, -0.01451711542904377, 0.016388311982154846, 0.011901282705366611, -0.027312416583299637, 0.027387918904423714, 0.02786789834499359, -0.010785848833620548, -0.015479891560971737, 0.05013427138328552, -0.019670139998197556, 0.02947438508272171, 0.002198481932282448, -0.006818719673901796, -0.028346043080091476, -0.09855937212705612, 0.0020416525658220053, 0.03413606807589531, -0.021749120205640793, -0.022497404366731644, -0.06529265642166138, -0.03113420307636261, -0.0576167032122612, 0.013844289816915989, -0.035969480872154236, 0.041772544384002686, 0.012555536814033985, 0.004566837567836046, -0.02231060527265072, -0.0192149318754673, -0.013886514119803905, -0.01697905734181404, 0.04505156725645065, 0.03967902809381485, 0.030743777751922607, -0.030131250619888306, 0.014257103204727173, -0.003659853944554925, -0.038381095975637436, -0.005697346292436123, 0.003436804050579667, -0.0074089290574193, -0.024929847568273544, 0.056489862501621246, -0.012198558077216148, -0.010110740549862385, 0.04903937876224518, 0.031069230288267136, 0.0037793475203216076, -0.0019368764478713274, -0.07225093245506287, -0.06324604898691177, 0.009172349236905575, -0.02496911771595478, 0.017017580568790436, -0.04755882918834686, -0.0091969333589077, 0.053446222096681595, 0.036812860518693924, 0.005707133561372757, 0.05541347339749336, -0.0050766365602612495, -0.004570535384118557, -0.028971780091524124, -0.019621428102254868, -0.011239266023039818, -0.008772829547524452, 0.012142898514866829, 0.003852721769362688, -0.0858762264251709, 0.01944427564740181, 0.044969577342271805, 0.003709332086145878, -0.01543214451521635, 0.012749584391713142, -0.016279416158795357, -0.006978405173867941, -0.023244408890604973, 0.0330129973590374, -0.014649029821157455, 0.06280986964702606, 0.012722757644951344, 0.04120543971657753, 0.013039927929639816, 0.018369155004620552, 0.018569057807326317, 0.010589252226054668, 0.011077145114541054, -0.008526429533958435, -0.03179416060447693, 0.015012772753834724, 0.010166876018047333, 0.003070020815357566, 0.053458958864212036, 0.0026793424040079117, 0.012907570227980614, -0.018729370087385178, -0.005220041610300541, 0.021100934594869614, 0.024104002863168716, 0.03701712563633919, 0.0035372546408325434, 0.022652355954051018, -0.04305269196629524, -0.05798007547855377, -0.06909569352865219, 0.015636630356311798, -0.012961268424987793, -0.0031792910303920507, 0.023521047085523605, -0.013499355874955654, -0.009301439858973026, -0.004968073684722185, 0.04944168031215668, -0.0313522145152092, -0.01505517028272152, -0.0026368640828877687, -0.049781251698732376, -0.04723761975765228, 0.07570546120405197, 0.03031674213707447, 0.00750780338421464, 0.05024237185716629, -0.006982892286032438, -0.052754174917936325, -0.005580720026046038, -0.031915925443172455, 0.05467914417386055, -0.048431891947984695, 0.0072539751417934895, 0.008546319790184498, 0.028994064778089523, -0.02915874496102333, 0.005806058179587126, -0.06696242094039917, 0.03427642583847046, 0.07975725084543228, 0.0037869259249418974, -0.002526945201680064, 0.02415451407432556, -0.017160754650831223, 0.0013983402168378234, -0.021078133955597878, -0.03287617117166519, -0.0412641242146492, 0.014990478754043579, 0.045972976833581924, 0.0029304258059710264, -0.0004885103553533554, 0.029647838324308395, 0.06031101942062378, 0.02811443991959095, 0.025040728971362114, 0.03738267347216606, -0.02466089092195034, -0.007287922780960798, 0.028412429615855217, -0.0035512845497578382, 0.01938818022608757, 0.006067065522074699, 0.00907642487436533, -0.019159456714987755, 0.0017727563390508294, -0.004351158160716295, -0.03351644054055214, 0.002065781969577074, 0.037273768335580826, 0.031061718240380287, -0.028754867613315582, -0.0280582457780838, 0.03909797966480255, -0.01821398176252842, 0.0039839125238358974, 0.04841240867972374, 0.030626289546489716, 0.025272000581026077, 0.00286012957803905, -0.051769014447927475, 0.019757844507694244, 0.01598314754664898, -0.03626411408185959, -0.022790983319282532, 0.02015644870698452, -0.030146699398756027, -0.0019797817803919315, -0.008694810792803764, -0.04435477778315544, -0.02781740203499794, 0.0022746401373296976, 0.045575451105833054, 0.01898379623889923, -0.0060624429024755955, -0.01615310274064541, -0.0175294429063797, 0.011377787217497826, -0.01751679927110672, 0.01985033228993416, 0.003099598689004779, -0.05952467396855354, 0.0428260900080204, 0.038491103798151016, -0.05373569577932358, 0.01885230280458927, -0.007067270576953888, -0.02573470026254654, 0.053250670433044434, -0.01806240901350975, -0.04417954757809639, -0.015585451386868954, -0.010990286245942116, 0.023650793358683586, -0.02939836122095585, -0.03844806179404259, 0.061903681606054306, 0.007622076664119959, -0.021120484918355942, 0.02688584104180336, -0.07672959566116333, -0.044778842478990555, -0.03498317673802376, 0.0007204376743175089, 0.01228900533169508, 0.0035419019404798746, 0.01634872518479824, 0.013540736399590969, 0.011344139464199543, -0.011842751875519753, -0.0863218903541565, -0.056502748280763626, 0.028127562254667282, -0.0426655188202858, 0.043903663754463196, -0.0013696241658180952, -0.009671001695096493, 0.03596757352352142, 0.0791042372584343, 0.012626275420188904, -0.009566972963511944, 0.01139796432107687, -0.010263520292937756, -0.026363948360085487, 0.01929667219519615, 0.014816333539783955, -0.016504010185599327, 0.013666476123034954, 0.002479150891304016, 0.0003716744831763208, 0.04764033108949661, -0.03414694964885712, -0.02991204895079136, 0.03194179758429527, -0.01998922787606716, 0.06800229847431183, 0.023627828806638718, 0.017991123721003532, -0.03375212475657463, -0.008773310109972954, -0.06020192429423332, -0.010222376324236393, -0.012919296510517597, -0.020702172070741653, -0.014389017596840858, -0.02401932328939438, -0.03834725543856621, -0.03739988058805466, 0.05278947204351425, -0.0025271226186305285, -0.04156633839011192, 0.007168348412960768, 0.0168222114443779, 0.02983938530087471, -0.01788514293730259, 0.009134266525506973, 0.03457021713256836, 0.024456964805722237, -0.0406196191906929, -0.01551959291100502, -0.03453601151704788, -0.008544201962649822, 0.013396110385656357, -0.031596362590789795, 0.0037254844792187214, -0.011130740866065025, 0.017716871574521065, -0.0011510950280353427, -0.0030523808673024178, -0.04822058975696564, -0.027472293004393578, -0.05111341550946236, 0.003911799285560846, 0.001423447858542204, 0.027939340099692345, 0.04608144238591194, 0.04642307758331299, -0.02119199000298977, -0.03817074000835419, 0.03336023911833763, 0.005069366190582514, -0.082240030169487, 0.04510961472988129, -0.000022957834517001174, -0.008302277885377407, -0.0068772765807807446, -0.02991344779729843, 0.019718440249562263, -0.019632382318377495, -0.0005786401452496648, -0.03127545490860939, -0.027320552617311478, -0.04197431728243828, 0.01577446609735489, -0.0364629365503788, -0.026319537311792374, 0.007815754041075706, -0.0034155729226768017, -0.008574990555644035, 0.015930812805891037, 0.045947201550006866, 0.02367604896426201, -0.01340553443878889, -0.004450942389667034, 0.014913516119122505, -0.02996196784079075, 0.01960466243326664, 0.016771871596574783, 0.011632180772721767, 0.04354622960090637, -0.02734922431409359, 0.03361402824521065, 0.0011126225581392646, 0.03230811655521393, 0.05556866154074669, 0.00480502238497138, -0.009129160083830357, -0.0542503260076046, -0.03901175782084465, 0.020135978236794472, 0.02448793314397335, 0.002077530138194561, -0.030830521136522293, 0.035099565982818604, 0.007986869663000107, -0.022341230884194374, 0.0003096598666161299, 0.043004829436540604, 0.008330361917614937, -0.01826118305325508, -0.015497269108891487, -0.00008555762906325981, 0.01116988155990839, 0.04523489251732826, -0.0010998802026733756, 0.034094832837581635, 0.019523169845342636, 0.03086625598371029, 0.05391427502036095, 0.013677545823156834, -0.035688046365976334, 0.026328038424253464, 0.018123522400856018, 0.0012739473022520542, 0.029873071238398552, -0.027677182108163834, 0.02995036169886589, 0.0639377236366272, 0.013459214940667152, 0.00750343082472682, 0.012170839123427868, -0.08440877497196198, -0.045471400022506714, 0.03361983597278595, 0.016529416665434837, -0.01686183735728264, -0.017395570874214172, -0.056880515068769455, -0.026028722524642944, 0.011600201949477196, -0.007114544045180082, 0.022579414770007133, 0.01325290184468031, -0.005074366461485624, 0.00032410744461230934, -0.04014194756746292, -0.05999904125928879, 0.022978927940130234, -0.02595689333975315, 0.02444479987025261, -0.0012546087382361293, -0.018829073756933212, -0.044627707451581955, 0.017081350088119507, 0.029798807576298714, 0.0023443405516445637, -0.019800903275609016, -0.034008488059043884, 0.01832277700304985, -0.02526700496673584, -0.018729479983448982, -0.061598118394613266, 0.004680135753005743, 0.010279734618961811, 0.024779126048088074, 0.02437403053045273, -0.01784111000597477, -0.003704272909089923, -0.01197084505110979, 0.014812948182225227, 0.01465899683535099, 0.02445663884282112, -0.05242633819580078, 0.04269212856888771, 0.014567043632268906, 0.012657169252634048, 0.0007204576395452023, 0.004553147125989199, -0.02456929348409176, -0.006779449991881847, -0.0008945665904320776, -0.019052498042583466, -0.015942716971039772, -0.008590158075094223, -0.046737588942050934, -0.018902434036135674, -0.05443386361002922, 0.00923319160938263, -0.047113172709941864, 0.045401617884635925, -0.01770569197833538, -0.04041489213705063, -0.036638155579566956, 0.036914948374032974, 0.030977187678217888, 0.03319554775953293, -0.0797935277223587, -0.008677295409142971, 0.02128393016755581, -0.0009832228533923626, 0.031329549849033356, -0.030604062601923943, 0.03670832887291908, 0.015347165986895561, -0.014146555215120316, 0.0276687890291214, -0.023899899795651436, -0.06510557234287262, -0.0005646086065098643, -0.05035797134041786, 0.04780983552336693, -0.014875485561788082, 0.042504746466875076, 0.05333025008440018, -0.05179654061794281, -0.06665362417697906, 0.0370803028345108, -0.0037336992099881172, 0.04059665650129318, -0.005865365732461214, 0.024188701063394547, -0.010632428340613842, -0.011433182284235954, -0.07422837615013123, -0.042395710945129395, 0.03600555285811424, -0.018877213820815086, -0.05096570402383804, -0.0297708697617054, 0.029020490124821663, 0.0000690134838805534, -0.04007169231772423, 0.000254126382060349, 0.020536115393042564, -0.013007692992687225, 0.016868436709046364, -0.012725952081382275, 0.019226521253585815, 0.07112230360507965, 0.0414932556450367, 0.0179386455565691, 0.04923682659864426, -0.0012206252431496978, -0.00752325588837266, -0.013445848599076271, 0.03222006931900978, -0.021215341985225677, 0.009350021369755268, 0.001581809832714498, 0.043836161494255066, 0.059617653489112854, -0.012492011301219463, 0.0052865659818053246, 0.012912098318338394, 0.009127113968133926, -0.015335315838456154, -0.028296995908021927, 0.005960346199572086, 0.011876814067363739, -0.0021888038609176874, -0.054260846227407455, -0.010318055748939514, 0.009849030524492264, -0.01722847670316696, 0.02256484515964985, 0.00974112469702959, -0.026978811249136925, -0.0004127851570956409, 0.06702353060245514, -0.018731867894530296, -0.04395768791437149, -0.006069345865398645, 0.019543426111340523, 0.044306691735982895, -0.003867147257551551, -0.0345197468996048, 0.020156022161245346, 0.017270810902118683, -0.020304536446928978, 0.01911018043756485, -0.032164815813302994, -0.023857511579990387, 0.04045650735497475, 0.019061315804719925, 0.030470116063952446, 0.024197401478886604, 0.047205545008182526, -0.006560091860592365, -0.0045243133790791035, 0.0008518848917447031, -0.012904958799481392, 0.01752942055463791, 0.027589287608861923, -0.01799965463578701, 0.03272485360503197, 0.07179579883813858, 0.02495836280286312, 0.034049004316329956, 0.060110677033662796, -0.0005450043827295303, -0.04389858618378639, 0.025823598727583885, -0.01436023972928524, -0.03371608629822731, 0.010000767186284065, -0.021294277161359787, 0.06198710948228836, -0.04081260785460472, -0.010546227917075157, 0.051174648106098175, 0.026588117703795433, -0.026433207094669342, -0.04561465233564377, 0.019553562626242638, -0.058472126722335815, -0.018458425998687744, 0.018324406817555428, 0.004171314649283886, 0.04249158874154091, 0.040931060910224915, 0.014445474371314049, 0.000150877793203108, 0.043435417115688324, -0.010793211869895458, -0.05739152804017067, 0.015884416177868843, -0.022235698997974396, -0.05184287205338478, 0.02892235480248928, 0.015977265313267708, -0.018388619646430016, 0.01041420642286539, -0.043500278145074844, 0.009806127287447453, 0.0033106724731624126, 0.03791894391179085, -0.017316196113824844, 0.08872459083795547, 0.0022944544907659292, -0.016808366402983665, -0.008796718902885914, -0.01464935950934887, 0.12786005437374115, 0.047866273671388626, 0.014469403773546219, -0.05138450860977173, -0.0022980214562267065, 0.01699043996632099, -0.001487339730374515, -0.015944911167025566, 0.010717942379415035, 0.015305518172681332, 0.008117548190057278, 0.04317155480384827, 0.013178723864257336, -0.008951271884143353, -0.016732892021536827, 0.02104872278869152, -0.04422180727124214, -0.04178227111697197, -0.01665116660296917, 0.01055322214961052, 0.03199760243296623, 0.038530588150024414, -0.04850677028298378, 0.024264711886644363, 0.0031819106079638004, -0.0232677198946476, -0.016503866761922836, -0.0413164459168911, -0.004795976914465427, -0.012330221943557262, -0.03001442551612854, 0.02708541229367256, 0.018544524908065796, -0.037340205162763596, -0.01054287888109684, 0.011727732606232166, -0.011384972371160984, -0.033383559435606, 0.017410099506378174, 0.07496563345193863, 0.023573433980345726, -0.0035429298877716064, -0.005299275275319815, 0.02995910868048668, -0.03980598971247673, -0.0005345757235772908, -0.07694904506206512, 0.02021441049873829, 0.02604263462126255, 0.03975917771458626, 0.01832004263997078, -0.01265377551317215, 0.0023340536281466484, -0.028485413640737534, -0.012380380183458328, 0.009632734581828117, 0.0055084265768527985, -0.03568718582391739, -0.022649986669421196, -0.02882361225783825, 0.013378606177866459, 0.00900451559573412, -0.028771746903657913, 0.0390423908829689, -0.013857037760317326, -0.023102208971977234, -0.023755555972456932, 0.02908572554588318, -0.018828915432095528, -0.004039213992655277, 0.0028936672024428844, -0.004096325021237135, -0.042795855551958084, 0.01310733426362276, 0.0253901407122612, 0.0008950654300861061, -0.016138531267642975, 0.004055000841617584, -0.00486741540953517, -0.0331462137401104, -0.018037188798189163, 0.0034458378795534372, -0.020133668556809425, -0.005257179494947195, -0.021393710747361183, -0.004023391287773848, -0.012461763806641102, 0.05994086340069771, 0.034678615629673004, 0.042930372059345245, -0.003925490193068981, 0.08860968053340912, 0.0319589227437973, -0.023221174255013466, 0.012216223403811455, -0.04088665544986725, -0.02020731382071972, 0.00845248717814684, 0.004688784014433622, 0.07360328733921051, 0.022986076772212982, -0.01750720664858818, 0.013126573525369167, -0.025705289095640182, -0.011862503364682198, 0.031498022377491, -0.03592648729681969, -0.06339263170957565, 0.015369271859526634, 0.027726223692297935, 0.01727084442973137, -0.03473717346787453, -0.03549407050013542, 0.035942405462265015, -0.0070587219670414925, -0.008088776841759682, -0.037682775408029556, -0.027055324986577034, 0.03762086480855942, 0.020814405754208565, 0.009483728557825089, 0.0008152692462317646, 0.006504293065518141, 0.003539477940648794, 0.00955994427204132, -0.02268131449818611, -0.004792928230017424, -0.023745065554976463, 0.014611690305173397, 0.021048562601208687, -0.016070226207375526, 0.0034876754507422447, -0.016121478751301765, 0.00938240997493267, -0.013082356192171574, 0.03897542506456375, -0.020199231803417206, 0.04781556874513626, -0.0013307408662512898, -0.041977956891059875, 0.02476213313639164, -0.06905567646026611, -0.02995411865413189, 0.04123920574784279, 0.01766635663807392, 0.06755071133375168, -0.019658567383885384, -0.015111704356968403, 0.036921750754117966, -0.007533011958003044, -0.04472292959690094, -0.04400010406970978, -0.009549056179821491, 0.0028358888812363148, 0.043314795941114426, -0.007046809419989586, -0.031034311279654503, 0.031512897461652756, -0.013152731582522392, 0.02278558723628521, 0.010328996926546097, -0.021307973191142082, -0.00744926230981946, 0.008658001199364662, -0.016577672213315964, 0.0014449089067056775, -0.007435082923620939, -0.02695961855351925, 0.054562292993068695, 0.03054610639810562, -0.011676951311528683, 0.024959638714790344, -0.021534252911806107, -0.029854588210582733, -0.07939047366380692, -0.027169791981577873, 0.0439925491809845, 0.0024809869937598705, 0.05733407288789749, -0.0621844157576561, -0.01133313775062561, 0.05866391584277153, -0.042357418686151505, 0.028398510068655014, 0.02669273316860199, 0.014976657927036285, -0.03237901255488396, -0.003955692984163761, 0.00948520191013813, 0.028640737757086754, 0.033453330397605896, 0.0254500899463892, 0.04435985907912254, 0.014044596813619137, 0.023190034553408623, -0.02607445791363716, 0.008107024244964123, 0.02709212340414524, 0.009440068155527115, -0.03385673090815544, 0.0498928464949131, -0.05419066548347473, 0.008368602953851223, 0.038835227489471436, -0.026953071355819702, 0.016553599387407303, 0.025475267320871353, 0.011669505387544632, 0.020610643550753593, 0.05809693783521652, 0.055595893412828445, -0.02460753172636032, 0.03500518947839737, -0.0015834181103855371, 0.0012076394632458687, 0.03555113077163696, -0.03098073974251747, -0.030310453847050667, 0.030809829011559486, -0.025513781234622, 0.01633446104824543, 0.024733848869800568, 0.03350424766540527, -0.03330598399043083, 0.006040612235665321, -0.024686137214303017, 0.012172090820968151, -0.01972551830112934, -0.025329457595944405, -0.016590220853686333, 0.009077237918972969, 0.030943304300308228, 0.0011229391675442457, -0.030218008905649185, 0.007200812455266714, -0.038001012057065964, -0.0537460520863533, -0.014315237291157246, -0.016279052942991257, -0.00574005302041769, 0.00772450165823102, 0.012221470475196838, -0.019782496616244316, -0.006607597228139639, -0.004432177636772394, 0.000010787950486701448, -0.04204576835036278, 0.03312714397907257, -0.0077919731847941875, 0.0025914697907865047, 0.028403351083397865, 0.0013821943430230021, 0.027370022609829903, -0.08409199863672256, 0.04664513096213341, 0.009555145166814327, 0.002349038841202855, -0.03598974645137787, -0.013735792599618435, -0.03548892214894295, 0.007544729392975569, 0.06483709812164307, 0.00848677009344101, -0.044736430048942566, 0.008753838948905468, 0.019377166405320168, 0.025998147204518318, -0.04893536493182182, 0.013650688342750072, -0.029233340173959732, -0.02107330970466137, -0.01746537536382675, -0.009731201454997063, 0.025594301521778107, 0.009166974574327469, -0.02095775678753853, -0.0036850410979241133, 0.023139305412769318, 0.025639686733484268, -0.03125595301389694, 0.017827287316322327, -0.011738952249288559, 0.009735701605677605, 0.03477436676621437, -0.010525951161980629, 0.02460521087050438, 0.03352760523557663, -0.02914813905954361, -0.06007236987352371, 0.023748503997921944, -0.045469194650650024, -0.020693115890026093, 0.028674591332674026, 0.00045818701619282365, -0.02521541155874729, -0.05472376570105553, -0.018784575164318085, 0.03448442369699478, -0.021942805498838425, 0.025188960134983063, 0.010630572214722633, 0.018557477742433548, 0.07157120108604431, -0.027664370834827423, 0.03514274209737778, -0.018535954877734184, 0.01723410189151764, -0.015004144050180912, -0.008186981081962585, 0.018328342586755753, -0.01100319903343916, 0.029266441240906715, 0.03283020853996277, -0.015106510370969772, 0.022789673879742622, -0.0015233574667945504, 0.020449502393603325, -0.018293818458914757, 0.001573062501847744, 0.01167411170899868, 0.02043052949011326, 0.016475407406687737, 0.023903455585241318, -0.02753189578652382, 0.04722996801137924, -0.02753833495080471, 0.004540151916444302, -0.02454036846756935, -0.010482698678970337, -0.055411405861377716, -0.017283065244555473, 0.05760476365685463, -0.02594207040965557, 0.00664082495495677, 0.008412177674472332, 0.007605650462210178, 0.025556601583957672, 0.011651438660919666, -0.054470907896757126, 0.0034598344936966896, 0.02557334117591381, -0.00363495503552258, -0.027690041810274124, -0.0072934445925056934, 0.01947963796555996, -0.026042036712169647, 0.04572194814682007, 0.05900871008634567, 0.0014157801633700728, 0.009157096035778522, 0.010786623694002628, -0.00040295859798789024, 0.03629961237311363, -0.06002160534262657, -0.005434736143797636, -0.0554317943751812, 0.009329256601631641, -0.00020854684407822788, -0.035461705178022385 ]
<p>I fitted the Generalized Pareto distribution (GPD) using the <code>POT</code> package in <code>R</code>.</p> <p>The fitted object provides shape and scale parameters, but not the location parameter. I need it to evaluate the quantile function with <code>qgpd(p, loc = 0, scale = 1, shape = 0, lower.tail = TRUE, lambda = 0)</code>.</p> <p>I am sure this is very basic question (maybe it is mean value, but from which values - all, or only that which are bigger than threshold?) but I am begginer in this area and help is highly appreciated.</p>
74,476
[ 0.008533447049558163, -0.02215508371591568, 0.025102272629737854, 0.01931406930088997, 0.03515367954969406, 0.007384210824966431, -0.017144842073321342, -0.01646575890481472, 0.009466740302741528, -0.05240333825349808, 0.03216061368584633, 0.034016408026218414, 0.05455050989985466, -0.002273987978696823, 0.04171564429998398, 0.01576620526611805, -0.03540591150522232, -0.004815712105482817, 0.012814590707421303, -0.04408099874854088, 0.006215579342097044, 0.02121572569012642, -0.01306708250194788, -0.025960169732570648, 0.016308313235640526, 0.024203406646847725, 0.0013175247004255652, 0.0010194930946454406, 0.017324455082416534, 0.07360853254795074, -0.03469867259263992, -0.05016447603702545, 0.019943298771977425, 0.038979124277830124, -0.002233878243714571, 0.015448064543306828, -0.03184451907873154, -0.045474547892808914, -0.03612198308110237, -0.003298236522823572, -0.011610693298280239, -0.017490524798631668, 0.04737051576375961, 0.0018181793857365847, 0.0213062334805727, 0.02561580389738083, 0.02931864932179451, -0.021772364154458046, 0.036395393311977386, -0.0477256253361702, 0.03603304922580719, 0.004830579739063978, 0.016043009236454964, 0.03643219918012619, -0.028051557019352913, 0.003957012202590704, 0.04721829667687416, 0.06233039125800133, -0.05782053992152214, -0.07566814124584198, -0.014552104286849499, -0.0249152984470129, 0.01754394918680191, -0.02225944586098194, -0.023541973903775215, -0.00932482723146677, -0.02552984282374382, -0.03456992655992508, -0.01862715184688568, 0.011605660431087017, -0.00046332020428963006, 0.016570717096328735, 0.0278876144438982, 0.018892014399170876, 0.040076032280921936, -0.003362164832651615, 0.010087128728628159, 0.014844279736280441, 0.04254094883799553, -0.007393043488264084, 0.007591341622173786, 0.0036456906236708164, -0.007844734936952591, 0.0220008734613657, 0.010481518693268299, 0.03643859550356865, 0.05451289936900139, -0.031148310750722885, 0.0048065343871712685, 0.023789778351783752, -0.03609238564968109, 0.008736437186598778, 0.04089973494410515, 0.017054542899131775, -0.02726970799267292, 0.007873415015637875, 0.027836788445711136, 0.030673734843730927, -0.008098333142697811, -0.023257967084646225, 0.005717955995351076, -0.04713660851120949, -0.010976891964673996, 0.043901070952415466, -0.013643394224345684, -0.0032118994276970625, -0.023492811247706413, -0.027706805616617203, -0.007914435118436813, 0.007288769353181124, 0.005946245044469833, 0.023970670998096466, 0.01932971179485321, -0.0420481376349926, 0.008532324805855751, -0.020788930356502533, -0.020565461367368698, -0.020775066688656807, 0.05697615072131157, 0.026416338980197906, 0.03469405695796013, -0.019549468532204628, 0.010020570829510689, -0.026391874998807907, -0.026290765032172203, 0.005055248737335205, 0.033577125519514084, -0.02206581085920334, -0.041443727910518646, 0.053388562053442, 0.010168766602873802, 0.012876355089247227, -0.005907288286834955, 0.00557837076485157, 0.04406263306736946, -0.025680245831608772, -0.0558650828897953, -0.0331277959048748, 0.021275566890835762, -0.005265865009278059, 0.030367843806743622, -0.03963864594697952, -0.017737561836838722, 0.031666580587625504, 0.03154456242918968, -0.0037727130111306906, -0.018291369080543518, 0.012463868595659733, -0.004593919962644577, -0.008734408766031265, -0.03427315503358841, 0.03147801384329796, -0.019392870366573334, -0.040154341608285904, 0.00864490121603012, -0.06265497207641602, -0.018444085493683815, 0.012135337106883526, 0.00047785943024791777, -0.015585941262543201, 0.0833485871553421, 0.010309354402124882, -0.023870017379522324, -0.02926851250231266, -0.014507991261780262, -0.035597190260887146, 0.07706135511398315, -0.006561681628227234, 0.027608901262283325, 0.005460487678647041, 0.0072861784137785435, -0.006822558119893074, 0.015163486823439598, 0.053418200463056564, 0.031580619513988495, -0.02650471217930317, -0.005125158932060003, -0.05165274813771248, 0.030345849692821503, 0.00039549783105030656, -0.05914638563990593, 0.005120137240737677, -0.012691257521510124, 0.0030685788951814175, 0.022190142422914505, 0.020508350804448128, -0.02364557795226574, -0.01116289384663105, 0.009040000848472118, -0.04243037477135658, -0.006240283604711294, -0.03244557976722717, -0.023908711969852448, 0.01886235736310482, -0.01668466627597809, -0.012525747530162334, -0.011072050780057907, 0.020159872248768806, 0.014886417426168919, 0.009960439056158066, -0.023267505690455437, -0.006290108431130648, 0.03779304400086403, -0.057308170944452286, -0.03434294834733009, 0.06070239469408989, 0.03936661779880524, -0.02567910961806774, 0.04580594599246979, -0.04635150730609894, -0.008715439587831497, 0.02277733013033867, -0.009441303089261055, 0.020432395860552788, -0.02629985474050045, -0.012673272751271725, 0.006509183906018734, 0.023141589015722275, 0.016461903229355812, 0.01434645801782608, -0.038990553468465805, 0.056427571922540665, 0.08743328601121902, 0.028089117258787155, -0.0010155345080420375, -0.042807430028915405, -0.0004332858952693641, 0.027025319635868073, -0.026594027876853943, -0.032556142657995224, -0.04148510470986366, -0.027984419837594032, 0.03948928415775299, -0.024437159299850464, -0.0339650884270668, -0.014185773208737373, 0.0717969760298729, -0.02302536554634571, 0.05036376789212227, 0.004982652608305216, -0.005008339881896973, 0.03318661451339722, 0.020456399768590927, 0.02561989612877369, 0.01967717707157135, -0.006444762460887432, 0.04966442659497261, 0.025666173547506332, 0.06406983733177185, -0.0000807738397270441, -0.0018637011526152492, 0.07289838790893555, 0.011966180056333542, 0.022454315796494484, -0.031108707189559937, 0.004568975418806076, 0.04759639874100685, -0.02609359472990036, 0.002482056152075529, 0.022380869835615158, 0.01221431978046894, -0.013932539150118828, 0.011784746311604977, -0.024835046380758286, 0.01324634812772274, 0.06622002273797989, -0.030377866700291634, 0.00502327224239707, 0.007328927516937256, -0.03785259276628494, 0.020232874900102615, -0.01900671236217022, -0.01150345429778099, -0.030199700966477394, 0.04237388074398041, 0.058919187635183334, 0.03934631124138832, -0.0060993158258497715, -0.04714149609208107, -0.05016680061817169, -0.01583945006132126, 0.009584172628819942, 0.015939414501190186, 0.027440955862402916, -0.06045093014836311, -0.023632729426026344, -0.03695333003997803, -0.041720472276210785, 0.003071159590035677, -0.0063659921288490295, -0.03318021818995476, 0.0011909275781363249, 0.0037575436290353537, -0.0026883655227720737, 0.02822132036089897, -0.05179029330611229, 0.007402107585221529, -0.03704342991113663, 0.008936918340623379, 0.039120230823755264, 0.00309005961753428, -0.01316706370562315, 0.01627613976597786, -0.021830489858984947, -0.01039355993270874, -0.03122144564986229, 0.031789153814315796, 0.028399072587490082, 0.024087173864245415, 0.05056742951273918, 0.03505367413163185, -0.002396845491603017, 0.0028640434611588717, -0.06679592281579971, -0.06007184460759163, 0.026173561811447144, -0.002360026817768812, 0.047316234558820724, -0.03212633728981018, -0.021466707810759544, 0.08048251271247864, 0.026831304654479027, -0.03381725400686264, -0.03109431266784668, 0.021031521260738373, -0.0015140518080443144, -0.015053904615342617, 0.020192930474877357, 0.020009618252515793, 0.02207505702972412, 0.0471288338303566, 0.007241465151309967, 0.04599512368440628, 0.046210188418626785, 0.0037734806537628174, -0.052823811769485474, 0.019359435886144638, 0.013833699747920036, -0.029295925050973892, 0.036931995302438736, 0.024160755798220634, -0.02527603507041931, 0.018495609983801842, -0.016755729913711548, 0.016608480364084244, 0.009346449747681618, -0.01356231514364481, 0.023275062441825867, 0.00004134058690397069, -0.007100960239768028, -0.035056065768003464, 0.05538381636142731, 0.006940259598195553, -0.05614982545375824, 0.009192009456455708, 0.004904832690954208, 0.07823575288057327, -0.03206539899110794, 0.013223160058259964, 0.034998416900634766, 0.004786165431141853, -0.03497760742902756, 0.004254148807376623, 0.03260042518377304, -0.03662923723459244, -0.011478650383651257, -0.0013503989903256297, -0.013111820444464684, 0.022736547514796257, 0.026390159502625465, 0.034001387655735016, 0.05990169942378998, 0.01832820661365986, 0.008939286693930626, -0.04991762712597847, 0.008361521176993847, 0.0022707779426127672, 0.04358329996466637, 0.010267914272844791, 0.017478134483098984, 0.03836619853973389, -0.02826675958931446, -0.026336494833230972, -0.004124535247683525, -0.058152247220277786, 0.036996420472860336, 0.00463402783498168, -0.002346542663872242, -0.030376270413398743, -0.05519551411271095, 0.0061184437945485115, -0.0018681178335100412, 0.02411898784339428, 0.02246200479567051, -0.01297827623784542, -0.010950637981295586, -0.00479876296594739, -0.019932754337787628, -0.002080395584926009, 0.0009885096224024892, 0.018169019371271133, -0.008552752435207367, -0.00969727337360382, 0.0336221419274807, 0.041627444326877594, -0.0018491637893021107, -0.010156933218240738, 0.010667514987289906, 0.005178687162697315, -0.0003409627825021744, 0.03874977305531502, 0.014449299313127995, 0.04216455668210983, -0.004001253750175238, 0.051862552762031555, 0.003001411911100149, 0.08750851452350616, 0.045458387583494186, -0.02080254815518856, 0.006706696003675461, -0.03880363702774048, 0.0034443195909261703, 0.01265855971723795, -0.008166271261870861, -0.021714556962251663, -0.03716302290558815, 0.04830008000135422, -0.025860246270895004, -0.06474903225898743, 0.010914215818047523, 0.08138352632522583, 0.002981500467285514, 0.00008450189488939941, -0.037210021167993546, -0.02022469975054264, -0.027880940586328506, -0.028246525675058365, 0.01948990859091282, 0.004509021062403917, -0.013360239565372467, -0.008081800304353237, 0.028810901567339897, 0.001752603449858725, -0.05373257398605347, -0.059260595589876175, 0.04711436107754707, 0.03207317739725113, -0.029784906655550003, -0.01892060786485672, 0.012381544336676598, 0.03684408590197563, 0.0033588099759072065, -0.015842365100979805, -0.009649090468883514, -0.09908448159694672, 0.004969165660440922, 0.08970299363136292, 0.042359400540590286, 0.007780570536851883, -0.02429775521159172, -0.07146985083818436, -0.0012871610233560205, 0.014096999540925026, -0.05542302504181862, 0.007827295921742916, 0.011440934613347054, 0.03725885599851608, 0.0058884224854409695, -0.009114736691117287, -0.03452906012535095, -0.0334305576980114, -0.05910239368677139, -0.0024759392254054546, -0.0675329640507698, -0.007841886952519417, -0.023922674357891083, 0.015239603817462921, -0.00763335544615984, 0.01248969230800867, -0.0007210023468360305, -0.014923302456736565, 0.017662791535258293, 0.0049980334006249905, 0.00606430834159255, -0.044245727360248566, 0.011023484170436859, -0.013822179287672043, 0.036024946719408035, 0.06898731738328934, 0.007592919748276472, -0.008584360592067242, 0.012768223881721497, 0.03454854339361191, -0.010845302604138851, -0.03182457014918327, -0.011261239647865295, 0.053790319710969925, 0.021814247593283653, -0.011790684424340725, 0.030192269012331963, 0.007534113712608814, -0.00979447178542614, -0.04258466884493828, -0.05809817835688591, -0.00851789116859436, 0.005443745292723179, -0.024447644129395485, -0.057448551058769226, -0.003951517399400473, -0.013921125791966915, 0.010179858654737473, 0.0031391701195389032, 0.02500033564865589, -0.03107495605945587, -0.016228394582867622, -0.002480256138369441, 0.034470781683921814, 0.010327759198844433, 0.004420507233589888, 0.031759005039930344, 0.011683115735650063, 0.02036331780254841, -0.00570856174454093, 0.02136993035674095, -0.011570346541702747, 0.00611367542296648, 0.011292061768472195, -0.018619267269968987, 0.06572093814611435, -0.0030213783029466867, -0.021256519481539726, 0.005064407829195261, -0.045340653508901596, 0.01030748151242733, -0.019434664398431778, 0.0024235944729298353, 0.0402696318924427, -0.04754819720983505, -0.018864421173930168, -0.03562348335981369, 0.013669583946466446, 0.027712585404515266, -0.026137342676520348, 0.05176841467618942, -0.0011230797972530127, 0.054522402584552765, -0.0650583952665329, -0.028020158410072327, 0.025975806638598442, 0.002094714203849435, -0.04262112081050873, -0.017716191709041595, 0.013594266027212143, -0.016224956139922142, -0.02656453289091587, 0.01444984320551157, 0.016780495643615723, -0.03246884420514107, -0.010940060019493103, -0.03973029926419258, 0.03658580780029297, 0.05551948770880699, -0.0021028437186032534, 0.01557377353310585, 0.04369514435529709, 0.010486648418009281, -0.027005767449736595, 0.004656554199755192, 0.0138253103941679, -0.05400864779949188, 0.008337453939020634, -0.022860199213027954, -0.008388889953494072, -0.00491290120407939, 0.021135147660970688, -0.033804479986429214, -0.006291375495493412, 0.0161893367767334, 0.025288064032793045, -0.04582633450627327, -0.02770497091114521, -0.00928567722439766, -0.020749231800436974, -0.032029226422309875, -0.023141276091337204, -0.0265866257250309, -0.005235524848103523, 0.03399531915783882, -0.030026106163859367, -0.00853009894490242, 0.025493619963526726, 0.12466631829738617, 0.009529243223369122, 0.022256257012486458, -0.01006039883941412, -0.044817231595516205, 0.05287865921854973, 0.019697614014148712, -0.055008918046951294, 0.004783367272466421, 0.04601261764764786, -0.02325916849076748, 0.020136425271630287, -0.06081971153616905, -0.02927219308912754, 0.049573056399822235, 0.019186634570360184, 0.06093849986791611, 0.011121531017124653, -0.018168266862630844, -0.04049326851963997, -0.028628427535295486, -0.03481965512037277, -0.0025387583300471306, 0.03671610355377197, 0.04764533415436745, 0.011873094365000725, -0.000326346984365955, 0.013498225249350071, 0.009560737758874893, -0.01725631393492222, 0.06000316143035889, 0.013129454106092453, 0.03264005109667778, -0.010300567373633385, -0.01959933526813984, -0.0033767896238714457, 0.032844264060258865, -0.029454518109560013, 0.03794516250491142, -0.05779628828167915, -0.019646093249320984, 0.021747728809714317, 0.002174562308937311, -0.03244407847523689, -0.016488799825310707, -0.010931337252259254, -0.03743620216846466, 0.0033476343378424644, 0.044711098074913025, -0.03888801857829094, -0.0024534794501960278, 0.020461799576878548, 0.0238882377743721, -0.004154247231781483, -0.001136935199610889, -0.03976970165967941, -0.0450245700776577, -0.0011299961479380727, -0.005463363137096167, -0.06517461687326431, 0.016475962474942207, -0.0004935299511998892, 0.010390305891633034, 0.025901269167661667, -0.05565612018108368, 0.014608796685934067, -0.0027424772270023823, 0.03835047036409378, 0.02082251012325287, 0.1285305768251419, -0.006143991835415363, -0.007481914013624191, 0.01136942207813263, -0.024226278066635132, 0.13584309816360474, 0.0863085612654686, -0.025301320478320122, -0.05884534493088722, 0.010323554277420044, -0.004115835763514042, 0.011517122387886047, -0.000060027148720109835, 0.0015547145158052444, -0.0018680131761357188, -0.006977397948503494, 0.09604515135288239, 0.03065560944378376, -0.01556865032762289, 0.01130333449691534, 0.04321444779634476, -0.02067587897181511, -0.06385849416255951, 0.011855768039822578, 0.04148024693131447, -0.040565721690654755, -0.0129185626283288, -0.03615612909197807, 0.03226267546415329, -0.036990560591220856, -0.01627044379711151, -0.07421185076236725, -0.02524002455174923, -0.03979533165693283, 0.014390726573765278, 0.0006770448526367545, -0.013624664396047592, -0.02015792764723301, 0.011993837542831898, 0.0039400323294103146, -0.0010238928953185678, -0.002455296227708459, -0.007407560013234615, -0.002827640390023589, 0.036765504628419876, -0.0028219979722052813, -0.01735479198396206, -0.021564006805419922, 0.019036250188946724, -0.040243297815322876, -0.032698098570108414, -0.03812474384903908, 0.028374649584293365, 0.00904337503015995, -0.005406586453318596, 0.014494079165160656, 0.012028960511088371, -0.03698451444506645, -0.05552155524492264, -0.025149349123239517, 0.012300390750169754, 0.03500842675566673, -0.0186291690915823, -0.0289925504475832, -0.009917957708239555, 0.04196298494935036, -0.008264627307653427, 0.029829243198037148, 0.016583528369665146, -0.01378602720797062, 0.012197725474834442, -0.04326438158750534, 0.07990949600934982, -0.003285418264567852, -0.0128915561363101, 0.01625966653227806, -0.03262852132320404, -0.011988002806901932, -0.0015592265408486128, -0.004012574907392263, -0.018313458189368248, 0.028308674693107605, 0.01759687066078186, 0.014841239899396896, -0.011058087460696697, -0.05036420375108719, 0.04218822717666626, -0.04720982909202576, -0.02091418020427227, -0.029606221243739128, -0.006929364986717701, 0.02984103374183178, 0.05681150034070015, 0.010322810150682926, 0.011783575639128685, -0.0006319170352071524, 0.04282384738326073, 0.022627465426921844, -0.06262126564979553, -0.025215232744812965, 0.02501630038022995, -0.05578726902604103, 0.005568508990108967, -0.02394065447151661, 0.06238606572151184, 0.01627015881240368, 0.007543128915131092, 0.016802625730633736, 0.020589079707860947, -0.03792177885770798, 0.02032642625272274, 0.014099781401455402, -0.027377011254429817, 0.023003604263067245, -0.04412148520350456, -0.005737681873142719, -0.031748492270708084, -0.011477761901915073, -0.0591973178088665, -0.05482189729809761, 0.027203084900975227, 0.013842551968991756, -0.026985999196767807, 0.013661452569067478, -0.026992447674274445, -0.017069878056645393, -0.001955496147274971, -0.011250470764935017, -0.0036393587943166494, -0.024639276787638664, -0.0201291274279356, -0.029259543865919113, -0.016540242359042168, -0.019130084663629532, -0.04557853937149048, -0.020236141979694366, 0.03319720923900604, 0.03420714661478996, 0.011753596365451813, 0.02613956294953823, 0.03380855172872543, -0.010098469443619251, 0.05452454835176468, -0.008602304384112358, -0.0017653786344453692, 0.049708858132362366, -0.06119587644934654, -0.009162694215774536, 0.045701764523983, 0.027472902089357376, 0.05135399103164673, 0.018986934795975685, 0.0029132342897355556, -0.029480302706360817, 0.048580192029476166, 0.017637507990002632, -0.001987939001992345, 0.022512199357151985, -0.014766053296625614, 0.004058948252350092, -0.016231607645750046, -0.038737356662750244, 0.011403162032365799, 0.006322401575744152, -0.018860265612602234, 0.03550416976213455, -0.004738923627883196, 0.016563059762120247, 0.020412888377904892, -0.033173706382513046, -0.039299700409173965, 0.03312407433986664, 0.0005500488914549351, 0.001806361135095358, 0.06909003853797913, -0.026194335892796516, 0.02505391277372837, -0.054344478994607925, -0.033074963837862015, -0.08669853955507278, -0.01291497889906168, 0.03057570569217205, -0.010877293534576893, 0.015379396267235279, -0.06676187366247177, 0.005060367286205292, 0.04087455943226814, -0.0422176867723465, 0.048437707126140594, 0.0023002203088253736, 0.002322512213140726, -0.007503671571612358, -0.006669292692095041, 0.001811931491829455, 0.03862026706337929, 0.04683692380785942, 0.0432296022772789, 0.06176866963505745, -0.021091965958476067, 0.025994930416345596, -0.03755154460668564, -0.030865782871842384, 0.04244925454258919, -0.005883310921490192, -0.05074208229780197, 0.029210401698946953, -0.03266042470932007, -0.011286484077572823, 0.017987055703997612, -0.04933588206768036, -0.0014859117800369859, 0.006132987327873707, 0.03339953348040581, 0.010922439396381378, 0.07141566276550293, 0.026258207857608795, 0.024484237655997276, -0.011518090032041073, 0.01300470158457756, 0.020886356011033058, 0.026171421632170677, -0.04164088889956474, 0.031172508373856544, 0.01011746097356081, -0.0018149460665881634, -0.02343466505408287, 0.01303834281861782, -0.03658966347575188, -0.022368736565113068, -0.007041357457637787, 0.012752347625792027, 0.026162900030612946, -0.04592183232307434, 0.02210823819041252, -0.04510810971260071, 0.02258308045566082, 0.05010537803173065, 0.012835178524255753, -0.019619522616267204, 0.0012517161667346954, -0.022500379011034966, -0.05543360486626625, 0.007472096476703882, -0.007885998114943504, -0.04475487768650055, -0.032271090894937515, -0.03573903813958168, -0.007770891301333904, 0.00870759878307581, 0.01135697029531002, -0.00983236450701952, 0.00896539818495512, -0.0092538520693779, -0.03813081234693527, -0.006842259783297777, 0.006456904578953981, 0.02820710651576519, 0.022360485047101974, -0.08110453933477402, 0.054604046046733856, 0.01805867627263069, -0.04782474413514137, -0.007750330492854118, -0.01959047093987465, -0.019994623959064484, -0.0009291001479141414, 0.011315016075968742, 0.012392712756991386, -0.010065972805023193, -0.010872012004256248, 0.020224416628479958, 0.012616291642189026, -0.05475052818655968, 0.026490794494748116, -0.008549360558390617, -0.023861361667513847, -0.00013461157504934818, -0.01137403305619955, 0.02983022667467594, 0.05710434168577194, 0.03315120190382004, -0.009298376739025116, 0.047107383608818054, -0.000542420253623277, -0.023607168346643448, 0.05783570930361748, 0.010433799587190151, 0.005968454293906689, 0.06746985763311386, 0.011569684371352196, -0.02619643695652485, 0.03521253913640976, 0.022015204653143883, -0.025288313627243042, 0.020995596423745155, -0.00002478158421581611, -0.023164190351963043, 0.017767077311873436, 0.017618335783481598, 0.01725762151181698, -0.05872981622815132, -0.009597662836313248, 0.006169230677187443, -0.050112638622522354, -0.019789790734648705, 0.028391506522893906, 0.02683536894619465, 0.043669939041137695, -0.01826118491590023, -0.008029550313949585, -0.01651724800467491, -0.03459034115076065, 0.03263887017965317, 0.03640346601605415, 0.008180920034646988, 0.030225664377212524, 0.03537074849009514, 0.020539311692118645, -0.021731985732913017, 0.0026488080620765686, -0.02133876271545887, 0.037670377641916275, -0.012615053914487362, -0.02424439787864685, -0.002975247334688902, 0.012116148136556149, 0.025925207883119583, -0.005900926422327757, -0.01527505461126566, 0.02034742757678032, 0.034625500440597534, -0.016212262213230133, -0.04032839834690094, -0.006849686149507761, -0.03708755970001221, 0.035044629126787186, 0.0005395128391683102, 0.034581076353788376, -0.00196375441737473, 0.03475375100970268, 0.02631487138569355, 0.03099435567855835, -0.005446196533739567, -0.02706042304635048, 0.024963488802313805, 0.00186681910417974, -0.01649673469364643, -0.030393989756703377, -0.013006320223212242, -0.007254224270582199, -0.0044748359359800816, 0.01603921875357628, 0.026212092489004135, 0.00721025699749589, -0.028624393045902252, -0.003246777458116412, -0.009030189365148544, 0.04264293238520622, -0.07847267389297485, -0.004429730121046305, -0.05306681990623474, -0.024454530328512192, -0.012856652028858662, -0.023292673751711845 ]
<p>I have 4 latent variables each with 3-7 indicators. I created a composite for each variable by summing the data and then mean-centering (variables have some collinearity issues, highly related). Thus I have Var1, Var2, Var3, Var4.</p> <p>I then wanted to create a master composite of all four variables. I thus summed all the individual indicators and mean-centered the total, for Var1234.</p> <p>I'm trying to test the theory of complementarity in which these four variables are greater together than individually (i.e. var1 + var2 + var3 + var4 = 4 ... but Var1234 >4)</p> <p>I ran two linear regressions.<br> MODEL 1: All the individual indicators + Individual interaction terms + 4 way interaction term = DV MODEL 2: Var1234 = DV</p> <p>In the 2nd model Var1234 is significant, however in the 1st model the 4 way interaction term is insignificant. I believe this is a problem, but I am not sure. Is it related to the way I created my composite variables, or the fact that there is a 2nd order variable that is a composite of other composites? </p> <p>Is there a way to explain why a 4 way interaction term is insignificant when the composite of those 4 terms IS significant?</p>
74,477
[ -0.04510673135519028, 0.033879753202199936, -0.004632450174540281, 0.03344068303704262, 0.06803322583436966, 0.01672215387225151, -0.009957892820239067, -0.029527124017477036, 0.036273155361413956, -0.04840020835399628, 0.010984426364302635, -0.012860837392508984, 0.04807192459702492, -0.024625137448310852, -0.013752875849604607, 0.017316732555627823, -0.023399099707603455, 0.02527591772377491, -0.010577707551419735, 0.007158583030104637, -0.039664141833782196, 0.011356987059116364, 0.023087427020072937, -0.003607038175687194, 0.026709118857979774, 0.04065323621034622, 0.0008889388991519809, -0.007978696376085281, 0.008026355877518654, 0.04265228286385536, -0.004815944470465183, -0.023011934012174606, 0.02333112806081772, 0.0338670015335083, -0.002990946639329195, 0.0022170136217027903, -0.0035629926715046167, -0.0004790071689058095, 0.027819136157631874, 0.039698585867881775, -0.015174945816397667, -0.01694234274327755, -0.007638195995241404, 0.044184327125549316, 0.009075956419110298, -0.008389865048229694, -0.00018999763415195048, -0.004062819294631481, 0.07151246815919876, -0.054676637053489685, 0.07959149032831192, 0.03085579350590706, 0.04267318919301033, 0.034554023295640945, -0.01586223766207695, -0.04295492544770241, 0.03948666900396347, 0.07412692159414291, 0.027803942561149597, -0.011514649726450443, -0.027114979922771454, -0.006239755544811487, 0.01798500306904316, -0.009183916263282299, -0.025920134037733078, 0.04460849240422249, 0.03135250508785248, 0.024063488468527794, 0.0497288815677166, -0.005483483895659447, -0.01095765270292759, 0.005347039084881544, 0.0373011976480484, 0.008677252568304539, 0.00604129396378994, 0.009514919482171535, 0.013634974136948586, 0.01916925050318241, 0.03781184181571007, 0.008714770898222923, -0.012859845533967018, 0.017737824469804764, -0.006332750432193279, 0.026340020820498466, 0.0077366880141198635, 0.029086200520396233, 0.05026080831885338, -0.02573006972670555, 0.013440445065498352, 0.036086197942495346, -0.0424916036427021, 0.0037867671344429255, 0.06183336675167084, 0.01754743792116642, -0.022928554564714432, 0.010505418293178082, -0.0127858966588974, 0.030766155570745468, 0.029248619452118874, 0.021468577906489372, -0.046771321445703506, 0.002994830720126629, 0.01891176775097847, 0.05014769732952118, -0.0077738333493471146, -0.022428754717111588, -0.06971663236618042, 0.004561552312225103, 0.018870869651436806, -0.04615262895822525, -0.06368432939052582, -0.02045195922255516, -0.0017541529377922416, -0.023324111476540565, 0.028919624164700508, -0.026077276095747948, -0.00009187366958940402, -0.008182138204574585, 0.06726285070180893, 0.05300867184996605, 0.0409637950360775, -0.055139534175395966, 0.013357686810195446, -0.04298932105302811, -0.05419033393263817, 0.015491827391088009, -0.012311836704611778, -0.04506298527121544, 0.0013231681659817696, 0.08279324322938919, 0.05120043456554413, -0.026227936148643494, 0.008081828244030476, 0.01993725262582302, 0.03780079260468483, 0.016501648351550102, -0.062641941010952, -0.03937073424458504, 0.04154631868004799, -0.024636326357722282, -0.006341799162328243, -0.0717020258307457, -0.0285812858492136, 0.017935315147042274, 0.0691506415605545, -0.03801447153091431, 0.015991035848855972, 0.04946988448500633, 0.036187898367643356, 0.031126396730542183, -0.0005137853440828621, -0.04455161094665527, -0.054217614233493805, -0.019338490441441536, -0.0015685148537158966, -0.09667277336120605, 0.0014336685417219996, 0.013285360299050808, -0.021964287385344505, 0.011279850266873837, 0.05291479453444481, 0.024288829416036606, -0.007117127534002066, -0.009043603204190731, 0.010662168264389038, 0.0018288333667442203, 0.03947765752673149, -0.025023367255926132, 0.006408399436622858, -0.0014067721785977483, 0.0260815117508173, -0.0038357602898031473, -0.003291889326646924, 0.08468589186668396, -0.004810333717614412, -0.008778396993875504, -0.01652316004037857, -0.005964977666735649, 0.001588988583534956, -0.011518237181007862, -0.03914273530244827, -0.058516815304756165, -0.03775838017463684, -0.01494700089097023, 0.026496104896068573, 0.0605229027569294, -0.02137783169746399, -0.022045569494366646, 0.02219446375966072, -0.013260792009532452, -0.055496685206890106, -0.046502579003572464, 0.027905691415071487, -0.004705996718257666, -0.0639752671122551, 0.022737083956599236, 0.0010401817271485925, 0.027196010574698448, 0.027323177084326744, -0.003111861180514097, -0.0069128889590501785, 0.019124556332826614, 0.0635974332690239, -0.021127531304955482, 0.01883579231798649, 0.018514439463615417, 0.0504838302731514, -0.028548533096909523, 0.029311971738934517, -0.00036371839814819396, -0.04885078966617584, 0.01058193389326334, -0.01800510473549366, 0.025107337161898613, -0.04072663560509682, -0.049551982432603836, 0.008752886205911636, -0.02652062103152275, 0.0007596206269226968, 0.06264952570199966, -0.04166419804096222, 0.07525309175252914, 0.05290720984339714, -0.015594027936458588, -0.014471586793661118, 0.02370661310851574, 0.010619345121085644, 0.039061158895492554, -0.04752141982316971, 0.007864958606660366, -0.020684877410531044, -0.01436797808855772, 0.025332216173410416, 0.04491725191473961, -0.028967872262001038, 0.03207257762551308, 0.06357228755950928, 0.022590965032577515, -0.0035213627852499485, 0.014685902744531631, 0.024130254983901978, -0.017615873366594315, 0.05965667590498924, 0.028462963178753853, 0.006728353910148144, 0.023377956822514534, 0.019189726561307907, 0.0031286878511309624, 0.0263334009796381, -0.02071780152618885, -0.006334399338811636, 0.03419084846973419, -0.0008732955320738256, 0.021784009411931038, -0.047256652265787125, 0.0008513466455042362, 0.028760802000761032, -0.0008460624958388507, 0.035992566496133804, 0.04376915842294693, 0.007627012673765421, 0.006347964983433485, 0.02485283464193344, -0.05229950696229935, 0.03702844679355621, 0.022709673270583153, -0.032310787588357925, -0.043645091354846954, 0.0008007557480596006, -0.02859661541879177, 0.026542112231254578, -0.0383957177400589, -0.00035129470052197576, -0.01988925039768219, 0.0019310065545141697, 0.02739296853542328, -0.016280507668852806, 0.021436680108308792, -0.03432115539908409, -0.015513667836785316, -0.0036061564460396767, -0.01675640419125557, -0.011678722687065601, -0.010017408058047295, -0.06047339364886284, -0.031654730439186096, -0.04146162047982216, -0.025191674008965492, 0.03021831624209881, -0.008520057424902916, -0.01624465361237526, 0.01981208100914955, -0.02715970389544964, -0.048284418880939484, -0.04696996137499809, -0.012429585680365562, -0.014626407995820045, -0.04738795757293701, -0.030804790556430817, 0.0311637744307518, 0.01266725454479456, -0.037683188915252686, 0.018067616969347, -0.0026387926191091537, -0.016789628192782402, 0.009454241953790188, -0.05112495645880699, 0.02322637289762497, 0.025236694142222404, 0.02895263582468033, 0.007609760854393244, -0.03513377532362938, -0.01689094677567482, -0.08133477717638016, -0.06775251775979996, 0.027066079899668694, 0.005790359806269407, 0.04251458868384361, -0.011843265034258366, -0.054676029831171036, 0.04925842955708504, 0.029301656410098076, -0.024658022448420525, -0.04283526539802551, -0.020464854314923286, -0.020219411700963974, -0.0019411698449403048, 0.04094568267464638, 0.025899045169353485, 0.01034344732761383, 0.02337740920484066, -0.03397684544324875, 0.02158956043422222, 0.017152901738882065, 0.02882072702050209, -0.011520029976963997, 0.041739996522665024, -0.031163416802883148, -0.03472788259387016, 0.021195372566580772, 0.03650624305009842, -0.006144022103399038, 0.008565159514546394, 0.021500645205378532, 0.021031545475125313, 0.005853820126503706, -0.01948847994208336, 0.01933155581355095, -0.002180023118853569, 0.022909626364707947, -0.01553681306540966, 0.010616240091621876, 0.027455437928438187, -0.0235166996717453, -0.04048239439725876, -0.007149075157940388, 0.06284957379102707, -0.008781018666923046, 0.061607468873262405, 0.053698282688856125, 0.004166072700172663, -0.013977011665701866, 0.031076237559318542, -0.015924744307994843, -0.017491662874817848, -0.000622039835434407, -0.009183271788060665, -0.004556614905595779, 0.06744090467691422, 0.02459891512989998, -0.003989586606621742, -0.017278151586651802, -0.05406256392598152, -0.00922300387173891, -0.056971948593854904, 0.026063015684485435, -0.042088113725185394, 0.011046981438994408, -0.0028221544343978167, 0.021742047742009163, 0.006373375188559294, -0.03013278916478157, -0.008716520853340626, -0.006816880777478218, -0.04298289120197296, 0.010060908272862434, -0.016389066353440285, 0.0069557237438857555, 0.018414031714200974, -0.004164451267570257, 0.009495490230619907, -0.044837795197963715, -0.003131569130346179, -0.03792211040854454, 0.05672774091362953, -0.0012566761579364538, 0.0090853963047266, -0.01703115738928318, -0.006152324844151735, 0.009599189274013042, 0.035282474011182785, 0.037057142704725266, 0.009201779961585999, 0.040824271738529205, 0.039777353405952454, -0.04845503345131874, -0.02229229360818863, -0.05793243274092674, -0.023193620145320892, 0.03748693689703941, 0.0401419997215271, 0.04159780219197273, 0.017953015863895416, -0.056169044226408005, -0.0015867208130657673, 0.027853744104504585, 0.04509367793798447, -0.010443019680678844, -0.007931362837553024, -0.04184276983141899, -0.025170329958200455, -0.035139381885528564, 0.0138295479118824, 0.019171161577105522, 0.0020487878937274218, 0.0058140535838902, 0.017693329602479935, 0.03604941442608833, -0.04914408177137375, 0.018272671848535538, 0.058939456939697266, 0.0419696569442749, -0.012815525755286217, -0.05386335402727127, -0.01473717950284481, 0.005104274954646826, -0.012232914566993713, 0.025278249755501747, 0.013985464349389076, 0.007341894321143627, -0.022512435913085938, 0.03543743118643761, -0.05320752412080765, 0.005220626015216112, 0.017954418435692787, -0.049001265317201614, 0.010893109254539013, -0.01181915681809187, -0.053744103759527206, 0.02606555074453354, 0.0472780279815197, 0.01425124891102314, 0.026062479242682457, 0.023968063294887543, -0.08372151851654053, 0.02888721227645874, 0.04388255253434181, 0.05282352864742279, -0.06015826761722565, -0.0039147124625742435, 0.011495117098093033, -0.022629350423812866, 0.031391777098178864, -0.01858465000987053, 0.04510755091905594, -0.005059481598436832, 0.03490793704986572, -0.0156180365011096, -0.034055501222610474, -0.030701875686645508, 0.023442257195711136, -0.017553377896547318, 0.007779550738632679, -0.021197669208049774, -0.006407761014997959, -0.06676577776670456, 0.0012865711469203234, 0.032409198582172394, 0.0189836248755455, -0.01657961495220661, -0.0242146123200655, 0.011270550079643726, 0.014716699719429016, -0.002932399744167924, -0.053957052528858185, 0.0416623093187809, -0.0034896221477538347, -0.039710648357868195, 0.07324782758951187, -0.031446173787117004, -0.03461058437824249, -0.025980159640312195, 0.016233600676059723, -0.005240599624812603, -0.012010952457785606, -0.02966696210205555, 0.04407958686351776, 0.01967693492770195, -0.004695018753409386, 0.05541924014687538, 0.007587271276861429, -0.03986044600605965, -0.008475047536194324, -0.025504179298877716, 0.02467712014913559, -0.034502096474170685, -0.0012428464833647013, -0.0003859858261421323, 0.024735862389206886, 0.006150164641439915, 0.019094396382570267, -0.014834641478955746, 0.027122365310788155, -0.04861905798316002, 0.00464250473305583, 0.009772596880793571, 0.004865005146712065, 0.0008052362827584147, -0.009504170157015324, 0.005782199092209339, 0.028866862878203392, 0.01969831995666027, -0.021136844530701637, 0.033083800226449966, -0.013385714963078499, -0.01958717219531536, 0.02586425468325615, -0.002990396460518241, 0.012007183395326138, -0.033193401992321014, -0.02895360253751278, -0.024054476991295815, -0.023507019504904747, -0.0003108062664978206, 0.008920913562178612, 0.03345063328742981, -0.01495007798075676, -0.02799598127603531, -0.019679153338074684, 0.018228111788630486, 0.005963314324617386, 0.028655923902988434, -0.021405715495347977, 0.042318761348724365, -0.02420375682413578, 0.008907568641006947, -0.05484619736671448, -0.061255961656570435, -0.014810193330049515, 0.013398591428995132, 0.020126154646277428, -0.0195677038282156, 0.006251197308301926, -0.030408788472414017, -0.02434980683028698, -0.01409501675516367, 0.0388745553791523, -0.030528752133250237, 0.005349044222384691, 0.002524297684431076, 0.021045811474323273, 0.050817348062992096, -0.0037984626833349466, 0.005853012204170227, 0.016071492806077003, -0.033876121044158936, -0.023273097351193428, -0.008441139943897724, 0.021527467295527458, -0.03362330049276352, -0.007557310629636049, 0.009323811158537865, -0.02789679728448391, 0.02826821431517601, -0.01960555650293827, -0.0033110391814261675, -0.040503401309251785, -0.014219016768038273, 0.006585277151316404, -0.004966061562299728, 0.0012985283974558115, 0.03158442676067352, 0.0042474837973713875, 0.02508135512471199, 0.025218607857823372, -0.03928423300385475, -0.009787948802113533, 0.028465429320931435, -0.019099030643701553, -0.04021090641617775, -0.016500387340784073, 0.07944028079509735, 0.03693201020359993, 0.0369199775159359, -0.001992537174373865, -0.012808182276785374, 0.03840558975934982, -0.01782689429819584, -0.014243723824620247, -0.00808661337941885, 0.03165184333920479, -0.03566662594676018, -0.022469937801361084, -0.01522072870284319, 0.02817062847316265, 0.06255137175321579, -0.0708058774471283, 0.048878852277994156, 0.04829266294836998, -0.03170381858944893, -0.014601269736886024, -0.031208066269755363, 0.013193303719162941, 0.039693064987659454, 0.00414370559155941, 0.05046079307794571, -0.03579820692539215, -0.01480118278414011, 0.03841526806354523, 0.00010490429122000933, 0.013127254322171211, 0.016792234033346176, 0.03128476440906525, 0.015466427430510521, 0.029159050434827805, -0.023429453372955322, -0.05127448961138725, 0.05383294075727463, -0.04473027214407921, 0.01726590283215046, -0.030648453161120415, -0.010867435485124588, 0.037127528339624405, 0.06714281439781189, -0.005959975998848677, -0.04803147539496422, -0.04826613888144493, -0.02165195532143116, -0.023067651316523552, 0.02818968892097473, -0.05462946370244026, 0.0034091316629201174, 0.021474404260516167, 0.03133426979184151, 0.022371074184775352, 0.020708508789539337, -0.03374943509697914, -0.07472000271081924, -0.04854341968894005, -0.0007863144273869693, -0.017600543797016144, 0.018992764875292778, -0.021889647468924522, -0.0534013956785202, 0.027756454423069954, -0.03549295663833618, -0.00674687884747982, -0.026126619428396225, -0.003537808544933796, -0.006322510074824095, 0.03370814770460129, 0.03259541094303131, -0.004156140144914389, 0.03037155792117119, 0.02560286782681942, 0.11043138802051544, 0.07410310953855515, 0.0035224484745413065, -0.07260708510875702, 0.05400707572698593, 0.017395664006471634, 0.025684569031000137, -0.06372549384832382, 0.022129910066723824, 0.014746228232979774, -0.009751862846314907, 0.011869698762893677, 0.054063063114881516, 0.036550361663103104, 0.0026365264784544706, 0.0450240895152092, -0.01649845391511917, -0.0305517315864563, -0.017444880679249763, 0.02164251171052456, -0.028628353029489517, -0.0246749185025692, -0.06506098061800003, -0.007206973619759083, -0.006889134179800749, 0.002156119327992201, -0.0055894386023283005, -0.012218669056892395, -0.02168351784348488, -0.016390793025493622, 0.015654325485229492, 0.005255783908069134, 0.048994436860084534, -0.00016406831855420023, -0.024461304768919945, 0.0001701708388281986, 0.03269922733306885, -0.03221743926405907, 0.034627221524715424, 0.019347278401255608, -0.04822409525513649, 0.002027963288128376, 0.02793927676975727, 0.027795160189270973, -0.043136563152074814, -0.03479143604636192, 0.011011742986738682, 0.062054410576820374, 0.045073170214891434, -0.00899482797831297, -0.02966701053082943, -0.008398239500820637, 0.025271611288189888, -0.030997933819890022, -0.033265408128499985, 0.006245562341064215, 0.025694042444229126, -0.04477454721927643, -0.021285036578774452, -0.017392564564943314, 0.007821091450750828, -0.029550092294812202, -0.004793679341673851, 0.018012499436736107, -0.03461586311459541, -0.0280186515301466, -0.04627164453268051, 0.024045074358582497, 0.024819331243634224, -0.024660475552082062, -0.009550333023071289, -0.013322792015969753, -0.005207598675042391, -0.011199038475751877, 0.003185505047440529, 0.0061728558503091335, 0.023387597873806953, 0.030921226367354393, 0.009007890708744526, -0.035567812621593475, -0.035105157643556595, 0.005501565523445606, -0.011429284699261189, -0.015343638136982918, -0.04296061769127846, 0.0007068978156894445, 0.049767300486564636, 0.015447135083377361, -0.010167849250137806, -0.007035874295979738, -0.029148969799280167, 0.03603489696979523, -0.00732214841991663, -0.05988327041268349, -0.05052803456783295, 0.004855396691709757, -0.00442495895549655, -0.01312526036053896, -0.01891528256237507, 0.02923116460442543, -0.00756671279668808, -0.0012124332133680582, 0.021984755992889404, 0.03164699301123619, -0.019084535539150238, 0.02943691797554493, 0.05721303075551987, -0.07365892082452774, 0.010603591799736023, 0.01792619191110134, 0.014574629254639149, -0.016231650486588478, -0.035319555550813675, -0.0378919281065464, -0.021289542317390442, -0.01629798114299774, 0.011036091484129429, -0.03360043838620186, -0.028213316574692726, -0.0272990632802248, 0.023746516555547714, -0.047954339534044266, -0.021693456918001175, -0.06476853042840958, 0.009970984421670437, -0.0035785797517746687, -0.01472247950732708, 0.0018530102679505944, 0.031627051532268524, -0.022263115271925926, 0.007302911952137947, 0.04158041998744011, 0.002937518758699298, -0.0009387112222611904, -0.04523547738790512, 0.03523844853043556, 0.01951262541115284, 0.044544950127601624, -0.0013820880558341742, -0.04874170944094658, 0.047687653452157974, -0.03120017610490322, -0.07678399980068207, 0.0014843631070107222, 0.0009019492426887155, 0.04886239767074585, 0.010477414354681969, 0.03424309566617012, -0.05676049366593361, 0.05784875899553299, -0.006367841269820929, 0.019574273377656937, 0.021362846717238426, 0.014853938482701778, 0.03140968456864357, 0.014638593420386314, -0.02842566929757595, 0.014595730230212212, 0.00031792264780960977, 0.008183514699339867, 0.05402572825551033, 0.00046238285722211003, -0.005216366611421108, -0.005219251848757267, -0.011386153288185596, 0.02874291129410267, -0.020527271553874016, 0.018598955124616623, 0.027920277789235115, 0.054859865456819534, 0.0008719729376025498, 0.04902176186442375, 0.012197754345834255, 0.017703942954540253, -0.09112588316202164, 0.001156709506176412, -0.013276576064527035, 0.014831454493105412, 0.03088982030749321, -0.034176718443632126, 0.018296465277671814, 0.013715681619942188, -0.048894234001636505, 0.013572843745350838, -0.013083692640066147, -0.004267875105142593, -0.04899030551314354, -0.06421267986297607, -0.03628295287489891, 0.046109750866889954, 0.026696844026446342, 0.03978535160422325, 0.0151590621098876, 0.02760292962193489, 0.015617970377206802, -0.023966843262314796, -0.001329466002061963, -0.01939494162797928, -0.014921552501618862, -0.05725467577576637, 0.047364622354507446, -0.0486835353076458, -0.05151748284697533, 0.04474886879324913, -0.016410253942012787, 0.014749049209058285, 0.010303662158548832, 0.03139493614435196, 0.0342257022857666, 0.06055557727813721, 0.018765153363347054, 0.003749087918549776, 0.028571253642439842, -0.01517853606492281, 0.0027133948169648647, 0.0017752519343048334, 0.0038015127647668123, 0.001887788763269782, -0.009912406094372272, -0.014813637360930443, -0.03264354169368744, 0.008859931491315365, -0.023330019786953926, -0.012415184639394283, -0.02479815110564232, -0.004729952197521925, 0.03605570271611214, -0.048416052013635635, 0.03141053766012192, -0.03914385661482811, -0.03053554706275463, 0.046236876398324966, 0.05122579261660576, -0.016932882368564606, -0.0019990401342511177, 0.005191910546272993, -0.006104441359639168, 0.017319340258836746, 0.03598450496792793, 0.03284699469804764, -0.04273061454296112, 0.0062661911360919476, -0.0037016677670180798, 0.0015542915789410472, -0.04070968180894852, -0.006006862036883831, -0.0596126988530159, 0.039665766060352325, -0.06346046924591064, 0.014413096010684967, -0.011225051246583462, -0.05629558116197586, 0.0321238674223423, -0.09436117857694626, 0.03687242791056633, 0.03105870820581913, -0.010257460176944733, -0.006514573469758034, 0.0029874187894165516, -0.0563618503510952, -0.0015036436961963773, 0.05806683003902435, 0.010663319379091263, -0.006604181602597237, 0.016444923356175423, 0.01801776885986328, 0.028482312336564064, -0.04035993292927742, 0.03301498666405678, 0.02708548493683338, 0.019059116020798683, 0.007687784265726805, -0.00022859546879772097, 0.03312116488814354, 0.0013147463323548436, 0.013715810142457485, -0.017189139500260353, -0.029227670282125473, -0.006797249894589186, -0.01629394292831421, 0.012684621848165989, -0.011112420819699764, -0.007300525903701782, 0.05381142720580101, 0.014262169599533081, 0.038713667541742325, 0.030122555792331696, 0.008076366037130356, -0.01846993714570999, 0.04162617027759552, -0.005285549908876419, -0.008849786594510078, 0.009262110106647015, 0.015298598445951939, 0.009170861914753914, -0.04901786148548126, 0.013196393847465515, 0.013151083141565323, -0.020208492875099182, -0.026437733322381973, 0.043304745107889175, 0.05701422318816185, 0.024291254580020905, 0.041526224464178085, 0.014776775613427162, -0.005364122800529003, -0.004309306386858225, 0.02380291000008583, 0.019339462742209435, 0.011482622474431992, 0.012038868851959705, -0.014118514955043793, 0.04880419746041298, -0.011252831667661667, 0.03148448094725609, -0.04119976609945297, 0.004604600835591555, 0.003171044634655118, -0.032240718603134155, 0.017434708774089813, -0.02345854602754116, 0.026667749509215355, -0.012038327753543854, 0.025839822366833687, 0.035174425691366196, -0.050696928054094315, 0.012094146572053432, -0.02452065236866474, 0.014122748747467995, -0.03547872230410576, 0.015152382664382458, 0.009849745780229568, 0.015306341461837292, -0.0019479634938761592, -0.0033962063025683165, 0.0023989370092749596, -0.037407416850328445, -0.010197481140494347, -0.01913890428841114, 0.015045631676912308, -0.03365441784262657, -0.018596550449728966, 0.006419647019356489, -0.0034016715362668037, -0.04573402926325798, -0.053789615631103516, 0.04418511688709259, 0.05865928903222084, 0.021232115104794502, -0.04217255115509033, -0.022003963589668274, 0.02179127186536789, 0.055585406720638275, -0.0537988655269146, -0.04234200716018677, -0.03373953700065613, 0.0036621869076043367, 0.010565732605755329, 0.017047086730599403 ]
<p>I have an experiment with two treatments. It is a split plot experiment, with the structure Block/Treatment1/Treatment2. Each treatment has 2 levels. The dependent variable is presence/absence data for functional speceis groups. I am analysing the data using mixed models via lme4 and afex.</p> <p>The model structure is as follows:</p> <pre><code>m &lt;- lmer (DV ~ Treatment 1 * Treatment 2 + (1|Block/Treatment1), family = binomial) </code></pre> <p>For graphical purposes however, I want to plot the treatment means for each of the 4 treatment combinations (Treatment 1 level A and Treatment 2 level A; Treatment 1 level B Treatment 2 level A; Treatment 1 level B and Treatment 2 level A; Treatment 1 level B and Treatment 2 level B). I couldn't find an intuitive way to extract these mean and standard error values in R for data with a binomial error distribution, thus I am calculating these values by hand. I appreciate that the standard errors I calculate will not take into account the random effect structure in my dataset, but I cannot find a way to calculate them to include this random effect structure (using a mcmc simulation in language R to create HPD confidence intervals only works for Gaussian data).</p> <p>As such, I want to calculate treatment means for the proportion of a particular functional group in a particular treatment combination, and then standard errors of these 4 treatment means.</p> <p>Consider that the proportions I have for a particular treatment are:</p> <pre><code>Plot 1: 24/65 Plot 2 26/64 Plot 3: 25/65 Plot 4: 22/62 Plot 5: 30/66 Plot 6: 29/65 </code></pre> <p>I understand that to calculate the average proportion I need to sum the total number of hits (sum of all the numerators above) and divide by the total sum of hits and misses (sum of all the denominators above). This gives me 0.40.</p> <p>My question then is, how does one calculate the standard error of the resulting proportion?</p> <p>Calling the proportion of hits p and misses q, I have the following formula for the standard error of a proportion:</p> <pre><code>sqrt((p*q)/n) </code></pre> <p>Is this correct? In addition, what is n? Is n the number of proportions that make up the mean proportion (in this case 6) or the total number of hits and misses (i.e. sum of all the denominators above, which here is 387)?</p> <p>I'm sorry that this is a simple question, I just cannot find an answer anywhere! Also i'm sorry if this is not the correct forum to post this in...</p> <p>Many thanks.</p>
74,478
[ -0.013630734756588936, -0.024509111419320107, -0.008892269805073738, -0.016624610871076584, 0.0084458626806736, 0.02490423060953617, -0.037163738161325455, -0.04635217413306236, 0.04747118055820465, -0.01842457428574562, 0.031304460018873215, 0.03855753690004349, 0.0773918479681015, -0.0005308276158757508, 0.01432229857891798, 0.002836535219103098, 0.0003658532223198563, -0.011638838797807693, 0.022124331444501877, -0.013285902328789234, -0.00853801891207695, 0.004003116860985756, -0.00914919562637806, -0.006432153284549713, -0.01269245333969593, 0.0461651012301445, 0.04411938413977623, -0.04539649933576584, -0.0031298515386879444, 0.037074435502290726, -0.03148739039897919, -0.046511247754096985, 0.04830913990736008, 0.035656578838825226, 0.009575850330293179, 0.006542821880429983, -0.004118070472031832, -0.004291188903152943, 0.009292601607739925, 0.014336525462567806, -0.05587776005268097, 0.024399299174547195, 0.0020235597621649504, 0.007254711352288723, -0.015551619231700897, 0.0007971682935021818, -0.022623680531978607, -0.014406951144337654, 0.060782019048929214, -0.025883197784423828, 0.06440865248441696, 0.007571305148303509, 0.05264907330274582, 0.027240850031375885, -0.034011054784059525, -0.010135871358215809, 0.07189363241195679, 0.03977997973561287, 0.03629569709300995, -0.08542770147323608, 0.006061166059225798, -0.022828323766589165, 0.01133878342807293, -0.034332241863012314, -0.0507679246366024, -0.016016747802495956, 0.0003399578854441643, -0.015389487147331238, 0.04665101692080498, 0.0069553605280816555, 0.04277841001749039, 0.032164327800273895, 0.027704816311597824, -0.0015146035002544522, 0.032898902893066406, -0.0061494940891861916, -0.0022308258339762688, 0.0013079330092296004, 0.025892185047268867, 0.02912910468876362, -0.0050274161621928215, 0.0118340402841568, 0.011879450641572475, 0.029146067798137665, -0.0012053507380187511, -0.01634020172059536, 0.04176238551735878, 0.0010650852927938104, 0.026595961302518845, -0.011561988852918148, -0.017390582710504532, 0.012084531597793102, 0.06828003376722336, 0.002685156650841236, -0.04411015659570694, 0.037141453474760056, -0.003335477551445365, 0.023209355771541595, 0.026485716924071312, 0.0050051151774823666, -0.030082816258072853, -0.03747212514281273, 0.010310436598956585, 0.07552266865968704, 0.007824935019016266, 0.01154019683599472, -0.01623714528977871, -0.023605532944202423, -0.00833998341113329, -0.010475429706275463, 0.00410052202641964, 0.034504830837249756, 0.01644197292625904, 0.010756143368780613, 0.004291243851184845, -0.056568387895822525, -0.01847284846007824, -0.012586203403770924, 0.07468206435441971, 0.045025456696748734, 0.032224517315626144, -0.024495957419276237, 0.021626422181725502, -0.008314325474202633, -0.055893782526254654, -0.01755932904779911, 0.0019684808794409037, -0.027074962854385376, -0.02963399700820446, 0.05435880273580551, 0.00224000820890069, -0.027123821899294853, 0.0361839160323143, 0.003298552241176367, -0.003158608917146921, -0.02415512315928936, -0.03176448866724968, -0.052562348544597626, 0.00938127189874649, -0.011281842365860939, 0.012253780849277973, -0.048625484108924866, 0.009014843963086605, 0.028317617252469063, -0.0002512755454517901, 0.002230216981843114, 0.02953707054257393, 0.023975210264325142, 0.03945332393050194, 0.006059067789465189, -0.01853235624730587, 0.012945985421538353, -0.02648618072271347, -0.01215292140841484, -0.05110781639814377, -0.07596322149038315, 0.026339489966630936, -0.0016268929466605186, -0.030666984617710114, 0.04278117045760155, 0.013206586241722107, 0.01461948361247778, 0.011441929265856743, -0.0019338260171934962, 0.029131917282938957, 0.011640463955700397, 0.04224511608481407, -0.009957961738109589, 0.050229791551828384, -0.000015572637494187802, -0.05317535623908043, -0.027054060250520706, -0.010467370972037315, 0.05225725471973419, 0.05486779287457466, -0.036335308104753494, 0.0026599769480526447, -0.005039914045482874, -0.007200365886092186, 0.0323043130338192, -0.05322674661874771, -0.013690128922462463, -0.05065333843231201, -0.03054238297045231, 0.051386430859565735, 0.016186559572815895, 0.0248220544308424, -0.002948978217318654, 0.04338942840695381, -0.02448500506579876, -0.035730160772800446, -0.09516971558332443, -0.0511508509516716, 0.0063408901914954185, -0.07048358768224716, -0.009620239026844501, -0.0021423588041216135, 0.01435112301260233, 0.017975086346268654, 0.00865973997861147, -0.026669856160879135, -0.009162834845483303, 0.03852507844567299, -0.0320071280002594, 0.019528549164533615, 0.01684684306383133, 0.06836751848459244, 0.0215995442122221, 0.0549677349627018, -0.030543789267539978, -0.01890319027006626, -0.016131741926074028, -0.024660060182213783, -0.0038326382637023926, 0.012771585024893284, -0.018415801227092743, 0.0004305701295379549, 0.009127197787165642, -0.008211913518607616, 0.02168484777212143, -0.05584901198744774, 0.05171440541744232, 0.09812317788600922, -0.0065153553150594234, 0.00331262219697237, 0.00820425245910883, -0.015181535854935646, 0.041349709033966064, -0.02491038851439953, -0.010873833671212196, -0.04332058131694794, -0.00763856852427125, 0.01886461116373539, -0.011370175518095493, -0.01654590293765068, -0.0002978831180371344, 0.05430565029382706, -0.017096424475312233, 0.04852192848920822, 0.024116970598697662, 0.008775800466537476, -0.004968774504959583, 0.020497703924775124, 0.05194152519106865, -0.005438583437353373, 0.0034543222282081842, 0.02068190649151802, 0.01966983824968338, 0.02915261685848236, 0.03231007978320122, 0.00042276561725884676, 0.04285319894552231, -0.009497310034930706, 0.0019517338369041681, -0.061801135540008545, 0.014018001966178417, 0.053365230560302734, 0.0021912564989179373, 0.009551232680678368, 0.04651537910103798, 0.0008203528122976422, -0.024694621562957764, 0.033335279673337936, -0.022905796766281128, 0.024675076827406883, 0.04209642484784126, 0.0037210527807474136, -0.0285334549844265, 0.011623740196228027, -0.015322710387408733, 0.018497750163078308, -0.03899894282221794, -0.019705595448613167, -0.038630083203315735, 0.024956241250038147, -0.016607115045189857, -0.006038385443389416, 0.022980278357863426, -0.044705357402563095, -0.0038304473273456097, 0.008487001992762089, 0.04958096146583557, 0.05070893466472626, -0.012532594613730907, -0.06106724217534065, -0.026343930512666702, -0.05069698393344879, -0.006073519121855497, 0.027030132710933685, -0.02526926063001156, -0.06591646373271942, 0.04123373329639435, 0.012929926626384258, -0.031065836548805237, -0.03326075151562691, -0.002318055834621191, -0.01078055240213871, -0.03727685660123825, 0.0034447177313268185, 0.00034736315137706697, 0.001700330525636673, -0.03158789500594139, 0.026178201660513878, -0.04958193376660347, 0.0317855179309845, -0.02572520636022091, -0.023989804089069366, 0.003883509198203683, 0.02451952174305916, -0.002702017081901431, 0.014477133750915527, 0.0007067910628393292, -0.026804473251104355, -0.0817333459854126, -0.026390567421913147, -0.0026831412687897682, 0.030909137800335884, 0.029867488890886307, 0.021000590175390244, -0.005562101025134325, 0.06272051483392715, 0.05928904190659523, -0.02533123642206192, -0.043523143976926804, -0.004727222491055727, 0.030467364937067032, 0.03281722590327263, 0.04984547570347786, 0.006468656938523054, 0.013133673928678036, 0.010651367716491222, -0.03345847129821777, 0.021737096831202507, 0.04389224946498871, -0.002618561265990138, 0.001244907733052969, 0.01850789226591587, -0.023137694224715233, -0.029763033613562584, 0.0649857372045517, 0.031034542247653008, -0.017720676958560944, 0.037614837288856506, 0.007407757919281721, 0.03895961120724678, -0.01098188478499651, -0.07658485323190689, -0.005912201013416052, -0.0010511561995372176, -0.020621124655008316, -0.028185583651065826, 0.009730271995067596, 0.03265479952096939, -0.02954014204442501, 0.02501247636973858, 0.029682137072086334, 0.011324438266456127, -0.023883646354079247, 0.0022305219899863005, 0.05093755945563316, 0.04998417943716049, -0.036286044865846634, -0.02640828862786293, 0.006873536389321089, -0.024451492354273796, 0.006673608906567097, -0.01661762036383152, -0.007790132891386747, 0.0016804918413981795, 0.03640450909733772, 0.006073285825550556, 0.015341726131737232, -0.015026960521936417, 0.01875997893512249, -0.0578453354537487, -0.006685175467282534, -0.07481659948825836, 0.02985607460141182, -0.002798309549689293, 0.049399178475141525, -0.004332403186708689, -0.024545643478631973, -0.038346368819475174, -0.049006566405296326, -0.02759617567062378, 0.018736431375145912, 0.0289481021463871, -0.040792014449834824, -0.00971155520528555, -0.0009499714360572398, 0.025558870285749435, -0.004244511481374502, 0.009250626899302006, -0.01072598434984684, 0.007279268931597471, 0.01523336861282587, 0.023230252787470818, 0.0218025092035532, -0.004047692753374577, -0.013244259171187878, 0.03126172721385956, 0.015820428729057312, -0.002950012916699052, -0.025896724313497543, 0.007458498701453209, -0.0012483211467042565, -0.008772792294621468, 0.004057863727211952, -0.00855468213558197, 0.012900609523057938, 0.06400160491466522, 0.039433181285858154, 0.030084634199738503, -0.042196013033390045, 0.039998967200517654, 0.01739691011607647, 0.07464799284934998, 0.05789859592914581, -0.012607832439243793, 0.025240404531359673, -0.025118619203567505, -0.005500589031726122, 0.025017855688929558, -0.00630226219072938, -0.020259922370314598, 0.02073531039059162, 0.037235233932733536, 0.02920723147690296, -0.07439829409122467, 0.009518774226307869, 0.04144622012972832, 0.01047347579151392, 0.021665001288056374, -0.08863725513219833, -0.010880935937166214, -0.041445277631282806, -0.008939198218286037, 0.04191920906305313, 0.021969731897115707, 0.018140669912099838, 0.031056376174092293, 0.061612568795681, 0.013629313558340073, -0.05224448814988136, 0.03567127138376236, 0.00182088662404567, -0.005219963379204273, -0.0032486976124346256, -0.011565336026251316, -0.0032502091489732265, 0.046316102147102356, 0.017241431400179863, -0.016225140541791916, 0.004915397614240646, -0.09015455842018127, 0.008631428703665733, 0.031297467648983, 0.04834403097629547, -0.016856011003255844, -0.0008231163956224918, -0.023870306089520454, 0.01443568430840969, -0.013619422912597656, -0.02850750833749771, 0.03515313193202019, -0.010621913708746433, 0.03981124237179756, -0.03907262533903122, -0.043392423540353775, -0.06586848944425583, 0.025592727586627007, -0.005405367352068424, -0.019319098442792892, -0.03503722324967384, -0.002991827903315425, -0.01046016626060009, 0.008439009077847004, 0.0021134447306394577, 0.050730958580970764, -0.028854476287961006, -0.034061599522829056, -0.007547854445874691, 0.01529623195528984, -0.02831355668604374, -0.052380651235580444, 0.0064428746700286865, -0.02790340967476368, 0.000410599255701527, 0.0676555410027504, -0.01677662320435047, 0.02934466488659382, 0.05479498580098152, 0.03745122626423836, -0.00009305086132371798, 0.0003816769749391824, -0.014391924254596233, 0.05304844304919243, 0.054617688059806824, 0.05559808015823364, 0.04717058315873146, -0.007738536223769188, -0.03484930098056793, 0.03878631442785263, -0.054888930171728134, 0.01875493861734867, 0.012908696196973324, -0.028570124879479408, -0.06208670884370804, -0.01111903041601181, 0.007342454511672258, -0.0034308703616261482, -0.05103995278477669, 0.02849753573536873, -0.02108643390238285, -0.016105974093079567, 0.04214786738157272, 0.01949077844619751, -0.018689395859837532, -0.018515298143029213, 0.010711731389164925, -0.013533595949411392, 0.00822640210390091, -0.03399569168686867, 0.0198138989508152, -0.02564581111073494, -0.0012933576945215464, 0.0031795320101082325, -0.04617268219590187, 0.006016991566866636, 0.00607970030978322, -0.00013177625078242272, 0.027316443622112274, -0.02126951888203621, -0.009023725986480713, -0.005982511211186647, 0.047545209527015686, -0.029508478939533234, -0.008247707039117813, -0.025837590917944908, 0.022808738052845, 0.008370257914066315, -0.004887073300778866, 0.021125460043549538, -0.007184362038969994, -0.027562018483877182, -0.006676584016531706, -0.08385223895311356, -0.03089485689997673, 0.007551609538495541, 0.013737783767282963, -0.010806671343743801, -0.03664931282401085, -0.014295869506895542, -0.0064855157397687435, -0.00978154968470335, 0.005294022150337696, 0.06381159275770187, -0.07043270766735077, -0.007042696233838797, -0.026899786666035652, 0.0060266838409006596, 0.05611349269747734, 0.003828797023743391, 0.0013043168000876904, 0.017480185255408287, 0.0030193945858627558, -0.029599536210298538, 0.017953814938664436, -0.011292671784758568, -0.0390833243727684, -0.00553677836433053, -0.027400629594922066, -0.007607582025229931, 0.049197133630514145, -0.020847037434577942, -0.02346896193921566, 0.005478282924741507, 0.023087501525878906, 0.05447597801685333, -0.051661524921655655, -0.018182380124926567, -0.015096070244908333, 0.026788240298628807, -0.017569970339536667, 0.02158062532544136, -0.055898748338222504, 0.034244827926158905, 0.0114367064088583, -0.046870920807123184, -0.026182856410741806, 0.043103672564029694, 0.09561000764369965, -0.002892532851547003, 0.02214868925511837, 0.02423197217285633, 0.005756199359893799, 0.017941802740097046, 0.012215516529977322, -0.0045984662137925625, 0.014705286361277103, 0.015253308229148388, -0.01228594034910202, -0.007686794735491276, -0.045668333768844604, 0.003953875973820686, 0.05445343255996704, -0.0043028430081903934, 0.03529706597328186, 0.037224315106868744, -0.043522827327251434, -0.024226641282439232, -0.011114933528006077, -0.035938918590545654, -0.008490386418998241, 0.01876113750040531, 0.06705173850059509, -0.012182899750769138, -0.011426640674471855, 0.0341002531349659, 0.007790412753820419, -0.0016630718018859625, 0.043546948581933975, -0.006180683616548777, -0.016688577830791473, 0.0019088095286861062, -0.012811213731765747, -0.03055928274989128, 0.04184061288833618, -0.05160697549581528, 0.02315218187868595, -0.042491063475608826, -0.0475800596177578, 0.012144479900598526, 0.033743083477020264, -0.04414686560630798, -0.027767566964030266, -0.008846873417496681, -0.01721099577844143, 0.04688473418354988, 0.02035658247768879, -0.021386215463280678, 0.02140878513455391, 0.026603439822793007, 0.027031879872083664, -0.03774549067020416, 0.08029696345329285, -0.013300547376275063, -0.07417020201683044, -0.004702631384134293, -0.03710278123617172, -0.029835868626832962, 0.05759454146027565, -0.028391597792506218, -0.0010274817468598485, -0.00010230441694147885, -0.03266223520040512, 0.031569741666316986, 0.006310026161372662, 0.00866573303937912, -0.006442383863031864, 0.028773119673132896, -0.0168923307210207, 0.026981623843312263, 0.0025880916509777308, -0.030115477740764618, 0.14648553729057312, 0.05872798338532448, 0.027695152908563614, -0.05113469436764717, 0.008705047890543938, 0.028229011222720146, 0.02306871861219406, -0.0013550333678722382, 0.0016421782784163952, 0.022447053343057632, -0.03694792836904526, 0.03484540432691574, 0.03786104917526245, 0.039386991411447525, 0.017072347924113274, 0.03551917150616646, -0.021506773307919502, -0.027261972427368164, -0.004752662964165211, -0.004640762694180012, -0.023553716018795967, 0.006958944723010063, -0.06786220520734787, -0.0042631970718503, 0.02122248336672783, 0.01858409121632576, -0.05281456187367439, 0.014608881436288357, -0.03249543905258179, 0.0208632480353117, -0.036680370569229126, 0.004957439843565226, 0.017811601981520653, -0.0017034807242453098, 0.014803275465965271, -0.05252499505877495, 0.04246925935149193, -0.02515171840786934, -0.006502111908048391, 0.0376114696264267, -0.023582134395837784, 0.017063070088624954, -0.00943820271641016, 0.039043087512254715, -0.01904427818953991, -0.05259382724761963, -0.006345072761178017, 0.05817802995443344, -0.020481709390878677, -0.002573256613686681, 0.002238078974187374, 0.0005628899089060724, 0.007350592408329248, 0.007881488651037216, -0.019943416118621826, 0.013726137578487396, 0.022802157327532768, -0.030084295198321342, -0.005409791134297848, 0.006085209548473358, 0.04139247164130211, 0.006104957312345505, 0.005355070810765028, 0.04769166558980942, -0.007327749393880367, -0.028176695108413696, -0.05939513444900513, 0.027756674215197563, -0.0316617377102375, -0.011540167033672333, -0.0015201873611658812, -0.017002953216433525, -0.02304372936487198, 0.026517249643802643, 0.003288970096036792, 0.04266927018761635, 0.028314528986811638, 0.025756588205695152, -0.025445297360420227, 0.004576819017529488, -0.046378668397665024, 0.014670777134597301, -0.044321008026599884, 0.011571056209504604, 0.004210516344755888, 0.001666273339651525, 0.02034451626241207, 0.05468684434890747, -0.026648342609405518, 0.0015598168829455972, 0.001469419221393764, 0.07870935648679733, 0.008454878814518452, -0.06637667864561081, -0.025989772751927376, 0.022080514580011368, -0.027139971032738686, -0.04012351483106613, -0.006309499964118004, 0.04267927259206772, 0.0008670991519466043, 0.009410823695361614, -0.013060466386377811, 0.04299106448888779, -0.002996286377310753, -0.008774081245064735, 0.006976303644478321, -0.027737457305192947, 0.00634800037369132, -0.023520726710557938, 0.024912824854254723, -0.03462199121713638, 0.047080423682928085, -0.02120657078921795, -0.02494824305176735, 0.017504146322607994, -0.018710454925894737, -0.024745827540755272, -0.020572854205965996, 0.009720520116388798, 0.0058738840743899345, 0.02992136962711811, 0.014077563770115376, -0.004316751845180988, -0.05707046017050743, -0.017485391348600388, -0.002586102345958352, -0.01062675379216671, 0.03163321316242218, -0.0021281226072460413, 0.025428153574466705, 0.00680647324770689, 0.016406487673521042, 0.023877300322055817, -0.011467423290014267, 0.01034381240606308, 0.021216748282313347, 0.025180604308843613, 0.05639087036252022, -0.011987840756773949, 0.0010722671868279576, -0.06675633043050766, -0.03550770878791809, 0.021306978538632393, 0.002360439859330654, 0.0040323673747479916, 0.00608514528721571, 0.014859786257147789, -0.04658932611346245, 0.020136896520853043, -0.038638461381196976, -0.05472814664244652, -0.04810580611228943, -0.012543966062366962, 0.01734676957130432, 0.0180152989923954, 0.022371061146259308, 0.024048149585723877, 0.031100304797291756, -0.004271009936928749, 0.027773108333349228, 0.004119077231734991, -0.009252393618226051, 0.009985278360545635, -0.027187323197722435, 0.022985056042671204, -0.0007664441945962608, -0.0048723286017775536, 0.01609228551387787, 0.043892405927181244, 0.016532039269804955, 0.02891574427485466, -0.033679693937301636, 0.021330177783966064, -0.0728692039847374, -0.08001464605331421, 0.01061550248414278, 0.03850886598229408, 0.012324685230851173, -0.044846292585134506, 0.02286624349653721, 0.05912911146879196, -0.037021342664957047, 0.019161298871040344, -0.0126078762114048, -0.006911184638738632, -0.017147554084658623, 0.038092389702796936, -0.015845932066440582, 0.01233508251607418, 0.009733167476952076, 0.007861408405005932, 0.049280550330877304, 0.015749186277389526, 0.047059305012226105, -0.0453905388712883, -0.02661958523094654, -0.02657473459839821, 0.03695306554436684, -0.058589398860931396, 0.021242834627628326, -0.026085566729307175, -0.003015124471858144, 0.005981164518743753, 0.03128362074494362, 0.04212547093629837, 0.007023561745882034, 0.02957536093890667, 0.007707148790359497, 0.06669189780950546, -0.021997129544615746, 0.03684304282069206, -0.0006470290245488286, -0.032256800681352615, 0.049766361713409424, 0.012946579605340958, -0.06364588439464569, -0.009262880310416222, 0.049969106912612915, -0.0001556623465148732, -0.040970444679260254, 0.007844893261790276, -0.0019851885735988617, -0.020474450662732124, -0.0359901487827301, -0.005957991816103458, 0.008973888121545315, -0.06834661215543747, 0.002597259124740958, -0.045454978942871094, 0.03803331032395363, 0.06684527546167374, 0.008487645536661148, -0.04174448922276497, 0.020866496488451958, -0.037742942571640015, 0.0005483471904881299, -0.032379407435655594, -0.00509427348151803, -0.03965255618095398, -0.032861918210983276, -0.025645406916737556, -0.017487499862909317, 0.01926056481897831, 0.004078670870512724, 0.00015205383533611894, -0.05290791764855385, 0.025507688522338867, -0.055536966770887375, -0.00941358134150505, -0.009394983761012554, -0.0035158488899469376, 0.0038327688816934824, -0.09787055850028992, 0.03669774904847145, 0.02676350250840187, -0.026457788422703743, -0.05005350708961487, 0.012270097620785236, -0.02243143878877163, 0.016843654215335846, 0.025473568588495255, 0.05859077349305153, -0.013590609654784203, 0.003761576721444726, 0.04448608681559563, 0.03583560138940811, -0.0685005858540535, 0.0286709051579237, -0.0020928040612488985, -0.019218627363443375, -0.0629311129450798, 0.013088117353618145, -0.022479994222521782, 0.013678137212991714, -0.004185573197901249, -0.014420312829315662, 0.004236977081745863, -0.049491818994283676, -0.009078901261091232, 0.012073040008544922, 0.011087684892117977, -0.04764309152960777, 0.016422230750322342, -0.0018418931867927313, 0.024945620447397232, 0.06535973399877548, 0.03589792177081108, -0.043390948325395584, 0.015114584006369114, -0.041257213801145554, -0.02432314120233059, -0.01667129248380661, -0.013429099693894386, 0.034590091556310654, -0.07666870206594467, 0.046078357845544815, 0.026325302198529243, -0.027697108685970306, -0.007423062808811665, 0.043015655130147934, -0.0020074008498340845, 0.04339441657066345, 0.0027265644166618586, 0.017015844583511353, -0.04031027853488922, -0.04397919774055481, 0.025637438520789146, 0.0011895649367943406, 0.02146962657570839, -0.002663352293893695, -0.01713337004184723, 0.004855827894061804, -0.01095518097281456, -0.00124917842913419, -0.006413192953914404, 0.05566839501261711, 0.025743398815393448, -0.01432267390191555, -0.01798298954963684, -0.021085847169160843, 0.014210378751158714, 0.024721693247556686, -0.009365180507302284, 0.03215714171528816, -0.018381716683506966, 0.02306995540857315, -0.04977104067802429, -0.015558494254946709, -0.0182352215051651, 0.00981646217405796, 0.011433186009526253, 0.03915925696492195, -0.017341623082756996, 0.029369182884693146, -0.006746324710547924, -0.015910102054476738, 0.014776959083974361, -0.011902734637260437, 0.023667754605412483, 0.0003659710637293756, 0.009692156687378883, -0.00764079112559557, -0.011079029180109501, -0.04913328215479851, -0.03813363239169121, 0.013705113902688026, 0.02456912212073803, -0.017633706331253052, -0.023734329268336296, -0.025628549978137016, 0.01054472103714943, 0.02420707792043686, -0.021754179149866104, -0.01900745928287506, -0.011895332485437393, -0.016266651451587677, -0.0009232008014805615, -0.0012876520631834865 ]
<p>I'm trying to optimise model parameters for times series data using k-fold cross-validation. I'm using the forward chaining strategy described here:</p> <p><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/14099/using-k-fold-cross-validation-for-time-series-model-selection">Using k-fold cross-validation for time-series model selection</a></p> <p>i.e.</p> <p>fold 1 : optimise [1], test [2]</p> <p>fold 2 : optimise [1 2], test [3]</p> <p>fold 3 : optimise [1 2 3], test [4]</p> <p>fold 4 : optimise [1 2 3 4], test [5]</p> <p>fold 5 : optimise [1 2 3 4 5], test [6]</p> <p>Then averaging the resulting optimised parameters from all five folds to give the final model parameters. My question is: does this not put an overly strong weighting on fold 1 which would be included in every optimisation run? Is there a way to avoid this, or a better cross-validation strategy? </p>
74,479
[ -0.029846269637346268, 0.012327495031058788, -0.05562758073210716, 0.029113048687577248, 0.01681428588926792, 0.0017906322609633207, -0.012213596142828465, -0.023123882710933685, 0.034485213458538055, -0.015189970843493938, 0.02876558154821396, 0.020093802362680435, 0.04056496545672417, -0.01760549657046795, 0.002475238870829344, -0.00024938114802353084, -0.00033085941686294973, -0.004376591183245182, 0.006328018847852945, -0.024151025339961052, 0.018620630726218224, 0.021407144144177437, -0.017046339809894562, -0.010464102029800415, -0.00108997558709234, 0.03317410871386528, 0.053729522973299026, -0.008992643095552921, 0.04369228705763817, 0.05089689418673515, -0.044851187616586685, 0.0031390355434268713, 0.004865929950028658, 0.07984945178031921, 0.001708631869405508, 0.010527257807552814, -0.010652735829353333, -0.03399696946144104, -0.024314768612384796, 0.05528305098414421, 0.020251013338565826, -0.011733539402484894, -0.013952929526567459, 0.0295198243111372, 0.009100974537432194, 0.03967331349849701, -0.015966633334755898, 0.012161844410002232, 0.01786709949374199, -0.05777806416153908, 0.09261325746774673, -0.00485296081751585, 0.0160930585116148, 0.04725653678178787, -0.004039172548800707, -0.010868369601666927, 0.06850968301296234, 0.06679601222276688, -0.024516446515917778, -0.06079389154911041, -0.019385801628232002, -0.031526077538728714, 0.017227718606591225, -0.004093891475349665, -0.02743489108979702, 0.035973433405160904, 0.03006036952137947, 0.0088691720739007, 0.030868474394083023, 0.01464446634054184, 0.01422602217644453, -0.0020575581584125757, 0.0408102311193943, -0.018639473244547844, -0.02271479368209839, 0.018723512068390846, 0.02907118760049343, 0.03892473503947258, 0.06049588695168495, 0.05112895742058754, -0.012220795266330242, -0.00367625686340034, 0.028570739552378654, 0.0030778171494603157, 0.014121404848992825, 0.00437142513692379, 0.059292133897542953, -0.036798007786273956, -0.003522830782458186, 0.017858315259218216, -0.008042245171964169, -0.005187892355024815, 0.03436757251620293, 0.0020140164997428656, -0.03166840970516205, 0.045938171446323395, 0.0032228510826826096, 0.018622498959302902, 0.0199172031134367, 0.0018384970026090741, -0.022154832258820534, -0.03418619930744171, 0.004209935665130615, 0.0380009263753891, -0.015508023090660572, 0.026855560019612312, -0.009895824827253819, -0.017195556312799454, -0.026076434180140495, -0.04087463766336441, -0.022037677466869354, -0.014695359393954277, -0.02214249037206173, -0.010849088430404663, 0.014232303947210312, -0.021949991583824158, -0.02276688814163208, -0.01157218124717474, 0.0376327708363533, 0.05665036290884018, 0.05188637226819992, -0.029108809307217598, 0.04241151362657547, -0.01505573745816946, -0.03807210549712181, -0.007728889584541321, -0.01365834940224886, -0.018374387174844742, -0.0010947042610496283, 0.056581176817417145, 0.025616561993956566, -0.037070974707603455, 0.01873527280986309, -0.008465619757771492, 0.04947032779455185, 0.013164377771317959, -0.08772964030504227, -0.06326823681592941, 0.038853660225868225, -0.006185800768435001, 0.0007426866213791072, -0.05225638672709465, -0.003118398366495967, 0.0028152575250715017, 0.05331660062074661, 0.03144019469618797, 0.020511997863650322, 0.04602101445198059, 0.032131269574165344, 0.01572340726852417, -0.022502640262246132, -0.06213390454649925, -0.051016662269830704, 0.011214655824005604, -0.03951413556933403, -0.07006406784057617, 0.018835848197340965, 0.009498707950115204, -0.015610266476869583, 0.016324715688824654, 0.021657133474946022, 0.01292935200035572, 0.01614425703883171, -0.017631052061915398, 0.006157938856631517, -0.022541621699929237, 0.03241213783621788, 0.017701420933008194, 0.022596312686800957, 0.011715048924088478, -0.028278978541493416, -0.011987622827291489, 0.005833667237311602, 0.024939890950918198, 0.022112982347607613, -0.013323330320417881, -0.0031795804388821125, -0.035010818392038345, 0.029079046100378036, 0.0191482026129961, -0.013913650996983051, -0.04567680507898331, -0.0031420267187058926, -0.005790022201836109, 0.005219802260398865, 0.04181976616382599, -0.007272298913449049, -0.02515021152794361, -0.01298853475600481, -0.05398596078157425, -0.05796525254845619, -0.041927192360162735, -0.009684446267783642, -0.039021119475364685, 0.006158008240163326, 0.005433864891529083, -0.0226163100451231, 0.03866114094853401, -0.011037100106477737, -0.01839834824204445, -0.017992233857512474, 0.004024282097816467, 0.048958566039800644, -0.022100107744336128, 0.009272407740354538, 0.031067930161952972, 0.016435176134109497, -0.044243600219488144, 0.04818336293101311, -0.015038032084703445, -0.04801642894744873, 0.004886573646217585, -0.05547896400094032, -0.02058989368379116, -0.01563446596264839, -0.01558710541576147, 0.022271761670708656, 0.011243538931012154, 0.004243760369718075, 0.01620708592236042, -0.06034526973962784, 0.07504340261220932, 0.05912597477436066, 0.0015828774776309729, 0.017641820013523102, 0.0013176039792597294, 0.027873098850250244, 0.049987904727458954, -0.016327865421772003, 0.010446373373270035, -0.042538370937108994, -0.02376355044543743, 0.04018034785985947, 0.00945368129760027, -0.04116985574364662, 0.0002508196921553463, 0.0634537935256958, 0.00668633496388793, 0.014715132303535938, 0.00005378026980906725, 0.008896272629499435, -0.00040040657040663064, 0.010853207670152187, 0.01711159385740757, 0.008771701715886593, -0.0001555867784190923, 0.0169272068887949, -0.01657518371939659, 0.013391154818236828, 0.015093866735696793, -0.007709871511906385, 0.03673180192708969, 0.00048599016736261547, 0.01555793359875679, -0.00928683765232563, -0.0279853418469429, 0.0467531718313694, -0.020082734525203705, 0.026956429705023766, 0.0143922483548522, 0.03186393156647682, 0.014658473432064056, 0.01305185817182064, -0.008053836412727833, 0.010555325075984001, 0.024319348856806755, -0.05726093426346779, 0.0032746416982263327, 0.021312594413757324, -0.04322073608636856, -0.0019759219139814377, -0.030097203329205513, -0.027549881488084793, -0.033940207213163376, 0.0024904117453843355, 0.028966274112462997, -0.010656015947461128, 0.0406666025519371, -0.035698503255844116, -0.01557173952460289, -0.023818613961338997, -0.007414580788463354, 0.016667675226926804, -0.002125937258824706, -0.024009263142943382, -0.006056096870452166, -0.03869928792119026, -0.0033035376109182835, 0.07161583751440048, -0.038858793675899506, -0.011093002744019032, 0.04702375456690788, 0.01826384663581848, -0.031053557991981506, -0.06417078524827957, -0.04806682839989662, 0.04041096940636635, -0.0009688982972875237, -0.006296648643910885, 0.04805098474025726, 0.044977691024541855, -0.07338761538267136, 0.0516330823302269, -0.019973764196038246, -0.019016923382878304, -0.03828461468219757, -0.006765749771147966, -0.018071651458740234, -0.00987150613218546, -0.011831485666334629, 0.025136826559901237, -0.020533546805381775, 0.008235672488808632, -0.0477244071662426, -0.0453777015209198, 0.052409201860427856, 0.003118539461866021, 0.02731398679316044, 0.00044374860590323806, -0.03616594150662422, 0.08899319916963577, 0.03971152752637863, -0.012244993820786476, -0.07973423600196838, -0.01255006343126297, -0.02321002259850502, -0.04523947462439537, 0.012002508156001568, 0.011911427602171898, 0.0037594069726765156, 0.05145426094532013, 0.033687811344861984, 0.01523861475288868, 0.07401125878095627, -0.055070824921131134, -0.010750778950750828, 0.017453016713261604, 0.013458246365189552, 0.004322531167417765, 0.014095895923674107, -0.005037146154791117, 0.006973209325224161, 0.018447013571858406, 0.016120022162795067, 0.013658312149345875, -0.017906833440065384, -0.031962744891643524, 0.0415455661714077, -0.015505163930356503, 0.024831436574459076, -0.03851807117462158, 0.02731916680932045, 0.006753438152372837, -0.02711666002869606, -0.05304888263344765, 0.03897329792380333, 0.038490261882543564, -0.014260011725127697, 0.044126927852630615, 0.03616708517074585, 0.060494132339954376, -0.01767759956419468, -0.025423264130949974, -0.02421978861093521, -0.0022332933731377125, 0.0074595180340111256, 0.017004001885652542, -0.026396701112389565, 0.051063355058431625, 0.039134807884693146, 0.008363809436559677, 0.02775862067937851, -0.06881366670131683, 0.008061726577579975, -0.09659223258495331, -0.014105439186096191, -0.04623998701572418, 0.059616878628730774, 0.021346841007471085, 0.024651585146784782, 0.03528109937906265, -0.020117593929171562, -0.00647093215957284, 0.04238268733024597, -0.04520736262202263, 0.02075490728020668, 0.019475553184747696, -0.029678598046302795, -0.008593867532908916, -0.026176532730460167, -0.019680602476000786, -0.04992467537522316, 0.006904452573508024, 0.007064423058182001, 0.022839834913611412, -0.03313760459423065, 0.013059471733868122, -0.011486216448247433, -0.010842269286513329, -0.022579375654459, 0.016542144119739532, 0.08155226707458496, 0.0021665191743522882, 0.04093782603740692, 0.018422124907374382, 0.003561242949217558, -0.0184470321983099, -0.044622331857681274, 0.027243344113230705, -0.00535993417724967, 0.027339061722159386, 0.010839720256626606, 0.02241375297307968, -0.0651218518614769, 0.029313623905181885, -0.008536241017282009, 0.00037496525328606367, 0.06285833567380905, -0.013268866576254368, -0.024696990847587585, -0.023662708699703217, -0.015867603942751884, 0.037841349840164185, -0.018389128148555756, 0.025723474100232124, 0.0031612361781299114, 0.05433037877082825, 0.02631470188498497, -0.031746651977300644, -0.009385199286043644, 0.07793517410755157, 0.0007180526736192405, -0.013750292360782623, -0.03673368692398071, -0.03574419394135475, 0.007651621010154486, -0.013847139663994312, 0.025706371292471886, 0.0023019295185804367, -0.004078040365129709, 0.017152095213532448, 0.0007899928605183959, -0.015476316213607788, -0.00883106142282486, 0.04096340388059616, 0.04656781628727913, 0.046666644513607025, -0.017533037811517715, -0.025043491274118423, 0.015384904108941555, 0.05864980071783066, 0.02807929925620556, 0.006176413968205452, -0.022026408463716507, -0.08286187797784805, -0.02625769004225731, 0.04470504820346832, 0.06587067991495132, -0.06633397191762924, -0.0030971562955528498, -0.02157299965620041, 0.00014435969933401793, 0.024960923939943314, -0.046089522540569305, 0.04494033753871918, -0.0006181594799272716, 0.012304112315177917, -0.02112010307610035, -0.01789684034883976, -0.04742247611284256, 0.02365870214998722, -0.02465631440281868, 0.0554606169462204, -0.019712623208761215, -0.02051529660820961, -0.02928937040269375, 0.02736872062087059, -0.01109031680971384, 0.04627052694559097, -0.03579117730259895, -0.02842227928340435, -0.012081597000360489, -0.0024746304843574762, -0.005836838390678167, -0.06264820694923401, -0.01484739687293768, -0.022121034562587738, -0.01195197831839323, 0.023772986605763435, 0.0012784757418558002, -0.029138004407286644, 0.009584566578269005, 0.04003917798399925, -0.011382217518985271, -0.001851894659921527, -0.014843180775642395, 0.030097100883722305, 0.056604236364364624, 0.011175712570548058, 0.0763256624341011, 0.045234210789203644, -0.017940344288945198, 0.0351993627846241, -0.0015905069885775447, 0.005327224265784025, -0.022236481308937073, -0.016127439215779305, -0.019467582926154137, -0.025311904028058052, -0.033501673489809036, -0.026036128401756287, 0.004730659071356058, 0.044608473777770996, -0.02650098130106926, -0.033616941422224045, -0.02831672504544258, 0.04268808662891388, 0.018970349803566933, -0.029139436781406403, 0.03613514453172684, 0.019677748903632164, -0.01783999614417553, -0.003125894581899047, -0.023265454918146133, -0.01857512630522251, -0.0062170266173779964, 0.02633979171514511, -0.018938949331641197, 0.024113385006785393, -0.011537597514688969, -0.022430216893553734, 0.003085484728217125, -0.007933123968541622, 0.02715213969349861, 0.0032074693590402603, -0.0014183606253936887, -0.002186697209253907, -0.03554866090416908, 0.007160336710512638, 0.013450512662529945, -0.012575135566294193, 0.01590273715555668, -0.025076519697904587, 0.04788205400109291, -0.010417556390166283, 0.01735258847475052, -0.0851074829697609, -0.005548627581447363, 0.030121097341179848, 0.014144880697131157, -0.021471792832016945, -0.011427655816078186, 0.008263673633337021, -0.034199122339487076, 0.00790376029908657, -0.014143264852464199, 0.0552452988922596, -0.033041395246982574, 0.0009380386327393353, 0.006971052847802639, 0.027470266446471214, 0.08454766869544983, 0.023862097412347794, 0.04006722569465637, 0.0019235779764130712, -0.04441694915294647, -0.026612726971507072, 0.009005886502563953, -0.003084785072132945, -0.04699762165546417, -0.000052326438890304416, -0.034785281866788864, 0.0305545162409544, 0.06358137726783752, -0.01059784647077322, -0.02263777330517769, 0.009343438781797886, -0.02280469238758087, 0.027230700477957726, -0.033961374312639236, 0.02061912976205349, -0.029698234051465988, -0.007821840234100819, 0.008106161840260029, 0.0248350128531456, -0.00873939972370863, -0.03660288825631142, 0.003922210540622473, -0.019940106198191643, -0.05278405919671059, 0.01953500136733055, 0.09121479839086533, -0.0026243794709444046, -0.0008602384477853775, -0.0194571353495121, -0.050949566066265106, 0.0402512401342392, 0.010028459131717682, -0.002021455904468894, 0.01634097471833229, 0.016992295160889626, -0.02711084857583046, -0.023409830406308174, -0.00895184837281704, -0.025372065603733063, 0.04990050941705704, -0.03053979203104973, 0.053166214376688004, 0.024440662935376167, 0.03214579448103905, -0.007456600200384855, -0.031325697898864746, 0.0015978495357558131, -0.04481435939669609, 0.0059834555722773075, 0.0595594123005867, 0.03136054426431656, 0.0020806780084967613, 0.03193434327840805, -0.027238965034484863, 0.05038149654865265, 0.02563631348311901, 0.031228642910718918, 0.04467667639255524, -0.020638588815927505, -0.03203168138861656, -0.042210690677165985, 0.01748548448085785, -0.06282409280538559, -0.008549554273486137, -0.0039314525201916695, -0.04581461474299431, 0.0019439212046563625, 0.03656165674328804, -0.015692997723817825, -0.01649460755288601, -0.015091676265001297, -0.017108693718910217, 0.02239486388862133, 0.028608372434973717, -0.029210204258561134, 0.05585675686597824, 0.013877663761377335, 0.05294899642467499, 0.036589909344911575, 0.02502484619617462, -0.03415905684232712, -0.07073374837636948, -0.01310523971915245, -0.024992022663354874, -0.029685022309422493, 0.04514690488576889, -0.0010484788799658418, -0.02229822799563408, 0.023345541208982468, -0.0007155781495384872, 0.02088676579296589, 0.002855992875993252, 0.02675224281847477, -0.03476053476333618, 0.0689098984003067, -0.000100390832812991, -0.002160703996196389, 0.0021460806019604206, 0.0009649006533436477, 0.12997131049633026, 0.08498918265104294, 0.044726282358169556, -0.06715855002403259, 0.009355277754366398, 0.027266081422567368, -0.004766497761011124, -0.00874236598610878, 0.01033498253673315, 0.011475387960672379, -0.004344012122601271, -0.021131888031959534, 0.033956270664930344, -0.001977255567908287, -0.024690216407179832, 0.030232064425945282, -0.026925992220640182, 0.015262441709637642, 0.04489076882600784, -0.00001526717642263975, 0.02894122712314129, -0.030735492706298828, -0.06666380167007446, 0.02359439991414547, -0.0006373297655954957, -0.029142383486032486, 0.007825561799108982, -0.03579733148217201, -0.010654259473085403, -0.023683615028858185, -0.006770681124180555, 0.00927211344242096, -0.0016190431779250503, -0.012074955739080906, -0.02600081078708172, 0.003930551465600729, -0.015364311635494232, 0.006336921360343695, 0.04271050915122032, 0.015958283096551895, 0.01271942537277937, 0.004092287737876177, 0.03699732944369316, 0.025744199752807617, -0.03246711194515228, -0.028216440230607986, -0.038365673273801804, 0.024100888520479202, -0.000624943757429719, -0.016259679570794106, -0.01298866793513298, 0.0054555549286305904, 0.028143415227532387, -0.06311941891908646, 0.009661728516221046, 0.003689275588840246, 0.04464004188776016, -0.04188644886016846, -0.049715667963027954, -0.038724564015865326, 0.003239245619624853, 0.030990350991487503, 0.04699369892477989, 0.027443960309028625, -0.02353554032742977, -0.02472352609038353, -0.015109069645404816, 0.06113274395465851, 0.030772676691412926, 0.01863951049745083, 0.028714779764413834, -0.02729220502078533, -0.060511574149131775, -0.006382482126355171, 0.036258354783058167, 0.008749923668801785, 0.04628505930304527, -0.030743638053536415, 0.008840342983603477, -0.032739534974098206, -0.050013940781354904, -0.027285004034638405, 0.003433824749663472, 0.0025576516054570675, -0.023950675502419472, -0.009323079138994217, 0.0037556816823780537, -0.020588625222444534, 0.0279469583183527, 0.031241199001669884, -0.030133098363876343, 0.03246635943651199, -0.015131711959838867, -0.07127983123064041, -0.025944704189896584, -0.01438868511468172, 0.0047628856264054775, 0.0011379263596609235, -0.0023460055235773325, 0.064530149102211, 0.008648710325360298, 0.021104533225297928, -0.013820578344166279, 0.03442239388823509, 0.006483936216682196, 0.013655230402946472, 0.021467044949531555, -0.06362903118133545, 0.006060662679374218, -0.014089963398873806, -0.03808814659714699, -0.046368952840566635, -0.013760306872427464, -0.044600531458854675, -0.01970987394452095, 0.06251419335603714, -0.009852154180407524, -0.06523757427930832, 0.03425068408250809, -0.03716936707496643, 0.02874959446489811, -0.041240084916353226, 0.020736530423164368, -0.03637727349996567, -0.011619197204709053, -0.05479900911450386, -0.053602881729602814, 0.019653916358947754, 0.01400109101086855, -0.009740745648741722, -0.0034795901738107204, 0.037033628672361374, 0.015699945390224457, 0.023741891607642174, -0.02646590769290924, 0.001493839779868722, -0.013187658041715622, 0.047586388885974884, -0.06217098981142044, -0.061180684715509415, 0.029782287776470184, -0.041516177356243134, -0.017796030268073082, -0.003570430912077427, -0.02347760647535324, 0.008836948312819004, 0.042864296585321426, -0.02204635739326477, -0.00592894246801734, 0.06575219333171844, -0.02456439658999443, 0.000874483841471374, 0.021804196760058403, 0.04826357588171959, 0.028239810839295387, -0.022710956633090973, -0.03037215769290924, 0.025353819131851196, 0.011551328003406525, 0.028595494106411934, 0.05564695969223976, 0.015311217866837978, -0.03644935414195061, 0.028023043647408485, 0.004283891059458256, 0.027839383110404015, 0.013321521691977978, 0.007812559604644775, 0.003839771030470729, 0.02910313755273819, -0.041404616087675095, 0.013318752869963646, -0.03592575713992119, 0.01072876900434494, -0.06946030259132385, -0.0021356733050197363, -0.015205216594040394, 0.01398438774049282, 0.0244972575455904, -0.052371639758348465, 0.010369043797254562, 0.02508767507970333, -0.04329352825880051, 0.023714514449238777, 0.0023119074758142233, 0.015343491919338703, -0.04591405391693115, 0.0041573732160031796, -0.004754810594022274, -0.004674674943089485, 0.039516448974609375, 0.022282103076577187, 0.01608581654727459, 0.019520947709679604, 0.007174838334321976, -0.05400286242365837, -0.020923102274537086, 0.03807297348976135, -0.02685718797147274, -0.04266751930117607, 0.058912165462970734, -0.005696927662938833, -0.06282303482294083, 0.007324642036110163, -0.0026559303514659405, 0.02301947772502899, 0.019267845898866653, 0.031165016815066338, 0.022012686356902122, 0.030829815194010735, 0.01768883317708969, -0.03494922071695328, 0.015212057158350945, 0.006705898325890303, -0.005467511713504791, 0.014255126006901264, -0.015934515744447708, 0.04965101182460785, 0.009718663990497589, -0.003044571727514267, -0.06991507112979889, 0.011431955732405186, -0.03218581900000572, -0.020419778302311897, -0.009019599296152592, -0.0051681301556527615, 0.013340837322175503, -0.030992988497018814, -0.03203055262565613, -0.01685040444135666, 0.01607181690633297, 0.043626006692647934, -0.014762410894036293, -0.023571493104100227, 0.0018010122003033757, -0.012227718718349934, -0.04145566374063492, -0.005612396635115147, -0.0007998754736036062, -0.0100489417091012, -0.03980325162410736, 0.012691638432443142, 0.04415197670459747, 0.011788773350417614, -0.042002122849226, -0.02174171805381775, 0.0035303120967000723, 0.058163121342659, -0.013173074461519718, 0.02542891539633274, 0.017017973586916924, -0.047900572419166565, -0.017524344846606255, -0.11464672535657883, 0.07053641974925995, -0.012060830369591713, -0.04785057157278061, -0.0030129756778478622, -0.014806228689849377, -0.03372076898813248, 0.012174428440630436, 0.04223977401852608, 0.02323620207607746, -0.0021768142469227314, -0.0013363128527998924, 0.043295033276081085, -0.01321723498404026, -0.019596487283706665, 0.048659056425094604, -0.0299009308218956, -0.021076403558254242, 0.007211139425635338, -0.0279166828840971, -0.0003278417862020433, 0.02014227584004402, 0.01753002591431141, 0.0033268355764448643, 0.016410717740654945, 0.0024657801259309053, 0.0009627239196561277, 0.04477259889245033, -0.008827795274555683, -0.0013467601966112852, 0.027697395533323288, 0.0203302763402462, 0.013294912874698639, 0.027966590598225594, 0.009826011024415493, -0.035561736673116684, 0.04191268980503082, -0.05051491782069206, -0.03716717287898064, -0.002380496123805642, 0.03699927404522896, -0.004605678841471672, -0.03436822071671486, -0.0011319478508085012, 0.06961187720298767, -0.043054111301898956, -0.01232408732175827, 0.03151003643870354, 0.0301979910582304, 0.016251424327492714, 0.023633617907762527, 0.017239294946193695, 0.03044106625020504, -0.008128644898533821, -0.021914303302764893, 0.00189902912825346, 0.018037326633930206, 0.025894714519381523, 0.0162085872143507, 0.02228633500635624, -0.023385662585496902, 0.033102139830589294, -0.02885790914297104, 0.04150984063744545, -0.06352514773607254, -0.023981336504220963, 0.0007500391802750528, -0.0030932489316910505, -0.030849521979689598, -0.0308680459856987, -0.002944013336673379, 0.037000857293605804, -0.028775516897439957, 0.00849483534693718, -0.02332257479429245, -0.038727495819330215, 0.007257331162691116, -0.0050681838765740395, 0.0037393085658550262, 0.00664729718118906, -0.0021259377244859934, -0.010298997163772583, -0.018113667145371437, -0.01247580535709858, 0.011324191465973854, -0.011148063465952873, 0.008939825929701328, -0.012349145486950874, -0.014499693177640438, -0.0012658521300181746, -0.005001290235668421, -0.03199130296707153, -0.0168872382491827, 0.006987340748310089, 0.04078693687915802, 0.022392040118575096, -0.06450964510440826, -0.025702646002173424, -0.006841911002993584, 0.03841855004429817, -0.044648393988609314, 0.0021290755830705166, -0.011420896276831627, 0.021774977445602417, 0.020963134244084358, -0.0015807163435965776 ]
<p>Let's say I'm computing some model parameters my minimizing the sum squared residuals, and I'm assuming my errors are Gaussian. My model produces analytical derivatives, so the optimizer does not need to use finite differences. Once the fit is complete, I want to calculate standard errors of the fitted parameters.</p> <p>Generally, in this situation, the Hessian of the error function is taken to be related to the covariance matrix by: $$ \sigma^2 H^{-1} = C $$ where $\sigma^2$ is the variance of the residuals.</p> <p>When no analytical derivatives of the error are available, it is typically impractical to compute the Hessian, so $J^TJ$ is taken as a good approximation.</p> <p>However, in my case, I've got an analytical J, so it's relatively cheap for me to compute H by finite differencing J.</p> <p>So, my question is this: Would it be more accurate to approximate H using my exact J and applying the above approximation, or to approximate H by finite differencing J?</p>
74,480
[ 0.017531126737594604, 0.0015775634674355388, -0.028814595192670822, -0.0014954347861930728, 0.026585465297102928, 0.039413172751665115, -0.020546656101942062, -0.026123732328414917, 0.053841616958379745, -0.02366253361105919, 0.00934357289224863, 0.0069359466433525085, 0.0671476423740387, -0.009390618652105331, 0.047751832753419876, -0.011075103655457497, -0.020400306209921837, -0.02336944080889225, -0.010170331224799156, 0.006231865379959345, -0.00537071330472827, 0.027266373857855797, -0.024053314700722694, -0.02036598138511181, -0.058013249188661575, 0.011621760204434395, 0.019261259585618973, -0.0032793746795505285, 0.020344113931059837, 0.04406508058309555, -0.05378943309187889, -0.011130563914775848, 0.03923074156045914, 0.06939011812210083, 0.028436237946152687, 0.004608058370649815, -0.0331055149435997, -0.02697196789085865, -0.015801049768924713, 0.025646673515439034, -0.044631317257881165, -0.05131244659423828, -0.0038295616395771503, 0.053438205271959305, -0.0011304353829473257, 0.011979378759860992, -0.034004662185907364, -0.052677448838949203, 0.044905200600624084, -0.030068352818489075, 0.07209958136081696, 0.010744499042630196, 0.03299330174922943, 0.01900883950293064, -0.02377428114414215, 0.00860427413135767, 0.04679432883858681, 0.04866057634353638, 0.011161484755575657, -0.08094723522663116, -0.01702800765633583, -0.020830655470490456, 0.00294112553820014, -0.04054418206214905, -0.005685668904334307, 0.017063762992620468, -0.007110957056283951, -0.06047823280096054, 0.008274746127426624, -0.03502935916185379, -0.006270240526646376, 0.02772538736462593, 0.02578510157763958, -0.02698059193789959, 0.030766919255256653, -0.015203982591629028, 0.015714827924966812, 0.05466887354850769, 0.04768625274300575, 0.012907854281365871, 0.035209689289331436, -0.00013698163093067706, 0.02312801592051983, 0.052693214267492294, 0.0036101441364735365, 0.013945692218840122, 0.040208637714385986, -0.01124478317797184, 0.02907530590891838, 0.036924831569194794, 0.0006985709187574685, 0.0328032560646534, 0.06399084627628326, -0.0029747867956757545, -0.010296003893017769, 0.0002837352512869984, -0.010729260742664337, 0.023596525192260742, 0.006263790652155876, -0.010154823772609234, -0.05197611078619957, -0.06810282170772552, -0.014154081232845783, 0.06270375102758408, 0.011006772518157959, -0.032070763409137726, 0.012695892713963985, -0.0026818946935236454, -0.021868562325835228, -0.04489836469292641, 0.007122309412807226, -0.011455520056188107, -0.029011070728302002, -0.009232552722096443, 0.04168488830327988, -0.030236544087529182, -0.029080333188176155, -0.03915034234523773, 0.04710584878921509, 0.06603370606899261, 0.0930551216006279, -0.010753504931926727, 0.03644990548491478, -0.03280982747673988, -0.05530098080635071, 0.025247175246477127, 0.033132437616586685, -0.047557488083839417, -0.07156631350517273, 0.012181994505226612, 0.007063078228384256, -0.024118874222040176, 0.0033417853992432356, 0.004165252670645714, -0.004540883004665375, -0.016267230734229088, -0.08625893294811249, -0.06573747843503952, -0.004913454409688711, -0.01104617491364479, 0.03912389650940895, -0.07592561095952988, -0.031092122197151184, 0.044249825179576874, 0.02525886707007885, 0.001531188958324492, 0.03805338591337204, 0.010544095188379288, 0.040158938616514206, -0.006827772594988346, -0.020691435784101486, -0.023355914279818535, -0.02055906318128109, -0.0394548736512661, -0.029302669689059258, -0.0462595634162426, 0.015197782777249813, 0.03666054084897041, -0.009173871017992496, 0.016236746683716774, 0.08769859373569489, 0.031533028930425644, -0.012737762182950974, 0.02200726605951786, -0.003413010388612747, -0.03223751112818718, 0.03363856300711632, 0.006179215386509895, 0.06325672566890717, 0.020862607285380363, 0.00016552084707655013, 0.00016095172031782568, 0.010672195814549923, 0.016448672860860825, 0.02993045374751091, -0.030463647097349167, 0.005160726141184568, -0.025113709270954132, 0.0013313848758116364, 0.020133018493652344, -0.03160940483212471, -0.009769237600266933, 0.011445519514381886, -0.0173842404037714, 0.00016754193347878754, 0.05450239032506943, 0.02008689008653164, 0.005698485299944878, 0.0005255733267404139, -0.04187851399183273, -0.019990911707282066, -0.0610320046544075, 0.01794675923883915, 0.011594162322580814, -0.007054552435874939, 0.04983935132622719, -0.012941094115376472, 0.027191398665308952, 0.03233146294951439, -0.015755143016576767, 0.006172870751470327, 0.005815971177071333, 0.035305824130773544, -0.033142246305942535, 0.03220261260867119, 0.031986482441425323, 0.044662825763225555, 0.01904027722775936, 0.07371228188276291, -0.03037385828793049, -0.059287380427122116, -0.017045965418219566, -0.03088349848985672, 0.022661561146378517, 0.01650630310177803, -0.025944361463189125, -0.019295979291200638, -0.0454774871468544, -0.014634222723543644, 0.02473069168627262, -0.06179658696055412, 0.06173470616340637, 0.08560660481452942, 0.03919567912817001, -0.013797522522509098, 0.0047541107051074505, 0.009318912401795387, -0.009715545922517776, -0.0024833206553012133, -0.0008279679459519684, -0.034962937235832214, 0.0036941186990588903, 0.04749144986271858, 0.060293909162282944, -0.06830695271492004, -0.01709999330341816, 0.050457168370485306, 0.019620077684521675, 0.03565981239080429, 0.03146674856543541, -0.037382710725069046, -0.02119448408484459, 0.038383882492780685, 0.015916988253593445, 0.0084011759608984, 0.026160193607211113, 0.01608714461326599, 0.014896872453391552, 0.0311635360121727, 0.006328424904495478, 0.003851930610835552, 0.043619878590106964, 0.019859276711940765, -0.025482630357146263, 0.006775930058211088, -0.020581606775522232, 0.02665030211210251, -0.028783254325389862, 0.0023210158105939627, 0.021802933886647224, -0.03946607932448387, -0.02496456541121006, -0.00512296287342906, -0.017004985362291336, 0.03429774194955826, -0.021015366539359093, -0.030819647014141083, 0.031939927488565445, 0.018727000802755356, -0.04690850153565407, 0.004064867738634348, -0.06782383471727371, 0.02253751829266548, -0.020701376721262932, 0.008836963213980198, 0.030384747311472893, 0.013037165626883507, 0.0010810160310938954, 0.01604335382580757, -0.03411400690674782, 0.0015208243858069181, -0.02216934598982334, 0.008654696866869926, 0.015338904224336147, -0.02925034798681736, -0.002877237042412162, -0.0627225860953331, -0.006755647249519825, 0.04269122704863548, -0.019056614488363266, 0.04223961383104324, -0.00038206775207072496, 0.00005347104524844326, -0.019213270395994186, -0.02073042094707489, 0.03079007938504219, 0.009889476001262665, 0.0030294612515717745, -0.02392045594751835, 0.008837299421429634, -0.0008569755009375513, -0.00840802863240242, 0.051836881786584854, -0.04784029349684715, -0.022544749081134796, -0.045074012130498886, 0.015512349084019661, 0.002322223735973239, -0.016839023679494858, 0.01628350466489792, 0.004811474122107029, -0.008023063652217388, -0.013336824253201485, -0.06970451772212982, -0.05713033303618431, 0.005782559514045715, 0.03950014337897301, 0.006417519878596067, 0.0036913377698510885, -0.031709883362054825, 0.0998021811246872, 0.03878118842840195, -0.019065789878368378, -0.01094376016408205, -0.009238891303539276, -0.0248017106205225, -0.03720070794224739, 0.0067762527614831924, -0.033082328736782074, 0.007570231799036264, 0.024874748662114143, -0.009959555231034756, -0.0010284449672326446, 0.07163230329751968, -0.00610003899782896, 0.0005532072973437607, 0.002008761977776885, -0.011204994283616543, -0.003053033258765936, 0.03438660502433777, -0.0006983020575717092, -0.0011918575037270784, 0.013998866081237793, 0.04509952664375305, 0.02512141317129135, 0.011465140618383884, -0.05536480247974396, 0.020218079909682274, -0.0349850133061409, 0.006030766759067774, -0.02901463955640793, 0.031667888164520264, 0.039002079516649246, -0.01392438169568777, -0.010054046288132668, 0.0256317351013422, -0.016601858660578728, -0.026424163952469826, 0.014169069938361645, 0.015734398737549782, 0.03342720493674278, 0.004673808813095093, -0.009362207725644112, -0.00968961976468563, 0.002780039794743061, 0.023654257878661156, -0.04233016446232796, -0.043933235108852386, 0.03385704755783081, 0.013495370745658875, -0.008957370184361935, -0.007059806492179632, -0.0541858971118927, 0.009126124903559685, -0.08286383002996445, 0.009836425073444843, 0.01618805155158043, 0.08078692108392715, -0.02093038521707058, 0.04865420237183571, -0.01884602941572666, 0.01772584207355976, 0.016105806455016136, -0.01360333152115345, -0.05656283348798752, 0.06255091726779938, -0.01475400011986494, -0.03174830228090286, 0.017307059839367867, -0.03955598175525665, 0.00937669351696968, -0.003698073560371995, 0.04579723998904228, -0.004393392708152533, 0.028191164135932922, -0.004038459621369839, 0.010168123990297318, -0.026108331978321075, -0.0261803288012743, -0.024836264550685883, 0.028038453310728073, 0.03814120963215828, -0.012590454891324043, 0.010536336340010166, 0.007924267090857029, -0.009723261930048466, -0.018624627962708473, -0.020726937800645828, 0.02329835668206215, 0.015932688489556313, 0.052466537803411484, 0.046395979821681976, 0.041905906051397324, -0.009908919222652912, 0.026455162093043327, -0.004913700744509697, 0.061375487595796585, 0.020684709772467613, 0.005421044770628214, -0.003370370715856552, -0.029812408611178398, -0.03666716441512108, -0.002404619939625263, 0.032884567975997925, -0.002650558017194271, 0.010869638994336128, 0.05084539204835892, 0.02136196196079254, 0.010215271264314651, 0.003167435061186552, 0.04649500921368599, 0.030164023861289024, -0.009255279786884785, -0.030681993812322617, -0.003428399097174406, -0.02055087313055992, 0.005053807515650988, 0.025941960513591766, 0.020591428503394127, -0.0018426423193886876, 0.0005065702134743333, 0.006596706807613373, -0.023980194702744484, 0.015442542731761932, 0.004421915393322706, 0.07963625341653824, 0.04112374037504196, 0.008912592194974422, 0.025553610175848007, 0.01334761455655098, 0.07155005633831024, 0.05654662102460861, -0.0008018556400202215, 0.016238121315836906, -0.0769294798374176, -0.006105196196585894, 0.020729273557662964, 0.0385378859937191, -0.031932391226291656, 0.00280990032479167, -0.012187874875962734, -0.017936812713742256, 0.06304647773504257, -0.0190869327634573, 0.047606971114873886, -0.010193564929068089, 0.010298088192939758, 0.0023626310285180807, -0.017823476344347, -0.055540382862091064, 0.019810227677226067, 0.020164774730801582, 0.031935594975948334, -0.03377876803278923, -0.011288230307400227, -0.061360280960798264, 0.01038264762610197, 0.012904027476906776, 0.0533670149743557, -0.012285605072975159, -0.004157328978180885, 0.014406794682145119, 0.014962824061512947, -0.004307824186980724, -0.060119353234767914, -0.018253309652209282, -0.00410718796774745, -0.0314028263092041, 0.03339843079447746, -0.010988187044858932, -0.01218352559953928, 0.061647024005651474, -0.013876905664801598, 0.008361934684216976, -0.022407373413443565, 0.02222343720495701, 0.015371727757155895, 0.052421458065509796, 0.013944474048912525, 0.03714584931731224, 0.022330818697810173, -0.00510377436876297, 0.002913702977821231, -0.03750818967819214, 0.007133780512958765, -0.004344428423792124, -0.05592506378889084, -0.03778151422739029, -0.021648991852998734, -0.006931954994797707, 0.014101993292570114, -0.0195822361856699, 0.04219963401556015, -0.04905090853571892, -0.026857491582632065, 0.02762410044670105, 0.07012689113616943, -0.016840700060129166, -0.006780015304684639, -0.012213647365570068, 0.05230448767542839, -0.0028888643719255924, -0.03880276530981064, -0.004013897851109505, -0.045061592012643814, 0.012251755222678185, 0.04767485335469246, -0.03699394688010216, 0.0025630260352045298, -0.014616486616432667, -0.027164526283740997, 0.018841618672013283, -0.017545700073242188, 0.015058156102895737, -0.03839584067463875, 0.02490871585905552, 0.016088830307126045, -0.06835506856441498, 0.019468067213892937, -0.02759723924100399, -0.011149133555591106, 0.03866514563560486, -0.021381070837378502, 0.009667170234024525, -0.011995897628366947, -0.010045497678220272, -0.08049944043159485, -0.015925545245409012, 0.007918615825474262, 0.01718703657388687, -0.07239675521850586, -0.0027182819321751595, -0.004280290100723505, -0.05512450262904167, -0.032157812267541885, -0.04285233095288277, 0.07234333455562592, -0.006401525344699621, -0.01987491175532341, 0.023983849212527275, 0.019466400146484375, 0.059950895607471466, -0.016707831993699074, 0.030686751008033752, 0.039399854838848114, -0.05139255151152611, -0.032226964831352234, 0.020472057163715363, 0.059578459709882736, -0.02380977012217045, 0.02731136791408062, -0.014063196256756783, -0.020968392491340637, 0.05272651091217995, 0.00838487222790718, -0.03498635068535805, 0.055634040385484695, 0.004375175107270479, 0.005254343152046204, -0.0011977559188380837, 0.015251580625772476, -0.02662360854446888, 0.035615209490060806, 0.0026302270125597715, 0.004346699919551611, 0.037167247384786606, 0.007540039252489805, -0.009696906432509422, 0.015758942812681198, -0.04252907261252403, 0.014345395378768444, 0.0764232873916626, -0.05148990824818611, -0.0038312494289129972, 0.04606969654560089, 0.005414455197751522, 0.053198084235191345, 0.009271183982491493, 0.029081866145133972, 0.001949971541762352, 0.038500554859638214, -0.017559237778186798, -0.03725530207157135, -0.028706388548016548, 0.03192957863211632, 0.07780878990888596, -0.030583828687667847, 0.015048394910991192, 0.028100576251745224, 0.013895818963646889, -0.025976719334721565, -0.0416283905506134, -0.0507424995303154, -0.007223307620733976, 0.0021972516551613808, 0.034898966550827026, 0.019507916644215584, -0.030672337859869003, 0.04876881092786789, -0.007985719479620457, 0.0016220388934016228, 0.04594158008694649, -0.011926332488656044, 0.03723961487412453, -0.005797135643661022, -0.00412984611466527, -0.031121959909796715, 0.016102511435747147, -0.03638298436999321, 0.013697884976863861, -0.044247712939977646, -0.03210657462477684, 0.021963583305478096, 0.024877319112420082, -0.0021866431925445795, -0.006495728623121977, -0.016957366839051247, -0.029172178357839584, 0.0327310748398304, 0.03573676571249962, -0.023510651662945747, 0.0005209805676713586, 0.02653939090669155, 0.029049653559923172, 0.001377246342599392, 0.07788404822349548, -0.006590960547327995, -0.07970377057790756, -0.010803190059959888, 0.006097142118960619, -0.027855847030878067, 0.023137271404266357, 0.029238084331154823, -0.06901766359806061, 0.0064255609177052975, -0.013980717398226261, 0.047546327114105225, 0.0016277622198686004, 0.016679633408784866, -0.002032801043242216, 0.056117840111255646, 0.00044608095777221024, -0.03824403136968613, -0.001313806977123022, -0.014881960116326809, 0.10285791754722595, 0.04071873798966408, 0.017846902832388878, -0.019489973783493042, 0.027225658297538757, -0.054197411984205246, -0.0125020332634449, -0.0017243018373847008, 0.04049856588244438, 0.0015436232788488269, 0.009521951898932457, 0.023148063570261, 0.018504783511161804, -0.02520960569381714, 0.018592458218336105, 0.03970889002084732, -0.05279666557908058, -0.025350501760840416, -0.012515326030552387, 0.017979279160499573, 0.008920202031731606, 0.0021563817281275988, -0.02292354591190815, 0.010295283980667591, -0.01784384623169899, -0.011622215621173382, -0.034896787256002426, -0.040057223290205, -0.017997076734900475, -0.0050748782232403755, -0.07741235196590424, 0.019773736596107483, 0.020631037652492523, 0.040525294840335846, -0.04352295771241188, 0.0382419116795063, 0.0075982194393873215, -0.00018656895554158837, 0.018034692853689194, 0.03212535381317139, 0.02526218816637993, -0.003796574892476201, 0.008218932896852493, -0.017255406826734543, -0.038309961557388306, -0.025198008865118027, -0.05696377903223038, 0.02836482785642147, -0.0001649900950724259, 0.0027072206139564514, -0.009336849674582481, -0.02231580764055252, 0.03189990669488907, -0.044363025575876236, -0.021186642348766327, 0.0012018439592793584, 0.016493631526827812, -0.013322586193680763, -0.0025603249669075012, -0.0014471930917352438, 0.039454419165849686, 0.014027660712599754, -0.015952255576848984, 0.04002132639288902, -0.03915847837924957, -0.015435246750712395, 0.0055709281004965305, 0.056763097643852234, -0.016620725393295288, -0.028229281306266785, -0.017176005989313126, -0.041114188730716705, -0.030357999727129936, -0.04122466966509819, 0.014421189203858376, 0.01173477340489626, 0.045174967497587204, -0.012126819230616093, -0.0018344607669860125, -0.010385152883827686, -0.0837007388472557, 0.02157682552933693, 0.007814510725438595, 0.02888631448149681, -0.04197040945291519, -0.023450950160622597, 0.02563198283314705, -0.01738988421857357, 0.005590515211224556, -0.0006217919872142375, 0.015864040702581406, 0.04104018956422806, 0.009354791603982449, -0.017867524176836014, -0.03300941735506058, -0.014132934622466564, -0.00898708961904049, 0.02014792151749134, -0.003384079784154892, 0.040043722838163376, 0.02755076251924038, 0.06435057520866394, -0.020700333639979362, 0.05800944194197655, -0.02155749499797821, 0.05907071754336357, 0.01050789188593626, -0.03502687066793442, -0.010597080923616886, 0.02634240873157978, 0.008617445826530457, -0.043078839778900146, 0.022590337321162224, -0.06410705298185349, -0.015283705666661263, -0.02146732434630394, 0.013980340212583542, -0.028706248849630356, 0.015196931548416615, -0.030434196814894676, 0.012985344044864178, -0.027654044330120087, 0.013932660222053528, -0.03425176441669464, 0.02098698914051056, -0.013929536566138268, -0.0004730249347630888, -0.0042823380790650845, -0.010095174424350262, -0.027957171201705933, -0.019675912335515022, 0.036876194179058075, 0.00944493431597948, 0.050415992736816406, -0.031339965760707855, 0.0009295793133787811, -0.012690906412899494, 0.01887870766222477, -0.03834070265293121, 0.008186503313481808, 0.002082845428958535, -0.04795220494270325, -0.052950117737054825, -0.001012238091789186, 0.00331916194409132, 0.011283746920526028, -0.0018713459139689803, -0.03407803922891617, -0.039990633726119995, 0.025830117985606194, -0.025913240388035774, 0.029567690566182137, -0.006440156605094671, 0.011421114206314087, -0.011352338828146458, -0.043412696570158005, 0.01889721490442753, -0.021702809259295464, 0.02551499754190445, 0.01316170021891594, 0.0005417651846073568, -0.01073989737778902, 0.008300128392875195, 0.010127225890755653, 0.0002394023904344067, -0.01049098465591669, 0.01075721811503172, -0.00028317191754467785, -0.012715756893157959, 0.04324939101934433, -0.016169792041182518, -0.008394940756261349, 0.005993818864226341, 0.051939934492111206, -0.09365366399288177, 0.008763360790908337, -0.003469571005553007, -0.0014720575418323278, 0.02237609401345253, -0.0510714054107666, 0.0069845071993768215, 0.03408360853791237, -0.050587594509124756, 0.01965019293129444, -0.051001764833927155, -0.023249551653862, -0.0024112307000905275, -0.012424838729202747, -0.021889984607696533, 0.03257622569799423, 0.02308964729309082, -0.009487686678767204, 0.02217775397002697, -0.018992716446518898, -0.004490095656365156, -0.032128918915987015, -0.005654250271618366, 0.03830623999238014, 0.013942684046924114, -0.05126180872321129, 0.019154053181409836, -0.010210243985056877, -0.06093953922390938, -0.005196862388402224, -0.027021192014217377, 0.03008044883608818, -0.028688492253422737, 0.041717663407325745, -0.0008556591928936541, 0.045682940632104874, 0.02496388740837574, 0.013654272072017193, 0.002222667681053281, -0.005723533220589161, 0.0060801575891673565, 0.02032720111310482, -0.02883758209645748, 0.015039784833788872, -0.0021319659426808357, -0.010950525291264057, -0.05630750209093094, -0.004940687213093042, 0.021991385146975517, -0.04732522740960121, -0.0061445836909115314, 0.00995697546750307, 0.017378833144903183, -0.02144789882004261, 0.020296579226851463, -0.01719007082283497, 0.011514978483319283, 0.040533896535634995, 0.01735733263194561, -0.045293036848306656, 0.02756658010184765, -0.02226024679839611, -0.05527716130018234, 0.009257753379642963, -0.002850705524906516, -0.04664546623826027, -0.05004950612783432, -0.02816079929471016, -0.00038208498153835535, -0.013925484381616116, -0.007193265948444605, 0.0014332033460959792, -0.03208136558532715, 0.06154733523726463, -0.0051587787456810474, -0.013805989176034927, 0.003894972149282694, -0.026280146092176437, 0.009647902101278305, -0.06599600613117218, 0.06381408870220184, -0.004932604264467955, -0.0901789516210556, 0.02230035327374935, 0.0006266586133278906, -0.0143975131213665, 0.035314857959747314, 0.09014806151390076, -0.008523033000528812, 0.004343145526945591, 0.010164153762161732, 0.01535053737461567, -0.02987530827522278, -0.027281567454338074, 0.032639529556035995, -0.001470470568165183, 0.0039879013784229755, 0.0018227467080578208, -0.0007986482232809067, -0.0005126550677232444, 0.0379735492169857, -0.00884078536182642, 0.0057793669402599335, 0.02915106900036335, -0.008941451087594032, -0.020253557711839676, 0.05095979943871498, 0.006843913812190294, -0.03169221803545952, 0.056165795773267746, 0.0013635209761559963, 0.012335014529526234, 0.02195614017546177, -0.016430608928203583, -0.041974589228630066, 0.013361112214624882, -0.028984403237700462, -0.008936096914112568, -0.007970442064106464, 0.0155189149081707, -0.0005139550194144249, -0.047678619623184204, 0.01935138925909996, 0.061480168253183365, -0.04005064815282822, 0.009922286495566368, 0.03674841299653053, 0.03611588850617409, -0.00674387626349926, 0.04101698473095894, 0.01408417895436287, 0.041783884167671204, -0.004186342004686594, -0.0029148482717573643, 0.0256208349019289, 0.03615884482860565, 0.023571530357003212, -0.009583631530404091, 0.008142506703734398, -0.03335576876997948, 0.020687906071543694, -0.02139921672642231, -0.008671669289469719, -0.01428564079105854, -0.02883215621113777, 0.00834608729928732, -0.004491692874580622, -0.03508415445685387, -0.03646064177155495, -0.036880407482385635, 0.05914915353059769, -0.041019994765520096, -0.008089009672403336, -0.018798071891069412, -0.0035713971592485905, -0.0010595618514344096, -0.00570776779204607, -0.021898213773965836, 0.024261442944407463, -0.016339268535375595, -0.010736451484262943, -0.009300255216658115, -0.014973676763474941, 0.02415747381746769, -0.032872751355171204, 0.027323424816131592, -0.02187957800924778, 0.03289069980382919, -0.037337545305490494, -0.023027237504720688, -0.06003108620643616, -0.01807756908237934, 0.0369146429002285, 0.04845522344112396, 0.031205620616674423, 0.006586061790585518, -0.046961233019828796, 0.014284363016486168, 0.05728963017463684, -0.0531880185008049, -0.004568409640341997, 0.006910191383212805, -0.020853793248534203, -0.004424089100211859, -0.01384790986776352 ]
<p>My study design involves a control and 2 test groups plus some covariates. Each group consists of around 20 observations. In total I look at around 1,000 variables.</p> <p>I created a linear model using the <code>lm()</code> function in R including 2 covariates. After that I thought I would include another covariate because doing a PCA plot earlier showed a slight effect on that covariate. However, after adding this covariate to the model 50% of the significant hits are now different. I was actually assuming that it would pretty much identical as the effect was hardly seen in the PCA.</p> <p>Could it be that I have overfitted the model? Or is the effect simple just not shown in the PCA plot but is there?</p> <p>I just compared the two models using <code>anova(lm1, lm2)</code> and the p-value is significant which I think means that the third covariate adds significant information to the model?</p> <pre><code>lm1 &lt;- lm(var ~ factor_of_interest + cov1 + cov2) lm2 &lt;- lm(var ~ factor_of_interest + cov1 + cov2 + cov3) anova(lm1, lm2) </code></pre>
49,662
[ -0.02690288983285427, 0.03203316405415535, -0.024317199364304543, 0.009899765253067017, 0.07741398364305496, 0.022408686578273773, -0.007089328020811081, -0.041341207921504974, 0.05224603787064552, -0.03985365480184555, 0.04828667268157005, 0.04748652130365372, 0.08116213977336884, -0.003391070757061243, 0.021557338535785675, 0.001395666622556746, 0.012462656013667583, -0.011381134390830994, 0.014208531938493252, 0.001297355629503727, -0.030739786103367805, 0.03130621090531349, 0.02106202021241188, -0.006323487497866154, -0.002960856771096587, 0.07716424763202667, 0.029709167778491974, -0.035947926342487335, 0.020739683881402016, -0.022194422781467438, -0.02997371181845665, -0.025047127157449722, 0.02466684952378273, 0.01675059273838997, 0.02624231018126011, 0.016386663541197777, 0.005259747616946697, -0.006342536769807339, 0.02179650589823723, 0.047389138489961624, -0.035590775310993195, 0.01080040168017149, 0.0027030850760638714, 0.05304685980081558, 0.0029042321257293224, 0.0013594899792224169, 0.0023897031787782907, -0.02452636882662773, 0.052976127713918686, -0.03839172050356865, 0.05164511501789093, 0.015977654606103897, 0.046976570039987564, 0.07692321389913559, -0.008022581227123737, -0.017502643167972565, 0.04726313427090645, 0.08999845385551453, 0.005472103599458933, -0.06748891621828079, -0.014290913008153439, -0.004081894177943468, 0.001720662578009069, -0.01985010877251625, -0.04859460890293121, 0.024625686928629875, 0.017541373148560524, -0.017947280779480934, 0.027111293748021126, -0.026158347725868225, 0.04910534992814064, -0.012754539959132671, 0.016329612582921982, 0.00680709071457386, 0.018277104943990707, -0.013156146742403507, 0.002985746832564473, -0.023762112483382225, 0.015689047053456306, 0.045106712728738785, 0.0005604480393230915, 0.023595580831170082, 0.0017237166175618768, 0.04877066612243652, 0.011089881882071495, 0.000351549155311659, 0.044856298714876175, -0.026932556182146072, 0.0020370366983115673, -0.00680424552410841, -0.06046400964260101, 0.011904837563633919, 0.06039152294397354, 0.011258634738624096, -0.02095593325793743, 0.056494083255529404, -0.02483188733458519, 0.040004853159189224, 0.013300709426403046, -0.01278766244649887, -0.058553293347358704, -0.022505447268486023, 0.05123722553253174, 0.04522528871893883, -0.013143545016646385, -0.022615477442741394, -0.038685064762830734, -0.009572154842317104, -0.011051233857870102, -0.03180527314543724, -0.011782546527683735, 0.025858920067548752, -0.006522787269204855, 0.003863312304019928, 0.006911229807883501, -0.04877199977636337, 0.0018583901692181826, 0.00345806498080492, 0.07491406053304672, 0.05200671777129173, 0.0450618639588356, -0.03699482977390289, 0.010630384087562561, -0.030437316745519638, -0.01537587121129036, 0.0010790101950988173, 0.0013523204252123833, -0.017627902328968048, -0.04277700185775757, 0.05982021614909172, -0.021256793290376663, -0.00962017197161913, 0.006254465319216251, -0.012338845059275627, 0.03459659218788147, -0.03601670265197754, -0.09345312416553497, -0.038941387087106705, 0.034755486994981766, -0.021807922050356865, 0.0060971020720899105, -0.07557659596204758, -0.011914297007024288, 0.01581190712749958, 0.056979380548000336, -0.010007611475884914, -0.008110275492072105, 0.03428104147315025, 0.027811331674456596, -0.0007962608360685408, -0.021563518792390823, 0.004418844357132912, -0.06335707008838654, -0.032191406935453415, -0.0484079085290432, -0.11715944856405258, -0.015661293640732765, 0.01686430722475052, 0.024214470759034157, 0.02691175416111946, 0.024445580318570137, 0.008506120182573795, -0.0038376636803150177, -0.01740994304418564, -0.008278938010334969, -0.025464102625846863, 0.04761359095573425, -0.021866103634238243, 0.04168654605746269, 0.04798946902155876, -0.006479674484580755, 0.040871284902095795, -0.003538477700203657, 0.03750554844737053, 0.0161421038210392, 0.004219330381602049, 0.017768315970897675, -0.020328279584646225, 0.012834078632295132, 0.040608007460832596, -0.05115815997123718, -0.04775790497660637, -0.019978735595941544, -0.0063547310419380665, 0.028483452275395393, 0.024673858657479286, -0.012874974869191647, -0.016825078055262566, 0.05001136288046837, -0.00753809092566371, -0.05067852512001991, -0.05761239677667618, -0.00177679059561342, -0.013720400631427765, -0.03451360762119293, 0.027599329128861427, 0.01777449995279312, 0.02695859968662262, 0.004649162758141756, 0.003049013437703252, -0.007897610776126385, -0.008581588044762611, 0.054392341524362564, -0.03962936997413635, 0.01736309938132763, 0.014081556349992752, 0.04725223779678345, -0.018545737490057945, 0.05884925648570061, -0.036783367395401, -0.010957199148833752, 0.030736049637198448, -0.024834485724568367, 0.009410562925040722, -0.030690902844071388, 0.007091296371072531, 0.0004278632113710046, 0.02369506098330021, -0.014673391357064247, 0.06983378529548645, -0.07251446694135666, 0.05845075473189354, 0.06786908209323883, -0.015039601363241673, 0.01544041745364666, 0.018817925825715065, 0.009936191141605377, 0.015454337000846863, -0.01955254189670086, 0.016064362600445747, -0.036303482949733734, -0.030891282483935356, 0.07014130800962448, -0.00909165944904089, -0.011666492559015751, -0.003914281725883484, 0.04565873369574547, 0.01702246442437172, 0.012702752836048603, 0.044248126447200775, 0.029060369357466698, -0.03188411146402359, 0.020236311480402946, 0.049077920615673065, -0.0057637328281998634, -0.016453593969345093, -0.008790325373411179, -0.01879400759935379, 0.05098041519522667, 0.009835976175963879, 0.004369307775050402, 0.07530778646469116, -0.01933709904551506, -0.001312400447204709, -0.032272547483444214, 0.03178202360868454, 0.03328271582722664, 0.017680078744888306, 0.039801761507987976, 0.034646324813365936, -0.003955839201807976, -0.049505073577165604, 0.010818619281053543, -0.04387601837515831, -0.007794463541358709, 0.04032377526164055, -0.03278195485472679, 0.024849385023117065, 0.010967112146317959, -0.035170719027519226, 0.0035179529804736376, -0.03886684030294418, -0.015971820801496506, -0.01879679597914219, 0.03565741330385208, 0.02876933291554451, 0.003035824280232191, 0.039511989802122116, -0.043735865503549576, -0.02135903388261795, -0.0116852056235075, -0.036540061235427856, 0.03193933516740799, -0.011642609722912312, -0.05336980149149895, 0.014358839951455593, -0.005555106792598963, 0.018720483407378197, 0.03001263737678528, -0.04282451421022415, 0.01990414969623089, 0.02609909325838089, -0.035385485738515854, -0.03831029683351517, -0.03965990990400314, -0.03582504764199257, 0.03978057950735092, -0.0029781286139041185, -0.062762051820755, 0.022100606933236122, 0.026785138994455338, -0.036673251539468765, 0.018343092873692513, 0.015128390863537788, 0.02011530101299286, 0.012358840554952621, -0.014366422779858112, 0.023376207798719406, -0.0043426561169326305, 0.010303117334842682, 0.021098656579852104, -0.03206615149974823, -0.04815907031297684, -0.05439761281013489, -0.030780943110585213, 0.0086292689666152, 0.020741544663906097, 0.02888334169983864, -0.021820461377501488, 0.012998340651392937, 0.055289220064878464, 0.04659919813275337, -0.018532397225499153, -0.043934062123298645, 0.005889652296900749, -0.061480022966861725, -0.018119093030691147, 0.011766038835048676, 0.003863823600113392, 0.008770228363573551, 0.04243132099509239, -0.017438186332583427, 0.008019251748919487, 0.06110203638672829, 0.009925794787704945, -0.01483389362692833, 0.039842650294303894, 0.020332427695393562, -0.019223345443606377, 0.033694665879011154, 0.015383448451757431, 0.003249170258641243, 0.021628927439451218, 0.037047743797302246, 0.017574122175574303, 0.01971214823424816, -0.02844414860010147, 0.025295177474617958, -0.05566931143403053, 0.02811610698699951, -0.058106862008571625, -0.0054374877363443375, 0.030356483533978462, -0.017027221620082855, -0.022527772933244705, 0.024693302810192108, 0.02964525856077671, -0.042885828763246536, 0.0027786155696958303, 0.05153545364737511, 0.00937049463391304, -0.008830105885863304, -0.006179723422974348, -0.04215789586305618, -0.012536394409835339, 0.007044101599603891, 0.01824430376291275, -0.001548156957142055, 0.0375974178314209, 0.028488606214523315, -0.014112989418208599, -0.023684062063694, -0.05766068398952484, 0.005400090012699366, -0.06119102984666824, 0.006724775768816471, -0.05655934661626816, 0.034316182136535645, 0.014789489097893238, 0.03565854951739311, 0.013545190915465355, -0.04504675790667534, -0.006279975175857544, -0.010331304743885994, -0.053320351988077164, 0.03575792908668518, -0.009417165070772171, -0.009115706197917461, 0.01706351339817047, -0.012611106038093567, 0.012199925258755684, 0.011153026483952999, 0.008863256312906742, 0.004736149217933416, 0.012730896472930908, -0.0016040075570344925, -0.01112985797226429, -0.012660644017159939, 0.02637079730629921, -0.02726840227842331, 0.02289506234228611, 0.0005329245468601584, -0.0068220291286706924, 0.037568263709545135, 0.023215027526021004, -0.021176720038056374, 0.0026414182502776384, -0.030616693198680878, -0.013461158610880375, 0.048776548355817795, 0.06095408648252487, 0.013255505822598934, 0.023096920922398567, -0.009991824626922607, 0.0526617132127285, -0.008622805587947369, 0.012454353272914886, 0.0366596020758152, 0.023133844137191772, -0.025145893916487694, -0.05099562928080559, -0.05447782948613167, -0.0026329022366553545, -0.002726708771660924, 0.020263515412807465, -0.009799323044717312, 0.0239892415702343, 0.040969621390104294, -0.04784225672483444, 0.020509807392954826, 0.058877985924482346, 0.030151788145303726, -0.0025326015893369913, -0.04751529172062874, 0.0036500354763120413, -0.011585270054638386, -0.021771924570202827, 0.03966938704252243, 0.010671379044651985, -0.014077707193791866, -0.0038161645643413067, 0.04836086928844452, -0.037422310560941696, -0.029414838179945946, -0.011196702718734741, 0.031183520331978798, 0.03974786028265953, 0.007123761810362339, -0.04743422567844391, -0.0059515866450965405, 0.04372922703623772, 0.00594209972769022, -0.0053220484405756, 0.0017329385736957192, -0.09424887597560883, -0.0007149443845264614, 0.049456726759672165, 0.06875570118427277, -0.024426205083727837, -0.01930948533117771, -0.014075390063226223, -0.011550191789865494, 0.0013265731977298856, -0.053858526051044464, 0.03061370551586151, -0.019009310752153397, 0.033876217901706696, -0.04512786865234375, -0.03854680806398392, -0.09428402781486511, 0.005544974934309721, -0.014745744876563549, 0.03720439225435257, -0.006949498318135738, -0.0375763475894928, -0.028244927525520325, 0.005793872755020857, 0.013669807463884354, 0.034073494374752045, -0.03702444210648537, -0.024835094809532166, -0.0014337640022858977, 0.010316489264369011, -0.007450435310602188, -0.07455263286828995, 0.011364911682903767, 0.0008929778705351055, -0.019816627725958824, 0.04254482686519623, -0.0244396161288023, -0.011469157412648201, -0.0020142870489507914, 0.012013174593448639, 0.02126801759004593, -0.03644298017024994, -0.03582996502518654, 0.060734834522008896, 0.029765326529741287, -0.02121603675186634, 0.06365462392568588, -0.022369123995304108, -0.01506020687520504, 0.0003700095403473824, -0.038557957857847214, 0.022710664197802544, -0.005608498118817806, -0.012557808309793472, -0.051603659987449646, -0.017269911244511604, -0.016796043142676353, 0.028839563950896263, -0.002884120913222432, 0.019178111106157303, -0.021251846104860306, 0.03635673597455025, 0.029009852558374405, 0.020570194348692894, -0.008329943753778934, -0.02393878623843193, -0.007966975681483746, -0.003871580120176077, -0.013890099711716175, -0.0007281033904291689, -0.009006298147141933, 0.015500773675739765, -0.011433135718107224, 0.025471052154898643, -0.028316212818026543, -0.0023457291536033154, -0.038401003926992416, -0.03305397182703018, -0.03279584273695946, -0.0517544262111187, 0.03314356133341789, 0.0023313635028898716, 0.039982933551073074, -0.003053839784115553, -0.04085132107138634, -0.021349696442484856, 0.032963354140520096, -0.00888348650187254, 0.028776248916983604, -0.040053267031908035, 0.05424421280622482, -0.037695568054914474, -0.005140694323927164, -0.06856599450111389, -0.03405466675758362, 0.027512958273291588, 0.0018233738373965025, 0.018689731135964394, -0.01814413070678711, -0.046147655695676804, -0.01308700442314148, -0.009441626258194447, -0.02633664757013321, 0.02865450829267502, -0.03954066336154938, -0.010130070149898529, -0.003150636563077569, 0.013691377826035023, 0.08412134647369385, -0.004056710284203291, 0.0010897540487349033, 0.01930157281458378, -0.02125874161720276, -0.04154469445347786, 0.006432007532566786, 0.01469272281974554, -0.028015216812491417, -0.007414774503558874, -0.04604422673583031, -0.011331877671182156, 0.05457242950797081, -0.04777612164616585, -0.03569779172539711, 0.019156958907842636, -0.020636174827814102, 0.015147260390222073, -0.05535619333386421, -0.015252822078764439, -0.010845666751265526, 0.03151729330420494, -0.022047007456421852, 0.01857905089855194, -0.007012099027633667, 0.01307650189846754, 0.03286794573068619, -0.012398655526340008, -0.013203013688325882, 0.021097637712955475, 0.08069873601198196, 0.013336630538105965, 0.04906274750828743, -0.012031600810587406, -0.008002104237675667, 0.02205837145447731, 0.0008521197596564889, 0.0023692913819104433, -0.017970813438296318, 0.03799043968319893, -0.04502856731414795, -0.004408493172377348, -0.04848194867372513, -0.007090105675160885, 0.045488376170396805, 0.01305709220468998, 0.02005651220679283, 0.04591197147965431, 0.013108295388519764, -0.010092003270983696, -0.005092577543109655, -0.01231434103101492, -0.008183416910469532, 0.02025851234793663, 0.03723219037055969, -0.022551070898771286, -0.026818206533789635, 0.03684728965163231, 0.01594550721347332, 0.014239543117582798, 0.017965709790587425, 0.0062339589931070805, 0.026305319741368294, 0.0012903987662866712, 0.016085868701338768, -0.03319191187620163, 0.03835718706250191, -0.021613722667098045, 0.01823016256093979, -0.05449133366346359, -0.019986053928732872, 0.03827313706278801, 0.03518382087349892, -0.0011476868530735373, -0.05662237107753754, -0.03458963707089424, -0.06850109994411469, -0.006220187991857529, 0.030947180464863777, -0.020372571423649788, 0.025081299245357513, -0.00383660732768476, 0.04672268033027649, -0.007397462613880634, 0.015477749519050121, -0.04487494379281998, -0.08848877996206284, -0.051240626722574234, -0.016102392226457596, 0.011593830771744251, 0.04835238680243492, -0.015854299068450928, -0.03688943758606911, 0.047238852828741074, -0.043368835002183914, 0.03427572548389435, -0.025569381192326546, 0.023712167516350746, -0.00590915884822607, 0.04782452434301376, -0.017674490809440613, 0.024351367726922035, 0.03125881031155586, -0.006139840930700302, 0.10172789543867111, 0.08247116208076477, 0.02028685063123703, -0.06457595527172089, 0.0521651990711689, 0.010599528439342976, 0.03313416242599487, -0.012951959855854511, 0.03635920211672783, -0.0014058196684345603, -0.019772831350564957, 0.04743790626525879, 0.042272716760635376, 0.010715843178331852, -0.019507145509123802, 0.01910650171339512, -0.016304342076182365, -0.016367634758353233, -0.0028163809329271317, -0.015662284567952156, -0.0016338378190994263, -0.036571912467479706, -0.03360779955983162, 0.005765165202319622, -0.004540967755019665, -0.0063734641298651695, -0.028020886704325676, -0.03270014002919197, -0.014827072620391846, -0.02543887123465538, -0.010847849771380424, 0.02415253221988678, 0.00024214465520344675, 0.0052008191123604774, -0.005019635893404484, 0.009878761135041714, 0.004675493575632572, -0.02897879295051098, -0.0036973131354898214, 0.02440498024225235, -0.008908695541322231, 0.008699855767190456, -0.012555384077131748, 0.045633651316165924, -0.04072026535868645, -0.05150066316127777, -0.009140902198851109, 0.0517938956618309, 0.0030986135825514793, 0.014661483466625214, -0.030877521261572838, 0.0013289946364238858, -0.011481089517474174, -0.03545437753200531, -0.04707956314086914, 0.03658219426870346, 0.020329106599092484, -0.025316940620541573, -0.025249991565942764, -0.03535973280668259, -0.0076303742825984955, -0.014887436293065548, 0.04933221638202667, 0.0378069244325161, 0.0034565695095807314, 0.01562792807817459, -0.027450358495116234, 0.07727102935314178, -0.0120754549279809, 0.0197339728474617, 0.0072204857133328915, -0.01191814336925745, 0.0021549260709434748, -0.014573943801224232, 0.017756387591362, 0.027477890253067017, -0.010125686414539814, -0.024346597492694855, -0.0028302231803536415, -0.03458523005247116, -0.0513601116836071, -0.009934737347066402, 0.00369882769882679, 0.0020134139340370893, -0.027241162955760956, -0.004493966698646545, 0.028698015958070755, 0.021958207711577415, 0.009301899932324886, -0.009857222437858582, 0.0013123820535838604, 0.07021386176347733, 0.03487860783934593, -0.04100074991583824, -0.01708868145942688, 0.005987720098346472, 0.003659579437226057, 0.006193249486386776, -0.0020346560049802065, 0.08570439368486404, 0.023120105266571045, 0.033391136676073074, 0.008499753661453724, 0.025012604892253876, -0.021216999739408493, 0.007795843295753002, 0.033476389944553375, -0.020030997693538666, 0.0024730300065129995, -0.033315375447273254, 0.03339060768485069, 0.013039859011769295, -0.013518976047635078, -0.02804955653846264, -0.05342812463641167, 0.0025551707949489355, -0.03150919824838638, -0.053517963737249374, 0.01186911016702652, -0.01986745558679104, 0.009234839119017124, -0.035752661526203156, -0.002663624007254839, -0.06888128072023392, 0.0050268108025193214, 0.004978237673640251, -0.03511092811822891, -0.013771402649581432, 0.0468328557908535, -0.006640482693910599, 0.025172699242830276, -0.006702658254653215, 0.008117982186377048, 0.02118682488799095, 0.004325407557189465, 0.010567950084805489, -0.011995146051049232, 0.029491668567061424, -0.016822567209601402, -0.011433081701397896, 0.03675935044884682, -0.041792113333940506, -0.028966568410396576, 0.02130512148141861, -0.00608055479824543, 0.049464937299489975, 0.013681186363101006, -0.014729226008057594, -0.016547178849577904, 0.05382803454995155, 0.01478185411542654, -0.02549457736313343, -0.010422705672681332, -0.003946114797145128, 0.004429930821061134, 0.01846589520573616, 0.029551271349191666, -0.014551464468240738, -0.007546633016318083, 0.046167854219675064, 0.06106826663017273, 0.007933325134217739, -0.02193470671772957, -0.009649356827139854, -0.02451140061020851, 0.007867776788771152, 0.006652825511991978, -0.0159660205245018, 0.055096060037612915, 0.044147029519081116, -0.0010946817928925157, 0.044458694756031036, -0.03703074902296066, 0.010460343211889267, -0.09939457476139069, -0.01843367889523506, -0.026914387941360474, 0.010983125306665897, 0.025403140112757683, -0.053907256573438644, 0.018665168434381485, 0.034261852502822876, -0.04791922867298126, -0.00007250224007293582, -0.028597695752978325, 0.009664183482527733, -0.04680071398615837, 0.01022792886942625, -0.027187079191207886, 0.017806535586714745, 0.0034212523605674505, -0.001720077940262854, 0.034712012857198715, 0.04522579163312912, 0.026532037183642387, -0.01525768730789423, 0.0014908787561580539, 0.03915959596633911, -0.007463593501597643, -0.08043880015611649, 0.012142706662416458, -0.013644098304212093, -0.023135365918278694, 0.008919183164834976, -0.003755686804652214, 0.005165559239685535, 0.04117446020245552, 0.02468946948647499, 0.01229637861251831, 0.0505327545106411, 0.050648219883441925, -0.015562396496534348, 0.005760131869465113, -0.0018440490821376443, 0.009372074156999588, -0.011538419872522354, -0.01884002983570099, 0.025696925818920135, 0.012474487535655499, 0.0018016037065535784, 0.006562105845659971, -0.008709137327969074, -0.006353610660880804, -0.017323344945907593, -0.030204711481928825, 0.017563743516802788, -0.0004828649398405105, -0.0576702244579792, 0.028660248965024948, -0.039123885333538055, -0.027547340840101242, 0.047221820801496506, 0.017566675320267677, -0.03769475966691971, -0.003769786562770605, -0.01811055839061737, -0.014140642248094082, -0.010419025085866451, 0.022380057722330093, -0.011487291194498539, -0.07860671728849411, 0.004945897497236729, -0.008665294386446476, -0.013674059882760048, -0.02559392899274826, -0.02505975216627121, -0.07400649785995483, 0.04454752802848816, -0.03406611829996109, -0.0035300771705806255, 0.007638305891305208, -0.013054284267127514, 0.024282265454530716, -0.10374285280704498, 0.06287351995706558, -0.002784003969281912, -0.0389711894094944, -0.0581921711564064, 0.009246707893908024, -0.038856398314237595, 0.059004612267017365, 0.03363219276070595, 0.018080148845911026, 0.011369287967681885, -0.019503548741340637, 0.02669554203748703, -0.005778196733444929, -0.039468761533498764, 0.0360356904566288, 0.002857473213225603, 0.01656605675816536, 0.0019003624329343438, -0.015091650187969208, 0.023631654679775238, 0.011733822524547577, 0.02331840619444847, -0.02652972936630249, 0.0307087991386652, -0.008639328181743622, -0.012812581844627857, 0.02806781604886055, -0.016503676772117615, -0.02482926845550537, 0.029357297345995903, 0.000637037621345371, 0.05580304563045502, 0.04789523035287857, 0.025841809809207916, -0.034249309450387955, 0.03930247575044632, -0.027071824297308922, 0.004143767524510622, 0.005075158551335335, -0.004567274823784828, -0.00607123039662838, -0.05338367447257042, 0.006567543372511864, -0.002116612857207656, -0.025193603709340096, -0.018851472064852715, 0.011250648647546768, 0.0029784489888697863, 0.03001094050705433, 0.007310079410672188, 0.04752502590417862, -0.005305918864905834, 0.02013094164431095, -0.010680904611945152, 0.03404773026704788, 0.019596511498093605, 0.010517943650484085, -0.011309567838907242, 0.04393335431814194, -0.020116008818149567, -0.009745622053742409, 0.00886741653084755, 0.0583062544465065, -0.03331183269619942, -0.0010970368748530746, -0.009872577153146267, -0.004874342121183872, 0.0326179601252079, -0.023816393688321114, 0.0033137332648038864, 0.015269262716174126, -0.06214011088013649, 0.011553664691746235, -0.01262566726654768, 0.026380294933915138, -0.0020589297637343407, 0.009430852718651295, 0.0064492919482290745, 0.05698226019740105, 0.01589757762849331, -0.005731983110308647, -0.018610497936606407, -0.018743915483355522, -0.014538804069161415, -0.022080572322010994, 0.021843884140253067, -0.0190931037068367, 0.010838541202247143, -0.01953933946788311, -0.00518537824973464, -0.04294706881046295, -0.02997254952788353, 0.015214534476399422, 0.04453687742352486, 0.028818994760513306, -0.03813505917787552, -0.024944180622696877, 0.02449650876224041, 0.05213220790028572, -0.05819374695420265, -0.005267830565571785, -0.004229321144521236, 0.0070453425869345665, 0.01124238409101963, -0.004936200566589832 ]
<p>I have a list of records with fields that can be seen as two sets of variables: dependent and independent. There are say 100 fields in each record and we consider 10 of them as dependent variables and 90 as independent. </p> <p>What are the methods to find all the correlations that exist between the two sets?</p> <p>(At introductory statistics course that I've taken we have been dealing with simple correlations between two variables but the task like this was not covered.)</p>
49,217
[ -0.039677694439888, 0.0026801300700753927, 0.0002847003052011132, 0.03265703096985817, 0.059662483632564545, -0.024699246510863304, 0.02576206997036934, -0.0096766771748662, 0.039222486317157745, -0.01066660974174738, 0.03966022655367851, 0.03297204151749611, 0.03807011991739273, 0.03911624476313591, 0.030708102509379387, -0.011629917658865452, 0.003053255146369338, 0.014208200387656689, 0.046066563576459885, -0.002311548450961709, -0.021363237872719765, 0.020009659230709076, 0.05331125855445862, -0.001054407679475844, -0.04167971387505531, 0.06363525986671448, 0.009226473048329353, -0.026777468621730804, 0.01553380861878395, 0.04028007760643959, -0.04049362614750862, -0.05089705064892769, 0.018870415166020393, 0.07084629684686661, 0.025089815258979797, -0.01517739798873663, -0.01842219941318035, -0.006059718783944845, 0.011931858956813812, 0.019333088770508766, -0.06378861516714096, -0.023437585681676865, -0.020379414781928062, 0.027990426868200302, -0.022754628211259842, 0.007146961055696011, 0.014985615387558937, -0.032248854637145996, 0.021810822188854218, -0.04138055071234703, 0.07929385453462601, -0.02657449245452881, 0.0486619807779789, 0.03241444751620293, -0.009602050296962261, 0.010137462988495827, 0.04933531954884529, 0.03149281442165375, -0.004191662184894085, -0.06805787980556488, -0.029785798862576485, -0.016014795750379562, -0.015767518430948257, -0.02283724956214428, -0.053014978766441345, 0.04153521731495857, -0.021940059959888458, -0.011866122484207153, 0.04519160836935043, -0.006965684704482555, 0.021541902795433998, 0.0442662313580513, 0.061524614691734314, -0.015361915342509747, 0.0003009236534126103, -0.02737315557897091, 0.029458222910761833, 0.00038520951056852937, 0.022964999079704285, 0.03807930648326874, 0.024199286475777626, 0.018084866926074028, 0.04698644578456879, 0.025344667956233025, 0.030787944793701172, -0.03331717476248741, 0.056634485721588135, -0.013515750877559185, 0.0035930287558585405, 0.018345292657613754, -0.006234491243958473, 0.004549780860543251, 0.022924290969967842, 0.047552790492773056, -0.06475374102592468, 0.025961285457015038, -0.04346480593085289, 0.05859871208667755, 0.006966808810830116, 0.011540164239704609, -0.008417487144470215, -0.021846333518624306, 0.030441192910075188, 0.06865358352661133, -0.057589419186115265, 0.012839367613196373, -0.04806692525744438, 0.004176332615315914, -0.016653859987854958, -0.016765978187322617, 0.008111144416034222, 0.009048101492226124, 0.027368078008294106, -0.000731963140424341, 0.026815054938197136, -0.005283987615257502, -0.023287111893296242, -0.008932672441005707, 0.030320895835757256, 0.06857927143573761, 0.02398957498371601, -0.07603137940168381, 0.029493778944015503, 0.01693960465490818, -0.03344259411096573, -0.0009916891576722264, 0.019417868927121162, -0.016126884147524834, -0.028268499299883842, 0.057604920119047165, -0.00939095951616764, -0.04149110987782478, -0.0028623766265809536, -0.0035606762394309044, 0.011474466882646084, 0.01317914854735136, -0.09248857200145721, -0.05193871259689331, 0.047682538628578186, -0.02628536894917488, -0.010680180974304676, 0.002000020584091544, 0.020022161304950714, 0.040505632758140564, 0.05613253638148308, -0.024039532989263535, 0.010366944596171379, -0.004597524646669626, 0.023803114891052246, 0.01829490251839161, 0.011987355537712574, -0.0221098680049181, -0.024458494037389755, -0.017528224736452103, -0.01437181606888771, -0.06516740471124649, 0.01440388709306717, 0.011296289041638374, -0.015210720710456371, -0.011321304365992546, 0.010709522292017937, 0.014763218350708485, -0.004143511410802603, -0.007083865348249674, 0.03606794774532318, -0.016177065670490265, 0.053004465997219086, -0.015173107385635376, 0.009893043898046017, 0.011433310806751251, -0.048103585839271545, 0.009684927761554718, 0.042266204953193665, 0.0484732948243618, 0.023807618767023087, 0.0022349474020302296, -0.03276096284389496, -0.008384136483073235, 0.0017393153393641114, 0.0006277174106799066, -0.0038055344484746456, -0.04221509397029877, -0.018095215782523155, -0.021627778187394142, 0.04176025465130806, 0.04484156146645546, 0.00777119817212224, -0.028766978532075882, 0.023520462214946747, -0.031245285645127296, -0.0139186792075634, -0.09002214670181274, 0.018512088805437088, -0.01414747629314661, -0.020422808825969696, 0.0519515685737133, 0.02969282865524292, 0.024140560999512672, -0.011932441964745522, -0.05808507651090622, -0.029849689453840256, -0.004405645187944174, 0.04620277136564255, -0.03214244544506073, 0.028220798820257187, 0.02459227666258812, 0.07222206890583038, -0.02778615988790989, 0.040836405009031296, -0.06550019234418869, -0.034314170479774475, 0.01634022779762745, -0.04071075841784477, -0.017008153721690178, -0.0012467807391658425, -0.030914204195141792, -0.007847906090319157, 0.01156986691057682, -0.01722184754908085, -0.005505847744643688, -0.06316554546356201, 0.06697334349155426, 0.07203464955091476, 0.018310144543647766, -0.011898376047611237, 0.014593295753002167, 0.024723416194319725, 0.036235272884368896, -0.002501936862245202, -0.015245344489812851, -0.07175862789154053, -0.005017347168177366, 0.027831565588712692, 0.026463400572538376, -0.04160158336162567, -0.02121601812541485, 0.058710452169179916, 0.049982551485300064, 0.007252814713865519, 0.048477236181497574, -0.030502235516905785, -0.01726161502301693, -0.0051083131693303585, 0.013904385268688202, 0.020581495016813278, 0.021826058626174927, 0.028028231114149094, 0.03754248470067978, 0.020472560077905655, 0.027036627754569054, -0.04037607088685036, 0.03149867430329323, 0.010553695261478424, 0.019039595499634743, -0.012855516746640205, -0.047064632177352905, 0.052871450781822205, -0.016390953212976456, 0.0073116738349199295, 0.01495529618114233, 0.01744205690920353, -0.005413388833403587, 0.029358750209212303, -0.0037738531827926636, 0.021452955901622772, -0.004102074075490236, -0.04045535624027252, -0.012937207706272602, 0.008191591128706932, -0.05186039209365845, 0.02071714960038662, 0.011976794339716434, -0.04162703827023506, -0.031072648242115974, 0.01054092962294817, 0.0377030111849308, 0.00011165090836584568, 0.04046286642551422, -0.02739088423550129, -0.027705373242497444, 0.0036807386204600334, -0.038490209728479385, -0.00933215394616127, -0.009247423149645329, -0.05155858397483826, -0.002082968130707741, -0.024841180071234703, -0.022849002853035927, 0.0016690067714080215, -0.03352959826588631, -0.01638963259756565, 0.03020656295120716, -0.0035848859697580338, -0.06908498704433441, -0.02038932591676712, 0.0045958636328577995, 0.01919005997478962, -0.05069241300225258, -0.0012574456632137299, 0.03759235516190529, 0.015538631938397884, -0.040344469249248505, -0.009684998542070389, -0.02928672730922699, -0.013654403388500214, -0.03397847339510918, 0.0018990456592291594, 0.03987544775009155, -0.007300493307411671, -0.04068848490715027, 0.02038739249110222, -0.002311531687155366, -0.009330266155302525, -0.0760788843035698, -0.07953054457902908, -0.006521673873066902, 0.010834922082722187, 0.04083961620926857, 0.009899497963488102, -0.04835861921310425, 0.03165731206536293, 0.027662917971611023, -0.05439167842268944, -0.04362918809056282, -0.01979241892695427, -0.009352580644190311, -0.012674076482653618, 0.05751965194940567, 0.0026654263492673635, -0.01420854963362217, 0.014264560304582119, 0.032625436782836914, -0.0018491653027012944, 0.056030645966529846, 0.025956032797694206, 0.013207504525780678, 0.02587982825934887, 0.007602613419294357, -0.011653139255940914, 0.020288916304707527, -0.0023111209738999605, -0.06370104849338531, 0.0042753336019814014, 0.0019185449928045273, 0.018134314566850662, 0.025966839864850044, -0.02762514352798462, 0.018354764208197594, 0.0051082768477499485, 0.01708890125155449, -0.06797070056200027, 0.002489021746441722, 0.0064548309892416, 0.011621061712503433, 0.0009841544087976217, 0.03184676915407181, 0.04608430713415146, -0.03137238323688507, -0.004105180501937866, 0.04931342229247093, 0.012816574424505234, -0.03200535103678703, -0.020043065771460533, -0.03235694766044617, -0.038491323590278625, 0.045244988054037094, -0.03960990905761719, -0.008185070008039474, 0.038987819105386734, 0.030094655230641365, 0.013537914492189884, -0.008600680157542229, -0.047126058489084244, 0.042574234306812286, -0.0876549556851387, -0.006441735662519932, -0.026653818786144257, 0.061740461736917496, 0.006442127749323845, 0.08374949544668198, 0.011231821961700916, 0.015525761060416698, 0.025775065645575523, 0.012792813591659069, -0.03927656263113022, 0.040959421545267105, -0.02964860573410988, 0.0010349855292588472, 0.015356671996414661, -0.03155187889933586, 0.03542964532971382, -0.01519752200692892, -0.007798340637236834, -0.02438504993915558, 0.01829017512500286, -0.02567179873585701, 0.0008891047327779233, -0.04444323107600212, -0.024361586198210716, -0.008483128622174263, 0.03952864184975624, -0.01179568376392126, -0.0012697572819888592, 0.06285770237445831, 0.039965879172086716, 0.009041001088917255, -0.0316796600818634, -0.01658851094543934, -0.025040367618203163, -0.003203833010047674, 0.05362795665860176, 0.005294750910252333, 0.004761799238622189, -0.03065125085413456, 0.04133894294500351, -0.004158809781074524, 0.039306286722421646, 0.04983322694897652, -0.004159710370004177, -0.0021725266706198454, -0.025215134024620056, 0.011272171512246132, -0.060726098716259, 0.024288689717650414, 0.017059847712516785, -0.011417357251048088, 0.07510913908481598, 0.02531798742711544, -0.06890235096216202, 0.03385324403643608, 0.050958745181560516, 0.025547383353114128, 0.011512399651110172, -0.013223819434642792, 0.003599069081246853, 0.004869561176747084, 0.031853534281253815, -0.0034460406750440598, 0.02284638024866581, 0.0036037717945873737, -0.0021383599378168583, 0.03844211995601654, -0.028759248554706573, -0.01806434988975525, -0.014800501987338066, -0.006861301604658365, 0.055657483637332916, -0.03282003477215767, -0.06857063621282578, 0.026851711794734, 0.05569642409682274, 0.019184211269021034, 0.0328264944255352, 0.022380029782652855, -0.08725439012050629, 0.03856426477432251, 0.034692857414484024, 0.029350645840168, -0.03553343936800957, 0.01881827414035797, -0.0158834345638752, -0.022555729374289513, 0.062012724578380585, -0.037691690027713776, 0.007576072122901678, 0.01299577858299017, 0.002443503588438034, -0.021417921409010887, -0.03563237190246582, -0.040024083107709885, 0.019899195060133934, -0.027857067063450813, 0.02237541414797306, 0.00877842865884304, -0.03287609666585922, -0.04714499041438103, 0.0022904174402356148, 0.018047666177153587, 0.07611377537250519, 0.009335419163107872, 0.010723617859184742, 0.0021202778443694115, 0.03616848960518837, -0.008008957840502262, -0.06495077162981033, 0.020233817398548126, -0.013114066794514656, -0.014882673509418964, 0.0629054456949234, -0.008450406603515148, -0.011649667285382748, -0.018295491114258766, -0.00491834431886673, -0.010974234901368618, -0.004213234875351191, -0.004185040015727282, 0.05260489508509636, 0.03834057226777077, 0.011799315921962261, 0.06630746275186539, 0.018694987520575523, -0.02806849405169487, -0.030060598626732826, -0.027316812425851822, 0.03137253597378731, -0.020518409088253975, 0.01564987376332283, -0.06328105926513672, 0.019334418699145317, -0.04619593545794487, 0.008846060372889042, -0.03379283472895622, 0.02631646767258644, -0.048516564071178436, 0.002488954458385706, -0.02818785049021244, 0.037223007529973984, -0.002888731425628066, 0.013072719797492027, 0.019340232014656067, 0.026417376473546028, -0.0032705774065107107, -0.06596824526786804, 0.013714425265789032, 0.004206662066280842, -0.03182249888777733, -0.015355936251580715, -0.024005990475416183, 0.01842687278985977, -0.0739830806851387, -0.015645351260900497, 0.0025166913401335478, -0.03155295550823212, 0.043292704969644547, 0.014741972088813782, 0.04117567092180252, 0.019684545695781708, -0.03079587034881115, -0.00907870288938284, 0.030794670805335045, 0.0014601462753489614, 0.04580328240990639, -0.03134019300341606, 0.03348880261182785, -0.039143435657024384, -0.013467639684677124, -0.06751126050949097, -0.04987340793013573, 0.03994351625442505, 0.0437592938542366, -0.019274001941084862, -0.04661647975444794, 0.020192312076687813, -0.027482924982905388, 0.006717470474541187, -0.04688826575875282, 0.052661992609500885, -0.015356591902673244, -0.006661098916083574, 0.0248252023011446, -0.001473444513976574, 0.06517034769058228, -0.010108660906553268, -0.014126922003924847, 0.02165243588387966, -0.006039340980350971, -0.014639433473348618, -0.009783990681171417, -0.021111955866217613, -0.02315155416727066, -0.033761683851480484, -0.04230918362736702, 0.0004895778256468475, 0.034905124455690384, -0.049120351672172546, 0.005286613944917917, -0.031569916754961014, 0.013430716469883919, -0.025565477088093758, -0.021643849089741707, 0.011020057834684849, -0.0052884649485349655, -0.00020348976249806583, -0.0016267995815724134, -0.0010603712871670723, -0.02524944394826889, -0.028181636705994606, 0.004326246213167906, 0.020170986652374268, -0.01781456172466278, 0.019006015732884407, 0.05475662648677826, -0.008144286461174488, -0.005319719668477774, -0.009743706323206425, -0.007407688535749912, 0.032791949808597565, 0.0033643378410488367, 0.016185184940695763, 0.00397723400965333, 0.028290314599871635, -0.044238533824682236, -0.020742293447256088, -0.00881385151296854, -0.010266238823533058, 0.07945027202367783, -0.013149015605449677, 0.060560811311006546, 0.09267877787351608, 0.012443961575627327, -0.005679607391357422, -0.03998306021094322, -0.018922096118330956, -0.0010700131533667445, 0.029652252793312073, 0.04335414618253708, -0.006189876236021519, 0.012471417896449566, 0.028079098090529442, 0.01291639357805252, 0.018636977300047874, 0.016670990735292435, -0.024406831711530685, 0.00607496639713645, 0.012798222713172436, -0.013639485463500023, -0.02616683952510357, 0.007450087461620569, -0.04286541789770126, -0.02595227025449276, -0.02429734356701374, -0.0024312182795256376, 0.04419969767332077, 0.03895086050033569, -0.005915659014135599, -0.02081531472504139, -0.043802935630083084, -0.03976356238126755, 0.020086519420146942, 0.015332408249378204, 0.01671436056494713, 0.018414853140711784, 0.02867785654962063, 0.03736775740981102, -0.00847585778683424, 0.014646139927208424, -0.014695418067276478, -0.06279820203781128, -0.024364197626709938, -0.008093228563666344, -0.022384246811270714, 0.03824184834957123, 0.006000754423439503, -0.008233482018113136, 0.005812732502818108, -0.013616539537906647, -0.001038127695210278, -0.01131927128881216, 0.009431710466742516, -0.013377713970839977, 0.06827867031097412, 0.04195314645767212, 0.023077648133039474, 0.009064645506441593, -0.0111234737560153, 0.09305675327777863, 0.07418813556432724, 0.04726213589310646, -0.08146645128726959, 0.007158828899264336, 0.02695702575147152, -0.03832723945379257, -0.054687075316905975, 0.03263009712100029, 0.002724967198446393, 0.0008153673843480647, 0.0433308370411396, 0.05678805336356163, 0.03859328478574753, 0.010696889832615852, 0.07748262584209442, -0.008885146118700504, -0.011111928150057793, -0.014406903646886349, 0.01051730290055275, -0.026828791946172714, -0.00041260552825406194, -0.04782191291451454, 0.01987151987850666, -0.006528743542730808, -0.028971077874302864, -0.05628354847431183, -0.012080388143658638, 0.033152204006910324, 0.0014031531754881144, -0.018552424386143684, -0.0009681856608949602, 0.03015998937189579, 0.03649516403675079, -0.031109808012843132, 0.012064660899341106, 0.06009313091635704, -0.024582911282777786, 0.0006677469937130809, 0.004671178758144379, -0.03575996682047844, 0.004919851664453745, -0.013983973301947117, 0.010762171819806099, -0.03229677304625511, -0.0221159178763628, -0.04739725589752197, 0.056843649595975876, -0.025845395401120186, -0.02044452168047428, -0.04732108488678932, -0.006116633769124746, 0.005275252275168896, -0.01635252870619297, -0.009887408465147018, 0.019702410325407982, 0.017379041761159897, -0.040593065321445465, 0.008721999824047089, -0.053698599338531494, 0.021119462326169014, -0.010749230161309242, 0.028855402022600174, 0.010889720171689987, 0.0025051324628293514, -0.01973322406411171, -0.05719301849603653, 0.052996452897787094, 0.01759358122944832, -0.005958615802228451, -0.030656684190034866, -0.019497402012348175, -0.027390390634536743, 0.03025343269109726, 0.01574513129889965, 0.026774659752845764, -0.001500654616393149, -0.0034683742560446262, 0.0007138213841244578, -0.03043685294687748, -0.01031668670475483, 0.006475988309830427, -0.01720941811800003, -0.00877137016505003, -0.01594390720129013, -0.0021321801468729973, 0.03705871105194092, 0.040775761008262634, 0.04676864296197891, 0.018215537071228027, -0.014677711762487888, 0.013888613320887089, 0.0198406670242548, -0.04606752470135689, -0.02456304430961609, -0.03304259479045868, -0.019769320264458656, -0.0035538985393941402, -0.02307835780084133, 0.05386669561266899, 0.03896048292517662, 0.014401281252503395, -0.001193446572870016, 0.03302944451570511, -0.004150542430579662, 0.012837419286370277, 0.018174603581428528, -0.04739246144890785, 0.006269537843763828, 0.022486267611384392, 0.00791780836880207, -0.022981829941272736, -0.018392566591501236, -0.028654664754867554, -0.009157677181065083, 0.01911100745201111, 0.014476705342531204, -0.03909764066338539, 0.0037513647694140673, 0.002762807300314307, 0.021413294598460197, -0.04058500751852989, 0.0009565008222125471, -0.0794495940208435, 0.003857793053612113, 0.020847264677286148, 0.00021903494780417532, -0.0022436475846916437, -0.006376059725880623, -0.020389357581734657, 0.009412719868123531, 0.0336674265563488, 0.010553055442869663, 0.017375145107507706, -0.019128037616610527, 0.022307785227894783, -0.008534354157745838, 0.07105778902769089, -0.03319322690367699, -0.006949235685169697, 0.0009051627712324262, -0.057536836713552475, 0.003937575500458479, 0.01379541214555502, 0.011292760260403156, 0.036767616868019104, 0.00039139349246397614, -0.015106288716197014, -0.019549109041690826, 0.02397906593978405, -0.017385834828019142, -0.020266324281692505, -0.02833205834031105, 0.009452573955059052, 0.02904227375984192, 0.0012628157855942845, 0.03270990401506424, 0.00877345260232687, -0.0064767212606966496, 0.004818441346287727, 0.0315251424908638, 0.006280014291405678, 0.00556623749434948, 0.014031663537025452, 0.035549916326999664, 0.00936640053987503, -0.006909820716828108, -0.028681952506303787, 0.020337074995040894, 0.05811360850930214, -0.031956810504198074, 0.049784790724515915, 0.0254841111600399, 0.0237199068069458, -0.07980889081954956, -0.004175199195742607, -0.005108844488859177, 0.014302333816885948, 0.05868048593401909, -0.046946678310632706, -0.006517770234495401, 0.043748099356889725, -0.04373570904135704, 0.044590335339307785, -0.015361065044999123, 0.006500618532299995, -0.008279259316623211, 0.027878211811184883, -0.03573194146156311, 0.03720078617334366, 0.015313323587179184, 0.05000334605574608, 0.011440247297286987, 0.03383344039320946, 0.01913934387266636, -0.009598169475793839, -0.04682665690779686, -0.022058652713894844, 0.040002983063459396, -0.03174880892038345, 0.01603340543806553, -0.025225281715393066, -0.036227017641067505, 0.03187214955687523, -0.012256515212357044, 0.01567479595541954, 0.005693249870091677, -0.0016718924744054675, -0.017264965921640396, 0.044787101447582245, 0.01150668878108263, -0.045158494263887405, -0.013529849238693714, 0.00041189463809132576, 0.02404531091451645, 0.030943945050239563, -0.007971190847456455, 0.011722824536263943, 0.022157128900289536, -0.008561225607991219, -0.034701425582170486, 0.04354303702712059, -0.005174684338271618, -0.001772383344359696, -0.02256767638027668, -0.034769318997859955, -0.0029742345213890076, -0.01609855145215988, 0.012306463904678822, -0.0481928214430809, -0.030866030603647232, 0.0312686562538147, 0.021265288814902306, -0.028057927265763283, 0.019325589761137962, -0.00812317244708538, -0.026631174609065056, 0.0007218497339636087, 0.02221084013581276, 0.021505173295736313, -0.058787908405065536, 0.005268107634037733, -0.015450619161128998, -0.013296948745846748, -0.023323357105255127, -0.004690670873969793, -0.05037542060017586, 0.034036725759506226, -0.030587101355195045, 0.005655752029269934, -0.010996154509484768, -0.048313602805137634, -0.002415295224636793, -0.04269900545477867, 0.015179155394434929, 0.014258242212235928, -0.025985974818468094, -0.05251918360590935, -0.011363571509718895, -0.02550598420202732, -0.005935218650847673, 0.05251070111989975, -0.0194838959723711, 0.014116165228188038, -0.05580281838774681, -0.0022220597602427006, 0.02254132553935051, -0.04057937115430832, 0.038841914385557175, -0.009437022730708122, -0.017621207982301712, 0.006639046128839254, -0.02680819295346737, 0.031704265624284744, -0.005142346024513245, -0.005201465450227261, -0.022701868787407875, 0.002543459879234433, 0.028453404083848, -0.0397636741399765, 0.05239409580826759, 0.01300205010920763, 0.009425949305295944, 0.03981815278530121, -0.008276493288576603, 0.00982464849948883, 0.06211545318365097, -0.032319359481334686, -0.028501497581601143, 0.027758603915572166, -0.05704476311802864, -0.027727145701646805, -0.013496147468686104, 0.044502004981040955, -0.020444467663764954, -0.0520482212305069, 0.014025145210325718, 0.02931920811533928, -0.04346054792404175, 0.007120361551642418, 0.04469067230820656, -0.01034568902105093, 0.015923649072647095, 0.01593863219022751, 0.020603511482477188, -0.02037762850522995, -0.03933483362197876, -0.0094221793115139, 0.027415361255407333, 0.05728060007095337, 0.009535466320812702, -0.009440542198717594, 0.04795220121741295, 0.013812074437737465, 0.008547836914658546, -0.013500882312655449, -0.018910393118858337, -0.01195978932082653, -0.019178589805960655, -0.00242588110268116, -0.011726428754627705, 0.04272928461432457, 0.029062964022159576, -0.03436516597867012, 0.03041725419461727, -0.08890791982412338, 0.02105577103793621, -0.06442143768072128, -0.01054115779697895, -0.050246551632881165, -0.004462697077542543, 0.007545990403741598, 0.014208506792783737, -0.001305058947764337, 0.01581382565200329, 0.011466959491372108, -0.016646388918161392, 0.016097482293844223, -0.0060684760101139545, 0.01803649216890335, -0.0286859180778265, -0.0018793328199535608, -0.007450790610164404, -0.017557797953486443, -0.030017297714948654, -0.02346380427479744, 0.0374908372759819, 0.0462958887219429, 0.016785025596618652, -0.003521393518894911, -0.01434379443526268, -0.004065884742885828, 0.05182398855686188, -0.05765211582183838, -0.006403729785233736, -0.04504133388400078, 0.03505069389939308, -0.006453521084040403, 0.01548281591385603 ]
<p>Please first have a look at the following little problem:</p> <blockquote> <p>There are two indistinguishable light bulbs A and B. A flashes red light with prob .8 and blue with prob .2; B red with .2 and blue .8. Now with .5 prob you are presented with either A or B. You're supposed to observe its flash color to make a best guess (maximizing probability of correct guessing) which bulb it is. Before you start to make observations, however, you must decide how many times you want to observe it (say n times, then you observe it flashing n times and make your guess). Suppose flashes are independent.</p> </blockquote> <p>Intuitively, one would think the more observations one makes, the better one's chances will be. Curiously though, it is easy calculation to show that n=2 doesn't improve upon n=1, and n=4 doesn't improve upon n=3. I didn't go further but I speculate n=2k doesn't improve upon n=2k-1. I'm not able to prove it for the general case. But is it true? If so, how can one intuitively understand the result? </p>
37,370
[ -0.0383743941783905, -0.025170743465423584, 0.01327711995691061, -0.012598959729075432, 0.011453121900558472, -0.02881627529859543, 0.005068937782198191, 0.006897949613630772, 0.002951070200651884, 0.002071734517812729, 0.012163369916379452, 0.04803156480193138, 0.046336568892002106, 0.031159553676843643, 0.016905996948480606, 0.027913512662053108, 0.006869890261441469, 0.004837872460484505, -0.009422366507351398, -0.007233681157231331, -0.025416336953639984, 0.04489210993051529, 0.045640572905540466, -0.010470460169017315, -0.06392975896596909, 0.03422423079609871, 0.03746829554438591, -0.042717646807432175, 0.02528083696961403, 0.039641059935092926, -0.01482671033591032, -0.008395884186029434, 0.017739778384566307, 0.059546422213315964, 0.0569894015789032, -0.014810732565820217, -0.006633024197071791, 0.005814092233777046, 0.014251929707825184, -0.0029539831448346376, -0.014386012218892574, -0.0006332348566502333, -0.004014709964394569, 0.024516403675079346, -0.04677443578839302, 0.029220709577202797, -0.008042874746024609, -0.06414032727479935, 0.033336661756038666, -0.06314979493618011, 0.08535175770521164, -0.0211920365691185, 0.03360137715935707, 0.03805612400174141, -0.042220428586006165, -0.008050631731748581, 0.0536845400929451, 0.06565654277801514, -0.014852591790258884, -0.024743080139160156, -0.01403773669153452, -0.013096003793179989, -0.025921989232301712, 0.0207050833851099, -0.018081095069646835, 0.021394141018390656, 0.009889560751616955, -0.022035054862499237, 0.030216870829463005, -0.014361475594341755, -0.00910605676472187, 0.03939905762672424, 0.0775056928396225, -0.0008287561940960586, 0.0004629483737517148, -0.034781649708747864, -0.0025271675549447536, 0.009423631243407726, 0.05029935762286186, 0.02744617871940136, -0.00924587156623602, -0.020286347717046738, 0.03222424164414406, 0.05148406699299812, 0.02963550202548504, -0.04098968580365181, 0.07101361453533173, -0.03293398767709732, 0.02546004392206669, 0.018635813146829605, 0.0050559029914438725, -0.02047838270664215, 0.06020593270659447, -0.012074294500052929, -0.03444965183734894, 0.041539959609508514, -0.022042859345674515, 0.01023910939693451, 0.004387167282402515, -0.019694188609719276, -0.05622604116797447, -0.026691509410738945, 0.022508569061756134, 0.03173786774277687, -0.04215991124510765, -0.04187263175845146, 0.004851709119975567, 0.048902008682489395, 0.03057292103767395, 0.020264407619833946, 0.004972714930772781, 0.022515568882226944, 0.038689255714416504, 0.0008978464175015688, 0.03054426982998848, -0.04862722009420395, -0.0022067322861403227, 0.004871899262070656, 0.0619986318051815, 0.07392879575490952, 0.0009172962745651603, -0.03630679473280907, 0.0063005853444337845, -0.04326638951897621, -0.011730720289051533, 0.009738542139530182, 0.03285115584731102, -0.016490694135427475, -0.03438225015997887, 0.04326949641108513, 0.005412284750491381, 0.010037548840045929, 0.006248059682548046, 0.020573610439896584, -0.005416342057287693, -0.0011922209523618221, -0.09512484073638916, -0.03228874132037163, 0.051724959164857864, -0.0342743881046772, 0.0007660642731934786, -0.08100540935993195, 0.033582303673028946, 0.05385395511984825, 0.08128157258033752, -0.013011829927563667, 0.02647840976715088, -0.02254677750170231, -0.0036618998274207115, 0.03751327469944954, -0.027310850098729134, -0.03205939382314682, 0.006429907865822315, -0.059547897428274155, -0.0011270606191828847, -0.05910367891192436, 0.008374391123652458, 0.023719916120171547, -0.006139135919511318, -0.023562204092741013, 0.040599118918180466, 0.015682721510529518, 0.006528593134135008, -0.017404427751898766, 0.003294326364994049, -0.018146274611353874, 0.09048038721084595, 0.008961488492786884, 0.03619881719350815, 0.028851361945271492, 0.007373809348791838, 0.03549448400735855, -0.008047742769122124, 0.02147226780653, 0.02038859948515892, -0.047212086617946625, -0.039179589599370956, 0.009011903777718544, 0.026677245274186134, -0.026311645284295082, -0.021255014464259148, -0.021643104031682014, -0.05302612856030464, -0.013960007578134537, 0.010125234723091125, 0.026898808777332306, 0.001298312097787857, 0.005220179911702871, 0.0222628116607666, -0.0339013896882534, -0.013888757675886154, -0.09278027713298798, -0.01647987961769104, 0.0283681470900774, -0.03889795020222664, 0.04196566715836525, -0.028968170285224915, 0.014237339608371258, -0.004751737229526043, -0.00697209220379591, -0.055922187864780426, -0.000912615389097482, 0.02310873195528984, -0.06910809874534607, 0.015058128163218498, 0.05524151399731636, 0.0054530370980501175, -0.014759975485503674, 0.06637731939554214, -0.06079897657036781, -0.03232286125421524, 0.04072517901659012, -0.015060292556881905, 0.017254240810871124, 0.0507061667740345, 0.02712414413690567, 0.032630741596221924, -0.0068176500499248505, -0.006878483109176159, 0.024462880566716194, -0.07828404009342194, 0.0519995242357254, 0.024286653846502304, 0.005592523142695427, -0.0003924018528778106, 0.043324459344148636, 0.021857483312487602, -0.01656281016767025, 0.008748750202357769, -0.026163117960095406, -0.04168448597192764, 0.0023229399230331182, -0.003612951375544071, 0.04937015846371651, -0.014828303828835487, -0.0005180882872082293, 0.053659990429878235, 0.027369774878025055, -0.01076662726700306, 0.014634368009865284, -0.023352907970547676, -0.008393360301852226, 0.010539036244153976, 0.007769078016281128, 0.0020596219692379236, 0.02310658060014248, 0.010449226945638657, 0.01455211453139782, 0.01843450590968132, 0.012315098196268082, -0.011020383797585964, 0.00905622262507677, -0.02097482793033123, 0.03741014376282692, -0.0114857517182827, -0.01761094108223915, 0.02992873452603817, -0.016389301046729088, 0.02440597489476204, 0.009725782088935375, 0.01092400960624218, 0.022823525592684746, -0.030874427407979965, -0.014788131229579449, 0.03151640295982361, -0.010166741907596588, -0.040601979941129684, 0.015097655355930328, 0.02172301895916462, -0.028040487319231033, 0.00874349009245634, -0.01940115913748741, -0.0007306753541342914, -0.009841393679380417, -0.009362979792058468, -0.022626617923378944, -0.01717372052371502, 0.02889290452003479, -0.047963228076696396, -0.013110567815601826, -0.037680260837078094, 0.006814970634877682, 0.05111335217952728, -0.007478003855794668, -0.04782768338918686, -0.020206773653626442, -0.006556883919984102, -0.034625519067049026, 0.022255614399909973, -0.030153989791870117, 0.005541852675378323, 0.020423538982868195, 0.0011306956876069307, -0.05776560679078102, -0.002206715289503336, -0.04191789776086807, 0.02039041742682457, -0.03752446174621582, -0.04057548940181732, 0.03384416177868843, 0.005877689924091101, -0.0323735736310482, 0.022309182211756706, -0.0259238313883543, -0.043453484773635864, -0.007084997370839119, -0.024309175089001656, 0.049880336970090866, -0.005188426002860069, -0.017094235867261887, 0.008612146601080894, -0.0014011445455253124, -0.014264365658164024, -0.06157069280743599, -0.11097541451454163, -0.0022219521924853325, 0.019428038969635963, 0.05000879988074303, -0.00019097828771919012, 0.007120904512703419, 0.051217928528785706, 0.05803898721933365, -0.026602473109960556, -0.017609620466828346, 0.02047315053641796, -0.02540193684399128, -0.008753489702939987, 0.017490370199084282, 0.04928458482027054, -0.023706184700131416, 0.03289613127708435, 0.021574880927801132, 0.04042770713567734, 0.06331110000610352, 0.01205119676887989, 0.004194681067019701, 0.029259350150823593, 0.025890393182635307, -0.007179197855293751, 0.010308855213224888, 0.030217977240681648, -0.06980355829000473, -0.012965688481926918, 0.004279456567019224, 0.0024095256812870502, 0.014388419687747955, -0.02448969893157482, 0.05959874391555786, -0.0020760386250913143, 0.04399348795413971, -0.04994692653417587, 0.0363798514008522, 0.0038776772562414408, 0.01259902399033308, 0.003730322001501918, -0.011466779746115208, 0.038096532225608826, -0.026538467034697533, 0.0032316811848431826, 0.056226592510938644, 0.02334192581474781, 0.0000813339211163111, -0.012192829512059689, -0.006683022249490023, -0.01942818984389305, 0.004602628294378519, -0.025249313563108444, 0.009178456850349903, 0.027517711743712425, 0.00825475249439478, -0.02116747573018074, 0.011194859631359577, -0.041112687438726425, 0.0010032204445451498, -0.0591367669403553, -0.01177289243787527, 0.00711553730070591, 0.043603964149951935, -0.007771648932248354, 0.06058059632778168, 0.016917094588279724, -0.015629075467586517, 0.01136417593806982, -0.014702345244586468, -0.08073096722364426, 0.0058873421512544155, -0.014503594487905502, 0.0041577816009521484, -0.013208488002419472, -0.041961420327425, 0.00668211467564106, -0.051459528505802155, 0.0028124351520091295, 0.006645163055509329, 0.03617798537015915, -0.04861415922641754, -0.00739617645740509, -0.014027819968760014, -0.0297995675355196, -0.008963512256741524, 0.024896958842873573, 0.05102084204554558, -0.015434895642101765, 0.05157040059566498, 0.013988700695335865, -0.025816941633820534, 0.010515606962144375, -0.019432127475738525, 0.029686423018574715, 0.03777856379747391, 0.03082859329879284, 0.022079482674598694, 0.04568104445934296, -0.007013863883912563, 0.026039045304059982, -0.005696441046893597, 0.004373687319457531, 0.026610955595970154, -0.017018157988786697, -0.01363710593432188, -0.025958243757486343, -0.033867187798023224, 0.0006624549860134721, 0.062254466116428375, -0.01631704345345497, 0.035884782671928406, 0.04942445829510689, -0.004992068745195866, -0.0013306953478604555, -0.023869941011071205, 0.06110701337456703, -0.03651632368564606, -0.03343430534005165, -0.03433334082365036, -0.014793086796998978, -0.045324184000492096, 0.045789577066898346, 0.005869999062269926, 0.010484333150088787, -0.01572691835463047, 0.0018629318801686168, 0.04223063960671425, -0.0034083190839737654, 0.01886896975338459, -0.00452365493401885, -0.006878139451146126, 0.011387032456696033, -0.008203377947211266, 0.009611519984900951, 0.003524060593917966, 0.033194828778505325, 0.0019165889825671911, 0.0385173074901104, -0.02384900487959385, -0.042319655418395996, 0.013170154765248299, 0.0367605984210968, 0.03384886309504509, -0.02784998156130314, 0.020043767988681793, -0.0843035951256752, -0.0006467386847361922, 0.033292967826128006, -0.028067627921700478, 0.044468045234680176, -0.018573665991425514, -0.008473297581076622, -0.056177955120801926, -0.034121252596378326, -0.007668528240174055, 0.028823494911193848, 0.027817850932478905, 0.05593974515795708, 0.013018094003200531, -0.030824001878499985, -0.04268321022391319, -0.015113968402147293, 0.04031982272863388, 0.0629921555519104, -0.061610136181116104, -0.02131296880543232, -0.015320182777941227, 0.002315523335710168, -0.0075804973021149635, -0.06005849689245224, 0.05698823928833008, -0.02189636416733265, -0.035074129700660706, 0.027649398893117905, -0.029704071581363678, -0.06310122460126877, 0.002362653845921159, 0.004817566368728876, -0.035773925483226776, 0.0024245735257864, -0.016937782987952232, 0.04655471071600914, 0.014209652319550514, 0.00628972053527832, 0.0042008874006569386, -0.003322388045489788, 0.007663835305720568, 0.021923113614320755, 0.006440797355026007, 0.03520818427205086, -0.000024147515432559885, 0.012689633294939995, 0.0012314943596720695, -0.007171732373535633, -0.027611970901489258, 0.05165846645832062, 0.031304024159908295, 0.07219979912042618, -0.01878935657441616, -0.017293967306613922, -0.011206506751477718, 0.017963046208024025, 0.026929624378681183, 0.0329282283782959, -0.026249893009662628, -0.015861643478274345, 0.023219658061861992, 0.002747968537732959, 0.03226354718208313, -0.02528519183397293, -0.002306918613612652, 0.006317300256341696, 0.0032630381174385548, 0.043840017169713974, -0.06854388862848282, -0.018180105835199356, 0.03690725564956665, -0.012456431984901428, 0.05003989115357399, -0.0033711690921336412, 0.04270058870315552, 0.026464741677045822, -0.02135561592876911, -0.05314919352531433, -0.020557550713419914, -0.02408701181411743, 0.030692782253026962, -0.07223072648048401, 0.009751579724252224, -0.009857897646725178, -0.03597467020153999, -0.06942396610975266, -0.01995134726166725, 0.02036874368786812, 0.004257938824594021, -0.002812275430187583, 0.003140580141916871, 0.006285632029175758, -0.0021192680578678846, -0.026062367483973503, -0.024568278342485428, 0.02040420100092888, 0.01776597835123539, -0.04511529952287674, 0.009312556125223637, 0.0053784833289682865, 0.03537115827202797, 0.002867253730073571, -0.003519025631248951, -0.012032720260322094, -0.0334763340651989, 0.007563546299934387, 0.008797469548881054, 0.04955670237541199, -0.018151473253965378, -0.04989786446094513, -0.02062865160405636, -0.0018764982232823968, 0.02570442669093609, -0.04786505922675133, -0.012302699498832226, 0.03432406485080719, -0.00810347031801939, 0.020390760153532028, 0.012479751370847225, -0.022221295163035393, 0.013789095915853977, 0.013828016817569733, 0.03918281942605972, 0.002405470237135887, 0.019227148965001106, -0.01693582907319069, 0.003634456545114517, 0.039450082927942276, -0.0004962340462952852, -0.007650280836969614, 0.026411956176161766, -0.007219251710921526, -0.011741545982658863, 0.04470067843794823, -0.003015226684510708, 0.031765058636665344, -0.04291427507996559, -0.005507580004632473, -0.020265430212020874, 0.006261258851736784, -0.04426686093211174, -0.03441491350531578, -0.017641862854361534, 0.010237282142043114, 0.05059810355305672, -0.012661508284509182, 0.04974904656410217, 0.03022509440779686, 0.011614744551479816, -0.026808617636561394, -0.03613732010126114, 0.001005729311145842, -0.034368228167295456, -0.00830348301678896, 0.05960732698440552, -0.025018276646733284, 0.004370043519884348, 0.046918198466300964, 0.05944910645484924, 0.03400098904967308, -0.0004051176074426621, 0.033314723521471024, 0.027099836617708206, 0.04941835254430771, -0.05661571025848389, -0.04014744982123375, 0.016981543973088264, -0.06779034435749054, -0.026781225576996803, -0.002609510673210025, 0.021442333236336708, 0.03171169012784958, -0.01730581372976303, -0.02601868286728859, -0.0639045313000679, -0.019090846180915833, -0.022715438157320023, -0.02246036008000374, 0.021535448729991913, 0.02737506851553917, -0.005894825793802738, 0.0008500965195707977, 0.0032197393011301756, -0.009813545271754265, 0.03696322441101074, -0.05678714066743851, -0.06590854376554489, -0.06756819039583206, -0.01492649968713522, -0.03786595165729523, 0.008474831469357014, 0.0027330562006682158, -0.04729897901415825, 0.013608865439891815, 0.0043442645110189915, 0.018829073756933212, 0.0297032929956913, 0.04185287654399872, -0.0014030096353963017, 0.0825093686580658, 0.004220013041049242, 0.029492106288671494, -0.006364704575389624, 0.03109876811504364, 0.12044455111026764, 0.05468439310789108, 0.0110825439915061, -0.05543680116534233, 0.03007529117166996, -0.01709526777267456, 0.01275988481938839, -0.04372471943497658, 0.02053023874759674, -0.008206234313547611, 0.005033140070736408, -0.007340569514781237, 0.029105955734848976, 0.06319859623908997, -0.03171176835894585, 0.004824118223041296, -0.03809882327914238, -0.01032230257987976, -0.0003400642017368227, 0.026436015963554382, 0.0032357939053326845, 0.016593731939792633, -0.03239208832383156, -0.016181200742721558, -0.035083115100860596, -0.014075098559260368, 0.02110760100185871, 0.00002285829759784974, -0.021377841010689735, 0.0034482176415622234, 0.010281382128596306, 0.02997032180428505, 0.03353934362530708, -0.02656073495745659, 0.010183514095842838, 0.043327998369932175, 0.028680654242634773, -0.020180586725473404, 0.04463554546236992, 0.015479538589715958, 0.015350252389907837, -0.006183325313031673, 0.01903783529996872, 0.010313240811228752, -0.02040570043027401, -0.034172479063272476, -0.04067358747124672, 0.027406195178627968, 0.006211606785655022, -0.015028245747089386, -0.004682204686105251, -0.03372342884540558, 0.00006261974340304732, -0.08600642532110214, -0.03856940567493439, 0.054908715188503265, 0.018848447129130363, -0.04291169345378876, -0.01479446329176426, 0.00823612604290247, 0.001856634160503745, -0.014580495655536652, -0.0020241462625563145, 0.004920062143355608, -0.010853055864572525, -0.04150814190506935, -0.0019672145135700703, 0.026078596711158752, 0.02985556237399578, -0.01175747998058796, 0.00522546237334609, -0.021214952692389488, -0.028984539210796356, -0.026499345898628235, -0.012856228277087212, -0.0028668816667050123, 0.030493132770061493, -0.03140123561024666, 0.0015549352392554283, 0.026373211294412613, -0.01839991845190525, -0.0030623963102698326, 0.008491660468280315, -0.023261303082108498, -0.011771333403885365, 0.025728464126586914, 0.022248659282922745, 0.017109297215938568, 0.020382314920425415, -0.010313632898032665, 0.033717941492795944, 0.04963910952210426, 0.013646777719259262, -0.03137749433517456, -0.010563922114670277, -0.01177859865128994, -0.025278348475694656, 0.0075057330541312695, 0.0033124112524092197, 0.047905758023262024, 0.015318943187594414, 0.004209050443023443, 0.04062288999557495, 0.02530612237751484, -0.03866947442293167, 0.022810565307736397, 0.006064136046916246, -0.05309218540787697, -0.015063120052218437, 0.003921977244317532, -0.0024849306792020798, -0.009925697930157185, -0.06971986591815948, -0.03531662002205849, 0.030629344284534454, -0.005560236517339945, -0.03175486996769905, -0.007336149923503399, -0.010776620358228683, -0.013779271394014359, 0.023672929033637047, -0.02249930426478386, -0.02074272558093071, -0.0025509255938231945, -0.018841693177819252, -0.04052051529288292, 0.022944582626223564, 0.017486058175563812, 0.05035218596458435, -0.010948801413178444, -0.04091407731175423, 0.04330668970942497, 0.004827258177101612, -0.0016338767018169165, -0.03133123368024826, 0.002478756010532379, -0.02087274007499218, 0.04549136385321617, -0.03709650784730911, -0.025006938725709915, 0.030796511098742485, -0.029886968433856964, -0.021626757457852364, 0.01792299374938011, -0.032701097428798676, 0.03938142955303192, 0.05833477899432182, -0.03969723358750343, -0.04092071205377579, 0.036206044256687164, -0.041070301085710526, -0.004747314378619194, 0.02233525738120079, 0.03445904701948166, 0.00747123034670949, 0.002499595982953906, -0.010778451338410378, -0.04158646613359451, -0.006257755681872368, -0.018053200095891953, 0.03526800498366356, 0.014495599083602428, -0.0046326955780386925, 0.002045626053586602, 0.019262824207544327, -0.010737283155322075, -0.013337538577616215, -0.003328089602291584, 0.011436907574534416, 0.04334189370274544, -0.027733180671930313, 0.03075195848941803, -0.019699955359101295, -0.010567731224000454, -0.07651209086179733, -0.003334818407893181, 0.0033326612319797277, 0.027379950508475304, 0.022104710340499878, -0.07193978130817413, 0.04501726105809212, 0.006991710513830185, -0.07858733832836151, 0.03915571793913841, 0.004057697486132383, -0.017709482461214066, -0.042639292776584625, 0.05384434387087822, -0.03624187782406807, 0.03284778073430061, 0.04305191710591316, 0.012595443986356258, 0.02307676337659359, 0.025003746151924133, -0.01864197663962841, -0.019350847229361534, -0.013617335818707943, 0.019920671358704567, 0.023213712498545647, -0.041752830147743225, 0.03549649938941002, -0.0691257193684578, -0.009024634957313538, 0.048706647008657455, -0.024607479572296143, -0.015504660084843636, -0.013695435598492622, 0.011124404147267342, 0.01345719676464796, 0.03476620465517044, 0.009811784140765667, -0.022651635110378265, -0.009904282167553902, 0.01541201863437891, 0.052007194608449936, 0.026575641706585884, 0.009605025872588158, -0.033509284257888794, 0.0316147617995739, -0.013980494812130928, -0.06471718847751617, 0.00024761894019320607, 0.032357703894376755, -0.011656931601464748, 0.037629134953022, 0.02820340357720852, 0.03690730035305023, -0.010788303799927235, 0.013974785804748535, -0.04661758616566658, -0.0011570749338716269, 0.004948099609464407, 0.02339775301516056, -0.01748104952275753, -0.03110506758093834, -0.011257299222052097, -0.03139033541083336, 0.0006502337055280805, 0.009932690300047398, 0.013023262843489647, -0.0556926466524601, 0.00497033167630434, 0.014384877867996693, 0.009049463085830212, 0.03618163987994194, -0.04970552772283554, -0.043614745140075684, 0.011195080354809761, -0.001674119965173304, -0.0004647983005270362, 0.01632719300687313, -0.02845483273267746, -0.03991946205496788, -0.10470524430274963, 0.0678924173116684, -0.022435177117586136, 0.032743122428655624, -0.07589774578809738, -0.031953953206539154, -0.04610227793455124, 0.05270247161388397, 0.061726488173007965, -0.003448826028034091, -0.013371162116527557, -0.001887514372356236, 0.001687909010797739, 0.004207983613014221, 0.0006411093636415899, 0.04208601266145706, -0.007238609250634909, -0.011963649652898312, -0.0020423217210918665, -0.005468095187097788, 0.04124140739440918, 0.014020068570971489, -0.018089821562170982, -0.004305880982428789, 0.012858427129685879, -0.008000355213880539, -0.0011869600275531411, 0.02059345878660679, -0.006152845453470945, -0.023923588916659355, 0.038404431194067, 0.0039818864315748215, 0.04799593612551689, -0.010964950546622276, -0.018905021250247955, -0.08236721903085709, 0.03591668978333473, -0.040469441562891006, -0.02998087927699089, -0.020160125568509102, -0.0006282514659687877, 0.024801140651106834, -0.01095560472458601, -0.006462801247835159, 0.004214671906083822, -0.04170874133706093, -0.010843823663890362, 0.05392801761627197, 0.0015146835939958692, 0.06592006236314774, -0.017855161800980568, 0.018347883597016335, -0.007833180017769337, 0.010053194127976894, 0.015208827331662178, 0.019442910328507423, -0.0014630609657615423, 0.00603965250775218, 0.06444016098976135, 0.04052730277180672, 0.010803589597344398, 0.0221236702054739, -0.012691883370280266, 0.020375430583953857, 0.012866536155343056, -0.004709444474428892, 0.007598001044243574, -0.015595509670674801, -0.025875911116600037, 0.038231391459703445, -0.00347158988006413, 0.054684728384017944, -0.010177218355238438, -0.012325282208621502, -0.01912045106291771, 0.04171231761574745, -0.03602279722690582, -0.014783045276999474, 0.014606394805014133, 0.013086378574371338, -0.0007391562685370445, 0.016072312369942665, -0.006482382770627737, 0.02209465578198433, 0.011972058564424515, -0.05592864379286766, 0.015374206006526947, -0.012466155923902988, -0.040952492505311966, -0.017364803701639175, 0.015518557280302048, -0.01863229274749756, -0.012625554576516151, 0.00279934611171484, 0.03770960494875908, 0.02838624082505703, 0.013918069191277027, -0.03352249041199684, -0.01788201928138733, 0.07660533487796783, -0.03867580369114876, -0.011097610928118229, -0.07207262516021729, 0.024345295503735542, -0.016390718519687653, -0.029578503221273422 ]
<p>I'm reading the results of an individual patient data (IPD) meta-analysis. The outcomes of the study is expressed in standard deviations (SD's). Comparisons between groups are stated as 0,23 (95% CI 0.15-0.33), SD 0.34, etc. I can't grasp how to interpretate this. Can somebody help?</p>
74,481
