question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I am reading the Hidden Markov Model note <a href="http://cs229.stanford.edu/section/cs229-hmm.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://cs229.stanford.edu/section/cs229-hmm.pdf</a> from Stanford and have problem finding the meaning of the notation described below.</p> <p>What does the semicolon (;) means in below (Page 2 in above link)?</p> <p>$$P( z_t, z_{t-1},\ldots, z_1; A )$$</p> <p>$A$ is the transition matrix. How should it be read? For example, I know $P( x | y )$ is "probability of $x$ GIVEN $y$"; $P( x=s_1 | y=o_1 )$ is "probability of $x$ being $s_1$ GIVEN that $y$ is $o_1$".</p> <p>Thanks in advance for any help for this possibly trivial, but surprisingly hard to find answer.</p> <p><strong>Further question on same notation issue.</strong></p> <p>In Wikipedia article on <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectation%E2%80%93maximization_algorithm" rel="nofollow">EM algorithm</a>, They have</p> <p>$$L( \theta;X ) = p( X,Z | \theta )$$</p> <p>In the above, X is the set of observed data, Z is the set of observed data and $\theta$ is a vector of parameters. Based on my current understanding of the notation, I will read the above as "the likelihood of theta given X is equal to the joint probability of X and Z given theta". In this context, X contains observed data, which to me appears to be random variables rather than fixed parameters. Why is semicolon ';' used here?</p> <p><strong>Update</strong></p> <p>I have just noticed a few other threads asking the same question, when these threads shown up as related threads on right pane. My apology that I couldn't find them earlier. The following two threads have elaborated answers, in agreement with the accepted answer of this thread.</p> <p><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/10234/meaning-of-probability-notations-pzd-w-and-pzd-w">Meaning of probability notations $P(z;d,w)$ and $P(z|d,w)$</a></p> <p><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/30825/what-is-the-meaning-of-the-semicolon-in-fx-theta">What is the meaning of the semicolon in $f(x;\Theta)$?</a></p>
49,858
[ -0.005342425312846899, -0.042553652077913284, -0.00478341244161129, -0.07791925221681595, 0.024209365248680115, 0.0431092232465744, -0.0032408509869128466, -0.032682519406080246, -0.0000809120901976712, -0.007604227866977453, 0.045547571033239365, 0.052272070199251175, 0.0719156488776207, 0.019334258511662483, 0.05151573196053505, 0.037739939987659454, 0.0211885254830122, 0.011214451864361763, -0.030153844505548477, 0.03293733671307564, -0.0006190286949276924, 0.0031790398061275482, -0.001184323220513761, -0.012326681986451149, 0.019880248233675957, 0.040923018008470535, 0.005066743586212397, -0.0059648845344781876, 0.0029825535602867603, 0.050488632172346115, -0.038676485419273376, -0.05239260569214821, -0.010061066597700119, 0.0064604030922055244, 0.009947244077920914, -0.020334767177700996, -0.03143512085080147, -0.03928544372320175, 0.011784778907895088, 0.04578234255313873, -0.027040649205446243, -0.00848675798624754, -0.021310390904545784, 0.04353702813386917, -0.033851247280836105, 0.034369438886642456, -0.03566825017333031, -0.013570591807365417, 0.007198487874120474, 0.0011554290540516376, 0.06572749465703964, -0.02796304039657116, 0.03490211442112923, 0.027672411873936653, -0.009034710936248302, 0.021477708593010902, 0.05267951264977455, 0.05724821612238884, 0.0003738771192729473, -0.08167285472154617, -0.01776127517223358, -0.03702477738261223, 0.020269455388188362, -0.02744048461318016, -0.02203598991036415, 0.01650051213800907, 0.04880507290363312, -0.02749745361506939, 0.025471966713666916, 0.006847710348665714, 0.022971168160438538, 0.02470177412033081, 0.02580789476633072, -0.019679958000779152, 0.022057311609387398, -0.023443885147571564, -0.014759681187570095, 0.013764191418886185, 0.01304650492966175, 0.028995241969823837, 0.006075409706681967, 0.004277516156435013, -0.008265550248324871, -0.014267644844949245, -0.03683902323246002, -0.01305812131613493, 0.07164845615625381, -0.023506978526711464, 0.008211025036871433, -0.0074014379642903805, -0.0015402034623548388, 0.051960598677396774, 0.019103027880191803, -0.05464749410748482, -0.03827344626188278, 0.05432729050517082, -0.018808513879776, 0.05689675733447075, -0.03766009956598282, 0.005690228193998337, 0.007468458265066147, -0.03655247390270233, -0.008466889150440693, 0.040028903633356094, -0.042496077716350555, 0.022740252315998077, -0.010575687512755394, 0.01251975167542696, -0.022428195923566818, -0.04394937679171562, -0.04069089889526367, 0.03966938704252243, -0.024598173797130585, 0.05338522791862488, -0.014419049955904484, -0.03753969073295593, -0.028631815686821938, 0.02023686096072197, 0.034680530428886414, 0.047049395740032196, 0.022135848179459572, -0.03652957081794739, 0.03245038539171219, -0.02314082160592079, -0.07503169775009155, -0.010395585559308529, 0.007265803869813681, 0.005505644716322422, -0.04291752353310585, 0.07380059361457825, -0.02381092682480812, -0.015632005408406258, 0.06431867927312851, 0.031820882111787796, 0.0023578598629683256, -0.002874980913475156, -0.08025539666414261, -0.038467876613140106, 0.046170685440301895, -0.008905811235308647, 0.04324807971715927, -0.060172151774168015, -0.001100296387448907, 0.03757351264357567, 0.004448854364454746, -0.03602852299809456, 0.03907417133450508, -0.009834601543843746, -0.0023418248165398836, 0.028562940657138824, -0.05623212456703186, 0.011349612846970558, -0.017156489193439484, -0.0038047025445848703, -0.01756344921886921, -0.04891379550099373, 0.022504819557070732, 0.022621802985668182, -0.006127816624939442, -0.016132742166519165, 0.027584031224250793, -0.025285648182034492, -0.038662105798721313, -0.003264831379055977, -0.004662801977247, -0.050786472856998444, 0.06834761798381805, 0.03071790188550949, 0.06041739508509636, 0.06389413774013519, -0.035163961350917816, -0.007988362573087215, -0.013221438974142075, 0.03667200729250908, 0.06703584641218185, -0.025220826268196106, -0.03856758400797844, -0.04071791470050812, 0.01140156202018261, 0.007396981120109558, -0.046601634472608566, -0.024040652438998222, -0.03112795017659664, 0.021163437515497208, 0.0006671149749308825, 0.03915197774767876, 0.03094051219522953, 0.004639352671802044, 0.032106462866067886, -0.06162760779261589, -0.047758083790540695, -0.04826705902814865, 0.014124824665486813, -0.04982154443860054, 0.0332413986325264, 0.06015699729323387, -0.006631609983742237, -0.0165630504488945, -0.01658668927848339, 0.01516424398869276, -0.018887069076299667, -0.00044238907867111266, 0.01388155110180378, -0.017842965200543404, 0.010640104301273823, 0.06941362470388412, 0.04641708731651306, 0.03232746571302414, 0.017856502905488014, -0.03212663531303406, -0.011615014635026455, 0.008220954798161983, -0.01521123293787241, 0.0029358724132180214, 0.01203975174576044, -0.015244741924107075, 0.021609609946608543, -0.012694778852164745, -0.014841949567198753, -0.010870915837585926, -0.07445403933525085, 0.025533519685268402, 0.062267135828733444, 0.03380078449845314, 0.0025748128537088633, 0.0038580482359975576, -0.007848446257412434, 0.03309425339102745, 0.004828075412660837, 0.010331879369914532, -0.021304232999682426, -0.011918938718736172, 0.05644804239273071, 0.014386164024472237, -0.02935108169913292, 0.004596243146806955, 0.05853961035609245, 0.023586289957165718, 0.0037849119398742914, 0.046294890344142914, -0.027947641909122467, -0.035534124821424484, 0.01873829960823059, 0.01986379735171795, 0.008600552566349506, 0.041369520127773285, -0.003295918693765998, -0.02185024507343769, 0.01798269711434841, 0.00038411663263104856, -0.003556220093742013, 0.03998822346329689, -0.004374799318611622, 0.010655720718204975, -0.05420788377523422, -0.0029634416569024324, 0.04169643670320511, -0.018196657299995422, 0.015223948284983635, -0.0010965329129248857, 0.0030617776792496443, -0.004437769763171673, -0.05081241577863693, -0.0242144912481308, -0.03234240785241127, 0.037770021706819534, -0.03190922737121582, 0.03035946562886238, 0.03023337759077549, -0.006346567068248987, 0.01666194200515747, -0.03140299394726753, -0.0462738499045372, -0.015877990052103996, -0.018161240965127945, -0.006197753362357616, -0.006056590937077999, 0.011070003733038902, -0.05521746724843979, -0.02958851307630539, -0.03301646560430527, -0.010541394352912903, 0.060929618775844574, 0.05938386917114258, -0.05481288582086563, -0.011999500915408134, -0.014708442613482475, -0.061762288212776184, 0.030935848131775856, -0.0057448213919997215, -0.005630238447338343, 0.000791064347140491, -0.023725101724267006, -0.04030446708202362, -0.0376625582575798, 0.012974310666322708, 0.01780884526669979, -0.02548374980688095, 0.009163404814898968, 0.07630854845046997, 0.00890737771987915, 0.0076849511824548244, -0.004514917731285095, -0.049628183245658875, -0.02331247180700302, -0.061557114124298096, -0.005146391224116087, 0.007432914804667234, 0.019522005692124367, 0.06034006550908089, 0.04132913425564766, -0.0029044141992926598, 0.016914132982492447, -0.07327865064144135, -0.047935884445905685, -0.002905387431383133, -0.034335196018218994, 0.003403583075851202, -0.01721140742301941, -0.031114183366298676, 0.10516426712274551, 0.011078509502112865, -0.03251446411013603, -0.017133180052042007, 0.03936198353767395, -0.0289263017475605, -0.045964378863573074, 0.004427152685821056, 0.03555382415652275, -0.011839864775538445, 0.03216611221432686, 0.007721809204667807, -0.00979591440409422, 0.03591305762529373, 0.004704460967332125, 0.031196067109704018, 0.025321006774902344, -0.003377361688762903, -0.040665775537490845, 0.05225996673107147, 0.016514930874109268, -0.01262680534273386, -0.00025527822435833514, -0.005960218142718077, 0.017320958897471428, 0.014047004282474518, -0.040844887495040894, 0.049795374274253845, -0.0047397855669260025, -0.005059042479842901, -0.018372157588601112, 0.06753972172737122, 0.028393417596817017, -0.04139955714344978, 0.0348142646253109, 0.008570568636059761, 0.016845853999257088, -0.03547123447060585, -0.036773018538951874, 0.03769993409514427, 0.033538587391376495, -0.04321081191301346, -0.008200262673199177, -0.021276775747537613, -0.025398124009370804, 0.03638587146997452, -0.025182420387864113, -0.05725744739174843, 0.0009566094377078116, 0.050175491720438004, -0.006665367633104324, 0.010359344072639942, -0.022869115695357323, -0.020334139466285706, -0.032828088849782944, 0.024082481861114502, 0.028755931183695793, 0.00929301604628563, 0.0033512862864881754, 0.07281480729579926, 0.008407015353441238, 0.006997168064117432, 0.02474723383784294, -0.0010223004501312971, -0.10060683637857437, -0.005861443467438221, 0.0028608841821551323, -0.03726770356297493, -0.011613933369517326, -0.04305329546332359, 0.08021407574415207, -0.004444149322807789, 0.019840702414512634, 0.0070385620929300785, 0.03368896618485451, -0.06562016904354095, 0.018523089587688446, -0.04553778097033501, 0.0075065381824970245, -0.04613162949681282, 0.006784744095057249, 0.03552491217851639, -0.010284221731126308, 0.03254443779587746, 0.025987785309553146, -0.020569410175085068, -0.021020855754613876, -0.028847049921751022, 0.006425362080335617, 0.03641580790281296, 0.0373004749417305, 0.02699517272412777, 0.03016684204339981, -0.011831405572593212, 0.02760879322886467, -0.002936388598755002, 0.06987161934375763, 0.02644900605082512, -0.013939104974269867, -0.01473071239888668, -0.01648673601448536, 0.0039624739438295364, 0.007315501105040312, 0.003915843553841114, 0.00023967123706825078, 0.03607984632253647, 0.06178408861160278, 0.008587947115302086, -0.015810135751962662, 0.024658773094415665, 0.0359237901866436, -0.017543379217386246, 0.013869441114366055, 0.011090155690908432, 0.04203013330698013, -0.03386469557881355, 0.021956870332360268, -0.006304078735411167, 0.0014366976683959365, 0.009707057848572731, 0.01851171813905239, 0.03566693887114525, 0.011394565925002098, -0.025333192199468613, -0.002673366339877248, 0.034126099199056625, 0.024462180212140083, -0.0014652411919087172, -0.04689960554242134, 0.025969231501221657, 0.02924579568207264, 0.01988304778933525, 0.016497692093253136, 0.004761104471981525, -0.040755536407232285, 0.0006024566246196628, 0.03652635216712952, 0.023952757939696312, 0.004100066609680653, -0.016280412673950195, -0.04205165058374405, -0.011314180679619312, -0.003890081075951457, 0.02418191358447075, 0.04907982423901558, -0.03778471797704697, -0.03061462752521038, -0.038123298436403275, -0.029736900702118874, -0.03506331518292427, 0.0017654544208198786, -0.014928324148058891, 0.031800903379917145, -0.014230645261704922, -0.016846036538481712, -0.01390727050602436, -0.022181160748004913, -0.020463405176997185, 0.044882241636514664, -0.010906937532126904, -0.017217310145497322, 0.011810176074504852, 0.054702356457710266, -0.0067384857684373856, -0.07920559495687485, 0.03973665460944176, -0.002467214362695813, 0.023091169074177742, 0.010086363181471825, -0.040024593472480774, -0.06658592075109482, 0.04411880299448967, 0.01147337257862091, -0.008163326419889927, 0.010608891025185585, 0.013124074786901474, 0.020334456115961075, 0.03472724184393883, -0.020540473982691765, 0.05895117297768593, -0.0021449781488627195, -0.012722726911306381, 0.007288340479135513, -0.013836112804710865, -0.010725519619882107, -0.03074263408780098, 0.017639854922890663, -0.05639733374118805, 0.020603792741894722, -0.025211123749613762, 0.031500838696956635, 0.012405190616846085, 0.018747929483652115, -0.07130453735589981, -0.00739358039572835, -0.0078234001994133, 0.027678290382027626, -0.0208542812615633, -0.0060382685624063015, -0.03853381425142288, 0.014526213519275188, -0.027857493609189987, -0.014953152276575565, 0.027244577184319496, -0.0766657292842865, 0.0026775363367050886, -0.011234104633331299, -0.02695847861468792, 0.00733310729265213, -0.052691131830215454, -0.03310307115316391, 0.08769199997186661, -0.02183503843843937, 0.02195780724287033, -0.0024869830813258886, 0.04117719084024429, 0.008237660862505436, -0.06556116789579391, -0.05588085204362869, 0.026641055941581726, -0.01738213188946247, 0.01998117007315159, -0.05099582299590111, 0.020354505628347397, 0.00312044657766819, -0.005233353469520807, -0.028214437887072563, -0.01967460662126541, 0.027683520689606667, -0.04031461849808693, -0.030216744169592857, -0.002389676170423627, -0.010165741667151451, 0.006385439075529575, -0.0781489834189415, -0.0010386094218119979, -0.006963889114558697, -0.03268393874168396, -0.0047471472062170506, 0.004386692773550749, 0.03698943927884102, 0.05300353839993477, 0.05105038359761238, -0.013053176924586296, 0.03118562325835228, -0.010488606058061123, 0.022603146731853485, 0.0021458067931234837, 0.01759711466729641, -0.020122310146689415, -0.005033379420638084, -0.015526232309639454, 0.00825121533125639, 0.010861479677259922, -0.007233848329633474, -0.014970089308917522, 0.00919414684176445, 0.005850032437592745, 0.019206354394555092, -0.03195842355489731, -0.03419745713472366, -0.03139525651931763, 0.024022608995437622, 0.015893131494522095, -0.017015770077705383, 0.009428898803889751, 0.008972556330263615, 0.016985680907964706, -0.019888902083039284, -0.004927751142531633, 0.014539687894284725, 0.0702141523361206, 0.013402752578258514, 0.011306731961667538, -0.014387620612978935, -0.01344242226332426, 0.042725931853055954, 0.0026300381869077682, 0.03370806202292442, 0.0035344718489795923, 0.004966916516423225, -0.035765763372182846, -0.0066628968343138695, -0.05871446430683136, -0.0016694125952199101, 0.055101726204156876, 0.006454430054873228, 0.021590830758213997, 0.04579687491059303, -0.019066235050559044, 0.027136044576764107, -0.042029280215501785, 0.004801599774509668, -0.016133340075612068, -0.011364411562681198, 0.017362499609589577, -0.004725039470940828, -0.010812836699187756, 0.04177657887339592, 0.005659868475049734, -0.00390413380227983, -0.00274147791787982, 0.011610118672251701, -0.001571370055899024, 0.015030505135655403, -0.0127726960927248, -0.03494114428758621, 0.0416610911488533, -0.03135200962424278, 0.02416078932583332, -0.04676227271556854, 0.014628611505031586, 0.02994263917207718, 0.04970845952630043, 0.02103305235505104, -0.054169055074453354, 0.022429943084716797, -0.07730171829462051, 0.018212655559182167, -0.008726169355213642, -0.03845294937491417, 0.06365837156772614, -0.020299043506383896, 0.031169092282652855, 0.008252468891441822, 0.02861890010535717, -0.01780490018427372, -0.061263617128133774, -0.047508083283901215, -0.02487649954855442, -0.03609161451458931, 0.02964271605014801, -0.00945923663675785, -0.0021618239115923643, -0.008716346696019173, -0.04090644046664238, 0.04866346716880798, 0.014871177263557911, 0.013939986936748028, -0.06444751471281052, 0.0754636898636818, -0.005052465014159679, 0.033941518515348434, -0.048203762620687485, -0.02319895662367344, 0.11036652326583862, 0.05983492732048035, 0.04919851943850517, -0.035848747938871384, 0.030134793370962143, 0.00302329333499074, 0.007687917444854975, -0.020793084055185318, -0.014220383018255234, 0.05958680436015129, -0.008590316399931908, 0.006156354211270809, 0.03289920464158058, 0.013554861769080162, -0.01081784162670374, 0.010023575276136398, -0.07387351989746094, -0.062043286859989166, 0.0035633237566798925, -0.017457112669944763, -0.03628190979361534, -0.02038840763270855, -0.051759812980890274, -0.01622091233730316, -0.0018184561049565673, -0.03397955745458603, 0.00846108514815569, -0.03253630921244621, 0.010757195763289928, -0.0004881465283688158, 0.00018755999917630106, 0.011331836692988873, 0.0022458897437900305, 0.022720465436577797, -0.006518153939396143, 0.015470708720386028, 0.002332666190341115, 0.005151140037924051, 0.018224090337753296, 0.04348757863044739, 0.009174611419439316, -0.026685647666454315, 0.009287514723837376, -0.022653138265013695, -0.02629288099706173, -0.01931515708565712, -0.007432560436427593, 0.06637491285800934, -0.002995265182107687, -0.013561764732003212, -0.0003676007327158004, 0.01756417378783226, -0.03527330234646797, -0.01518205739557743, 0.044610027223825455, 0.013969042338430882, 0.028916463255882263, -0.03125946223735809, -0.007144318427890539, -0.04893392324447632, -0.03601162135601044, -0.020270897075533867, 0.0008377688354812562, 0.04949188977479935, -0.022196391597390175, 0.0019762832671403885, -0.054726921021938324, 0.014314034953713417, -0.00032624491723254323, 0.022439854219555855, -0.004260348156094551, -0.0069470955058932304, -0.055316146463155746, -0.06387345492839813, 0.011616788804531097, -0.05858366936445236, 0.015311702154576778, -0.00011849803559016436, 0.03539096191525459, -0.018842147663235664, -0.029659869149327278, 0.020317211747169495, 0.00016205054998863488, -0.039642542600631714, -0.033951614052057266, 0.007661493960767984, 0.005698445253074169, 0.02638617344200611, -0.01761004514992237, 0.014165932312607765, 0.016377585008740425, 0.07668986916542053, 0.020690368488430977, -0.038916267454624176, -0.037496235221624374, 0.0337132066488266, -0.005685142241418362, -0.015652474015951157, -0.006823321338742971, 0.07694808393716812, 0.045773327350616455, 0.029841437935829163, -0.023616809397935867, 0.03262202814221382, 0.008239968679845333, -0.012382609769701958, 0.026829633861780167, -0.04223068058490753, 0.013966242782771587, 0.015812233090400696, 0.024441910907626152, -0.020781056955456734, 0.0012369295582175255, 0.01415379997342825, -0.016802236437797546, 0.015338217839598656, -0.01922745071351528, -0.03565099462866783, 0.008067821152508259, -0.014034095220267773, -0.011221399530768394, 0.03643457219004631, -0.01401823665946722, 0.014104893431067467, 0.013870678842067719, -0.01998310349881649, 0.029726596549153328, -0.029037384316325188, 0.013641093857586384, 0.013193774037063122, -0.03832264244556427, 0.01743360608816147, -0.005625528749078512, 0.029179977253079414, -0.020235033705830574, 0.018119845539331436, -0.0025405967608094215, 0.062125541269779205, -0.015078865922987461, -0.011614765040576458, 0.01707407273352146, -0.06060854345560074, -0.024529125541448593, 0.034085843712091446, 0.0384562686085701, 0.03267240896821022, 0.013207831420004368, -0.007617445662617683, -0.016297684982419014, 0.01611028052866459, -0.03351780027151108, -0.018247878178954124, -0.03142746165394783, -0.038251716643571854, -0.01629631407558918, -0.0007950708968564868, 0.009297234937548637, 0.03608977049589157, -0.023842256516218185, 0.03024573065340519, 0.052792564034461975, 0.006093951407819986, -0.02203376404941082, 0.015233791433274746, 0.03496008738875389, 0.04120944067835808, -0.006323542445898056, -0.0219461340457201, 0.05260215327143669, 0.007299888413399458, -0.008161044679582119, 0.008645569905638695, 0.015284455381333828, -0.00046009087236598134, -0.07482830435037613, -0.00032900148653425276, -0.0002064679138129577, -0.0034994736779481173, 0.03573760390281677, -0.060624707490205765, 0.01866784878075123, 0.02559436298906803, -0.028758589178323746, -0.0021228629630059004, 0.025576304644346237, -0.0006839577108621597, -0.03392358869314194, 0.02561708353459835, 0.014749295078217983, 0.08376861363649368, 0.034048501402139664, 0.02567867748439312, 0.054312895983457565, 0.03155016899108887, -0.03043617308139801, -0.02685363218188286, -0.014289299957454205, 0.07131163030862808, 0.023700596764683723, -0.03254074230790138, 0.06815066188573837, -0.04055633023381233, -0.02051895670592785, 0.0351216197013855, 0.0701209232211113, 0.0102976830676198, 0.02909122407436371, 0.03446061164140701, -0.001327158766798675, 0.038255784660577774, 0.04015570878982544, -0.00426422618329525, -0.0034671504981815815, -0.006433120463043451, -0.012530973181128502, 0.0020272827241569757, 0.015148093923926353, -0.015102124772965908, -0.011465263552963734, -0.028494013473391533, -0.04618163779377937, 0.0027544491458684206, 0.0022883492056280375, -0.0037768741603940725, 0.0005048849852755666, -0.040425416082143784, -0.008598433807492256, -0.04394682124257088, 0.02192419208586216, -0.013956937938928604, 0.0016073273727670312, 0.027471395209431648, 0.02667955495417118, 0.015338308177888393, -0.01376600842922926, -0.011774282902479172, -0.03089701011776924, 0.040740106254816055, 0.0001641250855755061, -0.016488242894411087, -0.05290617421269417, -0.016538210213184357, -0.0073315659537911415, -0.03480331599712372, -0.011189316399395466, 0.023147745057940483, -0.03384600579738617, -0.008707507513463497, -0.023492863401770592, -0.009201539680361748, -0.0071998839266598225, 0.01961125247180462, 0.011315479874610901, -0.07218508422374725, 0.07610033452510834, 0.01034559216350317, -0.013975059613585472, -0.0404382087290287, 0.02588479407131672, 0.023268165066838264, 0.0042310492135584354, 0.04014009237289429, 0.012741027399897575, 0.03353329747915268, -0.0014021240640431643, 0.03453560918569565, 0.01669762283563614, -0.04959116131067276, 0.03902863338589668, -0.027967378497123718, -0.0032255530823022127, -0.02219911850988865, -0.027068985626101494, 0.02828843519091606, 0.03487781435251236, 0.02273760363459587, -0.017342839390039444, 0.047927264124155045, 0.008651874959468842, -0.021026641130447388, -0.011349794454872608, 0.020228048786520958, -0.012665080837905407, 0.051650479435920715, -0.02140789106488228, 0.03435726463794708, 0.03849753364920616, -0.005282953381538391, -0.04270434379577637, -0.020651942119002342, -0.05069885775446892, -0.00988713838160038, 0.02540258690714836, -0.025173280388116837, 0.01116930041462183, -0.041657596826553345, -0.044025618582963943, 0.00997509341686964, -0.031214671209454536, -0.02299449034035206, 0.05273282155394554, 0.04397263750433922, 0.0689200758934021, -0.0004763321194332093, 0.00015215696475934237, -0.004371818155050278, -0.03091830387711525, 0.010613375343382359, 0.008893267251551151, 0.052402883768081665, -0.02401271089911461, 0.01647806353867054, 0.005135327111929655, -0.014485812745988369, 0.02531100995838642, 0.028780536726117134, 0.03451727330684662, -0.010683760978281498, -0.016441524028778076, -0.019624881446361542, -0.0160683486610651, -0.013189188204705715, -0.0028473762795329094, -0.01094144769012928, 0.06755584478378296, -0.028010521084070206, -0.004291307646781206, -0.03545665740966797, 0.042226362973451614, -0.02863127551972866, -0.017368145287036896, 0.021159345284104347, -0.0199752114713192, 0.004870662000030279, 0.021592119708657265, 0.017234070226550102, -0.01173471286892891, 0.00005403384056990035, -0.026166152209043503, 0.010675129480659962, 0.021927453577518463, -0.0034154073800891638, -0.006911146454513073, 0.0017698326846584678, -0.0094889085739851, -0.00515739805996418, 0.005030189175158739, 0.022519374266266823, 0.00009388013131683692, -0.023233670741319656, -0.023411240428686142, -0.01534388680011034, 0.03913687542080879, -0.022380996495485306, -0.00682035880163312, -0.025827595964074135, 0.00011523150897119194, 0.014190947636961937, -0.01895102858543396 ]
<p>It seems that WinBUGS has problems <strong>if it has only zero draws from one binomial distribution</strong>:</p> <p><strong>1. case - simple model</strong></p> <pre><code>for (i in 1:sites) { N[i] ~ dpois(lambda) for (j in 1:sample) { y[i, j] ~ dbin(p, N[i]) } } </code></pre> <p>If all values <code>y[i,]</code> are zero, then the following error message appears:</p> <blockquote> <p><strong>value of order of binomial y[53,1] must be greater than zero</strong></p> </blockquote> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong> note that <code>N[i]</code> was not zero in generated data upon failure.</p> <p><strong>2. case - advanced removal model</strong></p> <pre><code>for (i in 1:sites) { M[i] ~ dpois(lambda) for (j in 1:sample) { y[i, j, 1] ~ dbin(p, M[i]) after_removal[i, j] &lt;- M[i] - y[i, j, 1] y[i, j, 2] ~ dbin(p, after_removal[i, j]) } } </code></pre> <p>Here it seems that if some <code>y[i, j, 2]</code> is zero then the error message (same as in case 1) appears!</p> <p>Note that in this case, I found a workaround: I reparametrized the model to different one which <strong>I hope</strong> is equivalent:</p> <pre><code>for (i in 1:sites) { M[i] ~ dpois(lambda) for (j in 1:sample) { y[i, j, 1] ~ dbin(p, M[i]) obs[i, j] &lt;- y[i, j, 1] + y[i, j, 2] obs[i, j] ~ dbin(p_komb, M[i]) } } p_komb &lt;- p + (1 - p) * p </code></pre> <p>... anyway an explanation, clean solution and solution for case 1 wanted:</p> <h2>Why this happens? Is it a WinBUGS bug? How can it be overriden?</h2> <p>I have WinBUGS 1.4.3 (August 2007) with immortality patch installed. Below is complete <strong>reproducible code for R and package R2WinBUGS (with data generation)</strong>:</p> <p><strong>1. case</strong></p> <pre><code>require(vcd) sites &lt;- 120 # 60 mean_N &lt;- 16 N &lt;- rpois(sites, mean_N) p &lt;- 0.4 sample &lt;- 3 # 3 y = matrix(nrow = sites, ncol = sample) for (i in 1:sites) { y[i,] = rbinom(sample, N[i], p) } y[20,] = 0 sink("tmp_bugs/model.txt") cat(" model { # likelihood for (i in 1:sites) { N[i] ~ dpois(lambda) for (j in 1:sample) { y[i, j] ~ dbin(p, N[i]) } } # derived parameters Ntot &lt;- sum(N[]) # priors p &lt;- 1/(1+exp(-logit_p)) tau &lt;- 1/(4 * 4) logit_p ~ dnorm(0, tau) lambda ~ dunif(0, 100) } ") sink() win.data = list(y = y, sample = sample, sites = sites) #win.data = list(y = y) #inits = function () { list(N = apply(y, 1, max), p = mean(apply(y, 1, mean)/apply(y, 1, max))) } inits = function () { list(N = apply(y, 1, max), logit_p = rnorm(1, 0, 4)) } params = c("N", "p", "Ntot", "lambda") ni &lt;- 500 nt &lt;- 12 nb &lt;- 200 nc &lt;- 3 out &lt;- bugs(win.data, inits, params, "model.txt", nc, ni, nb, nt, bugs.directory = bugs.dir, working.directory = paste(getwd(), "/tmp_bugs/", sep = ""), debug = TRUE ) print(out, dig = 3) par(mfrow = c(2, 2)) hist(out$sims.list$p, breaks = 100) abline(v = out$mean$p, col = "red", lwd = 2) abline(v = p, col = "green", lwd = 2) #lines(quantile(out$sims.list$p, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(sum(par("usr")[3:4]*c(0.9,0.1)), 2), lwd = 2) lines(quantile(out$sims.list$p, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(par("usr")[3], 2), lwd = 4) legend("topleft", c("estimated", "real", "95% cred. int."), col = c("red", "green", "black"), lty = 1, box.lty = 0, cex = 0.7) #hist(mean(y) / out$sims.list$p, breaks = 1000, xlim = c(0, 50)) hist(out$sims.list$Ntot, breaks = 100) abline(v = out$mean$Ntot, col = "red", lwd = 2) abline(v = sum(N), col = "green", lwd = 2) #lines(quantile(out$sims.list$Ntot, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(sum(par("usr")[3:4]*c(0.9,0.1)), 2), lwd = 2) lines(quantile(out$sims.list$Ntot, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(par("usr")[3], 2), lwd = 4) legend("topright", c("estimated total N", "real total N", "95% credible int."), col = c("red", "green", "black"), lty = 1, box.lty = 0, cex = 0.7) </code></pre> <p><strong>2. case</strong></p> <p>(one of the <code>y[i, j, 2]</code> will likely be zero; if not, it can be assigned directly)</p> <pre><code>require(vcd) sites &lt;- 120 # 60 mean_M &lt;- 16 M &lt;- rpois(sites, mean_M) p &lt;- 0.4 #0.64 sample &lt;- 2 # 3 y = rep(NA, sites * sample * 2) dim(y) = c(sites, sample, 2) for (i in 1:sites) { # obs[i,] = rbinom(sample, M[i], p) for (j in 1:sample) { y[i,j,1] = rbinom(1, M[i], p) y[i,j,2] = rbinom(1, M[i] - y[i,j,1], p) } } y_sample_total = apply(y, c(1, 2), sum) obs = y_sample_total ############################################ sink("tmp_bugs/model.txt") cat(" model { # likelihood for (i in 1:sites) { M[i] ~ dpois(lambda) for (j in 1:sample) { y[i, j, 1] ~ dbin(p, M[i]) after_removal[i, j] &lt;- M[i] - y[i, j, 1] y[i, j, 2] ~ dbin(p, after_removal[i, j]) } } # derived parameters Mtot &lt;- sum(M[]) # priors tau &lt;- 1/(4 * 4) p &lt;- 1/(1+exp(-logit_p)) logit_p ~ dnorm(0, tau) lambda ~ dunif(0, 100) } ") sink() win.data = list(y = y, #obs = y_sample_total, sample = sample, sites = sites) inits = function () { list( M = apply(y_sample_total, 1, max), logit_p = rnorm(1, 0, 4) ) } #params = c("M", "M2", "p", "p2", "Mtot", "M2tot", "lambda", "lambda2") params = c("M", "p", "Mtot", "lambda") ni &lt;- 2500 nt &lt;- 16 nb &lt;- 1000 nc &lt;- 3 date() out &lt;- bugs(win.data, inits, params, "model.txt", nc, ni, nb, nt, bugs.directory = "C:/Program Files/WinBUGS14/", working.directory = paste(getwd(), "/tmp_bugs/", sep = ""), debug = TRUE ) date() ############################# print(out, dig = 3) par(mfrow = c(2, 2)) hist(out$sims.list$p, breaks = 100) abline(v = out$mean$p, col = "red", lwd = 2) abline(v = p, col = "green", lwd = 2) #lines(quantile(out$sims.list$p, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(sum(par("usr")[3:4]*c(0.9,0.1)), 2), lwd = 2) lines(quantile(out$sims.list$p, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(par("usr")[3], 2), lwd = 4) legend("topleft", c("estimated", "real", "95% cred. int."), col = c("red", "green", "black"), lty = 1, box.lty = 0, cex = 0.7) #hist(mean(y) / out$sims.list$p, breaks = 1000, xlim = c(0, 50)) hist(out$sims.list$Mtot, breaks = 100) abline(v = out$mean$Mtot, col = "red", lwd = 2) abline(v = sum(M), col = "green", lwd = 2) #lines(quantile(out$sims.list$Mtot, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(sum(par("usr")[3:4]*c(0.9,0.1)), 2), lwd = 2) lines(quantile(out$sims.list$Mtot, c(0.025, 0.975)), rep(par("usr")[3], 2), lwd = 4) legend("topright", c("estimated total M", "real total M", "95% credible int."), col = c("red", "green", "black"), lty = 1, box.lty = 0, cex = 0.7) hist(out$sims.list$lambda) </code></pre>
74,349
[ -0.032420575618743896, -0.026810165494680405, 0.016810668632388115, -0.011659817770123482, 0.012604622170329094, -0.03454713895916939, -0.036063916981220245, 0.007722573354840279, -0.007229992188513279, -0.040953464806079865, 0.07040456682443619, 0.03916632756590843, 0.04412490874528885, 0.027355032041668892, 0.001616662135347724, 0.008233394473791122, 0.0031036308500915766, -0.01027392316609621, 0.003767473855987191, -0.004152317531406879, -0.0049252500757575035, 0.032660696655511856, -0.019450077787041664, 0.018294088542461395, -0.02984246239066124, -0.01027250848710537, -0.00420927070081234, 0.01802416518330574, -0.011601862497627735, 0.08254344761371613, -0.07495812326669693, -0.05960896983742714, 0.0040095094591379166, 0.005074873100966215, -0.01815742999315262, 0.03271947056055069, -0.0003469131188467145, -0.03925740346312523, 0.0012156135635450482, 0.010531619191169739, -0.0065303887240588665, -0.013322069309651852, -0.010596243664622307, 0.04062075540423393, -0.020094087347388268, 0.012851404026150703, 0.0003431251388974488, -0.005960643757134676, 0.05331314355134964, 0.0017508402233943343, 0.08062659949064255, -0.0294762272387743, -0.005074810702353716, 0.0000969426691881381, -0.015021675266325474, -0.013701274059712887, 0.03308718651533127, 0.04875649884343147, -0.01884155347943306, -0.04563169926404953, -0.024162819609045982, -0.01860220730304718, 0.024345964193344116, -0.017921434715390205, -0.023892603814601898, -0.00558630982413888, 0.001869307248853147, -0.044671013951301575, 0.03139952942728996, 0.001675741164945066, 0.027088385075330734, -0.004876283463090658, 0.017101747915148735, -0.04998064786195755, 0.027883879840373993, -0.02015811577439308, -0.030900541692972183, -0.02378682978451252, 0.005962664727121592, 0.04369126632809639, -0.0019118862692266703, 0.041934262961149216, -0.017508594319224358, 0.011336828581988811, 0.011436371132731438, -0.03879322111606598, 0.05305567383766174, -0.03966766223311424, 0.020459365099668503, 0.020256461575627327, -0.029363859444856644, -0.02919362671673298, 0.06576116383075714, -0.014899847097694874, -0.024444032460451126, 0.019127674400806427, 0.006667383946478367, 0.02223622240126133, -0.020996039733290672, 0.003059609094634652, -0.05605900660157204, -0.0556306317448616, 0.00807281769812107, 0.035724442452192307, -0.03127593547105789, 0.009967699646949768, -0.04693387821316719, -0.015582004562020302, -0.023850392550230026, -0.02338736690580845, -0.03227241709828377, 0.06559634953737259, -0.0015523076290264726, -0.025088321417570114, 0.0070832776837050915, 0.001918549183756113, -0.009072260931134224, -0.004158983007073402, 0.03143870458006859, 0.06923405826091766, 0.04544082283973694, -0.0052322763949632645, 0.009712865576148033, -0.04813501983880997, -0.06742380559444427, -0.04925873875617981, 0.03975466266274452, -0.02745109423995018, -0.036034028977155685, 0.03829014673829079, 0.012554238550364971, -0.004549499601125717, 0.07390884310007095, -0.004799617454409599, 0.06556849926710129, 0.027279242873191833, -0.037627190351486206, -0.0715789869427681, 0.007537360768765211, -0.028294771909713745, 0.0229161586612463, 0.004954414442181587, -0.025049926713109016, 0.005555718671530485, 0.032805923372507095, -0.00023526768200099468, 0.02341194823384285, 0.008476859889924526, 0.018522216007113457, -0.01599361002445221, -0.025656558573246002, -0.02221003733575344, -0.03884328901767731, -0.029311642050743103, -0.07234262675046921, -0.08003190904855728, 0.0633050724864006, 0.031170744448900223, -0.04541366919875145, 0.015659188851714134, 0.017573997378349304, 0.024301443248987198, -0.0005460137617774308, -0.04740218073129654, -0.007605738937854767, -0.022798432037234306, 0.03970898315310478, -0.016585294157266617, 0.045010823756456375, 0.024242615327239037, -0.04485131427645683, 0.03913009539246559, -0.007989794947206974, 0.04059349000453949, 0.004726744722574949, -0.038080114871263504, -0.0009315611678175628, -0.010303723625838757, 0.013307662680745125, 0.05923435091972351, -0.034771766513586044, 0.012444456107914448, 0.007309628184884787, -0.010979270562529564, 0.025670437142252922, 0.043129973113536835, -0.005716707557439804, -0.00771280936896801, 0.032231904566287994, -0.030890872702002525, -0.029896222054958344, -0.013297151774168015, 0.0010849059326574206, 0.025848355144262314, -0.009450813755393028, 0.015747150406241417, -0.004460334777832031, -0.028140608221292496, 0.03938658535480499, 0.04553339257836342, -0.0361495204269886, -0.026924708858132362, 0.05382012203335762, -0.023862265050411224, -0.01679333858191967, 0.0520269013941288, 0.024261822924017906, -0.002419582102447748, 0.044455546885728836, -0.044849418103694916, 0.0035905432887375355, -0.0063462816178798676, -0.027301868423819542, -0.014494208618998528, -0.012856355868279934, -0.01586497202515602, 0.008547455072402954, -0.03175092861056328, -0.024666933342814445, 0.01793050207197666, -0.07852945476770401, 0.014858994632959366, 0.10477185994386673, 0.0016205597203224897, 0.01275925524532795, 0.020522311329841614, -0.026678018271923065, 0.013269295915961266, -0.015860753133893013, -0.002357386751100421, -0.039994388818740845, -0.019850991666316986, 0.013198520056903362, 0.029150275513529778, -0.0294045303016901, 0.009514930658042431, 0.018705550581216812, -0.0012509927619248629, 0.001329708960838616, 0.038288798183202744, 0.02124064229428768, -0.016124442219734192, 0.04625186324119568, -0.00975125003606081, 0.03463476151227951, 0.006326597183942795, 0.0005428203148767352, -0.030140606686472893, -0.0028818538412451744, -0.03369894251227379, 0.015431092120707035, 0.0243019238114357, 0.05039820075035095, -0.027905385941267014, -0.01428391132503748, -0.004890192300081253, 0.04053628444671631, 0.0033878947142511606, -0.010168570093810558, 0.05086633190512657, 0.012223201803863049, 0.014745333231985569, -0.0037604207172989845, 0.005624661222100258, -0.0016743362648412585, 0.014672570861876011, -0.020711351186037064, 0.01793178915977478, 0.027986641973257065, -0.03461412712931633, 0.005886076483875513, -0.0164656862616539, -0.02536151558160782, -0.04109770804643631, 0.04847371578216553, 0.03966772183775902, 0.022860867902636528, 0.018327957019209862, -0.060736704617738724, 0.018493572250008583, -0.01379933301359415, 0.008555439300835133, 0.01581241749227047, 0.0005669466918334365, -0.04130399972200394, -0.011442895047366619, -0.018040426075458527, -0.012389292940497398, 0.01840355433523655, 0.016072671860456467, -0.06195634976029396, 0.027281465008854866, 0.009684240445494652, -0.01096577849239111, -0.02993050403892994, 0.008219358511269093, -0.004806543234735727, 0.01561149675399065, -0.03045826219022274, 0.037555959075689316, 0.024994850158691406, -0.04047834500670433, 0.01710466668009758, -0.018518010154366493, 0.01783999428153038, -0.011739724315702915, -0.0005410981830209494, 0.0010246909223496914, 0.012051775120198727, -0.004314054269343615, 0.0010785661870613694, 0.0297401063144207, 0.00537647632881999, -0.08611126244068146, -0.06171305105090141, -0.023316429927945137, 0.010423279367387295, 0.029833657667040825, 0.009834733791649342, 0.02279507741332054, 0.09447890520095825, 0.0557536855340004, 0.013590325601398945, -0.022424761205911636, -0.004662296734750271, -0.041601065546274185, -0.03023405186831951, 0.012455401942133904, -0.0016689805779606104, -0.0018739576917141676, 0.03171543776988983, -0.01904487982392311, 0.022128012031316757, 0.04858892783522606, -0.019657893106341362, 0.000485669617773965, 0.02238859049975872, 0.017539342865347862, -0.021005569025874138, 0.0405941940844059, -0.019652849063277245, 0.012111100368201733, 0.007595537230372429, 0.008244849741458893, 0.02772710844874382, -0.024961013346910477, -0.037309467792510986, 0.00411022175103426, -0.006003829184919596, 0.030904613435268402, -0.017415858805179596, 0.026918107643723488, 0.020315907895565033, -0.06992544233798981, -0.02320163883268833, 0.016784701496362686, 0.0566779226064682, -0.01478936430066824, -0.019744019955396652, 0.04809495061635971, 0.032786957919597626, -0.04234457015991211, 0.038815002888441086, -0.032929662615060806, -0.03426850587129593, 0.024525508284568787, -0.014752937480807304, 0.01660005934536457, 0.0044944556429982185, 0.01864447444677353, -0.015836117789149284, 0.010630590841174126, -0.008432377129793167, -0.000012406685527821537, -0.031546346843242645, 0.039838071912527084, -0.01661144196987152, 0.000834894657600671, -0.020949766039848328, 0.0023629500064998865, 0.006934511009603739, -0.022333329543471336, -0.01775987073779106, 0.035291463136672974, -0.021664321422576904, -0.02309235744178295, 0.027385935187339783, -0.01642504334449768, -0.011841168627142906, -0.042165957391262054, 0.0404701866209507, -0.022397635504603386, 0.025695044547319412, -0.011295746080577374, 0.05293698236346245, -0.029826531186699867, 0.045998506247997284, -0.013002629391849041, -0.007353176362812519, -0.0018070567166432738, 0.022702643647789955, 0.03253057971596718, 0.016387587413191795, 0.036246996372938156, 0.01700976863503456, -0.0067602358758449554, 0.014177217148244381, 0.004510489758104086, -0.0020002371165901423, 0.0035977191291749477, 0.022265436127781868, 0.026418225839734077, 0.05418899655342102, -0.06335335969924927, -0.02564282715320587, -0.016995709389448166, 0.030202770605683327, 0.0987328514456749, -0.01772972382605076, -0.0016473913565278053, -0.0632796585559845, -0.021395394578576088, 0.028696764260530472, 0.041284214705228806, -0.0018069318030029535, -0.00475876871496439, 0.04535413533449173, 0.022069286555051804, -0.04033723846077919, -0.0057190642692148685, 0.040192216634750366, 0.020336614921689034, 0.02804066427052021, 0.0006150300614535809, 0.022385133430361748, 0.015902623534202576, 0.0006906367489136755, -0.01491721160709858, 0.05004175752401352, -0.008340228348970413, -0.05245295166969299, 0.03410644084215164, 0.0031697021331638098, -0.024005603045225143, 0.015817562118172646, 0.007341993972659111, 0.03036225400865078, -0.025410804897546768, 0.017530979588627815, 0.032252486795186996, 0.021303562447428703, 0.0013387397630140185, 0.02782297134399414, -0.018239540979266167, -0.06871405988931656, 0.005549242254346609, 0.03737449645996094, 0.06316579133272171, 0.01450686901807785, 0.0006648040725849569, -0.07333612442016602, -0.03049059771001339, -0.02345462329685688, -0.0062544457614421844, 0.03829475864768028, 0.01950444094836712, 0.025247925892472267, 0.0018983195768669248, -0.04278560355305672, -0.08071544021368027, 0.010563874617218971, -0.05173463374376297, 0.026545928791165352, -0.01986510492861271, -0.0018198651960119605, -0.03766590356826782, -0.014570401050150394, 0.04599815607070923, 0.04978231340646744, -0.04814404994249344, -0.021373283118009567, 0.017199169844388962, 0.015393613837659359, -0.04294645041227341, -0.013053469359874725, 0.02584250271320343, 0.015602285973727703, -0.009764928370714188, 0.09814140945672989, -0.006223227828741074, -0.0024866736494004726, 0.011739997193217278, 0.05501352623105049, -0.003707572352141142, 0.03445197641849518, -0.00694452878087759, 0.0019313778029754758, 0.03376616910099983, -0.02023044228553772, 0.06376810371875763, 0.056298185139894485, -0.018953055143356323, -0.0153981763869524, -0.05348505079746246, -0.011956702917814255, -0.053798772394657135, 0.0127450255677104, -0.0848621129989624, 0.01334133930504322, 0.01359365601092577, -0.00009731988393468782, 0.022867118939757347, 0.019599365070462227, -0.04465371370315552, -0.006868744734674692, 0.021128641441464424, -0.0034061907790601254, -0.0274557713419199, -0.015540544874966145, -0.026439398527145386, 0.029724575579166412, -0.03620004653930664, 0.02516855299472809, 0.02400941029191017, -0.03620176389813423, 0.00985404010862112, 0.004479848314076662, -0.023956729099154472, 0.0058065555058419704, -0.010651650838553905, 0.0011381952790543437, -0.01685202307999134, -0.00860176794230938, 0.015886107459664345, -0.001656763139180839, 0.03738635405898094, -0.002914074808359146, -0.021077921614050865, 0.0066925277933478355, -0.015040755271911621, -0.009975791908800602, -0.018105264753103256, 0.009426100179553032, 0.0076515027321875095, 0.00013286778994370252, 0.015437908470630646, -0.0807652696967125, -0.008205724880099297, -0.002749694511294365, 0.012514796108007431, -0.04478034749627113, -0.03134286031126976, -0.053108103573322296, -0.00759795680642128, -0.03956667706370354, -0.015836425125598907, 0.04856906831264496, -0.05831244960427284, 0.005757909268140793, -0.005870436783879995, -0.005612924695014954, 0.07237932831048965, -0.015410475432872772, -0.007255844306200743, 0.024117132648825645, -0.015986338257789612, -0.021484287455677986, -0.01122510526329279, -0.01894812472164631, -0.027732690796256065, 0.010422758758068085, -0.005843675695359707, 0.015601268038153648, 0.038426414132118225, -0.021619603037834167, -0.04074627906084061, 0.017159229144454002, 0.003851116867735982, -0.013223345391452312, -0.012850460596382618, -0.015306778252124786, -0.012021426111459732, 0.00753948325291276, -0.05367204546928406, 0.02870972268283367, 0.011877763085067272, 0.004929345566779375, 0.048231836408376694, -0.029151836410164833, 0.03275791183114052, 0.015571504831314087, 0.09666946530342102, -0.002454151399433613, 0.00019782851450145245, 0.0071287271566689014, 0.000858933839481324, 0.02088639698922634, -0.01170011144131422, -0.017329605296254158, -0.028969010338187218, 0.01636345125734806, -0.010036149993538857, -0.011793801560997963, -0.04435379430651665, 0.0533624105155468, 0.019824495539069176, 0.02586841955780983, 0.04198179394006729, 0.01788611337542534, 0.0022253564093261957, -0.010880081914365292, -0.06088368967175484, -0.00413972744718194, 0.010085737332701683, -0.0018483961466699839, 0.0763615146279335, 0.013057648204267025, -0.020815936848521233, 0.08133234083652496, 0.03221990540623665, 0.0668475553393364, 0.038129087537527084, 0.012996268458664417, -0.029504595324397087, 0.06045226380228996, -0.03446302190423012, -0.017086070030927658, 0.0019911162089556456, -0.049441345036029816, -0.0010790623491629958, -0.017849907279014587, -0.03208949789404869, 0.06499002128839493, 0.04216713830828667, -0.004139584489166737, -0.05396023392677307, -0.023144029080867767, -0.04316411539912224, 0.021337028592824936, 0.02137640118598938, -0.03370494768023491, 0.027309995144605637, 0.0034688105806708336, 0.036436744034290314, 0.021641813218593597, 0.03374313935637474, -0.011953290551900864, -0.03917510807514191, -0.037328485399484634, -0.004131235182285309, -0.010067688301205635, 0.048645906150341034, -0.01746208220720291, -0.007088906597346067, 0.010072896257042885, -0.006771671585738659, 0.08248382061719894, 0.00832607876509428, 0.04052240401506424, -0.001216722303070128, 0.03461466729640961, -0.018039673566818237, 0.009296220727264881, -0.01197450328618288, -0.0010697952238842845, 0.15977619588375092, 0.07012418657541275, 0.059516649693250656, -0.05634148046374321, -0.016001202166080475, 0.04881230741739273, -0.016581004485487938, 0.02067430689930916, -0.038624923676252365, 0.035818006843328476, -0.02534601278603077, 0.05121825262904167, 0.030596885830163956, -0.005123075097799301, 0.018410073593258858, 0.013497661799192429, -0.05652874335646629, -0.015703415498137474, 0.010466017760336399, 0.04329686984419823, -0.0012437512632459402, -0.021081095561385155, -0.043224036693573, 0.0037073278799653053, 0.05843339487910271, -0.020178357139229774, -0.0037613168824464083, -0.012924387119710445, -0.01780768856406212, 0.03154851868748665, -0.017949847504496574, 0.018677761778235435, 0.0015184334479272366, -0.014121967367827892, 0.03597932681441307, 0.0012362680863589048, 0.02774270996451378, -0.02121730148792267, -0.0038088043220341206, 0.06574248522520065, 0.03350771218538284, 0.004262128379195929, -0.002226320095360279, 0.02331865020096302, -0.05060071125626564, -0.029962942004203796, -0.019841641187667847, 0.0263824462890625, -0.01617772877216339, 0.003259324934333563, -0.011048981919884682, -0.05112680420279503, 0.00926295854151249, -0.02788713574409485, -0.018609194085001945, 0.033091526478528976, 0.028460800647735596, 0.003285830607637763, -0.031034983694553375, -0.020322231575846672, -0.00899466872215271, 0.028497250750660896, 0.008097780868411064, 0.02016606368124485, -0.027796713635325432, -0.07312911748886108, 0.004736022558063269, 0.07399394363164902, -0.008216457441449165, 0.02647969499230385, 0.02620627172291279, -0.018002260476350784, 0.0016748592024669051, -0.030138205736875534, -0.026592057198286057, -0.028613870963454247, 0.05491809919476509, 0.00979649182409048, -0.04259369522333145, -0.049864135682582855, -0.028989296406507492, -0.003684478346258402, -0.04985644668340683, -0.028494376689195633, -0.018507109954953194, -0.03503111004829407, -0.002281928202137351, 0.024032846093177795, 0.025342419743537903, -0.02384069748222828, -0.002898001577705145, 0.06434372067451477, -0.005622963886708021, -0.027288617566227913, -0.01537097804248333, -0.01005278155207634, -0.0464949868619442, -0.026205312460660934, 0.01007124688476324, 0.04397938773036003, 0.014212134294211864, 0.015234782360494137, 0.01695365458726883, 0.04674173519015312, -0.013102789409458637, -0.018991360440850258, 0.012802365235984325, -0.048881467431783676, -0.00789090245962143, 0.03501543030142784, -0.027108198031783104, -0.027305128052830696, 0.030647873878479004, -0.033912479877471924, -0.025894850492477417, 0.04831879213452339, -0.017617108300328255, -0.04319223389029503, -0.051976028829813004, -0.00773498835042119, -0.006472423672676086, -0.0006782255368307233, -0.051710937172174454, -0.016740161925554276, -0.022750617936253548, -0.013036131858825684, -0.012352057732641697, 0.009267942048609257, 0.0020018306095153093, -0.013109731487929821, 0.012385182082653046, -0.0053425999358296394, 0.005955361295491457, -0.0017261255998164415, -0.016418874263763428, -0.002072459552437067, 0.02633562684059143, 0.05616270378232002, 0.013803575187921524, 0.00899333693087101, -0.015002747997641563, -0.03992307931184769, -0.027646927163004875, -0.008893249556422234, 0.019616058096289635, 0.03755807876586914, -0.003110191086307168, 0.007523865904659033, -0.05341397598385811, 0.05378926917910576, -0.011673822067677975, -0.005148948635905981, 0.0018389095785096288, 0.02404208481311798, 0.009798108600080013, -0.02951676771044731, -0.009073158726096153, 0.010330604389309883, -0.01833437569439411, 0.009545160457491875, 0.0042404234409332275, 0.005895421374589205, -0.0030827580485492945, -0.014872877858579159, -0.02567177079617977, 0.02766970358788967, -0.015640754252672195, 0.00612145708873868, -0.03405293822288513, 0.04308377578854561, -0.015531551092863083, 0.036097507923841476, -0.02015537954866886, 0.005069783888757229, -0.11682265251874924, -0.04201662912964821, 0.03196212649345398, 0.008446510881185532, 0.040935955941677094, -0.04930669069290161, 0.02978748455643654, 0.04336053133010864, -0.04740499332547188, -0.023457732051610947, 0.0008703843341208994, 0.032436247915029526, -0.018367722630500793, 0.02299112267792225, -0.0447356291115284, 0.009464683942496777, 0.032110463827848434, 0.01889902353286743, 0.05835765600204468, 0.02141381986439228, -0.004164054989814758, -0.042342010885477066, -0.0032367072999477386, -0.006699875462800264, 0.028233317658305168, -0.04656190797686577, 0.014619105495512486, -0.039181966334581375, 0.0171505194157362, -0.004438322503119707, -0.04038216546177864, -0.006333498749881983, 0.0030536374542862177, 0.06740204244852066, 0.059611719101667404, 0.0541294626891613, 0.028322366997599602, -0.002193829510360956, 0.025302620604634285, -0.010531231760978699, -0.0020193078089505434, 0.02489444613456726, -0.012851573526859283, 0.040719810873270035, 0.046573176980018616, -0.018555976450443268, -0.005509051028639078, -0.008284671232104301, -0.004793848376721144, -0.0363316535949707, 0.003268588101491332, 0.021871861070394516, -0.017835967242717743, -0.02053138054907322, 0.02891007624566555, -0.048136647790670395, 0.018227919936180115, 0.08840219676494598, 0.017307056114077568, -0.014029507525265217, 0.00408530980348587, -0.010456105694174767, -0.05532568320631981, -0.021488774567842484, -0.0020665929187089205, -0.047072526067495346, -0.026853321120142937, 0.030190052464604378, -0.03120214305818081, -0.008611033670604229, -0.031032804399728775, -0.011181477457284927, -0.08401767164468765, 0.052983663976192474, -0.03830424323678017, -0.00016394117847085, -0.008516225032508373, 0.0074925911612808704, 0.041382595896720886, -0.09833838790655136, 0.044132813811302185, 0.0019383637700229883, -0.005895265843719244, -0.013095902279019356, -0.04651261493563652, 0.005596823059022427, 0.02942732721567154, 0.03603695333003998, 0.015201335772871971, -0.012716361321508884, 0.04640958085656166, 0.008868040516972542, -0.012713629752397537, -0.025575516745448112, 0.029507586732506752, 0.003062406787648797, 0.011003454215824604, 0.020077170804142952, 0.024302691221237183, 0.002758714370429516, 0.023877233266830444, -0.016653940081596375, 0.007774962577968836, -0.019738949835300446, 0.044138990342617035, 0.027814941480755806, -0.014377405866980553, -0.01944085583090782, 0.006740247365087271, 0.03536094352602959, -0.00007639409886905923, 0.02858646959066391, 0.010674634948372841, 0.029283562675118446, -0.07031845301389694, 0.033747997134923935, -0.027985965833067894, -0.03283676132559776, 0.020321274176239967, -0.015114170499145985, -0.005616007838398218, -0.00982972327619791, 0.007557470817118883, 0.00015412709035445005, -0.0017548786709085107, -0.04878931865096092, 0.006312517449259758, -0.0022483584471046925, 0.06000925600528717, 0.002547275274991989, 0.028206875547766685, -0.006788917817175388, -0.03852730244398117, 0.05216280370950699, 0.009392758831381798, -0.023751895874738693, 0.008778558112680912, 0.0016211641486734152, -0.030096109956502914, -0.021316831931471825, 0.039748042821884155, 0.006643086206167936, 0.05333637073636055, 0.01350125577300787, -0.016023708507418633, 0.02716083638370037, -0.03471057862043381, 0.0029041036032140255, 0.008707224391400814, -0.014542126096785069, 0.05080080032348633, 0.016644785180687904, 0.03620133176445961, -0.02033347636461258, -0.041964784264564514, 0.0026918468065559864, -0.00008646446076454595, -0.03066456876695156, 0.022491982206702232, 0.007630929816514254, 0.01135169342160225, 0.030992640182375908, -0.007643274497240782, -0.017181454226374626, -0.020209690555930138, -0.015888197347521782, 0.04608720913529396, 0.005827724002301693, 0.02669861912727356, 0.0011305974330753088, 0.0035105538554489613, -0.020914312452077866, 0.027502989396452904, 0.02382444031536579, -0.010606134310364723, -0.07932265102863312, 0.004290785174816847, 0.011952409520745277, 0.001964148133993149, -0.02700824849307537, -0.001281793462112546, -0.010777518153190613, 0.01458113081753254, 0.008382621221244335, -0.018119854852557182 ]
<p>When given samples of a discrete random variable, the entropy of the distribution may be estimated by $- \sum \hat{P_i} \log{\hat{P_i}}$, where $\hat{P_i}$ is the sample estimate of the frequency of the $i$th value. (this is up to a constant determined by the base of the log.) This estimate should not be applied to observations from a continuous distribution, at least naively, because it would yield a value which depends only on the sample size.</p> <p><a href="http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.87.5281" rel="nofollow">Beirlant <em>et al</em></a> describe a number of approaches for the continuous problem, including estimates based on empirical CDF, nearest neighbor distances and the $m$-spacing estimate, which is given by $$\frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^{n-m}\log{(\frac{n}{m}(X_{(i+m)} - X_{(i)}))}$$, where $X_{(i)}$ is the $i$th order statistic of the sample, and $m$ varies in a certain way with $n$. It is not clear how this estimate is to be computed in the presence of ties, <em>i.e.</em> it does not appear to be applicable to discrete distributions. (a naive correction for ties (drop terms which have $\log{0}$) appears to give an estimator which does not depend on the relative frequency of the classes, only their values, which seems wrong.) </p> <p>The question: is there an 'all-purpose' estimator which can deal with both discrete and continuous (or even mixed) distributions?</p>
37,205
[ -0.056629665195941925, -0.01423091720789671, 0.029235754162073135, -0.005086429417133331, -0.013449477031826973, 0.059228792786598206, -0.010353364050388336, 0.05302556976675987, 0.00834998395293951, -0.07030254602432251, 0.040215689688920975, 0.06865576654672623, 0.011756516993045807, 0.025480400770902634, 0.012933180667459965, -0.007298795972019434, -0.053428202867507935, 0.036709535866975784, 0.013539114035665989, -0.006740257143974304, 0.018908577039837837, 0.04811813309788704, 0.02042088843882084, -0.021636297926306725, -0.04000239446759224, 0.046294186264276505, 0.02170129492878914, -0.014669575728476048, 0.002278341678902507, 0.07073734700679779, -0.015689264982938766, -0.031548965722322464, 0.03146789222955704, 0.057879041880369186, 0.017288587987422943, -0.015582169406116009, -0.04857587814331055, -0.03870303928852081, -0.006052532233297825, 0.006614378187805414, -0.05698440223932266, -0.03375013917684555, -0.014775830321013927, -0.0195210762321949, -0.023990148678421974, 0.043744612485170364, 0.00855299737304449, -0.051843494176864624, 0.011338877491652966, -0.050641242414712906, 0.04677780717611313, -0.025818586349487305, 0.019917886704206467, -0.00073897500988096, -0.04071798548102379, 0.009726632386446, 0.02460535429418087, 0.06439215689897537, 0.015331944450736046, -0.04440607503056526, 0.006644353736191988, -0.0459720641374588, 0.011452295817434788, -0.015922795981168747, -0.008746801875531673, 0.03244462236762047, -0.01365644484758377, -0.007938310503959656, 0.02672724425792694, -0.01845795288681984, -0.02096862532198429, 0.00573888560757041, 0.06853454560041428, 0.03457490727305412, 0.03525441884994507, -0.01650099642574787, 0.011337576434016228, 0.025317274034023285, 0.0736689642071724, 0.02680048905313015, 0.002977633848786354, -0.025373922660946846, 0.02158200368285179, 0.04581376910209656, 0.04433714225888252, -0.06900499761104584, 0.07278064638376236, -0.04025469347834587, 0.06077834218740463, 0.013909691013395786, -0.0071083796210587025, -0.03100014477968216, 0.014394497498869896, -0.02732671983540058, -0.058620985597372055, 0.030992962419986725, -0.024487614631652832, -0.0024146498180925846, -0.016777124255895615, -0.025475386530160904, 0.0047017671167850494, -0.024398677051067352, 0.014023322612047195, 0.05844978988170624, -0.023355621844530106, 0.021734608337283134, -0.04398109391331673, 0.0024621945340186357, 0.01151352934539318, -0.02402760460972786, 0.004867876414209604, -0.010220113210380077, 0.029091348871588707, -0.009692621417343616, -0.01776561699807644, 0.006549997255206108, -0.0028960194904357195, 0.002009220886975527, 0.04397260397672653, 0.04899297282099724, 0.033637214452028275, -0.014292798936367035, -0.006648787762969732, -0.05330144241452217, -0.04644278809428215, 0.010635404847562313, 0.04768940061330795, -0.019225353375077248, -0.04423794895410538, 0.027902014553546906, -0.02712269499897957, -0.0011832657037302852, 0.028725674375891685, 0.009727158583700657, -0.004536573309451342, -0.011828909628093243, -0.07392463833093643, -0.03214498236775398, 0.015818942338228226, 0.016594192013144493, -0.02915351651608944, -0.03521589934825897, -0.008330591022968292, 0.027137966826558113, 0.01575513742864132, 0.022730501368641853, 0.060862522572278976, -0.021458622068166733, 0.061802394688129425, 0.03192618116736412, -0.030133157968521118, 0.004126408137381077, -0.04078347235918045, -0.004407171625643969, -0.05036897957324982, -0.06377316266298294, 0.03887508809566498, 0.03740977868437767, -0.006010548677295446, 0.014089824631810188, 0.0024775173515081406, 0.04798590764403343, -0.05145783722400665, -0.0044349804520606995, 0.004447192419320345, -0.03610806539654732, 0.050059594213962555, -0.027631383389234543, 0.06336938589811325, -0.0008245868375524879, 0.026005152612924576, -0.00788106955587864, 0.03325888141989708, 0.037420324981212616, 0.050395555794239044, -0.022636786103248596, -0.006273596081882715, -0.06515336036682129, -0.0013568204594776034, 0.01713528111577034, -0.011478692293167114, -0.017193539068102837, -0.002992333611473441, -0.010987001471221447, 0.0023010605946183205, -0.01456130389124155, 0.023044133558869362, -0.011780718341469765, 0.04511575028300285, -0.02814340963959694, -0.05749189481139183, -0.07700708508491516, -0.01886088401079178, -0.01470049750059843, -0.03135628253221512, 0.043329790234565735, 0.030298667028546333, 0.03610643744468689, 0.019063882529735565, -0.024293212220072746, 0.003167038783431053, -0.029334120452404022, 0.04874902218580246, -0.047388870269060135, -0.019482063129544258, 0.036517463624477386, 0.0635920837521553, -0.021984407678246498, 0.04673119634389877, -0.0104591753333807, -0.08573170751333237, -0.031202442944049835, -0.04588264226913452, 0.028787793591618538, -0.01124415174126625, 0.020987780764698982, 0.0450935922563076, -0.026972603052854538, -0.007564428262412548, 0.005458289757370949, -0.01678377576172352, 0.031183307990431786, 0.057482149451971054, 0.02951725386083126, -0.015349142253398895, 0.00021880993153899908, 0.014072470366954803, -0.014510422013700008, -0.0288202166557312, -0.02551695518195629, -0.051494110375642776, -0.024484742432832718, 0.045032236725091934, 0.04658159986138344, -0.035361725836992264, 0.002990308217704296, 0.04731231927871704, 0.05087815597653389, 0.009580269455909729, 0.00754902046173811, -0.04969318211078644, -0.035876624286174774, 0.018531201407313347, 0.014628731645643711, 0.022098958492279053, -0.006506025325506926, 0.053162042051553726, -0.013547425158321857, 0.040781307965517044, -0.010534060187637806, 0.010763270780444145, 0.009105423465371132, 0.00480180187150836, -0.021666737273335457, -0.01510703470557928, -0.031061792746186256, 0.028569458052515984, -0.04322265461087227, -0.014077452942728996, 0.025355450809001923, -0.01502315979450941, 0.01623607985675335, 0.028306422755122185, -0.009992985054850578, 0.02258775569498539, 0.0023063761182129383, -0.034368399530649185, -0.016027238219976425, 0.014061358757317066, -0.05694735050201416, -0.0048999483697116375, 0.004521079361438751, -0.029396122321486473, 0.017907746136188507, 0.035422198474407196, 0.0119269248098135, 0.020266257226467133, 0.009071462787687778, -0.017741609364748, -0.004378156270831823, -0.0183915663510561, 0.009604720398783684, 0.014899893663823605, 0.03671609237790108, -0.006051546428352594, -0.028024999424815178, 0.018274841830134392, -0.015962673351168633, 0.03143039718270302, 0.016278395429253578, -0.01934397965669632, -0.022385166957974434, -0.01430589146912098, -0.05329670011997223, -0.004332255572080612, 0.0014188281493261456, 0.01185932382941246, -0.06292150169610977, 0.005736654624342918, 0.05316856876015663, 0.008552813902497292, -0.052772849798202515, 0.0391668863594532, -0.03020058386027813, -0.03509415686130524, -0.03759756684303284, 0.00519010704010725, 0.004306111019104719, -0.011921491473913193, 0.0007006183150224388, 0.02146277204155922, 0.038633305579423904, -0.02147386223077774, -0.06462132930755615, -0.0809854045510292, 0.028470231220126152, -0.016598928719758987, 0.019579973071813583, 0.02436351776123047, -0.03000388853251934, 0.06710245460271835, 0.015220803208649158, -0.014512425288558006, -0.021448323503136635, -0.0010082857916131616, 0.0048834397457540035, 0.028949303552508354, 0.020306583493947983, 0.023529546335339546, -0.0009235803154297173, 0.009909600019454956, 0.0164572075009346, 0.009989630430936813, 0.008431784808635712, -0.01578754559159279, 0.011629669927060604, 0.06961040943861008, -0.004217685200273991, -0.019184906035661697, 0.013042409904301167, 0.027218719944357872, 0.004825772251933813, 0.004448618274182081, 0.006349870935082436, -0.032186709344387054, 0.029040368273854256, -0.031040091067552567, 0.03583630546927452, -0.006817879155278206, 0.005615659523755312, -0.008245343342423439, 0.02739887312054634, 0.004634807351976633, -0.04035579413175583, -0.0004760810697916895, 0.03921864926815033, 0.030443165451288223, -0.023655911907553673, 0.02257302962243557, 0.040183067321777344, 0.07936840504407883, -0.002284071873873472, 0.0008612584206275642, -0.0057548112235963345, -0.0003111587429884821, 0.05164877325296402, -0.06722608208656311, 0.014868810772895813, -0.029415924102067947, 0.04889335110783577, 0.0062778666615486145, -0.021044446155428886, -0.05458986759185791, 0.027631843462586403, -0.04587623476982117, -0.018878955394029617, -0.04109150916337967, 0.05482335016131401, 0.014490153640508652, 0.05082579702138901, 0.006691124755889177, -0.020645178854465485, 0.050859615206718445, 0.025989200919866562, -0.0606958232820034, 0.0038373093120753765, 0.0158969908952713, -0.021293986588716507, 0.02018679492175579, -0.0016293424414470792, 0.052783939987421036, -0.0035808265674859285, 0.0044353255070745945, -0.011661610566079617, 0.028895899653434753, -0.021874448284506798, -0.0030722992960363626, -0.016182193532586098, -0.03304378688335419, 0.0359998419880867, 0.0242687426507473, 0.03434985503554344, -0.052399564534425735, -0.0013130470179021358, 0.014426919631659985, 0.03972136601805687, -0.0003763400309253484, -0.024997275322675705, 0.000021677109543816186, -0.00520585710182786, 0.018635686486959457, -0.03339932858943939, 0.021233435720205307, -0.038914598524570465, 0.03323943540453911, -0.029141942039132118, 0.06926555931568146, 0.01519640814512968, -0.03895363584160805, 0.015158007852733135, -0.0007424185168929398, -0.03303443640470505, 0.02549843303859234, 0.03984208032488823, -0.01629553735256195, 0.026844847947359085, 0.07156036049127579, 0.04272999241948128, -0.085700623691082, 0.008738257922232151, 0.04352409020066261, 0.0019770185463130474, 0.01557075697928667, -0.028419870883226395, 0.04675428569316864, -0.022914061322808266, 0.004541465081274509, 0.02235184609889984, 0.007821084931492805, 0.007044818252325058, -0.017291100695729256, 0.02792934700846672, 0.011980460956692696, -0.044301293790340424, -0.04410918802022934, 0.04376251995563507, 0.046416766941547394, -0.01039913110435009, -0.01215176098048687, 0.03669624775648117, 0.03350459784269333, 0.03417975455522537, -0.0069221858866512775, 0.02263125218451023, -0.09480214864015579, 0.005772517994046211, 0.030895760282874107, 0.01991867460310459, -0.02007330395281315, 0.017688730731606483, -0.041170112788677216, 0.004106586799025536, 0.02372344583272934, -0.015182513743638992, 0.014019749127328396, -0.008348810486495495, 0.01873641647398472, -0.030486704781651497, -0.02288590371608734, -0.06749514490365982, -0.0014237109571695328, 0.008970568887889385, 0.012112360447645187, -0.039971254765987396, -0.024556484073400497, -0.03138961270451546, 0.03044603019952774, 0.01245097629725933, 0.06921973079442978, -0.008080440573394299, -0.01603975147008896, 0.011991128325462341, -0.0050825742073357105, 0.0027861082926392555, -0.05221477150917053, 0.04021725803613663, -0.006795716937631369, -0.010849199257791042, 0.01844005286693573, -0.0386289581656456, -0.0022629471495747566, 0.00006628046685364097, 0.003625517012551427, -0.008851488120853901, 0.011086864396929741, 0.002942846855148673, 0.06943566352128983, 0.024548647925257683, 0.017471475526690483, 0.03326353803277016, 0.02948000840842724, 0.020046290010213852, 0.008765138685703278, -0.017294403165578842, 0.004819551482796669, -0.025424910709261894, -0.008188140578567982, -0.023701835423707962, -0.0007733923848718405, -0.026097843423485756, 0.0404164120554924, -0.030054835602641106, 0.04254363849759102, 0.023439636453986168, -0.021800611168146133, 0.003719654167070985, -0.009943751618266106, -0.013703200966119766, -0.007291877642273903, 0.022596344351768494, 0.05974955856800079, -0.0040953620336949825, 0.02097168006002903, 0.0724959746003151, -0.0086276950314641, -0.0018198584439232945, 0.014041966758668423, -0.05561508238315582, -0.0011831013252958655, -0.0349508598446846, -0.005907846614718437, 0.0018342715920880437, 0.0033940128050744534, 0.06551993638277054, 0.0021122461184859276, 0.04272691532969475, -0.016151759773492813, -0.024999814108014107, 0.00158669741358608, 0.024834800511598587, 0.004913702607154846, 0.05006950721144676, -0.005427933298051357, 0.021625667810440063, 0.026316776871681213, -0.027671437710523605, -0.060936089605093, -0.025875374674797058, 0.02518453821539879, 0.0008560694404877722, -0.03345813229680061, -0.05747528001666069, -0.0038540554232895374, 0.00797224324196577, -0.011007647961378098, 0.027364134788513184, 0.05964575335383415, 0.0038885807152837515, -0.01550876721739769, -0.02557333931326866, 0.04638269171118736, 0.06251229345798492, 0.006481072399765253, -0.030230388045310974, 0.020309576764702797, -0.010355799458920956, -0.00035978457890450954, 0.024393292143940926, -0.001615248853340745, -0.030590355396270752, 0.010663497261703014, 0.0008854405023157597, -0.0001450376003049314, 0.007005970925092697, 0.0000895299090188928, -0.04450889676809311, 0.041272759437561035, -0.013873584568500519, 0.008149205707013607, -0.005971491802483797, 0.01654413901269436, 0.002803787589073181, 0.011085942387580872, -0.045250557363033295, -0.01295777689665556, -0.01607530750334263, -0.0016298729460686445, 0.003264559432864189, 0.0003602932265494019, -0.0265180766582489, 0.025161560624837875, 0.04677904024720192, -0.006802218500524759, -0.002406506333500147, 0.015125924721360207, -0.040798984467983246, 0.05149093270301819, 0.0028559942729771137, -0.015368898399174213, 0.001286136219277978, 0.023672768846154213, -0.03669682890176773, -0.00925956666469574, -0.04407623037695885, -0.006618860177695751, 0.035639334470033646, 0.010158411227166653, 0.035506732761859894, 0.03913615643978119, 0.0047273458912968636, -0.0031784302555024624, 0.012971010990440845, 0.01070511993020773, 0.004741111304610968, 0.022455420345067978, 0.030275287106633186, -0.034994110465049744, -0.004060196224600077, 0.029944108799099922, 0.004228849429637194, -0.009853902272880077, 0.04649548977613449, -0.028255103155970573, 0.030512532219290733, 0.032292019575834274, -0.05823065713047981, -0.017326775938272476, 0.039479151368141174, -0.08103255182504654, 0.012836405076086521, 0.0019306970061734319, -0.02702331729233265, 0.024994967505335808, 0.012949168682098389, 0.020787712186574936, -0.030422315001487732, -0.0474882498383522, -0.021003758534789085, 0.014928044751286507, -0.008569270372390747, -0.019645558670163155, 0.047692976891994476, -0.05736306682229042, 0.012373916804790497, -0.0021311796735972166, 0.029573656618595123, 0.002100141253322363, -0.04749530553817749, 0.0034269196912646294, -0.00642667431384325, -0.061954133212566376, -0.022819334641098976, 0.005380022339522839, -0.04033437371253967, 0.01335548609495163, -0.046249374747276306, 0.0378529392182827, 0.03302272781729698, 0.04370388761162758, 0.00592287490144372, 0.059665028005838394, -0.02111879177391529, 0.008013089187443256, -0.041334640234708786, -0.029421674087643623, 0.15577003359794617, 0.04703230410814285, 0.06632717698812485, -0.04091846942901611, 0.009079321287572384, 0.029980381950736046, 0.0140300951898098, -0.02904491126537323, 0.004080463666468859, 0.011141394264996052, -0.029118603095412254, 0.03940984606742859, 0.06620266288518906, 0.013981342315673828, -0.04731576144695282, 0.03326696529984474, -0.009088371880352497, 0.025720002129673958, 0.008206687867641449, 0.010152393020689487, 0.022562509402632713, -0.01129562221467495, -0.05420976132154465, 0.014190342277288437, 0.06357372552156448, -0.005476630292832851, -0.014254841953516006, -0.02293502166867256, -0.015634149312973022, 0.016934145241975784, -0.03296584635972977, 0.01292748749256134, 0.02825423888862133, 0.010312245227396488, 0.03283778950572014, -0.021101675927639008, -0.0006599492626264691, 0.023944735527038574, -0.0019796795677393675, 0.01622086577117443, 0.014144054614007473, 0.0207211896777153, 0.009159395471215248, -0.007970845326781273, -0.06134876608848572, -0.03649376705288887, -0.04634824022650719, 0.005396783817559481, -0.01779209077358246, -0.0013288623886182904, 0.0026071430183947086, -0.034468334168195724, -0.022497612982988358, -0.026879098266363144, -0.031735002994537354, 0.018153812736272812, 0.015168529935181141, -0.01039454247802496, -0.04352247342467308, -0.020878566429018974, 0.02164710871875286, -0.011650878004729748, 0.01115642860531807, -0.010908396914601326, -0.05371291935443878, -0.036883823573589325, 0.026872668415308, 0.03276549652218819, -0.01186563540250063, -0.007345809135586023, -0.008734003640711308, -0.018792789429426193, -0.04273776710033417, -0.02066800929605961, -0.009125746786594391, -0.02493593655526638, 0.06285680085420609, 0.03602609783411026, -0.009345436468720436, -0.03582119941711426, -0.011485876515507698, -0.02556253783404827, -0.026060018688440323, 0.002124637132510543, -0.023309845477342606, 0.004287919029593468, 0.018743334338068962, 0.01370227336883545, 0.017910603433847427, -0.0009859297424554825, 0.03254079073667526, 0.050352226942777634, 0.003859139047563076, -0.01216635387390852, 0.01784457266330719, 0.01631496101617813, -0.031237659975886345, 0.003339998656883836, 0.039023466408252716, 0.017405400052666664, 0.03277905285358429, 0.01279748696833849, -0.008716917596757412, 0.02683512680232525, 0.026434024795889854, 0.03245548903942108, 0.008513761684298515, -0.05207449942827225, -0.026344208046793938, 0.03239826858043671, -0.04157242551445961, -0.015546351671218872, -0.01256608497351408, -0.06882916390895844, -0.02426988258957863, -0.009158898144960403, -0.026645412668585777, -0.027736308053135872, -0.01059772726148367, -0.017066985368728638, 0.010330851189792156, -0.011234787292778492, -0.01261173840612173, -0.017020542174577713, -0.03136095032095909, -0.041874323040246964, 0.051689159125089645, 0.001990577904507518, -0.0006055053672753274, -0.03655247762799263, 0.021924057975411415, 0.04757360368967056, 0.012993039563298225, 0.008168919011950493, 0.009853326715528965, -0.00684076314792037, 0.01640339568257332, 0.04889494180679321, -0.022118208929896355, -0.04936733469367027, 0.03617876395583153, -0.03588744252920151, -0.04214797914028168, 0.021551715210080147, -0.016020014882087708, 0.030304256826639175, 0.0182208139449358, 0.010032651014626026, -0.04383367300033569, 0.036802276968955994, -0.06961828470230103, 0.015869829803705215, -0.0392875075340271, 0.010276425629854202, 0.0329650342464447, -0.012840930372476578, 0.002489313017576933, -0.018825849518179893, -0.013050362467765808, 0.03541078791022301, 0.027048969641327858, 0.0042756590992212296, -0.014109418727457523, 0.002807053504511714, -0.028996823355555534, 0.030178997665643692, 0.03145761042833328, 0.01874740608036518, 0.037255048751831055, 0.03198691084980965, -0.010562391020357609, 0.05522923171520233, 0.02243417128920555, 0.00011932413326576352, -0.08739231526851654, -0.02253669872879982, 0.05292735621333122, 0.01939084753394127, 0.007608375512063503, -0.05057474598288536, -0.017071880400180817, -0.003581168595701456, -0.040559057146310806, 0.03558873012661934, -0.019245656207203865, -0.009817433543503284, -0.04475752264261246, 0.04089796170592308, -0.04843007028102875, 0.011329542845487595, 0.021141480654478073, 0.02960440143942833, 0.031861402094364166, 0.03695622831583023, -0.04939405620098114, 0.007093643769621849, -0.008238222450017929, 0.0260367002338171, 0.013320164754986763, -0.07026532292366028, 0.020309187471866608, -0.017873616889119148, -0.012338993139564991, 0.05019095540046692, -0.035149626433849335, 0.001534495735540986, 0.022730519995093346, 0.029061628505587578, 0.009609163738787174, 0.03384875878691673, 0.029594222083687782, -0.032527368515729904, -0.012899264693260193, 0.016249246895313263, 0.02685551717877388, 0.0036144263576716185, -0.011165950447320938, 0.0046938275918364525, 0.017745593562722206, -0.005343015771359205, -0.053855907171964645, 0.006592997815459967, -0.009598451666533947, 0.016237586736679077, 0.002097995951771736, -0.025240544229745865, 0.014641453512012959, 0.018767667934298515, 0.046498432755470276, -0.05589784309267998, -0.0033870087936520576, -0.011697481386363506, 0.01922941394150257, 0.0008287708624266088, 0.00038094184128567576, -0.008650925941765308, -0.037236377596855164, -0.005933608394116163, 0.01002037525177002, -0.014549839310348034, -0.08503172546625137, -0.004605344031006098, 0.006688365712761879, 0.02376626431941986, -0.0159100741147995, -0.03641718998551369, 0.004590666387230158, 0.04599267989397049, -0.030325260013341904, 0.007906789891421795, -0.00457230769097805, -0.02952628768980503, 0.006962640676647425, -0.08953657746315002, 0.04498138651251793, 0.013863174244761467, 0.041806481778621674, 0.010628549382090569, 0.001226963708177209, -0.03405041992664337, -0.01152124535292387, 0.07833245396614075, 0.02587704174220562, -0.02394496276974678, -0.0130405742675066, 0.013447134755551815, 0.0010733816307038069, -0.03667665645480156, -0.022474732249975204, -0.07664760947227478, -0.01828848570585251, -0.007682255934923887, -0.04950765147805214, -0.011564851738512516, 0.010124247521162033, 0.018244553357362747, -0.07327868789434433, -0.027738608419895172, -0.004876839928328991, -0.0025789362844079733, 0.04386905953288078, 0.0203077532351017, -0.01791919581592083, 0.015408599749207497, -0.004597424529492855, 0.008526491932570934, 0.008653417229652405, 0.0017490109894424677, -0.06253794580698013, 0.014653279446065426, -0.014692043885588646, -0.05803302302956581, 0.01858857274055481, 0.03706616908311844, -0.003404604736715555, -0.008566363714635372, 0.004538076464086771, 0.010673483833670616, -0.034806229174137115, 0.004133336246013641, -0.003673677332699299, 0.03433730825781822, 0.07133050262928009, 0.012311862781643867, -0.016517508774995804, -0.00288182171061635, -0.04293445870280266, -0.004938534926623106, 0.032726116478443146, 0.02718542516231537, -0.016805939376354218, 0.007148141972720623, -0.009075493551790714, -0.015646159648895264, 0.02839893288910389, 0.020406613126397133, 0.0384032316505909, 0.0018038444686681032, -0.04193781316280365, 0.025844871997833252, -0.011202501133084297, 0.023108558729290962, -0.006744745187461376, 0.014022753573954105, 0.04363717511296272, 0.01886601746082306, 0.03090711124241352, -0.06327702105045319, -0.03684115409851074, -0.01448690053075552, 0.02746332250535488, -0.02939506806433201, -0.002037415746599436, -0.0074423993937671185, -0.014453391544520855, 0.006792142987251282, -0.0390336848795414, 0.03015587292611599, -0.01225595735013485, 0.008579486049711704, -0.006759324576705694, 0.02871861308813095, 0.008649934083223343, -0.034412261098623276, -0.027763647958636284, -0.05025330185890198, 0.028513986617326736, 0.029821287840604782, 0.011868808418512344, -0.016860155388712883, -0.020012859255075455, 0.0019024185603484511, 0.09110195934772491, -0.04411199688911438, -0.006166381761431694, -0.07058237493038177, 0.008759751915931702, 0.008498460985720158, -0.022636203095316887 ]
<p>I want to run ordinal logistic regression (OLR) in SPSS. My data include 6 predictor variable (two continuous and 4 categorical ) but my outcome variables are also 6 (categorical-likert scale). e.g my dependent variable is Business development and 6 likert scale questions were asked for this, increase in profit, sales, size, asset, marketing and labour.</p> <p>1-If I composite these 6 variable into one by first sum all the 6 variables and then recode them into again five categories like before (In SPSS in Transform, Compute variable and then recode into different variables). I think in this way I lost my original data and may categorize them wrong.</p> <p>2-If I think of using Categorical Principle component analysis for reducing the dependent variables, it will give results (object scores) in continuous form on which I have to run linear regression. I do not want to run linear regression as my original data is categorical. </p> <p>3-So option left is to run OLR without combining the dependent variable on each DV. It means that there is no model for Business development and 6 models for profit, sales.... </p> <p>My question is that</p> <ul> <li>Is it preferable to run OLR with each DV and then summarize the results</li> <li><p>OR Is there any other method for reducing DV and running OLR.</p></li> <li><p>OR Is there any better method than ordinal logistic regression for this data.</p></li> </ul>
74,350
[ -0.04517513886094093, 0.017719214782118797, 0.01908058300614357, 0.0345357321202755, 0.04266120120882988, -0.022166889160871506, -0.01842905767261982, -0.045008547604084015, 0.051926277577877045, -0.016397055238485336, 0.016776790842413902, -0.0009194407612085342, 0.02152273803949356, 0.007050306536257267, 0.015776213258504868, -0.01708669774234295, 0.005609196610748768, 0.034344036132097244, -0.009507539682090282, 0.008051816374063492, -0.01942705363035202, 0.02474787086248398, 0.0218051690608263, -0.0058839526027441025, 0.016563531011343002, 0.06241047382354736, 0.03421205282211304, -0.036467619240283966, 0.005026031751185656, 0.014809774234890938, 0.007794173900038004, -0.015576311387121677, -0.012654484249651432, 0.03789457306265831, 0.01003748644143343, -0.010073797777295113, 0.0034162907395511866, 0.007138495799154043, -0.024488268420100212, -0.00273028458468616, -0.014412238262593746, 0.009784502908587456, 0.014542235992848873, 0.024259986355900764, 0.018707172945141792, -0.0016987142153084278, -0.00551548833027482, -0.006748624611645937, 0.0008792299777269363, -0.038690946996212006, 0.06325663626194, -0.05203907936811447, 0.004598261322826147, 0.018799467012286186, 0.021756041795015335, 0.020128795877099037, 0.05443085357546806, 0.06449674069881439, 0.006861240603029728, -0.027335556223988533, -0.02072260156273842, 0.009472408331930637, 0.023654824122786522, -0.017525851726531982, -0.046040765941143036, 0.04196988046169281, 0.0016687603201717138, -0.002228486817330122, 0.05353177711367607, 0.0006333902711048722, 0.05040430650115013, 0.01565718464553356, 0.03325016796588898, 0.029519904404878616, 0.021531863138079643, -0.020260782912373543, -0.002571376971900463, 0.01586422137916088, 0.04808617755770683, 0.022730568423867226, 0.030347011983394623, -0.003737347899004817, -0.013242535293102264, 0.03386906906962395, 0.00463282922282815, -0.032265063375234604, 0.0352926142513752, -0.017553111538290977, 0.0005825960543006659, 0.030955936759710312, 0.03037049062550068, -0.00598940160125494, 0.05158662796020508, 0.04739206284284592, -0.024860521778464317, 0.009698241949081421, -0.021034615114331245, 0.039921294897794724, -0.010945520363748074, 0.03793669864535332, 0.011948694474995136, -0.03264353424310684, -0.0004690849455073476, 0.01969127170741558, -0.013866272754967213, 0.02341648004949093, -0.03158373385667801, -0.02570207230746746, -0.013943211175501347, -0.06277083605527878, 0.007520253770053387, 0.004156365059316158, 0.0260702446103096, -0.017664730548858643, -0.03056093491613865, 0.0007926266407594085, -0.03058462217450142, -0.010524102486670017, 0.04054485261440277, 0.04499010741710663, 0.017100710421800613, -0.04739934578537941, 0.019990302622318268, -0.011498991400003433, -0.041104402393102646, -0.01763654313981533, -0.005705769173800945, -0.0048250616528093815, -0.0050784326158463955, 0.03858933225274086, 0.00835487525910139, -0.03742261230945587, 0.034306786954402924, 0.05758918076753616, -0.020453765988349915, 0.019987771287560463, -0.06409937143325806, -0.04561445489525795, 0.014482160098850727, -0.026212340220808983, 0.0375547930598259, -0.03911704570055008, -0.015394515357911587, 0.02931586280465126, 0.02709461748600006, 0.015079070813953876, 0.015095091424882412, 0.05413367971777916, 0.0212579183280468, 0.0034458960872143507, -0.037075649946928024, -0.02782260999083519, -0.05489462986588478, -0.03381935507059097, -0.01755763404071331, -0.1056830957531929, -0.002364989137277007, 0.028207534924149513, -0.007848414592444897, 0.0010988499270752072, 0.041705746203660965, 0.029193492606282234, -0.028537945821881294, 0.003317604074254632, -0.008957634679973125, 0.00411955313757062, 0.0077995415776968, -0.031395792961120605, 0.019725630059838295, -0.0028859644662588835, -0.004452057648450136, 0.0024662003852427006, 0.007410402409732342, 0.06370006501674652, 0.025455184280872345, 0.008603203110396862, 0.003936558961868286, -0.026715882122516632, 0.0002800333022605628, -0.011318341828882694, -0.058949001133441925, -0.06984758377075195, -0.018264668062329292, -0.02056880109012127, 0.02676554024219513, 0.06956440210342407, -0.0017557399114593863, -0.02509540505707264, 0.003042394993826747, -0.034870877861976624, -0.10252609103918076, -0.04733649641275406, 0.035310935229063034, 0.000830177974421531, -0.03189922124147415, 0.01856790855526924, -0.004975891672074795, 0.05186797305941582, -0.00983054656535387, 0.005193585529923439, -0.0021658758632838726, 0.012162715196609497, 0.04992609843611717, -0.022903112694621086, 0.009093734435737133, 0.05141352862119675, 0.03384413942694664, -0.039032116532325745, 0.00831447634845972, -0.05425068363547325, -0.03780912607908249, -0.012805593200027943, 0.006877044215798378, -0.0021637827157974243, -0.02555074170231819, -0.024355987086892128, 0.05585192143917084, 0.02985788881778717, -0.05838899314403534, 0.04337431862950325, -0.06887803971767426, 0.08873506635427475, 0.06341578811407089, -0.0318041667342186, 0.016286786645650864, 0.012557913549244404, 0.0035884552635252476, 0.011164402589201927, -0.03412008285522461, 0.019821565598249435, -0.010563411749899387, -0.0012078533181920648, 0.021941499784588814, 0.012439010664820671, -0.0578596368432045, 0.01902494952082634, 0.05862811952829361, 0.008783160708844662, 0.00386223872192204, 0.023044785484671593, -0.03909030929207802, -0.008919600397348404, 0.009278476238250732, 0.0029296111315488815, 0.02135443687438965, 0.006065704394131899, -0.004221996292471886, 0.027556603774428368, 0.05465250834822655, 0.003931754268705845, -0.0007607032312080264, 0.05082576721906662, 0.02024741843342781, 0.008849434554576874, -0.017405405640602112, -0.010980112478137016, 0.025505077093839645, -0.038151662796735764, 0.015859100967645645, 0.06903886795043945, 0.0029740792233496904, -0.010371928103268147, 0.017590610310435295, -0.009091162122786045, 0.01120290718972683, 0.0871446430683136, -0.03755149245262146, 0.014272826723754406, 0.013340365141630173, -0.03726411238312721, 0.013985658995807171, -0.023645494133234024, -0.01276986114680767, -0.07088721543550491, 0.04003988951444626, 0.02725098468363285, -0.015234856866300106, 0.052102230489254, -0.004917567130178213, -0.01021038182079792, -0.007982357405126095, -0.023127030581235886, 0.017249388620257378, 0.00868051778525114, -0.07969775795936584, -0.0704493522644043, -0.04790693148970604, -0.03038698434829712, 0.03234831243753433, -0.021617144346237183, -0.028520211577415466, 0.03081231191754341, 0.037531957030296326, -0.09042100608348846, -0.05542031303048134, 0.008785733953118324, 0.021978110074996948, -0.012631543911993504, -0.021716024726629257, 0.011344139464199543, 0.016434650868177414, -0.01910821534693241, -0.029145970940589905, -0.050018779933452606, 0.00510041369125247, -0.0026143244467675686, -0.002813003258779645, 0.012472360394895077, 0.011915530078113079, -0.015562648884952068, -0.0018850286724045873, -0.020537322387099266, -0.00199724524281919, -0.08679579198360443, -0.03613872826099396, 0.010797938331961632, 0.0036787763237953186, 0.04216418042778969, 0.009330028668045998, -0.019257931038737297, 0.08462976664304733, 0.018678361549973488, -0.04856480658054352, -0.08432529866695404, 0.0038392420392483473, -0.008064898662269115, -0.034924089908599854, 0.01315674651414156, 0.00982069130986929, 0.0012564313365146518, 0.014099708758294582, -0.025024525821208954, -0.00027015956584364176, 0.04918009042739868, -0.006179407704621553, 0.0056618861854076385, 0.013083088211715221, -0.010910548269748688, -0.05148974061012268, 0.014379134401679039, 0.04473697021603584, -0.022701825946569443, 0.024937810376286507, 0.004414885304868221, 0.02528214640915394, 0.013447633944451809, -0.05755218118429184, -0.018808379769325256, 0.0006885218899697065, -0.006959598045796156, 0.013710561208426952, 0.0004076229815836996, 0.024428490549325943, -0.057392340153455734, -0.02162752114236355, 0.0026532693300396204, 0.01575079932808876, -0.01646897941827774, 0.012755884788930416, 0.04401151463389397, 0.03668421134352684, 0.006610253360122442, -0.009325455874204636, -0.018832892179489136, -0.014231798239052296, 0.038352932780981064, -0.009343949146568775, -0.008791875094175339, 0.03790426626801491, 0.05316115915775299, 0.05299932509660721, 0.003993544261902571, -0.033915579319000244, 0.041222747415304184, -0.07263617217540741, 0.008428054861724377, -0.05224223807454109, 0.08714049309492111, 0.01718791201710701, 0.03495560213923454, 0.002813831204548478, -0.011251833289861679, -0.0032591992057859898, 0.030672263354063034, -0.057903796434402466, 0.007425317540764809, -0.008134828880429268, 0.018648596480488777, 0.06247079744935036, -0.0005110056954436004, 0.012499244883656502, -0.03106892667710781, -0.02147400751709938, -0.0022239473182708025, 0.011510859243571758, -0.023755710572004318, -0.01809566095471382, 0.0230536088347435, -0.011729693040251732, -0.0036264327354729176, -0.00951401237398386, 0.013897842727601528, -0.02771071530878544, 0.03255865350365639, 0.042839184403419495, -0.0005303253419697285, -0.005838356446474791, -0.029326049610972404, -0.0035415736492723227, -0.010134018026292324, 0.05693204328417778, 0.01974528282880783, 0.017322679981589317, -0.017190877348184586, 0.05924341082572937, 0.03483234718441963, 0.05285387858748436, 0.02038387767970562, 0.0012139052851125598, -0.02254737913608551, -0.0256512388586998, -0.003226220142096281, 0.0021224829833954573, 0.013325510546565056, 0.012515396811068058, -0.03934863954782486, 0.038896165788173676, 0.04084662348031998, -0.03152017667889595, 0.004136689007282257, 0.08878544718027115, 0.0234824288636446, -0.03496459871530533, -0.016583405435085297, -0.01294630579650402, -0.03411979228258133, -0.027055591344833374, 0.042886968702077866, 0.026096561923623085, 0.006846276577562094, -0.012779747135937214, 0.0428268201649189, -0.002965237945318222, -0.03677875176072121, -0.0007721903384663165, 0.027011092752218246, 0.021252218633890152, 0.010439838282763958, -0.07824509590864182, 0.017762992531061172, 0.05956375598907471, 0.017922641709446907, 0.03542584553360939, 0.020853744819760323, -0.07791239768266678, 0.027195248752832413, 0.01776975579559803, 0.06748950481414795, -0.04372341185808182, 0.015038357116281986, 0.01635926030576229, -0.02709304727613926, 0.03678477555513382, -0.04754495993256569, 0.03010081872344017, -0.01911299116909504, 0.03688691183924675, -0.024011610075831413, -0.01579182781279087, -0.05413262918591499, 0.01723487116396427, -0.02718506194651127, 0.018623825162649155, -0.0012400122359395027, -0.002837794367223978, -0.03229930251836777, 0.024648869410157204, -0.009401417337357998, 0.03984056040644646, -0.024782445281744003, -0.029755573719739914, 0.01677745208144188, 0.03931879252195358, -0.03311629220843315, -0.04994240403175354, -0.003683630842715502, 0.00003467378701316193, -0.04117662087082863, 0.0736636072397232, -0.006329474970698357, -0.028021246194839478, 0.01121581718325615, 0.01648586429655552, -0.006133309565484524, -0.010289961472153664, -0.05912954732775688, 0.034227125346660614, -0.003649614518508315, -0.02116859331727028, 0.033461324870586395, 0.0418083630502224, -0.004057200625538826, 0.030963288620114326, -0.03429538011550903, -0.014763964340090752, 0.004684973042458296, -0.05408056825399399, -0.022010302171111107, 0.007120942696928978, 0.016375146806240082, 0.006311257369816303, -0.0011321732308715582, 0.007421651855111122, -0.01876068487763405, -0.024456923827528954, 0.0019651816692203283, 0.031637538224458694, 0.019452044740319252, -0.009953531436622143, 0.023134279996156693, 0.037270452827215195, 0.007035022601485252, -0.03636261448264122, 0.017456375062465668, 0.009204642847180367, 0.014687968418002129, 0.020429320633411407, -0.035123635083436966, 0.0027460497803986073, -0.02341214381158352, 0.005035443231463432, 0.032788436859846115, -0.03361009433865547, 0.016428368166089058, 0.03485193848609924, 0.04221295192837715, 0.02692277356982231, -0.05004654824733734, -0.010706479661166668, 0.006037211045622826, 0.026572847738862038, 0.007421168498694897, -0.047767698764801025, 0.044211022555828094, -0.011379512026906013, -0.033261921256780624, -0.06010787561535835, -0.028918948024511337, 0.018221775069832802, 0.024417657405138016, -0.016744451597332954, -0.021295074373483658, 0.002478825394064188, -0.01374505553394556, -0.013013499788939953, -0.05371008440852165, 0.0668097585439682, -0.028042368590831757, -0.003716377541422844, 0.012160589918494225, 0.023606177419424057, 0.046658240258693695, 0.004348923452198505, -0.018541179597377777, 0.015932895243167877, 0.02952822856605053, 0.0003900282026734203, -0.007037654984742403, 0.017890697345137596, -0.050933994352817535, -0.04665352776646614, -0.05114368349313736, -0.013136981055140495, 0.03599349409341812, -0.005430618766695261, -0.008250703103840351, -0.01044084969907999, 0.006202767603099346, 0.0010258854599669576, -0.013053803704679012, -0.013047417625784874, -0.008348963223397732, 0.015466995537281036, -0.01113743707537651, 0.04180062562227249, -0.05593039095401764, -0.008448605425655842, -0.03748675063252449, -0.004331287927925587, -0.019541997462511063, 0.038004614412784576, 0.06065234914422035, 0.020935896784067154, 0.01664026640355587, -0.03260685130953789, -0.01389666274189949, 0.028826287016272545, 0.045953039079904556, 0.004742464981973171, 0.011250748299062252, 0.04927265644073486, -0.011045971885323524, -0.024338530376553535, -0.018965506926178932, -0.011419735848903656, 0.040403448045253754, -0.0021024979650974274, 0.02529025264084339, 0.05643824487924576, -0.0034981733188033104, -0.004188025835901499, -0.04738966375589371, -0.01236306969076395, -0.007120736874639988, 0.0025612530298531055, 0.08419572561979294, 0.01456991583108902, -0.007112612947821617, 0.014732906594872475, 0.05290893837809563, 0.02613387443125248, 0.04110930114984512, 0.026657482609152794, 0.020914901047945023, 0.01858304627239704, -0.05089122802019119, -0.047700297087430954, 0.01988699845969677, -0.07573914527893066, 0.014406019821763039, -0.027609383687376976, -0.04889700189232826, 0.03518406301736832, 0.03389864042401314, -0.03577984496951103, -0.06944041699171066, -0.011943415738642216, -0.042706023901700974, 0.030003832653164864, -0.0009612534195184708, -0.018477128818631172, 0.02871345542371273, -0.007664530538022518, 0.05234738066792488, 0.007948555983603, 0.013097947463393211, -0.013168414123356342, -0.07428424060344696, -0.026722721755504608, -0.006431455723941326, -0.03427094966173172, 0.02848471887409687, -0.0301900003105402, -0.014800053089857101, -0.011712318286299706, -0.053519971668720245, 0.015652872622013092, 0.0056073712185025215, 0.02355271205306053, 0.04964106157422066, 0.04728313907980919, -0.0002840056549757719, 0.008664015680551529, 0.019126445055007935, 0.005169653799384832, 0.13840259611606598, 0.08649466186761856, 0.028532758355140686, -0.046493347734212875, 0.020919503644108772, 0.04830901697278023, 0.03014695644378662, -0.004657467361539602, -0.008187199011445045, -0.006543295457959175, -0.01328963041305542, 0.0334368497133255, 0.05218980088829994, 0.01795010268688202, 0.004597099963575602, 0.05039567872881889, -0.026477189734578133, -0.003355174558237195, 0.005776808597147465, 0.0006052496610209346, -0.006403149105608463, -0.01743537373840809, -0.03778304159641266, -0.030883528292179108, 0.018520887941122055, -0.021750930696725845, -0.017662344500422478, -0.0021668553818017244, -0.013693621382117271, -0.0016162190586328506, -0.024128612130880356, 0.008469372056424618, 0.021367939189076424, 0.04420493543148041, -0.049795422703027725, -0.0198607686907053, 0.015286626294255257, -0.06317915767431259, 0.008345461450517178, 0.03962034359574318, -0.011602688580751419, -0.006225156597793102, -0.003923266194760799, 0.02446678839623928, -0.059839848428964615, -0.01639617420732975, -0.049376193434000015, 0.030383247882127762, -0.01084420271217823, -0.018345126882195473, -0.02375739999115467, 0.0031341041903942823, 0.03826633095741272, -0.050681278109550476, -0.03413209691643715, 0.03754696995019913, 0.021224556490778923, -0.014707016758620739, -0.05465652048587799, -0.03614966943860054, -0.01183903869241476, 0.014389545656740665, 0.024003461003303528, -0.019820617511868477, 0.01568562723696232, -0.02311844564974308, -0.031864143908023834, 0.03256014734506607, 0.01405337918549776, 0.022142844274640083, -0.0251791812479496, 0.020957162603735924, -0.011483333073556423, 0.038442306220531464, 0.004925562534481287, 0.014316098764538765, -0.006921688094735146, -0.027904678136110306, -0.003039580537006259, -0.05020070821046829, -0.047165729105472565, -0.011286359280347824, -0.005459239706397057, 0.002835730090737343, -0.04011968895792961, 0.023859966546297073, 0.024455228820443153, 0.012200386263430119, -0.00027347455034032464, 0.022996798157691956, -0.008895739912986755, 0.05926203727722168, -0.002790175611153245, -0.03850521892309189, -0.01802353747189045, -0.01856529526412487, -0.038538843393325806, -0.01746312528848648, -0.01393268071115017, 0.07895873486995697, -0.00016929698176681995, 0.00633159838616848, -0.02932392619550228, 0.04050196334719658, -0.004830996505916119, 0.0267755389213562, 0.0192685816437006, -0.0531173050403595, 0.021784042939543724, 0.0027243061922490597, 0.008749558590352535, -0.0137691805139184, -0.004965349566191435, -0.050472479313611984, -0.06554396450519562, 0.03746180236339569, -0.054801493883132935, -0.03232671692967415, 0.018042808398604393, -0.022188479080796242, 0.05619892477989197, -0.024516137316823006, 0.0005512207862921059, -0.017682405188679695, 0.009763266891241074, -0.027332885190844536, -0.02263440564274788, -0.01604219526052475, 0.0387847013771534, 0.010022708214819431, 0.02145366370677948, 0.008347121998667717, 0.0454290471971035, 0.014631595462560654, -0.0215675737708807, 0.000631187460385263, -0.004479182884097099, 0.023763639852404594, 0.003375594038516283, -0.010126949287950993, 0.014791886322200298, -0.012240150943398476, 0.0031618920620530844, 0.04101666808128357, -0.021260535344481468, 0.04666395112872124, 0.028385059908032417, 0.005742150358855724, -0.039509546011686325, 0.03931845352053642, -0.024879423901438713, -0.010792603716254234, -0.033406537026166916, 0.010450507514178753, -0.006091848947107792, 0.006256035063415766, -0.006006953306496143, 0.014895658940076828, -0.025266271084547043, 0.009983870200812817, 0.0467984564602375, -0.022298339754343033, -0.004785418976098299, 0.023915419355034828, -0.03316342085599899, 0.039445992559194565, 0.014064944349229336, -0.0036411616019904613, 0.030740946531295776, 0.029316097497940063, 0.00771797401830554, 0.03787916526198387, -0.0097482455894351, 0.012706111185252666, -0.06590917706489563, -0.0451795719563961, -0.00837139505892992, 0.008635093457996845, 0.033871762454509735, -0.03514425456523895, 0.016875723376870155, 0.017511896789073944, -0.0759631022810936, 0.0069815670140087605, 0.003947609104216099, -0.003779292805120349, -0.02310781180858612, -0.004759301897138357, -0.015073876827955246, 0.02136511728167534, 0.015413754619657993, 0.02206350490450859, 0.015558316372334957, 0.039824943989515305, 0.04247050732374191, -0.03575232997536659, -0.02779608964920044, -0.01042577251791954, 0.017100254073739052, -0.07492734491825104, 0.02250213362276554, -0.03133504092693329, -0.017921170219779015, 0.014271554537117481, -0.006922323256731033, 0.018809901550412178, 0.07264912873506546, 0.017938556149601936, -0.02403438277542591, 0.01642186939716339, 0.02703273855149746, -0.02162034623324871, -0.04220147430896759, 0.014808263629674911, 0.02874240279197693, 0.01271277479827404, -0.012415502220392227, 0.02595987170934677, 0.04884554073214531, -0.022470790892839432, -0.01058973465114832, -0.015729866921901703, -0.02363089844584465, -0.0021584017667919397, 0.0011538867838680744, -0.005295013077557087, 0.010296977125108242, -0.024818554520606995, 0.019100015982985497, -0.060073040425777435, -0.0008882139227353036, 0.014216228388249874, -0.007644610479474068, -0.007337951101362705, 0.011293604969978333, -0.021298538893461227, -0.02722410298883915, -0.03123050555586815, 0.0022912221029400826, 0.024607306346297264, -0.03421569615602493, 0.026124292984604836, 0.02544822171330452, -0.03970850259065628, -0.03855341672897339, -0.0057980515994131565, 0.014128095470368862, 0.06470634043216705, -0.05767623335123062, 0.017674826085567474, 0.049152735620737076, -0.031049393117427826, 0.02536029741168022, -0.089662104845047, 0.07197991758584976, 0.00647979648783803, -0.030561769381165504, 0.005664834287017584, -0.013070886954665184, -0.03732505813241005, -0.0033766813576221466, 0.05509717017412186, -0.011072525754570961, 0.019910505041480064, -0.002282623900100589, 0.05287700891494751, 0.016580656170845032, -0.015001117251813412, 0.028017060831189156, 0.023259615525603294, -0.022860392928123474, -0.05286123603582382, -0.025902435183525085, -0.006343311630189419, -0.03595569357275963, 0.04586254432797432, -0.013263962231576443, 0.00861311610788107, -0.012706580571830273, -0.011697161011397839, 0.006101530976593494, 0.0008077474194578826, -0.022977208718657494, 0.02866247296333313, -0.01577521674335003, -0.028425531461834908, 0.04625621438026428, -0.00516401045024395, -0.02027055062353611, 0.039893753826618195, -0.03160957619547844, 0.005708311218768358, -0.018749093636870384, 0.03059486299753189, 0.0007521116640418768, -0.05316581949591637, 0.014395476318895817, 0.02559369057416916, -0.01685258001089096, 0.009591558948159218, 0.03957497328519821, -0.0029130897019058466, 0.022719217464327812, -0.025483012199401855, 0.02353287860751152, -0.004121911711990833, -0.031498078256845474, -0.004445842932909727, 0.0003411711077205837, 0.036729443818330765, 0.016598587855696678, -0.025492418557405472, 0.055561285465955734, -0.00037061842158436775, 0.07023007422685623, -0.0205286405980587, 0.027231669053435326, 0.004998133052140474, 0.0036419753450900316, 0.03584497049450874, -0.006196916103363037, 0.03245503082871437, 0.04486076906323433, -0.009657217189669609, 0.039303459227085114, -0.007432687096297741, -0.010783091187477112, -0.04274813458323479, -0.025921974331140518, -0.07701533287763596, -0.028007671236991882, 0.02369445003569126, 0.039855025708675385, 0.042245760560035706, -0.00831585843116045, -0.01931098662316799, -0.00299362582154572, -0.00015771627658978105, 0.013603705912828445, -0.013170489110052586, -0.040049921721220016, -0.03498454764485359, 0.007133134640753269, -0.05338365212082863, -0.020656196400523186, 0.006025990471243858, 0.032304249703884125, 0.020863674581050873, 0.04261239245533943, -0.028985463082790375, -0.02295515313744545, 0.012933136895298958, 0.032872918993234634, -0.020070405676960945, -0.037975553423166275, -0.040841035544872284, -0.03212185949087143, 0.012417007237672806, -0.03509595990180969 ]
<p>I am doing some basic fitting of data and exploring different fits. I understand that the residual is the difference between the sample and the estimated function value. The norm of the residuals is a measure of the deviation between the correlation and the data. A lower norm signifies a better fit.</p> <p>Suppose a cubic fit has a norm of residuals of 0.85655 and a linear fit has a norm of residuals of 0.89182. What if the norms are 0.17113 and 0.24916? Is the difference between these two significant? Is a norm of residual less than 1 considered good? If not what is generally regarded as "acceptable" norm of residual. </p>
74,351