[ -0.015085509046912193, -0.034703176468610764, -0.019445030018687248, -0.014874698594212532, 0.022513840347528458, 0.04855259507894516, -0.014516173861920834, -0.025958595797419548, 0.008682582527399063, -0.024856096133589745, 0.037600819021463394, 0.008040225133299828, 0.051405925303697586, -0.0019721209537237883, 0.006035664118826389, 0.0015744167612865567, -0.009858522564172745, 0.010788975283503532, 0.003065737895667553, 0.007049768231809139, 0.005892827175557613, -0.0232376791536808, -0.011185240931808949, 0.017519090324640274, -0.03368889167904854, 0.06477069109678268, 0.018229253590106964, -0.02382482774555683, 0.02627328783273697, 0.027437271550297737, -0.05260065197944641, -0.017464715987443924, -0.034122418612241745, -0.006834014784544706, -0.007286887615919113, -0.01274513266980648, -0.04560164734721184, -0.008561627939343452, -0.005479379557073116, 0.04443865269422531, -0.031373463571071625, -0.0011621691519394517, 0.016780981793999672, 0.005726298317313194, -0.05480988696217537, 0.021180350333452225, -0.001774802221916616, -0.04238496348261833, 0.0015214072773233056, -0.025349583476781845, 0.06587106734514236, -0.009099839255213737, 0.07001927495002747, 0.0190828125923872, -0.017602913081645966, 0.05077005922794342, 0.05579780042171478, 0.03160933405160904, 0.02276487834751606, -0.08719950169324875, -0.014644348062574863, -0.015487073920667171, -0.00626812968403101, 0.017299938946962357, 0.007544073276221752, 0.015821291133761406, 0.013856000266969204, -0.049422360956668854, 0.0421803817152977, 0.022608093917369843, 0.043067581951618195, 0.03595851734280586, 0.013469457626342773, -0.024186307564377785, 0.011493436992168427, -0.0280148908495903, 0.015306194312870502, 0.007770011201500893, 0.024473559111356735, 0.026349829509854317, 0.016094911843538284, 0.0028816810809075832, 0.02791954018175602, 0.014555278234183788, -0.023576388135552406, 0.004664114210754633, 0.06389161944389343, -0.005460295360535383, 0.02590601146221161, 0.020363569259643555, 0.012634643353521824, 0.002148322993889451, 0.0438966304063797, -0.01102419849485159, -0.05404392257332802, -0.006505078170448542, -0.0088047431781888, 0.043789368122816086, -0.025156352669000626, -0.012620821595191956, 0.008130320347845554, -0.032161056995391846, 0.010416796430945396, 0.019577382132411003, -0.0031791955698281527, -0.004115541465580463, -0.034693457186222076, 0.018814442679286003, 0.010002348572015762, -0.0009257639176212251, -0.013300741091370583, -0.0012314646737650037, 0.002619550097733736, 0.01965223252773285, 0.008206009864807129, -0.009966349229216576, -0.03290848806500435, 0.0044226255267858505, 0.03880194574594498, 0.036756597459316254, 0.0454559251666069, -0.041474420577287674, 0.03539934381842613, 0.022958779707551003, -0.04284645617008209, 0.032049424946308136, 0.02606847509741783, -0.006078646518290043, -0.03479203209280968, 0.036311857402324677, -0.00016348848294001073, -0.02430666610598564, 0.05763164907693863, 0.02159317024052143, 0.01260716188699007, -0.015026113949716091, -0.05459488928318024, -0.05530918017029762, 0.023307185620069504, 0.0038912512827664614, 0.0050413100980222225, -0.06310887634754181, -0.02904401533305645, 0.006711035035550594, 0.03419884666800499, 0.0035364425275474787, 0.059149518609046936, -0.014712665230035782, 0.01928299106657505, 0.04918977990746498, 0.0005455049686133862, 0.01023060642182827, -0.028120946139097214, -0.02201772853732109, -0.009405187331140041, -0.06540612131357193, 0.03773824870586395, -0.0019969053100794554, 0.010513604618608952, -0.033653903752565384, 0.015761150047183037, -0.025511614978313446, -0.009940959513187408, 0.008555547334253788, 0.012436466291546822, 0.015413905493915081, 0.05382898077368736, 0.003315286012366414, -0.0008198089199140668, 0.03569817543029785, 0.006530746817588806, 0.008697737008333206, 0.018841827288269997, 0.05405077338218689, 0.03068518079817295, 0.018111100420355797, 0.00022398891451302916, -0.0528523214161396, -0.007504686713218689, 0.01393152866512537, -0.05692390352487564, -0.012524563819169998, -0.035292018204927444, -0.002232352504506707, 0.0004402936901897192, 0.05579644814133644, -0.024961519986391068, -0.023828784003853798, 0.026683181524276733, -0.038793113082647324, -0.04800241440534592, -0.07714077085256577, 0.007962589152157307, -0.0004429667314980179, -0.03631480410695076, 0.02005852572619915, 0.029998403042554855, 0.048769693821668625, -0.03664873167872429, 0.010732609778642654, -0.0318300798535347, -0.03489282727241516, 0.05259181186556816, -0.016352692618966103, 0.031047143042087555, 0.023973895236849785, 0.04256301745772362, -0.018763883039355278, 0.013688690960407257, -0.022638479247689247, -0.056439124047756195, 0.008746011182665825, -0.018440280109643936, 0.023297974839806557, 0.01994083635509014, -0.007099863141775131, -0.01324374694377184, -0.011953277513384819, -0.010198727250099182, -0.010699436999857426, -0.033364783972501755, 0.07813950628042221, 0.06613022834062576, 0.027871781960129738, -0.027703288942575455, 0.01953696459531784, -0.0019224724965170026, -0.007444049697369337, -0.01669338159263134, -0.04119263216853142, -0.016488665714859962, -0.017442487180233, 0.039102669805288315, 0.023151010274887085, -0.020034056156873703, -0.017808984965085983, 0.06221117824316025, 0.031899165362119675, 0.02304922230541706, 0.03365481272339821, -0.00302907545119524, -0.01473286934196949, 0.0005344303208403289, 0.025614725425839424, 0.015786416828632355, 0.02283678576350212, 0.011172423139214516, 0.0132001843303442, 0.05441105365753174, 0.023392336443066597, -0.0016206088475883007, 0.04270165413618088, -0.009348434396088123, 0.015528444200754166, -0.012907291762530804, -0.028746528550982475, 0.02095276303589344, -0.03513024374842644, 0.020519470795989037, 0.024567317217588425, -0.01124619785696268, 0.010857975110411644, -0.01041447464376688, 0.011229429394006729, 0.015248209238052368, 0.03672686219215393, -0.016590679064393044, 0.02866530977189541, 0.016523241996765137, -0.03825853392481804, 0.02463250607252121, -0.010631775483489037, -0.048414409160614014, -0.020509690046310425, -0.023886363953351974, 0.016497230157256126, 0.010753296315670013, 0.06498324871063232, -0.010181228630244732, -0.0021055552642792463, -0.006332009099423885, -0.0017847710987553, 0.004529877565801144, 0.006344284396618605, -0.07865151017904282, 0.006342635024338961, 0.0008862616377882659, -0.03721929341554642, 0.019152339547872543, -0.008409904316067696, -0.00592304952442646, 0.003859245218336582, -0.018188728019595146, -0.0552421398460865, -0.006067984737455845, 0.013324921950697899, 0.02786439098417759, -0.009760109707713127, -0.001470826449804008, 0.02467605471611023, -0.013529508374631405, -0.029932189732789993, 0.02953675203025341, -0.02666260488331318, -0.0028379943687468767, -0.007884540595114231, 0.026539718732237816, 0.01346801221370697, 0.0028074688743799925, -0.0027947796043008566, 0.03320528566837311, -0.045802220702171326, -0.014728492125868797, -0.07461267709732056, -0.05403987690806389, 0.00847523845732212, 0.016294261440634727, 0.03132503107190132, -0.01775544136762619, -0.013105764985084534, 0.0890694409608841, 0.006386346649378538, -0.02849910594522953, -0.04175817593932152, 0.03202225640416145, -0.053376320749521255, 0.017516199499368668, 0.03117223270237446, 0.04725804179906845, -0.007657700218260288, 0.015481690876185894, 0.014580246061086655, 0.06411612033843994, 0.05851735919713974, -0.03359466418623924, -0.02853471226990223, 0.025699326768517494, 0.017873942852020264, -0.02091960608959198, 0.03444809094071388, 0.026911262422800064, -0.014432140626013279, 0.009391904808580875, 0.003539096564054489, 0.05014333128929138, 0.0007863315404392779, -0.05746624991297722, 0.04436330124735832, 0.03356902301311493, 0.0022816346026957035, -0.03620762750506401, 0.03801150992512703, 0.013401977717876434, -0.0004195381479803473, 0.009205161593854427, 0.004092774353921413, 0.03747306391596794, -0.041727110743522644, 0.0005402644746936858, 0.04573865607380867, 0.036818645894527435, 0.015694985166192055, -0.03219916671514511, 0.01940249651670456, -0.02229437604546547, -0.009607727639377117, -0.005726262927055359, -0.029656851664185524, 0.02885417826473713, 0.04183046892285347, 0.008944417349994183, -0.024052074179053307, -0.05462777987122536, 0.013624699786305428, -0.06301211565732956, -0.013368142768740654, -0.0068486640229821205, -0.0006520765018649399, -0.028791429474949837, 0.0405537411570549, 0.03855523467063904, -0.010146680288016796, -0.00795201025903225, -0.025978323072195053, -0.04995855689048767, 0.06427976489067078, -0.005965529941022396, 0.012568216770887375, -0.008862830698490143, -0.016957689076662064, 0.02101093903183937, -0.03541717678308487, 0.0037630824372172356, 0.014170367270708084, 0.021588975563645363, 0.02086784318089485, -0.036832112818956375, 0.005141951609402895, 0.007141839247196913, -0.02737826481461525, 0.025812534615397453, -0.0050679827108979225, -0.008625439368188381, -0.006132477894425392, 0.044672783464193344, 0.0003473886754363775, -0.008218787610530853, -0.04088817909359932, -0.005493022035807371, 0.03402270749211311, 0.0305884201079607, 0.036604464054107666, 0.015380528755486012, -0.004496174864470959, 0.03879832848906517, 0.0010700644925236702, 0.04765315726399422, 0.044437430799007416, -0.031198415905237198, -0.01536723505705595, -0.036616165190935135, -0.013287444598972797, 0.009347236715257168, -0.009921214543282986, 0.019160348922014236, 0.006663253530859947, 0.08064647018909454, 0.034230269491672516, -0.05702958256006241, 0.004435435868799686, 0.05175388976931572, 0.0003740466490853578, -0.028224213048815727, -0.05893364176154137, -0.02472526952624321, -0.011857256293296814, -0.027877962216734886, 0.06187882646918297, 0.024731595069169998, 0.007328518666327, -0.0007849966641515493, 0.05133747309446335, -0.030152983963489532, -0.06164940819144249, -0.018214959651231766, -0.022976284846663475, 0.04808592051267624, 0.008347058668732643, -0.020230649039149284, 0.02164085954427719, 0.02975328080356121, 0.06379370391368866, 0.0442209467291832, 0.02944224514067173, -0.06480830162763596, 0.0009312169859185815, 0.016999851912260056, 0.07191628962755203, -0.02063855528831482, -0.014964926056563854, -0.034334633499383926, 0.04388931766152382, 0.04706538841128349, -0.011621343903243542, 0.000883325410541147, -0.02403716929256916, 0.005030354019254446, -0.038198161870241165, -0.035105057060718536, -0.01585944928228855, 0.024790525436401367, 0.006785329896956682, 0.034919437021017075, -0.028954531997442245, -0.009322263300418854, -0.03733893856406212, -0.020116489380598068, 0.011782637797296047, 0.03472023829817772, -0.01579792983829975, 0.0014079709071666002, 0.02130419760942459, 0.050599437206983566, -0.027768023312091827, -0.0884028896689415, 0.017115261405706406, -0.00778504554182291, 0.024958372116088867, 0.03612512722611427, -0.04430596902966499, -0.037390075623989105, 0.004522010218352079, 0.028272578492760658, -0.040417373180389404, 0.002860240638256073, -0.036803241819143295, 0.025905637070536613, 0.006849442608654499, 0.0042500304989516735, 0.036244940012693405, -0.017891565337777138, -0.028146086260676384, -0.018045129254460335, -0.04558435082435608, 0.03801620379090309, 0.014473686926066875, -0.0056795962154865265, -0.05660878121852875, -0.040783219039440155, 0.0034579699859023094, -0.001084182527847588, -0.00485006021335721, 0.05323707312345505, 0.009509868919849396, 0.00742769381031394, -0.0008708742680028081, -0.014862798154354095, 0.024740731343626976, 0.005827594548463821, 0.009078615345060825, 0.005504158791154623, -0.00509868748486042, -0.06154267117381096, 0.04522552341222763, -0.0638863816857338, 0.013160895556211472, 0.014353456906974316, -0.04495835304260254, -0.008607340045273304, -0.021564751863479614, -0.07117830216884613, 0.0271381177008152, -0.07119767367839813, 0.02157221920788288, -0.03056637942790985, 0.00186281674541533, -0.017613233998417854, -0.019105980172753334, -0.04670677334070206, -0.0006933898548595607, -0.037906695157289505, 0.0448337085545063, -0.04781974479556084, 0.03570712357759476, -0.006170391570776701, -0.005079455208033323, -0.09311076253652573, -0.034842126071453094, 0.061809878796339035, 0.005195909645408392, -0.06356997042894363, -0.024479566141963005, 0.02691149152815342, -0.016071569174528122, -0.04417215660214424, -0.004680789075791836, 0.050687626004219055, 0.009437836706638336, -0.01461534108966589, -0.05081633850932121, 0.010427880100905895, 0.08681435883045197, -0.017182666808366776, -0.02125472202897072, 0.010670332238078117, -0.005605477374047041, -0.004385509993880987, -0.03671029955148697, 0.015994543209671974, -0.02006523497402668, 0.004143858328461647, -0.050362762063741684, 0.0010865803342312574, 0.007245863787829876, -0.031107710674405098, 0.010416965000331402, -0.022298641502857208, 0.006223964970558882, 0.02770007960498333, -0.011385809630155563, 0.01414427999407053, -0.020955486223101616, 0.05617203190922737, -0.0077346027828752995, 0.025585399940609932, -0.0043416800908744335, 0.025572385638952255, 0.02274077758193016, 0.025511864572763443, -0.0069594476372003555, 0.030344711616635323, 0.07200220227241516, -0.018997186794877052, 0.017644355073571205, -0.01968896947801113, -0.023991800844669342, 0.023864442482590675, 0.025691507384181023, 0.01654745638370514, -0.006301091052591801, 0.052589233964681625, -0.030222885310649872, -0.0026915385387837887, -0.06432988494634628, 0.03875109553337097, 0.04935789480805397, 0.007093545515090227, 0.03800862655043602, 0.08952789753675461, -0.0217945147305727, 0.012994169257581234, -0.03110835701227188, -0.025459032505750656, 0.012531003914773464, -0.007412209641188383, 0.04411562159657478, 0.0035832885187119246, -0.01786058023571968, 0.04763871058821678, 0.03758467361330986, -0.03033515438437462, 0.02309163473546505, 0.014379902742803097, -0.030585991218686104, 0.017794298008084297, -0.0006858532433398068, -0.03897426277399063, 0.03553350269794464, -0.03699268028140068, 0.02621305175125599, -0.06108958646655083, 0.015798496082425117, 0.03264879062771797, 0.015578196384012699, 0.014569186605513096, -0.047011423856019974, 0.0015606458764523268, -0.05844895914196968, -0.0023397079203277826, 0.03390979394316673, -0.027158433571457863, 0.006122476886957884, -0.0068108863197267056, 0.027327988296747208, -0.011349503882229328, 0.03129236027598381, -0.002923078602179885, -0.07300963997840881, -0.04037265107035637, -0.004566131625324488, -0.019432056695222855, 0.025535983964800835, -0.010072100907564163, -0.040698833763599396, 0.017409779131412506, -0.016053954139351845, 0.03379938378930092, 0.012515678070485592, -0.008677368983626366, 0.0015621335478499532, 0.052539944648742676, 0.03252168372273445, 0.027553396299481392, -0.005283609963953495, -0.01660437323153019, 0.12207157164812088, 0.04992428421974182, 0.021363012492656708, -0.07890347391366959, 0.02710488624870777, 0.010540405288338661, 0.002758848713710904, 0.026875615119934082, 0.042966362088918686, 0.016196951270103455, 0.005267024505883455, 0.06381430476903915, 0.033677950501441956, 0.01765955612063408, -0.021822599694132805, 0.048679169267416, -0.022616734728217125, -0.03506713733077049, 0.04035596922039986, 0.013402087613940239, -0.00798226147890091, -0.04186331853270531, -0.056646719574928284, 0.01296977698802948, -0.012656455859541893, 0.01986093260347843, -0.00023151490313466638, -0.02487586811184883, 0.007992371916770935, 0.019008588045835495, -0.031618427485227585, -0.019776927307248116, 0.01676201820373535, 0.02038123644888401, -0.032602544873952866, -0.031175171956419945, 0.01085642073303461, -0.025080757215619087, -0.0002154629910364747, 0.029494620859622955, 0.0024382106494158506, -0.010538853704929352, 0.00023892831814009696, 0.021038100123405457, -0.01879754289984703, -0.008794589899480343, -0.00525915902107954, 0.029649777337908745, -0.014154113829135895, -0.019649900496006012, -0.031236253678798676, 0.03638472035527229, -0.040163252502679825, -0.03953467682003975, 0.003757515223696828, -0.007460888009518385, 0.02162708155810833, -0.036941055208444595, -0.009038127027451992, -0.025754282251000404, -0.00779692130163312, -0.03719254210591316, 0.04219352826476097, 0.026213569566607475, -0.02261904999613762, -0.004388109780848026, -0.038039956241846085, -0.0019142775563523173, -0.028889209032058716, 0.010193681344389915, 0.023260870948433876, 0.021021639928221703, -0.017914339900016785, 0.007131896447390318, -0.009092225693166256, -0.008188358508050442, 0.04946735501289368, 0.002551527228206396, -0.0025634029880166054, -0.004756734240800142, -0.027247752994298935, 0.02612282522022724, -0.0316702276468277, -0.0021206634119153023, -0.012621699832379818, 0.011954724788665771, 0.031021898612380028, 0.04970693588256836, -0.02390323579311371, 0.057632364332675934, -0.014914598315954208, 0.05232167989015579, 0.016901198774576187, -0.04642541706562042, -0.024431977421045303, 0.014876289293169975, -0.033135320991277695, 0.0020841516088694334, -0.008046652190387249, 0.0569106861948967, 0.016560349613428116, -0.0046780649572610855, 0.02267824113368988, 0.06194645166397095, 0.002026450587436557, 0.014943785034120083, 0.009536808356642723, -0.08407721668481827, -0.0038968154694885015, 0.012885993346571922, 0.016208132728934288, -0.012307615950703621, 0.01804760843515396, -0.01678399182856083, -0.04217325150966644, 0.01143766101449728, 0.0014324282528832555, 0.0009530306560918689, 0.0005529721966013312, -0.015165195800364017, -0.018061328679323196, 0.026123298332095146, -0.033195529133081436, -0.051681339740753174, 0.001968445023521781, 0.023758193477988243, 0.012495440430939198, -0.003978112246841192, 0.015063039027154446, 0.006638474762439728, -0.026235664263367653, 0.006644588895142078, -0.0015310565941035748, -0.009365824982523918, 0.01779814437031746, 0.031430572271347046, -0.0001006385573418811, 0.022582031786441803, -0.02394561469554901, -0.009026991203427315, 0.048790521919727325, -0.01089384313672781, -0.05792815983295441, 0.03609788045287132, -0.0013338609132915735, 0.0021537174470722675, 0.008837105706334114, -0.02325475588440895, -0.029142694547772408, 0.08161360025405884, -0.08012555539608002, -0.07784753292798996, -0.024409472942352295, -0.013881460763514042, -0.005381615832448006, -0.00024950457736849785, 0.006526406854391098, 0.024130085483193398, -0.03034043312072754, 0.00955287553369999, 0.02422959730029106, 0.007898388430476189, 0.014694600366055965, 0.011519107036292553, 0.007463896181434393, 0.01109260693192482, 0.012443732470273972, 0.020541314035654068, 0.034165602177381516, 0.050076160579919815, -0.020581871271133423, 0.034805018454790115, 0.025191357359290123, 0.014618401415646076, -0.06461980193853378, -0.02537432685494423, -0.013068214058876038, -0.004426585044711828, -0.0029969951137900352, -0.07944369316101074, 0.0046261753886938095, 0.006764335557818413, -0.036188606172800064, 0.011046695522964, -0.02202390693128109, -0.08128722757101059, -0.04577501490712166, 0.01055707037448883, -0.006332450546324253, 0.035536304116249084, 0.018502848222851753, 0.005592092406004667, -0.000871863798238337, 0.0199925247579813, 0.004952082876116037, -0.01055122446268797, -0.06847365945577621, 0.03433125093579292, 0.032988041639328, -0.05506526306271553, 0.0016075297025963664, -0.014092013239860535, -0.047498006373643875, 0.04149575158953667, -0.007423119619488716, 0.0026474646292626858, 0.04324698448181152, 0.055360015481710434, -0.012425625696778297, 0.03079391084611416, 0.010880367830395699, -0.010140227153897285, -0.04984738305211067, -0.02407674305140972, 0.011785178445279598, 0.023868871852755547, -0.003191168885678053, 0.03772033751010895, 0.05489374324679375, -0.015489564277231693, -0.011122925207018852, 0.014176028780639172, -0.009991239756345749, -0.03282667323946953, -0.02016725204885006, -0.02328174188733101, 0.04342687875032425, -0.05388253927230835, 0.03163512051105499, -0.04756855592131615, 0.014328479766845703, 0.043747127056121826, 0.026526175439357758, -0.005299984477460384, 0.025344349443912506, -0.022277291864156723, -0.007933941669762135, -0.04101695492863655, 0.022490806877613068, -0.035227302461862564, -0.04285375028848648, 0.015873068943619728, -0.043073806911706924, -0.02729584276676178, -0.022454386577010155, 0.01850958913564682, -0.02135167084634304, 0.0074912565760314465, 0.020957693457603455, 0.0035840310156345367, 0.023939484730362892, -0.05739501491189003, 0.010646721348166466, -0.05889283865690231, 0.042322561144828796, 0.025758005678653717, -0.04705338925123215, -0.05281699821352959, -0.01180281862616539, -0.039020176976919174, 0.03259456157684326, 0.04318776726722717, -0.00518783601000905, 0.021298613399267197, -0.00008984369924291968, 0.0183747336268425, 0.008068356662988663, -0.07117046415805817, 0.05190758407115936, -0.013595796190202236, -0.03417619690299034, -0.011055276729166508, 0.01582157611846924, 0.0022149207070469856, -0.00203118659555912, 0.017904086038470268, -0.01547063048928976, 0.05038721114397049, 0.006892311852425337, 0.010929248295724392, 0.05066661536693573, -0.0009928209474310279, -0.0453459806740284, 0.0686834380030632, 0.001750987721607089, 0.022804833948612213, 0.03979594260454178, -0.008236547000706196, -0.06758438050746918, 0.0175706148147583, -0.003117866348475218, -0.010357116349041462, -0.008365994319319725, 0.011389445513486862, -0.005224599502980709, -0.06839622557163239, 0.028348293155431747, 0.019073111936450005, -0.03978949040174484, 0.0025511279236525297, 0.02582665905356407, 0.06587561964988708, 0.0034178888890892267, 0.005848384462296963, -0.03175447881221771, -0.018513409420847893, -0.05093879997730255, 0.002585784299299121, -0.0051093981601297855, 0.03439069166779518, 0.013188871555030346, -0.0021163213532418013, 0.006659323815256357, -0.03377482295036316, 0.04299214854836464, -0.022042591124773026, 0.028451208025217056, -0.03910428658127785, -0.007509911432862282, -0.01588984951376915, -0.03035418689250946, 0.03720678761601448, 0.015146227553486824, 0.032705146819353104, 0.08558493107557297, -0.03709946945309639, 0.020956292748451233, -0.025043893605470657, -0.030841132625937462, -0.027719831094145775, -0.0484580472111702, 0.07457584142684937, 0.03347046673297882, 0.0023591388016939163, -0.044570885598659515, 0.026339009404182434, 0.03387494757771492, 0.02938106283545494, -0.018416740000247955, 0.026861688122153282, 0.013145843520760536, -0.03237668797373772, -0.046576254069805145, 0.0011541772400960326, -0.008011876605451107, -0.017228296026587486, -0.013272283598780632, 0.04210847616195679, 0.035744667053222656, 0.008884061127901077, -0.043884798884391785, -0.016036657616496086, 0.05222776159644127, -0.06539995223283768, -0.038176923990249634, -0.035861268639564514, 0.037278082221746445, -0.0006863575545139611, -0.00215105339884758 ]
<p>Documentation states that R gbm with distribution = "adaboost" can be used for 0-1 classification problem. Consider the following code fragment:</p> <pre><code>gbm_algorithm &lt;- gbm(y ~ ., data = train_dataset, distribution = "adaboost", n.trees = 5000) gbm_predicted &lt;- predict(gbm_algorithm, test_dataset, n.trees = 5000) </code></pre> <p>It can be found in the documentation that predict.gbm </p> <blockquote> <p>Returns a vector of predictions. By default the predictions are on the scale of f(x).</p> </blockquote> <p>However the particular scale is not clear for the case of distribution = "adaboost". </p> <p><strong>Could anyone help with the interpretation of predict.gbm return values and provide an idea of conversion to the 0-1 output?</strong></p>
74,482
[ -0.022237330675125122, -0.01270231045782566, -0.005779176019132137, -0.0017267443472519517, -0.0007301976438611746, 0.00006787299207644537, -0.03081638552248478, -0.007164145819842815, 0.02662281133234501, -0.023427145555615425, 0.03425804525613785, 0.004642161540687084, 0.02218177728354931, 0.002285218797624111, 0.033674631267786026, 0.021486302837729454, -0.023630216717720032, 0.0022192555479705334, 0.005950125399976969, -0.012928333133459091, 0.015837853774428368, 0.03690536692738533, 0.021606089547276497, -0.012497495859861374, -0.017231635749340057, 0.04633653163909912, 0.02741769701242447, 0.02162175439298153, 0.026669034734368324, 0.04905454441905022, -0.06974875181913376, -0.003406927455216646, -0.024856168776750565, 0.04604841396212578, -0.016082797199487686, 0.013356582261621952, -0.014834478497505188, -0.02455681748688221, -0.03587905690073967, 0.01773008517920971, 0.002993609057739377, -0.031362418085336685, 0.0421159528195858, 0.06785748153924942, 0.0014665656490251422, 0.003342127427458763, -0.044528353959321976, -0.03774595260620117, 0.0472458153963089, -0.029587723314762115, 0.08286749571561813, 0.01941920444369316, 0.029303068295121193, 0.021670347079634666, -0.0223364420235157, 0.01190137304365635, 0.07705288380384445, 0.04691839590668678, -0.030576491728425026, -0.037381600588560104, -0.005461213644593954, -0.04487410932779312, 0.00868106260895729, -0.012309065088629723, -0.010394003242254257, 0.029176196083426476, 0.0031144474633038044, -0.04030463099479675, 0.034932445734739304, -0.007280309218913317, 0.019760748371481895, 0.041738808155059814, 0.021278556436300278, -0.02994382195174694, 0.04173615202307701, -0.009843059815466404, -0.024639829993247986, -0.011689786799252033, 0.06111092492938042, 0.04328947886824608, -0.006071746349334717, 0.0390784777700901, -0.004080135375261307, 0.0075502051040530205, 0.014271394349634647, -0.01492402981966734, 0.06532985717058182, -0.01876932568848133, 0.0323365293443203, 0.031817931681871414, -0.04048076644539833, 0.014013164676725864, 0.046117089688777924, -0.02705162763595581, -0.016700150445103645, 0.040016744285821915, 0.0036414414644241333, 0.016421347856521606, -0.0027162914630025625, -0.02736000344157219, -0.004805353935807943, -0.05326749011874199, 0.004734683316200972, 0.031048135831952095, -0.05513153597712517, -0.009224332869052887, -0.049767229706048965, -0.020826430991292, 0.0024867721367627382, -0.026762232184410095, 0.003528303699567914, 0.03518974035978317, 0.0020901074167340994, -0.03782765194773674, 0.04682362824678421, -0.014456136152148247, 0.023588914424180984, 0.018557235598564148, 0.021601352840662003, 0.028146805241703987, 0.033876292407512665, -0.02993001416325569, 0.010279349982738495, -0.0036870825570076704, -0.03855317458510399, -0.019867535680532455, 0.014968243427574635, -0.03686901554465294, -0.03586960211396217, 0.053864482790231705, -0.014641676098108292, -0.025884943082928658, 0.034156445413827896, 0.008040323853492737, 0.01582822948694229, -0.012282225303351879, -0.05968685448169708, -0.059308845549821854, 0.0177907757461071, -0.019313817843794823, 0.05294760689139366, -0.05758821219205856, 0.010126830078661442, -0.012862307019531727, 0.015076118521392345, 0.01600441336631775, 0.061433691531419754, 0.00829995796084404, 0.0057839746586978436, -0.014287242665886879, -0.02297276072204113, -0.0071401940658688545, -0.023363817483186722, -0.02727908082306385, -0.035155948251485825, -0.050924092531204224, 0.013118105940520763, 0.008973276242613792, -0.019119855016469955, -0.036469463258981705, 0.012742282822728157, -0.033410049974918365, 0.009728053584694862, -0.0015848007751628757, -0.005494614597409964, -0.014051022008061409, 0.08609894663095474, 0.02457818016409874, 0.050293195992708206, 0.03625122085213661, -0.009541584178805351, 0.008558633737266064, 0.0057529546320438385, 0.039472661912441254, 0.051153939217329025, 0.007433070335537195, -0.004891095217317343, -0.04121886566281319, 0.04815205931663513, 0.01583724282681942, -0.020617220550775528, 0.00031120466883294284, 0.010210978798568249, -0.024547381326556206, -0.0013178808148950338, 0.009316997602581978, -0.02476515807211399, 0.024825647473335266, 0.025821680203080177, -0.04158204048871994, -0.057600297033786774, -0.061915330588817596, -0.010931307449936867, -0.007648816332221031, 0.015617317520081997, -0.0031468751840293407, 0.01369689404964447, 0.027950642630457878, 0.006167940329760313, 0.03462100774049759, -0.021036488935351372, -0.02536240592598915, 0.03544094040989876, -0.05266151949763298, -0.0204438716173172, 0.052402522414922714, 0.02938937209546566, -0.039929214864969254, 0.07847601175308228, -0.04177021607756615, -0.04532143473625183, 0.037932395935058594, -0.05160723254084587, 0.026340888813138008, -0.009907512925565243, -0.0029435378964990377, 0.038039714097976685, 0.008888617157936096, -0.00393719831481576, 0.010320444591343403, -0.0803656280040741, 0.03557019308209419, 0.09825871884822845, 0.001825255691073835, 0.019015826284885406, -0.02029547095298767, -0.007831334136426449, 0.00923764519393444, -0.055890217423439026, -0.011052685789763927, -0.06367029994726181, -0.03745954856276512, 0.029913822188973427, 0.04612363502383232, -0.007853946648538113, -0.00324447313323617, 0.07724150270223618, 0.028319746255874634, 0.0031423778273165226, 0.01202498096972704, 0.006182975601404905, 0.011697527021169662, 0.020285258069634438, 0.01630582846701145, 0.02166399359703064, -0.004681768361479044, 0.026734204962849617, 0.02440009079873562, 0.02641880325973034, 0.023623820394277573, -0.04445097967982292, 0.05425130948424339, 0.016486695036292076, 0.011875541880726814, -0.0308722872287035, -0.005687070544809103, 0.0319993682205677, -0.050896838307380676, -0.011972017586231232, 0.06330528855323792, -0.01847238466143608, -0.019917793571949005, 0.0048564644530415535, -0.020296869799494743, 0.022798076272010803, 0.06674761325120926, -0.014172802679240704, -0.026841897517442703, 0.011638658121228218, -0.059318989515304565, 0.015579835511744022, 0.0056691705249249935, -0.02225632406771183, -0.05134451389312744, 0.03489404916763306, 0.029890568926930428, 0.019050082191824913, 0.004468296654522419, -0.056072767823934555, -0.031829286366701126, 0.01483271736651659, -0.012906225398182869, 0.02686990797519684, -0.004674837458878756, -0.04728895425796509, 0.009670323692262173, -0.05187802016735077, -0.005095386877655983, 0.0283969696611166, -0.012324709445238113, -0.049817945808172226, 0.014014075510203838, -0.010706158354878426, -0.036206550896167755, -0.026708589866757393, -0.03956940397620201, 0.031121399253606796, -0.0194992758333683, -0.029711894690990448, 0.05126586928963661, 0.002607006812468171, -0.01966313272714615, -0.012033607810735703, -0.020063389092683792, -0.01129661314189434, -0.042152076959609985, -0.020366504788398743, -0.0005534530500881374, 0.007833825424313545, 0.040463902056217194, 0.01885923743247986, -0.04950323328375816, -0.019846750423312187, -0.03562791272997856, -0.040084708482027054, 0.020990664139389992, 0.02178161032497883, -0.01163270603865385, 0.016314268112182617, 0.02039325051009655, 0.10969714820384979, 0.03042806126177311, -0.013812673278152943, -0.03188945725560188, -0.007679743692278862, -0.004477454349398613, -0.007725583855062723, 0.0037676780484616756, 0.032317884266376495, 0.03509070351719856, 0.011091917753219604, -0.02277681604027748, 0.03469695895910263, 0.06683947145938873, -0.001977403648197651, -0.0358247235417366, 0.01217127125710249, -0.02797938510775566, -0.006980789825320244, 0.027179589495062828, 0.004283888731151819, -0.012078244239091873, 0.014516448602080345, -0.023126430809497833, 0.002676089061424136, -0.029159128665924072, -0.005281115882098675, 0.016299286857247353, 0.0181127842515707, 0.030484095215797424, -0.028835445642471313, -0.0012643779627978802, -0.009829087182879448, -0.042404208332300186, -0.00344309420324862, 0.013066897168755531, 0.05710040405392647, -0.02583608217537403, -0.026228992268443108, 0.0336223728954792, 0.013756516389548779, -0.014388010837137699, -0.028223315253853798, -0.0021453348454087973, -0.03898206725716591, 0.015031025744974613, -0.005658695939928293, 0.015450659207999706, 0.023216912522912025, 0.04796706512570381, 0.013940061442553997, 0.011448981240391731, -0.007059653755277395, 0.007818846963346004, -0.04906697943806648, 0.016010968014597893, -0.006891644559800625, 0.060689833015203476, 0.007478504907339811, 0.05172017216682434, 0.0244793351739645, 0.009725071489810944, 0.01701216772198677, 0.03118649125099182, -0.03277495130896568, 0.06093356013298035, -0.00404842384159565, -0.006551539059728384, -0.002103811129927635, -0.021912675350904465, 0.0523785836994648, 0.016318488866090775, 0.0014987483154982328, 0.028555545955896378, 0.01586328260600567, -0.04115975648164749, 0.006176359951496124, 0.025749200955033302, -0.027599234133958817, -0.026974622160196304, 0.0016076703323051333, -0.0007462003850378096, -0.0015746551798656583, 0.031126564368605614, 0.023409998044371605, -0.017660299316048622, -0.002909161150455475, -0.023329665884375572, 0.05127616971731186, 0.01901324652135372, 0.043689124286174774, 0.03720429167151451, 0.016567759215831757, -0.0647994875907898, 0.012197610922157764, 0.026614714413881302, 0.048447463661432266, 0.030427614226937294, -0.030400123447179794, 0.005636394955217838, -0.07257632166147232, -0.005589580629020929, 0.03599861264228821, -0.02888469770550728, -0.012851045466959476, -0.023813575506210327, 0.0634148120880127, 0.025838881731033325, -0.02088225446641445, 0.052434321492910385, 0.08696532249450684, 0.005912316031754017, -0.018966101109981537, -0.0570308193564415, -0.013349211774766445, 0.003877742448821664, 0.0004086331755388528, 0.04702064022421837, 0.011153826490044594, -0.021467167884111404, 0.026054203510284424, 0.010693957097828388, -0.002315677236765623, -0.0454658605158329, -0.04581663757562637, 0.03332512453198433, 0.0752636194229126, -0.024870550259947777, 0.0002920277474913746, -0.022872110828757286, 0.06322187185287476, 0.01567334309220314, 0.014031453058123589, -0.002588824601843953, -0.08514825999736786, -0.003770737675949931, 0.022328820079565048, 0.023424573242664337, -0.030677054077386856, -0.014212090522050858, -0.050012730062007904, -0.0022940090857446194, 0.017926104366779327, -0.03080795332789421, 0.03098345547914505, -0.007681786082684994, 0.019140033051371574, 0.015533531084656715, 0.003829685039818287, -0.029463080689311028, 0.0101386783644557, -0.05161350965499878, 0.0304506067186594, -0.009750936180353165, 0.0016234474023804069, -0.04326222836971283, -0.027717670425772667, -0.03020433895289898, 0.08097611367702484, -0.052312303334474564, -0.01032528467476368, 0.016479982063174248, 0.014855141751468182, 0.020681390538811684, -0.04875624552369118, 0.024474075064063072, -0.026882808655500412, 0.02291322499513626, 0.04643933102488518, -0.020480629056692123, -0.0484016090631485, 0.022624026983976364, 0.027681520208716393, -0.03839360550045967, -0.021892350167036057, -0.03768191486597061, 0.017413325607776642, 0.006399653851985931, -0.02824559062719345, 0.042358290404081345, 0.026064831763505936, 0.01964026503264904, -0.004669513087719679, -0.0608014315366745, 0.020742148160934448, -0.02587272785604, -0.018896285444498062, -0.02983221784234047, 0.0016866263467818499, -0.01823689229786396, 0.019727984443306923, 0.05121886357665062, 0.07516400516033173, 0.006650883238762617, -0.052195556461811066, 0.011438963934779167, 0.025451699271798134, -0.022224191576242447, -0.023982737213373184, 0.005024605896323919, 0.018354039639234543, -0.005303047597408295, -0.00020210155344102532, 0.011581995524466038, -0.013792497105896473, 0.02345431037247181, 0.029654458165168762, -0.02336680330336094, 0.02835860848426819, 0.008296786807477474, -0.00020029611187055707, 0.028868502005934715, -0.05147084593772888, 0.03200008347630501, -0.0042001474648714066, 0.026977479457855225, 0.030613794922828674, -0.06515803933143616, -0.006949671544134617, 0.009634695947170258, -0.0050191450864076614, 0.015490734949707985, -0.039732612669467926, 0.019032729789614677, 0.003449400421231985, -0.024659309536218643, -0.05833893269300461, -0.036539237946271896, 0.018827268853783607, 0.0019627350848168135, -0.008899657055735588, -0.04240625724196434, 0.008838306181132793, -0.006303172092884779, 0.009345220401883125, 0.010040969587862492, 0.029981030151247978, 0.005302058532834053, -0.019931873306632042, -0.006676295306533575, -0.03291955217719078, 0.07188441604375839, 0.036929644644260406, -0.018555190414190292, 0.03285474330186844, 0.015898382291197777, -0.04738330468535423, 0.023185888305306435, 0.028848910704255104, -0.03137337788939476, 0.027859637513756752, -0.016757145524024963, -0.007401544135063887, 0.040019501000642776, 0.017027370631694794, -0.03176059201359749, -0.008764367550611496, -0.011270716786384583, 0.018016861751675606, -0.015383261255919933, 0.014580007642507553, -0.0300839152187109, -0.035708822309970856, -0.047978974878787994, -0.04278408735990524, -0.034811899065971375, -0.005948950070887804, 0.037494100630283356, -0.003479432314634323, 0.008059525862336159, 0.05794260650873184, 0.09082306921482086, 0.003809279529377818, 0.010636690072715282, -0.005498701706528664, -0.06296560168266296, 0.016551131382584572, 0.028615154325962067, 0.026534276083111763, 0.0015023049199953675, 0.03504931926727295, -0.03608972206711769, -0.008215327747166157, -0.015094064176082611, 0.005220623686909676, 0.03517574816942215, 0.03344929590821266, 0.0529136024415493, 0.020057642832398415, -0.005293558817356825, 0.007428058423101902, -0.04585845768451691, -0.006975287105888128, -0.009047786705195904, 0.010984569787979126, 0.054783470928668976, -0.01701749674975872, -0.011356080882251263, 0.039805807173252106, -0.003993085585534573, 0.009478493593633175, 0.03474058210849762, 0.026014337316155434, 0.0028771772049367428, 0.018435241654515266, -0.022761836647987366, -0.03075644001364708, 0.0755864754319191, 0.005847673863172531, 0.004309177398681641, 0.004946854896843433, -0.014257609844207764, 0.0661529079079628, 0.024681540206074715, 0.002143535763025284, -0.03791046887636185, -0.013431275263428688, -0.02226628176867962, 0.01625572144985199, 0.027880573645234108, -0.03346177563071251, 0.026293136179447174, 0.01685553789138794, 0.006914737168699503, -0.011317030526697636, 0.06004777550697327, -0.017549267038702965, -0.09275388717651367, -0.02509324997663498, -0.0490197129547596, -0.049378763884305954, 0.022300895303487778, 0.01555153913795948, -0.01887592487037182, -0.010210292413830757, -0.044371895492076874, 0.01993529498577118, 0.016132093966007233, 0.040829285979270935, -0.011306840926408768, 0.08273247629404068, -0.0023793058935552835, 0.004556389059871435, 0.016269056126475334, -0.013633948750793934, 0.12958386540412903, 0.08875846862792969, 0.024156490340828896, -0.07039440423250198, -0.016912192106246948, -0.018883978947997093, -0.01959552802145481, 0.0027772048488259315, -0.02795165777206421, -0.00469894427806139, -0.027136145159602165, 0.011575729586184025, 0.02744293212890625, 0.03237036243081093, 0.005886131897568703, 0.032181281596422195, -0.003893667832016945, -0.020674914121627808, 0.027395548298954964, 0.019231276586651802, 0.0038926813285797834, -0.03833645582199097, -0.027723217383027077, 0.014697377569973469, 0.029335059225559235, -0.008502291515469551, -0.019603455439209938, -0.0017651787493377924, -0.008410022594034672, 0.0019784981850534678, 0.021098025143146515, -0.022708838805556297, 0.021116778254508972, -0.006033981218934059, 0.044931262731552124, -0.008693831041455269, -0.0007599062519147992, -0.012295082211494446, -0.002742889104411006, 0.0607839971780777, -0.002709976164624095, 0.0006843575974926353, -0.0010678251273930073, 0.01623261347413063, -0.045020412653684616, -0.023339595645666122, -0.036392275243997574, 0.015793029218912125, -0.0019788031931966543, -0.011129369027912617, -0.006837216671556234, -0.00534549867734313, -0.02719653956592083, -0.052831217646598816, 0.025727104395627975, 0.02752082049846649, 0.03192462399601936, -0.032020922750234604, -0.08393512666225433, -0.043018605560064316, 0.028222503140568733, -0.049536317586898804, 0.036623720079660416, 0.02081247605383396, -0.019619153812527657, -0.010370966047048569, -0.032053153961896896, 0.051739323884248734, -0.016666153445839882, -0.01026797853410244, 0.02201288938522339, -0.008243909105658531, -0.06013292446732521, 0.008221946656703949, -0.006312352605164051, -0.007138298358768225, 0.007582138758152723, 0.00041994298226200044, -0.017690392211079597, -0.020817765966057777, -0.03535912185907364, 0.030121132731437683, -0.06573759764432907, -0.024609453976154327, -0.024164002388715744, 0.029836047440767288, 0.0003284735430497676, 0.0287088043987751, 0.025133725255727768, 0.0009777944069355726, -0.02270943485200405, 0.004510938189923763, 0.009777150116860867, -0.022432373836636543, -0.034833576530218124, 0.024513276293873787, -0.06608877331018448, -0.03540940582752228, 0.012410498224198818, 0.06661374866962433, 0.026257941499352455, -0.00021938118152320385, -0.025987744331359863, 0.02318490482866764, -0.024082813411951065, 0.004650390241295099, -0.018474524840712547, -0.015277204103767872, 0.009895311668515205, 0.0025866273790597916, -0.031016262248158455, -0.06047685816884041, -0.00876576453447342, -0.034437116235494614, -0.016367202624678612, 0.01280056219547987, 0.013263765722513199, -0.023529283702373505, -0.024544714018702507, -0.0033000765834003687, 0.006399672944098711, -0.022549394518136978, -0.04415000230073929, -0.014039859175682068, 0.00429110461845994, -0.011039936915040016, -0.06497570872306824, 0.020204350352287292, 0.022223275154829025, -0.013453889638185501, -0.029881825670599937, 0.021644292399287224, 0.011807053349912167, -0.005907456856220961, 0.0065605309791862965, 0.00322496285662055, -0.0066638728603720665, 0.06014558672904968, -0.013058553449809551, 0.0032584499567747116, 0.04563598334789276, -0.059467244893312454, -0.03969753906130791, 0.047991782426834106, -0.012726033106446266, 0.05524072051048279, -0.009852983057498932, -0.02249535731971264, -0.043597832322120667, 0.07676482200622559, -0.03549874201416969, 0.010939081199467182, -0.013851996511220932, -0.0009119163150899112, -0.0015982488403096795, 0.02747458592057228, -0.028769053518772125, -0.001384412287734449, 0.011841284111142159, -0.016746647655963898, 0.0032564664725214243, -0.004246874712407589, -0.013674593530595303, 0.021915357559919357, -0.021053913980722427, -0.03450283035635948, 0.02545425295829773, -0.0009646019898355007, 0.017221879214048386, 0.07455389201641083, -0.03567146137356758, 0.017083199694752693, -0.021344859153032303, 0.010018517263233662, -0.06571975350379944, -0.045174382627010345, 0.015950791537761688, -0.010604135692119598, 0.05504363402724266, -0.05263075977563858, 0.006572122685611248, 0.0037179661449044943, -0.01634887233376503, 0.013981378637254238, -0.001466357265599072, -0.04090440645813942, -0.0025273605715483427, 0.009299064986407757, -0.03372196480631828, 0.012521566823124886, 0.054877277463674545, -0.006265193689614534, 0.04514063522219658, -0.0054848650470376015, -0.05054245516657829, -0.01672731526196003, -0.024923885241150856, 0.010049186646938324, -0.008909877389669418, -0.03296630457043648, 0.031774912029504776, -0.023433322086930275, -0.010358774103224277, 0.05689496919512749, -0.0067212339490652084, -0.01332124788314104, 0.07739421725273132, 0.030226055532693863, 0.038287822157144547, 0.07412838935852051, 0.03717123717069626, -0.016201401129364967, -0.02860294096171856, 0.023158526048064232, 0.006533394102007151, -0.0052836923860013485, -0.006982611492276192, 0.004100628197193146, 0.008627952076494694, -0.02867284044623375, -0.008740573190152645, 0.011507443152368069, -0.045510679483413696, -0.022633178159594536, -0.014309372752904892, 0.002265774877741933, -0.021151090040802956, -0.04553738981485367, 0.024053147062659264, -0.03214675560593605, -0.0010446577798575163, 0.042684268206357956, 0.01904091238975525, -0.019109904766082764, 0.011001094244420528, -0.013418921269476414, -0.036170218139886856, 0.002349450718611479, -0.019257189705967903, -0.04964917525649071, -0.024051513522863388, -0.00244196061976254, -0.027992816641926765, -0.009656955488026142, -0.009625676088035107, -0.02974538318812847, -0.04212084040045738, 0.02989078313112259, -0.009209335781633854, 0.021752597764134407, 0.044680263847112656, -0.022901063784956932, 0.00019922976207453758, -0.10419856011867523, 0.08013681322336197, 0.014481444843113422, -0.034756794571876526, -0.01597258634865284, 0.0036976635456085205, -0.030756168067455292, -0.011789204552769661, 0.030460132285952568, 0.008135521784424782, -0.017896875739097595, -0.011641700752079487, 0.03712143376469612, -0.013926265761256218, -0.048954542726278305, 0.009956767782568932, 0.027369292452931404, -0.03101002611219883, -0.02777888998389244, 0.010104436427354813, -0.005968437995761633, 0.018802762031555176, 0.004596879240125418, -0.016755344346165657, -0.0013321347068995237, -0.009176128543913364, -0.02951372228562832, 0.04526874050498009, 0.03782258555293083, 0.022948751226067543, 0.048658356070518494, -0.023428646847605705, 0.009376571513712406, 0.0366920530796051, 0.02546732686460018, -0.06012337654829025, 0.011296911165118217, -0.020117787644267082, -0.003100867848843336, -0.01534783374518156, 0.04269219934940338, 0.0469253733754158, -0.009938803501427174, -0.0010347133502364159, -0.013241587206721306, 0.0005398330395109951, 0.024929944425821304, 0.03831838443875313, 0.023267054930329323, 0.07274416834115982, -0.01191133912652731, -0.016103463247418404, -0.022583650425076485, 0.012686826288700104, 0.002581242471933365, 0.01749236322939396, -0.017826465889811516, 0.010743828490376472, 0.03729093074798584, -0.0043467567302286625, -0.03135143220424652, 0.013096931390464306, -0.011431769467890263, 0.06533903628587723, -0.029126910492777824, -0.007786629255861044, 0.007372639607638121, -0.010877965949475765, 0.007668061647564173, 0.01698933355510235, -0.017631951719522476, 0.046615879982709885, -0.05429281294345856, -0.0017118429532274604, -0.0371570810675621, -0.05719301849603653, 0.00791989453136921, 0.016646606847643852, -0.007001666352152824, 0.03925246745347977, 0.01918722689151764, 0.050049878656864166, 0.05014979839324951, -0.012352545745670795, 0.03930218890309334, -0.03457868844270706, -0.0009338208474218845, -0.004405392333865166, 0.014029410667717457, -0.0013945524115115404, 0.008039584383368492, -0.0189189612865448, -0.007048923522233963, -0.025243328884243965, 0.024998575448989868, 0.030981920659542084, -0.04892527684569359, 0.002265870338305831, 0.008775017224252224, 0.036121465265750885, -0.031551435589790344, -0.009917170740664005, -0.0449242889881134, 0.01631910353899002, 0.012350526638329029, -0.01304030790925026 ]
<p><em>I am not a statistician, so please excuse my lack of statistics knowledge/terminology.</em> </p> <p>I have bunch of network nodes that I want to run cluster analysis on and identify clusters. So as far as I understand, I can follow the following steps to run a hierarchical agglomerative analysis (HAC):</p> <ol> <li>Identify variables</li> <li>Define a distance function</li> <li>Run the algorithm to join closer clusters and create one big cluster</li> <li>Cut the dendrogram tree at the height that makes meaningful clusters based on context</li> </ol> <p>My question is related to the second step even though it is not yet clear for me how I am going to do the last step.</p> <p>The data I want to analyse is bunch of computer network nodes which are down (not responding). I have the following information for each network node:</p> <ul> <li>location (longitude, latitude)</li> <li>time node went down</li> <li>network provider</li> </ul> <p>These are the most relevant information I believe I have to take into consideration for my clustering. Basically I want to cluster the nodes that went down probably because of the same reason in a region. </p> <p>For example if bunch of nodes went down at about the same time and physically they are close to each other and they have the same provider, so probably they fall into the same cluster.</p> <p>Now the question is how do I derive my distance function and include all these variables in it such that it would make sense? In other words <strong>what is the mechanism to derive a distance function based on multiple variables?</strong></p> <p>Also as you notice the variables are of different types. So, in the distance function should I take care of this by considering <strong>Gower's coefficient of similarity</strong>? How?</p> <p>Any examples or suggestion regarding whether I am in the right direction or not can be very helpful too.</p>
37,373
[ -0.05174002796411514, -0.020522387698292732, 0.0039607989601790905, -0.005577663891017437, 0.05211271345615387, -0.0038834549486637115, 0.006820733193308115, -0.008451604284346104, 0.04317733645439148, -0.05341758206486702, 0.005672186613082886, 0.04666171595454216, 0.05772247537970543, 0.006853179540485144, 0.026259521022439003, 0.0030201878398656845, -0.027593472972512245, 0.02208617329597473, -0.0016076936153694987, -0.046568144112825394, 0.019438758492469788, -0.003158638719469309, 0.0064245546236634254, -0.0356413871049881, -0.02195354923605919, 0.013127492740750313, -0.001556256553158164, -0.034482307732105255, -0.015499530360102654, 0.050394680351018906, -0.0009705150732770562, -0.030689118430018425, 0.0012008959893137217, 0.017253687605261803, 0.01207580603659153, -0.010226709768176079, -0.03898289427161217, -0.00016045427764765918, -0.02510344609618187, 0.041160933673381805, -0.024919020012021065, -0.026305360719561577, -0.03204165771603584, 0.04269743338227272, -0.02781047113239765, 0.0006673110765404999, 0.017503293231129646, -0.04351179674267769, 0.01817282661795616, -0.07113269716501236, 0.0459166057407856, -0.027694664895534515, 0.03576057031750679, 0.014459658414125443, -0.031154122203588486, -0.01680580899119377, 0.07168035954236984, 0.05805923417210579, -0.013482313603162766, -0.03133360669016838, -0.019412942230701447, -0.005700207315385342, -0.001868557301349938, -0.009338795207440853, -0.028797607868909836, 0.036261845380067825, -0.03364405781030655, -0.0032937589567154646, 0.04453323036432266, 0.002587386406958103, -0.014825770631432533, -0.026131389662623405, 0.02688181772828102, -0.026922110468149185, 0.024642430245876312, -0.009789081290364265, 0.0023957742378115654, -0.023339200764894485, 0.04707028344273567, 0.01836022362112999, 0.014298561029136181, 0.006146479398012161, -0.0068297297693789005, 0.007901092991232872, 0.04366578906774521, 0.016511688008904457, 0.07591462880373001, -0.07123398035764694, 0.009033376350998878, 0.013729277066886425, -0.012231322936713696, 0.03102385811507702, 0.002441029530018568, 0.04024437069892883, -0.025703227147459984, 0.00577639602124691, -0.025034615769982338, 0.01847701519727707, 0.005750620737671852, 0.03134800121188164, -0.02504369243979454, -0.05849778652191162, 0.007705098483711481, 0.009183038026094437, -0.0036615203134715557, 0.03447042033076286, -0.04282709211111069, -0.012167233973741531, -0.03606951981782913, -0.016214853152632713, -0.04800717905163765, 0.022168828174471855, 0.012240038253366947, -0.018350906670093536, 0.018706470727920532, -0.02578757517039776, -0.01614280603826046, 0.019024383276700974, 0.04430970922112465, 0.05580335855484009, 0.05963996797800064, 0.0024089606013149023, 0.0698261708021164, -0.04804503172636032, -0.06424260139465332, -0.00007059142080834135, 0.01458319928497076, -0.020645704120397568, -0.03277909383177757, 0.026956528425216675, -0.007211263291537762, 0.02136528305709362, 0.038350820541381836, -0.02655113860964775, 0.05866400897502899, 0.04403088614344597, -0.10532242804765701, -0.03499821946024895, 0.013864542357623577, -0.004486266523599625, 0.05269058421254158, -0.03446274623274803, -0.0331609770655632, -0.0099910544231534, 0.04758019000291824, 0.0328526645898819, 0.008278166875243187, -0.016457680612802505, 0.01187992189079523, 0.014660025015473366, -0.012130998075008392, -0.031732287257909775, -0.008881346322596073, -0.01452876627445221, -0.027053525671362877, -0.08270137012004852, 0.009226253256201744, 0.025839217007160187, 0.001161474036052823, 0.0013344385661184788, 0.03192226216197014, -0.009817535057663918, -0.043982163071632385, 0.008456960320472717, -0.01783248595893383, 0.009365617297589779, 0.08235307782888412, 0.028290899470448494, -0.011680128052830696, 0.028543705120682716, -0.01442144624888897, 0.021623820066452026, -0.002624673303216696, 0.016025131568312645, 0.03419291973114014, 0.019061880186200142, -0.013112706132233143, 0.03044898435473442, 0.007053087931126356, 0.026009371504187584, 0.0006919438601471484, -0.03003665618598461, 0.011797457933425903, 0.02170124463737011, -0.0004994143964722753, 0.01746835745871067, -0.014735044911503792, -0.035390205681324005, 0.031089095398783684, -0.00585881806910038, -0.02848009578883648, -0.041290752589702606, 0.00760215800255537, -0.04285430908203125, 0.02459493651986122, 0.018518319353461266, -0.006634396966546774, 0.0080338129773736, 0.011866643093526363, -0.013888505287468433, -0.03090125136077404, -0.022642379626631737, 0.07473940402269363, 0.007464882917702198, -0.01944163255393505, 0.04402275010943413, 0.012341548688709736, 0.02573573589324951, 0.048644211143255234, -0.027351096272468567, -0.027020011097192764, -0.014539828523993492, -0.032829660922288895, -0.028482742607593536, -0.03081904537975788, 0.011695437133312225, 0.036346837878227234, 0.016425512731075287, 0.007365412078797817, 0.031913336366415024, -0.07189320027828217, 0.08369411528110504, 0.09068188071250916, 0.027703434228897095, 0.028214890509843826, 0.015380490571260452, -0.002683543600142002, 0.01235662866383791, -0.0014742001658305526, 0.014442279934883118, -0.06222156807780266, -0.019375741481781006, 0.0015755497151985765, -0.008934629149734974, -0.031863387674093246, -0.015661198645830154, 0.03961731120944023, 0.02088100090622902, 0.005751145537942648, 0.03543904051184654, 0.018024064600467682, -0.02460530214011669, 0.027927996590733528, 0.027221277356147766, 0.00846558716148138, -0.0067174118012189865, -0.0055676912888884544, 0.0315135233104229, 0.0138376634567976, -0.05465022474527359, 0.003469763556495309, 0.0464986190199852, -0.00028368178755044937, 0.044131599366664886, -0.02003999426960945, -0.0017746217781677842, 0.053399305790662766, 0.0014043616829439998, -0.00177848304156214, 0.016962995752692223, 0.0034324161242693663, 0.0053406162187457085, -0.0127128129824996, -0.04939049482345581, 0.05450960248708725, 0.04497374966740608, -0.037491124123334885, 0.031778112053871155, 0.00782947801053524, -0.03926621004939079, 0.023621397092938423, -0.011006949469447136, -0.025866970419883728, -0.03590640798211098, 0.04521588236093521, 0.04740914702415466, 0.012266457080841064, 0.02445867285132408, 0.006384695414453745, -0.01155903935432434, -0.021086731925606728, -0.026348328217864037, -0.0016786650521680713, 0.04975225031375885, -0.021939659491181374, 0.011335878632962704, -0.020223187282681465, 0.01652257703244686, 0.016486963257193565, -0.012274439446628094, -0.03284235671162605, 0.014193499460816383, 0.004444783553481102, -0.05569152534008026, -0.015859078615903854, -0.011190296150743961, 0.031459346413612366, -0.025131121277809143, -0.008322294801473618, 0.013887695968151093, 0.007671174593269825, 0.002229658653959632, 0.011301602236926556, -0.042861077934503555, -0.023833274841308594, -0.010437668301165104, -0.016381077468395233, -0.009278110228478909, 0.004526711069047451, -0.0005679355817846954, 0.023632695898413658, -0.035157740116119385, 0.0017862905515357852, -0.04752364754676819, -0.08495787531137466, 0.029109753668308258, 0.001268390566110611, 0.04835398122668266, -0.0052390205673873425, -0.02463339827954769, 0.05497463792562485, 0.010000303387641907, -0.06283318251371384, -0.01309713814407587, -0.0011728580575436354, -0.059116560965776443, 0.029181774705648422, 0.02520398236811161, 0.030668795108795166, 0.001434092759154737, -0.009959830902516842, 0.02409421280026436, 0.020393207669258118, 0.09325116127729416, -0.014506642706692219, 0.002758878283202648, 0.04660118743777275, 0.01940312050282955, -0.03560760244727135, 0.03360704705119133, 0.019617734476923943, -0.029133563861250877, 0.037359874695539474, -0.03272436931729317, -0.011226550675928593, 0.024179892614483833, -0.04153819382190704, -0.025410016998648643, -0.0011327360989525914, -0.04066680371761322, -0.05435940623283386, -0.008043334819376469, 0.02043507806956768, -0.03329205885529518, 0.025012264028191566, 0.043275538831949234, 0.06746456027030945, -0.027459248900413513, -0.01662658154964447, 0.05974430963397026, 0.0489092692732811, -0.061684031039476395, -0.047502316534519196, -0.019583679735660553, -0.02790961228311062, -0.012092214077711105, -0.02314106747508049, 0.030257368460297585, -0.0035051144659519196, 0.019107861444354057, 0.04758428409695625, -0.006392079405486584, -0.04196253418922424, 0.038255054503679276, -0.09339960664510727, -0.00821854081004858, -0.03945425525307655, 0.059939127415418625, -0.02216293290257454, 0.0358792282640934, 0.03826897591352463, 0.00019590085139498115, 0.02239605225622654, 0.007896002382040024, -0.06140170246362686, -0.012499120086431503, -0.014162707142531872, 0.016084278002381325, -0.011631601490080357, -0.03306902199983597, 0.02825285494327545, -0.006558720488101244, 0.00696368794888258, 0.01639714650809765, 0.03524467721581459, -0.055435121059417725, -0.013135901652276516, -0.03807506710290909, 0.007591940462589264, -0.0033049334306269884, 0.003237461671233177, 0.04741330072283745, 0.020453650504350662, 0.010059609077870846, 0.051031019538640976, 0.016421280801296234, -0.010990005917847157, -0.013400642201304436, -0.02522335760295391, 0.034385085105895996, 0.002379131503403187, 0.016582347452640533, 0.04026379436254501, -0.020304955542087555, 0.0075767445378005505, -0.003531204303726554, 0.030082473531365395, 0.04456757754087448, -0.012825573794543743, -0.0257127583026886, 0.0002681017213035375, -0.04614638164639473, 0.013092842884361744, 0.043353404849767685, -0.009280756115913391, -0.010809868574142456, 0.022628240287303925, 0.04655972868204117, -0.03671615943312645, 0.033811263740062714, 0.040360648185014725, 0.027089813724160194, -0.009042958728969097, -0.011846635490655899, -0.03276805207133293, 0.0032542378176003695, -0.037412889301776886, 0.031565889716148376, 0.012237904593348503, -0.009957664646208286, 0.0036462151911109686, 0.055651355534791946, 0.003184488508850336, -0.06708415597677231, 0.01668509840965271, 0.03877762705087662, 0.03826604038476944, -0.014799906872212887, -0.04958125203847885, -0.002946868073195219, 0.04811115935444832, 0.006463310681283474, 0.011581435799598694, -0.025603828951716423, -0.11367573589086533, -0.02525700069963932, 0.011906372383236885, 0.011404165998101234, 0.006674416828900576, 0.03465939685702324, -0.042336322367191315, -0.0052116625010967255, 0.02451183833181858, -0.02049192041158676, 0.035472892224788666, -0.00701020797714591, 0.004115947522222996, -0.008364775218069553, -0.04800337925553322, 0.0018147338414564729, 0.030829355120658875, -0.020536081865429878, 0.052517980337142944, -0.05621043220162392, -0.0015064809704199433, -0.0335422046482563, 0.03135102987289429, -0.01257836539298296, 0.025709189474582672, 0.006817499175667763, -0.042459651827812195, -0.03022364340722561, 0.007207346148788929, -0.004556022118777037, -0.03426934778690338, 0.00513268169015646, 0.04084091633558273, 0.0070702629163861275, 0.07780947536230087, -0.015123275108635426, 0.010497719049453735, 0.01664116233587265, 0.016639187932014465, -0.04722078889608383, 0.013730097562074661, -0.0013345780316740274, 0.061936747282743454, 0.030917402356863022, -0.034126751124858856, 0.04212644323706627, -0.017832741141319275, -0.03293647989630699, 0.025284195318818092, -0.009720688685774803, -0.008985568769276142, -0.029048653319478035, 0.004663113038986921, -0.011536204256117344, -0.0349511057138443, 0.0031719598919153214, 0.030289340764284134, -0.009330912493169308, 0.0294063501060009, -0.026849279180169106, -0.01652642898261547, 0.003728329436853528, 0.025950292125344276, -0.009260794147849083, 0.028029588982462883, -0.024210231378674507, 0.033738743513822556, -0.008400732651352882, -0.022872956469655037, 0.007686657831072807, -0.022596461698412895, 0.04163966700434685, -0.017121216282248497, -0.029387446120381355, -0.019780397415161133, -0.03788679093122482, -0.014042658731341362, 0.04837728291749954, -0.014412639662623405, 0.015850266441702843, -0.011153284460306168, -0.0025942784268409014, 0.022001219913363457, -0.03633742779493332, -0.008070938289165497, 0.0233556367456913, -0.02020947076380253, 0.0011487255105748773, -0.02241436205804348, -0.006555773317813873, -0.0029987175948917866, -0.013298501260578632, -0.0738961324095726, -0.011109533719718456, 0.01203489676117897, 0.025429604575037956, -0.04145008698105812, -0.07214862108230591, 0.0023876926861703396, -0.010121578350663185, -0.04716510325670242, 0.008310950361192226, 0.04654408618807793, 0.016723578795790672, 0.0008914762875065207, -0.002422667806968093, -0.002854482503607869, 0.06714709848165512, 0.0070630768314003944, 0.01540337037295103, -0.013237127102911472, -0.009662564843893051, 0.02815445140004158, 0.0053258370608091354, 0.02190977893769741, -0.009760651737451553, -0.017371490597724915, -0.014547836035490036, 0.02061120793223381, 0.013317402452230453, -0.023315874859690666, -0.021157199516892433, -0.030956707894802094, -0.01007900107651949, 0.0008152570808306336, -0.021442243829369545, 0.02296620048582554, -0.02707514539361, 0.017651597037911415, -0.01980895735323429, 0.012938021682202816, -0.01714359223842621, -0.004213255830109119, 0.018220961093902588, -0.026406386867165565, -0.007334060966968536, 0.05466874688863754, 0.05193034186959267, -0.020172061398625374, -0.012664252892136574, 0.04327160120010376, -0.017967643216252327, 0.05995570495724678, -0.021968772634863853, -0.04995782673358917, 0.004453146364539862, 0.019018618389964104, 0.005820825230330229, -0.03219824656844139, -0.020598379895091057, 0.01633373275399208, 0.059565406292676926, 0.0017540727276355028, 0.03979703411459923, 0.05785013362765312, -0.016118109226226807, -0.005423456896096468, -0.004373817704617977, -0.019002236425876617, -0.005145179573446512, 0.015582557767629623, 0.049153730273246765, 0.002635495737195015, -0.00581800751388073, 0.0493263304233551, 0.02650250680744648, -0.050286028534173965, 0.054723139852285385, 0.00015935020928736776, 0.02828231453895569, 0.010331490077078342, -0.04259616136550903, -0.01266107615083456, -0.0068363007158041, -0.015279367566108704, 0.008698397316038609, -0.026921581476926804, -0.03502148389816284, 0.059166308492422104, 0.043038856238126755, 0.01636841706931591, -0.04554195702075958, -0.002216150052845478, -0.038104522973299026, 0.012763702310621738, 0.02515173889696598, 0.0006278777145780623, 0.009221041575074196, 0.04361411929130554, 0.03521222993731499, 0.023053620010614395, 0.015688540413975716, -0.03254631161689758, -0.059561312198638916, -0.05448565632104874, -0.0012435647659003735, -0.04624231159687042, 0.016983045265078545, 0.003973808605223894, -0.04700687900185585, 0.05553065612912178, 0.00033643629285506904, 0.008008026517927647, 0.01981702633202076, 0.02043415606021881, 0.022099459543824196, 0.08758396655321121, 0.019127003848552704, 0.01924947276711464, 0.012418688274919987, -0.014685015194118023, 0.12476258724927902, 0.06743177771568298, -0.005640476010739803, -0.04872124269604683, 0.006154100876301527, 0.04484403878450394, 0.015704795718193054, -0.039555031806230545, 0.008257276378571987, 0.006620669271796942, 0.0003546516236383468, 0.06285466998815536, 0.006884171161800623, 0.0046593244187533855, -0.006312280893325806, 0.07297024875879288, -0.012649613432586193, -0.061345674097537994, -0.02047545462846756, 0.018936902284622192, -0.024232633411884308, -0.006170141045004129, -0.04361986741423607, 0.04486837238073349, 0.012030617333948612, 0.0075425803661346436, 0.008414287120103836, 0.004136187955737114, 0.03537449613213539, 0.012727565132081509, -0.008409883826971054, 0.04622776806354523, 0.023534061387181282, -0.012246447615325451, -0.012218710966408253, -0.00037088143290020525, 0.012234833091497421, -0.048455577343702316, -0.01050170511007309, 0.002854760503396392, 0.01630750298500061, -0.015437901020050049, 0.009899371303617954, 0.006841070018708706, -0.0435488224029541, -0.03669597581028938, -0.03854476660490036, 0.027379659935832024, 0.023225611075758934, 0.02961764857172966, 0.002210047096014023, 0.003589927451685071, 0.004913453944027424, -0.017065776512026787, 0.01178442221134901, 0.021409472450613976, 0.0549585185945034, -0.022556385025382042, -0.03107178956270218, -0.05521384999155998, 0.019967425614595413, 0.0126750273630023, 0.001867958577349782, 0.0029680365696549416, -0.023898744955658913, 0.00209769862703979, -0.05679469555616379, 0.05989670753479004, -0.029665714129805565, -0.027154982089996338, -0.03059905581176281, -0.004265484865754843, -0.0025000812020152807, 0.01635732129216194, -0.018602533265948296, -0.0029238383285701275, -0.008519276976585388, 0.02886633761227131, -0.007948344573378563, -0.01737312041223049, -0.03974892571568489, 0.022004643455147743, -0.05715386942028999, -0.0343940369784832, -0.018068348988890648, -0.020136501640081406, 0.009604164399206638, 0.05264533311128616, 0.04889347776770592, 0.016200633719563484, -0.030386682599782944, 0.026107246056199074, 0.01197664812207222, -0.044298022985458374, -0.01407315582036972, -0.026132121682167053, -0.041832588613033295, -0.005152079276740551, 0.0123208649456501, 0.06836551427841187, 0.017830919474363327, -0.020536696538329124, -0.016201509162783623, 0.018985437229275703, -0.0035688490606844425, -0.02189563773572445, -0.012241160497069359, -0.052783574908971786, 0.01871996931731701, -0.008967158384621143, 0.011881059035658836, -0.02303273230791092, -0.02389189787209034, 0.025911623612046242, -0.016993999481201172, 0.01957320235669613, 0.020449353381991386, -0.03482723608613014, 0.0014511095359921455, -0.03364337608218193, 0.02486203983426094, -0.02698153257369995, 0.03878698870539665, -0.018347790464758873, -0.019709451124072075, -0.04239673539996147, -0.032369039952754974, 0.017587054520845413, 0.00021232450671959668, -0.011654431000351906, -0.008492165245115757, 0.034656088799238205, 0.004436639603227377, 0.023479053750634193, 0.0029101732652634382, 0.002713617170229554, -0.019884109497070312, 0.06197425350546837, 0.004202615469694138, -0.007940995506942272, 0.016664091497659683, -0.03787028789520264, -0.05165891721844673, 0.05731609836220741, 0.009148595854640007, 0.05863795429468155, 0.03080238401889801, -0.0076246014796197414, -0.00542497867718339, 0.047480203211307526, -0.00019645864085759968, 0.002935880795121193, 0.016071470454335213, -0.003395477309823036, 0.022442376241087914, 0.0021847409661859274, -0.008893955498933792, 0.02903093211352825, -0.03531995415687561, 0.028740108013153076, 0.03711822256445885, 0.02481750212609768, -0.0314042754471302, -0.013639428652822971, 0.019370637834072113, 0.03249777853488922, -0.017671599984169006, -0.014586534351110458, 0.07365593314170837, 0.052309468388557434, -0.001833889982663095, 0.006650504656136036, 0.007601726800203323, 0.032112035900354385, -0.07041233777999878, -0.004471211228519678, 0.02536356821656227, 0.01296481303870678, 0.0365627184510231, -0.05666251480579376, 0.0003257610369473696, 0.03702365234494209, -0.05212658271193504, 0.050828516483306885, -0.003233871888369322, -0.015796231105923653, 0.0017742178170010448, -0.017895227298140526, -0.028044067323207855, 0.0411231629550457, 0.03267247974872589, 0.05693332850933075, 0.032387930899858475, 0.025021499022841454, -0.01710258238017559, -0.034146297723054886, -0.028360452502965927, 0.014450374990701675, 0.020644040778279305, -0.04075268656015396, 0.015771346166729927, -0.03695489093661308, -0.025527779012918472, 0.02814662829041481, -0.07297689467668533, -0.04878762364387512, 0.0336463488638401, -0.02242700196802616, 0.013729835860431194, 0.012477291747927666, -0.0016300431452691555, -0.038632407784461975, -0.006287347991019487, -0.0157341156154871, 0.012186483480036259, 0.03022528626024723, 0.003725658170878887, -0.005321620963513851, 0.011140715330839157, -0.025140658020973206, -0.014571570791304111, 0.0024649552069604397, -0.029252061620354652, 0.008677204139530659, -0.0010604001581668854, -0.030447036027908325, -0.0004392793634906411, 0.014097596518695354, -0.02769620716571808, -0.014765317551791668, -0.00437103072181344, 0.0605989508330822, 0.015835905447602272, -0.012345640920102596, 0.0016988833667710423, -0.04987235739827156, -0.06201612204313278, 0.0007744773174636066, -0.02575392834842205, -0.05350751057267189, -0.027355188503861427, -0.013812515884637833, -0.022096499800682068, 0.0041554169729352, -0.04807372763752937, -0.0061080921441316605, -0.02339761145412922, 0.06490757316350937, -0.039339710026979446, 0.015622810460627079, 0.018783487379550934, -0.014283256605267525, 0.034819986671209335, -0.07391563802957535, 0.018531449139118195, 0.03613092377781868, 0.0018053860403597355, -0.022572753950953484, -0.005194098223000765, 0.0008128047338686883, -0.0011288209352642298, 0.029544809833168983, 0.010175908915698528, 0.01582156866788864, 0.01175782736390829, 0.03064924106001854, -0.01832648739218712, -0.023126589134335518, 0.05365416780114174, -0.0049666594713926315, -0.024600261822342873, 0.00909870583564043, -0.022778717800974846, 0.01399172656238079, 0.012551598250865936, -0.019441239535808563, -0.009813783690333366, 0.015125833451747894, -0.025623628869652748, -0.012779468670487404, 0.008200181648135185, -0.0747552290558815, -0.027514498680830002, 0.017913004383444786, -0.027448033913969994, -0.040598589926958084, 0.027331942692399025, 0.0051903207786381245, -0.029160667210817337, 0.03881055861711502, -0.01061786524951458, -0.028000608086586, 0.029295973479747772, -0.011354542337357998, 0.039349015802145004, -0.07983823120594025, -0.05823657661676407, -0.0015869666822254658, -0.02956429310142994, -0.004568225238472223, 0.06226187199354172, 0.03317398577928543, 0.04087664559483528, -0.003516651224344969, 0.015390479937195778, 0.030508892610669136, -0.01035367976874113, 0.030042072758078575, 0.035696905106306076, 0.01950433850288391, 0.019210675731301308, 0.011280639097094536, -0.013077188283205032, -0.0019445255165919662, 0.02904854714870453, -0.034640491008758545, 0.033624693751335144, -0.04622449353337288, 0.0073148091323673725, -0.01005692407488823, -0.001241895486600697, 0.019068509340286255, 0.03594503551721573, -0.006699234712868929, 0.060266487300395966, -0.012223979458212852, 0.014810442924499512, -0.027153028175234795, -0.012359751388430595, -0.0325748473405838, 0.05737624317407608, -0.03994867205619812, 0.036380622535943985, -0.038752369582653046, 0.029355846345424652, 0.008389840833842754, -0.020347850397229195, 0.036050695925951004, 0.019565271213650703, 0.03322640061378479, -0.033452991396188736, 0.013543027453124523, 0.0256038885563612, -0.019016345962882042, -0.0746360793709755, -0.03368552401661873, 0.015253397636115551, 0.053004682064056396, 0.05734787881374359, 0.030774889513850212, -0.013200045563280582, -0.0092397416010499, 0.04980003461241722, -0.07695052027702332, -0.020688172429800034, -0.09537707269191742, -0.010354496538639069, -0.03394356742501259, -0.000652152462862432 ]
<p>I have a techincal issue with Stata: I need to calculate the SSE of a regression model, but the automatic output just gives me RMSE; I need SSE of this constrained model because I have to test if this model is better than the completely-free model.</p> <p>SPSS gives me the SSE value in the regression output, but I don't know how to calculate a constrained linear regression with this model.</p>
40,405
[ -0.04129865765571594, -0.0018324718112125993, -0.04055088385939598, 0.012799630872905254, 0.01086051668971777, -0.013154332526028156, -0.008016075007617474, -0.023724593222141266, 0.02551794797182083, -0.020929789170622826, 0.029199181124567986, 0.03345204144716263, 0.0624375082552433, -0.005316066090017557, 0.0015733279287815094, 0.01587172970175743, -0.017236052080988884, 0.03696395456790924, 0.002527344971895218, 0.012535583227872849, -0.036852963268756866, 0.041307032108306885, -0.018951471894979477, -0.001905354904010892, 0.004405675921589136, 0.048738233745098114, 0.049333356320858, -0.02575490064918995, 0.005746501963585615, 0.07463205605745316, -0.011396899819374084, -0.027530096471309662, 0.0007585716084577143, 0.05929014831781387, 0.02794511988759041, -0.0032641789875924587, 0.017104826867580414, 0.004622600041329861, -0.014193400740623474, 0.016852684319019318, 0.012110231444239616, -0.015908246859908104, -0.01014800276607275, 0.016775159165263176, -0.012801745906472206, 0.019999222829937935, 0.005343036726117134, 0.001928166369907558, 0.05146301910281181, -0.019439999014139175, 0.08468595892190933, -0.0019941763021051884, 0.03846398741006851, 0.02857954613864422, -0.021032454445958138, 0.011166722513735294, 0.03245261684060097, 0.05158822238445282, -0.009192126803100109, -0.03562061861157417, -0.02405201457440853, -0.037140097469091415, 0.03834915906190872, -0.04750676825642586, -0.04066053405404091, 0.014706039801239967, 0.014537898823618889, -0.021042419597506523, 0.06946767866611481, -0.018794722855091095, 0.026590757071971893, 0.012798606418073177, 0.009955422952771187, -0.0031697512604296207, 0.002613167278468609, -0.0464782752096653, 0.0091999601572752, 0.01772618666291237, 0.020319964736700058, 0.027959825471043587, 0.006020877975970507, 0.006483455654233694, 0.009533613920211792, 0.04588647559285164, 0.017300667241215706, 0.010084645822644234, 0.06913375854492188, 0.0324733592569828, 0.020039454102516174, 0.009728268720209599, -0.025283146649599075, -0.017661763355135918, 0.04727547615766525, -0.029070818796753883, -0.02095228247344494, 0.008958072401583195, -0.01873783767223358, 0.045211248099803925, 0.018111109733581543, -0.03389512374997139, 0.0032707431819289923, -0.03212175518274307, 0.00615027267485857, 0.023901112377643585, -0.03574757277965546, 0.035084132105112076, -0.006108046509325504, 0.0050005605444312096, -0.0026539519894868135, -0.03750284016132355, -0.025965522974729538, 0.013977998867630959, 0.016381509602069855, -0.0130861084908247, 0.015661712735891342, -0.022591225802898407, -0.027001725509762764, -0.0074654375202953815, 0.013061254285275936, 0.04016626998782158, 0.04000137001276016, -0.04924627020955086, -0.004048795904964209, -0.02030242793262005, -0.03736346215009689, 0.03792404755949974, 0.006231158506125212, -0.04677320644259453, -0.057594142854213715, 0.03418881073594093, 0.018520785495638847, -0.07181044667959213, 0.02133495733141899, -0.011277217417955399, 0.012535074725747108, -0.036190152168273926, -0.05384647473692894, -0.07884375751018524, -0.003235204378142953, 0.007273971568793058, 0.0321580246090889, -0.037455372512340546, -0.01640995591878891, 0.009751864708960056, 0.0847279503941536, 0.012883271090686321, 0.059486087411642075, 0.051023468375205994, -0.005226115230470896, -0.012234000489115715, -0.021214168518781662, -0.03406462073326111, -0.043447766453027725, -0.029816363006830215, -0.002231819787994027, -0.05591309443116188, 0.0004686059255618602, 0.01228709053248167, -0.040106650441884995, 0.0012696731137111783, 0.04380906745791435, 0.03864775970578194, -0.04597132280468941, 0.02693127654492855, -0.01574140228331089, -0.059009797871112823, 0.04757805913686752, -0.01625867746770382, -0.019875532016158104, 0.01444269809871912, 0.012261055409908295, 0.020310673862695694, -0.030085569247603416, 0.06000928208231926, 0.02135218121111393, -0.027631787583231926, -0.01143038272857666, -0.028264883905649185, -0.003224465763196349, 0.029467515647411346, -0.07474149763584137, -0.026154888793826103, -0.008390827104449272, -0.0008787002880126238, 0.047912053763866425, 0.05639735236763954, -0.03938363865017891, -0.002397828735411167, 0.03270571306347847, -0.057799674570560455, -0.06264986842870712, -0.052884846925735474, -0.009108594618737698, -0.012062971480190754, -0.030255027115345, 0.02965424954891205, 0.006455516908317804, 0.046824563294649124, -0.006998981814831495, 0.001187209622003138, -0.016878310590982437, 0.004930405877530575, 0.0525706484913826, -0.006758077070116997, 0.01976979710161686, 0.024828428402543068, 0.05385681986808777, -0.015036961995065212, 0.02280362881720066, -0.02989933453500271, -0.04259468615055084, 0.021428726613521576, -0.015114360488951206, 0.00046884664334356785, 0.012419336475431919, -0.0012933831894770265, -0.014761949889361858, -0.007187696173787117, -0.0034910652320832014, 0.028390714898705482, -0.01849696971476078, 0.05064196139574051, 0.05010176822543144, 0.02117726393043995, -0.006872354540973902, 0.004990671295672655, 0.007066096644848585, 0.038463667035102844, -0.0389830656349659, -0.0060203480534255505, -0.009029059670865536, -0.02455083094537258, -0.00008778343180892989, 0.011256633326411247, -0.03459721803665161, -0.016716795042157173, 0.08254092186689377, -0.0031155829783529043, 0.03726416826248169, 0.036694932729005814, -0.03516450151801109, -0.0018176609883084893, 0.004451143089681864, -0.013918210752308369, 0.005440953653305769, 0.02147146873176098, -0.01392833050340414, 0.03457080200314522, 0.019930824637413025, 0.02992882765829563, 0.012594950385391712, 0.07170499116182327, 0.012468520551919937, -0.02252521552145481, -0.0006441556615754962, -0.002596233505755663, 0.04111093282699585, -0.02828148938715458, 0.012089700438082218, 0.06279852241277695, -0.011262794956564903, -0.02332129329442978, 0.002776523120701313, -0.006727234460413456, 0.042542822659015656, 0.03928959742188454, -0.021561376750469208, -0.01424833107739687, 0.027330510318279266, -0.004009990021586418, 0.023038385435938835, -0.018197080120444298, -0.044432174414396286, -0.05122325196862221, 0.0017993870424106717, 0.07322897762060165, 0.008945194073021412, 0.027086371555924416, -0.02480655536055565, 0.000054858064686413854, 0.010041648522019386, -0.03399176895618439, 0.023450085893273354, -0.01695776730775833, -0.04758743569254875, -0.029299195855855942, -0.02680802531540394, -0.05179385840892792, 0.050898708403110504, -0.0020837546326220036, -0.015339662320911884, 0.04273181036114693, -0.03089180402457714, -0.048491090536117554, -0.032528333365917206, -0.028038496151566505, 0.01809026300907135, -0.03144247084856033, 0.010224913246929646, 0.03876740112900734, -0.017573270946741104, -0.06742092221975327, -0.02131444402039051, -0.047802675515413284, -0.007017956115305424, -0.023712951689958572, 0.03045841120183468, 0.017316244542598724, -0.018418779596686363, 0.03766670450568199, 0.019593466073274612, -0.01330049429088831, 0.008694758638739586, -0.03967227041721344, -0.03656451031565666, 0.0027667793910950422, 0.019582608714699745, 0.025424109771847725, -0.005205482244491577, -0.03496960550546646, 0.09540749341249466, 0.02555703930556774, -0.030685363337397575, -0.06325016915798187, -0.02759438380599022, -0.006632110103964806, -0.06299088150262833, 0.008892068639397621, -0.007151021622121334, 0.008008910343050957, 0.04360751807689667, -0.00041170784970745444, 0.04419628158211708, 0.04742676392197609, 0.0019596111960709095, -0.00008907380106393248, 0.006383453030139208, -0.020094595849514008, -0.03741312399506569, 0.03514949232339859, 0.021343674510717392, -0.021634427830576897, 0.019862983375787735, -0.010889042168855667, 0.05167917534708977, -0.03566129133105278, -0.027209876105189323, -0.012300485745072365, -0.009222129359841347, 0.015869783237576485, -0.07378476858139038, 0.03451719507575035, 0.015224561095237732, 0.018705425783991814, 0.02956567332148552, 0.0045820120722055435, -0.01024770550429821, -0.012293750420212746, 0.001838351716287434, 0.025909679010510445, 0.031231874600052834, 0.001128401723690331, -0.013961639255285263, -0.040356364101171494, -0.012125319801270962, 0.0019119152566418052, 0.0007352977409027517, -0.025562115013599396, 0.035171955823898315, 0.01392658706754446, 0.03450261056423187, -0.009309441782534122, -0.04572628065943718, -0.014142078347504139, -0.06390146166086197, 0.012132197618484497, -0.025828730314970016, 0.07473063468933105, 0.01281075831502676, 0.006281683687120676, -0.008159074932336807, 0.020555736497044563, 0.006726590916514397, 0.002503280993551016, -0.06140813231468201, 0.06532369554042816, -0.003277846844866872, -0.02150750532746315, 0.031672216951847076, -0.008685358799993992, 0.0014681743923574686, -0.06468203663825989, -0.021287180483341217, -0.0006525260396301746, 0.016936874017119408, -0.026174139231443405, -0.011740928515791893, 0.007106410805135965, 0.01595032773911953, 0.005026475992053747, -0.00146882189437747, -0.03192964568734169, -0.03296792134642601, 0.013455666601657867, 0.04058557376265526, -0.012898015789687634, -0.005382969509810209, -0.03340736776590347, -0.0028506710659712553, -0.0058797504752874374, 0.055552978068590164, 0.03468566760420799, 0.017245693132281303, -0.04503254219889641, 0.006314165890216827, 0.012990135699510574, 0.04531422629952431, 0.043811287730932236, -0.0020851038862019777, -0.04877350851893425, -0.05155688151717186, -0.005355288740247488, 0.00844814907759428, -0.016673024743795395, 0.015957271680235863, 0.01379318442195654, 0.06488420814275742, 0.012915102764964104, -0.05328620970249176, 0.012251125648617744, 0.07668863981962204, 0.011904017999768257, -0.007987035438418388, -0.00417355028912425, -0.010490331798791885, -0.025215571746230125, 0.02377680502831936, 0.02279769629240036, -0.00356846209615469, 0.008927440270781517, -0.014934737235307693, 0.02613948844373226, -0.05624175816774368, -0.02028459869325161, 0.0016688607865944505, 0.04701194167137146, 0.04061412438750267, 0.026080673560500145, -0.03147246316075325, 0.041019048541784286, 0.038678888231515884, 0.0008554767118766904, 0.022578004747629166, 0.02289450541138649, -0.09204447269439697, -0.03606995940208435, 0.04236547648906708, 0.013401258736848831, -0.013133974745869637, -0.031343668699264526, -0.014477916993200779, -0.011601576581597328, 0.03535350039601326, -0.031087275594472885, -0.00008044717833399773, 0.01015061978250742, 0.04787920415401459, 0.013079917058348656, 0.0038959623780101538, -0.05344891920685768, 0.0208410806953907, 0.0049595823511481285, 0.02334507182240486, -0.009594065137207508, -0.023064889013767242, -0.04377792775630951, 0.0015533118275925517, -0.010356753133237362, 0.03824830800294876, -0.013774166814982891, 0.0019054118311032653, 0.02303471602499485, 0.06220303475856781, -0.05243125185370445, -0.0517803356051445, -0.027809148654341698, 0.0014993192162364721, -0.010725130327045918, 0.023564118891954422, -0.00936026219278574, -0.040613409131765366, 0.015370228327810764, 0.003379578236490488, -0.0033474937081336975, -0.006724474020302296, -0.014692394994199276, 0.033996447920799255, 0.022043973207473755, -0.0034099232871085405, 0.050104524940252304, 0.0404169037938118, -0.0014808267587795854, 0.012132258154451847, -0.03657566010951996, 0.0022294861264526844, -0.004465134348720312, -0.024648359045386314, -0.014232144691050053, -0.024186186492443085, -0.0022431949619203806, 0.0034138234332203865, 0.010223391465842724, 0.029478196054697037, -0.03032493032515049, -0.006513615604490042, -0.012934616766870022, 0.03481579199433327, -0.012845023535192013, 0.003689123084768653, 0.0014304612996056676, 0.04711868613958359, -0.016439687460660934, -0.042037103325128555, 0.04389137029647827, 0.023737750947475433, -0.016266435384750366, -0.010661846026778221, -0.053580138832330704, 0.0455348826944828, 0.028794869780540466, -0.04510672017931938, -0.002127354498952627, -0.06163344904780388, 0.0399702824652195, -0.027052028104662895, 0.002642342122271657, -0.03160739690065384, -0.03378986939787865, 0.004254668951034546, 0.019164128229022026, 0.015078195370733738, -0.005246889777481556, -0.025749966502189636, 0.025054750964045525, -0.006203710567206144, -0.0204702690243721, -0.06436225771903992, -0.021271875128149986, 0.01392595935612917, -0.014454702846705914, -0.048537518829107285, -0.03361276909708977, 0.009210150688886642, -0.00435152743011713, -0.03542353957891464, -0.007834918797016144, 0.04584493115544319, -0.033703967928886414, 0.01618589647114277, 0.002160661621019244, 0.005876277107745409, 0.026454899460077286, -0.013671357184648514, -0.0247853584587574, 0.0035225092433393, -0.018550287932157516, -0.019439926370978355, 0.001608007587492466, 0.03201163932681084, -0.05115940794348717, 0.0009884018218144774, -0.038896314799785614, -0.0170605406165123, 0.050464872270822525, -0.002987171523272991, 0.020831577479839325, -0.003441121894866228, 0.007369793951511383, 0.04093250259757042, -0.0005328094121068716, 0.022315209731459618, -0.011716107837855816, 0.036407552659511566, -0.020429804921150208, -0.0029530145693570375, -0.030410047620534897, 0.0019684124272316694, 0.04571537673473358, -0.006152016576379538, 0.0029801030177623034, -0.018740873783826828, 0.09676167368888855, 0.032557662576436996, 0.030685484409332275, -0.004406333435326815, 0.02139543928205967, 0.04886512830853462, 0.04941854998469353, 0.0013404825003817677, -0.00594303198158741, 0.008279498666524887, -0.043440818786621094, -0.027204876765608788, -0.02844087779521942, 0.011063585057854652, 0.08029244840145111, -0.04869012162089348, 0.0543946698307991, 0.07200013846158981, -0.0226939395070076, -0.02115265652537346, -0.056226566433906555, -0.0010076730977743864, 0.001850622589699924, 0.030464107170701027, 0.05363324284553528, 0.012540338560938835, 0.003556635929271579, 0.03776155784726143, 0.03971143439412117, 0.012335479259490967, 0.0652647614479065, 0.008190570399165154, 0.03213651478290558, 0.0386127308011055, -0.01943943277001381, -0.04195838421583176, 0.017248738557100296, -0.0008923992281779647, 0.0016040544724091887, -0.01032944954931736, -0.03558975085616112, 0.015666594728827477, 0.022459104657173157, 0.015080085955560207, -0.04816962778568268, -0.03524700179696083, -0.033938758075237274, 0.016714321449398994, 0.003125580959022045, -0.06174841150641441, 0.035052552819252014, 0.045984797179698944, 0.011781475506722927, 0.018187157809734344, 0.03524196520447731, -0.03646446391940117, -0.07935423403978348, -0.020022431388497353, -0.011640075594186783, -0.005825597792863846, 0.014910537749528885, 0.016583217307925224, -0.00297748064622283, 0.040175825357437134, -0.020189184695482254, -0.01491785142570734, 0.02938828244805336, 0.011561047285795212, 0.022849297150969505, 0.07671735435724258, -0.012383588589727879, 0.0007680815178900957, -0.023292627185583115, -0.003778159851208329, 0.11504624038934708, 0.07060885429382324, 0.026465896517038345, -0.09341931343078613, 0.005837482865899801, -0.0015792906051501632, 0.004592225421220064, 0.016742927953600883, -0.012249479070305824, 0.0034095162991434336, -0.05033564567565918, 0.034690164029598236, 0.06028169393539429, 0.0064140306785702705, 0.0015442981384694576, 0.04139988496899605, -0.04275429621338844, -0.020736893638968468, 0.004389522597193718, -0.003626651596277952, 0.010796980932354927, -0.006773017812520266, -0.04950018599629402, -0.005833861883729696, -0.03158197179436684, -0.046139877289533615, -0.05510738119482994, -0.01277618296444416, -0.0023913816548883915, -0.024078868329524994, -0.05338028445839882, 0.01454857736825943, 0.040026381611824036, 0.029994092881679535, -0.027311887592077255, 0.002242319518700242, 0.016472356393933296, 0.0008739288314245641, -0.003977617248892784, 0.008595386520028114, -0.0036462319549173117, 0.004948615562170744, -0.0005292329005897045, -0.02680111862719059, -0.009155112318694592, -0.03388967737555504, -0.03115309402346611, 0.0643240213394165, 0.01576426438987255, -0.03605740889906883, 0.008869445882737637, 0.0007918457267805934, -0.01564522087574005, -0.03337109833955765, -0.014239984564483166, -0.019001316279172897, 0.0002868634182959795, 0.00006637452315771952, -0.045535020530223846, -0.02209082432091236, -0.008374043740332127, -0.021467721089720726, 0.02132713422179222, 0.019464313983917236, -0.0187899898737669, 0.03415003791451454, -0.007772682700306177, 0.025622723624110222, 0.007059118710458279, -0.008424956351518631, 0.033152300864458084, -0.02145308628678322, -0.009890589863061905, -0.050162360072135925, 0.04589357599616051, -0.0000641901497147046, 0.021211514249444008, -0.012826718389987946, 0.01173674501478672, -0.06266940385103226, -0.051872432231903076, 0.018030507490038872, -0.06549543887376785, -0.01700098253786564, -0.05177197605371475, 0.013370620086789131, 0.04177704080939293, 0.05400862917304039, 0.01999782584607601, 0.010633748956024647, -0.004350534174591303, 0.022084636613726616, 0.025218818336725235, -0.0678713321685791, -0.01481536403298378, 0.022463807836174965, -0.04237768054008484, 0.031185325235128403, -0.024400176480412483, 0.03799472004175186, 0.01935679093003273, 0.026210134848952293, -0.017333094030618668, 0.03999567776918411, -0.029440680518746376, 0.023750342428684235, -0.000015139788956730627, -0.04707907885313034, 0.004109299276024103, 0.013301095925271511, -0.008595552295446396, -0.016372624784708023, 0.003645105753093958, -0.07642834633588791, -0.046190328896045685, 0.04006001353263855, 0.009127688594162464, -0.0521186962723732, 0.07926926016807556, 0.013911723159253597, 0.010488604195415974, -0.03203427419066429, 0.017567282542586327, -0.0017320788465440273, -0.010627955198287964, 0.030517926439642906, -0.035655029118061066, -0.004476956091821194, -0.019892634823918343, -0.018192099407315254, 0.012153773568570614, 0.028123972937464714, 0.011400776915252209, 0.03799426555633545, 0.0050602564588189125, 0.030052896589040756, 0.02410542219877243, 0.07652705907821655, -0.04007576406002045, 0.018704067915678024, 0.016718532890081406, -0.054593537002801895, -0.015947794541716576, 0.02943638153374195, -0.038886528462171555, 0.04529418796300888, 0.02773682400584221, 0.004351288545876741, -0.021230803802609444, 0.05732071399688721, -0.04087936505675316, 0.016922609880566597, -0.019863978028297424, 0.01362572517246008, 0.02644660510122776, 0.007971935905516148, -0.026057692244648933, 0.022183632478117943, -0.027247076854109764, 0.03021790087223053, 0.059984516352415085, -0.03969619795680046, -0.01940697617828846, 0.03330056741833687, 0.002137137809768319, 0.028116047382354736, 0.018526386469602585, 0.002843719208613038, 0.03687574341893196, 0.0017664942424744368, -0.011907504871487617, 0.038716401904821396, 0.018380338326096535, 0.022239023819565773, -0.06921223551034927, -0.01021893322467804, -0.04229800030589104, -0.00816392246633768, 0.031440507620573044, -0.036565493792295456, 0.009380608797073364, 0.03936131298542023, -0.048169054090976715, -0.0029402729123830795, -0.028347458690404892, 0.019892079755663872, -0.03770425543189049, -0.0013145685661584139, 0.0009047091589309275, 0.05652414634823799, 0.019086530432105064, 0.011407499201595783, 0.02465251460671425, -0.00040653368341736495, 0.010718525387346745, -0.03514096885919571, 0.0019112267764285207, -0.019134920090436935, 0.04236426204442978, -0.06742711365222931, 0.00534050865098834, -0.052241481840610504, -0.04155893996357918, 0.042684003710746765, -0.020765092223882675, 0.05821309611201286, 0.017348425462841988, 0.04383176565170288, -0.03792022541165352, 0.058813441544771194, 0.023367710411548615, 0.011454733088612556, -0.001619799411855638, -0.017193522304296494, 0.0021108905784785748, 0.024866346269845963, -0.03502284735441208, 0.029983999207615852, -0.008948590606451035, -0.03813713416457176, -0.02395809255540371, 0.003260181052610278, 0.001492754090577364, -0.006541942711919546, -0.008773674257099628, -0.018153171986341476, -0.005144490860402584, -0.05341644957661629, 0.023283416405320168, -0.02297150157392025, 0.02312588505446911, 0.04941840097308159, 0.036844924092292786, -0.0026305383071303368, -0.007907194085419178, -0.012865029275417328, -0.038155585527420044, 0.0320158377289772, 0.010982588864862919, -0.03743259236216545, -0.07528439909219742, 0.015027699060738087, 0.02233400009572506, -0.0401475615799427, -0.052962370216846466, 0.00038570299511775374, -0.027681656181812286, 0.04287324845790863, 0.008044066838920116, -0.01462499052286148, 0.037591010332107544, -0.03205592557787895, 0.03171306475996971, -0.06813426315784454, 0.056967951357364655, 0.022675342857837677, -0.02642768807709217, -0.025395816192030907, -0.007822951301932335, -0.022384054958820343, 0.00007319211727008224, 0.02179046906530857, -0.014211011119186878, 0.027865389361977577, 0.005566790699958801, 0.03664296492934227, 0.01637888327240944, -0.00766579108312726, 0.04184328019618988, 0.011834940873086452, -0.02947830595076084, -0.00841511506587267, -0.04050096124410629, -0.030407657846808434, 0.01447087712585926, 0.02155327796936035, -0.0038520521484315395, 0.010311389341950417, 0.027113638818264008, 0.0004246838216204196, 0.02346358448266983, 0.019192537292838097, -0.00523093668743968, 0.04191944748163223, -0.001931858016178012, -0.012824409641325474, 0.05971231311559677, 0.009422289207577705, -0.011290946044027805, 0.020319053903222084, -0.014414199627935886, -0.02085726149380207, 0.019021231681108475, 0.02622564695775509, -0.009886901825666428, -0.032816797494888306, 0.024614738300442696, 0.029755812138319016, -0.007957405410706997, -0.011700659058988094, 0.02912028692662716, 0.01962561160326004, 0.029490333050489426, -0.004387072287499905, 0.022718992084264755, -0.010251674801111221, -0.009356736205518246, 0.053681060671806335, 0.01259562373161316, 0.06602998822927475, -0.02180148847401142, 0.005740621592849493, 0.062463559210300446, -0.015692446380853653, 0.04869074374437332, -0.03457700088620186, 0.039401374757289886, -0.01445750705897808, -0.06148022040724754, -0.012205737642943859, 0.0027956150006502867, 0.0335698239505291, -0.019770434126257896, -0.02755146659910679, 0.031906262040138245, -0.04668264836072922, 0.014655915088951588, -0.013335811905562878, -0.004200474359095097, -0.03406282886862755, -0.045573778450489044, 0.003292693058028817, 0.009005279280245304, -0.004321695305407047, -0.010242998600006104, 0.023958398029208183, -0.03441547229886055, 0.02963421307504177, -0.005042874254286289, -0.005619968753308058, 0.01394105888903141, -0.014188572764396667, -0.05008339136838913, -0.00907162856310606, -0.006517039146274328, 0.008330009877681732, 0.030785655602812767, 0.05649872124195099, 0.0013185744173824787, -0.012390408664941788, -0.04674781858921051, -0.03254090994596481, 0.04810132458806038, -0.052114423364400864, -0.05461105331778526, -0.018930580466985703, 0.023548338562250137, -0.028116924688220024, -0.025375260040163994 ]
<p>I have a large dataset from a survey that describes what web pages people use. So for each person I have a list of pages that they visit and how frequently they visit them. What methods can be used to cluster both the webpages (based on similar users who use them) and the users (who use similar webpages).</p> <pre><code>Example&gt; User A visited web pages a, b, a, c User B visited a, b, d, b User C visited page e, e </code></pre> <p>Conclusion from that would be that pages <code>a</code>,<code>b</code>,<code>c</code>,<code>d</code> are somewhat similar and belong to the same cluster. The other cluster is page <code>e</code>. Also, users a,b are similar, the other user cluster is the one containing <code>User C</code>, who visits different pages.</p>
74,483
[ -0.06555008143186569, -0.0030575746204704046, -0.007319857832044363, -0.010691535659134388, 0.01444012951105833, 0.013936838135123253, 0.013961907476186752, -0.008309970609843731, 0.02501765452325344, 0.0033003620337694883, 0.04204319044947624, 0.0357537567615509, 0.042260803282260895, 0.002361895749345422, 0.05939919874072075, -0.007159133907407522, -0.012532670050859451, 0.0026475475169718266, 0.009042440913617611, 0.00835862010717392, -0.0259533803910017, -0.01644234172999859, 0.027544228360056877, -0.006439161952584982, -0.02432364597916603, 0.01022864319384098, 0.023548662662506104, -0.007228338159620762, 0.0015938935102894902, 0.0432703010737896, -0.04942883923649788, -0.003145543858408928, 0.02721209079027176, 0.033070508390665054, -0.0037161519285291433, 0.004784881602972746, -0.07490187138319016, -0.006082210689783096, -0.0335758775472641, 0.012737689539790154, -0.017916522920131683, 0.010430105961859226, -0.021923305466771126, 0.05029039457440376, 0.007368848193436861, 0.003491855226457119, -0.006000570021569729, -0.023931972682476044, 0.017065640538930893, -0.06071873754262924, 0.08048966526985168, -0.02627536468207836, 0.04209962487220764, 0.015795879065990448, -0.016414206475019455, -0.016261031851172447, 0.02511751465499401, 0.06181688979268074, -0.022509178146719933, -0.05493897199630737, -0.042276591062545776, -0.003970437217503786, 0.03167691454291344, -0.04003174602985382, -0.053806938230991364, 0.05367806553840637, -0.02383788861334324, 0.001523427083157003, 0.0505700446665287, -0.0008093583164736629, 0.01893613487482071, 0.010086499154567719, 0.04923291131854057, -0.03115149959921837, 0.025969060137867928, -0.03719146177172661, 0.00033280899515375495, 0.02732204832136631, 0.05496023967862129, 0.018077027052640915, 0.0009987567318603396, -0.001047409255988896, 0.00392569275572896, 0.008474616333842278, 0.056876398622989655, 0.0012433405499905348, 0.036214254796504974, -0.03559200093150139, -0.019914662465453148, 0.03642246127128601, -0.014742307364940643, -0.022536905482411385, 0.05898064374923706, 0.03267962113022804, -0.030419690534472466, 0.030272385105490685, -0.003966221585869789, 0.007229248993098736, 0.013831062242388725, 0.015123924240469933, -0.029030777513980865, -0.046565379947423935, 0.0030802213586866856, 0.04185079038143158, -0.0036066777538508177, -0.02056732028722763, -0.08259224891662598, -0.03271593526005745, -0.02252095378935337, 0.012295334599912167, -0.0017651255475357175, -0.004533103201538324, 0.019873136654496193, 0.0025635557249188423, 0.03879774734377861, -0.009640752337872982, -0.007045741192996502, -0.01020257268100977, 0.027708277106285095, 0.05667375400662422, 0.036480993032455444, -0.0006401148857548833, 0.01873859576880932, -0.04365187883377075, -0.03919230401515961, -0.011076013557612896, 0.03564104065299034, -0.019814854487776756, -0.013397951610386372, 0.0423206128180027, -0.04368595778942108, 0.0030914924573153257, 0.010520325973629951, -0.017251919955015182, 0.02690012753009796, 0.008896212093532085, -0.07369647175073624, -0.008405332453548908, 0.03387027978897095, -0.03046017326414585, 0.04201992601156235, -0.021224072203040123, 0.01171557791531086, 0.0013119550421833992, 0.0491955392062664, 0.02198258601129055, 0.0037613462191075087, 0.00035519321681931615, 0.02015470154583454, 0.007968099787831306, -0.012386421672999859, -0.02210252545773983, -0.01017840951681137, 0.011108677834272385, -0.025041865184903145, -0.06272397190332413, 0.0011067468440160155, 0.005264887120574713, -0.006636857520788908, 0.01683267392218113, 0.008333285339176655, -0.01119490060955286, -0.005662317853420973, -0.049681369215250015, 0.025846432894468307, -0.006871968973428011, 0.0702953115105629, 0.01711895316839218, 0.05906831845641136, 0.010898669250309467, -0.0358000174164772, 0.012983177788555622, -0.003777832258492708, 0.027364633977413177, 0.05109959468245506, 0.019753195345401764, 0.006422034464776516, -0.001225353917106986, 0.02722802199423313, 0.0036833963822573423, -0.02017870917916298, -0.05620763078331947, -0.000356373842805624, 0.016560181975364685, 0.01959073543548584, 0.04101992025971413, 0.0012827650643885136, -0.025161461904644966, 0.04082690551877022, -0.02585587464272976, -0.036269135773181915, -0.07530969381332397, 0.002652043243870139, -0.006553397513926029, -0.022071437910199165, 0.01760764978826046, -0.01144440844655037, -0.029327629134058952, 0.007069477811455727, -0.03657909855246544, -0.03516486659646034, 0.003526732325553894, 0.046507708728313446, -0.026153068989515305, -0.04473897069692612, 0.025653142482042313, 0.022752616554498672, -0.02515103854238987, 0.06089216098189354, -0.03786517679691315, -0.02976800873875618, -0.004390710964798927, -0.03043304942548275, -0.008946938440203667, -0.006216640118509531, 0.00983692891895771, 0.027047645300626755, 0.04767022654414177, -0.04687609523534775, -0.0018794983625411987, -0.0514073483645916, 0.06478981673717499, 0.039514098316431046, 0.006285410840064287, 0.005498738959431648, -0.030803663656115532, -0.01646079309284687, 0.011442732997238636, -0.014214408583939075, -0.00928111094981432, -0.10414450615644455, 0.005260908976197243, 0.04879774898290634, 0.02060430496931076, -0.029070843011140823, 0.008178949356079102, 0.06206469237804413, 0.06740586459636688, -0.020628485828638077, 0.037597041577100754, -0.04250430315732956, -0.009287223219871521, 0.03124195523560047, 0.022824089974164963, 0.02850479632616043, -0.0149199478328228, 0.00951367150992155, 0.0037555720191448927, 0.02163240686058998, 0.006495518144220114, -0.002278272993862629, 0.03063860721886158, 0.009700044989585876, 0.018130632117390633, 0.01116055529564619, -0.001424851012416184, 0.029520023614168167, -0.0013092353474348783, -0.010970201343297958, 0.022589728236198425, 0.028248222544789314, -0.02908589318394661, 0.02133224532008171, -0.06517349183559418, -0.006510282400995493, 0.05615588650107384, -0.05414930358529091, 0.018057258799672127, 0.011142052710056305, -0.02838509902358055, 0.024895479902625084, 0.001739824772812426, -0.020731180906295776, -0.03622107580304146, 0.049559228122234344, 0.04191375523805618, 0.00009151423728326336, 0.01702953316271305, -0.030349137261509895, -0.031088609248399734, -0.013588132336735725, -0.03373454511165619, -0.009284759871661663, -0.03529127314686775, -0.04973732307553291, 0.005515133962035179, 0.02188805118203163, -0.006219277158379555, 0.0017780765192583203, 0.015495726838707924, -0.026396485045552254, 0.017888344824314117, 0.005377395078539848, -0.05828023701906204, 0.016346897929906845, -0.01766272634267807, 0.034233104437589645, -0.004134113434702158, -0.012604057788848877, 0.038227975368499756, 0.015025606378912926, -0.04472814127802849, 0.023460753262043, -0.014661716297268867, -0.019903648644685745, -0.0029558073729276657, -0.03359149396419525, 0.009018843062222004, -0.02034025453031063, 0.017210828140378, 0.023766281083226204, -0.018470576032996178, 0.003945300355553627, -0.05673813074827194, -0.0896373987197876, 0.018846938386559486, -0.010416175238788128, 0.019618378952145576, 0.017104946076869965, -0.03735261783003807, 0.05822054669260979, 0.014961550012230873, -0.049912307411432266, -0.04186778515577316, -0.016273383051156998, -0.01798286847770214, -0.0038582379929721355, 0.05283522605895996, 0.03595009446144104, -0.0000394122107536532, -0.033706288784742355, 0.030259961262345314, 0.011549732647836208, 0.05620984360575676, 0.011302675120532513, 0.001969562843441963, -0.001300973235629499, 0.02369348146021366, 0.012322580441832542, 0.019867219030857086, 0.0020150351338088512, -0.06129850819706917, 0.007549407426267862, -0.007321881130337715, -0.013985523954033852, -0.005481919273734093, -0.015018405392765999, -0.004707884509116411, 0.0035451760049909353, 0.000021843892682227306, -0.032885149121284485, 0.03157932311296463, 0.028024163097143173, -0.0353129617869854, 0.01867370866239071, 0.06061367318034172, 0.014897741377353668, -0.015310212969779968, -0.02997252717614174, 0.05206822603940964, 0.04754884913563728, -0.04788772761821747, -0.016928236931562424, -0.02536793425679207, -0.020937424153089523, -0.00913802906870842, -0.05062488839030266, -0.012719321064651012, 0.008803092874586582, 0.05247557908296585, 0.016591684892773628, 0.0024975519627332687, -0.05738796666264534, 0.016087420284748077, -0.07964518666267395, 0.004724768456071615, -0.04724637791514397, 0.082639679312706, -0.014777165837585926, 0.04110065847635269, 0.031369950622320175, 0.003278202610090375, 0.02430884540081024, 0.004371813498437405, -0.07556361705064774, 0.028865648433566093, -0.01713230088353157, 0.009595579467713833, -0.005781358573585749, -0.05160398408770561, 0.03666819632053375, 0.0010761538287624717, 0.021176869049668312, -0.010557590052485466, 0.01796342432498932, 0.0026292740367352962, 0.014647272415459156, 0.009464799426496029, -0.004764157347381115, -0.0005295441951602697, 0.013777103275060654, 0.0003052790416404605, 0.021064510568976402, 0.06053527072072029, 0.03154158219695091, -0.017660876736044884, -0.015505664050579071, -0.006799024064093828, -0.0005937280366197228, 0.011579612269997597, 0.01251996774226427, -0.002622128464281559, 0.03415648639202118, -0.013656485825777054, -0.005308188032358885, -0.03139631077647209, 0.013049066066741943, 0.06014401838183403, -0.013577568344771862, 0.009536671452224255, -0.040785811841487885, -0.023307329043745995, -0.014344785362482071, 0.03566410019993782, -0.022051408886909485, 0.023986121639609337, 0.02078891731798649, 0.04917038604617119, -0.048718445003032684, 0.02962743490934372, 0.08762585371732712, 0.03471871837973595, -0.04978514090180397, -0.024235190823674202, 0.019072500988841057, 0.026063136756420135, 0.015392864122986794, 0.021883247420191765, 0.01753932796418667, 0.008909893222153187, 0.016665814444422722, 0.014933176338672638, -0.011629685759544373, -0.036718275398015976, 0.039483692497015, 0.005954990163445473, 0.03757205605506897, -0.010798852890729904, -0.07016222923994064, 0.0017911732429638505, 0.03843193128705025, 0.07069806754589081, 0.04485192894935608, -0.03308326378464699, -0.1014377623796463, -0.009663554839789867, 0.045210786163806915, 0.055799372494220734, -0.049383893609046936, 0.0035522994585335255, 0.0030484043527394533, 0.004488973878324032, 0.028549406677484512, -0.05844155699014664, 0.03327694535255432, -0.04225772246718407, 0.019324960187077522, -0.022838840261101723, -0.014617647975683212, -0.024167733266949654, 0.02524496242403984, -0.06846603751182556, 0.03830456733703613, -0.02716134488582611, -0.03895612433552742, -0.0828418955206871, 0.0011107457103207707, 0.033607855439186096, 0.03372157737612724, -0.06164449080824852, -0.0015172511339187622, 0.015461537055671215, 0.009681379422545433, -0.020640462636947632, -0.0539909228682518, 0.024370061233639717, 0.02433091402053833, -0.01848178170621395, 0.05582866817712784, 0.005955033004283905, -0.0246400386095047, 0.008616475388407707, 0.013071813620626926, -0.0013181815156713128, -0.014235739596188068, -0.011700577102601528, 0.05578344687819481, 0.04494431987404823, -0.010617912746965885, 0.02577154152095318, 0.0036850885953754187, 0.014336754567921162, 0.010216660797595978, -0.033021267503499985, -0.01804632879793644, -0.037937015295028687, 0.009558333083987236, -0.02181093581020832, -0.01986340433359146, -0.024050967767834663, 0.016543835401535034, -0.024448256939649582, -0.014862414449453354, -0.05095098167657852, -0.03472491726279259, -0.0007221862324513495, 0.008613228797912598, 0.010867700912058353, 0.0144196143373847, 0.01282635610550642, 0.019926974549889565, 0.018380234017968178, -0.010476171970367432, 0.028874609619379044, -0.021814415231347084, 0.016305746510624886, -0.026470888406038284, -0.038492415100336075, 0.010617314837872982, -0.0464751236140728, -0.01579265110194683, 0.022636031731963158, -0.02828841097652912, 0.03333163261413574, -0.008960133418440819, 0.04904105141758919, 0.03217646852135658, -0.010009649209678173, -0.022714292630553246, 0.030244169756770134, 0.009905264712870121, 0.018711641430854797, -0.03863852471113205, 0.07933209836483002, 0.003328389720991254, -0.05776223540306091, -0.07413375377655029, -0.03009888157248497, 0.046671804040670395, -0.0015539282467216253, -0.032710008323192596, -0.0896383598446846, -0.00866859033703804, -0.014534969814121723, -0.025283465161919594, -0.031240105628967285, 0.024054938927292824, -0.02317718416452408, -0.017193716019392014, -0.00954746175557375, -0.005925354082137346, 0.10049647837877274, 0.0321839340031147, -0.014068972319364548, -0.011096158996224403, 0.02667427808046341, -0.010663974098861217, -0.01834852434694767, 0.013160319067537785, -0.02535388246178627, -0.01878497749567032, -0.04713017866015434, 0.03412334620952606, 0.04517185688018799, -0.04077160730957985, 0.005993552505970001, -0.02173006907105446, 0.02082310989499092, 0.00017148944607470185, -0.025500696152448654, 0.03058837167918682, -0.013050100766122341, 0.03551675006747246, -0.053781334310770035, 0.03263954445719719, -0.02194182574748993, -0.0028169548604637384, 0.026883408427238464, 0.0019198301015421748, -0.01696128025650978, 0.0020859616342931986, 0.06271005421876907, 0.002222940558567643, -0.01408371888101101, -0.015412332490086555, -0.019451908767223358, 0.05189166218042374, -0.007219568360596895, -0.00796939991414547, -0.005026515573263168, 0.0457724928855896, -0.030284948647022247, -0.006831337232142687, -0.0064603425562381744, -0.0381237156689167, 0.07241792231798172, 0.0056695411913096905, 0.051873259246349335, 0.09657778590917587, 0.007001313380897045, 0.023170311003923416, -0.012968916445970535, -0.009113598614931107, -0.0331951305270195, 0.010376615449786186, 0.04879822954535484, -0.010808557271957397, -0.0098818214610219, 0.03195226937532425, 0.005849312990903854, 0.006200023461133242, 0.054649222642183304, 0.03771460801362991, 0.030991174280643463, 0.010304566472768784, -0.034133706241846085, -0.03383238613605499, 0.017451293766498566, -0.0395054928958416, 0.008257524110376835, -0.04233076423406601, -0.03306767717003822, 0.03404621407389641, 0.024282129481434822, -0.0031662650872021914, 0.011619905941188335, -0.022460034117102623, -0.03298044949769974, 0.022784601897001266, 0.023593135178089142, 0.0006722730468027294, 0.007173658814281225, 0.021805040538311005, 0.020745866000652313, 0.02847944386303425, 0.016530826687812805, -0.0013050766428932548, -0.06529366970062256, -0.025355473160743713, -0.013522403314709663, -0.05310610681772232, 0.02415977604687214, 0.0019993369933217764, -0.05186349153518677, 0.03249148279428482, -0.005473162978887558, 0.0033962971065193415, 0.023058898746967316, 0.030849386006593704, -0.004120052792131901, 0.054413486272096634, 0.010191752575337887, 0.04073731601238251, -0.023617025464773178, -0.019189534708857536, 0.11556833237409592, 0.06288676708936691, 0.04042535647749901, -0.08128233999013901, 0.011863043531775475, 0.02736574597656727, -0.02249857783317566, -0.052140530198812485, 0.024517763406038284, 0.00997941568493843, 0.03689794987440109, 0.0620887465775013, 0.033430520445108414, 0.03066745027899742, 0.010004953481256962, 0.0601021908223629, -0.030060412362217903, -0.03565654158592224, 0.012462599202990532, -0.004463925026357174, -0.042802777141332626, -0.020274797454476357, -0.07193005084991455, 0.01955576054751873, 0.03027234598994255, -0.026156384497880936, -0.03343123570084572, -0.021750876680016518, -0.02487151138484478, 0.010969067923724651, -0.0005665508797392249, 0.011969242244958878, -0.01743883267045021, -0.01504159439355135, -0.019230632111430168, -0.020258821547031403, 0.031077926978468895, -0.012256940826773643, 0.025095514953136444, 0.0122107844799757, -0.0032248564530164003, -0.026502244174480438, -0.04020505025982857, 0.03995750844478607, -0.013072210364043713, -0.022010480985045433, -0.032144516706466675, 0.032302968204021454, -0.017538780346512794, 0.021795373409986496, 0.018810272216796875, 0.02408742532134056, -0.0103510906919837, -0.009458675980567932, -0.021123850718140602, 0.03496408835053444, 0.022608879953622818, -0.028264647349715233, -0.019358795136213303, -0.040181197226047516, 0.010153673589229584, -0.014193491078913212, 0.022271037101745605, 0.005436195991933346, -0.0006506841746158898, -0.01354839839041233, -0.03451937064528465, 0.03163103014230728, -0.019948409870266914, 0.01713351346552372, -0.012977910228073597, -0.03899165615439415, -0.007937769405543804, 0.003587182145565748, 0.012773685157299042, -0.014476433396339417, 0.03466719388961792, 0.001600470393896103, 0.002914436860010028, -0.012710118666291237, 0.002450744155794382, 0.026776893064379692, -0.02995474264025688, -0.013801129534840584, -0.0438862182199955, 0.004688020795583725, 0.060599952936172485, 0.040898680686950684, 0.020590316504240036, 0.015632743015885353, -0.012473134323954582, 0.024533884599804878, 0.006693573202937841, -0.04062289372086525, -0.046678900718688965, -0.01590724103152752, -0.030183425173163414, 0.011106200516223907, 0.0020673780236393213, 0.06687232106924057, 0.03201936557888985, -0.03435108810663223, -0.02565612643957138, -0.012589765712618828, 0.0006747881998308003, 0.023553460836410522, -0.03138928860425949, -0.04197251424193382, -0.01692609116435051, 0.02408868446946144, 0.0049536204896867275, -0.02515709586441517, -0.0170869342982769, -0.004031062126159668, -0.0011582563165575266, 0.02358200214803219, -0.033474162220954895, -0.02102883905172348, 0.010488016530871391, -0.019327884539961815, 0.03130060061812401, -0.047683313488960266, -0.016209064051508904, -0.04382159188389778, -0.03650815784931183, -0.02782723493874073, 0.007276602555066347, -0.009722094982862473, 0.002795959822833538, 0.005027336999773979, 0.015726933255791664, 0.04193854704499245, 0.009473178535699844, 0.03314569965004921, 0.030061552301049232, 0.003954838030040264, -0.03401041403412819, 0.0341591015458107, -0.027455972507596016, -0.044740673154592514, 0.06891384720802307, -0.06160031259059906, -0.055450305342674255, 0.008444666862487793, -0.018484631553292274, 0.04066668450832367, -0.010045562870800495, -0.004942833911627531, 0.014030251652002335, 0.022217784076929092, 0.0017025347333401442, -0.03444081172347069, -0.01820247434079647, 0.011281144805252552, 0.04139989987015724, 0.027578115463256836, -0.008038725703954697, 0.025129932910203934, -0.02863321825861931, 0.002898705890402198, 0.03993988037109375, 0.005187465809285641, -0.02096879668533802, 0.013086721301078796, 0.028744211420416832, 0.030393779277801514, -0.014942474663257599, -0.002748458879068494, 0.05448753386735916, 0.020422784611582756, -0.049463383853435516, -0.002010394586250186, -0.035543497651815414, -0.018072467297315598, -0.04609410837292671, -0.016888830810785294, 0.0034986163955181837, -0.02714628353714943, 0.05286017060279846, -0.0675070732831955, -0.02330251969397068, 0.031714700162410736, -0.039835792034864426, 0.059161823242902756, 0.02342168428003788, -0.0158318430185318, -0.0577675923705101, 0.02542143501341343, -0.023475321009755135, 0.03202411159873009, 0.02292298898100853, 0.048416152596473694, 0.006798170041292906, 0.019598983228206635, 0.023052889853715897, -0.024920271709561348, -0.057666629552841187, -0.013452134095132351, 0.03199557960033417, -0.05264320597052574, 0.0385938435792923, -0.04407524690032005, -0.03257133066654205, 0.040494635701179504, -0.026434512808918953, 0.018117042258381844, 0.05859159305691719, -0.016525525599718094, -0.022610465064644814, 0.05882303789258003, 0.02768087573349476, -0.01974528096616268, -0.047534797340631485, 0.009658467024564743, -0.01223019603639841, 0.03851061314344406, 0.006555846892297268, 0.021649643778800964, 0.0038212172221392393, 0.01501618791371584, 0.011405443772673607, 0.043328817933797836, -0.023528892546892166, -0.02090528979897499, -0.013122374191880226, 0.005202241241931915, 0.019794194027781487, 0.0025609920267015696, -0.020330213010311127, -0.045534636825323105, 0.004815070889890194, 0.04577793553471565, 0.009680123068392277, 0.010889253579080105, 0.035910461097955704, -0.0027325674891471863, -0.0483759269118309, 0.0197609756141901, -0.005453673657029867, -0.008729112334549427, -0.041767437011003494, 0.0011239192681387067, -0.0016274921363219619, 0.0213389303535223, -0.009967171587049961, -0.018254084512591362, 0.01707444153726101, 0.05947210267186165, -0.028424810618162155, 0.0019655509386211634, 0.00718780979514122, -0.015059138648211956, 0.033505141735076904, -0.019634805619716644, 0.0468214750289917, 0.007596175651997328, 0.015209370292723179, -0.038253042846918106, -0.04541007801890373, -0.05878100171685219, 0.026296593248844147, 0.040655769407749176, 0.016419973224401474, 0.028776731342077255, -0.047181226313114166, 0.01920279860496521, 0.009817930869758129, -0.07763950526714325, 0.04505224898457527, -0.006755021866410971, -0.029722481966018677, 0.026690227910876274, -0.00012819354014936835, -0.012984776869416237, -0.012753108516335487, 0.007999943569302559, -0.014291967265307903, -0.01992824301123619, -0.029034461826086044, -0.03813565894961357, 0.03137274459004402, 0.014073247089982033, 0.037927594035863876, 0.02246144786477089, 0.024708537384867668, 0.009892144240438938, 0.03960563987493515, 0.018125096336007118, -0.0321771502494812, 0.0440230667591095, -0.07562462240457535, -0.039631348103284836, 0.030954262241721153, 0.0011612214148044586, -0.004789648577570915, -0.06411110609769821, -0.011155418120324612, -0.008234686218202114, 0.003491503419354558, -0.0011645597405731678, 0.02378392405807972, 0.025048822164535522, 0.04420119896531105, -0.012498350813984871, 0.02973153442144394, 0.0025896718725562096, -0.014738496392965317, 0.029630113393068314, 0.03430033475160599, 0.012985615991055965, -0.008806529454886913, 0.02571495994925499, 0.007636294700205326, 0.02432635985314846, 0.01964547298848629, -0.03881789371371269, 0.029040299355983734, -0.025192011147737503, 0.005217460915446281, 0.03793010488152504, -0.02727837860584259, -0.00630653090775013, 0.058348797261714935, 0.01688280887901783, 0.019510742276906967, -0.03673368692398071, 0.021087056025862694, -0.03216829523444176, -0.021903021261096, -0.04765443876385689, 0.040246009826660156, 0.00392889603972435, 0.02232665941119194, -0.009052794426679611, 0.008829992264509201, 0.031114134937524796, -0.004642412532120943, 0.008833016268908978, 0.029921628534793854, 0.03956427425146103, -0.019255707040429115, -0.012747681699693203, -0.0020988453179597855, -0.005840951111167669, -0.03983214497566223, -0.007863947190344334, 0.019270459190011024, 0.0707390084862709, 0.042396239936351776, 0.006800656206905842, 0.012458422221243382, 0.004539364483207464, 0.014066564850509167, -0.04226104915142059, -0.02626395784318447, -0.05302225798368454, 0.014905796386301517, -0.01666448824107647, -0.014666286297142506 ]
<p>I would be interested in finding ways in R for efficiently updating a linear model when an observation or a predictor is added. biglm has an updating capability when adding observations, but my data are small enough to reside in memory (although I do have a large number of instances to update). There are ways to do this with bare hands, e.g., to update the QR factorization (see "Updating the QR Factorization and the Least Squares Problem", by Hammarling and Lucas), but I am hoping for an existing implementation.</p>
74,484
[ -0.017169279977679253, 0.05523662269115448, -0.027861589565873146, -0.02315259724855423, 0.005110080819576979, -0.001650612917728722, 0.0068306163884699345, -0.03221528232097626, 0.022800937294960022, -0.03673047199845314, 0.0031369251664727926, 0.047710005193948746, 0.057153891772031784, 0.011926478706300259, -0.00820781197398901, -0.02024145983159542, -0.01103528868407011, -0.039400432258844376, -0.019801612943410873, 0.01163795217871666, -0.0030460406560450792, 0.036804091185331345, 0.018373696133494377, -0.024225154891610146, -0.006238678935915232, 0.09279364347457886, 0.04302860051393509, -0.021001344546675682, 0.022899333387613297, 0.05277286097407341, -0.015510288998484612, -0.03897076100111008, 0.021356279030442238, 0.05469193682074547, 0.01950892247259617, -0.029243584722280502, -0.037577297538518906, -0.04933684319257736, 0.0026236677076667547, 0.023598860949277878, -0.031139452010393143, -0.03355802968144417, -0.030392181128263474, 0.04887119308114052, -0.004604006186127663, -0.004454667214304209, -0.009072759188711643, -0.012854710221290588, 0.055338304489851, -0.02560724876821041, 0.07624919712543488, -0.0014624048490077257, 0.03346628323197365, 0.026466118171811104, -0.0508001483976841, 0.016401994973421097, 0.04667071998119354, 0.09988650679588318, 0.03154921159148216, -0.0034073751885443926, -0.013534409925341606, -0.024187542498111725, 0.025521423667669296, -0.0014371523866429925, -0.02417372725903988, 0.0024223902728408575, -0.021684542298316956, 0.0015088916989043355, -0.009930928237736225, -0.05996221303939819, -0.027793744578957558, 0.013918569311499596, 0.05807192623615265, -0.0013354147085919976, -0.010699179954826832, -0.024076852947473526, -0.021044133231043816, 0.0019561401568353176, 0.06354697048664093, 0.03712819889187813, 0.00023736193543300033, 0.008358138613402843, 0.04006396234035492, 0.029576580971479416, 0.004700300749391317, -0.010163537226617336, 0.03986191377043724, 0.004027510993182659, 0.022030804306268692, 0.026640385389328003, -0.030140506103634834, -0.005065644159913063, 0.06834554672241211, -0.02502935193479061, -0.050893429666757584, -0.006012102589011192, -0.0058414810337126255, 0.042091965675354004, 0.016168592497706413, 0.01621934399008751, 0.023710254579782486, -0.035511355847120285, -0.021005049347877502, 0.06012558192014694, -0.04765342175960541, -0.0342957004904747, -0.006795378867536783, -0.007335781119763851, -0.013395617716014385, -0.01378291379660368, -0.011788449250161648, 0.026048079133033752, -0.028761550784111023, -0.027204735204577446, 0.004010158125311136, -0.05906475707888603, -0.054715849459171295, -0.03027409501373768, 0.02810990996658802, 0.060763049870729446, 0.03846257925033569, -0.026380350813269615, 0.01815107837319374, -0.03064717911183834, -0.047051992267370224, 0.007965853437781334, -0.005685662850737572, -0.04919276386499405, -0.06615680456161499, 0.05920465290546417, -0.0017239464214071631, -0.059359658509492874, 0.06244571879506111, -0.025459906086325645, 0.011399762704968452, 0.013716389425098896, -0.08742447942495346, -0.04280218854546547, 0.04853552579879761, -0.020715128630399704, 0.015696194022893906, -0.06461828947067261, 0.0032192205544561148, 0.006279130466282368, 0.077693872153759, 0.04157538339495659, 0.010224911384284496, 0.04490872099995613, 0.004548329859972, -0.010114582255482674, -0.031098736450076103, -0.004020963795483112, -0.037072211503982544, -0.02144605666399002, -0.04697355628013611, -0.08600760996341705, -0.0031273076310753822, 0.025620916858315468, -0.037126533687114716, 0.004912246949970722, 0.05522310733795166, 0.006613679230213165, 0.009679733775556087, -0.014277685433626175, 0.023715071380138397, -0.02489752508699894, 0.014750384725630283, -0.01633264124393463, 0.039059605449438095, -0.0000957070806180127, 0.003983646165579557, -0.00006953744014026597, 0.025046996772289276, 0.03499825298786163, 0.03421088308095932, -0.026518212631344795, -0.010166862979531288, -0.03584853559732437, 0.018053272739052773, 0.01848028227686882, -0.007659919559955597, -0.039847321808338165, 0.012138508260250092, -0.04065266251564026, 0.010358923114836216, 0.028499441221356392, 0.005818226840347052, 0.0025504925288259983, 0.05311313271522522, -0.04503628984093666, -0.025157537311315536, -0.08478957414627075, 0.025951780378818512, 0.009622350335121155, -0.004853426944464445, 0.007814889773726463, 0.028197819367051125, 0.02288009785115719, 0.010680001229047775, -0.010595128871500492, -0.0074790422804653645, -0.03566715493798256, 0.023235268890857697, -0.02357872761785984, -0.02921651490032673, 0.0063400110229849815, 0.06745303422212601, -0.01998988166451454, 0.027690835297107697, -0.06353003531694412, -0.018817661330103874, 0.013967487961053848, -0.020328080281615257, -0.012893213890492916, -0.045804962515830994, -0.03142963722348213, -0.01995619386434555, -0.008795497938990593, 0.0046882713213562965, 0.005439691711217165, -0.035715993493795395, 0.03273399919271469, 0.05122004821896553, 0.04311526566743851, -0.0006952426047064364, 0.021318156272172928, 0.0013067405670881271, -0.007186495698988438, -0.02426871284842491, -0.01700405962765217, -0.04865974187850952, -0.015403036959469318, 0.06439425051212311, 0.009891063906252384, -0.020884742960333824, 0.02888193167746067, 0.05113134905695915, 0.01925356686115265, 0.03740736469626427, 0.032187569886446, -0.047959402203559875, -0.014590965583920479, 0.020721683278679848, -0.017105206847190857, 0.05383399501442909, -0.0023158700205385685, 0.01538142841309309, 0.001037798821926117, 0.05318376421928406, 0.007434654049575329, -0.005165855400264263, -0.0211538877338171, 0.01772208884358406, -0.018138708546757698, -0.035275377333164215, -0.032267969101667404, 0.024916164577007294, -0.03739965707063675, 0.030883053317666054, 0.010251500643789768, 0.013826960697770119, 0.012367088347673416, 0.004625832196325064, -0.003255643881857395, -0.0027602864429354668, 0.01774505525827408, -0.046643223613500595, 0.0011816980550065637, 0.01662621647119522, -0.026111315935850143, 0.05923611298203468, -0.022886615246534348, -0.004448200110346079, -0.049716465175151825, 0.04022911563515663, 0.012418451718986034, 0.016529979184269905, 0.035442598164081573, -0.06055434048175812, -0.01412339136004448, 0.004457517061382532, -0.0174789447337389, 0.02845953032374382, 0.04068518057465553, -0.020124005153775215, -0.0022782443556934595, -0.012506082653999329, -0.02172420173883438, 0.012918414548039436, 0.017491711303591728, -0.016238706186413765, 0.01879587210714817, -0.004758194088935852, -0.07033050805330276, -0.010872545652091503, -0.018924837931990623, 0.016463836655020714, -0.0015675686299800873, 0.004108253866434097, 0.028108859434723854, 0.03270898759365082, -0.04067780077457428, -0.03252609446644783, -0.038865357637405396, 0.027479104697704315, -0.04488874226808548, -0.035048071295022964, 0.013824483379721642, 0.007411376107484102, 0.020094236359000206, 0.02057085558772087, -0.03852331265807152, 0.023283151909708977, -0.06824173778295517, -0.0364750437438488, 0.017199963331222534, 0.005979504436254501, 0.041878413408994675, 0.024828575551509857, 0.0032192282378673553, 0.07329835742712021, 0.025709249079227448, -0.03629804030060768, -0.03691813349723816, -0.0018585043726488948, 0.023830628022551537, -0.036500733345746994, 0.014364898204803467, -0.01631123200058937, 0.0077421097084879875, 0.02754097618162632, -0.008657742291688919, -0.031270552426576614, 0.05191829055547714, 0.051177460700273514, -0.023154834285378456, 0.016026245430111885, -0.013409222476184368, 0.026438452303409576, 0.010355419479310513, 0.009828673675656319, -0.0032455420587211847, 0.024524128064513206, 0.00713622709736228, -0.022129148244857788, 0.020845457911491394, -0.006277116015553474, -0.012584531679749489, 0.0034451736137270927, 0.008577343076467514, -0.04901983588933945, 0.016280146315693855, -0.0039016848895698786, -0.043629616498947144, 0.0012889609206467867, 0.03520163148641586, 0.026403307914733887, -0.00009328868327429518, 0.013702639378607273, 0.008845440112054348, 0.01559831015765667, -0.03095574490725994, 0.05709841474890709, -0.008194247260689735, -0.028860490769147873, 0.010210400447249413, -0.04425086826086044, 0.010271445848047733, 0.050947677344083786, 0.024757735431194305, -0.0016060613561421633, 0.011266480199992657, -0.012912205420434475, 0.0298979040235281, -0.06890921294689178, -0.006546648219227791, -0.005084407050162554, 0.010656201280653477, 0.038904834538698196, 0.020577508956193924, -0.018788043409585953, 0.0013870303519070148, 0.046847667545080185, -0.02080114185810089, -0.08583357185125351, 0.014424917288124561, -0.008952398784458637, -0.011316542513668537, 0.037986136972904205, 0.012172270566225052, 0.016299093142151833, -0.024330338463187218, -0.02678927592933178, -0.02111179195344448, 0.02107546292245388, -0.047369860112667084, 0.03066529892385006, -0.030679121613502502, -0.033590517938137054, -0.018280716612935066, -0.026011496782302856, 0.05615370348095894, -0.05671105906367302, 0.014204981736838818, 0.013808296993374825, -0.03189467638731003, 0.001031409716233611, -0.019072500988841057, -0.013402486220002174, 0.016017891466617584, 0.04887426272034645, 0.008654770441353321, 0.0404970645904541, -0.05068435147404671, 0.02845965139567852, 0.006143839564174414, 0.023480793461203575, 0.032939132302999496, 0.0027673374861478806, -0.008020531386137009, -0.02923836000263691, -0.020329883322119713, -0.0017510894685983658, 0.010244735516607761, -0.01889016479253769, 0.006404270883649588, 0.05874822288751602, 0.02684897556900978, -0.017793359234929085, -0.01493624784052372, 0.09597517549991608, 0.024024857208132744, 0.02089519239962101, -0.01080875750631094, 0.015097549185156822, 0.016512688249349594, -0.023663952946662903, 0.0277689341455698, -0.01869533397257328, 0.03385026380419731, -0.009257975034415722, 0.009489909745752811, -0.041175153106451035, 0.025573033839464188, -0.01998859830200672, 0.03405164182186127, 0.050416313111782074, 0.030495457351207733, 0.014710906893014908, 0.006626814603805542, 0.048062924295663834, 0.03538431599736214, 0.018155887722969055, 0.014683428220450878, -0.11706103384494781, 0.035379886627197266, 0.03729943558573723, 0.04204770177602768, -0.017249276861548424, -0.005843514576554298, -0.05748366564512253, -0.030721720308065414, 0.033619534224271774, -0.03411921113729477, 0.03661692515015602, -0.0057313269935548306, -0.00364468595944345, -0.029178576543927193, -0.03620012104511261, -0.02530926838517189, 0.0005512681091204286, -0.06018223613500595, 0.028137030079960823, -0.017679842188954353, -0.02389562502503395, -0.06095534563064575, 0.025407608598470688, 0.017496054992079735, 0.05632968619465828, -0.01342525240033865, -0.00984545424580574, 0.03797229379415512, 0.004639497026801109, -0.03611993044614792, -0.04985847324132919, -0.005698299966752529, 0.00848106388002634, -0.013131245039403439, 0.01415283139795065, -0.03187699615955353, -0.011035137809813023, 0.027333445847034454, 0.022963160648941994, -0.049398623406887054, -0.027621641755104065, -0.0022107786498963833, 0.03337942436337471, 0.012918893247842789, 0.014799032360315323, 0.05939418822526932, 0.021328475326299667, 0.013397135771811008, 0.006938288453966379, -0.0199113842099905, -0.01944715343415737, -0.015140296891331673, -0.04241055250167847, -0.018948832526803017, -0.0031630576122552156, 0.013071313500404358, 0.05113406479358673, 0.008027821779251099, 0.03422602266073227, -0.011039121076464653, -0.0007698910194449127, 0.0075792670249938965, 0.07712558656930923, -0.0265490859746933, -0.0195209551602602, 0.00733549427241087, 0.040162213146686554, -0.020988674834370613, -0.027454622089862823, 0.04649486392736435, -0.01358614582568407, -0.007358300033956766, 0.01331221405416727, -0.05017370358109474, 0.013283082284033298, -0.026767922565340996, -0.0028931433334946632, -0.0006073651602491736, 0.01484130322933197, 0.03992237150669098, -0.021505989134311676, 0.019786562770605087, 0.00043655879562720656, -0.05376322194933891, -0.009222273714840412, -0.009435510262846947, -0.03591664507985115, -0.00982328224927187, -0.034710612148046494, 0.02398732304573059, -0.005730052012950182, 0.015687504783272743, -0.045578911900520325, -0.06613930314779282, 0.028817638754844666, -0.02845143713057041, -0.00020291285181883723, -0.06361294537782669, -0.008396069519221783, -0.037403978407382965, 0.016481781378388405, -0.01128483098000288, 0.024419119581580162, -0.0417766273021698, 0.027579352259635925, 0.0031389768701046705, 0.021942246705293655, 0.012073283083736897, -0.006069886963814497, 0.005630300845950842, 0.027214501053094864, -0.00690588029101491, -0.03589744493365288, 0.0007306489278562367, 0.01117109414190054, -0.043835557997226715, 0.005126606673002243, -0.028749629855155945, 0.005087783560156822, 0.0524049773812294, 0.001829260727390647, -0.004399399273097515, 0.029498208314180374, -0.01542175654321909, 0.01046169362962246, -0.04160897061228752, -0.0232844240963459, -0.018457580357789993, -0.0018424144946038723, -0.035335641354322433, 0.015617833472788334, 0.06373467296361923, -0.017464803531765938, 0.0044568972662091255, -0.009363719262182713, -0.00032957858638837934, -0.0325622633099556, 0.0761488750576973, 0.004183041863143444, 0.021429402753710747, 0.023123981431126595, -0.04347119852900505, 0.03678085654973984, 0.0005123128648847342, 0.012016704306006432, -0.010528571903705597, -0.006616485770791769, -0.0396844781935215, -0.05889352783560753, -0.006640603765845299, -0.02171853929758072, 0.028938226401805878, 0.02082153968513012, 0.024500269442796707, 0.05372936651110649, 0.007834703661501408, -0.005975636653602123, -0.006453719921410084, -0.011902094818651676, 0.004912751726806164, -0.013258406892418861, 0.08544464409351349, 0.022719651460647583, 0.0020973312202841043, 0.04463586211204529, 0.015197009779512882, 0.034332435578107834, 0.033442173153162, -0.0004881840432062745, 0.0485297329723835, 0.06117968633770943, -0.046036042273044586, -0.04192454740405083, 0.02569081261754036, -0.05245940014719963, 0.003922405187040567, -0.011378713883459568, -0.021438512951135635, 0.07269544154405594, 0.03815622627735138, 0.029677588492631912, -0.03672713786363602, 0.0006854485254734755, -0.05764598771929741, -0.019315587356686592, 0.0036425769794732332, -0.0012959555024281144, 0.02214379794895649, -0.017005814239382744, 0.042642224580049515, 0.033366765826940536, -0.0011783341178670526, -0.04517582803964615, -0.09842141717672348, -0.024524148553609848, 0.007436956278979778, -0.007915424183011055, 0.03067217394709587, 0.03201496973633766, -0.025951460003852844, -0.0005250133108347654, -0.01188460923731327, 0.016720129176974297, -0.00608343118801713, 0.07845791429281235, -0.030017858371138573, 0.06354326754808426, -0.03532189503312111, -0.02061859890818596, -0.004953747149556875, 0.0024009235203266144, 0.11846475303173065, 0.07317215949296951, 0.05535254627466202, -0.052052196115255356, 0.01562969759106636, 0.009339910931885242, -0.010711684823036194, -0.015437732450664043, -0.026334544643759727, -0.011426502838730812, -0.017951400950551033, 0.0076367296278476715, 0.04899287223815918, 0.012171375565230846, 0.010279172100126743, 0.045161765068769455, -0.03580708056688309, -0.014352124184370041, 0.01910753920674324, 0.013893777504563332, 0.008394502103328705, 0.01524171233177185, -0.04830675199627876, 0.02679162472486496, -0.0233398899435997, -0.040397096425294876, -0.01918296329677105, -0.010264875367283821, 0.0010183367412537336, 0.012785238213837147, -0.035170990973711014, 0.02667875401675701, -0.007288062479346991, 0.02154979296028614, 0.030234428122639656, 0.03754217177629471, 0.025468097999691963, 0.030354484915733337, 0.01797632686793804, 0.041334569454193115, 0.010145215317606926, 0.004757724702358246, -0.024050138890743256, -0.008730078116059303, -0.025455476716160774, -0.02069687470793724, -0.0464664101600647, 0.03419015556573868, -0.06700284034013748, 0.009668293409049511, -0.012877929955720901, -0.007050378248095512, 0.025564827024936676, -0.04153082147240639, -0.028483202680945396, 0.05803477019071579, 0.03151044249534607, 0.021399665623903275, -0.006775327492505312, 0.0029792319983243942, 0.035659145563840866, -0.015159151516854763, 0.009621286764740944, 0.04247966781258583, -0.04673955589532852, -0.016986656934022903, -0.01798439584672451, 0.031872741878032684, 0.00445420341566205, 0.0004516430199146271, -0.0026648978237062693, -0.022980444133281708, -0.011660812422633171, -0.03449653834104538, 0.03216152265667915, 0.02021748200058937, 0.012438694015145302, -0.05477249622344971, 0.025602353736758232, -0.03907307609915733, -0.04775251820683479, -0.04429791867733002, -0.02065689116716385, -0.010690280236303806, -0.053367339074611664, -0.010666088201105595, 0.055772565305233, 0.014725154265761375, 0.020014191046357155, 0.009562334977090359, -0.0020796118769794703, 0.014963937923312187, -0.004379113204777241, -0.043381866067647934, -0.013368657790124416, 0.007010691799223423, -0.0313609316945076, 0.03248950466513634, -0.016597984358668327, 0.04907764866948128, 0.009263220243155956, -0.009830594062805176, -0.022869214415550232, 0.07025564461946487, -0.030436331406235695, 0.03393082693219185, -0.004663339350372553, -0.034371644258499146, 0.025845471769571304, -0.032728519290685654, 0.027288004755973816, -0.009614743292331696, -0.011749843135476112, -0.02681124210357666, -0.030733764171600342, -0.017735596746206284, -0.013625694438815117, -0.03863569349050522, 0.021254051476716995, -0.015897642821073532, 0.022040395066142082, -0.0176167543977499, 0.005547255743294954, -0.017981093376874924, -0.035691190510988235, 0.02107848785817623, -0.028524039313197136, -0.01503940299153328, 0.005865900777280331, -0.03569192439317703, -0.005366823635995388, 0.046937841922044754, 0.009589778259396553, 0.008653353899717331, -0.008070810697972775, -0.002432241104543209, -0.004749959800392389, 0.045015204697847366, -0.0386359766125679, -0.05521233007311821, 0.04030032455921173, -0.030270365998148918, 0.008638594299554825, 0.04202328994870186, -0.008034681901335716, 0.016636526212096214, 0.047386061400175095, -0.022288605570793152, -0.03013593703508377, 0.029517697170376778, -0.014314529486000538, 0.011114058084785938, -0.012421472929418087, 0.007744034752249718, 0.011111533269286156, 0.008039770647883415, 0.045449886471033096, -0.024828976020216942, -0.0313228964805603, 0.009630055166780949, 0.049852997064590454, 0.025042889639735222, 0.02097162790596485, -0.0019073568983003497, 0.010063407942652702, -0.011573630385100842, -0.005957162939012051, -0.008168395608663559, 0.04799044877290726, 0.04203406721353531, -0.028619885444641113, 0.044266946613788605, 0.010558235459029675, 0.012507781386375427, -0.09685619920492172, -0.0006085063214413822, 0.00914554949849844, -0.006834268569946289, 0.052933577448129654, -0.07048482447862625, 0.016135362908244133, 0.05337121710181236, -0.04010332375764847, 0.005969916470348835, -0.03234638646245003, -0.000645406951662153, -0.014532922767102718, -0.014610142447054386, -0.00880899466574192, -0.003849388100206852, 0.0403621569275856, 0.00910472683608532, 0.037109605967998505, 0.02965424954891205, 0.01797662302851677, -0.01722746528685093, -0.0038993030320852995, 0.01487655844539404, 0.038425080478191376, -0.03265451639890671, -0.004736976232379675, -0.04525471851229668, 0.01590883545577526, -0.009400859475135803, -0.017105979844927788, 0.03150573745369911, 0.004740782547742128, 0.04174613207578659, -0.0002689352259039879, 0.07312595844268799, 0.0009406912722624838, 0.01892341673374176, 0.020007962360978127, -0.009279938414692879, -0.006603187881410122, 0.028978809714317322, -0.018960194662213326, 0.035265106707811356, 0.011519135907292366, -0.010922202840447426, -0.010325315408408642, -0.011158986017107964, -0.01581372320652008, 0.019770460203289986, -0.005425373092293739, 0.01763269305229187, -0.0031428285874426365, -0.018554432317614555, -0.03751549497246742, 0.0001792672701412812, 0.013270826078951359, 0.022038953378796577, 0.006922404281795025, -0.03700534626841545, 0.011538488790392876, 0.018553100526332855, -0.04199368134140968, 0.02777123637497425, -0.020925693213939667, 0.02554122731089592, -0.11133509129285812, -0.025474930182099342, 0.007335323374718428, -0.03674359619617462, -0.015227614901959896, 0.0064483704045414925, -0.0355510339140892, 0.06654869765043259, -0.03808160498738289, 0.017823167145252228, 0.017835117876529694, -0.00015751754108350724, 0.011657346971333027, -0.05701953545212746, 0.0845283642411232, 0.035798605531454086, 0.024747466668486595, -0.002443802310153842, -0.009777898900210857, -0.013965541496872902, 0.010847115889191628, 0.04833932965993881, 0.001769321970641613, 0.01839367486536503, -0.003709699958562851, 0.038288671523332596, 0.018566930666565895, -0.03443039581179619, 0.03199596703052521, -0.006972772069275379, 0.0020051978062838316, -0.030780166387557983, -0.012292562983930111, 0.014252528548240662, 0.023101279512047768, 0.012229401618242264, -0.02632521651685238, 0.013337244279682636, 0.0015095650451257825, -0.015653502196073532, 0.035048313438892365, 0.00973067618906498, -0.005345758982002735, 0.0285270307213068, 0.005834765266627073, 0.011173072271049023, 0.030490634962916374, -0.01756514236330986, -0.043325696140527725, 0.04840702563524246, -0.06088271364569664, -0.005862543359398842, 0.007183632347732782, -0.017844051122665405, 0.007579609751701355, -0.029621750116348267, 0.00105298834387213, 0.027477707713842392, -0.027939563617110252, 0.024855123832821846, 0.039640288800001144, -0.007830802351236343, 0.07828418165445328, 0.006634590681642294, 0.03182375431060791, 0.0013492113212123513, 0.015738768503069878, -0.009810895659029484, 0.021293049678206444, 0.012770970351994038, -0.007855131290853024, 0.04138431325554848, 0.03667419031262398, -0.005657583940774202, 0.011072869412600994, -0.011985737830400467, 0.008508013561367989, -0.04672307148575783, -0.03360481187701225, 0.014624792151153088, -0.03958168998360634, 0.041010186076164246, -0.02168688364326954, -0.03153056278824806, 0.033331625163555145, -0.05005145072937012, -0.04285629466176033, -0.03678152337670326, 0.0006303510162979364, 0.011039284989237785, -0.009806047193706036, -0.04100892320275307, 0.061386588960886, -0.0006499523879028857, 0.006918007507920265, 0.025983497500419617, -0.017750684171915054, 0.027565499767661095, -0.00013194777420721948, 0.010581377893686295, -0.03064950555562973, 0.0111134834587574, -0.0400426909327507, -0.020627299323678017, -0.012037409469485283, -0.016928914934396744, 0.04408598691225052, 0.057010989636182785, 0.03263411298394203, -0.012441068887710571, -0.03155321627855301, -0.029769552871584892, 0.020516779273748398, -0.032204318791627884, 0.021403854712843895, -0.045107580721378326, 0.01120544970035553, -0.025644848123192787, -0.019398367032408714 ]
<p>Suppose I observe <em>i.i.d.</em> $x_i \sim \mathcal{N}\left(\mu,\Sigma\right)$, and wish to test $H_0: A\ $<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vectorization_%28mathematics%29#Half-vectorization">vech</a>$\left(\Sigma^{-1}\right) = a$ for a conformable matrix $A$ and vector $a$. Is there known work on this problem? </p> <p>The obvious (to me) attempt would be via a likelihood ratio test, but it seems like maximizing the likelihood subject to the constraints of $H_0$ would require a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semidefinite_programming">SDP solver</a> and could be pretty hairy. </p>
74,485
[ -0.02431466244161129, 0.001887525082565844, 0.004393117036670446, -0.046963319182395935, 0.05182292312383652, 0.00903302151709795, -0.02831781841814518, -0.014894443564116955, 0.019618967548012733, -0.03438907861709595, 0.027323657646775246, 0.02743031270802021, 0.045520927757024765, 0.04103672504425049, 0.008546785451471806, 0.015925893560051918, 0.008300910703837872, 0.025098659098148346, -0.01848759688436985, -0.011468674056231976, 0.03992968797683716, 0.02704519033432007, 0.003550638910382986, 0.0008498537936247885, -0.034981682896614075, 0.014393969438970089, -0.005304859485477209, -0.04195074364542961, -0.015182912349700928, 0.08649930357933044, -0.04925556108355522, -0.02860896661877632, 0.002775157568976283, 0.0315212719142437, 0.004206329118460417, 0.01783888041973114, 0.005868413019925356, -0.010216266848146915, 0.014602379873394966, 0.036798056215047836, 0.0073421117849648, -0.014992860145866871, 0.028777604922652245, 0.05955490842461586, 0.0022901527117937803, 0.07555045187473297, -0.000731644278857857, -0.034221600741147995, 0.053025972098112106, -0.03840271383523941, 0.07235359400510788, 0.024619441479444504, 0.012752106413245201, 0.017755402252078056, -0.010612154379487038, -0.03523334488272667, 0.014319777488708496, 0.06648680567741394, 0.020253675058484077, -0.03463199734687805, -0.009843902662396431, -0.05910171568393707, -0.002099401317536831, -0.02619573101401329, -0.030141741037368774, 0.030551934614777565, 0.009074375964701176, -0.021312085911631584, 0.04710378497838974, -0.03581490367650986, -0.006830526515841484, -0.028662823140621185, 0.01652592234313488, -0.00061610626289621, -0.01213159877806902, 0.0007742150337435305, -0.012934591621160507, -0.0009650912834331393, 0.013638845644891262, -0.0026813005097210407, 0.010716712102293968, 0.012787317857146263, -0.0003629708371590823, 0.026739679276943207, 0.010490129701793194, -0.01703091897070408, 0.057148028165102005, -0.025946926325559616, -0.0018978253938257694, 0.013998469337821007, -0.029890963807702065, -0.014698182232677937, 0.07199972867965698, -0.00756465457379818, -0.0650462657213211, 0.04502351954579353, -0.03148196265101433, 0.02898625284433365, 0.014551001600921154, -0.02457936480641365, -0.03510190173983574, -0.01739814318716526, -0.03421180322766304, 0.057888250797986984, -0.011856316588819027, 0.025190124288201332, -0.006520004477351904, 0.025063704699277878, -0.02315429225564003, -0.030765613541007042, -0.0589047372341156, 0.04936476796865463, -0.011980809271335602, 0.029642073437571526, 0.017534183338284492, -0.015269650146365166, -0.029030010104179382, -0.03471151366829872, 0.038967061787843704, 0.06285279989242554, 0.021458197385072708, 0.0048398845829069614, -0.003796574892476201, -0.03689378872513771, -0.049972545355558395, -0.0014432368334382772, 0.018084639683365822, -0.004482826683670282, -0.05879032984375954, 0.04224849119782448, 0.02807457558810711, -0.003237880067899823, 0.02295807935297489, 0.036070965230464935, -0.0014529703184962273, -0.004164591431617737, -0.08200673013925552, -0.08088293671607971, 0.049002207815647125, 0.0005978884873911738, 0.007422721013426781, -0.05323363468050957, -0.029153479263186455, 0.07230361551046371, 0.09399116039276123, 0.0032932462636381388, 0.055694129317998886, 0.006259783171117306, 0.04054853692650795, 0.04787078872323036, 0.001423535868525505, -0.04764336720108986, -0.050844401121139526, -0.0038906768895685673, -0.02818528190255165, -0.05884302407503128, 0.01759032905101776, 0.013902626000344753, -0.044024981558322906, -0.025749571621418, 0.06772344559431076, 0.031245283782482147, -0.00632315780967474, -0.021415330469608307, 0.010758957825601101, -0.015287764370441437, 0.03717746585607529, 0.016055934131145477, 0.020086154341697693, 0.010952592827379704, -0.017561914399266243, 0.04448503628373146, 0.019729487597942352, 0.024622002616524696, 0.04291689023375511, -0.04355332627892494, -0.009571311995387077, 0.007101976312696934, 0.0036684933584183455, 0.014603019692003727, -0.0038780614268034697, -0.012522907927632332, -0.03206469491124153, 0.021801643073558807, 0.06227976828813553, 0.015058303251862526, -0.012319761328399181, -0.013858884572982788, 0.031438592821359634, -0.07490289211273193, -0.002047544112429023, -0.048108261078596115, -0.02496945671737194, 0.021067975088953972, -0.05031903088092804, 0.07529257237911224, -0.018282746896147728, -0.009848563931882381, 0.014940623193979263, -0.04015393555164337, -0.027965379878878593, 0.007380520924925804, 0.04909459128975868, -0.012387416325509548, 0.006797537673264742, 0.03961656242609024, 0.025038260966539383, -0.021123996004462242, 0.03123079426586628, 0.005983523093163967, -0.07528123259544373, -0.016267217695713043, -0.02874179556965828, 0.02629900351166725, 0.035131506621837616, 0.06027139350771904, 0.006515489425510168, -0.010725392028689384, 0.023360395804047585, 0.032572779804468155, -0.05247396603226662, 0.03269112855195999, 0.0544637106359005, 0.014962323941290379, 0.0001432281278539449, -0.0031787832267582417, 0.013703507371246815, 0.000736361660528928, -0.002070561982691288, -0.008775096386671066, -0.050407011061906815, -0.011710230261087418, 0.02735891193151474, 0.07962938398122787, -0.034962598234415054, -0.0015623662620782852, 0.05528305098414421, 0.05473466217517853, 0.012934580445289612, 0.04384622722864151, -0.015986919403076172, -0.04789228364825249, 0.01069190725684166, -0.004470597021281719, -0.0013980233343318105, 0.00949019007384777, 0.0014425504487007856, 0.016032066196203232, 0.02291715145111084, 0.017343446612358093, -0.00549916410818696, 0.05054440349340439, 0.006357877049595118, -0.002319635823369026, -0.02776436135172844, -0.02179163694381714, 0.013486422598361969, -0.010869641788303852, 0.002120777266100049, 0.05871408060193062, -0.014862682670354843, 0.007629437372088432, -0.04813822731375694, -0.02459149993956089, 0.004921231884509325, 0.02743304893374443, 0.010836892761290073, 0.016381751745939255, 0.02679543010890484, -0.03740948066115379, 0.007556997239589691, -0.042329493910074234, 0.0019114869646728039, -0.03420563414692879, -0.002201635157689452, 0.03317226096987724, -0.007737000938504934, -0.0027731943409889936, -0.0651344433426857, -0.026311203837394714, 0.02697533182799816, -0.010174456983804703, 0.06393502652645111, 0.013237562961876392, -0.040790706872940063, -0.01141392346471548, -0.05314348265528679, -0.016254974529147148, -0.008845845237374306, -0.000947086897213012, 0.017505064606666565, 0.04658867046236992, -0.009103981778025627, -0.02994804084300995, -0.02087872289121151, -0.019502287730574608, -0.0007577294018119574, -0.02184724248945713, 0.01869392767548561, 0.004930564668029547, 0.036745112389326096, -0.04238208755850792, 0.027500025928020477, 0.00283495313487947, -0.02783925272524357, -0.018136603757739067, -0.03136289119720459, 0.0029413136653602123, -0.013536727987229824, 0.07444802671670914, 0.06359502673149109, -0.010042401030659676, -0.006594023201614618, -0.07606826722621918, -0.03244168683886528, 0.0156716275960207, -0.003769525093957782, 0.012953095138072968, -0.014298909343779087, -0.008806117810308933, 0.07443998008966446, 0.04487625136971474, -0.013571836985647678, -0.055453669279813766, 0.022921616211533546, -0.014233320020139217, -0.024620819836854935, 0.01835300773382187, 0.010958629660308361, -0.020711548626422882, 0.06446419656276703, -0.022937685251235962, 0.015904871746897697, 0.03342685475945473, -0.0019410311942920089, 0.002964804880321026, 0.0382109135389328, 0.0014770933194085956, -0.005025744438171387, 0.05581273138523102, -0.008243857882916927, 0.009391670115292072, 0.009127861820161343, 0.00946054421365261, 0.022217385470867157, 0.040624238550662994, -0.029508724808692932, 0.013077305629849434, -0.017713602632284164, 0.013355785980820656, -0.005195802543312311, 0.036390554159879684, 0.03345080465078354, -0.013838871382176876, -0.034229815006256104, 0.031793851405382156, 0.026286283507943153, -0.013747629709541798, -0.01550403144210577, 0.06081922724843025, 0.011990492232143879, -0.04999632015824318, -0.005970298778265715, -0.04411594197154045, -0.005792376585304737, -0.0003672312886919826, -0.06590647995471954, -0.06669268757104874, 0.029613973572850227, 0.047045543789863586, 0.030417107045650482, -0.023004582151770592, -0.01176595687866211, -0.012733198702335358, -0.024023018777370453, 0.01944606378674507, -0.01254186499863863, 0.016719628125429153, 0.013189696706831455, -0.003519307356327772, 0.004316390957683325, 0.034239761531353, -0.04537240415811539, 0.0065879980102181435, -0.08621315658092499, -0.01031419076025486, -0.04674501717090607, 0.00438098656013608, -0.017977701500058174, -0.015497520565986633, 0.04072614386677742, -0.058803293853998184, 0.0036228748504072428, 0.01127618458122015, 0.03749562427401543, -0.020238906145095825, 0.017812149599194527, -0.03927719220519066, -0.02426687441766262, -0.016735872253775597, 0.040971338748931885, 0.00672197388485074, -0.0036331971641629934, -0.0029525861609727144, 0.03117884323000908, -0.018269266933202744, 0.0160081684589386, -0.0046599265187978745, -0.0014416625490412116, -0.02476118877530098, 0.05998964607715607, 0.006804444827139378, 0.034140415489673615, -0.03297916054725647, 0.03491678833961487, 0.0004093840252608061, 0.05348696559667587, 0.009465557523071766, 0.007409556303173304, -0.0034273897763341665, -0.0559823215007782, -0.050529930740594864, -0.0010615221690386534, 0.007276418153196573, 0.010409725829958916, 0.02142414264380932, 0.05722741037607193, 0.013189560733735561, -0.03565632924437523, 0.01761591248214245, 0.06623733043670654, 0.01773400790989399, -0.001048278994858265, -0.02207399159669876, -0.046818073838949203, -0.0020122097339481115, 0.04568479582667351, 0.002886166563257575, -0.014680861495435238, 0.020880337804555893, 0.002791935345157981, 0.03750399872660637, 0.005663562566041946, 0.011980350129306316, 0.022513067349791527, 0.0038407056126743555, 0.03749718517065048, 0.005952877923846245, -0.0021752824541181326, -0.005611588712781668, 0.04415325075387955, 0.050946805626153946, 0.040706053376197815, 0.01422973908483982, -0.06987085938453674, 0.015408492647111416, 0.019330346956849098, 0.05295144021511078, -0.002281854161992669, 0.010002966970205307, -0.07169680297374725, -0.05575862526893616, 0.05508579686284065, -0.011995021253824234, 0.010566094890236855, -0.00028971469146199524, 0.004272439982742071, -0.01264930423349142, -0.03296234458684921, -0.031224990263581276, 0.00888297613710165, -0.005757621023803949, 0.019681416451931, -0.04861681908369064, -0.025362877175211906, -0.022975485771894455, 0.02027890458703041, 0.05260599032044411, 0.04986656457185745, 0.01334329042583704, 0.014210820198059082, 0.0010861706687137485, 0.017285825684666634, -0.03946491330862045, -0.04857476428151131, 0.014797214418649673, 0.04553186893463135, -0.0517229326069355, 0.02880900166928768, -0.02963968925178051, -0.03313199430704117, 0.066831074655056, 0.0008085613953880966, -0.03088599070906639, 0.030509470030665398, 0.020770644769072533, 0.039514485746622086, -0.002452661981806159, 0.02255292795598507, 0.00881047360599041, 0.024854913353919983, 0.013667638413608074, 0.008898768573999405, -0.056952498853206635, -0.020246319472789764, -0.02046285942196846, 0.003369950922206044, -0.05298266559839249, 0.010402373969554901, -0.016732145100831985, 0.031670164316892624, 0.01583300717175007, 0.041153162717819214, 0.011543579399585724, 0.002570222830399871, -0.01214636955410242, 0.048002928495407104, -0.021053487434983253, -0.024817319586873055, 0.02611277624964714, 0.02166776917874813, 0.02796327881515026, -0.008629288524389267, 0.016496364027261734, -0.021501831710338593, 0.014540479518473148, 0.023599615320563316, -0.037018269300460815, 0.010798725299537182, -0.007142669055610895, -0.012078700587153435, -0.008879989385604858, -0.037057023495435715, 0.06576766073703766, -0.01979367434978485, 0.005181547254323959, -0.013282110914587975, -0.02416633628308773, 0.01620831899344921, 0.017919816076755524, -0.021304050460457802, 0.011918541975319386, -0.021007126197218895, -0.018062055110931396, -0.0032579584512859583, 0.020456463098526, -0.04601960629224777, -0.006485179997980595, -0.01655750162899494, 0.014067173935472965, -0.03169866278767586, -0.06712739914655685, 0.0006581046618521214, -0.018237870186567307, -0.02589648775756359, -0.014050493016839027, 0.03971048444509506, -0.04569859430193901, -0.0002046169392997399, -0.007038668263703585, 0.036882877349853516, 0.02859754115343094, -0.021367378532886505, -0.0022422918118536472, 0.009900087490677834, -0.0016848999075591564, -0.000035462009691400453, 0.05210680887103081, 0.015260789543390274, -0.0247259009629488, 0.004166964907199144, -0.03516504913568497, -0.02234198898077011, 0.033384621143341064, 0.026020865887403488, 0.006262356415390968, 0.024698834866285324, -0.014495433308184147, 0.03921522572636604, -0.03640909492969513, -0.004004104528576136, -0.0034543187357485294, 0.0049005248583853245, 0.031721081584692, 0.006573375780135393, -0.0001205280059366487, 0.004262772388756275, 0.03378446772694588, 0.00918855145573616, 0.003798827761784196, -0.003032091772183776, 0.06408913433551788, -0.01121340598911047, -0.0031238459050655365, 0.03454279899597168, 0.022301750257611275, 0.03892979025840759, 0.02153877168893814, 0.017197120934724808, 0.02021796628832817, 0.013955725356936455, -0.0583830289542675, -0.0570109486579895, -0.019008295610547066, 0.03171458840370178, 0.051529936492443085, 0.01384262926876545, 0.014138235710561275, 0.05626693740487099, 0.008172954432666302, -0.011342031881213188, -0.039007723331451416, 0.017680315300822258, -0.01147120725363493, 0.003520557889714837, 0.030463282018899918, -0.009090675972402096, -0.035475410521030426, 0.06787283718585968, 0.051092728972435, -0.027915164828300476, 0.003913405817002058, -0.0192831102758646, 0.01878238096833229, 0.06947878748178482, -0.07858835160732269, -0.0493089035153389, 0.037429507821798325, -0.06283208727836609, 0.05291307345032692, -0.044862039387226105, -0.013203165493905544, 0.023308970034122467, 0.02172541804611683, 0.02555510215461254, -0.03877006843686104, -0.028439564630389214, -0.06108429655432701, 0.01602426916360855, 0.014932505786418915, -0.03960276395082474, 0.03518398106098175, 0.027694836258888245, 0.035417113453149796, -0.03261245787143707, 0.01846431754529476, -0.01753915287554264, -0.0984724760055542, -0.04067849740386009, -0.0070784990675747395, -0.009389543905854225, 0.04522716999053955, 0.02306276746094227, -0.016440032050013542, -0.01771782897412777, 0.00812381599098444, 0.02604411542415619, -0.029032500460743904, 0.029063688591122627, -0.01736401952803135, 0.019648699089884758, -0.011488407850265503, 0.024275952950119972, -0.016651447862386703, 0.003508227411657572, 0.10882799327373505, 0.07769867777824402, 0.019093835726380348, -0.03656303882598877, 0.006598358508199453, -0.027758853510022163, -0.0031224836129695177, -0.04418904706835747, 0.014599964953958988, 0.009356027469038963, -0.014541488140821457, -0.013726379722356796, 0.02946186251938343, 0.0032308215741068125, -0.014802146703004837, 0.040921613574028015, -0.0449100062251091, -0.021302908658981323, 0.0004296496044844389, -0.01943681575357914, -0.01547156646847725, -0.02064226195216179, -0.011033697053790092, 0.014270625077188015, 0.008396091870963573, -0.03915250301361084, -0.026933642104268074, 0.01894761249423027, -0.014783727005124092, -0.035309918224811554, -0.013473276980221272, 0.0018565114587545395, 0.012907519936561584, 0.0032818580511957407, -0.002895442536100745, 0.03144117817282677, 0.0003658839559648186, 0.0033376070205122232, -0.007513225544244051, 0.006782215088605881, -0.006325872614979744, 0.006478846538811922, -0.01915706880390644, -0.01747201196849346, -0.022748272866010666, -0.007502789609134197, -0.02835991606116295, 0.06458330899477005, -0.027439050376415253, -0.044702984392642975, 0.026153286918997765, -0.029766099527478218, 0.007868952117860317, -0.030231231823563576, -0.019950395449995995, 0.012989326380193233, 0.014098037965595722, 0.0006195932510308921, -0.007840137928724289, 0.01954062283039093, 0.033275824040174484, -0.026877906173467636, 0.045679569244384766, 0.03599286451935768, -0.04399772733449936, -0.03792731463909149, -0.014745012857019901, 0.05356966331601143, 0.003953431732952595, -0.0260897446423769, 0.0170625988394022, -0.03164593130350113, -0.008097619749605656, -0.05342806130647659, 0.016477836295962334, -0.022494835779070854, 0.03638194128870964, 0.0010581908281892538, -0.01738891378045082, -0.03654390573501587, -0.05113808438181877, 0.0032199937850236893, -0.05274590477347374, 0.004858232103288174, -0.0354640819132328, -0.005555619485676289, 0.05434002727270126, 0.044879667460918427, -0.013494320213794708, -0.02922780252993107, 0.023007193580269814, 0.06335393339395523, 0.02909809909760952, -0.03358599916100502, -0.07795941084623337, -0.03546610847115517, -0.01240849494934082, 0.05947563797235489, -0.019713744521141052, 0.04064437001943588, -0.0010689012706279755, 0.02250411920249462, 0.02333158813416958, 0.019853943958878517, -0.033431559801101685, 0.02714187279343605, 0.035377196967601776, -0.03407462313771248, 0.014950346201658249, -0.019809052348136902, 0.021778488531708717, -0.051838669925928116, 0.006900757551193237, -0.06342309713363647, -0.01129856612533331, 0.022724032402038574, -0.05087596923112869, -0.05498674884438515, 0.03616132587194443, -0.005882066208869219, 0.010415575467050076, 0.0004033854929730296, -0.0171221774071455, 0.022144781425595284, -0.011100571602582932, -0.049837641417980194, 0.024526111781597137, 0.01813742332160473, -0.008466375060379505, -0.027924498543143272, -0.029065605252981186, 0.030668461695313454, 0.026949133723974228, -0.014780674129724503, -0.01685943454504013, 0.0346556156873703, 0.0260862335562706, 0.04859508201479912, 0.008513491600751877, -0.015279466286301613, 0.0271686390042305, -0.03684679791331291, -0.021953824907541275, 0.03403756022453308, -0.003348528640344739, 0.0294461902230978, -0.004832406062632799, -0.046398624777793884, -0.00440260861068964, 0.005227247718721628, -0.009136325679719448, 0.00525197759270668, 0.012738115154206753, -0.0030636428855359554, -0.006621118634939194, -0.004532301798462868, 0.04532550647854805, -0.02595050074160099, -0.030634555965662003, 0.013176326639950275, 0.0022771810181438923, -0.037718191742897034, 0.018825465813279152, 0.03734839707612991, -0.0206564050167799, 0.02570066787302494, 0.008093930780887604, -0.031176714226603508, 0.014586926437914371, 0.051232341676950455, -0.025446554645895958, 0.01659427024424076, -0.0029261901509016752, 0.016275878995656967, -0.10853604972362518, -0.004037757404148579, 0.01570385880768299, 0.05060337483882904, 0.035263098776340485, -0.04983319342136383, -0.0012061578454449773, 0.0134363928809762, -0.06526602059602737, 0.009352091699838638, -0.02304046042263508, -0.0007425184594467282, -0.04099898785352707, 0.011679260991513729, 0.002776022534817457, -0.0037020875606685877, 0.0002993492817040533, 0.03631381690502167, 0.02737124264240265, 0.031195761635899544, -0.03028256446123123, -0.046079427003860474, -0.0005309428088366985, -0.013176875188946724, 0.022010982036590576, -0.07958193123340607, 0.026516035199165344, -0.016675878316164017, -0.021405259147286415, -0.0016294941306114197, 0.027477506548166275, 0.034819092601537704, -0.01422144379466772, 0.04456396400928497, -0.000287832401227206, 0.0607917420566082, 0.01652315817773342, -0.011670348234474659, 0.033654626458883286, -0.025651955977082253, -0.017590688541531563, 0.026239773258566856, 0.000677227508276701, -0.003774818265810609, 0.018412996083498, 0.008898977190256119, -0.025987394154071808, 0.016698496416211128, 0.005508537869900465, -0.03841770812869072, -0.01783931814134121, -0.0458797924220562, 0.023531902581453323, -0.018806472420692444, 0.02958458662033081, -0.03792847320437431, -0.002358820987865329, -0.014520951546728611, 0.050079312175512314, -0.017025353386998177, -0.009705208241939545, -0.022775832563638687, -0.040097370743751526, 0.04409319907426834, -0.02618340589106083, -0.005661475472152233, -0.09270159900188446, -0.03596730902791023, -0.031197085976600647, 0.03859066963195801, -0.02830500155687332, -0.012451425194740295, -0.023947034031152725, 0.048901647329330444, 0.027179477736353874, 0.04163886234164238, 0.002018541330471635, -0.009211568161845207, -0.0014773047296330333, -0.057762566953897476, 0.05211975798010826, -0.0011107214959338307, 0.037957970052957535, 0.020773880183696747, -0.011875619180500507, -0.03867702558636665, -0.02345484308898449, 0.04949559271335602, -0.021434100344777107, 0.0345173142850399, 0.016717592254281044, -0.008851063437759876, -0.018541695550084114, -0.02227008529007435, 0.006881517358124256, -0.030972318723797798, -0.02499578706920147, -0.009994758293032646, -0.021920612081885338, 0.03658314421772957, -0.046237193048000336, -0.01526318583637476, 0.03721282631158829, 0.007082744035869837, -0.01419846247881651, -0.013323062099516392, 0.01625176891684532, -0.010752848349511623, -0.025502517819404602, 0.0443672314286232, 0.018868520855903625, -0.010964831337332726, -0.004917880054563284, 0.01896706409752369, -0.04777718707919121, 0.02507348358631134, -0.029090337455272675, -0.06231696903705597, 0.017604054883122444, 0.02989080362021923, -0.006279756315052509, -0.04316028580069542, 0.005576735828071833, 0.02522324025630951, -0.028858447447419167, -0.004466709680855274, -0.00005501976193045266, 0.01391313411295414, 0.03272121027112007, 0.014961018227040768, 0.03821907192468643, 0.05410865694284439, -0.013211083598434925, 0.026254696771502495, 0.028324071317911148, 0.008820688351988792, -0.033758267760276794, -0.000008328074727614876, 0.04584800451993942, 0.0036433786153793335, 0.024876940995454788, -0.01760636456310749, 0.017347091808915138, -0.014474814757704735, -0.02412406913936138, 0.0463055819272995, -0.025916283950209618, 0.006989514920860529, -0.00680950004607439, -0.0294440109282732, 0.07585243135690689, -0.035029973834753036, 0.003933577332645655, -0.05167936906218529, 0.019883545115590096, 0.011995242908596992, 0.022556450217962265, -0.01149788312613964, 0.053648561239242554, -0.01725544035434723, -0.0030420052353292704, 0.006259610876441002, -0.03342214599251747, 0.022138871252536774, -0.03434060141444206, -0.0019475321751087904, 0.00767776183784008, 0.011442811228334904, -0.011336186900734901, -0.009499279782176018, 0.0044573391787707806, -0.01673254184424877, 0.02204245701432228, 0.045115165412425995, 0.008089662529528141, -0.03106764517724514, -0.041539520025253296, -0.012113763019442558, 0.039043962955474854, -0.03669511154294014, -0.03891763836145401, -0.031082740053534508, -0.009232519194483757, -0.03453227877616882, 0.002971114357933402 ]
<p>I am confused how gaussian processes and kriging are related? Can anyone please give me some simple explanation. I tried to go through the wiki but I didn't get it</p>
74,486
[ -0.009032845497131348, -0.00404819892719388, -0.007777640130370855, -0.012744083069264889, 0.05656348168849945, 0.005078705493360758, 0.0012838579714298248, -0.05933799222111702, 0.029573461040854454, -0.024045413359999657, 0.020731309428811073, 0.04198247566819191, 0.03037080727517605, -0.015144538134336472, 0.009023113176226616, 0.016767192631959915, -0.01134356576949358, -0.013005919754505157, -0.012047254480421543, 0.002588025527074933, 0.01349093671888113, 0.03287619352340698, 0.00866978894919157, -0.025899706408381462, -0.02186385542154312, 0.03405466675758362, 0.03800741583108902, -0.008154596202075481, 0.022542409598827362, 0.0685395747423172, -0.008619219064712524, -0.02396627701818943, -0.00017097598174586892, 0.04726538062095642, 0.019007498398423195, -0.011402378790080547, -0.04833662509918213, -0.04074837639927864, -0.024913933128118515, 0.016055144369602203, -0.0371750108897686, -0.056649379432201385, -0.011728080920875072, 0.03491285443305969, -0.015503962524235249, 0.018368367105722427, -0.004622474312782288, -0.056753914803266525, 0.04651285335421562, -0.03568752110004425, 0.0395842008292675, -0.008877038955688477, 0.025468330830335617, 0.046240825206041336, 0.025145594030618668, 0.01911327801644802, 0.09395942836999893, 0.050168558955192566, -0.03274955973029137, -0.051902614533901215, -0.017523592337965965, -0.011885312385857105, 0.00326331565156579, -0.0066395532339811325, -0.01996675692498684, 0.018529051914811134, -0.020158689469099045, -0.017345789819955826, 0.009443533606827259, -0.00598988588899374, 0.018133550882339478, 0.008877704851329327, 0.048656661063432693, -0.04041702300310135, -0.00035466018016450107, -0.011407214216887951, 0.0026534737553447485, 0.0028263279236853123, 0.04007921740412712, 0.005690641701221466, 0.011894521303474903, 0.02300920896232128, -0.010016361251473427, -0.01247166097164154, 0.009320037439465523, 0.014117053709924221, 0.060389794409275055, -0.03242959454655647, 0.011589406989514828, 0.010505063459277153, -0.06028227135539055, 0.022892259061336517, 0.05554521083831787, 0.0014711891999468207, -0.04194743186235428, 0.03508983924984932, 0.009768549352884293, 0.031705744564533234, -0.019407840445637703, -0.0001677170948823914, -0.001432714518159628, -0.054884083569049835, 0.0065721492283046246, 0.03645465523004532, -0.0537143237888813, -0.024469099938869476, -0.007066258694976568, 0.022875381633639336, -0.04028588905930519, -0.033926721662282944, -0.04179006814956665, 0.012707572430372238, 0.02473323419690132, -0.007923243567347527, 0.05624072998762131, -0.02515149861574173, 0.01598694734275341, -0.011807904578745365, 0.02226860821247101, 0.075591079890728, 0.0570988692343235, -0.043338973075151443, 0.033371277153491974, -0.016335241496562958, -0.05260058492422104, 0.04427773877978325, -0.008251306600868702, -0.022930942475795746, -0.03885175287723541, 0.048579003661870956, -0.0064265974797308445, -0.030057039111852646, 0.012211632914841175, 0.013578043319284916, 0.027675660327076912, -0.03241376206278801, -0.104993537068367, -0.03304531052708626, 0.04977470636367798, -0.01307606790214777, 0.03889749199151993, -0.07721018046140671, -0.004858987405896187, -0.008756576105952263, 0.05934547260403633, 0.0042722271755337715, -0.0013316133990883827, -0.011869018897414207, 0.02728169597685337, -0.015982000157237053, -0.025182250887155533, -0.03260970488190651, -0.007492504548281431, -0.010387975722551346, 0.003100170288234949, -0.10514011234045029, 0.013221565634012222, 0.026893390342593193, -0.0398113839328289, -0.03828192874789238, 0.02656186930835247, 0.02078002318739891, -0.014886254444718361, 0.003906932193785906, 0.014643480069935322, -0.022953692823648453, 0.08700792491436005, 0.030737822875380516, 0.024683771654963493, 0.049498122185468674, -0.012181781232357025, -0.002337622456252575, 0.008456328883767128, 0.04816238209605217, 0.049650613218545914, -0.01642616279423237, 0.0062549724243581295, -0.039800066500902176, 0.034929435700178146, 0.013462196104228497, -0.051469046622514725, 0.0009403456933796406, 0.0214272141456604, 0.011630474589765072, 0.025272339582443237, 0.060701366513967514, 0.020284488797187805, -0.012025661766529083, 0.011034146882593632, -0.057684022933244705, 0.004684183746576309, -0.05641899257898331, 0.03745066747069359, 0.000859989901073277, 0.003138105385005474, 0.03241980820894241, 0.013415367342531681, 0.002461114665493369, -0.02387755736708641, -0.04693959280848503, 0.007120133377611637, -0.02262939140200615, 0.011856647208333015, -0.05149959772825241, 0.004836331587284803, 0.06741275638341904, 0.023566821590065956, -0.01470508985221386, 0.07734949886798859, -0.033803001046180725, -0.009403317235410213, 0.0036939354613423347, -0.008965391665697098, -0.0004281856818124652, -0.0298434030264616, -0.04974396526813507, 0.007982810959219933, 0.0012461908627301455, -0.04530353471636772, -0.0006002025911584496, -0.0894579142332077, 0.07277488708496094, 0.08033261448144913, -0.01726592890918255, -0.021153679117560387, 0.0035192612558603287, -0.017229629680514336, 0.025101805105805397, -0.024227123707532883, -0.05158457159996033, -0.04505249857902527, -0.021279944106936455, 0.04534098878502846, 0.043344564735889435, -0.027924904599785805, -0.020487720146775246, 0.028935885056853294, 0.04762374237179756, 0.02265925705432892, 0.032030876725912094, -0.018327368423342705, 0.0097422506660223, 0.02135586552321911, 0.00034183115349151194, -0.005406542215496302, -0.018719565123319626, -0.008545361459255219, 0.03175795078277588, 0.025095341727137566, -0.006945834960788488, -0.0347261019051075, 0.06264804303646088, -0.011569303460419178, 0.004467113874852657, 0.003774888115003705, -0.0026425488758832216, 0.010510602034628391, -0.04591169208288193, -0.0024702863302081823, 0.019263871014118195, 0.017547788098454475, -0.006099302787333727, -0.012149334885179996, -0.037902869284152985, 0.014785096049308777, 0.013672503642737865, -0.04872593283653259, 0.011962494812905788, 0.02040189877152443, -0.007795937359333038, 0.002681984333321452, -0.023047583177685738, -0.022796381264925003, -0.05301276221871376, 0.005885528400540352, 0.014767389744520187, -0.0035321631003171206, 0.02012069709599018, 0.003696782048791647, -0.0425090491771698, 0.00507285725325346, -0.007747762370854616, 0.0323946438729763, 0.01797264628112316, -0.04249591752886772, 0.0379791297018528, -0.01434516254812479, 0.021033449098467827, 0.035259880125522614, -0.06082466244697571, 0.0035507220309227705, -0.0036090705543756485, -0.024426089599728584, -0.03679841384291649, 0.02252165414392948, -0.026865394786000252, 0.028896596282720566, -0.000497838482260704, 0.00995605532079935, 0.03901177644729614, 0.01611911505460739, -0.032007720321416855, 0.0463058240711689, -0.015205870382487774, -0.02361791394650936, -0.06813082098960876, 0.004887319169938564, 0.03020728938281536, -0.008033708669245243, 0.048019543290138245, 0.03281918168067932, -0.06830864399671555, 0.007103248964995146, -0.008442921563982964, -0.045160021632909775, 0.027044571936130524, -0.015029976144433022, 0.02314108796417713, -0.015439899638295174, -0.023934513330459595, 0.06433820724487305, 0.04333337023854256, -0.025215188041329384, -0.004579012747853994, -0.013540850020945072, -0.03449028357863426, -0.019149787724018097, 0.02237754315137863, -0.006945323199033737, -0.010293129831552505, 0.04997013509273529, 0.019411379471421242, 0.020764824002981186, 0.07801304757595062, -0.0025976612232625484, 0.0033552837558090687, -0.028246797621250153, -0.009729105979204178, 0.01636754348874092, 0.025332869961857796, 0.009252576157450676, -0.0350329764187336, 0.018455635756254196, 0.023337842896580696, 0.012190022505819798, 0.024148985743522644, -0.008140523917973042, 0.0005278501776047051, -0.014847375452518463, -0.00896906666457653, -0.07239550352096558, 0.022891931235790253, 0.017344249412417412, -0.031083302572369576, 0.02517828717827797, 0.028003962710499763, 0.028951402753591537, -0.018407631665468216, 0.003779531456530094, 0.022740419954061508, 0.03440222516655922, -0.02845524251461029, 0.0034657372161746025, -0.013871601782739162, -0.020725512877106667, 0.033785175532102585, 0.005531394388526678, -0.03783528506755829, 0.037124257534742355, 0.03499237075448036, -0.014225606806576252, -0.020639987662434578, -0.05008569359779358, -0.0009268288849852979, -0.06006435677409172, -0.005320798605680466, 0.0033271510619670153, 0.03901493549346924, -0.017675774171948433, 0.05721535533666611, 0.03164205700159073, -0.03129943460226059, 0.008236398920416832, 0.00711019616574049, -0.046991415321826935, 0.024299949407577515, -0.03626635670661926, -0.015334497205913067, 0.00826058629900217, -0.03988761827349663, 0.021630557253956795, -0.016652775928378105, 0.004444172605872154, -0.019013606011867523, 0.021297195926308632, -0.07730454951524734, -0.00635226396843791, -0.042132046073675156, -0.02555338852107525, -0.0063466159626841545, 0.004054914228618145, 0.040709082037210464, -0.03686034679412842, 0.023754151538014412, 0.045088618993759155, -0.007045511621981859, -0.02258473075926304, 0.000781854847446084, 0.022213878110051155, 0.042621977627277374, 0.05834849178791046, 0.04077047482132912, 0.006810388527810574, -0.008596609346568584, 0.05629012733697891, 0.006130985915660858, 0.0677020251750946, 0.04154622182250023, -0.020585743710398674, -0.028121618553996086, -0.0513441376388073, -0.018148092553019524, -0.00864105299115181, 0.02762557752430439, 0.0025912688579410315, -0.0005650380626320839, 0.03506401926279068, 0.0017472825711593032, -0.0313754566013813, 0.004281259141862392, 0.037945706397295, -0.0032284785993397236, 0.004144005943089724, -0.03137309476733208, -0.0349186435341835, -0.0026476909406483173, -0.017374243587255478, 0.0687565803527832, -0.013528218492865562, -0.014219945296645164, 0.011880590580403805, 0.046795956790447235, -0.04464666545391083, -0.010624672286212444, -0.013698982074856758, 0.05143246799707413, 0.02471480518579483, -0.0031036362051963806, -0.057946279644966125, 0.00806092657148838, 0.050849635154008865, 0.030584372580051422, 0.044045571237802505, 0.01026445534080267, -0.07558712363243103, -0.0034026778303086758, 0.03864767774939537, -0.012653440237045288, -0.02328062616288662, 0.015293638221919537, -0.032954733818769455, -0.010842205956578255, 0.0467105470597744, -0.012702953070402145, 0.006915058474987745, -0.02310153655707836, 0.006568398326635361, -0.0189493577927351, 0.0049022650346159935, 0.0012520111631602049, 0.01736176200211048, -0.010428034700453281, 0.0332963690161705, -0.01879563182592392, -0.009936648420989513, -0.036247026175260544, 0.007211409974843264, -0.005053621716797352, 0.06394088268280029, -0.00476945610716939, -0.003500816412270069, -0.010702285915613174, 0.057375695556402206, 0.015522465109825134, -0.042716484516859055, 0.014454232528805733, 0.007837047800421715, -0.012205570936203003, 0.09569226205348969, -0.007241052575409412, -0.02108493074774742, 0.033654987812042236, 0.025128765031695366, -0.036088649183511734, -0.0028632155153900385, 0.015475749038159847, 0.034060556441545486, 0.03316327929496765, -0.0007314938702620566, 0.04808841273188591, 0.01716454327106476, -0.0159576665610075, -0.026273861527442932, -0.025939414277672768, 0.05259908735752106, -0.03481138497591019, -0.022384827956557274, -0.03832191601395607, -0.015953481197357178, -0.025036819279193878, 0.0024954054970294237, 0.003741682041436434, 0.022428056225180626, -0.027776235714554787, -0.01035011000931263, 0.0021831996273249388, 0.04324478656053543, 0.012830249965190887, 0.009694651700556278, -0.00041800702456384897, 0.04185311868786812, 0.02765645645558834, -0.06201295182108879, -0.0010091005824506283, 0.010012811049818993, -0.005872220266610384, -0.015672948211431503, -0.008745265193283558, -0.012264597229659557, -0.05957946553826332, -0.03310704603791237, 0.028939759358763695, -0.020814528688788414, 0.022640669718384743, -0.01773587428033352, 0.010146484710276127, 0.003246065229177475, -0.06633008271455765, -0.016645541414618492, -0.006306713446974754, -0.013617007061839104, 0.048469677567481995, -0.03863443806767464, 0.022060658782720566, -0.005668077617883682, 0.024932341650128365, -0.09821043908596039, -0.02226254716515541, 0.04235732555389404, -0.002877230290323496, -0.011853226460516453, -0.06935837119817734, 0.010165791027247906, -0.04583767428994179, -0.02340039610862732, -0.00897262990474701, 0.06917881965637207, -0.03398296609520912, -0.011075826361775398, 0.020459551364183426, 0.001561377546750009, 0.06987955421209335, -0.004006728995591402, -0.015347251668572426, 0.024947144091129303, -0.013839065097272396, -0.0339413657784462, -0.005566730163991451, 0.032071396708488464, -0.025801219046115875, 0.03350818529725075, -0.0417524091899395, -0.01895204745233059, 0.01896817423403263, -0.012533701956272125, -0.009975209832191467, 0.004983276128768921, 0.04305408149957657, 0.013812035322189331, -0.018755009397864342, -0.023333899676799774, 0.013778840191662312, 0.022908274084329605, -0.012396029196679592, -0.0248936228454113, 0.01658271811902523, 0.019315380603075027, 0.0523165799677372, -0.00838453508913517, 0.025263356044888496, 0.04545009136199951, 0.06467635929584503, -0.02230158820748329, 0.003245897823944688, 0.010317905806005001, -0.010820839554071426, 0.009833724237978458, -0.006044208537787199, 0.009294608607888222, 0.033824484795331955, 0.03492942452430725, -0.03788268193602562, -0.010419225320219994, -0.05720154196023941, -0.0010504915844649076, 0.09317967295646667, -0.040451779961586, 0.06402584910392761, 0.02313104458153248, 0.005625835619866848, 0.013401763513684273, -0.04430106282234192, 0.0023091458715498447, 0.004006880335509777, -0.05914590507745743, 0.039553917944431305, 0.014450933784246445, -0.02069985680282116, -0.004672263748943806, 0.010752004571259022, 0.017546214163303375, 0.0025398824363946915, 0.0009450149373151362, 0.06630974262952805, -0.010960235260426998, -0.010333552025258541, -0.04513004049658775, 0.03917597606778145, -0.01675591804087162, 0.01704798825085163, -0.027595601975917816, -0.0155477961525321, 0.03991764411330223, 0.028118697926402092, -0.025126708671450615, -0.03437301144003868, -0.010818122886121273, -0.056003667414188385, 0.04599686339497566, 0.011351585388183594, -0.039562322199344635, 0.017336076125502586, 0.011368224397301674, 0.007180239073932171, 0.02069300226867199, -0.012945164926350117, -0.03824364021420479, -0.05993502587080002, -0.03720908984541893, -0.05334590747952461, -0.04016854614019394, 0.0210128016769886, 0.026498377323150635, -0.07487104088068008, 0.02691766619682312, -0.01259705051779747, 0.0317867211997509, 0.005251498427242041, 0.010141745209693909, -0.011033184826374054, 0.11958496272563934, 0.02314852550625801, 0.009579543955624104, -0.024514639750123024, 0.00508820079267025, 0.10628831386566162, 0.07586324214935303, 0.006001023575663567, -0.08850265294313431, 0.01592077687382698, -0.02223864197731018, -0.015485242009162903, -0.028045428916811943, 0.019359569996595383, 0.01315559633076191, 0.015506542287766933, 0.02645316906273365, 0.04297115281224251, 0.03783230483531952, 0.008290777914226055, 0.08151299506425858, -0.033409394323825836, -0.02990841306746006, 0.004088869784027338, 0.0014210982481017709, -0.008148840628564358, 0.0038364334031939507, -0.06625820696353912, 0.02809462882578373, -0.03144150227308273, 0.022876624017953873, -0.025267090648412704, -0.020343182608485222, 0.007144693285226822, 0.013357866555452347, 0.005566680803894997, -0.009347356855869293, -0.0007979725487530231, -0.011422837153077126, -0.026991097256541252, 0.017925037071108818, 0.0105940205976367, -0.010402468964457512, 0.0023166597820818424, -0.00808634702116251, -0.0069761271588504314, 0.008493305183947086, -0.016165854409337044, 0.0032652721274644136, -0.021649004891514778, -0.005026114173233509, -0.03962099924683571, 0.04289543628692627, -0.01772535778582096, 0.013943158090114594, 0.009120034985244274, 0.02032933570444584, 0.008692658506333828, -0.041296131908893585, -0.006906378082931042, -0.009609377011656761, 0.03058173693716526, -0.022315798327326775, -0.021767353639006615, -0.043622180819511414, 0.04341349005699158, -0.012865816242992878, 0.05432528257369995, 0.0295365359634161, -0.01934170164167881, 0.01196384709328413, -0.018161507323384285, 0.05862283706665039, -0.01964273303747177, -0.014173891395330429, 0.015117422677576542, -0.01019827090203762, -0.010019434615969658, -0.027502045035362244, 0.033024922013282776, -0.013657120987772942, 0.038764532655477524, -0.015765361487865448, 0.0005829273140989244, 0.004670597147196531, -0.03641771525144577, 0.03777673467993736, -0.022981425747275352, 0.005530169233679771, -0.023232704028487206, -0.008495050482451916, 0.03748294338583946, 0.058949656784534454, 0.03999263793230057, 0.02680325321853161, -0.054472602903842926, 0.0006623002118431032, 0.005582632962614298, -0.05680794268846512, -0.0017209528014063835, -0.0038379414472728968, -0.03673839569091797, -0.02386648952960968, -0.005258044693619013, 0.04127989709377289, 0.05247296020388603, 0.03305415064096451, -0.01648424193263054, 0.03658711910247803, -0.014163241721689701, -0.005337230861186981, -0.019821301102638245, -0.03228604421019554, -0.012155297212302685, 0.012053478509187698, 0.011589862406253815, -0.04074432700872421, 0.002967802109196782, -0.006136876530945301, 0.012832204811275005, 0.004440574906766415, -0.02217734605073929, -0.037681519985198975, -0.005482364445924759, -0.026769811287522316, 0.048476193100214005, -0.01874469220638275, -0.012606164440512657, -0.041050106287002563, 0.01683407835662365, -0.012964647263288498, -0.020783500745892525, 0.0036318479105830193, -0.030688129365444183, 0.024162521585822105, -0.0057713924907147884, 0.04707891866564751, 0.00207474990747869, 0.03927447646856308, 0.012651033699512482, 0.03402366489171982, -0.03787142038345337, 0.05603708699345589, -0.04625062644481659, -0.006151404697448015, 0.036878716200590134, -0.04452311247587204, -0.06611216068267822, 0.025570135563611984, 0.003677572589367628, 0.053659986704587936, -0.0010103114182129502, -0.013969703577458858, -0.05133208632469177, 0.0633600577712059, -0.025341859087347984, 0.011626319959759712, -0.04026727005839348, 0.002769824117422104, -0.004228364676237106, -0.04031975194811821, 0.02877764403820038, 0.01355618704110384, -0.001689644530415535, 0.00410275487229228, 0.034857019782066345, -0.0046248347498476505, -0.005945677403360605, 0.028613625094294548, -0.02152378484606743, -0.0021514559630304575, 0.026260310783982277, 0.008957833051681519, 0.04202946275472641, 0.06385921686887741, -0.006650232244282961, 0.004397864453494549, -0.007859171368181705, 0.026901375502347946, -0.07125604897737503, 0.011859221383929253, 0.016667727380990982, -0.02578008733689785, 0.05071874335408211, -0.05467020720243454, -0.000199261266971007, 0.05133761465549469, -0.054291993379592896, 0.01308268029242754, 0.012843296863138676, -0.019849956035614014, -0.03508097678422928, 0.03728875890374184, -0.03260372206568718, 0.05402122810482979, 0.02613728865981102, 0.017493341118097305, 0.026255935430526733, 0.03946618735790253, 0.009566642343997955, 0.010258406400680542, -0.016481660306453705, 0.016979830339550972, -0.0015322500839829445, -0.026697102934122086, 0.05170368403196335, -0.02430594712495804, -0.016647037118673325, 0.023579899221658707, -0.029730984941124916, -0.017630767077207565, 0.013010812923312187, 0.02717382274568081, 0.008017836138606071, 0.0048295315355062485, 0.027417665347456932, -0.0026955760549753904, 0.006889618933200836, -0.011471870355308056, 0.023822786286473274, 0.015464195050299168, -0.006156482268124819, 0.024194272235035896, 0.012599365785717964, -0.03403361141681671, -0.02532925270497799, 0.03380076587200165, 0.0010589216835796833, -0.028218945488333702, 0.01837533712387085, 0.006712140515446663, 0.016571765765547752, -0.024053961038589478, 0.02850169688463211, -0.048557598143815994, 0.005087263882160187, 0.04071934521198273, -0.0056015546433627605, -0.029926933348178864, -0.01199523638933897, 0.008196806535124779, -0.053227394819259644, 0.0055705346167087555, -0.010694925673305988, -0.016886934638023376, -0.03074096143245697, -0.004345767665654421, 0.019956281408667564, -0.023677650839090347, -0.017483891919255257, -0.006318969652056694, -0.04608970507979393, 0.03773786500096321, 0.008218028582632542, 0.016573868691921234, 0.0052560786716639996, -0.005049985367804766, -0.011890978552401066, -0.06997306644916534, 0.08140741288661957, -0.031381912529468536, -0.04597228392958641, -0.040385231375694275, -0.009519103914499283, 0.005467562470585108, -0.01862003467977047, 0.03178386390209198, -0.017498601227998734, 0.021346349269151688, 0.004423179198056459, 0.03429359942674637, 0.011438575573265553, -0.037918571382761, 0.015194245614111423, 0.007402058225125074, -0.028449954465031624, 0.0031638150103390217, -0.04793988913297653, -0.01394149474799633, 0.03541060909628868, -0.025015974417328835, 0.010397308506071568, 0.014510232023894787, -0.0069763693027198315, 0.006978215649724007, 0.03674769401550293, 0.0445244126021862, 0.0030652324203401804, 0.07118736952543259, -0.04527578130364418, -0.002496392698958516, 0.029576130211353302, 0.01172272115945816, -0.01372476201504469, 0.03746994957327843, -0.037731561809778214, -0.03047122247517109, -0.005216068588197231, -0.004255366511642933, -0.0007947647827677429, -0.05687498301267624, -0.048368778079748154, 0.038425445556640625, -0.07064008712768555, -0.003359955968335271, 0.0488349087536335, 0.01851789280772209, 0.026134654879570007, 0.0021990868262946606, 0.003958818968385458, 0.01194150373339653, -0.0003797852841671556, -0.003917509689927101, 0.038039471954107285, 0.02064822055399418, -0.0027503983583301306, -0.0026037474162876606, 0.013195746578276157, -0.017355551943182945, 0.026785681024193764, -0.01695861853659153, 0.02596018835902214, -0.03140167146921158, -0.023369276896119118, -0.01379574928432703, -0.0013338978169485927, 0.0008908382151275873, 0.00023906570277176797, -0.0062895664013922215, 0.0467059388756752, -0.038745708763599396, -0.015555091202259064, -0.006220930255949497, 0.014943464659154415, -0.008706890046596527, -0.02398848347365856, 0.006342243868857622, 0.021799687296152115, -0.003307882696390152, -0.007109167519956827, -0.004653443582355976, 0.013947827741503716, 0.039165038615465164, -0.010920500382781029, 0.031100869178771973, -0.015198948793113232, -0.014011040329933167, 0.01709529012441635, -0.014529363252222538, -0.016108905896544456, -0.007491915952414274, -0.006036880426108837, 0.03895476087927818, 0.03285818547010422, 0.016713153570890427, -0.03784951940178871, -0.014761495403945446, 0.03450456261634827, -0.10171608626842499, 0.0009464247268624604, -0.021497203037142754, 0.0061717564240098, 0.011502290144562721, -0.005185709800571203 ]
<p>I wanted to know what the <em>n.minobsinnode</em> parameter means in the GBM package. I read the manual, but it is not clear what it does. Should that number be small or large to improve the results? </p>
49,224
[ 0.028294645249843597, -0.025299135595560074, 0.008606483228504658, -0.011631786823272705, 0.006357279606163502, -0.007117086090147495, -0.05463540926575661, -0.07365180552005768, -0.010473638772964478, -0.0072538903914391994, 0.0446339026093483, 0.043163444846868515, 0.01941538415849209, 0.05274101346731186, 0.0016807924257591367, -0.020806778222322464, -0.034381333738565445, -0.015771200880408287, 0.029746297746896744, -0.04383602738380432, -0.027192844077944756, 0.007955636829137802, 0.022780129685997963, -0.035692472010850906, 0.007034305017441511, 0.015498176217079163, -0.003271290333941579, -0.005607032682746649, -0.0056321341544389725, 0.009762085974216461, -0.054925963282585144, -0.015019235201179981, -0.004701314028352499, 0.03225298225879669, 0.01979638636112213, 0.015078868716955185, -0.0354250930249691, -0.023441461846232414, -0.018366394564509392, 0.011515838094055653, -0.03284843638539314, 0.05053544044494629, 0.03703468665480614, 0.01738489419221878, -0.012134019285440445, 0.03489580377936363, 0.002699335338547826, -0.02741076610982418, 0.0669737383723259, -0.03693745285272598, 0.04914766177535057, 0.052143361419439316, 0.03664286434650421, 0.004134712740778923, -0.017438814043998718, 0.010367734357714653, 0.05330974608659744, 0.07274491339921951, -0.0035610299091786146, -0.01299974787980318, 0.002417294541373849, -0.05655428394675255, 0.00407155929133296, -0.008200693875551224, 0.004480904899537563, 0.021214338019490242, 0.00827440619468689, -0.05566010996699333, 0.0046724011190235615, 0.007812464609742165, 0.003657434368506074, -0.0010583930416032672, 0.0275784432888031, -0.04193928837776184, 0.03678833320736885, -0.003566696308553219, -0.0037901229225099087, -0.006462573539465666, -0.0012300827074795961, 0.02575717493891716, -0.007012436632066965, 0.00020715226128231734, -0.006061837542802095, -0.0009087068610824645, -0.03723860904574394, -0.020721690729260445, 0.06812690198421478, -0.010233031585812569, 0.04260152578353882, 0.017080411314964294, -0.0692618191242218, 0.029226012527942657, 0.059247590601444244, 0.0064470297656953335, -0.042416051030159, 0.026352306827902794, -0.003632791806012392, 0.013625327497720718, -0.02167104370892048, -0.0193313080817461, -0.03191521018743515, -0.03286239504814148, 0.0006884637987241149, 0.07757642865180969, -0.03664782643318176, 0.007576632313430309, -0.009457054547965527, -0.021947285160422325, -0.02295098453760147, -0.00860549882054329, -0.028780672699213028, -0.027699504047632217, -0.008520304225385189, -0.0008181341108866036, 0.03713713586330414, -0.027418063953518867, 0.04727497324347496, -0.009515977464616299, 0.013360732235014439, 0.03375690430402756, 0.03445345535874367, -0.006224791519343853, 0.007578624412417412, -0.03158237040042877, -0.0750008150935173, 0.005681861657649279, 0.016667431220412254, -0.012022587470710278, -0.04795699194073677, 0.027252906933426857, 0.027736013755202293, 0.004134790040552616, 0.03016633167862892, 0.0025774554815143347, 0.014888366684317589, -0.002701610792428255, -0.054439738392829895, -0.049384765326976776, 0.08757325261831284, -0.013369252905249596, 0.005774675402790308, -0.11096832901239395, -0.0254378579556942, 0.015783829614520073, 0.061094388365745544, 0.007752404548227787, 0.036300115287303925, 0.015440106391906738, -0.002595949452370405, 0.023683251813054085, -0.0316271148622036, -0.02679295837879181, -0.02016775868833065, -0.03195332735776901, -0.024294685572385788, -0.07118372619152069, 0.02318151853978634, 0.0207393579185009, -0.023293711245059967, -0.016110198572278023, 0.04451945796608925, -0.019398359581828117, 0.010334334336221218, -0.009484969079494476, -0.0035014282912015915, -0.046300068497657776, 0.07588887214660645, 0.04147178307175636, 0.038304176181554794, 0.012228530831634998, 0.007766054477542639, 0.03348032385110855, 0.006587394513189793, -0.007599081844091415, 0.05126950517296791, -0.0065257060341537, 0.01180837769061327, -0.018890459090471268, 0.033180903643369675, 0.03313513100147247, -0.01611528918147087, 0.0013673631474375725, 0.04413361847400665, 0.015571033582091331, -0.013545764610171318, 0.010501871816813946, -0.012469522655010223, 0.011715412139892578, 0.055341217666864395, -0.030098972842097282, -0.041078176349401474, -0.04692671820521355, 0.000658363220281899, 0.0074914549477398396, -0.034157346934080124, 0.030605988577008247, -0.006846690084785223, 0.004429712891578674, 0.005419943016022444, 0.00891029741615057, -0.019763633608818054, 0.010029981844127178, 0.03952613100409508, -0.041104719042778015, -0.012767835520207882, 0.024371877312660217, 0.014422313310205936, -0.006060499232262373, 0.038778260350227356, -0.06211574748158455, -0.021127590909600258, 0.02622271329164505, -0.04052457585930824, -0.00583378691226244, -0.012361076660454273, -0.02548777125775814, 0.01620171219110489, 0.007032741792500019, 0.017674073576927185, 0.015058682300150394, -0.03705797716975212, 0.049882180988788605, 0.06830787658691406, 0.016681071370840073, -0.014193400740623474, 0.006667525041848421, 0.012851916253566742, 0.010168072767555714, 0.01132185198366642, -0.02633604221045971, -0.04097463935613632, -0.04823317751288414, 0.036628615111112595, 0.019256267696619034, -0.021083619445562363, 0.008235775865614414, 0.0759819895029068, -0.01890907809138298, 0.020952729508280754, 0.007874052040278912, 0.025302520021796227, -0.03213394805788994, 0.013695714995265007, 0.054103199392557144, -0.004530911799520254, 0.04230327531695366, 0.014678278006613255, 0.015337829478085041, 0.035861510783433914, 0.02076602168381214, -0.019189245998859406, 0.029182173311710358, 0.03911348059773445, -0.0001765340712154284, -0.032145123928785324, 0.002696444047614932, 0.0445266030728817, -0.04266227036714554, 0.012197352945804596, 0.07022982835769653, -0.014194028452038765, -0.03347824513912201, 0.004081511404365301, -0.018357841297984123, 0.026265403255820274, 0.028566518798470497, -0.016117706894874573, -0.001075816573575139, 0.02931595966219902, -0.08742526173591614, 0.03236525505781174, -0.04453755170106888, 0.008593418635427952, -0.042734112590551376, 0.007888729684054852, 0.049381036311388016, 0.017150018364191055, 0.051088232547044754, -0.02827487327158451, -0.03687291219830513, -0.028344636783003807, 0.01934644766151905, 0.017318153753876686, -0.026730945333838463, -0.034675486385822296, -0.03264102712273598, -0.021371252834796906, 0.0006172037101350725, -0.0038274277467280626, 0.0012394202640280128, 0.012889191508293152, 0.006324209272861481, -0.002298295497894287, 0.0012956028804183006, -0.033337078988552094, 0.009008717723190784, 0.010579261928796768, -0.03407491371035576, -0.021547216922044754, 0.028962286189198494, 0.01910734921693802, 0.0025667226873338223, 0.00567759620025754, -0.031394340097904205, -0.022470081225037575, -0.05087409168481827, 0.0008170795626938343, 0.035337720066308975, -0.0006849208730272949, -0.00918505061417818, 0.018443860113620758, 0.0282211322337389, 0.019980939105153084, -0.08232700824737549, -0.05762454867362976, 0.015541080385446548, -0.004211922641843557, -0.0005757063045166433, -0.031689081341028214, -0.018752191215753555, 0.1041102334856987, 0.04320317134261131, -0.05160897597670555, -0.02334020659327507, -0.042587652802467346, -0.007246905006468296, -0.05423598736524582, 0.029405387118458748, 0.04574102908372879, 0.019524024799466133, 0.011450078338384628, 0.009338732808828354, 0.020800719037652016, 0.07909936457872391, 0.006158010568469763, 0.007255525328218937, 0.0145875234156847, -0.00600062170997262, -0.024537213146686554, 0.04861892759799957, 0.017364755272865295, -0.012565464712679386, 0.03138289973139763, -0.053065016865730286, 0.006488322280347347, -0.016895290464162827, -0.04238073527812958, 0.0354832224547863, 0.016524259001016617, 0.022552870213985443, -0.0011214616242796183, 0.00003806127278949134, 0.001593431574292481, -0.04090721905231476, -0.010034999810159206, -0.0011584263993427157, 0.036047909408807755, -0.013375510461628437, -0.013493169099092484, 0.026399647817015648, -0.0024618490133434534, -0.00048014475032687187, 0.008448649197816849, 0.009361917153000832, -0.03174317628145218, -0.0010383008047938347, -0.03224245831370354, -0.01334512047469616, 0.008234991692006588, 0.06370027363300323, 0.015936128795146942, 0.003115384140983224, -0.036021921783685684, -0.018033068627119064, -0.056984566152095795, -0.014066222123801708, -0.017473405227065086, 0.022505799308419228, -0.01644773595035076, 0.04123860225081444, 0.0026482741814106703, 0.03880750760436058, 0.007353504654020071, -0.012650524266064167, -0.08311351388692856, 0.042601507157087326, 0.012287188321352005, -0.013544423505663872, 0.013865028508007526, -0.02899392880499363, 0.04642374813556671, -0.003433338599279523, -0.0008698685560375452, 0.018936755135655403, 0.04418719932436943, -0.054207123816013336, 0.035263799130916595, -0.011046601459383965, 0.01102644857019186, -0.02491246908903122, 0.022646300494670868, 0.03864645957946777, -0.02318793348968029, -0.060036756098270416, 0.017591824755072594, -0.026636933907866478, -0.03574121743440628, -0.009899774566292763, 0.01590590737760067, -0.02108119986951351, 0.045640505850315094, -0.010812997817993164, 0.03893497958779335, -0.055951423943042755, 0.03233571723103523, 0.05753638595342636, 0.05194377154111862, 0.03312559798359871, 0.02122664451599121, 0.0077298348769545555, -0.036310482770204544, -0.0058598993346095085, 0.02616044506430626, 0.014619848690927029, -0.0202549546957016, -0.031010495498776436, 0.0684008076786995, 0.029048971831798553, -0.010594635270535946, 0.02126733586192131, 0.08777587860822678, 0.018041439354419708, -0.01695091836154461, -0.06975527852773666, -0.016204072162508965, 0.009136977605521679, 0.004821004346013069, 0.016472024843096733, 0.021545466035604477, -0.026957787573337555, -0.007028321735560894, 0.018082670867443085, -0.030943715944886208, -0.020899225026369095, -0.029805947095155716, 0.022797849029302597, 0.04109371080994606, -0.035936951637268066, 0.052282582968473434, -0.008752632886171341, 0.00866689532995224, 0.03259304538369179, 0.019796311855316162, -0.005173501092940569, -0.07122840732336044, -0.011125463992357254, 0.060106974095106125, 0.034119896590709686, -0.025242049247026443, -0.0007365243509411812, -0.08021171391010284, -0.019642874598503113, 0.0059700170531868935, -0.02001802809536457, 0.009388871490955353, 0.02210875414311886, 0.004995441995561123, -0.03300261124968529, -0.0026601534336805344, -0.008617326617240906, -0.002427028026431799, -0.014714005403220654, 0.006904028356075287, -0.03919714316725731, -0.015685055404901505, -0.00018086767522618175, 0.02652890793979168, -0.02532164566218853, 0.06373414397239685, -0.024791628122329712, 0.002673266688361764, 0.05532632768154144, 0.010028827004134655, -0.03976539894938469, -0.054878268390893936, 0.015682296827435493, 0.013200242072343826, 0.0061221858486533165, 0.039436403661966324, -0.02167726866900921, -0.04468144103884697, 0.04685908928513527, 0.04457385092973709, -0.03924112394452095, -0.04595528542995453, -0.021822545677423477, 0.045043136924505234, 0.020237088203430176, -0.025769716128706932, 0.050552353262901306, -0.037991806864738464, -0.0037830143701285124, 0.004575877916067839, -0.0647403821349144, 0.07955121248960495, -0.0009801752166822553, -0.0066617392003536224, -0.023871101438999176, -0.024901462718844414, -0.00989634357392788, 0.040465641766786575, 0.05632670223712921, 0.05793832987546921, 0.004427789710462093, -0.04667096957564354, 0.02621009200811386, 0.03474796935915947, 0.00656508281826973, 0.016491016373038292, 0.05475256219506264, 0.006387681234627962, 0.03120698779821396, 0.023707816377282143, -0.004453092813491821, -0.05514002963900566, 0.029246855527162552, 0.05782962217926979, -0.012015222571790218, 0.023171763867139816, -0.014541988261044025, -0.028625525534152985, 0.03574490547180176, -0.008987321518361568, 0.03808857873082161, 0.02981938049197197, 0.004539702087640762, 0.05922041833400726, -0.04965054616332054, -0.012771716341376305, 0.004175660200417042, -0.03198060393333435, 0.020426737144589424, -0.0710299164056778, -0.00469888374209404, 0.017613040283322334, 0.045779842883348465, -0.029317868873476982, -0.06127968430519104, 0.05415638908743858, -0.0007976518245413899, 0.018268467858433723, -0.03045814111828804, -0.012768115848302841, 0.03042471595108509, -0.012444586493074894, 0.0008938249666243792, 0.024469943717122078, 0.01912609487771988, -0.03696925938129425, -0.006499702110886574, 0.041607145220041275, 0.056199800223112106, 0.03170546516776085, -0.005010339897125959, 0.027642298489809036, 0.002737426431849599, -0.02119334414601326, 0.025088481605052948, 0.017040327191352844, -0.020832309499382973, -0.02369704470038414, -0.035798706114292145, 0.009798860177397728, 0.055564723908901215, -0.027400193735957146, -0.019797056913375854, 0.024434704333543777, -0.01319166086614132, 0.04332762956619263, -0.006386071443557739, -0.03904382884502411, -0.04074695333838463, 0.005148676224052906, 0.0029786676168441772, 0.03694409132003784, 0.005089384503662586, -0.0160387996584177, 0.04759484902024269, 0.012469148263335228, 0.0019540125504136086, 0.012630276381969452, 0.06753304600715637, -0.014788290485739708, 0.027457259595394135, 0.05535491928458214, -0.04115266352891922, 0.0134090855717659, 0.03657468035817146, 0.01510495413094759, 0.026791181415319443, 0.023088723421096802, -0.03413444384932518, -0.03758901730179787, -0.03085516393184662, 0.020393457263708115, 0.043048419058322906, 0.0011038898956030607, 0.052531953901052475, 0.015006094239652157, -0.036266252398490906, -0.016464002430438995, -0.0184774287045002, -0.009418151341378689, -0.009895367547869682, -0.015283993445336819, 0.05437580496072769, -0.022863497957587242, -0.038872361183166504, 0.006463934667408466, 0.016006076708436012, -0.04509563371539116, -0.00012564762437250465, 0.041248902678489685, 0.023240918293595314, -0.01830701157450676, -0.04015147686004639, -0.05336524918675423, 0.07177280634641647, 0.01942926086485386, 0.06305809319019318, -0.01876949332654476, -0.015454346314072609, 0.023657428100705147, 0.018992794677615166, 0.03462415188550949, -0.013251951895654202, -0.014944961294531822, -0.015303279273211956, -0.010471131652593613, 0.04325644671916962, -0.08586863428354263, 0.0038055498152971268, 0.007964882999658585, 0.029040981084108353, 0.005162428133189678, 0.03232154995203018, -0.032724570482969284, -0.06617017835378647, -0.021870939061045647, 0.016140542924404144, -0.059450142085552216, 0.030408961698412895, -0.023124219849705696, -0.020973747596144676, 0.03455112874507904, -0.015643959864974022, 0.009400366805493832, -0.012816001661121845, 0.04099924489855766, 0.007041652221232653, 0.07848851382732391, 0.0018728278810158372, -0.0201591644436121, 0.02365068905055523, 0.008015302009880543, 0.16335725784301758, 0.04218615964055061, 0.01689000055193901, -0.06482195854187012, -0.010809406638145447, -0.017552345991134644, -0.0075623998418450356, -0.00012182228965684772, -0.012009319849312305, -0.004020020831376314, -0.027104638516902924, 0.03360987827181816, -0.013596886768937111, -0.014895410276949406, -0.011765241622924805, 0.0006871881196275353, -0.0144926393404603, -0.035983648151159286, 0.059028610587120056, 0.020435288548469543, -0.015650514513254166, -0.016021473333239555, -0.04196866601705551, 0.032412976026535034, 0.019432971253991127, -0.03346085548400879, -0.012343062087893486, -0.015067782253026962, 0.006101447623223066, 0.0006607557297684252, -0.0052086226642131805, -0.009382020682096481, 0.02865736000239849, -0.0059925466775894165, 0.034148406237363815, 0.010259512811899185, 0.009924277663230896, 0.027310039848089218, -0.002827717922627926, 0.006188197527080774, -0.00989228580147028, 0.0018325528362765908, -0.010191577486693859, 0.006369514856487513, -0.05079864338040352, -0.02715040184557438, 0.035127539187669754, 0.030142124742269516, -0.007663705851882696, -0.02076462283730507, -0.004904711153358221, 0.007306420709937811, -0.004858360160142183, -0.039853934198617935, 0.00973615050315857, 0.035199787467718124, 0.021770276129245758, -0.03712357208132744, -0.023275919258594513, 0.005664619151502848, 0.016550423577427864, -0.03252553194761276, -0.007477929349988699, 0.005948206875473261, -0.015222526155412197, 0.029915304854512215, -0.014650500379502773, 0.022890640422701836, -0.038170624524354935, -0.030911874026060104, -0.03563182055950165, -0.01928464137017727, -0.011847422458231449, -0.0008337294566445053, -0.024019327014684677, 0.009186854586005211, 0.018877657130360603, -0.029146049171686172, -0.019389834254980087, 0.01099022850394249, -0.034635432064533234, 0.05244402214884758, -0.0012181417550891638, -0.024241192266345024, -0.0013818693114444613, -0.018102210015058517, 0.0031180442310869694, 0.02205176092684269, -0.018174700438976288, 0.04667956009507179, -0.01127668283879757, 0.08506102114915848, 0.012207365594804287, -0.03247014805674553, -0.02296873740851879, 0.029660427942872047, -0.03783256933093071, -0.023807626217603683, 0.0012865329626947641, 0.0442860946059227, -0.018927164375782013, 0.022176841273903847, 0.043115708976984024, 0.04442205652594566, -0.03036300651729107, 0.0107377078384161, 0.011844543740153313, -0.03922542557120323, 0.007302784360945225, 0.0084468899294734, -0.0330478809773922, -0.04056774079799652, 0.0040190634317696095, -0.0021757236681878567, -0.020245404914021492, 0.05817531421780586, 0.0016376542625948787, -0.045321132987737656, 0.0033604097552597523, -0.007974118925631046, -0.021524492651224136, -0.028407741338014603, -0.023943031206727028, -0.0007414959254674613, 0.018794745206832886, -0.023009557276964188, 0.01804036647081375, 0.027116313576698303, 0.0127877751365304, -0.012515903450548649, -0.05104227364063263, 0.013503463007509708, 0.012751941569149494, 0.049146588891744614, 0.03488253057003021, -0.024906564503908157, 0.01784655451774597, 0.07127117365598679, 0.008102762512862682, -0.02952398918569088, 0.019344739615917206, -0.06012788787484169, -0.04795775189995766, 0.011956772767007351, -0.02310146763920784, 0.003855394432321191, 0.00990477204322815, -0.037526365369558334, -0.04602416232228279, 0.03558521345257759, -0.04371919110417366, -0.03323423117399216, -0.01367062609642744, -0.009440640918910503, -0.0008702162303961813, -0.04488731175661087, -0.034181732684373856, 0.005345542915165424, 0.019578594714403152, 0.008615626022219658, -0.003552937414497137, -0.020019039511680603, 0.004055153578519821, -0.0024779578670859337, -0.02090448886156082, -0.04372839629650116, -0.006881145294755697, 0.0055421567521989346, 0.010544504038989544, 0.07218217104673386, -0.029298530891537666, 0.019817864522337914, -0.04125972464680672, 0.018654635176062584, -0.055027879774570465, -0.04945434257388115, -0.030190743505954742, -0.01294998824596405, 0.03314811736345291, -0.03884870186448097, 0.016749968752264977, 0.017931349575519562, -0.026172013953328133, 0.011070537380874157, -0.026415489614009857, -0.03015611134469509, -0.06977719813585281, -0.046208277344703674, 0.002815276151522994, 0.016385098919272423, 0.02492203563451767, -0.00939962174743414, 0.04415557533502579, 0.0017176661640405655, -0.03053934872150421, -0.038694556802511215, -0.007001725025475025, 0.027167804539203644, -0.019445672631263733, -0.032933156937360764, -0.005798507947474718, -0.021165184676647186, -0.03362049162387848, 0.01911023072898388, -0.03761252760887146, 0.020509148016572, 0.01742139458656311, 0.035507503896951675, 0.013186728581786156, 0.06387549638748169, 0.04632439836859703, -0.042462464421987534, -0.020185010507702827, -0.003780350089073181, 0.0035261502489447594, -0.00206380314193666, -0.009384959936141968, 0.023996170610189438, -0.001748502254486084, -0.016863830387592316, -0.029412077739834785, -0.009697332978248596, -0.010305953212082386, 0.007757363375276327, 0.006744717713445425, 0.013414246030151844, 0.008769234642386436, -0.05532647669315338, 0.0021419336553663015, -0.008554748259484768, 0.023470429703593254, 0.027660099789500237, 0.03527943417429924, -0.03050418756902218, 0.00945881474763155, -0.030300362035632133, -0.02520451880991459, 0.006528971716761589, 0.023680610582232475, -0.07124321162700653, -0.03598072752356529, -0.012268525548279285, -0.002450856612995267, 0.009310178458690643, 0.00034739781403914094, 0.008996979333460331, -0.028875716030597687, 0.025625677779316902, -0.015290593728423119, 0.023861262947320938, -0.017574334517121315, -0.02862638607621193, 0.008153238333761692, -0.08672347664833069, 0.039162758737802505, 0.006711267400532961, 0.02651495672762394, -0.019502202048897743, -0.03545428067445755, -0.021858569234609604, 0.02032499387860298, 0.05210297182202339, 0.008902479894459248, -0.03179232031106949, 0.0068374620750546455, 0.03670092299580574, 0.01874367520213127, -0.027456756681203842, 0.02140745334327221, -0.007687373552471399, -0.004537085071206093, -0.017559099942445755, -0.010535148903727531, 0.008575782179832458, 0.01723146252334118, -0.007029193453490734, -0.0018325746059417725, -0.013818603940308094, -0.00602229218930006, -0.004152470733970404, 0.05353714898228645, -0.025874771177768707, -0.005389059893786907, 0.04656585305929184, -0.01703033037483692, -0.024639856070280075, 0.029363125562667847, 0.01245225127786398, -0.07419509440660477, -0.013147846795618534, -0.0059962403029203415, -0.030446413904428482, -0.019706036895513535, 0.0494554378092289, 0.04192618280649185, -0.0030105814803391695, 0.006337221246212721, -0.0009529894450679421, 0.0031111249700188637, 0.011894728057086468, 0.04470669478178024, 0.04775162413716316, 0.06253618746995926, 0.022788405418395996, 0.012246153317391872, 0.011676246300339699, -0.025022078305482864, -0.0038727433420717716, 0.03010687790811062, -0.04042841121554375, 0.024162959307432175, 0.006328505463898182, 0.00012235349277034402, -0.02996876649558544, 0.033433061093091965, -0.005858316086232662, 0.015590681694447994, -0.007119671907275915, -0.03265589475631714, 0.025966936722397804, -0.00581327872350812, 0.030560212209820747, -0.007717549800872803, 0.007685388438403606, 0.06363685429096222, -0.03501066192984581, -0.030036814510822296, -0.03566333279013634, 0.008357406593859196, 0.00825593527406454, 0.002946697873994708, 0.0028839099686592817, 0.04326227679848671, 0.049204133450984955, 0.030346939340233803, 0.02938034199178219, -0.016133449971675873, 0.053702741861343384, -0.024423131719231606, 0.007057469338178635, 0.015843767672777176, 0.027985654771327972, 0.007667044177651405, 0.0005951874190941453, -0.04983667656779289, -0.024288978427648544, -0.030654344707727432, 0.03924303129315376, -0.019060472026467323, -0.010072086937725544, -0.008137122727930546, 0.014394211582839489, 0.034655988216400146, -0.031061429530382156, -0.013403840363025665, -0.06817100197076797, -0.011563579551875591, -0.005292873829603195, 0.017490699887275696 ]
<p>I heard that the F-test is to advice you whether to use fixed effects or pooled OLS. However, I didn't find any details about it in books. Only in a very few studies. What is the hypothesis of the test? After I run my fixed model I got</p> <pre><code>F test that all u_i=0: F(100, 389) = 2.98 Prob &gt; F = 0.0000 </code></pre> <p>As I understand <code>u_i=0</code> means I shall use fixed effect (am I right?), in general how accurate is this F-test compared to the Hausman test and LM test given the fact that we will end to knowing whether to use fixed effects or pooled OLS?</p>
7,034
[ -0.022989675402641296, 0.002840788336470723, -0.023295460268855095, -0.005243178457021713, 0.03328247740864754, 0.0162343867123127, 0.022389745339751244, -0.049873169511556625, 0.051307469606399536, -0.0550360381603241, 0.03415406867861748, -0.002901565982028842, 0.02065310813486576, -0.034521546214818954, 0.05395624414086342, 0.013517670333385468, -0.004179663956165314, -0.009159394539892673, 0.0032023978419601917, 0.015410314314067364, -0.04153881222009659, 0.03841155394911766, 0.012756451033055782, -0.016719667240977287, -0.04688446223735809, 0.029873913154006004, -0.007927428930997849, -0.026216335594654083, 0.03298366814851761, 0.05432784557342529, -0.014852669090032578, -0.0014043336268514395, -0.018331335857510567, 0.03390253707766533, -0.014611531049013138, -0.006070486735552549, -0.008762327954173088, -0.03912440314888954, -0.026677096262574196, 0.030430229380726814, -0.000011908919987035915, -0.02890162356197834, 0.028046250343322754, 0.04763031378388405, 0.014819126576185226, 0.02702980674803257, 0.00723244296386838, -0.014725436456501484, 0.016596894711256027, -0.027190137654542923, 0.06303368508815765, -0.00481899781152606, 0.03823159262537956, 0.037153325974941254, 0.017546068876981735, -0.004332424141466618, 0.07252344489097595, 0.018544035032391548, -0.015666203573346138, -0.05368713289499283, -0.04888656362891197, -0.04434651881456375, 0.00949640292674303, -0.022291099652647972, -0.03042055480182171, 0.02017812430858612, -0.015729663893580437, -0.030267173424363136, 0.06028404086828232, -0.009257066994905472, -0.016031282022595406, 0.05482872575521469, 0.03620320186018944, -0.004244159907102585, 0.032413188368082047, -0.0410575196146965, 0.00677061639726162, -0.004055197350680828, 0.02626217156648636, 0.06499575823545456, -0.019299333915114403, 0.01756982132792473, 0.03472134843468666, 0.04485675320029259, 0.04308498650789261, -0.04078217223286629, 0.03449582681059837, 0.006879981607198715, 0.020825890824198723, 0.025231368839740753, -0.01818370446562767, -0.01247193943709135, 0.07351972907781601, 0.023281347006559372, -0.05362625792622566, 0.04834607243537903, -0.009089470840990543, 0.02474180795252323, -0.007063825614750385, -0.027925312519073486, -0.0052665723487734795, -0.048002999275922775, 0.012972577475011349, 0.03828670084476471, -0.005844978149980307, -0.000595278455875814, -0.028797056525945663, 0.025216156616806984, 0.012309307232499123, -0.028711827471852303, -0.0006602269131690264, 0.03631031885743141, -0.023373769596219063, 0.0003216838522348553, 0.05312695726752281, -0.04340078681707382, 0.013424470089375973, -0.0009692386374808848, 0.03887895122170448, 0.05464989319443703, 0.059027284383773804, 0.0008621539454907179, 0.040046125650405884, 0.013207606039941311, -0.04236998036503792, 0.011326932348310947, -0.0014171574730426073, -0.012824169360101223, -0.019428206607699394, 0.08260254561901093, 0.007075291592627764, -0.016760140657424927, 0.029836032539606094, 0.013262824155390263, 0.03597041219472885, 0.01570378802716732, -0.07965593785047531, -0.05914851650595665, 0.08444996178150177, -0.020250188186764717, 0.033036477863788605, -0.042076922953128815, -0.01574760675430298, -0.006270873825997114, 0.0667215958237648, 0.015050630085170269, 0.01820356398820877, -0.03643927350640297, 0.014993024058640003, 0.012448776513338089, -0.04926833137869835, -0.045278411358594894, -0.023364346474409103, -0.013976503163576126, -0.0014528089668601751, -0.07607372850179672, -0.003308085724711418, -0.01187939289957285, 0.00745213869959116, -0.017418617382645607, 0.021031785756349564, 0.0569910928606987, 0.013895510695874691, -0.004621146246790886, -0.04546342045068741, -0.029570871964097023, 0.04348360747098923, -0.03860644996166229, 0.03320074453949928, 0.030517522245645523, -0.033865995705127716, 0.03208041563630104, 0.020040079951286316, 0.05332690104842186, -0.0014331932179629803, -0.038352832198143005, 0.01540249865502119, -0.053398650139570236, 0.03775449097156525, 0.019813520833849907, -0.0602438822388649, 0.004137885756790638, -0.019913634285330772, -0.034803833812475204, -0.015060962177813053, 0.045428141951560974, -0.011738386936485767, 0.03481593728065491, 0.060006264597177505, -0.05626481771469116, -0.054472651332616806, -0.0994625985622406, 0.018594035878777504, -0.0095737986266613, -0.029863877221941948, 0.00839315727353096, 0.009454790502786636, 0.028520436957478523, 0.003569187130779028, -0.02740934118628502, -0.0537857748568058, 0.006873082835227251, 0.01309128850698471, -0.039724189788103104, 0.04399903491139412, 0.04691217094659805, 0.02655205689370632, -0.021786842495203018, 0.03329348936676979, -0.06662505120038986, -0.017888514325022697, 0.027889780700206757, -0.03090260550379753, 0.009433265775442123, -0.015779729932546616, -0.0009979131864383817, 0.02763574756681919, -0.00590301351621747, -0.003869268111884594, -0.0015007476322352886, -0.06483256816864014, 0.05544586852192879, 0.0698016881942749, 0.03112133964896202, 0.03548280522227287, 0.0063763577491045, 0.01770712435245514, -0.02418087236583233, 0.0026072352193295956, 0.01446736790239811, -0.05303380638360977, -0.01214537676423788, 0.019387487322092056, 0.01511136069893837, -0.0007295075338333845, -0.026256302371621132, 0.06558931618928909, -0.018611695617437363, -0.00018322978576179594, 0.027173692360520363, -0.03668174520134926, -0.05550767481327057, 0.0010805693455040455, 0.039103493094444275, 0.0410049743950367, 0.02649872750043869, 0.036367714405059814, 0.03407307341694832, 0.05369304120540619, -0.013276294805109501, -0.03779657557606697, 0.053372155874967575, -0.02078375406563282, -0.0002930648915935308, 0.00048663883353583515, 0.0036371524911373854, 0.0018690063152462244, -0.029698828235268593, 0.018273048102855682, 0.014004657976329327, 0.016295256093144417, 0.009674124419689178, -0.045885346829891205, -0.0413966178894043, 0.07151134312152863, 0.002769023645669222, -0.013891409151256084, 0.0007919764029793441, 0.010808488354086876, -0.036654021590948105, -0.010346652008593082, 0.001611359533853829, -0.01051969826221466, -0.0536981038749218, 0.033969759941101074, 0.004072400741279125, -0.014239877462387085, 0.0033774508628994226, -0.006306947208940983, 0.004340305924415588, -0.013030430302023888, -0.0214118342846632, 0.014667380601167679, -0.03997280076146126, -0.05407419055700302, 0.015037355944514275, -0.011298710480332375, 0.0028712614439427853, 0.03571194037795067, -0.015650032088160515, -0.021843768656253815, 0.05291731655597687, 0.03485731780529022, -0.02473246492445469, -0.021152274683117867, 0.018467245623469353, 0.005697945598512888, -0.011637232266366482, -0.019114291295409203, 0.02082037180662155, -0.02425159141421318, -0.02518869750201702, 0.03274901956319809, -0.044911254197359085, -0.010241975076496601, -0.01407529879361391, -0.004761194810271263, 0.01696542650461197, -0.022031528875231743, 0.018813176080584526, 0.0101237827911973, -0.06524975597858429, -0.009118365123867989, -0.04840566962957382, -0.044623684138059616, 0.004304799251258373, -0.007728483062237501, -0.011901547200977802, -0.004257484804838896, -0.03743782639503479, 0.0466499850153923, 0.007434656377881765, -0.013398322276771069, -0.07477788627147675, 0.011346843093633652, -0.00020768368267454207, -0.045157674700021744, 0.008255405351519585, 0.0034762066788971424, 0.03260696306824684, 0.013914259150624275, -0.015970734879374504, 0.036543115973472595, 0.050287939608097076, 0.020016077905893326, 0.023652594536542892, 0.014250410720705986, -0.008431519381701946, -0.043628446757793427, 0.004861300811171532, 0.01740616373717785, -0.007443646434694529, 0.010845312848687172, 0.03531743586063385, 0.04038805142045021, 0.007514823693782091, -0.002223893068730831, 0.04886890947818756, -0.02954617142677307, -0.0012231656583026052, -0.012227026745676994, 0.014839394949376583, -0.03290431946516037, -0.02103576250374317, -0.028632281348109245, -0.007956769317388535, 0.01988462544977665, -0.009602689184248447, 0.03655148670077324, 0.042483314871788025, 0.025229495018720627, -0.01633419841527939, -0.022068781778216362, -0.019091876223683357, -0.020828960463404655, 0.012545653618872166, -0.006795319262892008, 0.010076264850795269, 0.0385916568338871, 0.06450705230236053, 0.028701452538371086, 0.011136766523122787, -0.00897501315921545, -0.0018749031005427241, -0.019586605951189995, 0.006892270874232054, -0.014464533887803555, 0.046047698706388474, 0.020101232454180717, 0.026283610612154007, 0.01212268602102995, -0.009056758135557175, -0.03392895311117172, -0.011542804539203644, -0.041730280965566635, 0.038595374673604965, -0.0006435106624849141, 0.01734449528157711, -0.0048868730664253235, -0.0056918165646493435, 0.0038407952524721622, 0.00031375500839203596, 0.013045019470155239, -0.02188740484416485, 0.04627393186092377, -0.04371035099029541, 0.002776101930066943, 0.03281253203749657, 0.0026067232247442007, -0.0607660748064518, -0.005984014365822077, -0.0165103729814291, -0.01984996907413006, 0.026877103373408318, 0.013834497891366482, -0.00487567950040102, -0.007897824048995972, -0.01909373514354229, -0.006229919381439686, 0.02378985285758972, 0.024842917919158936, 0.02518283575773239, 0.016674291342496872, -0.047122322022914886, 0.018713124096393585, 0.008501383475959301, 0.03640194237232208, 0.04994618520140648, -0.015011596493422985, -0.026289571076631546, -0.015295329503715038, -0.027889670804142952, 0.01345693040639162, 0.014057880267500877, 0.025362646207213402, 0.008942320942878723, 0.056719936430454254, 0.03333862125873566, -0.04573269933462143, 0.011088741011917591, 0.13020920753479004, 0.0034498271998018026, -0.02686905674636364, -0.0559183806180954, -0.025052594020962715, -0.025743454694747925, 0.034002210944890976, 0.041837505996227264, -0.001785546075552702, -0.022303972393274307, 0.0003246017440687865, 0.060434043407440186, -0.020448952913284302, -0.03490693122148514, -0.010678982362151146, 0.046256035566329956, 0.017554080113768578, 0.004255788866430521, -0.04680076241493225, 0.013913901522755623, 0.046828702092170715, 0.021577373147010803, 0.02872680127620697, 0.008106655441224575, -0.04978225380182266, 0.028672168031334877, 0.016791095957159996, 0.03296418488025665, -0.026803335174918175, 0.045362748205661774, -0.003408120246604085, 0.03298734501004219, -0.004147718660533428, -0.027936439961194992, 0.010756106115877628, -0.0104441586881876, 0.03631667420268059, -0.06759423762559891, -0.010068056173622608, -0.039645854383707047, 0.0120568061247468, -0.005798269063234329, 0.012691210024058819, -0.0201487448066473, -0.025458727031946182, -0.025596166029572487, 0.016733143478631973, -0.009361947886645794, 0.018283924087882042, -0.04761584848165512, -0.01368255726993084, 0.028492366895079613, 0.05334818363189697, -0.03545317426323891, -0.08521788567304611, 0.013801482506096363, -0.002402869053184986, 0.0055897049605846405, 0.036063987761735916, 0.0009648161358200014, -0.028531964868307114, 0.006676437333226204, 0.020506631582975388, -0.023454977199435234, -0.013890211470425129, -0.020726293325424194, 0.025073911994695663, 0.03415766730904579, -0.0011536345118656754, 0.06413740664720535, 0.022899916395545006, -0.02847468852996826, -0.016888607293367386, -0.02752331830561161, 0.030455192551016808, -0.04684034734964371, -0.003663250943645835, -0.0549158938229084, 0.018853358924388885, -0.003336899681016803, -0.007687438279390335, -0.01712656579911709, 0.016654474660754204, -0.029442673549056053, 0.0009838440455496311, -0.034116100519895554, 0.03347600996494293, -0.004409361630678177, -0.009580636397004128, 0.01365380547940731, 0.0011535717640072107, 0.005327069200575352, 0.0019506113603711128, 0.0019795787520706654, -0.03166305273771286, 0.011895115487277508, 0.0025957240723073483, 0.002898573875427246, 0.02658059634268284, 0.033777184784412384, -0.03917117789387703, 0.029115663841366768, -0.004775300156325102, 0.03093528375029564, 0.013093430548906326, -0.024064067751169205, 0.004575980361551046, -0.06539525091648102, 0.00840351078659296, 0.046305231750011444, 0.010523405857384205, 0.06316769123077393, -0.008398670703172684, 0.041736453771591187, 0.022852888330817223, 0.004099608864635229, -0.07091902941465378, -0.03769049420952797, 0.026484442874789238, -0.025874124839901924, -0.012346071191132069, -0.030707944184541702, -0.01402309536933899, -0.03796352818608284, -0.029002411291003227, -0.022673942148685455, 0.09497056156396866, -0.039839938282966614, -0.023834610357880592, -0.014213680289685726, -0.019309084862470627, 0.05755520612001419, 0.011251564137637615, -0.016422685235738754, 0.008600779809057713, -0.03284835070371628, -0.026037132367491722, 0.01509963907301426, 0.016837649047374725, -0.026772765442728996, 0.02087651565670967, -0.045827433466911316, -0.016237348318099976, 0.049329716712236404, 0.0042533851228654385, -0.018645957112312317, 0.008095428347587585, 0.0035207730252295732, 0.037765875458717346, -0.01635347120463848, 0.005956793669611216, -0.04404677823185921, 0.039076466113328934, 0.008203107863664627, 0.027590187266469002, -0.0003741471446119249, -0.011905143968760967, 0.06616430729627609, -0.03005751594901085, -0.00912943109869957, 0.038646191358566284, 0.08300981670618057, -0.005688403267413378, -0.0015681383665651083, -0.02432624064385891, -0.021359266713261604, 0.009239478036761284, 0.021082239225506783, -0.0008890125318430364, 0.003186773508787155, 0.04368266463279724, -0.0248606875538826, -0.022519197314977646, -0.007908517494797707, 0.023942235857248306, 0.04125213250517845, 0.008784023113548756, 0.022641316056251526, 0.06888678669929504, 0.017313463613390923, -0.01213340274989605, 0.002384800696745515, 0.0007617317023687065, 0.021131206303834915, -0.011860896833240986, 0.041215915232896805, 0.006678840145468712, -0.03675981983542442, 0.03583065792918205, -0.0054617514833807945, 0.017915867269039154, 0.0013916912721469998, 0.03550292178988457, 0.03776492178440094, 0.01719212532043457, -0.025692788884043694, -0.056231673806905746, 0.03662121295928955, -0.05851263552904129, 0.0028965703677386045, -0.013161005452275276, -0.03037918731570244, 0.036649156361818314, 0.03250687196850777, 0.020376216620206833, -0.07406800240278244, -0.01257413625717163, -0.053051698952913284, 0.009968576021492481, -0.0013484288938343525, -0.022374160587787628, 0.008356684818863869, 0.004730574786663055, 0.05151541903614998, 0.01570877991616726, 0.04659925401210785, 0.0034089223481714725, -0.09114396572113037, -0.05130065605044365, -0.012679841369390488, 0.010583577677607536, 0.04286941513419151, -0.050295449793338776, -0.03794677555561066, 0.01781187392771244, -0.03677159547805786, 0.00017697102157399058, -0.025822343304753304, 0.026440734043717384, -0.007382790558040142, 0.07180730253458023, -0.041909359395504, 0.025618145242333412, -0.018558429554104805, -0.03482908383011818, 0.11390550434589386, 0.08678766340017319, 0.02802289091050625, -0.06678421050310135, -0.003940350841730833, 0.020351383835077286, -0.018572043627500534, -0.00034116616006940603, -0.0011916373623535037, 0.0052318936213850975, 0.026123974472284317, 0.03796233981847763, 0.07577941566705704, 0.019856315106153488, -0.01843382976949215, 0.05196668580174446, -0.0502389594912529, -0.03377117961645126, 0.005951822269707918, 0.00548229506239295, -0.012048994190990925, -0.05449746549129486, -0.03188481554389, -0.01711179129779339, 0.011856642551720142, -0.017909450456500053, -0.008925753645598888, -0.002887165639549494, 0.024265559390187263, 0.012683998793363571, -0.016166701912879944, -0.029491599649190903, -0.002609087387099862, 0.014822334051132202, -0.03429911658167839, -0.02984541654586792, -0.001386642106808722, -0.034972451627254486, 0.0101772490888834, 0.041735678911209106, -0.007518043275922537, -0.035898178815841675, 0.012281853705644608, 0.017370175570249557, -0.011648891493678093, 0.00021379822283051908, -0.004709437023848295, 0.03702928125858307, -0.00042194529669359326, -0.03841673582792282, -0.015356112271547318, 0.0019401432946324348, -0.005225923378020525, -0.008359584026038647, -0.01440696232020855, 0.0306034404784441, 0.022740451619029045, -0.03664102405309677, -0.035192470997571945, -0.05942139774560928, 0.010953376069664955, -0.014114958234131336, 0.008028330281376839, 0.025876212865114212, 0.005086857825517654, -0.005610305350273848, -0.013927937485277653, 0.042286910116672516, 0.010671302676200867, 0.018500549718737602, 0.022440681234002113, -0.023550434038043022, -0.03759855404496193, -0.01916499063372612, -0.0045541925355792046, -0.005088286940008402, 0.035431865602731705, -0.011410432867705822, -0.0014782011276111007, -0.019888676702976227, -0.030911944806575775, 0.0027317407075315714, -0.029033342376351357, -0.0004578950465656817, -0.07989635318517685, 0.01748313382267952, 0.040707021951675415, 0.007902656681835651, -0.005243667867034674, 0.02890085056424141, 0.0036342095118016005, 0.06482196599245071, 0.002863669767975807, -0.029198329895734787, -0.01120012253522873, -0.012552865780889988, -0.024806832894682884, -0.007123712915927172, -0.030727561563253403, 0.030947158113121986, 0.022678624838590622, 0.008287489414215088, -0.0020823993254452944, 0.005022358149290085, -0.021256858482956886, 0.008311989717185497, 0.004751309286803007, -0.03283754736185074, -0.01130922231823206, 0.027923546731472015, -0.019784608855843544, -0.029792213812470436, 0.007685839664191008, -0.03645502030849457, -0.04176342487335205, 0.0008188945357687771, -0.01774008199572563, -0.03799650818109512, 0.03563174977898598, -0.03215606510639191, 0.027247121557593346, -0.011184331960976124, -0.018428783863782883, -0.014671017415821552, 0.014560425654053688, 0.022025825455784798, -0.012692861258983612, -0.013419321738183498, 0.0024190107360482216, 0.031806379556655884, 0.00021866438328288496, -0.0004590282042045146, -0.0006234258180484176, -0.0031457291916012764, 0.010342921130359173, 0.013007261790335178, -0.02156168222427368, 0.01685500703752041, -0.0019068097462877631, -0.006553090643137693, 0.061869535595178604, -0.05024139955639839, -0.03357440605759621, 0.04228160157799721, 0.015679161995649338, 0.03489779680967331, 0.016817990690469742, 0.03481673821806908, 0.002187840174883604, 0.0439600944519043, -0.03707048296928406, 0.00936977006494999, -0.006136818788945675, -0.016551930457353592, -0.010227905586361885, 0.01721591129899025, -0.050748661160469055, -0.0030228677205741405, -0.010484704747796059, 0.03273167461156845, 0.0561818964779377, -0.014872918836772442, -0.001716851838864386, 0.019108159467577934, -0.02797836624085903, 0.02254127524793148, 0.02271970920264721, -0.026686955243349075, -0.006696536671370268, 0.032356634736061096, 0.0019523497903719544, 0.008041242137551308, -0.07340379059314728, 0.005453801713883877, -0.07273473590612411, -0.030767397955060005, 0.019318945705890656, 0.024503091350197792, 0.03765835240483284, -0.04682009667158127, -0.021031124517321587, 0.02043081820011139, -0.01886603608727455, -0.015596337616443634, -0.026242384687066078, -0.018129032105207443, -0.028606368228793144, -0.004417641554027796, -0.026168541982769966, 0.0490109920501709, 0.005026097409427166, -0.005692233797162771, 0.016515061259269714, 0.009683279320597649, 0.017485681921243668, -0.017335427924990654, 0.015456522814929485, 0.016333822160959244, -0.00966266542673111, -0.08382246643304825, 0.028301699087023735, -0.005011132452636957, -0.03415524214506149, 0.008235500194132328, 0.003972952254116535, 0.013783701695501804, 0.017325283959507942, 0.059937797486782074, 0.013823739252984524, 0.04178646579384804, 0.015205813571810722, 0.04228499159216881, -0.014185682870447636, 0.03476385027170181, 0.020627856254577637, 0.06297391653060913, -0.009374221786856651, 0.032984063029289246, -0.005170279648154974, -0.0107757318764925, -0.045439984649419785, 0.03343088924884796, -0.02020755596458912, -0.011459599249064922, 0.027093885466456413, -0.04807063564658165, -0.0234586950391531, -0.01877499744296074, -0.012453718110918999, -0.02967657521367073, -0.012254759669303894, 0.05072261393070221, 0.03930531069636345, -0.016615787521004677, 0.03085511550307274, -0.03840355947613716, -0.021657489240169525, 0.001547261606901884, 0.006541246082633734, -0.0006004113820381463, -0.040969762951135635, -0.0265257116407156, 0.02896224334836006, 0.00534196337684989, -0.046755410730838776, 0.01948091760277748, 0.008364124223589897, 0.025772687047719955, -0.01817491464316845, -0.02684531919658184, 0.029783470556139946, -0.021656351163983345, 0.03456614539027214, -0.05474112555384636, 0.07846713066101074, 0.023683609440922737, -0.02673860639333725, -0.0193296130746603, -0.01806609332561493, -0.02367960475385189, 0.01615012437105179, 0.04372132942080498, -0.007969928905367851, -0.020254381000995636, -0.031107867136597633, 0.03707704693078995, 0.001890165382064879, -0.05679274722933769, 0.03649244084954262, -0.022136323153972626, -0.03388378769159317, -0.035981953144073486, -0.01820262335240841, 0.0017427194397896528, -0.021692471578717232, 0.018529372289776802, -0.028882931917905807, 0.012127434834837914, -0.027687901630997658, -0.004737087059766054, 0.018906161189079285, 0.04800188168883324, 0.000049490925448480994, 0.05726534500718117, -0.007489629089832306, 0.04136987775564194, 0.023996422067284584, -0.019006459042429924, -0.036066845059394836, 0.059450846165418625, -0.03549189493060112, 0.030310070142149925, -0.00158640556037426, 0.0059388442896306515, -0.007157802581787109, -0.056724853813648224, 0.020658301189541817, 0.022501667961478233, -0.040559735149145126, -0.01032786164432764, 0.019797340035438538, 0.05364453047513962, -0.004803257994353771, 0.03823218122124672, -0.01323882956057787, -0.027825234457850456, -0.040033936500549316, 0.009908139705657959, 0.015931522473692894, 0.0830785408616066, -0.0008547414909116924, 0.003064161166548729, 0.015795614570379257, -0.04437630623579025, 0.041920941323041916, -0.04096140339970589, 0.0721031203866005, -0.050892364233732224, -0.013541660271584988, 0.02566436678171158, 0.026062214747071266, 0.017483485862612724, 0.014841912314295769, -0.022622615098953247, 0.05235057324171066, -0.07463748008012772, 0.023378416895866394, 0.0065437075681984425, -0.045712050050497055, -0.035127192735672, 0.004761016461998224, 0.01872524805366993, 0.0368279367685318, -0.026014316827058792, 0.007283833343535662, -0.011839618906378746, -0.035012900829315186, 0.03868565335869789, -0.00294250575825572, 0.010023017413914204, 0.0016498269978910685, -0.03726813942193985, -0.026003295555710793, 0.0206968542188406, -0.054581817239522934, -0.0107351653277874, 0.01182018406689167, 0.006963873747736216, -0.0007486188551411033, -0.03825954347848892, -0.019260525703430176, 0.010132256895303726, 0.06270143389701843, -0.07595488429069519, 0.01724451594054699, -0.025944380089640617, 0.01228458620607853, 0.006811578292399645, 0.021556060761213303 ]
<p>I am reviewing my time series knowledge and looking for a document that has the commonly-used time series tests, what they are used for, how to use them, etc. e.g. Augmented Dickey–Fuller test, PACF tests, etc. </p> <p>I found a wikipedia page of common statistical tests, but I am looking for a list of such that is specific for time series analysis. </p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_hypothesis_testing#Common_test_statistics" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_hypothesis_testing#Common_test_statistics</a></p> <p>Thanks! </p>
74,487
[ 0.024440690875053406, -0.049470074474811554, -0.020630570128560066, 0.013064968399703503, 0.050726160407066345, 0.003138348925858736, 0.01493348740041256, -0.039002012461423874, -0.0034097800962626934, -0.038125019520521164, 0.05366266146302223, 0.04320017993450165, 0.02663489617407322, -0.00018752756295725703, 0.010827803984284401, -0.002702397061511874, -0.025106439366936684, -0.003768275724723935, -0.007750892546027899, -0.020297877490520477, 0.028707390651106834, -0.00034432896063663065, 0.043827932327985764, -0.0034792248625308275, -0.0034971104469150305, 0.03601612150669098, 0.03047184646129608, 0.007202210370451212, 0.006678433623164892, 0.06895630806684494, -0.062302086502313614, -0.0232242438942194, -0.04086676985025406, 0.042431313544511795, -0.019726436585187912, -0.024846237152814865, 0.006884352304041386, -0.027105841785669327, -0.0024708150885999203, 0.05564606189727783, -0.042176254093647, -0.018570248037576675, 0.010147981345653534, 0.04346637800335884, -0.013679307885468006, 0.021089689806103706, 0.02168676070868969, -0.02331422083079815, -0.011207932606339455, -0.05556069314479828, 0.06603148579597473, -0.00737763149663806, 0.033639051020145416, 0.011625231243669987, 0.011041306890547276, 0.01869869790971279, 0.027791758999228477, 0.03472505509853363, -0.04534023627638817, -0.05963217467069626, -0.000226725431275554, -0.03607955202460289, 0.0026203959714621305, -0.04086937755346298, -0.04595651105046272, 0.06371278315782547, -0.024456456303596497, -0.009004040621221066, 0.0403834767639637, -0.02245143987238407, 0.026326561346650124, 0.02292477712035179, 0.02492980845272541, -0.00973937101662159, -0.047326743602752686, -0.026314107701182365, 0.016893349587917328, 0.011367922648787498, 0.04307503253221512, 0.08058372884988785, 0.009957803413271904, 0.02736561745405197, -0.0018501973245292902, 0.020839735865592957, 0.05002857744693756, 0.01705484837293625, 0.09810133278369904, -0.04237671196460724, -0.013101335614919662, 0.008401862345635891, -0.02346440590918064, -0.03704521432518959, 0.007134567014873028, -0.003388082841411233, -0.050533927977085114, 0.011373400688171387, -0.034681081771850586, 0.03139267489314079, -0.018808186054229736, -0.005813040304929018, -0.0017870994051918387, -0.030527332797646523, 0.0076682716608047485, 0.047152452170848846, -0.044085435569286346, 0.0047936285845935345, -0.016866397112607956, -0.0070946104824543, -0.021029286086559296, -0.00026490259915590286, -0.025469910353422165, 0.023693319410085678, -0.01295329537242651, 0.017218977212905884, -0.018394388258457184, 0.012990875169634819, 0.009815599769353867, -0.0034112166613340378, 0.05903619900345802, 0.06070144101977348, 0.06558183580636978, -0.02524751052260399, 0.02895667403936386, -0.03986777365207672, -0.03078065812587738, 0.005037340801209211, -0.011947285383939743, -0.025121694430708885, -0.020105332136154175, 0.0927443653345108, -0.002895722398534417, -0.06701217591762543, 0.03300226107239723, -0.00518803671002388, 0.08114197850227356, 0.0018072715029120445, -0.07897847145795822, -0.04292381554841995, 0.05263464152812958, -0.00439488934352994, -0.012869066558778286, -0.058584172278642654, 0.03789791092276573, -0.025013528764247894, 0.025125907734036446, 0.020322393625974655, 0.05305702984333038, 0.00581886013969779, 0.022098978981375694, 0.025930184870958328, -0.0665552020072937, 0.000035374770959606394, 0.001818730030208826, 0.009189629927277565, 0.01170029304921627, -0.07748692482709885, 0.02135736495256424, 0.018038310110569, 0.019289670512080193, -0.01932714693248272, 0.049361858516931534, 0.01152146514505148, -0.01477531623095274, -0.0014250132953748107, 0.002710656262934208, -0.01497670728713274, 0.06002417206764221, -0.00626315688714385, -0.008105697110295296, 0.003051232313737273, 0.009940474294126034, 0.03401049226522446, 0.014683926478028297, 0.02666589990258217, 0.025012942031025887, -0.022709552198648453, 0.009241897612810135, -0.0001811102411011234, 0.001666781958192587, 0.009960757568478584, -0.03937282785773277, -0.03681843727827072, -0.0012254605535417795, -0.019278956577181816, 0.008850163780152798, 0.03890613839030266, 0.0018914968241006136, -0.03815017640590668, 0.026734400540590286, -0.06939839571714401, -0.013382112607359886, -0.0589449517428875, -0.0012260008370503783, -0.045349765568971634, -0.012430555187165737, 0.0433281846344471, 0.023012332618236542, 0.0562538243830204, -0.03520529344677925, -0.03078884817659855, -0.03218992054462433, 0.001657282467931509, 0.0323176383972168, -0.06621504575014114, 0.008242075331509113, 0.003196221310645342, 0.03739771991968155, -0.02480350434780121, 0.003878690768033266, -0.03513188660144806, -0.024593621492385864, 0.022747032344341278, -0.09336879104375839, 0.008613072335720062, -0.0071191550232470036, -0.00748489098623395, 0.02294853702187538, 0.028187567368149757, -0.0068026334047317505, 0.024736110121011734, -0.025984391570091248, 0.038307711482048035, 0.039207179099321365, 0.01215671468526125, 0.02557988278567791, -0.010135606862604618, 0.04471287876367569, 0.007645263336598873, -0.024709736928343773, 0.031974080950021744, -0.053460486233234406, 0.033840835094451904, 0.059931959956884384, 0.005440466571599245, -0.038753997534513474, 0.0314905121922493, 0.09650082141160965, 0.022778555750846863, -0.02054206281900406, 0.046161506325006485, 0.008682677522301674, -0.04739990085363388, -0.04249480739235878, 0.015319781377911568, 0.000059560938098002225, 0.01528911292552948, 0.032769739627838135, 0.013445121236145496, 0.042997654527425766, 0.02595522813498974, -0.01422381866723299, 0.05652870237827301, -0.013978353701531887, 0.024546246975660324, -0.003906283527612686, -0.038353752344846725, 0.03396649658679962, -0.028836067765951157, -0.013299833983182907, 0.0031024846248328686, 0.005950176622718573, 0.021467410027980804, 0.01221625879406929, -0.024678347632288933, -0.0019336806144565344, -0.004732524510473013, -0.0481351837515831, -0.0008832424064166844, 0.026011446490883827, -0.04367535561323166, 0.011392548680305481, -0.03248521685600281, -0.013877307064831257, -0.08005179464817047, -0.020752154290676117, 0.017387328669428825, 0.02228350192308426, 0.04098490998148918, -0.012653905898332596, 0.000055931697716005147, 0.013076950795948505, -0.018854038789868355, 0.029897309839725494, -0.014405762776732445, -0.02487788535654545, 0.023201489821076393, -0.015982376411557198, -0.024177614599466324, 0.05703821778297424, -0.03155438229441643, 0.01611180044710636, 0.04250205680727959, -0.0005454345373436809, -0.021990647539496422, -0.03632180765271187, -0.009602339938282967, 0.027440857142210007, -0.03578603267669678, -0.022131452336907387, 0.05229713022708893, -0.024466684088110924, -0.03858884796500206, 0.02959136664867401, -0.04120754450559616, -0.012585101649165154, -0.04232049360871315, -0.00019458231690805405, 0.004509916994720697, -0.0367773063480854, -0.00727655878290534, 0.014102298766374588, -0.06721469014883041, -0.0009781263070181012, -0.028464552015066147, -0.057778798043727875, -0.003758831648156047, 0.0141923688352108, 0.05592859908938408, -0.0074901580810546875, -0.03016766905784607, 0.027730468660593033, 0.00979912281036377, -0.03801015019416809, -0.04278859496116638, 0.0030155996792018414, -0.04294842854142189, -0.02139742486178875, 0.019277526065707207, 0.032335735857486725, -0.014708142727613449, 0.013887312263250351, 0.033513523638248444, 0.026681404560804367, 0.03436081111431122, 0.031766459345817566, 0.016979841515421867, 0.02478119358420372, -0.0033838609233498573, -0.025505011901259422, 0.019356844946742058, 0.033657290041446686, -0.037044066935777664, -0.00808806624263525, 0.0009423714363947511, 0.02773439511656761, 0.0026886803098022938, -0.041107937693595886, 0.02476155012845993, -0.03966430574655533, -0.02415904588997364, -0.03797512874007225, 0.02755582146346569, 0.009012650698423386, 0.010698609054088593, -0.0460858978331089, 0.051398761570453644, -0.007980488240718842, 0.005635653622448444, 0.02665526792407036, 0.0446171872317791, 0.023882269859313965, -0.04298987239599228, -0.02914530038833618, -0.040912073105573654, -0.008968152105808258, 0.033832650631666183, -0.04072317108511925, -0.02865920029580593, 0.06125916540622711, 0.053988076746463776, 0.01678372360765934, -0.0012216258328408003, -0.034559305757284164, 0.035227544605731964, -0.08971402794122696, -0.0016427997034043074, -0.045540951192379, 0.03910317271947861, -0.00197010044939816, 0.0494975820183754, 0.033111751079559326, -0.016214249655604362, 0.04775749146938324, -0.01588703878223896, -0.05485975369811058, 0.05956549942493439, -0.028660155832767487, -0.02940806746482849, 0.00481751374900341, 0.02060607448220253, 0.038428399711847305, -0.025909990072250366, 0.021569469943642616, 0.004251700825989246, 0.03359675779938698, -0.035195574164390564, 0.017429880797863007, 0.00849734153598547, -0.027252938598394394, -0.01906421408057213, -0.017200451344251633, 0.04058900102972984, -0.019299373030662537, 0.04536743462085724, 0.05109574273228645, 0.006568232551217079, -0.020623814314603806, 0.008476201444864273, 0.002759721362963319, 0.04683662950992584, 0.020101170986890793, 0.045164626091718674, -0.008061109110713005, -0.05051810294389725, 0.04768263176083565, 0.013919306918978691, 0.02272840030491352, 0.030762935057282448, -0.009170567616820335, -0.010271687060594559, -0.019385935738682747, 0.011655272915959358, -0.00016377409338019788, 0.0028222501277923584, 0.052459463477134705, -0.013901474885642529, 0.06264003366231918, 0.021390903741121292, -0.03281337767839432, 0.024148985743522644, 0.05186877027153969, -0.02929028868675232, 0.030540689826011658, -0.022091791033744812, -0.019399158656597137, -0.022851156070828438, 0.0029273568652570248, 0.025781994685530663, 0.01014926377683878, 0.0010502912336960435, 0.01617203839123249, 0.015477897599339485, -0.00856903288513422, -0.020083345472812653, -0.009669585153460503, 0.02352367341518402, 0.06534885615110397, 0.004198681563138962, -0.030715461820364, 0.05207442864775658, 0.02068592980504036, 0.02458229847252369, 0.05323074012994766, -0.020415792241692543, -0.0706433653831482, 0.07051444798707962, 0.06545459479093552, 0.026502041146159172, -0.013410251587629318, -0.019439594820141792, -0.03569191321730614, 0.0013228892348706722, 0.042613547295331955, -0.02324511669576168, 0.03024357743561268, -0.005617544986307621, -0.006845362484455109, -0.0429345965385437, -0.014847504906356335, -0.008095050230622292, 0.01751253381371498, 0.013267667964100838, 0.033707670867443085, -0.04447143152356148, -0.009450520388782024, -0.015562999062240124, -0.017135407775640488, 0.001901041716337204, 0.029495371505618095, -0.00014078013191465288, 0.022050485014915466, 0.011733883060514927, 0.021858781576156616, -0.01241631992161274, -0.06023271009325981, -0.0030987965874373913, 0.00636558560654521, 0.0026759624015539885, 0.034950096160173416, -0.015012877061963081, -0.022107131779193878, 0.006488150451332331, -0.01495917234569788, -0.057691436260938644, -0.010448974557220936, -0.03327880799770355, 0.014608269557356834, 0.03338386118412018, 0.02779863029718399, 0.07189366221427917, 0.0313197486102581, -0.00029407249530777335, 0.0058330693282186985, 0.005267830099910498, 0.011984043754637241, -0.038591984659433365, 0.00018580688629299402, -0.03000457026064396, -0.03190653398633003, -0.03862461447715759, 0.017027199268341064, -0.0056419954635202885, -0.0032873530872166157, -0.01639353670179844, 0.030686797574162483, -0.018017536029219627, 0.04262514039874077, 0.0219738632440567, -0.01601344719529152, 0.027530167251825333, 0.002207414945587516, -0.021533764898777008, 0.0062925550155341625, 0.03190559893846512, -0.006092205177992582, -0.028423044830560684, 0.01577375829219818, 0.0026938747614622116, 0.001540029188618064, -0.004279075190424919, -0.02110665664076805, 0.006534719839692116, -0.015467491932213306, 0.020664392039179802, 0.01857788674533367, 0.01612924039363861, -0.005698304623365402, -0.022905807942152023, -0.05035999417304993, 0.0336015559732914, -0.0015797578962519765, 0.06959231942892075, -0.0556061714887619, 0.0433180145919323, -0.017087412998080254, 0.015870805829763412, -0.033921051770448685, -0.04492387920618057, 0.05839655548334122, 0.019151099026203156, -0.051466263830661774, -0.003625978482887149, 0.010499715805053711, -0.008252437226474285, 0.010820471681654453, -0.0369042232632637, 0.03773006796836853, -0.01799534633755684, -0.028174495324492455, -0.020486127585172653, 0.016598274931311607, 0.11130338907241821, 0.0010053261648863554, -0.033194318413734436, 0.025054730474948883, -0.009780258871614933, -0.03924885019659996, -0.027025530114769936, 0.014062244445085526, -0.04665520042181015, 0.011923840269446373, -0.033937934786081314, 0.002014232100918889, 0.008926781825721264, -0.03367244452238083, -0.008764096535742283, 0.012240609154105186, 0.008801591582596302, -0.0010938146151602268, -0.05197739228606224, 0.01791514828801155, -0.05037347972393036, -0.001824825070798397, 0.002080177189782262, -0.006822847295552492, -0.020021790638566017, -0.04012995958328247, -0.015619822777807713, -0.013375726528465748, -0.015533546917140484, 0.027772335335612297, 0.04410770907998085, 0.017403848469257355, -0.0018007027683779597, -0.014353525824844837, -0.017839759588241577, 0.00998834427446127, -0.016634132713079453, 0.011784388683736324, -0.015181138180196285, 0.003913095686584711, -0.04371422901749611, -0.021105581894516945, -0.01874775066971779, -0.015574123710393906, 0.07255063951015472, 0.003386878874152899, 0.07059912383556366, 0.050931744277477264, -0.006229177117347717, 0.014568054117262363, -0.007116854190826416, -0.0020747119560837746, -0.027069635689258575, 0.010986106470227242, 0.03736555576324463, 0.003063751617446542, 0.030667956918478012, 0.022218691185116768, -0.003985615447163582, 0.025232169777154922, 0.045647237449884415, 0.02876080945134163, 0.03488684445619583, 0.01827736757695675, -0.025716956704854965, -0.047121886163949966, 0.042898304760456085, -0.03141948953270912, 0.02187144197523594, -0.016228869557380676, 0.01889907568693161, 0.04489976167678833, 0.04736938700079918, -0.013226469047367573, -0.04087812453508377, 0.003612559288740158, -0.05680888891220093, 0.017438232898712158, 0.014391148462891579, -0.03565595671534538, 0.00475675705820322, 0.03336641564965248, 0.05079250782728195, -0.002159843686968088, 0.035794004797935486, -0.006536849308758974, -0.050110913813114166, -0.02877000905573368, -0.028029702603816986, -0.02703128568828106, 0.02587723359465599, -0.02041868306696415, -0.038667671382427216, 0.005500859580934048, -0.01796342246234417, 0.013959081843495369, 0.011540865525603294, 0.02231479249894619, -0.027570009231567383, 0.0825004130601883, -0.018070511519908905, 0.0061464374884963036, -0.019757870584726334, -0.03253057599067688, 0.11876089870929718, 0.06578632444143295, 0.017028244212269783, -0.0795726403594017, 0.00778591725975275, 0.02038273960351944, 0.035897478461265564, -0.05230116844177246, 0.024801934137940407, -0.010427183471620083, 0.010972240939736366, 0.05347258225083351, 0.07073365896940231, -0.008794535882771015, -0.03554043918848038, 0.07140455394983292, -0.00013082839723210782, -0.018057506531476974, -0.012948914431035519, 0.022629529237747192, -0.007198717910796404, 0.012352271936833858, -0.06531544029712677, 0.015028041787445545, -0.0139870410785079, -0.01458511408418417, -0.008947092108428478, -0.03712966665625572, 0.010393073782324791, 0.002095788484439254, -0.016003740951418877, -0.013971274718642235, 0.03958398848772049, 0.0164884515106678, -0.028878228738904, -0.03672214597463608, 0.014252376742661, -0.02659911848604679, 0.019357427954673767, 0.01756722293794155, 0.014078089967370033, -0.016230769455432892, -0.0036280169151723385, 0.0006035784026607871, -0.010117664933204651, -0.0025210976600646973, -0.02579318732023239, 0.039492107927799225, -0.029887428507208824, 0.008201748132705688, -0.027728714048862457, 0.014133037067949772, -0.01398903876543045, -0.01966642588376999, -0.019249189645051956, 0.004727672785520554, 0.05246591940522194, -0.05335170403122902, -0.00771678239107132, -0.06134246662259102, -0.013193808495998383, -0.021596865728497505, 0.043448496609926224, 0.013633918948471546, -0.0077760228887200356, -0.009056665934622288, -0.04215195029973984, 0.05442551523447037, -0.03908935934305191, -0.006601421628147364, 0.03649983927607536, -0.0027939295396208763, -0.04372372105717659, 0.020568151026964188, 0.04181165620684624, -0.0024604396894574165, 0.030223948881030083, 0.0004123809339944273, -0.010768407955765724, 0.009863615036010742, -0.036550894379615784, 0.020949311554431915, -0.0335431843996048, -0.0337316170334816, -0.026407109573483467, -0.0018647484248504043, 0.07903110235929489, 0.007922288030385971, 0.040924977511167526, 0.011189290322363377, -0.045737374573946, 0.020418204367160797, 0.05192050710320473, -0.05601046606898308, 0.0005676175933331251, 0.011895881965756416, 0.03433028981089592, -0.023594554513692856, -0.04431295767426491, 0.06245582550764084, 0.05620865896344185, -0.021036872640252113, -0.015883097425103188, 0.02261277474462986, -0.012972994707524776, 0.002080117352306843, -0.015211028046905994, -0.04968106001615524, -0.016442276537418365, 0.016323549672961235, 0.004089807625859976, -0.043640751391649246, -0.0442243255674839, -0.025105882436037064, 0.03091447241604328, 0.010971258394420147, -0.01215021125972271, -0.052421070635318756, 0.016937697306275368, -0.0068683922290802, 0.01395320799201727, -0.044486626982688904, 0.019225403666496277, -0.0501883327960968, -0.04448815435171127, -0.015246604569256306, -0.012087162584066391, -0.0024685123935341835, -0.00399473262950778, -0.030309610068798065, 0.015840942040085793, 0.032444413751363754, 0.005352184176445007, -0.0009506104397587478, 0.014887996017932892, -0.0009258192731067538, -0.031439922749996185, 0.023356402292847633, -0.008292099460959435, -0.023747965693473816, 0.049044299870729446, -0.033320292830467224, -0.0433005690574646, 0.022170210257172585, -0.02014087326824665, 0.007870713248848915, -0.0208012443035841, 0.02683720923960209, -0.016993753612041473, 0.009074131958186626, -0.0039252182468771935, 0.028640491887927055, -0.020232519134879112, 0.019902938976883888, 0.015774007886648178, 0.022658929228782654, 0.014120521955192089, 0.0024210039991885424, -0.02150307036936283, 0.00013100045907776803, 0.08297213912010193, 0.025372367352247238, 0.01366929616779089, 0.009454888291656971, -0.0019164022523909807, 0.02469087764620781, 0.0367797426879406, -0.025638330727815628, 0.06210737302899361, 0.04919159784913063, -0.02857511304318905, 0.036335669457912445, -0.0390368290245533, -0.023716192692518234, -0.07219091802835464, 0.013582629151642323, -0.018246931955218315, 0.010640392079949379, 0.016130294650793076, -0.04962511733174324, -0.0014148817863315344, 0.02678440324962139, -0.031121956184506416, 0.05417875945568085, 0.0010807333746924996, -0.013153760693967342, 0.0010500064818188548, -0.026040708646178246, 0.012634923681616783, 0.05626504868268967, 0.02186884544789791, 0.008252477273344994, 0.03760714456439018, 0.01816151849925518, 0.023127811029553413, -0.0014048238517716527, -0.007468004710972309, 0.018398484215140343, 0.0075698234140872955, -0.044138990342617035, 0.009408957324922085, -0.029042551293969154, -0.029050545766949654, 0.010685153305530548, -0.007928583770990372, 0.02619156986474991, -0.004870154429227114, 0.0026244588661938906, -0.03681106120347977, 0.0367656946182251, 0.02171555906534195, -0.02898075245320797, -0.034857284277677536, -0.006711224094033241, -0.004917651414871216, 0.03312113508582115, 0.009836041368544102, -0.009570254012942314, 0.013914979994297028, -0.04261552169919014, -0.05851735919713974, 0.0007229213952086866, -0.0022421684116125107, -0.008623084053397179, 0.02063615806400776, -0.03651668503880501, 0.017235107719898224, 0.016053615137934685, 0.029671262949705124, -0.021360069513320923, 0.022387923672795296, 0.012717931531369686, -0.008478580042719841, -0.008604184724390507, 0.03196913003921509, -0.01408480480313301, -0.020873092114925385, 0.033568210899829865, 0.005045589525252581, 0.004086221102625132, -0.0541948638856411, -0.00329392752610147, 0.00945299956947565, -0.012184261344373226, -0.030359970405697823, -0.0023093249183148146, -0.018644394353032112, 0.03811328485608101, -0.0053944215178489685, -0.05509251728653908, 0.015941902995109558, 0.00721170986071229, 0.005815364886075258, -0.06799115240573883, 0.052162036299705505, -0.015605269931256771, -0.022055860608816147, -0.025108464062213898, 0.0075974734500050545, -0.024028439074754715, -0.014521541073918343, 0.034302715212106705, -0.024491989985108376, 0.037072815001010895, -0.02156311273574829, 0.01734941639006138, 0.006190113723278046, -0.06814594566822052, 0.03906150534749031, -0.04048303887248039, -0.05286281183362007, -0.006255717482417822, -0.028255153447389603, 0.027291547507047653, -0.022277969866991043, 0.023701606318354607, 0.01273265015333891, 0.040760233998298645, 0.011248479597270489, 0.006465039681643248, 0.047510065138339996, 0.04052373021841049, -0.0171787291765213, 0.04084277153015137, -0.017276016995310783, 0.027508370578289032, -0.009858503006398678, -0.0048515684902668, -0.0393819697201252, 0.02926865592598915, -0.01731271669268608, -0.044218696653842926, 0.006853587459772825, 0.017292644828557968, 0.006236810237169266, -0.04968545213341713, -0.011135244742035866, 0.02143007516860962, -0.027059730142354965, 0.012284510768949986, 0.022389432415366173, 0.02632732130587101, 0.049954142421483994, -0.028682734817266464, 0.035975292325019836, 0.0015850861091166735, -0.014934924431145191, 0.0031306324526667595, -0.013106334954500198, 0.041176870465278625, -0.016965826973319054, 0.003840523539111018, 0.022480832412838936, -0.02218179777264595, 0.03478556126356125, -0.017477571964263916, 0.014589712023735046, -0.042223986238241196, -0.011773199774324894, 0.003667967626824975, -0.039361536502838135, 0.007211380638182163, 0.0048013417981565, 0.005947789177298546, 0.05901096761226654, -0.06486274302005768, 0.005861918907612562, -0.0029662244487553835, -0.050664275884628296, -0.031563907861709595, -0.007422162685543299, -0.02020684815943241, -0.0062018707394599915, -0.015196138061583042, 0.011166395619511604, -0.000156607071403414, 0.011287989094853401, 0.05227246508002281, -0.0028820012230426073, 0.0425213985145092, 0.0024980392772704363, -0.013327485881745815, -0.011725264601409435, 0.0057235704734921455, -0.024275120347738266, -0.03565063700079918, 0.01338478084653616, 0.02231760136783123, 0.010945179499685764, -0.03428594395518303, -0.012873377650976181, 0.02212887816131115, 0.02776900865137577, -0.09583989530801773, 0.010822020471096039, -0.05181393399834633, 0.022774817422032356, 0.011472765356302261, 0.007228726055473089 ]
<p>I was reading <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaussian_process_regression" rel="nofollow">this wikipedia article</a> related to kriging . I didn't understand the part when it says that</p> <p>Kriging computes the best linear unbiased estimator, $\hat Z (x_0)$, of $Z(x_0)$ such that kriging variance of is minimized with the unbiasedness condition. I didn't get the derivation and also how the variance is minimized. Any suggestions?</p> <p>Specially, I didn't get the part where applies minimized subject to unbiasedness condition.</p> <p>I think it should have been</p> <p>E[Z'(x0)-Z(x0)] instead of E[Z'(x)-Z(x)] isn't it. ' is equivalent to hat in the wiki article. Also I didn't get how the kriging error is derived</p>
74,488
[ -0.009291931986808777, -0.02059294283390045, 0.013969868421554565, -0.014654843136668205, 0.04000665247440338, 0.01062979456037283, -0.011599655263125896, -0.04820236191153526, 0.039727695286273956, -0.022396421059966087, 0.026949213817715645, 0.05565236136317253, 0.05995628610253334, 0.01870385929942131, 0.021376032382249832, 0.013065529055893421, -0.004134434275329113, 0.00823546014726162, -0.016404030844569206, -0.010230574756860733, -0.011590818874537945, 0.04828105494379997, -0.00959369633346796, -0.0008778809569776058, -0.03194223344326019, 0.02430311031639576, 0.025681644678115845, 0.006383760366588831, 0.0038407989777624607, 0.07239343225955963, -0.03352031856775284, -0.0365181528031826, 0.012916135601699352, 0.044493090361356735, 0.047297194600105286, -0.009046731516718864, -0.03525551036000252, -0.0637717917561531, -0.013455354608595371, 0.046142809092998505, -0.013612939976155758, -0.038036782294511795, -0.001640739501453936, 0.038827020674943924, -0.006503926124423742, 0.02296328730881214, 0.001981730805709958, -0.03839855268597603, 0.042466290295124054, -0.03330383822321892, 0.01596176251769066, -0.008266794495284557, 0.008944162167608738, 0.03457895293831825, 0.015354448929429054, 0.014678830280900002, 0.0605243556201458, 0.04272967576980591, -0.021006908267736435, -0.049945004284381866, 0.012690975330770016, -0.028476128354668617, 0.02609059028327465, -0.024386027827858925, -0.03427330031991005, -0.006131470203399658, 0.0192398838698864, -0.005270221270620823, 0.014771047979593277, 0.006963301450014114, 0.03209192305803299, 0.014995768666267395, 0.0011215060949325562, -0.021258266642689705, -0.005260587204247713, -0.03082754835486412, -0.012237527407705784, 0.022670982405543327, 0.056007061153650284, 0.015051211230456829, 0.032710377126932144, 0.007341025862842798, 0.024905957281589508, -0.0008192912209779024, -0.009057475253939629, 0.01687249168753624, 0.07030180096626282, -0.015966977924108505, 0.007805357687175274, 0.029240433126688004, -0.013677629642188549, 0.024777108803391457, 0.0444149523973465, -0.045547157526016235, -0.03966647386550903, 0.030181648209691048, 0.01706928387284279, 0.05305256322026253, -0.02351093292236328, -0.014888445846736431, 0.004027676302939653, -0.04272573068737984, -0.006383535452187061, 0.012036403641104698, -0.030682267621159554, -0.018914824351668358, 0.02125435136258602, 0.019169121980667114, -0.02497132122516632, -0.048876311630010605, -0.06643493473529816, 0.032267890870571136, 0.0029814632143825293, -0.010027935728430748, 0.029272109270095825, -0.029862666502594948, 0.04520948603749275, 0.01033691968768835, 0.004906833171844482, 0.03884536027908325, 0.04125836119055748, -0.042361076921224594, 0.020932339131832123, -0.021225979551672935, -0.049161724746227264, 0.045648932456970215, 0.005650583188980818, -0.0028781285509467125, -0.056150373071432114, 0.05561964213848114, 0.009540184400975704, -0.021557025611400604, 0.02017144486308098, 0.032903920859098434, -0.009329129941761494, -0.029864119365811348, -0.10328857600688934, -0.04452051967382431, 0.0528411865234375, -0.010391857475042343, 0.05263485014438629, -0.08110363781452179, -0.013913881964981556, 0.008349308744072914, 0.05943999066948891, -0.009418862871825695, 0.013988238759338856, -0.000976738054305315, 0.048434555530548096, -0.020485179498791695, -0.006222509779036045, -0.0216140765696764, -0.006816835608333349, -0.018298467621207237, -0.01273544505238533, -0.08320288360118866, 0.018916532397270203, 0.018208367750048637, -0.045503731817007065, -0.020197371020913124, 0.049621764570474625, 0.014712341129779816, -0.007634986191987991, 0.0007889108383096755, 0.004854070954024792, -0.02333354949951172, 0.07390233129262924, 0.027377767488360405, 0.040303245186805725, 0.04479357227683067, 0.0008950341725721955, 0.0012833861401304603, -0.026020778343081474, 0.03116527572274208, 0.055367402732372284, -0.039385467767715454, 0.01252853311598301, -0.05146532878279686, 0.020672066137194633, 0.01637640967965126, -0.07686543464660645, 0.015232130885124207, 0.012380975298583508, 0.030000654980540276, 0.019821031019091606, 0.040392808616161346, 0.0036986549384891987, -0.00627323379740119, 0.035201139748096466, -0.0634695515036583, -0.02086261659860611, -0.05758616328239441, 0.038194652646780014, 0.012178915552794933, 0.002678735414519906, 0.013561667874455452, -0.008224883116781712, -0.0036286457907408476, -0.0339881032705307, -0.04018215462565422, 0.035741787403821945, -0.021802591159939766, 0.050562869757413864, -0.031075607985258102, -0.008397475816309452, 0.0779954046010971, 0.040581461042165756, -0.008315960876643658, 0.051186516880989075, -0.027814636006951332, -0.013497382402420044, -0.005690224468708038, 0.0019136909395456314, 0.014076787047088146, -0.02002589963376522, -0.0338561087846756, 0.02091710828244686, -0.00846156757324934, -0.011355524882674217, -0.019645806401968002, -0.06991950422525406, 0.03303868696093559, 0.10853234678506851, 0.0011642215540632606, 0.004971473477780819, 0.01545446366071701, -0.007904010824859142, 0.02300378493964672, -0.041911594569683075, -0.04203511029481888, -0.058205243200063705, -0.02638021484017372, 0.051661595702171326, 0.012495363131165504, -0.02896597795188427, -0.02758425660431385, 0.03838055953383446, 0.04667201638221741, 0.004995944444090128, 0.029347145929932594, -0.04386139661073685, 0.008843016810715199, 0.04832182824611664, 0.012908374890685081, 0.00328062498010695, 0.016458457335829735, -0.017052363604307175, 0.0012507557403296232, 0.031218379735946655, 0.01056688278913498, -0.0232477355748415, 0.07550419867038727, -0.021712718531489372, 0.025068961083889008, -0.009156904183328152, 0.007616223301738501, -0.0017527654999867082, -0.05207689106464386, 0.009593713097274303, 0.019560474902391434, 0.022037087008357048, 0.024061985313892365, -0.022214550524950027, -0.020436100661754608, -0.0003476736310403794, 0.014329159632325172, -0.03418375551700592, 0.022430580109357834, 0.014353468082845211, 0.0015396206872537732, -0.010574530810117722, -0.026285171508789062, -0.029712151736021042, -0.05693797394633293, -0.0021515863481909037, 0.01684972271323204, 0.023872336372733116, 0.0010083324741572142, -0.0034801310393959284, -0.010888474993407726, -0.03535550460219383, 0.0042228177189826965, 0.03693820908665657, 0.038322389125823975, -0.023566344752907753, -0.005039132200181484, -0.019705265760421753, -0.00042658235179260373, 0.045997750014066696, -0.03303661197423935, 0.009723600000143051, -0.027577342465519905, 0.022101951763033867, -0.04376755654811859, -0.011393043212592602, -0.023553596809506416, 0.015836969017982483, -0.008356942795217037, -0.0002657037985045463, 0.03414935618638992, 0.02838963083922863, -0.027129193767905235, 0.07744729518890381, -0.027839476242661476, -0.04367135837674141, -0.031251054257154465, -0.010424022562801838, 0.038670700043439865, -0.0012858397094532847, 0.051825765520334244, 0.041537635028362274, -0.02200818620622158, 0.01748529076576233, -0.022897984832525253, -0.04256080463528633, 0.05146011710166931, -0.025233831256628036, 0.0231577567756176, 0.00439872033894062, -0.01851089484989643, 0.08265592157840729, 0.029082171618938446, -0.010746032930910587, -0.02173536643385887, 0.0244539026170969, -0.03128868713974953, -0.028080733492970467, 0.0003308859886601567, -0.0011262856423854828, -0.0008060187101364136, 0.03378612920641899, -0.012258232571184635, 0.01359586138278246, 0.04637524485588074, -0.004483833443373442, 0.02238929644227028, -0.02518283948302269, -0.02471352368593216, 0.0074505493976175785, 0.04771356284618378, 0.014402355998754501, 0.006810116581618786, 0.02402719296514988, 0.03846742585301399, 0.006071333307772875, 0.0067853969521820545, -0.030106522142887115, 0.010100999847054482, -0.01687776856124401, -0.023400910198688507, -0.04817549139261246, 0.03262432664632797, -0.006659284234046936, -0.04066276177763939, 0.022331876680254936, 0.022467389702796936, 0.03146974742412567, -0.029789594933390617, -0.012069834396243095, 0.020719684660434723, 0.028119545429944992, -0.022171664983034134, -0.0053291539661586285, -0.03198632970452309, -0.013790024444460869, 0.04349607974290848, -0.0099943857640028, -0.0523659847676754, 0.04117017239332199, 0.07149443030357361, 0.0017419274663552642, -0.007341404911130667, -0.0761217400431633, -0.010007575154304504, -0.05134424939751625, 0.020386911928653717, 0.000293853459879756, 0.027264896780252457, -0.012461954727768898, 0.03970276936888695, 0.01972976140677929, -0.02489958144724369, 0.013603310100734234, 0.00646250182762742, -0.07601694017648697, 0.029644837602972984, -0.03229531645774841, -0.025712307542562485, 0.014051446691155434, -0.03903902694582939, 0.0405803844332695, -0.006391076371073723, 0.050988055765628815, -0.009058033116161823, 0.023355234414339066, -0.05351126566529274, 0.00032569048926234245, -0.022925619035959244, -0.022611349821090698, -0.0301969051361084, 0.001808659639209509, 0.01550340373069048, -0.055927474051713943, 0.03775912895798683, 0.0556400828063488, -0.00933719240128994, -0.005453766789287329, -0.023582791909575462, -0.0005927380989305675, 0.033002909272909164, 0.05266477167606354, 0.011704938486218452, -0.008039062842726707, 0.03217557445168495, 0.025415470823645592, -0.028452178463339806, 0.05887932702898979, 0.047003526240587234, -0.006392255891114473, -0.018738916143774986, -0.027097830548882484, -0.009631332010030746, -0.010920635424554348, -0.00031672584009356797, 0.013431066647171974, 0.008845447562634945, 0.06448899954557419, -0.004129448439925909, -0.025294777005910873, 0.01200021430850029, 0.03381828963756561, 0.009052990935742855, 0.028085794299840927, -0.028609372675418854, -0.02361934632062912, -0.0014401032822206616, -0.015794461593031883, 0.07384217530488968, -0.008649483323097229, -0.02409079112112522, -0.02236914075911045, 0.06861969083547592, -0.007106866221874952, -0.025300581008195877, -0.013024190440773964, 0.05155221000313759, 0.03574099391698837, -0.014780131168663502, -0.05468097701668739, 0.03970787301659584, 0.0340857096016407, 0.02499188482761383, 0.0471416637301445, -0.015499576926231384, -0.0716695562005043, -0.034994374960660934, 0.03261740133166313, 0.01794608123600483, -0.004340387415140867, 0.016969822347164154, -0.06181621178984642, -0.0026317702140659094, 0.026657728478312492, -0.014590295031666756, 0.011187574826180935, -0.047073476016521454, 0.016973474994301796, -0.020387303084135056, -0.010759866796433926, -0.024050822481513023, -0.028179587796330452, -0.017063604667782784, 0.03667668253183365, -0.019784430041909218, -0.02037779986858368, -0.01701452024281025, -0.0018089700024574995, -0.006884071044623852, 0.05117923766374588, -0.007452419027686119, -0.016914021223783493, -0.010794457979500294, 0.06825928390026093, -0.012743784114718437, -0.07046925276517868, -0.00292800460010767, 0.014428072609007359, -0.0016382749890908599, 0.07698274403810501, -0.017479510977864265, -0.034672852605581284, 0.02095828577876091, 0.03738345950841904, -0.048154085874557495, -0.019708165898919106, 0.007204373367130756, 0.03697009012103081, 0.04026595130562782, -0.00007261557038873434, 0.08403176814317703, 0.013028513640165329, -0.02153169736266136, -0.026195021346211433, -0.009666834026575089, 0.03793714940547943, -0.0357130728662014, -0.003751900279894471, -0.050743356347084045, -0.0008731326088309288, -0.0202287957072258, -0.002328445902094245, -0.01830143667757511, 0.03199486806988716, -0.04585171863436699, -0.011252018623054028, 0.008490216918289661, 0.02834482491016388, 0.002792985877022147, 0.011714509688317776, -0.02365790866315365, 0.02351456508040428, 0.008072631433606148, -0.04454273730516434, -0.004292689263820648, 0.030032780021429062, 0.009575382806360722, 0.020553046837449074, -0.02140229009091854, 0.024112369865179062, -0.03935041278600693, -0.049992531538009644, 0.015582673251628876, -0.039047811180353165, 0.024528739973902702, 0.0070378901436924934, 0.012445515021681786, 0.01485795620828867, -0.03307582065463066, -0.028469286859035492, -0.0014071770710870624, -0.013134310021996498, 0.021046046167612076, -0.06644966453313828, 0.022846078500151634, -0.0033941660076379776, 0.02486744150519371, -0.06801733374595642, -0.024652624502778053, 0.02418563887476921, -0.01515345461666584, -0.0053479657508432865, -0.037368420511484146, -0.01049216277897358, -0.03540373593568802, -0.042187005281448364, -0.01600046269595623, 0.03325898200273514, -0.042050063610076904, -0.006960299331694841, 0.019167831167578697, 0.048451513051986694, 0.05417371541261673, -0.008476386778056622, -0.017197735607624054, 0.0388013981282711, -0.027016092091798782, -0.026948848739266396, 0.010847731493413448, 0.021359451115131378, -0.012807760387659073, 0.01592591404914856, -0.046854183077812195, 0.022081367671489716, 0.02403705194592476, 0.02440873347222805, -0.014623251743614674, 0.017336953431367874, 0.0247795432806015, -0.007924255914986134, -0.0252093393355608, -0.045138999819755554, -0.02449699491262436, 0.01833493635058403, -0.006053662858903408, -0.02971152774989605, 0.03142186999320984, 0.005057475529611111, 0.0451011136174202, -0.004865124821662903, 0.0037481728941202164, 0.033248480409383774, 0.08085264265537262, 0.013412795029580593, 0.03258316591382027, 0.016989998519420624, -0.038596875965595245, 0.031325049698352814, 0.00925951637327671, -0.004209946375340223, 0.03289256989955902, 0.03781861439347267, -0.04284709319472313, -0.0034645255655050278, -0.06362611800432205, 0.023588260635733604, 0.08866817504167557, -0.02604246325790882, 0.06987524777650833, 0.02566845528781414, 0.014462663792073727, -0.015243171714246273, -0.05094336345791817, -0.008238418027758598, -0.019712969660758972, -0.042790792882442474, 0.046034716069698334, 0.022740153595805168, -0.004140208009630442, 0.012462196871638298, 0.0069390470162034035, -0.003309759544208646, -0.011355895549058914, 0.017275109887123108, 0.04125254601240158, -0.03285766392946243, -0.048629190772771835, -0.05187414586544037, 0.019838524982333183, -0.007292943075299263, 0.024416347965598106, -0.011841651983559132, -0.03467721864581108, 0.01882956735789776, 0.008267123252153397, 0.012859297916293144, -0.03463035449385643, -0.006274711806327105, -0.07022473961114883, 0.03397733345627785, -0.000025553928935551085, -0.07021672278642654, 0.013886111788451672, -0.00669716065749526, 0.015852604061365128, 0.012390578165650368, 0.018490418791770935, -0.04224570095539093, -0.02932933159172535, -0.019193733111023903, -0.05000963807106018, -0.01923574134707451, 0.02431538701057434, 0.01465513277798891, -0.04682121425867081, 0.050603557378053665, -0.031529445201158524, 0.04259563237428665, -0.004499433562159538, 0.01600571908056736, -0.006963942665606737, 0.11143754422664642, 0.033988241106271744, -0.008766574785113335, -0.04921157658100128, 0.015521211549639702, 0.09519215673208237, 0.04911639541387558, 0.015684202313423157, -0.06447850167751312, 0.011815560050308704, -0.04440205544233322, -0.017689377069473267, -0.020414460450410843, 0.014131895266473293, -0.009324179030954838, 0.02514241635799408, 0.024155601859092712, 0.021930193528532982, 0.012776692397892475, -0.01117035560309887, 0.04395017400383949, -0.04949673265218735, -0.030401960015296936, -0.0041100038215518, -0.00702486140653491, -0.0018406311282888055, -0.01078481413424015, -0.06829890608787537, 0.03144792839884758, -0.037729330360889435, 0.013641338795423508, -0.04996980354189873, -0.012097926810383797, -0.009968673810362816, -0.019432242959737778, -0.005748108495026827, -0.0010496099712327123, -0.027909735217690468, -0.009954697452485561, -0.04870783910155296, 0.01010956522077322, 0.0002587841299828142, -0.009305284358561039, 0.016240375116467476, -0.011521655134856701, -0.01946827955543995, 0.00782216526567936, 0.006305274087935686, -0.029971402138471603, -0.022781983017921448, 0.015451730228960514, -0.008706611581146717, 0.06690172106027603, -0.02722303569316864, -0.0015972245018929243, 0.006186302285641432, 0.0038558999076485634, -0.004800925496965647, -0.03686697408556938, 0.0029363350477069616, 0.003183412831276655, 0.019689690321683884, -0.0353706069290638, -0.022263526916503906, -0.01403785403817892, 0.009536859579384327, -0.0036715040914714336, 0.024456601589918137, 0.02584075555205345, -0.013797396793961525, -0.004838017281144857, -0.015593948774039745, 0.06457682698965073, -0.0002560613793320954, 0.008379780687391758, 0.017248420044779778, -0.009212372824549675, -0.02708902209997177, -0.016533970832824707, 0.041587647050619125, -0.04160677269101143, 0.060838356614112854, -0.010694338008761406, 0.010191132314503193, -0.012077989988029003, -0.06159992143511772, 0.04316172003746033, -0.02092069387435913, -0.01453209389001131, -0.027513520792126656, 0.014777556993067265, 0.02468980848789215, 0.04400496929883957, 0.033344317227602005, 0.0088533079251647, -0.019212890416383743, 0.018163425847887993, -0.014274973422288895, -0.031844086945056915, -0.007458329666405916, -0.00238818465732038, -0.012086283415555954, -0.012155687436461449, 0.005299500655382872, 0.04662429541349411, 0.05935881286859512, 0.04293715953826904, -0.023907121270895004, 0.03955451026558876, -0.0074013592675328255, 0.0032258082646876574, -0.013065638020634651, -0.02170555666089058, 0.0018226411193609238, 0.039607275277376175, 0.013919991441071033, -0.07188823074102402, 0.010453233495354652, -0.023468617349863052, -0.013247785158455372, -0.00979363452643156, -0.02414601482450962, -0.037413690239191055, 0.019062720239162445, -0.022735022008419037, 0.03842867910861969, -0.010228192433714867, 0.002116370014846325, -0.038309380412101746, 0.018793445080518723, -0.008010064251720905, 0.0157470740377903, 0.0021562965121120214, -0.018408797681331635, -0.0006523480406031013, -0.004509232472628355, 0.04239976778626442, -0.007812902331352234, 0.03355986997485161, 0.031931906938552856, 0.00201640697196126, -0.00823606364428997, 0.04022979736328125, -0.03798871859908104, -0.004385401960462332, 0.028497835621237755, -0.046826884150505066, -0.056967996060848236, 0.0243831779807806, 0.019296426326036453, 0.032186780124902725, -0.026998795568943024, -0.011798395775258541, -0.049081772565841675, 0.016793912276625633, -0.022268906235694885, 0.025104280561208725, -0.04580236226320267, -0.00885765627026558, 0.007777043152600527, -0.03950724005699158, 0.024226218461990356, 0.003527806606143713, 0.004111854825168848, 0.007860427722334862, 0.03956311568617821, -0.0075743901543319225, 0.014150059781968594, 0.004518129397183657, -0.015052692033350468, -0.018457313999533653, 0.01776423305273056, 0.00039609384839423, 0.030336445197463036, 0.06168960779905319, -0.029193874448537827, 0.01348357554525137, -0.007183372974395752, 0.03363413363695145, -0.06790699809789658, -0.010425418615341187, 0.005571526475250721, 0.007325143553316593, 0.04804117605090141, -0.06141797453165054, -0.0033492129296064377, 0.0381767600774765, -0.03817513585090637, 0.024020811542868614, 0.008924592286348343, 0.0020925209391862154, -0.034047674387693405, 0.009919608943164349, -0.04581831023097038, 0.060401856899261475, 0.015011666342616081, 0.01095782220363617, 0.01369229145348072, 0.07838043570518494, 0.0006625468377023935, 0.004057120066136122, -0.003573427675291896, 0.024214185774326324, 0.008438754826784134, -0.02740313857793808, 0.07741875946521759, -0.024585368111729622, -0.028518110513687134, 0.04135473072528839, 0.00456226198002696, -0.024096447974443436, -0.002936519216746092, 0.02348075434565544, 0.003245936706662178, 0.018004773184657097, 0.04528961330652237, -0.006504048127681017, 0.009336112067103386, -0.010757007636129856, 0.021717824041843414, 0.018571849912405014, 0.023232946172356606, 0.03836805745959282, -0.01709810271859169, 0.01594778522849083, -0.037122681736946106, 0.026938719674944878, 0.015298466198146343, -0.028149427846074104, 0.007951635867357254, 0.02698429860174656, -0.00499893631786108, -0.03515953943133354, 0.01997293159365654, -0.02986687421798706, -0.018513476476073265, 0.06685089319944382, -0.013753936626017094, -0.021579043939709663, -0.00341493240557611, -0.018906792625784874, -0.052904773503541946, 0.031309887766838074, -0.04102154076099396, -0.028864186257123947, -0.03732553496956825, 0.019030245020985603, 0.014548201113939285, -0.025351522490382195, -0.022564148530364037, -0.01355687715113163, -0.06005006283521652, 0.00838929321616888, -0.002421261975541711, -0.03775155171751976, -0.021659281104803085, -0.018480800092220306, 0.0084035350009799, -0.05501869320869446, 0.07341498136520386, -0.01719851978123188, -0.03953500837087631, -0.025126466527581215, -0.024953849613666534, -0.0014472187031060457, -0.014807136729359627, 0.026875240728259087, -0.0033729886636137962, 0.017538532614707947, -0.008389685302972794, 0.05625934153795242, 0.022684898227453232, -0.03345467522740364, 0.0561583936214447, 0.027358660474419594, -0.027424870058894157, 0.0024929549545049667, -0.05900487303733826, -0.005220907740294933, 0.02610497549176216, 0.0124318553134799, 0.01639661006629467, 0.020748931914567947, 0.02025594748556614, 0.012434973381459713, 0.027216648682951927, 0.034261781722307205, 0.0060002729296684265, 0.086502805352211, -0.013858352787792683, 0.0277217049151659, 0.023186510428786278, 0.02765691839158535, -0.024626243859529495, 0.003050162922590971, -0.032716963440179825, -0.02892899513244629, -0.019260887056589127, -0.006043446250259876, 0.02335496060550213, -0.04837641492486, -0.02273508347570896, 0.04162468761205673, -0.06251191347837448, -0.01942976750433445, 0.035631995648145676, 0.012757014483213425, 0.03901844099164009, 0.0092716533690691, -0.005291074980050325, 0.017698165029287338, -0.026875769719481468, -0.004902704153209925, 0.04275426268577576, 0.022958166897296906, -0.004465154837816954, 0.00895526260137558, 0.01577753573656082, -0.01854364387691021, 0.05595985800027847, 0.01506293285638094, 0.025008495897054672, -0.04332370311021805, -0.050239406526088715, -0.0013407516526058316, 0.014819106087088585, -0.01012454368174076, -0.011735981330275536, -0.014661068096756935, 0.03750256448984146, -0.026666611433029175, -0.011852999217808247, 0.008064591325819492, 0.008723719976842403, -0.030083682388067245, 0.010270056314766407, -0.015320936217904091, 0.03796056658029556, -0.004316024482250214, 0.000508297118358314, -0.010675160214304924, 0.020483214408159256, 0.03947477415204048, -0.007855113595724106, 0.027941443026065826, -0.012457136064767838, -0.033769600093364716, 0.016338562592864037, -0.0424211248755455, -0.015492657199501991, -0.030065948143601418, -0.008701703511178493, 0.04312600567936897, 0.004341000225394964, -0.01629076898097992, -0.03516723960638046, -0.030655747279524803, 0.036066241562366486, -0.09145544469356537, -0.017248649150133133, 0.02139643207192421, -0.017060797661542892, 0.002873664954677224, -0.004145137965679169 ]
<p>I have been looking for an alternative to Google Docs as a web based spreadsheet application as my employer's corporate firewall now blocks this application. I kicked around a few alternatives such as Zoho.com. I found the latter practically unusable. All its applications took a long time to load and really did not work well if at all most of the time. </p> <p>When I came across EditGrid, I was delighted. It feels pretty much like Excel on a lot of counts. However, there is no apparent support besides a Help Center that is inactive and invariably does not address the problems I have. For instance, I have no idea how to include titles and legends within charts. I also don't see how one can create folders. </p> <p>I thought maybe someone would be familiar with EditGrid and either being able to help me out directly or point me in a direction of a support group somewhere. Thanks in advance for any info. </p>
74,489
[ -0.04360364377498627, -0.012241876684129238, 0.027149761095643044, 0.015396691858768463, 0.058899689465761185, 0.0030675302259624004, -0.0034461382310837507, -0.020831793546676636, 0.0010067865950986743, -0.03596993535757065, 0.04840238019824028, 0.05884575843811035, 0.04289219155907631, 0.04371596872806549, 0.02102423831820488, -0.0494677871465683, -0.020376864820718765, 0.01132829487323761, -0.016481343656778336, -0.01471772976219654, -0.04343116655945778, 0.012274536304175854, 0.009909658692777157, 0.01182619296014309, 0.020603524520993233, -0.012265365570783615, 0.0006956804427318275, -0.01657913625240326, -0.01684299111366272, 0.017599061131477356, -0.03667769581079483, -0.016124986112117767, 0.019932087510824203, 0.029911907389760017, 0.043398045003414154, -0.028525853529572487, -0.019273797050118446, -0.03657251596450806, -0.03391057625412941, -0.001181308296509087, -0.00670324033126235, 0.01914752461016178, -0.01787649467587471, 0.039796262979507446, -0.030603671446442604, 0.03479684516787529, -0.03255189582705498, -0.014490693807601929, 0.03221571817994118, -0.036379072815179825, 0.05937231332063675, -0.0008610551594756544, 0.05558240786194801, 0.020210837945342064, -0.03165657818317413, 0.009708236902952194, 0.024868318811058998, 0.03718259930610657, 0.004195258021354675, -0.03610708937048912, 0.0036868948955088854, -0.007559607736766338, 0.009630667045712471, -0.034549780189991, -0.03511675447225571, 0.03225380927324295, -0.030320344492793083, 0.011881889775395393, 0.0344543531537056, -0.004124954808503389, 0.007268055342137814, 0.04062023386359215, 0.014898519963026047, -0.0015552283730357885, 0.041817352175712585, -0.08896861970424652, 0.011774825863540173, -0.011216407641768456, 0.02973499335348606, 0.05302078649401665, 0.004601634107530117, 0.055567096918821335, 0.03562881797552109, 0.0038011278957128525, 0.023957176133990288, -0.010774330236017704, 0.11278646439313889, -0.025599833577871323, 0.025807227939367294, -0.0044176471419632435, -0.013924691826105118, -0.025923343375325203, 0.024125641211867332, 0.055981725454330444, 0.013424130156636238, -0.007548860739916563, -0.04132869094610214, 0.05888083204627037, -0.009334632195532322, 0.013550379313528538, 0.0195196233689785, 0.00693700322881341, 0.012553072534501553, 0.05208313465118408, -0.05782552808523178, -0.010186868719756603, -0.04432104527950287, -0.04629256948828697, 0.00602089473977685, -0.01441563293337822, 0.011215835809707642, 0.028136713430285454, -0.009885241277515888, -0.025526300072669983, 0.008890236727893353, -0.0177746694535017, -0.01628430187702179, 0.02243068255484104, 0.03472788259387016, 0.0775635614991188, 0.049604929983615875, -0.045450810343027115, 0.028551403433084488, -0.038635171949863434, -0.06955742835998535, 0.001617445144802332, -0.0014447406865656376, -0.021885082125663757, -0.04247624799609184, 0.06253032386302948, -0.013044686056673527, -0.004601791966706514, 0.005419066641479731, -0.005266972351819277, 0.043970923870801926, -0.018046462908387184, -0.08077901601791382, -0.06022327020764351, 0.06170101836323738, 0.0035625456366688013, -0.019790509715676308, -0.047543756663799286, -0.010004468262195587, 0.004967941902577877, 0.03352158144116402, 0.02126307412981987, -0.003786246757954359, 0.04138124734163284, -0.005431006196886301, -0.017160657793283463, -0.02993074432015419, 0.004585691262036562, -0.012835786677896976, -0.040411464869976044, 0.02725926600396633, -0.04955587908625603, 0.03937040641903877, 0.0022509517148137093, -0.0017802754882723093, -0.0307575985789299, 0.013062658719718456, 0.03431385010480881, -0.012311071157455444, 0.030471518635749817, 0.0054679266177117825, -0.031641874462366104, 0.08049014955759048, 0.003156340681016445, 0.031975988298654556, 0.02864704467356205, 0.022932255640625954, 0.0022870306856930256, 0.04335261508822441, -0.008718261495232582, 0.05432809516787529, 0.019990965723991394, -0.031859613955020905, -0.009679139591753483, 0.006121725309640169, -0.008631657809019089, -0.04463156685233116, -0.04756036028265953, -0.016050375998020172, -0.016711942851543427, 0.036584168672561646, 0.01478949561715126, 0.04241575673222542, -0.00425812928006053, 0.024438584223389626, -0.059909041970968246, -0.02727539651095867, -0.0631454735994339, 0.04147890955209732, 0.0010034932056441903, 0.0357542522251606, -0.01525377482175827, 0.03524560108780861, 0.03294095769524574, -0.0002507626195438206, -0.01856755092740059, -0.013241482898592949, 0.015608979389071465, 0.003410209435969591, -0.06761927157640457, -0.04631582275032997, 0.055266980081796646, 0.029662085697054863, -0.06005152314901352, 0.04118124395608902, -0.04944910481572151, -0.06966159492731094, -0.036572039127349854, -0.04151276871562004, 0.008556160144507885, -0.007825388573110104, -0.031485505402088165, -0.007213382050395012, 0.027214115485548973, -0.014324777759611607, 0.017758170142769814, -0.021479813382029533, 0.023271288722753525, 0.04026951268315315, 0.0250896867364645, 0.042039211839437485, -0.0014319003093987703, 0.0010567964054644108, 0.008133194409310818, -0.01759067177772522, 0.0040537286549806595, -0.015320410951972008, 0.010443304665386677, 0.06913422793149948, -0.01682819053530693, -0.018177244812250137, 0.008315425366163254, 0.06553101539611816, -0.002109203953295946, -0.00783624965697527, -0.013214693404734135, -0.02280026115477085, 0.02419215254485607, 0.016564710065722466, 0.04148392379283905, 0.02465427853167057, 0.04750068485736847, 0.003672197461128235, -0.010029236786067486, 0.012682782486081123, -0.016141358762979507, -0.03725164011120796, 0.032320380210876465, 0.0049314433708786964, 0.003663543378934264, 0.01775999180972576, 0.00584082305431366, 0.08298356831073761, -0.0015890715876594186, -0.0113803930580616, 0.005877380724996328, 0.004794269800186157, -0.041730042546987534, 0.018812788650393486, 0.002996382536366582, -0.037741079926490784, 0.016125613823533058, -0.047058556228876114, -0.05368297919631004, 0.005882454104721546, -0.026257364079356194, 0.03260703384876251, -0.03992347791790962, -0.014107320457696915, -0.08267326653003693, 0.020222913473844528, -0.004874927457422018, 0.02645687945187092, 0.023127535358071327, -0.0036608821246773005, -0.04535337910056114, -0.014352479949593544, -0.012838938273489475, -0.011203091591596603, 0.0010592809412628412, -0.015490512363612652, -0.0188720915466547, -0.010797170922160149, 0.018193189054727554, 0.05759863927960396, 0.025892863050103188, -0.0132210124284029, 0.02500985935330391, 0.02861085906624794, -0.03721068426966667, -0.019420558586716652, -0.020618731155991554, 0.03817041590809822, -0.018529754132032394, 0.0016631698235869408, 0.03232914209365845, -0.004735095892101526, -0.009207535535097122, 0.049750737845897675, -0.0521448478102684, 0.008196658454835415, -0.05433791130781174, 0.05163289234042168, -0.01377407368272543, -0.03243514522910118, -0.0036089459899812937, 0.022692978382110596, -0.030430616810917854, -0.006271648220717907, -0.046243228018283844, -0.051911480724811554, 0.020008327439427376, -0.0035767925437539816, 0.019988540560007095, 0.013273267075419426, -0.018012702465057373, 0.021830134093761444, 0.005136089865118265, -0.04617633670568466, -0.08603307604789734, -0.02591414377093315, 0.025801977142691612, -0.013498743996024132, 0.05074916034936905, -0.0014124710578471422, -0.02786893956363201, -0.03189083933830261, -0.007680882234126329, 0.0056549604050815105, 0.011243369430303574, -0.008863055147230625, 0.0188582930713892, 0.012767582200467587, 0.0062355962581932545, 0.005202974658459425, 0.013936602510511875, 0.02169659733772278, -0.032735615968704224, -0.033815059810876846, -0.04214783012866974, 0.0066439430229365826, 0.023359039798378944, -0.05813365802168846, 0.0011231229873374104, -0.002994383918121457, 0.07504653185606003, -0.019163282588124275, 0.01532015297561884, -0.0067547643557190895, -0.024043964222073555, 0.01307704858481884, 0.029623838141560555, 0.06562108546495438, 0.007256268057972193, -0.04346312955021858, 0.04981909319758415, 0.04541965201497078, -0.019337978214025497, -0.025013403967022896, -0.0019665551371872425, -0.0022148957941681147, 0.02900599129498005, -0.017611064016819, 0.004641186445951462, 0.07262907177209854, 0.0622662715613842, -0.006399037782102823, 0.010837369598448277, -0.03303724527359009, 0.0069900453090667725, -0.08138234168291092, 0.006474616471678019, -0.02546834573149681, 0.02897733449935913, -0.003577378811314702, 0.04900582507252693, 0.029556792229413986, 0.024168075993657112, 0.025389695540070534, 0.00709884287789464, -0.08477988094091415, 0.012756682932376862, -0.028521940112113953, 0.01847817376255989, -0.010638711974024773, 0.014466815628111362, -0.013003562577068806, 0.03469650447368622, -0.016143960878252983, -0.01549453753978014, 0.005615973379462957, -0.03669492155313492, 0.02609858289361, -0.02038116753101349, 0.022310765460133553, 0.023781199008226395, -0.005924620199948549, 0.003354375483468175, 0.00044231751235201955, 0.024633796885609627, 0.016789661720395088, 0.000055174452427309006, -0.0798676460981369, -0.025928271934390068, -0.0008318822947330773, 0.02012621983885765, 0.024243243038654327, -0.007790228817611933, 0.01494526769965887, -0.020564233884215355, -0.004997191485017538, -0.019391505047678947, 0.019443102180957794, -0.0013824887573719025, 0.0321521982550621, 0.0037021103780716658, -0.061894841492176056, 0.010379333049058914, -0.000385033170459792, -0.01077254582196474, -0.0027340722735971212, 0.016981394961476326, 0.01104909460991621, 0.013482523150742054, -0.06042466685175896, 0.024128710851073265, 0.06409445405006409, 0.049521304666996, 0.008891990408301353, -0.009026174433529377, -0.02604767680168152, -0.028364406898617744, -0.055950406938791275, 0.01756591722369194, 0.04597807675600052, 0.0068106092512607574, 0.056133970618247986, -0.0027768288273364305, -0.06301003694534302, -0.02323245257139206, -0.013075180351734161, 0.026029882952570915, 0.04152124375104904, -0.02334226667881012, 0.029551727697253227, 0.0446641780436039, 0.03152180463075638, 0.03825908154249191, 0.0029491866007447243, 0.012308774515986443, -0.10563535988330841, 0.015660857781767845, 0.05516144260764122, 0.061792805790901184, -0.03156469017267227, 0.0110948346555233, -0.028633922338485718, -0.03807169944047928, 0.017693668603897095, -0.06651075929403305, 0.0042132483795285225, -0.050487034022808075, -0.008880659937858582, -0.01279586274176836, -0.018338991329073906, 0.02942633256316185, 0.00022815869306214154, -0.04676102474331856, 0.0069553442299366, -0.011516112834215164, 0.015752630308270454, -0.013606848195195198, 0.04801908880472183, 0.0009906420018523932, 0.07364770770072937, 0.02713492326438427, -0.010092617943882942, 0.01717398688197136, 0.006754748988896608, -0.07201582938432693, -0.05547155812382698, -0.013678964227437973, 0.01413241308182478, 0.00773056223988533, 0.04095686227083206, -0.007821335457265377, -0.03585897386074066, 0.01648717001080513, 0.0323801226913929, -0.05150049552321434, -0.010916918516159058, -0.009221376851201057, 0.01897622086107731, 0.06356601417064667, -0.007538282312452793, 0.07200518995523453, 0.04504784941673279, -0.017245791852474213, 0.008437080308794975, -0.03806984797120094, 0.007722135167568922, -0.015606729313731194, -0.012890760786831379, -0.03554213419556618, -0.0003956420405302197, -0.05907868593931198, 0.003070889040827751, -0.003386245807632804, 0.012181518599390984, -0.05232280492782593, -0.025292713195085526, 0.010895712301135063, -0.002134541980922222, 0.03412226587533951, -0.05459805205464363, 0.02659338340163231, 0.029635215178132057, 0.010270983912050724, -0.033874768763780594, 0.04033822566270828, 0.015991680324077606, -0.011311006732285023, -0.012851117178797722, -0.013834639452397823, -0.008860290050506592, -0.02542070299386978, 0.00003172106153215282, -0.01435019075870514, -0.024218976497650146, 0.04894936829805374, -0.02082955464720726, 0.05745091661810875, 0.003040843177586794, -0.0303655918687582, -0.016177019104361534, 0.007104554213583469, -0.01717297174036503, -0.010533616878092289, -0.020826539024710655, 0.07768508791923523, 0.030019208788871765, -0.027949517592787743, -0.043644215911626816, -0.0606122650206089, 0.021875379607081413, 0.01825815439224243, -0.0005418139626272023, -0.00553519930690527, -0.005367218982428312, -0.0030868551693856716, -0.03641807287931442, 0.011786353774368763, -0.032618679106235504, -0.007467755116522312, 0.01225748099386692, 0.03646406903862953, 0.0269327349960804, 0.05117160454392433, -0.005153871141374111, 0.018654735758900642, -0.007102452218532562, 0.022839637473225594, -0.01181512326002121, 0.0012957776198163629, 0.020826207473874092, -0.013459596782922745, -0.018020566552877426, -0.026030292734503746, 0.006058830767869949, -0.020773019641637802, -0.01001809909939766, 0.05218106135725975, 0.0444493405520916, -0.012690862640738487, -0.019360598176717758, -0.05705074220895767, 0.030620433390140533, -0.013823181390762329, -0.01594911515712738, -0.01821281388401985, 0.008275153115391731, -0.003421204863116145, 0.020751817151904106, -0.009014059789478779, -0.007150270510464907, 0.013031532987952232, 0.018993861973285675, 0.09662648290395737, 0.0044142333790659904, 0.023944484069943428, 0.005352465435862541, -0.05708501487970352, -0.015130551531910896, -0.011934632435441017, -0.006150230299681425, -0.011350997723639011, 0.040107548236846924, -0.062313396483659744, -0.028821134939789772, 0.004390479065477848, -0.018750876188278198, 0.03320535272359848, -0.010826470330357552, 0.000052519542805384845, 0.030530454590916634, -0.007828283123672009, -0.0005007889703847468, -0.05457913503050804, -0.019940625876188278, 0.010149011388421059, 0.02489062212407589, 0.07194692641496658, 0.024147864431142807, 0.0024123727343976498, 0.03239734470844269, 0.016227122396230698, 0.020375272259116173, 0.043066736310720444, 0.0462133064866066, -0.017693206667900085, -0.007525311317294836, -0.030096914619207382, -0.05573052912950516, 0.009595554322004318, -0.036554303020238876, 0.050694797188043594, -0.010066373273730278, -0.0325809046626091, 0.027899961918592453, 0.012894710525870323, -0.017179518938064575, -0.0013407885562628508, -0.016875935718417168, -0.026564236730337143, 0.02503950521349907, -0.010697641409933567, -0.030277196317911148, 0.029612932354211807, -0.04289025068283081, 0.03565317019820213, -0.010963221080601215, -0.008276979438960552, -0.014087816700339317, -0.0592971071600914, 0.0068704308941960335, -0.01920609548687935, -0.049555618315935135, 0.05224498733878136, 0.005283656995743513, -0.009071530774235725, -0.01604747399687767, -0.001286700484342873, -0.03723416104912758, -0.01724463701248169, 0.035318754613399506, -0.0230688638985157, 0.03433064743876457, -0.01393248699605465, 0.016030123457312584, 0.004613115452229977, -0.04573538154363632, 0.12289505451917648, 0.08294255286455154, 0.04075731337070465, -0.07341077923774719, -0.0026450054720044136, 0.030122952535748482, 0.014483924023807049, -0.0065415906719863415, -0.01667630672454834, -0.028105024248361588, 0.020415037870407104, 0.030573582276701927, 0.06623008102178574, 0.02606257237493992, 0.04346704110503197, 0.035972196608781815, -0.0057913511991500854, -0.04216906428337097, -0.013880537822842598, -0.007834446616470814, -0.015375722199678421, -0.01835821196436882, -0.1028435006737709, 0.020593466237187386, 0.0038675516843795776, -0.027527229860424995, -0.043474163860082626, -0.03230845183134079, 0.01970847137272358, 0.02358420565724373, -0.05048467963933945, -0.01613643765449524, 0.0062781888991594315, -0.0003424752503633499, -0.006430725567042828, -0.008945085108280182, -0.021323932334780693, 0.02176789380609989, 0.007671484723687172, 0.06632981449365616, -0.028839461505413055, -0.014805133454501629, -0.01774592511355877, 0.012202084064483643, -0.06317517906427383, 0.0024738130159676075, -0.013715396635234356, -0.0013678789837285876, -0.012932254001498222, -0.011041254736483097, -0.038739413022994995, 0.007145559880882502, -0.016062185168266296, -0.031103262677788734, 0.000735741457901895, -0.005293012131005526, 0.047045331448316574, -0.00871002022176981, -0.02031593769788742, 0.016165638342499733, 0.030393844470381737, -0.03369731828570366, 0.015300790779292583, 0.05992361158132553, -0.03597503527998924, -0.013567334040999413, -0.03894776850938797, 0.0006934877601452172, -0.0030567930079996586, -0.006608102936297655, 0.018258757889270782, 0.02880733646452427, -0.037536993622779846, -0.018656505271792412, 0.005875514354556799, 0.039710693061351776, 0.03289564326405525, 0.011457966640591621, 0.023101171478629112, -0.005386613309383392, -0.04581345245242119, 0.05464794859290123, -0.023774605244398117, -0.046185143291950226, -0.02857915498316288, 0.03759879991412163, 0.04748072475194931, -0.008582835085690022, 0.045340653508901596, 0.05435642600059509, -0.016485435888171196, 0.015724940225481987, -0.028635205700993538, 0.011280822567641735, -0.04487514868378639, 0.04154304787516594, -0.045127660036087036, 0.012641075998544693, -0.020787809044122696, 0.053747326135635376, -0.013576285913586617, -0.005781237967312336, -0.026104215532541275, 0.03776802122592926, 0.0037590176798403263, 0.02439608797430992, -0.005930725950747728, -0.054144810885190964, -0.00561685161665082, -0.022342218086123466, 0.011512930504977703, -0.01642237976193428, -0.006012091878801584, -0.036273516714572906, -0.008400993421673775, 0.01460107322782278, 0.03354810178279877, -0.046832699328660965, 0.003560907207429409, -0.02266409434378147, 0.023582732304930687, -0.02388707920908928, 0.012185133062303066, -0.03529002517461777, -0.013704321347177029, -0.030766719952225685, 0.0040770941413939, 0.005143775604665279, 0.0027912126388400793, -0.0008283183560706675, 0.018190011382102966, -0.0073839761316776276, 0.038305848836898804, 0.005864567589014769, 0.010644196532666683, -0.03519978001713753, 0.0026918977964669466, 0.04799140617251396, -0.04686247557401657, -0.012442808598279953, 0.06912072002887726, -0.013455296866595745, -0.04890185967087746, 0.027766544371843338, 0.0075090182945132256, 0.0303565114736557, 0.01358247734606266, -0.049413178116083145, -0.021713484078645706, 0.065543033182621, 0.04128647595643997, -0.008600867353379726, -0.04766751453280449, -0.024385353550314903, 0.02566567063331604, 0.03192721679806709, 0.01048428937792778, -0.007743416354060173, -0.02569199539721012, 0.005332989618182182, 0.02257043868303299, 0.0143981222063303, -0.0025685483124107122, 0.015963396057486534, 0.04774979501962662, 0.007123907096683979, 0.02213570848107338, -0.016322363168001175, 0.008117161691188812, 0.027553381398320198, -0.05835141986608505, 0.028243808075785637, 0.04918193817138672, -0.006713979411870241, -0.02233806811273098, 0.003019526833668351, 0.00703918794170022, 0.010747215710580349, 0.011039431206882, -0.01968218758702278, 0.015609762631356716, 0.04050351306796074, -0.03236465901136398, 0.01674497127532959, 0.0017819538479670882, -0.023057805374264717, -0.0056338063441216946, 0.0035061254166066647, 0.012466128915548325, -0.0006843261071480811, 0.04081321507692337, 0.009856109507381916, 0.019949879497289658, 0.01901603862643242, -0.02169536054134369, -0.010784395970404148, -0.01481885090470314, 0.03226156905293465, 0.0048092445358633995, -0.017551623284816742, 0.01723398081958294, -0.019051572307944298, -0.03490467742085457, 0.032035745680332184, -0.0017479637172073126, 0.046020589768886566, 0.012543311342597008, 0.006040897220373154, -0.0007173037156462669, 0.044424932450056076, 0.0005858169752173126, -0.020341038703918457, -0.03389814868569374, 0.017492016777396202, 0.011211554519832134, 0.01974240504205227, 0.03179440274834633, 0.033208321779966354, 0.002843323163688183, 0.03624531999230385, -0.018423186615109444, 0.013808364048600197, -0.02295796014368534, 0.04266248643398285, -0.017842847853899002, -0.016393518075346947, 0.02242979221045971, -0.024127040058374405, 0.012806564569473267, -0.03999709337949753, 0.0013808972435072064, 0.025266719982028008, -0.012705315835773945, 0.015696601942181587, 0.02818637527525425, 0.008499248884618282, -0.009879850782454014, -0.002198456786572933, -0.014096845872700214, -0.011801832355558872, -0.06125541031360626, 0.010168004781007767, -0.04071074724197388, -0.010842756368219852, 0.03008292056620121, 0.02306678146123886, 0.0263358261436224, 0.035728372633457184, 0.007159464992582798, -0.03275175392627716, -0.018737541511654854, 0.006433703936636448, 0.0032288639340549707, -0.053675513714551926, 0.05884627625346184, 0.032421573996543884, -0.05145875737071037, 0.010003606788814068, -0.005984390154480934, 0.01867811195552349, 0.01719244383275509, 0.05874430015683174, -0.01803225465118885, 0.006647039670497179, -0.04409654065966606, 0.005605400074273348, 0.013147756457328796, -0.056561179459095, 0.04169223830103874, -0.009896948002278805, -0.0590595118701458, 0.0026697178836911917, -0.007215168792754412, -0.000604432774707675, -0.010280595161020756, 0.019275737926363945, -0.07189203798770905, -0.0007880868506617844, 0.007353105582296848, -0.01784311793744564, 0.01880219765007496, 0.011264282278716564, -0.03589930757880211, 0.07406123727560043, -0.03392549231648445, 0.006379523314535618, 0.041511714458465576, 0.015269411727786064, 0.02129976451396942, 0.04924424737691879, -0.07343519479036331, 0.019326455891132355, 0.0004234632942825556, -0.006630985531955957, -0.0009984305361285806, -0.055556200444698334, 0.009325183928012848, -0.002368329092860222, -0.0019505221862345934, 0.010211492888629436, 0.03497683256864548, 0.03337462246417999, 0.06519688665866852, 0.013515673577785492, -0.004069724585860968, -0.002086333464831114, -0.03995528072118759, 0.020423175767064095, -0.0068437024019658566, 0.01815982162952423, 0.06142434850335121, 0.004995456896722317, 0.03833940625190735, -0.007324164733290672, 0.014995347708463669, 0.024264510720968246, 0.016791250556707382, -0.008481522090733051, -0.022048549726605415, -0.00007723370072199032, -0.01055172085762024, 0.01766207069158554, 0.01270685438066721, -0.025127634406089783, 0.049774281680583954, -0.020972780883312225, -0.002151490654796362, -0.06210782006382942, -0.028192756697535515, -0.026583893224596977, -0.01728033646941185, -0.016209425404667854, 0.028433844447135925, -0.008279513567686081, 0.049825627356767654, 0.007991171441972256, 0.0057732160203158855, 0.057696837931871414, 0.026521552354097366, 0.02925993874669075, -0.040815141052007675, 0.003256244584918022, 0.0310884527862072, -0.03540613874793053, -0.01517084427177906, 0.014790745452046394, 0.013741772621870041, 0.011487261392176151, -0.010294058360159397, -0.028405679389834404, -0.02514197863638401, 0.0037634880281984806, 0.009321406483650208, -0.05122584477066994, -0.03515562042593956, -0.04044519364833832, -0.007597252726554871, 0.001443806104362011, 0.020466912537813187 ]
<p>I am looking for methods which can be used to estimate the "OLS" measurement error model.</p> <p>$$y_{i}=Y_{i}+e_{y,i}$$ $$x_{i}=X_{i}+e_{x,i}$$ $$Y_{i}=\alpha + \beta X_{i}$$</p> <p>Where the errors are independent normal with unknown variances $\sigma_{y}^{2}$ and $\sigma_{x}^{2}$. "Standard" OLS won't work in this case.</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_error_model" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a> has some unappealing solutions - the two given force you to assume that either the "variance ratio" $\delta=\frac{\sigma_{y}^{2}}{\sigma_{x}^{2}}$ or the "reliability ratio" $\lambda=\frac{\sigma_{X}^{2}}{\sigma_{x}^{2}+\sigma_{X}^{2}}$ is known, where $\sigma_{X}^2$ is the variance of the true regressor $X_i$. I am not satisfied by this, because how can someone who doesn't know the variances know their ratio?</p> <p>Anyways, are there any other solutions besides these two which don't require me to "know" anything about the parameters? </p> <p>Solutions for just the intercept and slope are fine.</p>
37,379
[ -0.02795051969587803, 0.021625759080052376, -0.00877197552472353, -0.01796441152691841, 0.027433933690190315, -0.0024828610476106405, -0.021573059260845184, -0.012330123223364353, 0.03992841765284538, -0.03999408334493637, 0.03142783045768738, 0.026699230074882507, 0.07312922179698944, 0.05538554489612579, 0.053613193333148956, -0.021081630140542984, -0.012165773659944534, 0.02642381191253662, -0.006188808009028435, 0.0022917846217751503, 0.008453106507658958, -0.016133474186062813, -0.02961890585720539, -0.024835005402565002, -0.020960265770554543, 0.0354834720492363, 0.02955280803143978, -0.0176195427775383, -0.008203518576920033, 0.06480930745601654, -0.009207707829773426, -0.024616306647658348, 0.015495693311095238, 0.03644398972392082, 0.004926899913698435, -0.0025778862182050943, 0.024469787254929543, -0.021037928760051727, -0.02000708319246769, 0.05153642222285271, -0.050386328250169754, -0.009153561666607857, 0.006821113638579845, 0.02019842155277729, 0.023981226608157158, 0.01815248467028141, -0.01111383643001318, -0.04304220527410507, 0.023569099605083466, -0.034318603575229645, 0.11469121277332306, -0.01622045785188675, 0.042958687990903854, 0.026879282668232918, -0.0195931363850832, 0.011154542677104473, 0.07162328064441681, 0.0631556361913681, -0.025074822828173637, -0.0258460845798254, -0.044544655829668045, -0.004676313605159521, 0.0074557592160999775, -0.019669441506266594, -0.03254593536257744, 0.008160922676324844, -0.017771631479263306, -0.03488949313759804, 0.032912928611040115, -0.0025696877855807543, -0.004426353611052036, 0.005795622244477272, 0.015354486182332039, 0.023098763078451157, 0.007250173483043909, -0.02756538800895214, -0.0024148407392203808, -0.003795887343585491, 0.037133850157260895, 0.03625230863690376, 0.020605700090527534, 0.007343103643506765, 0.03826506808400154, 0.022281289100646973, -0.014788022264838219, -0.019732750952243805, 0.05170607194304466, -0.005034243687987328, 0.032862406224012375, 0.03226141631603241, 0.0007061999058350921, 0.01721869967877865, 0.026430226862430573, -0.01971130445599556, -0.061744727194309235, 0.05180688574910164, -0.0014134577941149473, 0.04862966015934944, 0.0009778598323464394, 0.0022131160367280245, -0.0041298395954072475, -0.04348469898104668, 0.003407103009521961, 0.041196439415216446, -0.023607052862644196, -0.04619394242763519, 0.00979138445109129, 0.008289836347103119, -0.013600805774331093, -0.06833935528993607, 0.01630634069442749, 0.00012006785982521251, -0.0006359515828080475, 0.01722969487309456, 0.03208315744996071, -0.0203546229749918, -0.04434733837842941, -0.032890837639570236, 0.04714749753475189, 0.09061137586832047, 0.0012204648228362203, -0.015360399149358273, -0.00213796179741621, 0.021283024922013283, -0.024120483547449112, 0.030727559700608253, 0.04042447730898857, -0.034801166504621506, -0.05489758402109146, 0.04217846691608429, 0.015428224578499794, -0.0376724898815155, 0.04011491686105728, 0.009601021185517311, 0.0065503171645104885, 0.005912735592573881, -0.10430765151977539, -0.0825701579451561, 0.004559612367302179, -0.0034691602922976017, -0.006122698076069355, -0.07992886006832123, 0.001581127173267305, 0.03671669960021973, 0.03723274916410446, 0.029377548024058342, 0.034466639161109924, 0.021133240312337875, 0.0014107216848060489, 0.008092451840639114, -0.01913476176559925, -0.03406357765197754, 0.00029197780531831086, -0.050371911376714706, -0.0010861309710890055, -0.05070650205016136, -0.009857194498181343, 0.0054526785388588905, -0.0296850074082613, 0.010961889289319515, 0.013132236897945404, 0.025993885472416878, -0.05165854096412659, 0.024584153667092323, 0.03570210188627243, -0.04215923696756363, 0.03978880122303963, -0.01712256297469139, 0.013483926653862, 0.005238388665020466, -0.010370539501309395, -0.012588190846145153, 0.010601723566651344, 0.015504513867199421, 0.07103242725133896, -0.022233424708247185, -0.042828191071748734, -0.0191385205835104, 0.007110144477337599, 0.04131833836436272, -0.07429195940494537, -0.033475298434495926, -0.022064395248889923, -0.008158671669661999, 0.012685863301157951, 0.043291039764881134, -0.006561939138919115, -0.0014417200582101941, 0.026069276034832, -0.05008983612060547, -0.018952351063489914, -0.050173304975032806, 0.026914235204458237, -0.010605164803564548, -0.008432785049080849, 0.02067187801003456, 0.0066213952377438545, -0.007935174740850925, -0.008664628490805626, -0.04477617144584656, -0.0031957305036485195, 0.010032430291175842, 0.05720892176032066, -0.031133772805333138, 0.009882775135338306, 0.028021633625030518, 0.061028674244880676, -0.025526894256472588, 0.04544690251350403, -0.026141883805394173, -0.026742495596408844, -0.022345013916492462, -0.04564228653907776, 0.018165895715355873, -0.021876024082303047, -0.029388315975666046, -0.002501634182408452, -0.035934049636125565, -0.015496081672608852, 0.005574874579906464, -0.06000307947397232, 0.05502062663435936, 0.052261125296354294, 0.02439749613404274, -0.001927538774907589, 0.033041734248399734, 0.013335533440113068, 0.017833853140473366, -0.04433102905750275, -0.008806826546788216, -0.04023057222366333, -0.00370994140394032, 0.031262002885341644, 0.021537790074944496, -0.049694206565618515, 0.034964073449373245, 0.043046899139881134, 0.034289103001356125, 0.004994225222617388, 0.03577285259962082, 0.002670499961823225, -0.017196662724018097, -0.022777004167437553, -0.00004174635250819847, 0.002826305106282234, 0.04105272889137268, 0.0032121476251631975, 0.013472182676196098, 0.037021901458501816, 0.0113989831879735, 0.01613764651119709, 0.01366692129522562, 0.0036125080659985542, 0.0009542382904328406, 0.026808811351656914, -0.028765838593244553, 0.05382252112030983, 0.013166873715817928, 0.039976272732019424, 0.040014587342739105, -0.01565510965883732, -0.0015634341398254037, 0.033227529376745224, 0.007020820863544941, 0.029947005212306976, 0.008384411223232746, -0.05120190605521202, 0.0037651530001312494, 0.004786505829542875, -0.02285308949649334, -0.011325675994157791, -0.025901557877659798, -0.0022685457952320576, -0.024928981438279152, -0.0007739450666122139, 0.009638452902436256, 0.01748264953494072, 0.00577891431748867, -0.002893619006499648, -0.05083214491605759, 0.009576649405062199, -0.02756350114941597, 0.006893876474350691, 0.010618341155350208, -0.03302561119198799, -0.009739409200847149, -0.03846266120672226, -0.007031826768070459, 0.018158596009016037, -0.005422835238277912, -0.004746255464851856, 0.017491517588496208, -0.006212777458131313, -0.051451873034238815, -0.012270827777683735, -0.03897880017757416, -0.004415686707943678, 0.007610603701323271, -0.007744400762021542, 0.027883179485797882, -0.023781267926096916, -0.03847207874059677, 0.02006453275680542, -0.06416936218738556, -0.009451317600905895, -0.03241158276796341, -0.002568113151937723, 0.020138433203101158, -0.026359155774116516, 0.041416481137275696, 0.04333840683102608, -0.01071486622095108, -0.031128982082009315, -0.05930455029010773, -0.0800831988453865, 0.012695572338998318, 0.02482898347079754, 0.006889657583087683, -0.0011580092832446098, -0.02932809479534626, 0.07683608680963516, 0.009222078137099743, -0.008252675645053387, -0.026105718687176704, 0.01416083239018917, 0.014877046458423138, -0.052109118551015854, 0.009203539229929447, 0.0014176595723256469, 0.009177122265100479, 0.05142228677868843, -0.0357905849814415, 0.00496238749474287, 0.05042227730154991, 0.009641752578318119, 0.013177420012652874, -0.013650310225784779, 0.009951930493116379, -0.0165878776460886, 0.05371077358722687, 0.020400382578372955, -0.007868610322475433, -0.006123796571046114, 0.06393882632255554, 0.03885018453001976, 0.007189626339823008, -0.037426020950078964, -0.013470001518726349, -0.04839065670967102, -0.019439179450273514, -0.02292390912771225, -0.005963792093098164, 0.02678787335753441, -0.009462453424930573, -0.022891275584697723, 0.04513948783278465, 0.008377672173082829, 0.006194878835231066, 0.019109638407826424, 0.04373905435204506, 0.020466476678848267, 0.01920013315975666, -0.01630266197025776, -0.0011656285496428609, -0.014551067724823952, 0.017152313143014908, -0.021239982917904854, -0.02176399528980255, 0.0619613341987133, 0.030679011717438698, 0.0321534164249897, -0.015397654846310616, -0.03990885615348816, 0.035963501781225204, -0.0746440440416336, 0.018354706466197968, -0.031349066644907, 0.056253645569086075, 0.017034363001585007, 0.04123374819755554, 0.010914717800915241, -0.01627810113132, 0.01564338430762291, -0.004610840231180191, -0.05645275115966797, 0.027904147282242775, -0.03684978559613228, -0.05064163729548454, 0.02332865260541439, 0.0051825023256242275, 0.05589081719517708, -0.045038510113954544, -0.007913441397249699, -0.004806754179298878, 0.051153942942619324, -0.015391221269965172, 0.004381880164146423, 0.006602511741220951, -0.03248481824994087, -0.0021552047692239285, 0.01602003537118435, -0.028348058462142944, -0.05215923860669136, -0.010461781173944473, 0.03289416432380676, -0.004918891005218029, -0.01957164704799652, -0.05156242474913597, -0.016935639083385468, -0.0036419937387108803, 0.05531696975231171, 0.018244557082653046, 0.032466523349285126, -0.029073506593704224, 0.03206014633178711, 0.004779480397701263, 0.03642403334379196, 0.03711108863353729, 0.00011306141823297366, -0.006627087015658617, -0.003623436437919736, -0.02041814848780632, 0.0008876128122210503, 0.024707036092877388, -0.01857823319733143, -0.006461917422711849, 0.06915056705474854, 0.030458087101578712, -0.041372064501047134, 0.015038919635117054, 0.04784725606441498, 0.006756530608981848, 0.03522700071334839, 0.026952754706144333, -0.006588467862457037, 0.0009135127766057849, -0.001883872551843524, 0.006287372671067715, -0.007434403989464045, 0.011096278205513954, -0.043635301291942596, 0.0528641939163208, -0.015935316681861877, -0.002881502965465188, 0.005791826639324427, 0.01393106672912836, 0.04090474173426628, 0.019754866138100624, -0.017702173441648483, -0.009138268418610096, 0.03262893855571747, 0.06586480885744095, 0.02567681483924389, 0.004598875530064106, -0.06348410248756409, 0.009871792048215866, 0.017586475238204002, 0.030556675046682358, -0.061407849192619324, -0.014255794696509838, -0.022336963564157486, -0.04061274230480194, 0.046395186334848404, -0.03960244357585907, 0.03250763565301895, -0.012876048684120178, 0.011899631470441818, -0.0032426477409899235, -0.014476790092885494, -0.06411004811525345, 0.002514927415177226, 0.007782394532114267, 0.028142178431153297, -0.006344382185488939, -0.039449628442525864, -0.028814829885959625, -0.010625039227306843, 0.015564311295747757, 0.08401472121477127, -0.0025248131714761257, -0.018204471096396446, 0.01835954561829567, 0.06595996767282486, -0.047238755971193314, -0.07728194445371628, 0.008461205288767815, 0.006844460964202881, -0.027214765548706055, 0.03384487330913544, 0.010558092035353184, -0.060880694538354874, 0.003479717532172799, 0.014340885914862156, -0.022601205855607986, 0.011352458037436008, -0.014200004749000072, 0.02305617183446884, 0.04678961634635925, 0.039288923144340515, 0.08414865285158157, 0.02089943177998066, 0.011723082512617111, -0.018303142860531807, -0.028530975803732872, -0.0040442198514938354, -0.059637024998664856, -0.04302498325705528, -0.028449947014451027, 0.01912086084485054, -0.005302644334733486, 0.053661271929740906, 0.0065152901224792, 0.05988498777151108, -0.03359956294298172, -0.053916629403829575, 0.02161504700779915, 0.017763080075383186, -0.014392486773431301, -0.027145439758896828, 0.0017502387054264545, 0.05030957609415054, -0.00924636796116829, -0.009778810665011406, -0.01015598326921463, 0.0005606947233900428, -0.013810187578201294, 0.015792949125170708, -0.04386167600750923, 0.01689976640045643, -0.030033724382519722, -0.0363042950630188, -0.01466395054012537, -0.01570749096572399, 0.02898307889699936, -0.014783615246415138, 0.007918545044958591, -0.01447136327624321, -0.028607644140720367, -0.00787428393959999, 0.002276302082464099, 0.021660439670085907, 0.03871319070458412, -0.019384853541851044, -0.002179989591240883, -0.008620688691735268, 0.0077939643524587154, -0.09981589019298553, -0.05036572739481926, 0.007086437661200762, -0.008761292323470116, 0.00014188831846695393, -0.020828567445278168, 0.022410539910197258, -0.01862819492816925, -0.06943054497241974, -0.002042507752776146, 0.0432317852973938, -0.023541241884231567, -0.016665803268551826, -0.017208058387041092, 0.055731598287820816, 0.039967745542526245, -0.008530378341674805, 0.008899844251573086, 0.020049579441547394, -0.03600792959332466, -0.034385114908218384, 0.018848679959774017, 0.01481194980442524, -0.03261927142739296, -0.01779453456401825, -0.01651267521083355, -0.013052877970039845, 0.0566062293946743, -0.017416030168533325, -0.01843094266951084, 0.03136603906750679, 0.027782322838902473, -0.021994145587086678, -0.0026590372435748577, 0.012807438150048256, -0.021994467824697495, 0.016977686434984207, -0.007483243476599455, -0.01063748262822628, -0.04605172201991081, 0.025080159306526184, 0.04504534974694252, 0.024325799196958542, -0.03128868713974953, 0.027623359113931656, 0.10006298869848251, 0.012515588663518429, -0.028785165399312973, 0.03225469961762428, -0.013001014478504658, 0.03485533967614174, 0.03821880742907524, 0.023414360359311104, 0.02869260683655739, 0.027497075498104095, -0.03881969675421715, -0.07489048689603806, -0.004481066949665546, 0.008064876310527325, 0.09331673383712769, -0.02337174117565155, 0.050314392894506454, 0.034677162766456604, 0.01762826181948185, -0.01909373328089714, -0.017979027703404427, -0.0140424445271492, 0.003502940060570836, -0.024222802370786667, 0.06962799280881882, -0.027320699766278267, -0.02942260541021824, 0.03277816250920296, 0.015931960195302963, 0.019056852906942368, 0.03223336488008499, -0.014988865703344345, 0.044641364365816116, 0.020474489778280258, -0.027175646275281906, -0.04762314632534981, 0.02253984473645687, -0.02076464518904686, 0.004131061490625143, -0.017491867765784264, -0.021457472816109657, 0.045181144028902054, 0.011995900422334671, 0.001218317891471088, 0.00038059448706917465, -0.030107054859399796, -0.02782260626554489, 0.006706311833113432, 0.016673123463988304, -0.03843553736805916, 0.03576832264661789, 0.012206712737679482, 0.03680127114057541, -0.005965020041912794, 0.04185410588979721, -0.022081950679421425, -0.11875747889280319, -0.008299374021589756, 0.01660281792283058, -0.033312954008579254, 0.046296946704387665, -0.004887663293629885, -0.016878748312592506, 0.009229752235114574, -0.023358087986707687, 0.007439988665282726, 0.006273243110626936, 0.030091555789113045, -0.023781418800354004, 0.05593849718570709, -0.02908080630004406, -0.008088293485343456, -0.015329414047300816, 0.00023390614660456777, 0.08494637906551361, 0.10294826328754425, 0.03327563777565956, -0.0554068423807621, 0.016948923468589783, -0.015175734646618366, -0.00612256582826376, -0.00780376186594367, 0.016421644017100334, 0.014516939409077168, 0.00022223390988074243, 0.03162844106554985, 0.06973225623369217, 0.03341063857078552, -0.01834585703909397, 0.05082857236266136, -0.014111199416220188, -0.025688348338007927, 0.018347563222050667, -0.01035238802433014, -0.0022886996157467365, -0.0317121297121048, 0.012357950210571289, 0.05692827329039574, -0.010876864194869995, -0.019734200090169907, -0.02710244618356228, -0.021486666053533554, 0.006830867379903793, -0.00469587929546833, -0.047404415905475616, 0.01982750929892063, 0.0047928099520504475, 0.016919277608394623, 0.0035860356874763966, 0.011480290442705154, 0.024802720174193382, -0.004209060687571764, 0.01785891316831112, 0.02145608514547348, -0.0031898708548396826, 0.01115464512258768, 0.02635091543197632, 0.021798521280288696, -0.03237438574433327, -0.04487905651330948, -0.03110811486840248, 0.049192726612091064, -0.020401306450366974, 0.008305608294904232, -0.025389041751623154, -0.017066337168216705, -0.0106922322884202, -0.03270738944411278, 0.008275226689875126, 0.029978781938552856, 0.010685555636882782, -0.0615297332406044, -0.005393319297581911, 0.0014721965417265892, 0.008359664119780064, -0.016891688108444214, 0.03973519802093506, 0.02745538018643856, -0.040232520550489426, -0.03344867005944252, -0.01438051089644432, 0.0313473716378212, 0.04228751361370087, -0.0118234409019351, 0.003446373390033841, -0.03084377758204937, -0.006400370970368385, -0.014948631636798382, 0.03568767011165619, -0.005111707374453545, 0.03665954992175102, 0.008309446275234222, -0.005562481936067343, -0.029148252680897713, -0.037982866168022156, 0.009424552321434021, -0.021555382758378983, -0.0005743551882915199, -0.04856494441628456, -0.009244199842214584, 0.03499119356274605, 0.013566032983362675, 0.005057493224740028, -0.04312891513109207, 0.021622324362397194, 0.04084305465221405, -0.009045431390404701, -0.03389136120676994, -0.020115485414862633, 0.018084296956658363, -0.020933283492922783, -0.007657105568796396, 0.005280922167003155, 0.03847837075591087, 0.02406778559088707, 0.06741507351398468, -0.021514026448130608, 0.041499700397253036, -0.02922968752682209, 0.008432814851403236, 0.026198605075478554, -0.026557225733995438, -0.020091596990823746, 0.01290171593427658, 0.03723808005452156, -0.004956476856023073, -0.0008842031820677221, -0.03266771510243416, -0.04337763413786888, -0.01588468998670578, 0.011465098708868027, -0.050454024225473404, 0.006287276744842529, -0.023433418944478035, 0.019808636978268623, -0.030509406700730324, 0.01546780951321125, -0.008450418710708618, -0.013874703086912632, -0.016955001279711723, -0.0035160507541149855, -0.017098339274525642, 0.016067296266555786, 0.01624099351465702, 0.0004622667911462486, 0.05384904891252518, 0.053335998207330704, 0.005569996777921915, -0.0007418452296406031, -0.03217364102602005, 0.0517275296151638, 0.04619506001472473, -0.04203958436846733, 0.007581935729831457, 0.03938048705458641, -0.06069949269294739, -0.021078258752822876, 0.03343379870057106, -0.005612214561551809, 0.023836348205804825, 0.008975018747150898, -0.019843120127916336, -0.026384705677628517, 0.020274633541703224, -0.00818331353366375, 0.029932601377367973, -0.03709784150123596, 0.01750814914703369, 0.00021444605954457074, -0.010463190264999866, 0.032930243760347366, -0.02298005111515522, -0.0018450523493811488, 0.05168203264474869, 0.033216435462236404, -0.017386145889759064, 0.01453820988535881, 0.046429768204689026, 0.023253055289387703, -0.0030088578350842, 0.0029670505318790674, -0.005914686713367701, -0.009487898088991642, 0.026561396196484566, -0.03551606088876724, 0.020118501037359238, -0.010775397531688213, 0.008455339819192886, -0.07322253286838531, 0.006751715671271086, 0.0051213717088103294, 0.031068628653883934, 0.04560418054461479, -0.0409480556845665, -0.008435896597802639, 0.04064916446805, -0.042726196348667145, -0.04401145502924919, -0.028399888426065445, -0.02029409259557724, 0.01364823803305626, -0.016614196822047234, -0.015459432266652584, 0.023123575374484062, 0.03644770011305809, 0.021172868087887764, 0.008939353749155998, 0.0245415847748518, 0.007415828760713339, -0.05225555971264839, 0.004278458189219236, -0.0009396952227689326, 0.057577259838581085, -0.07246466726064682, 0.02682935632765293, -0.04502178356051445, 0.005252351053059101, 0.017351796850562096, 0.030012469738721848, 0.04999781399965286, -0.004062802996486425, 0.010113589465618134, -0.01668359339237213, 0.059757836163043976, 0.009579189121723175, 0.007417477201670408, -0.006272609811276197, -0.01216253824532032, 0.003170979907736182, 0.02886572666466236, -0.01460949145257473, -0.01774817332625389, 0.011159949004650116, -0.0026124620344489813, -0.04197503253817558, -0.0030915848910808563, -0.01485653780400753, -0.0277724526822567, 0.020632488653063774, -0.013805610127747059, 0.02452755533158779, -0.07181583344936371, 0.03924750164151192, -0.04435146972537041, -0.02205837517976761, 0.05116022005677223, 0.006754620932042599, -0.025859717279672623, 0.021410880610346794, -0.015005550347268581, -0.02784823067486286, 0.044250793755054474, -0.005422587040811777, -0.0022915853187441826, -0.08359089493751526, -0.0181268323212862, 0.000004229589194437722, -0.036738842725753784, -0.005364844109863043, -0.00013941423094365746, 0.0013995696790516376, 0.07556077092885971, -0.029982279986143112, 0.00740173552185297, -0.00414521899074316, -0.01002452801913023, 0.018260441720485687, -0.05608614534139633, 0.061289895325899124, 0.03759235516190529, -0.005089643876999617, -0.013266374357044697, -0.00844321958720684, -0.03349381312727928, -0.0050805239006876945, 0.07098837196826935, -0.004977562464773655, -0.00933707132935524, -0.0010676556266844273, 0.04235391691327095, -0.010379749350249767, -0.04376166686415672, 0.0545937716960907, -0.0010808341903612018, -0.024905679747462273, -0.04588087275624275, -0.013441236689686775, 0.015378461219370365, -0.02089444361627102, 0.024545943364501, -0.020754214376211166, -0.0015582275809720159, 0.029062435030937195, 0.007513898424804211, 0.008631359785795212, 0.011931540444493294, 0.0023673565592616796, 0.04186986759305, -0.015680277720093727, 0.025340326130390167, 0.05384400859475136, -0.020854104310274124, -0.06429311633110046, 0.02824820578098297, -0.02626246027648449, -0.002932988340035081, -0.039410531520843506, 0.026442725211381912, -0.014555441215634346, -0.01618417166173458, -0.012260138057172298, 0.0072227600030601025, -0.04648656025528908, -0.037367697805166245, 0.029596947133541107, 0.006827585864812136, 0.022675346583127975, -0.015138411894440651, 0.011526412330567837, 0.032771240919828415, -0.01653207838535309, -0.0011778038460761309, 0.01274955552071333, 0.07168959081172943, 0.021489402279257774, 0.009221050888299942, 0.04560691863298416, -0.012883972376585007, 0.02063010260462761, -0.03391603007912636, 0.03225914388895035, -0.03869888558983803, -0.021025845780968666, 0.02525258995592594, -0.025444528087973595, 0.006696751806885004, -0.020651595667004585, -0.04341105744242668, 0.06626234203577042, -0.046619683504104614, -0.006492838263511658, -0.04743659868836403, -0.004045569337904453, 0.004744172561913729, -0.013314868323504925, -0.019728705286979675, 0.0183450598269701, 0.026056498289108276, 0.03725510463118553, -0.017890557646751404, -0.009283460676670074, 0.003451906144618988, -0.04267602786421776, 0.015751784667372704, -0.02172870934009552, 0.0034753112122416496, -0.03062065877020359, -0.03621354326605797, -0.041596993803977966, -0.05315205454826355, 0.035285040736198425, 0.02681473083794117, 0.038557812571525574, -0.03492472320795059, -0.0288405604660511, -0.004356862045824528, 0.048056747764348984, -0.08184745162725449, -0.021182440221309662, 0.015209914185106754, -0.006247909273952246, -0.007167459931224585, -0.023026302456855774 ]
<p>I'm looking at doing text classification/spam filtering using naive Bayesian classifiers with the e1071 or klaR package on R. Is there a good tutorial out there to describe this? I'm kind of stuck because I'm not sure what to use as the data to input into the NaiveBayes function.</p> <p>Some help very much appreciated, thanks!</p>
74,490
[ -0.025529300794005394, -0.04441223293542862, -0.0012351659825071692, 0.001993631711229682, 0.018160348758101463, 0.0019782863091677427, 0.02260761521756649, 0.0067159803584218025, 0.005978275090456009, -0.01926960051059723, 0.047176212072372437, 0.08355379104614258, 0.03992127627134323, 0.01353692077100277, 0.008647804148495197, -0.013452166691422462, -0.009547709487378597, -0.002477309899404645, 0.016869988292455673, 0.013805716298520565, 0.01477988064289093, -0.016350969672203064, 0.023787587881088257, 0.016886811703443527, 0.0048992387019097805, 0.032462604343891144, 0.0015048333443701267, -0.012541744858026505, 0.005085873417556286, 0.02894223853945732, -0.013502169400453568, -0.030763661488890648, 0.00009900485747493804, 0.016620101407170296, 0.007290188688784838, -0.02373914234340191, -0.03816010430455208, -0.042610909789800644, -0.02080346643924713, 0.026146432384848595, -0.04588551074266434, -0.028147226199507713, 0.030088050290942192, 0.04165308177471161, -0.02992965653538704, -0.015469175763428211, -0.0025691702030599117, -0.02140938490629196, 0.006056166719645262, -0.062034863978624344, 0.052994515746831894, 0.025682957842946053, 0.020805584266781807, 0.05294403061270714, -0.01634216122329235, -0.018282998353242874, 0.054741330444812775, 0.06674760580062866, -0.030123213306069374, -0.04647786542773247, -0.04145639017224312, -0.024035628885030746, 0.0024977049324661493, -0.04544464498758316, -0.04875381290912628, 0.01998937875032425, 0.001093123690225184, -0.025727225467562675, 0.04850396513938904, -0.0019126558909192681, 0.015865150839090347, -0.006404845975339413, 0.04119053855538368, -0.03632799908518791, 0.0066197593696415424, -0.026722773909568787, 0.011387922801077366, 0.036224137991666794, 0.01987951062619686, 0.02545579895377159, 0.007317464333027601, -0.009686593897640705, -0.005099017173051834, 0.028040755540132523, 0.007281466852873564, -0.017269430682063103, 0.07406044006347656, -0.017704946920275688, 0.020840216428041458, 0.002507029101252556, -0.04788203164935112, 0.02507522515952587, 0.04928372800350189, 0.03819931298494339, -0.008776477538049221, 0.06241540238261223, 0.006823165342211723, 0.050667595118284225, -0.032361939549446106, -0.03408006206154823, 0.01889096014201641, -0.03844841942191124, 0.015278905630111694, 0.0751643031835556, -0.06129152700304985, -0.018759872764348984, -0.04411381855607033, -0.02155434899032116, -0.028049232438206673, -0.011033900082111359, -0.028668459504842758, 0.035112932324409485, -0.014165695756673813, -0.024008018895983696, 0.01669260486960411, -0.03412631154060364, 0.012756049633026123, -0.03119421750307083, 0.02510814554989338, 0.0399131216108799, 0.056673720479011536, 0.004589464049786329, 0.06270720064640045, -0.0332195945084095, -0.06390523165464401, -0.0020995584782212973, -0.004404745530337095, -0.02182266302406788, -0.009030075743794441, 0.06562771648168564, -0.058183930814266205, -0.03613271191716194, 0.059218235313892365, 0.01653415709733963, 0.026196187362074852, -0.020565127953886986, -0.07099225372076035, -0.0152724739164114, 0.022326288744807243, -0.009062208235263824, 0.010770236141979694, -0.06629976630210876, -0.02046666294336319, 0.014813324436545372, 0.00783677026629448, 0.030241331085562706, 0.02430180087685585, 0.00626908615231514, 0.02005545236170292, 0.013095458038151264, -0.04183172434568405, -0.017184479162096977, -0.0066468482837080956, 0.0326085165143013, -0.029376542195677757, -0.07314561307430267, 0.014970134943723679, 0.021702125668525696, -0.02853100188076496, -0.02336605079472065, 0.021542595699429512, 0.0016126042464748025, -0.01605256088078022, 0.0026072754990309477, 0.00040834376704879105, 0.00196499889716506, 0.08513109385967255, 0.06662026792764664, 0.02515583671629429, 0.006055847276002169, -0.012665723450481892, 0.04200715199112892, 0.02671544998884201, 0.023480728268623352, 0.028659088537096977, -0.01050349697470665, -0.004356991034001112, -0.03818351775407791, 0.030993742868304253, 0.00037863696343265474, 0.003328912425786257, -0.03947566822171211, 0.01230670977383852, -0.0029940849635750055, -0.019007159397006035, -0.0020006662234663963, 0.020965341478586197, -0.023624610155820847, 0.014648376032710075, -0.008397694677114487, -0.06643004715442657, -0.09537255018949509, -0.005547292996197939, -0.043384771794080734, -0.03282640501856804, -0.010896367952227592, 0.01798185519874096, 0.017474714666604996, -0.024728907272219658, -0.0016899771289899945, -0.042786870151758194, -0.01555556058883667, 0.03799973428249359, -0.03323792293667793, -0.02590327151119709, 0.05696752667427063, 0.018495522439479828, -0.04040548950433731, 0.03623034805059433, -0.020438851788640022, -0.060923073440790176, -0.0008565977332182229, -0.035314593464136124, 0.024116137996315956, -0.04433324933052063, -0.010428187437355518, 0.02307768724858761, 0.0005767777329310775, 0.012928210198879242, 0.004510793834924698, -0.0662357360124588, 0.04663390293717384, 0.07533076405525208, 0.029486162588000298, -0.025409676134586334, -0.01911480911076069, 0.01178048551082611, 0.04141993075609207, -0.02077683061361313, -0.01901225745677948, -0.054353222250938416, -0.006464051082730293, 0.05066005885601044, -0.011225512251257896, -0.026053568348288536, 0.02689741738140583, 0.004691959824413061, -0.0007831155089661479, 0.036020826548337936, 0.025019710883498192, -0.006210615858435631, 0.004475044552236795, 0.0328388512134552, 0.022768013179302216, -0.015669651329517365, 0.022710036486387253, 0.03732560947537422, 0.004421544726938009, 0.05566529184579849, 0.01974092423915863, -0.02738969400525093, 0.04521144926548004, -0.008275942876935005, 0.019421406090259552, -0.010593182407319546, -0.03446364402770996, 0.050381146371364594, -0.038682546466588974, -0.02034771256148815, 0.00701112300157547, 0.0198771171271801, 0.0009622187353670597, 0.035923443734645844, 0.010434431955218315, 0.0026201801374554634, 0.03999077528715134, -0.0054575055837631226, -0.0001906758116092533, 0.017324604094028473, -0.06306880712509155, 0.02241651713848114, 0.014196648262441158, -0.025754615664482117, -0.060588616877794266, 0.027028707787394524, 0.028183074668049812, 0.009339835494756699, -0.009101731702685356, -0.015991980209946632, -0.04305495694279671, 0.03723876550793648, -0.019103117287158966, 0.007549211848527193, -0.00796972680836916, -0.037293773144483566, 0.0030912067741155624, -0.020640676841139793, 0.002613204065710306, 0.01762613281607628, -0.025987982749938965, -0.035954561084508896, 0.005635461304336786, -0.009725774638354778, -0.026660706847906113, -0.01316770352423191, -0.017670532688498497, -0.004474751651287079, -0.025927986949682236, -0.0050110165029764175, 0.015173964202404022, 0.023627791553735733, -0.015002540312707424, 0.02394995465874672, -0.0374612919986248, -0.04088518023490906, -0.04361703246831894, -0.022531451657414436, -0.033765438944101334, -0.012825516983866692, -0.01928790658712387, 0.011658533476293087, -0.011923507787287235, 0.01538021583110094, -0.051531821489334106, -0.02789987437427044, 0.041337497532367706, 0.021511271595954895, 0.019693106412887573, 0.010981681756675243, -0.006376797799021006, 0.0767686739563942, 0.01080776285380125, -0.04289756715297699, -0.010890793986618519, -0.032176729291677475, -0.06191561743617058, -0.0025825328193604946, -0.004422157071530819, 0.007683063857257366, -0.020604394376277924, -0.01926521398127079, 0.015237816609442234, -0.003566981293261051, 0.06274546682834625, -0.0065766810439527035, -0.022393202409148216, 0.020967354997992516, -0.04225434735417366, -0.013447367586195469, 0.03127526491880417, 0.05390654504299164, -0.03881802409887314, 0.037488099187612534, 0.02868710085749626, 0.03413725271821022, 0.009303160011768341, -0.05307747796177864, -0.010106134228408337, 0.021592389792203903, 0.019950414076447487, -0.020591843873262405, -0.0018849847838282585, -0.01801813207566738, -0.011710734106600285, 0.008944619446992874, -0.021291160956025124, 0.03574437275528908, -0.030987869948148727, 0.010163064114749432, 0.03572283312678337, 0.03713219612836838, -0.009754342027008533, -0.034434687346220016, -0.02625541016459465, -0.014020921662449837, 0.0111148152500391, 0.00034450204111635685, 0.0158331748098135, 0.03688238561153412, 0.027730107307434082, 0.00786909181624651, 0.003622237592935562, -0.04163898155093193, 0.03108946979045868, -0.0738534927368164, -0.003009767970070243, 0.010641027241945267, 0.03294648602604866, -0.013025506399571896, 0.015293714590370655, 0.02648213319480419, -0.01683061756193638, 0.023780416697263718, 0.021059779450297356, -0.0412159189581871, 0.012451086193323135, -0.0339229553937912, -0.0313221774995327, -0.0015106602804735303, -0.002767897443845868, 0.03400846943259239, 0.008095360361039639, -0.008281795307993889, -0.015688521787524223, 0.007974282838404179, -0.04338894411921501, 0.002157654846087098, -0.03478438779711723, 0.015958143398165703, -0.002596850972622633, -0.005687799770385027, 0.025286363437771797, 0.02204681932926178, 0.004847988951951265, 0.03838551044464111, -0.002832218538969755, 0.010174219496548176, 0.003289211541414261, -0.012674982659518719, 0.026288693770766258, 0.04127296060323715, 0.020200839266180992, 0.014090988785028458, -0.041398949921131134, 0.015427910722792149, -0.038909316062927246, 0.053768109530210495, 0.029979754239320755, -0.0253060944378376, 0.0021929678041487932, -0.039837032556533813, -0.008890875615179539, 0.0006859928835183382, 0.01650814339518547, -0.03725839778780937, -0.023999974131584167, 0.04007415845990181, 0.0687844529747963, -0.0718182623386383, 0.022892402485013008, 0.05484804883599281, 0.06533600389957428, -0.013495827093720436, -0.02624744176864624, -0.00010355473932577297, 0.016119813546538353, -0.0005298619507811964, 0.02950192429125309, 0.03655548766255379, 0.0021127844229340553, -0.004392619244754314, 0.03396616131067276, -0.058463968336582184, -0.014055811800062656, -0.02863237075507641, 0.013226744718849659, 0.03314457833766937, -0.02682730183005333, -0.016757965087890625, 0.02322489395737648, 0.05401287600398064, 0.04418177902698517, -0.02374795824289322, 0.006219191011041403, -0.11947806924581528, -0.0010890732519328594, 0.051827576011419296, 0.040345508605241776, -0.023666657507419586, -0.0005105416057631373, -0.07541840523481369, -0.029406610876321793, 0.058791764080524445, -0.04988860711455345, 0.015102067030966282, -0.025267010554671288, -0.0021930858492851257, 0.014428938739001751, 0.016657263040542603, -0.0008128069457598031, 0.0031186973210424185, -0.048845674842596054, 0.06551210582256317, 0.017979199066758156, -0.012639620341360569, -0.048502128571271896, 0.009453198872506618, 0.022253865376114845, 0.05182887613773346, -0.02197626419365406, -0.0038589786272495985, 0.02815186232328415, -0.007113959640264511, -0.011889589950442314, -0.029368633404374123, 0.0015600866172462702, -0.009461762383580208, 0.004296720493584871, 0.06528528034687042, -0.03927268832921982, 0.006106377113610506, 0.021094053983688354, 0.0432763546705246, -0.03627266734838486, -0.04252878203988075, -0.01454671286046505, -0.01980586163699627, 0.02639583870768547, 0.004566613119095564, 0.06866950541734695, 0.0027449573390185833, 0.01752341352403164, 0.0002697640738915652, -0.05552534759044647, 0.038445062935352325, -0.027287770062685013, -0.04443185776472092, -0.08034256845712662, 0.0037752115167677402, -0.0023246060591191053, 0.024173390120267868, 0.029830263927578926, 0.020905308425426483, -0.040600620210170746, -0.028613023459911346, 0.030901320278644562, 0.06066085770726204, -0.023787489160895348, -0.009328354150056839, -0.006912498269230127, 0.04244597256183624, -0.02375689148902893, 0.00027751686866395175, 0.027957560494542122, 0.0014294811990112066, 0.02460682950913906, -0.02843690663576126, -0.04427304118871689, 0.029251260682940483, -0.051936328411102295, -0.005001828074455261, 0.04111746326088905, -0.038812607526779175, 0.06780045479536057, 0.011282465420663357, 0.016190189868211746, 0.0025711096823215485, -0.03275178000330925, -0.025659499689936638, -0.0009007782791741192, -0.030598344281315804, 0.03444512188434601, -0.03629172220826149, 0.02316754311323166, -0.010339922271668911, -0.03809221461415291, -0.058883439749479294, -0.054086167365312576, 0.02446265146136284, -0.030512448400259018, -0.013965561054646969, -0.05127247795462608, 0.01685524918138981, -0.0017581433057785034, -0.024610649794340134, 0.0006244107498787344, 0.042361196130514145, -0.003127831034362316, 0.0077055031433701515, 0.0061898366548120975, 0.010054775513708591, 0.06817089021205902, 0.022816356271505356, 0.001001879689283669, 0.024109944701194763, -0.02622203715145588, -0.007185884285718203, -0.013827288523316383, 0.004598109517246485, -0.03216777741909027, 0.019419029355049133, -0.04596712067723274, 0.05050206184387207, 0.027301477268338203, -0.029104704037308693, 0.011157786473631859, 0.02961800992488861, 0.016353297978639603, -0.006622703280299902, -0.05553632229566574, -0.025307519361376762, -0.012483589351177216, -0.002357067307457328, -0.06079002097249031, 0.010799244977533817, 0.016784464940428734, -0.03368237987160683, 0.053877681493759155, 0.004800398368388414, 0.0323578380048275, 0.044354941695928574, 0.060039639472961426, -0.004191723186522722, 0.06079103797674179, -0.009481684304773808, -0.019492682069540024, 0.04619207978248596, 0.013009562157094479, -0.0066982535645365715, 0.001976274186745286, 0.007506377529352903, -0.0201390590518713, -0.031985703855752945, -0.05933259800076485, -0.0115794837474823, 0.0685729905962944, 0.0003806153545156121, 0.04717766493558884, 0.02087337337434292, 0.017077045515179634, 0.005963990464806557, -0.030461309477686882, -0.036880478262901306, -0.03146135434508324, 0.040532298386096954, 0.03230062872171402, 0.015442525036633015, 0.02530048042535782, 0.0357857383787632, 0.005669744685292244, 0.05551290512084961, 0.04610281437635422, 0.03396201878786087, 0.029726743698120117, 0.019486572593450546, -0.0464535728096962, -0.020693283528089523, 0.019654806703329086, -0.019134391099214554, 0.022812101989984512, -0.01947934366762638, -0.07745643705129623, 0.03678002581000328, 0.03594308719038963, 0.0016380896558985114, -0.028745166957378387, -0.025458961725234985, -0.0386909618973732, 0.07998906075954437, 0.03320861980319023, -0.008677526377141476, 0.04798470437526703, 0.013184835202991962, 0.02363681234419346, 0.005790302995592356, 0.046827591955661774, -0.002125190105289221, -0.07158651202917099, -0.027635352686047554, -0.03578609600663185, -0.025875002145767212, 0.0027395710349082947, 0.030292056500911713, -0.039452966302633286, 0.013960469514131546, -0.05771305412054062, 0.060971640050411224, 0.024468442425131798, 0.04576481133699417, -0.012469134293496609, 0.04480893909931183, -0.021711599081754684, 0.026075497269630432, 0.03112463653087616, -0.009391611441969872, 0.11470316350460052, 0.061132319271564484, 0.06827282905578613, -0.09702600538730621, 0.019837331026792526, 0.045252326875925064, -0.021741321310400963, -0.02167177014052868, 0.005816575139760971, 0.012024052441120148, 0.018955329433083534, 0.002003676490858197, 0.02230086922645569, 0.025696512311697006, 0.003566163359209895, 0.05037430301308632, -0.0004995490307919681, -0.03810974583029747, 0.007788367103785276, 0.035232063382864, -0.013364067301154137, -0.016255702823400497, -0.0789048969745636, 0.04590143635869026, 0.020297696813941002, -0.05315544828772545, -0.014752083458006382, -0.049134261906147, -0.012262320145964622, 0.0014252333203330636, 0.04813658446073532, -0.013186146505177021, -0.009145415388047695, -0.04932261258363724, 0.07116979360580444, 0.015182171948254108, -0.013672233559191227, -0.021010415628552437, -0.008651948533952236, 0.006443454418331385, 0.03695325925946236, -0.015971360728144646, 0.018155379220843315, -0.020900197327136993, -0.03854687139391899, -0.01950303092598915, 0.0005140358698554337, 0.05175933241844177, -0.02482347935438156, 0.017197271808981895, -0.0025499893818050623, 0.012163087725639343, 0.026232842355966568, -0.05973388999700546, -0.0029097977094352245, 0.024570176377892494, 0.007739275228232145, -0.015741894021630287, 0.002148522064089775, -0.025117989629507065, 0.03653014823794365, -0.04118816927075386, 0.020981499925255775, 0.023853980004787445, 0.001242443802766502, -0.01934567093849182, -0.030680429190397263, -0.014850672334432602, -0.020692648366093636, -0.044220004230737686, 0.0005814166506752372, -0.028526199981570244, -0.025410564616322517, -0.015355422161519527, 0.013887382112443447, 0.04299510270357132, -0.010797134600579739, -0.038129761815071106, -0.016802310943603516, -0.007929982617497444, -0.004514800384640694, 0.01247967779636383, -0.03048722818493843, -0.0038462679367512465, -0.00975961796939373, 0.0031617614440619946, 0.048117611557245255, 0.011369203217327595, 0.03705981373786926, 0.04167202115058899, -0.009658289141952991, 0.018526660278439522, 0.02598428726196289, -0.02922915667295456, 0.0003329318715259433, -0.008409589529037476, -0.049104299396276474, 0.00336966454051435, 0.008898163214325905, 0.0532754622399807, 0.03393115475773811, 0.014201367273926735, -0.014606752432882786, 0.009575399570167065, -0.03390589356422424, 0.012552852742373943, -0.000993287656456232, -0.04677404835820198, 0.008823158219456673, -0.012900766916573048, -0.007032271008938551, -0.04181119054555893, -0.010009785182774067, -0.023756785318255424, -0.00007926060789031908, 0.023376313969492912, -0.0010537047637626529, -0.06068791449069977, 0.02770056389272213, -0.0021064728498458862, 0.027466030791401863, -0.05383048579096794, -0.009793132543563843, -0.021673081442713737, 0.017165012657642365, -0.013381478376686573, 0.0010529308347031474, -0.007425324060022831, 0.0030479184351861477, -0.020045123994350433, 0.010290899313986301, 0.009456783533096313, 0.004409851972013712, 0.030103961005806923, -0.006797436624765396, 0.03735676780343056, -0.03155999258160591, 0.06490354239940643, -0.04671751335263252, -0.0118492990732193, 0.03311125561594963, -0.0348983071744442, -0.017358245328068733, -0.0350588858127594, 0.01723431795835495, -0.011596225202083588, 0.009148893877863884, -0.05160922557115555, -0.019214067608118057, 0.06326515227556229, -0.0018479236168786883, -0.032414209097623825, 0.014052638784050941, 0.01343433279544115, 0.011588347144424915, 0.020987583324313164, 0.045944470912218094, -0.0019174347398802638, -0.008823566138744354, 0.0025397345889359713, 0.0184628926217556, 0.017257608473300934, -0.021322695538401604, 0.0045992350205779076, -0.010984198190271854, -0.011837787926197052, 0.006648417562246323, -0.004283839836716652, 0.020409224554896355, 0.0566137358546257, 0.014374691992998123, 0.026223724707961082, -0.003172864904627204, 0.009312892332673073, -0.055621515959501266, 0.008536262437701225, 0.01805911958217621, 0.006144849583506584, 0.048323482275009155, -0.05166713520884514, 0.021374240517616272, 0.05777399241924286, -0.012706364504992962, 0.02592349983751774, -0.0023138674441725016, -0.004522213712334633, -0.009218168444931507, 0.019232429563999176, -0.0178929902613163, 0.006765431724488735, 0.00747154513373971, 0.013696316629648209, 0.023840442299842834, 0.021104395389556885, -0.0003540907637216151, -0.0018049745121970773, 0.009212583303451538, 0.06936141103506088, 0.015079738572239876, -0.04265333339571953, 0.033212170004844666, -0.005169914104044437, -0.01504218764603138, 0.04769674316048622, 0.040619269013404846, -0.0010157526703551412, 0.025308802723884583, 0.03857039660215378, 0.019352268427610397, 0.05307361111044884, 0.02423885092139244, -0.008489140309393406, 0.014542446471750736, -0.005141285248100758, 0.025605270639061928, 0.03170440346002579, 0.014905793592333794, 0.012210303917527199, 0.006150324363261461, -0.0432724803686142, -0.0037998270709067583, 0.0050368113443255424, -0.030349628999829292, -0.014729119837284088, -0.008449389599263668, -0.04243534058332443, 0.0017026617424562573, -0.015774359926581383, 0.02499503269791603, -0.06884565204381943, -0.0010132445022463799, 0.06120330095291138, -0.01605670526623726, 0.00950225256383419, 0.04327678307890892, -0.001716097816824913, -0.0655105859041214, 0.00963527336716652, 0.0024078183341771364, -0.011654422618448734, -0.07661101967096329, 0.034015972167253494, 0.01680341549217701, -0.005552746821194887, -0.041366223245859146, -0.005176224280148745, -0.021425845101475716, 0.044447239488363266, -0.029087569564580917, 0.012209371663630009, 0.0254204198718071, -0.038780950009822845, 0.044392116367816925, -0.04057282209396362, 0.06899876892566681, 0.015409104526042938, -0.009804945439100266, -0.04011157155036926, -0.024498116225004196, -0.0341181717813015, -0.012335188686847687, 0.04019575193524361, -0.021897172555327415, 0.008020346984267235, -0.0315718948841095, 0.009179576300084591, 0.0026979960966855288, -0.049552593380212784, 0.04467463865876198, -0.007914362475275993, -0.04522402212023735, 0.000393477501347661, 0.015283196233212948, -0.010874774307012558, 0.008224784396588802, 0.0053121717646718025, -0.00006510147068183869, -0.01887214183807373, 0.021556617692112923, -0.04670746251940727, 0.02296888455748558, 0.009968436323106289, 0.025378864258527756, 0.013835452497005463, -0.028774186968803406, 0.010995987802743912, 0.047820188105106354, 0.02075236104428768, -0.012975032441318035, 0.0290127694606781, -0.0395905077457428, 0.0002475450746715069, 0.0023640375584363937, -0.0005302500212565064, 0.005527891218662262, -0.07546577602624893, 0.021425172686576843, 0.013671088963747025, -0.03955275937914848, 0.040519699454307556, 0.02853821963071823, -0.001138397492468357, 0.04885583743453026, 0.006010449957102537, 0.01346495095640421, 0.031511109322309494, -0.01748129539191723, 0.0037332605570554733, 0.0018480115104466677, 0.019997678697109222, 0.006557709537446499, 0.037239763885736465, 0.035595230758190155, -0.020053166896104813, 0.02414374239742756, -0.011332301422953606, 0.027254601940512657, -0.06023656204342842, -0.020634453743696213, -0.030843742191791534, 0.007456060033291578, -0.013371912762522697, -0.019644297659397125, -0.010164396837353706, 0.04892686754465103, -0.08239881694316864, 0.026072146371006966, -0.015052048489451408, -0.021039582788944244, -0.014527800492942333, 0.015391283668577671, -0.014713912270963192, 0.00046953573473729193, -0.0016522171208634973, 0.006671668030321598, 0.0045872218906879425, -0.009825249202549458, 0.043387122452259064, -0.03428219258785248, 0.008860471658408642, -0.010323337279260159, 0.00637552235275507, -0.002123217098414898, -0.025502750650048256, 0.007222514599561691, -0.0010046977549791336, -0.006214331369847059, 0.029095256701111794, 0.024162184447050095, -0.039294347167015076, -0.002404810395091772, 0.008939635939896107, 0.00887320190668106, -0.06686680018901825, 0.041649285703897476, -0.0509302094578743, -0.007344777695834637, -0.031260840594768524, 0.01573057658970356 ]
<p>This is closely related to a question I asked yesterday but I've now got a much more complete answer on which I was hoping to get feedback. The previous question was just looking for conceptual advice and was very helpful. You can find the relevant data and introduction <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/62646/pooled-time-series-regression-in-r">here</a>.</p> <p>I wanted to find period effects for each age group. I've run two regressions using dummies as part of an interaction term. I'm hoping to see if my method is flawed and if my interpretation of the results is correct or not. They first regression is as follows:</p> <pre><code>&gt; ## Generate YearDummy and AgeGroupDummy using factor() &gt; &gt; YearDummy &lt;- factor(YearVar) &gt; AgeGroupDummy &lt;- factor(AgeGroup) &gt; &gt; ## Check to see that YearDummy and CohortDummy are indeed factor variables &gt; &gt; is.factor(YearDummy) [1] TRUE &gt; is.factor(AgeGroupDummy) [1] TRUE &gt; ## Regress on AgeGroup and include AgeGroup*YearDummy interaction terms &gt; &gt; PooledOLS1 &lt;- lm(PPHPY ~ AgeGroup + AgeGroup*YearDummy + 0, data=maildatapooled) &gt; summary(PooledOLS1) Call: lm(formula = PPHPY ~ AgeGroup + AgeGroup * YearDummy + 0, data = maildatapooled) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -38.852 -10.632 3.298 11.275 26.481 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) AgeGroup 26.2212 3.5070 7.477 3.84e-10 *** YearDummy1 119.8836 15.6840 7.644 1.99e-10 *** YearDummy2 123.7458 15.6840 7.890 7.55e-11 *** YearDummy3 103.2660 15.6840 6.584 1.28e-08 *** YearDummy4 97.7102 15.6840 6.230 5.06e-08 *** YearDummy5 103.3295 15.6840 6.588 1.26e-08 *** YearDummy6 103.2330 15.6840 6.582 1.29e-08 *** YearDummy7 84.8291 15.6840 5.409 1.16e-06 *** YearDummy8 70.7114 15.6840 4.509 3.09e-05 *** YearDummy9 90.9566 15.6840 5.799 2.65e-07 *** YearDummy10 50.0885 15.6840 3.194 0.00224 ** YearDummy11 37.7004 15.6840 2.404 0.01933 * YearDummy12 33.1947 15.6840 2.116 0.03846 * AgeGroup:YearDummy2 1.8066 4.9597 0.364 0.71695 AgeGroup:YearDummy3 -3.8022 4.9597 -0.767 0.44632 AgeGroup:YearDummy4 -1.7436 4.9597 -0.352 0.72640 AgeGroup:YearDummy5 -6.0494 4.9597 -1.220 0.22735 AgeGroup:YearDummy6 -6.7992 4.9597 -1.371 0.17552 AgeGroup:YearDummy7 -3.6752 4.9597 -0.741 0.46158 AgeGroup:YearDummy8 -0.4799 4.9597 -0.097 0.92323 AgeGroup:YearDummy9 -9.8190 4.9597 -1.980 0.05232 . AgeGroup:YearDummy10 -2.2452 4.9597 -0.453 0.65241 </code></pre> <p>My interpretation of the interaction term coefficients is that they represent the difference in slope of AgeGroup between the period of the corresponding YearDummy and the AgeGroup slope at the top of the results. This is kind of like the AgeGroup effect across different periods.</p> <p>My second regression is as follows:</p> <pre><code>&gt; ## Regress YearVar and Include YearVar*AgeGroupDUmmy &gt; &gt; PooledOLS2 &lt;- lm(PPHPY ~ YearVar + YearVar*AgeGroupDummy + 0, data=maildatapooled) &gt; summary(PooledOLS2) Call: lm(formula = PPHPY ~ YearVar + YearVar * AgeGroupDummy + 0, data = maildatapooled) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -29.345 -9.325 -0.915 8.540 40.150 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) YearVar -7.089 1.252 -5.664 3.04e-07 *** AgeGroupDummy1 142.292 9.211 15.447 &lt; 2e-16 *** AgeGroupDummy2 185.508 9.211 20.139 &lt; 2e-16 *** AgeGroupDummy3 218.170 9.211 23.685 &lt; 2e-16 *** AgeGroupDummy4 255.733 9.211 27.763 &lt; 2e-16 *** AgeGroupDummy5 278.180 9.211 30.200 &lt; 2e-16 *** AgeGroupDummy6 300.910 9.211 32.667 &lt; 2e-16 *** AgeGroupDummy7 282.325 9.211 30.650 &lt; 2e-16 *** YearVar:AgeGroupDummy2 -1.737 1.770 -0.981 0.3298 YearVar:AgeGroupDummy3 -2.401 1.770 -1.357 0.1792 YearVar:AgeGroupDummy4 -3.772 1.770 -2.131 0.0366 * YearVar:AgeGroupDummy5 -2.915 1.770 -1.647 0.1040 YearVar:AgeGroupDummy6 -3.587 1.770 -2.026 0.0465 * YearVar:AgeGroupDummy7 -2.372 1.770 -1.340 0.1846 --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 14.97 on 70 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.9946, Adjusted R-squared: 0.9935 F-statistic: 917.9 on 14 and 70 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 </code></pre> <p>My interpretation of the interaction term coefficients here is that they represent the difference in slope of YearVar between the corresponding AgeGroup in the interaction term and the YearVar result at the very top. That is, they are something like a period effect across the different age groups.</p> <p>Can anyone see a problem with what I've done here or with my interpretation? This second regression is the closest thing to period effects across distinct age groups that I've been able to muster. Any critiques/new ideas are welcome.</p>
31,358
[ -0.0023073668126016855, -0.009668126702308655, 0.0025075466837733984, -0.007608457468450069, -0.013781342655420303, -0.025990035384893417, 0.012076543644070625, -0.05052558332681656, 0.04325403273105621, -0.013979675248265266, 0.04932224750518799, 0.007662869989871979, 0.048935338854789734, 0.003319860203191638, 0.015315636061131954, 0.04103437438607216, -0.013475769199430943, -0.011843692511320114, 0.013647681102156639, 0.0051623983308672905, -0.025363042950630188, 0.023252543061971664, -0.03236375376582146, -0.024244708940386772, -0.012089263647794724, 0.04398784413933754, 0.014962341636419296, -0.04693171754479408, -0.0017607707995921373, 0.031473346054553986, -0.03098314255475998, -0.031210757791996002, 0.0024438442196696997, -0.005265509709715843, 0.0278716329485178, 0.027829786762595177, -0.006612114608287811, 0.0026164585724473, 0.02308144047856331, 0.044306155294179916, -0.0399329736828804, -0.004546583164483309, 0.0022826935164630413, 0.03301592916250229, -0.007960819639265537, 0.015089992433786392, -0.006613429170101881, 0.04663790762424469, 0.07664245367050171, -0.0056565552949905396, 0.06162555515766144, 0.022616013884544373, 0.004921790212392807, 0.03485985845327377, -0.022280199453234673, -0.04156192019581795, 0.05755140632390976, 0.03870300576090813, 0.040342897176742554, -0.03331967815756798, -0.014043176546692848, -0.0006215536268427968, 0.019527575001120567, -0.019410554319620132, -0.051281172782182693, -0.024859201163053513, 0.048073094338178635, -0.013334803283214569, 0.024573445320129395, -0.036734916269779205, 0.02857608161866665, -0.01965126022696495, 0.007611867506057024, 0.0012471263762563467, 0.02354595996439457, -0.0464392751455307, -0.015772365033626556, 0.004551171790808439, 0.025162750855088234, 0.04604361578822136, -0.03783499076962471, 0.04647395387291908, 0.003110277932137251, 0.017384078353643417, 0.018763000145554543, 0.02631235122680664, 0.07729193568229675, -0.05206955224275589, 0.020565012469887733, -0.009455516934394836, -0.01700098253786564, 0.035381168127059937, 0.0539017878472805, 0.029430940747261047, -0.01378433033823967, 0.044083088636398315, -0.03783498331904411, 0.007985126227140427, 0.022763337939977646, 0.017402827739715576, -0.012104256078600883, -0.03489714115858078, 0.0386650413274765, 0.04033457115292549, -0.012312374077737331, -0.02997770719230175, -0.045649975538253784, -0.03518266603350639, 0.005735102575272322, -0.06080933287739754, -0.012890422716736794, 0.014709538780152798, -0.029668457806110382, -0.014861909672617912, 0.031702473759651184, -0.028064394369721413, -0.010622208006680012, 0.022187691181898117, 0.06641076505184174, 0.0708264708518982, 0.028356632217764854, -0.044298600405454636, 0.01807652972638607, -0.02505725435912609, -0.07503797858953476, 0.0033369939774274826, 0.03136187791824341, -0.00499726040288806, -0.04599112644791603, 0.04921842738986015, 0.015538192354142666, -0.04249822720885277, 0.05833616107702255, -0.010345779359340668, 0.009415868669748306, 0.01445127185434103, -0.09831923246383667, -0.06842850148677826, 0.018282825127243996, -0.030486248433589935, 0.012828225269913673, -0.041950471699237823, -0.018666857853531837, -0.021646849811077118, 0.0503576286137104, -0.01709629036486149, 0.034268029034137726, 0.0012309661833569407, 0.042673416435718536, 0.02904808707535267, -0.023920685052871704, 0.0008503592689521611, -0.020545220002532005, -0.0043532634153962135, 0.010212383233010769, -0.0730326920747757, -0.002564686816185713, 0.010693779215216637, -0.010185382328927517, 0.05833835527300835, 0.05056845769286156, -0.012022662907838821, -0.033958423882722855, 0.018623733893036842, 0.016984516754746437, -0.04012242332100868, 0.050020501017570496, -0.012278907001018524, 0.014866799116134644, 0.014612892642617226, -0.018777646124362946, 0.035821087658405304, 0.01263394020497799, 0.033134281635284424, -0.006307106930762529, -0.023122161626815796, 0.020898086950182915, -0.012615020386874676, -0.02586999721825123, -0.04388914257287979, -0.06808777153491974, -0.01989622600376606, -0.035219598561525345, -0.01620279811322689, 0.01384309958666563, 0.0238832775503397, -0.008327214047312737, 0.001649008016102016, 0.05518724024295807, -0.015004988759756088, -0.08732728660106659, -0.07491276413202286, -0.0026746022049337626, -0.03760785609483719, -0.038860004395246506, -0.018942570313811302, -0.035499148070812225, 0.03371404483914375, 0.0014339786721393466, 0.0021512373350560665, -0.04522857442498207, 0.03188987821340561, 0.01993199810385704, 0.006518010050058365, -0.01031207200139761, 0.00026347723905928433, 0.04990049824118614, -0.017939604818820953, 0.0034197934437543154, -0.053142402321100235, -0.021544836461544037, 0.016076480969786644, -0.045345813035964966, 0.048059120774269104, -0.03374424949288368, -0.04232925921678543, 0.025592749938368797, -0.005530427675694227, -0.020430371165275574, 0.05656690150499344, -0.05044347792863846, 0.0028208002913743258, 0.04034385830163956, 0.002910093404352665, -0.029231563210487366, 0.005568843334913254, 0.008940662257373333, 0.033267490565776825, -0.021122753620147705, 0.02330249361693859, -0.012781886383891106, -0.03946715220808983, 0.054083552211523056, 0.017738234251737595, 0.026249246671795845, -0.010763670317828655, 0.032380517572164536, -0.04543912038207054, 0.023699169978499413, 0.019796699285507202, 0.03159058094024658, 0.02003886178135872, 0.028354307636618614, 0.050316713750362396, 0.00719507597386837, 0.01870308816432953, 0.06680157035589218, -0.006579739041626453, 0.03839588910341263, 0.036367978900671005, 0.0006244920659810305, 0.06515053659677505, -0.019124776124954224, 0.01893947832286358, -0.035229530185461044, 0.014713995158672333, 0.03219260275363922, -0.03496069461107254, 0.01597536914050579, 0.004863016307353973, 0.003178487066179514, -0.012234525755047798, -0.0019279305124655366, -0.044886086136102676, -0.003443097695708275, 0.024423329159617424, -0.03233146667480469, -0.02175632119178772, 0.00025693117640912533, -0.024373697116971016, 0.016757408156991005, -0.03078148141503334, -0.026935352012515068, -0.030128484591841698, 0.003637702437117696, 0.007157313171774149, -0.010913386940956116, 0.034822117537260056, -0.03212334215641022, 0.005842094775289297, 0.013509958982467651, -0.0013890787959098816, 0.0276276133954525, -0.02498004585504532, -0.04696455970406532, -0.02682623267173767, -0.023672502487897873, 0.009752210229635239, 0.03408912941813469, 0.02357090823352337, -0.016757050529122353, 0.040567751973867416, 0.012997675687074661, -0.04861639067530632, -0.005274593364447355, -0.03357017785310745, -0.02889338694512844, -0.04455612227320671, -0.016207177191972733, 0.03265223652124405, 0.011329724453389645, -0.03446901589632034, 0.0064100404269993305, -0.033090755343437195, -0.020239615812897682, -0.016384808346629143, -0.03370710462331772, -0.028667790815234184, 0.003962271846830845, -0.022505179047584534, 0.015853973105549812, -0.015957240015268326, 0.018464526161551476, -0.07608772814273834, -0.024719560518860817, 0.04977922514081001, -0.005985702853649855, 0.005032682325690985, -0.015102604404091835, 0.00020247990323696285, 0.031202416867017746, 0.015204386785626411, -0.013795625418424606, -0.05598985403776169, 0.015703139826655388, -0.008504455909132957, -0.030645936727523804, 0.05070618540048599, 0.011375176720321178, 0.05159392207860947, 0.004736590199172497, -0.03970237448811531, 0.03200143575668335, 0.006868408061563969, -0.01622048392891884, -0.0012965294299647212, -0.00930085126310587, -0.0034978825133293867, -0.009161672554910183, 0.04705231636762619, 0.009215669706463814, -0.015741849318146706, 0.010668790899217129, -0.008389906957745552, 0.02762206457555294, -0.005256660748273134, -0.04139189422130585, -0.014686406590044498, -0.03620170056819916, 0.0025316020473837852, -0.023165496066212654, 0.006253655534237623, 0.01066842582076788, -0.0588037483394146, -0.028774455189704895, -0.02103233151137829, 0.029877925291657448, -0.014633619226515293, -0.001797962817363441, 0.08010556548833847, 0.013670341111719608, -0.0001717160630505532, 0.0410955511033535, 0.001962027046829462, -0.04445228725671768, 0.009870989248156548, -0.018206492066383362, -0.0026312386617064476, 0.06109162047505379, 0.02649553306400776, -0.009297571144998074, -0.015486937947571278, -0.03710189834237099, -0.0025579622015357018, -0.06523320078849792, 0.03301531448960304, -0.009518538601696491, 0.044477760791778564, 0.0037520669866353273, 0.0280319657176733, 0.002515990287065506, -0.02403974160552025, -0.024563930928707123, -0.0038725140038877726, -0.03816688433289528, 0.010786869563162327, -0.024474970996379852, -0.01604500040411949, 0.019818199798464775, -0.030167846009135246, 0.029999101534485817, -0.005888729356229305, -0.02335578016936779, -0.021359816193580627, 0.04272982478141785, 0.005270098801702261, -0.029298318549990654, 0.002855766098946333, 0.028833921998739243, -0.01875470206141472, -0.023606741800904274, 0.05628884583711624, -0.00024141369794961065, 0.026712214574217796, 0.04950350150465965, 0.021427122876048088, -0.024064963683485985, -0.05284842848777771, -0.00808095745742321, 0.02957860939204693, 0.037396568804979324, 0.03640878200531006, 0.0173159372061491, -0.01828761212527752, 0.013750054873526096, -0.019205840304493904, 0.014838065020740032, 0.043076351284980774, 0.00204176246188581, -0.035933833569288254, -0.007161623798310757, -0.02578304521739483, 0.029041027650237083, 0.0027278910856693983, 0.012922493740916252, 0.006469540763646364, 0.06745103746652603, 0.031088316813111305, 0.005189085379242897, 0.04186788201332092, 0.07861623167991638, 0.037575528025627136, -0.009000777266919613, -0.03772247955203056, -0.010105942375957966, 0.02432384341955185, 0.016570957377552986, 0.037866320461034775, -0.010173874907195568, 0.04568186402320862, -0.01446639932692051, 0.05713779106736183, -0.026381835341453552, -0.03339463844895363, 0.026717908680438995, 0.047379158437252045, 0.014003082178533077, 0.0035072341561317444, -0.03907870128750801, 0.015298900194466114, 0.03727143257856369, 0.027046136558055878, 0.004035124089568853, 0.017069624736905098, -0.1075015440583229, -0.002588803181424737, 0.045505717396736145, 0.0575132817029953, -0.05614775791764259, -0.018870718777179718, -0.016961656510829926, -0.01010708138346672, 0.0010647978633642197, -0.025553390383720398, 0.036207571625709534, -0.006256335414946079, 0.019898882135748863, -0.03187363222241402, -0.04539582505822182, -0.036573976278305054, 0.014264938421547413, -0.03391381353139877, -0.005907472688704729, -0.019607460126280785, -0.02293042466044426, -0.04165644198656082, 0.020825007930397987, 0.02447918802499771, 0.012474432587623596, -0.047649066895246506, -0.0036850683391094208, 0.024750027805566788, -0.00917966477572918, -0.04103181138634682, -0.07839871197938919, 0.037745390087366104, -0.023201830685138702, -0.0016773154493421316, 0.06773754954338074, 0.02094990387558937, -0.018442850559949875, -0.005282552447170019, 0.007277063559740782, -0.003249233588576317, -0.008828721940517426, -0.027719810605049133, 0.033044688403606415, 0.01506161130964756, 0.010725308209657669, 0.05081541836261749, 0.07397592812776566, -0.005384087096899748, 0.011127575300633907, -0.06345739215612411, 0.002551119541749358, -0.008025884628295898, -0.05406315624713898, -0.04132641851902008, -0.007677420042455196, 0.030057566240429878, -0.001214185613207519, -0.048991356045007706, -0.005389714613556862, -0.05215438827872276, 0.021152181550860405, 0.024341514334082603, 0.037962738424539566, -0.02181467041373253, 0.027969393879175186, 0.0552813895046711, -0.01937340945005417, 0.007858961820602417, -0.023292753845453262, -0.006182992365211248, -0.0023037083446979523, -0.014266720041632652, 0.030927937477827072, -0.046043068170547485, 0.0033637918531894684, 0.03453497216105461, -0.01721034198999405, -0.043558456003665924, -0.0011921284021809697, -0.0002520697598811239, -0.031893424689769745, 0.04911582171916962, -0.005682498682290316, -0.001592425163835287, 0.029432756826281548, 0.01642586477100849, -0.014504766091704369, 0.006704581901431084, 0.019673779606819153, 0.047424931079149246, 0.010625653900206089, -0.01610029861330986, -0.053177610039711, -0.025876060128211975, 0.04812786728143692, 0.0010780909797176719, -0.044563744217157364, -0.007087437901645899, -0.01142335869371891, -0.026883378624916077, -0.03505944088101387, -0.012647787109017372, 0.0650382712483406, -0.03328925371170044, 0.0007864707731641829, -0.020153868943452835, 0.005650629755109549, 0.054435741156339645, -0.009769599884748459, 0.029462603852152824, 0.02535642869770527, 0.025785254314541817, -0.016052503138780594, -0.010795771144330502, -0.011144761927425861, -0.004918643273413181, -0.012311721220612526, 0.012575509026646614, -0.0029899505898356438, 0.04858481511473656, -0.056412115693092346, -0.05146194249391556, 0.034151751548051834, -0.044844064861536026, 0.005800297483801842, -0.05947777256369591, 0.0090678995475173, -0.026640765368938446, 0.0044151125475764275, -0.005568109918385744, -0.003205372951924801, 0.023340273648500443, -0.010994648560881615, 0.012507479637861252, -0.035790618509054184, -0.0437493622303009, 0.04536766558885574, 0.09375745803117752, 0.018481342121958733, 0.03257409483194351, -0.01807834953069687, -0.026735777035355568, 0.045568227767944336, 0.013591199181973934, -0.01245538704097271, 0.00033054110826924443, 0.023361634463071823, -0.02511262148618698, -0.03818763792514801, -0.028598112985491753, 0.013444498181343079, 0.12641067802906036, -0.033304326236248016, 0.02461130917072296, 0.025507252663373947, -0.018129756674170494, 0.012212049216032028, -0.04112314432859421, -0.02607695572078228, 0.012830426916480064, -0.0014374521560966969, 0.06766631454229355, -0.02994588389992714, -0.01103138830512762, 0.04320964962244034, -0.04019208997488022, 0.009994328953325748, 0.04248524084687233, -0.00695155281573534, -0.002000061795115471, 0.002719979966059327, -0.01931249536573887, -0.03231418505311012, -0.0015693913446739316, -0.055316682904958725, -0.0026274058036506176, -0.06316623836755753, -0.04309437423944473, 0.02470155991613865, 0.005484357941895723, -0.023508580401539803, -0.03078622929751873, -0.01675402745604515, -0.06334271281957626, -0.01790853962302208, 0.0444430448114872, -0.030746320262551308, 0.04780569300055504, -0.007407723926007748, 0.04798285663127899, 0.014008290134370327, 0.04336581751704216, -0.017226584255695343, -0.06182781606912613, 0.0011390980798751116, -0.00937651190906763, -0.013121839612722397, 0.026531992480158806, -0.00928997341543436, -0.014967842027544975, 0.02529187873005867, -0.0285195242613554, -0.006332193035632372, 0.017297321930527687, 0.02581327222287655, -0.009022506885230541, 0.04459429532289505, 0.019731488078832626, -0.03044973500072956, -0.013615339063107967, -0.0037628388963639736, 0.16469867527484894, 0.06053633615374565, 0.03982437774538994, -0.05306905135512352, -0.012448836117982864, 0.04768993332982063, -0.007698141038417816, -0.014716217294335365, -0.03437390923500061, -0.009530716575682163, -0.01890341378748417, 0.05820615962147713, 0.031154897063970566, 0.03985241428017616, 0.012204130180180073, 0.030062349513173103, -0.021584950387477875, -0.0021474764216691256, 0.002406773855909705, -0.01665518246591091, -0.0033329331781715155, -0.008584106341004372, -0.037509869784116745, 0.0005437695072032511, -0.0015750935999676585, 0.010894324630498886, -0.02695922926068306, 0.004195054993033409, -0.02617758698761463, 0.011115774512290955, -0.06457662582397461, 0.008158243261277676, 0.0022764974273741245, -0.0002676797448657453, 0.02654426358640194, 0.02007501944899559, 0.012576778419315815, -0.0684320256114006, 0.020116930827498436, 0.004562043584883213, 0.0009219358908012509, 0.003584616119042039, 0.024641070514917374, 0.01810002326965332, -0.01519237644970417, -0.015901345759630203, 0.0007785985362716019, 0.04388973116874695, -0.005726531147956848, 0.02582276612520218, -0.053276773542165756, -0.013491206802427769, -0.0006810431950725615, 0.0017910361057147384, 0.004546304699033499, 0.03123246319591999, 0.03440966457128525, -0.018964774906635284, -0.03945549577474594, -0.027577541768550873, -0.017576705664396286, -0.03880792483687401, 0.04244544357061386, 0.007109074387699366, -0.03259926289319992, -0.010168016888201237, -0.06462381780147552, 0.03107399307191372, -0.004790462553501129, 0.009913120418787003, 0.02881169691681862, 0.0035764588974416256, -0.02839125134050846, -0.006971719209104776, 0.04411559924483299, 0.032369691878557205, 0.02020227536559105, -0.011948390863835812, 0.009879677556455135, -0.05933930724859238, -0.03897131606936455, 0.0473921000957489, -0.007271186448633671, 0.005275472532957792, -0.025696301832795143, -0.006275731138885021, 0.042798057198524475, 0.022763554006814957, 0.008868305943906307, 0.040015656501054764, -0.013286728411912918, 0.10344380140304565, -0.018353627994656563, -0.03355685621500015, -0.029236072674393654, -0.007140996865928173, -0.016283957287669182, -0.049019187688827515, -0.010195222683250904, 0.04616539552807808, 0.011546939611434937, 0.021703673526644707, -0.025612227618694305, 0.011945881880819798, -0.014380560256540775, 0.00010035932791652158, 0.050226952880620956, -0.0573691725730896, 0.020883938297629356, -0.02689351513981819, 0.017944391816854477, -0.01898718811571598, -0.009902825579047203, 0.0014039019588381052, -0.05928311496973038, 0.010563305579125881, -0.0226487684994936, -0.04021245986223221, 0.030437273904681206, -0.014094237238168716, 0.013038089498877525, -0.006328389048576355, -0.006690616253763437, -0.0645504742860794, -0.029324203729629517, 0.00030926073668524623, -0.031378909945487976, -0.0037482562474906445, 0.006419171579182148, -0.00608019158244133, 0.00974363274872303, 0.04355861619114876, 0.027333827689290047, 0.006375621072947979, -0.030656704679131508, 0.045735184103250504, 0.016838200390338898, 0.03538244217634201, 0.027903692796826363, -0.030142800882458687, -0.0017618718557059765, -0.012981835752725601, -0.016754621639847755, 0.014832478947937489, 0.010184750892221928, 0.027896355837583542, 0.042454879730939865, -0.002635536016896367, 0.02193569950759411, 0.10167822241783142, -0.02439485490322113, -0.0002845238777808845, -0.003683651564642787, -0.0024663812946528196, 0.06925582885742188, -0.018496211618185043, -0.047164496034383774, 0.016818014904856682, -0.019441107288002968, 0.014577091671526432, 0.020138146355748177, 0.008589046075940132, -0.0015153831336647272, -0.004780193790793419, -0.028460612520575523, -0.01718175783753395, -0.026871180161833763, -0.003670013975352049, 0.029777243733406067, 0.041449740529060364, -0.01701771467924118, 0.04595962539315224, -0.032071612775325775, 0.02374436892569065, -0.06606751680374146, -0.0297419261187315, 0.0105460649356246, 0.0721362829208374, 0.03198128566145897, -0.04485711455345154, 0.012861845083534718, 0.05740462988615036, 0.010779349133372307, 0.022225631400942802, -0.016714541241526604, 0.019455311819911003, -0.008280612528324127, 0.017580224201083183, -0.019146636128425598, 0.005682798568159342, 0.030244937166571617, 0.0252844225615263, 0.008290406316518784, 0.03553236648440361, 0.021031107753515244, -0.0731896162033081, -0.017438581213355064, -0.031669732183218, 0.011766414158046246, -0.022319890558719635, 0.017676733434200287, -0.016949757933616638, -0.004278669133782387, 0.0031638327054679394, -0.01007825043052435, 0.05575637146830559, 0.023643381893634796, 0.029153231531381607, 0.010426796972751617, 0.007658643182367086, 0.04287513718008995, -0.016504911705851555, 0.005122951231896877, 0.015042167156934738, 0.004242153372615576, 0.04089314118027687, -0.01572335697710514, 0.017503958195447922, 0.003526178188621998, 0.0011777798645198345, 0.013202877715229988, 0.0038875455502420664, -0.00046068598749116063, -0.012275350280106068, 0.0033308714628219604, -0.008517497219145298, -0.020370643585920334, -0.034027379006147385, 0.03377167135477066, -0.030923200771212578, -0.004281216766685247, 0.084011010825634, 0.044230591505765915, -0.05141445994377136, 0.039231643080711365, -0.027554169297218323, -0.020541023463010788, 0.012381200678646564, 0.00975495669990778, 0.02098565548658371, -0.026223955675959587, 0.0021382493432611227, -0.021981675177812576, -0.009184975177049637, -0.027713147923350334, 0.005526753142476082, -0.04980010539293289, 0.039377108216285706, -0.020204314962029457, -0.014424835331737995, -0.021713806316256523, -0.007450127974152565, 0.03290640190243721, -0.08341342955827713, 0.0418698787689209, 0.021134410053491592, -0.021687258034944534, -0.044721391052007675, 0.0035974476486444473, -0.026755033060908318, 0.033265620470047, 0.048349905759096146, 0.0018716453341767192, 0.021002108231186867, 0.008763552643358707, 0.03687964752316475, 0.011323387734591961, -0.03628667816519737, 0.0787578895688057, 0.007546457462012768, 0.003992882557213306, 0.03026413545012474, 0.03903293237090111, 0.005056709982454777, -0.02289719693362713, -0.000823640963062644, 0.011561467312276363, 0.009766088798642159, 0.04288855940103531, -0.027794651687145233, 0.04746741056442261, 0.016506319865584373, -0.004888382274657488, 0.024570992216467857, 0.016753222793340683, 0.023907652124762535, 0.024435527622699738, 0.020061520859599113, -0.05687446892261505, 0.03584340214729309, 0.004210285376757383, 0.01743869110941887, 0.003233201103284955, 0.02017066814005375, 0.00040016224374994636, -0.05552078038454056, 0.02109752595424652, 0.033004045486450195, -0.022101538255810738, -0.013062032870948315, 0.031044667586684227, 0.00022437576262746006, -0.009239649400115013, -0.005311992019414902, 0.012234221212565899, 0.01051168143749237, -0.04458407685160637, 0.020244106650352478, -0.0055663613602519035, 0.023800885304808617, -0.01616000011563301, 0.007145420182496309, 0.03373226895928383, -0.015489628538489342, -0.008200940676033497, -0.024958748370409012, 0.008865953423082829, -0.010726330801844597, -0.015260236337780952, 0.02777755819261074, -0.016837649047374725, 0.014036058448255062, 0.013468924909830093, 0.0009525344939902425, 0.027774536982178688, -0.050903402268886566, 0.006565956398844719, -0.0397036038339138, -0.018455862998962402, 0.0030312403105199337, 0.006539350841194391, 0.026296624913811684, -0.0050630415789783, 0.012908103875815868, -0.016919750720262527, -0.009632762521505356, -0.03477993234992027, -0.013787944801151752, -0.010874757543206215, 0.024778511375188828, -0.008598585613071918, 0.005658136680722237, -0.010374117642641068, -0.018605507910251617, -0.04168108478188515, -0.046670954674482346, 0.018349504098296165, 0.014180079102516174, 0.01940113864839077, -0.05663342401385307, 0.014861434698104858, -0.0035023123491555452, 0.0527278333902359, -0.046957261860370636, -0.006157590076327324, -0.017621643841266632, -0.01621440425515175, 0.013447262346744537, -0.015058830380439758 ]
<p>I came in a new post because I’m quite confused with the use of an offset in gam() function (mgcv package). I’m actually working on predicting marine top predator’s distribution using aerial surveys (predators’ observations) and secondary production model outputs. My data are shaped in a 0.25° resolution grid, over large areas such as south-west Indian Ocean. Surveys have been done in several sectors over that grid, that is, all the grid is not sampled. My secondary production covariates are from SEAPODYM model, developed by Lehodey et al. I have a set of about 12 covariates, and wish to find the best combination of them to <em>predict</em> predators’ distribution. </p> <p>That said, because my goal is to predict predators’ distribution, I performed a model selection based on GCV score, after having excluded all combinations of correlated covariates. I am modelling observations, therefore I used a quasipoisson distribution (overdispersed data) with sampled area per pixel as an offset. I made my model selection with the model written as follows:</p> <pre><code>mod1&lt;-gam(Y ~ offset(log(sampled area))+ covariate1 + covariate2 + covariate3 + covariate4, family=quasipoisson) </code></pre> <p>Until then, everything worked well, but then I started predicting predators’ observations over my full grid. Doing this with the previous model resulted in predicting only over sampled pixel. Following colleagues’ advices, I predicted using a different writing, thinking it would not change anything in the results: </p> <pre><code>mod2&lt;-gam(Y ~ covariate1 + covariate2 + covariate3 + covariate4, offset(log(sampled area)), family=quasipoisson) </code></pre> <p>Indeed, it allows me to predict observation over the entire grid, but I am completely confused since I looked at the summaries of the models. The results are in fact quite different, with both GCV scores and Explained Deviances having higher values: </p> <pre><code>summary(mod1) Family: quasipoisson Link function: log Formula: species ~ offset(log(sampled area) + s(covariate1,k=4) + s(covariate2,k=4) + s(covariate3,k=4) + s(covariate4,k=4) Parametric coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) -0.12268 0.08025 -1.529 0.127 Approximate significance of smooth terms: edf Ref.df F p-value s(bathy_mnk_B) 2.722 2.951 15.89 4.83e-10 *** s(meso_mnk_B) 2.995 3.000 17.52 3.52e-11 *** s(bathy_mnk_P) 2.989 3.000 20.37 6.21e-13 *** s(mmeso_mnk_P) 2.536 2.855 12.71 6.49e-08 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 R-sq.(adj) = 0.0838 Deviance explained = 16.4% GCV score = 22.371 Scale est. = 22.188 n = 1491 summary(mod2) Family: quasipoisson Link function: log Formula: species ~ s(covariate1,k=4) + s(covariate2,k=4) + s(covariate3,k=4) + s(covariate4,k=4) Parametric coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 1.30093 0.07884 16.5 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Approximate significance of smooth terms: edf Ref.df F p-value s(bathy_mnk_B) 2.802 2.974 17.37 5.18e-11 *** s(meso_mnk_B) 3.000 3.000 16.35 1.86e-10 *** s(bathy_mnk_P) 2.988 3.000 27.75 &lt; 2e-16 *** s(mmeso_mnk_P) 2.460 2.806 12.47 1.12e-07 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 R-sq.(adj) = 0.0938 Deviance explained = 17.5% GCV score = 31.809 Scale est. = 31.547 n = 1491 </code></pre> <p>Given that I based my model selection on GCV scores, the fact that it changed like that puzzled me, and I am wondering whether or not my model selection was correct. I re-performed a model selection with the second kind of model (Y~X1+X2,offset), and resulting selected models are not always the same than with my first procedure. </p> <p>Seeing this, I am wondering on which writing of the model should I base my modelling and predictions? </p> <p>Does anyone could explain me why those two models are giving such different results? </p> <p>Thanks in advance for your help and advices, </p> <p>Charlotte</p>
41,855
[ 0.0013292795047163963, -0.004842908121645451, 0.027865132316946983, 0.030878620222210884, 0.029523853212594986, 0.037647638469934464, -0.0322953462600708, -0.005721083842217922, 0.03571515530347824, -0.04029153287410736, 0.02420021966099739, 0.07944569736719131, 0.06726200878620148, 0.01718887686729431, 0.019848108291625977, -0.0016944913659244776, -0.020917778834700584, 0.016157101839780807, 0.012419207021594048, -0.031268175691366196, -0.030285963788628578, 0.04209006205201149, 0.01551353745162487, -0.010704276151955128, 0.00933234952390194, 0.062142014503479004, 0.05673428252339363, 0.01003082562237978, 0.0064302608370780945, 0.0029835382010787725, -0.0324222557246685, -0.02919633872807026, 0.008526922203600407, 0.04267718642950058, 0.028227247297763824, 0.02742793597280979, -0.008649948053061962, -0.0416857972741127, 0.014731884934008121, 0.03385064750909805, -0.014741436578333378, -0.012902461923658848, 0.014257940463721752, 0.014474472962319851, 0.0016160631785169244, 0.01365691889077425, -0.0341770276427269, 0.0027813371270895004, 0.07055322825908661, -0.027664100751280785, 0.062276389449834824, 0.027494540438055992, 0.02433236688375473, 0.06276915967464447, 0.0048781493678689, 0.012054537422955036, 0.06224526837468147, 0.09509121626615524, -0.0006624070811085403, -0.023975513875484467, 0.000949730456341058, -0.03308318555355072, 0.009687826968729496, -0.03744809329509735, -0.0015750331804156303, 0.014420503750443459, 0.015793494880199432, -0.03261685371398926, 0.029681773856282234, -0.029107969254255295, 0.02766011282801628, -0.02427724190056324, 0.005268840119242668, 0.022595245391130447, 0.03373005613684654, -0.025481706485152245, -0.012311927042901516, 0.020338106900453568, 0.028849562630057335, 0.01041773147881031, 0.0038157484959810972, 0.036480143666267395, -0.018712574616074562, 0.026445947587490082, 0.030123407021164894, -0.0006230459548532963, 0.05865254998207092, -0.021912744268774986, -0.005352905951440334, 0.033573467284440994, -0.039526328444480896, 0.0059051853604614735, 0.044512707740068436, -0.009456874802708626, -0.028098588809370995, 0.06929951161146164, 0.01323690451681614, 0.0036772582679986954, -0.007342567667365074, -0.016446223482489586, -0.05206448212265968, -0.04866693913936615, 0.00971855316311121, 0.06942088901996613, -0.02226553112268448, 0.0025374512188136578, -0.08735393732786179, -0.028121445327997208, -0.019140921533107758, -0.047593291848897934, -0.010934852994978428, 0.06512269377708435, -0.019243167713284492, 0.008310568518936634, -0.0010925069218501449, -0.02998952381312847, 0.01765872724354267, -0.005436919629573822, 0.03573574870824814, 0.06515384465456009, 0.03935274854302406, -0.023561246693134308, -0.00517182657495141, -0.033265769481658936, -0.065118707716465, -0.009805642999708652, 0.05015838146209717, -0.010899181477725506, -0.034638937562704086, 0.04644543677568436, 0.0094277523458004, -0.02455429919064045, 0.014472408220171928, -0.013918085023760796, 0.02668854221701622, -0.0032886317931115627, -0.08819647133350372, -0.02374718338251114, 0.05548640340566635, -0.0074355159886181355, 0.06368193030357361, -0.04727502912282944, -0.024764347821474075, 0.013721151277422905, 0.03885001316666603, 0.003262059995904565, -0.003741089953109622, 0.010887492448091507, -0.00014561526768375188, -0.015092148445546627, -0.01484498381614685, 0.006935528479516506, -0.027878709137439728, -0.009212998673319817, -0.04239906743168831, -0.0797882229089737, 0.019729988649487495, -0.011968168430030346, 0.004452391527593136, 0.0264081209897995, 0.03678777441382408, -0.020786147564649582, -0.028050413355231285, -0.02824261784553528, -0.0020293244160711765, -0.0590975247323513, 0.07564835995435715, 0.0023071791511029005, 0.04823099076747894, 0.0018124417401850224, -0.019587375223636627, -0.009901205077767372, -0.015158481895923615, 0.03621847182512283, 0.03009393997490406, 0.0036729758139699697, 0.05552174523472786, -0.06213600933551788, 0.007087168283760548, 0.028102660551667213, -0.05548984929919243, -0.05214616656303406, -0.005595901980996132, -0.022029612213373184, 0.03540174663066864, 0.048691365867853165, -0.003499340731650591, -0.029942791908979416, 0.0357343927025795, -0.03532128036022186, -0.08268391340970993, -0.018389642238616943, -0.015400473959743977, -0.010348762385547161, 0.011211791075766087, 0.00848684273660183, -0.018274463713169098, 0.03868326172232628, 0.057790931314229965, -0.02310367487370968, -0.03684774413704872, 0.026363465934991837, 0.04044085368514061, -0.03776102513074875, 0.014008653350174427, 0.038753751665353775, 0.0137188034132123, -0.01587698981165886, 0.046055883169174194, -0.029726888984441757, -0.03310643509030342, 0.011842849664390087, -0.0505889393389225, 0.019233468919992447, -0.01680867187678814, -0.033500656485557556, 0.023567507043480873, 0.029614558443427086, -0.04493984952569008, 0.001824296428821981, -0.0412416085600853, 0.03826940059661865, 0.08905817568302155, 0.010723014362156391, 0.007284210063517094, 0.01869557425379753, -0.013992611318826675, 0.05300309136509895, -0.03437083214521408, -0.02450503222644329, -0.05092743784189224, -0.0009101234609261155, 0.06414681673049927, -0.012095157988369465, -0.0033215624280273914, 0.029055757448077202, 0.008808712475001812, -0.007684566546231508, 0.029263412579894066, 0.028360679745674133, 0.025973273441195488, -0.018008878454566002, 0.022703867405653, 0.0090564526617527, 0.005594103131443262, -0.03793957829475403, 0.05337052047252655, -0.02413453347980976, 0.0187317356467247, -0.0014745948137715459, -0.01497313380241394, 0.04142225906252861, 0.010743673890829086, 0.005902008153498173, -0.04009651392698288, -0.02954237535595894, 0.05559871718287468, -0.000863158144056797, 0.017345115542411804, 0.049148138612508774, 0.020280562341213226, -0.01323642861098051, 0.010826499201357365, -0.0069863577373325825, -0.018032586202025414, 0.03757340833544731, -0.002680908888578415, 0.016440443694591522, 0.026526907458901405, -0.03777936100959778, 0.0362539142370224, -0.03206175938248634, -0.039075884968042374, -0.036167651414871216, 0.0017896671779453754, 0.05748356506228447, 0.007920267060399055, 0.019470470026135445, -0.014429721049964428, -0.033523041754961014, -0.012361478060483932, 0.028412140905857086, 0.04437453672289848, 0.01805715076625347, -0.02578439749777317, -0.016614962369203568, -0.043800923973321915, -0.003456280566751957, -0.004543837159872055, -0.0004932901356369257, -0.0033344817347824574, 0.0005022836849093437, 0.0018235094612464309, -0.0280649121850729, -0.04211294651031494, -0.016296418383717537, 0.0017767110839486122, -0.031666602939367294, -0.06486059725284576, 0.04384574294090271, 0.023090386763215065, -0.031622566282749176, 0.03179166838526726, -0.034315288066864014, -0.002394357230514288, -0.0157335065305233, 0.016117719933390617, -0.00811796821653843, 0.013992994092404842, 0.03170681744813919, 0.027275651693344116, 0.020326796919107437, -0.035987768322229385, -0.06969239562749863, -0.04346619173884392, -0.010452380403876305, -0.0015474428655579686, 0.009180460125207901, -0.050128836184740067, 0.0020841534715145826, 0.062161896377801895, 0.029374651610851288, 0.019856128841638565, -0.022567234933376312, -0.01680620014667511, -0.016778193414211273, -0.04757724329829216, 0.01974811963737011, -0.0016298817936331034, 0.012007234618067741, 0.04570094496011734, -0.024319348856806755, 0.03769785910844803, 0.020677872002124786, -0.008447665721178055, 0.00035959415254183114, 0.025734635069966316, -0.009941868484020233, -0.022026950493454933, 0.025318536907434464, 0.023409385234117508, 0.0039774649776518345, 0.021074611693620682, -0.0265684612095356, -0.008430038578808308, -0.0002474859356880188, -0.056622374802827835, -0.008083454333245754, 0.008113835006952286, 0.01980348862707615, -0.044015444815158844, 0.05242003872990608, 0.05121732875704765, -0.07829778641462326, -0.035320498049259186, -0.00569012388586998, 0.0610656663775444, -0.01061031874269247, -0.027708036825060844, 0.07727585732936859, 0.027992742136120796, 0.02802872098982334, 0.03864550590515137, -0.030135273933410645, -0.005258336663246155, -0.000782982911914587, -0.013328750617802143, -0.011899566277861595, 0.01810365915298462, 0.04433098062872887, -0.01160973310470581, -0.0025540904607623816, -0.010286259464919567, -0.025408893823623657, -0.06141301244497299, -0.007136662025004625, -0.042801618576049805, 0.07321906089782715, -0.018711870536208153, 0.012563499622046947, 0.01416589692234993, 0.007585306651890278, 0.024942871183156967, 0.05734948068857193, -0.017940357327461243, 0.02294735610485077, 0.01095806248486042, 0.015306617133319378, -0.0005090063204988837, -0.03911212086677551, 0.021111391484737396, 0.03216440603137016, 0.01771792583167553, -0.02025412581861019, -0.01937423087656498, -0.01681583933532238, 0.005819964688271284, 0.001978727523237467, -0.007699599023908377, -0.021655632182955742, 0.01803778111934662, 0.007795811165124178, -0.016055578365921974, 0.016192177310585976, 0.01607019267976284, -0.01636701077222824, -0.0043741194531321526, -0.04173125699162483, 0.02720002643764019, 0.018644209951162338, 0.05097847059369087, 0.022811919450759888, 0.009438840672373772, -0.04224416986107826, 0.0092923017218709, -0.014899501577019691, 0.03193201497197151, 0.02939482033252716, -0.0195333082228899, 0.0016529676504433155, -0.04230916127562523, 0.001235311501659453, 0.043094173073768616, 0.006973644252866507, 0.006721861194819212, -0.0180466640740633, 0.039509814232587814, 0.021581094712018967, -0.00751482043415308, 0.016692355275154114, 0.033528510481119156, 0.03685537725687027, 0.005263175815343857, -0.03253135085105896, -0.004344409331679344, -0.007370800711214542, -0.0031099754851311445, 0.048690032213926315, 0.00020552781643345952, -0.022677704691886902, -0.007944675162434578, 0.010019004344940186, -0.025763871148228645, -0.02286146581172943, 0.01619505137205124, 0.03519751876592636, 0.060510989278554916, -0.012082559987902641, 0.00007048646511975676, -0.012119393795728683, 0.0034257203806191683, 0.018444394692778587, 0.012881939299404621, -0.02020212821662426, -0.06018667295575142, -0.034821707755327225, 0.05977756157517433, -0.005821955855935812, 0.007190499920397997, -0.01435652282088995, -0.048953793942928314, -0.0009242918458767235, -0.04020005837082863, -0.0035942355170845985, -0.004467687103897333, -0.012784833088517189, -0.0019781363662332296, -0.0003543176280800253, -0.04475325718522072, -0.05419420450925827, 0.009397472254931927, -0.02852373942732811, 0.014732583425939083, -0.026622390374541283, -0.040834940969944, -0.03634466975927353, 0.020258979871869087, -0.015747345983982086, 0.05302925035357475, -0.006061145570129156, -0.03125656396150589, 0.0040758647955954075, -0.006613295990973711, 0.0009411949431523681, -0.026826974004507065, 0.05838280916213989, -0.026547886431217194, 0.007537476718425751, 0.07473810017108917, -0.014866591431200504, -0.020967889577150345, 0.03810812905430794, 0.036108341068029404, -0.03930474817752838, -0.044264111667871475, -0.036137938499450684, 0.010082690045237541, 0.019121738150715828, -0.014032718725502491, 0.054464191198349, 0.0287982989102602, -0.02275330387055874, 0.012071589939296246, -0.03224824741482735, 0.012965360656380653, -0.003556113224476576, -0.050013963133096695, -0.039034269750118256, -0.035221390426158905, 0.00047983499825932086, -0.026223553344607353, 0.004041752312332392, 0.05041491985321045, -0.0381346121430397, -0.015482292510569096, 0.029628761112689972, 0.01648271083831787, -0.05195202678442001, 0.014843310229480267, 0.004617649596184492, 0.013204765506088734, 0.001101847505196929, 0.01566101424396038, -0.010291235521435738, -0.011864643543958664, -0.008313666097819805, 0.018039485439658165, -0.0367499515414238, -0.024926945567131042, -0.04815180227160454, 0.020334044471383095, 0.0006123341736383736, 0.004661445505917072, 0.03331436216831207, 0.0011152118677273393, 0.04324399307370186, 0.024307329207658768, -0.0828862264752388, -0.04241373389959335, 0.0204529520124197, 0.009338801726698875, 0.023464202880859375, 0.005084675271064043, 0.043636951595544815, -0.023971889168024063, 0.011431470513343811, -0.06704984605312347, -0.003234776435419917, 0.0007804113556630909, 0.00003763612767215818, -0.019895222038030624, -0.03103415109217167, -0.038473621010780334, -0.030691416934132576, -0.016939837485551834, -0.01335078664124012, 0.020839056000113487, -0.017723679542541504, 0.008853956125676632, -0.0024243176449090242, 0.01604972966015339, 0.09602651000022888, -0.04874184727668762, -0.0033070696517825127, 0.061280637979507446, -0.0030388771556317806, -0.014903143048286438, 0.02577313408255577, 0.010267204605042934, -0.02057071216404438, -0.0010461172787472606, -0.028643060475587845, 0.029640763998031616, 0.008292731828987598, 0.0014365864917635918, -0.015365651808679104, -0.0037071905098855495, -0.0057305763475596905, 0.030969291925430298, -0.028411686420440674, -0.011858295649290085, 0.005712381564080715, -0.03199217841029167, -0.03147174045443535, 0.04141581431031227, -0.01723117008805275, -0.03254782781004906, 0.057388078421354294, -0.03372728079557419, 0.0103635024279356, 0.031155575066804886, 0.08198388665914536, -0.005863501690328121, 0.014583871699869633, 0.013064063154160976, -0.03260218724608421, 0.03661401569843292, 0.0103084035217762, 0.022825954481959343, 0.008110707625746727, 0.048249609768390656, -0.06661805510520935, -0.001341561903245747, -0.04047246649861336, 0.01743345335125923, 0.052056241780519485, 0.000705127022229135, 0.02807956375181675, -0.028264755383133888, 0.00583749869838357, 0.02516983263194561, -0.058588720858097076, -0.006286792457103729, 0.0048833382315933704, -0.026297112926840782, 0.05765596032142639, -0.037465691566467285, -0.00028056331211701035, 0.007707563694566488, -0.006561954040080309, 0.032323308289051056, 0.0432899072766304, -0.010685540735721588, 0.02500953897833824, -0.0399177186191082, -0.02078324928879738, -0.02373097650706768, 0.04456047713756561, -0.046663276851177216, 0.000802861584816128, -0.07394979894161224, -0.01699012704193592, 0.03340715542435646, 0.05669219791889191, -0.02301168255507946, -0.08626385778188705, -0.024137472733855247, -0.04048869386315346, 0.02258935570716858, 0.020290229469537735, -0.009328511543571949, 0.017171792685985565, 0.014872721396386623, 0.055082786828279495, -0.0443376824259758, 0.05360427126288414, -0.03213030472397804, -0.08271630853414536, -0.02922685071825981, -0.030254172161221504, -0.03474690020084381, 0.033201202750205994, 0.00013714593660552055, -0.01819496974349022, 0.020741166546940804, 0.005659074522554874, -0.003507467685267329, 0.037563759833574295, 0.014438863843679428, 0.001391968340612948, 0.07876947522163391, -0.007140766363590956, -0.010259607806801796, -0.009699170477688313, -0.03736152872443199, 0.15833669900894165, 0.043184779584407806, 0.04378321394324303, -0.053813233971595764, 0.007224964909255505, 0.033743713051080704, -0.0026394231244921684, -0.019636889919638634, -0.036691438406705856, 0.024336745962500572, -0.04080037400126457, 0.03563765808939934, 0.03263937309384346, 0.028178516775369644, -0.0034012380056083202, 0.0320487804710865, -0.03615698963403702, -0.017879296094179153, 0.00137087213806808, -0.004478778224438429, 0.0005164449103176594, -0.0324288010597229, -0.05055251345038414, 0.019087020307779312, 0.004673867020756006, 0.026501405984163284, -0.03287602961063385, -0.004193068481981754, -0.029244177043437958, 0.015660755336284637, -0.004358652513474226, -0.0207588542252779, -0.018942706286907196, 0.027456456795334816, 0.02479739300906658, -0.028720127418637276, 0.015146544203162193, -0.02925935760140419, 0.011137559078633785, 0.02445150353014469, -0.03160465881228447, 0.030176186934113503, -0.013163872063159943, 0.017558684572577477, -0.02437187358736992, -0.05630190670490265, -0.0032154989894479513, 0.0504128523170948, 0.011813477613031864, -0.014456280507147312, -0.01476068701595068, 0.018405478447675705, -0.004693253897130489, -0.022738341242074966, 0.001620814437046647, -0.0010816665599122643, 0.03861650079488754, -0.017526643350720406, -0.047161899507045746, -0.007525987457484007, 0.042515337467193604, -0.011844982393085957, 0.050222404301166534, -0.011174806393682957, -0.005133709404617548, -0.03748339042067528, -0.0097883902490139, 0.061822373420000076, 0.0020429000724107027, -0.0055388049222528934, 0.018731294199824333, -0.0010875518200919032, -0.02253122627735138, -0.03494514897465706, -0.005134531296789646, -0.018576541915535927, -0.001336695277132094, -0.007348844315856695, -0.023405827581882477, -0.01853940263390541, -0.07306147366762161, -0.008016367442905903, -0.04993635416030884, -0.004945127293467522, -0.04445253312587738, -0.013065015897154808, -0.004881519358605146, 0.03622373193502426, 0.046704743057489395, 0.007318718824535608, -0.0053855134174227715, 0.06970804929733276, 0.002602767199277878, -0.0260939784348011, -0.040597058832645416, -0.02425966039299965, -0.03213152289390564, -0.03307243436574936, 0.021071359515190125, 0.05154696851968765, 0.013772265054285526, 0.006421851925551891, 0.006172409281134605, 0.03196099400520325, 0.0028875775169581175, -0.0016244438011199236, 0.01664668694138527, -0.020565321668982506, -0.010195406153798103, -0.029978647828102112, -0.015151998028159142, -0.04074903205037117, 0.018664134666323662, 0.015500894747674465, -0.031981900334358215, 0.01295003667473793, -0.05407720431685448, -0.025709105655550957, 0.0023267820943146944, -0.034946687519550323, 0.016523342579603195, 0.0033914351370185614, -0.028943313285708427, -0.03335866332054138, -0.037229813635349274, -0.02121214009821415, -0.02244558371603489, -0.01208829041570425, 0.007710656151175499, -0.05171135067939758, -0.004649828653782606, 0.01757671684026718, -0.03254401311278343, 0.02761353738605976, 0.011265785433351994, 0.030007662251591682, -0.005522340536117554, 0.02859736792743206, 0.014212275855243206, -0.0029190967325121164, 0.0316515751183033, -0.00718501815572381, -0.045536767691373825, -0.005344896111637354, -0.005104835145175457, 0.08125212043523788, -0.01835581101477146, 0.02409098856151104, -0.056063443422317505, 0.07144845277070999, -0.0011992884101346135, -0.005210053641349077, -0.012572077102959156, 0.004726774524897337, 0.006858948618173599, -0.000825837894808501, 0.0050247181206941605, 0.016569092869758606, 0.0035797804594039917, 0.01882648654282093, 0.018893521279096603, 0.0077369180507957935, -0.007028267253190279, -0.00039594396366737783, -0.05761660262942314, 0.024051155894994736, -0.024481933563947678, -0.005974449682980776, 0.028289705514907837, 0.04764271527528763, 0.014975478872656822, 0.024908438324928284, -0.01930682733654976, 0.007064292207360268, -0.059508226811885834, -0.033458322286605835, 0.024490326642990112, 0.017586462199687958, 0.03948276489973068, -0.027909472584724426, 0.011710220016539097, 0.05831882730126381, -0.028169073164463043, 0.014887959696352482, 0.05211827903985977, 0.0000676931522320956, -0.012047731317579746, 0.024084895849227905, -0.03005135804414749, -0.03827209770679474, 0.05544964596629143, -0.02403244376182556, 0.06588872522115707, 0.03498828783631325, -0.005706185474991798, -0.05729082599282265, -0.012509973719716072, -0.011323929764330387, 0.015786396339535713, -0.01460389606654644, 0.027111519128084183, -0.02775939181447029, 0.016654707491397858, 0.022330831736326218, -0.0016420643078163266, 0.000010301043403160293, 0.021887242794036865, 0.051070719957351685, 0.013165444135665894, 0.05086520314216614, 0.055872343480587006, 0.005085439886897802, -0.0010234385263174772, -0.003488514805212617, 0.027363743633031845, -0.0062448796816170216, -0.036018647253513336, 0.027761925011873245, 0.0022479125764220953, 0.003446064656600356, -0.016452379524707794, 0.00935788732022047, 0.0005201482563279569, -0.0128505052998662, 0.011255844496190548, -0.003891365835443139, -0.019076786935329437, -0.021175334230065346, -0.005797967314720154, -0.03256705403327942, -0.0032220708671957254, 0.04766348749399185, 0.035804130136966705, -0.03417227417230606, -0.014471355825662613, -0.0042119878344237804, -0.025554047897458076, -0.01904216781258583, -0.0017424378311261535, -0.027356160804629326, -0.02878037840127945, 0.0062387678772211075, -0.021711844950914383, 0.012556836940348148, -0.030049780383706093, 0.0036376197822391987, -0.047314729541540146, 0.04348677396774292, 0.0021800321992486715, 0.0044186776503920555, 0.011682096868753433, 0.012531016021966934, 0.04259395971894264, -0.0862208679318428, 0.07693161070346832, 0.019764624536037445, -0.03881204500794411, -0.05005823075771332, -0.026173770427703857, 0.00650482764467597, 0.037995610386133194, 0.044282473623752594, 0.006966462358832359, 0.007790467701852322, 0.007139865309000015, 0.044832829385995865, -0.023739952594041824, -0.032838545739650726, 0.0367010161280632, 0.013752230443060398, -0.041911687701940536, 0.007908035069704056, 0.008206016384065151, 0.0031203150283545256, 0.008630843833088875, 0.0017162676667794585, -0.012420152314007282, 0.013873760588467121, 0.027109138667583466, -0.033196549862623215, 0.040346093475818634, -0.013976460322737694, -0.0027496071998029947, 0.02262142300605774, -0.02636096440255642, 0.014171549119055271, 0.0023894570767879486, 0.018259551376104355, -0.0651690736413002, 0.007712831720709801, -0.05125425383448601, -0.012718476355075836, -0.005859273485839367, 0.02272390015423298, 0.00017784643569029868, -0.05023925006389618, 0.02768467366695404, 0.007993019185960293, -0.01254911907017231, -0.006970277521759272, 0.01646970398724079, -0.006070929113775492, 0.042744316160678864, -0.02481624111533165, 0.03279624134302139, -0.010583428665995598, 0.013666708953678608, 0.040926430374383926, 0.047360651195049286, 0.01637735217809677, 0.01244101207703352, -0.009304262697696686, 0.04125119000673294, 0.012643562629818916, 0.01859101466834545, -0.046654440462589264, 0.04792345315217972, -0.0305214561522007, 0.007857331074774265, 0.038817957043647766, -0.03009008802473545, -0.017651844769716263, 0.016867222264409065, 0.010086465626955032, 0.028135523200035095, -0.04310622438788414, -0.05337952449917793, -0.01284472830593586, -0.02835698239505291, -0.03322090581059456, 0.03860776871442795, -0.011782429181039333, 0.023983435705304146, 0.03008483164012432, 0.05294647067785263, 0.004813654348254204, -0.008683845400810242, 0.025379778817296028, -0.0009765065624378622, 0.015054258517920971, -0.003878649789839983, 0.022919034585356712, 0.02128951996564865, 0.002694521564990282, -0.00984024815261364, 0.0137102622538805, 0.009254055097699165, 0.016347961500287056, 0.01192933414131403, -0.03713541105389595, -0.02014501765370369, -0.01176683884114027, 0.04287154972553253, -0.08717121928930283, -0.04052325338125229, -0.04088219627737999, -0.02683529630303383, 0.03533599525690079, -0.005221130326390266 ]
<p>It is well known that most model selection algorithms can easily fall into a multiple comparison trap. To quote Friedman:</p> <blockquote> <p>Consider developing a regression model in a context where substantive theory is weak. To focus on an extreme case, suppose that in fact there is no relationship between the dependent variable and the explanatory variables. Even so, if there are many explanatory variables, the R2 will be high. If explanatory variables with small t statistics are dropped and the equation refitted, the R2 will stay high and the overall F will become highly significant. This is demonstrated by simulation and by asymptotic calculation.</p> </blockquote> <p>Now, say you've got a multiple regression model based on multiple theories; you expect correlation between $y$ and many of your $X$'s, but you're not entirely sure how those correlations are affected by partial co-linearity between your $X$'s. Further, lets say that you suspect that there might be interactions between some of your $X$'s, but you're not sure. Because of collinearity, you want to estimate a model with all the $X$'s, rather than several separate models.</p> <p>Now, say you were fitting the model to the population, rather that a sample from the population. Suppose that some subset of your $X$'s and your interactions were in fact poor predictors. Since you're in the population, all coefficient estimates are unbiased, and those poor predictions represent real, but weak, correlations.</p> <p>But what if you're not sure about the model? Coefficient estimates suffer from omitted variables bias, or misspecification bias, or probably both. </p> <p>Now go from the population to the sample. You specify the same rich model based on your best guess of theory, expecting that some aspects of your theory are correct, and some are not. If you <strong>do not</strong> select out (say via AIC) some parameters, your model is overfit, and will generalize poorly. If you <strong>do</strong> select out certain terms (say via backwards selection), your model will suffer from a multiple comparison problem -- certain features will be deemed "significant" even if they do not represent real population correlations.</p> <p>So what is an applied guy to do? I've got a complicated dataset with a bunch of correlated variables, and a bunch of reasonably well-justified theories. I want to test whether there is any support for the theories, and I want to make predictions (with associated measures of uncertainty of predictions) based on the most robust model I can construct. </p> <p>I've been doing iterative backwards selection -- dropping terms that lower AIC the most when dropped. <strong>Is there a way to correct standard errors and/or prediction intervals for multiple comparison after doing backwards selection</strong>? </p> <p>(Note that I do NOT want to do ridge regression or lasso, because I am not willing to trade bias for variance. I know that mis-specification can lead to bias, but I am using semi-parametrics to avoid functional form mis-specification on features.)</p>
74,491
[ -0.031010953709483147, 0.003551695728674531, 0.026076553389430046, -0.01638980396091938, 0.02361287921667099, 0.04611005634069443, 0.006030725315213203, -0.006824517156928778, 0.03014851175248623, -0.041219234466552734, 0.00537906913086772, 0.04644422233104706, 0.05535808578133583, 0.014143690466880798, 0.020322009921073914, 0.0172922071069479, 0.0009906162740662694, 0.02439246140420437, 0.020598873496055603, -0.004971825983375311, -0.021142609417438507, 0.04041927680373192, -0.00289247022010386, 0.03257172927260399, -0.03388119116425514, 0.05238782986998558, 0.007708681747317314, -0.011669420637190342, -0.0003120562178082764, 0.023367181420326233, -0.011087444610893726, -0.0056315199472010136, -0.0037682978436350822, 0.043198321014642715, 0.03943385183811188, 0.03219498693943024, 0.036460116505622864, -0.008224458433687687, 0.029412977397441864, 0.047604791820049286, -0.0379958301782608, -0.04295850917696953, -0.0024106092751026154, 0.017196722328662872, -0.012965998612344265, 0.03243135288357735, 0.006117277778685093, -0.013954482972621918, 0.061251137405633926, -0.035661160945892334, 0.05146188288927078, -0.0138962147757411, 0.017680617049336433, 0.07021922618150711, -0.05076342076063156, 0.009152447804808617, 0.06144162267446518, 0.0721963495016098, -0.029512034729123116, -0.05813286453485489, -0.013352111913263798, -0.011907423846423626, 0.01426659058779478, -0.005801223684102297, -0.039682067930698395, 0.021052483469247818, 0.01903456449508667, -0.014733993448317051, 0.024019263684749603, -0.022695906460285187, -0.004202456213533878, 0.01190764270722866, -0.012611440382897854, -0.002094005700200796, 0.02886173129081726, -0.010176016949117184, -0.0014307645615190268, -0.0006050102529115975, 0.018259204924106598, 0.027947422116994858, 0.016741331666707993, -0.012468699365854263, 0.00611187145113945, 0.04953598976135254, 0.0039067999459803104, 0.004191981628537178, 0.05853588506579399, -0.04282423108816147, 0.028359942138195038, 0.04665159806609154, -0.03302988409996033, -0.011672471649944782, 0.02904464118182659, -0.03103271685540676, -0.0046231807209551334, 0.022220611572265625, -0.0015352624468505383, 0.023426538333296776, 0.02719755843281746, -0.007179666310548782, -0.044844936579465866, -0.037796881049871445, -0.023420171812176704, 0.047766730189323425, -0.01742628589272499, -0.00859422329813242, -0.009598968550562859, -0.01910913549363613, -0.0008655120618641376, -0.043400898575782776, -0.011063285171985626, 0.02719750814139843, -0.019371161237359047, -0.004652670118957758, 0.0113653764128685, 0.008604028262197971, 0.020046450197696686, -0.02673351764678955, 0.08890001475811005, 0.05859370529651642, 0.03712347522377968, -0.026811670511960983, 0.013182271271944046, -0.020418277010321617, -0.03486904501914978, -0.003976219333708286, 0.021424362435936928, -0.030634833499789238, -0.036285318434238434, 0.03708892688155174, 0.049325138330459595, 0.007222816813737154, -0.021822115406394005, 0.008246348239481449, 0.005542494356632233, 0.004905399400740862, -0.0589044988155365, -0.06330682337284088, 0.030186280608177185, -0.034996144473552704, 0.010490949265658855, -0.02439439669251442, -0.008611713536083698, 0.025642313063144684, 0.07854633778333664, -0.014502394944429398, 0.03197607770562172, 0.012139462865889072, 0.02232939377427101, -0.013588200323283672, -0.015620159916579723, -0.02339179627597332, -0.018002772703766823, -0.005707282107323408, -0.04741808399558067, -0.13461898267269135, 0.01164394710212946, 0.007129391189664602, -0.03752993792295456, 0.039565589278936386, 0.030627751722931862, -0.01087415311485529, -0.04719329997897148, -0.008025717921555042, -0.0268404558300972, -0.01869724504649639, 0.07926489412784576, 0.01491464115679264, 0.04389879107475281, 0.03264975547790527, -0.018254762515425682, 0.030327465385198593, -0.01736011542379856, 0.04536132887005806, 0.027741260826587677, -0.03695390373468399, 0.007675647735595703, -0.016417110338807106, -0.02058817259967327, 0.021273275837302208, -0.02815907448530197, -0.05435895174741745, -0.0007178484811447561, -0.026330353692173958, 0.013338286429643631, 0.03274189680814743, -0.015199367888271809, -0.01742028258740902, 0.05159446597099304, -0.043753303587436676, -0.0511850044131279, -0.061250027269124985, -0.029246129095554352, 0.010424958541989326, -0.030555102974176407, 0.05475199595093727, 0.014385560527443886, -0.0000805733579909429, 0.014665307477116585, -0.011352606117725372, -0.02769729308784008, 0.029820645228028297, 0.04026656970381737, -0.030335860326886177, 0.047014251351356506, 0.03708928823471069, 0.047022413462400436, -0.01964505761861801, 0.056537896394729614, -0.01867852732539177, -0.021737361326813698, 0.04203345254063606, -0.04562560096383095, -0.0013805156340822577, -0.00833739060908556, -0.033159516751766205, 0.02063765563070774, -0.05029962211847305, -0.022999370470643044, 0.044956762343645096, -0.037084728479385376, 0.04290136694908142, 0.04758666455745697, -0.03215484321117401, -0.013111922889947891, 0.05523795261979103, -0.017977498471736908, 0.03185063600540161, -0.0340338796377182, 0.02405548468232155, -0.058546870946884155, -0.05006477236747742, 0.016831547021865845, 0.037386007606983185, -0.0728333443403244, 0.025681691244244576, 0.03337656706571579, 0.009383340366184711, 0.02008748985826969, 0.01042293943464756, 0.004821888171136379, -0.035188738256692886, 0.040304239839315414, 0.004762756172567606, 0.0031090464908629656, 0.0022062771022319794, 0.015039632096886635, 0.005479894112795591, -0.004422408062964678, -0.0027049670461565256, 0.0456077940762043, 0.039369434118270874, 0.047034624963998795, 0.003774343291297555, -0.015015971846878529, -0.030507126823067665, 0.007551458198577166, -0.0024625661317259073, 0.022598883137106895, 0.028430793434381485, 0.012204560451209545, 0.0084540955722332, -0.030384816229343414, 0.01713589020073414, 0.04063304886221886, 0.010626367293298244, -0.026635833084583282, -0.0005556754767894745, 0.036499716341495514, -0.05497220158576965, -0.01739097386598587, -0.018517902120947838, -0.01725880056619644, -0.013161160983145237, 0.020189324393868446, 0.018993500620126724, -0.010744895786046982, 0.021506277844309807, 0.006512897554785013, 0.007596937008202076, -0.007164158392697573, -0.009077719412744045, 0.04364476352930069, -0.014219866134226322, -0.056953758001327515, 0.016767209395766258, -0.07975894212722778, -0.02554037608206272, 0.025685224682092667, -0.015606530010700226, -0.007774450816214085, 0.02026967518031597, 0.01300103310495615, -0.06465913355350494, -0.05931264907121658, -0.022330958396196365, 0.00845369789749384, -0.026554614305496216, -0.055428799241781235, 0.03193611279129982, 0.012940450571477413, -0.08839879930019379, 0.018457410857081413, -0.03311879187822342, -0.005306690465658903, -0.009219955652952194, -0.024280907586216927, -0.03756183385848999, -0.015942201018333435, 0.005241028964519501, 0.0011261163745075464, -0.027575485408306122, -0.01978806033730507, -0.07791797816753387, -0.020176976919174194, 0.01268927101045847, 0.007767156697809696, 0.06677474826574326, -0.007853914052248001, 0.011721853166818619, 0.0754479244351387, 0.03896429017186165, -0.0009758516680449247, -0.019104287028312683, 0.012158402241766453, -0.045038677752017975, -0.014575711451470852, 0.032482635229825974, 0.010116064921021461, 0.006988527253270149, 0.038463469594717026, -0.011934660375118256, 0.021275844424962997, 0.023823188617825508, -0.010195882990956306, 0.01713823527097702, 0.03683025762438774, -0.008518735878169537, 0.006989903748035431, 0.002693097572773695, 0.03027118742465973, -0.024677138775587082, 0.014009326696395874, -0.005817287601530552, 0.003279726952314377, 0.03410561382770538, -0.02106662467122078, 0.030307753011584282, -0.03380710631608963, 0.02164280228316784, -0.02940625138580799, 0.004908079747110605, 0.0302069541066885, -0.041412800550460815, -0.03484412655234337, 0.010143307037651539, 0.03478224575519562, -0.007511975709348917, -0.01820446364581585, 0.018464669585227966, 0.03003116510808468, -0.02873845584690571, 0.005994509905576706, -0.04319372773170471, -0.015543263405561447, -0.006295178085565567, -0.01175515167415142, -0.003499938640743494, 0.053718600422143936, -0.0005311679560691118, -0.01208852045238018, 0.002010588999837637, -0.02831370010972023, 0.002445727586746216, -0.022536084055900574, -0.017223287373781204, -0.04928519204258919, 0.06389446556568146, 0.005572803318500519, -0.009018891490995884, 0.0006666000699624419, -0.01389395259320736, -0.017908239737153053, 0.006150510627776384, -0.03847258538007736, 0.019338050857186317, 0.008131217211484909, -0.0012853543739765882, 0.015598556958138943, 0.0005392383318394423, 0.04934136942028999, -0.02895321696996689, 0.005041073076426983, -0.05821514129638672, 0.057062484323978424, -0.01054815948009491, 0.019404971972107887, 0.0036563044413924217, -0.03474903851747513, -0.009855620563030243, 0.05400272086262703, 0.05086614191532135, -0.0424889475107193, 0.03162118047475815, 0.03767763078212738, 0.0010274212108924985, 0.00975028332322836, -0.03833514451980591, 0.008586998097598553, 0.06639707833528519, 0.048017051070928574, 0.0460745245218277, 0.011694177985191345, -0.026686202734708786, 0.004641965962946415, 0.03421679511666298, 0.05712922662496567, 0.0421253927052021, 0.006799232214689255, -0.0024880587588995695, -0.008125950582325459, -0.03795403614640236, 0.014716261066496372, 0.029678091406822205, -0.023295624181628227, -0.01792825199663639, 0.0368635319173336, 0.03671136870980263, -0.052372392266988754, 0.025298738852143288, -0.013345236890017986, 0.030907269567251205, 0.018857283517718315, -0.00035947130527347326, -0.013522817753255367, 0.017606552690267563, 0.001101187663152814, -0.025455713272094727, 0.019335269927978516, -0.023539641872048378, -0.012949435971677303, 0.038473766297101974, 0.02080494910478592, -0.058808453381061554, 0.0027139289304614067, 0.005276798736304045, 0.02957197278738022, -0.001102730049751699, -0.023852797225117683, -0.015299323946237564, 0.03968266770243645, 0.003071567276492715, 0.025484714657068253, 0.04786231368780136, -0.06594428420066833, -0.004464711062610149, 0.03357374668121338, 0.04688743129372597, -0.024177636951208115, 0.017514608800411224, -0.019787786528468132, -0.015684956684708595, 0.021459510549902916, 0.017302842810750008, 0.02665424346923828, -0.045797791332006454, 0.009856813587248325, 0.01164876576513052, -0.04642261937260628, -0.09923647344112396, -0.004267747048288584, -0.00304179429076612, 0.02720908634364605, -0.05684983357787132, 0.002446610014885664, -0.02797921746969223, 0.017157377675175667, -0.02732709050178528, 0.07196053862571716, -0.025464743375778198, -0.03296972066164017, -0.010782548226416111, 0.014743411913514137, 0.01508566364645958, -0.05464647337794304, -0.0005941535928286612, -0.0048723104409873486, -0.025489838793873787, 0.06730441004037857, -0.026607267558574677, -0.04363609105348587, 0.00022405025083571672, 0.0013215745566412807, -0.012570678256452084, 0.005620007403194904, -0.009134916588664055, 0.029652167111635208, 0.013927401043474674, 0.0330527164041996, 0.06572190672159195, 0.03448106721043587, -0.02796090394258499, 0.005810952745378017, -0.023967623710632324, -0.014401665888726711, -0.032317545264959335, -0.02191905863583088, -0.037207212299108505, -0.00010677434329409152, -0.02904834970831871, 0.00424327002838254, -0.0020849723368883133, 0.03535610809922218, -0.02596970833837986, -0.0031146251130849123, 0.017055194824934006, 0.012855436652898788, -0.02041122317314148, -0.01214117556810379, 0.007711379323154688, 0.025097602978348732, -0.02757204882800579, -0.010109723545610905, 0.0031779753044247627, -0.0039013864006847143, 0.01926727034151554, 0.026216326281428337, -0.013860154896974564, -0.007970699109137058, -0.0035593979991972446, -0.025668486952781677, -0.005887625738978386, 0.024899540469050407, 0.021360792219638824, -0.002589341253042221, 0.031168237328529358, -0.03336912766098976, -0.026613667607307434, -0.009625459089875221, 0.05047835782170296, 0.0020463939290493727, 0.018988892436027527, 0.012094645760953426, 0.004886174108833075, -0.04198847711086273, -0.012991041876375675, -0.05667397379875183, -0.02325098216533661, -0.01400050986558199, 0.012315350584685802, -0.0034842665772885084, 0.004725390113890171, -0.009792832657694817, -0.014733398333191872, -0.022295264527201653, -0.022741924971342087, 0.04261833056807518, -0.01395899523049593, -0.004271691665053368, 0.0195907112210989, 0.032359179109334946, 0.03158554807305336, 0.0011518674436956644, -0.01883818954229355, 0.043157052248716354, -0.031207779422402382, -0.011025839485228062, 0.005294952541589737, -0.034419648349285126, -0.017282675951719284, -0.021901806816458702, -0.02453731931746006, -0.01650191657245159, 0.0166938379406929, 0.003932605497539043, -0.03667004406452179, 0.04555513337254524, -0.06511756777763367, 0.013750282116234303, -0.013378025963902473, -0.013439822010695934, -0.04546865448355675, 0.049846965819597244, 0.002639404498040676, -0.011284815147519112, 0.00027595393476076424, -0.01176381390541792, 0.025767061859369278, -0.017392510548233986, -0.05840589478611946, 0.014135751873254776, 0.05897779390215874, 0.008443880826234818, 0.017310848459601402, -0.030257616192102432, -0.021737143397331238, 0.047484684735536575, 0.009206712245941162, 0.029242293909192085, -0.043024685233831406, 0.03515816852450371, -0.02780693583190441, -0.029778936877846718, -0.0011148737976327538, 0.00740890484303236, 0.07428695261478424, -0.02052837610244751, 0.022038310766220093, 0.07109043002128601, -0.058690618723630905, -0.007073648739606142, -0.024659978225827217, -0.01985907182097435, 0.007311317138373852, -0.009597120806574821, 0.07263356447219849, -0.007209626026451588, -0.025780104100704193, 0.0728272870182991, -0.0047868164256215096, 0.03874756023287773, 0.00670517235994339, -0.03403857350349426, 0.023405596613883972, 0.02225145883858204, -0.038483813405036926, -0.053007058799266815, 0.03293601796030998, -0.06563446670770645, -0.010329893790185452, -0.018624715507030487, -0.0035298645962029696, 0.01706443540751934, 0.06578946858644485, 0.001690202159807086, -0.051915403455495834, -0.03263102471828461, -0.05173036456108093, -0.016049975529313087, -0.0031561730429530144, -0.014707183465361595, 0.010400715284049511, -0.015271157026290894, 0.016824619844555855, -0.023339372128248215, 0.04153402894735336, -0.02983396127820015, -0.0888047143816948, -0.054429810494184494, -0.008584151975810528, 0.04182698205113411, 0.029064685106277466, -0.00009902532474370673, -0.01971275731921196, 0.038186851888895035, -0.02221275307238102, 0.021012362092733383, 0.026449183002114296, 0.03347453847527504, -0.051101185381412506, 0.019679494202136993, -0.014693976379930973, -0.007866478525102139, -0.002459389390423894, -0.0601925253868103, 0.14589692652225494, 0.09011267125606537, 0.03029644303023815, -0.08949948102235794, 0.017308294773101807, 0.0038588354364037514, 0.007957183755934238, -0.011311155743896961, -0.014869439415633678, 0.0069883097894489765, 0.02778675965964794, 0.017506876960396767, 0.0365619920194149, 0.005521588958799839, -0.017455844208598137, 0.027148714289069176, -0.05246700718998909, -0.003460406791418791, 0.0026322246994823217, 0.037534527480602264, 0.015442866832017899, 0.0009264048421755433, -0.010301657021045685, -0.02298353798687458, 0.020682508125901222, 0.011163940653204918, -0.009082425385713577, 0.00637713773176074, -0.018887808546423912, 0.005781933199614286, -0.03602466359734535, 0.024437054991722107, 0.02038910612463951, 0.0020571178756654263, -0.00921504758298397, 0.020281247794628143, 0.023764481768012047, -0.031130371615290642, 0.008400077931582928, 0.012504993937909603, -0.028817590326070786, 0.018102269619703293, -0.004113989882171154, 0.0064675468020141125, -0.04048013687133789, -0.03330231085419655, -0.03380798175930977, 0.026198454201221466, 0.01588885486125946, -0.038693834096193314, 0.006881995592266321, -0.005423121619969606, 0.035844847559928894, 0.007662512362003326, -0.04015450179576874, 0.04371532425284386, 0.030916329473257065, -0.050336580723524094, -0.029303086921572685, -0.016598911955952644, 0.01751532405614853, 0.004866508767008781, 0.013361174613237381, 0.031204964965581894, -0.07533349096775055, -0.026872452348470688, -0.018748141825199127, 0.040333960205316544, 0.04152052477002144, 0.018400488421320915, -0.017581528052687645, 0.0005831894814036787, -0.045224305242300034, -0.024848269298672676, 0.024334467947483063, 0.017716988921165466, 0.039832767099142075, -0.004688237328082323, 0.006949401460587978, -0.05726737156510353, -0.005872998386621475, -0.00030024873558431864, -0.0256122425198555, 0.016842208802700043, -0.06357552856206894, -0.021723290905356407, -0.014468582347035408, 0.03711295872926712, 0.030780386179685593, -0.04181014746427536, 0.009429815225303173, 0.06264844536781311, 0.007340954151004553, -0.043889328837394714, -0.05019715055823326, 0.0046357703395187855, -0.05911273509263992, -0.018089134246110916, 0.02106601558625698, 0.037776872515678406, 0.030974166467785835, 0.02184356190264225, -0.011887223459780216, 0.014805621467530727, -0.011467724107205868, -0.016847893595695496, 0.04289669916033745, -0.036949336528778076, -0.01746947318315506, 0.04369695112109184, 0.010186121799051762, -0.041822709143161774, -0.004597565159201622, -0.021401213482022285, -0.02063593454658985, 0.0428595095872879, 0.0034723689313977957, -0.04642505943775177, 0.025277193635702133, -0.010922173969447613, 0.06073221564292908, -0.0346938893198967, -0.019675593823194504, -0.029738236218690872, -0.0065127466805279255, -0.01495599839836359, 0.0038481217343360186, 0.01590469479560852, -0.002837818581610918, -0.035158637911081314, 0.009412494488060474, 0.03591645881533623, -0.016199951991438866, 0.001153771299868822, -0.012209257110953331, 0.019765153527259827, -0.019839750602841377, 0.015573263168334961, 0.005284921266138554, -0.0018016649410128593, 0.021430576220154762, -0.027859464287757874, -0.0505373515188694, 0.005381274037063122, -0.029379570856690407, 0.02867284044623375, -0.0002130520442733541, 0.01869053952395916, -0.034254394471645355, 0.030401434749364853, -0.057115089148283005, -0.015451873652637005, -0.022372594103217125, 0.05484356731176376, 0.007170755881816149, -0.01953844539821148, 0.034492406994104385, -0.005849873181432486, -0.004431260284036398, 0.03375277668237686, 0.026034213602542877, 0.005292295012623072, -0.044233500957489014, -0.004760970361530781, -0.006489632651209831, 0.02924485318362713, -0.007441770751029253, -0.018177703022956848, 0.011634055525064468, 0.018976852297782898, 0.0042198230512440205, 0.08494782447814941, 0.04571306332945824, -0.003999036271125078, -0.11936701089143753, -0.035337671637535095, 0.008960769511759281, 0.05006682872772217, 0.04906493052840233, -0.041164446622133255, -0.015421311371028423, 0.042906422168016434, -0.05200629681348801, -0.011556860990822315, 0.013624577783048153, 0.008767465129494667, -0.028919097036123276, 0.010026483796536922, -0.053132910281419754, 0.0010423987405374646, 0.03021148219704628, 0.0140232490375638, 0.018600033596158028, 0.006126656197011471, 0.0064718713983893394, -0.018577635288238525, -0.05266902223229408, -0.018061380833387375, -0.015919357538223267, -0.02739092893898487, 0.04538107290863991, -0.04679049178957939, -0.019445791840553284, 0.03562137857079506, 0.008379412814974785, 0.02907245047390461, 0.015257701277732849, 0.027550306171178818, 0.01476595550775528, 0.021591559052467346, 0.022142937406897545, -0.023075813427567482, 0.006683535873889923, 0.0034912514965981245, -0.007380835246294737, 0.03163617104291916, -0.002241248730570078, 0.008634443394839764, -0.016598958522081375, -0.011998092755675316, -0.007730464451014996, -0.0008636535494588315, 0.018604351207613945, -0.009844827465713024, 0.012231828644871712, 0.022621380165219307, -0.007685505785048008, 0.002961458871141076, 0.003362905001267791, -0.03482915461063385, -0.02538345754146576, 0.04739215970039368, 0.07297417521476746, -0.017673086374998093, 0.013835674151778221, -0.059961430728435516, -0.04373518005013466, 0.04639270901679993, 0.0057347118854522705, -0.0027761843521147966, -0.02701799012720585, -0.0396488793194294, 0.025351911783218384, -0.014931964688003063, -0.04075277969241142, 0.012856105342507362, -0.07746455073356628, 0.04524163156747818, -0.011141235008835793, 0.008505959995090961, -0.004264410585165024, -0.06559669971466064, 0.02269039861857891, -0.11121931672096252, 0.040025364607572556, 0.0026781552005559206, 0.018336201086640358, -0.018964702263474464, 0.006191418040543795, 0.002192217856645584, 0.006969190202653408, 0.03450828045606613, 0.005329150706529617, 0.014691226184368134, 0.010499239899218082, 0.010176065377891064, -0.0002393672039033845, -0.03680455684661865, 0.04024697095155716, 0.02215554192662239, 0.018666578456759453, 0.01964782178401947, 0.007166897878050804, 0.023892205208539963, 0.015172815881669521, 0.01628405973315239, -0.020125268027186394, 0.031320419162511826, 0.030037201941013336, 0.006951665505766869, 0.05255033075809479, -0.004966307897120714, 0.007790661882609129, 0.037529848515987396, 0.005453399382531643, 0.06083749979734421, 0.01167039293795824, 0.0024946171324700117, -0.06477922946214676, 0.011142863892018795, -0.03126369044184685, -0.04065118357539177, 0.022440150380134583, 0.01509147323668003, -0.027790255844593048, -0.012734715826809406, 0.025805562734603882, 0.04066876322031021, -0.02159949764609337, -0.008166206069290638, 0.013576658442616463, 0.030523722991347313, 0.05122041702270508, 0.005178882274776697, 0.015080136246979237, 0.010244504548609257, -0.03252674639225006, 0.026773864403367043, 0.02394838072359562, 0.04456339776515961, 0.03169809654355049, 0.025519682094454765, 0.029879959300160408, 0.0019215528154745698, 0.03916402906179428, -0.03143220394849777, 0.031169122084975243, -0.0582885704934597, -0.005379056092351675, 0.02144484408199787, -0.004262056667357683, 0.03741011768579483, -0.023725897073745728, 0.003750408301129937, 0.06269526481628418, -0.04489810764789581, -0.016557199880480766, -0.014323363080620766, 0.005468119401484728, -0.012499113567173481, 0.011020067147910595, 0.004784086253494024, 0.02189997024834156, -0.013465831987559795, 0.012451449409127235, -0.020089544355869293, -0.007753461133688688, 0.016579462215304375, 0.0010411519324406981, 0.010221955366432667, 0.028487997129559517, -0.018981510773301125, 0.00015549335512332618, -0.017762186005711555, -0.01571316458284855, -0.03478348255157471, 0.018932344391942024, 0.056834883987903595, 0.02211916260421276, -0.04033966362476349, 0.006499664392322302, 0.020935149863362312, 0.020864175632596016, -0.06323207169771194, 0.010469627566635609, -0.03569632023572922, 0.012791294604539871, -0.021046793088316917, -0.002938837045803666 ]
<p>So I have data like:</p> <pre><code>Cost 20 30 10 5 Rating 5 3 2 5 </code></pre> <p>I want to make a chart of rating vs. cost, so the points would be </p> <pre><code>[(5,20), (3,30), (2,10), (5,5)] </code></pre> <p>I can't seem to get excel to do anything other than put the two rows as independent series. Am I missing something, or I do have to pivot the data somehow to make it do that?</p> <p>(Actually, I'm using an old-ish version of <a href="http://www.apple.com/iwork/numbers/" rel="nofollow">Numbers.app</a> on OS X, but I'm hoping the concept will be the same. I have access to excel if need be.)</p>
74,492