[ 0.0055409143678843975, 0.03312477096915245, -0.02121879905462265, 0.0033644919749349356, 0.013238532468676567, 0.04062194377183914, -0.009505600668489933, -0.01712580770254135, 0.02118513733148575, -0.02934003621339798, 0.00900847278535366, 0.037069641053676605, 0.04247475787997246, -0.0001652763457968831, 0.047596290707588196, -0.010976199992001057, -0.0014184997417032719, -0.004959133453667164, -0.003920659888535738, -0.020154761150479317, 0.011065513826906681, 0.022537143900990486, 0.025002723559737206, -0.0006131372647359967, -0.04007837548851967, 0.05407878756523132, 0.03582245483994484, 0.015035928227007389, 0.04178011417388916, 0.048830050975084305, -0.023277005180716515, -0.021345334127545357, -0.006796450354158878, 0.026776781305670738, 0.017406633123755455, 0.011369950138032436, -0.012058771215379238, -0.014727216213941574, 0.0045602708123624325, 0.061417434364557266, -0.037398405373096466, -0.0253398846834898, -0.0046837893314659595, 0.043039675801992416, 0.00247828452847898, -0.012868702411651611, 0.0230527613312006, -0.05762380361557007, 0.018477970734238625, -0.045577939599752426, 0.048423800617456436, -0.01343307364732027, 0.04769636318087578, 0.03125164285302162, -0.00998926255851984, -0.006784099619835615, 0.04275968670845032, 0.028449643403291702, -0.016764406114816666, -0.06660076975822449, -0.003409529337659478, -0.015733713284134865, -0.0009525373461656272, 0.02449759468436241, -0.03262002766132355, 0.046288106590509415, -0.01538592018187046, -0.023932723328471184, 0.05656569451093674, 0.022717613726854324, 0.02102666161954403, 0.045471809804439545, 0.03515929356217384, -0.05325049161911011, 0.02760046347975731, -0.035095490515232086, 0.0013724458403885365, 0.0005373264430090785, 0.012077552266418934, 0.06194962188601494, 0.021196071058511734, 0.017699291929602623, 0.023793669417500496, 0.03434706851840019, 0.005295844282954931, 0.006002337671816349, 0.07144911587238312, -0.027268648147583008, 0.038705043494701385, 0.0354781448841095, 0.036686986684799194, 0.027745869010686874, 0.0515914224088192, -0.013930220156908035, -0.023389063775539398, 0.008986695669591427, -0.006978167220950127, 0.021011417731642723, 0.03855833038687706, -0.01960897073149681, -0.00437898701056838, -0.04365851730108261, 0.03682316094636917, 0.0420745350420475, -0.00959532056003809, 0.008203962817788124, -0.009093211032450199, 0.03037595935165882, 0.025886457413434982, -0.03457186371088028, 0.00008059945685090497, -0.0068547967821359634, 0.008342467248439789, -0.002709787804633379, 0.04216426610946655, -0.010844568721950054, -0.01464086677879095, -0.02357776276767254, 0.07107218354940414, 0.0313754566013813, 0.028948606923222542, -0.02960752509534359, 0.010667950846254826, 0.01485352125018835, -0.04111701622605324, 0.02679343707859516, 0.032053858041763306, -0.01760255917906761, -0.038673125207424164, 0.05605635792016983, -0.027102651074528694, -0.021355904638767242, -0.022054756060242653, 0.0012357981177046895, 0.046363696455955505, -0.004901729058474302, -0.06632839888334274, -0.06670688092708588, 0.025131946429610252, 0.025166219100356102, -0.006921950727701187, -0.037336353212594986, -0.0064688012935221195, 0.02920159511268139, 0.045788899064064026, 0.028771836310625076, 0.029266105964779854, -0.003948729019612074, 0.010254829190671444, 0.0011107400059700012, -0.026293449103832245, -0.012245276011526585, -0.0154976025223732, -0.04816391319036484, -0.006797351874411106, -0.07162871211767197, -0.02185985818505287, 0.009837698191404343, -0.009112696163356304, -0.03569094464182854, 0.03109978698194027, 0.012438003905117512, -0.0037817875854671, -0.009289423935115337, 0.027227353304624557, -0.019787754863500595, 0.07303181290626526, -0.04029155522584915, 0.022450590506196022, 0.022652026265859604, -0.010642720386385918, -0.005085870157927275, 0.027645273134112358, 0.021305056288838387, 0.0481141023337841, 0.0023015481419861317, -0.006254926323890686, -0.033583417534828186, 0.057620298117399216, 0.013875876553356647, -0.06712712347507477, -0.01695539429783821, -0.015353742986917496, 0.017059804871678352, -0.017787957563996315, 0.07437378168106079, -0.004514107946306467, -0.027001433074474335, 0.02989051677286625, -0.03330294042825699, -0.030124759301543236, -0.04390101134777069, 0.010722912847995758, -0.00216301204636693, -0.02691720612347126, 0.03165494278073311, 0.03003646805882454, 0.006139975972473621, -0.029549889266490936, 0.01601552590727806, -0.004018574021756649, -0.0023316179867833853, 0.021108003333210945, -0.030189700424671173, 0.04039172828197479, 0.04471628740429878, 0.027860235422849655, -0.0016603473341092467, 0.05830244719982147, -0.01336032897233963, -0.033245060592889786, 0.020090093836188316, -0.030789319425821304, 0.01589309237897396, -0.0122937997803092, -0.0041281310841441154, -0.004449425730854273, -0.019287053495645523, -0.004652694799005985, 0.03978709504008293, -0.019386423751711845, 0.08157731592655182, 0.042432013899087906, 0.00827622227370739, -0.02199876680970192, 0.006868716329336166, -0.004915792495012283, 0.0018149408278986812, -0.028949283063411713, -0.0107288071885705, -0.04071878641843796, -0.009121791459619999, 0.03513941913843155, 0.03607465699315071, -0.050010692328214645, 0.000903667532838881, 0.08380565792322159, -0.009247887879610062, 0.054475050419569016, 0.03427533805370331, -0.029598282650113106, -0.022666627541184425, -0.025992607697844505, 0.042980607599020004, 0.03969305753707886, -0.0011184577597305179, 0.002536671468988061, 0.006635712459683418, 0.04598889499902725, 0.01584569364786148, 0.009713234379887581, 0.06421701610088348, 0.018205786123871803, -0.004576199222356081, -0.024890054017305374, -0.0015978643205016851, 0.0513606071472168, -0.01880752108991146, -0.0046011353842914104, -0.0021762142423540354, -0.024563981220126152, -0.016016462817788124, 0.02305399812757969, -0.0010299701243638992, 0.049014050513505936, 0.025379160419106483, -0.009289703331887722, -0.022166267037391663, 0.0044023687951266766, -0.015701262280344963, -0.012930931523442268, -0.051452215760946274, -0.047211963683366776, -0.024326695129275322, -0.033373791724443436, 0.026389582082629204, 0.018011486157774925, 0.042927905917167664, -0.030711408704519272, -0.0006832253420725465, -0.062489740550518036, -0.03259721025824547, -0.004692582879215479, 0.00004794368214788847, -0.014215877279639244, -0.015456253662705421, -0.007410233840346336, -0.010120756924152374, 0.002896561287343502, -0.024271169677376747, 0.0364583358168602, 0.03483305871486664, -0.02534068562090397, -0.030624767765402794, -0.03471085801720619, -0.045976873487234116, -0.003199320286512375, 0.007937817834317684, -0.03898291289806366, 0.0355374850332737, -0.022877976298332214, -0.046877503395080566, 0.040404558181762695, -0.04030708223581314, -0.023234441876411438, -0.040296733379364014, 0.001196918892674148, -0.0006936599384061992, -0.008988754823803902, -0.0030033444054424763, -0.005210437346249819, -0.042333878576755524, -0.009971801191568375, -0.04320327192544937, -0.06578715890645981, 0.03664350137114525, -0.00999782420694828, 0.02726670354604721, 0.0033903561998158693, -0.04401064291596413, 0.08815623074769974, 0.01994282193481922, -0.0007435572915710509, -0.03698243200778961, 0.020474176853895187, -0.035545215010643005, -0.00845090951770544, 0.044377826154232025, 0.03552516922354698, 0.017761612311005592, 0.04379773139953613, -0.019047308713197708, 0.0661664828658104, 0.027678916230797768, 0.009693268686532974, 0.006707020569592714, 0.03414737805724144, 0.004024898633360863, -0.04107337072491646, 0.042249344289302826, 0.017661653459072113, -0.02339508756995201, 0.038565050810575485, 0.0021435939706861973, 0.028017682954669, 0.016792206093668938, -0.026089785620570183, 0.030309347435832024, -0.006753640715032816, -0.006665813270956278, -0.015797698870301247, 0.008316830731928349, 0.006156102754175663, -0.016139812767505646, 0.0063991062343120575, 0.003708771662786603, -0.018270062282681465, -0.0046118698082864285, 0.010683693923056126, 0.03682402893900871, 0.05883019417524338, -0.02928270772099495, -0.003304342506453395, -0.022071639075875282, 0.015634479001164436, 0.04622216150164604, -0.012770889326930046, -0.029691854491829872, 0.07288577407598495, 0.0231284461915493, 0.016276808455586433, -0.025570014491677284, -0.04958326742053032, -0.0011774857994168997, -0.0807194858789444, 0.003996290732175112, 0.021514862775802612, 0.06921666860580444, -0.014696577563881874, 0.022099236026406288, 0.033154428005218506, -0.01252797618508339, 0.013260909356176853, 0.0033062915317714214, -0.0747719407081604, 0.07366649061441422, -0.017439819872379303, -0.031389910727739334, -0.020474005490541458, -0.013012684881687164, 0.0026470106095075607, -0.022610345855355263, 0.022180629894137383, 0.009157799184322357, 0.007581348996609449, -0.03692987188696861, 0.01673746109008789, -0.019464097917079926, 0.017726002261042595, -0.004014958627521992, 0.027739515528082848, -0.005764128174632788, -0.02773279696702957, 0.013576013967394829, 0.024859029799699783, -0.028669606894254684, 0.017878007143735886, 0.005751105956733227, 0.0245574489235878, 0.055779170244932175, 0.04029886797070503, 0.022028999403119087, 0.002095804549753666, 0.0013844817876815796, 0.011407860554754734, 0.017094749957323074, 0.042056746780872345, 0.035586271435022354, 0.004515293054282665, 0.0031913721468299627, -0.03469394892454147, -0.01810050569474697, -0.04742635414004326, 0.022413210943341255, -0.022992806509137154, -0.0025086398236453533, 0.03763372451066971, 0.004118665121495724, -0.04860781878232956, 0.06152110919356346, 0.06473764777183533, -0.00789189524948597, 0.0016823976766318083, -0.029985500499606133, -0.020071007311344147, -0.0018161619082093239, -0.009764308109879494, 0.027807364240288734, 0.02917752042412758, -0.03187606856226921, -0.03785640373826027, 0.033197928220033646, -0.03538257256150246, -0.06263765692710876, -0.025901559740304947, 0.03139816224575043, 0.054399535059928894, -0.04181152954697609, -0.03888499736785889, 0.017881574109196663, 0.030895935371518135, 0.046298373490571976, 0.036056432873010635, 0.00594730582088232, -0.07126526534557343, 0.0008992950315587223, 0.024999380111694336, 0.03128037601709366, -0.02860867790877819, -0.004532319027930498, -0.020461026579141617, -0.034752655774354935, 0.08550001680850983, -0.04162638261914253, 0.016977664083242416, 0.018073253333568573, 0.023595750331878662, -0.023157646879553795, -0.00013120462244842201, -0.07181572169065475, 0.006336498539894819, -0.010589521378278732, 0.021476948633790016, -0.03464910760521889, -0.028902053833007812, -0.028825437650084496, 0.037405118346214294, -0.006187592167407274, 0.05099546164274216, 0.00570643600076437, -0.011614799499511719, 0.01573125272989273, 0.037244994193315506, -0.00771560100838542, -0.05752604082226753, 0.01114293560385704, 0.004917518701404333, -0.006901216227561235, 0.01789737306535244, 0.001072690007276833, -0.0418073870241642, -0.00610318360850215, -0.005137018393725157, -0.011662091128528118, 0.003323851153254509, -0.04507159814238548, 0.03880961239337921, 0.04471825808286667, 0.022976670414209366, 0.036955103278160095, 0.028703011572360992, -0.013919624499976635, -0.02717273123562336, -0.03670573607087135, 0.0041320365853607655, -0.022552572190761566, -0.02930617891252041, -0.03814615309238434, -0.04212750121951103, -0.03350748494267464, 0.05267086625099182, -0.024425599724054337, 0.024644790217280388, -0.015395472757518291, -0.02760535664856434, 0.015210355632007122, 0.04081284627318382, -0.007801848463714123, 0.025642409920692444, 0.031146030873060226, -0.002626148983836174, -0.02495180256664753, -0.05052633583545685, -0.013010706752538681, -0.0034716352820396423, 0.0011712561827152967, 0.012693269178271294, -0.042019303888082504, -0.00835219956934452, -0.007071981206536293, -0.015290276147425175, -0.016883742064237595, -0.018407931551337242, 0.0734964907169342, 0.0068726795725524426, 0.02502005733549595, -0.026143420487642288, -0.0640079453587532, 0.024507643654942513, 0.02529052086174488, -0.005142177455127239, 0.07531306147575378, -0.05420031398534775, 0.07191615551710129, -0.008592783473432064, -0.028967753052711487, -0.0639789029955864, -0.03316829726099968, -0.023352256044745445, 0.025781406089663506, -0.023796187713742256, 0.012301387265324593, -0.011575514450669289, 0.01292356476187706, -0.0033121241722255945, -0.01185598410665989, 0.05512773618102074, -0.008888030424714088, -0.03622015565633774, -0.009926332160830498, -0.0016953235026448965, 0.08359383791685104, -0.02555614709854126, -0.012714747339487076, -0.0034573946613818407, -0.005839188117533922, -0.01942165568470955, 0.012111660093069077, 0.04513997957110405, -0.033266302198171616, -0.01065062079578638, -0.0407438762485981, -0.007909341715276241, 0.07401876151561737, -0.015147553756833076, -0.03208666667342186, 0.010594906285405159, -0.01970837451517582, 0.01653497852385044, -0.006598534993827343, 0.005058388225734234, -0.006888426840305328, 0.02164882980287075, -0.016646288335323334, -0.008291025646030903, -0.0015540305757895112, -0.02566789649426937, -0.0003592672001104802, 0.02513989433646202, 0.0028898289892822504, 0.029110411182045937, 0.0389542318880558, -0.008801015093922615, 0.01971421390771866, -0.005765603855252266, -0.011386021971702576, 0.030770067125558853, 0.0027309474535286427, 0.015359542332589626, 0.006879444234073162, 0.04390239343047142, -0.03325935825705528, -0.043887898325920105, -0.032917965203523636, -0.0283807385712862, 0.06568536907434464, -0.011804363690316677, 0.046547599136829376, 0.060671158134937286, -0.008674651384353638, -0.01135309599339962, -0.05684580281376839, -0.019646404311060905, -0.03491167724132538, -0.02429991401731968, 0.04643885791301727, -0.04586182162165642, -0.027617963030934334, 0.03246696665883064, -0.0027932424563914537, 0.020250415429472923, 0.03285688906908035, 0.003660467453300953, 0.03876597806811333, 0.010272076353430748, 0.024908576160669327, -0.06226653605699539, 0.014249234460294247, -0.007944646291434765, 0.01213629450649023, 0.011645112186670303, 0.01366435643285513, 0.043745845556259155, 0.04476773738861084, 0.041261591017246246, -0.013114511035382748, -0.03046867996454239, -0.03425373509526253, -0.008596966043114662, 0.02430405095219612, -0.029205288738012314, 0.009566949680447578, -0.017644310370087624, 0.04883100092411041, 0.0031511157285422087, 0.029763035476207733, -0.03840835392475128, -0.0606469064950943, -0.03769558668136597, -0.03245113790035248, -0.02915487065911293, 0.015222445130348206, -0.00938273686915636, -0.0572667196393013, 0.020248085260391235, -0.08006647974252701, -0.00817941315472126, 0.013832555152475834, 0.04232364520430565, -0.010995768941938877, 0.06873570382595062, -0.005002079997211695, -0.007204767782241106, -0.003487132489681244, -0.003905009478330612, 0.11358813941478729, 0.05719716474413872, 0.011621270328760147, -0.05446154251694679, 0.048054151237010956, -0.032860856503248215, -0.01758521795272827, 0.005241662263870239, 0.015161873772740364, -0.023056847974658012, 0.019780859351158142, 0.06701593846082687, 0.04390721395611763, 0.0003360876871738583, -0.024898534640669823, 0.05592790246009827, -0.01454867608845234, -0.03144609183073044, 0.0019104178063571453, 0.030483538284897804, -0.005254433024674654, 0.005245407111942768, -0.01984124258160591, 0.03560024872422218, -0.014585166238248348, -0.04247739538550377, -0.016343748196959496, -0.0036236350424587727, 0.027175765484571457, -0.02596692368388176, -0.03768906742334366, 0.002132304711267352, 0.0070753032341599464, 0.009339052252471447, -0.049292970448732376, 0.01976621523499489, 0.016442343592643738, -0.02530941739678383, 0.0011040729004889727, 0.03800350800156593, -0.006561547052115202, -0.0015554215060546994, 0.017394952476024628, -0.025747744366526604, -0.06521808356046677, -0.02201581746339798, -0.05491768196225166, 0.04463672265410423, 0.026835137978196144, -0.02429109625518322, 0.019764667376875877, 0.0005502973217517138, -0.013624804094433784, -0.05698442459106445, -0.009018014185130596, 0.032128483057022095, 0.005356608424335718, 0.00021199765615165234, -0.002176610752940178, -0.028180260211229324, 0.04305166006088257, -0.009225999936461449, 0.011363091878592968, 0.022272873669862747, -0.0459618978202343, 0.013865943998098373, -0.020414063706994057, 0.047514408826828, -0.021329240873456, -0.003443516558036208, -0.0011718327878043056, -0.0012643847148865461, -0.03465280681848526, 0.007311925757676363, -0.009955143555998802, 0.00692941015586257, 0.06855455040931702, -0.009026024490594864, 0.0020249304361641407, -0.024156738072633743, -0.11122668534517288, 0.01477005984634161, -0.02906707488000393, 0.0007500650244764984, -0.04048926755785942, -0.02623625099658966, 0.04488292336463928, 0.010357966646552086, 0.031151583418250084, -0.016993798315525055, -0.0031299113761633635, 0.005502030719071627, 0.004253098275512457, -0.056715063750743866, -0.006325407885015011, 0.022676773369312286, -0.021828358992934227, 0.008450038731098175, -0.012667126953601837, 0.06108418479561806, 0.047015462070703506, 0.025773996487259865, -0.008792035281658173, 0.04125252738595009, -0.007586866617202759, 0.01482356432825327, 0.0021727157291024923, -0.04133656993508339, -0.004454233683645725, 0.027353454381227493, -0.018124835565686226, -0.015853645280003548, -0.03373349830508232, -0.06022448092699051, -0.045313574373722076, -0.0006613272707909346, 0.0202521663159132, -0.026365626603364944, 0.039637427777051926, -0.014978831633925438, -0.004736568778753281, -0.022017275914549828, -0.03943135589361191, -0.04218302667140961, -0.011014636605978012, 0.027547992765903473, -0.011736529879271984, -0.01168399304151535, 0.0013478038599714637, -0.01746923290193081, 0.016750693321228027, 0.04782607778906822, 0.0118718221783638, 0.04597701132297516, -0.03894641250371933, -0.012398473918437958, 0.0018761634128168225, 0.04481358826160431, -0.058764781802892685, -0.00435707438737154, 0.044971827417612076, -0.012565435841679573, -0.030740590766072273, 0.023824350908398628, -0.0004265243769623339, 0.01098717749118805, 0.02900884300470352, 0.026370666921138763, -0.040013689547777176, 0.046454355120658875, -0.023198584094643593, 0.0022820159792900085, -0.054313644766807556, -0.001382671296596527, -0.006230486556887627, -0.0012467788765206933, 0.007735783234238625, -0.024845954030752182, -0.0031983531080186367, 0.02214864082634449, 0.039235446602106094, -0.03830551728606224, 0.02818608656525612, -0.02159876376390457, 0.021590255200862885, -0.03265685588121414, -0.005032511427998543, -0.016740847378969193, 0.036079417914152145, 0.034425731748342514, -0.03182416036725044, 0.03667294234037399, 0.00861874595284462, 0.014678267762064934, -0.0979967936873436, -0.013026201166212559, -0.02297317050397396, 0.0036481847055256367, 0.02229711227118969, -0.05966290831565857, -0.0145375682041049, 0.049975842237472534, -0.018290163949131966, -0.023518525063991547, -0.03959834203124046, -0.025211049243807793, -0.041402675211429596, 0.006477673072367907, 0.01049272995442152, 0.02546609938144684, 0.011080687865614891, 0.03015127219259739, 0.0013154336484149098, -0.01694318652153015, -0.015223575755953789, 0.000866200658492744, -0.0017339913174510002, 0.04219578951597214, -0.024055013433098793, -0.037556182593107224, 0.0020110730547457933, -0.049455005675554276, -0.023901838809251785, 0.04846701771020889, -0.04581718519330025, 0.01916443556547165, 0.02811407297849655, -0.005116741172969341, -0.002172415843233466, 0.04627590253949165, 0.03560874983668327, -0.008623563684523106, -0.04225164279341698, -0.01430407352745533, 0.04574176296591759, 0.026804709807038307, 0.010247983038425446, 0.010249792598187923, 0.01052762009203434, -0.02288607507944107, -0.00922217033803463, 0.03872757777571678, 0.0026914088521152735, -0.016432687640190125, 0.0018528468208387494, 0.014242424629628658, 0.018589863553643227, -0.058803949505090714, 0.04383056238293648, -0.01849166862666607, 0.019879963248968124, 0.042136043310165405, 0.03780844062566757, -0.036160800606012344, -0.011624044738709927, -0.012049791403114796, -0.030684808269143105, -0.0026638885028660297, -0.005491302814334631, 0.009072056040167809, -0.04785972088575363, -0.008684173226356506, -0.028097055852413177, -0.03611572086811066, -0.02254379913210869, -0.01781483367085457, -0.004677945747971535, 0.04982860013842583, -0.04180135950446129, 0.00109140295535326, 0.013547880575060844, -0.052960943430662155, -0.034203123301267624, -0.09790783375501633, 0.07018902152776718, 0.0009307404980063438, -0.024672403931617737, -0.05224030092358589, -0.006759876850992441, -0.04749544337391853, -0.007227265276014805, 0.037224605679512024, 0.011632264591753483, 0.015570277348160744, -0.024799196049571037, -0.01838390901684761, -0.00022121146321296692, -0.032345615327358246, 0.024831119924783707, -0.022514980286359787, -0.02498028241097927, -0.005267399363219738, 0.007932432927191257, -0.0028076551388949156, 0.003211371134966612, 0.01452753134071827, -0.03432700037956238, 0.030769508332014084, -0.017766904085874557, -0.03355885669589043, 0.05728554353117943, 0.02920457161962986, -0.049652352929115295, 0.057042140513658524, -0.010454799979925156, 0.04242389276623726, 0.043076083064079285, -0.004339735023677349, -0.04682284966111183, 0.017749616876244545, -0.019901102408766747, -0.02829916402697563, 0.011274856515228748, 0.015462997369468212, -0.005198940634727478, -0.06286763399839401, -0.027972768992185593, 0.029083870351314545, -0.027538759633898735, 0.010667596012353897, 0.030843600630760193, 0.04707484692335129, 0.018523115664720535, 0.00040510555845685303, 0.014535130001604557, 0.004032851196825504, -0.025470152497291565, 0.015605163760483265, -0.0011903583072125912, 0.02778218500316143, 0.03547654300928116, 0.020018460229039192, 0.02634187415242195, -0.020679112523794174, -0.00014243005716707557, 0.01894824206829071, 0.07622227817773819, -0.022768141701817513, 0.012014527805149555, 0.005169772543013096, 0.02318534627556801, 0.03498789295554161, -0.0049271900206804276, 0.010894757695496082, 0.03724117577075958, -0.060111869126558304, -0.0009771628538146615, -0.0538390576839447, -0.0224900059401989, -0.011230639182031155, -0.00811743550002575, 0.02411593310534954, 0.02876972407102585, -0.003735197940841317, 0.011968441307544708, 0.0037815473042428493, 0.006387369241565466, 0.0647466704249382, -0.02454705908894539, 0.02573070488870144, -0.01381300762295723, 0.018241871148347855, -0.054805412888526917, -0.015328967943787575, -0.04063347354531288, -0.023409569635987282, 0.01092361006885767, 0.05036315694451332, 0.020927656441926956, -0.01323727611452341, -0.017624706029891968, 0.0012587810633704066, 0.050229284912347794, -0.06771183758974075, 0.008591174148023129, -0.040930651128292084, 0.021332846954464912, 0.004292348865419626, -0.008470023050904274 ]
<p>I am working on an assignment for a course in statistics, and a part of the assignment is to give the null hypothesis of an experiment. The experiment is as followed (short summary):</p> <p>A company is testing 3 interfaces for a website. They test the interfaces with 15 students, 5 for each interface, and all 5 have a different computer knowledge level. They are all given the same task and the time it takes for each of them to complete the task is the data we're using. </p> <p>I know need to find the null hypothesis of interest. As far as I understand null hypothesis and the alternative hypothesis should be 2 competing propositions. However, as far as I can tell I have 3 proposition: interface 1 is better, interface 2 is better and interface 3 is better. </p> <p>What null hypothesis should I have here and why?</p> <p>Thanks in advance!</p>
37,210
[ -0.06345300376415253, -0.041582897305488586, -0.026158245280385017, 0.023764023557305336, 0.00575412530452013, 0.00273772981017828, 0.011920154094696045, -0.006776818074285984, 0.003864169819280505, 0.049449507147073746, 0.05698765069246292, 0.04278917983174324, 0.016396837309002876, 0.00507399020716548, 0.025614922866225243, 0.047362856566905975, -0.02834077551960945, -0.007881807163357735, -0.008695494383573532, 0.006476225331425667, -0.00224540033377707, -0.0012250846484676003, 0.0020204156171530485, -0.035012613981962204, -0.03071552701294422, 0.013288662768900394, -0.0046223425306379795, -0.02463626116514206, -0.01210565771907568, 0.05021500214934349, -0.04326071962714195, -0.013604523614048958, -0.011588816531002522, 0.023673580959439278, 0.0015994284767657518, 0.022267714142799377, 0.0027853797655552626, -0.016217738389968872, 0.012056443840265274, 0.05184861272573471, 0.00040670594898983836, 0.00032824111985974014, 0.021808627992868423, 0.0340675413608551, -0.021093295887112617, 0.02367580682039261, -0.002833588747307658, -0.019048349931836128, -0.021844839677214622, -0.05748629942536354, 0.07286648452281952, -0.028507377952337265, 0.053060971200466156, 0.02879560925066471, -0.0005871763569302857, -0.01978239417076111, 0.04573807865381241, 0.0680423229932785, -0.030122041702270508, -0.07214688509702682, -0.027553364634513855, -0.04047238826751709, -0.004664665088057518, -0.0023388497065752745, -0.023936165496706963, 0.038062646985054016, -0.01395376306027174, 0.011843563988804817, 0.03825109079480171, -0.021758683025836945, 0.022353220731019974, 0.034244000911712646, 0.04908674955368042, -0.006583194248378277, -0.000032294090487994254, -0.023080695420503616, 0.041208263486623764, 0.039676252752542496, 0.013548702001571655, 0.048953793942928314, -0.005295649636536837, -0.006513417232781649, 0.057501886039972305, 0.07543620467185974, -0.0044540404342114925, -0.02324344590306282, 0.04664044827222824, -0.026889575645327568, -0.0005391206941567361, 0.0120019456371665, -0.04101112484931946, -0.022104967385530472, 0.039308998733758926, 0.019861288368701935, -0.013466623611748219, 0.021640662103891373, -0.02885039709508419, 0.045489173382520676, 0.0314880833029747, 0.015423002652823925, -0.0019890095572918653, -0.04439527541399002, 0.010980602353811264, 0.03769737482070923, 0.008454694412648678, 0.031531285494565964, -0.04529612511396408, 0.02681237831711769, -0.026588283479213715, -0.00061368802562356, 0.00460815941914916, 0.03294023871421814, 0.01316478569060564, 0.025003809481859207, 0.016637803986668587, -0.008582506328821182, 0.0059232525527477264, -0.01721629500389099, 0.07170505076646805, 0.05463074520230293, 0.009533223696053028, -0.004078749101608992, 0.04069101810455322, 0.008539797738194466, -0.016749514266848564, 0.03657705709338188, -0.034747324883937836, -0.021002260968089104, -0.002920108148828149, 0.04898672550916672, -0.020056089386343956, -0.0032957997173070908, 0.04618386924266815, -0.01021295040845871, 0.04366731271147728, -0.0032212338410317898, -0.08992870897054672, -0.0533643513917923, 0.05071445554494858, -0.02423003874719143, -0.019976293668150902, -0.05977052450180054, 0.01570645160973072, -0.001044844975695014, 0.03228702396154404, -0.004789459053426981, 0.034141656011343, -0.004408760461956263, 0.021856671199202538, 0.026148349046707153, 0.01872517727315426, -0.02192533202469349, 0.014154773205518723, -0.02638150565326214, -0.007007513660937548, -0.08967328816652298, -0.02160620130598545, 0.01971966028213501, -0.009561512619256973, -0.02433444932103157, 0.020217178389430046, 0.026344425976276398, 0.0012816301314160228, 0.00362127972766757, 0.03247847408056259, -0.00966134574264288, 0.09629824012517929, -0.004779875744134188, 0.010013516061007977, 0.00791621208190918, -0.003474174067378044, 0.04109952971339226, -0.007188125979155302, 0.02645440399646759, 0.05154166370630264, -0.043920814990997314, -0.004829083569347858, 0.002257312647998333, -0.004528151825070381, -0.00890121329575777, 0.006814817897975445, -0.027899358421564102, 0.009328015148639679, -0.0043474589474499226, -0.0012318309163674712, 0.06754612922668457, -0.012590495869517326, -0.02119223028421402, 0.038956932723522186, -0.040169648826122284, -0.06428317725658417, -0.11662620306015015, -0.013407516293227673, 0.01301549468189478, -0.03185480460524559, 0.017612304538488388, -0.023365437984466553, 0.007491253782063723, -0.021749215200543404, -0.0013020567130297422, -0.029485898092389107, -0.018872732296586037, 0.036168988794088364, -0.010616293177008629, 0.012573311105370522, 0.06139553338289261, 0.06745035946369171, -0.02517363242805004, 0.005605848506093025, -0.02337837964296341, -0.020552832633256912, 0.0002806310949381441, -0.026539135724306107, 0.000009692083949630614, -0.0004578979278448969, -0.016432875767350197, -0.0016589288134127855, 0.04415929690003395, -0.014528551138937473, 0.0331742949783802, -0.026363791897892952, 0.08855830132961273, 0.02357068657875061, -0.024996943771839142, -0.002163825323805213, -0.011042064055800438, 0.0008427036809735, 0.04356498271226883, 0.016065632924437523, 0.004138595890253782, -0.028894081711769104, -0.009778056293725967, 0.021326757967472076, -0.007748661562800407, -0.019802961498498917, 0.04638929292559624, 0.06260614842176437, 0.016993628814816475, -0.00822262093424797, 0.04776404798030853, 0.03741493448615074, -0.0005886128637939692, 0.0018619510810822248, 0.022705309092998505, 0.010690988041460514, 0.048231229186058044, 0.04535054787993431, -0.014880501665174961, 0.0019836851861327887, 0.03952822461724281, -0.0016623650444671512, 0.024427050724625587, 0.023850558325648308, 0.02437257394194603, -0.026427682489156723, -0.029374251142144203, 0.011320317164063454, -0.005355842411518097, -0.005883125122636557, 0.046620968729257584, 0.002350905444473028, -0.013544983230531216, -0.014630042016506195, -0.02396199107170105, 0.017558787018060684, 0.019176797941327095, -0.016938436776399612, 0.010317245498299599, 0.028197454288601875, -0.034732919186353683, -0.004743513185530901, -0.013125663623213768, -0.01090816967189312, -0.043131016194820404, -0.023574968799948692, 0.013311306945979595, -0.024537337943911552, 0.04061686620116234, -0.04085832089185715, -0.008404996246099472, -0.009117759764194489, -0.026729034259915352, 0.019503341987729073, -0.021569108590483665, -0.0384945347905159, -0.008960687555372715, 0.007236125413328409, -0.04602563753724098, 0.0395297035574913, -0.03893861919641495, 0.006959826685488224, 0.03758133575320244, -0.03134854882955551, -0.01397459302097559, -0.049570661038160324, -0.052437905222177505, 0.03428575396537781, -0.01201341301202774, -0.006574876606464386, 0.039408013224601746, 0.026899851858615875, -0.039769403636455536, 0.05473023280501366, -0.05365496128797531, -0.0870010256767273, 0.004959597252309322, -0.003960182424634695, 0.0022074999287724495, 0.0009184807422570884, -0.02224000357091427, 0.017836103215813637, -0.016476398333907127, 0.013802940025925636, -0.062037959694862366, -0.09987043589353561, 0.062269821763038635, 0.0006287215510383248, -0.00414218520745635, -0.04847782477736473, -0.05005933716893196, 0.06458169221878052, 0.0004168977902736515, -0.04127287119626999, -0.04427028074860573, -0.0021759578958153725, -0.0013497096952050924, 0.011047917418181896, 0.06366631388664246, 0.03798714652657509, -0.004700699355453253, 0.012359107844531536, -0.008942993357777596, 0.05616465583443642, 0.03601623326539993, 0.015742724761366844, -0.011914112605154514, 0.007393364328891039, 0.007547423709183931, -0.02594032697379589, 0.03203659877181053, 0.002660492667928338, -0.036469511687755585, 0.019977757707238197, -0.043366774916648865, 0.015853215008974075, -0.025170015171170235, -0.054512038826942444, 0.013463828712701797, -0.04162593558430672, 0.018763750791549683, -0.00037786041502840817, 0.010931632481515408, 0.008768442086875439, -0.0016485184896737337, -0.006967117078602314, 0.02883555367588997, 0.0050310054793953896, -0.06553472578525543, 0.018740108236670494, 0.06651942431926727, 0.0034773433580994606, -0.0447823703289032, -0.0370740108191967, -0.012953989207744598, -0.02777264639735222, -0.0062275901436805725, -0.0178377665579319, -0.04966201260685921, 0.045431092381477356, 0.02171766571700573, 0.026416348293423653, 0.01207984983921051, -0.06205960735678673, 0.014156305231153965, -0.07856839895248413, 0.022772204130887985, -0.009176036342978477, 0.05621708929538727, -0.008768807165324688, 0.010409022681415081, 0.03753207251429558, 0.005561779718846083, -0.0037710703909397125, -0.009995447471737862, -0.04306814819574356, 0.028707124292850494, -0.00957044493407011, -0.01515390258282423, 0.03307893127202988, -0.03502875193953514, 0.04806298390030861, -0.042667824774980545, 0.04207231476902962, 0.03762369602918625, 0.049307871609926224, -0.03978177532553673, 0.01825590617954731, -0.033479269593954086, -0.0035975135397166014, 0.005108380224555731, 0.014703248627483845, 0.007845108397305012, -0.016190875321626663, 0.02511787787079811, 0.0005629363586194813, -0.025641262531280518, -0.024137401953339577, 0.005350375082343817, -0.027066010981798172, 0.035502541810274124, 0.01803390122950077, 0.008323954418301582, 0.030036561191082, -0.02872932329773903, 0.051894597709178925, -0.010774440132081509, 0.06858629733324051, 0.034670062363147736, 0.01799658127129078, -0.0015998121816664934, -0.02679654024541378, -0.014361079782247543, 0.002198825590312481, 0.04948333278298378, 0.02911427989602089, -0.030639300122857094, 0.034206461161375046, 0.0461612269282341, -0.030113505199551582, 0.020081331953406334, 0.06986409425735474, 0.023196056485176086, 0.008320609107613564, -0.02591777592897415, -0.04587504267692566, -0.019895531237125397, -0.02760957181453705, 0.06963770091533661, 0.04742380604147911, -0.021952180191874504, -0.0015677579212933779, 0.039234671741724014, 0.008533268235623837, -0.04086729511618614, 0.03176324442028999, 0.00021528506476897746, 0.017372552305459976, 0.03537832945585251, -0.04695891961455345, 0.011350785382091999, 0.06018522381782532, 0.017977306619286537, 0.017772138118743896, -0.024650203064084053, -0.07192301750183105, -0.006767525803297758, 0.042923059314489365, 0.037179406732320786, -0.048510000109672546, -0.00013332691742107272, -0.005357192829251289, 0.0384446382522583, 0.008975234813988209, -0.060126252472400665, 0.028673088178038597, -0.021804004907608032, 0.036633118987083435, -0.04723881557583809, -0.002786124823614955, -0.04255712404847145, -0.004047816153615713, 0.00042317676707170904, 0.050122085958719254, -0.022093847393989563, -0.02292904257774353, -0.00816846452653408, 0.000852040306199342, 0.020248383283615112, 0.04598667472600937, -0.044106025248765945, 0.0012233166489750147, 0.05125631392002106, 0.00944049283862114, -0.040988706052303314, -0.039817146956920624, 0.035383932292461395, 0.018692463636398315, 0.03592846170067787, 0.04589907452464104, -0.02060454525053501, -0.033161286264657974, 0.019618956372141838, -0.012514020316302776, -0.029025834053754807, -0.009035272523760796, -0.04032272845506668, -0.014025403186678886, 0.03494461998343468, 0.016296444460749626, 0.04738270863890648, -0.03104121796786785, -0.00798596628010273, 0.011540588922798634, -0.02813129499554634, 0.01284889504313469, -0.03946883976459503, -0.005495454650372267, -0.020346395671367645, -0.024083612486720085, -0.013457508757710457, 0.03078320063650608, 0.006525936536490917, 0.051829420030117035, -0.05241001397371292, -0.02919478341937065, -0.01939781755208969, -0.011509888805449009, 0.013270984403789043, -0.010029591619968414, 0.004829274490475655, -0.014703319407999516, 0.01564962975680828, -0.02579088695347309, 0.002313006203621626, -0.03883490338921547, -0.01308390498161316, -0.023569179698824883, 0.015387103892862797, 0.04178832098841667, -0.037478528916835785, -0.034313660115003586, 0.020188599824905396, -0.039975203573703766, 0.020694199949502945, -0.002242633607238531, 0.02321368083357811, 0.011737698689103127, -0.049060553312301636, -0.0470057912170887, 0.023447897285223007, 0.012456689961254597, 0.018847940489649773, -0.03924810141324997, 0.04366954416036606, -0.01644323021173477, 0.009846202097833157, -0.08085139840841293, -0.02900158427655697, 0.006497504189610481, 0.028291119262576103, -0.01635082997381687, 0.007796002086251974, -0.04185175895690918, -0.0029191351495683193, -0.018677646294236183, -0.0023826498072594404, 0.052615147083997726, -0.019193610176444054, -0.03360356017947197, -0.009075918234884739, -0.0049249944277107716, 0.06166679412126541, 0.029448043555021286, -0.0029418841004371643, -0.04008329659700394, -0.027636902406811714, -0.012839541770517826, -0.008288064040243626, 0.0034845219925045967, -0.0051296367309987545, 0.011485726572573185, -0.030254093930125237, 0.013437868095934391, 0.04769612103700638, -0.040802642703056335, 0.015519315376877785, -0.03594764694571495, -0.01824067533016205, -0.04502486810088158, -0.04104921594262123, 0.02809411846101284, -0.018402734771370888, 0.019885115325450897, 0.0071709235198795795, 0.03499141335487366, -0.03147115558385849, -0.032176338136196136, 0.03218201547861099, 0.0008880043169483542, -0.04084914177656174, 0.03425677493214607, 0.07166718691587448, 0.012931003235280514, -0.006147359032183886, -0.015768777579069138, -0.007436907384544611, 0.02082410268485546, 0.0014420639490708709, -0.011493506841361523, 0.0045683905482292175, 0.03321494534611702, -0.03866428881883621, 0.009353590197861195, -0.02878204919397831, 0.024395646527409554, 0.05273826792836189, -0.024870295077562332, 0.05123565346002579, 0.0424838550388813, -0.00033935860847122967, -0.0004045336099807173, -0.01572556048631668, 0.025646843016147614, -0.01843426562845707, 0.029986588284373283, 0.04442554712295532, -0.005467109382152557, -0.0074628796428442, 0.0692477598786354, 0.022362643852829933, 0.011443693190813065, 0.03873421624302864, 0.04131680354475975, 0.017094403505325317, 0.028473716229200363, -0.0399763323366642, -0.04892456904053688, 0.02964700013399124, -0.045548878610134125, 0.022952696308493614, -0.0393691249191761, -0.0022401916794478893, 0.03623761981725693, 0.01932056061923504, 0.024962671101093292, -0.0511711947619915, 0.004439592827111483, -0.03292549028992653, -0.004148988984525204, 0.05131816491484642, -0.00986433308571577, 0.01939001865684986, -0.0006526499637402594, 0.029538054019212723, 0.0018262071534991264, 0.012452676892280579, -0.046914421021938324, -0.10980908572673798, -0.023635679855942726, -0.01103506051003933, -0.006871100049465895, -0.0005091773928143084, -0.006367983762174845, -0.026495110243558884, 0.023523148149251938, -0.04802623763680458, -0.022094178944826126, -0.002760492032393813, 0.035724226385354996, -0.009903473779559135, 0.06603503227233887, 0.015131307765841484, 0.009161369875073433, 0.0034459494054317474, -0.009737127460539341, 0.12087211012840271, 0.09127026051282883, 0.025338761508464813, -0.06895976513624191, 0.04497069492936134, 0.023297660052776337, 0.0032169935293495655, -0.041387367993593216, 0.02016158029437065, 0.02068455144762993, 0.017121748998761177, 0.04581644758582115, 0.02236097864806652, 0.014594456180930138, 0.0043742298148572445, 0.032016485929489136, -0.04042670503258705, -0.017369205132126808, 0.029728395864367485, 0.0104972580447793, 0.014581002295017242, -0.0368984080851078, -0.03550088405609131, 0.034835297614336014, -0.0038201783318072557, -0.00901983305811882, 0.05331142619252205, -0.005533281248062849, 0.038524024188518524, 0.01991049200296402, 0.0017104275757446885, 0.02377927117049694, 0.017064837738871574, -0.004815435037016869, -0.054974112659692764, -0.012830636464059353, -0.024772608652710915, -0.019971726462244987, 0.0028359696734696627, 0.036408036947250366, 0.016976086422801018, -0.023139318451285362, 0.015231800265610218, 0.022359883412718773, -0.05933630093932152, -0.024465572088956833, -0.016837531700730324, 0.022656863555312157, -0.028136316686868668, -0.008187803439795971, -0.03783940151333809, 0.013898229226469994, -0.04839175567030907, -0.05103418976068497, -0.012819532305002213, -0.015189062803983688, 0.0036431208718568087, -0.02966618537902832, -0.011217175051569939, -0.05925928056240082, 0.023188704624772072, -0.039864927530288696, 0.028109192848205566, 0.026587754487991333, -0.008236102759838104, -0.020040027797222137, -0.0394950695335865, 0.04475397244095802, -0.0005324064404703677, -0.035293955355882645, 0.016084326431155205, -0.026078585535287857, -0.03605300560593605, 0.017344756051898003, 0.020443392917513847, -0.02637483738362789, 0.013273957185447216, -0.02048441395163536, -0.010027562268078327, -0.021898454055190086, -0.038785774260759354, 0.009421532042324543, 0.019986014813184738, -0.02165539562702179, -0.03155101090669632, -0.022559160366654396, 0.000003413169679333805, 0.03606458753347397, 0.057865552604198456, 0.035710129886865616, 0.007366179954260588, 0.03636044263839722, 0.02043865993618965, -0.05194321647286415, -0.03392190858721733, -0.014810334891080856, -0.035423845052719116, -0.01697443798184395, -0.04443014785647392, 0.08053307980298996, 0.01614658161997795, -0.008586307056248188, 0.008462191559374332, 0.005416975822299719, -0.02012481354176998, 0.000387763197068125, -0.009159918874502182, -0.018476363271474838, -0.0024462812580168247, 0.04698745906352997, 0.01864699460566044, -0.04280419275164604, -0.052030157297849655, -0.024688104167580605, 0.0071898275054991245, 0.0055724396370351315, -0.02762705087661743, 0.005664285738021135, 0.04352698475122452, -0.0004492636362556368, 0.016385233029723167, -0.04122055694460869, 0.019857771694660187, -0.05519171804189682, -0.004788279999047518, 0.02935635671019554, 0.005476552993059158, 0.005084578413516283, 0.009675655514001846, -0.011499316431581974, -0.004558830056339502, 0.001145262154750526, 0.029457908123731613, 0.002896307036280632, 0.0009135009022429585, 0.017379390075802803, -0.005279487930238247, 0.030317705124616623, -0.020792337134480476, -0.013597141951322556, 0.05307065695524216, -0.053826987743377686, -0.016672562807798386, 0.03364109247922897, -0.0005113539518788457, 0.027990715578198433, -0.017559124156832695, 0.01592152565717697, -0.02259557694196701, 0.044188518077135086, -0.057702794671058655, -0.010324648581445217, -0.007114131934940815, -0.013784848153591156, 0.01361237931996584, 0.03195134177803993, -0.022661300376057625, 0.03709789738059044, -0.021087361499667168, 0.025394415482878685, 0.03137115761637688, -0.019297314807772636, 0.009748931042850018, -0.017458219081163406, 0.027680406346917152, 0.031011581420898438, 0.003929561469703913, -0.046741072088479996, 0.014327125623822212, 0.05131189152598381, -0.050485655665397644, 0.04284575581550598, -0.017385268583893776, -0.013017057441174984, -0.06330841779708862, 0.006072825286537409, 0.012374337762594223, 0.028025219216942787, 0.05565967038273811, -0.04919853433966637, 0.02686699479818344, 0.05304454639554024, -0.05322856083512306, 0.032484300434589386, 0.011424127034842968, -0.02924913354218006, -0.058163322508335114, -0.03210524842143059, 0.01251746341586113, -0.015910498797893524, 0.0029036528430879116, 0.008527793921530247, 0.02260545641183853, 0.03634876385331154, 0.007922584190964699, -0.037903040647506714, -0.026254767552018166, 0.05648311972618103, -0.0068096681497991085, -0.05519925430417061, 0.03518928587436676, 0.003212901996448636, -0.031921371817588806, 0.018356280401349068, -0.022838177159428596, 0.023787477985024452, 0.03249656781554222, -0.004012217279523611, -0.019569581374526024, 0.024845164269208908, 0.03620509058237076, -0.04567022621631622, 0.00514264078810811, -0.00032704215846024454, -0.00193282391410321, 0.0330350287258625, 0.02048162743449211, -0.011929074302315712, 0.030620163306593895, 0.0014131496427580714, -0.01144122239202261, 0.012973949313163757, 0.001081967493519187, -0.02066553197801113, 0.014840671792626381, -0.024331852793693542, 0.03518866375088692, -0.040406398475170135, -0.04415538161993027, -0.04130680486559868, -0.005777391605079174, 0.03197356313467026, 0.009956358931958675, -0.03814058005809784, -0.01927793025970459, -0.03671112656593323, -0.004791195970028639, 0.0025009505916386843, 0.00673373369500041, 0.017392685636878014, -0.03912868723273277, -0.011854094453155994, -0.026051931083202362, 0.023963704705238342, -0.019200682640075684, -0.037646785378456116, 0.018884407356381416, 0.03842664510011673, -0.018918586894869804, -0.026479465886950493, -0.014818115159869194, -0.03096713125705719, 0.0004466746759135276, -0.045676689594984055, 0.051195453852415085, -0.0023168642073869705, 0.01112711988389492, -0.035152096301317215, -0.0037127004470676184, -0.05755733326077461, 0.023639850318431854, 0.032133471220731735, 0.01617373339831829, -0.027346663177013397, -0.014015336520969868, -0.008548651821911335, -0.014631494879722595, -0.058221541345119476, 0.03140774369239807, -0.001879922696389258, -0.03382846713066101, -0.014878950081765652, -0.021852994337677956, 0.03993796929717064, 0.003710805671289563, 0.003165752859786153, 0.013316876254975796, 0.009228129871189594, 0.010738042183220387, -0.020759034901857376, -0.011438543908298016, -0.004390403628349304, 0.053189266473054886, 0.05408886820077896, -0.010570568963885307, 0.012500149197876453, -0.00857478566467762, 0.016507554799318314, -0.07812189310789108, 0.04332875460386276, -0.004576627630740404, 0.01788531430065632, 0.005264578387141228, 0.010282309725880623, -0.0005499409744516015, -0.08882808685302734, 0.0016719875857234001, 0.0035723457112908363, 0.004678461235016584, -0.013438563793897629, 0.04122312366962433, 0.050063133239746094, 0.026600167155265808, -0.035353463143110275, 0.03336228430271149, -0.022321805357933044, -0.001403111033141613, 0.021453149616718292, 0.044964499771595, -0.005697950720787048, 0.018427640199661255, 0.03283139690756798, 0.053513024002313614, -0.021493438631296158, 0.010861620306968689, -0.029160041362047195, 0.0311100073158741, -0.03626520186662674, -0.03426990658044815, 0.01060931384563446, 0.014078198932111263, -0.022615958005189896, 0.017707033082842827, 0.019112002104520798, 0.04265518859028816, -0.03232427313923836, 0.003121821442618966, -0.04127366095781326, -0.013121158815920353, -0.04717922583222389, -0.0114892041310668, 0.02696376107633114, 0.029068460687994957, -0.009763055481016636, 0.00606493279337883, -0.00862952508032322, 0.022556835785508156, 0.04254016652703285, 0.0010500927455723286, 0.0014715094584971666, 0.0011000821832567453, -0.017914317548274994, -0.0034240696113556623, 0.010865933261811733, -0.032077714800834656, 0.0020579565316438675, 0.019939372316002846, 0.05122940242290497, 0.011964196339249611, -0.025614211335778236, -0.02378704957664013, -0.003807554254308343, 0.04873693734407425, -0.014940805733203888, -0.03254016861319542, -0.02824907749891281, 0.014098381623625755, 0.01483815535902977, 0.018537525087594986 ]
<p>When I want to apply an ARIMA model like this:</p> <pre><code>arimax(dataMat, order=c(7,0,0), xreg=xreg) </code></pre> <p>it raises an error </p> <blockquote> <p>"singular and could not compute QR decomposition of Hessian" for xreg.</p> </blockquote> <p>How can I fit proper model by using <code>xreg</code> values?</p>
74,352
[ -0.021082963794469833, -0.0023420536890625954, 0.00043706511496566236, -0.023092592135071754, 0.034941431134939194, 0.005336451344192028, -0.03928331285715103, -0.011996036395430565, 0.025970028713345528, -0.010942129418253899, 0.04953473061323166, 0.000020384526578709483, 0.05678320303559303, 0.011980082839727402, 0.06081218644976616, -0.004083028994500637, 0.025939149782061577, -0.03503334894776344, 0.005078402813524008, 0.014331053011119366, -0.0006384295411407948, 0.03215545043349266, -0.052389852702617645, -0.0012965250061824918, -0.004462368320673704, 0.03423526510596275, 0.04719214513897896, 0.024459850043058395, 0.013168783858418465, 0.07335465401411057, -0.024698318913578987, -0.022285405546426773, 0.008192366920411587, 0.0393766351044178, 0.0031823264434933662, 0.0010343494359403849, 0.022662732750177383, -0.0018315381603315473, 0.0030848339665681124, 0.011789127252995968, -0.014895426109433174, -0.015476223081350327, 0.032084569334983826, 0.041918735951185226, -0.028668228536844254, 0.028085986152291298, 0.024583686143159866, -0.02248971536755562, 0.0458860844373703, -0.025398653000593185, 0.06852329522371292, -0.016849935054779053, 0.007995450869202614, 0.04763893783092499, -0.02253306657075882, -0.00011385967809474096, 0.06250809133052826, 0.07748361676931381, -0.03038618713617325, -0.05530702695250511, -0.013824610970914364, -0.0390746183693409, -0.02660319209098816, -0.024411022663116455, -0.050476010888814926, 0.017312344163656235, 0.01133968960493803, -0.022828897461295128, -0.008260003291070461, -0.024411413818597794, 0.028181154280900955, 0.014601076021790504, -0.002743637887760997, -0.03658820316195488, 0.016016708686947823, -0.01910761557519436, 0.025860054418444633, -0.014864487573504448, 0.0476670078933239, 0.030434083193540573, 0.0409453883767128, 0.031990472227334976, 0.031332243233919144, 0.0000793369545135647, 0.0020885963458567858, 0.004822746384888887, 0.03794657438993454, 0.005888651590794325, 0.010991253890097141, 0.03184652701020241, -0.023287160322070122, 0.03199061006307602, 0.05247309431433678, -0.010231549851596355, -0.05239700525999069, 0.0026522246189415455, -0.0003662261296994984, 0.0117188086733222, -0.008512726053595543, -0.021112781018018723, 0.002300502499565482, -0.04513474926352501, -0.0009333835332654417, 0.038214173167943954, -0.010227888822555542, -0.012517467141151428, -0.017773734405636787, -0.028815723955631256, 0.0038846752140671015, -0.05130375921726227, 0.0005317305913195014, 0.013388378545641899, -0.005117272026836872, -0.04991234093904495, 0.010492782108485699, -0.006347494199872017, -0.026907453313469887, -0.043295588344335556, 0.028322381898760796, 0.033023249357938766, 0.05157658830285072, 0.020041316747665405, 0.016391295939683914, -0.04883577302098274, -0.04657847434282303, 0.013087163679301739, -0.014305822551250458, -0.007119561079889536, -0.09333640336990356, 0.01108254212886095, -0.012801927514374256, -0.021652866154909134, 0.029249031096696854, -0.03083270974457264, 0.016213595867156982, 0.0022928768303245306, -0.08303768932819366, -0.02901451475918293, 0.029475616291165352, 0.0132990637794137, 0.0391978845000267, -0.042722783982753754, 0.0126586789265275, 0.06182561069726944, 0.057409681379795074, 0.030171645805239677, 0.059554606676101685, 0.061903052031993866, 0.008483607321977615, -0.02857014164328575, -0.03666970133781433, 0.014266323298215866, -0.03631661459803581, -0.03533703088760376, -0.005340201780200005, -0.0887601375579834, 0.0013867935631424189, 0.025335734710097313, -0.01242848951369524, 0.011894220486283302, 0.037000689655542374, 0.02717619203031063, -0.03607354685664177, -0.013476506806910038, -0.047600507736206055, 0.009878874756395817, 0.05573359131813049, 0.01820722222328186, 0.019693460315465927, -0.017410196363925934, -0.008993512019515038, 0.034463394433259964, -0.002333627315238118, 0.056219231337308884, 0.07741400599479675, 0.002046414418146014, 0.012975470162928104, -0.032300662249326706, -0.0021281037479639053, 0.02097129635512829, -0.06755596399307251, -0.026256587356328964, 0.00861266441643238, -0.010434607975184917, 0.023285211995244026, 0.01891758292913437, -0.0215359628200531, -0.007171961944550276, 0.038082052022218704, -0.03948009014129639, -0.02654881402850151, -0.018532434478402138, 0.03386314958333969, -0.024745704606175423, -0.02506997063755989, -0.01438765786588192, -0.001145266811363399, 0.04515192657709122, 0.017093610018491745, 0.0019150958396494389, -0.01371210440993309, -0.0245161484926939, 0.04017416015267372, -0.011323228478431702, -0.0031253767665475607, 0.03265821188688278, 0.021778039634227753, -0.014654798433184624, 0.022963181138038635, -0.028260622173547745, 0.016157090663909912, 0.002640950959175825, -0.022985750809311867, 0.018482675775885582, -0.0399559922516346, -0.013924708589911461, 0.019328853115439415, 0.026019984856247902, -0.0020740784239023924, 0.04478324204683304, -0.06126534193754196, 0.01774566061794758, 0.04986128583550453, 0.027229761704802513, -0.006395020056515932, 0.002208026824519038, 0.012052309699356556, 0.0019794919062405825, -0.03609433397650719, 0.007467153016477823, -0.025981714949011803, -0.004006214905530214, 0.04267338290810585, 0.02155572734773159, -0.04407569393515587, 0.027506569400429726, 0.08574553579092026, 0.02209402061998844, -0.0021747532300651073, 0.0393199697136879, -0.01875813491642475, -0.004327807109802961, 0.02515431120991707, -0.005212893709540367, 0.040076740086078644, 0.000845639908220619, 0.02233518846333027, -0.01875246688723564, 0.021550001576542854, -0.009614337235689163, 0.0027086129412055016, 0.06202198565006256, 0.010669230483472347, -0.0032764237839728594, 0.01065858919173479, -0.03148701414465904, 0.05979249253869057, -0.006619867868721485, 0.00751808937638998, 0.05813826620578766, 0.012495226226747036, -0.0030900288838893175, 0.019647877663373947, 0.008645555935800076, -0.014506787061691284, 0.0533866323530674, -0.03500048443675041, -0.017285069450736046, 0.015356135554611683, -0.02414335496723652, 0.009723035618662834, -0.0500958114862442, -0.033271290361881256, -0.10147171467542648, 0.013673990964889526, 0.03197140619158745, 0.02226496860384941, -0.00922976341098547, -0.03569558635354042, -0.01793435402214527, 0.013184137642383575, -0.026448871940374374, 0.017545118927955627, 0.0024904627352952957, -0.035800427198410034, 0.020406624302268028, -0.028067968785762787, -0.03197185695171356, 0.03436567261815071, 0.0038720115553587675, -0.020821785554289818, -0.0011749418918043375, -0.02226915769279003, -0.042586375027894974, -0.01025134976953268, -0.06943563371896744, 0.012693025171756744, -0.023061029613018036, -0.04901525005698204, 0.037741512060165405, -0.00193382881116122, -0.03851951286196709, -0.013209743425250053, -0.05809700861573219, 0.026436714455485344, -0.008758623152971268, 0.007643599528819323, 0.025403128936886787, 0.024936486035585403, 0.03598778322339058, 0.050133779644966125, -0.03582628816366196, 0.004476672504097223, -0.06616337597370148, -0.03517137095332146, 0.01231323927640915, -0.012877630069851875, 0.009050709195435047, 0.02777753211557865, -0.0029509516898542643, 0.05654311180114746, 0.05605882406234741, -0.021827489137649536, -0.05481557920575142, -0.012040812522172928, -0.019032718613743782, -0.01723916456103325, 0.014992066659033298, 0.025091882795095444, 0.023707661777734756, 0.0079923365265131, -0.015979859977960587, 0.032099559903144836, 0.052980151027441025, -0.04544711112976074, -0.03396306186914444, 0.02461259439587593, 0.0002908465685322881, 0.017460666596889496, 0.0395456999540329, -0.0059810527600348, 0.0035774167627096176, 0.031437948346138, 0.03229990974068642, -0.000009633084118831903, -0.023842554539442062, -0.0524972528219223, 0.013420418836176395, -0.013860134407877922, 0.03840921074151993, -0.01267651841044426, 0.03364982083439827, 0.006212432403117418, -0.05666754022240639, 0.015219205059111118, 0.0030664491932839155, -0.012110450305044651, -0.03254280239343643, 0.0066233547404408455, 0.02310548536479473, 0.03381893038749695, -0.06341598927974701, -0.007609978783875704, 0.03026425652205944, -0.036829546093940735, 0.029088186100125313, -0.023691590875387192, -0.020798061043024063, 0.011764943599700928, 0.014284326694905758, 0.037907447665929794, -0.0028619084041565657, -0.038594868034124374, 0.0042970976792275906, -0.0831884890794754, 0.03151160851120949, -0.027000129222869873, 0.0616329126060009, 0.0016739265993237495, 0.03547809273004532, 0.01996302232146263, -0.00015185214579105377, 0.007420418784022331, 0.009473690763115883, -0.04651099815964699, 0.06683088093996048, 0.009416929446160793, -0.028114771470427513, 0.046431634575128555, -0.020478682592511177, 0.03080640360713005, -0.02101721242070198, 0.028638875111937523, -0.01325457263737917, -0.0010530625004321337, -0.042993247509002686, 0.014989874325692654, -0.008039183914661407, 0.008869966492056847, -0.025698676705360413, -0.009962709620594978, 0.0794585719704628, -0.016004545614123344, 0.014292227104306221, 0.07486315816640854, 0.009981204755604267, -0.040223538875579834, -0.012036936357617378, 0.015192756429314613, 0.009544464759528637, 0.07631849497556686, 0.02717728726565838, -0.015207094140350819, -0.051868271082639694, 0.019016027450561523, 0.005425385665148497, 0.03154025971889496, 0.03725792467594147, 0.006567022297531366, -0.03757086023688316, -0.020246591418981552, -0.028776075690984726, 0.016699202358722687, -0.022963035851716995, -0.010932138189673424, -0.014073697850108147, 0.032295290380716324, 0.03275027126073837, -0.014429215341806412, 0.003746009897440672, 0.05629461631178856, 0.0414595901966095, 0.00005728692849515937, -0.0352216437458992, -0.012197018601000309, -0.01935104839503765, 0.0027542670723050833, 0.021937672048807144, -0.002537224907428026, -0.03256455063819885, 0.009931515902280807, 0.031876031309366226, -0.03879738599061966, -0.0024726816918700933, -0.0014204946346580982, 0.06390222162008286, 0.033839039504528046, -0.017424775287508965, -0.0322791263461113, 0.024709178134799004, 0.03857892379164696, 0.024081096053123474, 0.019169654697179794, -0.014648018404841423, -0.12292971462011337, 0.024085616692900658, 0.021975785493850708, 0.015637259930372238, -0.011855253018438816, -0.026550455018877983, -0.06227176636457443, -0.01842169091105461, 0.060305241495370865, -0.03221182897686958, 0.0986671969294548, -0.008959733881056309, 0.0077970088459551334, -0.0509931705892086, -0.02480020560324192, -0.0306722279638052, 0.03668651729822159, -0.031096652150154114, 0.023924309760332108, -0.015528272837400436, -0.03851001709699631, -0.03558915853500366, -0.020482685416936874, 0.022033050656318665, 0.0369064025580883, 0.005643456242978573, -0.009387923404574394, -0.007756438106298447, 0.018485600128769875, -0.03723054379224777, -0.06467237323522568, 0.01278979703783989, -0.02717757597565651, -0.014446980319917202, 0.05332714691758156, -0.0037232288159430027, -0.01703173667192459, 0.02728036791086197, 0.03374164551496506, 0.01629696413874626, -0.021430397406220436, -0.03146273270249367, 0.04945714399218559, 0.030012721195816994, 0.004444499965757132, 0.051746197044849396, 0.02212686836719513, -0.014353584498167038, -0.015806427225470543, -0.0667494386434555, -0.012713512405753136, -0.019003896042704582, -0.03425318002700806, -0.054014917463064194, 0.012118970975279808, -0.01796604134142399, 0.014245056547224522, 0.017580075189471245, 0.026547949761152267, -0.04188447818160057, 0.002675300929695368, 0.01889762096107006, 0.032659292221069336, -0.01604583114385605, -0.052180059254169464, 0.012709008529782295, 0.014578936621546745, -0.028519224375486374, -0.0009070092928595841, 0.02737521193921566, -0.04771759733557701, -0.03341231867671013, 0.036381885409355164, -0.03911327198147774, 0.01462479680776596, 0.012722320854663849, -0.019418837502598763, -0.014353649690747261, -0.03042169101536274, 0.0071447924710810184, 0.0012564262142404914, 0.019824955612421036, 0.016238363459706306, -0.02197292074561119, -0.00016956886975094676, 0.004672701936215162, 0.01900695636868477, 0.0017160670831799507, -0.050216857343912125, 0.0425688698887825, 0.012735013850033283, -0.002630727831274271, -0.08993224054574966, -0.028941456228494644, 0.03634348511695862, -0.007593872491270304, -0.04241948947310448, -0.03538336232304573, 0.030573761090636253, -0.029868202283978462, -0.0005637064459733665, -0.023484451696276665, 0.029969196766614914, -0.02231130376458168, 0.010326708666980267, 0.00475320965051651, 0.03604212403297424, 0.068137027323246, 0.006072206422686577, 0.0010875711450353265, 0.06952153146266937, -0.016766218468546867, -0.03004770167171955, -0.013109036721289158, 0.02031976543366909, -0.025845838710665703, 0.010946748778223991, -0.05239391699433327, -0.009635279886424541, 0.05722271651029587, 0.033808715641498566, -0.009778647683560848, 0.008562530390918255, 0.0025325226597487926, 0.022982658818364143, -0.030494553968310356, -0.0075920275412499905, -0.0012021263828501105, -0.0018105126218870282, -0.02875484526157379, -0.04830688610672951, -0.04298431798815727, -0.01323677133768797, -0.01857760362327099, -0.021132629364728928, 0.005030766129493713, 0.040603283792734146, 0.12033618241548538, 0.006973112002015114, -0.01833852380514145, -0.00293373828753829, -0.011400514282286167, 0.058440014719963074, -0.009061106480658054, 0.004996993578970432, -0.025029558688402176, 0.002906061476096511, -0.018877437338232994, -0.04100794717669487, -0.03595529869198799, 0.002619535196572542, 0.06499087065458298, -0.017081592231988907, 0.03371405601501465, 0.017591217532753944, -0.003913962747901678, -0.019738387316465378, -0.011769848875701427, -0.0032164917793124914, -0.03479083627462387, -0.0014125964371487498, 0.06602898985147476, 0.03460530564188957, -0.02003064751625061, 0.017912019044160843, 0.007333553861826658, 0.024836502969264984, 0.03852143511176109, 0.026318447664380074, 0.031884144991636276, -0.0336548276245594, 0.0009719064109958708, -0.03755965828895569, 0.042201366275548935, -0.018200473859906197, 0.05334087088704109, -0.028306860476732254, -0.024925699457526207, 0.033467795699834824, 0.02990330196917057, -0.03217826038599014, -0.019177652895450592, 0.0031246906146407127, -0.04190634936094284, -0.006694368086755276, 0.005008697044104338, -0.02088191919028759, 0.04499261826276779, 0.045384980738162994, 0.06470916420221329, 0.016099704429507256, 0.0539599172770977, 0.007670547813177109, -0.04862481728196144, 0.0019701190758496523, -0.016854137182235718, -0.05780121311545372, 0.06365205347537994, -0.02480195462703705, 0.013964391313493252, 0.014238913543522358, -0.03688804805278778, 0.047222305089235306, -0.04643269255757332, 0.03684413805603981, 0.013771944679319859, 0.07063228636980057, -0.007428743876516819, -0.01752926968038082, -0.00034410913940519094, -0.000636266078799963, 0.12856826186180115, 0.07160613685846329, 0.002393126953393221, -0.042132165282964706, 0.027690047398209572, 0.04456394165754318, -0.009417528286576271, -0.028948385268449783, -0.004504562355577946, 0.002089405432343483, 0.002382479375228286, 0.044177860021591187, 0.03856227546930313, 0.013239076361060143, 0.019043684005737305, 0.019505193457007408, -0.05593954399228096, -0.03368537873029709, 0.014135037548840046, 0.02388630248606205, -0.0021405597217381, -0.004770738538354635, -0.06709561496973038, 0.0026028314605355263, -0.01745489612221718, -0.01145672146230936, -0.02958640642464161, -0.010327283293008804, -0.02683069556951523, 0.0070315697230398655, -0.01202484779059887, 0.020654447376728058, 0.0036511558573693037, 0.03310743719339371, -0.016754349693655968, -0.005733374040573835, -0.011318611912429333, -0.004342243075370789, 0.0073906430043280125, 0.022265059873461723, 0.005629681050777435, -0.03226742520928383, -0.009119107387959957, -0.009783683344721794, -0.05110524222254753, -0.023894859477877617, -0.021390199661254883, 0.028130410239100456, -0.019069503992795944, 0.004731951281428337, -0.0028827085625380278, 0.02274089679121971, -0.01817275770008564, -0.01598307490348816, -0.020035455003380775, 0.01637331023812294, 0.000266045710304752, -0.031990714371204376, -0.028576986864209175, -0.010270371101796627, -0.01886104606091976, -0.0059353564865887165, 0.04204406216740608, 0.03788308799266815, -0.036938413977622986, 0.01837562583386898, -0.06576338410377502, 0.07612282037734985, -0.03785889968276024, 0.017085274681448936, -0.0233024712651968, -0.022569779306650162, -0.01111888699233532, -0.03461148962378502, 0.017672065645456314, -0.005377344787120819, 0.05643174797296524, -0.03585033863782883, -0.01927926205098629, -0.021251603960990906, -0.0031004869379103184, 0.01093803159892559, -0.017937537282705307, -0.021068241447210312, -0.047416429966688156, 0.014885632321238518, 0.0029872057493776083, 0.03587554767727852, 0.02894274890422821, 0.0019684794824570417, -0.0403502956032753, 0.0136505626142025, 0.01860843040049076, -0.016164017841219902, -0.03856104612350464, 0.004106628242880106, -0.03796062618494034, 0.0019690152257680893, 0.029453430324792862, 0.07263816893100739, 0.015459136106073856, 0.01578790321946144, -0.02943338453769684, 0.010870348662137985, -0.014967558905482292, 0.013751148246228695, 0.016178719699382782, 0.0017715708818286657, 0.034792881458997726, 0.022873347625136375, 0.06091941520571709, -0.0438431054353714, -0.026805859059095383, -0.04972606524825096, -0.04639811813831329, -0.003230797126889229, 0.007211882155388594, -0.025250190868973732, 0.030336720868945122, -0.03589833155274391, 0.024096500128507614, -0.04459422826766968, 0.0005845336709171534, -0.00002525117997720372, -0.004577526357024908, -0.03923557326197624, -0.0026107081212103367, -0.02834666334092617, 0.01563749834895134, -0.016294311732053757, 0.026878846809267998, 0.02893734909594059, 0.0032369953114539385, 0.0031156265176832676, -0.018059536814689636, 0.0010252698557451367, -0.015087856911122799, 0.06856084614992142, 0.0020008529536426067, -0.02600226365029812, 0.03789893910288811, -0.06490116566419601, -0.023051703348755836, -0.029227284714579582, -0.026115484535694122, 0.01075656060129404, 0.017317472025752068, -0.0018685354152694345, 0.026198267936706543, -0.001999400556087494, 0.021909642964601517, -0.005183672998100519, 0.0019844253547489643, 0.018393365666270256, 0.025782372802495956, -0.01729288510978222, 0.0061783860437572, 0.00917581096291542, -0.02754649892449379, 0.009646046906709671, 0.04433136060833931, 0.019302373751997948, 0.026394937187433243, 0.03455621376633644, 0.006608821451663971, 0.003170018782839179, 0.01412923913449049, -0.0038201671559363604, 0.055762890726327896, 0.0291470717638731, -0.05953389033675194, -0.002818340202793479, -0.04870595410466194, -0.00609169527888298, -0.04133497178554535, -0.010460088029503822, -0.0045421309769153595, -0.03540759161114693, 0.05274660512804985, -0.04567715898156166, 0.026347924023866653, 0.03370879590511322, -0.037929266691207886, 0.02631876803934574, -0.0005616277339868248, -0.002415656577795744, -0.020010199397802353, 0.024200504645705223, -0.02037028782069683, 0.024175086989998817, 0.051910243928432465, 0.014031202532351017, 0.04338744655251503, 0.0140236122533679, 0.024838048964738846, -0.0007836514269001782, -0.032652728259563446, -0.0060357279144227505, -0.02939314767718315, -0.0732957273721695, 0.04906022176146507, -0.03240933641791344, -0.01353143248707056, -0.000029126229492248967, -0.0583617202937603, 0.022842634469270706, 0.014953836798667908, 0.03328675031661987, 0.02086576446890831, 0.025321893393993378, 0.0552540197968483, -0.020202863961458206, -0.028225643560290337, -0.018801147118210793, 0.02780846506357193, 0.03514295071363449, -0.01801753230392933, 0.024866599589586258, 0.0034803273156285286, 0.01834724470973015, -0.014215366914868355, 0.01173181552439928, -0.012577254325151443, -0.04510301724076271, -0.01422182284295559, 0.012081311084330082, -0.02932305634021759, -0.01848972775042057, 0.021573567762970924, -0.00849873200058937, 0.009799153544008732, 0.033976275473833084, 0.02347314916551113, -0.012123172171413898, 0.013866247609257698, -0.004797785077244043, -0.0502186119556427, 0.024828998371958733, -0.004784443415701389, 0.003535290714353323, -0.046716731041669846, -0.013176264241337776, 0.000023837601474951953, 0.007264767307788134, -0.0331827811896801, 0.0027612391859292984, -0.040131062269210815, 0.05634206905961037, -0.03673083707690239, -0.00944729708135128, 0.03142146021127701, -0.01266586221754551, 0.02266320399940014, -0.08962088078260422, 0.05121259391307831, -0.009981852024793625, -0.025907395407557487, 0.015623919665813446, -0.05272531509399414, -0.0289804395288229, 0.028790103271603584, 0.050677429884672165, 0.0201845932751894, 0.02227094955742359, 0.00987483561038971, 0.035281192511320114, -0.0062184687703847885, -0.02985372580587864, 0.00557773606851697, 0.008600215427577496, 0.00045740901259705424, -0.01583465375006199, -0.010448286309838295, -0.0099489102140069, -0.013904069550335407, -0.002512649865821004, 0.015668336302042007, 0.023498916998505592, 0.005811333656311035, -0.017634714022278786, 0.03192188963294029, -0.013644369319081306, -0.005252638831734657, 0.04709804430603981, 0.01638520509004593, -0.007543489336967468, 0.07464951276779175, -0.007573586422950029, -0.060644760727882385, 0.0070612626150250435, -0.05317992717027664, -0.008098969236016273, 0.015874391421675682, -0.0029716945718973875, 0.027685772627592087, -0.05510778725147247, -0.011211657896637917, 0.06754843145608902, -0.03390495106577873, 0.014505945146083832, 0.040914252400398254, -0.002050628885626793, 0.03333393856883049, -0.00033991667442023754, 0.02854870818555355, 0.01274347584694624, -0.004965139552950859, 0.0032641978468745947, 0.017687872052192688, 0.019936850294470787, -0.002309041330590844, -0.001462071668356657, 0.03218977525830269, -0.00593936163932085, 0.03553236648440361, -0.02003190480172634, 0.052898723632097244, -0.011654837056994438, -0.045533567667007446, 0.0054339393973350525, 0.001112243509851396, 0.01850593462586403, 0.007386394310742617, -0.005498397164046764, 0.03613666817545891, -0.009395122528076172, -0.014813493937253952, 0.009148324839770794, 0.013420104049146175, -0.04243519529700279, 0.020105063915252686, 0.01035771332681179, 0.020410655066370964, -0.024114251136779785, -0.003607088001444936, 0.016802873462438583, -0.0415930338203907, 0.019182689487934113, -0.00464524095878005, -0.05179252848029137, 0.008865765295922756, 0.0059046619571745396, -0.024630527943372726, -0.035676028579473495, -0.00288600055500865, -0.03961297124624252, 0.03925284743309021, 0.004598098807036877, 0.009149095974862576, -0.031057491898536682, -0.03460957854986191, -0.013382733799517155, 0.010272777639329433, -0.07133776694536209, -0.042037833482027054, 0.0009010072681121528, -0.030998796224594116, -0.013122362084686756, -0.025933032855391502 ]
<p>I am doing a two-way independent ANOVA using type of organisational change (5 levels) and job level (7 levels) within the organisation as the factors (in SPSS). I followed Andy Field's procedure (<em>Discovering Statistics Using SPSS</em>, third edition) and I cannot manage to get the option of Post-Hoc tests for cases where equal variance is not assumed, i.e. Games-Howell. </p> <p>I searched the syntax help files and somewhere there's a note saying that when using more than one factor Games-Howell cannot be performed. However, Andy Field did it! (please see page 434 of his book). Any ideas how can I do the same?</p>
74,353
[ -0.05585998296737671, 0.016511354595422745, -0.00041831875569187105, 0.02093360386788845, 0.012232523411512375, -0.00775988819077611, 0.0042453333735466, -0.038098178803920746, 0.016212955117225647, -0.02064124308526516, 0.015509556047618389, 0.024074554443359375, 0.06048272177577019, -0.0026696810964494944, 0.01239213440567255, -0.031208785250782967, 0.0030707442201673985, -0.006540406960994005, -0.00014074610953684896, 0.004022171255201101, -0.011308913119137287, -0.002143238903954625, -0.02870137244462967, 0.006875497754663229, -0.005878404248505831, 0.0469941608607769, 0.016205763444304466, -0.03944427892565727, -0.006441003642976284, 0.0379529632627964, -0.028176601976156235, -0.04206472635269165, -0.0070351953618228436, -0.004790192935615778, 0.03338688984513283, -0.011730560101568699, -0.0038001311477273703, -0.03284347429871559, 0.006110659800469875, 0.024510284885764122, -0.015109517611563206, 0.009999345056712627, 0.003702105488628149, 0.08238846808671951, -0.029854759573936462, 0.018737921491265297, -0.02047504484653473, 0.007478402461856604, 0.04064415395259857, -0.029821962118148804, 0.06167617812752724, -0.01102498173713684, 0.019126450642943382, 0.07062890380620956, -0.04597650095820427, 0.011612038128077984, 0.031043531373143196, 0.020195981487631798, -0.024799225851893425, -0.0183015875518322, -0.035899899899959564, -0.03831440210342407, 0.0033439151011407375, 0.024339672178030014, -0.05472978204488754, 0.009387519210577011, -0.0028177930507808924, -0.01658850908279419, 0.06083808094263077, -0.018908586353063583, 0.03839533403515816, 0.0014995088567957282, 0.045199889689683914, 0.004897465929389, 0.009635752066969872, -0.041544798761606216, 0.042626045644283295, 0.02447468973696232, 0.012524133548140526, 0.029894940555095673, -0.0011320298071950674, 0.04597068578004837, -0.008209562860429287, 0.009704677388072014, 0.003574731294065714, -0.02448493055999279, 0.051313113421201706, -0.02637971192598343, -0.022667793557047844, 0.03625533729791641, -0.023292675614356995, -0.014857949689030647, 0.07633199542760849, 0.047148264944553375, -0.025661557912826538, 0.005928855389356613, -0.03704144433140755, 0.04038136824965477, -0.04456145316362381, 0.010475610382854939, 0.012272010557353497, -0.016066063195466995, 0.0579020231962204, 0.0156670194119215, -0.016952089965343475, 0.016386736184358597, -0.017296040430665016, -0.02860603667795658, -0.03189285844564438, -0.055321451276540756, -0.026468425989151, 0.021137168630957603, -0.008033229038119316, -0.02239852398633957, -0.008110499009490013, -0.01436614990234375, -0.048476964235305786, 0.038876332342624664, 0.07464391738176346, 0.06153162196278572, 0.04330506548285484, -0.04325420409440994, 0.04383604973554611, -0.025439497083425522, -0.0901588425040245, -0.01076837070286274, 0.005273264367133379, -0.016123618930578232, -0.0163323525339365, 0.07163667678833008, 0.017396993935108185, 0.0267051812261343, 0.03301971033215523, 0.03230449557304382, 0.0375107116997242, 0.015396536327898502, -0.09578893333673477, -0.0969938263297081, 0.008329678326845169, -0.016463644802570343, 0.04395369440317154, -0.06661099195480347, -0.008726155385375023, 0.00893904734402895, 0.05495328828692436, -0.0042377132922410965, 0.0015623806975781918, -0.00345921004191041, 0.008325386792421341, 0.01860235258936882, -0.015016886405646801, -0.021900512278079987, -0.02965427003800869, -0.04161230847239494, -0.001228546374477446, -0.06418247520923615, 0.00596702890470624, 0.003778838086873293, -0.010507226921617985, 0.017418794333934784, 0.021571939811110497, 0.03788788244128227, -0.02655191160738468, -0.02374240756034851, 0.01096090953797102, -0.011432511731982231, 0.0746026411652565, -0.018394315615296364, 0.005549915134906769, -0.002982676960527897, -0.006711847614496946, 0.016320552676916122, -0.05470575764775276, 0.035488568246364594, 0.03504763916134834, -0.03338545188307762, -0.029394984245300293, -0.00689656613394618, 0.014069539494812489, 0.0019004005007445812, -0.057397693395614624, 0.00574204046279192, -0.04393678531050682, 0.000991086708381772, 0.02046680822968483, 0.010835429653525352, -0.00230991980060935, 0.010486425831913948, 0.04511893540620804, -0.04669403284788132, -0.08481793105602264, -0.05497974157333374, 0.041492048650979996, 0.03926951810717583, -0.02566634863615036, 0.03899196535348892, -0.01592276804149151, 0.02245377004146576, -0.019166477024555206, -0.024380499497056007, -0.0026438937056809664, 0.004053826443850994, 0.037795327603816986, -0.06355424970388412, 0.009355639107525349, 0.033540286123752594, 0.023322025313973427, -0.01678326353430748, 0.04309142753481865, -0.06218603625893593, -0.033448413014411926, 0.02496505156159401, -0.03840956836938858, 0.026631275191903114, -0.0011387590784579515, -0.00930789951235056, 0.0333537720143795, 0.0331866480410099, -0.005710169207304716, 0.04896427318453789, -0.07339209318161011, 0.06630168855190277, 0.10175904631614685, -0.011838722042739391, 0.0244365893304348, 0.011753417551517487, 0.025172777473926544, 0.026110826060175896, -0.042715150862932205, 0.02229880355298519, -0.0006537563749589026, -0.016407009214162827, 0.023993467912077904, -0.03465403988957405, -0.03739291429519653, -0.0033149796072393656, 0.0659685954451561, 0.01288795005530119, -0.005938738118857145, 0.07702133059501648, 0.004419415257871151, -0.009189588949084282, 0.004370213486254215, 0.029508324339985847, 0.02093835361301899, 0.024672003462910652, 0.006868604104965925, 0.003268874017521739, 0.016782475635409355, 0.008021035231649876, -0.0010588514851406217, 0.007414859253913164, 0.010228464379906654, 0.02894683927297592, -0.00975535623729229, -0.024307528510689735, 0.029920214787125587, 0.002568639349192381, 0.041076529771089554, 0.04718003794550896, 0.015676554292440414, -0.042279038578271866, 0.005442607682198286, -0.033091846853494644, 0.03910573944449425, 0.021095145493745804, -0.04861673712730408, 0.004610653035342693, 0.026179179549217224, -0.017214110121130943, -0.0028802002780139446, -0.007374221924692392, -0.0042076027020812035, -0.03278152272105217, -0.003157423809170723, 0.017915816977620125, 0.00048252649139612913, 0.06032169982790947, -0.021148888394236565, 0.03061048872768879, -0.02864563651382923, 0.012343090958893299, 0.03965708985924721, 0.022596778348088264, -0.04287363961338997, -0.020794473588466644, -0.011881164275109768, -0.015907103195786476, 0.013155854307115078, -0.01887389086186886, -0.02000133879482746, 0.060486335307359695, 0.030117904767394066, -0.026494890451431274, -0.004171482753008604, 0.013713160529732704, 0.00538469385355711, 0.01255277544260025, -0.028926631435751915, 0.042135290801525116, 0.04150083661079407, -0.0216861329972744, -0.0007940143113955855, -0.014256520196795464, -0.011032840237021446, -0.0018436784157529473, 0.003808604786172509, -0.02515176683664322, 0.019362375140190125, 0.012292447499930859, 0.03301364183425903, -0.02970268577337265, -0.012636923231184483, -0.03780382126569748, -0.06316044181585312, -0.00032291104434989393, 0.025816569104790688, 0.04226929321885109, -0.06622743606567383, -0.013215137645602226, 0.047628484666347504, 0.02405717223882675, -0.01992625743150711, -0.08028870820999146, -0.03449730947613716, -0.04011774808168411, -0.06399523466825485, 0.03188232704997063, 0.013807600364089012, -0.02543298713862896, 0.036647696048021317, 0.008085335604846478, 0.028981534764170647, 0.07863865047693253, 0.011173118837177753, 0.00010980016668327153, 0.0075911181047558784, 0.039818499237298965, 0.01054023951292038, 0.04370253160595894, -0.028432363644242287, -0.03202435001730919, -0.0006791604100726545, -0.019659297540783882, 0.024307608604431152, -0.024015605449676514, -0.0037127407267689705, -0.0007974010659381747, -0.0018454974051564932, 0.006729522254317999, -0.05501052737236023, 0.03312307968735695, 0.0462992787361145, -0.025346484035253525, 0.008520122617483139, -0.002736407797783613, 0.02816344052553177, -0.01895896904170513, -0.01589381881058216, 0.049800895154476166, 0.005714640952646732, 0.0008910059696063399, -0.027681313455104828, -0.018651390448212624, -0.0012814286164939404, 0.04891031235456467, -0.021809590980410576, -0.034188736230134964, 0.029664987698197365, 0.031034911051392555, 0.03973371163010597, -0.00838092528283596, -0.035209640860557556, 0.03619702532887459, -0.05109574273228645, 0.034225158393383026, -0.016710784286260605, 0.034554462879896164, -0.014693628996610641, 0.06234296038746834, 0.010078377090394497, -0.014690646901726723, -0.020341748371720314, -0.015884989872574806, -0.026460006833076477, 0.021929414942860603, -0.006542093586176634, 0.020727816969156265, 0.06613747030496597, 0.0049142357893288136, 0.023827604949474335, -0.021588077768683434, -0.00030163562041707337, 0.02599574625492096, 0.023079734295606613, -0.0017411664593964815, -0.002838218817487359, -0.03592406213283539, -0.01947268843650818, 0.0031203720718622208, 0.028714526444673538, 0.018348999321460724, -0.027905303984880447, 0.030975263565778732, -0.03408601135015488, -0.016128111630678177, -0.022320149466395378, 0.004123978782445192, 0.01099962368607521, 0.0040675061754882336, 0.031517159193754196, 0.025711694732308388, 0.030106371268630028, -0.04983348026871681, 0.03397423028945923, 0.008384195156395435, 0.01524257194250822, 0.03387230262160301, 0.014622977934777737, -0.027026493102312088, -0.009546979330480099, -0.010610707104206085, -0.002579750493168831, 0.0286659337580204, 0.006762940436601639, -0.012125122360885143, 0.019610295072197914, 0.05435018241405487, -0.061084456741809845, -0.0009733414044603705, 0.07654334604740143, 0.02008003555238247, -0.028316840529441833, 0.012562914751470089, -0.009464300237596035, -0.011340045370161533, -0.016984514892101288, 0.014491528272628784, 0.04672761633992195, 0.038194987922906876, 0.02235397696495056, 0.08461442589759827, -0.010071801021695137, -0.021723652258515358, 0.020341120660305023, 0.008741267025470734, 0.016424326226115227, 0.024473339319229126, -0.02727305144071579, 0.014150772243738174, 0.021476171910762787, 0.036435019224882126, 0.007164657115936279, -0.010569159872829914, -0.045500416308641434, -0.007990607060492039, 0.05952556058764458, 0.0570356510579586, 0.012287846766412258, 0.030394427478313446, 0.0062121679075062275, -0.028462734073400497, 0.01828400045633316, -0.031977348029613495, 0.0471930056810379, -0.016187600791454315, -0.011965901590883732, -0.03711410239338875, -0.019046112895011902, -0.026056241244077682, 0.013920544646680355, -0.01036018319427967, 0.03923884034156799, 0.01324230432510376, -0.03777552396059036, -0.008527197875082493, -0.035908229649066925, 0.017448024824261665, 0.02168126031756401, -0.023448826745152473, -0.020166512578725815, 0.010419710539281368, 0.04387389123439789, -0.012385882437229156, -0.0335247777402401, -0.002622221363708377, 0.008243978954851627, 0.004253195133060217, 0.06408421695232391, -0.021938510239124298, -0.018508825451135635, -0.014077313244342804, 0.006038374733179808, 0.003537341021001339, -0.004123433493077755, 0.0027384827844798565, 0.05153575912117958, 0.020472578704357147, -0.0024991915561258793, 0.07222969084978104, -0.015726521611213684, 0.007895492017269135, -0.001821463811211288, -0.030313409864902496, 0.027414677664637566, -0.006230419501662254, -0.01038387417793274, -0.05441823974251747, 0.025046387687325478, -0.02365596778690815, 0.019061041995882988, 0.025447318330407143, 0.030076321214437485, -0.04727105051279068, -0.016488363966345787, -0.012397476471960545, 0.033813878893852234, -0.006795268040150404, 0.007428252138197422, 0.019304905086755753, 0.009823424741625786, -0.010170012712478638, -0.02368253283202648, 0.0121756661683321, -0.028685975819826126, -0.010853905230760574, -0.007639024872332811, -0.03053976036608219, 0.034964848309755325, -0.04213443025946617, -0.018367143347859383, -0.01454488281160593, -0.04765794426202774, -0.0037944400683045387, -0.031506527215242386, 0.05930313095450401, -0.024985961616039276, -0.006706236395984888, -0.012281340546905994, 0.044925592839717865, 0.0015551320975646377, -0.006770947016775608, -0.022384032607078552, 0.015452361665666103, -0.0038972622714936733, -0.0006726905703544617, -0.08622174710035324, -0.022207120433449745, -0.0009500223095528781, 0.012631334364414215, 0.0003804015286732465, 0.008841305039823055, -0.022767340764403343, -0.0035991398617625237, 0.002002906519919634, -0.03514166548848152, 0.041783787310123444, -0.03846745565533638, 0.02315795049071312, 0.03221803531050682, 0.06207134574651718, 0.021840423345565796, 0.010722161270678043, -0.001981412060558796, 0.0124626774340868, -0.03175615891814232, 0.0014088638126850128, -0.01307397335767746, -0.02908411994576454, -0.03856758773326874, -0.0011237403377890587, -0.006658898666501045, 0.004265652969479561, 0.02316748909652233, -0.02801906131207943, -0.018412701785564423, 0.026124998927116394, -0.030043169856071472, 0.008130094036459923, -0.02873200736939907, 0.013645670376718044, -0.022521506994962692, 0.021914396435022354, -0.025056548416614532, 0.011256666854023933, -0.013848597183823586, 0.0038908086717128754, -0.019390996545553207, -0.0015722085954621434, -0.016982562839984894, 0.029826750978827477, 0.09157203882932663, -0.02383675053715706, -0.021331055089831352, 0.03838079422712326, -0.037029702216386795, 0.005567741114646196, 0.027063637971878052, 0.013524025678634644, -0.028941065073013306, 0.02663641981780529, -0.052611563354730606, -0.02484368346631527, 0.01421006117016077, 0.01681470312178135, 0.04205549508333206, 0.003989682532846928, 0.04421195387840271, 0.07256146520376205, 0.016912037506699562, -0.03982110694050789, -0.03225059062242508, -0.026126742362976074, -0.023395895957946777, -0.01013842411339283, 0.08758227527141571, 0.011250108480453491, 0.027922770008444786, 0.045623380690813065, 0.05381511151790619, 0.022955162450671196, 0.04428073391318321, 0.035756517201662064, 0.040747057646512985, -0.0006854039966128767, -0.01026119664311409, -0.04408233240246773, 0.0062874602153897285, -0.05236577242612839, 0.007565206848084927, -0.0578041709959507, -0.007072433363646269, 0.026571273803710938, 0.0940513089299202, -0.013437441550195217, -0.010833696462213993, -0.01454938855022192, -0.0572679340839386, 0.03524434566497803, -0.021549517288804054, -0.013047565706074238, -0.003091057064011693, 0.011925511062145233, 0.05382499471306801, -0.012459089048206806, -0.0281522274017334, -0.01343806553632021, -0.035009533166885376, -0.012269356288015842, -0.019900701940059662, -0.013976650312542915, 0.037245720624923706, -0.019901093095541, -0.02614133432507515, -0.001971713500097394, -0.008391237817704678, 0.013929272070527077, -0.00812080129981041, 0.01931794360280037, 0.02610485814511776, 0.04324750974774361, -0.006290915422141552, 0.03357166051864624, -0.005756214261054993, -0.009086310863494873, 0.12161221355199814, 0.059291284531354904, 0.04528344050049782, -0.04869725927710533, -0.00003883118915837258, -0.006581114139407873, 0.024467524141073227, -0.01926359534263611, 0.0027047526091337204, -0.03294874355196953, -0.025392185896635056, 0.002006735187023878, 0.07587643712759018, 0.06682748347520828, -0.02489141933619976, 0.055223412811756134, -0.03260130435228348, -0.027549704536795616, -0.03243962675333023, 0.015544479712843895, -0.004019396845251322, -0.05043811351060867, -0.028859443962574005, 0.0040242173708975315, 0.025515669956803322, 0.020456518977880478, -0.009575826115906239, -0.008827653713524342, 0.0032476731576025486, 0.0202901903539896, -0.015128438360989094, -0.001668988261371851, 0.0165372546762228, 0.021240612491965294, -0.0336158312857151, -0.01734248176217079, 0.026891933754086494, -0.03581641614437103, 0.03171847388148308, 0.054805852472782135, 0.04695858433842659, -0.015876032412052155, 0.01526650134474039, -0.0010172162437811494, -0.03467264398932457, 0.0014217263087630272, 0.016982080414891243, 0.015460880473256111, 0.009811780415475368, -0.03489471599459648, -0.038039710372686386, -0.0333157517015934, -0.023458613082766533, -0.017594721168279648, -0.0069485194981098175, -0.0005046919686719775, 0.04293186962604523, -0.05082856863737106, 0.0002931402705144137, -0.04623541980981827, -0.029180705547332764, 0.00009538144513498992, 0.027281679213047028, 0.06142799183726311, -0.02833399549126625, -0.011382953263819218, -0.06038583070039749, 0.01753709837794304, -0.00629679299890995, -0.032538216561079025, -0.002451872918754816, 0.04433099180459976, -0.025106247514486313, -0.0038556973449885845, -0.01489479374140501, 0.0401257760822773, 0.02561117149889469, -0.006580173037946224, -0.03723572939634323, -0.03212650865316391, -0.04836323484778404, -0.012190134264528751, -0.04951997846364975, -0.007379127666354179, -0.010917887091636658, 0.021476024761795998, 0.026029448956251144, 0.020780770108103752, -0.008588346652686596, -0.024034062400460243, -0.021254293620586395, 0.032593946903944016, 0.04143062233924866, -0.08398310840129852, -0.03970057889819145, -0.005705083254724741, -0.054768647998571396, -0.0290879774838686, -0.046156421303749084, 0.04649681597948074, 0.001288499217480421, 0.00522767286747694, -0.002647493965923786, 0.012656796723604202, -0.03008096106350422, 0.03236452862620354, 0.03436416760087013, -0.03457379341125488, -0.03919773921370506, 0.0040086861699819565, -0.01153389923274517, -0.01852804236114025, -0.007336361333727837, -0.07843761891126633, -0.007071152329444885, 0.026578016579151154, -0.012227741070091724, -0.032556936144828796, -0.03718337044119835, -0.015058308839797974, 0.01432929839938879, -0.03215819597244263, 0.021285342052578926, -0.020340019837021828, -0.0250858087092638, -0.004119431599974632, 0.006019356660544872, -0.014249619096517563, 0.0317629836499691, -0.025085894390940666, 0.019508354365825653, 0.02448759600520134, 0.027828138321638107, -0.017094941809773445, -0.011538921855390072, -0.008372257463634014, 0.02516118623316288, 0.05763229727745056, 0.00954226404428482, 0.019124388694763184, 0.004913511220365763, -0.03926287591457367, -0.0411188080906868, 0.03395330160856247, 0.0014875518390908837, 0.08301158994436264, 0.01616870053112507, -0.015069971792399883, -0.05055380240082741, 0.06391460448503494, -0.031308613717556, -0.0657821074128151, -0.018405424430966377, 0.021008916199207306, -0.008221261203289032, -0.034320395439863205, 0.008135772310197353, 0.024560095742344856, -0.010888200253248215, 0.03370624780654907, 0.027313929051160812, 0.011549178510904312, -0.06243640556931496, -0.012656236998736858, -0.017066417261958122, 0.015592928044497967, 0.04310024529695511, -0.009646342135965824, 0.03596332296729088, 0.06908522546291351, 0.0012571931583806872, 0.004744336940348148, 0.001341679715551436, 0.018862657248973846, -0.07319668680429459, -0.020740335807204247, -0.011227886192500591, 0.023199664428830147, 0.014953909441828728, -0.042992811650037766, 0.017367340624332428, 0.008577356114983559, -0.08077090233564377, -0.00108535576146096, 0.024922626093029976, -0.0182228721678257, -0.00720409257337451, -0.0022278781980276108, -0.051123470067977905, -0.0009352373308502138, 0.02261529117822647, 0.03162774443626404, 0.015974316745996475, 0.011009217239916325, -0.01022393349558115, -0.05626816675066948, 0.005990978796035051, 0.002789311110973358, 0.03251420706510544, -0.07421727478504181, -0.004848309326916933, -0.00540916109457612, -0.03396154195070267, 0.011837108992040157, -0.047969039529561996, 0.001739008235745132, 0.0071704937145113945, 0.04172566533088684, 0.011485408991575241, 0.04880413040518761, 0.0047888378612697124, -0.004769215825945139, -0.0074865552596747875, 0.0024547858629375696, -0.002244004048407078, 0.012068266049027443, -0.026117704808712006, 0.0022858481388539076, 0.011504601687192917, -0.0276032667607069, -0.031477589160203934, -0.018142281100153923, -0.034114643931388855, 0.008004418574273586, 0.016994021832942963, -0.005045958794653416, 0.036108795553445816, 0.020184500142931938, -0.005442416295409203, -0.02190239168703556, -0.007771686185151339, 0.027000823989510536, 0.021287187933921814, -0.01003194134682417, -0.0023211247753351927, -0.0158685389906168, -0.020999375730752945, 0.01483963429927826, -0.030638430267572403, -0.0018964556511491537, -0.08286360651254654, -0.012026388198137283, -0.015199418179690838, -0.002738681621849537, 0.00007313623063964769, -0.000029275699489517137, 0.005832530092447996, 0.01988166756927967, -0.02056359313428402, -0.014956818893551826, 0.011887132190167904, -0.004030324053019285, 0.034781210124492645, -0.07558757811784744, 0.05983294919133186, -0.004104902036488056, -0.04832589626312256, -0.033103615045547485, -0.06280706822872162, -0.03687307983636856, 0.020915314555168152, 0.06282471120357513, -0.03694341704249382, 0.03675007447600365, -0.035311415791511536, 0.029826711863279343, -0.014177098870277405, -0.05267590284347534, 0.07162852585315704, -0.0018995832651853561, -0.006055071484297514, 0.047523315995931625, -0.007733985316008329, 0.032031524926424026, 0.00263927667401731, 0.013385508209466934, -0.015513420104980469, 0.00961195956915617, -0.017107747495174408, -0.005344698205590248, -0.015368053689599037, -0.005067984573543072, -0.02258428744971752, -0.0035138230305165052, -0.016066506505012512, -0.015570889227092266, 0.029033608734607697, 0.025809723883867264, -0.023061977699398994, 0.05849696695804596, -0.039073288440704346, -0.010325949639081955, -0.013007424771785736, 0.045571353286504745, 0.018857048824429512, -0.018493035808205605, 0.004931680392473936, -0.009962234646081924, -0.04396389052271843, 0.0067990617826581, 0.05378245189785957, 0.01406012661755085, 0.020285138860344887, 0.002008523093536496, -0.031045986339449883, -0.003603121032938361, -0.025208577513694763, 0.029797619208693504, 0.009682048112154007, 0.03272136673331261, 0.03648513928055763, -0.023569654673337936, 0.05402112379670143, 0.006729599088430405, 0.026185862720012665, 0.0022044284269213676, -0.0038188062608242035, 0.006799942348152399, 0.0057846554554998875, 0.017646528780460358, -0.010405679233372211, 0.025522705167531967, 0.01934952288866043, -0.032437894493341446, 0.03387622535228729, -0.051456741988658905, 0.02228519693017006, -0.03267793357372284, 0.023937689140439034, -0.0018086680211126804, -0.011291190050542355, 0.04101366549730301, 0.035357244312763214, -0.04294998198747635, -0.005455025006085634, 0.0380377434194088, -0.018586965277791023, -0.01607481576502323, 0.0016751402290537953, 0.011128461919724941, -0.01701166480779648, 0.02606944367289543, -0.016706442460417747, -0.009588274173438549, -0.01649441570043564, -0.0419343076646328, 0.05129537358880043, 0.02915322780609131, 0.02958999015390873, -0.07489004731178284, -0.04421132430434227, -0.01912098564207554, 0.05329252406954765, -0.006238326895982027, -0.019527550786733627, -0.0383894145488739, 0.022878333926200867, -0.013292524963617325, 0.01052758377045393 ]
<p>So I have a multi-label classification problem where the exact number of labels in each test set example is unknown. The loss function is mean F1-score which is </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/5bMSS.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>where p is the precision and r is the recall. I also have posterior (beta) distributions for each of the possible labels. I am wondering how I would calculate the Bayesian expected loss for each possible label. And since it is a multi-label classification problem, I would also need to calculate the expected loss for all possible combinations of labels. Is this even a tractable problem?</p>
74,354
[ -0.035650551319122314, -0.023316679522395134, 0.003095172578468919, 0.014132100157439709, 0.0462355874478817, 0.03159245476126671, -0.00314067373983562, 0.006857664790004492, 0.01230934914201498, -0.004476921167224646, 0.05091781169176102, 0.013634230941534042, 0.05656875669956207, -0.00848995242267847, 0.006858286447823048, -0.004488786216825247, -0.03146020323038101, 0.002101549645885825, -0.011334918439388275, -0.02789502963423729, 0.008019584231078625, 0.03858603909611702, 0.0497056283056736, -0.04405781626701355, -0.02886175736784935, 0.020625382661819458, 0.045339323580265045, -0.03323645517230034, 0.013803206384181976, 0.041905589401721954, 0.01663106493651867, -0.033829525113105774, 0.051619336009025574, 0.043787967413663864, 0.020376475527882576, -0.012928233481943607, -0.03683717921376228, -0.023846426978707314, -0.06157875433564186, 0.005940657574683428, -0.03372045233845711, -0.028784915804862976, -0.002497632522135973, 0.037948399782180786, -0.014846346341073513, -0.02170301228761673, -0.027685394510626793, -0.003026974620297551, 0.016066906973719597, -0.034387677907943726, 0.07084985077381134, 0.024075090885162354, 0.06188764423131943, 0.03877868130803108, -0.019592665135860443, -0.0030572654213756323, 0.04373878240585327, 0.1068853810429573, 0.01661772094666958, -0.0466737374663353, -0.02105211839079857, -0.01696695014834404, 0.020728884264826775, -0.060356415808200836, -0.058593351393938065, 0.05370129272341728, -0.004065786488354206, 0.0000660300866002217, 0.029654886573553085, 0.03843153640627861, -0.016716985031962395, 0.02401350811123848, 0.04718596860766411, 0.009796970523893833, 0.03597235679626465, 0.011755075305700302, 0.031435105949640274, 0.06867582350969315, 0.03820990398526192, 0.025938449427485466, -0.02334672585129738, 0.022170044481754303, 0.01339657511562109, 0.06900565326213837, 0.0033178203739225864, -0.02536069042980671, 0.05814046040177345, -0.04946518316864967, 0.017416026443243027, 0.012761305086314678, -0.033367451280355453, -0.01785220578312874, 0.036339618265628815, -0.0035266298800706863, -0.07390447705984116, 0.039802923798561096, -0.004923841450363398, 0.045627739280462265, 0.012235279195010662, -0.0328511968255043, 0.009185782633721828, -0.019081903621554375, -0.011223018169403076, 0.05669109895825386, -0.03705862909555435, 0.0030732606537640095, -0.04193718731403351, -0.010895274579524994, -0.011763923801481724, -0.014255870133638382, 0.00048121047439053655, 0.05405678227543831, -0.01661570742726326, -0.009921961463987827, 0.003843174083158374, -0.016340581700205803, -0.031524013727903366, -0.038297101855278015, 0.027413230389356613, 0.04864644631743431, 0.016760006546974182, -0.03309112787246704, 0.03342652693390846, -0.013842979446053505, -0.049600694328546524, -0.0015912672970443964, -0.0035617833491414785, -0.04529815539717674, -0.027283502742648125, 0.035817574709653854, -0.04125414416193962, -0.011047396808862686, 0.0322282537817955, 0.0012550089741125703, -0.030288906767964363, -0.05040283873677254, -0.061883345246315, -0.04145653545856476, -0.0007235808297991753, -0.0420818105340004, -0.01888410933315754, -0.039853665977716446, 0.004695274401456118, 0.04647738113999367, -0.0016612575855106115, 0.01281051430851221, 0.046838752925395966, 0.04246971011161804, 0.018805397674441338, 0.008542853407561779, -0.011421028524637222, 0.02021954394876957, -0.058882053941488266, 0.025151638314127922, -0.022759664803743362, -0.08830049633979797, -0.01083312090486288, 0.007005416788160801, -0.0003436110564507544, 0.006064246874302626, 0.0023302522022277117, 0.009066496044397354, 0.001222116407006979, -0.02096901647746563, 0.004387213382869959, -0.027681859210133553, 0.04918757081031799, 0.020040156319737434, 0.039736922830343246, 0.04429882764816284, -0.002422645455226302, -0.02794392593204975, 0.006700566969811916, 0.046061281114816666, 0.07418468594551086, -0.04579612612724304, -0.02860092744231224, -0.005921782460063696, 0.0455254502594471, 0.0023728706873953342, -0.004177804104983807, -0.002643657848238945, -0.026804402470588684, -0.0006574588478542864, 0.002229892648756504, 0.005522969178855419, 0.027516156435012817, -0.026886362582445145, 0.025374174118041992, -0.037009160965681076, -0.04342653974890709, -0.062462691217660904, -0.005876939743757248, -0.03452359884977341, -0.006943933200091124, 0.02059130370616913, 0.010229035280644894, 0.0221620611846447, 0.014412036165595055, -0.052678946405649185, -0.046408284455537796, -0.0020304822828620672, -0.00401119003072381, -0.042566217482089996, 0.00403647730126977, 0.053067050874233246, 0.04794527217745781, -0.014638449996709824, 0.04884824529290199, -0.044093046337366104, -0.04429132863879204, -0.016439776867628098, -0.035643577575683594, 0.002436518669128418, 0.0017995162634178996, -0.014889134094119072, 0.030122162774205208, -0.00785225909203291, -0.011357482522726059, 0.0102812759578228, -0.02520083636045456, 0.05671762302517891, 0.07755787670612335, 0.01095646247267723, 0.006945113185793161, -0.010854560881853104, 0.0008484279969707131, 0.010507304221391678, -0.0286837387830019, -0.02393426187336445, -0.047923773527145386, -0.0018568088999018073, 0.02303370274603367, 0.024657275527715683, 0.008858051151037216, 0.016798406839370728, 0.04895538464188576, 0.01871594972908497, -0.010257779620587826, 0.0428035669028759, 0.00838286429643631, 0.017495356500148773, 0.030919458717107773, 0.06406521797180176, -0.013961968012154102, 0.008271968923509121, 0.02879370003938675, 0.023280808702111244, 0.04567166417837143, -0.02778170444071293, -0.011212863028049469, 0.03980844095349312, 0.0027044741436839104, -0.017370663583278656, -0.015556520782411098, -0.03333351016044617, 0.01667541265487671, -0.016411731019616127, 0.042260073125362396, 0.03436511382460594, 0.019036924466490746, -0.027897542342543602, 0.02714344672858715, -0.005636504385620356, 0.03761323541402817, 0.04635987430810928, -0.025290274992585182, -0.011351283639669418, 0.022405359894037247, -0.051681436598300934, 0.05188219994306564, 0.020598294213414192, 0.013829518109560013, 0.004641351755708456, 0.05077211931347847, 0.002800402697175741, -0.03002343140542507, -0.003055082866922021, -0.02949858270585537, -0.029471518471837044, 0.01382463239133358, -0.008343947120010853, 0.020822806283831596, -0.017412714660167694, -0.06560884416103363, 0.009132223203778267, -0.019291836768388748, -0.027110064402222633, 0.019505523145198822, -0.012912854552268982, -0.0634753629565239, -0.002747613936662674, -0.029909180477261543, -0.056482620537281036, -0.043397169560194016, -0.0333833321928978, 0.020067553967237473, -0.03256356716156006, 0.013304897584021091, 0.013177324086427689, 0.04047027975320816, -0.03234381601214409, 0.013076504692435265, -0.013448127545416355, -0.03600740432739258, 0.005275893956422806, -0.037610337138175964, -0.0007932452135719359, -0.026295173913240433, 0.023409372195601463, 0.03932628780603409, -0.024508511647582054, -0.005100684240460396, -0.05787032097578049, -0.05931468680500984, 0.037783168256282806, 0.006553899962455034, -0.0022623753175139427, 0.009876271709799767, -0.009661147370934486, 0.07901456952095032, 0.030449727550148964, -0.03502971678972244, 0.012650771997869015, 0.05575357750058174, -0.006898290012031794, -0.001611104467883706, -0.011087100021541119, 0.009603044018149376, -0.02910982444882393, 0.017015302553772926, 0.010716388933360577, -0.0043472652323544025, 0.03889143839478493, -0.0047718845307827, 0.03567352518439293, 0.019399330019950867, 0.027952129021286964, -0.0013810982927680016, -0.0012814532965421677, 0.05573991686105728, -0.005292006302624941, 0.0406426303088665, 0.00046807833132334054, 0.024614671245217323, -0.01382619608193636, -0.038693975657224655, 0.02017422951757908, -0.0006223348318599164, 0.020272087305784225, -0.03993016853928566, 0.02755613811314106, 0.032735325396060944, -0.005087328143417835, 0.0036186696961522102, 0.027104737237095833, 0.031035955995321274, -0.04054223373532295, 0.026435062289237976, 0.07452832162380219, 0.05188877508044243, 0.0047036437317729, -0.06539754569530487, -0.021537914872169495, 0.001359711168333888, -0.019361313432455063, -0.008861462585628033, -0.021531270816922188, -0.01625302992761135, 0.036094944924116135, 0.03822354972362518, 0.036910150200128555, -0.028756286948919296, 0.018682660534977913, -0.03370828926563263, -0.030332792550325394, -0.02096141129732132, 0.043313462287187576, 0.03880127891898155, 0.03751908615231514, -0.0027005167212337255, -0.0033932719379663467, -0.022505614906549454, 0.0211679358035326, -0.03842770680785179, 0.021302644163370132, 0.0016046451637521386, -0.012541969306766987, -0.013142582960426807, -0.03414004668593407, 0.07452592253684998, -0.04259990528225899, 0.008929741568863392, -0.027517545968294144, 0.027722014114260674, -0.030316421762108803, -0.008304386399686337, -0.01079574879258871, 0.02152060717344284, -0.0038483806420117617, 0.05778079852461815, -0.0018026651814579964, 0.0015562259359285235, 0.021645111963152885, 0.019450007006525993, -0.01951189897954464, -0.050204042345285416, -0.03621946647763252, 0.031749796122312546, -0.02871708944439888, 0.02777623012661934, 0.03338921442627907, 0.067169688642025, -0.027355996891856194, 0.02177741937339306, 0.006625641603022814, 0.05080973356962204, 0.052851442247629166, -0.03622381016612053, -0.012178180739283562, -0.05564426630735397, -0.0186021588742733, 0.013974277302622795, 0.04323289543390274, 0.009553528390824795, 0.029785461723804474, 0.042664989829063416, 0.014882152900099754, -0.09464223682880402, -0.00040783308213576674, 0.046987906098365784, -0.019649257883429527, -0.020126165822148323, -0.018922999501228333, 0.012245136313140392, -0.024259492754936218, 0.013261133804917336, -0.009869194589555264, 0.0007106764824129641, -0.03291388228535652, -0.01028289645910263, 0.013075397349894047, -0.049735989421606064, -0.027891939505934715, -0.008234462700784206, 0.005553248804062605, 0.02158437855541706, 0.051131002604961395, -0.027805877849459648, 0.021368810907006264, 0.04194255545735359, 0.029785634949803352, 0.013010622933506966, 0.014007698744535446, -0.06720917671918869, 0.027642158791422844, 0.02633020095527172, 0.024757781997323036, -0.003787592053413391, 0.022126542404294014, -0.02073374018073082, 0.00764754181727767, 0.02071140706539154, -0.035455260425806046, 0.0005100489361211658, 0.007224714383482933, 0.03622675687074661, 0.0006156078306958079, -0.035753391683101654, -0.02981661632657051, -0.005895014852285385, -0.0503261424601078, 0.037152860313653946, -0.020504163578152657, 0.023210808634757996, -0.01245843805372715, -0.01908566802740097, 0.004487411584705114, 0.0719398707151413, -0.013317324221134186, -0.018741549924016, 0.008289092220366001, 0.0028831246308982372, -0.022101810202002525, -0.05898413062095642, -0.002968118293210864, -0.018861141055822372, -0.0200065728276968, 0.050563015043735504, -0.062106430530548096, -0.056580960750579834, 0.027624063193798065, 0.007509449031203985, -0.020495079457759857, -0.001880278461612761, -0.013559297658503056, 0.031029969453811646, 0.04436661675572395, 0.0034492406994104385, 0.07808728516101837, -0.010024300776422024, 0.009573662653565407, 0.03268086165189743, -0.01382879726588726, 0.03271305933594704, -0.0518760085105896, 0.0037330910563468933, -0.050781842321157455, 0.02735416777431965, -0.005260124336928129, 0.058781031519174576, -0.015100612305104733, 0.028018133714795113, -0.02131771668791771, -0.01650227978825569, -0.031107373535633087, 0.005868604406714439, 0.00754180271178484, -0.011452785693109035, -0.023129750043153763, 0.04077841714024544, -0.012916344217956066, 0.01608528383076191, 0.010337816551327705, -0.009386722929775715, 0.03560306131839752, 0.011304904706776142, -0.01657390594482422, 0.04683583602309227, 0.011689458042383194, -0.029428139328956604, 0.005151841323822737, -0.04954177886247635, 0.02394324354827404, -0.011496786959469318, 0.003522923681885004, -0.026346441358327866, -0.004460236057639122, -0.033920127898454666, -0.00028272889903746545, -0.017544707283377647, 0.041571520268917084, -0.021274534985423088, 0.0037447696086019278, -0.01945296861231327, -0.03534245118498802, -0.05314984545111656, -0.03163335099816322, 0.02748309075832367, 0.0288400799036026, -0.026106998324394226, -0.0160196702927351, 0.024413838982582092, -0.016343863680958748, -0.019634097814559937, -0.03202952817082405, 0.020839592441916466, -0.014559279195964336, -0.016617141664028168, -0.010745798237621784, 0.006289985496550798, 0.045318618416786194, 0.03199414908885956, 0.02423400990664959, 0.015167013742029667, -0.009900623001158237, -0.012762647122144699, -0.007112179882824421, 0.0009125697542913258, -0.020687932148575783, -0.030817177146673203, -0.020182795822620392, 0.032820895314216614, 0.03632831946015358, -0.024425623938441277, 0.011069368571043015, -0.020827563479542732, 0.025888869538903236, -0.025422094389796257, -0.0353890024125576, -0.031791627407073975, -0.004060060251504183, 0.006109300535172224, -0.03828242048621178, 0.018504202365875244, 0.0034916196018457413, 0.015600222162902355, 0.032696183770895004, -0.021142588928341866, 0.015879863873124123, 0.006955916993319988, 0.07879086583852768, -0.003016429953277111, 0.017163416370749474, -0.004644365515559912, -0.01755114272236824, 0.04923221468925476, 0.015985865145921707, 0.0026301522739231586, 0.014687860384583473, -0.00771512882784009, -0.05689030885696411, 0.02747988887131214, -0.06980981677770615, 0.00431156437844038, 0.06253877282142639, -0.01648143120110035, 0.04016401618719101, 0.03548610210418701, 0.023238208144903183, -0.011513433419167995, -0.026099875569343567, -0.0008009385201148689, 0.02709953673183918, 0.02777063474059105, 0.047938600182533264, -0.007301712408661842, 0.001900641480460763, 0.01989537850022316, -0.021185385063290596, 0.03025810793042183, 0.03881964460015297, 0.004012155346572399, 0.007540664169937372, 0.006039411295205355, -0.02627740427851677, -0.01979513093829155, -0.01909724995493889, -0.010500297881662846, -0.00879401434212923, -0.013171895407140255, -0.05895925313234329, 0.034681085497140884, 0.03472718596458435, 0.0005098660476505756, -0.037409745156764984, -0.05112091451883316, -0.031944602727890015, 0.06287026405334473, 0.015951557084918022, 0.03281017765402794, -0.0006086419452913105, -0.009338661096990108, 0.024344708770513535, -0.0042452262714505196, 0.03878118842840195, -0.032010432332754135, -0.04490164667367935, -0.04935125634074211, -0.012787977233529091, -0.018048111349344254, -0.023068245500326157, 0.03126087039709091, -0.004305674694478512, 0.015352261252701283, 0.0028519509360194206, 0.03814331069588661, -0.031180590391159058, 0.03068886511027813, -0.02553056925535202, 0.055492665618658066, 0.0032432186417281628, 0.04691530764102936, 0.015537604689598083, -0.0036100554279983044, 0.10226049274206161, 0.07587499916553497, 0.06334812939167023, -0.055256448686122894, -0.013125492259860039, -0.007319208700209856, -0.03682433441281319, -0.06997562944889069, 0.055327847599983215, 0.026030831038951874, -0.010273197665810585, 0.014111433178186417, 0.06371227651834488, 0.003890987252816558, -0.01866551674902439, 0.05382583290338516, -0.02601577341556549, 0.006046866066753864, 0.004427993670105934, 0.026603136211633682, 0.020344000309705734, -0.0027506162878125906, -0.08268465846776962, 0.03355066478252411, 0.016839943826198578, -0.01619776524603367, -0.026950502768158913, -0.006384466774761677, -0.018831487745046616, 0.011603688821196556, 0.07340764999389648, -0.004047113005071878, 0.0036736091133207083, -0.010982215404510498, 0.021146930754184723, -0.010182320140302181, 0.028251683339476585, -0.03925924375653267, -0.009619535878300667, 0.020814020186662674, -0.011185282841324806, 0.0017115464434027672, -0.02500796504318714, -0.00961561780422926, -0.0218960028141737, -0.029445352032780647, -0.046218421310186386, 0.05916668474674225, -0.015325619839131832, -0.005064576864242554, -0.010866479948163033, -0.017441892996430397, -0.007390857208520174, -0.04989734664559364, 0.0232181828469038, 0.04102233052253723, 0.023170631378889084, -0.022407297044992447, -0.015643229708075523, -0.005129499360918999, 0.05293852835893631, -0.002175728091970086, -0.005166053771972656, 0.006526193115860224, -0.014444553293287754, -0.034727077931165695, -0.012209797278046608, 0.02514631859958172, 0.02397541143000126, -0.01673419214785099, 0.007571481633931398, -0.013425830751657486, 0.003169000381603837, -0.018712937831878662, -0.003736477578058839, -0.022593945264816284, 0.008502880111336708, 0.001963562797755003, -0.002993978327140212, -0.03587113320827484, -0.044998083263635635, 0.010144539177417755, -0.0597565658390522, -0.011001731269061565, -0.03940674662590027, -0.00882734451442957, 0.05773372948169708, 0.0492250919342041, -0.001884449739009142, 0.04173699766397476, -0.00988340936601162, 0.027871549129486084, 0.023965273052453995, -0.03432339057326317, 0.033834636211395264, -0.00777396047487855, -0.06864143908023834, 0.010917135514318943, -0.02434268593788147, 0.08044634759426117, 0.04017185792326927, 0.04178217053413391, 0.020865337923169136, 0.009152648039162159, 0.016923798248171806, 0.017274577170610428, -0.036510784178972244, -0.07010142505168915, 0.022530801594257355, -0.01074762362986803, 0.001249394379556179, -0.05004042014479637, -0.03022695519030094, -0.04759272187948227, -0.02024259604513645, 0.043597981333732605, -0.010376744903624058, -0.04366978257894516, -0.005129349417984486, 0.012181747704744339, 0.02558060921728611, -0.029459817335009575, 0.041699521243572235, 0.01804530993103981, 0.02242003194987774, -0.04018385708332062, -0.02884679101407528, -0.014213012531399727, 0.011012189090251923, -0.049344342201948166, -0.0008393243770115077, 0.04230679199099541, 0.022211743518710136, 0.007904239930212498, 0.004830654710531235, 0.03270268067717552, -0.019262155517935753, 0.026428384706377983, -0.025255801156163216, 0.00026986325974576175, 0.03226163983345032, -0.09347008168697357, -0.04569154605269432, 0.014403248205780983, 0.0036630863323807716, 0.059047434478998184, 0.027377746999263763, 0.006859585177153349, -0.040679678320884705, 0.01739479973912239, -0.04202847182750702, -0.02545125037431717, -0.0002812438760884106, 0.03483409062027931, 0.013207998126745224, 0.010693034157156944, 0.00702374754473567, 0.029779398813843727, 0.011330139823257923, 0.004631515126675367, 0.02026338130235672, 0.02548852376639843, -0.013971090316772461, 0.011370422318577766, -0.042173437774181366, 0.036582253873348236, 0.011916140094399452, 0.0036835367791354656, -0.007550827693194151, 0.03722059354186058, 0.004190176259726286, 0.023929869756102562, -0.001709710224531591, 0.0027349928859621286, -0.09680923074483871, -0.01264571025967598, 0.011130224913358688, 0.0025176063645631075, 0.037632957100868225, -0.04289430379867554, 0.03461617976427078, 0.013988164253532887, -0.02965512126684189, 0.010435123927891254, -0.004820007830858231, 0.010042552836239338, -0.0159445907920599, -0.005828961730003357, -0.029242591932415962, 0.013667991384863853, 0.019724680110812187, 0.03509823605418205, 0.026354385539889336, 0.009935472160577774, -0.020457735285162926, -0.03668368235230446, 0.0029483723919838667, 0.022445671260356903, -0.0007153204060159624, -0.06868203729391098, 0.04865124076604843, -0.02517932653427124, -0.04729694873094559, 0.008857480250298977, 0.031124964356422424, -0.005924023687839508, 0.018180062994360924, 0.036158669739961624, 0.01779978908598423, 0.050407472997903824, 0.009419609792530537, -0.006205153185874224, -0.022997532039880753, 0.028878197073936462, -0.022670796141028404, -0.01125432550907135, -0.013291792012751102, 0.010383209213614464, 0.03617706149816513, -0.01986522041261196, -0.06929631531238556, 0.023207474499940872, -0.011804958805441856, -0.028516922146081924, -0.032308485358953476, -0.01346003171056509, 0.0266550425440073, -0.0216075386852026, 0.010635207407176495, -0.0420212522149086, 0.03194976970553398, 0.06394695490598679, 0.022740837186574936, 0.0016524469247087836, -0.009538527578115463, -0.029285138472914696, -0.04046430066227913, 0.0022871128749102354, 0.0008113584481179714, -0.03546757251024246, -0.06801381707191467, 0.022804586216807365, 0.016026638448238373, -0.0384865403175354, -0.03065795637667179, -0.030839182436466217, -0.07606162875890732, 0.014895283617079258, -0.018434207886457443, 0.022898053750395775, 0.020485209301114082, -0.007102754432708025, 0.005216114688664675, -0.08705951273441315, 0.05102107301354408, -0.011475733481347561, -0.00771625991910696, -0.01547988224774599, 0.04216625541448593, -0.028510667383670807, -0.006576737854629755, 0.0657225251197815, -0.0017180554568767548, 0.005426154471933842, -0.002796329790726304, 0.012883219867944717, 0.022982634603977203, -0.07072456181049347, 0.030187338590621948, -0.027599206194281578, -0.017545286566019058, -0.047467052936553955, -0.025570569559931755, 0.04069722071290016, -0.00583296362310648, 0.005006022285670042, -0.05722049996256828, -0.01669961027801037, 0.0014092691708356142, 0.0008946295129135251, 0.002141211647540331, -0.040676817297935486, 0.01955813728272915, 0.011002084240317345, 0.010303252376616001, 0.01415161695331335, -0.011218346655368805, 0.016167692840099335, -0.05166419968008995, 0.029473736882209778, -0.006167199928313494, -0.027758946642279625, -0.0066384668461978436, 0.0028781425207853317, -0.029223337769508362, -0.0493105910718441, 0.013312087394297123, 0.017437223345041275, -0.05460420995950699, 0.007397332228720188, 0.04288904741406441, -0.005645288620144129, 0.04895904287695885, -0.013861708343029022, 0.015087030827999115, -0.01621839962899685, -0.030185775831341743, 0.037767089903354645, 0.015574096702039242, 0.02014034055173397, 0.0044098710641264915, 0.048381924629211426, 0.025039881467819214, -0.04582175239920616, 0.044149234890937805, 0.001651614555157721, 0.03343044966459274, -0.02012210339307785, 0.007077603600919247, 0.017503736540675163, 0.010141057893633842, -0.004528316203504801, -0.010083320550620556, -0.010313080623745918, 0.07376497983932495, -0.010950500145554543, 0.00438784109428525, -0.03948014974594116, -0.004055846016854048, -0.00749767292290926, 0.023515844717621803, -0.017519446089863777, 0.051095057278871536, 0.019937727600336075, 0.017045240849256516, -0.028743278235197067, 0.007828276604413986, 0.04952326416969299, -0.05774154141545296, 0.010788975283503532, -0.008331854827702045, -0.026186877861618996, 0.02375207468867302, -0.012718192301690578, -0.030453147366642952, -0.004753368906676769, -0.0008643184555694461, 0.019686566665768623, 0.03722333535552025, -0.011241945438086987, -0.023384157568216324, 0.023298518732190132, 0.0301518477499485, -0.047822847962379456, 0.017713047564029694, -0.0633435919880867, 0.02479442209005356, -0.007386405952274799, -0.007083073724061251 ]