[ -0.050661634653806686, 0.02861957438290119, 0.011096322908997536, 0.025817811489105225, 0.02436024695634842, -0.006777937524020672, -0.0000816416650195606, -0.00412972504273057, 0.028490696102380753, -0.025556951761245728, 0.038603827357292175, 0.04834241047501564, 0.029086148366332054, 0.06432626396417618, 0.038025036454200745, -0.009744126349687576, 0.00814018864184618, 0.013064483180642128, 0.008596224710345268, -0.019534926861524582, -0.0031839751172810793, -0.02127450704574585, 0.03545582666993141, -0.008830291219055653, -0.026483891531825066, 0.025483401492238045, 0.0315723679959774, -0.006987708155065775, -0.01213070284575224, 0.041181281208992004, -0.029848119243979454, -0.029629752039909363, 0.043465618044137955, 0.021437855437397957, 0.042196422815322876, 0.04651302471756935, -0.0228047426789999, -0.012714934535324574, -0.037126168608665466, 0.01979518122971058, 0.0228310264647007, -0.021622003987431526, -0.03269365057349205, 0.01824561320245266, -0.045873042196035385, 0.015031066723167896, 0.005097224377095699, -0.008277646265923977, 0.01585710421204567, -0.030243461951613426, 0.0697699785232544, -0.046871770173311234, 0.029778746888041496, 0.049551334232091904, -0.054305192083120346, 0.0006748842424713075, 0.009107548743486404, 0.04642296954989433, 0.013150445185601711, -0.06398449838161469, -0.002300078049302101, -0.030019300058484077, -0.013373010791838169, -0.02112613059580326, -0.056456923484802246, 0.019633153453469276, -0.014488677494227886, -0.016133150085806847, 0.003154291771352291, -0.05567990243434906, 0.0024536342825740576, 0.0471351332962513, 0.01452971063554287, -0.026521097868680954, -0.018506711348891258, -0.06015941873192787, 0.07082006335258484, -0.019776100292801857, 0.06306587159633636, 0.04416022449731827, -0.005793394520878792, 0.03366635739803314, 0.028028279542922974, 0.016848942264914513, 0.04569369554519653, 0.0010599893284961581, 0.05037504434585571, -0.04026429355144501, 0.016843417659401894, 0.021988902240991592, 0.01529062632471323, -0.007490682881325483, 0.04255389794707298, 0.03954506292939186, -0.00524400919675827, 0.022362861782312393, -0.020016485825181007, -0.015957167372107506, 0.020496651530265808, -0.009795153513550758, -0.012353257276117802, 0.004562896676361561, 0.008398737758398056, 0.023116368800401688, -0.03402248024940491, -0.03631199151277542, 0.0025940174236893654, -0.03487807512283325, 0.038592029362916946, -0.014664897695183754, -0.015994161367416382, -0.016312990337610245, 0.0047620739787817, -0.003642470808699727, 0.033322833478450775, -0.0276987012475729, 0.004465110134333372, 0.05644405633211136, 0.022946229204535484, 0.03985271975398064, 0.045414477586746216, -0.025920765474438667, 0.06292954087257385, -0.028932802379131317, -0.04795285686850548, 0.0009964165510609746, -0.023611223325133324, -0.03352755308151245, -0.02801193855702877, 0.043079350143671036, -0.07427201420068741, 0.003519749268889427, 0.039456646889448166, -0.014822038821876049, 0.017759738489985466, 0.029924819245934486, -0.06529676169157028, -0.03705602511763573, 0.013840718194842339, -0.020829955115914345, 0.008355987258255482, -0.03140610083937645, 0.042615290731191635, -0.00047375919530168176, 0.03754154592752457, 0.011513267643749714, 0.009617938660085201, 0.026429587975144386, 0.005566192325204611, 0.026709062978625298, -0.04763706400990486, -0.022155804559588432, -0.003944804426282644, -0.0655784085392952, -0.012245111167430878, -0.03753542900085449, -0.016774307936429977, 0.02193291112780571, 0.021346088498830795, -0.017188452184200287, 0.011980750598013401, 0.0000917398720048368, 0.02310759387910366, -0.013670792803168297, -0.04181667044758797, -0.03623567521572113, 0.04950539395213127, 0.011671124026179314, 0.028665242716670036, 0.040757693350315094, 0.0002640559687279165, -0.005136270076036453, -0.012414897792041302, 0.01612384431064129, 0.06426412612199783, 0.043104417622089386, -0.006693636998534203, 0.009405958466231823, -0.0013341057347133756, 0.015570899471640587, -0.03659173846244812, -0.06084014102816582, 0.0005993457161821425, -0.0204396303743124, 0.06685490161180496, 0.0442565381526947, 0.011826072819530964, -0.015489257872104645, 0.021402770653367043, -0.013362850062549114, -0.012273232452571392, -0.061389412730932236, 0.02053193747997284, 0.014627518132328987, -0.0046454379335045815, -0.013121433556079865, -0.028131645172834396, 0.028405776247382164, 0.009347876533865929, -0.02473861165344715, -0.03248322382569313, -0.021457990631461143, 0.04527002573013306, -0.05629036948084831, -0.006899712607264519, 0.029191115871071815, 0.02107141725718975, -0.015187135897576809, 0.06696130335330963, -0.01796828769147396, -0.0014846998965367675, -0.0107205705717206, -0.038295160979032516, 0.03374311700463295, -0.0021709867287427187, -0.003958472982048988, 0.0196955855935812, 0.025179779157042503, -0.017437821254134178, 0.041221704334020615, -0.019746892154216766, 0.03484368324279785, 0.05339284613728523, 0.00006668263813480735, 0.03909643739461899, -0.06510798633098602, 0.022907955572009087, 0.05434495583176613, -0.0014322161441668868, -0.004946342669427395, -0.02364867925643921, 0.020041389390826225, 0.03923545032739639, 0.013211003504693508, -0.03217845410108566, -0.026122896000742912, 0.10293199867010117, 0.017354367300868034, -0.004158955067396164, 0.030482053756713867, -0.038062307983636856, 0.009995503351092339, 0.00790323968976736, 0.013373792171478271, 0.021107571199536324, -0.005029032472521067, 0.022498322650790215, 0.0028984330128878355, 0.020324666053056717, -0.006416378077119589, -0.017539002001285553, 0.005164449103176594, -0.019803699105978012, 0.00604753103107214, -0.013727220706641674, -0.03243846818804741, 0.05160658061504364, -0.0370790958404541, 0.00455444073304534, 0.036584485322237015, 0.03179141506552696, -0.04114210978150368, 0.008579134941101074, -0.0005242822808213532, -0.03945421800017357, 0.05310751125216484, -0.033726245164871216, -0.006945968139916658, 0.026334961876273155, 0.011460437439382076, 0.0589735209941864, -0.04639764875173569, -0.005810141563415527, -0.06360888481140137, 0.02337813191115856, -0.0011257855221629143, 0.0020067067816853523, 0.03134537488222122, -0.0320168174803257, -0.04886002838611603, 0.0012307828292250633, -0.019392332062125206, 0.029409950599074364, -0.021054282784461975, -0.031510863453149796, -0.0017669351072981954, -0.006987850647419691, -0.0027162248734384775, 0.06964171677827835, 0.046655770391225815, -0.055689964443445206, -0.006286478601396084, -0.010366144590079784, -0.012478752993047237, 0.002836569445207715, -0.014916634187102318, 0.04496152698993683, -0.016758499667048454, 0.013652840629220009, 0.0556446835398674, -0.02008136175572872, -0.04377833008766174, 0.021898793056607246, -0.03912224993109703, 0.006841274909675121, -0.03030887432396412, 0.021870650351047516, 0.026830017566680908, -0.01569468528032303, 0.001715007470920682, 0.037624578922986984, -0.007251489907503128, 0.0027074057143181562, -0.054092101752758026, -0.027250202372670174, 0.0013304983731359243, 0.02791234292089939, 0.011147473007440567, 0.0013242554850876331, -0.03446514531970024, 0.023804495111107826, 0.008396148681640625, -0.042387161403894424, -0.07102874666452408, -0.03559166565537453, 0.0038967011496424675, 0.00194148242007941, 0.021045073866844177, 0.027612237259745598, -0.030184593051671982, -0.01363804005086422, -0.01268552802503109, 0.03434218466281891, 0.06977564841508865, 0.010158384218811989, 0.03581336885690689, 0.006689919624477625, 0.026161273941397667, -0.01933647319674492, 0.02446288801729679, 0.04315144196152687, -0.04759493097662926, -0.00861402228474617, 0.006096637342125177, 0.02231432870030403, 0.004581032320857048, -0.02732156217098236, -0.007637534756213427, 0.002089612651616335, 0.04301859810948372, -0.017299266532063484, 0.01731816492974758, 0.03366659954190254, 0.008550133556127548, -0.031509071588516235, 0.028319161385297775, 0.04631901532411575, -0.05866844952106476, -0.02830488234758377, 0.05978783220052719, 0.0492379367351532, -0.028428783640265465, -0.011197223328053951, 0.021556738764047623, 0.007414877414703369, 0.002897875849157572, -0.02381233684718609, -0.0019051283597946167, 0.027346111834049225, 0.03429925814270973, 0.036554865539073944, 0.06477303057909012, -0.043269310146570206, 0.04500005021691322, -0.08647114783525467, 0.005543197970837355, 0.0016620632959529757, 0.06655915081501007, 0.027266845107078552, 0.05043625086545944, 0.011363765224814415, 0.0017672507092356682, 0.02056235261261463, 0.008635460399091244, -0.039156947284936905, 0.0318949818611145, 0.038008932024240494, -0.01992262899875641, 0.009418557398021221, -0.007191326469182968, 0.007382163777947426, -0.026727236807346344, 0.0172396469861269, 0.009100127965211868, -0.021495696157217026, -0.015033362433314323, 0.018937479704618454, 0.004193461034446955, 0.03905085101723671, 0.00022304971935227513, -0.007059004623442888, 0.056067414581775665, -0.02623385190963745, 0.06160639226436615, 0.038512542843818665, -0.018803896382451057, -0.0352814607322216, -0.02513068914413452, 0.02963005192577839, -0.011633436195552349, -0.03822854906320572, -0.003593283938243985, 0.02721787802875042, 0.0034290782641619444, 0.008125119842588902, -0.0033873196225613356, 0.026617685332894325, 0.009825185872614384, -0.022665152326226234, 0.02172326296567917, -0.014289844781160355, -0.004921932704746723, 0.011789988726377487, -0.004742409102618694, -0.007234348449856043, 0.00018699507927522063, 0.027299005538225174, 0.024601779878139496, -0.04403182119131088, 0.026386814191937447, 0.09468507766723633, 0.027485845610499382, 0.006227651610970497, -0.0003707748546730727, -0.04245832934975624, -0.0012214923044666648, -0.023361431434750557, 0.029337061569094658, 0.030018163844943047, -0.0035533662885427475, 0.05143935605883598, 0.012707122601568699, -0.020215606316924095, 0.010982649400830269, 0.010622578673064709, -0.04135137423872948, 0.03989705070853233, -0.030129380524158478, -0.04045324772596359, 0.0321892648935318, 0.015614806674420834, 0.04282478243112564, 0.05192257836461067, -0.015300559811294079, -0.12739405035972595, -0.005860439036041498, 0.030169866979122162, 0.031734514981508255, -0.0564701072871685, -0.028305530548095703, -0.012102940119802952, -0.01567164435982704, 0.038017794489860535, -0.052044667303562164, 0.053721826523542404, 0.0005682596820406616, -0.009974723681807518, -0.01066678948700428, 0.00700691482052207, -0.011104168370366096, 0.0030036030802875757, -0.028929801657795906, 0.03225043788552284, -0.005955522879958153, -0.04971086606383324, -0.07073309272527695, 0.037101566791534424, 0.002004516776651144, 0.08068208396434784, -0.04771646484732628, -0.032700393348932266, -0.00021514511900022626, -0.0037312752101570368, -0.02940378524363041, -0.0486987940967083, 0.007220265455543995, 0.004492912907153368, -0.0031395701225847006, 0.0522858090698719, 0.026772942394018173, -0.02145007997751236, 0.00879720039665699, -0.0034624338150024414, 0.011168438009917736, 0.010520565323531628, -0.017424222081899643, 0.02664920501410961, 0.01606013812124729, 0.003458128310739994, 0.028082197532057762, 0.0535343699157238, -0.04105665162205696, 0.00694915559142828, -0.025172675028443336, 0.019386785104870796, -0.0027557082939893007, -0.0066851298324763775, -0.04879853501915932, 0.021625254303216934, -0.02700703777372837, 0.02761521190404892, 0.020242583006620407, -0.013586509972810745, -0.05550302937626839, 0.010184809565544128, -0.013429677113890648, 0.040461428463459015, 0.0073370374739170074, -0.04416099190711975, 0.02275160700082779, 0.02662968821823597, -0.023263156414031982, -0.013137636706233025, 0.017871487885713577, -0.0415634922683239, -0.001044173608534038, -0.009904279373586178, -0.01598859578371048, -0.0016649545868858695, -0.025834491476416588, 0.008524758741259575, -0.017909379675984383, -0.023459238931536674, -0.0072600338608026505, 0.034162670373916626, 0.02808336354792118, 0.010455806739628315, -0.023232879117131233, -0.007227662950754166, 0.028494995087385178, 0.010354021564126015, -0.008627627044916153, -0.0338219590485096, 0.058931853622198105, -0.017715176567435265, -0.051298949867486954, -0.02792607992887497, -0.03597233444452286, 0.03892136737704277, -0.011375916190445423, -0.036201901733875275, -0.03138963133096695, 0.0008874507038854063, 0.03127511218190193, -0.007692560087889433, 0.011999944224953651, -0.009194936603307724, -0.05470680445432663, -0.032888591289520264, 0.02027345448732376, -0.001122950343415141, 0.08479771763086319, 0.04809713736176491, -0.02000994049012661, 0.019481591880321503, 0.015438823960721493, -0.03225424885749817, -0.0062935869209468365, 0.020480355247855186, -0.006717360578477383, -0.018677325919270515, -0.03789426013827324, -0.027248498052358627, 0.018092399463057518, -0.021869918331503868, 0.014750517904758453, -0.033203478902578354, 0.023448945954442024, 0.0072179860435426235, -0.04576878622174263, 0.019126735627651215, -0.0064642527140676975, -0.01664969138801098, -0.08356574922800064, -0.0005705994553864002, -0.06416516751050949, 0.011567577719688416, -0.03659309446811676, 0.022293340414762497, -0.02364634908735752, 0.004758389201015234, 0.05160912498831749, -0.012666105292737484, -0.03218537196516991, 0.011380378156900406, -0.005859406664967537, 0.01993957720696926, -0.005710210185497999, -0.003493052674457431, 0.004806141834706068, 0.024884628131985664, -0.0439271405339241, 0.016143396496772766, -0.019658902660012245, -0.013518177904188633, 0.027888070791959763, 0.004095329437404871, 0.045185964554548264, 0.051534660160541534, -0.015423349104821682, 0.024518491700291634, -0.021558178588747978, 0.0003372117062099278, -0.017445199191570282, 0.04704281687736511, 0.08150851726531982, -0.026843242347240448, 0.013517066836357117, 0.054248228669166565, 0.005250934045761824, 0.03090738318860531, 0.02094634249806404, 0.04406808316707611, -0.038659606128931046, 0.017332877963781357, 0.01004521083086729, -0.033481210470199585, 0.015619227662682533, -0.011560373939573765, 0.01644851081073284, -0.03278036043047905, -0.04391705244779587, 0.036741938441991806, 0.06502396613359451, -0.02789357863366604, 0.006951762363314629, -0.053805965930223465, -0.04561874270439148, 0.008565161377191544, -0.003699385793879628, 0.014274577610194683, 0.008899115957319736, -0.003734599333256483, 0.018474871292710304, -0.005111864767968655, 0.01185520924627781, -0.03278530389070511, -0.04138968512415886, -0.019119560718536377, -0.04641680046916008, -0.013917360454797745, 0.04346015676856041, -0.01574542745947838, 0.01582939177751541, 0.013040178455412388, -0.011231992393732071, -0.001364165567792952, 0.0033774375915527344, 0.014474648050963879, -0.00516951410099864, 0.054679300636053085, 0.00034299262915737927, -0.03434031084179878, 0.008559047244489193, -0.032613467425107956, 0.1214662492275238, 0.07123011350631714, 0.02128429152071476, -0.050822917371988297, 0.008950714021921158, 0.04421500116586685, 0.003162041073665023, -0.038073692470788956, -0.012633574195206165, -0.005451010540127754, -0.008223902434110641, 0.05940878018736839, 0.06801929324865341, 0.023455169051885605, 0.005442135967314243, 0.05321059376001358, -0.01307542435824871, 0.0176012571901083, 0.01884668692946434, -0.0014219701988622546, -0.006144010927528143, -0.006609205622226, -0.06201581656932831, -0.0021433650981634855, 0.022926729172468185, -0.011378682218492031, -0.03114824928343296, -0.021700238808989525, -0.017028259113430977, 0.03433386608958244, -0.019323598593473434, 0.0029108913149684668, 0.05067446082830429, 0.03556939959526062, 0.03770025074481964, 0.014378971420228481, 0.03983981907367706, -0.026189737021923065, -0.012817050330340862, 0.05074893310666084, -0.0041311075910925865, -0.017831625416874886, -0.041241034865379333, 0.0014350865967571735, -0.05174529179930687, -0.054933562874794006, -0.047966789454221725, -0.010154719464480877, -0.031003735959529877, -0.022393077611923218, -0.023195194080471992, 0.009959453716874123, -0.009456471540033817, -0.042767275124788284, 0.0017577479593455791, 0.021258505061268806, 0.010138611309230328, -0.005363235250115395, -0.03452478349208832, 0.022220687940716743, -0.018265096470713615, -0.01600254513323307, 0.010674790479242802, 0.04942822456359863, 0.0025534802116453648, -0.017569003626704216, -0.0342981219291687, 0.03273443877696991, 0.0009068798972293735, 0.011919856071472168, 0.034739334136247635, 0.004009115044027567, -0.030894087627530098, -0.05218387022614479, 0.030232880264520645, 0.0570807084441185, -0.0033759891521185637, -0.01878158375620842, -0.013461560942232609, -0.012412503361701965, -0.00788042414933443, 0.029916368424892426, -0.01784002035856247, -0.010045473463833332, -0.024791060015559196, 0.022352831438183784, 0.04106761887669563, 0.017340518534183502, 0.04846714064478874, 0.020785167813301086, -0.032719437032938004, 0.04037493094801903, -0.014185679145157337, -0.057178985327482224, -0.05848442763090134, 0.022527502849698067, -0.026053903624415398, -0.017233025282621384, -0.020160799846053123, 0.08675983548164368, 0.012336649931967258, 0.0218228530138731, -0.008868958801031113, 0.01155245304107666, -0.02333795465528965, -0.0038026049733161926, 0.003985840827226639, -0.04707465320825577, 0.027193820104002953, 0.01212754100561142, -0.035320136696100235, 0.0027194395661354065, 0.00046408845810219646, -0.07068989425897598, -0.03508225828409195, -0.02067268267273903, 0.03247974067926407, -0.038053225725889206, 0.014819950796663761, -0.025912392884492874, 0.014958692714571953, -0.03769351541996002, -0.0025828497018665075, -0.03161630034446716, -0.03433917462825775, -0.021873503923416138, -0.01744030974805355, -0.04798528179526329, 0.027219297364354134, -0.04042781889438629, 0.009028150700032711, 0.019067758694291115, 0.035836704075336456, 0.015643779188394547, -0.03926583752036095, 0.025569552555680275, 0.028714967891573906, 0.02675640396773815, -0.04298446327447891, -0.030430901795625687, 0.0060718548484146595, -0.03869003802537918, -0.019949238747358322, -0.023092852905392647, -0.02766789309680462, 0.06184045225381851, 0.008933697827160358, 0.013923536986112595, -0.01179354265332222, 0.06478877365589142, 0.017551295459270477, -0.025499777868390083, 0.004163801670074463, 0.0035568480379879475, 0.043684981763362885, 0.03214866295456886, -0.047758206725120544, -0.01528223231434822, -0.023157350718975067, 0.006389671005308628, 0.056164100766181946, 0.02375708520412445, 0.008988987654447556, 0.0240730382502079, -0.004494373686611652, 0.015558134764432907, 0.036935955286026, -0.0005598336574621499, -0.004280734807252884, 0.011774367652833462, -0.056964460760354996, 0.02511223964393139, -0.014325032010674477, 0.026960931718349457, -0.035958968102931976, -0.016589149832725525, -0.02740359492599964, -0.028898265212774277, 0.019492490217089653, -0.04101472720503807, -0.019728532060980797, -0.02220855839550495, -0.04289811849594116, 0.04169226065278053, -0.0009313805494457483, 0.014537782408297062, -0.00888325646519661, 0.017838004976511, -0.04011595621705055, 0.022029457613825798, 0.01807006634771824, 0.05505925789475441, 0.047877877950668335, 0.01572636514902115, 0.009733518585562706, -0.013866039924323559, -0.004474211018532515, -0.011038375087082386, -0.0042150369845330715, -0.0539902038872242, 0.03963535279035568, -0.048064980655908585, -0.00339371501468122, 0.02647673524916172, -0.01570797525346279, 0.03070584498345852, 0.015711065381765366, -0.012518911622464657, 0.014297928661108017, 0.06477493047714233, -0.009046580642461777, 0.004176662303507328, -0.04569815844297409, 0.01631631702184677, -0.010700229555368423, -0.013088020496070385, 0.010613281279802322, 0.05946534126996994, 0.05008583888411522, 0.017635421827435493, -0.02441120147705078, -0.008950453251600266, -0.011339116841554642, 0.01104798261076212, -0.0362454317510128, 0.023101724684238434, 0.05088939145207405, -0.001251000678166747, 0.005708409007638693, -0.05570220202207565, 0.01534204836934805, 0.014425053261220455, -0.06184513121843338, 0.03516455739736557, 0.013540481217205524, 0.014585824683308601, -0.030334319919347763, -0.040656451135873795, 0.015495003201067448, 0.00805862806737423, -0.056806739419698715, -0.014385093934834003, -0.01000931765884161, -0.015209781937301159, -0.032481368631124496, 0.028929542750120163, -0.00001181294737762073, -0.0020283996127545834, 0.0077773029915988445, 0.0012168465182185173, 0.031135782599449158, -0.0038530786987394094, 0.011475032195448875, -0.06292719393968582, 0.03709420561790466, 0.024383816868066788, -0.025577500462532043, -0.009303354658186436, -0.0595671646296978, -0.059793729335069656, 0.04488818347454071, 0.05904613435268402, -0.03130796551704407, 0.019651159644126892, -0.07699786871671677, 0.02027004584670067, 0.027597086504101753, -0.004923210013657808, 0.05181189626455307, 0.012192551977932453, -0.04819531738758087, 0.0022165330592542887, -0.0068391915410757065, -0.0044958884827792645, -0.001114788232371211, 0.033618953078985214, -0.05027184635400772, -0.05606561526656151, -0.04289964586496353, -0.04252822697162628, -0.013836890459060669, 0.02730237878859043, -0.018790174275636673, 0.032248251140117645, 0.033544205129146576, -0.016774047166109085, 0.045049943029880524, -0.0043607004918158054, -0.05686241388320923, 0.037016529589891434, -0.06370759755373001, -0.03175639733672142, 0.003031542059034109, 0.00628582201898098, -0.019460299983620644, -0.07486410439014435, 0.00046692430623807013, 0.01919127255678177, -0.0070667932741343975, -0.036654241383075714, 0.02217766083776951, 0.036791782826185226, 0.041730742901563644, 0.002904018387198448, -0.00386756076477468, -0.021076573058962822, -0.033076804131269455, 0.036229975521564484, -0.008560930378735065, 0.03489891067147255, 0.016493655741214752, -0.004314883146435022, 0.03259348124265671, 0.03568902611732483, 0.018548598513007164, -0.024287333711981773, 0.06894418597221375, 0.01278743240982294, -0.0256006121635437, 0.016078993678092957, -0.024105042219161987, 0.03651800379157066, 0.01813562586903572, -0.024609602987766266, 0.00934853870421648, 0.000704338657669723, 0.042349785566329956, -0.04388691112399101, -0.010809185914695263, -0.05341583117842674, -0.0010341283632442355, 0.013454696163535118, 0.03391818702220917, -0.04687393456697464, -0.004599964711815119, 0.02885194681584835, -0.01838277280330658, 0.002701307414099574, -0.01713692396879196, 0.014058127999305725, -0.03328152373433113, -0.011359373107552528, -0.002678824355825782, 0.0030434944201260805, -0.03787454962730408, 0.0017705548088997602, 0.006129329092800617, 0.004312022589147091, 0.008062622509896755, -0.06380973756313324, 0.0005055423825979233, -0.0003072693070862442, -0.011088971979916096, -0.02101651206612587, -0.00794181413948536, -0.021716253831982613, 0.014399263076484203, 0.018773537129163742, 0.005840912461280823 ]
<p>How to interpret the Null and Residual Deviance in GLM in R? Like we say the for AIC that smaller AIC is better, is there any similar and quick interpretation for the deviances also?</p> <p>Null deviance: 1146.1 on 1077 degrees of freedom Residual deviance: 4589.4 on 1099 degrees of freedom AIC: 11089</p>
37,385
[ -0.02374977618455887, 0.03078925795853138, -0.012461756356060505, -0.026928165927529335, 0.03788486123085022, 0.012184306979179382, -0.02736772783100605, -0.017893439158797264, 0.009765541180968285, -0.03365659341216087, 0.022806202992796898, 0.046062588691711426, 0.04856262728571892, 0.01668217033147812, 0.04838298633694649, 0.0412282720208168, -0.0185694620013237, 0.015151957981288433, 0.040006887167692184, 0.003689391538500786, -0.006613390054553747, 0.013420244678854942, 0.04627948999404907, -0.01605040393769741, -0.03844769299030304, 0.04663838818669319, 0.050218839198350906, -0.0044170464389026165, 0.01897117681801319, 0.04644061625003815, -0.04230571165680885, 0.021749183535575867, 0.002600149717181921, 0.039052482694387436, 0.0026894817128777504, 0.02824660949409008, 0.005109396763145924, -0.005113773979246616, -0.004434036090970039, 0.0424903966486454, -0.04871538281440735, -0.048510920256376266, -0.011957363225519657, 0.02289675548672676, -0.014838610775768757, -0.013849353417754173, 0.013284476473927498, -0.051933690905570984, 0.0447092168033123, -0.04395689070224762, 0.059400252997875214, -0.0014997681137174368, -0.0004382347106002271, 0.02608954720199108, -0.019627902656793594, 0.0120045505464077, 0.03655286505818367, 0.04769149050116539, -0.04335194453597069, -0.059520870447158813, -0.01076503749936819, -0.07484045624732971, 0.019490094855427742, -0.018867023289203644, 0.0001949495926965028, 0.028640927746891975, 0.03544582426548004, -0.04744135960936546, 0.03517015650868416, -0.013869655318558216, 0.010104755870997906, 0.02229791134595871, -0.01452088262885809, -0.013578932732343674, 0.04192233830690384, -0.008731408044695854, -0.013341029174625874, 0.0003400980494916439, 0.04278721660375595, 0.04891608655452728, 0.010748275555670261, 0.03154117986559868, 0.013168774545192719, 0.015065214596688747, 0.018314171582460403, -0.01937757432460785, 0.059694960713386536, -0.025638747960329056, 0.005074609071016312, 0.01607438549399376, -0.0259817223995924, 0.004732418339699507, 0.05325958505272865, 0.01926935836672783, -0.041438184678554535, 0.028161736205220222, -0.019455986097455025, 0.018563056364655495, 0.009823600761592388, -0.00951034389436245, -0.03922025486826897, -0.062433525919914246, 0.03313504904508591, 0.030317217111587524, -0.02940034680068493, -0.005875830072909594, -0.032414183020591736, 0.0075523993000388145, -0.02013089694082737, -0.03249281272292137, -0.014593157917261124, 0.012927476316690445, 0.008958789519965649, 0.023683572188019753, 0.024192994460463524, 0.0028156223706901073, 0.0048681446351110935, -0.030300337821245193, 0.03949740156531334, 0.06228375807404518, 0.03907185420393944, -0.011689110659062862, 0.03156622499227524, 0.0007159642991609871, -0.044646456837654114, 0.028988370671868324, 0.04299405589699745, -0.03322668373584747, -0.028775636106729507, 0.0629425048828125, -0.005988215561956167, -0.049075473099946976, 0.0076509746722877026, 0.0005788175039924681, 0.012628902681171894, 0.018668200820684433, -0.07325500249862671, -0.0328185111284256, 0.029737263917922974, -0.0386386401951313, 0.018273865804076195, -0.049881722778081894, -0.0009174417937174439, 0.010374496690928936, 0.03401060029864311, 0.016302399337291718, 0.0535782128572464, -0.025050951167941093, -0.016694897785782814, -0.0033098545391112566, -0.024793880060315132, -0.011464191600680351, -0.037108685821294785, -0.02699974551796913, -0.017345041036605835, -0.06730200350284576, -0.00516167189925909, 0.02501845359802246, -0.020583167672157288, -0.013360010460019112, 0.018234066665172577, 0.010125471279025078, -0.026235178112983704, 0.007543843239545822, -0.007949543185532093, 0.015132385306060314, 0.08476591110229492, -0.006466364022344351, 0.02346991002559662, 0.03212118148803711, -0.025935960933566093, 0.018702678382396698, 0.006960694212466478, 0.05363129824399948, 0.025571707636117935, 0.004890028852969408, 0.01075718179345131, -0.04077674821019173, 0.03644857183098793, 0.016058875247836113, -0.05216338485479355, 0.00520292716100812, -0.022547263652086258, -0.04292786121368408, 0.010352586396038532, 0.04815554618835449, -0.0536472350358963, -0.006804656703025103, 0.06040184572339058, -0.0442877858877182, -0.015515120700001717, -0.07277204096317291, -0.012018593959510326, 0.002604046370834112, -0.028284363448619843, 0.00834067165851593, 0.030055437237024307, 0.03372972831130028, -0.0175977423787117, 0.01872008666396141, -0.03449910879135132, -0.022481786087155342, -0.01543426513671875, -0.022402098402380943, -0.009459039196372032, 0.013368545100092888, 0.027489081025123596, -0.007859241217374802, 0.04567592963576317, -0.0547822080552578, -0.018696581944823265, 0.05225791037082672, -0.037180930376052856, 0.006600632332265377, -0.011869833804666996, -0.05437833070755005, 0.004171436652541161, 0.0001895157474791631, -0.055778227746486664, 0.002247532131150365, -0.012597644701600075, 0.07635575532913208, 0.04385407641530037, -0.0005199589068070054, -0.01793999969959259, 0.012290959246456623, 0.010497918352484703, -0.015722524374723434, -0.04720025509595871, 0.008316436782479286, -0.042415130883455276, -0.04102020338177681, 0.046152036637067795, 0.013673086650669575, -0.021230194717645645, -0.0037276516668498516, 0.05330430716276169, 0.006755225360393524, 0.04304391145706177, 0.029781540855765343, -0.00016983305977191776, -0.039464835077524185, 0.019741442054510117, 0.0024641873314976692, 0.02607310749590397, -0.026689020916819572, 0.03461828827857971, 0.004907830618321896, 0.047357045114040375, -0.002169647952541709, -0.0342584028840065, 0.04127606749534607, 0.0035105145070701838, -0.028038375079631805, -0.039553042501211166, -0.010513230226933956, 0.019787384197115898, -0.0020120262634009123, 0.013793163932859898, 0.050361163914203644, 0.00583303440362215, -0.014180523343384266, 0.004105595406144857, 0.0007065153913572431, 0.054733484983444214, 0.03701790049672127, -0.014034446328878403, 0.007935261353850365, 0.021020231768488884, -0.000218616085476242, 0.03201093152165413, -0.01839553751051426, -0.04070137068629265, -0.05951833724975586, 0.002024005400016904, 0.03909331560134888, 0.010445485822856426, 0.002810555277392268, -0.021703096106648445, -0.01803555339574814, -0.031512223184108734, -0.0049802991561591625, 0.03173777088522911, 0.013592754490673542, -0.052725568413734436, -0.003887448227033019, -0.025113340467214584, -0.031200291588902473, 0.02383524924516678, -0.005111405625939369, 0.014014464803040028, 0.019691379740834236, -0.014054146595299244, -0.03863946348428726, -0.04588859900832176, 0.012311379425227642, -0.004196299239993095, -0.034023310989141464, -0.037349142134189606, 0.04673924297094345, -0.03595227003097534, -0.02893812023103237, 0.011301498860120773, -0.03890763595700264, -0.009889566339552402, -0.009862663224339485, 0.009695586748421192, 0.03238769248127937, 0.011161250993609428, 0.019605614244937897, 0.018327010795474052, -0.05041831359267235, 0.018824297934770584, -0.04144887998700142, -0.049875658005476, 0.03579956665635109, -0.02468097023665905, 0.0029384978115558624, -0.01945006288588047, -0.06621351093053818, 0.08376871794462204, 0.06291864067316055, 0.0015571160474792123, -0.039167776703834534, -0.029800066724419594, -0.007391170598566532, -0.03211888670921326, 0.0040276991203427315, 0.05074300616979599, 0.04184813052415848, 0.06922002136707306, -0.007011497393250465, 0.04940315708518028, 0.03780857101082802, 0.011695670895278454, -0.009488089941442013, 0.01579609327018261, 0.001089264638721943, -0.033222269266843796, 0.0019379121949896216, 0.011545260436832905, -0.04813756048679352, 0.024583058431744576, 0.012050984427332878, 0.055785924196243286, -0.026697007939219475, -0.020812101662158966, 0.011366017162799835, -0.012654977850615978, 0.010294078849256039, -0.003171368734911084, 0.04104292020201683, 0.0206108707934618, -0.01435855496674776, 0.02708403207361698, -0.007374708540737629, 0.024973593652248383, -0.01860414259135723, 0.001624125987291336, 0.008184699341654778, -0.003867542603984475, -0.0017722646007314324, 0.045539114624261856, -0.03173147141933441, -0.025081690400838852, 0.03307471051812172, -0.03708293288946152, -0.008967175148427486, 0.05709026753902435, 0.03441881015896797, -0.01680622808635235, -0.0003283890546299517, -0.03444162756204605, 0.04965135455131531, -0.05706435441970825, 0.027828266844153404, -0.017700204625725746, 0.03272034227848053, -0.022214651107788086, 0.0026319667231291533, 0.027667222544550896, 0.03796368092298508, -0.002988379215821624, -0.03684500232338905, -0.04092031344771385, 0.01107258815318346, -0.01961696706712246, -0.004405533894896507, -0.016898617148399353, -0.018428146839141846, 0.05445746332406998, -0.03890625759959221, 0.014241875149309635, -0.020093638449907303, 0.025077596306800842, -0.027392443269491196, 0.025331271812319756, -0.007918854244053364, 0.015989407896995544, 0.006651983130723238, 0.0004787782672792673, 0.02620178461074829, -0.005735971033573151, 0.026398664340376854, 0.04722604528069496, 0.00465837586671114, -0.010759654454886913, -0.019806383177638054, 0.003351296531036496, -0.0031179068610072136, 0.03213539347052574, 0.05839420109987259, 0.023546652868390083, -0.01866818219423294, 0.032711684703826904, 0.015085636638104916, 0.04556818678975105, 0.026296019554138184, -0.009647494181990623, -0.005397504661232233, -0.044262904673814774, -0.015384732745587826, -0.018357958644628525, 0.038999758660793304, 0.022648653015494347, -0.003989174030721188, 0.05133719742298126, 0.023856177926063538, -0.013070129789412022, 0.02978365868330002, 0.037574607878923416, 0.012782080098986626, -0.04185342416167259, -0.02777099423110485, -0.011242198757827282, 0.013262423686683178, 0.006331487093120813, 0.05392804741859436, -0.0019756380934268236, 0.0004703288141172379, -0.006151179783046246, 0.04649706929922104, -0.053366769105196, -0.03857426717877388, -0.021441495046019554, 0.021928397938609123, 0.022450551390647888, 0.036399178206920624, -0.037724971771240234, 0.004000945948064327, 0.029850466176867485, 0.03492521867156029, 0.05179116129875183, 0.011463694274425507, -0.08671233057975769, 0.002522382652387023, 0.05574146285653114, 0.0005457769730128348, -0.03611401468515396, -0.010300911962985992, -0.05426718667149544, -0.02937072329223156, 0.01794358715415001, -0.01848805509507656, 0.02371675707399845, 0.007490892894566059, 0.023658571764826775, -0.017744209617376328, -0.015179398469626904, -0.0451698899269104, 0.044975996017456055, -0.008274023421108723, 0.003175953635945916, -0.04350206255912781, -0.04507214576005936, -0.06123756617307663, -0.017160654067993164, -0.03567007929086685, 0.016687901690602303, -0.001895241905003786, 0.020135575905442238, 0.03161076083779335, 0.06866899877786636, 0.01575946994125843, -0.017008012160658836, 0.03011770360171795, 0.005533550400286913, 0.007501588668674231, 0.07493824511766434, 0.001314222696237266, -0.023011554032564163, -0.003835624549537897, 0.016728710383176804, -0.01653934456408024, 0.006510878447443247, -0.03492555394768715, 0.030192231759428978, 0.011307029984891415, -0.0199723057448864, 0.05909287929534912, -0.01090682577341795, -0.012695265002548695, -0.009283569641411304, -0.050672031939029694, 0.038980405777692795, -0.04868726432323456, -0.06720291078090668, -0.055768754333257675, -0.02461850829422474, 0.009550457820296288, 0.03548620268702507, -0.0028347873594611883, 0.048448581248521805, -0.022796738892793655, -0.023797979578375816, 0.024500494822859764, 0.036697641015052795, 0.031231865286827087, -0.0013617868535220623, 0.017742769792675972, 0.00940491072833538, 0.003712377278134227, -0.018112787976861, -0.020640704780817032, -0.010805997997522354, 0.013311854563653469, -0.00042426411528140306, -0.060852404683828354, 0.006929885130375624, -0.023541973903775215, -0.01995876431465149, 0.0047346362844109535, -0.0014417441561818123, 0.019842682406306267, 0.006160566583275795, -0.00906008668243885, 0.00100266607478261, -0.037793803960084915, -0.026487944647669792, 0.0016835356364026666, -0.012470799498260021, 0.05811074376106262, -0.03386928513646126, 0.029802925884723663, -0.008223342709243298, 0.016026128083467484, -0.06821625679731369, -0.010703937150537968, -0.011384415440261364, -0.017786167562007904, -0.021572716534137726, 0.008590334095060825, -0.007911245338618755, -0.002778989030048251, -0.015370042994618416, -0.004862291272729635, 0.07193773984909058, -0.04688511788845062, 0.000373742135707289, -0.02935054525732994, 0.0030053798109292984, 0.06906615197658539, -0.01524506974965334, -0.02328314632177353, 0.009748178534209728, -0.052279308438301086, 0.014960285276174545, 0.046628985553979874, 0.05421587452292442, -0.03255705162882805, -0.009692738763988018, -0.038468070328235626, -0.03267694264650345, 0.016121823340654373, -0.006500787101686001, -0.02649753727018833, -0.02849591337144375, 0.01739666610956192, 0.017796846106648445, -0.01199964340776205, -0.02315506897866726, -0.02374962344765663, 0.01644604653120041, 0.00002975494680867996, 0.007719985209405422, 0.0022994668688625097, -0.0250859335064888, 0.0678212121129036, 0.04057280346751213, -0.017988277599215508, 0.008834833279252052, 0.07363229990005493, -0.036774251610040665, 0.016186527907848358, -0.019450588151812553, 0.001453316304832697, 0.039553865790367126, 0.011243689805269241, 0.0144912488758564, 0.016145646572113037, 0.030754022300243378, -0.05900835245847702, -0.023997390642762184, -0.033712487667798996, -0.0035978739615529776, 0.05920519307255745, -0.025476394221186638, 0.0540306456387043, 0.050515156239271164, -0.027023328468203545, 0.017259562388062477, -0.04901682958006859, -0.009658179245889187, 0.030952729284763336, -0.014204282313585281, 0.059866830706596375, -0.03462507948279381, -0.02854260802268982, 0.057043660432100296, 0.0033778653014451265, -0.006501832045614719, 0.014787386171519756, -0.01163952611386776, 0.04069308564066887, -0.01443050429224968, 0.013498297892510891, -0.057742778211832047, 0.04242514818906784, -0.028491642326116562, 0.01596454158425331, -0.011993388645350933, 0.019680345430970192, 0.0389561653137207, 0.032959531992673874, 0.026574255898594856, -0.05977470427751541, -0.04510203376412392, -0.06643678992986679, 0.005084056872874498, 0.06755911558866501, -0.015152521431446075, -0.023426523432135582, 0.020407550036907196, 0.04593484103679657, -0.025721929967403412, 0.010164485312998295, -0.025093914940953255, -0.07980573177337646, -0.04741263762116432, 0.006470635067671537, 0.0037522597704082727, -0.016332251951098442, -0.009341788478195667, -0.02404037117958069, 0.011329368688166142, -0.010740550234913826, -0.010924396105110645, -0.0010006485972553492, 0.0326748788356781, -0.014799528755247593, 0.07845829427242279, -0.028353938832879066, 0.0010439804755151272, -0.013544078916311264, -0.019860735163092613, 0.1337164342403412, 0.06132761761546135, 0.01821480318903923, -0.07913493365049362, 0.039446428418159485, 0.02203829400241375, -0.027057336643338203, -0.013313991017639637, -0.014802688732743263, 0.024749333038926125, 0.016758376732468605, 0.06896764039993286, 0.03390021622180939, 0.040387995541095734, -0.013862407766282558, 0.033988870680332184, -0.018378574401140213, -0.0006198152550496161, -0.00572276720777154, 0.03227795287966728, 0.002709502587094903, -0.0071646892465651035, -0.06885115802288055, 0.019417474046349525, 0.035251956433057785, -0.01332507748156786, -0.03195370361208916, 0.023687247186899185, -0.002188062760978937, 0.0033853892236948013, -0.018103616312146187, -0.03363211080431938, 0.0129496855661273, 0.007172934710979462, -0.025476068258285522, -0.010436296463012695, -0.012211831286549568, -0.045005135238170624, -0.011312414892017841, 0.06138714775443077, 0.0117513258010149, -0.01881529577076435, 0.009962649084627628, -0.021543586626648903, -0.01993090845644474, -0.04486585035920143, -0.013167672790586948, 0.028035100549459457, 0.007158293854445219, 0.008237025700509548, -0.028179211542010307, 0.012884888797998428, -0.007208633702248335, -0.03529048711061478, -0.01561613380908966, 0.014048803597688675, -0.004071858245879412, 0.016818052157759666, -0.011643326841294765, -0.040364839136600494, 0.02283703163266182, -0.02329893968999386, 0.052518103271722794, -0.012459647841751575, -0.03826747089624405, -0.013735841028392315, -0.014970504678785801, 0.08886649459600449, -0.018441779538989067, 0.008909913711249828, 0.0007244500447995961, -0.01786939613521099, -0.013719777576625347, -0.021661853417754173, 0.02434299699962139, -0.021355854347348213, 0.004675965290516615, -0.018547676503658295, 0.009911904111504555, -0.01748761348426342, -0.04981132596731186, 0.018677642568945885, -0.04696040228009224, 0.034247878938913345, -0.023917116224765778, -0.029606612399220467, 0.04167000576853752, 0.011724919080734253, 0.03405545651912689, 0.02982478030025959, -0.020156243816018105, 0.058193694800138474, -0.04156609997153282, -0.05282721295952797, -0.009407998993992805, -0.002232686150819063, -0.052505575120449066, -0.022130802273750305, -0.01542490255087614, 0.0581342875957489, 0.04805970937013626, 0.007625145372003317, 0.0012749549932777882, 0.04056639224290848, -0.01356450654566288, -0.0066165863536298275, 0.0260227732360363, -0.058398716151714325, -0.016147030517458916, 0.03880438208580017, -0.01518783438950777, -0.025020601227879524, -0.03910233825445175, -0.0111983772367239, -0.04810676723718643, 0.061040714383125305, -0.002246131654828787, -0.01567724347114563, 0.005711131729185581, 0.01182926632463932, 0.010767862200737, -0.059214577078819275, -0.02730986662209034, -0.011757819913327694, -0.006844509858638048, 0.005322996526956558, -0.03336991369724274, 0.027338624000549316, -0.02323778346180916, -0.02319568209350109, 0.0239664725959301, 0.05264996364712715, -0.0078077781945466995, 0.032025232911109924, 0.003523861523717642, 0.017523949965834618, 0.005557391792535782, 0.03932798281311989, -0.025518963113427162, 0.004212735220789909, 0.01249026507139206, -0.04434453323483467, -0.015697132796049118, 0.03375879302620888, -0.00427286047488451, 0.00920960959047079, -0.015925325453281403, 0.011286737397313118, -0.04253702238202095, 0.069051094353199, -0.032382380217313766, 0.008778143674135208, -0.024259354919195175, 0.00644984794780612, -0.011271798051893711, -0.023638639599084854, 0.017702344805002213, -0.014866572804749012, -0.00041877623880282044, 0.025836151093244553, 0.05965503677725792, -0.03075367584824562, -0.015023574233055115, 0.05856039375066757, -0.01892908103764057, -0.041388001292943954, -0.0012775968061760068, -0.0028801411390304565, -0.007041610311716795, 0.04622828587889671, -0.01714376173913479, 0.03254668787121773, -0.009048718959093094, 0.05353099852800369, -0.10980625450611115, 0.0005026475992053747, 0.019723525270819664, 0.016995547339320183, 0.02900891751050949, -0.056762028485536575, 0.0027066697366535664, 0.06043197214603424, -0.0399496890604496, -0.0020627242047339678, -0.018334582448005676, -0.008206400088965893, -0.04191335290670395, -0.0031868629157543182, -0.00731388945132494, 0.03880321606993675, 0.002400721423327923, -0.006982412654906511, 0.008319507353007793, 0.003073554253205657, -0.01927037350833416, -0.020744290202856064, -0.002528583165258169, 0.026727119460701942, 0.023209309205412865, -0.06644897162914276, 0.040051110088825226, -0.013562461361289024, -0.026422852650284767, 0.015524323098361492, 0.01996547542512417, 0.021920248866081238, 0.020209919661283493, 0.01107857283204794, 0.009092616848647594, 0.05084981024265289, -0.0014138218248263001, 0.0041150921024382114, -0.04938469082117081, -0.005822787526994944, 0.01680467277765274, 0.03666340559720993, -0.02300981432199478, 0.003257340518757701, -0.031867556273937225, -0.012122155167162418, -0.0010292616207152605, 0.0007646800950169563, -0.029506443068385124, -0.044241540133953094, -0.0036807165015488863, 0.020600400865077972, 0.009166357107460499, -0.047221191227436066, 0.0029330060351639986, -0.012562409043312073, -0.014380881562829018, 0.05765523388981819, 0.028418511152267456, 0.008887847885489464, 0.035232238471508026, -0.02865222655236721, -0.04051564261317253, 0.03476891666650772, 0.04190484434366226, -0.0016065951203927398, -0.030342528596520424, -0.0020500498358160257, -0.0028167094569653273, -0.03260942921042442, 0.008727828040719032, 0.02392847277224064, -0.043026454746723175, 0.03158272057771683, -0.016078278422355652, 0.005598330404609442, 0.035063039511442184, -0.027260836213827133, 0.0018667737022042274, -0.07382269948720932, 0.07682754844427109, 0.015518128871917725, -0.01291181705892086, -0.06376723945140839, -0.0019179333467036486, -0.027774682268500328, -0.0008952991920523345, 0.059243567287921906, 0.01845986396074295, 0.0014997926773503423, -0.02835356816649437, 0.008673501200973988, 0.0013941082870587707, -0.01990460976958275, 0.052132315933704376, 0.009724159725010395, -0.011166595853865147, 0.010812507010996342, 0.006500487215816975, 0.03134692460298538, 0.042913228273391724, -0.030475955456495285, 0.0072701056487858295, 0.009635990485548973, 0.008802244439721107, 0.01839786395430565, 0.05293339490890503, 0.02842080406844616, 0.00016316719120368361, 0.0462258905172348, -0.03795618936419487, -0.003936766646802425, 0.03566095605492592, 0.003995183389633894, -0.04408624395728111, 0.03923216089606285, -0.012532738037407398, -0.011975335888564587, -0.009945770725607872, 0.009282573126256466, 0.012084657326340675, -0.037631332874298096, -0.0016848171362653375, 0.02283640019595623, -0.017705803737044334, 0.022591914981603622, 0.020233282819390297, 0.02612147107720375, 0.0667317807674408, -0.04053398594260216, 0.005652959458529949, 0.002886805683374405, -0.0076760402880609035, 0.016718542203307152, 0.027949968352913857, 0.004195563029497862, 0.01949808932840824, 0.009372802451252937, 0.010113908909261227, -0.002412497764453292, 0.017926989123225212, -0.01590234972536564, 0.06008750945329666, 0.005227985326200724, -0.0010169313754886389, 0.005181737709790468, 0.018453650176525116, 0.018690841272473335, 0.006605536676943302, -0.00957949087023735, 0.03673253208398819, -0.06635735929012299, -0.05025433748960495, -0.017301103100180626, -0.04046585410833359, -0.02511923760175705, -0.0291180070489645, 0.0021112761460244656, 0.031235897913575172, 0.022379228845238686, -0.0012454998213797808, 0.0016771287191659212, -0.0145039651542902, 0.03428603336215019, -0.02793007530272007, 0.017920726910233498, -0.006863757502287626, 0.003299837466329336, -0.019392814487218857, -0.011820178478956223, -0.05332968384027481, -0.03042454831302166, -0.0063367546536028385, 0.046528611332178116, 0.045976411551237106, -0.02636645920574665, -0.06106385961174965, 0.01197024155408144, 0.04899555444717407, -0.08534795790910721, -0.04152568429708481, -0.03780875355005264, 0.03493986651301384, 0.007482411339879036, 0.003448006696999073 ]
<p>I am using the R 'multcomp' library (<a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/multcomp/" rel="nofollow">http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/multcomp/</a>) to calculate Dunnett's test. I am using the script below:</p> <pre><code>Group &lt;- factor(c("A","A","B","B","B","C","C","C","D","D","D","E","E","F","F","F")) Value &lt;- c(5,5.09901951359278,4.69041575982343,4.58257569495584,4.79583152331272,5,5.09901951359278,4.24264068711928,5.09901951359278,5.19615242270663,4.58257569495584,6.16441400296898,6.85565460040104,7.68114574786861,7.07106781186548,6.48074069840786) data &lt;- data.frame(Group, Value) aov &lt;- aov(Value ~ Group, data) summary(glht(aov, linfct=mcp(Group="Dunnett"))) </code></pre> <p>Now if I run this script through the R Console multiple times I get very slightly different results each time. Here's one example:</p> <pre><code> Simultaneous Tests for General Linear Hypotheses Multiple Comparisons of Means: Dunnett Contrasts Fit: aov(formula = Value ~ Group, data = data) Linear Hypotheses: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) B - A == 0 -0.35990 0.37009 -0.972 0.76545 C - A == 0 -0.26896 0.37009 -0.727 0.90019 D - A == 0 -0.09026 0.37009 -0.244 0.99894 E - A == 0 1.46052 0.40541 3.603 0.01710 * F - A == 0 2.02814 0.37009 5.480 0.00104 ** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 (Adjusted p values reported -- single-step method) </code></pre> <p>And here's another:</p> <pre><code> Simultaneous Tests for General Linear Hypotheses Multiple Comparisons of Means: Dunnett Contrasts Fit: aov(formula = Value ~ Group, data = data) Linear Hypotheses: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) B - A == 0 -0.35990 0.37009 -0.972 0.7654 C - A == 0 -0.26896 0.37009 -0.727 0.9001 D - A == 0 -0.09026 0.37009 -0.244 0.9989 E - A == 0 1.46052 0.40541 3.603 0.0173 * F - A == 0 2.02814 0.37009 5.480 &lt;0.001 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 (Adjusted p values reported -- single-step method) </code></pre> <p>As you can see, the above two results differ very slightly, but it's enough to move the final group (F) from two stars to three stars, which I find worrying. </p> <p>I have several questions regarding this:</p> <ol> <li>Why is this happening?! Surely if you put the same data in each time you should get the same data out. </li> <li>Is there some kind of random number being used somewhere in the Dunnett's calculation?</li> <li>Is this slight variation each time actually a problem?</li> </ol>
74,493
[ -0.05083531141281128, 0.025068094953894615, -0.01264683436602354, -0.03293135017156601, 0.032434333115816116, 0.014917894266545773, -0.03373771905899048, -0.06650549918413162, -0.02808332070708275, 0.0012568598613142967, 0.023094233125448227, 0.0253618061542511, 0.06704679131507874, 0.021195434033870697, -0.0077433898113667965, -0.012569642625749111, -0.018199807032942772, 0.01028495654463768, -0.007141224108636379, -0.009575859643518925, -0.025099551305174828, 0.012179789133369923, -0.006029179319739342, -0.039542295038700104, -0.010191299021244049, 0.051060132682323456, 0.006529594771564007, 0.018234994262456894, 0.019419340416789055, 0.04322522133588791, -0.044720832258462906, -0.009589123539626598, 0.02207992412149906, 0.004521254450082779, -0.0007653970969840884, 0.048760171979665756, 0.013388054445385933, -0.003172529162839055, -0.04010855779051781, 0.03515663743019104, -0.012945116497576237, -0.017274335026741028, -0.028068050742149353, 0.051816631108522415, 0.01916869543492794, 0.014591180719435215, -0.009442757815122604, 0.01392416562885046, 0.07495538890361786, 0.01834845542907715, 0.08117107301950455, 0.022328153252601624, 0.0003087426593992859, 0.017009062692523003, -0.020849177613854408, 0.004588456358760595, 0.027899127453565598, 0.057936351746320724, 0.0010512840235605836, -0.04606516659259796, 0.03174487501382828, -0.04690010845661163, 0.0017889984883368015, -0.003260069526731968, -0.058763280510902405, 0.003579565556719899, -0.0034644969273358583, -0.01248666550964117, 0.021600767970085144, -0.014712691307067871, 0.025442035868763924, 0.018146436661481857, 0.026318732649087906, -0.030109575018286705, 0.006224083714187145, -0.02032739482820034, 0.0024393699131906033, -0.021271122619509697, 0.06694193184375763, 0.03733733668923378, -0.008906389586627483, 0.008492105640470982, 0.016854967921972275, -0.006343891844153404, 0.038164738565683365, 0.01388793345540762, 0.04858001321554184, -0.02250261791050434, 0.009470341727137566, 0.0326082743704319, -0.012123635038733482, 0.023546922951936722, 0.061845291405916214, 0.07014159858226776, -0.0361582450568676, 0.060179054737091064, -0.03589054197072983, 0.052255779504776, 0.012375601567327976, -0.012362872250378132, -0.015071128495037556, -0.051300887018442154, 0.016378095373511314, -0.01417128462344408, -0.020396586507558823, -0.0088554248213768, -0.07362174987792969, -0.03704584762454033, 0.01000763289630413, -0.008500475436449051, -0.011573566123843193, 0.02582477405667305, -0.04934344440698624, -0.04071202501654625, 0.02497103437781334, -0.026472805067896843, -0.025797344744205475, 0.00685492530465126, 0.05472595989704132, 0.04117138311266899, 0.05094597861170769, 0.003035189351066947, 0.012411861680448055, -0.03437099978327751, -0.011554133147001266, -0.005822202656418085, 0.012170725502073765, -0.03831569477915764, -0.018828552216291428, 0.042144618928432465, 0.025312894955277443, 0.0036377236247062683, 0.018141761422157288, -0.008043905720114708, -0.0028387445490807295, -0.023969534784555435, -0.0829373374581337, -0.09946317970752716, 0.047399844974279404, -0.04654792696237564, 0.010817394591867924, -0.0070733861066401005, -0.013633123598992825, -0.011653079651296139, 0.024424977600574493, -0.011606036685407162, 0.029442433267831802, 0.039858076721429825, 0.02724757231771946, 0.028982240706682205, -0.030858585610985756, 0.008791626431047916, -0.03000270389020443, 0.02610158734023571, 0.014031823724508286, -0.0821072906255722, -0.005116183776408434, -0.019970115274190903, 0.0113410959020257, 0.02659219317138195, 0.02856578305363655, -0.03183693438768387, -0.0453682467341423, -0.0407906137406826, 0.0162301454693079, -0.014568131417036057, 0.058181554079055786, 0.006597401108592749, 0.0181334987282753, 0.03172192722558975, -0.045621901750564575, 0.010816467925906181, -0.01480782125145197, 0.04103061556816101, 0.046363480389118195, -0.026730917394161224, 0.03766772523522377, -0.030710682272911072, 0.03837759420275688, 0.003779653226956725, -0.03990030288696289, -0.030819013714790344, -0.01323179341852665, -0.04866162687540054, 0.02188742533326149, 0.022244779393076897, -0.0009009505738504231, 0.01550215296447277, 0.0586363859474659, -0.05635228008031845, -0.0529153011739254, -0.055161502212285995, -0.01857909746468067, 0.014081585220992565, -0.054356515407562256, -0.009584987536072731, 0.021827369928359985, 0.024933457374572754, 0.013472631573677063, -0.019121086224913597, -0.00888399314135313, 0.023990431800484657, 0.03494428098201752, -0.03358670696616173, 0.0009220343199558556, 0.04015762358903885, 0.07221905142068863, -0.012493925169110298, 0.014938510954380035, -0.012913778424263, -0.013936602510511875, 0.02563680149614811, -0.038013216108083725, -0.010528186336159706, 0.0038082944229245186, 0.0012410107301548123, -0.00477454112842679, 0.032572295516729355, -0.023032890632748604, 0.05321526527404785, -0.07651905715465546, -0.01595623418688774, 0.06705116480588913, -0.021586516872048378, -0.0041241152212023735, -0.02257910743355751, -0.031188948079943657, 0.00775805301964283, -0.04542384296655655, 0.012435555458068848, -0.03511042520403862, -0.03299567475914955, 0.0066887494176626205, 0.02662554755806923, -0.005777457728981972, 0.008726120926439762, 0.029920270666480064, -0.016712386161088943, -0.012710221111774445, 0.03345079720020294, 0.02085934765636921, -0.03801437467336655, 0.04767131060361862, 0.029484326019883156, 0.024381859228014946, 0.0034278666134923697, 0.03208138421177864, -0.030015621334314346, 0.07360633462667465, -0.0562458299100399, 0.001079181325621903, 0.026764923706650734, 0.015173293650150299, -0.01928252913057804, -0.019136782735586166, -0.008000992238521576, 0.008020774461328983, -0.023784227669239044, -0.024012848734855652, 0.04150000959634781, 0.01494596991688013, -0.0035170316696166992, -0.02229810133576393, -0.022565599530935287, -0.0004554556799121201, 0.03168410435318947, -0.017441216856241226, -0.0019976114854216576, 0.017272641882300377, -0.0010988287394866347, 0.022615864872932434, -0.06127838417887688, 0.0010126829147338867, -0.018830962479114532, -0.005447832867503166, 0.0019051616545766592, 0.008160592056810856, 0.031487490981817245, -0.042833104729652405, 0.041041191667318344, -0.015453862957656384, -0.039967723190784454, 0.02635723538696766, -0.027518082410097122, -0.019193697720766068, 0.009890707209706306, -0.0035287716891616583, 0.005072515457868576, 0.0231455247849226, 0.036456719040870667, -0.02574154920876026, 0.023859523236751556, 0.013718415051698685, -0.047752853482961655, -0.015653980895876884, -0.025837749242782593, -0.036654695868492126, -0.03964419290423393, -0.014521421864628792, 0.03993290662765503, -0.03400181233882904, -0.05853349342942238, 0.016661403700709343, -0.0642552375793457, 0.023218581452965736, -0.011794961988925934, -0.03036649338901043, -0.02355709858238697, -0.010417266748845577, -0.01905064843595028, 0.020366890355944633, -0.03819678723812103, 0.008546506986021996, -0.0423535481095314, -0.015147835947573185, 0.00890669971704483, -0.016325682401657104, -0.0028263935819268227, -0.028991125524044037, -0.030456624925136566, 0.06829183548688889, 0.038873087614774704, -0.055033184587955475, -0.0810946673154831, 0.007389034144580364, -0.023951660841703415, 0.0006920109735801816, 0.03971169516444206, 0.04237755015492439, -0.007227582391351461, 0.03826962038874626, -0.00722423056140542, 0.03614041209220886, 0.0572148822247982, -0.019748156890273094, 0.010254510678350925, -0.007512494456022978, 0.0013837760780006647, -0.027129700407385826, 0.01962697133421898, 0.030659144744277, 0.021308453753590584, 0.001081803347915411, 0.022955626249313354, 0.0000594438097323291, -0.04065393656492233, -0.0349637046456337, 0.04265381768345833, 0.028721019625663757, 0.012997172772884369, -0.08112820982933044, 0.034704096615314484, 0.030024774372577667, -0.03851752355694771, -0.0462711900472641, -0.013138199225068092, 0.03460513800382614, -0.03602856025099754, -0.0222134068608284, 0.05087614804506302, 0.03820136561989784, -0.014757447876036167, 0.006865857634693384, -0.02998582273721695, -0.0059213824570178986, 0.004005577880889177, -0.040196891874074936, -0.03855254128575325, 0.06630712747573853, 0.038311272859573364, 0.022056998685002327, -0.002666712738573551, -0.059844791889190674, 0.02356567792594433, -0.030000023543834686, 0.003813211340457201, -0.014081835746765137, 0.024717608466744423, 0.044529106467962265, 0.05058452859520912, 0.01692298613488674, -0.009183122776448727, -0.024743614718317986, -0.04096154868602753, -0.07063445448875427, 0.061562854796648026, 0.013769939541816711, -0.008631596341729164, 0.013207392767071724, -0.07703643292188644, 0.007452917750924826, -0.02550392411649227, 0.00990046001970768, 0.012840683571994305, 0.028088053688406944, -0.020981870591640472, 0.03967461735010147, 0.009546729736030102, 0.011529024690389633, -0.05919795110821724, 0.023115556687116623, 0.06974634528160095, -0.007925541140139103, 0.02515922673046589, 0.01577785052359104, -0.05323788523674011, 0.0036280211061239243, -0.001886909012682736, 0.027354387566447258, 0.029240161180496216, 0.015043765306472778, 0.03844764083623886, 0.016796240583062172, -0.022146666422486305, 0.006217630114406347, -0.015965163707733154, 0.03339951112866402, 0.05182956904172897, -0.025865254923701286, -0.03790702298283577, -0.0015186024829745293, -0.014832909218966961, 0.0111569594591856, 0.010119634680449963, 0.0041414001025259495, 0.010235031135380268, 0.013933598063886166, 0.06028700992465019, -0.026331953704357147, 0.03546633943915367, 0.025259150192141533, 0.005808611866086721, -0.014272784814238548, -0.012323006056249142, 0.0061023663729429245, -0.006269545294344425, -0.0034570263233035803, 0.03074946440756321, 0.02035382203757763, 0.01106624398380518, -0.006085702683776617, 0.05156737565994263, -0.00927045475691557, -0.03674042969942093, 0.02980140410363674, 0.022510193288326263, 0.011216439306735992, -0.00013384233170654625, -0.02642618864774704, 0.002168206963688135, 0.025686239823698997, 0.017133187502622604, 0.020156869664788246, 0.035149719566106796, -0.0740167498588562, 0.0041102394461631775, 0.03554730489850044, 0.03804256021976471, -0.03742004930973053, 0.018858691677451134, -0.03063788078725338, 0.014482995495200157, 0.001954543637111783, -0.04541895166039467, 0.03449089452624321, -0.010476439259946346, 0.030106032267212868, -0.02436852641403675, -0.018428150564432144, -0.04529143497347832, 0.020892389118671417, -0.0203679371625185, -0.002652099123224616, -0.029473431408405304, 0.008119937963783741, -0.0355798713862896, 0.007529539987444878, 0.0006726767169311643, 0.05173840373754501, -0.05039001256227493, 0.0023069093003869057, 0.0500500425696373, 0.014093619771301746, -0.020449474453926086, -0.008922641165554523, 0.011645161546766758, -0.0376412458717823, -0.009524389170110226, 0.04214128851890564, -0.018135135993361473, 0.0005752231809310615, 0.009966375306248665, 0.005171964876353741, -0.0377647802233696, 0.00015559664461761713, -0.029596678912639618, 0.0044951546005904675, 0.03188711404800415, -0.01432168111205101, 0.08172260969877243, 0.0017512571066617966, -0.034171998500823975, 0.018030624836683273, -0.03884771093726158, 0.021273456513881683, 0.017542976886034012, -0.008421390317380428, -0.048282526433467865, -0.005216632969677448, -0.0005591544904746115, 0.02773650921881199, 0.028738226741552353, 0.026975169777870178, -0.012550395913422108, 0.04103895649313927, 0.02906416542828083, 0.022330228239297867, -0.011306289583444595, 0.014222715981304646, 0.03672770410776138, 0.010245228186249733, -0.02843816950917244, -0.00039292211295105517, 0.023886853829026222, -0.03562752902507782, 0.011238522827625275, 0.019788386300206184, -0.04606189206242561, -0.007184989750385284, -0.00024693223531357944, -0.006041058339178562, -0.023735614493489265, -0.02849833481013775, -0.0160729568451643, -0.0001415592123521492, 0.03765244036912918, 0.0039496030658483505, -0.03581555187702179, -0.02127191424369812, 0.05026475712656975, -0.0005225393688306212, 0.013076664879918098, -0.000862417567986995, 0.06592711806297302, 0.009257419034838676, 0.0015073387185111642, -0.04853906109929085, -0.01385178416967392, 0.04039325937628746, -0.04329078271985054, -0.0602407269179821, -0.019590364769101143, -0.06169426068663597, -0.001930183032527566, 0.02990352362394333, -0.023940198123455048, 0.030461657792329788, -0.022740142419934273, -0.004452552646398544, -0.031467556953430176, -0.0018662685761228204, 0.0751185193657875, -0.022418538108468056, 0.0346328504383564, -0.007066761609166861, 0.009578577242791653, -0.020726483315229416, 0.0008859206573106349, -0.014620212838053703, -0.033785898238420486, -0.012492985464632511, -0.02072019875049591, 0.00004627364614862017, 0.04873171076178551, 0.0007182829431258142, -0.009561016224324703, -0.02797919325530529, -0.011003755033016205, 0.011671104468405247, -0.046612441539764404, -0.0007596376817673445, -0.021040644496679306, 0.005239546764642, -0.03266126662492752, 0.007427803240716457, 0.014763209968805313, -0.0026696613058447838, -0.02140442468225956, -0.021988848224282265, -0.040197353810071945, 0.00784513633698225, 0.07535829395055771, -0.005312055349349976, 0.014586773701012135, -0.03921299800276756, -0.025276297703385353, 0.005365092307329178, 0.009165400639176369, -0.01426174957305193, -0.02187660150229931, 0.010619291104376316, -0.07461939752101898, 0.015358188189566135, -0.008714462630450726, 0.013334120623767376, 0.03665979206562042, 0.0027336766943335533, 0.06595490872859955, 0.06983014196157455, 0.008809948340058327, -0.005405967589467764, -0.052861910313367844, -0.014173367992043495, -0.03451698645949364, 0.055629976093769073, 0.07538754492998123, 0.02035270445048809, -0.011084649711847305, 0.047946762293577194, 0.03553077206015587, 0.04003334790468216, 0.04103688523173332, 0.030964108183979988, -0.0013277825200930238, 0.022361131384968758, -0.03356610983610153, 0.0004144434933550656, 0.011368365958333015, -0.01681291125714779, 0.007376477587968111, -0.009279546327888966, -0.030431272462010384, 0.03400138020515442, 0.014689645729959011, -0.012281130999326706, -0.03267194703221321, -0.012649834156036377, -0.05050944909453392, 0.019664322957396507, -0.016257090494036674, -0.016282808035612106, 0.06334645301103592, 0.0369831882417202, 0.002360521350055933, 0.0111484844237566, 0.02178407460451126, -0.059840645641088486, -0.073216512799263, -0.015456232242286205, -0.004186400678008795, -0.04444935917854309, 0.052815474569797516, -0.02376163750886917, -0.05382835119962692, -0.0031664525158703327, -0.043649762868881226, 0.0371621772646904, -0.0011351669672876596, 0.008900079876184464, -0.014007444493472576, 0.050142623484134674, -0.04704367369413376, -0.010756978765130043, -0.015135256573557854, -0.05548970401287079, 0.1438368558883667, 0.04935172200202942, 0.006518138572573662, -0.07397039234638214, 0.004875965882092714, 0.04916580766439438, -0.03546398878097534, -0.01857413910329342, -0.007782737258821726, 0.007519005332142115, 0.008663324639201164, 0.07096490263938904, 0.05282069370150566, 0.07945416867733002, -0.008060568943619728, 0.01337005477398634, -0.015713248401880264, 0.004778905771672726, 0.00417145062237978, 0.04346246272325516, 0.02310028299689293, -0.02955973520874977, -0.03528676927089691, 0.026964792981743813, 0.010260725393891335, 0.017449183389544487, -0.0037438184954226017, -0.02027202397584915, -0.027446774765849113, 0.01655702106654644, -0.019224422052502632, 0.03141526132822037, -0.0011421630624681711, -0.005086645949631929, -0.005368974059820175, 0.023306390270590782, 0.04249884560704231, -0.06878260523080826, -0.0006793289794586599, 0.048871733248233795, 0.021222565323114395, -0.014543227851390839, 0.022120174020528793, 0.002926664426922798, -0.0004847849195357412, -0.02000288851559162, -0.017290154471993446, 0.04357327148318291, -0.01191339548677206, -0.035269297659397125, -0.029719466343522072, 0.001200002385303378, -0.00120609812438488, -0.034274715930223465, -0.017489267513155937, -0.02513224259018898, 0.02092430740594864, -0.007401876617223024, -0.007231846451759338, -0.006744574289768934, 0.02337908186018467, 0.013749615289270878, 0.042532384395599365, 0.03563595563173294, -0.025763504207134247, -0.05329533666372299, -0.04449600353837013, 0.04540236294269562, -0.014489846304059029, 0.03246968612074852, 0.042667537927627563, 0.0013605032581835985, -0.029364239424467087, -0.035631515085697174, 0.022328635677695274, 0.019199922680854797, 0.030701780691742897, 0.008649911731481552, -0.0070941634476184845, -0.045014943927526474, -0.02522248961031437, -0.02499416470527649, -0.052418652921915054, -0.018905114382505417, -0.03155026212334633, -0.02693379856646061, 0.022224798798561096, 0.01994650438427925, 0.01681450940668583, 0.04383338615298271, 0.0046852449886500835, 0.06486500054597855, -0.010123038664460182, -0.055494844913482666, -0.03948713466525078, 0.015737229958176613, -0.020379597321152687, -0.025130031630396843, -0.03475036099553108, 0.05538184195756912, -0.004617469850927591, 0.022275639697909355, 0.0017862583044916391, 0.025211356580257416, -0.029536090791225433, -0.0034674247726798058, 0.02572772465646267, -0.012356407009065151, 0.028031615540385246, 0.011451776139438152, -0.016213443130254745, -0.04506608098745346, 0.0219008456915617, -0.03548150509595871, -0.048650991171598434, 0.03420596197247505, -0.01607079990208149, -0.03290262445807457, 0.0006610768032260239, 0.0013085982063785195, -0.008284496143460274, -0.010884623974561691, -0.010331557132303715, -0.02104528807103634, -0.006458963267505169, -0.017750035971403122, -0.018275417387485504, -0.02972394786775112, 0.043868377804756165, -0.025996478274464607, 0.02222728542983532, 0.05916987359523773, 0.009988144971430302, 0.028001008555293083, -0.003860302735120058, 0.05825652927160263, -0.005574957933276892, 0.05657470226287842, 0.04675900936126709, -0.02690100111067295, 0.026590347290039062, -0.025645475834608078, -0.018747225403785706, 0.011821296997368336, 0.03960181027650833, 0.01754823699593544, 0.003448988776654005, 0.032085079699754715, 0.001214970019645989, 0.07102534919977188, -0.06600063294172287, 0.02504611387848854, -0.02991349622607231, 0.007089369464665651, 0.03579403832554817, 0.03338734060525894, -0.0259561724960804, 0.008918681181967258, 0.017989469692111015, 0.012747482396662235, 0.04150383919477463, 0.015438171103596687, 0.0034685973078012466, -0.01926487684249878, -0.04827112704515457, 0.005698707420378923, 0.021457919850945473, -0.011324851773679256, 0.0038763675838708878, 0.037744421511888504, 0.002028224989771843, 0.016101868823170662, 0.0025708875618875027, 0.029686495661735535, -0.09102487564086914, -0.0030132413376122713, 0.0013151930179446936, 0.04989065229892731, 0.00625674007460475, -0.03441662713885307, -0.018891723826527596, 0.020696407184004784, -0.043884262442588806, -0.008098185062408447, 0.017098957672715187, 0.02100415527820587, -0.050622593611478806, -0.0007351160165853798, -0.02704915776848793, 0.007421541027724743, 0.02831817977130413, 0.023625167086720467, 0.06827263534069061, 0.0003968402452301234, 0.002476854482665658, -0.043598778545856476, -0.016033105552196503, 0.017653584480285645, 0.027292102575302124, -0.03580256178975105, 0.029551586136221886, -0.004427663516253233, -0.023034129291772842, 0.005768917500972748, -0.0302690751850605, 0.04524850845336914, 0.003726302646100521, 0.037407610565423965, 0.03826657310128212, 0.05079270154237747, -0.008358989842236042, 0.006431670393794775, -0.007524662185460329, -0.0007859778706915677, -0.0030509615316987038, 0.002703464590013027, -0.020357200875878334, 0.021179864183068275, 0.018396608531475067, 0.015313440002501011, -0.02544928528368473, 0.027021754533052444, -0.019009413197636604, -0.013666109181940556, -0.023557426407933235, 0.0018658756744116545, 0.008283221162855625, -0.01741761714220047, 0.008006058633327484, -0.01970091462135315, 0.01928688772022724, 0.050865430384874344, 0.050846755504608154, -0.00766103295609355, 0.01042063720524311, -0.009835480712354183, -0.04198595881462097, 0.04646892845630646, -0.012738965451717377, 0.0388355515897274, -0.038452330976724625, -0.0064712692983448505, -0.03301398083567619, -0.018181847408413887, -0.00363127700984478, 0.0022348365746438503, -0.025451188907027245, 0.0191804151982069, -0.003972087986767292, 0.0022967904806137085, 0.0018176616868004203, 0.005952096544206142, 0.003933066967874765, -0.11473599076271057, 0.1033182218670845, 0.004603681154549122, 0.004852249287068844, -0.033856190741062164, 0.01089454721659422, -0.049766335636377335, 0.045315906405448914, 0.02356729842722416, -0.009620588272809982, 0.00781102292239666, 0.008209088817238808, 0.017416873946785927, 0.014845140278339386, -0.058466698974370956, 0.018846770748496056, 0.0041184495203197, -0.003799998201429844, -0.012741262093186378, -0.011112545616924763, 0.026541784405708313, 0.017201635986566544, -0.021709566935896873, -0.018523486331105232, -0.02263193391263485, 0.007148837670683861, -0.0029662924353033304, 0.05119319632649422, 0.0016763813327997923, -0.030311115086078644, 0.005445959512144327, -0.03198746219277382, 0.009049588814377785, 0.05136134847998619, 0.01877821795642376, -0.04215608909726143, 0.03494049236178398, -0.0068582212552428246, 0.000330267968820408, 0.009854450821876526, -0.007106014993041754, -0.025821596384048462, -0.07440371066331863, 0.03029628098011017, 0.030569005757570267, -0.007878536358475685, -0.021610399708151817, 0.02562873438000679, -0.00828343816101551, 0.04322510585188866, 0.005254941992461681, 0.01483339536935091, -0.03405716270208359, -0.04003218933939934, 0.027720335870981216, -0.012502419762313366, 0.00605820631608367, 0.02402583137154579, 0.012502877973020077, -0.005348007660359144, -0.06457369029521942, 0.04486095532774925, -0.007956593297421932, 0.04521393030881882, -0.012601787224411964, -0.02885471098124981, 0.01695350557565689, -0.01240368839353323, 0.020277805626392365, -0.016049612313508987, -0.015024141408503056, 0.055945489555597305, -0.053967710584402084, 0.030256692320108414, -0.013179185800254345, 0.012248899787664413, -0.012676277197897434, -0.006346757058054209, 0.005248516332358122, 0.02539839595556259, -0.010897145606577396, 0.026073403656482697, 0.004475451074540615, 0.009314545430243015, 0.01091468520462513, 0.0058755455538630486, 0.03090256080031395, -0.029821889474987984, 0.013300953432917595, 0.01617583818733692, -0.011568543501198292, -0.030319122597575188, -0.03473324701189995, 0.04581420123577118, -0.018042679876089096, -0.022269032895565033, -0.03849845752120018, -0.01558332983404398, 0.022474180907011032, 0.05441366508603096, -0.041697531938552856, -0.021029967814683914, -0.025208568200469017, 0.019796593114733696, 0.008557596243917942, -0.0225732009857893 ]
<p>i have a new data set which is basically as bad as the last (same sort of data) and have been asked to try non linear regression on it, with the focus on partition (I will be using boosting and bagging). The dependent variable is continuous however.</p> <p>I require the input variables intact (as in not factorized) as i again require identification of what input variables affect the dependent variable of interest and how.</p> <p>Again the many X input variables are very different in terms of distribution, i have categorical inputs too.</p> <p>I do not see much information in general with regards to non linear regression and linear correlation. Leaving the data set as is causes multiple inclusion of what are strongly correlated variables particularly in bootstrapping (the reason seems obvious due to the nature of bootstrap). </p> <p>to what degree is this a problem? For example; if X1 and X2 are collinear and X1 is Out of Bag with X2 in bag you have effectively not taken that variable out. Is this even an issue?</p>
37,388
[ -0.024799853563308716, 0.035158008337020874, -0.016086677089333534, 0.003672002349048853, 0.017079675570130348, 0.012131423689424992, -0.03204713761806488, 0.003615714842453599, 0.030078254640102386, -0.008841780945658684, 0.024862682446837425, 0.003475536359474063, 0.04048336297273636, -0.010738352313637733, -0.028873948380351067, -0.0013093174202367663, 0.004657315090298653, -0.002836747094988823, 0.04377805441617966, 0.020571472123265266, -0.04487118870019913, 0.03176400437951088, 0.010442376136779785, 0.00789592508226633, -0.018160760402679443, 0.042864713817834854, 0.004839415196329355, -0.011140906251966953, 0.05996847525238991, 0.04328472912311554, -0.016342686489224434, -0.0196041502058506, 0.020338397473096848, 0.042833469808101654, 0.009969727136194706, -0.010166872292757034, -0.032103147357702255, -0.03506883978843689, -0.011301146820187569, 0.039396487176418304, -0.05589991807937622, -0.023047897964715958, 0.015808338299393654, 0.03991713747382164, 0.002682702150195837, 0.03649274259805679, 0.038972944021224976, -0.010351309552788734, 0.031114881858229637, -0.03765648975968361, 0.07524479925632477, -0.016707424074411392, 0.05645144730806351, 0.05559786781668663, -0.010116560384631157, -0.008445494808256626, 0.04898757115006447, 0.09178099781274796, -0.024388693273067474, -0.04622422158718109, -0.01906415820121765, -0.01364949531853199, -0.0047722430899739265, 0.0053131673485040665, -0.014731178060173988, 0.018898267298936844, 0.019456693902611732, -0.00826515443623066, 0.0286034494638443, -0.029082205146551132, 0.01788945496082306, 0.01836281828582287, 0.05523201823234558, -0.04284157603979111, 0.002993987174704671, 0.006454620976001024, 0.02022499404847622, 0.014746906235814095, 0.023188550025224686, 0.023997044190764427, 0.020249225199222565, -0.004412381909787655, 0.005476867314428091, 0.05354085937142372, 0.0291869156062603, -0.023752517998218536, 0.05345674231648445, -0.0583752766251564, 0.030977673828601837, 0.03438560292124748, -0.03284178301692009, 0.005090717226266861, 0.05534011498093605, 0.02312173694372177, -0.05050419643521309, 0.019322656095027924, -0.02115076221525669, 0.04205213487148285, 0.02567397803068161, -0.005567691754549742, -0.003665162017568946, -0.005341530777513981, 0.030398067086935043, 0.044198036193847656, 0.006261295173317194, 0.020835500210523605, -0.042536843568086624, 0.016518238931894302, -0.00686329510062933, -0.03519339859485626, -0.021658895537257195, -0.007951843552291393, -0.007540576625615358, -0.015319839119911194, 0.03434981033205986, -0.014380352571606636, -0.032127536833286285, -0.025235332548618317, 0.025420665740966797, 0.07262744754552841, 0.008417103439569473, -0.04525144398212433, 0.03143000230193138, 0.014702715910971165, -0.024647103622555733, 0.039746154099702835, 0.03914276510477066, -0.025711704045534134, -0.028970571234822273, 0.04571163281798363, 0.007641449570655823, -0.006866356823593378, 0.03197845071554184, 0.009872201830148697, 0.019812049344182014, 0.008405625820159912, -0.08970171958208084, -0.05702313408255577, 0.0426352396607399, -0.056634340435266495, 0.014766011387109756, -0.01198447123169899, -0.02704390324652195, 0.014464120380580425, 0.07232941687107086, -0.015148247592151165, 0.0016229958273470402, -0.002641362836584449, 0.03557995706796646, 0.006285863928496838, -0.017997493967413902, -0.02055412530899048, -0.04994938150048256, -0.04958552122116089, -0.02699074149131775, -0.07558641582727432, 0.05349738523364067, 0.056834448128938675, 0.0058080293238162994, -0.02988429367542267, -0.011834320612251759, 0.008066672831773758, -0.0060015530325472355, 0.015476671047508717, -0.012266673147678375, -0.024694077670574188, 0.05821138247847557, -0.02679971605539322, 0.08138374984264374, 0.014257223345339298, -0.032937269657850266, 0.015441716648638248, -0.004695829935371876, 0.055917888879776, 0.045426785945892334, 0.0036642663180828094, -0.020581677556037903, -0.02158643864095211, 0.01619511842727661, -0.010882205329835415, -0.030822629109025, -0.031895749270915985, -0.015768317505717278, 0.017399892210960388, 0.021450497210025787, 0.04735396429896355, 0.022150784730911255, -0.06742516160011292, 0.048380058258771896, -0.04207763820886612, -0.05167096108198166, -0.06189969554543495, 0.03173777088522911, -0.02392633445560932, -0.041006460785865784, 0.038384996354579926, 0.002319296356290579, 0.020252669230103493, -0.003655462060123682, -0.04285043105483055, 0.011165990494191647, -0.012717893347144127, 0.012238050810992718, -0.051861539483070374, 0.010026995092630386, 0.03891880065202713, 0.026925230398774147, -0.01890772581100464, 0.05005597323179245, -0.043065931648015976, -0.07530073076486588, 0.018124336376786232, -0.02090771682560444, 0.018218621611595154, -0.07408954948186874, 0.019572056829929352, 0.03393954411149025, -0.020550280809402466, -0.047421813011169434, 0.022671852260828018, -0.04859064891934395, 0.06994412839412689, 0.04110053554177284, -0.019631626084446907, -0.03736826404929161, 0.010836567729711533, -0.007011250127106905, 0.02492387592792511, -0.006907681468874216, 0.014805453829467297, -0.04764685407280922, -0.00916170235723257, 0.03336700424551964, 0.03834258392453194, -0.007422386668622494, 0.016155391931533813, 0.047475505620241165, 0.018674304708838463, 0.03104666993021965, -0.0035604170989245176, 0.01013405155390501, -0.006167123559862375, 0.03178136795759201, -0.01571987196803093, 0.03968603536486626, -0.006731409579515457, 0.006084769032895565, -0.004325643181800842, 0.04508421942591667, 0.021134480834007263, 0.001343691605143249, 0.04629959911108017, 0.023370180279016495, 0.02123255282640457, -0.022930432111024857, -0.03191493824124336, 0.05611433833837509, -0.012351744808256626, 0.06168775632977486, 0.03324053809046745, 0.015587790869176388, -0.0231623612344265, -0.0019396505085751414, -0.016319619491696358, 0.0013135060435160995, 0.034075263887643814, -0.05826719477772713, 0.014782816171646118, 0.021739332005381584, -0.03452127426862717, 0.004309831187129021, -0.002441159915179014, -0.009693851694464684, -0.057886019349098206, 0.03156420215964317, 0.012155555188655853, -0.025195827707648277, 0.049164462834596634, -0.0031235634814947844, 0.018277456983923912, -0.00916233565658331, -0.024728819727897644, 0.0010750119108706713, 0.026099203154444695, -0.020087631419301033, -0.012551268562674522, -0.03593707084655762, 0.001801606616936624, 0.031233100220561028, -0.026347691193223, -0.0023597506806254387, 0.007724094204604626, -0.036136362701654434, -0.058804161846637726, -0.041144952178001404, -0.05196964368224144, 0.0025651678442955017, -0.0095582390204072, -0.04492799565196037, 0.013947379775345325, 0.025863509625196457, -0.04721725359559059, 0.0058250948786735535, -0.05256746709346771, -0.008441279642283916, -0.04496438056230545, 0.004026724491268396, 0.014650208875536919, -0.003374663880094886, -0.0037751076743006706, 0.01901138201355934, -0.021123996004462242, 0.024012669920921326, -0.07081488519906998, -0.056738656014204025, 0.0180111825466156, 0.021168379113078117, 0.0009691402083262801, 0.004730739165097475, -0.020695649087429047, 0.0759541243314743, 0.019942019134759903, -0.023652736097574234, -0.023427298292517662, -0.04217669367790222, -0.024272160604596138, -0.01490797009319067, 0.009079787880182266, 0.0029832341242581606, 0.04176299273967743, 0.010210073553025723, -0.016127169132232666, 0.03133271634578705, 0.028829170390963554, 0.0059895808808505535, -0.01080792024731636, 0.03785105049610138, -0.0026840479113161564, -0.0007019092445261776, 0.023069478571414948, 0.02920529805123806, -0.033301252871751785, -0.01960831508040428, -0.0002799962239805609, 0.001483820378780365, 0.04467706009745598, -0.037328608334064484, 0.012867922894656658, -0.0037779712583869696, 0.029439853504300117, -0.02672404609620571, -0.004805766046047211, 0.0015371885383501649, -0.06483744829893112, 0.039865992963314056, 0.0072364588268101215, 0.03527067229151726, -0.011495612561702728, 0.011839047074317932, 0.04035988077521324, 0.043043527752161026, -0.00844690389931202, 0.007318944204598665, -0.010576845146715641, -0.004928393755108118, 0.019551957026124, -0.023791246116161346, 0.0064453864470124245, 0.027324624359607697, 0.025887494906783104, 0.005558711942285299, 0.0019689034670591354, -0.045936230570077896, 0.01574031449854374, -0.0680379644036293, 0.017018185928463936, 0.011091373860836029, 0.059862032532691956, 0.016385620459914207, 0.031131980940699577, -0.005963436793535948, -0.013919265940785408, 0.004694976378232241, 0.01583539880812168, -0.0824052020907402, 0.017697541043162346, 0.005339235998690128, -0.002722646575421095, 0.005587385036051273, -0.015443083830177784, 0.007052415516227484, -0.030870376154780388, 0.01339386310428381, -0.0035712914541363716, 0.03101123683154583, -0.03555505722761154, -0.00037646162672899663, -0.04718703776597977, -0.025647930800914764, 0.0007923324010334909, -0.020233947783708572, 0.013155680149793625, -0.02134479023516178, 0.05708391219377518, 0.01986425183713436, -0.006159190088510513, -0.013378530740737915, -0.026732301339507103, 0.005457625724375248, 0.024147966876626015, 0.06158113479614258, 0.009194832295179367, 0.006700085010379553, -0.02646593190729618, 0.013636788353323936, 0.01479408424347639, 0.054917994886636734, 0.012291938997805119, -0.013803939335048199, 0.0014624730683863163, -0.011102311313152313, -0.038466259837150574, -0.0191733930259943, 0.019607994705438614, 0.013085339218378067, 0.004576532170176506, 0.04449659585952759, 0.024252256378531456, -0.046075239777565, 0.011339453980326653, 0.05818891152739525, 0.019604720175266266, -0.03351063281297684, -0.03294757753610611, -0.004930642433464527, 0.0025530150160193443, 0.026710495352745056, 0.011377111077308655, -0.006857973989099264, 0.006515625398606062, -0.00023740810866001993, 0.023834317922592163, 0.025047902017831802, -0.0036469169426709414, 0.012137169018387794, 0.05512869730591774, 0.02899383008480072, -0.011702579446136951, -0.03285745531320572, 0.042191389948129654, 0.05988818034529686, 0.015971288084983826, 0.02217445708811283, -0.00639163376763463, -0.0931982472538948, 0.0236053466796875, 0.03761771693825722, 0.03375282138586044, -0.023503363132476807, -0.013011823408305645, -0.030978817492723465, -0.021439211443066597, 0.02084580808877945, -0.022318735718727112, 0.009818851947784424, -0.034312594681978226, 0.019427983090281487, -0.022177768871188164, -0.057249732315540314, -0.05974855273962021, 0.006958505604416132, -0.0231844000518322, 0.035410765558481216, -0.020543644204735756, -0.04402846843004227, -0.03320503234863281, 0.035723745822906494, 0.028979232534766197, 0.07073356211185455, -0.018376300111413002, -0.039961762726306915, -0.0010901604546234012, 0.04495588317513466, -0.006663275882601738, -0.047140803188085556, 0.02922673523426056, 0.012402461841702461, -0.032972075045108795, 0.032543718814849854, 0.017526034265756607, -0.053161900490522385, -0.018033895641565323, -0.005373009946197271, -0.01274870801717043, -0.01290297694504261, -0.029937783256173134, 0.049753062427043915, -0.004295036196708679, 0.0016442619962617755, 0.047331999987363815, 0.029501590877771378, -0.010951584205031395, 0.006247906945645809, -0.04182165488600731, 0.02708459086716175, -0.042869359254837036, -0.019405782222747803, -0.06747017800807953, -0.028599504381418228, -0.02300902083516121, 0.038164716213941574, -0.004561164882034063, 0.03455951809883118, -0.0024474284145981073, -0.0442582331597805, 0.02477569505572319, 0.037392422556877136, 0.013236097991466522, 0.004535657353699207, -0.01821761019527912, -0.01088492851704359, -0.022823486477136612, -0.005904612131416798, -0.008389544673264027, 0.006944054272025824, -0.002446004655212164, 0.023908492177724838, -0.03700120374560356, -0.025846684351563454, -0.03072226420044899, 0.005144162569195032, -0.02805963158607483, 0.004516401793807745, 0.013198169879615307, 0.03459324687719345, 0.05280140042304993, 0.005059021525084972, -0.03385978937149048, 0.021100904792547226, 0.0491831973195076, -0.004958063829690218, 0.022351516410708427, -0.06673021614551544, 0.06355182826519012, -0.05364701896905899, 0.016019053757190704, -0.05460755527019501, -0.09059122204780579, -0.002964440267533064, -0.02170044183731079, -0.028446532785892487, -0.048251714557409286, 0.013642351143062115, -0.025011802092194557, -0.019143162295222282, -0.03661118447780609, 0.05153569206595421, -0.02289375476539135, 0.013159389607608318, 0.01966521330177784, 0.018000487238168716, 0.05052622780203819, 0.0014010126469656825, -0.012407442554831505, 0.010887510143220425, 0.016026178374886513, -0.013905451633036137, -0.020385943353176117, -0.024768581613898277, -0.011581378988921642, -0.005912907421588898, -0.028905998915433884, -0.0006578908651135862, 0.025138288736343384, -0.012820138595998287, -0.012092724442481995, -0.01828134059906006, -0.0025057645980268717, 0.019347989931702614, 0.012829183600842953, -0.006791559047996998, -0.005877508781850338, -0.007084792014211416, -0.012745514512062073, 0.006114429794251919, 0.004145996645092964, -0.03394032642245293, 0.0431370735168457, -0.005181967746466398, -0.020161038264632225, 0.04033176973462105, 0.05051237717270851, 0.03437827154994011, 0.018908558413386345, -0.002805606462061405, -0.031801093369722366, 0.0781218558549881, 0.02135101892054081, 0.017143238335847855, -0.01160429511219263, 0.003797705052420497, -0.02996833436191082, -0.024515928700566292, -0.024657391011714935, -0.019695132970809937, 0.04886433482170105, 0.004710231442004442, 0.02472269907593727, 0.04531845077872276, 0.013975369744002819, -0.01716797612607479, -0.04495988041162491, 0.022008342668414116, -0.023762235417962074, -0.003796237986534834, 0.06212115287780762, 0.03496711328625679, -0.001501934020780027, 0.024640733376145363, -0.0053276303224265575, 0.029552584514021873, 0.02204705774784088, -0.016587642952799797, 0.03748417645692825, 0.059052687138319016, -0.0016352408565580845, -0.06607636064291, 0.016128385439515114, -0.06488744914531708, -0.03076804243028164, -0.009554530493915081, -0.03642556816339493, 0.03108949027955532, 0.043783802539110184, 0.013185651041567326, -0.05969085544347763, -0.028619147837162018, -0.011860613711178303, -0.007031482178717852, 0.009881369769573212, -0.021310530602931976, 0.0432758629322052, 0.006190590560436249, 0.01610516756772995, 0.003008377505466342, 0.011164232157170773, -0.04523605480790138, -0.069544717669487, -0.0518416203558445, -0.05966022610664368, -0.005757444072514772, 0.022298766300082207, -0.034060124307870865, -0.03267568349838257, 0.027425063773989677, -0.02944178879261017, 0.01659601554274559, -0.03383364900946617, 0.044311605393886566, -0.003864587750285864, 0.05539294332265854, -0.009909247048199177, 0.002084889682009816, -0.007851426489651203, 0.008144441992044449, 0.10263089090585709, 0.05927103012800217, 0.03720397502183914, -0.06595297157764435, 0.00025148995337076485, -0.0089527303352952, -0.006512886844575405, -0.035234179347753525, -0.008646655827760696, 0.02609098330140114, -0.00826221238821745, 0.03810064494609833, 0.06464353203773499, 0.003908058628439903, 0.009543366730213165, 0.0754849910736084, -0.03604244440793991, 0.014586702920496464, 0.03621552512049675, 0.0221527349203825, -0.031447865068912506, -0.028921768069267273, -0.05766497924923897, 0.00717883137986064, 0.00847555324435234, -0.0018446054309606552, 0.00022140236978884786, -0.0269396360963583, 0.013768414035439491, -0.009334254078567028, -0.02013891004025936, 0.02662034146487713, 0.003104861592873931, -0.007181072607636452, -0.01113283820450306, 0.00966381561011076, 0.008817917667329311, -0.048894502222537994, 0.0061112972907722, 0.031566426157951355, 0.03205570578575134, -0.012815774418413639, 0.0008239815360866487, -0.0016687437891960144, -0.03760562837123871, -0.03178531676530838, -0.027413228526711464, 0.0613822340965271, -0.04123412445187569, -0.02012890949845314, -0.014344841241836548, 0.014624844305217266, 0.0009681352530606091, -0.023605242371559143, -0.01457095518708229, 0.022958960384130478, 0.01139356754720211, 0.014265008270740509, -0.0372636541724205, -0.01914263516664505, 0.006804275326430798, 0.02315169759094715, 0.026246342808008194, 0.00213316990993917, -0.024536626413464546, 0.008997734636068344, 0.029942739754915237, 0.06305339932441711, 0.01645682565867901, -0.012593897990882397, -0.026026267558336258, -0.01179096195846796, -0.02884168177843094, -0.010374996811151505, 0.039910584688186646, -0.0005928542814217508, 0.01688324846327305, -0.036820653825998306, 0.012248916551470757, -0.021213924512267113, -0.039994508028030396, 0.004724342841655016, -0.02363855019211769, 0.01094952691346407, -0.03042646497488022, -0.008433765731751919, -0.005392810329794884, 0.057086050510406494, 0.04026700556278229, -0.014723720960319042, 0.017649885267019272, 0.03177276998758316, 0.0023240111768245697, -0.03921307995915413, -0.05112214386463165, -0.03203583508729935, -0.022299781441688538, 0.003763416316360235, -0.015919122844934464, 0.08312860876321793, 0.0061773015186190605, 0.0025826517958194017, -0.04123840481042862, 0.02814142219722271, 0.016851281747221947, 0.03338892385363579, 0.05625513941049576, -0.07364150136709213, 0.0018683517118915915, 0.02425348572432995, 0.023677079007029533, -0.027556488290429115, -0.0035984546411782503, -0.0034400708973407745, -0.03517201915383339, -0.02018965221941471, -0.0389317125082016, -0.029330458492040634, -0.004511192906647921, -0.00699223717674613, 0.05024959519505501, -0.056569963693618774, -0.01785028912127018, -0.06001800298690796, 0.029457924887537956, -0.010682458057999611, -0.025257881730794907, 0.021666329354047775, 0.0051798694767057896, -0.020403074100613594, 0.02356264740228653, 0.033293042331933975, 0.025630934163928032, 0.0012019830755889416, -0.034496650099754333, 0.004588225390762091, -0.021343519911170006, 0.04445039853453636, -0.05382255092263222, -0.020219996571540833, 0.07016139477491379, -0.006379581987857819, -0.05419998988509178, 0.02580757811665535, 0.0314294695854187, 0.058273687958717346, 0.0062578520737588406, 0.007404669187963009, -0.04289659112691879, 0.04069838300347328, -0.009142044000327587, 0.00034546610550023615, 0.009064235724508762, -0.007748058997094631, -0.01645147055387497, -0.006750668864697218, -0.016164766624569893, -0.007143516559153795, -0.01864750124514103, 0.030408667400479317, 0.0351034514605999, 0.021701598539948463, -0.012170720845460892, 0.02649999037384987, 0.00613518338650465, 0.035976145416498184, -0.007446124218404293, 0.01553200464695692, 0.034683387726545334, 0.062017299234867096, -0.04872335121035576, 0.02706036902964115, 0.01402376126497984, 0.006501378957182169, -0.09242872893810272, -0.04707961529493332, -0.0016962895169854164, 0.02589389681816101, 0.030333399772644043, -0.0656714141368866, 0.011461440473794937, 0.043784089386463165, -0.04901072382926941, 0.009971457533538342, -0.0025684484280645847, -0.02177422307431698, -0.014949487522244453, 0.00417603924870491, -0.011842107400298119, 0.02380346693098545, 0.06093043088912964, 0.024485895410180092, 0.008120587095618248, 0.021609345450997353, 0.016259951516985893, 0.005271116271615028, -0.029751479625701904, -0.04433738440275192, -0.014712913893163204, -0.07538887858390808, 0.04634477198123932, -0.0033486168831586838, -0.025339527055621147, 0.025899410247802734, -0.04974854364991188, 0.0016655891668051481, 0.05551278963685036, 0.016833925619721413, 0.012794526293873787, 0.045892853289842606, 0.039662666618824005, -0.01109496969729662, 0.0073040020652115345, -0.007006082218140364, 0.020097248256206512, 0.03697199374437332, -0.009545293636620045, 0.02483700029551983, -0.009167724289000034, -0.014411206357181072, -0.016856778413057327, 0.034392550587654114, -0.020843597128987312, -0.01559603400528431, 0.021691378206014633, 0.015373014844954014, -0.01583060249686241, 0.014391697011888027, 0.009085669182240963, -0.04543023928999901, 0.007999460212886333, 0.021230239421129227, 0.03536301851272583, -0.02003326639533043, -0.004431866575032473, -0.04064278304576874, -0.0599784329533577, -0.0089510353282094, 0.010365192778408527, 0.038797903805971146, -0.06482716649770737, 0.006424069870263338, -0.010263651609420776, -0.035165511071681976, -0.008698278106749058, -0.04244536533951759, -0.04433726519346237, 0.08314048498868942, -0.03036363609135151, 0.0417119525372982, 0.03627709671854973, -0.035710450261831284, 0.013240921311080456, -0.08973227441310883, 0.04055491462349892, 0.012976150028407574, -0.006874463986605406, -0.012982930056750774, 0.026812052354216576, -0.05903191119432449, -0.0029097762890160084, 0.020098542794585228, -0.010990413837134838, 0.011203689500689507, 0.0023722241166979074, 0.009376764297485352, -0.014379087835550308, 0.003113147569820285, 0.046296291053295135, -0.012489577755331993, 0.00927851814776659, -0.0024106160271912813, -0.037397097796201706, -0.004108537919819355, 0.005180586129426956, 0.03357834741473198, -0.002754726679995656, 0.018185511231422424, 0.0037707840092480183, -0.003620523028075695, 0.024247867986559868, -0.016487013548612595, 0.009412428364157677, 0.0350513719022274, -0.019957229495048523, 0.020802441984415054, 0.006096791476011276, -0.010675482451915741, -0.0593884252011776, 0.021173246204853058, -0.0025536243338137865, -0.03220314532518387, -0.010421652346849442, 0.0002235153369838372, -0.021097542718052864, -0.03611597791314125, 0.007880042307078838, 0.03973390907049179, -0.02237502485513687, 0.024411343038082123, 0.03279632702469826, 0.06041079759597778, 0.03049957938492298, -0.010704736225306988, 0.00371425854973495, 0.016972867771983147, 0.0008268851088359952, 0.021248504519462585, 0.013957825489342213, 0.02506839856505394, 0.030728233978152275, -0.013346582651138306, 0.021583514288067818, -0.017937039956450462, 0.02998039685189724, -0.016940539702773094, 0.06120869889855385, -0.036318302154541016, -0.015568659640848637, 0.0005828164285048842, -0.010698995552957058, 0.052155785262584686, -0.012490397319197655, 0.0041104950942099094, 0.03498808294534683, -0.04721961170434952, 0.0010084479581564665, -0.03004322201013565, 0.020116856321692467, -0.015016661956906319, 0.03308591619133949, 0.024275628849864006, 0.07378360629081726, 0.018910080194473267, -0.021067699417471886, -0.03386219963431358, -0.01471786666661501, 0.02164584770798683, -0.012867157347500324, 0.012729143723845482, -0.045480743050575256, -0.018953373655676842, 0.0005249260575510561, -0.04669039696455002, -0.005398795939981937, -0.0454251691699028, -0.007177397143095732, 0.05018899217247963, 0.04354644939303398, -0.043952297419309616, -0.03164888545870781, -0.004986897110939026, 0.03906181827187538, -0.03833683207631111, -0.014344659633934498, -0.023355362936854362, 0.006387095432728529, -0.021126804873347282, -0.01697932370007038 ]
<p>Say we have $N$ time series $X_t^i$ for $i=1...N$and we want to predict a separate time series $Y_t$. Let's consider the following model: $Y_t = \sum_{i} \beta_i X_{t-1}^i $</p> <p>I am just trying to figure when such a model makes sense</p> <ul> <li>Does this model have a name? Is there an interpretation in terms of random processes? Are there any known applications?</li> <li>Does it make sense to solve the $\beta_i$ by using regression approaches (ridge, lasso, etc) using the training points $(&lt;x_{t-1}^1... x_{t-1}^N&gt;, y_t)$?</li> </ul>
74,494
[ -0.018856516107916832, -0.017638003453612328, 0.006738447118550539, -0.022771568968892097, 0.028681159019470215, 0.020466845482587814, -0.020684286952018738, -0.008477343246340752, 0.04567998647689819, -0.044617585837841034, 0.03841007128357887, 0.01992468163371086, 0.0420590341091156, -0.014200047589838505, 0.02631310187280178, 0.02212161011993885, -0.014910062775015831, -0.00008148913912009448, -0.03829251602292061, 0.0008108951151371002, 0.028143052011728287, 0.023525411263108253, 0.004669485613703728, -0.003948691766709089, -0.02565624937415123, 0.03406653553247452, 0.011499767191708088, 0.004366224631667137, -0.002768981968984008, 0.04111558198928833, -0.027047524228692055, 0.00042730895802378654, -0.024371366947889328, 0.06892387568950653, -0.0000688838554196991, -0.00966461468487978, 0.008280494250357151, -0.026213781908154488, 0.023115143179893494, 0.030369359999895096, 0.0043443236500024796, -0.051109135150909424, -0.0036955627147108316, 0.026983052492141724, -0.023458577692508698, 0.04687882959842682, -0.013993998989462852, -0.03555513173341751, 0.022738993167877197, -0.027513308450579643, 0.07173921167850494, -0.020092936232686043, 0.019409405067563057, 0.01974635012447834, 0.018931154161691666, 0.010584387928247452, 0.032135240733623505, 0.0489080548286438, -0.004370152018964291, -0.028655415400862694, 0.004578498657792807, 0.006311969831585884, 0.023806991055607796, 0.002952928189188242, -0.03794075921177864, 0.04187251627445221, -0.0003384114243090153, -0.00573855172842741, -0.0014511836925521493, -0.029596608132123947, 0.024355752393603325, 0.004873552825301886, 0.025524085387587547, 0.011000946164131165, -0.006396100856363773, -0.0053688096813857555, -0.007119984365999699, 0.03047340363264084, 0.05442827567458153, 0.005076357629150152, 0.04175301268696785, 0.013878374360501766, 0.03242423012852669, 0.011788384988904, 0.006743715610355139, -0.011959810741245747, 0.05644218996167183, -0.020488424226641655, 0.04275224357843399, 0.0420365035533905, -0.0032051934394985437, -0.004533969331532717, 0.0532272607088089, -0.013060087338089943, -0.03470383584499359, 0.04093959182500839, -0.010013852268457413, 0.0001727296330500394, 0.03128378465771675, 0.010201373137533665, 0.018000110983848572, -0.034898754209280014, -0.03188246488571167, 0.06509292125701904, -0.0494508258998394, -0.035559192299842834, -0.005094385705888271, -0.00754531379789114, 0.003860937897115946, -0.022040406242012978, -0.062682144343853, 0.014645489864051342, 0.007018891163170338, 0.014364023692905903, 0.02861127257347107, 0.03068123199045658, 0.004663367290049791, -0.004584337584674358, 0.03071606159210205, 0.08735406398773193, 0.02200319431722164, -0.043576374650001526, 0.041829802095890045, -0.022906579077243805, -0.03800638020038605, -0.001993968151509762, 0.0025215093046426773, -0.03486700356006622, -0.059155918657779694, 0.06183730810880661, -0.014810008928179741, -0.03058372065424919, 0.03913659602403641, 0.029593952000141144, 0.04038383439183235, 0.0227516982704401, -0.08914268761873245, -0.0511254258453846, 0.045682910829782486, -0.04951084032654762, 0.0010482041398063302, -0.01745784468948841, 0.03034834936261177, 0.037055157124996185, 0.06791041791439056, 0.00699147954583168, 0.03730878606438637, 0.025468826293945312, 0.02811916545033455, -0.013561252504587173, -0.022665688768029213, -0.03644361346960068, 0.01801450364291668, -0.05585614591836929, -0.001084514893591404, -0.0875706896185875, 0.02778867445886135, 0.03735148906707764, -0.024209998548030853, -0.01248270645737648, 0.03144348785281181, 0.027705425396561623, -0.010092529468238354, 0.0013929663691669703, 0.022275712341070175, -0.0326906181871891, 0.06319840997457504, 0.010395490564405918, 0.03849349915981293, 0.05030975118279457, -0.0012111883843317628, 0.02821308933198452, 0.03215730935335159, 0.06994004547595978, 0.01719791069626808, 0.026033572852611542, 0.004309377633035183, -0.011628738604485989, -0.009265045635402203, 0.02465326152741909, -0.06608131527900696, -0.03359215334057808, -0.012911682017147541, 0.03460350260138512, 0.026645012199878693, 0.06371251493692398, -0.015600623562932014, -0.02438582293689251, 0.01294361799955368, -0.033985719084739685, -0.025580592453479767, -0.03227269649505615, -0.012407904490828514, -0.06335946917533875, 0.003539763856679201, 0.03812434896826744, -0.00591287249699235, 0.04916854947805405, -0.031134149059653282, -0.01316938828676939, -0.03223496675491333, 0.01686830446124077, 0.03306702896952629, -0.03612492233514786, 0.0077750044874846935, 0.0432736799120903, -0.003841015975922346, 0.009570877999067307, 0.037040118128061295, -0.04368399456143379, -0.04826342314481735, -0.044721804559230804, -0.05435725674033165, 0.022698555141687393, -0.03984919190406799, 0.0037665681447833776, 0.011975474655628204, -0.029582124203443527, 0.002033786615356803, 0.018078086897730827, -0.08479855209589005, 0.04889872670173645, 0.04890288785099983, 0.006644588429480791, 0.007549935020506382, 0.007669033482670784, 0.035369157791137695, 0.013674373738467693, -0.03655347600579262, -0.028693929314613342, -0.03750759735703468, -0.005502282176166773, 0.01866421103477478, 0.0952129065990448, -0.023895924910902977, 0.008194221183657646, 0.06355679035186768, 0.035839807242155075, -0.017123166471719742, 0.037229686975479126, -0.025724977254867554, 0.029014114290475845, 0.001195024000480771, -0.02448253333568573, -0.0077759502455592155, -0.01749235764145851, -0.019163919612765312, -0.005532565526664257, 0.022293632850050926, -0.0186338871717453, -0.024398181587457657, 0.04552677273750305, 0.02146260254085064, 0.01602138578891754, -0.007033866364508867, -0.03198472037911415, 0.0240024346858263, -0.04234025999903679, 0.010675845667719841, 0.007445049937814474, 0.007715905085206032, 0.031486622989177704, 0.00014001579256728292, -0.007285346742719412, 0.028386659920215607, 0.04249468445777893, -0.017193684354424477, -0.024980494752526283, 0.03223887085914612, -0.051430124789476395, 0.028994712978601456, -0.019941935315728188, -0.030139489099383354, -0.0003075078420806676, 0.004736865870654583, 0.020815717056393623, 0.004301181063055992, 0.012465142644941807, -0.031343765556812286, -0.013089936226606369, 0.01221280638128519, -0.049004390835762024, 0.03177107870578766, -0.004121222533285618, -0.028769521042704582, -0.002318550134077668, -0.033350057899951935, 0.021916205063462257, 0.03977886214852333, 0.014617226086556911, -0.006416328717023134, 0.00544629106298089, -0.023645242676138878, -0.08848579972982407, -0.06572142988443375, -0.06450784206390381, 0.02245551347732544, -0.03470476344227791, -0.04813474789261818, 0.08709206432104111, -0.002830461598932743, -0.03405444696545601, 0.01565328799188137, -0.05275712162256241, 0.004623448941856623, -0.047841839492321014, 0.0057105110026896, 0.023371325805783272, -0.008295412175357342, 0.035004954785108566, 0.04635291546583176, -0.008553308434784412, 0.00023064039123710245, -0.06328289210796356, -0.054518070071935654, -0.0036650863476097584, -0.035799384117126465, 0.023217950016260147, 0.04632028937339783, -0.031386878341436386, 0.07184859365224838, 0.021952394396066666, -0.012843766249716282, -0.01567131280899048, 0.005361328832805157, -0.029527980834245682, -0.04285898432135582, 0.03730754554271698, 0.029781347140669823, -0.0048544383607804775, 0.005291513632982969, 0.013141017407178879, 0.021808551624417305, 0.06644751876592636, 0.017631610855460167, 0.007564061786979437, 0.009613600559532642, 0.0014874881599098444, 0.016562888398766518, 0.01571708917617798, 0.012045635841786861, -0.013739455491304398, -0.01462769228965044, -0.0069003626704216, 0.029904374852776527, 0.04011986777186394, -0.036940377205610275, 0.0187578983604908, 0.004619422368705273, 0.0032986162696033716, -0.004674387630075216, 0.049541838467121124, 0.0004649741458706558, -0.008595523424446583, -0.0693034678697586, 0.038045961409807205, 0.026627806946635246, 0.0003856618714053184, 0.030882924795150757, 0.03297818452119827, 0.031802911311388016, -0.020527100190520287, -0.012854306027293205, -0.025546984747052193, -0.024360325187444687, 0.010034034959971905, -0.01281652320176363, -0.017325932160019875, 0.0424376018345356, 0.021483009681105614, 0.00008940044790506363, -0.011534611694514751, -0.05078691244125366, -0.002086062915623188, -0.0660482794046402, 0.0003446510818321258, -0.017935097217559814, 0.06599484384059906, -0.003974264487624168, 0.031118769198656082, 0.013419841416180134, -0.01974363997578621, 0.065760038793087, 0.027195513248443604, -0.03182506188750267, 0.00989645067602396, 0.00422658259049058, 0.005276467651128769, -0.02347666770219803, 0.006890836171805859, 0.052784230560064316, -0.028010567650198936, 0.013111138716340065, 0.014524850994348526, 0.022614991292357445, -0.050335194915533066, -0.016194386407732964, -0.011800015345215797, -0.02879496105015278, -0.014926685020327568, 0.02655273862183094, 0.026185691356658936, -0.029441267251968384, 0.024769779294729233, 0.031920358538627625, 0.016577953472733498, -0.012547334656119347, -0.0199840497225523, -0.004618003498762846, 0.008678970858454704, 0.0021982856560498476, 0.022692427039146423, 0.021749937906861305, -0.023748744279146194, 0.042124971747398376, 0.001320489915087819, 0.028712842613458633, 0.053429942578077316, -0.016241081058979034, -0.010543816722929478, -0.03154397010803223, 0.003826989559456706, 0.046191226691007614, 0.004356801975518465, 0.058746278285980225, 0.00624868692830205, 0.052183397114276886, 0.022917937487363815, -0.05419977009296417, -0.010068698786199093, 0.03197408840060234, 0.029939137399196625, 0.007511218078434467, -0.024318670853972435, 0.014841512776911259, 0.006850219797343016, 0.04851961135864258, 0.015187020413577557, -0.0334024652838707, -0.012583356350660324, 0.001409383723512292, 0.0062514194287359715, 0.00021818387904204428, -0.02085120603442192, -0.002191372448578477, 0.030764533206820488, 0.05848612263798714, 0.017072005197405815, -0.07593507319688797, 0.032917093485593796, 0.03272887319326401, 0.04215557873249054, 0.04749408736824989, 0.013039412908256054, -0.09603632986545563, -0.02341630309820175, 0.030045660212635994, -0.006847337819635868, -0.0339784137904644, -0.02834014594554901, -0.03630288317799568, -0.002007614355534315, 0.058007173240184784, -0.013019377365708351, 0.03845219686627388, 0.006206966936588287, -0.01711484231054783, -0.015113750472664833, -0.027674896642565727, -0.0428280383348465, 0.008372168987989426, -0.016970250755548477, 0.06422776728868484, -0.022878188639879227, -0.01729874312877655, -0.036015965044498444, -0.03340321406722069, 0.010593036189675331, 0.050988733768463135, -0.01688985712826252, 0.0063124652951955795, -0.019346434623003006, 0.051656775176525116, 0.0012748449807986617, -0.04901846498250961, 0.01522066816687584, 0.040872469544410706, -0.028782997280359268, 0.0014591754879802465, -0.02406659722328186, -0.08080883324146271, 0.013795449398458004, 0.018673578277230263, -0.01651790365576744, -0.015257112681865692, -0.01967967487871647, 0.01199273020029068, 0.0398806631565094, 0.011304585263133049, 0.06685703992843628, 0.0608815960586071, 0.017187384888529778, 0.0001403740025125444, -0.004302368499338627, 0.006662630010396242, -0.013300887309014797, -0.023075971752405167, -0.03250493109226227, -0.018537886440753937, -0.02790726348757744, 0.04396011307835579, -0.002656489610671997, 0.04962891712784767, -0.012787772342562675, -0.004004346206784248, -0.016224289312958717, 0.04240487515926361, -0.006024551577866077, -0.04914034903049469, -0.008538209833204746, 0.03130672499537468, 0.02262168750166893, -0.008406750857830048, 0.009862191043794155, -0.02323330007493496, 0.02391650527715683, 0.036929644644260406, -0.005831644404679537, -0.011292618699371815, -0.007805803790688515, 0.002171624219045043, 0.024438416585326195, 0.005891956854611635, 0.03990481421351433, 0.002727248938754201, 0.041279155761003494, -0.0020801001228392124, -0.03364424407482147, -0.0045414697378873825, -0.01418071985244751, 0.02396448142826557, 0.02588224597275257, -0.03767640143632889, -0.017535099759697914, -0.026088407263159752, -0.017818279564380646, -0.04840211942791939, -0.042580489069223404, 0.05371181294322014, 0.006629164330661297, -0.016928426921367645, -0.032153476029634476, 0.030453741550445557, -0.03888845443725586, -0.03976300358772278, 0.00696493498980999, 0.0652996152639389, -0.010612607933580875, -0.028658198192715645, -0.0037425183691084385, 0.03145727515220642, 0.07491547614336014, 0.027789834886789322, -0.007134493440389633, 0.045522574335336685, -0.0021384540013968945, -0.02820955589413643, -0.026183150708675385, 0.04405180364847183, -0.04783595725893974, 0.03016962856054306, -0.043371591717004776, -0.019491013139486313, 0.028614498674869537, -0.02646109275519848, -0.008475369773805141, 0.031722307205200195, 0.025181440636515617, 0.011619003489613533, -0.06242343410849571, 0.004163818433880806, 0.02282497100532055, 0.00034204995608888566, 0.00048045514267869294, 0.0027691032737493515, 0.015393962152302265, -0.03483165428042412, 0.03580409288406372, -0.004835430067032576, -0.026885852217674255, 0.048199839890003204, 0.018216831609606743, -0.013875413686037064, -0.021966345608234406, -0.013127041980624199, -0.002760072471573949, 0.03574329987168312, 0.03662331402301788, 0.014050345867872238, 0.012965456582605839, 0.03892195597290993, -0.06662668287754059, -0.04052388295531273, -0.03881927207112312, 0.012797102332115173, 0.06617332994937897, -0.03258682042360306, 0.018594780936837196, 0.0391370989382267, -0.00246775196865201, 0.010575942695140839, -0.04398944601416588, 0.0007526504923589528, -0.038415443152189255, -0.014201832003891468, 0.036128003150224686, -0.012732273899018764, -0.035368114709854126, 0.01565147191286087, -0.0030750015284866095, -0.008811489678919315, 0.03732437640428543, 0.008500312454998493, 0.025334767997264862, -0.0010396107099950314, -0.022122083231806755, -0.06003095954656601, 0.030806919559836388, -0.0286862850189209, -0.0161979328840971, -0.027090299874544144, -0.009083445183932781, 0.029308628290891647, 0.06867954134941101, 0.016838153824210167, -0.07035679370164871, -0.0165577232837677, -0.04624030366539955, -0.0007508761482313275, 0.02506423555314541, -0.01866469904780388, 0.05724050849676132, 0.0056145754642784595, 0.012352612800896168, -0.0035118632949888706, 0.03127312287688255, -0.021658308804035187, -0.07943145185709, -0.016083108261227608, -0.022789161652326584, -0.059049077332019806, 0.02447495423257351, -0.011481638997793198, -0.05118349567055702, -0.020964043214917183, -0.037233952432870865, 0.004387858789414167, 0.010208647698163986, 0.033739957958459854, -0.0009999059839174151, 0.07483521848917007, 0.011606162413954735, 0.01511341705918312, -0.007898714393377304, 0.009025589562952518, 0.11623018980026245, 0.08241904526948929, 0.03258715569972992, -0.06646493822336197, -0.01638581044971943, 0.006949480157345533, -0.026249900460243225, -0.019061727449297905, 0.002409345470368862, 0.03198054060339928, 0.0009161923662759364, 0.028551649302244186, 0.0354212261736393, 0.007931072264909744, -0.02380514144897461, 0.043059807270765305, -0.05214177444577217, 0.009239011444151402, 0.014321799390017986, -0.03713511303067207, 0.007685332093387842, -0.014388811774551868, -0.04588118568062782, 0.01441306620836258, -0.011831856332719326, -0.03997742757201195, 0.028304098173975945, 0.010380938649177551, 0.008678913116455078, -0.00021369908063206822, -0.0056330738589167595, 0.021710094064474106, 0.016352206468582153, 0.01362388301640749, -0.0005806597182527184, 0.025307675823569298, -0.01707460731267929, -0.020646611228585243, 0.03124261647462845, 0.013209383003413677, -0.007573393173515797, -0.008119625970721245, 0.011443129740655422, -0.004106586333364248, -0.03884904459118843, -0.037324000149965286, -0.050885144621133804, 0.024738898500800133, -0.00431082583963871, -0.009770231321454048, -0.014291247352957726, 0.03615085780620575, 0.014968577772378922, -0.029551709070801735, -0.007243504282087088, 0.014862832613289356, 0.03941217064857483, -0.052984751760959625, -0.010529577732086182, -0.02612624317407608, -0.012268963269889355, -0.010310657322406769, 0.02671555057168007, 0.013593987561762333, -0.058961812406778336, -0.014418922364711761, -0.0031840819865465164, 0.04066479578614235, 0.014186220243573189, 0.02171030268073082, -0.011505410075187683, 0.011690882034599781, -0.0020612450316548347, -0.012620870023965836, 0.02341618575155735, -0.032000526785850525, 0.006890708114951849, -0.021128065884113312, -0.04550458863377571, -0.026845278218388557, -0.02813546545803547, 0.024050787091255188, -0.02898876741528511, 0.0005287278909236193, -0.029151538386940956, -0.03207474946975708, 0.004491729196161032, 0.05925367400050163, 0.004748763050884008, -0.006921263411641121, -0.028664391487836838, 0.05975993350148201, 0.013887387700378895, -0.055154766887426376, -0.00742128724232316, -0.016019674018025398, -0.024429570883512497, -0.0012189410626888275, -0.021397005766630173, 0.07102414965629578, 0.042159516364336014, 0.018581513315439224, -0.03653595969080925, 0.044228099286556244, -0.01598714478313923, -0.0019527811091393232, -0.014997424557805061, -0.06592284142971039, 0.0513218455016613, 0.027603382244706154, 0.0032912821043282747, -0.031031515449285507, -0.011173971928656101, 0.01679127663373947, -0.012187863700091839, -0.007381238043308258, -0.01252239290624857, -0.05033298209309578, 0.013551757670938969, -0.019923875108361244, 0.034435972571372986, -0.016898425295948982, -0.009467012248933315, -0.011163168586790562, 0.01583239994943142, -0.011714011430740356, -0.03618607297539711, 0.003041463205590844, 0.01319447997957468, -0.027287093922495842, -0.011662248522043228, 0.02968805469572544, 0.00526427524164319, -0.004510457161813974, -0.030415605753660202, 0.005694137420505285, -0.034313641488552094, 0.026440652087330818, -0.011106424033641815, -0.04325886443257332, 0.03274105116724968, -0.04001563787460327, -0.05217061936855316, 0.031150218099355698, -0.004983371123671532, 0.045604001730680466, 0.009470866993069649, 0.033155445009469986, -0.027401475235819817, -0.004163213074207306, -0.009994907304644585, -0.014507381245493889, 0.0018877607071772218, 0.03164224699139595, 0.012044364586472511, -0.014922259375452995, 0.021707920357584953, 0.02748633362352848, -0.011470296420156956, -0.03282582387328148, 0.04154517129063606, -0.00968549307435751, -0.01440352387726307, 0.03683092072606087, -0.022360170260071754, 0.0234504546970129, -0.02165205217897892, -0.0004957233904860914, 0.0336323082447052, 0.03137635439634323, -0.025464534759521484, 0.017952078953385353, 0.0029447562992572784, -0.009835703298449516, -0.07940711081027985, -0.014802598394453526, 0.017058929428458214, -0.010550420731306076, 0.035222288221120834, -0.020613055676221848, 0.0059439376927912235, 0.03272608667612076, -0.03153577446937561, 0.03040025383234024, 0.030654417350888252, 0.01758890226483345, -0.02344272844493389, 0.022934935986995697, -0.036760542541742325, 0.03191401809453964, 0.06435924768447876, 0.025345895439386368, 0.027974611148238182, 0.058881133794784546, 0.0016906078672036529, -0.04458296298980713, -0.00488955108448863, 0.016337275505065918, 0.002266266383230686, -0.0542118139564991, 0.0330105684697628, -0.046182889491319656, -0.01979011483490467, 0.01649375818669796, -0.027456723153591156, 0.03139934688806534, 0.010840920731425285, 0.003956044092774391, 0.003225830150768161, 0.026249125599861145, 0.01531148236244917, -0.04573669284582138, -0.009754103608429432, 0.015439976938068867, 0.018697017803788185, -0.0013608729932457209, 0.007860171608626842, -0.010861041024327278, 0.012881533242762089, -0.0031783583108335733, -0.043251946568489075, -0.011602954007685184, 0.026493139564990997, -0.05108274146914482, 0.007048805709928274, -0.024460071697831154, -0.016485244035720825, -0.024432267993688583, 0.015215090475976467, -0.034267134964466095, -0.004764399025589228, 0.02568865194916725, 0.02436676435172558, -0.018837643787264824, -0.0202836524695158, -0.013684776611626148, -0.08393638581037521, 0.02143385447561741, 0.0005223703919909894, 0.0028579586651176214, -0.05938145890831947, -0.0198249239474535, 0.024415399879217148, -0.004469917621463537, -0.07138374447822571, 0.002118065720424056, 0.012581637129187584, 0.03027050383388996, 0.0020702886395156384, 0.007253029849380255, 0.04303782805800438, -0.03750119358301163, 0.011952616274356842, -0.06715776026248932, 0.10489846765995026, -0.021891118958592415, -0.006136762443929911, 0.001272345893085003, -0.019086303189396858, -0.02179761417210102, -0.014379976317286491, 0.07919716089963913, 0.013220444321632385, 0.04652649164199829, 0.02933754026889801, 0.03385539725422859, 0.010308917611837387, -0.02878890000283718, 0.019206656143069267, -0.016634337604045868, -0.0016189165180549026, -0.031309179961681366, -0.011244033463299274, 0.0045089819468557835, -0.005975611042231321, 0.016646521165966988, -0.006389053538441658, -0.013555302284657955, -0.015474573709070683, 0.01184050366282463, 0.01976197585463524, 0.03567325323820114, 0.005341971293091774, 0.03103901445865631, -0.01475771889090538, 0.017354795709252357, 0.021830176934599876, -0.0358784943819046, -0.07842528074979782, -0.029539842158555984, -0.054863061755895615, -0.049224309623241425, -0.018454095348715782, 0.01596229337155819, -0.03321504965424538, -0.0452943779528141, -0.01467644702643156, 0.017645813524723053, -0.02976212278008461, -0.010805835016071796, 0.04987696558237076, -0.006358906161040068, 0.05651818588376045, -0.012231973931193352, -0.007472275290638208, 0.03758518397808075, -0.003088372992351651, -0.003609149716794491, 0.0022145924158394337, 0.07595981657505035, -0.02175944857299328, 0.011299521662294865, -0.02213585004210472, 0.010643001645803452, 0.014823752455413342, -0.012762060388922691, 0.031106194481253624, -0.01721562258899212, -0.018465565517544746, 0.03648696839809418, -0.04521716758608818, -0.022015580907464027, 0.004778021946549416, -0.016268841922283173, 0.06173039972782135, -0.030858442187309265, -0.028330281376838684, -0.024617735296487808, 0.000228907898417674, 0.00003898067370755598, -0.0015411513159051538, -0.011496281251311302, 0.008884080685675144, 0.013400116004049778, 0.006371982861310244, 0.017805663868784904, 0.0074087148532271385, 0.02400745078921318, -0.03371008113026619, 0.01933455653488636, -0.0067524295300245285, -0.004198598675429821, -0.002496854169294238, -0.049878619611263275, -0.03545701876282692, -0.04932965710759163, 0.03647815063595772, 0.04306953027844429, 0.010930967517197132, -0.0022876320872455835, -0.022321296855807304, -0.02935585007071495, 0.044211529195308685, -0.08192794770002365, -0.011191603727638721, -0.03661054000258446, 0.03650357574224472, 0.007135261781513691, -0.03673754632472992 ]
<p>Let's say I am using a logistic model to predict whether it rains (yes or no) based on the high temperature and have collected data for the past 100 days. Let's say that it rains 30/100 days. Furthermore, let's say that 70/100 days the temperature is actually 50 degrees. So there were only 30/100 days where the temperature was not 50 degrees. </p> <p>So in terms of the response variable (rain - yes or no), there is enough variation to develop the model. However, in regard to the predictor (temperature), with so many days where the temperature is 50 degrees, how does a recurring variable "element" (50 degrees) impact the calculations of a logistic model?</p>
37,390
[ -0.029882382601499557, 0.004365392029285431, 0.010491164401173592, 0.026354439556598663, 0.053191233426332474, 0.018779786303639412, 0.0237620547413826, -0.012181275524199009, 0.050444770604372025, -0.0031505064107477665, 0.027519328519701958, 0.0262297410517931, 0.03435173258185387, -0.010126880370080471, 0.00898601021617651, -0.0011903500417247415, -0.006668472662568092, -0.015729017555713654, 0.02233671024441719, 0.007757144048810005, 0.010195650160312653, 0.011217189021408558, 0.02971666492521763, -0.021883631125092506, -0.004517768509685993, 0.04498734325170517, 0.04210766404867172, 0.012078478001058102, 0.03830854222178459, 0.027422994375228882, -0.020227866247296333, -0.03251136839389801, 0.02831869199872017, 0.08057712018489838, 0.04845985770225525, 0.01831144653260708, -0.030109405517578125, -0.004615366458892822, -0.03192505985498428, -0.0037923601921647787, -0.02810843288898468, -0.01583593711256981, 0.008190978318452835, 0.002741466276347637, -0.033854320645332336, 0.018730394542217255, -0.0011265152134001255, -0.03438595309853554, 0.06973308324813843, -0.02122572436928749, 0.06571854650974274, -0.0012476377887651324, 0.03497207909822464, 0.037267640233039856, -0.0027389160823076963, 0.016897058114409447, 0.07537433505058289, 0.0390733927488327, -0.025188907980918884, -0.04417992755770683, -0.019449077546596527, -0.011422669515013695, -0.003355477238073945, -0.013023247942328453, -0.01591889001429081, 0.012246444821357727, 0.03475286811590195, -0.034877803176641464, 0.050069525837898254, 0.020772699266672134, 0.010153654962778091, -0.009485727176070213, 0.042540621012449265, 0.04010937362909317, 0.019091201946139336, -0.03513503819704056, -0.004426474682986736, -0.004648174159228802, 0.027198700234293938, 0.023170126602053642, -0.02022155001759529, 0.0005930348415859044, -0.01689697802066803, 0.013896468095481396, 0.03736819326877594, -0.027447832748293877, 0.013306576758623123, -0.03688888996839523, 0.029268478974699974, 0.022697946056723595, -0.018603116273880005, 0.028849372640252113, 0.01801687479019165, 0.002828418044373393, -0.03988061472773552, 0.029238497838377953, 0.0004735367838293314, 0.0038541206158697605, 0.022170834243297577, 0.035401251167058945, 0.005210788454860449, -0.0373123474419117, 0.02534935064613819, 0.016573701053857803, -0.02288646064698696, -0.020017609000205994, -0.027862468734383583, -0.030551539734005928, -0.012569964863359928, -0.02427794598042965, -0.012188448570668697, -0.013199669308960438, -0.008349984884262085, 0.029323771595954895, 0.03661249577999115, -0.0009012137306854129, -0.022165557369589806, -0.033300139009952545, 0.0242548156529665, 0.035912010818719864, 0.02192513644695282, -0.009454911574721336, 0.04441550001502037, -0.04115115478634834, -0.044828593730926514, 0.014040329493582249, 0.0072668506763875484, -0.017856430262327194, -0.025404229760169983, 0.0374198742210865, 0.01229814998805523, -0.009214031510055065, 0.0281682051718235, -0.0022006698418408632, 0.004778583999723196, 0.0174392219632864, -0.07964120805263519, -0.02800222858786583, -0.004977196920663118, -0.012151538394391537, -0.017014339566230774, -0.08118930459022522, 0.008752943947911263, 0.03085748292505741, 0.04205608740448952, 0.0157399270683527, 0.03662925213575363, 0.02356371283531189, 0.00922983605414629, 0.04519312456250191, -0.0228731706738472, 0.0005382011295296252, 0.002958717057481408, -0.03142719343304634, -0.0305064357817173, -0.07944870740175247, 0.01987251453101635, 0.038191597908735275, 0.008017584681510925, -0.009974083863198757, -0.012045520357787609, -0.014504123479127884, -0.00114045524969697, 0.0151981757953763, -0.010109375230967999, -0.013143833726644516, 0.08877895772457123, -0.029918629676103592, 0.036892686039209366, 0.027806155383586884, 0.015187746845185757, -0.0032586304005235434, 0.030750686302781105, 0.0687829777598381, 0.053388506174087524, -0.006707943044602871, 0.0075054471381008625, -0.042216673493385315, 0.0033237498719245195, 0.03116079792380333, -0.03926491364836693, -0.0003117658197879791, 0.021882036700844765, 0.01292084064334631, -0.007507581263780594, 0.007971099577844143, -0.02581225335597992, -0.0032899659126996994, 0.06296097487211227, -0.04250803962349892, -0.027589183300733566, -0.039963725954294205, 0.02739688940346241, -0.027683641761541367, -0.010494831949472427, 0.04102654010057449, 0.002715880051255226, 0.00812663696706295, 0.02552582137286663, -0.006362119689583778, -0.020609861239790916, -0.028141964226961136, 0.04146169126033783, -0.046192772686481476, 0.0009561910410411656, 0.01406616996973753, 0.03025117516517639, 0.011526376940310001, 0.03682529553771019, -0.07784581929445267, -0.07202102243900299, -0.002687077969312668, -0.012069830670952797, -0.012123051099479198, -0.0439610630273819, -0.06567621976137161, 0.010215881280601025, -0.012008230201900005, -0.04070376604795456, 0.04154374450445175, -0.07153811305761337, 0.04965312406420708, 0.07792596518993378, -0.013268450275063515, 0.0010077919578179717, 0.023868095129728317, -0.014852197840809822, 0.020855173468589783, -0.04203219711780548, -0.0176391638815403, -0.0593782514333725, -0.004140191711485386, 0.01278691180050373, 0.01033979281783104, -0.004283844958990812, 0.001759256119839847, 0.04207044467329979, 0.018001951277256012, 0.041437454521656036, 0.055673617869615555, 0.05185234174132347, 0.04511059820652008, 0.000329068599967286, -0.011481965892016888, 0.043763499706983566, 0.003031064523383975, 0.03102031536400318, -0.0005320475902408361, 0.007437105290591717, -0.002631447045132518, -0.00647951802238822, 0.06806915253400803, -0.0035078239161521196, 0.006243811920285225, -0.01573546789586544, 0.004234008491039276, 0.03276801109313965, -0.04808163270354271, -0.015799392014741898, 0.06916379183530807, 0.06331497430801392, 0.0007442451315000653, -0.020048825070261955, -0.02648458257317543, 0.018448609858751297, 0.05365149676799774, -0.043345626443624496, 0.0007765640621073544, 0.02296368218958378, -0.0028607710264623165, -0.004648428410291672, -0.026308836415410042, -0.011698245070874691, -0.04091370105743408, 0.0275463555008173, 0.04753836989402771, -0.0037506981752812862, 0.037035610526800156, 0.009087757207453251, -0.05880066007375717, 0.0036405015271157026, -0.011595514602959156, -0.020183691754937172, -0.011058468371629715, -0.048369087278842926, 0.012063379399478436, -0.0030268817208707333, -0.035073183476924896, 0.027060063555836678, -0.025311080738902092, -0.02104209177196026, 0.006794909480959177, -0.029518457129597664, -0.047123704105615616, 0.017246264964342117, -0.029254673048853874, 0.023685438558459282, -0.028406063094735146, -0.0413348488509655, 0.05391135439276695, 0.022348061203956604, -0.02569587156176567, -0.01775832660496235, -0.0639212504029274, -0.005151065532118082, -0.03474241495132446, -0.052514396607875824, 0.010741167701780796, 0.005648421589285135, -0.01070448849350214, 0.05274231731891632, -0.04271988570690155, 0.0051743704825639725, -0.08262652158737183, -0.09136371314525604, -0.041565027087926865, 0.005286756902933121, 0.03253768011927605, -0.01812814734876156, 0.018882689997553825, 0.053781475871801376, 0.033288344740867615, -0.037433937191963196, -0.0338156558573246, -0.02037958800792694, 0.0008897262159734964, -0.03970646113157272, 0.007169897668063641, -0.004379682242870331, 0.004855048377066851, 0.030624262988567352, 0.006039838772267103, 0.015222404152154922, 0.050736166536808014, 0.05678669735789299, -0.04056091234087944, 0.01069808192551136, 0.019631514325737953, -0.00164334150031209, 0.020124340429902077, 0.02076859027147293, -0.03892100602388382, 0.028180314227938652, -0.026493588462471962, 0.06996975839138031, 0.007845000363886356, -0.04036771506071091, -0.015210691839456558, -0.010332707315683365, 0.027634769678115845, -0.013641905039548874, 0.04144567251205444, -0.015298023819923401, -0.021389929577708244, -0.05264029651880264, 0.04428504407405853, 0.04468700662255287, -0.00551735982298851, -0.030672991648316383, 0.07659215480089188, 0.0726613700389862, -0.04235145077109337, 0.012629712000489235, 0.019822897389531136, 0.011793904937803745, 0.01975272223353386, -0.04024089500308037, -0.023610401898622513, 0.03032456338405609, -0.0245809443295002, 0.014912656508386135, -0.00965104904025793, -0.04839815944433212, 0.001422249828465283, -0.05980600789189339, -0.05497682839632034, -0.005455293692648411, 0.06800742447376251, -0.01144297607243061, 0.04412677884101868, -0.0038249639328569174, 0.0037901627365499735, 0.01748894713819027, 0.013895411044359207, -0.05224708467721939, 0.017520131543278694, -0.0004995525232516229, -0.029109690338373184, 0.01833932474255562, -0.036358967423439026, 0.040712591260671616, -0.049245089292526245, 0.00514773977920413, 0.03228049725294113, 0.008116384968161583, -0.017981136217713356, 0.001640069647692144, -0.016843829303979874, -0.028030946850776672, -0.04397648572921753, -0.016072161495685577, 0.038064777851104736, -0.014621402136981487, 0.05876825377345085, 0.046709783375263214, 0.01899632066488266, -0.020881591364741325, -0.01796448975801468, 0.00037421597517095506, 0.026780178770422935, 0.07525642961263657, 0.019695984199643135, 0.036057669669389725, -0.05141854286193848, 0.032706908881664276, 0.030392324551939964, 0.07042752951383591, 0.04268566891551018, 0.019666967913508415, -0.012866610661149025, -0.02718414179980755, -0.01443351898342371, 0.023176424205303192, 0.00892950501292944, 0.0040654633194208145, 0.018107125535607338, 0.058785129338502884, 0.011713564395904541, -0.03829420357942581, -0.03352832421660423, 0.023424068465828896, 0.016604725271463394, -0.01674552820622921, -0.0031871728133410215, 0.039295658469200134, -0.03231740742921829, 0.01993902027606964, 0.007936140522360802, 0.0032783031929284334, 0.006326478440314531, 0.004667697940021753, 0.02750282734632492, -0.0010578574147075415, -0.027983926236629486, -0.0032031326554715633, 0.03984358534216881, 0.03760208562016487, 0.010880878195166588, -0.04353443160653114, 0.01145152561366558, 0.04658393934369087, -0.01274564303457737, 0.018264776095747948, -0.008660015650093555, -0.08377784490585327, -0.010462531819939613, 0.023558946326375008, 0.024111712351441383, -0.06169404834508896, -0.023881280794739723, -0.026549581438302994, 0.001364541589282453, 0.03813951089978218, -0.01865524984896183, 0.01229336392134428, -0.009494437836110592, 0.030820179730653763, -0.002395991003140807, -0.05640879273414612, -0.03222540393471718, 0.03838560730218887, -0.05977991223335266, 0.03567889332771301, -0.00041871843859553337, -0.0393582284450531, -0.04534212127327919, 0.029212191700935364, 0.007657489739358425, 0.030684325844049454, -0.03754343464970589, -0.010910924524068832, 0.0092263612896204, 0.0019724827725440264, 0.039569348096847534, -0.06878043711185455, -0.01059756614267826, 0.0257346760481596, 0.014149226248264313, 0.022514045238494873, 0.006141898222267628, -0.030261894688010216, 0.015093499794602394, 0.060660600662231445, -0.016246994957327843, -0.017815174534916878, -0.050723545253276825, 0.017264576628804207, -0.0072983307763934135, -0.025819499045610428, 0.04992556571960449, -0.016159070655703545, 0.026678986847400665, -0.009236411191523075, -0.04014914110302925, 0.037218257784843445, -0.0092272087931633, -0.018836194649338722, -0.03974316641688347, -0.01689460501074791, -0.01754997856914997, 0.027290096506476402, 0.023901693522930145, 0.018367495387792587, -0.015886174514889717, -0.039677802473306656, -0.01869383454322815, 0.038447510451078415, -0.007124109659343958, -0.0064292969182133675, -0.02008223347365856, 0.026771314442157745, -0.023357516154646873, -0.024769239127635956, 0.026088876649737358, -0.03529009968042374, 0.009725085459649563, 0.03572864457964897, -0.0277414433658123, 0.005978986155241728, -0.03556496277451515, -0.03783493861556053, 0.03409375995397568, 0.008517610840499401, 0.005527963396161795, -0.03938483074307442, 0.009197110310196877, 0.017701884731650352, -0.05054403841495514, -0.003751888172701001, 0.0036188585218042135, -0.006370066665112972, -0.001582189230248332, -0.00812910869717598, 0.03551281988620758, -0.015936359763145447, 0.005055324640125036, -0.08224571496248245, -0.056949492543935776, 0.03877343237400055, -0.0018183444626629353, -0.059967294335365295, -0.010197953321039677, 0.001982394140213728, -0.052634306252002716, -0.024196358397603035, -0.012563069351017475, 0.058481987565755844, 0.0016236965311691165, -0.020633909851312637, -0.003011430846527219, 0.024910172447562218, 0.06721051782369614, -0.004367276094853878, -0.009528595954179764, -0.008085470646619797, -0.03938194364309311, -0.012691146694123745, -0.04032272472977638, 0.007783915381878614, -0.04777387157082558, -0.016741788014769554, -0.002649585483595729, -0.009843102656304836, 0.0358356349170208, 0.005309378262609243, -0.028985893353819847, 0.03412555903196335, -0.006862120237201452, 0.04832899197936058, -0.021550282835960388, 0.017954062670469284, 0.024053208529949188, 0.003205938497558236, -0.026740027591586113, -0.017707429826259613, -0.023693403229117393, -0.007625374011695385, 0.03180969879031181, 0.018291087821125984, 0.00981577392667532, 0.022933656349778175, 0.07244530320167542, -0.009316896088421345, -0.00859044585376978, -0.013504786416888237, -0.030363228172063828, 0.050771258771419525, 0.03267619013786316, -0.02714685909450054, 0.01704440452158451, 0.022472038865089417, -0.013313574716448784, -0.02010013349354267, -0.03948543593287468, 0.014376243576407433, 0.05251454561948776, -0.01136887539178133, 0.01356833428144455, 0.029235830530524254, -0.009774239733815193, 0.008854185231029987, -0.007928580045700073, -0.006403894629329443, -0.003820529207587242, -0.006711997557431459, 0.03708861395716667, 0.008562909439206123, -0.012369580566883087, 0.005157851614058018, 0.018436700105667114, 0.020724739879369736, 0.007691172882914543, -0.008951283991336823, 0.017844051122665405, 0.0205200407654047, -0.01868652179837227, -0.05380835384130478, -0.004068318288773298, -0.024675896391272545, 0.02346181869506836, -0.02022414095699787, -0.00716323172673583, 0.028413739055395126, 0.020644526928663254, -0.015037866309285164, -0.08049441128969193, -0.015808014199137688, -0.04011918231844902, 0.02198169007897377, 0.02309960313141346, 0.0048358384519815445, 0.01821262203156948, 0.03202612325549126, -0.006343289278447628, -0.0010373740224167705, -0.027162592858076096, -0.012687810696661472, -0.07740990817546844, -0.00321759469807148, -0.007918542250990868, -0.02094108611345291, 0.017857495695352554, 0.011973374523222446, -0.007897463627159595, -0.016509588807821274, -0.03885915130376816, 0.012399667873978615, 0.031916387379169464, 0.024337276816368103, 0.001124030677601695, 0.07199845463037491, 0.01577448658645153, -0.004239220172166824, -0.003927342593669891, 0.04906652122735977, 0.10662772506475449, 0.06007855758070946, -0.01221372839063406, -0.06999538838863373, 0.024143990129232407, 0.006632764358073473, -0.00528754573315382, -0.00421338714659214, 0.0069563016295433044, 0.02044324018061161, 0.01820535585284233, 0.06059453263878822, -0.011133454740047455, -0.018551528453826904, 0.011837596073746681, 0.06412016600370407, -0.04346860945224762, 0.022580407559871674, 0.04278546944260597, -0.009376460686326027, 0.009265650063753128, 0.029323486611247063, -0.012270665727555752, 0.010766273364424706, -0.00865345448255539, 0.010176603682339191, -0.005720837041735649, -0.047106560319662094, 0.009837477467954159, -0.003922412171959877, -0.011922510340809822, 0.013802943751215935, 0.027243763208389282, 0.0524836890399456, -0.00432637520134449, 0.01690761186182499, 0.030642235651612282, -0.04186472296714783, -0.009145855903625488, 0.049023013561964035, -0.012742437422275543, -0.012078620493412018, -0.028720926493406296, 0.01539307925850153, 0.012737667188048363, -0.05015433207154274, -0.07687649875879288, 0.02834743820130825, -0.007365154568105936, 0.02302997186779976, -0.0033153491094708443, 0.013435651548206806, 0.018916165456175804, -0.023526951670646667, -0.030490092933177948, 0.025700809434056282, 0.002221070695668459, -0.04448064789175987, -0.027952319011092186, -0.012191930785775185, 0.0373794361948967, -0.019203202798962593, 0.021510286256670952, 0.030371611937880516, -0.06589089334011078, -0.013230937533080578, -0.01467555109411478, 0.06848476827144623, 0.0034893874544650316, -0.013705849647521973, -0.012748407199978828, -0.02621074579656124, -0.035999540239572525, -0.009225361980497837, 0.014669930562376976, 0.024099431931972504, -0.007152603007853031, -0.04724453389644623, -0.03217783942818642, -0.02996746450662613, -0.007645405828952789, -0.0012781418627128005, 0.014454061165452003, -0.008230327628552914, -0.04369557276368141, 0.021256279200315475, -0.00384330190718174, 0.05842303857207298, 0.022539053112268448, -0.0111376428976655, -0.013556143268942833, 0.03414399176836014, -0.007871151901781559, -0.07821953296661377, -0.037571873515844345, 0.03255019709467888, -0.06176399067044258, 0.012310750782489777, 0.019036483019590378, 0.08163859695196152, 0.005590148735791445, 0.03538394719362259, -0.028195062652230263, 0.05802309885621071, -0.014310531318187714, 0.015788059681653976, 0.0590524896979332, -0.023865321651101112, 0.024110976606607437, 0.001787144923582673, -0.005787876434624195, -0.02745959348976612, -0.05694909021258354, -0.03223467245697975, -0.019278770312666893, 0.016407513990998268, -0.014287450350821018, -0.03668536990880966, -0.022891685366630554, -0.0033414007630199194, 0.05263498052954674, -0.012644318863749504, -0.009198037907481194, -0.06460274755954742, 0.004160583484917879, 0.02651566080749035, -0.045552484691143036, -0.0024785837158560753, 0.013082346878945827, -0.00555539270862937, -0.01735781691968441, 0.04120730608701706, 0.04936954006552696, 0.0647592693567276, -0.02828342281281948, 0.01130478922277689, 0.0063084801658988, 0.061354607343673706, -0.04585598036646843, -0.03151584044098854, 0.03439050540328026, -0.04670362547039986, 0.001540064113214612, 0.048416558653116226, -0.03398642688989639, 0.01977805234491825, 0.007352390792220831, 0.026841245591640472, 0.00866528507322073, 0.07725608348846436, 0.002924518194049597, 0.007618190720677376, -0.0033584055490791798, 0.007333835586905479, -0.0013681803829967976, -0.015461397357285023, 0.0014070116449147463, 0.011351469904184341, -0.03485690429806709, 0.0201592855155468, 0.07582371681928635, 0.012234711088240147, -0.017873765900731087, 0.010168102569878101, 0.00447496585547924, 0.003940899856388569, -0.016233963891863823, 0.013147757388651371, 0.025120239704847336, 0.04010467603802681, -0.032668597996234894, 0.020608676597476006, 0.000056556247727712616, 0.03716469556093216, -0.07345268875360489, -0.018440116196870804, 0.050407715141773224, -0.012769771739840508, 0.013792281039059162, -0.02173047512769699, -0.02260986529290676, 0.02751758135855198, -0.031176896765828133, 0.009236748330295086, 0.003987882751971483, -0.010021078400313854, -0.05055753514170647, 0.002964811632409692, -0.033961229026317596, -0.009636946022510529, 0.06060410290956497, -0.019111687317490578, 0.018680404871702194, 0.018933266401290894, 0.030974606052041054, -0.03570257127285004, -0.007298503071069717, 0.018179133534431458, -0.01475846953690052, -0.024741625413298607, 0.011095824651420116, -0.02854430302977562, -0.05695805326104164, 0.008538104593753815, -0.017723964527249336, 0.017104696482419968, 0.012965438887476921, 0.005503851920366287, 0.011026647873222828, 0.05949779227375984, 0.054595693945884705, -0.007427032571285963, -0.004449346102774143, -0.005346282385289669, 0.003034096211194992, 0.035983290523290634, 0.0022963513620197773, -0.0012303031980991364, 0.014012481085956097, -0.031331442296504974, -0.03862019628286362, 0.014985661953687668, 0.003009867388755083, -0.033223312348127365, 0.027553623542189598, 0.013077903538942337, -0.0001274886744795367, -0.026983465999364853, -0.009313431568443775, -0.06362296640872955, -0.0027437873650342226, 0.047428831458091736, 0.0064502437599003315, -0.035966046154499054, -0.0015019411221146584, -0.02826358564198017, -0.05522795394062996, -0.004060778301209211, 0.011948466300964355, -0.040069881826639175, -0.04747948423027992, 0.0061475797556340694, 0.01247505471110344, -0.013793691992759705, -0.03322159871459007, -0.012711750343441963, -0.03946002572774887, 0.02765243500471115, -0.01798587292432785, 0.04318087175488472, 0.012402686290442944, -0.024119030684232712, 0.02976696752011776, -0.07318850606679916, 0.09483473747968674, -0.008583014830946922, -0.010581579059362411, -0.06413096934556961, -0.025221750140190125, -0.06525944918394089, 0.022779863327741623, 0.05154627189040184, -0.0012690516887232661, 0.0014712321572005749, 0.003749629482626915, 0.05245330557227135, -0.007015009876340628, -0.010688276030123234, 0.04588698595762253, -0.00046167869004420936, -0.01869579590857029, -0.000518954242579639, -0.026710454374551773, -0.012225724756717682, -0.007508649490773678, 0.008104810491204262, -0.02449674718081951, 0.03441745042800903, -0.017706001177430153, -0.0027042091824114323, 0.014565393328666687, -0.007182546425610781, 0.02327789179980755, 0.02914765104651451, -0.0011596637777984142, 0.0053957379423081875, 0.0007286756881512702, 0.005831557791680098, -0.07699614763259888, 0.034846026450395584, -0.050079792737960815, -0.012021830305457115, 0.05412868410348892, 0.014293812215328217, 0.02459973841905594, -0.0547441691160202, 0.012494119815528393, 0.05435321107506752, 0.0020434935577213764, -0.0005695770378224552, 0.02774904854595661, -0.006382301449775696, 0.0071143489331007, -0.047959502786397934, 0.0009912459645420313, 0.018582822754979134, 0.00007923365774331614, -0.04072970524430275, 0.03285157307982445, -0.0019370070658624172, -0.0010873606661334634, 0.0044220066629350185, 0.013952640816569328, 0.01894316077232361, 0.026818176731467247, -0.0045080119743943214, 0.028272369876503944, -0.03168315067887306, -0.01774453930556774, 0.00038722503813914955, -0.03310348466038704, 0.02591349557042122, 0.04231240972876549, 0.004049122799187899, 0.03854930400848389, -0.015889538452029228, 0.011270575225353241, -0.04562072828412056, 0.02084651216864586, -0.007827996276319027, -0.012304810807108879, 0.04243855178356171, 0.03725481033325195, 0.00867062620818615, 0.0012519092997536063, 0.029556723311543465, -0.012983988039195538, -0.00032297958387061954, -0.018662309274077415, 0.0027986105997115374, -0.010102393105626106, 0.004039564169943333, -0.0172609630972147, -0.015178120695054531, -0.05382760241627693, -0.03168832138180733, 0.035708799958229065, 0.046238698065280914, 0.04216080158948898, 0.010416889563202858, -0.051895786076784134, -0.0007818868034519255, 0.02852441929280758, -0.05488630756735802, -0.016515830531716347, -0.030048837885260582, 0.03099086321890354, -0.013904239051043987, -0.0546359121799469 ]
<p>I am looking for a certain multivariate probability distribution function to fit to my data, but the usual multivariate normal distribution is unfit, since my data has a dent (antimode) instead of a peak in certain cases. (In other cases the data does have a peak.)</p> <p>My data consists of data points with multiple variables, which are all constrained to be within the interval [0,1].</p> <p>In the univariate case I would simply use the beta distribution, but the multivariate analogue, the Dirichlet distribution, seems unfit as well; it constrains the input variables to sum up to 1, instead of demanding all the input variables to lie within the interval [0,1]. Furthermore, it seems that the distribution doesn't depend on the covariance matrix - it seems to be unable to distinguish high covariance from low covariance given the same variances.</p> <p>What kind of distribution should I use?</p>
74,495
[ -0.0055437879636883736, 0.02860950119793415, 0.053968850523233414, -0.02534543350338936, 0.06752397865056992, -0.004346625879406929, 0.0027354920748621225, -0.011928725987672806, 0.022685930132865906, -0.048506949096918106, 0.04306807741522789, 0.025030717253684998, 0.04395454004406929, 0.047523707151412964, 0.028942681849002838, -0.021734779700636864, -0.02247975394129753, -0.03686140850186348, -0.04774073511362076, -0.0468226782977581, 0.004961965139955282, 0.02195967175066471, 0.004895173944532871, -0.025756696239113808, -0.02780061960220337, 0.0461667962372303, 0.030568286776542664, -0.003615648252889514, 0.012343759648501873, 0.05367888882756233, -0.08139877766370773, -0.03845018520951271, 0.0107908109202981, 0.036913786083459854, 0.01148049533367157, 0.008329823613166809, -0.021902240812778473, -0.05488569661974907, -0.024494173005223274, 0.041304368525743484, -0.02363596111536026, 0.006208681967109442, -0.0006597927422262728, 0.04135609790682793, -0.024668944999575615, 0.029304897412657738, 0.017915885895490646, -0.03596203774213791, 0.028032587841153145, -0.04224096238613129, 0.07821405678987503, 0.020946793258190155, 0.052147556096315384, 0.01002785749733448, -0.025990571826696396, -0.046146512031555176, 0.04921863600611687, 0.0979263037443161, 0.04507081210613251, -0.08364686369895935, -0.01620652712881565, -0.055601902306079865, 0.004808227531611919, -0.012006672099232674, 0.004898879677057266, 0.04954667016863823, 0.0015973600093275309, -0.022270122542977333, 0.029129859060049057, -0.010671964846551418, 0.03936860337853432, 0.02166113443672657, 0.018607210367918015, -0.035013534128665924, 0.005818275269120932, -0.005804693326354027, 0.045072585344314575, 0.0396915003657341, 0.04010690003633499, -0.005337166134268045, 0.06215908005833626, 0.019116543233394623, -0.008836262859404087, 0.008605966344475746, 0.018215544521808624, -0.007466054521501064, 0.09063941240310669, -0.036869339644908905, 0.002563012298196554, 0.014242958277463913, -0.06475900858640671, -0.0068726143799722195, 0.033744510263204575, 0.03937942907214165, -0.06567662209272385, 0.045971162617206573, -0.02680281363427639, 0.02264430932700634, -0.01856129989027977, -0.003915464971214533, -0.013841532170772552, -0.040753092616796494, 0.013802406378090382, 0.07310370355844498, 0.00969514437019825, 0.0345660038292408, -0.02966785989701748, -0.00589904747903347, -0.02296425960958004, -0.0008660499006509781, -0.025956422090530396, 0.03963226079940796, 0.020604515448212624, -0.016773860901594162, 0.01952030323445797, -0.0009448397904634476, -0.0009691240848042071, -0.029384847730398178, 0.048144154250621796, 0.06731054931879044, 0.02700059860944748, 0.0022402480244636536, 0.022810425609350204, -0.021718623116612434, -0.06965671479701996, 0.04103698208928108, 0.018465105444192886, -0.003552960930392146, -0.0514063686132431, 0.047857318073511124, -0.021057253703475, -0.0545634850859642, 0.05993156135082245, 0.0013324090978130698, 0.03855893760919571, -0.0006911613745614886, -0.07170230150222778, -0.03663831576704979, -0.02130749076604843, 0.002622816013172269, -0.0267668217420578, -0.041147373616695404, -0.004323560744524002, 0.03736637532711029, 0.06002216786146164, -0.017633652314543724, 0.05596113204956055, 0.02724098227918148, 0.051538337022066116, 0.015236926265060902, -0.030715161934494972, -0.009785971604287624, -0.020516254007816315, -0.034514766186475754, -0.007709911093115807, -0.0759941041469574, 0.02224365435540676, -0.01985851489007473, 0.003209071233868599, 0.006325045134872198, 0.012657499872148037, 0.019589627161622047, -0.0466233491897583, -0.007197489961981773, 0.027698196470737457, -0.04122388735413551, 0.05409182980656624, -0.017528429627418518, 0.04191157966852188, -0.0009714291663840413, -0.007892221212387085, -0.00025428086519241333, -0.017751619219779968, 0.05857811123132706, 0.03470967710018158, -0.015812329947948456, 0.010516062378883362, 0.005249474197626114, 0.03886057063937187, 0.02002749778330326, -0.05298277735710144, -0.03913387656211853, -0.00008318386971950531, 0.007687037345021963, -0.0005458177183754742, 0.035392601042985916, 0.027434075251221657, -0.03486957401037216, 0.050486546009778976, -0.05968158319592476, -0.03247442469000816, -0.032244354486465454, 0.003093310631811619, -0.013813885860145092, -0.00061513960827142, 0.024656442925333977, 0.00432067085057497, -0.034626442939043045, 0.011356281116604805, -0.003370788414031267, -0.013492659665644169, -0.026949770748615265, 0.037602927535772324, -0.04470261558890343, -0.021803276613354683, 0.03155393525958061, 0.0343870185315609, -0.012443252839148045, 0.061922501772642136, -0.008974038995802402, -0.0181872695684433, -0.04304584860801697, -0.07643382996320724, 0.043881479650735855, -0.013238596729934216, 0.0016371876699849963, 0.02518976852297783, 0.021103162318468094, -0.00916111096739769, -0.006196686532348394, -0.043172288686037064, 0.042469918727874756, 0.06687618792057037, -0.019509362056851387, -0.019034380093216896, 0.033911678940057755, 0.02708585560321808, 0.02053128182888031, -0.0331876166164875, -0.017768189311027527, -0.03971231356263161, 0.03101324290037155, 0.044340264052152634, -0.006230638828128576, -0.01218955684453249, 0.04380881413817406, 0.04817913472652435, 0.010105617344379425, -0.0065459576435387135, 0.032566800713539124, 0.016950519755482674, -0.03868402540683746, 0.031430549919605255, -0.033082444220781326, 0.0329403430223465, -0.034457504749298096, 0.0027365286368876696, -0.0028569672722369432, 0.02272077091038227, -0.018637755885720253, -0.00791406910866499, 0.016533726826310158, -0.020657435059547424, 0.022208062931895256, -0.020326213911175728, -0.008254929445683956, 0.02893805503845215, -0.018532060086727142, 0.030815212056040764, 0.016878541558980942, -0.017341013997793198, -0.0490926057100296, 0.01604665443301201, -0.032234326004981995, 0.03819208964705467, 0.05793674290180206, -0.005597819574177265, -0.0018642292125150561, 0.02258685790002346, -0.04259040951728821, 0.0011316759046167135, -0.033052150160074234, -0.03390442207455635, -0.023766038939356804, 0.006210025399923325, 0.038759201765060425, 0.01989763416349888, 0.017686177045106888, -0.025916360318660736, -0.0307613518089056, -0.0024501895532011986, -0.018421858549118042, 0.03639928251504898, 0.025630531832575798, -0.03459276631474495, -0.028403926640748978, -0.03981975093483925, -0.0002396799245616421, 0.04855288565158844, -0.001514068222604692, 0.011928532272577286, -0.0076238964684307575, -0.018903443589806557, -0.023748941719532013, -0.011668647639453411, -0.019060712307691574, -0.007743962109088898, -0.05151796340942383, -0.013343443162739277, 0.07404495775699615, 0.0220614243298769, -0.040763743221759796, 0.035065121948719025, -0.021780293434858322, -0.04700468108057976, -0.04995220527052879, 0.002723036101087928, 0.021348007023334503, 0.011225062422454357, 0.03661389276385307, 0.04996435344219208, -0.007086471654474735, 0.014602011069655418, -0.07320968806743622, -0.06841635704040527, 0.009660178795456886, 0.014684720896184444, 0.015080496668815613, 0.03074260801076889, -0.012998753227293491, 0.031410519033670425, 0.030077269300818443, -0.035323597490787506, -0.0453483909368515, 0.0022964144591242075, -0.016271278262138367, -0.029087383300065994, 0.04558528587222099, 0.018398797139525414, 0.022282876074314117, 0.0372152142226696, -0.013018662109971046, -0.007593100890517235, 0.03329690173268318, 0.01639971323311329, -0.018545979633927345, 0.04572419077157974, -0.0021122139878571033, -0.01044716127216816, 0.00891922041773796, 0.018708085641264915, -0.0015867731999605894, 0.022411664947867393, -0.009723491966724396, -0.006308417301625013, 0.027131689712405205, -0.021443959325551987, -0.005965916905552149, -0.033911775797605515, 0.0072346278466284275, -0.05941934883594513, 0.022293271496891975, 0.005946519318968058, -0.03683067485690117, -0.008217795751988888, 0.037736766040325165, 0.03454174846410751, -0.004961112514138222, 0.043623972684144974, 0.053735580295324326, 0.033493511378765106, -0.013664059340953827, -0.0004240567213855684, -0.0315430723130703, 0.02078891359269619, 0.0014638400170952082, -0.030484938994050026, -0.026159163564443588, 0.038859181106090546, 0.0030916433315724134, 0.006216366775333881, 0.014068995602428913, -0.054345373064279556, 0.012412039563059807, -0.06180282309651375, 0.024199670180678368, -0.062100157141685486, 0.038031063973903656, 0.032107315957546234, 0.04242253303527832, 0.04710518568754196, -0.012013966217637062, 0.025160333141684532, 0.0027849969919770956, -0.06615972518920898, 0.014119498431682587, -0.005211628973484039, -0.005194318015128374, -0.022694014012813568, -0.0018975053681060672, 0.000634102791082114, 0.0010572259780019522, 0.025574302300810814, 0.00035019032657146454, 0.021027371287345886, -0.029595153406262398, 0.018229063600301743, -0.05192820355296135, -0.03998177498579025, -0.0327320471405983, 0.001180890598334372, 0.013333604671061039, -0.023840291425585747, 0.03373612090945244, 0.010150574147701263, -0.009205525740981102, 0.0016412490513175726, -0.010490169748663902, -0.002674412913620472, 0.033520571887493134, 0.007571989670395851, -0.01176986750215292, 0.02464408427476883, -0.017565429210662842, 0.025395644828677177, -0.007427810225635767, 0.07116852700710297, 0.043663229793310165, -0.02303355000913143, -0.004329243674874306, -0.036160584539175034, -0.005204605404287577, 0.0066987741738557816, 0.019862106069922447, 0.013098184950649738, -0.018251076340675354, -0.004200601484626532, 0.01970508322119713, -0.0574246346950531, 0.0354144312441349, 0.09364139288663864, 0.019362138584256172, -0.023134907707571983, -0.02590775676071644, 0.004202370066195726, -0.010026018135249615, 0.014595680870115757, -0.01550217904150486, 0.014933389611542225, -0.029601402580738068, 0.025313466787338257, 0.022983890026807785, -0.015043918043375015, -0.030128035694360733, -0.019552381709218025, 0.026982169598340988, 0.04114735499024391, -0.02365446463227272, -0.06736963987350464, 0.014834888279438019, 0.031266190111637115, 0.04806571826338768, 0.06269001215696335, 0.023471707478165627, -0.08174649626016617, 0.026766639202833176, 0.06307540833950043, 0.027741434052586555, -0.006516539957374334, -0.016878431662917137, -0.04037952795624733, -0.0495784692466259, 0.058611877262592316, -0.022843755781650543, -0.01861817017197609, 0.01167565118521452, 0.022474557161331177, -0.002403493272140622, -0.009974954649806023, -0.037689194083213806, 0.024016480892896652, -0.012439174577593803, 0.020862936973571777, -0.03194437921047211, -0.01969384029507637, -0.050422873347997665, 0.0003246478154323995, 0.02547919563949108, 0.06688694655895233, 0.015634935349225998, -0.027353303506970406, -0.015079193748533726, 0.032560937106609344, -0.011725611984729767, -0.04588526114821434, -0.011120835319161415, 0.0024640599731355906, -0.02166205830872059, 0.03219575062394142, -0.02861456200480461, -0.019377795979380608, 0.026679612696170807, -0.030827874317765236, 0.009489965625107288, 0.020839380100369453, -0.010757201351225376, 0.035914767533540726, 0.012953716330230236, 0.029784144833683968, 0.03576826676726341, 0.02397644892334938, -0.007974275387823582, -0.0020605691242963076, -0.029353145509958267, -0.0015152513515204191, -0.0054734982550144196, -0.04855216294527054, -0.04739005118608475, -0.01059312280267477, -0.023578813299536705, -0.017797106876969337, -0.0022738808766007423, 0.03123559057712555, -0.008365136571228504, -0.018113616853952408, -0.028168607503175735, 0.02044970542192459, -0.021832525730133057, 0.013847410678863525, 0.0027936953119933605, 0.041157547384500504, 0.01882621832191944, -0.007897676900029182, 0.023504843935370445, 0.024893024936318398, 0.00757988914847374, 0.01412235852330923, -0.04480335861444473, -0.0010364002082496881, -0.047114141285419464, -0.011210432276129723, -0.007019419223070145, -0.03910382464528084, 0.03637903183698654, -0.018835576251149178, 0.05651876702904701, 0.014298881404101849, -0.02716875821352005, 0.00013938528718426824, 0.03837449848651886, -0.0055208089761435986, 0.06935872882604599, -0.03589322790503502, 0.03267497196793556, -0.049752216786146164, 0.002587619936093688, -0.05104302987456322, -0.05819444730877876, 0.0020695962011814117, 0.0009201614302583039, -0.01352685410529375, -0.04405082389712334, 0.0046962713822722435, -0.01349154207855463, -0.014307432807981968, 0.01000023540109396, 0.0334748849272728, -0.007127770688384771, 0.006590741220861673, 0.006188773550093174, 0.02062651328742504, 0.07657220214605331, -0.02708422765135765, 0.03318551555275917, 0.04242992028594017, -0.012767062522470951, -0.005899549461901188, -0.003769696457311511, 0.026080215349793434, -0.05038194730877876, 0.01212208904325962, -0.005909716710448265, 0.008375684730708599, 0.018411140888929367, -0.05605809763073921, -0.003626221790909767, 0.0007639381219632924, -0.003163648769259453, -0.010989337228238583, -0.04120803251862526, 0.009553490206599236, -0.01569199375808239, -0.029673218727111816, -0.02262997068464756, 0.007577736862003803, -0.04360851272940636, -0.02095101960003376, 0.01896798424422741, -0.0036645596846938133, -0.009681690484285355, 0.009561718441545963, 0.05360805243253708, 0.013875569216907024, 0.01983756572008133, -0.020187631249427795, -0.03481840714812279, 0.03518567234277725, -0.00778962904587388, -0.028350727632641792, 0.01471046544611454, 0.04859035462141037, -0.05080096796154976, -0.018375175073742867, -0.03185022249817848, -0.011065442115068436, 0.034372251480817795, 0.0064176698215305805, 0.016884058713912964, 0.03833286836743355, 0.017289958894252777, -0.03213203325867653, -0.029101163148880005, -0.027300048619508743, -0.011908283457159996, 0.010705518536269665, 0.03972531482577324, -0.004218550864607096, -0.009566538967192173, 0.03403577208518982, 0.014046721160411835, 0.007876693271100521, 0.058104123920202255, 0.01844310201704502, 0.03446301445364952, 0.007433072663843632, -0.011223149485886097, -0.03251790627837181, 0.04752519354224205, -0.04508335143327713, 0.01851469650864601, -0.024562591686844826, -0.02772154100239277, 0.04617767035961151, 0.03671415150165558, 0.013951200991868973, -0.028958512470126152, 0.015747133642435074, -0.03322022035717964, 0.009328113868832588, 0.03825054690241814, -0.002585548674687743, 0.019532425329089165, 0.0023724401835352182, 0.04562889784574509, 0.013034855015575886, 0.017715701833367348, -0.01934914104640484, -0.08838425576686859, -0.006025917828083038, -0.030249185860157013, -0.04757879301905632, 0.0048654465936124325, -0.011308068409562111, -0.04199211299419403, 0.015354291535913944, -0.029068313539028168, -0.0049846358597278595, -0.0022908435203135014, 0.03799953684210777, -0.016224591061472893, 0.04099613055586815, 0.0032104388810694218, -0.024594232439994812, 0.0126039432361722, -0.01981757953763008, 0.1273118257522583, 0.07497262954711914, 0.04831884428858757, -0.04138254374265671, -0.03459626063704491, -0.01686624065041542, -0.027620747685432434, -0.00901485700160265, 0.041338637471199036, -0.0029301526956260204, 0.00987977534532547, 0.06236398592591286, 0.03819120302796364, -0.008961568586528301, 0.012368621304631233, 0.055711906403303146, -0.008544374257326126, -0.025205537676811218, 0.0018256207695230842, 0.008952259086072445, -0.017400657758116722, -0.016344144940376282, -0.041903916746377945, 0.04436708614230156, -0.005500433035194874, -0.009976825676858425, -0.01175642292946577, -0.04650094360113144, 0.012020041234791279, 0.025741398334503174, -0.020174439996480942, 0.007389368023723364, 0.03433100879192352, 0.0171195175498724, -0.008587387390434742, -0.01050680223852396, 0.012337901629507542, -0.03036411851644516, -0.005778308492153883, 0.042151980102062225, 0.004031546879559755, -0.0069339401088654995, -0.011860067956149578, 0.008299270644783974, -0.025758013129234314, -0.07173840701580048, -0.03450190648436546, 0.02452162466943264, 0.015321600250899792, 0.007294788025319576, -0.00900369230657816, 0.02049543522298336, 0.009662497788667679, -0.03645101562142372, 0.03444327786564827, -0.016339780762791634, 0.04233796149492264, 0.01842266134917736, -0.018084419891238213, -0.008225849829614162, 0.035675935447216034, 0.012507625855505466, 0.03130372613668442, 0.011366220191121101, -0.03457672894001007, -0.006994781084358692, 0.0008635407430119812, 0.08975224196910858, 0.012735811062157154, 0.007243987638503313, 0.011118571273982525, -0.011086562648415565, -0.01024157740175724, -0.006641271058470011, 0.031109202653169632, -0.002351197646930814, 0.02359551191329956, 0.015231745317578316, 0.012803124263882637, -0.03523724153637886, -0.06249815598130226, 0.01613360270857811, -0.04194365069270134, -0.028498131781816483, -0.011116202920675278, -0.03385186567902565, 0.03514633700251579, 0.06637048721313477, 0.0062005906365811825, 0.008124048821628094, -0.03211768716573715, 0.03792915120720863, 0.02232491597533226, -0.04671458899974823, -0.017743542790412903, -0.021102553233504295, -0.013628356158733368, 0.00007711158104939386, -0.013204180635511875, 0.038655273616313934, 0.011393972672522068, 0.03450159355998039, -0.0310084018856287, 0.039256103336811066, -0.020152494311332703, -0.013726840727031231, 0.01233785878866911, -0.052206337451934814, -0.014091411605477333, -0.013229086063802242, -0.0024634639266878366, -0.02095361426472664, -0.009338248521089554, -0.016352761536836624, -0.013503809459507465, -0.009733513928949833, 0.013871366158127785, -0.02675299346446991, -0.02957463636994362, -0.00011195882689207792, -0.02807646058499813, -0.0246037058532238, 0.040298521518707275, -0.01042353454977274, 0.026359356939792633, -0.010703833773732185, 0.005994773469865322, -0.01015371736139059, 0.016537608578801155, -0.03304930031299591, 0.008332667872309685, 0.0036354365292936563, -0.0023959598038345575, 0.012123044580221176, 0.02028627321124077, 0.011473855003714561, 0.0038643802981823683, 0.0464460551738739, -0.027342088520526886, 0.015184776857495308, 0.022262731567025185, -0.027689306065440178, -0.04466142877936363, 0.00007707280747126788, 0.01617094874382019, 0.02651473879814148, 0.007880356162786484, 0.02077990025281906, -0.04880421236157417, 0.039542701095342636, -0.00007282708247657865, -0.013337255455553532, -0.0036556164268404245, 0.01252028439193964, 0.033502448350191116, 0.045100193470716476, 0.028243383392691612, 0.01256711408495903, -0.0013954121386632323, 0.03742711991071701, 0.01593334600329399, -0.0071447440423071384, 0.022083792835474014, 0.020206235349178314, -0.04759206622838974, 0.001858890289440751, 0.024246588349342346, -0.024163642898201942, 0.07292914390563965, 0.04237542673945427, -0.04449251666665077, 0.03243944048881531, -0.018664877861738205, 0.00986842717975378, -0.09883588552474976, -0.015428148210048676, 0.023563846945762634, -0.04704203084111214, 0.03489911928772926, -0.04895349591970444, -0.01553652435541153, 0.03774510696530342, -0.0655079334974289, 0.016920072957873344, 0.0021501544397324324, -0.025475317612290382, -0.035464271903038025, -0.007352876476943493, 0.0014508188469335437, 0.03188498318195343, 0.029962707310914993, 0.01724034920334816, 0.03904061019420624, 0.014255736954510212, -0.0241312887519598, -0.02636008895933628, -0.01921190693974495, 0.03795652091503143, -0.029698854312300682, -0.051005057990550995, -0.004956912249326706, -0.03055950626730919, -0.03820201754570007, 0.0307364109903574, -0.029288653284311295, 0.01828663982450962, 0.01007853727787733, 0.04524736851453781, 0.01326250471174717, 0.0731048434972763, 0.05111485719680786, -0.00968657061457634, 0.02836933545768261, 0.023720379918813705, 0.01731034740805626, 0.006729824002832174, -0.03748379275202751, 0.03857231140136719, -0.011121082119643688, -0.021055562421679497, -0.020433764904737473, 0.015680374577641487, 0.008299841545522213, -0.017733588814735413, -0.03549118712544441, 0.005476405378431082, 0.018832406029105186, -0.03874573856592178, 0.004826236516237259, -0.03362351655960083, -0.010479515418410301, 0.03804114833474159, -0.00272591901011765, -0.0119258351624012, 0.01986307092010975, -0.029524818062782288, -0.04775767773389816, -0.0038074273616075516, 0.03073952905833721, -0.00849086232483387, -0.04782281816005707, -0.033507004380226135, -0.007462780922651291, 0.02006632834672928, 0.0019723891746252775, -0.032881319522857666, -0.026321392506361008, 0.029467888176441193, -0.013459046371281147, 0.007523737382143736, 0.03958708420395851, -0.027088593691587448, 0.01220360491424799, -0.0753253698348999, 0.05621477589011192, -0.03686615452170372, -0.006111621391028166, -0.010483582504093647, -0.0017638741992413998, -0.01437342818826437, -0.003076489781960845, 0.05778026953339577, 0.02201967127621174, 0.029494907706975937, 0.0032487891148775816, 0.021295437589287758, -0.0018892016960307956, -0.06640465557575226, 0.0440998300909996, -0.024392833933234215, -0.042502254247665405, -0.031344007700681686, 0.01873195916414261, -0.006446860730648041, 0.01956101320683956, 0.028090931475162506, -0.04036395624279976, 0.011142943985760212, 0.01974664255976677, -0.04089927300810814, 0.005990264937281609, -0.004008435178548098, -0.03404422849416733, 0.0360424742102623, -0.015110194683074951, 0.005168597213923931, -0.0012042226735502481, -0.001222918275743723, -0.06262745708227158, 0.041284386068582535, -0.012109853327274323, -0.033920641988515854, -0.02597855031490326, 0.03149095177650452, -0.022477706894278526, -0.0839587077498436, 0.013974596746265888, 0.02463272400200367, -0.035206735134124756, -0.030062485486268997, 0.013142181560397148, 0.04121233522891998, 0.056392453610897064, -0.029579324647784233, 0.015461699105799198, 0.0017321208724752069, -0.013977236114442348, 0.0031984117813408375, 0.01171340886503458, 0.045944612473249435, -0.0085105886682868, 0.020408201962709427, 0.043978530913591385, -0.03481477499008179, 0.011640260927379131, -0.03977969288825989, 0.0326567180454731, -0.027623523026704788, 0.0030984366312623024, 0.03659573942422867, -0.023698672652244568, 0.04779787361621857, -0.006253519095480442, 0.0006912839016877115, 0.06706385314464569, -0.032054394483566284, -0.0008118479163385928, -0.060160208493471146, -0.04365551099181175, -0.040455352514982224, 0.0024545982014387846, -0.005914227105677128, 0.051021166145801544, 0.005587118212133646, 0.023550495505332947, 0.00009944367047864944, 0.00847925990819931, 0.040531694889068604, -0.020017731934785843, 0.020106658339500427, -0.0321788489818573, 0.008992417715489864, -0.02559014968574047, 0.011427441611886024, -0.06168869137763977, 0.0006932112155482173, 0.015274101868271828, 0.037507880479097366, 0.01112207118421793, -0.014197004027664661, -0.02000272460281849, 0.0010491906432434916, 0.01547019463032484, -0.05834462493658066, -0.019070584326982498, -0.038873475044965744, 0.009873725473880768, -0.012636442668735981, 0.04147978127002716 ]
<p>In my research I am working on some data (let’s call it sales data), however we almost have no information on the original sample. My goal is to come up with possible explanations on how it could be sampled by consistency arguments. </p> <p>In more detail, the data provided is composed of sales transactions and it has 2 columns (buyer and receiver). One of the most reasonable ways to sample would be (we believe) to assign a probability (p) to include each transaction or not, and then include a subset of transactions according to random realizations ( sampling without replacement). </p> <p>This corresponds to binomial sampling. Our information on the original sample is limited (almost none), except that I have an estimate on total number of buyers there may be on overall (circa ~2 million). In addition, we assume that buyers are the customers that belong to a network of original data provider, however sellers may belong to other networks, thus our attention is limited to buyers. </p> <p>The consistency argument is based on the following: on the original network if the buyer is highly active (there are more transactions) then the probability that that specific buyer gets included in a sample is higher than a less active customer. </p> <p>Then by counting how many transactions each buyer makes, and grouping them by common number of transactions – we get the number of buyers who make $i$ number of transactions. Then, based on our estimate on the total number of buyers in the network (2 M), my goal to estimate the sampling rate (p). </p> <p>R code:</p> <pre><code> set.seed(0); ##generate random sales transactions ss1= sample.int( 100, size = 100,replace = TRUE, prob = NULL) ss2= sample.int(10000, size = 100, replace = TRUE, prob = NULL) buyer= sort(ss1,decreasing=TRUE); receiver = sort(ss2,decreasing=TRUE); data= data.frame("buyer"= buyer, "receiver"= receiver); ##compute the number of sales - each buyer makes count= data.frame(table(buyer)); buyer.sales = count[order(count$Freq,decreasing=TRUE),]; df = data.frame(table(buyer.sales$Freq)); ##number of buyers who make 1 transaction, 2 transactions etc... ## We have a guess on total number of buyers - 2M. What would be the sampling rate(p)? </code></pre> <p>Here are the approaches I’ve tried so far: </p> <p><strong>Approach 1:</strong></p> <p>Pose Y_i the number of customers who make “i” calls in the sample (data), and similarly X_i the number of customers who make “i” calls in the original network. We know the Y’s and try to get X’s. </p> <p>Then if the transactions are sampled with a constant p rate, then </p> <p>$Y_i = sum_{k=i}^{k= max(i)} N_k * (choose(k,i))* p^k * (1-p)^{(n-k)}$;</p> <p>If we define the matrix A as follows:</p> <pre><code> A &lt;- function(i,j,prob) ifelse(i &gt; j, 0,(choose(j,i)*((1-prob)^(j-i))*(prob^(i))) ); </code></pre> <p>The problem would be solve A*x= b, which has an easy solution since A is upper triangular. But for my current problem, the x values that I get do not make any sense – they highly range between plus-minus infinity and ideally I would think that x vector should have some kind of correlation with y’s. </p> <p>I solved the linear system of equalities by minimizing L1, L2 norms and also with the positivity constraints as well. Still, not correlated results- and the sum of x_i’s are highly different than 2M. </p> <p><strong>Approach 2:</strong></p> <p>This approach is on subsampling from the sample (data). I thought I could subsample from the sample with a given p, then count the number of buyers I get in that subsample. The probability value –p, which has generates the following ratio ( the number of buyers original / the number of buyers in sample), equal to (the number of buyers in sample / the number of buyers in subsample) would be the most reasonable choice. </p> <p>This approach gave me p~0.02% but I don’t think this is correct. I think approach 1 makes more sense but the results do not suggest that.</p> <p>I should note as well, that the data on hand is composed of monthly transaction data for a period of 12 months. Thus the amount of data I take as the sample is important as well. I tried poisson rate estimation (<a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/2466/estimate-the-size-of-a-population-being-sampled-by-the-number-of-repeat-observat">Estimate the size of a population being sampled by the number of repeat observations</a>) but the amount of data I include, highly effects the estimate of total number of buyers – and I am really stuck. </p> <p>I would think that the original data would have some kind of a power law behavior, but that’s purely a guess without any justification. I am really stuck on which approach makes more sense. Any comments, ideas appreciated. </p>
37,392
[ -0.012547682039439678, -0.020501816645264626, 0.02205987274646759, -0.04122941568493843, 0.006720246747136116, -0.0024104982148855925, 0.010287540964782238, -0.011982251890003681, 0.010871522128582, 0.009665253572165966, 0.055327024310827255, 0.05246282368898392, -0.0009554036660119891, 0.015076186507940292, -0.010606723837554455, 0.040098562836647034, -0.02294127456843853, 0.013323366641998291, -0.004293059464544058, -0.004483462776988745, 0.0019654829520732164, 0.026623571291565895, 0.02299305982887745, -0.017280686646699905, -0.07436921447515488, 0.03936814144253731, 0.003603794379159808, -0.050185371190309525, -0.019317060708999634, 0.07161376625299454, -0.07944689691066742, -0.03432744741439819, 0.0016004065982997417, 0.03164832293987274, 0.04379807412624359, 0.02660534530878067, -0.022526586428284645, -0.03363485261797905, 0.0002933638170361519, 0.012445271015167236, -0.05935076251626015, 0.02517610974609852, 0.011482371017336845, 0.006430409383028746, -0.0010182627011090517, 0.010755649767816067, 0.030565137043595314, -0.036394596099853516, 0.016980495303869247, -0.01940632425248623, 0.06369785964488983, -0.008188244886696339, 0.026258140802383423, 0.008959723636507988, -0.03197617083787918, -0.0007939518545754254, 0.06425034999847412, 0.05090335011482239, -0.013946986757218838, -0.050612062215805054, -0.014487408101558685, -0.05362612009048462, -0.012094812467694283, -0.07138960063457489, -0.033447399735450745, 0.03021821565926075, 0.001656693872064352, -0.027225496247410774, 0.017785638570785522, -0.035052672028541565, 0.03700268268585205, -0.012099003419280052, 0.012754418887197971, -0.005912811029702425, 0.016146793961524963, -0.0020901833195239305, 0.0040870471857488155, -0.01793426088988781, 0.02751419134438038, 0.0067783198319375515, -0.0059848325327038765, -0.022924629971385002, 0.006321337539702654, 0.03303660452365875, 0.031225966289639473, -0.04073881730437279, 0.04789896681904793, -0.011680364608764648, 0.01711098849773407, -0.004882024601101875, -0.00583336828276515, -0.019350964576005936, 0.03798852488398552, -0.013141290284693241, -0.020428208634257317, -0.023724325001239777, -0.04597931727766991, 0.01502940896898508, -0.016995927318930626, 0.00993330404162407, -0.033883653581142426, -0.07717856019735336, -0.009346109814941883, 0.05632055923342705, -0.03877021744847298, -0.024860570207238197, -0.04300699010491371, -0.0384456031024456, -0.04053812474012375, -0.015997255221009254, -0.0015778526430949569, 0.007225346751511097, 0.007954639382660389, 0.04060077294707298, -0.006392363458871841, -0.001230258378200233, -0.011492114514112473, -0.005171196535229683, 0.05981624498963356, 0.05872912332415581, 0.03420117497444153, 0.018234219402074814, 0.02081817388534546, -0.015922682359814644, -0.022221365943551064, 0.022279705852270126, 0.012907711789011955, 0.0066393595188856125, -0.039438486099243164, 0.05471546947956085, 0.017559651285409927, -0.0024108148645609617, 0.059783823788166046, 0.0089510353282094, 0.012340146116912365, -0.012279677204787731, -0.08518937230110168, -0.05938994139432907, 0.04785378649830818, -0.04594133049249649, 0.04212005436420441, -0.05722812935709953, 0.023066507652401924, 0.030473286285996437, 0.06626028567552567, 0.028317784890532494, 0.057992491871118546, -0.014703824184834957, 0.0057575879618525505, 0.04723629355430603, -0.01560600008815527, -0.012868296355009079, -0.05806613713502884, 0.00733168376609683, -0.04604468122124672, -0.03169699013233185, 0.034472838044166565, 0.02904067002236843, -0.013078129850327969, -0.04365372657775879, -0.012882050126791, 0.026695014908909798, -0.007078040391206741, -0.01209314540028572, -0.004143835976719856, -0.022698145359754562, 0.05532345920801163, 0.029332304373383522, 0.03765399008989334, -0.00879606045782566, -0.05015949159860611, 0.048063039779663086, 0.010981055907905102, 0.034519705921411514, 0.06151226907968521, -0.013288282789289951, -0.011672254651784897, -0.00803685374557972, 0.009526608511805534, 0.024338407441973686, 0.016679881140589714, 0.005952151957899332, -0.020021025091409683, -0.0423215813934803, 0.02127891406416893, -0.01172432117164135, 0.003337196074426174, -0.02252943627536297, -0.0016369549557566643, -0.06153598800301552, -0.04767311364412308, -0.0741410106420517, -0.015644410625100136, -0.004616164602339268, -0.04496301710605621, -0.03449874371290207, -0.008787792176008224, 0.005444364622235298, 0.009031734429299831, 0.00030943326419219375, -0.04700004681944847, -0.010018957778811455, 0.04776427149772644, -0.030971599742770195, -0.027504481375217438, 0.03076540306210518, 0.04742569476366043, 0.0072134677320718765, 0.023966684937477112, -0.01878643035888672, -0.03108087182044983, 0.008266249671578407, -0.007364369463175535, -0.013156424276530743, 0.009246530011296272, -0.02089257910847664, 0.07347056269645691, 0.009034516289830208, -0.029344897717237473, 0.04350356385111809, -0.06877157092094421, 0.008082803338766098, 0.08242921531200409, 0.02418758161365986, 0.018564822152256966, 0.009601273573935032, 0.013827430084347725, -0.0022017420269548893, -0.02710597589612007, -0.02464902214705944, -0.07030166685581207, -0.017724933102726936, 0.02445843815803528, 0.047794703394174576, -0.02923383191227913, -0.024003971368074417, 0.0774122104048729, -0.009443948976695538, 0.005300143267959356, 0.01822943426668644, -0.013612329959869385, -0.050547484308481216, 0.002117717871442437, 0.0027903220616281033, 0.036907609552145004, -0.00018913036910817027, 0.006015477702021599, -0.00566553371027112, 0.06569484621286392, -0.008008472621440887, -0.0005801305524073541, -0.011368480511009693, 0.035596124827861786, 0.0068498644977808, -0.003289684420451522, 0.03468839079141617, 0.017876118421554565, 0.009369890205562115, 0.004188637714833021, 0.02099071815609932, -0.00021258534980006516, -0.012430967763066292, -0.014493176713585854, -0.05035454034805298, 0.01848764531314373, 0.04139942675828934, -0.03215525299310684, 0.013854622840881348, 0.012271568179130554, -0.0639829933643341, -0.0030933162197470665, -0.018626753240823746, -0.024946322664618492, -0.054877061396837234, 0.04942062124609947, 0.02212054282426834, 0.011282045394182205, 0.021940313279628754, -0.029568877071142197, -0.006315490696579218, 0.0006558049353770912, 0.022559065371751785, -0.006954523269087076, 0.007214506156742573, -0.06968775391578674, -0.022692257538437843, 0.0033939750865101814, -0.020647285506129265, -0.008304079063236713, 0.010449563153088093, 0.002092793583869934, 0.013933318667113781, 0.025294486433267593, -0.05455934256315231, 0.011805456131696701, -0.0031622385140508413, 0.012264021672308445, -0.050670377910137177, -0.021873172372579575, 0.014930704608559608, 0.04440576955676079, -0.049782346934080124, 0.021905889734625816, -0.07473348081111908, -0.0034591644071042538, -0.04364955797791481, -0.006207811180502176, -0.007552298251539469, -0.005469312891364098, -0.0009879088029265404, 0.0023485550191253424, 0.06193985044956207, -0.005066814832389355, -0.08118768036365509, -0.06593262404203415, -0.009563565254211426, -0.0025279109831899405, 0.05247136577963829, 0.03534068167209625, -0.0029062910471111536, 0.10232050716876984, 0.07112716883420944, -0.02250983566045761, -0.0034812153317034245, -0.006337094586342573, -0.03386422246694565, -0.009160815738141537, 0.055494487285614014, 0.04422096908092499, -0.0445820689201355, 0.029798058792948723, 0.02069798856973648, 0.010931090451776981, 0.035987403243780136, -0.029328079894185066, 0.005040076095610857, 0.02233407087624073, 0.009702702984213829, -0.0004196070658508688, 0.06407703459262848, -0.0035691328812390566, -0.045819059014320374, 0.01462422963231802, -0.013571207411587238, -0.0019735763780772686, -0.009155012667179108, -0.08292533457279205, -0.019565820693969727, -0.00600774772465229, 0.03217950090765953, -0.03923245146870613, 0.03480858728289604, 0.013143572025001049, -0.04305817559361458, 0.006891232915222645, 0.00944848544895649, 0.05394376441836357, -0.020940331742167473, -0.03677322715520859, 0.050745889544487, 0.003404587507247925, -0.07909815013408661, 0.028841601684689522, -0.014275701716542244, -0.005441991146653891, -0.02867913618683815, -0.037910096347332, -0.027119982987642288, -0.014342851005494595, 0.02612772025167942, 0.02897569350898266, 0.023777101188898087, -0.013769714161753654, -0.02404855377972126, -0.007469721604138613, 0.013654908165335655, -0.03417057543992996, 0.030780311673879623, -0.005201604682952166, 0.05075784772634506, -0.017155639827251434, -0.02162122167646885, -0.03170819580554962, -0.026136688888072968, -0.0425446480512619, 0.018377335742115974, 0.0011851424351334572, 0.0006473350222222507, -0.004301221575587988, -0.06152719259262085, 0.02552100270986557, -0.012508124113082886, 0.02894645370543003, -0.016733430325984955, 0.01154109463095665, -0.03635887801647186, 0.006823812145739794, 0.0192364901304245, 0.00983883161097765, 0.015443626791238785, 0.00569091085344553, 0.046559836715459824, -0.011390158906579018, 0.055119141936302185, 0.00394650362432003, 0.01211179606616497, -0.0002474859938956797, -0.01875709928572178, -0.01315162144601345, 0.012707562185823917, 0.040357623249292374, -0.013265067711472511, 0.0061284806579351425, -0.00914331991225481, 0.0014296286972239614, 0.004649527370929718, 0.038371630012989044, 0.07295054197311401, -0.018451740965247154, 0.014909244142472744, -0.004534923005849123, -0.026747487485408783, 0.010744287632405758, 0.017170926555991173, 0.008103868924081326, -0.03386443108320236, 0.07765210419893265, 0.045601047575473785, -0.02050497569143772, -0.010997160337865353, 0.04842255264520645, 0.029377469792962074, 0.041949816048145294, -0.03235466033220291, 0.02469494938850403, 0.036053530871868134, 0.014610071666538715, 0.032013993710279465, 0.018494848161935806, 0.007099148817360401, 0.003661972703412175, 0.013423063792288303, 0.020434094592928886, -0.05947929620742798, 0.007582169957458973, 0.005205824505537748, 0.04433590546250343, 0.001262763747945428, -0.03917936980724335, -0.02630963735282421, 0.04342265799641609, -0.005725090857595205, 0.03361502289772034, -0.0131726935505867, -0.06837578117847443, -0.0019764676690101624, 0.04549508914351463, 0.012475641444325447, -0.0316564105451107, 0.022793225944042206, -0.03839268907904625, -0.016506481915712357, -0.00892319343984127, -0.023151759058237076, 0.02668999880552292, -0.048324961215257645, 0.05537499859929085, -0.035999804735183716, -0.07770127058029175, -0.031114362180233, 0.0016378196887671947, -0.06004047393798828, 0.01524636521935463, -0.02824321947991848, -0.0399361327290535, -0.05220499262213707, 0.016002902761101723, 0.030065443366765976, 0.07954391092061996, -0.03802965208888054, -0.014467083849012852, 0.002383213257417083, 0.006443281192332506, -0.025876907631754875, -0.029810937121510506, 0.04580242931842804, -0.01549183577299118, 0.011314927600324154, 0.047615598887205124, 0.007463226094841957, 0.0035635139793157578, 0.017885273322463036, -0.003423033282160759, -0.01935645006597042, 0.006795384921133518, -0.040774039924144745, 0.041855841875076294, 0.05096923187375069, 0.009322892874479294, 0.03332788497209549, 0.025935029610991478, -0.0022290393244475126, 0.03594554215669632, -0.022433174774050713, -0.0074341269209980965, -0.025119800120592117, 0.0035112600307911634, -0.049118537455797195, -0.038155630230903625, -0.02034372091293335, 0.033642061054706573, 0.005541179794818163, 0.024449381977319717, -0.015021356754004955, 0.00869901105761528, 0.04788589105010033, 0.06511445343494415, -0.002623397158458829, 0.030646950006484985, -0.03645392507314682, 0.002111038425937295, -0.01731698401272297, -0.0027359630912542343, 0.05114932358264923, -0.03820956125855446, 0.00036485481541603804, 0.011526891030371189, -0.03184513747692108, 0.021936526522040367, -0.06885712593793869, -0.03134786710143089, 0.005190955474972725, -0.02769974060356617, 0.043141547590494156, 0.006098093930631876, 0.04939786344766617, -0.03251422196626663, -0.03145875409245491, -0.01394422072917223, 0.016690276563167572, -0.023500800132751465, -0.009733322076499462, -0.006048223935067654, 0.020303290337324142, 0.009202026762068272, -0.0013002646155655384, -0.06495043635368347, -0.011336824856698513, 0.005003505852073431, -0.014455071650445461, -0.038587797433137894, -0.04053269326686859, -0.019076574593782425, 0.00417213374748826, 0.00907407607883215, -0.018878217786550522, 0.023927444592118263, 0.008749383501708508, -0.016038717702031136, -0.019590014591813087, 0.015727613121271133, 0.07178190350532532, 0.005409193225204945, -0.026279808953404427, 0.04385581612586975, -0.019364947453141212, -0.028628524392843246, 0.011450883001089096, -0.019138531759381294, -0.033127639442682266, -0.03763420134782791, -0.04086781293153763, 0.0006166655803099275, 0.06901940703392029, -0.033696506172418594, -0.01902008056640625, -0.0012543651973828673, 0.011007196269929409, 0.007684050593525171, -0.01683419942855835, -0.011846702545881271, 0.000835262646432966, 0.01046822965145111, -0.004025882109999657, -0.005217172671109438, -0.0066663846373558044, -0.029545212164521217, 0.004253045190125704, -0.020078638568520546, -0.02430630847811699, 0.03766696900129318, 0.05419251322746277, 0.007030118256807327, -0.027089159935712814, -0.00368701689876616, -0.004692200571298599, 0.03126504644751549, -0.011281128972768784, 0.0009573042625561357, -0.006794419605284929, 0.03780417889356613, -0.017705773934721947, -0.01658332161605358, -0.031564753502607346, 0.03625992313027382, 0.05307785049080849, -0.006851774640381336, 0.04534237086772919, -0.0008614197140559554, -0.016744539141654968, 0.0028280862607061863, -0.03534288331866264, 0.01292893011122942, -0.022541124373674393, -0.00366827636025846, 0.028767768293619156, -0.01359496545046568, -0.020481497049331665, 0.050639379769563675, 0.030017884448170662, 0.04979967698454857, 0.038110315799713135, -0.023723432794213295, -0.0072492435574531555, 0.03190091624855995, -0.031120801344513893, -0.01423883717507124, 0.021618757396936417, -0.03550927713513374, 0.03955075889825821, -0.06581339240074158, -0.03128700703382492, 0.021498486399650574, 0.008711797185242176, -0.013302486389875412, -0.018241774290800095, -0.02601858414709568, -0.0773489773273468, -0.010844366624951363, 0.012781460769474506, -0.004984310828149319, 0.049588657915592194, -0.020611904561519623, 0.0021954693365842104, -0.020024504512548447, 0.04863293096423149, 0.03576216474175453, -0.04890964925289154, -0.03252357244491577, 0.0018351577455177903, -0.051996294409036636, 0.029805058613419533, -0.015464922413229942, -0.0028395000845193863, 0.0007801359170116484, -0.0012510092929005623, 0.039785824716091156, 0.03353207930922508, 0.0012792162597179413, -0.007269568275660276, 0.08931361138820648, 0.016010094434022903, 0.04600178077816963, -0.03405860811471939, -0.00431798305362463, 0.14309513568878174, 0.067105732858181, 0.05080477520823479, -0.01734999381005764, 0.008204770274460316, 0.049965038895606995, -0.0012384970905259252, -0.027449291199445724, 0.023707129061222076, 0.03017265535891056, 0.017057176679372787, 0.033231623470783234, 0.03097642958164215, -0.024985946714878082, 0.03366611897945404, 0.048692312091588974, -0.045668311417102814, -0.019632946699857712, 0.009823771193623543, 0.04951780289411545, -0.014150927774608135, -0.05040916055440903, -0.06440682709217072, 0.019286122173070908, 0.027265073731541634, -0.028103603050112724, -0.012464946135878563, 0.058600105345249176, -0.003891065251082182, -0.024016758427023888, 0.02601827308535576, 0.015672851353883743, 0.027122020721435547, -0.007630749139934778, 0.03495779260993004, -0.02468930184841156, 0.018448425456881523, -0.04545263200998306, 0.011882658116519451, 0.02119649015367031, 0.006920550484210253, -0.005563803017139435, -0.02227204665541649, 0.025721050798892975, -0.05151047930121422, -0.024801351130008698, -0.05186755955219269, 0.020344668999314308, -0.010854164138436317, -0.0023887623101472855, 0.0015994153218343854, -0.01028386689722538, 0.007115999236702919, -0.013298300094902515, -0.0008234858396463096, 0.037173815071582794, -0.0007566074491478503, 0.018599793314933777, -0.03902773559093475, -0.027600828558206558, 0.011940943077206612, 0.005179064814001322, 0.003972823731601238, 0.044363461434841156, -0.01901637390255928, -0.0401405468583107, -0.0141176488250494, 0.04465504363179207, -0.036705151200294495, 0.037295158952474594, -0.020369693636894226, -0.027253689244389534, -0.018958069384098053, -0.025798240676522255, 0.006845940835773945, -0.029047876596450806, 0.02453732304275036, -0.02390625700354576, 0.03808086737990379, 0.0015636937459930778, -0.006725967861711979, 0.013721393421292305, -0.00891428254544735, -0.008507822640240192, 0.01260681264102459, 0.00268431194126606, -0.008786322548985481, 0.03074396401643753, 0.04449966922402382, -0.001717858831398189, 0.0006687762797810137, 0.0652216374874115, -0.020878363400697708, -0.0035006552934646606, -0.015618490055203438, -0.03332836553454399, -0.04091169685125351, -0.01393142156302929, 0.00847061350941658, 0.05107302963733673, 0.005239283200353384, -0.008414126932621002, 0.024964673444628716, -0.007676746230572462, -0.01449640840291977, 0.02170104905962944, 0.04436333104968071, -0.06549377739429474, 0.019978506490588188, 0.0008722055936232209, -0.013723534531891346, -0.0023658128920942545, -0.006569898687303066, 0.012346307747066021, -0.012908883392810822, 0.001801281701773405, -0.018901508301496506, -0.04993312805891037, 0.009939680807292461, 0.01559608057141304, 0.03229553997516632, -0.0004994980990886688, -0.020969748497009277, -0.013775606639683247, -0.03501852974295616, -0.033683519810438156, 0.018739718943834305, -0.0013325735926628113, 0.00727683212608099, 0.020336363464593887, 0.0295503381639719, 0.009962073527276516, -0.0045373765751719475, 0.007565653882920742, -0.05273600295186043, 0.04105037823319435, -0.002174057299271226, -0.016769666224718094, -0.03405468538403511, -0.015381603501737118, 0.031741295009851456, -0.050778526812791824, 0.011404499411582947, 0.020716067403554916, -0.010848351754248142, 0.02459113858640194, -0.028615031391382217, -0.020524170249700546, -0.004406181164085865, 0.00789735745638609, -0.04840422049164772, -0.016272714361548424, -0.018647169694304466, 0.03511348366737366, 0.05353112518787384, -0.031209217384457588, 0.006729199085384607, 0.005365357268601656, -0.003138881642371416, -0.0006333139026537538, 0.05235613137483597, -0.002012802055105567, -0.045437365770339966, 0.004266856238245964, -0.012227452360093594, 0.04395172744989395, 0.01733681559562683, -0.010979237966239452, 0.022775467485189438, 0.03398985043168068, -0.038649480789899826, 0.024341963231563568, -0.019959326833486557, -0.00457755196839571, -0.10094238072633743, -0.04281015321612358, 0.04170753434300423, 0.016018474474549294, 0.03433673456311226, -0.027004070580005646, 0.019417209550738335, 0.02804320678114891, -0.030275315046310425, 0.03790834918618202, -0.0015326645225286484, 0.0324389785528183, -0.012160070240497589, 0.026545504108071327, -0.048474401235580444, 0.024287324398756027, 0.04870904982089996, 0.045035067945718765, 0.06925709545612335, 0.015568291768431664, 0.05020982027053833, -0.02218656986951828, -0.028537007048726082, 0.00982146430760622, 0.008202001452445984, -0.05629706010222435, 0.02257341518998146, -0.019656425341963768, -0.016474848613142967, 0.03622368350625038, 0.00780033553019166, -0.0017418526113033295, 0.00045407802099362016, 0.028220975771546364, -0.023951413109898567, 0.026171144098043442, 0.014213559217751026, 0.02486433833837509, 0.032760269939899445, -0.014770114794373512, 0.02409849502146244, 0.019770586863160133, 0.044194210320711136, -0.005654599983245134, 0.03224075585603714, -0.0060473475605249405, 0.016675937920808792, 0.014449586160480976, 0.009146956726908684, 0.004883714020252228, 0.012359870597720146, -0.0008139624260365963, -0.009533162228763103, -0.01861369051039219, 0.012267150916159153, -0.029087627306580544, 0.020420419052243233, 0.06539107859134674, 0.06313391029834747, -0.027676811441779137, 0.010579906404018402, -0.005157909356057644, -0.030868547037243843, 0.043552249670028687, -0.007456302642822266, -0.02379695139825344, -0.05662763863801956, -0.023221103474497795, -0.015180852264165878, 0.0075630019418895245, -0.0012418392580002546, -0.003423063550144434, -0.02710605040192604, 0.0553208626806736, -0.03249169886112213, 0.014510009437799454, 0.0010559367947280407, -0.016735060140490532, 0.01682901754975319, -0.09065571427345276, 0.055236127227544785, 0.015130387619137764, 0.007144263945519924, -0.02627260982990265, -0.018654434010386467, -0.026899920776486397, 0.029847774654626846, 0.0348365418612957, 0.03451814129948616, 0.004812912549823523, 0.006770228035748005, 0.005495506804436445, 0.04045996069908142, -0.04208837077021599, 0.02563922479748726, -0.043181002140045166, -0.008210612460970879, 0.004792527761310339, -0.025954172015190125, 0.022586587816476822, 0.016165902838110924, -0.018547549843788147, -0.003829122753813863, 0.024824101477861404, 0.026913831010460854, -0.0007951372535899282, 0.03102859854698181, -0.024292489513754845, 0.03694263473153114, 0.033295486122369766, 0.0066328831017017365, -0.011050823144614697, 0.011122317984700203, 0.013459756970405579, -0.07655225694179535, 0.059338249266147614, -0.05712790787220001, -0.0313861258327961, 0.01927870884537697, -0.004269033670425415, 0.008964047767221928, -0.05410225689411163, -0.02556774765253067, 0.015712495893239975, -0.015371229499578476, 0.03408094868063927, 0.01730530895292759, 0.01003445964306593, 0.011097388342022896, 0.015662746503949165, 0.02920842170715332, -0.036390140652656555, -0.027253903448581696, -0.010381840169429779, 0.016047587618231773, -0.015738502144813538, -0.028327060863375664, 0.006332534831017256, 0.06256642192602158, 0.02055339701473713, -0.01667867973446846, -0.03636360540986061, 0.03019670769572258, -0.03264695033431053, 0.017770450562238693, 0.00548007944598794, -0.017310503870248795, 0.024142514914274216, 0.03025098517537117, 0.013022175058722496, 0.04403151571750641, -0.017901206389069557, 0.03227816894650459, -0.02509589120745659, -0.040002964437007904, -0.009172685444355011, 0.036469779908657074, 0.0027284896932542324, 0.048061080276966095, -0.011981552466750145, 0.031080350279808044, 0.006918550468981266, 0.005380868911743164, 0.025523869320750237, 0.010042274370789528, 0.015701085329055786, 0.015522954985499382, -0.004263868555426598, -0.056995097547769547, -0.020032739266753197, 0.013798420317471027, -0.0183488130569458, 0.004256878048181534, 0.03127260506153107, 0.015361492522060871, -0.006454139482229948, -0.00019301276188343763, 0.030995268374681473, 0.03534400835633278, -0.020481474697589874, -0.01196728739887476, -0.07282209396362305, 0.012415570206940174, -0.010905659757554531, -0.03021181747317314 ]
<p>I want to understand how the sampling distribution of the whole covariance matrix behaves for large $n$. I am trying to use the delta method and multivariate CLT. I am trying to show that when the $X$'s are IID with nonzero finite fourth order moments then the operation (sample variance) takes place, as in this equation:</p> <p>$$\sqrt{n}(s_X^2 - \sigma^2) \underset{n\rightarrow \infty}{\overset{d}{\longrightarrow}} N(0, \mathbb{E}X_1^4 - (\mathbb{E}X_1^2)^2).$$</p> <p>(For simplicity I have assumed $\mathbb{E}X_i = 0$). Help is solicited in understanding the steps I need to take. I started with studying the asymptotic behavior of the sample variance and then went on to use the delta method for the following function $g(a,b) = b - a^2$.</p>
49,248
[ -0.0038312776014208794, -0.013449800200760365, 0.037472013384103775, -0.006792937871068716, 0.0513569638133049, 0.021285133436322212, -0.0014488383894786239, -0.036201685667037964, 0.0012826684396713972, -0.05899110436439514, 0.04032748192548752, 0.00745125999674201, 0.051395516842603683, 0.01269820611923933, 0.04037495329976082, -0.016442369669675827, -0.04175623878836632, -0.0025563810486346483, -0.0039556208066642284, -0.033960971981287, 0.007226651068776846, 0.04314476624131203, -0.0038936403580009937, -0.04987850785255432, -0.07025520503520966, -0.014272743836045265, -0.010803299024701118, -0.0033993979450315237, 0.0017394276801496744, 0.08821679651737213, -0.06577695161104202, -0.003085952950641513, 0.030806921422481537, 0.06689494103193283, -0.0025232392363250256, 0.013153518550097942, -0.04692919924855232, -0.06044737249612808, 0.032850231975317, 0.03465680032968521, -0.07108496129512787, -0.022454258054494858, 0.006156891584396362, 0.027867257595062256, 0.04281088337302208, 0.02560953050851822, -0.010492603294551373, -0.05435697361826897, 0.04378657788038254, -0.042478401213884354, 0.12263313680887222, 0.012600741349160671, 0.06067730486392975, 0.035078126937150955, -0.026611093431711197, -0.01214621588587761, 0.027893386781215668, 0.04701067879796028, 0.0044915382750332355, -0.03841845691204071, -0.0029058714862912893, -0.038704220205545425, 0.02838738262653351, -0.030671125277876854, -0.028530700132250786, -0.02247517742216587, 0.011870719492435455, -0.042586177587509155, 0.004850693047046661, -0.04064426198601723, 0.022273730486631393, 0.029427198693156242, 0.028398901224136353, -0.003353527747094631, 0.00356754451058805, 0.010714109987020493, 0.022620221599936485, 0.00032852153526619077, 0.0395924411714077, -0.002620968734845519, -0.004164405632764101, 0.03995528817176819, 0.006577662192285061, -0.004413203336298466, -0.001293706358410418, 0.005689481273293495, 0.04062880948185921, 0.00015795027138665318, 0.031414590775966644, 0.013642835430800915, -0.03026772104203701, 0.0033073057420551777, 0.0603981539607048, -0.03978565335273743, -0.07650697976350784, 0.04893961176276207, -0.011203833855688572, 0.03689824044704437, -0.003040896961465478, -0.007180048152804375, -0.02925155684351921, -0.05912821739912033, 0.02286749891936779, 0.060167279094457626, -0.00868296530097723, 0.011899623088538647, -0.008952999487519264, 0.03491495922207832, -0.00570253049954772, -0.04289335757493973, -0.020525874570012093, 0.016858084127306938, 0.020808683708310127, -0.012023556977510452, 0.030608415603637695, -0.02477950043976307, -0.0064895362593233585, -0.008723342791199684, -0.015508083626627922, 0.0406014621257782, 0.038207292556762695, -0.012085048481822014, 0.038638655096292496, -0.016512015834450722, -0.048924483358860016, 0.04438745975494385, 0.01976235955953598, -0.03831038996577263, -0.06389875710010529, 0.01374661736190319, 0.012196862138807774, -0.02592720463871956, 0.01448088325560093, 0.019600361585617065, 0.017673751339316368, -0.020716197788715363, -0.08956997841596603, -0.06536936014890671, 0.0600762739777565, -0.03516515716910362, 0.037577033042907715, -0.10056101530790329, 0.01459600031375885, 0.03359450399875641, 0.042274415493011475, -0.023680957034230232, 0.04267829656600952, 0.012544697150588036, 0.028686698526144028, 0.04819579795002937, -0.04682197421789169, 0.010960384272038937, -0.04286836087703705, -0.02023904398083687, -0.00849769078195095, -0.052676972001791, 0.016485165804624557, 0.02908032387495041, 0.00767516577616334, -0.03413155674934387, 0.023252416402101517, 0.012685887515544891, -0.006079619284719229, -0.01848442107439041, 0.04032665118575096, -0.01924441196024418, 0.07539200782775879, 0.01977323181927204, 0.046947214752435684, 0.01563543826341629, -0.008832551538944244, 0.02679469995200634, 0.0035318760201334953, 0.08031605184078217, 0.041738834232091904, -0.029072094708681107, 0.00022949064441490918, -0.00930522195994854, -0.010710230097174644, -0.004243212286382914, -0.032890383154153824, -0.0007034380687400699, 0.0035792721901088953, 0.014296265318989754, 0.024311412125825882, 0.055479004979133606, -0.007662112824618816, -0.010085542686283588, 0.01848440431058407, -0.06092251092195511, -0.0390898734331131, -0.06551406532526016, 0.004335467703640461, 0.02028198167681694, -0.04731066897511482, 0.009294837713241577, -0.012945118360221386, 0.021241672337055206, 0.019306605681777, -0.04135964438319206, -0.025979058817029, 0.0007295476971194148, 0.040235500782728195, -0.014150691218674183, 0.020205924287438393, 0.029322287067770958, 0.047336988151073456, 0.001007172279059887, 0.050414636731147766, -0.01198351290076971, -0.045310139656066895, 0.011837536469101906, -0.015985732898116112, 0.02771923504769802, -0.01819572038948536, -0.02493930794298649, 0.0022345746401697397, -0.02669428661465645, 0.01615177094936371, 0.04670121148228645, -0.02660198137164116, 0.05300630256533623, 0.06280045211315155, 0.02771899476647377, -0.018100954592227936, 0.028607413172721863, 0.04071059823036194, 0.008173641748726368, -0.01740534044802189, -0.017984308302402496, -0.0596572645008564, 0.013603026047348976, 0.0007817195728421211, 0.07821638882160187, -0.028349271044135094, -0.013999180868268013, 0.06217743456363678, 0.02499745413661003, 0.02827504090964794, 0.02320597507059574, 0.009072421118617058, -0.002792137674987316, -0.029376422986388206, -0.0012012070510536432, 0.02348220720887184, 0.01371066179126501, -0.026059336960315704, -0.004717262927442789, 0.054225675761699677, 0.011043580248951912, -0.01959470473229885, 0.014393624849617481, -0.014880018308758736, 0.01376243494451046, -0.023904401808977127, -0.026021171361207962, 0.03812146931886673, 0.032966192811727524, -0.037452660501003265, 0.045944131910800934, -0.006609256379306316, 0.013883929699659348, -0.011873395182192326, -0.03972936421632767, 0.09998782724142075, -0.005274264141917229, -0.0332588292658329, -0.026201268658041954, 0.017030885443091393, -0.010358327999711037, 0.01763651706278324, -0.028857490047812462, -0.029184143990278244, -0.032528746873140335, 0.04357827454805374, 0.002900107530876994, 0.005629860796034336, -0.0010278841946274042, 0.004692254588007927, -0.040993206202983856, -0.016295399516820908, 0.0013289820635691285, 0.03174000605940819, 0.01009177416563034, -0.040777746587991714, 0.00899499747902155, -0.027150427922606468, -0.010250703431665897, 0.03291583061218262, 0.0023067265283316374, 0.005334585905075073, 0.00020503254199866205, -0.006011823657900095, -0.010557412169873714, 0.006019896361976862, 0.01944093033671379, -0.030055999755859375, -0.019370781257748604, 0.002190561033785343, 0.024983327835798264, -0.015171132050454617, -0.01433425210416317, 0.04629494622349739, -0.03457016497850418, -0.04828611761331558, -0.052260056138038635, 0.010854189284145832, 0.0409153588116169, -0.01801357977092266, 0.07594197243452072, -0.03061370924115181, 0.009862031787633896, -0.006679339800029993, -0.043036531656980515, -0.05813831835985184, -0.012379810214042664, 0.011551073752343655, 0.002530499594286084, -0.010633851401507854, -0.021181905642151833, 0.07273785024881363, 0.019289111718535423, 0.011265263892710209, 0.0064970143139362335, -0.023936163634061813, -0.019540078938007355, -0.008219570852816105, 0.04281998798251152, -0.0007968849968165159, -0.025583874434232712, 0.05293688178062439, -0.01949959807097912, 0.005648304708302021, 0.04801535606384277, -0.019806379452347755, -0.012471849098801613, 0.011711404658854008, -0.013584072701632977, 0.015054061077535152, 0.03749778866767883, 0.000598963291849941, 0.009153129532933235, -0.004594089463353157, 0.041284576058387756, -0.005864486563950777, 0.01844887062907219, -0.020047292113304138, 0.01778872311115265, -0.027557535097002983, -0.002300434047356248, -0.0354289673268795, 0.047276947647333145, 0.03373606503009796, -0.04686678200960159, -0.005994032137095928, 0.021680761128664017, 0.03016534633934498, -0.003607895690947771, 0.008667536079883575, 0.0489836186170578, 0.010378309525549412, -0.0066531626507639885, -0.01605350896716118, -0.016047751531004906, -0.01271007303148508, 0.027509573847055435, -0.04631580039858818, -0.012566894292831421, 0.001657084678299725, 0.031955838203430176, -0.01728503778576851, -0.029717477038502693, -0.017133766785264015, 0.00016255647642537951, -0.019279643893241882, -0.0003650207363534719, -0.020663008093833923, 0.040739960968494415, -0.0163081344217062, 0.06457477062940598, 0.004248715937137604, 0.021685635671019554, 0.01564839296042919, 0.025612739846110344, -0.04373359680175781, 0.02399580180644989, -0.03340733051300049, -0.025610458105802536, -0.010021527297794819, 0.012802204117178917, 0.06992501765489578, 0.041905079036951065, 0.02803477644920349, -0.0185087900608778, 0.00589214451611042, -0.03664771094918251, 0.004258153960108757, -0.03495760262012482, -0.014726138673722744, -0.039248961955308914, 0.021007511764764786, 0.006332597695291042, -0.027596820145845413, 0.023366177454590797, 0.03729141503572464, -0.0319722443819046, 0.03478002920746803, -0.009586067870259285, -0.015213919803500175, 0.01476548332720995, 0.028489122167229652, 0.005674617365002632, 0.033003926277160645, -0.03269911929965019, -0.003291530068963766, 0.020654313266277313, 0.0769016444683075, 0.03346503898501396, -0.0018347998848184943, 0.02953137271106243, -0.035454753786325455, -0.014336193911731243, 0.016225231811404228, 0.022510014474391937, 0.0006408847402781248, 0.01801026239991188, 0.05235536769032478, 0.02226867713034153, -0.038128580898046494, 0.01308990828692913, 0.0635962188243866, 0.010805501602590084, -0.002255088882520795, 0.010452980175614357, 0.014077535830438137, -0.03160741552710533, 0.014182858169078827, 0.026679085567593575, 0.009465530514717102, -0.03466164693236351, -0.01119162980467081, 0.06837335228919983, 0.01135068479925394, -0.014275219291448593, -0.0063157216645777225, 0.036866866052150726, 0.04105764999985695, -0.00006597731407964602, -0.02020128443837166, 0.010178654454648495, 0.007450183853507042, 0.06742936372756958, 0.01909817010164261, 0.022835953161120415, -0.04893827065825462, -0.0031647717114537954, 0.024604104459285736, 0.030702287331223488, -0.004450121894478798, 0.031071411445736885, -0.05366380512714386, -0.03910272195935249, 0.020036382600665092, -0.049494389444589615, 0.029255051165819168, -0.031175464391708374, 0.015033971518278122, -0.05541355162858963, -0.012340240180492401, -0.028284190222620964, -0.02585378848016262, -0.03271098807454109, 0.04526734724640846, -0.010329787619411945, -0.04170117899775505, -0.039349306374788284, 0.0026362501084804535, 0.054077811539173126, 0.07546635717153549, -0.011378686875104904, -0.026606636121869087, -0.00956054124981165, 0.06577209383249283, -0.04890262335538864, -0.030143368989229202, 0.03618096187710762, 0.012682967819273472, -0.05008212849497795, 0.06213201582431793, -0.033819932490587234, -0.0648975819349289, 0.026347819715738297, -0.02569528855383396, 0.0020013563334941864, 0.006982437334954739, -0.010051487945020199, 0.03405909985303879, 0.008669689297676086, 0.01723340153694153, 0.06323312968015671, 0.013255898840725422, 0.006247344426810741, 0.023019900545477867, -0.009774553589522839, 0.025090880692005157, -0.02881360985338688, -0.015513950958848, -0.03781432285904884, -0.029681187123060226, -0.031222673133015633, 0.010515401139855385, -0.02213546261191368, 0.07181253284215927, -0.018789630383253098, -0.01084755826741457, 0.03703262656927109, 0.04617459326982498, 0.03104698844254017, 0.030255287885665894, -0.013423971831798553, 0.02908344939351082, 0.01960860751569271, -0.029942497611045837, 0.018855268135666847, 0.00030307137058116496, -0.02105218917131424, -0.006980789825320244, -0.03732292354106903, -0.009068403393030167, -0.02948758192360401, -0.0321299210190773, -0.035182513296604156, -0.034519296139478683, 0.025728240609169006, -0.0063933986239135265, 0.026214148849248886, 0.023938514292240143, -0.027766423299908638, -0.00024176946317311376, 0.03503689169883728, -0.02368868514895439, 0.027889302000403404, -0.046937186270952225, -0.01862276904284954, 0.024296322837471962, 0.0011001175735145807, -0.0922364592552185, -0.05342020466923714, -0.00032287021167576313, -0.013250081799924374, -0.023825012147426605, -0.02603699453175068, -0.022827178239822388, -0.017503513023257256, -0.024362070485949516, -0.05120643973350525, 0.03448984771966934, -0.00799172930419445, -0.003966027405112982, -0.0065293037332594395, 0.026214398443698883, 0.07189580798149109, -0.03358648717403412, -0.0067154220305383205, 0.023084763437509537, -0.04195524379611015, -0.02767929993569851, 0.012762774713337421, 0.0084109241142869, -0.013545512221753597, 0.022995227947831154, -0.009584959596395493, 0.008250612765550613, 0.009392289444804192, -0.011635727249085903, -0.027428271248936653, 0.016954410821199417, 0.015807747840881348, 0.028734542429447174, -0.013958839699625969, -0.06988412141799927, 0.0064096092246472836, 0.037135183811187744, -0.01734006591141224, -0.011693700216710567, 0.00698669021949172, -0.00858782883733511, 0.0188712440431118, 0.016842033714056015, 0.015451248735189438, 0.025707513093948364, 0.08259465545415878, 0.0018117702566087246, -0.004381816368550062, 0.009229502640664577, 0.010061768814921379, 0.021985063329339027, 0.05276894196867943, 0.006954442244023085, 0.005736267194151878, 0.004428367130458355, -0.005223417188972235, -0.057825133204460144, -0.016453158110380173, 0.03856901451945305, 0.06448229402303696, -0.009511738084256649, 0.01037354115396738, 0.04551196098327637, 0.019246511161327362, -0.027526916936039925, -0.041149500757455826, -0.010736806318163872, 0.0017643517348915339, -0.026899289339780807, 0.02485927939414978, -0.007044234778732061, -0.04039493948221207, 0.014938403852283955, -0.004132585600018501, 0.0042520565912127495, 0.020462676882743835, 0.022014042362570763, 0.005116669926792383, 0.0011415028711780906, 0.00931796059012413, -0.03393050283193588, 0.024159938097000122, -0.060875799506902695, 0.03550630807876587, -0.025087108835577965, -0.0016495621530339122, 0.020378222689032555, 0.033573947846889496, 0.010868093930184841, -0.03811437264084816, -0.050471898168325424, -0.04080667719244957, -0.01805991493165493, 0.020381534472107887, -0.020013362169265747, 0.02612924575805664, 0.01542973704636097, -0.012915635481476784, 0.013495455496013165, 0.032889656722545624, -0.05370039865374565, -0.05200762674212456, -0.037990596145391464, -0.0053937616758048534, -0.04510919377207756, 0.04403340071439743, -0.0025640479288995266, -0.035050734877586365, 0.00825091265141964, -0.045946769416332245, 0.05927625671029091, -0.008472517132759094, 0.013096543028950691, -0.02765609137713909, 0.07291646301746368, 0.03161592036485672, 0.03511112183332443, 0.031091146171092987, 0.022975075989961624, 0.07112357765436172, 0.05793345719575882, 0.003963400609791279, -0.05192016437649727, 0.010547742247581482, -0.03279367834329605, 0.014450626447796822, -0.048319485038518906, -0.01672772690653801, -0.009977922774851322, 0.006283099297434092, 0.024150488898158073, 0.03890286013484001, 0.011637733317911625, 0.003913490567356348, 0.043551381677389145, -0.03896165266633034, -0.04032912477850914, -0.01897674798965454, 0.00749827828258276, -0.03649308532476425, -0.01602928340435028, -0.05182073637843132, 0.023171646520495415, -0.018195902928709984, 0.011497740633785725, -0.04832053929567337, 0.0006316123763099313, -0.008807532489299774, -0.009870670735836029, -0.035709306597709656, 0.034494251012802124, 0.03319259360432625, -0.030496766790747643, -0.03158240020275116, 0.00014623104652855545, 0.007398619316518307, -0.0012830061605200171, 0.03415647894144058, 0.03183808550238609, -0.017077963799238205, 0.01276152953505516, 0.015927869826555252, 0.01942175254225731, -0.01177437324076891, -0.058864280581474304, -0.02333476021885872, 0.046181656420230865, -0.010967803187668324, -0.021252872422337532, -0.003680588211864233, -0.005402783397585154, 0.0029917277861386538, -0.04809833690524101, -0.004900130443274975, 0.017816804349422455, 0.0321883000433445, -0.058408431708812714, -0.04508058354258537, 0.010070767253637314, 0.019828349351882935, -0.008237426169216633, -0.003751553827896714, -0.01658840849995613, -0.026374025270342827, -0.01329330075532198, -0.015150662511587143, 0.004991901107132435, -0.0008260200847871602, -0.00891245435923338, -0.012919520027935505, -0.012223344296216965, -0.037782538682222366, -0.012968766503036022, 0.030249997973442078, -0.017144599929451942, 0.0476141981780529, -0.03365767374634743, -0.00742424326017499, -0.025928372517228127, -0.06713982671499252, -0.00478346599265933, -0.0416351743042469, -0.028867082670331, -0.0262621883302927, -0.02422553114593029, 0.03652167692780495, 0.031245512887835503, 0.0018094772240146995, -0.007015663664788008, 0.005614961963146925, 0.05531023442745209, 0.022057898342609406, -0.03545519337058067, -0.017181050032377243, -0.0035845183301717043, 0.007630199659615755, 0.0035278196446597576, -0.005028798244893551, 0.036656737327575684, 0.05819058418273926, 0.01601431891322136, 0.007752977777272463, 0.05148891359567642, -0.034276239573955536, 0.02452460490167141, 0.031325988471508026, -0.0486709289252758, 0.004719946067780256, 0.03900628164410591, -0.0027168174274265766, -0.012944499962031841, -0.0007872413261793554, -0.04952550679445267, -0.015628060325980186, -0.027817917987704277, 0.00564365740865469, -0.024411646649241447, -0.03166625648736954, -0.017768049612641335, 0.0007594353519380093, -0.02106238715350628, -0.012241222895681858, -0.005585653707385063, 0.04168875515460968, -0.01644304022192955, 0.010213000699877739, -0.03109622187912464, 0.012982127256691456, -0.008315985091030598, -0.030489221215248108, 0.021325163543224335, 0.01277121715247631, -0.008830111473798752, -0.013575193472206593, -0.028328746557235718, -0.007478845305740833, 0.029627995565533638, 0.006311511155217886, 0.01566680148243904, 0.06544994562864304, -0.06317702680826187, -0.03855186328291893, 0.03379115089774132, 0.02940363809466362, 0.013829275965690613, 0.021779948845505714, -0.016037937253713608, -0.04632255434989929, 0.03751898184418678, -0.06160122901201248, 0.025645770132541656, -0.025171717628836632, -0.006951967254281044, 0.003048874903470278, 0.0036255945451557636, 0.020480841398239136, -0.002136972500011325, 0.03413420915603638, 0.028347667306661606, 0.04571382701396942, -0.022675657644867897, 0.009186417795717716, 0.03148363530635834, -0.016982264816761017, 0.004064042121171951, 0.022875206544995308, 0.006617236882448196, 0.01231673639267683, 0.09515263140201569, -0.022576654329895973, 0.03410176560282707, -0.057617053389549255, 0.028207192197442055, -0.0634162425994873, -0.00002117149779223837, 0.0007638877723366022, -0.013118459843099117, 0.07598710805177689, -0.04590912163257599, -0.022683704271912575, 0.06755835562944412, -0.06743179261684418, 0.018363041803240776, -0.04131193459033966, -0.015123685821890831, -0.046802766621112823, -0.014476125128567219, -0.03228839486837387, 0.013885578140616417, 0.02456897310912609, 0.018931137397885323, 0.045320358127355576, 0.02908128686249256, 0.0061873882077634335, -0.015140442177653313, -0.002514955587685108, 0.021287523210048676, 0.018159713596105576, -0.05867917463183403, -0.002040571067482233, -0.016164705157279968, -0.028306586667895317, 0.04781576246023178, -0.008509771898388863, -0.03165566176176071, 0.002981242723762989, 0.049194686114788055, 0.003356791567057371, 0.048296790570020676, 0.02966681681573391, 0.01959952525794506, 0.04715517908334732, 0.00429150927811861, 0.02021535113453865, 0.021724890917539597, -0.0363638773560524, 0.025168584659695625, 0.03060207888484001, -0.03806864470243454, -0.01828422211110592, 0.013997824862599373, 0.006499829236418009, -0.018257802352309227, -0.017276447266340256, -0.0008179505239240825, -0.00638345954939723, -0.04343194514513016, 0.04055672883987427, -0.015217460691928864, -0.027181928977370262, 0.027440259233117104, 0.037492066621780396, 0.011176418513059616, 0.02006402052938938, -0.001926933415234089, -0.047979336231946945, 0.014462952502071857, 0.0262885931879282, -0.032033521682024, -0.05956587940454483, -0.056297894567251205, -0.007869372144341469, -0.008712965063750744, 0.007470585405826569, -0.014837830327451229, -0.048877786844968796, 0.03528375178575516, -0.03262892737984657, 0.0152242137119174, -0.033224429935216904, -0.02274279296398163, -0.011341984383761883, -0.100594162940979, 0.06667929142713547, -0.021153345704078674, -0.008335579186677933, -0.06466557830572128, 0.032178789377212524, -0.01710146851837635, 0.0024027214385569096, 0.01931396871805191, 0.0038640680722892284, 0.0228941161185503, 0.03631620109081268, 0.04255927354097366, 0.017890045419335365, -0.028231225907802582, 0.029367059469223022, -0.0032230957876890898, -0.008556985296308994, -0.03346136212348938, -0.029324959963560104, 0.017104096710681915, -0.004888222552835941, -0.03194791451096535, -0.009231752716004848, 0.017688270658254623, 0.03547511249780655, -0.03484085947275162, 0.024083035066723824, 0.002867296105250716, -0.000502735550981015, 0.06921383738517761, -0.020876087248325348, -0.0032343300990760326, 0.03707781806588173, -0.0035951032768934965, -0.019636765122413635, 0.0013010052498430014, -0.00672588124871254, 0.011319716461002827, -0.010699087753891945, 0.028566908091306686, 0.003407902317121625, -0.047304295003414154, -0.020201746374368668, 0.021790428087115288, -0.028030216693878174, 0.013670296408236027, 0.06567323207855225, 0.03357481211423874, 0.02288665436208248, -0.0073860748670995235, -0.030722375959157944, 0.013589358888566494, 0.01842554658651352, 0.012258022092282772, 0.013885646127164364, 0.00023046684509608895, -0.020451825112104416, 0.01654702238738537, 0.010979119688272476, -0.036570485681295395, 0.01587245613336563, -0.017451969906687737, 0.020313570275902748, -0.0434890054166317, -0.04465753585100174, 0.031846657395362854, -0.020940540358424187, 0.023155586794018745, 0.010161933489143848, -0.03862945735454559, 0.058916352689266205, -0.025247003883123398, 0.015720611438155174, 0.005079642403870821, -0.029961558058857918, 0.0037107369862496853, 0.01320298109203577, -0.005673807114362717, 0.011925806291401386, -0.02805292047560215, 0.024530498310923576, -0.000008697848898009397, -0.0026601748540997505, 0.021923542022705078, -0.029533520340919495, 0.03627333045005798, -0.018108727410435677, 0.0044182464480400085, -0.03258076310157776, -0.028496425598859787, -0.024401992559432983, -0.028613144531846046, 0.012733143754303455, 0.03690231218934059, 0.021360311657190323, -0.007602176163345575, -0.005119832698255777, 0.031949520111083984, 0.041483961045742035, -0.021418338641524315, 0.011062860488891602, 0.013565397821366787, 0.010819495655596256, -0.016242342069745064, 0.0027928308118134737 ]
<p>After fitting a coxmodel it is possible to make predictions and retrieve the relative risk of new data. What I don't understand is how the relative risk is computed for an individual and what is it relative to (i.e. the average of the population)? Any recommendations for resources to help understand (I not very advanced in survival analysis so the simpler the better)?</p>
74,496
[ 0.0015183492796495557, -0.04559354856610298, 0.02187269926071167, -0.05620840936899185, 0.015568955801427364, 0.0403205081820488, -0.0014177175471559167, -0.022986654192209244, 0.05798337608575821, -0.05008479952812195, 0.02155366539955139, 0.04526052623987198, 0.047821294516325, -0.021609842777252197, 0.0014882284449413419, 0.018284764140844345, -0.025604810565710068, -0.017155705019831657, -0.024606935679912567, -0.007769488263875246, 0.024359680712223053, 0.03396143764257431, 0.02523551881313324, -0.006531598977744579, -0.009702648967504501, 0.07131139934062958, 0.057044681161642075, -0.008224784396588802, 0.016126027330756187, 0.05390952527523041, -0.009937007911503315, -0.04531706124544144, -0.0009580806363373995, 0.02383945882320404, 0.02358800731599331, 0.025212235748767853, -0.01891731657087803, -0.018737222999334335, -0.01722838543355465, 0.0515136644244194, -0.036076195538043976, -0.053302980959415436, -0.019490718841552734, 0.05135113373398781, -0.02792675979435444, -0.003984827548265457, -0.014177112840116024, -0.023268025368452072, 0.03556720167398453, -0.028630675747990608, 0.05507761612534523, -0.030113857239484787, 0.042423561215400696, 0.03344140946865082, 0.000524484203197062, 0.018542034551501274, 0.04842233657836914, 0.06606582552194595, 0.009750043042004108, -0.05135736241936684, -0.04873792082071304, -0.01745612919330597, -0.015819106251001358, -0.016286375001072884, -0.02558545395731926, -0.01880401186645031, 0.00285517075099051, -0.0494515597820282, 0.0351802296936512, 0.011456678621470928, 0.011897868476808071, 0.04283978044986725, 0.039897143840789795, -0.007947131060063839, 0.019098646938800812, 0.0021922981832176447, -0.015121527947485447, 0.0021184084471315145, 0.040954723954200745, -0.009840589947998524, -0.005158489104360342, -0.010848592966794968, 0.018984060734510422, 0.07159778475761414, -0.030410509556531906, -0.010453354567289352, 0.06222664192318916, -0.008287275210022926, -0.0018922168528661132, 0.017005467787384987, 0.005166417453438044, 0.025530900806188583, 0.025974780321121216, -0.008954918943345547, -0.04615825414657593, 0.06582686305046082, -0.013220156542956829, 0.0170807596296072, 0.004849933087825775, 0.027940841391682625, -0.010316537693142891, -0.047329239547252655, -0.009349812753498554, 0.021760109812021255, -0.0008766044047661126, -0.0351516529917717, -0.03557556867599487, -0.0273416917771101, -0.009348802268505096, -0.021752478554844856, -0.0015528544317930937, 0.022028960287570953, -0.02747298963367939, -0.017237966880202293, -0.006801156792789698, 0.010270586237311363, 0.0034607243724167347, -0.03428366780281067, 0.07044558972120285, 0.05261881276965141, 0.031123634427785873, 0.0005229614325799048, 0.008599999360740185, -0.023151760920882225, -0.021954698488116264, 0.005332178436219692, 0.011344661004841328, -0.03183355554938316, -0.042963407933712006, 0.053984008729457855, 0.004526954144239426, -0.02963387966156006, 0.034557878971099854, -0.0018266355618834496, 0.03138858824968338, -0.02474791184067726, -0.07636846601963043, -0.04157361760735512, 0.034891869872808456, -0.004736436530947685, -0.030314266681671143, -0.04829484969377518, -0.00832767877727747, 0.0254671610891819, 0.015420496463775635, 0.024307889863848686, 0.035317312926054, 0.0030306316912174225, -0.0018795490032061934, 0.013813173398375511, -0.019289078190922737, -0.028846438974142075, -0.01846960186958313, 0.009073366411030293, -0.041129566729068756, -0.07717543095350266, -0.011073911562561989, -0.008198801428079605, -0.0015648235566914082, -0.022359881550073624, 0.05028117820620537, -0.015728505328297615, -0.0036015512887388468, -0.014767189510166645, -0.016400368884205818, -0.029178930446505547, 0.08744686096906662, -0.001120282569900155, 0.0009531588875688612, 0.022212736308574677, 0.0022699330002069473, 0.0054583679884672165, 0.02350621297955513, 0.06645765155553818, 0.0392269566655159, -0.00720379501581192, 0.0028716062661260366, -0.032887641340494156, 0.0131303109228611, 0.016517793759703636, -0.06394874304533005, -0.011880089528858662, -0.013867361471056938, -0.0002096540993079543, 0.03594762459397316, 0.00901731476187706, -0.016161272302269936, -0.04001231491565704, 0.039659302681684494, -0.028268937021493912, -0.05564166232943535, -0.05750477313995361, -0.027063200250267982, 0.01430211029946804, 0.0007336956914514303, 0.0015655673341825604, 0.03604501858353615, 0.024852639064192772, -0.01040820125490427, -0.0008967823814600706, -0.02652452513575554, -0.014713527634739876, 0.03106573224067688, -0.02208750881254673, 0.0033006223384290934, 0.04252897948026657, 0.052090417593717575, -0.004690561909228563, 0.04660433158278465, -0.0688026025891304, -0.06597726792097092, 0.007256245240569115, -0.05292467400431633, 0.040082309395074844, -0.0065940325148403645, -0.05200841277837753, -0.004135259427130222, -0.014479721896350384, 0.005343807395547628, 0.0013578786747530103, -0.01929977722465992, 0.0654190257191658, 0.06378805637359619, -0.01203440222889185, -0.022165223956108093, -0.006224372424185276, -0.0037056414876133204, -0.007438689470291138, -0.0095068933442235, -0.012300414964556694, -0.0177493654191494, -0.011584123596549034, 0.03678864240646362, -0.005429231561720371, -0.028585713356733322, 0.007830578833818436, 0.057180967181921005, 0.016522791236639023, 0.02943028323352337, 0.03612353652715683, 0.038076337426900864, -0.01752534881234169, 0.029920222237706184, 0.032828930765390396, -0.03033365309238434, -0.0344647616147995, -0.01695139892399311, -0.009675145149230957, 0.03114856220781803, 0.0011377499904483557, -0.0329485721886158, 0.06737729161977768, 0.010553563013672829, -0.010563700459897518, -0.018113525584340096, -0.041412852704524994, 0.03818034008145332, -0.04280571639537811, 0.029651964083313942, 0.02674919366836548, -0.01261307206004858, -0.02054133079946041, 0.004509698133915663, -0.014757195487618446, 0.026826506480574608, 0.04213748127222061, -0.07177036255598068, 0.02706277184188366, 0.0196453295648098, -0.01992967166006565, 0.015355557203292847, -0.02879033237695694, -0.0354926735162735, -0.018839647993445396, -0.023392822593450546, 0.05878834053874016, -0.00024587716325186193, 0.04416731745004654, 0.012473703362047672, -0.045849595218896866, 0.0203989427536726, -0.012708527967333794, 0.027208510786294937, 0.04277781397104263, -0.05864690989255905, 0.013979687355458736, -0.014580463990569115, -0.033243998885154724, 0.016134625300765038, -0.007466434501111507, -0.03392089530825615, 0.03621082007884979, -0.00984028447419405, -0.045515093952417374, -0.03036012127995491, 0.005048817954957485, -0.021802060306072235, -0.03269496560096741, -0.025518083944916725, 0.05536167696118355, 0.004872284363955259, -0.002146771876141429, 0.04279022663831711, -0.034371767193078995, -0.004082485102117062, 0.014054693281650543, 0.048161301761865616, 0.038792774081230164, 0.007710128556936979, 0.0262185949832201, 0.02875003032386303, -0.04918290302157402, -0.02511858381330967, -0.07045497000217438, -0.04741010069847107, 0.04720702022314072, -0.0011657866416499019, -0.001984531292691827, 0.028491484001278877, 0.00028278553509153426, 0.10178807377815247, -0.0052484734915196896, -0.021193131804466248, -0.045033812522888184, 0.04336099326610565, -0.014760658144950867, -0.02114006318151951, 0.01680952124297619, 0.011366422288119793, -0.008743721060454845, 0.03285922855138779, 0.0021741499658674, 0.04446060582995415, 0.052443891763687134, -0.0027000033296644688, 0.004541925620287657, 0.017373790964484215, 0.0076019251719117165, -0.0018395620863884687, 0.0234727393835783, 0.0053430539555847645, -0.014166830107569695, 0.018324613571166992, 0.018803788349032402, 0.030194777995347977, 0.01694655418395996, -0.04684118926525116, 0.008223576471209526, -0.023466115817427635, -0.022876814007759094, -0.0465683788061142, 0.02908339910209179, -0.03187895566225052, -0.03989150747656822, 0.0057150935754179955, 0.010032285004854202, 0.016255365684628487, -0.03266692906618118, -0.009066990576684475, 0.014352372847497463, 0.03665897622704506, -0.01268825028091669, 0.004788800608366728, -0.00971655547618866, -0.004887208808213472, 0.004243306815624237, -0.03765692189335823, -0.029850684106349945, 0.029976340010762215, 0.035736531019210815, -0.0036779495421797037, -0.042608100920915604, -0.037262529134750366, 0.021693013608455658, -0.050283558666706085, -0.008509566076099873, -0.006946838926523924, 0.028554366901516914, 0.015096643008291721, 0.021525440737605095, 0.012971045449376106, -0.017976975068449974, 0.007532258052378893, 0.019489537924528122, -0.046882081776857376, 0.018396200612187386, -0.007746492046862841, -0.0027618149761110544, -0.01727995090186596, -0.013509652577340603, 0.05387923866510391, 0.007090309169143438, -0.012101986445486546, -0.007517179008573294, 0.03865537792444229, 0.008702724240720272, 0.01190279796719551, -0.014693332836031914, 0.006191679276525974, 0.001583826495334506, 0.009229573421180248, -0.004337849095463753, -0.013559743762016296, 0.02883429452776909, 0.04689902812242508, -0.016823360696434975, -0.00610903836786747, -0.005584564991295338, 0.018412107601761818, 0.05404658243060112, 0.014809556305408478, 0.07724542170763016, -0.0010012404527515173, -0.05112794041633606, 0.008826718665659428, -0.011335779912769794, 0.023652615025639534, 0.061034247279167175, -0.020196234807372093, -0.014802096411585808, -0.014374859631061554, -0.023410167545080185, -0.015236345119774342, -0.01508068386465311, 0.004493932239711285, -0.00833397638052702, 0.07476393133401871, 0.015147613361477852, -0.08400789648294449, 0.004605649970471859, 0.02922125533223152, -0.0003585422527976334, 0.0009660042705945671, -0.02498685196042061, -0.0022573452442884445, -0.010606309399008751, -0.017318010330200195, 0.04230951890349388, 0.0029097050428390503, 0.00006459633732447401, 0.0018151558469980955, 0.014841008000075817, -0.04026487097144127, -0.025960329920053482, -0.027143163606524467, 0.002219931688159704, 0.02962937019765377, 0.01735406368970871, -0.04801294952630997, 0.0016433618729934096, 0.022387251257896423, 0.03572015464305878, 0.021146100014448166, 0.04354000464081764, -0.09023508429527283, -0.018423739820718765, 0.03260565921664238, 0.07281776517629623, -0.037133753299713135, -0.042111750692129135, -0.029028261080384254, -0.006285646930336952, 0.04712243005633354, -0.01181585993617773, -0.027672622352838516, 0.04026050865650177, -0.013162018731236458, 0.01688552461564541, -0.03318026289343834, -0.04227505251765251, 0.0264282189309597, -0.03397591784596443, 0.00020631798543035984, 0.003924394957721233, -0.018972937017679214, -0.07286486774682999, 0.031899306923151016, -0.019094334915280342, 0.025608275085687637, -0.04450041428208351, -0.005690405145287514, 0.03839176893234253, 0.037232790142297745, -0.0000968893218669109, -0.04310426115989685, -0.00002813762694131583, 0.01412646472454071, -0.007804678287357092, 0.05627710372209549, -0.00904934760183096, 0.00853557325899601, 0.01186967920511961, 0.016576843336224556, -0.024903679266572, -0.0019862623885273933, -0.014480131678283215, 0.05815873667597771, 0.005601697135716677, -0.03502485901117325, 0.08446840941905975, 0.009869872592389584, 0.007652894128113985, -0.04147348180413246, -0.02903417870402336, 0.0105189373716712, -0.01305894460529089, -0.025380806997418404, -0.03488531708717346, -0.027642467990517616, 0.0343601256608963, 0.009525449946522713, -0.0308705922216177, 0.031120268628001213, 0.0004770987725351006, -0.005864512175321579, 0.00809754803776741, 0.018666278570890427, 0.008528707548975945, -0.009271902963519096, 0.02971496433019638, 0.018139909952878952, 0.042969875037670135, -0.03399389237165451, 0.007583102211356163, -0.02367761731147766, 0.013130838051438332, -0.018970083445310593, -0.025314997881650925, -0.004112774971872568, -0.028719961643218994, -0.031198114156723022, 0.045644138008356094, -0.05255883187055588, 0.04279862716794014, -0.012843646109104156, 0.01110268197953701, 0.0022594432812184095, -0.045152533799409866, -0.023627586662769318, -0.008688201196491718, -0.02046911045908928, 0.06583777070045471, -0.03095613420009613, 0.04063820838928223, -0.015801364555954933, 0.014609013684093952, -0.05200823023915291, -0.03431858867406845, 0.0319836363196373, -0.009809119626879692, -0.017178189009428024, -0.04262474924325943, 0.024329200387001038, -0.020022481679916382, -0.024698471650481224, 0.046128928661346436, 0.02509268932044506, -0.02542337402701378, -0.00989563763141632, -0.03348660096526146, 0.013493843376636505, 0.039528485387563705, -0.004530685022473335, -0.011504460126161575, 0.05057826265692711, -0.0053537217900156975, -0.0032626104075461626, -0.019723519682884216, 0.02567656710743904, -0.044322941452264786, 0.0018335881177335978, -0.03543953225016594, 0.0030433705542236567, 0.04075969383120537, -0.035377003252506256, 0.01157044991850853, 0.0009405630989931524, 0.028153225779533386, 0.03519517928361893, -0.030217012390494347, -0.01960008777678013, 0.009864602237939835, 0.04686203971505165, -0.010728062130510807, 0.009275859221816063, 0.03416036441922188, -0.011983761563897133, 0.01485361997038126, 0.009610342793166637, 0.01341312751173973, 0.02080642059445381, 0.029553985223174095, -0.02089005336165428, 0.017379317432641983, -0.014115724712610245, -0.06275386363267899, 0.0031831027008593082, 0.02704881690442562, 0.02149178832769394, 0.04281621798872948, 0.03175540640950203, -0.057832036167383194, 0.0033885985612869263, -0.07367489486932755, -0.006727479863911867, 0.03500014543533325, -0.03653913363814354, 0.038776058703660965, 0.03280779719352722, -0.002105391351506114, -0.015555784106254578, -0.031985148787498474, -0.031569842249155045, -0.0005808686837553978, 0.0018884940072894096, 0.052927952259778976, -0.01587029919028282, -0.029601817950606346, 0.03356153890490532, 0.04566359519958496, -0.02664024941623211, 0.05707842856645584, 0.020780546590685844, 0.01177719421684742, 0.016740281134843826, 0.017034703865647316, -0.028557300567626953, 0.03496518358588219, -0.0034159005153924227, 0.0028950287960469723, -0.024114111438393593, -0.00576440617442131, 0.05141149461269379, 0.03980275243520737, 0.022241629660129547, -0.05246021971106529, -0.04689449071884155, -0.017475180327892303, -0.0024984467308968306, 0.030438944697380066, -0.00431425403803587, 0.041659876704216, 0.011990061961114407, 0.023686887696385384, 0.0088574243709445, 0.020194537937641144, -0.02749590016901493, -0.0705341324210167, -0.03042847290635109, -0.011567761190235615, -0.06461353600025177, 0.005604520905762911, 0.019105970859527588, -0.005568161606788635, 0.015619172714650631, -0.04243127256631851, -0.004117640666663647, -0.005710133351385593, 0.05284101516008377, 0.0009705956326797605, 0.08083236217498779, 0.0288990531116724, 0.010895338840782642, -0.005371288862079382, -0.040140245109796524, 0.12321621924638748, 0.08645757287740707, 0.038510702550411224, -0.0582735575735569, -0.011801059357821941, -0.015915755182504654, 0.011753403581678867, 0.000979931210167706, 0.028028875589370728, 0.03791683167219162, 0.0016262137796729803, 0.09015912562608719, 0.04755369573831558, 0.0021036951802670956, 0.0037789514753967524, 0.06261289864778519, -0.021242663264274597, -0.03429168835282326, 0.005340965930372477, 0.006488024722784758, -0.0008423993131145835, -0.016839485615491867, -0.016886159777641296, 0.02839672937989235, 0.00427685072645545, -0.0012052261736243963, -0.0260346457362175, -0.027676178142428398, -0.022179823368787766, -0.025384293869137764, -0.006081306375563145, -0.0024201353080570698, 0.018157958984375, 0.023535218089818954, -0.021224718540906906, 0.03360944613814354, 0.016374856233596802, -0.0068703265860676765, -0.01473972201347351, 0.022447729483246803, 0.0007363941404037178, 0.023459596559405327, 0.004585379268974066, 0.00953726563602686, -0.03310123458504677, -0.020842107012867928, -0.03051907941699028, 0.022626632824540138, 0.004739653784781694, -0.008268431760370731, -0.033971089869737625, 0.01040886715054512, -0.010521337389945984, -0.03239017352461815, -0.01895851269364357, 0.04357077181339264, 0.011652088724076748, -0.014980319887399673, -0.011632462963461876, -0.015842387452721596, 0.024379875510931015, 0.0018655145540833473, 0.03601916506886482, 0.03922700509428978, -0.05855178460478783, -0.011200792156159878, -0.08143755048513412, 0.006664982531219721, -0.021502623334527016, 0.006273848004639149, 0.0013946018880233169, 0.006752109620720148, -0.025779206305742264, -0.016668355092406273, 0.022689620032906532, -0.019846318289637566, 0.04683199152350426, -0.000830466509796679, 0.009478479623794556, -0.008053728379309177, -0.06961219757795334, 0.037696242332458496, -0.02499665692448616, -0.003355891676619649, -0.05306750908493996, 0.009869634173810482, 0.031001588329672813, 0.07033134996891022, -0.013117472641170025, 0.03407951444387436, -0.01109481230378151, 0.0014415890909731388, 0.012204239144921303, -0.026003021746873856, -0.004274445120245218, 0.031027378514409065, -0.009122689254581928, 0.006835896521806717, 0.02330625243484974, 0.08191297203302383, 0.020374510437250137, 0.020814720541238785, -0.033310431987047195, 0.05082349479198456, 0.014487188309431076, 0.02730351686477661, -0.030788209289312363, -0.07862433791160583, 0.0024726479314267635, -0.0017105713486671448, 0.005411804653704166, -0.03944019973278046, -0.032891206443309784, -0.01919463276863098, -0.04509498178958893, 0.031407006084918976, -0.018786409869790077, -0.008936905302107334, -0.021418342366814613, -0.0182929839938879, 0.05512477457523346, 0.008550452999770641, -0.01620485633611679, -0.04338474199175835, 0.014970455318689346, 0.02811804600059986, -0.05032111331820488, -0.010901580564677715, -0.016016444191336632, 0.026595454663038254, 0.012113829143345356, 0.003987707197666168, 0.010627558454871178, -0.005107817705720663, -0.00003047035170311574, -0.005905831232666969, -0.018636412918567657, 0.07356110960245132, -0.027412259951233864, -0.04371537268161774, 0.036432888358831406, -0.03529351204633713, -0.04126637428998947, 0.03886597603559494, 0.020120292901992798, 0.05036398768424988, 0.02610703557729721, -0.005598204676061869, -0.006026474293321371, 0.03152766451239586, -0.048525936901569366, -0.07786264270544052, -0.030316555872559547, 0.0165848508477211, 0.014224736951291561, 0.012430919334292412, 0.004959287587553263, 0.007829252630472183, -0.019686531275510788, 0.02242410182952881, 0.034634653478860855, -0.022162578999996185, -0.004552227444946766, 0.0032346604857593775, -0.016356222331523895, 0.022723505273461342, 0.006033912301063538, 0.03746049851179123, 0.038540396839380264, 0.03449712321162224, -0.0036645533982664347, 0.04963891953229904, -0.007726879790425301, -0.01061526220291853, -0.0875663235783577, -0.010346120223402977, -0.006581823341548443, -0.017314864322543144, 0.0040848758071660995, -0.04163910076022148, -0.005037845112383366, 0.03273003548383713, -0.05104348808526993, 0.050285305827856064, 0.011403704062104225, -0.03303470090031624, -0.05541001260280609, 0.02511505037546158, 0.008040577173233032, 0.0729527473449707, 0.03452984616160393, 0.01593627780675888, 0.04456142336130142, -0.024689806625247, 0.0006400690763257444, -0.026266323402523994, -0.012438633479177952, 0.040325067937374115, 0.00813712552189827, -0.052976325154304504, 0.04197460040450096, -0.046011488884687424, -0.03461531177163124, 0.03608747199177742, -0.011070671491324902, 0.007325677201151848, 0.03856640309095383, 0.005838810000568628, 0.008956117555499077, 0.007681071292608976, 0.017177291214466095, -0.01118160504847765, -0.010159825906157494, -0.02364381216466427, 0.024326639249920845, 0.04024193808436394, -0.0440329909324646, 0.04738124459981918, 0.018443262204527855, -0.018137328326702118, -0.057389914989471436, 0.03745264187455177, -0.023022469133138657, -0.03879491239786148, -0.003679105080664158, -0.01696448028087616, -0.00882188230752945, -0.04486420005559921, 0.02380145713686943, -0.014890778809785843, -0.0082643311470747, 0.041463159024715424, 0.028053250163793564, 0.019015436992049217, 0.04171362146735191, -0.01954660750925541, -0.029270410537719727, 0.01167354080826044, 0.010415693745017052, -0.027999725192785263, -0.04559548571705818, -0.027273844927549362, -0.007723634596914053, -0.013512391597032547, -0.021775713190436363, -0.012704585678875446, -0.03517546504735947, 0.014746129512786865, 0.013016517274081707, 0.03309917822480202, 0.03093857131898403, -0.022128013893961906, 0.009004068560898304, -0.11077316850423813, 0.07274328172206879, 0.01475520059466362, -0.044237010180950165, -0.040455594658851624, 0.012641211040318012, -0.006286095827817917, -0.025758516043424606, 0.035785503685474396, 0.017141219228506088, 0.023714285343885422, -0.036902278661727905, 0.0462765097618103, -0.024739950895309448, -0.0486689917743206, 0.027240894734859467, -0.0017626003827899694, -0.018510714173316956, -0.07132060080766678, 0.012251339852809906, 0.0038919420912861824, 0.020185258239507675, 0.004108792636543512, -0.035212647169828415, 0.03561653569340706, 0.010530161671340466, 0.04026908427476883, 0.021647218614816666, -0.0014576950343325734, -0.01720110885798931, 0.039971500635147095, 0.002013955032452941, 0.005425304174423218, 0.04782285913825035, -0.02496395818889141, -0.02889730967581272, 0.05781048163771629, -0.01160088088363409, -0.026893367990851402, 0.01399445254355669, -0.01147010549902916, 0.003383199917152524, -0.042375706136226654, -0.009321967139840126, 0.022452637553215027, -0.017969483509659767, 0.024938102811574936, 0.05859050899744034, 0.04594352841377258, 0.005451662000268698, -0.011255334131419659, 0.029149189591407776, 0.026270991191267967, -0.024432815611362457, -0.0018297166097909212, -0.005782270338386297, 0.034481167793273926, -0.009448058903217316, 0.032638926059007645, 0.030544625595211983, -0.027980146929621696, 0.014353279024362564, -0.014283384196460247, 0.04637562483549118, -0.0591924749314785, 0.004788950085639954, -0.010238928720355034, -0.04217316955327988, 0.028784843161702156, 0.015982627868652344, -0.013024837709963322, 0.04369010403752327, -0.01651875115931034, -0.016634363681077957, -0.015403595753014088, 0.009144255891442299, -0.04304623603820801, -0.008046362549066544, 0.0396149680018425, 0.02166835591197014, -0.021206414327025414, 0.007628641556948423, 0.0123467817902565, 0.0194462388753891, 0.020562972873449326, -0.01170080341398716, 0.05718294531106949, 0.010396851226687431, -0.011546961963176727, -0.018911762163043022, -0.023549890145659447, -0.014462968334555626, -0.008752651512622833, 0.007892901077866554, 0.029822198674082756, 0.018389428034424782, 0.019614003598690033, -0.01752185821533203, 0.010358178056776524, 0.010833228938281536, -0.06314901262521744, -0.014266455546021461, -0.08694919943809509, 0.024723108857870102, -0.016444886103272438, -0.027534756809473038 ]
<p>Should false discovery be controlled at the data acquisition level, or should this be at the data interpretation level?</p> <p>I have an experiment in which microarrays were used to quantify the expression of about 30,000 genes (variables) in two groups of biological tissues (group-sizes of 75 and 76). Raw array data was pre-processed to remove background signals and genes whose expression levels are undetectable, and to normalize values across arrays. The final data was then examined using the Mann-Whitney U test to compare gene expression between the two groups to identify differentially expressed genes, with false discovery rate (FDR) controlled with the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_discovery_rate#Benjamini.E2.80.93Hochberg_procedure" rel="nofollow">Benjamini-Hochberg</a> procedure. At FDR &lt;5%, no gene is identified as differentially expressed, and I formally conclude that 'there is no differential expression of genes between the two tissues.'</p> <p>Now, suppose someone is interested in the expression of only one specific gene. Using my pre-processed gene expression data-set and the U test, they compare the two groups for the expression of only this gene and notice a P value &lt;0.05, the commonly used significance threshold in my field of study. As this does not involve multiple testing, there is no false discovery control. Can this observer formally conclude that 'the gene is differentially expressed between the two tissues,' contradicting my conclusion?'</p> <p>Or should the observer have applied false discovery control because such a control has to be applied at the data acquisition level (as per which, data on multiple variables were collected) and not at the data interpretation level (as per which, data for only one variable was analyzed)?</p>
49,249
[ -0.038929976522922516, 0.012283609248697758, -0.014637063257396221, -0.029428552836179733, 0.021974613890051842, 0.026074962690472603, -0.008386515080928802, -0.039172399789094925, 0.015368588268756866, -0.003915110602974892, 0.060585301369428635, 0.00010383372864453122, 0.04674796387553215, -0.028329135850071907, 0.02129383385181427, 0.002884333487600088, 0.009227296337485313, -0.007521378342062235, -0.02223416604101658, -0.01952444761991501, -0.015374655835330486, 0.020785214379429817, 0.015581503510475159, -0.00048618781147524714, -0.03745215758681297, 0.04736664891242981, 0.016046717762947083, 0.01433505117893219, -0.017221931368112564, 0.014243314042687416, -0.03687632083892822, -0.0032508312724530697, 0.023968106135725975, 0.015933072194457054, 0.011918720789253712, -0.01745889149606228, -0.00859584379941225, -0.024287745356559753, 0.002694031223654747, 0.029722411185503006, -0.00831057969480753, -0.029373522847890854, 0.01855251006782055, 0.03372443467378616, -0.00204102392308414, 0.000142827644594945, 0.012476619333028793, -0.04079562425613403, 0.03449303284287453, -0.010794267989695072, 0.08310773968696594, 0.012515194714069366, 0.044659461826086044, 0.051771022379398346, -0.04724930599331856, -0.004812599625438452, 0.05823930725455284, 0.048851437866687775, 0.00874886941164732, -0.046055153012275696, -0.05772678181529045, 0.013532031327486038, -0.0018326006829738617, -0.010800759308040142, -0.05889848247170448, 0.050278618931770325, -0.04941016435623169, -0.022905603051185608, -0.015308445319533348, 0.009855618700385094, -0.01158734131604433, -0.00331357354298234, 0.020144466310739517, -0.010489226318895817, 0.03472231701016426, -0.04002956673502922, 0.02788355015218258, 0.00302533688955009, 0.007408829405903816, 0.021690189838409424, -0.008501836098730564, 0.0071662734262645245, 0.021042292937636375, 0.05393346771597862, 0.05105370655655861, -0.017961127683520317, 0.07410051673650742, -0.01439688540995121, 0.028833387419581413, 0.06356972455978394, -0.019583964720368385, 0.000007397578883683309, 0.03510119765996933, 0.02343296818435192, -0.03662336617708206, 0.02999163791537285, -0.03576216474175453, 0.038166120648384094, -0.03771061450242996, -0.01656074821949005, -0.013125201687216759, -0.04774477332830429, 0.0622309148311615, 0.03431598097085953, 0.008789447136223316, -0.04245331138372421, -0.021270016208291054, 0.02014888823032379, -0.03788049891591072, -0.017370786517858505, -0.00470871152356267, 0.030254120007157326, -0.019698219373822212, 0.006914901081472635, 0.026709286496043205, 0.018841715529561043, 0.007156990002840757, -0.016666224226355553, 0.08627544343471527, 0.04967878386378288, 0.07086322456598282, -0.020810768008232117, 0.030084436759352684, 0.0006015199469402432, -0.057387735694646835, -0.019146600738167763, 0.026776181533932686, -0.016377530992031097, -0.036631084978580475, 0.05291277915239334, 0.006412810180336237, 0.010766484774649143, 0.033283770084381104, -0.01993858627974987, 0.03942769393324852, 0.0019002821063622832, -0.07360275834798813, -0.0640612244606018, 0.05192048102617264, 0.02952643111348152, 0.019924839958548546, -0.10457441210746765, -0.045743610709905624, 0.04961327090859413, 0.04451585188508034, -0.003119983011856675, 0.02157106250524521, -0.021477768197655678, 0.029771167784929276, -0.01689787209033966, -0.004167718812823296, -0.02038075029850006, -0.02553367055952549, -0.029536111280322075, -0.03561672940850258, -0.040195267647504807, 0.0205126591026783, 0.000816553772892803, -0.012455800548195839, 0.023387311026453972, 0.015183395706117153, -0.033814847469329834, 0.011670511215925217, -0.005464110057801008, -0.007916359230875969, 0.024476265534758568, 0.07800556719303131, -0.0005430948222056031, 0.03971710801124573, 0.011953476816415787, 0.017265262082219124, 0.02491506189107895, 0.007931987755000591, 0.062093041837215424, 0.03778323531150818, -0.023941483348608017, 0.006503097712993622, -0.0000321174411510583, 0.04327917471528053, 0.010138077661395073, -0.0380563959479332, -0.003535541007295251, -0.020246682688593864, -0.013326551765203476, 0.014239874668419361, 0.017959721386432648, -0.020289327949285507, -0.011747388169169426, 0.023965226486325264, -0.04474029690027237, -0.06393323093652725, -0.06118117272853851, -0.02901533991098404, -0.027383729815483093, -0.03493306413292885, 0.017325544729828835, -0.002892148680984974, -0.003123406320810318, -0.056524522602558136, -0.028631746768951416, -0.03767804428935051, 0.019061706960201263, 0.03778985142707825, -0.03309297189116478, -0.023621635511517525, 0.042881131172180176, 0.01564946398139, -0.007063012104481459, 0.03381168097257614, -0.03490815684199333, -0.06563208997249603, 0.031121928244829178, -0.020896054804325104, -0.0038592496421188116, 0.01884184405207634, -0.006476238835602999, -0.009742319583892822, -0.05017578974366188, -0.0547807440161705, 0.048067040741443634, -0.045138705521821976, 0.07760018855333328, 0.05942697077989578, 0.01660790853202343, 0.002920700004324317, 0.018589891493320465, 0.005914343986660242, -0.03498487174510956, -0.04332339018583298, -0.021257853135466576, -0.03974815085530281, 0.006547723896801472, 0.027332819998264313, 0.01655786670744419, -0.015830179676413536, 0.03997370973229408, 0.028904616832733154, -0.007043824531137943, 0.0025432566180825233, 0.03983905166387558, 0.0274199265986681, -0.03837915137410164, 0.02292385883629322, 0.03961177170276642, -0.004976498894393444, -0.0007991682505235076, 0.034062739461660385, -0.008339187130331993, 0.057543735951185226, 0.01817021518945694, 0.03152801841497421, 0.03956989198923111, -0.00640843017026782, -0.0019791109953075647, 0.015386883169412613, -0.0005972786457277834, 0.013784262351691723, -0.0072420802898705006, 0.04991360381245613, 0.014809067361056805, 0.0034582954831421375, 0.0008518065442331135, -0.028949491679668427, -0.002223225077614188, 0.024287879467010498, 0.024453097954392433, -0.06022559478878975, 0.005541566293686628, 0.02241578884422779, -0.03605949506163597, -0.01071813516318798, -0.06678174436092377, -0.00856088474392891, -0.019835583865642548, 0.01115193497389555, -0.00615205243229866, 0.01705350913107395, 0.060216184705495834, -0.06269620358943939, -0.019782697781920433, -0.029722224920988083, -0.018318278715014458, 0.05160096660256386, -0.032133568078279495, -0.05794643610715866, 0.028768569231033325, -0.0351606160402298, -0.025816693902015686, 0.031164154410362244, -0.026272021234035492, -0.021923484280705452, 0.02324712462723255, 0.010623732581734657, -0.042099494487047195, -0.026579145342111588, -0.024402862414717674, 0.003260934492573142, 0.011657669208943844, -0.05206974595785141, 0.02818998508155346, -0.02361675165593624, -0.002752517117187381, 0.06555449217557907, -0.02454434707760811, -0.009060169570147991, 0.030888045206665993, 0.0005067518795840442, 0.002588235540315509, 0.019395848736166954, 0.01712275668978691, 0.015704236924648285, -0.06088588386774063, -0.04445400461554527, -0.04672137647867203, -0.08190592378377914, 0.017551038414239883, 0.006477118469774723, 0.043338555842638016, -0.02493664063513279, -0.024276893585920334, 0.03763877600431442, 0.018560077995061874, -0.005883730947971344, -0.04966701567173004, 0.029446350410580635, -0.042618174105882645, -0.015141153708100319, 0.0033154496923089027, 0.0032044185791164637, -0.011494596488773823, 0.019426360726356506, -0.00878266990184784, 0.004053367767482996, 0.0467674620449543, 0.008386208675801754, -0.018883679062128067, 0.010945435613393784, 0.022397812455892563, 0.00163886824157089, 0.008445823565125465, 0.05182349309325218, 0.0025486296508461237, 0.029160168021917343, -0.0020300496835261583, 0.010918908752501011, -0.005075871478766203, -0.03526508808135986, 0.03933856636285782, 0.030267799273133278, 0.03060503676533699, -0.02157266065478325, -0.03197851404547691, 0.032534386962652206, -0.012439681217074394, -0.016846077516674995, -0.0068573784083127975, 0.020968107506632805, -0.024723485112190247, -0.015375809744000435, 0.037324998527765274, 0.016749771311879158, -0.004338765516877174, -0.009593766182661057, 0.006435978692024946, -0.017794249579310417, 0.03116205707192421, -0.025408420711755753, -0.03477855399250984, 0.03512636572122574, 0.027832798659801483, 0.030322406440973282, -0.02118661440908909, -0.05647760629653931, 0.003466363064944744, -0.05224989354610443, 0.017889030277729034, -0.01019715704023838, 0.02309953235089779, -0.0054572876542806625, 0.020510314032435417, 0.043656524270772934, -0.0270397812128067, -0.0339440256357193, -0.0010034255683422089, -0.0730564072728157, 0.03435667231678963, -0.02454039826989174, -0.0013669756008312106, -0.012014939449727535, -0.049171674996614456, 0.03891688212752342, -0.0018564356723800302, 0.07962413132190704, -0.00990530289709568, 0.03484208136796951, -0.03176118806004524, 0.008000165224075317, 0.0009682586533017457, -0.01705959253013134, -0.033861443400382996, -0.003266991814598441, 0.030356548726558685, 0.039748791605234146, 0.03825655207037926, 0.03373337164521217, 0.0083672059699893, -0.006709718611091375, -0.0018381361151114106, 0.003480741288512945, 0.01783250831067562, 0.020607730373740196, 0.02364228293299675, 0.03433284908533096, -0.04994449391961098, 0.03802798315882683, 0.01935391128063202, 0.06290140748023987, 0.014247585088014603, -0.0008186052436940372, -0.03362350910902023, -0.02976466901600361, -0.03688963130116463, 0.00247380742803216, 0.02261979691684246, 0.01193959265947342, -0.0240971390157938, 0.038973115384578705, 0.03622225299477577, -0.06237780675292015, 0.057455841451883316, 0.04890288785099983, 0.008426394313573837, 0.02506393939256668, -0.016493292525410652, -0.008101874962449074, -0.020118042826652527, -0.0036101818550378084, 0.05133239924907684, 0.02836521714925766, 0.02014191448688507, -0.03818197175860405, 0.009547529742121696, -0.0045100669376552105, -0.022623324766755104, 0.015103498473763466, 0.010634454898536205, 0.024177035316824913, -0.012569518759846687, 0.025943418964743614, 0.056731902062892914, 0.038444701582193375, 0.01589646004140377, 0.018070368096232414, -0.008387143723666668, -0.07069946825504303, 0.0018850353080779314, 0.02682548202574253, 0.025004789233207703, -0.039079319685697556, -0.009990005753934383, -0.03916998580098152, 0.010475515387952328, 0.0030399488750845194, -0.021609364077448845, 0.009942387230694294, -0.018866606056690216, 0.01150287501513958, -0.026679104194045067, -0.02095453254878521, -0.02286599762737751, 0.006852603051811457, -0.023914413526654243, 0.03154255822300911, -0.005253310780972242, -0.007327810861170292, -0.047096919268369675, -0.00865108985453844, -0.021314790472388268, 0.05776422098278999, -0.014378484338521957, -0.018047302961349487, 0.03421299532055855, -0.008146407082676888, -0.030211126431822777, -0.0917641893029213, 0.018535612151026726, -0.012051312252879143, 0.014682094566524029, 0.08564988523721695, 0.009012488648295403, -0.03020196408033371, 0.06147359311580658, 0.039865680038928986, -0.023997347801923752, 0.004079774022102356, -0.00950363464653492, 0.06355805695056915, 0.024175258353352547, 0.023103859275579453, 0.08886405825614929, -0.032122138887643814, 0.0063768355175852776, -0.003033188870176673, -0.03213774040341377, 0.036145664751529694, -0.05000942200422287, -0.012250956147909164, -0.02617422118782997, -0.023178912699222565, -0.006047459319233894, 0.020857417955994606, 0.0370146669447422, -0.019631726667284966, -0.01563732512295246, 0.01195814460515976, 0.02761378325521946, 0.004993048030883074, 0.0003743154520634562, -0.032414067536592484, -0.021655205637216568, 0.016372371464967728, -0.03636333346366882, 0.0039377412758767605, -0.0016753905219957232, -0.046958304941654205, 0.0016581674572080374, 0.019399788230657578, -0.03406776115298271, 0.027020810171961784, -0.01796497218310833, -0.04555989429354668, 0.014217034913599491, -0.022959647700190544, 0.014125167392194271, -0.015317036770284176, 0.009336251765489578, -0.02812209352850914, -0.035354871302843094, 0.009071516804397106, 0.01634909398853779, 0.016317514702677727, 0.047663815319538116, -0.04756549000740051, 0.04615836590528488, -0.03153017535805702, 0.017244921997189522, -0.05833124741911888, 0.00442886259406805, 0.02875812165439129, 0.05164185166358948, 0.021526528522372246, -0.014883835799992085, 0.019086703658103943, -0.03814498707652092, -0.02664950117468834, 0.002957801101729274, 0.031570978462696075, -0.018152130767703056, -0.043720025569200516, -0.008443278260529041, 0.04943404346704483, 0.053521741181612015, -0.0595797561109066, 0.041109468787908554, -0.012833009473979473, -0.0014961030101403594, -0.007908874191343784, 0.01324809342622757, 0.011467264965176582, -0.012655955739319324, 0.005243534687906504, -0.049584709107875824, -0.004539355635643005, 0.013381198048591614, -0.021466517820954323, -0.007528745569288731, 0.015713868662714958, -0.005660064052790403, -0.0123540498316288, -0.015254347585141659, -0.014990434981882572, -0.06772439181804657, 0.0072833700105547905, 0.007502830121666193, 0.020971203222870827, -0.0028127962723374367, 0.003620027331635356, 0.00817964132875204, 0.0020639405120164156, -0.008508901111781597, 0.04992160573601723, 0.05326364189386368, -0.005559356417506933, 0.02423754148185253, -0.030960598960518837, -0.02713136188685894, 0.018896810710430145, -0.02432316727936268, 0.004539067856967449, 0.024088608101010323, 0.003420773893594742, -0.024764422327280045, 0.0022720941342413425, -0.00008387752313865349, 0.025090452283620834, 0.046447791159152985, -0.0024593775160610676, 0.05118006840348244, 0.04726867750287056, -0.003641370451077819, 0.0071020107716321945, -0.03633226826786995, 0.009954119101166725, 0.017941288650035858, 0.009152679704129696, 0.04050512611865997, -0.009540076367557049, 0.005611882545053959, 0.04183368384838104, -0.015461265109479427, 0.01127233449369669, 0.049654487520456314, 0.051638681441545486, 0.023931564763188362, 0.04030240699648857, -0.01856059767305851, -0.035642243921756744, 0.05236683785915375, -0.059000734239816666, -0.004994166549295187, -0.01766853779554367, -0.006727098021656275, 0.01953807845711708, 0.0455261692404747, -0.0002377966302447021, -0.03329664468765259, -0.055395301431417465, -0.06599149852991104, 0.021234620362520218, 0.0033298879861831665, 0.008796893060207367, 0.0647004172205925, -0.03551279380917549, 0.021634690463542938, -0.004835454747080803, 0.0471174418926239, 0.00801074504852295, -0.04287762567400932, -0.07229945808649063, -0.07023266702890396, 0.012063171714544296, 0.0598837248980999, 0.013519976288080215, -0.03242746368050575, 0.014979299157857895, -0.03585178032517433, 0.029445085674524307, 0.020931201055645943, 0.04092638939619064, -0.03146791458129883, 0.03302144631743431, 0.02105657383799553, 0.024631351232528687, 0.008428108878433704, -0.023745525628328323, 0.13776953518390656, 0.0893845409154892, 0.03932063654065132, -0.06264407187700272, 0.006902159191668034, 0.0011396169429644942, -0.020632745698094368, -0.014292510226368904, 0.006943716201931238, 0.014466984197497368, 0.0029256222769618034, 0.026034606620669365, 0.045763637870550156, 0.026102451607584953, 0.0072867083363235, 0.07645351439714432, -0.036536019295454025, 0.001572904409840703, 0.03441411256790161, 0.00530037609860301, 0.02709283120930195, -0.032365910708904266, 0.0009760645916685462, -0.0072648609057068825, -0.006735936738550663, -0.01761755906045437, 0.027109133079648018, -0.02926708199083805, -0.02007250487804413, 0.03173583373427391, -0.032209526747465134, -0.022172940894961357, 0.002944801701232791, 0.008516925387084484, -0.04511275887489319, -0.011941099539399147, -0.011728485114872456, -0.03464869037270546, -0.004807248245924711, 0.06548147648572922, -0.0005141664296388626, -0.009606784209609032, 0.023278966546058655, 0.070200115442276, -0.005945436656475067, 0.018025556579232216, -0.002493150532245636, 0.06795601546764374, -0.025698279961943626, -0.012288719415664673, 0.0006893938989378512, -0.0276112649589777, -0.015348884277045727, -0.026925358921289444, -0.01279179286211729, 0.00963443424552679, -0.007821355015039444, -0.01877795346081257, 0.0014536944217979908, -0.01314582396298647, 0.013163437135517597, -0.005681987851858139, 0.026387447491288185, 0.03974569961428642, -0.013873095624148846, -0.0023076937068253756, 0.0028975435998290777, 0.040408581495285034, -0.01685422658920288, 0.0400063619017601, -0.01382802240550518, -0.002489652018994093, -0.035139262676239014, -0.0015663662925362587, -0.006931943818926811, -0.003393766935914755, 0.02346702292561531, -0.008873161859810352, -0.006530369631946087, -0.01825655810534954, -0.03962121903896332, 0.04087661951780319, -0.00630970997735858, -0.010554575361311436, -0.053781501948833466, -0.021780284121632576, 0.03573378548026085, 0.05796556919813156, -0.008655133657157421, 0.011005278676748276, 0.025432445108890533, 0.037824105471372604, 0.01578257791697979, -0.048236314207315445, 0.002593275858089328, -0.016692759469151497, -0.018294818699359894, -0.013358700089156628, 0.00014294707216322422, 0.04496399685740471, -0.00021060106519144028, 0.020059743896126747, -0.02141372673213482, 0.04247601702809334, -0.030145026743412018, 0.0021953394170850515, -0.013814936392009258, -0.03661026060581207, 0.004128236323595047, 0.03123265877366066, 0.018470091745257378, -0.04824674129486084, -0.05404384806752205, -0.06689268350601196, -0.046160634607076645, 0.039371371269226074, -0.02118547447025776, 0.014404813759028912, 0.001992788864299655, 0.025274725630879402, -0.006899027619510889, -0.006942552514374256, -0.017545459792017937, -0.0667378380894661, 0.001388541073538363, 0.027857400476932526, -0.017366845160722733, -0.017772231251001358, -0.005556655116379261, -0.024627095088362694, -0.011506479233503342, 0.019651958718895912, 0.014370844699442387, 0.006746668368577957, 0.0005601110169664025, 0.032610900700092316, 0.022011583670973778, 0.02968326024711132, 0.008268646895885468, -0.006879743188619614, 0.0362124890089035, -0.04729030281305313, -0.02235722728073597, 0.022373871877789497, -0.0075592524372041225, 0.013438875786960125, 0.0077569386921823025, 0.01194855198264122, -0.011882287450134754, 0.0059991395100951195, -0.0010878383181989193, -0.03760010376572609, 0.02410263940691948, -0.008600507862865925, -0.057914067059755325, 0.01273477915674448, 0.024701299145817757, 0.012203764170408249, -0.026622407138347626, 0.03450682386755943, 0.02228228561580181, 0.05686373636126518, -0.0033308537676930428, -0.008418327197432518, 0.00019692449131980538, 0.03894519433379173, 0.002113809110596776, -0.009047103114426136, 0.0210736021399498, 0.06325118243694305, -0.023298481479287148, -0.009065236896276474, -0.013583535328507423, -0.001977776177227497, -0.09789028018712997, -0.052314773201942444, 0.004226821940392256, 0.01995335891842842, 0.022707447409629822, -0.0318029522895813, 0.03173338249325752, 0.023842765018343925, -0.0468713603913784, 0.014427264221012592, -0.05873814597725868, -0.0007743448950350285, -0.03470023721456528, -0.04894610866904259, -0.048034973442554474, 0.003124442184343934, 0.0305399801582098, 0.022839896380901337, 0.037894364446401596, 0.0020580622367560863, -0.008219465613365173, -0.01604725606739521, -0.005617508199065924, 0.02997024729847908, -0.01069363858550787, -0.10658599436283112, 0.018282145261764526, -0.018394464626908302, -0.05040335655212402, 0.04083187133073807, 0.009273683652281761, 0.0037442354951053858, 0.015145358629524708, -0.0002588207134976983, 0.014668382704257965, -0.015803420916199684, 0.02644798345863819, -0.014020446687936783, -0.0036067122127860785, -0.005157836712896824, 0.0023439961951225996, 0.028949925675988197, -0.02195175178349018, -0.005350561812520027, 0.01656869426369667, -0.008362924680113792, -0.021112389862537384, -0.001080947695299983, -0.027409987524151802, 0.00334757287055254, 0.010654907673597336, -0.004661242943257093, -0.01278296671807766, -0.0474606454372406, -0.014217187650501728, -0.04055016115307808, -0.01722707599401474, 0.024071209132671356, 0.07114426046609879, -0.05740895867347717, 0.010782144032418728, -0.027498045936226845, -0.00939321517944336, 0.02585088089108467, -0.018331823870539665, 0.004234205465763807, -0.060702625662088394, 0.034344129264354706, -0.03437387943267822, -0.024936649948358536, -0.01939142309129238, -0.019788313657045364, -0.03849999979138374, 0.0362691655755043, -0.020750541239976883, -0.002551447134464979, -0.030393438413739204, -0.03825869783759117, 0.01568789593875408, -0.0912352055311203, 0.05842238664627075, 0.033703867346048355, 0.01592588610947132, -0.050963327288627625, -0.005541947670280933, -0.013969771564006805, 0.018023259937763214, 0.037335723638534546, 0.010919274762272835, 0.002833501435816288, 0.011300609447062016, 0.032400332391262054, -0.017666343599557877, -0.04230264946818352, 0.0724819004535675, -0.021670248359441757, -0.0032693592365831137, -0.044783420860767365, -0.016068993136286736, 0.021760571748018265, 0.004140041768550873, -0.005486767273396254, 0.04396878555417061, 0.02377026155591011, 0.014447269029915333, -0.006929212249815464, 0.025445161387324333, -0.021496841683983803, -0.01908954605460167, 0.04734053835272789, 0.007045114412903786, 0.01187441311776638, 0.0002884358982555568, 0.007979698479175568, -0.03565773740410805, 0.032228734344244, -0.013751042075455189, -0.03391555696725845, 0.0033674791920930147, 0.03210138529539108, -0.018217064440250397, -0.05722836032509804, 0.01278416346758604, -0.015495787374675274, -0.0375002883374691, 0.016655202955007553, 0.01163718942552805, 0.01002564374357462, 0.007544997613877058, -0.0016748313792049885, 0.03191392123699188, -0.0012405648594722152, -0.029126890003681183, -0.012045088224112988, 0.011381153017282486, 0.009352128952741623, 0.01177922822535038, 0.02814653515815735, 0.04652046784758568, -0.06634780764579773, 0.022655129432678223, -0.006531479302793741, 0.069405697286129, -0.022285008803009987, -0.03488260880112648, 0.012558922171592712, 0.003482996253296733, 0.005301137454807758, 0.012346452102065086, 0.01617935299873352, 0.07043968886137009, -0.025103358551859856, 0.007186936214566231, -0.017364684492349625, -0.02351986989378929, 0.016402453184127808, 0.02125169336795807, 0.057455066591501236, 0.03351129963994026, 0.017457010224461555, 0.00449566962197423, -0.05903894454240799, -0.0030794027261435986, 0.022984903305768967, 0.0008674779091961682, 0.02114117704331875, -0.017884282395243645, -0.021748226135969162, 0.006312382407486439, -0.019688982516527176, -0.018475931137800217, -0.004420838784426451, 0.032100070267915726, 0.0023655579425394535, 0.02225613407790661, -0.03514900431036949, -0.026503926143050194, -0.036674778908491135, 0.017605571076273918, -0.07478872686624527, -0.008246893994510174, -0.03759104385972023, -0.006503907032310963, 0.011189124546945095, 0.0013326769694685936 ]
<p>I am reading the article of wikipedia about <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayesian_average" rel="nofollow">bayesian average</a>. This seems very interesting about on developing rating systems, but I have a doubt. How to fix the weight C of the average?</p>
74,497
[ -0.02967635728418827, -0.026914287358522415, 0.003800374921411276, -0.03656997159123421, 0.0762917622923851, 0.007202752400189638, -0.011365178972482681, -0.029225975275039673, 0.019211772829294205, -0.05019990727305412, 0.023829840123653412, 0.05290088430047035, 0.06781061738729477, 0.06783595681190491, 0.023318741470575333, -0.03375528007745743, 0.0032845735549926758, 0.00456079700961709, -0.030721265822649002, -0.02259138412773609, 0.005415814928710461, 0.03191058710217476, 0.0010216089431196451, -0.030802594497799873, -0.00043990847188979387, 0.04113824665546417, 0.053147174417972565, -0.02835705317556858, 0.046943776309490204, 0.06861331313848495, -0.02134229615330696, -0.006108107976615429, 0.05817607045173645, 0.012371394783258438, 0.009710566140711308, -0.026953332126140594, -0.028626717627048492, -0.02463621273636818, -0.038103073835372925, 0.011469456367194653, -0.022986119613051414, -0.0029027212876826525, -0.019839871674776077, 0.03024720773100853, -0.043239422142505646, -0.007395211141556501, 0.002402695594355464, -0.05686362087726593, 0.017790134996175766, -0.07010474056005478, 0.06103024631738663, 0.011461712419986725, 0.028016116470098495, 0.03779007866978645, -0.0030544339679181576, -0.038762710988521576, 0.04236781224608421, 0.06990028917789459, -0.012870718725025654, -0.042402248829603195, -0.017043462023139, -0.0024156684521585703, 0.02162155508995056, -0.009770252741873264, 0.013360810466110706, 0.023775160312652588, -0.010204504244029522, -0.029170051217079163, 0.04938856139779091, 0.019121073186397552, 0.0027832351624965668, 0.025052057579159737, 0.027877725660800934, -0.025230195373296738, 0.03797972947359085, -0.049754660576581955, 0.0264287032186985, 0.04080203175544739, 0.027004899457097054, 0.022877536714076996, -0.00612016161903739, -0.011874333955347538, 0.04692758619785309, 0.08229376375675201, -0.01835688203573227, -0.011343976482748985, 0.0681665763258934, -0.035688627511262894, 0.02326158620417118, 0.012196068651974201, -0.023279381915926933, 0.005837923847138882, 0.025346113368868828, -0.0405888631939888, -0.05653652176260948, 0.03144063428044319, -0.018441183492541313, 0.05012845993041992, 0.0020859804935753345, -0.019952811300754547, 0.025319045409560204, -0.006736244075000286, 0.003261162666603923, 0.032580554485321045, -0.015563084743916988, -0.02590157464146614, -0.031841494143009186, 0.0026592754293233156, 0.003973847255110741, -0.0006930211675353348, -0.036237336695194244, 0.028028206899762154, 0.01084403321146965, -0.01558239758014679, 0.025548497214913368, -0.004566594492644072, 0.03190634399652481, -0.016734162345528603, 0.05725798383355141, 0.03591020777821541, 0.024293221533298492, -0.028970269486308098, 0.02609524503350258, 0.0000033653113860054873, -0.05797408148646355, 0.011015176773071289, 0.01476341299712658, -0.03868228942155838, -0.043125495314598083, 0.03642437979578972, -0.0050894832238554955, -0.02954629622399807, 0.04502209648489952, 0.013009874150156975, -0.012663217261433601, -0.012392831966280937, -0.10594744980335236, -0.039946381002664566, 0.020293528214097023, -0.012126917019486427, -0.005067493300884962, -0.08947741985321045, 0.005857088603079319, 0.03863145783543587, 0.044936779886484146, 0.032307133078575134, 0.038225796073675156, 0.030100634321570396, 0.03144368529319763, -0.013974823988974094, 0.012982736341655254, -0.05148429796099663, 0.013144970871508121, -0.04103713482618332, -0.032292142510414124, -0.10421018302440643, 0.005447709001600742, -0.013305263593792915, 0.008969869464635849, -0.00492770504206419, 0.022605519741773605, -0.01717250794172287, -0.03126499429345131, -0.02672492153942585, 0.012807555496692657, -0.017370693385601044, 0.07033056020736694, 0.008079185150563717, 0.03937527909874916, -0.0028432526160031557, -0.01743439771234989, 0.00041002195212058723, 0.018744932487607002, 0.05072405934333801, 0.05799514427781105, -0.022702768445014954, -0.02473480813205242, -0.03420114144682884, 0.0428035631775856, -0.03698031231760979, -0.026460176333785057, -0.0033309648279100657, -0.01737537421286106, 0.021328875795006752, 0.026242824271321297, 0.03421152010560036, -0.002363591454923153, 0.013741387985646725, 0.018305599689483643, -0.035061124712228775, -0.04809049889445305, -0.06931997835636139, -0.014112106524407864, -0.00016518695338163525, 0.004747373517602682, 0.018212683498859406, -0.00721919909119606, 0.018908098340034485, -0.038397520780563354, 0.02281355671584606, -0.049165304750204086, -0.016489023342728615, 0.016398699954152107, -0.038909200578927994, 0.015566658228635788, 0.053804535418748856, 0.04843667149543762, -0.010424944572150707, 0.037357937544584274, -0.0437508150935173, -0.0739138051867485, 0.005603922996670008, -0.023929400369524956, 0.012778135016560555, -0.0004343051405157894, -0.013935623690485954, 0.013106423430144787, 0.010423562489449978, -0.015927186235785484, -0.0029238311108201742, -0.05603138729929924, 0.09062216430902481, 0.056580957025289536, -0.018773743882775307, 0.004934241995215416, 0.047676436603069305, 0.013689297251403332, 0.024087149649858475, -0.005786743946373463, -0.01852581650018692, -0.07199016213417053, 0.00034907273948192596, 0.02102840133011341, -0.015128015540540218, -0.043908774852752686, 0.000008320099368575029, 0.03393382951617241, 0.031285323202610016, 0.04240255802869797, 0.02627144753932953, 0.007756021339446306, -0.02907712757587433, 0.029983097687363625, 0.021864373236894608, 0.025122612714767456, 0.013621296733617783, 0.009184343740344048, 0.016028767451643944, 0.02689473330974579, -0.010413181968033314, 0.0020279642194509506, 0.010417439043521881, -0.02690362185239792, 0.03905252367258072, -0.008550348691642284, -0.004962209612131119, 0.04177822545170784, -0.04842497780919075, 0.027779821306467056, 0.02348974347114563, 0.0009888368658721447, -0.0162774957716465, 0.00833151675760746, -0.025407372042536736, 0.004128261934965849, 0.07524487376213074, -0.0625021830201149, -0.02256982959806919, 0.012022171169519424, 0.008810639381408691, 0.019766539335250854, -0.012016675435006618, -0.014053244143724442, -0.054910995066165924, 0.02506215125322342, 0.007161309942603111, -0.022498704493045807, 0.01180800050497055, -0.010665609501302242, -0.04678788781166077, -0.022238261997699738, -0.005879083648324013, -0.015843093395233154, -0.0004065602843184024, -0.0417402982711792, -0.005261674523353577, 0.021780217066407204, -0.018791863694787025, 0.03778642788529396, -0.04273155331611633, -0.02549770474433899, 0.04190945252776146, 0.0053177401423454285, -0.011577298864722252, -0.006168995518237352, -0.006538711953908205, 0.010626680217683315, -0.039635080844163895, -0.04527538642287254, 0.05421270430088043, 0.04951155558228493, -0.016297023743391037, 0.037155695259571075, -0.0349867157638073, -0.058804791420698166, -0.019466085359454155, -0.015549806877970695, -0.005974380765110254, 0.002911964198574424, 0.04711811617016792, 0.03022671490907669, -0.04419074207544327, 0.006037394516170025, -0.04722697660326958, -0.08863618224859238, 0.056512679904699326, -0.009673901833593845, 0.04021115228533745, 0.017465781420469284, -0.014614037238061428, 0.06697007268667221, 0.010671830736100674, -0.04828478768467903, 0.0011668872321024537, 0.01172666810452938, 0.013726949691772461, 0.0011128609767183661, -0.0023634186945855618, 0.04671154171228409, -0.018226666375994682, 0.03128845989704132, 0.012146594934165478, -0.0014553177170455456, 0.05794989690184593, 0.01853126659989357, -0.010825336910784245, 0.017389796674251556, 0.0003967512457165867, -0.018118591979146004, 0.023265156894922256, 0.03016928769648075, -0.02962491475045681, -0.007766798138618469, 0.020664894953370094, 0.0426710806787014, 0.01039312593638897, -0.013757765293121338, 0.012975966557860374, -0.0007327703642658889, 0.010110290721058846, -0.03579849377274513, 0.008867385797202587, 0.008744803257286549, -0.002489338396117091, 0.02454492263495922, 0.0010648977477103472, 0.03282554820179939, -0.008013761602342129, 0.04203815385699272, 0.04479006677865982, 0.0636841207742691, -0.020945696160197258, -0.04620273783802986, 0.02103392966091633, -0.006975418422371149, 0.014172475785017014, -0.008637133054435253, -0.007153218612074852, 0.03664752095937729, 0.01937597058713436, 0.038551103323698044, -0.005525846034288406, -0.03219520300626755, 0.016917945817112923, -0.06292322278022766, -0.024939147755503654, -0.012317863292992115, 0.03868235647678375, 0.010621880181133747, 0.01710759848356247, 0.01653284579515457, 0.005543931387364864, 0.014424597844481468, 0.010764729231595993, -0.07877318561077118, -0.009482109919190407, -0.03718400374054909, -0.01916183903813362, -0.01384283322840929, -0.04235808923840523, 0.03101489320397377, -0.020482273772358894, 0.020119795575737953, -0.04071882367134094, 0.020750101655721664, -0.005139618646353483, -0.0019072581781074405, -0.03291000798344612, -0.0071488539688289165, 0.009553802199661732, -0.025095924735069275, 0.017032774165272713, -0.02828208915889263, 0.015371310524642467, 0.05304170772433281, 0.0005947480094619095, -0.04630136117339134, -0.028178192675113678, -0.001166391302831471, 0.025582527741789818, 0.0271614957600832, 0.0015529145020991564, 0.04960205778479576, -0.025611845776438713, 0.04736997187137604, -0.0016873959684744477, 0.015463321469724178, 0.049642302095890045, -0.04387124255299568, -0.0023626338224858046, -0.02436901070177555, -0.03278421610593796, -0.017221199348568916, -0.002878671744838357, -0.015132551081478596, -0.006115114316344261, 0.013306931592524052, -0.007691818289458752, -0.07982524484395981, 0.043801113963127136, 0.05817059054970741, 0.01225837878882885, -0.004291816148906946, -0.025476722046732903, -0.003556168405339122, -0.018587931990623474, -0.036711227148771286, 0.023331638425588608, 0.0351182296872139, -0.04517701268196106, 0.011213764548301697, 0.05848408490419388, -0.026583636179566383, -0.03747139126062393, -0.005112087354063988, 0.008293240331113338, 0.015968328341841698, 0.03131233900785446, -0.03620162978768349, 0.02296227402985096, 0.028515569865703583, 0.029971681535243988, -0.0028429003432393074, -0.00892367959022522, -0.08338741213083267, -0.01643875055015087, 0.0261785127222538, 0.03369444981217384, -0.028804801404476166, -0.004199621733278036, -0.05111319571733475, 0.023940932005643845, 0.04910184442996979, -0.02573855221271515, 0.02234506607055664, -0.015977686271071434, 0.033303577452898026, 0.0035486984997987747, -0.0179965291172266, -0.011395069770514965, 0.03350936993956566, 0.014120289124548435, 0.025684745982289314, -0.00476830406114459, -0.009588879533112049, -0.026247022673487663, -0.012154791504144669, 0.018689241260290146, 0.040976181626319885, -0.019481724128127098, -0.03150666877627373, -0.02287290059030056, 0.020934930071234703, -0.013577154837548733, -0.09041988104581833, -0.019371427595615387, -0.00007474119047401473, -0.018897876143455505, 0.0098305968567729, -0.029242699965834618, -0.034208547323942184, -0.0002630738017614931, 0.03873623162508011, -0.036270495504140854, -0.0015655749011784792, -0.03979046642780304, 0.043234869837760925, 0.02501644380390644, -0.024713072925806046, 0.06207450479269028, 0.012336838990449905, -0.03342238813638687, 0.009802266024053097, -0.018579434603452682, 0.00071434595156461, -0.046200938522815704, -0.0018452752847224474, -0.024139530956745148, -0.0008397700730711222, 0.004674335476011038, 0.01903979480266571, 0.004997534211724997, 0.03778481110930443, -0.03882488235831261, -0.019611233845353127, -0.021966619417071342, -0.02387860231101513, 0.003177819773554802, -0.004819989670068026, -0.007685726508498192, 0.013057124800980091, 0.027669355273246765, 0.0017573225777596235, 0.029218953102827072, 0.0065230210311710835, 0.025527043268084526, -0.00769853126257658, -0.04499851539731026, 0.004483204800635576, -0.04031579568982124, -0.005411231424659491, 0.02807707153260708, -0.057488180696964264, 0.062171295285224915, 0.028297841548919678, 0.027585899457335472, 0.021767007187008858, -0.030682945623993874, -0.03396433964371681, -0.010500981472432613, 0.010336752980947495, 0.0495748408138752, -0.053182605654001236, 0.015009542927145958, -0.015671484172344208, 0.01676306501030922, -0.061092082411050797, -0.007157490588724613, 0.024480381980538368, -0.02116939052939415, -0.010558887384831905, -0.01991373673081398, 0.03110462985932827, -0.014618711546063423, -0.027092257514595985, -0.005587161052972078, 0.03732231259346008, -0.0173246618360281, -0.020911814644932747, 0.008022594265639782, -0.006330828182399273, 0.06475482136011124, 0.015263870358467102, -0.019688697531819344, 0.007632726337760687, -0.03760568052530289, -0.010421463288366795, -0.017316292971372604, 0.04793126508593559, -0.040159836411476135, -0.001635285560041666, -0.0034316477831453085, 0.02897469699382782, 0.02472502551972866, -0.019065843895077705, 0.016770372167229652, -0.002433872316032648, 0.014440080150961876, -0.03275510296225548, -0.02343768998980522, 0.005733383819460869, -0.02126793935894966, -0.01130899228155613, -0.02882782183587551, 0.0018891472136601806, 0.002548913937062025, -0.00882729422301054, 0.02871018275618553, 0.01219221018254757, -0.007642725482583046, -0.02227529138326645, 0.04533056542277336, -0.004517545457929373, -0.02115391194820404, 0.0006183258374221623, -0.02455839142203331, 0.014279299415647984, 0.012636921368539333, -0.021851707249879837, 0.030296016484498978, -0.013745990581810474, -0.004941675812005997, -0.02437610924243927, -0.0772421583533287, -0.01690763421356678, 0.06313342601060867, -0.0031000126618891954, 0.07080354541540146, 0.03201530873775482, 0.02992844022810459, -0.013938549906015396, 0.001870654639787972, -0.007274059113115072, -0.009020695462822914, 0.01953185722231865, 0.015032319352030754, -0.02326931245625019, 0.004893230274319649, 0.02614312246441841, -0.009545900858938694, 0.016073185950517654, 0.036861542612314224, 0.021948272362351418, 0.03375910222530365, 0.017372339963912964, -0.017547868192195892, -0.04087147116661072, 0.07826874405145645, -0.0317036509513855, 0.00783300306648016, -0.030414843931794167, -0.05834958702325821, 0.030330320820212364, 0.025279127061367035, -0.029649991542100906, -0.07439091801643372, -0.04216012731194496, -0.02835710160434246, 0.022921718657016754, 0.012882949784398079, -0.013245942071080208, 0.04826589301228523, -0.016932278871536255, 0.019718119874596596, 0.010325990617275238, 0.021253935992717743, -0.03210289403796196, -0.08295498788356781, -0.044579435139894485, -0.044463615864515305, -0.05495123192667961, 0.012512873858213425, 0.033612146973609924, -0.029560914263129234, 0.0019159311195835471, -0.02406642772257328, 0.007216599769890308, 0.00442513357847929, 0.02887759543955326, 0.0033424438443034887, 0.07526993006467819, -0.010388214141130447, 0.036277301609516144, 0.018067196011543274, 0.008888954296708107, 0.1199864000082016, 0.05567556247115135, 0.023852849379181862, -0.05958551913499832, 0.05456094071269035, 0.009590447880327702, 0.0018645040690898895, -0.052414633333683014, 0.04588938131928444, 0.013966139405965805, -0.004237680695950985, -0.022098377346992493, 0.025861099362373352, 0.041041724383831024, -0.02059491164982319, 0.05643694847822189, -0.034109536558389664, -0.04549405723810196, 0.019051723182201385, 0.015862446278333664, -0.013985858298838139, -0.01746882125735283, -0.03688028082251549, 0.006296571809798479, 0.024167174473404884, 0.0038427039980888367, -0.015430938452482224, -0.011639395728707314, -0.033921487629413605, 0.004035457037389278, -0.0017062448896467686, -0.019124554470181465, 0.02481648325920105, -0.026441136375069618, -0.0013306201435625553, -0.012855011969804764, 0.03193947672843933, -0.018299566581845284, 0.016303541138768196, 0.003140996443107724, -0.01311494130641222, -0.024203049018979073, 0.004293852020055056, -0.013129524886608124, -0.020088903605937958, -0.04814224690198898, -0.023678526282310486, 0.027022598311305046, -0.02074909210205078, -0.004549161996692419, -0.014740764163434505, 0.0007987668504938483, -0.02234317548573017, -0.05335375294089317, 0.024474263191223145, 0.019452640786767006, 0.03921746835112572, -0.01685457117855549, -0.060376569628715515, -0.004396448843181133, 0.01887521892786026, -0.012279556132853031, 0.05155768617987633, 0.03244927525520325, -0.02954181656241417, -0.06043444946408272, -0.06429507583379745, 0.027034014463424683, 0.020435964688658714, -0.01829126663506031, -0.005237207747995853, 0.007866988889873028, -0.03821306303143501, -0.034958887845277786, -0.05519751086831093, 0.015193179249763489, 0.018958844244480133, -0.002684085164219141, 0.02292689122259617, -0.024271050468087196, -0.017759406939148903, 0.023339973762631416, -0.03339800983667374, -0.014325465075671673, -0.038294363766908646, -0.0049564349465072155, 0.0370880626142025, 0.049829643219709396, 0.002365654334425926, 0.02796207182109356, -0.0032466112170368433, 0.011748782359063625, 0.030618848279118538, -0.042784783989191055, 0.0062064821831882, 0.02480103261768818, -0.049394115805625916, 0.0074485125951468945, 0.03511049598455429, 0.07635270804166794, 0.012949462048709393, -0.00531713105738163, -0.0046670627780258656, 0.02685346081852913, -0.005521966610103846, 0.006245806813240051, -0.020547624677419662, -0.035826846957206726, -0.008926820941269398, -0.0007772675598971546, 0.005834755953401327, -0.025680895894765854, -0.02756710723042488, -0.022818803787231445, -0.013639342039823532, 0.020141921937465668, 0.009532766416668892, -0.012773011811077595, 0.00748576270416379, -0.0374956838786602, 0.008401483297348022, -0.022625407204031944, 0.038570381700992584, 0.012919988483190536, 0.011358213610947132, -0.03782336786389351, 0.0058791907504200935, -0.054983772337436676, 0.016361527144908905, -0.017109669744968414, 0.009453590959310532, 0.02620638906955719, -0.008765319362282753, 0.003001716686412692, -0.014553727582097054, -0.01335663627833128, -0.008047965355217457, 0.03825806453824043, -0.0011767789255827665, -0.04623935744166374, 0.04638189077377319, -0.04497427120804787, -0.026877621188759804, 0.009838982485234737, 0.01567985862493515, 0.04863165691494942, 0.003975305240601301, -0.003612883621826768, -0.011137783527374268, 0.04338887706398964, -0.029551168903708458, -0.023784175515174866, 0.0023508972954005003, -0.004530970938503742, 0.006310220342129469, 0.03186512738466263, 0.03123881109058857, 0.01866874098777771, -0.008480741642415524, 0.01838131807744503, 0.06476207822561264, 0.0031808693893253803, 0.0038189219776540995, 0.026050765067338943, -0.00848702434450388, 0.015608787536621094, -0.010107919573783875, 0.013892960734665394, 0.03303084149956703, 0.05003602057695389, -0.035447753965854645, 0.03978653624653816, -0.026006197556853294, 0.007948573678731918, -0.06294949352741241, -0.019515426829457283, 0.004792924039065838, -0.011101382784545422, 0.06324618309736252, -0.02075052447617054, 0.05233142524957657, 0.01585480198264122, -0.013263248838484287, 0.031506191939115524, 0.004667875822633505, -0.02060806006193161, -0.005201214458793402, -0.0044226935133337975, -0.024855170398950577, 0.05392669886350632, 0.01956549473106861, -0.0009989122627303004, 0.06745876371860504, -0.00041216908721253276, 0.009201748296618462, -0.0014264460187405348, -0.0027553504332900047, 0.037899527698755264, 0.003964051604270935, -0.056699808686971664, 0.05791350454092026, -0.039037879556417465, -0.041371703147888184, 0.05346490815281868, 0.03600912541151047, 0.035362355411052704, -0.002628380199894309, 0.026469942182302475, 0.024228164926171303, 0.03494175896048546, 0.034984685480594635, -0.01318960078060627, -0.00007957024354254827, 0.027691682800650597, 0.04346587136387825, 0.02929903194308281, -0.010105513967573643, 0.024027202278375626, 0.0012102846521884203, -0.018364090472459793, -0.06889242678880692, 0.014001724310219288, -0.004603163804858923, -0.01276328694075346, -0.0030818269588053226, -0.04018924757838249, 0.008798467926681042, -0.015524765476584435, -0.0012568340171128511, -0.035114262253046036, 0.00716063380241394, 0.049637310206890106, -0.03932095691561699, 0.0008851808379404247, -0.0036146061029285192, -0.008036504499614239, -0.046948257833719254, 0.03339482843875885, 0.0015708566643297672, -0.032225605100393295, -0.05018153414130211, 0.026177309453487396, 0.006179837975651026, -0.010766709223389626, -0.042804814875125885, -0.02878613770008087, -0.04895634576678276, 0.025576230138540268, -0.0037429840303957462, 0.00025626635761000216, 0.023570489138364792, -0.0068119424395263195, 0.0039345077238976955, -0.06720936298370361, 0.0869598314166069, 0.01802898570895195, -0.03131801262497902, -0.026451032608747482, -0.03388798609375954, -0.021855393424630165, -0.008325718343257904, 0.06427084654569626, -0.013719260692596436, -0.025938302278518677, -0.046993765980005264, 0.020987635478377342, 0.000361103710019961, -0.041574977338314056, 0.04187265783548355, 0.012518917210400105, -0.02680531144142151, -0.04062982276082039, 0.011214292608201504, 0.017556965351104736, -0.01465623639523983, 0.01196272112429142, -0.02868584170937538, 0.004872893914580345, -0.006043301895260811, 0.002913055010139942, 0.03924046829342842, 0.012854025699198246, -0.015127857215702534, 0.04511557146906853, -0.0005490813637152314, 0.04264817759394646, 0.050845883786678314, 0.000007842981176509056, -0.030094580724835396, 0.029635701328516006, -0.010215806774795055, -0.0002699201868381351, 0.0015523183392360806, -0.006797128356993198, -0.007361784111708403, -0.06910973787307739, 0.0049399868585169315, 0.07644718885421753, -0.02972058579325676, 0.013848408125340939, 0.05482643097639084, 0.011134902015328407, 0.02716587856411934, 0.011222338303923607, 0.01648891158401966, -0.0022137961350381374, -0.017659394070506096, 0.0026581487618386745, 0.02033109962940216, 0.08425390720367432, -0.007973208092153072, 0.05417604371905327, 0.04776301234960556, -0.011258491314947605, 0.05090859532356262, 0.006156404037028551, 0.05104515329003334, -0.04199294373393059, 0.021958956494927406, -0.0006465992191806436, 0.002669179579243064, 0.015132589265704155, 0.014296903274953365, -0.015665387734770775, 0.0531180165708065, 0.0016487638931721449, -0.012939694337546825, -0.019268175587058067, -0.0008243042975664139, -0.05846814438700676, -0.026709651574492455, 0.0068341814912855625, 0.04426487907767296, 0.0403253398835659, -0.0016623858828097582, 0.010348883457481861, 0.007108437363058329, 0.0032756261061877012, -0.02771240845322609, 0.05021064355969429, -0.020142344757914543, 0.02535797655582428, 0.008072426542639732, 0.005269963294267654, -0.02285788767039776, -0.011610705405473709, 0.015192755497992039, 0.02442595362663269, 0.05323265492916107, 0.005837162956595421, -0.036748021841049194, -0.023479580879211426, 0.029397813603281975, -0.060905829071998596, -0.004473629407584667, -0.05525274574756622, 0.03150048851966858, -0.016956163570284843, -0.033308807760477066 ]
<p>I am doing a regression analysis which troubled me. </p> <p>My independent variable are 4 interplanetary condition components, and the dependent variable is the latitude of auroral oval boundary. So far, the specific relationship is still unknown in physical principle, what we want to do is to get a model (function expression) from the massive data which shows how these independent variables affect the dependent variable.</p> <p>I used the Matlab statistical toolbox to do the regression analysis, but the results were very bad. The p values of the F statistic and t statistic are very small, but the R² is also very low, about 20%. </p> <p>So how should I improve the R²? Are there good methods? I see that SVM (or LS-SVM) can do regression anaysis, is it a good way to manage the massive data, multiple independent variables regression anaysis?</p> <p>The following are the results:</p> <pre><code>mdl = Linear regression model: y ~ 1 + x1*x2 + x1*x3 + x1*x4 + x2*x3 + x2*x4 + x1^2 + x2^2 + x3^2 + x4^2 Number of observations: 18471, Error degrees of freedom: 18457 Root Mean Squared Error: 2.44 R-squared: 0.225, Adjusted R-Squared 0.225 F-statistic vs. constant model: 413, p-value = 0 </code></pre> <p>when we add another predictor, i.e., the independent variables become 5, the resuts of the regression analysis are:</p> <p>Linear regression model:</p> <pre><code>y ~ 1 + x1*x2 + x1*x3 + x1*x4 + x1*x5 + x2*x3 + x2*x4 + x2*x5 + x3*x5 + x2^2 + x3^2 + x4^2 + x5^2 </code></pre> <p>Number of observations: 18457, Error degrees of freedom: 18439 Root Mean Squared Error: 2.21 R-squared: 0.366, Adjusted R-Squared 0.366 F-statistic vs. constant model: 627, p-value = 0</p>
74,498
[ -0.011694381013512611, 0.008568868041038513, -0.01972493715584278, 0.014886858873069286, 0.04760543629527092, 0.007265718188136816, -0.00454770028591156, -0.023938322439789772, 0.00514212716370821, -0.06042369082570076, 0.027891451492905617, -0.006819475907832384, 0.03793629631400108, 0.04199361056089401, -0.011470300145447254, -0.01991877518594265, 0.050301045179367065, 0.03154664859175682, 0.035473790019750595, -0.020656965672969818, -0.0249666478484869, 0.023998932912945747, -0.008068053983151913, -0.020478328689932823, -0.0191207155585289, 0.08316216617822647, 0.054163623601198196, -0.01701856590807438, -0.0007517954218201339, 0.036359723657369614, -0.01712740771472454, -0.01076070312410593, 0.04293881729245186, 0.017760377377271652, 0.015697231516242027, 0.02200116403400898, -0.0026279964949935675, -0.01611318811774254, 0.033740561455488205, 0.05143069848418236, -0.025707202032208443, -0.024529965594410896, -0.021760165691375732, 0.017905453220009804, -0.006744271144270897, -0.005149709526449442, 0.019753864035010338, -0.012256830930709839, 0.057254958897829056, -0.04371652379631996, 0.09484350681304932, 0.010104627348482609, 0.057618074119091034, 0.0020877139177173376, -0.03083096258342266, -0.02424781210720539, 0.05211929976940155, 0.07239072024822235, 0.03605328127741814, -0.050600793212652206, -0.01858546957373619, -0.008133004419505596, -0.0007136929198168218, -0.03408223018050194, -0.009138993918895721, 0.029688337817788124, -0.0304409209638834, 0.024870090186595917, -0.0011225356720387936, 0.023483920842409134, 0.02223224565386772, -0.02375270612537861, -0.007051725871860981, 0.009214584715664387, -0.009947211481630802, 0.004265711642801762, -0.0069436244666576385, 0.03441992402076721, 0.025498878210783005, 0.011273602955043316, 0.001390079502016306, 0.008468471467494965, 0.009737039916217327, 0.00922392774373293, 0.034231167286634445, 0.015265894122421741, 0.02251557819545269, 0.0019239046378061175, 0.024697942659258842, 0.027704020962119102, -0.031716637313365936, 0.018183482810854912, 0.047826528549194336, 0.01346784457564354, -0.059704627841711044, 0.014981326647102833, -0.005403577350080013, 0.03180399909615517, 0.00864301435649395, 0.00640976894646883, 0.004579360596835613, -0.033489059656858444, -0.04134024679660797, 0.047598812729120255, -0.009069213643670082, -0.028757769614458084, -0.02474578097462654, -0.026689663529396057, -0.005682931747287512, -0.043173596262931824, -0.0009858707198873162, 0.017141686752438545, 0.002079759258776903, -0.042877741158008575, -0.026822324842214584, -0.0224594846367836, -0.006313219200819731, -0.0017330340342596173, 0.04293455183506012, 0.0659976452589035, 0.027728211134672165, -0.01778401993215084, 0.026457807049155235, -0.01799599826335907, -0.017581257969141006, 0.02749600261449814, 0.005867458414286375, -0.013304993510246277, -0.022269975394010544, 0.04186984524130821, 0.010603117756545544, -0.039723314344882965, 0.007181203458458185, -0.03853601589798927, 0.03405735269188881, 0.020866133272647858, -0.07259304076433182, -0.04943874105811119, 0.04530506581068039, -0.01980247162282467, 0.012193037196993828, -0.018525056540966034, -0.00506833428516984, 0.027620157226920128, 0.08017637580633163, 0.01775440014898777, 0.048268381506204605, 0.017217162996530533, 0.038917914032936096, 0.01117982342839241, -0.05645228177309036, 0.00978371687233448, -0.05794322118163109, -0.023366205394268036, -0.060973186045885086, -0.07664761692285538, -0.007855595089495182, 0.00923989713191986, -0.03320114314556122, 0.06434530764818192, 0.026277441531419754, 0.02857734076678753, 0.022351039573550224, 0.006350223906338215, -0.024256059899926186, -0.024306604638695717, 0.07354559749364853, -0.0001613408385310322, 0.06216759979724884, 0.025931159034371376, 0.009211888536810875, 0.01337906252592802, 0.025188498198986053, 0.009275178425014019, 0.04875972494482994, 0.0013953505549579859, -0.01016409695148468, -0.018488774076104164, -0.005273604765534401, 0.002020050771534443, -0.08013447374105453, -0.07269024848937988, -0.007866742089390755, 0.0054235877469182014, -0.0035048495046794415, 0.0904470905661583, 0.0006334547069855034, -0.031739331781864166, 0.0693536251783371, -0.05949045717716217, -0.01161279622465372, -0.026433473452925682, 0.0024605325888842344, -0.016034875065088272, -0.014480932615697384, 0.024250639602541924, -0.028116310015320778, 0.014720305800437927, 0.018208349123597145, 0.007512600161135197, -0.01350063644349575, 0.04776689037680626, 0.07403741031885147, -0.00916739460080862, 0.026108141988515854, 0.04141413792967796, 0.032065991312265396, -0.0029029573779553175, -0.015311173163354397, -0.03199777379631996, -0.018134893849492073, 0.005658565554767847, -0.03305221349000931, 0.004570972174406052, -0.019028473645448685, -0.030916603282094002, 0.004913676995784044, -0.011161817237734795, -0.021166939288377762, -0.0030195284634828568, -0.01937711052596569, 0.06264596432447433, 0.02262619324028492, 0.025516759604215622, 0.032846495509147644, 0.0069887675344944, 0.014017445966601372, 0.04112713411450386, -0.01994590274989605, 0.012951002456247807, -0.05939587950706482, 0.001415872946381569, 0.07634475827217102, -0.0007217174861580133, -0.018138812854886055, 0.005679364316165447, 0.06952942162752151, 0.025148771703243256, 0.0035416348837316036, 0.006908070761710405, -0.021522851660847664, 0.004804270341992378, 0.005445488728582859, 0.007939858362078667, 0.03409380093216896, -0.00426099868491292, 0.016625553369522095, 0.02135874144732952, 0.015155965462327003, -0.023203125223517418, -0.00477652158588171, 0.03768111765384674, -0.0063193547539412975, -0.019175035879015923, -0.029439648613333702, 0.008917191997170448, 0.03268701583147049, -0.02489844523370266, -0.01136702485382557, 0.04570819064974785, 0.016067227348685265, 0.014428265392780304, -0.027425117790699005, 0.000664550403598696, 0.006285617593675852, -0.014474893920123577, -0.011247100308537483, 0.014660955406725407, 0.011366956867277622, -0.05878612771630287, -0.025058550760149956, -0.011387266218662262, -0.045073289424180984, -0.0496329627931118, 0.02015042118728161, 0.032538898289203644, 0.0103591438382864, -0.013795612379908562, 0.010052355006337166, 0.014286711812019348, -0.0021684858947992325, 0.008034287951886654, 0.011837086640298367, -0.00687058363109827, -0.05155991390347481, 0.01350761204957962, -0.051208771765232086, 0.008931336924433708, 0.026591919362545013, -0.026356244459748268, -0.03783072158694267, 0.014053460210561752, -0.032065000385046005, -0.07016407698392868, -0.04014555737376213, -0.04176904261112213, 0.002409585751593113, -0.03762529790401459, -0.017918990924954414, 0.054593175649642944, -0.034484174102544785, -0.02082853391766548, 0.026799630373716354, -0.05264216661453247, -0.0100652314722538, -0.006852102931588888, -0.015503909438848495, -0.000527496449649334, -0.013769431039690971, 0.03915880247950554, -0.016113555058836937, -0.0021729355212301016, 0.02555520087480545, -0.03342984616756439, -0.03480921685695648, -0.0029859812930226326, -0.006088802590966225, 0.020275842398405075, -0.04127811640501022, -0.0473339706659317, 0.059857144951820374, 0.05231719836592674, -0.01921703666448593, -0.052194323390722275, 0.03806972876191139, -0.035892803221940994, -0.0141431400552392, -0.000051601055020000786, 0.01522685308009386, 0.046688493341207504, 0.005925378296524286, -0.033966414630413055, 0.013875081203877926, 0.016070380806922913, 0.014874557964503765, -0.0267731174826622, 0.05457805097103119, 0.0007839243626222014, 0.011283722706139088, 0.07570727914571762, 0.05066738277673721, -0.0007815907592885196, 0.037920206785202026, 0.02513895370066166, -0.0006960163009352982, 0.020805615931749344, -0.06543038040399551, -0.00974043644964695, -0.016186801716685295, 0.01500194612890482, -0.0005224280757829547, -0.04063227400183678, 0.018178744241595268, -0.02609064243733883, -0.008466875180602074, 0.024957695975899696, 0.048841968178749084, 0.023711852729320526, -0.02775089256465435, 0.053879447281360626, 0.01328953169286251, 0.016169963404536247, 0.022789007052779198, -0.025777220726013184, 0.0020955512300133705, 0.038740064948797226, -0.040280867367982864, -0.014451860450208187, 0.012303225696086884, 0.01772124506533146, 0.02442687749862671, -0.0007553352625109255, -0.03322736918926239, -0.0038026038091629744, -0.058195099234580994, -0.005701531656086445, -0.07516767829656601, 0.056472163647413254, 0.01662362739443779, 0.02744191512465477, -0.004253027494996786, -0.04352308809757233, 0.04419976472854614, 0.004816284403204918, -0.07479657977819443, 0.022320814430713654, 0.009281710721552372, -0.018294915556907654, 0.024838725104928017, -0.005133375525474548, 0.02361559309065342, -0.03616812452673912, 0.04657893627882004, -0.02632010728120804, 0.006380949169397354, -0.023527363315224648, 0.014324107207357883, 0.012608351185917854, 0.011201680637896061, -0.047391269356012344, 0.030226828530430794, 0.03623367100954056, -0.02898234874010086, 0.044101495295763016, 0.012119440361857414, -0.012041179463267326, -0.008409254252910614, -0.03689487278461456, -0.005124752409756184, 0.035966284573078156, 0.034149687737226486, -0.01505412720143795, -0.01086441334336996, -0.0278989989310503, -0.023930221796035767, -0.011067517101764679, -0.00941498763859272, 0.04724689945578575, 0.01512754987925291, -0.0052568065002560616, -0.01060077827423811, -0.015345150604844093, 0.04271077364683151, 0.015019592829048634, -0.0036728784907609224, 0.02526533417403698, 0.05441414937376976, -0.0023008338175714016, -0.02799585834145546, -0.01743156462907791, 0.051467519253492355, -0.021705755963921547, -0.008580758236348629, -0.04463495314121246, -0.03569972142577171, -0.01798463985323906, -0.006999427452683449, 0.028538400307297707, -0.008190037682652473, -0.051086969673633575, -0.04028046131134033, 0.021381434053182602, 0.00215060543268919, -0.03148132935166359, 0.005534093827009201, 0.008466560393571854, 0.01457997877150774, -0.008547905832529068, -0.04733497276902199, 0.03197026997804642, 0.028830265626311302, 0.027616506442427635, -0.0010793495457619429, 0.007835480384528637, -0.10887149721384048, 0.01551701407879591, 0.002776685170829296, 0.05119458585977554, -0.02159273996949196, -0.018695076927542686, -0.05631735548377037, 0.004537764471024275, -0.007923036813735962, -0.0449807271361351, 0.00019540231733117253, -0.0122224697843194, 0.029485009610652924, -0.0435650609433651, -0.042659394443035126, -0.0854860246181488, 0.019174298271536827, -0.029816100373864174, 0.02687380649149418, -0.0704682394862175, -0.0076893400400877, -0.014849014580249786, 0.03141500800848007, 0.028034688904881477, 0.03048527054488659, 0.019685562700033188, -0.03881189972162247, 0.01015092246234417, 0.04219098016619682, -0.011953432112932205, -0.061215560883283615, 0.012352248653769493, 0.029242748394608498, -0.04215477406978607, 0.039995674043893814, -0.0026692000683397055, -0.050888869911432266, 0.03385945037007332, 0.039219360798597336, -0.00742162112146616, -0.02871439792215824, -0.048991378396749496, 0.03861633315682411, 0.038247160613536835, -0.010279570706188679, 0.07112523913383484, 0.021328840404748917, -0.0295083150267601, -0.015280631370842457, -0.03290620073676109, -0.004763016942888498, 0.006894534919410944, -0.02733568474650383, -0.04476996883749962, 0.009945100173354149, 0.007587549276649952, 0.014161310158669949, -0.007234314456582069, 0.02219606190919876, -0.02995029278099537, -0.006835975684225559, 0.027202844619750977, 0.008649476803839207, -0.032763831317424774, -0.02137659676373005, -0.02439533919095993, 0.005291549488902092, -0.02249707281589508, -0.03435080125927925, -0.0057856193743646145, -0.02418704703450203, 0.0016030898550525308, 0.019568976014852524, -0.04044058546423912, -0.017411233857274055, -0.014134276658296585, -0.06035451963543892, -0.03092549927532673, -0.025457728654146194, 0.044087961316108704, -0.030733441933989525, 0.016795489937067032, 0.019995873793959618, -0.02341964654624462, 0.010940497741103172, 0.014672505669295788, 0.013415366411209106, 0.05059221759438515, -0.015472731553018093, -0.005668116267770529, -0.0034404564648866653, 0.016236437484622, -0.05449480190873146, -0.035267457365989685, 0.022345298901200294, -0.011443976312875748, -0.06283890455961227, -0.022415636107325554, -0.03524986281991005, -0.034586478024721146, -0.02209620550274849, -0.008267744444310665, 0.03749919682741165, -0.03881582245230675, -0.02392280101776123, -0.006009184755384922, 0.02454039826989174, 0.08494268357753754, -0.03709953650832176, -0.005472152028232813, 0.012200034223496914, -0.007194703444838524, -0.02768890932202339, -0.0011007707798853517, -0.01162329874932766, -0.028725523501634598, -0.04542207345366478, -0.029108045622706413, 0.005637678317725658, 0.008921059779822826, 0.003855274524539709, -0.013027030974626541, 0.01473588403314352, 0.016254885122179985, -0.006743865553289652, -0.014277930371463299, 0.016010649502277374, -0.006631652358919382, 0.000819689710624516, 0.026282815262675285, 0.0005396886263042688, -0.010000179521739483, 0.009538534097373486, -0.010858212597668171, -0.03883085399866104, -0.0044582379050552845, 0.007884937338531017, 0.05479998141527176, 0.02670840546488762, 0.02516370825469494, 0.002455062000080943, 0.004763870500028133, 0.031304068863391876, -0.005051723215728998, 0.03902033716440201, 0.01730133220553398, 0.034825216978788376, -0.05573216453194618, -0.04775933921337128, -0.053559646010398865, -0.0020282180048525333, 0.06192529574036598, -0.03216065838932991, 0.014731526374816895, 0.02168981358408928, 0.022800467908382416, -0.034037020057439804, -0.007446991745382547, 0.008247427642345428, -0.00818211492151022, -0.008778132498264313, 0.06782213598489761, -0.017846327275037766, -0.010359068401157856, 0.02023228071630001, 0.02910500578582287, -0.029340507462620735, 0.030128896236419678, 0.008384138345718384, 0.01835927553474903, 0.029477614909410477, -0.06221766397356987, -0.06384757161140442, -0.008548557758331299, -0.04437769204378128, 0.012075651437044144, -0.00556389894336462, 0.034649986773729324, 0.06615807116031647, 0.0487009696662426, 0.013965604826807976, -0.0746811032295227, -0.028647301718592644, -0.05275329574942589, 0.009619753807783127, 0.06085999682545662, -0.01116070244461298, 0.03677624836564064, 0.02107778750360012, 0.008607158437371254, 0.010888130404055119, 0.015591481700539589, -0.04467541724443436, -0.07916612923145294, -0.033379700034856796, -0.004692427814006805, -0.03934122249484062, 0.09106718003749847, -0.022440064698457718, -0.03766573593020439, 0.016900794580578804, -0.017220444977283478, 0.02587694302201271, 0.04046429321169853, 0.021140826866030693, 0.0147835249081254, 0.057812198996543884, -0.045435577630996704, -0.041516076773405075, -0.011990669183433056, 0.029694553464651108, 0.1200070008635521, 0.09497871994972229, 0.02892153337597847, -0.04875776916742325, 0.01749776117503643, 0.022396808490157127, 0.01184181310236454, -0.04340003803372383, -0.018842997029423714, -0.040704138576984406, -0.0414242297410965, 0.037385281175374985, 0.002283283043652773, -0.005542186554521322, -0.004185177385807037, 0.028299879282712936, -0.029270565137267113, 0.004039313644170761, -0.014697092585265636, 0.015004833228886127, -0.009025649167597294, -0.005685632117092609, -0.04778629541397095, 0.018509212881326675, -0.01633969508111477, 0.018284916877746582, -0.04062075912952423, -0.030378613620996475, 0.016639459878206253, 0.01972806826233864, -0.0468616709113121, 0.04506153613328934, -0.0025710570625960827, 0.03900885209441185, -0.010939736850559711, 0.02802763506770134, 0.026832837611436844, -0.04847828671336174, -0.006240004673600197, 0.01325897965580225, -0.015853075310587883, -0.011682817712426186, 0.011254001408815384, 0.01789940521121025, -0.012600104324519634, -0.022721095010638237, -0.03299126401543617, 0.062343429774045944, 0.03185096010565758, -0.029656698927283287, 0.0017130844062194228, 0.06123941391706467, -0.02465938776731491, -0.024905791506171227, 0.007198606617748737, 0.019034570083022118, 0.04119659587740898, -0.004247777629643679, -0.002213034313172102, 0.011686024256050587, 0.03899136185646057, 0.004313407465815544, 0.008613793179392815, 0.034203145653009415, -0.015537403523921967, -0.02443835884332657, -0.003910045605152845, 0.07519370317459106, 0.025869937613606453, 0.0015790548641234636, -0.013387847691774368, -0.009501484222710133, -0.012830995954573154, -0.012711125425994396, 0.0448986254632473, -0.011147607117891312, 0.03147336468100548, -0.020987501367926598, -0.05186401680111885, -0.02936875820159912, -0.03224777430295944, 0.044308118522167206, -0.023368466645479202, 0.0170452743768692, -0.030156796798110008, -0.001730507705360651, 0.016997892409563065, 0.017546068876981735, 0.04762585088610649, 0.003995222970843315, 0.000055063486797735095, 0.035293444991111755, 0.005878294352442026, -0.03790084645152092, -0.04984553903341293, 0.005520041100680828, -0.011737941764295101, 0.019552037119865417, -0.00028410350205376744, 0.05274498835206032, 0.02994619496166706, 0.00786078441888094, 0.007661658339202404, 0.05416339635848999, -0.021546853706240654, 0.011450610123574734, 0.00853259302675724, -0.05465586110949516, -0.008098657242953777, -0.023054616525769234, -0.024720443412661552, -0.01599590852856636, 0.015234316699206829, -0.003658967325463891, -0.02687133103609085, 0.006893775891512632, -0.00512285390868783, -0.04332733899354935, 0.05616772919893265, 0.0050955465994775295, 0.028283091261982918, -0.024924028664827347, 0.0025925913359969854, -0.02326427772641182, 0.00940391980111599, -0.013601030223071575, -0.020366542041301727, -0.0328654982149601, 0.00047549180453643203, -0.014112137258052826, 0.006244179327040911, 0.024582432582974434, -0.005388007033616304, 0.01799583062529564, -0.0173316840082407, 0.026743285357952118, -0.007585430983453989, 0.05628364533185959, -0.037064436823129654, -0.00981573760509491, -0.007928276434540749, -0.0451570600271225, -0.038047559559345245, 0.011673483066260815, -0.02258114330470562, 0.05594422668218613, 0.007854815572500229, 0.016347073018550873, -0.03762422874569893, 0.07667891681194305, 0.005312841851264238, -0.01433323509991169, -0.02326182834804058, 0.013674184679985046, 0.031151752918958664, 0.004177411552518606, 0.04090331867337227, -0.009890805929899216, 0.015819920226931572, 0.01654926873743534, 0.049205098301172256, -0.019643090665340424, 0.0130570437759161, 0.04081494361162186, -0.028882332146167755, 0.017578914761543274, -0.006686977576464415, -0.006235076580196619, 0.06016763299703598, -0.006763599347323179, 0.0020171464420855045, 0.03430328145623207, 0.0038729608058929443, 0.05276642367243767, -0.06354136765003204, -0.02578231506049633, -0.022298160940408707, 0.04579857364296913, 0.02600756846368313, -0.09752127528190613, 0.02039608359336853, 0.04118669405579567, -0.02986975386738777, 0.004047235008329153, -0.010206140577793121, -0.017032340168952942, 0.007626676000654697, -0.041290439665317535, -0.03268333896994591, 0.008407903835177422, 0.014407397247850895, 0.03684603050351143, 0.005610206164419651, 0.07923690229654312, 0.006657151505351067, -0.029661282896995544, -0.04150116443634033, 0.0097962049767375, 0.022543497383594513, -0.017916198819875717, 0.02836688794195652, -0.02577010914683342, 0.02241836115717888, 0.02782774344086647, -0.0007942725787870586, 0.020471444353461266, 0.021127790212631226, 0.03272343426942825, 0.030580738559365273, 0.034795310348272324, 0.01296065654605627, -0.007278528530150652, -0.010677709244191647, -0.016529347747564316, 0.020122595131397247, 0.029474124312400818, 0.010931365191936493, 0.04318172112107277, 0.006505764555186033, 0.0024736584164202213, -0.0006426048930734396, 0.014738161116838455, -0.021378740668296814, -0.00135423440951854, 0.021938486024737358, -0.0008550727507099509, -0.017366420477628708, -0.04488859698176384, -0.01934257708489895, -0.03733259439468384, 0.017798062413930893, 0.024032220244407654, 0.021458860486745834, -0.01715267077088356, -0.01203245297074318, -0.019760342314839363, -0.04972231388092041, 0.023828694596886635, -0.03790106996893883, 0.00992974266409874, -0.017492789775133133, -0.00785046722739935, 0.004459870979189873, -0.04099857807159424, -0.03535650297999382, -0.024339409545063972, -0.03976950794458389, 0.041471365839242935, -0.00017096445662900805, 0.004451516550034285, 0.0017202170565724373, -0.029132742434740067, 0.050048746168613434, -0.055517006665468216, 0.05316387116909027, -0.02556183561682701, -0.054382503032684326, 0.01478166040033102, -0.03325079753994942, -0.041144516319036484, 0.010142742656171322, 0.024476362392306328, 0.00945507176220417, 0.033831313252449036, -0.00498803798109293, 0.0222571212798357, 0.02381744422018528, -0.05890220031142235, 0.04766209423542023, 0.03574769198894501, 0.0008165839244611561, 0.001171081094071269, -0.009980924427509308, 0.04544966295361519, 0.010611066594719887, 0.029108237475156784, 0.016287315636873245, 0.018773507326841354, 0.017428625375032425, -0.04849126189947128, -0.01407693512737751, -0.02885068580508232, -0.035131849348545074, 0.05919613316655159, -0.006193380802869797, 0.017528172582387924, 0.033757492899894714, -0.02894456312060356, -0.03593091666698456, 0.004440506920218468, -0.017311859875917435, -0.016608092933893204, 0.012075868435204029, 0.0030505491886287928, -0.010666977614164352, -0.04602339118719101, 0.022356173023581505, 0.03272638097405434, -0.03883558139204979, -0.008870860561728477, 0.04890163615345955, -0.019413907080888748, 0.03133461996912956, -0.009923262521624565, 0.03687737137079239, 0.0047452375292778015, -0.016120607033371925, 0.00748022086918354, -0.0065374174155294895, 0.027416003867983818, 0.06368853151798248, 0.0430259071290493, 0.04133230447769165, 0.02139046974480152, 0.03800371661782265, -0.00833622831851244, 0.031481146812438965, -0.019193166866898537, -0.021692443639039993, 0.007985088974237442, -0.01608479581773281, 0.0086777089163661, -0.010542306117713451, 0.010500364936888218, 0.0718168318271637, -0.04456094652414322, -0.020277706906199455, -0.01579643040895462, -0.01799720712006092, -0.0625109151005745, 0.017084011808037758, -0.00028656545327976346, 0.034476980566978455, 0.012597701512277126, 0.014619206078350544, -0.010791943408548832, -0.004733054433017969, 0.03790027275681496, 0.003468518378213048, 0.002152194269001484, -0.018135858699679375, 0.01575685665011406, 0.030785899609327316, -0.009657853282988071, -0.020981520414352417, -0.053352802991867065, 0.03227830305695534, 0.032233260571956635, 0.025310225784778595, -0.03918803855776787, -0.0042160991579294205, -0.03183473274111748, 0.010497696697711945, -0.06537090241909027, -0.031536802649497986, -0.006476469803601503, 0.030371632426977158, 0.02066841535270214, 0.0003526147629600018 ]
<p>This is a problem from the "7th Kolmogorov Student Olympiad in Probability Theory":</p> <blockquote> <p>Given one observation $X$ from a $\operatorname{Normal}(\mu,\sigma^2)$ distribution with both parameters unknown, give a confidence interval for $\sigma^2$ with a confidence level of at least 99%.</p> </blockquote> <p>It seems to me that this should be impossible. I have the solution, but haven't read it yet. Any thoughts?</p> <p>I'll post the solution in a couple days.</p> <p>[Follow-up edit: Official solution posted below. Cardinal's solution is longer, but gives a better confidence interval. Thanks also to Max and Glen_b for their input.]</p>
37,394
[ -0.03547422215342522, -0.06885542720556259, 0.0066245743073523045, 0.012575230561196804, -0.004587558098137379, 0.008607258088886738, -0.02536838687956333, -0.026804612949490547, -0.0012585234362632036, -0.05362580344080925, 0.059356190264225006, 0.05054458603262901, 0.0346241295337677, 0.052033089101314545, 0.008615168742835522, 0.001339516369625926, -0.028891902416944504, 0.02361994795501232, -0.018017705529928207, 0.0040738326497375965, -0.022381585091352463, 0.018062220886349678, -0.002897336147725582, -0.02003588154911995, 0.006855769082903862, 0.0016150717856362462, 0.0327172577381134, -0.011570636183023453, 0.0032111851032823324, 0.0973723977804184, -0.07693728804588318, -0.04667985066771507, 0.03584679216146469, 0.04191076010465622, 0.01725449599325657, 0.022201426327228546, -0.015159373171627522, -0.027411943301558495, 0.0021907310001552105, 0.01935521513223648, -0.03876899555325508, -0.003571280976757407, 0.04700586572289467, 0.024073684588074684, -0.011619814671576023, 0.016450541093945503, -0.013148595578968525, -0.06648869067430496, 0.040809862315654755, -0.008293410763144493, 0.08180680871009827, -0.0017686414066702127, 0.07945900410413742, 0.023632926866412163, -0.0038758658338338137, -0.016903076320886612, 0.04283689707517624, 0.08665544539690018, -0.0019320198334753513, -0.050398558378219604, -0.013281997293233871, -0.04994435980916023, -0.009166792035102844, 0.008869062177836895, -0.03269258886575699, -0.029267409816384315, -0.01751275733113289, -0.00600651279091835, 0.03688029572367668, -0.0058718714863061905, -0.003126955358311534, 0.04352867230772972, 0.06710205227136612, -0.022601498290896416, 0.013382244855165482, -0.017622308805584908, 0.012725851498544216, 0.01801888272166252, 0.02762412652373314, 0.016094215214252472, 0.001177410245873034, 0.012590985745191574, 0.06840936839580536, 0.02910766191780567, 0.012192871421575546, -0.012393281795084476, 0.0655963122844696, -0.016562292352318764, 0.016426196321845055, 0.03595681115984917, -0.01875978335738182, 0.0185646153986454, 0.03873888775706291, -0.025100557133555412, -0.04429991543292999, 0.054749682545661926, -0.03679782897233963, 0.0447072796523571, 0.001298501854762435, -0.024925777688622475, 0.012200407683849335, -0.03307325020432472, 0.03577052056789398, 0.06800618022680283, 0.008167797699570656, 0.01067353505641222, -0.010517657734453678, 0.00987799372524023, -0.0009907596977427602, -0.0227128304541111, 0.008349200710654259, 0.0331861712038517, -0.0019283455330878496, 0.01190185546875, 0.027936924248933792, -0.009735450148582458, -0.041050102561712265, -0.03289896622300148, 0.03794853016734123, 0.04995320364832878, 0.041139423847198486, 0.010629151947796345, -0.0005030390457250178, -0.02802775613963604, -0.04384057968854904, 0.023758839815855026, 0.03385821729898453, 0.017119426280260086, -0.056195683777332306, 0.058209244161844254, -0.018901830539107323, 0.009204283356666565, 0.017607025802135468, 0.005882090888917446, 0.031209025532007217, -0.02602955512702465, -0.06619852036237717, -0.058180712163448334, 0.018287135288119316, 0.004992512054741383, -0.03372513875365257, -0.06675028800964355, 0.003122613998129964, 0.06953366845846176, 0.04864209517836571, 0.0016531208530068398, 0.04024718701839447, -0.023858683183789253, 0.03526376932859421, 0.022664733231067657, 0.016047703102231026, -0.015850761905312538, -0.011825318448245525, -0.003741653636097908, -0.01533510722219944, -0.040399372577667236, 0.035525135695934296, 0.004680858459323645, -0.013489418663084507, -0.021472003310918808, 0.016413234174251556, -0.002423896687105298, -0.021025704219937325, -0.02161402627825737, 0.03749823197722435, -0.018246373161673546, 0.07257582992315292, 0.019404634833335876, 0.019728371873497963, -0.004016354214400053, 0.013494670391082764, 0.02922927774488926, 0.004298967309296131, 0.023013349622488022, 0.08161680400371552, -0.0619841068983078, -0.04376891627907753, -0.017593462020158768, 0.03524581715464592, 0.028435256332159042, -0.01632010191679001, 0.011972066015005112, -0.0022094042506068945, 0.021198313683271408, 0.009527480229735374, 0.016945866867899895, 0.024005737155675888, -0.024093398824334145, 0.01769178919494152, -0.05642162263393402, -0.019041182473301888, -0.05756145343184471, -0.0069366563111543655, -0.001598738948814571, -0.024983974173665047, 0.03630189225077629, -0.0063799647614359856, -0.0028280396945774555, -0.01990671269595623, -0.05084480345249176, -0.016457494348287582, -0.0005700301262550056, 0.03453780338168144, -0.02198064513504505, 0.033644672483205795, 0.04706510156393051, 0.07063461095094681, -0.026664117351174355, 0.03803069144487381, -0.03985501825809479, -0.03754854574799538, -0.01407315582036972, -0.041789207607507706, 0.0064950017258524895, 0.0145653635263443, 0.007407607976347208, 0.008686093613505363, 0.011083699762821198, -0.000011265218745393213, -0.0032089250162243843, -0.08789914846420288, 0.037624772638082504, 0.04094308614730835, 0.006879143882542849, -0.009825028479099274, 0.01023175660520792, 0.0509813018143177, -0.018386276438832283, -0.010299299843609333, -0.02714574709534645, -0.03367088735103607, -0.019760005176067352, 0.016312630847096443, 0.010742497630417347, -0.045528341084718704, 0.04004422202706337, 0.030262738466262817, 0.02315632812678814, 0.021744107827544212, 0.04960901662707329, 0.031092166900634766, -0.023132555186748505, -0.013176653534173965, -0.00017434914479963481, 0.015655335038900375, 0.04879142343997955, 0.01605476625263691, 0.02652016282081604, 0.015270164236426353, -0.0001223648141603917, -0.015366663224995136, 0.017749950289726257, -0.014737376011908054, -0.0007157393847592175, -0.007630008272826672, 0.005592093337327242, 0.05410459265112877, -0.024340087547898293, 0.030202515423297882, 0.036383017897605896, -0.005190971307456493, 0.02595601975917816, 0.000008667005204188172, 0.019199227914214134, 0.012669230811297894, 0.04045489430427551, -0.026727881282567978, 0.029643597081303596, 0.01984902285039425, -0.018590861931443214, -0.015838509425520897, -0.01297979149967432, 0.013035275042057037, -0.00027294884785078466, 0.006977233104407787, -0.01201881654560566, -0.00920519046485424, 0.003261962439864874, -0.03421385586261749, -0.05016192048788071, 0.003679307410493493, 0.010443668812513351, 0.0010983635438606143, 0.028922680765390396, -0.054717183113098145, 0.00943224597722292, 0.025352254509925842, -0.019861916080117226, 0.010281053371727467, -0.014959877356886864, 0.0031068914104253054, 0.01363217830657959, -0.027319295331835747, -0.06297200173139572, -0.024360697716474533, -0.038412563502788544, -0.008496695198118687, -0.025829261168837547, 0.014057308435440063, 0.04725441709160805, 0.04645790532231331, -0.05770942568778992, 0.032418545335531235, 0.013232836499810219, -0.022475866600871086, -0.07752630859613419, 0.03136351332068443, 0.010714743286371231, -0.01274320762604475, 0.02608787640929222, 0.022379105910658836, 0.029103565961122513, 0.006981926970183849, -0.05431947484612465, -0.06956057995557785, 0.0072797127068042755, 0.009972711093723774, 0.02671692706644535, -0.01497705653309822, -0.0047712079249322414, 0.0776633694767952, 0.01145692728459835, -0.009009008295834064, 0.0014850592706352472, 0.008329307660460472, -0.01923789456486702, -0.027253495529294014, -0.019832737743854523, -0.014174136333167553, -0.020027462393045425, 0.06353200972080231, 0.02025914564728737, -0.015849294140934944, 0.03004046529531479, 0.018645387142896652, -0.006647673435509205, -0.03762887418270111, 0.012714690528810024, -0.03953738883137703, 0.057890646159648895, -0.005408366676419973, -0.0017086436273530126, -0.007882236503064632, 0.006095981691032648, 0.006522940006107092, 0.049623239785432816, -0.027081817388534546, 0.030705541372299194, -0.06324078887701035, 0.012401137501001358, -0.062223438173532486, 0.028960954397916794, 0.028740229085087776, -0.027711980044841766, -0.007068745791912079, 0.003332528518512845, 0.04542110115289688, -0.03082786500453949, -0.014356490224599838, 0.058837465941905975, 0.03513488173484802, -0.004831524100154638, -0.02684250846505165, 0.0005646295030601323, 0.001290386775508523, 0.010040517896413803, -0.04540075734257698, -0.0037025511264801025, -0.0077887331135571, 0.04309337958693504, 0.019710645079612732, -0.0033394123893231153, -0.011117136105895042, -0.027089310809969902, -0.05689964070916176, 0.02553735487163067, -0.03206309303641319, 0.00763360969722271, -0.007656571920961142, 0.04409373179078102, 0.02496997080743313, -0.027603749185800552, 0.0018524222541600466, 0.02438250184059143, -0.10201110690832138, 0.03617796301841736, -0.03961890935897827, -0.047348570078611374, 0.03244619444012642, -0.017497384920716286, 0.03101005032658577, -0.016514888033270836, 0.007026854902505875, -0.011854162439703941, 0.03702615574002266, -0.04640054702758789, 0.01661340333521366, -0.05008839815855026, -0.0420791357755661, -0.0006165397353470325, 0.01598222739994526, 0.014509707689285278, -0.030243638902902603, 0.025475047528743744, 0.007866677828133106, -0.012627813033759594, -0.01807156577706337, -0.03636316955089569, -0.0041947015561163425, 0.0018495359690859914, 0.0440378412604332, 0.006111554801464081, 0.0327422060072422, 0.0015950119122862816, -0.0018139273161068559, -0.0009786424925550818, 0.06692522764205933, 0.031638387590646744, -0.015434876084327698, 0.005474456585943699, -0.005038018338382244, -0.030603377148509026, -0.0056409891694784164, 0.013939756900072098, -0.018967973068356514, 0.010315774008631706, 0.048854127526283264, 0.01917852833867073, -0.027675539255142212, 0.029045697301626205, 0.06802528351545334, 0.02217012643814087, 0.013845051638782024, -0.008568568155169487, 0.006199032999575138, -0.017008818686008453, 0.002135713119059801, -0.024933665990829468, 0.0149622717872262, 0.014061839319765568, -0.029263315722346306, 0.027221430093050003, -0.013033324852585793, -0.00019838013395201415, 0.022044934332370758, 0.022644268348813057, 0.047260310500860214, 0.0008328918484039605, -0.004383874125778675, -0.0007734740502201021, 0.013909627683460712, 0.036407895386219025, 0.004272522870451212, 0.009041859768331051, -0.05197102576494217, 0.004240133799612522, 0.023624490946531296, 0.054441504180431366, -0.0002800084766931832, -0.008229050785303116, -0.045961447060108185, 0.013717444613575935, 0.04807346686720848, -0.04077694192528725, 0.03306407853960991, -0.013444289565086365, -0.017685040831565857, 0.002773334039375186, -0.022308170795440674, -0.05479249730706215, -0.02041495405137539, 0.0057291509583592415, 0.003358098678290844, -0.009425794705748558, -0.01735224574804306, -0.041208717972040176, -0.004136169329285622, 0.05390314757823944, 0.07348315417766571, 0.024031709879636765, -0.021970896050333977, 0.005624437239021063, 0.01601065695285797, -0.05153004080057144, -0.06342356652021408, 0.009620008990168571, -0.01608469896018505, -0.0015279068611562252, 0.01983342319726944, -0.049416620284318924, -0.03488548472523689, 0.06240939721465111, -0.0036154768895357847, -0.04492730647325516, 0.008071725256741047, 0.005910263862460852, 0.02155224233865738, 0.06066571921110153, 0.02575712278485298, 0.04303263500332832, -0.003474233439192176, 0.018903259187936783, -0.000288974930299446, -0.045385073870420456, 0.010676548816263676, -0.011395469307899475, 0.010896222665905952, -0.02742994762957096, 0.0029831656720489264, -0.01763901300728321, 0.00653809541836381, 0.0033331839367747307, 0.032366421073675156, -0.003500135149806738, 0.007676611188799143, 0.003717646934092045, 0.008854367770254612, 0.006784264929592609, 0.010475789196789265, -0.025130020454525948, 0.02347916178405285, -0.018595457077026367, -0.009566177614033222, 0.005141988396644592, -0.04318217560648918, 0.027922403067350388, 0.016415471211075783, -0.04565441235899925, 0.060835570096969604, -0.06125506013631821, -0.0577838309109211, -0.01803845912218094, -0.06410633027553558, 0.04554750397801399, -0.03608375042676926, 0.029728155583143234, 0.007264615502208471, -0.04145842790603638, -0.03858692944049835, 0.029072904959321022, 0.007362742442637682, 0.04253344610333443, -0.02453368343412876, 0.0443735234439373, 0.02532055787742138, 0.012142007239162922, -0.08898430317640305, -0.03231634572148323, 0.008287282660603523, -0.0018787890439853072, 0.0048416052013635635, -0.01679948903620243, 0.02030431665480137, 0.0007135344785638154, 0.00003759392348001711, -0.030836086720228195, 0.024379288777709007, 0.015360157005488873, -0.03715330362319946, -0.011100957170128822, 0.022279957309365273, 0.03986046835780144, 0.015596994198858738, 0.01270266342908144, -0.006156405434012413, -0.03474043682217598, -0.01999744586646557, 0.029691055417060852, 0.02850509248673916, -0.005427251569926739, -0.025352628901600838, 0.006941438652575016, -0.010849779471755028, 0.027488024905323982, -0.004935325123369694, -0.02412821352481842, 0.04301852360367775, 0.027048077434301376, -0.015458072535693645, -0.003169952193275094, -0.04948252812027931, -0.0015207084361463785, 0.0031378627754747868, -0.00482036592438817, -0.004417345393449068, -0.008928311988711357, -0.018991781398653984, 0.02172960713505745, 0.0017897040816023946, -0.007326401770114899, -0.024702956900000572, 0.10238884389400482, -0.011713789775967598, -0.024791520088911057, -0.009346289560198784, 0.0036107944324612617, -0.001430559903383255, 0.013371191918849945, -0.005782996769994497, 0.027186250314116478, 0.008398141711950302, -0.06755824387073517, 0.00021381217811722308, 0.0024028378538787365, -0.0006335261277854443, 0.026443110778927803, -0.0014133001677691936, 0.051809296011924744, 0.0012327085714787245, 0.020234663039445877, -0.009777223691344261, -0.01456891093403101, -0.01665893942117691, -0.006060123443603516, 0.012652675621211529, 0.04724634811282158, -0.003827574197202921, -0.006436588242650032, 0.037245772778987885, 0.027665050700306892, 0.027546165511012077, 0.04181265830993652, -0.0032075438648462296, 0.03687325119972229, 0.010267005302011967, -0.015209549106657505, -0.018794231116771698, 0.045669544488191605, -0.0401482954621315, -0.010139523074030876, -0.033862676471471786, -0.003206005087122321, 0.02788594737648964, 0.010977021418511868, -0.011538914404809475, 0.012487035244703293, -0.011195097118616104, -0.07300660014152527, 0.008431660011410713, -0.023007798939943314, 0.011076628230512142, 0.050151847302913666, -0.010502774268388748, 0.011406573466956615, 0.011622658930718899, 0.05866996571421623, -0.06538161635398865, -0.08116134256124496, -0.0423000268638134, -0.0013939704513177276, -0.038640134036540985, 0.023475948721170425, -0.006186653859913349, -0.018758626654744148, 0.03750617429614067, -0.030787523835897446, 0.029437711462378502, 0.010457123629748821, 0.014359542168676853, -0.024620749056339264, 0.07429525256156921, 0.009878269396722317, 0.05057479068636894, -0.01683948002755642, 0.023122960701584816, 0.09537915885448456, 0.08809203654527664, 0.030941128730773926, -0.05161517113447189, 0.008304123766720295, -0.03767610341310501, -0.00935747753828764, -0.027583392336964607, 0.012020252645015717, 0.015817394480109215, -0.03738197311758995, 0.02767406776547432, 0.01601482182741165, 0.023013751953840256, -0.02702675200998783, 0.04555978626012802, -0.008738193660974503, -0.03680294752120972, -0.03160838782787323, -0.0034214677289128304, -0.03945939615368843, -0.033044878393411636, -0.010040855035185814, 0.05451066046953201, -0.03189443051815033, 0.001559457741677761, 0.007225659675896168, -0.06609882414340973, -0.005345763638615608, -0.007806919980794191, -0.014912365935742855, -0.0019260668195784092, 0.026353180408477783, -0.015539354644715786, -0.01567314937710762, 0.008524550125002861, 0.022298764437437057, 0.0024326504208147526, 0.012327374890446663, 0.02527673915028572, 0.013303090818226337, 0.027451980859041214, 0.035078756511211395, -0.0026044719852507114, -0.03638152778148651, -0.04521910101175308, -0.02358122542500496, 0.035732023417949677, -0.0011335905874148011, -0.02421397529542446, -0.0013515445170924067, -0.045467253774404526, -0.03614675626158714, -0.01747749000787735, 0.003388417884707451, 0.016044748947024345, 0.014720240607857704, -0.051386717706918716, -0.012489785440266132, -0.012067289091646671, 0.058597419410943985, -0.018375800922513008, 0.004622241016477346, 0.019857294857501984, -0.039051320403814316, -0.040436383336782455, -0.012442050501704216, 0.05198640748858452, 0.016019154340028763, -0.023353973403573036, 0.009086026810109615, -0.037926528602838516, -0.016700807958841324, -0.009801045060157776, 0.013802892528474331, -0.03042994625866413, 0.040375202894210815, 0.008577574044466019, 0.006214064080268145, -0.004820722155272961, -0.01947491616010666, -0.0012771792244166136, -0.023443743586540222, 0.0022753896191716194, -0.010283381678164005, -0.00446610851213336, 0.00010356331767980009, 0.024139396846294403, -0.01279999315738678, 0.020041756331920624, 0.038522105664014816, 0.04669392853975296, 0.030154217034578323, -0.07350394129753113, -0.038581088185310364, -0.0073107643984258175, -0.043995656073093414, 0.017162984237074852, 0.014237581752240658, 0.040925219655036926, -0.005526148714125156, 0.04643014073371887, 0.017732679843902588, 0.017451003193855286, -0.03355468064546585, 0.024769188836216927, 0.0179958026856184, -0.04627496749162674, -0.04048147425055504, 0.015345689840614796, 0.045246709138154984, -0.0113750621676445, -0.040333107113838196, -0.02734401449561119, -0.00775304576382041, 0.019351784139871597, -0.011242925189435482, -0.057545606046915054, 0.0022456985898315907, -0.007494968827813864, -0.013558698818087578, 0.004094245377928019, -0.01571669429540634, 0.00021744320110883564, -0.009260314516723156, -0.002428934909403324, -0.0038230428472161293, -0.013469486497342587, 0.013865676708519459, -0.011850967071950436, 0.009569494985044003, 0.0466131716966629, 0.010576415807008743, 0.019805461168289185, -0.006015839520841837, 0.03681211546063423, 0.02129696123301983, 0.06035452336072922, -0.05189920589327812, 0.013294373638927937, 0.03044997528195381, -0.0373724065721035, -0.01085748989135027, 0.02058774046599865, 0.011313811875879765, 0.03177481144666672, 0.0016335913678631186, -0.04313429445028305, -0.016851995140314102, 0.05848833546042442, -0.05122363939881325, 0.011697346344590187, -0.0019739933777600527, -0.002668818924576044, -0.0061429874040186405, -0.021843822672963142, -0.023139588534832, -0.003519331570714712, -0.012356067076325417, 0.019738607108592987, 0.02308339625597, 0.008055124431848526, 0.039642345160245895, 0.021304618567228317, 0.024635475128889084, 0.024260636419057846, -0.005400809925049543, 0.024207815527915955, 0.02944142185151577, 0.05191783607006073, -0.025037428364157677, 0.04954342544078827, -0.009045220911502838, 0.007182402536273003, -0.09738308191299438, 0.0001296422997256741, 0.007974044419825077, 0.02442457340657711, 0.0658702403306961, -0.026394372805953026, 0.026328708976507187, 0.04690532386302948, -0.03285033628344536, -0.04626602306962013, -0.04409291595220566, 0.01609807461500168, -0.014755784533917904, -0.014346848241984844, -0.013933680020272732, 0.018704934045672417, 0.012544914148747921, -0.0007981694652698934, 0.011616570875048637, 0.07205235213041306, 0.00046953780110925436, -0.029777003452181816, 0.0027852675411850214, 0.004698723088949919, -0.0005185893969610333, -0.045693766325712204, 0.020705580711364746, -0.038629718124866486, -0.009268238209187984, 0.012489436194300652, 0.003209930844604969, 0.03926020488142967, -0.005076347850263119, 0.0341014601290226, 0.01819809526205063, 0.04697230085730553, 0.0220787413418293, 0.023516088724136353, 0.009546739980578423, -0.026178382337093353, 0.032409269362688065, 0.02289569191634655, -0.04003627598285675, -0.019440529868006706, 0.02431546524167061, -0.01689685322344303, -0.06420258432626724, 0.04853300005197525, -0.006931661162525415, -0.022569086402654648, 0.013619545847177505, -0.030182987451553345, -0.027424553409218788, -0.04470766335725784, 0.03762637451291084, -0.05060282722115517, -0.0248453039675951, 0.01800117827951908, 0.04440959915518761, -0.018527671694755554, -0.01239472720772028, -0.0026712461840361357, -0.039462193846702576, 0.04460925981402397, -0.021430399268865585, -0.045275621116161346, -0.08764763921499252, -0.01600930094718933, -0.028931668028235435, 0.018456891179084778, 0.03087880276143551, -0.03279469534754753, -0.052704114466905594, 0.05011971294879913, -0.015085465274751186, 0.003936754073947668, 0.02143881656229496, -0.002959124045446515, -0.02213883213698864, -0.10495728999376297, 0.04497586563229561, 0.02835342288017273, -0.01647687330842018, -0.021665357053279877, 0.00015398698451463133, -0.02481083571910858, -0.03218859061598778, 0.024502988904714584, 0.026180928573012352, -0.0026068463921546936, 0.00890426617115736, 0.04028524085879326, 0.02427726238965988, -0.04468560218811035, 0.038196861743927, -0.0315658301115036, -0.00838960986584425, -0.027906762436032295, -0.03384796902537346, 0.00826177466660738, -0.002637235214933753, 0.013416222296655178, -0.005953535903245211, 0.01912008225917816, 0.014701240696012974, 0.01175101101398468, 0.010918216779828072, 0.0260053351521492, -0.016410382464528084, 0.02831208147108555, 0.0012833144282922149, -0.00527166249230504, 0.029128186404705048, 0.015053810551762581, -0.07568984478712082, 0.049494966864585876, -0.04398573935031891, -0.050950147211551666, -0.028048066422343254, 0.01822449266910553, -0.01037279237061739, -0.0761527568101883, -0.024022122845053673, 0.01938231848180294, -0.034108176827430725, -0.01429352629929781, 0.04700761288404465, 0.018022647127509117, 0.04547816887497902, 0.008495445363223553, 0.014718662947416306, 0.014024835079908371, -0.016914526000618935, 0.015371652320027351, 0.0011953175999224186, 0.01626264862716198, -0.031781140714883804, 0.034977804869413376, 0.03254425525665283, -0.023078225553035736, 0.023597830906510353, -0.009131715632975101, 0.019803015515208244, -0.011885363608598709, -0.05941319093108177, 0.0038748595397919416, -0.001248620916157961, 0.034699857234954834, -0.045175857841968536, -0.004540620371699333, 0.0315532386302948, -0.027991807088255882, 0.005134528037160635, -0.07735269516706467, 0.009173490107059479, -0.025807753205299377, 0.01060690451413393, 0.04868971183896065, 0.0008549667545594275, 0.0025248753372579813, 0.006487826816737652, -0.0067170667462050915, 0.023890919983386993, 0.00034980944474227726, -0.029467472806572914, 0.014953933656215668, -0.03386535868048668, 0.005805770866572857, -0.058694664388895035, -0.013955355621874332, -0.0027526244521141052, -0.039409440010786057, 0.028188109397888184, 0.03374331817030907, -0.0026852013543248177, -0.0029410480055958033, -0.07766546308994293, -0.013141618110239506, 0.09751960635185242, -0.05119134858250618, 0.020099323242902756, -0.03380408510565758, 0.026811499148607254, -0.012086721137166023, -0.05125989764928818 ]
<p>Stats noob here. I've been trying to find out if there is a technique to perform a certain type of analysis but so far a lot of searching hasn't yielded anything.</p> <p>My question is, if a large peak or trough is identified in an organisation's overall rate, is there a way of identifying which of the organisation's production sites has contributed the most to this rate change?</p> <p>The data describes an organisation and it's performance against a rate based performance measure (let's say % wastage on a washer production line). The dataset contains 4 fields. These fields are:</p> <ol> <li>Site (There are 100+ of these)</li> <li>Month</li> <li>Numerator (Number of washers lost to wastage)</li> <li>Denominator (Total number of washers produced)</li> </ol> <p>The organisation monitors it's performance based on its overall rate (sum of all numerators / sum of all denominators) by month. This gives a trend line. If there is a sudden large increase/decrease in rate then the organisation wants to target the sites which have most contributed to this rate change.</p> <p>I'm not certain if there is an answer to this question, as one site could see a decrease in denominator and another could see an increase in its numerator value, meaning these sites both show a small change, whilst the organisation as a whole may see a larger scale change when the figures are combined and the overall rate is calculated.</p> <p>I was originally thinking about something like a logistic regression with weighting but wasn't sure if this was quite the way to go...</p>
74,499
[ -0.025374440476298332, -0.019306590780615807, -0.03186771273612976, 0.011873967945575714, 0.027770746499300003, 0.0019618719816207886, 0.001629195990972221, -0.02002888359129429, 0.0463954359292984, -0.03919728100299835, -0.012076773680746555, 0.020631030201911926, 0.042502064257860184, 0.035038601607084274, -0.001408188953064382, 0.030991243198513985, 0.004375920165330172, 0.01190305408090353, -0.0239412821829319, -0.027665428817272186, 0.022694168612360954, -0.008548686280846596, -0.028099678456783295, -0.011529326438903809, -0.04024435207247734, 0.010011237114667892, 0.016293592751026154, -0.018736135214567184, -0.0188894160091877, 0.03150327876210213, 0.013440744951367378, -0.0719861388206482, 0.01846284233033657, 0.0503288172185421, -0.012362735345959663, 0.01737912930548191, -0.01101573184132576, -0.004247289150953293, -0.014755930751562119, 0.07145794481039047, -0.019321609288454056, -0.03418683260679245, 0.017787795513868332, 0.008469440042972565, -0.004931110888719559, 0.025034107267856598, -0.0261787548661232, -0.005875071976333857, 0.03373091667890549, -0.0421888493001461, 0.054420460015535355, -0.012914814986288548, -0.003117678454145789, -0.004815652500838041, -0.040003661066293716, -0.005744336638599634, 0.016345033422112465, 0.04634801298379898, -0.021630723029375076, -0.004110240377485752, -0.023682652041316032, 0.024472786113619804, -0.013028615154325962, -0.011392347514629364, -0.00048059356049634516, 0.009365865960717201, -0.00010125905100721866, -0.019724518060684204, 0.056517355144023895, 0.0007053607259877026, -0.013201909139752388, 0.022818194702267647, 0.04243152216076851, 0.0119182039052248, 0.012354609556496143, -0.05617842450737953, 0.020777108147740364, 0.0029217370320111513, 0.053524162620306015, 0.022454645484685898, -0.033375803381204605, 0.014227474108338356, 0.03993348404765129, 0.05401274561882019, 0.06528803706169128, -0.008142529055476189, 0.039566438645124435, -0.03236665204167366, 0.0063253664411604404, 0.029479926452040672, -0.0012732604518532753, -0.022830717265605927, 0.023265769705176353, 0.010389150120317936, -0.05467208847403526, -0.014192638918757439, -0.022540727630257607, 0.01620456762611866, 0.025666140019893646, 0.02013295702636242, -0.0008312278660014272, -0.04844552278518677, 0.010830920189619064, 0.03254960849881172, -0.005312649998813868, -0.011596553958952427, -0.04101710021495819, -0.010455097071826458, -0.05796477571129799, -0.01420210488140583, -0.0594266802072525, -0.007812135852873325, 0.04336893931031227, -0.011777731589972973, -0.011103692464530468, 0.010496064089238644, -0.010751442052423954, -0.0006616075406782329, 0.05513656884431839, 0.038569044321775436, 0.0310820322483778, -0.013957185670733452, 0.03486694395542145, -0.014408850111067295, -0.06458526104688644, 0.03524596989154816, 0.007199581246823072, -0.02516358345746994, -0.04979447275400162, 0.06515291333198547, 0.013914051465690136, -0.06313976645469666, 0.04968387633562088, -0.015430787578225136, 0.050651270896196365, 0.06694890558719635, -0.06599446386098862, -0.0525243766605854, 0.014770208857953548, -0.018850455060601234, 0.020856712013483047, -0.014982419088482857, -0.05046718195080757, 0.0395578071475029, 0.021851295605301857, 0.06756514310836792, -0.010778241790831089, 0.021457228809595108, 0.002612755633890629, -0.0053725652396678925, -0.007841518148779869, -0.03628198802471161, 0.00294763152487576, -0.03717034310102463, -0.04006089270114899, -0.0643719807267189, 0.0008733869763091207, 0.024120809510350227, 0.013373504392802715, -0.021909145638346672, 0.02798367105424404, 0.04825092479586601, -0.018304163590073586, -0.0017307602101936936, 0.027852538973093033, 0.01634928025305271, 0.0677616074681282, -0.026820937171578407, 0.0028673734050244093, -0.022675249725580215, 0.01714271679520607, 0.022466471418738365, 0.02054181694984436, 0.01987675577402115, 0.056630320847034454, -0.034988608211278915, 0.005377725698053837, -0.012561830691993237, -0.015013336203992367, -0.021792413666844368, -0.03514067828655243, -0.057898394763469696, -0.04468856751918793, 0.002494232030585408, 0.036441538482904434, 0.05069863423705101, -0.017403092235326767, -0.05003649741411209, 0.05175216868519783, -0.055923473089933395, -0.02658700756728649, -0.05948904901742935, 0.005077200010418892, -0.06540250033140182, -0.014007986523211002, 0.016988616436719894, -0.007828475907444954, 0.019527513533830643, -0.02466333843767643, 0.030111802741885185, 0.011082629673182964, -0.015426643192768097, 0.04468396678566933, -0.004109995439648628, -0.03055722266435623, 0.005797059275209904, 0.013841974548995495, -0.022958753630518913, 0.02235451713204384, -0.08195677399635315, -0.03332800790667534, 0.014329277910292149, -0.03270691633224487, -0.025824297219514847, -0.020303884521126747, -0.03584503009915352, 0.01633925549685955, 0.009070966392755508, -0.031112993136048317, 0.009941698983311653, -0.0697963610291481, 0.07220178097486496, 0.045078475028276443, -0.024406760931015015, 0.016289688646793365, 0.00445124227553606, 0.003839016193524003, 0.02076394110918045, -0.020425114780664444, -0.037720102816820145, -0.04083867743611336, 0.027982531115412712, 0.033227887004613876, -0.0012707666028290987, -0.02078014798462391, -0.006993113551288843, 0.04509936645627022, -0.02454782836139202, 0.0032109790481626987, 0.02750396355986595, 0.007382036652415991, 0.02886330336332321, -0.0036417830269783735, 0.017926238477230072, -0.010224289260804653, 0.028521012514829636, 0.006169114727526903, 0.017282741144299507, 0.047900427132844925, 0.00015886942856013775, 0.00006115645373938605, 0.024789802730083466, 0.014598400332033634, 0.018858881667256355, 0.017071222886443138, 0.0010695516830310225, 0.028136592358350754, -0.06245740130543709, 0.010835767723619938, 0.01787853240966797, -0.004625404253602028, 0.011363297700881958, 0.019409429281949997, -0.0325796902179718, 0.03503355756402016, 0.04792208597064018, -0.050335582345724106, 0.007065787445753813, 0.027961816638708115, -0.033399879932403564, 0.0008126850007101893, -0.01711123436689377, -0.009523472748696804, -0.017964454367756844, 0.017915135249495506, 0.042636528611183167, 0.010202869772911072, 0.004302434157580137, -0.04822453111410141, -0.023349251598119736, -0.04842979833483696, -0.02613748051226139, 0.01998748444020748, 0.009453349746763706, -0.00785468053072691, -0.020737972110509872, 0.009820881299674511, -0.04090277850627899, 0.06497984379529953, -0.03786548972129822, -0.025403648614883423, 0.031719088554382324, 0.03710035979747772, -0.0807865560054779, -0.016886724159121513, -0.01123562827706337, 0.04327316954731941, -0.0034409824293106794, 0.026654940098524094, 0.017763443291187286, -0.0026879620272666216, -0.033532727509737015, 0.01429027784615755, -0.059873972088098526, -0.030784089118242264, -0.031906068325042725, 0.0037157635670155287, 0.017739662900567055, 0.008715536445379257, 0.005570502020418644, 0.02590160071849823, 0.012006520293653011, -0.0023360964842140675, -0.04518774524331093, -0.04462508484721184, 0.0009767808951437473, -0.0496465340256691, 0.039122890681028366, -0.02741989679634571, -0.023989573121070862, 0.07208637148141861, 0.06291855126619339, -0.05062123015522957, -0.03047308884561062, -0.0005365930846892297, -0.00652001379057765, -0.01867823302745819, 0.02443377487361431, 0.0013511021388694644, 0.005891087930649519, 0.026889072731137276, -0.004411854315549135, 0.026382269337773323, 0.07405839115381241, 0.01671169325709343, -0.008219116367399693, 0.026149677112698555, -0.0029454990290105343, -0.009423277340829372, 0.004359173122793436, 0.02363700047135353, -0.0430622324347496, 0.05485225468873978, -0.02176235243678093, 0.022038524970412254, 0.012041421607136726, -0.026734016835689545, -0.013718034140765667, 0.000040664603147888556, -0.022339187562465668, 0.0107383131980896, -0.011843239888548851, 0.03533173352479935, -0.0356229692697525, -0.03249583765864372, 0.031014220789074898, 0.04499923437833786, -0.003663908690214157, -0.017298894003033638, 0.04272031411528587, 0.058358434587717056, -0.007321547716856003, -0.013322700746357441, -0.018752101808786392, -0.018509481102228165, -0.0004148634325247258, -0.03873038664460182, -0.03123762086033821, 0.0063643744215369225, 0.023578180000185966, 0.03396856412291527, -0.007575319614261389, -0.036489441990852356, -0.0026192215736955404, -0.08165967464447021, -0.0374625027179718, -0.016637450084090233, 0.05675407871603966, 0.0081173125654459, 0.016958855092525482, 0.023085523396730423, 0.0175998043268919, 0.03715028986334801, 0.008098721504211426, -0.05374026298522949, 0.04103192687034607, 0.018854601308703423, -0.015842420980334282, 0.03045709617435932, -0.0293129850178957, 0.02043457143008709, -0.014219183474779129, -0.010731169022619724, -0.017475765198469162, 0.03398807719349861, -0.03631342947483063, -0.0022699630353599787, -0.04110070690512657, -0.0223990585654974, 0.0031476086005568504, 0.03463595360517502, 0.0006970281829126179, -0.014692653901875019, 0.03760416805744171, 0.010751677677035332, -0.0293527040630579, -0.0026322160847485065, -0.025821464136242867, -0.03098614141345024, -0.0113133005797863, 0.0163178239017725, 0.014020453207194805, 0.028549885377287865, -0.05842740461230278, 0.06637562066316605, 0.0036355634219944477, 0.036404579877853394, 0.03390614315867424, -0.020151477307081223, -0.0306642297655344, -0.019616926088929176, -0.00910983607172966, 0.02334538660943508, -0.003934397362172604, 0.006170615088194609, 0.01364665012806654, 0.0462789423763752, 0.02322329953312874, -0.016406821087002754, -0.016115626320242882, 0.07115969806909561, 0.04403059557080269, 0.026221781969070435, -0.0021974374540150166, -0.023632781580090523, 0.03371846675872803, 0.0011932640336453915, 0.00881055649369955, 0.06952505558729172, 0.006353373639285564, 0.007123481947928667, 0.059547439217567444, 0.0427376963198185, -0.05648910626769066, 0.009657194837927818, 0.008780318312346935, 0.014063718728721142, 0.007929271087050438, -0.03411657363176346, 0.06486643105745316, -0.005479283165186644, 0.04740623012185097, 0.020457860082387924, 0.03704686462879181, -0.13445007801055908, -0.024098819121718407, 0.04025786742568016, 0.06456980109214783, -0.047873444855213165, -0.026543987914919853, -0.011301576159894466, -0.014824451878666878, 0.0377659946680069, -0.0500938817858696, 0.025512877851724625, 0.019870424643158913, 0.022775666788220406, 0.0002053291827905923, -0.048140399158000946, -0.00729750981554389, 0.04665406793355942, -0.04277211055159569, 0.028186462819576263, 0.0021614127326756716, -0.023002255707979202, -0.024972250685095787, 0.022813690826296806, -0.003090286860242486, 0.053476251661777496, -0.002096267184242606, -0.005137795116752386, -0.008542612195014954, 0.058896347880363464, -0.03439862281084061, -0.03672054409980774, 0.02943025901913643, 0.03224548324942589, -0.023326322436332703, 0.0470002107322216, -0.01077940221875906, 0.020893780514597893, 0.010186564177274704, 0.02340954728424549, -0.03850729763507843, -0.019027983769774437, -0.023036036640405655, 0.04095368832349777, 0.060778215527534485, -0.0017580443527549505, 0.02773345075547695, 0.03724440559744835, -0.03196900710463524, -0.011596949771046638, -0.02392454631626606, 0.020062679424881935, -0.02655104175209999, -0.016495922580361366, -0.00815704744309187, 0.006861057132482529, -0.006913431920111179, -0.005718482192605734, 0.03946566954255104, 0.012841373682022095, -0.029339710250496864, -0.008180164732038975, -0.012870057485997677, -0.008035064674913883, -0.022948209196329117, -0.015487505123019218, -0.00012511199747677892, 0.031208686530590057, -0.000984952668659389, -0.002922375686466694, -0.00245105754584074, -0.013525410555303097, -0.0009439447312615812, -0.01095524337142706, -0.009981250390410423, 0.006894770078361034, -0.018245866522192955, -0.015176776796579361, 0.013353435322642326, 0.0193159319460392, 0.050788022577762604, 0.0096853943541646, 0.0040901340544223785, 0.0180880855768919, 0.00010686078167054802, -0.0066169374622404575, 0.007791064213961363, -0.01675627939403057, 0.023628395050764084, -0.016151731833815575, 0.02137153036892414, -0.01978658139705658, 0.025463702157139778, -0.04789051041007042, -0.04684293642640114, 0.035210952162742615, 0.04593572020530701, -0.0597146637737751, -0.019703535363078117, -0.03588133305311203, 0.006085377186536789, 0.0021297906059771776, -0.0023652492091059685, 0.05568530410528183, -0.02906804345548153, -0.0069377426989376545, 0.015720263123512268, 0.017147552222013474, 0.09340284019708633, -0.010508649051189423, -0.018268108367919922, 0.0019662058912217617, 0.01953992061316967, -0.018409036099910736, -0.03817060589790344, 0.010722117498517036, -0.04657960683107376, -0.019278643652796745, -0.003306970000267029, -0.01212560199201107, 0.08343230932950974, -0.02972133830189705, 0.03544986620545387, 0.03928685933351517, 0.023481039330363274, 0.007230550982058048, -0.03200853615999222, 0.014076190069317818, -0.014739206060767174, 0.01821196638047695, -0.03205519914627075, -0.0007788792718201876, -0.011627284809947014, 0.0035338501911610365, -0.004099676851183176, 0.024621928110718727, -0.021245142444968224, 0.05187558755278587, 0.048752784729003906, -0.010131292045116425, 0.0033922246657311916, -0.009599385783076286, -0.004258033353835344, 0.0413578525185585, -0.027186252176761627, 0.02854354865849018, -0.004162797704339027, 0.00132744200527668, 0.0017760510090738535, -0.043951570987701416, -0.012108074501156807, -0.005111460108309984, 0.07033631950616837, 0.004461740143597126, -0.0010260763810947537, 0.024784747511148453, 0.013187404721975327, -0.012117690406739712, -0.059449438005685806, -0.01231874618679285, -0.009257587604224682, -0.00806666910648346, 0.02942272461950779, -0.011089068837463856, -0.00517960824072361, 0.044287681579589844, -0.02965189889073372, 0.02027575485408306, 0.03826703131198883, 0.003413644852116704, 0.06258364766836166, 0.04767398536205292, -0.02762204222381115, -0.03701498359441757, -0.00799888651818037, -0.00879302341490984, 0.032987914979457855, -0.03522757440805435, -0.02676059864461422, 0.0380447581410408, 0.03763873875141144, -0.014948193915188313, -0.06137053668498993, -0.03034396655857563, -0.08892422169446945, 0.049233198165893555, -0.004868753254413605, -0.030365068465471268, 0.046683650463819504, 0.03763679414987564, 0.04213160648941994, 0.010122377425432205, 0.0009508226648904383, -0.034145742654800415, -0.033616431057453156, 0.0018711561569944024, -0.019770408049225807, -0.0507781058549881, -0.0010590177262201905, -0.023452982306480408, -0.03799207881093025, 0.02869708463549614, -0.025235680863261223, -0.01871298998594284, -0.0028179411310702562, 0.019467506557703018, 0.018648365512490273, 0.10280301421880722, 0.01601465232670307, 0.018393171951174736, 0.03629330173134804, -0.0013537569902837276, 0.13225069642066956, 0.11233366280794144, 0.013145641423761845, -0.05412895232439041, -0.020121412351727486, 0.040702857077121735, 0.00765695795416832, -0.0050997668877244, -0.015637649223208427, 0.01620364375412464, -0.022920969873666763, 0.07053633779287338, 0.05598359555006027, 0.013863268308341503, -0.004303811118006706, 0.08404349535703659, -0.0239332877099514, 0.01989232935011387, 0.014016359113156796, 0.004479778464883566, 0.0025629799347370863, 0.0037217936478555202, -0.06781774759292603, 0.06756098568439484, 0.04096679389476776, -0.007675786968320608, -0.015903949737548828, -0.022826794534921646, -0.001718264538794756, 0.005279806442558765, -0.03526753559708595, 0.052455972880125046, 0.024126507341861725, -0.008851703256368637, -0.02697039023041725, -0.016736451536417007, -0.003019151045009494, -0.04649725928902626, -0.01645163632929325, 0.046948306262493134, 0.04541075974702835, -0.019783906638622284, -0.04053231328725815, 0.03228259086608887, -0.015169152989983559, -0.02028631418943405, -0.060270871967077255, 0.007727933581918478, -0.002120828256011009, 0.007506113965064287, -0.001601821044459939, -0.04215620458126068, 0.03052675351500511, 0.0020089142490178347, -0.00903807207942009, 0.0385068915784359, 0.02017436921596527, -0.017395034432411194, 0.0025873000267893076, -0.0129508376121521, 0.011781403794884682, 0.0158058051019907, -0.0070339832454919815, 0.061566274613142014, -0.041668228805065155, -0.03650055453181267, -0.02732067182660103, 0.08829394727945328, 0.011234071105718613, 0.0036660199984908104, 0.030094284564256668, 0.019883280619978905, 0.0010249519255012274, 0.017665790393948555, -0.022327495738863945, -0.016851844266057014, 0.01017745304852724, 0.014533262699842453, -0.00019125855760648847, -0.018874071538448334, -0.061850596219301224, 0.024489769712090492, 0.021372951567173004, -0.012999085709452629, -0.020025502890348434, -0.019833482801914215, 0.030889378860592842, 0.03576711192727089, 0.03135775402188301, 0.003987499047070742, -0.02144317515194416, 0.055374275892972946, 0.012762113474309444, -0.0671595111489296, -0.02537357807159424, -0.0013986192643642426, -0.02914407290518284, -0.02869599685072899, -0.009814235381782055, 0.07760003209114075, -0.013222627341747284, -0.016417888924479485, 0.022294770926237106, 0.010280576534569263, -0.029331590980291367, 0.021355457603931427, -0.01325936894863844, -0.043860483914613724, -0.018347974866628647, -0.020428892225027084, -0.050520993769168854, -0.03841512277722359, -0.02076919749379158, -0.024980468675494194, 0.006672913674265146, 0.01794314570724964, 0.005503615364432335, -0.05530727654695511, 0.011241661384701729, -0.03984683379530907, 0.02146369218826294, -0.030448563396930695, -0.00365926930680871, -0.04985740780830383, -0.06448295712471008, 0.03177574276924133, 0.02188538946211338, 0.012479905039072037, 0.02312873676419258, 0.028631940484046936, -0.02249561809003353, -0.012262587435543537, 0.036303646862506866, 0.01301833987236023, -0.023599253967404366, -0.0032321750186383724, -0.0005872290348634124, 0.05117436870932579, -0.022106392309069633, -0.028282102197408676, -0.006836207117885351, 0.0012934431433677673, 0.005659168586134911, 0.047204893082380295, -0.01575297676026821, 0.003321716096252203, -0.02457631379365921, 0.024315781891345978, -0.03579122945666313, 0.026688430458307266, -0.021808333694934845, 0.019731130450963974, 0.0020043053664267063, 0.02058628387749195, 0.020068945363163948, -0.02390989288687706, 0.015759646892547607, 0.05520669370889664, -0.020755406469106674, 0.006702542304992676, 0.037149205803871155, -0.02233733795583248, 0.023168103769421577, -0.016245801001787186, -0.031280506402254105, 0.014326494187116623, 0.014130571857094765, 0.0041082268580794334, 0.0548030287027359, 0.027246562764048576, -0.016576940193772316, -0.0030845990404486656, -0.01101443450897932, -0.01590029150247574, -0.09188212454319, -0.03067624941468239, 0.012466328218579292, -0.019662588834762573, 0.02080240100622177, -0.0256740003824234, 0.02990748919546604, 0.020272767171263695, -0.04344438388943672, 0.01620415411889553, 0.018861208111047745, 0.009312126785516739, -0.042115915566682816, -0.019236428663134575, -0.0010363534092903137, 0.024288756772875786, -0.014984379522502422, 0.026651935651898384, 0.023326082155108452, 0.05116003006696701, 0.017586981877684593, -0.04092956706881523, -0.0416017584502697, -0.007280218414962292, 0.04411047324538231, -0.03258248046040535, 0.03655543550848961, -0.05300413444638252, -0.004842166323214769, 0.027121271938085556, -0.07230221480131149, 0.03443564474582672, -0.00048466576845385134, -0.011363836005330086, 0.008339187130331993, 0.03531939536333084, 0.04018928483128548, 0.0020317407324910164, -0.03407328203320503, -0.018573500216007233, 0.030344681814312935, 0.002467891899868846, -0.015645690262317657, 0.04038329795002937, 0.05194314941763878, -0.037850458174943924, 0.016525007784366608, -0.04331280291080475, -0.005076706409454346, 0.0014652146492153406, 0.010511649772524834, -0.024040352553129196, 0.04642612114548683, 0.006366504356265068, 0.033691439777612686, -0.03864685818552971, 0.025859979912638664, 0.022281689569354057, -0.013838982209563255, -0.031070321798324585, 0.0199916772544384, -0.017123444005846977, -0.027693014591932297, -0.04772027209401131, 0.012424446642398834, -0.0383647121489048, -0.019842782989144325, -0.004521965514868498, -0.012840787880122662, -0.024636097252368927, -0.04501711204648018, 0.030247896909713745, -0.024610379710793495, 0.06554985046386719, -0.0028361272998154163, -0.027518771588802338, 0.04416472092270851, -0.011343354359269142, 0.04207172617316246, -0.06980425119400024, 0.052218228578567505, -0.003969760145992041, -0.024134229868650436, -0.021371228620409966, -0.04879247024655342, 0.006358281709253788, 0.0003476559941191226, 0.033009644597768784, -0.002591656055301428, 0.033805955201387405, -0.028439104557037354, -0.005637532565742731, -0.014798024669289589, -0.007006986998021603, 0.044298555701971054, -0.037515368312597275, -0.033450186252593994, -0.01185748539865017, -0.006909299176186323, 0.017133858054876328, -0.03194521367549896, 0.0013916995376348495, 0.018465697765350342, -0.011677222326397896, -0.01073283702135086, 0.026905030012130737, 0.0005324478843249381, -0.022451693192124367, 0.01965213753283024, 0.02631150744855404, 0.006296627223491669, 0.010758723132312298, 0.015545672737061977, 0.004074891563504934, -0.07963763922452927, 0.051892347633838654, -0.011537856422364712, -0.025242343544960022, 0.03238951787352562, -0.007339497096836567, 0.008763063699007034, -0.060547906905412674, -0.023581622168421745, 0.02837778627872467, 0.02665342018008232, -0.004811890888959169, 0.03057659976184368, 0.006834634579718113, 0.002213367260992527, -0.02261180244386196, 0.02660650946199894, -0.0040891882963478565, 0.0012942405883222818, -0.017061825841665268, 0.0313943549990654, -0.0014690917450934649, -0.000912451941985637, -0.012724499218165874, 0.03365236148238182, 0.009649721905589104, 0.004616247024387121, -0.009961842559278011, 0.01819036528468132, -0.03538196533918381, -0.007187997456640005, 0.00905650295317173, -0.01621314510703087, -0.004837441723793745, 0.0362468883395195, 0.024631787091493607, 0.05487581342458725, -0.013702603988349438, 0.009724467992782593, -0.05334455892443657, -0.011413765139877796, -0.007210372481495142, -0.02099154144525528, -0.002211908809840679, 0.018312495201826096, 0.009610237553715706, -0.008836975321173668, 0.01649392955005169, 0.009563388302922249, -0.0034813210368156433, -0.0014413339085876942, 0.026188137009739876, -0.024329302832484245, -0.01753992959856987, 0.011783452704548836, -0.030667658895254135, -0.03511890396475792, -0.028529103845357895, 0.02371378242969513, 0.004128056112676859, 0.03459140658378601, 0.017871620133519173, -0.012266216799616814, 0.03461572900414467, -0.006389561574906111, -0.027701718732714653, -0.024126581847667694, -0.045210808515548706, -0.001937122899107635, 0.01419764757156372, -0.06271792948246002 ]
<p>I want to know I often I need to crawl certain webpages, to make sure I have the newest content as fast as possible. The naïve approach to this, is to simply calculate the average over a certain period of time. However, different web pages are updated at different rates, so this wouldn't be a good fit. I did some googling, and apparently, the Poisson distribution is a good fit for this kind of estimation. My question is, how should I calculate lambda? And it should be constantly updated, correct?</p> <p><strong>Edit:</strong> John's answer helped me out; for further reference, check this article: <a href="http://oak.cs.ucla.edu/~cho/papers/cho-freq.pdf" rel="nofollow">Estimating Frequency of Change</a></p> <p>Thank you</p>
74,500
[ -0.025379562750458717, -0.015229743905365467, 0.031109483912587166, -0.013099909760057926, 0.017100637778639793, 0.0017108262982219458, 0.040012434124946594, -0.014932526275515556, 0.041883040219545364, -0.03993196785449982, 0.024047011509537697, 0.06949055939912796, 0.03601117059588432, 0.0015678888885304332, 0.019032390788197517, -0.006738496012985706, -0.027800261974334717, -0.003969076555222273, -0.018462086096405983, 0.010276461951434612, 0.004444900434464216, 0.01337918546050787, -0.005946309305727482, -0.008941137231886387, -0.03665595501661301, 0.01758830063045025, 0.016162479296326637, -0.011551202274858952, 0.013360523618757725, 0.0786244198679924, -0.050464123487472534, -0.02425377070903778, 0.03425166755914688, 0.07268475741147995, -0.0020105286967009306, 0.008423331193625927, -0.07230904698371887, -0.04411443695425987, -0.04962104186415672, 0.047778479754924774, -0.03084016963839531, 0.019657479599118233, -0.0013460307382047176, 0.035438910126686096, -0.020761853083968163, 0.02639501541852951, -0.028424443677067757, -0.03875291720032692, 0.027056755498051643, -0.02795717492699623, 0.059726547449827194, -0.020740298554301262, 0.030843129381537437, 0.005490096751600504, -0.021178964525461197, -0.0015774762723594904, 0.04714738577604294, 0.02412826009094715, -0.022213589400053024, -0.05127784609794617, -0.016717758029699326, -0.026802541688084602, -0.0047656334936618805, -0.028764991089701653, -0.007868063636124134, 0.02886788919568062, -0.038708653301000595, -0.004428524989634752, 0.0736665278673172, -0.00020373369625303894, 0.01795152761042118, -0.014520193450152874, 0.05291621387004852, 0.0028586694970726967, 0.002399809192866087, -0.06293753534555435, -0.0044533321633934975, 0.045906271785497665, 0.014887293800711632, 0.02670636773109436, -0.026555627584457397, -0.0009580647456459701, 0.03162672743201256, 0.04605291411280632, 0.02308729849755764, -0.021003520116209984, 0.09490949660539627, 0.0008095150697045028, 0.010220232419669628, 0.027182631194591522, 0.009542063809931278, -0.026649173349142075, 0.024216679856181145, -0.03125758096575737, -0.0068277595564723015, 0.021819228306412697, -0.017614208161830902, -0.008756181225180626, 0.017072882503271103, -0.005511597730219364, 0.013583462685346603, -0.044201672077178955, 0.019693057984113693, 0.07058318704366684, -0.043547965586185455, -0.007881106808781624, -0.025947624817490578, -0.024932442232966423, -0.025548778474330902, -0.023084281012415886, -0.008106225170195103, 0.0032892515882849693, 0.023719817399978638, 0.012175080366432667, -0.009124690666794777, 0.016832923516631126, 0.02655228227376938, 0.006133026443421841, 0.03883666545152664, 0.05763128772377968, 0.025656450539827347, -0.03072349913418293, 0.03635924682021141, -0.01830359175801277, -0.023450806736946106, 0.039673320949077606, 0.01778780296444893, -0.02333044447004795, -0.06279492378234863, 0.06613196432590485, -0.04000237584114075, -0.0348602831363678, 0.05546578764915466, -0.02420661225914955, 0.031214028596878052, -0.010341016575694084, -0.07709042727947235, -0.029634876176714897, -0.003436637343838811, 0.0038257210981100798, 0.005696907639503479, -0.06622645258903503, -0.01437103096395731, 0.020168429240584373, 0.04287256300449371, 0.058516040444374084, 0.004268209915608168, 0.0055795093066990376, -0.023834751918911934, -0.026008527725934982, -0.05598960444331169, -0.027159057557582855, 0.013432950712740421, -0.018641460686922073, -0.003534727031365037, -0.0720912292599678, -0.00987125001847744, -0.0074931257404387, 0.040123362094163895, -0.007748649455606937, 0.02151765301823616, 0.044349078088998795, -0.021692069247364998, -0.03642049804329872, 0.034580379724502563, -0.05814165621995926, 0.0811164379119873, 0.005992341786623001, 0.015852155163884163, -0.012432841584086418, -0.010445946827530861, -0.0076367659494280815, -0.013842319138348103, 0.024925142526626587, 0.06795170903205872, -0.0064172521233558655, 0.002382769947871566, -0.06870200484991074, -0.0015409818151965737, 0.002080364152789116, -0.003930217120796442, -0.010571899823844433, -0.0165629331022501, 0.019722100347280502, 0.01954469457268715, 0.0351666621863842, -0.015753963962197304, 0.017603259533643723, 0.017064787447452545, -0.03142128139734268, -0.046782806515693665, -0.029141878709197044, 0.023195207118988037, -0.00824930053204298, 0.018349705263972282, 0.029781946912407875, 0.024198127910494804, -0.0020197287667542696, -0.024594323709607124, 0.019287291914224625, -0.004118842072784901, -0.01699371263384819, 0.02182653918862343, -0.059866081923246384, -0.021763451397418976, 0.05799398198723793, 0.008671611547470093, -0.009647442027926445, 0.03207617253065109, -0.0456710159778595, -0.028167499229311943, -0.03669632226228714, -0.04499754309654236, -0.006420745048671961, -0.007969280704855919, 0.01846250519156456, 0.03973618522286415, 0.026862837374210358, -0.011672522872686386, 0.00841560959815979, -0.051677022129297256, 0.058589786291122437, 0.03941308334469795, 0.04178076982498169, 0.013051592744886875, 0.0306231752038002, -0.007183414418250322, 0.0237271711230278, -0.028614625334739685, -0.055054109543561935, -0.07805574685335159, 0.0054776594042778015, 0.021058060228824615, -0.007326474878937006, -0.01507681142538786, 0.007289662025868893, 0.062279269099235535, 0.02400258183479309, 0.025100117549300194, 0.0362560860812664, -0.01388213038444519, -0.017202459275722504, 0.024905767291784286, 0.012696797959506512, -0.0003764700086321682, 0.022443149238824844, 0.031833719462156296, 0.0035450386349111795, 0.03507675603032112, 0.010233394801616669, 0.027079805731773376, 0.02127864584326744, 0.010768432170152664, 0.01970461569726467, -0.02697875164449215, -0.008543391712009907, 0.07807934284210205, 0.0063371798023581505, -0.016067825257778168, 0.04080342501401901, 0.004870857577770948, 0.013094109483063221, 0.022273264825344086, -0.061490681022405624, 0.034591346979141235, 0.0057758367620408535, -0.06555983424186707, -0.0283943023532629, 0.008292620070278645, -0.024369165301322937, 0.022969763725996017, -0.015877338126301765, -0.034140992909669876, -0.030127638950943947, 0.023289937525987625, -0.0045936135575175285, 0.015184298157691956, 0.0068869986571371555, -0.008684196509420872, -0.009499563835561275, 0.013891754671931267, -0.0037664531264454126, 0.01876778155565262, -0.013991420157253742, -0.0181985292583704, -0.0010485410457476974, 0.05976022034883499, -0.05059286206960678, 0.037075188010931015, 0.005533244926482439, 0.011177336797118187, 0.022128412500023842, 0.014949582517147064, -0.062107764184474945, 0.01994112879037857, -0.00727090472355485, 0.009863318875432014, -0.034232646226882935, -0.009726456366479397, 0.0267806313931942, 0.015741422772407532, -0.02175046131014824, 0.06580554693937302, -0.03628017380833626, -0.055381473153829575, -0.05664977803826332, 0.0003960610774811357, -0.006959012243896723, -0.013112952001392841, 0.034064263105392456, 0.023752473294734955, 0.01845471002161503, -0.006442779675126076, -0.05598731338977814, -0.09323819726705551, 0.008074396289885044, -0.017619557678699493, 0.06207219511270523, -0.011248737573623657, -0.029451988637447357, 0.061787329614162445, 0.029127022251486778, -0.06861884891986847, -0.005751435179263353, 0.03083307109773159, -0.02082926034927368, -0.023065829649567604, 0.02946494147181511, -0.023944847285747528, -0.014331995509564877, -0.010297531262040138, 0.007229991722851992, 0.04134371876716614, 0.04878062382340431, 0.040503717958927155, 0.003616869216784835, 0.008398976176977158, 0.030333954840898514, 0.00279918871819973, 0.03674090653657913, 0.02647511661052704, -0.017073119059205055, 0.018055958673357964, -0.02053799107670784, 0.014363420195877552, -0.006086593493819237, -0.012731810100376606, 0.03336483985185623, 0.0024374586064368486, -0.02400686778128147, -0.010275114327669144, 0.04534435272216797, 0.029296306893229485, -0.02412026934325695, -0.020097676664590836, 0.04140200465917587, 0.013563085347414017, -0.02750096097588539, -0.01607610285282135, 0.059833310544490814, 0.06471376866102219, -0.045800138264894485, -0.02190103940665722, -0.06417926400899887, 0.021641941741108894, -0.02119063399732113, -0.03824638947844505, -0.038396671414375305, -0.019105536863207817, 0.03171897307038307, 0.021400349214673042, -0.023839373141527176, -0.020595205947756767, 0.0019491289276629686, -0.05981625244021416, -0.0388341061770916, 0.012149007990956306, 0.07477656751871109, 0.023243408650159836, 0.01453150063753128, 0.021397670730948448, 0.004964384716004133, 0.027086883783340454, 0.03095903992652893, -0.08857335150241852, 0.029724249616265297, -0.02682456001639366, 0.005298044066876173, -0.00961450394243002, -0.03310611844062805, 0.009379171766340733, -0.026778962463140488, 0.00036193575942888856, -0.0079584252089262, -0.014457667246460915, -0.023111829534173012, 0.0012412257492542267, -0.018454749137163162, 0.029342561960220337, -0.007316443603485823, 0.007388887461274862, -0.015457909554243088, 0.006021978799253702, 0.024575071409344673, 0.03080458752810955, 0.02335752733051777, -0.018224351108074188, -0.02446441538631916, 0.002453424734994769, -0.026448756456375122, 0.020903052762150764, 0.011318566277623177, 0.032357294112443924, -0.04873448610305786, 0.06275049597024918, -0.022499607875943184, 0.019787725061178207, 0.040479641407728195, 0.0029692829120904207, 0.017156198620796204, -0.03826344758272171, -0.027962710708379745, 0.009959152899682522, 0.021765749901533127, 0.010016393847763538, 0.052888091653585434, 0.049281466752290726, 0.012939329259097576, -0.0581812746822834, 0.032415613532066345, 0.07638024538755417, -0.018229907378554344, -0.004487715661525726, 0.0018099562730640173, 0.0203090887516737, 0.005989257711917162, -0.019754210487008095, -0.02236155979335308, 0.015127262100577354, 0.0016894993605092168, 0.03051447682082653, -0.010046176612377167, -0.018699046224355698, -0.034902963787317276, -0.004126526415348053, -0.008151303045451641, 0.022727593779563904, -0.03302011266350746, -0.02842402085661888, 0.015425819903612137, 0.04752032458782196, 0.06329041719436646, -0.012251072563230991, -0.00028154003666713834, -0.08924299478530884, -0.04285857453942299, 0.032581791281700134, 0.030402695760130882, -0.0398029200732708, -0.029214447364211082, -0.0459202378988266, -0.033523887395858765, 0.034001532942056656, -0.020464809611439705, 0.03429921716451645, -0.001029554521664977, -0.012989301234483719, 0.010078657418489456, -0.010041247121989727, -0.012897581793367863, 0.014744866639375687, -0.0483841635286808, 0.054735518991947174, -0.043694913387298584, 0.009874578565359116, -0.04357994347810745, 0.028776897117495537, -0.018333958461880684, 0.03500959277153015, -0.03348464518785477, -0.01503419503569603, -0.0010384984780102968, 0.003732487093657255, -0.024402810260653496, -0.05610436201095581, 0.03665278106927872, -0.0017822819063439965, 0.019542761147022247, 0.004304375033825636, -0.002672187052667141, 0.026069501414895058, -0.0032516203355044127, 0.036262962967157364, -0.048722993582487106, -0.012352799996733665, -0.03665194287896156, 0.020136650651693344, 0.03418786823749542, 0.023071764037013054, 0.07473549991846085, 0.0519949346780777, -0.001961474772542715, 0.03513488918542862, -0.0112631656229496, 0.030530698597431183, -0.018225165084004402, 0.03461406007409096, 0.002256940584629774, -0.004417847841978073, -0.03086215816438198, 0.0630163848400116, -0.019676299765706062, 0.01058254949748516, -0.02117016725242138, 0.031108301132917404, -0.018772277981042862, -0.0016136167105287313, 0.01477187778800726, 0.02861666865646839, 0.043691761791706085, 0.004604213871061802, -0.02365264669060707, -0.014929946511983871, 0.020492026582360268, -0.028326047584414482, -0.00755481468513608, 0.015090842731297016, -0.03375811129808426, 0.011431030929088593, -0.04462417960166931, -0.007998628541827202, 0.05442032963037491, -0.03849710524082184, 0.039049528539180756, -0.004842645023018122, 0.040178216993808746, 0.011051799170672894, -0.027958547696471214, -0.008218275383114815, 0.02124079316854477, -0.013742368668317795, 0.030140157788991928, -0.024633532389998436, 0.051053453236818314, -0.017787734046578407, -0.01598953828215599, -0.07360071688890457, -0.052731819450855255, 0.0666821077466011, -0.01004886720329523, -0.03241041675209999, -0.03696689382195473, 0.016262387856841087, -0.008368746377527714, -0.024716529995203018, -0.0038063775282353163, 0.017604997381567955, 0.009811610914766788, -0.0022409893572330475, -0.0056334673427045345, -0.007083585020154715, 0.08039455115795135, 0.02685113437473774, -0.0053647360764443874, 0.002974021714180708, -0.0013066156534478068, -0.015969473868608475, -0.011510397307574749, 0.03822264447808266, -0.032426800578832626, 0.005927804857492447, 0.007228432688862085, -0.008981147781014442, 0.043446216732263565, -0.037851203233003616, -0.009510711766779423, 0.03491031005978584, -0.007231477648019791, 0.013602153398096561, -0.027372540906071663, 0.01569482684135437, 0.002620786428451538, 0.020488565787672997, -0.03396059200167656, 0.009078728035092354, -0.015566994436085224, -0.013926902785897255, 0.02993602864444256, 0.0028075468726456165, 0.0565604642033577, 0.04834897816181183, 0.08576469868421555, -0.028524212539196014, -0.04002462700009346, -0.01665450818836689, -0.02513565868139267, 0.01759764924645424, 0.00043902909965254366, -0.007278852630406618, 0.02706977166235447, -0.03365905210375786, -0.0323764905333519, -0.005738583393394947, -0.04131653159856796, -0.005346774589270353, 0.06547704339027405, -0.019128406420350075, 0.04388924688100815, 0.02041470631957054, 0.022817028686404228, -0.0028337575495243073, 0.022291362285614014, -0.021587036550045013, -0.028081949800252914, -0.0010261256247758865, 0.0036875654477626085, -0.035768166184425354, 0.003627039259299636, 0.03423887863755226, 0.009815006516873837, 0.02528391405940056, 0.0695548877120018, 0.006201718933880329, 0.0377366840839386, 0.07366269826889038, -0.024428702890872955, -0.05140926316380501, 0.037123627960681915, -0.0361538827419281, 0.055270805954933167, -0.04062321037054062, -0.029039371758699417, 0.060334399342536926, 0.010440900921821594, 0.009305093437433243, -0.026167385280132294, -0.026867222040891647, -0.035125844180583954, 0.017882829532027245, 0.0024833991192281246, -0.005732353311032057, 0.027213795110583305, 0.01902843452990055, 0.047257233411073685, 0.008715152740478516, 0.0343606099486351, -0.017005467787384987, -0.060639888048172, 0.031222283840179443, -0.0016394125996157527, -0.09138551354408264, 0.023431722074747086, 0.012515891343355179, -0.00785456970334053, -0.005298835225403309, -0.007377227768301964, -0.0064871227368712425, 0.03327520564198494, 0.031032860279083252, -0.026732368394732475, 0.11641570180654526, -0.026523135602474213, 0.004382907412946224, -0.020888183265924454, 0.01513435784727335, 0.12486543506383896, 0.09382188320159912, 0.0018156887963414192, -0.07303473353385925, -0.021670902147889137, -0.023197688162326813, -0.010393081232905388, -0.03133470192551613, 0.0007738658459857106, 0.025776414200663567, -0.008878647349774837, 0.0416584350168705, 0.03401104733347893, 0.005530395545065403, -0.025888800621032715, 0.05929965525865555, -0.024206746369600296, 0.016503380611538887, 0.00276498356834054, 0.00794217549264431, 0.011394237168133259, 0.012440194375813007, -0.041899424046278, 0.011227861046791077, 0.01363246701657772, -0.006982983089983463, -0.00934118777513504, -0.017866114154458046, -0.0570843368768692, -0.016906151548027992, -0.031130988150835037, 0.03386698663234711, 0.022373832762241364, -0.03989611938595772, 0.00463724322617054, 0.013338304124772549, 0.0020438216160982847, -0.004676835611462593, 0.03735532611608505, 0.032811567187309265, 0.01614881493151188, 0.002114964881911874, 0.02823197841644287, 0.024615829810500145, 0.005275577772408724, -0.021101847290992737, -0.07030575722455978, 0.0049667092971503735, -0.0004288993077352643, 0.04002853482961655, 0.013359613716602325, 0.0022074305452406406, -0.006679451558738947, -0.018365032970905304, -0.005735074635595083, 0.011236353777348995, 0.0158985685557127, -0.013501456007361412, -0.02681300789117813, -0.014805953949689865, 0.010362980887293816, 0.011729159392416477, 0.0164633821696043, 0.05471138656139374, -0.036729346960783005, -0.047926757484674454, -0.03069792129099369, 0.0352775901556015, -0.011160786263644695, -0.030835257843136787, 0.0068235755898058414, -0.05111422762274742, -0.017832646146416664, 0.028350496664643288, -0.041846394538879395, -0.03163987398147583, 0.019487055018544197, -0.02538321353495121, -0.0327959768474102, 0.004630723502486944, -0.06140327453613281, 0.020210137590765953, 0.01991874724626541, -0.006322523113340139, -0.03371443226933479, -0.011748392134904861, 0.03939705342054367, 0.0020286748185753822, 0.015780910849571228, 0.026210572570562363, -0.03128007799386978, 0.01872728392481804, 0.04737057164311409, -0.02823750302195549, 0.0006685420521534979, -0.003170666052028537, -0.0348421074450016, -0.01581394486129284, -0.043175067752599716, 0.029158558696508408, 0.010424146428704262, -0.022125035524368286, -0.01825185865163803, -0.00961424969136715, 0.007295256946235895, 0.027586612850427628, -0.011989478021860123, -0.05240015685558319, 0.0000659362121950835, -0.001515527837909758, -0.008953893557190895, -0.016254350543022156, -0.022983329370617867, -0.04302895814180374, 0.009164391085505486, 0.017234761267900467, -0.03879154846072197, -0.04257484897971153, -0.005518740974366665, -0.020625514909625053, 0.027585748583078384, 0.009026938118040562, -0.017240582033991814, -0.011524858884513378, -0.00863106083124876, -0.002579974476248026, 0.03385515883564949, -0.023143311962485313, 0.01815592497587204, 0.0017256358405575156, -0.031071385368704796, 0.012844139710068703, -0.010265015065670013, -0.0024861148558557034, 0.011700810864567757, 0.0010745263425633311, -0.019688989967107773, 0.009920059703290462, -0.038791801780462265, -0.03821529448032379, 0.05412384122610092, -0.04683265462517738, -0.02416832372546196, 0.07119259983301163, -0.017459062859416008, 0.009040302596986294, 0.0003357711248099804, -0.028388602659106255, 0.01313683483749628, -0.016438307240605354, -0.008542242459952831, 0.014608195051550865, -0.012688243761658669, -0.0025097017642110586, 0.02957494929432869, 0.010202702134847641, -0.03516481816768646, 0.04325030371546745, 0.000054736676247557625, -0.02096404880285263, 0.014258497394621372, -0.03164319694042206, 0.013410466723144054, -0.0039824554696679115, -0.029508017003536224, 0.003363877534866333, 0.03177290037274361, 0.002707121428102255, 0.0529385507106781, 0.04393242299556732, -0.04503478482365608, -0.021170122548937798, -0.028301870450377464, -0.027696317061781883, -0.06259925663471222, 0.027802271768450737, 0.03224528208374977, -0.019236966967582703, 0.026428859680891037, -0.02888801321387291, -0.0072259195148944855, 0.01225909125059843, -0.013240797445178032, 0.04973839223384857, 0.01357192825525999, 0.0027769573498517275, -0.056994952261447906, 0.0018818170065060258, -0.009282703511416912, 0.006911444012075663, 0.04215851053595543, 0.025170736014842987, 0.038067154586315155, 0.014545101672410965, -0.04414484277367592, -0.052674800157547, 0.008302628062665462, 0.029125403612852097, 0.04081664979457855, -0.04657632112503052, -0.00028555726748891175, -0.03009762428700924, -0.026055416092276573, 0.041364409029483795, -0.05491364374756813, -0.00489933742210269, -0.0004020398191642016, 0.021913738921284676, 0.0013624303974211216, 0.04764280095696449, 0.029708214104175568, 0.0006964735803194344, 0.017094193026423454, 0.006586396601051092, 0.008869471028447151, 0.051582079380750656, -0.030937474220991135, 0.00528681231662631, 0.051214549690485, -0.041623737663030624, -0.02664690837264061, 0.01762847974896431, -0.00760247465223074, -0.019119083881378174, 0.01992008648812771, -0.03001057542860508, 0.019234275445342064, 0.01752016507089138, -0.001872414955869317, -0.028491025790572166, 0.017665920779109, 0.04375159367918968, 0.019924182444810867, -0.03387833386659622, 0.029496824368834496, -0.016757221892476082, -0.013700553216040134, 0.00574966985732317, -0.006474532652646303, -0.04085467755794525, -0.06272507458925247, 0.001808341359719634, -0.013628054410219193, 0.013611639849841595, -0.02137554995715618, -0.0017671863315626979, -0.02177913300693035, 0.023077134042978287, -0.007284332532435656, -0.04177561402320862, -0.005146368872374296, 0.008077455684542656, 0.04987431690096855, -0.028996266424655914, 0.05792372673749924, 0.04441668093204498, -0.0017000616062432528, -0.020371517166495323, -0.04229702800512314, -0.005725223105400801, 0.000050517974159447476, 0.05417461693286896, -0.01242235116660595, -0.009796802885830402, -0.026774058118462563, 0.02302180975675583, 0.04879983142018318, -0.036778680980205536, 0.006549801677465439, -0.061504047363996506, -0.04255698248744011, -0.0062789651565253735, 0.0011791123542934656, -0.0038690962828695774, 0.011260940693318844, 0.012383476831018925, -0.020454317331314087, 0.014669091440737247, -0.01752592995762825, -0.021744756028056145, -0.004586321301758289, 0.05183659866452217, -0.0237581804394722, 0.01758861169219017, -0.007564653642475605, 0.04107510298490524, 0.000304041983326897, 0.05423322319984436, -0.05957586318254471, 0.05984373390674591, -0.030346635729074478, 0.011379197239875793, 0.03875010088086128, 0.0114810261875391, -0.015843553468585014, -0.05846564099192619, -0.021322058513760567, 0.016888275742530823, -0.01797299273312092, 0.009134427644312382, 0.0342617928981781, -0.008043210953474045, 0.017880363389849663, 0.0024964739568531513, 0.014947411604225636, 0.009738340973854065, 0.021833207458257675, -0.01253130566328764, 0.03188038989901543, -0.03058854676783085, -0.048360425978899, 0.01321483589708805, 0.04241970553994179, 0.009141567163169384, 0.035246022045612335, 0.006676661781966686, 0.05351503938436508, -0.03964029625058174, -0.005596842151135206, -0.008355443365871906, -0.01991921104490757, -0.037981461733579636, 0.06221560761332512, -0.026648368686437607, 0.023764489218592644, -0.01506031770259142, 0.05908336862921715, -0.011130506172776222, -0.017520543187856674, -0.03221552446484566, -0.007788172457367182, 0.0020398152992129326, 0.02000979520380497, -0.012762993574142456, 0.00685155251994729, 0.017256690189242363, 0.021207820624113083, 0.04044704511761665, -0.03824421018362045, 0.03475671634078026, 0.020710479468107224, 0.01636081002652645, -0.03531026840209961, -0.03425582870841026, -0.03378074988722801, -0.009986802004277706, 0.021650735288858414, 0.002905365079641342, -0.008151345886290073, 0.016379302367568016, 0.008499151095747948, -0.010869493708014488, 0.01991027034819126, -0.06116849556565285, -0.0049597108736634254, -0.06821771711111069, 0.0006106230430305004, 0.016481487080454826, -0.02040785364806652 ]
<p>We have a small dataset (about 250 samples * 100 features) on which we want to build a binary classifier after selecting the best feature subset. Lets say that we partition the data into:</p> <p>Training, Validation and Testing</p> <p>For feature selection, we apply a wrapper model based on selecting features optimizing performance of classifiers X, Y and Z, separately. In this pre-processing step, we use training data for training the classifiers and validation data for evaluating every candidate feature subset.</p> <p>At the end, we want to compare the different classifiers (X, Y and Z). Of course, we can use the testing part of the data to have a fair comparison and evaluation. However in my case, the testing data would be really small (around 10 to 20 samples) and thus, I want to apply cross-validation for evaluating the models.</p> <p>The distribution of the positive and negative examples is highly ill-balanced (about 8:2). So, a cross-validation could miss-lead us in evaluating the performance. To overcome this, we plan to have the testing portion (10-20 samples) as a second comparison method and to validate the cross-validation.</p> <p>In summary, we are partitioning data into training, validation and testing. Training and validation parts are to be used for feature selection. Then, cross-validation over the same data is to be applied to estimate the models. Finally, testing is used to validate the cross-validation given the imbalance of the data.</p> <p><strong>The question is:</strong> If we use the same data (training+validation) used in selecting the features optimizing the performance of classifiers X, Y and Z, can we apply cross-validation over the same data (training+validation) used for feature selection to measure the final performance and compare the classifiers?</p> <p>I do not know if this setting could lead to a biased cross-validation measure and result in un-justified comparison or not.</p>
49,252
[ -0.027662936598062515, 0.021825041621923447, -0.029958872124552727, -0.018183892592787743, 0.04527048021554947, 0.021093666553497314, -0.012012085877358913, -0.0058189621195197105, 0.040830109268426895, 0.009704054333269596, 0.041470952332019806, 0.05239400640130043, 0.04741938039660454, -0.016575142741203308, -0.009411388076841831, -0.017886243760585785, -0.026053043082356453, -0.012448263354599476, -0.005105411168187857, 0.007017106283456087, -0.013927317224442959, 0.016796262934803963, 0.0656934455037117, 0.020648453384637833, -0.031955309212207794, 0.025774173438549042, 0.020798655226826668, -0.01711178384721279, 0.011801336891949177, 0.025376105681061745, -0.02398376539349556, -0.008510676212608814, -0.0029544963035732508, 0.08098553866147995, 0.013549395836889744, -0.016233716160058975, -0.03015035018324852, -0.044738173484802246, -0.03189648687839508, 0.0019611362367868423, -0.007878396660089493, -0.013637794181704521, -0.012298718094825745, 0.043803974986076355, 0.0051186587661504745, 0.009314313530921936, -0.029125891625881195, -0.029204273596405983, 0.022635120898485184, -0.05302110314369202, 0.05527551472187042, -0.005496121011674404, 0.06061795726418495, 0.05471271649003029, -0.00398382218554616, -0.036690786480903625, 0.0677957683801651, 0.09211172163486481, -0.02292836643755436, -0.04104236140847206, 0.028036264702677727, -0.04112783446907997, -0.003573291702196002, 0.008921949192881584, -0.0074433861300349236, 0.04303189367055893, -0.0064394776709377766, -0.02312062494456768, -0.002046066103503108, 0.0038359009195119143, 0.012260885909199715, 0.01462815422564745, 0.01452162116765976, -0.031871452927589417, 0.020518271252512932, -0.00899870228022337, 0.0022521554492413998, 0.032957542687654495, 0.03923175856471062, 0.019837867468595505, 0.012758241966366768, 0.0036570667289197445, -0.0015788963064551353, 0.08442685008049011, 0.021771229803562164, -0.017797060310840607, 0.07674819231033325, -0.022365016862750053, 0.024336928501725197, -0.006897374521940947, 0.024501383304595947, -0.005390889011323452, 0.0401754155755043, 0.013550147414207458, -0.016466425731778145, 0.021903222426772118, 0.004989142995327711, 0.018642937764525414, 0.02191794104874134, -0.0016512866131961346, 0.003302541561424732, -0.016905706375837326, 0.030494244769215584, 0.05704764276742935, -0.022704768925905228, 0.014838824979960918, -0.025941696017980576, -0.02272721938788891, -0.008636795915663242, 0.007229266222566366, -0.018562519922852516, 0.014416845515370369, 0.006234004627913237, -0.013464974239468575, 0.035675328224897385, 0.009169153869152069, 0.0014607291668653488, -0.018634114414453506, 0.02515346370637417, 0.04633188620209694, 0.04284379631280899, -0.02379422076046467, 0.028145667165517807, -0.03028417006134987, -0.03653663769364357, -0.0016854453133419156, 0.004367261193692684, 0.015644889324903488, -0.025287481024861336, 0.03779519721865654, -0.022971857339143753, -0.027352431789040565, -0.003006531624123454, 0.0077082812786102295, 0.024764273315668106, 0.026978349313139915, -0.09862614423036575, -0.06367580592632294, 0.008654236793518066, -0.042120981961488724, 0.03239081799983978, -0.05109976604580879, -0.025985321030020714, 0.022711848840117455, 0.04235847294330597, -0.010125711560249329, 0.0443095862865448, 0.0068908995017409325, 0.015551879070699215, 0.000003020346412085928, -0.005147894378751516, -0.0329953171312809, -0.04259790852665901, 0.008963385596871376, -0.03272736817598343, -0.08827559649944305, 0.03185248374938965, 0.010455384850502014, -0.041169777512550354, -0.023201487958431244, -0.02493562549352646, -0.009803712368011475, 0.0028228156734257936, -0.018910974264144897, 0.008800845593214035, -0.017400138080120087, 0.05608266964554787, 0.025980044156312943, 0.06516575813293457, 0.020972449332475662, -0.03142796829342842, -0.001490447553806007, 0.04365920647978783, 0.014476342126727104, 0.025589780882000923, -0.01463257521390915, 0.017617488279938698, -0.02667136676609516, 0.04618258774280548, 0.007231232710182667, -0.022295154631137848, -0.03682956472039223, -0.00985195953398943, 0.0019000472966581583, -0.0042987242341041565, 0.0376972071826458, 0.024949291720986366, -0.02234191820025444, 0.05519133806228638, -0.04453170672059059, -0.05881548300385475, -0.058154549449682236, 0.010480623692274094, -0.006102578714489937, -0.04733424261212349, 0.044879328459501266, 0.029943887144327164, 0.028222599998116493, -0.029910694807767868, -0.03546036034822464, -0.019440120086073875, -0.014722859486937523, 0.024126999080181122, -0.026052692905068398, 0.01437218114733696, 0.05148342624306679, -0.0075542195700109005, -0.05656527355313301, 0.07864102721214294, -0.023435112088918686, -0.09749790281057358, 0.010376768186688423, -0.04055068641901016, 0.007970682345330715, -0.0016431374242529273, -0.0352008230984211, 0.05059872567653656, -0.002275410806760192, -0.030822105705738068, 0.027718329802155495, -0.039031703025102615, 0.08666064590215683, 0.07075752317905426, -0.02218252420425415, 0.0250087920576334, -0.017330212518572807, 0.025312088429927826, 0.046111416071653366, -0.005905617494136095, 0.010750943794846535, -0.06284072995185852, -0.02084844931960106, 0.056921958923339844, 0.012570774182677269, -0.052067141979932785, 0.0025071180425584316, 0.03591025620698929, -0.02037672884762287, 0.018418900668621063, 0.01678401045501232, 0.013669626787304878, -0.00840722769498825, 0.030461296439170837, 0.04609791561961174, 0.028874540701508522, -0.005145312286913395, 0.009870858862996101, -0.013141283765435219, 0.03509349748492241, 0.0015417482936754823, -0.02424563281238079, 0.0643521249294281, 0.005363191943615675, -0.00019022045307792723, 0.0029468180146068335, -0.04550223425030708, 0.021879056468605995, 0.0048888688907027245, 0.018753884360194206, 0.012514215894043446, 0.005978394765406847, 0.01461589615792036, -0.011155333369970322, 0.007699173875153065, 0.016699081286787987, 0.007818339392542839, -0.02208786830306053, 0.0065453234128654, 0.022110847756266594, -0.06395924836397171, -0.018727298825979233, 0.008236520923674107, -0.029025981202721596, -0.053673155605793, 0.010457095690071583, 0.0407019667327404, -0.00885511189699173, 0.019079674035310745, -0.02326595038175583, -0.03955550864338875, -0.01184222474694252, -0.010334644466638565, 0.03150021657347679, -0.00037965524825267494, -0.019961470738053322, 0.010225964710116386, -0.03848730027675629, -0.02153477817773819, 0.043751467019319534, -0.012439589947462082, -0.0009462962625548244, -0.012391776777803898, 0.017532367259263992, -0.008060885593295097, -0.04651789367198944, -0.014778452925384045, 0.02778054215013981, -0.03103332780301571, -0.059470586478710175, 0.06370632350444794, 0.03048843704164028, -0.05766503885388374, 0.03288967162370682, 0.010271571576595306, -0.03549525886774063, 0.008601649664342403, -0.017460940405726433, 0.016071446239948273, -0.017642809078097343, -0.004588721320033073, 0.04715687409043312, -0.017358912155032158, 0.006078136153519154, -0.0432877279818058, -0.06042398884892464, 0.007276515942066908, -0.015169372782111168, 0.042451705783605576, 0.02979445457458496, -0.002652261173352599, 0.07593555748462677, 0.046700604259967804, -0.010072628036141396, -0.06797982007265091, 0.028795897960662842, -0.05023502930998802, -0.023950953036546707, -0.0117421243339777, 0.02904212661087513, 0.014768549241125584, 0.04367148503661156, 0.010635711252689362, -0.0104329539462924, 0.05631006509065628, -0.0062461839988827705, -0.03445478901267052, 0.00991581566631794, 0.031019261106848717, -0.0025729986373335123, -0.0082843117415905, 0.005714318249374628, -0.02215619944036007, 0.0024659456685185432, -0.01387792732566595, 0.0303049236536026, 0.013987652026116848, -0.04911097511649132, 0.01604914478957653, -0.0256134532392025, 0.03157401457428932, -0.01365516148507595, 0.03377566114068031, 0.003885523648932576, -0.03669654205441475, 0.01367165893316269, 0.01889617368578911, 0.032704442739486694, -0.011093691922724247, -0.020735446363687515, 0.02459998056292534, 0.033816661685705185, -0.010791880078613758, -0.0009002833976410329, -0.03233150392770767, 0.012667268514633179, 0.022303063422441483, 0.000239194676396437, -0.012581626884639263, 0.05701018497347832, 0.05314747616648674, 0.012254168279469013, -0.00018606969388201833, -0.05730424076318741, 0.01722070761024952, -0.05294700339436531, -0.01550969760864973, -0.01618925668299198, 0.06419375538825989, 0.001749207149259746, 0.014406777918338776, 0.000988313928246498, -0.040961459279060364, 0.006527364253997803, 0.017971474677324295, -0.05438440293073654, 0.019928952679038048, 0.006652358919382095, 0.024271873757243156, -0.016728952527046204, -0.035570912063121796, 0.013840585015714169, -0.04880964383482933, 0.007996664382517338, -0.008750462904572487, 0.02990655042231083, -0.021688975393772125, 0.001196273835375905, -0.05106445029377937, -0.016663193702697754, 0.00246474239975214, 0.04807104542851448, 0.02407652512192726, -0.009027458727359772, 0.031188633292913437, 0.02173207700252533, 0.004582541529089212, 0.014558958820998669, -0.019165953621268272, 0.029962705448269844, -0.012005110271275043, 0.04839586839079857, -0.01080938708037138, 0.057454101741313934, -0.05325520411133766, -0.012480995617806911, -0.020985493436455727, 0.04906437173485756, 0.04921962693333626, -0.006276555359363556, -0.040016837418079376, -0.06852909922599792, -0.022663259878754616, -0.015260430984199047, 0.01807451620697975, 0.01654321700334549, -0.03637855127453804, 0.033451009541749954, 0.03202410787343979, -0.06179168447852135, -0.012774418108165264, 0.0797196552157402, 0.04257849603891373, -0.022826896980404854, -0.04605981335043907, -0.04110529646277428, 0.0006597737083211541, -0.017099056392908096, 0.02557096816599369, -0.0002971159992739558, -0.007465723901987076, 0.01612657867372036, 0.020179295912384987, -0.01594010554254055, -0.04605385661125183, 0.00968153402209282, 0.040735334157943726, 0.04762053117156029, 0.017489049583673477, -0.023787446320056915, 0.005938822403550148, 0.05626183748245239, 0.0583421066403389, 0.01477736234664917, -0.022198790684342384, -0.08886219561100006, -0.004899383056908846, 0.0589364618062973, 0.033784013241529465, -0.012834971770644188, -0.03708009421825409, -0.04623042792081833, -0.004824242554605007, 0.01777425967156887, -0.02643100917339325, 0.026004472747445107, -0.014717325568199158, 0.01790502294898033, -0.04151366278529167, 0.005990674719214439, -0.04477786645293236, 0.014236463233828545, -0.030130615457892418, 0.03218192234635353, -0.0177137553691864, -0.042113713920116425, -0.020525261759757996, -0.007019409444183111, -0.003624160075560212, 0.06263324618339539, -0.014816568233072758, 0.0033040735870599747, -0.018732981756329536, 0.024047045037150383, 0.0024952124804258347, -0.07176009565591812, -0.038807664066553116, 0.008788110688328743, -0.012780960649251938, 0.045479197055101395, 0.0071957712061703205, -0.03229326754808426, 0.025198165327310562, 0.011941595934331417, -0.020322900265455246, 0.001635860651731491, -0.04091140627861023, 0.02449103258550167, 0.025693733245134354, 0.018703574314713478, 0.04061020538210869, -0.0027154621202498674, 0.00040731500484980643, -0.00821707770228386, 0.004536042921245098, 0.017360113561153412, -0.02204802818596363, -0.04307613521814346, -0.03637644648551941, -0.01994839310646057, -0.016315871849656105, 0.04196590185165405, 0.0030806874856352806, 0.00456982059404254, -0.014762172475457191, -0.030251136049628258, -0.013028504326939583, 0.0032634746748954058, -0.02592957206070423, -0.06146223098039627, -0.019119517877697945, 0.04098820686340332, -0.011334456503391266, 0.01395412441343069, 0.005241297651082277, -0.008970179595053196, 0.016316840425133705, 0.022104548290371895, -0.056873634457588196, 0.01903606206178665, -0.040996287018060684, 0.009235311299562454, 0.008299725130200386, 0.024347417056560516, 0.016106579452753067, 0.006917205639183521, 0.034023936837911606, 0.000507031159941107, -0.05142183229327202, 0.005189051851630211, 0.04144623130559921, 0.020806502550840378, 0.013111106120049953, -0.03890205919742584, 0.04383600875735283, 0.0008723387727513909, -0.03449520841240883, -0.08687517791986465, -0.006865562405437231, 0.01017437782138586, -0.012273323722183704, -0.0038183596916496754, -0.014016102999448776, -0.006041084881871939, 0.003613033564761281, -0.014804596081376076, -0.0024091568775475025, 0.024467887356877327, -0.00722107570618391, -0.014182657934725285, 0.026832779869437218, -0.00677706953138113, 0.05623037368059158, -0.012057697400450706, 0.016671156510710716, 0.004894313868135214, -0.022315388545393944, -0.03184175863862038, 0.04070724546909332, 0.0000755710425437428, -0.03771097585558891, -0.017397252842783928, -0.05250687152147293, 0.0024781785905361176, 0.0008768022526055574, 0.005374259781092405, -0.04864928498864174, -0.014109226875007153, -0.03268970176577568, -0.007695313543081284, -0.022146129980683327, 0.01340272556990385, -0.0056394124403595924, -0.016980038955807686, -0.02825256809592247, 0.02112756110727787, 0.0010382931213825941, -0.014838393777608871, 0.04054650291800499, 0.029727758839726448, -0.0574846975505352, 0.0194571353495121, 0.0636269673705101, -0.02951631508767605, 0.015501631423830986, -0.021312640979886055, -0.03993195295333862, 0.08247476816177368, -0.006425673142075539, -0.0085690813139081, 0.02789594605565071, 0.05548940226435661, -0.03805375099182129, 0.0034509359393268824, -0.02493915893137455, -0.023763932287693024, 0.021794134750962257, -0.034218959510326385, 0.028561759740114212, 0.05103861913084984, 0.008622447960078716, -0.0033039390109479427, -0.05017527565360069, 0.014272691681981087, -0.012327468022704124, -0.018123706802725792, 0.06034568324685097, 0.03873950242996216, 0.01026061363518238, 0.04067537933588028, -0.002857977757230401, 0.0339183583855629, 0.030857417732477188, -0.013184620067477226, 0.031367767602205276, 0.00870104506611824, -0.03762419894337654, -0.031136518344283104, 0.03012232668697834, -0.04869109019637108, -0.03432495892047882, -0.0255353432148695, -0.026468731462955475, 0.013668878935277462, 0.017930209636688232, 0.027012739330530167, -0.03762691095471382, -0.00048113433877006173, -0.06180151179432869, 0.0352218858897686, 0.01841413788497448, -0.005457114893943071, 0.02554706297814846, 0.007194212172180414, 0.00936819612979889, 0.023985687643289566, 0.011115177534520626, -0.009274105541408062, -0.050518978387117386, -0.041170358657836914, -0.0367424450814724, -0.015018660575151443, 0.03872963413596153, 0.02414926141500473, -0.030735209584236145, 0.025789866223931313, -0.006754397414624691, 0.042916812002658844, -0.00046875132829882205, 0.05071687698364258, -0.04388643056154251, 0.03806247189640999, 0.0024336352944374084, 0.028453504666686058, 0.023540550842881203, 0.020216912031173706, 0.12612026929855347, 0.09530933946371078, 0.056517165154218674, -0.03513483330607414, 0.03361910209059715, 0.005854490213096142, -0.04064954072237015, -0.013321533799171448, 0.00005697644519386813, 0.029298698529601097, 0.00178254465572536, 0.017181210219860077, 0.018757032230496407, 0.024929344654083252, -0.023728687316179276, 0.050553202629089355, -0.031955331563949585, 0.02599792182445526, 0.03034929744899273, 0.017755236476659775, 0.010526896454393864, -0.0143381142988801, -0.04365529492497444, 0.021670106798410416, 0.014069609344005585, -0.013042047619819641, -0.017324795946478844, -0.02636837400496006, -0.008034154772758484, -0.010863207280635834, -0.012395880185067654, 0.002516878768801689, -0.0014079805696383119, 0.0005511341732926667, -0.01025899313390255, -0.004568320699036121, 0.0010175511706620455, -0.01627586968243122, 0.03226197138428688, 0.031239435076713562, 0.023684227839112282, -0.026071535423398018, -0.026732681319117546, 0.034856945276260376, -0.06139036640524864, -0.007265781052410603, -0.06908653676509857, 0.035843465477228165, -0.0038901923689991236, -0.012888956815004349, 0.02142178826034069, -0.005589608568698168, 0.03570454195141792, -0.021374095231294632, -0.04767036810517311, 0.016092827543616295, 0.01768481358885765, -0.014058442786335945, -0.060889601707458496, -0.04212116822600365, 0.05028756707906723, -0.00011343370715621859, 0.039739370346069336, -0.016386866569519043, -0.034316014498472214, -0.009960179217159748, 0.014976352453231812, 0.03508049622178078, 0.029418107122182846, 0.04196419566869736, -0.009878935292363167, -0.03156305477023125, -0.03258096054196358, -0.01291540265083313, 0.027498966082930565, 0.007127875927835703, 0.006737806368619204, -0.009845959022641182, -0.02828069031238556, -0.011360589414834976, -0.017502179369330406, -0.003804886480793357, -0.025381917133927345, 0.007626539096236229, -0.04480905085802078, -0.008572421036660671, 0.0015276370104402304, 0.04248844087123871, 0.04242084175348282, -0.0092361094430089, 0.019907146692276, 0.026854464784264565, -0.025897877290844917, -0.022263851016759872, -0.05157354101538658, -0.010734819807112217, -0.03325248509645462, 0.025505702942609787, 0.007788064423948526, 0.06829555332660675, 0.014908187091350555, 0.005142467562109232, -0.014356105588376522, 0.03694939613342285, -0.01546399388462305, -0.005174089688807726, 0.01761988177895546, -0.05117964372038841, -0.02948257327079773, 0.018999459221959114, -0.0032654760871082544, -0.05020103231072426, -0.001014434965327382, -0.05709575489163399, -0.038631316274404526, 0.05140816792845726, -0.0311419814825058, -0.01083145197480917, 0.0018052688101306558, 0.005324411205947399, 0.022830158472061157, -0.019026707857847214, 0.003454037709161639, -0.03815826028585434, -0.0017877895152196288, -0.047582268714904785, -0.03248488903045654, 0.023546189069747925, 0.0025287445168942213, -0.023259857669472694, -0.017171254381537437, 0.02901977114379406, -0.011541235260665417, 0.010986260138452053, 0.013977319933474064, 0.022396374493837357, 0.022528503090143204, 0.030337875708937645, -0.05310613289475441, -0.005028191953897476, 0.025331828743219376, -0.036768533289432526, -0.007849412970244884, 0.030528711155056953, -0.02886808104813099, 0.03819311410188675, 0.01720483973622322, 0.009153289720416069, -0.011059273034334183, 0.026200097054243088, -0.026241805404424667, -0.02714959904551506, 0.007401699665933847, 0.01914394460618496, -0.006671622861176729, 0.0399012416601181, 0.04881297051906586, -0.005443887319415808, -0.028374243527650833, 0.022352509200572968, 0.04022689536213875, 0.024625172838568687, -0.023852629587054253, -0.00036821409594267607, 0.0025805295445024967, 0.035503461956977844, 0.006649488117545843, -0.0028108723927289248, -0.005045827478170395, 0.04640175774693489, -0.021934403106570244, 0.05918425694108009, -0.003851938061416149, -0.0006027827621437609, -0.0910225510597229, -0.01950962282717228, 0.03645962104201317, 0.018678616732358932, 0.019651593640446663, -0.06730525195598602, 0.0197945237159729, 0.016741622239351273, -0.03279897943139076, 0.03636932373046875, -0.01004023663699627, -0.011513881385326385, -0.03430167958140373, 0.005204333458095789, -0.054746828973293304, -0.010667604394257069, 0.025954876095056534, 0.003628911217674613, 0.04346292465925217, 0.02546806074678898, -0.021044466644525528, 0.008182603865861893, -0.04086054861545563, 0.006777419243007898, 0.0036541351582854986, -0.032376036047935486, 0.04540267959237099, -0.024204205721616745, -0.0744517371058464, 0.041990555822849274, 0.006206980906426907, -0.001357567380182445, 0.024081839248538017, 0.010206778533756733, 0.019887316972017288, 0.03422712907195091, 0.060085754841566086, -0.022960897535085678, 0.021818414330482483, 0.03850176930427551, 0.003575378330424428, -0.010732063092291355, -0.006696809083223343, 0.022655995562672615, 0.016334161162376404, 0.013036555610597134, -0.01276027224957943, 0.031307607889175415, -0.008184872567653656, -0.01561674103140831, -0.009042289108037949, 0.04956519976258278, 0.0025804927572607994, -0.030426038429141045, -0.00554098654538393, -0.0267675518989563, 0.011371546424925327, 0.02252921089529991, 0.0018124623456969857, -0.027600407600402832, -0.0042474353685975075, -0.021294955164194107, -0.054088834673166275, -0.02321685291826725, 0.011723908595740795, 0.006470502819865942, -0.0499013215303421, 0.025164831429719925, 0.017284944653511047, -0.0324871651828289, -0.030784767121076584, -0.021290436387062073, -0.005468198098242283, 0.05482352524995804, -0.04828202724456787, 0.07130913436412811, 0.016535449773073196, -0.04964177682995796, -0.0010676933452486992, -0.09643025696277618, 0.04005032777786255, -0.010320053435862064, -0.022271553054451942, 0.01564873196184635, 0.0074772583320736885, -0.05070453882217407, -0.029405636712908745, 0.03390611335635185, 0.0372539758682251, 0.01000248920172453, -0.01571171171963215, 0.010383703745901585, -0.0022113467566668987, -0.06666237860918045, 0.04155217111110687, -0.029453514143824577, -0.03394930809736252, -0.0039005253929644823, -0.028002573177218437, -0.026783399283885956, 0.012079361826181412, 0.011298896744847298, -0.004390023648738861, -0.000500048219691962, 0.03042258508503437, -0.014656277373433113, 0.055038344115018845, -0.013332083821296692, 0.04385219141840935, 0.05308716744184494, 0.017899950966238976, 0.020495373755693436, -0.0036083452869206667, 0.02591545134782791, -0.07574953883886337, 0.002434230875223875, -0.04898390546441078, -0.022856641560792923, -0.0013591143069788814, 0.05512091517448425, -0.016113439574837685, -0.043327465653419495, 0.023437924683094025, 0.011844826862215996, -0.020228739827871323, 0.0029191444627940655, 0.03001684509217739, 0.02966391295194626, 0.02257109060883522, -0.01838565245270729, 0.021405670791864395, 0.0052878232672810555, -0.003728060517460108, -0.013451620936393738, 0.002991842105984688, 0.025299640372395515, 0.012302985414862633, 0.038082923740148544, 0.00858160201460123, -0.004759758245199919, 0.04301460087299347, 0.001224013278260827, 0.0675438866019249, -0.030420534312725067, -0.006220229901373386, 0.04199674725532532, -0.0011564504820853472, 0.014137990772724152, -0.028608178719878197, 0.020929692313075066, 0.06289651244878769, -0.04591081291437149, -0.017674487084150314, -0.05448618158698082, -0.05720095708966255, -0.009113081730902195, 0.010251517407596111, 0.002965375082567334, 0.04676932469010353, 0.002823550021275878, 0.02780868485569954, -0.03383142128586769, -0.02449467033147812, 0.035147905349731445, 0.0028597654309123755, 0.032574571669101715, -0.007550729904323816, -0.022294359281659126, 0.031450700014829636, -0.011249465867877007, -0.006384995300322771, 0.00007749234646325931, -0.006799167487770319, 0.06119222566485405, 0.043303411453962326, -0.0028910147957503796, -0.03160412237048149, -0.007130028679966927, 0.018308019265532494, -0.057619813829660416, -0.0057111093774437904, -0.05680815875530243, 0.011710412800312042, 0.0016545862890779972, -0.03267467021942139 ]
<p>My understanding is that a hazard ratio from a Cox <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_hazards_model" rel="nofollow">proportional hazards model</a> compares the effect on the hazard rate of a given factor to a reference group. Does that actual group have to exist in the data?</p> <p>Say we enroll people in a study of how long before they buy a couch. We right-censor at 3 years. For this example we have two factors: age &lt; 30 or >= 30, whether they own a cat. It turns out the hazard ratio of "owns cat" to the reference group (age &lt; 30, "doesn't own cat") is 1.2, and significant (say p&lt;0.05). Do I know that the data includes people with age &lt; 30 who don't own a cat?</p> <p>For this example it seems a little crazy, but if there are many factors in the model, it becomes easier to imagine that there might be no data for some combination of factors, and that might end up as the reference group if chosen arbitrarily. In fact I think I've had that happen (in R, if it matters).</p>
74,501
[ -0.017679724842309952, 0.022372186183929443, 0.02374434471130371, -0.037882447242736816, 0.034800928086042404, 0.018267588689923286, -0.035987451672554016, 0.013970338739454746, 0.04556989297270775, -0.06290038675069809, 0.014666273258626461, 0.021503321826457977, 0.042287133634090424, 0.018256206065416336, 0.009728992357850075, 0.015214864164590836, -0.007863462902605534, -0.011088312603533268, -0.0009225528337992728, 0.010652254335582256, 0.007460230961441994, 0.03432481363415718, 0.017358379438519478, -0.010011601261794567, 0.014387201517820358, 0.03444484621286392, 0.016583284363150597, -0.023296676576137543, 0.0021579002495855093, 0.02788025140762329, 0.00321245938539505, -0.02563801035284996, -0.006386078894138336, 0.0011514879297465086, 0.020907940343022346, 0.05178070440888405, -0.000701116572599858, 0.0007624455029144883, -0.002351578092202544, 0.048263754695653915, -0.06151898205280304, -0.00015027042536530644, -0.02945890836417675, 0.03604413568973541, -0.024997733533382416, -0.0003692629106808454, 0.011424722149968147, -0.022757867351174355, 0.04526761174201965, -0.018135664984583855, 0.06838606297969818, -0.015324662439525127, 0.049271874129772186, 0.018536696210503578, -0.0010218811221420765, 0.003231494454666972, 0.040608350187540054, 0.07647068798542023, -0.013989189639687538, -0.028264619410037994, -0.06260122358798981, -0.006255405489355326, -0.006286789197474718, -0.013585581444203854, -0.018729375675320625, -0.020382998511195183, -0.010730365291237831, -0.0687813088297844, 0.010639943182468414, -0.0038496714551001787, 0.0066628423519432545, -0.02292637899518013, 0.04234417527914047, 0.04109065979719162, 0.013791400007903576, -0.010926597751677036, 0.027261778712272644, 0.030804108828306198, 0.03386302664875984, 0.020458992570638657, -0.002877478487789631, -0.028377791866660118, -0.0035829353146255016, 0.05309845134615898, 0.01557104755192995, -0.014823277480900288, 0.03881107643246651, -0.03719881549477577, 0.024466870352625847, 0.034783985465765, -0.016977354884147644, -0.004268068820238113, 0.02783975377678871, -0.015985742211341858, -0.045602601021528244, 0.05161159113049507, -0.008654391393065453, 0.016106892377138138, 0.0069909957237541676, 0.03828634321689606, -0.018434256315231323, -0.04902142658829689, 0.01732868328690529, 0.006438449956476688, -0.01957915723323822, -0.006068636197596788, -0.03969541937112808, -0.011794296093285084, 0.0015668930718675256, -0.040887221693992615, -0.033065181225538254, 0.006532325875014067, -0.01967446506023407, -0.008983445353806019, 0.0029880953952670097, 0.01716354303061962, 0.003609820269048214, -0.051925260573625565, 0.09517279267311096, 0.03835112228989601, 0.055960800498723984, 0.0052912007085978985, 0.011832589283585548, -0.0059476676397025585, -0.04939714074134827, 0.01663210615515709, 0.027780644595623016, -0.022680899128317833, -0.02674945257604122, 0.053463246673345566, 0.010312419384717941, -0.008329535834491253, 0.07781891524791718, 0.018456431105732918, 0.021683672443032265, -0.016224203631281853, -0.09251707792282104, -0.0336461067199707, 0.04667610302567482, 0.012207403779029846, -0.02461070381104946, -0.06467951834201813, 0.006156697403639555, 0.04615852236747742, 0.04676690325140953, -0.019080962985754013, 0.0366196408867836, -0.03135775774717331, 0.00948292762041092, 0.010854199528694153, -0.012849502265453339, 0.0013799256412312388, -0.004661766346544027, -0.02940978854894638, -0.03259718790650368, -0.08687025308609009, 0.020513033494353294, 0.010374602861702442, 0.03174879029393196, -0.006810027174651623, 0.0190616175532341, -0.03069997765123844, -0.03133382275700569, 0.026422467082738876, -0.017043765634298325, -0.0353921577334404, 0.05170949175953865, -0.03942282125353813, 0.01356451865285635, 0.014991643838584423, 0.05218721181154251, 0.04322677478194237, 0.033235229551792145, 0.07030834257602692, 0.02728274092078209, -0.0040011536329984665, -0.004358151461929083, -0.020243115723133087, 0.014727185480296612, 0.011723032221198082, -0.07060779631137848, 0.01634841039776802, -0.0017180648865178227, -0.017477044835686684, 0.013638263568282127, -0.0004508672282099724, -0.012555066496133804, -0.012242221273481846, 0.048362672328948975, -0.011016413569450378, -0.0468301922082901, -0.06881831586360931, -0.029672536998987198, -0.03622310981154442, -0.013606672175228596, 0.0243841540068388, 0.012782741338014603, -0.011380424723029137, -0.02757040597498417, -0.011506241746246815, -0.01809508353471756, -0.014663325622677803, 0.015838416293263435, -0.05780569463968277, 0.002124638296663761, 0.011969651095569134, 0.048722852021455765, -0.004453736357390881, 0.04734040051698685, -0.05496066436171532, -0.04492177814245224, 0.009273529052734375, -0.029910827055573463, 0.006605988834053278, -0.00809810496866703, -0.021512694656848907, 0.0031669852323830128, -0.024158360436558723, -0.022627878934144974, 0.06754372268915176, -0.05098380893468857, 0.052732743322849274, 0.05000165104866028, -0.006138728465884924, 0.005244475789368153, 0.00851679127663374, 0.02140294387936592, -0.00922608096152544, -0.0264268945902586, -0.018199780955910683, -0.021137867122888565, -0.03525366261601448, 0.055250637233257294, -0.022761624306440353, -0.01671637035906315, 0.049625977873802185, 0.02214505895972252, 0.04063359275460243, 0.004837120417505503, 0.033976249396800995, 0.023518558591604233, 0.01638041064143181, 0.008806631900370121, 0.03779637813568115, 0.0006825902964919806, -0.011729896999895573, 0.01214173249900341, -0.009289240464568138, 0.05439010262489319, -0.0214927289634943, -0.004720883443951607, 0.06404333561658859, 0.013902809470891953, -0.00209438381716609, 0.046575795859098434, -0.0004462498181965202, 0.029382318258285522, -0.024077635258436203, 0.020355787128210068, 0.002784156007692218, 0.02030295319855213, -0.02499312162399292, 0.024713223800063133, -0.044588442891836166, 0.017699403688311577, 0.04943752661347389, -0.0783877745270729, 0.0185930784791708, 0.010316058993339539, -0.03256085887551308, -0.01197132933884859, -0.01258272398263216, -0.030480556190013885, -0.004926178604364395, -0.0018501956947147846, 0.014883884228765965, 0.007456916384398937, 0.05324966460466385, 0.005245018284767866, -0.02412075735628605, -0.0013135583139955997, -0.03215866535902023, 0.013821500353515148, 0.03331667184829712, -0.020775360986590385, 0.01932777650654316, -0.04339094087481499, -0.019163774326443672, 0.013713418506085873, -0.0021938043646514416, -0.02600759081542492, -0.014583241194486618, -0.027066227048635483, -0.03060727007687092, -0.05035047605633736, -0.051628079265356064, -0.021661289036273956, -0.024688946083188057, -0.03264379873871803, 0.011480346322059631, 0.017306435853242874, -0.010956013575196266, 0.03809976950287819, -0.03167201951146126, -0.030461348593235016, -0.004315007012337446, -0.007624710910022259, 0.021416326984763145, -0.011563054285943508, 0.012339850887656212, 0.007740165572613478, -0.03118704818189144, -0.0003952024271711707, -0.05798032134771347, -0.09703920036554337, 0.03543198108673096, 0.02647971361875534, 0.009267943911254406, 0.03850485011935234, 0.024175437167286873, 0.089408278465271, 0.044935934245586395, -0.015475817956030369, -0.01796754077076912, -0.007832078263163567, -0.022415651008486748, -0.0528850220143795, 0.0017499930690973997, 0.01586546003818512, 0.016020027920603752, 0.027795733883976936, -0.013292727991938591, 0.03812859207391739, 0.036605484783649445, -0.005082577001303434, 0.028614014387130737, 0.03706542029976845, 0.01909390464425087, 0.00029004854150116444, 0.05084019526839256, 0.06979531794786453, 0.005684792995452881, 0.012138566933572292, -0.006914583500474691, 0.054280154407024384, 0.00011092032946180552, -0.051862020045518875, -0.009573681280016899, -0.013277783058583736, 0.009700317867100239, -0.03186289593577385, 0.01831667125225067, 0.011976170353591442, -0.0033933764789253473, 0.003477758029475808, 0.0026689881924539804, 0.03210998326539993, -0.035046305507421494, -0.017660152167081833, 0.005937797017395496, 0.026826797053217888, 0.008492647670209408, 0.005315031390637159, -0.026275375857949257, -0.004108137916773558, 0.0289424080401659, 0.0017198326531797647, -0.028234751895070076, 0.05408898741006851, 0.011979134753346443, 0.05592948570847511, -0.0439302958548069, -0.04269350692629814, 0.0018273477908223867, -0.03835340961813927, 0.008651749230921268, -0.017911871895194054, 0.06048078089952469, 0.00027927503106184304, 0.01927941106259823, 0.0030384717974811792, -0.025387626141309738, -0.05208342522382736, 0.005499814637005329, -0.03228068724274635, 0.011533157899975777, -0.027248213067650795, -0.011413928121328354, 0.0011773542501032352, -0.04085886478424072, 0.059590648859739304, -0.0014464048435911536, 0.0013411364052444696, -0.008889489807188511, 0.027230840176343918, -0.047210101038217545, 0.013985158875584602, -0.019802188500761986, -0.012257137335836887, 0.010225021280348301, -0.021186497062444687, 0.03423761576414108, 0.009841129183769226, -0.0028616494964808226, 0.06374190747737885, -0.009358289651572704, 0.014406416565179825, -0.034151628613471985, 0.00466789910569787, 0.036273445934057236, 0.027427857741713524, 0.021796327084302902, 0.033656664192676544, -0.0280775036662817, 0.02036331593990326, -0.011960604228079319, 0.02574343793094158, 0.042774591594934464, -0.0034356084652245045, -0.01895177736878395, -0.02977711334824562, -0.04994981735944748, -0.007197079248726368, 0.007353213150054216, -0.004845188464969397, 0.0019620296079665422, 0.07171384990215302, 0.03817954659461975, -0.06308628618717194, 0.000006907584975124337, 0.019601652398705482, 0.01463603600859642, 0.006824458483606577, -0.010642106644809246, 0.004302646033465862, 0.018850402906537056, -0.03701057285070419, 0.0071852239780128, 0.007236961741000414, -0.006677577272057533, 0.0001049255151883699, 0.009664973244071007, -0.010354282334446907, -0.029868608340620995, 0.011450933292508125, 0.03739399090409279, 0.01719444990158081, 0.005894007161259651, -0.025318825617432594, 0.021899549290537834, 0.030764464288949966, 0.007220285478979349, 0.0024622443597763777, -0.017194902524352074, -0.07480847835540771, 0.025915175676345825, 0.04381778463721275, 0.058962851762771606, -0.027556581422686577, -0.019566180184483528, -0.0027164057828485966, -0.01721663773059845, 0.022892560809850693, -0.03355316072702408, -0.00454814312979579, -0.020765192806720734, -0.022315772250294685, -0.0135943703353405, -0.03597915172576904, -0.02118591219186783, 0.0034006857313215733, -0.017331760376691818, 0.006717927288264036, 0.025837702676653862, -0.028074972331523895, -0.038030751049518585, 0.04437487572431564, -0.005376880988478661, 0.03269684687256813, -0.0406859926879406, -0.012251034379005432, 0.028532644733786583, 0.02433580905199051, -0.02369503490626812, -0.07597654312849045, 0.012024248018860817, -0.015115221031010151, 0.02243686653673649, 0.08832241594791412, 0.009817025624215603, -0.0259637963026762, 0.017850879579782486, 0.00980844721198082, -0.03059072606265545, 0.0048590837977826595, -0.012225016951560974, 0.03537629917263985, -0.0012724582338705659, -0.05159616097807884, 0.08557872474193573, 0.022243725135922432, 0.029420575127005577, -0.0024252114817500114, -0.024287177249789238, 0.02256329171359539, -0.029056351631879807, 0.022169627249240875, -0.07266148179769516, -0.015034200623631477, 0.01665646582841873, -0.006076956167817116, -0.01179814338684082, 0.02700950764119625, -0.0003821331192739308, 0.0056732213124632835, 0.04832695424556732, -0.01674673706293106, 0.011287984438240528, -0.006710648536682129, 0.01909719966351986, -0.0009115537395700812, -0.0015443071024492383, -0.02643350325524807, 0.02085965871810913, -0.027212727814912796, 0.019876059144735336, 0.014937007799744606, -0.0296657532453537, -0.010283272713422775, -0.01714928261935711, -0.048602111637592316, 0.013863170519471169, -0.004916197620332241, 0.030467813834547997, -0.018558641895651817, 0.032180339097976685, -0.013318915851414204, -0.015223215334117413, 0.01324984710663557, 0.009413382038474083, 0.00764745008200407, 0.04397420957684517, -0.012010953389108181, 0.05195528268814087, -0.013090032152831554, 0.001201035687699914, -0.06239931657910347, -0.02008219249546528, 0.0037438473664224148, 0.015331300906836987, -0.052438002079725266, -0.03237147256731987, 0.01532096415758133, -0.017851660028100014, -0.04902046546339989, 0.016830572858452797, 0.07129217684268951, -0.03734627738595009, -0.021619023755192757, -0.02777441032230854, 0.040515024214982986, 0.059329885989427567, -0.01087311003357172, -0.01721690408885479, 0.00919265951961279, 0.0025276083033531904, 0.009297818876802921, -0.0015916903503239155, 0.006001126021146774, -0.037630029022693634, -0.017331350594758987, -0.02205435186624527, -0.004660243634134531, 0.031089039519429207, -0.03323398903012276, -0.019036103039979935, 0.009202424436807632, -0.02401614934206009, 0.0333392508327961, -0.035089392215013504, -0.008214469999074936, 0.0077984267845749855, 0.02879788540303707, -0.016592370346188545, 0.002117346040904522, 0.007015469018369913, 0.0035019104834645987, 0.043061643838882446, -0.023456357419490814, 0.015532680787146091, 0.04143810644745827, 0.05251498147845268, -0.025069277733564377, 0.02765405923128128, -0.003913449123501778, -0.029772281646728516, 0.042451195418834686, 0.006078068632632494, -0.016545811668038368, 0.00684788404032588, 0.01867455430328846, -0.03679603710770607, 0.0029118561651557684, -0.06951669603586197, -0.009325157850980759, 0.04275301843881607, -0.02675000950694084, 0.03506823629140854, 0.0037043862976133823, -0.0295272059738636, -0.025616727769374847, -0.013944792561233044, -0.016640150919556618, 0.011306488886475563, 0.0062279654666781425, 0.04415291175246239, -0.03306206688284874, -0.002136851893737912, 0.03945784270763397, 0.026923008263111115, 0.019447479397058487, 0.05460875853896141, 0.0355084054172039, -0.0014726303052157164, 0.029703153297305107, 0.0022515328601002693, -0.006699426099658012, 0.028788316994905472, -0.032869309186935425, 0.013852947391569614, -0.045058198273181915, -0.02155527099967003, 0.040918804705142975, 0.023651856929063797, -0.032059699296951294, -0.06090784817934036, -0.06391815841197968, -0.025837894529104233, 0.01378085557371378, 0.01467227004468441, -0.0016298061236739159, 0.04532880708575249, -0.05446375906467438, 0.05085356533527374, 0.014239929616451263, 0.018529148772358894, -0.0016681831330060959, -0.06041010469198227, -0.017844388261437416, -0.00787549652159214, -0.03421232849359512, 0.021948212757706642, 0.00893038883805275, -0.017604131251573563, -0.0012434421805664897, -0.040587522089481354, 0.010259797796607018, -0.0005021183751523495, 0.0561569407582283, -0.014715183526277542, 0.07891518622636795, 0.026508456096053123, 0.022353945299983025, -0.008543373085558414, -0.008438858203589916, 0.12539170682430267, 0.054180216044187546, 0.02346022054553032, -0.02262159250676632, -0.0017870826413854957, 0.010653315111994743, 0.018897756934165955, -0.02784949727356434, 0.009232788346707821, 0.03290301188826561, 0.0181085504591465, 0.05431639403104782, 0.07183489948511124, 0.011257223784923553, 0.008300045505166054, 0.05777245759963989, -0.022913893684744835, -0.04846109449863434, 0.017453208565711975, 0.026885177940130234, 0.003330132458359003, -0.050353340804576874, 0.019590403884649277, 0.008977888152003288, 0.03653910383582115, 0.01826484128832817, -0.016865963116288185, -0.018064556643366814, -0.014167028479278088, 0.024771662428975105, -0.013206759467720985, -0.015841608867049217, -0.002444235375151038, 0.02206074446439743, -0.020018648356199265, -0.01444117072969675, -0.009304255247116089, -0.009307857602834702, -0.014719847589731216, 0.020652251318097115, -0.013934562914073467, -0.0014135332312434912, 0.019115911796689034, 0.004352143500000238, -0.03186652436852455, -0.034310657531023026, -0.025986764580011368, 0.014494834467768669, -0.046066224575042725, 0.010333296842873096, -0.0588650107383728, -0.014035748317837715, 0.010371417738497257, -0.03162240609526634, -0.027921516448259354, 0.03237834945321083, 0.022933125495910645, -0.022067388519644737, 0.013007750734686852, -0.023805268108844757, 0.02410423755645752, -0.00007797928992658854, 0.023760054260492325, 0.04901786893606186, -0.07484997063875198, -0.009341144934296608, -0.09158499538898468, 0.017597218975424767, -0.012457809410989285, 0.027004757896065712, -0.008759580552577972, -0.03542686626315117, -0.033918675035238266, -0.017233816906809807, 0.030227109789848328, 0.0406179204583168, 0.05941915884613991, -0.03997763618826866, -0.01823453977704048, -0.031125495210289955, -0.05466962978243828, -0.00364575139246881, -0.020870883017778397, -0.054910022765398026, -0.07853221148252487, -0.016471760347485542, -0.013777609914541245, 0.05973920226097107, 0.006730720400810242, 0.043226223438978195, 0.007095255423337221, 0.013844242319464684, -0.026384159922599792, -0.060718972235918045, 0.01716926321387291, 0.03624803572893143, -0.01606426015496254, 0.005023795645684004, 0.010213878005743027, 0.08174582570791245, 0.021930236369371414, 0.009346285834908485, 0.006892481818795204, 0.03439248353242874, 0.009210429154336452, 0.007575362455099821, 0.017369121313095093, -0.05380841717123985, -0.00163969153072685, 0.029265161603689194, 0.023792285472154617, -0.025925684720277786, -0.061167314648628235, -0.0403754785656929, -0.075445756316185, 0.00728852953761816, -0.02082432433962822, -0.008004826493561268, -0.03921481966972351, -0.029785774648189545, 0.05849277600646019, -0.03310006856918335, 0.0062188878655433655, -0.07374601811170578, 0.011322557926177979, 0.005330716725438833, -0.013364646583795547, -0.030072789639234543, -0.008908567950129509, 0.014072460122406483, 0.03269082307815552, -0.0048265908844769, 0.014802777208387852, 0.007898835465312004, -0.008274568244814873, -0.011685103178024292, 0.0032301980536431074, 0.04054692015051842, -0.007974809035658836, -0.007919985800981522, 0.06439965218305588, -0.043631814420223236, -0.007674139458686113, 0.03788843750953674, 0.0353650338947773, 0.04225203022360802, 0.004069824703037739, 0.011187123134732246, 0.00134470674674958, 0.057829584926366806, -0.051146406680345535, -0.03032786212861538, -0.008410177193582058, 0.0007554664043709636, 0.012910213321447372, -0.019527342170476913, -0.00295079592615366, -0.014150729402899742, -0.017321830615401268, 0.047340646386146545, 0.049725450575351715, 0.025141321122646332, -0.025942068547010422, 0.0081603042781353, -0.023799439892172813, -0.012996471486985683, 0.00025897283921949565, 0.058631908148527145, 0.021005449816584587, 0.03356727585196495, -0.028129376471042633, 0.056338246911764145, 0.008757833391427994, 0.015060355886816978, -0.0556882843375206, -0.04956894367933273, 0.007653151638805866, 0.00103614607360214, 0.010608307085931301, -0.025213494896888733, 0.006683963350951672, 0.02566598914563656, -0.0689738318324089, 0.021031642332673073, -0.013554384000599384, -0.01757803186774254, -0.07175786793231964, 0.01013084314763546, -0.011394927278161049, 0.042713191360235214, 0.06256580352783203, 0.01253863051533699, 0.037887390702962875, -0.009225916117429733, -0.010758203454315662, -0.05540130287408829, -0.01483441237360239, 0.023702003061771393, 0.0019930750131607056, -0.04367399215698242, 0.053180571645498276, -0.019763344898819923, -0.024871207773685455, 0.016409479081630707, 0.01577332243323326, 0.0289450753480196, 0.04964257776737213, 0.02195892296731472, 0.0037384023889899254, 0.012779602780938148, 0.08862219005823135, -0.00029008460114710033, -0.025894856080412865, 0.013321253471076488, -0.006105850450694561, 0.02926216833293438, -0.015337971970438957, 0.018031146377325058, 0.006955794058740139, -0.03124675527215004, -0.03265142813324928, 0.03402236849069595, 0.0014477412914857268, 0.0065269069746136665, 0.006649684626609087, -0.02595452032983303, -0.0012424287851899862, -0.02534632571041584, 0.04284389317035675, -0.0568111278116703, 0.004682796075940132, 0.0734371617436409, 0.027081318199634552, -0.017262594774365425, 0.032105546444654465, -0.042066872119903564, -0.046748802065849304, 0.0009611397399567068, 0.013161363080143929, -0.034692347049713135, -0.05506499484181404, -0.021659381687641144, -0.03657587990164757, -0.004454790148884058, -0.028798379004001617, 0.0005851482856087387, -0.05046609044075012, 0.043419208377599716, -0.028010815382003784, -0.003921945113688707, 0.009706208482384682, -0.010961237363517284, 0.006953882053494453, -0.08049064129590988, 0.06368432193994522, 0.042944103479385376, -0.0013493688311427832, -0.05254950746893883, -0.004762179218232632, -0.011122948490083218, -0.02406027913093567, 0.022084221243858337, 0.0024050686042755842, 0.031039724126458168, -0.010211033746600151, 0.011869416572153568, -0.025962140411138535, -0.04884492978453636, 0.032648444175720215, -0.00017416515038348734, 0.005134467501193285, -0.05871845409274101, 0.0486539788544178, -0.024737441912293434, -0.017908375710248947, 0.031315259635448456, -0.01380553375929594, 0.02318730391561985, 0.04483843967318535, 0.005901799071580172, 0.03928986191749573, 0.008954958990216255, 0.0020928140729665756, 0.020528560504317284, 0.005281468387693167, 0.03669501841068268, 0.07071751356124878, -0.019123436883091927, -0.04699796810746193, 0.028815511614084244, -0.018502987921237946, -0.03336067870259285, 0.018321482464671135, 0.0013782851165160537, 0.0067314463667571545, -0.0016335465479642153, -0.013323912397027016, 0.01927710324525833, -0.031729090958833694, 0.006386266089975834, -0.023832909762859344, 0.014829288236796856, 0.0332675501704216, -0.03844180330634117, 0.025300893932580948, -0.002788929268717766, -0.07277892529964447, 0.025885675102472305, -0.01100251730531454, 0.0065193031914532185, -0.002817467087879777, 0.016145039349794388, 0.023901043459773064, -0.0008155090035870671, -0.011978225782513618, 0.008878352120518684, 0.06750711798667908, -0.028298737481236458, -0.0014142808504402637, -0.002262651454657316, -0.04218655079603195, 0.03272726759314537, -0.00707263732329011, 0.010326109826564789, 0.04930390417575836, 0.015869949012994766, 0.011529759503901005, -0.0013853423297405243, 0.02782653458416462, -0.041658516973257065, 0.013819499872624874, 0.028338579460978508, 0.046150363981723785, -0.025532852858304977, -0.010182964615523815, -0.021672969684004784, -0.02575523406267166, 0.025224432349205017, -0.01181456446647644, 0.02906969003379345, 0.001439873012714088, -0.04717165604233742, -0.0018577517475932837, -0.028503727167844772, -0.032965704798698425, -0.025342373177409172, 0.030201004818081856, 0.053449325263500214, 0.024214603006839752, -0.03338198736310005, -0.00886134896427393, 0.03970801457762718, 0.00043344165896996856, -0.07811562716960907, -0.01030402909964323, -0.051551297307014465, 0.0023895525373518467, 0.0010273216757923365, -0.00868796557188034 ]