<p>I have a time-series forecasting task and would like some input on variable selection and regularisation.</p> <p>My problem has the following characteristics:</p> <ul> <li>2,000,000 sample size.</li> <li>Most of the time, no change in the response. Change in the response happens 0.3% of the time and is what I'm interested in (don't talk about asymmetric loss functions and the like - I'm purely interested in variable selection/regularlisation).</li> <li>I will be predicting direction (up/down/no change). </li> <li>100 predictor variables. Mostly hand engineered from complex non-stationary data. All carry some predictive power - the useless ones with no univariate forecasting power were eliminated early in the process.</li> <li>There will be clusters of highly correlated predictors - in general if you select two predictors at random the correlation will not be high.</li> <li>Predictors are heteroscedastic in nature.</li> <li>Some predictors are heavily serially correlated, many are not. </li> <li>Predictors all evolve continuously and are decimal processes. They are all bell shaped. </li> <li>Some could be non-stationary, but are thought to carry critical information about the evolution of the response process that would be lost upon differencing or similar $I(0)$ transforms.</li> <li>My forecasting model will be linear, but least squares loss function is not certain (perpendicular regression and quantile regression and discrete response regression will be tried).</li> <li>Standard error unbiasedness and variance is not a direct consideration. All I care about is out of sample forecast accuracy and model generalisation. </li> </ul> <p>I know I can use anything from non-negative garotte, ridge, lasso, elastic nets, random subspace learning, PCA/manifold learning, least angle regression and various yucky hacks to select based on out of sample forecast performance. But is there anything specific to forecasting, or to the characteristics of my data, that would push me one way over another (time efficiency is important - trying everything and selecting the best is not practical). </p> <p>Note that decision boundaries on the forecasts are not intended to be part of the regularisation algorithm, but integration could be possible. </p> <p>I will also be using a supercomputer. </p>
74,355
[ -0.03309740871191025, -0.015166609548032284, 0.005234743934124708, -0.00698093231767416, 0.0504203625023365, -0.028388040140271187, -0.043753284960985184, -0.022760117426514626, 0.030666567385196686, -0.043998152017593384, 0.024119632318615913, 0.03030373714864254, 0.032429955899715424, 0.012240713462233543, -0.023570483550429344, 0.008334179408848286, -0.014754864387214184, -0.00021631672279909253, -0.005605774000287056, -0.0038664343301206827, 0.026998989284038544, 0.022774994373321533, -0.0019972671288996935, 0.04746461287140846, -0.03050139918923378, 0.06476324796676636, 0.016408752650022507, -0.013656139373779297, -0.0021444500889629126, 0.050436485558748245, -0.04128936678171158, -0.0295425858348608, -0.021918799728155136, 0.0764448344707489, 0.014547993429005146, 0.009055380709469318, -0.00027315583429299295, -0.03333248570561409, 0.008627726696431637, 0.036629773676395416, -0.03547005355358124, -0.02042848989367485, 0.007101883180439472, 0.0426020473241806, -0.001980111002922058, 0.03868509456515312, -0.012919951230287552, -0.003536815755069256, 0.028587505221366882, -0.05171719938516617, 0.07238834351301193, -0.005615897011011839, 0.00479978509247303, 0.025061922147870064, -0.04336081072688103, -0.010676463134586811, 0.062117401510477066, 0.07548332959413528, -0.00047272437950596213, -0.0663231685757637, 0.018333565443754196, 0.028311438858509064, 0.008015481755137444, -0.03230896219611168, -0.02816762402653694, 0.01217599306255579, 0.010519771836698055, 0.009589116089046001, 0.010541057214140892, -0.021157056093215942, 0.026465119794011116, -0.0252936203032732, 0.0018335821805521846, 0.023307623341679573, -0.009894621558487415, -0.005887733772397041, -0.01564777083694935, 0.026202945038676262, 0.04034123197197914, 0.025948580354452133, 0.01590622402727604, -0.008273901417851448, 0.011407332494854927, 0.00936058722436428, 0.02945096045732498, 0.014724516309797764, 0.07440104335546494, -0.02685984969139099, 0.018785271793603897, 0.03416841849684715, -0.02553688921034336, -0.016332656145095825, 0.05276412144303322, 0.002035838784649968, -0.03527809679508209, 0.008347444236278534, -0.00040431105298921466, 0.011758789420127869, -0.006149415858089924, 0.00678784865885973, -0.023349056020379066, -0.028988180682063103, -0.035301581025123596, 0.05703672394156456, -0.017382675781846046, 0.017873769626021385, -0.024100100621581078, -0.017295818775892258, -0.042742908000946045, -0.041527003049850464, -0.014765913598239422, 0.005612588487565517, -0.011061722412705421, -0.018849235028028488, -0.019245872274041176, -0.02714645303785801, -0.011980918236076832, -0.04172080010175705, 0.021096300333738327, 0.08358240127563477, 0.005357816349714994, -0.03242608532309532, -0.009646175429224968, -0.026193035766482353, -0.03651170805096626, -0.007699690293520689, 0.04664439335465431, 0.014523521065711975, -0.03440144658088684, 0.05222427472472191, 0.03070318140089512, -0.02686355449259281, 0.04475316032767296, 0.00833533238619566, 0.02905914932489395, -0.015940167009830475, -0.11756862699985504, -0.03350374475121498, 0.03880656883120537, -0.05321405455470085, 0.011335432529449463, -0.03371642902493477, -0.01545540802180767, 0.028950855135917664, 0.04852820560336113, 0.019621936604380608, 0.04211828112602234, 0.047091249376535416, 0.031398236751556396, 0.0015074334805831313, -0.024065490812063217, 0.01730031706392765, -0.0317378044128418, -0.01769418455660343, -0.019087674096226692, -0.03049103543162346, 0.0006357274833135307, 0.03948669508099556, -0.003202075371518731, 0.036765340715646744, -0.006035548634827137, -0.005897556431591511, -0.012907112017273903, 0.0011424788972362876, 0.000020080738977412693, -0.042640797793865204, 0.06042269989848137, 0.013816703110933304, 0.021156229078769684, 0.02231224626302719, -0.01494971290230751, 0.010851457715034485, 0.031138194724917412, 0.04878533259034157, 0.03803982958197594, -0.0007961848750710487, 0.013131925836205482, -0.021701529622077942, -0.013923263177275658, 0.01670626364648342, -0.04921332374215126, -0.028674457222223282, -0.025861572474241257, -0.011471584439277649, 0.01336595043540001, 0.05142886936664581, 0.013785215094685555, -0.022375840693712234, 0.03470534458756447, -0.0604700930416584, -0.043426189571619034, 0.0011832386953756213, -0.0015914738178253174, -0.013294223695993423, 0.006611053366214037, 0.052732598036527634, -0.01147006917744875, 0.01950901933014393, -0.028072059154510498, -0.04146406427025795, -0.011458891443908215, 0.022874407470226288, 0.029667740687727928, -0.035989079624414444, 0.013830266892910004, 0.032113462686538696, 0.007408786099404097, -0.01635347306728363, 0.02477003075182438, -0.04670174419879913, -0.05380205065011978, 0.011535259895026684, -0.02869359403848648, 0.02931470423936844, -0.06085369735956192, -0.017027821391820908, 0.0465020127594471, -0.020382236689329147, -0.013854613527655602, 0.009342639707028866, -0.05646076425909996, 0.061476659029722214, 0.050814732909202576, -0.007151969242841005, 0.010310934856534004, 0.04184233024716377, 0.009762851521372795, 0.026024140417575836, -0.0654674619436264, 0.004568086471408606, -0.065766341984272, -0.019616220146417618, 0.053702324628829956, 0.06471683084964752, -0.03622075170278549, 0.037552572786808014, 0.03887796029448509, 0.026005931198596954, -0.00011310043191770092, 0.013105359859764576, -0.028443792834877968, -0.018555283546447754, 0.00949167925864458, -0.03761572390794754, 0.011183813214302063, -0.021208111196756363, 0.008249212056398392, -0.010431136004626751, 0.03828834742307663, -0.013671507127583027, -0.00893283262848854, 0.06200156733393669, 0.004752827808260918, -0.028521237894892693, -0.020376674830913544, -0.023105571046471596, 0.01091869454830885, -0.017446817830204964, 0.0016246725572273135, 0.025080008432269096, 0.020974786952137947, 0.014849239960312843, 0.016296718269586563, -0.010435004718601704, 0.017644759267568588, 0.04026312008500099, -0.02179746888577938, 0.01240168884396553, 0.03032110445201397, -0.05262022092938423, 0.012732562609016895, 0.02237067185342312, -0.011027655564248562, -0.039216119796037674, -0.011398444883525372, 0.043696001172065735, 0.019424162805080414, -0.0020001332741230726, 0.010460712015628815, -0.030893979594111443, 0.035834476351737976, -0.0012721269158646464, 0.04511236399412155, 0.030863843858242035, -0.036712490022182465, 0.011473545804619789, -0.03929132595658302, -0.011317269876599312, 0.05277172848582268, -0.018216926604509354, -0.019980182871222496, 0.029541773721575737, -0.0259474478662014, -0.09087523818016052, -0.06226455792784691, -0.07637828588485718, 0.04885046184062958, -0.020744485780596733, -0.022288823500275612, 0.05755402520298958, 0.007681170012801886, -0.05011367425322533, 0.0017987347673624754, -0.036388229578733444, -0.006506224628537893, -0.032294102013111115, 0.0074121723882853985, -0.0265518706291914, -0.03319669887423515, 0.019321545958518982, 0.022689785808324814, -0.01496131345629692, 0.02731715887784958, -0.047966986894607544, -0.03465022146701813, -0.00743643194437027, -0.016506684944033623, 0.04711822792887688, 0.008779365569353104, -0.009364926256239414, 0.0432155504822731, 0.029239095747470856, -0.018621740862727165, -0.03101639449596405, -0.007379386108368635, -0.0458793044090271, -0.060136791318655014, 0.04019942879676819, -0.014392377808690071, -0.007466401904821396, 0.027975842356681824, -0.024960782378911972, 0.027402544394135475, 0.040552012622356415, 0.014962921850383282, -0.008658896200358868, 0.04262464493513107, -0.023791862651705742, 0.03610788658261299, 0.028740186244249344, 0.02953583560883999, -0.01279547717422247, -0.0031225455459207296, 0.0009968017693609, -0.01244048960506916, 0.022655704990029335, -0.06780283153057098, 0.011368467472493649, -0.006202736869454384, 0.03263178467750549, -0.017833851277828217, -0.0031520340126007795, -0.011176078580319881, -0.05097033828496933, -0.034238941967487335, -0.0043505034409463406, 0.025544511154294014, 0.010631361976265907, 0.03933018445968628, 0.041834477335214615, 0.03907362371683121, 0.015945710241794586, 0.00922693032771349, -0.010709976777434349, -0.006823027040809393, 0.03300341218709946, -0.019082998856902122, -0.00736693199723959, 0.03423449769616127, 0.02767779305577278, -0.01180844847112894, 0.011831416748464108, -0.02357291243970394, 0.01308466587215662, -0.05856102332472801, 0.01256253570318222, -0.0307015348225832, 0.08845946192741394, 0.027003949508070946, -0.00321754883043468, 0.018993640318512917, -0.002050975803285837, 0.0065661221742630005, 0.013913762755692005, -0.0492694191634655, 0.06272207200527191, 0.00834862794727087, 0.0216544009745121, 0.014936202205717564, 0.00951561238616705, 0.03871092200279236, -0.039262961596250534, 0.02002151869237423, -0.012809380888938904, 0.0579996332526207, -0.053845927119255066, 0.014472936280071735, -0.00941684190183878, -0.03781237453222275, -0.04102916643023491, 0.003092376049607992, 0.025303777307271957, -0.028922852128744125, 0.05162207409739494, 0.03458398953080177, 0.016195401549339294, -0.03669676557183266, -0.0018790796166285872, 0.0005604408215731382, 0.005505240056663752, 0.05224321410059929, 0.02090776525437832, 0.0020250952802598476, -0.07538726925849915, 0.02924048900604248, 0.023437319323420525, 0.047323454171419144, 0.0037886386271566153, 0.020797882229089737, -0.020479952916502953, -0.043310437351465225, -0.037101536989212036, 0.034430131316185, 0.005697291344404221, 0.03207356482744217, -0.04102295637130737, 0.0676293671131134, -0.009286964312195778, -0.01770251803100109, -0.011777251958847046, 0.009423569776117802, 0.021371163427829742, 0.021534550935029984, 0.023534812033176422, -0.01567503623664379, 0.02288341335952282, 0.010565454140305519, 0.027533913031220436, -0.017982833087444305, 0.022388949990272522, -0.02417619712650776, 0.026261869817972183, -0.003032238455489278, -0.012206315994262695, -0.004218305926769972, 0.0538390688598156, 0.07293709367513657, 0.005538688972592354, -0.022408172488212585, 0.013073248788714409, 0.03544702008366585, 0.036283623427152634, 0.0446622259914875, 0.03914227336645126, -0.10351511090993881, -0.023781074211001396, 0.039718832820653915, 0.05734873190522194, -0.02801179513335228, -0.029081925749778748, -0.04680866748094559, -0.033810149878263474, 0.02429273910820484, -0.033571500331163406, 0.020310774445533752, 0.01089012622833252, 0.010137461125850677, -0.011288552545011044, -0.04497206583619118, -0.04856501519680023, -0.005567333661019802, -0.04013692960143089, 0.03654637560248375, -0.021365497261285782, -0.03648439049720764, -0.036977652460336685, -0.0013676678063347936, -0.031761448830366135, 0.05012788996100426, 0.007072288077324629, -0.013263684697449207, 0.0012459226418286562, 0.02919727750122547, 0.03201524168252945, -0.07349526137113571, 0.012577800080180168, 0.03913496807217598, -0.030917130410671234, 0.05506221204996109, -0.004411546513438225, -0.05754672363400459, 0.019827743992209435, 0.009123909287154675, -0.01515083946287632, 0.017300885170698166, -0.028928695246577263, 0.041034996509552, -0.002728530205786228, 0.0010672113858163357, 0.05075007677078247, 0.051238764077425, 0.003004775382578373, 0.022402897477149963, -0.04406740516424179, 0.0038707430940121412, -0.024270327761769295, -0.008601758629083633, -0.050062794238328934, -0.02627871185541153, -0.028430549427866936, 0.014085468836128712, 0.005811017006635666, 0.036889150738716125, -0.03681381791830063, -0.014279328286647797, 0.0007157580694183707, 0.0507173053920269, -0.022071272134780884, -0.0310805756598711, 0.003708126023411751, 0.0022536907345056534, -0.041729748249053955, 0.009100955910980701, -0.004880571737885475, 0.0063912454061210155, 0.01743578352034092, 0.02221105806529522, -0.037753138691186905, -0.031277719885110855, -0.021711524575948715, 0.023938922211527824, 0.0027069111820310354, 0.007835069671273232, 0.053754184395074844, 0.030675005167722702, 0.046840451657772064, 0.01431462075561285, -0.02448543719947338, 0.007960278540849686, 0.013861688785254955, 0.00737052783370018, 0.03531106188893318, -0.0197167806327343, -0.007741916924715042, -0.06259635090827942, -0.013629736378788948, -0.03960490971803665, -0.003863421268761158, 0.018092364072799683, 0.013970849104225636, -0.03928773105144501, -0.022713713347911835, 0.02851371094584465, -0.045385122299194336, -0.011020736768841743, 0.0031965081579983234, 0.01952737383544445, -0.02190016582608223, 0.022199172526597977, 0.021556222811341286, 0.04495593160390854, 0.04583284631371498, -0.030135346576571465, -0.0003101608599536121, 0.019233638420701027, -0.0057625859044492245, -0.014734802767634392, -0.022419169545173645, -0.01004125364124775, -0.04369175806641579, -0.0035896210465580225, -0.02990909293293953, -0.022049738094210625, 0.0335274413228035, -0.018552344292402267, -0.002559900050982833, 0.028914228081703186, -0.0007719850982539356, -0.009440872818231583, -0.016456544399261475, 0.016364578157663345, -0.03514773026108742, -0.008677160367369652, -0.023787466809153557, -0.0022919971961528063, -0.007502228952944279, -0.03291142359375954, 0.006210152991116047, -0.014201351441442966, -0.020136239007115364, 0.038851577788591385, 0.009310267865657806, 0.01920381933450699, 0.010519345290958881, -0.0019006265792995691, -0.039851874113082886, 0.04703830927610397, 0.010916655883193016, 0.041205890476703644, 0.00931263342499733, -0.008367778733372688, -0.05784895271062851, -0.08647297322750092, -0.031325582414865494, -0.026455754414200783, 0.051037099212408066, 0.00946848001331091, 0.03788664937019348, 0.04083262383937836, 0.000467165868030861, -0.011038758791983128, -0.06610902398824692, 0.0023184004239737988, -0.0011009984882548451, -0.00822511874139309, 0.039071425795555115, 0.023613341152668, 0.012169617228209972, 0.04554610326886177, -0.01940646581351757, 0.03006804548203945, 0.030844127759337425, -0.004810618702322245, 0.039613015949726105, 0.025505468249320984, -0.06804799288511276, -0.047030311077833176, -0.016557449474930763, -0.05699542909860611, 0.008796592243015766, -0.011125857941806316, 0.00689814193174243, 0.02584676444530487, 0.08170375227928162, 0.028523705899715424, -0.03784157335758209, 0.005528788547962904, -0.0656953901052475, -0.009183171205222607, 0.034599464386701584, -0.059278953820466995, 0.004758195951581001, 0.06703504174947739, 0.027614042162895203, -0.002204983029514551, 0.029668401926755905, -0.01994820311665535, -0.06503019481897354, -0.02987014502286911, -0.00329312845133245, -0.01622982881963253, 0.05278511717915535, 0.005382330622524023, -0.004982946906238794, 0.007147510536015034, -0.01836860179901123, 0.018387405201792717, -0.004276868887245655, 0.03524265065789223, -0.014250785112380981, 0.05416252464056015, -0.005469304975122213, -0.01935672201216221, -0.017179276794195175, -0.011539009399712086, 0.14651210606098175, 0.07607637345790863, 0.01241503655910492, -0.05344735458493233, -0.012183139100670815, -0.005622211843729019, 0.00591689720749855, -0.006555742118507624, -0.011005963198840618, 0.019503913819789886, -0.013389529660344124, 0.05036479979753494, 0.011206871829926968, -0.028535014018416405, -0.01963081583380699, 0.05691315233707428, -0.02567237801849842, 0.011266689747571945, -0.034130796790122986, 0.022533785551786423, 0.056790050119161606, 0.03484439104795456, -0.04067608341574669, 0.05503051355481148, -0.03486054018139839, -0.0089674461632967, -0.025484535843133926, -0.019524773582816124, 0.014471650123596191, -0.023742137476801872, -0.011139251291751862, 0.0012108910595998168, 0.008321966975927353, 0.024640103802084923, -0.002900340361520648, 0.042218953371047974, 0.009362741373479366, -0.03425794839859009, 0.0141008161008358, 0.02900833450257778, -0.005090481601655483, -0.016011599451303482, 0.011074105277657509, -0.017789684236049652, -0.03774179518222809, -0.0320228673517704, -0.06893563270568848, 0.03832150995731354, -0.007765769958496094, -0.0268501378595829, 0.010017335414886475, 0.012235431931912899, 0.0496281236410141, -0.0133162597194314, -0.015021526254713535, 0.01997963897883892, 0.03895406797528267, -0.04289467632770538, -0.01895359344780445, 0.01770961657166481, 0.0016520475037395954, 0.01230086013674736, 0.0470554381608963, 0.02116851508617401, -0.0533188134431839, -0.028737593442201614, -0.017267856746912003, 0.039255786687135696, 0.030282940715551376, 0.02244224026799202, 0.010825136676430702, 0.00642964756116271, -0.0257369764149189, 0.011675382032990456, 0.03795348107814789, 0.0022720941342413425, 0.05731125548481941, -0.026813015341758728, 0.007287099026143551, -0.03500144183635712, -0.0525481179356575, 0.01892184466123581, -0.024019666016101837, 0.007184406742453575, -0.03341764956712723, 0.009359774179756641, 0.005181333515793085, 0.040444985032081604, 0.040644679218530655, -0.015476240776479244, -0.006149351596832275, 0.029977548867464066, 0.03272998332977295, -0.0525156669318676, -0.029330063611268997, -0.0024718029890209436, -0.03133873641490936, 0.004223253577947617, 0.011717518791556358, 0.07059463113546371, 0.043749406933784485, -0.008071709424257278, -0.02507362887263298, 0.05881766229867935, -0.0138026038184762, -0.011046696454286575, 0.018933333456516266, -0.05449213832616806, 0.011775008402764797, -0.011108196340501308, 0.013694521971046925, -0.027521951124072075, -0.020473062992095947, 0.00452353386208415, -0.016627170145511627, -0.005669547710567713, -0.011916290037333965, -0.0061341943219304085, 0.029446503147482872, -0.004840622190386057, 0.0601235069334507, -0.03876454010605812, -0.01441680546849966, -0.02062392607331276, 0.004585220478475094, -0.00834662839770317, -0.0240703746676445, -0.010055606253445148, 0.008275022730231285, -0.022211596369743347, -0.01711796410381794, 0.040412623435258865, 0.02315455861389637, 0.013996143825352192, -0.026876170188188553, 0.007405831478536129, -0.040178775787353516, 0.007411685306578875, -0.017549289390444756, -0.03159859776496887, 0.025486037135124207, -0.012899578548967838, -0.052768271416425705, 0.02833659015595913, 0.006752053275704384, 0.038992106914520264, 0.01787688583135605, 0.006246828008443117, -0.05058082565665245, 0.04349253326654434, -0.0020896049682050943, 0.013222151435911655, -0.020378325134515762, 0.05381734296679497, 0.010937056504189968, -0.034485504031181335, 0.04249256104230881, 0.002942128572613001, -0.0035904336255043745, 0.002854307182133198, 0.02320919930934906, 0.012627121061086655, -0.002526390366256237, 0.023444296792149544, -0.030810825526714325, 0.006516911555081606, 0.03110351413488388, -0.006070439703762531, 0.01268045511096716, 0.052543867379426956, -0.03427779674530029, 0.0216254573315382, 0.02133784256875515, -0.01767122931778431, -0.11325690895318985, -0.01006791926920414, 0.018007751554250717, 0.0065970527939498425, 0.040829386562108994, -0.04728960990905762, -0.00763300247490406, 0.028612326830625534, -0.05755500867962837, 0.01869058795273304, -0.00042619032319635153, 0.01103186048567295, 0.006729013752192259, -0.009098317474126816, -0.04516155272722244, 0.015981266275048256, 0.037319447845220566, 0.05030744895339012, 0.03192510828375816, 0.035173218697309494, 0.011896859854459763, -0.0031662278342992067, -0.00028215651400387287, 0.012253559194505215, -0.00770246097818017, -0.03326493874192238, 0.011588537134230137, -0.04151737689971924, -0.0281402338296175, 0.01298544928431511, 0.015232744626700878, 0.023813357576727867, -0.011859118938446045, 0.0016275894595310092, 0.016892151907086372, 0.04297624155879021, 0.026582535356283188, -0.04426580294966698, 0.04114586487412453, -0.015545325353741646, 0.004555919673293829, 0.014750320464372635, -0.01806090772151947, 0.04423592984676361, -0.004973003640770912, -0.020724734291434288, -0.02332433871924877, -0.002203695708885789, -0.030132867395877838, -0.029239263385534286, 0.026054447516798973, 0.011736253276467323, -0.03101518377661705, 0.015009686350822449, -0.0072529311291873455, -0.023482026532292366, -0.036457743495702744, 0.01902088150382042, 0.029345549643039703, -0.037576399743556976, 0.027041247114539146, -0.04289965331554413, -0.038777656853199005, 0.028676526620984077, -0.02337442897260189, 0.0252158772200346, -0.06012754887342453, -0.0005129084456712008, 0.0179892685264349, -0.023468900471925735, -0.0578402541577816, -0.0019273122306913137, -0.06868881732225418, 0.02356433868408203, -0.004542824812233448, 0.015967581421136856, 0.02297135815024376, -0.018571285530924797, 0.021846028044819832, -0.09835615009069443, 0.046960584819316864, -0.008433821611106396, -0.019849425181746483, -0.014851990155875683, -0.0561104379594326, -0.03143737092614174, 0.0228481013327837, 0.0612248033285141, -0.019145729020237923, 0.01271168515086174, 0.014875018037855625, 0.019550232216715813, 0.007869252003729343, -0.025462212041020393, 0.056414104998111725, -0.016201836988329887, 0.0007064883247949183, -0.020114334300160408, -0.033469703048467636, 0.03094918094575405, 0.02712281234562397, 0.059103965759277344, -0.03330065310001373, 0.013000973500311375, 0.03357943147420883, -0.01627182401716709, 0.04601062461733818, -0.006420896388590336, 0.003930838778614998, 0.026169298216700554, 0.0011768582044169307, 0.00881102029234171, -0.019296392798423767, -0.03168288245797157, -0.05848761647939682, -0.008509780280292034, -0.01563500240445137, -0.035682570189237595, -0.030764520168304443, 0.014835241250693798, 0.02785428613424301, -0.005676587577909231, -0.005091295577585697, 0.021538637578487396, -0.013695171102881432, 0.02237299457192421, 0.03339267894625664, -0.0024989917874336243, 0.013636380434036255, 0.00013044053048361093, 0.01780398003757, 0.010521995835006237, 0.007786975242197514, 0.005858294665813446, 0.005392884369939566, 0.041355956345796585, 0.007729921955615282, 0.01479154359549284, 0.012233538553118706, -0.029351789504289627, 0.04729021340608597, -0.03203324228525162, 0.028591228649020195, -0.08120547235012054, -0.010681061074137688, 0.022980747744441032, -0.021668849512934685, -0.00048107796465046704, 0.01642991229891777, -0.003920725546777248, 0.06366676092147827, -0.029802145436406136, -0.03826524317264557, -0.034564059227705, 0.01149323582649231, -0.005857616662979126, 0.015768006443977356, -0.025475436821579933, 0.023746175691485405, 0.006281385198235512, 0.037024516612291336, -0.0024893805384635925, -0.00832045916467905, 0.02489253506064415, -0.03390076011419296, 0.020418819040060043, 0.04359539970755577, -0.019734321162104607, 0.0036739022471010685, -0.04223969206213951, -0.018688911572098732, -0.04194299876689911, 0.004090913571417332, 0.04035972058773041, -0.00583026884123683, -0.03530071675777435, 0.004874540958553553, -0.020239785313606262, 0.025060459971427917, -0.05232677608728409, -0.0006045189220458269, -0.0330607071518898, 0.013872809708118439, 0.0038667500484734774, 0.0017798112239688635 ]
<p>I work in a problem where:</p> <ul> <li>The input data is a collection of time series from different sensor modalities, where each sensor comes with different acquisition rates and dynamic ranges</li> <li>The number of potential features vastly exceeds the number of instances (i.e. $p \gg N$)</li> </ul> <p>My question is: <strong>Has deep learning been applied on this type of data before?</strong> </p>
74,356
[ 0.024560535326600075, -0.03132912144064903, 0.0031183231621980667, 0.010342291556298733, 0.046555694192647934, 0.023321550339460373, -0.006097331177443266, -0.023808535188436508, 0.01518403459340334, -0.024652916938066483, 0.02772042714059353, 0.020563166588544846, 0.023549221456050873, 0.018212441354990005, 0.01653192564845085, -0.006880324333906174, -0.030541982501745224, 0.01684659533202648, 0.005662914831191301, -0.03767776116728783, -0.001904214732348919, 0.03994768112897873, 0.03741845488548279, -0.017029497772455215, -0.007311874069273472, 0.035553302615880966, -0.028975121676921844, -0.036288291215896606, -0.018775995820760727, 0.042815253138542175, -0.030740857124328613, 0.0008603261085227132, -0.013403749093413353, 0.05694703757762909, 0.03034711256623268, 0.017195921391248703, -0.03645137697458267, -0.04965217411518097, 0.01295236125588417, 0.03565386310219765, -0.027350645512342453, -0.050981562584638596, 0.012044902890920639, 0.042849667370319366, -0.011820586398243904, 0.04115957021713257, -0.0150367496535182, -0.02537834644317627, -0.030844131484627724, -0.05544504523277283, 0.09787605702877045, -0.005712020676583052, 0.0657360851764679, 0.019148845225572586, -0.03794753924012184, -0.001783881220035255, 0.06300191581249237, 0.05831822380423546, -0.0018473557429388165, -0.05145834758877754, -0.015555907040834427, -0.013576071709394455, -0.007111868355423212, -0.03508384898304939, -0.01891268417239189, 0.01309734582901001, 0.00927775353193283, -0.007897552102804184, 0.0008597814594395459, -0.018697354942560196, 0.0019398372387513518, 0.014942929148674011, 0.05787568539381027, 0.02223021909594536, 0.004912026692181826, 0.004984825849533081, 0.007947039790451527, 0.017788859084248543, 0.04851141571998596, 0.0008388188434764743, 0.006752330344170332, -0.008842851966619492, -0.0041242241859436035, 0.01500544510781765, 0.025840772315859795, -0.017995448783040047, 0.06787995994091034, -0.04289025068283081, -0.0094586918130517, -0.012071593664586544, -0.0034041223116219044, 0.018711676821112633, 0.01797942817211151, -0.005151533987373114, -0.03170051425695419, 0.01927645318210125, 0.017633091658353806, 0.015620042569935322, 0.013568196445703506, -0.034112926572561264, 0.04347134754061699, -0.03154587000608444, 0.006665367167443037, 0.07787644863128662, -0.015362410806119442, 0.00948355533182621, -0.016975609585642815, 0.00849743839353323, -0.003606565296649933, 0.03389304503798485, -0.0642596185207367, 0.004216373432427645, 0.015788085758686066, -0.006244388408958912, 0.007727375254034996, -0.01736655831336975, -0.035270433872938156, -0.01834528148174286, 0.049101293087005615, 0.1047401949763298, 0.016269294545054436, -0.04030689597129822, 0.04086248204112053, -0.06227010861039162, -0.051736269146203995, 0.015706917271018028, 0.004087591078132391, -0.009392432868480682, -0.03525656461715698, 0.04654328525066376, -0.025010971352458, -0.01621798612177372, 0.025446856394410133, -0.018009191378951073, 0.012298818677663803, -0.00855943188071251, -0.07626265287399292, -0.04655078053474426, 0.06787819415330887, -0.027499012649059296, 0.018838752061128616, -0.039035845547914505, 0.02995310351252556, 0.048767510801553726, 0.04688038304448128, 0.014774915762245655, 0.031665410846471786, 0.04728778824210167, 0.009511486627161503, -0.018009187653660774, -0.023455236107110977, 0.001961846835911274, 0.0007199177634902298, 0.019455300644040108, 0.0038154085632413626, -0.08218177407979965, 0.04690932109951973, 0.036508627235889435, 0.010674107819795609, 0.007878836244344711, 0.01846427284181118, 0.0019969050772488117, -0.0013720204588025808, 0.03783728554844856, 0.011021244339644909, -0.019092943519353867, 0.03342882916331291, 0.02311180718243122, 0.05295731872320175, 0.0307156965136528, 0.016102701425552368, 0.025184599682688713, 0.03730357438325882, 0.023089708760380745, 0.03808426856994629, 0.006339350715279579, -0.02996267005801201, 0.021852295845746994, 0.014008303172886372, 0.025735313072800636, 0.012077405117452145, -0.030802106484770775, -0.022460995241999626, 0.008630159310996532, 0.010843168944120407, 0.042314041405916214, -0.009681777097284794, -0.021041039377450943, 0.029697146266698837, -0.03494955226778984, -0.0024476787075400352, -0.03203510120511055, 0.022155286744236946, -0.04057534039020538, 0.0009067092323675752, 0.024475140497088432, -0.003681376576423645, 0.044757179915905, -0.018729839473962784, -0.044715557247400284, -0.0186321921646595, -0.01847642846405506, 0.02813759818673134, -0.05586865171790123, -0.04430801421403885, 0.04338774085044861, -0.028364131227135658, -0.00029015884501859546, 0.0496169812977314, -0.013601242564618587, -0.02969229966402054, -0.0056578232906758785, -0.024310115724802017, 0.004774954169988632, -0.0014550479827448726, -0.009218537248671055, 0.026926856487989426, -0.016424313187599182, -0.03704194352030754, 0.03301072120666504, -0.0556613989174366, 0.03764749690890312, 0.053099703043699265, -0.01612347923219204, 0.03342679888010025, 0.01275237649679184, 0.02015506662428379, -0.021962152794003487, 0.0022297983523458242, -0.030311960726976395, -0.08653626590967178, -0.013636897318065166, 0.03246409818530083, 0.08507582545280457, -0.03195381164550781, 0.014296812936663628, 0.04968270659446716, 0.061252761632204056, 0.015931615605950356, 0.005020339973270893, -0.0016711505595594645, -0.0313224233686924, 0.01648625358939171, 0.020393792539834976, 0.015317071229219437, -0.02450992539525032, 0.02767232432961464, 0.02700781635940075, 0.04589559882879257, 0.011228998191654682, -0.010584757663309574, 0.037701480090618134, -0.01342987921088934, 0.03529321029782295, -0.004390842746943235, 0.009699413552880287, 0.014534086920320988, -0.036500927060842514, 0.020414147526025772, 0.010833114385604858, 0.021351110190153122, -0.004332829266786575, -0.003750183619558811, -0.0371486097574234, 0.009149179793894291, 0.035212721675634384, -0.011933713220059872, -0.01588616892695427, 0.043017253279685974, -0.055942244827747345, 0.04746053367853165, -0.028147654607892036, -0.011923895217478275, -0.02094530314207077, 0.021319318562746048, 0.05787886679172516, -0.011282753199338913, 0.008993573486804962, -0.021371623501181602, 0.0012391643831506371, 0.035189367830753326, -0.011394692584872246, 0.02645760029554367, 0.03107072412967682, -0.05613478645682335, 0.023969659581780434, 0.011914643459022045, -0.006663079839199781, 0.01368342898786068, -0.002507146680727601, -0.00042593866237439215, 0.03909721598029137, -0.05030544474720955, -0.06046817824244499, 0.00227621803060174, -0.056668251752853394, 0.048561498522758484, -0.03480922058224678, -0.014399707317352295, 0.041609831154346466, 0.00776642607524991, -0.030375681817531586, -0.016758447512984276, -0.015920160338282585, -0.009144257754087448, -0.05590754747390747, -0.014543814584612846, -0.012337126769125462, -0.02460492216050625, -0.001816397998481989, 0.049445122480392456, -0.013272333890199661, 0.025918317958712578, -0.053684525191783905, -0.05372602865099907, 0.017257461324334145, -0.027302738279104233, 0.03914825618267059, 0.01785741001367569, 0.022959288209676743, 0.06458929926156998, 0.05923057347536087, -0.0358620285987854, -0.014713050797581673, -0.022882839664816856, -0.011867234483361244, -0.06903774291276932, 0.042780984193086624, 0.010379977524280548, -0.008867835626006126, -0.006194303743541241, -0.0010546903358772397, 0.0208393894135952, 0.07019072026014328, -0.0011239981977269053, -0.012572412379086018, 0.038546450436115265, -0.003499682992696762, 0.031205248087644577, 0.018955616280436516, 0.04019938036799431, -0.037512365728616714, 0.032623451203107834, -0.0076847923919558525, -0.004571135621517897, 0.009791048243641853, -0.01735803484916687, 0.01983911171555519, -0.014276613481342793, -0.0012228094274178147, -0.05148186907172203, 0.010108674876391888, -0.022869616746902466, -0.015382294543087482, -0.05071375519037247, 0.06506086885929108, 0.04392491281032562, -0.00927386898547411, -0.02080475352704525, 0.0346817784011364, 0.015144775621592999, -0.0024150670506060123, -0.0008709690300747752, 0.032694995403289795, -0.020482005551457405, 0.013438170775771141, 0.01204559113830328, 0.011187699623405933, 0.011363225989043713, 0.022487329319119453, 0.03047100268304348, 0.03548048436641693, -0.030965067446231842, 0.021197255700826645, -0.055847879499197006, 0.000555887701921165, -0.009752866812050343, 0.057844776660203934, 0.0067238821648061275, 0.02825489081442356, 0.03081141598522663, -0.004421169403940439, 0.0175178162753582, -0.021828563883900642, -0.06112980097532272, 0.005320789758116007, -0.008757554925978184, -0.012453297153115273, -0.015357712283730507, -0.04977617412805557, 0.044611796736717224, -0.0280980933457613, 0.026874404400587082, -0.017444919794797897, 0.024437813088297844, -0.03321509808301926, -0.007735697086900473, -0.02016892097890377, -0.00483503844588995, -0.02943306788802147, 0.023884963244199753, 0.04681302234530449, 0.025966327637434006, 0.02346385456621647, 0.015531154349446297, 0.00406362721696496, -0.017440224066376686, -0.011372591368854046, 0.0032372428104281425, -0.03573380410671234, 0.03656977415084839, -0.01407718937844038, 0.033331841230392456, -0.03731725737452507, 0.025684474036097527, -0.024768000468611717, 0.03473595529794693, 0.04038126766681671, -0.0026002905797213316, -0.024764029309153557, -0.03960654139518738, -0.01498554740101099, 0.040356315672397614, 0.045771628618240356, 0.024143194779753685, -0.005472726188600063, 0.016203859820961952, 0.009269739501178265, -0.06965859234333038, -0.0025938120670616627, 0.02513190358877182, -0.007459977176040411, -0.01780516654253006, -0.04910000413656235, -0.016085248440504074, 0.013947596773505211, 0.032752517610788345, 0.05031082406640053, -0.0033381511457264423, -0.023611003533005714, 0.016720712184906006, 0.04395422339439392, 0.014181582257151604, -0.05268487706780434, 0.0023225178010761738, 0.060935791581869125, 0.03755919635295868, 0.01822606846690178, -0.006657655816525221, 0.010448993183672428, 0.06204989179968834, 0.05712723359465599, 0.0022030819673091173, -0.012945269234478474, -0.1248607337474823, 0.016051284968852997, 0.05557310953736305, -0.0027776635251939297, 0.01422458328306675, -0.00993464607745409, -0.034842923283576965, 0.024407455697655678, 0.03932933136820793, 0.008730137720704079, 0.029587309807538986, -0.003874788759276271, -0.03504842892289162, -0.01021361444145441, -0.0478467233479023, 0.002275897189974785, 0.011743391864001751, -0.02119906060397625, 0.04047428444027901, 0.0026213442906737328, -0.02476939745247364, -0.022944333031773567, 0.0025193877518177032, 0.012750660069286823, 0.04200799763202667, -0.0002928833127953112, -0.001999456901103258, -0.034713052213191986, 0.02591346763074398, 0.008037429302930832, -0.04273083060979843, 0.048971403390169144, 0.006586340721696615, 0.013586217537522316, 0.0026855512987822294, -0.00986900832504034, -0.04713497310876846, 0.03943421691656113, -0.00954783521592617, 0.015244190581142902, -0.02977052889764309, -0.02985510230064392, 0.012218989431858063, 0.05818547308444977, 0.01768650859594345, 0.05427629500627518, 0.021076222881674767, 0.025474263355135918, 0.023360686376690865, 0.0112082464620471, 0.047267310321331024, -0.055836498737335205, -0.032756783068180084, 0.004400140605866909, -0.009145120158791542, -0.019448917359113693, 0.055326320230960846, 0.025236763060092926, 0.06143178045749664, 0.0015946278581395745, -0.00994719285517931, -0.01014260109513998, 0.03663980960845947, 0.0276578851044178, -0.03776698186993599, -0.035360608249902725, 0.027046864852309227, 0.0073735686019063, 0.004247631411999464, 0.006829499267041683, -0.024046076461672783, -0.008923749439418316, 0.04309837520122528, -0.023168938234448433, -0.016032926738262177, -0.04652858152985573, -0.01693214848637581, 0.015389148145914078, -0.015194689854979515, 0.06154228374361992, -0.004929284565150738, -0.0022188429720699787, 0.02185775712132454, -0.05043131113052368, -0.008520386181771755, -0.007224350702017546, -0.03713492304086685, 0.029580235481262207, -0.06914684921503067, 0.024165011942386627, -0.04511316493153572, 0.01601295918226242, -0.0694575384259224, -0.02523224614560604, 0.06097092851996422, 0.023106683045625687, -0.02164396084845066, -0.05317523330450058, 0.02373679354786873, -0.0041461000218987465, -0.013706009835004807, -0.009940003976225853, 0.038794562220573425, -0.012309913523495197, -0.0178415197879076, 0.0012258831411600113, 0.007845005951821804, 0.07011186331510544, -0.016978994011878967, 0.019436275586485863, 0.031880415976047516, -0.01264209020882845, -0.010143495164811611, -0.056384675204753876, 0.015086980536580086, -0.05592550337314606, -0.00674561457708478, -0.05446918308734894, 0.0009765964932739735, 0.03279166668653488, -0.05653166025876999, 0.0018714559264481068, 0.03188838064670563, -0.011251281946897507, -0.006545579060912132, -0.039024852216243744, 0.012254343368113041, -0.006860042456537485, -0.05056397244334221, -0.03183884546160698, 0.009596450254321098, 0.012175105512142181, -0.03402581810951233, 0.023430803790688515, 0.014191728085279465, -0.0011151686776429415, 0.0029980859253555536, 0.03237513452768326, -0.03212741017341614, -0.019511859863996506, -0.01770826242864132, -0.03512992337346077, 0.06793864071369171, 0.0012864553136751056, 0.012735217809677124, -0.016386784613132477, 0.019531674683094025, -0.055409256368875504, -0.028633059933781624, -0.027344999834895134, -0.00233280286192894, 0.07493463158607483, 0.01837320439517498, 0.05139985308051109, 0.023421043530106544, -0.004369495436549187, 0.021153677254915237, -0.02797681838274002, -0.02074151299893856, 0.024219898506999016, 0.0097579350695014, 0.02830975130200386, 0.031798139214515686, -0.0010718452977016568, 0.02579289674758911, -0.028323853388428688, 0.03992917016148567, 0.05233343690633774, -0.028198668733239174, -0.0001238208933500573, 0.0023686811327934265, -0.03732520341873169, -0.06529402732849121, 0.0008785444661043584, -0.036893442273139954, 0.004413258749991655, -0.021732917055487633, -0.029765622690320015, 0.05794753506779671, 0.03451094031333923, -0.0027821101248264313, -0.03904644399881363, -0.020567284896969795, -0.042616598308086395, 0.0019271946512162685, 0.047874610871076584, -0.01717420294880867, 0.04320184141397476, -0.005397804547101259, 0.0009791949996724725, -0.01155018713325262, -0.0021805160213261843, 0.01914595626294613, -0.059180084615945816, -0.02498364821076393, -0.025866113603115082, -0.029514599591493607, 0.0492495633661747, -0.01427263393998146, -0.02907768450677395, 0.013280469924211502, -0.016470156610012054, 0.01237244252115488, 0.008660485036671162, 0.03013208694756031, -0.014749924652278423, 0.08289628475904465, 0.017112890258431435, 0.05598964914679527, -0.012137440964579582, 0.015410246327519417, 0.101390041410923, 0.08454904705286026, 0.03628547862172127, -0.03567426651716232, -0.003069232916459441, 0.014483161270618439, -0.012829912826418877, -0.025972524657845497, 0.01497088186442852, 0.03531872481107712, -0.020082779228687286, -0.035062599927186966, 0.027387896552681923, 0.038295939564704895, -0.024292411282658577, 0.05942492559552193, -0.029249832034111023, 0.0295060146600008, 0.023189261555671692, 0.00018153482233174145, -0.008466667495667934, 0.0011749380500987172, -0.05385773628950119, 0.01354136597365141, -0.027894597500562668, -0.03537869453430176, 0.008135630749166012, -0.027657965198159218, 0.01877588964998722, 0.017539987340569496, -0.005805795080959797, -0.013865800574421883, 0.0016218816163018346, -0.009050371125340462, -0.0020763936918228865, 0.008518458344042301, -0.01985699124634266, -0.0026034347247332335, -0.011926328763365746, 0.024603599682450294, 0.03216796740889549, -0.03368156775832176, -0.005097539629787207, -0.0037922700867056847, -0.038740843534469604, -0.032705049961805344, -0.0628325566649437, 0.03175259009003639, -0.00406217435374856, 0.019036339595913887, 0.03601134195923805, 0.014974096789956093, -0.009843911044299603, -0.03218887746334076, -0.03671744465827942, 0.02648542821407318, 0.044445883482694626, -0.015327122993767262, -0.031031832098960876, -0.020724739879369736, -0.001442904700525105, 0.010233079083263874, 0.022726664319634438, 0.023345690220594406, -0.003389133606106043, 0.02096840925514698, -0.028789177536964417, 0.02758767642080784, -0.02379598468542099, 0.03629479184746742, -0.008536754176020622, -0.0002947617613244802, -0.006593485362827778, -0.04898513853549957, 0.04628569632768631, -0.01421239785850048, -0.01706363819539547, 0.011140023358166218, -0.03891906514763832, -0.03866160660982132, -0.04696490243077278, 0.005104124546051025, -0.01713419519364834, 0.015056649222970009, -0.04793180525302887, -0.007045844104140997, 0.03906550258398056, 0.039247751235961914, 0.022680286318063736, -0.0025477914605289698, -0.003954119049012661, 0.023809561505913734, 0.03458784520626068, -0.035098493099212646, -0.020744450390338898, -0.03358769044280052, -0.057897601276636124, 0.03147628903388977, -0.010990545153617859, 0.057826779782772064, 0.004231220111250877, 0.01769343391060829, 0.01135578565299511, 0.03494556248188019, -0.04313254728913307, 0.010628419928252697, -0.0058861724101006985, -0.040676191449165344, 0.0017926666187122464, -0.031144505366683006, 0.0278795063495636, -0.039056070148944855, -0.05510162562131882, -0.029221970587968826, 0.00034317540121264756, 0.0030286433175206184, 0.02129443548619747, -0.045630648732185364, 0.0005574779934249818, -0.0008899629465304315, 0.01765301451086998, -0.018272001296281815, 0.020287051796913147, -0.06671535223722458, -0.020567532628774643, -0.022300250828266144, -0.04769667610526085, -0.013007808476686478, 0.024712231010198593, -0.013776744715869427, -0.01884552091360092, -0.0027876943349838257, 0.02642962336540222, 0.0006362289423123002, -0.03224942460656166, 0.02795197069644928, -0.05118346959352493, 0.006656332407146692, -0.02055295743048191, -0.02741912566125393, 0.04114805534482002, -0.036887913942337036, -0.00952861923724413, 0.05134298652410507, 0.009083045646548271, 0.06161839887499809, 0.021638063713908195, 0.029432030394673347, -0.0032934003975242376, 0.04805366322398186, 0.0019197454676032066, -0.007252959068864584, 0.020984552800655365, 0.027683021500706673, -0.007459612563252449, 0.012046757154166698, 0.04820558801293373, 0.020969001576304436, -0.00616725068539381, -0.014094095677137375, 0.04285072907805443, 0.037681616842746735, -0.038468535989522934, 0.0026258600410073996, -0.022647801786661148, 0.05164807289838791, 0.02013673633337021, 0.02566664107143879, 0.02551821991801262, -0.0053679486736655235, -0.017597584053874016, -0.0008071226184256375, 0.007444772403687239, -0.007634314242750406, -0.09373855590820312, -0.01301264762878418, 0.03556611016392708, -0.0038580496329814196, 0.04281678423285484, -0.0695386752486229, 0.012362188659608364, 0.010222661308944225, -0.05611167103052139, 0.019998662173748016, 0.0009722091490402818, 0.0013361377641558647, -0.02129422314465046, 0.03152254596352577, -0.015263205394148827, 0.0067949360236525536, 0.0373539924621582, 0.016150956973433495, 0.027391746640205383, 0.036187659949064255, 0.0007591446628794074, -0.03857937082648277, -0.020479189231991768, 0.01376296766102314, 0.009996048174798489, -0.03425910696387291, 0.01598641462624073, -0.0852975994348526, -0.026378396898508072, 0.01052203681319952, -0.01821671798825264, 0.0013359850272536278, 0.01228516735136509, 0.017635002732276917, 0.01934853382408619, 0.04326663166284561, 0.01710990071296692, -0.017957568168640137, 0.0003762917476706207, 0.004112411290407181, 0.0025598034262657166, -0.005765231791883707, -0.017858318984508514, -0.006523771211504936, -0.016842683777213097, -0.024035286158323288, -0.05499203875660896, -0.026012662798166275, 0.010478354059159756, -0.011580758728086948, 0.022231679409742355, -0.0006809040787629783, -0.009305553510785103, -0.037749435752630234, 0.03031449392437935, -0.03138916939496994, 0.02487441897392273, 0.009798785671591759, 0.017635323107242584, -0.04640394449234009, 0.002418074756860733, -0.021660663187503815, -0.049406491219997406, 0.006148482207208872, 0.0019680256955325603, 0.0005032356129959226, -0.07105423510074615, 0.01667245849967003, 0.03385806456208229, -0.0007326214690692723, -0.04186386987566948, 0.002772324485704303, -0.059555534273386, 0.026478717103600502, -0.019831031560897827, 0.04345081374049187, 0.050109874457120895, -0.04295077547430992, -0.006887699011713266, -0.11574123054742813, 0.047739896923303604, -0.019440600648522377, -0.013462036848068237, -0.017460264265537262, -0.020609797909855843, -0.04122820496559143, -0.002212311839684844, 0.03232433646917343, -0.020824121311306953, 0.011046324856579304, 0.008051243610680103, 0.011232360266149044, -0.0010849410900846124, -0.03140419349074364, 0.011156927794218063, -0.027962764725089073, -0.03311122953891754, 0.014076444320380688, -0.03045915998518467, -0.010497317649424076, -0.040001753717660904, 0.004473110195249319, 0.007744388189166784, 0.006564682349562645, 0.036750540137290955, 0.015433240681886673, 0.04842926561832428, -0.013846775516867638, 0.02995031513273716, 0.026485133916139603, -0.012222187593579292, 0.014968686737120152, -0.000620933948084712, 0.014984410256147385, -0.08435480296611786, -0.00987804215401411, -0.0572412833571434, -0.03681446239352226, -0.022661738097667694, 0.02517642453312874, 0.023446831852197647, -0.051105860620737076, -0.028565429151058197, 0.0032719969749450684, -0.028053248301148415, 0.0005524443695321679, 0.027463261038064957, -0.010123010724782944, 0.04566285386681557, -0.016020186245441437, 0.01426976453512907, -0.01785329356789589, 0.012316626496613026, -0.012920650653541088, 0.005736771039664745, 0.047965727746486664, -0.06671641021966934, 0.01885828748345375, 0.017852919176220894, -0.020097825676202774, 0.011775542050600052, -0.002349901245906949, 0.03303983807563782, -0.01731760986149311, -0.001334305270574987, 0.019396569579839706, 0.003083303337916732, 0.001828297390602529, 0.02382051758468151, 0.006522428244352341, 0.09881670773029327, -0.02521170862019062, -0.004758129827678204, -0.03239551931619644, -0.014800427481532097, 0.010957276448607445, 0.026307759806513786, -0.011709469370543957, 0.041515957564115524, -0.014498434960842133, 0.04824984073638916, -0.0030171077232807875, 0.0012302862014621496, 0.00009762516856426373, -0.07340940833091736, 0.014624166302382946, -0.011591831222176552, -0.015665367245674133, 0.020792290568351746, -0.02258334867656231, -0.004486083053052425, -0.041407402604818344, -0.008591298945248127, 0.008616302162408829, 0.04368302598595619, -0.0037799424026161432, -0.024030694738030434, -0.036795858293771744, 0.018427425995469093, -0.05770007520914078, 0.019611487165093422, -0.04764885827898979, 0.038229648023843765, -0.0080436235293746, -0.035796284675598145 ]
<p>Suppose a data set contains the numbers $1-100$ (i.e. $\{1, \dots, 100 \}$). In $10$-fold cross validation, the data set is divided into $10$ subsets with one used as the validation data set. For example, one such division is $S_1 = \{1, \dots, 10 \}$, $S_2 = \{11, \dots, 20 \}, \dots, S_{10} = \{91, \dots, 100 \}$. </p> <p>In "regular" 10-fold cross validation, each subset is used as the test data set. In 10-repeated 10-fold cross validation (for example), the part that is repeated is how $S_1, \dots, S_{10}$ are constructed?</p>
74,357
[ -0.021445361897349358, 0.007181238848716021, -0.00891811028122902, -0.011260963045060635, 0.024501830339431763, 0.020749639719724655, 0.015283685177564621, -0.012744681909680367, 0.061683036386966705, -0.03328407555818558, 0.06436151266098022, 0.009071067906916142, 0.04989921301603317, -0.010737216100096703, 0.01204000972211361, 0.004979033023118973, -0.037113893777132034, 0.01708543673157692, 0.007297310512512922, 0.015254870988428593, 0.02633047290146351, 0.0021206254605203867, 0.0007408765959553421, -0.01695462502539158, -0.026511287316679955, 0.027575787156820297, 0.01800837367773056, -0.025545665994286537, 0.035878803580999374, 0.029965300112962723, -0.020230473950505257, -0.03860438987612724, -0.014217826537787914, 0.07518568634986877, -0.00630393298342824, -0.03196576237678528, -0.00685470923781395, -0.028821229934692383, -0.014988364651799202, 0.014010578393936157, -0.04965275153517723, -0.01827375218272209, -0.022571684792637825, 0.0217608455568552, 0.012333495542407036, 0.018149247393012047, -0.01592875085771084, -0.04197574779391289, 0.015106148086488247, -0.04341870918869972, 0.06432141363620758, 0.007261638529598713, 0.03735838085412979, 0.014237641356885433, -0.03594844043254852, -0.010732704773545265, 0.059854909777641296, 0.045118797570466995, -0.045051079243421555, -0.08367029577493668, -0.015031260438263416, -0.04367413744330406, 0.007263644132763147, 0.014275120571255684, -0.05770156532526016, 0.029719842597842216, 0.0005419193767011166, -0.009832737036049366, -0.005819497164338827, -0.03535938262939453, 0.0020558570977300406, 0.040100883692502975, 0.03408019617199898, -0.040923282504081726, -0.02459772117435932, 0.0008783037192188203, 0.020553916692733765, 0.0318276509642601, 0.053735848516225815, 0.03659955784678459, 0.02597714774310589, 0.0017345118103548884, 0.0071165552362799644, 0.02326974645256996, 0.02780677191913128, -0.018413109704852104, 0.07507545500993729, -0.0037252854090183973, 0.018963303416967392, 0.014780043624341488, 0.021943224593997, 0.012693270109593868, 0.02796250954270363, 0.0047450559213757515, -0.03752906620502472, 0.051097869873046875, -0.015214069746434689, 0.0136313671246171, -0.006344015244394541, -0.012850185856223106, 0.020586391910910606, -0.055355921387672424, 0.022049957886338234, 0.05675423517823219, -0.031692493706941605, 0.012591737322509289, -0.0186449121683836, -0.0013917189789935946, -0.01852390356361866, 0.00923969503492117, 0.00272557744756341, 0.0404595285654068, 0.030933303758502007, 0.017737315967679024, 0.040606822818517685, 0.020784471184015274, 0.005121972877532244, -0.020740142092108727, 0.0032519190572202206, 0.04502493515610695, 0.041136663407087326, -0.024982763454318047, 0.04730641841888428, -0.006630782037973404, -0.048220615833997726, 0.025301141664385796, 0.009056191891431808, -0.0033151288516819477, -0.02445792220532894, 0.05468416586518288, -0.011324076913297176, -0.021639293059706688, 0.03305814042687416, 0.013561934232711792, 0.020092392340302467, 0.013584290631115437, -0.07876087725162506, -0.05323959141969681, 0.03147149085998535, -0.006762331817299128, 0.025710230693221092, -0.06012547388672829, 0.023033544421195984, 0.022281751036643982, 0.041401393711566925, 0.009971664287149906, 0.024479106068611145, 0.025597063824534416, 0.05103561282157898, 0.021672448143363, 0.033272046595811844, -0.03568746894598007, 0.003474744502454996, 0.013042590580880642, -0.033679764717817307, -0.07593495398759842, 0.03273313492536545, 0.020520038902759552, -0.01740833930671215, -0.014343181625008583, -0.019816864281892776, -0.012026514858007431, -0.012167971581220627, 0.0010308932978659868, 0.02550429292023182, -0.004510459490120411, 0.03491879627108574, 0.030870357528328896, 0.029893822968006134, 0.056259676814079285, -0.026593323796987534, -0.009785967878997326, 0.049257148057222366, 0.06859029084444046, 0.02599361538887024, -0.01204876508563757, 0.013421298004686832, -0.028530316427350044, 0.02814469300210476, 0.03898070752620697, -0.012084650807082653, 0.0018488497007638216, 0.0004072348529007286, 0.000039695005398243666, 0.013708824291825294, 0.038409676402807236, 0.0019050195114687085, -0.0066830748692154884, 0.030801109969615936, -0.050514429807662964, -0.05799239128828049, -0.08381933718919754, 0.02579694241285324, -0.026581259444355965, -0.02856731042265892, 0.023808056488633156, 0.003950778394937515, -0.0008398848585784435, 0.00916223879903555, -0.034354325383901596, -0.016363775357604027, 0.014303016476333141, 0.0362059660255909, -0.04350870102643967, -0.011935455724596977, 0.04210261255502701, 0.016448063775897026, -0.0173165462911129, 0.08220143616199493, -0.02758963778614998, -0.053697943687438965, 0.002151873428374529, -0.04139619693160057, 0.013146327808499336, -0.017648911103606224, -0.042702797800302505, 0.018808744847774506, -0.010929545387625694, -0.0249888114631176, 0.0821094959974289, -0.06572971493005753, 0.03578444570302963, 0.10826865583658218, 0.023185431957244873, 0.018710646778345108, -0.024573184549808502, 0.009389260783791542, 0.031712692230939865, -0.009846819564700127, -0.05615033954381943, -0.061321746557950974, -0.031899429857730865, 0.045373816043138504, 0.0036010441835969687, -0.03140967711806297, 0.0005812724120914936, 0.0610356368124485, 0.025563262403011322, 0.004186292178928852, 0.02911021187901497, -0.004374064039438963, -0.01268940232694149, 0.004112413618713617, 0.030279163271188736, 0.011380876414477825, 0.0042142379097640514, 0.0047957198694348335, 0.0045635392889380455, 0.037604447454214096, 0.05132519453763962, 0.008912350051105022, 0.04672989994287491, -0.021731089800596237, -0.021804915741086006, 0.005753849633038044, -0.00900909211486578, 0.05379905551671982, -0.039543893188238144, 0.0025499435141682625, 0.00042542844312265515, 0.002542931819334626, -0.010636581107974052, -0.006574783008545637, 0.009491825476288795, 0.00831160880625248, 0.018241388723254204, -0.02915387786924839, 0.010715359821915627, 0.014854474924504757, -0.06373457610607147, -0.017444489523768425, -0.04019555449485779, -0.00876691285520792, -0.04007822275161743, -0.0013450374826788902, 0.057015370577573776, 0.0033731008879840374, 0.022030092775821686, -0.04029523953795433, -0.028145112097263336, -0.004213425796478987, -0.03505967557430267, 0.027346111834049225, -0.02294810861349106, -0.027620289474725723, -0.013244451954960823, -0.0263789352029562, 0.006623645778745413, 0.031449608504772186, -0.016688885167241096, -0.008502684533596039, -0.0019112180452793837, 0.0044150142930448055, -0.012455408461391926, -0.030075926333665848, -0.058188386261463165, 0.02197910286486149, -0.03095528855919838, -0.022152071818709373, 0.03874048963189125, 0.031119484454393387, -0.047714099287986755, 0.03955437242984772, -0.0043624029494822025, -0.012829572893679142, -0.03472130745649338, -0.024872735142707825, 0.021951112896203995, -0.03658674284815788, 0.008294484578073025, 0.03657277673482895, 0.006009054370224476, 0.0041554952040314674, -0.05427863076329231, -0.08272220194339752, -0.015774130821228027, -0.003486859379336238, 0.02672111801803112, 0.04713568836450577, -0.034756846725940704, 0.06712193787097931, 0.02942279540002346, -0.024062691256403923, -0.0393449068069458, 0.04877733066678047, -0.011844293214380741, -0.03215593844652176, 0.010162473656237125, 0.005926833022385836, 0.016594350337982178, 0.008738884702324867, 0.035542476922273636, 0.028311431407928467, 0.0785168781876564, -0.014044399373233318, -0.03269997239112854, 0.011048533953726292, 0.011455285362899303, 0.000704256643075496, 0.00013327952183317393, -0.033523786813020706, -0.026463374495506287, -0.004129655193537474, 0.0005259109893813729, 0.018037376925349236, 0.03921995684504509, -0.03596291318535805, 0.033084142953157425, -0.014189181849360466, 0.009025161154568195, -0.026356955990195274, 0.043917395174503326, -0.0038109885063022375, -0.035808712244033813, -0.009070896543562412, 0.04884971305727959, 0.03423668071627617, -0.04694189876317978, -0.008680718019604683, 0.023975366726517677, 0.02408749796450138, -0.039702028036117554, -0.01345089916139841, -0.018510203808546066, -0.017636319622397423, 0.04732435941696167, -0.012177628464996815, -0.029208742082118988, 0.03927602618932724, 0.05896877497434616, 0.022922001779079437, -0.008066344074904919, -0.03377808257937431, 0.029682839289307594, -0.0959569439291954, -0.043416254222393036, -0.027832545340061188, 0.053784728050231934, -0.0046822004951536655, 0.05733427032828331, 0.024389952421188354, -0.038354963064193726, 0.005060916300863028, 0.027145080268383026, -0.06494072079658508, 0.0162646621465683, 0.00772168580442667, -0.0041995965875685215, 0.004478251561522484, -0.01731925457715988, 0.02659010887145996, 0.006283349357545376, 0.006272170692682266, 0.006254881154745817, 0.02286568097770214, -0.04655003547668457, 0.007701973896473646, -0.044788461178541183, -0.0024206696543842554, -0.02839805744588375, 0.032107871025800705, 0.03909559175372124, -0.02285282127559185, 0.007089690770953894, 0.003632465610280633, 0.01813356578350067, 0.01647173799574375, -0.030023887753486633, 0.014553970657289028, 0.03499184921383858, 0.04618719220161438, 0.016116222366690636, 0.038308270275592804, -0.0416843481361866, 0.017943501472473145, -0.019489603117108345, 0.04777831584215164, 0.05920378863811493, 0.022370100021362305, -0.057921238243579865, -0.0526968352496624, -0.004213583189994097, 0.0026933522894978523, 0.012655392289161682, 0.0064813438802957535, -0.004144550766795874, 0.06272587180137634, 0.03847723826766014, -0.0666293352842331, 0.023325609043240547, 0.03860529884696007, 0.026906557381153107, -0.016621321439743042, -0.046671006828546524, -0.002278556115925312, -0.012507692910730839, -0.023069527000188828, 0.03606414049863815, 0.0025477500166743994, 0.0052095153369009495, 0.031130362302064896, 0.04039142653346062, -0.04237177222967148, -0.048758022487163544, 0.016997242346405983, 0.012981805019080639, 0.04433968663215637, -0.0202676672488451, -0.03271310776472092, -0.012550655752420425, 0.054647382348775864, 0.06989345699548721, 0.012995951808989048, -0.018140681087970734, -0.07734988629817963, 0.03091677837073803, 0.02759643644094467, 0.043180305510759354, -0.04083617776632309, 0.01145401131361723, -0.03923019394278526, 0.008935096673667431, 0.019717371091246605, -0.047593262046575546, -0.003826752072200179, -0.03277947008609772, -0.014560847543179989, -0.03506502881646156, -0.004173815716058016, -0.018254438415169716, 0.029221609234809875, -0.01622661203145981, 0.029205646365880966, -0.016894357278943062, -0.021711166948080063, -0.0408836230635643, 0.009632769972085953, 0.004466972779482603, 0.07002229988574982, -0.037382546812295914, -0.006898604799062014, -0.023582138121128082, 0.013851840980350971, -0.000036225119401933625, -0.05258477106690407, -0.007928083650767803, 0.009982607327401638, -0.005819419864565134, 0.048869527876377106, 0.001320845214650035, -0.045318037271499634, 0.02000320330262184, 0.016808848828077316, -0.0023366534151136875, 0.01234922930598259, 0.007427399046719074, 0.04977564513683319, 0.05338997393846512, 0.0058208308182656765, 0.053657907992601395, -0.014075953513383865, 0.005560027901083231, -0.0176222063601017, 0.005773303098976612, 0.026655592024326324, -0.03952806070446968, -0.011770191602408886, -0.048866577446460724, 0.006720679812133312, -0.03072352148592472, 0.032830629497766495, -0.025904210284352303, 0.02473645843565464, -0.02810010127723217, -0.04654233902692795, 0.004681664053350687, 0.03357449173927307, -0.0025260879192501307, -0.009237740188837051, 0.0075399503111839294, 0.04810601472854614, 0.004279076587408781, 0.0028518165927380323, -0.004036641214042902, -0.024036284536123276, 0.01813463680446148, -0.020711204037070274, -0.01847049407660961, 0.03539084643125534, -0.06551944464445114, -0.0077448743395507336, 0.04619167745113373, -0.02723689004778862, 0.051553405821323395, -0.021825838834047318, 0.002511183265596628, -0.019211411476135254, -0.049918606877326965, 0.006655672565102577, 0.011905894614756107, 0.01370878517627716, 0.029419321566820145, -0.022576484829187393, 0.026297224685549736, 0.00479202251881361, -0.01708025112748146, -0.09493464231491089, -0.05058521032333374, 0.046918243169784546, 0.03130095452070236, -0.019453180953860283, 0.005824926774948835, -0.004768611863255501, -0.01641327701508999, -0.025297118350863457, -0.023483654484152794, 0.03883266821503639, -0.03143085911870003, -0.023219922557473183, 0.009379795752465725, 0.015894129872322083, 0.043677378445863724, -0.018457086756825447, 0.043442606925964355, -0.02922803722321987, -0.014357062056660652, -0.007286193314939737, 0.009660182520747185, -0.006528167054057121, -0.022244442254304886, 0.013661284931004047, -0.05360064283013344, -0.003482238622382283, 0.01952754519879818, -0.03180085867643356, -0.027892116457223892, -0.005174892023205757, -0.02199014648795128, 0.030922040343284607, -0.002559023443609476, -0.0030729922000318766, -0.015735773369669914, 0.024418240413069725, -0.023015083745121956, -0.0012075194390490651, -0.005810021888464689, -0.011404648423194885, 0.041328903287649155, 0.019262870773673058, -0.027754105627536774, 0.03411722555756569, 0.09169155359268188, -0.04533927142620087, 0.0068885828368365765, -0.0008925936999730766, -0.028247587382793427, 0.06031303480267525, 0.009997722692787647, 0.012641950510442257, 0.026325328275561333, 0.007344632875174284, -0.04655368626117706, 0.005131760146468878, -0.025196732953190804, 0.007110385224223137, 0.04577769711613655, -0.02502327226102352, 0.03773649409413338, 0.05206765979528427, -0.010666461661458015, 0.027208970859646797, -0.06217903271317482, 0.005446801893413067, -0.005593329668045044, 0.029621750116348267, 0.033414311707019806, 0.029738960787653923, -0.03164124861359596, 0.02224138006567955, 0.02729080431163311, 0.027640441432595253, 0.030763233080506325, 0.005936513654887676, 0.02256879396736622, -0.008347060531377792, -0.04493569955229759, -0.04374092072248459, 0.0147236417979002, -0.05458379164338112, -0.007881649769842625, -0.0037434231489896774, -0.020106257870793343, 0.01701578125357628, 0.006112308241426945, 0.03649600222706795, -0.016112569719552994, -0.03580991551280022, -0.059738755226135254, 0.0436834916472435, 0.0152262719348073, 0.023815158754587173, 0.026777448132634163, 0.005077406298369169, 0.013865556567907333, 0.019549181684851646, 0.03209648281335831, -0.005507895722985268, -0.05158030986785889, -0.05583338066935539, 0.008045141585171223, -0.017793893814086914, 0.03821462392807007, 0.004588528070598841, -0.03656184300780296, 0.016422554850578308, -0.03893963620066643, 0.038469426333904266, 0.02843736857175827, 0.058838047087192535, -0.03834601119160652, 0.05551464110612869, 0.016968239098787308, 0.01922726444900036, 0.0010368371149525046, -0.018575670197606087, 0.12978319823741913, 0.08527123183012009, 0.043297674506902695, -0.04937346279621124, 0.018681690096855164, -0.017723239958286285, -0.020565753802657127, 0.0033146480564028025, 0.01818958856165409, 0.03186944127082825, 0.007330935914069414, 0.0002159096038667485, 0.05314568430185318, 0.001627509482204914, 0.02489616535604, 0.037203699350357056, -0.03316163271665573, 0.016535917297005653, 0.023842165246605873, 0.017636070027947426, 0.002489466918632388, -0.025027165189385414, -0.023975100368261337, 0.004443387035280466, -0.019227800890803337, -0.012795752845704556, -0.03658812865614891, -0.020664464682340622, 0.012491659261286259, -0.0037778716068714857, -0.005618644878268242, -0.003659230889752507, -0.0005656175781041384, 0.005307020153850317, -0.05104634910821915, 0.021246405318379402, -0.022154957056045532, -0.013524672016501427, 0.018780620768666267, 0.030364198610186577, -0.006021430715918541, -0.018863320350646973, -0.00489833066239953, 0.034020327031612396, -0.03958522155880928, -0.0046013472601771355, -0.03746079280972481, 0.050518058240413666, -0.04669877514243126, -0.027301453053951263, -0.013194830156862736, -0.003657511668279767, 0.016637811437249184, -0.027654478326439857, -0.03225305303931236, 0.0381954163312912, 0.005597710609436035, -0.03393322229385376, -0.03476903587579727, -0.06618402898311615, 0.001827190280891955, -0.043735671788454056, 0.03774797171354294, 0.01447481382638216, -0.018140505999326706, -0.01877906545996666, 0.011091110296547413, 0.019552310928702354, 0.01615035906434059, 0.0072808885015547276, -0.015710504725575447, -0.026998326182365417, -0.02328001894056797, -0.0030350268352776766, 0.02738068997859955, 0.030338967218995094, 0.03545430302619934, 0.0030508418567478657, -0.018108999356627464, -0.0036037603858858347, -0.014701965264976025, -0.0065713911317288876, -0.004924341104924679, 0.008303438313305378, -0.0026648095808923244, -0.020488182082772255, -0.009857003577053547, 0.04664042964577675, -0.0036539463326334953, 0.01612107828259468, 0.009893802925944328, 0.018279777839779854, -0.008896912448108196, -0.05958438292145729, -0.03423305228352547, -0.016084685921669006, 0.0011022898834198713, -0.0027114031836390495, -0.000027906631657970138, 0.05292217433452606, 0.026936886832118034, 0.03895295411348343, -0.04364873468875885, 0.04575267806649208, -0.011370254680514336, 0.017964698374271393, 0.020469391718506813, -0.04838056489825249, 0.0061605083756148815, 0.01679946482181549, 0.009900628589093685, -0.04362858086824417, -0.011032608337700367, -0.04846685379743576, -0.008386623114347458, 0.04799843207001686, -0.022412778809666634, -0.01520546991378069, -0.007126517128199339, -0.012852410785853863, 0.016593197360634804, -0.021499261260032654, 0.0047671678476035595, -0.05231410637497902, 0.009614808484911919, -0.014733602292835712, -0.04582521319389343, 0.017732128500938416, -0.02235506847500801, -0.008027824573218822, -0.006056634709239006, 0.06888134777545929, 0.032136671245098114, 0.039958249777555466, 0.0035482554230839014, -0.009470461867749691, 0.010166429914534092, 0.049466174095869064, -0.0654328316450119, -0.03585129231214523, 0.04547160863876343, -0.07025355100631714, -0.013736649416387081, 0.043151214718818665, -0.010704181157052517, 0.029322156682610512, 0.04643285647034645, -0.0014399486826732755, 0.02346637472510338, 0.023648176342248917, -0.029264675453305244, -0.026285860687494278, 0.008597420528531075, 0.0136131402105093, 0.02725086733698845, -0.0032200717832893133, 0.024867579340934753, 0.024857837706804276, 0.014940353110432625, 0.005521618761122227, 0.04608912765979767, 0.0033029078040271997, -0.03409626707434654, 0.021958384662866592, -0.006189627572894096, 0.02683936059474945, 0.018499402329325676, 0.03320460766553879, -0.02630944736301899, 0.05163786560297012, -0.03144365921616554, 0.010956717655062675, -0.017514124512672424, -0.012288274243474007, -0.10039856284856796, -0.019242651760578156, 0.010438267141580582, 0.016537727788090706, -0.029265154153108597, -0.03364547714591026, -0.008442285470664501, 0.03700776770710945, -0.06156788021326065, 0.07024700194597244, -0.022676406428217888, 0.0007709713536314666, -0.03224615380167961, -0.010455365292727947, -0.036979738622903824, 0.02379339188337326, 0.06145656481385231, 0.0075469352304935455, 0.012302173301577568, 0.015607480891048908, -0.0121053047478199, -0.00824364647269249, -0.03006596490740776, 0.021504709497094154, 0.0007968286518007517, -0.0768219605088234, 0.04507150128483772, 0.0039609321393072605, -0.06285522878170013, 0.012446101754903793, 0.012478744611144066, 0.00836079753935337, 0.018438737839460373, 0.019709866493940353, -0.003690491896122694, 0.013755113817751408, 0.0347130112349987, 0.009840186685323715, -0.012210257351398468, 0.028730178251862526, 0.016743505373597145, 0.001975992927327752, -0.006339075975120068, 0.02422781102359295, 0.018617922440171242, 0.00797201506793499, -0.045950211584568024, 0.02278674580156803, -0.015497011132538319, -0.03635295480489731, 0.022057974711060524, 0.0011377976043149829, 0.02267318218946457, -0.03042474389076233, 0.0011523576686158776, -0.05142130330204964, -0.008840840309858322, 0.006177975796163082, -0.007575765252113342, -0.04067400470376015, 0.027521474286913872, -0.010738527402281761, -0.037240222096443176, -0.005065036006271839, 0.010576213710010052, -0.01153525896370411, -0.09171809256076813, 0.00000662262573314365, 0.0022102973889559507, -0.019408468157052994, -0.03545248508453369, -0.006419713608920574, -0.0039940946735441685, 0.06915140151977539, 0.0012175196316093206, 0.0019469168037176132, 0.017924364656209946, -0.03345687314867973, -0.014902208931744099, -0.07265505939722061, 0.03774125874042511, 0.0259694866836071, -0.04080645367503166, -0.03957943245768547, 0.005424105562269688, -0.05129677429795265, -0.019529974088072777, 0.05498756468296051, 0.040918268263339996, 0.0067758699879050255, -0.024629779160022736, 0.04810411483049393, -0.004023952409625053, -0.07007669657468796, 0.021826937794685364, -0.028112761676311493, -0.022154511883854866, -0.033257514238357544, -0.012747393921017647, 0.0004557509091682732, 0.005824805703014135, 0.01989847980439663, 0.004062389023602009, 0.0010817083530128002, -0.0211813822388649, -0.01052071899175644, 0.021489182487130165, 0.006359754595905542, 0.03255688026547432, 0.03423358127474785, 0.010595431551337242, -0.0013336321571841836, 0.0046596527099609375, 0.0011488860473036766, -0.041299138218164444, 0.0009286543936468661, -0.0523800365626812, -0.009200675413012505, -0.02986670657992363, 0.03177744895219803, 0.010353987105190754, -0.035695210099220276, -0.02821819670498371, 0.039936698973178864, -0.01930815353989601, -0.028503568843007088, 0.045580487698316574, 0.04636913537979126, 0.004447115119546652, 0.01957087777554989, 0.014291959814727306, 0.007862089201807976, -0.015255153179168701, -0.02540781907737255, 0.01937340386211872, 0.024986661970615387, 0.006672801449894905, 0.013119390234351158, 0.02356140874326229, -0.0088192168623209, 0.0032464906107634306, 0.0033745637629181147, 0.06370668858289719, -0.03856329247355461, -0.012450216338038445, 0.006321128457784653, -0.0257557462900877, 0.02361094392836094, -0.035580430179834366, -0.005439350381493568, 0.060267072170972824, -0.037994254380464554, 0.016179466620087624, -0.04425705969333649, -0.03160860762000084, -0.0006154567818157375, -0.0034604223910719156, 0.01742377318441868, 0.03266836702823639, 0.006859584711492062, -0.025823161005973816, -0.03736630827188492, -0.019832197576761246, 0.05163907632231712, 0.0025306351017206907, 0.02417435683310032, -0.02260357141494751, -0.030495082959532738, -0.031066635623574257, -0.03671040013432503, -0.008578282780945301, -0.014386940747499466, 0.005017763469368219, 0.03814076632261276, 0.009435744024813175, -0.009867658838629723, -0.03627622872591019, 0.0011249813251197338, 0.04422378912568092, -0.0645514577627182, -0.016614899039268494, -0.019960716366767883, 0.023566706106066704, 0.009682955220341682, -0.019210418686270714 ]
<p>I computed the T-score and P-value using <code>t.test()</code> for my data, and finally I've plotted the density of my p-value and I've got strange plot. I don't know, why I see peak around 0, which it's density is bigger than 1 ? can anybody help me with the interpretation of this plot ? I used the <code>plot(density(mymatrix))</code> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/GFWrW.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
49,345
[ -0.02859649993479252, 0.01001050230115652, 0.005959330126643181, -0.012199290096759796, 0.04497789964079857, 0.01799006760120392, -0.008850554935634136, -0.011150560341775417, 0.014982902444899082, -0.05113573372364044, 0.05600607767701149, 0.053932204842567444, 0.029668355360627174, 0.027896417304873466, 0.040600474923849106, -0.0056811850517988205, -0.013392078690230846, -0.011665590107440948, 0.0067544663324952126, -0.014774751849472523, -0.021174058318138123, 0.042666736990213394, 0.013185245916247368, -0.0011309327092021704, -0.035483166575431824, 0.0584385059773922, -0.0028021971229463816, -0.0012209239648655057, 0.015768198296427727, 0.04688160493969917, -0.05699298530817032, -0.029025424271821976, 0.025722568854689598, -0.020687755197286606, 0.048745736479759216, 0.005222524516284466, -0.004330477677285671, -0.005387676879763603, -0.01788853481411934, 0.020145151764154434, 0.009427046403288841, -0.07642675936222076, 0.0047883158549666405, 0.06825052201747894, -0.010923639871180058, 0.015634765848517418, 0.04906634986400604, -0.031811028718948364, 0.06786329299211502, -0.04308844730257988, 0.0792492926120758, 0.03587080538272858, 0.05959658697247505, 0.020503873005509377, -0.0010370094096288085, 0.006742364726960659, 0.0479048453271389, 0.05733279511332512, -0.03713344410061836, -0.07117491960525513, -0.003674145555123687, -0.08427577465772629, -0.018331974744796753, -0.010552733205258846, -0.03539090231060982, 0.012119580060243607, -0.03294472023844719, -0.03510170429944992, 0.0030169205274432898, -0.03180857002735138, -0.0020594531670212746, 0.04479033872485161, 0.008263975381851196, -0.03930456563830376, 0.025576049461960793, -0.027956897392868996, 0.038551099598407745, 0.009022843092679977, 0.0700538158416748, 0.01043578702956438, 0.060471076518297195, 0.023191407322883606, -0.008731125853955746, 0.02767215296626091, 0.027688171714544296, 0.0016428495291620493, 0.047230564057826996, -0.03680974245071411, 0.02024077996611595, 0.03628285974264145, -0.042223092168569565, 0.0034588042180985212, 0.056470926851034164, 0.03129582107067108, -0.03303788974881172, 0.03547990322113037, -0.014442232437431812, 0.05666746199131012, -0.00008817371417535469, -0.011066040955483913, -0.020574824884533882, -0.038365401327610016, 0.0398266464471817, 0.012630447745323181, -0.0333016961812973, -0.018231680616736412, -0.029270632192492485, -0.004381787497550249, 0.019581357017159462, -0.0064209140837192535, -0.025115709751844406, 0.040198590606451035, 0.006820968817919493, -0.04698175936937332, 0.009072043932974339, -0.041454046964645386, 0.008836286142468452, 0.0012167096138000488, 0.04887662082910538, 0.04086249694228172, 0.023765210062265396, 0.0032506126444786787, 0.027623455971479416, -0.00805661827325821, -0.06184201315045357, 0.02150479517877102, 0.02657196670770645, -0.02139328606426716, -0.0075266798958182335, 0.0574103444814682, -0.037278495728969574, -0.0023492800537496805, 0.05452028289437294, -0.005241199396550655, 0.049283575266599655, -0.03720950707793236, -0.06899414211511612, -0.014866774901747704, 0.04517173394560814, 0.006541428621858358, -0.0046915109269320965, -0.06462379544973373, -0.009944943711161613, 0.026969315484166145, 0.057032667100429535, 0.01435278169810772, 0.01951720006763935, 0.0044621555134654045, 0.04519707337021828, -0.006211584899574518, -0.03372484818100929, -0.01453384105116129, -0.036136358976364136, -0.03653215616941452, 0.011703256517648697, -0.06132248789072037, -0.009486638940870762, 0.017100945115089417, 0.0019987199921160936, -0.007198188919574022, 0.027030428871512413, 0.0002999596472363919, 0.0032143602147698402, 0.005830856040120125, -0.025377588346600533, -0.011970183812081814, 0.07382085919380188, 0.0071447244845330715, 0.02221231907606125, 0.038647379726171494, -0.02578320913016796, 0.027897879481315613, 0.007333526387810707, 0.06617916375398636, 0.005765540990978479, -0.022928521037101746, -0.024875512346625328, -0.0266888327896595, 0.049295760691165924, -0.0042904941365122795, -0.03366079926490784, -0.015443498268723488, 0.0015007049078121781, 0.011519711464643478, 0.03531068563461304, 0.024975087493658066, -0.04068247601389885, -0.026095421984791756, 0.039922572672367096, -0.034932855516672134, -0.06426464021205902, -0.06302270293235779, 0.0019450278487056494, -0.026991060003638268, -0.020390227437019348, -0.02936209738254547, 0.004476438742130995, 0.04316830635070801, 0.007174881175160408, 0.03289273381233215, -0.028742386028170586, -0.017692482098937035, 0.016969820484519005, -0.026282116770744324, 0.004710472654551268, 0.027150604873895645, 0.03234347328543663, 0.003212809329852462, 0.020559241995215416, -0.06052902713418007, -0.027487175539135933, 0.02397853322327137, -0.029731322079896927, 0.020405910909175873, -0.020072538405656815, -0.05533730983734131, 0.0023504155687987804, -0.008828825317323208, -0.02810206077992916, 0.03909286856651306, -0.03859294205904007, 0.05887651443481445, 0.026153994724154472, 0.002635811222717166, -0.003586605889722705, -0.008562273345887661, -0.022994376718997955, -0.004622382111847401, -0.04240380972623825, 0.024480707943439484, -0.03683437407016754, -0.01080255676060915, 0.04011649265885353, 0.034995339810848236, -0.01624293066561222, -0.006297537125647068, 0.05063832551240921, -0.007524901535362005, 0.007242618128657341, 0.04019392281770706, -0.0019397217547520995, -0.028487151488661766, 0.02518979273736477, 0.04819781333208084, -0.002708621323108673, -0.015168762765824795, 0.026980744674801826, -0.005377153865993023, 0.0420805886387825, -0.007441497407853603, -0.0408242903649807, 0.07436960935592651, -0.044429708272218704, -0.004494105000048876, -0.038042377680540085, -0.010597266256809235, 0.004209978971630335, -0.030598601326346397, -0.032904986292123795, 0.028158672153949738, 0.0051423124969005585, -0.0014345977688208222, -0.037545207887887955, -0.03188019618391991, 0.025270361453294754, 0.05731002241373062, -0.02763286419212818, -0.011539538390934467, 0.000985469901934266, -0.013271535746753216, 0.014920012094080448, 0.00713239936158061, -0.027043964713811874, -0.042011357843875885, 0.03442275524139404, 0.029337940737605095, 0.022279761731624603, 0.021794889122247696, -0.04803387075662613, -0.04393533244729042, 0.008634384721517563, -0.01502598449587822, 0.021182581782341003, -0.026176517829298973, -0.09113110601902008, -0.014121182262897491, -0.035144783556461334, -0.029441243037581444, 0.04091094061732292, 0.021324312314391136, -0.022101014852523804, -0.01158958114683628, -0.012082187458872795, -0.011953235603868961, -0.042534150183200836, -0.026067659258842468, 0.012954200617969036, 0.015183926559984684, 0.0009020523866638541, 0.03351366147398949, -0.027460839599370956, -0.01984207145869732, 0.043402038514614105, -0.02801956981420517, 0.0009231243748217821, -0.029329923912882805, -0.019223202019929886, 0.026031572371721268, -0.0019177580252289772, 0.015294159762561321, 0.011117514222860336, -0.04380602389574051, 0.002941470593214035, -0.0729648545384407, -0.020966582000255585, 0.031498003751039505, 0.007884823717176914, 0.03362809866666794, 0.02155681885778904, -0.021920010447502136, 0.06583033502101898, 0.026827199384570122, 0.004102041479200125, -0.06590475887060165, -0.02130608819425106, -0.05491480603814125, -0.0006973480340093374, 0.019808024168014526, 0.018934737890958786, 0.02427232451736927, 0.02726941555738449, -0.0025672418996691704, 0.035185884684324265, 0.06738243997097015, -0.013680260628461838, -0.03320903331041336, 0.03355683758854866, -0.010514471679925919, -0.03160358965396881, 0.02610909193754196, 0.011430050246417522, -0.0039987084455788136, 0.022172842174768448, 0.026132171973586082, 0.036444950848817825, -0.0034381363075226545, -0.03892618417739868, 0.030043108388781548, 0.0019729023333638906, 0.028489192947745323, -0.06014474481344223, 0.028968630358576775, 0.007282128557562828, -0.020358677953481674, -0.008070242591202259, 0.05319724231958389, 0.01700761169195175, -0.03534981608390808, -0.03638497367501259, 0.060052040964365005, -0.004253495950251818, -0.03847067803144455, -0.012471790425479412, 0.00696740485727787, -0.00759076327085495, 0.020296959206461906, -0.03103446029126644, -0.03729724884033203, 0.05459876358509064, -0.00552330119535327, 0.032346244901418686, 0.024693859741091728, -0.04764498397707939, 0.004790830425918102, -0.026401417329907417, 0.02908751182258129, -0.025975024327635765, 0.05163849517703056, 0.005691456608474255, 0.04235616326332092, 0.046446770429611206, 0.028750015422701836, 0.0160279031842947, 0.00029663267196156085, -0.05207508057355881, 0.006283388007432222, -0.010248223319649696, -0.03479001671075821, 0.01497364230453968, -0.01686134748160839, 0.006558070424944162, -0.01885462924838066, 0.01291451696306467, 0.029187779873609543, 0.027933306992053986, -0.04619764909148216, 0.02134205400943756, 0.002635227981954813, 0.03541314974427223, -0.0390469916164875, 0.003185112262144685, 0.004825436044484377, 0.022372843697667122, 0.048746779561042786, 0.06507038325071335, -0.010807279497385025, -0.0002588067436590791, 0.003140923334285617, -0.027536405250430107, 0.07338269799947739, 0.023785796016454697, 0.0551956482231617, 0.04016526788473129, -0.04395154491066933, 0.02033139206469059, -0.00214553065598011, 0.09654118865728378, 0.07608667016029358, -0.007802925538271666, -0.0047338418662548065, -0.0408857986330986, -0.018349021673202515, -0.005326731130480766, 0.010878892615437508, -0.012376230210065842, 0.006053358782082796, -0.000059095629694638774, 0.022447435185313225, -0.030004341155290604, 0.02114640362560749, 0.05953517183661461, 0.05058335140347481, 0.016053903847932816, -0.038067206740379333, -0.010912928730249405, -0.04450742527842522, 0.006651213858276606, 0.011770082637667656, 0.005272486247122288, -0.018185680732131004, 0.00006419688725145534, 0.03876831755042076, -0.02652403526008129, -0.014599191024899483, -0.049687858670949936, 0.020018815994262695, 0.03146900236606598, -0.023120028898119926, -0.020936179906129837, -0.0017223994946107268, 0.03190126642584801, 0.021054325625300407, 0.006387386936694384, 0.006913198158144951, -0.08420742303133011, -0.005327495746314526, 0.032462574541568756, 0.030928699299693108, -0.023356225341558456, -0.0034176711924374104, -0.0446770116686821, 0.011788282543420792, 0.022367052733898163, -0.06199575588107109, 0.033612508326768875, -0.03461714833974838, 0.015713203698396683, -0.01685815490782261, 0.02782323770225048, -0.05494455620646477, 0.007375016342848539, -0.026701731607317924, 0.050027698278427124, -0.019404063001275063, -0.02876255288720131, -0.028793685138225555, 0.005499644670635462, -0.00895044393837452, 0.019796615466475487, -0.05544155463576317, -0.018168291077017784, -0.010541846975684166, -0.015193646773695946, -0.008673698641359806, -0.054450951516628265, -0.00775274820625782, -0.023949500173330307, 0.0012022822629660368, 0.05993808060884476, -0.02234119549393654, -0.010110442526638508, 0.017297876998782158, 0.018521040678024292, -0.011608977802097797, -0.011049343273043633, -0.035760942846536636, 0.028697382658720016, 0.021611172705888748, -0.0492875911295414, 0.03620044142007828, 0.021663334220647812, 0.02433401346206665, 0.004131474997848272, -0.0583839938044548, 0.02697763219475746, -0.018571840599179268, -0.015351768583059311, -0.05392506718635559, -0.012430915609002113, -0.02148454822599888, -0.004053555894643068, 0.026646196842193604, 0.016031721606850624, -0.05899873748421669, -0.002888585440814495, 0.03407931700348854, 0.04054895043373108, 0.025259049609303474, 0.020440852269530296, 0.01830167882144451, -0.018208255991339684, 0.0013369261287152767, -0.0242049228399992, 0.03885896876454353, -0.030310021713376045, 0.007052465807646513, 0.021255940198898315, 0.011408527381718159, 0.041390806436538696, 0.004679475445300341, -0.02303207851946354, 0.0190349780023098, -0.04007494077086449, 0.02485596016049385, -0.010873374529182911, 0.04000163823366165, 0.015954872593283653, -0.018109478056430817, -0.0006914772093296051, 0.0008901956025511026, -0.0174478180706501, 0.05340133607387543, -0.03428921103477478, 0.05446052923798561, -0.014366023242473602, -0.013154313899576664, -0.04159482195973396, -0.04709095135331154, 0.005665227770805359, 0.01142932940274477, -0.05462757498025894, -0.026230745017528534, -0.028869817033410072, -0.01710451766848564, 0.0071379938162863255, 0.025500450283288956, 0.026468072086572647, -0.015669643878936768, -0.03512318804860115, 0.01787169836461544, -0.01361307967454195, 0.052501920610666275, 0.01503701601177454, -0.002899598330259323, 0.00544570991769433, -0.023075560107827187, -0.026157516986131668, -0.024436697363853455, 0.01397159043699503, -0.04050115868449211, -0.007267293985933065, -0.02317226119339466, 0.02819107659161091, 0.051977530121803284, -0.015845173969864845, -0.011092320084571838, -0.01809135265648365, -0.00912046991288662, 0.02290586568415165, -0.04025505483150482, -0.01411642786115408, -0.032420579344034195, -0.019322745501995087, -0.00678484421223402, -0.0372072234749794, -0.044026024639606476, -0.029725639149546623, 0.03896747902035713, -0.0027803012635558844, -0.006081758998334408, 0.021779650822281837, 0.10332343727350235, -0.007632164284586906, 0.04133853316307068, -0.0414760522544384, -0.021987279877066612, -0.010810661129653454, 0.05989601090550423, -0.020972896367311478, 0.025971081107854843, 0.028186965733766556, -0.03324609622359276, 0.027323007583618164, -0.05420916900038719, 0.014098451472818851, 0.030823664739727974, 0.020884905010461807, 0.04869624972343445, 0.048822030425071716, -0.012648435309529305, 0.0038798220921307802, -0.005847090855240822, -0.018711378797888756, -0.0007051675929687917, 0.009471451863646507, 0.014988229610025883, 0.002956944517791271, -0.005865215789526701, 0.06634911894798279, 0.02707125060260296, -0.014076488092541695, 0.042997315526008606, 0.04381030425429344, -0.013472575694322586, 0.019039994105696678, 0.02034066990017891, -0.024490507319569588, 0.022915324196219444, -0.0015920287696644664, 0.03983793780207634, -0.041479747742414474, -0.0157980527728796, 0.03088466450572014, 0.047672465443611145, -0.009313664399087429, -0.012976596131920815, -0.0016519869677722454, -0.021336782723665237, 0.018469469621777534, 0.02971423976123333, -0.030204420909285545, 0.04455636441707611, 0.022632531821727753, 0.010437416844069958, 0.02032667212188244, 0.030086688697338104, -0.027058124542236328, -0.03098655492067337, -0.033847711980342865, -0.04483603313565254, -0.05082903802394867, 0.024495558813214302, -0.013894886709749699, -0.02171459048986435, 0.04387763515114784, -0.04019893333315849, 0.0345473475754261, 0.0032850804273039103, 0.030977068468928337, -0.02748296596109867, 0.05477405712008476, 0.029188280925154686, 0.004237359389662743, 0.018801653757691383, -0.021794868633151054, 0.10398950427770615, 0.08777831494808197, 0.029424404725432396, -0.06497057527303696, -0.004163371864706278, 0.004403391387313604, 0.0008478148956783116, -0.052998147904872894, 0.015450835227966309, 0.031118618324398994, 0.008961967192590237, 0.05471998080611229, 0.048939239233732224, 0.017261087894439697, 0.025646887719631195, 0.04788908362388611, 0.0007016912568360567, -0.04283645376563072, -0.019728001207113266, 0.03331698477268219, -0.006890065968036652, -0.05360107123851776, -0.07438036799430847, 0.0009752503247000277, 0.005846281070262194, 0.012916779145598412, -0.027401911094784737, -0.031055619940161705, -0.020604467019438744, -0.009359937161207199, 0.0026120920665562153, -0.006116683594882488, -0.0021579095628112555, 0.020347926765680313, -0.04658940061926842, -0.010900053195655346, 0.0007695364765822887, 0.0030714168678969145, -0.00634986674413085, 0.04843290522694588, -0.007947535254061222, 0.0012167925015091896, -0.005883481819182634, 0.051155935972929, -0.030759837478399277, -0.014233035035431385, 0.0030031809583306313, 0.06195675581693649, -0.004375990480184555, -0.001963704125955701, -0.0015558961313217878, 0.02375359833240509, 0.0011474828934296966, -0.047129902988672256, -0.02881540171802044, 0.014007237739861012, 0.007912700064480305, -0.014948018826544285, -0.013136006891727448, -0.03894234821200371, -0.007226885296404362, -0.02754293940961361, 0.025151381269097328, 0.03277052566409111, 0.02789152041077614, -0.0014842714881524444, -0.04524174705147743, 0.06150607019662857, -0.03563239052891731, 0.021034525707364082, 0.01305396854877472, -0.047928303480148315, -0.02337668277323246, -0.045356448739767075, 0.019741438329219818, 0.00827467069029808, 0.007316070608794689, 0.017584919929504395, -0.021644363179802895, -0.012339724227786064, -0.020271029323339462, 0.008945982903242111, -0.046542804688215256, -0.010222893208265305, -0.06628909707069397, -0.009281201288104057, 0.010929353535175323, 0.048726316541433334, 0.0233062282204628, 0.023863358423113823, -0.008626784197986126, 0.031960099935531616, -0.001960421446710825, -0.01885467767715454, -0.021838804706931114, 0.010577929206192493, -0.0163334459066391, 0.006041646935045719, 0.009820764884352684, 0.033780474215745926, 0.03769417107105255, 0.029253482818603516, -0.013683988712728024, -0.014186142012476921, -0.03820111230015755, -0.02414601668715477, -0.02443026565015316, -0.056618254631757736, -0.011716275475919247, 0.018553415313363075, -0.012807398103177547, 0.005920087918639183, -0.02384321764111519, -0.027461595833301544, -0.0542425811290741, 0.006246682722121477, 0.008221245370805264, -0.025572650134563446, -0.04285884276032448, 0.023006778210401535, 0.009085147641599178, -0.0013316393597051501, -0.02147710882127285, -0.06513547897338867, 0.0023105377331376076, -0.008306082338094711, -0.014020518399775028, -0.03173872083425522, 0.025563467293977737, -0.01039951853454113, 0.0237051323056221, 0.015880800783634186, 0.004601174965500832, 0.007896781899034977, 0.0017232901882380247, 0.03312693536281586, 0.0001050103091984056, 0.021943645551800728, 0.0020367142278701067, -0.015456045977771282, 0.07580563426017761, -0.05336311087012291, -0.02977495640516281, 0.009574325755238533, -0.0014832206070423126, 0.030060669407248497, 0.004604719113558531, 0.006674339063465595, -0.0005365569377318025, 0.05141662433743477, -0.009113817475736141, -0.0263422392308712, 0.015779035165905952, -0.011005045846104622, -0.0032087822910398245, 0.025780444964766502, -0.014046860858798027, -0.011468972079455853, -0.020104631781578064, 0.016036566346883774, 0.07547792792320251, 0.000489291560370475, 0.00616688746958971, 0.03381423279643059, -0.024302950128912926, -0.0002655867428984493, 0.03210717439651489, -0.004938974976539612, 0.0034883792977780104, 0.04738153889775276, 0.0026099765673279762, 0.02278408408164978, -0.03823821246623993, 0.029081249609589577, -0.08406569063663483, -0.010631851851940155, 0.010284134186804295, -0.05770055204629898, 0.047829221934080124, -0.047909703105688095, -0.016942158341407776, 0.039640672504901886, -0.045810267329216, 0.04321182891726494, 0.0014993646182119846, -0.03598890081048012, -0.03655572608113289, -0.011475981213152409, 0.0030462956055998802, 0.0592934712767601, 0.04804088920354843, 0.018427399918437004, 0.06610376387834549, 0.004216312896460295, -0.03338583558797836, 0.006212746724486351, -0.011979028582572937, 0.08274072408676147, -0.002494887914508581, -0.05377935990691185, 0.014291467145085335, -0.030160602182149887, -0.04113394394516945, 0.021723194047808647, -0.005982158239930868, 0.0009979668539017439, 0.034346744418144226, 0.026236457750201225, 0.028766214847564697, 0.007613795343786478, 0.038367096334695816, -0.0010834024287760258, -0.013283987529575825, 0.013329068198800087, -0.004308625124394894, -0.004541750065982342, -0.007252056617289782, 0.04385880008339882, 0.009773301891982555, -0.03160921484231949, -0.0011867462890222669, 0.026554403826594353, -0.022554881870746613, 0.0068322764709591866, 0.0006548533565364778, 0.02525266818702221, 0.008139106445014477, -0.05764681100845337, 0.02860962226986885, -0.04214758425951004, -0.012730060145258904, 0.02255181036889553, 0.019043924286961555, -0.013668308034539223, 0.031006162986159325, 0.004705715924501419, -0.043480463325977325, 0.03905605152249336, -0.01265059132128954, -0.028801925480365753, -0.04489878565073013, -0.001840743119828403, -0.013262438587844372, -0.0009824937442317605, 0.022069526836276054, 0.0035570538602769375, -0.03015127405524254, 0.04038938134908676, 0.00011298482422716916, -0.01836639828979969, 0.017434202134609222, -0.02805776335299015, 0.0027503713499754667, -0.11550052464008331, 0.05295652523636818, -0.0538373626768589, -0.036051757633686066, -0.03863123059272766, 0.024475350975990295, -0.04104107245802879, 0.0248622577637434, -0.0037522329948842525, 0.06698355078697205, 0.022740866988897324, 0.016877377405762672, 0.02181469090282917, -0.0034721712581813335, -0.06144695356488228, 0.023136110976338387, 0.0028062835335731506, -0.034271858632564545, -0.020700570195913315, -0.005995017476379871, 0.02674662508070469, 0.043299172073602676, 0.010679001919925213, -0.024911975488066673, -0.006188665982335806, -0.004427862819284201, -0.010378606617450714, 0.039389465004205704, 0.0042718760669231415, -0.03615795448422432, 0.07782004028558731, -0.014191145077347755, 0.030524587258696556, 0.03784145414829254, -0.01292775571346283, -0.032851692289114, 0.04829540103673935, -0.007505309768021107, -0.015571452677249908, 0.007124070543795824, 0.016575071960687637, 0.004130733665078878, -0.05522118881344795, 0.0008660195744596422, 0.018334588035941124, -0.02043897658586502, -0.02005225047469139, 0.025172920897603035, 0.008344601839780807, 0.026193194091320038, -0.04742811620235443, 0.04621974751353264, -0.009355731308460236, -0.03558925911784172, 0.023773936554789543, 0.04118617996573448, -0.010498863644897938, -0.01962384395301342, 0.007438224274665117, 0.013369569554924965, -0.04192689061164856, 0.0027151601389050484, -0.015268095768988132, 0.023644546046853065, -0.03780995309352875, -0.015530761331319809, 0.01737741194665432, -0.018979638814926147, 0.03401147201657295, -0.002921087434515357, -0.004284850787371397, 0.04507606104016304, -0.029285544529557228, 0.008613970130681992, -0.001322436728514731, -0.022624874487519264, -0.03695543110370636, 0.00031456779106520116, 0.040694937109947205, 0.042964428663253784, -0.016632452607154846, 0.01042601466178894, -0.0037001955788582563, -0.0074225799180567265, 0.022689228877425194, -0.011623063124716282, 0.01380927674472332, -0.025651821866631508, -0.019463898614048958, -0.019896510988473892, 0.0036102773156017065, -0.02448187954723835, 0.005600541364401579, 0.0180323775857687, 0.0002834673214238137, 0.0051594204269349575, -0.049016181379556656, -0.033782217651605606, 0.00015054656250867993, 0.02715243585407734, -0.02132478915154934, -0.027076493948698044, -0.023584755137562752, 0.035927191376686096, -0.004987203516066074, -0.026235055178403854 ]
<p>I would like to specify a multivariate model with <code>lme</code> with a random effect for group which is independent across variables. I found <a href="http://scs.math.yorku.ca/index.php/Mixed_Models_with_R/Multivariate_Mixed_Models.Rmd" rel="nofollow">this post</a>, which explains that the model specified as:</p> <pre><code>fit.multilevel &lt;- lme( y ~ var -1, dd, random = ~ var -1| school, correlation = corSymm( form = ~ v |school/id), weights = varIdent(form = ~ 1 | v)) </code></pre> <p>is equivalent to (using <code>MCMCglmm</code>):</p> <pre><code>fit.w.null &lt;- MCMCglmm( cbind(mathach, ses) ~ trait -1 , random = ~us(trait):school, rcov = ~us(trait):units, data = hs, family = c("gaussian","gaussian")) </code></pre> <p>However the model I would really like has independent random effects for school across the variables:</p> <pre><code>fit.w.null &lt;- MCMCglmm( cbind(mathach, ses) ~ trait -1 , random = ~idh(trait):school, rcov = ~us(trait):units, data = hs, family = c("gaussian","gaussian")) </code></pre> <p>(the random effect is specified with <code>idh()</code>). I cannot find a way to specify this in <code>lme</code>.<br> Here is some code to generate example data and run the analysis:</p> <pre><code>gr=rep(c("A","B","C"),each=100) grp.mean=rep(rnorm(3,5,1),each=100) var1=rnorm(300,rep(rnorm(3,5,1),each=100),1) var2=0.8*var1+3*rnorm(300,rep(rnorm(3,5,1),each=100),2) dat.mcmc=data.frame(var1=var1,var2=var2,group=gr) dat.lme=data.frame(y=c(var1,var2),var=rep(c("1","2"),each=length(gr)), group=rep(gr,2),id=rep(1:length(gr),2)) dat.lme$v=as.integer(dat.lme$var) </code></pre> <p>Currently this is the best I can do:</p> <pre><code>fit.multilevel &lt;- lme( y ~ var -1, dat.lme, random = ~ var -1| group, correlation = corSymm( form = ~ v |group/id), weights = varIdent(form = ~ 1 | v)) </code></pre> <p>This is (I believe) equivalent to:</p> <pre><code>fit.w.null &lt;- MCMCglmm( cbind(var1, var2) ~ trait -1 , random = ~us(trait):group, rcov = ~us(trait):units, data = dat.mcmc, family = c("gaussian","gaussian")) </code></pre> <p>However, I would like an <code>lme</code> command equivalent to:</p> <pre><code>fit.w.null &lt;- MCMCglmm( cbind(var1, var2) ~ trait -1 , random = ~idh(trait):group, rcov = ~us(trait):units, data = hs, family = c("gaussian","gaussian")) </code></pre> <p>Any help you can give me will be much appreciated.</p>
74,358
[ -0.04502246901392937, 0.021756624802947044, 0.034511152654886246, -0.026122700423002243, 0.026541240513324738, 0.031933750957250595, -0.041148338466882706, -0.05993657186627388, 0.062065839767456055, -0.07435780763626099, 0.05405440926551819, 0.06681887805461884, 0.07941711694002151, 0.032345037907361984, 0.06476498395204544, -0.0012593178544193506, 0.012338187545537949, 0.01631919853389263, 0.0035284236073493958, -0.044475894421339035, -0.007341613527387381, 0.02767110802233219, -0.006416537333279848, -0.034167103469371796, -0.0063162911683321, 0.01753222942352295, 0.0346997007727623, -0.007247792091220617, 0.02050516940653324, 0.018606189638376236, -0.06531770527362823, -0.008937466889619827, -0.000018662916772882454, 0.029590824618935585, -0.016287971287965775, 0.009218623861670494, 0.021725831553339958, -0.003181154141202569, 0.020305603742599487, 0.006716595962643623, -0.005783713422715664, 0.018687473610043526, 0.0057142674922943115, 0.05498392507433891, -0.00495868781581521, 0.03549718111753464, -0.008811043575406075, -0.0008428927976638079, 0.05707179754972458, -0.01135182287544012, 0.05749397724866867, -0.02872549742460251, 0.0418890118598938, 0.047099221497774124, -0.03667980432510376, 0.013110464438796043, 0.0499945767223835, 0.05571424961090088, 0.020970668643712997, -0.030872849747538567, -0.02324698306620121, -0.03373800590634346, 0.01880505494773388, -0.004843334201723337, -0.01939592882990837, -0.010635682381689548, 0.02011149190366268, 0.011767884716391563, 0.02553310990333557, -0.043431129306554794, 0.04808059334754944, 0.003154237987473607, 0.04884110391139984, -0.02032078057527542, 0.04612753167748451, -0.017077913507819176, 0.006657764781266451, 0.012024552561342716, 0.03499173745512962, 0.0017850366421043873, -0.010855074040591717, 0.03347465395927429, -0.01625983417034149, 0.013373234309256077, 0.010720817372202873, -0.03992931917309761, 0.041504766792058945, -0.03028002940118313, 0.03763076663017273, 0.03273501247167587, -0.05589021369814873, 0.0017431728774681687, 0.035205092281103134, 0.039509665220975876, -0.05655922368168831, 0.06735403090715408, 0.004286359529942274, 0.018630612641572952, 0.004879853222519159, 0.01617596670985222, 0.005498658865690231, -0.0485905185341835, 0.0030443642754107714, 0.07863441109657288, 0.027253756299614906, 0.005386556498706341, -0.009739663451910019, -0.002129998989403248, -0.0323239266872406, -0.027571212500333786, 0.009466137737035751, 0.04113118350505829, -0.014211887493729591, -0.03582828864455223, 0.02823403850197792, -0.022901959717273712, -0.022061379626393318, -0.028113320469856262, 0.053209975361824036, 0.07044319808483124, 0.04172739386558533, -0.019479164853692055, 0.035443264991045, -0.042824868112802505, -0.03529314696788788, 0.021476712077856064, -0.006205558776855469, 0.007338488940149546, -0.02468694932758808, 0.038293443620204926, 0.010882173664867878, -0.011047200299799442, 0.012630213983356953, 0.01961318589746952, 0.011059527285397053, -0.043497465550899506, -0.07634846866130829, -0.0748952180147171, 0.014613406732678413, -0.00930450577288866, 0.004178974777460098, -0.042297642678022385, 0.006851765792816877, 0.018003160133957863, 0.050410863012075424, -0.006217906251549721, 0.031041868031024933, 0.003785146865993738, 0.04034850373864174, -0.009201128967106342, -0.02258627489209175, 0.021284498274326324, -0.04243352636694908, -0.018950602039694786, -0.031889379024505615, -0.12529133260250092, 0.01052921824157238, 0.023373015224933624, -0.035530250519514084, 0.04030035436153412, -0.002750576240941882, -0.021138278767466545, -0.02595038153231144, -0.01181937288492918, 0.01776270382106304, -0.035885367542505264, 0.025564661249518394, -0.021574275568127632, 0.03980465978384018, 0.023541154339909554, -0.034179095178842545, 0.013226608745753765, 0.003204949665814638, 0.07327961921691895, 0.019737757742404938, 0.0005501423729583621, 0.013153710402548313, 0.011957616545259953, 0.029348455369472504, 0.041875362396240234, -0.04776715859770775, -0.0016658671665936708, -0.027546435594558716, 0.0027213420253247023, 0.015371856279671192, 0.018261080607771873, 0.03190780431032181, 0.033063776791095734, 0.059024274349212646, -0.031148824840784073, -0.04044651985168457, -0.03775950148701668, 0.0065044523216784, 0.04660344868898392, -0.026205044239759445, 0.017207518219947815, -0.019732095301151276, 0.04092252999544144, 0.008464409038424492, -0.006578706670552492, -0.03871979936957359, -0.010921508073806763, 0.02341105416417122, -0.040419671684503555, 0.01682007871568203, 0.0024299840442836285, 0.04548656940460205, -0.014472552575170994, 0.01211114227771759, 0.0077531663700938225, 0.016685502603650093, -0.020811036229133606, -0.0400218702852726, -0.012443851679563522, -0.012919876724481583, 0.003032251028344035, -0.014917520806193352, -0.00034155158209614456, -0.0286483783274889, 0.03917103260755539, -0.0757107138633728, 0.01558515802025795, 0.07414527982473373, 0.005544094368815422, -0.017715752124786377, 0.006586334202438593, 0.009168285876512527, 0.0014870923478156328, -0.058557748794555664, -0.007367228623479605, -0.03883639723062515, -0.016271136701107025, 0.047608472406864166, 0.0001262335863430053, -0.038921523839235306, 0.017461692914366722, 0.07671422511339188, 0.006686197128146887, 0.005862351506948471, 0.03494014963507652, 0.005114707164466381, -0.012414990924298763, 0.032449834048748016, 0.004410081543028355, 0.037434086203575134, 0.025134701281785965, 0.010837062261998653, -0.015508836135268211, 0.03845501318573952, 0.024471357464790344, 0.009547684341669083, 0.034434832632541656, 0.023332510143518448, -0.0015827888855710626, -0.028782134875655174, -0.0008752846042625606, 0.03595592826604843, 0.028269825503230095, 0.02171562798321247, 0.046372994780540466, -0.005140783730894327, -0.05538100004196167, 0.0023681093007326126, -0.023975610733032227, -0.011913012713193893, 0.037602879106998444, -0.008412189781665802, -0.005095652770251036, 0.007401175796985626, -0.023055747151374817, -0.012803583405911922, 0.011789279989898205, -0.020305892452597618, -0.05626855045557022, 0.033736225217580795, 0.01712823286652565, 0.005148358643054962, -0.024919042363762856, -0.0533112995326519, -0.024870486930012703, 0.03926752507686615, 0.01806962862610817, 0.036736637353897095, -0.02627469226717949, -0.03026619553565979, 0.004161636345088482, -0.02358749695122242, 0.0017155940877273679, 0.0267303679138422, -0.008624523878097534, -0.05850667878985405, 0.026367314159870148, -0.007005525287240744, -0.06210732087492943, -0.016176709905266762, -0.014736362732946873, -0.010191830806434155, -0.017417576164007187, -0.023585496470332146, 0.048832766711711884, 0.02577671781182289, -0.07218494266271591, 0.0008756445604376495, -0.033907536417245865, -0.007255278993397951, -0.03597961738705635, -0.007031800225377083, 0.02996930480003357, 0.02979663573205471, 0.052756063640117645, 0.021382654085755348, 0.0027854100335389376, 0.0032577901147305965, -0.06336253136396408, -0.039886604994535446, 0.014702579006552696, 0.025473134592175484, 0.013272019103169441, -0.0074841417372226715, 0.0023099887184798717, 0.04287051409482956, 0.021266184747219086, -0.02656102553009987, -0.07556741684675217, -0.005772567354142666, -0.012120770290493965, -0.027830587700009346, 0.037797532975673676, -0.0035403678193688393, 0.011113880202174187, 0.005483224056661129, 0.004683589097112417, 0.003065545577555895, 0.041559040546417236, -0.018475960940122604, 0.03226471692323685, -0.0014189383946359158, -0.017008813098073006, -0.02544521912932396, 0.0376167856156826, 0.013324244879186153, 0.017380766570568085, -0.012221173383295536, 0.003479226026684046, 0.01140840444713831, -0.0147635443136096, -0.04164543375372887, 0.02888166531920433, -0.0008171055233106017, 0.019492994993925095, -0.06564022600650787, 0.016071012243628502, 0.012330317869782448, -0.04574280232191086, 0.005202369764447212, -0.013635030947625637, 0.04332248121500015, -0.0030126445926725864, -0.00140964740421623, 0.0489608496427536, -0.006114441901445389, -0.01591362990438938, 0.02205049805343151, 0.0007600090466439724, 0.0023471235763281584, 0.0227541271597147, -0.06257455050945282, 0.031172150745987892, 0.012411024421453476, 0.019332636147737503, 0.004078942816704512, 0.014324381947517395, -0.03712328523397446, 0.028253793716430664, -0.06413336098194122, 0.06490280479192734, -0.04260552302002907, 0.023389004170894623, 0.017189940437674522, 0.011567865498363972, 0.017080338671803474, -0.01950971782207489, -0.014440307393670082, -0.014395598322153091, -0.04444696381688118, 0.022382225841283798, -0.004245958756655455, -0.029709305614233017, 0.006635251455008984, -0.028762515634298325, -0.007081528659909964, 0.010763715952634811, -0.003985822666436434, -0.0010762530146166682, -0.0001334443804807961, 0.016225682571530342, 0.021773288026452065, -0.018352268263697624, -0.039832670241594315, -0.023774709552526474, 0.03789922967553139, 0.028020380064845085, -0.026235053315758705, -0.03944113850593567, -0.000029897504646214657, -0.015783729031682014, 0.001052708481438458, -0.029686789959669113, -0.021445339545607567, -0.005030172877013683, 0.024323437362909317, 0.04279433935880661, 0.03643139451742172, -0.032265689224004745, 0.003965487238019705, 0.011895176023244858, 0.0322355218231678, 0.07398878782987595, -0.043023623526096344, -0.0005809800932183862, -0.022043542936444283, 0.017143486067652702, 0.024249529466032982, 0.023160789161920547, -0.0055671208538115025, -0.01900804229080677, 0.04501819610595703, 0.015837427228689194, -0.06199700012803078, 0.02162080816924572, 0.060809794813394547, 0.007223157212138176, 0.01587078347802162, -0.021789798513054848, 0.007002982776612043, -0.016054609790444374, 0.0038650173228234053, 0.03265976905822754, 0.0177847258746624, 0.01916317641735077, 0.01144458632916212, 0.009831879287958145, -0.013216954655945301, -0.004004773683845997, 0.0009011458023451269, 0.033379118889570236, 0.048195306211709976, 0.0009189493139274418, -0.023114031180739403, -0.005049240309745073, 0.03538225218653679, -0.0013231761986389756, 0.013690948486328125, 0.005232850555330515, -0.06695803254842758, -0.0242585688829422, 0.03226106986403465, 0.05052300915122032, -0.04093802347779274, -0.0075594536028802395, -0.025252172723412514, 0.006926140747964382, 0.017725618556141853, -0.007013161201030016, 0.02089475281536579, 0.015185884200036526, 0.021137677133083344, 0.005188681650906801, -0.020195642486214638, -0.08025483042001724, 0.042415421456098557, -0.04934781417250633, -0.02861914597451687, -0.026812812313437462, -0.021105026826262474, -0.018198516219854355, 0.014335830695927143, 0.001416421844623983, 0.0361795537173748, -0.048858340829610825, -0.029310042038559914, -0.006062264088541269, -0.0004582647525239736, 0.010306769981980324, -0.0157909132540226, 0.027174698188900948, -0.011824559420347214, 0.0032318534795194864, 0.04857797548174858, 0.0017337495228275657, -0.00249180244281888, -0.006576149258762598, 0.007947116158902645, 0.0119485417380929, 0.01734260655939579, -0.027510153129696846, 0.06072267144918442, 0.03302173689007759, 0.006084248889237642, 0.027416959404945374, 0.020402446389198303, 0.004200017545372248, -0.03137444332242012, -0.08078733086585999, 0.02664625644683838, -0.0416177473962307, -0.07121869176626205, -0.053753290325403214, -0.022930292412638664, -0.00006410367495846003, 0.03475499898195267, -0.006834656931459904, 0.016426771879196167, -0.07537756115198135, -0.034726835787296295, 0.024816647171974182, 0.041186120361089706, -0.010715733282268047, -0.02456982061266899, -0.04155785217881203, -0.01541343703866005, -0.023559531196951866, -0.008756835013628006, 0.01180639024823904, -0.01619570143520832, 0.003458612132817507, 0.003992125391960144, -0.022957881912589073, -0.01239585131406784, 0.022654850035905838, -0.010098408907651901, -0.02873826213181019, -0.03053402714431286, 0.001666452270001173, -0.010829771868884563, 0.05570346489548683, -0.02059461735188961, -0.03547993302345276, 0.005439971573650837, 0.06208191439509392, -0.028358537703752518, -0.02540905959904194, 0.02235899306833744, 0.02388181909918785, -0.029628699645400047, -0.00872740801423788, -0.07560098171234131, -0.04223620891571045, -0.03060004487633705, -0.04874745383858681, 0.009814075194299221, -0.04789130762219429, -0.01696474850177765, -0.008266746997833252, 0.029719524085521698, -0.024241110309958458, 0.04936889931559563, -0.03428642451763153, 0.04218645393848419, -0.02078585885465145, 0.013270650058984756, 0.057803068310022354, -0.016822881996631622, -0.0007958899368532002, 0.04228685796260834, -0.034778185188770294, -0.021139200776815414, 0.014545024372637272, 0.00574920978397131, -0.027994506061077118, 0.022159742191433907, -0.03886708989739418, 0.024127911776304245, 0.03395932912826538, -0.005090958904474974, -0.02773360349237919, 0.003990974742919207, -0.005708780605345964, 0.02909606136381626, -0.047399427741765976, 0.0063215200789272785, -0.006392584182322025, -0.00014459552767220885, -0.01575557328760624, 0.04687916114926338, -0.037524688988924026, 0.001632307074032724, 0.017641397193074226, -0.03750428557395935, -0.012176242657005787, -0.005242085549980402, 0.0672333613038063, 0.0032430191058665514, 0.01975279673933983, -0.018636781722307205, -0.031452059745788574, -0.0003494076372589916, 0.012826904654502869, -0.0035627863835543394, 0.007696450222283602, -0.003984502982348204, -0.026985427364706993, -0.023320641368627548, -0.05120137706398964, 0.010771717876195908, 0.03670596331357956, 0.011175775900483131, 0.02040703035891056, 0.06908704340457916, -0.03749861940741539, 0.002201103838160634, -0.04170113801956177, -0.007488588336855173, -0.03225215896964073, 0.015444234944880009, 0.08070459961891174, -0.0017742920899763703, -0.008161176927387714, 0.02006571553647518, 0.009603160433471203, 0.025333283469080925, 0.05157657340168953, 0.016753286123275757, -0.014944796450436115, 0.017860475927591324, 0.005871640983968973, -0.037989042699337006, 0.0480707623064518, -0.03116866573691368, -0.016229556873440742, -0.04814960062503815, -0.030213255435228348, 0.02423040196299553, 0.05789921060204506, -0.022591063752770424, -0.04491652920842171, -0.0018605143995955586, -0.042469579726457596, 0.029892155900597572, 0.04145577922463417, -0.008593060076236725, 0.01093868725001812, -0.011397883296012878, 0.022216131910681725, -0.010053076781332493, 0.04120177403092384, -0.057812854647636414, -0.08623158931732178, -0.00039405550342053175, -0.023697692900896072, -0.002281077904626727, 0.03714296221733093, 0.018303053453564644, -0.014443643391132355, 0.010038246400654316, -0.03433549404144287, 0.053235579282045364, -0.018731098622083664, 0.009983357973396778, 0.023168182000517845, 0.06562630832195282, 0.010541373863816261, 0.011491316370666027, -0.0250470582395792, -0.04300566762685776, 0.13781453669071198, 0.05525792017579079, 0.05469438433647156, -0.07445289939641953, 0.003171444870531559, 0.029081152752041817, -0.00740415183827281, -0.0056526875123381615, -0.032726023346185684, -0.018174001947045326, -0.037776511162519455, 0.05716690793633461, 0.04169498756527901, 0.0315052792429924, -0.01431541983038187, 0.02436719834804535, -0.0262172631919384, -0.0012307966826483607, -0.016977844759821892, -0.008733835071325302, -0.012119372375309467, 0.0020175804384052753, -0.05361616611480713, -0.0032554015051573515, 0.03323569893836975, 0.0028219074010849, -0.03349348530173302, -0.03515702486038208, -0.00818279292434454, 0.04136016219854355, -0.0012414525263011456, -0.0021771753672510386, -0.0037532818969339132, 0.028145987540483475, 0.007449962664395571, -0.04726431891322136, 0.058348339051008224, 0.01067210454493761, 0.020766129717230797, 0.026225509122014046, 0.015443745069205761, 0.006030313670635223, -0.009954496286809444, 0.00582388648763299, -0.01452209148555994, -0.056235890835523605, 0.0014890566235408187, 0.05912475287914276, -0.017922623082995415, -0.018753938376903534, -0.031063077971339226, 0.019449681043624878, 0.00801398791372776, -0.03723950684070587, -0.029153229668736458, -0.015473362058401108, 0.023762641474604607, -0.01688431017100811, -0.0022303787991404533, -0.0013272309442982078, 0.007971039041876793, -0.028614304959774017, 0.05433698743581772, 0.005126245319843292, -0.02219211868941784, -0.007823762483894825, -0.05580304190516472, 0.047791048884391785, 0.007444172631949186, 0.01133614033460617, 0.03912603110074997, -0.03928497061133385, -0.027840590104460716, -0.017489604651927948, 0.05246156081557274, 0.0013174632331356406, 0.0262497216463089, -0.012193364091217518, -0.01762796752154827, -0.03430136293172836, -0.007755560800433159, -0.017199566587805748, -0.04283342882990837, -0.030458996072411537, 0.008734512142837048, 0.003216769779101014, 0.009909861721098423, 0.049821630120277405, 0.02218160219490528, 0.0020063291303813457, -0.0262952521443367, 0.03372161090373993, -0.028841616585850716, -0.04166208952665329, -0.03304175287485123, 0.0025586148258298635, -0.038896188139915466, -0.010750029236078262, 0.0034085859078913927, 0.024925976991653442, 0.02404611185193062, 0.031607408076524734, -0.004834670573472977, 0.05508604645729065, -0.006110111717134714, -0.006715531460940838, 0.011857946403324604, -0.019260456785559654, 0.010344545356929302, -0.005583804100751877, -0.020712826400995255, 0.013232403434813023, 0.04065406322479248, -0.03529825434088707, -0.04110390692949295, -0.009455820545554161, -0.015922849997878075, -0.03681974858045578, 0.006450718734413385, -0.03294810280203819, 0.0014804058009758592, -0.03008410520851612, 0.0018931637750938535, -0.029461778700351715, -0.014499680139124393, 0.004374006763100624, -0.02273760735988617, 0.014104558154940605, 0.05275290831923485, -0.016315441578626633, 0.023817991837859154, 0.021968001499772072, 0.012099946849048138, 0.028153562918305397, -0.016029516234993935, 0.02593337558209896, 0.011277247220277786, 0.07349855452775955, 0.01959698274731636, 0.006218411028385162, -0.02967948280274868, -0.025698591023683548, -0.016439490020275116, -0.03342125192284584, 0.008033327758312225, 0.03399474546313286, 0.02696794457733631, 0.014529394917190075, -0.04550768435001373, 0.06933116912841797, -0.016360940411686897, -0.0008482476114295423, -0.0022362335585057735, 0.0036349897272884846, 0.0314502939581871, -0.020866459235548973, -0.022099675610661507, 0.03781742602586746, 0.0015598242171108723, 0.04281047359108925, 0.03614620864391327, 0.016710150986909866, -0.030373362824320793, 0.02225724421441555, -0.02697124145925045, 0.024662647396326065, 0.010621932335197926, 0.018016230314970016, 0.027315590530633926, 0.037120234221220016, -0.026698928326368332, 0.07446601241827011, 0.004973466508090496, 0.025949206203222275, -0.13836878538131714, -0.046487193554639816, -0.00825200043618679, 0.030914433300495148, 0.05138349160552025, 0.011340244673192501, -0.034426409751176834, 0.020059123635292053, -0.06482952833175659, -0.006995203904807568, 0.012431745417416096, 0.01702389493584633, -0.03287390619516373, 0.041704654693603516, -0.04062245413661003, -0.008670222014188766, 0.010904570110142231, 0.02532084845006466, 0.043292056769132614, 0.004523156210780144, -0.009793682023882866, -0.03671425208449364, -0.042844437062740326, -0.010668877512216568, 0.04727298021316528, -0.04056115448474884, 0.04378996789455414, -0.005004980601370335, -0.0036982311867177486, -0.01469274703413248, 0.03755545988678932, 0.029621724039316177, -0.002470699604600668, 0.047111574560403824, 0.04098055511713028, 0.056109245866537094, 0.021474109962582588, 0.0025000523310154676, 0.007190441247075796, -0.008475085720419884, 0.0015662329969927669, 0.038357529789209366, -0.04026133939623833, -0.012362037785351276, -0.028958572074770927, -0.010830376297235489, -0.01959189958870411, 0.032471928745508194, -0.01471914816647768, -0.024060454219579697, -0.013706525787711143, -0.003709303680807352, -0.017494264990091324, -0.04636773839592934, -0.022133195772767067, -0.06617402285337448, 0.01589767262339592, 0.0697736069560051, 0.03450557962059975, -0.004913168027997017, 0.020083041861653328, -0.02768252044916153, -0.00981251709163189, -0.02949502319097519, -0.005881860386580229, -0.038938991725444794, -0.0257484819740057, -0.007105684373527765, -0.0034436353016644716, -0.008999671787023544, -0.008394070900976658, 0.028227288275957108, -0.04636652395129204, 0.04159686714410782, -0.020180223509669304, -0.006573028862476349, -0.009798426181077957, 0.023701751604676247, 0.019160019233822823, -0.04156223684549332, 0.061980459839105606, 0.012281617149710655, -0.018219303339719772, -0.050364602357149124, -0.005577655043452978, 0.001638672430999577, 0.053787484765052795, 0.04411889612674713, 0.022610971704125404, 0.01934080757200718, 0.007621047552675009, 0.050399504601955414, 0.00790192000567913, -0.029057027772068977, 0.06007438153028488, 0.006764539051800966, -0.016995863988995552, -0.017355987802147865, -0.004894352983683348, 0.0056943888776004314, 0.02195863053202629, 0.022413980215787888, -0.03858662396669388, 0.0015918479766696692, 0.01274371612817049, -0.020804088562726974, 0.00323333777487278, -0.0037881454918533564, -0.0318031907081604, 0.025474941357970238, -0.00843394547700882, -0.020761772990226746, 0.011677994392812252, 0.027922367677092552, -0.04096530005335808, 0.015360360033810139, -0.06470729410648346, -0.012812872417271137, 0.026171814650297165, 0.04128987714648247, -0.031508270651102066, -0.04980526491999626, 0.050448380410671234, 0.008282437920570374, -0.043787166476249695, -0.030441652983427048, 0.0334215946495533, -0.014663401991128922, 0.04742833971977234, 0.005837028380483389, -0.02715265564620495, -0.017102142795920372, -0.06042476370930672, 0.015877123922109604, 0.004258325323462486, 0.029819099232554436, -0.0009737939108163118, -0.0072013009339571, 0.058897651731967926, 0.0014168528141453862, 0.018627068027853966, 0.02126988396048546, 0.039283305406570435, -0.030977295711636543, -0.0383690744638443, 0.024172572419047356, -0.016486650332808495, 0.02244841679930687, -0.008102541789412498, -0.012768303975462914, 0.0603165365755558, -0.052935391664505005, 0.031291328370571136, -0.05479626730084419, -0.0037557862233370543, -0.015583795495331287, 0.03750159218907356, -0.010016093961894512, 0.031567737460136414, 0.006484785117208958, -0.0020157727412879467, 0.006443105638027191, -0.05672895535826683, 0.003603026270866394, -0.018575841560959816, 0.04281419515609741, -0.01490727998316288, -0.0067956638522446156, 0.022160319611430168, 0.019341351464390755, -0.04568737372756004, -0.01711287721991539, -0.006518540903925896, 0.013759651221334934, 0.012210242450237274, -0.0647740438580513, 0.001043661148287356, 0.02365873195230961, 0.03866574913263321, -0.03972289711236954, 0.0038246142212301493, -0.01693752594292164, 0.005875234957784414, -0.008407866582274437, 0.029330572113394737 ]
<p>Through the last year I have been working with support vector machines for a binary text classification task. Having used software such as R and Rapidminer I have not spent much time on understanding what actually goes on inside support vector machines. This I have now started looking into in the hope of getting a better understanding of this classification/regression method. </p> <p>I have spent a lot of time looking for calculation examples as it tends to enhance my understanding of a concept quite well if I can actually setup a problem in Excel. Therefore I hope to get guidance by asking this question here, as I have not been able to find any step-by-step calculation examples. One can easily find descriptions of the math and optimization problems one need to understand and solve computationally, but a step-by-step calculation example I have not been able to find.</p> <p>If the forum approves my idea of producing such an example I will do the editing and in the end produce a nice and clear Excel sheet and a guide for future use.</p> <p>I suggest that we use the <em>Iris</em> dataset (even though it is a multiclass dataset) and simply try to separate <em>Iris setosa</em> from <em>Iris versicolor</em>.</p> <p>I provide three links. Link one is theory of application of SVMs which I thought one could use as a scaffold. Link two provides a regression example of how I was thinking our product would look in the end. Link three will take you to the <em>Iris</em> dataset.</p> <p><a href="http://sutikno.blog.undip.ac.id/files/2011/11/SVM-Explained.pdf" rel="nofollow">Theory and application of SVMs</a></p> <p><a href="http://www.cba.edu.kw/zainal/docs/220Docs/Regression%20Analysis.pdf" rel="nofollow">A guide for regressions</a></p> <p><a href="http://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/machine-learning-databases/iris/" rel="nofollow">Link for the Iris dataset</a></p> <p>Below I will try to formulate the problem more neatly.</p> <p>Problem description:</p> <blockquote> <p>How can one apply Excel and the technique of a linear support vector machine with soft margins in order to solve a binomial classification task given by separating <em>Iris setosa</em> and <em>Iris versicolor</em> from the <em>Iris</em> dataset using all available features?</p> </blockquote>
74,359
[ -0.03614088147878647, -0.0493292473256588, -0.005973311606794596, -0.005843745544552803, 0.04463033005595207, -0.013964289799332619, -0.008181849494576454, 0.006519163493067026, 0.03647255152463913, -0.004587871953845024, 0.0433766208589077, 0.03385967016220093, 0.018409622833132744, 0.0589757040143013, 0.02024262025952339, -0.00039065279997885227, 0.00012970938405487686, 0.01236432883888483, -0.006589369382709265, 0.0525466687977314, 0.005024202633649111, 0.007974503561854362, -0.006271318066865206, 0.004010911099612713, 0.015904171392321587, 0.046461671590805054, -0.00522847892716527, -0.03529109060764313, 0.0191754549741745, 0.026260534301400185, -0.028443753719329834, -0.01548857893794775, 0.0044289277866482735, 0.0366305448114872, 0.039304766803979874, 0.02559998631477356, 0.002107752952724695, -0.003025926649570465, 0.025360288098454475, 0.04264368861913681, -0.02793419361114502, 0.037511058151721954, -0.00855331402271986, 0.05814187973737717, -0.04300782084465027, 0.00368564878590405, 0.008259724825620651, -0.013812690041959286, -0.022164588794112206, -0.05228513851761818, 0.07330746948719025, 0.0018551383400335908, 0.019912632182240486, 0.05745435506105423, -0.006211313419044018, 0.00038976382347755134, 0.022471576929092407, 0.05381535738706589, 0.03879253566265106, -0.033000171184539795, 0.014512690715491772, 0.005284300539642572, -0.01939086802303791, -0.03578539565205574, -0.028296496719121933, 0.038417935371398926, 0.016650419682264328, -0.0048559317365288734, 0.047084640711545944, -0.009981918148696423, 0.013057547621428967, -0.020173458382487297, -0.0015211973804980516, -0.003291070694103837, 0.002903436776250601, -0.02050766721367836, 0.0028154058381915092, 0.025192182511091232, 0.004608839750289917, 0.019451351836323738, 0.020693227648735046, 0.010605820454657078, 0.032666344195604324, 0.03763605281710625, -0.0018534897826611996, -0.015980683267116547, 0.08105004578828812, -0.009945157915353775, 0.016226530075073242, 0.01792334020137787, -0.025579089298844337, 0.04085646569728851, 0.025160161778330803, 0.014303427189588547, -0.05000242590904236, 0.04083027318120003, -0.01867615059018135, 0.024687783792614937, 0.012625628150999546, -0.043983686715364456, 0.005799994803965092, -0.011001026257872581, 0.007124776486307383, 0.08123039454221725, -0.06667429208755493, -0.032024066895246506, -0.017519429326057434, -0.00294216675683856, -0.03343060240149498, -0.04049716144800186, -0.04151495173573494, 0.03153189644217491, 0.003564087674021721, -0.0061112078838050365, -0.010830377228558064, -0.016787318512797356, 0.03513333946466446, -0.0403287298977375, 0.01689942739903927, 0.03323984146118164, 0.04715632647275925, -0.0504729226231575, -0.006757014896720648, -0.03729971498250961, -0.031203515827655792, 0.019040143117308617, 0.023313147947192192, -0.026960080489516258, -0.03299938514828682, 0.029231956228613853, -0.01351084839552641, -0.005433717742562294, 0.020805710926651955, -0.030214106664061546, -0.01843751221895218, -0.0029509267769753933, -0.08289284259080887, -0.06990431249141693, 0.0361936092376709, -0.024561578407883644, 0.009210438467562199, -0.02578016370534897, -0.006022956222295761, 0.021350834518671036, 0.05830405279994011, 0.021238738670945168, 0.0427868589758873, 0.03316895663738251, 0.056227006018161774, 0.016501368954777718, -0.04428458586335182, 0.033854201436042786, -0.019490055739879608, -0.007835368625819683, -0.0413876548409462, -0.0642431452870369, 0.016430966556072235, 0.006456256378442049, -0.028827644884586334, 0.0000697123832651414, 0.009252399206161499, 0.022095924243330956, -0.009305845946073532, -0.03435587137937546, -0.013434451073408127, 0.01070224866271019, 0.037874042987823486, 0.02308047004044056, 0.038719359785318375, 0.01625899225473404, 0.0011287193046882749, 0.011615503579378128, 0.035458508878946304, 0.01856437884271145, 0.06486120074987411, -0.009070232510566711, 0.0056356084533035755, -0.013849928043782711, 0.025670263916254044, -0.007844510488212109, -0.061806775629520416, -0.055051058530807495, 0.014012794010341167, 0.04211010783910751, 0.024217762053012848, 0.05761409550905228, -0.0025399280712008476, -0.008992665447294712, 0.05006889998912811, -0.025821877643465996, -0.013333044946193695, -0.033607639372348785, 0.029115252196788788, -0.027231214568018913, -0.03343387693166733, 0.009604272432625294, -0.01566735841333866, -0.010799038223922253, -0.007049748674035072, -0.01577218435704708, -0.05739748105406761, 0.024557238444685936, 0.047362927347421646, -0.02899893745779991, -0.014588307589292526, 0.05051266774535179, 0.026733005419373512, -0.0640840008854866, 0.013240206055343151, -0.0379696860909462, -0.05093161761760712, -0.00040534668369218707, -0.010681280866265297, 0.04004416987299919, -0.030386032536625862, -0.016036834567785263, 0.039754267781972885, 0.013197064399719238, -0.009616591967642307, 0.02497168630361557, -0.0377192497253418, 0.04871423915028572, 0.07446929067373276, 0.03857583552598953, 0.01749010942876339, -0.0021530359517782927, 0.001893852953799069, 0.022391507402062416, 0.011372920125722885, -0.010542592033743858, -0.04776427894830704, -0.02120780013501644, 0.06445299834012985, 0.01859363541007042, -0.036596283316612244, -0.006543148774653673, 0.023523731157183647, 0.006121501792222261, 0.02824273519217968, -0.013386301696300507, -0.044901106506586075, -0.03472229838371277, 0.011871025897562504, 0.023442603647708893, -0.021174678578972816, 0.01162625290453434, 0.0011955625377595425, -0.006760899908840656, 0.033048126846551895, 0.0012011321960017085, -0.002788887359201908, 0.07638435065746307, 0.0179456640034914, -0.015356678515672684, -0.017612313851714134, -0.001865389640443027, 0.040560074150562286, -0.033504556864500046, -0.02973172813653946, 0.06001433730125427, -0.004549829289317131, -0.017801258713006973, 0.006276165600866079, 0.01126453559845686, 0.04045115411281586, 0.030916694551706314, -0.002910478273406625, 0.010130002163350582, 0.015658671036362648, -0.05185119807720184, 0.03254071623086929, -0.011510469019412994, -0.034457094967365265, -0.05883943662047386, 0.029872434213757515, 0.010418024845421314, -0.0126885287463665, 0.010384613648056984, -0.0006180444033816457, -0.005656046327203512, 0.014634672552347183, -0.01712886057794094, 0.03552764281630516, -0.013686423189938068, -0.05349091440439224, -0.0002770047285594046, -0.02715734951198101, -0.03774695098400116, 0.04637692868709564, 0.0008156329859048128, -0.04483336955308914, 0.022795120254158974, -0.015087819658219814, -0.06057056784629822, -0.041549138724803925, -0.037827398627996445, 0.0029561975970864296, -0.022358017042279243, -0.026564855128526688, 0.032388702034950256, -0.016165656968951225, -0.07697649300098419, 0.017080049961805344, -0.012373801320791245, -0.048234689980745316, -0.042499516159296036, -0.019251815974712372, -0.016170218586921692, -0.016341693699359894, -0.018331460654735565, 0.0013308587949723005, 0.011757804080843925, -0.002493871608749032, -0.04734054580330849, -0.03137033432722092, 0.021338636055588722, -0.0019707134924829006, 0.027921419590711594, 0.0205144714564085, 0.011424193158745766, 0.10295017808675766, 0.034495484083890915, -0.03618757054209709, -0.046197809278964996, -0.006018343381583691, -0.008902665227651596, -0.008272076025605202, 0.027889663353562355, 0.021862084046006203, 0.003954119980335236, 0.004122976213693619, -0.03602004423737526, 0.008902261964976788, 0.07144488394260406, -0.0029236094560474157, 0.008790383115410805, 0.034385908395051956, -0.03438592702150345, -0.02720416709780693, 0.060948774218559265, 0.03301217034459114, -0.00002817593667714391, 0.017203880473971367, -0.012303091585636139, 0.0031846852507442236, 0.00762664619833231, -0.05006078630685806, 0.010181485675275326, 0.0012595690786838531, 0.018420781940221786, -0.023456422612071037, -0.0067026447504758835, 0.020655205473303795, -0.03994990885257721, 0.03095107153058052, -0.0319882370531559, 0.019258011132478714, -0.030877677723765373, -0.030159424990415573, 0.033419400453567505, 0.06481260061264038, -0.00009350557229481637, -0.020901992917060852, -0.03638329729437828, -0.011419660411775112, 0.03108900971710682, -0.03565666452050209, 0.010562518611550331, 0.06022778898477554, 0.06012740731239319, 0.004526819102466106, 0.0038435717578977346, -0.03960550203919411, -0.0017921732505783439, -0.07179190218448639, -0.027870742604136467, -0.04377516359090805, 0.05188761278986931, 0.0032363629434257746, -0.011985513381659985, -0.011155621148645878, -0.01807352714240551, 0.042107295244932175, 0.012863032519817352, -0.05932151898741722, 0.02325788326561451, 0.0022214462514966726, 0.0038767836522310972, 0.009952322579920292, -0.017146779224276543, 0.05191062018275261, -0.042358625680208206, -0.012145333923399448, -0.055742427706718445, 0.01996222697198391, -0.03645709529519081, 0.03837312385439873, 0.009693007916212082, 0.005824059713631868, 0.02479458972811699, 0.012246488593518734, 0.0072943465784192085, -0.04177379608154297, -0.005768158473074436, 0.011440814472734928, -0.019902806729078293, -0.01312638632953167, -0.02615920640528202, 0.011704839766025543, 0.03367527574300766, 0.013612722977995872, 0.024348439648747444, 0.007508981507271528, -0.06858650594949722, 0.050548139959573746, -0.003403915325179696, 0.020469313487410545, 0.05430116876959801, -0.016023222357034683, -0.030661163851618767, -0.036088187247514725, -0.016838157549500465, 0.01810639351606369, 0.031198322772979736, -0.0060692355036735535, 0.012757141143083572, 0.0718579962849617, 0.03084074705839157, -0.056533247232437134, -0.008365914225578308, 0.016407044604420662, 0.0092861857265234, 0.04015535116195679, -0.02611011080443859, -0.007359613198786974, -0.006013461388647556, -0.015609337948262691, 0.04374388977885246, 0.0206131748855114, 0.0020101869013160467, -0.020899007096886635, 0.021175827831029892, -0.03682760149240494, -0.07469184696674347, 0.01035542692989111, 0.031109649688005447, 0.026470154523849487, -0.018113773316144943, -0.017463210970163345, -0.010735027492046356, 0.05328606814146042, 0.05180652067065239, -0.018313733860850334, 0.03300761058926582, -0.11528957635164261, -0.05086605250835419, 0.0648171603679657, 0.04191174358129501, -0.055140480399131775, 0.004288111813366413, -0.04361123964190483, -0.049832794815301895, 0.02809116430580616, -0.02329624816775322, 0.04761689528822899, 0.016444114968180656, 0.019016247242689133, -0.02693050540983677, -0.010809271596372128, -0.03613544628024101, 0.02558375522494316, -0.02707640267908573, 0.05236993357539177, 0.00477456022053957, -0.02433386817574501, -0.04150955006480217, -0.006197243928909302, 0.006852237042039633, 0.037065476179122925, 0.016597174108028412, -0.024904558435082436, 0.007775087840855122, -0.006836002226918936, -0.007028418593108654, -0.047677043825387955, -0.00759528111666441, 0.0016581111121922731, -0.030125677585601807, 0.04680120572447777, -0.015796570107340813, -0.06492292135953903, 0.031143201515078545, 0.03457372263073921, -0.04264041781425476, -0.015069044195115566, -0.02892208844423294, 0.0205971859395504, 0.03598048537969589, 0.024852752685546875, 0.04916248098015785, 0.01713775284588337, -0.004303246736526489, 0.015460265800356865, -0.04426523298025131, -0.016528906300663948, 0.008131680078804493, -0.05877833068370819, -0.03630781173706055, -0.004290599841624498, -0.015054113231599331, 0.04573250934481621, 0.028438961133360863, 0.007011394016444683, -0.046428706496953964, -0.014236342161893845, -0.027845147997140884, 0.023860935121774673, -0.028728140518069267, -0.022275403141975403, 0.011525426991283894, 0.02196108177304268, -0.0020211043301969767, -0.01120276190340519, 0.03949182108044624, -0.013578097335994244, 0.023738553747534752, 0.05503402277827263, -0.059135258197784424, 0.015237739309668541, -0.013349485583603382, -0.019049087539315224, -0.001413269666954875, -0.003313916502520442, 0.07746068388223648, -0.026700038462877274, 0.0674346461892128, 0.023509379476308823, -0.015361281111836433, -0.03600078821182251, 0.014165841042995453, 0.011071089655160904, 0.01765124313533306, -0.0003557906311471015, -0.003137084888294339, 0.01581580750644207, -0.0340564139187336, -0.037071600556373596, -0.009156541898846626, 0.0021710607688874006, -0.01119700726121664, -0.029383650049567223, -0.02911180444061756, 0.012540530413389206, -0.005618550814688206, -0.055129580199718475, 0.01684235781431198, 0.04714711382985115, -0.06729292124509811, 0.0030151016544550657, -0.01033712737262249, -0.009031733497977257, 0.09121625870466232, -0.013736892491579056, 0.005978361703455448, -0.0026294158305972815, -0.019356759265065193, -0.0023528998717665672, 0.04033096507191658, 0.0220887940376997, -0.021594306454062462, -0.014556567184627056, -0.06177164614200592, 0.024813275784254074, 0.030658908188343048, -0.0030642098281532526, 0.031170455738902092, 0.003940180409699678, -0.0054844520054757595, 0.02750561200082302, -0.02399730682373047, 0.007343583274632692, 0.023733966052532196, -0.017522476613521576, -0.007411576341837645, 0.01817992702126503, -0.002167419996112585, 0.035324279218912125, -0.0008800782379694283, -0.018332766368985176, -0.004140655975788832, 0.0028409541118890047, 0.07117703557014465, -0.027045750990509987, 0.03406323119997978, -0.0031025665812194347, -0.012147865258157253, 0.03755448758602142, -0.012816477566957474, 0.03620360419154167, -0.005837185308337212, 0.02260931394994259, -0.032407332211732864, 0.0023270579986274242, -0.07034185528755188, 0.009873408824205399, 0.034502554684877396, 0.003820105455815792, 0.04857436195015907, 0.042817261070013046, 0.001980668166652322, 0.010781390592455864, -0.059126272797584534, 0.004702103324234486, -0.009346016682684422, -0.018313704058527946, 0.051204998046159744, -0.00328473630361259, -0.01260906457901001, 0.06119251623749733, 0.022248024120926857, -0.01602073945105076, 0.04432503134012222, 0.03521953895688057, -0.006602564360946417, 0.03851357102394104, -0.05784158036112785, -0.040480297058820724, 0.027434688061475754, -0.002192452782765031, -0.003250849200412631, 0.021898766979575157, 0.0018817587988451123, 0.04459170624613762, 0.015497463755309582, 0.00954838190227747, -0.06619393080472946, -0.013270338997244835, -0.0535525344312191, 0.02582826465368271, 0.007713040336966515, -0.040053535252809525, 0.007317000534385443, 0.016763072460889816, 0.027978437021374702, -0.025123896077275276, 0.04971279203891754, -0.03253883495926857, -0.04970845952630043, 0.004230490420013666, -0.04468657076358795, -0.060012880712747574, 0.05237812548875809, 0.011922067031264305, -0.056222543120384216, -0.0023901474196463823, -0.03861529007554054, 0.04749744385480881, -0.000403223792091012, 0.03727637231349945, 0.010261922143399715, 0.049218181520700455, -0.037286411970853806, -0.005229179281741381, 0.03470459580421448, -0.022868940606713295, 0.13531506061553955, 0.08808888494968414, 0.035294972360134125, -0.04827113449573517, 0.03545723110437393, 0.041207730770111084, 0.02326786518096924, -0.020042411983013153, -0.0013543445384129882, -0.018085576593875885, -0.029350178316235542, 0.0006017587729729712, 0.0051019093953073025, -0.01055820845067501, -0.014156930148601532, 0.028178628534078598, -0.029376260936260223, -0.008858714252710342, -0.008979314006865025, 0.009800338186323643, 0.0052578202448785305, -0.005064783152192831, -0.07363098114728928, 0.0351061187684536, 0.001385632436722517, -0.05985566973686218, -0.03834078088402748, -0.01417568325996399, 0.02996852435171604, -0.028766730800271034, -0.01897742599248886, -0.009555419906973839, 0.03177209943532944, 0.004834051243960857, 0.0020800004713237286, 0.013559702783823013, 0.0203192550688982, -0.04237660765647888, 0.014492684043943882, 0.05751460790634155, 0.026401517912745476, -0.0035819862969219685, 0.03202714025974274, 0.007898204028606415, -0.05987609177827835, -0.023741833865642548, -0.06368786841630936, 0.07037483155727386, 0.014962815679609776, -0.05019749328494072, -0.0017376559553667903, 0.006688171066343784, 0.01632840186357498, -0.01698567159473896, -0.015446689911186695, 0.03475605696439743, 0.02801070734858513, -0.005107649601995945, -0.006509408820420504, -0.002679231343790889, 0.024558663368225098, -0.03053603321313858, 0.029985902830958366, 0.04313986748456955, -0.05029549077153206, -0.013817824423313141, -0.0455654114484787, 0.002058787504211068, 0.009527690708637238, -0.008099311031401157, -0.017236584797501564, -0.042689498513936996, 0.006572209298610687, -0.006709788925945759, 0.0023232323583215475, 0.011570210568606853, -0.0063123684376478195, -0.03939178213477135, -0.01838371902704239, -0.018439725041389465, -0.05741870775818825, 0.026039564982056618, -0.01610126532614231, -0.009657364338636398, -0.03204459324479103, 0.009634776972234249, 0.024768995121121407, 0.029960868880152702, 0.027202604338526726, 0.011014070361852646, 0.022805113345384598, 0.016000380739569664, 0.02395639568567276, -0.036596812307834625, -0.021616673097014427, -0.009264876134693623, -0.013468571938574314, 0.013696485199034214, -0.003682401031255722, 0.023639529943466187, 0.02991204895079136, 0.022622138261795044, 0.012518089264631271, 0.03456087037920952, 0.01919163577258587, 0.010365721769630909, -0.026622842997312546, -0.05001801997423172, 0.04620373994112015, 0.011989200487732887, 0.0011279928730800748, -0.037399772554636, -0.013502934016287327, -0.01539947371929884, -0.015544737689197063, 0.01924164593219757, -0.033530138432979584, -0.03358883783221245, 0.026033908128738403, -0.040905170142650604, 0.041838597506284714, -0.03697307035326958, -0.009250819683074951, -0.007407683413475752, 0.020564287900924683, -0.029185613617300987, -0.032438505440950394, -0.0012751364847645164, -0.0031760118436068296, 0.017581762745976448, 0.01389214675873518, 0.04617727920413017, -0.0018547866493463516, 0.014564628712832928, -0.007545065134763718, 0.03290419280529022, -0.021332355216145515, 0.03936028108000755, 0.001499565434642136, -0.022303925827145576, -0.002391129732131958, -0.05656741186976433, -0.0036419741809368134, 0.009107023477554321, -0.0416780523955822, 0.01326341275125742, 0.02107718400657177, -0.005974349565804005, -0.026848213747143745, 0.04395000636577606, 0.011234491132199764, -0.0031811532098799944, 0.004330317489802837, 0.0037534558214247227, 0.02334088459610939, 0.02460584044456482, -0.00016823792248032987, 0.006780682131648064, -0.04685167968273163, 0.010217948816716671, 0.014819425530731678, -0.0015652956208214164, -0.022089798003435135, 0.03194976970553398, -0.020466117188334465, -0.008915390819311142, 0.007501489482820034, -0.02079741656780243, 0.062049176543951035, 0.04432119429111481, -0.048782382160425186, 0.04558712616562843, -0.00330320349894464, 0.046122848987579346, -0.08154486864805222, -0.0023637833073735237, 0.010469192638993263, 0.035261426120996475, 0.025784647092223167, -0.05631542578339577, 0.035132165998220444, 0.02568022347986698, 0.005650872830301523, 0.00583299994468689, 0.002919392194598913, 0.008690950460731983, 0.00766703300178051, -0.010403274558484554, -0.05160421505570412, 0.012109490111470222, 0.024136193096637726, 0.01578516513109207, 0.0262131430208683, 0.03503383323550224, -0.03306162357330322, -0.02323056012392044, -0.016571510583162308, 0.035239387303590775, -0.006680641323328018, -0.011949636042118073, 0.05262405797839165, -0.013296018354594707, -0.005554039962589741, 0.005475881043821573, 0.025003978982567787, 0.03646555170416832, 0.07202940434217453, 0.016132144257426262, -0.006325398571789265, 0.05392418056726456, 0.01887870579957962, 0.010003115981817245, -0.0045790602453053, -0.025481797754764557, 0.019217293709516525, 0.017673751339316368, -0.007074997294694185, 0.013516607694327831, 0.03288900479674339, 0.009354726411402225, 0.002415809314697981, 0.016081642359495163, -0.05028339847922325, -0.043640509247779846, -0.00006505378405563533, 0.00250939535908401, 0.007817158475518227, -0.011776297353208065, 0.023427557200193405, -0.06301416456699371, -0.02370847761631012, -0.01129690371453762, 0.014483761973679066, -0.01815710961818695, 0.028656981885433197, 0.003419276559725404, -0.03501560911536217, 0.008595073595643044, -0.026009006425738335, -0.02998889423906803, -0.06191041320562363, -0.002342699095606804, 0.029323259368538857, -0.030306726694107056, -0.08591154217720032, 0.022576207295060158, -0.0039931172505021095, 0.05799493193626404, -0.007454161997884512, 0.023948868736624718, 0.007280605845153332, -0.007722601760178804, 0.010311937890946865, -0.0817776620388031, 0.06023623049259186, 0.026640795171260834, -0.02888200432062149, -0.026932822540402412, -0.013850126415491104, -0.02273135632276535, -0.01659388840198517, 0.049005936831235886, -0.02799874357879162, 0.023400912061333656, -0.02368566021323204, 0.009042014367878437, 0.015118403360247612, -0.04824170842766762, 0.02733978070318699, 0.021540943533182144, -0.04151903837919235, -0.021723803132772446, -0.013982542790472507, 0.0016241467092186213, 0.009562477469444275, 0.03395473212003708, -0.017857296392321587, -0.03456038236618042, 0.03506980836391449, 0.0009209885611198843, 0.0009312678594142199, 0.018894722685217857, 0.011752936989068985, 0.025174647569656372, 0.018018795177340508, 0.006812488194555044, 0.034737057983875275, 0.006195573136210442, -0.0553329661488533, 0.02070697210729122, -0.0342341773211956, -0.012020681984722614, -0.018247855827212334, -0.009557469747960567, 0.0070595708675682545, -0.07146342098712921, -0.005779594648629427, 0.035260237753391266, 0.016830816864967346, 0.011106269434094429, 0.0176839642226696, -0.02590338885784149, 0.0201351810246706, 0.015211055986583233, 0.037000250071287155, -0.005251796450465918, -0.030750298872590065, 0.030965100973844528, -0.024888386949896812, 0.020830435678362846, 0.002837719861418009, 0.006035541649907827, 0.06520603597164154, -0.014470214955508709, 0.01078991312533617, 0.0023545140866190195, -0.01162766758352518, -0.050363291054964066, -0.007743449416011572, 0.001783258281648159, 0.01703563705086708, -0.02983907237648964, 0.005848654080182314, -0.017922241240739822, 0.061793114989995956, -0.052220992743968964, 0.004982877057045698, -0.056786928325891495, 0.02263096533715725, -0.03145309165120125, 0.008666489273309708, 0.01247000228613615, 0.042463269084692, 0.010416337288916111, 0.006990046706050634, 0.029856299981474876, -0.013521231710910797, 0.06898919492959976, 0.007443004287779331, -0.012398853898048401, 0.013306809589266777, -0.009363621473312378, -0.013168368488550186, -0.013541409745812416, 0.004662282299250364, -0.019013263285160065, 0.005670316517353058, 0.042322661727666855, -0.015831394121050835, 0.004447006620466709, -0.008234015665948391, -0.002407533349469304, 0.05901124328374863, -0.06035014986991882, -0.024226423352956772, -0.030018767341971397, -0.006974890828132629, -0.019380157813429832, -0.040281347930431366 ]
<p>I have a set of results of independent measurements of some physical quantity. As an example I give here real expermental data on methanol refractive index at 25 degrees Celsius published in scientific literature from 1960 to 2011:</p> <pre><code>data={{1960, 1.32652}, {1961, 1.32662}, {1963, 1.32650}, {1963, 1.32750}, {1968, 1.32698}, {1968, 1.32890}, {1970, 1.32657}, {1970, 1.32660}, {1971, 1.3260}, {1971, 1.32610}, {1971, 1.32630}, {1971, 1.3350}, {1972, 1.32640}, {1972, 1.32661}, {1973, 1.32860}, {1975, 1.32515}, {1975, 1.32641}, {1976, 1.32663}, {1977, 1.32670}, {1980, 1.3250}, {1983, 1.32850}, {1985, 1.32653}, {1991, 1.32710}, {1995, 1.32621}, {1995, 1.32676}, {1996, 1.32601}, {1996, 1.32645}, {1996, 1.32715}, {1998, 1.32820}, {1999, 1.32730}, {1999, 1.32780}, {2001, 1.32634}, {2006, 1.32620}, {2011, 1.32667}}; </code></pre> <p>The first number is the year of first publication, the second is the published value. The authors do not always provide their own estimate for error of the published value and even when they do this, the published estimate is often not accurate.</p> <p>It is easy to see that the distribution is asymmetrical (other datasets I work with are even more asymmetrical). Here is a density histogram with bins selected by hands:</p> <pre><code>bins = {1.325, 1.3259, 1.3261, 1.3263, 1.3265, 1.3266, 1.3267, 1.3269, 1.3275, 1.328}; Histogram[dataFirst[[All, 2]], {bins}, "PDF"] </code></pre> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/x4lne.png" alt="histogram"></p> <p>Because of asymmetric feature of the distribution I cannot use the mean as an estimate for the true value of methanol refractive index. </p> <p>The fact is that the probability to get smaller value than the true value in general is not equal to the probability to get higher value. This means that the median in general is also unsuitable.</p> <p>It may be assumed that each invidual measurement has normal distribution for the instrumental error of the measurement. Additional sources of error are impurities in methanol. The most common impurity is water which increases the refractive index, but authors usually dry methanol before measurement. Probably this is the reason why the density is higher for low values: other impurities such as some common organic solvents (benzene) and (possibly) diluted gases (methane, carbon oxide, carbon dioxide) lower the refractive index. From the other hand alcohols, aldehydes and ketones which may present in industrial methanol and some organic solvents (CCl4) increase the refractive index. So there at least two sources of error: one (instrumental) may be assumed normally distributed and even equal for the all measurements and the second (impurities) is probably asymmetrical (and may be even bimodal) and depends on how methanol was obtained and purified.</p> <p>What is the best way to estimate the true value and its 95% confidence bands for the measured quantity in such cases? </p> <p>P.S. References for relevant scientific papers will be appreciated.</p> <p>P.S.2. The above code is for <em>Mathematica</em> system.</p>
74,360
[ -0.024940961971879005, -0.03619089722633362, 0.009314115159213543, -0.041040074080228806, 0.025639094412326813, 0.011969022452831268, -0.037393346428871155, 0.022921472787857056, -0.026707297191023827, -0.006373378913849592, 0.1093946024775505, 0.027765097096562386, 0.04466351494193077, 0.04821653291583061, 0.048884209245443344, 0.009126312099397182, -0.014115141704678535, 0.024077927693724632, 0.01190398819744587, 0.00451558455824852, 0.015474011190235615, 0.02738410234451294, -0.0076240235939621925, -0.019126620143651962, -0.020957719534635544, 0.01627020537853241, -0.026923533529043198, -0.02001260221004486, 0.02388482168316841, 0.060493163764476776, -0.06606990844011307, -0.03866200894117355, 0.04036906734108925, -0.0012375081423670053, 0.04260870814323425, 0.0212351456284523, -0.010118836537003517, -0.042253974825143814, -0.03177938237786293, 0.03668857365846634, -0.04904879629611969, 0.011223465204238892, 0.008534573949873447, 0.046973466873168945, 0.02604413591325283, 0.025581488385796547, 0.027498532086610794, -0.020813507959246635, 0.0333767794072628, -0.028216829523444176, 0.05693458020687103, 0.00007138795626815408, 0.032957810908555984, 0.056624885648489, -0.045185964554548264, -0.014179102145135403, 0.03177911043167114, 0.06628606468439102, 0.006870071403682232, -0.0781714916229248, 0.008346057496964931, -0.010218292474746704, 0.0047469232231378555, -0.007637800648808479, 0.005639249924570322, -0.005398339591920376, -0.028576014563441277, -0.03873467445373535, 0.01972191035747528, -0.019787685945630074, -0.009384933859109879, 0.0048792860470712185, -0.008108066394925117, 0.004538969602435827, 0.01964026875793934, 0.007071617990732193, -0.015287443064153194, 0.010001596063375473, 0.04089752212166786, 0.03599390760064125, -0.004572584293782711, -0.008325415663421154, 0.033209603279829025, -0.010851199738681316, 0.009398527443408966, -0.027842320501804352, 0.08438745886087418, -0.027543989941477776, 0.021891586482524872, -0.007199014071375132, -0.005508755333721638, -0.015187068842351437, 0.010303561575710773, 0.017209401354193687, -0.009427354671061039, 0.012202121317386627, -0.0038082937244325876, 0.018847931176424026, -0.01787867210805416, -0.055342771112918854, -0.008891833946108818, -0.019951535388827324, -0.0006638759514316916, 0.05631745979189873, -0.017138974741101265, -0.057253118604421616, -0.02199769951403141, -0.05138188600540161, -0.04142571985721588, -0.017220791429281235, 0.00490213930606842, -0.0026960447430610657, 0.0032115832436829805, 0.00942990742623806, 0.027372658252716064, -0.03354456648230553, 0.014414745382964611, -0.0010438183089718223, 0.056932248175144196, 0.04372540861368179, 0.033358391374349594, -0.010926030576229095, 0.025050202384591103, -0.026222441345453262, -0.055371303111314774, 0.03491237387061119, 0.061882469803094864, -0.00070456403773278, -0.003560581710189581, 0.025257715955376625, -0.00028842012397944927, 0.01632385142147541, 0.05584587901830673, -0.025467045605182648, 0.01789219118654728, 0.03733666613698006, -0.041117046028375626, -0.06845942884683609, 0.02984236553311348, 0.019791465252637863, 0.0007574079209007323, -0.07801005989313126, 0.036643583327531815, 0.032997578382492065, 0.06193738803267479, 0.03137602657079697, 0.007642094045877457, 0.012625390663743019, 0.09376195818185806, 0.001206709654070437, -0.005640946328639984, -0.0008327672840096056, 0.02521957829594612, -0.025689972564578056, -0.05678096413612366, -0.06054366007447243, 0.007366715930402279, -0.017133021727204323, 0.003946615848690271, 0.020637117326259613, 0.0071509783156216145, -0.01476071123033762, 0.006165079306811094, -0.03868890181183815, -0.016224617138504982, -0.05549638345837593, 0.12216641008853912, 0.01998082548379898, 0.011740566231310368, 0.019771380349993706, -0.03317414969205856, 0.016940802335739136, 0.002935132710263133, -0.014711598865687847, 0.08093404024839401, -0.013940674252808094, 0.021874994039535522, 0.008231466636061668, -0.009632504545152187, 0.011361042968928814, -0.02873665653169155, -0.020709063857793808, -0.021060092374682426, -0.007674406748265028, 0.009194709360599518, 0.012115678749978542, 0.024778343737125397, -0.015965474769473076, 0.03425419703125954, -0.0866011306643486, -0.013170704245567322, -0.02422867715358734, 0.004266930744051933, -0.018567876890301704, -0.02089536003768444, 0.034451086074113846, -0.013678321614861488, -0.03863007575273514, 0.002855208469554782, -0.02541979029774666, -0.00035061759990639985, 0.0022473440039902925, 0.060349877923727036, -0.030982645228505135, 0.00038348708767443895, 0.04616817459464073, 0.047917429357767105, 0.0006582041387446225, 0.03958327695727348, -0.010353117249906063, 0.0016766011249274015, 0.019814202561974525, -0.059683095663785934, -0.017734086140990257, -0.021519329398870468, -0.008430657908320427, -0.016246188431978226, 0.018997566774487495, -0.021756326779723167, -0.012669689953327179, -0.010820364579558372, 0.01653190329670906, 0.06415114551782608, 0.008488425053656101, 0.03226751461625099, 0.032381217926740646, -0.004803168121725321, 0.03679149970412254, -0.006724952720105648, -0.02068924531340599, -0.0669824406504631, 0.012538548558950424, 0.0049719191156327724, 0.05443568900227547, -0.03518691286444664, 0.008953624404966831, 0.04613922908902168, 0.019316228106617928, 0.025525877252221107, -0.025262795388698578, -0.03220159560441971, -0.05043713003396988, 0.05193495750427246, 0.0012150697875767946, 0.007796477992087603, 0.002085439395159483, 0.0009255618206225336, 0.02441607043147087, 0.027768732979893684, 0.00037042691837996244, 0.03148668631911278, -0.0024111277889460325, -0.038368333131074905, -0.05304061248898506, -0.016837475821375847, 0.010538621805608273, -0.008307809010148048, 0.0009147516684606671, 0.012195389717817307, 0.04318678379058838, -0.009240294806659222, 0.01763232797384262, -0.03500998020172119, -0.04150661826133728, 0.006584153510630131, 0.04925402253866196, -0.07371070981025696, -0.01624937355518341, 0.023054787889122963, -0.027654647827148438, 0.015010503120720387, -0.01404839288443327, -0.04933125153183937, -0.00883349310606718, 0.031875260174274445, 0.018712850287556648, 0.05409305542707443, -0.01136836502701044, 0.0016936790198087692, -0.0027240233030170202, -0.01040861289948225, 0.021603619679808617, 0.060794662684202194, 0.012099065817892551, -0.02462044358253479, 0.0034383246675133705, 0.00633371714502573, 0.00005218826845521107, 0.037722889333963394, 0.018916239961981773, -0.08255274593830109, 0.0488610714673996, 0.010123099200427532, -0.012239319272339344, -0.016390085220336914, -0.00954960286617279, -0.0034241373650729656, -0.025051170960068703, 0.021953973919153214, 0.03885427862405777, -0.01941540092229843, -0.029035363346338272, 0.012103695422410965, -0.03433595970273018, -0.024465881288051605, -0.0049862926825881, -0.027732234448194504, -0.006495105568319559, 0.03015744499862194, 0.011783492751419544, 0.03183101490139961, 0.025957591831684113, -0.042367126792669296, -0.05015372857451439, -0.06485603004693985, -0.0296692606061697, -0.03304629027843475, 0.031761329621076584, -0.013766508549451828, 0.015638383105397224, 0.022299684584140778, 0.02942052111029625, -0.05236222967505455, 0.013719026930630207, 0.028811750933527946, -0.024972328916192055, -0.017125746235251427, 0.032588981091976166, 0.02390017732977867, 0.02702292427420616, 0.021311728283762932, -0.007919559255242348, 0.02752752974629402, 0.0481899194419384, -0.01103222370147705, 0.029757509008049965, 0.0435965321958065, 0.04579370841383934, -0.051018133759498596, 0.01630582846701145, 0.018623333424329758, -0.022869352251291275, -0.010090072639286518, 0.007123840507119894, 0.027972541749477386, 0.0328206866979599, -0.0611274391412735, 0.02920931950211525, -0.02128085494041443, 0.034572843462228775, -0.01411785464733839, 0.03138666972517967, 0.011741346679627895, -0.05018634349107742, -0.050708070397377014, 0.028240647166967392, 0.018688911572098732, -0.0066269091330468655, -0.011161932721734047, 0.020511260256171227, 0.01848343014717102, -0.0409698486328125, -0.014477239921689034, -0.03472154960036278, -0.021753935143351555, 0.05567357689142227, -0.04173737391829491, 0.006796322762966156, 0.025537587702274323, 0.04461648687720299, 0.010671394877135754, -0.03330941125750542, -0.026154574006795883, 0.007059080526232719, -0.030973918735980988, -0.012635034509003162, -0.0535016693174839, 0.035324256867170334, 0.025258418172597885, 0.022956503555178642, -0.0265171118080616, 0.010725505650043488, -0.019544685259461403, 0.002471023704856634, -0.044663719832897186, 0.007329782471060753, -0.006492903456091881, -0.010462634265422821, -0.04160241037607193, -0.030127812176942825, 0.03360016644001007, -0.03284401819109917, 0.006103483960032463, -0.006761858705431223, 0.03915175050497055, -0.04511479660868645, 0.008496355265378952, 0.0011449046432971954, -0.03832148388028145, -0.03279390558600426, 0.017415251582860947, 0.01388007402420044, -0.021535953506827354, 0.052890580147504807, 0.019377615302801132, 0.027045248076319695, -0.028411434963345528, -0.06747374683618546, 0.009745538234710693, 0.02559996210038662, 0.03217420354485512, 0.004586583934724331, 0.013475228101015091, -0.04463719576597214, 0.019786592572927475, 0.03448590636253357, 0.010503636673092842, 0.07713587582111359, 0.010541493073105812, 0.011237013153731823, 0.010949160903692245, 0.000761207367759198, 0.001071716658771038, 0.002008241368457675, -0.0104128522798419, 0.02261003479361534, -0.018665015697479248, 0.003947476856410503, 0.008501292206346989, 0.006936074700206518, 0.02221912145614624, -0.010270833037793636, 0.015291234478354454, -0.0188638623803854, -0.019156360998749733, -0.012055331841111183, 0.010084109380841255, -0.00636722706258297, 0.06916645914316177, 0.0060380129143595695, 0.005095003638416529, 0.02523542195558548, 0.01995849609375, -0.07134248316287994, 0.017318101599812508, 0.047837212681770325, -0.0018168985843658447, -0.036404840648174286, -0.008181489072740078, 0.0331488661468029, 0.03133346885442734, 0.046818457543849945, -0.011710806749761105, 0.0008333356818184257, -0.07116344571113586, -0.011275996454060078, 0.03756336867809296, 0.06180102750658989, -0.04652484878897667, 0.007195818237960339, -0.08797580748796463, 0.012282917276024818, 0.039965517818927765, -0.012644420377910137, 0.03758787363767624, -0.010963027365505695, 0.04138847440481186, -0.027198398485779762, -0.030263885855674744, -0.06788382679224014, 0.02298908680677414, -0.0002767695114016533, -0.01838095299899578, -0.038426660001277924, -0.014749104157090187, -0.03675154596567154, -0.0025197823997586966, 0.010071160271763802, 0.05262894928455353, -0.04890168085694313, -0.028816262260079384, 0.000031447380024474114, -0.014229534193873405, -0.014106827788054943, -0.05446941405534744, 0.027911093086004257, 0.004033296834677458, 0.016855886206030846, 0.057071883231401443, -0.018611721694469452, -0.037651177495718, 0.04891590029001236, 0.005706269294023514, -0.021732164546847343, -0.006607339717447758, 0.007513958495110273, 0.058470044285058975, 0.011043949984014034, 0.025958850979804993, 0.06131963059306145, 0.08629254251718521, -0.002679992699995637, 0.042679544538259506, -0.09315399080514908, -0.014970744960010052, -0.035775989294052124, -0.005128930788487196, -0.06595737487077713, -0.005587729159742594, -0.04278897866606712, 0.010511305183172226, -0.009980438277125359, 0.008263472467660904, -0.0022739770356565714, -0.010352082550525665, 0.015908924862742424, 0.05175165459513664, -0.020487096160650253, 0.009844401851296425, 0.006520062685012817, -0.0021536301355808973, -0.011031338945031166, 0.020202811807394028, -0.009924439713358879, -0.0061093405820429325, 0.022366581484675407, -0.007392398081719875, -0.025453057140111923, 0.03067055344581604, -0.045792654156684875, -0.02970840223133564, -0.01715470664203167, -0.025846220552921295, 0.017929479479789734, 0.0023812998551875353, 0.054615069180727005, 0.03924799710512161, -0.03948460519313812, -0.0111409155651927, 0.001594336237758398, -0.00492303678765893, 0.010274608619511127, -0.05443963035941124, -0.03870765492320061, 0.01330728828907013, 0.03207297623157501, -0.07313036918640137, 0.0011687850346788764, 0.05068616941571236, 0.011835184879601002, -0.029742447659373283, -0.017258718609809875, -0.01492199394851923, 0.019400211051106453, -0.01505318284034729, 0.006785281002521515, 0.02914314530789852, 0.005298350937664509, -0.05383652448654175, -0.023824438452720642, -0.0026343525387346745, 0.052944909781217575, -0.06026628613471985, 0.026586145162582397, 0.0025926423259079456, -0.03227126970887184, -0.006433313712477684, 0.028047239407896996, -0.018623756244778633, -0.023017704486846924, -0.02346172370016575, -0.05233999341726303, -0.0019061192870140076, 0.036598384380340576, -0.010016568936407566, -0.010698193684220314, 0.008277131244540215, -0.011953816749155521, 0.008812366984784603, 0.000004391794391267467, -0.021440252661705017, -0.0069043864496052265, -0.001038671238347888, -0.03458261489868164, -0.001161540625616908, -0.009275318123400211, -0.0055229077115654945, -0.014918386936187744, -0.005812218878418207, -0.04144531860947609, 0.039707958698272705, 0.06480739265680313, -0.009623882360756397, 0.015330907888710499, -0.0001966587151400745, -0.024160992354154587, -0.010851610451936722, 0.015361477620899677, -0.023407146334648132, 0.005284275859594345, 0.022934377193450928, 0.002927107736468315, -0.0067539275623857975, -0.04862918332219124, -0.01011041272431612, 0.07279723137617111, 0.025283198803663254, 0.04954468086361885, 0.04037734866142273, 0.007722516544163227, 0.008465771563351154, -0.0010141803650185466, -0.032027553766965866, 0.03094160370528698, -0.024963216856122017, 0.05325685068964958, -0.03220045194029808, -0.013887112960219383, 0.03875916451215744, 0.02534407563507557, -0.021365921944379807, 0.0030514902900904417, -0.03232520818710327, 0.024530138820409775, 0.002810434438288212, -0.040273506194353104, -0.02207515947520733, 0.0474831648170948, -0.02638179622590542, 0.004631436429917812, 0.017746057361364365, -0.023556174710392952, -0.0013403479242697358, 0.03734765201807022, -0.03685350343585014, -0.04253716766834259, -0.02477543242275715, -0.05048606917262077, 0.01882183365523815, 0.03374893590807915, -0.004259005654603243, 0.016467001289129257, -0.008624487556517124, -0.02221943624317646, 0.03585316613316536, 0.01611964963376522, -0.023008495569229126, -0.049378782510757446, -0.013263336382806301, -0.014696793630719185, -0.07286468148231506, 0.07030855119228363, -0.023760447278618813, -0.04098500311374664, 0.008861850947141647, 0.014950177632272243, 0.05224880948662758, 0.025894872844219208, -0.01656804233789444, 0.01359483227133751, 0.08350002765655518, -0.013699144124984741, 0.0028678972739726305, -0.019573861733078957, -0.028884494677186012, 0.15893857181072235, 0.08126669377088547, 0.060644082725048065, -0.04126180335879326, 0.00335611030459404, 0.04108657315373421, 0.006431904621422291, -0.030655790120363235, -0.0005023378762416542, -0.00859115645289421, 0.002560092369094491, 0.02226921357214451, 0.02899206057190895, 0.01674536056816578, 0.02288239821791649, 0.012257841415703297, -0.038257963955402374, -0.00030400921241380274, -0.0031754521187394857, 0.0344531387090683, 0.014500096440315247, 0.008759656921029091, -0.053487520664930344, 0.0013371401000767946, 0.02266662009060383, 0.013936517760157585, -0.030060475692152977, -0.04037825018167496, -0.0024827432353049517, 0.03733747825026512, -0.030416950583457947, 0.022452635690569878, 0.057550981640815735, 0.028289226815104485, 0.009866796433925629, -0.002807385055348277, 0.028037870302796364, -0.010218797251582146, 0.0119931036606431, 0.01919584535062313, -0.00024236319586634636, 0.0027132767718285322, 0.024051088839769363, 0.04196683689951897, -0.04610684886574745, -0.026394249871373177, 0.015932058915495872, 0.00372576666995883, -0.034792639315128326, -0.028999853879213333, -0.0039864396676421165, 0.005108457524329424, -0.01557153183966875, -0.004545299336314201, -0.01936352625489235, 0.007984215393662453, -0.01759149879217148, -0.014645293354988098, -0.008344215340912342, 0.018003273755311966, -0.011063920333981514, 0.004174929112195969, 0.03152849152684212, 0.03593643754720688, -0.0011540816631168127, -0.03769301995635033, -0.02154957316815853, 0.044342633336782455, 0.0030863743741065264, -0.004264814779162407, -0.025322474539279938, -0.04526355490088463, -0.0342593640089035, -0.022305496037006378, 0.001534310751594603, 0.008021973073482513, 0.03747851401567459, 0.009352358058094978, -0.03284522145986557, -0.01387015637010336, -0.056976523250341415, -0.001347844023257494, -0.015751386061310768, 0.0006803954020142555, -0.04761536791920662, -0.016222048550844193, -0.015840712934732437, 0.019906818866729736, -0.006522259674966335, -0.00850033387541771, 0.008389376103878021, 0.07405328005552292, 0.005227456800639629, -0.029302066192030907, -0.006170283537358046, 0.006864908151328564, -0.05883850157260895, -0.019247623160481453, -0.002585601294413209, 0.045745231211185455, 0.03091275319457054, -0.009217632003128529, 0.027672655880451202, 0.0037305683363229036, -0.01936052367091179, 0.0041192397475242615, 0.014958592131733894, -0.021990768611431122, -0.029525067657232285, -0.008866251446306705, 0.007014223840087652, -0.02148588001728058, -0.036384452134370804, -0.040984611958265305, -0.017515184357762337, 0.020696690306067467, 0.022960025817155838, -0.021288037300109863, -0.0040594288147985935, -0.014865686185657978, -0.024920308962464333, 0.005494589917361736, -0.020239271223545074, -0.030418993905186653, -0.02450510300695896, -0.05076907202601433, 0.029759466648101807, 0.017882214859128, 0.0381004698574543, 0.023442409932613373, 0.030843766406178474, 0.0477936789393425, 0.011978257447481155, -0.00622647674754262, -0.010546492412686348, -0.01597936451435089, 0.04290233179926872, 0.042979177087545395, 0.007687118835747242, -0.02934449352324009, 0.018534963950514793, 0.008613759651780128, -0.04571156948804855, 0.00925082340836525, -0.01338582206517458, 0.013722377829253674, 0.025592368096113205, 0.008379305712878704, -0.02014848403632641, 0.04173789173364639, -0.06301431357860565, -0.014226788654923439, 0.01579095609486103, -0.006512429565191269, 0.030367180705070496, 0.021123157814145088, 0.0022338100243359804, 0.008863703347742558, -0.006804930977523327, 0.05296681076288223, 0.06196783110499382, 0.04631485790014267, -0.008379335515201092, 0.036307401955127716, -0.00403109285980463, -0.03271815925836563, -0.007985381409525871, 0.007868016138672829, 0.029522957280278206, 0.04180896654725075, -0.07438082993030548, 0.018952736631035805, 0.007362675853073597, 0.01897343248128891, -0.08181516826152802, -0.019089866429567337, 0.028076279908418655, 0.011846471577882767, 0.03601393103599548, -0.05420096963644028, 0.02198547124862671, -0.002378367120400071, -0.013325439766049385, 0.03649720177054405, -0.052298370748758316, -0.012423403561115265, -0.03230345621705055, -0.01430593617260456, -0.025944698601961136, 0.0436507873237133, 0.03368319943547249, 0.04596002772450447, 0.03468512371182442, 0.039775729179382324, -0.02437971532344818, -0.010781044140458107, -0.05504368618130684, 0.01029752567410469, -0.008817775174975395, -0.06493823975324631, 0.03357929736375809, -0.03936951607465744, -0.02779679000377655, 0.022865917533636093, -0.011964536271989346, -0.031895652413368225, -0.011029730550944805, -0.00863605085760355, -0.03701036795973778, 0.04895753413438797, 0.02896331436932087, 0.007510986644774675, -0.0023797107860445976, -0.005264457780867815, 0.008421776816248894, 0.024286502972245216, -0.06772800534963608, 0.042007844895124435, -0.02059185318648815, -0.03491387143731117, -0.03864579275250435, 0.010835289023816586, 0.006052698474377394, -0.016357360407710075, -0.02239546738564968, -0.0022852951660752296, 0.027588821947574615, -0.014923621900379658, 0.0062256306409835815, -0.05883326381444931, 0.016631420701742172, 0.01885068416595459, -0.0010279141133651137, 0.02684985101222992, 0.031851835548877716, -0.027669984847307205, -0.038220200687646866, -0.009407916106283665, 0.02961583063006401, -0.023183953016996384, -0.05128923058509827, -0.0427168607711792, -0.003484210930764675, -0.015312114730477333, -0.003360131988301873, 0.005579206161201, -0.06825434416532516, 0.01469782367348671, -0.003147523384541273, -0.045728959143161774, -0.0007808861555531621, 0.008135221898555756, -0.006333695724606514, -0.09624463319778442, 0.003763572545722127, 0.007619379088282585, 0.00008645425259601325, -0.015848107635974884, -0.023196853697299957, -0.028306998312473297, 0.058017317205667496, 0.01335199736058712, 0.04640345647931099, -0.026360193267464638, -0.011190176010131836, -0.0015107485232874751, 0.04170708358287811, -0.07086403667926788, 0.03952647000551224, -0.01668189838528633, -0.006081205327063799, 0.0002719554759096354, 0.012616227380931377, 0.02014642208814621, 0.025974571704864502, 0.02126416377723217, 0.002542047528550029, -0.008300038985908031, 0.06925090402364731, -0.03042387031018734, 0.01693025231361389, 0.01578548178076744, -0.019979534670710564, 0.025715749710798264, -0.008432439528405666, 0.015754418447613716, 0.03039541095495224, 0.009808313101530075, -0.04971786215901375, 0.010523248463869095, -0.03003954328596592, -0.032524194568395615, 0.012648005038499832, 0.01668296940624714, -0.024549180641770363, -0.03555772081017494, 0.018435996025800705, 0.01730494014918804, -0.03090389259159565, -0.004862370900809765, -0.00021417229436337948, -0.0003276183851994574, 0.03764656186103821, 0.007031541783362627, 0.03056740202009678, 0.022508757188916206, -0.036179233342409134, -0.022454531863331795, 0.032024770975112915, 0.04370677471160889, 0.018629610538482666, 0.03366830199956894, 0.010757636278867722, -0.019016116857528687, 0.014361608773469925, 0.05105961486697197, 0.06445754319429398, -0.030750328674912453, -0.010625111870467663, 0.04033209756016731, 0.006850992329418659, -0.03852510079741478, 0.025071054697036743, 0.029156913980841637, 0.023076726123690605, 0.018389498814940453, 0.05310026928782463, -0.05267373472452164, -0.014703051187098026, -0.005759378895163536, 0.022296074777841568, -0.0005388514255173504, 0.01665055751800537, 0.01206720806658268, 0.017523745074868202, -0.025635618716478348, 0.03384841978549957, 0.01257326453924179, 0.016721254214644432, 0.017249904572963715, 0.016041988506913185, 0.010691766627132893, -0.013430359773337841, -0.006543975789099932, -0.014944756403565407, -0.03498711809515953, 0.050194792449474335, -0.0005772908916696906, 0.002670968882739544, -0.007110857870429754, -0.031780704855918884, -0.01783057488501072, 0.03833731263875961, -0.03041033074259758, -0.023173529654741287, -0.010261386632919312, 0.010912743397057056, 0.012334917671978474, -0.010075357742607594 ]
<p>I have problem with real basics. I have variable that has p=.000 in Shapiro-Wilk. As I looked on the histogram it appears that the cause is natural limit for this measurement (value 0, skewness > 1,5).I'm wondering what whould be the best way to present this data as descriptives. What parameters of descriptive &amp; non-paramteric statistics would be the best to present data like this? Is there equivalent of 95%CI for non-normal distribution ? (for example interquartile range)</p> <p>Thank you in advance!</p>
74,361
[ -0.03168236091732979, -0.02837163209915161, 0.010890577919781208, 0.03658115491271019, 0.03869413584470749, 0.013799947686493397, -0.009437563829123974, 0.02151360549032688, -0.004626348614692688, -0.04447510465979576, 0.03642819821834564, 0.001951285288669169, -0.0026334861759096384, 0.0025445304345339537, 0.04085689038038254, 0.013477850705385208, -0.01087256334722042, -0.01761217974126339, -0.0341593436896801, 0.006412931717932224, 0.012876835651695728, 0.02037883922457695, -0.018658321350812912, -0.007238102611154318, -0.044320378452539444, 0.060333002358675, 0.01441754400730133, -0.016859782859683037, -0.020586522296071053, 0.04027697816491127, -0.03874646872282028, -0.006027450319379568, 0.0052065178751945496, 0.005179600790143013, 0.056865766644477844, 0.019028224050998688, -0.01814642921090126, -0.019875310361385345, 0.007077285088598728, -0.0011517110979184508, -0.037592481821775436, 0.00320799695327878, 0.012090574018657207, 0.033944930881261826, -0.0040186140686273575, -0.005472282879054546, 0.02149416320025921, -0.03889261558651924, 0.014652084559202194, -0.050202567130327225, 0.05072065442800522, -0.006310326978564262, 0.03969135880470276, -0.00715527543798089, 0.010693293996155262, -0.010703906416893005, 0.0896250456571579, 0.03422616049647331, -0.010299049317836761, -0.068174809217453, 0.003651597071439028, -0.015493882820010185, -0.022553743794560432, -0.029040580615401268, -0.01287326030433178, 0.01549396850168705, -0.007300117984414101, -0.06861864030361176, 0.004921342711895704, -0.007755931466817856, 0.038870736956596375, 0.04133689031004906, 0.04663727432489395, -0.013424061238765717, 0.03953971713781357, -0.016221346333622932, 0.025797024369239807, -0.00045123029849492013, 0.015453496016561985, -0.012492651119828224, 0.002468162914738059, 0.0032330064568668604, -0.02213573455810547, 0.04402526840567589, -0.017242079600691795, -0.03641117736697197, 0.06300494074821472, -0.031960628926754, 0.024673720821738243, 0.07400225847959518, -0.02618560381233692, -0.03423072770237923, 0.06243972107768059, 0.008072067983448505, -0.018963970243930817, 0.010594556108117104, -0.031177788972854614, 0.058566104620695114, -0.026737844571471214, 0.0028584084939211607, 0.034447308629751205, -0.08177357167005539, -0.002618012484163046, 0.02866268716752529, -0.014595979824662209, -0.005135328508913517, -0.013005448505282402, -0.0011600721627473831, 0.0043125576339662075, -0.03241198882460594, -0.0021165180951356888, 0.03127269446849823, 0.024531887844204903, 0.007851500995457172, 0.00775092002004385, -0.009527181275188923, 0.012640404514968395, -0.01636604778468609, 0.04791850969195366, 0.040968671441078186, 0.04414426535367966, -0.009118867106735706, 0.021281857043504715, 0.007947617210447788, -0.043710965663194656, 0.011541801504790783, 0.032180193811655045, -0.03903903812170029, -0.027582688257098198, 0.029617376625537872, -0.0066049974411726, 0.011893021874129772, 0.03817472234368324, -0.046943433582782745, 0.01917363330721855, -0.021160220727324486, -0.0495120994746685, -0.045299191027879715, 0.02065073326230049, 0.0007750392542220652, -0.006577046122401953, -0.05017773061990738, -0.01640710048377514, 0.06207379326224327, 0.021084286272525787, 0.0026911781169474125, 0.03052464872598648, -0.010237183421850204, 0.02003166638314724, 0.0071990881115198135, -0.020296210423111916, -0.004690088331699371, -0.005074965301901102, -0.052123263478279114, -0.010812124237418175, -0.05804827809333801, 0.027549561113119125, 0.00209601316601038, 0.03912631794810295, 0.006970555521547794, 0.009471581317484379, -0.017640208825469017, -0.007281817030161619, 0.012720570899546146, 0.007454359903931618, -0.02925584651529789, 0.08042778819799423, -0.0077009983360767365, 0.033175766468048096, 0.00688170688226819, -0.009067644365131855, 0.015946224331855774, 0.019539475440979004, 0.03580766171216965, 0.0554240345954895, -0.02203630842268467, 0.008375086821615696, -0.006423920392990112, 0.009428693912923336, 0.03161007538437843, -0.04278885945677757, 0.029590444639325142, -0.02938292734324932, 0.02288876101374626, 0.017791487276554108, 0.004872200079262257, -0.03065238893032074, 0.019405493512749672, 0.034640632569789886, -0.03219417855143547, -0.03532545641064644, -0.00575943011790514, -0.011329488828778267, -0.0063096326775848866, -0.027318408712744713, 0.04597283899784088, -0.028023354709148407, 0.021208418533205986, 0.002536712447181344, 0.01338618528097868, 0.004295043647289276, 0.011653135530650616, 0.06721848994493484, -0.06198127195239067, 0.00011189850920345634, 0.02143416553735733, 0.025621190667152405, 0.014020894654095173, -0.008311602286994457, -0.06140875071287155, -0.05113459751009941, -0.024260003119707108, 0.0002297735627507791, 0.029494883492588997, 0.017370302230119705, 0.02226994000375271, -0.017826439812779427, 0.01982850208878517, -0.02977241948246956, 0.02328137494623661, -0.04830083250999451, 0.06312611699104309, 0.0807516947388649, 0.013068925589323044, -0.0016750675858929753, -0.011975201778113842, 0.0027507743798196316, -0.01222391240298748, -0.026902340352535248, -0.025922397151589394, -0.00017047239816747606, 0.023098375648260117, 0.01742224022746086, 0.04512302577495575, -0.04186424985527992, -0.022783683612942696, 0.031638551503419876, -0.006808679550886154, 0.012467033229768276, 0.026829201728105545, 0.0005111183854751289, -0.002234754152595997, 0.02109069935977459, 0.02418600767850876, 0.0368390753865242, -0.004954483360052109, 0.014105048030614853, 0.016716301441192627, 0.030983613803982735, -0.009679015725851059, 0.012131832540035248, -0.0019046535016968846, 0.009541478008031845, 0.02018832601606846, -0.012852579355239868, 0.019736668094992638, 0.04357243329286575, 0.0017317793099209666, 0.006950376555323601, 0.0651610940694809, -0.015452033840119839, -0.017977584153413773, -0.01943838596343994, -0.02137145586311817, 0.050327274948358536, 0.059185706079006195, -0.01291653048247099, 0.005350085441023111, 0.011452248319983482, -0.046576980501413345, -0.003457552520558238, 0.0010909342672675848, -0.03038407862186432, -0.04031816124916077, -0.0007010124390944839, 0.06099315732717514, 0.039403922855854034, 0.011912168934941292, -0.04050663858652115, -0.008329585194587708, 0.020027056336402893, 0.026918958872556686, 0.02624034881591797, 0.018664119765162468, -0.06483127176761627, 0.0017132944194599986, -0.010089877061545849, -0.017068801447749138, 0.017500029876828194, -0.04228305444121361, -0.01775229535996914, 0.0023789796978235245, -0.014399685896933079, -0.046318233013153076, -0.034545790404081345, -0.05967037379741669, 0.04777318984270096, -0.045817624777555466, -0.03698013350367546, 0.05435978248715401, 0.006240060552954674, -0.01838277094066143, 0.01988573931157589, -0.058604221791028976, -0.05593284219503403, -0.019588066264986992, -0.0005358883645385504, 0.027417488396167755, 0.007664572913199663, 0.031692761927843094, 0.010766580700874329, -0.027181044220924377, 0.022796019911766052, -0.08299048244953156, -0.07357391715049744, 0.008052278310060501, 0.021389266476035118, 0.035975582897663116, -0.02970230020582676, -0.0546758696436882, 0.07086452096700668, 0.06493788212537766, -0.01617405377328396, -0.04758184030652046, -0.0003867759951390326, -0.025159012526273727, -0.01391808595508337, -0.02250053733587265, 0.02021777257323265, 0.0341653972864151, 0.01696411892771721, -0.013095580972731113, 0.039661236107349396, 0.00422159256413579, 0.005712489597499371, -0.008568794466555119, 0.06417745351791382, -0.027762817218899727, -0.0017831939039751887, 0.04068317264318466, 0.07591045647859573, -0.03353850916028023, 0.012404111213982105, 0.010422845371067524, 0.015975194051861763, 0.003956683911383152, -0.056707967072725296, 0.006150198634713888, 0.002322898246347904, 0.02211599610745907, -0.0322093591094017, -0.0007187192677520216, -0.00018524742336012423, -0.04796331003308296, 0.010476063936948776, -0.004873294848948717, 0.008022152818739414, -0.026051826775074005, 0.028160814195871353, 0.01597633585333824, 0.0013699282426387072, 0.03128816559910774, -0.027756864205002785, 0.00814356841146946, -0.023963019251823425, -0.01065261010080576, 0.009583434090018272, -0.02358844503760338, 0.011909173801541328, 0.02253471314907074, 0.028799157589673996, -0.016255944967269897, -0.021757934242486954, 0.02078552357852459, -0.030636876821517944, -0.0009072003304027021, -0.026247890666127205, 0.0638013407588005, 0.04794158786535263, 0.012782716192305088, 0.02797822281718254, 0.009184733964502811, -0.007465088739991188, 0.020166682079434395, -0.05183255299925804, 0.026897748932242393, -0.02164263091981411, 0.0011300388723611832, -0.01213143952190876, -0.04788161441683769, 0.03710472583770752, -0.056407906115055084, 0.04857976362109184, 0.055126041173934937, 0.026668986305594444, -0.017626356333494186, -0.010000701062381268, -0.008860597386956215, 0.00685849878937006, -0.030543984845280647, -0.02374809794127941, -0.002517778193578124, -0.01458181906491518, 0.0182561706751585, 0.038782574236392975, 0.03546491637825966, -0.020435746759176254, -0.06783396005630493, 0.010343030095100403, -0.009190118871629238, 0.04033995419740677, 0.027208277955651283, 0.04252154752612114, -0.01424736250191927, 0.01735394448041916, 0.009265690110623837, 0.07558614760637283, 0.04210370406508446, 0.01126618217676878, -0.023972302675247192, -0.0015316783683374524, -0.02020985633134842, 0.003875176655128598, 0.01386992447078228, 0.0031978085171431303, 0.014473052695393562, 0.045169003307819366, -0.0046258242800831795, -0.03725432604551315, 0.06591431796550751, 0.0029697588179260492, 0.006032684817910194, -0.022687658667564392, -0.024033764377236366, -0.01687241904437542, 0.007540893740952015, 0.02003154717385769, 0.008729003369808197, 0.07021898031234741, 0.00826174858957529, -0.017476754263043404, 0.043494436889886856, -0.021528203040361404, -0.022156504914164543, 0.042021743953228, 0.004079624079167843, 0.03392297774553299, -0.04674622789025307, -0.0055463882163167, 0.06617182493209839, -0.004105111584067345, -0.0044973199255764484, 0.015959030017256737, -0.011901728808879852, -0.04274028539657593, 0.011359481140971184, 0.062035124748945236, 0.025766544044017792, -0.007963621988892555, 0.004227990750223398, -0.051567379385232925, -0.02845507673919201, 0.015949705615639687, -0.03698934614658356, -0.022028833627700806, 0.02241848036646843, -0.0010532308369874954, -0.036297284066677094, -0.02761191874742508, -0.06142352148890495, 0.03776994347572327, -0.00407205056399107, 0.01943724974989891, -0.05082833021879196, -0.020181262865662575, -0.08542689681053162, 0.024262119084596634, 0.01817861758172512, 0.032264694571495056, -0.020715033635497093, -0.01776507869362831, 0.0017200564034283161, 0.01263835933059454, 0.007027329411357641, -0.0719718337059021, 0.025384092703461647, -0.04446355998516083, -0.00006588825635844842, 0.061774592846632004, 0.0027799915987998247, -0.04359108954668045, 0.02547076717019081, 0.022646866738796234, -0.01069747656583786, 0.004999960772693157, -0.046862807124853134, 0.0709872841835022, -0.033113423734903336, 0.004598766565322876, 0.016135796904563904, 0.009202878922224045, 0.008726638741791248, -0.006004422903060913, -0.04747338965535164, 0.03565492853522301, -0.015722671523690224, -0.01204930804669857, -0.08712869882583618, -0.013400023803114891, -0.02178286202251911, 0.022081181406974792, -0.03016977570950985, 0.03730233013629913, -0.06549875438213348, -0.03421328216791153, 0.035616807639598846, 0.01162935420870781, 0.012942994013428688, -0.005044698249548674, -0.0209975466132164, -0.012841285206377506, 0.0008905382128432393, -0.016834432259202003, -0.0004661670245695859, -0.049360502511262894, -0.002327136229723692, 0.03148700296878815, -0.02417410910129547, 0.00849695224314928, -0.03983286768198013, -0.05644699186086655, -0.012507323175668716, -0.03683045879006386, 0.046838194131851196, -0.008044409565627575, 0.029977234080433846, -0.007777117192745209, -0.018069397658109665, 0.021683163940906525, 0.013305042870342731, 0.015243206173181534, 0.03014550358057022, -0.05443600192666054, -0.021794933825731277, -0.03985961526632309, -0.011692801490426064, -0.08507596701383591, -0.03022867441177368, 0.021359356120228767, -0.0027715801261365414, -0.025313207879662514, -0.01863090880215168, -0.026667797937989235, -0.0016177503857761621, -0.03943617641925812, 0.025876356288790703, 0.06306096911430359, -0.004683757200837135, -0.005378308240324259, -0.027843844145536423, 0.011132207699120045, 0.08379611372947693, -0.06762871146202087, 0.006752452347427607, 0.04657094553112984, 0.0017668143846094608, -0.02722371742129326, 0.02559267170727253, 0.04287661612033844, -0.01767684891819954, -0.013245864771306515, -0.009309078566730022, 0.0017329042311757803, 0.011231384240090847, -0.01805545575916767, 0.005668823141604662, -0.027592983096837997, 0.027302023023366928, 0.0003491756215225905, -0.007067469879984856, -0.03920964151620865, 0.03650673106312752, 0.020275836810469627, -0.006762299221009016, -0.020104508846998215, -0.042185306549072266, -0.03132113814353943, 0.025476420298218727, 0.013895259238779545, 0.0403403602540493, 0.04342171177268028, 0.04208886995911598, 0.001560922130011022, 0.027453817427158356, 0.014072484336793423, -0.025655683130025864, 0.013130581937730312, 0.03335343301296234, -0.020084640011191368, -0.009642829187214375, 0.012946739792823792, -0.022230742499232292, 0.0045601241290569305, -0.06210273131728172, 0.03233588486909866, 0.017484132200479507, 0.028928497806191444, 0.05647837743163109, 0.03119680844247341, 0.01650846190750599, -0.013923629187047482, 0.008276971988379955, -0.0070530143566429615, 0.0005672740517184138, 0.037975672632455826, 0.0714973509311676, -0.009146034717559814, 0.01866530068218708, 0.005291067995131016, 0.01195064838975668, -0.029447520151734352, 0.04961581900715828, 0.026672909036278725, 0.03187507390975952, 0.032331760972738266, -0.034234412014484406, -0.017383679747581482, 0.03581797704100609, -0.021883133798837662, 0.06589201092720032, 0.00482600461691618, -0.008089827373623848, 0.004810391925275326, 0.050722695887088776, -0.005738440901041031, -0.05662712827324867, -0.038138050585985184, -0.05579756200313568, -0.008991388604044914, 0.05733458697795868, -0.029825907200574875, 0.0036617720033973455, -0.016009844839572906, 0.034447479993104935, -0.028739670291543007, 0.023832673206925392, -0.026170015335083008, -0.043236251920461655, -0.0002339547936571762, -0.00039349193684756756, -0.07693611830472946, 0.013295777142047882, -0.024705883115530014, 0.036395467817783356, 0.0016556656919419765, -0.04684746265411377, 0.03551274165511131, -0.03933821991086006, 0.004404874052852392, 0.025357035920023918, 0.035426076501607895, 0.04053298011422157, -0.022328898310661316, -0.0130739351734519, 0.029901903122663498, 0.13590635359287262, 0.07092795521020889, 0.024083441123366356, -0.07850781828165054, 0.0021644432563334703, 0.0024782968685030937, 0.030118979513645172, -0.013860131613910198, 0.04301922395825386, -0.0035700169391930103, -0.029911592602729797, 0.0449184812605381, 0.037863630801439285, 0.014859109185636044, 0.040926363319158554, 0.06614935398101807, -0.04369449242949486, -0.023052046075463295, -0.012214337475597858, 0.02057238109409809, -0.006163259968161583, -0.026300668716430664, -0.03483493998646736, 0.031933099031448364, -0.010776468552649021, -0.0157297495752573, -0.010722172446548939, -0.008854510262608528, 0.002591084223240614, 0.021036647260189056, -0.00004237682151142508, 0.005864197388291359, 0.03606738895177841, 0.008465396240353584, 0.010599303990602493, -0.01811470091342926, 0.011345877312123775, -0.008749725297093391, 0.0257034320384264, 0.02865835838019848, -0.019017145037651062, -0.017785286530852318, 0.056594789028167725, 0.03362971916794777, -0.015410020016133785, -0.019638163968920708, -0.015907378867268562, 0.04215480014681816, -0.008111247792840004, -0.03089355118572712, -0.018509192392230034, 0.010466020554304123, -0.016989313066005707, -0.03198422119021416, -0.017763344570994377, -0.003045394318178296, 0.014551517553627491, -0.020231805741786957, -0.017844999209046364, -0.03479684516787529, -0.01786261424422264, 0.005740555934607983, 0.03642367571592331, 0.06744690239429474, -0.003820155980065465, -0.014804596081376076, -0.024200227111577988, 0.03241362422704697, 0.012070408090949059, -0.010276716202497482, -0.017434170469641685, -0.015233572572469711, -0.0072506750002503395, 0.007644901052117348, -0.006462165620177984, -0.005066380370408297, 0.014124805107712746, 0.016480715945363045, -0.009387152269482613, -0.0725802406668663, -0.044645365327596664, 0.026911690831184387, 0.00561885628849268, -0.019287368282675743, -0.03382158279418945, -0.03710274025797844, -0.006924312096089125, 0.07727200537919998, -0.031732574105262756, 0.009056626819074154, -0.026695173233747482, 0.09314710646867752, 0.034063633531332016, -0.02643292210996151, 0.01054958812892437, 0.04357242211699486, -0.02403775230050087, 0.024807289242744446, 0.021910587325692177, 0.06551574915647507, 0.006809604354202747, 0.0017188522033393383, 0.0025867940858006477, -0.009480043314397335, -0.0328092947602272, 0.0298478826880455, 0.033539608120918274, -0.05822205916047096, 0.020264381542801857, 0.032152704894542694, 0.017570441588759422, 0.009686050936579704, -0.043325651437044144, -0.016924846917390823, -0.043599650263786316, -0.0220672395080328, 0.028248202055692673, 0.002773134969174862, -0.016978846862912178, -0.03225892782211304, -0.01977360248565674, -0.024283571168780327, -0.011544221080839634, -0.04256322607398033, -0.004449589177966118, 0.00374241778627038, -0.017398271709680557, -0.005195774137973785, 0.01265108771622181, 0.02432897500693798, 0.0039283051155507565, 0.028595590963959694, 0.0034535371232777834, 0.015957346186041832, 0.007845900021493435, -0.0419645830988884, -0.011782028712332249, 0.0422808863222599, -0.020972825586795807, 0.04378955438733101, 0.04031242057681084, -0.022826891392469406, -0.02673141285777092, 0.04020616039633751, -0.0034827201161533594, -0.003694797633215785, -0.02785518579185009, 0.017386868596076965, 0.005160624627023935, 0.029221098870038986, -0.00935670081526041, -0.02562207169830799, 0.007275007199496031, 0.028629036620259285, -0.034954506903886795, 0.011761274188756943, 0.026686720550060272, 0.01931709796190262, -0.007906056009232998, 0.03306704759597778, 0.053258586674928665, 0.03492923080921173, -0.00892794318497181, 0.024216804653406143, -0.0439143069088459, 0.014319540932774544, 0.01890329085290432, 0.018773574382066727, 0.04525938257575035, 0.005257032345980406, -0.045686524361371994, -0.03749224543571472, -0.06542777270078659, -0.001958750421181321, -0.05368010327219963, -0.006290405057370663, 0.030559103935956955, 0.0039705014787614346, 0.03594600409269333, -0.0389862023293972, -0.015293261967599392, -0.0037873932160437107, -0.0383172407746315, 0.022608276456594467, -0.010343711823225021, -0.019324883818626404, -0.04908106476068497, -0.012693686410784721, -0.014412259683012962, 0.06480742245912552, 0.014714592136442661, 0.04600806161761284, -0.0030947155319154263, 0.045827969908714294, -0.025759123265743256, 0.006128118373453617, 0.013029769994318485, -0.006879622116684914, -0.0060204146429896355, -0.06941763311624527, 0.05243808031082153, -0.025692423805594444, -0.010986980982124805, 0.014789221808314323, -0.04637555778026581, -0.006170005537569523, 0.011889793910086155, 0.04188121110200882, 0.011999226175248623, 0.0752340704202652, 0.04490642249584198, -0.014942560344934464, -0.005024690646678209, -0.019925542175769806, 0.034368693828582764, 0.035044215619564056, -0.023533865809440613, 0.011185364797711372, 0.04806888848543167, -0.025492582470178604, -0.021444492042064667, 0.0065613058395683765, -0.025712070986628532, -0.045113708823919296, -0.019117871299386024, -0.017172273248434067, 0.028157580643892288, -0.005718052852898836, 0.028093459084630013, -0.07870645076036453, 0.02853502705693245, 0.03166602551937103, 0.04286684840917587, -0.02175554260611534, 0.0008070255862548947, -0.03664809465408325, -0.0725601464509964, -0.008618666790425777, 0.033589866012334824, -0.009080016985535622, -0.03171177953481674, -0.021123139187693596, -0.033126477152109146, 0.003792105009779334, -0.005633438937366009, 0.012584544718265533, -0.08487206697463989, 0.05124329403042793, -0.030958401039242744, -0.007069589104503393, 0.037885237485170364, -0.0006014698301441967, -0.017464958131313324, -0.08047502487897873, 0.04379700869321823, 0.009823905304074287, 0.035451389849185944, -0.022663133218884468, 0.00753000658005476, -0.012863769195973873, 0.022670676931738853, 0.06997983902692795, 0.010280678980052471, -0.001002254313789308, -0.015192404389381409, -0.001193285803310573, 0.0049658105708658695, -0.07431011646986008, -0.010050899349153042, -0.01325979083776474, -0.01724233292043209, -0.041130345314741135, -0.004259900189936161, 0.04410645365715027, -0.015800241380929947, -0.008773846551775932, 0.003625164506956935, 0.02311553619801998, 0.010982670821249485, -0.0705251470208168, 0.013671468943357468, -0.004553993232548237, -0.03722008317708969, 0.04196803271770477, -0.025810612365603447, 0.0007930481224320829, 0.03681117296218872, -0.020085511729121208, -0.05759416148066521, 0.033503178507089615, 0.0004402632766868919, -0.04865704104304314, -0.004848142620176077, -0.007205817382782698, 0.007352998945862055, -0.05112075433135033, 0.02218211628496647, 0.00717929657548666, -0.056884266436100006, -0.0048447949811816216, -0.014256903901696205, 0.008073752745985985, 0.028587719425559044, -0.015886647626757622, -0.020696857944130898, -0.011420324444770813, -0.007694637402892113, 0.003968033008277416, -0.006765387021005154, 0.005633088760077953, 0.012029650621116161, -0.007088526617735624, 0.024173298850655556, -0.0227196142077446, 0.0321350060403347, -0.025042405351996422, 0.03158542886376381, -0.017629140987992287, 0.003065550234168768, 0.04135127738118172, 0.026100991293787956, 0.04883904755115509, 0.023486999794840813, 0.00874463189393282, 0.043320998549461365, -0.0038574645295739174, 0.01556288544088602, -0.04935261979699135, -0.007743578404188156, -0.050306059420108795, -0.01381185557693243, 0.034491926431655884, -0.006741134449839592, 0.01121425535529852, -0.018809029832482338, -0.021569252014160156, 0.02138408273458481, 0.03190511465072632, -0.03320332616567612, 0.004944351501762867, -0.017433179542422295, 0.005354344844818115, 0.032907404005527496, -0.04840944707393646, -0.03411892428994179, 0.02469060570001602, 0.020148737356066704, 0.014160371385514736, -0.00009239344944944605, -0.022532133385539055, -0.02696998231112957, 0.02174760401248932, 0.0328119732439518, -0.05188623070716858, 0.01576567441225052, -0.010545792989432812, 0.03359080106019974, -0.022513482719659805, -0.015529563650488853 ]
<p>I use <a href="http://stat.ethz.ch/R-manual/R-devel/library/stats/html/optim.html" rel="nofollow">optim()</a> in R to do a lot of MLE. I've used the approach for a lot of problems, but the one I'm working on right now consists of fitting the parameters of the generalized extreme value distribution (GEV). There are three parameters (location scale shape), and I want to get the standard errors from this fit. An example of a paper doing this is <a href="https://www.isse.ucar.edu/staff/katz/docs/pdf/ecology.pdf" rel="nofollow">Katz et al. 2005</a>, and here is the <a href="http://www.esapubs.org/archive/ecol/E086/060/rextreme.txt" rel="nofollow">online code</a> for the article. I am unaffiliated with this publication. I should also point out that the GEV question is just an example of the type of approach I take -- most of my MLE fits are time series models (state-space). I could give more examples if needed.</p> <p>1) Which of the arguments to optim() are of particular relevance to the statistical validity of using the optim() Hessian to computer standard errors? </p> <ul> <li>The first thing that comes to mind is the type of algorithm -- In R, optim() is a wrapper for several types of optimization algorithms (see above link for reference on optim()). I don't even think all of them return a Hessian.</li> <li>I also think that the parameters relating to the <code>reltol</code> and <code>abstol</code> parameters could be important, but I don't fully understand what they do.</li> </ul> <p>2) Is there some pre-treatment of the data (e.g., standardizing data before doing the MLE) that is advisable if I want to use the hessian to compute S.E.'s of the fitted parameters?</p> <p>3) In general, of what do I need to be careful. I just don't want to incorrectly use this approach.</p> <p>4) Is there anything you can think of that I definitely <strong>should not</strong> do?</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
47,570
[ -0.033335037529468536, -0.0052045839838683605, -0.02352859452366829, -0.0031546796672046185, -0.008736099116504192, 0.026084331795573235, -0.013172142207622528, -0.021560562774538994, 0.04610465466976166, -0.007688858546316624, 0.026985716074705124, 0.04243965446949005, 0.06086292862892151, 0.04934506490826607, 0.04585515707731247, 0.0032149457838386297, 0.003077936125919223, 0.005064144264906645, -0.011629132553935051, 0.017279449850320816, 0.008993122726678848, 0.018348151817917824, -0.03396763280034065, -0.021870018914341927, 0.010769456624984741, 0.045235734432935715, -0.0003364943549968302, 0.01286085695028305, 0.015183416195213795, 0.044277798384428024, -0.07024058699607849, -0.022802839055657387, -0.0025477390736341476, 0.028823010623455048, 0.034399885684251785, 0.026956848800182343, 0.002661082660779357, -0.014920888468623161, -0.0036698097828775644, 0.03985411301255226, -0.017326438799500465, 0.005956434644758701, -0.006405877880752087, 0.03150780871510506, -0.02717059850692749, 0.038905542343854904, -0.04081825166940689, -0.042795468121767044, 0.05608060956001282, -0.02421271800994873, 0.07253628969192505, 0.022239159792661667, -0.007771909236907959, 0.04066620022058487, -0.020037854090332985, 0.006795329041779041, 0.05314401909708977, 0.057598844170570374, -0.00888274796307087, -0.07860256731510162, 0.004754649940878153, -0.01464779768139124, 0.02171008288860321, -0.023740267381072044, -0.024717936292290688, 0.0307405237108469, 0.017985906451940536, -0.010838665068149567, 0.04846110939979553, -0.009035320021212101, 0.016835873946547508, -0.001896846923045814, 0.03174297511577606, 0.0026471437886357307, 0.03009614907205105, -0.007569652982056141, 0.014786254614591599, 0.004516029264777899, 0.02540232054889202, 0.02597622759640217, -0.014582201838493347, -0.01594921201467514, 0.0029586153104901314, 0.006222744006663561, 0.005101232789456844, 0.02365046925842762, 0.07987864315509796, -0.028907394036650658, 0.010994273237884045, -0.018343333154916763, -0.026910223066806793, 0.03050086461007595, 0.055184610188007355, -0.00731096975505352, -0.02908078394830227, 0.04686066135764122, 0.0031802495941519737, 0.022316845133900642, 0.0012179731857031584, -0.02397290989756584, -0.010496393777430058, -0.005214717239141464, -0.028455128893256187, 0.05272912606596947, -0.01807478815317154, -0.024424541741609573, -0.008095023222267628, -0.019406840205192566, -0.033486321568489075, -0.02024121582508087, -0.012531000189483166, 0.014283166266977787, -0.015302215702831745, -0.036373820155858994, 0.015559440478682518, -0.005820630583912134, -0.0017699337331578135, -0.009676600806415081, 0.03154105320572853, 0.033303987234830856, 0.05666326731443405, 0.004983915481716394, 0.02669466659426689, -0.0445825532078743, -0.03717779740691185, 0.015628116205334663, 0.03126213699579239, -0.03146672993898392, -0.043650295585393906, 0.0394587405025959, -0.02907324954867363, -0.021308042109012604, 0.05459818243980408, -0.007358841132372618, 0.029576988890767097, 0.002950881142169237, -0.08178745955228806, -0.07569286227226257, 0.0664931982755661, -0.012324986048042774, 0.048034004867076874, -0.05567358434200287, -0.04372731223702431, 0.025818010792136192, 0.025991078466176987, 0.03318234160542488, 0.04844924807548523, 0.007612740620970726, 0.03270138427615166, -0.0036132147070020437, -0.019217396154999733, 0.010019443929195404, -0.0158999040722847, -0.029950827360153198, -0.033624619245529175, -0.05569057911634445, 0.016601111739873886, 0.016591228544712067, 0.00989245343953371, 0.05778916925191879, 0.08586301654577255, 0.009879466146230698, -0.013050295412540436, -0.006513834465295076, -0.029026389122009277, -0.031039969995617867, 0.06296364963054657, 0.0036068579647690058, 0.030534492805600166, 0.010979633778333664, -0.02146478183567524, 0.04027145355939865, -0.002884511137381196, -0.010986527428030968, 0.010357501916587353, -0.0492781363427639, 0.008921906352043152, -0.04988414794206619, -0.00015449500642716885, -0.005544144660234451, -0.049062713980674744, -0.04856390133500099, 0.022604703903198242, -0.036033935844898224, 0.01070791482925415, 0.01847998984158039, -0.007982711307704449, 0.019752884283661842, 0.03510208800435066, -0.03848123177886009, -0.03802197799086571, -0.03674810007214546, -0.023624368011951447, -0.001742096384987235, -0.024887366220355034, 0.018990084528923035, 0.00023341520864050835, 0.018072305247187614, 0.01695065200328827, -0.0035777336452156305, 0.011493642814457417, 0.029931070283055305, 0.030265849083662033, -0.0025071026757359505, 0.0023836742620915174, 0.03966710716485977, 0.05569297820329666, -0.0017809018027037382, 0.01673702709376812, -0.030924664810299873, -0.04192935302853584, -0.023037685081362724, -0.0602693147957325, 0.013705968856811523, 0.028236273676156998, -0.01691502146422863, 0.010945765301585197, -0.007703856565058231, 0.003357970854267478, -0.012401813641190529, -0.035950884222984314, 0.03671016916632652, 0.04721424728631973, -0.014754933305084705, 0.027997612953186035, 0.014708062633872032, 0.02000255696475506, 0.05174165219068527, -0.034159887582063675, 0.020614415407180786, -0.07494068890810013, -0.033940088003873825, 0.039501506835222244, 0.036208976060152054, 0.001053560758009553, 0.02198369801044464, 0.04485902190208435, 0.008349783718585968, 0.004713906906545162, 0.01134957280009985, -0.05070917308330536, -0.05157141759991646, 0.004467517137527466, 0.035769786685705185, -0.009761398658156395, 0.02923285961151123, 0.01782539114356041, -0.030969664454460144, 0.0360046848654747, 0.012105466797947884, 0.02223583497107029, 0.040176887065172195, 0.030015449970960617, -0.00749162444844842, -0.010933824814856052, 0.005508804693818092, 0.03800933063030243, -0.02398175746202469, 0.010036644525825977, 0.008876773528754711, 0.00412343954667449, -0.029508545994758606, 0.006316727958619595, -0.02958584949374199, -0.001784557942301035, 0.02517661266028881, -0.016066856682300568, 0.010125013999640942, 0.024356836453080177, -0.04711823910474777, 0.030338751152157784, -0.04335993155837059, -0.04112568870186806, -0.042438287287950516, 0.01557614654302597, 0.00594345573335886, 0.02623797208070755, 0.014025713317096233, -0.025936592370271683, -0.016366003081202507, -0.02016381174325943, 0.0005367241101339459, 0.032014183700084686, -0.00854369904845953, -0.02413698472082615, 0.013222838751971722, -0.04747019335627556, -0.009147396311163902, 0.019224990159273148, -0.0014047992881387472, -0.0016239394899457693, 0.07611620426177979, 0.027362573891878128, -0.05386894568800926, -0.023887138813734055, -0.02349192276597023, 0.01425816211849451, -0.02282649464905262, -0.035082701593637466, 0.040821924805641174, 0.014862540178000927, -0.04716857895255089, 0.014789437875151634, -0.04519682750105858, -0.018748290836811066, -0.02712937630712986, -0.001932153245434165, -0.02717532403767109, 0.04033108055591583, 0.021595507860183716, 0.01527200173586607, -0.004797876346856356, -0.011803432367742062, -0.06265725940465927, -0.05064011365175247, 0.0037453973200172186, -0.020595865324139595, 0.024846110492944717, -0.0010074825258925557, -0.023804130032658577, 0.08518554270267487, 0.03652908280491829, -0.03416776657104492, -0.029227307066321373, 0.005234006326645613, 0.008683553896844387, -0.033901963382959366, 0.03993740305304527, 0.01387304998934269, 0.05299194157123566, 0.008589972741901875, -0.02802015282213688, 0.022197548300027847, 0.05842052027583122, -0.011957932263612747, 0.010244411416351795, 0.04901161044836044, 0.0009885765612125397, -0.06305444985628128, 0.04259728640317917, 0.04895946383476257, 0.021818095818161964, 0.058039337396621704, -0.023019826039671898, -0.0133152911439538, -0.0034886584617197514, -0.08880063146352768, 0.03306375816464424, -0.028757117688655853, 0.009194353595376015, -0.043416108936071396, 0.015899822115898132, 0.02517351694405079, -0.03690328076481819, -0.006244947202503681, 0.022918997332453728, -0.018850838765501976, -0.011493619531393051, 0.019739488139748573, 0.03958088904619217, 0.06658851355314255, -0.005379049573093653, -0.009083722718060017, -0.030569544062018394, 0.009611357003450394, -0.024685950949788094, -0.014293010346591473, -0.010386517271399498, 0.05203694850206375, 0.03853322193026543, 0.0071216546930372715, -0.024373065680265427, -0.021045546978712082, -0.01526719145476818, -0.06275931745767593, 0.04104333370923996, -0.02246994897723198, 0.05765886977314949, 0.04306909441947937, 0.011069199070334435, -0.01715393364429474, 0.008135383948683739, 0.014002947136759758, 0.005759367719292641, -0.05724122375249863, 0.033919427543878555, -0.020871592685580254, -0.021558038890361786, 0.00284910062327981, -0.021287404000759125, 0.0368511825799942, -0.029951006174087524, 0.038668546825647354, 0.002218908164650202, 0.011545488610863686, -0.012926665134727955, 0.0043777539394795895, -0.004594525787979364, -0.029612310230731964, 0.0009657200425863266, 0.004347373265773058, 0.033181607723236084, -0.009167439304292202, 0.02700098417699337, 0.026527466252446175, -0.02350948005914688, -0.03390628844499588, -0.012348055839538574, 0.003316303947940469, 0.03649790957570076, 0.047966230660676956, 0.007826237939298153, 0.01786830648779869, -0.053153008222579956, 0.011158144101500511, -0.0013699621194973588, 0.04010019823908806, 0.024553099647164345, -0.010676953941583633, -0.034212447702884674, -0.011853674426674843, -0.009057779796421528, 0.017985066398978233, -0.0062537649646401405, 0.019158517941832542, 0.0007541516679339111, 0.015881983563303947, 0.023930538445711136, 0.0028559500351548195, -0.015618495643138885, 0.02598850429058075, -0.0031505257356911898, 0.045998234301805496, -0.028794243931770325, -0.03875605762004852, 0.01597684994339943, 0.012732204049825668, 0.022881926968693733, 0.01565231755375862, -0.012701236642897129, -0.0031599081121385098, 0.04210064560174942, -0.005595056340098381, -0.006624299567192793, -0.009690397419035435, 0.025525333359837532, 0.04095158725976944, -0.02746291272342205, -0.025455577298998833, -0.018579119816422462, 0.03612358868122101, 0.04837564006447792, 0.0077341217547655106, 0.03575177118182182, -0.08923695236444473, -0.01450781337916851, 0.04125888645648956, 0.035574302077293396, -0.02613217569887638, -0.00010479625052539632, -0.04038648679852486, -0.012061738409101963, 0.044280968606472015, -0.01302915159612894, 0.022039717063307762, -0.012383969500660896, 0.03335925191640854, -0.0317520797252655, -0.04545266553759575, -0.045985933393239975, -0.0157314483076334, -0.02610076405107975, 0.04444316774606705, -0.016661882400512695, -0.027001092210412025, -0.05420847609639168, -0.015825605019927025, -0.034896694123744965, 0.01347056683152914, 0.0022680924739688635, -0.0026461263187229633, 0.036140166223049164, -0.0072425673715770245, -0.03008051961660385, -0.07487901300191879, 0.005582119803875685, -0.027395639568567276, 0.05029993876814842, 0.03300473466515541, 0.0063637737184762955, -0.05230411887168884, 0.016671687364578247, 0.042016830295324326, -0.028295159339904785, 0.0006667058914899826, -0.030233636498451233, 0.0367763414978981, 0.02163688838481903, 0.005885154940187931, 0.04431198537349701, 0.008806679397821426, 0.011716420762240887, 0.016818225383758545, -0.044624604284763336, -0.006416679359972477, -0.010068920440971851, -0.052583664655685425, -0.013382108882069588, -0.016149692237377167, -0.01694728061556816, 0.012025943957269192, 0.017020193859934807, 0.04287901148200035, -0.040182482451200485, -0.006806913297623396, 0.015622350387275219, 0.045102279633283615, -0.05092795565724373, -0.010393795557320118, 0.004937679972499609, 0.016381997615098953, -0.003356007393449545, -0.017284121364355087, 0.019582198932766914, -0.00689605763182044, 0.0015241202199831605, 0.016786079853773117, -0.07858406007289886, 0.01911139488220215, -0.016422903165221214, -0.026675065979361534, 0.009588153101503849, -0.019869443029165268, 0.030026022344827652, -0.015342493541538715, 0.001416230690665543, 0.02034900151193142, -0.03187700733542442, -0.04786788299679756, -0.0006707439315505326, -0.005060407333076, -0.0012403487926349044, -0.02079191617667675, 0.030181320384144783, -0.026218585669994354, -0.01194690726697445, -0.06729476153850555, -0.02164561301469803, 0.006142346188426018, -0.030506843701004982, -0.05978672206401825, -0.02688446454703808, -0.016979962587356567, -0.022621534764766693, -0.025933925062417984, -0.0062776776030659676, 0.07286689430475235, -0.043630201369524, 0.011463177390396595, -0.0347091406583786, 0.0016238450771197677, 0.08940455317497253, -0.023736434057354927, 0.018723029643297195, 0.006831038743257523, -0.024107223376631737, -0.007061421871185303, -0.005185846239328384, 0.013849928975105286, -0.020813167095184326, -0.02566872350871563, -0.04276946187019348, 0.010388863272964954, 0.011166623793542385, 0.028365183621644974, -0.045069023966789246, 0.044824641197919846, -0.01632235199213028, 0.010681696236133575, -0.022286931052803993, 0.006121710874140263, -0.021046437323093414, -0.0016275693196803331, 0.00041248087654821575, 0.0016361926682293415, 0.01731615699827671, -0.00754404254257679, 0.033438608050346375, -0.05383290350437164, 0.019041480496525764, 0.022734420374035835, 0.07039620727300644, -0.0006129104876890779, 0.011757063679397106, -0.02575124241411686, -0.01787422224879265, 0.046907976269721985, -0.005258914548903704, -0.010658740997314453, 0.009765329770743847, 0.04205988347530365, -0.05420682951807976, -0.03255132958292961, -0.05643317848443985, 0.009673811495304108, 0.06884344667196274, 0.007106015924364328, 0.02533620037138462, 0.04705065116286278, -0.04941811040043831, -0.01200420968234539, -0.06644614785909653, -0.001859708339907229, 0.012541449628770351, 0.039626266807317734, 0.05896001309156418, -0.00522538460791111, -0.006356992293149233, 0.060600392520427704, 0.0017437345813959837, 0.011119544506072998, 0.04960551857948303, 0.007012674119323492, 0.04927758127450943, 0.007368701510131359, -0.030325565487146378, -0.05393116548657417, 0.020494457334280014, -0.04051952064037323, 0.010229076258838177, -0.02710992656648159, -0.03194892778992653, -0.0019030873663723469, 0.01205413043498993, -0.00614182511344552, -0.06655403226613998, -0.014557233080267906, -0.04862736538052559, 0.031476832926273346, 0.03904777392745018, -0.061341144144535065, 0.03684839978814125, 0.03836610168218613, 0.04587547853589058, -0.015116286464035511, 0.03707974776625633, -0.01628168299794197, -0.09148800373077393, -0.013090929947793484, 0.014385247603058815, -0.053197216242551804, 0.05280255153775215, 0.0034955863375216722, -0.014559349045157433, 0.023961331695318222, -0.03886215388774872, 0.008131996728479862, 0.03674725070595741, 0.022234322503209114, -0.003181296167895198, 0.059203796088695526, -0.03884616866707802, -0.07236742973327637, -0.038043390959501266, -0.01921190693974495, 0.16021104156970978, 0.04061251878738403, 0.02725405991077423, -0.050555821508169174, 0.00530165433883667, 0.047897081822156906, -0.004138588439673185, 0.02659410797059536, -0.028993090614676476, -0.00007357036520261317, -0.015732772648334503, 0.01912039890885353, -0.00040902214823290706, 0.0035943014081567526, -0.045771658420562744, 0.03422605246305466, -0.05836418643593788, -0.05866537243127823, -0.00793787743896246, -0.0019199424423277378, 0.011156694032251835, -0.013243813998997211, -0.012749692425131798, 0.002926918910816312, -0.01056672539561987, -0.025229562073946, -0.01646813005208969, -0.0383199043571949, -0.015002131462097168, -0.04564865678548813, -0.013668578118085861, 0.0018668730044737458, -0.010132724419236183, -0.021853920072317123, 0.02129010111093521, 0.013713098131120205, -0.03285084664821625, -0.013226755894720554, 0.0013718026457354426, 0.024504564702510834, -0.013073928654193878, -0.013095078989863396, 0.028293659910559654, 0.003252028487622738, -0.026182403787970543, -0.037973981350660324, -0.03943900018930435, 0.03774498403072357, -0.020930197089910507, -0.04711025208234787, 0.017725037410855293, -0.008568896912038326, 0.04475356265902519, -0.034380462020635605, 0.028639482334256172, -0.008174528367817402, 0.012259310111403465, -0.016086628660559654, 0.005070056300610304, -0.00033790231100283563, 0.016675695776939392, 0.006868299562484026, 0.010036025196313858, 0.05329461023211479, -0.02424260601401329, -0.02654869295656681, -0.04695497453212738, 0.05261923745274544, 0.0012352477060630918, 0.007877688854932785, -0.020588304847478867, -0.043082643300294876, -0.010170284658670425, 0.005170089658349752, 0.02928483858704567, 0.0005208684597164392, 0.031620245426893234, -0.028349561616778374, -0.01539189275354147, -0.03582286462187767, -0.0271728727966547, 0.005418473854660988, -0.023839686065912247, 0.0072040497325360775, -0.020012708380818367, -0.016428425908088684, 0.03608853742480278, 0.02970706857740879, 0.041870806366205215, 0.027075743302702904, -0.0035120018292218447, 0.02917134016752243, 0.013512114062905312, -0.012076414190232754, -0.05854823812842369, -0.008754375390708447, -0.029418503865599632, -0.0036657063756138086, -0.033869948238134384, 0.032525595277547836, 0.010018731467425823, 0.023012787103652954, -0.011183755472302437, 0.006668928544968367, 0.021218201145529747, -0.0025850676465779543, 0.02481122501194477, -0.04007195681333542, 0.0005683232448063791, -0.00203743577003479, -0.01855277456343174, -0.035930048674345016, 0.01688145473599434, -0.047728776931762695, -0.016131054610013962, 0.0013264917070046067, -0.005280668381601572, -0.0493798702955246, 0.08851173520088196, -0.006267175078392029, 0.026258889585733414, -0.048791639506816864, 0.003917225636541843, -0.0002821780217345804, -0.016480369493365288, -0.0525224506855011, 0.007604821119457483, -0.006873203907161951, -0.0008576829568482935, -0.00815068930387497, -0.02036789245903492, 0.02556297741830349, 0.007224942557513714, 0.032971758395433426, -0.009998684749007225, 0.006426146719604731, 0.026173371821641922, 0.0517704039812088, -0.008913191966712475, 0.0010911317076534033, 0.02168118767440319, -0.051112446933984756, -0.04670354351401329, -0.010111178271472454, 0.0011985580204054713, -0.023904265835881233, 0.004332573153078556, -0.008764568716287613, -0.019639525562524796, 0.021588381379842758, -0.003115816507488489, 0.017577650025486946, -0.055679261684417725, 0.02420058846473694, 0.05424794554710388, -0.024024447426199913, 0.008688898757100105, 0.023297011852264404, -0.011516972444951534, 0.008612414821982384, 0.014816537499427795, -0.004647402558475733, 0.03505987301468849, 0.012156590819358826, -0.02806723676621914, -0.01799219474196434, 0.003155233571305871, -0.005839117802679539, 0.05864879488945007, 0.03931232914328575, -0.0363122895359993, 0.011423886753618717, -0.02335282787680626, 0.01708187721669674, -0.09212859719991684, 0.023388240486383438, 0.03190349414944649, 0.004497597459703684, 0.04896699637174606, -0.049365244805812836, -0.024510186165571213, 0.03798339515924454, -0.04189329594373703, 0.02320939674973488, -0.004238039720803499, -0.0027033425867557526, -0.030579514801502228, 0.016621900722384453, -0.03554622828960419, 0.039675548672676086, -0.00012802665878552943, 0.014196795411407948, 0.042251795530319214, -0.005243123974651098, 0.007115549873560667, -0.03877153620123863, -0.018011361360549927, 0.04111751168966293, 0.05497933551669121, -0.041684240102767944, 0.04725241661071777, -0.03590473532676697, 0.03018740937113762, 0.0060028391890227795, -0.00007421504415106028, 0.05431639403104782, 0.0025188205763697624, 0.01873967982828617, -0.007240751758217812, 0.05176996812224388, 0.04827980697154999, 0.01662163995206356, 0.029352035373449326, -0.04872215911746025, -0.008556772023439407, 0.03424651175737381, -0.04257816821336746, 0.03469974175095558, 0.00961813610047102, 0.01194504089653492, -0.05198507383465767, 0.03317670151591301, -0.0013975979527458549, -0.0449054054915905, -0.00011940002877963707, 0.004066262394189835, -0.002450747648254037, -0.01901943050324917, 0.009013280272483826, -0.014199837110936642, 0.01746281422674656, 0.07340802252292633, 0.04497208818793297, -0.010384967550635338, 0.02082507684826851, 0.019814960658550262, -0.01981176808476448, 0.00016552153101656586, -0.008079685270786285, -0.013562962412834167, -0.048963941633701324, 0.0264301598072052, -0.01625697873532772, 0.0004403562343213707, -0.06692949682474136, -0.0014528636820614338, -0.07555919140577316, 0.024782776832580566, 0.016533415764570236, -0.004367113579064608, 0.004325816407799721, -0.029832011088728905, 0.04751787334680557, -0.09056514501571655, 0.08330018818378448, 0.025720825418829918, -0.004339074250310659, -0.0015017361147329211, -0.037082985043525696, -0.004101431462913752, 0.044073764234781265, 0.04081055894494057, 0.01055505033582449, 0.006831161677837372, 0.015723178163170815, 0.02080255001783371, 0.032016344368457794, -0.06607630848884583, 0.04933544993400574, -0.0016633280320093036, 0.005576372612267733, 0.004835662432014942, 0.004555954597890377, 0.0013009634567424655, 0.02595268189907074, 0.0262391809374094, -0.0011245894711464643, 0.030445972457528114, 0.012153424322605133, -0.03429461643099785, 0.03178464621305466, 0.018618855625391006, -0.031399231404066086, 0.048471201211214066, -0.003811871400102973, 0.03454360365867615, 0.017767593264579773, -0.0006369997281581163, -0.054440103471279144, 0.008197106420993805, -0.030077878385782242, -0.0077318912371993065, 0.00032012720475904644, 0.021573413163423538, 0.02873307280242443, -0.040893327444791794, 0.0010526396799832582, 0.03651069477200508, -0.017411772161722183, 0.021741552278399467, 0.018605239689350128, 0.011412086896598339, 0.017539765685796738, 0.027640432119369507, 0.03886568173766136, -0.0032997136004269123, -0.006455067079514265, -0.018046202138066292, 0.008706575259566307, 0.06930036097764969, 0.011251546442508698, -0.010684467852115631, 0.05665457248687744, 0.009382487274706364, 0.03003605455160141, -0.012931762263178825, 0.03647911176085472, -0.05402659624814987, -0.032853864133358, 0.03624996542930603, 0.014675646089017391, -0.04728146642446518, -0.00955210905522108, -0.021540505811572075, 0.04800697788596153, -0.03268614038825035, -0.0027462211437523365, -0.0010085934773087502, -0.02363203465938568, -0.015672927722334862, -0.003501454833894968, -0.021477075293660164, 0.0181770920753479, 0.0073763844557106495, 0.01572120375931263, 0.02094336226582527, 0.016779309138655663, 0.06718622148036957, 0.0009535288554616272, 0.02107739821076393, 0.048061855137348175, 0.01504616066813469, 0.01032550074160099, -0.016039617359638214, -0.0224797073751688, -0.02447241172194481, 0.016402415931224823, 0.03002139739692211, -0.003792732022702694, -0.014029955491423607, -0.05389987304806709, -0.009265273809432983, 0.058308809995651245, -0.03970681130886078, -0.014193889684975147, 0.0019207249861210585, -0.030942557379603386, -0.03286155313253403, -0.018530379980802536 ]
<p>Is there anything wrong with regressing a ratio on itself? For example can we regress the log(savings ratio) on log(income) or the log(debt to income) ratio on log(income)? If not, should we use the log transformation to take income to the RHS and regress log(savings) on log(income)? If using a log transformation is the way to go, how do I interpret my results, given that the savings ratio is what I am interest in, not savings?</p>
74,362