<p><em>Mathematics and Statistics are quite far behind in my educational curriculum, and yet now I seem to need them again, so this set of questions is very basic I suppose:</em></p> <h2>What is a trend line? What various types of trend lines are there? And what are their respective use or relevance?</h2> <h3>Background:</h3> <p>I'm working on a thesis and I am producing some visual rendering of a survey I ran, in which I tried to measure public knowledge of (colonial) history and heritage in a town of Kerala, India.</p> <p>I have data for instance, representing the result of a test, the average result of which is compared to various criteria of the population (age, education, etc.) With regard to criteria such as age-group, income or education, it is also interesting to find out whether their increase improves the results.</p> <p>I am working on this data with LibreOffice, which offers me the possibility to show a "trend line", and I suppose the trend-line is adequate to show the relation between <em>x</em> and <em>y</em>, i.e. criteria and result. However, there are 4 types of trend lines available: <em>linear, logarithmic, exponential</em> and <em>power</em>.</p> <p>Which one should I chose? Which difference does it make? How would I figure out a trend line if LibreOffice would not do it for me?</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trend_line" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a> brings some light on those questions. Although I am not sure whether I should look at linear regression or technical trend line analysis.</p> <p>Could you please provide a short "Trend Line for Dummies" introduction? Thanks :)</p>
37,397
[ -0.0332745686173439, -0.029080931097269058, -0.005021245684474707, 0.03253714367747307, 0.035853806883096695, 0.012694114819169044, -0.012177164666354656, 0.009035859256982803, 0.04159753397107124, -0.02881013974547386, 0.06830497086048126, 0.02644258365035057, 0.06274455040693283, 0.03669656068086624, 0.03205689415335655, 0.01557049062103033, -0.006102931685745716, 0.052670929580926895, -0.020318664610385895, -0.01623893715441227, 0.009930131956934929, -0.00771028408780694, 0.007955065928399563, 0.016270369291305542, -0.030585113912820816, 0.0626637190580368, 0.045027296990156174, -0.015270225703716278, -0.013943628408014774, 0.055886782705783844, -0.04985414072871208, -0.049959052354097366, 0.010617381893098354, 0.00831034779548645, 0.022502010688185692, 0.013168133795261383, 0.04320855438709259, -0.015191790647804737, 0.05024745315313339, 0.037155430763959885, -0.02480156347155571, -0.04602068290114403, 0.013890722766518593, 0.02064349688589573, -0.04415412247180939, 0.019926749169826508, 0.001079645357094705, -0.03909249231219292, 0.014842935837805271, -0.03429258242249489, 0.03709106147289276, -0.02503962069749832, 0.040617864578962326, 0.021851293742656708, -0.014024279080331326, 0.012344595976173878, 0.021470017731189728, 0.037539511919021606, -0.03692658618092537, -0.05191551893949509, 0.0018238392658531666, 0.01817241683602333, -0.015863565728068352, 0.008512228727340698, -0.03452737256884575, 0.030535783618688583, -0.019554633647203445, 0.013146857731044292, 0.06307137757539749, -0.04186199977993965, 0.002676695352420211, 0.040971044450998306, 0.05664964020252228, -0.007819144986569881, -0.0002305544912815094, -0.03827628120779991, 0.002280970336869359, 0.01694786548614502, 0.06673935055732727, 0.08467982709407806, -0.010473103262484074, 0.01341745350509882, 0.03517886996269226, 0.0546986386179924, 0.028147440403699875, -0.0034871548414230347, 0.09670567512512207, -0.029429249465465546, -0.0056317453272640705, 0.020978935062885284, 0.07025542855262756, -0.018330097198486328, 0.016289103776216507, -0.03037669137120247, 0.009270905517041683, 0.026953866705298424, -0.01822449266910553, 0.01736857183277607, 0.03487517312169075, 0.009879760444164276, 0.010066301561892033, 0.005480899475514889, 0.03625265508890152, 0.038875896483659744, -0.031289760023355484, 0.020299667492508888, -0.004819625057280064, -0.04033263027667999, -0.009133122861385345, -0.017788920551538467, -0.01956259272992611, 0.006033374462276697, 0.017750060185790062, 0.03072013519704342, -0.015060988254845142, -0.00005704323484678753, 0.025543134659528732, 0.019191063940525055, 0.07438960671424866, 0.030891334637999535, 0.019538991153240204, -0.04825728014111519, 0.019946804270148277, 0.0038402967620640993, -0.046854451298713684, -0.013172345235943794, 0.0024902629666030407, -0.011597289703786373, -0.05274439975619316, 0.05356951057910919, -0.040577370673418045, -0.019816938787698746, 0.017722103744745255, -0.015496691688895226, 0.032712098211050034, 0.0400458462536335, -0.07116053998470306, -0.055404406040906906, 0.06528452783823013, 0.02751474827528, -0.006582924630492926, -0.048137303441762924, -0.02890079654753208, 0.00570438988506794, 0.012383539229631424, 0.005370841361582279, -0.0012306647840887308, 0.02489274926483631, 0.01569163054227829, 0.018178265541791916, -0.036646768450737, 0.017802095040678978, 0.036375630646944046, -0.023540137335658073, 0.0028857861179858446, -0.061818938702344894, 0.0008801732328720391, 0.038342803716659546, -0.009999068453907967, -0.020210599526762962, 0.0768842026591301, 0.023736003786325455, -0.005397162865847349, -0.0000711789689376019, -0.0000743371929274872, -0.027782099321484566, 0.05730447545647621, -0.015242485329508781, 0.03982444107532501, 0.03245249390602112, 0.010145638138055801, 0.029573995620012283, 0.022913968190550804, -0.0010677056852728128, 0.03510725125670433, -0.018982941284775734, -0.0050306739285588264, -0.03992820903658867, -0.053476400673389435, 0.006782403215765953, -0.08795983344316483, -0.06235351786017418, -0.0047911773435771465, 0.015670765191316605, 0.02540397457778454, 0.0396181084215641, 0.00014313111023511738, -0.002090351888909936, 0.025088248774409294, -0.029059959575533867, -0.044170867651700974, -0.07318976521492004, 0.028661102056503296, 0.007713492959737778, 0.0016634921776130795, 0.009746349416673183, -0.034927599132061005, 0.000009443927410757169, -0.019847847521305084, -0.00154549116268754, 0.012346422299742699, 0.027025358751416206, 0.04899738356471062, -0.03850013017654419, 0.015348691493272781, 0.05082457885146141, 0.03158626705408096, -0.03979756310582161, -0.013858983293175697, -0.04967588931322098, -0.01727668009698391, 0.016189701855182648, -0.014873926527798176, 0.02534354478120804, -0.010433798655867577, -0.014337175525724888, -0.046062108129262924, 0.028857896104454994, -0.02567693218588829, 0.03161737695336342, -0.025185134261846542, 0.06964045017957687, 0.04750712960958481, 0.02660978212952614, 0.025568388402462006, 0.0012095595011487603, 0.02501712366938591, 0.04992778226733208, 0.006432314403355122, -0.02840298041701317, -0.03837147355079651, 0.024432599544525146, 0.01711622066795826, 0.008970104157924652, -0.04370841383934021, 0.015089022926986217, 0.03579297289252281, 0.026759525761008263, -0.009191184304654598, 0.027122419327497482, -0.03879876062273979, 0.0005335091263987124, -0.04305568337440491, 0.0035927854478359222, -0.01128876581788063, 0.03055471181869507, -0.0009716303320601583, 0.012204675003886223, 0.0493735633790493, 0.03168606758117676, 0.008454766124486923, 0.030581358820199966, 0.0053051533177495, 0.0018795063951984048, -0.015378027223050594, 0.015143492259085178, 0.03123427927494049, -0.056955620646476746, -0.016551822423934937, 0.021544083952903748, 0.03502678871154785, -0.013147237710654736, 0.022820277139544487, -0.023457007482647896, -0.003515174612402916, 0.004026113543659449, -0.010449249297380447, 0.0041250623762607574, 0.028680987656116486, -0.03363143652677536, 0.02911200374364853, -0.050074681639671326, -0.04695015773177147, -0.044958651065826416, -0.0309665035456419, 0.03275880590081215, 0.010522059164941311, 0.023084986954927444, -0.05668364837765694, -0.026798391714692116, 0.003775296499952674, -0.03436856344342232, 0.01163935475051403, -0.028134994208812714, -0.03875543549656868, -0.011209542863070965, -0.020609423518180847, -0.013467610813677311, 0.03837808221578598, 0.015504640527069569, 0.0031994732562452555, 0.051757246255874634, 0.020047692582011223, -0.06881395727396011, -0.06639492511749268, -0.025323132053017616, 0.02740924060344696, 0.017246311530470848, -0.0077361008152365685, 0.03434884175658226, -0.06555298715829849, -0.012367572635412216, 0.04741529002785683, -0.05213676765561104, -0.051694974303245544, -0.06486545503139496, 0.02160746417939663, -0.014480026438832283, 0.018632452934980392, -0.005838900804519653, 0.01316926907747984, -0.024760877713561058, -0.011043427512049675, -0.060009270906448364, -0.03918753191828728, 0.022989630699157715, -0.03239249438047409, 0.07499931752681732, -0.003906700760126114, -0.02392202615737915, 0.03402639552950859, 0.03166826441884041, -0.05440850555896759, -0.058884866535663605, -0.017828375101089478, -0.015967044979333878, -0.06243222951889038, 0.036352530121803284, 0.026905780658125877, -0.001843053032644093, -0.011768384836614132, -0.003512496128678322, 0.05007610470056534, 0.03458833321928978, 0.0009471889934502542, 0.012416188605129719, -0.022233933210372925, -0.022811057046055794, -0.01408021803945303, 0.04683960601687431, 0.028464585542678833, -0.04370228573679924, 0.003621631534770131, -0.042928628623485565, 0.056903500109910965, 0.032279517501592636, -0.05258873477578163, 0.019798144698143005, 0.006111332215368748, -0.019866298884153366, -0.02288120985031128, 0.006963218096643686, 0.04411403462290764, -0.0024782761465758085, -0.031683772802352905, -0.0020131641067564487, 0.04002806171774864, -0.02601414918899536, 0.005419156979769468, 0.01961885578930378, 0.07214304059743881, -0.029339870437979698, 0.022647377103567123, -0.001528287655673921, 0.022164616733789444, 0.002628576010465622, -0.01889023743569851, 0.0156239103525877, 0.029993347823619843, 0.05421725660562515, -0.012129069305956364, 0.006713616196066141, -0.06899993121623993, -0.012757868506014347, -0.05893116071820259, -0.031688667833805084, -0.03172947093844414, 0.06599706411361694, -0.009102418087422848, 0.043614014983177185, 0.010417756624519825, -0.007602144498378038, 0.0211549811065197, -0.04141397401690483, -0.06151692941784859, 0.03469531238079071, -0.04049864411354065, -0.010192500427365303, 0.010410517454147339, 0.018840046599507332, 0.0023508062586188316, 0.0019837594591081142, -0.032615602016448975, -0.03928099572658539, -0.009615179151296616, -0.01755920983850956, 0.02233187109231949, -0.04656454548239708, -0.014603040181100368, 0.012562405318021774, -0.0012179685290902853, -0.01021654438227415, -0.03439250588417053, 0.048526257276535034, 0.029513470828533173, 0.0328226201236248, 0.008126995526254177, 0.002581880195066333, -0.01830914057791233, 0.013025575317442417, 0.016754545271396637, -0.007607240695506334, -0.0030073532834649086, -0.06251746416091919, 0.04575694724917412, 0.008546454831957817, 0.04217659309506416, 0.018423501402139664, -0.005824470426887274, -0.009943856857717037, -0.02946133352816105, 0.002387044485658407, 0.014845812693238258, 0.008037528023123741, 0.030564168468117714, 0.012563600204885006, 0.041354380548000336, 0.02965233288705349, -0.043152377009391785, 0.06917884945869446, 0.0313047431409359, -0.026972506195306778, 0.04463997483253479, -0.017484933137893677, -0.014139922335743904, 0.014722254127264023, -0.01950523816049099, -0.006809028796851635, 0.028402704745531082, -0.006565473973751068, -0.007125777658075094, 0.03177184984087944, 0.005996093153953552, -0.0189060065895319, -0.006851492915302515, 0.02933315560221672, 0.04507269337773323, -0.011606549844145775, -0.02852790616452694, 0.02319498360157013, 0.037188488990068436, 0.028657227754592896, 0.016622262075543404, 0.025585103780031204, -0.0872088149189949, -0.023131292313337326, 0.04099235311150551, 0.039208605885505676, -0.03624330088496208, -0.04756568744778633, -0.03717530146241188, -0.0031094958540052176, 0.013930374756455421, -0.02914123795926571, -0.016228312626481056, -0.031004637479782104, 0.004578873049467802, -0.03988184779882431, -0.00773752573877573, -0.04774368181824684, 0.0028411869425326586, -0.006414318922907114, 0.01579565927386284, -0.04140501469373703, -0.006990642286837101, -0.05263209342956543, 0.04692467302083969, -0.016708066686987877, 0.038509029895067215, -0.03513859212398529, -0.009245960973203182, 0.02033216319978237, -0.004244894254952669, -0.023965105414390564, -0.07887744158506393, -0.005488800350576639, 0.0004849013057537377, -0.013679927214980125, 0.039705581963062286, 0.008785884827375412, -0.02175852097570896, -0.01884617656469345, 0.014011786319315434, -0.029477441683411598, 0.019877085462212563, -0.0031437899451702833, 0.02095222845673561, 0.03882197290658951, 0.022930540144443512, 0.030815061181783676, 0.052823763340711594, 0.009887982159852982, -0.0018148368690162897, -0.008104038424789906, 0.009269527159631252, -0.0178120955824852, 0.010049104690551758, -0.03641487658023834, -0.0011351668508723378, -0.0503486730158329, 0.02305171824991703, 0.009945536963641644, -0.013043493032455444, -0.031625330448150635, -0.005236954893916845, -0.0008906673174351454, 0.010103841312229633, -0.012537987902760506, -0.01272303145378828, 0.02877196855843067, 0.016725026071071625, 0.011032716371119022, -0.00292580877430737, 0.03896103426814079, -0.008648085407912731, 0.011615078896284103, 0.0317721851170063, -0.011258457787334919, 0.021846938878297806, -0.019714169204235077, -0.01878846436738968, 0.0023553313221782446, -0.025438200682401657, 0.05921796336770058, 0.027226446196436882, 0.022045675665140152, 0.02316962741315365, -0.032442815601825714, 0.010878210887312889, 0.03593293949961662, 0.00892594177275896, -0.0007621411932632327, -0.012289721518754959, 0.018964113667607307, 0.0027633258141577244, 0.003858353942632675, -0.038168974220752716, -0.04599587619304657, 0.043912649154663086, 0.014235218986868858, -0.03864250332117081, 0.015740852802991867, -0.0033935660030692816, -0.0018489295616745949, -0.031972721219062805, -0.014359043911099434, 0.043125707656145096, -0.04465293139219284, -0.029726484790444374, 0.002912952797487378, 0.033343855291604996, 0.12031382322311401, -0.03608646243810654, -0.03579841926693916, 0.009005319327116013, 0.019778341054916382, 0.01796817034482956, -0.04997045546770096, 0.03567550331354141, -0.03595060482621193, -0.007309990935027599, -0.01876981183886528, -0.007190329488366842, 0.037043482065200806, -0.05344260856509209, 0.0006042278837412596, 0.03575705736875534, -0.00408219126984477, 0.002456479240208864, -0.017395440489053726, 0.01748237945139408, -0.03640056028962135, 0.002885987749323249, -0.05513530969619751, -0.01212700642645359, 0.010153636336326599, -0.018216317519545555, 0.017501819878816605, 0.029070274904370308, 0.01103808544576168, 0.01928378827869892, 0.02103487402200699, -0.011344044469296932, -0.010177196934819221, 0.0035615277010947466, -0.021339358761906624, 0.048784367740154266, 0.04146714136004448, -0.018223391845822334, -0.017738765105605125, -0.00817040540277958, -0.023674126714468002, -0.031584203243255615, -0.009165534749627113, -0.02091997303068638, 0.04822218418121338, -0.004909344483166933, 0.05049131438136101, 0.0591169148683548, -0.004340763669461012, 0.015389390289783478, -0.028321467339992523, 0.006302710622549057, -0.023119857534766197, 0.0050698076374828815, -0.015638090670108795, -0.027112433686852455, 0.001464666100218892, 0.04593773931264877, 0.024984167888760567, 0.028858838602900505, 0.02288241498172283, 0.02616952732205391, 0.02514015883207321, 0.036449454724788666, -0.029918750748038292, -0.04557633027434349, 0.018841685727238655, -0.02118801325559616, 0.027697540819644928, 0.006107067223638296, -0.027705557644367218, 0.01777070388197899, 0.017325157299637794, -0.007370182778686285, -0.050376515835523605, 0.03585665300488472, -0.07860776036977768, -0.031611036509275436, -0.015582761727273464, -0.019702859222888947, -0.005770660471171141, -0.020428190007805824, 0.025547528639435768, -0.017459558323025703, -0.02735552191734314, -0.03673465922474861, -0.06429716944694519, -0.018011722713708878, -0.013755095191299915, -0.04311084374785423, 0.026242123916745186, -0.00391271710395813, -0.04513932019472122, 0.0011830833973363042, -0.035589806735515594, -0.016848832368850708, 0.018811887130141258, 0.04405280202627182, -0.0008758973563089967, 0.05638540908694267, -0.024432145059108734, 0.013247079215943813, -0.038796715438365936, -0.03688213229179382, 0.13591736555099487, 0.06664358824491501, 0.04795903339982033, -0.05709700286388397, 0.007241741754114628, 0.004578994587063789, 0.016192039474844933, -0.012964737601578236, -0.0074652740731835365, -0.028293805196881294, 0.0089228805154562, 0.03969455882906914, 0.06752374768257141, 0.007881819270551205, 0.019637256860733032, 0.04804888367652893, -0.055519092828035355, -0.020360451191663742, -0.001115150866098702, 0.011669796891510487, 0.012227021157741547, 0.06208700314164162, -0.06881066411733627, 0.046961575746536255, -0.006381390616297722, -0.02392394281923771, 0.006179760675877333, -0.04928966984152794, 0.036394212394952774, -0.015935823321342468, -0.04852326214313507, 0.0028835595585405827, 0.028113825246691704, 0.01137001533061266, -0.042284682393074036, -0.012197562493383884, 0.012203682214021683, -0.04025270789861679, 0.010096154175698757, 0.03156236186623573, -0.02663002349436283, -0.026421360671520233, 0.014676875434815884, -0.0001264424790861085, -0.045339714735746384, 0.014849604107439518, -0.036450427025556564, 0.01454107090830803, 0.0054084318690001965, 0.00038609455805271864, -0.027581026777625084, 0.018905071541666985, -0.022558555006980896, -0.03859802335500717, -0.05334092676639557, 0.021665357053279877, 0.04040410742163658, 0.0125935273244977, -0.0303958747535944, -0.023572849109768867, 0.01086334977298975, -0.011667869985103607, 0.04849674925208092, 0.03350622579455376, -0.03742007538676262, 0.01064868550747633, -0.015238924883306026, 0.038568802177906036, -0.014623117633163929, 0.029216505587100983, 0.011001814156770706, -0.009835255332291126, -0.054055675864219666, 0.0031020084861665964, 0.013490650802850723, 0.03345686197280884, -0.012846335768699646, 0.016967162489891052, -0.010992923751473427, -0.009188022464513779, -0.035844940692186356, 0.019712530076503754, 0.01957753859460354, 0.005851459223777056, -0.017654195427894592, 0.0065208966843783855, 0.03200177103281021, 0.02625270001590252, 0.03550655022263527, 0.03594624251127243, 0.011700126342475414, 0.0436149463057518, 0.0499044768512249, -0.07191506773233414, -0.026880161836743355, 0.015786489471793175, -0.02688799612224102, -0.010329339653253555, -0.047181203961372375, 0.06014527752995491, -0.00807761400938034, 0.005258149933069944, -0.018633298575878143, 0.03236393257975578, -0.005340433679521084, 0.026652701199054718, 0.013342438265681267, -0.05025312304496765, 0.004458082839846611, -0.002771242056041956, -0.016173869371414185, -0.05370250344276428, -0.03939118981361389, -0.04040856286883354, 0.002832219935953617, 0.014741357415914536, -0.007383220829069614, 0.003125943010672927, 0.054902635514736176, -0.05541086569428444, 0.05773036926984787, -0.03934646025300026, -0.022526850923895836, -0.03223884850740433, -0.021879686042666435, -0.010762600228190422, -0.005490174051374197, 0.005091664846986532, 0.049232859164476395, -0.013881525956094265, 0.05959351733326912, 0.01111229881644249, 0.027211537584662437, 0.006347167305648327, -0.0029107886366546154, 0.007961522787809372, -0.008668705821037292, 0.03033558838069439, -0.01369411963969469, -0.06790637224912643, 0.021176647394895554, 0.003279035445302725, -0.03859512135386467, 0.022646259516477585, -0.009918213821947575, -0.0008870756719261408, -0.011450986377894878, 0.012301331385970116, 0.00644463486969471, 0.023608354851603508, -0.0073881749995052814, 0.00786995142698288, -0.016138549894094467, -0.017974909394979477, 0.05089212581515312, -0.005979680921882391, -0.018164653331041336, -0.0018462312873452902, -0.015470466576516628, 0.015538555569946766, 0.0788239911198616, -0.014287278056144714, -0.005633589345961809, -0.027200013399124146, -0.04498734325170517, 0.00423148088157177, -0.0027036070823669434, -0.005120587069541216, 0.07839296758174896, 0.04750736057758331, -0.04743566736578941, 0.01517760194838047, 0.00400103023275733, 0.0011412816820666194, -0.0638464167714119, 0.022833582013845444, -0.0013226016890257597, -0.0094470689073205, 0.014248769730329514, -0.03474637493491173, -0.013198000378906727, 0.050246577709913254, -0.0020429978612810373, 0.02255409024655819, 0.005278478376567364, 0.002939617959782481, -0.021679405122995377, -0.01270771399140358, 0.03053426928818226, 0.008602962829172611, -0.013232648372650146, 0.062379345297813416, 0.010251687839627266, 0.03578561171889305, 0.004706694278866053, -0.048781078308820724, -0.016177868470549583, 0.012462603859603405, -0.03224872425198555, -0.04143515229225159, 0.0027763494290411472, 0.0024637074675410986, 0.00924723781645298, 0.013306367211043835, -0.013187884353101254, 0.06221148744225502, 0.026528362184762955, 0.0060564689338207245, -0.030687356367707253, 0.042467761784791946, 0.04094604775309563, -0.02678372524678707, -0.03358462080359459, -0.015510907396674156, 0.006270697806030512, 0.020221658051013947, 0.029429307207465172, 0.012911221012473106, 0.05404673144221306, -0.04407329484820366, -0.026060044765472412, 0.024130739271640778, -0.014004001393914223, -0.011480728164315224, 0.012115858495235443, -0.02388519048690796, 0.005461896304041147, -0.007420347072184086, 0.01254207082092762, -0.035934094339609146, -0.008385569788515568, 0.023854482918977737, -0.010258850641548634, 0.020453304052352905, 0.012169231660664082, -0.013585968874394894, -0.005234967451542616, 0.0048182038590312, -0.018827801570296288, 0.00975548941642046, -0.06332037597894669, 0.023972028866410255, 0.016567932441830635, -0.02141595631837845, -0.011073661968111992, -0.00471080606803298, 0.005335743073374033, 0.04814032092690468, -0.0013971792068332434, -0.018259616568684578, 0.009732629172503948, -0.043313849717378616, -0.0072816819883883, -0.041278500109910965, 0.07966188341379166, 0.02864205092191696, 0.0017757597379386425, -0.03799384459853172, -0.01809542067348957, -0.050320785492658615, 0.030282778665423393, 0.08263327181339264, -0.000476762157632038, 0.0021889321506023407, -0.031380463391542435, 0.0178040973842144, 0.024261735379695892, -0.02938438206911087, 0.015307996422052383, -0.013712635263800621, -0.014332566410303116, -0.006420908961445093, -0.013940137811005116, -0.02878776751458645, 0.009266315028071404, 0.04876962676644325, -0.02480766549706459, 0.007819858379662037, 0.0208758432418108, -0.015762772411108017, 0.0032350155524909496, 0.042879678308963776, -0.05934100225567818, 0.04084262624382973, -0.015399488620460033, 0.007979323156177998, 0.0487075001001358, -0.00858335942029953, -0.054483119398355484, 0.03122210130095482, -0.01046750694513321, -0.0623670369386673, -0.024347912520170212, -0.023360999301075935, 0.01786649227142334, -0.07082466036081314, -0.008734505623579025, 0.01868656650185585, -0.010688532143831253, 0.0015653247246518731, 0.06077263131737709, 0.008695309981703758, 0.025623878464102745, -0.004740763921290636, 0.020406261086463928, -0.018450221046805382, -0.024312635883688927, 0.006902711000293493, -0.01088149007409811, 0.04984240233898163, 0.00309104286134243, -0.004455091431736946, 0.021457694470882416, 0.0036397059448063374, 0.023718304932117462, -0.010812300257384777, 0.01859627105295658, -0.022320164367556572, -0.0096109164878726, 0.01320669986307621, 0.005903379060328007, -0.004786378238350153, 0.021537357941269875, 0.005024347919970751, 0.04246166720986366, -0.0407576784491539, 0.004791262559592724, -0.06205662712454796, -0.04891504347324371, -0.030779967084527016, -0.017390454187989235, 0.01106264814734459, 0.0016589420847594738, -0.01167194452136755, 0.039408013224601746, -0.007869238965213299, -0.018263565376400948, 0.03618215024471283, 0.009309183806180954, 0.02996160462498665, -0.012489682994782925, -0.036449138075113297, 0.01691586710512638, -0.0078028240241110325, -0.020975645631551743, 0.004509183578193188, 0.033419348299503326, 0.012206044048070908, 0.017477208748459816, -0.0217036884278059, -0.006380364298820496, 0.012224068865180016, 0.03156035766005516, -0.07432438433170319, -0.018051182851195335, -0.03475048765540123, 0.013741671107709408, 0.030861545354127884, -0.045491158962249756 ]
<p>As science must be reproducible, by definition, there is increasing recognition that data and code are an essential component of the reproduciblity, as discussed by the <a href="http://reproducible-research.googlegroups.com/web/CISE-12-5-News.pdf">Yale Roundtable for data and code sharing</a>.</p> <p>In reviewing a manuscript for a journal that does not require data and code sharing, can I request that the data and code be made available </p> <ol> <li>to me at the time of review</li> <li>publicly at time of publication (the journal supports supplements)</li> </ol> <p>also, how might I phrase such a request?</p> <hr> <p><em>update</em>: although I am interested in the general case, this particular case consists of a meta-analysis with all previously published data, and the code is simple linear models in SAS</p> <p><em>side note</em> the ability to make cross-study inference (as is the goal of meta-analysis) would be greatly enhanced if more studies provided raw data </p> <p><em>update 2</em>: </p> <p>I requested the data and code from the editor for purposes of review, the editor considered the request reasonable, and I have received the requested material (sufficient but with cryptic variable names, no metadata, and few inline comments) within a day.</p>
74,502
[ -0.04720129072666168, 0.034470126032829285, -0.02411310188472271, 0.011857017874717712, 0.03399716690182686, 0.02887425571680069, -0.04383576661348343, -0.013816322200000286, 0.024845844134688377, -0.012521373108029366, 0.041914816945791245, 0.04329179227352142, 0.053882285952568054, 0.02890515886247158, -0.00828132126480341, -0.0020623423624783754, 0.0030251999851316214, 0.0020384863018989563, 0.0011749083641916513, -0.02269766665995121, 0.01455224771052599, -0.004248057026416063, -0.01800270937383175, -0.008595073595643044, -0.012867447920143604, 0.023890210315585136, 0.024982299655675888, -0.022887002676725388, 0.007735205814242363, 0.007897512055933475, -0.012734083458781242, -0.015157238580286503, 0.007992680184543133, 0.01655508391559124, 0.004937268793582916, -0.0016867424128577113, -0.031815189868211746, -0.01953650824725628, 0.0538473017513752, 0.021974990144371986, -0.043202128261327744, 0.033638644963502884, 0.012751616537570953, 0.002447755541652441, -0.012720131315290928, 0.009162933565676212, -0.03142941743135452, 0.020810019224882126, -0.004096215590834618, -0.007289551664143801, 0.04509047046303749, -0.00020828489505220205, 0.03382742032408714, -0.0024610196705907583, -0.0525926910340786, 0.04929366707801819, 0.04879193380475044, 0.0691402330994606, 0.06634208559989929, -0.04225306212902069, -0.013119667768478394, 0.0018299000803381205, 0.008327774703502655, 0.011425461620092392, -0.034858446568250656, 0.04338272288441658, -0.025278670713305473, -0.00196080538444221, 0.008711541071534157, -0.035386599600315094, 0.028706608340144157, -0.004240479785948992, 0.02383296564221382, 0.0030408536549657583, 0.009326967410743237, -0.017268287017941475, 0.00643940269947052, 0.022616691887378693, 0.015561365522444248, 0.03136495128273964, -0.030328787863254547, 0.004313351586461067, 0.02833317220211029, 0.04383712261915207, 0.015170871280133724, -0.011378000490367413, 0.09136403352022171, -0.030407346785068512, 0.01769791729748249, -0.015169097110629082, 0.047631558030843735, 0.0054413145408034325, 0.026588059961795807, 0.00957346148788929, -0.03379897400736809, 0.009062770754098892, 0.0033952516969293356, 0.05133100971579552, -0.05156895890831947, -0.03173390030860901, 0.01700674369931221, -0.04489560052752495, 0.028719421476125717, 0.04189702868461609, 0.0020201606675982475, -0.033431779593229294, -0.014524388127028942, 0.00693083181977272, -0.012616775929927826, -0.04914816468954086, -0.001678838743828237, 0.01000975351780653, -0.02736770734190941, 0.014479107223451138, 0.007547290064394474, -0.036055900156497955, 0.009038833901286125, 0.01603919267654419, 0.11638850718736649, 0.04283826798200607, 0.07828698307275772, -0.011236466467380524, 0.02213313616812229, -0.006260105408728123, -0.025907237082719803, 0.013428226113319397, 0.012705384753644466, -0.0165947824716568, -0.05131744593381882, 0.03718395531177521, -0.010859573259949684, -0.02294163964688778, 0.03723102807998657, 0.007584508508443832, 0.01486032735556364, -0.0007379339658655226, -0.1023179367184639, -0.0722588375210762, 0.05095163360238075, 0.027068981900811195, 0.013771787285804749, -0.0901309922337532, -0.0010980445658788085, 0.01885826326906681, 0.04999866336584091, -0.009708968922495842, 0.04465199261903763, 0.0014824832323938608, 0.050478629767894745, 0.00006976278382353485, 0.01397271640598774, -0.013497564010322094, 0.0008161059813573956, -0.020182041451334953, -0.03862205147743225, -0.05715686455368996, 0.03357535973191261, 0.032643433660268784, -0.025948667898774147, 0.02570168301463127, 0.04309004917740822, -0.003972876351326704, -0.0020717596635222435, 0.005167427938431501, 0.013306258246302605, -0.06052175164222717, 0.017675988376140594, 0.004621331579983234, 0.0008314815349876881, 0.035191308706998825, -0.009557459503412247, -0.024136362597346306, 0.019366970285773277, 0.04343026876449585, 0.011737494729459286, -0.021298835054039955, 0.017777442932128906, 0.017786012962460518, -0.003087236313149333, 0.019220290705561638, -0.00574242789298296, -0.001487090950831771, 0.014974386431276798, 0.028908954933285713, 0.016305983066558838, 0.024667924270033836, -0.011068194173276424, 0.0032189725898206234, 0.06540098786354065, -0.05464969575405121, -0.034419912844896317, -0.048071376979351044, 0.019246568903326988, -0.004865655675530434, -0.0019229170866310596, -0.01428774930536747, -0.012524440884590149, 0.02967866323888302, 0.005295755807310343, -0.04574555903673172, 0.015281676314771175, -0.0006207907572388649, 0.08560386300086975, 0.016540253534913063, -0.008419509045779705, 0.0194215327501297, 0.04836951568722725, -0.02497018501162529, 0.01453913189470768, 0.013443014584481716, -0.08408547937870026, 0.024622462689876556, -0.04193051531910896, 0.00413209293037653, -0.007805490400642157, -0.010439367033541203, -0.02391492761671543, 0.007400349713861942, -0.03874023258686066, 0.03209152817726135, -0.03726695850491524, 0.0628407746553421, 0.03772507235407829, 0.04226014018058777, -0.024066273123025894, 0.04078232869505882, 0.011604834347963333, -0.0003711506142280996, -0.019011760130524635, -0.012614439241588116, -0.07626771181821823, -0.00026069910381920636, 0.043418947607278824, -0.01242075301706791, -0.015996143221855164, 0.016004499047994614, 0.03349054604768753, -0.017598547041416168, 0.007014915347099304, 0.02356201969087124, -0.011640282347798347, -0.06009207293391228, 0.02871263027191162, 0.012586867436766624, 0.05361022427678108, 0.02439672313630581, -0.024093864485621452, 0.014767753891646862, 0.014860653318464756, 0.043101757764816284, 0.01891997829079628, 0.029289379715919495, 0.005001890007406473, -0.04697864130139351, -0.006583149079233408, -0.0023713342379778624, 0.08164241164922714, -0.030155979096889496, 0.016768960282206535, 0.028502190485596657, -0.0035516738425940275, 0.00918151531368494, 0.02435922622680664, -0.011509910225868225, -0.0016004737699404359, 0.014719897881150246, -0.05676815286278725, -0.0029190615750849247, 0.0035220321733504534, -0.037172675132751465, 0.0033731376752257347, -0.06710812449455261, -0.017450090497732162, -0.041063811630010605, 0.006462364923208952, 0.006680143065750599, -0.00935074407607317, 0.006776589434593916, -0.02849523536860943, -0.006458064075559378, 0.008929098956286907, 0.0076079340651631355, 0.013089798390865326, 0.01091538555920124, -0.0558069609105587, -0.014885659329593182, -0.02627125009894371, -0.028290659189224243, 0.043311093002557755, -0.007675500586628914, -0.017991704866290092, 0.030502399429678917, -0.002193466993048787, -0.046702828258275986, 0.015904702246189117, -0.0043374234810471535, 0.032472968101501465, 0.008629793301224709, -0.013812235556542873, 0.0008442233083769679, 0.0008490596082992852, -0.04128235951066017, 0.005534518510103226, 0.01936138980090618, -0.022078247740864754, 0.0397939570248127, 0.012261555530130863, 0.024230219423770905, 0.004008241463452578, 0.011899285018444061, 0.017478810623288155, -0.005181855522096157, -0.033023636788129807, -0.06070604547858238, -0.0732278898358345, 0.026564938947558403, 0.013428755104541779, 0.017470188438892365, 0.029682613909244537, 0.008205840364098549, 0.0582105927169323, 0.03224962204694748, -0.017996396869421005, -0.021543044596910477, -0.01164617296308279, -0.008839323185384274, -0.016746165230870247, -0.029572542756795883, 0.0011673307744786143, 0.025176450610160828, 0.013993107713758945, 0.004369217902421951, 0.050002653151750565, 0.044174425303936005, -0.004322534427046776, -0.01085197739303112, -0.020835740491747856, 0.015890086069703102, -0.01692305877804756, -0.013545016758143902, 0.03673707693815231, -0.008180572651326656, -0.018972137942910194, 0.034347642213106155, 0.05147556588053703, 0.012281998991966248, -0.05972379818558693, 0.03195348009467125, 0.024660464376211166, 0.020038817077875137, -0.026131685823202133, 0.03827662393450737, 0.03476881980895996, -0.03749154880642891, 0.041949041187763214, 0.04101446643471718, 0.0007482974324375391, 0.01896013133227825, -0.04701022431254387, 0.07866409420967102, 0.030597034841775894, -0.002112927380949259, 0.01610013283789158, -0.034675925970077515, 0.019613048061728477, 0.006769941188395023, -0.016255633905529976, 0.026920082047581673, -0.018778663128614426, 0.03280939906835556, 0.025369342416524887, -0.015757886692881584, -0.0772169753909111, 0.020976794883608818, -0.08984410017728806, 0.01331773679703474, -0.031015129759907722, 0.03138763830065727, 0.00946766510605812, 0.057437777519226074, 0.012380910106003284, -0.01978381723165512, -0.015140174888074398, -0.016026930883526802, -0.04758552089333534, -0.02221052162349224, -0.029882829636335373, 0.04906187579035759, -0.001701353001408279, -0.00009647727711126208, 0.005682687275111675, 0.03135627135634422, -0.019951092079281807, 0.012774595990777016, 0.016881998628377914, -0.026611292734742165, 0.01202932745218277, -0.013282140716910362, -0.00941355898976326, -0.0006774562643840909, 0.013164160773158073, 0.015218694694340229, -0.015176413580775261, 0.023870589211583138, 0.021709904074668884, 0.03741896525025368, -0.04378877580165863, -0.02961461991071701, 0.012652730569243431, -0.031972646713256836, 0.05190381407737732, -0.013938749209046364, -0.001952177844941616, -0.04878662899136543, 0.040581412613391876, 0.0052032447420060635, 0.01835617423057556, 0.01548592559993267, -0.005874999333173037, 0.0030372492037713528, -0.016297580674290657, 0.022787170484662056, 0.05146248638629913, -0.009856308810412884, -0.025367222726345062, 0.004123734310269356, 0.03161759674549103, 0.0513242743909359, -0.022032586857676506, 0.03639386594295502, 0.06588151305913925, 0.010211886838078499, 0.0340711772441864, -0.024476399645209312, -0.01129231695085764, -0.01974189095199108, -0.01385913323611021, 0.03438357636332512, 0.0351913757622242, 0.03873321786522865, 0.019818678498268127, -0.004822301212698221, 0.025581449270248413, -0.030659619718790054, 0.005331279709935188, 0.007680458016693592, 0.07689026743173599, 0.001441975007764995, -0.012296170927584171, -0.0025105131790041924, 0.06064850091934204, 0.055727872997522354, 0.006485014222562313, -0.030934056267142296, -0.06725715845823288, 0.004609975963830948, 0.04470386728644371, 0.05235491693019867, -0.03615572676062584, 0.006200371775776148, -0.06567066162824631, 0.027270127087831497, 0.017301151528954506, -0.005972700659185648, 0.0014933118363842368, -0.04550917074084282, 0.0274521391838789, -0.005124854855239391, -0.051850322633981705, 0.015069965273141861, 0.009119345806539059, 0.008346542716026306, 0.003266644896939397, 0.006366767920553684, -0.01365743950009346, -0.039618879556655884, 0.03813892602920532, -0.01877591758966446, 0.026519404724240303, -0.02970827743411064, -0.014092021621763706, -0.021660780534148216, 0.013318526558578014, -0.03040619008243084, -0.07628440856933594, -0.001531745190732181, -0.01594359241425991, -0.0042423103004693985, 0.06626613438129425, -0.029682740569114685, -0.020616447553038597, 0.047708719968795776, 0.0023942545522004366, -0.03743888437747955, -0.023892689496278763, -0.03184109553694725, 0.05917485058307648, 0.04819951578974724, 0.04697621241211891, 0.07141336798667908, 0.03780180588364601, -0.007063356228172779, -0.006963861174881458, -0.04990784823894501, -0.006334921810775995, -0.038276463747024536, -0.0072433194145560265, -0.039394281804561615, -0.039280183613300323, -0.0411318801343441, 0.01916106976568699, 0.0041575124487280846, -0.01026223786175251, -0.014461388811469078, -0.014621677808463573, -0.005564938765019178, 0.007778794504702091, -0.013928573578596115, -0.02797860838472843, -0.027520576491951942, -0.019021635875105858, -0.044410448521375656, -0.010084155015647411, 0.06468582898378372, -0.03546935319900513, -0.022076833993196487, 0.01712927035987377, -0.05670971795916557, -0.01923038437962532, -0.045580167323350906, -0.020634930580854416, 0.019133012741804123, -0.047135304659605026, 0.006078395526856184, -0.02302890084683895, 0.027679290622472763, -0.01357324980199337, -0.06477057188749313, 0.016437700018286705, 0.02818685956299305, -0.035695455968379974, 0.004374405834823847, -0.04175492376089096, 0.04307031258940697, -0.052309367805719376, -0.022982722148299217, -0.048361800611019135, -0.0228241179138422, 0.05797010287642479, 0.0023217732086777687, -0.031112181022763252, -0.030584022402763367, -0.024025190621614456, -0.02761956863105297, -0.004356255754828453, 0.007552388124167919, 0.045832470059394836, -0.044757917523384094, -0.020913250744342804, -0.011204985901713371, 0.018208228051662445, 0.0632123053073883, -0.04316089302301407, -0.019080739468336105, 0.006638889200985432, -0.012573732063174248, 0.0012422156287357211, -0.018778789788484573, -0.002154548419639468, -0.034094683825969696, -0.01767180860042572, -0.06720573455095291, 0.0017289319075644016, 0.04588649421930313, -0.001865639234893024, 0.012893077917397022, 0.032685134559869766, -0.04942582547664642, 0.014700928702950478, -0.038029760122299194, 0.018903564661741257, -0.04153575748205185, 0.038527898490428925, -0.06283581256866455, 0.02954583428800106, -0.01336119044572115, 0.01074798870831728, 0.0194591972976923, 0.0013024762738496065, -0.0029590739868581295, 0.0052897012792527676, 0.061452317982912064, 0.006227080710232258, 0.02326650358736515, -0.0014150843489915133, -0.03131260722875595, 0.04315904155373573, 0.013194079510867596, 0.05614833906292915, -0.008801998570561409, -0.0036044695880264044, -0.008040335960686207, -0.03901461139321327, -0.0017806473188102245, -0.00689241848886013, 0.05087647959589958, -0.0161293838173151, -0.017107432708144188, 0.062052078545093536, -0.019091133028268814, 0.020263878628611565, -0.004365336615592241, 0.029413335025310516, -0.008366948924958706, 0.041485052555799484, 0.05803525820374489, -0.004836668726056814, -0.05927615612745285, 0.013477684929966927, -0.011231324635446072, 0.011020399630069733, 0.0287920031696558, 0.0034155496396124363, 0.0038133845664560795, 0.007496356498450041, -0.04741575941443443, -0.04476908594369888, -0.000014607496268581599, -0.07066453248262405, 0.036720532923936844, -0.007387315388768911, -0.045580390840768814, 0.04168868437409401, 0.02567760832607746, 0.038428895175457, -0.03789345920085907, -0.015921631827950478, -0.042137593030929565, -0.005979384295642376, -0.01642991416156292, -0.025167234241962433, 0.02178644947707653, -0.029054034501314163, 0.013647415675222874, -0.013738357461988926, 0.03830356150865555, -0.031098758801817894, -0.11015937477350235, -0.026848381385207176, -0.00903794914484024, -0.018738504499197006, 0.07422585040330887, 0.005526169203221798, 0.006352135445922613, 0.03182591125369072, -0.07502037286758423, 0.019934412091970444, 0.013628660701215267, 0.03997594863176346, -0.018517272546887398, 0.08100517839193344, -0.03475773707032204, 0.0035411531571298838, -0.02866748906672001, -0.018414977937936783, 0.12425157427787781, 0.035043805837631226, 0.0542772114276886, -0.046174414455890656, 0.09027671813964844, 0.013612077571451664, 0.009952662512660027, 0.028701836243271828, -0.029122602194547653, -0.0009020648431032896, -0.012668069452047348, 0.04645226523280144, 0.025536352768540382, -0.0035406057722866535, 0.005878236144781113, 0.052703794091939926, -0.05190949887037277, 0.014022278599441051, 0.009214960038661957, 0.013531086966395378, 0.02382589690387249, -0.023084206506609917, -0.03334381431341171, -0.03070041537284851, 0.04118570312857628, -0.04165489599108696, 0.002790814498439431, -0.04228822514414787, -0.017749175429344177, 0.0256886538118124, -0.018208127468824387, -0.0007155284401960671, 0.026228023692965508, 0.028915394097566605, 0.004727816209197044, -0.020076269283890724, 0.024492627009749413, -0.009700940921902657, -0.006307214964181185, 0.0644269734621048, -0.03132132813334465, 0.032836589962244034, -0.014672941528260708, 0.04786819964647293, -0.008425530977547169, 0.007776162121444941, -0.0043439255096018314, 0.013585902750492096, -0.013381111435592175, -0.034665755927562714, 0.010849743150174618, 0.013331686146557331, -0.0024246948305517435, -0.027899999171495438, -0.03485377877950668, 0.018642250448465347, 0.0011316353920847178, -0.03170846775174141, -0.016381289809942245, 0.02334464155137539, 0.0419049933552742, -0.01832207664847374, 0.040223728865385056, 0.034528590738773346, -0.02352190390229225, -0.0007882267236709595, -0.033287808299064636, -0.0030904151499271393, -0.014242371544241905, 0.0325460359454155, -0.025188345462083817, 0.0012427918845787644, -0.039045315235853195, -0.016180342063307762, -0.007385332137346268, -0.006714509800076485, 0.02791951410472393, 0.005833025090396404, -0.003967082593590021, -0.014071784913539886, -0.053556282073259354, 0.01482330821454525, 0.00024966607452370226, 0.003084808122366667, -0.024441005662083626, -0.007580621633678675, 0.01524069719016552, 0.006820231210440397, -0.017319023609161377, 0.001527904998511076, 0.011079485528171062, 0.05210673063993454, -0.005924164783209562, -0.016937559470534325, -0.008990436792373657, 0.021748121827840805, -0.05802939459681511, 0.008661074563860893, -0.022551296278834343, 0.04316398873925209, 0.011421930976212025, 0.028350794687867165, -0.004774154629558325, 0.018403667956590652, -0.011468690820038319, -0.013518627732992172, 0.02203184925019741, -0.06464672088623047, -0.0020029384177178144, 0.005838758312165737, 0.011570096015930176, -0.002580918138846755, -0.029758982360363007, -0.05856041610240936, -0.03702827915549278, 0.011613803915679455, -0.04242335632443428, -0.04348693788051605, 0.028537914156913757, -0.020286299288272858, 0.006594603881239891, -0.021899709478020668, -0.0012108063092455268, -0.05039265751838684, -0.014233396388590336, 0.015111788176000118, -0.04487632215023041, -0.01280144415795803, 0.04894553869962692, -0.001163117354735732, 0.004196594003587961, 0.01103720162063837, 0.004117801319807768, -0.008691458962857723, 0.0355418361723423, -0.023688985034823418, -0.010828819125890732, 0.06110792234539986, -0.018878759816288948, -0.0465727373957634, 0.020478591322898865, -0.027893217280507088, 0.01251321379095316, 0.014682750217616558, -0.07242707908153534, 0.00034322761348448694, 0.02420762926340103, -0.016116544604301453, -0.031352460384368896, 0.03909239172935486, -0.019494200125336647, 0.005776565056294203, 0.03296618163585663, 0.015204183757305145, -0.018286840990185738, 0.023760806769132614, 0.029950037598609924, 0.000744663062505424, -0.04818188399076462, 0.046019382774829865, 0.052998341619968414, 0.009469172917306423, -0.010066202841699123, 0.026211632415652275, -0.01370117999613285, 0.03047749772667885, 0.016566868871450424, 0.024140121415257454, 0.013224558904767036, 0.017917368561029434, -0.05927389860153198, 0.022496633231639862, -0.007859442383050919, 0.01534966193139553, -0.11361696571111679, -0.000643466948531568, 0.015533411875367165, 0.008228623308241367, 0.011898648925125599, -0.018362246453762054, 0.03959798440337181, 0.005744377616792917, -0.04295603558421135, 0.028493251651525497, -0.017051860690116882, -0.04997248202562332, -0.04053015634417534, 0.04073476046323776, -0.04046827182173729, -0.023351961746811867, 0.022505618631839752, -0.020388813689351082, 0.027818532660603523, 0.048902545124292374, 0.020507145673036575, -0.025353044271469116, -0.018668686971068382, 0.03910493850708008, 0.008388929069042206, -0.011881273239850998, 0.02308511920273304, -0.007760174572467804, -0.06194334477186203, 0.024631567299365997, 0.037950947880744934, 0.013512976467609406, 0.008401423692703247, 0.020872734487056732, -0.018065033480525017, 0.02147848717868328, 0.020699167624115944, -0.004284682217985392, -0.02173243649303913, -0.030009359121322632, 0.004809196572750807, 0.011019657365977764, 0.006909490562975407, 0.061790745705366135, -0.006039334926754236, 0.005150143522769213, -0.0019243883434683084, 0.016563620418310165, -0.040604669600725174, -0.03154700994491577, -0.009918023832142353, 0.013558798469603062, 0.016378439962863922, -0.021206030622124672, -0.030299054458737373, -0.058484382927417755, 0.0200081504881382, 0.03934335708618164, 0.033071961253881454, -0.01799221709370613, 0.023809483274817467, -0.0321199893951416, 0.013706622645258904, -0.008976215496659279, 0.00819702073931694, -0.018625294789671898, -0.06713144481182098, -0.008253070525825024, 0.005513092968612909, 0.003364059841260314, -0.006222381256520748, 0.004025233909487724, -0.021221427246928215, 0.016445303335785866, -0.0038645295426249504, -0.0005791403818875551, -0.014758051373064518, -0.01942385546863079, 0.016353435814380646, -0.03345981240272522, 0.04114745557308197, 0.048402223736047745, 0.005651193205267191, -0.04325530305504799, -0.0398021899163723, -0.028151795268058777, -0.0032421445939689875, 0.036057017743587494, 0.010656923986971378, 0.008541831746697426, -0.00582530302926898, 0.021178750321269035, -0.006378484889864922, -0.008743930608034134, 0.05357002839446068, -0.03271522372961044, 0.004819635767489672, -0.060431212186813354, -0.0344369150698185, -0.021117335185408592, 0.02553592436015606, 0.05466724559664726, 0.006411587353795767, 0.036229200661182404, 0.007413879968225956, 0.003111751051619649, 0.04302309826016426, -0.0018176909070461988, -0.03444375470280647, 0.020473813638091087, 0.002686265390366316, -0.0020323118660598993, 0.027727114036679268, 0.03365781530737877, -0.03435485064983368, 0.039358124136924744, -0.041668981313705444, -0.03700130060315132, -0.004688100889325142, -0.008411677554249763, 0.003842787118628621, -0.06684860587120056, 0.03204455226659775, 0.027123408392071724, -0.013443228788673878, -0.017337242141366005, 0.0063948133029043674, 0.01676574908196926, 0.042788174003362656, 0.010146969929337502, 0.016409773379564285, -0.0023445317056030035, -0.04455294460058212, -0.02879277989268303, -0.0035182812716811895, 0.026982612907886505, -0.00848578754812479, -0.03387926146388054, 0.052431002259254456, 0.004511604085564613, 0.04277145490050316, -0.014163525775074959, 0.06339458376169205, -0.048922616988420486, -0.02671516127884388, 0.02940273843705654, -0.03205499053001404, -0.006143760401755571, 0.009494084864854813, -0.0065891626290977, 0.047281887382268906, 0.001750060822814703, 0.025830136612057686, -0.04556046053767204, 0.01032665092498064, -0.005483928602188826, 0.01817893795669079, -0.02260040119290352, 0.027260052040219307, 0.005106780678033829, 0.0007165148854255676, -0.01696120575070381, -0.028886379674077034, 0.05177663266658783, -0.019718579947948456, 0.043680138885974884, -0.015067599713802338, -0.00215405086055398, -0.01679869368672371, -0.033287495374679565, 0.017702072858810425, -0.019245577976107597, 0.05341532453894615, 0.023990340530872345, -0.03378200903534889, -0.046551663428545, -0.041781045496463776, -0.009035270661115646, 0.062063053250312805, -0.02916884794831276, 0.0016803049948066473, -0.02928895503282547, 0.007210267707705498, 0.01505982968956232, -0.018555153161287308 ]
<p>I am using SVM to predict diabetes. I am using the <a href="http://www.cdc.gov/BRFSS/">BRFSS</a> data set for this purpose. The data set has the dimensions of $432607 \times 136$ and is skewed. The percentage of <code>Y</code>s in the target variable is $11\%$ while the <code>N</code>s constitute the remaining $89\%$.</p> <p>I am using only <code>15</code> out of <code>136</code> independent variables from the data set. One of the reasons for reducing the data set was to have more training samples when rows containing <code>NA</code>s are omitted.</p> <p>These <code>15</code> variables were selected after running statistical methods such as random trees, logistic regression and finding out which variables are significant from the resulting models. For example, after running logistic regression we used <code>p-value</code> to order the most significant variables.</p> <p>Is my method of doing variable selection correct? Any suggestions to is greatly welcome. </p> <p>The following is my <code>R</code> implementation. </p> <pre><code>library(e1071) # Support Vector Machines #-------------------------------------------------------------------- # read brfss file (huge 135 MB file) #-------------------------------------------------------------------- y &lt;- read.csv("http://www.hofroe.net/stat579/brfss%2009/brfss-2009-clean.csv") indicator &lt;- c("DIABETE2", "GENHLTH", "PERSDOC2", "SEX", "FLUSHOT3", "PNEUVAC3", "X_RFHYPE5", "X_RFCHOL", "RACE2", "X_SMOKER3", "X_AGE_G", "X_BMI4CAT", "X_INCOMG", "X_RFDRHV3", "X_RFDRHV3", "X_STATE"); target &lt;- "DIABETE2"; diabetes &lt;- y[, indicator]; #-------------------------------------------------------------------- # recode DIABETE2 #-------------------------------------------------------------------- x &lt;- diabetes$DIABETE2; x[x &gt; 1] &lt;- 'N'; x[x != 'N'] &lt;- 'Y'; diabetes$DIABETE2 &lt;- x; rm(x); #-------------------------------------------------------------------- # remove NA #-------------------------------------------------------------------- x &lt;- na.omit(diabetes); diabetes &lt;- x; rm(x); #-------------------------------------------------------------------- # reproducible research #-------------------------------------------------------------------- set.seed(1612); nsamples &lt;- 1000; sample.diabetes &lt;- diabetes[sample(nrow(diabetes), nsamples), ]; #-------------------------------------------------------------------- # split the dataset into training and test #-------------------------------------------------------------------- ratio &lt;- 0.7; train.samples &lt;- ratio*nsamples; train.rows &lt;- c(sample(nrow(sample.diabetes), trunc(train.samples))); train.set &lt;- sample.diabetes[train.rows, ]; test.set &lt;- sample.diabetes[-train.rows, ]; train.result &lt;- train.set[ , which(names(train.set) == target)]; test.result &lt;- test.set[ , which(names(test.set) == target)]; #-------------------------------------------------------------------- # SVM #-------------------------------------------------------------------- formula &lt;- as.formula(factor(DIABETE2) ~ . ); svm.tune &lt;- tune.svm(formula, data = train.set, gamma = 10^(-3:0), cost = 10^(-1:1)); svm.model &lt;- svm(formula, data = train.set, kernel = "linear", gamma = svm.tune$best.parameters$gamma, cost = svm.tune$best.parameters$cost); #-------------------------------------------------------------------- # Confusion matrix #-------------------------------------------------------------------- train.pred &lt;- predict(svm.model, train.set); test.pred &lt;- predict(svm.model, test.set); svm.table &lt;- table(pred = test.pred, true = test.result); print(svm.table); </code></pre> <p>I ran with $1000$ (training = $700$ and test = $300$) samples since it is faster in my laptop. The confusion matrix for the test data ($300$ samples) I get is quite bad.</p> <pre><code> true pred N Y N 262 38 Y 0 0 </code></pre> <p>I need to improve my prediction for the <code>Y</code> class. In fact, I need to be as accurate as possible with <code>Y</code> even if I perform poorly with <code>N</code>. Any suggestions to improve the accuracy of classification would be greatly appreciated.</p>
13,014
[ -0.019528992474079132, -0.03369781747460365, 0.024265293031930923, 0.005177697166800499, 0.04079274833202362, -0.011124566197395325, -0.023493340238928795, -0.024734342470765114, 0.04752413555979729, -0.056100260466337204, 0.036119431257247925, 0.0501139834523201, 0.04997275769710541, 0.06828397512435913, 0.0385054387152195, -0.0214584581553936, 0.017708534374833107, 0.012913619168102741, 0.024859435856342316, -0.004206568468362093, -0.008539220318198204, 0.02369801141321659, 0.007892749272286892, -0.01066697295755148, -0.02276425249874592, 0.0633993148803711, -0.012063410133123398, -0.009627686813473701, -0.023836545646190643, 0.03730804845690727, -0.045121751725673676, -0.0154838552698493, 0.021619273349642754, 0.02479197457432747, 0.008111647330224514, 0.013933367095887661, 0.0044359490275382996, -0.006069534923881292, 0.008371640928089619, 0.02143067494034767, 0.010509932413697243, 0.01407806109637022, -0.04923751950263977, 0.05112692341208458, 0.014632586389780045, 0.04675083979964256, -0.017353219911456108, 0.002355239586904645, 0.027833616361021996, -0.025226842612028122, 0.07546686381101608, -0.02843892201781273, 0.06653541326522827, 0.03647362068295479, -0.013647648505866528, -0.04240122437477112, 0.020098041743040085, 0.08765176683664322, 0.005168988835066557, -0.062005285173654556, -0.016086680814623833, -0.03470039367675781, -0.0374193899333477, -0.015395363792777061, -0.021840011700987816, 0.017801115289330482, 0.003217155346646905, -0.027778208255767822, 0.03094404749572277, -0.014113923534750938, -0.007941138930618763, -0.02363354153931141, -0.010434525087475777, 0.02985244430601597, 0.0018487044144421816, -0.025292139500379562, -0.0033716531470417976, -0.012559006921947002, -0.0021872601937502623, -0.0046162474900484085, 0.021714691072702408, 0.030158182606101036, 0.012508874759078026, 0.005981632508337498, 0.01415353361517191, -0.0019472113344818354, 0.024707641452550888, -0.015583928674459457, 0.0038248759228736162, 0.03141896426677704, -0.029399918392300606, 0.02985267899930477, 0.04503616318106651, 0.02843538299202919, -0.013279599137604237, 0.036721400916576385, -0.016916561871767044, 0.04191897064447403, 0.009364904835820198, -0.0043289437890052795, -0.014760986901819706, -0.05518120899796486, 0.005180597770959139, 0.06877443194389343, -0.05795423686504364, -0.03716196492314339, -0.04301556944847107, -0.01011587679386139, -0.015943853184580803, -0.04517054930329323, -0.043212857097387314, 0.0015291745075955987, 0.005698374938219786, -0.034043338149785995, 0.011389786377549171, -0.0706004947423935, -0.018634293228387833, -0.02241351641714573, 0.02677072584629059, 0.03187672421336174, 0.045438915491104126, -0.02609936334192753, 0.007073963992297649, -0.017429294064641, -0.00021768496662843972, 0.022941455245018005, 0.014747644774615765, 0.017682787030935287, -0.03521379083395004, 0.01976989023387432, -0.020839819684624672, -0.01493860688060522, 0.055486343801021576, -0.01848401129245758, 0.01171520072966814, 0.00770535646006465, -0.059278033673763275, -0.03311741724610329, 0.07272479683160782, -0.02459336258471012, 0.03961338847875595, -0.05203993618488312, -0.01660815067589283, 0.024938995018601418, 0.05407898873090744, 0.009433655068278313, 0.004669565241783857, 0.023509109392762184, 0.031191041693091393, 0.0039705741219222546, -0.011571599170565605, 0.006635771133005619, -0.026302555575966835, 0.018228020519018173, -0.029266100376844406, -0.07017014920711517, -0.014243514277040958, 0.022843344137072563, 0.002854526275768876, 0.021671423688530922, -0.018189288675785065, -0.00303826411254704, 0.009366650134325027, -0.027651159092783928, -0.02490832284092903, -0.02946753054857254, 0.03529607504606247, 0.0065413787961006165, 0.046051375567913055, 0.031242283061146736, -0.03870692476630211, 0.037950243800878525, 0.03616781532764435, 0.03083549067378044, 0.03963000699877739, 0.012142912484705448, 0.026074035093188286, -0.02275751158595085, 0.015256882645189762, 0.024193119257688522, -0.04580390080809593, -0.04983973503112793, -0.05366851016879082, 0.008440481498837471, 0.03169550746679306, 0.06493401527404785, 0.0037119698245078325, -0.03032979927957058, 0.06946750730276108, -0.06127442419528961, -0.06728623062372208, -0.0318576842546463, -0.03050634264945984, -0.004341339226812124, -0.010934645310044289, -0.0069310422986745834, 0.011484796181321144, 0.02212321199476719, 0.046164367347955704, 0.007012215442955494, -0.0663444921374321, 0.005979530513286591, 0.06257201731204987, -0.03849980980157852, 0.008537047542631626, 0.026875974610447884, 0.024405717849731445, -0.03621629625558853, 0.029350774362683296, -0.022392913699150085, -0.033141184598207474, 0.046300008893013, -0.039980992674827576, 0.009165585041046143, -0.02115507423877716, -0.005177770741283894, 0.010983587242662907, 0.002419804921373725, -0.027863282710313797, 0.040293075144290924, -0.07066335529088974, 0.030978351831436157, 0.04405661299824715, 0.03237975761294365, 0.01783824898302555, -0.022930432111024857, -0.002409254666417837, 0.06845604628324509, -0.025333184748888016, 0.008542457595467567, -0.05639052763581276, -0.03664616867899895, 0.060621410608291626, -0.007312816567718983, -0.06948371976613998, -0.008839556947350502, 0.05685654282569885, -0.013332744129002094, 0.047222018241882324, 0.021318655461072922, -0.029504764825105667, 0.0018664933741092682, 0.03348058462142944, -0.0029994735959917307, -0.009326359257102013, -0.013060469180345535, 0.0196076612919569, -0.009058493189513683, 0.04263807833194733, 0.019230401143431664, 0.0023356147576123476, 0.03394461050629616, 0.003769238945096731, 0.006662450265139341, -0.0013909188564866781, -0.04061228781938553, 0.04738130047917366, 0.0025140910875052214, -0.034601978957653046, 0.061584435403347015, -0.0037752878852188587, 0.012537844479084015, -0.015973158180713654, -0.018094737082719803, 0.010845426470041275, 0.03622166067361832, -0.02684398554265499, 0.025334862992167473, -0.00037669038283638656, -0.07242884486913681, 0.0019959851633757353, -0.013101023621857166, -0.04542360082268715, -0.06565205007791519, 0.037970151752233505, 0.02956077829003334, 0.008980811573565006, 0.004789115861058235, 0.012656277976930141, -0.003886933671310544, 0.020744308829307556, -0.042039867490530014, 0.017148396000266075, -0.006673861760646105, -0.06320223212242126, -0.04645831510424614, -0.03585338220000267, -0.0063917855732142925, 0.05640324950218201, -0.0201245304197073, -0.0511414110660553, 0.02254735492169857, -0.01667322963476181, -0.03210250288248062, -0.016568826511502266, -0.02067388966679573, 0.011481696739792824, 0.016992177814245224, -0.02993880771100521, 0.030611341819167137, 0.022716952487826347, -0.04048432409763336, 0.013175876811146736, -0.02836660109460354, -0.01598050631582737, -0.03218211606144905, -0.04303174093365669, -0.021175526082515717, -0.01209243293851614, -0.0003427110204938799, -0.002315150573849678, 0.013306625187397003, 0.024027029052376747, -0.07039832323789597, -0.036793049424886703, 0.013626686297357082, 0.029947051778435707, 0.022051682695746422, 0.0005290207336656749, 0.007294097449630499, 0.06872884184122086, 0.03260016441345215, -0.03554188832640648, -0.008299079723656178, -0.00923268310725689, -0.05264904350042343, -0.028605526313185692, 0.03638489544391632, 0.0555359311401844, 0.04689520597457886, -0.017945289611816406, -0.00681415107101202, 0.048979226499795914, 0.04662955552339554, 0.007123146206140518, 0.0036832059267908335, 0.04043741896748543, -0.026796385645866394, -0.014667844399809837, 0.02231149561703205, 0.026409601792693138, -0.027544088661670685, 0.031114498153328896, -0.0021327324211597443, 0.00260941032320261, -0.006772825960069895, -0.04364817589521408, 0.02443283423781395, -0.0005017270450480282, 0.058916497975587845, -0.024786172434687614, -0.010304587893188, 0.01733834110200405, -0.04190761595964432, 0.005097880028188229, -0.019484782591462135, 0.06766347587108612, -0.027289200574159622, 0.0014187851920723915, 0.014836284331977367, 0.009873232804238796, 0.03356014937162399, 0.05836937949061394, -0.027712637558579445, -0.02885284647345543, -0.0004909182898700237, -0.04220051318407059, 0.0015815345104783773, 0.02456667274236679, 0.05428898707032204, 0.005883786827325821, 0.010545512661337852, -0.022642647847533226, 0.023597687482833862, -0.07541180402040482, -0.025566259399056435, -0.02774716541171074, 0.042675867676734924, 0.002099852543324232, -0.0032761639449745417, 0.02424386329948902, -0.021327881142497063, 0.006268450058996677, -0.0009222126100212336, -0.025721631944179535, 0.01432924997061491, 0.02329947240650654, 0.01957649737596512, 0.006163106765598059, -0.04175373911857605, 0.034465983510017395, -0.02158178761601448, 0.031723879277706146, -0.021139824762940407, 0.040991105139255524, -0.0322355218231678, 0.014827650040388107, 0.002760513685643673, 0.006292480509728193, -0.01374821737408638, 0.022463873028755188, 0.019917311146855354, -0.022032471373677254, 0.012659875676035881, 0.029645724222064018, -0.03584708273410797, -0.00468712393194437, -0.009865195490419865, 0.014332595281302929, 0.049883704632520676, 0.02855546586215496, 0.019489025697112083, 0.008549860678613186, -0.06092682108283043, -0.017293911427259445, -0.0031754758674651384, -0.013733689673244953, 0.041333552449941635, -0.010208279825747013, -0.04145364463329315, -0.03966695815324783, -0.02276064082980156, 0.012112906202673912, 0.017277494072914124, 0.006566731259226799, 0.03645172715187073, 0.08525152504444122, 0.011502602137625217, -0.07610077410936356, 0.011509131640195847, 0.06247561797499657, -0.0034916161093860865, -0.008230204693973064, -0.04591074213385582, 0.005121129564940929, 0.0016253424109891057, 0.029211753979325294, 0.05758530646562576, 0.01529713161289692, -0.03842725232243538, -0.028649017214775085, 0.007277372293174267, -0.031787436455488205, -0.029979506507515907, 0.017469502985477448, 0.02389240823686123, 0.07925410568714142, -0.027611175552010536, -0.02761693485081196, -0.0016976890619844198, 0.022804422304034233, -0.0036893202923238277, -0.0016047139652073383, 0.01424693688750267, -0.07202719897031784, -0.021998725831508636, 0.04770427942276001, 0.06183933466672897, -0.06091367453336716, 0.013458481058478355, -0.05147290602326393, 0.0059472620487213135, 0.017267350107431412, -0.04251779988408089, 0.01445488166064024, -0.002434530993923545, -0.00790706928819418, -0.025145957246422768, -0.0343937911093235, -0.05749502405524254, 0.012377427890896797, -0.05260181799530983, 0.04318372905254364, -0.04596564546227455, -0.07227570563554764, -0.03941123187541962, -0.003488959511741996, 0.0006704781553708017, 0.05817045643925667, -0.025947578251361847, -0.049656942486763, 0.015323536470532417, 0.028115583583712578, 0.003068758873268962, -0.03217605501413345, 0.03438247740268707, 0.004285038914531469, -0.016581587493419647, 0.0293525829911232, 0.024168141186237335, -0.04631994292140007, 0.009132171981036663, 0.03586882725358009, -0.00846942514181137, -0.009670215658843517, -0.017186414450407028, 0.03378921002149582, -0.00826527364552021, -0.0460088774561882, 0.020344752818346024, 0.02118770405650139, -0.008364369161427021, 0.014946318231523037, -0.07320253551006317, -0.009920003823935986, -0.010870239697396755, -0.009620835073292255, -0.071550153195858, -0.016765767708420753, -0.03513673320412636, 0.01903527043759823, -0.006976661272346973, 0.03770381957292557, -0.028328130021691322, 0.005392868537455797, 0.03760476037859917, 0.016385940834879875, -0.011635667644441128, -0.01930755190551281, -0.01602938212454319, -0.0019464208744466305, -0.04173079878091812, 0.019282618537545204, 0.03204737976193428, -0.03175836056470871, 0.014836611226201057, 0.003152951132506132, -0.06478073447942734, -0.027419570833444595, -0.03171506151556969, -0.008575791493058205, -0.0041781337931752205, -0.016706528142094612, 0.018786802887916565, 0.021172095090150833, 0.04152405634522438, -0.022411620244383812, -0.021227849647402763, -0.04752437025308609, 0.03117118775844574, 0.016631918027997017, 0.02953215502202511, 0.016011258587241173, 0.03754481300711632, -0.006284881848841906, -0.011959974654018879, -0.04298749566078186, -0.04285011067986488, 0.01605064608156681, -0.005056784022599459, -0.00337628903798759, -0.05167070031166077, 0.007556712254881859, -0.02721543051302433, -0.015104271471500397, 0.009090278297662735, 0.02447543852031231, -0.03216060996055603, 0.01868385821580887, -0.0027728804852813482, 0.009319891221821308, 0.06373146176338196, 0.0023629784118384123, 0.010174406692385674, 0.006625781301409006, -0.020909985527396202, -0.02145499922335148, 0.012381114065647125, -0.006051898933947086, -0.021839382126927376, 0.00583903631195426, -0.030529238283634186, -0.008709392510354519, 0.03693513199687004, 0.023763084784150124, -0.040654804557561874, -0.010760374367237091, -0.02556578256189823, 0.017186354845762253, -0.015497260726988316, 0.0013582828687503934, 0.0048309750854969025, -0.024277040734887123, 0.009133781306445599, 0.005836689844727516, -0.009973431937396526, -0.0208283644169569, 0.01216837763786316, -0.01732313260436058, 0.00019989797146990895, 0.00809602253139019, 0.04035564139485359, -0.02788381278514862, 0.033517323434352875, -0.03306494653224945, -0.01599457673728466, 0.042268600314855576, 0.007680773735046387, 0.020026642829179764, -0.015616231597959995, 0.0687653049826622, -0.034113261848688126, -0.020451033487915993, -0.044990669935941696, -0.016471702605485916, 0.05258508026599884, 0.02133137732744217, 0.04581005126237869, 0.01825050264596939, -0.007598170079290867, 0.03062961809337139, -0.04229038581252098, -0.01247714925557375, 0.023751074448227882, 0.04063955694437027, 0.032208673655986786, 0.0014520135009661317, 0.016214586794376373, 0.08465643972158432, 0.01676608994603157, 0.004358906764537096, 0.04264557361602783, 0.01719731278717518, -0.017929842695593834, 0.004660184029489756, -0.07100865244865417, -0.04347076267004013, 0.0035889882128685713, -0.03460530564188957, 0.016175055876374245, -0.022711072117090225, -0.006659894250333309, 0.06728528439998627, 0.011795325204730034, 0.018197160214185715, -0.028567198663949966, -0.01254192553460598, -0.05145038291811943, -0.010153442621231079, 0.017488544806838036, -0.03900846838951111, 0.04944271221756935, 0.023848986253142357, 0.028173543512821198, 0.014070848934352398, 0.04391055554151535, -0.06291298568248749, -0.07077611982822418, -0.025723811239004135, -0.012830582447350025, -0.05544089153409004, 0.06531761586666107, -0.0027275835163891315, -0.011469583958387375, -0.03821709379553795, -0.006071710959076881, 0.04549310728907585, 0.03160301595926285, 0.03815827518701553, 0.02231048420071602, 0.054771389812231064, -0.01971285231411457, 0.03476475551724434, 0.014222420752048492, -0.027235958725214005, 0.13786768913269043, 0.08324892818927765, 0.00620958860963583, -0.059219520539045334, 0.016591204330325127, 0.023845095187425613, -0.005950808059424162, 0.006827943027019501, -0.03564697504043579, 0.01158442348241806, -0.03689126297831535, 0.03804613649845123, 0.01063304953277111, 0.023339807987213135, -0.01625191606581211, 0.03577527403831482, -0.028193632140755653, -0.006711072754114866, 0.028679857030510902, 0.03368670120835304, -0.01955139823257923, -0.01124915573745966, -0.053110040724277496, 0.0015440181596204638, 0.03788872808218002, -0.06103101000189781, -0.06706693023443222, 0.011383951641619205, -0.042234867811203, -0.000986746046692133, 0.027265937998890877, -0.0188286155462265, -0.006867940071970224, 0.0153517359867692, -0.0004982600221410394, 0.03512509539723396, -0.014638533815741539, -0.03891221806406975, 0.004023188259452581, 0.027990570291876793, 0.006600898690521717, 0.0071127754636108875, 0.012195036746561527, 0.02958986535668373, -0.085975281894207, -0.0029395532328635454, -0.014141304418444633, 0.06735510379076004, 0.016933677718043327, -0.013359034433960915, -0.03547696769237518, 0.016362389549613, 0.029900921508669853, -0.05742775276303291, 0.0034473175182938576, 0.021701589226722717, 0.027679018676280975, -0.04502134770154953, -0.004876440856605768, 0.011390102095901966, 0.016250960528850555, 0.005250210408121347, 0.034297142177820206, 0.04476715996861458, -0.02181197702884674, 0.0025059364270418882, 0.0008363688248209655, 0.028645973652601242, 0.011108340695500374, 0.033486705273389816, 0.009714107029139996, -0.010959596373140812, 0.010531000792980194, 0.004589087329804897, 0.03262964263558388, 0.014986707828938961, -0.003947305027395487, -0.013665495440363884, -0.029294252395629883, -0.037899747490882874, -0.03343992307782173, 0.03981857746839523, -0.027485499158501625, 0.004400438629090786, -0.0578140988945961, 0.007899065501987934, -0.026164229959249496, 0.06027102470397949, 0.034571319818496704, 0.003678497625514865, 0.011841977946460247, 0.03559641167521477, -0.011767982505261898, -0.046101946383714676, -0.03960786387324333, 0.020761623978614807, -0.033607903867959976, 0.02486376091837883, 0.031482066959142685, 0.08633032441139221, 0.04659967124462128, -0.0012743431143462658, 0.02138376049697399, 0.03188159316778183, 0.002517093438655138, -0.03143811598420143, -0.023961421102285385, -0.060765933245420456, -0.02236470952630043, -0.031173815950751305, -0.0041787149384617805, -0.027499759569764137, 0.008519900031387806, 0.014399027451872826, -0.02289755828678608, 0.006807165686041117, -0.015034529380500317, 0.011156518943607807, 0.005034319125115871, -0.023462403565645218, 0.02670932002365589, -0.050844404846429825, -0.021084513515233994, -0.02530345693230629, -0.017261169850826263, -0.028550591319799423, -0.02960069477558136, 0.008926295675337315, 0.0029757844749838114, -0.0034350063651800156, 0.017553972080349922, 0.035337433218955994, -0.0284273624420166, 0.030465496703982353, -0.005156907718628645, 0.01569218561053276, -0.007913261651992798, 0.06037912145256996, 0.008081083185970783, -0.0024556301068514585, 0.00364543660543859, -0.03341808542609215, -0.029532959684729576, 0.009013398550450802, -0.01764228381216526, 0.047231052070856094, 0.006227868143469095, 0.02157375030219555, -0.01413772813975811, 0.05606531724333763, -0.019341345876455307, 0.005026607308536768, 0.0008782859076745808, 0.022182011976838112, 0.03932550176978111, -0.000007946462574182078, -0.022268090397119522, 0.01898214779794216, -0.01752454973757267, 0.008461732417345047, 0.03442178666591644, 0.019603529945015907, -0.0390118844807148, 0.02782623842358589, 0.008763546124100685, -0.002983327955007553, 0.003992981743067503, 0.0009305157582275569, 0.028891578316688538, 0.02489786595106125, -0.014534595422446728, 0.06947845965623856, -0.026978759095072746, 0.00846648309379816, -0.08190865814685822, -0.020093144848942757, -0.01190910767763853, 0.04089383780956268, 0.008105290122330189, -0.03877904638648033, 0.009769240394234657, -0.0026295646093785763, -0.050890229642391205, 0.0002231873368145898, 0.016016677021980286, 0.028120724484324455, -0.02408454939723015, 0.008864057250320911, -0.03535707667469978, -0.025117067620158195, 0.04332945868372917, 0.009494040161371231, 0.04202621430158615, 0.006560586858540773, 0.009855298325419426, -0.03446974605321884, -0.03544918820261955, 0.03038097731769085, -0.001594948349520564, -0.09681276977062225, 0.013859335333108902, -0.0253763385117054, 0.015036226250231266, 0.012168199755251408, -0.0024143089540302753, 0.04640691354870796, 0.03618556261062622, 0.022607827559113503, 0.046549297869205475, 0.06472757458686829, 0.03263058885931969, -0.011159376241266727, -0.01100947242230177, -0.027729762718081474, 0.01945408061146736, 0.008748671039938927, -0.014046765863895416, 0.026742594316601753, 0.03509944677352905, 0.008671391755342484, -0.0158468559384346, -0.0014412321615964174, -0.03114856779575348, -0.010455932468175888, -0.0003129834949504584, -0.00473106699064374, -0.030490905046463013, -0.05991746485233307, -0.026663782075047493, -0.04176947474479675, 0.005841088946908712, 0.04318815842270851, -0.00011269933747826144, -0.029478300362825394, 0.016892356798052788, 0.02032255008816719, -0.03850673511624336, -0.029253115877509117, -0.017658641561865807, -0.024790683761239052, -0.04425048828125, -0.0011106012389063835, 0.009807388298213482, -0.015729693695902824, -0.03163420036435127, 0.02327139303088188, -0.03394739702343941, 0.054936788976192474, 0.006344249472022057, 0.035233110189437866, 0.04903449863195419, -0.038854457437992096, 0.024303900077939034, -0.05715654045343399, 0.03710562735795975, -0.0008668829104863107, -0.012843322940170765, -0.028551168739795685, -0.012673864141106606, -0.031552281230688095, 0.02640099823474884, 0.05886603146791458, 0.00522106746211648, 0.019136076793074608, -0.015667624771595, 0.015304679982364178, -0.0017873046454042196, -0.053051602095365524, 0.054689664393663406, 0.0004891831194981933, -0.015667371451854706, 0.0007144721457734704, 0.011663042940199375, 0.04768087714910507, 0.031836844980716705, 0.0034550840500742197, -0.00871029682457447, -0.03297547996044159, 0.03395017236471176, 0.011079076677560806, 0.0293237566947937, -0.01804150827229023, 0.001091390149667859, 0.021446099504828453, 0.013118070550262928, -0.008908466435968876, 0.06945525109767914, -0.003339420072734356, -0.05078168585896492, -0.01659909076988697, -0.00987184327095747, 0.004002669360488653, 0.01215128879994154, -0.022957809269428253, 0.036942578852176666, -0.0351322665810585, 0.010412816889584064, 0.0016268861945718527, -0.014002732001245022, 0.012838086113333702, 0.01504059974104166, -0.004241589922457933, 0.016236767172813416, 0.024673761799931526, 0.028336208313703537, -0.011376561596989632, -0.007249848451465368, 0.007242056541144848, 0.03657707944512367, 0.01368215586990118, -0.033353764563798904, 0.01126818172633648, 0.04087452217936516, 0.014176162891089916, 0.011115618981420994, 0.004678576253354549, 0.0525236651301384, -0.035267122089862823, -0.01934610866010189, -0.010046749375760555, 0.011807659640908241, 0.024713432416319847, -0.006170371547341347, -0.009354684501886368, 0.02790030650794506, -0.03818127512931824, 0.0030688459519296885, -0.018971681594848633, -0.03655143827199936, -0.027761096134781837, 0.027060218155384064, -0.019339529797434807, 0.02390865609049797, -0.019742993637919426, 0.017617778852581978, 0.030899260193109512, 0.019397465512156487, 0.007496965117752552, -0.02584603987634182, 0.03667644038796425, 0.014627372846007347, -0.010278435423970222, 0.032786063849925995, 0.013502757996320724, 0.03449374809861183, -0.02197946235537529, 0.013811822980642319, 0.05819562077522278, -0.022331904619932175, -0.017333660274744034, -0.009341109544038773, -0.00221498915925622, 0.027384284883737564, -0.020587045699357986, -0.032276492565870285, -0.048701684921979904, 0.01633591204881668, -0.0011067617451772094, -0.010809113271534443 ]
<p>I am working on a stock prediction model which predicts next day Open High Low and Close stock prices, my question is how to use RMSE and MAD to measure the error or accuracy for the entire model say 500 stocks? Or to clarify is the concept of RMSE and MAD useful only when looking at a single stock prediction error ? Does it make sense to average all RMSE or MAD for all 500 stocks ?</p> <p>Thanks,</p> <p>Deepesh</p>
74,503
[ -0.02610190585255623, 0.016873648390173912, -0.04079318791627884, 0.003778071841225028, 0.04987066984176636, 0.03601544350385666, -0.03834475204348564, -0.05764215067028999, 0.04427238926291466, -0.016942333430051804, 0.04376698285341263, 0.047851160168647766, 0.06309591978788376, 0.01375596784055233, 0.0025928157847374678, 0.03061431087553501, -0.03823809698224068, -0.03130638971924782, 0.01953510381281376, -0.048468053340911865, 0.0057784863747656345, 0.02083996869623661, 0.02406320907175541, 0.0015939142322167754, -0.02533922903239727, 0.048163462430238724, 0.07510871440172195, 0.01776118203997612, 0.012722749263048172, -0.004106901586055756, -0.046385250985622406, -0.028669055551290512, 0.0376250334084034, 0.06222034618258476, 0.007286377716809511, 0.017610160633921623, 0.004766830708831549, -0.032274506986141205, -0.06957904249429703, 0.014122430235147476, 0.01441800408065319, -0.04167594015598297, 0.014867116697132587, 0.007907687686383724, -0.028180725872516632, -0.02925020456314087, -0.031607210636138916, -0.044842179864645004, 0.03819454833865166, -0.03489978238940239, 0.10014694184064865, -0.0072561027482151985, 0.010523343458771706, 0.005480620078742504, -0.013864648528397083, 0.05631827190518379, 0.015434379689395428, 0.04836451634764671, -0.02909044921398163, -0.04207818582653999, -0.018908198922872543, -0.0061679985374212265, 0.005608933977782726, -0.0057144565507769585, -0.012768824584782124, 0.059744205325841904, -0.012383446097373962, 0.012978941202163696, 0.04728283733129501, 0.002594119170680642, 0.007829469628632069, 0.004752304870635271, 0.032347194850444794, 0.05045408010482788, 0.033467669039964676, -0.046918779611587524, 0.02063233032822609, 0.054666515439748764, 0.056120749562978745, 0.044177114963531494, -0.010507890023291111, 0.009552533738315105, 0.03292100131511688, 0.026401622220873833, 0.06839301437139511, -0.005210938863456249, 0.04641173034906387, 0.0043942066840827465, 0.06028240546584129, 0.026987003162503242, -0.02483479306101799, -0.015300696715712547, 0.02769167535007, -0.039026014506816864, -0.049798835068941116, 0.03494107350707054, -0.015990138053894043, 0.03741542622447014, 0.02161088027060032, -0.024929234758019447, 0.004664435517042875, -0.010386358015239239, 0.04254491627216339, 0.05051178112626076, 0.005924900062382221, -0.03072386421263218, -0.021413300186395645, -0.0383898951113224, -0.019469140097498894, -0.05455156788229942, -0.014772895723581314, -0.004077620338648558, 0.01582035981118679, -0.033079396933317184, 0.013297099620103836, 0.03196346014738083, -0.006748249288648367, 0.009543871507048607, 0.03320106491446495, 0.06308946013450623, 0.0276018213480711, -0.007699161767959595, 0.038912802934646606, -0.031052757054567337, -0.059067629277706146, 0.02228720858693123, 0.009434397332370281, -0.0377526693046093, -0.051460184156894684, 0.06287238746881485, 0.0075150420889258385, -0.025826124474406242, 0.00986072514206171, -0.03053301014006138, 0.04496930167078972, -0.0040029603987932205, -0.09602058678865433, -0.05414290353655815, 0.040654513984918594, 0.004372006747871637, 0.018237894400954247, -0.032705891877412796, -0.001857095048762858, 0.048013344407081604, 0.03419014811515808, 0.053393371403217316, 0.080966055393219, 0.049607567489147186, 0.034918468445539474, -0.013826420530676842, -0.053929634392261505, -0.0077468170784413815, -0.030016420409083366, 0.009967201389372349, -0.023083630949258804, -0.046531785279512405, 0.010319718159735203, 0.016825567930936813, -0.03974520415067673, 0.004087245091795921, -0.0014050123281776905, -0.0014259977033361793, -0.020072873681783676, 0.020408622920513153, 0.002485179342329502, -0.03555718809366226, 0.05660940334200859, 0.00047960327356122434, 0.03198250010609627, 0.0056591578759253025, -0.004776637069880962, -0.004434946924448013, 0.004398911260068417, 0.029493974521756172, 0.03540965914726257, -0.006020458415150642, 0.029377929866313934, -0.018695788457989693, 0.040857020765542984, 0.025409048423171043, -0.04786524176597595, 0.0007423343486152589, 0.006137317046523094, -0.011187877506017685, 0.011514698155224323, 0.04564407095313072, -0.007435513194650412, -0.0047168550081551075, 0.017520273104310036, -0.046131569892168045, -0.008295534178614616, -0.07085727900266647, -0.011548643000423908, -0.10327920317649841, -0.012848559767007828, -0.00021057769481558353, -0.01129840686917305, -0.015278574079275131, -0.01779920421540737, 0.00041066098492592573, -0.03903830051422119, -0.0028554375749081373, 0.023079244419932365, -0.01574520207941532, 0.043531227856874466, -0.010287698358297348, 0.003150410484522581, -0.025945723056793213, -0.018623502925038338, -0.07030532509088516, -0.02863694541156292, -0.012834794819355011, -0.024612031877040863, -0.0034277322702109814, 0.024967212229967117, -0.04124806821346283, 0.039986662566661835, -0.019145218655467033, -0.012188724242150784, -0.005171556957066059, -0.02270466275513172, 0.05505498871207237, 0.02919699437916279, -0.0119068194180727, 0.021295437589287758, 0.018101297318935394, 0.02053779736161232, -0.018485713750123978, -0.021497875452041626, 0.0044603850692510605, -0.029367541894316673, -0.014173694886267185, 0.0038364350330084562, 0.028834601864218712, -0.03423469886183739, 0.015279220417141914, 0.08405380696058273, -0.017215503379702568, 0.018924899399280548, 0.010623241774737835, -0.02887616492807865, -0.010941138491034508, 0.012969461269676685, 0.0067755077034235, -0.0273592472076416, -0.004893498029559851, 0.04260461777448654, 0.008687233552336693, -0.00912287924438715, 0.004263315815478563, 0.010868441313505173, 0.0729655921459198, -0.036393288522958755, 0.022273413836956024, -0.01628262735903263, -0.046059317886829376, 0.008460325188934803, 0.004029002506285906, 0.0015133451670408249, 0.039855726063251495, 0.014540725387632847, -0.00769707839936018, 0.02206295356154442, -0.021690158173441887, -0.009059985168278217, 0.03226722404360771, -0.04413694888353348, -0.02181454747915268, 0.01985142193734646, -0.04781637340784073, -0.0015951493987813592, 0.01846720464527607, 0.010089559480547905, -0.03310568258166313, 0.03510868176817894, 0.06539324671030045, -0.008337631821632385, 0.03826948627829552, -0.029756704345345497, -0.03623224049806595, -0.03757515549659729, -0.026615576818585396, 0.030840806663036346, -0.006696708500385284, -0.052164364606142044, 0.029793482273817062, -0.006485543213784695, -0.056966252624988556, 0.033655084669589996, 0.009642659686505795, -0.03164523467421532, 0.051195867359638214, -0.006262315437197685, -0.045497529208660126, -0.03975630924105644, -0.035228099673986435, -0.00928562507033348, -0.004148473031818867, -0.009587245993316174, 0.036558203399181366, 0.019530102610588074, -0.03878270089626312, 0.012972953729331493, -0.03902700915932655, -0.00903371348977089, -0.030976254492998123, -0.02029927633702755, 0.017331663519144058, -0.02034524828195572, 0.028700731694698334, 0.04777916520833969, -0.022654922679066658, -0.012209979817271233, -0.07255128771066666, -0.07444038987159729, 0.008029420860111713, 0.013766990974545479, 0.01326968614012003, 0.036129433661699295, -0.005745577160269022, 0.059326767921447754, 0.01816471852362156, -0.03723416477441788, -0.043187256902456284, 0.005480374209582806, -0.014270424842834473, -0.018352307379245758, 0.011887275613844395, -0.0005108874174766243, 0.015191200189292431, -0.006563262082636356, 0.0040292805060744286, 0.02843509614467621, 0.051159296184778214, -0.00845872052013874, 0.009917660616338253, 0.0029011813458055258, 0.0025974244344979525, -0.024349458515644073, 0.02859232947230339, -0.0028918643947690725, -0.008899913169443607, -0.01247410848736763, 0.01292075403034687, 0.01755165122449398, 0.015374531969428062, -0.021434515714645386, 0.02102796733379364, -0.05455756187438965, -0.03116714023053646, -0.0013664052821695805, 0.03267786279320717, -0.004670135676860809, -0.01984814926981926, 0.005398096051067114, 0.013686460442841053, 0.024671459570527077, 0.009883233346045017, -0.01646178402006626, 0.05803682655096054, 0.004343385808169842, -0.0120003130286932, -0.04315178841352463, -0.023434190079569817, 0.01616514101624489, -0.0025682372506707907, -0.01725504733622074, -0.018587494269013405, 0.018024375662207603, 0.010080520063638687, 0.032226987183094025, -0.005704933777451515, -0.038378871977329254, -0.0002234966232208535, -0.027112353593111038, 0.006118240766227245, -0.07013122737407684, 0.07401304692029953, 0.025166770443320274, 0.04102924466133118, 0.012250290252268314, -0.023848148062825203, 0.028198715299367905, 0.011674885638058186, -0.0312592051923275, 0.0464724563062191, 0.006766387261450291, -0.027018675580620766, -0.008590396493673325, -0.029103415086865425, 0.02744659036397934, -0.04780513048171997, 0.0058612702414393425, -0.008595910854637623, 0.008681422099471092, -0.07697848975658417, -0.028831440955400467, -0.011223557405173779, 0.002450021216645837, -0.016946522518992424, 0.01591555029153824, 0.003423270070925355, 0.014811922796070576, 0.05182645842432976, 0.015521208755671978, -0.043088991194963455, -0.029907921329140663, -0.021229470148682594, 0.003832923946902156, -0.006631683092564344, 0.040799617767333984, 0.06673894077539444, 0.04040710628032684, -0.06532768905162811, 0.04938903823494911, 0.026440128684043884, 0.06522770971059799, 0.06118357181549072, -0.013148999772965908, -0.012912376783788204, -0.04102368280291557, -0.011914823204278946, 0.016101516783237457, -0.007764490321278572, -0.0028041789773851633, -0.008144140243530273, 0.06493843346834183, -0.009106475859880447, -0.03857582062482834, 0.008363126777112484, 0.06936077028512955, -0.002026861999183893, 0.008680913597345352, -0.04126721993088722, 0.012412875890731812, 0.005732736084610224, -0.0014277261216193438, 0.03623189032077789, -0.01779429242014885, -0.004812761675566435, -0.0077346679754555225, 0.012736818753182888, -0.024010883644223213, -0.0507538877427578, 0.007610099855810404, 0.049475062638521194, 0.03365940973162651, 0.014000322669744492, -0.024109087884426117, 0.02097349427640438, 0.03716917708516121, 0.041040219366550446, 0.0025904544163495302, -0.0046550799161195755, -0.10118110477924347, 0.042115550488233566, 0.027637029066681862, 0.035228632390499115, -0.02006189525127411, -0.022213641554117203, -0.04206904396414757, 0.014815227128565311, 0.036506012082099915, -0.0061576212756335735, 0.018832892179489136, -0.020975710824131966, 0.050686195492744446, -0.018201574683189392, 0.004687517415732145, -0.019860398024320602, 0.006565123796463013, -0.008519746363162994, 0.03634261712431908, -0.018354132771492004, 0.023481683805584908, -0.024455420672893524, -0.01024711225181818, 0.02760099247097969, 0.053235869854688644, -0.016038216650485992, 0.017855774611234665, -0.004196920432150364, 0.010089362971484661, -0.0027830081526190042, -0.0479927659034729, -0.01643487624824047, -0.014133757911622524, -0.028063638135790825, 0.04322119057178497, -0.016728943213820457, -0.04938780143857002, 0.0256794523447752, 0.0387301966547966, 0.006276451982557774, -0.03703846037387848, -0.04321015253663063, -0.0037479684688150883, 0.013957205228507519, 0.013433149084448814, 0.04813193902373314, 0.0016994350589811802, 0.031892042607069016, 0.021463733166456223, -0.010565990582108498, 0.019398963078856468, -0.023344554007053375, -0.04207354784011841, -0.010292570106685162, -0.051619503647089005, -0.022691531106829643, 0.023674683645367622, -0.02388903498649597, 0.055083129554986954, -0.04278326779603958, -0.016567302867770195, -0.011824208311736584, 0.030237087979912758, -0.012415762059390545, -0.019813571125268936, -0.018168197944760323, 0.00464635482057929, -0.06643453240394592, -0.01383544597774744, 0.018732592463493347, -0.019034111872315407, 0.028475353494286537, 0.02455642819404602, -0.028906291350722313, -0.0024897148832678795, -0.0012742056278511882, -0.028973029926419258, 0.022109072655439377, 0.024844981729984283, 0.061281125992536545, -0.0036933363880962133, -0.0031914052087813616, -0.012206992134451866, -0.033527396619319916, 0.007403957657516003, 0.02251167967915535, 0.009284190833568573, 0.025727882981300354, 0.002138284035027027, 0.027926264330744743, -0.00016549920837860554, -0.02626030705869198, -0.05443592742085457, -0.08237233012914658, 0.029161963611841202, 0.006130514666438103, -0.018064754083752632, -0.013557769358158112, 0.025343451648950577, -0.03389344736933708, 0.005136614199727774, -0.03971714898943901, 0.023426035419106483, 0.00513992877677083, -0.007503192406147718, 0.016519563272595406, -0.02207815833389759, 0.07775453478097916, 0.004213526379317045, -0.02465556561946869, 0.02307101897895336, 0.015645340085029602, -0.0028937782626599073, 0.036547835916280746, 0.048108138144016266, -0.043244075030088425, -0.0005777628975920379, -0.04229138791561127, -0.029879650101065636, 0.04737472906708717, 0.011284171603620052, 0.0049823890440166, 0.015353105030953884, 0.033239275217056274, 0.007506436202675104, -0.04311458021402359, -0.0023676964920014143, 0.0019005005015060306, -0.004303761757910252, 0.017260391265153885, -0.009043307974934578, 0.01738682948052883, 0.007153210695832968, 0.0190840195864439, 0.0022062945645302534, -0.01820818893611431, 0.024480948224663734, 0.09512507170438766, 0.004625079687684774, 0.012903774157166481, -0.006294544320553541, -0.024227986112236977, 0.05156906321644783, -0.021913466975092888, 0.03168769180774689, 0.004636723548173904, 0.03798731788992882, -0.0031995202880352736, -0.03954402729868889, -0.01908859983086586, 0.019926732406020164, 0.08391358703374863, -0.02331569418311119, 0.02868877351284027, 0.01254733745008707, 0.050361596047878265, -0.02711659111082554, -0.07509490847587585, -0.007945636287331581, 0.0024432316422462463, 0.012592769227921963, 0.040510691702365875, -0.010549778118729591, 0.03339121863245964, -0.016940215602517128, 0.007007186766713858, 0.03138203173875809, 0.04021383449435234, 0.015066638588905334, 0.05570180341601372, 0.00033903660369105637, -0.003526452463120222, -0.0303379874676466, 0.02975328639149666, -0.025647642090916634, -0.0018907968187704682, -0.058495864272117615, -0.007830639369785786, 0.014359197579324245, 0.019703254103660583, 0.004629562143236399, -0.03392763435840607, -0.01073237881064415, -0.03516286611557007, 0.023429078981280327, 0.01596304588019848, -0.018097879365086555, 0.026669148355722427, 0.016223004087805748, 0.04031383618712425, 0.007534445729106665, 0.05857529491186142, -0.003160529537126422, -0.06960861384868622, -0.006487488280981779, -0.020843027159571648, -0.025399742648005486, 0.017036983743309975, 0.02193816564977169, -0.01158810593187809, 0.019170628860592842, -0.012129150331020355, 0.004649371840059757, -0.00434138486161828, 0.010839836671948433, -0.02146032080054283, 0.061897605657577515, -0.013091184198856354, 0.01142881065607071, 0.012117135338485241, -0.0021918779239058495, 0.1165555864572525, 0.07811473309993744, 0.00018212548457086086, -0.06153716892004013, -0.0071221692487597466, -0.03604644909501076, -0.0035278007853776217, -0.026482857763767242, 0.03672683611512184, -0.022420989349484444, -0.01383951585739851, 0.04394260793924332, 0.052201103419065475, -0.003385267686098814, -0.003186499932780862, 0.03284502401947975, -0.037736181169748306, -0.01860756240785122, 0.01859567128121853, 0.0009199914638884366, 0.053358327597379684, 0.0073229107074439526, -0.025996752083301544, 0.05861932039260864, -0.05985833704471588, -0.003917108289897442, -0.0044885799288749695, -0.0012949502561241388, 0.016393359750509262, 0.004019479732960463, -0.01138272788375616, 0.012127772904932499, 0.014741824939846992, 0.02659025974571705, 0.006804984528571367, 0.010969218797981739, 0.004757487680763006, -0.04054021090269089, 0.015185324475169182, 0.0060329497791826725, -0.006377688609063625, -0.009239178150892258, 0.0023832442238926888, 0.014612511731684208, -0.022074097767472267, -0.043772660195827484, -0.05387398600578308, 0.0068186805583536625, 0.03367670997977257, -0.020915495231747627, -0.010297933593392372, 0.03143475204706192, -0.021537821739912033, -0.04934019595384598, -0.01255510002374649, 0.037743572145700455, -0.0020134993828833103, -0.036194052547216415, -0.006252923049032688, -0.02918803133070469, 0.04969734698534012, 0.0024696113541722298, 0.013173114508390427, -0.005926127545535564, -0.043097808957099915, -0.026050908491015434, -0.02848895452916622, 0.048305023461580276, -0.037700798362493515, 0.0013287158217281103, -0.027027636766433716, 0.00322244456037879, -0.04338241368532181, -0.022701671347022057, -0.0020583535078912973, 0.00791460182517767, 0.02062820829451084, 0.0022069367114454508, 0.0024382974952459335, 0.0010168550070375204, -0.06105370074510574, 0.027397122234106064, 0.005794570315629244, -0.02496333047747612, -0.0583556704223156, -0.0042086634784936905, 0.04760359227657318, 0.02903762087225914, 0.022992901504039764, 0.004916540812700987, -0.02271994948387146, 0.042207490652799606, 0.023066604509949684, -0.016227005049586296, 0.00018795397772919387, 0.04952944442629814, -0.04040628299117088, 0.01939527690410614, -0.02900310419499874, 0.05099450796842575, 0.027554892003536224, -0.014186948537826538, -0.027661612257361412, 0.03565289080142975, 0.012761013582348824, 0.019688641652464867, -0.02520923689007759, -0.037708744406700134, 0.001897726091556251, 0.015451398678123951, -0.04022984951734543, -0.01410412136465311, -0.0013672191416844726, -0.04947665333747864, -0.0011270291870459914, 0.00010969792492687702, -0.008210751228034496, -0.025266965851187706, 0.04011424630880356, 0.0074143316596746445, 0.03709467500448227, -0.008254875428974628, -0.01845693401992321, -0.010362636297941208, 0.0003806437598541379, -0.016494717448949814, -0.05319833382964134, -0.012884744442999363, -0.010071353986859322, -0.012927169911563396, -0.013742474839091301, 0.012537372298538685, 0.016244245693087578, -0.0056621902622282505, -0.028619689866900444, -0.010044978931546211, -0.01923978514969349, 0.06426826864480972, -0.04599723592400551, -0.01649957336485386, 0.0109795480966568, -0.08541863411664963, -0.03639722988009453, 0.014730867929756641, 0.0008275853469967842, 0.030811261385679245, 0.02489841729402542, 0.01973719149827957, -0.02913336083292961, 0.03676781430840492, -0.03809602931141853, -0.02480732463300228, -0.008857210166752338, 0.009414163418114185, 0.03686199337244034, 0.01608245261013508, 0.034441519528627396, 0.006896452512592077, -0.008108876645565033, 0.008503520861268044, 0.023867236450314522, 0.01733027584850788, -0.02838573046028614, 0.020809682086110115, -0.012704048305749893, 0.020735083147883415, -0.01846453920006752, 0.00020684974151663482, 0.05527651682496071, 0.024120137095451355, -0.022694861516356468, -0.0032949158921837807, -0.03040795400738716, 0.010338946245610714, -0.06432344019412994, -0.024536574259400368, 0.0329066626727581, -0.004179363138973713, 0.042998965829610825, -0.03082527406513691, -0.0036172475665807724, 0.06246701255440712, -0.06416257470846176, 0.0035852522123605013, -0.016205238178372383, 0.0018201322527602315, -0.0409911647439003, 0.024084284901618958, -0.007908482104539871, 0.02213309146463871, -0.006460995879024267, -0.030117804184556007, 0.028482303023338318, -0.019510291516780853, -0.013221087865531445, -0.011028512381017208, -0.006406668573617935, 0.049234043806791306, 0.033188894391059875, -0.05056647211313248, 0.02752820961177349, -0.054255638271570206, -0.06025496870279312, 0.06642643362283707, -0.006909056566655636, 0.01975890062749386, 0.023501425981521606, 0.04619252309203148, -0.011031984351575375, 0.04723614454269409, 0.0007460222113877535, -0.03296351432800293, -0.0023598431143909693, -0.001521624973975122, 0.023158540949225426, 0.03951822221279144, 0.0009149928810074925, 0.027689989656209946, 0.015145890414714813, -0.02009008638560772, -0.04654437676072121, 0.013136005029082298, 0.027114262804389, -0.04052009433507919, -0.03549831733107567, 0.01307094655930996, 0.007263873238116503, -0.0393117293715477, 0.010055432096123695, 0.004973617382347584, 0.012823659926652908, 0.06293962150812149, 0.010690001770853996, -0.000505749718286097, 0.010254587978124619, 0.0025218327064067125, -0.0403483584523201, 0.04450028017163277, 0.012557818554341793, -0.03429776057600975, -0.028013674542307854, -0.0031850836239755154, 0.02459642104804516, -0.02654399909079075, -0.04367604851722717, -0.023335231468081474, -0.010579319670796394, 0.06124524027109146, -0.0392029844224453, 0.02860129065811634, 0.036925654858350754, -0.010995951481163502, -0.00905646849423647, -0.07481425255537033, 0.05855296179652214, 0.02123243361711502, -0.015308467671275139, -0.01832563616335392, 0.009880992583930492, -0.0025128722190856934, -0.015815751627087593, 0.018062448129057884, 0.008675934746861458, 0.003676388645544648, 0.008870409801602364, 0.019892241805791855, 0.002453187946230173, -0.05889667198061943, 0.024494456127285957, -0.03924974426627159, -0.024925334379076958, -0.043634314090013504, -0.0169962290674448, 0.0005623518954962492, 0.008873365819454193, -0.0013289285125210881, -0.02209978550672531, 0.025328630581498146, -0.006458923686295748, 0.02845347672700882, 0.04683650657534599, 0.02453610859811306, -0.03459935635328293, 0.06842941045761108, 0.03641375154256821, -0.0033765106927603483, 0.018207691609859467, 0.0007254676893353462, -0.041454605758190155, 0.021898575127124786, 0.0011063560377806425, -0.03745884448289871, -0.01915416307747364, 0.023758603259921074, -0.004389445763081312, -0.034113604575395584, -0.03724539652466774, 0.0408555306494236, -0.04168292507529259, 0.009920850396156311, 0.046508386731147766, 0.006646389607340097, 0.041227150708436966, -0.009162891656160355, 0.037270933389663696, 0.026827476918697357, -0.038885485380887985, -0.001185656408779323, -0.02464870922267437, 0.0516718327999115, 0.017894448712468147, 0.035727404057979584, 0.030077725648880005, -0.05808884650468826, -0.001522753038443625, -0.022861482575535774, 0.041631635278463364, -0.020324967801570892, -0.015013711526989937, 0.01228687446564436, -0.03304844722151756, 0.00723009929060936, -0.00551978126168251, -0.03202278912067413, 0.039655886590480804, -0.0450885146856308, -0.019363602623343468, -0.03546629846096039, -0.02810186706483364, -0.022161433473229408, -0.007518487982451916, -0.01438619289547205, 0.04184628650546074, 0.01900763437151909, -0.00356597313657403, 0.013806002214550972, 0.016650531440973282, 0.05185084789991379, -0.03740214556455612, 0.031912341713905334, -0.017147576436400414, 0.02698400616645813, -0.008037440478801727, 0.008030053228139877, -0.06785466521978378, -0.029851490631699562, 0.037444859743118286, 0.0515303909778595, 0.03940463811159134, 0.005577719304710627, -0.053891316056251526, -0.019602494314312935, 0.011808972805738449, -0.0763167217373848, -0.005586243700236082, -0.03161301836371422, 0.004866676405072212, -0.026274871081113815, -0.013593149371445179 ]
<p>I have about $50$ Bernoulli random variables $X_i$ whose joint distribution is unknown, but I can generate a sample of size on the order of $10^4$. They are not independent, but I think the dependence is rather weak. I would like to get some idea of ${\rm Pr}({\rm all}\ X_i = 1)$, which I expect to be considerably smaller than $10^{-4}$, maybe around $10^{-6}$ (so it's unlikely that the sample will contain outcomes with all $X_i = 1$). If I assumed they were independent, I could estimate their means and multiply these estimates. What can I do that takes correlations into account?</p>
74,504
[ -0.01218528300523758, -0.02779022976756096, -0.0016542646335437894, 0.004860570654273033, 0.06182261183857918, 0.03441542387008667, -0.017949597910046577, -0.0011520319385454059, 0.0029972135089337826, -0.07341358065605164, 0.06090344488620758, 0.055165089666843414, 0.05012432485818863, 0.023653773590922356, 0.046362314373254776, 0.006381053943186998, -0.04172390699386597, -0.026514019817113876, 0.016153696924448013, -0.025625478476285934, 0.03801769018173218, 0.030856026336550713, 0.05464271083474159, 0.004746002145111561, -0.03197171911597252, 0.05138147249817848, 0.0011832176242023706, -0.010922144167125225, -0.013022815808653831, 0.08432017266750336, -0.008841187693178654, -0.034074973315000534, 0.02032475359737873, 0.06710267812013626, -0.008314902894198895, -0.014223208650946617, -0.01745668612420559, -0.02489982359111309, 0.013526393100619316, 0.024041855707764626, -0.0912850871682167, -0.04861947149038315, 0.011946604587137699, -0.015677781775593758, 0.003678959095850587, 0.0016160092782229185, 0.028503401204943657, -0.0658990740776062, 0.04091135039925575, -0.019824277609586716, 0.08275596797466278, 0.03899451717734337, 0.02464219182729721, 0.03862203657627106, -0.008884363807737827, -0.029747670516371727, 0.026616765186190605, 0.06820863485336304, 0.01082307193428278, -0.03555893152952194, -0.007927377708256245, -0.039716076105833054, 0.036963194608688354, -0.039447080343961716, -0.03523319214582443, -0.005595790687948465, -0.034175071865320206, -0.022464795038104057, 0.023580780252814293, 0.0019166311249136925, 0.04371386021375656, 0.05707569420337677, 0.031197763979434967, 0.022066399455070496, 0.008084793575108051, 0.023865411058068275, 0.016806524246931076, 0.015847012400627136, 0.045834727585315704, 0.02429524064064026, -0.01802804321050644, 0.016565514728426933, 0.02835056744515896, 0.029106512665748596, 0.0034284288994967937, -0.00867810845375061, 0.07266929745674133, 0.008710443042218685, 0.026043707504868507, 0.0054459478706121445, -0.02049579657614231, -0.005630912259221077, 0.0603526346385479, 0.031054042279720306, -0.03719622641801834, 0.012607249431312084, -0.05480777844786644, 0.050862159579992294, -0.020022233948111534, -0.010810146108269691, -0.007711948826909065, -0.04150630906224251, -0.0008272181730717421, 0.07066451013088226, -0.04586898535490036, -0.02489047683775425, -0.021240150555968285, 0.01022002100944519, -0.0160954799503088, -0.060950521379709244, -0.008445169776678085, 0.016251493245363235, 0.01621563918888569, -0.01295708678662777, 0.031262531876564026, -0.004258941859006882, -0.010109280236065388, -0.014612802304327488, 0.02391759864985943, 0.07369250804185867, 0.022423142567276955, -0.031435295939445496, 0.024618444964289665, -0.04666176810860634, -0.054760828614234924, 0.03434234857559204, 0.009559287689626217, -0.05222926288843155, -0.0417901948094368, 0.05037296563386917, -0.016143061220645905, -0.032172247767448425, 0.001712130382657051, 0.020775869488716125, 0.02827444113790989, -0.00776424678042531, -0.06148615851998329, -0.03271779045462608, 0.054935865104198456, -0.04280998185276985, -0.004760087467730045, -0.04932280629873276, 0.025320665910840034, 0.029558682814240456, 0.06443285197019577, -0.02637992426753044, 0.04083148390054703, 0.005007427651435137, 0.042069390416145325, 0.013686778023838997, -0.023537958040833473, -0.014149445109069347, -0.010248015634715557, 0.0016482338542118669, -0.009633929468691349, -0.08083446323871613, -0.0001910329156089574, 0.00048722606152296066, -0.006639653351157904, -0.030415857210755348, 0.04699862748384476, 0.03834272921085358, -0.01371132954955101, -0.026238150894641876, 0.05350598692893982, -0.04099120944738388, 0.08822760730981827, -0.0025886886287480593, 0.026469608768820763, 0.014590376056730747, -0.003795419353991747, -0.028346717357635498, 0.04104086011648178, 0.03689666837453842, 0.06105220690369606, -0.0024263360537588596, -0.00015908341447357088, 0.004411893896758556, -0.009155514650046825, 0.005968083627521992, -0.020466743037104607, -0.039273593574762344, -0.031084217131137848, -0.02455822005867958, -0.00009859907004283741, 0.040686462074518204, 0.0001210726477438584, -0.004765882156789303, 0.021236514672636986, -0.02991580218076706, -0.035784199833869934, -0.08238060772418976, -0.017497727647423744, 0.008010318502783775, -0.014394143596291542, 0.04603847861289978, 0.014889673329889774, 0.03329294174909592, 0.004054955206811428, -0.04872654750943184, -0.053965043276548386, 0.0017669672379270196, 0.059381578117609024, -0.04109915345907211, 0.014021105132997036, 0.006039516534656286, 0.03356694430112839, -0.02337210439145565, 0.027783934026956558, -0.030331803485751152, -0.053170863538980484, 0.018665876239538193, -0.05680672451853752, 0.020651226863265038, -0.0021474850364029408, -0.04870917275547981, -0.010418897494673729, -0.0126709695905447, -0.004041677340865135, 0.007246800698339939, -0.0014954439830034971, 0.05761914327740669, 0.049893107265233994, 0.03410149738192558, -0.008699760772287846, 0.01481441967189312, 0.0379473939538002, -0.015700729563832283, -0.05492985248565674, -0.0293019637465477, -0.06660297513008118, -0.011256717145442963, 0.02742956392467022, 0.037965040653944016, -0.030366400256752968, 0.002246939344331622, 0.06081251800060272, 0.02378017082810402, 0.0216105617582798, 0.0179130956530571, 0.0073297275230288506, -0.017088403925299644, -0.003785088425502181, 0.01676168479025364, 0.018659742549061775, -0.0074691204354166985, -0.03189073130488396, 0.021158475428819656, 0.028095556423068047, -0.007223594002425671, -0.00925310980528593, 0.004402576945722103, 0.008657680824398994, 0.015167907811701298, -0.026755258440971375, -0.01802559569478035, 0.03216542303562164, -0.0203841719776392, -0.0019006750080734491, 0.028421642258763313, 0.03721202537417412, 0.0029091788455843925, 0.027074335142970085, -0.050123654305934906, 0.04530642181634903, 0.031503502279520035, -0.06569325923919678, -0.016809476539492607, 0.0016555965412408113, -0.023069845512509346, 0.012199417687952518, -0.012023401446640491, -0.02218598686158657, -0.03036799654364586, 0.01191623229533434, 0.034102968871593475, 0.026415342465043068, 0.021691706031560898, -0.04277986288070679, -0.0339384526014328, 0.03502407297492027, -0.002313703065738082, -0.003032354637980461, 0.029838627204298973, -0.03785952925682068, -0.018595624715089798, -0.028085801750421524, -0.02285725809633732, 0.035181302577257156, 0.013952085748314857, -0.021862804889678955, 0.007505674846470356, -0.013266916386783123, -0.044933997094631195, -0.019899914041161537, -0.023419175297021866, -0.0023764909710735083, -0.06062087416648865, -0.02884916216135025, 0.07063949853181839, -0.01768052950501442, -0.03495451807975769, -0.013997050002217293, -0.038727860897779465, -0.007441369350999594, -0.028485167771577835, 0.002780090318992734, 0.03607868775725365, -0.00003398083572392352, 0.020098475739359856, 0.01097705215215683, 0.011189989745616913, -0.017036542296409607, -0.04129423573613167, -0.08514445275068283, 0.0259750634431839, 0.005529569927603006, 0.016002802178263664, 0.018582196906208992, -0.037312354892492294, 0.055402278900146484, 0.01122205052524805, 0.005688363686203957, -0.045531440526247025, -0.000589001108892262, 0.015371977351605892, 0.006263697985559702, -0.005692131817340851, -0.00286294287070632, -0.004808573517948389, 0.026795025914907455, 0.024113375693559647, 0.00033654627623036504, 0.016498196870088577, 0.0317031592130661, -0.0012799054384231567, 0.009448721073567867, -0.0222173985093832, 0.022243572399020195, 0.0010595540516078472, -0.0029114496428519487, -0.03221200406551361, -0.006031263154000044, 0.02155563049018383, 0.029019705951213837, 0.03582904487848282, -0.020080197602510452, 0.011656366288661957, 0.010872944258153439, 0.02343953214585781, -0.034728433936834335, 0.03502585366368294, 0.018980111926794052, -0.034050192683935165, 0.010369028896093369, 0.025204723700881004, 0.05327636003494263, -0.000745137978810817, 0.03327513486146927, 0.034336019307374954, 0.010052964091300964, 0.007004003971815109, -0.017530281096696854, -0.022804778069257736, -0.05087443068623543, 0.015112212859094143, -0.0075385114178061485, -0.004873256199061871, 0.04637981206178665, 0.037885915488004684, 0.011011038906872272, -0.03205472603440285, -0.04107198864221573, 0.0261880811303854, -0.028670188039541245, -0.011373826302587986, -0.04282407462596893, 0.058421798050403595, 0.02480403706431389, 0.03577988222241402, 0.005271620117127895, -0.020433863624930382, 0.003520568599924445, 0.03757776692509651, -0.05534784868359566, 0.04007810354232788, -0.02895526774227619, -0.006452577188611031, -0.002046526875346899, -0.008525856770575047, 0.06286583840847015, 0.0007194738136604428, 0.016697097569704056, -0.01852487213909626, 0.039441026747226715, -0.032023437321186066, -0.014454232528805733, -0.03822951763868332, -0.01380076352506876, -0.005649312864989042, 0.029039651155471802, -0.00480152852833271, -0.029944218695163727, 0.04402681440114975, 0.025000574067234993, 0.013677595183253288, -0.005908579099923372, -0.047339778393507004, 0.029009900987148285, -0.015262334607541561, 0.04522491618990898, 0.026499899104237556, 0.028172969818115234, -0.032367147505283356, 0.04061873257160187, 0.0012493041576817632, 0.0482584647834301, 0.04222358018159866, 0.01363369356840849, 0.03660125657916069, -0.05723641812801361, -0.010537865571677685, 0.018999069929122925, -0.02532210759818554, 0.00799830537289381, 0.008388538844883442, 0.07372824847698212, 0.023734070360660553, -0.0669793114066124, -0.0024332294706255198, 0.02702370472252369, -0.0016773000825196505, -0.00997074693441391, -0.016360832378268242, 0.00846017710864544, -0.0020637440029531717, 0.029501792043447495, -0.00541782658547163, -0.0049696145579218864, 0.004227301571518183, -0.002850191667675972, 0.04839566722512245, -0.022268477827310562, -0.035833001136779785, -0.00855412520468235, -0.0341554619371891, 0.040786437690258026, -0.009696885012090206, -0.08806010335683823, 0.016822252422571182, 0.010760015808045864, -0.0012006062315776944, 0.015756526961922646, 0.01993473991751671, -0.08250877261161804, 0.02596578747034073, 0.01914277859032154, 0.044352538883686066, -0.03180038928985596, 0.00338056986220181, -0.017041202634572983, -0.027375133708119392, 0.07029999792575836, 0.000035668843338498846, -0.02407017908990383, 0.015628447756171227, -0.007022351026535034, 0.009737447835505009, -0.05186765268445015, -0.05676205828785896, 0.01982712186872959, -0.036008041352033615, 0.01304786279797554, -0.01892634853720665, -0.003445798996835947, -0.03334156796336174, 0.025463629513978958, 0.011666711419820786, 0.062265392392873764, -0.0014801938086748123, 0.011298549361526966, -0.022956643253564835, 0.039579059928655624, 0.04847275838255882, -0.0769767239689827, 0.016354676336050034, -0.0046449946239590645, -0.05079489201307297, 0.06266956031322479, -0.032568346709012985, -0.04965986683964729, 0.03932506591081619, -0.026780012995004654, -0.01842441037297249, -0.0213753804564476, -0.016702501103281975, 0.06047103554010391, 0.03192644566297531, 0.02313389629125595, 0.05046815797686577, 0.03990308567881584, -0.011429019272327423, -0.03379209339618683, -0.011932077817618847, 0.03301790729165077, -0.02802436612546444, 0.0028062209021300077, -0.03799956291913986, 0.002417051000520587, 0.005674386862665415, 0.045064475387334824, -0.02450958639383316, 0.05076974630355835, 0.017148364335298538, -0.018110767006874084, -0.006778640206903219, 0.042582686990499496, 0.017774231731891632, 0.018972814083099365, 0.002986957086250186, 0.0018196053570136428, -0.010373063385486603, -0.03674103692173958, 0.015426411293447018, 0.010942650027573109, 0.0019916172605007887, 0.022242411971092224, -0.04073624312877655, -0.004838301334530115, -0.05641162395477295, -0.007135459221899509, 0.005209203343838453, -0.04029150307178497, 0.05622237175703049, 0.015462227165699005, 0.039998240768909454, -0.015297184698283672, -0.020165933296084404, 0.004732142668217421, 0.006322728004306555, 0.010938161984086037, 0.045414358377456665, -0.026629038155078888, -0.016082877293229103, -0.04832309111952782, 0.0026494362391531467, -0.055637456476688385, -0.047688115388154984, 0.013951978646218777, 0.029615657404065132, 0.049335986375808716, -0.04809514433145523, 0.007230971474200487, -0.01180496159940958, -0.027910694479942322, -0.02500128373503685, 0.029919136315584183, -0.0012891492806375027, -0.007963252253830433, -0.0018454231321811676, 0.0221050214022398, 0.09153420478105545, -0.021136820316314697, -0.0052269077859818935, 0.03262338414788246, -0.02027706243097782, -0.016950534656643867, 0.014511852525174618, -0.02128300629556179, -0.027162699028849602, 0.00822877325117588, -0.01641702465713024, -0.01914667710661888, 0.029291044920682907, -0.04163842648267746, -0.011217796243727207, 0.03985685482621193, 0.03144729509949684, 0.0038973952177911997, -0.0164737980812788, -0.0261350329965353, -0.01054378878325224, 0.006295692175626755, 0.0016273076180368662, -0.02677743136882782, -0.002893122611567378, -0.021633299067616463, 0.05905543640255928, 0.05027839168906212, -0.018132565543055534, 0.018765388056635857, 0.057206083089113235, 0.006541147828102112, -0.016733786091208458, 0.01171282771974802, 0.00013172102626413107, 0.021644463762640953, 0.021718710660934448, 0.00225929100997746, 0.026978690177202225, 0.014772267080843449, -0.030575914308428764, -0.034828491508960724, -0.03395116701722145, 0.00021097593707963824, 0.07009012997150421, -0.04179149493575096, 0.042439285665750504, 0.030627992004156113, 0.0009565908112563193, -0.0021154682617634535, -0.0009378553368151188, -0.010109924711287022, 0.022062277421355247, 0.005620328243821859, 0.020375655964016914, -0.02399866282939911, -0.021332478150725365, 0.006364753469824791, 0.002841806737706065, -0.012743687257170677, 0.017416272312402725, -0.0014705198118463159, 0.03221132233738899, 0.01849590614438057, -0.05205945670604706, -0.008776338770985603, 0.010448168963193893, -0.046562206000089645, -0.02770797722041607, -0.02433086186647415, -0.010117046535015106, 0.042266808450222015, 0.03553968667984009, 0.017853926867246628, -0.016648899763822556, -0.03710782900452614, -0.0305206086486578, 0.010254405438899994, 0.017946379259228706, 0.0039010364562273026, 0.04503249749541283, 0.006533904001116753, 0.0020286748185753822, -0.02704375982284546, 0.05398150905966759, -0.04335381090641022, -0.057091858237981796, -0.036212459206581116, -0.006472502835094929, -0.03166164085268974, 0.011414031498134136, 0.013783616945147514, -0.029238056391477585, 0.027862580493092537, -0.04867534711956978, 0.022016964852809906, 0.0071722944267094135, 0.031198149546980858, -0.012200014665722847, 0.05821359530091286, 0.021178219467401505, 0.02684822306036949, 0.03253605216741562, 0.0150455916300416, 0.11258246004581451, 0.036455411463975906, 0.02320779860019684, -0.048059605062007904, -0.006774073000997305, -0.015584063716232777, -0.0014936289517208934, -0.040304943919181824, 0.038467325270175934, 0.016368575394153595, -0.03706035390496254, 0.03419042378664017, 0.05403837561607361, 0.0016896547749638557, 0.007179045118391514, 0.07703816145658493, -0.012126337736845016, -0.00022075703600421548, 0.019079482182860374, 0.016639498993754387, -0.007980253547430038, -0.05609160289168358, -0.024596981704235077, -0.004901259671896696, -0.013237344101071358, -0.04949701577425003, -0.054053034633398056, -0.011848588474094868, -0.04169614613056183, 0.024257995188236237, 0.008130655623972416, -0.016245119273662567, 0.04723979905247688, 0.008783616125583649, 0.007748065982013941, 0.01626943051815033, 0.02094496414065361, -0.020160283893346786, 0.013929694890975952, 0.005943130236119032, -0.04260982573032379, 0.011028887704014778, 0.012522805482149124, -0.0005358892376534641, -0.030960720032453537, -0.05237850174307823, -0.05194733291864395, 0.043404605239629745, -0.026795629411935806, 0.012820493429899216, -0.04044331610202789, 0.006003308575600386, 0.005728299729526043, -0.03704608231782913, -0.005421718116849661, 0.023333974182605743, 0.042332351207733154, -0.04621981829404831, -0.027990372851490974, -0.008934099227190018, 0.02995542623102665, -0.012720524333417416, 0.03371751680970192, -0.0025522583164274693, -0.030964311212301254, -0.019261816516518593, -0.021658070385456085, 0.03810523450374603, 0.04099877551198006, -0.030575769022107124, -0.01991046778857708, -0.01773187145590782, -0.023211907595396042, -0.005977261811494827, -0.003688378259539604, -0.04801829904317856, 0.04206063970923424, 0.011790302582085133, -0.017156293615698814, -0.009733330458402634, -0.029690692201256752, 0.005699193105101585, -0.020906688645482063, -0.003566365223377943, -0.01469026692211628, 0.00014642170572187752, 0.019073443487286568, 0.03862110897898674, 0.016604838892817497, -0.029615279287099838, -0.003743057604879141, 0.057639848440885544, 0.023228662088513374, -0.02088870480656624, -0.003973306622356176, -0.029969030991196632, -0.026319541037082672, 0.002367257373407483, -0.001346046687103808, 0.03580401837825775, 0.02483275905251503, 0.0027167547959834337, -0.005789431277662516, 0.00550702353939414, -0.02137484960258007, 0.010060536675155163, 0.020327134057879448, -0.0579342395067215, -0.027373583987355232, 0.01708117499947548, -0.007463951129466295, -0.018673785030841827, -0.012932466343045235, -0.039049431681632996, -0.016300741583108902, -0.0014843979151919484, -0.014818434603512287, -0.01945626363158226, -0.03842414915561676, -0.018726516515016556, 0.018744226545095444, 0.0018777743680402637, 0.03500352054834366, -0.03740484267473221, 0.006669060792773962, 0.014932898804545403, 0.0075432551093399525, -0.010097836144268513, -0.009758301079273224, 0.0076815239153802395, -0.027869390323758125, 0.05416037514805794, 0.02240445651113987, 0.01588517241179943, -0.00487591652199626, -0.004010731820017099, -0.013685639947652817, 0.04554593935608864, -0.05951376259326935, -0.03092731162905693, 0.04596259072422981, -0.05470313876867294, 0.002701705088838935, 0.027047883719205856, 0.006349830888211727, 0.03795391693711281, 0.016692765057086945, 0.011514395475387573, -0.06295927613973618, 0.035823144018650055, -0.05488276109099388, -0.0016200552927330136, -0.007602631114423275, 0.025010570883750916, 0.01234541554003954, 0.03768360614776611, 0.021158456802368164, -0.013883802108466625, 0.03044627606868744, 0.0017043011030182242, 0.035323284566402435, 0.002327789319679141, -0.01289544627070427, 0.04154825210571289, 0.03141435608267784, -0.000981058576144278, -0.013059699907898903, -0.005829889327287674, 0.01069974061101675, 0.06454608589410782, -0.05098504200577736, 0.03557711839675903, 0.003158211475238204, 0.024974312633275986, -0.08828126639127731, -0.001464025117456913, 0.0037022170145064592, 0.010127444751560688, 0.0827428549528122, -0.061636872589588165, 0.009916495531797409, 0.0450296550989151, -0.030068673193454742, 0.040323637425899506, -0.026738261803984642, -0.008693128824234009, -0.04093850031495094, 0.01262761652469635, -0.011464002542197704, 0.06980755925178528, 0.027683056890964508, 0.05703394114971161, 0.03209787234663963, 0.04718199744820595, -0.005106794182211161, -0.008240521885454655, -0.014915174804627895, -0.007454910781234503, 0.013444853946566582, -0.05849278345704079, 0.019128920510411263, -0.04656064137816429, -0.04703553766012192, 0.07827160507440567, -0.005413211416453123, 0.010116985999047756, -0.030104124918580055, 0.006474215071648359, -0.027644021436572075, 0.051218461245298386, 0.025677278637886047, -0.03606758639216423, 0.03975662589073181, 0.031496141105890274, 0.010610002093017101, 0.007771266158670187, -0.00405631260946393, 0.00490519218146801, 0.026412343606352806, -0.02382700704038143, -0.03828096762299538, 0.031840018928050995, 0.0003267760912422091, -0.033873170614242554, -0.02523769997060299, 0.0005259852623566985, -0.014127364382147789, -0.018205910921096802, 0.038773998618125916, -0.03444552421569824, -0.021949375048279762, 0.06173829361796379, -0.003894072026014328, -0.04153933748602867, -0.005227048881351948, -0.017000490799546242, -0.04616360738873482, -0.023845434188842773, -0.017798399552702904, -0.032021548599004745, -0.06959009915590286, -0.040598053485155106, -0.00809082668274641, 0.007348069455474615, -0.02355446293950081, -0.011544058099389076, -0.04304132238030434, 0.028940195217728615, -0.0030421135015785694, 0.0341423824429512, -0.01870659366250038, 0.0035715734120458364, -0.005246965680271387, -0.02654636837542057, 0.05162786319851875, 0.012614014558494091, -0.0034109000116586685, -0.030358752235770226, -0.016716621816158295, -0.018112577497959137, -0.025780213996767998, 0.06293579936027527, 0.0028339840937405825, 0.032482828944921494, -0.004237334243953228, 0.06677838414907455, 0.0028492570854723454, -0.015525084920227528, -0.0004739746218547225, -0.060653604567050934, 0.017527427524328232, -0.02333786152303219, -0.014307248406112194, 0.03716491162776947, -0.0012206521350890398, -0.0188585352152586, -0.02055910788476467, -0.023515840992331505, 0.008556216023862362, -0.006065888796001673, 0.07149522751569748, 0.004025864880532026, -0.013922026380896568, 0.032916221767663956, 0.0249186959117651, 0.02935217134654522, 0.013176077976822853, -0.011270671151578426, -0.04504101723432541, 0.015695447102189064, -0.04536059871315956, -0.05660885572433472, -0.0016877235611900687, 0.021969452500343323, -0.02276565693318844, -0.04235377535223961, 0.019352398812770844, 0.009638827294111252, -0.049866918474435806, 0.008297604508697987, 0.03905938193202019, 0.006794895511120558, 0.03634797781705856, -0.010918986983597279, 0.007016949355602264, 0.012398668564856052, 0.016118740662932396, -0.011678685434162617, 0.024739932268857956, 0.02793901227414608, 0.0004710658686235547, 0.01102196890860796, 0.02458244189620018, -0.0044241538271307945, 0.028638141229748726, -0.0029526776634156704, 0.019474871456623077, -0.001867787097580731, -0.006361786276102066, 0.007356895599514246, -0.019387690350413322, -0.017981208860874176, -0.020684385672211647, -0.009184828028082848, 0.048750683665275574, -0.010825944133102894, 0.018042976036667824, -0.055802736431360245, -0.047152142971754074, -0.011964687146246433, -0.02662147395312786, -0.007572977803647518, 0.035553574562072754, -0.01671711914241314, -0.008086376823484898, 0.01780501939356327, -0.042629122734069824, 0.0045392438769340515, -0.04250418767333031, 0.0172821506857872, 0.008121165446937084, 0.019259102642536163, -0.02190602570772171, -0.050890952348709106, -0.0197589211165905, -0.02016676776111126, 0.027510646730661392, 0.03288840875029564, 0.006243004929274321, 0.006576305255293846, -0.03255652263760567, 0.02955213002860546, 0.0666777715086937, -0.051118940114974976, 0.011586419306695461, -0.039585378021001816, 0.0164609607309103, 0.006162256468087435, -0.003700615605339408 ]
<p>I'm looking for insights on how to test the accuracy of a model I built to predict next days stock price - Open, High, Low and Close next day prices.</p> <p>Is there a unique indicator of accuracy or standard approach that should be used to represent the accuracy of this system ? </p> <p>This is a predictive model for prices, not a trading system.</p> <p>Input to the model is the historic time series - end of day stock prices-Open, High, Low, Closing.</p> <p>I've run some initial stats by calculating the ratio of predicted prices to the actual end of day prices i.e if PC represents predicted close price for next day I am simply taking the ratio of PC / C where C is the actual close price for the predicted day and representing it as a %.</p> <p>Have researched some forecasting system models online and understand that the common approach is to use Mean Absolute Percent Error, Mean Absolute Deviation, R-Squared, Correlation, Cumulative Forecast Error. As an example my prediction model is giving me values for Correlation and R-Squared 0.995 0.9924 0.9912 0.9885 &amp; 0.9905 0.983 0.981 0.976 respectively for the O H L C predictions..would these be considered good values ?</p> <p>Any suggestions on what would be the best approach?</p>
74,505
[ 0.004773561842739582, -0.02539915218949318, -0.010968833230435848, 0.009297989308834076, 0.05773217976093292, 0.011604068800807, -0.02129376493394375, -0.05862938240170479, 0.0585036464035511, -0.015239863656461239, 0.031008655205368996, 0.03959603235125542, 0.01126936450600624, 0.032908178865909576, 0.012221780605614185, -0.0035306646022945642, -0.0403297133743763, -0.01726970076560974, 0.00472389766946435, -0.024177294224500656, 0.01884171925485134, 0.015631988644599915, 0.00773496413603425, 0.008310415782034397, -0.02116391249001026, 0.03135233744978905, 0.03286388888955116, 0.0022500737104564905, 0.0384051576256752, 0.02800852432847023, -0.0398571714758873, -0.055268947035074234, 0.018327023833990097, 0.08089056611061096, 0.01744299754500389, 0.02501174993813038, 0.020783232524991035, -0.06464840471744537, -0.035104602575302124, 0.032806601375341415, -0.03973908722400665, -0.010637897066771984, 0.02094779722392559, 0.01543367374688387, 0.015315673314034939, -0.03227060288190842, -0.02408335916697979, -0.04995983466506004, 0.014169014059007168, -0.07118263840675354, 0.0882258340716362, 0.004497024696320295, 0.022689132019877434, 0.021564919501543045, 0.020839285105466843, 0.018993638455867767, 0.046846263110637665, 0.07796917855739594, -0.010960342362523079, -0.04942958801984787, 0.000004854140115639893, 0.00402655778452754, 0.005369020160287619, -0.022157849743962288, -0.0342998281121254, 0.035524699836969376, -0.021244540810585022, -0.0024329388979822397, 0.015513276681303978, -0.026544542983174324, 0.03472166135907173, 0.0199880488216877, 0.03265168517827988, 0.026131438091397285, 0.033333949744701385, -0.029268603771924973, -0.016321010887622833, 0.03144378960132599, 0.03771299496293068, 0.039798419922590256, -0.008304388262331486, 0.009896489791572094, 0.022077705711126328, 0.03500397503376007, 0.054554153233766556, -0.010393749922513962, 0.05167217552661896, -0.029533540830016136, 0.028887279331684113, 0.04274953156709671, -0.01602993533015251, 0.023959478363394737, 0.03279564902186394, -0.02313586324453354, -0.0477694496512413, 0.016136597841978073, 0.008203300647437572, 0.01818358525633812, -0.01535725872963667, -0.03208949416875839, -0.006463386118412018, -0.04554850608110428, -0.018362021073698997, 0.0650986060500145, -0.004963400308042765, -0.044640760868787766, -0.03849799185991287, -0.03295690938830376, 0.005852775648236275, -0.06306873261928558, -0.021651480346918106, 0.02650926634669304, -0.0039008965250104666, -0.017193641513586044, -0.02059592865407467, -0.03230460733175278, -0.0008379879873245955, -0.04176650941371918, 0.044502247124910355, 0.04118675738573074, 0.028291814029216766, 0.012532593682408333, 0.016508866101503372, -0.025350520387291908, -0.02623540349304676, -0.028380857780575752, 0.017961030825972557, -0.03252933546900749, -0.04726727306842804, 0.06300614029169083, -0.005971034988760948, -0.009572669863700867, 0.025803502649068832, -0.010252305306494236, 0.045776478946208954, 0.0022503186482936144, -0.08571452647447586, -0.04257236793637276, 0.053815025836229324, -0.030660124495625496, 0.022164687514305115, -0.03276830166578293, 0.004785022232681513, 0.0417446568608284, 0.025089111179113388, 0.037004318088293076, 0.03134801611304283, -0.0014179758727550507, 0.02132810652256012, 0.01260512974113226, -0.05587902292609215, -0.0010131342569366097, -0.027841318398714066, -0.012080024927854538, -0.03839263319969177, -0.04199478030204773, -0.000189521029824391, 0.03188994154334068, -0.020090321078896523, -0.022517191246151924, 0.0019460158655419946, 0.01491541787981987, -0.022750016301870346, 0.015340239740908146, -0.0005095505039207637, -0.03166165202856064, 0.03223010152578354, 0.0019411882385611534, 0.027245134115219116, 0.001561403158120811, -0.0014782591024413705, -0.01662634313106537, 0.020496660843491554, 0.008546262048184872, 0.042810577899217606, 0.02121760882437229, 0.00998861063271761, -0.03497212380170822, -0.0039687552489340305, 0.009624091908335686, -0.02950693666934967, -0.008119136095046997, -0.030505741015076637, -0.0018262615194544196, 0.005410024896264076, 0.04817498102784157, -0.020663410425186157, -0.03905917704105377, 0.01498810201883316, -0.05645665526390076, -0.030172724276781082, -0.06405723094940186, -0.011019785888493061, -0.037293534725904465, -0.0019971064757555723, 0.02770952135324478, -0.018704738467931747, 0.01643344759941101, -0.008042189292609692, -0.02754252776503563, -0.03824836388230324, 0.01674937829375267, 0.05147508904337883, -0.03615992143750191, 0.0513615719974041, 0.05615050718188286, 0.009786377660930157, -0.030747368931770325, -0.004824772942811251, -0.03726404905319214, -0.07650972157716751, -0.008091024123132229, -0.03435433283448219, -0.0033725169487297535, -0.034335728734731674, -0.014112908393144608, 0.05554831027984619, 0.015066346153616905, 0.01292235217988491, 0.009530655108392239, -0.020092040300369263, 0.052976179867982864, 0.059786196798086166, -0.006804626435041428, 0.020772326737642288, 0.018053166568279266, 0.0012965175556018949, 0.02063177153468132, -0.045593686401844025, -0.011087654158473015, -0.03691403195261955, 0.021237263455986977, 0.01772807165980339, 0.0390658937394619, -0.041512489318847656, 0.023487655445933342, 0.07701629400253296, -0.0032049340661615133, 0.029081206768751144, 0.03861419856548309, -0.016529198735952377, -0.0022509994450956583, -0.015197900123894215, -0.019033774733543396, 0.0185871385037899, -0.011921576224267483, 0.025255240499973297, 0.026569919660687447, 0.027155600488185883, -0.00020828803826589137, 0.005029749590903521, 0.04148929938673973, -0.0073365881107747555, -0.0003962907940149307, -0.0014380187494680285, -0.007327442988753319, 0.02854791097342968, -0.006701588165014982, -0.02010265365242958, 0.029844077304005623, 0.007435217034071684, -0.001830264925956726, 0.0030876107048243284, -0.025113340467214584, 0.00981026142835617, 0.03749585896730423, -0.05163349211215973, 0.00016981392400339246, 0.012949565425515175, -0.04327915981411934, 0.0026043092366307974, -0.01589638739824295, -0.0043886094354093075, -0.02734156884253025, 0.0206584632396698, 0.02933240681886673, 0.004090849310159683, 0.046308260411024094, -0.006259377580136061, -0.02283547818660736, -0.004131040070205927, 0.0030847613234072924, -0.014963976107537746, 0.004207035060971975, -0.06290037930011749, -0.0006631939322687685, -0.006685512140393257, -0.024646708741784096, 0.019286876544356346, -0.00980135053396225, -0.016862504184246063, 0.03981814906001091, 0.006638088263571262, -0.04919208958745003, -0.03911413997411728, -0.03284166753292084, -0.00507346773520112, -0.011660704389214516, -0.03619180992245674, 0.04146765545010567, -0.015192454680800438, -0.025706365704536438, 0.03915809094905853, -0.022533008828759193, 0.006349239498376846, -0.020126046612858772, 0.01221240684390068, -0.003111164551228285, -0.03651953861117363, 0.02650117129087448, 0.021111438050866127, -0.0015991127584129572, -0.01776719279587269, -0.07677264511585236, -0.04941222816705704, -0.009686593897640705, -0.0028780477587133646, 0.025753745809197426, 0.034871917217969894, -0.01841021701693535, 0.07095003873109818, -0.003858181880787015, -0.0312426146119833, -0.04405035078525543, 0.015583597123622894, -0.047024667263031006, -0.03624549135565758, -0.004490516148507595, 0.010843220166862011, 0.006351478863507509, -0.0036134126130491495, -0.010654162615537643, -0.0006588699179701507, 0.05070649832487106, 0.0050967480055987835, 0.026908308267593384, 0.023859726265072823, -0.01948072575032711, 0.014928235672414303, 0.021935900673270226, -0.021102504804730415, -0.0077864076010882854, -0.0027084017638117075, 0.020225202664732933, 0.013901489786803722, 0.014107313938438892, -0.06072229519486427, 0.020008478313684464, -0.00522876251488924, -0.010411721654236317, 0.015473231673240662, 0.01828911155462265, -0.027783093973994255, -0.0465351864695549, -0.023252742365002632, 0.010570062324404716, 0.01056015957146883, 0.0337819866836071, 0.025677353143692017, 0.06161423772573471, 0.009367215447127819, -0.00815643835812807, -0.030208682641386986, 0.0031638811342418194, -0.013718286529183388, 0.01912061683833599, 0.0012612051796168089, 0.007492971606552601, 0.06497253477573395, 0.0342719592154026, 0.04323963075876236, -0.01131720095872879, -0.03141341730952263, 0.0026153260841965675, -0.04710762947797775, 0.0071770683862268925, -0.06420108675956726, 0.06120278313755989, 0.033233895897865295, 0.0664302259683609, 0.03945304453372955, -0.043093904852867126, 0.03843312710523605, 0.016342444345355034, -0.03820997104048729, 0.0550006665289402, 0.021657414734363556, -0.005999207030981779, -0.0315655954182148, -0.023735303431749344, 0.00862379651516676, -0.01482776552438736, 0.010188600979745388, 0.012386207468807697, 0.030570494011044502, -0.03852376341819763, -0.002361863385885954, -0.004497764632105827, 0.013885244727134705, -0.028681322932243347, -0.0055809482000768185, -0.019683750346302986, 0.028684597462415695, 0.05936724692583084, 0.05316333845257759, -0.015744246542453766, -0.022723428905010223, -0.014851413667201996, 0.01894565112888813, 0.02437046356499195, 0.03130507469177246, 0.055065691471099854, 0.00470330473035574, -0.052000779658555984, 0.025900689885020256, 0.024910371750593185, 0.035471200942993164, 0.06499197334051132, 0.002741452306509018, -0.01905405893921852, -0.01936184987425804, -0.008401857689023018, 0.04002881795167923, -0.008174555376172066, -0.004108513239771128, -0.005774635821580887, 0.06005897372961044, -0.01047836896032095, -0.022357547655701637, 0.013977935537695885, 0.08057399839162827, 0.028462884947657585, 0.0013306370237842202, -0.022855283692479134, 0.0019684922881424427, 0.0023652962408959866, -0.0076113417744636536, 0.009750966913998127, -0.023298073559999466, 0.006185274571180344, -0.030554845929145813, 0.01500761229544878, -0.017240947112441063, -0.026335151866078377, 0.013262015767395496, 0.0340275913476944, 0.047700654715299606, 0.023274093866348267, -0.020293917506933212, 0.011362585239112377, 0.053758494555950165, 0.058379583060741425, -0.0008244951022788882, 0.009632875211536884, -0.10300774872303009, 0.00942922756075859, 0.03718941658735275, 0.04607267677783966, 0.005881096702069044, -0.027219997718930244, -0.03442131727933884, -0.0048749432899057865, 0.012912567704916, -0.041572026908397675, 0.028954502195119858, 0.013560141436755657, 0.014548738487064838, -0.021368293091654778, -0.019975852221250534, -0.04760874807834625, 0.013879403471946716, -0.041035208851099014, 0.049711357802152634, -0.02612016722559929, -0.003630624618381262, -0.05996853858232498, -0.010216407477855682, 0.02373831905424595, 0.04000795632600784, -0.016730282455682755, -0.02704370766878128, -0.007126123644411564, 0.009264826774597168, -0.009796369820833206, -0.07534275203943253, -0.005242055281996727, 0.00008248518133768812, -0.019811144098639488, 0.04506923258304596, 0.003941081929951906, -0.043967146426439285, 0.006260099355131388, 0.023684745654463768, -0.006355102173984051, -0.014772058464586735, -0.05106841400265694, 0.01847182773053646, -0.002530573168769479, -0.004383989609777927, 0.05998812988400459, 0.021685782819986343, -0.0017274259589612484, 0.003343168180435896, -0.0019331695511937141, 0.012349970638751984, 0.020610084757208824, -0.01671895757317543, -0.027642976492643356, -0.020262548699975014, -0.03217516094446182, 0.0005837769713252783, -0.02906838059425354, 0.044248081743717194, -0.047052592039108276, 0.01083631906658411, -0.013590965420007706, 0.04016561061143875, -0.006225909106433392, -0.012621967121958733, -0.028685420751571655, 0.00015626686217729002, -0.05225476622581482, 0.009586062282323837, -0.007843391969799995, -0.013656550087034702, 0.01490395050495863, 0.026955576613545418, -0.03048250451683998, -0.025904258713126183, -0.009641749784350395, 0.011374346911907196, 0.006877654232084751, 0.0071659209206700325, 0.03968155384063721, 0.0005953207146376371, 0.01803896389901638, 0.0070143211632966995, -0.027944685891270638, -0.023074571043252945, 0.03573060408234596, 0.024371018633246422, 0.04232798144221306, -0.002177309710532427, 0.026229538023471832, -0.014833975583314896, -0.024908000603318214, -0.06637059152126312, -0.03680755943059921, 0.03188341483473778, 0.013066730462014675, -0.06931309401988983, -0.027814680710434914, 0.011239832267165184, -0.050155237317085266, -0.004858499858528376, -0.041229233145713806, 0.009851195849478245, -0.011182717978954315, -0.024708375334739685, 0.012617506086826324, -0.013451526872813702, 0.061894237995147705, -0.0036794422194361687, -0.006745674181729555, 0.02215353213250637, 0.012654143385589123, -0.019854294136166573, 0.02283698506653309, 0.0247275959700346, -0.04876326397061348, -0.010652617551386356, -0.03453613072633743, -0.003539958968758583, 0.07288351655006409, -0.017166199162602425, -0.005746725481003523, 0.022964460775256157, 0.023305099457502365, 0.007511966396123171, -0.0166312288492918, 0.019008509814739227, -0.008534087799489498, -0.020830392837524414, -0.006685045547783375, -0.0015825110021978617, -0.00992918573319912, -0.01050206832587719, -0.003595254849642515, -0.002986928215250373, -0.015174982137978077, 0.014012188650667667, 0.07528434693813324, -0.003729415126144886, 0.008146236650645733, -0.028391677886247635, -0.03253646194934845, 0.04417652264237404, 0.011203126050531864, 0.025244466960430145, 0.028478531166911125, 0.021214500069618225, -0.028200022876262665, -0.043532706797122955, -0.02261832356452942, -0.027163613587617874, 0.07546571642160416, 0.005375604145228863, 0.05233122035861015, -0.0005688133533112705, 0.05605039373040199, -0.01702074147760868, -0.03297210484743118, -0.0045098429545760155, -0.0009414080996066332, 0.013439926318824291, 0.03589695319533348, 0.020597558468580246, -0.01719471998512745, 0.0009585845982655883, -0.0014126038877293468, 0.04026514291763306, 0.03949931636452675, 0.05577518045902252, 0.011683940887451172, -0.007825625129044056, 0.004479951225221157, -0.031240595504641533, 0.022985277697443962, -0.041577573865652084, 0.01618281751871109, -0.05690735951066017, -0.009067774750292301, 0.03873926028609276, 0.020667746663093567, -0.018821127712726593, -0.035755567252635956, -0.022228330373764038, -0.03476333245635033, -0.001000304240733385, 0.006899957545101643, -0.03643431141972542, 0.017213258892297745, 0.025483721867203712, 0.03993809595704079, 0.003647010074928403, 0.055780574679374695, -0.007001379504799843, -0.08066093921661377, -0.015271840617060661, -0.011947965249419212, -0.03116608038544655, 0.04602835327386856, 0.011522233486175537, -0.010293913073837757, 0.020126771181821823, -0.004865966271609068, -0.0008762501529417932, -0.023486461490392685, -0.0019901820924133062, -0.02107817493379116, 0.09913070499897003, 0.006884720642119646, -0.007495821453630924, 0.02265108749270439, -0.01568985916674137, 0.12384907901287079, 0.101964570581913, 0.007995693013072014, -0.047160711139440536, 0.027012644335627556, 0.0038389021065086126, 0.0070873890072107315, -0.035323336720466614, 0.023751849308609962, 0.004623159766197205, 0.01973998360335827, 0.061118509620428085, 0.0635952278971672, -0.02555358223617077, -0.030685460194945335, 0.03578738868236542, -0.03521081432700157, -0.025679444894194603, 0.038019388914108276, 0.02286013774573803, 0.014773108065128326, -0.019723709672689438, -0.024526512250304222, 0.039859969168901443, -0.057633545249700546, -0.008156849071383476, -0.01466440036892891, -0.01429061684757471, 0.015044649131596088, -0.000035266766644781455, -0.031118258833885193, -0.008868247270584106, 0.018429240211844444, 0.03587385639548302, -0.012034023180603981, -0.014933592639863491, 0.019769420847296715, -0.025172851979732513, 0.0009560636826790869, 0.008681445382535458, 0.006893839221447706, -0.020661486312747, 0.0404030866920948, 0.021993042901158333, -0.06522327661514282, -0.020825132727622986, -0.0519387386739254, 0.01773444376885891, 0.0007144961855374277, -0.01815635897219181, -0.01881580241024494, 0.008883587084710598, -0.025842297822237015, -0.029344825074076653, -0.012232480570673943, 0.05484236776828766, 0.03160808980464935, -0.049453504383563995, -0.020547758787870407, -0.07203425467014313, 0.02045859396457672, -0.010762468911707401, 0.0352146290242672, 0.00604260666295886, -0.04121231287717819, -0.031903162598609924, -0.04103589430451393, 0.08038914948701859, -0.006283125374466181, 0.022042645141482353, 0.02036946453154087, -0.0018702716333791614, -0.044293519109487534, -0.005194772966206074, 0.003557363525032997, -0.02316184528172016, 0.004886819049715996, 0.008434425108134747, 0.0009650319698266685, -0.013192696496844292, -0.0778101235628128, 0.016155289486050606, 0.016811558976769447, 0.004896126221865416, -0.08995531499385834, -0.006045619957149029, 0.02945031225681305, 0.03824366629123688, 0.029516296461224556, 0.020392829552292824, -0.060921501368284225, 0.036477167159318924, 0.024044275283813477, -0.03209170699119568, 0.007028957828879356, 0.008257401175796986, -0.058201391249895096, 0.00983505044132471, 0.0008961085695773363, 0.05593397840857506, 0.018249159678816795, -0.006638281047344208, -0.022882657125592232, 0.012148639187216759, 0.003178701503202319, 0.01979748159646988, -0.012269868515431881, -0.04741523042321205, 0.0005889827152714133, 0.007285142783075571, 0.014767776243388653, -0.030353404581546783, -0.011030439287424088, -0.023079996928572655, -0.026966726407408714, 0.012576689943671227, -0.006447464693337679, -0.029836416244506836, 0.013646649196743965, -0.00633897352963686, 0.026803113520145416, -0.004217077512294054, -0.0127522898837924, -0.017847657203674316, 0.013603116385638714, -0.028672916814684868, -0.055304016917943954, -0.007892653346061707, 0.01332137268036604, 0.013822424225509167, -0.019773121923208237, 0.06642230600118637, 0.016384026035666466, -0.0027539925649762154, -0.02983945794403553, -0.004905969835817814, -0.009135360829532146, 0.03679998591542244, -0.03823649510741234, -0.05503299832344055, 0.0380084328353405, -0.019464144483208656, -0.06217936426401138, 0.009700406342744827, 0.03314701467752457, 0.06223410367965698, 0.008604513481259346, 0.008169705979526043, -0.0010139573132619262, 0.029874581843614578, -0.016464507207274437, -0.011662307195365429, 0.003855458926409483, 0.027592888101935387, 0.02025432139635086, 0.010687929578125477, 0.03485223278403282, 0.013148453086614609, -0.010644257068634033, 0.02369759976863861, 0.034761738032102585, 0.02240871451795101, 0.029964763671159744, 0.0073910546489059925, -0.016219237819314003, -0.01453555840998888, 0.03264223411679268, -0.021180860698223114, 0.056931301951408386, -0.005059461575001478, -0.022711876779794693, 0.027224665507674217, -0.030680013820528984, 0.022601468488574028, -0.07570892572402954, -0.01603173278272152, 0.04214208573102951, 0.0017680482706055045, 0.04426475986838341, -0.024737371131777763, -0.007201795000582933, 0.03400731086730957, -0.028775164857506752, -0.0035277982242405415, -0.0007656022207811475, -0.001821183250285685, 0.002037598052993417, -0.016811523586511612, -0.025716548785567284, 0.0315571166574955, 0.01276717334985733, -0.012626053765416145, 0.023030975833535194, -0.008507478050887585, 0.009271235205233097, -0.019669244065880775, 0.0015264787944033742, 0.05667916685342789, 0.014592873863875866, -0.042750634253025055, 0.019861575216054916, -0.02836143597960472, -0.02495279349386692, 0.04668272286653519, -0.0051163919270038605, 0.028462443500757217, 0.022665493190288544, 0.010005430318415165, 0.008890539407730103, 0.028867676854133606, 0.03502015769481659, 0.0023701414465904236, -0.03463968634605408, -0.002768978476524353, 0.02003234438598156, 0.0348031260073185, -0.004241454415023327, 0.02579578571021557, 0.0432451069355011, -0.028911227360367775, -0.055352501571178436, 0.015047076158225536, -0.021644309163093567, 0.0058486685156822205, -0.0074473158456385136, 0.01739821955561638, 0.003465376328676939, -0.048693668097257614, 0.022724544629454613, -0.001268142368644476, -0.024510134011507034, 0.055340416729450226, 0.04890713468194008, -0.04169798269867897, 0.004668691661208868, -0.027681700885295868, -0.04656589403748512, 0.03902638703584671, -0.005026529543101788, 0.006707790307700634, -0.049067623913288116, -0.006100093945860863, 0.013875595293939114, -0.01916293054819107, -0.03187365084886551, -0.009420008398592472, -0.007387401536107063, 0.055963121354579926, -0.04197953641414642, 0.028489068150520325, 0.05056685954332352, -0.004034525249153376, -0.00909910537302494, -0.0966021791100502, 0.09335481375455856, -0.0036623957566916943, -0.04599522426724434, -0.020506147295236588, -0.022471128031611443, -0.024584610015153885, -0.030909501016139984, 0.059898532927036285, 0.005909066181629896, -0.006903317756950855, -0.0032006683759391308, 0.02941500023007393, -0.03366071358323097, -0.0894099697470665, 0.029927490279078484, -0.03021218813955784, -0.020884249359369278, -0.03813135623931885, -0.0264892540872097, 0.0014022744726389647, 0.006005176343023777, 0.01011201087385416, -0.03484279289841652, 0.01833459921181202, 0.008377136662602425, -0.018302548676729202, 0.025213414803147316, 0.007451601326465607, -0.023355402052402496, 0.07388900965452194, 0.029874930158257484, -0.0014410808216780424, 0.0608057864010334, -0.02770240791141987, -0.04672840237617493, 0.04694806784391403, -0.01988179050385952, 0.00008527272439096123, -0.011769548989832401, 0.017338190227746964, -0.0010690096532925963, -0.04232930392026901, -0.028141112998127937, 0.05870296433568001, -0.05064575374126434, 0.03441043198108673, 0.036738321185112, -0.008259017951786518, 0.025349600240588188, -0.021222833544015884, 0.03562436252832413, 0.027190469205379486, -0.014238858595490456, -0.020453479140996933, -0.03921246528625488, 0.06814452260732651, 0.001571090193465352, 0.03893258795142174, 0.03219127282500267, -0.02790297009050846, 0.015720698982477188, -0.03484411910176277, 0.021622173488140106, -0.054657693952322006, -0.006532533094286919, 0.04286139830946922, -0.012439657002687454, 0.031070364639163017, 0.0017617348348721862, -0.030822258442640305, 0.06125686317682266, -0.046222276985645294, 0.010913677513599396, -0.03514653071761131, -0.034706961363554, -0.009306847117841244, 0.01864210143685341, 0.0078109861351549625, 0.034859541803598404, 0.014648674987256527, 0.03017776645720005, 0.03793540224432945, 0.023531729355454445, 0.033646877855062485, -0.025045298039913177, 0.0059058405458927155, -0.010762319900095463, 0.017518870532512665, -0.025961685925722122, -0.03783653303980827, -0.029848873615264893, -0.02207496017217636, 0.02983120083808899, 0.02013440988957882, 0.024101560935378075, 0.011842716485261917, -0.05056353658437729, 0.020223626866936684, 0.05965552106499672, -0.08012820780277252, 0.014815004542469978, -0.03292180225253105, 0.0045030806213617325, -0.01887786015868187, -0.03656107559800148 ]
<p>We have the following solar meteorology parameters through satellite data with resolution of 100 km$^2$ (10 km x 10 km). </p> <p>Insolation on horizontal surface </p> <p>Diffuse radiation on horizontal surface </p> <p>Direct normal radiation </p> <p>Like this we can have about 4-5 more parameters which are associated with Solar Power generation. These same parameters are also measured at 23 ground stations.</p> <p>We also have same parameter data which are taken at ground station at respective long-latitude locations. Our objective will be to estimate all those solar parameters for every 1 km x 1 km area. By interpolating satellite data and ground station data in given vicinity area with best possible accuracy. My question is Which is best interpolation technique we can use: please provide some references and the software which can be used.</p>
74,506
[ -0.02974550426006317, -0.011547645553946495, -0.015203745104372501, 0.030475130304694176, 0.04328233376145363, 0.013217351399362087, -0.02417508140206337, -0.06816911697387695, 0.02555975876748562, -0.06278182566165924, 0.05369781702756882, 0.034034863114356995, 0.02441268227994442, 0.04535339027643204, 0.02493823505938053, -0.022435903549194336, -0.04673923924565315, 0.04413936287164688, -0.0025246774312108755, 0.004628944676369429, 0.00035849199048243463, 0.004981890320777893, -0.003502778708934784, -0.004357089288532734, -0.020198088139295578, -0.016354043036699295, -0.0019243714632466435, 0.00992836058139801, -0.011300471611320972, 0.09599241614341736, -0.010327511467039585, -0.04061958193778992, -0.011686999350786209, 0.05413677170872688, -0.015875373035669327, -0.0008801190415397286, -0.0202855933457613, -0.03639250621199608, -0.009237661957740784, 0.024017779156565666, -0.04659980535507202, -0.04429955780506134, -0.026468869298696518, 0.006088126450777054, 0.015961742028594017, -0.0002867327129933983, 0.002429553307592869, -0.05334120988845825, 0.011069797910749912, -0.07525748014450073, 0.06743652373552322, 0.004047704394906759, 0.05042476952075958, 0.01724136248230934, -0.025372784584760666, -0.007413003593683243, 0.06115107983350754, 0.06636695563793182, 0.011884523555636406, -0.02627634070813656, -0.017070868983864784, -0.011080906726419926, 0.008387950249016285, -0.02350449748337269, -0.05182847008109093, 0.037811193615198135, -0.0013356651179492474, -0.01205653790384531, -0.004176945425570011, 0.017316659912467003, 0.02471010573208332, -0.014903491362929344, 0.03203017637133598, -0.002953560324385762, 0.001803730963729322, -0.02704448625445366, -0.0038074578624218702, 0.026846693828701973, 0.043004609644412994, 0.0019752539228647947, 0.004201475065201521, 0.05940896272659302, 0.00910528190433979, 0.021321501582860947, 0.02688714675605297, 0.03923102095723152, 0.06571149080991745, -0.008717233315110207, 0.02936204895377159, 0.013317893259227276, -0.016167279332876205, 0.02470575086772442, 0.04576811566948891, -0.002452688291668892, -0.015441445633769035, 0.03075813315808773, -0.003445462789386511, 0.033996593207120895, -0.003892218694090843, -0.036033548414707184, 0.03381533548235893, -0.019045060500502586, 0.0018428739858791232, 0.04647408798336983, 0.01390004064887762, -0.03025689348578453, -0.0114741837605834, -0.0247899629175663, -0.018857909366488457, -0.01645888015627861, 0.01890520378947258, 0.013773668557405472, -0.004865860100835562, 0.0005416512722149491, 0.029850443825125694, -0.007184063550084829, 0.02134176902472973, -0.00995655544102192, 0.019650747999548912, 0.08158273249864578, 0.035090371966362, -0.0008447402506135404, 0.04285663738846779, -0.0211150161921978, -0.036860402673482895, 0.03091714158654213, -0.006452667526900768, -0.004770265892148018, -0.05004351958632469, -0.00224861572496593, 0.029539328068494797, -0.016799170523881912, 0.015685316175222397, -0.02664817124605179, 0.03960340842604637, 0.011284133419394493, -0.07331394404172897, -0.03493490815162659, 0.01923001930117607, -0.016937021166086197, 0.04851507022976875, -0.055042166262865067, 0.024340426549315453, 0.02512708120048046, 0.06154476851224899, 0.018260566517710686, 0.0410948246717453, 0.00525724096223712, 0.05351589247584343, -0.0196674857288599, -0.04263308271765709, -0.014696149155497551, 0.018815217539668083, -0.03944819048047066, -0.022818170487880707, -0.07888098061084747, 0.025277305394411087, 0.044009577482938766, -0.0020400143694132566, 0.0043232617899775505, 0.07147563248872757, 0.025386624038219452, -0.01369994692504406, 0.01865524798631668, 0.05301213264465332, -0.028947530314326286, 0.05756863206624985, 0.015218043699860573, 0.03092925064265728, 0.020567074418067932, 0.012888645753264427, 0.029809974133968353, 0.037139564752578735, 0.011156944558024406, 0.061464276164770126, -0.014556889422237873, 0.019707540050148964, -0.025807326659560204, 0.02604544907808304, 0.022241588681936264, -0.05147272348403931, -0.017123468220233917, 0.0314570814371109, 0.004522618371993303, 0.044956278055906296, 0.0712522640824318, -0.030343996360898018, -0.043525055050849915, 0.037062548100948334, -0.07849609851837158, 0.009308473207056522, -0.015749214217066765, -0.006669309921562672, 0.009112544357776642, -0.009486779570579529, 0.0403711274266243, -0.027144672349095345, -0.0037219207733869553, 0.014583521522581577, -0.018861182034015656, -0.013996479101479053, 0.026164092123508453, 0.07923902571201324, 0.003808876732364297, 0.01846293918788433, 0.0666416808962822, 0.020506102591753006, -0.022624371573328972, 0.009227685630321503, -0.003557787276804447, -0.04450684040784836, -0.007984913885593414, -0.06690382212400436, 0.01864335685968399, 0.006675257813185453, -0.032942984253168106, 0.024438537657260895, 0.017888164147734642, -0.02123880386352539, 0.013738323003053665, -0.04222015291452408, 0.054407715797424316, 0.04982983320951462, 0.00041329144733026624, 0.0442829504609108, 0.01702658087015152, 0.024377794936299324, 0.03324930742383003, -0.021500490605831146, -0.04421355947852135, -0.06701762974262238, 0.029880091547966003, 0.040401749312877655, -0.004698147065937519, -0.06321772187948227, 0.007840050384402275, 0.056954532861709595, 0.0033327098935842514, 0.06476449221372604, 0.013504776172339916, -0.006936424411833286, 0.02051577903330326, 0.01158288586884737, 0.017766032367944717, 0.0032757180742919445, 0.014392578974366188, -0.028641751036047935, 0.03346705064177513, 0.006145179271697998, -0.01802307739853859, 0.007180302403867245, 0.07749581336975098, -0.02422492392361164, 0.011169224977493286, -0.004810062237083912, 0.004589676391333342, 0.05101505666971207, -0.06079550459980965, -0.018201353028416634, 0.011943412944674492, -0.010471638292074203, 0.010326874442398548, 0.008141756989061832, -0.005633774679154158, 0.016215020790696144, -0.0006663992535322905, -0.018127169460058212, 0.014031334780156612, 0.02520070970058441, -0.058455873280763626, 0.022154876962304115, -0.026740258559584618, 0.0037079663015902042, -0.04839790239930153, -0.010132773779332638, 0.07474260032176971, 0.002047700574621558, -0.006916511803865433, -0.013084071688354015, -0.02692388743162155, -0.02074059471487999, -0.02270999737083912, 0.0052541643381118774, 0.02511429786682129, -0.046501561999320984, -0.026204921305179596, -0.021563688293099403, -0.014430602081120014, 0.04825364425778389, -0.02082064561545849, 0.019492408260703087, 0.01065276749432087, 0.015760846436023712, -0.05069712549448013, -0.01743173599243164, -0.026105906814336777, 0.012180956080555916, -0.0004476922913454473, -0.049756549298763275, 0.06104983389377594, 0.0054010325111448765, -0.030200909823179245, 0.029715344309806824, -0.08132246881723404, -0.0425918810069561, -0.008088489063084126, 0.0279785618185997, 0.014550430700182915, -0.03493819758296013, 0.012327783741056919, 0.04315922409296036, -0.03529306501150131, 0.014986206777393818, -0.07139339298009872, -0.049726322293281555, 0.015484522096812725, -0.004346161149442196, 0.04176310449838638, -0.023400742560625076, -0.047311726957559586, 0.05602840334177017, 0.03886173665523529, -0.014655039645731449, -0.03265230730175972, 0.005801834631711245, -0.03805078566074371, -0.010753493756055832, -0.00559281837195158, -0.007599722594022751, 0.013630234636366367, 0.019501246511936188, -0.0010069544659927487, -0.007117765489965677, 0.056943174451589584, -0.011815589852631092, -0.01339761447161436, -0.0032981839030981064, -0.016401449218392372, 0.025465024635195732, 0.08266851305961609, 0.005400429014116526, -0.032803673297166824, -0.012875542975962162, -0.023860672488808632, 0.005163791123777628, -0.012730319052934647, -0.025496266782283783, -0.0025315035600215197, -0.021188795566558838, -0.01689411699771881, -0.0389244481921196, 0.021045006811618805, 0.05825146287679672, -0.011048720218241215, -0.009325585328042507, 0.03483420982956886, 0.045917659997940063, -0.016245409846305847, -0.017490098252892494, 0.04756442829966545, 0.06257697194814682, -0.009667951613664627, -0.039935171604156494, -0.007451148703694344, -0.007779239676892757, -0.0048345765098929405, 0.0024142127949744463, -0.010563749819993973, 0.043136414140462875, 0.05056095868349075, 0.015691252425312996, -0.0033844741992652416, -0.011897941119968891, -0.0065013146959245205, -0.07987883687019348, -0.0271149929612875, -0.04375104233622551, 0.0775727778673172, 0.0012648965930566192, 0.028114398941397667, 0.04738784581422806, -0.007566565647721291, 0.04468928277492523, 0.017498387023806572, -0.07488595694303513, 0.03176078200340271, -0.006434396840631962, -0.014122075401246548, 0.0023455412592738867, -0.008021046407520771, -0.014253607019782066, -0.022500596940517426, 0.014386028982698917, -0.017852209508419037, 0.029040846973657608, -0.0507112480700016, -0.007586382795125246, -0.036336854100227356, -0.02766820602118969, -0.06325799971818924, 0.04409632831811905, 0.02995668351650238, -0.06242747604846954, 0.019908612594008446, 0.03364760801196098, -0.0015936363488435745, -0.04340441897511482, -0.02814187854528427, 0.01466235052794218, -0.026433374732732773, 0.0385369136929512, 0.024114862084388733, 0.030599121004343033, -0.03261880204081535, -0.014503766782581806, 0.014053658582270145, 0.026179740205407143, 0.033420074731111526, -0.01660315692424774, -0.028549322858452797, -0.04119875282049179, 0.000045392207539407536, 0.009551101364195347, 0.005522459279745817, -0.03146669641137123, -0.016749601811170578, 0.04620704427361488, 0.007282293401658535, -0.02350286953151226, 0.0479607991874218, 0.04434504732489586, -0.0002629341324791312, -0.0009420753922313452, -0.02936212718486786, -0.03693946450948715, 0.002386667300015688, -0.032598841935396194, 0.045654285699129105, -0.008959989063441753, -0.016635658219456673, -0.02627667970955372, 0.03734836354851723, -0.005116969812661409, -0.019507378339767456, 0.027800997719168663, 0.05250046029686928, 0.0414109081029892, 0.0160820335149765, -0.035561613738536835, -0.004936483222991228, 0.03859347105026245, 0.019291063770651817, 0.0037700084503740072, 0.011225164867937565, -0.08985412120819092, 0.01691792719066143, 0.027587151154875755, 0.024756327271461487, -0.02495810016989708, -0.009339629672467709, -0.05789443105459213, -0.0044919648207724094, 0.007639172486960888, -0.013075240887701511, 0.03206930682063103, -0.013135256245732307, -0.0007295034592971206, -0.03271157667040825, 0.0008841377566568553, -0.01725449413061142, -0.0015184354269877076, -0.000639597768895328, 0.03662511706352234, -0.03952760249376297, 0.01221206784248352, -0.008009414188563824, 0.05965792387723923, 0.010599100962281227, 0.06182530149817467, 0.016489753499627113, -0.011464016512036324, 0.005026157479733229, 0.017406640574336052, 0.003628722159191966, -0.05714023858308792, -0.019409187138080597, 0.03204701095819473, -0.02906818874180317, 0.04680104926228523, -0.004072815179824829, -0.04551402106881142, 0.03790903836488724, 0.007144168950617313, -0.025313135236501694, -0.03920399397611618, -0.036549877375364304, 0.022296927869319916, 0.032416924834251404, 0.0025986097753047943, 0.07277272641658783, 0.03434313088655472, -0.029479827731847763, -0.013168536126613617, -0.017406262457370758, 0.016574889421463013, -0.008246920071542263, -0.04698359593749046, -0.018144730478525162, 0.0013438872992992401, -0.01595931127667427, 0.004080709535628557, 0.0010300985304638743, 0.050176288932561874, -0.03946894779801369, -0.013008322566747665, -0.005934232380241156, 0.04537869617342949, 0.0019013987621292472, 0.00347749306820333, 0.0007656876696273685, 0.043237362056970596, 0.003119058208540082, -0.02781931683421135, -0.012286876328289509, -0.01258845068514347, 0.0193338543176651, -0.008341554552316666, -0.022670060396194458, 0.007823432795703411, -0.04982941225171089, -0.014657516963779926, 0.022193005308508873, -0.014311997219920158, 0.03396355360746384, -0.009447064250707626, 0.05533455312252045, 0.05214601010084152, -0.10358166694641113, -0.029099252074956894, 0.019707271829247475, 0.005990405101329088, 0.05019698292016983, -0.028506102040410042, -0.005464636720716953, -0.014165426604449749, -0.025892185047268867, -0.08086521923542023, -0.04187597706913948, 0.04645303264260292, 0.009890668094158173, -0.03695744648575783, -0.011645290069282055, -0.01429757196456194, -0.028237424790859222, -0.004736817441880703, -0.016131402924656868, 0.03042740747332573, -0.013133448548614979, -0.016831068322062492, 0.0028083492070436478, 0.026081141084432602, 0.06879940629005432, -0.057040877640247345, 0.018940653651952744, 0.011552544310688972, -0.008536836132407188, -0.027339065447449684, 0.0003961017064284533, 0.011351128108799458, -0.032743386924266815, -0.01486534345895052, -0.03594314679503441, 0.0062983292154967785, 0.03005400486290455, -0.0008532353094778955, -0.010262316092848778, 0.07387544959783554, 0.05831480398774147, -0.02903461456298828, -0.002421468961983919, 0.01358697097748518, -0.029862482100725174, -0.0021070092916488647, -0.012575282715260983, -0.0084510687738657, -0.020790250971913338, 0.004154680762439966, -0.005476201884448528, -0.009129234589636326, -0.004681760910898447, -0.0038888612762093544, 0.046241145581007004, -0.012479694560170174, 0.0029165134765207767, 0.037222664803266525, 0.0068984972313046455, 0.021450817584991455, 0.004676245618611574, 0.04203137755393982, 0.005592771805822849, 0.03292584419250488, -0.021384019404649734, -0.03308820351958275, -0.021079210564494133, -0.003169545205309987, 0.07575344294309616, -0.023938817903399467, 0.05488991364836693, 0.04030190780758858, 0.0353655070066452, 0.02088688500225544, -0.03890111669898033, -0.011329051107168198, -0.01304690632969141, -0.0018205840606242418, 0.0544898584485054, -0.010194503702223301, -0.021300487220287323, -0.0050611491315066814, 0.0007140700472518802, 0.011272541247308254, 0.023524919524788857, 0.0032345172949135303, 0.02435590699315071, -0.002250306773930788, -0.045379217714071274, -0.04049260914325714, 0.006050508003681898, -0.03639668598771095, 0.024116748943924904, 0.02101694792509079, -0.01785147748887539, 0.033959899097681046, 0.01696017012000084, 0.00554130831733346, -0.03798876702785492, -0.003195184050127864, -0.06610409915447235, 0.0008046175935305655, 0.030251888558268547, 0.018392913043498993, -0.003516559721902013, 0.047832660377025604, 0.03431136906147003, 0.00779960909858346, 0.023862764239311218, -0.008054750971496105, -0.07156986743211746, -0.027447910979390144, -0.0067029837518930435, -0.06254420429468155, 0.07684590667486191, -0.0031244915444403887, -0.04299255833029747, 0.0018425401067361236, 0.002484107855707407, 0.029987316578626633, 0.016082538291811943, 0.029742905870079994, -0.009100532159209251, 0.0661274790763855, -0.012625915929675102, 0.011570271104574203, -0.00042909878538921475, 0.02680163085460663, 0.08556850254535675, 0.08875720202922821, 0.00617231335490942, -0.05209699273109436, 0.022870216518640518, 0.003251094603911042, -0.00798560120165348, -0.0394294336438179, 0.042732108384370804, 0.02226918376982212, -0.0015089919324964285, 0.01759512908756733, -0.021258139982819557, -0.033814478665590286, 0.013663227669894695, 0.04374883696436882, -0.013564501889050007, -0.0255439355969429, 0.04668665677309036, 0.01700662076473236, 0.003339561400935054, 0.02957783080637455, -0.03237270563840866, -0.0036005035508424044, -0.013057093136012554, -0.007801234722137451, -0.03314156457781792, -0.035671837627887726, 0.027463527396321297, 0.0018981739412993193, -0.07445000857114792, 0.004738264251500368, 0.0030516923870891333, 0.008376478217542171, -0.03576763719320297, -0.01546658668667078, -0.0018933139508590102, -0.018992934376001358, -0.0005524774314835668, 0.02633732743561268, 0.016366682946681976, -0.008768729865550995, 0.021157115697860718, 0.0210796520113945, -0.021632401272654533, 0.007183888927102089, -0.03265766054391861, 0.017909293994307518, -0.010530105791985989, 0.006446638610213995, -0.00412325095385313, 0.028268294408917427, -0.020704004913568497, -0.04431702569127083, 0.005192772950977087, 0.004210051614791155, 0.02378273941576481, -0.06957009434700012, -0.015888312831521034, -0.0354907400906086, 0.024276383221149445, -0.01693234033882618, 0.019870080053806305, 0.0005510679329745471, -0.014557369984686375, 0.0052907331846654415, -0.003286364022642374, 0.07029566913843155, 0.007694908417761326, -0.010259997099637985, -0.002940670819953084, -0.04302274435758591, -0.005625016521662474, -0.03297192230820656, 0.046559955924749374, 0.011769683100283146, 0.04546404629945755, 0.025508955121040344, 0.009385948069393635, -0.014991126954555511, -0.020731691271066666, 0.0024900799617171288, -0.0011943753343075514, 0.02599751576781273, -0.0392674058675766, 0.006444291211664677, 0.04894696921110153, 0.007821164093911648, 0.02992190606892109, -0.009951944462954998, -0.018728185445070267, 0.012072867713868618, 0.00812109000980854, -0.06251474469900131, -0.018759943544864655, -0.013180689886212349, -0.009886184707283974, 0.010824736207723618, -0.03585975244641304, 0.03537621721625328, 0.013086286373436451, 0.017408199608325958, -0.03710755333304405, 0.059524036943912506, -0.0074135554023087025, 0.010958230122923851, -0.00897805392742157, -0.016984622925519943, 0.03232589736580849, -0.0323021225631237, -0.021336883306503296, -0.00042529968777671456, 0.0424567312002182, 0.022494439035654068, 0.0001481066719861701, 0.015379276126623154, -0.005205102730542421, -0.05775834992527962, 0.03787326067686081, -0.013475107029080391, 0.019194329157471657, -0.012119575403630733, 0.007597493007779121, -0.04868137836456299, 0.015374168753623962, -0.026964372023940086, -0.008437853306531906, -0.025562524795532227, -0.006775566842406988, -0.040134940296411514, -0.04046431556344032, 0.0576198473572731, 0.007794595323503017, 0.037693168967962265, -0.019050907343626022, 0.01556374691426754, -0.024067988619208336, 0.09211451560258865, -0.03876675292849541, -0.025518206879496574, 0.02259395271539688, -0.034752339124679565, -0.05813738331198692, 0.021601559594273567, -0.006700357422232628, 0.02254096418619156, 0.03946326673030853, -0.057313527911901474, -0.03774654492735863, 0.0748615488409996, -0.022076178342103958, 0.011804746463894844, -0.02779863215982914, 0.025099456310272217, 0.019767483696341515, 0.009385691024363041, 0.01813422702252865, -0.027807269245386124, 0.0020995845552533865, 0.009619436226785183, 0.01967676728963852, 0.005204773508012295, -0.002873759949579835, 0.014527535066008568, -0.004727567546069622, -0.021894564852118492, 0.01157098077237606, -0.03875346481800079, 0.02523217722773552, 0.018653448671102524, -0.040215395390987396, 0.01656033843755722, -0.002560664899647236, 0.00241889338940382, -0.05201828107237816, 0.0010151596507057548, 0.016241788864135742, 0.014782270416617393, 0.022794600576162338, -0.06881514936685562, -0.0034427864011377096, 0.02488362230360508, -0.032173216342926025, -0.005953927990049124, 0.00466547766700387, 0.0209114421159029, -0.016656313091516495, -0.011422069743275642, -0.03572934493422508, 0.014142248779535294, 0.059946175664663315, 0.014008003287017345, -0.006013382691890001, 0.04023898020386696, 0.020934857428073883, 0.004361228086054325, -0.038448870182037354, 0.016735248267650604, 0.043215617537498474, -0.041861843317747116, 0.033012453466653824, -0.005890306085348129, -0.06535986065864563, 0.0006240350194275379, -0.018538078293204308, 0.01778358779847622, -0.026511598378419876, 0.026304788887500763, -0.00047242623986676335, 0.04479042813181877, 0.009866920299828053, -0.025499198585748672, -0.022373778745532036, 0.013223571702837944, 0.032188780605793, 0.013546169735491276, 0.004909465555101633, 0.033486105501651764, 0.02409922145307064, 0.0006476592971011996, -0.018895719200372696, 0.025230664759874344, -0.008062858134508133, -0.047623779624700546, 0.013056593015789986, 0.004653405863791704, 0.021576622501015663, -0.005896812304854393, -0.023950615897774696, -0.050564322620630264, -0.015922939404845238, 0.00027628810494206846, -0.03554210066795349, -0.00856682751327753, 0.008934439159929752, 0.018816864117980003, -0.05337586626410484, 0.04234682768583298, -0.03493683785200119, -0.023550014942884445, -0.028312940150499344, -0.023071156814694405, 0.009632550179958344, -0.007811260875314474, -0.037857089191675186, -0.016391193494200706, -0.055243004113435745, 0.022580213844776154, -0.021015098318457603, -0.009804023429751396, 0.015365894883871078, -0.001782808220013976, 0.005009776446968317, -0.0210606399923563, 0.030186256393790245, -0.040898457169532776, -0.032482970505952835, -0.01682860217988491, -0.026784762740135193, -0.007432646583765745, 0.00814053788781166, 0.02427048049867153, -0.011111674830317497, -0.013578778132796288, -0.010814675129950047, 0.015599530190229416, 0.033318184316158295, -0.056680887937545776, 0.040404126048088074, 0.000867599796038121, -0.07358991354703903, -0.0006838341359980404, -0.047153353691101074, 0.015502641908824444, 0.006893896963447332, 0.015525344759225845, 0.0021445953752845526, 0.04862203449010849, 0.021123312413692474, 0.005979061592370272, -0.0022244839929044247, 0.006979929283261299, -0.03491703420877457, 0.040772512555122375, -0.004217423498630524, -0.006122597027570009, 0.02831311896443367, 0.00651336507871747, -0.03984628990292549, 0.012168279848992825, -0.038309741765260696, -0.019615620374679565, -0.010987882502377033, 0.0004878005711361766, 0.002255568979308009, -0.06436803191900253, -0.023677902296185493, 0.0492987297475338, -0.044431015849113464, -0.0013022401835769415, 0.07313647866249084, -0.025843199342489243, -0.020934032276272774, -0.0005636651185341179, 0.04474419727921486, 0.05358980596065521, -0.0004127297434024513, -0.04534196853637695, 0.018508002161979675, 0.0329289548099041, -0.00546814501285553, 0.032439831644296646, 0.0061655971221625805, 0.0376255176961422, 0.050179120153188705, -0.012138060294091702, 0.021431492641568184, -0.04236924275755882, -0.03595961630344391, 0.021694809198379517, 0.030433308333158493, -0.003059219103306532, -0.005594027228653431, -0.02680077776312828, 0.05777416005730629, -0.0153786176815629, -0.03277043625712395, -0.05402631685137749, -0.026626955717802048, -0.04026280343532562, 0.0018328588921576738, -0.020128998905420303, 0.05618581920862198, 0.015363475307822227, -0.0080181322991848, -0.006159419193863869, 0.019124578684568405, 0.015651728957891464, -0.029912816360592842, 0.026808420196175575, -0.02482912689447403, -0.0156552791595459, -0.013223525136709213, -0.009844183921813965, -0.017366565763950348, -0.002349487505853176, 0.04039009287953377, 0.0505245216190815, 0.01587720401585102, 0.015334275551140308, -0.01978253573179245, 0.01331676822155714, 0.03870994225144386, -0.08947202563285828, -0.03593897446990013, 0.009265155531466007, -0.01488681323826313, 0.008161301724612713, -0.03153782710433006 ]
<p>Let's say I have a grid of cells from a satellite image that take on the value of 0 or 1, with 1 being forest.</p> <p>There are many spatial pattern metrics that measure things about this pattern such as some dimension of forest fragmentation.</p> <p>A common one is the join-count statistic which is simple enough that its expectation and variance are calculable for a random allocation process. This allows one to estimate the probability of a join-count with an equal or greater value than that observed, given a random process. One only needs to know the relationship among grid cells (are they spatially connected/neighbors or not) and the probability of any cells taking on a specific value (e.g. the probability that a cell is forest and probability that it is not).</p> <p>More complex spatial patterns do not typically have a standardized version. For instance, the perimeter of all forest patches can be divided by the surface area of all patches to calculate a perimeter-area ratio. The farther from one large circle (the minimum) then the more fragmented.</p> <p>It would be easy to calculate the probability of any given spatial pattern (they would all be the same, I believe, if they contain the same number of forested/non-forested cells), however I am interested in knowing the expected perimeter-area ratio and variance so that measures such as this can be standardized.</p> <p>Are there any texts someone can suggest? </p> <p>I have read quite extensively within landscape ecology and related fields, but I do not believe this has been addressed, so I need a math text or even area of study to research of which I am not currently aware.</p> <p>A simple approach would be Monte Carlo simulation, but this would be very computationally intensive for even moderately large collections of grid cells. Further, the patterns observed are typically quite rare in comparison to a random process and so you could allow the simulation to run quite a while and I believe never fill in the tails of the distribution created by it so as to get a good handle on the probability of observing a pattern with the same value or greater.</p> <p>Any guidance related to obtaining my objective is appreciated.</p> <p>The primary motivation of this is not to test "straw man" null hypotheses of random allocation but instead to be able to compare the patterns from two areas while removing some of the confounding due to differences in the number of cells allocated to each category.</p>
74,507
[ -0.021760307252407074, -0.009400732815265656, 0.018446044996380806, -0.03351086750626564, 0.04602256044745445, 0.021119268611073494, 0.0015853603836148977, -0.03193633258342743, 0.019383737817406654, -0.059028610587120056, 0.021621042862534523, 0.03617103397846222, 0.012876344844698906, 0.045705828815698624, 0.014039314351975918, -0.0035942760296165943, -0.021381184458732605, 0.014062800444662571, -0.05840196833014488, -0.019201798364520073, 0.017506154254078865, 0.01747698150575161, 0.03952547535300255, -0.02507692016661167, -0.04043777659535408, 0.037449389696121216, -0.0034753570798784494, -0.018892107531428337, -0.004788956139236689, 0.08983442932367325, -0.027623238041996956, -0.0013852656120434403, 0.011572198010981083, 0.027956949546933174, 0.01706947386264801, -0.023121880367398262, -0.012966922484338284, -0.02585456147789955, -0.0027729771099984646, 0.006011215969920158, -0.006243533454835415, -0.02123473584651947, -0.018126267939805984, 0.019673697650432587, -0.028270931914448738, 0.013612017966806889, -0.03092384897172451, -0.05938560515642166, 0.03874202445149422, -0.0474264957010746, 0.06379207223653793, 0.030241843312978745, 0.06041466072201729, 0.03280971944332123, 0.03577765077352524, -0.01883210428059101, 0.039383891969919205, 0.031409215182065964, -0.0030341031961143017, -0.024415211752057076, -0.041643429547548294, -0.02951110526919365, 0.04676993563771248, -0.048658449202775955, -0.0027113391552120447, 0.027787838131189346, -0.020205525681376457, -0.02890271134674549, 0.06915199756622314, 0.0055904751643538475, 0.009298579767346382, 0.03015870973467827, 0.031405653804540634, 0.0032649391796439886, 0.01929505355656147, 0.001877051079645753, 0.016787929460406303, 0.024797281250357628, 0.041357893496751785, 0.024632537737488747, 0.008818025700747967, 0.019846636801958084, -0.015860646963119507, 0.00029091950273141265, 0.05880022421479225, 0.0032770701218396425, 0.05298982560634613, -0.03788119927048683, -0.0024795380886644125, 0.003147820243611932, -0.003971134778112173, -0.010249772109091282, 0.03559470921754837, -0.03530420735478401, -0.05291919782757759, 0.06651060283184052, -0.021512281149625778, 0.04513191431760788, -0.010211171582341194, 0.017241133376955986, -0.027680356055498123, -0.0661301538348198, -0.015640342608094215, 0.047918517142534256, -0.03133455291390419, 0.0012823367724195123, -0.03713706508278847, 0.02224654331803322, -0.027573898434638977, 0.014945996925234795, 0.004614240489900112, 0.017097029834985733, 0.044349055737257004, 0.02550855651497841, 0.01594032347202301, 0.005624756682664156, 0.025846710428595543, -0.03470930829644203, 0.03756318613886833, 0.05448898300528526, 0.06597844511270523, -0.04415575787425041, -0.0011672956170514226, -0.025212062522768974, -0.06958555430173874, 0.03080294467508793, 0.014520065858960152, -0.006930150557309389, -0.02842477522790432, 0.02762225642800331, -0.0135311558842659, -0.0000737017035135068, 0.04685864597558975, -0.020997485145926476, 0.019374698400497437, 0.021990705281496048, -0.06723735481500626, -0.04555876553058624, 0.05368947982788086, 0.008628391660749912, 0.012733599171042442, -0.033775944262742996, -0.010867559351027012, 0.0023465934209525585, 0.02498515322804451, -0.002816346473991871, 0.022049618884921074, 0.003574445378035307, 0.028756046667695045, -0.03418230637907982, -0.05324321612715721, 0.017171842977404594, 0.008035109378397465, -0.029780657961964607, -0.02869834564626217, -0.07141588628292084, 0.036188945174217224, 0.04937518760561943, 0.00022885586076881737, -0.018946440890431404, 0.039036672562360764, 0.005837146192789078, 0.0060433875769376755, 0.0019312594085931778, -0.015515627339482307, -0.018351297825574875, 0.07435507327318192, -0.004765321966260672, 0.008702508173882961, -0.02510513737797737, 0.00127984129358083, -0.03186952322721481, 0.020996522158384323, 0.008183124475181103, 0.08329819142818451, -0.026621777564287186, 0.03702560067176819, 0.01861509494483471, -0.011248493567109108, 0.02404012531042099, -0.0317542739212513, 0.009498002007603645, -0.02499276027083397, 0.011364464648067951, 0.02744406834244728, 0.01703607477247715, -0.02328021451830864, -0.041502371430397034, 0.04538647085428238, -0.02503478154540062, -0.038386933505535126, -0.046507418155670166, -0.003401590511202812, 0.004465759266167879, -0.01575024425983429, 0.008446217514574528, -0.0176065806299448, -0.0049015311524271965, 0.005101483780890703, -0.007639989722520113, -0.006122898310422897, -0.002217290224507451, 0.01722658798098564, -0.056145522743463516, -0.01457124762237072, 0.04548996314406395, 0.01236600149422884, -0.006050257943570614, 0.015180722810328007, -0.010172201320528984, -0.06279783695936203, -0.06451039761304855, -0.060115840286016464, 0.04150892049074173, -0.027814410626888275, -0.003082091687247157, 0.03520761802792549, -0.0027082080487161875, -0.007811947725713253, -0.026549559086561203, -0.026287831366062164, 0.0188521146774292, 0.06350713223218918, 0.02698591537773609, -0.004804374184459448, 0.013436485081911087, -0.03570906072854996, -0.02470037341117859, -0.046467091888189316, -0.018208518624305725, -0.07564540207386017, -0.006039558444172144, 0.07578399777412415, 0.009140496142208576, 0.007490523625165224, 0.00007853429269744083, 0.05898740887641907, 0.03781972825527191, 0.007311876863241196, 0.010158801451325417, -0.028385883197188377, 0.009966873563826084, 0.021153274923563004, 0.012485037557780743, 0.02762935310602188, -0.0036351631861180067, -0.01368558406829834, 0.007161634508520365, -0.010885601863265038, 0.013285445980727673, -0.0544859804213047, -0.00013769071665592492, -0.029835423454642296, 0.0024805618450045586, -0.022239720448851585, 0.031598448753356934, 0.027001965790987015, -0.00016791805683169514, -0.011312591843307018, 0.012807340361177921, 0.016773058101534843, -0.00039513027877546847, -0.027412230148911476, -0.039173997938632965, 0.008767519146203995, 0.03765399008989334, -0.02089831419289112, -0.0002862675173673779, 0.00895442720502615, -0.0014471550239250064, 0.06260892003774643, -0.01785704866051674, -0.03881782665848732, -0.022520827129483223, -0.011732502840459347, 0.043751202523708344, 0.015444452874362469, 0.014585024677217007, -0.011553077027201653, 0.01039421558380127, -0.03179058060050011, 0.016154564917087555, 0.029135828837752342, 0.024432389065623283, -0.019846046343445778, 0.004848712123930454, -0.00397368473932147, -0.009339864365756512, 0.024254992604255676, -0.014965624548494816, -0.01608537696301937, 0.022223589941859245, 0.02244008146226406, -0.04599735140800476, -0.012821361422538757, -0.04280571639537811, -0.02484801784157753, -0.02088932693004608, -0.010235851630568504, 0.017956385388970375, 0.0032675412949174643, -0.10196839272975922, 0.06159682944417, -0.04533517733216286, -0.008707533590495586, -0.06882935017347336, 0.007806344423443079, 0.022297663614153862, -0.033635739237070084, 0.03913574665784836, -0.006858742795884609, -0.0221455916762352, 0.0009752067853696644, -0.0569724515080452, -0.057578932493925095, -0.023501882329583168, -0.017159484326839447, 0.06099053472280502, -0.04218749701976776, -0.033449385315179825, 0.08172929286956787, 0.021150385960936546, 0.005210366100072861, 0.0007463775691576302, 0.05416538938879967, -0.021772760897874832, 0.003951483406126499, 0.026174766942858696, 0.0016128092538565397, 0.04128620773553848, 0.01688440516591072, -0.009034311398863792, 0.04214270040392876, 0.027340486645698547, -0.009782793931663036, -0.0021896257530897856, 0.05448613315820694, -0.038829781115055084, -0.017167342826724052, 0.04778270795941353, 0.044583845883607864, 0.008502321317791939, 0.036831386387348175, -0.029513105750083923, -0.014965319074690342, 0.040459342300891876, -0.09500052034854889, -0.004311066586524248, -0.02787116914987564, 0.003352175233885646, -0.022005438804626465, 0.03173267841339111, 0.0028267616871744394, -0.0034025488421320915, 0.02881300263106823, 0.009409858845174313, 0.06305669993162155, 0.002856210805475712, -0.03155307471752167, 0.04812520742416382, 0.05222062021493912, 0.0004479844938032329, -0.025011174380779266, -0.014155792072415352, 0.013080395758152008, -0.0024496265687048435, -0.038907527923583984, -0.023810431361198425, 0.04217289015650749, 0.0588943250477314, 0.04017379879951477, 0.002888798015192151, -0.029203278943896294, -0.012897509150207043, -0.04595789313316345, -0.04636940360069275, -0.037062812596559525, 0.03697904571890831, -0.002453139517456293, 0.012240231037139893, -0.00495160324499011, 0.005861291661858559, 0.009852453134953976, 0.0198277086019516, -0.07673324644565582, -0.01749406009912491, 0.0018700560322031379, -0.016507232561707497, -0.02538766711950302, -0.004330214578658342, 0.03676372021436691, 0.001215641968883574, -0.008405603468418121, 0.012206087820231915, 0.03493126481771469, -0.06253000348806381, 0.005971238482743502, -0.005856165662407875, -0.015780402347445488, -0.04534917324781418, 0.04683103412389755, 0.009550569579005241, -0.01803477667272091, 0.04506652057170868, 0.03295743092894554, 0.03868621587753296, -0.038679081946611404, -0.04294217377901077, -0.009871914982795715, 0.023050805553793907, 0.03129297494888306, -0.002128319814801216, 0.00946755800396204, -0.0496564619243145, 0.017279157415032387, 0.014125746674835682, 0.04016811400651932, -0.00908207893371582, 0.02611168660223484, 0.009668147191405296, -0.018048247322440147, -0.015184255316853523, 0.015656426548957825, 0.014809615910053253, -0.02563762106001377, -0.015994329005479813, 0.03983350470662117, 0.039519213140010834, -0.041889406740665436, 0.066327303647995, 0.02110830508172512, -0.0011055506765842438, -0.020210163667798042, -0.02139517478644848, -0.029456472024321556, 0.00872335396707058, -0.02537134476006031, 0.008929260075092316, 0.0234893336892128, 0.006893185433000326, -0.019672701135277748, 0.026984961703419685, -0.009619425982236862, -0.03235260024666786, -0.022642014548182487, -0.00397825799882412, 0.011957298032939434, -0.009986378252506256, -0.02019466646015644, 0.011438810266554356, 0.003096775384619832, 0.027629351243376732, 0.045677147805690765, 0.004411830101162195, -0.047625716775655746, -0.02575504034757614, 0.048755086958408356, -0.0017213430255651474, -0.012819377705454826, 0.007023491896688938, -0.013713491149246693, -0.008614062331616879, 0.004356831312179565, -0.010837347246706486, -0.013832049444317818, -0.0253079142421484, 0.003507030662149191, 0.009815339930355549, -0.0035840424243360758, -0.02861352264881134, -0.011551570147275925, 0.02615421637892723, 0.044036589562892914, -0.04915306344628334, 0.0027102541644126177, -0.04029485955834389, 0.04854758828878403, 0.005418910179287195, 0.023164158686995506, -0.003511138027533889, 0.015496223233640194, -0.02561391144990921, -0.0065499222837388515, 0.01910525932908058, -0.05799243226647377, 0.07751818001270294, 0.026915401220321655, 0.039482422173023224, 0.056443944573402405, -0.015033072791993618, -0.03924762085080147, 0.018088288605213165, -0.024655835703015327, -0.04027661308646202, -0.003440604545176029, -0.011372932232916355, 0.04012031853199005, 0.014971943572163582, 0.007637329399585724, 0.0496852807700634, 0.04035905748605728, -0.008265662007033825, 0.015288062393665314, -0.028985917568206787, 0.04180243983864784, -0.027292760089039803, -0.019159691408276558, -0.0471036359667778, -0.007907970808446407, -0.0207555890083313, 0.011822008527815342, -0.016466576606035233, 0.03791815787553787, -0.018042396754026413, -0.04169730842113495, 0.006886470131576061, 0.014272669330239296, -0.011640348471701145, 0.044558290392160416, -0.017238974571228027, 0.02070412039756775, 0.009429131634533405, -0.028888581320643425, 0.009465866722166538, 0.00026261544553563, -0.0031653852201998234, 0.006688517518341541, -0.014828044921159744, -0.026369793340563774, -0.04698304831981659, 0.006077455822378397, 0.023371346294879913, -0.015251103788614273, 0.07842981815338135, 0.0013059311313554645, 0.026613349094986916, 0.013813621364533901, -0.0364084430038929, -0.033220838755369186, 0.02285180799663067, -0.0056399195455014706, 0.02551480010151863, -0.024012688547372818, -0.016028190031647682, -0.03848414123058319, 0.026011625304818153, -0.08021674305200577, -0.024174047634005547, -0.03347187861800194, 0.02009406127035618, -0.010210031643509865, -0.0651310458779335, -0.010906364768743515, 0.013030445203185081, -0.04094161093235016, 0.030055969953536987, 0.06435059756040573, -0.046600718051195145, 0.0029403362423181534, -0.03185407444834709, 0.0218508280813694, 0.07398750633001328, -0.02622586116194725, -0.0069396886974573135, 0.04415034130215645, -0.027822090312838554, -0.0186204444617033, 0.0050241160206496716, 0.014146391302347183, -0.03935961425304413, 0.005992348305881023, -0.03629674017429352, -0.0025301987770944834, 0.014715351164340973, -0.02795736864209175, -0.027163850143551826, -0.003172745928168297, 0.005435165949165821, 0.005873279180377722, -0.0052024563774466515, 0.0022416787687689066, 0.0038841203786432743, -0.029545780271291733, -0.012150241993367672, 0.0033091844525188208, -0.02358136512339115, -0.006071453448385, 0.006217177491635084, -0.003272540634498, 0.025311749428510666, 0.01751769334077835, 0.027003511786460876, 0.0016729600029066205, -0.018529660999774933, 0.022190464660525322, -0.016258420422673225, 0.05722144618630409, -0.005749821662902832, 0.022927064448595047, 0.026322003453969955, 0.043824415653944016, -0.05587400123476982, -0.024340907111763954, -0.041941817849874496, -0.025156157091259956, 0.0338800773024559, 0.004888402298092842, 0.01963099278509617, 0.031238697469234467, -0.007608648389577866, 0.02480316534638405, -0.01975744031369686, 0.03174193575978279, 0.004097724799066782, 0.004314823541790247, 0.06251166760921478, -0.03959796205163002, 0.00771963968873024, 0.030177827924489975, 0.0060601974837481976, -0.017645256593823433, 0.046290963888168335, 0.0014469841262325644, 0.01262034010142088, 0.0851331278681755, -0.04753096029162407, -0.045312147587537766, 0.04315994307398796, -0.016838734969496727, 0.017060084268450737, 0.00267044547945261, -0.03488387167453766, 0.06615905463695526, 0.05876502767205238, -0.03331196308135986, -0.03683719411492348, -0.029221538454294205, -0.0632290244102478, 0.019802531227469444, 0.002518337918445468, -0.023145074024796486, -0.006399519741535187, -0.0024365487042814493, 0.02845306135714054, -0.047240305691957474, -0.020014533773064613, -0.011187579482793808, -0.05474184826016426, -0.023890800774097443, -0.03576992452144623, -0.06864374876022339, 0.015474358573555946, 0.02885119616985321, -0.01867498643696308, -0.006406553089618683, -0.0059721157886087894, 0.015247439965605736, 0.03876033425331116, 0.01632602885365486, -0.005892644170671701, 0.036219336092472076, -0.002533335005864501, 0.05626552551984787, -0.05814942345023155, 0.037268951535224915, 0.11856553703546524, 0.050139281898736954, 0.016084684059023857, -0.03651779145002365, 0.029770532622933388, -0.011370931752026081, -0.0014864696422591805, -0.036899566650390625, 0.006294520106166601, 0.047070618718862534, -0.011296207085251808, 0.045692238956689835, 0.038165383040905, -0.021508069708943367, -0.04284908249974251, 0.05109623819589615, 0.007921784184873104, -0.048095036298036575, -0.0049711973406374454, 0.015390701591968536, 0.025873862206935883, -0.0003737192018888891, -0.062613844871521, 0.02248629555106163, 0.0487496443092823, 0.004367496818304062, -0.017191292718052864, 0.0039479974657297134, 0.02527957409620285, 0.038852401077747345, -0.028938008472323418, -0.0312059223651886, 0.0387842021882534, 0.010915553197264671, -0.007292940281331539, -0.03986530005931854, 0.0019903562497347593, -0.005072608590126038, 0.014930231496691704, 0.041936010122299194, -0.0009617161704227328, 0.005695397965610027, 0.016919730231165886, 0.00483586173504591, -0.04083159938454628, -0.01632871851325035, -0.043750081211328506, 0.060097835958004, -0.02024696208536625, -0.02886255644261837, -0.008060506545007229, -0.0008635306148789823, -0.017667852342128754, -0.028300687670707703, 0.0020664155017584562, -0.012890789657831192, 0.027511533349752426, -0.01703045889735222, -0.030655615031719208, 0.039181336760520935, 0.023065470159053802, -0.033531226217746735, 0.0003316572110634297, 0.04305538162589073, -0.037051282823085785, -0.07873217016458511, -0.04076617211103439, 0.07112859189510345, -0.0028317731339484453, -0.011852110736072063, -0.009087756276130676, -0.01974359340965748, -0.01657644845545292, -0.028211921453475952, -0.022730521857738495, -0.015292073599994183, 0.0650453194975853, 0.02574203535914421, -0.043272148817777634, 0.03515719249844551, -0.024799762293696404, 0.005447873845696449, -0.04375085607171059, 0.0013978744391351938, -0.04076181724667549, 0.01133659202605486, 0.04462932050228119, 0.015289903618395329, 0.0029394468292593956, 0.0062280199490487576, -0.02297593653202057, 0.028309447690844536, 0.01001106109470129, -0.029627611860632896, -0.026983754709362984, -0.004772050306200981, -0.042372483760118484, 0.014470013789832592, 0.006634777877479792, 0.00730625307187438, 0.017380166798830032, -0.01306200586259365, 0.00046664386172778904, 0.036498527973890305, 0.02378297783434391, 0.0075796921737492085, -0.017846446484327316, -0.0548601895570755, 0.011348715983331203, -0.012351896613836288, 0.02767089754343033, 0.004458373878151178, 0.01958473213016987, -0.0012025575852021575, -0.006927968468517065, -0.0011046748841181397, 0.001989104086533189, -0.039324916899204254, -0.02551858499646187, -0.031427331268787384, 0.017499860376119614, 0.01477431133389473, -0.058307353407144547, -0.011867423541843891, -0.02827518619596958, -0.003964664880186319, -0.018918005749583244, 0.0006996941519901156, -0.002485595177859068, 0.008282539434731007, -0.01803363300859928, 0.0512983500957489, -0.005164249800145626, 0.02750878594815731, 0.0007928702398203313, 0.002667531371116638, 0.011594266630709171, 0.055716339498758316, 0.009333976544439793, 0.0013899884652346373, 0.044962819665670395, -0.047400180250406265, -0.056079622358083725, 0.017100853845477104, -0.033284466713666916, 0.05103197693824768, 0.005216152407228947, -0.0068934583105146885, -0.02929481491446495, 0.04271310940384865, 0.023835478350520134, -0.010064691305160522, -0.02274543233215809, 0.020954957231879234, 0.025232983753085136, -0.03472181409597397, 0.04113909229636192, 0.007478911429643631, -0.006358204875141382, -0.00707702711224556, 0.004433088935911655, -0.029779158532619476, 0.001171462470665574, 0.03175274282693863, -0.056009646505117416, 0.01824190840125084, -0.028994647786021233, 0.004626122768968344, 0.011108874343335629, 0.056375060230493546, -0.026855286210775375, -0.01763576827943325, 0.006030873861163855, -0.012230420485138893, -0.05388365313410759, -0.027237847447395325, 0.0201963409781456, 0.020823506638407707, 0.0048776366747915745, -0.035899460315704346, -0.025242777541279793, 0.05192413553595543, -0.03311554342508316, -0.002253306098282337, 0.049490176141262054, -0.008154688403010368, -0.07893605530261993, -0.018540604040026665, -0.030368542298674583, 0.022137872874736786, 0.02112412452697754, 0.02761128731071949, -0.01232213620096445, 0.06210733577609062, -0.04410812631249428, -0.006383235566318035, -0.0015483208699151874, 0.008406336419284344, 0.01917690597474575, -0.013650990091264248, -0.013562319800257683, -0.015474146232008934, 0.01177170779556036, 0.01648496463894844, -0.004390781745314598, 0.0000027360281364963157, 0.010283654555678368, 0.018691884353756905, 0.0011710755061358213, 0.05046393349766731, 0.023585498332977295, -0.03248143568634987, -0.017589418217539787, -0.02695346251130104, 0.004062573425471783, -0.01002445351332426, -0.05145680531859398, 0.03918128088116646, 0.04374180734157562, -0.005926332902163267, -0.030136648565530777, 0.039062000811100006, -0.0184658020734787, -0.05122263729572296, -0.016067540273070335, -0.02670697309076786, 0.04124648869037628, 0.0031244931742548943, -0.007841364480555058, -0.02535209432244301, 0.03488848730921745, 0.04539407044649124, 0.009153280407190323, -0.012178556062281132, 0.030406970530748367, -0.003936664201319218, -0.007762704510241747, 0.032039858400821686, 0.007485565263777971, -0.0194083359092474, -0.06992676854133606, -0.029107490554451942, -0.05573997646570206, 0.013283593580126762, 0.0007265924941748381, -0.00017668095824774355, -0.01815255917608738, 0.028148870915174484, 0.011338544078171253, 0.004195095505565405, -0.004750359337776899, 0.00033415548386983573, 0.02909700572490692, -0.04598649591207504, 0.06054998189210892, 0.01199999451637268, 0.036811523139476776, -0.023672964423894882, -0.01080018375068903, -0.0008060985128395259, 0.000559172302018851, 0.034315384924411774, 0.02376765012741089, 0.03826960548758507, -0.009049670770764351, 0.06712320446968079, 0.02277381345629692, -0.03625043109059334, 0.02469494752585888, -0.019380416721105576, -0.04375656694173813, -0.011591553688049316, -0.01712271198630333, 0.04878095164895058, -0.027881257236003876, 0.015248560346662998, 0.015467480756342411, -0.048283349722623825, -0.02425236627459526, -0.03268822655081749, 0.05845648795366287, 0.007533724419772625, -0.04254269599914551, 0.0801580548286438, -0.005264457780867815, -0.0016762071754783392, -0.022886505350470543, 0.009809279814362526, -0.022106006741523743, 0.008543687872588634, -0.06737363338470459, -0.04835813492536545, 0.009820416569709778, 0.07650292664766312, 0.03066970966756344, -0.04051543027162552, -0.0216537918895483, 0.030222848057746887, -0.03291022405028343, -0.01601918786764145, 0.04278619587421417, -0.007998086512088776, 0.03909357637166977, 0.012106033973395824, 0.0071295807138085365, 0.03354639187455177, -0.013974334113299847, -0.002278330037370324, 0.01765471138060093, 0.03926529362797737, -0.00898786075413227, 0.016642127186059952, 0.015739740803837776, 0.003971507307142019, 0.025596091523766518, -0.022587843239307404, 0.00008637688006274402, -0.01041896641254425, 0.022791706025600433, 0.07644188404083252, -0.005884741432964802, 0.031092222779989243, -0.017623256891965866, -0.0012653478188440204, 0.08829161524772644, 0.03770364075899124, -0.022883230820298195, -0.04979115352034569, -0.024887170642614365, -0.040382854640483856, 0.041982755064964294, -0.0037426247727125883, 0.039090827107429504, -0.006618720479309559, 0.07118149846792221, 0.006810444872826338, 0.0406930185854435, 0.03324790671467781, -0.057877108454704285, 0.04270987585186958, -0.010176131501793861, 0.02555036172270775, 0.03619663417339325, 0.0020727880764752626, -0.025473598390817642, 0.0035632201470434666, -0.0065183513797819614, 0.011046823114156723, 0.05499505624175072, 0.040255140513181686, -0.01574202999472618, 0.021164992824196815, 0.05730833485722542, -0.0322851799428463, -0.05112990736961365, -0.03673039749264717, 0.00753670372068882, -0.01024469081312418, -0.011897227726876736 ]
<p>I was just recently using the Student t-Test to check whether values from two samples could have an identical mean or not. I was wondering whether there is a complementary technique in bayesian statistics that does a similar thing.</p> <p>Especially I am wondering about the $P$ values that I obtain as a result (<a href="http://docs.scipy.org/doc/scipy/reference/generated/scipy.stats.ttest_ind.html" rel="nofollow">http://docs.scipy.org/doc/scipy/reference/generated/scipy.stats.ttest_ind.html</a>). With a sample size of 2 in my two samples, I figure that the resulting p value would probably fluctuate quite a bit if I added some more measurements or take some away.</p>
74,508
[ -0.045962974429130554, 0.006682009436190128, 0.011360758915543556, -0.010315758176147938, 0.04144592210650444, 0.04666682332754135, 0.007075343746691942, -0.024404410272836685, 0.016044313088059425, -0.053162116557359695, 0.027332071214914322, 0.061742205172777176, 0.046477753669023514, 0.006545012351125479, 0.029839754104614258, -0.018959559500217438, -0.026438672095537186, -0.014152486808598042, -0.010996553115546703, -0.039639607071876526, 0.015586908906698227, 0.019494546577334404, 0.03483245149254799, -0.025465277954936028, -0.023350762203335762, 0.019884653389453888, 0.008792298845946789, -0.026799650862812996, 0.014995258301496506, 0.06355977803468704, -0.055252548307180405, -0.04642259329557419, 0.020032865926623344, 0.02671351283788681, -0.0029816417954862118, -0.03205813840031624, -0.009758460335433483, -0.04095104709267616, -0.009439260698854923, 0.035171784460544586, -0.05505527928471565, -0.018715448677539825, -0.012257842347025871, 0.022364607080817223, -0.004059734288603067, 0.005665680393576622, -0.011394345201551914, -0.05293354019522667, 0.029955927282571793, -0.051771219819784164, 0.06290251761674881, 0.027020733803510666, 0.018052684143185616, 0.021964987739920616, -0.0165115837007761, -0.008143813349306583, 0.031870536506175995, 0.04313988611102104, -0.04089467227458954, -0.049525875598192215, -0.01473669521510601, -0.05218661576509476, 0.021475164219737053, -0.017936738207936287, -0.06835414469242096, 0.024752993136644363, -0.029920367524027824, -0.03533606603741646, -0.0016700325068086386, -0.005698955152183771, 0.03571860119700432, 0.0358208566904068, 0.0381312370300293, -0.0014733002753928304, 0.01382632739841938, -0.025018414482474327, 0.02097087725996971, 0.04311946779489517, 0.04681035503745079, 0.05646186321973801, 0.01660856418311596, -0.01614972949028015, 0.03443301096558571, 0.05309075489640236, 0.01808488368988037, -0.030181292444467545, 0.0470840223133564, -0.03690849244594574, 0.0012447714107111096, 0.014271176420152187, -0.0555575005710125, -0.013329300098121166, 0.05340825766324997, -0.021423304453492165, -0.04721464589238167, 0.040483199059963226, -0.022310711443424225, 0.059811778366565704, -0.01635235920548439, 0.009917735122144222, 0.011878257617354393, -0.04095584899187088, 0.019325781613588333, 0.05403666943311691, -0.0251736082136631, -0.05906832963228226, -0.03280479460954666, -0.002348707290366292, -0.029912488535046577, 0.005179871339350939, -0.019841836765408516, 0.03997696936130524, 0.012953720986843109, -0.01685723103582859, 0.041196439415216446, -0.004988409578800201, 0.014126389287412167, -0.05321511998772621, 0.061705730855464935, 0.05771385878324509, 0.038486968725919724, -0.018387455493211746, 0.04366083815693855, -0.02301172725856304, -0.04947228357195854, 0.013943944126367569, -0.021150022745132446, -0.004580950364470482, -0.012789570726454258, 0.041373588144779205, -0.01002467144280672, 0.002671029418706894, 0.06868727505207062, -0.005668726749718189, 0.012948664836585522, 0.010205385275185108, -0.07638976722955704, -0.0455213338136673, 0.03129711374640465, -0.024972403421998024, -0.032679855823516846, -0.07466628402471542, -0.01274814922362566, 0.0380641371011734, 0.0197944063693285, 0.009448545053601265, 0.03300081565976143, -0.010054383426904678, 0.03343091905117035, 0.010307280346751213, -0.02026306837797165, -0.01462576724588871, -0.006755731534212828, -0.014009018428623676, -0.005870448425412178, -0.10740329325199127, -0.017262324690818787, 0.004014105070382357, -0.013558341190218925, 0.031230611726641655, 0.03828442841768265, -0.020757826045155525, -0.009642082266509533, -0.01906127855181694, 0.0422726534307003, -0.01343320682644844, 0.07774948328733444, 0.015698261559009552, 0.022429877892136574, -0.009596826508641243, -0.0034803305752575397, 0.002842768793925643, 0.019690770655870438, 0.027683356776833534, 0.0339428074657917, -0.05450310558080673, -0.027270302176475525, 0.006296962033957243, 0.06687037646770477, 0.000520578701980412, -0.0008137209224514663, 0.03144751861691475, -0.026226364076137543, 0.003243116196244955, -0.0018928888021036983, 0.04700353741645813, 0.03861294314265251, -0.016974715515971184, 0.03317389264702797, -0.04622192680835724, -0.04210113734006882, -0.08296158164739609, 0.006085824221372604, -0.003895297646522522, -0.009789535775780678, 0.05030524730682373, 0.02312992885708809, 0.02875455841422081, -0.03257228061556816, -0.024612223729491234, -0.012732208706438541, -0.017202135175466537, 0.012881279923021793, -0.0323108471930027, 0.00859694741666317, 0.03364979103207588, 0.06302483379840851, 0.012813777662813663, 0.03889394551515579, -0.0385529100894928, -0.0528705008327961, -0.0007578644435852766, -0.039465129375457764, -0.007038301322609186, -0.01734962873160839, -0.01706944778561592, 0.02445109188556671, -0.011503404937684536, -0.024909134954214096, 0.03553173691034317, -0.07518515735864639, 0.07355107367038727, 0.04057835042476654, 0.02489352412521839, 0.016195420175790787, 0.004517686553299427, 0.006989582907408476, 0.030118780210614204, -0.04327773302793503, -0.029766423627734184, -0.05681176483631134, -0.003133968450129032, 0.04174603149294853, 0.022320101037621498, -0.028716789558529854, 0.024011284112930298, 0.03984883427619934, -0.018481262028217316, 0.016880791634321213, 0.038499634712934494, 0.0007749017677269876, -0.04928525537252426, 0.007474866695702076, 0.01722560077905655, 0.016376353800296783, 0.0008566303295083344, 0.021314390003681183, -0.0005089523619972169, 0.04154105484485626, 0.001358144567348063, -0.020338015630841255, -0.008427766151726246, -0.011508217081427574, 0.000603795750066638, -0.006077408324927092, -0.04001237824559212, 0.002190549857914448, -0.023154988884925842, 0.005232923198491335, 0.010610729455947876, 0.01705583557486534, -0.035390421748161316, -0.019033893942832947, -0.03814530000090599, 0.042610328644514084, 0.029901448637247086, -0.025160273537039757, 0.010451669804751873, 0.008175554685294628, -0.05680167302489281, 0.004151143133640289, 0.009536187164485455, -0.027673490345478058, -0.02088511735200882, 0.03986421227455139, 0.018889466300606728, -0.01614689640700817, 0.029031595215201378, -0.044959019869565964, -0.015799440443515778, -0.0034581481013447046, 0.004955285228788853, -0.009916596114635468, -0.017253171652555466, -0.05835608020424843, 0.012849060818552971, -0.0038365654181689024, -0.010352983139455318, 0.018011586740612984, -0.02975187823176384, 0.01851089484989643, 0.00939482357352972, -0.005660630762577057, -0.042958445847034454, 0.0006844810559414327, -0.04370051622390747, -0.03280046954751015, -0.008295592851936817, -0.0019394413102418184, 0.027227450162172318, 0.008257199078798294, -0.024025825783610344, 0.04525657743215561, -0.03402489796280861, -0.04702752083539963, -0.05406373739242554, 0.003927335143089294, 0.03103703260421753, -0.006889371667057276, 0.012820078060030937, 0.05504758283495903, -0.03584170341491699, 0.015735939145088196, -0.05324570834636688, -0.06195588782429695, 0.04918593540787697, 0.0054768407717347145, 0.03496892750263214, 0.012547682039439678, -0.017188819125294685, 0.07106398791074753, 0.009894968010485172, -0.03494563326239586, -0.011256499215960503, 0.023188641294836998, -0.01453617587685585, 0.02317047491669655, -0.0020963975694030523, 0.015576749108731747, -0.020637977868318558, 0.0020332112908363342, -0.006902931723743677, -0.006012912839651108, 0.036573123186826706, 0.03305808827280998, 0.00979536958038807, -0.004379259888082743, 0.02259896509349346, -0.006501826923340559, 0.027766156941652298, 0.011814815923571587, -0.02840847335755825, -0.0027013588696718216, 0.018372656777501106, 0.03763752803206444, -0.006702654995024204, -0.019830165430903435, 0.02591158077120781, 0.0024336129426956177, 0.018656950443983078, -0.06985019892454147, 0.04358105733990669, -0.005195229779928923, -0.01758432947099209, -0.007318255957216024, 0.04480765014886856, 0.006254996173083782, -0.011509041301906109, 0.04226730763912201, 0.09064558148384094, 0.03618752211332321, -0.02269536256790161, -0.024661879986524582, -0.016664450988173485, -0.006037029437720776, 0.011009194888174534, -0.019095905125141144, -0.04019969701766968, 0.053607046604156494, 0.0324164517223835, 0.0419873483479023, 0.008788752369582653, -0.04902369901537895, 0.014490673318505287, -0.06531843543052673, -0.014113705605268478, -0.048427071422338486, 0.02545851469039917, 0.007039565127342939, 0.016429642215371132, 0.02291017584502697, 0.019971411675214767, 0.0014783217338845134, -0.0005591277149505913, -0.0589442104101181, -0.004540278576314449, -0.03387713432312012, -0.04731978476047516, -0.003722787369042635, -0.008934248238801956, 0.03114556521177292, -0.020019661635160446, 0.053278598934412, -0.01620084047317505, 0.017685098573565483, -0.047068703919649124, -0.02380693145096302, -0.048931751400232315, -0.01886836439371109, 0.019238395616412163, 0.044358640909194946, 0.029355479404330254, -0.02361590415239334, 0.006216890178620815, 0.030469341203570366, -0.0382390096783638, -0.0223474632948637, 0.0031114821322262287, 0.027625905349850655, -0.021620064973831177, 0.030538741499185562, 0.04617833346128464, 0.07943922281265259, -0.05220147222280502, 0.021268943324685097, 0.0017390300054103136, 0.042130861431360245, 0.055397070944309235, -0.01918295957148075, -0.0001702838926576078, -0.021582195535302162, -0.04159771651029587, 0.0004865783266723156, 0.010429050773382187, -0.02144443988800049, -0.010705402120947838, 0.02232983522117138, 0.04439746215939522, -0.06957163661718369, 0.03447062149643898, 0.04880392551422119, 0.012017114087939262, 0.01163923554122448, -0.04599876329302788, -0.013932167552411556, -0.01747783087193966, -0.023128194734454155, 0.025679517537355423, 0.020661834627389908, -0.02343614026904106, 0.0034971118438988924, 0.03251862898468971, 0.003054470755159855, -0.022598927840590477, -0.03771805390715599, 0.0037047765217721462, 0.035570334643125534, 0.029350072145462036, -0.04618489742279053, 0.011221514083445072, 0.03531607240438461, -0.00617963308468461, 0.009252863004803658, 0.02045293338596821, -0.062100354582071304, 0.014375856146216393, 0.03366377204656601, 0.0301726795732975, -0.03684926778078079, 0.03261775150895119, -0.02370348572731018, -0.0009874125244095922, 0.04552406072616577, -0.040686946362257004, 0.007494352757930756, -0.005387530196458101, 0.00788120087236166, -0.005346807651221752, -0.00008850255835568532, -0.04743153229355812, 0.025160569697618484, -0.027288857847452164, -0.002772093517705798, -0.016047555953264236, -0.0516173392534256, -0.038204655051231384, -0.005063595250248909, 0.017193548381328583, 0.06609636545181274, -0.043600428849458694, -0.01297775749117136, 0.01653589867055416, 0.009132574312388897, 0.022040652111172676, -0.06084968522191048, 0.010442403145134449, 0.004481389187276363, -0.02077431231737137, 0.03733528032898903, -0.02607353962957859, -0.024088526144623756, 0.02955746091902256, -0.0176050066947937, -0.027590297162532806, 0.02983960323035717, 0.007768587674945593, 0.03688526526093483, 0.0332365445792675, -0.008380908519029617, 0.05938868597149849, 0.004899215418845415, 0.025026600807905197, -0.01791652850806713, -0.021234046667814255, 0.035935211926698685, -0.0515589602291584, -0.01605909690260887, -0.0543597936630249, -0.01923113688826561, -0.026587793603539467, 0.0585455521941185, 0.022022970020771027, 0.035420503467321396, -0.027004588395357132, -0.001348718418739736, 0.014150775969028473, 0.021763186901807785, 0.04641484469175339, 0.017145652323961258, -0.015750767663121223, 0.014154260978102684, 0.008848757483065128, -0.019208358600735664, 0.022635502740740776, -0.004982482176274061, -0.001013107248581946, -0.010720489546656609, -0.044773682951927185, 0.055587898939847946, -0.05291418731212616, -0.02034892700612545, 0.03502378985285759, -0.028326010331511497, 0.012609584257006645, -0.011421147733926773, 0.03802763670682907, 0.01116316206753254, -0.016257397830486298, -0.01290221232920885, 0.04306274279952049, 0.007278726901859045, 0.02688016928732395, -0.05963613837957382, 0.052729032933712006, -0.010139720514416695, -0.014756941236555576, -0.06608711928129196, -0.028428079560399055, 0.03452645242214203, 0.004932600539177656, -0.009087566286325455, -0.05545291304588318, 0.001030980609357357, 0.004681343212723732, -0.001755087054334581, -0.021828630939126015, 0.05924740061163902, 0.0014292760752141476, -0.026905382052063942, -0.02407018467783928, 0.004975371528416872, 0.08242110908031464, -0.003132219659164548, -0.023025918751955032, 0.004810587503015995, -0.004685362335294485, -0.005094531457871199, 0.007719655055552721, 0.02615957334637642, -0.0413622111082077, 0.0036744989920407534, -0.023205796256661415, 0.022792646661400795, 0.04814014211297035, -0.06207902729511261, -0.03554036095738411, 0.018996598199009895, 0.0009166154195554554, 0.015203398652374744, -0.01313899364322424, -0.0012885726755484939, -0.02288784645497799, -0.032622165977954865, -0.04731441289186478, -0.0036945510655641556, 0.009123091585934162, -0.034465353935956955, 0.014193971641361713, 0.005103886127471924, -0.05094268545508385, -0.0045323921367526054, 0.04302860423922539, 0.008149986155331135, -0.009779362939298153, -0.02129223197698593, -0.0156367477029562, 0.01995404250919819, 0.02348528616130352, -0.028480269014835358, 0.011106260120868683, -0.006799950264394283, -0.03451135754585266, -0.029002657160162926, -0.03276792913675308, -0.039953507483005524, 0.06073683127760887, 0.004653220064938068, 0.09073745459318161, 0.05233759805560112, 0.046148642897605896, 0.013615930452942848, -0.0032091063912957907, 0.01475947629660368, -0.00512352492660284, 0.0018227830296382308, 0.013991313055157661, -0.02108178101480007, 0.010954751633107662, 0.04193037748336792, 0.014025863260030746, 0.031961116939783096, 0.0336066298186779, 0.010421141982078552, 0.04131726548075676, 0.05681205168366432, -0.044740211218595505, -0.03340967372059822, 0.03941047564148903, -0.03552241623401642, 0.012858955189585686, -0.05614596605300903, -0.03094564750790596, 0.023257439956068993, 0.024983251467347145, 0.008740907534956932, -0.04868181422352791, -0.02119077742099762, -0.059560663998126984, 0.025628216564655304, 0.02999865449965, 0.023295465856790543, 0.04025673493742943, 0.010499267838895321, 0.021425923332571983, -0.0055611529387533665, 0.028410308063030243, -0.049694567918777466, -0.05983934551477432, -0.052860572934150696, -0.011785426177084446, 0.005588025785982609, 0.02849634550511837, 0.004217979498207569, -0.0015010753413662314, 0.01864272728562355, -0.04423631727695465, 0.03739519789814949, -0.00956649612635374, 0.04484489560127258, -0.04047968611121178, 0.06690321117639542, 0.001693369704298675, 0.036399632692337036, -0.01901249773800373, -0.013405225239694118, 0.09431515634059906, 0.07340434938669205, 0.05579739063978195, -0.06699642539024353, 0.029308494180440903, -0.01778162270784378, -0.022684579715132713, -0.02982194907963276, 0.02329886332154274, 0.037028469145298004, -0.025730689987540245, 0.011939484626054764, 0.0717160701751709, 0.03401150926947594, -0.05012071505188942, 0.08795812726020813, -0.008713440969586372, -0.003967104479670525, 0.010980998165905476, 0.02010980248451233, -0.0035717589780688286, -0.02727905847132206, -0.05403933301568031, 0.028639813885092735, -0.008685954846441746, -0.013692887499928474, -0.024662328884005547, -0.023668861016631126, -0.04336993023753166, 0.017391150817275047, 0.005766530986875296, -0.007423147093504667, -0.011034643277525902, -0.011071370914578438, -0.009144270792603493, 0.0013446511002257466, 0.006303717847913504, -0.002020925981923938, -0.0014623763272538781, 0.0468926727771759, 0.002275009173899889, -0.007533269468694925, -0.0074463896453380585, 0.05049828812479973, -0.030919577926397324, -0.03178877383470535, -0.016941260546445847, 0.06740424036979675, -0.019249770790338516, -0.006401467602699995, -0.027275407686829567, -0.007428037468343973, 0.0019612193573266268, -0.030177194625139236, -0.035075392574071884, 0.014514164999127388, 0.02657664567232132, -0.022282328456640244, 0.027884745970368385, -0.015020063146948814, 0.0350869856774807, -0.022378165274858475, 0.017459917813539505, 0.03254827857017517, -0.017920350655913353, -0.03657793998718262, -0.012568807229399681, 0.06680357456207275, 0.03472978621721268, -0.019846610724925995, 0.01045738160610199, -0.029540669173002243, -0.03897051885724068, -0.0021295121405273676, 0.004541114438325167, -0.0012634358135983348, 0.0245363712310791, 0.004430991131812334, -0.014140747487545013, -0.008598913438618183, -0.01805175095796585, 0.025195999071002007, -0.030770467594265938, -0.0016594910994172096, -0.0149979367852211, -0.009677276015281677, 0.06145292520523071, 0.03860451281070709, 0.021209685131907463, 0.030537083745002747, 0.012727987952530384, 0.028729436919093132, 0.0156741663813591, -0.06725423038005829, 0.0011279558530077338, -0.026197755709290504, -0.03084065392613411, -0.02375217154622078, -0.004610652569681406, 0.022332971915602684, 0.03799867257475853, 0.04882833734154701, 0.018240198493003845, -0.011818692088127136, -0.003537579672411084, 0.018362982198596, -0.034432314336299896, -0.04521951079368591, -0.028522972017526627, 0.0006291932659223676, 0.002341949613764882, 0.0014368161791935563, -0.0002822662645485252, -0.017555411905050278, -0.0058716898784041405, 0.01922900602221489, -0.038198042660951614, -0.027116430923342705, -0.02013050951063633, 0.008985424414277077, -0.002051417250186205, -0.04316196218132973, 0.028977230191230774, -0.006226268596947193, -0.004925164859741926, -0.009805798530578613, -0.0001992171019082889, -0.027876680716872215, 0.013181624934077263, -0.03605107590556145, -0.033289067447185516, 0.07147972285747528, 0.012358428910374641, 0.03370678052306175, -0.018504656851291656, 0.03197397664189339, 0.007979296147823334, 0.04167454317212105, -0.019019141793251038, -0.029979923740029335, 0.06986995786428452, -0.042614977806806564, -0.02151118963956833, 0.042695220559835434, 0.00982604268938303, 0.0038509280420839787, 0.0189030934125185, -0.014882741495966911, -0.007107771001756191, 0.05601084604859352, -0.04245532676577568, -0.00934042688459158, 0.00724975299090147, -0.0029083420522511005, -0.007005736697465181, -0.027189131826162338, 0.011758580803871155, 0.02373279072344303, -0.013236282393336296, 0.02170252986252308, 0.03492964431643486, -0.010497687384486198, 0.02167053148150444, -0.00892423652112484, -0.022219756618142128, -0.000541325774975121, -0.002809743396937847, -0.008152220398187637, 0.03907365724444389, 0.08374481648206711, 0.0029132713098078966, 0.030607184395194054, -0.026181906461715698, 0.016205497086048126, -0.1154690608382225, -0.001943516544997692, 0.029923714697360992, 0.006066889502108097, 0.05056588724255562, -0.028431212529540062, 0.015388811938464642, 0.0006357213133014739, -0.05486563220620155, 0.012809478677809238, -0.010030044242739677, -0.02243393287062645, -0.024583643302321434, 0.01050359196960926, -0.04073898866772652, 0.04476327821612358, 0.005533849820494652, 0.05007687583565712, 0.03582436591386795, 0.04199837148189545, -0.0018168891547247767, 0.012789392843842506, -0.021073298528790474, 0.024445729330182076, 0.019437473267316818, -0.05798773095011711, 0.03150181099772453, -0.00830884464085102, -0.05484411120414734, 0.0136574013158679, 0.02393876574933529, 0.030453354120254517, -0.01883082464337349, 0.032542869448661804, 0.008837343193590641, 0.03137204796075821, 0.04729785770177841, 0.009131061844527721, -0.01888956129550934, 0.006606328766793013, -0.01224000658839941, 0.025708544999361038, -0.012949704192578793, -0.006903481669723988, 0.021176278591156006, -0.014013699255883694, 0.0013709847116842866, 0.01147713977843523, -0.0027570058591663837, -0.03893757238984108, 0.01575998030602932, 0.005639542825520039, 0.007545184809714556, -0.010192968882620335, 0.0022921946365386248, -0.06256468594074249, 0.009896916337311268, 0.056133825331926346, 0.017911579459905624, -0.02299605868756771, 0.016825785860419273, -0.016867361962795258, -0.030637133866548538, 0.02929619699716568, -0.0022112412843853235, -0.00438942015171051, -0.035379160195589066, 0.007622528355568647, 0.0340699702501297, 0.010896970517933369, -0.015665456652641296, -0.049472808837890625, -0.0237584225833416, 0.022047992795705795, -0.026450542733073235, 0.015692338347434998, 0.003921394236385822, 0.03016963228583336, -0.005488856695592403, -0.04185086861252785, 0.07055265456438065, -0.02666824869811535, -0.0024780365638434887, -0.04930524155497551, -0.0025105683598667383, -0.029176561161875725, 0.0008537406101822853, 0.06187131255865097, 0.005975006613880396, 0.02501068077981472, 0.00734577514231205, 0.013739683665335178, 0.02615826576948166, -0.05784212797880173, 0.01187832374125719, -0.00785572174936533, -0.008256042376160622, -0.016108136624097824, -0.008890771307051182, 0.030250662937760353, 0.011225277557969093, 0.031591303646564484, -0.056063976138830185, 0.03285500407218933, 0.021458148956298828, 0.010041853412985802, 0.06053680181503296, -0.005058532580733299, 0.0014148628106340766, 0.04709381237626076, 0.007351594045758247, 0.024388758465647697, 0.016184905543923378, 0.008637969382107258, -0.050137490034103394, 0.03847132623195648, -0.003879283554852009, -0.03551861271262169, -0.006488202139735222, 0.03536226600408554, -0.022921428084373474, -0.03691872954368591, -0.0003385122399777174, 0.014088247902691364, -0.0237817894667387, -0.010993530042469501, 0.019388975575566292, 0.012523317709565163, 0.027862446382641792, -0.025581007823348045, 0.04928041994571686, 0.026053108274936676, 0.00276594958268106, 0.0029867368284612894, 0.008092043921351433, 0.025357002392411232, 0.011266203597187996, 0.020169610157608986, 0.03677092492580414, -0.01665211282670498, 0.025441069155931473, -0.015483599156141281, 0.011375928297638893, -0.010583985596895218, -0.021859247237443924, -0.0026400797069072723, 0.002563162473961711, 0.033146947622299194, -0.006362093612551689, -0.01587851159274578, 0.09593002498149872, -0.025141768157482147, -0.003824768355116248, -0.017786050215363503, 0.0008564818999730051, -0.026752330362796783, -0.009960471652448177, 0.012711135670542717, 0.017514938488602638, 0.0130046047270298, -0.005950283724814653, -0.0050147599540650845, -0.03290346637368202, -0.006152596324682236, -0.04624299705028534, 0.0017162866424769163, -0.03460124507546425, -0.01916094683110714, -0.0167321115732193, 0.0026447803247720003, -0.05221349373459816, -0.017335254698991776, 0.009392503648996353, 0.03770064935088158, 0.036890652030706406, -0.022705065086483955, -0.03776911646127701, 0.025403395295143127, 0.0449540950357914, -0.07350292801856995, -0.009018462151288986, -0.04066323861479759, 0.012163424864411354, -0.002085053129121661, -0.039812371134757996 ]