[ -0.0016352947568520904, 0.02119603008031845, -0.02113053947687149, 0.0010018189204856753, 0.011548073962330818, 0.00999389961361885, -0.012399843893945217, -0.005419299937784672, 0.04776396229863167, -0.03817633166909218, 0.007518124300986528, -0.0017065092688426375, 0.04806819558143616, 0.0178875382989645, 0.02765548974275589, 0.01350091677159071, -0.03059905208647251, 0.012544265016913414, 0.0104481540620327, -0.0026951886247843504, -0.010939772240817547, 0.03798963874578476, 0.017906086519360542, 0.008163043297827244, 0.0009309520828537643, 0.04924344643950462, 0.03213687613606453, -0.0202085729688406, -0.008804673328995705, 0.06372933089733124, 0.003570044646039605, -0.012071162462234497, -0.0069192880764603615, 0.0754542425274849, -0.009971816092729568, 0.0015013858210295439, -0.017959900200366974, -0.02780957520008087, -0.027070626616477966, 0.058545030653476715, 0.004569427575916052, 0.026064109057188034, 0.013097599148750305, 0.03737855702638626, 0.007030246313661337, 0.03835694491863251, -0.011877995915710926, -0.029315369203686714, -0.005188317038118839, -0.032094426453113556, 0.08276012539863586, -0.009815976954996586, 0.02806166373193264, 0.039982009679079056, -0.01754903607070446, -0.005220082122832537, 0.07095320522785187, 0.05685602128505707, -0.008993512019515038, -0.03179164603352547, -0.0423697829246521, 0.021956413984298706, -0.005574674345552921, 0.00327872671186924, 0.0021316073834896088, -0.022147763520479202, -0.029114579781889915, -0.0016055952291935682, 0.06777603179216385, -0.03841481730341911, 0.03301241621375084, 0.014314289204776287, 0.015592004172503948, -0.01085533294826746, 0.013971813954412937, 0.006004711147397757, -0.006491148844361305, 0.014510712586343288, 0.056203193962574005, 0.035552021116018295, 0.007520662155002356, -0.010210175067186356, 0.052430905401706696, 0.0627969354391098, 0.01240262109786272, -0.021360337734222412, 0.021806247532367706, -0.04402855411171913, 0.04971189796924591, 0.010645681992173195, -0.0011799470521509647, -0.008325058966875076, 0.021857811138033867, -0.013352815061807632, -0.02479122020304203, 0.048018425703048706, -0.018148159608244896, 0.005591959692537785, -0.0038332680705934763, -0.0025877447333186865, -0.04995383694767952, -0.020145775750279427, -0.0005142432637512684, -0.0026238926220685244, -0.010718600824475288, 0.005570434965193272, -0.006683651823550463, 0.02156904898583889, 0.03273212909698486, -0.053759824484586716, -0.016124367713928223, 0.02580893784761429, -0.004692224320024252, 0.020322129130363464, 0.02214783988893032, -0.02422894351184368, 0.006102192215621471, 0.00609674071893096, 0.03561542555689812, 0.023408303037285805, 0.013537283055484295, -0.019088033586740494, 0.008184507489204407, 0.03654591739177704, -0.037247639149427414, 0.03530799224972725, 0.004620116204023361, -0.023387769237160683, -0.06232220679521561, 0.030603796243667603, -0.028701774775981903, -0.06203668937087059, 0.03571292385458946, 0.01629660464823246, 0.03859064728021622, -0.0035308203659951687, -0.08150435239076614, -0.018914544954895973, 0.023426154628396034, 0.02388036996126175, -0.014041423797607422, -0.04641541466116905, 0.002538858214393258, 0.029344972223043442, 0.05179781839251518, 0.035586435347795486, 0.04992889240384102, 0.038231201469898224, 0.00794266164302826, 0.026982832700014114, -0.05267135053873062, -0.03425460681319237, 0.0007292953669093549, -0.04189708083868027, 0.008431379683315754, -0.05084240809082985, -0.004386328160762787, 0.011682958342134953, -0.01989906281232834, 0.013650039210915565, 0.05128318443894386, 0.007539026904851198, -0.035217735916376114, 0.023253655061125755, -0.03976977616548538, -0.02871830388903618, 0.05200432240962982, -0.02839886024594307, 0.029662057757377625, -0.010821016505360603, 0.008789136074483395, -0.00705748051404953, 0.019139202311635017, 0.053291741758584976, 0.06118964031338692, 0.006616016384214163, -0.01577710174024105, -0.03666543960571289, -0.000632482289802283, -0.015314015559852123, -0.021297072991728783, -0.03957848995923996, -0.012334944680333138, -0.03594199940562248, 0.03141108900308609, 0.02178986556828022, -0.00014102880959399045, -0.040092792361974716, 0.028479237109422684, -0.046197790652513504, -0.059330105781555176, -0.037798549979925156, 0.016589898616075516, 0.003153995843604207, 0.02317843772470951, -0.01618681661784649, 0.0015429618069902062, 0.019081609323620796, -0.0375455766916275, -0.014509902335703373, 0.013630153611302376, -0.00036487102624960244, -0.003338603302836418, -0.028803102672100067, 0.030056457966566086, 0.03952319175004959, 0.026317639276385307, -0.022836212068796158, 0.016830971464514732, -0.04417208209633827, -0.024992164224386215, 0.014648467302322388, -0.009805143810808659, 0.01635182648897171, -0.014464502222836018, 0.02075454778969288, 0.02110116183757782, -0.020828207954764366, -0.026694433763623238, 0.03977563977241516, -0.05700534209609032, 0.0391446128487587, 0.04098619148135185, 0.019820749759674072, -0.0259799063205719, 0.014580332674086094, 0.015989331528544426, 0.0004377513541840017, -0.024481872096657753, -0.03753625974059105, -0.026376886293292046, 0.028318865224719048, 0.017272714525461197, 0.04414151608943939, -0.03886048495769501, 0.028455711901187897, 0.07422266900539398, 0.01502037700265646, 0.015327426604926586, 0.027062682434916496, 0.004067566245794296, -0.020761562511324883, -0.012561915442347527, 0.01812998205423355, 0.04598786681890488, -0.018527351319789886, 0.0075484937988221645, -0.01977693662047386, 0.05542491003870964, -0.01517887320369482, -0.018054451793432236, 0.04752862825989723, -0.00021618072059936821, 0.03981864079833031, -0.0004152042674832046, -0.02170475386083126, 0.037277404218912125, -0.035509463399648666, 0.023012323305010796, 0.01706230267882347, 0.028852615505456924, 0.010470105335116386, -0.004694073926657438, -0.00914399977773428, -0.010856960900127888, 0.06377927213907242, -0.017929162830114365, -0.0036047177854925394, 0.013151892460882664, -0.03338158503174782, -0.02282225340604782, -0.04451333358883858, -0.024190492928028107, -0.05631100758910179, -0.01976398564875126, -0.002745813224464655, -0.00790489837527275, 0.024162668734788895, -0.02823013998568058, -0.04571428522467613, 0.021270163357257843, -0.012624367140233517, 0.006679275073111057, -0.025360921397805214, -0.0514044426381588, -0.0032819469925016165, -0.019794095307588577, -0.009297986514866352, 0.019041478633880615, -0.009173842146992683, 0.01878882758319378, -0.02583502046763897, 0.00822832714766264, -0.0734468623995781, -0.015911923721432686, -0.029414206743240356, 0.02242923714220524, -0.018040932714939117, -0.015323682688176632, 0.07703564316034317, -0.022929202765226364, -0.05136978626251221, -0.05043496936559677, -0.03964449092745781, -0.029977187514305115, -0.034248385578393936, 0.011446922086179256, -0.04271853715181351, 0.020121252164244652, 0.034831199795007706, -0.011402950622141361, -0.0384257473051548, -0.020542623475193977, -0.0918813943862915, -0.0636209174990654, 0.01659443974494934, 0.01226093526929617, 0.025436505675315857, 0.018912846222519875, -0.050374727696180344, 0.05514875426888466, 0.03192703798413277, -0.00020854838658124208, -0.052504148334264755, 0.006622291635721922, 0.015478323213756084, -0.062231678515672684, 0.005121889989823103, 0.0304022915661335, 0.0024245691020041704, 0.02806554175913334, 0.00280643324367702, 0.07603850215673447, 0.040153492242097855, 0.015253615565598011, -0.03054632805287838, 0.014555389061570168, 0.021642854437232018, -0.0016509915003553033, 0.021543068811297417, 0.039060402661561966, 0.017053987830877304, 0.013524949550628662, 0.01161383930593729, 0.04963751137256622, 0.02615789696574211, -0.07330701500177383, 0.037935521453619, -0.0021906080655753613, 0.018951784819364548, -0.012619838118553162, -0.0007725260220468044, 0.02077941782772541, 0.010277904570102692, 0.0011278894962742925, -0.0020151061471551657, 0.01560813095420599, -0.009644808247685432, 0.02925710752606392, -0.008753805421292782, 0.05048511549830437, 0.014999124221503735, -0.021661581471562386, -0.01435872446745634, -0.03643239662051201, 0.025849856436252594, 0.008682813495397568, -0.009354243054986, 0.03566022962331772, 0.054989103227853775, 0.04882906749844551, -0.03402449190616608, -0.07740143686532974, 0.04122466221451759, -0.06124858185648918, 0.008702149614691734, 0.004453799221664667, 0.07513134926557541, 0.0017802814254537225, 0.01704917475581169, 0.01747642643749714, -0.005165309179574251, 0.01578921638429165, -0.003955716732889414, -0.08176954835653305, 0.02974788472056389, -0.03571604937314987, 0.04280415549874306, 0.04071395471692085, 0.007231289055198431, 0.011691919527947903, -0.04337875545024872, -0.037273671478033066, -0.019042715430259705, 0.014499356038868427, -0.023603405803442, -0.005484575405716896, -0.014089676551520824, -0.04918741062283516, -0.025039568543434143, -0.03319256752729416, 0.010102925822138786, -0.04111968353390694, 0.0327925980091095, 0.07458817958831787, 0.014310567639768124, -0.01006771158427, -0.02626727521419525, 0.028085986152291298, 0.018531259149312973, 0.045884743332862854, 0.027280429378151894, -0.0014815577305853367, -0.04866088181734085, 0.0693850964307785, 0.014695053920149803, 0.009875843301415443, 0.001637930516153574, -0.042938847094774246, -0.04358048364520073, -0.013236411847174168, -0.049981214106082916, -0.03258850798010826, 0.016455376520752907, 0.02953393943607807, -0.01563338376581669, 0.0682782530784607, 0.047899674624204636, -0.0009860339341685176, 0.018492240458726883, 0.1184118315577507, -0.004301919136196375, -0.05366213992238045, -0.015396365895867348, -0.02738242968916893, 0.0014914319617673755, 0.0063755507580935955, 0.011288671754300594, -0.005348254926502705, -0.046935275197029114, -0.006304183509200811, 0.011782868765294552, -0.01796678453683853, 0.002643390092998743, 0.01261492632329464, 0.036200474947690964, 0.07024228572845459, 0.027960345149040222, -0.00143326073884964, 0.03287648782134056, 0.011800525709986687, 0.05251835659146309, 0.046416595578193665, 0.031351618468761444, -0.06537774950265884, 0.02573760412633419, 0.030783843249082565, 0.027930380776524544, -0.08946283906698227, 0.0009908810025081038, -0.008536051027476788, 0.006786102894693613, 0.023355429992079735, -0.057869940996170044, 0.03276017680764198, -0.03709300234913826, 0.0288992989808321, 0.005172661039978266, -0.01691892184317112, -0.012030396610498428, 0.03280511870980263, -0.0028020027093589306, 0.016051629558205605, -0.00005346993202692829, -0.01988609880208969, -0.04508817568421364, 0.0325884073972702, -0.024262532591819763, 0.030242646113038063, -0.03604989871382713, -0.015284370630979538, 0.0060611264780163765, 0.03772576525807381, -0.03509419038891792, -0.06806878745555878, -0.004038544371724129, 0.002040491672232747, -0.004455669317394495, 0.030583156272768974, 0.028736500069499016, -0.0761435329914093, 0.004478709772229195, 0.007841849699616432, -0.035882338881492615, -0.0009374694200232625, -0.04710223525762558, 0.021827170625329018, 0.020584937185049057, -0.02718450501561165, 0.05733335763216019, 0.06099669635295868, -0.008681152947247028, -0.009585024788975716, -0.03634260222315788, 0.007453358732163906, -0.056562017649412155, 0.008486494421958923, -0.031302690505981445, -0.018717922270298004, -0.00482155941426754, 0.008027113042771816, -0.0197967030107975, 0.06045353412628174, -0.04209916666150093, 0.0009966655634343624, -0.0200975202023983, -0.000014123414985078853, -0.00886958371847868, -0.005682374816387892, 0.027475208044052124, 0.0338514968752861, -0.021392595022916794, -0.013647890649735928, -0.028884727507829666, -0.025416767224669456, 0.016623402014374733, 0.04802745580673218, -0.020730383694171906, 0.012771174311637878, 0.001271766028366983, -0.02636427991092205, 0.010861514136195183, -0.016476105898618698, 0.03572838380932808, -0.016338801011443138, 0.0045150103978812695, -0.009991745464503765, -0.007524723187088966, 0.013664753176271915, 0.008949904702603817, 0.04145440086722374, 0.005597172770649195, -0.06433630734682083, 0.040326833724975586, -0.003740671556442976, -0.026206905022263527, -0.08842992782592773, -0.03291427344083786, 0.003770334180444479, -0.014760302379727364, -0.024876564741134644, -0.027789130806922913, -0.010086528025567532, 0.0005298145115375519, -0.0403275191783905, -0.023408837616443634, 0.06975608319044113, -0.03736423701047897, -0.01674831658601761, -0.04118083789944649, 0.052864570170640945, 0.05344810336828232, -0.03389858081936836, 0.01654857024550438, 0.0005348281119950116, -0.04657374322414398, -0.009645300917327404, -0.025004908442497253, -0.005935377907007933, -0.027354072779417038, 0.0024634473957121372, -0.016058139503002167, -0.020519157871603966, 0.02547622099518776, -0.03806013613939285, 0.02378936856985092, 0.05817084759473801, -0.0002681418554857373, 0.012649702839553356, 0.012383601628243923, 0.04646342247724533, -0.009769691154360771, 0.021129071712493896, 0.013914655894041061, 0.009888092055916786, -0.02863924950361252, -0.005608838517218828, 0.03711472824215889, 0.009170333854854107, 0.009617547504603863, 0.018709400668740273, 0.056617721915245056, -0.012087461538612843, -0.015736976638436317, -0.012289922684431076, -0.013641850091516972, 0.02460082434117794, 0.007286481559276581, 0.02360287494957447, 0.021807240322232246, -0.016680575907230377, -0.046424996107816696, -0.0834667980670929, -0.0012647781986743212, -0.008130352012813091, 0.06134459748864174, -0.018534043803811073, 0.015484859235584736, 0.019428374245762825, 0.012825505807995796, 0.0013711190549656749, -0.03336244449019432, -0.0006481165182776749, -0.024308305233716965, 0.01659643091261387, 0.04255286231637001, -0.010630368255078793, 0.005138261243700981, 0.008457048796117306, 0.022701991721987724, -0.0089131323620677, 0.0314364917576313, 0.02528280019760132, 0.0052832369692623615, 0.024790272116661072, -0.011358455754816532, -0.027989907190203667, 0.03986704349517822, -0.059900883585214615, 0.002994149224832654, -0.0701838880777359, -0.019966265186667442, 0.056219346821308136, 0.02849697694182396, 0.029898758977651596, -0.037359319627285004, -0.021494146436452866, -0.021932074800133705, 0.004145565442740917, 0.017286647111177444, 0.02068788930773735, 0.0651930719614029, -0.029103677719831467, 0.04878544434905052, 0.010673480108380318, 0.018163926899433136, -0.022533049806952477, -0.0854218602180481, 0.009674721397459507, 0.003669340629130602, -0.009951449930667877, 0.019335327669978142, -0.01828780397772789, -0.019753530621528625, 0.03595919534564018, -0.02058992348611355, -0.004602000117301941, 0.029628241434693336, 0.024311061948537827, 0.005788557231426239, 0.06636534631252289, 0.01413652952760458, -0.005147490184754133, 0.008153666742146015, -0.00507411127910018, 0.12728425860404968, 0.06803813576698303, 0.00229795859195292, -0.08065544068813324, 0.01860041916370392, -0.027646901085972786, 0.012550734914839268, -0.023368535563349724, -0.0022951927967369556, 0.01812570169568062, 0.03951502963900566, 0.03007032535970211, 0.06616544723510742, -0.02014872618019581, -0.04643060266971588, 0.025791749358177185, -0.02512325718998909, 0.0021524287294596434, 0.018310917541384697, 0.023790033534169197, 0.009368873201310635, 0.01406124047935009, -0.004942864179611206, 0.007020249962806702, -0.010357948951423168, 0.015848949551582336, 0.012505611404776573, -0.028756659477949142, 0.005015816539525986, -0.022741250693798065, -0.02623031660914421, 0.008480454795062542, 0.01842193678021431, -0.0013261082349345088, 0.012895386666059494, -0.01232808455824852, 0.000056047145335469395, -0.02057802863419056, -0.015129654668271542, 0.02755134180188179, -0.0019083202350884676, 0.014660908840596676, 0.018994977697730064, -0.011393452994525433, -0.09369494765996933, -0.011086193844676018, -0.030167562887072563, -0.010975414887070656, -0.019123705103993416, 0.00807671807706356, -0.04423832520842552, 0.005345664452761412, 0.021983914077281952, -0.04739713296294212, -0.004584531299769878, 0.026707686483860016, 0.017087750136852264, -0.0026307508815079927, -0.05712412670254707, 0.01354790385812521, 0.0075701503083109856, -0.015125762671232224, 0.06849368661642075, 0.005749307107180357, -0.04044625908136368, -0.022794833406805992, -0.007082803640514612, -0.007101273629814386, -0.01833907701075077, 0.019377851858735085, -0.0030035236850380898, 0.03863314911723137, 0.0020790304988622665, -0.04534037038683891, 0.018192781135439873, 0.01950693503022194, 0.035352177917957306, -0.012239379808306694, 0.017060058191418648, -0.01879233494400978, -0.06444663554430008, 0.03581881523132324, -0.01961357891559601, 0.005800868850201368, -0.08347846567630768, 0.025653524324297905, 0.03915977105498314, 0.050709329545497894, 0.0085173724219203, -0.004527643788605928, -0.01105461735278368, 0.07229544222354889, -0.005565532483160496, -0.04230878874659538, -0.01749318093061447, 0.007549898698925972, -0.05772562697529793, -0.027104241773486137, -0.02332710288465023, 0.03218068182468414, 0.035091448575258255, 0.023336216807365417, -0.029873576015233994, 0.025353223085403442, -0.014308941550552845, 0.04491738975048065, 0.03912017121911049, -0.03295860439538956, 0.024631952866911888, 0.031829461455345154, 0.02127166837453842, -0.011381921358406544, -0.005714493338018656, -0.01869109272956848, 0.0008416621130891144, -0.016581419855356216, -0.041739556938409805, -0.03901595622301102, 0.0318140983581543, -0.017530493438243866, 0.021698083728551865, -0.027057819068431854, -0.04085036739706993, -0.038105253130197525, -0.01777554862201214, -0.0002695274306461215, -0.04323145002126694, -0.004511367995291948, 0.027496125549077988, 0.022873904556035995, 0.015408974140882492, 0.045805927366018295, 0.00855545699596405, -0.012421583756804466, -0.0349697582423687, 0.031700488179922104, -0.00037023823824711144, 0.023820269852876663, -0.060398880392313004, -0.018282631412148476, 0.04063336178660393, -0.014121249318122864, 0.0016779842553660274, 0.02634480595588684, 0.003109972458332777, 0.019099527969956398, -0.02014998160302639, 0.010314411483705044, -0.021800704300403595, 0.02785516157746315, -0.011491415090858936, 0.020180169492959976, -0.002734176581725478, -0.03900230675935745, 0.004292716737836599, -0.004689417779445648, -0.011313400231301785, -0.00815607700496912, 0.006606946233659983, 0.028854629024863243, 0.05388743057847023, -0.0057661281898617744, -0.01176594477146864, 0.006773665081709623, 0.008800303563475609, 0.005685992538928986, -0.01172048319131136, 0.00469224713742733, 0.035129349678754807, 0.0034954724833369255, -0.029705852270126343, 0.006514194421470165, -0.0024970006197690964, 0.020229661837220192, -0.04656272009015083, -0.009915962815284729, 0.01881956309080124, 0.016499318182468414, 0.03396928682923317, -0.02896977961063385, 0.014837978407740593, -0.042200859636068344, -0.013231192715466022, -0.01455320417881012, -0.04182418808341026, -0.006949175149202347, -0.0370715893805027, -0.03512435778975487, 0.005046202335506678, 0.018866725265979767, 0.02985277771949768, 0.0006118587916716933, 0.0020585765596479177, 0.006980664096772671, -0.00025198477669619024, -0.02995361015200615, -0.0036871242336928844, 0.015367269515991211, -0.01977907121181488, -0.03835687413811684, 0.024409597739577293, -0.03381602093577385, -0.04316828027367592, 0.023298494517803192, -0.027867818251252174, 0.037776459008455276, 0.02763538993895054, 0.0460001640021801, 0.02661736123263836, 0.06173809617757797, 0.05663235858082771, 0.006733593065291643, -0.04983291029930115, 0.0037462315522134304, 0.037942834198474884, 0.01090914011001587, -0.019099514931440353, -0.01898711733520031, 0.02178249880671501, -0.054760854691267014, -0.02081158757209778, -0.019670335575938225, -0.0007060641655698419, 0.011313825845718384, 0.006463359575718641, -0.009553324431180954, 0.012350129894912243, -0.015418808907270432, 0.019039761275053024, -0.03664771094918251, 0.005221367347985506, 0.07728275656700134, -0.01996140368282795, 0.004380688536912203, -0.00581306591629982, -0.011340456083416939, -0.05380618944764137, 0.019780665636062622, 0.01612824946641922, -0.008793152868747711, -0.06041915714740753, -0.004082886967808008, 0.010936824604868889, -0.022539082914590836, -0.03648301959037781, 0.016201946884393692, 0.015481051057577133, 0.05798296257853508, -0.022817503660917282, 0.06379074603319168, 0.040244173258543015, -0.03126389905810356, -0.015758594498038292, -0.05688580125570297, 0.11109896749258041, 0.016911881044507027, -0.008280962705612183, -0.013260348699986935, -0.022646520286798477, -0.0482262559235096, -0.012714422307908535, 0.07580926269292831, -0.01851871982216835, -0.003171493299305439, -0.042494725435972214, 0.028220297768712044, -0.013409417122602463, -0.009760008193552494, 0.008335771970450878, 0.024572553113102913, -0.018561752513051033, -0.026603426784276962, -0.01080187875777483, -0.04316344112157822, -0.017612800002098083, 0.022475935518741608, -0.03122413530945778, -0.003967389464378357, 0.01777544431388378, 0.0035461403895169497, 0.008014751598238945, 0.02203243412077427, -0.02357415482401848, 0.04037144035100937, 0.006899912375956774, 0.02195371687412262, 0.020610729232430458, -0.028503194451332092, -0.07598722726106644, 0.023032348603010178, -0.033471740782260895, -0.00955263338983059, -0.023925181478261948, 0.017782697454094887, 0.05722423642873764, -0.007334976922720671, -0.03582831099629402, 0.03327252343297005, -0.027789397165179253, 0.0261236522346735, 0.03299986571073532, 0.029269706457853317, 0.05090256780385971, -0.033199116587638855, 0.013865523040294647, 0.02471514418721199, -0.032382186502218246, 0.007200643420219421, -0.00037343858275562525, 0.04094863682985306, -0.008334594778716564, -0.002401364967226982, 0.044602010399103165, 0.0023221392184495926, 0.006990661844611168, -0.000043271644244669005, 0.036148104816675186, -0.037284839898347855, -0.008642088621854782, 0.03831730782985687, -0.02614891715347767, -0.0011992856161668897, -0.0011496365768834949, -0.015440409071743488, 0.03876793012022972, 0.006143486127257347, 0.020255781710147858, -0.024395424872636795, -0.04172602668404579, -0.04031475633382797, 0.017437444999814034, 0.007921514101326466, 0.03467463329434395, -0.0001426188537152484, 0.00195296760648489, 0.012865683063864708, -0.024021290242671967, -0.004502043593674898, -0.0002399877121206373, 0.005966259632259607, -0.0069905780255794525, -0.0020461431704461575, 0.0013054510345682502, -0.030241699889302254, -0.038175854831933975, -0.051706839352846146, 0.004300418309867382, 0.03867708146572113, 0.041464123874902725, -0.013140695169568062, -0.05351526662707329, 0.03289934620261192, 0.050870396196842194, -0.0537414513528347, -0.038638439029455185, -0.0036814729683101177, -0.01230474654585123, 0.0190318301320076, -0.04598201811313629 ]
<p>I am trying to calculate the average of hourly data of three sensors but the hourly timestamps of all three sensors are different. How is it possible to measure the average of hourly data of all three sensors at a regular interval of hours say- 01:00,02:00,03:00 and so on.</p> <p>And also is it possible to start an extensible time series with a specific time which is before the first timestamp of the given dataset so that the extra timestamps have NA values and i can use na.rm=TRUE while calculating mean.:</p> <pre><code> library(xts) library(forecast) data1$V1&lt;-as.POSIXct(paste(data1$V1, data1$V2), format="%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S") sensid&lt;-as.factor(data1$V4) #For Temp for(i in 1:length(levels(sensid))) { l[[i]]=data.frame(data1$V6[data1$V4==i]) l[[i]]&lt;-xts(l[[i]],order.by=data1$V1[data1$V4==i]) if(length(which (is.na(l[[i]])))&lt;length(l[[i]])) { wAvgt[[i]]&lt;-apply.weekly(l[[i]], function(x) sapply(x,mean,na.rm=TRUE)) #Weekly Average of Temp dAvgt[[i]]&lt;- apply.daily(l[[i]], function(x) sapply(x,mean,na.rm=TRUE)) #Daily Average of Temp hrAvgt[[i]] &lt;- period.apply(l[[i]], endpoints(l[[i]], on = "hours", 1), function(x) sapply(x,mean,na.rm=TRUE)) #Hourly Average of Temp #For forecasting future values aritw[[i]]&lt;-auto.arima(wAvgt[[i]]) #Weekly Forecast ARIMA model using ARIMA foretw[[i]]&lt;-forecast.Arima(aritw[[i]],h=5) #Forecast of Weekly Average of Temp arith[[i]]&lt;-auto.arima(hrAvgt[[i]]) #Hourly Forecast ARIMA model using ARIMA foreth[[i]]&lt;-forecast.Arima(arith[[i]],h=50)#Forecast of Hourly Average of Temp aritd[[i]]&lt;-auto.arima(dAvgt[[i]]) #Daily Forecast ARIMA model using ARIMA foretd[[i]]&lt;-forecast.Arima(aritd[[i]],h=10)#Forecast of Daily Average of Temp } else { next } } </code></pre> <p>I have 27 sensors data. so i m trying to caclulate hourly,weekly and daily average of each sensors but each sensor provides 4 critical parameters like - blood pressure, temperature, Pulse and WBC. The above loop provided is only for temperature of 27 sensors. I have a bed connected to some 3 sensors and each sensor has 4 critical parameters to measure. I m concerned only with temperature for now. I need to calculate hourly average of temp for that bed only. So, initially i measure hourly average of any 3 given sensors each and then i intend to take the hourly average between these 3 sensors.</p> <p>The problem i m facing here is each hourly average has different number of rows and different timestamps. How to normalise all the timestamps?</p> <p>If the starting timestamp of sensor 1 is 2004-02-28 00:59:16, sensor 2 is 2004-02-28 01:08:23, sensor 3 is 2004-02-28 01:19:34, it is not possible to normalise them by any methods i know of yet.</p> <p>Please help me find the hourly average of three sensors.</p>
74,363
[ 0.021959789097309113, -0.005783486180007458, -0.007046977058053017, 0.02298206277191639, 0.012071609497070312, -0.0029704009648412466, -0.03309807926416397, -0.034095942974090576, 0.0012363389832898974, -0.003292161738499999, 0.04794057831168175, 0.040852971374988556, 0.041707053780555725, 0.04588732868432999, 0.055902495980262756, 0.001405389979481697, -0.00400051474571228, 0.00046258530346676707, 0.001948369899764657, -0.021845344454050064, -0.021798105910420418, 0.006641368381679058, -0.014005725271999836, -0.03704600781202316, -0.034071922302246094, 0.023838507011532784, 0.008077691309154034, 0.010118076577782631, -0.005616426933556795, 0.058082643896341324, -0.03196005895733833, -0.038291312754154205, 0.024657344445586205, 0.03160228207707405, 0.03285996615886688, 0.02927740477025509, 0.014769801869988441, -0.016827058047056198, 0.016548268496990204, 0.044427916407585144, -0.03850071132183075, 0.03727712482213974, 0.009761128574609756, 0.02109292522072792, -0.0058786640875041485, 0.02648095041513443, 0.01688936911523342, 0.02195805311203003, 0.014592592604458332, -0.029710015282034874, 0.05629322677850723, -0.03497452661395073, 0.0224747471511364, 0.006172845605760813, -0.044654376804828644, -0.009386321529746056, 0.035720475018024445, 0.034750547260046005, 0.014111768454313278, -0.041402220726013184, 0.014345334842801094, -0.004102415405213833, -0.04340693727135658, -0.01665346510708332, -0.025816332548856735, -0.022741351276636124, -0.0030512616503983736, -0.025861885398626328, 0.0020894340705126524, -0.006196386646479368, 0.03895469382405281, 0.005657901056110859, -0.024111432954669, -0.015427155420184135, 0.006456743460148573, 0.0033010898623615503, -0.029375173151493073, -0.0016605138080194592, 0.03311075270175934, 0.02997710183262825, 0.022730695083737373, 0.023824697360396385, 0.03296363353729248, 0.0029610558412969112, 0.04915357008576393, 0.0150967538356781, 0.05897431820631027, -0.005288971122354269, 0.005286900792270899, 0.02236134186387062, -0.0002550983044784516, 0.040116455405950546, 0.03963622450828552, 0.03793159872293472, -0.014568600803613663, 0.03523306921124458, 0.009114899672567844, 0.025334546342492104, -0.043768469244241714, -0.015151523984968662, 0.0005740805063396692, -0.022108325734734535, 0.03169725090265274, 0.004400623496621847, -0.04612763971090317, -0.04656790941953659, -0.023921772837638855, -0.015157775953412056, -0.00860187504440546, -0.04689851403236389, -0.022090379148721695, 0.012495085597038269, -0.0390462726354599, -0.008087549358606339, 0.015764808282256126, -0.023565642535686493, -0.00011875186464749277, 0.01580609753727913, 0.027321720495820045, 0.06580749154090881, 0.08625946193933487, -0.026528730988502502, 0.03623964637517929, -0.012317296117544174, -0.06050500273704529, 0.02014177478849888, -0.040978703647851944, -0.009713603183627129, -0.028399696573615074, 0.04430622607469559, 0.012936647981405258, -0.05667606368660927, 0.046801164746284485, -0.026526551693677902, 0.038298461586236954, 0.008362280204892159, -0.05382320657372475, -0.01994192786514759, 0.05103793740272522, -0.019539449363946915, -0.0035867842379957438, -0.04371199011802673, 0.031557925045490265, -0.016716212034225464, 0.03988664224743843, -0.025167765095829964, 0.02808859944343567, 0.04844316840171814, -0.002485899720340967, -0.03671444579958916, -0.04551559314131737, -0.017467470839619637, -0.03432116284966469, -0.02045968361198902, -0.022078298032283783, -0.056712470948696136, 0.03346792608499527, -0.0039780340157449245, 0.0019199075177311897, 0.021157512441277504, 0.02435578778386116, 0.024602526798844337, -0.005160660017281771, 0.007195847574621439, 0.024373039603233337, -0.03867737203836441, 0.03713013976812363, -0.008047769777476788, -0.004920580890029669, 0.01764470897614956, -0.04004228860139847, 0.0017872105818241835, -0.014991226606070995, 0.04976372793316841, 0.036796730011701584, 0.029254909604787827, -0.010153587907552719, -0.017679385840892792, 0.020799139514565468, 0.003904073964804411, -0.008776983246207237, -0.012394927442073822, -0.004020763095468283, -0.03044026345014572, 0.032123368233442307, 0.012588072568178177, 0.0002747045364230871, -0.013541811145842075, 0.02655276283621788, -0.05380072072148323, -0.022350329905748367, -0.04315011203289032, -0.01761549338698387, 0.0029357876628637314, -0.0488862544298172, -0.007075238972902298, -0.028572022914886475, 0.042946770787239075, 0.010844666510820389, -0.011064538732171059, -0.017403583973646164, 0.023583421483635902, 0.06917423754930496, -0.03288847208023071, -0.03111683763563633, 0.05180681124329567, 0.04188605397939682, 0.008663521148264408, 0.040529247373342514, -0.032366715371608734, -0.0018715366022661328, 0.02086336724460125, -0.0693950429558754, 0.007937154732644558, -0.008285953663289547, 0.011889560148119926, 0.030968597158789635, 0.030905192717909813, -0.014089326374232769, 0.05584929510951042, -0.07413413375616074, -0.00607812125235796, 0.06640081852674484, -0.009955590590834618, 0.010797112248837948, -0.007500051520764828, 0.028176704421639442, 0.034834325313568115, -0.03199800103902817, -0.0020699810702353716, -0.07271768152713776, -0.014975341036915779, 0.02438604086637497, 0.04404948279261589, 0.014976203441619873, 0.01130392961204052, 0.049875952303409576, -0.009743046015501022, 0.00038052344461902976, 0.05598760023713112, 0.04291106387972832, 0.007012686692178249, -0.0016848084051162004, 0.006289044860750437, 0.006417032331228256, -0.0032984802965074778, 0.022700155153870583, 0.0007399767637252808, 0.03164072707295418, 0.029241057112812996, -0.022855009883642197, 0.03969046100974083, 0.01103497389703989, 0.029727712273597717, 0.008295681327581406, -0.016068561002612114, 0.05363933742046356, -0.001786876586265862, 0.010482797399163246, 0.01185090932995081, 0.03663632273674011, -0.0159043837338686, 0.052694935351610184, -0.003414047183468938, -0.008522527292370796, 0.05402625724673271, -0.04208403453230858, -0.041581571102142334, 0.013688966631889343, -0.007842153310775757, 0.022318577393889427, -0.015764813870191574, -0.00337669113650918, -0.03473108634352684, 0.004481516312807798, 0.03591316193342209, 0.009876800701022148, 0.024963151663541794, -0.03889092057943344, -0.015733428299427032, 0.01279155258089304, -0.03349016606807709, 0.011230378411710262, 0.03767065331339836, 0.018793532624840736, 0.0007192799239419401, 0.0008979300619103014, -0.03196016699075699, 0.037239816039800644, 0.0041048526763916016, -0.037220194935798645, 0.05746658518910408, -0.0020187515765428543, -0.03656537085771561, 0.010605067014694214, -0.053723208606243134, 0.001590594882145524, -0.0583675242960453, -0.006778862327337265, 0.04547307267785072, 0.022435614839196205, -0.06891275197267532, -0.019672894850373268, -0.054747823625802994, 0.02062065340578556, -0.015922579914331436, -0.009346941486001015, -0.021264677867293358, 0.03542650118470192, 0.010193001478910446, 0.03286335989832878, -0.03009999729692936, -0.00973460078239441, -0.03690553829073906, -0.04439328983426094, 0.013371242210268974, -0.004877992440015078, 0.0178611371666193, 0.012243167497217655, -0.008568787947297096, 0.06159979850053787, 0.044400475919246674, -0.03301573917269707, -0.015400445088744164, -0.014594576321542263, -0.015807267278432846, -0.024483175948262215, 0.02896803244948387, -0.0023248204961419106, -0.0011201155139133334, -0.019042721018195152, 0.011300920508801937, 0.03489530459046364, 0.05112563818693161, 0.0006780590629205108, 0.05411797761917114, -0.023874785751104355, -0.004527234006673098, -0.009784623980522156, 0.037208180874586105, 0.019997525960206985, 0.026067258790135384, -0.017147276550531387, 0.0022812490351498127, 0.014321474358439445, 0.006215336732566357, -0.051695551723241806, 0.008307055570185184, 0.024573830887675285, 0.035423312336206436, -0.07065561413764954, 0.042886096984148026, 0.021259086206555367, -0.035747505724430084, -0.05365396663546562, 0.027127379551529884, 0.045474786311388016, -0.05242273956537247, 0.0008611484663560987, 0.04509829357266426, 0.05582423880696297, -0.026635872200131416, 0.005891159642487764, -0.01144458632916212, 0.003534113522619009, 0.012279087677598, -0.04489949345588684, -0.02335464023053646, 0.0672084242105484, 0.07548920065164566, 0.02662575989961624, 0.0009497342980466783, -0.01703256368637085, 0.052461206912994385, -0.07705400884151459, 0.0029792755376547575, -0.05372897908091545, 0.05974630266427994, 0.026297984644770622, 0.043407343327999115, 0.020234689116477966, 0.007279368583112955, 0.032196201384067535, -0.03830016776919365, -0.05261848866939545, 0.024432159960269928, 0.023584304377436638, -0.0017158492701128125, -0.0019407920772209764, -0.0586896613240242, 0.028618844226002693, -0.04260438308119774, 0.010087937116622925, -0.0018626811215654016, 0.010958894155919552, -0.035736069083213806, 0.014480005949735641, 0.006811619736254215, 0.022977881133556366, -0.044535089284181595, 0.00999425258487463, 0.1063135489821434, -0.02105010114610195, 0.018878642469644547, 0.03379654884338379, -0.006031883880496025, 0.009218634106218815, -0.03271587938070297, 0.007509476505219936, 0.027690209448337555, 0.01829141564667225, 0.0447726845741272, 0.01411640178412199, -0.014834390953183174, 0.019602132961153984, 0.007236409932374954, 0.01799469254910946, 0.054843734949827194, -0.01393511239439249, -0.02917172946035862, -0.003480927785858512, 0.017175057902932167, 0.04008559137582779, 0.030231263488531113, -0.017759885638952255, 0.031131528317928314, 0.01798338070511818, 0.011605467647314072, -0.006270754616707563, 0.015348095446825027, 0.0638139396905899, 0.013885755091905594, 0.010286440141499043, -0.044762443751096725, -0.0023560249246656895, -0.023135729134082794, -0.010493083856999874, 0.04479462280869484, 0.012132080271840096, -0.013730227015912533, 0.009594608098268509, -0.011611736379563808, 0.0008217276772484183, -0.02318287454545498, 0.015863677486777306, 0.019160166382789612, 0.06470713019371033, -0.012077699415385723, -0.055470507591962814, -0.01622537337243557, 0.053311459720134735, 0.014477956108748913, -0.013460750691592693, 0.027195772156119347, -0.13959713280200958, 0.013882488012313843, 0.05015796050429344, 0.0429949015378952, -0.02017810568213463, -0.02556457929313183, -0.021061791107058525, -0.005591282621026039, 0.03769931197166443, -0.008733796887099743, 0.02668280526995659, 0.0028050036635249853, 0.011177201755344868, -0.04029854014515877, -0.04284660518169403, -0.024889729917049408, -0.03835892304778099, -0.03592286258935928, 0.024100102484226227, 0.005304747726768255, -0.05754675343632698, -0.013454539701342583, 0.015917081385850906, 0.027909431606531143, -0.011233512312173843, -0.05203495919704437, -0.02319701388478279, 0.008205932565033436, 0.022256920114159584, -0.006830282509326935, -0.04029861465096474, -0.002865878865122795, 0.018637441098690033, -0.03146324306726456, 0.04572976008057594, -0.006259032525122166, 0.003580548567697406, 0.04082552716135979, 0.006709497421979904, -0.0356365405023098, -0.03350731357932091, -0.03271020948886871, 0.04419700801372528, 0.030399499461054802, -0.006307817064225674, 0.04604516550898552, 0.028337517753243446, 0.026132022961974144, 0.04014642536640167, -0.04711468890309334, -0.015355813317000866, -0.04513203352689743, -0.020284011960029602, -0.043615248054265976, -0.030745618045330048, 0.009123298339545727, 0.020640632137656212, -0.025100070983171463, 0.029172683134675026, -0.024348059669137, 0.0142299709841609, 0.014146682806313038, 0.025293365120887756, -0.032424990087747574, -0.01788848452270031, -0.013025538064539433, 0.00929789524525404, -0.027133777737617493, -0.03878075256943703, 0.004433220252394676, -0.030754517763853073, -0.012324509210884571, 0.02382594533264637, -0.04077477380633354, -0.004555738531053066, -0.013760353438556194, 0.026394851505756378, 0.02100655436515808, 0.009020973928272724, -0.028875593096017838, 0.004528778605163097, 0.08070598542690277, 0.011284098029136658, -0.007073629181832075, 0.0033121276646852493, 0.015101633034646511, -0.020319407805800438, -0.004111416172236204, 0.0029419828206300735, 0.0738440677523613, 0.017649857327342033, -0.0113255325704813, -0.05530776083469391, -0.004584843758493662, -0.0061573367565870285, -0.01901387795805931, -0.05671045929193497, -0.05604822561144829, -0.006709260866045952, -0.052833426743745804, 0.004847973585128784, -0.027409786358475685, 0.028268583118915558, -0.03871775045990944, -0.010142968967556953, -0.0019463862990960479, 0.014360938221216202, 0.08246224373579025, -0.000019538314518285915, 0.032180000096559525, 0.00209440547041595, -0.0036953033413738012, -0.03112177923321724, -0.04476558044552803, -0.01071531604975462, -0.042353514581918716, -0.02477368898689747, 0.011226396076381207, -0.03261621668934822, 0.06056388095021248, -0.011570095084607601, -0.013995436020195484, 0.006869788281619549, -0.00022715391241945326, 0.014903373084962368, -0.062441349029541016, 0.013434884138405323, 0.009151761420071125, 0.0003139941254630685, -0.02500481903553009, 0.01006372645497322, -0.022063231095671654, -0.02391621842980385, -0.009643741883337498, -0.0139699038118124, -0.0015746643766760826, 0.02368840016424656, 0.05844314768910408, 0.024568570777773857, 0.017750119790434837, 0.007018103264272213, 0.006082987878471613, 0.0004324145847931504, -0.032216574996709824, 0.0001794309209799394, -0.00867173820734024, -0.0022385341580957174, -0.02487345226109028, -0.0719892606139183, -0.05781583860516548, -0.02662712149322033, 0.03926561772823334, -0.015444612130522728, 0.05458293855190277, 0.03056485950946808, 0.03392324969172478, 0.01469123549759388, -0.05245882645249367, -0.014688494615256786, -0.02277265302836895, -0.014345823787152767, 0.0793624147772789, 0.005954201798886061, -0.022815363481640816, -0.004474025685340166, -0.009688450023531914, 0.04133797064423561, 0.01613970845937729, 0.02074243128299713, 0.0024361410178244114, -0.04414847120642662, -0.003878288436681032, -0.03928158059716225, 0.027488991618156433, -0.008186843246221542, -0.0004483778029680252, -0.048558399081230164, -0.028245240449905396, -0.003971661441028118, -0.011277205310761929, -0.03949068486690521, -0.06973650306463242, -0.034884724766016006, -0.060762710869312286, 0.008940642699599266, 0.0412733368575573, -0.012722245417535305, 0.02620687335729599, 0.05319301038980484, 0.018794046714901924, -0.027641111984848976, 0.019769510254263878, -0.035492293536663055, -0.05940349027514458, 0.012735151685774326, 0.01210656575858593, -0.0521710142493248, 0.07780799269676208, -0.026259377598762512, -0.016521256417036057, -0.016025232151150703, -0.032010745257139206, 0.047310106456279755, -0.006125176791101694, 0.04158177599310875, 0.02942103147506714, 0.09050924330949783, -0.0055565666407346725, -0.002114073606207967, -0.024168362841010094, 0.013218974694609642, 0.14973871409893036, 0.04059506207704544, 0.04839494451880455, -0.03789743781089783, -0.017181286588311195, 0.03612503781914711, 0.004121264908462763, -0.054889168590307236, 0.011865432374179363, -0.009935394860804081, 0.021230259910225868, 0.04651433229446411, 0.01331200823187828, -0.007498867344111204, -0.01126992329955101, 0.03472994267940521, -0.01795903593301773, 0.007289716508239508, 0.0016955342143774033, 0.01984022743999958, 0.010951069183647633, 0.007928017526865005, -0.063355952501297, 0.052389077842235565, -0.00140663783531636, -0.016114814206957817, 0.0014816013863310218, -0.014119572006165981, 0.007381561677902937, 0.00709680886939168, -0.03837813436985016, 0.040709588676691055, 0.03276607394218445, 0.03218216449022293, 0.01914413459599018, 0.0017617258708924055, -0.014980045147240162, -0.041812628507614136, 0.04839516431093216, 0.04443468153476715, -0.004579627420753241, -0.0293488260358572, -0.0028435129206627607, 0.034668195992708206, -0.035682469606399536, -0.0071021211333572865, -0.06762712448835373, 0.027884535491466522, -0.0022121076472103596, -0.038113802671432495, 0.001768917078152299, 0.025622013956308365, 0.015313180163502693, -0.04387878626585007, -0.026421204209327698, -0.0016361202578991652, 0.05886968970298767, -0.035060346126556396, -0.0048436629585921764, 0.0021343696862459183, 0.030890755355358124, 0.023300811648368835, 0.036264818161726, 0.02578647807240486, -0.002972091780975461, -0.03234503045678139, -0.02297009713947773, 0.03711105138063431, -0.025617487728595734, 0.017961112782359123, 0.0357392281293869, 0.02176794596016407, -0.011077399365603924, -0.01918819732964039, 0.025011606514453888, -0.017840320244431496, 0.009140962734818459, 0.01739467866718769, -0.026901543140411377, -0.0012636075261980295, -0.057821374386548996, -0.0314541794359684, -0.012129503302276134, -0.011494755744934082, -0.002442537108436227, 0.022123295813798904, 0.0512951985001564, 0.020832138136029243, 0.04036758467555046, 0.003579310607165098, -0.00415846286341548, 0.08535700291395187, 0.009152766317129135, -0.03441960737109184, -0.038856957107782364, 0.011090656742453575, -0.04155943915247917, -0.007865887135267258, 0.017622318118810654, 0.06622827053070068, 0.02459077537059784, 0.012020960450172424, -0.025115378201007843, 0.016069184988737106, -0.005795022938400507, -0.002051818883046508, 0.00971988309174776, -0.0012274077162146568, 0.038390930742025375, -0.009489479474723339, 0.03266081213951111, -0.03401581943035126, -0.01360225584357977, -0.012170469388365746, -0.037065327167510986, -0.007903619669377804, -0.05589563772082329, -0.01723901927471161, 0.027595143765211105, -0.011103869415819645, 0.010698812082409859, -0.010970771312713623, 0.002662271959707141, -0.014864547178149223, -0.04041790962219238, -0.04159101843833923, -0.059220511466264725, -0.016950253397226334, 0.015825064852833748, -0.05403858423233032, -0.016802387312054634, 0.0240588691085577, 0.005819227546453476, -0.0009461740264669061, -0.041706304997205734, -0.006851510610431433, -0.01686476543545723, 0.021066926419734955, 0.020388998091220856, -0.026275698095560074, 0.015312626026570797, -0.0519787073135376, -0.02571284957230091, 0.01428817119449377, 0.004777386784553528, 0.02949717454612255, 0.0051138391718268394, -0.02904641442000866, -0.034753624349832535, 0.03226246312260628, -0.029760969802737236, 0.00808040052652359, 0.001212074770592153, -0.005605651531368494, -0.0051786755211651325, 0.02486789971590042, -0.023647818714380264, 0.039499349892139435, 0.03452214226126671, -0.013507595285773277, 0.05046629160642624, -0.006433024536818266, -0.0015264307148754597, -0.009845049120485783, -0.012354450300335884, -0.013822957873344421, -0.013932738453149796, -0.01489641610532999, 0.032847385853528976, 0.04608874022960663, -0.008390521630644798, 0.007750790566205978, -0.058028217405080795, -0.005589915905147791, -0.06641378998756409, 0.007322967052459717, 0.02465081587433815, 0.019604578614234924, -0.02182685025036335, -0.029125506058335304, 0.004497874993830919, 0.0035113433841615915, -0.008739173412322998, 0.020329052582383156, 0.025707006454467773, -0.0012478192802518606, -0.011797383427619934, 0.053348638117313385, -0.02276047132909298, -0.014636216685175896, 0.05217983201146126, -0.01055062934756279, 0.009190287441015244, 0.018768901005387306, 0.04560903459787369, -0.046490628272295, -0.03383634239435196, 0.017028585076332092, 0.03774084523320198, -0.05996961519122124, 0.03734360262751579, -0.0503242202103138, 0.018499914556741714, 0.021808385848999023, -0.007299597375094891, 0.005948237143456936, -0.002921817824244499, 0.02382844127714634, 0.008800933137536049, 0.04997790977358818, -0.020975742489099503, -0.003466412890702486, 0.002707222243770957, -0.013500742614269257, 0.006131802685558796, 0.0071168988943099976, 0.008113410323858261, 0.014155466109514236, 0.020576944574713707, -0.005662356503307819, -0.042094871401786804, -0.003104335628449917, 0.0004965272382833064, -0.05099768564105034, 0.006716816686093807, -0.01643701083958149, -0.015360547229647636, -0.04649022966623306, -0.000517080130521208, -0.015200458467006683, 0.03353043273091316, 0.059111855924129486, 0.02983132004737854, -0.042919550091028214, 0.0030970368534326553, 0.004476128611713648, -0.047637250274419785, -0.009539803490042686, 0.026353348046541214, 0.012220986187458038, -0.03464242070913315, -0.02026377245783806, -0.021210243925452232, -0.005305700935423374, -0.020269498229026794, 0.03034607134759426, -0.05371067672967911, 0.030630839988589287, -0.03615275397896767, 0.013520338572561741, -0.011682501994073391, -0.014832718297839165, -0.005870346911251545, -0.10296405851840973, 0.0800846740603447, 0.020955661311745644, -0.003099475521594286, -0.036920201033353806, -0.05918089300394058, -0.05088672414422035, 0.05694343522191048, 0.04284483566880226, 0.03444276377558708, -0.00040308971074409783, -0.007456623483449221, 0.03474901244044304, -0.024555640295147896, -0.03229943662881851, 0.06336185336112976, 0.019753742963075638, -0.0015919870929792523, 0.03008228912949562, -0.03944097459316254, 0.008741114288568497, 0.016812220215797424, -0.022007973864674568, -0.03309148550033569, -0.011156227439641953, 0.007220132276415825, -0.023011337965726852, 0.00927742850035429, -0.012399065308272839, -0.01136511005461216, 0.027198126539587975, 0.011705737560987473, -0.0074467440135777, 0.024756425991654396, -0.008792425505816936, -0.012580901384353638, 0.04032808169722557, -0.04622763395309448, 0.002009280491620302, 0.007367456331849098, 0.003710747929289937, 0.026502126827836037, -0.04405505955219269, -0.023354945704340935, 0.018243901431560516, -0.005212679505348206, 0.011984161101281643, 0.05017716810107231, -0.03223882615566254, 0.039151329547166824, -0.04261191934347153, 0.05146730691194534, -0.02155088260769844, 0.007867448031902313, 0.05063726752996445, -0.009133024141192436, 0.01248929463326931, -0.02440350316464901, -0.02526409924030304, 0.030258934944868088, -0.006635870784521103, 0.02483557164669037, -0.021199699491262436, 0.05015707388520241, 0.02034725248813629, -0.037188105285167694, 0.023271407932043076, -0.028272051364183426, -0.02605077624320984, -0.01139076892286539, 0.027159908786416054, 0.05255526304244995, -0.040633659809827805, 0.02593652904033661, -0.0338270477950573, -0.04388152062892914, -0.003364318050444126, 0.031117912381887436, -0.025097347795963287, 0.023609118536114693, -0.030743839219212532, 0.050604432821273804, 0.04465784132480621, -0.006406624801456928, -0.023989196866750717, -0.023038312792778015, 0.020401829853653908, -0.008733546361327171, -0.004067352507263422, -0.004353193566203117, -0.01445059198886156, -0.02161898836493492, -0.03014678880572319, -0.007773430552333593, 0.048351943492889404, 0.004617850296199322, 0.009896144270896912, -0.022510461509227753, 0.013275587931275368, 0.030827896669507027, -0.07339713722467422, -0.00844040047377348, -0.006642723456025124, 0.006000311113893986, 0.020900988951325417, -0.04832214489579201 ]
<p>I've the following situation.</p> <p>I've a binary classifier which classifies input feature vectors into either of two classes 'y' or 'n', along with the probability of it being in either of the classes P_y and P_n. I know that the classifier is right 60% of the time. How do I estimate the true probability of it being in each of the classes? </p> <p>What I'm doing now is to compute 0.6*P_y / (0.6*P_y + 0.4*(1- P_y)). This is a Bayesian adjustment, but I'm not sure if I'm doing the right thing. Any pointers much appreciated.</p>
37,217
[ -0.01523633673787117, -0.01459561102092266, -0.011738996021449566, -0.006080224644392729, 0.028283383697271347, 0.032197073101997375, 0.015934543684124947, 0.0008410107111558318, 0.022391043603420258, -0.020726338028907776, 0.03616693243384361, 0.06698447465896606, 0.06366230547428131, 0.036265257745981216, 0.00424587819725275, -0.013203560374677181, -0.016030697152018547, -0.02454945631325245, 0.004485076759010553, -0.037651177495718, -0.0048244488425552845, 0.02043779008090496, 0.037785422056913376, -0.03146051615476608, -0.013676345348358154, 0.04872534051537514, 0.03813963010907173, -0.0034692029003053904, 0.030033297836780548, 0.06542970985174179, -0.021366877481341362, -0.03860480338335037, 0.006268746219575405, 0.0563860684633255, 0.05056111514568329, -0.00987288635224104, 0.00015712306776549667, -0.020524488762021065, -0.03263314440846443, 0.014303208328783512, -0.02456481195986271, 0.004692074842751026, -0.011668250896036625, 0.053299788385629654, -0.01639081910252571, 0.013213095255196095, 0.0032123352866619825, -0.011036229319870472, 0.040447745472192764, -0.048955608159303665, 0.08514571934938431, -0.021851785480976105, 0.02171054482460022, 0.07280424237251282, -0.0018744294065982103, -0.011051647365093231, 0.05589192733168602, 0.08676151186227798, -0.013996480032801628, -0.021916041150689125, -0.016489151865243912, -0.025894159451127052, -0.021129151806235313, -0.04365822672843933, -0.016366196796298027, 0.015057976357638836, -0.02785036899149418, -0.04225284233689308, 0.026015089824795723, 0.0040453108958899975, 0.004098503850400448, 0.010762959718704224, 0.03455686569213867, -0.03983867168426514, 0.02496016025543213, -0.053579181432724, 0.012985515408217907, 0.07852163910865784, 0.011145597323775291, 0.001432872610166669, 0.00046606393880210817, 0.010222573764622211, 0.011796815320849419, 0.04495701566338539, 0.009941589087247849, -0.04248071834445, 0.06413274258375168, -0.01928129605948925, 0.043046656996011734, 0.016620846465229988, -0.04173710569739342, 0.01773430034518242, 0.03673838824033737, 0.0038584815338253975, -0.05311156064271927, 0.07295750081539154, -0.001980286091566086, 0.03914628177881241, 0.013140130788087845, -0.01628921739757061, 0.022633522748947144, -0.019750304520130157, -0.016535140573978424, 0.06876669824123383, -0.05511615052819252, -0.013544153422117233, -0.041517823934555054, 0.0014477873919531703, 0.01512238010764122, -0.0018525703344494104, -0.015237725339829922, 0.033846139907836914, 0.006101064383983612, -0.011704918928444386, 0.007002574857324362, -0.02115015871822834, -0.01538042537868023, -0.0185981597751379, 0.011755774728953838, 0.05951949581503868, 0.03544636443257332, -0.03471947833895683, 0.051974210888147354, -0.010197342373430729, -0.03716995194554329, -0.0033202737104147673, 0.011264893226325512, -0.02697279490530491, -0.011895029805600643, 0.036996714770793915, -0.018827227875590324, -0.0254195723682642, 0.032147157937288284, -0.01732698641717434, -0.0045715561136603355, 0.011041182093322277, -0.06746659427881241, -0.04388255998492241, -0.0012661602813750505, -0.02794543281197548, -0.0099266292527318, -0.055747345089912415, 0.016331946477293968, 0.04956955462694168, 0.03935727849602699, -0.010089600458741188, 0.03727798908948898, 0.03037443570792675, 0.013834952376782894, -0.02693314477801323, -0.03972122073173523, -0.023516420274972916, -0.027760570868849754, -0.020437126979231834, -0.020969899371266365, -0.11133161187171936, 0.007571637164801359, -0.0012101673055440187, -0.0065096113830804825, -0.04440993815660477, 0.008996323682367802, 0.0030039239209145308, -0.0280652716755867, -0.02029924839735031, 0.03232773020863533, -0.023236839100718498, 0.07998858392238617, 0.02100912295281887, 0.025579407811164856, 0.024785218760371208, -0.017994197085499763, -0.0004203811986371875, 0.030620142817497253, 0.037530623376369476, 0.06523244827985764, -0.05474536493420601, -0.019276851788163185, -0.023577870801091194, 0.040674950927495956, -0.002031255979090929, -0.024125073105096817, -0.020261714234948158, -0.010940308682620525, 0.00015775689098518342, -0.023829059675335884, 0.0216143149882555, 0.026196179911494255, -0.030879421159625053, 0.01819288730621338, -0.027912987396121025, -0.02660606987774372, -0.058221735060214996, -0.011910634115338326, -0.018796708434820175, -0.034933269023895264, 0.01972593180835247, 0.03393521159887314, 0.023466598242521286, -0.03304995223879814, -0.018223309889435768, -0.04964076727628708, -0.027955075725913048, 0.01705380342900753, -0.04792878404259682, -0.016819089651107788, 0.07220031321048737, 0.033472876995801926, -0.01835026405751705, 0.08247468620538712, -0.05714159831404686, -0.023970840498805046, 0.004356811288744211, -0.01989237777888775, -0.013940989039838314, -0.015066687017679214, -0.022875934839248657, 0.04849250614643097, -0.025497090071439743, 0.0034996126778423786, 0.024369366466999054, -0.0466870479285717, 0.056281160563230515, 0.05791105329990387, 0.001826715306378901, 0.0028313908260315657, 0.0040277475491166115, -0.011796589009463787, -0.0012998238671571016, 0.0007384076016023755, 0.010541989468038082, -0.056266628205776215, 0.0020099205430597067, 0.04942479729652405, -0.0026884896215051413, -0.02415960468351841, 0.009409019723534584, 0.05316294729709625, -0.003651296952739358, 0.0028087287209928036, 0.03976040333509445, -0.005934827029705048, -0.018576113507151604, 0.023171884939074516, 0.009127218276262283, 0.007360056508332491, 0.004588155075907707, 0.0444355309009552, 0.008361038751900196, 0.05906295403838158, -0.0009381115669384599, -0.010272679850459099, 0.03762690722942352, -0.007372192572802305, 0.03679263964295387, -0.013229331001639366, -0.03495392948389053, 0.01872800476849079, 0.004204921890050173, 0.007022610399872065, 0.020041989162564278, -0.02075606770813465, -0.029809659346938133, 0.019498014822602272, -0.029909400269389153, 0.03938458487391472, 0.037344370037317276, -0.04873839020729065, 0.010722125880420208, 0.016948502510786057, -0.03675724193453789, 0.013273085467517376, 0.01640309952199459, -0.04985945299267769, -0.012307209894061089, 0.055004019290208817, 0.032522186636924744, 0.01116526871919632, 0.03046586364507675, -0.03168739750981331, -0.02536020427942276, 0.010029204189777374, -0.004731083754450083, 0.03106902539730072, -0.025480881333351135, -0.09070928394794464, 0.009522109292447567, -0.006089910864830017, -0.03427789360284805, 0.001676811370998621, -0.02553197368979454, -0.05807140842080116, 0.01187533512711525, -0.022306548431515694, -0.025758668780326843, -0.01079253014177084, -0.027371764183044434, 0.008342397399246693, -0.017619814723730087, -0.036281485110521317, 0.017595482990145683, 0.0018054007086902857, -0.031604886054992676, 0.03172745555639267, -0.02126920036971569, -0.044194817543029785, -0.05261997878551483, -0.0014679183950647712, 0.008584722876548767, 0.0026961693074554205, 0.024108057841658592, 0.02622404135763645, -0.013888183981180191, -0.0021587552037090063, -0.05840471014380455, -0.0977620929479599, 0.010012387298047543, -0.008255476132035255, 0.013729597441852093, 0.01853364147245884, 0.0134507417678833, 0.06449810415506363, 0.0065299104899168015, -0.038795534521341324, 0.010406171903014183, 0.021455155685544014, -0.011760166846215725, 0.017476173117756844, 0.02866450510919094, 0.01837688870728016, -0.01587771624326706, 0.03818480297923088, -0.004425286781042814, -0.005309666972607374, 0.06146937981247902, -0.0023388739209622145, 0.001766317174769938, 0.014133768156170845, -0.01734589971601963, -0.008200166746973991, 0.038620129227638245, 0.01172375213354826, -0.03285454586148262, 0.024883106350898743, -0.03069085069000721, -0.01456072274595499, 0.02685713581740856, -0.032770946621894836, -0.0071930899284780025, -0.034787729382514954, 0.01348009705543518, -0.04972744360566139, 0.02653457596898079, 0.00685685221105814, -0.013922430574893951, 0.022795623168349266, 0.0016097408952191472, 0.04969325661659241, -0.003580319695174694, 0.018078653141856194, 0.06782778352499008, 0.026980752125382423, 0.010437685064971447, -0.021902503445744514, -0.0003694310144055635, -0.006937004160135984, 0.015216335654258728, -0.020411349833011627, -0.020245317369699478, 0.01900501549243927, 0.023368149995803833, 0.03484285995364189, -0.013833352364599705, -0.021206354722380638, 0.026488251984119415, -0.05908825993537903, -0.013145986944437027, -0.016208045184612274, 0.03633160516619682, 0.012077935971319675, 0.016787024214863777, 0.010517988353967667, -0.02250787615776062, 0.023490477353334427, 0.022368159145116806, -0.06691616773605347, 0.03183094039559364, -0.007718291133642197, -0.023667432367801666, -0.0317968875169754, -0.02008398249745369, 0.04022151604294777, -0.04466773197054863, 0.0037147237453609705, -0.01012189220637083, -0.010736518539488316, -0.044610247015953064, 0.01968499831855297, -0.017824331298470497, -0.007181516382843256, 0.00856017880141735, 0.022548740729689598, 0.044338956475257874, 0.018528437241911888, 0.029549596831202507, 0.05590086802840233, 0.013782031834125519, -0.0010199544485658407, -0.0021787015721201897, 0.013287420384585857, 0.006564748007804155, 0.044217441231012344, 0.029207486659288406, 0.08278633654117584, -0.028875786811113358, 0.029874315485358238, 0.003832456888630986, 0.061798322945833206, 0.07219964265823364, -0.030267439782619476, -0.020927852019667625, -0.04944278299808502, -0.032670844346284866, -0.02280263416469097, 0.02584182657301426, -0.0026865198742598295, -0.012082161381840706, 0.055670928210020065, 0.020317384973168373, -0.09243706613779068, 0.0026383036747574806, 0.08835197985172272, -0.00882712285965681, -0.002939357189461589, -0.039504703134298325, 0.0017160773277282715, -0.029420282691717148, -0.005849593318998814, 0.02379130944609642, 0.02478942833840847, -0.026590408757328987, -0.0075092557817697525, 0.03509905934333801, 0.00124318094458431, 0.0013420035829767585, -0.01597018353641033, 0.024500619620084763, 0.0266654584556818, 0.015893926844000816, -0.0291738398373127, 0.0028391811065375805, 0.05630479380488396, 0.033125121146440506, 0.0013330866349861026, 0.0030069819185882807, -0.08921872079372406, -0.0023698045406490564, 0.043166808784008026, 0.052155204117298126, -0.056335534900426865, -0.002918665064498782, -0.017169799655675888, -0.008738495409488678, 0.06884615123271942, -0.033684294670820236, 0.03199473023414612, -0.0024624515790492296, 0.011573458090424538, 0.03464113920927048, 0.0037262116093188524, -0.08804161101579666, -0.0012313785264268517, -0.03420013561844826, 0.05045735463500023, -0.04041771963238716, -0.04637056961655617, -0.0364929661154747, 0.009337021969258785, 0.03153102472424507, 0.06830864399671555, -0.018333587795495987, -0.024162674322724342, -0.024876784533262253, 0.017200030386447906, 0.02782422862946987, -0.07423458248376846, 0.024099266156554222, -0.007181236986070871, -0.03268947824835777, 0.031094523146748543, -0.026959560811519623, -0.04798002168536186, 0.022150425240397453, 0.0012523644836619496, -0.04057342931628227, -0.030240485444664955, -0.013421221636235714, 0.02456451952457428, 0.03769468888640404, 0.022618262097239494, 0.03247785195708275, -0.013887246139347553, 0.021462036296725273, -0.022663235664367676, -0.030534684658050537, 0.005153140518814325, -0.02227998897433281, -0.010405137203633785, -0.007044376339763403, 0.009357728995382786, 0.002820377005264163, 0.04917098581790924, -0.008479985408484936, 0.042090803384780884, -0.015200391411781311, -0.027476731687784195, -0.02327844686806202, 0.014467807486653328, 0.0018169617978855968, -0.018890738487243652, -0.01436800416558981, 0.00202692742459476, 0.010047979652881622, 0.03012077510356903, 0.02892342023551464, -0.006225998047739267, -0.013496367260813713, 0.020028812810778618, -0.02415352500975132, 0.017969217151403427, -0.01694149151444435, -0.03241496905684471, 0.019462766125798225, -0.04202212020754814, 0.016746820881962776, 0.010710516013205051, 0.05248723179101944, -0.009667390026152134, -0.04296904429793358, -0.03546769171953201, -0.010409988462924957, 0.029536984860897064, 0.04727181792259216, -0.04384976625442505, 0.02066039852797985, -0.03790617734193802, 0.03728712350130081, -0.06450573354959488, -0.012352277524769306, 0.004143596161156893, 0.03316662088036537, -0.037764064967632294, -0.0620214119553566, 0.019614502787590027, 0.020761676132678986, -0.010553080588579178, 0.0008233730331994593, 0.01126005593687296, -0.01761436276137829, -0.027118515223264694, -0.0005335908499546349, 0.006256834603846073, 0.06899154931306839, -0.01219446025788784, 0.008062412962317467, 0.03846574202179909, -0.0032537116203457117, -0.013087376020848751, 0.014384877867996693, 0.019222399219870567, -0.026165083050727844, -0.01932653598487377, 0.005593309178948402, 0.041531242430210114, 0.031236868351697922, -0.0259691271930933, -0.0008780859061516821, 0.018572848290205002, 0.027910035103559494, -0.014802577905356884, -0.03529532998800278, 0.008545844815671444, -0.004895648919045925, -0.013968884013593197, -0.006420856341719627, 0.008169567212462425, 0.0032224487513303757, 0.016818584874272346, 0.010409649461507797, -0.01898408681154251, -0.016530513763427734, -0.000053502975788433105, 0.060015395283699036, -0.02071344666182995, -0.009883238933980465, 0.008347827941179276, -0.048545483499765396, 0.05664835870265961, 0.056357502937316895, -0.025770654901862144, 0.004015316721051931, 0.012795554473996162, -0.030506296083331108, 0.017449116334319115, -0.062184493988752365, -0.015716196969151497, 0.07604335248470306, -0.024033507332205772, 0.04248444736003876, 0.02918710932135582, 0.04713435098528862, 0.0010662581771612167, -0.003744540037587285, -0.024052819237113, -0.01263394020497799, -0.02126353420317173, 0.023720793426036835, -0.02217518910765648, -0.005749001633375883, 0.034816429018974304, -0.006740078795701265, 0.0432911179959774, 0.04226841777563095, 0.013183800503611565, 0.006640299689024687, 0.08426115661859512, -0.004487896338105202, -0.05301147326827049, 0.027385402470827103, -0.025671903043985367, 0.03179900720715523, -0.015336885116994381, -0.05177341774106026, 0.05082828179001808, 0.02056410163640976, -0.03307534009218216, -0.037250448018312454, -0.013112575747072697, -0.005415068008005619, 0.004605843219906092, 0.0005154880927875638, 0.010801879689097404, 0.017943499609827995, 0.0165566299110651, 0.013123338110744953, 0.010303613729774952, 0.01372000016272068, -0.014714347198605537, -0.08494893461465836, -0.028355319052934647, -0.04364421218633652, -0.025227652862668037, 0.012356502003967762, 0.04113049805164337, -0.024480020627379417, 0.02883363515138626, 0.0012517293216660619, 0.013068650849163532, -0.0011972710490226746, 0.054076362401247025, 0.009700821712613106, 0.03052402473986149, -0.0029767651576548815, 0.049220096319913864, 0.00325829372741282, 0.0060655176639556885, 0.1005665734410286, 0.08174280822277069, 0.04847189038991928, -0.05573100969195366, 0.013415847904980183, -0.027074720710515976, -0.007859732024371624, -0.020174629986286163, 0.03235981613397598, 0.027625419199466705, -0.02110162191092968, 0.018170300871133804, -0.0016428526723757386, 0.036337923258543015, -0.017057986930012703, 0.05388129502534866, -0.03148601949214935, -0.013475710526108742, 0.010946759954094887, 0.03138824552297592, 0.02658938802778721, -0.022123325616121292, -0.06902725994586945, 0.008156079798936844, 0.011925820261240005, -0.02866765670478344, -0.04514529928565025, -0.03178929537534714, 0.017083613201975822, 0.02642977423965931, -0.005710596218705177, -0.0056700315326452255, 0.0077218059450387955, -0.009622872807085514, 0.02204814925789833, -0.017730621621012688, 0.024974245578050613, -0.024876762181520462, 0.006986177526414394, 0.02106827311217785, 0.009443876333534718, 0.0005796078476123512, -0.014176111668348312, 0.004559995606541634, -0.07462354749441147, -0.01762254722416401, -0.05859397351741791, 0.053788598626852036, 0.008958199061453342, 0.005636658053845167, 0.002495347987860441, 0.000989999738521874, 0.026607830077409744, -0.045619718730449677, -0.025043491274118423, 0.03583284839987755, 0.027689775452017784, -0.003684138646349311, -0.021228766068816185, -0.01191707793623209, 0.021031102165579796, -0.00910116545855999, 0.026263494044542313, 0.029141515493392944, -0.009616484865546227, -0.03357188031077385, -0.0247732512652874, 0.03917156159877777, -0.002226993441581726, 0.0031784481834620237, 0.0033442946150898933, -0.04016100615262985, -0.026743745431303978, -0.01146833784878254, -0.03919900953769684, -0.011277084238827229, -0.016218867152929306, -0.014377936720848083, -0.035429202020168304, 0.009184878319501877, -0.029228858649730682, -0.008234511129558086, -0.03372300788760185, 0.00837347935885191, -0.04073888063430786, 0.008458143100142479, 0.056250326335430145, 0.02100985124707222, 0.028148885816335678, 0.025868112221360207, 0.01117149367928505, 0.024709707126021385, 0.004246296361088753, -0.03035888448357582, -0.0015362828271463513, -0.002016854239627719, -0.03503045439720154, 0.008258477784693241, 0.01917777583003044, 0.05298389121890068, 0.023859819397330284, 0.03638365492224693, 0.02935463935136795, 0.011341397650539875, -0.021525723859667778, 0.01459014043211937, -0.04070993512868881, -0.04811525344848633, -0.0171012245118618, -0.0028551467694342136, 0.011458084918558598, -0.0453462116420269, -0.01162127498537302, -0.010065815411508083, -0.011308493092656136, 0.036520443856716156, 0.012234624475240707, -0.05290128290653229, 0.003052858170121908, 0.017694206908345222, 0.009313262067735195, 0.003194423858076334, 0.014404461719095707, 0.0003279702796135098, -0.0013307410990819335, -0.0256512351334095, 0.013692231848835945, -0.037959180772304535, 0.004342576023191214, -0.01637387089431286, -0.01944361813366413, 0.04755488783121109, -0.004363890737295151, 0.051881901919841766, -0.014874826185405254, 0.03160034865140915, -0.017835257574915886, 0.03993786871433258, -0.04833094775676727, 0.0026569406036287546, 0.025195108726620674, -0.053708646446466446, -0.02745874412357807, 0.05500921607017517, 0.008900897577404976, 0.051425594836473465, 0.03397662937641144, -0.01137312687933445, -0.005677827168256044, 0.05817033350467682, -0.031523000448942184, -0.011767873540520668, -0.01644917204976082, 0.0310807041823864, -0.027383029460906982, 0.020561866462230682, 0.002171810483559966, 0.016981428489089012, 0.002346278866752982, 0.018665634095668793, 0.02637431025505066, 0.006645083427429199, -0.028765346854925156, 0.01586454175412655, 0.02083297073841095, 0.006236366927623749, 0.008686489425599575, -0.05007534101605415, 0.0025557191111147404, 0.038174014538526535, -0.00461428239941597, 0.05476294085383415, -0.023872263729572296, -0.005902942735701799, -0.0683102086186409, -0.034078121185302734, 0.008906299248337746, 0.01901356875896454, 0.04672445356845856, -0.06070893257856369, 0.03676503151655197, 0.03330221772193909, -0.013471917249262333, -0.0007436086307279766, 0.011969398707151413, -0.0034974385052919388, -0.039728377014398575, 0.03683353587985039, -0.03429993987083435, 0.00870028231292963, 0.03678872808814049, -0.004927527625113726, 0.043074846267700195, 0.016167884692549706, -0.02216135896742344, -0.029296506196260452, -0.013858800753951073, 0.017527099698781967, 0.02126608043909073, -0.0703144371509552, 0.017317382618784904, -0.05163687467575073, -0.058543384075164795, 0.03466131165623665, -0.009171159006655216, 0.0036177171859890223, 0.021987317129969597, 0.028923777863383293, 0.01346095185726881, 0.021940339356660843, 0.0412420928478241, -0.001835581031627953, 0.0064993309788405895, 0.03013080731034279, 0.03000401146709919, 0.017774170264601707, -0.03924829885363579, -0.023330027237534523, 0.0011674679117277265, 0.0064378115348517895, -0.031036602333188057, 0.010508392937481403, 0.015273737721145153, 0.014201045967638493, -0.008605925366282463, -0.007453812751919031, -0.007967555895447731, -0.04834457486867905, 0.02098117209970951, -0.08589909970760345, 0.00013512240548152477, 0.029827235266566277, 0.03339722007513046, -0.016637999564409256, -0.0003541759797371924, -0.04251674935221672, -0.04762548580765724, -0.004877185449004173, -0.010621913708746433, 0.0006860152934677899, -0.029868055135011673, 0.025378208607435226, 0.02939113974571228, -0.025696367025375366, 0.02594548650085926, -0.0534956268966198, -0.03608885407447815, 0.011285039596259594, -0.019061017781496048, 0.009025887586176395, 0.03181633725762367, 0.009574220515787601, -0.01245555654168129, -0.08019409328699112, 0.05954807996749878, 0.014431529678404331, -0.027727773413062096, -0.023155324161052704, 0.011284117586910725, -0.04189237579703331, 0.008847012184560299, 0.04656146466732025, 0.0014641548041254282, -0.015889981761574745, -0.003707408905029297, -0.005906473379582167, 0.007772402837872505, -0.05912023410201073, 0.015407086350023746, -0.011116859503090382, -0.046922892332077026, -0.01927775703370571, -0.038706742227077484, -0.0029966102447360754, 0.006220285315066576, 0.0060432832688093185, -0.007528634276241064, 0.010187115520238876, 0.013685768470168114, -0.0032411059364676476, 0.0034129281993955374, -0.04365123435854912, 0.031208854168653488, 0.049732740968465805, 0.000781275040935725, 0.00523714441806078, 0.03006858006119728, -0.004399599973112345, -0.0831487849354744, 0.023251721635460854, -0.01581265777349472, -0.01946815848350525, 0.013285116292536259, 0.025542203336954117, 0.023304443806409836, -0.10155719518661499, 0.027159499004483223, -0.001130458083935082, -0.03582124784588814, 0.009485218673944473, 0.044027380645275116, -0.005888030398637056, 0.04800046235322952, -0.011304768733680248, 0.0476798377931118, -0.01933268830180168, -0.00882206205278635, 0.0413045734167099, 0.007429087068885565, 0.019218426197767258, -0.007151152938604355, 0.04742090031504631, 0.04114764183759689, 0.019221946597099304, 0.025658205151557922, 0.0052710482850670815, 0.02641022391617298, -0.024317389354109764, 0.030318785458803177, 0.009599229320883751, -0.03033141978085041, 0.01881529949605465, -0.0011339811608195305, -0.009760638698935509, 0.03590943664312363, -0.014722252264618874, -0.004468804225325584, -0.04056861251592636, -0.01990753598511219, -0.015854639932513237, -0.027560094371438026, -0.00190359924454242, 0.013152320869266987, 0.0222514308989048, -0.004294553771615028, 0.0006630601128563285, -0.022415848448872566, 0.03664989024400711, -0.02702619880437851, -0.005523396655917168, -0.038648974150419235, 0.008323807269334793, 0.0069136726669967175, 0.006303851958364248, -0.03366924449801445, 0.0038152895867824554, -0.01331382803618908, 0.0538533478975296, 0.05684255063533783, -0.013191238045692444, -0.04724792391061783, -0.007351404521614313, 0.034813039004802704, -0.03623272851109505, 0.011974809691309929, -0.06538989394903183, 0.01366329938173294, 0.004078995436429977, -0.06825456023216248 ]
<p>I have a GLMM of the form: </p> <pre><code>lmer(present? ~ factor1 + factor2 + continuous + factor1*continuous + (1 | factor3), family=binomial) </code></pre> <p>When I use <code>drop1(model, test="Chi")</code>, I get different results than if I use <code>Anova(model, type="III")</code> from the car package or <code>summary(model)</code>. These latter two give the same answers. </p> <p>Using a bunch of fabricated data, I have found that these two methods normally do not differ. They give the same answer for balanced linear models, unbalanced linear models (where unequal n in different groups), and for balanced generalised linear models, but not for balanced generalised linear mixed models. So it appears that only in cases where random factors are included does this discord manifest.</p> <ul> <li>Why is there a discrepancy between these two methods? </li> <li>When using GLMM should <code>Anova()</code> or <code>drop1()</code> be used? </li> <li>The difference between these two is rather slight, at least for my data. Does it even matter which is used?</li> </ul>
47,657
[ -0.02965802326798439, 0.014884745702147484, -0.0204261876642704, -0.0014825784601271152, 0.013660984113812447, 0.009757023304700851, -0.032219406217336655, -0.004252547863870859, 0.05698753148317337, -0.012269609607756138, 0.051712557673454285, 0.06055131554603577, 0.07376062124967575, 0.013929076492786407, 0.04959237203001976, -0.0006777846720069647, 0.011888635344803333, -0.03638208284974098, 0.005758810322731733, 0.0025939014740288258, -0.0117088807746768, 0.012203782796859741, 0.018101399764418602, -0.012908258475363255, -0.036827243864536285, 0.05160418897867203, -0.007824794389307499, -0.038892339915037155, 0.01149397250264883, 0.029363395646214485, -0.03488883003592491, -0.025995949283242226, -0.03406764939427376, -0.02430877648293972, -0.019325071945786476, -0.0021642434876412153, 0.010837812907993793, -0.014360683038830757, -0.02377096563577652, 0.03615199029445648, -0.04402763023972511, -0.008113392628729343, -0.0435631237924099, 0.005951016675680876, -0.01775198057293892, 0.004900441505014896, -0.004186089616268873, -0.0021705760154873133, 0.043078988790512085, -0.05008441582322121, 0.052794262766838074, 0.0036279296036809683, 0.025913814082741737, 0.03427905961871147, -0.026489678770303726, 0.016314566135406494, 0.04103487730026245, 0.03939538821578026, 0.005044161342084408, -0.056040167808532715, -0.01644953154027462, -0.04177713021636009, 0.013417202979326248, -0.0036363229155540466, -0.027266202494502068, 0.006192254368215799, 0.04343795403838158, -0.05079491809010506, 0.0655006393790245, -0.025745052844285965, 0.012418422847986221, 0.018396995961666107, 0.027213655412197113, -0.009169048629701138, 0.017724890261888504, -0.003956555854529142, -0.002523950068280101, -0.012892648577690125, 0.05647941306233406, 0.043751928955316544, -0.009846036322414875, 0.03030874952673912, 0.016903851181268692, 0.05097333714365959, 0.013607999309897423, -0.05089407414197922, 0.08702730387449265, 0.0038351493421941996, -0.02307983674108982, 0.03212934732437134, 0.002766999416053295, 0.004427510779350996, 0.05065621808171272, 0.03731045871973038, -0.024736812338232994, 0.04446374252438545, -0.02540837787091732, 0.0342983640730381, 0.009373834356665611, -0.01856968365609646, -0.04039420932531357, -0.052713535726070404, 0.045230649411678314, 0.0471828356385231, -0.03915097936987877, 0.02055053412914276, -0.036181457340717316, 0.015074798837304115, -0.02355232462286949, -0.030973702669143677, 0.0005927087040618062, 0.049258649349212646, -0.018560485914349556, -0.006175711285322905, 0.016649506986141205, -0.027689430862665176, 0.017791835591197014, -0.025953026488423347, 0.0697299987077713, 0.05821526050567627, 0.04012349247932434, -0.0067373584024608135, -0.006954198237508535, -0.01095698494464159, -0.043939728289842606, -0.019306734204292297, 0.012762093916535378, 0.002332463162019849, -0.049393050372600555, 0.03787897527217865, -0.004250101279467344, -0.014318341389298439, 0.05479075014591217, -0.00936701986938715, -0.01742188259959221, 0.0019809571094810963, -0.05808892101049423, -0.053922366350889206, 0.008587784133851528, -0.020148374140262604, 0.040846433490514755, -0.0686970129609108, -0.015279521234333515, 0.010000533424317837, 0.06270702183246613, 0.01952618919312954, 0.03607418015599251, 0.018131177872419357, 0.02299461141228676, -0.0035732644610106945, -0.04272590950131416, -0.03030909039080143, -0.03634553775191307, -0.01702789217233658, -0.03419264033436775, -0.09814151376485825, 0.061995524913072586, 0.018189240247011185, 0.021770726889371872, 0.03377862274646759, 0.01623757742345333, 0.005358950234949589, -0.00563347153365612, 0.013531622476875782, 0.007333415560424328, 0.0007515748147852719, 0.06999479234218597, -0.012398453429341316, 0.06279101967811584, 0.0008373294840566814, -0.003333493135869503, 0.014807859435677528, 0.018975073471665382, 0.032312095165252686, 0.04254816472530365, -0.007552616763859987, 0.028120335191488266, -0.02744153141975403, 0.02613641694188118, 0.061216119676828384, -0.062206581234931946, -0.011383354663848877, -0.011935502290725708, -0.012038911692798138, 0.01781805418431759, 0.02154574915766716, -0.004994934890419245, -0.022483721375465393, 0.07869748771190643, -0.03683730587363243, -0.04134688898921013, -0.07748310267925262, -0.021675437688827515, 0.031180277466773987, -0.01971532218158245, 0.0108757633715868, 0.021879831328988075, 0.049520619213581085, -0.0043341671116650105, -0.0029388198163360357, -0.015585882589221, -0.01831642910838127, 0.03065122477710247, -0.01680784486234188, -0.020944232121109962, 0.0320582389831543, 0.03780950605869293, -0.03903970867395401, 0.046388763934373856, -0.01841973513364792, -0.03943846747279167, -0.010613792575895786, -0.007990850135684013, -0.0002948193869087845, -0.032211512327194214, -0.04419390484690666, 0.013787485659122467, 0.02555457316339016, -0.029591146856546402, 0.04774006828665733, -0.07053583860397339, 0.04887530207633972, 0.04135115072131157, 0.006378041580319405, 0.01367737166583538, 0.0058736978098750114, 0.0061829471960663795, 0.006643983069807291, -0.030340971425175667, 0.015479092486202717, -0.014570851810276508, -0.03528599441051483, 0.08102204650640488, -0.02961103990674019, -0.004779731389135122, 0.023858962580561638, 0.012334353290498257, -0.008927497081458569, 0.011910835281014442, 0.03121369332075119, -0.017627229914069176, -0.06188630685210228, 0.03298448771238327, 0.03714891895651817, 0.02933179959654808, -0.012272898107767105, 0.021522652357816696, -0.05390273407101631, 0.017230818048119545, -0.010874992236495018, -0.013548093847930431, 0.04201330617070198, -0.006028423551470041, -0.026851631700992584, -0.02344484068453312, -0.006492072716355324, 0.0491500124335289, -0.009566932916641235, -0.02311793342232704, 0.041328269988298416, 0.007745486218482256, -0.03662016987800598, 0.0009279194637201726, -0.0034485275391489267, 0.03715517371892929, 0.024440962821245193, -0.040607258677482605, -0.003491050098091364, 0.020876750349998474, -0.03241113945841789, 0.022344306111335754, -0.05369500815868378, -0.009008979424834251, -0.04673352837562561, 0.03614821285009384, -0.013931870460510254, -0.019046375527977943, 0.035268865525722504, -0.005981843918561935, -0.01221784669905901, -0.0057865348644554615, -0.03880627080798149, 0.03746166452765465, -0.0033105870243161917, -0.03437758609652519, -0.009948896244168282, -0.05072781443595886, 0.019983762875199318, 0.026608388870954514, -0.00466508511453867, -0.02800242230296135, 0.008317113853991032, 0.011657879687845707, -0.04766527935862541, -0.07319889962673187, -0.018240077421069145, 0.029681405052542686, 0.017271311953663826, -0.03311745077371597, 0.011594549752771854, 0.0055436426773667336, -0.0253805760294199, 0.01965842768549919, -0.02956247702240944, -0.0007446145173162222, -0.005161076318472624, 0.0060429503209888935, 0.01540282741189003, -0.006606733426451683, -0.021367013454437256, 0.03228749707341194, -0.02754492498934269, -0.00027982937172055244, -0.07453497499227524, -0.04533977434039116, 0.021144365891814232, -0.011311469599604607, 0.027259185910224915, 0.015621467493474483, 0.021592380478978157, 0.09189473092556, 0.03147801756858826, -0.0029811083804816008, -0.04027824476361275, -0.039329804480075836, -0.0012924085604026914, -0.024288827553391457, -0.005327956285327673, 0.01315156277269125, 0.011823516339063644, 0.045884694904088974, -0.025454187765717506, 0.00019641815742943436, 0.02315322495996952, 0.0557769350707531, -0.019207414239645004, 0.00772751634940505, 0.016228944063186646, -0.05307275801897049, 0.03977096453309059, 0.03503413125872612, -0.0018577318405732512, 0.007053972687572241, 0.011180130764842033, 0.02991761453449726, -0.024235479533672333, -0.07363538444042206, 0.014400028623640537, -0.0462140217423439, 0.007788744289427996, -0.018966589123010635, 0.0456579215824604, 0.02300294302403927, -0.03719169273972511, 0.020303471013903618, 0.0002222806215286255, 0.03289205580949783, -0.028685778379440308, -0.034189045429229736, 0.029440537095069885, 0.03424115478992462, -0.034176912158727646, 0.016966938972473145, 0.0059435549192130566, -0.01563749834895134, 0.048213161528110504, -0.031062327325344086, -0.0005550712230615318, 0.05027938634157181, 0.05263699218630791, 0.0180790014564991, -0.01192543189972639, -0.05360884219408035, 0.013323531486093998, -0.07628047466278076, 0.03459567576646805, -0.04557890072464943, 0.03631363809108734, 0.014055236242711544, 0.026325754821300507, 0.030796291306614876, -0.017778705805540085, -0.023219740018248558, -0.03525037690997124, -0.030050644651055336, 0.022416789084672928, 0.014938038773834705, -0.020373599603772163, 0.011861634440720081, 0.0005974989617243409, 0.04457757622003555, 0.029689287766814232, 0.028432520106434822, -0.006924760993570089, 0.04201746731996536, -0.016766317188739777, 0.021566463634371758, -0.011117992922663689, -0.05459382385015488, -0.02570969983935356, -0.008016478270292282, 0.01870976947247982, 0.008706253953278065, 0.0014833766035735607, 0.018689490854740143, 0.008567403070628643, 0.008597648702561855, 0.0019463259959593415, 0.004565914161503315, 0.03903442248702049, 0.026983650401234627, 0.011914684437215328, 0.006551353260874748, -0.02900036796927452, 0.06173844635486603, 0.04581860452890396, 0.028850268572568893, 0.0012830639025196433, 0.02123952843248844, 0.034168634563684464, -0.05147269368171692, -0.021764341741800308, 0.006439599674195051, -0.0001514814211986959, -0.008879141882061958, 0.007385571487247944, 0.03158482164144516, 0.0456203818321228, -0.006143875885754824, 0.01263604685664177, 0.030954422429203987, 0.008024049922823906, 0.005789525806903839, -0.03834463283419609, 0.018700076267123222, -0.003930235747247934, -0.0057615418918430805, 0.04458862170577049, 0.03586696833372116, 0.020052079111337662, -0.007076384034007788, 0.04312021657824516, -0.04212677851319313, -0.022563990205526352, -0.019070778042078018, 0.060605280101299286, 0.005988331511616707, 0.013011740520596504, -0.03373303264379501, 0.0019013117998838425, 0.03977423533797264, 0.03151627629995346, 0.013874559663236141, -0.018209023401141167, -0.07043067365884781, 0.01733255572617054, 0.056760456413030624, 0.05564623326063156, -0.0347183421254158, -0.013332382775843143, 0.004984462168067694, -0.023741496726870537, -0.023683663457632065, -0.017586158588528633, 0.04216277226805687, -0.017169151455163956, 0.015595933422446251, -0.01191230583935976, -0.02312931790947914, -0.06470423936843872, 0.03943478316068649, -0.0025370668154209852, 0.025111345574259758, 0.017380384728312492, -0.041445765644311905, -0.007197058293968439, 0.01831432618200779, -0.006408660672605038, 0.03545895218849182, -0.03922857344150543, -0.01198984868824482, 0.011133546940982342, 0.012049069628119469, -0.026352064684033394, -0.042826537042856216, 0.03000677563250065, -0.01991134323179722, 0.0072025093249976635, 0.06549733132123947, -0.02862386219203472, -0.05218895897269249, 0.000774538901168853, 0.03736168146133423, -0.023266449570655823, 0.0010259520495310426, -0.018955139443278313, 0.048560287803411484, 0.033415552228689194, -0.017633050680160522, 0.08134323358535767, 0.033619459718465805, -0.013104375451803207, 0.010137274861335754, -0.03788084164261818, -0.025985533371567726, -0.04963134229183197, -0.05017213895916939, -0.042927198112010956, -0.006683884654194117, -0.02512160874903202, 0.026129070669412613, 0.03520865738391876, 0.04970597103238106, -0.03061600774526596, -0.015829799696803093, 0.046672649681568146, -0.011761575937271118, -0.017056314274668694, -0.028513340279459953, 0.024571236222982407, -0.008052069693803787, -0.0003714640042744577, 0.007404449861496687, 0.02036285400390625, -0.032785337418317795, -0.01336414273828268, -0.0016428682720288634, -0.032913219183683395, 0.03907771408557892, -0.005470611155033112, -0.013935215771198273, 0.011429762467741966, 0.0004631397023331374, 0.02080416865646839, 0.02487766742706299, 0.06339138746261597, -0.015884647145867348, -0.06708096712827682, -0.02356744557619095, 0.019378427416086197, -0.007251345086842775, 0.052770841866731644, -0.0428055115044117, 0.031105229631066322, 0.0006331534241326153, -0.011649043299257755, -0.058079689741134644, -0.018373854458332062, 0.0207598265260458, -0.005462352652102709, 0.0032906110864132643, -0.03552551940083504, -0.027720890939235687, -0.029901474714279175, 0.004150087013840675, -0.003205670276656747, 0.0759984701871872, -0.029816340655088425, 0.022172152996063232, -0.006463466212153435, 0.032667648047208786, 0.07293878495693207, -0.009277353063225746, -0.006432036403566599, 0.0068537648767232895, -0.015088416635990143, -0.010553336702287197, 0.03326641395688057, 0.014297631569206715, -0.057780299335718155, 0.016184335574507713, -0.011492053046822548, 0.012748858891427517, 0.06779879331588745, -0.014826585538685322, -0.06048202142119408, 0.043664973229169846, -0.024198321625590324, 0.0008478641393594444, -0.04716024175286293, -0.027941379696130753, -0.01319340243935585, 0.01775507442653179, -0.03514671325683594, 0.021903928369283676, 0.0019618303049355745, -0.0010648550232872367, 0.03800657391548157, -0.031621139496564865, -0.00518149184063077, 0.0020601574797183275, 0.07362755388021469, -0.03463262692093849, -0.003434428945183754, 0.027562348172068596, -0.0009036619449034333, 0.014660071581602097, -0.014146935194730759, 0.007059529423713684, 0.018628064543008804, 0.03741889446973801, 0.01806366629898548, -0.03458377718925476, -0.012750011868774891, 0.019525310024619102, 0.02480147033929825, 0.013883167877793312, 0.01376709621399641, 0.045485641807317734, -0.020760439336299896, 0.001491929404437542, -0.023690981790423393, -0.025478173047304153, 0.007545989006757736, 0.015618743374943733, 0.09170660376548767, -0.009875846095383167, 0.003827870124951005, 0.04883737489581108, 0.007039585150778294, 0.003864054102450609, 0.028247402980923653, -0.028016112744808197, 0.0140807731077075, 0.006300909444689751, 0.0036321531515568495, -0.03160946071147919, 0.04650279879570007, -0.050741102546453476, 0.026448719203472137, -0.04652305319905281, -0.04207776486873627, 0.0561666414141655, 0.03823432698845863, -0.00011190692021045834, -0.10444901883602142, -0.022275401279330254, -0.05328787863254547, -0.013567068614065647, -0.0024763785768300295, -0.02350282296538353, 0.021080786362290382, -0.03594032675027847, 0.04619525000452995, 0.01754492148756981, 0.01680993102490902, -0.009095855057239532, -0.089173324406147, -0.037165239453315735, 0.0003597999457269907, -0.027857981622219086, 0.02152532897889614, -0.01855347864329815, -0.0382215715944767, 0.03097764402627945, -0.05231998860836029, 0.02860521525144577, 0.00538260443136096, 0.03026081621646881, 0.006347345188260078, 0.011805128306150436, -0.00786396861076355, 0.04434429109096527, 0.004979992285370827, -0.013637163676321507, 0.13191945850849152, 0.0274798721075058, 0.057324059307575226, -0.0869898870587349, 0.05141304433345795, 0.013574987649917603, 0.020486164838075638, 0.007699084468185902, -0.02286306954920292, 0.012471454218029976, -0.015849711373448372, 0.053465358912944794, 0.06978830695152283, 0.019416365772485733, -0.02709271013736725, 0.033473048359155655, -0.024597151204943657, -0.009614800103008747, 0.0025283875875175, 0.027150698006153107, -0.00464226957410574, -0.030583135783672333, -0.04483136162161827, 0.015551235526800156, 0.07353496551513672, 0.02245481312274933, -0.01157915499061346, -0.018769964575767517, -0.03510727360844612, 0.00973134022206068, -0.024428727105259895, -0.012616735883057117, 0.00808580219745636, -0.01441442221403122, 0.01995674893260002, -0.02498386614024639, 0.029491011053323746, -0.04472552239894867, 0.007857875898480415, 0.03515944629907608, 0.01086835190653801, -0.01125133316963911, 0.01042559277266264, 0.009364611469209194, -0.04586628079414368, -0.00874309055507183, 0.015246344730257988, 0.016588663682341576, -0.02843225933611393, 0.0028199045918881893, -0.02252822555601597, -0.039832744747400284, 0.013233931735157967, -0.02583615668118, -0.0514955036342144, 0.020688502117991447, 0.023765992373228073, -0.018473651260137558, 0.0013645875733345747, -0.04171418026089668, 0.010174051858484745, -0.022270305082201958, 0.029725059866905212, 0.03881201893091202, -0.03976121172308922, -0.005320826079696417, -0.027934111654758453, 0.03662116453051567, 0.011517916806042194, 0.02043226920068264, -0.016890749335289, -0.008085188455879688, -0.02521457150578499, -0.015328825451433659, 0.004034880548715591, 0.009197286330163479, 0.04613063111901283, -0.03316124156117439, -0.0010005722288042307, -0.009933216497302055, -0.0626370832324028, -0.01679207943379879, -0.01679551973938942, 0.004106137435883284, -0.04306899383664131, 0.007121250499039888, 0.003524055704474449, 0.0005215585115365684, 0.0294894278049469, 0.0000612967269262299, -0.004830766469240189, 0.06390998512506485, 0.015528569929301739, -0.04903436452150345, -0.005088995676487684, 0.017970576882362366, -0.009181749075651169, -0.035091932862997055, -0.025214433670043945, 0.04402546584606171, 0.016634253785014153, 0.012709522619843483, -0.00012734404299408197, 0.03174588829278946, -0.001654415507800877, -0.003108617151156068, 0.024211956188082695, -0.03242664784193039, -0.01740356720983982, 0.009955554269254208, -0.00016413225966971368, -0.009211422875523567, -0.014654790051281452, -0.05352216586470604, -0.05984640121459961, 0.037344109266996384, -0.027719158679246902, -0.05526693910360336, -0.023355253040790558, 0.0033099232241511345, 0.004250809550285339, -0.018625065684318542, 0.0032523581758141518, -0.02047974243760109, -0.013636037707328796, -0.0005572646041400731, -0.024159498512744904, 0.0015419465489685535, 0.02576858177781105, -0.010350484400987625, 0.038564398884773254, 0.007321902085095644, -0.00965042132884264, 0.036812424659729004, -0.005602709949016571, -0.008049163967370987, 0.001387077267281711, 0.032116957008838654, -0.005908760707825422, -0.018016256392002106, 0.03231830894947052, -0.007295095827430487, -0.01011219434440136, -0.005133488215506077, 0.009182125329971313, 0.020545242354273796, -0.010994375683367252, 0.0028688989114016294, -0.03317052125930786, 0.02790861390531063, -0.024645371362566948, -0.014159646816551685, -0.027429290115833282, -0.010408301837742329, 0.022264232859015465, -0.0415085107088089, -0.01779817044734955, -0.0037382023874670267, -0.03565215691924095, 0.0634928047657013, 0.03546120226383209, 0.00016539882926736027, 0.009029150009155273, 0.012737828306853771, -0.04197821021080017, 0.03394487872719765, 0.007864772342145443, -0.00700225867331028, 0.020796461030840874, 0.049622222781181335, -0.015609018504619598, 0.04899756237864494, -0.03681238368153572, 0.026454893872141838, -0.08028732240200043, -0.06362612545490265, -0.011261100880801678, 0.009313026443123817, -0.009036020375788212, -0.024843556806445122, 0.033488791435956955, 0.03147251158952713, -0.040936943143606186, -0.017213962972164154, 0.01377026829868555, -0.009955245070159435, -0.047131359577178955, 0.00792684406042099, -0.004984586033970118, -0.041302356868982315, -0.01920108124613762, -0.03511276841163635, 0.03634308651089668, 0.02440398558974266, 0.016795381903648376, -0.018825411796569824, -0.012233342044055462, 0.0003527621738612652, 0.016383429989218712, -0.0768129751086235, 0.012897418811917305, -0.020366910845041275, -0.020453011617064476, 0.007832041010260582, -0.000943536520935595, 0.029973972588777542, 0.03423762694001198, 0.036557573825120926, 0.027290841564536095, 0.03466810658574104, 0.011563125997781754, 0.019267678260803223, -0.012393086217343807, 0.0034169526770710945, 0.02240043692290783, -0.006177394650876522, -0.038711052387952805, 0.019437026232481003, 0.015025736764073372, 0.009033169597387314, -0.024826521053910255, 0.005906740669161081, -0.027195867151021957, -0.01580316573381424, -0.024858152493834496, 0.004558992572128773, -0.0011400476796552539, -0.04165203124284744, -0.008096428588032722, -0.019976431503891945, 0.0034053167328238487, 0.01925087533891201, 0.04099399223923683, -0.02029212936758995, 0.011019174940884113, -0.023124687373638153, -0.008344145491719246, -0.019507423043251038, 0.008797298185527325, 0.003547375788912177, -0.032101619988679886, -0.017289407551288605, -0.00438770791515708, 0.011433563195168972, 0.019977647811174393, -0.014490008354187012, -0.021098323166370392, 0.029257381334900856, -0.027955884113907814, -0.034563686698675156, -0.022870292887091637, 0.026478169485926628, 0.055955395102500916, -0.08973421156406403, 0.05309220403432846, 0.021249273791909218, -0.020176541060209274, -0.07541318237781525, 0.0035820119082927704, -0.04525219649076462, 0.027015581727027893, 0.06289096176624298, 0.031121212989091873, -0.0024733964819461107, 0.010818219743669033, 0.030932920053601265, -0.006943854968994856, 0.004459189251065254, 0.007191687356680632, -0.019589541479945183, 0.014386322349309921, -0.03079207055270672, -0.026248551905155182, -0.005989531986415386, -0.005247266963124275, 0.028048889711499214, -0.0058134556747972965, 0.01697753369808197, -0.015080537647008896, 0.023960335180163383, 0.05169641971588135, 0.0005739236949011683, -0.05702503025531769, 0.03038633242249489, -0.01690053567290306, 0.01812812127172947, 0.027334248647093773, 0.01330514345318079, -0.0538756288588047, 0.035902440547943115, -0.03587871417403221, 0.0025230685714632273, 0.008400348015129566, -0.002229075413197279, 0.028552252799272537, -0.057710736989974976, 0.03695303201675415, -0.00006630837015109137, -0.012233344838023186, 0.022506149485707283, 0.020351609215140343, 0.0371088832616806, 0.06592248380184174, -0.005355381406843662, 0.01844489760696888, -0.009543903172016144, -0.014868896454572678, -0.0006332959746941924, 0.04985595494508743, 0.02097184769809246, -0.0026136923115700483, -0.00811220332980156, 0.025710387155413628, -0.027870239689946175, 0.030346959829330444, -0.020357845351099968, 0.06116935983300209, 0.022589460015296936, -0.003278429387137294, 0.0016184709966182709, 0.009223509579896927, 0.02467222884297371, 0.020514782518148422, -0.00994657352566719, 0.042720478028059006, -0.06278128176927567, 0.03804483637213707, -0.01142849400639534, -0.013796699233353138, 0.010965989902615547, -0.004301590379327536, 0.016186369583010674, 0.04525478184223175, 0.02433239296078682, -0.011388699524104595, -0.03377272188663483, -0.031078528612852097, 0.03301567584276199, -0.00162994593847543, 0.025233134627342224, -0.02736818790435791, 0.010435553267598152, -0.013113060034811497, -0.036721378564834595, 0.002708622720092535, -0.04966383054852486, -0.000048687346861697733, 0.03242485597729683, 0.04057159274816513, -0.08560942858457565, -0.04875657707452774, 0.013675461523234844, 0.04421810433268547, -0.023044690489768982, -0.01635560765862465, -0.04133285582065582, 0.006585908122360706, -0.008526671677827835, -0.04793709143996239 ]
<p>I need to get as accurate as possible a value for the brightness of a mainly stable light source given twelve sample luminosity values. The sensor is imperfect, and the light can occasionally "flicker" brighter or darker, which can be ignored, hence my need for outlier detection (I think?).</p> <p>I've done some reading up on various approaches here and can't decide on which approach to go for. The number of outliers is never known in advance and will often be zero. Flicker is generally a very large deviation from the stable brightness (enough to really mess with any average taken with a big one present), but not necessarily so.</p> <p>Here's a sample set of 12 measurements for completeness of the question:</p> <p>295.5214, 277.7749, 274.6538, 272.5897, 271.0733, 292.5856, 282.0986, 275.0419, 273.084, 273.1783, 274.0317, 290.1837</p> <p>My gut feeling is there are probably no outliers in that particular set, although 292 and 295 look a little high.</p> <p>So, my question is, what would be the best approach here? I should mention that the values come from taking the euclidean distance of the R G and B components of the light from a zero (black) point. It would be programmatically painful, but possible, to get back to these values if required. The euclidean distance was used as a measure of "overall strength" as I'm not interested in the color, just the strength of output. However, there's a reasonable chance that the flickers I mentioned have a different RGB composition to the usual output.</p> <p>At the moment I am toying with some sort of function that will repeat until a stable membership of allowed measures is reached by:</p> <ol> <li>Finding the standard deviation</li> <li>Putting everything outside say 2 SDs into an ignore list</li> <li>Recalculating the average and SD with the ignore list excluded</li> <li>Re-deciding who to ignore based on the new average and SD (assess all 12)</li> <li>Repeat until stable.</li> </ol> <p>Is there any value in that approach?</p> <p>All comments gratefully accepted!</p>
74,364
[ -0.02787412703037262, 0.012731747701764107, 0.018151139840483665, -0.027689525857567787, 0.02765948511660099, -0.004309067036956549, -0.02357906848192215, -0.031469784677028656, -0.0344766341149807, -0.033259861171245575, 0.03335806354880333, 0.013025977648794651, 0.04858192801475525, 0.05447801202535629, 0.009453551843762398, -0.05282416194677353, 0.025444073602557182, -0.01701507344841957, 0.003922121599316597, -0.067975252866745, 0.012210451997816563, 0.005875052884221077, 0.02224215865135193, -0.05549268424510956, -0.07426194846630096, 0.02151528187096119, 0.030829885974526405, -0.006569108925759792, -0.013600805774331093, 0.05680833384394646, -0.07190875709056854, -0.04057467356324196, -0.006761163007467985, 0.027606111019849777, 0.012327439151704311, 0.015451675280928612, -0.0038741803728044033, 0.006629118230193853, -0.046564605087041855, 0.02255261316895485, -0.04706933721899986, 0.012545295991003513, -0.00322197237983346, 0.03575148805975914, 0.007150839548557997, -0.0034168106503784657, 0.005387107841670513, -0.03135751932859421, 0.04924936592578888, -0.05581220984458923, 0.0698544830083847, -0.008780925534665585, 0.037785764783620834, 0.00900508463382721, -0.04456424340605736, 0.004086954519152641, 0.034197937697172165, 0.06759064644575119, 0.012993375770747662, -0.041641660034656525, -0.004242835100740194, 0.0030132452957332134, -0.023635057732462883, -0.010448983870446682, 0.0035016785841435194, -0.007666326593607664, -0.0013200737303122878, 0.005505711771547794, 0.058474186807870865, -0.004206595942378044, -0.0025483763311058283, 0.007565604057163, 0.002825810806825757, -0.0025315831881016493, 0.027084335684776306, -0.030781541019678116, 0.0065664383582770824, 0.028852248564362526, 0.017170999199151993, 0.013380361720919609, 0.016963301226496696, -0.02475913055241108, -0.010717145167291164, 0.025481123477220535, 0.026221370324492455, -0.023565495386719704, 0.05844856798648834, -0.01908324658870697, 0.000029783563149976544, 0.021728914231061935, 0.021580813452601433, -0.007259340491145849, 0.0514417365193367, 0.06394995003938675, -0.0674157664179802, 0.023790014907717705, -0.02683579921722412, 0.014075936749577522, -0.03498639538884163, -0.026224402710795403, -0.000202068971702829, -0.007602596655488014, 0.03675585985183716, 0.05601256713271141, -0.03417273983359337, 0.005365154705941677, 0.004241703078150749, -0.03105349652469158, 0.028280777856707573, 0.019223034381866455, -0.020956644788384438, -0.013626938685774803, 0.014041843824088573, 0.0021550916135311127, 0.014995452016592026, -0.033503834158182144, -0.030112501233816147, 0.006163096521049738, 0.041454315185546875, 0.034250762313604355, 0.005929557606577873, -0.016905296593904495, 0.016613369807600975, -0.017448432743549347, -0.03112269937992096, 0.019761985167860985, 0.02620311826467514, -0.01497695967555046, -0.05279727280139923, 0.03642680495977402, 0.008035395294427872, -0.010963698849081993, 0.06592679023742676, 0.012324397452175617, 0.02631717547774315, -0.017899040132761, -0.0693754032254219, -0.07210815697908401, 0.0400204136967659, 0.007072837091982365, -0.0013997069327160716, -0.0666910782456398, -0.05847672373056412, 0.02846905216574669, 0.042087625712156296, 0.009367474354803562, 0.003434332786127925, 0.004392818547785282, 0.03768082335591316, -0.030834471806883812, -0.02718154713511467, -0.032303571701049805, -0.03559514880180359, -0.035601742565631866, -0.031133726239204407, -0.04427693039178848, 0.025904573500156403, 0.024056175723671913, -0.03704074025154114, -0.019362566992640495, 0.0411725789308548, 0.029606342315673828, 0.01865152269601822, 0.036710742861032486, 0.025482935830950737, 0.0026081998366862535, 0.0633033961057663, 0.00150062155444175, 0.013278349302709103, -0.010973556898534298, -0.029316794127225876, 0.0048401691019535065, 0.011068696156144142, -0.006713861133903265, 0.06703686714172363, 0.0006417163531295955, -0.01880612038075924, -0.007455397862941027, 0.044552307575941086, 0.002580029424279928, -0.055352382361888885, -0.03885343298316002, -0.06500329822301865, -0.010089673101902008, 0.055693577975034714, 0.05577011778950691, -0.028175601735711098, 0.006301688030362129, 0.06638720631599426, -0.030867375433444977, 0.0028900133911520243, -0.045491982251405716, -0.04407777264714241, 0.036862313747406006, -0.04622591286897659, 0.00975876860320568, -0.02864479273557663, 0.0058619300834834576, 0.031042054295539856, 0.019075622782111168, -0.013406233862042427, -0.014397047460079193, 0.061830226331949234, -0.04115819185972214, 0.011583715677261353, 0.04084678366780281, 0.05007744953036308, 0.016814325004816055, 0.03436766564846039, -0.03706958517432213, -0.029150234535336494, -0.02149083837866783, -0.028443781659007072, 0.0167834609746933, -0.0154117401689291, 0.003939228598028421, 0.03399402275681496, -0.005167992785573006, 0.011186684481799603, -0.016710646450519562, -0.028474368155002594, 0.04212110862135887, 0.010672264732420444, -0.016498051583766937, -0.010663888417184353, 0.009693781845271587, -0.02481054700911045, 0.016161253675818443, 0.00048297684406861663, 0.006137557327747345, -0.04428999125957489, 0.012226520106196404, 0.032839734107255936, 0.018539924174547195, -0.048053015023469925, -0.00005416579369921237, 0.06673914194107056, 0.011788293719291687, 0.008559529669582844, 0.03984993323683739, -0.023010369390249252, -0.028465701267123222, 0.00011835565965157002, 0.025710303336381912, 0.015954891219735146, 0.013400459662079811, -0.01939678005874157, -0.0029891321901232004, 0.0026037367060780525, 0.03630648925900459, 0.045472607016563416, 0.005705056246370077, 0.02894650213420391, 0.006890911143273115, -0.04799153283238411, -0.0034055185969918966, 0.03126678615808487, 0.007566297426819801, -0.004110174719244242, 0.054649468511343, -0.0017311560222879052, -0.011460707522928715, 0.016936490312218666, -0.04459846019744873, 0.03420592099428177, 0.014888297766447067, -0.03951573744416237, -0.01215369813144207, 0.008964324370026588, -0.02374863438308239, 0.029162926599383354, -0.032682470977306366, -0.014925075694918633, -0.034101326018571854, -0.012661585584282875, 0.044297587126493454, 0.03574438765645027, -0.00388041022233665, -0.0386965312063694, 0.015972351655364037, -0.03892811760306358, 0.022863470017910004, 0.020574452355504036, 0.0225740484893322, -0.04727677255868912, -0.03394849970936775, 0.014551949687302113, -0.029009433463215828, 0.009256218560039997, -0.002688745269551873, -0.0000634437965345569, 0.06258627027273178, 0.028994616121053696, -0.06915373355150223, 0.011583077721297741, -0.013683137483894825, -0.0060591320507228374, -0.04839140176773071, -0.037868816405534744, 0.022704437375068665, 0.0050119985826313496, -0.09047233313322067, 0.04221758246421814, -0.045644115656614304, -0.005270086228847504, -0.024354539811611176, -0.003475556615740061, -0.016624560579657555, -0.02115352638065815, 0.007383876014500856, -0.006478131283074617, -0.00010340203152736649, 0.009550364688038826, -0.06151250749826431, -0.04828115925192833, -0.038828294724226, 0.028853191062808037, 0.06948994100093842, 0.017803624272346497, -0.003665161319077015, 0.09338779747486115, 0.061821579933166504, -0.04304378107190132, -0.03518135845661163, 0.010181761346757412, -0.035910747945308685, -0.019140571355819702, 0.008738805539906025, 0.013076418079435825, 0.006375256925821304, 0.022417550906538963, -0.03671196103096008, 0.027896931394934654, 0.06345368921756744, 0.006483659613877535, -0.0024679284542798996, 0.02964264340698719, -0.015766188502311707, -0.03389692306518555, 0.060742270201444626, 0.05292441323399544, 0.002831161953508854, -0.0015311029274016619, 0.0038152607157826424, 0.04719017818570137, 0.03376162797212601, -0.03371250256896019, -0.0005517054814845324, -0.006198563147336245, 0.032310850918293, -0.010192540474236012, 0.01951533555984497, 0.0431731753051281, -0.029633617028594017, -0.04328826442360878, -0.014266046695411205, 0.05502604320645332, -0.018473586067557335, -0.01705271378159523, 0.07659288495779037, 0.03882412239909172, 0.015197161585092545, -0.022237204015254974, 0.0033352342434227467, -0.004253722727298737, 0.010137899778783321, -0.027262486517429352, -0.02573437988758087, 0.0520278736948967, 0.02579805813729763, 0.005886255297809839, -0.013764123432338238, -0.013170316815376282, -0.018257830291986465, -0.07988998293876648, -0.03403923660516739, -0.04742203652858734, 0.05784572660923004, 0.012924659065902233, 0.022091085091233253, 0.04181109368801117, -0.01127475406974554, -0.025058574974536896, 0.02761908993124962, -0.09148465842008591, 0.026234863325953484, -0.0003334181383252144, -0.006559919565916061, -0.029118387028574944, -0.051012761890888214, -0.007795308250933886, -0.0323193185031414, 0.02206708863377571, -0.021930649876594543, 0.051836300641298294, -0.03231795132160187, -0.015134194865822792, 0.00007818639278411865, 0.004980943165719509, -0.01427741814404726, 0.03724660351872444, -0.018005801364779472, 0.0045072599314153194, 0.03876277804374695, 0.010310716927051544, -0.010569923557341099, -0.013310839422047138, -0.02147357165813446, 0.019792839884757996, 0.014115415513515472, 0.015322438441216946, 0.019065404310822487, 0.062271568924188614, -0.02090497314929962, -0.009219063445925713, 0.0022909080144017935, 0.042838018387556076, 0.004454551264643669, 0.00034125978709198534, 0.009905915707349777, -0.009996071457862854, -0.04882510378956795, 0.015846898779273033, 0.05654333904385567, -0.033687807619571686, -0.008759933523833752, 0.0367475301027298, -0.009317401796579361, -0.04539588838815689, -0.013929514214396477, 0.03450554236769676, -0.0006972631090320647, -0.030902663245797157, -0.047186996787786484, -0.008821507915854454, 0.03420014679431915, 0.02120606228709221, 0.02967447228729725, 0.0303996242582798, 0.03613629192113876, -0.045311346650123596, 0.03740369528532028, 0.009560862556099892, -0.06436596810817719, -0.011418651789426804, 0.0035826023668050766, 0.015369746834039688, -0.020439691841602325, 0.012252400629222393, 0.02209075354039669, 0.042129337787628174, 0.05391145125031471, 0.026931190863251686, -0.019949134439229965, -0.06015107408165932, -0.025034718215465546, 0.03811945393681526, 0.06603732705116272, 0.011197029612958431, -0.003809700720012188, -0.05081119388341904, -0.01587311364710331, 0.017016001045703888, -0.015885625034570694, 0.020183751359581947, 0.0071800039149820805, -0.01377998199313879, -0.009859531186521053, -0.042132969945669174, -0.0306582972407341, -0.0031075449660420418, -0.00688666058704257, 0.05847887694835663, -0.02769303135573864, -0.0403163768351078, 0.005750888492912054, 0.021872952580451965, 0.008665827102959156, 0.0671243742108345, -0.03204376995563507, -0.027670808136463165, 0.021995948627591133, 0.004439882934093475, 0.011320597492158413, -0.06196574494242668, 0.0005882349796593189, 0.002798519330099225, 0.006811870262026787, 0.07780061662197113, -0.0057972692884504795, -0.05036989226937294, 0.0025522620417177677, 0.011458144523203373, 0.012454479932785034, 0.01800079084932804, -0.01261825580149889, 0.027918806299567223, 0.042842522263526917, 0.03080461546778679, 0.04183003678917885, 0.04710017889738083, 0.003180145053192973, 0.007663756143301725, -0.032340340316295624, 0.004590424709022045, -0.04659015312790871, -0.02169337496161461, -0.014401874504983425, -0.01573248952627182, -0.0349167101085186, 0.035480957478284836, 0.0055501507595181465, 0.054624903947114944, 0.032205481082201004, -0.03766803815960884, 0.03769770637154579, 0.03414497151970863, -0.0074382065795362, 0.028082823380827904, -0.03655904158949852, 0.04618103802204132, -0.00651279091835022, -0.004869064316153526, 0.01394205167889595, -0.011171340011060238, 0.010542703792452812, 0.032246820628643036, -0.04277113452553749, 0.02198442816734314, -0.07644741237163544, 0.015500946901738644, -0.02011162042617798, -0.029602736234664917, 0.060341306030750275, 0.010639320127665997, 0.07556857168674469, 0.05391044169664383, -0.014873667620122433, -0.027309466153383255, -0.01759316772222519, -0.04667767509818077, 0.07440772652626038, -0.060953445732593536, 0.030410176143050194, -0.020797915756702423, 0.007985921576619148, -0.09075756371021271, -0.02765253745019436, -0.007666327990591526, 0.04745486378669739, -0.01944475620985031, -0.024682702496647835, 0.009229632094502449, 0.01043607946485281, 0.0023418646305799484, -0.020049896091222763, 0.025343703106045723, 0.01003875769674778, -0.011752478778362274, -0.013534611091017723, 0.02104986272752285, 0.05093258246779442, -0.014918781816959381, 0.01668844185769558, 0.02808704599738121, 0.003870217828080058, -0.023847520351409912, 0.004681595601141453, 0.018371835350990295, -0.044274307787418365, -0.022947227582335472, -0.032005906105041504, 0.018998388200998306, -0.0011214184341952205, 0.0022267652675509453, 0.008821283467113972, -0.02087879739701748, -0.0049058725126087666, 0.012502146884799004, -0.0068627288565039635, 0.020554181188344955, -0.024188585579395294, -0.009023436345160007, 0.009530960582196712, -0.02418479695916176, 0.0242184866219759, -0.014273867942392826, -0.0007707750191912055, 0.027552200481295586, -0.003340112743899226, -0.005221903789788485, 0.05279342457652092, 0.010699087753891945, -0.03734058141708374, 0.030259450897574425, -0.012862969189882278, 0.04922454431653023, -0.01675729639828205, 0.02200516127049923, 0.021246813237667084, -0.0019499146146699786, -0.03918587788939476, -0.023030417039990425, -0.042597610503435135, -0.016290156170725822, 0.058564890176057816, 0.003610719693824649, 0.0427883118391037, -0.010586122050881386, -0.02458445355296135, 0.00547426613047719, -0.05356442555785179, -0.014205953106284142, 0.02485305443406105, 0.0010218112729489803, 0.037993256002664566, -0.0038698369171470404, -0.008477970026433468, 0.0031948566902428865, -0.00532642612233758, 0.01614750176668167, 0.04794350266456604, 0.02344636619091034, 0.042503707110881805, 0.028965983539819717, -0.05723590403795242, -0.06409052759408951, 0.003913319204002619, -0.05261252820491791, 0.012344779446721077, 0.01142785232514143, 0.015174192376434803, 0.021693632006645203, 0.009036671370267868, 0.02496873401105404, -0.02070324309170246, -0.03957553952932358, -0.06925967335700989, 0.021026611328125, 0.03458031639456749, -0.04608054831624031, -0.0071836914867162704, 0.003783921943977475, 0.003817299148067832, 0.028601380065083504, -0.00984099879860878, -0.06843585520982742, -0.06509509682655334, -0.03890617564320564, -0.01280332449823618, -0.055238377302885056, 0.0509779192507267, -0.01034720428287983, -0.025150183588266373, 0.005084704607725143, -0.00832637120038271, 0.00803897064179182, -0.000827585521619767, 0.04444675147533417, -0.00705355778336525, 0.004934214986860752, -0.016990724951028824, 0.02133089303970337, -0.024456214159727097, -0.004434958100318909, 0.13919876515865326, 0.0456271655857563, 0.039673011749982834, -0.047493256628513336, -0.00234553893096745, 0.00805581919848919, 0.0007807808578945696, -0.02347531169652939, 0.06046097353100777, -0.0094360476359725, 0.00542909512296319, 0.02993668243288994, 0.011482248082756996, 0.05590662360191345, -0.014819285832345486, 0.02652754820883274, 0.0120725492015481, 0.02089480496942997, 0.01596546731889248, 0.07080661505460739, -0.01146343257278204, 0.027846746146678925, -0.045692041516304016, 0.043707720935344696, -0.012312558479607105, -0.046981923282146454, -0.010657094419002533, -0.02203751727938652, -0.014120150357484818, -0.005970917642116547, 0.0053323376923799515, 0.020845694467425346, 0.01637958362698555, 0.014425764791667461, -0.021656576544046402, -0.0005190824740566313, 0.011643464677035809, -0.039429888129234314, 0.022395122796297073, 0.024149758741259575, 0.00838403683155775, -0.01223406195640564, 0.013639386743307114, -0.018826553598046303, -0.035974837839603424, -0.055248722434043884, -0.047825295478105545, 0.05223919078707695, 0.01025351695716381, 0.0030804253183305264, 0.014371789060533047, 0.009592229500412941, -0.014627129770815372, -0.07475142925977707, -0.0020494828931987286, -0.009793495759367943, -0.001946316915564239, -0.009817897342145443, -0.018796324729919434, 0.00584854930639267, 0.02848401851952076, 0.011792181059718132, -0.001564587582834065, -0.010345024056732655, 0.023477686569094658, -0.05332019552588463, -0.006687027867883444, 0.07904830574989319, 0.024776404723525047, -0.023443279787898064, -0.011477700434625149, -0.002050654496997595, 0.014396010898053646, -0.02651514671742916, 0.020008565858006477, 0.0295205507427454, 0.013672387227416039, 0.04213804751634598, 0.007411494851112366, -0.014246268197894096, -0.05873363837599754, 0.0012159874895587564, -0.0369052030146122, -0.03280898183584213, -0.014229378663003445, -0.01680012047290802, 0.02140035107731819, 0.04562697187066078, 0.03406208008527756, 0.007619102019816637, 0.02052215300500393, 0.08546257019042969, 0.026586230844259262, -0.03648615628480911, 0.022667184472084045, 0.01180252991616726, -0.05060151219367981, 0.01946416310966015, 0.02651202492415905, 0.043381430208683014, -0.006660712417215109, 0.017408452928066254, 0.007652809377759695, 0.03199336677789688, 0.0015261245425790548, 0.0010552858002483845, -0.010437474586069584, -0.03147108852863312, -0.022267337888479233, -0.03338346257805824, 0.012997664511203766, 0.0063796029426157475, -0.03790481016039848, -0.012618882581591606, -0.04918249323964119, -0.003438711166381836, -0.00296193384565413, -0.013750693760812283, -0.021938273683190346, 0.010347351431846619, -0.03933195024728775, 0.004673192743211985, -0.011207310482859612, 0.0064159659668803215, -0.02286999300122261, -0.021310439333319664, 0.016984377056360245, -0.002104428131133318, 0.020396187901496887, 0.009374815970659256, -0.006412385497242212, 0.05239654704928398, 0.002929449314251542, 0.0333188958466053, -0.02862940914928913, 0.01171465776860714, -0.021340791136026382, 0.03470522537827492, 0.005601624026894569, -0.0007526869885623455, 0.013184899464249611, -0.02504485845565796, -0.05256031081080437, 0.03620939329266548, 0.006970369257032871, 0.0171657744795084, 0.010587691329419613, -0.010086803697049618, 0.013830660842359066, 0.029897527769207954, 0.0093770083039999, -0.04870084673166275, -0.02173873595893383, -0.007954243570566177, 0.028756091371178627, 0.023339755833148956, 0.04269058257341385, -0.013612596318125725, 0.018034759908914566, 0.018115844577550888, 0.012987532652914524, -0.06621992588043213, -0.002719117561355233, -0.007344024255871773, 0.0001488228444941342, -0.0331229567527771, -0.0458219051361084, 0.0405389629304409, -0.004334191791713238, 0.012021008878946304, -0.015866922214627266, 0.02005920000374317, -0.0072734300047159195, -0.014981856569647789, -0.07425548881292343, -0.03741117939352989, 0.01345923449844122, 0.004081507213413715, 0.009425319731235504, -0.08021114021539688, 0.023571651428937912, 0.06097428500652313, -0.056535568088293076, -0.012375845573842525, 0.008793818764388561, -0.02738681621849537, -0.05189621075987816, 0.0038129864260554314, -0.03372379019856453, -0.05008280649781227, -0.013094364665448666, 0.018335552886128426, 0.013851799070835114, 0.041786063462495804, -0.027186987921595573, -0.03803350776433945, 0.0008248913800343871, 0.037164267152547836, 0.03611936420202255, -0.04907587543129921, 0.0072114295326173306, -0.01107762847095728, 0.02251211367547512, 0.007136177737265825, 0.017856717109680176, 0.027012046426534653, -0.05262809619307518, 0.042574115097522736, -0.009582338854670525, 0.05553454905748367, 0.019551804289221764, 0.012206003069877625, -0.01960853487253189, -0.04700007289648056, 0.033843282610177994, 0.02248172089457512, -0.031212888658046722, 0.012430386617779732, 0.0008524889126420021, -0.04341063275933266, -0.05665820464491844, 0.02038055844604969, -0.006498664617538452, -0.014840511605143547, 0.034586407244205475, 0.008506761863827705, -0.007361809257417917, -0.05565209314227104, -0.014574190601706505, -0.04947606474161148, 0.032954245805740356, 0.0389510877430439, 0.015119200572371483, -0.008131551556289196, 0.006674178875982761, -0.041318606585264206, -0.03292599320411682, -0.004432559013366699, 0.006986367516219616, -0.028312286362051964, -0.044489163905382156, 0.0004367304500192404, -0.03027396649122238, 0.00814671441912651, 0.009334980510175228, 0.005080797243863344, -0.0345119871199131, 0.0033371069002896547, 0.012235589325428009, 0.024099966511130333, 0.013053849339485168, -0.0423973985016346, -0.016141681000590324, -0.06818941235542297, 0.03606148809194565, 0.019583173096179962, -0.009441753849387169, -0.01975083351135254, -0.010245468467473984, -0.03239671513438225, 0.017698615789413452, 0.032104216516017914, 0.019404396414756775, -0.023686736822128296, 0.009472250938415527, 0.0158575139939785, -0.0021873144432902336, -0.042678579688072205, 0.054557859897613525, 0.025423971936106682, -0.0016645333962514997, -0.037623319774866104, -0.008984971791505814, 0.006665682420134544, -0.013225850649178028, 0.002624260727316141, 0.0045578619465231895, 0.02232065424323082, 0.009887578897178173, -0.019802920520305634, 0.05377066507935524, -0.02893875166773796, -0.012518277391791344, 0.02002297155559063, 0.011073339730501175, 0.003957023844122887, 0.04068128764629364, -0.012175737880170345, -0.055070437490940094, 0.0432659387588501, 0.013417292386293411, -0.060335639864206314, 0.024075645953416824, 0.02160492353141308, 0.02104496769607067, -0.04939448460936546, -0.005401760805398226, 0.01859302818775177, -0.008707845583558083, -0.008072072640061378, 0.058039844036102295, -0.010882580652832985, 0.054833900183439255, 0.006343033164739609, 0.05486931651830673, 0.009261955507099628, -0.010179688222706318, 0.029482197016477585, -0.01447303406894207, -0.01266972441226244, 0.01532196719199419, 0.020146025344729424, 0.023732135072350502, 0.01139537151902914, 0.03472881391644478, 0.010318328626453876, 0.044591695070266724, -0.02144729718565941, -0.002345746848732233, 0.025457965210080147, 0.013015608303248882, 0.012513885274529457, 0.024059973657131195, 0.006968791130930185, 0.0679764449596405, -0.038631122559309006, -0.011469872668385506, -0.05444282665848732, -0.021950462833046913, -0.020943619310855865, 0.032941240817308426, 0.029305972158908844, 0.044238749891519547, -0.005557207390666008, 0.0029766482766717672, 0.006055778823792934, 0.040460750460624695, -0.00618627667427063, -0.05516684055328369, 0.07175477594137192, 0.008629731833934784, 0.007513779681175947, 0.009048226289451122, 0.02207197993993759, 0.002460344461724162, -0.004604385234415531, -0.02327711135149002, 0.019591985270380974, 0.017778227105736732, -0.001569041982293129, -0.002458238275721669, -0.0245131216943264, 0.025103192776441574, -0.015620161779224873, -0.011862113140523434, -0.022296873852610588, 0.02330852672457695, -0.051385875791311264, -0.019219595938920975 ]