<p>I am working on multi class imbalance data.I want to divide my classes based on one verus one method and then perform sampling techinque How can I do that I just want to divide the classes not classification. Is it possible in libsvm</p>
22,166
[ -0.0024320255033671856, -0.00007263397128554061, -0.007807017304003239, -0.015438592992722988, 0.006529248785227537, -0.015253692865371704, -0.050687696784734726, -0.017266685143113136, 0.03319243714213371, -0.001081238966435194, 0.03949643298983574, 0.050901032984256744, 0.05034682899713516, 0.0380544438958168, 0.0004513836174737662, -0.015857161954045296, -0.018692081794142723, -0.0006468661595135927, 0.02036934532225132, 0.008213446475565434, -0.038270726799964905, -0.011636451818048954, 0.04287753626704216, -0.023448484018445015, -0.04509562626481056, 0.028963731601834297, 0.04987514019012451, -0.0049652038142085075, 0.004490010440349579, 0.020009178668260574, -0.031426358968019485, -0.03117320127785206, 0.007404616568237543, 0.03916436806321144, 0.016433928161859512, 0.01445220597088337, -0.029515348374843597, -0.011364351026713848, -0.04213544726371765, 0.0034844789188355207, -0.005383704788982868, 0.005822052247822285, -0.014544559642672539, 0.03556277975440025, 0.009052131325006485, 0.0059760925360023975, 0.012566275894641876, -0.016539575532078743, 0.05903543904423714, -0.02634335681796074, 0.08273839205503464, -0.01816863752901554, 0.04651753231883049, 0.03593745827674866, 0.0006260981317609549, 0.028517920523881912, 0.02657199278473854, 0.081427663564682, -0.0020593467634171247, 0.022939560934901237, -0.004438918083906174, -0.0036359569057822227, -0.0016370337689295411, -0.011062546633183956, -0.04216870293021202, 0.007313546258956194, -0.016399161890149117, -0.013955486938357353, 0.020060788840055466, -0.009422709234058857, -0.0006753980997018516, -0.02950390614569187, -0.011932972818613052, -0.031190933659672737, -0.01513952948153019, -0.012669984251260757, -0.002439983654767275, 0.032939374446868896, 0.03612857684493065, 0.008680852130055428, 0.008071547374129295, 0.02985619567334652, -0.0066353254951536655, 0.021371114999055862, 0.04216928780078888, -0.02927662990987301, 0.0429852157831192, -0.03160054609179497, -0.00792547408491373, 0.04038728401064873, -0.01657223515212536, -0.003919034264981747, 0.03743743896484375, 0.031095268204808235, -0.06801789999008179, 0.040060002356767654, 0.010121019557118416, 0.014301547780632973, 0.012228268198668957, -0.014905931428074837, 0.020920217037200928, -0.00562431151047349, 0.007673675660043955, 0.035597413778305054, -0.05155738443136215, 0.005348078440874815, -0.04090560972690582, -0.003490240778774023, 0.02713082730770111, -0.0023393977899104357, -0.004197948612272739, 0.0062478710897266865, 0.010394028387963772, -0.017134597525000572, 0.021843571215867996, 0.007838155142962933, 0.0022849077358841896, -0.019665410742163658, 0.02206735871732235, 0.07909390330314636, 0.03522013500332832, -0.03273755684494972, 0.04785264655947685, -0.028528213500976562, -0.07606501132249832, -0.00046985308290459216, 0.00826783012598753, -0.03443363308906555, -0.01105860061943531, 0.016614003106951714, -0.016551345586776733, -0.035448502749204636, 0.052954576909542084, -0.016396736726164818, 0.01683812029659748, -0.011758056469261646, -0.06150505691766739, -0.03110271878540516, 0.010043160989880562, -0.046215955168008804, 0.02387414686381817, -0.017958825454115868, 0.01831412874162197, 0.008081701584160328, 0.015715479850769043, 0.0585772767663002, 0.0501486100256443, 0.02014029584825039, 0.024762658402323723, 0.01582263596355915, -0.023492828011512756, 0.0011617520358413458, -0.02753913402557373, 0.020188825204968452, -0.031218530610203743, -0.04621231183409691, 0.00973432045429945, 0.04014943912625313, -0.023192262277007103, 0.03892862796783447, -0.010321936570107937, 0.014643187634646893, 0.0031520656775683165, -0.0076722861267626286, 0.008115803822875023, -0.04169243574142456, 0.03829076513648033, -0.004005263559520245, 0.07355649769306183, -0.0009426195756532252, -0.02509797178208828, 0.010408364236354828, 0.04175134003162384, 0.018128836527466774, 0.05447641387581825, 0.002591834170743823, -0.003233572468161583, -0.0009610819979570806, 0.05252721905708313, 0.0017385336104780436, -0.03998308256268501, -0.046344537287950516, 0.043701980262994766, 0.010965436697006226, 0.013035086914896965, 0.029943184927105904, -0.001977029023692012, -0.023410921916365623, 0.01941550150513649, -0.03982415422797203, -0.031111953780055046, -0.01771639846265316, -0.012394532561302185, -0.008779884316027164, -0.05143323913216591, -0.015560018830001354, 0.020215030759572983, 0.03908644616603851, -0.03448985517024994, -0.038353778421878815, -0.047795381397008896, -0.011691962368786335, 0.021900175139307976, -0.03860289603471756, -0.025072531774640083, 0.011995386332273483, 0.0016382042085751891, -0.0288475900888443, 0.0887816771864891, -0.012982956133782864, -0.01618771068751812, 0.018734481185674667, -0.006999074947088957, -0.005035269074141979, -0.010184132494032383, -0.01925507001578808, 0.045476097613573074, 0.029146475717425346, 0.010882713831961155, 0.04041207581758499, -0.02277444489300251, 0.08084789663553238, 0.09063371270895004, 0.000558840692974627, 0.000931565766222775, -0.029071344062685966, -0.003444001078605652, 0.010284113697707653, 0.002747131045907736, -0.017978278920054436, -0.007782318163663149, -0.0010818121954798698, 0.03138119354844093, -0.011486249044537544, -0.03764377906918526, 0.0348244346678257, 0.05930532515048981, -0.0037355574313551188, 0.040616221725940704, 0.02260631136596203, -0.009937254711985588, 0.008897965773940086, 0.023828119039535522, 0.02997257001698017, 0.0362156480550766, -0.02206653170287609, 0.024099906906485558, -0.006455853581428528, 0.038384005427360535, -0.01016452070325613, -0.00854456052184105, 0.06804487109184265, -0.0031514232978224754, -0.015498580411076546, 0.010336746461689472, -0.0328482948243618, -0.0021123713813722134, -0.014782710000872612, 0.030176136642694473, 0.053328268229961395, 0.005925214849412441, -0.023977257311344147, 0.016125638037919998, -0.008418183773756027, 0.03728260099887848, 0.057645078748464584, -0.015047934837639332, 0.02223631925880909, 0.054594509303569794, -0.05437253788113594, 0.012708263471722603, 0.028053931891918182, -0.0031633235048502684, -0.04852468520402908, 0.04955538734793663, 0.046115048229694366, -0.018269317224621773, 0.006685619242489338, -0.00792266521602869, 0.011095273308455944, 0.020334288477897644, -0.001261085388250649, 0.0222957544028759, -0.029410483315587044, -0.06030518189072609, 0.049822594970464706, -0.0070851813070476055, -0.04733894765377045, -0.009182637557387352, 0.05044477432966232, -0.023156853392720222, 0.004336502868682146, 0.010424772277474403, -0.0595628097653389, -0.0101356515660882, -0.030560025945305824, 0.013583972118794918, 0.006006774492561817, -0.008175264112651348, -0.003403909271582961, 0.046602725982666016, -0.04311750829219818, -0.007593180518597364, -0.020319880917668343, -0.04513770714402199, -0.04367860406637192, -0.02264026366174221, 0.013366821222007275, -0.01964709907770157, 0.02447669208049774, 0.047463513910770416, -0.02941795438528061, 0.01738874427974224, -0.05048544332385063, -0.045126285403966904, 0.014051053673028946, 0.04127012938261032, 0.022728081792593002, 0.04621472209692001, -0.02273186482489109, 0.07722718268632889, 0.023568570613861084, -0.033369746059179306, -0.015011033974587917, -0.018472593277692795, -0.011250622570514679, -0.029089152812957764, 0.027706477791070938, 0.001994780031964183, -0.005616188049316406, 0.025091366842389107, 0.017038047313690186, 0.013496045023202896, 0.07847732305526733, -0.015409189276397228, -0.027835780754685402, 0.0062011717818677425, 0.01324471365660429, -0.007360418792814016, 0.0334254615008831, 0.014812528155744076, -0.03096408024430275, -0.010711557231843472, -0.000214718995266594, 0.012650755234062672, 0.0073597920127213, -0.013054469600319862, -0.013373059220612049, -0.02452746219933033, 0.0019472502171993256, -0.04764537885785103, -0.013905075378715992, 0.03135206177830696, -0.027037208899855614, 0.02724885568022728, 0.024945974349975586, 0.021097080782055855, -0.036935996264219284, -0.03426387906074524, 0.05814584717154503, 0.037727899849414825, -0.022541455924510956, -0.039169926196336746, -0.003188098780810833, 0.008213874883949757, 0.03864071145653725, -0.0067893387749791145, -0.003282829187810421, 0.030205296352505684, 0.07319700717926025, 0.026903675869107246, 0.004792471881955862, -0.028499124571681023, 0.036956537514925, -0.028540469706058502, -0.006600973661988974, 0.004104742780327797, 0.07166449725627899, 0.004783319309353828, 0.0010177146177738905, 0.02699809893965721, -0.004124463070183992, 0.013356226496398449, 0.0031527813989669085, -0.046097300946712494, 0.014452106319367886, 0.024146126583218575, -0.033925071358680725, -0.0065672677010297775, -0.030240682885050774, 0.015302890911698341, -0.019635235890746117, -0.022206565365195274, -0.03438398614525795, -0.028123656287789345, -0.056511376053094864, 0.026879891753196716, 0.0027462539728730917, 0.02435913495719433, -0.004900246858596802, 0.048071831464767456, 0.04417167231440544, -0.016970984637737274, -0.007042143493890762, 0.018990375101566315, 0.02352084219455719, -0.005355759058147669, -0.006479811854660511, 0.013090671971440315, -0.010556738823652267, 0.047473981976509094, 0.01616213284432888, 0.04926734417676926, -0.06129404157400131, 0.0005165990442037582, -0.005381335970014334, 0.09154254198074341, 0.030634403228759766, -0.0315251499414444, -0.017933662980794907, -0.025613676756620407, -0.03324172645807266, -0.0010072881123051047, 0.0530608594417572, -0.00335783907212317, -0.0413493774831295, 0.03773687407374382, 0.03912258520722389, -0.1063552051782608, 0.022080590948462486, 0.09242076426744461, -0.012007125653326511, -0.010416409932076931, -0.033174630254507065, 0.0018246304243803024, 0.03037365712225437, -0.020186636596918106, 0.008264781907200813, 0.0060665784403681755, -0.01571536995470524, 0.018373960629105568, 0.032732050865888596, 0.003862256184220314, -0.015198325738310814, 0.013926989398896694, 0.01964687369763851, 0.03869110345840454, -0.0076826103031635284, 0.00394051568582654, -0.013052914291620255, 0.047940030694007874, 0.04511723667383194, 0.006757411640137434, -0.015430738218128681, -0.11719201505184174, 0.003057976486161351, 0.05507468059659004, -0.015972964465618134, -0.04159604385495186, -0.016295410692691803, -0.015301921404898167, 0.008283497765660286, 0.0575149804353714, -0.07408741116523743, 0.028677545487880707, -0.008166707120835781, 0.029430925846099854, -0.01853744499385357, 0.01147922221571207, -0.04035516083240509, 0.031550899147987366, -0.032007865607738495, 0.027195313945412636, -0.014207731932401657, -0.021460723131895065, -0.030750088393688202, 0.017590215429663658, 0.020288590341806412, 0.05327107757329941, -0.029307516291737556, -0.005700836423784494, -0.04050979018211365, 0.048147380352020264, -0.04351980239152908, -0.047582563012838364, -0.012790737673640251, -0.014405650086700916, 0.007405683398246765, 0.043964218348264694, -0.0029511370230466127, -0.04640811309218407, 0.06793395429849625, 0.04169674590229988, 0.0035965805873274803, -0.029654933139681816, -0.03801363706588745, 0.012633243575692177, 0.008370333351194859, 0.008437788113951683, 0.0553523413836956, -0.00441824970766902, 0.04407952353358269, -0.0009226143010891974, -0.016787495464086533, 0.022910788655281067, -0.051385749131441116, -0.053271662443876266, -0.017606675624847412, -0.014771988615393639, -0.01722525805234909, 0.034836526960134506, -0.009178590960800648, 0.030514581128954887, -0.029557587578892708, -0.0207670945674181, 0.0026038805954158306, 0.000010237788046651985, 0.011133680120110512, -0.030477097257971764, 0.004876479506492615, 0.03072075918316841, 0.00010178903175983578, 0.03488876298069954, -0.005945656914263964, -0.022035731002688408, 0.021430689841508865, -0.007884310558438301, -0.02455906942486763, 0.026297153905034065, -0.040028806775808334, -0.021139588207006454, 0.030342238023877144, -0.039023637771606445, 0.030600961297750473, -0.03616369143128395, 0.04717935621738434, -0.01633068546652794, -0.0569801963865757, -0.009726034477353096, 0.00922316312789917, -0.008130684494972229, 0.031239641830325127, -0.042806584388017654, 0.0388648621737957, 0.022178323939442635, -0.00266779912635684, -0.09251152724027634, -0.024903342127799988, 0.01796874962747097, -0.032779350876808167, -0.0043741315603256226, -0.040297430008649826, -0.009582821279764175, 0.0025405960623174906, -0.03581705689430237, 0.005911674816161394, 0.06875215470790863, -0.007409884128719568, -0.01921333372592926, -0.026583479717373848, -0.003873775014653802, 0.03597653657197952, 0.007806082721799612, 0.031868889927864075, 0.000010981520972563885, -0.02056189812719822, -0.0009891114896163344, 0.013486163690686226, 0.01673371158540249, -0.023240450769662857, -0.00923746544867754, -0.012115384452044964, -0.0034625327680259943, 0.0408506914973259, -0.004362074658274651, -0.012650699354708195, 0.012169202789664268, 0.018584800884127617, 0.005050722975283861, -0.03916962444782257, 0.0009527194197289646, 0.03254494443535805, -0.016224827617406845, -0.04861393943428993, 0.005663927644491196, -0.023725954815745354, -0.015532257035374641, 0.025838464498519897, 0.0017977975076064467, -0.0050949035212397575, 0.010553558357059956, 0.06608406454324722, -0.023157330229878426, 0.002416021889075637, 0.015888294205069542, -0.04130958765745163, 0.0024721724912524223, 0.0017546419985592365, -0.005403561517596245, 0.013715611770749092, 0.01348904799669981, -0.014433389529585838, -0.011913103982806206, -0.029946673661470413, 0.01727677322924137, 0.047205664217472076, 0.014976044185459614, 0.06081584095954895, 0.07119245827198029, 0.017009863629937172, 0.008977975696325302, -0.010312758386135101, -0.017983468249440193, 0.00684445071965456, -0.005034401547163725, 0.08250465989112854, -0.015308277681469917, 0.012601478956639767, 0.00047215798986144364, 0.009221565909683704, 0.040344204753637314, 0.05932135134935379, -0.02278852090239525, 0.04138123244047165, 0.020251374691724777, 0.019037028774619102, -0.0435117743909359, -0.017463264986872673, -0.01523294486105442, 0.007054752204567194, -0.02817009761929512, -0.023835206404328346, 0.03654931113123894, 0.01144586130976677, 0.0006047285278327763, -0.06068912521004677, -0.032757971435785294, -0.09146798402070999, 0.02923208847641945, 0.0032107557635754347, 0.014242256060242653, 0.009559041820466518, 0.04160071909427643, 0.02659875899553299, -0.012594105675816536, 0.01438954845070839, -0.0391671359539032, -0.06691377609968185, -0.07037962973117828, -0.046768464148044586, -0.04084241762757301, -0.0007135492051020265, 0.017755750566720963, -0.019049422815442085, 0.01983685791492462, 0.0014920771354809403, 0.09430880844593048, -0.01451828796416521, 0.051213592290878296, 0.0013728048652410507, 0.04359547048807144, 0.008862903341650963, 0.06534948199987411, -0.0036970265209674835, 0.035371776670217514, 0.14649078249931335, 0.06866420805454254, 0.07517034560441971, -0.06404430419206619, 0.010212644934654236, 0.010694582015275955, -0.03994446620345116, -0.030842632055282593, 0.015147212892770767, -0.008469401858747005, -0.010751316323876381, 0.016020208597183228, 0.015175334177911282, 0.025614842772483826, 0.015004302375018597, 0.07646775990724564, 0.004435839597135782, 0.007305574603378773, 0.024440059438347816, 0.011627430096268654, 0.0021962770260870457, -0.003939473070204258, -0.07472046464681625, 0.05747152492403984, 0.004100647754967213, -0.01081660483032465, -0.029488541185855865, -0.020916810259222984, 0.008657360449433327, -0.0013116617919877172, -0.004140682518482208, 0.0000549392934772186, 0.01169737707823515, 0.008090774528682232, 0.022082338109612465, -0.03976774960756302, 0.01236744038760662, -0.031709443777799606, 0.004281834699213505, 0.021422522142529488, 0.052425820380449295, -0.0058804284781217575, -0.020195012912154198, 0.02141597680747509, -0.029126029461622238, 0.010580024681985378, -0.026816843077540398, 0.020127518102526665, -0.02485421672463417, -0.026033150032162666, 0.00260320957750082, 0.0045288302935659885, 0.014980603940784931, -0.040884003043174744, -0.03555308282375336, 0.019913138821721077, 0.004211323335766792, -0.002026414033025503, -0.035110265016555786, -0.03827456012368202, 0.029665281996130943, -0.03216097503900528, 0.00297943945042789, -0.05763505771756172, -0.03296646103262901, -0.013691811822354794, 0.0046715992502868176, -0.008785899728536606, 0.0055470652878284454, -0.01636119745671749, 0.02038390561938286, -0.029021650552749634, 0.005056362133473158, -0.009726671501994133, -0.012642845511436462, 0.020627090707421303, -0.008460363373160362, -0.0047495197504758835, -0.04964720085263252, -0.024150259792804718, -0.020591121166944504, -0.006886808667331934, -0.02382269687950611, 0.01521114632487297, -0.01624530367553234, 0.021771345287561417, 0.008787648752331734, 0.04590196534991264, 0.022256622090935707, -0.011325894854962826, 0.015231653116643429, 0.01548507995903492, -0.011247157119214535, -0.034194767475128174, -0.021860182285308838, -0.03442475199699402, -0.04400814697146416, 0.028714332729578018, -0.03659053519368172, 0.07945826649665833, 0.010312536731362343, -0.03703748807311058, -0.011635537259280682, 0.02509445510804653, -0.014604602940380573, 0.025008942931890488, -0.009195622056722641, -0.06932193785905838, 0.006509906146675348, -0.0025716316886246204, -0.004360489547252655, -0.053695738315582275, 0.00982084684073925, -0.048608552664518356, -0.03222361207008362, 0.009757806546986103, -0.02462334744632244, -0.04440563917160034, 0.007591087371110916, -0.01567336916923523, 0.008357211947441101, -0.025481168180704117, -0.01341735664755106, -0.01632208377122879, -0.022493800148367882, -0.046351030468940735, -0.010894406586885452, -0.003314952366054058, 0.004862157627940178, -0.02181275002658367, 0.004680043086409569, 0.056624386459589005, 0.023834215477108955, 0.037635836750268936, 0.029224252328276634, 0.0614452064037323, -0.006642213091254234, 0.01910330355167389, -0.015850462019443512, 0.01773296482861042, 0.03898831084370613, -0.044403284788131714, -0.03496319428086281, 0.008560196496546268, -0.016070367768406868, 0.03441856801509857, 0.05852557346224785, -0.02052723802626133, 0.007793079596012831, 0.0604080893099308, -0.022051826119422913, 0.006397228688001633, -0.014414775185286999, -0.031025098636746407, -0.01860041543841362, -0.0161270909011364, 0.0020388818811625242, 0.011369054205715656, -0.032470639795064926, 0.027486536651849747, 0.036119237542152405, 0.03549643233418465, -0.06451795250177383, 0.007308846339583397, -0.0005643339827656746, 0.04075167328119278, 0.009426945820450783, -0.02659071981906891, 0.06740462779998779, 0.033232685178518295, -0.017880605533719063, 0.026157941669225693, -0.03131129592657089, -0.0003519306774251163, -0.0657537430524826, -0.042339954525232315, -0.004900861065834761, -0.0020926762372255325, 0.0387696735560894, -0.03114961087703705, 0.004893864039331675, 0.017349762842059135, -0.015747172757983208, -0.005550657864660025, -0.008458374068140984, -0.026810768991708755, -0.05549590662121773, 0.02290971763432026, -0.04594935476779938, -0.018535533919930458, 0.016612045466899872, -0.029586171731352806, 0.029844028875231743, 0.017462989315390587, 0.005839053075760603, -0.018918076530098915, -0.029264114797115326, -0.027305126190185547, 0.01112295314669609, -0.06560397893190384, 0.005782977677881718, -0.033185284584760666, -0.022015199065208435, 0.024376560002565384, -0.04386194795370102, 0.005261298269033432, 0.08225306123495102, 0.043650317937135696, -0.0013681582640856504, 0.04656129330396652, 0.007786646485328674, -0.008122865110635757, 0.02834925800561905, 0.021078266203403473, 0.0013719761045649648, 0.000453107466455549, 0.028675226494669914, -0.008534354157745838, 0.036225106567144394, -0.012581168673932552, 0.008719821460545063, 0.02522619254887104, -0.015304317697882652, -0.04729265719652176, -0.04079127311706543, 0.011839945800602436, 0.0021163544151932, -0.042387012392282486, 0.013837771490216255, -0.030906328931450844, 0.031017154455184937, 0.03948269784450531, -0.0074218446388840675, -0.03621430695056915, -0.01903809979557991, -0.021157272160053253, -0.05935099720954895, -0.01963006891310215, 0.00913769006729126, -0.022789061069488525, -0.03652186319231987, 0.031873103231191635, 0.033799536526203156, -0.04066205769777298, -0.005170194897800684, -0.023242712020874023, 0.013360127806663513, 0.028926905244588852, -0.04453609883785248, 0.04115946963429451, -0.006424334365874529, 0.019732065498828888, 0.020559119060635567, -0.06063549220561981, 0.07427459955215454, 0.005497022997587919, -0.01524428278207779, -0.018983744084835052, -0.007655832450836897, -0.04253755509853363, 0.015946069732308388, 0.01601622998714447, -0.007783263921737671, 0.026802729815244675, -0.026388004422187805, 0.018787598237395287, 0.005560330580919981, -0.03253333270549774, 0.008296022191643715, -0.013059200718998909, -0.0653722733259201, 0.012577115558087826, -0.018915852531790733, 0.008953523822128773, -0.009742439724504948, 0.005233277101069689, -0.007215588819235563, -0.0360615998506546, 0.012696610763669014, -0.010216793976724148, -0.03168262541294098, -0.0008317551692016423, 0.03279871493577957, 0.00014070879842620343, -0.030772250145673752, 0.004537758883088827, -0.009497557766735554, 0.0025984682142734528, -0.03638659790158272, -0.007031574845314026, -0.07240742444992065, -0.024616751819849014, -0.02730417810380459, -0.00477554090321064, 0.019108271226286888, -0.03570963814854622, -0.023031452670693398, 0.008429786190390587, -0.026573164388537407, 0.046991411596536636, 0.045319803059101105, -0.01448387186974287, 0.02620725706219673, 0.0016059785848483443, 0.031905196607112885, -0.011046318337321281, -0.0073942383751273155, 0.03572359308600426, 0.029654236510396004, -0.029422074556350708, 0.021457696333527565, -0.014749323017895222, 0.00946955569088459, 0.025617411360144615, 0.052082084119319916, -0.005487937014549971, 0.026825645938515663, -0.00820435956120491, -0.019637862220406532, -0.02132190577685833, -0.019515180960297585, 0.02500167302787304, 0.004836347419768572, -0.010478607378900051, 0.04042676463723183, -0.03547381982207298, 0.002784665673971176, -0.07122694700956345, -0.03210847079753876, -0.0376126654446125, 0.021960681304335594, 0.01479328516870737, 0.06992819160223007, -0.013293067924678326, -0.01112285815179348, 0.016733475029468536, -0.003260326338931918, 0.03213800862431526, -0.035507384687662125, 0.05278557911515236, -0.008386358618736267, -0.007784505374729633, 0.005349283572286367, -0.0030422918498516083, -0.03835563361644745, -0.03020641952753067, -0.01258043386042118, 0.06291832029819489, 0.07166249305009842, -0.011937256902456284, -0.05129433795809746, -0.018616510555148125, 0.004576169420033693, -0.032140471041202545, -0.033191487193107605, -0.04116521775722504, 0.012067290022969246, -0.0033954933751374483, -0.021953396499156952 ]
<p>Suppose that the sample space S of some experiment is finite. Show that the collection of all subsets of S satisfies the three conditions required to be called the collection of events:</p> <ol> <li>$S \in \beta $</li> <li>$ if \; A \in \beta, \; A^\complement\in\beta$</li> <li>$if A_{1},A_{2},\cdots,A_{n}\in\beta,\; A_{1}\cup A_{2}\cdots\cup A_{n}\in\beta$</li> </ol> <p>How can I proove axioms above? I.e., how can I show that the collection of all subsets of S satisfies the three conditions required to be called the collection of events.</p> <p>A detailed explanation with Borel field and its full proof will do help me improve my statistical insight and skills.</p>
43,009
[ -0.02730727195739746, -0.018128253519535065, -0.004661502782255411, 0.015137474052608013, 0.013953265734016895, 0.0054830689914524555, 0.011755842715501785, 0.01576423831284046, 0.013387663289904594, -0.004497184418141842, 0.037059586495161057, -0.01733887381851673, 0.021024160087108612, 0.028013262897729874, -0.01167381089180708, -0.004197091329842806, -0.028052639216184616, -0.01764691062271595, -0.02528645470738411, -0.0038846947718411684, 0.005528301000595093, 0.03324002027511597, -0.0031974753364920616, -0.008118202909827232, -0.05478585883975029, 0.03970376402139664, 0.003976631443947554, 0.003363748313859105, -0.0011875240597873926, 0.0646132305264473, -0.04241045191884041, -0.06503630429506302, 0.00910085067152977, 0.02131342701613903, 0.028795510530471802, -0.004290169570595026, -0.03397395834326744, 0.0025487185921519995, 0.046132054179906845, -0.014710651710629463, -0.05251725763082504, -0.004724759142845869, -0.0323450043797493, 0.007717628963291645, -0.034884966909885406, -0.016387080773711205, 0.001069086603820324, -0.007460964843630791, 0.0005448326119221747, -0.04175560176372528, 0.06983969360589981, -0.000006413200480892556, 0.07436112314462662, 0.030246689915657043, 0.004978677723556757, -0.024841200560331345, 0.002319276798516512, 0.076055608689785, 0.0063316710293293, -0.0193952564150095, -0.013324841856956482, -0.039308127015829086, 0.029635803773999214, -0.032702669501304626, -0.0688401609659195, 0.05064235255122185, 0.02094365656375885, 0.018022064119577408, 0.013944629579782486, 0.008399703539907932, 0.02698361873626709, 0.011330648325383663, 0.03193435072898865, 0.04513569548726082, -0.013242035172879696, 0.0066503784619271755, 0.00722237303853035, 0.003146206261590123, 0.04708219692111015, 0.022258052602410316, -0.0021517314016819, 0.05360478162765503, 0.004220924340188503, 0.009498882107436657, 0.05504075810313225, -0.07162444293498993, 0.07151670008897781, -0.03849363699555397, -0.003661508671939373, -0.023856230080127716, -0.011019369587302208, -0.016377532854676247, 0.029081149026751518, 0.0035255702678114176, -0.04669928550720215, 0.03564707189798355, -0.05305350944399834, 0.05453411862254143, -0.01918419823050499, -0.0006035320111550391, -0.0007021193741820753, -0.05557408183813095, 0.029215695336461067, 0.08673107624053955, -0.022890837863087654, -0.006078547332435846, -0.042526233941316605, 0.023348715156316757, -0.024988345801830292, 0.01110581960529089, -0.028009064495563507, 0.06222743168473244, -0.018238529562950134, 0.07071501761674881, 0.0015068213688209653, -0.0027267199475318193, 0.009841855615377426, 0.00016931831487454474, 0.039904821664094925, 0.0721590593457222, 0.04246469587087631, -0.012847312726080418, 0.01294686459004879, -0.005860387813299894, -0.0848412960767746, 0.0415019690990448, -0.01153901219367981, -0.009154800325632095, -0.009873706847429276, 0.03207382187247276, 0.013464073650538921, -0.03517947718501091, 0.004043282475322485, 0.012077213265001774, 0.023311305791139603, -0.01979091390967369, -0.08403730392456055, -0.022852879017591476, 0.0238405242562294, 0.004172495100647211, -0.04831094667315483, -0.06433422118425369, 0.012216199189424515, 0.03648335114121437, 0.05615059658885002, -0.0355558805167675, 0.018038270995020866, 0.03295305371284485, 0.01599181815981865, 0.02990853786468506, -0.06357266008853912, -0.010509729385375977, -0.03338630497455597, 0.0021548455115407705, -0.045069992542266846, -0.03408027067780495, 0.06755902618169785, 0.00813690572977066, 0.013048735447227955, -0.024127451702952385, 0.0187058188021183, -0.013317839242517948, -0.026637371629476547, -0.0235894862562418, 0.00772346556186676, -0.023990284651517868, 0.05158732458949089, -0.009813937358558178, 0.03058963641524315, 0.016543149948120117, 0.005163724534213543, 0.018856758251786232, -0.01889663003385067, 0.045132096856832504, 0.06279093027114868, -0.01862681284546852, -0.002762857126072049, -0.0008300206973217428, 0.008143289014697075, 0.037840336561203, -0.0016115506878122687, 0.013114840723574162, -0.04956397786736488, 0.022368790581822395, 0.016739800572395325, 0.027515308931469917, 0.03304167836904526, -0.050390079617500305, 0.03517530485987663, -0.04440184682607651, -0.044680118560791016, -0.11751861125230789, 0.032227568328380585, -0.05265755578875542, -0.0260397270321846, 0.01256685983389616, 0.010030207224190235, -0.02462061308324337, -0.026091650128364563, -0.029333705082535744, -0.024187922477722168, 0.02609073929488659, 0.020996302366256714, -0.03081645630300045, 0.004591106902807951, 0.046507712453603745, 0.08862338960170746, -0.022949853911995888, 0.04389519244432449, -0.005206211935728788, -0.00007595397619297728, -0.005554406438022852, -0.009512764401733875, -0.0004941120860166848, -0.013546762987971306, 0.002789232647046447, 0.017167193815112114, 0.011698673479259014, -0.01996784098446369, 0.04896154627203941, -0.05982111394405365, 0.05559553951025009, 0.04789026826620102, -0.00045126370969228446, 0.03473256900906563, -0.015708472579717636, 0.023370664566755295, 0.012728833593428135, 0.0028349929489195347, 0.01462628599256277, -0.043296121060848236, -0.02030717208981514, 0.014511563815176487, 0.030980482697486877, -0.011191083118319511, 0.013325641863048077, 0.024525156244635582, 0.00789488386362791, -0.02799219638109207, 0.025546738877892494, 0.011297772638499737, 0.025747211650013924, -0.015871703624725342, -0.013664806261658669, 0.038888394832611084, -0.021933795884251595, -0.04101794958114624, -0.01636791042983532, 0.014604429714381695, -0.025867152959108353, -0.0012011573417112231, 0.033457498997449875, -0.010537346825003624, -0.023627806454896927, -0.024194130674004555, -0.01812104508280754, 0.010815861634910107, -0.012312798760831356, 0.007230265066027641, 0.01070275716483593, 0.018087146803736687, 0.013596853241324425, 0.013270063325762749, -0.007696664892137051, 0.0322689414024353, -0.0012325135758146644, -0.0035074930638074875, -0.03293405473232269, 0.029014740139245987, -0.05876348912715912, 0.005680962465703487, 0.006550945807248354, -0.044475700706243515, -0.002619194332510233, -0.002865467220544815, 0.0149907311424613, -0.01302308589220047, 0.02445913664996624, -0.032924141734838486, 0.008389796130359173, -0.007435510400682688, 0.014483144506812096, 0.05189870297908783, 0.0320189967751503, -0.05956335738301277, -0.0060070836916565895, -0.05310911685228348, -0.0048029785975813866, 0.008113004267215729, 0.008856484666466713, -0.023433905094861984, 0.022033721208572388, 0.009100563824176788, -0.04697495698928833, 0.018856920301914215, -0.00426086550578475, 0.016887247562408447, -0.037583623081445694, 0.019580554217100143, 0.08262087404727936, 0.0612366758286953, -0.04987757280468941, -0.014381367713212967, -0.0070524439215660095, -0.01687573455274105, -0.0215789545327425, -0.03356350213289261, 0.017682716250419617, -0.029826031997799873, 0.028080236166715622, 0.028196554630994797, -0.016797849908471107, 0.0011074537178501487, -0.05329207330942154, -0.0798102468252182, -0.02184721827507019, -0.005357574205845594, 0.027428042143583298, 0.009952867403626442, -0.04893523082137108, 0.04602992534637451, 0.07705501466989517, -0.053074441850185394, -0.0010754985269159079, -0.008028544485569, -0.005186461377888918, -0.047285232692956924, 0.04326106607913971, -0.010096754878759384, -0.01455152127891779, 0.049745477735996246, 0.018270540982484818, 0.014317560009658337, 0.021351130679249763, 0.00351881911046803, 0.0035366031806916, -0.01261452678591013, 0.007479428313672543, 0.03381224721670151, 0.04073255509138107, 0.029431689530611038, -0.025339161977171898, 0.011353252455592155, -0.025991205126047134, 0.03282111883163452, 0.045104123651981354, -0.046553194522857666, -0.005974982399493456, -0.006844799499958754, -0.00219350284896791, -0.005013963673263788, 0.05452277511358261, 0.007297230884432793, -0.0298023484647274, 0.01931651122868061, 0.023785488680005074, -0.011355680413544178, -0.02309536375105381, 0.009967084042727947, 0.03483930230140686, 0.04499046131968498, -0.07909299433231354, -0.033632248640060425, -0.04687783122062683, -0.03287702053785324, 0.003239560406655073, -0.019859684631228447, -0.020383354276418686, 0.03431176766753197, 0.041370343416929245, 0.0027237311005592346, 0.01807696372270584, -0.024805931374430656, -0.034359484910964966, -0.03957495838403702, -0.005760088097304106, -0.017385464161634445, 0.025445599108934402, -0.016500849276781082, 0.06718060374259949, -0.0030996487475931644, -0.03307393938302994, 0.00308858510106802, -0.004277910105884075, -0.05717626214027405, -0.006766191683709621, -0.0000026647978756955126, -0.003253709990531206, -0.003126842202618718, -0.003561037126928568, 0.07994686812162399, -0.0009731772006489336, 0.0057942066341638565, -0.0397908017039299, -0.036064937710762024, -0.04315030202269554, -0.009959149174392223, -0.06392960250377655, -0.017679506912827492, 0.024963581934571266, 0.05111585929989815, 0.07488173246383667, 0.00829632394015789, 0.025596903637051582, 0.018442027270793915, 0.0026789812836796045, -0.0057708099484443665, 0.010286830365657806, 0.053483281284570694, 0.025614241138100624, 0.05560332536697388, 0.011572645977139473, 0.03198368102312088, -0.013048863038420677, -0.00008253037958638743, 0.0021998928859829903, 0.03048214316368103, 0.030649960041046143, -0.014969004318118095, -0.036186330020427704, -0.03685829043388367, -0.03760053589940071, 0.03178409859538078, 0.034125834703445435, 0.04551343619823456, -0.006838637869805098, 0.060200612992048264, 0.027365928515791893, -0.041702304035425186, 0.02653338387608528, 0.035309866070747375, 0.0067902724258601665, -0.014727847650647163, 0.01327812485396862, -0.004091318696737289, -0.008900592103600502, -0.009323276579380035, -0.013122566044330597, 0.004959103185683489, 0.00948414672166109, 0.027025142684578896, 0.02164267748594284, -0.042425233870744705, -0.053781840950250626, 0.03480847179889679, -0.007633347995579243, 0.018178217113018036, 0.02380543015897274, -0.06815916299819946, 0.03881470113992691, 0.06169410049915314, 0.01780647225677967, 0.029751230031251907, -0.0037310104817152023, -0.028719672933220863, 0.025766313076019287, 0.02531254105269909, 0.02080083079636097, 0.0014984781155362725, -0.016565250232815742, -0.03511877357959747, -0.01894627884030342, 0.021256165578961372, -0.09127140045166016, 0.026284517720341682, -0.02345353737473488, 0.0014975644880905747, -0.037443529814481735, -0.03390415757894516, -0.06235608458518982, 0.03215998038649559, 0.004380245693027973, 0.025771871209144592, -0.01836651936173439, -0.005322075914591551, -0.009644117206335068, -0.024371810257434845, 0.016461677849292755, 0.014655755832791328, -0.01012516301125288, 0.0101725272834301, -0.027948910370469093, 0.0026097875088453293, -0.04717615619301796, -0.048013925552368164, 0.041777439415454865, 0.024740619584918022, 0.00042319539352320135, 0.019046669825911522, -0.028165645897388458, -0.0389246791601181, -0.011020282283425331, 0.02740069106221199, -0.02958524040877819, 0.03236681967973709, -0.05060458928346634, 0.04906828701496124, 0.06365849077701569, 0.03404999151825905, 0.056586187332868576, 0.00239023775793612, 0.030756577849388123, 0.011935118585824966, 0.0054512834176421165, -0.013599314726889133, -0.027074133977293968, -0.008780023083090782, -0.045957185328006744, -0.018218837678432465, -0.0366232804954052, 0.02799929678440094, -0.04232768714427948, -0.008493861183524132, 0.009788144379854202, -0.02094070240855217, 0.005532992072403431, -0.0007578031509183347, -0.001398219377733767, -0.0017058852827176452, -0.009279577992856503, 0.02296237088739872, 0.041956569999456406, 0.004128387197852135, 0.04784948378801346, 0.0005270388792268932, 0.03634075075387955, 0.005888437852263451, -0.011821474879980087, 0.060151174664497375, -0.08327655494213104, -0.01022132858633995, -0.038501985371112823, -0.025235380977392197, 0.03786078095436096, -0.020915884524583817, 0.023023121058940887, 0.010938078165054321, -0.03533894941210747, -0.05649541690945625, 0.03555944934487343, 0.010377515107393265, -0.007372845429927111, -0.0719689205288887, 0.018133671954274178, 0.05615221709012985, 0.010144909843802452, -0.09058026224374771, -0.04039117693901062, -0.004522919654846191, 0.012988549657166004, -0.005643719341605902, -0.04463614895939827, -0.030968613922595978, 0.013306891545653343, -0.04270866885781288, -0.018824182450771332, 0.03665155917406082, -0.030055679380893707, -0.01849387027323246, 0.01758544147014618, 0.006555302068591118, 0.05462847277522087, 0.017505094408988953, 0.02128760702908039, 0.02475396730005741, -0.013072769157588482, -0.012124592438340187, 0.010597148910164833, 0.00931761134415865, -0.0190312247723341, -0.035628680139780045, -0.01229130383580923, 0.0031043551862239838, 0.012369777075946331, 0.0007802853360772133, -0.0396132729947567, -0.007956136018037796, -0.01623069867491722, -0.022204145789146423, -0.022828642278909683, -0.038744620978832245, 0.0304572694003582, -0.003213971620425582, -0.008355778641998768, -0.013793428428471088, 0.016999714076519012, -0.015062781982123852, 0.01584455370903015, -0.005181117914617062, -0.04344416782259941, 0.011223158799111843, 0.043399661779403687, 0.0026523242704570293, 0.029362443834543228, 0.013149721547961235, 0.0077122533693909645, 0.025325799360871315, -0.03288476914167404, 0.021233145147562027, -0.019902057945728302, 0.01128162071108818, -0.05122345685958862, 0.012689000926911831, -0.05894513055682182, 0.040435828268527985, 0.02677367441356182, -0.006571514997631311, 0.014100245200097561, 0.08185481280088425, 0.0077802445739507675, -0.006328472401946783, -0.03272872418165207, 0.028879236429929733, -0.008277790620923042, 0.03113257698714733, 0.04007609188556671, -0.030266636982560158, -0.01600826345384121, 0.03030780516564846, 0.02462310716509819, -0.03819667920470238, -0.00023316076840274036, 0.015742028132081032, 0.008817896246910095, 0.00897160079330206, -0.019360685721039772, -0.04395725950598717, 0.03682481870055199, -0.054803233593702316, -0.010662568733096123, 0.023952575400471687, -0.02285788021981716, 0.02081499807536602, 0.03203347325325012, 0.008465705439448357, -0.04923588037490845, -0.0402320958673954, -0.06823037564754486, 0.008867328055202961, 0.010501119308173656, 0.010365246795117855, 0.039508990943431854, -0.021953636780381203, 0.036126889288425446, -0.022801164537668228, 0.010221305303275585, -0.007669439539313316, -0.0386594794690609, -0.006995707284659147, -0.07645195722579956, -0.04602530971169472, 0.03569073975086212, -0.03058805875480175, -0.010696394369006157, -0.04925873130559921, -0.012134363874793053, 0.021909961476922035, 0.04852720722556114, 0.03598875552415848, -0.0037737414240837097, 0.058166708797216415, 0.019569862633943558, 0.051349904388189316, -0.005400887690484524, 0.005928457248955965, 0.10428708791732788, 0.059121448546648026, 0.01869327761232853, -0.07703991234302521, 0.017159562557935715, 0.018665997311472893, -0.03135884553194046, -0.0016427395166829228, 0.01158065814524889, -0.001958138309419155, 0.009528695605695248, 0.012403479777276516, 0.04940641298890114, -0.001998292049393058, -0.010504349134862423, 0.03673997148871422, -0.048461366444826126, -0.027839522808790207, 0.006573415827006102, 0.011133936233818531, -0.01644728146493435, 0.005344838369637728, -0.07606594264507294, 0.0022789952345192432, 0.04372924193739891, -0.01837998628616333, 0.01630622148513794, -0.028059491887688637, 0.030195876955986023, 0.00974664930254221, 0.03782963007688522, -0.013795421458780766, 0.04928863048553467, -0.014787537045776844, -0.024083707481622696, -0.03229575976729393, 0.012795686721801758, -0.02925434522330761, 0.027350308373570442, 0.011079196818172932, 0.035087622702121735, 0.005211834795773029, 0.02413463406264782, 0.04385565593838692, -0.056588176637887955, -0.03387024253606796, -0.01711953803896904, 0.022586314007639885, -0.02923314832150936, -0.029807666316628456, -0.03384195268154144, -0.0038474230095744133, -0.0009912429377436638, -0.028632784262299538, -0.019518081098794937, 0.0005858066724613309, 0.010733751580119133, -0.022706113755702972, -0.04255857318639755, -0.018291324377059937, 0.01509155984967947, -0.007803339045494795, 0.024896232411265373, -0.01254267618060112, -0.032500796020030975, 0.0017691870452836156, -0.01173893641680479, -0.014608011581003666, 0.028511829674243927, 0.024217428639531136, -0.012083344161510468, -0.017280446365475655, -0.035175830125808716, -0.013433324173092842, 0.013837308622896671, -0.022975193336606026, 0.02013287879526615, 0.013255903497338295, 0.014870795421302319, -0.000030385843274416402, -0.02139187604188919, -0.004528312012553215, -0.05830678343772888, -0.0003973318380303681, -0.03722710162401199, -0.005291469395160675, -0.03429305925965309, 0.05311379209160805, 0.00458865612745285, -0.015011071227490902, 0.0025396139826625586, 0.07831829786300659, 0.048849862068891525, -0.04607785493135452, 0.0019810539670288563, 0.022039925679564476, -0.05529848858714104, -0.009856588207185268, 0.003728495677933097, 0.08858597278594971, 0.03444082662463188, 0.04905249550938606, 0.03640805184841156, 0.029841648414731026, -0.0006854254752397537, -0.0037908488884568214, -0.005810133181512356, -0.016279837116599083, -0.01069935504347086, 0.06859173625707626, 0.03575059771537781, -0.035950951278209686, -0.0677153691649437, 0.017842426896095276, 0.029922032728791237, 0.02887566015124321, -0.05956558883190155, -0.045735374093055725, 0.00415722094476223, -0.012791425921022892, 0.027458306401968002, -0.035543881356716156, 0.04455883800983429, -0.0149620296433568, -0.004193321336060762, -0.009786020964384079, 0.020457439124584198, -0.009001479484140873, 0.0014138827100396156, -0.04074779152870178, -0.03326592594385147, 0.05229239910840988, -0.006503437180072069, -0.022677065804600716, -0.019314365461468697, 0.023503076285123825, 0.028979653492569923, 0.019021982327103615, 0.004976893309503794, 0.017341790720820427, 0.04287207871675491, -0.05122669041156769, 0.0023039670195430517, 0.03365382179617882, 0.011932057328522205, 0.05880244821310043, 0.028249986469745636, 0.004376806318759918, -0.001983490539714694, 0.0023873760364949703, -0.028950383886694908, -0.024195047095417976, -0.010302716866135597, 0.0023033020552247763, 0.03294581547379494, 0.020540663972496986, 0.033527497202157974, 0.03115176595747471, -0.016464222222566605, 0.00317364395596087, 0.025981461629271507, -0.0013486068928614259, -0.05321846529841423, -0.010803629644215107, -0.013229893520474434, -0.001981747569516301, -0.017016641795635223, -0.010412330739200115, -0.0191599540412426, 0.05142413452267647, -0.056057557463645935, 0.05038449168205261, -0.002708869520574808, -0.0021913694217801094, -0.06864548474550247, -0.029433006420731544, 0.03119293600320816, 0.010807528160512447, 0.057779353111982346, -0.04382549226284027, 0.04112262651324272, 0.04113016650080681, -0.025907810777425766, -0.009746863506734371, -0.01329740509390831, 0.007311892695724964, -0.054072365164756775, 0.01633150689303875, -0.030477510765194893, 0.030675413087010384, -0.0023381898645311594, 0.040877606719732285, 0.02019359916448593, 0.03230392187833786, -0.0012290742015466094, -0.032641809433698654, -0.00871040765196085, 0.030225243419408798, 0.028468264266848564, -0.03224598988890648, 0.0449674092233181, -0.00931108370423317, -0.02694280445575714, 0.025230830535292625, 0.012590613216161728, -0.030351033434271812, 0.05259845405817032, 0.02736918069422245, 0.016835592687129974, 0.025404341518878937, 0.028538046404719353, 0.013537338934838772, 0.01969924196600914, 0.022246191278100014, 0.011408340185880661, 0.034815624356269836, -0.019310032948851585, -0.03901480510830879, 0.047610968351364136, -0.032868217676877975, -0.021815931424498558, 0.0018819101387634873, 0.023957237601280212, -0.009112482890486717, 0.013934001326560974, -0.026766713708639145, -0.008640198037028313, -0.007737223990261555, -0.02978271245956421, -0.01613226905465126, -0.01284110825508833, 0.020854519680142403, 0.02706400863826275, -0.00442036148160696, -0.006729480344802141, -0.02029358595609665, -0.061325762420892715, 0.011559604667127132, 0.03770437836647034, -0.020456520840525627, -0.02690816856920719, -0.010217617265880108, 0.03838016837835312, 0.01615377888083458, 0.004556958097964525, -0.02044396847486496, -0.008585277013480663, 0.0375891737639904, -0.014232886023819447, 0.008184723556041718, -0.02430734783411026, -0.0033027874305844307, 0.006427235435694456, -0.06546460837125778, 0.04719770699739456, 0.02647472359240055, 0.022275665774941444, -0.04672444984316826, 0.04865790903568268, -0.016877533867955208, 0.0042708395048975945, 0.030221790075302124, 0.012616879306733608, 0.018093792721629143, 0.010057806968688965, 0.013711313717067242, 0.030399296432733536, -0.04390721768140793, 0.020533950999379158, -0.0373220257461071, 0.01070351805537939, -0.013300364837050438, -0.01336643286049366, 0.000322023086482659, 0.005091927945613861, 0.00796129647642374, 0.00021545962954405695, 0.019540555775165558, 0.01130201667547226, -0.03501313924789429, 0.030879050493240356, -0.004561467096209526, 0.00966228824108839, 0.0410737544298172, -0.027282653376460075, -0.007881500758230686, 0.008491489104926586, -0.03524370864033699, -0.02070167474448681, 0.026168253272771835, -0.03183024376630783, -0.001345499767921865, -0.010174250230193138, -0.020243247970938683, 0.00258302828297019, -0.049234189093112946, -0.012834646739065647, 0.009718811139464378, -0.003850802779197693, -0.019395291805267334, 0.04014671966433525, 0.016813302412629128, 0.06370815634727478, -0.02863715961575508, 0.008462022058665752, -0.015133479610085487, -0.02013481967151165, -0.007016987539827824, 0.022121738642454147, 0.028646521270275116, -0.014969505369663239, 0.006949377711862326, 0.0601903535425663, 0.022929856553673744, 0.0178749468177557, 0.033930253237485886, 0.04907327517867088, -0.006424187682569027, -0.030655913054943085, 0.008773029781877995, -0.023540426045656204, 0.02508796565234661, -0.021025316789746284, 0.01015381794422865, 0.07863421738147736, -0.03915788233280182, 0.006483636796474457, -0.023493288084864616, -0.003063738811761141, -0.05125164985656738, -0.00844107661396265, -0.004722141195088625, 0.007285512983798981, -0.03041846677660942, 0.02692222222685814, -0.021851133555173874, -0.0005361298681236804, 0.018920425325632095, 0.001373204286210239, 0.02330121025443077, -0.0006993858842179179, -0.016297202557325363, 0.013354992493987083, 0.008232485502958298, 0.027551183477044106, -0.006258859299123287, -0.0004006389353889972, 0.026761509478092194, -0.021217476576566696, 0.013574023731052876, -0.013369360938668251, -0.022076841443777084, 0.061690445989370346, -0.04357416555285454, -0.017328640446066856, -0.07961950451135635, 0.03156480938196182, -0.015237544663250446, -0.003578337375074625 ]
<p>In many financial models we are interested in measuring the correlation between variables, returns etc. However, research shows that during crises times we observe "Correlation Breaks" where previously un-correlated variables become correlated.</p> <p>What is the best way to quantify "stability of correlation" by examining the historic time series of the variables on which I am interested?</p> <p>Would some kind of bootstrapping be a good way to start examining the sample distribution of the correlation? Is there any other method that I could apply?</p>
37,407
[ -0.016205893829464912, 0.007873665541410446, 0.028660593554377556, -0.005567024927586317, 0.04342508688569069, 0.009434323757886887, -0.012169511057436466, -0.02059684880077839, 0.06826523691415787, -0.03850476071238518, 0.04568351060152054, 0.04261941835284233, 0.037207771092653275, 0.02803465910255909, 0.010411788709461689, -0.03764847666025162, -0.011494277976453304, -0.023674365133047104, 0.02116672694683075, -0.010706882923841476, 0.0032450936269015074, 0.03378770872950554, -0.01846780814230442, 0.015026996843516827, -0.018937718123197556, 0.029198825359344482, 0.0013836377765983343, -0.016467496752738953, 0.02989014983177185, 0.0536554753780365, -0.05614476278424263, 0.0016941794892773032, 0.015281050466001034, 0.0696219876408577, 0.002261676825582981, -0.012818794697523117, 0.0034236321225762367, -0.06073443219065666, -0.009623642079532146, 0.030838992446660995, -0.059907060116529465, -0.04172196611762047, 0.0033265370875597, 0.046618763357400894, -0.018146762624382973, -0.003376864129677415, 0.030184529721736908, -0.0572676919400692, 0.027419062331318855, -0.025073254480957985, 0.08099134266376495, -0.033892206847667694, 0.03144601732492447, 0.034461457282304764, -0.009969303384423256, -0.006978467106819153, 0.026729440316557884, 0.026264576241374016, -0.010104595683515072, -0.039919767528772354, -0.012742799706757069, -0.014785674400627613, 0.01717977598309517, -0.01805100031197071, -0.041365329176187515, 0.0661618635058403, -0.0052144164219498634, -0.05572907254099846, 0.029188061133027077, -0.04113898426294327, -0.020458193495869637, 0.006823102943599224, 0.04980786144733429, -0.012988816015422344, 0.037355996668338776, -0.011456465348601341, 0.012217347510159016, 0.019657695665955544, 0.054243363440036774, 0.06770522892475128, 0.025676758959889412, 0.010082993656396866, 0.02369062229990959, 0.03677932173013687, 0.051648180931806564, -0.02253783866763115, 0.09858620911836624, -0.048964571207761765, 0.030355527997016907, 0.030615709722042084, -0.021505622193217278, -0.0025140130892395973, 0.037189092487096786, 0.017683889716863632, -0.0781887024641037, 0.012287125922739506, 0.011342606507241726, 0.025332503020763397, -0.0003173969453200698, -0.024495601654052734, 0.011401411145925522, -0.047370605170726776, -0.004813511390239, 0.04742947220802307, -0.0036829591263085604, 0.0016073549631983042, -0.031199825927615166, -0.024694548919796944, -0.03803528845310211, -0.06221064552664757, -0.058612532913684845, -0.013574686832726002, 0.02709878422319889, 0.0024107997305691242, 0.037303488701581955, 0.017919857054948807, -0.0431501604616642, -0.05339673161506653, 0.05609680712223053, 0.0580880381166935, 0.03807591646909714, -0.021722912788391113, 0.012673895806074142, -0.004618112929165363, -0.0362703800201416, 0.01652865670621395, 0.019988343119621277, -0.014579234644770622, -0.03139692172408104, 0.05908685922622681, 0.018777254968881607, -0.04661676660180092, 0.009242302738130093, -0.020261099562048912, 0.05034233257174492, 0.01649681106209755, -0.089506596326828, -0.05239558964967728, 0.07511966675519943, -0.009630545973777771, 0.010909026488661766, -0.04598957672715187, -0.007268558256328106, 0.004749143961817026, 0.0540001355111599, -0.010979619808495045, 0.030842995271086693, -0.00782820489257574, 0.03600610792636871, 0.02846851386129856, -0.028356356546282768, -0.015159279108047485, 0.013519235886633396, 0.014967244118452072, 0.003168958704918623, -0.06979112327098846, -0.002627741312608123, 0.04816361144185066, 0.003277682699263096, 0.0018624744843691587, 0.04263545200228691, 0.01246968749910593, -0.05439012870192528, -0.008348231203854084, -0.0033627350348979235, -0.011947093531489372, 0.06513378024101257, -0.0033076161053031683, 0.013360219076275826, -0.001606267411261797, -0.000201723727514036, 0.007057661190629005, 0.029906155541539192, 0.03936636820435524, 0.00759192556142807, -0.04193262383341789, 0.002252769423648715, -0.004620606545358896, -0.020707344636321068, -0.01205888669937849, -0.034339774399995804, -0.025072237476706505, -0.05017382651567459, -0.003834423143416643, 0.03939800336956978, 0.06626913696527481, -0.01013470534235239, -0.006345979869365692, 0.009606190957129002, -0.04104911908507347, -0.041506629437208176, -0.057272084057331085, 0.007637353613972664, -0.03160922974348068, -0.00935317762196064, 0.04340527579188347, -0.010365264490246773, 0.034438252449035645, -0.002383696846663952, -0.03934480622410774, -0.028897248208522797, -0.022515013813972473, 0.034135282039642334, -0.05236002430319786, 0.04455134645104408, -0.0019300749991089106, 0.0316658541560173, -0.002751076128333807, 0.03937948867678642, -0.024392396211624146, -0.05693177878856659, 0.005978723056614399, -0.04425203055143356, 0.003911666572093964, -0.036452002823352814, -0.007026223465800285, 0.021059732884168625, -0.032790832221508026, -0.003530224086716771, 0.012448006309568882, -0.01898382045328617, 0.023079615086317062, 0.020051514729857445, 0.011890986934304237, -0.008403724990785122, 0.02201434224843979, 0.04691096022725105, 0.0255888719111681, -0.020290808752179146, 0.006796423811465502, -0.06365557014942169, -0.016580672934651375, 0.023653414100408554, 0.06911496073007584, -0.01764129102230072, 0.01854168437421322, 0.09656534343957901, 0.029623011127114296, 0.0030332449823617935, 0.02922559157013893, -0.023358866572380066, -0.004751057829707861, -0.005924795288592577, 0.020148323848843575, 0.024587227031588554, -0.006365299224853516, -0.007656547240912914, -0.016168437898159027, 0.006673253607004881, -0.0035336287692189217, 0.0034827436320483685, -0.014315479435026646, 0.0032466426491737366, 0.008871378377079964, -0.041350845247507095, -0.056025430560112, 0.04897260665893555, -0.013639969751238823, -0.007745342329144478, 0.008303200826048851, 0.025931252166628838, 0.020344505086541176, 0.012659860774874687, -0.00721879955381155, 0.05164709314703941, 0.010034726932644844, -0.027141699567437172, -0.0038868621923029423, 0.024270327761769295, -0.0016379193402826786, 0.006601961329579353, -0.012389005161821842, -0.03671717271208763, 0.014506766572594643, 0.015676001086831093, 0.03826779127120972, 0.011894986033439636, 0.020101573318243027, 0.005937873851507902, -0.03361646831035614, 0.008863852359354496, -0.019305802881717682, 0.00751733360812068, 0.0026492876932024956, -0.020619887858629227, 0.030441144481301308, 0.016117095947265625, 0.025186432525515556, 0.012619701214134693, 0.0015780242392793298, 0.03299681842327118, 0.028413956984877586, -0.009450397454202175, -0.032326992601156235, -0.03265906125307083, -0.030041413381695747, 0.012516696006059647, -0.02603720873594284, -0.015245423652231693, 0.031140731647610664, -0.022995589300990105, -0.04861455410718918, 0.012570079416036606, -0.04685221612453461, -0.02084222435951233, -0.055729541927576065, -0.029625754803419113, 0.015758290886878967, -0.006367797497659922, -0.00799986720085144, -0.006867622956633568, -0.027159612625837326, 0.008852168917655945, -0.06963630020618439, -0.04261203482747078, 0.01656222902238369, -0.01869039796292782, 0.03241685777902603, -0.0072595844976603985, -0.02458229660987854, 0.046724408864974976, 0.006742183119058609, -0.0016102453228086233, -0.01842612586915493, -0.028366101905703545, -0.05017409101128578, 0.0005979554844088852, 0.005140370689332485, 0.0010799310402944684, 0.037045661360025406, 0.038065630942583084, -0.0028533556032925844, 0.01673554629087448, 0.034229978919029236, 0.01660577394068241, 0.013991218991577625, 0.012646932154893875, -0.03417956456542015, 0.023505087941884995, 0.012120380997657776, -0.001525262137874961, -0.0396566204726696, -0.02926226705312729, 0.034727856516838074, 0.017124751582741737, 0.04339384287595749, -0.03233342990279198, 0.012092809192836285, 0.00962714571505785, 0.012089846655726433, -0.023728976026177406, 0.009763456881046295, -0.002267790725454688, -0.019419236108660698, -0.005916200578212738, 0.024297380819916725, 0.020186059176921844, 0.01407613418996334, 0.015999985858798027, 0.04010869190096855, 0.008529332466423512, -0.00962853990495205, -0.020905964076519012, -0.026749689131975174, -0.03777843341231346, 0.047204263508319855, -0.03062373399734497, -0.001899738097563386, 0.013557154685258865, 0.024515613913536072, 0.042380351573228836, -0.01652783341705799, -0.04751397669315338, -0.007893548347055912, -0.04901118203997612, -0.0020844724494963884, -0.00378984771668911, 0.041868656873703, 0.025779323652386665, 0.03994525223970413, 0.027270684018731117, 0.012256050482392311, 0.006312377750873566, -0.009606802836060524, -0.08481734246015549, 0.016404317691922188, -0.028109658509492874, 0.004646163433790207, 0.019267620518803596, -0.0022634025663137436, 0.012416522949934006, -0.016694074496626854, 0.01411485392600298, -0.02992158755660057, 0.00633731996640563, -0.031626395881175995, 0.006688528228551149, -0.02012600190937519, -0.019539516419172287, -0.0034202018287032843, -0.044343411922454834, 0.03520771861076355, 0.012509181164205074, 0.057069484144449234, 0.04251717031002045, -0.00658417446538806, 0.0144709637388587, -0.020828604698181152, 0.03358958661556244, 0.02238457463681698, 0.02168952487409115, 0.02825404889881611, 0.005096445791423321, -0.03626548871397972, 0.0511615127325058, 0.046591293066740036, 0.037594206631183624, 0.019436005502939224, -0.008170575834810734, 0.002150298561900854, -0.04491516202688217, -0.02361658401787281, 0.016529815271496773, -0.02092820592224598, 0.01672595739364624, -0.0018632226856425405, 0.061616603285074234, 0.017864564433693886, -0.06317471712827682, 0.04423077777028084, 0.07855211943387985, 0.03165247291326523, -0.002053681295365095, -0.019891753792762756, -0.006780608557164669, 0.016287369653582573, 0.00500378618016839, 0.01803848333656788, -0.001058616559021175, -0.032169610261917114, 0.009203904308378696, 0.04460611194372177, 0.013951661996543407, -0.021529773250222206, -0.01548268273472786, 0.04059286043047905, 0.04680560529232025, 0.018341481685638428, -0.04753074049949646, 0.029742633923888206, 0.022569064050912857, 0.02005705237388611, 0.04546361044049263, -0.009153291583061218, -0.07836142927408218, 0.016605256125330925, 0.039855170994997025, 0.0145928505808115, -0.02253761887550354, -0.02667553536593914, -0.050266657024621964, -0.03096500225365162, 0.05518532916903496, -0.006231080740690231, 0.01674746535718441, -0.0005411377642303705, 0.0011315718293190002, -0.016920436173677444, -0.030920078977942467, -0.03965311497449875, 0.041069988161325455, 0.022018583491444588, 0.03503840044140816, -0.055376991629600525, -0.029311444610357285, -0.021293241530656815, -0.004915035329759121, 0.02187873050570488, 0.07521605491638184, 0.0028370721265673637, 0.016815681010484695, -0.02402576617896557, 0.033690061420202255, -0.008639886975288391, -0.12853588163852692, 0.045043181627988815, 0.00129691360052675, -0.03223080188035965, 0.040097836405038834, 0.017857413738965988, -0.03422969952225685, -0.006030202843248844, -0.014156192541122437, 0.017528515309095383, 0.0004492855805438012, 0.010806918144226074, 0.02854103222489357, 0.01627238281071186, 0.03842180594801903, 0.05730205774307251, 0.04303271695971489, 0.030890272930264473, -0.0021645124070346355, 0.0031957803294062614, 0.006473951507359743, -0.005577026400715113, 0.021950602531433105, -0.010234003886580467, 0.0036072551738470793, -0.05399451404809952, 0.03995171934366226, 0.0033856513909995556, 0.034833844751119614, 0.012568231672048569, 0.04586528241634369, 0.015191965736448765, 0.03218955546617508, -0.01755739189684391, -0.018463440239429474, 0.016160303726792336, 0.014432448893785477, -0.02549644559621811, -0.0015179364709183574, 0.017312083393335342, -0.020134469494223595, -0.03311815857887268, -0.00959616620093584, -0.04889068752527237, -0.01185551006346941, -0.05283435061573982, -0.00928395614027977, -0.0036681985948234797, 0.009952438995242119, 0.02976219914853573, 0.021700138226151466, 0.03762100636959076, 0.020607851445674896, -0.03414549306035042, 0.02070014737546444, 0.03952910751104355, 0.004070427734404802, 0.056970205157995224, -0.06323475390672684, 0.026126813143491745, -0.005817660130560398, -0.014147037640213966, -0.0719911977648735, -0.06553034484386444, 0.06570997834205627, 0.03347380831837654, -0.037694063037633896, -0.03892488032579422, 0.040587373077869415, -0.007814016193151474, -0.01571766659617424, -0.04043174162507057, 0.028481334447860718, 0.008392173796892166, 0.007334610912948847, 0.005739698652178049, -0.005763894412666559, 0.07012835144996643, -0.04245644062757492, -0.015544738620519638, -0.0028227451257407665, -0.008869459852576256, -0.0205305814743042, -0.007661112118512392, 0.026022186502814293, -0.036735907196998596, -0.033811748027801514, -0.02835327573120594, -0.024338141083717346, 0.02267262525856495, -0.03108643740415573, -0.026564456522464752, 0.008112804964184761, -0.02237868495285511, 0.011064217425882816, -0.0024874904192984104, 0.006777520757168531, -0.018511353060603142, -0.0038289809599518776, -0.0052151973359286785, -0.011993292719125748, -0.013349784538149834, -0.04204655438661575, 0.027304114773869514, -0.0070426384918391705, -0.03330669552087784, 0.013000625185668468, 0.033891040831804276, -0.010422698222100735, -0.013409823179244995, -0.0029089669696986675, 0.0015190895646810532, 0.03521876037120819, 0.012959442101418972, -0.0048509021289646626, 0.0022217195946723223, -0.02043989673256874, -0.029238440096378326, -0.05995665118098259, -0.005148880183696747, -0.00416951347142458, 0.06259918957948685, 0.004691502079367638, 0.036258991807699203, 0.0419301800429821, 0.007761887740343809, 0.018712235614657402, -0.00499425083398819, 0.014603561721742153, -0.0011681849136948586, -0.00923319160938263, 0.03470517694950104, -0.04933110997080803, 0.013759118504822254, 0.0037374980747699738, 0.008082753047347069, 0.012861238792538643, 0.04385505989193916, -0.011621544137597084, 0.009298695251345634, 0.041562508791685104, -0.02413180284202099, -0.0402110256254673, 0.0628669485449791, -0.06640265136957169, 0.030592666938900948, -0.039818599820137024, -0.019475901499390602, 0.01973344013094902, 0.024297868832945824, -0.01409237738698721, -0.0011620590230450034, -0.0295922439545393, -0.027123674750328064, -0.002909233560785651, 0.010228468105196953, -0.044212523847818375, 0.04107573255896568, 0.04631245881319046, 0.039513442665338516, -0.026132330298423767, 0.03452051058411598, -0.010132900439202785, -0.0708114430308342, 0.007353520952165127, -0.020852234214544296, -0.028691837564110756, 0.05992278829216957, -0.01509606372565031, -0.02039458602666855, 0.01618940569460392, -0.014733020216226578, -0.01419510692358017, -0.025642074644565582, 0.03683717921376228, -0.03807032108306885, 0.0889943465590477, -0.009259030222892761, 0.015763526782393456, -0.003903060918673873, -0.014899230562150478, 0.09531228244304657, 0.0726165771484375, 0.009993594139814377, -0.06368807703256607, 0.011622481048107147, 0.011749770492315292, 0.02531299740076065, -0.05947216600179672, 0.01994326524436474, 0.012824547477066517, 0.002589944051578641, 0.05208815634250641, 0.07155325263738632, 0.005883666221052408, 0.004792842082679272, 0.050085972994565964, -0.03026621975004673, 0.008360953070223331, -0.0001229670742759481, 0.030668163672089577, -0.011406425386667252, 0.022478971630334854, -0.04307796433568001, 0.04659537225961685, -0.03810951113700867, -0.0465913787484169, 0.0005131121724843979, -0.0013246723683550954, 0.01650829426944256, -0.021060926839709282, -0.011260075494647026, 0.006122320890426636, 0.056902412325143814, -0.01033081952482462, 0.005091949366033077, -0.013077785260975361, 0.011290892958641052, -0.017722124233841896, 0.03976079821586609, 0.019977359101176262, -0.021136878058314323, -0.029217014089226723, -0.02494284324347973, 0.018076768144965172, -0.031347304582595825, -0.0397469624876976, -0.0576576292514801, 0.0289778932929039, 0.010833642445504665, 0.009806684218347073, -0.03555229306221008, 0.010300254449248314, 0.010466833598911762, -0.01244895625859499, -0.057395413517951965, 0.009076151065528393, 0.009120280854403973, -0.060957543551921844, -0.015502773225307465, -0.05893625691533089, -0.014655628241598606, -0.019317761063575745, 0.037156496196985245, -0.002733700443059206, -0.04011308774352074, 0.008794017136096954, -0.03450963273644447, 0.05414003133773804, -0.008759581483900547, -0.00831567496061325, -0.03796165809035301, -0.008299157954752445, -0.05742482468485832, -0.01426220778375864, 0.029646389186382294, 0.006939757615327835, 0.041009318083524704, 0.01140867080539465, -0.0007620567339472473, -0.01940182037651539, -0.026583246886730194, 0.027149200439453125, -0.03127904608845711, -0.0002150192012777552, -0.05873360484838486, 0.004819484427571297, 0.04638012498617172, 0.022869009524583817, 0.032307129353284836, -0.024614127352833748, -0.025715995579957962, 0.0007246048771776259, 0.05554093047976494, -0.051784172654151917, -0.0036388097796589136, -0.032492417842149734, -0.019901424646377563, -0.03181330859661102, -0.0710538923740387, 0.04758305847644806, 0.016695614904165268, -0.005156633444130421, -0.005086705554276705, 0.01461553480476141, 0.00834763515740633, 0.029398862272500992, 0.05742151290178299, -0.04489736631512642, -0.03910823538899422, 0.01473473384976387, 0.021608563140034676, 0.0204999428242445, -0.0072288475930690765, 0.0020516146905720234, 0.0019259455148130655, 0.00011214086407562718, -0.0030822556000202894, -0.037319112569093704, -0.006538897752761841, 0.007527690846472979, 0.026866694912314415, -0.05951816216111183, -0.024683043360710144, -0.04265134409070015, 0.015188015066087246, -0.00468745781108737, -0.011340203694999218, -0.01181743759661913, 0.020910300314426422, 0.011953381821513176, 0.011152214370667934, 0.06833261996507645, 0.030668118968605995, 0.002134394133463502, -0.022729231044650078, 0.0070653269067406654, 0.01937006041407585, 0.06279630213975906, -0.014377724379301071, -0.026805009692907333, 0.03693826124072075, -0.034433621913194656, -0.006462005898356438, 0.020289169624447823, 0.0009244564571417868, 0.011002535000443459, 0.0095133688300848, 0.016833754256367683, -0.015768686309456825, 0.019690807908773422, -0.016712358221411705, -0.005500029306858778, 0.0014417280908674002, 0.01287282444536686, 0.007621253374963999, 0.023570170626044273, 0.039027292281389236, -0.0014347853139042854, -0.01586369425058365, 0.0032568008173257113, 0.05434130132198334, 0.009477712213993073, 0.026314573362469673, 0.03008175641298294, -0.017715413123369217, -0.0030188015662133694, 0.00023581364075653255, -0.007253365591168404, 0.060172248631715775, 0.08029371500015259, -0.0068978662602603436, -0.005934182088822126, -0.0028574406169354916, -0.005506567191332579, -0.08459936827421188, -0.017418980598449707, 0.0011401887750253081, -0.0020659398287534714, 0.03528495132923126, -0.03951817750930786, 0.004806733690202236, 0.03677164390683174, -0.02139929309487343, 0.03270833194255829, 0.0020444102119654417, -0.02919338084757328, -0.03086477518081665, -0.023428043350577354, -0.03520052880048752, 0.08704212307929993, 0.027300026267766953, 0.016684677451848984, 0.005160043016076088, 0.046784866601228714, 0.011026126332581043, 0.028286106884479523, -0.009947914630174637, -0.03045051544904709, -0.0086877616122365, -0.04526812210679054, 0.02554711326956749, -0.03771607205271721, -0.028128085657954216, 0.043726906180381775, -0.005440808366984129, 0.027193598449230194, 0.022569987922906876, 0.01409902237355709, -0.004425793420523405, 0.032798513770103455, 0.03393931686878204, -0.04287827014923096, -0.015672624111175537, -0.019253339618444443, 0.021731415763497353, 0.04033731669187546, 0.005868102889508009, 0.021269679069519043, 0.00368701433762908, -0.0325307697057724, -0.026385745033621788, -0.00413602264598012, -0.02482619136571884, 0.0027433084324002266, 0.027816947549581528, -0.02634662203490734, -0.010727879591286182, 0.03431176021695137, 0.02992185950279236, -0.025812720879912376, -0.01436767727136612, 0.044643159955739975, 0.05029338225722313, -0.0035271018277853727, 0.010561307892203331, -0.025488171726465225, -0.04304256662726402, 0.030520858243107796, -0.005905895493924618, -0.007623925339430571, -0.04391629621386528, -0.0009229493443854153, 0.020296433940529823, -0.004314301535487175, -0.01922360248863697, -0.014074143022298813, 0.012416709214448929, 0.04672081395983696, -0.010618801228702068, 0.0076106539927423, 0.015362084843218327, -0.05014539137482643, -0.00005831765884067863, -0.08592160791158676, 0.05264809727668762, -0.006095021963119507, -0.028496108949184418, -0.005179040599614382, -0.008850464597344398, -0.0727434754371643, -0.03270116075873375, 0.04670838639140129, -0.017975274473428726, 0.021685143932700157, -0.005028917454183102, 0.025245623663067818, 0.014417043887078762, -0.04794640839099884, 0.00598983746021986, -0.036539554595947266, 0.008597496896982193, -0.007477137725800276, -0.04751633480191231, 0.024817591533064842, -0.014027074910700321, 0.00779791921377182, -0.019258903339505196, 0.02000502124428749, 0.038729164749383926, -0.017058534547686577, 0.03167392313480377, 0.009993901476264, -0.06194285675883293, 0.0723506435751915, -0.001378193381242454, 0.007381587289273739, 0.020340481773018837, -0.023959357291460037, -0.049319155514240265, 0.013859166763722897, -0.010387438349425793, -0.032682329416275024, -0.001953987404704094, -0.004653594922274351, -0.061703361570835114, -0.060298509895801544, 0.0019579592626541853, 0.019084589555859566, -0.06968282163143158, 0.05389153212308884, 0.011729516088962555, -0.005541101563721895, 0.027042198926210403, -0.0016389957163482904, 0.016606679186224937, 0.026724908500909805, -0.007115797605365515, -0.009638885036110878, 0.005833446979522705, 0.04232170060276985, -0.00611378438770771, 0.01017085649073124, 0.00998914334923029, -0.018226057291030884, 0.025486893951892853, -0.028922811150550842, -0.006197839044034481, -0.02859673835337162, -0.026160933077335358, 0.034469131380319595, -0.013853671960532665, 0.024704236537218094, 0.0036611459217965603, -0.016195716336369514, 0.04946674779057503, -0.03410443291068077, 0.020311444997787476, 0.0003004284808412194, 0.014926502481102943, -0.0417231060564518, 0.027004238218069077, 0.006339517887681723, 0.014415397308766842, 0.002606343710795045, 0.01740025170147419, -0.006077585741877556, 0.001942422823049128, 0.014186101965606213, -0.002278351690620184, 0.03453277796506882, -0.0376664400100708, 0.025179686024785042, -0.01846982352435589, -0.015467952005565166, -0.05732443556189537, -0.04949382692575455, 0.009212467819452286, -0.002341784071177244, 0.028296351432800293, -0.00910366140305996, -0.04822251573204994, -0.01565844751894474, 0.06645464897155762, -0.0652935653924942, -0.012299297377467155, -0.052827730774879456, 0.03612762689590454, -0.03774689882993698, -0.024331215769052505 ]
<p>My data is as follows. I have two groups of patients. Patients in each group had a different type of eye surgery. 5 variables were measured on patients in each group. I want to compare those variables between the two groups using a permutation test or MANOVA. The eye on which the surgery was done does not really matter in the analysis. However, Patient 2 in group A for example, had the surgery on both eyes and therefore has those 5 variables measured twice, one time on each eye. Can I consider patient 2 Left and patient 2 Right as two different observations? Same for patient 31 in group B. $$ \begin{array} \hline \text{Patient} &amp; \text{Surgery type} &amp; \text{Side} &amp; \text{V1}&amp; \ldots &amp; V5\\ 1 &amp; \text{A} &amp; \text{Left} &amp; 91 &amp; \ldots &amp; 22\\ 2 &amp; \text{A} &amp; \text{Left} &amp; 87 &amp; \ldots &amp; 19\\ 2 &amp; \text{A} &amp; \text{Right} &amp; 90 &amp; \ldots &amp; 23\\ . &amp; . &amp; . &amp;\\ 31 &amp; \text{B} &amp; \text{Left} &amp; 90 &amp; \ldots &amp; 17\\ 31 &amp; \text{B} &amp; \text{Right} &amp; 88 &amp; \ldots &amp; 19\\ 32 &amp; \text{B} &amp; \text{Right} &amp; 91 &amp; \ldots &amp; 24\\ . &amp; . &amp; . &amp;\\ \hline \end{array} $$ Thank you</p>
37,408
[ -0.04265730828046799, -0.0066154710948467255, -0.03001278266310692, 0.016161417588591576, 0.04368545487523079, 0.0039576152339577675, 0.01807587221264839, 0.005503691732883453, 0.027145639061927795, -0.0036132566165179014, 0.04040718078613281, -0.013455409556627274, 0.03656196966767311, -0.003879323834553361, 0.015279388055205345, -0.0014746806118637323, -0.030046667903661728, 0.022395940497517586, 0.0011125578312203288, 0.035319648683071136, -0.021037913858890533, -0.0003455030673649162, 0.072038933634758, -0.015933778136968613, -0.03203286975622177, 0.047155749052762985, 0.023630967363715172, -0.06421520560979843, -0.01646108366549015, 0.008860030211508274, -0.005641144700348377, -0.018153002485632896, -0.000314990320475772, 0.07583525031805038, -0.011773672886192799, 0.005076860077679157, 0.005009963642805815, -0.00691313436254859, 0.007069207727909088, 0.018217161297798157, -0.04185419902205467, 0.010836806148290634, -0.0352521575987339, 0.02710389532148838, -0.0016194544732570648, -0.0008423700928688049, -0.0170434582978487, -0.016032757237553596, 0.011092958971858025, -0.04094183072447777, 0.0997442677617073, -0.011988568119704723, 0.039252880960702896, 0.021304922178387642, -0.048205818980932236, 0.02971557341516018, 0.035983361303806305, 0.06728928536176682, 0.009540489874780178, -0.04217668995261192, -0.045150596648454666, -0.03325434401631355, 0.012291532941162586, 0.019544513896107674, -0.026276513934135437, 0.0024911013897508383, -0.02854677475988865, 0.0009820798877626657, 0.030272454023361206, -0.02835872955620289, 0.0028862517792731524, 0.004337960854172707, 0.043771952390670776, -0.03635053709149361, 0.021004144102334976, -0.02678597718477249, 0.04666883498430252, 0.022792141884565353, 0.014308217912912369, -0.008862005546689034, -0.01545297633856535, -0.003595436690375209, -0.003375166328623891, 0.038893021643161774, 0.028058836236596107, -0.027424022555351257, 0.061332181096076965, -0.04348394647240639, 0.03052988089621067, 0.026667863130569458, -0.013854149729013443, 0.004820472095161676, 0.04119843617081642, 0.014390702359378338, -0.05664614215493202, 0.031211823225021362, -0.023687124252319336, 0.014852441847324371, -0.024976307526230812, -0.007667871657758951, -0.018267324194312096, -0.028247488662600517, -0.012675696052610874, 0.054551780223846436, 0.009735630825161934, 0.00506177544593811, -0.02190057747066021, 0.024985145777463913, 0.020231569185853004, 0.007960258051753044, -0.019995765760540962, 0.02273053675889969, -0.02036149986088276, 0.004618773236870766, 0.01871458813548088, -0.022471897304058075, -0.0362643264234066, -0.019744351506233215, 0.06688849627971649, 0.06374204158782959, 0.07314281910657883, -0.05054745823144913, 0.012730306014418602, -0.02996913157403469, -0.056998640298843384, 0.005778564140200615, 0.017861582338809967, 0.0006399829871952534, -0.04538711905479431, 0.056105390191078186, 0.0249816682189703, -0.020958205685019493, 0.047187864780426025, -0.015337488614022732, 0.0013868202222511172, -0.008082345128059387, -0.07600997388362885, -0.04731382057070732, 0.04153675585985184, -0.019378216937184334, 0.011698982678353786, -0.039325449615716934, 0.019691187888383865, 0.04185666888952255, 0.08696957677602768, 0.0015378845855593681, 0.038513973355293274, -0.007910131476819515, 0.04715395346283913, 0.024724235758185387, -0.01711471751332283, 0.053001776337623596, -0.014751800335943699, -0.017874104902148247, -0.008934631943702698, -0.07794464379549026, -0.017887158319354057, 0.025965280830860138, 0.015776529908180237, -0.00674678897485137, -0.00792242307215929, -0.010440866462886333, 0.0023188870400190353, -0.014576831832528114, 0.004913514479994774, -0.008844761177897453, 0.0627581849694252, -0.013393357396125793, 0.033958274871110916, 0.024127952754497528, 0.03383348509669304, 0.024177338927984238, 0.0032410616986453533, 0.0715155228972435, 0.04513772577047348, 0.006014982238411903, 0.03688960522413254, 0.004649304319173098, 0.009531470946967602, 0.02260226011276245, -0.043849337846040726, -0.014308045618236065, -0.03403341770172119, -0.005290252156555653, 0.007130063604563475, 0.060445211827754974, -0.021525913849473, 0.011723602190613747, 0.06632734835147858, -0.030921895056962967, 0.007580003701150417, -0.0653131902217865, 0.0032123459968715906, 0.02311393991112709, -0.01975378580391407, 0.019349297508597374, -0.02115468494594097, 0.01059541292488575, 0.043886322528123856, -0.033364612609148026, -0.005790617782622576, -0.005809152033179998, 0.05024029314517975, -0.03904455900192261, -0.004130426328629255, 0.01811058260500431, 0.049484945833683014, 0.007585627492517233, 0.0479629784822464, -0.0201812032610178, 0.006521881092339754, 0.02305394411087036, -0.01542678289115429, -0.012368518859148026, -0.014421019703149796, -0.027654405683279037, -0.00874221883714199, 0.05483011528849602, -0.004368319641798735, 0.0972796157002449, -0.04624178633093834, 0.05595182254910469, 0.0886695384979248, -0.007855424657464027, 0.01255637314170599, -0.008083058521151543, 0.020688237622380257, 0.03891677409410477, -0.003184164874255657, -0.03929094597697258, -0.04026595503091812, 0.00784189160913229, -0.003606165060773492, -0.030914073809981346, -0.011110357008874416, 0.019937841221690178, 0.04693467170000076, 0.02692137286067009, -0.02058723010122776, 0.05832589045166969, 0.02627905085682869, -0.0061167944222688675, 0.0215429849922657, 0.04887465760111809, 0.04853307083249092, 0.004296341445297003, 0.01593399979174137, -0.03444686904549599, 0.06703787297010422, 0.027914507314562798, 0.06150825694203377, 0.03886993229389191, 0.006069006398320198, -0.03313998132944107, -0.016276663169264793, 0.010313745588064194, 0.03254355117678642, -0.03176619112491608, 0.02100423350930214, 0.041619084775447845, 0.020357850939035416, -0.04414651542901993, 0.0008646163623780012, -0.006553879007697105, 0.01727658323943615, 0.033466801047325134, -0.010340485721826553, 0.029019953683018684, 0.013558011502027512, -0.035581301897764206, 0.019256476312875748, -0.012672659009695053, 0.02528637833893299, -0.01946348138153553, 0.0184813030064106, 0.020050665363669395, -0.012251308187842369, 0.009887891821563244, -0.01261906698346138, 0.0015139029128476977, 0.00955155212432146, -0.007469238247722387, 0.0165417343378067, -0.002888653427362442, -0.05566463619470596, 0.012340676039457321, -0.0062150368466973305, 0.020305706188082695, 0.022932639345526695, -0.004852575249969959, -0.03968280553817749, 0.03219762444496155, -0.020886389538645744, -0.027377890422940254, -0.01422581821680069, -0.055100519210100174, 0.02846212312579155, -0.006721103563904762, -0.04463714361190796, 0.023032793775200844, 0.003376911859959364, -0.01970173977315426, -0.0070269107818603516, -0.030556732788681984, -0.03636637330055237, 0.019499043002724648, -0.0008241866598837078, 0.024234646931290627, 0.011751189827919006, -0.0211857371032238, 0.041455917060375214, -0.0022168585564941168, -0.01572231389582157, -0.07913894206285477, -0.06397372484207153, 0.00876626931130886, 0.016004102304577827, -0.002334039891138673, 0.008130674250423908, -0.03007691353559494, 0.05049712955951691, 0.038781262934207916, -0.034923892468214035, -0.02537672407925129, 0.02090647630393505, -0.05984929949045181, -0.008891771547496319, 0.018550489097833633, 0.03040388599038124, -0.010907422751188278, 0.045355360954999924, 0.028785206377506256, 0.023375513032078743, 0.06522517651319504, -0.013388700783252716, -0.021783899515867233, 0.0036153707187622786, 0.013937431387603283, -0.017525408416986465, 0.01334257610142231, 0.004830172751098871, -0.020358068868517876, 0.01580500416457653, 0.011573299765586853, 0.023609085008502007, 0.010322521440684795, -0.055057596415281296, 0.029019689187407494, -0.011293064802885056, 0.016035689041018486, -0.042411934584379196, -0.00596965616568923, 0.049004241824150085, -0.004646020475775003, -0.0371076874434948, 0.04634298384189606, 0.03828292340040207, -0.058024268597364426, 0.012498480267822742, 0.06355114281177521, 0.013599553145468235, -0.0022413514088839293, -0.004764830693602562, -0.03939254209399223, 0.02176043763756752, 0.04302676394581795, -0.048502348363399506, 0.020207127556204796, 0.00803404301404953, 0.02787143737077713, 0.01358298771083355, -0.020956143736839294, -0.006437579169869423, 0.02206018753349781, -0.060701947659254074, 0.007963832467794418, -0.014240002259612083, 0.011121454648673534, -0.0006514886044897139, 0.017661137506365776, 0.01747671142220497, -0.008679763413965702, -0.03071470931172371, -0.031186774373054504, -0.057661812752485275, 0.032845329493284225, 0.014657167717814445, 0.0076696621254086494, 0.0021200987976044416, -0.03194562718272209, -0.014594685286283493, -0.0445689857006073, 0.029194233939051628, 0.01447770930826664, 0.023200776427984238, -0.011742739006876945, -0.003026053076609969, -0.06300892680883408, 0.008401255123317242, 0.0036826333962380886, 0.03830413520336151, 0.006505202502012253, -0.054299402981996536, 0.01634286716580391, 0.017370106652379036, -0.02144320122897625, 0.013544812798500061, -0.037126339972019196, 0.001169821247458458, -0.0029062367975711823, 0.06344947218894958, -0.0063719917088747025, 0.04727046564221382, -0.0033459996338933706, -0.0072852736338973045, 0.0013361960882321, -0.002651259070262313, 0.024867137894034386, -0.01055134367197752, 0.0036664786748588085, -0.02023131586611271, -0.03505806624889374, -0.02585182711482048, 0.04408012703061104, 0.02602587267756462, -0.006016299594193697, 0.044195279479026794, 0.03277808800339699, -0.054587673395872116, -0.01784477010369301, 0.05674896761775017, 0.01863936334848404, 0.014439046382904053, -0.03950553387403488, 0.004598388448357582, -0.01038393098860979, -0.01779996231198311, 0.04606308043003082, 0.023391859605908394, 0.007211199030280113, -0.03066345863044262, 0.028641721233725548, -0.00007944659591885284, -0.0421142615377903, 0.028708651661872864, -0.00930558331310749, 0.030572276562452316, -0.01557148527354002, 0.02089347504079342, 0.041109561920166016, 0.04027308151125908, 0.012265072204172611, -0.0028023377526551485, -0.02058367431163788, -0.07303795218467712, 0.003720259992405772, 0.024438783526420593, 0.06709437817335129, -0.024867095053195953, 0.012546551413834095, -0.02701612003147602, 0.014610642567276955, 0.004310141783207655, -0.007316195406019688, 0.05104734003543854, -0.0045424653217196465, -0.01239604689180851, -0.022322455421090126, -0.02278294414281845, -0.022699672728776932, 0.023691751062870026, 0.003872946370393038, -0.008929974399507046, -0.002021096646785736, -0.027397682890295982, -0.028169184923171997, -0.04175899922847748, 0.030174436047673225, 0.04934227839112282, -0.041545189917087555, -0.003237402532249689, 0.007426640018820763, 0.0233939066529274, -0.02374202013015747, -0.0655737966299057, 0.030083585530519485, 0.019196877256035805, -0.003688928671181202, 0.08262418210506439, -0.006877346895635128, -0.03475097566843033, 0.06110982969403267, -0.02899741567671299, 0.02361990697681904, 0.006432275287806988, 0.027559882029891014, 0.05460966005921364, 0.014539435505867004, -0.003809585003182292, 0.06253181397914886, -0.006128770764917135, 0.01963319256901741, -0.009240850806236267, -0.007021389435976744, 0.018293015658855438, -0.008413545787334442, -0.023322705179452896, -0.03873169422149658, -0.029905466362833977, -0.00707206828519702, 0.033164132386446, -0.002110854024067521, 0.05031810700893402, -0.03222574666142464, -0.010905974544584751, 0.018410956487059593, 0.011050260625779629, 0.03311333805322647, 0.005732202436774969, -0.020648283883929253, -0.007588962558656931, -0.02800232172012329, -0.04273264482617378, 0.011056281626224518, -0.06960228830575943, 0.006095397286117077, 0.03130596503615379, -0.030983926728367805, 0.004550310783088207, -0.0562148280441761, -0.026267215609550476, -0.006683018058538437, -0.034284643828868866, 0.029578326269984245, -0.014031627215445042, 0.009572860784828663, -0.01982804574072361, -0.060045596212148666, -0.011268041096627712, 0.024445492774248123, 0.0010519331553950906, -0.007262535393238068, -0.02506357617676258, 0.034397803246974945, 0.0053329067304730415, -0.02926751971244812, -0.0819791629910469, -0.013673162087798119, -0.010252056643366814, 0.04251934587955475, -0.017623497173190117, -0.01517740823328495, -0.0030631336849182844, -0.038040854036808014, -0.06152413785457611, -0.03135334700345993, 0.03697239235043526, -0.01573837921023369, -0.025807995349168777, -0.0327933244407177, -0.010867803357541561, 0.0822194442152977, -0.016153575852513313, -0.01952057145535946, -0.038549862802028656, -0.029131993651390076, 0.02893715724349022, 0.028935037553310394, 0.0025618390645831823, -0.011260290630161762, 0.0007980623631738126, -0.01685117371380329, 0.016692334786057472, 0.04025913029909134, -0.03360619768500328, 0.003316969610750675, -0.013763220980763435, -0.03266016021370888, 0.007494556717574596, -0.01037596631795168, -0.0146884610876441, -0.021023141220211983, 0.014846432954072952, -0.013296419754624367, 0.016647575423121452, 0.012447349727153778, 0.0004041241481900215, 0.025733519345521927, -0.0005449434393085539, -0.043593332171440125, 0.01617276854813099, 0.08358670026063919, 0.010211685672402382, 0.02812322787940502, -0.009557048790156841, -0.044186051934957504, 0.03173055127263069, -0.006982099264860153, -0.014820961281657219, -0.020826101303100586, 0.03778105974197388, -0.036869194358587265, -0.022985374554991722, -0.0191514752805233, 0.02992061898112297, 0.05660514160990715, 0.04020902141928673, 0.054974962025880814, 0.07305839657783508, -0.00984872505068779, 0.0014002628158777952, -0.04231548681855202, 0.0006725257844664156, 0.020193900913000107, 0.017576899379491806, 0.035086557269096375, -0.023298360407352448, 0.000003544248784237425, 0.016957717016339302, 0.036311253905296326, 0.015129809267818928, 0.038956496864557266, 0.016176091507077217, 0.003660179441794753, -0.001185101456940174, -0.008911999873816967, -0.03376997262239456, 0.01341070793569088, -0.05039006844162941, 0.00848197378218174, -0.08374983817338943, -0.02476748637855053, 0.040439605712890625, 0.043691013008356094, 0.012884890660643578, -0.07180558145046234, -0.07711338251829147, -0.0727272555232048, 0.017814239487051964, 0.02830595336854458, 0.02085455134510994, 0.033494386821985245, 0.007957500405609608, 0.019830843433737755, -0.01946769841015339, 0.014852049760520458, -0.053450457751750946, -0.06760513782501221, -0.059359993785619736, -0.032956741750240326, 0.004346414934843779, 0.07181601226329803, -0.012487765401601791, -0.00036673471913672984, 0.016838284209370613, -0.049205902963876724, 0.007149147801101208, 0.0089100431650877, 0.0604669451713562, -0.033211659640073776, 0.06551562249660492, 0.005678465124219656, 0.03259389102458954, 0.024960406124591827, -0.0061071282252669334, 0.12641824781894684, 0.06762981414794922, 0.020139506086707115, -0.05035531520843506, 0.04546443000435829, 0.003457173239439726, -0.01573970913887024, -0.05987360700964928, 0.06066056713461876, 0.005739188753068447, 0.011075122281908989, 0.03412797674536705, 0.05447530746459961, 0.021482618525624275, -0.03956998884677887, 0.03804060444235802, -0.015838587656617165, -0.020596839487552643, 0.034960269927978516, -0.0198773555457592, -0.012158512137830257, 0.0003329917381051928, -0.006575233303010464, -0.002834040904417634, -0.008894916623830795, -0.015638314187526703, -0.007058961782604456, -0.0062266807071864605, 0.0030155987478792667, 0.009665459394454956, 0.005363759119063616, 0.04026016220450401, 0.010506460443139076, 0.012909883633255959, -0.057985175400972366, -0.017426783218979836, 0.027694204822182655, -0.04348647594451904, 0.02131241373717785, 0.034666214138269424, -0.0014239093288779259, 0.009073498658835888, 0.011386592872440815, 0.011876234784722328, -0.037885501980781555, -0.01286663394421339, 0.00397632597014308, 0.050383515655994415, -0.020655885338783264, -0.003180532716214657, -0.02988218143582344, -0.02896547131240368, -0.014251288026571274, -0.0319833904504776, -0.039765868335962296, 0.021130776032805443, 0.023037105798721313, -0.030944017693400383, 0.003378296038135886, -0.030668476596474648, 0.018161512911319733, 0.0033765912521630526, 0.02094488963484764, 0.0007335877162404358, 0.0006195418536663055, -0.02070480026304722, -0.01041479129344225, 0.03840842470526695, -0.014513983391225338, -0.00909838080406189, -0.0026312798727303743, 0.0011275522410869598, -0.020900936797261238, -0.008951076306402683, 0.01564701274037361, 0.0282671507447958, 0.01416323147714138, -0.002494597574695945, -0.024741342291235924, -0.00869164988398552, -0.03828950971364975, -0.01326157059520483, -0.015140905044972897, -0.031758181750774384, -0.024728164076805115, 0.0004756765265483409, 0.02618676796555519, 0.03763071820139885, -0.0007270296919159591, -0.0022258232347667217, 0.01048803236335516, 0.041917212307453156, 0.0295526422560215, -0.07441047579050064, -0.03657963126897812, -0.009629227221012115, -0.014142252504825592, -0.009842433035373688, -0.05947308614850044, 0.06265856325626373, 0.02075388841331005, 0.02015567757189274, -0.002513039158657193, 0.02989254891872406, -0.01061741728335619, 0.004141686484217644, 0.022848613560199738, -0.051603734493255615, 0.013742810115218163, 0.02335568144917488, 0.03184139356017113, 0.009995165280997753, -0.03625843673944473, -0.024502011016011238, -0.036944545805454254, 0.022050851956009865, -0.04354673624038696, -0.013206158764660358, -0.030809590592980385, 0.0056721242144703865, 0.0031794700771570206, -0.03183641657233238, 0.020077696070075035, -0.02830543741583824, 0.018176419660449028, 0.033785246312618256, -0.013585633598268032, -0.006782705429941416, 0.008526545949280262, -0.019379639998078346, -0.03632315620779991, 0.058932285755872726, 0.045261528342962265, 0.04645313322544098, 0.015295089222490788, -0.006847827695310116, 0.002269987715408206, 0.049431800842285156, -0.01239707414060831, 0.006309060845524073, 0.01555244904011488, -0.04534522816538811, -0.011874690651893616, 0.01749689131975174, 0.003898501629009843, 0.02936524711549282, -0.011687304824590683, -0.0006129967514425516, -0.014489919878542423, 0.054383330047130585, -0.04554881155490875, -0.03954828158020973, 0.009636055678129196, -0.01240972988307476, -0.021820567548274994, -0.022984301671385765, 0.014230625703930855, 0.024654744192957878, -0.012037129141390324, 0.040924400091171265, 0.03760330006480217, 0.020695937797427177, -0.03878108784556389, -0.0010968977585434914, 0.025452909991145134, 0.03571268543601036, -0.017265688627958298, 0.012892127968370914, 0.04002763330936432, 0.022992687299847603, -0.00399757781997323, 0.05081099644303322, -0.016697034239768982, 0.01299967523664236, -0.08608071506023407, -0.03837230056524277, 0.01345418393611908, 0.02478383481502533, 0.04190479591488838, -0.05379107967019081, 0.029410263523459435, 0.01617482863366604, -0.0359414704144001, 0.0404476635158062, -0.02478099800646305, -0.007916940376162529, -0.07673950493335724, 0.019791655242443085, -0.03429193049669266, -0.015170669183135033, 0.020764879882335663, 0.017736656591296196, 0.03417684882879257, 0.02815486676990986, -0.003978103864938021, -0.02982224151492119, -0.00007655985245946795, 0.01185968890786171, 0.0006718575023114681, -0.06056991219520569, 0.0150704775005579, -0.034204814583063126, -0.06855197995901108, 0.011705073527991772, 0.013729475438594818, -0.014319805428385735, 0.04521415755152702, 0.002929599490016699, 0.0011569784255698323, 0.004412401467561722, 0.029604895040392876, 0.013431676663458347, -0.04504324123263359, -0.027311749756336212, -0.024019943550229073, 0.017054922878742218, -0.04119112342596054, 0.027853969484567642, 0.05277218297123909, -0.034811459481716156, -0.0336732491850853, -0.00941971130669117, -0.025728704407811165, -0.022136226296424866, -0.011559810489416122, -0.027678653597831726, -0.009029627777636051, -0.00542041938751936, 0.013900374062359333, -0.08118466287851334, 0.03697526827454567, 0.029429126530885696, 0.006913275923579931, -0.014419103041291237, -0.00033275922760367393, -0.006227473728358746, -0.036653731018304825, -0.030553365126252174, 0.011817905120551586, -0.007173330523073673, -0.044996220618486404, -0.009397534653544426, -0.003743662964552641, -0.04970049485564232, -0.02440815232694149, -0.00648100720718503, -0.01593385823071003, 0.01026428584009409, -0.0463232584297657, -0.025501109659671783, 0.024808306246995926, 0.0034898212179541588, 0.002351525239646435, -0.0631336122751236, -0.002108982764184475, 0.022471435368061066, -0.03347952663898468, -0.05405948683619499, -0.005161191802471876, -0.04836372658610344, 0.02838090993463993, 0.023552948608994484, 0.026187537238001823, 0.009081285446882248, -0.012537315487861633, 0.0439511202275753, 0.008230239152908325, -0.05194025859236717, 0.07443547993898392, -0.056139081716537476, 0.013010411523282528, -0.00623179180547595, 0.02316705323755741, 0.013081618584692478, -0.004829224199056625, -0.007746891584247351, -0.043423689901828766, 0.015921883285045624, 0.012199939228594303, -0.030297860503196716, 0.00291753513738513, -0.049131184816360474, -0.010762251913547516, 0.018454186618328094, 0.03809836134314537, 0.007932200096547604, 0.003918327856808901, 0.01582888886332512, -0.06807217001914978, 0.027168279513716698, -0.05949975922703743, -0.010128101333975792, -0.03645303100347519, 0.013513264246284962, 0.020084571093320847, -0.051054418087005615, 0.015925751999020576, 0.0020927877631038427, -0.04289799556136131, -0.014451265335083008, 0.03268033638596535, 0.020855169743299484, -0.011191315948963165, -0.035418275743722916, 0.015102749690413475, -0.022676562890410423, -0.05455651879310608, -0.016854548826813698, 0.01642548479139805, -0.010690548457205296, 0.03144560381770134, 0.0032813427969813347, 0.04695184901356697, 0.0031870605889707804, 0.018531527370214462, 0.007048735860735178, 0.03972352296113968, 0.025318697094917297, 0.004437136463820934, -0.01924319937825203, 0.006322490982711315, 0.0025101788341999054, -0.04187663644552231, -0.0013255801750347018, 0.011236379854381084, -0.010575543157756329, 0.017858566716313362, -0.047722622752189636, 0.011471631936728954, -0.010696390643715858, 0.005767046008259058, 0.04193175211548805, -0.0012650449061766267, 0.015130937099456787, 0.012762993574142456, -0.037273600697517395, -0.007659350987523794, 0.041325561702251434, -0.015347503125667572, 0.012391109019517899, 0.00032666532206349075, -0.06052621081471443, 0.007253589574247599, -0.015389669686555862, -0.055417902767658234, -0.028504209592938423, -0.010535931214690208, 0.048939917236566544, 0.05403922498226166, -0.019038300961256027, -0.04398322477936745, 0.003953384701162577, 0.04501575231552124, -0.03526435047388077, -0.036069899797439575, -0.0229094997048378, 0.008227950893342495, -0.0024526577908545732, 0.022673143073916435 ]
<p>I am creating a small webapp and a part of it is generating a number (I like to call it diversity coefficient) that would represent how "diverse" someones listening habits are. The problem is - I am not sure how to create a valid formula for what I want. I will try my best to explain what information I have, and what I need as a result, and hopefully someone will be able to provide me with a solution. I guess it's nothing hard or complicated, but I am not that deep into math, so I am not sure how to get what I want (tried playing with different formula ideas for a few day, but could not get what I wanted)...</p> <p>What I do is - I gather information from someones <a href="http://www.last.fm/" rel="nofollow">lastfm</a> profile, which is a website that lets you track the music you listen to, and also lets you use all the data that they have stored on their servers to create something with that data (you can see a sample of a profile and what it is about <a href="http://www.last.fm/user/pootzko" rel="nofollow">here</a> if you like, just to better understand what it's all about). So let's say you listen to a certain band, and you listen to a number of their songs. </p> <p>The data that I have is the following:</p> <ul> <li>total count of how many times you listened to a certain band </li> <li>number of different songs (from that band) that you listened to</li> <li>total count of how many times you listened to each of that different songs</li> </ul> <p>For example:</p> <ul> <li>someone listened to a band called FooBar for 1012 times</li> <li>he listened to 17 different songs from that band</li> <li>he listened to the first of that 17 songs for 100 times, the second one of that 17 for 110 times, the third one 120 times, the fourth one 170 times, the fifth one 500 times and the remaining 12 songs only once per song.</li> </ul> <p>What I would like to have as a result is a number that ranges from 0-100. That number would represent if a person listens to all the songs evenly or if he just listens to one or two song from a band all the time, and all the other song only once or twice and then forgets about them...</p> <p>A perfect 100 score would be for a person that listened to FooBar for 500 times, 5 different song, each one 100 times... That is as even as it gets.</p> <p>A score of 0 (or some very low score) would be for a person that listened to FooBar for 500 times, 5 different songs - one of them for 496 times, and the remaining four songs only once per song. </p> <p>I think that it is some kind of "density" that I want, but how to get to that number - I am not sure.. And that is where I need your help. I would be happy to provide any additional info to help you help me.</p> <p>The thing looks like this (if you take a look at these bars each one representing a different song (and its share of total count), that is why I say "density"):</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IoOer.jpg" alt="bars sample"></p> <p>In this example it is clear that Dredg is more evenly spread than Deftones, and should have a higher score (in my case the score is almost the same which is not good, it's just something that remained from my experimenting with the formula).</p> <p>Thanks!</p> <p>PS - feel free to edit tags, I really have no clue what to put there..</p>
74,509
[ -0.03202204778790474, -0.04804767295718193, 0.03831233084201813, 0.006165743339806795, 0.05367470160126686, 0.0005007065483368933, 0.01394109521061182, -0.0447390154004097, 0.026341386139392853, 0.013215810991823673, 0.04124743118882179, 0.028996706008911133, 0.038732677698135376, 0.025531021878123283, 0.04535346478223801, 0.03570683300495148, 0.01903415098786354, 0.05970921367406845, -0.019131530076265335, -0.013715988956391811, -0.03346411511301994, 0.0029057376086711884, -0.017251135781407356, -0.010491673834621906, -0.007350026164203882, 0.019399072974920273, 0.02854268252849579, -0.012634881772100925, -0.022606724873185158, 0.04732947051525116, -0.038500577211380005, -0.03921151161193848, 0.04750657454133034, 0.01702689379453659, 0.07958611845970154, 0.051453378051519394, -0.03810260444879532, -0.01337608601897955, -0.026867873966693878, 0.002627875190228224, -0.026351938024163246, 0.021625978872179985, -0.003631033468991518, 0.03745421767234802, -0.039032191038131714, 0.05937925726175308, 0.021030394360423088, 0.0027940128929913044, 0.008990680798888206, -0.032337743788957596, 0.08885245770215988, -0.01422816887497902, 0.07137391716241837, 0.014891154132783413, -0.020253989845514297, 0.0075561730191111565, 0.034066226333379745, 0.03295598924160004, -0.008574303239583969, -0.04949537664651871, 0.0005694378050975502, -0.013068344444036484, -0.04747612029314041, -0.00658246548846364, 0.00021428437321446836, 0.013357184827327728, 0.0024352087639272213, 0.003357907058671117, 0.019112519919872284, -0.04662448540329933, 0.0035264568869024515, 0.007127391640096903, 0.0177052840590477, -0.03532947599887848, 0.008486207574605942, -0.04859691485762596, 0.017184972763061523, -0.01915065385401249, 0.043721143156290054, 0.025756826624274254, -0.025746449828147888, -0.01641610637307167, -0.001645987038500607, 0.008638964034616947, 0.06538885086774826, -0.043471477925777435, 0.04560057073831558, -0.03233662247657776, -0.0010600956156849861, 0.0058580380864441395, 0.003320580581203103, -0.006632539909332991, 0.05322631448507309, 0.033881206065416336, -0.020329203456640244, 0.054681289941072464, -0.02178363874554634, -0.007700169924646616, 0.007657631766051054, -0.012145115062594414, -0.025925852358341217, -0.0417359285056591, 0.04866485670208931, 0.07381059229373932, -0.03805197402834892, -0.010196419432759285, -0.014026248827576637, -0.03896600380539894, -0.0018902994925156236, -0.0016983072273433208, 0.01787588559091091, 0.0038013968151062727, 0.01464884728193283, -0.013512387871742249, 0.013568993657827377, -0.026143832132220268, -0.025823920965194702, -0.0019942771177738905, 0.037627167999744415, 0.07423415780067444, 0.039439816027879715, -0.00926760584115982, 0.046608954668045044, -0.007607656996697187, -0.03477690368890762, 0.0019359936704859138, -0.017342744395136833, 0.013266628608107567, -0.05540773272514343, 0.03912165015935898, -0.03128405660390854, -0.007288065738976002, 0.023936046287417412, -0.013308516703546047, -0.022681940346956253, -0.00414497684687376, -0.09163420647382736, 0.00007193881901912391, 0.03535519540309906, -0.024627139791846275, -0.013340558856725693, -0.029665648937225342, 0.07325323671102524, 0.021319080144166946, 0.06643762439489365, 0.01932164654135704, 0.047416940331459045, -0.004241519141942263, 0.004416557960212231, 0.012602013535797596, -0.02309407666325569, -0.025349052622914314, -0.025204097852110863, -0.015151695348322392, -0.019126053899526596, -0.04414154961705208, -0.01179670449346304, -0.001378623186610639, 0.007488397415727377, 0.006748824380338192, 0.0011627529747784138, 0.011427456513047218, -0.026549026370048523, 0.013473575003445148, 0.0014703318011015654, -0.015594610013067722, 0.06959953904151917, 0.005214989185333252, -0.007883938029408455, -0.006264610216021538, -0.011609721928834915, 0.001900884322822094, 0.0023812646977603436, -0.0018496171105653048, 0.07435788959264755, -0.002157936803996563, 0.015020152553915977, -0.025087472051382065, 0.0004995139897800982, 0.015201367437839508, -0.039058618247509, -0.04456436634063721, 0.02450798824429512, 0.014697091653943062, 0.050780829042196274, 0.011804146692156792, 0.057385388761758804, 0.011155725456774235, 0.019693447276949883, 0.004234209191054106, 0.008184399455785751, -0.03930864855647087, 0.003062552772462368, 0.0005264656501822174, -0.006514451932162046, -0.018963221460580826, -0.023119090124964714, 0.004254552070051432, 0.0017803353257477283, -0.030365459620952606, -0.0029976677615195513, 0.023239977657794952, 0.053470317274332047, -0.04230012744665146, -0.03827952966094017, 0.07537507265806198, 0.019711483269929886, -0.043702587485313416, 0.04910721629858017, -0.04199177399277687, -0.027315784245729446, -0.04569730907678604, -0.04710270091891289, 0.022618867456912994, -0.007924193516373634, -0.0038799371104687452, 0.012074354104697704, 0.047057125717401505, -0.009301816113293171, 0.015288145281374454, -0.03438263013958931, 0.03717787563800812, 0.06441880762577057, 0.026705704629421234, 0.05684215575456619, -0.034279219806194305, 0.0031414751429110765, -0.009129076264798641, 0.0168607234954834, -0.038215722888708115, -0.0771038830280304, 0.015475931577384472, 0.04442619904875755, -0.003398364642634988, -0.007405023090541363, -0.018551407381892204, 0.06365355104207993, 0.00018206848471891135, 0.014195999130606651, 0.044158242642879486, 0.01214044913649559, 0.020130377262830734, 0.03048234060406685, -0.008475227281451225, 0.0464140884578228, 0.02876286767423153, 0.00521463667973876, 0.010106939822435379, 0.037772756069898605, 0.0007075009634718299, -0.008238915354013443, 0.02314009703695774, 0.053595781326293945, -0.005975408013910055, -0.012312977574765682, 0.021095886826515198, 0.02781524322926998, -0.01028369553387165, -0.004560344386845827, 0.046105723828077316, 0.012842044234275818, -0.04870401322841644, -0.0026157470420002937, -0.013586923480033875, -0.031470321118831635, 0.03386342525482178, -0.023535849526524544, -0.007140173111110926, 0.018212545663118362, 0.009333482943475246, 0.0017812970327213407, -0.002870033960789442, 0.018241971731185913, -0.05451056733727455, -0.037722986191511154, 0.015253761783242226, -0.00869489461183548, 0.023394273594021797, -0.018450316041707993, -0.029393987730145454, -0.002090318128466606, -0.008523440919816494, 0.00560374092310667, -0.0243485476821661, -0.05593712255358696, -0.018075687810778618, 0.04929225146770477, 0.012840164825320244, 0.02382769249379635, 0.03594842180609703, -0.02686001919209957, 0.030646031722426414, -0.01775742881000042, -0.0858616977930069, -0.021157966926693916, -0.015670929104089737, 0.036913953721523285, -0.03759016469120979, -0.010421853512525558, 0.037189312279224396, -0.006609605625271797, -0.031146321445703506, 0.030277565121650696, -0.030032198876142502, -0.04548992961645126, -0.07572904974222183, 0.01319026667624712, -0.027439847588539124, 0.0112998615950346, 0.005169569980353117, -0.0178378913551569, 0.027138467878103256, -0.016643395647406578, -0.07043967396020889, -0.04152199253439903, -0.003973916172981262, -0.00500963069498539, 0.02585029974579811, 0.005929755046963692, 0.006177539937198162, 0.0349041223526001, 0.03541959822177887, -0.05907284468412399, -0.058676380664110184, -0.029917800799012184, 0.018315166234970093, -0.013928028754889965, 0.02815353311598301, 0.007284832652658224, -0.07299309968948364, -0.016873296350240707, -0.005768991075456142, 0.017361536622047424, 0.044137731194496155, -0.002665810054168105, -0.01558800507336855, 0.013705309480428696, 0.01963665336370468, -0.02354622446000576, 0.05266569182276726, 0.06289985030889511, -0.0386861227452755, 0.05074620246887207, -0.034134555608034134, 0.02791612036526203, 0.03354155272245407, -0.07631611078977585, -0.036837492138147354, 0.003268815577030182, 0.0006189686246216297, -0.043190836906433105, 0.031624965369701385, -0.0030263818334788084, -0.05083823204040527, -0.039863187819719315, 0.04700535908341408, 0.0386623777449131, -0.019306756556034088, -0.04472006857395172, 0.044385869055986404, 0.08957279473543167, -0.05066273361444473, -0.025294393301010132, -0.025369124487042427, -0.020214615389704704, -0.0009906478226184845, -0.03912791237235069, -0.018469156697392464, 0.03210547938942909, 0.0379502959549427, -0.01403938140720129, 0.0013695084489881992, -0.02402506396174431, -0.012498869560658932, -0.07538439333438873, -0.008985593914985657, -0.03840228542685509, 0.06548630446195602, -0.02690894715487957, 0.03675683215260506, -0.00906353909522295, -0.010259118862450123, -0.012403441593050957, 0.017964214086532593, -0.0916367769241333, 0.016996080055832863, 0.0217424426227808, -0.006370506715029478, 0.01273544505238533, -0.010033884085714817, 0.06408185511827469, -0.003469218732789159, 0.011847923509776592, -0.013138486072421074, 0.030668944120407104, -0.032254502177238464, 0.015435902401804924, -0.02915659174323082, -0.012415981851518154, -0.020340483635663986, 0.03394826874136925, 0.04476442560553551, 0.022901594638824463, 0.022729720920324326, 0.014735786244273186, -0.014825145713984966, -0.03692688047885895, -0.04808053374290466, -0.03075335919857025, -0.009402274154126644, 0.009225765243172646, -0.016840189695358276, 0.054785825312137604, -0.017012260854244232, 0.013673902489244938, -0.03138526529073715, 0.03202230855822563, 0.025082610547542572, 0.04018609970808029, 0.026139475405216217, -0.039955295622348785, 0.013119285926222801, 0.0051041883416473866, 0.0209960974752903, -0.007822869345545769, 0.0281305480748415, 0.0301663801074028, 0.011331011541187763, -0.037894055247306824, 0.025604790076613426, 0.028102273121476173, 0.02309226617217064, 0.0099266292527318, -0.014795098453760147, 0.03692058473825455, -0.01237990241497755, 0.013373949564993382, -0.009475184604525566, 0.03103584609925747, 0.04296744614839554, 0.004979721736162901, 0.005822212900966406, -0.011641938239336014, -0.0346633642911911, 0.05493097007274628, -0.014389676041901112, 0.05261983722448349, -0.06112424656748772, -0.03587929531931877, -0.002153510693460703, 0.047295015305280685, 0.04750528186559677, -0.0013538243947550654, -0.01554565504193306, -0.10535681992769241, -0.016746334731578827, 0.016431735828518867, 0.035151515156030655, -0.03721103444695473, -0.006762171164155006, -0.00042701035272330046, -0.033829670399427414, -0.018847398459911346, -0.0007842303020879626, 0.03791724517941475, -0.019043082371354103, 0.0452963151037693, 0.016018901020288467, -0.04363613575696945, 0.013924232684075832, 0.02907682955265045, -0.06272640079259872, 0.01014540996402502, -0.02991241030395031, -0.010348503477871418, -0.057798948138952255, 0.06502507627010345, 0.0032858869526535273, 0.038305118680000305, -0.06561468541622162, -0.004359723534435034, 0.035837020725011826, -0.0111164515838027, -0.03356054797768593, -0.06414700299501419, 0.023022741079330444, 0.03448968380689621, 0.03461674973368645, 0.05382680520415306, -0.004406329710036516, -0.011605747044086456, 0.013792487792670727, 0.03718409687280655, -0.018675148487091064, 0.0025884010829031467, -0.027442362159490585, 0.003465482499450445, 0.03085951879620552, 0.016163459047675133, 0.054004862904548645, 0.05326021835207939, 0.029837343841791153, 0.03171517327427864, -0.01555719319730997, -0.012169335968792439, 0.00135604792740196, 0.011983306147158146, -0.030542105436325073, -0.018514657393097878, -0.03627823293209076, -0.007070424500852823, -0.00038319180021062493, -0.009228898212313652, -0.07151670008897781, -0.0002028916496783495, 0.0018902169540524483, 0.016652332618832588, -0.00907887239009142, -0.018013980239629745, 0.034089021384716034, 0.002297181636095047, -0.00126750732306391, -0.01809190958738327, -0.007807665038853884, -0.06718118488788605, 0.010269585065543652, -0.025298282504081726, 0.023778781294822693, 0.011934109032154083, -0.042886968702077866, -0.02188783325254917, 0.0312550812959671, -0.008828106336295605, 0.03810543566942215, -0.007646022830158472, 0.05243607610464096, 0.030776573345065117, -0.020553912967443466, 0.00468786433339119, 0.010710805654525757, -0.025310499593615532, 0.016292788088321686, -0.001657457323744893, 0.030560098588466644, -0.004306240472942591, -0.06346834450960159, -0.045131467282772064, -0.014861132949590683, 0.04177839681506157, 0.006380097940564156, -0.016896847635507584, -0.060611385852098465, -0.04411184787750244, -0.0068395077250897884, -0.019398966804146767, 0.040175214409828186, 0.002310066483914852, -0.026721017435193062, -0.013129496946930885, 0.009898023679852486, -0.020370889455080032, 0.06053641065955162, -0.014430760405957699, 0.01278762798756361, -0.017507007345557213, 0.02398836612701416, -0.006491451058536768, -0.0077934726141393185, -0.041077278554439545, -0.04034532234072685, 0.000054289615945890546, -0.020807798951864243, -0.026777416467666626, 0.030455904081463814, -0.022500360384583473, -0.004415498115122318, -0.044928211718797684, -0.009955169633030891, -0.00009473326645093039, -0.054166197776794434, 0.0129933413118124, -0.002269906923174858, -0.005777004640549421, -0.02778453379869461, 0.037645552307367325, -0.03888567537069321, 0.01574857160449028, 0.004275484010577202, 0.014179077930748463, 0.013861025683581829, 0.005923022981733084, 0.0787505954504013, -0.01748819462954998, -0.02197614125907421, 0.012936310842633247, -0.017237234860658646, 0.03492647409439087, -0.014005486853420734, -0.01795833185315132, 0.00036864279536530375, 0.042671628296375275, -0.02953970804810524, -0.004408380016684532, -0.03565377742052078, -0.014168326742947102, 0.014071913436055183, -0.004587353207170963, 0.02692907117307186, 0.07254038751125336, 0.0019404750782996416, 0.003209913382306695, -0.029421715065836906, -0.0010114101460203528, -0.009333633817732334, 0.009679141454398632, 0.06513170897960663, -0.01172152254730463, -0.010786260478198528, 0.056055374443531036, 0.015252803452312946, 0.04650582745671272, 0.026437344029545784, 0.016015823930501938, 0.02128727175295353, -0.00427838321775198, -0.02824562042951584, -0.0387001596391201, 0.020537767559289932, -0.018059141933918, 0.00706452876329422, -0.004125507082790136, -0.017947549000382423, 0.051796458661556244, 0.045967184007167816, -0.013922372832894325, -0.0359647236764431, 0.0026775693986564875, -0.06085299327969551, 0.010711955837905407, 0.05835586413741112, 0.017915144562721252, 0.029395362362265587, -0.03551784157752991, 0.026890283450484276, -0.011318245902657509, 0.017182061448693275, 0.004057371988892555, -0.05474719777703285, 0.005114269442856312, -0.014358164742588997, -0.07997702807188034, 0.015896905213594437, -0.012545909732580185, -0.026486245915293694, 0.029960455372929573, -0.009538006037473679, 0.0031116183381527662, 0.027508046478033066, 0.04048565775156021, -0.006980156991630793, 0.06244978308677673, 0.031130017712712288, -0.006974793504923582, -0.023054130375385284, -0.023915139958262444, 0.15495580434799194, 0.052296195179224014, 0.018999498337507248, -0.03428059443831444, -0.02098689414560795, 0.031571779400110245, 0.01125568151473999, -0.048410966992378235, -0.004654357675462961, -0.004403012804687023, 0.04123320057988167, 0.018812060356140137, 0.04347926750779152, 0.024699172005057335, -0.012693584896624088, 0.015767864882946014, -0.006958119571208954, 0.00784455519169569, 0.014731104485690594, -0.02505512163043022, 0.022703710943460464, -0.001218670979142189, -0.05771179124712944, 0.005315725225955248, 0.014041692949831486, 0.005225566681474447, -0.008257188834249973, -0.02238975465297699, -0.010243679396808147, 0.04370906949043274, -0.013620680198073387, 0.08377723395824432, 0.03749262914061546, -0.007637983188033104, 0.0161274541169405, 0.028394492343068123, 0.05052684620022774, -0.025425851345062256, -0.028835712000727654, 0.0694911777973175, 0.021358095109462738, -0.038496360182762146, -0.035260144621133804, 0.023903684690594673, -0.03229101747274399, -0.03130294382572174, -0.03738218545913696, 0.00799292977899313, 0.020483432337641716, -0.01951238326728344, -0.0338590182363987, 0.017637886106967926, 0.013491129502654076, -0.025133559480309486, 0.0044739991426467896, 0.030509253963828087, 0.023392053321003914, -0.011525332927703857, -0.018570035696029663, -0.003118575783446431, 0.017627470195293427, -0.0027657609898597, -0.021420473232865334, 0.047117386013269424, -0.03688803315162659, -0.0343305766582489, -0.04405737668275833, 0.01513688825070858, -0.0002758007904049009, -0.012897349894046783, -0.027911288663744926, -0.06480579823255539, -0.030233483761548996, -0.01634266972541809, 0.0033330130390822887, 0.013054155744612217, -0.022125575691461563, -0.006520435679703951, 0.0381917767226696, -0.033352307975292206, -0.005121135152876377, 0.030598234385252, 0.027366453781723976, -0.016036802902817726, 0.001620654365979135, -0.0014594340464100242, 0.014235440641641617, 0.010522251017391682, 0.04270802438259125, 0.0112504493445158, 0.002590036019682884, 0.0491555854678154, 0.011971713975071907, -0.019217805936932564, -0.05240988731384277, 0.02714431844651699, -0.008914587087929249, 0.00901802722364664, 0.028231875970959663, 0.033404603600502014, 0.011433654464781284, 0.006714263465255499, 0.00844231341034174, 0.0008112690993584692, -0.017985070124268532, 0.016866274178028107, -0.012677759863436222, -0.06107557937502861, 0.008960291743278503, -0.010375085286796093, -0.012301420792937279, -0.02994650788605213, -0.006292921956628561, -0.03371204808354378, -0.013387576676905155, 0.034774743020534515, -0.0202250387519598, -0.04626994952559471, 0.004528924357146025, -0.014882027171552181, 0.03226831182837486, 0.023935338482260704, -0.00403060344979167, -0.026895727962255478, -0.009624539874494076, -0.0033296504989266396, -0.0011335419258102775, -0.03176473453640938, 0.013840793631970882, -0.0024219383485615253, 0.01777579076588154, 0.042563024908304214, 0.00808114092797041, 0.03195936605334282, -0.020271101966500282, 0.0350537933409214, 0.0033993071410804987, -0.008790499530732632, -0.02987174689769745, -0.035399530082941055, 0.05638058856129646, -0.0357416607439518, -0.01304394006729126, 0.02497081086039543, 0.027995355427265167, 0.04149185121059418, 0.020531702786684036, -0.006848827935755253, 0.0037146045360714197, 0.03343740850687027, -0.004620455205440521, -0.05783073231577873, 0.0011852834140881896, -0.005838488694280386, 0.076541967689991, 0.007718630135059357, 0.001161926076747477, 0.016969924792647362, -0.03059992752969265, 0.00025540642673149705, 0.05284930765628815, 0.0010337716666981578, -0.008799027651548386, -0.007436246145516634, -0.019962485879659653, -0.0008617472485639155, 0.012193063274025917, 0.011686810292303562, 0.02144680544734001, 0.028172418475151062, -0.02980300597846508, -0.046386219561100006, -0.0057331593707203865, 0.005961782298982143, -0.024987686425447464, -0.03777046501636505, 0.003540497040376067, 0.027905298396945, 0.036215927451848984, -0.01704644039273262, 0.019734781235456467, 0.013543719425797462, -0.04653649032115936, 0.026131263002753258, 0.0048707895912230015, 0.022318929433822632, -0.02063007839024067, 0.019730057567358017, -0.017293276265263557, 0.0058440337888896465, 0.026076076552271843, 0.0556894913315773, 0.017629362642765045, 0.0324377603828907, 0.01199522614479065, -0.07038761675357819, -0.01206304132938385, -0.02477896958589554, -0.02437581494450569, -0.03670920804142952, 0.06108085438609123, -0.018706059083342552, -0.01729295775294304, 0.005780415143817663, -0.06089892238378525, 0.02472175471484661, -0.004112154711037874, 0.047081563621759415, 0.01869850419461727, 0.018019508570432663, -0.036398474127054214, -0.006128588225692511, 0.0053909881971776485, 0.0010446137748658657, 0.004725227132439613, 0.005242813844233751, 0.00042136217234656215, 0.009899912402033806, 0.04699953645467758, 0.005851528141647577, -0.06420887261629105, 0.010653529316186905, -0.009975808672606945, 0.025743821635842323, -0.005236204247921705, -0.03962578997015953, 0.009209834970533848, -0.023427581414580345, -0.02279805578291416, -0.04178408905863762, 0.04093201458454132, 0.035312194377183914, -0.033579397946596146, -0.038900621235370636, 0.004764096345752478, -0.002172744134441018, -0.015977315604686737, 0.028755469247698784, 0.005780736915767193, -0.013769579119980335, -0.0594739206135273, -0.00865159835666418, -0.004503484815359116, -0.01802873983979225, 0.013609523884952068, 0.04061146825551987, -0.0011445156997069716, 0.01620294526219368, 0.031891997903585434, -0.037332985550165176, 0.007185626309365034, -0.031226543709635735, 0.0381079725921154, -0.07832245528697968, 0.01480845920741558, 0.04944434016942978, -0.007872012443840504, -0.05527389794588089, -0.013107970356941223, -0.02291957661509514, 0.045379988849163055, 0.05635718256235123, -0.004431552719324827, -0.02597985975444317, -0.05654343217611313, -0.009029087610542774, 0.006736245006322861, -0.036616723984479904, 0.04674602672457695, -0.002665553241968155, 0.0038562407717108727, -0.02628401294350624, 0.0246135164052248, -0.011180715635418892, -0.0237658079713583, 0.013349592685699463, -0.028599172830581665, -0.010590477846562862, 0.001045375713147223, -0.012656130827963352, 0.018001768738031387, 0.012118836864829063, 0.0027005563024431467, 0.00372394360601902, 0.00037009085644967854, -0.0003089972888119519, 0.04229120537638664, 0.016057658940553665, -0.08891405910253525, 0.04639078304171562, -0.0522882305085659, 0.005719436332583427, -0.04007822275161743, 0.012092139571905136, 0.02476310543715954, -0.050674788653850555, -0.009726136922836304, 0.03768099471926689, -0.022879060357809067, -0.021662523970007896, 0.039971355348825455, 0.013474557548761368, 0.06527675688266754, -0.031446948647499084, 0.012626980431377888, 0.015603885985910892, -0.07650487869977951, 0.012737286277115345, 0.014778103679418564, 0.046712178736925125, -0.012944542802870274, 0.008524365723133087, 0.0308542400598526, 0.012762779369950294, 0.021384606137871742, 0.011573727242648602, 0.03220317140221596, -0.030539248138666153, 0.018848439678549767, 0.02122410386800766, -0.02619030699133873, -0.0015163896605372429, 0.0593247190117836, -0.002593799727037549, 0.04596887156367302, -0.023152759298682213, 0.009189405478537083, -0.054078176617622375, -0.0033941580913960934, -0.0295808557420969, 0.02129916287958622, -0.00027986036729998887, 0.024846557527780533, -0.0048886933363974094, -0.015442992560565472, -0.02252640388906002, 0.0158995334059, 0.024044061079621315, -0.01732492446899414, 0.03838074207305908, -0.006169062107801437, -0.004164645913988352, 0.01144841406494379, -0.011170949786901474, -0.025280285626649857, -0.025223998352885246, 0.03375856578350067, 0.02444775030016899, -0.009925629012286663, -0.02002844773232937, 0.006434346083551645, -0.04835079610347748, 0.0273541659116745, -0.023651262745261192, -0.04226784035563469, -0.03943952918052673, 0.008871377445757389, -0.019969329237937927, -0.03335926681756973 ]
<p>I'm trying to make sense of these two statements about UMP (uniformly most powerful) tests: </p> <ol> <li><p>If $g(t\mid\theta)~$ is a UMP then $~g(t\mid\theta_1)&gt;k g(t\mid\theta_0)~\forall~t\in C$ and $g(t\mid\theta_1)&lt;k g(t\mid\theta_0)~\forall~t\in C^c$</p></li> <li><p>For $\mathbf X~i.i.d.~f(x\mid\theta): \theta\in\Omega\subset\mathcal R$ if $f(x\mid\theta)$ has an MLR in $T(x)$ and any $k$, a test that rejects $H_0 \iff T&gt;k~$ is a UMP test of size $\alpha$ with $\alpha=P_{\theta_0}(T&gt;k)$</p></li> </ol> <p>Why are these statements not tautological? How are they not the definition of <em>any</em> one-tailed statistical test? What would be an example of a one-tailed statistical test that isn't a UMP? </p> <p>Moreover, what is the relationship between LRT and UMP tests? I'm reviewing old exams where sometimes a question asks for an LRT and sometimes a UMP... Aren't all simple LRT tests UMP?</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
74,510
[ -0.03806788846850395, -0.04443839192390442, 0.0216740220785141, -0.012057546526193619, 0.0009535735589452088, 0.027946576476097107, 0.006193942856043577, -0.025488197803497314, -0.001440830179490149, -0.009691542945802212, 0.030815398320555687, 0.007186937145888805, 0.07252226024866104, 0.003541612299159169, 0.011134663596749306, -0.03286208584904671, -0.043118059635162354, 0.030048944056034088, 0.0024014455266296864, -0.026958182454109192, 0.023560255765914917, 0.04549607262015343, 0.04045740142464638, -0.0047472212463617325, 0.045636747032403946, -0.004047822672873735, 0.005057957489043474, 0.020961668342351913, 0.015235712751746178, 0.08035716414451599, -0.04510416090488434, -0.019722996279597282, -0.014783620834350586, -0.004104380030184984, 0.010023722425103188, 0.011318190023303032, -0.034168075770139694, 0.02983226254582405, 0.009583650156855583, 0.0295516736805439, -0.016888929530978203, -0.05877304822206497, 0.0063414191827178, 0.013684707693755627, -0.0033064072486013174, 0.016149461269378662, -0.024295130744576454, -0.03148902207612991, 0.0399208627641201, -0.01284787431359291, 0.01512457337230444, 0.0046759978868067265, -0.012510472908616066, 0.03506113216280937, 0.010407722555100918, 0.02309863455593586, 0.030022140592336655, 0.07275833934545517, -0.03913620114326477, -0.02562425099313259, -0.015730036422610283, -0.04246986284852028, 0.04043211787939072, 0.012154473923146725, -0.04521873965859413, 0.06372807919979095, 0.004173897672444582, -0.016405541449785233, 0.042372435331344604, -0.007648819591850042, 0.006073111668229103, 0.03853124380111694, 0.00037282059201970696, 0.04189465939998627, -0.008909390307962894, 0.02220023237168789, -0.012882118113338947, 0.01648034155368805, 0.06851207464933395, 0.07016883045434952, -0.010084695182740688, 0.03167359158396721, 0.0005772088188678026, 0.03774890676140785, 0.024246517568826675, 0.013756885193288326, 0.08080369979143143, 0.0014632995007559657, -0.002564531983807683, 0.02200848050415516, -0.016956495121121407, -0.036023762077093124, 0.026945598423480988, -0.02848772332072258, -0.06250473111867905, 0.009982222691178322, -0.021553238853812218, -0.01208239421248436, -0.020125683397054672, 0.0018756375648081303, -0.015089740045368671, -0.04436352103948593, 0.034312933683395386, 0.04197198897600174, 0.02200654335319996, -0.021484985947608948, -0.002062239684164524, 0.01617424376308918, 0.004480487667024136, 0.004982649814337492, -0.01410429272800684, 0.0507519505918026, 0.014534358866512775, 0.0063294777646660805, -0.01269302237778902, 0.04686790332198143, -0.023599257692694664, 0.001245428342372179, 0.02533234842121601, 0.036265332251787186, 0.04530228674411774, 0.007505880203098059, 0.015145570039749146, -0.05518113449215889, -0.05960362032055855, 0.037344079464673996, 0.010654185898602009, -0.020966634154319763, -0.02047405019402504, 0.051361579447984695, -0.00996269378811121, -0.02712961472570896, 0.033343356102705, 0.05318358913064003, 0.07409226149320602, -0.019254226237535477, -0.10996102541685104, -0.04513634368777275, 0.03477580100297928, 0.03420712426304817, 0.026048149913549423, -0.010248333215713501, 0.006075539160519838, 0.046932466328144073, 0.03480120748281479, -0.007929172366857529, 0.03917969390749931, -0.015110871754586697, -0.010891995392739773, 0.03818611800670624, -0.021665289998054504, -0.014253382571041584, -0.04337088018655777, -0.015403391793370247, -0.01256655529141426, -0.07490590214729309, 0.0460810512304306, 0.012164877727627754, 0.001716618542559445, -0.035805441439151764, 0.08874744921922684, -0.005824057850986719, -0.0019814714323729277, -0.03978342190384865, 0.006392288953065872, 0.009449545294046402, 0.10897208005189896, 0.03671000152826309, 0.005982830189168453, 0.006327482406049967, 0.01201594527810812, 0.011950306594371796, 0.011021695099771023, 0.0418238565325737, 0.011475921608507633, -0.0181676484644413, -0.01891191676259041, -0.04903237894177437, 0.006950711831450462, 0.02590212970972061, -0.034761298447847366, 0.016856668516993523, -0.014390692114830017, -0.040469229221343994, -0.00012630019045900553, 0.04114341363310814, -0.01233851071447134, -0.026423899456858635, 0.06341942399740219, -0.03987841680645943, -0.032361142337322235, -0.03853742778301239, 0.0027604387141764164, -0.003577524796128273, -0.045375607907772064, 0.03991728276014328, 0.0004954955657012761, 0.016025373712182045, -0.02365678921341896, -0.009301410056650639, -0.01092476025223732, 0.003485816763713956, -0.01308633666485548, -0.018727155402302742, 0.018796317279338837, 0.04034237936139107, 0.03211422637104988, -0.007715611252933741, 0.04065043106675148, -0.04239998012781143, -0.05832401290535927, 0.01062892097979784, -0.04751310870051384, -0.006223534233868122, 0.006756817921996117, -0.013467078097164631, 0.005399296525865793, -0.01836320571601391, 0.016883715987205505, 0.07048393785953522, -0.04925936833024025, 0.01586918905377388, 0.038671985268592834, 0.032143812626600266, 0.007485533133149147, 0.009811118245124817, 0.014501286670565605, -0.01659289561212063, -0.04352216050028801, 0.004851384554058313, -0.05264910310506821, -0.009772364981472492, 0.06722686439752579, 0.021975744515657425, -0.024801084771752357, 0.014541351236402988, 0.04261401668190956, 0.0614485889673233, -0.013652786612510681, 0.04435480013489723, -0.032112594693899155, -0.05063457041978836, 0.0238861795514822, 0.011189145036041737, 0.03319625183939934, -0.025607002899050713, -0.02238023281097412, 0.018209712579846382, 0.01271622721105814, 0.018728580325841904, 0.00168428139295429, 0.05473451316356659, 0.008807838894426823, -0.015642376616597176, -0.01348759513348341, 0.0008915577200241387, 0.0380934476852417, -0.027982326224446297, -0.003529546083882451, 0.02295685186982155, 0.0112420953810215, -0.0001519306533737108, -0.012281526811420918, -0.009766963310539722, 0.04015197232365608, 0.0005943021969869733, -0.016106000170111656, -0.029031803831458092, 0.035956479609012604, -0.011725368909537792, -0.015991777181625366, -0.04409725219011307, -0.027349015697836876, -0.015049539506435394, 0.019133593887090683, 0.026573264971375465, 0.003460943466052413, 0.04375724866986275, -0.026990430429577827, -0.017793890088796616, -0.006084032356739044, -0.05665072798728943, 0.020820453763008118, -0.004888196010142565, -0.04313608631491661, 0.016875363886356354, -0.020680343732237816, -0.014094538055360317, 0.04377821460366249, 0.018167855218052864, 0.018876956775784492, 0.034474361687898636, -0.0030239184852689505, -0.06022709980607033, -0.03515652194619179, -0.04896080121397972, -0.00740851741284132, -0.011925708502531052, -0.03910517692565918, 0.05241728946566582, 0.015596884302794933, -0.015455778688192368, 0.025754563510417938, -0.033710967749357224, 0.002379694953560829, -0.012867800891399384, 0.0026331651024520397, 0.02430778183043003, 0.0019738662522286177, 0.02139231748878956, 0.01790144294500351, -0.10261282324790955, -0.04426988214254379, -0.06799201667308807, -0.0396273247897625, -0.0035243560560047626, -0.03449973091483116, 0.051554374396800995, -0.0033095532562583685, -0.050784818828105927, 0.048148803412914276, 0.04128396883606911, -0.013603508472442627, -0.018115568906068802, 0.002973982598632574, -0.019692877307534218, -0.003832328598946333, 0.001980067929252982, 0.007179398089647293, -0.007361400872468948, 0.05137175694108009, 0.019077714532613754, 0.0035508153960108757, 0.046153903007507324, 0.021976640447974205, 0.0048767984844744205, 0.013472686521708965, -0.02127082832157612, -0.010885758325457573, 0.02420848421752453, 0.05607245862483978, -0.010061593726277351, -0.0008749248227104545, 0.013868923299014568, 0.01972641795873642, 0.023006685078144073, -0.07126667350530624, 0.04421866312623024, 0.015727449208498, 0.0005425550625659525, -0.009242587722837925, 0.05299735814332962, 0.034996397793293, -0.03109634481370449, -0.020343244075775146, 0.02168199233710766, 0.01679707132279873, -0.03641948103904724, 0.00825158879160881, 0.0137082040309906, 0.0740417093038559, -0.024289026856422424, -0.045730676501989365, -0.022403014823794365, 0.0030687577091157436, 0.02339739352464676, -0.04113210737705231, -0.04311345890164375, 0.05087269842624664, 0.025209276005625725, 0.020266881212592125, -0.01296019647270441, -0.037630025297403336, -0.010569448582828045, -0.015132375061511993, 0.00041726516792550683, -0.011950582265853882, 0.04826079681515694, 0.004016056191176176, 0.01926593855023384, 0.037569809705019, 0.000014406782611331437, -0.04551665112376213, 0.02574734389781952, -0.07195522636175156, 0.020993873476982117, -0.039389461278915405, -0.03893910348415375, 0.03162820637226105, 0.02378622442483902, 0.02849704772233963, 0.012096748687326908, 0.001288525527343154, 0.0004249995981808752, 0.02783908322453499, -0.055642884224653244, 0.025641310960054398, -0.00958971306681633, -0.03583201766014099, -0.020742440596222878, 0.02682134136557579, 0.02456594631075859, -0.032884519547224045, 0.01269079651683569, 0.07536507397890091, -0.01661458984017372, 0.005747981369495392, -0.020413581281900406, 0.031738728284835815, 0.03053271770477295, 0.0242767296731472, 0.029422322288155556, 0.017351845279335976, -0.022512884810566902, 0.03374163806438446, 0.03791104257106781, 0.08639475703239441, 0.03180459141731262, -0.04006426781415939, -0.03711044043302536, -0.07122563570737839, -0.03145623207092285, 0.006349848583340645, 0.04543960839509964, 0.02795478329062462, -0.0446755588054657, 0.056535083800554276, 0.031648021191358566, 0.02621539682149887, 0.027335289865732193, 0.04931199178099632, 0.002282378962263465, 0.0013631730107590556, -0.010748321190476418, -0.01193923968821764, -0.002757060108706355, -0.008377781137824059, 0.018444329500198364, 0.014119734987616539, 0.03674029931426048, -0.024396849796175957, 0.043385010212659836, -0.024064546450972557, -0.03139004856348038, -0.033429548144340515, 0.009714020416140556, 0.028085337951779366, -0.016641683876514435, -0.056506574153900146, 0.011534984223544598, 0.04182511940598488, 0.032586004585027695, 0.02280125394463539, 0.015915194526314735, -0.03765544295310974, 0.043796148151159286, 0.040616475045681, 0.025138135999441147, 0.018166644498705864, -0.02783854864537716, -0.0068607633002102375, -0.001485392334870994, 0.06692701578140259, -0.02277073636651039, 0.04876670241355896, 0.006045076996088028, 0.001282262266613543, -0.05096562206745148, -0.04656974971294403, -0.036090362817049026, 0.0132893742993474, -0.005492555908858776, 0.03758430480957031, -0.03326106444001198, -0.020563634112477303, -0.026505447924137115, -0.019261011853814125, 0.00379713112488389, 0.03802747279405594, -0.03249521180987358, -0.029806261882185936, 0.009295610710978508, 0.03724794462323189, -0.029882656410336494, -0.04512028768658638, -0.006229672115296125, -0.01368339266628027, -0.0034202185925096273, 0.04066763445734978, -0.04468674212694168, -0.06950623542070389, 0.032436419278383255, 0.01973661035299301, -0.037384044378995895, 0.01992836594581604, -0.03040608949959278, 0.0243461262434721, 0.03259320929646492, 0.03618156537413597, 0.07152456045150757, 0.02752533182501793, -0.009574688039720058, -0.008068826049566269, -0.02268584817647934, 0.01042178738862276, -0.034551527351140976, -0.011719760484993458, -0.06272212415933609, -0.06127900257706642, -0.057384394109249115, 0.03688187897205353, 0.0325031653046608, -0.01910886913537979, -0.027265246957540512, -0.01575050875544548, -0.027759402990341187, 0.008681617677211761, 0.036455653607845306, -0.00010102280066348612, 0.003924827557057142, 0.0035921356175094843, -0.0007639528485015035, 0.01737246848642826, 0.02653193101286888, -0.045749325305223465, 0.03235502168536186, 0.011032280512154102, 0.009131478145718575, -0.01222314964979887, 0.010065884329378605, 0.002521602204069495, 0.0029006609693169594, -0.015788216143846512, 0.034938376396894455, -0.008287440054118633, 0.016521194949746132, 0.021673481911420822, -0.05293161794543266, -0.018884237855672836, 0.015654953196644783, 0.010862117633223534, 0.013948704116046429, -0.05834915488958359, 0.008916261605918407, -0.00028094524168409407, -0.013094039633870125, -0.04299410060048103, -0.006254138890653849, 0.029010973870754242, 0.02668950892984867, -0.002226108219474554, 0.0005370283615775406, -0.004382051061838865, -0.022392088547348976, -0.037178996950387955, -0.04769438877701759, 0.03986108675599098, 0.0263490192592144, -0.003595667891204357, -0.007515523582696915, 0.05368969216942787, 0.07974699139595032, 0.002977869939059019, -0.007812697440385818, 0.027746517211198807, -0.031574785709381104, 0.011654382571578026, 0.005036034155637026, 0.015556246042251587, -0.030701113864779472, -0.03846471384167671, -0.05102447047829628, -0.033689677715301514, -0.008783851750195026, -0.019573628902435303, -0.0715358629822731, 0.029388222843408585, -0.03735123947262764, 0.0012766908621415496, -0.0048911068588495255, -0.020570755004882812, 0.005789410322904587, 0.02944776602089405, -0.0013509122654795647, 0.0119557473808527, 0.0034578212071210146, -0.03177887946367264, -0.002227851189672947, -0.004840896464884281, -0.003442122135311365, 0.05394098535180092, 0.09978898614645004, -0.024485252797603607, 0.019863996654748917, -0.01685812696814537, -0.005090963561087847, 0.016141526401042938, 0.0011054821079596877, 0.0024154435377568007, 0.009026890620589256, 0.001141156884841621, -0.027186471968889236, -0.012956293299794197, -0.020011842250823975, 0.025240201503038406, 0.03935905545949936, -0.00629657506942749, 0.024555454030632973, 0.025723833590745926, -0.016296012327075005, -0.025500748306512833, -0.021261949092149734, -0.02553469128906727, -0.01723421737551689, -0.0049818227998912334, 0.03023889847099781, -0.002178268041461706, -0.0091658690944314, 0.05626484006643295, -0.0014875283231958747, 0.018460247665643692, -0.027548031881451607, 0.02868463844060898, 0.041311394423246384, 0.014875870198011398, -0.023611655458807945, -0.03112492337822914, 0.033745717257261276, -0.050606198608875275, 0.01588914357125759, 0.02537209913134575, -0.008282173424959183, 0.029689345508813858, 0.03760905936360359, 0.0006852579535916448, -0.08407330513000488, -0.000895123346708715, -0.05890943109989166, 0.028156569227576256, 0.012345566414296627, 0.015521901659667492, 0.03535659983754158, -0.018367595970630646, 0.026231328025460243, 0.002885914407670498, 0.03638933226466179, 0.009914333000779152, -0.058525752276182175, -0.04080401360988617, 0.008222874253988266, -0.05571318045258522, 0.019814029335975647, -0.0008407629793509841, -0.015426268801093102, 0.01386903878301382, -0.03506546467542648, 0.03424686938524246, 0.018610065802931786, 0.04513753205537796, -0.033144138753414154, 0.05607280135154724, 0.018913865089416504, 0.04156897962093353, -0.03670329600572586, -0.051027409732341766, 0.1197686567902565, 0.028015555813908577, 0.028769774362444878, -0.05284135043621063, 0.014621799811720848, -0.019370896741747856, -0.012490876019001007, -0.04351673275232315, 0.0158931165933609, 0.002981066470965743, 0.016151150688529015, 0.030816132202744484, 0.06610499322414398, -0.007187703158706427, -0.019731609150767326, 0.08250347524881363, -0.04914611205458641, -0.03107331693172455, 0.028137369081377983, -0.007519539911299944, 0.001490956638008356, -0.024678198620676994, -0.02409449592232704, -0.00946019683033228, 0.01789797656238079, 0.007642798125743866, -0.012891452759504318, -0.030094200745224953, 0.035064518451690674, -0.007317361421883106, -0.004330650437623262, -0.016241928562521935, 0.0043226988054811954, -0.007073190528899431, -0.012263447046279907, -0.011066663078963757, 0.026327641680836678, -0.03167681023478508, 0.019276807084679604, 0.05067971721291542, 0.013988434337079525, -0.014100386761128902, 0.018520426005125046, 0.006516389083117247, -0.020053675398230553, 0.006003885064274073, -0.04639424383640289, 0.018049394711852074, -0.016670916229486465, 0.03852682188153267, -0.009520034305751324, 0.007906519807875156, -0.019181234762072563, -0.03279221057891846, 0.015762729570269585, 0.009471675381064415, 0.02919922024011612, -0.0466894656419754, -0.0019301045686006546, -0.030949333682656288, 0.026767663657665253, -0.006685453467071056, 0.05250050127506256, -0.041973777115345, -0.06053328141570091, -0.015867499634623528, -0.036291543394327164, 0.007021012250334024, 0.009307852946221828, -0.017673762515187263, -0.01473085954785347, 0.014565025456249714, -0.022985883057117462, 0.024964462965726852, -0.000674332317430526, -0.020970970392227173, 0.05889972299337387, -0.008583609946072102, -0.0013782678870484233, -0.0323820598423481, -0.029853355139493942, 0.0284196175634861, -0.05201146379113197, -0.03103223443031311, -0.05928054079413414, -0.025226686149835587, -0.018992308527231216, 0.0022402333561331034, 0.03249009698629379, -0.023864086717367172, -0.0032170708291232586, 0.07095654308795929, 0.0023208248894661665, -0.06726314127445221, -0.03538420423865318, -0.04251684620976448, -0.01134453434497118, -0.016450103372335434, -0.012136902660131454, 0.02499549835920334, 0.042417190968990326, -0.003127029165625572, -0.055190254002809525, 0.03266631066799164, 0.0025512268766760826, 0.002395742340013385, 0.02952314168214798, -0.02762620523571968, 0.006694610696285963, 0.060657721012830734, 0.030057139694690704, -0.01149648055434227, -0.06511827558279037, -0.027571966871619225, -0.025752073153853416, 0.027883661910891533, -0.0482344925403595, -0.036754947155714035, -0.009761047549545765, 0.029500095173716545, 0.04225969687104225, -0.009214424528181553, -0.007150955032557249, -0.014334308914840221, -0.008693479001522064, -0.004097297787666321, -0.010432366281747818, 0.016690008342266083, 0.033486831933259964, -0.04300844296813011, -0.023088740184903145, 0.014051142148673534, 0.0507228784263134, -0.010201886296272278, 0.0040945494547486305, 0.00906982272863388, -0.009393041022121906, 0.027796223759651184, -0.002541015623137355, -0.00010294694948242977, 0.05913913622498512, -0.01095725130289793, -0.056183334439992905, 0.028501031920313835, -0.005585482809692621, 0.027234496548771858, 0.009833406656980515, -0.0031092397402971983, -0.016130954027175903, -0.012082613073289394, -0.01282633189111948, 0.003915911540389061, -0.02347460389137268, -0.023012783378362656, 0.0008791743312031031, -0.006478439085185528, 0.02394382655620575, 0.006956329103559256, 0.0075117358937859535, -0.0031523604411631823, 0.048130325973033905, -0.007552406284958124, -0.013673699460923672, -0.006264528725296259, -0.00900210440158844, 0.037978511303663254, 0.007246071472764015, 0.01645866595208645, 0.03748977929353714, 0.07108648121356964, -0.027582257986068726, 0.03970208019018173, -0.022582687437534332, 0.02076363004744053, -0.0749489888548851, -0.03662966191768646, 0.01568424701690674, 0.010348085314035416, 0.03191942721605301, -0.025501158088445663, -0.012946177273988724, 0.02511650323867798, -0.04902150109410286, -0.024479540064930916, -0.025468874722719193, -0.043765854090452194, -0.03942215070128441, -0.02519902214407921, -0.0032838089391589165, 0.023527082055807114, 0.0017677738796919584, 0.006399707868695259, 0.018430355936288834, 0.04855905473232269, -0.019425921142101288, -0.00033839180832728744, -0.04133348539471626, 0.013871566392481327, 0.0038191538769751787, -0.05556188523769379, 0.04198228940367699, -0.030792074277997017, -0.007118231616914272, 0.031953152269124985, -0.032547902315855026, -0.0061143445782363415, -0.004193659871816635, 0.020870322361588478, 0.01935013197362423, 0.038806263357400894, 0.05956847965717316, -0.0061262729577720165, -0.013467601500451565, 0.008170119486749172, 0.00023217334819491953, 0.04702577739953995, -0.010491040535271168, -0.030606212094426155, 0.004774827044457197, -0.019834721460938454, -0.011149391531944275, 0.008898106403648853, -0.003359681461006403, -0.007419542409479618, -0.024312689900398254, -0.013500346802175045, -0.003887301543727517, 0.006353807635605335, 0.03355452045798302, -0.027448926120996475, 0.00074915518052876, 0.006386976223438978, 0.019481951370835304, 0.004998084623366594, -0.00025725903105922043, 0.008739440701901913, -0.03549995645880699, 0.008587270975112915, -0.024860700592398643, -0.013366203755140305, -0.05891913175582886, -0.015043220482766628, -0.04204055294394493, 0.0008513944339938462, 0.005217657424509525, -0.017513873055577278, -0.010786924511194229, 0.00908947829157114, -0.04401666298508644, -0.006528966128826141, -0.034949567168951035, 0.008915671147406101, -0.00862029753625393, -0.08693715184926987, 0.06382060050964355, -0.0053564682602882385, 0.03190850093960762, -0.011043508537113667, -0.025021841749548912, 0.0018969201482832432, 0.0027114092372357845, 0.042619965970516205, 0.004802755545824766, 0.020041918382048607, 0.040090713649988174, -0.008689135313034058, 0.001748364418745041, -0.04249463975429535, 0.017658455297350883, -0.019184675067663193, 0.009820516221225262, -0.011518650688230991, -0.018790654838085175, 0.05598505958914757, -0.004413737449795008, 0.03817911446094513, 0.01521974802017212, 0.013246164657175541, -0.020890986546874046, -0.00242639915086329, 0.029112232849001884, 0.011513750068843365, -0.033236127346754074, 0.04994219169020653, 0.0007740257424302399, 0.03771049529314041, -0.01962185651063919, 0.017234809696674347, -0.05649019405245781, 0.04330051317811012, -0.027837499976158142, -0.015367698855698109, -0.01597677357494831, 0.02643493376672268, 0.027910377830266953, -0.05425514280796051, -0.0744478851556778, 0.015152419917285442, -0.00002311140087840613, -0.012452244758605957, 0.012913089245557785, 0.0000665922780171968, 0.021914636716246605, 0.007570982910692692, -0.02806333638727665, 0.0029463921673595905, -0.04851187393069267, -0.0004933164454996586, 0.01587250642478466, 0.02103649638593197, 0.0161025058478117, 0.023249246180057526, 0.015877531841397285, -0.05799061059951782, 0.023721972480416298, -0.013698076829314232, 0.05379528924822807, -0.029433082789182663, -0.04747834429144859, 0.011404955759644508, -0.001512240502052009, -0.01868278719484806, 0.028299326077103615, -0.00787767581641674, 0.060569148510694504, -0.01937832310795784, -0.0014842974487692118, -0.04559965059161186, -0.010851932689547539, 0.04636089876294136, 0.0175781212747097, 0.05341097339987755, 0.007908870466053486, -0.005598989315330982, -0.016817251220345497, 0.015587897039949894, 0.011690111830830574, 0.04898722097277641, -0.030811911448836327, -0.008527910336852074, 0.019747840240597725, -0.0024035160895437002, -0.03452680632472038, -0.04429701343178749, -0.04121674224734306, -0.0038707598578184843, 0.049568090587854385, 0.007048563566058874, 0.04178856685757637, -0.04144716262817383, -0.04191796854138374, -0.011851077899336815, 0.06700838357210159, -0.04550279304385185, -0.0071348762139678, -0.021840497851371765, 0.0011945420410484076, -0.0028532142750918865, -0.03179699182510376 ]
<p>In the following example:</p> <pre><code>x &lt;- rnorm(100) y &lt;- rpois(100, exp(1+x))+10 g1 &lt;- glm(y ~ x, family = Gamma(link = "log")) par(mfrow = c(2,2)) plot(y~x) plot(y,resid(g1)) plot(y,resid(g1$lm)) </code></pre> <p>I am trying to look at the pattern in the predictor variable, i.e. if the model is 'correct' there should be no patterns left in the residuals when plotted against the predictor. From the example shown, which residual am I suppose to use, <code>resid(g1)</code> or <code>resid(g1$lm)</code>, or something else? </p> <p>Same goes when using a <code>gam</code>, is that <code>resid(g1$lm)</code>, <code>resid(g1$gam)</code>? I find this very confusing. </p>
74,511
[ -0.001562098623253405, 0.016847310587763786, -0.017958374693989754, 0.0049927616491913795, 0.009165388531982899, 0.03172298148274422, 0.010515086352825165, -0.036917079240083694, 0.0218490157276392, -0.02010468579828739, 0.025784621015191078, 0.05008446052670479, 0.05472052842378616, -0.005594913382083178, 0.09322352707386017, -0.01519136130809784, 0.0048864251002669334, -0.0009212978766299784, 0.036650802940130234, -0.050418075174093246, -0.004698574542999268, -0.014056621119379997, 0.0052752443589270115, -0.01128574088215828, -0.012592758983373642, 0.06876210123300552, 0.026662753894925117, 0.03789113089442253, 0.05500878393650055, 0.03616118058562279, -0.021314896643161774, -0.03175355866551399, -0.034986741840839386, 0.018702831119298935, 0.005303974729031324, 0.02085491642355919, 0.010483644902706146, -0.032044924795627594, -0.0032338062301278114, 0.03539888560771942, -0.0010602206457406282, -0.0060756322927773, 0.014858131296932697, 0.0475425161421299, -0.018144605681300163, 0.0016981010558083653, -0.01752866432070732, 0.001992632634937763, 0.08388076722621918, -0.01776263304054737, 0.03833338990807533, -0.013400235213339329, 0.026941794902086258, 0.034681376069784164, -0.026832258328795433, 0.00746402982622385, 0.07017942517995834, 0.05010414496064186, -0.031137945130467415, -0.07410383224487305, -0.005863663740456104, -0.014740319922566414, 0.02191489189863205, 0.023426493629813194, -0.03123464062809944, 0.012472926639020443, 0.014938663691282272, -0.037846580147743225, 0.06416407227516174, -0.009146804921329021, 0.014676658436655998, 0.02017214708030224, 0.035979919135570526, -0.022836321964859962, 0.037604402750730515, -0.019985666498541832, -0.008707049302756786, 0.0016948216361925006, 0.036834049969911575, 0.038062334060668945, -0.006474450696259737, 0.02387824095785618, -0.0011114291846752167, 0.05290309712290764, -0.014324159361422062, 0.016505533829331398, 0.03815227001905441, -0.025305133312940598, 0.046124957501888275, 0.023405374959111214, -0.013114431872963905, 0.02975567802786827, 0.03909854218363762, 0.019861115142703056, -0.04155047610402107, 0.05554291233420372, -0.013443888165056705, 0.01909102313220501, 0.030279360711574554, 0.005697308573871851, -0.031162718310952187, -0.06243564933538437, 0.009973504580557346, 0.028384746983647346, -0.05273061245679855, -0.01087727677077055, -0.025697994977235794, -0.009606124833226204, -0.00457460293546319, -0.032888513058423996, -0.009308072738349438, 0.04413995146751404, 0.0019030164694413543, 0.02131982520222664, 0.029694311320781708, -0.0359201580286026, 0.0069954292848706245, 0.03924458473920822, 0.05635795742273331, 0.03809840977191925, 0.030095558613538742, -0.017621930688619614, 0.018375596031546593, 0.010124952532351017, -0.05190799757838249, -0.006286643911153078, 0.034460119903087616, -0.005425106734037399, -0.02438005432486534, 0.036208853125572205, -0.03918571025133133, -0.02823593094944954, 0.029058152809739113, 0.009896552190184593, 0.02387174405157566, -0.007773476652801037, -0.06050146743655205, -0.04494870454072952, 0.026539962738752365, -0.0005845305859111249, 0.019708940759301186, -0.0629332885146141, -0.0016522543737664819, 0.0036629808600991964, 0.04174818843603134, 0.010271713137626648, 0.016200240701436996, 0.01438758336007595, -0.004358039237558842, 0.0012653786689043045, -0.05166952684521675, -0.020146595314145088, -0.013118550181388855, -0.04392119497060776, -0.03928479552268982, -0.06731420010328293, -0.01663825660943985, 0.027290191501379013, -0.020479507744312286, -0.005916852969676256, 0.04879285395145416, -0.03521918132901192, -0.0067330412566661835, -0.0060723875649273396, -0.025574255734682083, -0.009889218956232071, 0.08746222406625748, -0.007529886905103922, 0.06289149820804596, 0.039844367653131485, 0.005133704282343388, 0.004164241719990969, -0.010044286027550697, 0.021302493289113045, 0.05954402685165405, -0.013736143708229065, -0.0055958121083676815, -0.03740667551755905, 0.0330544076859951, 0.022346656769514084, -0.05901540815830231, -0.04062163084745407, -0.013071173802018166, -0.006511515937745571, 0.01059485599398613, -0.008222703821957111, 0.011232842691242695, -0.021049439907073975, 0.0412098690867424, -0.03726855292916298, -0.07799487560987473, -0.05366179347038269, -0.00027935177786275744, 0.002307595917955041, -0.00618521636351943, 0.020060107111930847, 0.011099438183009624, 0.03067466989159584, 0.003953948151320219, -0.01831868849694729, -0.026810113340616226, -0.015798557549715042, 0.024931466206908226, -0.04718935862183571, -0.03988351672887802, 0.000570035248529166, 0.039947591722011566, -0.0151669317856431, 0.06417031586170197, -0.04474112018942833, -0.011189323849976063, 0.026068389415740967, -0.026650361716747284, 0.006886194460093975, -0.02501700073480606, -0.04446082562208176, 0.011089753359556198, 0.03619774803519249, -0.016375310719013214, 0.042138487100601196, -0.05600094795227051, 0.011328712105751038, 0.07472262531518936, 0.0274959784001112, -0.04453658685088158, -0.02488965168595314, -0.02336771972477436, 0.03491448238492012, -0.05803191661834717, 0.009041626006364822, -0.0091653261333704, -0.0584055595099926, 0.05611822381615639, 0.0038711577653884888, -0.019840171560645103, 0.028632737696170807, 0.08204841613769531, 0.00017586167086847126, 0.015057642944157124, 0.05900774151086807, 0.015523968264460564, -0.03502218797802925, 0.0049828942865133286, 0.03695785999298096, 0.01324152946472168, 0.015891067683696747, 0.04714234173297882, -0.0030461838468909264, -0.0007918496266938746, 0.0007750238873995841, 0.013419228605926037, 0.05805506557226181, -0.02196543477475643, -0.0049879783764481544, -0.007415746338665485, -0.01771029271185398, 0.05044063925743103, -0.004748313222080469, 0.006848915014415979, 0.012914329767227173, 0.015211397781968117, -0.03836725652217865, -0.019472796469926834, -0.013750961981713772, -0.017777565866708755, 0.033661115914583206, -0.04074103385210037, -0.017133589833974838, 0.024797700345516205, -0.02637432888150215, 0.026317177340388298, -0.03273642808198929, -0.024502571672201157, -0.05946776643395424, 0.038063183426856995, 0.01972966454923153, -0.014805602841079235, 0.026690946891903877, -0.029317712411284447, -0.07995912432670593, 0.0001595105422893539, -0.047755297273397446, 0.03838121145963669, -0.02632795460522175, -0.047896649688482285, -0.008265419863164425, -0.034090615808963776, 0.011475728824734688, 0.011630263179540634, -0.0040189605206251144, -0.045738644897937775, -0.0033450727351009846, -0.010326357558369637, -0.042176444083452225, -0.026805998757481575, -0.040594540536403656, 0.01818285882472992, 0.015833817422389984, -0.053511038422584534, 0.04559098929166794, -0.007234475575387478, -0.03078419342637062, 0.0039319926872849464, -0.0639437586069107, -0.004133517388254404, -0.03797703981399536, -0.0019932191353291273, 0.034522127360105515, 0.009396613575518131, 0.025655141100287437, 0.03419074788689613, -0.02770254760980606, -0.034536391496658325, -0.0498473197221756, -0.05399825796484947, 0.010564644820988178, -0.0003664730757009238, -0.012378288432955742, -0.01391446404159069, 0.006120418664067984, 0.04688620939850807, 0.0377400703728199, 0.00798693485558033, -0.03571655973792076, -0.013540921732783318, 0.012848523445427418, -0.04933854192495346, 0.0015608277171850204, 0.013392542488873005, 0.042548514902591705, 0.029167966917157173, -0.027297673746943474, 0.01552031934261322, 0.03528638184070587, -0.007852588780224323, 0.00017045583808794618, 0.0051492140628397465, 0.008456747978925705, -0.0352739542722702, 0.020794184878468513, 0.03758901730179787, -0.01629115454852581, 0.052603304386138916, 0.006575110834091902, 0.028875501826405525, -0.0022371597588062286, -0.03660270944237709, -0.002097437623888254, -0.027475696057081223, 0.02639191783964634, -0.009909940883517265, 0.030438782647252083, 0.012865198776125908, -0.05002182349562645, 0.024144591763615608, 0.028412610292434692, 0.05751052498817444, -0.03135361149907112, -0.025589482858777046, 0.029867906123399734, 0.036720145493745804, 0.010514295659959316, 0.03416566550731659, 0.025768501684069633, -0.05059331655502319, 0.03576422855257988, -0.042470380663871765, -0.0225298460572958, 0.042002562433481216, 0.01948220282793045, 0.01739305816590786, 0.0026056671049445868, -0.06647457927465439, 0.015434598550200462, -0.0621798038482666, 0.019405370578169823, -0.02852865308523178, 0.05045156180858612, 0.01620223931968212, 0.04936527833342552, 0.009492849931120872, 0.018461061641573906, 0.010708045214414597, 0.01649918220937252, -0.06819965690374374, 0.038189977407455444, 0.014853440225124359, -0.010152366012334824, -0.035039421170949936, -0.012902273796498775, 0.07462198287248611, -0.012912066653370857, 0.014610804617404938, 0.026649758219718933, 0.014233550056815147, -0.029254190623760223, 0.00016295185196213424, -0.02935744822025299, 0.004068696405738592, -0.013999814167618752, 0.0029991446062922478, 0.03836673125624657, 0.010147737339138985, 0.01912546157836914, 0.039076127111911774, 0.004102533217519522, -0.012004749849438667, -0.02478218264877796, 0.009912761859595776, 0.024464532732963562, 0.04255466163158417, 0.03613850474357605, 0.021775467321276665, -0.02538870833814144, 0.0019522205693647265, 0.0073515004478394985, 0.048304714262485504, 0.04506006836891174, -0.00443282863125205, 0.008542590774595737, -0.004973168950527906, 0.00022460792388301343, 0.007818840444087982, 0.03120521828532219, -0.00929730199277401, -0.016060752794146538, 0.03655261918902397, 0.04838337004184723, -0.016602272167801857, 0.04648095369338989, 0.07291240990161896, -0.0068353768438100815, -0.013778092339634895, -0.025284461677074432, 0.009363190270960331, -0.002480173949152231, 0.020739085972309113, 0.03789764270186424, -0.0008974050870165229, -0.03850438818335533, -0.014506074599921703, 0.037644293159246445, -0.02687169797718525, -0.02641145884990692, -0.002897301921620965, 0.03780894726514816, 0.03957077115774155, 0.015224162489175797, -0.053514380007982254, -0.004336167126893997, 0.017165308818221092, 0.04110797122120857, 0.04143379628658295, -0.003342420794069767, -0.0925426259636879, -0.005720268469303846, 0.07841386646032333, 0.01927156373858452, -0.038409337401390076, -0.03457104414701462, -0.029588982462882996, -0.013037501834332943, 0.005373988300561905, -0.046611297875642776, 0.02014421857893467, -0.011792478151619434, 0.022923456504940987, 0.015146848745644093, -0.002704078331589699, -0.07720810920000076, 0.002802910516038537, -0.029372230172157288, 0.02633722499012947, -0.015905195847153664, -0.01570131629705429, -0.06361721456050873, 0.01073531061410904, -0.022059805691242218, 0.029376350343227386, -0.042194534093141556, -0.03297392651438713, 0.01118451077491045, 0.048254501074552536, 0.006112343166023493, -0.06207878515124321, 0.02020549774169922, -0.0027742546517401934, -0.005560834426432848, 0.06508849561214447, 0.004498705267906189, -0.060413043946027756, 0.014303176663815975, 0.04897131025791168, -0.005839821416884661, -0.01403783168643713, -0.034177619963884354, 0.03561665862798691, 0.038602203130722046, -0.008943702094256878, 0.04274110868573189, 0.0411045141518116, 0.005644550547003746, -0.04483270272612572, -0.03707347437739372, -0.019161604344844818, -0.043284930288791656, -0.017836999148130417, -0.048647306859493256, -0.009457754902541637, -0.04983842372894287, 0.01857174001634121, -0.0008995130774565041, -0.0034164718817919493, -0.028116770088672638, -0.01824435032904148, 0.02611001580953598, 0.03368164971470833, -0.032517194747924805, 0.018465431407094002, -0.00821752194315195, 0.018109280616044998, -0.013010350055992603, 0.010228961706161499, -0.016037411987781525, -0.01130626443773508, -0.01739283837378025, 0.031188389286398888, -0.011390483938157558, 0.015858696773648262, 0.006383409723639488, 0.002644333755597472, -0.0061723957769572735, -0.01497685257345438, 0.0022405930794775486, 0.03098679892718792, 0.031435854732990265, 0.011956509202718735, -0.04531891271471977, -0.00686906510964036, -0.0027584342751652002, -0.00521727092564106, 0.009670495055615902, -0.037221428006887436, 0.05612978711724281, -0.022076968103647232, -0.03390078619122505, -0.05370889976620674, -0.057000286877155304, 0.029505407437682152, -0.006953887175768614, -0.04209807515144348, -0.006956540979444981, -0.017834194004535675, -0.017894849181175232, -0.00014344997180160135, 0.008282872848212719, 0.03793918713927269, -0.04103929549455643, -0.020142169669270515, 0.0028907295782119036, 0.034585580229759216, 0.09324181079864502, 0.0018482354935258627, 0.003026904072612524, 0.018956048414111137, -0.03205978870391846, -0.006369041278958321, 0.019360601902008057, -0.03511539474129677, -0.038048744201660156, -0.00897946860641241, -0.04509885981678963, 0.042288634926080704, 0.058957576751708984, 0.006159523967653513, -0.025835998356342316, 0.015319419093430042, 0.0022446198854595423, 0.05137789994478226, -0.045801546424627304, -0.019917871803045273, -0.04384719952940941, 0.021900616586208344, 0.0035594601649791002, -0.016229623928666115, -0.018890591338276863, 0.003975504543632269, 0.04278889670968056, 0.004884845111519098, 0.01132216677069664, 0.05450942739844322, 0.08490361273288727, -0.021649692207574844, -0.008122092112898827, -0.00915013998746872, -0.015395057387650013, 0.048306774348020554, 0.012799744494259357, 0.0304703526198864, -0.0007915556197986007, 0.06433706730604172, -0.02684490755200386, -0.003499939339235425, -0.01949457824230194, -0.023301683366298676, 0.05315972492098808, -0.0043328250758349895, 0.044093094766139984, 0.01114416029304266, 0.001576144713908434, 0.04437209665775299, -0.038629256188869476, -0.0184425488114357, -0.0146964555606246, 0.013667107559740543, 0.08485494554042816, -0.042501699179410934, -0.01764618046581745, 0.03529788926243782, -0.013709748163819313, 0.01606375351548195, 0.013804889284074306, 0.022006863728165627, 0.00534141156822443, 0.000913743453565985, -0.02718622051179409, -0.012854143977165222, 0.024958638474345207, -0.001086280564777553, 0.022776450961828232, -0.018512001261115074, -0.012240183539688587, 0.053674567490816116, 0.05995161458849907, 0.004749257583171129, -0.03476822376251221, 0.004302346613258123, -0.03872372955083847, -0.01762225851416588, 0.01968962326645851, -0.02903260849416256, 0.008392411284148693, -0.005156898871064186, 0.020520225167274475, 0.01058287639170885, 0.013705306686460972, -0.019778642803430557, -0.06322602927684784, -0.04187442362308502, 0.008333997800946236, -0.008977078832685947, 0.030885284766554832, -0.03860565647482872, -0.01750701479613781, 0.018787473440170288, -0.05862046405673027, 0.015427722595632076, 0.015287362970411777, 0.04853631928563118, 0.001349642057903111, 0.03870502859354019, -0.010026137344539165, 0.023277651518583298, -0.009037143550813198, -0.04024355858564377, 0.11981774121522903, 0.07446954399347305, 0.03239035606384277, -0.08681202679872513, 0.0212464090436697, 0.010372448712587357, 0.0005677859298884869, 0.006361179053783417, 0.004609986208379269, 0.023372992873191833, 0.012618741020560265, 0.050075922161340714, 0.04036535695195198, 0.005137545056641102, 0.01712816394865513, 0.033195190131664276, -0.06314215064048767, -0.002520862501114607, -0.010370900854468346, 0.004306131042540073, -0.018218887969851494, -0.015441901050508022, -0.04664904996752739, 0.024838348850607872, 0.05930405110120773, -0.0018475265242159367, -0.02766439877450466, -0.019240064546465874, -0.007585653103888035, 0.005823793355375528, 0.007098470814526081, -0.004962855018675327, -0.007206805050373077, 0.02828935533761978, -0.009039859287440777, 0.0015783795388415456, 0.0086927879601717, -0.023133467882871628, -0.006628102157264948, 0.055696193128824234, 0.0019103389931842685, 0.012833653949201107, -0.015643972903490067, -0.017630545422434807, -0.03354548662900925, -0.031279973685741425, -0.007144473027437925, 0.05690653622150421, 0.00727970851585269, -0.03027859330177307, -0.009675889275968075, 0.005083226133137941, 0.019125713035464287, -0.04126822203397751, -0.005064753815531731, 0.04635436087846756, 0.02393411286175251, -0.016318274661898613, 0.0034927234519273043, -0.013165201991796494, 0.0020689568482339382, -0.024229226633906364, 0.026962844654917717, 0.02288375049829483, -0.04150735214352608, -0.00035488311550579965, -0.04564633592963219, 0.03520851582288742, -0.04133734107017517, -0.009981440380215645, 0.03043903224170208, 0.0019502142677083611, -0.018686385825276375, -0.029130108654499054, 0.03512239828705788, 0.02228108048439026, -0.01380797941237688, -0.014302657917141914, -0.016985494643449783, -0.014444039203226566, -0.03086092695593834, 0.06324499100446701, -0.06177278980612755, 0.0055492413230240345, -0.021093137562274933, -0.0044375318102538586, 0.04629132151603699, 0.05544017627835274, 0.034862369298934937, 0.013449884951114655, 0.008076542057096958, 0.06431599706411362, -0.013946553692221642, -0.04865000396966934, -0.039989884942770004, 0.04679366201162338, -0.030168471857905388, -0.010609319433569908, -0.005575454328209162, 0.05871094390749931, 0.031410619616508484, 0.03277699649333954, -0.031805556267499924, 0.02510494738817215, -0.0026550795882940292, 0.001026282785460353, 0.0005574430688284338, -0.02874181792140007, 0.004669988993555307, -0.02139766700565815, -0.013293969444930553, -0.003277743235230446, -0.034268490970134735, -0.003800340462476015, -0.029033243656158447, 0.017628055065870285, 0.000499236339237541, -0.05419038608670235, 0.02277369052171707, 0.014950484037399292, 0.04528726264834404, -0.03768165409564972, -0.04087316244840622, -0.06851936876773834, -0.02282644622027874, 0.006709212437272072, -0.03589223325252533, -0.011941168457269669, 0.010729266330599785, -0.026180967688560486, 0.0033096191473305225, 0.035744182765483856, 0.011977258138358593, 0.005244450643658638, -0.005852323491126299, 0.003802583087235689, 0.002363431267440319, 0.04487793147563934, -0.027523430064320564, -0.009121588431298733, 0.003954729996621609, -0.05775108560919762, -0.03690522164106369, 0.015172343701124191, -0.014192507602274418, 0.00909013394266367, -0.020909033715724945, 0.027830876410007477, -0.05872548371553421, 0.04416235163807869, 0.00976767297834158, 0.029256952926516533, -0.010813592001795769, 0.007449435535818338, 0.024359311908483505, -0.02818336710333824, 0.003906727768480778, -0.0030298589263111353, -0.002859328640624881, 0.021374491974711418, 0.03836948052048683, 0.008364677429199219, -0.02614576928317547, 0.003294415306299925, 0.025079550221562386, 0.014248431660234928, 0.0012643890222534537, -0.028100445866584778, -0.00040136463940143585, 0.0134887071326375, -0.01595667377114296, 0.02847953513264656, -0.034183599054813385, 0.011083479970693588, -0.08654680848121643, -0.03677831590175629, -0.023432457819581032, 0.02162531390786171, -0.02339140512049198, -0.019871674478054047, -0.019677668809890747, 0.005972621496766806, -0.001882562879472971, -0.012385121546685696, 0.0015725689008831978, 0.00033679496846161783, -0.00943055935204029, 0.0456634946167469, -0.0004284812603145838, 0.044714752584695816, 0.044505972415208817, -0.015230384655296803, 0.014301779679954052, -0.019326690584421158, -0.012496108189225197, -0.0349385142326355, 0.001829294255003333, 0.010061915963888168, -0.02027975581586361, -0.058039166033267975, 0.04398288577795029, -0.040586698800325394, 0.01592099852859974, -0.002369692549109459, -0.0026996107771992683, 0.0244916845113039, 0.018197759985923767, -0.010182052850723267, 0.012141368351876736, 0.05261588469147682, 0.029324591159820557, -0.0023372031282633543, -0.02880704030394554, 0.022575903683900833, 0.007771333213895559, -0.0037891454994678497, -0.013392902910709381, 0.03881433233618736, -0.02165646106004715, 0.01956951431930065, -0.015034849755465984, 0.0011852821335196495, -0.017336063086986542, -0.03378990292549133, -0.024913139641284943, 0.02599170058965683, 0.017843659967184067, -0.03830338642001152, 0.017075926065444946, -0.049486320465803146, 0.0066907526925206184, 0.03937810659408569, 0.05552774295210838, -0.020168181508779526, 0.007334145251661539, -0.030236179009079933, -0.04545905441045761, 0.004569886717945337, 0.001959692919626832, -0.01131078414618969, -0.0358973927795887, -0.019915442913770676, 0.013708067126572132, -0.005983013194054365, -0.0010515559697523713, -0.007079712580889463, -0.025518354028463364, 0.028306560590863228, -0.026794403791427612, 0.01151498407125473, 0.031602513045072556, -0.023923270404338837, 0.055231302976608276, -0.09724663197994232, 0.07024930417537689, 0.00844497513025999, -0.019289530813694, -0.062056638300418854, -0.019367709755897522, -0.05687166377902031, 0.008382140658795834, 0.04898712784051895, 0.007873612456023693, -0.0030166259966790676, -0.012086558155715466, 0.019729632884263992, -0.01994946040213108, -0.026514679193496704, 0.03541583567857742, 0.008151260204613209, -0.016000650823116302, -0.032736990600824356, 0.003369121113792062, 0.005246651358902454, 0.03778277710080147, 0.03793526440858841, 0.016164686530828476, -0.026336494833230972, -0.03634341433644295, -0.0069546871818602085, 0.03301187977194786, 0.028303159400820732, -0.016563475131988525, 0.023889737203717232, 0.0027618687599897385, 0.02534855529665947, 0.07134034484624863, 0.0013519482454285026, -0.0660698413848877, 0.022130033001303673, -0.04061363637447357, -0.0220204908400774, 0.0010149456793442369, -0.006421604193747044, 0.03557831048965454, -0.03000754863023758, -0.007750475313514471, -0.0008050943142734468, -0.019533786922693253, -0.03004935383796692, 0.02178276889026165, 0.04996352642774582, 0.02036936767399311, -0.027663197368383408, -0.011657827533781528, 0.004592787474393845, -0.020766647532582283, -0.011312155984342098, 0.038371920585632324, 0.04677414521574974, 0.002310618059709668, 0.013398527167737484, -0.004059239756315947, -0.009706968441605568, 0.009824743494391441, -0.0296935997903347, 0.09337959438562393, -0.03148627281188965, 0.025529036298394203, 0.02200341783463955, -0.01559506542980671, 0.015241716988384724, -0.029166949912905693, -0.013954444788396358, 0.016964374110102654, -0.06819174438714981, -0.030824901536107063, -0.014964064583182335, -0.018952500075101852, -0.024338245391845703, 0.018189499154686928, 0.022352857515215874, 0.028989601880311966, 0.031930480152368546, 0.03831198066473007, -0.0060811759904026985, 0.009209062904119492, 0.03190583735704422, -0.024654123932123184, 0.03298582509160042, -0.00912180170416832, 0.0134423291310668, -0.0194548312574625, -0.007925529032945633, -0.03652479872107506, -0.0340561717748642, 0.013325267471373081, 0.028505496680736542, 0.0033458443358540535, -0.06591220945119858, -0.02739289216697216, -0.03187732398509979, 0.013294599018990993, -0.05765533819794655, -0.007349676452577114, -0.044016316533088684, 0.0007585549028590322, 0.05075209215283394, -0.022121010348200798 ]
<p>I came across a paper that uses the abbreviation "p.e.":</p> <p><a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/2984884" rel="nofollow">Khatri and Madria, The Von Mises-Fisher Matrix Distribution in Orientation Statistics. 1976.</a></p> <p>It's in Section 7 on page 105. I'm including a short excerpt:</p> <blockquote> <p>Using the density function of $K^{\frac{1}{2}}XX'K^{\frac{1}{2}} = S$ given in Khatri (1975a), we find that the p.e. $X$ given $XX'=I_n$ is</p> </blockquote> <p>What does the abbreviation "p.e." mean in this sentence?</p>
43,010
[ -0.06056566536426544, 0.005626328755170107, -0.0015159408794716, -0.03569415584206581, 0.01629774644970894, 0.02576303854584694, -0.005070923827588558, 0.030818048864603043, 0.02499508298933506, -0.05815986543893814, 0.07340625673532486, 0.07426102459430695, 0.07317019999027252, 0.0440811887383461, 0.03665526583790779, 0.026582639664411545, -0.0029109143652021885, 0.041283637285232544, -0.01465840358287096, -0.035359177738428116, 0.020990295335650444, -0.03273140639066696, -0.032667916268110275, 0.01800418086349964, -0.00360171590000391, 0.05964503437280655, 0.013512048870325089, -0.020431412383913994, 0.010156347416341305, 0.04920722171664238, -0.036449067294597626, -0.01343469973653555, 0.02713228389620781, -0.0011658304138109088, -0.003209891961887479, -0.030610699206590652, 0.0013080250937491655, -0.037097472697496414, 0.022307174280285835, 0.02435740828514099, -0.03083992376923561, 0.002755440305918455, 0.016578545793890953, -0.008565410040318966, -0.02482813410460949, 0.039164405316114426, -0.0005325092934072018, -0.07872319221496582, 0.059170160442590714, -0.028270181268453598, 0.05916602164506912, 0.005642974749207497, 0.018936600536108017, 0.005218568257987499, -0.03691626712679863, 0.042005978524684906, 0.04709332808852196, 0.04896315932273865, 0.0019625909626483917, -0.06521926820278168, -0.0043545374646782875, -0.008701133541762829, 0.01800425909459591, -0.02394767291843891, -0.02817065827548504, 0.006381378509104252, 0.028789231553673744, -0.04767627641558647, 0.06100389361381531, -0.037599749863147736, 0.02360120415687561, 0.03260359168052673, 0.05320408195257187, -0.04310571402311325, 0.0070726824924349785, -0.04213283583521843, 0.03192688152194023, 0.011979487724602222, 0.014782099984586239, 0.01777254417538643, 0.035409972071647644, -0.02610684372484684, 0.016793429851531982, 0.0017219323199242353, -0.029558571055531502, 0.022030098363757133, 0.06605296581983566, -0.036307577043771744, 0.029417673125863075, 0.0027205124497413635, 0.009278731420636177, 0.03420598804950714, 0.04393693804740906, -0.04467172548174858, -0.020464645698666573, 0.011282374151051044, -0.0009402736905030906, 0.08505631238222122, -0.01296245213598013, 0.002602474996820092, 0.0010229547042399645, -0.038388583809137344, -0.023798171430826187, 0.03780749440193176, -0.008965983986854553, -0.03711988776922226, -0.03662164881825447, 0.02118111029267311, 0.005080585367977619, -0.0463634692132473, -0.00996019784361124, 0.027960918843746185, -0.018459124490618706, 0.038171738386154175, 0.00424158712849021, -0.011634953320026398, -0.0060965195298194885, 0.04884092137217522, 0.04852822795510292, 0.06435780227184296, 0.0291010569781065, 0.01282696146517992, 0.03199757635593414, -0.03454718738794327, -0.05090916156768799, 0.03342507407069206, 0.06631173938512802, -0.006206744350492954, -0.05128313973546028, 0.03755795955657959, 0.011027283035218716, -0.01478159986436367, 0.0443282276391983, -0.0023678820580244064, -0.009501778520643711, 0.011437335051596165, -0.09448369592428207, -0.044979896396398544, 0.013660929165780544, 0.01627720333635807, 0.015747206285595894, -0.10025481134653091, -0.011340616270899773, 0.06070819869637489, 0.0515897311270237, -0.03003578446805477, 0.04306918755173683, -0.03185081481933594, 0.012738440185785294, 0.011370745487511158, -0.028885412961244583, -0.03882414102554321, 0.0019014127319678664, -0.05846177041530609, 0.01715157926082611, -0.05169270187616348, 0.018734436482191086, 0.05223063379526138, 0.009731626138091087, -0.025903619825839996, 0.04437696933746338, 0.011904586106538773, -0.020390385761857033, 0.020586393773555756, -0.0261401254683733, -0.03231552243232727, 0.08959941565990448, 0.018132992088794708, 0.03796491399407387, 0.05100297927856445, 0.016269057989120483, 0.046337492763996124, -0.011640665121376514, 0.04764368757605553, 0.051489245146512985, -0.04121113196015358, -0.003498218022286892, 0.005118042230606079, -0.00684013357385993, -0.02420467510819435, -0.059823885560035706, -0.004655467811971903, 0.05305669829249382, -0.015423418954014778, 0.02230185642838478, 0.01741628162562847, 0.011137647554278374, -0.02528572827577591, 0.0005665456992574036, -0.03692242130637169, -0.024949925020337105, -0.0561121441423893, 0.04488873481750488, 0.006670922506600618, -0.04140966013073921, 0.025663139298558235, -0.016216790303587914, 0.0015856303507462144, -0.0064350333996117115, -0.016911273822188377, -0.03276883810758591, -0.03362596035003662, 0.06165938079357147, -0.05701108276844025, -0.0013374690897762775, 0.005878007039427757, 0.011763776652514935, 0.013801433145999908, 0.013509350828826427, -0.03016340732574463, -0.015744559466838837, 0.013200901448726654, -0.0024579628370702267, 0.04100113362073898, 0.0028109638951718807, -0.028512677177786827, 0.00976418424397707, 0.006420564372092485, 0.003359297988936305, 0.0020206677727401257, -0.04284261167049408, 0.034837499260902405, 0.0801529660820961, 0.021854205057024956, 0.0034937055315822363, -0.01679409109055996, -0.0006134924478828907, 0.03046945482492447, -0.0030284810345619917, -0.0592975914478302, -0.007169021759182215, -0.011967422440648079, 0.017251182347536087, -0.0021895715035498142, -0.023147258907556534, 0.031360525637865067, 0.030455579981207848, 0.010936154052615166, -0.002918011974543333, 0.032731685787439346, -0.010986657813191414, -0.02229468710720539, 0.016440996900200844, 0.00736588379368186, -0.014561988413333893, 0.016482967883348465, 0.02558441460132599, 0.004981103353202343, 0.04337608069181442, -0.0065972693264484406, -0.006774224806576967, 0.029300790280103683, -0.04284689575433731, 0.008535290136933327, -0.009722930379211903, -0.022534340620040894, 0.025834113359451294, -0.05287199094891548, -0.012160198763012886, 0.04040789231657982, 0.009449230507016182, 0.028785133734345436, -0.023345332592725754, -0.0427590049803257, -0.017429737374186516, 0.0209554024040699, -0.050712618976831436, -0.06119151413440704, 0.01598198711872101, -0.03024906851351261, 0.04229429364204407, 0.00872985739260912, -0.053847745060920715, 0.007572138216346502, -0.0064392355270683765, 0.034797552973032, 0.030430149286985397, -0.005400350783020258, -0.018997779116034508, -0.006557992659509182, -0.005996862892061472, -0.0007396034779958427, 0.035904042422771454, 0.011296244338154793, -0.02156168967485428, -0.012218437157571316, -0.014815687201917171, -0.03945981338620186, 0.015264824032783508, -0.0038425757084041834, -0.03814796358346939, 0.0012852856889367104, 0.008946048095822334, -0.008674884214997292, -0.01563001424074173, -0.000008341923603438772, 0.013957955874502659, -0.013057825155556202, -0.026162074878811836, 0.029756033793091774, -0.014276822097599506, 0.017479989677667618, 0.02178814634680748, -0.06631608307361603, -0.04800531268119812, -0.0006309538730420172, -0.023525824770331383, 0.020130742341279984, 0.011620424687862396, 0.06156168505549431, 0.02333279512822628, 0.01848871447145939, -0.019528131932020187, -0.04482989385724068, -0.09293537586927414, -0.013630497269332409, 0.0008129453053697944, 0.029866114258766174, 0.007766686379909515, -0.0134307025000453, 0.09573543071746826, 0.01900516264140606, -0.023955117911100388, -0.021491307765245438, 0.0020642071031033993, -0.05009333789348602, -0.02347092516720295, 0.009900666773319244, 0.009582324884831905, 0.013218734413385391, 0.022656865417957306, 0.011637590825557709, 0.0395018644630909, 0.03796332702040672, 0.012824495323002338, 0.021064110100269318, 0.04511447623372078, -0.022793248295783997, -0.0235211830586195, 0.029036100953817368, 0.04909633472561836, -0.01808643341064453, 0.02040715143084526, 0.010225131176412106, 0.011220836080610752, 0.025937873870134354, -0.019654102623462677, 0.02661941945552826, -0.043991800397634506, -0.0047784107737243176, -0.022914253175258636, 0.0485372394323349, 0.046223755925893784, -0.04348532110452652, -0.0027084150351583958, 0.026116320863366127, -0.010146774351596832, -0.0271237064152956, 0.0005937680834904313, 0.04429317265748978, 0.005708001088351011, -0.020425500348210335, -0.009726930409669876, -0.03888793662190437, 0.003477249527350068, 0.03330202028155327, -0.018805040046572685, -0.04392034560441971, 0.04432808607816696, 0.005522888619452715, -0.006068792659789324, 0.00932974461466074, -0.04066457599401474, 0.031330328434705734, -0.056703418493270874, 0.012304226867854595, 0.004006730392575264, 0.01274783443659544, 0.010571499355137348, 0.0731024444103241, 0.01623344048857689, -0.0011593737872317433, 0.021600615233182907, 0.031247228384017944, -0.07330922782421112, 0.001352778053842485, -0.0069559067487716675, -0.025596996769309044, -0.003847199259325862, -0.004245413932949305, 0.028153246268630028, -0.03287111967802048, -0.01155460812151432, 0.03489796072244644, 0.0036425888538360596, -0.04535714164376259, 0.00865486916154623, -0.044760122895240784, -0.025862237438559532, -0.013952305540442467, 0.019212357699871063, 0.02594340778887272, -0.019081754609942436, 0.045281339436769485, 0.03203330188989639, -0.0019560744985938072, -0.023162927478551865, -0.000020275749193388037, -0.018563322722911835, 0.022354353219270706, 0.011553163640201092, -0.026033170521259308, 0.004545215982943773, -0.009538265876471996, 0.03542887046933174, -0.03574973717331886, 0.08984624594449997, 0.050876323133707047, -0.016981881111860275, 0.03336057439446449, 0.031394004821777344, 0.00960460677742958, -0.004402306396514177, 0.008230132050812244, -0.006508373189717531, 0.015026993118226528, 0.04146074876189232, 0.025179075077176094, -0.04720700532197952, 0.013617174699902534, 0.04790918529033661, 0.02945871278643608, 0.02001793123781681, -0.03676057979464531, 0.004966964013874531, 0.010974802076816559, 0.0015005641616880894, -0.0194864422082901, -0.012858070433139801, 0.01984277553856373, 0.006137755699455738, 0.03059757500886917, 0.0008612393867224455, -0.03229834511876106, -0.024699874222278595, -0.010753653943538666, -0.00531817926093936, -0.025933433324098587, -0.015488284640014172, 0.030876565724611282, 0.042724721133708954, 0.007521572057157755, 0.026595812290906906, -0.000692602014169097, -0.048226453363895416, 0.02371470257639885, 0.029523584991693497, 0.042203839868307114, -0.005937091074883938, 0.024138955399394035, -0.05570063367486, 0.009950881823897362, 0.012853551656007767, -0.00875866785645485, 0.01569506525993347, -0.044200439006090164, -0.035093601793050766, 0.023427944630384445, 0.0126228928565979, -0.05424182862043381, -0.013404855504631996, 0.04790689796209335, 0.018336376175284386, 0.0015390602638944983, -0.009296010248363018, -0.022955307736992836, 0.0014830459840595722, 0.017229601740837097, 0.02815426141023636, -0.0024172028061002493, 0.005442443303763866, 0.00858974363654852, 0.022938890382647514, -0.03187115490436554, -0.06311149150133133, 0.018477870151400566, -0.012708944268524647, 0.028430894017219543, 0.016598651185631752, -0.03419317677617073, -0.036959510296583176, 0.019178124144673347, -0.03939150646328926, -0.029785145074129105, -0.01279386691749096, -0.02829383686184883, 0.03975207358598709, 0.03736071288585663, 0.017973080277442932, 0.07085555046796799, 0.002618553815409541, -0.011283712461590767, 0.00020255242998246104, -0.07363755255937576, 0.04503626748919487, -0.03926493227481842, 0.01716693304479122, -0.04453960433602333, 0.04030468314886093, -0.031497515738010406, 0.010957593098282814, -0.017406361177563667, 0.024939946830272675, -0.06015036627650261, -0.042902860790491104, 0.007179491221904755, 0.006761909928172827, -0.01553104817867279, -0.004738421179354191, 0.00007937609916552901, 0.03641650825738907, 0.0037254984490573406, 0.0027092357631772757, 0.0487331822514534, 0.0006320573738776147, 0.0171646848320961, 0.044957127422094345, -0.016585467383265495, -0.0008022117544896901, -0.04060734063386917, -0.04819992929697037, 0.03004719875752926, -0.023165663704276085, 0.030465926975011826, -0.014537783339619637, 0.021974291652441025, 0.009658640250563622, -0.03676128014922142, -0.032825320959091187, 0.009518956765532494, -0.0029125292785465717, 0.05315391346812248, -0.04899001866579056, 0.009331170469522476, -0.04141831770539284, 0.03151785582304001, -0.07120657712221146, -0.031485192477703094, 0.038749732077121735, 0.017027556896209717, -0.06719076633453369, -0.015204861760139465, -0.019905149936676025, -0.016928978264331818, -0.0351271815598011, -0.008602303452789783, 0.018240222707390785, -0.013418106362223625, -0.021197551861405373, 0.015564504079520702, 0.07341894507408142, 0.043858032673597336, 0.012596593238413334, -0.03191322833299637, 0.03727305680513382, -0.05359640344977379, -0.014945360831916332, -0.001473878277465701, 0.02106151171028614, -0.03672228008508682, -0.0048053693026304245, -0.03324234113097191, 0.03047281689941883, -0.00016907491954043508, -0.030247708782553673, -0.015105795115232468, 0.02687603421509266, -0.00035059868241660297, -0.01942361891269684, 0.006140909157693386, -0.013041052035987377, -0.0429941862821579, -0.0030330857262015343, -0.0014589580241590738, 0.0009400356211699545, 0.02752879448235035, 0.024536553770303726, 0.013277238234877586, 0.006561881396919489, -0.013512132689356804, -0.009114748798310757, 0.10982026904821396, -0.023118071258068085, 0.03648006543517113, 0.05117451399564743, -0.011920115910470486, 0.010307145304977894, 0.03993851691484451, -0.0008914003265090287, -0.025699902325868607, -0.0027920592110604048, -0.006639640312641859, -0.02713850699365139, -0.06418892741203308, 0.04046573117375374, 0.07744232565164566, -0.01971205323934555, 0.023192422464489937, 0.05124363303184509, -0.021704083308577538, -0.010324271395802498, -0.018354875966906548, 0.017624404281377792, -0.03368310257792473, 0.026054317131638527, 0.03648032620549202, -0.007590045221149921, -0.012480542063713074, 0.035909999161958694, 0.04043600708246231, -0.03190622106194496, 0.028479084372520447, -0.009387807920575142, 0.022307366132736206, -0.006064319983124733, -0.04077049344778061, -0.06601385027170181, 0.07617804408073425, -0.0441339910030365, 0.03368375450372696, -0.062022849917411804, -0.05715760216116905, 0.023587556555867195, 0.021391700953245163, 0.006271831225603819, -0.04052787274122238, -0.005059169605374336, -0.026097362861037254, -0.008847696706652641, 0.0167077723890543, -0.03331999108195305, 0.01964581571519375, -0.04023061320185661, 0.01730210892856121, -0.022928545251488686, 0.0424252450466156, -0.05052712932229042, -0.009242908097803593, -0.002159815514460206, -0.043556589633226395, -0.030429568141698837, 0.028456130996346474, -0.000014985104826337192, -0.017177950590848923, 0.025500722229480743, -0.020952433347702026, 0.030264001339673996, -0.00417223060503602, 0.03828611969947815, -0.013672327622771263, 0.10709301382303238, -0.0006701656966470182, 0.014521724544465542, -0.019627170637249947, 0.002302458742633462, 0.11704937368631363, 0.0582466647028923, 0.04196534305810928, -0.02638970874249935, 0.01745353639125824, -0.017447350546717644, 0.024430781602859497, -0.01190674863755703, -0.019103500992059708, -0.04010401666164398, 0.007666050922125578, 0.02067483402788639, 0.07555512338876724, 0.01969211921095848, -0.021481387317180634, 0.0310645904392004, -0.06609534472227097, -0.054130785167217255, 0.011623849160969257, -0.03958268091082573, -0.02732405811548233, -0.035033389925956726, -0.031073689460754395, -0.0009161151247099042, -0.0007672174833714962, 0.004233211744576693, -0.04880473017692566, -0.027695460245013237, 0.028695931658148766, -0.0013611752074211836, -0.0026240218430757523, -0.02015717513859272, -0.0007667380850762129, 0.032972898334264755, 0.006275201216340065, -0.018543941900134087, 0.02542649582028389, -0.0420064814388752, 0.0404653437435627, 0.04032479599118233, -0.0014477341901510954, -0.0020200598519295454, 0.0327204167842865, 0.009292274713516235, -0.024641750380396843, -0.019186051562428474, -0.020922744646668434, 0.05547831207513809, 0.0029559500981122255, 0.01015204656869173, -0.03765333071351051, -0.003996862564235926, -0.023329805582761765, -0.02798818238079548, 0.02030816487967968, -0.014913620427250862, -0.014092259109020233, -0.0010233733337372541, -0.005474502686411142, -0.017790712416172028, -0.01995568908751011, 0.004397217184305191, 0.014260342344641685, 0.010770942084491253, -0.03137468546628952, 0.004811618477106094, -0.002685912186279893, 0.023787617683410645, -0.033103566616773605, -0.018872633576393127, -0.04061860963702202, -0.02215624786913395, -0.04371962696313858, -0.05066794902086258, 0.00335849542170763, -0.006094806827604771, 0.0292318444699049, -0.005616948939859867, -0.016245102509856224, -0.04479667544364929, -0.017914433032274246, -0.00014134557568468153, -0.0016856048023328185, -0.02336110919713974, -0.010323895141482353, 0.004440348129719496, 0.04902967810630798, -0.002126749139279127, 0.007296056021004915, 0.011260487139225006, 0.010900895111262798, 0.03426189720630646, 0.018270406872034073, -0.01280911359935999, -0.053493205457925797, 0.023107079789042473, -0.0033463211730122566, 0.01572391949594021, -0.033613014966249466, 0.016851386055350304, 0.01759638637304306, -0.03433675691485405, 0.012535251677036285, -0.018031110987067223, -0.02037438564002514, 0.007669416256248951, -0.010798889212310314, -0.0192478708922863, 0.009445946663618088, 0.00890237744897604, -0.02282026596367359, -0.03487604483962059, 0.008057529106736183, -0.009482181631028652, 0.005243200808763504, -0.017451202496886253, 0.006858387030661106, -0.03407633304595947, 0.008771299384534359, -0.03268134966492653, 0.018393628299236298, -0.016567444428801537, -0.010993204079568386, -0.022854289039969444, -0.031093483790755272, 0.021976012736558914, 0.043393880128860474, 0.00041751592652872205, 0.04850858822464943, -0.019701331853866577, -0.018252475187182426, 0.02005617879331112, 0.010012232698500156, 0.0032253682147711515, 0.00005514472286449745, 0.002060241298750043, 0.008780191652476788, 0.05685719847679138, -0.034474700689315796, -0.023192891851067543, 0.03225883096456528, -0.061083972454071045, -0.08749610930681229, 0.01403892133384943, 0.01749441772699356, 0.05371316522359848, 0.019493931904435158, 0.03021307848393917, -0.04492924362421036, 0.02421528659760952, -0.03997132554650307, -0.016260923817753792, -0.005272751674056053, -0.036968935281038284, 0.00010271072096657008, -0.023201828822493553, -0.013072368688881397, 0.024010304361581802, -0.03139856085181236, 0.012914446182549, 0.02637331560254097, -0.04011215269565582, -0.032410651445388794, 0.006581491325050592, 0.0005374445463530719, -0.009964140132069588, -0.00849947053939104, -0.013593087904155254, 0.031720709055662155, 0.01587241142988205, -0.04173378273844719, 0.004637967329472303, -0.03193439915776253, 0.002870455151423812, -0.05879900977015495, -0.016003696247935295, 0.02727821283042431, 0.029354166239500046, 0.05023245885968208, -0.06255272775888443, 0.012966149486601353, 0.03550684452056885, -0.07840190827846527, 0.04689536243677139, -0.0021372302435338497, -0.012260804884135723, -0.020143628120422363, 0.03780354559421539, -0.01141376607120037, 0.04738166555762291, 0.011690582148730755, -0.003388025565072894, 0.0336456298828125, 0.029071830213069916, 0.006340904161334038, -0.015457739122211933, 0.005492201074957848, 0.07515039294958115, 0.0031884911004453897, -0.0347871333360672, 0.03920033201575279, -0.0400891974568367, -0.04837077111005783, 0.046005818992853165, 0.005016004201024771, 0.006945139262825251, 0.03580884262919426, 0.014097977429628372, -0.0016431965632364154, 0.028404299169778824, 0.007064194418489933, -0.021837148815393448, 0.009444198571145535, -0.009871203452348709, 0.019075490534305573, 0.03380811959505081, 0.022982336580753326, -0.03269237279891968, -0.0010966917034238577, -0.009245435707271099, -0.03487671911716461, 0.024820899590849876, -0.004037686623632908, -0.01062582153826952, -0.01123551931232214, 0.018147235736250877, 0.03302404284477234, 0.0012108790688216686, 0.07510566711425781, -0.05063740909099579, -0.01120374072343111, -0.007503703236579895, -0.012804612517356873, -0.013598072342574596, 0.07037970423698425, -0.009627549909055233, -0.04389620199799538, 0.028808169066905975, -0.004148172214627266, -0.02161363698542118, -0.04935729131102562, 0.0028403610922396183, -0.022868787869811058, 0.01578245498239994, 0.02121138945221901, -0.01790083572268486, -0.049756087362766266, -0.010003031231462955, -0.02053867094218731, -0.014778041280806065, 0.011567633599042892, -0.004550617188215256, 0.0018133666599169374, -0.05395195633172989, 0.054841797798871994, -0.0037370212376117706, -0.03200489282608032, -0.04199068620800972, -0.01742512173950672, -0.007164857815951109, 0.03279382735490799, 0.04755975678563118, 0.012236509472131729, -0.00771342683583498, -0.02718675322830677, 0.02005126141011715, 0.028207482770085335, -0.05401484668254852, 0.05191309377551079, 0.0006474403198808432, -0.017359783872961998, 0.014040255919098854, 0.02075931429862976, -0.018827900290489197, 0.0051496257074177265, 0.041509706526994705, 0.026542743667960167, 0.002792354905977845, -0.008350073359906673, -0.036180280148983, 0.054261136800050735, 0.0013715395471081138, 0.010960685089230537, 0.04916510358452797, -0.017741838470101357, 0.021229056641459465, -0.006776975467801094, 0.005308052524924278, -0.0742119699716568, -0.002714322181418538, -0.06528648734092712, -0.03036922961473465, 0.02105141431093216, 0.01114511676132679, 0.02608359418809414, -0.0313151478767395, -0.005874487105756998, 0.01082901656627655, -0.05138557031750679, -0.026608170941472054, 0.04111219570040703, 0.05032447353005409, 0.0031241686083376408, -0.01232753787189722, 0.013211037032306194, -0.012065104208886623, -0.0601968877017498, -0.033764518797397614, 0.01714279130101204, 0.032912448048591614, 0.0007137137581594288, 0.0346578024327755, 0.013303498737514019, 0.02018328756093979, 0.04684024676680565, 0.021104490384459496, 0.028916899114847183, -0.0032953540794551373, 0.011978281661868095, 0.0245318952947855, -0.03179432079195976, 0.0041143158450722694, 0.0078064631670713425, -0.027326669543981552, 0.036154069006443024, 0.011808481067419052, 0.005361104849725962, -0.01871063932776451, 0.005903497338294983, -0.03978583961725235, -0.05180395022034645, 0.009935214184224606, 0.010354867205023766, 0.00646106107160449, 0.005680220201611519, -0.01295760553330183, -0.01957658678293228, 0.016373803839087486, -0.020661253482103348, -0.006427115760743618, 0.043944183737039566, -0.002462958451360464, 0.003873094217851758, 0.0010646566515788436, -0.004457743372768164, -0.008717555552721024, 0.024583593010902405, 0.000956290285103023, 0.01890908181667328, -0.01069082785397768, 0.008499114774167538, 0.037770386785268784, 0.09529154002666473, -0.021419677883386612, -0.003967940341681242, -0.008501454256474972, 0.01199799682945013, 0.03499412536621094, 0.005152248777449131 ]
<p>Under the GARCH($m$,$s$) model, it can be shown that $ E(\eta_t\eta_{t-j}) = E[(a_t^{2}-\sigma_t^{2})(a_{t-j}^{2}-\sigma_{t-j}^{2})] = 0 $.</p> <p>In my proof attempt, I came across $ E(\epsilon_t^{2}\epsilon_{t-j}^{2}) = 1 $ where $ \epsilon_t \sim^{iid} (0,1) $.</p> <p>Is it indeed true that if $ \epsilon_t \sim^{iid} (0,1) $, then $ E(\epsilon_t^{2}\epsilon_{t-j}^{2}) = 1 $?</p>
37,414
[ -0.008792285807430744, -0.020406069234013557, 0.02127963677048683, -0.02596927620470524, 0.0467449352145195, 0.008421570993959904, -0.001087278826162219, -0.021266596391797066, 0.03695819526910782, -0.05784067511558533, 0.046205852180719376, -0.0016353731043636799, 0.05997798964381218, 0.010014398954808712, 0.009813356213271618, 0.015441836789250374, -0.04301033169031143, -0.0022996854968369007, -0.020228056237101555, 0.028194209560751915, 0.009097492322325706, 0.04229159653186798, -0.0023270216770470142, -0.009774026460945606, -0.08022025972604752, 0.042002122849226, 0.002366894856095314, -0.03506357595324516, -0.014618427492678165, 0.0732521265745163, -0.06132196635007858, 0.029364166781306267, 0.01799732632935047, 0.009630616754293442, -0.011767959222197533, 0.0037017606664448977, -0.024320777505636215, -0.043916765600442886, 0.007876674644649029, 0.030027681961655617, -0.008076976984739304, 0.034964412450790405, 0.0030528209172189236, 0.028367213904857635, -0.023961352184414864, 0.007947538048028946, -0.012561697512865067, -0.024074651300907135, 0.05460263416171074, -0.0023251010570675135, 0.059036899358034134, -0.024282755330204964, 0.0008264454663731158, 0.030868956819176674, -0.004764933604747057, -0.02403085120022297, 0.027885323390364647, 0.012418375350534916, 0.002128608524799347, -0.033356279134750366, -0.015356176532804966, 0.018405208364129066, 0.0506562814116478, -0.023741208016872406, -0.010783345438539982, 0.003425587434321642, 0.01293316949158907, -0.03578687086701393, 0.044871632009744644, -0.007232983596622944, 0.017134923487901688, 0.02021416835486889, 0.0045081935822963715, -0.005467261653393507, 0.02443726733326912, -0.02203662507236004, 0.029801882803440094, 0.05152469500899315, 0.06435451656579971, 0.05216507613658905, 0.04236738383769989, 0.020398057997226715, 0.018242571502923965, 0.04404998570680618, 0.060713496059179306, 0.029172496870160103, 0.05940621718764305, -0.005907020531594753, 0.01856706291437149, 0.0538337416946888, -0.04170900583267212, -0.0024428567849099636, 0.027606982737779617, -0.05340862274169922, -0.05900470167398453, 0.056766171008348465, -0.01650254987180233, 0.02029775083065033, 0.021180031821131706, -0.015472139231860638, -0.0689617171883583, -0.04618646204471588, 0.014124845154583454, 0.05351375788450241, 0.0075108385644853115, 0.010540314950048923, -0.017924552783370018, -0.022786322981119156, -0.026501622051000595, -0.04599974676966667, -0.07687093317508698, -0.014605546370148659, -0.011587402783334255, -0.0047631897032260895, 0.01365930400788784, -0.014835024252533913, 0.004695951007306576, -0.03507239371538162, -0.0005405216943472624, 0.057123515754938126, 0.03754701837897301, -0.00006946013309061527, -0.01831333339214325, -0.006652036216109991, -0.04299008101224899, 0.03234075382351875, 0.03469744324684143, -0.019375640898942947, -0.06116342544555664, 0.0372743159532547, 0.0014895936474204063, 0.005100768059492111, 0.00966881588101387, 0.02424781024456024, 0.05344857648015022, -0.027566539123654366, -0.08605606853961945, -0.047067832201719284, 0.03259427845478058, -0.045236341655254364, 0.043346770107746124, -0.060916244983673096, -0.008452307432889938, 0.0218375064432621, 0.06830058246850967, -0.01537306047976017, 0.07735102623701096, -0.004142765887081623, 0.019492726773023605, 0.03013746254146099, -0.020395128056406975, -0.044932834804058075, 0.009875547140836716, -0.02050040103495121, 0.024280840530991554, -0.07988405972719193, 0.02452686056494713, 0.0298214852809906, -0.020277846604585648, -0.005675468593835831, 0.044224534183740616, -0.0036472065839916468, 0.0014143827138468623, -0.03125385195016861, 0.008720588870346546, -0.05953647568821907, 0.06625396758317947, 0.006998561322689056, 0.02749832719564438, -0.013064136728644371, 0.03246317803859711, -0.008102807216346264, 0.006904227193444967, 0.07984180748462677, 0.01817745342850685, -0.04076351970434189, -0.035898517817258835, -0.008688307367265224, 0.019100435078144073, 0.027702806517481804, -0.056144677102565765, 0.007625668775290251, -0.049152836203575134, -0.007378080859780312, -0.004445997998118401, 0.026936151087284088, 0.006911756936460733, -0.0011493680067360401, 0.015981070697307587, -0.03342774137854576, -0.012198631651699543, -0.06843216717243195, 0.024115009233355522, 0.021118544042110443, -0.023976154625415802, 0.01380155049264431, -0.021824827417731285, 0.009621212258934975, 0.006647900212556124, -0.017955245450139046, -0.019166184589266777, 0.022434938699007034, 0.027827389538288116, -0.04785076901316643, 0.026518139988183975, 0.029681382700800896, 0.052276358008384705, 0.03008681908249855, 0.023434428498148918, -0.01498795673251152, -0.0471215657889843, 0.013543223962187767, 0.0008274031570181251, 0.05801047012209892, 0.006214954424649477, -0.01816936768591404, 0.018130086362361908, -0.010171971283853054, -0.014733333140611649, 0.02609194815158844, -0.040677860379219055, 0.026920294389128685, 0.06461942940950394, 0.013608714565634727, -0.008662124164402485, 0.030070345848798752, 0.023115791380405426, 0.03394176810979843, -0.04487641155719757, -0.01017434149980545, -0.02102040871977806, -0.003881271695718169, 0.04917425289750099, 0.0908937007188797, -0.02487182430922985, 0.027253231033682823, 0.09176319092512131, 0.037153586745262146, -0.01629474386572838, 0.030793167650699615, 0.021535681560635567, -0.016662195324897766, 0.025580020621418953, -0.008007786236703396, 0.012167718261480331, 0.006237868685275316, 0.01800495944917202, -0.025524476543068886, 0.018530305474996567, -0.04503478854894638, -0.012769380584359169, 0.024837657809257507, -0.006652480456978083, -0.0019673416391015053, 0.018425283953547478, 0.011708229780197144, 0.03176647424697876, -0.02825303003191948, 0.017089255154132843, 0.0185769684612751, 0.01235285121947527, 0.01191132515668869, 0.006758866831660271, -0.0016369379591196775, 0.040683187544345856, 0.015916086733341217, -0.019795015454292297, -0.02033129148185253, 0.014135845005512238, -0.04287978261709213, 0.006928355433046818, 0.006327037233859301, -0.02746080607175827, -0.024128273129463196, 0.007930106483399868, 0.039675384759902954, 0.006136505864560604, 0.017279459163546562, -0.025663331151008606, -0.003496615681797266, 0.016312910243868828, -0.019067857414484024, 0.03843141347169876, 0.014921089634299278, -0.02868620865046978, -0.012349690310657024, -0.026206322014331818, -0.019470874220132828, 0.062017686665058136, 0.0061035603284835815, 0.012727639637887478, -0.005562935955822468, 0.009419398382306099, -0.015246307477355003, -0.019544405862689018, -0.05206126719713211, -0.01592613384127617, -0.04042506590485573, -0.032940495759248734, 0.04164253920316696, 0.0008478831732645631, -0.05049150064587593, 0.021789228543639183, -0.034080151468515396, -0.021427802741527557, -0.04827190563082695, 0.000434591609518975, 0.028034420683979988, -0.04141836240887642, 0.056347377598285675, 0.03270764276385307, 0.012353750877082348, -0.0018608985701575875, -0.042825788259506226, -0.06081538274884224, 0.012402301654219627, -0.012407718226313591, 0.02448762021958828, 0.025703536346554756, -0.04398198053240776, 0.07946649193763733, 0.04252137243747711, 0.015156236477196217, 0.017392294481396675, -0.02063233219087124, -0.008760535158216953, -0.0222166795283556, 0.01401354931294918, 0.007460400462150574, -0.023494020104408264, 0.06579709053039551, -0.011648588813841343, 0.06441576778888702, 0.04178115352988243, 0.0010015025036409497, -0.01651114970445633, -0.0010964582907035947, -0.020563706755638123, 0.02991042658686638, 0.03324723616242409, 0.012569158338010311, 0.057481516152620316, -0.019856242462992668, 0.018356941640377045, 0.0332384929060936, 0.0008338501793332398, -0.06108388304710388, 0.05656592175364494, -0.01289051491767168, -0.013131660409271717, -0.029834773391485214, 0.06304575502872467, 0.03576934337615967, -0.0010474147275090218, -0.017743313685059547, -0.00755410548299551, 0.022839458659291267, 0.0044652861542999744, 0.03130020573735237, 0.04818592220544815, -0.030639411881566048, -0.011851685121655464, -0.02079855464398861, -0.02722523920238018, -0.022049617022275925, 0.02709352597594261, -0.040196940302848816, -0.021387938410043716, 0.02372376061975956, 0.03219907730817795, 0.026750290766358376, 0.004964814987033606, -0.018879106268286705, -0.007509645540267229, -0.05753329023718834, 0.006745019927620888, -0.01275643240660429, 0.02975527010858059, 0.031104598194360733, 0.04307789355516434, 0.000978368567302823, -0.006433666218072176, 0.017122043296694756, -0.005364029202610254, -0.031048299744725227, -0.006921821273863316, -0.018837440758943558, 0.010135212913155556, -0.0068148719146847725, -0.016279812902212143, 0.0512118823826313, -0.03270141780376434, 0.008078060112893581, -0.02146541327238083, 0.0307934433221817, -0.027332665398716927, 0.013026565313339233, -0.05436641722917557, -0.03484597057104111, -0.011540370061993599, 0.014617744833230972, 0.016471639275550842, -0.014340770430862904, 0.0062393019907176495, 0.02853311039507389, 0.014140475541353226, 0.00883602537214756, -0.026397906243801117, 0.02961513213813305, 0.028594348579645157, 0.010769729502499104, 0.04986598342657089, -0.017718149349093437, -0.018305974081158638, 0.025185149163007736, 0.02586464397609234, 0.03862876445055008, 0.04251774400472641, -0.02051389403641224, -0.018354879692196846, -0.04036761820316315, -0.06546466797590256, 0.03177063167095184, 0.035741545259952545, 0.016336195170879364, -0.0005937609821557999, 0.05220189690589905, 0.009721348993480206, -0.01964336261153221, 0.02360476553440094, 0.07422300428152084, 0.006379994098097086, 0.0036885030567646027, -0.04185253381729126, -0.03782546520233154, -0.02468564547598362, 0.028528913855552673, 0.0013538929633796215, -0.02315874956548214, -0.026407582685351372, -0.028710851445794106, 0.01233586110174656, -0.009004615247249603, 0.0057924301363527775, 0.033124931156635284, 0.052634723484516144, 0.03206061199307442, 0.05874929577112198, -0.0379800908267498, 0.030985774472355843, 0.02245953679084778, 0.02231001853942871, 0.029199697077274323, 0.009677219204604626, -0.07080874592065811, -0.024043358862400055, 0.013040173798799515, 0.023588955402374268, -0.025912802666425705, 0.010773275047540665, -0.03293800726532936, -0.0015877167461439967, 0.007428694516420364, -0.03313755616545677, 0.03677484020590782, -0.005100546404719353, -0.045484695583581924, 0.014645656570792198, -0.02863352932035923, -0.00043379017733968794, 0.010696575045585632, 0.024806279689073563, 0.009599089622497559, -0.014084610156714916, -0.014939568936824799, -0.06170804053544998, -0.046348944306373596, 0.03112149052321911, 0.023992430418729782, -0.027220645919442177, -0.007770932745188475, -0.01726905070245266, 0.05623771995306015, -0.03444879129528999, -0.07542568445205688, 0.01225065253674984, 0.0005123803857713938, -0.027162687852978706, 0.05619983747601509, -0.0419333390891552, -0.03915352001786232, 0.03274548798799515, 0.03709876909852028, -0.022182254120707512, 0.0061020078137516975, -0.02522755041718483, 0.03601120039820671, 0.012853346765041351, 0.009676597081124783, 0.013828232884407043, 0.04003323242068291, -0.0053445082157850266, 0.008196184411644936, -0.023542283102869987, -0.00815609935671091, -0.03551056236028671, 0.015512211248278618, -0.029358334839344025, -0.012253058142960072, -0.0333489365875721, 0.015317991375923157, -0.009244697168469429, 0.032228898257017136, -0.012263626791536808, 0.012829802930355072, 0.032824598252773285, 0.03730356693267822, 0.003834320930764079, -0.0025463479105383158, -0.014535917900502682, 0.03944908082485199, -0.023913267999887466, -0.004114234354346991, -0.0011997561668977141, -0.035467278212308884, -0.009008713997900486, 0.01868858002126217, -0.0015011932700872421, 0.022017965093255043, -0.0274438988417387, -0.011335979215800762, -0.041342709213495255, -0.010276304557919502, 0.023875657469034195, -0.015005610883235931, -0.001092246500775218, 0.04025597870349884, 0.011962619610130787, 0.015475922264158726, -0.0029686654452234507, 0.0022221144754439592, -0.013102615252137184, -0.020197801291942596, 0.020331542938947678, 0.05708128213882446, -0.009551665745675564, -0.08004789799451828, -0.01897636614739895, 0.034148313105106354, -0.0272359661757946, -0.05343393608927727, -0.006597431842237711, 0.007408520672470331, -0.02603251300752163, -0.06693202257156372, 0.005731500219553709, 0.04954531788825989, 0.015722259879112244, -0.03608396276831627, 0.0016365638002753258, 0.028466448187828064, 0.06744564324617386, -0.007333023939281702, -0.01080138236284256, 0.06718190014362335, -0.021580124273896217, -0.016962699592113495, 0.016548363491892815, 0.06925227493047714, -0.0365765281021595, 0.02711649239063263, -0.005422181915491819, -0.05504261702299118, 0.014240938238799572, -0.0034947111271321774, -0.03911945968866348, 0.027787700295448303, 0.011627278290688992, 0.04213767126202583, -0.01458577811717987, 0.012653494253754616, 0.007773593068122864, 0.0173636581748724, 0.004809723701328039, -0.013409633189439774, -0.020579339936375618, -0.011408056132495403, 0.025116445496678352, -0.027739735320210457, -0.0017946335719898343, -0.0021764859557151794, 0.10356967896223068, -0.048199091106653214, -0.019925754517316818, 0.02912280149757862, 0.01185294333845377, 0.020002786070108414, -0.010023380629718304, 0.0006201533251442015, -0.01318519376218319, 0.00017813588783610612, -0.057509370148181915, -0.0473625473678112, -0.029570322483778, 0.0047681392170488834, 0.051537226885557175, -0.024920795112848282, 0.07288921624422073, 0.005787080619484186, 0.0016601411625742912, 0.0139883141964674, -0.03933548554778099, -0.0010676641250029206, -0.056499406695365906, -0.012598465196788311, 0.012949242256581783, -0.028981035575270653, 0.014161769300699234, 0.02921653352677822, 0.019631531089544296, -0.0493926964700222, 0.023239141330122948, 0.010402281768620014, -0.007546865846961737, 0.004564895760267973, -0.005948467645794153, -0.022288698703050613, 0.04099545627832413, -0.022129958495497704, 0.04636630415916443, -0.04017136991024017, -0.01899850182235241, 0.02797718346118927, 0.053851015865802765, -0.004045301117002964, -0.03593986853957176, 0.015589305199682713, -0.04343348369002342, 0.004565093666315079, 0.023708418011665344, 0.006071572657674551, 0.0087164007127285, 0.005705033894628286, 0.06395382434129715, -0.019885383546352386, 0.023943211883306503, -0.03401710093021393, -0.07946090400218964, 0.011384527198970318, -0.015229256823658943, -0.038462765514850616, 0.024867191910743713, 0.00036062675644643605, 0.021336091682314873, -0.021887047216296196, -0.020348872989416122, 0.007135652005672455, -0.010841216892004013, -0.00709470734000206, -0.021181423217058182, 0.08788128197193146, 0.006537456996738911, 0.03602780029177666, -0.010688386857509613, 0.00856262817978859, 0.1180357038974762, 0.07860256731510162, 0.007644284516572952, -0.0588756687939167, 0.0178120955824852, -0.024114567786455154, 0.0010140299564227462, -0.022508151829242706, 0.0126602528616786, -0.023594794794917107, -0.0004354161210358143, 0.021555356681346893, 0.04419998079538345, -0.037775520235300064, -0.04280111566185951, 0.009291311725974083, -0.0027512996457517147, -0.014857943169772625, -0.043531376868486404, 0.013731713406741619, -0.0200436320155859, -0.014932123944163322, -0.04695255681872368, 0.04637937247753143, -0.041295018047094345, -0.009935320354998112, -0.008215600624680519, -0.022091107442975044, -0.027676399797201157, -0.004578396677970886, -0.011748197488486767, -0.02568596974015236, 0.05205657333135605, -0.006575067061930895, -0.026652691885828972, -0.006351209711283445, -0.013431091792881489, 0.0013371241511777043, 0.0312960110604763, 0.03939405456185341, -0.020227568224072456, 0.017716970294713974, 0.04663124307990074, 0.020144859328866005, -0.032879650592803955, -0.039387401193380356, -0.03510507196187973, 0.05039690062403679, 0.008522136136889458, -0.011862309649586678, -0.03882055729627609, -0.051808323711156845, 0.007344800513237715, -0.0308803953230381, -0.03196825087070465, -0.0054192752577364445, 0.011228526942431927, -0.005498615559190512, 0.019742615520954132, -0.04713499918580055, 0.040483005344867706, -0.007786829490214586, 0.0195755697786808, 0.012904265895485878, -0.05506754666566849, -0.016842251643538475, -0.00830233283340931, 0.04975924640893936, 0.019835490733385086, 0.016436442732810974, -0.004808465484529734, -0.036517493426799774, -0.030121106654405594, -0.0246414951980114, -0.023757506161928177, -0.0015887231566011906, 0.048739686608314514, 0.024736983701586723, -0.01470104604959488, 0.004848063923418522, -0.04734647646546364, 0.013502665795385838, -0.046574629843235016, -0.0050069913268089294, -0.05315297096967697, -0.02680487371981144, 0.04869262874126434, -0.0024023225996643305, -0.02092929184436798, 0.04324182868003845, -0.004672504495829344, 0.07400968670845032, 0.018085060641169548, -0.0328604057431221, -0.029822813346982002, -0.02466879040002823, 0.014362365938723087, 0.009573795832693577, -0.017499513924121857, 0.01736663654446602, 0.008384539745748043, 0.051228299736976624, -0.037297748029232025, -0.004093201365321875, -0.014452585019171238, 0.008662103675305843, 0.02817806974053383, -0.03286812826991081, 0.0072287037037312984, 0.045305415987968445, 0.027555469423532486, -0.01873362995684147, 0.0017775541637092829, -0.005474324803799391, 0.0021267260890454054, -0.015433140099048615, 0.0002523273869883269, -0.05509449541568756, 0.004494660068303347, -0.04161185026168823, 0.02465778775513172, -0.048475779592990875, -0.004300315864384174, 0.008863385766744614, 0.009775605984032154, 0.0025677429512143135, 0.014247954823076725, 0.0007457907777279615, 0.0008389743161387742, -0.01652570068836212, 0.0009244218817912042, 0.042276181280612946, -0.004808608442544937, -0.022046295925974846, -0.01680689863860607, 0.06278423964977264, -0.008762972429394722, 0.04722893610596657, -0.039591964334249496, -0.043144408613443375, 0.03608839213848114, -0.03523226082324982, 0.004489042330533266, 0.032733891159296036, -0.018670445308089256, 0.03541870042681694, 0.02792220562696457, -0.028742529451847076, -0.036098647862672806, 0.03907167166471481, -0.04028359800577164, 0.011128643527626991, 0.0044684638269245625, -0.030261650681495667, 0.03398554399609566, -0.005662951618432999, -0.02714317850768566, 0.021059319376945496, -0.006693062838166952, 0.0188811756670475, 0.036458857357501984, 0.001673421123996377, -0.028524398803710938, 0.021088246256113052, 0.006307500880211592, 0.008467345498502254, 0.009964370168745518, -0.01215189229696989, 0.018111655488610268, 0.017050419002771378, -0.003125607967376709, 0.008556652814149857, -0.008890887722373009, -0.013742927461862564, -0.044152773916721344, 0.028894580900669098, 0.0203245859593153, 0.026924416422843933, 0.030219899490475655, -0.013335046358406544, 0.0037867974024266005, 0.010869470424950123, -0.07141268253326416, -0.0016052474966272712, -0.010586525313556194, -0.049135785549879074, -0.04830210655927658, -0.02175571769475937, -0.0799141675233841, 0.05014777183532715, 0.028541535139083862, 0.01797112077474594, 0.005580937955528498, 0.03392354026436806, -0.0009100274182856083, -0.01775139756500721, -0.02519194222986698, 0.013978083617985249, -0.003278495045378804, -0.03249247744679451, 0.048368215560913086, -0.04510924592614174, -0.019877221435308456, 0.06964312493801117, 0.02345661073923111, -0.004816499538719654, -0.005880542099475861, 0.023848969489336014, -0.004042316228151321, 0.01999911479651928, 0.028404828161001205, 0.02448328584432602, 0.027106989175081253, -0.019055813550949097, -0.009973205626010895, 0.016490427777171135, -0.014155481941998005, 0.012196915224194527, 0.03138771280646324, -0.00635190773755312, -0.009398980997502804, 0.037817295640707016, -0.0294178556650877, -0.03234000504016876, -0.012696621008217335, 0.004387208726257086, -0.022082900628447533, -0.009121689014136791, 0.04320135712623596, 0.009661946445703506, -0.028352368623018265, 0.07954788208007812, 0.05919704958796501, -0.030073106288909912, 0.011637046933174133, -0.014271195977926254, -0.0749446302652359, 0.061328306794166565, 0.03800906985998154, -0.045610468834638596, -0.043210674077272415, -0.03933856263756752, -0.019270315766334534, 0.02787765860557556, -0.019448043778538704, -0.027044732123613358, -0.025716029107570648, 0.026195788756012917, 0.022486327216029167, 0.03366048261523247, 0.017171397805213928, -0.008250030688941479, -0.008617772720754147, -0.06684049218893051, 0.05161145702004433, -0.016113508492708206, -0.04329819232225418, -0.013246886432170868, -0.02084234729409218, -0.035582613199949265, -0.017394665628671646, 0.03587886318564415, 0.03067098930478096, 0.0008836492779664695, 0.04105649143457413, 0.015385963022708893, 0.014309941790997982, -0.03251326084136963, 0.029596559703350067, -0.005062277894467115, -0.009935225360095501, -0.010643292218446732, -0.010173866525292397, -0.023614054545760155, 0.013389520347118378, 0.023850765079259872, 0.003964017610996962, 0.017442164942622185, 0.0065619745291769505, -0.01583017222583294, 0.01763521507382393, -0.014702882617712021, -0.02336130663752556, 0.09595070034265518, 0.033368177711963654, -0.020333515480160713, -0.02537291869521141, -0.03188050538301468, -0.040245186537504196, 0.00986526720225811, -0.028098074719309807, -0.00424386840313673, -0.030131405219435692, 0.02151699922978878, 0.0024888073094189167, -0.0436793714761734, 0.004098536446690559, 0.04767456650733948, -0.012701953761279583, -0.004919625818729401, 0.036928996443748474, 0.010278284549713135, 0.008083502762019634, 0.027847787365317345, 0.03213360905647278, 0.0064768074080348015, -0.01437937282025814, 0.04776157811284065, 0.010760875418782234, 0.008067109622061253, -0.02005121111869812, 0.004176238551735878, 0.004048021975904703, -0.06047617644071579, -0.0003116489970125258, -0.05238664522767067, -0.02132393606007099, -0.029196973890066147, -0.06165606528520584, 0.039675965905189514, -0.01789063960313797, 0.011195536702871323, 0.002957119606435299, -0.040020961314439774, 0.030434273183345795, -0.029549989849328995, -0.0036681254860013723, -0.0009573451825417578, 0.009790823794901371, -0.03378940746188164, 0.008306913077831268, 0.004040250554680824, -0.005791123956441879, 0.0025616686325520277, -0.0035704602487385273, 0.020754499360919, -0.023831482976675034, 0.0044157179072499275, -0.06613133102655411, 0.027772625908255577, 0.026920896023511887, -0.0015417697140946984, -0.04827134311199188, -0.02970465086400509, -0.031041786074638367, -0.0460459440946579, 0.009146375581622124, 0.01815245859324932, 0.004738180432468653, -0.041614074259996414, -0.01935524307191372, 0.014243866316974163, 0.06667064875364304, -0.06737057119607925, 0.014273294247686863, -0.010925045236945152, 0.001478257472626865, -0.014485484920442104, -0.04621212184429169 ]