<p>I am implementing the ARIMAX model for stock price predictions. To select the order, I looped through $0\le p,d,q\le10$ and found the best order to be (1,0,10). I'm a bit confused how to interpret these results. How do I tell if its reasonable, and what does this imply about the data?</p>
37,220
[ -0.0003632514562923461, -0.04341612756252289, -0.0099724642932415, -0.03024488314986229, 0.048372529447078705, 0.028661489486694336, 0.03445090726017952, 0.028989195823669434, -0.0028382716700434685, -0.05433916673064232, 0.03483084961771965, 0.015626221895217896, 0.025307361036539078, 0.014327592216432095, 0.03304584324359894, 0.041613515466451645, -0.024819009006023407, -0.05306970700621605, 0.024512387812137604, -0.021332666277885437, 0.004541011061519384, 0.06486120074987411, -0.013749644160270691, 0.01335177943110466, -0.05262940376996994, 0.05388035625219345, 0.03274857625365257, 0.02465987391769886, 0.01915799453854561, 0.026061667129397392, -0.018153266981244087, -0.029090864583849907, -0.001212838920764625, 0.03980560600757599, 0.028511393815279007, 0.0013041686033830047, 0.005818563513457775, -0.005389237776398659, -0.0027372450567781925, 0.005120171699672937, -0.03531133383512497, -0.0418197326362133, -0.0016589229926466942, 0.005436063278466463, -0.01028600987046957, 0.0015698324423283339, 0.041466258466243744, -0.07033498585224152, 0.031200652942061424, -0.028722338378429413, 0.08185551315546036, 0.01646278239786625, -0.016215821728110313, 0.05539322644472122, -0.012849786318838596, -0.010390459559857845, 0.04002897068858147, 0.0661604255437851, -0.031210264191031456, -0.06023262441158295, 0.01160421036183834, -0.02461797557771206, -0.009040606208145618, 0.014513520523905754, -0.016243813559412956, 0.03281576931476593, 0.002975475275889039, 0.005370692815631628, -0.008153353817760944, -0.01907516084611416, 0.013955553993582726, 0.030336299911141396, 0.05861612409353256, 0.01075065415352583, 0.03998531773686409, -0.012093811295926571, 0.018986869603395462, 0.015192397870123386, 0.06452780961990356, 0.02220645546913147, 0.017986323684453964, 0.035154543817043304, 0.01895013265311718, 0.03008713386952877, -0.0021717259660363197, 0.023736895993351936, 0.044582124799489975, -0.02371232584118843, 0.011465032584965229, 0.04732324182987213, -0.026406506076455116, -0.0022189998999238014, 0.018186088651418686, 0.002638324163854122, -0.05297059938311577, 0.013463867828249931, -0.01682228036224842, 0.020307695493102074, -0.021199369803071022, -0.022497933357954025, 0.010183680802583694, -0.040477972477674484, 0.012962322682142258, 0.06086184084415436, -0.003082271432504058, -0.0176364928483963, -0.023338105529546738, -0.003771608229726553, -0.012254606001079082, -0.014862161129713058, -0.012649728916585445, 0.02276991307735443, 0.0083070183172822, -0.003689424367621541, -0.0055904146283864975, -0.0005813483148813248, 0.008449395187199116, -0.03293720260262489, 0.022627217695116997, 0.020658697932958603, 0.002729216357693076, -0.01056701224297285, 0.019903244450688362, 0.007057406939566135, -0.02803526632487774, -0.0038854805752635, -0.0006114225252531469, -0.03960564360022545, -0.05714637041091919, 0.026485208421945572, -0.013221356086432934, 0.012910147197544575, 0.03822966292500496, -0.01765313185751438, 0.024698108434677124, -0.008961685933172703, -0.06353563070297241, -0.03157135099172592, 0.055194638669490814, -0.01248194370418787, 0.07115928083658218, -0.06073497608304024, -0.005849514622241259, 0.04792684316635132, 0.019391587004065514, -0.013462047092616558, 0.04678528010845184, 0.009804182685911655, 0.006199401803314686, -0.004483516793698072, -0.04142754524946213, 0.019638512283563614, -0.030727747827768326, -0.01363616343587637, 0.019840598106384277, -0.04831946641206741, 0.005396564491093159, 0.018554626032710075, -0.010531946085393429, -0.02869247831404209, 0.01610749401152134, -0.012986624613404274, -0.022059787064790726, -0.017307158559560776, -0.030394280329346657, 0.028074685484170914, 0.06232358142733574, 0.031118445098400116, 0.019446292892098427, 0.002779789734631777, 0.010083690285682678, 0.013044248335063457, 0.010434585623443127, 0.06312580406665802, 0.059509869664907455, 0.019062437117099762, 0.019570447504520416, -0.0875134989619255, 0.008245150558650494, -0.010560133494436741, -0.008775987662374973, -0.018022146075963974, -0.02645607478916645, 0.005702134221792221, -0.01636318862438202, 0.023367278277873993, -0.040521178394556046, 0.004428043495863676, 0.04847486689686775, -0.03765725716948509, -0.04221947863698006, -0.040168095380067825, 0.011798152700066566, -0.002430809661746025, -0.011717618443071842, 0.013814397156238556, -0.0047703636810183525, 0.016234247013926506, 0.007830490358173847, -0.007241970393806696, -0.03368702903389931, -0.03953145071864128, 0.04206177219748497, -0.03660419583320618, 0.03036772459745407, 0.07989705353975296, -0.00909379031509161, -0.015078750438988209, 0.01202995516359806, -0.0489206500351429, -0.02845040149986744, 0.011324530467391014, 0.009298134595155716, -0.003084010211750865, -0.007772850338369608, -0.016435470432043076, 0.057339057326316833, 0.00785802025347948, -0.0012294766493141651, 0.027343597263097763, -0.0399879515171051, 0.05431656911969185, 0.059258799999952316, 0.0129302479326725, -0.017028041183948517, 0.01406184397637844, 0.001473688054829836, 0.0032816429156810045, -0.053925853222608566, -0.017463620752096176, -0.039340294897556305, -0.019356217235326767, 0.029604170471429825, 0.046807970851659775, -0.04881385341286659, 0.018652677536010742, 0.04498368501663208, 0.03985324501991272, -0.0004976100171916187, 0.04021299630403519, -0.014444789849221706, 0.004424039740115404, 0.024980241432785988, 0.018475109711289406, 0.00825287215411663, 0.010822996497154236, 0.019211653620004654, -0.005325585138052702, 0.03461608663201332, -0.004670301917940378, 0.003284492762759328, 0.04599115997552872, -0.005431242752820253, 0.0049353064969182014, -0.011383144184947014, -0.039185237139463425, 0.019223615527153015, -0.06369737535715103, -0.003430548356845975, 0.03681636601686478, 0.027955325320363045, -0.008608262054622173, 0.023122938349843025, -0.007914112880825996, 0.01332173589617014, 0.05420205742120743, -0.030383586883544922, -0.03191770985722542, 0.04840468242764473, -0.04333963990211487, 0.0057502747513353825, -0.02132781408727169, -0.0389670804142952, -0.0596344955265522, 0.0012102049076929688, 0.05453051999211311, 0.0064037567935884, 0.006702135317027569, -0.03574278950691223, -0.02708348073065281, -0.02952548675239086, -0.05210398510098457, 0.04921411722898483, 0.015215525403618813, -0.059151411056518555, -0.013812822289764881, -0.019249603152275085, -0.05090606212615967, 0.036092936992645264, -0.001132568228058517, -0.0048652826808393, 0.020805146545171738, -0.05756855010986328, -0.017875270918011665, -0.03507065400481224, -0.061313971877098083, 0.01684950292110443, -0.036064840853214264, -0.026372961699962616, 0.04802350327372551, 0.008725162595510483, -0.04545484855771065, 0.015279477462172508, -0.05315352976322174, -0.007054502610117197, -0.006197070702910423, 0.01414491981267929, -0.011056622490286827, 0.01833941973745823, 0.010098280385136604, 0.017951641231775284, 0.001748531823977828, -0.005693398416042328, -0.06227423995733261, -0.09109082818031311, 0.0068918028846383095, -0.039305783808231354, 0.014376848004758358, 0.006271630059927702, -0.023057861253619194, 0.07385225594043732, 0.04909712076187134, -0.030225008726119995, -0.02454274706542492, 0.01911347545683384, 0.0014417347265407443, -0.0072156270034611225, 0.025150002911686897, 0.06655985116958618, -0.0012856832472607493, 0.02988608181476593, -0.01959504373371601, 0.08696619421243668, 0.03955560922622681, -0.06575905531644821, -0.035234685987234116, 0.058659277856349945, -0.0019734164234250784, -0.002712950110435486, -0.014527034014463425, -0.002636462450027466, 0.008377745747566223, 0.04435979574918747, -0.008683422580361366, 0.026078414171934128, 0.01873614452779293, -0.027103682979941368, 0.06031343713402748, -0.008131258189678192, -0.004010658711194992, 0.0028841544408351183, 0.03501376137137413, 0.005543190985918045, -0.04976348206400871, -0.0050327591598033905, -0.02796487882733345, 0.01750371605157852, -0.045051366090774536, -0.015917092561721802, 0.04548795893788338, -0.008523695170879364, -0.01649354211986065, 0.008268224075436592, 0.004603103268891573, -0.008098074235022068, 0.005577000789344311, -0.02330857887864113, -0.013276081532239914, 0.02310759946703911, 0.029764236882328987, 0.017960768193006516, 0.010134055279195309, -0.04961260035634041, 0.022724419832229614, -0.06254439055919647, -0.018054507672786713, -0.03836334869265556, 0.06670983880758286, 0.02501266822218895, 0.05782001093029976, 0.0225596372038126, 0.015179190784692764, -0.007211026735603809, 0.040890172123909, -0.017393624410033226, 0.029870502650737762, 0.001933600171469152, 0.0009212701697833836, -0.019586067646741867, -0.04018355533480644, 0.010392168536782265, -0.029343923553824425, 0.01835213229060173, -0.002757629845291376, -0.00886443816125393, -0.0646933913230896, -0.005292339716106653, -0.04207557439804077, 0.004684988409280777, 0.0014919815585017204, 0.015537743456661701, 0.0352611243724823, -0.015585343353450298, 0.03606034815311432, 0.04283079504966736, -0.03332703188061714, 0.005481258500367403, 0.008740406483411789, 0.03678598999977112, 0.029534952715039253, 0.03205682709813118, 0.017228126525878906, -0.019886033609509468, -0.06325932592153549, 0.0284320916980505, -0.04322380572557449, 0.07765506207942963, 0.044049203395843506, -0.01954656094312668, -0.04298415035009384, -0.029244253411889076, 0.008776349015533924, 0.0054424116387963295, -0.0010677987011149526, -0.03954946622252464, 0.02152218297123909, 0.07769672572612762, 0.03146323561668396, -0.03213232010602951, 0.00013238032988738269, 0.05150178074836731, -0.01564786210656166, 0.0012970014940947294, -0.04938806593418121, -0.001044215401634574, -0.013789760880172253, 0.023534169420599937, 0.006290887016803026, -0.005123859271407127, -0.009109818376600742, 0.009942298755049706, 0.02747548557817936, -0.05323898419737816, -0.04141753911972046, 0.015473375096917152, 0.009871464222669601, 0.06600669771432877, -0.01538246963173151, -0.07677615433931351, 0.02484758011996746, 0.015517068095505238, 0.03574688732624054, 0.04697220399975777, 0.013680918142199516, -0.08932249993085861, 0.019270651042461395, 0.06792005896568298, 0.024775711819529533, 0.005042368546128273, 0.014325867407023907, -0.0907871201634407, -0.024475833401083946, 0.012709402479231358, -0.027034083381295204, 0.05213451758027077, -0.02457275055348873, -0.003732360200956464, -0.05460464209318161, -0.038234077394008636, -0.04299364984035492, 0.030896948650479317, -0.008944747038185596, 0.04601342976093292, -0.012184149585664272, -0.018600981682538986, -0.046792082488536835, 0.015112003311514854, -0.01183890737593174, 0.022224757820367813, -0.03862437978386879, 0.004280854016542435, 0.005381720140576363, -0.014788509346544743, -0.009347250685095787, -0.06209053099155426, 0.04253287613391876, -0.02470295876264572, 0.01893645152449608, 0.05935586988925934, -0.031123725697398186, -0.024568483233451843, 0.008289906196296215, -0.0001619537506485358, 0.03528415784239769, 0.027308862656354904, -0.017005445435643196, 0.06474117189645767, -0.00007009296678006649, 0.00861692987382412, 0.01166581641882658, 0.010989614762365818, -0.010430291295051575, -0.019571270793676376, -0.026032816618680954, 0.028755489736795425, -0.03193416818976402, -0.00121798156760633, -0.04474684223532677, -0.008404450491070747, -0.05816349759697914, 0.018865089863538742, 0.01026987750083208, 0.0563209131360054, -0.01761571131646633, -0.006918723229318857, -0.019184190779924393, 0.0011612232774496078, 0.02601444162428379, -0.033026810735464096, -0.030165137723088264, 0.03743425011634827, -0.03208098188042641, -0.011397616006433964, 0.03329872712492943, -0.03018384613096714, 0.007133560720831156, 0.023395491763949394, -0.033703651279211044, 0.012757242657244205, -0.015551985241472721, -0.01104056928306818, -0.013095374219119549, -0.032363925129175186, 0.06370363384485245, -0.002802103292196989, -0.008911849930882454, -0.006875323597341776, -0.0348518006503582, -0.03955750912427902, -0.00114697334356606, -0.02117844857275486, 0.026581307873129845, -0.055903173983097076, 0.043378375470638275, -0.0069568264298141, 0.001654498977586627, -0.06529581546783447, -0.033514782786369324, 0.04983781650662422, 0.006161672994494438, -0.05660725384950638, -0.012408369220793247, -0.007670724764466286, -0.014095989055931568, -0.0287761352956295, -0.03428484499454498, 0.01902846246957779, 0.0018393300706520677, -0.027115607634186745, 0.018232760950922966, 0.0014534145593643188, 0.07219908386468887, 0.013683526776731014, -0.025867238640785217, 0.04153238981962204, 0.0027807874139398336, -0.007461239583790302, 0.011533631943166256, 0.01605955697596073, -0.037483759224414825, 0.010046133771538734, -0.07999475300312042, -0.004156692884862423, 0.027682213112711906, -0.012192880734801292, 0.00007283224113052711, 0.027646826580166817, 0.0078039937652647495, 0.030648544430732727, -0.0111664654687047, -0.03257002308964729, -0.021374668926000595, -0.029325101524591446, -0.00307040149345994, -0.032916247844696045, 0.009670443832874298, -0.03727632388472557, 0.02521086484193802, -0.011461456306278706, -0.01754450425505638, 0.045715220272541046, 0.053947094827890396, -0.0015080611919984221, -0.019859984517097473, -0.04065348580479622, -0.02834518812596798, 0.03917870298027992, 0.005906048230826855, -0.0038091386668384075, -0.01973394677042961, 0.0495624914765358, -0.048566754907369614, -0.013076376169919968, -0.03754366561770439, 0.008832943625748158, 0.045787420123815536, 0.0026995260268449783, 0.041139550507068634, 0.040457308292388916, 0.006991686765104532, 0.006507507991045713, -0.002091366797685623, -0.032532040029764175, 0.019873136654496193, 0.01479146908968687, 0.04670394957065582, 0.010738544166088104, 0.016964878886938095, 0.015421382151544094, 0.009099287912249565, 0.01123233325779438, -0.00904315710067749, 0.04279999062418938, -0.002184722339734435, -0.004969942849129438, -0.020223896950483322, -0.0560285784304142, 0.017252866178750992, -0.03610887750983238, 0.006175145972520113, -0.032059695571660995, 0.0043141962960362434, 0.033866122364997864, 0.022217009216547012, 0.023480691015720367, -0.030298784375190735, -0.029711106792092323, -0.020935697481036186, 0.0006208386621437967, 0.031723931431770325, 0.006407386623322964, 0.0387519970536232, 0.004542491398751736, 0.020772656425833702, 0.02483382634818554, 0.014143789187073708, 0.03045203909277916, -0.025857819244265556, -0.022406693547964096, -0.00778678385540843, -0.054920971393585205, 0.01980147324502468, -0.004029176663607359, 0.0039058078546077013, -0.013551410287618637, -0.016401084139943123, 0.010286176577210426, -0.010537284426391125, -0.008194510824978352, -0.012473709881305695, 0.08182187378406525, 0.04369157552719116, -0.011780248954892159, 0.02385399118065834, -0.024768920615315437, 0.13877731561660767, 0.0841871127486229, 0.0015488587087020278, -0.05362768471240997, 0.03656416013836861, 0.011540059000253677, -0.004914494697004557, -0.02989603579044342, 0.031434230506420135, -0.005193580407649279, 0.013088542968034744, 0.04637390375137329, 0.006811274215579033, 0.014396348036825657, 0.01907295547425747, 0.054926797747612, -0.08482301235198975, -0.021765470504760742, 0.033701106905937195, 0.02589731104671955, 0.011965070851147175, -0.03839759901165962, -0.05728159844875336, 0.0015004215529188514, -0.009756968356668949, -0.0016665066359564662, -0.011464525014162064, 0.0030899811536073685, -0.017902253195643425, 0.01645490899682045, 0.01736474223434925, -0.001021229662001133, 0.02140377275645733, 0.014797592535614967, -0.022893590852618217, 0.004660931881517172, -0.026844674721360207, -0.011381669901311398, -0.0034583297092467546, 0.015062304213643074, -0.015117284841835499, -0.009407705627381802, -0.0016761838924139738, -0.0038274982944130898, -0.034259311854839325, -0.0025898360181599855, -0.026622870936989784, 0.003981549292802811, -0.00427962327376008, -0.026827886700630188, -0.01507900096476078, 0.024843262508511543, -0.036633510142564774, -0.06112400442361832, -0.022748909890651703, 0.03445605933666229, 0.049024853855371475, -0.011624800972640514, -0.023478427901864052, -0.027237296104431152, -0.009546985849738121, -0.043424226343631744, 0.042808257043361664, 0.008422406390309334, -0.0447857603430748, -0.007361575961112976, -0.024321328848600388, 0.04447192698717117, -0.04131576418876648, 0.021525071933865547, -0.01590481773018837, -0.010113151744008064, -0.03169175609946251, -0.0232545118778944, -0.015932822600007057, -0.021350404247641563, 0.04271867498755455, 0.002931301249191165, -0.018994681537151337, 0.0012825651792809367, 0.00021377677330747247, -3.543617026480206e-7, -0.029096132144331932, 0.010092883370816708, -0.05867689847946167, -0.01481956522911787, -0.01981617882847786, 0.08083011209964752, 0.016149159520864487, 0.014310131780803204, -0.02939346246421337, 0.022405870258808136, -0.012508055195212364, -0.007621270604431629, -0.00944594293832779, 0.023908564820885658, -0.08800068497657776, -0.0020333188585937023, 0.014515023678541183, 0.09058577567338943, 0.014443434774875641, 0.011709658429026604, 0.007076589856296778, 0.018884845077991486, -0.016015583649277687, 0.026577677577733994, -0.001323995180428028, -0.05072423815727234, 0.03985046595335007, 0.006186827085912228, 0.003790340619161725, -0.05209159851074219, -0.031096631661057472, 0.003188760718330741, 0.0005860405508428812, 0.0020447203423827887, -0.001846730592660606, 0.005353118292987347, -0.001733862911351025, -0.010485958307981491, 0.0022779691498726606, -0.017971474677324295, -0.01116895955055952, -0.036891281604766846, 0.022724328562617302, -0.03347492590546608, -0.00912598054856062, -0.009579875506460667, -0.00045029199100099504, 0.013091806322336197, -0.005641532596200705, 0.05129382759332657, -0.00589996762573719, -0.004082683939486742, -0.03681538254022598, 0.011370382271707058, 0.0033838676754385233, 0.06364062428474426, -0.04864579439163208, -0.06979607790708542, -0.00913656409829855, -0.05781541392207146, -0.015613202005624771, 0.0411497987806797, 0.005045448895543814, 0.0257403701543808, 0.03412719815969467, 0.02155357226729393, -0.00890673603862524, 0.025123629719018936, -0.019846124574542046, -0.040501877665519714, 0.04070170968770981, 0.005880249664187431, 0.04243850335478783, 0.0038573797792196274, -0.00473181763663888, 0.01785469241440296, 0.016960522159934044, -0.0020642050076276064, 0.021862784400582314, 0.01961127109825611, -0.011254985816776752, 0.041429486125707626, 0.0006670932052657008, 0.01681058295071125, 0.003916098736226559, 0.0046226866543293, 0.01444284152239561, 0.017249900847673416, -0.026032788679003716, 0.06399942934513092, -0.02044081501662731, -0.011899985373020172, -0.030964870005846024, -0.017050864174962044, 0.02728830836713314, -0.0009952390100806952, 0.0492900013923645, -0.02645125798881054, 0.03288757801055908, 0.011816320940852165, -0.024175796657800674, 0.04564875736832619, 0.019644934684038162, 0.010132630355656147, -0.06224967911839485, 0.001740774023346603, -0.048191845417022705, 0.034281402826309204, 0.06758993864059448, 0.007075074594467878, 0.06024235486984253, -0.011377235874533653, -0.00898082833737135, -0.012614566832780838, 0.022726820781826973, 0.06424092501401901, -0.02046740986406803, -0.05222576856613159, 0.02623722143471241, -0.033142268657684326, -0.039202358573675156, 0.05472894757986069, 0.014307752251625061, 0.01225398201495409, 0.02651367336511612, 0.04776746779680252, -0.00028375055990181863, 0.07455082982778549, 0.039351146668195724, -0.006952180061489344, -0.020253170281648636, -0.009811460971832275, 0.044648490846157074, -0.000024743096219026484, 0.006429251283407211, 0.04028001427650452, 0.039763592183589935, -0.006332335993647575, 0.005981032736599445, -0.008117137476801872, -0.0115235336124897, -0.004105617292225361, -0.002211659913882613, 0.003908790182322264, 0.0002506487653590739, -0.036005448549985886, 0.012423479929566383, -0.008153295144438744, -0.019148029386997223, 0.02028745599091053, 0.04404392093420029, -0.027299189940094948, 0.010738838464021683, -0.00626719556748867, -0.06816504150629044, 0.0067161680199205875, 0.03187483176589012, 0.0095753138884902, -0.03511359170079231, 0.0024965095799416304, -0.013631508685648441, 0.00678966473788023, -0.030941274017095566, -0.034050486981868744, -0.018319420516490936, -0.005110107362270355, -0.0213747788220644, -0.01705927588045597, 0.04044368118047714, -0.04332784190773964, -0.0026659287977963686, -0.08137287199497223, 0.06914329528808594, 0.009047497063875198, -0.020419273525476456, 0.002874397672712803, 0.006899029016494751, -0.026238692924380302, -0.000447239464847371, 0.031691741198301315, 0.046513281762599945, -0.024714889004826546, -0.0027923404704779387, -0.004647246096283197, 0.02176099456846714, -0.02868630364537239, -0.028971608728170395, -0.02846851758658886, -0.003980408422648907, -0.0423930361866951, -0.012420582585036755, 0.016670383512973785, 0.0008631960954517126, -0.0056099481880664825, 0.015911493450403214, 0.020376063883304596, 0.01902851276099682, 0.02428964525461197, 0.03491580858826637, -0.008045504800975323, 0.04011663421988487, 0.08302228897809982, 0.005001596640795469, -0.017767898738384247, 0.03398861363530159, -0.005490997806191444, -0.06938546895980835, 0.042952295392751694, -0.0061274622566998005, -0.004332852084189653, 0.015164638869464397, 0.018864478915929794, 0.04758288338780403, -0.03967781737446785, -0.030720243230462074, 0.0603938028216362, -0.023343650624155998, -0.0075728981755673885, 0.03680289536714554, 0.009270098991692066, 0.023227345198392868, -0.005756468512117863, 0.006089385598897934, -0.0030624615028500557, -0.020153753459453583, 0.015498453751206398, 0.010435652919113636, 0.04822453483939171, 0.008318301290273666, 0.041409194469451904, 0.03976942598819733, -0.044275421649217606, -0.006046897266060114, -0.031099004670977592, 0.03640035167336464, -0.005747273098677397, -0.026049038395285606, 0.03554846718907356, -0.022216783836483955, 0.012274138629436493, -0.010553593747317791, -0.00261182663962245, 0.05894707143306732, -0.05943261831998825, 0.03521928936243057, -0.029207268729805946, 0.003089091507717967, -0.03766828030347824, -0.01050764974206686, -0.01281440444290638, 0.0048706503584980965, -0.002443477511405945, 0.0022279885597527027, 0.016557985916733742, -0.007548321038484573, 0.025760740041732788, -0.0483468621969223, -0.00934277381747961, 0.018212389200925827, -0.0012529488885775208, -0.005189636256545782, -0.03928561136126518, -0.026005493476986885, -0.015403279103338718, 0.04808088764548302, -0.00007072872540447861, 0.01466567162424326, 0.006792988628149033, -0.041559863835573196, 0.00128321279771626, 0.03225238248705864, -0.04766475781798363, -0.021050885319709778, -0.06278499215841293, -0.017958754673600197, -0.006043275818228722, -0.02562003768980503 ]
<p>I know 3 methods to do parameter estimation, ML, MAP and Bayes approach. And for MAP and Bayes approach, we need to pick priors for parameters, right? </p> <p>Say I have this model $p(x|\alpha,\beta)$, in which $\alpha,\beta$ are parameters, in order to do the estimation using MAP or Bayes, I read in the book that we'd better <em>pick a conjugate prior $p(\alpha,\beta)$</em>, which is a <strong>joint</strong> probability of $\alpha,\beta$, right?</p> <p>I have 2 questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>Do we have other choices picking the prior other than this conjugate one? </p></li> <li><p>Can we pick priors for $\alpha$ and $\beta$ respectively like $p(\alpha)$ and $p(\beta)$, other than put them together in a joint one?</p></li> </ol>
37,221
[ -0.03095858357846737, -0.0035515823401510715, 0.029300488531589508, -0.03846677020192146, 0.030849682167172432, 0.034363217651844025, -0.03233107924461365, -0.030256597325205803, 0.02911498211324215, -0.02103365771472454, 0.030937369912862778, 0.06974165141582489, 0.07175755500793457, 0.004993452690541744, 0.03642645478248596, 0.003568371059373021, -0.012124454602599144, -0.014894387684762478, -0.029476530849933624, 0.012617349624633789, 0.011074148118495941, 0.03741559013724327, 0.03481635823845863, 0.004894630052149296, -0.010562647134065628, 0.03824261948466301, 0.02443496137857437, -0.009067179635167122, -0.01680399291217327, 0.06677094101905823, -0.02767994999885559, -0.02924928441643715, 0.03102198615670204, 0.050073087215423584, -0.029868509620428085, -0.027327638119459152, -0.004736311733722687, -0.02528534084558487, -0.03592274338006973, 0.0339667871594429, -0.046406231820583344, -0.04481980949640274, -0.0068423994816839695, -0.00467298598960042, -0.041967254132032394, 0.021307876333594322, 0.004002285189926624, -0.061154983937740326, -0.01565573923289776, -0.041325852274894714, 0.05257755517959595, -0.0006569043616764247, 0.038612909615039825, 0.05378657206892967, -0.005953608546406031, -0.025522181764245033, 0.03945138677954674, 0.07967369258403778, -0.0025662065017968416, -0.05887670814990997, 0.004524459131062031, -0.03450791537761688, 0.043421950191259384, -0.03908674418926239, -0.035304319113492966, 0.0234444011002779, 0.009072758257389069, -0.0005949433543719351, 0.014110288582742214, -0.007888815365731716, 0.018231699243187904, 0.001864850171841681, 0.03969993069767952, 0.012827380560338497, 0.026072541251778603, -0.012041714042425156, -0.002418744843453169, 0.031497180461883545, 0.06433559954166412, 0.034970708191394806, -0.007283499930053949, 0.019060201942920685, 0.040797993540763855, 0.011685081757605076, -0.001820298726670444, -0.016064392402768135, 0.06381049007177353, 0.002372101414948702, 0.005691647529602051, -0.020854925736784935, -0.04275769367814064, 0.015290726907551289, -0.004791396204382181, -0.004731967579573393, -0.015658413991332054, 0.05644075572490692, -0.0055921743623912334, 0.0558522567152977, 0.01064173225313425, -0.011457379907369614, 0.008830591104924679, -0.023709164932370186, -0.000038387162931030616, 0.04244459420442581, -0.020479146391153336, -0.005962675902992487, -0.0007003544014878571, -0.008746744133532047, -0.03681381791830063, -0.04895439371466637, -0.0591907724738121, 0.04835738241672516, -0.02385406196117401, -0.0024394167121499777, 0.012504799291491508, -0.020276281982660294, 0.019904742017388344, -0.05168174207210541, 0.08847343176603317, 0.07186473906040192, 0.018205352127552032, -0.02329382114112377, -0.004241274669766426, -0.020484881475567818, -0.0596163272857666, -0.0048378389328718185, 0.011013524606823921, -0.017091665416955948, -0.03340157866477966, 0.03280409798026085, -0.0014602510491386056, 0.006182828918099403, 0.046061206609010696, 0.030886590480804443, -0.0000981886696536094, 0.014050815254449844, -0.06062560901045799, -0.04466923698782921, 0.03802298754453659, -0.03563075140118599, 0.001485201297327876, -0.05781356245279312, 0.036688998341560364, 0.021494776010513306, 0.03743727505207062, -0.0034176718909293413, 0.053771257400512695, 0.033596109598875046, 0.013765770941972733, -0.013956291601061821, -0.02130611427128315, -0.026765333488583565, -0.011945768259465694, 0.025228185579180717, -0.030524952337145805, -0.10260875523090363, 0.011634438298642635, -0.010163098573684692, 0.002229844219982624, -0.01249891147017479, 0.0532626137137413, -0.008511523716151714, -0.012621804140508175, 0.015481017529964447, 0.0029601140413433313, -0.05369707569479942, 0.0807182565331459, 0.01211483683437109, 0.05567669868469238, 0.04187643527984619, -0.0038823045324534178, 0.04277082532644272, 0.027639277279376984, 0.027798866853117943, 0.013721343129873276, -0.016815559938549995, -0.05283290147781372, -0.020353395491838455, 0.023550409823656082, 0.010869694873690605, -0.00860185269266367, -0.017762968316674232, -0.008462452329695225, 0.02670242078602314, 0.0003827843174804002, 0.04227534309029579, 0.02351495809853077, -0.032313037663698196, 0.03643408417701721, -0.05061715096235275, -0.02282392606139183, -0.07667190581560135, 0.006003046408295631, -0.03718569502234459, -0.009268248453736305, 0.0474097803235054, -0.015581033192574978, -0.002531131962314248, -0.0038399212062358856, 0.00911465659737587, -0.03225957974791527, -0.011076150462031364, 0.0257534459233284, -0.023475581780076027, 0.028769126161932945, 0.061908699572086334, 0.016719110310077667, -0.007461914326995611, 0.030590971931815147, -0.028084268793463707, -0.04887994006276131, 0.015591630712151527, -0.04012409970164299, -0.0023368876427412033, 0.00006250340084079653, -0.03915854170918465, -0.003923140931874514, 0.003604482626542449, -0.03778669983148575, 0.005791706498712301, -0.05980507284402847, 0.05571003258228302, 0.0514337383210659, 0.002064200583845377, 0.000304275075905025, 0.024525215849280357, 0.0099955964833498, 0.03055102378129959, -0.0013444182695820928, 0.021930940449237823, -0.04836638644337654, -0.008930814452469349, 0.03149952366948128, 0.007291434798389673, -0.04264490306377411, 0.06325262039899826, 0.01806601509451866, 0.01898689940571785, 0.028027521446347237, -0.005887867882847786, 0.007966096512973309, -0.008312463760375977, 0.005982091184705496, 0.021886557340621948, -0.009982244111597538, 0.028355402871966362, 0.019214602187275887, -0.0022088519763201475, 0.041285641491413116, -0.041970156133174896, -0.0016960930079221725, 0.039318475872278214, -0.022001786157488823, -0.00696773175150156, -0.0036393199115991592, 0.0028163674287497997, 0.021837856620550156, -0.025597387924790382, 0.012869317084550858, -0.0012934781843796372, 0.009721770882606506, -0.003920190967619419, 0.007876417599618435, -0.00868296530097723, 0.0002209989761468023, 0.0474751777946949, -0.052942413836717606, -0.0014690820826217532, 0.020019453018903732, -0.07036161422729492, 0.009155331179499626, 0.0006888227653689682, 0.0017894944176077843, -0.03167728707194328, -0.002831897232681513, 0.007444196846336126, -0.04237014055252075, 0.01190558634698391, -0.028670011088252068, -0.05614585801959038, 0.0023425251711159945, -0.0204396340996027, 0.011385975405573845, 0.017601650208234787, -0.0671614482998848, 0.012900150381028652, -0.07551664113998413, -0.013910614885389805, 0.030828936025500298, -0.01429913192987442, -0.018393663689494133, -0.03874656930565834, -0.023587828502058983, -0.056648824363946915, -0.04843766614794731, -0.03205333277583122, 0.03330294415354729, -0.029779603704810143, -0.012579668313264847, 0.052995715290308, 0.0016335119726136327, -0.0009493922698311508, 0.009565982036292553, -0.0464337095618248, -0.041708920150995255, -0.02327647991478443, 0.01162663009017706, 0.00018600589828565717, 0.002985544502735138, 0.021508991718292236, 0.0346837043762207, -0.0441543310880661, 0.010090380907058716, -0.09182736277580261, -0.01734878122806549, 0.020370837301015854, 0.006105197127908468, 0.024368498474359512, 0.0034415393602102995, -0.02958272397518158, 0.06405379623174667, 0.04458906129002571, -0.041391193866729736, 0.0020753052085638046, 0.06406867504119873, -0.04324924200773239, -0.01638094335794449, -0.019097669050097466, 0.051082294434309006, 0.005971022881567478, 0.021730046719312668, -0.009878873825073242, -0.003599874209612608, 0.04354289546608925, 0.03488154709339142, 0.006361436098814011, 0.03004409745335579, 0.01672828011214733, -0.009528635069727898, 0.024650348350405693, 0.017878012731671333, -0.005854656454175711, 0.017206022515892982, -0.006254781037569046, 0.009283020161092281, -0.005036862101405859, -0.019821766763925552, 0.009117750450968742, -0.028221987187862396, -0.015444787219166756, -0.047104883939027786, 0.05777798593044281, 0.050206661224365234, -0.022973215207457542, 0.02234414778649807, -0.0013710309285670519, 0.019284788519144058, -0.03300922363996506, 0.008367404341697693, 0.02913711965084076, 0.027680130675435066, -0.0602911077439785, -0.011098120361566544, -0.033546753227710724, -0.006212226580828428, 0.012541945092380047, -0.00259199645370245, 0.007815775461494923, 0.028275517746806145, 0.03280452638864517, 0.03114069253206253, -0.00571498554199934, -0.02078709565103054, -0.05408504977822304, -0.08223855495452881, 0.029963294044137, -0.0008474559872411191, 0.02204434759914875, 0.005790769122540951, 0.03424127772450447, 0.015991870313882828, 0.0018585999496281147, 0.00811243336647749, -0.002657552482560277, -0.08683537691831589, -0.007229096256196499, -0.00320658041164279, -0.01224552933126688, 0.011121437884867191, -0.05372922867536545, 0.037879832088947296, -0.03767047077417374, -0.007247020024806261, -0.03126850351691246, -0.00026860483922064304, -0.042168088257312775, 0.017048634588718414, -0.0502614751458168, -0.012519579380750656, 0.02703431062400341, 0.047794159501791, 0.015115641988813877, -0.025957340374588966, 0.0218042004853487, 0.024354174733161926, -0.015433542430400848, -0.0019075528252869844, -0.0026315657887607813, 0.019045019522309303, -0.009500475600361824, 0.029392993077635765, 0.005219402257353067, 0.07237623631954193, -0.010876845568418503, 0.00852048397064209, 0.03158044442534447, 0.08082018047571182, 0.06953532993793488, -0.028070824220776558, -0.012405439279973507, -0.02950303442776203, -0.007361772935837507, -0.0033665241207927465, 0.013659466989338398, 0.006622239947319031, -0.025894274935126305, 0.0526689849793911, 0.010238733142614365, -0.03616685792803764, 0.031064946204423904, 0.04685310274362564, 0.019915373995900154, -0.005122607108205557, -0.02192176692187786, -0.010609527118504047, 0.0008592211524955928, -0.027206165716052055, 0.005971824284642935, 0.0027165040373802185, -0.04304017871618271, -0.010141110979020596, 0.021470913663506508, -0.011231924407184124, -0.027119627222418785, -0.003900062758475542, 0.04943910241127014, 0.021136056631803513, 0.018119586631655693, -0.06086161732673645, 0.00459111575037241, 0.05431493744254112, 0.010078624822199345, -0.0038830996491014957, -0.007365098688751459, -0.058071959763765335, 0.015336529351770878, 0.02650722861289978, 0.01717272400856018, -0.05969957634806633, 0.03740910440683365, -0.04768206179141998, -0.03496405854821205, 0.008730399422347546, 0.011806403286755085, 0.014479120261967182, -0.03546628728508949, -0.01034336443990469, -0.006864306982606649, -0.025104602798819542, -0.05253104493021965, 0.018740873783826828, 0.011122695170342922, -0.014698036015033722, -0.03808719292283058, 0.029009973630309105, -0.010334612801671028, 0.004324211739003658, 0.007720546796917915, 0.061701465398073196, -0.015569320879876614, -0.008106888271868229, 0.018455618992447853, 0.0051117404364049435, 0.0010201858822256327, -0.09098539501428604, -0.0014652855461463332, -0.016782565042376518, -0.02903364971280098, 0.013992736116051674, -0.0042425948195159435, -0.0647536963224411, 0.049450021237134933, 0.007115610875189304, -0.007636697497218847, 0.039902471005916595, -0.019013023003935814, 0.014238680712878704, 0.01596894860267639, 0.015422586351633072, 0.07072614878416061, -0.012668095529079437, -0.004530593287199736, 0.007715677376836538, -0.04032880440354347, 0.009139864705502987, -0.036736808717250824, 0.006018688436597586, -0.049012988805770874, -0.002461872762069106, -0.026125716045498848, 0.05428239330649376, -0.005732575431466103, 0.024702919647097588, -0.013930302113294601, -0.02833043970167637, 0.013762520626187325, 0.0493992418050766, 0.01491278875619173, 0.02036893367767334, -0.0032262930180877447, 0.025182630866765976, -0.012046987190842628, -0.004744560457766056, 0.009348138235509396, -0.04076312854886055, 0.032730456441640854, -0.0066644782200455666, -0.03694140166044235, 0.01834423467516899, -0.05324292182922363, -0.01050250418484211, 0.04615975171327591, -0.010554417967796326, 0.038911569863557816, 0.02260993979871273, 0.03612857311964035, 0.007882123813033104, -0.05078570172190666, -0.03388432040810585, -0.0056357975117862225, -0.0143178291618824, 0.0363769605755806, -0.02637588605284691, 0.013474490493535995, 0.009042762219905853, -0.005463773850351572, -0.04898318275809288, -0.034914836287498474, 0.019951770082116127, -0.027270257472991943, -0.032123465090990067, -0.000340176688041538, 0.07004127651453018, -0.028409253805875778, -0.05197904258966446, -0.02644243836402893, 0.07034799456596375, -0.0021105429623275995, -0.02422124706208706, -0.01847980171442032, 0.0460851788520813, 0.04965848848223686, 0.03522716835141182, -0.02187495119869709, 0.029690761119127274, -0.0041704364120960236, -0.006142267491668463, 0.005728512071073055, 0.010704893618822098, -0.03098873607814312, -0.015223772265017033, -0.009494566358625889, 0.003401401685550809, 0.07059436291456223, -0.010424548760056496, -0.00969376415014267, 0.05939263477921486, 0.013972272165119648, -0.021232441067695618, 0.009616098366677761, -0.028738804161548615, 0.006979209370911121, 0.004447780549526215, -0.026292309165000916, 0.004799751099199057, -0.01429365761578083, -0.044669926166534424, 0.06305912882089615, -0.03322984278202057, -0.021201778203248978, 0.005328651983290911, 0.06143755093216896, 0.0024504822213202715, 0.038051754236221313, -0.017106033861637115, 0.0027525736950337887, 0.03272619843482971, -0.017608050256967545, 0.0257712509483099, 0.0474163182079792, -0.006735258270055056, -0.03672495111823082, 0.0024779082741588354, -0.05446799471974373, 0.007619130425155163, 0.06153470650315285, -0.028633084148168564, 0.03877590596675873, 0.03259362652897835, 0.024921635165810585, -0.010125026106834412, -0.035532817244529724, -0.02295299991965294, -0.009500253945589066, -0.008491972461342812, 0.06812058389186859, -0.0070200650952756405, 0.011054343543946743, 0.056208282709121704, -0.0262934397906065, 0.019083723425865173, 0.007171714212745428, -0.0020664900075644255, 0.05341944843530655, 0.012166262604296207, -0.021881455555558205, -0.020209934562444687, 0.04041830450296402, -0.054850466549396515, 0.005548371467739344, -0.041811875998973846, -0.06714245676994324, 0.025634152814745903, 0.03089912049472332, -0.014063662849366665, -0.06251869350671768, -0.012061447836458683, -0.05429884418845177, 0.022637173533439636, 0.03346811234951019, 0.025869134813547134, 0.033125586807727814, 0.016806192696094513, 0.039401859045028687, -0.006914214696735144, 0.03128731995820999, -0.02002931572496891, -0.08802857249975204, -0.03081059455871582, 0.006417388096451759, -0.03174889460206032, 0.0055975173600018024, -0.006756733637303114, -0.032790057361125946, 0.005036346148699522, -0.05067584291100502, 0.05174417048692703, 0.020678754895925522, 0.038175132125616074, -0.07857118546962738, 0.09148341417312622, 0.00009530641546007246, 0.02186744287610054, -0.008367246016860008, 0.006194402929395437, 0.11080741137266159, 0.09221821278333664, 0.06889364123344421, -0.05726981535553932, -0.0025116584729403257, -0.014191566966474056, -0.008540465496480465, -0.030817681923508644, 0.01430188026279211, 0.021305875852704048, 0.0185401514172554, 0.017561882734298706, 0.04921908676624298, 0.001568314153701067, -0.02220587059855461, 0.04248581454157829, -0.04459839686751366, -0.043715622276067734, 0.02420150861144066, 0.00005059697650722228, -0.007421422749757767, -0.007344918325543404, -0.012069843709468842, -0.025728793814778328, 0.04560775309801102, -0.011693999171257019, -0.020289627835154533, -0.01596352644264698, 0.0039435457438230515, 0.0033236516173928976, 0.013298663310706615, -0.01880611479282379, 0.0074021839536726475, -0.0006117931916378438, -0.0038555231876671314, 0.0034628764260560274, -0.01923251524567604, -0.0333825908601284, 0.025515122339129448, 0.028699198737740517, -0.00695779686793685, 0.0015375696821138263, 0.0013267125468701124, 0.008422624319791794, -0.04010000452399254, -0.025202307850122452, -0.025097733363509178, 0.038520608097314835, -0.01596907153725624, -0.0014866362325847149, -0.008160170167684555, 0.020685896277427673, -0.015715762972831726, -0.043977584689855576, 0.013736387714743614, 0.03420913964509964, 0.04427316039800644, -0.013080376200377941, -0.031838249415159225, -0.05371466651558876, 0.029885755851864815, -0.015236747451126575, 0.021606724709272385, 0.0038404371589422226, -0.07742102444171906, -0.016857776790857315, -0.007129496429115534, 0.026964571326971054, 0.040036749094724655, 0.00222818017937243, -0.005677600856870413, -0.011170064099133015, -0.025422558188438416, -0.04990767687559128, 0.03603288531303406, -0.010804321616888046, 0.021235134452581406, 0.0022989765275269747, 0.01971546746790409, -0.021062247455120087, -0.0071225096471607685, 0.00855646375566721, -0.010378842242062092, -0.007207018788903952, -0.035522282123565674, 0.0338282473385334, 0.02028620056807995, 0.03615716099739075, 0.04018131271004677, -0.009968415834009647, -0.025820417329669, 0.011201536282896996, 0.028005309402942657, -0.055256057530641556, -0.02911471575498581, 0.0201498344540596, -0.030147742480039597, 0.016014259308576584, -0.007762595545500517, 0.04951527342200279, 0.03847122564911842, 0.047994621098041534, -0.034884024411439896, 0.023053988814353943, 0.025760317221283913, 0.002508964389562607, -0.0378606878221035, -0.05491997301578522, -0.01988057978451252, -0.0058348411694169044, 0.021761486306786537, -0.007306271232664585, -0.019808795303106308, -0.000014508517779177055, 0.022640421986579895, 0.023537462577223778, -0.021413695067167282, -0.04666846990585327, 0.024171538650989532, 0.022263262420892715, 0.042544737458229065, -0.004530866630375385, 0.03717269375920296, 0.03207767754793167, -0.020239312201738358, -0.004665947053581476, -0.020848900079727173, -0.011334248818457127, 0.012989923357963562, -0.023069556802511215, -0.02066040225327015, 0.005089594051241875, 0.008014517836272717, 0.01881844364106655, 0.01048156339675188, 0.02955123968422413, -0.006688357796519995, 0.06027142331004143, -0.0021482983138412237, -0.026507364585995674, 0.022078735753893852, -0.03615427389740944, -0.008005594834685326, 0.007634839043021202, 0.02145344763994217, 0.034105923026800156, 0.023846810683608055, 0.019142212346196175, -0.013774908147752285, 0.007038199342787266, -0.046805042773485184, -0.03667517006397247, -0.013249066658318043, 0.02344442903995514, -0.0035173161886632442, -0.010495451278984547, -0.00134309905115515, -0.004634405951946974, 0.01566493697464466, 0.009692532941699028, 0.004703333135694265, -0.00028421482420526445, -0.005798030644655228, 0.04428509250283241, 0.009165430441498756, 0.027548199519515038, -0.007354007568210363, 0.013102930039167404, 0.004919522907584906, 0.016934696584939957, 0.01056708674877882, 0.06975577026605606, 0.029361849650740623, -0.00020301956101320684, -0.1090942844748497, -0.022363044321537018, 0.030737943947315216, 0.020777171477675438, 0.050090495496988297, -0.05726766958832741, 0.024380261078476906, 0.04326416552066803, -0.05055510252714157, 0.01076484378427267, 0.0029223368037492037, 0.015883902087807655, -0.047317665070295334, 0.0143717797473073, -0.017676904797554016, 0.04957561939954758, 0.009165463037788868, 0.029392316937446594, 0.0438486784696579, 0.013972960412502289, 0.045415349304676056, -0.014038308523595333, -0.006590115372091532, 0.02120891958475113, 0.0051807924173772335, -0.05104072019457817, 0.07004475593566895, -0.0621032677590847, -0.05413234233856201, 0.015809277072548866, 0.04147297888994217, 0.019634339958429337, -0.007509030867367983, 0.024939121678471565, -0.00041328687802888453, 0.018226509913802147, 0.03295246511697769, -0.0050499048084020615, 0.0013506164541468024, 0.008608177304267883, -0.014773139730095863, 0.028876695781946182, -0.015631552785634995, 0.017591377720236778, -0.0028894490096718073, -0.026343347504734993, -0.019650589674711227, -0.0029620861168950796, 0.0006678997306153178, -0.06019659340381622, 0.03594234958291054, -0.007399925962090492, -0.02393019199371338, -0.019784411415457726, 0.004958930891007185, -0.034328386187553406, 0.0014294135617092252, 0.03702862188220024, 0.0006542345508933067, 0.0020077016670256853, -0.008276562206447124, -0.013668765313923359, -0.031489625573158264, 0.037795957177877426, 0.000477265304652974, -0.0017992655048146844, -0.07265137881040573, -0.009995208121836185, 0.03737209364771843, 0.002043473068624735, -0.024138225242495537, -0.00292621529661119, -0.012979254126548767, 0.026979325339198112, -0.048425380140542984, 0.016645513474941254, 0.008294557221233845, 0.007482281420379877, -0.03249994292855263, -0.061386168003082275, 0.05487101897597313, 0.00392675306648016, -0.03848911076784134, -0.030302591621875763, 0.0043588485568761826, -0.021126283332705498, -0.017595000565052032, 0.024525292217731476, 0.020083488896489143, 0.026188988238573074, -0.014180408790707588, 0.037991952151060104, 0.013719521462917328, -0.034821994602680206, 0.01600380800664425, 0.00027197852614335716, -0.018090005964040756, -0.010993016883730888, 0.017764965072274208, 0.03302687406539917, 0.03096756525337696, 0.023218635469675064, -0.03109617345035076, 0.028057733550667763, 0.019293004646897316, 0.015431894920766354, -0.0062501090578734875, 0.04584093764424324, -0.0009930331725627184, 0.0250250231474638, 0.0005324752419255674, 0.02194599062204361, 0.008782481774687767, -0.0036862888373434544, -0.06002938002347946, 0.007529576774686575, -0.010325317271053791, -0.05416417866945267, 0.005800545681267977, -0.006552099250257015, -0.011262577027082443, -0.026524215936660767, -0.027385320514440536, 0.04046684503555298, -0.06760645657777786, 0.02388373389840126, 0.008386198431253433, -0.010684528388082981, 0.05876555293798447, 0.017809415236115456, 0.008340933360159397, 0.036881331354379654, -0.02546790987253189, -0.014636144042015076, 0.01198884379118681, 0.08356036990880966, -0.01720801368355751, 0.006788530852645636, 0.021341511979699135, 0.010636461898684502, 0.005445178598165512, 0.00200193771161139, 0.06405432522296906, -0.028393493965268135, -0.01892559416592121, 0.02143913134932518, 0.031595706939697266, -0.002853436628356576, -0.026998288929462433, -0.018724139779806137, 0.07065481692552567, -0.02564171515405178, -0.002822148846462369, -0.049462802708148956, -0.0036841058172285557, -0.027199186384677887, 0.005822419188916683, -0.00003863757592625916, -0.0011953444918617606, 0.0394071489572525, -0.0025043527130037546, -0.01622370071709156, 0.0023757771123200655, 0.02732975222170353, -0.05080248787999153, 0.000622856430709362, -0.010364742949604988, -0.022213343530893326, -0.009165573865175247, -0.02425653301179409, -0.01297059841454029, -0.029698997735977173, 0.021183766424655914, 0.009271402843296528, 0.023629024624824524, -0.029125254601240158, -0.05222822725772858, -0.026755647733807564, 0.017703169956803322, -0.033837974071502686, 0.003921789582818747, -0.029906488955020905, -0.013579422608017921, -0.011476789601147175, -0.007043569814413786 ]
<p>I have a dependent variable (in counts, i.e., a number of technicians). My independent variable is a grouping factor (control and treatment). From the literature, the average number of technician required for the procedure is 3 with SD of 1. I would like to calculate a sample size to determine significant changes of 1 SD decrease in technicians.</p> <p>I think that these count data should follow a Poisson distribution and I could do a sample size calculation for Poisson regression. However, my SD is lower than one assumed for Poison regression (sqrt(mean)=1.73). What alternative tool should I use to determine a 1 SD difference and a sample size?</p> <p>Thanks! Julia</p>
74,365
[ -0.038560640066862106, -0.039950914680957794, 0.008719370700418949, -0.012016580440104008, 0.014582542702555656, 0.00853636022657156, 0.0035125189460814, -0.016228100284934044, 0.012808755040168762, -0.02666732296347618, 0.03956620767712593, 0.02681279182434082, 0.0637740045785904, -0.009244558401405811, 0.009074866771697998, 0.018456628546118736, 0.008036640472710133, -0.009407938458025455, -0.0064693717285990715, -0.007111478131264448, -0.0011483111884444952, -0.003378608264029026, 0.037857089191675186, -0.04181252792477608, 0.000433263776358217, 0.06524331122636795, -0.016230084002017975, -0.022634904831647873, -0.0336822085082531, 0.027472225949168205, -0.03558683767914772, -0.024927692487835884, 0.007638874463737011, 0.012616124004125595, -0.00582184037193656, -0.014258205890655518, -0.019874338060617447, -0.038059331476688385, -0.015189592726528645, 0.01990203745663166, -0.03694726899266243, -0.01496910396963358, -0.0032745497301220894, 0.007930250838398933, 0.0005537979304790497, 0.03414084389805794, -0.01898799277842045, -0.051792390644550323, 0.035779617726802826, -0.013307706452906132, 0.06569033861160278, 0.014807485975325108, 0.04697118327021599, -0.002324773697182536, -0.02909540757536888, -0.012011460959911346, 0.002567525487393141, 0.03454902768135071, -0.03566642850637436, -0.004297909792512655, -0.01323278434574604, -0.022711588069796562, 0.003425939939916134, -0.018810860812664032, -0.026430904865264893, 0.0031818479765206575, -0.03505725786089897, -0.013606461696326733, 0.003566431812942028, -0.028339432552456856, 0.042068082839250565, -0.0011945593869313598, 0.01579686626791954, 0.014036517590284348, -0.0422927662730217, -0.02122119441628456, 0.02123887836933136, 0.04590165242552757, 0.058865997940301895, 0.04908384755253792, -0.007400311529636383, 0.014561924152076244, 0.039153944700956345, 0.012414085678756237, 0.015968017280101776, -0.014457025565207005, 0.07058081775903702, -0.0029492443427443504, 0.025725683197379112, 0.019425949081778526, -0.03966379165649414, 0.000545279763173312, 0.07081969082355499, 0.02560179866850376, -0.018986904993653297, -0.017691798508167267, -0.048359088599681854, 0.0491078719496727, -0.015837879851460457, 0.036181870847940445, -0.007319688331335783, -0.047955725342035294, 0.03795987740159035, 0.020330369472503662, -0.04874155670404434, 0.008199903182685375, -0.0006743367412127554, -0.021421121433377266, -0.012306428514420986, -0.038374971598386765, -0.0050920164212584496, -0.006669891532510519, 0.031913891434669495, -0.0013017132878303528, 0.007761136628687382, 0.01957327499985695, -0.027696935459971428, 0.020421797409653664, 0.08387885987758636, 0.07356397062540054, 0.0380123034119606, -0.01625947467982769, 0.016472071409225464, -0.026651587337255478, -0.03518544137477875, 0.032517824321985245, -0.008787347003817558, -0.028777778148651123, -0.0687170997262001, 0.03758702799677849, 0.024034228175878525, -0.02159336768090725, 0.034830592572689056, -0.0006957342266105115, 0.03235822543501854, -0.0031301744747906923, -0.06189606338739395, -0.0321974903345108, 0.01708601601421833, 0.005455856677144766, 0.051354024559259415, -0.02874686010181904, -0.0020717214792966843, 0.004600034561008215, 0.021767033264040947, 0.05040232837200165, 0.03800155222415924, 0.0041678608395159245, 0.012633170932531357, 0.010960094630718231, -0.017254943028092384, -0.006255519110709429, -0.002668909262865782, -0.020733797922730446, 0.0008165118633769453, -0.07199113070964813, 0.02864997088909149, 0.015716055408120155, 0.030199116095900536, -0.004186253994703293, 0.04956863448023796, 0.00622269231826067, 0.01903333142399788, -0.010768389329314232, 0.027557220309972763, -0.019248314201831818, 0.04716222733259201, -0.014634073711931705, 0.0064549692906439304, -0.016564680263400078, 0.027614878490567207, 0.03573682904243469, -0.003663055831566453, 0.03527100756764412, 0.020392611622810364, 0.008917040191590786, 0.02704285830259323, -0.011095542460680008, 0.013529299758374691, 0.032662663608789444, -0.03769082576036453, 0.008227854035794735, -0.028047123923897743, -0.010248052887618542, 0.02048298344016075, 0.0691978856921196, 0.006794774439185858, -0.000032872081646928564, 0.005436854436993599, -0.011658729054033756, -0.051801420748233795, -0.07636187970638275, 0.008662558160722256, 0.019296683371067047, -0.0388021357357502, 0.03910733014345169, 0.032601915299892426, 0.01633402146399021, 0.003971313592046499, 0.00997140258550644, -0.021176937967538834, -0.0193376112729311, 0.04364708438515663, -0.04437034949660301, 0.013398404233157635, 0.05041991174221039, 0.08174251019954681, -0.023906301707029343, 0.03662339597940445, -0.018139293417334557, -0.03232762590050697, -0.008443254046142101, -0.05902649834752083, -0.01020949985831976, 0.0024044278543442488, -0.01903228648006916, 0.026102392002940178, -0.03182261437177658, -0.049521733075380325, 0.057634804397821426, -0.023966509848833084, 0.04555644094944, 0.04590297117829323, -0.005215906538069248, 0.03396914154291153, 0.011065773665904999, -0.004326912574470043, -0.002314445096999407, -0.004010345786809921, -0.043526824563741684, -0.03399435430765152, -0.0006683185929432511, 0.03188207373023033, 0.020655805245041847, -0.04152795299887657, -0.017308419570326805, 0.04571337625384331, -0.03369897976517677, 0.027278970927000046, 0.01698717288672924, 0.006853334605693817, -0.011524960398674011, -0.01192828081548214, 0.0005522581050172448, 0.02800126001238823, -0.04574361443519592, 0.015772342681884766, 0.001650925725698471, 0.05403114855289459, -0.017377158626914024, 0.01831950433552265, 0.002242117887362838, -0.03350049629807472, 0.011097230948507786, 0.01461974997073412, 0.006424120161682367, 0.03736480697989464, -0.020733196288347244, -0.011937301605939865, 0.047947436571121216, 0.007450205273926258, 0.008593742735683918, 0.02739035151898861, -0.01945533975958824, 0.03238096088171005, 0.04005115106701851, -0.03536555543541908, 0.04264587536454201, 0.013145976699888706, -0.07054546475410461, 0.013855629600584507, 0.0005298980395309627, -0.0504336878657341, -0.07161349803209305, 0.018893079832196236, 0.01898634247481823, 0.012557322159409523, 0.026762574911117554, -0.008915737271308899, 0.007559587247669697, -0.013346562162041664, 0.0010751152876764536, 0.04140274599194527, 0.0116663109511137, -0.04512796178460121, -0.02772156149148941, 0.01784641481935978, -0.02818440832197666, 0.04464688524603844, 0.008843949064612389, -0.026577483862638474, 0.02541808784008026, -0.004890390206128359, -0.045267414301633835, -0.04423851892352104, 0.0065899742767214775, -0.008659277111291885, 0.02642507664859295, -0.006020057946443558, -0.0035862575750797987, 0.024113042280077934, -0.011465432122349739, 0.008931935764849186, -0.03668312728404999, -0.008609441109001637, -0.03752340003848076, 0.02815445326268673, -0.011213641613721848, -0.00329477502964437, -0.0067904056049883366, 0.035581644624471664, -0.005256666336208582, -0.02228601463139057, -0.06596345454454422, -0.046970516443252563, -0.023772742599248886, 0.01731220632791519, 0.06357718259096146, -0.014901489019393921, -0.02825123630464077, 0.057520605623722076, 0.023992862552404404, -0.028768932446837425, -0.02420455403625965, 0.012812339700758457, -0.04705064371228218, -0.011344906874001026, 0.04649559408426285, 0.025845520198345184, -0.0022479048930108547, 0.011894593015313148, -0.055422961711883545, 0.028867609798908234, 0.03775468468666077, 0.029122846201062202, -0.011470573954284191, 0.002332862000912428, 0.00021658968762494624, -0.010723126120865345, 0.03157229721546173, 0.03306474909186363, -0.06607454270124435, 0.0157325379550457, -0.015605892054736614, 0.027693621814250946, -0.010239504277706146, -0.04633743315935135, -0.029115870594978333, 0.046351078897714615, -0.010708321817219257, 0.0041535357013344765, 0.007310850080102682, 0.05657467991113663, -0.0589187815785408, 0.002239697612822056, 0.0456574410200119, 0.006247148383408785, -0.04390419274568558, -0.029433535411953926, 0.039738256484270096, 0.09464652091264725, -0.022297972813248634, -0.037282779812812805, -0.017716920003294945, -0.010200495831668377, -0.02056528627872467, -0.017766505479812622, -0.03391672670841217, 0.029770299792289734, 0.01816411130130291, 0.03599150851368904, -0.02515091933310032, -0.003885705256834626, 0.007863041013479233, -0.03729519248008728, -0.03662595897912979, 0.0012232180451974273, 0.06654252111911774, 0.010375162586569786, 0.019468458369374275, -0.0022980310022830963, 0.00513489730656147, 0.020525524392724037, -0.031222157180309296, -0.055334609001874924, 0.05706261843442917, -0.014661716297268867, -0.005727196112275124, 0.00486376229673624, 0.021093834191560745, 0.009878203272819519, -0.018483148887753487, 0.044810760766267776, -0.0005520441918633878, 0.07187916338443756, 0.007380131632089615, 0.00039306460530497134, 0.013224601745605469, -0.0032257058192044497, -0.0033084703609347343, 0.027431555092334747, 0.010188048705458641, 0.009112859144806862, -0.01850956492125988, -0.012386620976030827, -0.0270175002515316, -0.03523914888501167, -0.04080196097493172, 0.01753816567361355, 0.004580672364681959, 0.0336543470621109, 0.042789917439222336, 0.03262130171060562, -0.043360404670238495, 0.03598915413022041, 0.0014515765942633152, 0.014348717406392097, 0.015344302169978619, 0.014754658564925194, 0.0017364656087011099, -0.08451908081769943, 0.022348683327436447, -0.001141440006904304, 0.004911037161946297, -0.013688328675925732, 0.009685386903584003, 0.05467766150832176, -0.0042639789171516895, -0.07700025290250778, -0.0029361897613853216, 0.03156992793083191, 0.013746034353971481, 0.01954149268567562, -0.048320237547159195, 0.02950163744390011, -0.004272860940545797, -0.030808867886662483, 0.040959861129522324, 0.04779929295182228, 0.001148356357589364, 0.001064715557731688, 0.02271711267530918, 0.004964055027812719, -0.0466921292245388, -0.018072785809636116, 0.015881378203630447, 0.049014728516340256, 0.04688812792301178, -0.02042398788034916, 0.022523989900946617, 0.05100679770112038, 0.026513054966926575, 0.005183891858905554, 0.0052793435752391815, -0.06125526502728462, 0.009531407617032528, 0.027361977845430374, 0.05168488249182701, -0.054633621126413345, 0.007854106836020947, -0.009464788250625134, -0.017264673486351967, 0.03252480924129486, -0.07710094004869461, 0.001338366768322885, -0.005799793638288975, -0.0029397981707006693, -0.01511931698769331, -0.03111223876476288, -0.08770433068275452, 0.031066788360476494, -0.04396768659353256, 0.015068292617797852, -0.023818006739020348, -0.023644670844078064, 0.0003611740539781749, 0.01487043034285307, 0.027037981897592545, 0.06921073794364929, -0.04628417268395424, -0.016711382195353508, 0.02250443957746029, 0.01954827830195427, -0.010799446143209934, -0.03541037440299988, -0.002712507266551256, -0.0027104190085083246, 0.013054010458290577, 0.06413699686527252, -0.023000655695796013, -0.030343802645802498, 0.039131324738264084, 0.029888952150940895, -0.019546741619706154, -0.012423176318407059, -0.008857489563524723, 0.028208844363689423, 0.03913826122879982, 0.009183710440993309, 0.03613637015223503, 0.030604029074311256, 0.018906237557530403, 0.028058519586920738, -0.02169177122414112, -0.034147102385759354, -0.005647339392453432, -0.03028675727546215, -0.04435441270470619, 0.04738636687397957, -0.01465761847794056, 0.054097726941108704, -0.006121319252997637, 0.03091830015182495, -0.009160921908915043, 0.015541770495474339, 0.03530822694301605, 0.01641528680920601, 0.0166142750531435, -0.011460795067250729, 0.01438239123672247, 0.016754290089011192, 0.012992039322853088, -0.038231540471315384, 0.006690824404358864, -0.04268689826130867, 0.012664010748267174, -0.0008311607525683939, -0.055824872106313705, 0.004081556107848883, -0.021580636501312256, -0.03603620454668999, 0.04790366813540459, -0.03927101939916611, 0.05520948767662048, -0.04441739246249199, 0.04407885670661926, -0.04752512648701668, -0.011222261004149914, 0.003874971065670252, 0.004582005087286234, -0.039871688932180405, 0.032966792583465576, -0.04733077809214592, 0.040563277900218964, -0.007469905074685812, -0.025110051035881042, -0.0803261324763298, -0.044402386993169785, 0.024895112961530685, -0.007837176322937012, -0.04257669672369957, -0.025771718472242355, -0.03183581680059433, -0.00851339939981699, -0.03268323466181755, -0.003250692505389452, 0.05464653670787811, -0.018322845920920372, -0.016042260453104973, -0.013381276279687881, 0.0084554897621274, 0.06242097541689873, 0.005287001375108957, -0.018570877611637115, -0.025593969970941544, -0.05061543732881546, -0.01748533919453621, 0.013376335613429546, -0.008329290896654129, -0.029856042936444283, -0.01754087582230568, -0.01628083363175392, -0.014951596967875957, 0.027169229462742805, -0.04415702447295189, -0.025826014578342438, -0.02268093265593052, 0.012369555421173573, 0.03304222971200943, -0.024727389216423035, -0.004541040398180485, 0.013196722604334354, 0.029651181772351265, -0.0312928669154644, 0.03350331261754036, -0.021092873066663742, -0.0024285141844302416, -0.00819819699972868, 0.053976673632860184, -0.014874415472149849, 0.01066627912223339, 0.04669312760233879, 0.027229461818933487, 0.017463570460677147, 0.02240285836160183, -0.0017952296184375882, 0.04911215230822563, -0.013017285615205765, 0.006357072852551937, 0.013290722854435444, 0.028675470501184464, -0.04266613721847534, -0.04164406284689903, -0.023103628307580948, 0.00854756124317646, 0.040434565395116806, 0.015043399296700954, 0.03639770299196243, 0.05448959022760391, 0.0014523881254717708, -0.0005893105990253389, -0.04061924293637276, -0.01167262252420187, -0.013644478283822536, -0.005230383947491646, 0.0532403327524662, -0.018279843032360077, 0.023515775799751282, 0.050693247467279434, 0.03610296547412872, -0.02237660437822342, 0.05915624275803566, 0.013755635358393192, 0.013883392326533794, 0.04719164967536926, -0.04450852423906326, -0.0428292378783226, 0.014965864829719067, -0.018040411174297333, 0.020649416372179985, -0.04202696308493614, -0.017006859183311462, 0.05704040080308914, 0.03367019072175026, 0.02325756847858429, -0.039006274193525314, -0.0332060232758522, -0.06000538170337677, -0.0072903684340417385, 0.02327592298388481, -0.020323319360613823, 0.014614047482609749, 0.01425605546683073, 0.027762586250901222, 0.0007531442097388208, 0.03702780604362488, -0.04143432155251503, -0.02538621798157692, -0.004092099145054817, -0.024867458269000053, -0.008522785268723965, 0.018709778785705566, -0.04228805750608444, -0.040630992501974106, 0.009333126246929169, -0.004699239041656256, 0.010325447656214237, 0.010021582245826721, -0.0016384633490815759, -0.003622592892497778, 0.04133852198719978, 0.007232167292386293, 0.014886319637298584, 0.05037587508559227, 0.03415388986468315, 0.13357549905776978, 0.08546362072229385, 0.01405534241348505, -0.058515362441539764, -0.003665686585009098, 0.024230318143963814, 0.012631906196475029, -0.009485370479524136, 0.005468261428177357, 0.005745753180235624, -0.01177876815199852, 0.02429022826254368, 0.0461600236594677, -0.009242866188287735, 0.0008123877923935652, 0.08082354068756104, -0.0020540542900562286, -0.009823950007557869, -0.011708860285580158, 0.008101312443614006, -0.018746519461274147, -0.00689140846952796, -0.0564437136054039, 0.041710857301950455, 0.017300298437476158, -0.029277533292770386, -0.039233703166246414, 0.021872345358133316, -0.023751838132739067, 0.011582853272557259, -0.019284844398498535, -0.004132494796067476, 0.001554572256281972, 0.04125174880027771, -0.03839445486664772, -0.017971087247133255, 0.01646149531006813, -0.07890891283750534, -0.02856293134391308, 0.05976599454879761, -0.016327129676938057, 0.01287104096263647, -0.006938130594789982, -0.004360429476946592, -0.048433542251586914, 0.0006568274111486971, -0.03393750637769699, 0.028622737154364586, 0.019525809213519096, 0.004852116107940674, -0.0048607587814331055, -0.014013991691172123, -0.011117767542600632, -0.03930586948990822, -0.017263125628232956, 0.017323093488812447, 0.01269425917416811, -0.03940277919173241, -0.030916526913642883, -0.008629861287772655, -0.0007155608618631959, -0.014200795441865921, 0.01054332684725523, 0.08214971423149109, -0.025866642594337463, -0.03551225736737251, 0.000769622391089797, 0.04003138095140457, 0.008085246197879314, -0.011449172161519527, 0.002322857966646552, 0.006989792920649052, 0.018610317260026932, -0.0166274793446064, 0.010007566772401333, 0.02521742694079876, 0.060243502259254456, -0.01332030724734068, -0.016907118260860443, -0.0029954840429127216, -0.0766734853386879, 0.027938254177570343, -0.020612888038158417, 0.004344025161117315, -0.05831725895404816, 0.005112943239510059, -0.0053405119106173515, 0.03083687089383602, -0.011255246587097645, -0.04766708239912987, 0.04257165640592575, 0.041949477046728134, 0.028950609266757965, -0.050033364444971085, 0.006938243750482798, 0.026358701288700104, -0.04029829055070877, 0.021985873579978943, -0.030416803434491158, 0.06483636051416397, -0.02079964615404606, -0.004860442131757736, 0.006556130480021238, 0.013817919418215752, -0.024122100323438644, 0.03256748616695404, -0.0123618608340621, -0.054432354867458344, -0.006267026998102665, 0.015727603808045387, -0.0056474399752914906, -0.0221624206751585, -0.028091738000512123, -0.03725527971982956, -0.023432577028870583, -0.01225734781473875, -0.019566889852285385, -0.03141292184591293, -0.025172347202897072, -0.028387781232595444, 0.007259082980453968, 0.018512411043047905, 0.035451021045446396, -0.025741849094629288, -0.04797883331775665, 0.011028892360627651, -0.008419728837907314, -0.012179676443338394, 0.004433315712958574, -0.0027743272949010134, 0.04232575744390488, 0.021689755842089653, 0.021041681990027428, 0.012810527347028255, -0.000218893401324749, -0.016578078269958496, -0.018182920292019844, 0.028233569115400314, -0.023467065766453743, 0.0239429771900177, 0.07709281146526337, -0.07380258291959763, -0.034903183579444885, 0.04853355139493942, -0.025038914754986763, 0.04924739897251129, 0.0313679538667202, -0.004324933048337698, 0.009381141513586044, 0.03022836335003376, -0.027997760102152824, -0.03701361268758774, -0.03534689173102379, -0.00010781815944937989, -0.0035225297324359417, -0.042004309594631195, -0.0072548589669167995, 0.03151991218328476, 0.00547901913523674, 0.017676154151558876, 0.029832206666469574, -0.006816860754042864, -0.006320035085082054, -0.0036291482392698526, 0.006911732256412506, 0.018512368202209473, -0.001456163707189262, -0.03423968330025673, 0.02929377369582653, 0.07983069866895676, -0.05174199491739273, 0.023894881829619408, -0.020001087337732315, 0.034316591918468475, -0.1079191192984581, -0.024108408018946648, -0.026110799983143806, -0.001449430943466723, 0.03488994017243385, -0.04157098010182381, 0.008013797923922539, 0.009236740879714489, -0.04456217214465141, -0.026732157915830612, -0.04370342940092087, -0.030044103041291237, -0.04042196273803711, -0.029746076092123985, 0.006024747621268034, 0.014560310170054436, 0.011424819938838482, 0.03218454495072365, 0.028707947582006454, 0.03845728188753128, 0.009184143505990505, -0.034630291163921356, -0.0032272525131702423, 0.031775809824466705, -0.014012709259986877, -0.08218857645988464, 0.008334263227880001, -0.05706309899687767, 0.01063491776585579, 0.03356797620654106, -0.007438101340085268, -0.0017126837046816945, 0.0404161736369133, 0.03228415176272392, -0.04178858920931816, 0.08684087544679642, 0.020292453467845917, -0.004194299690425396, -0.03090708702802658, -0.027466123923659325, -0.01076402235776186, 0.028495825827121735, 0.020062899217009544, 0.007427708711475134, 0.03993820771574974, -0.0006277517531998456, 0.014947171323001385, -0.011018235236406326, 0.009422109462320805, -0.030727261677384377, 0.007132330443710089, 0.008692154660820961, -0.012323372066020966, 0.000023347580281551927, 0.017132053151726723, -0.05553939566016197, 0.009058086201548576, 0.05028512328863144, 0.05332006514072418, -0.031206181272864342, 0.010006790980696678, -0.0216879490762949, -0.03804708272218704, -0.003297161078080535, -0.010706310160458088, -0.01593320071697235, -0.029617996886372566, 0.016034413129091263, -0.021384844556450844, 0.02858937904238701, -0.04392348229885101, 0.0118514159694314, -0.005918326787650585, 0.054996639490127563, -0.049022167921066284, -0.03895331174135208, 0.03762819617986679, 0.015071938745677471, 0.062115542590618134, -0.08183988928794861, 0.052793990820646286, 0.03879070281982422, -0.041763611137866974, -0.02910424955189228, -0.020805049687623978, -0.048007093369960785, 0.014417029917240143, 0.06502652168273926, 0.028175991028547287, -0.008139431476593018, 0.0015817541861906648, 0.037733178585767746, 0.00795621145516634, -0.04274637624621391, 0.039916153997182846, -0.02943621389567852, -0.017763745039701462, -0.048031438142061234, 0.007507558912038803, 0.044749706983566284, 0.00518615311011672, -0.029043162241578102, 0.008831124752759933, 0.009317048825323582, 0.0012872486840933561, -0.00846293568611145, -0.02342992275953293, 0.012709804810583591, 0.0012854482047259808, 0.04962054640054703, 0.0015470559010282159, 0.00472033116966486, -0.002024887129664421, 0.010165465995669365, -0.03311409428715706, 0.02052365243434906, -0.009842686355113983, -0.0025184203404933214, 0.00705926725640893, -0.010578922927379608, 0.0042867097072303295, -0.036531005054712296, 0.022702889516949654, -0.026119986549019814, -0.028404662385582924, -0.012765111401677132, 0.01732032187283039, 0.03786975517868996, 0.050912484526634216, -0.02570960484445095, 0.0030433847568929195, -0.00028349438798613846, 0.016224300488829613, 0.022689159959554672, 0.017171259969472885, -0.030177565291523933, 0.014672759920358658, -0.012544427998363972, 0.04422660544514656, -0.01191682368516922, 0.007389959413558245, 0.027953583747148514, 0.01420748420059681, 0.025721456855535507, -0.018785560503602028, 0.014550537802278996, -0.022738659754395485, 0.019152915105223656, 0.008096817880868912, 0.03180845454335213, 0.03680204600095749, -0.010730407200753689, 0.005163881927728653, -0.044824372977018356, -0.01848601922392845, -0.020711375400424004, -0.017706502228975296, 0.0006623720400966704, 0.038761917501688004, -0.0320717878639698, 0.004649877082556486, -0.0028545698150992393, -0.00705289700999856, 0.004238001070916653, -0.03233564272522926, 0.05165814608335495, 0.007515231613069773, -0.004262596368789673, -0.04149686545133591, -0.017332326620817184, 0.019967546686530113, -0.01804998889565468, 0.04967019334435463, 0.05892954766750336, 0.0479404553771019, -0.014075947925448418, -0.03185466304421425, -0.015413953922688961, 0.0455290749669075, -0.054777052253484726, -0.07272467017173767, -0.06141968443989754, 0.007398196961730719, 0.010500926524400711, 0.00131577393040061 ]
<p>An experiment has two possible outcomes: A or B. In 20 experiments, A happened 2 times, and B happens 18 times. What would I expect from a larger number of experiments? With what confidence can I say that the mean number of outcome A is 10%?</p>
74,366
[ -0.037421949207782745, -0.03842209279537201, -0.01099397148936987, -0.0003602597862482071, 0.05681924521923065, -0.0015940068988129497, -0.017820991575717926, -0.022597666829824448, -0.0006351602496579289, -0.0035445510875433683, 0.05507531389594078, 0.02745356410741806, 0.007908528670668602, 0.009609569795429707, -0.0028748810291290283, 0.02471829578280449, -0.017390243709087372, 0.010632463730871677, 0.021198133006691933, -0.003748017828911543, -0.010965037159621716, 0.03507375717163086, -0.007793299853801727, 0.01585787534713745, -0.017504176124930382, 0.028340531513094902, 0.053786661475896835, -0.03211512044072151, 0.012533343397080898, 0.032914984971284866, -0.027686936780810356, -0.022975420579314232, 0.03022860549390316, 0.041180212050676346, 0.030703755095601082, -0.01664210855960846, -0.005484332796186209, -0.025742916390299797, 0.003112610662356019, 0.0028815469704568386, -0.036188386380672455, 0.007949348539113998, 0.011356205679476261, 0.019785426557064056, -0.0032931650057435036, 0.01538575068116188, 0.01723853312432766, -0.08170130103826523, 0.017640478909015656, -0.03201674669981003, 0.08375226706266403, 0.004161181394010782, 0.03323386609554291, 0.022855177521705627, -0.01622767560184002, -0.007359697017818689, 0.029930375516414642, 0.06530770659446716, -0.011608258821070194, -0.06103890761733055, 0.013770832680165768, -0.03225363790988922, -0.016491785645484924, 0.02755226381123066, -0.022847358137369156, -0.00531941931694746, -0.026849253103137016, -0.017211809754371643, 0.03661732375621796, -0.013522879220545292, 0.015800736844539642, 0.011135837063193321, 0.08183454722166061, 0.025814728811383247, 0.01375493686646223, -0.0003380900889169425, 0.028938040137290955, 0.0009245834080502391, 0.054338596761226654, 0.0543610118329525, -0.00543711194768548, -0.00008255239663412794, 0.013863259926438332, 0.030137909576296806, 0.015221308916807175, -0.040897972881793976, 0.07276233285665512, -0.014689733274281025, 0.02181130088865757, 0.02529069222509861, -0.015842249616980553, -0.0023670680820941925, 0.03676671162247658, 0.02388828806579113, -0.03708180412650108, -0.010175999253988266, -0.027018539607524872, 0.0495174266397953, 0.0005809724098071456, 0.011473390273749828, -0.02142852172255516, -0.01864572986960411, 0.03975210338830948, 0.05854106694459915, -0.02087845653295517, 0.012568574398756027, -0.017292046919465065, -0.010633343830704689, -0.04278683289885521, 0.008289945311844349, 0.009033356793224812, 0.06410785019397736, 0.01573578640818596, 0.056055352091789246, -0.008154716342687607, -0.019611025229096413, 0.008022360503673553, -0.012208267115056515, 0.05239151418209076, 0.0682729184627533, 0.024992482736706734, -0.01947782002389431, 0.009958738461136818, -0.0050806924700737, -0.0299594197422266, 0.02654692903161049, 0.013108679093420506, -0.0077293324284255505, -0.03892957791686058, 0.051850493997335434, 0.00228811870329082, -0.009283351711928844, -0.014097064733505249, 0.013533840887248516, 0.017106300219893456, -0.035251278430223465, -0.07969850301742554, -0.06678339093923569, 0.05382417514920235, -0.03230320289731026, -0.026791775599122047, -0.08062201738357544, 0.02529483288526535, 0.03647291660308838, 0.04717559367418289, 0.013990798965096474, 0.02160196751356125, 0.01638791151344776, 0.04958730563521385, 0.00800386257469654, -0.012376382015645504, 0.039381444454193115, -0.01055274996906519, -0.010766252875328064, -0.021722398698329926, -0.08714623749256134, 0.02754429168999195, 0.010336535051465034, 0.01154718454927206, -0.0027950063813477755, -0.013783787377178669, -0.01700950413942337, -0.03158366680145264, 0.0024400462862104177, -0.0008305254159495234, -0.0010909164557233453, 0.08221567422151566, 0.036725472658872604, 0.0305639635771513, 0.009427489712834358, 0.009186187759041786, 0.019258474931120872, 0.039773859083652496, 0.023156026378273964, 0.04045012965798378, -0.01924337074160576, 0.029125196859240532, 0.004696941003203392, 0.004848022945225239, 0.00529116578400135, -0.017627675086259842, -0.012459716759622097, -0.02470148727297783, 0.02659088931977749, 0.024101661518216133, 0.0013402721378952265, 0.01758487895131111, -0.010138089768588543, 0.007719836663454771, -0.011898028664290905, -0.05977162718772888, -0.09632740914821625, -0.009625987149775028, -0.008115396834909916, 0.0021356490906327963, -0.030334483832120895, 0.021013645455241203, -0.0021728656720370054, -0.014416455291211605, 0.008328392170369625, -0.03539128229022026, -0.004077473655343056, 0.017471257597208023, -0.019464291632175446, 0.012413372285664082, 0.0610598549246788, 0.03856564685702324, -0.021413613110780716, 0.0562150813639164, -0.04983319714665413, -0.04277067631483078, -0.03718264028429985, -0.022605711594223976, -0.016179164871573448, 0.005777572747319937, -0.02986404486000538, 0.016399281099438667, -0.006376839708536863, -0.03276747092604637, 0.04926784336566925, -0.05274210125207901, 0.07042141258716583, 0.07010136544704437, 0.018296292051672935, -0.0021780095994472504, 0.013036149553954601, 0.023039206862449646, -0.006251216866075993, -0.015051898546516895, -0.030621487647294998, -0.06827852129936218, 0.0011414828477427363, 0.0218216422945261, 0.004242460243403912, -0.0413300059735775, 0.029770266264677048, 0.06712129712104797, 0.029657011851668358, -0.012880483642220497, 0.0584518164396286, 0.01702074334025383, 0.002608169801533222, 0.003184795379638672, 0.030072709545493126, 0.019110361114144325, 0.016420885920524597, -0.014715097844600677, 0.009766372852027416, 0.011442321352660656, 0.026744190603494644, 0.0008261346956714988, -0.0026001869700849056, -0.0041841622442007065, -0.0014296341687440872, -0.01635119505226612, -0.021201249212026596, 0.018276052549481392, -0.005922062322497368, -0.02841765619814396, 0.011289366520941257, 0.030477309599518776, -0.00006749278691131622, 0.01415062602609396, -0.027648108080029488, 0.0008185071055777371, 0.013528273440897465, -0.007737091742455959, -0.033639390021562576, 0.0386677086353302, -0.03147970885038376, -0.01776268146932125, -0.04363707825541496, 0.0036372134927660227, -0.035980306565761566, -0.026131324470043182, 0.020895445719361305, -0.0041839610785245895, 0.04196442291140556, -0.02841927669942379, -0.03414515033364296, -0.04631542041897774, -0.013614601455628872, 0.007826977409422398, -0.028096545487642288, -0.06981571018695831, 0.017056936398148537, 0.00029791565611958504, -0.051203858107328415, 0.024199066683650017, -0.029963938519358635, 0.000301489548292011, 0.03003513254225254, 0.007943585515022278, -0.035809967666864395, -0.013842495158314705, -0.016610341146588326, -0.0156108932569623, -0.017263351008296013, -0.0032432228326797485, 0.058210741728544235, 0.0018328627338632941, -0.041235752403736115, 0.027366317808628082, -0.008528110571205616, -0.03795550391077995, -0.03395088016986847, 0.009840680286288261, -0.008726666681468487, 0.00017005203699227422, 0.003210230264812708, -0.024306658655405045, -0.007193943485617638, -0.07023253291845322, -0.07001283764839172, -0.06680569797754288, 0.0011349974665790796, 0.003188301809132099, 0.06316551566123962, 0.0019068924011662602, 0.013317110948264599, 0.08268015831708908, 0.029543425887823105, -0.03797956928610802, -0.003854336217045784, 0.009934386238455772, -0.012587080709636211, -0.009923008270561695, 0.01638646051287651, 0.012060155160725117, -0.04112914577126503, 0.033687252551317215, 0.008170767687261105, 0.02033686265349388, 0.035785503685474396, -0.022651514038443565, -0.00014147342881187797, 0.0066307238303124905, 0.03913353383541107, -0.03573489934206009, 0.03130274638533592, 0.033829446882009506, -0.04178785905241966, -0.005488199647516012, -0.03274757042527199, 0.01542788464576006, 0.007832573726773262, -0.07507885247468948, 0.0450349859893322, -0.020468242466449738, 0.0014932557241991162, -0.02996744215488434, 0.007766083814203739, -0.016539769247174263, -0.009320848621428013, 0.008820424787700176, -0.0048988680355250835, 0.06472969055175781, -0.02624046429991722, -0.026545187458395958, 0.023322122171521187, 0.06148478761315346, 0.004426301922649145, -0.03149925917387009, -0.025133322924375534, -0.018771182745695114, -0.013258994556963444, -0.017358845099806786, -0.04021352529525757, 0.04144418239593506, 0.026633091270923615, -0.0057905856519937515, -0.003564816666767001, -0.0393223837018013, -0.0006805961602367461, -0.05836430564522743, -0.01563107594847679, -0.0463612824678421, 0.0166051983833313, 0.007574761752039194, 0.01945788599550724, -0.020041801035404205, -0.02305738441646099, -0.020271696150302887, -0.01479161623865366, -0.061233002692461014, 0.03927698731422424, -0.028994515538215637, 0.006770351901650429, -0.008634183555841446, 0.0014313232386484742, 0.05454455688595772, -0.0030871769413352013, 0.01680193655192852, -0.016538148745894432, 0.02209128998219967, -0.03474296256899834, 0.031030533835291862, -0.038122158497571945, -0.032764434814453125, 0.00454459385946393, 0.016536468639969826, 0.006702195852994919, 0.02269682288169861, 0.0692327544093132, -0.015183603391051292, -0.0341012217104435, -0.028965376317501068, 0.008710365742444992, 0.012067196890711784, 0.01815471053123474, 0.05743153765797615, -0.0005445504211820662, 0.029196303337812424, -0.04698517918586731, 0.03853254392743111, 0.004058568272739649, 0.060324776917696, 0.019878337159752846, 0.007108775433152914, -0.022462597116827965, -0.05373598262667656, 0.0015535176498815417, 0.012479269877076149, -0.004021750297397375, -0.0034678869415074587, -0.0044201756827533245, 0.03959512338042259, 0.0028686756268143654, -0.07233790308237076, 0.014328965917229652, 0.02823738567531109, -0.019808128476142883, 0.00393000990152359, -0.04465562477707863, -0.007208546157926321, 0.015646016225218773, -0.013752643018960953, -0.012464717961847782, -0.019201358780264854, 0.005507116671651602, 0.0009033769019879401, 0.06963108479976654, -0.031208423897624016, -0.05644911155104637, 0.022112563252449036, -0.05731145665049553, 0.0468592643737793, 0.022759726271033287, -0.04029455780982971, -0.005535560194402933, 0.03136920556426048, 0.021189121529459953, 0.026344342157244682, -0.005499543156474829, -0.038667235523462296, 0.03747144341468811, 0.021119847893714905, 0.056189198046922684, -0.027962923049926758, 0.02344556152820587, -0.03143441304564476, -0.015724211931228638, 0.04242214560508728, -0.055271994322538376, 0.00212877057492733, -0.05319128558039665, 0.02916547656059265, -0.02411254681646824, -0.017619287595152855, -0.04353943467140198, -0.00467308796942234, -0.02512040175497532, 0.012561975046992302, 0.0027933891396969557, -0.016885800287127495, 0.013426725752651691, 0.0004410020774230361, 0.07142482697963715, 0.07227129489183426, -0.04404202476143837, 0.013176028616726398, -0.012735899537801743, -0.00991539005190134, -0.02025933377444744, -0.06581607460975647, 0.02212122082710266, -0.02041703090071678, -0.0018664420349523425, 0.030757740139961243, -0.018165361136198044, -0.06643764674663544, 0.01031112764030695, -0.013467802666127682, -0.02935650944709778, -0.01619749329984188, -0.034626636654138565, 0.0125883799046278, 0.03631143644452095, 0.008203059434890747, 0.05270707979798317, -0.028989380225539207, 0.0026530628092586994, 0.0030914165545254946, -0.024238863959908485, 0.034867800772190094, -0.014537283219397068, 0.010311825200915337, -0.04626813158392906, 0.005403274670243263, 0.012145045213401318, 0.03613016754388809, 0.020317157730460167, 0.0009119740570895374, -0.003981935791671276, -0.03869939595460892, 0.0033478382974863052, 0.013747270219027996, 0.03134988993406296, -0.02453986182808876, 0.007492725737392902, -0.00531639251857996, 0.00415162043645978, -0.03468501940369606, 0.014069759286940098, 0.004208849277347326, 0.05288304015994072, 0.0004421530175022781, -0.056194983422756195, 0.017992578446865082, -0.08195338398218155, 0.01542169600725174, 0.020337993279099464, -0.07816047221422195, 0.06915272772312164, -0.011932517401874065, 0.012849956750869751, 0.008285821415483952, 0.0038408320397138596, -0.012752372771501541, 0.009178105741739273, 0.0004179525712970644, 0.02005775272846222, -0.05473942309617996, 0.009671129286289215, 0.005368548911064863, 0.015018200501799583, -0.09105857461690903, -0.05502680689096451, 0.034479886293411255, 0.03789934515953064, 0.031665366142988205, 0.008740713819861412, -0.04331161826848984, 0.01202325988560915, -0.05613769590854645, -0.042456161230802536, 0.026907887309789658, -0.007730563636869192, -0.03992057219147682, -0.006878936663269997, 0.04777434095740318, 0.06727702915668488, 0.013094600290060043, -0.042125023901462555, 0.005703292787075043, -0.02838541567325592, -0.04804067313671112, 0.010241137817502022, 0.007031623739749193, -0.049791913479566574, -0.0207219198346138, -0.045754361897706985, 0.03303410857915878, 0.04433394968509674, -0.014227616600692272, 0.002496586414054036, 0.03122892789542675, -0.01652306318283081, 0.025018349289894104, -0.014143062755465508, -0.0023167075123637915, -0.0022824250627309084, 0.02453589253127575, 0.017563270404934883, 0.016083305701613426, 0.01321189571171999, 0.023629633709788322, 0.026133833453059196, 0.044362623244524, -0.04522829130291939, 0.00013026095984969288, 0.04458831623196602, -0.02444186434149742, 0.00839159544557333, -0.0015256720362231135, -0.03601980209350586, 0.01030613761395216, -0.02769487351179123, 0.027584485709667206, 0.035318344831466675, -0.006667894311249256, -0.048791609704494476, -0.02411077544093132, -0.02945641428232193, -0.0010131917661055923, 0.05791618674993515, -0.02359658293426037, 0.042783867567777634, 0.027835451066493988, -0.009355488233268261, 0.007155326195061207, -0.02921980991959572, -0.001134850550442934, 0.014883439987897873, 0.029138684272766113, 0.03160030022263527, -0.030395235866308212, -0.020607413724064827, 0.03431081771850586, 0.04928157478570938, 0.04233469441533089, 0.0374862477183342, 0.038144588470458984, 0.02296784147620201, 0.017587820068001747, -0.025466613471508026, -0.03358229622244835, 0.026236170902848244, -0.06901939958333969, 0.02462342008948326, -0.04915538430213928, 0.016617344692349434, 0.03642894700169563, 0.01059544738382101, -0.004963631276041269, -0.003573571564629674, -0.026718635112047195, -0.04307466000318527, 0.00429046805948019, 0.0035731445532292128, 0.020104680210351944, 0.021694768220186234, -0.0029136461671441793, 0.011625397950410843, -0.014005332253873348, 0.014009974896907806, -0.04023020714521408, -0.05909869074821472, -0.04423946514725685, -0.014849759638309479, -0.07576800882816315, 0.04478716105222702, 0.013080136850476265, -0.015957849100232124, 0.008025161921977997, -0.0007090225117281079, -0.019847946241497993, 0.0003879500727634877, 0.05093980208039284, -0.0447516143321991, 0.05077704042196274, 0.05363621190190315, 0.007193089462816715, -0.0013467675307765603, 0.003885174635797739, 0.11861295998096466, 0.06255786120891571, 0.021412760019302368, -0.03720368817448616, 0.03720330074429512, -0.01204640045762062, 0.0013805849011987448, -0.018310129642486572, 0.014787391759455204, 0.0010149168083444238, 0.008978837169706821, 0.05002744495868683, 0.023439617827534676, 0.002121557714417577, -0.004581550136208534, 0.06107049062848091, -0.02919817715883255, -0.05762211233377457, -0.020228812471032143, -0.00018216134048998356, -0.015053987503051758, -0.005767530295997858, -0.03421442210674286, -0.004235669504851103, -0.020106447860598564, 0.008122436702251434, -0.009666234254837036, -0.005891973152756691, -0.017531387507915497, -0.00031298710382543504, 0.010342332534492016, 0.0020660352893173695, 0.03498375043272972, -0.009050671942532063, -0.039914570748806, 0.0014122923603281379, 0.030413998290896416, -0.005568069405853748, -0.009379514493048191, 0.016892550513148308, 0.014785139821469784, 0.033276330679655075, -0.019197555258870125, 0.022549450397491455, -0.06777580827474594, -0.001727701281197369, 0.0006841417634859681, 0.03121764026582241, -0.010761041194200516, 0.006991120520979166, -0.02578004263341427, -0.021296285092830658, -0.01925467886030674, 0.02889101393520832, 0.002124397549778223, 0.024321414530277252, -0.008755311369895935, -0.03576637804508209, -0.05388528108596802, -0.02175682783126831, 0.03518689051270485, -0.044368352741003036, 0.032618455588817596, 0.06824034452438354, 0.003244485706090927, -0.035293493419885635, 0.00024328277504537255, 0.03388714790344238, 0.000779970723669976, 0.011032517068088055, -0.04213482514023781, -0.009842375293374062, -0.04991744086146355, 0.005505560897290707, -0.02422068640589714, -0.011066948994994164, 0.06000101566314697, 0.022168712690472603, -0.013087717816233635, -0.01051473431289196, 0.013972567394375801, 0.009433199651539326, -0.012757389806210995, -0.00009876721742330119, -0.02025975100696087, 0.0360470749437809, -0.013435841538012028, 0.025687316432595253, -0.02996869571506977, 0.024745861068367958, 0.01671598292887211, 0.004604677204042673, 0.04375572130084038, -0.029472988098859787, -0.01802314817905426, -0.012678736820816994, -0.04120809584856033, -0.043305404484272, 0.011934526264667511, 0.09432871639728546, 0.012578324414789677, 0.02660961262881756, 0.03685619682073593, -0.0032748261000961065, -0.018818244338035583, 0.023309621959924698, -0.0027545145712792873, -0.06767529994249344, -0.019944462925195694, 0.03232268616557121, 0.008728436194360256, -0.01626838557422161, -0.01130021270364523, -0.006370921153575182, -0.01142083015292883, 0.03088490292429924, -0.013644585385918617, -0.031319547444581985, 0.012787112034857273, 0.0047812252305448055, 0.03907184675335884, -0.03140765056014061, -0.010531017556786537, -0.05337263271212578, -0.024220161139965057, 0.008861541748046875, 0.018101289868354797, -0.0021768747828900814, -0.0005866947467438877, -0.0010089633287861943, -0.008653653785586357, 0.03503531962633133, -0.005301107186824083, 0.013523849658668041, -0.004075561184436083, 0.0093067716807127, 0.0150254862383008, 0.03521370515227318, -0.0534285306930542, -0.06695521622896194, 0.05543626844882965, -0.027505677193403244, -0.011026857420802116, 0.023323073983192444, 0.009836164303123951, 0.059995006769895554, 0.043919216841459274, 0.0020121827255934477, -0.026035137474536896, 0.025811228901147842, -0.05484643951058388, -0.041668035089969635, -0.012199042364954948, -0.04619581997394562, 0.03802618384361267, -0.004230688791722059, 0.03527790307998657, 0.022058071568608284, -0.00946112908422947, 0.0006902095628902316, 0.026568131521344185, 0.011816929094493389, 0.01912643574178219, -0.002695247298106551, 0.05580155551433563, 0.04338233917951584, -0.015395858325064182, -0.001682607689872384, -0.018262073397636414, 0.045088332146406174, -0.03564343601465225, 0.04327975958585739, -0.008911208249628544, 0.00005504284490598366, -0.05518774315714836, -0.017768295481801033, -0.027282947674393654, 0.03757733851671219, 0.009116694331169128, -0.022037876769900322, 0.00249166670255363, 0.04367578774690628, -0.037734437733888626, 0.019616179168224335, 0.019805915653705597, -0.02865409292280674, -0.033243328332901, -0.004395004361867905, -0.01558663696050644, 0.05948010832071304, 0.030697183683514595, 0.046800803393125534, 0.024760762229561806, 0.019985103979706764, 0.011422529816627502, -0.04362460598349571, -0.010402819141745567, 0.03709486499428749, 0.007015674840658903, -0.031319014728069305, 0.019779521971940994, -0.014578850008547306, -0.045974817126989365, 0.050825342535972595, 0.0268081184476614, 0.04862194508314133, -0.016872752457857132, 0.01319175772368908, -0.004915944766253233, 0.0717163234949112, 0.027528949081897736, -0.0014832421438768506, -0.007177705876529217, -0.0033504946622997522, 0.005919429007917643, 0.014320715330541134, -0.02021244913339615, -0.01063267420977354, 0.06734055280685425, 0.011948457919061184, -0.03881193697452545, 0.015607012435793877, 0.010235846042633057, -0.011735638603568077, -0.010302316397428513, -0.005903555080294609, 0.016896342858672142, -0.033670827746391296, 0.03602452203631401, -0.029704872518777847, -0.013671395368874073, 0.03573346883058548, 0.0024456828832626343, -0.02736128680408001, 0.03738122060894966, 0.018848448991775513, 0.017083561047911644, -0.016039615496993065, -0.00346021237783134, -0.017774038016796112, -0.07366645336151123, -0.004609924741089344, -0.005132813937962055, 0.008497313596308231, 0.016438672319054604, -0.04496290162205696, -0.04535027593374252, 0.00998594332486391, 0.016773873940110207, 0.02468087151646614, 0.0007273360970430076, -0.021347051486372948, -0.0032043929677456617, -0.08271102607250214, 0.07685437798500061, 0.013006219640374184, 0.022424811497330666, -0.06629790365695953, -0.025980068370699883, 0.0005170790245756507, -0.012804622761905193, 0.03758540004491806, 0.06909295171499252, -0.0026996342930942774, 0.0058343540877103806, 0.013333435170352459, 0.03560236841440201, -0.07255272567272186, 0.02395365945994854, -0.03908824920654297, 0.021608669310808182, -0.03054085187613964, -0.010430557653307915, 0.01814461126923561, -0.014462168328464031, 0.01072627305984497, -0.008530394174158573, 0.0025885808281600475, 0.03256165608763695, 0.013206814415752888, 0.042091354727745056, 0.03111659362912178, 0.0008613619720563293, 0.06131140515208244, 0.022074498236179352, 0.040557559579610825, -0.0226551815867424, -0.00024296084302477539, -0.045265082269907, 0.05014778673648834, -0.03703312575817108, 0.006782279349863529, -0.007318547926843166, -0.02514968439936638, 0.015635769814252853, -0.06481175124645233, -0.0166048351675272, -0.011672227643430233, -0.05381335690617561, 0.01010924018919468, 0.03023293800652027, 0.018570583313703537, 0.030890827998518944, -0.021064378321170807, 0.02559749409556389, -0.012796054594218731, -0.023846391588449478, -0.02505534701049328, -0.0011459325905889273, 0.028383539989590645, 0.001263871556147933, 0.016758333891630173, 0.04641854390501976, -0.030016103759407997, 0.03231693431735039, 0.025334276258945465, 0.022772110998630524, -0.017425501719117165, -0.02302551455795765, 0.009556300938129425, -0.009307343512773514, 0.005815489217638969, -0.016497479751706123, -0.002330488758161664, 0.06096227094531059, -0.006399829871952534, -0.0014293288113549352, -0.032874420285224915, -0.010214445181190968, -0.007831686176359653, -0.04763125255703926, 0.027060136198997498, 0.01636655069887638, 0.05781838297843933, 0.02027742750942707, -0.026255616918206215, 0.02992381528019905, 0.055787526071071625, -0.026568908244371414, 0.0380438007414341, -0.008314474485814571, -0.03198655694723129, -0.009336468763649464, 0.01206180639564991, -0.06475276499986649, -0.022282922640442848, 0.017214061692357063, 0.012156044133007526, 0.01192067377269268, 0.0023372455034404993, -0.03597042337059975, 0.01055736094713211, 0.0355415940284729, -0.03220928832888603, -0.03623674437403679, -0.06662808358669281, 0.011515511199831963, 0.022279659286141396, -0.02420908398926258 ]
<p>I have to incorporate a number of line plots in a Latex document and I want to get a very high quality.</p> <p>Are there any website that show some templates or default plots styles that I can use. Myself I am not good in designing this kind of plot style, so I am searching some good basic settings for the tool I want to use.</p> <p>About the tools, I think I would like to use Tikz or gnuplot as I want to build tex document and plots in a single run. My data is anyway stored in text files.</p>
74,367
[ -0.010142514482140541, -0.02727484330534935, 0.005365041550248861, 0.0010691306088119745, 0.010020800866186619, 0.0360095240175724, -0.010792838409543037, -0.027915552258491516, 0.024794455617666245, -0.033141523599624634, 0.05606348067522049, 0.036906082183122635, 0.05764840170741081, 0.04085736349225044, 0.0009880424477159977, -0.03645186498761177, -0.03849302604794502, -0.013976952992379665, -0.008449389599263668, -0.05356617271900177, -0.010741421952843666, 0.016944672912359238, 0.05749928578734398, 0.015339385718107224, -0.013443674892187119, 0.040577683597803116, 0.03395344689488411, 0.04292144253849983, 0.035907894372940063, 0.03645796701312065, -0.0729924812912941, -0.039643581956624985, 0.007325153332203627, 0.043421078473329544, 0.0029019820503890514, -0.008489271625876427, 0.010962480679154396, -0.02962428703904152, 0.023918386548757553, 0.0003242657403461635, -0.0549895241856575, 0.0021264106035232544, 0.029416456818580627, 0.03556181490421295, -0.026027385145425797, 0.008230303414165974, -0.008732140064239502, -0.052538253366947174, 0.02916540950536728, -0.04915362223982811, 0.05112621188163757, 0.021665485575795174, 0.05358020216226578, 0.04547928273677826, -0.004234801046550274, 0.019027160480618477, 0.03097204864025116, 0.0868229940533638, -0.0010729677742347121, -0.06851927936077118, 0.03198304399847984, -0.031408634036779404, 0.023126335814595222, -0.01983330398797989, -0.06933484226465225, 0.05415039137005806, -0.029108408838510513, 0.015219363383948803, -0.005603613797575235, -0.013223635964095592, -0.017074545845389366, 0.026235459372401237, 0.04310159012675285, -0.05222027748823166, -0.004613347817212343, -0.017405059188604355, 0.03988511860370636, 0.01240833755582571, 0.07993583381175995, 0.03212355822324753, -0.0006899870932102203, 0.05028665438294411, 0.012947208248078823, 0.007728000171482563, 0.008716834709048271, -0.00944299902766943, 0.09412438422441483, -0.021909479051828384, 0.030405359342694283, 0.01587194763123989, -0.011161134578287601, 0.018824344500899315, 0.04789888486266136, 0.01675158180296421, 0.0005274050636216998, -0.016319099813699722, -0.006001092027872801, 0.04199676588177681, -0.013903232291340828, -0.042476579546928406, 0.02748120203614235, -0.025141119956970215, -0.002250404329970479, 0.06106309965252876, 0.008241689763963223, 0.0006686345441266894, -0.004457354545593262, -0.017055774107575417, 0.010752460919320583, -0.000967629486694932, 0.0063481759279966354, 0.010847766883671284, -0.010776049457490444, 0.008354554884135723, 0.006035172380506992, -0.01581816002726555, 0.02649187110364437, -0.00583032937720418, 0.055471789091825485, 0.04993850737810135, 0.04181336984038353, -0.05515686050057411, 0.07160027325153351, -0.018521685153245926, -0.0390964113175869, 0.0023922238033264875, -0.010926510207355022, -0.019782718271017075, -0.00537479342892766, 0.060604192316532135, -0.0429275706410408, -0.008485594764351845, 0.039250608533620834, 0.020441321656107903, 0.05385449528694153, -0.00902637094259262, -0.05792655050754547, -0.06753744930028915, 0.043108753859996796, -0.03161667287349701, 0.014413509517908096, -0.05955653637647629, 0.008396612480282784, 0.01400392409414053, 0.031158050522208214, -0.009763495065271854, -0.007734155282378197, 0.03241410851478577, 0.02591327764093876, -0.016876040026545525, -0.01869669370353222, 0.00788203626871109, 0.009403200820088387, -0.05945908650755882, 0.007255503907799721, -0.05406348407268524, 0.01809217408299446, 0.03636745736002922, 0.007567130494862795, -0.04246440902352333, 0.038940392434597015, -0.005215369164943695, 0.012418854050338268, -0.0067514944821596146, 0.017110086977481842, -0.014745949767529964, 0.05247955396771431, 0.016814418137073517, 0.014357232488691807, 0.014715285040438175, -0.006202368065714836, 0.030458925291895866, 0.026309482753276825, 0.007442569360136986, 0.04034923017024994, -0.0069949571043252945, 0.015687959268689156, 0.009349936619400978, -0.021615726873278618, 0.06110130622982979, -0.016493940725922585, -0.04581024497747421, 0.008814199827611446, 0.004147604573518038, 0.024447696283459663, 0.06327269971370697, 0.012801405973732471, -0.03689505532383919, 0.033674728125333786, -0.0633406788110733, -0.042158134281635284, -0.06249300390481949, 0.03337955102324486, -0.012916292063891888, -0.00252148718573153, 0.000850740703754127, 0.034072425216436386, -0.010598457418382168, -0.032759472727775574, -0.0410090796649456, -0.020714182406663895, 0.012731668539345264, 0.03018692508339882, -0.028377413749694824, -0.015509463846683502, 0.055619556456804276, 0.021376674994826317, -0.024940593168139458, 0.019623687490820885, -0.02078174613416195, -0.03179119899868965, -0.006326971109956503, -0.053213804960250854, 0.019532859325408936, -0.026374952867627144, -0.01808197796344757, 0.009866003878414631, 0.03676515072584152, -0.013724328018724918, 0.01598106138408184, -0.015307399444282055, 0.044242918491363525, 0.07171523571014404, 0.022476142272353172, -0.012122409418225288, -0.01170052494853735, 0.020341388881206512, 0.0407705157995224, -0.015899335965514183, -0.005360038485378027, -0.03149988129734993, 0.03044629469513893, 0.05949316546320915, 0.02959739975631237, -0.05757859721779823, 0.035340674221515656, 0.05861848220229149, 0.026725921779870987, 0.039408937096595764, 0.04289949685335159, -0.02473173663020134, -0.004868220072239637, -0.041402339935302734, 0.040043022483587265, 0.023754984140396118, -0.00316737056709826, 0.0017152820946648717, 0.0458349734544754, 0.028009245172142982, -0.006329224910587072, -0.03228212893009186, 0.04923569783568382, -0.052402008324861526, 0.0030405789148062468, 0.0007568942382931709, -0.016889231279492378, 0.05038592591881752, -0.02783609926700592, 0.0203616414219141, 0.008528059348464012, -0.00978061743080616, 0.00869345385581255, 0.053535666316747665, -0.015082713216543198, 0.011952480301260948, 0.0425679013133049, -0.025690652430057526, -0.011567439883947372, 0.01944156177341938, -0.02469078078866005, 0.026702363044023514, -0.051419276744127274, -0.011280356906354427, -0.07774504274129868, 0.03217155486345291, 0.009403987787663937, 0.015630429610610008, 0.03990203142166138, 0.0014814265305176377, -0.07392456382513046, 0.01911778189241886, -0.03724744915962219, 0.018219685181975365, 0.004381984937936068, -0.026049941778182983, -0.00032598068355582654, -0.03662828728556633, -0.006304810754954815, 0.03560463339090347, -0.002401089994236827, 0.02766982652246952, 0.020304979756474495, 0.0009060893789865077, -0.04665706306695938, -0.046868592500686646, -0.01280900277197361, 0.0020935595966875553, 0.023470252752304077, -0.013064760714769363, 0.02037231996655464, -0.03144058585166931, -0.02920992113649845, 0.053133558481931686, -0.048537012189626694, -0.011962284334003925, -0.03193804621696472, 0.04752768948674202, 0.018543755635619164, -0.005083910655230284, -0.009162886068224907, 0.0246922355145216, -0.06651198863983154, -0.03245134279131889, -0.04761272668838501, -0.0524703748524189, 0.012759129516780376, -0.002897371305152774, 0.057622916996479034, -0.001133978134021163, -0.027804318815469742, 0.040932584553956985, 0.017834672704339027, -0.05472575128078461, -0.06656643748283386, -0.02806006371974945, -0.024283260107040405, -0.048107463866472244, 0.016486145555973053, 0.00038666510954499245, 0.00866096280515194, 0.00018802686827257276, 0.027795149013400078, -0.009022328071296215, 0.03611435741186142, -0.006736572831869125, 0.0005692083504982293, 0.010854661464691162, 0.011868071742355824, -0.0025425401981920004, 0.008616701699793339, 0.03555353358387947, -0.03706727921962738, -0.008988827466964722, -0.032364871352910995, 0.02338314615190029, 0.01490536518394947, -0.047778524458408356, -0.0058304485864937305, 0.008170001208782196, 0.004211505874991417, -0.029637612402439117, -0.015914494171738625, 0.02881671115756035, -0.007899941876530647, -0.021108560264110565, 0.03589046001434326, 0.03155731037259102, -0.030631758272647858, -0.02280331589281559, 0.037567559629678726, 0.04603610187768936, -0.04326993227005005, -0.02944004163146019, -0.007121414877474308, -0.0066588823683559895, 0.02014196291565895, -0.028619371354579926, 0.019442390650510788, 0.03840537741780281, 0.006353778298944235, 0.016155676916241646, 0.0090248454362154, -0.04069727659225464, 0.02998545952141285, -0.07015129178762436, -0.0011822498636320233, -0.014384934678673744, 0.07377956807613373, 0.020456381142139435, 0.05963421240448952, -0.001613774336874485, -0.0019054473377764225, 0.03149302676320076, -0.029511572793126106, -0.06948348879814148, 0.045376814901828766, -0.009648535400629044, 0.0033526630140841007, 0.015519542619585991, -0.0018253993475809693, -0.00032910812296904624, -0.03421486169099808, -0.011433850973844528, -0.01582709141075611, 0.015499323606491089, -0.038714371621608734, -0.014384054578840733, -0.02420014888048172, -0.005354594439268112, -0.030359376221895218, 0.05512266978621483, 0.025104835629463196, -0.03419450670480728, 0.022448649629950523, 0.034772664308547974, -0.029393520206212997, -0.05996113643050194, 0.00338914361782372, 0.02647552452981472, 0.016790935769677162, 0.041465435177087784, 0.02394530177116394, 0.023996416479349136, -0.013453023508191109, 0.019756877794861794, -0.032397475093603134, 0.08253901451826096, 0.026593992486596107, -0.0028616797644644976, 0.0059935650788247585, -0.018870675936341286, 0.0033581238240003586, 0.020683933049440384, 0.01568366214632988, 0.010639925487339497, -0.025201303884387016, 0.04580031335353851, 0.004702053964138031, -0.04197198897600174, 0.03324407711625099, 0.0063841622322797775, 0.028358932584524155, -0.004663768690079451, -0.015136471018195152, -0.03920736536383629, -0.008380894549190998, 0.0029879058711230755, -0.004516386892646551, 0.027263060212135315, -0.0353374183177948, 0.016300322487950325, 0.021578453481197357, -0.017884917557239532, -0.04114244133234024, -0.01207142136991024, 0.05121663585305214, 0.04352089762687683, 0.011971063911914825, 0.0007623087731190026, 0.012381751090288162, 0.030258435755968094, 0.03464830666780472, 0.02317843772470951, -0.037671275436878204, -0.07968048006296158, -0.016203515231609344, 0.046499285846948624, 0.033975642174482346, 0.003566182218492031, -0.027919063344597816, -0.04937775060534477, 0.01449365634471178, 0.047579165548086166, -0.03647761419415474, 0.02834351360797882, -0.022345291450619698, -0.010743574239313602, -0.038537606596946716, -0.01544217113405466, -0.02572951838374138, 0.04304266721010208, -0.013598300516605377, 0.029001714661717415, -0.028109226375818253, 0.004248301964253187, -0.06263665109872818, 0.028359858319163322, -0.02054605446755886, 0.06920934468507767, 0.02628125250339508, -0.026507297530770302, 0.018426809459924698, 0.02385414019227028, -0.019871288910508156, -0.06126227229833603, 0.002320024184882641, 0.019744357094168663, 0.0253883246332407, 0.04581115394830704, -0.019619271159172058, 0.005995952058583498, -0.0013339478755369782, -0.00042436333023943007, -0.02451615408062935, 0.003173539647832513, -0.035784877836704254, 0.01814854145050049, 0.025939172133803368, 0.0288427472114563, 0.0427192747592926, 0.05812624841928482, -0.018430566415190697, -0.02308281697332859, -0.04571912810206413, 0.04224252328276634, -0.021472249180078506, -0.02696097269654274, -0.05131528154015541, -0.042329102754592896, -0.03707796707749367, -0.017056085169315338, -0.045857127755880356, 0.007445398718118668, -0.018364006653428078, 0.004303559195250273, 0.004429809283465147, 0.04545285925269127, 0.05699650198221207, 0.0003759549872484058, 0.013044582679867744, 0.003736441722139716, 0.001704968512058258, -0.004326370544731617, 0.02940385974943638, -0.010106762871146202, -0.006944069638848305, 0.006208603736013174, -0.02960040047764778, 0.01618400774896145, -0.021833566948771477, 0.013036012649536133, -0.0196961909532547, -0.026675887405872345, 0.06367101520299911, -0.008808068931102753, 0.04498991370201111, 0.047552380710840225, -0.061142340302467346, -0.021057721227407455, 0.04757264256477356, 0.0013249570038169622, 0.007859046570956707, -0.05278148502111435, 0.05356631055474281, -0.032672204077243805, 0.0008398614590987563, -0.04938111454248428, -0.07801622152328491, 0.036327071487903595, -0.02175353281199932, -0.010394045151770115, -0.018917197361588478, 0.007798591163009405, 0.01716422662138939, 0.018623925745487213, -0.01367816049605608, -0.004017298109829426, 0.008260453119874, -0.05091913044452667, 0.000006264977855607867, 0.006697613280266523, 0.07262047380208969, 0.018121596425771713, 0.0017525592120364308, -0.005289904773235321, -0.007655251305550337, -0.02065596543252468, -0.008828605525195599, 0.006403534673154354, -0.03703317791223526, 0.004902860149741173, -0.009238735772669315, 0.021766671910881996, 0.032078713178634644, -0.019724855199456215, 0.04863746091723442, 0.019094577059149742, 0.031124748289585114, -0.009537586942315102, -0.04645436629652977, -0.0022074365988373756, -0.03213192895054817, 0.003008298808708787, -0.039605796337127686, -0.031995657831430435, -0.018749678507447243, -0.025144090875983238, -0.037720538675785065, 0.014983981847763062, -0.007679356727749109, 0.029610784724354744, 0.06693089753389359, 0.05057079717516899, -0.011512585915625095, 0.009824774228036404, -0.05726582184433937, 0.005905545316636562, -0.0007349374936893582, 0.008001012727618217, 0.021004164591431618, 0.025213541463017464, -0.019510788843035698, -0.031081849709153175, -0.003459386294707656, -0.028140131384134293, 0.02868717350065708, -0.008479866199195385, 0.052366338670253754, 0.07077179104089737, 0.009681746363639832, -0.0060788169503211975, -0.021191461011767387, -0.03947659209370613, -0.03165925294160843, 0.022420719265937805, 0.07128270715475082, -0.009125342592597008, -0.01283279899507761, 0.0006413019145838916, 0.005192264914512634, 0.017967887222766876, 0.05430019274353981, -0.013834989629685879, -0.008816797286272049, 0.0034447573125362396, 0.02515057474374771, -0.04041668400168419, 0.0188003983348608, -0.012103221379220486, 0.048763781785964966, -0.01797085627913475, -0.04303624480962753, 0.019864507019519806, 0.033584341406822205, -0.02064068429172039, -0.0013424156932160258, -0.008258833549916744, -0.008594044484198093, 0.011492282152175903, 0.021325701847672462, -0.026713281869888306, -0.011326189152896404, 0.02956201136112213, 0.037433188408613205, -0.03205971419811249, 0.05197563022375107, -0.025847649201750755, -0.07775247097015381, -0.019391227513551712, -0.03527248278260231, -0.04885412007570267, 0.024551067501306534, -0.006726331543177366, -0.029058540239930153, 0.010243323631584644, -0.012865650467574596, 0.010198707692325115, -0.016226936131715775, 0.023747289553284645, 0.0007661015260964632, 0.03822970390319824, -0.03981991112232208, 0.013932663016021252, 0.0015760903479531407, -0.02384219504892826, 0.10079105943441391, 0.08823487162590027, 0.046000607311725616, -0.10417166352272034, 0.03801124170422554, -0.011369065381586552, 0.014954189769923687, -0.014543965458869934, 0.03814548999071121, 0.009538237936794758, 0.0009163853828795254, 0.042488645762205124, 0.0558900460600853, -0.03222652152180672, 0.04438651353120804, 0.07433761656284332, -0.05173598229885101, -0.04894747957587242, -0.013996131718158722, 0.008245233446359634, -0.007309251930564642, 0.02697531320154667, -0.06866441667079926, 0.00926409661769867, 0.0014441302046179771, -0.028590839356184006, -0.005815827753394842, -0.053165074437856674, 0.05435968562960625, 0.016684332862496376, -0.02103479579091072, -0.017414117231965065, 0.04425979033112526, -0.0004717968113254756, -0.024889592081308365, -0.021947689354419708, 0.003891551401466131, -0.01610308140516281, 0.009099160321056843, 0.04030894115567207, 0.0035017726477235556, -0.019642863422632217, -0.00041653343942016363, 0.013598757795989513, -0.035815659910440445, -0.02929595112800598, -0.021228615194559097, -0.0005590473883785307, -0.026982594281435013, -0.000598953221924603, -0.02080865018069744, 0.05115726962685585, 0.04393193870782852, -0.025753408670425415, -0.036405231803655624, -0.0006808414473198354, 0.030718812718987465, -0.017154511064291, -0.006289692595601082, -0.02122482657432556, 0.02178613655269146, -0.034469254314899445, 0.03845324367284775, 0.016902966424822807, -0.017865268513560295, -0.012099423445761204, -0.027276508510112762, 0.014444796368479729, 0.015728121623396873, 0.004732072353363037, -0.01528250239789486, 0.012883149087429047, -0.031040936708450317, -0.007862629368901253, 0.031173309311270714, 0.04957040399312973, -0.008964824490249157, -0.002552586141973734, -0.015642646700143814, 0.033335864543914795, -0.04134069010615349, 0.03911740705370903, -0.03260497748851776, -0.02547306753695011, -0.019872885197401047, 0.0019383488688617945, 0.07447994500398636, 0.03898179903626442, 0.06116398051381111, 0.012724097818136215, -0.031771913170814514, 0.0016064047813415527, 0.0465511828660965, -0.01951955072581768, 0.014643874019384384, -0.0000396070972783491, -0.02664932794868946, -0.04500887542963028, -0.007524554152041674, 0.048335056751966476, 0.008662136271595955, -0.01063925214111805, 0.023700503632426262, 0.035501666367053986, 0.010943281464278698, -0.002596406266093254, 0.01404021866619587, -0.05204398185014725, 0.02143706940114498, -0.0018397191306576133, -0.011943655088543892, -0.03022933006286621, -0.014491239562630653, -0.023805230855941772, -0.014864368364214897, 0.010053802281618118, 0.0007731057703495026, -0.04052931070327759, 0.05040333420038223, -0.014083961956202984, 0.02277468889951706, -0.038338325917720795, 0.01327255554497242, -0.029201431199908257, -0.014630066230893135, 0.008925212547183037, 0.017586514353752136, 0.0007894080481491983, 0.0090903639793396, 0.0024847558233886957, 0.011911273002624512, 0.010167145170271397, 0.012252897955477238, 0.0012573100393638015, 0.008220985531806946, 0.017361106351017952, 0.03356369212269783, 0.03947966918349266, -0.034129682928323746, -0.032317426055669785, 0.019038012251257896, -0.05417989566922188, -0.013603240251541138, -0.009955392219126225, -0.015977172181010246, -0.01439682487398386, 0.003688202006742358, -0.018754595890641212, -0.044923488050699234, 0.06031273677945137, -0.009819711558520794, -0.031134365126490593, 0.006483406759798527, 0.009806482121348381, -0.0030687754042446613, 0.022825514897704124, -0.006446699611842632, -0.037323981523513794, 0.02448747679591179, 0.022693155333399773, 0.03635283187031746, 0.019576510414481163, -0.012105091474950314, 0.018849678337574005, 0.009435463696718216, 0.02244063839316368, 0.016619037836790085, -0.04233527183532715, 0.06315648555755615, 0.037742119282484055, -0.062013160437345505, 0.0017835479229688644, 0.003394093830138445, -0.003932173363864422, -0.058076925575733185, -0.016145730391144753, -0.014730450697243214, -0.02766151912510395, 0.0037084438372403383, -0.07545649260282516, -0.029051925987005234, 0.037779465317726135, -0.004295642487704754, -0.011105898767709732, -0.009565223008394241, 0.013084260746836662, -0.03487835451960564, -0.023303784430027008, -0.0015385901788249612, 0.0397753082215786, 0.03245913237333298, 0.04883773997426033, 0.03921356052160263, 0.005868059117347002, 0.005423340946435928, 0.0023144360166043043, -0.014852894470095634, 0.010795670561492443, -0.010840202681720257, -0.05616075545549393, 0.016774030402302742, 0.006270929705351591, -0.034652091562747955, 0.019922742620110512, 0.02943781577050686, 0.01623707264661789, 0.015834832563996315, -0.0002873812918551266, -0.0067116860300302505, 0.05629616975784302, 0.005874343682080507, -0.01754567213356495, -0.029222045093774796, -0.0025649606250226498, 0.026776177808642387, -0.0021175709553062916, -0.017013024538755417, 0.011881577782332897, 0.02068089321255684, -0.0348375104367733, -0.031052596867084503, 0.03176857531070709, -0.006467917934060097, -0.028850052505731583, -0.006337963510304689, 0.026074623689055443, 0.020236695185303688, -0.024800343438982964, 0.017125796526670456, -0.034462615847587585, 0.005958308931440115, 0.018836122006177902, -0.02474234066903591, 0.041938021779060364, 0.02116312086582184, -0.0024604175705462694, -0.05241705849766731, 0.0013245961163192987, -0.0010018940083682537, -0.023433461785316467, -0.0502275750041008, 0.015655409544706345, -0.005606921389698982, -0.01527583971619606, 0.0012100746389478445, -0.02472887560725212, -0.017237287014722824, 0.0026756024453788996, -0.036844007670879364, 0.00535705266520381, -0.012503006495535374, -0.02008827030658722, 0.006874940823763609, -0.008901907131075859, 0.04991694912314415, -0.014000202529132366, 0.005519655533134937, -0.054466526955366135, -0.0012594180880114436, -0.01017751544713974, 0.04403834044933319, 0.02996227517724037, -0.020822223275899887, -0.001932727755047381, -0.029844287782907486, 0.022194497287273407, 0.03722694143652916, -0.03992072492837906, 0.008899479173123837, -0.001114669255912304, -0.06180626526474953, -0.00324484845623374, -0.021732475608587265, 0.014149551279842854, 0.0231564212590456, 0.03773466870188713, -0.03469683974981308, 0.004506980534642935, 0.013345212675631046, -0.04046211764216423, -0.0017009888542816043, -0.011647425591945648, -0.05784468725323677, 0.08295976370573044, -0.020054485648870468, 0.0065647903829813, 0.017144465819001198, 0.00039007008308544755, -0.02213296853005886, 0.024768542498350143, -0.05431040748953819, -0.007653386332094669, -0.031193932518363, -0.02717556245625019, 0.006264341063797474, -0.07654859125614166, 0.05257008224725723, 0.0015480394940823317, -0.015187145210802555, 0.00667918287217617, 0.04638085141777992, 0.018450520932674408, 0.033175986260175705, -0.0011094619985669851, 0.042066540569067, -0.022165950387716293, -0.002889732364565134, -0.02323625609278679, -0.019579028710722923, 0.002354356460273266, 0.022390322759747505, 0.0014615323161706328, 0.02517346292734146, -0.010788328014314175, 0.039958514273166656, 0.005971695762127638, 0.033002037554979324, -0.043821781873703, 0.000037860547308810055, 0.007950964383780956, -0.05699856951832771, 0.02883266471326351, -0.013952670618891716, -0.022342437878251076, 0.05237229913473129, -0.05437285825610161, 0.01649586856365204, -0.06265448033809662, -0.056703709065914154, -0.057898007333278656, 0.01760787144303322, -0.026356466114521027, 0.052336275577545166, -0.00847866851836443, 0.047493550926446915, -0.013395854271948338, -0.00584943313151598, 0.05738160014152527, 0.011369401589035988, 0.029143763706088066, -0.021779291331768036, -0.024753950536251068, 0.0005151821533218026, -0.00474125612527132, -0.008078801445662975, -0.03555963560938835, 0.005432932171970606, 0.009565860033035278, -0.005911041516810656, -0.014999369159340858, 0.0008847919525578618, 0.00597807252779603, 0.021199727430939674, -0.06693786382675171, -0.017973830923438072, -0.012088117189705372, 0.00238107074983418, 0.009199989028275013, -0.002611546777188778 ]
<p>Let's say we created a plot, with labels:</p> <pre><code>plot(1, xlab = "text", ylab = "text times three") # text too small </code></pre> <p>In this plot there is still a lot of free region to enlarge the text. We could do so by using cex.lab, like this:</p> <pre><code>par(cex.lab = 2) plot(1, xlab = "text", ylab = "text times three") </code></pre> <p>Questions:</p> <ol> <li>Is there a way to know what is the largest cex.lab possible, without the text getting over the borders?</li> <li>Is it possible to do that separately for each component of the axis? (so to have a different fitting of cex.axis to the xlab vs the ylab) ?</li> </ol>
49,011
[ -0.03199135512113571, -0.0015082121826708317, -0.015775810927152634, 0.0237679872661829, 0.035645339637994766, 0.04852106049656868, -0.01746276393532753, -0.016630744561553, 0.018665224313735962, 0.006723777391016483, 0.06161649897694588, 0.02335994876921177, 0.04946749284863472, 0.0305444598197937, 0.02364419959485531, -0.0027299830690026283, -0.0009738247026689351, -0.025366798043251038, 0.010367946699261665, -0.049381956458091736, 0.01819555088877678, -0.0020280019380152225, 0.01955130137503147, -0.009934133850038052, 0.0010571385500952601, 0.056319788098335266, 0.004585955757647753, -0.039778489619493484, 0.000051548806368373334, 0.06143045797944069, 0.006302985828369856, -0.050019580870866776, 0.04555227607488632, -0.0032698505092412233, 0.04201643541455269, 0.030593354254961014, 0.020947618409991264, -0.03191722556948662, 0.01751001738011837, -0.0028593880124390125, -0.060041628777980804, 0.023038441315293312, 0.052255477756261826, 0.014026429504156113, 0.01667230762541294, 0.02770308032631874, -0.02798193320631981, -0.026128051802515984, 0.036432914435863495, -0.00679102772846818, 0.06449490785598755, -0.026748910546302795, 0.021998731419444084, 0.021472850814461708, -0.0513678640127182, -0.03482499346137047, 0.04974493384361267, 0.05581174045801163, -0.012176569551229477, -0.05472413823008537, 0.015422148630023003, -0.02022169902920723, 0.007294415961951017, 0.008610035292804241, -0.04806523025035858, 0.03349469229578972, -0.02544432505965233, -0.005977966357022524, 0.04311761260032654, -0.028228189796209335, -0.036083344370126724, 0.005533149465918541, 0.01687486842274666, 0.0028274196665734053, 0.047605108469724655, -0.009790242649614811, 0.006517938803881407, 0.03467002883553505, 0.036195218563079834, 0.04582730680704117, -0.009324703365564346, 0.04954427108168602, 0.03020317107439041, 0.024113738909363747, 0.015166607685387135, 0.006631351076066494, 0.06966029107570648, -0.036172494292259216, 0.03514661267399788, 0.031462833285331726, 0.02350851334631443, 0.00858398713171482, 0.05285641551017761, 0.029113246127963066, 0.002338966354727745, 0.03450305387377739, 0.015615836717188358, 0.01507559698075056, 0.010358205065131187, -0.005097842309623957, -0.001068167737685144, -0.05670274794101715, -0.03241695463657379, 0.03798998147249222, 0.0016240564873442054, 0.0036070654168725014, -0.028861306607723236, -0.023536164313554764, -0.007829486392438412, 0.027410460636019707, -0.03460320830345154, 0.0015786923468112946, 0.020783720538020134, 0.01973678544163704, 0.04140050336718559, -0.0409562923014164, 0.0011867807479575276, -0.002156608272343874, 0.060339074581861496, 0.037321481853723526, 0.04454781115055084, -0.0179344080388546, 0.010471710935235023, 0.020516633987426758, -0.058823131024837494, 0.008355313912034035, -0.019303707405924797, 0.007861639373004436, -0.022088447585701942, 0.0424858033657074, -0.02845025062561035, -0.011052217334508896, 0.022122126072645187, -0.01329727377742529, 0.007943474687635899, 0.028548970818519592, -0.07591857761144638, -0.083699069917202, 0.04693860188126564, -0.0032573218923062086, -0.029331929981708527, -0.062174901366233826, -0.02466547302901745, 0.006444115657359362, 0.03652871772646904, 0.029562754556536674, 0.010101675055921078, 0.010648883879184723, -0.03203090280294418, 0.010706105269491673, -0.016341904178261757, 0.04431712627410889, -0.008710955269634724, -0.00391367869451642, 0.00972821470350027, -0.06196017190814018, -0.02123834192752838, 0.04845612868666649, -0.023908957839012146, -0.0064038680866360664, 0.07111844420433044, -0.006808166857808828, 0.0188200194388628, -0.03802065551280975, -0.02118062786757946, -0.017542047426104546, 0.10347327589988708, 0.02684733085334301, 0.031925275921821594, 0.0189049169421196, -0.024975290521979332, 0.02801896259188652, 0.0029420703649520874, -0.016240930184721947, 0.049078017473220825, 0.01755959540605545, -0.0421900600194931, -0.029907898977398872, 0.025165855884552002, 0.050597842782735825, -0.009762147441506386, -0.026882149279117584, -0.03323952853679657, 0.017127837985754013, 0.03069339506328106, 0.055948976427316666, 0.026294199749827385, -0.03130786493420601, 0.030586905777454376, -0.06242317706346512, -0.031336963176727295, -0.05408179759979248, -0.0003061143506783992, 0.0029799595940858126, -0.04042954370379448, -0.004136017989367247, 0.005143458489328623, -0.002136481925845146, 0.017192291095852852, -0.019386643543839455, -0.010988670401275158, 0.007792894262820482, 0.04749161750078201, -0.024572869762778282, 0.011173037812113762, 0.051661111414432526, 0.03966813161969185, -0.028774671256542206, -0.005722845438867807, -0.041224464774131775, -0.020639609545469284, 0.018258389085531235, -0.03134962543845177, 0.024540700018405914, -0.010808396153151989, -0.042067766189575195, -0.02104073017835617, 0.04941621795296669, -0.044299978762865067, 0.021356644108891487, -0.03048696182668209, 0.05786009132862091, 0.060030825436115265, -0.011983695439994335, 0.00449437415227294, -0.040306299924850464, 0.01170219574123621, 0.04464214667677879, -0.007516816724091768, -0.028768999502062798, -0.045082394033670425, -0.037622757256031036, 0.025013986974954605, 0.018725696951150894, -0.02447410859167576, -0.011123308911919594, 0.028872869908809662, -0.029028519988059998, 0.010071642696857452, 0.0073168352246284485, -0.0017684599151834846, 0.01051581185311079, 0.00266131735406816, 0.031057005748152733, 0.044217873364686966, 0.0028341892175376415, 0.024487024173140526, 0.04441085830330849, 0.05395366623997688, -0.0070728519931435585, 0.008468516170978546, 0.010677660815417767, -0.0067969681695103645, -0.013014299795031548, 0.015245534479618073, 0.005920105148106813, 0.03761104494333267, -0.005866329185664654, 0.010301434434950352, 0.03816407173871994, 0.0004345405614003539, -0.025324616581201553, -0.011089753359556198, -0.0008045273716561496, -0.026116235181689262, 0.03770759329199791, -0.022627925500273705, -0.035743698477745056, 0.024983292445540428, -0.02538023516535759, 0.004150553606450558, -0.014275239780545235, -0.02132093533873558, -0.0674411728978157, 0.006191785912960768, 0.05001135170459747, 0.033560656011104584, 0.046742405742406845, -0.06500303745269775, -0.04579565301537514, 0.021464712917804718, -0.018082965165376663, 0.03582523390650749, -0.008405978791415691, -0.023675013333559036, 0.03668288514018059, -0.011710477992892265, -0.03610919788479805, -0.006640666164457798, -0.0008602429297752678, -0.022610148414969444, 0.035096656531095505, -0.032712385058403015, -0.04395966976881027, -0.035654183477163315, -0.01675344631075859, -0.012270311824977398, -0.008958517573773861, 0.0022090026177465916, 0.038543373346328735, -0.007258635945618153, -0.027902668341994286, -0.007530417293310165, -0.046034716069698334, -0.01217133179306984, -0.024637490510940552, 0.0027294259052723646, -0.029633041471242905, 0.02079978585243225, 0.0038819306064397097, 0.04125290364027023, -0.007956719025969505, -0.03208132088184357, -0.04235159605741501, -0.03827054053544998, 0.005902976728975773, 0.0014900631504133344, 0.030627848580479622, 0.006370768416672945, 0.026369014754891396, 0.06283752620220184, 0.015022837556898594, -0.07798495143651962, -0.047050390392541885, -0.014652351848781109, -0.006042825523763895, -0.046408336609601974, 0.03416496515274048, 0.023642655462026596, 0.009643417783081532, -0.009203744120895863, 0.013874986208975315, 0.06922323256731033, 0.03365223482251167, 0.008669170551002026, 0.024591857567429543, -0.03168312460184097, -0.009924180805683136, -0.04701723903417587, 0.02652529627084732, 0.059496793895959854, 0.0024635116569697857, 0.0015461082803085446, 0.00179492705501616, 0.04041400924324989, 0.01286004576832056, -0.029706645756959915, 0.025871315971016884, -0.0039003395941108465, 0.03640234097838402, -0.008931474760174751, 0.020836403593420982, 0.021529346704483032, -0.010580003261566162, -0.0004635595250874758, 0.023778488859534264, 0.024599771946668625, -0.02931426838040352, -0.02849428355693817, 0.030332105234265327, 0.03756194934248924, -0.0337541289627552, -0.003863399848341942, 0.0032872087322175503, 0.014141479507088661, 0.013779127970337868, -0.044189874082803726, -0.015241434797644615, 0.06216127797961235, 0.04593340680003166, 0.010061007924377918, 0.027319693937897682, -0.013617122545838356, 0.008985107764601707, -0.09149913489818573, -0.012818457558751106, -0.010622693225741386, 0.03778662532567978, 0.03393329307436943, 0.02138579450547695, 0.009669761173427105, 0.01506387535482645, 0.023708540946245193, 0.002787589794024825, -0.11206244677305222, 0.025924332439899445, -0.006883080117404461, -0.00038827056414447725, -0.036802008748054504, -0.011098598130047321, 0.05999806150794029, -0.031360384076833725, 0.009057517163455486, -0.025996970012784004, 0.023960208520293236, -0.04436012730002403, -0.0034544812515378, 0.021707942709326744, 0.030666938051581383, -0.029310159385204315, 0.010698480531573296, 0.04873228445649147, 0.02437848411500454, 0.037621717900037766, 0.018516357988119125, -0.038302358239889145, -0.034200482070446014, 0.023821840062737465, 0.005323218647390604, 0.005383580457419157, 0.05378662422299385, -0.008036908693611622, 0.009298289194703102, -0.01828184351325035, 0.017930954694747925, 0.014500134624540806, 0.03620805963873863, 0.04340362921357155, -0.007629381492733955, -0.007672311272472143, -0.03182158246636391, -0.008854826912283897, -0.006213521584868431, 0.020218761637806892, -0.013066294603049755, -0.02759905718266964, 0.0059579708613455296, 0.034731991589069366, -0.07229681313037872, 0.0033953937236219645, 0.08514692634344101, 0.018327780067920685, -0.014936352148652077, -0.04203614965081215, -0.02181103080511093, 0.004767572972923517, 0.004824050236493349, -0.027549879625439644, 0.003999690525233746, -0.0006978822639212012, 0.010861706919968128, 0.02337142825126648, -0.004581104498356581, -0.03339831903576851, -0.0014057363150641322, 0.005852526053786278, 0.00040876877028495073, -0.007257426623255014, -0.024289708584547043, 0.009481259621679783, 0.007949231192469597, 0.033599965274333954, -0.007213728968054056, -0.03730497509241104, -0.12796607613563538, -0.01511074136942625, 0.05286729335784912, 0.053338196128606796, -0.021077871322631836, -0.007207943592220545, -0.030011463910341263, -0.01706014573574066, 0.03532211482524872, -0.053116947412490845, 0.025501105934381485, -0.008973267860710621, 0.016927409917116165, -0.06715168058872223, -0.03466912731528282, -0.07390085607767105, 0.014605363830924034, -0.054819654673337936, -0.012738585472106934, -0.036315713077783585, -0.005019232630729675, -0.017276538535952568, 0.02955286204814911, -0.0051978230476379395, 0.0439533069729805, -0.034090232104063034, -0.048871178179979324, -0.0003012285742443055, 0.0325898714363575, -0.03614075481891632, -0.039315931499004364, -0.0005212070536799729, 0.02638389728963375, -0.00547496834769845, 0.0437767431139946, 0.028223009780049324, -0.00939200073480606, 0.04687616601586342, -0.00024501641746610403, -0.025929246097803116, 0.008370616473257542, 0.0036717832554131746, 0.0633411556482315, 0.03992115706205368, -0.008364931680262089, 0.015456200577318668, 0.03280600532889366, 0.03233351930975914, -0.0016627050936222076, -0.04951368272304535, 0.016916846856474876, -0.010759592056274414, 0.010509386658668518, -0.056666892021894455, -0.021693997085094452, -0.007330885156989098, 0.022255275398492813, -0.013616190291941166, 0.037129007279872894, -0.0736813172698021, -0.030796656385064125, -0.003361165290698409, 0.05035637319087982, 0.015578890219330788, -0.03469734638929367, 0.007283840794116259, 0.0437471978366375, 0.003583593061193824, -0.03069966845214367, 0.03446494787931442, -0.01649121753871441, 0.033562082797288895, 0.01820226013660431, -0.06184647977352142, 0.009339047595858574, 0.0217000599950552, -0.0025504406075924635, 0.01129121147096157, -0.06175839155912399, 0.048758912831544876, -0.027138985693454742, 0.03871946781873703, 0.03532421588897705, 0.015035527758300304, -0.006697333883494139, 0.03609257936477661, -0.021708989515900612, -0.0033827819861471653, -0.04129555821418762, 0.05449480563402176, -0.02749016508460045, -0.024818746373057365, -0.029103899374604225, -0.047605253756046295, 0.015286114066839218, 0.02665829099714756, -0.014769265428185463, 0.005679069086909294, -0.05058211460709572, 0.008125371299684048, 0.0007294430397450924, -0.017018599435687065, 0.014444030821323395, -0.020906075835227966, -0.006741881370544434, -0.015001164749264717, 0.01483420841395855, 0.08051589131355286, 0.02547685243189335, 0.0007155021885409951, 0.011407434940338135, 0.018918223679065704, -0.013377155177295208, -0.017584485933184624, 0.010464126244187355, -0.026251068338751793, -0.025096651166677475, -0.03916604816913605, 0.05182936415076256, 0.04656967520713806, 0.018008941784501076, -0.014616633765399456, -0.007064615376293659, -0.017082439735531807, -0.004336017183959484, -0.037353795021772385, -0.04016075283288956, -0.014798732474446297, 0.018170533701777458, -0.023583728820085526, -0.011180023662745953, -0.04637248069047928, -0.005470613483339548, -0.014280185103416443, 0.026177959516644478, 0.004026240203529596, 0.019443493336439133, 0.04265750199556351, 0.008250507526099682, 0.032579585909843445, -0.0002927783061750233, -0.006776338908821344, 0.03202405571937561, 0.035572171211242676, -0.022079454734921455, 0.02533690631389618, 0.0012175256852060556, -0.05224820226430893, -0.011943375691771507, -0.04837769269943237, -0.03418775275349617, 0.0430193692445755, -0.005842455197125673, 0.0347430594265461, 0.033803749829530716, -0.005435465835034847, -0.03610754758119583, -0.04316757619380951, -0.045191746205091476, -0.02715986780822277, -0.007838268764317036, 0.07713458687067032, -0.006810015067458153, -0.02485070563852787, 0.019592834636569023, 0.0009018062264658511, -0.008576231077313423, 0.007257041521370411, 0.025150474160909653, 0.010944994166493416, 0.015053440816700459, -0.04989451915025711, -0.01098253857344389, 0.03481380268931389, 0.01003669947385788, -0.002320136409252882, -0.03490675240755081, -0.00889201182872057, 0.023564590141177177, 0.031025758013129234, -0.04620670899748802, -0.044121287763118744, -0.01822044514119625, -0.06222636625170708, 0.0001659580011619255, 0.04717725142836571, -0.029832402244210243, 0.0335061214864254, -0.025342652574181557, 0.044599395245313644, -0.026795994490385056, 0.02007879875600338, -0.05411737784743309, -0.050094034522771835, -0.019408663734793663, -0.031686555594205856, -0.01822960376739502, 0.03687181696295738, 0.003501853672787547, -0.0017367881955578923, 0.03620873764157295, -0.07460260391235352, 0.08459052443504333, 0.018264343962073326, 0.04800918325781822, 0.013153605163097382, 0.034582510590553284, -0.020371289923787117, -0.002930347342044115, -0.021806692704558372, -0.018514510244131088, 0.12737344205379486, 0.07138007879257202, 0.01884554512798786, -0.04562413692474365, 0.055540598928928375, 0.04273497685790062, -0.020609866827726364, -0.03438124060630798, -0.02988753281533718, -0.006552435457706451, 0.027310652658343315, 0.03832056745886803, 0.045520395040512085, -0.005938470829278231, 0.07601572573184967, 0.018900064751505852, -0.047788288444280624, -0.004296678584069014, 0.012697301805019379, 0.036364324390888214, 0.005280137062072754, -0.04171261191368103, -0.09850265830755234, 0.003953957464545965, 0.04703253507614136, -0.018974021077156067, -0.029162876307964325, -0.018770229071378708, 0.016707643866539, 0.011817775666713715, -0.03017680160701275, 0.029694851487874985, 0.006500793620944023, 0.009244677610695362, -0.010105310007929802, -0.005311199929565191, 0.021336155012249947, -0.016614273190498352, 0.0016106062103062868, 0.01781401038169861, 0.010189208202064037, -0.015509397722780704, -0.04686705395579338, 0.02462923526763916, -0.012684053741395473, -0.02764688804745674, -0.023000741377472878, 0.04147173464298248, 0.006398608908057213, -0.03458492085337639, 0.043246712535619736, 0.03234443813562393, 0.006992683745920658, -0.006697321310639381, -0.040126822888851166, 0.03530260547995567, -0.022116800770163536, 0.013663344085216522, 0.018074406310915947, 0.010111082345247269, 0.03464089334011078, -0.01873224601149559, -0.00509462459012866, 0.015682417899370193, 0.03270586207509041, 0.02182324416935444, -0.03942390903830528, 0.03012854978442192, -0.0063485451973974705, 0.01119090337306261, 0.03859204798936844, -0.00694497674703598, -0.008881598711013794, -0.030557524412870407, -0.004388384521007538, -0.00401525292545557, -0.005454179365187883, 0.00978800468146801, -0.028173161670565605, -0.04916021227836609, 0.011678277514874935, 0.04450341314077377, -0.05311460793018341, -0.029192885383963585, -0.05299258977174759, 0.03372448682785034, 0.05898731201887131, 0.015956729650497437, 0.013492727652192116, 0.006284487899392843, 0.002444352488964796, 0.05691225081682205, 0.014084863476455212, 0.014048580080270767, -0.03311530500650406, 0.02330571599304676, -0.02768424153327942, 0.0029711141251027584, 0.01508816983550787, 0.1114223450422287, -0.013494330458343029, 0.011214992962777615, 0.000708000676240772, -0.005122794304043055, -0.022845033556222916, -0.005289375316351652, 0.008247830905020237, -0.04698158800601959, 0.0020603046286851168, -0.007103888317942619, 0.007459070533514023, -0.0628812313079834, -0.010952752083539963, -0.03734206408262253, -0.05779058113694191, 0.02893999218940735, 0.04607284814119339, -0.01671476662158966, 0.053128305822610855, -0.016601424664258957, -0.014826075173914433, -0.05727355182170868, -0.016265740618109703, -0.0120217464864254, -0.050617024302482605, -0.037260185927152634, -0.05943978205323219, 0.001997285522520542, 0.032102085649967194, -0.05041928216814995, 0.0016748739872127771, 0.010964191518723965, 0.045517195016145706, 0.004378428217023611, -0.015608896501362324, 0.02147621102631092, 0.023534761741757393, 0.009248978458344936, -0.024472204968333244, -0.011720866896212101, 0.04432158172130585, -0.05205731466412544, -0.0017436007037758827, -0.02903655543923378, -0.04864756390452385, 0.02427809312939644, 0.002148117171600461, 0.014348872005939484, 0.012219207361340523, 0.013522776775062084, 0.01846090890467167, -0.019375376403331757, -0.0215605515986681, 0.007200879510492086, 0.008557412773370743, 0.008175299502909184, -0.011077368631958961, -0.02290675789117813, 0.002160032279789448, 0.021165573969483376, 0.0017073132330551744, 0.00009009492350742221, -0.0030559569131582975, 0.009639129042625427, -0.00035515069612301886, -0.014998788014054298, 0.010891075246036053, -0.02846328169107437, -0.014744481071829796, 0.016108442097902298, -0.02231975458562374, 0.03487296774983406, 0.015150226652622223, 0.0011900723911821842, -0.09094160050153732, -0.005780700594186783, -0.029476093128323555, -0.008940021507441998, 0.02196468785405159, -0.05790512636303902, 0.0185252632945776, 0.029585545882582664, -0.05940306559205055, 0.02070717327296734, -0.0052839783020317554, 0.0003426577022764832, -0.02555779181420803, 0.06036227196455002, -0.01781543344259262, 0.027951451018452644, 0.04483478143811226, 0.012801350094377995, 0.024459993466734886, 0.015552427619695663, 0.01378378365188837, -0.06257655471563339, -0.0066827102564275265, 0.02138475514948368, 0.0004957501078024507, -0.0387234129011631, 0.062717005610466, -0.03777260705828667, -0.007614444475620985, 0.012167295441031456, -0.018970072269439697, 0.011375038884580135, 0.020849697291851044, -0.023753684014081955, 0.006695369258522987, 0.05739165470004082, 0.02030535601079464, 0.007822769694030285, -0.04042460396885872, 0.007787922862917185, -0.016236454248428345, -0.013551606796681881, -0.01936851069331169, 0.025641124695539474, 0.02445492148399353, -0.0006169610423967242, -0.0003052769461646676, 0.0036814436316490173, 0.016407238319516182, -0.004970524460077286, 0.0006727567524649203, 0.007360559422522783, 0.010030752047896385, -0.041096802800893784, 0.002871220465749502, -0.020148856565356255, 0.017001595348119736, 0.023239361122250557, 0.04160952568054199, -0.002565839095041156, 0.005870737601071596, 0.00654300581663847, -0.0558001771569252, 0.015109644271433353, 0.026361551135778427, -0.024525111541152, -0.042118631303310394, -0.005279942415654659, -0.008142606355249882, -0.023663586005568504, -0.0028648334555327892, -0.006745602935552597, -0.022571807727217674, 0.02221035398542881, -0.017253288999199867, 0.017426462844014168, 0.03157762065529823, 0.015615998767316341, 0.011089936830103397, -0.09076680988073349, 0.05017291009426117, -0.005187449045479298, 0.041215043514966965, -0.04241747781634331, -0.011338988319039345, -0.04406721889972687, 0.002034534001722932, 0.08214239031076431, 0.028025837615132332, 0.005567500367760658, -0.05661245062947273, -0.012904254719614983, -0.005667865741997957, -0.056058671325445175, 0.010162660852074623, 0.006782216019928455, 0.008812632411718369, 0.010473411530256271, 0.007879157550632954, -0.016857299953699112, 0.011843465268611908, 0.03582251816987991, 0.022174540907144547, -0.014814297668635845, -0.014086509123444557, -0.019529392942786217, 0.01736670732498169, 0.004106732551008463, -0.00796516239643097, 0.06732982397079468, 0.024845391511917114, -0.0012214492307975888, 0.03455192223191261, 0.016252979636192322, -0.04477475956082344, 0.007080498151481152, -0.048880018293857574, -0.0058716824278235435, -0.03679151087999344, 0.023895442485809326, 0.008644725196063519, -0.030925607308745384, 0.03148101270198822, 0.018462173640727997, -0.04157991707324982, -0.03832568600773811, 0.021948015317320824, 0.0015418331604450941, 0.007977588102221489, 0.0015007959445938468, 0.01931419037282467, 0.018524933606386185, -0.021844303235411644, 0.0017775384476408362, 0.011828734539449215, 0.013493810780346394, 0.026541221886873245, 0.021126417443156242, 0.03558424115180969, -0.02570033073425293, -0.007495029829442501, 0.006736137438565493, 0.049327511340379715, -0.025846708565950394, -0.009276026859879494, 0.0029349434189498425, 0.000048529269406571984, -0.0006427631014958024, -0.012788299471139908, -0.003605024656280875, 0.020305180922150612, -0.037030693143606186, 0.013553923927247524, -0.04084775596857071, -0.017499590292572975, -0.02137535624206066, 0.03721131384372711, 0.0017452524043619633, 0.030202221125364304, 0.0031372318044304848, -0.00691396975889802, -0.03432035818696022, 0.003948092460632324, -0.010263796895742416, -0.018957696855068207, 0.03243805468082428, -0.05327200889587402, -0.0024006408639252186, 0.028312578797340393, 0.010161287151277065, -0.007163194939494133, -0.020875239744782448, 0.0220022015273571, 0.015041965991258621, 0.005359356291592121, -0.0031877486035227776, -0.019171621650457382, 0.012874910607933998, 0.023962365463376045, -0.057304512709379196, -0.04212786257266998, -0.021056266501545906, 0.011356118135154247, 0.014447432942688465, -0.01857743225991726 ]
<p>Despite this being of a program-related question I was asked to submit this here instead stackoverflow.</p> <p>Is it possible to have confint use the robust variance-covariance matrix obtained by vcovHC (from the sandwich package) after fitting a model? I\ve been looking around without finding it..</p>
49,012
[ -0.004587812814861536, 0.02259458601474762, 0.01570001430809498, 0.00889846496284008, 0.0388992540538311, 0.0006031895754858851, -0.025923239067196846, -0.00235653854906559, 0.05462142080068588, -0.054133158177137375, 0.03560031205415726, 0.05835879594087601, 0.08203288167715073, 0.02842302806675434, -0.011432615108788013, -0.032654888927936554, 0.006315137725323439, -0.023248421028256416, -0.0112528707832098, -0.020997831597924232, -0.00432242639362812, 0.027112862095236778, 0.0006972858100198209, -0.002254386432468891, -0.00858604907989502, 0.04251300171017647, 0.026560548692941666, -0.014641446992754936, -0.02137071080505848, 0.03244449943304062, -0.07362521439790726, -0.03602062538266182, 0.01881704293191433, 0.014953955076634884, 0.00639389781281352, 0.004279539454728365, 0.019757237285375595, -0.04160162806510925, 0.007731725461781025, 0.022066494449973106, -0.008785146288573742, -0.00007007699605310336, -0.000039456270314985886, 0.05998716130852699, 0.0039740013889968395, 0.0246384646743536, -0.02533450350165367, -0.010967168025672436, 0.044118210673332214, -0.024496009573340416, 0.06523480266332626, 0.032401226460933685, 0.007314800750464201, 0.06188840791583061, -0.01948677748441696, -0.013671234250068665, 0.047157831490039825, 0.05978921055793762, -0.009819877333939075, -0.04146821051836014, -0.03144920989871025, -0.012264332734048367, -0.02241809293627739, 0.003896452020853758, -0.006556704640388489, 0.021952692419290543, -0.004694199655205011, -0.04959104582667351, 0.01629430428147316, -0.03852922096848488, -0.0012001418508589268, 0.008491763845086098, 0.0024729177821427584, -0.05352449789643288, 0.04148022085428238, 0.00888130534440279, 0.006753928028047085, 0.004365972708910704, 0.004014580510556698, 0.012989278882741928, 0.02126091904938221, 0.029863424599170685, 0.005174481775611639, -0.0013945355312898755, 0.00022759540297556669, -0.013243659399449825, 0.05970686301589012, -0.055716052651405334, -0.01285601407289505, 0.05274530127644539, -0.003804884385317564, 0.011842415668070316, 0.051286909729242325, 0.01728214882314205, -0.048813026398420334, 0.03169657662510872, 0.02307596616446972, 0.060830213129520416, -0.012953266501426697, 0.009619397111237049, -0.04360556602478027, 0.008600424975156784, -0.002731607062742114, 0.035650502890348434, -0.0011673769913613796, -0.006808848585933447, 0.009161070920526981, -0.007995872758328915, -0.005292106419801712, -0.018321804702281952, -0.0594242662191391, 0.019418681040406227, -0.019611738622188568, -0.020758522674441338, 0.030298622325062752, -0.03805295377969742, 0.0020205643959343433, -0.026789695024490356, 0.07738005369901657, 0.06605158746242523, 0.04908391833305359, -0.0006446926854550838, 0.037761952728033066, -0.021289432421326637, -0.08040433377027512, -0.0002694592985790223, 0.02268894761800766, -0.010903929360210896, -0.06780151277780533, 0.052301786839962006, 0.024749429896473885, -0.020834561437368393, 0.011787235736846924, -0.015639429911971092, 0.04629122093319893, 0.001170038478448987, -0.0854308232665062, -0.06759648770093918, 0.0349566712975502, 0.013229387812316418, -0.01406621839851141, -0.04983403906226158, 0.04340289905667305, -0.004603851120918989, 0.03569697588682175, 0.01255103014409542, 0.030256563797593117, -0.012698479928076267, -0.02578786201775074, 0.008363235741853714, -0.02452962100505829, -0.00945951882749796, -0.0022368207573890686, -0.019595878198742867, -0.03392501175403595, -0.10730628669261932, 0.00435554189607501, 0.008574742823839188, -0.006157072726637125, 0.029308002442121506, 0.06926935166120529, -0.008993349969387054, -0.012416123412549496, -0.03935208544135094, -0.0012226301478222013, -0.061450932174921036, 0.05820038542151451, -0.009083021432161331, 0.004055182449519634, 0.021470200270414352, -0.0247820857912302, 0.011902030557394028, 0.02185233123600483, 0.006881275214254856, 0.032646309584379196, -0.04050956666469574, 0.005120149347931147, 0.0005362053052522242, 0.033514562994241714, 0.01244153268635273, -0.009472089819610119, -0.04155464470386505, 0.01808193139731884, 0.03652569279074669, -0.007284458726644516, 0.0576530359685421, -0.02600553259253502, 0.007688100915402174, 0.010203948244452477, -0.04017433524131775, -0.027815820649266243, -0.030464189127087593, -0.035802509635686874, -0.0011846846900880337, 0.002120359567925334, 0.019144462421536446, 0.006114944815635681, 0.03261355310678482, 0.04831725358963013, -0.008545373566448689, -0.021894510835409164, -0.0030318330973386765, 0.06063332408666611, -0.020943669602274895, -0.0034649844747036695, -0.021127808839082718, 0.055636245757341385, 0.003937368281185627, 0.057684555649757385, -0.0027250477578490973, -0.05693865194916725, -0.01248101145029068, -0.03744174540042877, -0.00623509893193841, -0.010147946886718273, 0.004845743533223867, 0.009952109307050705, 0.004949651658535004, -0.0016800975427031517, 0.0365082323551178, 0.01464766450226307, 0.03523005545139313, 0.08039569109678268, 0.026505107060074806, 0.008115521632134914, 0.000668419583234936, -0.00842017587274313, 0.01606331765651703, -0.007127984892576933, -0.014673754572868347, -0.05463326349854469, -0.003915946464985609, 0.03666510805487633, 0.015585772693157196, -0.014034326188266277, 0.02289353869855404, 0.046626608818769455, -0.02509911172091961, 0.0188197810202837, 0.012316424399614334, -0.028945226222276688, 0.009467944502830505, 0.0219603031873703, 0.025895893573760986, 0.06079186499118805, -0.024445420131087303, -0.030149666592478752, 0.021574771031737328, 0.027726316824555397, 0.02047986350953579, 0.021026773378252983, 0.05903773009777069, 0.022029487416148186, -0.04899847134947777, -0.03861591964960098, -0.005197345279157162, 0.04022469371557236, 0.023102959617972374, 0.04448101297020912, 0.039656516164541245, 0.0021855637896806, -0.016675181686878204, -0.01486219186335802, -0.001569547806866467, 0.023334385827183723, 0.0277483519166708, -0.031812187284231186, 0.009248930960893631, 0.030648263171315193, -0.060829006135463715, 0.008595614694058895, -0.031006457284092903, -0.02044473960995674, -0.02026897296309471, 0.05136464163661003, 0.018561335280537605, -0.017958257347345352, 0.009187720715999603, -0.04832681268453598, -0.023680023849010468, 0.020691359415650368, -0.0014319472247734666, -0.001343427924439311, 0.028533702716231346, -0.020550496876239777, 0.002529354300349951, -0.06458853930234909, -0.03481435775756836, 0.011034714058041573, -0.022761689499020576, 0.014422127045691013, 0.03118767961859703, -0.017901061102747917, -0.015886377543210983, 0.005421486683189869, 0.009112490341067314, -0.023554759100079536, -0.040492698550224304, -0.044248078018426895, 0.010140501894056797, 0.03729541599750519, 0.007460007444024086, 0.03223004564642906, -0.013558600097894669, -0.007785425987094641, -0.028085798025131226, -0.010147897526621819, 0.005597492679953575, 0.019534900784492493, 0.020840603858232498, 0.022825852036476135, 0.004476532805711031, -0.003498028265312314, -0.04628961533308029, -0.023232774809002876, 0.0028113152366131544, 0.005408655386418104, -0.00022989927674643695, 0.017229542136192322, -0.027757057920098305, 0.08915676921606064, 0.006459963973611593, -0.026201436296105385, -0.030115148052573204, -0.018603505566716194, -0.055555641651153564, -0.03466811403632164, -0.006311145145446062, -0.02484017051756382, 0.007890460081398487, 0.003272147150710225, -0.01974092796444893, 0.013691029511392117, 0.06369809806346893, -0.0070534273982048035, -0.011532990261912346, 0.030787957832217216, -0.0007147918222472072, -0.010741482488811016, 0.02850603125989437, -0.011490939185023308, 0.03053407371044159, -0.0005533782532438636, 0.014589209109544754, -0.00811682641506195, -0.012894213199615479, -0.06951248645782471, 0.00904764048755169, -0.015073847025632858, 0.03719630464911461, -0.0726989209651947, 0.03172031790018082, 0.01888708770275116, -0.006984292529523373, -0.022135861217975616, 0.012990827672183514, 0.03254752978682518, -0.027992067858576775, -0.0009749223827384412, 0.04444386437535286, 0.038058627396821976, 0.024043593555688858, -0.008269085548818111, 0.019893337041139603, -0.0033737788908183575, -0.0055875759571790695, -0.018931221216917038, -0.05311788246035576, 0.04514358192682266, 0.03777286037802696, 0.012521535158157349, -0.008987375535070896, -0.038042791187763214, 0.00992478895932436, -0.07334990054368973, 0.026319634169340134, -0.06272480636835098, 0.04867803305387497, 0.014352090656757355, 0.03598480671644211, 0.0185712818056345, 0.01076993253082037, -0.011941783130168915, 0.0015735217602923512, -0.07666958123445511, -0.025431271642446518, -0.022879384458065033, -0.029139820486307144, -0.0297619067132473, -0.040100760757923126, 0.04611076042056084, 0.03385233134031296, 0.0022638309746980667, -0.0092756487429142, 0.020589705556631088, -0.0435667522251606, -0.012480010278522968, -0.02505527436733246, -0.020952390506863594, -0.019036291167140007, 0.022649167105555534, 0.035947784781455994, -0.03064284846186638, 0.03824533149600029, 0.03071998991072178, 0.0012524581979960203, -0.015521426685154438, -0.004290676210075617, -0.010110524483025074, -0.007578371558338404, 0.04414902254939079, 0.006530249025672674, 0.03080027922987938, -0.053494200110435486, -0.003551912261173129, -0.010036284103989601, 0.036051418632268906, 0.0400172583758831, 0.008625366725027561, -0.005642034579068422, -0.06568053364753723, -0.042826924473047256, 0.0072319116443395615, 0.003360595554113388, -0.0005374609609134495, -0.021569784730672836, 0.07436268031597137, 0.037750162184238434, -0.052110716700553894, -0.004238732624799013, 0.040781836956739426, 0.0425235778093338, -0.00028985945391468704, -0.034050341695547104, -0.0012750242603942752, 0.003547938074916601, -0.020959923043847084, -0.006419227924197912, 0.021984441205859184, -0.006259055342525244, 0.027199234813451767, 0.0005493935896083713, -0.012486021034419537, 0.003814015304669738, 0.03666448965668678, 0.04391554743051529, 0.05436800420284271, -0.03608192503452301, 0.022397799417376518, 0.025532977655529976, 0.016757911071181297, -0.0020183653105050325, 0.04409229755401611, 0.032523877918720245, -0.09428435564041138, -0.017458923161029816, 0.055557772517204285, 0.024714570492506027, -0.012186442501842976, -0.016208235174417496, -0.009320810437202454, -0.012387672439217567, 0.03364328294992447, -0.008822423405945301, 0.042308565229177475, -0.011043539270758629, 0.027368977665901184, -0.007331788539886475, -0.010182611644268036, -0.036584869027137756, -0.016345467418432236, -0.004165464546531439, -0.005760662257671356, -0.0063162450678646564, 0.002791771898046136, -0.01846117340028286, 0.009835246950387955, -0.00693769846111536, 0.03441813588142395, -0.021563006564974785, -0.03824392333626747, 0.02711474522948265, 0.009088423103094101, -0.05111101269721985, -0.07143094390630722, -0.014280132949352264, 0.012087857350707054, 0.006696077063679695, 0.03291012719273567, 0.004064407665282488, -0.017181670293211937, 0.025570126250386238, -0.007931716740131378, -0.013116604648530483, 0.009841786697506905, -0.007067408412694931, 0.05234387889504433, 0.03057008795440197, 0.0027510186191648245, 0.04067319631576538, 0.02630767412483692, 0.05597824975848198, -0.02133275382220745, -0.022998839616775513, 0.052334319800138474, -0.027645902708172798, -0.006409811321645975, -0.051273785531520844, -0.03640783950686455, -0.032205406576395035, -0.0020136625971645117, 0.03623619303107262, 0.08507341891527176, -0.000020939907699357718, -0.014906021766364574, 0.027225885540246964, 0.06058559566736221, -0.05002370476722717, -0.0029618795961141586, 0.024649742990732193, -0.015182020142674446, 0.0049391076900064945, -0.054066386073827744, -0.015362633392214775, -0.020732952281832695, -0.007783334236592054, 0.008691960014402866, -0.019765488803386688, -0.006538670510053635, -0.029141109436750412, -0.0017808788688853383, 0.033008377999067307, -0.04388324171304703, 0.04863401874899864, -0.021393198519945145, 0.02363521233201027, -0.01358036044985056, -0.07108850032091141, 0.004263358656316996, 0.035772208124399185, -0.05272558331489563, 0.0037703453563153744, -0.041483648121356964, 0.06274769455194473, -0.022227782756090164, 0.016106098890304565, -0.050942108035087585, -0.04146753251552582, 0.005271932575851679, 0.015427262522280216, -0.017990916967391968, -0.05360793322324753, -0.019193820655345917, 0.0015166490338742733, -0.053384095430374146, -0.0422101765871048, 0.06445222347974777, -0.021021166816353798, 0.02517423965036869, -0.012797686271369457, 0.012139582075178623, 0.05643637478351593, 0.01529752928763628, 0.04990891367197037, 0.030657611787319183, -0.01976323127746582, -0.013949756510555744, 0.04102971777319908, 0.0035351726692169905, -0.043068476021289825, -0.009827003814280033, -0.038492850959300995, -0.006691591814160347, 0.058651234954595566, -0.009820606559515, 0.01878942735493183, 0.03868843987584114, 0.0009739779634401202, 0.011349504813551903, -0.05234374850988388, -0.015768859535455704, -0.0036732933949679136, -0.004852029494941235, -0.037453606724739075, 0.008963622152805328, -0.02013489231467247, -0.005215695593506098, 0.04195508733391762, 0.020711705088615417, -0.042987432330846786, 0.0018268183339387178, 0.06434649974107742, -0.0026104310527443886, -0.016033895313739777, -0.009415778331458569, -0.02938861958682537, 0.020223544910550117, 0.01976814679801464, 0.016141237691044807, 0.021396977826952934, 0.03596757352352142, -0.03660818561911583, -0.04057202488183975, -0.0387466624379158, -0.008174649439752102, 0.04090028256177902, -0.06032116338610649, 0.07730256021022797, 0.04403236508369446, -0.048185113817453384, -0.04004067927598953, -0.031486574560403824, -0.029103707522153854, 0.024680670350790024, 0.0011640916345641017, 0.03110799752175808, -0.007746392861008644, 0.0048309448175132275, 0.026152193546295166, 0.054264701902866364, -0.0036493558436632156, 0.033500704914331436, -0.008090836927294731, 0.060575325042009354, -0.004463097080588341, 0.011260746978223324, -0.03374511003494263, 0.0407223105430603, -0.04117695614695549, 0.026630351319909096, -0.0384066067636013, -0.04447430744767189, 0.022422881796956062, 0.027867158874869347, 0.015803681686520576, -0.050818976014852524, -0.06621044129133224, -0.03674139082431793, 0.062402453273534775, 0.04350202903151512, -0.02517811767756939, 0.02283627726137638, 0.025564247742295265, 0.04541844502091408, -0.0053536659106612206, -0.005436847452074289, -0.04915474355220795, -0.08083122223615646, -0.003474506316706538, -0.018270958214998245, 0.023276424035429955, 0.023087812587618828, -0.009426680393517017, -0.03471127897500992, 0.043679315596818924, -0.02552122436463833, 0.005109063815325499, 0.023153109475970268, 0.02850111573934555, -0.002815977204591036, 0.10355645418167114, -0.00605804892256856, -0.020224185660481453, -0.019767241552472115, 0.03210052102804184, 0.14286203682422638, 0.07413412630558014, 0.05150524154305458, -0.04806927591562271, -0.02216835878789425, -0.000458663038443774, -0.010261258110404015, -0.003165836911648512, -0.009028233587741852, -0.0007550857262685895, -0.0020751385018229485, 0.0010747738415375352, 0.040847551077604294, 0.03083612769842148, 0.04074333980679512, 0.030208030715584755, 0.0008191725355572999, -0.026089981198310852, 0.021916551515460014, 0.022887540981173515, 0.005368588026612997, -0.04455375298857689, -0.023667415603995323, 0.0074495552107691765, 0.0006211972795426846, -0.003996334969997406, -0.038777418434619904, -0.012323940172791481, -0.008809976279735565, -0.03765023127198219, 0.0038719642907381058, 0.014665949158370495, 0.0316782146692276, 0.006535218097269535, 0.001264923601411283, 0.0012315035564824939, 0.008372883312404156, 0.012871968559920788, 0.0011853452306240797, 0.04589274525642395, 0.003650133963674307, 0.001292373868636787, -0.027270542457699776, 0.005523247178643942, -0.02794548310339451, -0.023256169632077217, -0.023739296942949295, 0.033732909709215164, 0.015440593473613262, 0.015929726883769035, 0.014589335769414902, -0.007179843261837959, 0.019948400557041168, -0.011075724847614765, -0.010017047636210918, -0.0006005179020576179, -0.0072943223640322685, 0.00001205406260851305, 0.024211807176470757, -0.04327990859746933, -0.00889270193874836, -0.03288658708333969, -0.029943879693746567, 0.02724319137632847, -0.024319134652614594, -0.0066733453422784805, -0.02364346571266651, 0.0797681137919426, -0.01683361455798149, -0.017727961763739586, 0.0035086257848888636, -0.03636625409126282, -0.0316590890288353, -0.022331975400447845, -0.004737946670502424, 0.0336485281586647, 0.0245351679623127, -0.01255884487181902, -0.0025221083778887987, -0.0014459758531302214, -0.0691361054778099, 0.00823479425162077, -0.059771452099084854, 0.0022183407563716173, -0.04835886508226395, -0.0010314325336366892, 0.019263308495283127, 0.06866616010665894, -0.0015171386767178774, -0.0026088960003107786, -0.017916163429617882, 0.05635685846209526, -0.0075681437738239765, -0.04313955456018448, -0.06266790628433228, -0.006148155312985182, -0.04224647209048271, 0.025048453360795975, -0.021488364785909653, 0.052049245685338974, 0.013609686866402626, 0.005910900887101889, -0.013387976214289665, 0.03640804812312126, -0.0063735307194292545, 0.04445045813918114, 0.04396778345108032, -0.05573045834898949, 0.01999475620687008, -0.017241550609469414, 0.0021886099129915237, 0.0021556608844548464, -0.005747153889387846, -0.008365045301616192, -0.07983282953500748, -0.012380863539874554, -0.02492670901119709, -0.04569488763809204, -0.010142664425075054, 0.00021418833057396114, 0.0014146307948976755, -0.020210716873407364, -0.0023236656561493874, 0.0006378755788318813, -0.022036634385585785, -0.021520452573895454, -0.023471593856811523, 0.0037299753166735172, -0.022008130326867104, -0.060712121427059174, -0.0085334787145257, 0.03542962297797203, 0.011034484021365643, 0.021522654220461845, -0.008904816582798958, -0.017415858805179596, 0.049582116305828094, 0.06222548708319664, -0.019895529374480247, -0.0018970087403431535, 0.03676670789718628, -0.01719181425869465, -0.029867075383663177, -0.009407492354512215, 0.01891946606338024, 0.034269779920578, 0.034768346697092056, 0.030770540237426758, -0.020171690732240677, 0.05300332233309746, -0.03940968215465546, 0.015316500328481197, -0.0036153867840766907, -0.02705877088010311, -0.00523442542180419, -0.007941722869873047, 0.015694931149482727, 0.008507388643920422, -0.009592829272150993, 0.019001349806785583, 0.04915378987789154, -0.002695197006687522, -0.0002874216006603092, 0.006826694123446941, 0.0050995261408388615, 0.0045824176631867886, 0.027966689318418503, 0.00999230332672596, 0.01732122339308262, 0.018559075891971588, -0.01182212121784687, -0.010563986375927925, -0.0030174478888511658, 0.028112025931477547, -0.10166125744581223, -0.0010720845311880112, -0.009800593368709087, 0.001033610780723393, 0.011806691065430641, -0.03196711093187332, 0.02655814401805401, 0.013538381084799767, -0.051042258739471436, -0.009562352672219276, 0.022774500772356987, -0.03672675043344498, -0.03988561034202576, 0.039903588593006134, -0.01938757114112377, -0.006375954020768404, -0.004011675249785185, -0.0492105633020401, 0.035666972398757935, 0.018202513456344604, 0.0020276012364774942, -0.03161163255572319, 0.002881199587136507, 0.029222270473837852, 0.018365979194641113, -0.0031896771397441626, 0.019816718995571136, 0.01782083697617054, -0.01422859076410532, -0.004146117251366377, -0.006005539558827877, 0.01411636546254158, -0.007088626269251108, 0.0425194576382637, 0.002532396698370576, 0.05379819497466087, 0.05055118352174759, 0.012176424264907837, 0.014823630452156067, -0.024506792426109314, -0.006669602822512388, 0.009369239211082458, -0.02242552861571312, 0.03910598158836365, 0.024376071989536285, 0.0019316549878567457, -0.027465634047985077, 0.018929867073893547, -0.029005270451307297, -0.00043797833495773375, -0.03782501071691513, -0.048789650201797485, -0.009930538013577461, -0.013141271658241749, 0.02756511978805065, -0.09777192771434784, 0.025589684024453163, 0.041704606264829636, 0.03429696708917618, -0.029591219499707222, -0.023167593404650688, -0.029767652973532677, -0.023449227213859558, 0.018406152725219727, 0.02145143412053585, -0.05101341754198074, -0.048726264387369156, -0.028586165979504585, 0.04395221173763275, 0.021930290386080742, 0.008415214717388153, -0.01832260563969612, 0.0004021487256977707, 0.040994640439748764, -0.031233537942171097, 0.0019373371032997966, 0.032043661922216415, -0.009910941123962402, 0.031857993453741074, -0.056400686502456665, 0.05972866341471672, -0.012896680273115635, -0.020051265135407448, -0.010880699381232262, 0.0053363679908216, -0.023201555013656616, -0.002136954804882407, 0.039947472512722015, -0.013023004867136478, 0.04201974347233772, -0.004298590589314699, 0.008745909668505192, -0.014064619317650795, -0.047816578298807144, 0.047739382833242416, -0.002953395713120699, 0.00072636385448277, 0.009002531878650188, -0.013665818609297276, -0.006274251267313957, 0.007854507304728031, 0.027417656034231186, 0.013971604406833649, 0.03340201452374458, 0.0028074297588318586, -0.05585072189569473, 0.018702704459428787, -0.008022268302738667, 0.010727428831160069, 0.0411154180765152, -0.025716576725244522, -0.002767026424407959, 0.02634660340845585, 0.03301609307527542, -0.015392238274216652, 0.0202938225120306, -0.05296532064676285, -0.030226372182369232, 0.004072318784892559, 0.007395030464977026, -0.03738127276301384, -0.05053523927927017, 0.018132561817765236, 0.027486586943268776, -0.029367949813604355, -0.029252508655190468, 0.025392679497599602, -0.010261284187436104, 0.02908974327147007, -0.011806322261691093, 0.02530059404671192, 0.03609887510538101, -0.016634663566946983, 0.02038377895951271, 0.02417449653148651, 0.05405769497156143, 0.01993446983397007, 0.015991313382983208, 0.041397809982299805, -0.0013150107115507126, 0.04623638466000557, -0.02243014983832836, 0.011456994339823723, -0.015674380585551262, -0.03836093097925186, 0.0005954520893283188, -0.034713201224803925, 0.014800779521465302, -0.05167265236377716, -0.046467702835798264, 0.05320354923605919, -0.019957469776272774, 0.0031464232597500086, -0.020039759576320648, -0.01790286973118782, -0.039325304329395294, 0.027761336416006088, 0.017522292211651802, 0.02579200454056263, 0.018651893362402916, 0.03491053357720375, -0.016573728993535042, 0.004721735138446093, 0.0220893993973732, -0.02492411993443966, 0.020976055413484573, 0.005426748190075159, 0.03883923217654228, -0.0478394590318203, -0.02201303094625473, -0.016098860651254654, -0.026445355266332626, 0.020472070202231407, 0.007534136064350605, 0.013348336331546307, -0.05988834798336029, -0.024072064086794853, 0.006198020651936531, 0.060775451362133026, -0.03475932776927948, -0.014507872983813286, -0.006790752522647381, -0.019741233438253403, -0.01669977977871895, 0.017882857471704483 ]
<p>consider the following sorted sample: </p> <p>$x_1&lt;x_2&lt;\ldots&lt;x_n$</p> <p>and the kernel function:</p> <p>$h(j)=\log(x_j-x_1), j&gt;1$. </p> <p>Now, it turns out that when I draw data from many continuous distributions, sort them and compute $h(j)$, the plot of the $h(j)$ as a function of $j$ is concave in this sense: $h((j+k)/2)&gt;(h(j)+h(k))/2$ for $1&lt;j&lt;j+1&lt;k&lt;n$ </p> <p>My question is the following: will this observation (concavity of $h(j)$ as a function of $j$) be true for all continuous distributions? If not is there a class of distributions for which it will always be true?</p> <p>Thanks in advance, </p> <p>At this point, given the useful comments from @Glen_b and @Momo, I think I should give an example.</p> <p>this is a vector of values of $x_j-x_1,j&gt;1$ (where the $x$'s are drawn from a continuous distribution, but have been rounded here to the third digit so that they don't take too much place.)</p> <p>My problem, is that when I plot $h(j)$ for this data-set, the result is clearly nor concave (in the sense I outlined above). </p> <pre><code>x=c(1.403, 1.406, 1.408, 1.416, 1.417, 1.42, 1.427, 1.441, 1.448, 1.456, 1.458, 1.465, 1.466, 1.472, 1.472, 1.477, 1.477, 1.479, 1.482, 1.491, 1.5, 1.504, 1.518, 1.52, 1.52, 1.53, 1.544, 1.545, 1.561, 1.573, 1.595, 1.595, 1.599, 1.603, 1.605, 1.612, 1.617, 1.618, 1.618, 1.628, 1.64, 1.644, 1.646, 1.653, 1.679, 1.682, 1.682, 1.693, 1.694, 1.71, 1.71, 1.711, 1.741, 1.75, 1.756, 1.773, 1.794, 1.799, 1.804, 1.808, 1.86, 1.882, 1.895, 1.955, 1.992, 1.995, 2.009, 2.009, 2.063, 2.123, 2.329, 2.356, 2.405, 2.535, 2.632, 2.635, 2.725, 2.763, 2.783) </code></pre>
37,231
[ -0.04038463532924652, -0.006757162511348724, 0.053837865591049194, -0.016549773514270782, 0.033896494656801224, 0.026772471144795418, -0.01621314510703087, 0.007422006689012051, 0.012876652181148529, -0.04161207377910614, 0.03510836884379387, 0.010194993577897549, 0.007605161052197218, 0.026217494159936905, 0.02256116271018982, 0.004530515056103468, -0.06691697239875793, 0.020805533975362778, 0.013344921171665192, -0.010066897608339787, -0.007307642139494419, 0.03857148811221123, 0.028202377259731293, -0.04408244043588638, -0.02516450732946396, 0.03074864111840725, -0.011677640490233898, -0.021429290995001793, 0.004965960048139095, 0.08845747262239456, -0.0065432023257017136, -0.001801618025638163, 0.032322414219379425, 0.06330037862062454, -0.007336266338825226, 0.01988730952143669, -0.03394521400332451, -0.039942849427461624, -0.015893859788775444, 0.025341978296637535, -0.04609791934490204, -0.004521670285612345, 0.021454380825161934, 0.015598859637975693, 0.02828807197511196, 0.06784588098526001, 0.008284525945782661, -0.00547871645539999, 0.021474260836839676, -0.041182249784469604, 0.04728049784898758, 0.006180868484079838, 0.026821888983249664, 0.020725393667817116, -0.02245953492820263, -0.01736421324312687, 0.0486382320523262, 0.07901401817798615, -0.01672925427556038, -0.06642699986696243, -0.009837012737989426, -0.05650711432099342, -0.030846193432807922, 0.015542766079306602, -0.0017488320590928197, 0.016822118312120438, -0.01607566699385643, -0.024793721735477448, -0.009386288933455944, -0.03843020647764206, -0.004879157058894634, 0.03810150548815727, 0.016438504680991173, -0.019529050216078758, 0.013438176363706589, 0.00011971128697041422, 0.025106491521000862, 0.012548092752695084, 0.05245259031653404, 0.014648102223873138, -0.0002625786291901022, 0.026336967945098877, 0.012087712064385414, 0.07332228869199753, 0.007872020825743675, 0.012719067744910717, 0.07593272626399994, -0.04506702721118927, 0.048534002155065536, 0.051834799349308014, -0.006622993852943182, 0.0025650071911513805, 0.04163162037730217, -0.018413105979561806, -0.0350177064538002, 0.026491807773709297, -0.039608184248209, -0.014987988397479057, 0.0209722388535738, -0.036806996911764145, -0.023617208003997803, -0.04825814813375473, 0.014993198215961456, 0.03306607902050018, -0.012468374334275723, -0.0023148898035287857, -0.01700441911816597, 0.0051266830414533615, -0.007486036513000727, -0.003789744572713971, -0.038450345396995544, 0.034695129841566086, 0.01949292980134487, 0.02157493121922016, 0.02888331562280655, -0.04964810982346535, -0.027189714834094048, -0.01584327034652233, 0.04591596871614456, 0.0021730673033744097, 0.06572935730218887, -0.006890433840453625, 0.017705703154206276, -0.04874904081225395, -0.02909945510327816, 0.013004405423998833, 0.03875647485256195, 0.02091176062822342, -0.030655911192297935, 0.02451668493449688, -0.01407046802341938, -0.012299176305532455, 0.05729999765753746, 0.010712876915931702, 0.02929953671991825, 0.00001954716572072357, -0.09383488446474075, -0.02574322372674942, 0.07633798569440842, -0.0019011247204616666, 0.019292524084448814, -0.035631269216537476, -0.0036755374167114496, 0.03739809989929199, 0.02070188894867897, -0.005121186841279268, 0.03454630821943283, 0.0017103580757975578, 0.04711262881755829, 0.011098066344857216, -0.025913594290614128, -0.021436495706439018, 0.002898573176935315, -0.016968300566077232, -0.017894012853503227, -0.053792331367731094, 0.007922416552901268, -0.0026558861136436462, 0.01932493969798088, -0.012428886257112026, 0.051946353167295456, -0.02877943404018879, -0.021923933178186417, -0.05661433935165405, -0.00522200483828783, -0.030113495886325836, 0.054691705852746964, 0.02320905588567257, 0.028175419196486473, -0.022779451683163643, -0.013408356346189976, 0.01390927005559206, 0.000575054029468447, 0.03642837703227997, 0.044403836131095886, -0.03284291923046112, -0.0272322129458189, -0.08142385631799698, 0.017537949606776237, 0.024720454588532448, -0.007833537645637989, 0.0023501820396631956, -0.03771897405385971, -0.002905829343944788, 0.023120030760765076, 0.028784750029444695, -0.023542381823062897, -0.010610864497721195, 0.05746394768357277, -0.04961855709552765, -0.05491726100444794, -0.03442905843257904, -0.03441185876727104, 0.026089372113347054, -0.06506229937076569, 0.05239885672926903, 0.020165087655186653, -0.0050581395626068115, 0.004810559097677469, 0.008755991235375404, -0.0018024691380560398, -0.027714934200048447, 0.040152132511138916, -0.05697806552052498, -0.00359688070602715, 0.011263107880949974, 0.04947914183139801, 0.00649897288531065, 0.07237605005502701, -0.01164576131850481, -0.06718534976243973, 0.017272386699914932, -0.042453281581401825, 0.004354576114565134, -0.01221124641597271, 0.019742097705602646, -0.010220885276794434, -0.002769523998722434, -0.03486505150794983, 0.03121153451502323, -0.07811687141656876, 0.020773740485310555, 0.08170480281114578, -0.002894693287089467, -0.018001478165388107, 0.0034551669377833605, -0.02089967019855976, 0.017658576369285583, -0.028255386278033257, -0.0019115672912448645, -0.05318750441074371, -0.01887352205812931, 0.01704709418118, 0.05668175593018532, -0.036653026938438416, 0.008335295133292675, 0.06445255130529404, 0.040620382875204086, 0.012335310690104961, 0.015453432686626911, 0.0008197535644285381, -0.04901459068059921, 0.007882267236709595, 0.020868735387921333, 0.009833537973463535, -0.009594091214239597, 0.005363193806260824, 0.006538335233926773, 0.0527644008398056, -0.033638209104537964, -0.009325728751718998, 0.02660469152033329, -0.016463320702314377, -0.002088664099574089, -0.024316472932696342, 0.03559392690658569, 0.03989090397953987, 0.005740819498896599, -0.012881400994956493, 0.03853317350149155, -0.0005804234533570707, 0.02826547622680664, -0.04233679175376892, -0.004473365843296051, 0.015208225697278976, 0.041588809341192245, -0.05911760404706001, -0.01606679894030094, 0.011579967103898525, -0.0232588741928339, -0.009080209769308567, -0.02788568288087845, -0.016191795468330383, -0.0033417486120015383, 0.02456522360444069, 0.022764960303902626, 0.012002453207969666, -0.007169508840888739, 0.010586339049041271, -0.005579879507422447, 0.013145132921636105, -0.022002771496772766, 0.05162486061453819, 0.007525445893406868, -0.02604622021317482, -0.04901986941695213, -0.02189590409398079, -0.009050827473402023, 0.055109310895204544, -0.005061089061200619, 0.013557122088968754, 0.005405427422374487, -0.03454279527068138, -0.03304448351264, -0.013538600876927376, -0.02381305582821369, 0.009205075912177563, -0.040689289569854736, -0.017769813537597656, 0.045042555779218674, 0.005891629494726658, -0.03527465835213661, 0.01674901694059372, -0.004644028842449188, -0.012405377812683582, -0.03495969995856285, -0.027324490249156952, 0.005643139593303204, 0.030965978279709816, -0.013033539056777954, 0.02611888386309147, 0.013127833604812622, -0.022234993055462837, -0.05717410892248154, -0.053592048585414886, 0.02459566481411457, -0.019398219883441925, 0.009646602906286716, 0.024796215817332268, 0.0012969690142199397, 0.07594719529151917, 0.0589032918214798, -0.026028718799352646, -0.042529214173555374, -0.00862323772162199, -0.04684498533606529, 0.0047281295992434025, 0.019295956939458847, 0.014363466762006283, 0.019773321226239204, 0.045848846435546875, -0.018667662516236305, 0.04380286484956741, 0.04117549955844879, -0.025903688743710518, -0.01079163234680891, 0.045263875275850296, -0.01754850521683693, -0.006293945945799351, 0.0007756825070828199, 0.0250020083039999, -0.016696123406291008, 0.018304189667105675, 0.03028375282883644, -0.012406795285642147, -0.0009314569178968668, -0.05068144202232361, 0.04826267063617706, -0.017608540132641792, 0.03320134058594704, -0.033046942204236984, 0.02365824766457081, 0.05270978435873985, -0.04188691824674606, -0.023358866572380066, -0.0017922233091667295, 0.04871603846549988, -0.03923564776778221, 0.01620403490960598, 0.008868077769875526, 0.04682571813464165, -0.025628628209233284, 0.017612889409065247, 0.01321980357170105, -0.017701024189591408, 0.03285464271903038, -0.046459347009658813, -0.019317282363772392, 0.009249040856957436, 0.0063127558678388596, -0.006793517153710127, -0.02287990041077137, -0.03244665637612343, 0.024511298164725304, -0.03257019445300102, -0.023184912279248238, -0.044128235429525375, 0.029221419245004654, 0.00334844714961946, 0.042700231075286865, -0.0095777353271842, -0.006193368695676327, -0.003272255649790168, 0.0003482031461317092, -0.0467725470662117, 0.026229796931147575, 0.011033725924789906, 0.045441776514053345, -0.017075663432478905, -0.03556114807724953, 0.027470912784337997, -0.02086476795375347, 0.014594041742384434, -0.0051291389390826225, 0.04286917299032211, -0.03095885179936886, -0.03223085403442383, -0.03279707953333855, -0.03105209209024906, -0.016011977568268776, 0.01027901004999876, 0.019641488790512085, -0.03353254869580269, 0.06957037001848221, -0.005436891224235296, -0.005807900335639715, 0.025509517639875412, -0.015054954215884209, 0.02537509612739086, 0.042202189564704895, 0.048658907413482666, 0.008847770281136036, 0.020021773874759674, -0.004429090768098831, 0.04806796461343765, -0.022699257358908653, 0.04008089005947113, 0.048119038343429565, -0.02966254949569702, 0.01228942908346653, -0.02132236585021019, -0.03904229402542114, -0.022419802844524384, 0.04926813021302223, 0.006006111856549978, 0.016345156356692314, 0.06604379415512085, 0.021932503208518028, -0.032783277332782745, -0.016701728105545044, 0.060683611780405045, 0.028036154806613922, -0.016720619052648544, -0.03322942182421684, 0.0017990614287555218, -0.031361959874629974, 0.011637893505394459, 0.013283060863614082, 0.0012093073455616832, -0.017449090257287025, -0.007106741890311241, 0.039673786610364914, 0.008311832323670387, -0.006279834546148777, 0.012353152967989445, 0.06609466671943665, 0.04084650054574013, -0.0022936370223760605, -0.02565108984708786, 0.04542082920670509, 0.012137121520936489, 0.03315572813153267, -0.004310502205044031, 0.02105986699461937, -0.0918797105550766, -0.0019513728329911828, 0.044650450348854065, 0.009924989193677902, -0.035829175263643265, -0.007502473425120115, -0.06821952015161514, 0.02654857747256756, 0.025757236406207085, -0.006524332799017429, 0.03397822007536888, -0.036095425486564636, 0.019767893478274345, -0.012859449721872807, -0.010336628183722496, -0.08640984445810318, -0.005385995376855135, -0.014938285574316978, 0.01439980510622263, -0.0649542436003685, 0.016419749706983566, -0.0580173023045063, 0.010995093733072281, 0.004237477667629719, 0.04819108173251152, 0.008177228271961212, -0.030270351096987724, 0.02582615427672863, -0.004946685861796141, 0.004605602007359266, -0.04123743996024132, 0.053736597299575806, -0.013907977379858494, 0.024524835869669914, 0.03084665536880493, 0.029766786843538284, -0.01827264204621315, 0.01982562243938446, -0.017739955335855484, -0.018849845975637436, 0.055244263261556625, 0.025736382231116295, 0.04441481828689575, 0.019520172849297523, 0.003462658729404211, -0.0001180150720756501, 0.058606408536434174, 0.016074111685156822, 0.013088354840874672, -0.027145225554704666, 0.03057147189974785, -0.0002291013952344656, -0.035422101616859436, -0.06602790951728821, -0.0358034111559391, -0.010398317128419876, 0.004067257046699524, 0.009569689631462097, 0.02898731455206871, 0.006210035178810358, 0.02683098055422306, 0.045987676829099655, 0.020051361992955208, -0.0012800610857084394, 0.00821168813854456, -0.013977797701954842, 0.028062788769602776, 0.02191281132400036, -0.013780820183455944, 0.0029245917685329914, 0.028712429106235504, 0.01671414077281952, 0.03723544999957085, -0.050075139850378036, -0.02129865251481533, -0.015285969711840153, 0.034967388957738876, -0.015605172142386436, 0.015541658736765385, 0.01807526685297489, 0.0080906106159091, 0.03304360434412956, 0.028325777500867844, -0.04415962100028992, 0.0189319159835577, 0.021647613495588303, -0.015981880947947502, 0.04441232979297638, -0.028299521654844284, 0.012571672908961773, 0.012219957076013088, -0.017189620062708855, -0.06181102618575096, -0.0007837393786758184, 0.029199587181210518, -0.018439963459968567, -0.019276557490229607, -0.03285425901412964, -0.012383734807372093, 0.013606834225356579, -0.016719527542591095, 0.00878843292593956, 0.016023866832256317, -0.01888442412018776, -0.029314475134015083, -0.01531926728785038, -0.016489598900079727, 0.08855624496936798, 0.002336235484108329, 0.002403046004474163, 0.03301020339131355, -0.009855952113866806, -0.0511682853102684, 0.013075974769890308, -0.0073796832002699375, -0.028294941410422325, 0.009858631528913975, 0.0019971595611423254, -0.04224012792110443, 0.03632881119847298, -0.018992919474840164, -0.05014554411172867, -0.005019986070692539, -0.0260122362524271, 0.014997105114161968, 0.011406328529119492, 0.00013577185745816678, -0.030309421941637993, -0.0242027398198843, -0.023748314008116722, -0.024519000202417374, -0.0189971961081028, -0.046583034098148346, -0.0037681690882891417, 0.00904656108468771, -0.03162667900323868, 0.029227405786514282, 0.05301233381032944, -0.03768903762102127, -0.026191405951976776, -0.0030012745410203934, -0.026007385924458504, 0.018218642100691795, -0.009174077771604061, -0.006246541161090136, -0.014776105061173439, 0.0019986224360764027, -0.03718362748622894, 0.019349539652466774, -0.05945659056305885, 0.010139032267034054, 0.05086132138967514, -0.015753118321299553, 0.030075957998633385, 0.020635873079299927, 0.02808520570397377, 0.016106320545077324, -0.01998981088399887, -0.011665841564536095, -0.002141026547178626, 0.017854079604148865, 0.03683340549468994, -0.008166440762579441, -0.007352260872721672, 0.027866194024682045, -0.013954997062683105, -0.005822258070111275, 0.012857523746788502, -0.04998629167675972, 0.006503887474536896, 0.02890886552631855, -0.019993383437395096, -0.05311315879225731, 0.024823978543281555, -0.01379216369241476, 0.03013528138399124, -0.05756998807191849, -0.05729595199227333, 0.013608792796730995, 0.033680301159620285, 0.012759230099618435, -0.03694574907422066, -0.06879684329032898, -0.004606439266353846, 0.0026957341469824314, 0.011195345781743526, -0.014791332185268402, 0.016547147184610367, 0.023331353440880775, 0.043720245361328125, 0.000002102405005643959, 0.030433863401412964, -0.03977307677268982, -0.05490855500102043, -0.032572608441114426, -0.029331035912036896, -0.05874985083937645, -0.013803164474666119, 0.004913658834993839, -0.0774676576256752, 0.03880752623081207, -0.020949654281139374, 0.03588174656033516, 0.012280055321753025, 0.0036113925743848085, 0.04059861600399017, 0.08691225945949554, -0.007971877232193947, 0.026217497885227203, -0.008802808821201324, -0.006875117775052786, 0.1398005485534668, 0.04159357398748398, 0.03388757258653641, -0.023821726441383362, 0.014080621302127838, 0.0019805142655968666, -0.001674880855716765, -0.017402565106749535, 0.023767627775669098, 0.009639612399041653, -0.0397505909204483, 0.02023676037788391, 0.04691335931420326, 0.002594091696664691, 0.006078190635889769, 0.0569915771484375, -0.04990771785378456, 0.01487534586340189, 0.010752848349511623, 0.026166381314396858, 0.005276675336062908, -0.003886884544044733, -0.047192178666591644, 0.0055768596939742565, 0.0030157838482409716, 0.013734902255237103, -0.05568486824631691, -0.01196757797151804, -0.010864920914173126, 0.001147302333265543, -0.0507325679063797, -0.01179599016904831, 0.03648768365383148, -0.02588207833468914, 0.0066251978278160095, -0.008610720746219158, 0.02257940173149109, -0.027744026854634285, 0.02200121432542801, 0.05116162449121475, 0.02802244946360588, -0.002228763420134783, 0.03890460729598999, 0.010884813964366913, -0.03877577185630798, -0.04369521513581276, -0.04990018904209137, 0.03338352590799332, 0.025300227105617523, -0.014415647834539413, -0.004381501581519842, 0.002673851791769266, -0.028916766867041588, -0.0537874773144722, -0.04687115177512169, 0.006259039510041475, -0.006607248447835445, 0.012866795994341373, -0.04216158762574196, -0.009355765767395496, 0.02122313529253006, -0.0016974121099337935, 0.0139955785125494, 0.02001151442527771, -0.08084435760974884, -0.03357675299048424, -0.011240777559578419, 0.054751213639974594, -0.01052328571677208, -0.012250472791492939, 0.000559959386009723, -0.02089935913681984, -0.0028230310417711735, -0.0299222469329834, -0.012141529470682144, -0.008625687099993229, 0.01913931779563427, 0.03980274498462677, -0.0360102653503418, 0.018244165927171707, -0.04040408506989479, 0.020191160961985588, -0.043317608535289764, 0.007194657810032368, -0.08499541878700256, -0.0006930201780050993, 0.002147180028259754, 0.03690012916922569, 0.04593370854854584, -0.025246577337384224, -0.004161181394010782, 0.0478866808116436, 0.021492548286914825, -0.061758242547512054, -0.017813973128795624, 0.01485459040850401, -0.026924122124910355, 0.002299809129908681, -0.02680356428027153, 0.05999734252691269, 0.040051449090242386, 0.04452548548579216, 0.012484574690461159, -0.004672899842262268, 0.010906086303293705, 0.01728338934481144, 0.014927529729902744, -0.05003766715526581, 0.037165384739637375, -0.002625293331220746, 0.030333414673805237, -0.047816868871450424, -0.042738176882267, -0.030327579006552696, -0.007759160827845335, -0.04671214148402214, -0.035916443914175034, 0.017489470541477203, -0.03935253992676735, -0.019476037472486496, 0.030880797654390335, -0.03822002187371254, -0.024397827684879303, -0.014189432375133038, -0.007380241993814707, -0.032145529985427856, 0.028026781976222992, 0.0242448840290308, 0.012310756370425224, -0.01772228442132473, 0.011208079755306244, 0.033129096031188965, 0.014626836404204369, 0.03244810178875923, -0.018572824075818062, 0.03148027881979942, -0.03146540746092796, 0.01286841556429863, 0.009236987680196762, -0.03064909763634205, 0.04694873094558716, -0.03457868844270706, -0.03744523599743843, -0.007132727652788162, -0.0007630608743056655, 0.00333387334831059, 0.0041420599445700645, 0.026057757437229156, -0.04414184391498566, 0.03145146742463112, -0.022324910387396812, 0.033544015139341354, 0.006993470713496208, -0.014188291504979134, 0.021578572690486908, -0.008814992383122444, -0.0223775003105402, -0.00674872100353241, 0.01673083007335663, 0.03243660926818848, 0.022972749546170235, -0.01441808883100748, -0.003576749935746193, 0.022927790880203247, -0.026364756748080254, 0.025566235184669495, 0.011004691943526268, 0.0018706361297518015, 0.04937715455889702, 0.018333889544010162, -0.05851121246814728, 0.0254999827593565, 0.024717317894101143, 0.0328761525452137, -0.09234680980443954, -0.008380904793739319, 0.02851136215031147, 0.009586581960320473, 0.026169056072831154, -0.06508668512105942, -0.01762118935585022, 0.021258393302559853, -0.05423809960484505, 0.042692236602306366, -0.0007527552079409361, -0.0020192095544189215, -0.06278837472200394, -0.006245974451303482, -0.015128837898373604, 0.00826497096568346, 0.028751278296113014, 0.030924925580620766, 0.03867616876959801, 0.005479839164763689, -0.0052218372002244, 0.006069067399948835, -0.006211265921592712, 0.001541721518151462, 0.006107789929956198, -0.05283629521727562, 0.03874267637729645, 0.010621379129588604, -0.010449153371155262, 0.025406641885638237, -0.0010410898830741644, 0.002447130624204874, 0.009858577512204647, 0.01920965686440468, 0.02474251203238964, 0.04617806151509285, 0.012186736799776554, 0.03289148584008217, -0.001632368890568614, -0.0030303008388727903, 0.04420377314090729, -0.0009459976572543383, -0.047365978360176086, 0.014794074930250645, 0.05415236949920654, -0.016781844198703766, -0.016278143972158432, 0.0026444774121046066, 0.00014617101987823844, -0.017565475776791573, -0.022421974688768387, 0.0016249464824795723, 0.011791670694947243, 0.013088197447359562, 0.07514414191246033, -0.03707105293869972, -0.014194798655807972, -0.0021961629390716553, 0.0364895723760128, -0.0055398656986653805, -0.02933529205620289, -0.00997151993215084, -0.051003675907850266, -0.0015507600037381053, 0.005049204919487238, -0.0019394255941733718, -0.07391266524791718, -0.022157246246933937, -0.008559268899261951, 0.003047139151021838, -0.028150418773293495, -0.03924332559108734, -0.0539981946349144, 0.03999194875359535, -0.0075398278422653675, 0.007020374294370413, 0.04423506557941437, 0.005877831485122442, -0.029979780316352844, -0.10735256224870682, 0.04329276457428932, 0.042579762637615204, -0.008189074695110321, 0.005649308208376169, 0.019864588975906372, -0.039333686232566833, 0.017842942848801613, 0.07481929659843445, 0.01118201669305563, 0.005366266239434481, -0.004272085148841143, -0.005820669233798981, 0.0014212224632501602, -0.07787829637527466, 0.028230687603354454, -0.029192684218287468, -0.019756047055125237, -0.03269141539931297, 0.01510227844119072, -0.0051385220140218735, 0.044430363923311234, 0.007116362452507019, 0.007699135225266218, -0.005658101290464401, -0.013473437167704105, -0.008667634800076485, 0.007661951240152121, -0.013231655582785606, -0.031058553606271744, 0.033826276659965515, -0.004946453496813774, 0.0024228342808783054, -0.01825016178190708, 0.015178178437054157, -0.08923491835594177, -0.02170928567647934, 0.01625857874751091, -0.035838086158037186, 0.0001295979309361428, 0.01791955903172493, -0.020855408161878586, -0.008928054012358189, -0.03203790262341499, 0.028193477541208267, -0.034261155873537064, -0.03138893097639084, 0.011398125439882278, 0.06410084664821625, 0.044781289994716644, 0.019239572808146477, 0.013854633085429668, 0.017377277836203575, -0.007256644312292337, 0.052096400409936905, 0.03438893333077431, 0.037697210907936096, -0.025763191282749176, -0.0006643833476118743, -0.027352510020136833, -0.029843231663107872, 0.02197941392660141, -0.004390384536236525, 0.05843834578990936, -0.009272070601582527, -0.011474112048745155, 0.0319688618183136, 0.008869519457221031, -0.023269474506378174, -0.01923614926636219, 0.005439447239041328, 0.03711416572332382, 0.00014642340829595923, 0.02966601587831974, -0.02993994578719139, -0.005211463663727045, 0.007290399633347988, 0.00807574950158596, 0.007343549747020006, 0.015093138441443443, -0.010115483775734901, 0.006405677646398544, 0.01762637309730053, 0.014675055630505085, 0.03621908277273178, 0.006410375237464905, 0.02667166292667389, 0.02396191470324993, 0.01613518036901951, 0.006949038244783878, -0.03435894101858139, 0.040758367627859116, -0.03985384479165077, 0.012573454529047012, 0.032859575003385544, 0.03163652867078781, 0.002697722287848592, -0.03008073754608631, -0.005854445975273848, 0.0697026327252388, -0.06900149583816528, -0.037121642380952835, -0.03363346308469772, 0.036874253302812576, 0.009230159223079681, -0.022920800372958183 ]
<p>My background is in labor economics/applied micro but I am currently working with data collected from a field experiment. My experimental/micro skills are rusty to say the least.</p> <p>In my data, I observe individuals choosing one of the choices $A, B, C, D$. The value of the choice is realized after the choice. I know that </p> <p>$$E(A) &lt;= E(B) &lt;= E(C) &lt;= E(D)$$ $$VAR(A) &lt;= VAR(B) &lt;= VAR(C) &lt;= VAR(D)$$</p> <p>If I assume that $A, B, C, D$ are continuous, independent and normally distributed and individuals are aware of expected payoffs $E(i)$ and variances $VAR(i)$. </p> <ul> <li>Is there a way to estimate a expected risk aversion parameter (e.g. CRRA) for a group of people? </li> <li>Would it make sense to compare these risk estimates from two groups of people, say men and women or high educated and low educated?</li> </ul> <p>I would appreciate if you guys could come up with some relevant literature.</p>
74,368
[ -0.053340520709753036, -0.0245555080473423, 0.005053122527897358, -0.015945635735988617, 0.028286373242735863, 0.026057180017232895, -0.03671811521053314, -0.01217785943299532, 0.04167235270142555, -0.0087299644947052, 0.00048301246715709567, 0.05732147768139839, 0.05199744924902916, 0.03485095873475075, 0.039968833327293396, 0.023181170225143433, -0.01958788000047207, -0.0029587142635136843, -0.006267372984439135, 0.013690141029655933, -0.005541297607123852, 0.03401690348982811, 0.017192436382174492, -0.022240327671170235, -0.027700303122401237, 0.023289384320378304, 0.016803663223981857, -0.038945164531469345, -0.009973980486392975, 0.07441624999046326, -0.005665418226271868, -0.015425910241901875, -0.016652535647153854, 0.036139629781246185, -0.014151066541671753, 0.00579097680747509, -0.033780068159103394, -0.048991844058036804, -0.019206413999199867, 0.04184596240520477, -0.030772728845477104, -0.02990908734500408, 0.011038332246243954, 0.033450886607170105, -0.02506135404109955, -0.006504759658128023, 0.017364228144288063, -0.05314674228429794, 0.016431111842393875, -0.06181425228714943, 0.05445873364806175, 0.0016522301593795419, 0.022659752517938614, 0.025111107155680656, -0.012903688475489616, -0.02657962776720524, 0.04251345992088318, 0.07020101696252823, -0.011129853315651417, -0.046161189675331116, 0.001318967086263001, -0.021232418715953827, 0.004146826919168234, 0.0032401469070464373, -0.042672742158174515, -0.0015499150613322854, -0.01983392797410488, -0.020519567653536797, 0.027140356600284576, -0.026750575751066208, 0.01768033765256405, 0.026123858988285065, 0.006514422129839659, 0.03103579767048359, 0.04436329007148743, -0.012140774168074131, 0.013250923715531826, 0.04140423983335495, 0.07098530232906342, 0.033435676246881485, -0.02637697011232376, 0.005275233183056116, 0.02641216106712818, 0.059589941054582596, -0.0057341367937624454, -0.022792579606175423, 0.040927816182374954, -0.014630047604441643, 0.02916855737566948, 0.005697053391486406, -0.021726226434111595, 0.00015219757915474474, 0.03505469486117363, 0.005839803256094456, -0.07524769008159637, 0.01876930333673954, -0.014359946362674236, 0.02477569505572319, -0.004230864346027374, -0.02511623315513134, -0.021027762442827225, -0.020499413833022118, 0.008259267546236515, 0.03241223469376564, 0.01270892284810543, -0.008674092590808868, -0.032154347747564316, 0.0029146794695407152, 0.006682889070361853, -0.05587754398584366, -0.04620897024869919, 0.03515031188726425, -0.012014112435281277, -0.0027612890116870403, 0.02750985138118267, -0.008868299424648285, -0.019835220649838448, -0.03499346971511841, 0.10113290697336197, 0.06565649062395096, 0.03566044569015503, -0.03942500799894333, 0.028818996623158455, -0.029939623549580574, -0.03130903095006943, 0.005133884493261576, 0.030309118330478668, -0.0056376466527581215, -0.025658804923295975, 0.06323777139186859, 0.018305901437997818, 0.0014209940563887358, 0.026903536170721054, -0.0008226499194279313, -0.010247580707073212, -0.003203192027285695, -0.08525868505239487, -0.04424961656332016, 0.0295431986451149, -0.0052022868767380714, 0.009871684946119785, -0.08197152614593506, -0.022169023752212524, 0.003937877714633942, 0.03414643555879593, -0.018050070852041245, 0.060794927179813385, -0.005191480740904808, 0.026806030422449112, 0.03013862855732441, -0.02851494587957859, 0.015813110396265984, 0.004237028770148754, 0.02944755367934704, 0.0018858240218833089, -0.07753133773803711, -0.005528817418962717, 0.033541809767484665, -0.053660716861486435, -0.007969332858920097, 0.047992803156375885, 0.032109785825014114, -0.030631668865680695, -0.006802686490118504, 0.029924822971224785, -0.011325766332447529, 0.0776272565126419, 0.01514186430722475, 0.0075785256922245026, -0.02198113314807415, 0.005876714829355478, 0.02437741868197918, 0.0007367397774942219, 0.06606540828943253, 0.07720205187797546, -0.03331952169537544, -0.010416973382234573, -0.0034999616909772158, 0.024732625111937523, -0.010678471066057682, -0.016661403700709343, 0.0064015742391347885, -0.012635650113224983, -0.020854543894529343, -0.01285852026194334, 0.029619408771395683, -0.00734893511980772, -0.019569754600524902, 0.008585125207901001, -0.03247421234846115, -0.06064440682530403, -0.0968804731965065, -0.0013714737724512815, 0.03668350353837013, -0.043019913136959076, 0.005652041174471378, -0.005916062742471695, 0.031176496297121048, -0.023248299956321716, -0.010423488914966583, -0.019608713686466217, -0.0066479407250881195, 0.022398553788661957, -0.012516152113676071, -0.0012824161676689982, 0.03283866494894028, 0.04778120666742325, -0.015595450066030025, 0.012685675173997879, -0.005745378788560629, -0.040412191301584244, 0.0008266381919384003, -0.03822468966245651, 0.041844163089990616, -0.01236729882657528, 0.0016315028769895434, 0.03596368059515953, -0.02501986175775528, 0.011895821429789066, 0.040606360882520676, -0.05697513371706009, 0.034645769745111465, 0.05865143984556198, -0.005200051236897707, -0.023102249950170517, 0.03798317909240723, 0.04530993476510048, 0.015627168118953705, -0.02806454338133335, 0.0010855449363589287, -0.03379141539335251, 0.024680841714143753, 0.021649613976478577, -0.005666445009410381, -0.06005169451236725, 0.03979392349720001, 0.06046312302350998, 0.033143915235996246, 0.018692007288336754, 0.06087365746498108, 0.008295755833387375, -0.031001733615994453, -0.000817795458715409, 0.034098245203495026, -0.026618974283337593, 0.020488416776061058, 0.004455376882106066, -0.0035365826915949583, 0.02274394780397415, -0.03618859499692917, 0.03393549099564552, 0.016642022877931595, -0.022922664880752563, 0.01656561903655529, -0.035956334322690964, 0.026080939918756485, 0.056709107011556625, -0.025837093591690063, 0.024108704179525375, 0.011814163997769356, 0.008740285411477089, -0.019743654876947403, 0.010583605617284775, -0.056108977645635605, 0.03170838579535484, 0.04478038102388382, -0.04985527694225311, -0.0015165412332862616, 0.020007792860269547, 0.012961861677467823, 0.004692984279245138, 0.026533355936408043, 0.001059092814102769, -0.04069285839796066, 0.004596840124577284, 0.007157114800065756, -0.015435577370226383, 0.01391297485679388, -0.010028879158198833, -0.029616422951221466, 0.021021151915192604, 0.00567323574796319, 0.05019248276948929, 0.01511668972671032, -0.039527762681245804, 0.022230057045817375, -0.013559332117438316, -0.04060354083776474, 0.029058119282126427, -0.004110896959900856, 0.0023471193853765726, 0.05256795510649681, 0.0043957470916211605, -0.042375896126031876, 0.00979943759739399, 0.011096535250544548, 0.02018510363996029, -0.009463340044021606, -0.015694277361035347, 0.021086310967803, -0.03544624149799347, 0.0038742301985621452, 0.035764530301094055, -0.04409537464380264, -0.02017654851078987, 0.01170380599796772, -0.010920422151684761, -0.014257167465984821, 0.01055163610726595, 0.0014335360610857606, 0.020756009966135025, -0.00006251301238080487, -0.018873613327741623, -0.08688995242118835, -0.08915989845991135, 0.0468934066593647, -0.01137604285031557, -0.009619293734431267, -0.012875853106379509, -0.0040465849451720715, 0.039776090532541275, 0.028604671359062195, -0.04480637609958649, -0.011450748890638351, -0.032535772770643234, -0.014064406044781208, -0.007064910605549812, 0.021250678226351738, 0.03149699047207832, -0.03600494936108589, 0.051521386951208115, -0.0037468906957656145, 0.023252088576555252, 0.05607707053422928, -0.01667884923517704, 0.008865091018378735, 0.009904667735099792, -0.012215692549943924, 0.013332772068679333, 0.024258673191070557, -0.0034782218281179667, -0.0066579957492649555, 0.008105623535811901, 0.0009618284530006349, 0.028511058539152145, 0.002621525665745139, -0.04145534336566925, 0.021657029166817665, -0.02055532857775688, -0.03350405767560005, -0.044033072888851166, 0.009816793724894524, 0.020327560603618622, -0.030543064698576927, 0.006735704839229584, -0.01672481745481491, 0.012698600068688393, -0.013786171562969685, 0.03468983620405197, 0.01462493184953928, 0.04094931483268738, 0.04033919796347618, -0.033859677612781525, -0.01631527952849865, 0.04359821602702141, 0.02584126405417919, -0.030443286523222923, -0.004955187439918518, 0.026239031925797462, 0.057478003203868866, -0.0012736825738102198, -0.03742707893252373, -0.07735546678304672, 0.011593537405133247, -0.0728020966053009, 0.010530534200370312, -0.020460641011595726, 0.06288119405508041, 0.0186984334141016, 0.02960362285375595, -0.0012494310503825545, -0.004742240067571402, -0.01948302425444126, -0.0048347357660532, -0.06656736880540848, 0.02758215181529522, -0.0038277916610240936, 0.007286828011274338, 0.006003201939165592, -0.01013820432126522, 0.06674177199602127, -0.018674593418836594, -0.023503025993704796, -0.006856539286673069, 0.054209139198064804, -0.015848133713006973, -0.010687382891774178, -0.02357669174671173, -0.027776628732681274, -0.0017484090058133006, 0.009750906378030777, -0.03333284705877304, -0.03169042244553566, 0.0074676270596683025, 0.03584403172135353, -0.023135146126151085, -0.016307484358549118, -0.02159327082335949, 0.0007106068660505116, -0.006376892328262329, 0.04265270009636879, 0.04868865758180618, 0.007557291071861982, -0.033859074115753174, 0.026034334674477577, -0.0012927153147757053, 0.04413321986794472, 0.04142701253294945, -0.000025337851184303872, -0.016218973323702812, -0.042094144970178604, -0.04128314554691315, -0.011059830896556377, 0.008562620729207993, -0.017608270049095154, 0.01053086668252945, 0.0696016401052475, 0.027848659083247185, -0.04712072014808655, 0.0075695510022342205, -0.01100180484354496, 0.0066771176643669605, -0.011512070894241333, -0.003289804793894291, -0.00646174605935812, -0.010751709342002869, -0.016324784606695175, 0.007315867114812136, -0.002803199924528599, -0.011568519286811352, -0.01698601059615612, 0.06734178215265274, 0.01768701709806919, -0.02364305593073368, 0.030701495707035065, 0.015111157670617104, 0.046733494848012924, 0.026366936042904854, -0.05493093654513359, 0.01691746711730957, 0.03482656925916672, 0.021255942061543465, 0.027356771752238274, 0.02831094339489937, -0.06888007372617722, -0.03799264878034592, 0.007798826787620783, 0.049495894461870193, -0.06633120030164719, -0.016636690124869347, -0.013080703094601631, -0.011695346795022488, 0.043767187744379044, 0.000746673671528697, -0.0008544225711375475, -0.03468937426805496, -0.006570592522621155, -0.023932339623570442, -0.03669431060552597, -0.04186338931322098, -0.0000432259330409579, -0.0026490020100027323, 0.013483869843184948, 0.005217389669269323, -0.02952205389738083, -0.013420077972114086, -0.00880811084061861, 0.042165808379650116, 0.08167915046215057, -0.03750668093562126, 0.01773974858224392, 0.021464582532644272, 0.030977046117186546, 0.006819607689976692, -0.06790772825479507, 0.03564693406224251, 0.00670645572245121, -0.004547247663140297, 0.07553043961524963, -0.016133129596710205, -0.03289801999926567, 0.014074128121137619, 0.0021251123398542404, -0.02571217156946659, 0.013171748258173466, -0.0050826105289161205, 0.025503966957330704, 0.03232579305768013, 0.023590529337525368, 0.03099898062646389, 0.0004711796354968101, -0.013344796374440193, 0.02279796451330185, -0.015717577189207077, 0.020056625828146935, -0.04276727885007858, -0.04028792679309845, -0.061550624668598175, -0.017204299569129944, 0.004965891130268574, 0.04882364347577095, 0.035970576107501984, 0.04891789332032204, -0.05802079662680626, -0.0274127796292305, -0.013755658641457558, 0.03816581517457962, 0.008273262530565262, -0.0031274922657757998, 0.008001863956451416, -0.0016211533220484853, -0.0028326786123216152, -0.012533333152532578, 0.011640075594186783, -0.009730959311127663, -0.0052458904683589935, -0.019777506589889526, -0.07133188843727112, 0.01174218114465475, -0.03898453712463379, -0.046113286167383194, 0.01614941842854023, -0.048196692019701004, 0.06275279819965363, 0.014791805297136307, 0.029982328414916992, -0.025091221556067467, -0.03559938818216324, 0.005225377157330513, 0.028915852308273315, 0.0025571698788553476, 0.05186604708433151, -0.027997683733701706, 0.037556521594524384, -0.0007263370789587498, -0.004084884189069271, -0.06166878715157509, -0.006197887007147074, 0.00933646596968174, 0.005789218470454216, -0.012074158526957035, -0.014762339182198048, 0.024570506066083908, -0.01547458115965128, -0.026589257642626762, -0.005881378427147865, 0.06642697751522064, -0.006075836718082428, 0.014726394787430763, -0.0060696909204125404, 0.0267174132168293, 0.06808554381132126, -0.017549648880958557, -0.02090662345290184, 0.026310615241527557, -0.03144659474492073, -0.030172841623425484, -0.009494899772107601, 0.03817164897918701, -0.032096587121486664, -0.025555584579706192, -0.017366036772727966, -0.00960365030914545, 0.06782589107751846, -0.008480286225676537, -0.010082735680043697, 0.029555130749940872, -0.005683360155671835, 0.0012147241504862905, -0.020462442189455032, 0.006733534391969442, -0.00013346078048925847, 0.023441653698682785, -0.03316991403698921, 0.0005103868898004293, -0.030769087374210358, -0.004131564870476723, 0.02928861230611801, 0.011309792287647724, -0.04342563822865486, 0.013678381219506264, 0.06088607758283615, -0.0059116012416779995, -0.025455206632614136, -0.019795075058937073, -0.001436327351257205, 0.047001972794532776, -0.044378332793712616, 0.02150890976190567, 0.02268398553133011, 0.03317665308713913, -0.03812602534890175, -0.06050802394747734, -0.037290770560503006, 0.009174820967018604, 0.05779724940657616, -0.01982433721423149, 0.07680581510066986, 0.049764234572649, 0.019511736929416656, -0.027571333572268486, -0.006844052113592625, 0.014897570013999939, -0.0023982294369488955, -0.020972715690732002, 0.022437458857893944, -0.0028621177189052105, 0.0025381792802363634, 0.03318026289343834, -0.010927606374025345, 0.007226230576634407, 0.04291069135069847, -0.011189242824912071, 0.05417145788669586, 0.013155723921954632, -0.04405106231570244, -0.03927205502986908, 0.024740004912018776, -0.03631383553147316, 0.021236969158053398, -0.04789062216877937, -0.046192072331905365, 0.05478430539369583, 0.05920155346393585, -0.009265740402042866, -0.018820544704794884, -0.014472683891654015, -0.04372095316648483, 0.02137075364589691, 0.03336258605122566, -0.047938887029886246, 0.016626037657260895, -0.022085973992943764, 0.040319107472896576, -0.02595861814916134, 0.03950566425919533, -0.015880513936281204, -0.07172228395938873, -0.004402887541800737, -0.028942709788680077, -0.0067009273916482925, 0.0008756855386309326, 0.006160357967019081, 0.007848191075026989, 0.00026259972946718335, -0.05440935865044594, -0.0009960135212168097, -0.009235953912138939, 0.005865055602043867, 0.0009135185973718762, 0.07887791097164154, -0.001918036607094109, 0.043277669697999954, -0.024044599384069443, 0.005684210918843746, 0.10146789252758026, 0.07452211529016495, 0.03664958104491234, -0.056406863033771515, 0.03970435634255409, -0.027261868119239807, 0.002923400141298771, -0.011267183348536491, 0.01757149025797844, 0.02826019562780857, -0.0083529744297266, 0.01596764475107193, 0.05456027761101723, 0.012767603620886803, -0.013377843424677849, 0.049848321825265884, -0.011340219527482986, -0.03234574571251869, 0.04357197880744934, 0.010637393221259117, 0.018185177817940712, -0.026377450674772263, -0.00889525841921568, 0.03155604004859924, 0.003946061246097088, -0.0017850431613624096, -0.002402928890660405, -0.002904951572418213, 0.006586144212633371, -0.01847745291888714, -0.01626640185713768, -0.023011261597275734, 0.018542911857366562, 0.005487306974828243, -0.011758372187614441, 0.003954228945076466, 0.00024176892475225031, -0.025206102058291435, 0.020017806440591812, -0.00003413449667277746, -0.044153302907943726, 0.000605097331572324, 0.02681644819676876, 0.002653091447427869, -0.039405401796102524, -0.03866002708673477, -0.04087108001112938, 0.04402780532836914, -0.04474906623363495, -0.011755798012018204, -0.04093015193939209, 0.01670241355895996, 0.008154473267495632, -0.03486340865492821, -0.05313785746693611, 0.023510118946433067, 0.0074601685628294945, -0.004282703157514334, 0.0016855663852766156, -0.046071119606494904, 0.008063851855695248, -0.017160363495349884, 0.0040112086571753025, -0.004069696646183729, -0.0934678241610527, -0.07671297341585159, -0.026149507611989975, 0.020520729944109917, 0.013899937272071838, -0.013397599570453167, -0.013432947918772697, -0.03449402377009392, -0.02434615045785904, -0.017663439735770226, -0.011970963329076767, -0.0023508556187152863, 0.014029416255652905, -0.015878789126873016, 0.01279926672577858, 0.009232179261744022, 0.004705629777163267, 0.005953359417617321, -0.03616933152079582, 0.019529851153492928, -0.05889005959033966, 0.004709693603217602, 0.028012437745928764, -0.0071505713276565075, 0.027576396241784096, -0.003840251825749874, 0.008747194893658161, 0.04060961306095123, -0.004673335701227188, -0.038336098194122314, -0.012172440998256207, -0.03594811260700226, -0.06047659367322922, -0.003570130094885826, 0.008901523426175117, 0.0622943714261055, -0.018070241436362267, 0.02658306062221527, -0.018102450296282768, 0.01660681702196598, 0.000947798602283001, 0.031052254140377045, 0.022252282127738, -0.07986273616552353, -0.004153002519160509, 0.017126334831118584, 0.033261850476264954, -0.024963492527604103, 0.004850195255130529, -0.028261099010705948, -0.01608794927597046, -0.009028376080095768, -0.0473712719976902, -0.018507864326238632, 0.015031861141324043, -0.029576368629932404, 0.05527462065219879, -0.020686805248260498, -0.008135586977005005, -0.017899535596370697, -0.014522498473525047, 0.003962777089327574, 0.0035942336544394493, -0.017394598573446274, 0.026150142773985863, 0.012170271016657352, 0.010722307488322258, 0.01768719218671322, 0.02306291088461876, 0.008982734754681587, -0.02135418727993965, 0.016812745481729507, -0.018171321600675583, 0.04550252482295036, -0.0063175018876791, -0.07157260924577713, 0.04910583049058914, -0.046645261347293854, 0.011492944322526455, 0.015034559182822704, 0.01203895453363657, 0.06548871099948883, 0.00037074583815410733, -0.01620364747941494, 0.002900903346017003, 0.047930993139743805, -0.010764846578240395, -0.019991202279925346, -0.0031320075504481792, 0.004739952739328146, 0.004758073017001152, -0.023468730971217155, -0.013058093376457691, -0.012566822580993176, 0.011715284548699856, 0.02967114932835102, 0.022735673934221268, 0.0016801237361505628, -0.021758142858743668, 0.020398277789354324, 0.00784824788570404, 0.0006980145117267966, 0.005623594857752323, -0.013040527701377869, 0.004735964350402355, 0.03255174681544304, -0.016467014327645302, 0.019811386242508888, 0.00559367286041379, 0.01242402009665966, -0.0813661590218544, -0.027357611805200577, 0.04470178857445717, 0.01366536132991314, 0.021886179223656654, -0.07029237598180771, 0.005994059145450592, 0.03013184852898121, -0.04885042831301689, 0.020047154277563095, 0.012071964330971241, 0.018911492079496384, -0.027427423745393753, 0.01922956109046936, -0.02879852056503296, 0.03308240324258804, -0.011527545750141144, 0.02689853124320507, 0.053490910679101944, 0.005371732637286186, -0.006178183015435934, -0.011016120202839375, 0.0058151488192379475, 0.017795270308852196, 0.03622474893927574, -0.06797018647193909, 0.07052436470985413, -0.052621595561504364, -0.029012637212872505, 0.06558794528245926, 0.03839223459362984, 0.042739056050777435, 0.020207978785037994, 0.019541721791028976, 0.0077751558274030685, 0.04190361872315407, 0.010509209707379341, 0.0003543681523296982, -0.001513743307441473, -0.01412129681557417, 0.026123153045773506, 0.0035123175475746393, -0.01479767169803381, 0.0036364186089485884, 0.053079064935445786, 0.01697683334350586, -0.0029099229723215103, 0.03848009556531906, -0.030260290950536728, -0.033767640590667725, -0.021915998309850693, -0.057671912014484406, 0.0353412888944149, -0.033578380942344666, 0.051325324922800064, -0.04121862351894379, -0.026431255042552948, 0.0326763316988945, 0.016113389283418655, 0.009647300466895103, 0.02957833930850029, -0.0028479555621743202, -0.0916249081492424, 0.02430872619152069, 0.016784990206360817, -0.021364115178585052, -0.039963919669389725, -0.016377480700612068, 0.0020972772035747766, 0.012622084468603134, -0.02849642187356949, -0.019572783261537552, -0.012287963181734085, 0.01987195946276188, -0.042639464139938354, -0.01271709892898798, 0.014521614648401737, -0.00028714927611872554, -0.021147960796952248, -0.06928369402885437, 0.0654744803905487, -0.0035967910662293434, -0.016089461743831635, -0.038883812725543976, 0.010895675979554653, -0.03239542245864868, -0.04596375301480293, 0.0443873405456543, -0.012076161801815033, -0.011662904173135757, 0.023933080956339836, 0.0379374660551548, -0.01414817851036787, -0.03847941756248474, 0.045134756714105606, -0.012009352445602417, 0.015072571113705635, -0.02588535286486149, 0.006487368140369654, 0.03178947791457176, 0.002938652178272605, 0.0034794150851666927, 0.004028096795082092, 0.005285424645990133, 0.027131671085953712, 0.013457413762807846, 0.020898576825857162, 0.01266228687018156, -0.014482134953141212, 0.045609086751937866, 0.010115456767380238, 0.01998765952885151, -0.032039858400821686, -0.03463129326701164, -0.012552028521895409, 0.05314197018742561, -0.022504286840558052, -0.0369085855782032, 0.015504459850490093, 0.00879612285643816, -0.020170707255601883, -0.057892896234989166, 0.00858925748616457, 0.0305933840572834, -0.03236621990799904, 0.004948802292346954, 0.0434141531586647, 0.03518598899245262, 0.03407258167862892, -0.0015217727050185204, 0.049598079174757004, -0.0014794585295021534, -0.02134336531162262, -0.008037776686251163, 0.026168756186962128, 0.060486599802970886, -0.009672789834439754, 0.042520273476839066, 0.03537670895457268, -0.04122206196188927, 0.00014767167158424854, -0.03697238489985466, 0.027634989470243454, -0.027695855125784874, -0.02131734974682331, 0.04631531983613968, 0.023603927344083786, -0.004801537841558456, -0.018068505451083183, -0.012649604119360447, 0.05250732600688934, -0.008485415950417519, -0.0020894305780529976, -0.0318731814622879, 0.006926027126610279, -0.028469448909163475, -0.025962190702557564, 0.029155105352401733, 0.005105878692120314, 0.02266639657318592, 0.005470604170113802, -0.018157165497541428, -0.010753687471151352, 0.024493681266903877, -0.002002836437895894, 0.039791665971279144, -0.000053350951930042356, -0.024678366258740425, -0.006431261543184519, -0.04886965826153755, -0.003992200829088688, -0.04237658157944679, 0.02978389896452427, 0.03644649684429169, 0.04241766035556793, 0.018052712082862854, -0.04767502099275589, 0.0578179694712162, 0.07668104022741318, -0.08300568908452988, 0.006045497488230467, -0.0407889224588871, 0.007799522951245308, -0.027756258845329285, -0.023795798420906067 ]
<p>I have a set of Likert type items asking respondents their attitude on different topics. For example, attitudes toward drugs/alcohol where 1=strongl disagree and 5=strongly agree to the statement "I think it is okay for someone my age to smoke marijuana." The 6 items in this particular scale are then scored using the mean of non-missing items. Is there some advantage to first rescaling the items so that the range of responses goes from 0-4 rather than 1-5? The only difference is in interpretation of the scale where the average "attitude" is 3.5 on a scale of 0-4 and 4.5 on a scale of 1-5. From an interpretation standpoint, what is easier for a lay audience? Or is there some standard of practice in terms of reporting? </p>
36,204