<blockquote> <p>Let $X_{1},..,X_{n}$ be a sample from normal distribution with mean ${\theta}$ and variance 1. Let $H_{0}:{\theta}={\theta}_{0}$ and $H_{1}:{\theta}={\theta}_{1}$. Use the Neyman-Pearson lemma to show that the best test for $H_{0}$ vs $H_{1}$ has a critical region of the form mean$(X_{1},..,X_{n}){\geq}k$.</p> </blockquote> <p>I have done this part. The next question is: </p> <blockquote> <p>Let ${\theta}_{0}=0$ and ${\theta}_{1}=1$. Find the values of $n$ and $k$ so that the power function of the test ${\phi}$ has values ${\phi}{\theta}_{0}=0.01$ and ${\phi}{\theta}_{1}=0.9$. Write down the corresponding decision rule.</p> </blockquote> <p>My work thus far: Let $Y= \text{mean}(X_{1},..,X_{n})$. we have $P(Y{\geq}k|{\theta}_{0})=0.01$. Similarly for ${\theta}_{1}$. But how do I go from here? </p>
74,512
[ -0.02918572910130024, -0.08411920815706253, 0.02491108328104019, -0.0008795573958195746, 0.00927776750177145, 0.015772724524140358, 0.007601603399962187, -0.005823699291795492, 0.051359280943870544, -0.011268648318946362, 0.05940933898091316, 0.022705672308802605, 0.05628178268671036, 0.08885611593723297, 0.015624484047293663, 0.0035620303824543953, -0.027147162705659866, 0.0014853383181616664, -0.023152094334363937, 0.001074653584510088, -0.007546492852270603, -0.0006741915713064373, 0.011777267791330814, -0.013021194376051426, -0.06052500754594803, 0.020971084013581276, 0.011120293289422989, 0.00844280794262886, 0.0046454560942947865, 0.08297429978847504, -0.027341628447175026, -0.012950155884027481, 0.01760830543935299, 0.007714299019426107, 0.021987689658999443, 0.009600130841135979, -0.0005666117067448795, -0.0008759695920161903, 0.01230734121054411, -0.0034580794163048267, -0.05213366821408272, -0.028002537786960602, 0.04082377254962921, -0.008239212445914745, -0.01970013976097107, -0.0019983837846666574, -0.021576259285211563, -0.04108553007245064, 0.02414102479815483, -0.051763102412223816, 0.04995701089501381, 0.021800480782985687, 0.030963152647018433, 0.023858018219470978, 0.04262213781476021, -0.05546247214078903, 0.022408535704016685, 0.06706522405147552, -0.01573304459452629, -0.04446711018681526, 0.012836734764277935, -0.06742484867572784, -0.02367979846894741, -0.008065594360232353, -0.025405552238225937, 0.032370686531066895, -0.018135007470846176, -0.0007012207061052322, 0.0009315977804362774, -0.018857896327972412, 0.002892124932259321, 0.016100890934467316, 0.014157143421471119, 0.021673360839486122, 0.005998316220939159, -0.013985974714159966, 0.013307112269103527, 0.022581126540899277, 0.027576640248298645, 0.03440455347299576, 0.024644088000059128, 0.03505168482661247, 0.05027297884225845, 0.03631571680307388, -0.006260667461901903, 0.02251848578453064, 0.10325548052787781, -0.021544042974710464, -0.00809798389673233, 0.07482246309518814, 0.016278643161058426, -0.009664065204560757, 0.0261489599943161, -0.0475153848528862, -0.05363715440034866, 0.020544735714793205, -0.04223225638270378, -0.012544508092105389, 0.017954187467694283, 0.009252970106899738, -0.02057173103094101, -0.055972617119550705, 0.043565694242715836, 0.026550833135843277, -0.018972620368003845, 0.0003706466231960803, -0.024874452501535416, -0.0037007234059274197, 0.000948564033024013, -0.004291657358407974, -0.004623671527951956, 0.045609939843416214, -0.0017433686880394816, 0.045770786702632904, -0.014589077793061733, 0.01750510185956955, -0.03276984021067619, -0.0343850813806057, 0.07019320875406265, 0.028669102117419243, 0.060376547276973724, 0.04108118638396263, 0.008620006032288074, -0.0038375293370336294, -0.04066905751824379, 0.030796900391578674, 0.008552122861146927, -0.013392187654972076, -0.023029278963804245, 0.031718023121356964, -0.018069220706820488, 0.03627179563045502, 0.021362435072660446, 0.017946882173419, 0.023951254785060883, -0.007269341964274645, -0.07604598253965378, -0.021434996277093887, 0.05565981939435005, -0.022813042625784874, 0.0035351791884750128, -0.025603661313652992, -0.016610197722911835, 0.0657418966293335, 0.029995078220963478, -0.013863337226212025, 0.05243578553199768, 0.0008322449866682291, -0.005651956424117088, 0.027411343529820442, -0.027352655306458473, 0.0031896946020424366, -0.005029792431741953, 0.021417295560240746, -0.01890326291322708, -0.07397477328777313, 0.02799246273934841, 0.005458553787320852, -0.03975701704621315, -0.05120962858200073, 0.024134885519742966, -0.02391778863966465, -0.005867131520062685, -0.07474100589752197, -0.025612758472561836, -0.005333586595952511, 0.06018611788749695, 0.0032559914980083704, 0.04634523391723633, 0.008658013306558132, 0.017325539141893387, 0.019430840387940407, -0.012372810393571854, 0.05094343051314354, 0.028114859014749527, -0.017675507813692093, 0.0018202845240011811, -0.07076786458492279, 0.018847456201910973, 0.012888954021036625, -0.00916824210435152, 0.039000362157821655, -0.041318152099847794, 0.03256915137171745, 0.024146832525730133, 0.03815167769789696, 0.006208623759448528, -0.04005379229784012, 0.04270903393626213, -0.04199635982513428, -0.03531990200281143, -0.04795308783650398, -0.017613975331187248, 0.01894991658627987, -0.054199688136577606, 0.040995724499225616, 0.007175262551754713, 0.020122254267334938, 0.002459572860971093, 0.004363218322396278, -0.013861817307770252, 0.006392893381416798, 0.035075996071100235, -0.044277481734752655, 0.02316572703421116, 0.05384735390543938, 0.019980929791927338, -0.020069653168320656, 0.03694421797990799, -0.06314627826213837, 0.0003055579727515578, 0.012838629074394703, -0.038008950650691986, 0.01192676555365324, 0.0028104702942073345, 0.02176475338637829, 0.011501726694405079, 0.011702869087457657, 0.027977824211120605, 0.03511875495314598, -0.07742806524038315, 0.05809561908245087, 0.06322414427995682, -0.007816478610038757, 0.03881911560893059, -0.019284719601273537, 0.012985263019800186, -0.0006830399506725371, -0.024914957582950592, 0.004942855332046747, -0.043905481696128845, 0.010333962738513947, 0.0451369434595108, 0.01143980585038662, -0.04066089540719986, 0.018250521272420883, 0.05044971778988838, -0.030772417783737183, 0.024615805596113205, 0.021053006872534752, 0.004557978827506304, 0.013299721293151379, -0.011561602354049683, 0.05915716663002968, -0.013551638461649418, -0.001965865958482027, -0.010287229903042316, 0.008450117893517017, 0.044464994221925735, -0.016480451449751854, -0.014490770176053047, 0.07094617187976837, -0.0074792723171412945, 0.024395739659667015, 0.00946008786559105, -0.014045627787709236, 0.07058247923851013, -0.05341774970293045, -0.004693192895501852, 0.025683624669909477, 0.003987365867942572, 0.00830620713531971, -0.026768632233142853, 0.000701507437042892, 0.049016110599040985, 0.03660784661769867, 0.002135632559657097, 0.018953636288642883, 0.03935757279396057, -0.049743667244911194, 0.00830747839063406, -0.02934281714260578, -0.052383940666913986, -0.005296129267662764, 0.0003794941876549274, 0.019578928127884865, 0.03474050015211105, 0.005834212061017752, -0.012477264739573002, -0.026810819283127785, -0.047791723161935806, -0.017927825450897217, 0.03535694256424904, -0.005530530121177435, -0.07211710512638092, -0.02701462432742119, -0.020662110298871994, 0.0031077065505087376, 0.010765371844172478, 0.014063725247979164, -0.0006145783117972314, 0.0031276049558073282, 0.025110162794589996, -0.05250153690576553, -0.012214737944304943, -0.04286401718854904, 0.002789977705106139, -0.055045127868652344, -0.022653009742498398, 0.049898870289325714, 0.02349103055894375, -0.037765633314847946, -0.0008463303092867136, -0.005670958664268255, -0.03599337488412857, -0.04247376695275307, 0.04090280085802078, -0.022034352645277977, 0.011839760467410088, 0.006273308768868446, 0.008261150680482388, 0.009532909840345383, -0.03342980891466141, -0.0697828009724617, -0.0365571491420269, 0.00865829549729824, -0.021680274978280067, 0.05244012549519539, 0.00043979601468890905, -0.013869033195078373, 0.09018973261117935, 0.06538713723421097, -0.0025919792242348194, -0.03221254423260689, 0.033918920904397964, -0.013534128665924072, -0.06798024475574493, 0.02217273600399494, 0.03731951490044594, -0.016425151377916336, 0.029274024069309235, 0.018757641315460205, 0.04487664997577667, 0.0520322322845459, -0.007551727816462517, 0.0009533191914670169, 0.018962185829877853, -0.004670438822358847, -0.02615026943385601, 0.05916139483451843, 0.031518012285232544, -0.005330621264874935, 0.007352454122155905, -0.0134377246722579, 0.04159620404243469, 0.042197760194540024, -0.037048354744911194, 0.025269176810979843, -0.013663015328347683, 0.020768772810697556, 0.003160475753247738, 0.02259724959731102, 0.0058463686145842075, -0.017301494255661964, -0.016916748136281967, 0.012453973293304443, 0.012957598082721233, -0.03365432843565941, -0.01248645968735218, 0.027586733922362328, 0.07883360981941223, -0.03769616037607193, -0.046144790947437286, -0.014702199958264828, -0.017503395676612854, 0.044543951749801636, -0.0329938642680645, -0.01875988394021988, 0.003371843136847019, 0.043484486639499664, 0.002147757215425372, 0.0019470457918941975, -0.014947475865483284, -0.003515376942232251, -0.021114753559231758, 0.030893636867403984, -0.02390129119157791, 0.04453883320093155, -0.021149352192878723, 0.04371142014861107, 0.07026669383049011, -0.03465249389410019, 0.007180575747042894, -0.0010603484697639942, -0.06693053245544434, 0.04851677268743515, -0.00609176978468895, -0.012488662265241146, 0.022122478112578392, -0.018825653940439224, 0.02999621070921421, -0.038317710161209106, 0.041966572403907776, 0.0014669918455183506, 0.024180736392736435, -0.050011757761240005, 0.028566226363182068, -0.019782723858952522, -0.04535341635346413, -0.03239738196134567, 0.027460461482405663, 0.02222726121544838, -0.004096683580428362, 0.02130088582634926, 0.04911411181092262, -0.029152246192097664, 0.03554603457450867, 0.010564539581537247, 0.03282574564218521, 0.01622948609292507, 0.04842810332775116, 0.02005365490913391, 0.03857673332095146, 0.006101618055254221, 0.029715413227677345, -0.03454591706395149, 0.03142445906996727, 0.0483924001455307, 0.0007694561500102282, -0.0062304213643074036, -0.013233202509582043, -0.009617729112505913, -0.015800027176737785, -0.0034923572093248367, 0.0014730433467775583, -0.02863638661801815, 0.054445333778858185, 0.009711970575153828, -0.014498143456876278, 0.0065878345631062984, 0.06729934364557266, 0.028796063736081123, 0.005136336665600538, -0.009038131684064865, 0.017886996269226074, -0.03980297967791557, 0.006390547379851341, -0.03639553114771843, 0.03833992779254913, 0.024808932095766068, -0.022350119426846504, 0.05464983731508255, -0.0003887921047862619, -0.0197589173913002, 0.009155577048659325, -0.005466540344059467, 0.03765687346458435, -0.007774006575345993, -0.03640155866742134, 0.027476683259010315, 0.0012986311921849847, -0.015865743160247803, 0.012825330719351768, -0.012770714238286018, -0.017628740519285202, 0.013808953575789928, 0.056144509464502335, 0.035205140709877014, -0.004187829792499542, 0.005678165704011917, -0.0738171860575676, -0.02934986725449562, 0.044865041971206665, -0.04677889496088028, 0.0727580338716507, -0.021432453766465187, -0.022044150158762932, -0.034753549844026566, -0.020426031202077866, -0.06423981487751007, 0.038944654166698456, -0.020095132291316986, 0.05723617225885391, -0.03362797945737839, -0.013253062032163143, -0.04910009726881981, 0.007181223016232252, 0.00002658475023054052, 0.07189393043518066, -0.014847014099359512, -0.0168301984667778, -0.036916714161634445, 0.0066136750392615795, -0.025633659213781357, -0.0658828616142273, 0.015785662457346916, 0.023281220346689224, 0.020781921222805977, 0.0056975604966282845, -0.04687431827187538, -0.060307443141937256, 0.05443909764289856, 0.009302278980612755, -0.051008984446525574, 0.036892350763082504, 0.0002155867259716615, 0.06925398111343384, 0.04057106375694275, 0.012891603633761406, 0.022344639524817467, -0.015983371064066887, -0.0049389502964913845, -0.0034618701320141554, -0.053151935338974, -0.03218036890029907, -0.005223435815423727, -0.003966893535107374, -0.03542773798108101, -0.0120997354388237, -0.03412773460149765, 0.0030701705254614353, 0.010968965478241444, 0.046118780970573425, -0.002204609103500843, 0.02490728348493576, -0.020717326551675797, -0.027293529361486435, 0.009608632884919643, -0.023084696382284164, 0.00552596990019083, 0.006379882805049419, 0.029462197795510292, 0.04167584702372551, 0.03501003235578537, -0.03804825618863106, 0.010559760965406895, 0.041280634701251984, -0.04192182049155235, -0.011237533763051033, -0.05202845484018326, -0.0308453980833292, -0.02015022560954094, -0.04506697878241539, 0.05096656456589699, -0.020084146410226822, 0.017199905589222908, 0.017420412972569466, 0.0076329149305820465, -0.00017085220315493643, 0.022419126704335213, -0.008857034146785736, 0.01994348131120205, -0.0024281609803438187, 0.025117604061961174, -0.025917919352650642, 0.00021417986135929823, -0.07449513673782349, -0.010268960148096085, -0.007660051342099905, 0.013235083781182766, -0.00528310239315033, -0.025010067969560623, 0.011001551523804665, 0.014073933474719524, -0.04372407868504524, -0.003519250312820077, 0.03556963428854942, -0.00026544748106971383, -0.029462594538927078, 0.003950370475649834, 0.03123318962752819, 0.11192663758993149, -0.0050027379766106606, -0.022533956915140152, 0.03141264244914055, -0.014100211672484875, -0.015999536961317062, 0.012096067890524864, 0.00525665795430541, -0.024882756173610687, -0.025191811844706535, -0.04331032186746597, 0.005244056228548288, -0.0006415166426450014, 0.025564607232809067, -0.023360280320048332, 0.0025835889391601086, 0.002262931549921632, -0.02295084483921528, -0.0057673207484185696, -0.03832133114337921, -0.002598400926217437, 0.018670961260795593, -0.000011728230674634688, -0.0030851727351546288, -0.0068739186972379684, -0.005415713414549828, -0.0023779859766364098, 0.013791644014418125, 0.01622384786605835, 0.023833852261304855, 0.0662226527929306, -0.03277990594506264, -0.008487465791404247, 0.009786977432668209, -0.027158761397004128, 0.018314724788069725, 0.0093622962012887, -0.000418018433265388, -0.017492271959781647, 0.005358814727514982, -0.03548763692378998, -0.00018454478413332254, -0.051347728818655014, 0.022977737709879875, 0.039703402668237686, 0.0029941643588244915, 0.049332473427057266, 0.030748222023248672, 0.005820938386023045, -0.029512040317058563, -0.030284827575087547, -0.028405331075191498, -0.04863864555954933, 0.004170488566160202, 0.06077360734343529, 0.03226824477314949, -0.002719482872635126, 0.08847352117300034, 0.013911057263612747, 0.014714609831571579, -0.01230761967599392, 0.0018577368464320898, -0.01648067496716976, 0.03783944249153137, -0.045872338116168976, -0.011990421451628208, 0.026269547641277313, -0.04715007171034813, 0.0017385468818247318, -0.016236916184425354, -0.005589642096310854, 0.02931821346282959, 0.022204721346497536, -0.009304311126470566, -0.03393235802650452, -0.022861430421471596, -0.0626431480050087, -0.004832837730646133, -0.007081678602844477, -0.021637054160237312, 0.009016647934913635, 0.030359391123056412, 0.01066164392977953, -0.01046066451817751, 0.02402585558593273, -0.007482106797397137, -0.05408143252134323, -0.022616509348154068, -0.020341815426945686, -0.07237419486045837, 0.018139297142624855, 0.002655924065038562, -0.02033773995935917, 0.03939592093229294, -0.048495855182409286, 0.0019112419104203582, 0.01901763118803501, -0.008808212354779243, -0.00824054516851902, 0.0627974420785904, 0.02697313018143177, 0.06207278370857239, 0.02604806050658226, -0.006987767294049263, 0.12868696451187134, 0.06901207566261292, 0.014804734848439693, -0.07422429323196411, 0.019892830401659012, -0.015240738168358803, -0.0011376691982150078, -0.04096183180809021, -0.004828391596674919, 0.015370144508779049, 0.023783916607499123, 0.027922235429286957, 0.029719194397330284, 0.014443996362388134, -0.00514680752530694, 0.05649131163954735, -0.021495796740055084, -0.032484058290719986, -0.004520933609455824, 0.02489912323653698, -0.01341386791318655, -0.008682242594659328, -0.01352581474930048, 0.011971944011747837, -0.016313057392835617, -0.042269520461559296, -0.044832900166511536, -0.017574071884155273, 0.0175533015280962, -0.026895174756646156, -0.016451895236968994, 0.007463059388101101, 0.012517624534666538, -0.026358846575021744, 0.0028016173746436834, -0.025550633668899536, -0.011828117072582245, -0.04107526317238808, 0.01613280177116394, 0.0375032052397728, 0.019783135503530502, -0.024658139795064926, 0.0038136153016239405, 0.0030615231953561306, -0.025630753487348557, -0.008288301527500153, -0.018345050513744354, 0.03356863558292389, 0.018212655559182167, -0.027656687423586845, 0.025912340730428696, -0.0060973335057497025, -0.007263182662427425, -0.030559208244085312, -0.015004517510533333, 0.04328346252441406, 0.02332659810781479, -0.04228037968277931, -0.018060771748423576, -0.03130921348929405, 0.02336041070520878, -0.015091403387486935, 0.03679947927594185, -0.0013187875738367438, -0.037086986005306244, -0.01443573273718357, -0.016834482550621033, 0.015437188558280468, 0.02535550855100155, -0.0031199264340102673, -0.015311417169868946, -0.011825823225080967, -0.01092352345585823, -0.0005598573479801416, -0.02192901074886322, -0.046477191150188446, 0.02379465475678444, 0.028509149327874184, -0.032172974199056625, -0.029523443430662155, -0.031247735023498535, 0.004517607856541872, -0.030319256708025932, 0.02035733312368393, -0.018760621547698975, -0.031715504825115204, -0.03161351755261421, 0.01782659813761711, 0.04257987439632416, -0.06339950859546661, 0.05434593930840492, 0.023304304108023643, 0.050472281873226166, -0.06956431269645691, -0.02478913590312004, -0.014277777634561062, -0.05021442472934723, 0.031021127477288246, -0.0007048029219731688, 0.06428299099206924, 0.02748345397412777, 0.030229531228542328, 0.020800862461328506, 0.013304862193763256, -0.035770609974861145, 0.014070645906031132, -0.028360076248645782, -0.03184662386775017, 0.005026564467698336, 0.015887269750237465, 0.0381176620721817, -0.02865699492394924, -0.0273373331874609, -0.03200918808579445, -0.003763907589018345, 0.018039820715785027, -0.008350683376193047, 0.007106421049684286, 0.007968531921505928, -0.010749037377536297, 0.04503104090690613, -0.02419041283428669, 0.03028748370707035, 0.026558268815279007, -0.011346988379955292, -0.008885438553988934, 0.012256886810064316, -0.004087827634066343, 0.01694696582853794, 0.03453956916928291, -0.010029499419033527, 0.03011450543999672, 0.03851556405425072, 0.03942912817001343, -0.007342225406318903, -0.024465398862957954, 0.0030921236611902714, 0.04792116582393646, -0.01715758442878723, 0.022277209907770157, 0.034558508545160294, -0.037807125598192215, -0.005356589797884226, 0.004737939685583115, 0.026768166571855545, 0.012881780043244362, 0.01575644314289093, -0.02539817988872528, -0.0038180111441761255, 0.015502367168664932, -0.0015481639420613647, -0.010679048486053944, -0.024667957797646523, 0.01810448057949543, 0.008966979570686817, -0.00011113051004940644, -0.004600224085152149, -0.005627347156405449, 0.02657017856836319, 0.021760134026408195, 0.007704159244894981, 0.004856000654399395, -0.0010202861158177257, -0.001255731680430472, 0.006006857845932245, 0.02189774066209793, -0.016100965440273285, -0.03636590391397476, 0.0322730578482151, 0.04342084378004074, -0.029586059972643852, 0.020402224734425545, -0.03848477452993393, 0.009441855363547802, -0.0846392810344696, -0.06303638964891434, 0.034150198101997375, -0.012690387666225433, 0.031783509999513626, -0.0322740375995636, 0.019432151690125465, 0.033465851098299026, -0.02451847866177559, 0.013572999276220798, 0.013026246801018715, 0.02144130878150463, -0.06926661729812622, 0.01826152764260769, -0.005531980190426111, 0.025201719254255295, 0.003336325054988265, -0.014901389367878437, 0.03273160383105278, 0.04847162589430809, 0.004396308679133654, -0.0228548813611269, 0.013075756840407848, -0.014047285541892052, -0.02051909640431404, -0.08240412175655365, 0.030192047357559204, -0.04445721209049225, -0.03467507287859917, 0.014604576863348484, -0.03571045771241188, 0.0044354042038321495, 0.008949903771281242, 0.020767342299222946, 0.01426361408084631, 0.06273774057626724, 0.02122468315064907, 0.010936085134744644, -0.010634496808052063, -0.02983204275369644, 0.039150964468717575, 0.014886693097651005, -0.024020615965127945, -0.023726630955934525, 0.044582948088645935, -0.007144065108150244, -0.056300047785043716, -0.005900062154978514, 0.017699457705020905, -0.052300311625003815, 0.008311263285577297, 0.004339929204434156, -0.01241376157850027, -0.016468344256281853, 0.019505128264427185, -0.0418681763112545, -0.05206850916147232, 0.0016280756099149585, 0.03463144972920418, -0.002189639722928405, 0.006245466880500317, -0.022292258217930794, -0.029960596933960915, -0.013635530136525631, 0.005393168888986111, -0.0043044667690992355, -0.03446408361196518, -0.01992722414433956, -0.022219501435756683, 0.030301257967948914, -0.008308830671012402, -0.004664723761379719, -0.0676589384675026, 0.004570883698761463, -0.016417689621448517, 0.014661078341305256, -0.0040893699042499065, -0.020420171320438385, -0.002661993494257331, -0.09480545669794083, 0.022910114377737045, 0.024886734783649445, -0.013667835853993893, -0.018436618149280548, -0.028529280796647072, -0.049604687839746475, -0.008781778626143932, 0.05501354858279228, 0.020526697859168053, 0.007306124549359083, -0.03698209300637245, 0.015178426168859005, -0.01293281838297844, -0.0854463204741478, 0.03307344391942024, -0.029821868985891342, 0.011188716627657413, -0.007634234149008989, -0.017495572566986084, 0.06762603670358658, 0.009252374060451984, -0.007445249706506729, 0.04429345205426216, -0.015287327580153942, -0.0008215480484068394, 0.014630974270403385, 0.015308203175663948, -0.0018667202675715089, 0.0006456024129875004, 0.04570324718952179, -0.018569525331258774, 0.00607330072671175, -0.024491870775818825, 0.008537166751921177, -0.07522207498550415, 0.010951363481581211, -0.06065811589360237, -0.041557881981134415, -0.03277146443724632, 0.016369322314858437, 0.023042885586619377, -0.07076996564865112, -0.011560920625925064, 0.049641188234090805, -0.0017841272056102753, -0.0039198799058794975, 0.01963672786951065, 0.024130510166287422, 0.034442707896232605, -0.03542682155966759, 0.005065127741545439, -0.02785646729171276, -0.020039275288581848, 0.019707558676600456, 0.014262907207012177, 0.022181231528520584, -0.03588346391916275, 0.00978593248873949, 0.012414521537721157, 0.018741754814982414, 0.04194566607475281, -0.01077797170728445, 0.03720698133111, 0.022048939019441605, -0.027260063216090202, 0.04053451493382454, -0.014822674915194511, -0.020811021327972412, -0.005287417210638523, 0.01447011437267065, 0.04929265379905701, -0.04288293048739433, 0.002431316999718547, -0.021404016762971878, -0.019460877403616905, -0.0010567395947873592, -0.015054658055305481, 0.0295111071318388, 0.003408027347177267, -0.047945454716682434, 0.012665275484323502, 0.026024503633379936, 0.010436666198074818, 0.018456848338246346, -0.012798472307622433, -0.006730148568749428, -0.005627039819955826, -0.00013577388017438352, -0.007327753119170666, -0.04686861112713814, -0.03528185933828354, -0.0013419613242149353, 0.011696495115756989, 0.02791525609791279, 0.004635379184037447, -0.0026995635125786066, -0.03625636175274849, -0.013214058242738247, 0.04703143984079361, -0.02581562101840973, 0.008809560909867287, -0.015252731740474701, -0.004096362739801407, -0.0005840298836119473, -0.05750712752342224 ]
<p>I am trying to understand the relative behavior of the following rank correlation statistics:</p> <ol> <li>Spearman coefficient</li> <li>Kendall Tau / Concordance percentage</li> <li>Normalized Gini coefficient (area under curve of percentage captured versus percentage observations)</li> <li>Normalized Area under ROC curve (for binary classifiers)</li> </ol> <p>I don't believe any of these are functionally related to the others. The accepted answer <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/3943/kendall-tau-or-spearmans-rho">here</a> references <a href="http://www.amstat.org/publications/jse/v14n3/datasets.winner.html" rel="nofollow">this paper</a> and Spearman and Kendall are highly correlated (as one would expect).</p> <p>Are there good intuitions behind/discussions of relative (across datasets) or absolute (for a given dataset) differences for (any pair of) these measures?</p>
74,513
[ -0.04175977036356926, -0.010416821576654911, -0.022159812971949577, -0.01571919023990631, 0.031454164534807205, 0.008419950492680073, -0.007670149672776461, -0.02645144797861576, 0.031887274235486984, -0.03303370624780655, 0.024092311039566994, 0.006159569602459669, 0.060370560735464096, 0.036091770976781845, 0.008591283112764359, 0.00121846585534513, -0.026834722608327866, 0.014542859978973866, 0.015782004222273827, -0.010734610259532928, 0.01230345293879509, 0.04125469923019409, 0.0008964150329120457, 0.0212458036839962, -0.006032406818121672, 0.05184396728873253, -0.03209395706653595, -0.0122855668887496, 0.02077341079711914, 0.05179033428430557, -0.019118761643767357, 0.00002489591497578658, -0.027343900874257088, 0.03896795213222504, 0.008792947977781296, -0.015578008256852627, -0.01569058932363987, -0.012280954979360104, -0.020043056458234787, 0.03514421358704567, -0.050351157784461975, -0.057213421911001205, -0.02887035720050335, 0.022875597700476646, -0.03808578848838806, 0.02161850407719612, -0.007381382863968611, -0.010462688282132149, 0.03960660472512245, -0.04479507356882095, 0.053496189415454865, 0.015430279076099396, 0.02214507944881916, 0.060302019119262695, 0.010771259665489197, 0.002973340917378664, 0.03003094717860222, 0.06697548925876617, -0.014396312646567822, -0.05218404904007912, -0.018237384036183357, -0.010563485324382782, -0.004172390326857567, -0.007007558364421129, -0.01537265069782734, 0.0465271919965744, -0.0013591337483376265, -0.04630131646990776, 0.05571547523140907, -0.018792305141687393, 0.024202562868595123, 0.07584697008132935, 0.020212778821587563, -0.0522969625890255, 0.009756681509315968, -0.04322557896375656, 0.006493268068879843, 0.007792481686919928, 0.03980472683906555, 0.0316409096121788, 0.010027725249528885, 0.028136907145380974, 0.03777163103222847, 0.0480407290160656, 0.04890311881899834, 0.018598871305584908, 0.08645785599946976, -0.03542059659957886, 0.003386005060747266, 0.02408263459801674, 0.008799170143902302, 0.0007472959696315229, 0.015307949855923653, 0.031230788677930832, -0.030069610103964806, 0.025866340845823288, -0.011717201210558414, 0.016960998997092247, -0.010309466160833836, 0.024580834433436394, -0.017501750960946083, -0.022867240011692047, 0.002736206166446209, 0.027262194082140923, -0.025111684575676918, -0.04770234599709511, -0.05352981388568878, 0.01234798226505518, -0.02736828289926052, -0.027317261323332787, -0.025958649814128876, 0.016359766945242882, -0.004081756342202425, -0.012484103441238403, 0.011266548186540604, 0.003964297939091921, 0.0002722933131735772, -0.0028455599676817656, 0.07640071958303452, 0.07128465175628662, 0.042076557874679565, -0.012940282933413982, -0.003904022742062807, -0.056791797280311584, -0.01930086687207222, 0.035719867795705795, 0.05063232034444809, -0.013916153460741043, -0.04777093231678009, 0.05339760705828667, -0.01079853530973196, -0.009228259325027466, 0.015618965029716492, -0.015898866578936577, 0.043434690684080124, -0.0077726892195641994, -0.08163683116436005, -0.0328957624733448, 0.05100923776626587, 0.015446697361767292, -0.0038772504776716232, -0.018241994082927704, 0.0049468036741018295, 0.023800209164619446, 0.05484478175640106, 0.007428805343806744, 0.006167692597955465, -0.023557106032967567, 0.04745309799909592, 0.032780662178993225, -0.033895887434482574, 0.0037316614761948586, -0.021701565012335777, -0.014301292598247528, -0.03541078791022301, -0.06862115859985352, -0.01924668811261654, 0.008359949104487896, 0.01534088235348463, -0.004407241940498352, 0.04780465364456177, 0.032274357974529266, -0.03447524830698967, -0.02443302609026432, 0.00826229713857174, 0.003898032708093524, 0.07077206671237946, 0.005277490708976984, 0.015078321099281311, 0.0026647932827472687, 0.027342036366462708, -0.0032301254104822874, 0.013036472722887993, 0.04958255589008331, 0.054870087653398514, -0.024154381826519966, 0.005726526025682688, -0.036596719175577164, 0.013659577816724777, -0.008777045644819736, -0.05635497719049454, -0.028301158919930458, -0.05577080696821213, -0.030964890494942665, 0.011701790615916252, 0.020922323688864708, -0.04543614760041237, -0.01912824437022209, 0.06492982804775238, -0.04523824527859688, -0.048377931118011475, -0.08268213272094727, 0.0007055675378069282, -0.031700365245342255, -0.04929732903838158, 0.051594071090221405, 0.04395730793476105, 0.037922754883766174, -0.018297310918569565, -0.015256586484611034, -0.007736339699476957, -0.01944730244576931, 0.016720212996006012, -0.016471508890390396, 0.013811859302222729, 0.006660065613687038, 0.027211587876081467, -0.0432465635240078, 0.03476889804005623, -0.05695904791355133, -0.07944046705961227, 0.04191473871469498, -0.017722930759191513, 0.0390852652490139, -0.01611337810754776, -0.041002217680215836, 0.011472216807305813, -0.0056188395246863365, -0.04162927716970444, 0.018374113366007805, -0.05924724042415619, 0.07291559875011444, 0.02776525914669037, -0.001808712026104331, -0.008485011756420135, 0.01457640714943409, 0.009317315183579922, 0.0117610152810812, -0.03448132053017616, -0.01472215075045824, -0.027092719450592995, -0.013395633548498154, 0.036946430802345276, 0.019106239080429077, -0.010855080559849739, 0.013388153165578842, 0.055949997156858444, 0.037789493799209595, -0.012634782120585442, 0.015083655714988708, -0.009909860789775848, -0.02643568068742752, -0.00688930181786418, 0.019239261746406555, 0.012128647416830063, -0.01650194637477398, -0.007489274255931377, -0.030255859717726707, 0.04822416603565216, 0.015571878291666508, 0.0029285247437655926, 0.037037443369627, 0.0015447890618816018, 0.005458626430481672, -0.013686953112483025, -0.017882514744997025, 0.05364852771162987, -0.003945768810808659, -0.012667546980082989, 0.0456170029938221, -0.009271591901779175, 0.003562245750799775, -0.028523890301585197, -0.03424808010458946, 0.009160819463431835, 0.011640298180282116, -0.02017509937286377, 0.011516195721924305, 0.0020010273437947035, -0.028836345300078392, -0.01122319046407938, -0.0423458106815815, -0.003835080424323678, -0.03618896007537842, 0.013841977342963219, 0.058282990008592606, -0.0060462504625320435, 0.056272849440574646, -0.024223484098911285, -0.0000657725686323829, -0.00011345773964421824, -0.0067975278943777084, 0.02074630744755268, 0.018769972026348114, -0.06790389120578766, 0.011441787704825401, -0.02728963829576969, -0.003753266530111432, -0.011294092051684856, -0.0272414181381464, -0.016994088888168335, 0.022195344790816307, -0.009215665981173515, -0.045909225940704346, -0.02198740467429161, -0.007194029167294502, 0.02643422596156597, 0.0012488329084590077, -0.013177280314266682, 0.04286407679319382, -0.03041697107255459, -0.03226640075445175, 0.026969846338033676, -0.00521324947476387, -0.008861134760081768, 0.00676730228587985, 0.015274216420948505, 0.041369661688804626, -0.005161090288311243, -0.019582953304052353, 0.041758086532354355, -0.03065524995326996, -0.05111708492040634, -0.030511189252138138, -0.04976451024413109, 0.045204151421785355, 0.023877838626503944, 0.024687372148036957, 0.011074122041463852, -0.020177751779556274, 0.058107294142246246, 0.01706572435796261, -0.03419423848390579, -0.05999800190329552, 0.003924767952412367, -0.046968284994363785, 0.015024122782051563, -0.013587533496320248, 0.0342513844370842, 0.00713614746928215, 0.030313929542899132, 0.0046348716132342815, 0.0648571029305458, 0.0264714565128088, -0.0015169951366260648, 0.02787076309323311, 0.025685301050543785, 0.04041624441742897, -0.05012929067015648, 0.07218416035175323, 0.011088714003562927, -0.0284428671002388, -0.040464241057634354, 0.00293348147533834, -0.014663280919194221, 0.015354826115071774, -0.04938247427344322, 0.023375842720270157, -0.010451831854879856, 0.017657633870840073, -0.035867590457201004, -0.0034213154576718807, 0.008740155026316643, -0.03885011747479439, -0.003024715231731534, 0.04005734622478485, -0.0033895208034664392, -0.030207326635718346, -0.0007120125228539109, 0.04019667208194733, 0.0383058562874794, 0.005046902224421501, 0.005022272001951933, -0.03264642506837845, -0.002959025325253606, 0.05350740998983383, -0.07024052739143372, 0.019548585638403893, 0.0571407712996006, 0.015879863873124123, 0.007180771790444851, 0.005771140102297068, -0.05469541996717453, 0.004301062785089016, -0.056692712008953094, 0.009982050396502018, -0.04468590393662453, 0.06006329506635666, 0.0207129567861557, 0.03653305023908615, 0.00002300667438248638, -0.010544510558247566, 0.004333578050136566, 0.00740244472399354, -0.056139420717954636, 0.015876630321145058, -0.04632626846432686, -0.015973703935742378, 0.04980717599391937, -0.013344623148441315, 0.03476760908961296, -0.009828430600464344, -0.026633676141500473, -0.008109208196401596, 0.049449238926172256, -0.045229196548461914, 0.002554837614297867, -0.05565612018108368, -0.03653283417224884, 0.05845457687973976, 0.018547983840107918, -0.026902470737695694, -0.013138482347130775, 0.05526748672127724, 0.051843512803316116, 0.003633040003478527, -0.010180887766182423, -0.01787342131137848, 0.01945246011018753, 0.015964379534125328, 0.013462239876389503, 0.057502493262290955, 0.002196899149566889, -0.034250408411026, 0.042186085134744644, -0.00031514474540017545, 0.028300561010837555, 0.020269978791475296, -0.03423396125435829, -0.011328411288559437, 0.0034099824260920286, -0.009618693962693214, 0.00455454969778657, 0.03091665543615818, 0.0074112629517912865, -0.017087435349822044, 0.04372818022966385, 0.05746324360370636, -0.03437063470482826, 0.031595002859830856, 0.043493401259183884, 0.009489309042692184, 0.0027760332450270653, -0.03874535858631134, 0.0000021188443497521803, -0.0037892507389187813, -0.029620695859193802, 0.04310578107833862, 0.0028499318286776543, -0.011697155423462391, -0.00939219631254673, 0.005782950669527054, -0.034258805215358734, -0.06947901099920273, -0.02451174706220627, 0.030935827642679214, 0.021649280562996864, -0.035974904894828796, -0.022265629842877388, -0.008981268852949142, -0.00019507641263771802, 0.05987069383263588, 0.012979011051356792, 0.03208179771900177, -0.0585339292883873, -0.005274247843772173, 0.04320584610104561, 0.027884630486369133, -0.03995087370276451, -0.016506558284163475, -0.018661998212337494, -0.005239507649093866, 0.015853164717555046, -0.025300225242972374, 0.01099509745836258, 0.008030268363654613, -0.01184830628335476, -0.029860438778996468, -0.016309626400470734, -0.01370165217667818, 0.004153019282966852, 0.019914863631129265, 0.0009888160275295377, -0.008784023113548756, -0.013350668363273144, -0.045151498168706894, -0.003431277582421899, -0.040457822382450104, 0.03928929939866066, -0.006994538940489292, 0.007344233803451061, 0.016831863671541214, 0.02487674169242382, 0.014399553649127483, -0.08510623127222061, 0.034477509558200836, 0.009901766665279865, -0.02486407198011875, 0.08071262389421463, -0.020028499886393547, -0.01904667355120182, 0.0005950210033915937, 0.008284316398203373, -0.040752142667770386, 0.034926850348711014, -0.012831530533730984, 0.06284811347723007, 0.0574822798371315, -0.002687852829694748, 0.05542558431625366, 0.011741682887077332, -0.009438114240765572, -0.03399798274040222, -0.0307929590344429, 0.019024929031729698, -0.015356692485511303, -0.02225283347070217, -0.06271905452013016, -0.011001979000866413, -0.021207263693213463, 0.05815233662724495, -0.0008075142395682633, 0.032529376447200775, -0.0171581469476223, 0.007646756246685982, 0.00884913094341755, 0.018425997346639633, -0.054844923317432404, 0.0014851507730782032, 0.03082370012998581, 0.030665896832942963, 0.023209625855088234, -0.023720020428299904, 0.027971580624580383, 0.006755308713763952, -0.01909944787621498, 0.010264923796057701, 0.004939417354762554, 0.03397807851433754, -0.0033870674669742584, 0.0022959085181355476, 0.015629682689905167, 0.015265055932104588, 0.005028929561376572, 0.031425975263118744, -0.010372074320912361, 0.01707504317164421, -0.021314579993486404, -0.010496623814105988, 0.008243776857852936, 0.014813818968832493, 0.0662853866815567, -0.006574023514986038, 0.04965852200984955, 0.01947365701198578, -0.02785531058907509, -0.056389451026916504, -0.036296021193265915, 0.025043746456503868, 0.01088604424148798, -0.013259596191346645, -0.020890291780233383, 0.010996931232511997, 0.003976196050643921, -0.012715333141386509, 0.0139702670276165, 0.05864868685603142, -0.04662467539310455, -0.019096702337265015, 0.004973492119461298, 0.012397234328091145, 0.06054750084877014, -0.026642102748155594, 0.017026612535119057, 0.006054217927157879, 0.016975032165646553, 0.0005647704238072038, 0.037239864468574524, 0.04838450253009796, -0.0323062539100647, -0.03889290988445282, -0.0636841282248497, -0.0354016050696373, 0.04619620367884636, 0.0023129889741539955, -0.00017693459813017398, 0.0062169888988137245, 0.003788667032495141, 0.014311851933598518, 0.000022178295694175176, 0.007819016464054585, 0.015193779952824116, 0.003373665502294898, -0.0032695005647838116, -0.027928167954087257, -0.016005152836441994, 0.0008357304031960666, 0.023455066606402397, -0.0018951575038954616, -0.004912571050226688, 0.001685615978203714, 0.06631609052419662, -0.0058811381459236145, 0.03230879083275795, 0.005401154514402151, -0.06600596010684967, 0.08728596568107605, 0.012001348659396172, 0.022768644616007805, 0.02124931290745735, 0.004074394702911377, -0.017188087105751038, -0.015715815126895905, -0.03916965425014496, -0.006251286715269089, 0.08257532119750977, -0.030817948281764984, 0.05672839656472206, 0.04817808419466019, -0.050342150032520294, 0.015528611838817596, -0.04999518394470215, -0.013181434012949467, -0.0059760818257927895, 0.02210521511733532, 0.03781875967979431, -0.053591255098581314, -0.01012195460498333, 0.03336009383201599, 0.0082537941634655, -0.011268100701272488, 0.01928750053048134, 0.002815172541886568, 0.04000025615096092, 0.026613157242536545, 0.002458389149978757, -0.03202635422348976, 0.037058040499687195, -0.013626995496451855, 0.008100542239844799, 0.004795360378921032, -0.02885323204100132, 0.046153705567121506, 0.038358140736818314, 0.0022521091159433126, -0.06990597397089005, -0.06526011228561401, -0.033269040286540985, 0.018698640167713165, -0.022379925474524498, -0.034537870436906815, 0.0017445464618504047, -0.0001523654646007344, 0.019796399399638176, -0.019779561087489128, 0.04990850389003754, -0.012699433602392673, -0.07562556862831116, -0.029347069561481476, -0.007956407032907009, -0.043531935662031174, 0.02085329033434391, 0.0019993700552731752, -0.024219075217843056, 0.030257415026426315, -0.07987790554761887, -0.0005928475875407457, 0.021156759932637215, 0.0222573671489954, 0.008924184367060661, 0.031511470675468445, -0.025276092812418938, 0.02751949056982994, -0.01626766473054886, -0.0459817610681057, 0.11231575161218643, 0.06635510921478271, 0.028091605752706528, -0.04428860917687416, 0.04885902628302574, -0.017343899235129356, -0.005230493377894163, -0.011681776493787766, -0.007295385934412479, 0.0220353864133358, -0.035171058028936386, 0.045850638300180435, 0.06769897788763046, 0.032927531749010086, -0.013960100710391998, 0.04550790786743164, -0.013656586408615112, -0.010503838770091534, -0.0015866192989051342, 0.018706602975726128, -0.022986844182014465, -0.030504876747727394, -0.019304512068629265, -0.0011870971648022532, 0.006057256832718849, -0.01195643749088049, -0.03226912394165993, 0.010605444200336933, -0.020979154855012894, -0.0007994138286449015, -0.030390135943889618, 0.0022391187958419323, 0.019651418551802635, -0.0005753498408012092, 0.021343257278203964, 0.025542020797729492, 0.01265660859644413, -0.037676382809877396, -0.011387655511498451, 0.04003433510661125, 0.02718093991279602, -0.006652152631431818, 0.035779524594545364, 0.013799822889268398, -0.060545578598976135, 0.01948736235499382, -0.06766407191753387, 0.006941997911781073, -0.011411506682634354, 0.00827641412615776, -0.020325586199760437, -0.006982116959989071, -0.03195175901055336, -0.026359932497143745, -0.05591342970728874, 0.030515031889081, 0.012365195900201797, -0.0041973404586315155, -0.009076452814042568, -0.0031738204415887594, -0.005647956393659115, -0.02180098183453083, 0.058071319013834, 0.019554346799850464, -0.04481368884444237, 0.02043037675321102, -0.03870607912540436, 0.03220927342772484, -0.011572299525141716, 0.02344069443643093, -0.007324632722884417, -0.008290381170809269, -0.04527663812041283, 0.009687616489827633, -0.04344358295202255, 0.0017121124546974897, 0.05874384939670563, 0.023014970123767853, -0.012882565148174763, -0.023561883717775345, -0.051573820412158966, 0.013129724189639091, -0.025111228227615356, -0.0032629133202135563, -0.05029028281569481, 0.009571229107677937, 0.02627272717654705, 0.0032616874668747187, 0.02066764235496521, 0.009747322648763657, -0.009330078959465027, 0.05379413068294525, 0.00013936712639406323, -0.03045015037059784, -0.007050337269902229, 0.004646203946322203, -0.056423358619213104, -0.021815065294504166, -0.00228482554666698, 0.050124138593673706, 0.026675261557102203, 0.016663048416376114, -0.025102173909544945, 0.0031410853844136, 0.010164717212319374, -0.000558107509277761, 0.03575953096151352, -0.028241725638508797, 0.018558183684945107, 0.03093990497291088, -0.017301475629210472, -0.04882004112005234, -0.015376972034573555, -0.04086523503065109, -0.04171600192785263, -0.01294542197138071, -0.040350839495658875, -0.045313671231269836, -0.037702325731515884, 0.033145803958177567, 0.02066296897828579, -0.0028984667733311653, -0.02142683044075966, -0.07064123451709747, 0.01196582056581974, 0.006018348503857851, 0.025580376386642456, -0.00889743585139513, 0.028827717527747154, 0.007080317474901676, 0.025980966165661812, 0.04401537403464317, -0.007561353500932455, -0.005301064811646938, -0.0021083096507936716, -0.003494363045319915, 0.003123630303889513, 0.042129263281822205, -0.02548295073211193, -0.004816435743123293, 0.03417877107858658, -0.04350876808166504, -0.03977629542350769, 0.014241678640246391, -0.013749620877206326, -0.002339678118005395, -0.02174224890768528, 0.011528360657393932, -0.012926332652568817, 0.03696783259510994, -0.002020427491515875, -0.013358497992157936, -0.014775477349758148, 0.00741170160472393, -0.012255407869815826, -0.000562391709536314, 0.011478742584586143, 0.011249111033976078, -0.047562818974256516, 0.00558379665017128, 0.061499789357185364, -0.05840562283992767, -0.0002203983603976667, -0.0021075932309031487, -0.024381613358855247, 0.023509444668889046, -0.012596437707543373, -0.0019881653133779764, 0.04705134406685829, 0.05868018791079521, -0.07837915420532227, 0.047631144523620605, -0.007740770000964403, 0.02653968334197998, -0.05788327753543854, -0.024647153913974762, 0.006354505196213722, -0.011174985207617283, -0.021448323503136635, -0.059405554085969925, -0.025480328127741814, 0.00016157154459506273, -0.039505735039711, 0.08408720791339874, 0.0190623477101326, 0.006684392224997282, -0.027030223980545998, 0.00642838841304183, 0.013924500904977322, 0.028770573437213898, 0.01646902598440647, -0.008373983204364777, 0.031715620309114456, 0.03758080303668976, 0.01030826661735773, 0.012667277827858925, -0.05749127268791199, 0.020526809617877007, 0.036087896674871445, -0.05515315383672714, 0.041483473032712936, -0.0492854043841362, -0.03330421820282936, 0.04171152040362358, -0.035430919378995895, -0.005059062037616968, 0.028527885675430298, -0.020033009350299835, 0.0009973554406315088, 0.001808722852729261, 0.017749691382050514, -0.03969699516892433, -0.047807130962610245, 0.009929407387971878, 0.0029180594719946384, 0.015247617848217487, -0.023075295612215996, 0.012501318007707596, 0.04723183810710907, -0.009570673108100891, 0.020749567076563835, 0.007516511250287294, -0.03515918552875519, -0.033079590648412704, -0.007677453104406595, 0.002105358289554715, 0.01721871644258499, -0.005961155518889427, 0.04071291536092758, -0.051131878048181534, -0.008212056010961533, 0.016257265582680702, 0.028128622099757195, -0.0064785536378622055, -0.001306613557972014, -0.007950200699269772, -0.02234644815325737, 0.01221660990267992, 0.01684471219778061, 0.009268824011087418, -0.04517233371734619, 0.006769050844013691, 0.0004014770092908293, -0.04877855256199837, -0.02238532342016697, -0.04317738115787506, -0.03213600441813469, 0.0504588820040226, -0.0284164659678936, 0.028414102271199226, -0.011125407181680202, -0.01277888286858797, 0.013363002799451351, -0.09311718493700027, 0.028334209695458412, 0.03319648280739784, -0.003888654289767146, -0.02251557633280754, 0.013650678098201752, -0.043150629848241806, -0.008242782205343246, 0.05467265471816063, 0.007563999388366938, 0.01272832415997982, -0.04427889361977577, -0.0031881884206086397, -0.0046725026331841946, 0.0012110555544495583, 0.01864888332784176, -0.01272343285381794, -0.00045918833347968757, 0.017070461064577103, -0.013141953386366367, 0.026460139080882072, 0.0031047810334712267, 0.011285685934126377, -0.05264938995242119, 0.022766757756471634, 0.005447372794151306, 0.014431735500693321, 0.04254073649644852, 0.008609030395746231, -0.012239455245435238, 0.052210722118616104, 0.0030860791448503733, 0.02061660774052143, 0.03810013085603714, -0.006706072483211756, -0.02394910715520382, 0.04329509288072586, -0.015226203016936779, -0.055253636091947556, 0.01572539657354355, 0.030212391167879105, 0.0013052205322310328, -0.05030348151922226, -0.013263768516480923, 0.036368463188409805, -0.02935689501464367, 0.013134856708347797, 0.029471948742866516, 0.05632345750927925, 0.015498528257012367, 0.01018359512090683, 0.03558168187737465, 0.019905060529708862, -0.039063047617673874, 0.0014424892142415047, 0.011735467240214348, 0.05694408714771271, 0.042965296655893326, 0.010255427099764347, 0.03638840094208717, -0.03291574493050575, 0.010118423961102962, -0.03703145682811737, 0.057594165205955505, -0.02983970381319523, -0.01757843606173992, 0.03546003997325897, -0.017997831106185913, 0.03256193920969963, -0.001754850265569985, 0.009026621468365192, 0.05829840153455734, -0.02896999381482601, -0.004688598681241274, -0.03336859121918678, -0.0060655949637293816, -0.01993717812001705, 0.000731765991076827, -0.007113112602382898, 0.005532334558665752, -0.00879996083676815, 0.004315908532589674, -0.017798928543925285, -0.036177150905132294, 0.049973227083683014, -0.001728720380924642, -0.01681581139564514, -0.00254830508492887, 0.004235492087900639, 0.011789463460445404, -0.02861492708325386, 0.008379768580198288, -0.014366299845278263, 0.04621744155883789, 0.044188376516103745, 0.005808887537568808, -0.0014645004412159324, -0.030836643651127815, 0.007076738402247429, 0.05815786123275757, -0.08343449234962463, -0.02952374331653118, -0.05704842135310173, 0.030175473541021347, 0.019512426108121872, -0.010277493856847286 ]
<p>A rather elementary question: If we have:</p> <p>$X = X_1 + X_2 + ... + X_n$ and $X_i \sim N(0,\sigma^2)$ and independent, </p> <p>can we express $X$ as $\sqrt n X_i$ for any $i = 1,...,n$ ? </p> <p>I think since all the components $X_i$ follow the normal distribution and we are summing $n$ of them up, the resulting rv is $X \sim N(0, n\sigma^2)$ and therefor we can use $X = \sqrt n X_i$. </p> <p>Is this reasoning correct? If yes, under what condition it can be false? </p>
74,514
[ -0.03401017189025879, -0.016566533595323563, -0.0010389006929472089, -0.0271413866430521, 0.04662737622857094, -0.009801645763218403, -0.019557200372219086, -0.004762569908052683, 0.015333910472691059, -0.06346326321363449, 0.04277930036187172, -0.0005825290572829545, 0.10037792474031448, 0.025713574141263962, 0.029466114938259125, 0.030787518247961998, -0.025722332298755646, 0.03204631805419922, -0.01029240246862173, -0.0078100962564349174, -0.0016807853244245052, 0.07014115154743195, 0.02896786667406559, -0.04649098217487335, -0.04575929045677185, 0.03091791830956936, -0.008765959180891514, -0.0048732147552073, 0.007025434635579586, 0.06224370002746582, -0.038220785558223724, 0.03590616583824158, 0.03740202262997627, 0.04930504783987999, 0.03795143589377403, 0.024927504360675812, -0.00930636003613472, -0.0034776623360812664, 0.02374432608485222, -0.0024541004095226526, -0.03652303293347359, -0.029915641993284225, 0.040962498635053635, 0.055653560906648636, -0.016981426626443863, 0.05419578775763512, -0.033442363142967224, -0.05718952417373657, 0.031012576073408127, -0.025619179010391235, 0.0903119295835495, 0.020832382142543793, 0.06476161628961563, 0.037777550518512726, -0.004478995222598314, -0.006559824105352163, 0.01751941442489624, 0.037868089973926544, -0.0028713857755064964, -0.014325262978672981, 0.035077523440122604, -0.039959751069545746, -0.002413583919405937, -0.039242424070835114, -0.014803929254412651, -0.005300310906022787, 0.00898191798478365, -0.004409062676131725, 0.019577451050281525, -0.02458556927740574, -0.019493818283081055, 0.023985296487808228, 0.013915030285716057, -0.01697627641260624, -0.03772762417793274, 0.02514357678592205, 0.03534317389130592, -0.030053524300456047, 0.02842566929757595, -0.003961194772273302, 0.024217871949076653, 0.019518164917826653, 0.05545395240187645, 0.019352102652192116, 0.04511585086584091, -0.006110661197453737, 0.021024217829108238, -0.00035890060826204717, 0.054885536432266235, 0.022564027458429337, 0.02471422217786312, 0.035072535276412964, 0.06651382148265839, -0.04488305747509003, -0.055663879960775375, 0.050991326570510864, -0.028322935104370117, 0.002879075240343809, 0.0015124917263165116, -0.028450796380639076, 0.0006717460928484797, -0.0332673080265522, 0.0159470085054636, 0.054084137082099915, -0.020388007164001465, 0.00007934527820907533, -0.011396491900086403, 0.015066233463585377, -0.02624356560409069, -0.0241750068962574, -0.01403998862951994, 0.001981594832614064, 0.004690068308264017, -0.020344529300928116, 0.02824021875858307, 0.0010628814343363047, -0.01673767901957035, -0.011952841654419899, 0.02949574403464794, 0.0681290403008461, 0.014671576209366322, -0.01745225302875042, 0.02251362055540085, -0.026967491954565048, -0.04642152786254883, 0.04463614523410797, 0.002109091728925705, -0.015040111728012562, -0.06035144627094269, 0.05077392980456352, 0.036471765488386154, -0.024481283500790596, 0.020265165716409683, 0.008043364621698856, 0.029239840805530548, -0.003931510262191296, -0.08710718154907227, -0.04865960776805878, 0.03296887129545212, -0.056167762726545334, 0.011902169324457645, -0.07844320684671402, 0.03243381902575493, 0.08157001435756683, 0.06544345617294312, -0.013157256878912449, 0.06509125232696533, -0.0028474433347582817, 0.004311185795813799, 0.026661019772291183, -0.03542158007621765, -0.082157202064991, -0.007501035928726196, -0.059179697185754776, -0.003659806912764907, -0.07206286489963531, 0.03342652693390846, 0.029254354536533356, 0.008267031982541084, -0.011612344533205032, 0.010565931908786297, -0.018319593742489815, 0.02789454534649849, -0.008698580786585808, 0.030247226357460022, -0.012831397354602814, 0.06085001304745674, 0.0011127442121505737, 0.016811134293675423, 0.0021057261619716883, -0.03250019624829292, 0.026385242119431496, 0.029126308858394623, 0.07096123695373535, 0.05917170271277428, -0.05983945354819298, -0.0055684312246739864, -0.03470740467309952, 0.024492593482136726, 0.007933671586215496, -0.038746416568756104, 0.009605259634554386, -0.022902974858880043, -0.008600267581641674, 0.020505128428339958, 0.06344600766897202, 0.015066987834870815, -0.02043895237147808, -0.0026195941027253866, -0.01797274872660637, 0.009602454490959644, -0.0621008574962616, 0.02522898092865944, -0.0010960196377709508, -0.0555780753493309, -0.008109619840979576, -0.007181906141340733, 0.03570542111992836, -0.009782897308468819, -0.011651817709207535, -0.006043393164873123, 0.01410902664065361, 0.0032940825913101435, -0.029363621026277542, 0.020319851115345955, 0.007300172001123428, 0.0520252101123333, 0.010736539028584957, 0.03154939040541649, -0.007058465387672186, -0.07177329063415527, -0.0031470302492380142, -0.05434887483716011, 0.016414552927017212, -0.006993898656219244, -0.007052105385810137, 0.012400762178003788, -0.012570226565003395, -0.011663883924484253, 0.05056820437312126, -0.04191695526242256, 0.014791681431233883, 0.027259888127446175, 0.007630127482116222, -0.020058829337358475, 0.005288631189614534, 0.04598501697182655, -0.028966860845685005, -0.008929776027798653, -0.010547458194196224, -0.05219663679599762, 0.005321626551449299, 0.04289894551038742, 0.06878897547721863, -0.03762898966670036, 0.018962334841489792, 0.08505953848361969, 0.042866844683885574, 0.012700438499450684, 0.03078693524003029, 0.016272004693746567, -0.026465903967618942, 0.0056996834464371204, -0.006861092988401651, 0.04021979495882988, 0.002897838829085231, 0.006697803735733032, -0.012849884107708931, 0.046639058738946915, 0.01344230305403471, -0.006856970954686403, 0.031131310388445854, -0.022118648514151573, -0.0026461458764970303, -0.005988480057567358, -0.025604819878935814, -0.0003420387511141598, -0.007970429956912994, 0.03905783221125603, -0.01141062006354332, 0.009239880368113518, -0.033557385206222534, -0.028690945357084274, 0.022042296826839447, 0.0005954220541752875, 0.0018384314607828856, -0.05110931769013405, -0.016085628420114517, 0.028363019227981567, -0.039066214114427567, -0.010412325151264668, -0.05438032001256943, -0.005033222027122974, 0.000004614799763658084, 0.015003993175923824, 0.016259819269180298, -0.034325651824474335, 0.010164228267967701, -0.01649726741015911, -0.03238599747419357, -0.005721344146877527, -0.024480201303958893, 0.010693312622606754, 0.0009106267243623734, -0.035825613886117935, -0.0016467015957459807, -0.0157811027020216, -0.020193034783005714, 0.024088073521852493, -0.026073703542351723, -0.019891956821084023, 0.040182266384363174, -0.04457445070147514, -0.05595254898071289, -0.003932982683181763, -0.0394325815141201, -0.0024325111880898476, -0.039431944489479065, -0.0336848683655262, 0.03197633847594261, -0.0024650150444358587, -0.006696157623082399, 0.00743084168061614, -0.020847130566835403, -0.04115726426243782, -0.022478489205241203, -0.01403700653463602, 0.06057202070951462, -0.03671699017286301, 0.04055356606841087, 0.052165593951940536, -0.041254039853811264, 0.018440011888742447, -0.05296687036752701, -0.07120513170957565, -0.009967327117919922, -0.014715014025568962, 0.04299643263220787, 0.0307481586933136, -0.039498452097177505, 0.07181800156831741, 0.012638749554753304, -0.006823795847594738, -0.0037370023783296347, 0.022839892655611038, 0.009014827199280262, -0.052050597965717316, -0.00039623782504349947, -0.007555531803518534, -0.00909931305795908, 0.05927081033587456, -0.010512229986488819, -0.010026042349636555, 0.05644303187727928, 0.015296387486159801, -0.010921267792582512, -0.008827968500554562, 0.002161080949008465, -0.0017773620784282684, 0.031682129949331284, 0.015690527856349945, -0.00771502498537302, 0.012676479294896126, 0.017208650708198547, 0.03136550262570381, 0.038812749087810516, -0.029532860964536667, 0.05574282258749008, -0.016079936176538467, 0.030544504523277283, -0.05013800412416458, 0.0628848597407341, 0.04143731668591499, -0.015099125914275646, -0.04090466350317001, 0.024581272155046463, -0.0015036854892969131, -0.040061477571725845, 0.01335429958999157, 0.034550730139017105, 0.050312310457229614, -0.018321847543120384, -0.031597673892974854, 0.012460289523005486, 0.0038271129596978426, 0.010910896584391594, -0.02275078371167183, -0.02124774642288685, 0.010215342976152897, 0.0021282664965838194, 0.0013431409606710076, -0.016779864206910133, -0.007186003029346466, 0.014398787170648575, -0.035471539944410324, 0.017211679369211197, -0.0129008824005723, 0.01744012162089348, 0.005402572453022003, 0.039393339306116104, -0.026863785460591316, -0.005877385381609201, -0.01727469637989998, 0.010105720721185207, -0.04012735188007355, -0.0313982255756855, -0.03158944100141525, -0.044717688113451004, 0.012435166165232658, -0.016002662479877472, 0.0036555235274136066, 0.026534033939242363, 0.026357581838965416, 0.01204310916364193, 0.00300703477114439, -0.024028802290558815, -0.026485923677682877, -0.018471606075763702, -0.042652007192373276, -0.0020637984853237867, 0.03682476654648781, 0.017143072560429573, -0.047750264406204224, 0.03461267054080963, 0.037171583622694016, 0.0039031729102134705, 0.001359027810394764, -0.03414827585220337, 0.0024042241275310516, 0.0005861875833943486, 0.017043326050043106, 0.024441856890916824, 0.022239429876208305, 0.005047602113336325, 0.06317634135484695, 0.025072453543543816, 0.06329921633005142, 0.009572231210768223, -0.0017816699109971523, -0.008579393848776817, -0.026001475751399994, -0.03193674609065056, -0.022545158863067627, 0.02667553350329399, 0.007819151505827904, -0.005177710670977831, 0.05231427773833275, 0.026814669370651245, -0.03437082841992378, -0.01670045219361782, 0.05190720409154892, 0.00734406104311347, -0.017648912966251373, -0.0233916062861681, 0.001440836233086884, -0.005802480969578028, -0.004778931848704815, 0.015060347504913807, -0.014322328381240368, -0.02115238457918167, 0.012533221393823624, 0.03125866875052452, -0.015971440821886063, 0.0047775497660040855, 0.00355433183722198, 0.014041244052350521, 0.04176565259695053, -0.002246435033157468, -0.02293960005044937, 0.0025431844405829906, 0.03453955426812172, 0.0472540482878685, 0.027908697724342346, -0.0166015625, -0.029721418395638466, 0.027089329436421394, 0.03274436667561531, 0.013399294577538967, -0.017679743468761444, 0.011422277428209782, -0.051850996911525726, -0.0069433595053851604, 0.04274662211537361, -0.016939692199230194, 0.02611350268125534, -0.04973834380507469, 0.003315496491268277, 0.006516349036246538, -0.030713355168700218, -0.04355817288160324, -0.009691853076219559, 0.0019419610034674406, 0.03968906030058861, -0.01697746105492115, -0.024634428322315216, -0.040237151086330414, -0.004333177115768194, 0.031073642894625664, 0.06079532951116562, -0.022074738517403603, 0.009013192728161812, -0.02732987143099308, 0.05615517869591713, -0.018529675900936127, -0.0771758183836937, 0.025210006162524223, 0.0396706648170948, -0.017320172861218452, 0.043791476637125015, -0.019895080476999283, -0.03282744064927101, 0.018646961078047752, 0.026850666850805283, -0.013236233964562416, 0.043576329946517944, -0.010767091996967793, 0.05671907216310501, 0.04766298457980156, 0.01108517311513424, 0.04165998846292496, 0.020780179649591446, 0.025546856224536896, 0.017403308302164078, -0.049695514142513275, 0.0142982117831707, -0.05532913655042648, -0.03559955954551697, -0.04245997592806816, -0.01603218913078308, 0.02504836581647396, 0.03498825803399086, -0.005684598349034786, 0.053882043808698654, -0.0006658125785179436, -0.019548267126083374, 0.013315255753695965, 0.00484259519726038, 0.010107803158462048, 0.01616273634135723, -0.012429757043719292, 0.049539003521203995, 0.016485078260302544, -0.010331468656659126, -0.008734758011996746, -0.011279727332293987, 0.012420711107552052, 0.049256399273872375, -0.014471624046564102, 0.02243533730506897, -0.01967562921345234, -0.016057398170232773, -0.015736041590571404, -0.03306257352232933, 0.04972471669316292, -0.02231251820921898, 0.03556022047996521, 0.026426637545228004, -0.05393562465906143, -0.005874149035662413, 0.012729919515550137, -0.007955986075103283, -0.008119906298816204, -0.048646632581949234, 0.0239078588783741, 0.028678959235548973, 0.010371067561209202, -0.06495926529169083, -0.034742049872875214, -0.004352298099547625, -0.001805052743293345, 0.021918674930930138, -0.05584406107664108, 0.008346023969352245, -0.03346230089664459, -0.047602131962776184, -0.01856512948870659, 0.046551305800676346, 0.009978992864489555, -0.027132704854011536, 0.007089853286743164, 0.015705687925219536, 0.060725901275873184, 0.011224638670682907, 0.0028021049220114946, 0.014683246612548828, -0.02920512668788433, -0.016491280868649483, 0.02922637388110161, 0.04221022501587868, -0.028310028836131096, 0.014827905222773552, -0.040286216884851456, -0.06080455705523491, 0.008526730351150036, -0.0024204556830227375, -0.03868000581860542, -0.002749807434156537, -0.01688195951282978, 0.0015841479180380702, -0.023102182894945145, -0.02572614699602127, 0.009447472169995308, 0.023385988548398018, 0.010787038132548332, -0.013029180467128754, -0.008974075317382812, -0.01415819302201271, 0.024793317541480064, 0.02509644255042076, 0.0014167868066579103, 0.05818873271346092, 0.07159885764122009, -0.013298610225319862, -0.02313385158777237, -0.0011169399367645383, 0.01389993168413639, 0.0319133885204792, 0.021235713735222816, -0.019267013296484947, -0.0018701932858675718, -0.019356966018676758, -0.006105001550167799, -0.03801193833351135, -0.034948091953992844, 0.030680639669299126, 0.030552655458450317, -0.0186257716268301, 0.03210097923874855, 0.03447680547833443, 0.0041024708189070225, -0.053234949707984924, -0.06232445687055588, 0.017190543934702873, -0.032640643417835236, -0.013954871334135532, 0.07562295347452164, -0.014686843380331993, -0.0006031516240909696, 0.025227464735507965, 0.01743343286216259, 0.01261630468070507, -0.003856403287500143, -0.00830821879208088, 0.000727334525436163, 0.00894197914749384, 0.008738979697227478, -0.032702840864658356, 0.005647980608046055, -0.06721500307321548, 0.014443345367908478, -0.02512926049530506, -0.010708590038120747, 0.0272663626819849, -0.008558319881558418, 0.01166114117950201, -0.04629536718130112, -0.035615868866443634, -0.021209800615906715, -0.00036299723433330655, 0.022202318534255028, 0.0355798602104187, 0.03612609952688217, 0.005286904517561197, 0.016400206834077835, -0.010259549133479595, 0.0227669570595026, -0.024721231311559677, -0.08476249873638153, -0.05311978608369827, -0.002077595330774784, -0.02475076913833618, 0.015127969905734062, -0.00026436668122187257, -0.01914229430258274, 0.006791622377932072, -0.05426914244890213, 0.023781150579452515, 0.019743742421269417, 0.03186394274234772, 0.013687585480511189, 0.08023692667484283, 0.023215515539050102, 0.04713970795273781, 0.0020770870614796877, 0.036141738295555115, 0.11138313263654709, 0.06481467932462692, 0.030649064108729362, -0.006982483901083469, -0.005160273052752018, -0.033376533538103104, 0.0046786232851445675, -0.036680713295936584, 0.017501022666692734, 0.011639493517577648, -0.01650182530283928, 0.034004922956228256, 0.04766519367694855, 0.0052115293219685555, -0.030562404543161392, 0.031884338706731796, -0.03439641371369362, -0.04665490984916687, -0.0019836726132780313, -0.0010179720120504498, -0.0006169489934109151, -0.008508767932653427, -0.025435175746679306, 0.01381758414208889, -0.012649213895201683, -0.017834430560469627, -0.0076436856761574745, -0.0017076162621378899, -0.021183867007493973, 0.0011801221407949924, -0.016341963782906532, 0.0012073173420503736, 0.05679359287023544, -0.01684960164129734, -0.010773890651762486, -0.026657378301024437, 0.02095106989145279, -0.026149354875087738, 0.01976918987929821, 0.029492661356925964, -0.005276606883853674, -0.0025451090186834335, 0.02867116406559944, 0.00726090744137764, -0.03667242079973221, -0.025953248143196106, -0.03907991945743561, 0.018890250474214554, -0.016455713659524918, 0.01777176558971405, -0.013436962850391865, 0.01753447949886322, 0.008230322040617466, -0.09831570833921432, -0.010924172587692738, 0.023497339338064194, 0.03578316420316696, -0.00400438392534852, 0.00396615918725729, -0.014270758256316185, 0.010455152951180935, 0.020726775750517845, 0.03127545863389969, 0.0009221147047355771, -0.04192333295941353, -0.006587978918105364, -0.02038004621863365, 0.018440499901771545, -0.008024632930755615, -0.026479940861463547, -0.014627226628363132, -0.021534910425543785, -0.02657361887395382, -0.027036508545279503, 0.028021380305290222, -0.021952001377940178, 0.04870712012052536, -0.020846841856837273, 0.03130291402339935, 0.02575690485537052, -0.04898078367114067, 0.0158478282392025, -0.04837869107723236, -0.002103715669363737, -0.01743421144783497, -0.028637899085879326, 0.01059762667864561, 0.0593608058989048, -0.007184199523180723, -0.017715388908982277, 0.018800662830471992, 0.09523080289363861, 0.03143269941210747, -0.045673567801713943, -0.017453758046030998, 0.03161360323429108, -0.016783997416496277, 0.008812226355075836, 0.008047420531511307, 0.021073969081044197, 0.04610146954655647, 0.04077499359846115, -0.014846582897007465, 0.05302249640226364, -0.00959119200706482, 0.0017385598039254546, 0.038056280463933945, -0.027426959946751595, 0.03344152122735977, 0.03541161119937897, 0.020951418206095695, -0.01456998661160469, -0.041823841631412506, -0.015093261376023293, -0.007830750197172165, -0.020211242139339447, -0.029024917632341385, -0.05398792773485184, 0.004473981447517872, -0.028852110728621483, 0.003813468385487795, 0.0005502015701495111, -0.02828180231153965, 0.014094026759266853, -0.005870554596185684, 0.001469350652769208, -0.02688772790133953, -0.025888873264193535, 0.023852074518799782, -0.013252892531454563, -0.025605788454413414, 0.045705292373895645, 0.022580301389098167, -0.022082898765802383, -0.04530086740851402, -0.03220129758119583, 0.013485354371368885, 0.04117598012089729, -0.043703023344278336, -0.022136835381388664, 0.0431487150490284, -0.05361451581120491, -0.019481947645545006, 0.01775430701673031, 0.03980988264083862, 0.028895631432533264, 0.004909917246550322, 0.009290061891078949, -0.03303327038884163, -0.0022452562116086483, -0.032286904752254486, 0.016737012192606926, -0.0057887788861989975, 0.0189158096909523, -0.018366843461990356, -0.033680081367492676, 0.009233804419636726, -0.004671401809900999, -0.008246474899351597, 0.03205180913209915, 0.04166721925139427, -0.029619799926877022, 0.01673579402267933, 0.04712072014808655, -0.003761349944397807, -0.0028626529965549707, 0.010367744602262974, 0.02893570438027382, 0.02543259598314762, 0.03861324489116669, -0.040085166692733765, 0.04843046888709068, -0.023459045216441154, -0.025819649919867516, -0.10317733883857727, -0.027272125706076622, 0.025735648348927498, 0.0042277611792087555, 0.041464999318122864, -0.03903984650969505, 0.007983519695699215, -0.0006036388222128153, -0.08956164121627808, -0.008360917679965496, -0.0015293634496629238, -0.03422803059220314, -0.032456379383802414, 0.030204834416508675, -0.0014087618328630924, 0.004805695731192827, 0.018937572836875916, 0.03388558328151703, 0.02726721204817295, 0.027812637388706207, 0.005051604937762022, -0.002184332348406315, -0.007859092205762863, -0.01292314101010561, -0.0015371076297014952, -0.05945107340812683, 0.023145083338022232, -0.05330245569348335, 0.007894188165664673, -0.012528630904853344, -0.00406764866784215, 0.016168951988220215, 0.0007428880198858678, 0.035857707262039185, 0.004015064798295498, 0.04038427397608757, 0.01199596468359232, -0.030004756525158882, 0.019138187170028687, 0.011108092963695526, 0.044513456523418427, 0.045285794883966446, -0.02244395762681961, -0.0543941892683506, 0.030690468847751617, -0.02193308062851429, -0.047667477279901505, 0.02228262461721897, -0.0007618525996804237, -0.024736281484365463, -0.021201007068157196, -0.024265170097351074, -0.014383696019649506, -0.0173451229929924, 0.07377053797245026, -0.050759464502334595, 0.015261456370353699, 0.013924682512879372, 0.018953917548060417, -0.0157112255692482, -0.006155242677778006, 0.010705005377531052, -0.04885108768939972, -0.00044887250987812877, -0.00917453970760107, -0.04231295734643936, -0.07063367962837219, -0.023610292002558708, 0.019916867837309837, -0.008780375123023987, -0.03020113706588745, -0.0214198250323534, 0.003176526864990592, 0.028386110439896584, 0.010608923621475697, 0.0495087094604969, 0.03807248920202255, -0.03540857508778572, -0.017018388956785202, -0.07367832958698273, 0.04247439280152321, 0.05957399308681488, 0.008094985969364643, -0.0420529879629612, -0.01730082742869854, -0.047807712107896805, -0.035847008228302, 0.064007967710495, 0.010339543223381042, 0.0036173746921122074, 0.011638261377811432, 0.05709487199783325, 0.02309824898838997, -0.018984679132699966, 0.018555929884314537, -0.021234668791294098, -0.029429450631141663, -0.07650170475244522, -0.02488052472472191, 0.012873158790171146, -0.01709112338721752, 0.013549037277698517, 0.003657229710370302, -0.0051665715873241425, -0.01105887908488512, -0.043367814272642136, 0.05525685474276543, -0.014749807305634022, -0.027698997408151627, 0.049842916429042816, -0.03763224184513092, -0.00786225963383913, 0.0442204587161541, -0.02540312521159649, -0.05714090168476105, -0.00339909503236413, -0.009087464772164822, -0.030936801806092262, -0.005872952751815319, 0.007170306984335184, -0.011186260730028152, -0.038187675178050995, -0.021932028234004974, 0.052416007965803146, -0.022723080590367317, -0.0012322209076955914, 0.06214940547943115, 0.04749869182705879, 0.04127346724271774, 0.01028487365692854, -0.014902031049132347, 0.020877942442893982, -0.023359224200248718, 0.015617486089468002, -0.004666794091463089, 0.022118188440799713, -0.015698043629527092, -0.004551147110760212, 0.04884906858205795, -0.020354215055704117, 0.030251942574977875, -0.00876173097640276, 0.03831068053841591, -0.04047723487019539, -0.012204763479530811, 0.022156232967972755, -0.027745576575398445, 0.030088290572166443, -0.0020095729269087315, -0.0297805555164814, 0.08319942653179169, -0.010195336304605007, 0.027018297463655472, -0.002219041343778372, -0.0029254260007292032, -0.02497652918100357, -0.02569267340004444, 0.020746342837810516, 0.02445852942764759, -0.014972478151321411, -0.017374806106090546, -0.0018988189985975623, -0.016177967190742493, 0.017991114407777786, -0.04156851768493652, 0.02722945623099804, -0.012786517851054668, 0.019100425764918327, -0.04079630970954895, -0.009114551357924938, 0.002947890432551503, -0.011808405630290508, 0.015561959706246853, 0.023470107465982437, 0.014980229549109936, 0.011272020637989044, -0.034879833459854126, 0.005456164479255676, 0.06422869116067886, -0.05594724044203758, -0.017309950664639473, -0.04276992753148079, 0.01615826226770878, 0.029586197808384895, -0.031015481799840927 ]
<p>What is the impact of data dimensionality on computation complexity of SVM? I found on the literature that the complexity of SVM is $O(N^3)$, where $N$ is the number of training examples. If the number of dimension (e.g., $D$) does not impact the training time why it s better to reduce the dimensionality for training high-dimension dataset? Is it just to avoid overfitting? </p> <p>BTW, I m using SVDD (support vector data description) from RRTools.</p>
74,515
[ -0.0201285257935524, 0.011001245118677616, 0.0035186633467674255, -0.023575201630592346, 0.03652632236480713, 0.006122372578829527, -0.040105998516082764, -0.021527161821722984, 0.016322100535035133, -0.05291815474629402, 0.022099757567048073, -0.0012933913385495543, 0.01789580099284649, 0.037755586206912994, 0.022958768531680107, 0.01030057668685913, -0.010825440287590027, -0.021328438073396683, 0.0035722805187106133, 0.030314132571220398, -0.001942947506904602, 0.01866045407950878, 0.03974001482129097, -0.020500142127275467, -0.033138077706098557, 0.07035455107688904, 0.0322430282831192, 0.01233631931245327, 0.0296049565076828, 0.030590474605560303, -0.03936564922332764, 0.006481202319264412, 0.0363590307533741, 0.07583530992269516, 0.03004656732082367, -0.016230473294854164, -0.026289857923984528, -0.030387071892619133, 0.021045662462711334, 0.0352364107966423, 0.0246100053191185, -0.017905663698911667, 0.0038808605168014765, 0.06470045447349548, 0.01094540860503912, 0.06184673309326172, -0.008576352149248123, -0.021818732842803, -0.010562920942902565, -0.02043195813894272, 0.09231345355510712, -0.004329454619437456, 0.04405849054455757, 0.008833303116261959, -0.015893930569291115, -0.004169541876763105, 0.04662291333079338, 0.07400055974721909, 0.032496366649866104, -0.027880534529685974, 0.013504303991794586, -0.030681347474455833, 0.02448403276503086, -0.03946956992149353, -0.01616518385708332, 0.06525161862373352, 0.006752329412847757, 0.0013096265029162169, 0.009801210835576057, -0.007598093245178461, 0.008385912515223026, -0.02415459416806698, 0.00965102482587099, 0.013803454115986824, -0.010496524162590504, -0.007475780788809061, -0.01609329879283905, 0.02496916987001896, 0.047438185662031174, 0.01377236470580101, 0.004746464546769857, 0.02703234553337097, 0.007971067912876606, 0.011426761746406555, 0.021054714918136597, -0.017123736441135406, 0.04624888300895691, -0.00387167907319963, -0.0017682829638943076, 0.015970353037118912, -0.016121407970786095, 0.04079558700323105, 0.024951616302132607, 0.0008832211024127901, -0.028331078588962555, 0.03279615938663483, -0.017051396891474724, 0.010185820050537586, 0.020042063668370247, -0.0450286902487278, -0.02447722852230072, -0.033041488379240036, 0.01005533803254366, 0.05946924164891243, -0.026279157027602196, -0.01028649602085352, -0.025055628269910812, 0.0068996259942650795, -0.024332165718078613, -0.020529676228761673, -0.0017012845491990447, -0.004015189595520496, -0.013850664719939232, 0.012870903126895428, 0.016974911093711853, -0.014902678318321705, 0.009284875355660915, -0.016742002218961716, 0.03109896369278431, 0.08074726164340973, -0.019348544999957085, -0.05164886265993118, 0.013971074484288692, -0.030187509953975677, -0.04886366426944733, 0.019909817725419998, 0.014852688647806644, -0.018229631707072258, -0.022306226193904877, 0.021300053223967552, 0.011719133704900742, -0.029904108494520187, 0.04669906944036484, -0.022265121340751648, 0.010455086827278137, -0.004280283115804195, -0.08802422136068344, -0.051601771265268326, 0.05832492560148239, -0.013278809376060963, 0.006515588145703077, -0.04358754679560661, 0.0018445962341502309, 0.00685128616169095, 0.002629391383379698, -0.0026074436027556658, 0.06256908923387527, 0.07372357696294785, 0.02940111607313156, 0.003183323424309492, -0.03192692622542381, -0.005441618617624044, -0.019061200320720673, 0.014834740199148655, -0.015950027853250504, -0.040896058082580566, 0.02871812880039215, 0.019514117389917374, 0.0017604135209694505, -0.0027372241020202637, 0.00378732499666512, -0.008051824755966663, 0.00047915903269313276, 0.010708631947636604, 0.0007152587058953941, -0.011606365442276001, 0.020068025216460228, 0.008771207183599472, 0.08604946732521057, 0.026674985885620117, -0.059855442494153976, 0.015265649184584618, 0.028919529169797897, 0.052970677614212036, 0.037894412875175476, 0.031956616789102554, -0.012841829098761082, -0.034224655479192734, 0.030432909727096558, -0.00474014924839139, -0.029849834740161896, -0.05805876851081848, -0.009786793030798435, 0.02073880285024643, 0.009864489547908306, 0.06153258681297302, 0.015689261257648468, -0.02948748506605625, 0.03160904347896576, -0.03807608410716057, -0.04137885570526123, -0.04855473339557648, 0.021011993288993835, -0.00396732660010457, -0.044138725847005844, 0.006037852726876736, 0.019093656912446022, -0.010177817195653915, -0.005948929116129875, -0.0008418824290856719, -0.046731241047382355, 0.030385971069335938, 0.028821907937526703, -0.05282120406627655, 0.013816742226481438, 0.040630314499139786, 0.029313892126083374, -0.018628256395459175, 0.0326865091919899, 0.008958299644291401, -0.06533986330032349, 0.02606285735964775, -0.011591843329370022, 0.009553251788020134, -0.048385027796030045, -0.009607699699699879, 0.02437460608780384, -0.02264486439526081, -0.06938498467206955, 0.03422557935118675, -0.010507471859455109, 0.07183150202035904, 0.03587662801146507, -0.006033062003552914, -0.0007070839637890458, -0.01589338667690754, -0.0026351059786975384, -0.011693686246871948, -0.013257896527647972, 0.006798553746193647, -0.049613311886787415, -0.017256658524274826, 0.06739146262407303, 0.07040756195783615, -0.05839552357792854, 0.011198684573173523, 0.03639338165521622, 0.03891882672905922, 0.02073352038860321, 0.005177417304366827, -0.024187419563531876, -0.010932321660220623, 0.022648828104138374, 0.010576494038105011, -0.014324437826871872, -0.026142682880163193, 0.004284940659999847, -0.005651162937283516, 0.029091501608490944, -0.030038421973586082, -0.022853707894682884, 0.04478653892874718, -0.02316650189459324, -0.005211185198277235, 0.0027363859117031097, 0.010232335887849331, 0.023895850405097008, -0.03196931630373001, -0.020053481683135033, 0.01630580611526966, 0.009757542982697487, 0.04854966700077057, -0.017636330798268318, -0.012974737212061882, 0.013154666870832443, 0.02592281810939312, -0.014356411062180996, -0.011784062720835209, 0.03317280113697052, -0.04884761944413185, 0.020057417452335358, -0.028671227395534515, -0.015479063615202904, -0.04295168071985245, 0.03891322761774063, 0.060455575585365295, -0.0390312634408474, 0.01756548509001732, -0.01142244040966034, 0.013276009820401669, 0.02419392392039299, -0.029585236683487892, 0.024419791996479034, 0.002075688913464546, -0.05990419536828995, 0.006455501075834036, -0.042566727846860886, -0.019371381029486656, 0.034010957926511765, -0.01939893700182438, -0.008600848726928234, 0.00796580035239458, -0.003106220392510295, -0.05407213047146797, -0.01900595799088478, -0.043484169989824295, 0.0655873641371727, -0.010857509449124336, 0.004126297309994698, 0.04082999750971794, -0.021991871297359467, -0.04845057800412178, 0.0011734380386769772, -0.020992472767829895, -0.06005459651350975, -0.03214507922530174, -0.0232810378074646, -0.013867461122572422, -0.027546977624297142, -0.009685513563454151, 0.03322603181004524, -0.03437497094273567, 0.013609367422759533, -0.052606936544179916, -0.026640789583325386, 0.013747368939220905, -0.00581509992480278, 0.068789042532444, 0.00005091286948299967, -0.029060635715723038, 0.06937326490879059, 0.05290526896715164, -0.03346145153045654, -0.015734996646642685, -0.015246261842548847, -0.0321120023727417, -0.004767099395394325, 0.022117456421256065, 0.008773225359618664, 0.024317825213074684, -0.0012422424042597413, -0.0005190226947888732, 0.023163780570030212, 0.05054600536823273, -0.0017607019981369376, -0.01651313528418541, 0.025071224197745323, 0.016289371997117996, 0.027101967483758926, 0.006137487478554249, 0.02450466714799404, -0.026294130831956863, 0.01420379988849163, 0.009486913681030273, 0.0055467779748141766, 0.018206018954515457, -0.016549214720726013, 0.026208005845546722, -0.0408850722014904, 0.04646388813853264, -0.037721291184425354, -0.015716787427663803, 0.02241566590964794, -0.005120575428009033, 0.006799357943236828, 0.017474094405770302, 0.03763516992330551, -0.041905466467142105, -0.008088094182312489, 0.026179322972893715, 0.02381649799644947, -0.007730288431048393, 0.026619236916303635, -0.01060381717979908, -0.03936799615621567, 0.01225748099386692, -0.014578440226614475, -0.012409442104399204, 0.014060404151678085, 0.05189291015267372, -0.0014612068189308047, 0.0030127698555588722, -0.035571154206991196, -0.0011596836848184466, -0.06337884813547134, -0.011462855152785778, -0.03977714478969574, 0.06361394375562668, 0.005146600306034088, 0.042453352361917496, -0.0009966976940631866, -0.00579491350799799, -0.0002788178971968591, -0.02249196544289589, -0.05348045006394386, -0.010727087035775185, -0.033720117062330246, 0.021119998767971992, 0.005128560587763786, -0.04496852308511734, 0.04545033723115921, -0.040262509137392044, 0.0029035687912255526, -0.015051474794745445, 0.03562096506357193, -0.03937142714858055, 0.03246042877435684, 0.010550417006015778, 0.035510096698999405, -0.053685273975133896, 0.03549303486943245, 0.024797886610031128, -0.035857852548360825, 0.004140088334679604, 0.016078295186161995, -0.04001230001449585, -0.02120564877986908, 0.00039296806789934635, 0.006777076981961727, 0.0021465751342475414, 0.03378532826900482, -0.00499495817348361, 0.018361886963248253, -0.03218058869242668, 0.004870292264968157, 0.0027940403670072556, 0.04672228544950485, 0.01812143810093403, -0.02368239127099514, -0.0053602601401507854, -0.051509540528059006, -0.016504451632499695, 0.0018832667265087366, 0.05822006240487099, -0.013677767477929592, 0.01757456734776497, 0.030369332060217857, -0.004023647401481867, -0.056652847677469254, -0.004496085923165083, 0.03502386063337326, 0.02748708240687847, -0.02014485001564026, -0.04792294278740883, -0.013935858383774757, -0.01743873953819275, -0.008163939230144024, 0.013454772531986237, -0.0008016438223421574, -0.043991684913635254, -0.008367872796952724, 0.027654197067022324, -0.03989831358194351, -0.02960643172264099, 0.014295139349997044, 0.051149386912584305, 0.04550876468420029, 0.023403357714414597, 0.00519446050748229, -0.0028643247205764055, 0.034690216183662415, 0.054095931351184845, 0.009188294410705566, 0.03461989760398865, -0.07089387625455856, -0.028377139940857887, 0.05533178523182869, 0.04721500352025032, -0.0534055233001709, 0.0007575455820187926, -0.048523224890232086, -0.012570102699100971, 0.035109732300043106, -0.04864700511097908, 0.019374435767531395, -0.02742260880768299, -0.017652105540037155, -0.05705517902970314, -0.05301563814282417, -0.02342286892235279, 0.006205225829035044, 0.014227285049855709, 0.08093368262052536, -0.021348588168621063, -0.014555064961314201, -0.04474898427724838, -0.018488122150301933, 0.03212032839655876, 0.037100065499544144, -0.007735927123576403, 0.012305132113397121, -0.009383844211697578, 0.03160642087459564, -0.008299109525978565, -0.059369754046201706, 0.008185207843780518, 0.027067864313721657, 0.015940915793180466, 0.03887203708291054, -0.03487173840403557, -0.07911858707666397, 0.02550029195845127, 0.037522055208683014, 0.0051234145648777485, -0.014451837167143822, -0.029679154977202415, 0.04752615466713905, 0.05565832182765007, 0.00878856610506773, 0.02976479008793831, 0.003614696441218257, 0.013766751624643803, 0.009669862687587738, -0.03572481498122215, 0.002740860916674137, -0.06124471500515938, -0.03868437930941582, -0.006576833315193653, 0.0024247330147773027, -0.026561886072158813, 0.04266979545354843, -0.0024934615939855576, 0.05476557835936546, -0.020573485642671585, 0.01660298742353916, -0.023388266563415527, 0.036938153207302094, 0.024400286376476288, -0.05867330729961395, -0.026698686182498932, 0.05095529928803444, -0.018961528316140175, 0.0012165739899501204, -0.012188308872282505, -0.0155783174559474, 0.009694303385913372, 0.03522374480962753, -0.041082948446273804, -0.015068872831761837, -0.0345376580953598, -0.018894724547863007, 0.008997452445328236, 0.008706886321306229, 0.03974059969186783, -0.02200065739452839, 0.002307051792740822, 0.008539156056940556, -0.07027930021286011, 0.005034198518842459, 0.005416769068688154, -0.013453197665512562, 0.045212917029857635, -0.006700043100863695, 0.012942087836563587, -0.0015971842221915722, -0.004858780652284622, -0.06260938942432404, -0.029390787705779076, 0.0075450497679412365, -0.010626372881233692, -0.026792407035827637, -0.03755471855401993, 0.020589269697666168, -0.013966944999992847, -0.04862561076879501, -0.015956683084368706, 0.05584094673395157, 0.008706051856279373, 0.0017027229769155383, 0.026555662974715233, 0.012423274107277393, 0.051151737570762634, -0.03808365762233734, 0.03318874165415764, -0.0053954944014549255, -0.01113178115338087, 0.013873475603759289, -0.024417264387011528, 0.023593218997120857, -0.015734659507870674, -0.004370208829641342, -0.018420791253447533, -0.020061422139406204, 0.01908007822930813, -0.002679706085473299, -0.011960108764469624, -0.001631550258025527, -0.03213212266564369, 0.005713973194360733, -0.01916581206023693, -0.006406377535313368, 0.03111254796385765, -0.00036535068647935987, 0.022371696308255196, -0.014341446571052074, -0.020751217380166054, -0.021988900378346443, -0.03522795811295509, -0.012127958238124847, -0.011588183231651783, 0.009613992646336555, 0.020510375499725342, -0.05381583794951439, 0.012628152035176754, -0.053363487124443054, -0.03729121387004852, 0.011450500227510929, -0.021188735961914062, 0.01974806934595108, -0.011196081526577473, 0.05158616229891777, -0.03280535340309143, -0.045184772461652756, -0.052644193172454834, 0.0287745650857687, 0.04267174378037453, 0.033895716071128845, 0.0400298610329628, 0.0326254740357399, -0.005904050078243017, 0.01107791904360056, -0.05337230861186981, -0.013826005160808563, 0.026703836396336555, 0.012261837720870972, 0.027269719168543816, 0.04024771228432655, 0.0014916462823748589, 0.043701495975255966, -0.025309612974524498, 0.009730227291584015, 0.040188852697610855, 0.006512691266834736, -0.013070286251604557, 0.011349504813551903, -0.057673923671245575, -0.04187265783548355, 0.018811745569109917, -0.005831924732774496, 0.024305889382958412, -0.014738054946064949, 0.018483584746718407, 0.048441484570503235, 0.007066341117024422, 0.02310892939567566, -0.051348213106393814, -0.009837370365858078, -0.050665177404880524, 0.005283096805214882, 0.04912112280726433, -0.0027323304675519466, 0.023112989962100983, 0.01075531356036663, -0.002438200172036886, -0.0010585363488644361, 0.02139335125684738, 0.008423369377851486, -0.05549508333206177, -0.03408234566450119, -0.009332042187452316, -0.044283006340265274, 0.052693355828523636, 0.019323263317346573, -0.05256051570177078, -0.01781374216079712, -0.04243943467736244, 0.06021301448345184, 0.00009483195754000917, 0.04051392897963524, -0.018843363970518112, 0.03565505892038345, 0.018214132636785507, 0.032824594527482986, 0.01984996534883976, 0.011916345916688442, 0.10438050329685211, 0.07431340217590332, 0.04580775275826454, -0.04611287638545036, -0.008807367645204067, 0.000648836197797209, -0.01662919484078884, -0.04483994096517563, 0.020029928535223007, -0.0001593301713000983, -0.013274891301989555, 0.016636528074741364, 0.008816026151180267, -0.016016684472560883, -0.027088696137070656, 0.018554436042904854, -0.06060664355754852, -0.005756093189120293, -0.012329153716564178, 0.008936959318816662, 0.013501781970262527, 0.020984144881367683, -0.03993560001254082, -0.005093429237604141, -0.0400456003844738, -0.03512459248304367, -0.023314908146858215, -0.01642318069934845, 0.015471323393285275, -0.032295793294906616, -0.03646049275994301, -0.031155172735452652, 0.013440974988043308, -0.017894355580210686, -0.04060440883040428, 0.018336549401283264, -0.02156982012093067, -0.02143145725131035, -0.014087294228374958, 0.03841715306043625, -0.019122321158647537, 0.0010609523160383105, -0.006216965615749359, 0.0026791428681463003, -0.05181087180972099, -0.0212402306497097, -0.027874035760760307, 0.036591727286577225, -0.00016601482639089227, 0.016043975949287415, 0.011988596990704536, 0.02482781745493412, -0.014624609611928463, -0.045718591660261154, 0.018827619031071663, 0.00663740886375308, 0.049246661365032196, -0.03366508334875107, -0.028446411713957787, -0.029503151774406433, 0.010467357002198696, -0.03343015909194946, 0.049728646874427795, -0.0009656756883487105, -0.055187176913022995, -0.01978115737438202, -0.0055297971703112125, 0.017669256776571274, -0.00961519405245781, 0.008241705596446991, -0.026583967730402946, 0.018371475860476494, 0.01972310245037079, -0.03847387805581093, 0.032114531844854355, 0.009504671208560467, 0.004450140055269003, -0.0010770617518574, -0.02893906459212303, -0.030748706310987473, -0.04787098616361618, 0.0037949825637042522, -0.01879086159169674, 0.008184700272977352, -0.04950302094221115, 0.007411319762468338, 0.02449127286672592, 0.03886134922504425, 0.04949832707643509, 0.03205437585711479, 0.0036773511674255133, 0.015294979326426983, 0.027374250814318657, -0.03368010371923447, 0.003038579598069191, -0.00943703856319189, -0.06184355169534683, 0.04706723988056183, 0.01164221204817295, 0.0290707815438509, 0.06416338682174683, 0.011167209595441818, -0.0062828585505485535, 0.07299675047397614, 0.01740209013223648, -0.006532431114464998, -0.003462287364527583, -0.0277653019875288, 0.022875351831316948, -0.0013230930780991912, -0.002003611298277974, -0.044459618628025055, -0.020552443340420723, -0.017417117953300476, -0.0028209511656314135, -0.00575583940371871, 0.0025085981469601393, -0.014270749874413013, 0.015112016350030899, -0.014195186085999012, 0.05252089723944664, -0.02503860928118229, -0.032723940908908844, -0.012296979315578938, 0.036335404962301254, -0.014560618437826633, -0.048152726143598557, 0.01619584858417511, -0.01968884840607643, 0.027760706841945648, 0.013495522551238537, 0.01617593690752983, 0.049919191747903824, 0.019237998872995377, -0.025573091581463814, 0.039802778512239456, -0.012672080658376217, 0.05659758299589157, -0.02150917798280716, -0.015061762183904648, 0.02875489555299282, -0.0789223238825798, -0.038583699613809586, 0.05139379948377609, -0.05285169184207916, 0.02610797993838787, 0.018657393753528595, 0.023295728489756584, -0.029652317985892296, 0.02708260715007782, -0.007803057786077261, -0.01755019836127758, 0.008111082948744297, 0.001319308066740632, -0.01953624188899994, 0.017385253682732582, 0.012290379032492638, -0.014075320214033127, -0.0018779407255351543, 0.004287204705178738, 0.007408262230455875, 0.0002265687071485445, -0.02542988769710064, 0.046876344829797745, -0.013941525481641293, 0.06517775356769562, 0.017340639606118202, -0.008969209156930447, 0.06448458880186081, 0.05876297876238823, -0.008403734304010868, 0.04940849170088768, 0.004323463421314955, 0.02436375804245472, -0.1310867965221405, -0.0017410353757441044, 0.030327148735523224, 0.03587161749601364, 0.029497729614377022, -0.08603035658597946, 0.027668306604027748, 0.030970923602581024, -0.08919194340705872, 0.043223220854997635, -0.01629086770117283, 0.013553006574511528, -0.046074990183115005, -0.03813965618610382, -0.005026255268603563, -0.0010927492985501885, 0.052919261157512665, 0.022181786596775055, 0.031776733696460724, 0.03174334019422531, -0.03434611111879349, -0.024190660566091537, -0.026522068306803703, 0.08643049746751785, -0.06849167495965958, -0.05798367038369179, 0.034327905625104904, -0.02606916055083275, -0.008292353712022305, -0.008170925080776215, 0.01882046088576317, 0.010158955119550228, 0.05806412175297737, 0.05663161724805832, 0.03239930793642998, 0.03542761504650116, 0.05167099088430405, -0.03476395830512047, -0.023199651390314102, 0.023312699049711227, 0.0004406564694363624, -0.004221835173666477, 0.013844302855432034, 0.0326569639146328, 0.002543345093727112, -0.016388431191444397, 0.009791753254830837, 0.0082789845764637, -0.010067697614431381, -0.02682584524154663, 0.000958218181040138, -0.017263922840356827, -0.022426417097449303, -0.017782827839255333, 0.015080811455845833, -0.016407862305641174, -0.02130156196653843, 0.01618572324514389, 0.017257526516914368, -0.010282435454428196, 0.0246909037232399, 0.015471646562218666, -0.07171288132667542, 0.022033758461475372, 0.012599478475749493, -0.0073305340483784676, -0.06092198193073273, 0.012753061018884182, 0.018072346225380898, -0.013906796462833881, -0.015430260449647903, -0.01655055768787861, -0.018283873796463013, 0.043164703994989395, 0.011698329821228981, 0.05814213678240776, 0.01876082643866539, -0.043826352804899216, -0.0332283116877079, -0.06915736198425293, 0.04388293996453285, -0.005820659454911947, -0.023296276107430458, -0.01958674192428589, 0.014547633938491344, -0.04823274537920952, -0.0013604012783616781, 0.06607700884342194, 0.002552167046815157, 0.008043411187827587, -0.03190791234374046, 0.013968201354146004, 0.016046738252043724, -0.06051202118396759, -0.0051883491687476635, -0.00745405862107873, -0.009830723516643047, -0.008880047127604485, -0.02171100676059723, 0.03822162374854088, -0.013826237991452217, 0.011552882380783558, 0.0005558446864597499, -0.01605040207505226, 0.020376039668917656, 0.00822682585567236, 0.04291732981801033, 0.03397023677825928, 0.024322550743818283, 0.06420096009969711, 0.02590925432741642, 0.0004958613426424563, -0.010807658545672894, -0.00964520126581192, -0.015870675444602966, -0.01267307810485363, 0.0054478333331644535, -0.008256496861577034, 0.011777696199715137, 0.026503004133701324, 0.023565616458654404, -0.041573598980903625, -0.028201039880514145, 0.05880967155098915, -0.016768265515565872, -0.013134731911122799, 0.03253834322094917, 0.008379238657653332, 0.03472822904586792, 0.004261701367795467, 0.03445490449666977, 0.018552720546722412, -0.006572273094207048, 0.015859611332416534, -0.0005006571882404387, 0.006299057509750128, -0.00048145363689400256, 0.04865043982863426, 0.010680275037884712, -0.027574675157666206, 0.013455799780786037, -0.012908569537103176, 0.04232175648212433, -0.05255494639277458, -0.04520741477608681, 0.008211201056838036, -0.011760406196117401, 0.024111825972795486, -0.003009231761097908, -0.0441865511238575, 0.09792158007621765, -0.03738445043563843, -0.009687650948762894, -0.030153917148709297, -0.03148580342531204, -0.03385762870311737, -0.014296998269855976, 0.02091573365032673, 0.04849150404334068, -0.02742060273885727, 0.01630937121808529, 0.014933319762349129, 0.01776309497654438, 0.05527106299996376, -0.036021824926137924, 0.03948669135570526, 0.024854259565472603, -0.006488095968961716, 0.0052537377923727036, 0.023532308638095856, -0.008397279307246208, -0.01662113144993782, 0.02648954652249813, 0.044601596891880035, 0.008938568644225597, 0.03130287677049637, -0.030068011954426765, 0.0221486184746027, 0.0257637370377779, -0.052733197808265686, -0.010216409340500832, -0.05370696634054184, -0.006837066728621721, -0.03490588441491127, -0.009643333032727242 ]
<p>I am running a pooled OLS regression and Random effects regression. </p> <p>I have tested for autocorrelation for both methods. In the pooled OLS model I find serial correlation but for the RE model I find no serial correlation. </p> <p>How is this possible? Is it possible that the unobserved time invariant variables that are removed in RE model are causing serial correlation in the pooled OLS regression? </p>
74,516
[ -0.028683962300419807, 0.0007207677699625492, 0.00849557388573885, 0.006407228764146566, 0.023255378007888794, 0.0038637688849121332, -0.021005569025874138, -0.000057743465731618926, 0.03901289403438568, -0.02633446641266346, 0.03721736744046211, 0.024125728756189346, 0.0593341588973999, 0.019569551572203636, 0.01691211760044098, -0.021519707515835762, 0.016978606581687927, 0.02291364036500454, 0.027843844145536423, 0.01970076933503151, -0.026496874168515205, 0.02610624209046364, 0.020529627799987793, -0.006252800580114126, -0.04224275052547455, 0.06240434944629669, 0.011558362282812595, -0.03399293124675751, 0.0325961597263813, 0.05568991228938103, -0.02127312682569027, -0.03128499910235405, -0.01128953043371439, 0.02602664940059185, 0.005925597157329321, 0.005716162268072367, -0.011234408244490623, -0.042245347052812576, 0.004672341048717499, 0.010761545039713383, -0.024725737050175667, -0.02969564124941826, -0.03251103684306145, 0.05704274773597717, -0.011543666943907738, -0.0035644634626805782, -0.002408832311630249, 0.0251749437302351, 0.05384254828095436, 0.00541754299774766, 0.056127093732357025, -0.007246328517794609, 0.0576922632753849, 0.04099520668387413, -0.0309735294431448, 0.028198618441820145, 0.06738995760679245, 0.045362602919340134, -0.010237067937850952, -0.046070896089076996, -0.0015968678053468466, 0.0131531348451972, 0.026418890804052353, 0.006025912240147591, -0.033928483724594116, 0.0068807657808065414, 0.010974030941724777, -0.018945559859275818, 0.028726091608405113, -0.00015410348714794964, 0.0330166295170784, 0.014934753999114037, 0.04042749106884003, 0.01484124269336462, 0.04815209284424782, -0.05730900913476944, 0.018985481932759285, -0.01091720163822174, 0.02508854679763317, 0.04326876252889633, 0.022080792114138603, 0.02723664604127407, 0.022268839180469513, 0.003191219875589013, 0.03142343461513519, -0.012580463662743568, 0.022935306653380394, 0.002999786287546158, -0.0035311952233314514, 0.03303312882781029, -0.01898616924881935, 0.03095242567360401, 0.04476234316825867, 0.011273492127656937, -0.035120680928230286, 0.017397763207554817, -0.00293163675814867, 0.0767824649810791, 0.014930360019207, -0.001993314130231738, -0.025951940566301346, -0.05263666808605194, 0.0054118144325912, 0.0805354192852974, -0.01321740448474884, -0.0033624477218836546, -0.004693651106208563, 0.0033499719575047493, -0.0015529406955465674, -0.06213358789682388, -0.03398457542061806, 0.00212509511038661, -0.010345203801989555, 0.0022901673801243305, 0.0359535850584507, -0.0185773316770792, -0.017928246408700943, -0.0022651860490441322, 0.0741826668381691, 0.0728893056511879, 0.017849206924438477, -0.041205234825611115, -0.00009349976608064026, -0.030231280252337456, -0.039347730576992035, 0.02739623188972473, 0.018682388588786125, -0.011818889528512955, -0.05837366729974747, 0.05406296253204346, 0.013615913689136505, -0.04700477048754692, 0.00908973440527916, -0.021490179002285004, 0.045059531927108765, 0.005718062166124582, -0.10698224604129791, -0.06827755272388458, 0.020203810185194016, -0.040188267827034, 0.02184775285422802, -0.049499064683914185, -0.023226037621498108, -0.006815624423325062, 0.07275478541851044, -0.0009709582664072514, 0.02692570723593235, 0.0002701668709050864, 0.007376564666628838, 0.04009252414107323, -0.00009148683602688834, -0.013364281505346298, -0.03167390078306198, -0.018074141815304756, 0.008338838815689087, -0.07845253497362137, -0.01057964377105236, 0.0281106885522604, -0.011276306584477425, 0.022008951753377914, 0.030495278537273407, 0.02924276702105999, -0.005298682488501072, 0.01280999556183815, 0.01670697145164013, -0.057499196380376816, 0.04336005449295044, -0.01808791421353817, 0.006416551768779755, 0.033607978373765945, -0.0007052092696540058, 0.034743886440992355, 0.008262280374765396, 0.07630385458469391, 0.01525875274091959, -0.007485211826860905, -0.00383792188949883, 0.026901498436927795, 0.0025655643548816442, 0.01943511888384819, -0.0740293338894844, -0.011795233935117722, -0.015011328272521496, -0.07500158995389938, 0.003430065233260393, 0.031926922500133514, -0.0026386284735053778, 0.0229052621871233, 0.004384293220937252, -0.028635090216994286, -0.04854085296392441, -0.08119292557239532, 0.023187020793557167, -0.003626208519563079, -0.005918745882809162, 0.009339580312371254, -0.007357652764767408, 0.040303733199834824, -0.005113663151860237, -0.02632342465221882, -0.013535435311496258, 0.0014854558976367116, 0.03908225893974304, -0.05442595109343529, 0.04920686036348343, 0.007287450600415468, 0.025357840582728386, -0.02124524675309658, 0.01973734237253666, -0.015949612483382225, -0.03718952834606171, 0.039289455860853195, -0.009952783584594727, 0.02389749325811863, -0.01708095334470272, -0.0329391211271286, 0.010611983947455883, -0.0027867904864251614, -0.02224915288388729, 0.034177929162979126, -0.031711235642433167, 0.016207313165068626, 0.05848991870880127, 0.020739000290632248, -0.01747400127351284, 0.06073088198900223, 0.017063483595848083, 0.017866646870970726, -0.020478500053286552, -0.03968110308051109, -0.03080621175467968, -0.014287957921624184, 0.05203460156917572, 0.034494318068027496, -0.026495901867747307, 0.023529931902885437, 0.06626619398593903, 0.04953094571828842, 0.0042930482886731625, 0.03283132612705231, 0.01473743375390768, 0.002393061062321067, 0.011509714648127556, 0.010445686988532543, 0.0388462170958519, 0.034010838717222214, 0.02054860070347786, -0.01125755812972784, 0.05181106925010681, -0.007912312634289265, -0.021918298676609993, 0.04446732997894287, 0.03504844009876251, 0.0026004547253251076, -0.034836456179618835, -0.029891807585954666, 0.022945454344153404, -0.013967599719762802, 0.014349231496453285, 0.0026277487631887197, 0.053761113435029984, 0.014243749901652336, -0.028627654537558556, -0.027537334710359573, 0.032453522086143494, -0.010954178869724274, -0.008992811664938927, -0.020070992410182953, -0.0012015579268336296, -0.03877035900950432, -0.0013364719925448298, -0.010267410427331924, 0.013969526626169682, -0.06094367429614067, 0.016542233526706696, 0.05932226777076721, -0.0074623748660087585, 0.015122734010219574, -0.018001588061451912, -0.003155885962769389, 0.0012907562777400017, -0.008918730542063713, 0.0009216119651682675, -0.012874250300228596, -0.044632334262132645, 0.02978227101266384, -0.021675847470760345, 0.01743561401963234, 0.00670517235994339, 0.0005746788810938597, -0.007674388121813536, 0.055933430790901184, -0.01884819008409977, -0.05251621454954147, -0.048758432269096375, -0.0093306265771389, 0.012247449718415737, -0.036660559475421906, -0.030568936839699745, 0.052344366908073425, -0.0067893643863499165, -0.04439055174589157, 0.0022688955068588257, -0.04710357263684273, 0.019610872492194176, 0.0071517350152134895, -0.00890914723277092, -0.009224321693181992, -0.02040271833539009, 0.02610936388373375, 0.018521420657634735, -0.05784452334046364, -0.021236602216959, -0.061599232256412506, -0.04723550006747246, 0.016171958297491074, 0.01482614129781723, 0.027439892292022705, 0.0008613097597844899, -0.021081971004605293, 0.028445269912481308, 0.016992885619401932, 0.009357715956866741, -0.06488891690969467, 0.011126089841127396, -0.01388819981366396, -0.055000144988298416, 0.044725365936756134, -0.021752245724201202, 0.023324817419052124, 0.021399570629000664, -0.02305789478123188, 0.04931275546550751, 0.04752426594495773, -0.015804417431354523, -0.008113387040793896, 0.0018910181242972612, -0.008104212582111359, -0.010734925046563148, 0.03608215972781181, -0.015236692503094673, -0.016018619760870934, -0.022134656086564064, 0.025089699774980545, 0.015504213981330395, -0.016541697084903717, -0.05454252287745476, 0.03431133180856705, -0.016889574006199837, 0.017601467669010162, -0.014162209816277027, 0.020138386636972427, 0.00504217529669404, -0.02929234318435192, -0.06458123028278351, -0.01191395241767168, 0.032788220793008804, -0.00037013590917922556, 0.0014714642893522978, 0.04241674765944481, 0.01700863614678383, 0.00028925115475431085, -0.0029407856054604053, -0.043022576719522476, -0.008730767294764519, 0.03304952755570412, -0.005142490845173597, 0.012271304614841938, 0.05171158164739609, 0.0051949811168015, 0.004459954332560301, -0.028686581179499626, -0.07226195931434631, -0.0647466778755188, -0.0831691175699234, 0.045422039926052094, -0.03430895134806633, 0.053046874701976776, 0.010979019105434418, 0.047375500202178955, 0.021974116563796997, -0.023924052715301514, -0.028032073751091957, -0.001850481959991157, -0.06102690100669861, 0.04492288827896118, -0.0316433347761631, -0.010623685084283352, 0.019587337970733643, -0.05767487362027168, -0.005371680483222008, -0.021006669849157333, 0.004742187913507223, -0.006756278686225414, 0.01620524562895298, -0.026488345116376877, -0.02384759485721588, -0.009707177057862282, -0.016074206680059433, -0.00023277822765521705, -0.013928115367889404, -0.013080588541924953, -0.03758009895682335, 0.038992658257484436, 0.05183909460902214, 0.019571907818317413, -0.012045962736010551, -0.05368749797344208, 0.010347243398427963, -0.001500812009908259, 0.020440679043531418, 0.05798014998435974, -0.010888560675084591, -0.04436606913805008, 0.04055560752749443, 0.015995804220438004, 0.03661593049764633, 0.05436255410313606, 0.0239705927670002, -0.04368553310632706, -0.026765910908579826, -0.0038058129139244556, 0.04627060145139694, 0.010373464785516262, 0.03559723123908043, 0.01649582013487816, 0.04991450160741806, 0.028735624626278877, -0.03024344891309738, -0.01904531940817833, 0.046166419982910156, 0.017699746415019035, 0.0020526726730167866, -0.01876446232199669, -0.00481000728905201, 0.016555946320295334, -0.025513797998428345, 0.06401105225086212, -0.019684890285134315, -0.019615938887000084, -0.02910429611802101, 0.03631792217493057, -0.033150605857372284, -0.026162685826420784, 0.013823195360600948, 0.04581216722726822, 0.03455204516649246, -0.007781404536217451, -0.030908377841114998, 0.0034215664491057396, 0.04642321541905403, 0.0209001787006855, 0.05437559261918068, 0.02177424542605877, -0.05524691194295883, -0.01318312156945467, 0.010465001687407494, 0.01978602632880211, -0.03819006681442261, 0.04109200835227966, -0.01733420602977276, -0.010082957334816456, -0.008490212261676788, -0.010512355715036392, 0.020034203305840492, -0.028888730332255363, 0.033294569700956345, -0.0011844249675050378, -0.051244720816612244, -0.023687193170189857, 0.02028086967766285, 0.005376572720706463, 0.03236870840191841, -0.007014876697212458, -0.04061533138155937, -0.02946559712290764, 0.007578396704047918, 0.030479680746793747, 0.02000182308256626, -0.032525502145290375, 0.026394996792078018, 0.011567043140530586, 0.052268173545598984, -0.015255956910550594, -0.08392907679080963, 0.005279208533465862, -0.01755937933921814, -0.00817384384572506, 0.06596831232309341, -0.008768520317971706, 0.0014959167456254363, -0.007759402506053448, 0.02130475826561451, 0.01903400383889675, -0.024833912029862404, -0.03083799220621586, 0.040691133588552475, 0.032221607863903046, 0.011497405357658863, 0.04713932052254677, 0.0330609455704689, 0.03626358136534691, -0.05147220566868782, -0.012676835991442204, 0.02933691255748272, -0.06729346513748169, -0.015247704461216927, -0.029559511691331863, 0.014550077728927135, -0.01798839122056961, 0.017754603177309036, -0.02231772616505623, 0.02863977663218975, -0.039533790200948715, -0.008028590120375156, 0.008330654352903366, 0.050917331129312515, -0.02616674266755581, 0.020908379927277565, -0.02106752246618271, -0.007829957641661167, -0.03966088965535164, -0.0259612575173378, -0.030551504343748093, -0.006824756972491741, -0.0034765698947012424, 0.010419768281280994, -0.02173895575106144, 0.013070140033960342, 0.01673627644777298, -0.022371938452124596, 0.005620636511594057, -0.012738392688333988, 0.002893247874453664, 0.010712829418480396, 0.005217875819653273, -0.006241873372346163, -0.04357346519827843, 0.023498397320508957, 0.014496443793177605, -0.0019938433542847633, 0.015389962121844292, -0.03214104846119881, 0.08120172470808029, 0.017544841393828392, -0.022839559242129326, -0.09349900484085083, -0.08874667435884476, 0.018930654972791672, -0.009534670040011406, -0.022713376209139824, -0.02854325994849205, 0.006277914624661207, -0.05527813732624054, -0.0034009143710136414, -0.0232196394354105, 0.0823211520910263, -0.039944492280483246, 0.010239875875413418, -0.006891523953527212, 0.02835133671760559, 0.07644663006067276, -0.021004237234592438, -0.0047323270700871944, 0.027655133977532387, -0.0354422889649868, -0.029098760336637497, -0.016998419538140297, 0.03426893427968025, -0.021901216357946396, -0.01028826180845499, -0.037267670035362244, -0.0019326413748785853, 0.04710816591978073, -0.040526896715164185, -0.02036319486796856, 0.01791413128376007, 0.008863547816872597, 0.023785630241036415, -0.02382584661245346, 0.00759134953841567, 0.0017535659717395902, 0.008873754180967808, 0.0059966035187244415, -0.007784709800034761, -0.016877759248018265, -0.003808391047641635, 0.040576014667749405, -0.015791738405823708, 0.00028991943690925837, 0.027266986668109894, 0.07005797326564789, -0.002005011076107621, 0.00868549756705761, -0.002661960432305932, -0.023743372410535812, 0.07417618483304977, -0.0007056898903101683, 0.023278294131159782, 0.012971458956599236, 0.01963154226541519, -0.04718949273228645, -0.06486397981643677, -0.023740729317069054, 0.010425752960145473, 0.07398785650730133, 0.0035855574533343315, 0.032309044152498245, 0.05296686291694641, -0.018020309507846832, -0.021480601280927658, -0.0527069978415966, -0.007571708410978317, -0.005296980496495962, -0.008003422990441322, 0.049016837030649185, -0.0011686997022479773, 0.012425546534359455, -0.002221102360635996, 0.00882263109087944, 0.03298241272568703, 0.035266801714897156, 0.018729092553257942, 0.013884407468140125, 0.00790475495159626, -0.0035618385300040245, -0.02715819515287876, 0.004642707761377096, -0.01991688646376133, 0.004031382966786623, -0.02871895208954811, -0.006372375879436731, 0.05797160416841507, 0.0400211326777935, 0.02070096880197525, -0.06574651598930359, -0.030213307589292526, -0.06301148235797882, 0.008199505507946014, 0.013408600352704525, -0.010127545334398746, 0.028553292155265808, 0.014234183356165886, 0.04666156321763992, 0.018779568374156952, 0.02170816995203495, 0.0009828907204791903, -0.08994749188423157, 0.014365902170538902, 0.013833514414727688, 0.0334719680249691, 0.055911239236593246, -0.02064325660467148, -0.02595682255923748, 0.004076739307492971, -0.025854237377643585, -0.021099375560879707, 0.009939666837453842, 0.0299884881824255, -0.02416159398853779, 0.08121997117996216, 0.0206023920327425, 0.02173355408012867, -0.015569234266877174, -0.002584584290161729, 0.10512182116508484, 0.06735105812549591, 0.01082455925643444, -0.05193516984581947, 0.003138757310807705, -0.003282411489635706, -0.010925871320068836, 0.005168986972421408, -0.024119574576616287, -0.0154580632224679, -0.0024057503324002028, 0.04526297375559807, 0.04409562051296234, 0.017497621476650238, -0.028539352118968964, 0.03064161352813244, -0.019683359190821648, -0.019054364413022995, -0.006005424074828625, 0.004218261688947678, 0.026874620467424393, -0.016006968915462494, -0.04363848641514778, 0.010465980507433414, -0.012820752337574959, -0.034968968480825424, -0.029583806172013283, -0.02447044663131237, -0.020601550117135048, 0.0019020566251128912, -0.0023549101315438747, 0.004732978064566851, 0.016696324571967125, 0.02583269588649273, -0.0038119361270219088, 0.015734290704131126, 0.013319239020347595, -0.06515809893608093, 0.05498901382088661, 0.027502965182065964, -0.019519492983818054, -0.030076898634433746, 0.008975610136985779, -0.00694071501493454, -0.07469961792230606, -0.003574620233848691, -0.026920655742287636, 0.05030738562345505, -0.02007957734167576, -0.03793451189994812, -0.04746801406145096, -0.02162455953657627, 0.022378185763955116, -0.03955643251538277, -0.0390101820230484, 0.019343305379152298, -0.013644879683852196, -0.03885696828365326, -0.026642726734280586, -0.05652404949069023, -0.01742207072675228, -0.019609741866588593, 0.052664756774902344, 0.03149836137890816, -0.01292723324149847, 0.018573036417365074, -0.054147470742464066, 0.054290980100631714, -0.009872650727629662, 0.017269864678382874, -0.01927369087934494, -0.009704590775072575, -0.028479116037487984, -0.00801182072609663, 0.02134975604712963, 0.027259254828095436, 0.029239481315016747, 0.005117332562804222, -0.014380655251443386, -0.032416023313999176, -0.06477585434913635, -0.010470776818692684, -0.0378718227148056, -0.03275785967707634, -0.05719081684947014, 0.014573432505130768, 0.03982652351260185, 0.03569366782903671, -0.0062147872522473335, 0.024460315704345703, 0.0041189007461071014, 0.033557452261447906, 0.009273380972445011, -0.018466759473085403, -0.009125548414885998, -0.013184157200157642, -0.013716143555939198, -0.007612364832311869, -0.010231523774564266, 0.031115055084228516, 0.009322496131062508, 0.024435020983219147, -0.027048766613006592, 0.02107957936823368, -0.026110321283340454, 0.0019073814619332552, 0.03508879616856575, -0.007357816211879253, 0.011053240858018398, 0.002043022308498621, 0.009204111061990261, -0.0019702587742358446, 0.02680519036948681, -0.015153765678405762, -0.0022067867685109377, 0.0012989314272999763, -0.033129796385765076, -0.032182857394218445, 0.011696917936205864, -0.02865666337311268, 0.057698413729667664, -0.016354506835341454, -0.018986815586686134, -0.06578738242387772, -0.0024533970281481743, 0.007790598087012768, 0.012515130452811718, -0.020649176090955734, 0.04564627259969711, 0.015578826889395714, -0.013493902049958706, 0.02617688663303852, 0.012432785704731941, 0.00697371968999505, 0.019843006506562233, 0.007778211031109095, -0.028333568945527077, 0.015641571953892708, 0.01283024251461029, -0.05638815090060234, 0.020669175311923027, -0.03555768355727196, 0.02369387075304985, -0.0023232861422002316, -0.000601042527705431, 0.03506762906908989, 0.018490295857191086, 0.04122417792677879, -0.0022030938416719437, 0.0458747074007988, -0.02462266944348812, 0.017859145998954773, -0.012118798680603504, 0.013966133818030357, 0.02552909404039383, 0.007121189963072538, -0.0034425556659698486, 0.03363640978932381, -0.022297613322734833, 0.03094697743654251, 0.05066288262605667, 0.005445289425551891, 0.0020464055705815554, 0.02247260883450508, -0.013366623781621456, 0.01587321236729622, 0.004495554603636265, 0.005206417758017778, -0.035159673541784286, 0.049550723284482956, -0.04742339625954628, 0.04666217789053917, 0.016121238470077515, -0.021064117550849915, -0.07623926550149918, -0.0030102829914540052, 0.011198705993592739, 0.016057590022683144, 0.019762562587857246, -0.013196641579270363, -0.050647806376218796, 0.027270935475826263, -0.03756357729434967, 0.010547427460551262, -0.0036227619275450706, -0.009511489421129227, -0.03760572522878647, 0.019594131037592888, -0.01635919325053692, 0.011555150151252747, 0.02519288845360279, 0.02691749855875969, 0.018552126362919807, 0.019841816276311874, -0.0016855811700224876, -0.012634940445423126, -0.04961109533905983, -0.016830941662192345, 0.022948358207941055, -0.034538816660642624, 0.031135529279708862, -0.04989679530262947, -0.009336617775261402, 0.024971723556518555, -0.04024466499686241, 0.029652735218405724, 0.0023682613391429186, 0.03035019338130951, -0.014891167171299458, 0.029583008959889412, 0.06139753758907318, -0.012608904391527176, 0.030601758509874344, -0.00047741783782839775, -0.000509185716509819, 0.028614472597837448, -0.0257626473903656, 0.04268021881580353, -0.011419171467423439, -0.0013661907287314534, -0.00020966869487892836, 0.0219575222581625, -0.0019943122752010822, -0.04672415181994438, 0.022555366158485413, -0.011819899082183838, 0.004900127649307251, -0.012150000780820847, 0.006989139132201672, -0.016391215845942497, -0.01899615488946438, 0.09028056263923645, 0.02441975474357605, -0.0482793003320694, 0.03156358003616333, -0.022787146270275116, -0.03191835433244705, 0.012692018412053585, 0.000642348371911794, -0.024760104715824127, -0.08380094915628433, -0.003967430908232927, -0.0007297421689145267, -0.006979542784392834, -0.038979094475507736, -0.0036326672416180372, -0.027221309021115303, 0.028253354132175446, -0.01963704451918602, 0.0010528527200222015, 0.014782133512198925, -0.009371630847454071, 0.016379812732338905, -0.035235125571489334, 0.02257351763546467, 0.013711453415453434, -0.05633627250790596, -0.054987337440252304, -0.03524499759078026, -0.022081691771745682, 0.007669323123991489, 0.05622491613030434, 0.013879915699362755, 0.0181618370115757, 0.038804713636636734, 0.057514846324920654, 0.007691988255828619, -0.013108808547258377, 0.06779467314481735, -0.00713713513687253, -0.013604696840047836, 0.015576108358800411, -0.044587649405002594, -0.02250361628830433, 0.015883872285485268, -0.016751177608966827, -0.05529702827334404, 0.008893785998225212, 0.02325272373855114, -0.0411316379904747, 0.043949879705905914, -0.004197766538709402, -0.013032544404268265, 0.039355263113975525, -0.0010732181835919619, 0.03810187056660652, 0.004437197931110859, -0.00488832825794816, -0.03818671032786369, 0.04936419054865837, -0.05265924707055092, -0.01488073542714119, 0.0070451730862259865, 0.02467026188969612, -0.013006067834794521, -0.05870451778173447, 0.017855769023299217, 0.021165182814002037, -0.040350593626499176, -0.014258652925491333, 0.04509848356246948, -0.024888411164283752, -0.003982287831604481, 0.024211429059505463, 0.03029961697757244, -0.013645556755363941, -0.03573385253548622, 0.019381968304514885, 0.042932190001010895, 0.030162794515490532, 0.008786972612142563, -0.019727937877178192, 0.045541372150182724, -0.0309530571103096, 0.055940933525562286, -0.03191082179546356, 0.014860376715660095, -0.05107192322611809, -0.010045389644801617, 0.019253354519605637, -0.017012137919664383, 0.027439560741186142, 0.006320137996226549, -0.03569465130567551, 0.07894674688577652, -0.067175954580307, 0.024370795115828514, 0.004780789837241173, -0.018520208075642586, -0.028522180393338203, -0.013040336780250072, 0.031306542456150055, 0.014093841426074505, 0.0057531436905264854, 0.003021307522431016, 0.006179705262184143, -0.026000911369919777, -0.0055187721736729145, 0.006730349734425545, 0.013962225057184696, -0.00426275422796607, -0.04766574501991272, -0.02799719013273716, -0.0021336323115974665, -0.029473569244146347, -0.05195728689432144, 0.035342078655958176, 0.03448403626680374, 0.010865362361073494, -0.04162249714136124, -0.0247768834233284, 0.01479408424347639, 0.05847018212080002, -0.059806108474731445, -0.020561303943395615, -0.02045905776321888, -0.003388789715245366, -0.014105476438999176, 0.004741853103041649 ]
<p>In Frank Harrell's <a href="http://biostat.mc.vanderbilt.edu/wiki/Main/RmS" rel="nofollow">RMS Short Course</a> today, I became aware that multiple imputation with <code>Hmisc:aregImpute</code> is not invariant to the ordering of terms in its formula argument, and that one therefore ought to check results of imputation under permutations of these terms. Here's a simple function that generates the necessary permutations:</p> <pre><code>perms &lt;- function(n, formula) { rhs &lt;- attr(terms(formula), 'term.labels') formulae &lt;- list() for(i in 1:n){ formulae[[i]] &lt;- as.formula(paste("~", paste(sample(rhs), collapse="+"))) } formulae } </code></pre> <p>For example:</p> <pre><code>&gt; perms(5, ~ age + sex + bp + death + mi) [[1]] ~mi + age + bp + sex + death &lt;environment: 0x10dc9cbb8&gt; [[2]] ~bp + mi + sex + age + death &lt;environment: 0x10dc9cbb8&gt; [[3]] ~mi + bp + age + death + sex &lt;environment: 0x10dc9cbb8&gt; [[4]] ~age + death + bp + sex + mi &lt;environment: 0x10dc9cbb8&gt; [[5]] ~bp + age + death + sex + mi &lt;environment: 0x10dc9cbb8&gt; &gt; </code></pre> <p>This could be used with <code>lapply</code> as follows:</p> <pre><code>as &lt;- lapply(perms(5, ~ age + sex + bp + death + mi) , aregImpute, data=mydata, n.impute=10) </code></pre> <p>But I wonder whether it might make more sense to incorporate this into aregImpute itself.</p>
37,417
[ -0.0287980604916811, -0.005925743840634823, 0.007756458595395088, -0.008849896490573883, 0.005569757428020239, -0.031471364200115204, -0.03791956230998039, 0.003867681138217449, 0.019877975806593895, -0.004221891053020954, 0.033073872327804565, 0.005401153117418289, 0.04596725478768349, 0.0037818599957972765, 0.048228971660137177, 0.033372536301612854, 0.008186396211385727, 0.05877149477601051, 0.0036664940416812897, 0.019280387088656425, 0.003684569615870714, 0.019994281232357025, 0.008147018030285835, -0.007000577636063099, 0.009264390915632248, 0.028976142406463623, 0.005684093106538057, -0.0322241373360157, -0.04708653688430786, 0.06590140610933304, -0.03817299008369446, 0.0015898627461865544, 0.026623470708727837, 0.004231796599924564, 0.020379958674311638, 0.04066033661365509, 0.0037009557709097862, -0.048490025103092194, -0.011551576666533947, 0.03842061758041382, -0.02304813824594021, -0.015419027768075466, -0.016792796552181244, 0.04485119879245758, -0.006469840183854103, 0.01192003209143877, -0.029037876054644585, 0.0357486754655838, 0.03182525187730789, -0.03761393576860428, 0.031797781586647034, -0.024576419964432716, 0.033757664263248444, 0.008580412715673447, -0.0712139829993248, -0.009674403816461563, 0.03980759158730507, 0.06129809468984604, 0.014119734056293964, -0.05797179043292999, -0.025335470214486122, -0.06455755978822708, 0.0143332714214921, -0.028345778584480286, -0.01754089631140232, -0.017828045412898064, 0.02919963002204895, 0.03684939816594124, 0.0341271236538887, -0.03996056318283081, 0.013058731332421303, -0.01228964515030384, 0.03412517160177231, -0.0072344704531133175, 0.016092997044324875, -0.03335324674844742, -0.004056517034769058, -0.017743520438671112, 0.00920573528856039, 0.020687997341156006, -0.026406530290842056, 0.03862956538796425, -0.011253371834754944, 0.027211174368858337, 0.004766169469803572, -0.0037251277826726437, 0.08052768558263779, -0.040909476578235626, 0.0598534531891346, 0.010928727686405182, -0.01185285672545433, -0.00186642212793231, 0.038476645946502686, 0.007140491623431444, -0.006690518464893103, 0.034289538860321045, -0.045152448117733, 0.02750522643327713, -0.023162923753261566, 0.007325458340346813, -0.0228301789611578, -0.03319735825061798, 0.041689351201057434, 0.050002679228782654, -0.036234185099601746, -0.006097789853811264, -0.027334479615092278, -0.003165679518133402, -0.015957273542881012, -0.04293569177389145, -0.01868927851319313, 0.030997557565569878, 0.006016833707690239, 0.004333840683102608, -0.028167741373181343, -0.04525370895862579, 0.0003994839789811522, 0.016175443306565285, 0.04252751171588898, 0.08438524603843689, 0.06625455617904663, -0.01073297020047903, 0.014971829950809479, -0.01383660826832056, -0.0035269625950604677, 0.013198379427194595, -0.00139256299007684, 0.0049949996173381805, 0.00037562186480499804, -0.019717777147889137, -0.0035302522592246532, -0.045393552631139755, 0.04523360729217529, 0.027808774262666702, 0.014878630638122559, -0.0103185148909688, -0.11160159111022949, -0.04370100423693657, 0.014049426652491093, -0.034741051495075226, 0.006343962624669075, 0.006482487078756094, 0.054132506251335144, 0.026302563026547432, 0.04961412027478218, -0.020307116210460663, 0.05760932341217995, 0.017681268975138664, 0.020787468180060387, 0.0064073665998876095, 0.006401790771633387, -0.012147101573646069, -0.028781458735466003, 0.007749443873763084, 0.002532304497435689, -0.08659608662128448, 0.01307151559740305, 0.021579893305897713, -0.011928802356123924, 0.02718566544353962, 0.028987376019358635, -0.0006789655308239162, -0.021808208897709846, -0.03495994582772255, -0.01349607203155756, -0.03347010910511017, 0.06478095799684525, 0.01649634540081024, 0.009161444380879402, 0.03193751350045204, -0.026387613266706467, 0.056392937898635864, -0.010635221377015114, 0.002829935634508729, 0.03470929339528084, -0.016527606174349785, 0.013044174760580063, -0.021969353780150414, 0.014312435872852802, 0.048028364777565, -0.058772239834070206, -0.012465395964682102, 0.0018801609985530376, -0.009105227887630463, 0.04365653917193413, -0.028873106464743614, 0.011416058987379074, -0.01314566470682621, 0.07089266180992126, -0.03791986033320427, -0.0313706174492836, -0.028632752597332, -0.022269660606980324, -0.00571035360917449, -0.009857463650405407, -0.006892635487020016, -0.009888765402138233, 0.021569781005382538, 0.03695613890886307, -0.034273531287908554, -0.034547653049230576, 0.010136673226952553, 0.03816351294517517, -0.025049813091754913, -0.057940371334552765, 0.008111107163131237, 0.02501305378973484, -0.02665315940976143, 0.010089251212775707, -0.05813302844762802, 0.006882753688842058, 0.008856457658112049, -0.04497598111629486, 0.05016055703163147, -0.022164994850754738, -0.014585696160793304, 0.004749902989715338, 0.018286988139152527, 0.0073023950681090355, 0.05210185796022415, -0.05215344578027725, 0.015979673713445663, 0.09247104078531265, 0.013443183153867722, 0.00798076018691063, 0.000611557683441788, 0.016757817938923836, 0.051220089197158813, -0.025983300060033798, -0.011323856189846992, -0.0802578553557396, -0.046662747859954834, 0.03247462958097458, -0.00435482244938612, -0.025250261649489403, 0.004401851445436478, 0.04818357527256012, 0.020941365510225296, 0.011042453348636627, 0.046097129583358765, 0.0022401476744562387, -0.04057428240776062, 0.04527454450726509, -0.006980903446674347, 0.01819796860218048, 0.015869557857513428, 0.007351459935307503, -0.023288544267416, 0.03379989415407181, 0.02696702629327774, -0.0070424433797597885, 0.032170407474040985, -0.0057694753631949425, -0.006897879298776388, -0.02956381067633629, -0.03254580870270729, 0.0344572477042675, -0.031089304015040398, 0.04471466317772865, 0.04475205019116402, -0.001251222100108862, -0.029801107943058014, 0.017077431082725525, -0.012306394055485725, 0.003991296514868736, 0.020981216803193092, -0.05098848044872284, 0.019706040620803833, 0.0023414622992277145, -0.0317726731300354, 0.0037745812442153692, -0.011301652528345585, -0.029216036200523376, -0.046205464750528336, 0.031578194350004196, 0.02450369857251644, -0.011499155312776566, 0.032484300434589386, -0.04244235157966614, -0.009901875630021095, 0.010408768430352211, -0.021087972447276115, 0.019862079992890358, 0.019428998231887817, -0.03181427717208862, -0.03935519978404045, 0.003228491870686412, -0.042610667645931244, 0.051240839064121246, 0.00028133331215940416, -0.07049068808555603, 0.01797514781355858, 0.014020749367773533, -0.025463616475462914, -0.014750887639820576, 0.01046370156109333, -0.006811230909079313, -0.04072987660765648, -0.01201999094337225, 0.07574188709259033, 0.05128689110279083, -0.054506637156009674, -0.018610596656799316, 0.000005380293714551954, 0.007416635286062956, 0.0003442176675889641, 0.011813001707196236, 0.012516477145254612, -0.01248673815280199, 0.0018778626108542085, 0.014536501839756966, 0.02114707976579666, -0.00203076028265059, -0.05871231481432915, -0.05904038995504379, 0.023485394194722176, 0.014188649132847786, 0.00541266705840826, 0.0211405660957098, 0.015517937950789928, 0.059704262763261795, 0.05579867586493492, -0.0527721606194973, -0.06504206359386444, -0.02029968425631523, 0.02944975160062313, -0.016755137592554092, 0.03077693283557892, 0.012800639495253563, 0.036674849689006805, 0.00877998024225235, 0.022947004064917564, 0.055284056812524796, 0.03247968852519989, -0.03269997611641884, 0.028138399124145508, -0.0034050545655190945, 0.0013714320957660675, -0.040627483278512955, 0.04646683111786842, 0.010419306345283985, -0.004926482681185007, 0.009662700816988945, 0.007474114652723074, 0.025652963668107986, -0.012509926222264767, -0.05902085080742836, -0.005680319853127003, -0.013677413575351238, 0.026743272319436073, -0.058682773262262344, 0.024114998057484627, 0.06453374028205872, -0.052255354821681976, -0.03618166968226433, 0.022300783544778824, 0.037069518119096756, -0.05905897915363312, 0.00679299421608448, 0.04511718451976776, 0.06743256002664566, -0.013595158234238625, 0.008405196480453014, -0.05723383277654648, 0.011306215077638626, 0.012203868478536606, -0.05101277679204941, -0.006280447822064161, 0.03879658505320549, 0.05635247379541397, -0.030876094475388527, 0.011306697502732277, -0.04411505162715912, 0.012234371155500412, -0.029110845178365707, -0.021046888083219528, -0.017537429928779602, 0.011039810255169868, -0.006191931199282408, 0.015205351635813713, 0.021523065865039825, -0.0023901639506220818, 0.005121275316923857, 0.0016696249367669225, -0.024165889248251915, -0.0012032516533508897, 0.03128759190440178, -0.006472395732998848, 0.0031625276897102594, -0.05531541258096695, 0.025191279128193855, -0.036432571709156036, -0.013765675015747547, -0.0061688851565122604, -0.007755996659398079, -0.028115982189774513, 0.07020444422960281, -0.007468318101018667, -0.009395786561071873, 0.006846059579402208, 0.012905188836157322, 0.028777223080396652, 0.025772714987397194, 0.011440515518188477, 0.01227148063480854, -0.0001741566084092483, -0.008003052324056625, -0.02476789802312851, 0.004810103680938482, 0.0033302747178822756, 0.0006386761670000851, 0.008902547881007195, 0.034328196197748184, -0.020032858476042747, 0.028894219547510147, -0.019907519221305847, -0.0029480885714292526, 0.05285384878516197, -0.008232520893216133, -0.03696885704994202, 0.017713088542222977, 0.02228149212896824, 0.029046742245554924, -0.022506169974803925, -0.00046485403436236084, 0.035665109753608704, 0.07123761624097824, 0.031583521515131, -0.033544331789016724, 0.00018199854821432382, 0.02668485976755619, 0.03003569506108761, -0.02463028021156788, -0.026530424132943153, 0.011642851866781712, 0.005469052121043205, 0.010988074354827404, 0.045570895075798035, 0.03777564316987991, 0.0028631805907934904, -0.019907237961888313, 0.014660447835922241, -0.04543088749051094, -0.04314696416258812, -0.009393488056957722, -0.044219110161066055, 0.03453221544623375, 0.0073623452335596085, -0.0034120543859899044, -0.010833079926669598, -0.003909704275429249, 0.0242213923484087, 0.002585311885923147, 0.003737421939149499, -0.0641416683793068, 0.02001352235674858, 0.0646664947271347, 0.043557312339544296, -0.016856331378221512, 0.00030859955586493015, -0.06535332649946213, -0.030741890892386436, -0.003799131140112877, -0.030357317999005318, -0.010650129057466984, -0.029977325350046158, 0.013629015535116196, -0.042951978743076324, -0.0753074511885643, -0.017045341432094574, 0.009414182975888252, -0.06411271542310715, 0.023395882919430733, -0.03146560117602348, -0.03784515708684921, -0.03219357505440712, 0.004276189487427473, 0.02145090326666832, 0.0243123359978199, -0.037671320140361786, -0.002062438055872917, -0.009922916069626808, 0.002394663169980049, -0.017283830791711807, -0.021669920533895493, 0.03138353303074837, 0.007963321171700954, 0.025634195655584335, 0.05846919119358063, -0.030099719762802124, -0.03463345021009445, 0.017001179978251457, 0.016318410634994507, -0.02568616159260273, -0.0023714685812592506, -0.014787555672228336, 0.02589092031121254, -0.0011541580315679312, -0.013632281683385372, 0.03209196776151657, 0.006449760869145393, -0.022664466872811317, 0.023096946999430656, -0.08525848388671875, -0.007974636740982533, -0.03947695344686508, -0.01253481674939394, -0.032211773097515106, -0.011729685589671135, -0.01840432733297348, 0.006987194996327162, 0.031518012285232544, 0.01657763496041298, -0.03539891541004181, 0.01484852097928524, 0.030518006533384323, -0.001250929431989789, -0.010629285126924515, 0.032660212367773056, 0.008402924053370953, 0.021291609853506088, 0.00759825250133872, -0.0012528313091024756, 0.07891739904880524, -0.00908120721578598, 0.0026586365420371294, 0.023242799565196037, -0.03816413879394531, 0.024224035441875458, 0.0018629786791279912, 0.0049402001313865185, -0.002582926768809557, 0.02762640453875065, 0.016571560874581337, 0.018647203221917152, 0.054740577936172485, -0.01266789436340332, -0.032663170248270035, -0.0176004096865654, 0.009345471858978271, -0.036690764129161835, -0.007740746717900038, 0.018869496881961823, 0.003576971823349595, 0.005938325077295303, -0.0055320607498288155, -0.0578036867082119, -0.04198920726776123, 0.0017910940805450082, 0.01549775805324316, -0.035509273409843445, -0.02308267541229725, -0.0546061173081398, 0.012824521400034428, -0.031301289796829224, 0.03690330684185028, 0.05139954388141632, -0.04097538813948631, 0.006698516197502613, -0.03801770135760307, -0.02073056250810623, 0.08600213378667831, 0.020215952768921852, 0.023558570072054863, 0.002562370151281357, -0.02995464764535427, 0.02346113510429859, 0.04798449948430061, -0.017595233395695686, -0.008107403293251991, -0.029865862801671028, -0.001955130835995078, 0.006568361073732376, 0.03013770654797554, 0.03210201859474182, -0.020601598545908928, 0.0004044309025630355, -0.04008449986577034, 0.00490853376686573, -0.045466624200344086, -0.0006882259622216225, -0.05642465129494667, 0.011420294642448425, -0.017058080062270164, 0.019291376695036888, 0.002673305571079254, 0.02595737762749195, 0.015616648830473423, -0.028809353709220886, -0.0018733135657384992, 0.031358640640974045, 0.07432328909635544, -0.014914455823600292, 0.02806713804602623, 0.009770541451871395, -0.044404029846191406, 0.026154620572924614, 0.04492051154375076, 0.04440097510814667, -0.042547643184661865, 0.014345541596412659, -0.029802503064274788, -0.028095709159970284, -0.058116935193538666, 0.020431075245141983, 0.032727692276239395, 0.0006862770533189178, 0.025568682700395584, 0.06378360092639923, -0.013016273267567158, 0.02231634221971035, -0.02302180603146553, 0.012749348767101765, 0.010221198201179504, 0.03465333208441734, 0.07764153927564621, -0.02570245787501335, 0.006361388601362705, 0.06497166305780411, 0.024743378162384033, 0.000552659563254565, 0.02478940039873123, -0.011657419614493847, -0.0038964091800153255, 0.007509440649300814, -0.020532170310616493, -0.006590491160750389, 0.009436145424842834, -0.03863201290369034, -0.015132393687963486, -0.022782709449529648, -0.07420242577791214, 0.026450341567397118, 0.035474956035614014, 0.0005390997393988073, 0.010913397185504436, -0.046142127364873886, -0.038835007697343826, 0.01242029294371605, 0.005071477964520454, -0.005330598447471857, 0.023594507947564125, -0.0025852203834801912, 0.052778325974941254, 0.002735395450145006, 0.03078463487327099, -0.05902063101530075, -0.04490983113646507, -0.01809176430106163, 0.0007881973288021982, -0.05019913241267204, 0.0637933611869812, -0.004548718221485615, -0.019588107243180275, -0.036060623824596405, 0.005734141916036606, -0.0027723375242203474, 0.023174433037638664, 0.052628785371780396, -0.038924239575862885, 0.043359264731407166, -0.020508555695414543, -0.000900989689398557, 0.002534297527745366, -0.03866533190011978, 0.1613159030675888, 0.0642164945602417, 0.08003982901573181, -0.0756324976682663, 0.001020722440443933, 0.0371924452483654, 0.013398675248026848, 0.01409123744815588, -0.032052427530288696, 0.009563378989696503, -0.02013787440955639, 0.026321345940232277, 0.06288853287696838, -0.001694867154583335, 0.007774381898343563, 0.05109286308288574, -0.04118399694561958, 0.002100917510688305, 0.01632024720311165, 0.006701362319290638, -0.014303857460618019, 0.010975823737680912, -0.05166172981262207, 0.016424307599663734, 0.062459513545036316, 0.008546712808310986, -0.051800455898046494, -0.010743368417024612, 0.005513006821274757, 0.01627611368894577, 0.006275681313127279, 0.025380779057741165, -0.008366045542061329, 0.011936374008655548, 0.06147924065589905, -0.03081968054175377, 0.036070942878723145, -0.0318337082862854, 0.034824881702661514, 0.05978338047862053, 0.023261290043592453, 0.04012531787157059, 0.026746682822704315, 0.013593541458249092, -0.03890753537416458, -0.04194166138768196, -0.015284829773008823, 0.019998425617814064, -0.017687037587165833, -0.01533916499465704, -0.03298623487353325, 0.0036465460434556007, -0.0097902687266469, -0.03455277532339096, -0.004326203837990761, 0.02295922115445137, 0.045835018157958984, -0.018216950818896294, -0.021203676238656044, -0.006476875394582748, 0.0028478570748120546, -0.009434549137949944, 0.044893912971019745, 0.05138067528605461, -0.03737909346818924, -0.04774098098278046, -0.02700667642056942, 0.029475394636392593, -0.02605312131345272, 0.025371748954057693, -0.0087916050106287, -0.04472648724913597, -0.01789725571870804, -0.04041652753949165, 0.00782741978764534, 0.01049482449889183, 0.00887747947126627, -0.009593459777534008, -0.004702857229858637, -0.012436329387128353, -0.034559983760118484, -0.02090872824192047, -0.010168162174522877, -0.022547004744410515, -0.013624359853565693, -0.03265302628278732, 0.019776994362473488, 0.0012063339818269014, 0.007080348674207926, 0.031143030151724815, -0.010028854943811893, 0.07738977670669556, -0.0421903170645237, -0.03587370738387108, -0.016410890966653824, 0.039277009665966034, -0.04669388756155968, -0.03623425215482712, -0.004090907517820597, 0.04874124377965927, 0.013660568743944168, 0.019228586927056313, -0.004656737204641104, 0.007009549532085657, 0.01017000898718834, -0.01748114638030529, 0.008165901526808739, -0.03951200842857361, 0.020408792421221733, -0.015247148461639881, 0.010720639489591122, -0.04393403232097626, 0.0060981204733252525, -0.01911880448460579, -0.027846740558743477, 0.03264226019382477, -0.04028930142521858, -0.06889370083808899, 0.02768389880657196, 0.01590648479759693, 0.01329737901687622, -0.024633781984448433, 0.033377546817064285, -0.015557349659502506, 0.005813115742057562, 0.007931852713227272, -0.04950578138232231, 0.0037253727205097675, 0.0008967008325271308, -0.04701314866542816, 0.015819881111383438, 0.04793548583984375, 0.004223820753395557, -0.01318351924419403, -0.015258705243468285, 0.018242262303829193, 0.037269338965415955, 0.02871447242796421, 0.01842750422656536, -0.013975221663713455, -0.024624085053801537, -0.07894489169120789, -0.05024333670735359, 0.016764719039201736, 0.014936370775103569, 0.025643931701779366, 0.011221209540963173, -0.01309099793434143, -0.013684102334082127, 0.0656549483537674, -0.029299886897206306, 0.005595050286501646, -0.011863055638968945, 0.037702448666095734, 0.0530775785446167, -0.0018685305258259177, -0.0240439772605896, -0.01907588168978691, -0.00823351088911295, -0.0009432921651750803, 0.04614713788032532, 0.014787466265261173, -0.0010068956762552261, 0.011009233072400093, -0.024410493671894073, 0.018986361101269722, -0.006223632022738457, 0.0012364076683297753, 0.01981237716972828, 0.029834363609552383, -0.03190299868583679, 0.05603092908859253, -0.021757468581199646, 0.036774855107069016, -0.0797652080655098, -0.01700950227677822, 0.02574949711561203, 0.022022776305675507, 0.04508243501186371, -0.01940295659005642, 0.02182295359671116, 0.011928649619221687, -0.04734516888856888, 0.03327931836247444, 0.0013074006419628859, 0.04452630877494812, -0.032922860234975815, 0.049798619002103806, -0.03391537815332413, 0.0044272830709815025, 0.05754651129245758, 0.014797843992710114, 0.03887828439474106, -0.019307296723127365, -0.01042223908007145, -0.03399943932890892, -0.03999081254005432, 0.009078511036932468, 0.00982485432177782, -0.031077569350600243, 0.03190271556377411, 0.002765968907624483, -0.02507897838950157, -0.003432690631598234, -0.009772357530891895, -0.0040770345367491245, 0.02457333914935589, 0.04900720342993736, -0.005531204864382744, 0.038053616881370544, -0.0359467975795269, 0.003151155775412917, -0.04258826747536659, -0.005228005349636078, -0.02025727741420269, 0.03825099766254425, -0.035336900502443314, 0.03055918589234352, 0.04229284077882767, -0.02341274544596672, -0.027765287086367607, 0.02250947616994381, -0.014212429523468018, -0.018915267661213875, -0.022524429485201836, -0.042991068214178085, 0.014839088544249535, 0.004280282184481621, 0.006171044893562794, -0.04441280663013458, 0.030387016013264656, 0.052667036652565, 0.07019728422164917, 0.03187955915927887, 0.012110792100429535, 0.009003536775708199, -0.006894972641021013, -0.034540608525276184, 0.014458682388067245, -0.01753794029355049, -0.03857498988509178, 0.004753511399030685, 0.006112697068601847, -0.018200475722551346, -0.04006218910217285, 0.035947397351264954, -0.02539994567632675, 0.04984311759471893, 0.02245604246854782, -0.009334293194115162, -0.011832465417683125, -0.028642695397138596, 0.04053378850221634, -0.05844850838184357, -0.0022009287495166063, -0.008065033704042435, 0.019370147958397865, -0.06505238264799118, 0.029840368777513504, -0.0027906547766178846, 0.041658930480480194, 0.03800108656287193, -0.01942550390958786, -0.013575454242527485, -0.020109940320253372, 0.013506555929780006, -0.0048560188151896, -0.047467462718486786, 0.053868211805820465, -0.004133573733270168, 0.011526137590408325, 0.0015778089873492718, 0.004235123749822378, 0.026669912040233612, 0.0316200852394104, -0.02807789295911789, -0.04686709865927696, 0.002352476818487048, 0.02870243601500988, 0.0060145375318825245, -0.026854975149035454, -0.001615853514522314, -0.010120878927409649, -0.023384802043437958, -0.01511051133275032, -0.000044543310650624335, 0.04009602591395378, 0.01713968627154827, -0.062042731791734695, 0.05356341600418091, -0.019148467108607292, 0.006993657443672419, 0.021268872544169426, -0.02319471538066864, 0.026887962594628334, -0.01628793217241764, 0.010919538326561451, -0.00399450259283185, -0.005340690724551678, -0.04163733497262001, -0.0026046722196042538, -0.015623541548848152, 0.04712299630045891, 0.0021070451475679874, -0.002826661104336381, -0.042052339762449265, -0.040684107691049576, 0.02420766092836857, 0.006228187587112188, -0.011250607669353485, -0.01767008751630783, -0.002122632460668683, 0.019810961559414864, -0.011739548295736313, 0.0229850634932518, 0.015732452273368835, 0.026058422401547432, -0.007458743639290333, -0.020713696256279945, -0.014335446991026402, -0.025107016786932945, -0.012668284587562084, -0.025666940957307816, 0.008909535594284534, 0.034069184213876724, -0.021318882703781128, 0.021808411926031113, -0.04781971499323845, -0.019092796370387077, -0.04914414510130882, 0.021212173625826836, -0.026604020968079567, 0.017060840502381325, -0.01066217664629221, 0.0015207582619041204, 0.012567470781505108, -0.017728643491864204, 0.048635825514793396, -0.04400103911757469, 0.03270407393574715, 0.0037965215742588043, 0.003934843931347132, 0.012563809752464294, -0.00798680167645216, -0.02246139571070671, -0.02334989234805107, 0.023822084069252014, 0.04110044613480568, 0.029169244691729546, -0.06652674078941345, 0.0001258371485164389, -0.0161264818161726, 0.05544782802462578, -0.021212471649050713, -0.05566147714853287, -0.02409324236214161, 0.03604955971240997, -0.0037369257770478725, -0.032481249421834946 ]
<p>For an application I'm working on, I need to go from some uniformly distributed variables to an uniform distribution on an n-sphere. The standard way to do this seems to be choose (n+1) normal distributed variables, and then divide by the norm.</p> <p>However, I need to be able to, given a point on the sphere, extract the uniform values I would have used to get this point. There the standard method fails, at it is not injective. I think I have devised a way to do this, however, but would like someone with more statistical knowledge than me to confirm this. Or if anyone knows of an easier way to do it, that's also appreciated.</p> <p>Now, here's the idea:</p> <p>Let $x_1, \ldots, x_n$ be cartesian coordinates for $\mathbb{R}^n$, and choose spherical coordinates given as in the Wikipedia article for an <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-sphere" rel="nofollow">n-sphere</a>, i.e.</p> <p>$\begin{align} x_1 &amp;= r\cos\phi_1 \\ x_2 &amp;= r\sin\phi_1\cos\phi_2\\ x_3 &amp;= r\sin\phi_1\sin\phi_2\cos\phi_3\\ &amp;\qquad\vdots\\ x_{n-1} &amp;= r\sin\phi_1\ldots\sin\phi_{n-2}\cos\phi_{n-1}\\ x_n &amp;= r\sin\phi_1\ldots\sin\phi_{n-1} \end{align}$</p> <p>The volume element of an (n-1)-sphere of radius r is</p> <p>$\mathrm{d}V = r^{n-1}sin^{n-2}\phi_1\sin^{n-3}\phi_2\ldots\sin\phi_{n-2} \mathrm{d}\phi_1\mathrm{d}\phi_2\ldots\mathrm{d}\phi_{n-1}.$</p> <p>If we compute $\mathrm{d}x_i$ and $\mathrm{d}x_1\mathrm{d}x_2\ldots\mathrm{d}x_{n-2}$ I think we get that</p> <p>$\mathrm{d}V = (-1)^nr\mathrm{d}x_1\ldots\mathrm{d}x_{n-2}\mathrm{d}\phi_{n-1}.$</p> <p>I am then of the belief (and this is what I want confirmed by someone "in the know") that to choose points uniformly on the sphere, we can choose points $x_1, \ldots, x_{n-2}$ uniformly on the ball $x_1^2+\ldots x_{n-2}^2 \leq r^2$ and choose $\phi_{n-1}$ uniformly from $[0,2\pi)$.</p> <p>If we can, we have reduced the problem to finding points uniformly on a (n-2)-ball. This can be done by choosing points uniformly on the boundary and multiplying by $u^{1/(n-2)}$, where $u$ is uniformly chosen from $[0,1]$. Choosing points uniformly on the boundary is the same as choosing points uniformly on an $n-3$-sphere, and we're back to the original problem, but now 2 dimensions lower. We can work our way down to either the 1-sphere or the 1-ball, where we can choose a point uniformly with no problem.</p>
74,517
[ -0.035316724330186844, 0.013758602552115917, -0.007258736994117498, -0.04796780273318291, -0.008362474851310253, -0.028700707480311394, -0.04379953071475029, -0.022101733833551407, 0.05083809047937393, -0.07244055718183517, 0.03751793131232262, 0.015501612797379494, 0.07201065123081207, 0.02909088507294655, 0.0005775599856860936, 0.009043087251484394, -0.002055078512057662, -0.0045592766255140305, -0.02940938249230385, -0.04614707827568054, 0.01609816402196884, 0.029712669551372528, -0.01126358937472105, -0.03338126093149185, 0.0036681892815977335, 0.05039922520518303, 0.021487146615982056, -0.048183392733335495, -0.022589681670069695, 0.05970010161399841, -0.05074600502848625, -0.02537907287478447, 0.04277987778186798, 0.05594382807612419, 0.017237210646271706, 0.03733576461672783, -0.0036417243536561728, -0.004596854094415903, -0.00871081743389368, -0.0034480025060474873, -0.06064116954803467, 0.009474016726016998, -0.03466592729091644, 0.06386993825435638, -0.002170031424611807, 0.039031609892845154, -0.00586157850921154, -0.03926113247871399, -0.008698554709553719, -0.0726449266076088, 0.12629951536655426, 0.02486489526927471, 0.015986459329724312, -0.0022969087585806847, -0.016904376447200775, -0.024843724444508553, 0.05457603186368942, 0.024792632088065147, 0.02602127566933632, -0.041928187012672424, 0.023789262399077415, -0.03109465166926384, -0.05636660382151604, -0.0341416671872139, 0.014449724927544594, -0.03989195451140404, 0.024343334138393402, 0.0023275157436728477, 0.016902530565857887, -0.03730590268969536, 0.016039080917835236, 0.005634373519569635, 0.023450031876564026, -0.04508272185921669, -0.0024070153012871742, 0.011277655139565468, 0.002480151131749153, -0.03073413483798504, 0.029961921274662018, -0.008880723267793655, -0.016748514026403427, 0.014035186730325222, 0.03839675337076187, 0.04480835795402527, -0.014138719998300076, -0.01712629199028015, 0.042884960770606995, -0.04017054662108421, 0.018293190747499466, 0.04517937824130058, -0.01223691925406456, -0.02809923328459263, 0.044743068516254425, -0.004221423529088497, -0.03189811110496521, 0.04074803367257118, -0.032013487070798874, 0.01275385171175003, -0.01168231200426817, -0.03676997870206833, -0.028564197942614555, -0.04182884842157364, 0.013574808835983276, 0.06608279049396515, 0.0011367317056283355, -0.015068558976054192, -0.008150053210556507, -0.030408188700675964, 0.023356588557362556, 0.004928844980895519, -0.05802391842007637, 0.04664153605699539, -0.018475037068128586, -0.0002765496028587222, 0.04869464039802551, -0.017485840246081352, -0.016867514699697495, -0.0273065734654665, 0.03734653815627098, 0.06438101083040237, 0.021073071286082268, -0.006733509246259928, 0.03718963637948036, -0.03791000694036484, -0.05240326002240181, 0.001492086099460721, 0.022374998778104782, 0.03969843313097954, -0.016260642558336258, 0.03031306341290474, 0.025093479081988335, -0.023925667628645897, 0.033452339470386505, 0.011316330172121525, -0.004059236962348223, -0.007891222834587097, -0.10492227226495743, -0.03507998213171959, 0.024366475641727448, 0.008365890011191368, 0.032972175627946854, -0.04063241556286812, 0.04758205637335777, 0.04065127670764923, 0.021330462768673897, 0.04196056351065636, 0.02340652234852314, 0.003847464919090271, 0.06673208624124527, -0.024652695283293724, -0.007686206139624119, -0.011859241873025894, -0.010889830999076366, -0.05801572650671005, 0.005819844547659159, -0.04026256501674652, 0.09009820967912674, 0.008491641841828823, 0.02139599248766899, 0.0026535214856266975, 0.05382276326417923, 0.003087783930823207, 0.02690199390053749, -0.003181514795869589, 0.01927107945084572, -0.015275365673005581, 0.041178736835718155, 0.005194193683564663, 0.004244662821292877, 0.0421733483672142, -0.047739166766405106, 0.012417647987604141, -0.003744940273463726, 0.07156150043010712, 0.04636840522289276, -0.027080025523900986, 0.014436311088502407, -0.033844225108623505, 0.027820732444524765, -0.0008745259256102145, -0.0196741484105587, 0.010239076800644398, 0.016938647255301476, -0.0012805946171283722, 0.01854012906551361, 0.021085325628519058, 0.028009211644530296, -0.005098823923617601, 0.017897017300128937, -0.04549393802881241, 0.028094260022044182, -0.017141271382570267, 0.007356470916420221, 0.009803838096559048, -0.06500893831253052, 0.050568509846925735, 0.016801785677671432, 0.01998692750930786, 0.013114385306835175, -0.006269431207329035, -0.03355924412608147, -0.011843455955386162, 0.04383118078112602, -0.05805278569459915, 0.03036041371524334, 0.06813626736402512, 0.034106817096471786, 0.017412826418876648, 0.010805757716298103, -0.0323837548494339, -0.0074124992825090885, -0.03410348296165466, -0.026996856555342674, 0.026586193591356277, 0.030131161212921143, 0.01832818239927292, 0.023124337196350098, 0.011271447874605656, -0.016716498881578445, 0.0052570472471416, -0.05928175896406174, 0.04671582952141762, 0.033116575330495834, 0.0008154452661983669, -0.012522147037088871, 0.003602602519094944, 0.015504548326134682, 0.0002640689199324697, 0.0238532405346632, -0.021391773596405983, -0.021458003669977188, 0.0008684989879839122, 0.02214835397899151, 0.040225572884082794, -0.031124701723456383, -0.022930925711989403, 0.06260889023542404, 0.028685888275504112, 0.05498994514346123, 0.013816719874739647, 0.01314621977508068, -0.04045441001653671, 0.015334907919168472, 0.0004728111089207232, 0.03295447304844856, 0.021628517657518387, 0.004420580342411995, 0.01902400702238083, 0.05051325261592865, 0.014111407101154327, -0.007937796413898468, 0.027750151231884956, 0.00230345013551414, -0.025830531492829323, -0.000837537576444447, 0.044120900332927704, 0.008612341247498989, 0.0005277555319480598, 0.0038094844203442335, 0.03069429099559784, 0.027386175468564034, -0.014245697297155857, -0.02170739322900772, 0.0005898904055356979, 0.03145015612244606, 0.042635880410671234, 0.013963109813630581, 0.03525983542203903, 0.008834888227283955, -0.05655166134238243, -0.0020415508188307285, -0.007746026385575533, -0.01638437621295452, -0.029272528365254402, 0.005999880842864513, -0.02101961150765419, 0.01603798381984234, -0.054803770035505295, -0.011993066407740116, 0.017614820972085, -0.022941624745726585, 0.037865396589040756, -0.0005712748388759792, 0.03299460932612419, -0.044873107224702835, -0.0063598607666790485, -0.0012650425778701901, -0.001007055165246129, 0.013299604877829552, -0.005859242752194405, -0.01607331447303295, 0.04969760775566101, 0.00817260891199112, -0.07554969191551208, -0.00514152692630887, -0.005130478646606207, 0.029020139947533607, -0.03360683470964432, -0.002902122214436531, 0.04430355131626129, 0.028073623776435852, -0.059321507811546326, -0.0018318367656320333, -0.04101692512631416, -0.03286365792155266, -0.04484584182500839, -0.005647451151162386, 0.021564006805419922, -0.024736199527978897, 0.02130991220474243, 0.060853466391563416, -0.0015884144231677055, -0.015206045471131802, -0.05532706156373024, -0.06471876800060272, -0.004069002345204353, 0.00809211004525423, 0.04154898226261139, 0.010882957838475704, -0.036964301019907, 0.0933905690908432, 0.00832573976367712, -0.027663711458444595, 0.01079835556447506, 0.04189731925725937, -0.005329023580998182, -0.0001196650555357337, 0.014461307786405087, 0.008708769455552101, -0.005634433589875698, 0.005394567735493183, 0.016270259395241737, 0.007671622559428215, 0.03463909775018692, 0.01060548610985279, 0.0061157564632594585, 0.044621217995882034, 0.005658709444105625, -0.013536963611841202, 0.056997306644916534, -0.00044080064981244504, -0.030630819499492645, -0.0220242477953434, -0.019246220588684082, 0.01809893548488617, -0.0033252197317779064, -0.05534106865525246, -0.01959306187927723, -0.017851615324616432, 0.014604801312088966, 0.016689864918589592, 0.0064494069665670395, 0.018617428839206696, -0.051029060035943985, -0.014993449673056602, 0.05174641311168671, 0.03900459408760071, -0.024315526708960533, -0.025738753378391266, 0.047556351870298386, 0.03513156995177269, -0.0143304243683815, 0.02250347100198269, -0.021621406078338623, 0.018579702824354172, 0.037462297827005386, -0.023643385618925095, 0.017513571307063103, 0.006299906875938177, 0.014447858557105064, 0.019658846780657768, -0.004455741960555315, -0.0075281900353729725, -0.0019341838778927922, -0.02972041442990303, 0.03931086137890816, -0.03151009976863861, 0.031310517340898514, 0.009318197146058083, 0.07796870172023773, 0.008446098305284977, -0.004251881968230009, -0.013850059360265732, -0.0150434086099267, -0.05249418690800667, 0.005687208380550146, 0.010509053245186806, 0.0007078085327520967, -0.03092089667916298, -0.02529233880341053, 0.013782965019345284, 0.016900338232517242, -0.015666376799345016, 0.0037065043579787016, -0.01070332620292902, -0.05543934181332588, 0.013485735282301903, -0.018900705501437187, -0.03084033541381359, -0.028190674260258675, 0.06318202614784241, 0.03684668242931366, -0.05715184658765793, 0.048784349113702774, 0.023779479786753654, -0.011751361191272736, -0.0032340157777071, -0.010245773941278458, 0.02989848144352436, 0.011366257444024086, 0.011203193105757236, -0.04320086911320686, 0.047082338482141495, 0.03889467194676399, 0.00024879726697690785, -0.057863812893629074, 0.057002581655979156, 0.039618246257305145, 0.01635918952524662, -0.0048314351588487625, -0.0431867353618145, -0.01064256764948368, 0.024952445179224014, 0.0465068444609642, -0.014557492919266224, 0.01507139764726162, 0.054938800632953644, -0.029105616733431816, -0.015771307051181793, 0.0006958080921322107, 0.04018951207399368, -0.00832809042185545, -0.018986675888299942, -0.016249381005764008, -0.008853588253259659, 0.01577109657227993, -0.012414205819368362, 0.022635051980614662, 0.004796716384589672, -0.03209126740694046, -0.020803505554795265, 0.041550375521183014, 0.017789509147405624, 0.01217967364937067, -0.023564884439110756, 0.0009065123158507049, 0.027517862617969513, 0.0021599745377898216, -0.028252827003598213, 0.031815238296985626, 0.02583494409918785, 0.048108600080013275, 0.03503769636154175, 0.00869673490524292, -0.06705513596534729, -0.0026611860375851393, 0.013837904669344425, 0.0037222804967314005, 0.00031952650169841945, 0.0013992503518238664, -0.04622725024819374, -0.025602662935853004, 0.04446790739893913, -0.025835486128926277, 0.014732453972101212, -0.0034183270763605833, -0.008417340926826, -0.0064716762863099575, -0.06374286115169525, -0.06737761944532394, 0.002308174967765808, -0.035410523414611816, 0.008841544389724731, -0.026566825807094574, -0.005400465801358223, -0.03590264171361923, 0.01909247599542141, 0.002032991498708725, 0.07998291403055191, 0.007251611445099115, -0.02357705682516098, 0.0033691171556711197, 0.04088732600212097, 0.013729098252952099, -0.053662966936826706, 0.060869816690683365, 0.04745331034064293, -0.018064431846141815, 0.043717559427022934, -0.011550601571798325, -0.056106895208358765, 0.029760636389255524, -0.014175605028867722, 0.02481170743703842, 0.05998613312840462, -0.023541076108813286, 0.05401740223169327, 0.01119193434715271, -0.010567973367869854, 0.049356088042259216, 0.03346052020788193, 0.012342121452093124, -0.027150800451636314, -0.04481510818004608, 0.004870428238064051, -0.02067776396870613, -0.044283900409936905, -0.0048071532510221004, 0.010265707038342953, 0.000738643342629075, 0.016781827434897423, 0.008819037117064, 0.02721787616610527, -0.025582635775208473, -0.0004020004125777632, 0.03448034077882767, 0.019017698243260384, 0.015924490988254547, 0.012135980650782585, 0.016701800748705864, -0.003010947722941637, 0.02185402251780033, -0.03042391873896122, 0.022143302485346794, -0.03412464261054993, 0.030078932642936707, -0.01416998915374279, -0.0323718897998333, -0.008013435639441013, -0.02860858105123043, -0.007466163951903582, -0.000010195831237069797, -0.05980033427476883, 0.07065169513225555, -0.002101949183270335, 0.056641288101673126, 0.006146668456494808, -0.03093545511364937, 0.00024148717056959867, 0.013974976725876331, -0.009114503860473633, 0.015886206179857254, -0.021640729159116745, -0.022459786385297775, 0.0018999158637598157, 0.043883852660655975, -0.04605188965797424, -0.03727509081363678, 0.03038560226559639, -0.014958961866796017, -0.010414088144898415, -0.04860265925526619, 0.0201558917760849, -0.010160339064896107, -0.015751374885439873, -0.01289469376206398, 0.018371639773249626, -0.04207126423716545, 0.004235500935465097, -0.017010604962706566, 0.047127824276685715, 0.05406033992767334, -0.04262673109769821, -0.03597032651305199, 0.02665420062839985, 0.0124133862555027, -0.008674721233546734, 0.008574262261390686, -0.006080678664147854, -0.026618825271725655, -0.0089672626927495, -0.0004214710497763008, -0.032744426280260086, -0.009226453490555286, -0.03313402831554413, -0.04208045452833176, 0.00039178464794531465, -0.03313007950782776, 0.010734942741692066, -0.009065181948244572, -0.04317815974354744, 0.011318616569042206, -0.01709158346056938, -0.06843549013137817, 0.011964856646955013, -0.012971179559826851, 0.02089574746787548, 0.020604584366083145, -0.024634886533021927, 0.049905095249414444, -0.004793462343513966, 0.027101321145892143, -0.0011970960767939687, 0.0011054594069719315, 0.0357065349817276, 0.032966963946819305, 0.010946506634354591, -0.006745138205587864, -0.030736109241843224, 0.008642197586596012, -0.01805177889764309, -0.03989603370428085, -0.020864006131887436, -0.0627240538597107, 0.022459562867879868, 0.04438057914376259, 0.0005230826209299266, 0.04166027531027794, 0.04701793193817139, -0.010107645764946938, -0.024937966838479042, -0.01854579895734787, -0.016984645277261734, 0.014695967547595501, -0.018393969163298607, 0.05786794051527977, -0.012895748019218445, 0.007531594485044479, -0.01107492670416832, 0.0206100232899189, -0.018683891743421555, 0.0818190723657608, -0.04468840733170509, 0.0018977632280439138, 0.03474575653672218, -0.03463934734463692, -0.043698180466890335, 0.028635429218411446, -0.055167797952890396, 0.03406333923339844, -0.004201591946184635, 0.0004284679307602346, 0.01192040927708149, 0.010710367001593113, 0.014559928327798843, -0.03614577651023865, -0.04409090802073479, -0.0015202639624476433, 0.02554282546043396, 0.04503340274095535, -0.03442639485001564, -0.03354458510875702, -0.00784911960363388, 0.04984962195158005, -0.019869137555360794, 0.012869312427937984, -0.038273025304079056, -0.06067953258752823, 0.010288288816809654, -0.04360223561525345, -0.052033036947250366, 0.05045963078737259, 0.007683920208364725, -0.00017412440502084792, 0.012720083817839622, 0.0082044443115592, 0.012284628115594387, 0.020538853481411934, 0.00839382503181696, -0.04613208770751953, 0.0927819013595581, -0.00036597848520614207, -0.0006698790239170194, -0.03829338029026985, 0.00001195751246996224, 0.12728115916252136, 0.045032650232315063, 0.02308034524321556, -0.026605036109685898, -0.023258090019226074, -0.010367237031459808, -0.0016774291871115565, -0.0399811826646328, -0.03181050717830658, -0.008612026460468769, -0.026013009250164032, -0.002152061788365245, 0.03692387044429779, -0.0037267315201461315, 0.004879535175859928, 0.015637479722499847, -0.03903133422136307, -0.014369241893291473, -0.031132999807596207, 0.0473584346473217, -0.018000101670622826, 0.029954975470900536, -0.04353484511375427, 0.0716097503900528, -0.02550566755235195, -0.0501350499689579, -0.06267345696687698, 0.0061338902451097965, 0.015725839883089066, 0.012261290103197098, -0.03197159245610237, 0.010769098997116089, -0.011890214867889881, -0.026102280244231224, 0.02324409782886505, 0.0032222268637269735, 0.016619013622403145, -0.03926628828048706, 0.01709752343595028, 0.011321854777634144, 0.003658231347799301, 0.005503660533577204, 0.0004139643569942564, 0.0056580533273518085, -0.049301814287900925, -0.025366151705384254, -0.04608919844031334, 0.057277433574199677, -0.04306209087371826, -0.007458400912582874, -0.04241326451301575, 0.022452743723988533, 0.02147557958960533, -0.05102198198437691, -0.012853063642978668, 0.010258828289806843, 0.01462078932672739, -0.012966111302375793, -0.005218151491135359, 0.023041177541017532, 0.007605248596519232, 0.011729015037417412, 0.0346231572329998, -0.028976233676075935, -0.017017154023051262, -0.014307820238173008, -0.014059625566005707, 0.05582220107316971, -0.024058882147073746, -0.03858020901679993, -0.04936954379081726, -0.00040337370592169464, -0.016901589930057526, -0.0056050983257591724, -0.007038405165076256, -0.03152666985988617, 0.04753489792346954, 0.006286421790719032, 0.009035198949277401, 0.0016657207161188126, -0.0387430377304554, 0.00040362629806622863, -0.033929962664842606, -0.029141608625650406, -0.03014853596687317, -0.012193956412374973, 0.0008452372858300805, 0.04626297950744629, 0.03717789798974991, -0.005116522312164307, 0.0002983469457831234, 0.04287896677851677, 0.06788982450962067, -0.03975854068994522, -0.028681624680757523, 0.0195617638528347, -0.05924329161643982, 0.004572913981974125, -0.01150613185018301, 0.039449915289878845, 0.053666699677705765, 0.025204481557011604, 0.021749362349510193, 0.04179096594452858, -0.0058862981386482716, 0.000340642494847998, 0.0015048942295834422, -0.06187736988067627, 0.04466506093740463, 0.012532256543636322, 0.011831347830593586, -0.0401291698217392, 0.0205864105373621, 0.007518752012401819, -0.018463706597685814, -0.019868630915880203, -0.045938216149806976, -0.0063859992660582066, -0.012728162109851837, -0.03811044245958328, 0.024750465527176857, 0.011029185727238655, -0.0038535348139703274, 0.03312192112207413, -0.013173148036003113, -0.030847791582345963, 0.03759700804948807, -0.03397933393716812, 0.04703601449728012, -0.02224368415772915, 0.01420286763459444, 0.03319378197193146, -0.008401853032410145, 0.03945475071668625, -0.033127497881650925, 0.00032817196915857494, -0.01848088577389717, 0.031232306733727455, -0.003666577162221074, -0.054620254784822464, 0.00443566869944334, -0.020749367773532867, -0.021778902038931847, 0.013204677030444145, 0.010817110538482666, 0.053753409534692764, 0.031671393662691116, -0.024210112169384956, -0.04235200583934784, 0.052776772528886795, -0.01976296864449978, -0.028727352619171143, -0.007812247145920992, -0.002375307958573103, 0.006130701396614313, -0.013851120136678219, 0.03195788711309433, -0.034793756902217865, -0.004892437718808651, 0.015509330667555332, 0.01523443590849638, -0.013707934878766537, 0.008011803962290287, 0.034940194338560104, 0.0018444469897076488, -0.013292355462908745, 0.012882593087852001, 0.015401378273963928, 0.05974604934453964, 0.03986517712473869, -0.03899592533707619, 0.028043771162629128, 0.045519325882196426, -0.0019161500968039036, -0.07405748963356018, -0.042686156928539276, 0.030346928164362907, -0.0038680622819811106, 0.029749274253845215, -0.07448891550302505, -0.004490003455430269, 0.005949133541435003, -0.09484634548425674, 0.02736886776983738, -0.002090109745040536, -0.011592535302042961, -0.05586133152246475, 0.004572688136249781, -0.015017342753708363, -0.00979915726929903, -0.017402680590748787, 0.03496615216135979, 0.0049508740194141865, 0.055182844400405884, -0.04232756048440933, -0.040305640548467636, -0.015427649952471256, 0.00974432472139597, 0.029392631724476814, -0.04532274603843689, 0.01598789170384407, -0.034568365663290024, -0.004238337278366089, 0.011668571271002293, -0.02328951470553875, 0.01562015525996685, -0.01959179900586605, 0.013703403063118458, 0.00833318941295147, 0.00677277659997344, 0.025479992851614952, 0.03452763706445694, 0.007581119425594807, -0.027092786505818367, 0.08169136196374893, -0.019011033698916435, -0.044529061764478683, -0.0236640814691782, 0.05629384517669678, -0.015971511602401733, -0.020197978243231773, 0.027982644736766815, -0.007265814114362001, 0.003188778879120946, 0.018274489790201187, -0.04445068910717964, 0.011515011079609394, -0.029175516217947006, 0.002208014251664281, -0.051956359297037125, -0.028098350390791893, 0.021738732233643532, -0.0052092112600803375, 0.011729879304766655, -0.0009480237495154142, -0.037962306290864944, -0.062357109040021896, 0.02498217485845089, 0.015191285870969296, 0.01847872883081436, -0.06402552872896194, -0.007025004830211401, 0.009081150405108929, -0.011137256398797035, 0.0016702329739928246, -0.0013932650908827782, -0.03306682035326958, 0.007125306874513626, 0.041756268590688705, 0.0031933533027768135, -0.003002696903422475, -0.01566203497350216, -0.010356267914175987, -0.06240234151482582, 0.028828447684645653, 0.01715310662984848, -0.01151216495782137, -0.005589371081441641, 0.009903939440846443, -0.005415621213614941, 0.032062727957963943, 0.04768585041165352, 0.05394556745886803, 0.013701279647648335, 0.015291813760995865, 0.01799049600958824, 0.06682698428630829, -0.0675971657037735, 0.03748653456568718, -0.014725758694112301, -0.024066200479865074, -0.005007389932870865, 0.003217658493667841, 0.004434541799128056, 0.020700126886367798, -0.0073356288485229015, -0.022003788501024246, -0.01819031499326229, -0.0014630187069997191, -0.022628184407949448, 0.0037255054339766502, -0.026997672393918037, -0.027716584503650665, 0.015531362034380436, -0.036314111202955246, -0.009212839417159557, 0.021400364115834236, 0.012264933437108994, -0.04479692876338959, -0.010276665911078453, -0.05852150917053223, -0.05380845069885254, -0.011701392009854317, 0.008208277635276318, 0.014912168495357037, -0.03668922185897827, -0.0052784513682127, 0.040951408445835114, -0.05083329603075981, -0.008442831225693226, 0.05655313655734062, -0.03832889348268509, 0.045666519552469254, 0.013635124079883099, 0.010342806577682495, 0.007930663414299488, -0.0322837233543396, 0.036383286118507385, 0.009920408017933369, 0.039569251239299774, -0.023096077144145966, -0.02021944522857666, 0.011648371815681458, 0.0007696643588133156, 0.047211386263370514, 0.00045015112846158445, 0.07626444101333618, -0.010420609265565872, 0.016858497634530067, 0.01023921463638544, -0.017193693667650223, 0.010058928281068802, 0.013441873714327812, -0.006472758483141661, 0.04447462782263756, 0.026170725002884865, -0.006299425847828388, -0.03303578868508339, 0.031306225806474686, -0.008082845248281956, 0.02178346924483776, -0.00560755655169487, 0.053311269730329514, -0.013029908761382103, 0.008895528502762318, -0.035899169743061066, 0.0019940517377108335, 0.01823396608233452, -0.017577357590198517, 0.021266788244247437, 0.029633071273565292, 0.0371088944375515, 0.013398334383964539, -0.034301646053791046, -0.015676138922572136, -0.023770475760102272, 0.015054944902658463, 0.02693895809352398, 0.027135109528899193, -0.012532609514892101, 0.008042961359024048, -0.038280829787254333, 0.04620414972305298, -0.037410181015729904, -0.05230538919568062, -0.010253854095935822, 0.01221632119268179, -0.00933475885540247, 0.0200392697006464 ]
<p>$X_{1}$ and $X_{2}$ are independent, chi-square distributed random variables. I've managed to show that $Z=X_{1}+X_{2}$ is independent of $\frac{X_{1}}{Z}$. How do I conclude then that $Z=X_{1}+X_{2}$ is independent of $(\frac{X_{1}}{Z},\frac{X_{2}}{Z})$? </p>
37,421
[ 0.011286909691989422, -0.030446814373135567, -0.009311903268098831, 0.01264469139277935, 0.03495347127318382, 0.030060237273573875, -0.011938785202801228, -0.009344099089503288, 0.023231832310557365, -0.035174909979104996, 0.05580157786607742, 0.028248781338334084, 0.05896727740764618, 0.0019795510452240705, 0.05004427954554558, -0.0163820032030344, -0.03952151536941528, 0.021876294165849686, -0.0058218068443238735, -0.01314025279134512, -0.014247145503759384, 0.021643077954649925, 0.0482013076543808, -0.0030714895110577345, -0.038708847016096115, 0.05118643492460251, 0.005509885028004646, -0.011386029422283173, 0.005927314516156912, 0.06850490719079971, -0.0009887765627354383, -0.03160978481173515, 0.025804705917835236, 0.03222012147307396, -0.0007708609336987138, -0.017120759934186935, -0.017380621284246445, -0.00022719915432389826, 0.01095846388489008, 0.022278837859630585, -0.05027953162789345, -0.010452735237777233, -0.0027336832135915756, 0.015569239854812622, -0.05443700775504112, -0.007768233772367239, 0.008511320687830448, -0.06971028447151184, 0.047121115028858185, -0.026510264724493027, 0.07918471097946167, -0.017504481598734856, 0.06259266287088394, 0.04759710654616356, 0.004070772789418697, -0.03313702344894409, 0.028408600017428398, 0.05340797081589699, 0.0142141655087471, -0.0402718223631382, 0.011123836040496826, -0.02985331602394581, -0.02758081816136837, -0.03466663882136345, -0.056401435285806656, 0.00577134545892477, 0.002711562206968665, -0.02825874276459217, 0.003938058391213417, -0.023558178916573524, 0.0018479310674592853, 0.04495486244559288, 0.05091202259063721, -0.022357886657118797, -0.022646430879831314, -0.021198883652687073, 0.04143465682864189, 0.03635304048657417, 0.025212185457348824, -0.0049629658460617065, 0.005116595420986414, 0.008162095211446285, 0.033964112401008606, 0.02672320231795311, -0.0029416244942694902, -0.009689906612038612, 0.07123102992773056, -0.0018079133005812764, 0.00037108943797647953, 0.019524693489074707, -0.0054802075028419495, 0.018934758380055428, 0.03326534107327461, 0.003696927335113287, -0.04242931678891182, 0.040967900305986404, -0.048272617161273956, 0.03616287186741829, -0.008092246949672699, -0.03754832223057747, 0.0009268301073461771, -0.02458891272544861, 0.01627444475889206, 0.0749199166893959, -0.06898114085197449, 0.002867742907255888, -0.0289662666618824, 0.041742514818906784, -0.02590044215321541, -0.03762616589665413, -0.02253860794007778, 0.028587406501173973, -0.010925532318651676, -0.015865106135606766, 0.014897996559739113, -0.011924364604055882, -0.030187439173460007, -0.010176852345466614, 0.0309850312769413, 0.07389511913061142, 0.05556575208902359, -0.048275455832481384, 0.00397763354703784, 0.006718335207551718, -0.013390431180596352, 0.02449246309697628, -0.005004568956792355, -0.0010685286251828074, -0.05282537266612053, 0.060640737414360046, 0.01649988628923893, -0.011417051777243614, -0.022184988483786583, 0.036493588238954544, -0.0005173356039449573, 0.0012673874152824283, -0.059939634054899216, -0.01890701614320278, 0.03986320272088051, -0.06224032863974571, -0.004373450297862291, -0.08905602246522903, 0.007828040979802608, 0.06363474577665329, 0.10747267305850983, -0.00922288279980421, 0.01824374310672283, 0.003704506205394864, 0.016029704362154007, 0.01822931133210659, -0.041140008717775345, -0.06538041681051254, -0.027928221970796585, -0.0255793035030365, 0.020968006923794746, -0.022543368861079216, 0.04934705048799515, -0.01010353583842516, -0.03408393636345863, -0.030833646655082703, 0.03368068113923073, 0.017430657520890236, -0.00339128146879375, 0.012886954471468925, 0.036790862679481506, -0.019319048151373863, 0.08160287886857986, 0.008174535818397999, 0.015171878971159458, 0.03748592361807823, -0.0028821835294365883, 0.008133325725793839, 0.014323060400784016, 0.05231301859021187, 0.03356585279107094, 0.004048701375722885, -0.041763659566640854, 0.0020231695380061865, 0.008600990287959576, 0.02095712721347809, -0.05513888597488403, -0.006102222017943859, -0.0295596681535244, 0.019425470381975174, 0.002656525932252407, 0.052358292043209076, 0.027069641277194023, -0.018502429127693176, 0.023312365636229515, 0.001139301573857665, 0.013191776350140572, -0.06353830546140671, 0.0084886085242033, 0.03157883137464523, -0.02518104948103428, 0.005995876621454954, 0.012521691620349884, 0.014991139061748981, -0.019568907096982002, -0.04407435283064842, -0.003363615134730935, 0.0008825455443002284, 0.021557573229074478, -0.044871509075164795, 0.012014255858957767, 0.042343106120824814, 0.06614692509174347, 0.0030604139901697636, 0.062389981001615524, -0.014825820922851562, -0.009479301050305367, 0.027781181037425995, -0.013306832872331142, -0.00972339604049921, -0.03107781708240509, 0.011503317393362522, 0.014369865879416466, 0.002098996890708804, -0.010321935638785362, 0.04562811180949211, -0.05195130035281181, 0.039842717349529266, 0.03626227751374245, 0.021528666839003563, -0.015380831435322762, -0.000366016203770414, 0.02377568930387497, 0.02242179401218891, -0.017839284613728523, -0.023003553971648216, -0.07940574735403061, -0.015237592160701752, 0.04975000023841858, 0.009413170628249645, -0.04498033598065376, -0.001014859532006085, 0.040269386023283005, 0.050954513251781464, 0.0208590105175972, 0.04410114511847496, -0.027779240161180496, -0.004349761642515659, 0.00035036608460359275, 0.011098594404757023, 0.00945983175188303, -0.0024128248915076256, 0.020913641899824142, 0.009000956080853939, -0.009183593094348907, 0.017346860840916634, -0.030430173501372337, 0.04776492714881897, -0.026398777961730957, 0.007767379283905029, -0.008171363733708858, -0.036995213478803635, 0.03268812596797943, 0.0014655408449470997, 0.0021133923437446356, 0.027924614027142525, 0.035631269216537476, -0.031513359397649765, -0.015148485079407692, 0.009335391223430634, 0.006219773553311825, -0.0021298963110893965, -0.09046947211027145, 0.015059432946145535, 0.015514981001615524, 0.0031027833465486765, -0.005764676257967949, -0.01821001246571541, -0.03883839398622513, -0.0013521704822778702, -0.012479460798203945, 0.01895669288933277, 0.007182606961578131, 0.010934178717434406, 0.014331303536891937, -0.05164040997624397, 0.0016217895317822695, -0.03673338517546654, 0.028835080564022064, 0.015057293698191643, -0.026349127292633057, 0.0035409284755587578, -0.018060939386487007, -0.008547797799110413, 0.025797229260206223, 0.005409617442637682, 0.026285208761692047, 0.010287607088685036, -0.007142135873436928, -0.048190634697675705, 0.004012421239167452, -0.04702647402882576, 0.035284895449876785, -0.061820078641176224, 0.0076987543143332005, 0.04573225975036621, 0.024940982460975647, -0.033042531460523605, 0.0345672145485878, -0.036715295165777206, -0.033721886575222015, -0.008210173808038235, 0.0026031858287751675, 0.03993377834558487, -0.014600313268601894, 0.045818258076906204, 0.013507978990674019, -0.013078373856842518, 0.012758370488882065, -0.06005890667438507, -0.0558723583817482, 0.009441752918064594, 0.017314398661255836, 0.020573817193508148, 0.009367598220705986, -0.021835383027791977, 0.03227744624018669, 0.011234457604587078, -0.015890995040535927, 0.0022792043164372444, 0.01244029588997364, -0.004952636081725359, -0.06295952945947647, 0.012965047731995583, 0.019283892586827278, -0.007367781829088926, 0.040933698415756226, 0.02728225849568844, -0.002990740817040205, 0.0784471184015274, -0.002857198705896735, 0.018660984933376312, -0.0010432387934997678, 0.0026083062402904034, -0.001927947043441236, 0.00891776941716671, 0.012060947716236115, -0.04061557352542877, -0.009831107221543789, 0.05400712788105011, 0.03791090101003647, 0.011170241981744766, -0.04257027804851532, 0.026615986600518227, -0.0230945385992527, 0.021345777437090874, -0.03445682302117348, 0.08374880999326706, 0.042118459939956665, -0.015366352163255215, 0.024019913747906685, -0.01844927668571472, 0.03820328414440155, -0.04649018123745918, 0.032588694244623184, 0.0373578742146492, 0.0023448194842785597, -0.008180112577974796, -0.0239301435649395, -0.04636361077427864, -0.00008105181768769398, 0.04479296877980232, -0.019516395404934883, -0.013851272873580456, 0.02746005728840828, 0.02742440067231655, 0.014845805242657661, -0.015552236698567867, -0.027002638205885887, 0.04343771934509277, -0.09716122597455978, 0.004128413740545511, -0.017847461625933647, 0.0398377999663353, 0.009476917795836926, 0.08571862429380417, -0.006871343124657869, -0.023485755547881126, 0.007406360004097223, -0.012762423604726791, -0.0737699568271637, 0.027401261031627655, -0.01916697435081005, -0.031120436266064644, -0.002890851814299822, -0.04986407607793808, 0.01082553993910551, -0.025874534621834755, 0.013521631248295307, -0.006992769427597523, -0.03365703299641609, -0.023293156176805496, 0.0064630634151399136, -0.05064525827765465, -0.031225817278027534, 0.0063125332817435265, 0.0315021388232708, 0.007894854061305523, -0.030699502676725388, 0.019271360710263252, 0.037314124405384064, 0.021678613498806953, 0.0178774856030941, -0.03583196550607681, -0.012416192330420017, 0.021550126373767853, 0.016386542469263077, -0.0034572347067296505, 0.03550146892666817, 0.020735956728458405, 0.018448686227202415, -0.028376664966344833, 0.050663989037275314, 0.026458552107214928, 0.0068342420272529125, -0.019805260002613068, -0.042660001665353775, -0.015676524490118027, -0.01991105265915394, 0.0410175547003746, 0.020999187603592873, -0.00013664131984114647, 0.07717392593622208, 0.006083622574806213, -0.04296025633811951, 0.025987237691879272, 0.06603840738534927, 0.023174265399575233, -0.03212910518050194, -0.020063353702425957, 0.0004217777168378234, -0.03400034457445145, -0.044394560158252716, 0.022892171517014503, -0.01076465379446745, 0.011246287263929844, 0.0011332618305459619, 0.034316401928663254, 0.007309029810130596, 0.01814616657793522, -0.02210083231329918, 0.0089327497407794, 0.06056583300232887, 0.027870263904333115, -0.058618612587451935, -0.005272004287689924, 0.03773917630314827, 0.006661783438175917, 0.022664574906229973, -0.022657295688986778, -0.044989146292209625, 0.030887121334671974, -0.0011770250275731087, 0.004856344778090715, -0.02681315504014492, 0.009704187512397766, -0.0450485423207283, 0.00243510608561337, 0.0501098707318306, -0.026562022045254707, 0.04155237600207329, -0.007433718536049128, 0.00020138232503086329, 0.0016022224444895983, 0.006641977466642857, -0.05391500145196915, 0.027172960340976715, 0.012726230546832085, 0.03282630816102028, -0.037535469979047775, -0.032989419996738434, -0.06632951647043228, 0.022882141172885895, 0.04238920286297798, 0.055544640868902206, 0.019129907712340355, -0.023903759196400642, -0.016338616609573364, 0.06971367448568344, 0.001606966950930655, -0.06719277799129486, 0.034903135150671005, -0.01236252672970295, -0.0035966960713267326, 0.04308004677295685, -0.0339481458067894, -0.054940830916166306, 0.025125108659267426, 0.014269598759710789, -0.03306145966053009, 0.028668519109487534, -0.006723787169903517, 0.02931288629770279, 0.03473920375108719, 0.02449626848101616, 0.06856796145439148, 0.024197332561016083, -0.027831366285681725, -0.017472287639975548, -0.006353315897285938, 0.03531677648425102, -0.03800841048359871, -0.0001275851100217551, -0.03854956850409508, 0.0035200878046453, -0.004104748368263245, 0.01592005416750908, -0.028483958914875984, 0.028501566499471664, -0.03730442374944687, -0.006172467488795519, -0.010280599817633629, 0.03953377529978752, -0.02812047302722931, 0.0320412740111351, 0.0069447848945856094, 0.04237957298755646, -0.027626458555459976, -0.026479553431272507, 0.02244509942829609, 0.0065069315023720264, -0.014812403358519077, -0.018371127545833588, -0.03205312415957451, 0.030107107013463974, -0.04387083277106285, -0.032302532345056534, -0.014061401598155499, -0.022638093680143356, 0.03250338137149811, -0.034602150321006775, 0.036230478435754776, -0.002240407047793269, -0.03496408835053444, -0.028436793014407158, 0.03951498866081238, 0.028566842898726463, 0.04787907376885414, -0.05180584266781807, 0.024015897884964943, 0.0038523380644619465, -0.02695922739803791, -0.0656621903181076, -0.044184066355228424, 0.011712826788425446, 0.014930070377886295, 0.008218217641115189, -0.05186113715171814, 0.011076140217483044, -0.004250456113368273, -0.04519614204764366, -0.023843571543693542, 0.02387908659875393, 0.012369805946946144, -0.03250466287136078, 0.012621336616575718, 0.020725511014461517, 0.0598129965364933, -0.0048125493340194225, -0.012812339700758457, 0.020567890256643295, -0.048559755086898804, -0.0346977636218071, 0.010144805535674095, 0.00037897739093750715, -0.017249882221221924, 0.007335720118135214, -0.022558333352208138, -0.012568962760269642, 0.016092706471681595, -0.03352035582065582, -0.04280563071370125, -0.0029522250406444073, 0.009763902984559536, -0.01051388680934906, -0.03923618420958519, -0.017315834760665894, -0.0005733143188990653, 0.038680240511894226, 0.00474576698616147, -0.02006928063929081, -0.0035610359627753496, 0.0025993480812758207, 0.021533064544200897, 0.016239404678344727, 0.01338941976428032, -0.0038449096027761698, 0.061228539794683456, -0.008105166256427765, 0.006934132426977158, -0.012965701520442963, 0.044600892812013626, 0.03412698954343796, -0.011159610003232956, -0.0067844451405107975, -0.0033485800959169865, 0.013223003596067429, -0.024276474490761757, 0.01632850430905819, -0.010659193620085716, 0.01481850165873766, 0.06938551366329193, -0.042469147592782974, 0.051085665822029114, 0.04344693198800087, 0.0336378812789917, -0.012696798890829086, -0.018072303384542465, -0.008212443441152573, -0.02058066986501217, -0.019821835681796074, 0.038394276052713394, -0.020383013412356377, -0.005534025840461254, 0.05524840205907822, 0.026651674881577492, -0.0021241919603198767, 0.007475502323359251, -0.009405255317687988, 0.0067618065513670444, 0.009807869791984558, -0.004379376769065857, -0.03475950285792351, 0.027632836252450943, -0.03150221332907677, -0.011434226296842098, -0.03615462779998779, -0.0032317095901817083, 0.05095313861966133, 0.030550679191946983, -0.021795714274048805, -0.026561006903648376, -0.028368866071105003, -0.02506401017308235, 0.010529862716794014, -0.002599947387352586, 0.006457291077822447, 0.029573874548077583, -0.005253530107438564, 0.0047139972448349, -0.011997181922197342, 0.008105228655040264, -0.01864355430006981, -0.06840596348047256, 0.01999638043344021, -0.024428794160485268, -0.03529695048928261, 0.028440335765480995, 0.029550697654485703, -0.04091957211494446, 0.016508052125573158, -0.023554176092147827, 0.03488056734204292, -0.01031990721821785, 0.04184629023075104, 0.0014495707582682371, 0.06504714488983154, 0.012272577732801437, 0.028372161090373993, 0.019765760749578476, -0.0018622743664309382, 0.08758839219808578, 0.031037788838148117, 0.0201907679438591, -0.06439068913459778, 0.029137050732970238, -0.03525799140334129, -0.01231898833066225, -0.07231342792510986, 0.04563259705901146, -0.004615767393261194, 0.012986613437533379, 0.060685668140649796, 0.06794578582048416, 0.012022792361676693, -0.03818061947822571, 0.06404577940702438, -0.030613400042057037, -0.030560828745365143, -0.012952128425240517, 0.026618650183081627, -0.0075537096709012985, -0.00013456637680064887, -0.04616152122616768, 0.0032867074478417635, -0.028736073523759842, -0.017504645511507988, -0.06523363292217255, -0.02833297662436962, -0.00607619434595108, -0.004013121593743563, -0.02535170689225197, -0.01643362082540989, 0.04122450202703476, 0.029470294713974, -0.03162701055407524, 0.02577996999025345, 0.0037111600395292044, -0.033095210790634155, 0.03756267949938774, -0.00040451137465424836, -0.009580754674971104, 0.014102143235504627, 0.040082160383462906, 0.008148997090756893, -0.038150858134031296, -0.028846416622400284, -0.038221098482608795, 0.05409882590174675, -0.015708139166235924, -0.019034994766116142, -0.03422074019908905, 0.021974164992570877, 0.008394492790102959, -0.03842534124851227, -0.023132506757974625, 0.01065519917756319, 0.009146243333816528, -0.04049558937549591, 0.03202107921242714, -0.024849403649568558, 0.04190114513039589, 0.016216833144426346, 0.013798515312373638, 0.010965440422296524, -0.0437188483774662, 0.0015198026085272431, -0.022345004603266716, 0.03920727223157883, 0.002556483494117856, -0.03009963035583496, 0.010864369571208954, -0.02745775692164898, -0.01933388225734234, 0.0014171231305226684, -0.007767527364194393, -0.010749324224889278, 0.0037711949553340673, -0.0003061035240534693, -0.00027920218417420983, 0.004449540749192238, -0.052138034254312515, 0.025443434715270996, -0.01729642227292061, 0.03501084819436073, -0.0334223210811615, -0.012742867693305016, 0.02154088020324707, 0.04948514327406883, 0.00024287414271384478, 0.0017220344161614776, -0.01942013017833233, 0.04434583708643913, 0.018995607271790504, -0.02728334069252014, 0.002568284748122096, -0.02259279228746891, -0.019881125539541245, -0.0069878422655165195, -0.021395016461610794, 0.06791321933269501, 0.03410402312874794, 0.05578199401497841, -0.02117120660841465, 0.007504026405513287, -0.026277540251612663, 0.02984585426747799, 0.03781847655773163, -0.04378126934170723, -0.006052492652088404, 0.02501818537712097, 0.06099038943648338, -0.003920792602002621, -0.03455913066864014, 0.00042600734741427004, -0.016854526475071907, 0.007142985705286264, -0.029644208028912544, -0.06384307146072388, -0.040174324065446854, -0.026850242167711258, 0.027014151215553284, -0.007104786112904549, -0.009235674515366554, -0.04220973700284958, 0.018124723806977272, 0.021491410210728645, -0.0308070108294487, -0.03520165756344795, 0.011713428422808647, -0.011765425093472004, -0.004857272375375032, 0.04473099857568741, -0.0110700111836195, 0.03756766393780708, -0.01505846157670021, 0.023086484521627426, -0.02038482390344143, 0.04924457520246506, -0.0371781662106514, 0.0006439261487685144, 0.031863804906606674, -0.026120593771338463, 0.011600270867347717, -0.007146554067730904, -0.01284831017255783, 0.046414513140916824, 0.008161024190485477, -0.04511752724647522, -0.043077170848846436, -0.0006696921773254871, -0.019700773060321808, -0.011513559147715569, -0.007769506424665451, -0.013658415526151657, -0.007319688331335783, -0.0010367769282311201, 0.000038231188227655366, -0.012519173324108124, -0.005785385146737099, 0.021441685035824776, 0.04476628080010414, -0.005356532521545887, -0.00194559374358505, 0.019834546372294426, 0.03697826340794563, 0.01707722805440426, 0.0186021588742733, 0.010787321254611015, 0.07948710769414902, 0.06467356532812119, -0.015796704217791557, -0.00037452596006914973, -0.029293058440089226, 0.013386715203523636, -0.10573961585760117, -0.009125088341534138, 0.0253510233014822, 0.01840876415371895, 0.022143062204122543, -0.037654414772987366, 0.027430441230535507, 0.022630592808127403, -0.07007268816232681, 0.008805830962955952, -0.01490593608468771, -0.006873548496514559, -0.0351891852915287, 0.003996440675109625, -0.0013021990889683366, 0.031529683619737625, 0.022571489214897156, 0.00668216310441494, 0.0160895474255085, 0.025104427710175514, -0.020582810044288635, 0.0068009477108716965, -0.02025984600186348, -0.037184327840805054, 0.0065901814959943295, -0.04858437180519104, 0.017426026985049248, -0.012240283191204071, -0.001323629287071526, 0.009920522570610046, -0.004519694484770298, 0.007636978756636381, 0.01773025095462799, 0.001001309254206717, 0.023875685408711433, 0.031361863017082214, -0.030431458726525307, -0.004622416105121374, -0.007827785797417164, -0.013717591762542725, 0.03950590640306473, 0.02141442336142063, -0.04831031709909439, -0.05768973007798195, 0.04245297610759735, -0.0018110674573108554, -0.06726127117872238, 0.03437880799174309, -0.002871736651286483, -0.013581913895905018, 0.01007837150245905, -0.007437055930495262, 0.021445460617542267, -0.024353710934519768, 0.06153644993901253, -0.054505880922079086, -0.030342819169163704, 0.028719456866383553, 0.031086117029190063, -0.031118737533688545, -0.019486814737319946, -0.009185997769236565, -0.03622511774301529, 0.015052896924316883, 0.012972444295883179, 0.007751704193651676, -0.04489213228225708, -0.02147362381219864, 0.010048256255686283, -0.022658098489046097, 0.006529651116579771, -0.05648352950811386, -0.029560549184679985, 0.02566731534898281, 0.019223138689994812, -0.0011694262502714992, -0.04330020025372505, -0.0004427832900546491, -0.008210308849811554, -0.07702852040529251, 0.004512829706072807, 0.026594489812850952, -0.035589758306741714, -0.034243520349264145, -0.020450541749596596, -0.04765745997428894, -0.026451341807842255, 0.0757027342915535, 0.04201221093535423, 0.023794660344719887, -0.0016439005266875029, 0.052434179931879044, 0.034425344318151474, -0.020025772973895073, 0.027925999835133553, -0.013043186627328396, -0.011635479517281055, -0.048547472804784775, -0.027409829199314117, 0.01805596798658371, 0.005284052342176437, 0.019763635471463203, 0.006070749368518591, 0.017306450754404068, 0.0037353364750742912, -0.03801441565155983, 0.05022386088967323, -0.0066477274522185326, -0.03000953607261181, 0.06167532131075859, -0.030537443235516548, 0.011525506153702736, 0.02752329781651497, -0.010221964679658413, -0.04017878323793411, 0.049996308982372284, -0.07603148370981216, -0.011181768961250782, -0.0320143923163414, 0.0442625917494297, -0.03350452333688736, -0.045184046030044556, 0.011621263809502125, 0.0071899499744176865, -0.06523196399211884, -0.009336317889392376, 0.043415144085884094, 0.010032406076788902, 0.016843117773532867, 0.013707575388252735, -0.0007601603865623474, 0.0022619946394115686, 0.01346542313694954, 0.03623095154762268, 0.04155357927083969, 0.01848752796649933, 0.021123288199305534, -0.014745785854756832, 0.04568358138203621, 0.0016758952988311648, 0.019994789734482765, -0.01542386133223772, 0.003600531490519643, 0.020777473226189613, -0.006260487250983715, -0.03154558688402176, -0.018141213804483414, 0.006964081898331642, 0.0136757493019104, -0.028797263279557228, 0.06096372380852699, -0.023618433624505997, 0.0359325148165226, -0.019045187160372734, 0.0008282061899080873, -0.037945594638586044, -0.016073184087872505, 0.02524816431105137, 0.023680120706558228, -0.03522277623414993, -0.00006671147275483236, 0.01127531100064516, -0.03649283945560455, 0.01621389202773571, -0.0011284659849479795, 0.014543039724230766, 0.011011739261448383, 0.0012120632454752922, -0.015482166782021523, -0.042166322469711304, -0.013451100327074528, -0.030430922284722328, 0.02596748061478138, 0.08286586403846741, 0.009566218592226505, -0.0061125485226511955, -0.03448554128408432, -0.029932301491498947, 0.07372017949819565, -0.08715017884969711, -0.02088763378560543, -0.025396347045898438, 0.02603214792907238, 0.007067217957228422, -0.001642113900743425 ]
<p>Regression: Wage=b0+b1collegegrad, where collegegrad is a dummy variable. Suppose you want to estimate the wage ratio between college graduates and non-college graduates. Is the estimator theta=b0/b1 consistent?</p> <p>My thinking is that if we could increase our sample size to infinity, we would cover the entire population and thus get the true ratio, so the estimator is consistent. Am I correct, or am I missing something?</p>
74,518
[ -0.051217518746852875, 0.008880370296537876, 0.028157902881503105, 0.01217538584023714, 0.04104061797261238, 0.012379189021885395, -0.0023087996523827314, -0.0036852234043180943, -0.006109577603638172, -0.009519592858850956, 0.010591880418360233, 0.05428396165370941, 0.024810077622532845, -0.010504395700991154, 0.019832473248243332, 0.010106310248374939, -0.008870841935276985, 0.03811698406934738, -0.010871336795389652, -0.006929271388798952, 0.001711909775622189, 0.07152906805276871, 0.0203765369951725, -0.03632153198122978, -0.03489121049642563, 0.04805626720190048, 0.02135273441672325, -0.00987515039741993, 0.001158869476057589, 0.0671008750796318, -0.017794743180274963, -0.05093887075781822, 0.0252275001257658, 0.033980321139097214, 0.057337481528520584, 0.015429757535457611, -0.0018851873464882374, -0.05569235607981682, 0.009747186675667763, 0.01479330100119114, -0.0514410100877285, -0.0021855374798178673, 0.012689036317169666, 0.007998335175216198, -0.027106255292892456, -0.011615633033216, 0.002927680965512991, -0.057767871767282486, 0.04466567933559418, -0.021312352269887924, 0.07836697995662689, 0.009019886143505573, 0.023428553715348244, 0.04387384653091431, -0.024909473955631256, -0.023364083841443062, 0.03981964290142059, 0.049418020993471146, -0.027140019461512566, -0.02593584544956684, 0.017795275896787643, -0.03722960874438286, -0.03538312017917633, 0.032736655324697495, -0.025950944051146507, 0.027434660121798515, -0.020892605185508728, -0.010318468324840069, 0.018786869943141937, -0.04611862450838089, 0.04700453206896782, -0.0040116747841238976, 0.030103979632258415, 0.023683488368988037, -0.009455434046685696, -0.027043920010328293, -0.00003718799416674301, 0.041127149015665054, 0.029857860878109932, 0.045727334916591644, -0.018245823681354523, -0.01328857708722353, 0.06327123194932938, 0.047786686569452286, 0.04168320074677467, -0.0019972417503595352, 0.04940923675894737, -0.033841002732515335, 0.04600054398179054, 0.07090667635202408, -0.008510245941579342, 0.02768201194703579, 0.03227311372756958, -0.033583782613277435, -0.01735573820769787, 0.022326240316033363, -0.05002547800540924, 0.05677458271384239, -0.03407978266477585, 0.017911097034811974, -0.0010022538481280208, -0.03356988728046417, -0.04123182222247124, 0.006094093434512615, -0.019455142319202423, -0.005650735460221767, -0.03683249279856682, -0.010776440612971783, -0.009541033767163754, -0.04712501913309097, -0.011294670403003693, 0.006855339277535677, -0.010891799814999104, 0.0416361503303051, 0.008714105933904648, -0.013211117126047611, 0.028979582712054253, -0.008494856767356396, 0.07213233411312103, 0.02989235520362854, 0.010778744705021381, -0.020031092688441277, 0.03582104295492172, -0.001810309011489153, -0.016119036823511124, 0.05810241401195526, 0.01832706481218338, -0.022556541487574577, -0.078926682472229, 0.007191663607954979, -0.01231820322573185, -0.006955097895115614, 0.04965576156973839, 0.0162242129445076, 0.045714616775512695, -0.006866824813187122, -0.06479788571596146, -0.041600264608860016, -0.008053289726376534, 0.01757037080824375, -0.014249431900680065, -0.08044997602701187, 0.027233170345425606, 0.016403380781412125, 0.03774997219443321, 0.013269111514091492, 0.0636667013168335, 0.0140844052657485, -0.0032857470214366913, 0.0059533072635531425, -0.036105964332818985, 0.004915835801512003, -0.02092650718986988, -0.03780234605073929, 0.022252419963479042, -0.0788799598813057, 0.017963917925953865, 0.002515762345865369, 0.004654258489608765, -0.016039971262216568, 0.02229233644902706, 0.008634456433355808, -0.03675391897559166, 0.017066018655896187, 0.04090014845132828, -0.021701008081436157, 0.05892049893736839, -0.011830156669020653, 0.04763837531208992, -0.024393828585743904, 0.01086478028446436, 0.012739652767777443, 0.019391199573874474, 0.024908369407057762, 0.025258077308535576, -0.04029682278633118, -0.0024611400440335274, -0.041951168328523636, 0.03067529760301113, 0.014760684221982956, -0.06523751467466354, -0.03129154443740845, -0.001972370548173785, 0.018148476257920265, 0.022104747593402863, 0.0407814159989357, -0.005285133607685566, -0.03009406104683876, 0.018690478056669235, -0.03700033575296402, -0.03112860955297947, -0.042921338230371475, 0.021629326045513153, 0.001592636457644403, -0.023253347724676132, 0.006493513938039541, -0.0014686731155961752, 0.007154697086662054, -0.07036478817462921, -0.003566813189536333, -0.02211977168917656, -0.00376085564494133, 0.03632225841283798, -0.02319387160241604, -0.005470106843858957, 0.025849267840385437, 0.046828366816043854, 0.012418982572853565, 0.036375198513269424, -0.033252473920583725, -0.05220792815089226, 0.019145039841532707, -0.03440781682729721, 0.04431347921490669, -0.03684955835342407, 0.029826778918504715, 0.03665126860141754, 0.007472987286746502, -0.03941824287176132, 0.07950376719236374, -0.07124949991703033, 0.05134421959519386, 0.04052066057920456, -0.0021067801862955093, 0.004163559526205063, 0.019106470048427582, 0.027604568749666214, -0.000489545869641006, -0.05135274678468704, -0.01814240589737892, -0.07319124788045883, 0.04025314748287201, 0.011860714294016361, -0.003206734312698245, -0.027089620009064674, 0.00456819636747241, 0.06235160678625107, 0.046244483441114426, -0.003175282385200262, 0.019603542983531952, -0.02092147432267666, -0.018614931032061577, 0.0037989472039043903, -0.0209441389888525, 0.01810985803604126, 0.005187598057091236, 0.02293204702436924, 0.0008346026297658682, 0.0241806972771883, 0.0032216007821261883, 0.023457666859030724, 0.008840193971991539, 0.008874927647411823, 0.033411264419555664, -0.004687362816184759, 0.02386065013706684, 0.005129929166287184, -0.052863482385873795, 0.0025268434546887875, 0.025030119344592094, 0.015986600890755653, -0.013063428923487663, -0.007982238195836544, -0.04218526929616928, 0.012895703315734863, 0.05541377514600754, -0.037874288856983185, 0.038930125534534454, 0.022710097953677177, -0.0169229619204998, -0.02993018925189972, -0.046321555972099304, -0.04163220524787903, -0.02731385827064514, -0.0027718383353203535, 0.05115854740142822, -0.000262629211647436, 0.011395713314414024, -0.02914220280945301, -0.028673416003584862, 0.0017246890347450972, -0.009635464288294315, -0.012290691025555134, -0.0036533211823552847, -0.05624193698167801, 0.010050392709672451, -0.019082937389612198, -0.02223643660545349, 0.013246145099401474, 0.037639424204826355, 0.03362572565674782, 0.011907530017197132, 0.00489032082259655, -0.03269756957888603, 0.005454306490719318, 0.0025990004651248455, -0.008532023057341576, -0.01873771846294403, -0.006234323605895042, 0.020660750567913055, -0.006983163300901651, -0.02058946155011654, 0.021542729809880257, -0.05373673141002655, -0.08082202821969986, -0.019929325208067894, 0.006384897977113724, 0.016276035457849503, 0.016116222366690636, 0.04203177988529205, 0.034442901611328125, -0.013926906511187553, -0.037097249180078506, -0.06923755258321762, -0.07817269116640091, -0.019142355769872665, 0.021893402561545372, 0.03763341158628464, 0.009405909106135368, -0.00428980216383934, 0.0445319302380085, 0.033140942454338074, -0.0056077963672578335, -0.012010141275823116, 0.01012748759239912, 0.012742175720632076, -0.03768712654709816, -0.004809552803635597, 0.023686939850449562, -0.0017720909090712667, -0.019977519288659096, -0.017894627526402473, 0.04783646762371063, 0.03136616200208664, 0.035454947501420975, -0.005018751136958599, 0.02280847728252411, 0.03198451176285744, 0.025876060128211975, 0.04606866464018822, 0.022921571508049965, -0.040029436349868774, -0.021905845031142235, 0.004394372925162315, 0.03796626999974251, -0.01904289238154888, -0.06369064003229141, 0.011637330055236816, -0.027418266981840134, -0.016695884987711906, -0.03584109991788864, 0.02592085674405098, 0.019409704953432083, -0.03332570567727089, -0.03099445439875126, -0.003117764601483941, 0.026967840269207954, -0.005352934822440147, 0.003253063652664423, 0.04458282142877579, -0.006778865121304989, -0.03421199694275856, 0.001520321355201304, -0.013790450990200043, -0.014011772349476814, 0.001626476994715631, -0.011196684092283249, -0.04474867880344391, 0.020249085500836372, 0.07841082662343979, 0.006525629200041294, -0.019356830045580864, -0.04584411159157753, 0.0026491950266063213, -0.06516885757446289, -0.0033611010294407606, -0.006317551247775555, 0.045490458607673645, -0.007900379598140717, 0.04135395586490631, 0.001001755241304636, 0.031511664390563965, 0.01853809878230095, 0.040618184953927994, -0.06591709703207016, 0.012369171716272831, -0.035080764442682266, -0.04425862058997154, 0.012290730141103268, -0.03105679340660572, 0.049772657454013824, -0.014877257868647575, 0.026775619015097618, 0.0013913906877860427, 0.012628446333110332, -0.03661758080124855, 0.006538769695907831, 0.0024665165692567825, -0.015694143250584602, 0.001704090740531683, -0.0044195945374667645, 0.0018315680790692568, -0.017778899520635605, 0.026028446853160858, 0.05553426593542099, 0.012578381225466728, -0.01822059229016304, -0.03540237247943878, 0.04032127186655998, -0.004949238151311874, 0.08210774511098862, 0.027505973353981972, 0.030784783884882927, -0.05832858011126518, 0.017145710065960884, 0.006740369368344545, 0.03121912106871605, 0.050184592604637146, 0.0013696799287572503, -0.05224934592843056, -0.027825864031910896, -0.029938362538814545, 0.014788326807320118, 0.004905893467366695, 0.013116205111145973, -0.05189044401049614, 0.09904206544160843, 0.031932663172483444, -0.04001821577548981, -0.010482179000973701, 0.05375562608242035, 0.022757170721888542, -0.01084231398999691, -0.033770568668842316, 0.027354607358574867, 0.0029921596869826317, 0.02976234257221222, -0.02377530001103878, -0.004514648579061031, 0.005828406196087599, -0.02441413514316082, 0.048933301120996475, 0.021941212937235832, -0.029780162498354912, 0.02074706181883812, 0.017162419855594635, 0.0398595966398716, 0.00589401088654995, -0.044638365507125854, 0.016732722520828247, 0.018248166888952255, 0.05513768643140793, 0.043863698840141296, 0.005682989023625851, -0.0691109150648117, 0.0025752228684723377, 0.008391252718865871, 0.004410175606608391, -0.02039315737783909, -0.02290533483028412, -0.010262998752295971, -0.0377240926027298, 0.03465646505355835, -0.04301256313920021, 0.027862975373864174, -0.020161278545856476, 0.00883964542299509, -0.025959713384509087, -0.045336682349443436, -0.028208449482917786, 0.031439755111932755, -0.03602069243788719, 0.006524855270981789, -0.001042026444338262, -0.027096722275018692, -0.012395236641168594, 0.04587231203913689, 0.031412381678819656, 0.058358389884233475, -0.015128107741475105, -0.04302714392542839, -0.0010651437332853675, 0.03807036951184273, -0.010860606096684933, -0.04055732488632202, 0.02178303711116314, 0.00601093377918005, 0.0035787925589829683, 0.004971350077539682, 0.0036415341310203075, -0.06127988174557686, 0.02148599736392498, 0.004551083315163851, -0.02101668156683445, 0.004271272104233503, -0.045964404940605164, 0.04265671595931053, 0.01038101501762867, 0.03876854106783867, 0.07405988872051239, 0.010377682745456696, 0.024201953783631325, 0.01164883840829134, -0.04627804458141327, -0.014730029739439487, -0.01979336142539978, -0.014221184886991978, -0.03185669705271721, -0.02586113102734089, -0.01652471348643303, -0.0013893558643758297, -0.0006306493887677789, 0.03564972057938576, -0.02896943688392639, 0.011109178885817528, 0.019107261672616005, 0.03505122289061546, -0.002065411303192377, 0.017152806743979454, 0.003925076685845852, 0.015468348748981953, -0.0008882596739567816, -0.01069093681871891, 0.03764910250902176, -0.017306553199887276, -0.01782233826816082, 0.028213150799274445, -0.010322019457817078, -0.013895604759454727, -0.02294931188225746, -0.0407014861702919, 0.009825359098613262, -0.02484792098402977, 0.0427219532430172, -0.016535570845007896, 0.03693900629878044, -0.017661774531006813, -0.0011886985739693046, 0.01194598525762558, 0.032220251858234406, 0.00923707615584135, 0.035574495792388916, -0.04463818296790123, 0.02069474756717682, 0.016035834327340126, 0.03176691755652428, -0.0754510834813118, -0.015466177836060524, -0.00178387516643852, 0.019117163494229317, 0.0032593088690191507, -0.02601747214794159, -0.018515298143029213, 0.01588384248316288, -0.05451876297593117, 0.013096344657242298, 0.04338976740837097, -0.030110575258731842, -0.005635482724756002, -0.044674351811409, 0.050491735339164734, 0.0802498459815979, -0.018514586612582207, -0.01872895658016205, 0.0307443980127573, -0.033678408712148666, 0.0015752011677250266, 0.012371719814836979, 0.012720689177513123, -0.03253018110990524, -0.009798879735171795, -0.02516544610261917, 0.001965315779671073, 0.031331710517406464, 0.037551235407590866, -0.028741056099534035, 0.037775732576847076, -0.01936807669699192, 0.03210346773266792, -0.023748477920889854, -0.016677504405379295, -0.002047652378678322, -0.010769758373498917, -0.03753864765167236, -0.014442767947912216, 0.007545762229710817, -0.0342734195291996, 0.011205202899873257, 0.04163330793380737, -0.023733682930469513, -0.006919820327311754, 0.068919837474823, -0.014409084804356098, 0.009445146657526493, -0.003954289481043816, -0.04230858013033867, 0.05709649249911308, 0.03140393644571304, -0.02103552035987377, 0.013222160749137402, 0.03879045695066452, -0.05271953344345093, -0.040856581181287766, -0.019152527675032616, 0.008696355856955051, 0.05802806094288826, 0.020719818770885468, 0.03973488137125969, 0.01481917779892683, 0.0002623454201966524, 0.015274164266884327, -0.038648515939712524, -0.0009282258106395602, -0.01196000725030899, -0.06629520654678345, 0.02005726285278797, 0.00032171880593523383, -0.03643181174993515, 0.05227279290556908, 0.020869698375463486, 0.021190524101257324, 0.038490258157253265, 0.018031716346740723, 0.01140316016972065, 0.017791884019970894, 0.02481112815439701, -0.04793352633714676, 0.026221688836812973, -0.048813845962285995, 0.03514741361141205, -0.058824364095926285, -0.017544373869895935, 0.05557005852460861, 0.023786790668964386, 0.06314457952976227, -0.0226727407425642, -0.03034529648721218, -0.028258176520466805, 0.0016332160448655486, -0.013474353589117527, 0.02818376198410988, 0.02175344154238701, -0.014331362210214138, -0.004183787386864424, 0.005343179684132338, 0.0036503158044070005, -0.05346771329641342, -0.07647097110748291, -0.02754811942577362, -0.04020657390356064, -0.023655790835618973, 0.0008217677823267877, -0.026033297181129456, 0.002233818406239152, 0.04685407504439354, -0.055158380419015884, 0.02969072200357914, -0.008298370987176895, 0.042778730392456055, -0.027113493531942368, 0.01704399660229683, 0.034906577318906784, 0.0524810366332531, -0.001958367880433798, 0.011568276211619377, 0.12166988104581833, 0.09574595838785172, 0.02320791222155094, -0.026210768148303032, 0.02204664796590805, -0.006463565398007631, -0.010552569292485714, -0.029315508902072906, -0.013567240908741951, -0.016575656831264496, -0.019412802532315254, 0.025272322818636894, 0.05014137551188469, 0.011625389568507671, -0.007106400094926357, 0.057516034692525864, -0.008614649064838886, -0.03965422511100769, 0.02669813483953476, 0.027818860486149788, 0.026684755459427834, -0.002440243260934949, -0.038891859352588654, 0.02089923433959484, -0.005052610766142607, -0.014971962198615074, -0.03637852892279625, -0.00017059821402654052, -0.011618142947554588, -0.018117787316441536, -0.05053011327981949, -0.0038008654955774546, -0.014576956629753113, -0.006271463818848133, 0.006397513672709465, -0.019861774519085884, 0.017051538452506065, -0.011354081332683563, 0.002910194220021367, 0.037466078996658325, -0.03426771238446236, 0.027974311262369156, 0.00945814698934555, -0.019433023408055305, -0.022193610668182373, 0.023703061044216156, -0.04876427724957466, 0.03386963903903961, -0.01963857188820839, 0.007020687684416771, -0.017660995945334435, -0.004912493750452995, -0.017332609742879868, -0.032524555921554565, 0.004294903948903084, 0.0415508896112442, -0.0039658755995333195, -0.005179110448807478, -0.04924311488866806, 0.004375815391540527, 0.017114048823714256, 0.007832640781998634, 0.011296921409666538, 0.043070368468761444, -0.0647619292140007, -0.017075490206480026, -0.008912734687328339, 0.06537783890962601, 0.00009231099829776213, 0.00004461165735847317, 0.036863941699266434, -0.007794438395649195, -0.05387510731816292, -0.048225633800029755, -0.001994804013520479, 0.004138389136642218, 0.053667183965444565, -0.03827056288719177, 0.004417470656335354, -0.033574990928173065, -0.03085365518927574, 0.028066663071513176, -0.009039150550961494, -0.006008462514728308, -0.07114538550376892, 0.010679954662919044, 0.0031572829466313124, 0.03509528562426567, -0.022476106882095337, 0.004139415454119444, 0.0036933082155883312, 0.0338134691119194, 0.014159968122839928, -0.008691051974892616, -0.016920726746320724, -0.0367124043405056, -0.07465613633394241, 0.004929597955197096, -0.0028361622244119644, 0.04542484134435654, 0.008221004158258438, 0.04680556803941727, 0.006579303648322821, 0.013200703077018261, -0.00811387412250042, 0.05376582220196724, -0.003608014201745391, -0.06494834274053574, 0.006875172723084688, 0.06918460130691528, -0.019180024042725563, -0.002732980763539672, -0.011149449273943901, -0.058828771114349365, -0.007399481255561113, 0.003954545594751835, -0.04710274934768677, -0.03567500784993172, 0.006087476387619972, 0.0014290991239249706, 0.0230421032756567, -0.0035418509505689144, -0.01110850740224123, -0.018902642652392387, -0.020649690181016922, 0.003027005586773157, -0.017171472311019897, 0.007110563572496176, 0.001684132614172995, -0.02171599306166172, -0.0109543576836586, 0.043641816824674606, -0.011255389079451561, -0.003049618098884821, -0.02024502120912075, 0.025445686653256416, 0.026992347091436386, 0.035971492528915405, -0.05094270035624504, -0.016686804592609406, 0.04622919484972954, -0.03600061312317848, 0.020602039992809296, 0.032228510826826096, -0.034259162843227386, 0.04002276062965393, -0.006481148302555084, 0.0015160749899223447, 0.0009637411567382514, 0.0484297052025795, -0.03942461311817169, -0.00325912912376225, -0.02730066515505314, 0.005950946360826492, 0.04481836408376694, -0.028891347348690033, 0.012214116752147675, -0.013011515140533447, -0.0038283399771898985, 0.04247709736227989, 0.03225244954228401, 0.00431449431926012, -0.015186421573162079, -0.006397203542292118, 0.03601923957467079, 0.0009151480044238269, 0.021742284297943115, 0.002743228804320097, 0.030393807217478752, 0.0566924586892128, -0.0629144236445427, 0.023037713021039963, -0.01918400637805462, 0.00015584024367854, -0.07891563326120377, -0.04315473884344101, 0.021133581176400185, 0.020313097164034843, 0.008673904463648796, -0.028923628851771355, -0.03662022203207016, 0.0033305801916867495, -0.07033612579107285, 0.007140359375625849, 0.016071787104010582, -0.0008852315368130803, -0.03945671766996384, -0.004830898717045784, -0.011161239817738533, -0.0006008214550092816, 0.033972736448049545, 0.03192872181534767, -0.0015102963661774993, 0.009515049867331982, -0.0157705619931221, -0.02986905910074711, -0.00867158081382513, 0.006851780693978071, -0.013218418695032597, -0.05921825394034386, 0.007353200577199459, -0.03870007395744324, -0.008365579880774021, 0.049091339111328125, 0.005837257951498032, 0.025167016312479973, 0.02851761132478714, 0.014857550151646137, 0.019280262291431427, 0.03617069125175476, 0.04541604593396187, 0.0033279340714216232, -0.01737884432077408, 0.020464790984988213, 0.014259746298193932, 0.044850364327430725, -0.023279620334506035, 0.014424897730350494, 0.03817411884665489, -0.0232041385024786, -0.022482432425022125, 0.008645426481962204, -0.0028519530314952135, 0.009824839420616627, 0.03293821960687637, -0.005287599749863148, -0.013369620777666569, 0.012471506372094154, 0.028329839929938316, -0.0629572719335556, -0.03823310136795044, 0.038027483969926834, 0.0599939338862896, 0.010355434380471706, -0.0058130547404289246, 0.0027057554107159376, -0.008495565503835678, 0.023398932069540024, 0.005011755507439375, -0.0063109188340604305, -0.05690469220280647, 0.00884054321795702, 0.0076341787353158, -0.01810975931584835, 0.012623189948499203, 0.0032572830095887184, -0.011518571525812149, 0.025122037157416344, -0.019737660884857178, 0.006837502121925354, 0.01098856795579195, -0.014203396625816822, -0.03045833483338356, -0.04471467435359955, 0.10600633919239044, -0.00425123842433095, 0.024632973596453667, -0.03816866874694824, -0.05451836809515953, -0.026741357520222664, 0.0059465570375323296, 0.021183907985687256, -0.006698697339743376, 0.04829360544681549, 0.021168099716305733, -0.00000926434040593449, -0.0005773889715783298, -0.027925385162234306, 0.0390179380774498, 0.0055254073813557625, -0.03324919193983078, -0.032762255519628525, 0.003687129821628332, 0.010476180352270603, -0.010717764496803284, -0.027502574026584625, -0.005769881885498762, 0.028233414515852928, 0.061701592057943344, 0.0001410172408213839, 0.03336020186543465, 0.03206288442015648, 0.011127562262117863, 0.06575549393892288, -0.0021292115561664104, 0.020102469250559807, 0.008776665665209293, -0.016267674043774605, -0.09606607258319855, 0.02683275192975998, -0.027176417410373688, -0.024148261174559593, -0.031468942761421204, 0.02790543995797634, 0.005412284750491381, -0.010532960295677185, 0.007906410843133926, 0.045839644968509674, -0.05810324475169182, 0.014429524540901184, 0.01665988191962242, 0.009685078635811806, 0.05245506018400192, -0.050010498613119125, 0.019257815554738045, 0.010760861448943615, -0.03667634353041649, 0.012851261533796787, 0.012977524660527706, -0.005357418674975634, 0.0008030151948332787, 0.020668864250183105, 0.028650334104895592, 0.005275290459394455, 0.033311665058135986, -0.018815085291862488, 0.03147187456488609, -0.04005970433354378, -0.03865795210003853, 0.029831934720277786, -0.008918586187064648, 0.028191188350319862, 0.008407940156757832, -0.017312373965978622, 0.051179781556129456, -0.019849495962262154, -0.002704593585804105, -0.002984594088047743, -0.01664123684167862, -0.02323562279343605, -0.000640427228063345, 0.00042302641668356955, 0.008618454448878765, -0.020566288381814957, -0.03162764012813568, 0.012346263974905014, -0.03310179337859154, 0.01647394336760044, -0.0484497956931591, -0.022684546187520027, -0.0010038368636742234, -0.02516859397292137, -0.028912074863910675, 0.0025966346729546785, -0.04701900854706764, -0.03848036006093025, 0.042595915496349335, 0.017100537195801735, 0.033488497138023376, -0.030742650851607323, -0.040885649621486664, 0.014556952752172947, 0.041856199502944946, -0.07197973877191544, -0.006216883193701506, -0.026089711114764214, -0.0014379707863554358, 0.00560927065089345, -0.05479435250163078 ]