[ -0.033804286271333694, -0.016762522980570793, 0.01109421718865633, 0.03688136115670204, 0.02760954387485981, 0.024164456874132156, 0.0025498622562736273, -0.026003923267126083, 0.003415378974750638, 0.0015436132671311498, 0.02214542031288147, 0.005436232779175043, 0.019642364233732224, -0.009088418446481228, -0.0030867750756442547, 0.011309321038424969, -0.007560153491795063, -0.013238699175417423, -0.03627057373523712, -0.024865025654435158, 0.016208916902542114, 0.018152650445699692, -0.013280906714498997, -0.024339891970157623, -0.005267942789942026, 0.03795722872018814, 0.05827012658119202, -0.0024078846909105778, 0.014338785782456398, 0.019779453054070473, -0.01260888110846281, -0.02483445405960083, 0.011681678704917431, -0.004461211618036032, 0.025112828239798546, 0.00487338425591588, 0.026998110115528107, -0.019223488867282867, 0.020879801362752914, 0.0430576354265213, -0.06402091681957245, 0.009359023533761501, -0.002804012503474951, -0.009290286339819431, -0.0075054350309073925, -0.0025256106164306402, -0.030656497925519943, -0.015096237882971764, 0.012000410817563534, -0.04827441647648811, 0.061873745173215866, 0.04266766831278801, 0.02982904762029648, 0.038029950112104416, -0.014178818091750145, -0.015262283384799957, 0.031638603657484055, 0.05912128463387489, 0.005692873615771532, -0.05620782822370529, -0.018179990351200104, -0.020463546738028526, 0.007190039847046137, 0.02120496891438961, -0.017548156902194023, 0.03197534382343292, 0.016559598967432976, -0.042649008333683014, 0.04889065399765968, 0.022939056158065796, 0.001564903766848147, 0.030686140060424805, 0.05477263033390045, -0.015181288123130798, 0.013948061503469944, -0.043364018201828, 0.002436667215079069, 0.010280069895088673, 0.03573997691273689, 0.05022137984633446, -0.023747041821479797, 0.003809463931247592, 0.013652580790221691, 0.0172245092689991, -0.012259671464562416, -0.002857700688764453, 0.07974410057067871, -0.03481551259756088, 0.020484616979956627, 0.053513891994953156, -0.02953512966632843, -0.01884506270289421, 0.039555057883262634, 0.01049407385289669, -0.018930617719888687, 0.054916996508836746, -0.03435366228222847, 0.03036900982260704, 0.02784140594303608, 0.014896251261234283, -0.020382817834615707, 0.0004323309985920787, 0.024861903861165047, 0.029537778347730637, -0.02148539572954178, -0.04649067297577858, -0.03327583521604538, 0.015332136303186417, 0.002461286261677742, -0.005310205277055502, 0.019168363884091377, 0.005079709459096193, 0.0061087640933692455, 0.007169007323682308, 0.044250812381505966, 0.0195884108543396, -0.009043602272868156, -0.017174744978547096, 0.050332654267549515, 0.052805107086896896, 0.04176679253578186, -0.017701853066682816, 0.025507930666208267, 0.010282222181558609, -0.03797101974487305, 0.023495294153690338, 0.006128459237515926, -0.02660704031586647, -0.0014170178910717368, 0.04231684282422066, -0.008388448506593704, 0.0075036813504993916, 0.07072483748197556, -0.003176958067342639, 0.04830582067370415, 0.004448231775313616, -0.06876033544540405, -0.051899928599596024, -0.013241303153336048, 0.021175559610128403, 0.009347786195576191, -0.05474473908543587, 0.0013194737257435918, 0.05706033855676651, 0.019350577145814896, 0.03737189993262291, 0.03412170708179474, -0.029627472162246704, 0.041484955698251724, 0.010932724922895432, -0.051838479936122894, -0.019434265792369843, -0.031122352927923203, -0.060851264744997025, -0.02525285817682743, -0.03625191003084183, 0.010841583833098412, 0.05433714762330055, 0.009373738430440426, -0.022941263392567635, 0.024326184764504433, -0.0037762036081403494, -0.018213380128145218, 0.02832666039466858, 0.06021571159362793, 0.03611091524362564, 0.046436190605163574, -0.05118739977478981, 0.010626718401908875, -0.001509642694145441, 0.0076530505903065205, 0.007806153502315283, 0.005866942927241325, 0.04984009638428688, 0.08484623581171036, 0.014195024035871029, -0.036035411059856415, -0.020771697163581848, 0.026031633839011192, 0.0041702017188072205, 0.010981041938066483, -0.004797691013664007, -0.04161791130900383, -0.0003481339372228831, 0.03118084743618965, 0.015573644079267979, -0.002144358353689313, -0.024238863959908485, 0.028325533494353294, -0.04813192039728165, -0.06262324005365372, -0.05732140690088272, 0.005622365511953831, 0.0024365726858377457, -0.026958953589200974, 0.03202499449253082, -0.04510483890771866, -0.016210591420531273, 0.016965145245194435, -0.000053199568355921656, 0.0008357058395631611, -0.017657671123743057, 0.025250017642974854, -0.07599938660860062, -0.016553685069084167, 0.06121442839503288, -0.02000490203499794, -0.027039386332035065, 0.034190643578767776, -0.04622999578714371, -0.06306391209363937, -0.015065416693687439, 0.008486533537507057, -0.015173929743468761, 0.004438865929841995, 0.02274501509964466, -0.04179072380065918, -0.005616449750959873, -0.03046383708715439, 0.03442467004060745, -0.05580199137330055, 0.10058411955833435, 0.07580839842557907, -0.0357915535569191, 0.00013990404841024429, 0.03602273762226105, 0.02005712129175663, 0.00039754839963279665, -0.02288132533431053, -0.036231204867362976, -0.09632737189531326, 0.009055466391146183, -0.012523285113275051, 0.0187201090157032, -0.04100998118519783, -0.0058257002383470535, 0.05661516636610031, 0.029064802452921867, 0.008563779294490814, 0.019433103501796722, -0.001690011122263968, -0.011823046021163464, 0.02268541418015957, -0.007458831649273634, 0.02578878588974476, 0.008914926089346409, -0.026913242414593697, 0.04490365460515022, -0.009683399461209774, 0.061026934534311295, 0.02300093322992325, 0.024379439651966095, 0.02939446084201336, 0.023838723078370094, -0.033043041825294495, 0.029724640771746635, 0.043416399508714676, -0.047921471297740936, 0.02464735507965088, 0.052094876766204834, -0.03642260283231735, -0.024403465911746025, 0.04488743096590042, 0.0047242711298167706, 0.011619017459452152, 0.05302019417285919, -0.03174712136387825, -0.032494377344846725, -0.00022736542450729758, -0.030891867354512215, -0.009380348026752472, -0.06428296118974686, -0.035935960710048676, -0.04451306536793709, 0.005488803144544363, 0.03458724915981293, -0.0038692366797477007, 0.00862027145922184, -0.02643982693552971, 0.029442837461829185, -0.013740458525717258, 0.02817843295633793, -0.00397978350520134, 0.04219747707247734, -0.03575596958398819, -0.024256505072116852, -0.006586333736777306, -0.01700412668287754, 0.022809455171227455, -0.028494615107774734, -0.0041685523465275764, 0.057792313396930695, 0.01752757839858532, -0.07848787307739258, -0.023427773267030716, -0.012950221076607704, 0.018212532624602318, 0.009761666879057884, -0.03392606973648071, 0.04102856665849686, 0.010359164327383041, -0.02298029512166977, 0.01714787259697914, -0.053602591156959534, -0.024529002606868744, -0.03882549703121185, -0.011374144814908504, 0.0073357936926186085, 0.02067955583333969, -0.0033423348795622587, -0.012811213731765747, -0.030424315482378006, 0.011318814940750599, -0.0840170755982399, -0.0715225413441658, 0.022150736302137375, 0.010895935818552971, 0.042557716369628906, 0.02635687217116356, 0.03105171211063862, 0.07906709611415863, 0.03448661416769028, 0.005395746324211359, -0.03668714314699173, 0.014997264370322227, -0.004165072459727526, 0.005748418625444174, 0.013020670041441917, 0.05148547887802124, 0.017195770516991615, 0.02568775974214077, -0.004822970367968082, 0.04015929624438286, 0.03688327968120575, 0.03159607946872711, -0.003927453421056271, 0.013145086355507374, 0.0287571270018816, 0.0013742210576310754, -0.0009450842626392841, 0.034953825175762177, -0.039755381643772125, -0.006089095491915941, -0.026511935517191887, 0.03743913397192955, 0.019517503678798676, -0.03113742172718048, 0.014219098724424839, -0.03275291994214058, -0.012525125406682491, 0.007729336619377136, 0.03833034262061119, 0.009678933769464493, 0.009023741818964481, -0.015421025454998016, 0.010128932073712349, 0.03895771875977516, -0.005970565136522055, 0.004443006590008736, 0.05132818967103958, 0.03020639345049858, -0.00748432194814086, -0.017960144206881523, 0.01982801966369152, -0.012122508138418198, 0.03131159022450447, -0.02954782545566559, -0.02023134008049965, 0.05394221097230911, 0.06684116274118423, 0.03765597566962242, -0.010626154951751232, -0.04571719840168953, 0.046955596655607224, -0.10819611698389053, -0.015557004138827324, -0.035166483372449875, 0.04311839118599892, 0.001145947608165443, 0.019535532221198082, 0.040878795087337494, 0.024431562051177025, -0.04067761078476906, 0.015255939215421677, -0.0581403449177742, 0.013598289340734482, -0.057006798684597015, 0.012385888025164604, -0.040878452360630035, 0.017331283539533615, 0.023980533704161644, 0.008796563372015953, -0.009422718547284603, -0.01276617031544447, 0.012757590040564537, -0.03244867920875549, 0.03554535284638405, 0.017737066373229027, 0.02386762574315071, -0.00011961183918174356, -0.008935769088566303, 0.00028701513656415045, -0.029669318348169327, 0.06494610756635666, 0.008361704647541046, 0.0309299249202013, -0.004227162804454565, -0.044945474714040756, -0.0028978099580854177, -0.007881475612521172, 0.05857521668076515, 0.012767885811626911, 0.012666162103414536, -0.05049221217632294, 0.046499695628881454, 0.017371509224176407, 0.043692249804735184, 0.023227479308843613, -0.03606721758842468, -0.0031321842689067125, -0.01123876590281725, -0.008653213270008564, -0.020044410601258278, 0.02460215613245964, -0.017712440341711044, 0.007482243236154318, 0.04917428269982338, -0.0026570106856524944, -0.027610601857304573, 0.042793892323970795, 0.01780817098915577, -0.012318064458668232, -0.010053372010588646, -0.0824398547410965, -0.0262453593313694, -0.019932013005018234, -0.005409739445894957, 0.029989279806613922, 0.05219435319304466, 0.0018675519386306405, -0.012200308963656425, 0.08845816552639008, -0.0016533606685698032, -0.06531231105327606, 0.0210997574031353, -0.018036339432001114, 0.01402813196182251, -0.016003020107746124, -0.022096559405326843, 0.02194923534989357, 0.05399593710899353, 0.05575616657733917, 0.009820322506129742, -0.011394243687391281, -0.07555507868528366, 0.0015576515579596162, 0.0035344024654477835, 0.02888304926455021, -0.03003043681383133, 0.0010232289787381887, -0.022322973236441612, -0.033815037459135056, 0.04718829691410065, -0.036573443561792374, 0.009075024165213108, -0.03047068975865841, 0.015317937359213829, -0.037347253412008286, -0.0010486310347914696, -0.02377091348171234, 0.023545045405626297, -0.02197517640888691, 0.026111120358109474, 0.01625492051243782, 0.0018788902088999748, -0.05260584503412247, 0.013743508607149124, 0.03233572095632553, 0.08186357468366623, 0.010681502521038055, -0.021219123154878616, -0.006137052550911903, 0.004910636227577925, -0.015039370395243168, -0.025260943919420242, 0.018367435783147812, -0.019626513123512268, -0.00037513062125071883, 0.037401169538497925, -0.013868151232600212, -0.01720467209815979, -0.014681891538202763, 0.021007267758250237, 0.002319389721378684, 0.016720104962587357, -0.03393145650625229, 0.06317906826734543, 0.006978954654186964, 0.015062853693962097, 0.03343123942613602, 0.05449830740690231, 0.0015828520990908146, 0.03771144151687622, -0.04623489826917648, -0.006168849766254425, -0.06396235525608063, -0.0074248346500098705, -0.015586137771606445, -0.0408569760620594, -0.015400714240968227, 0.031500719487667084, -0.008551258593797684, 0.04531543701887131, -0.03541835397481918, -0.013241047970950603, 0.0193865317851305, 0.00822612177580595, 0.022394584491848946, 0.01640257239341736, 0.000015985473510227166, 0.019952287897467613, 0.024527961388230324, -0.042368415743112564, 0.0174745824187994, -0.04704393446445465, 0.006546747405081987, 0.037991251796483994, -0.05094355717301369, 0.005098605528473854, -0.03579244762659073, -0.02995925024151802, -0.0008343888912349939, -0.03549419716000557, 0.03287474438548088, -0.036131877452135086, 0.019045274704694748, -0.007174030411988497, -0.03559793904423714, 0.003862514393404126, 0.017957564443349838, -0.03056330233812332, 0.035237912088632584, -0.05063469335436821, 0.04440368711948395, -0.02504662424325943, 0.0011515239020809531, -0.07994019985198975, -0.0477137565612793, 0.02053825743496418, -0.010671938769519329, -0.0073739890940487385, 0.028267228975892067, 0.015525142662227154, 0.003970591351389885, 0.0005232291296124458, -0.0191398523747921, 0.05169503018260002, -0.0250423364341259, -0.02095508761703968, -0.025329865515232086, 0.008156710304319859, 0.09786153584718704, -0.014108976349234581, -0.02621813490986824, 0.03702574968338013, -0.022373482584953308, -0.0027225546073168516, -0.025779137387871742, -0.013708564452826977, -0.05642082542181015, -0.025158492848277092, -0.04317612200975418, 0.014593880623579025, 0.03060251660645008, -0.01639576256275177, 0.0030772516038268805, 0.010182767175137997, -0.02695019170641899, 0.00860532931983471, -0.010221144184470177, -0.02518298290669918, -0.03556475415825844, -0.02726670540869236, -0.011987593956291676, 0.0006579720065928996, 0.001593640074133873, 0.011727292090654373, 0.013325365260243416, 0.02716907486319542, -0.016177469864487648, 0.01803683117032051, 0.03754249960184097, -0.0007762191817164421, 0.015682391822338104, 0.039035480469465256, -0.02457008883357048, 0.02587994374334812, 0.04302963241934776, -0.015951944515109062, 0.0006565016810782254, 0.044215839356184006, -0.03089023008942604, -0.033341728150844574, 0.012234671041369438, -0.0328529067337513, 0.055799826979637146, 0.0016365541378036141, 0.05646693333983421, 0.053246043622493744, -0.02389155514538288, -0.03478410094976425, -0.017209451645612717, 0.01348865870386362, -0.020830027759075165, 0.003226920962333679, 0.03926967829465866, -0.04282732307910919, 0.03707708790898323, -0.004241918679326773, 0.055967845022678375, 0.014081996865570545, 0.04543323442339897, 0.060162823647260666, 0.02145238034427166, 0.03527537360787392, -0.019205940887331963, -0.04539535194635391, 0.03811870142817497, -0.0455692782998085, -0.007952051237225533, 0.0015560727333649993, -0.039897602051496506, -0.011402335949242115, 0.003928081598132849, -0.03451415151357651, -0.06158965826034546, -0.004053435288369656, -0.009359613992273808, 0.01971869356930256, 0.02680249512195587, -0.004661554004997015, 0.024048084393143654, -0.032350774854421616, 0.012346398085355759, -0.004469656851142645, 0.03863292932510376, -0.020865118131041527, -0.05753277242183685, -0.03681155666708946, -0.002782343653962016, -0.05994543805718422, 0.004425385966897011, -0.00002078505167446565, 0.003040232229977846, 0.004223266616463661, -0.051492054015398026, -0.01160230953246355, 0.0017203703755512834, -0.004899985622614622, -0.011809158138930798, 0.04458307847380638, 0.03605012595653534, 0.010144099593162537, 0.007156126666814089, 0.042930036783218384, 0.11715025454759598, 0.04913190007209778, 0.03584685176610947, -0.030724016949534416, 0.04437186196446419, 0.013243303634226322, 0.010014832019805908, 0.025034939870238304, 0.009403320960700512, -0.023964114487171173, -0.004807708319276571, 0.013869250193238258, 0.06853921711444855, 0.018739361315965652, -0.013777444139122963, 0.04639306291937828, -0.013285638764500618, -0.015047958120703697, -0.0031845360063016415, 0.02979899011552334, 0.02613508701324463, -0.010120585560798645, -0.06734482198953629, -0.006478261202573776, 0.0471755675971508, -0.04848257824778557, 0.01660940609872341, -0.0034890775568783283, -0.024309858679771423, 0.026734216138720512, -0.026823172345757484, 0.05533241108059883, 0.03260417655110359, -0.013894562609493732, -0.010369103401899338, 0.0044331662356853485, 0.0353209525346756, -0.026234447956085205, -0.015193412080407143, 0.05164572224020958, -0.030859380960464478, -0.006852385587990284, 0.02653534896671772, 0.06443452835083008, -0.04577554389834404, -0.028611304238438606, -0.024975864216685295, -0.012188253924250603, -0.0022560078650712967, 0.004048783332109451, -0.004108552820980549, 0.006251156330108643, -0.045706406235694885, -0.07161302119493484, -0.029287461191415787, 0.029941929504275322, 0.01784570887684822, 0.002916427794843912, -0.043597158044576645, -0.013866850174963474, 0.0066264658235013485, -0.0157153382897377, 0.024219051003456116, 0.049400679767131805, -0.016604244709014893, -0.029173653572797775, -0.046196501702070236, 0.016175538301467896, 0.00855557806789875, -0.006635074503719807, 0.04871493950486183, 0.02082456834614277, -0.06327314674854279, 0.014528544619679451, -0.04871055856347084, -0.00025299008120782673, 0.059649862349033356, -0.018267573788762093, -0.008528542704880238, -0.029296664521098137, -0.036729831248521805, -0.018981926143169403, -0.021447133272886276, -0.0030238016042858362, -0.06329865008592606, -0.041231974959373474, 0.012159451842308044, -0.016127582639455795, -0.03557164967060089, 0.003313101828098297, 0.0006926205242052674, 0.07321938872337341, -0.0007074066670611501, -0.032257143408060074, 0.012601490132510662, -0.009960010647773743, -0.05718497559428215, 0.0016948932316154242, 0.0037063134368509054, 0.06777264177799225, 0.022281011566519737, -0.028171146288514137, -0.007672579027712345, 0.03673764318227768, 0.02071780152618885, 0.0003817098040599376, 0.01970636285841465, -0.0313805490732193, -0.012008536607027054, -0.006140486802905798, 0.009097179397940636, -0.01086448971182108, -0.011160575784742832, -0.07407502830028534, -0.05090734362602234, 0.012946275062859058, -0.025475366041064262, 0.006432069465517998, 0.021212080493569374, -0.01176565419882536, 0.012804576195776463, 0.009287049062550068, -0.05801413953304291, -0.04203321039676666, -0.02050967700779438, 0.014518631622195244, -0.00952297542244196, 0.004949931055307388, 0.01091751642525196, -0.02495580166578293, 0.03550191596150398, 0.03636917471885681, -0.005928732920438051, -0.007005045656114817, 0.005514098331332207, -0.0040432969108223915, -0.01243418175727129, 0.06630329042673111, -0.01965956576168537, -0.015736056491732597, 0.02924428880214691, -0.049299437552690506, -0.013628150336444378, 0.009386150166392326, 0.011977040208876133, 0.006021477282047272, -0.004782944917678833, -0.020662279799580574, -0.03165517747402191, 0.0291057750582695, -0.037780310958623886, -0.021959692239761353, -0.010919318534433842, 0.00806739367544651, 0.0028721909038722515, -0.008262621238827705, -0.04344600811600685, 0.026662461459636688, 0.02382531389594078, 0.02627583220601082, 0.02811584249138832, 0.018642058596014977, -0.003910377621650696, 0.00842411257326603, 0.003518044715747237, -0.0071753934025764465, -0.02521410584449768, -0.002998007694259286, 0.01508262101560831, 0.028511179611086845, -0.05760715529322624, 0.009923513047397137, -0.010535696521401405, 0.003034010762348771, -0.0551028735935688, -0.001954522216692567, -0.005978054367005825, -0.009311402216553688, 0.0028737070970237255, -0.047832753509283066, 0.010682855732738972, 0.0006655578617937863, -0.03596528246998787, -0.0066060395911335945, -0.06186194717884064, -0.047124233096838, -0.0558619387447834, -0.008720621466636658, 0.01035202294588089, 0.01744440384209156, 0.04082141071557999, 0.009515303187072277, -0.013847013004124165, 0.003593576606363058, -0.004434201866388321, -0.021801255643367767, 0.002968583954498172, 0.0477682426571846, 0.014804705046117306, -0.08132904767990112, 0.019498035311698914, -0.014938117004930973, -0.040412429720163345, 0.06868091225624084, -0.003580436808988452, 0.014560943469405174, 0.01090296171605587, 0.033329084515571594, -0.013190671801567078, 0.05648788809776306, 0.01785501465201378, -0.009131540544331074, -0.016505494713783264, -0.008436006493866444, 0.00985514372587204, 0.016393430531024933, -0.02098979987204075, 0.029413912445306778, 0.06741219013929367, -0.010744119994342327, 0.023780079558491707, -0.00958162173628807, -0.0027083009481430054, -0.0479779914021492, -0.038200341165065765, -0.035751841962337494, 0.06207778677344322, -0.049142591655254364, 0.01733076386153698, -0.04810004681348801, -0.016692642122507095, 0.03665240481495857, -0.006128233857452869, -0.009684599936008453, 0.00676797516644001, 0.009492103010416031, -0.007114356849342585, -0.004311877768486738, 0.0099681681022048, 0.011857261881232262, -0.04144587740302086, -0.034811247140169144, -0.021353473886847496, 0.03183829411864281, -0.012297146953642368, -0.005856440402567387, 0.015558984130620956, 0.013820544816553593, -0.03684278205037117, 0.01653636060655117, 0.006144136190414429, -0.010892253369092941, 0.018639719113707542, -0.05043783038854599, 0.03441273793578148, 0.034760329872369766, 0.009248681366443634, -0.021923398599028587, 0.011134388856589794, -0.025217030197381973, 0.018137561157345772, 0.06173248961567879, 0.014220906421542168, -0.025772700086236, -0.01954963244497776, 0.014188212342560291, 0.0006890982040204108, -0.04831082373857498, 0.03289065510034561, 0.021146677434444427, -0.010890128090977669, 0.030468307435512543, 0.027476821094751358, 0.0012471475638449192, -0.015470070764422417, 0.01819307915866375, 0.008169981651008129, 0.03165630251169205, -0.007553786505013704, 0.006965870503336191, 0.014322667382657528, 0.0448673740029335, -0.040974557399749756, 0.04653129726648331, -0.03327225148677826, 0.009347628802061081, 0.04892446845769882, 0.02519257552921772, -0.03306732699275017, 0.03509550914168358, -0.021620722487568855, -0.020467037335038185, 0.03468557447195053, 0.011103049851953983, -0.014508777298033237, -0.06593044102191925, -0.03398113697767258, 0.019452910870313644, -0.04372059553861618, -0.017826180905103683, 0.029877185821533203, 0.012009530328214169, 0.0439404733479023, -0.013505860231816769, -0.008298499509692192, 0.015394546091556549, -0.01686241291463375, 0.0006362118292599916, -0.006009536329656839, 0.04915645346045494, 0.04773368313908577, 0.017309363931417465, 0.00550719304010272, -0.06357195973396301, -0.0068379612639546394, 0.006056864745914936, 0.0514342300593853, -0.009350137785077095, -0.007507902104407549, 0.00010202755947830155, -0.004010513890534639, 0.01730610989034176, 0.048319682478904724, -0.006813010200858116, 0.033118993043899536, 0.005979706533253193, 0.005231908988207579, -0.05144893378019333, -0.02724667638540268, -0.02014670893549919, 0.02786785550415516, 0.009238027036190033, 0.015032890252768993, 0.027721690014004707, 0.007978607900440693, -0.015142819844186306, -0.00799061730504036, 0.04016777500510216, -0.034336842596530914, 0.01990903727710247, -0.031614039093256, 0.025903893634676933, -0.033262718468904495, -0.031244978308677673, -0.0231087114661932, 0.012831774540245533, 0.01646483689546585, 0.0023634780663996935, 0.022362740710377693, -0.04270189255475998, -0.027470655739307404, -0.010557375848293304, 0.006282386835664511, -0.03551356494426727, -0.050286535173654556, -0.035896316170692444, -0.021665383130311966, 0.024839583784341812, -0.02327973023056984 ]
<p>Near the middle of page 16 of Andrew Ng's <a href="http://cs229.stanford.edu/notes/cs229-notes3.pdf" rel="nofollow">notes on SVM</a>, he explained an intuitive view of kernel as measuring similarity between observations, but then added the caveat that</p> <blockquote> <p>there are things wrong with this intuition, but nevermind</p> </blockquote> <p>The notes don't really explain what's wrong with this intuition. Does anyone know what he might be referring to?</p>
74,369
[ -0.017534995451569557, -0.004901342559605837, -0.008477883413434029, 0.0004895450547337532, 0.012533208355307579, 0.006226058583706617, 0.016119973734021187, 0.02767314203083515, 0.0442153662443161, 0.008908301591873169, 0.0020948436576873064, 0.023722918704152107, 0.05629407614469528, 0.01104633416980505, 0.008147239685058594, 0.019261233508586884, -0.01810421235859394, -0.0032418060582131147, 0.018562322482466698, -0.013630249537527561, -0.012972582131624222, 0.046398721635341644, 0.014048987999558449, -0.005749973468482494, -0.013390449807047844, 0.03124549798667431, -0.01708347164094448, -0.02876836434006691, 0.038228925317525864, 0.007554320152848959, -0.051238492131233215, -0.028322424739599228, 0.016980741173028946, 0.019681381061673164, 0.03699837997555733, -0.0022577897179871798, -0.021164685487747192, -0.004594836849719286, 0.013591274619102478, 0.028494808822870255, -0.004029349889606237, -0.0031269416213035583, -0.001847894280217588, 0.06250853091478348, -0.026767248287796974, 0.024503208696842194, -0.007780765648931265, -0.010710272938013077, 0.009323956444859505, -0.012300808914005756, 0.06102489307522774, -0.0274333618581295, 0.007097756955772638, 0.04918293654918671, -0.02577870339155197, 0.03707026690244675, 0.05117575451731682, 0.06717456877231598, -0.03565768525004387, -0.04387591779232025, -0.009675614535808563, -0.031610023230314255, -0.001201361883431673, -0.02689282037317753, -0.006060399115085602, 0.047472063452005386, -0.014642734080553055, -0.02854391187429428, 0.0335686169564724, -0.013379841111600399, -0.006044719368219376, 0.025370098650455475, 0.022183740511536598, 0.013777939602732658, 0.026375513523817062, -0.015814023092389107, 0.013136015273630619, 0.015671033412218094, 0.06545926630496979, 0.016964638605713844, 0.027738863602280617, 0.02021925151348114, 0.017068849876523018, 0.02100040391087532, 0.03310824930667877, 0.0074750157073140144, 0.06512026488780975, -0.02506275288760662, -0.0013508101692423224, 0.07841598987579346, -0.019131649285554886, 0.036389220505952835, 0.01001725159585476, -0.02752578817307949, -0.04899660497903824, 0.02813725173473358, -0.008075078949332237, 0.006629465147852898, 0.0027653274592012167, -0.014457086101174355, -0.00937346275895834, -0.017078513279557228, 0.009779899381101131, 0.03000425547361374, -0.032349102199077606, -0.02948845736682415, -0.05620044097304344, 0.02940322458744049, 0.02350601740181446, -0.020945634692907333, -0.03269379958510399, 0.005019618663936853, 0.0027990243397653103, 0.04287610575556755, 0.029988236725330353, -0.0013992851600050926, -0.013777198269963264, 0.0014406880363821983, 0.03231804072856903, 0.028360191732645035, 0.02823539450764656, -0.03265495225787163, 0.012904984876513481, -0.03870246559381485, -0.03922566398978233, 0.04971824958920479, 0.04136190563440323, -0.050495147705078125, -0.022045129910111427, 0.03879376873373985, -0.0015639237826690078, -0.009756944142282009, -0.004533447790890932, -0.018112443387508392, 0.016841672360897064, -0.00870269164443016, -0.09812559187412262, -0.04618815332651138, 0.04625139757990837, -0.010272071696817875, 0.0027092930395156145, -0.07649395614862442, 0.0022931115236133337, 0.019622085615992546, 0.0654628723859787, 0.0029847733676433563, 0.0022979583591222763, -0.0005593113601207733, 0.014440760016441345, -0.004112797789275646, -0.039145566523075104, -0.034207768738269806, -0.012196688912808895, -0.03485773131251335, -0.04110860079526901, -0.029556065797805786, 0.011363890953361988, 0.02153647318482399, -0.005787331610918045, 0.004259349778294563, -0.014377633109688759, -0.020143559202551842, -0.005561815109103918, -0.0075736744329333305, 0.00557170482352376, -0.04505961388349533, 0.05275770276784897, 0.011483795940876007, 0.044692933559417725, 0.07173505425453186, -0.036280177533626556, 0.02480039931833744, 0.015232806093990803, 0.016161585226655006, 0.07378923147916794, 0.007849463261663914, -0.013752712868154049, -0.038514431565999985, 0.03885309770703316, 0.014517037197947502, -0.06409543007612228, -0.041832756251096725, -0.0022644612472504377, 0.04648208245635033, 0.01828344352543354, 0.042671333998441696, -0.015721451491117477, -0.029974315315485, 0.003941118251532316, -0.034920934587717056, -0.056181833148002625, -0.06473874300718307, 0.0273501668125391, -0.01587170921266079, -0.0017314417054876685, 0.06175372377038002, -0.011518814601004124, -0.01904914714396, -0.03986690938472748, -0.020504819229245186, -0.001239040051586926, -0.02768728882074356, 0.02950643189251423, -0.05422697961330414, -0.020716259256005287, 0.06663485616445541, 0.017002440989017487, -0.023292401805520058, 0.05945296958088875, -0.028710931539535522, -0.04582016170024872, 0.041794855147600174, 0.015637721866369247, -0.0011066136648878455, -0.010297408327460289, 0.0030824372079223394, 0.03935921937227249, 0.009965742006897926, -0.041743241250514984, 0.010697823949158192, -0.06734856963157654, 0.03570069372653961, 0.03980793431401253, 0.04056838899850845, -0.021398521959781647, 0.015210493467748165, 0.010334780439734459, 0.009770088829100132, 0.00750212324783206, -0.009829617105424404, -0.049845751374959946, -0.008450115099549294, 0.04975377023220062, 0.057245928794145584, -0.022736819460988045, 0.0312667153775692, 0.06654774397611618, 0.04502864554524422, -0.02914867363870144, 0.006704755127429962, 0.005294617731124163, -0.00036687313695438206, 0.03173361346125603, -0.0008873564074747264, 0.0005087708705104887, -0.00826488621532917, 0.009575779549777508, 0.0022595971822738647, 0.05039643868803978, 0.021613366901874542, -0.04737424850463867, 0.039967816323041916, -0.0024112407118082047, 0.03442168980836868, 0.00011811560398200527, 0.009333492256700993, 0.039166949689388275, -0.023986002430319786, -0.010587608441710472, 0.04402654990553856, 0.002640689956024289, 0.017362115904688835, -0.00854094885289669, -0.011895583011209965, -0.0024622941855341196, 0.043288830667734146, -0.04163424298167229, 0.014975489117205143, 0.015269843861460686, -0.07109682261943817, 0.008786714635789394, -0.014418493025004864, -0.024846097454428673, -0.01685219816863537, 0.03021625056862831, 0.05228717252612114, -0.013335558585822582, 0.02987794205546379, -0.03590763360261917, -0.019847465679049492, -0.013795274309813976, -0.03698413819074631, 0.015572291798889637, 0.0017318704631179571, -0.07449988275766373, -0.0028636062052100897, -0.013751393184065819, -0.01971624419093132, 0.029400082305073738, -0.010735709220170975, 0.01428249478340149, -0.02202598564326763, -0.012574225664138794, -0.038175541907548904, 0.006250700447708368, -0.044705457985401154, 0.014419280923902988, -0.016500912606716156, -0.035011135041713715, 0.042997200042009354, -0.007330685388296843, -0.05236709490418434, 0.035644736140966415, 0.005216030869632959, -0.06554950028657913, 0.00039824447594583035, -0.02768990397453308, 0.014694794081151485, -0.029940595850348473, 0.028515757992863655, 0.029459571465849876, -0.016595400869846344, 0.0010665868176147342, -0.05170682817697525, -0.07930516451597214, 0.04274839907884598, 0.004822917282581329, 0.03662016987800598, 0.04065840318799019, -0.004551614169031382, 0.12007401883602142, -0.010603233240544796, -0.016429712995886803, -0.04993170127272606, 0.009264787659049034, -0.06771955639123917, 0.017451530322432518, 0.0021428195759654045, 0.010568981058895588, 0.037619803100824356, 0.03122902847826481, -0.006682012230157852, 0.029319502413272858, 0.05380156263709068, -0.03006150759756565, -0.018886644393205643, 0.03565133363008499, -0.010585581883788109, -0.022060075774788857, 0.02175651118159294, 0.015100621618330479, -0.03924986720085144, -0.016139334067702293, 0.025517627596855164, -0.005396478809416294, -0.0051315901800990105, -0.004668959882110357, 0.06665930896997452, -0.01345838699489832, 0.000057614961406216025, -0.026289161294698715, 0.020609179511666298, 0.02433512546122074, -0.02691514603793621, 0.0004535173356998712, 0.04151621833443642, 0.04395192861557007, -0.056863315403461456, -0.007735025137662888, 0.04942109063267708, 0.0012329679448157549, 0.009443869814276695, -0.005624606739729643, -0.018446940928697586, -0.024131562560796738, 0.025534214451909065, -0.005705524701625109, 0.006831506732851267, 0.050622813403606415, 0.043686386197805405, -0.024490024894475937, 0.010482804849743843, -0.059167515486478806, 0.02054254338145256, -0.057967659085989, -0.01619662158191204, -0.012691277079284191, 0.04245781525969505, 0.0010237331734970212, 0.0358160175383091, 0.04644830897450447, -0.02054346352815628, 0.02517940290272236, 0.011432277038693428, -0.055803898721933365, -0.027127141132950783, -0.009601546451449394, -0.013008722104132175, -0.009867480024695396, -0.04120900481939316, 0.030792489647865295, -0.020075585693120956, 0.02783919684588909, -0.02571089193224907, 0.011637868359684944, -0.020046358928084373, 0.006358674727380276, -0.009766998700797558, -0.006913963705301285, 0.012216291390359402, -0.048108696937561035, 0.046961624175310135, -0.020079392939805984, -0.0014741948107257485, 0.04037197679281235, -0.02840461954474449, -0.02388823591172695, -0.030560847371816635, 0.023733370006084442, 0.018112219870090485, 0.017434900626540184, -0.0019786919001489878, 0.0437983013689518, -0.03137299790978432, 0.02901981957256794, -0.01126870047301054, 0.060214877128601074, 0.04050733521580696, -0.040833089500665665, -0.03852641209959984, -0.02017694152891636, -0.0452147051692009, 0.013285156339406967, 0.0462321974337101, -0.0027888191398233175, 0.042756542563438416, 0.03794519230723381, 0.012578682042658329, -0.044246189296245575, 0.0017374209128320217, 0.03268541768193245, 0.04277479276061058, -0.03047279641032219, -0.049292489886283875, 0.020023619756102562, -0.0038816677406430244, -0.019174914807081223, 0.012493858113884926, 0.00935827661305666, -0.03881692513823509, -0.044982828199863434, 0.020355558022856712, -0.04803796857595444, -0.04885363206267357, 0.007385717239230871, -0.0008647359209135175, -0.004938337951898575, -0.02781149186193943, -0.0032403820659965277, 0.01567288115620613, 0.06036444380879402, 0.06476190686225891, 0.044992197304964066, -0.025424346327781677, -0.07105416059494019, -0.02384774759411812, 0.08468970656394958, -0.007142847869545221, -0.014435852877795696, -0.03108096495270729, -0.040318652987480164, -0.020502198487520218, 0.004363468382507563, -0.011763248592615128, 0.04675256088376045, -0.051231786608695984, -0.017634300515055656, -0.06144281476736069, -0.03205377981066704, -0.02856629528105259, 0.02893586829304695, 0.005114549305289984, 0.06194116920232773, -0.03912986069917679, -0.04254104569554329, -0.08368882536888123, -0.005770802963525057, -0.009574053809046745, 0.02759895659983158, -0.005034864414483309, -0.05497974157333374, 0.005426414776593447, 0.038362082093954086, -0.00820831023156643, -0.07532207667827606, 0.006238359492272139, 0.011765765957534313, -0.026754990220069885, 0.01991317979991436, -0.022996630519628525, -0.06131039932370186, 0.024966007098555565, 0.0163878221064806, -0.0134738739579916, -0.013410289771854877, -0.030844680964946747, 0.0427989661693573, 0.06328937411308289, 0.029459239915013313, 0.04607829451560974, -0.008662121370434761, -0.01331060379743576, 0.009976785629987717, -0.04264974221587181, 0.0090165501460433, -0.04195552319288254, -0.008061658591032028, -0.03569437190890312, -0.031558554619550705, -0.02418704144656658, 0.024014340713620186, 0.059638574719429016, 0.04532324895262718, -0.03720983862876892, -0.03748394176363945, 0.007551996037364006, -0.029939834028482437, 0.007207229733467102, -0.010042088106274605, -0.013523037545382977, 0.03464959189295769, 0.012835764326155186, 0.0014113598736003041, -0.016187231987714767, -0.007423568982630968, 0.022569013759493828, 0.06406088173389435, -0.03041391633450985, 0.006681718863546848, -0.047761186957359314, -0.03109900839626789, 0.0483524426817894, -0.012955477461218834, 0.026199640706181526, -0.018343517556786537, 0.027675138786435127, 0.02404692769050598, -0.01403716579079628, -0.03267168253660202, -0.005566846113651991, -0.0161431897431612, 0.03404957428574562, -0.036809105426073074, 0.053815148770809174, 0.0312671884894371, -0.028485208749771118, -0.06968658417463303, -0.009700307622551918, 0.041658442467451096, -0.023224318400025368, -0.03531850874423981, -0.044601064175367355, -0.010593263432383537, 0.012790799140930176, -0.04456884786486626, -0.0006015777471475303, 0.03984597325325012, -0.027121422812342644, -0.03753954917192459, 0.0129191679880023, 0.004097080789506435, 0.07842601835727692, -0.019223222509026527, 0.01252302061766386, 0.02217005379498005, -0.015362097881734371, -0.008712622337043285, 0.050426557660102844, 0.02982182987034321, -0.02158750593662262, 0.0034972657449543476, -0.030169451609253883, 0.003044232726097107, 0.055511921644210815, -0.0012094207340851426, 0.0030766513664275408, 0.018722329288721085, -0.04751354455947876, 0.01627855934202671, -0.014625425450503826, 0.03781609982252121, -0.01203339733183384, 0.008540812879800797, -0.0014343089424073696, -0.021551726385951042, 0.006895118393003941, -0.016686586663126945, 0.04667101427912712, 0.016830140724778175, 0.0063470411114394665, 0.013643554411828518, 0.056700412184000015, -0.020178377628326416, 0.02252502366900444, 0.006982802879065275, -0.007188786752521992, 0.03868343308568001, 0.008055636659264565, 0.030256038531661034, -0.01620515249669552, 0.0335860438644886, -0.03907490149140358, -0.01837253011763096, -0.022969329729676247, -0.007570967078208923, 0.04200762137770653, -0.022343534976243973, 0.06982379406690598, 0.026717914268374443, -0.02292412519454956, 0.011095072142779827, -0.00034285581205040216, 0.017407812178134918, -0.046349961310625076, -0.008414984680712223, 0.04243423417210579, -0.028662828728556633, -0.007240808103233576, 0.05244319140911102, 0.028593270108103752, 0.01041320152580738, -0.009391533210873604, -0.0013360223965719342, 0.011829107999801636, 0.054243918508291245, 0.0043154614977538586, -0.04897149279713631, 0.05097002908587456, -0.034449346363544464, 0.005057419650256634, 0.0012599141336977482, 0.0005820629885420203, 0.05929461121559143, 0.0042604417540133, 0.01574634574353695, -0.046377554535865784, -0.0368422195315361, -0.005291889421641827, -0.008207648992538452, 0.029137970879673958, -0.017594316974282265, 0.03674370422959328, 0.027559874579310417, 0.021908875554800034, 0.022128835320472717, -0.007680555339902639, -0.01897047460079193, -0.062463853508234024, -0.041124291718006134, -0.03808720037341118, -0.013472924940288067, 0.009063942357897758, 0.012829862534999847, -0.055129069834947586, -0.0019088201224803925, 0.005555193871259689, 0.02873302809894085, 0.0010674394434317946, 0.050315868109464645, -0.012936601415276527, 0.06259395182132721, -0.00469982298091054, 0.019677655771374702, -0.04596545547246933, -0.02006593719124794, 0.11878719925880432, 0.06230475381016731, 0.02159297838807106, -0.0667218342423439, 0.024327494204044342, -0.023342065513134003, -0.02817998081445694, -0.002932273782789707, 0.005521454382687807, 0.015145683661103249, 0.027735356241464615, 0.02978464961051941, 0.013135163113474846, 0.03209204971790314, -0.011682942509651184, 0.043483197689056396, -0.018848003819584846, 0.002528785727918148, 0.010890671983361244, 0.003972159698605537, 0.017556054517626762, -0.037150248885154724, -0.05315866321325302, 0.013974763453006744, 0.022712474688887596, -0.007780167739838362, 0.00218247901648283, -0.04133232310414314, 0.014305698685348034, 0.013890717178583145, 0.01187503058463335, 0.01141970232129097, 0.019380459561944008, -0.026330171152949333, -0.0005061982083134353, 0.0031603481620550156, 0.023728113621473312, -0.0033047699835151434, 0.047014057636260986, 0.01820148527622223, 0.038343895226716995, -0.01758287288248539, 0.0005993100930936635, 0.0103656817227602, -0.01672070287168026, -0.03634168952703476, -0.001254330389201641, 0.06297633796930313, 0.04106529429554939, -0.0052504935301840305, 0.00631176820024848, 0.00014488860324490815, -0.012537903152406216, -0.06251610070466995, 0.01486063003540039, 0.010289972648024559, 0.03405935317277908, -0.026103749871253967, -0.0325067900121212, -0.01405355054885149, 0.016567761078476906, -0.023175960406661034, 0.03345242142677307, 0.004860798828303814, -0.0377315953373909, -0.0034534039441496134, -0.015986723825335503, 0.036005083471536636, -0.024285396561026573, -0.02609921805560589, -0.009566345252096653, -0.03574399650096893, -0.018352096900343895, -0.029895083978772163, -0.00786230992525816, -0.009183524176478386, 0.018462294712662697, -0.0055062780156731606, -0.004063643980771303, -0.03753749281167984, -0.04952901974320412, 0.02940005250275135, -0.021633939817547798, 0.003261629957705736, -0.016488661989569664, 0.03535015881061554, 0.019870758056640625, 0.03031291626393795, -0.004484477452933788, 0.003364158095791936, 0.03993804752826691, 0.049049172550439835, 0.008146606385707855, -0.020354650914669037, -0.002590464660897851, -0.013445264659821987, -0.031750813126564026, 0.017233766615390778, 0.0018912525847554207, 0.015720410272479057, 0.04682747274637222, 0.010817092843353748, 0.013482057489454746, 0.014051239937543869, -0.003326485399156809, -0.0025698912795633078, -0.025482678785920143, -0.03150281682610512, -0.012284738011658192, 0.004442932084202766, 0.011450047604739666, -0.06771822273731232, -0.026054956018924713, -0.026265829801559448, -0.015152879059314728, -0.02024073153734207, -0.00358949089422822, -0.028668785467743874, -0.01187206618487835, 0.024171030148863792, 0.04082752391695976, -0.013398319482803345, -0.02906201034784317, -0.02940136007964611, 0.0020969207398593426, -0.02935189940035343, -0.015805235132575035, 0.0033338607754558325, 0.011233680881559849, 0.02793402224779129, 0.003732192562893033, 0.05587844178080559, 0.020775295794010162, 0.008893669582903385, -0.012427684850990772, -0.0017632248345762491, -0.033930446952581406, 0.02492360584437847, -0.0481872595846653, -0.00328355235978961, 0.03936997428536415, -0.03322051465511322, -0.04058865085244179, 0.052505362778902054, -0.03498545289039612, -0.006912888493388891, -0.02627445198595524, -0.0019421700853854418, -0.032162390649318695, 0.027990596368908882, -0.023687591776251793, 0.00002159095492970664, -0.019586915150284767, -0.006242595613002777, -0.011738566681742668, -0.02570740319788456, 0.007902000099420547, -0.013514379970729351, -0.019646046683192253, 0.004482342395931482, 0.03386644646525383, -0.012364284135401249, -0.02164246328175068, 0.01142033375799656, -0.013475684449076653, -0.0032423529773950577, -0.0264076329767704, 0.020759528502821922, 0.0810384750366211, 0.006442680489271879, -0.04789608344435692, -0.010988941416144371, -0.021965736523270607, 0.004544077441096306, -0.0719517320394516, -0.013717243447899818, 0.008955519646406174, 0.018268369138240814, 0.027517614886164665, -0.0756414458155632, 0.010834744200110435, 0.0072688446380198, -0.08209900557994843, 0.024002062156796455, 0.0199259165674448, -0.03931931033730507, -0.028846196830272675, 0.036599114537239075, -0.027094349265098572, 0.025050422176718712, 0.035247184336185455, 0.01742350123822689, 0.010087420232594013, 0.0036513982340693474, -0.00721300533041358, -0.008342339657247066, -0.037869080901145935, 0.05176927521824837, -0.02172442153096199, -0.04454546794295311, 0.04112083464860916, -0.026840150356292725, -0.03283854201436043, 0.03967510163784027, -0.009957457892596722, -0.0020036688074469566, 0.08038203418254852, 0.01969606801867485, 0.021695038303732872, 0.021999593824148178, 0.024094805121421814, -0.005930377636104822, -0.03899849206209183, -0.031064951792359352, 0.02322705090045929, 0.04143444821238518, -0.005412409082055092, -0.008716857992112637, 0.012233337387442589, -0.009587079286575317, -0.01713644154369831, 0.005751556716859341, -0.037354715168476105, -0.01771804690361023, 0.014635656028985977, 0.016065897420048714, -0.026787199079990387, -0.008089203387498856, 0.04339182749390602, -0.037424471229314804, -0.04126882180571556, 0.018038693815469742, 0.032348789274692535, -0.012269014492630959, 0.0063950130715966225, -0.01824013888835907, -0.03993766009807587, 0.018269473686814308, 0.0245650727301836, 0.005238575395196676, -0.05230705812573433, 0.000603709660936147, 0.019206738099455833, -0.015258685685694218, 0.002672962611541152, -0.035599350929260254, -0.06125815212726593, 0.06002698838710785, 0.025211498141288757, 0.01076850388199091, 0.04258549213409424, -0.014277182519435883, 0.017397508025169373, -0.0939674824476242, 0.05133293196558952, 0.02841670624911785, -0.017971554771065712, -0.02382132038474083, -0.007973569445312023, 0.005165054462850094, -0.003921241965144873, 0.04436090961098671, 0.004236397333443165, -0.006559877656400204, -0.006475139409303665, -0.005123261362314224, 0.024316860362887383, -0.023661773651838303, 0.030639471486210823, -0.04189835116267204, -0.014748962596058846, 0.021346237510442734, -0.03741517663002014, -0.019961144775152206, -0.012312855571508408, 0.047286417335271835, 0.003053835825994611, -0.003512580180540681, -0.015516639687120914, -0.00888067577034235, 0.027290545403957367, 0.027113545686006546, 0.0026013816241174936, 0.026359235867857933, 0.004763796925544739, 0.0020369801204651594, 0.007693286053836346, 0.01656927540898323, -0.07285052537918091, 0.024634694680571556, -0.017595475539565086, -0.03461775183677673, 0.0025053597055375576, 0.009758027270436287, 0.03650177642703056, -0.007870395667850971, -0.06648509204387665, 0.04942529648542404, -0.03442871943116188, -0.00954731460660696, 0.030588293448090553, 0.014588749036192894, 0.040303412824869156, 0.028182849287986755, 0.02429841458797455, 0.00768062612041831, -0.020233148708939552, 0.010083125904202461, 0.027358507737517357, 0.026296431198716164, 0.029869703575968742, 0.007708151824772358, -0.004947819747030735, -0.0038237781263887882, 0.03032320737838745, -0.009375215508043766, 0.05211327224969864, -0.045604314655065536, -0.03016204759478569, -0.021054742857813835, -0.0032055547926574945, 0.0062127443961799145, 0.027120443060994148, -0.008042486384510994, 0.09222692996263504, -0.026127342134714127, 0.014448288828134537, -0.0344177708029747, 0.02373785339295864, -0.03128774091601372, 0.03443669527769089, 0.05577335134148598, 0.029702449217438698, 0.010318642482161522, 0.011582592502236366, 0.010472668334841728, 0.015302108600735664, 0.018006891012191772, -0.02988569624722004, -0.015978563576936722, -0.02287791669368744, 0.01652221754193306, 0.03022204153239727, -0.011706502176821232, -0.0032077115029096603, 0.013711861334741116, 0.03282579034566879, 0.050732869654893875, 0.03623131290078163, 0.021519741043448448, -0.028496984392404556, -0.006259265821427107, 0.02794788032770157, -0.11917070299386978, -0.02510872669517994, -0.029123106971383095, 0.023182624951004982, 0.01151613611727953, -0.028593450784683228 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/26650/how-do-i-reference-a-regression-models-coefficients-standard-errors">How do I reference a regression model&#39;s coefficient&#39;s standard errors?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>If I have a dataset:</p> <pre><code>data = data.frame(xdata = 1:10,ydata = 6:15) </code></pre> <p>and I run a linear regression:</p> <pre><code>fit = lm(ydata~.,data = data) out = summary(fit) Call: lm(formula = ydata ~ ., data = data) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -5.661e-16 -1.157e-16 4.273e-17 2.153e-16 4.167e-16 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 5.000e+00 2.458e-16 2.035e+16 &lt;2e-16 *** xdata 1.000e+00 3.961e-17 2.525e+16 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 3.598e-16 on 8 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 1, Adjusted R-squared: 1 F-statistic: 6.374e+32 on 1 and 8 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 </code></pre> <p>How do I extract the standard errors of the regression coefficients from either fit or out? I can't seem to figure it out. Thanks!</p>
49,930
[ -0.04663165658712387, 0.029802050441503525, -0.02597465179860592, 0.0017105136066675186, 0.014433087781071663, 0.02290811948478222, 0.0079953009262681, -0.014651649631559849, 0.02586434967815876, -0.016448894515633583, 0.038734037429094315, 0.029716582968831062, 0.06370846182107925, -0.011408920399844646, 0.040805574506521225, 0.0288732647895813, 0.022306594997644424, -0.000798783206846565, 0.025628915056586266, -0.019128894433379173, -0.013568954542279243, 0.011304225772619247, -0.006879511289298534, 0.013093214482069016, 0.0007074702880345285, 0.03701917082071304, 0.02660503424704075, 0.0031915404833853245, 0.005831203889101744, 0.04492604732513428, -0.03457329049706459, -0.02601984702050686, 0.017374075949192047, 0.01222775224596262, 0.018263433128595352, 0.027440989390015602, 0.021855775266885757, -0.018063848838210106, 0.016261495649814606, 0.031384456902742386, -0.011302083730697632, 0.005895175505429506, 0.0038443547673523426, 0.05546906217932701, 0.009295588359236717, 0.030512262135744095, -0.012197324074804783, -0.006925296038389206, 0.052156541496515274, -0.0228958111256361, 0.06283200532197952, -0.031088797375559807, 0.010528216138482094, 0.05083305388689041, -0.04775702580809593, -0.0031851488165557384, 0.04400169849395752, 0.03744817525148392, -0.012156606651842594, -0.049460235983133316, -0.011845598928630352, -0.025881465524435043, 0.0201182272285223, 0.001751832664012909, -0.04973667860031128, 0.02255002222955227, 0.0009753782651387155, -0.017524994909763336, 0.064692921936512, -0.034424830228090286, -0.011049213819205761, 0.02767910249531269, 0.0256443340331316, -0.03863602504134178, 0.03368966281414032, -0.0306672602891922, -0.007195450831204653, -0.009974992834031582, 0.0132202273234725, 0.06455209851264954, -0.026034066453576088, 0.01198608335107565, 0.016751613467931747, 0.012357095256447792, 0.014066635631024837, 0.010459702461957932, 0.0710996761918068, -0.017695685848593712, 0.024379167705774307, 0.007484870031476021, 0.01121357548981905, 0.002424100646749139, 0.06514661014080048, 0.024838540703058243, -0.009883026592433453, 0.050677474588155746, -0.010280216112732887, 0.02438083104789257, 0.042991869151592255, -0.024986276403069496, -0.024183645844459534, -0.057689644396305084, 0.03163847699761391, 0.03443479165434837, -0.024984369054436684, -0.0038628235924988985, -0.027418600395321846, -0.011978819034993649, -0.013806511647999287, -0.04794224724173546, 0.0006097669247537851, 0.024190708994865417, -0.021801186725497246, -0.023000149056315422, 0.0372229665517807, -0.02456987462937832, -0.0015146436635404825, -0.0062092668376863, 0.04002290591597557, 0.05001932010054588, 0.04852517694234848, -0.03627612814307213, 0.008411876857280731, -0.03130991384387016, -0.06331311166286469, -0.015389970503747463, 0.021899031475186348, -0.025500696152448654, -0.029684539884328842, 0.03581201657652855, -0.024134131148457527, -0.04421470686793327, 0.02096140757203102, 0.007025967352092266, 0.017225725576281548, 0.005080584902316332, -0.07810775190591812, -0.09804603457450867, 0.025698434561491013, -0.01717924326658249, -0.03235866501927376, -0.03298794478178024, 0.014804339036345482, 0.02430320903658867, 0.041462842375040054, 0.01539011299610138, 0.026385637000203133, 0.013535924255847931, 0.0005723724607378244, 0.015745630487799644, -0.012562790885567665, 0.016503116115927696, -0.046942338347435, -0.03628411144018173, -0.013195754028856754, -0.04462801292538643, -0.016740627586841583, 0.010465000756084919, -0.03654927760362625, 0.011682916432619095, 0.04240649938583374, -0.0027161508332937956, 0.016267230734229088, 0.0018528691725805402, -0.018183516338467598, -0.02708711102604866, 0.09931246191263199, 0.01899905316531658, 0.012884248979389668, 0.03164729103446007, -0.018947038799524307, 0.014174572192132473, -0.012002700008451939, 0.024308959022164345, 0.04195214807987213, 0.0065299877896904945, 0.007259635720402002, -0.012951274402439594, 0.022450482472777367, 0.027442699298262596, -0.08086200803518295, -0.030653944239020348, 0.008200293406844139, -0.050977565348148346, 0.032618675380945206, 0.06563183665275574, -0.005676943343132734, -0.029139399528503418, 0.04409276694059372, -0.06973056495189667, -0.024486267939209938, -0.060291506350040436, 0.006857546046376228, -0.010731090791523457, -0.018508268520236015, 0.004000876098871231, 0.011593515053391457, 0.01612781174480915, 0.0020622180309146643, 0.00488370331004262, -0.02172069624066353, 0.015624207444489002, 0.07102042436599731, -0.017866820096969604, -0.047469548881053925, 0.045431528240442276, 0.054900068789720535, -0.02290242537856102, 0.0397820882499218, -0.034515250474214554, -0.03121783956885338, 0.04719546064734459, -0.05744196102023125, 0.018891451880335808, -0.030706342309713364, -0.022445764392614365, -0.012542342767119408, -0.0011148399207741022, -0.03402509540319443, 0.04418075829744339, -0.04627692699432373, 0.03647777438163757, 0.04854699596762657, 0.011889592744410038, -0.013652598485350609, -0.012181057594716549, 0.016625575721263885, 0.0625806376338005, -0.022937381640076637, 0.023877423256635666, -0.03958616033196449, -0.029715197160840034, 0.04816366359591484, -0.005809447728097439, -0.050450220704078674, -0.01042342372238636, 0.05018812417984009, 0.005820971913635731, -0.00009928335202857852, 0.026987584307789803, -0.03406279534101486, 0.018089374527335167, -0.0032222226727753878, -0.005167510360479355, 0.02573874406516552, -0.0004338974831625819, 0.018699437379837036, 0.040516581386327744, 0.01103125885128975, 0.032098330557346344, 0.048521239310503006, 0.04041966050863266, -0.03911072760820389, -0.04210427775979042, -0.003103554015979171, -0.016206638887524605, 0.0619419626891613, -0.002714583184570074, 0.01443446334451437, 0.0474943108856678, -0.005502257030457258, 0.012759248726069927, -0.001673490391112864, -0.010218395851552486, -0.001633486128412187, 0.017656700685620308, -0.037761908024549484, -0.03160225227475166, 0.03016761504113674, -0.019544651731848717, 0.02407539077103138, -0.052289288491010666, -0.031615693122148514, -0.02722163312137127, 0.026191478595137596, 0.008436850272119045, 0.001292495639063418, 0.017510028555989265, -0.04015011340379715, -0.004456058610230684, -0.03084009326994419, 0.007890598848462105, 0.029123317450284958, -0.027087511494755745, -0.027075674384832382, -0.008593477308750153, -0.020887473598122597, -0.031739912927150726, 0.0246171522885561, 0.006062757223844528, -0.029134919866919518, 0.023991119116544724, -0.00842166319489479, -0.02388409711420536, -0.02423100359737873, -0.0307680182158947, -0.0036128940992057323, 0.003861258504912257, -0.03915826603770256, 0.03887352719902992, -0.021532485261559486, -0.03991997241973877, 0.020673811435699463, -0.05346513167023659, -0.021590260788798332, -0.01671666093170643, -0.017086107283830643, 0.003058656118810177, -0.0027497271075844765, -0.0027911595534533262, 0.0023789445403963327, -0.027422359213232994, -0.01904871128499508, -0.058002881705760956, -0.049102965742349625, -0.0045260535553097725, 0.031226322054862976, -0.0020077370572835207, 0.0037611625157296658, -0.0048538995906710625, 0.04528557509183884, 0.032276496291160583, -0.06955710798501968, -0.05810203775763512, -0.005570817738771439, -0.03570353612303734, -0.043971892446279526, -0.0019812884274870157, -0.004895949270576239, 0.027716636657714844, 0.007145065814256668, -0.024143805727362633, 0.03412233665585518, 0.027896543964743614, -0.014393225312232971, 0.015578738413751125, -0.011924701742827892, -0.017844529822468758, -0.016564693301916122, 0.03974257409572601, 0.0336306169629097, -0.003508966648951173, 0.024758046492934227, 0.005525218788534403, 0.05728753283619881, -0.015524428337812424, -0.03287452086806297, 0.007004973478615284, 0.0037101428024470806, 0.0318572036921978, -0.03161199018359184, 0.025630297139286995, 0.006589987780898809, 0.0018246712861582637, -0.006914287805557251, 0.00040425590123049915, 0.015172459185123444, -0.017825191840529442, -0.010957158170640469, 0.023544088006019592, 0.040623366832733154, -0.01172855868935585, -0.013943877071142197, -0.03111972101032734, 0.002231438411399722, 0.0013531309086829424, -0.0037110100965946913, 0.006948940455913544, 0.09892046451568604, 0.03124050423502922, 0.014420205727219582, -0.00638794619590044, -0.05294540524482727, 0.014964225701987743, -0.06586544960737228, 0.00018737671780399978, -0.02431493252515793, 0.013766408897936344, -0.004449546802788973, 0.03819601982831955, -0.013255736790597439, -0.008687336929142475, -0.007967199198901653, -0.0055685569532215595, -0.05414533242583275, 0.031758517026901245, -0.0014049262972548604, -0.024387521669268608, 0.013275603763759136, -0.0016538238851353526, 0.03514548018574715, -0.045061420649290085, 0.026150718331336975, -0.00516064278781414, -0.007626466453075409, -0.003550860797986388, 0.020329667255282402, 0.023127954453229904, 0.0356108620762825, -0.013190069235861301, -0.0016530959401279688, 0.0616987980902195, -0.004883881192654371, 0.004618989769369364, 0.05696815997362137, -0.017685234546661377, -0.005361421033740044, -0.038093119859695435, 0.006457865703850985, 0.026752280071377754, 0.007566195446997881, 0.05136505514383316, 0.016452571377158165, -0.0018800562247633934, 0.04332477226853371, -0.010531209409236908, 0.0029058947693556547, 0.058958571404218674, -0.012190049514174461, -0.012429794296622276, -0.021709619089961052, -0.02062070369720459, -0.014218294993042946, 0.007532814517617226, -0.02310505509376526, 0.025215433910489082, 0.07662156224250793, 0.04710010811686516, -0.05960843712091446, 0.06975140422582626, 0.04275567829608917, 0.004665757529437542, -0.03114345669746399, -0.04535960406064987, 0.005859209690243006, -0.01190817542374134, 0.0010529038263484836, 0.027535371482372284, 0.009178596548736095, 0.026003951206803322, -0.014969777315855026, 0.018482407554984093, -0.02795698493719101, -0.026342513039708138, 0.010723000392317772, 0.032702039927244186, 0.027218826115131378, -0.02350195311009884, -0.023198164999485016, -0.026851708069443703, 0.022161204367876053, 0.03619128838181496, 0.006755612324923277, 0.006063668988645077, -0.10113515704870224, 0.013419345021247864, 0.030632775276899338, 0.06671153008937836, -0.03488845378160477, -0.005455033853650093, -0.03904036432504654, -0.03386041522026062, 0.022295475006103516, -0.032943468540906906, 0.02355385385453701, -0.02384011819958687, 0.028617218136787415, -0.013502663001418114, -0.02919253334403038, -0.04429817944765091, -0.009372551925480366, 0.004214604385197163, 0.03785492852330208, -0.018813064321875572, -0.01701132208108902, -0.03062521107494831, 0.026264416053891182, -0.0013987048296257854, 0.05110612511634827, -0.028008027002215385, -0.01952885091304779, 0.03229665383696556, 0.010486693121492863, -0.004718049895018339, -0.04402261972427368, -0.02725689485669136, 0.014948394149541855, -0.01731075532734394, 0.038462720811367035, -0.010562369599938393, -0.04774007201194763, 0.020413769409060478, 0.0006494647241197526, -0.015124415047466755, -0.00029570251354016364, -0.022428661584854126, 0.039880190044641495, 0.045420363545417786, 0.023330606520175934, 0.07214805483818054, 0.043073009699583054, 0.010602626949548721, 0.009711003862321377, -0.05182616785168648, 0.012890290468931198, -0.012659749947488308, -0.03346549719572067, -0.04045905917882919, -0.005582164041697979, -0.009308362379670143, 0.010198026895523071, -0.008408162742853165, 0.013652442954480648, -0.020996879786252975, 0.0023395575117319822, 0.01576741598546505, 0.04288344457745552, -0.007122839335352182, -0.02952723577618599, 0.057327963411808014, 0.024065658450126648, -0.03736957535147667, -0.03369128704071045, 0.030995693057775497, 0.004269202705472708, 0.0063231103122234344, 0.028453532606363297, -0.032085906714200974, -0.013918932527303696, 0.0037016132846474648, -0.016661927103996277, 0.0036338940262794495, -0.05192389711737633, -0.0009413670632056892, -0.011778483167290688, 0.030333390459418297, -0.018873631954193115, -0.02075980417430401, -0.003968833480030298, 0.02327653393149376, 0.015002704225480556, -0.016846152022480965, -0.014667781069874763, 0.031736213713884354, -0.0009364418219774961, -0.04192306101322174, -0.04964381083846092, -0.033043645322322845, 0.01744135282933712, 0.018925780430436134, -0.03747313842177391, -0.018384242430329323, -0.028600335121154785, 0.007988114841282368, 0.0081982696428895, -0.019646331667900085, 0.07066494226455688, -0.058545663952827454, -0.03229428082704544, -0.028570614755153656, 0.009930836968123913, 0.07341087609529495, -0.000029764336431981064, 0.004345937166363001, 0.0013408609665930271, -0.0007168558076955378, -0.03913665935397148, 0.01845623552799225, -0.006429153494536877, -0.01901460997760296, -0.020264264196157455, -0.019400600343942642, -0.018166253343224525, 0.028110960498452187, -0.010872527956962585, -0.018744172528386116, 0.004138953983783722, -0.011726594530045986, 0.002332122530788183, -0.04457345977425575, 0.020437510684132576, -0.03568876534700394, 0.02810172736644745, -0.007075294386595488, 0.03840348869562149, -0.01739691011607647, 0.012763765640556812, 0.040187768638134, -0.029587993398308754, -0.007597677409648895, 0.022389959543943405, 0.08398175239562988, 0.0005955424276180565, 0.04084523022174835, -0.011870497837662697, -0.011824555695056915, 0.06359809637069702, 0.008940128609538078, 0.008792213164269924, -0.012350797653198242, 0.02568787895143032, -0.02290913835167885, -0.03138664737343788, -0.02063225395977497, -0.01178189367055893, 0.046856097877025604, -0.025440610945224762, 0.03074713610112667, 0.05496995151042938, -0.03577380254864693, 0.03233155980706215, -0.016064317896962166, -0.026027163490653038, -0.023353587836027145, 0.035255834460258484, 0.06620121747255325, 0.012187125161290169, 0.010505886748433113, 0.05549221485853195, 0.007822933606803417, 0.025242045521736145, 0.0059262667782604694, 0.008152730762958527, -0.011813705787062645, 0.021382778882980347, -0.013043138198554516, -0.018443115055561066, 0.03017990104854107, -0.03746381774544716, 0.018475376069545746, -0.007507725153118372, -0.04822934418916702, 0.03635375201702118, 0.007827121764421463, -0.014289360493421555, -0.0017914497293531895, -0.02438415214419365, -0.0698891133069992, -0.0021370574831962585, 0.029539700597524643, -0.046295080333948135, -0.013217928819358349, -0.0170445516705513, 0.060459405183792114, -0.026968451216816902, 0.05247536674141884, -0.043227989226579666, -0.08311876654624939, -0.05709635093808174, 0.0011046697618439794, 0.01792619191110134, 0.10369416326284409, 0.017639312893152237, -0.023182151839137077, 0.024381300434470177, -0.05811742693185806, 0.02929234504699707, 0.02164018154144287, 0.05927930772304535, -0.018248923122882843, 0.04568365961313248, -0.02227257937192917, -0.025377223268151283, -0.012233554385602474, -0.041699592024087906, 0.12725608050823212, 0.1027790755033493, 0.06409723311662674, -0.07936108112335205, -0.005361747462302446, 0.012194843962788582, 0.0020996276289224625, 0.014547948725521564, -0.022764425724744797, 0.006681852042675018, 0.008086158894002438, 0.06737416237592697, 0.05860091373324394, 0.04991550371050835, 0.012882137671113014, 0.021071530878543854, -0.03788791596889496, -0.007812073454260826, -0.018902726471424103, 0.048421844840049744, 0.022870441898703575, -0.037243589758872986, -0.030747301876544952, -0.01922995038330555, -0.0006889401702210307, -0.0022436375729739666, -0.045661162585020065, 0.0020118493121117353, -0.035084959119558334, 0.02642880566418171, -0.04957502707839012, 0.0029830695129930973, 0.012975621968507767, 0.01095956563949585, 0.0179746076464653, 0.02111089788377285, 0.03474358096718788, 0.0018274070462211967, -0.0005351219442673028, 0.021252399310469627, 0.0025474857538938522, -0.017239218577742577, 0.0019932950381189585, 0.032886870205402374, -0.03267712518572807, -0.025655588135123253, -0.025661436840891838, 0.012967380695044994, -0.003833678551018238, -0.03067813068628311, -0.005120527930557728, 0.01606176234781742, -0.011881613172590733, -0.013895578682422638, 0.011808422394096851, 0.04062207415699959, -0.011251281015574932, -0.007748715579509735, -0.013018927536904812, -0.020765436813235283, 0.035685788840055466, -0.005577272269874811, 0.0008942615240812302, 0.03486871346831322, -0.043525129556655884, -0.005750031676143408, -0.03999082371592522, 0.04338882863521576, -0.024710457772016525, 0.013132142834365368, -0.009972813539206982, -0.03207523375749588, -0.047296032309532166, 0.006523789372295141, 0.03518882021307945, -0.004080364480614662, 0.02918390743434429, -0.025509895756840706, 0.023601790890097618, -0.03667205199599266, -0.050856709480285645, 0.03319291025400162, -0.03915032371878624, -0.004803477320820093, -0.048053938895463943, -0.00672871945425868, 0.030556734651327133, -0.009614386595785618, 0.01697671413421631, 0.013914844952523708, -0.011153053492307663, 0.06425712257623672, -0.02762516960501671, -0.05365961417555809, -0.019685078412294388, 0.044748056679964066, -0.030306510627269745, -0.0005029586027376354, 0.006142419762909412, 0.04831955209374428, 0.008244900032877922, 0.0199444442987442, -0.0035494836047291756, 0.042536281049251556, 0.008502230979502201, -0.0064102462492883205, 0.032622698694467545, -0.028300989419221878, 0.008772398345172405, 0.03262097015976906, -0.03473573178052902, -0.01872340962290764, 0.008323573507368565, -0.07538865506649017, -0.07626158744096756, 0.028804512694478035, 0.04143224656581879, -0.04992629587650299, 0.032753147184848785, -0.02888433448970318, -0.01057305745780468, -0.05038818344473839, -0.011558381840586662, -0.041842494159936905, -0.026827936992049217, -0.0003607311809901148, -0.0732666403055191, -0.025953078642487526, -0.009293700568377972, -0.0085090771317482, 0.003093413542956114, 0.008078302256762981, 0.02364221401512623, 0.017204394564032555, -0.015570983290672302, 0.024953536689281464, 0.004216827917844057, 0.03553013503551483, -0.016363568603992462, -0.025123439729213715, 0.016544252634048462, -0.017396721988916397, -0.0223753210157156, 0.03020697645843029, -0.015917547047138214, 0.01744551584124565, 0.014854631386697292, 0.009943019598722458, 0.02494891546666622, 0.04668339341878891, -0.008415299467742443, -0.01604076288640499, 0.011900695040822029, -0.0015898658894002438, 0.0024077522102743387, -0.01047348789870739, 0.03614082932472229, -0.006707726512104273, -0.026737801730632782, 0.02086091786623001, 0.05126163363456726, 0.003296578535810113, -0.009289507754147053, 0.022108033299446106, -0.01385784987360239, 0.02307257615029812, 0.016680855304002762, -0.000554034486413002, 0.020808886736631393, 0.016551803797483444, -0.03344374895095825, 0.04111498221755028, -0.01661774143576622, 0.022043317556381226, -0.09732852876186371, -0.02378656528890133, 0.006624814588576555, 0.012136104516685009, 0.027969269081950188, -0.06340502202510834, 0.014060749672353268, 0.03285448998212814, -0.03627751022577286, -0.006607049144804478, -0.0030905066523700953, -0.006675258744508028, 0.0166945680975914, 0.06786775588989258, -0.029659366235136986, 0.015026791952550411, 0.02878546714782715, 0.03226650133728981, 0.023627787828445435, -0.006502571981400251, 0.027409443631768227, -0.03070283867418766, -0.022399041801691055, 0.008362424559891224, 0.022338297218084335, -0.038133811205625534, 0.024547230452299118, -0.009336601942777634, -0.016438983380794525, 0.005662781652063131, 0.001288072788156569, 0.0359095074236393, 0.033475685864686966, 0.026782434433698654, -0.003161526983603835, 0.07210376113653183, 0.02263733372092247, 0.022339997813105583, -0.06570432335138321, -0.01796063967049122, 0.01065536867827177, 0.01853325590491295, -0.016467494890093803, 0.0267947930842638, -0.00463239336386323, -0.001118992455303669, -0.03835859149694443, 0.03038082644343376, -0.03513693809509277, -0.02265297807753086, -0.008922039531171322, 0.0201168954372406, 0.010765736922621727, -0.03711022809147835, 0.01090026181191206, -0.07367143779993057, 0.03292744979262352, 0.04554469883441925, 0.03755827248096466, -0.017293838784098625, 0.025013819336891174, -0.031072698533535004, -0.03332887962460518, 0.005157287698239088, -0.0011303980136290193, -0.03935782611370087, -0.032731328159570694, -0.023334672674536705, 0.0023420925717800856, -0.030152447521686554, -0.009376844391226768, -0.0020952345803380013, -0.06364014744758606, 0.04184788465499878, 0.009142760187387466, 0.016164656728506088, 0.028706951066851616, -0.0331682413816452, 0.03487151488661766, -0.09875307977199554, 0.018199017271399498, 0.01734274812042713, 0.02360186167061329, -0.04809262976050377, 0.017116989940404892, -0.02040916681289673, 0.04866401106119156, 0.05788096785545349, 0.012678209692239761, 0.006592120043933392, -0.00588067714124918, 0.026708319783210754, -0.01855619251728058, -0.060967668890953064, 0.03438081964850426, 0.02472103200852871, 0.012926931492984295, -0.0002433194313198328, 0.000651016307529062, 0.003309369320049882, 0.01603105664253235, 0.037641722708940506, 0.016005273908376694, 0.013326195999979973, -0.009958522394299507, -0.00011042382539017126, 0.07601846009492874, 0.013727028854191303, -0.045857906341552734, 0.044953517615795135, 0.026303837075829506, 0.03980224207043648, 0.08929954469203949, 0.01868005283176899, -0.06109871342778206, 0.02956654131412506, -0.010965521447360516, -0.03740611672401428, 0.004365075845271349, -0.03475276753306389, 0.011745304800570011, -0.06303781270980835, 0.019532112404704094, 0.026825187727808952, -0.027445074170827866, -0.012162244878709316, -0.0038735377602279186, 0.05622658506035805, 0.029892975464463234, 0.018399538472294807, 0.002191248582676053, 0.01692851446568966, -0.035813409835100174, 0.026921609416604042, 0.01473145466297865, 0.05000744387507439, -0.0240308940410614, 0.02482892945408821, 0.012053163722157478, -0.018989646807312965, 0.015087607316672802, -0.01621272787451744, 0.06513538211584091, -0.023814119398593903, -0.030395613983273506, -0.011329653672873974, -0.0012762011028826237, 0.004545696545392275, -0.01285477727651596, -0.017506785690784454, 0.029587309807538986, -0.04753788933157921, 0.015555962920188904, -0.010183197446167469, 0.0015046177431941032, -0.029242966324090958, -0.0012013238156214356, 0.0024970199447125196, 0.00477726012468338, -0.016683246940374374, -0.014904303476214409, 0.014670387841761112, -0.0297201257199049, 0.005866409745067358, 0.003128871088847518, 0.0026012647431343794, -0.00864134356379509, 0.006067630369216204, -0.031984928995370865, -0.020163124427199364, -0.015142747201025486, -0.04565088823437691, 0.013875646516680717, 0.02967154048383236, -0.025334611535072327, -0.06721559166908264, -0.010966897942125797, -0.008475754410028458, 0.048187870532274246, -0.054489217698574066, -0.018773704767227173, -0.020947182551026344, 0.007207687012851238, -0.020012319087982178, -0.026152735576033592 ]
<p>A massive problem in communicating the results of statistical calculations to the media and to the public is how we communicate uncertainty. Certainly most mass media seems to like a hard and fast number, even though except in a relatively small number of cases, numbers always have some uncertainty.</p> <p>So, how can we, as statisticians (or scientists describing statistical work), best communicate our results, while keeping the uncertainty in tact, and making it meaningful to our audience?</p> <p>I realise that this isn't actually a statistics question, rather a psychology question about statistics, but it's certainly something that most statisticians and scientists will be concerned about. I'm imagining that good answers might reference psychological research more than stats textbooks...</p> <hr> <p><strong>Edit:</strong> As per user568458's suggestion, a case-study may be useful here. If possible, please keep answers generalisable to other areas.</p> <p>The particular case that I'm interested in serves as a nice example: <em>the communication of climate science to politicians and the general public, through mass media</em>. In other words, as a scientist, it is your job to convey information to a journalist in such a way that they have little difficulty in accurately conveying that information to the public - that is, the truth, although not necessarily the <em>whole</em> truth, which won't usually fit in a news-bite. </p> <p>Some particularly common examples might be the communication of the uncertainty in the estimate of degree of warming over the remainder of the century, or in the increased likelihood of a specific extreme weather event (i.e. in response to a "was this storm caused by climate change" type question).</p>
74,370
[ -0.032992441207170486, -0.0412888377904892, -0.029435181990265846, -0.03455571085214615, 0.030382269993424416, 0.04574806988239288, -0.006183699704706669, -0.011005825363099575, 0.024861812591552734, -0.001288189901970327, 0.021132418885827065, 0.04059845209121704, 0.03581370413303375, 0.012680827639997005, 0.01703893579542637, 0.01399402879178524, 0.015486136078834534, 0.010324855335056782, -0.03209696337580681, 0.0006725374842062593, 0.030757172033190727, 0.003950127866119146, -0.04363766685128212, 0.006755633279681206, -0.014185513369739056, 0.04887225851416588, 0.04560008645057678, 0.017289213836193085, 0.006973200477659702, 0.05389620363712311, -0.009988818317651749, -0.014670582488179207, 0.03500580042600632, 0.035178933292627335, 0.02880270592868328, -0.004971943795681, -0.012203297577798367, -0.022848408669233322, -0.0068722078576684, 0.03668795898556709, -0.06836940348148346, -0.0362820103764534, 0.005013367626816034, -0.0024352692998945713, -0.04009678587317467, 0.00830123946070671, -0.00711044343188405, -0.025694480165839195, 0.019791364669799805, -0.030014056712388992, 0.062346480786800385, 0.021071596071124077, 0.014843066222965717, 0.032515376806259155, -0.011001151986420155, 0.015859898179769516, 0.05875193700194359, 0.05572175607085228, -0.013654746115207672, -0.07940106838941574, -0.004748489707708359, -0.030415654182434082, -0.00563447829335928, -0.0055564031936228275, -0.019652677699923515, 0.0481538362801075, -0.010052664205431938, -0.030057048425078392, 0.03427310660481453, 0.006235437002032995, -0.018666710704565048, 0.029479658231139183, 0.034089505672454834, 0.030469615012407303, 0.01125218253582716, -0.05224890634417534, 0.032258305698633194, 0.024285918101668358, 0.04011528939008713, 0.02924048714339733, -0.011689871549606323, 0.01608358509838581, 0.04180080071091652, 0.04547842964529991, 0.017901252955198288, -0.021510878577828407, 0.06066132336854935, -0.045952968299388885, 0.023452991619706154, 0.035394325852394104, -0.02343067340552807, -0.012525281868875027, 0.011095275171101093, -0.013350242748856544, -0.046551696956157684, 0.017595630139112473, -0.01969189941883087, 0.10238876938819885, 0.010365336202085018, -0.019946478307247162, -0.0020667072385549545, 0.006968046072870493, 0.020514244213700294, 0.05936306715011597, -0.025349222123622894, -0.03400658443570137, -0.03744983300566673, -0.030581079423427582, -0.020732291042804718, -0.04788685217499733, 0.007840323261916637, 0.01177506148815155, 0.0015325389103963971, -0.010677865706384182, 0.030105281621217728, -0.02953605353832245, 0.034188155084848404, -0.00781308300793171, 0.07775776833295822, 0.047058433294296265, 0.04710638150572777, -0.022024646401405334, 0.030084198340773582, 0.001942644827067852, -0.031224261969327927, 0.010497433133423328, 0.03581893816590309, -0.03708251193165779, -0.049205534160137177, 0.0408564992249012, 0.012892559170722961, 0.012220882810652256, -0.0031031316611915827, -0.01625054143369198, 0.003162490436807275, 0.019225560128688812, -0.09393684566020966, -0.04753829166293144, 0.03836669400334358, 0.006067966111004353, -0.045007623732089996, -0.0655800923705101, 0.011616175994277, 0.026440376415848732, 0.03861049935221672, 0.004569381941109896, 0.056098125874996185, -0.003722036723047495, 0.027949579060077667, 0.0009604230290278792, -0.008013478480279446, -0.01250737439841032, 0.03530389443039894, -0.0022478026803582907, -0.019978586584329605, -0.0844949409365654, 0.019951267167925835, 0.02092711441218853, 0.008689030073583126, -0.014346368610858917, 0.020817622542381287, -0.011429778300225735, -0.025132518261671066, -0.007067334838211536, 0.02399066835641861, -0.013994378037750721, 0.0809643343091011, -0.023460907861590385, 0.0051290313713252544, -0.0065893204882740974, 0.02412833459675312, 0.011680157855153084, 0.05399814993143082, 0.023280326277017593, 0.061404697597026825, -0.03251754865050316, 0.012017997913062572, 0.021061519160866737, -0.01655084453523159, 0.0011455523781478405, -0.010511945001780987, -0.0066155316308140755, -0.014610578306019306, 0.005962856113910675, 0.012549427337944508, 0.0302861500531435, 0.004456611815840006, -0.0030153021216392517, 0.057903729379177094, -0.03732063248753548, -0.029611561447381973, -0.06780467182397842, 0.03137228265404701, -0.006967265158891678, 0.026766974478960037, 0.027495887130498886, -0.038464706391096115, 0.01964225061237812, -0.0051238201558589935, -0.006772742606699467, 0.017291195690631866, 0.013591058552265167, 0.07466022670269012, -0.0486803762614727, -0.02371417172253132, 0.033771075308322906, 0.039768099784851074, -0.02032838575541973, 0.014765148982405663, -0.0216081365942955, -0.06401314586400986, -0.006749107968062162, 0.0035408735275268555, 0.027631646022200584, 0.002681662328541279, -0.029907800257205963, 0.0018779666861519217, -0.018552253022789955, -0.02217646688222885, 0.01576770283281803, -0.061403267085552216, 0.08154226094484329, 0.05018053948879242, -0.015496314503252506, -0.009895199909806252, 0.03913535177707672, 0.01856253482401371, -0.018089255318045616, -0.004096085671335459, -0.028903787955641747, -0.06565525382757187, 0.024632077664136887, 0.03505834564566612, 0.0018814848735928535, -0.013738973066210747, -0.01649237796664238, 0.051398660987615585, 0.07396294176578522, 0.00984150543808937, 0.030534109100699425, -0.014786513522267342, -0.010407979600131512, -0.006966103333979845, -0.020944533869624138, 0.0028231446631252766, 0.010900165885686874, -0.013891419395804405, 0.005134356673806906, 0.0024702679365873337, -0.0024441275745630264, -0.006219532806426287, 0.05117601528763771, -0.013411330059170723, -0.012397967278957367, -0.0029974866192787886, 0.00157713342923671, 0.03799141198396683, -0.028266537934541702, -0.026820886880159378, 0.015567125752568245, 0.024786213412880898, 0.027817266061902046, 0.0038140222895890474, -0.018216079100966454, 0.008579926565289497, 0.042506106197834015, -0.04476066678762436, 0.018662070855498314, 0.010956499725580215, -0.03584642708301544, -0.017506983131170273, -0.04203873127698898, -0.021935908123850822, -0.0023600589483976364, 0.02778656780719757, 0.03845351189374924, -0.008300966583192348, 0.015543818473815918, -0.011392557062208652, -0.03894631192088127, -0.0047917147167027, -0.002346097957342863, -0.0004098596691619605, 0.023691706359386444, -0.058068446815013885, 0.01699245348572731, -0.0318906344473362, -0.012389425188302994, 0.03890828415751457, -0.05529552698135376, -0.00006375625525834039, 0.007525239605456591, 0.007967227138578892, -0.046982575207948685, -0.015576895326375961, -0.037931621074676514, -0.002927560592070222, 0.00206134095788002, -0.02119273878633976, 0.04188006743788719, -0.00570946279913187, -0.029680771753191948, -0.017106935381889343, -0.02851320244371891, -0.03029639460146427, -0.057326555252075195, -0.014277597889304161, -0.011506934650242329, 0.012179959565401077, 0.007461655884981155, 0.027374127879738808, -0.019343620166182518, -0.016641374677419662, -0.06963381916284561, -0.07456817477941513, 0.03548698499798775, -0.0004075499018654227, 0.040734514594078064, -0.02457631565630436, -0.016495071351528168, 0.059167783707380295, 0.014150780625641346, 0.014889144338667393, -0.023549284785985947, 0.0029307855293154716, -0.007607532199472189, -0.029843898490071297, 0.017693916335701942, 0.028163475915789604, 0.01566501520574093, 0.05837596207857132, 0.03279503434896469, -0.004432270303368568, -0.008177919313311577, 0.0232101883739233, -0.024698534980416298, 0.00226575811393559, -0.005934001412242651, 0.03148267790675163, 0.023701772093772888, 0.04477082937955856, -0.07565873116254807, 0.05057746544480324, -0.01657750830054283, 0.020227154716849327, 0.015331869013607502, -0.02795441262423992, -0.005436278413981199, -0.018742665648460388, -0.0011160720605403185, -0.046440962702035904, 0.03500102460384369, 0.010222968645393848, 0.008892550133168697, 0.034734323620796204, 0.018361449241638184, 0.031770672649145126, -0.006409802474081516, 0.00010821831529028714, 0.043217625468969345, 0.06826698780059814, -0.02052796445786953, -0.001047330442816019, -0.019685173407197, -0.0015025861794129014, 0.03295157104730606, -0.009539286606013775, -0.01828496716916561, 0.04225294291973114, 0.015369375236332417, 0.020871708169579506, -0.01843644678592682, -0.013216136023402214, 0.0016037512104958296, -0.06882844865322113, -0.010297464206814766, -0.02148769423365593, 0.012510341592133045, -0.008245497941970825, 0.03128647804260254, 0.02563648670911789, 0.028852371498942375, 0.004588090814650059, 0.03560709208250046, -0.0487300306558609, 0.03618745505809784, -0.024098727852106094, -0.027239790186285973, -0.006692385300993919, 0.005832222755998373, 0.026470471173524857, -0.009584952145814896, 0.013069409877061844, -0.024869197979569435, 0.03874681890010834, -0.033580482006073, 0.01522198785096407, 0.007054166402667761, -0.06259194761514664, -0.029772713780403137, -0.006915498059242964, 0.009350544773042202, -0.024611523374915123, 0.05851544067263603, 0.04567897692322731, 0.02768757939338684, -0.015386718325316906, -0.0445968322455883, -0.007763404864817858, 0.04499143734574318, 0.04427671432495117, -0.002330185379832983, 0.01020851917564869, -0.04751168191432953, 0.0728590339422226, 0.030808640643954277, -0.0018217244651168585, 0.016206461936235428, -0.009092090651392937, -0.016612373292446136, -0.0232413150370121, 0.008141858503222466, -0.01385438721626997, 0.014730233699083328, -0.03375082090497017, 0.013035773299634457, 0.04150757938623428, -0.008820977061986923, -0.027210136875510216, 0.008777489885687828, 0.04334652051329613, -0.024036558344960213, 0.011244640685617924, -0.006130618508905172, -0.028683077543973923, -0.011598427779972553, -0.009379396215081215, 0.00839654915034771, 0.05095769464969635, 0.019027631729841232, -0.0016302572330459952, 0.051760561764240265, -0.014824974350631237, -0.042328882962465286, 0.00482928566634655, 0.01007584948092699, 0.02493709698319435, 0.015267311595380306, -0.03022228181362152, 0.006247920449823141, 0.050833672285079956, 0.007045472972095013, 0.028202760964632034, -0.01310903113335371, -0.07413776218891144, -0.030511289834976196, 0.026837583631277084, 0.05298551544547081, -0.045720044523477554, -0.002800575690343976, -0.023868108168244362, 0.012112168595194817, 0.05453035980463028, -0.0122987637296319, -0.0044023520313203335, -0.017287390306591988, 0.01960100792348385, 0.01748993806540966, 0.008634832687675953, -0.017681241035461426, 0.0018908735364675522, 0.0015404323348775506, 0.031344685703516006, 0.010849508456885815, 0.0005919632967561483, -0.04843265190720558, 0.02480562962591648, 0.055679187178611755, 0.05835433676838875, 0.009411640465259552, -0.04086971655488014, 0.006497804541140795, -0.01674625277519226, -0.0537998341023922, -0.04719626158475876, 0.013542817905545235, 0.022050414234399796, -0.01822008565068245, 0.0471324659883976, -0.013553505763411522, -0.047199416905641556, 0.009195388294756413, 0.003566477680578828, -0.06043010950088501, -0.007597147021442652, -0.02565789967775345, 0.046694379299879074, 0.02001800760626793, 0.014305015094578266, 0.022920915856957436, 0.0629991963505745, 0.009896663017570972, 0.03311467543244362, -0.013430383987724781, 0.004961737897247076, -0.05505126342177391, -0.021506013348698616, 0.005477239843457937, 0.0009450174984522164, -0.04475881904363632, 0.022078335285186768, 0.012041253037750721, 0.0174130629748106, -0.014288880862295628, -0.04817722737789154, -0.025724591687321663, 0.042672548443078995, -0.04503747820854187, 0.03634683042764664, -0.005019443575292826, 0.019823875278234482, -0.009756281040608883, -0.002840320346876979, -0.007639400195330381, -0.0034875005949288607, -0.025024596601724625, 0.01155154313892126, -0.04955141246318817, 0.010686044581234455, -0.05479011312127113, -0.03476004675030708, 0.010732708498835564, -0.04092716798186302, 0.024020325392484665, 0.014032503589987755, 0.01283123530447483, 0.00815669633448124, -0.0505538284778595, -0.010896005667746067, 0.010251319035887718, 0.0013671788619831204, 0.07260432094335556, -0.04354358837008476, 0.002291090553626418, -0.03786683455109596, 0.02023199386894703, -0.06666465103626251, -0.006397572346031666, 0.03549811244010925, 0.05345752462744713, -0.04813331738114357, -0.01983710192143917, 0.029520638287067413, -0.012582476250827312, -0.010302192531526089, -0.03646859899163246, 0.06883631646633148, -0.012564806267619133, -0.021127618849277496, -0.015460167080163956, 0.0005184807232581079, 0.09039108455181122, -0.06390572339296341, -0.019608071073889732, 0.018732091411948204, -0.042857881635427475, -0.04034929350018501, -0.0097358962520957, 0.01189097948372364, -0.04244286194443703, -0.03598717600107193, -0.00983624067157507, 0.02538861706852913, 0.027698146179318428, 0.011105109006166458, 0.014006676152348518, 0.02851133421063423, 0.030787857249379158, 0.0008075839723460376, 0.0017965296283364296, -0.006387763656675816, -0.011423232033848763, 0.029281368479132652, -0.03943392261862755, 0.010548765771090984, 0.02115544304251671, -0.016488267108798027, 0.0277620330452919, 0.01098614651709795, -0.036384403705596924, 0.0034608219284564257, 0.03497130051255226, 0.009440054185688496, 0.017262209206819534, 0.014834750443696976, -0.009915555827319622, 0.022148925811052322, -0.008012674748897552, 0.028599539771676064, -0.031355131417512894, 0.0031636026687920094, -0.016787519678473473, -0.023446395993232727, -0.01736556738615036, -0.005889569874852896, 0.046657804399728775, -0.025775648653507233, 0.041851356625556946, 0.01797434315085411, 0.0017421916127204895, -0.018536308780312538, -0.054918453097343445, -0.005290835164487362, -0.035146210342645645, 0.0013189867604523897, 0.015440626069903374, 0.006912728305906057, 0.009792344644665718, 0.01681344211101532, 0.024467622861266136, 0.010450278408825397, 0.029631536453962326, -0.010140109807252884, 0.049000333994627, 0.041608843952417374, -0.041269730776548386, -0.029518140479922295, 0.033967673778533936, -0.06537730246782303, 0.006131832487881184, -0.017712440341711044, -0.02482384257018566, 0.004610402975231409, -0.00019365166372153908, -0.029704611748456955, -0.010548055171966553, -0.040584638714790344, -0.0740148052573204, 0.02958730235695839, -0.000783392577432096, -0.009543794207274914, 0.034717824310064316, -0.04311631619930267, 0.011621152050793171, -0.03407871723175049, -0.004571514669805765, -0.04654550924897194, -0.086084745824337, -0.035126347094774246, -0.035708602517843246, -0.06322663277387619, 0.04590010270476341, -0.003931771963834763, -0.012454362586140633, 0.018553579226136208, -0.029250221326947212, -0.0036218357272446156, 0.034267719835042953, -0.004147697705775499, -0.01827193982899189, 0.045567985624074936, 0.03393127769231796, 0.009820484556257725, -0.023502511903643608, -0.0061585670337080956, 0.10223094373941422, 0.051962777972221375, 0.04804200306534767, -0.06273500621318817, 0.02516225539147854, 0.040026113390922546, 0.010501333512365818, -0.01957753114402294, 0.0008434781339019537, -0.0020865201950073242, 0.01753748580813408, 0.014178303070366383, 0.06363638490438461, -0.007829898968338966, -0.016829710453748703, 0.06922148913145065, -0.03509204462170601, -0.015709729865193367, -0.01289096288383007, -0.013516704551875591, 0.030231868848204613, -0.0021107483189553022, -0.04649205133318901, -0.00294476468116045, 0.024890931323170662, 0.016856472939252853, -0.025405818596482277, -0.033982809633016586, 0.01330566592514515, 0.02373948134481907, -0.04358341172337532, 0.006833155173808336, 0.04088452085852623, 0.03725087642669678, -0.038929883390665054, -0.043463848531246185, 0.021334480494260788, -0.011840803548693657, 0.006933761294931173, 0.019266964867711067, -0.01400957815349102, -0.023454120382666588, 0.00744269136339426, 0.05224735289812088, -0.054572027176618576, -0.05911080166697502, -0.01803656481206417, 0.02901807241141796, -0.04079847410321236, -0.041882336139678955, -0.006586887873709202, -0.016019418835639954, -0.03977416083216667, -0.00811430811882019, 0.01537106093019247, 0.021873563528060913, 0.020380545407533646, -0.030751343816518784, -0.02533104456961155, 0.017320336773991585, 0.01227066945284605, -0.03229741379618645, 0.01825457438826561, 0.09077657014131546, -0.009781905449926853, -0.058106474578380585, -0.012677918188273907, 0.01413892675191164, 0.011442039161920547, 0.01828339509665966, -0.020648915320634842, 0.0031059966422617435, -0.06718596071004868, -0.03071586601436138, 0.013216442428529263, -0.033158592879772186, 0.0018660317873582244, 0.01569334790110588, 0.015444474294781685, 0.0213601253926754, -0.011237401515245438, 0.0025885957293212414, -0.003329850733280182, 0.018733728677034378, -0.041397951543331146, -0.004503647331148386, 0.019585303962230682, -0.009569407440721989, -0.020829958841204643, 0.016421794891357422, -0.01755679026246071, 0.03575386479496956, 0.03777402639389038, -0.08475375175476074, -0.00790281780064106, -0.007864812389016151, -0.03011292591691017, -0.013163863681256771, 0.00824606604874134, 0.046488113701343536, 0.028589947149157524, 0.011403484269976616, 0.027733294293284416, -0.0018227967666462064, 0.0042356583289802074, 0.011455804109573364, 0.017749767750501633, -0.055247094482183456, -0.03835788741707802, 0.008711384609341621, -0.008991552516818047, -0.01623213291168213, -0.03153765946626663, -0.038607362657785416, -0.00029471295420080423, 0.015601675026118755, -0.0030181333422660828, -0.04541172832250595, 0.03820312023162842, 0.01107269898056984, 0.012338991276919842, 0.004529821220785379, 0.014270715415477753, -0.04987938329577446, -0.009082674048841, -0.03790340945124626, -0.0423286072909832, -0.001942940172739327, 0.00699601648375392, -0.045541249215602875, -0.01597241498529911, 0.04107455164194107, -0.013713174499571323, 0.03365705907344818, 0.02871042676270008, -0.0042166137136518955, -0.006449343636631966, 0.03910285234451294, -0.01983487419784069, -0.02641158550977707, 0.05166780203580856, -0.008421479724347591, -0.0608149915933609, 0.024872642010450363, -0.01957784593105316, 0.030937762930989265, 0.012821346521377563, 0.004744342062622309, -0.0022078698966652155, 0.04303472861647606, -0.009543160907924175, 0.022775189951062202, 0.01287293341010809, 0.016513219103217125, -0.004846029449254274, 0.003636749228462577, 0.020817017182707787, -0.003718968480825424, -0.014396713115274906, 0.037508249282836914, 0.0579567588865757, -0.001044057309627533, 0.03475808724761009, -0.005140738561749458, -0.02676638588309288, 0.020043112337589264, 0.004562691319733858, 0.01771669089794159, 0.02112840674817562, 0.0482611246407032, -0.0448831170797348, 0.017503362149000168, 0.010002805851399899, 0.021229879930615425, -0.11648617684841156, -0.005751685705035925, 0.03040495328605175, -0.001152316341176629, 0.03005628101527691, -0.03302540257573128, 0.05848914384841919, 0.041486673057079315, -0.06269489973783493, -0.019775882363319397, -0.021002838388085365, -0.018945815041661263, -0.0030799596570432186, 0.0031458239536732435, -0.03343529254198074, 0.045459140092134476, 0.025700882077217102, 0.024922557175159454, 0.017624739557504654, 0.012378169223666191, 0.019127432256937027, -0.012008743360638618, -0.0428425632417202, 0.03131411597132683, 0.004598780069500208, -0.009714550338685513, 0.05682666227221489, -0.021727124229073524, 0.0007211571792140603, 0.04470418393611908, -0.03592502698302269, 0.04842191934585571, 0.03401236981153488, 0.017075035721063614, 0.01163124106824398, 0.012591803446412086, 0.01775342971086502, 0.0077385930344462395, 0.003706233575940132, -0.00033591792453080416, 0.019183583557605743, 0.02167692966759205, -0.034951914101839066, 0.01780635118484497, 0.012361196801066399, -0.006219853647053242, -0.007246959488838911, 0.008530322462320328, -0.010481378994882107, -0.014728267677128315, -0.01035663578659296, -0.02563522383570671, 0.05352992191910744, -0.03677846118807793, 0.028960466384887695, -0.049832820892333984, -0.018895817920565605, 0.023571232333779335, 0.03834005072712898, -0.007865752093493938, -0.0006192357395775616, -0.044114850461483, -0.026820197701454163, -0.024989506229758263, -0.020251374691724777, -0.026470528915524483, -0.05431480333209038, -0.032787200063467026, 0.028528792783617973, 0.019782397896051407, -0.00586797995492816, -0.03142997995018959, -0.05431278049945831, 0.0488656684756279, 0.009762044064700603, 0.018114930018782616, -0.01087181642651558, -0.0076680961064994335, 0.0010584788396954536, -0.0675245076417923, 0.03465899080038071, 0.021902471780776978, 0.05807732045650482, -0.03659280762076378, -0.0028287109453231096, 0.0007543468382209539, 0.017806658521294594, 0.07022903859615326, 0.020449286326766014, 0.0008257413282990456, 0.011835962533950806, -0.0078015075996518135, 0.027621837332844734, -0.0381544753909111, 0.02767523191869259, -0.030640386044979095, 0.004565088078379631, -0.02327849343419075, -0.01780553348362446, 0.022962871938943863, -0.0037308852188289165, -0.003452175995334983, 0.050680190324783325, 0.046247243881225586, -0.007740634027868509, -0.0026135765947401524, 0.03672004118561745, 0.02568340115249157, -0.04786459729075432, 0.046717382967472076, -0.012291381135582924, 0.006054211407899857, 0.019711753353476524, 0.00626800674945116, -0.049890343099832535, 0.05605948716402054, -0.024363460019230843, -0.027795374393463135, 0.0068861148320138454, 0.015442236326634884, 0.004198923707008362, -0.09557326883077621, -0.02031325176358223, 0.014348257333040237, -0.031398165971040726, 0.015614379197359085, 0.01930435746908188, 0.02208719775080681, 0.023544352501630783, 0.029511962085962296, -0.023748163133859634, 0.008431722410023212, 0.0025522238574922085, -0.05615078657865524, -0.006337384227663279, 0.07283046841621399, 0.016371937468647957, 0.032646678388118744, 0.035071443766355515, -0.012944486923515797, 0.05188426747918129, 0.014480923302471638, 0.029813898727297783, -0.019648924469947815, -0.011062613688409328, 0.02445306070148945, 0.0027915865648537874, -0.01684698462486267, 0.015156882815063, 0.031276799738407135, 0.05401770770549774, 0.011502189561724663, -0.0052686114795506, -0.04751459136605263, -0.01793382316827774, -0.040047045797109604, -0.03208528831601143, 0.026844168081879616, 0.05013308301568031, 0.03303975239396095, -0.019494744017720222, 0.013536518439650536, 0.01461001019924879, 0.019657909870147705, -0.0023004519753158092, 0.010548785328865051, -0.0678776428103447, -0.03948226571083069, -0.05719150975346565, -0.01446562446653843, -0.04404663294553757, 0.024730851873755455, 0.050697848200798035, 0.00853431411087513, 0.03341066092252731, 0.014054995030164719, -0.05577985942363739, -0.011297623626887798, 0.048759493976831436, -0.07501603662967682, -0.009021739475429058, -0.052916090935468674, 0.007879721000790596, -0.011441797949373722, -0.04411660507321358 ]
<p>I want to estimate</p> <p>$\log Y_t=\beta_0+\beta_1\log X_{1t}+\beta_2\log X_{2t}+e_t$</p> <p>Using ADF-tests, I have found that both $\{\log Y_t\}$ and $\{\log X_{1t}\}$ are I(1) (i.e. they contain a unit root), while $\{\log X_{2t}\}$ is I(2). I have checked that $\{\Delta \log Y_t\}$, $\{\Delta \log X_{1t}\}$ and $\{\Delta_2\log X_{2t}\}$ are all stationary. Now my question is what regression do I run using these differences, so that I can still say something about the original relationship above? Can I simply take second differences of $\{\log Y_t\}$ and $\{\log X_{1t}\}$ and estimate</p> <p>$\Delta_2\log Y_t=\beta_1\Delta_2\log X_{1t}+\Delta_2\beta_2\log X_{2t}+v_t$</p> <p>or does taking the second difference of an I(1) series introduce some kind of problem?</p>
37,238
[ 0.014759285375475883, -0.01538813952356577, -0.011572386138141155, 0.016645872965455055, 0.006372281815856695, 0.022985152900218964, 0.005075547378510237, -0.03535142168402672, 0.04867774620652199, -0.043151624500751495, 0.022585734724998474, 0.007208474446088076, 0.053339116275310516, -0.01140609011054039, 0.043126653879880905, 0.004643844440579414, 0.0019672918133437634, 0.020045867189764977, 0.014885523356497288, -0.006910016294568777, 0.01926388591527939, 0.015965832397341728, 0.03678252175450325, 0.010662137530744076, -0.024009615182876587, 0.05243569612503052, 0.0012309773592278361, 0.028048327192664146, -0.036444127559661865, 0.06056532263755798, -0.01565835066139698, -0.001902228919789195, -0.012301204726099968, 0.05067964643239975, -0.01599999889731407, 0.009467149153351784, -0.013063173741102219, -0.05481444671750069, -0.03165050595998764, 0.054715000092983246, -0.05587517097592354, -0.010934865102171898, 0.010658902116119862, 0.04312445595860481, 0.019970638677477837, -0.0005541113205254078, 0.006311779376119375, -0.03200117498636246, 0.027938729152083397, -0.005491402465850115, 0.04926289990544319, -0.01566261611878872, 0.03125877305865288, 0.05128790810704231, -0.035998087376356125, -0.0026613478548824787, 0.04638676345348358, 0.0523081049323082, -0.033374618738889694, -0.02225140854716301, -0.039628878235816956, -0.011364053934812546, 0.020596375688910484, -0.0008526047458872199, -0.052385807037353516, 0.04261479899287224, -0.020935405045747757, -0.0010536081390455365, -0.009917225688695908, -0.04440153390169144, 0.05243543162941933, -0.01094507984817028, 0.034958332777023315, -0.017138179391622543, 0.005584158003330231, -0.026779023930430412, -0.00621231971308589, 0.0459294356405735, 0.03268376737833023, 0.050861258059740067, 0.004074153956025839, -0.00021535564155783504, 0.03881071135401726, 0.05010437220335007, 0.021546972915530205, -0.001001619966700673, 0.06967435032129288, -0.03141403943300247, 0.03369727358222008, 0.09295425564050674, 0.003302894765511155, -0.007495812140405178, 0.045298267155885696, -0.016563035547733307, -0.021037256345152855, 0.02640407159924507, -0.01404352393001318, 0.060959551483392715, -0.017261074855923653, 0.000989354681223631, 0.0036803309340029955, -0.02693021297454834, 0.01800430379807949, 0.06473443657159805, -0.010016373358666897, -0.029075918719172478, -0.020247897133231163, 0.008716881275177002, -0.005646248813718557, -0.05704888328909874, -0.027885135263204575, 0.004878170322626829, -0.014470034278929234, -0.002869974821805954, 0.022596528753638268, -0.003298235824331641, -0.023025212809443474, -0.007381248753517866, 0.024021228775382042, 0.055997930467128754, 0.02690969407558441, -0.02491827681660652, -0.0010639703832566738, 0.024196388199925423, -0.023197608068585396, 0.000029593604267574847, 0.018260199576616287, -0.013267505913972855, -0.05892864987254143, 0.02993258461356163, -0.012500767596065998, 0.006271881051361561, 0.0075562638230621815, -0.003930830862373114, 0.03531034663319588, 0.021115494892001152, -0.055457379668951035, -0.0535898394882679, 0.04540325328707695, -0.03300517052412033, 0.012256745249032974, -0.06748328357934952, 0.0014303589705377817, 0.028963502496480942, 0.048243649303913116, 0.01202604454010725, 0.03808038309216499, -0.0030349052976816893, 0.014258437789976597, 0.02166237309575081, -0.04053538292646408, -0.050511617213487625, -0.016195029020309448, -0.023297902196645737, 0.02929968573153019, -0.05459107086062431, 0.0030128818470984697, 0.024488285183906555, -0.015776045620441437, -0.001815830240957439, 0.07623416930437088, 0.03566034510731697, -0.03580649942159653, -0.004265150986611843, 0.018000679090619087, -0.02572416141629219, 0.0678819790482521, -0.012222484685480595, 0.019503867253661156, -0.008447954431176186, 0.004128005355596542, 0.016614047810435295, -0.0286690816283226, 0.051278870552778244, 0.04257342219352722, 0.0034233639016747475, -0.02715061977505684, -0.02587646245956421, 0.02736820839345455, 0.043400052934885025, -0.048880379647016525, -0.01012694276869297, -0.032974325120449066, -0.028422841802239418, 0.010029492899775505, 0.08944030106067657, 0.006186787970364094, 0.00584982056170702, 0.03759467974305153, -0.03746899217367172, -0.022158022969961166, -0.04998001456260681, -0.01275127474218607, 0.009860232472419739, 0.008134320378303528, 0.04726136103272438, -0.007060886360704899, 0.06185578554868698, -0.022676214575767517, -0.03558731824159622, -0.017031356692314148, 0.01122177392244339, 0.03817296773195267, -0.03620805963873863, 0.012218647636473179, 0.016755053773522377, 0.04505442455410957, 0.0024197562597692013, 0.03542020544409752, -0.03420165181159973, -0.03390807658433914, 0.012180145829916, -0.05564604699611664, 0.02087872102856636, 0.0012985157081857324, -0.01876293122768402, 0.017284095287322998, -0.030463287606835365, 0.005530727561563253, 0.042225345969200134, -0.03554303199052811, 0.07189338654279709, 0.03469596803188324, 0.006829812191426754, -0.02077898569405079, 0.010891025885939598, 0.010249188169836998, 0.01933656632900238, -0.06304812431335449, -0.04056711122393608, -0.0667002722620964, -0.023742245510220528, 0.05366257205605507, 0.04803333804011345, -0.0552968755364418, 0.011874453164637089, 0.037197455763816833, 0.024299629032611847, 0.01863795332610607, 0.01697969250380993, -0.002167971571907401, -0.028244728222489357, 0.023769745603203773, -0.020587211474776268, 0.004159686621278524, 0.006483104079961777, 0.03240593150258064, 0.007566171232610941, 0.03583033010363579, -0.005687601864337921, -0.005857223644852638, 0.04655969515442848, 0.008392224088311195, -0.002043382730334997, 0.0027726897969841957, -0.010125148110091686, 0.07546734064817429, -0.023763038218021393, 0.02146868407726288, 0.015474950894713402, 0.011552286334335804, -0.0024567923974245787, 0.03417143598198891, 0.021457377821207047, 0.04338587820529938, 0.018266547471284866, -0.029901374131441116, -0.0018748969305306673, 0.011645205318927765, -0.053259119391441345, -0.007203415501862764, -0.02928842604160309, -0.03969965875148773, -0.015577550046145916, -0.003515642136335373, 0.02651906944811344, -0.00027515063993632793, 0.021237865090370178, 0.010546171106398106, -0.013487410731613636, 0.011226503178477287, -0.050096578896045685, 0.013814239762723446, -0.006336616352200508, -0.016722645610570908, 0.030980465933680534, -0.025726892054080963, -0.004519124049693346, 0.008988048881292343, 0.009675346314907074, 0.04031679406762123, 0.02050631120800972, -0.04011155664920807, -0.07951824367046356, -0.04231127351522446, -0.04951758682727814, 0.03717020899057388, -0.004277384839951992, -0.047554243355989456, 0.03777554631233215, -0.004183817654848099, -0.015014385804533958, 0.005266241729259491, -0.06187175586819649, 0.007706616073846817, -0.04622703790664673, 0.01151342038065195, -0.005019620060920715, -0.04620545729994774, 0.036716315895318985, 0.01677992194890976, -0.03328131139278412, -0.02432515099644661, -0.07189808040857315, -0.06877917051315308, 0.008906370028853416, 0.01605844870209694, 0.022114001214504242, -0.007535990793257952, -0.07119937241077423, 0.06328085064888, 0.061575889587402344, -0.013057269155979156, -0.012805837206542492, -0.02212303876876831, -0.021236445754766464, -0.05868079140782356, 0.02502065896987915, 0.011086263693869114, -0.016734331846237183, 0.06173428148031235, 0.002517311368137598, 0.025633780285716057, 0.03642147406935692, -0.022881489247083664, 0.015567612834274769, 0.02358601614832878, 0.020680192857980728, 0.01792847365140915, 0.040223073214292526, 0.03425843268632889, 0.007744267582893372, -0.016881395131349564, 0.002445436315611005, 0.025952303782105446, 0.03150278702378273, -0.004932259675115347, 0.04242464527487755, -0.0017369911074638367, -0.0376557894051075, -0.03009272739291191, 0.03498878702521324, 0.05882740393280983, -0.00722081121057272, -0.03920403867959976, -0.012820438481867313, 0.0007626207661814988, -0.009108035825192928, -0.007914050482213497, 0.032859861850738525, 0.02424803376197815, 0.005730446893721819, -0.05312759429216385, -0.030881721526384354, -0.011438118293881416, 0.0076480433344841, -0.022669196128845215, -0.03961961343884468, 0.03097582794725895, 0.018008876591920853, 0.020841149613261223, -0.0352681539952755, -0.04004150256514549, -0.021862944588065147, -0.07550613582134247, 0.027956552803516388, 0.017739905044436455, 0.08508908748626709, -0.005455333273857832, 0.021720686927437782, 0.021527964621782303, -0.0014953266363590956, 0.04022761434316635, -0.010205334983766079, -0.07387068122625351, 0.03829885274171829, -0.03369391709566116, -0.02505902387201786, 0.009796912781894207, 0.017456695437431335, 0.057549525052309036, -0.0509970597922802, 0.029057761654257774, -0.015580025501549244, 0.006750932428985834, -0.028232194483280182, -0.012876614928245544, -0.028507784008979797, -0.007793985307216644, 0.0019070184789597988, 0.009253487922251225, 0.016630273312330246, -0.038562044501304626, 0.003586800303310156, 0.05824699252843857, -0.0036576646380126476, 0.033226944506168365, -0.07036246359348297, 0.02045479789376259, 0.026083674281835556, 0.029535183683037758, 0.052196335047483444, -0.007727576419711113, -0.014002760872244835, 0.04540788009762764, 0.002899664919823408, 0.014325039461255074, 0.04204801470041275, -0.014502129517495632, -0.022891204804182053, -0.025176910683512688, -0.010991565883159637, 0.0006803765427321196, 0.05841648578643799, 0.020652998238801956, 0.010910640470683575, 0.05931735411286354, 0.021733149886131287, -0.014723425731062889, 0.011264169588685036, 0.03670285642147064, -0.013243296183645725, 0.003173717763274908, 0.003267868421971798, -0.011581466533243656, 0.0060822851955890656, -0.011046088300645351, 0.02890568971633911, -0.0019643164705485106, -0.026522373780608177, -0.012293459847569466, 0.032973553985357285, -0.0077788312919437885, -0.009040750563144684, 0.021656056866049767, 0.04075286164879799, 0.042147085070610046, 0.023700745776295662, -0.050043895840644836, 0.03379390761256218, 0.05634036660194397, 0.02821563370525837, 0.02345782332122326, 0.028545957058668137, -0.09677169471979141, 0.026665814220905304, 0.0276879221200943, -0.000059687605244107544, -0.032822348177433014, -0.03522452339529991, -0.030848510563373566, 0.006581384222954512, 0.05420239642262459, -0.0436827577650547, 0.0519586056470871, 0.011975550092756748, -0.019825568422675133, -0.007978095673024654, -0.04960227757692337, -0.05376758426427841, 0.034715089946985245, 0.012124704197049141, 0.044991347938776016, 0.0038280640728771687, -0.01613677851855755, -0.03481583297252655, 0.011278829537332058, -0.015495574101805687, 0.07829771190881729, -0.029586108401417732, -0.0015990001847967505, 0.0022097178734838963, 0.06201953813433647, -0.006618525832891464, -0.04037618637084961, 0.0008494161302223802, 0.0241593848913908, -0.008877764455974102, 0.023670455440878868, 0.0033285163808614016, -0.0564134307205677, 0.034471672028303146, 0.019873250275850296, -0.015438001602888107, -0.0022135251201689243, -0.03293992951512337, 0.06325095146894455, 0.0429689921438694, 0.025824686512351036, 0.07765653729438782, 0.045189447700977325, -0.00016625541320536286, -0.00040692550828680396, 0.0015342197148129344, -0.011105610989034176, -0.03610968962311745, -0.009170976467430592, -0.026876414194703102, 0.008659806102514267, -0.025816479697823524, 0.02418258599936962, -0.007933040149509907, 0.0416388064622879, -0.008958390913903713, -0.007295885123312473, 0.012934647500514984, 0.049420036375522614, -0.016163000836968422, -0.007202639244496822, -0.013127361424267292, 0.016095632687211037, -0.034890200942754745, -0.030464166775345802, 0.010674548335373402, -0.01020880974829197, -0.01103200577199459, -0.011477679945528507, -0.025385955348610878, 0.031243130564689636, -0.01167272962629795, -0.006522648967802525, 0.015577111393213272, -0.0068034278228878975, 0.018330102786421776, 0.0210844986140728, 0.0231404360383749, 0.012628035619854927, -0.03426462411880493, -0.0022765842732042074, 0.026186149567365646, 0.0013721653958782554, 0.028200164437294006, -0.06792069971561432, 0.03579432889819145, -0.028922060504555702, -0.027818549424409866, -0.07335825264453888, -0.05392928794026375, 0.027933450415730476, -0.0011927010491490364, -0.04506267234683037, -0.03472095727920532, -0.003572680987417698, -0.014615201391279697, -0.0317685641348362, -0.021060597151517868, 0.06337419897317886, 0.006100933998823166, -0.030081719160079956, -0.01546915341168642, 0.0661424845457077, 0.05964575707912445, 0.022826842963695526, -0.003915189299732447, 0.01952160708606243, -0.02919180318713188, -0.031227556988596916, 0.007436418440192938, 0.03253760561347008, -0.02830057591199875, 0.018522556871175766, -0.031070562079548836, -0.016155831515789032, 0.01774171181023121, -0.03744922950863838, -0.04642397165298462, 0.050968755036592484, 0.015438564121723175, -0.005786136258393526, -0.0263422392308712, 0.031087014824151993, -0.006800565402954817, 0.016508188098669052, 0.0077136787585914135, -0.014245540834963322, 0.02092546597123146, -0.025751376524567604, 0.008325818926095963, 0.02557368017733097, -0.027713816612958908, 0.025687437504529953, 0.041068125516176224, -0.032054733484983444, 0.0042968872003257275, 0.029421167448163033, -0.0035536340437829494, 0.0340135395526886, 0.002874301979318261, 0.0020828223787248135, -0.0004187061858829111, 0.008651435375213623, -0.06453265994787216, -0.053824055939912796, -0.0034267983864992857, 0.0002152168599423021, 0.0713002011179924, -0.019356943666934967, 0.05242951214313507, 0.02377956546843052, -0.011157679371535778, 0.0015232800506055355, -0.03005119226872921, -0.026649411767721176, -0.026735328137874603, -0.04152201488614082, 0.03955252096056938, -0.03326994925737381, -0.024631233885884285, -0.002491151914000511, -0.0031602077651768923, 0.0015103912446647882, 0.020179959014058113, -0.008951344527304173, 0.0009342320263385773, -0.026724904775619507, -0.012804335914552212, -0.05435400828719139, 0.026835743337869644, -0.025796320289373398, 0.014157375320792198, -0.05751648172736168, -0.010038390755653381, 0.0832424908876419, 0.013446343131363392, 0.043387237936258316, -0.06445446610450745, -0.07692524045705795, -0.03798908367753029, -0.024297460913658142, 0.03693069517612457, 0.005129572469741106, 0.052484963089227676, 0.03183067589998245, 0.010683350265026093, -0.0011103677097707987, 0.022783396765589714, -0.02644057385623455, -0.07990632951259613, -0.017085349187254906, -0.02104688063263893, -0.018590807914733887, 0.05977805703878403, -0.023357989266514778, -0.04499658942222595, 0.021699262782931328, -0.04205430671572685, -0.0026594572700560093, 0.02694506011903286, 0.021760156378149986, -0.0008114663069136441, 0.09394407272338867, 0.010492537170648575, 0.014539125375449657, 0.008543800562620163, -0.016506509855389595, 0.10498201847076416, 0.08039788901805878, 0.0435790978372097, -0.05158441513776779, 0.01692182384431362, -0.03485926240682602, 0.01144583709537983, -0.052808064967393875, 0.024135876446962357, -0.0050702509470283985, -0.008804496377706528, 0.025737840682268143, 0.06204492598772049, -0.0009490952361375093, -0.0005305084050633013, 0.04980526864528656, -0.03510214388370514, 0.005238181445747614, 0.014634063467383385, 0.007665625307708979, 0.013055805116891861, 0.009825211018323898, -0.002803815295919776, 0.015871882438659668, -0.02419016882777214, 0.003726708237081766, 0.007083121687173843, -0.034853119403123856, 0.027495957911014557, -0.018285682424902916, -0.017344774678349495, -0.0008695060387253761, 0.05283553525805473, 0.03298087790608406, -0.03889494761824608, -0.0116460882127285, -0.006547252647578716, -0.011772624216973782, 0.042963460087776184, -0.0009601357160136104, 0.003667183220386505, -0.03338996693491936, 0.028020592406392097, 0.02947310544550419, -0.04506390914320946, -0.02724754996597767, -0.03200831264257431, 0.05291749909520149, -0.018242772668600082, -0.021931419149041176, -0.008650284260511398, -0.006618799176067114, -0.013951760716736317, -0.048127178102731705, -0.013451575301587582, 0.019868576899170876, 0.015740586444735527, -0.03179311007261276, 0.0009325277642346919, -0.05547011271119118, 0.02125350572168827, 0.01904480718076229, 0.05206131562590599, -0.011620590463280678, -0.046954985707998276, -0.012709613889455795, 0.010840843431651592, 0.05746657773852348, -0.029422927647829056, -0.027062006294727325, -0.00042093286174349487, 0.01871206983923912, -0.04056897014379501, -0.007663323078304529, 0.02637210488319397, -0.00598782766610384, 0.02102375216782093, -0.010149125941097736, -0.030544498935341835, -0.03139786422252655, -0.04652409628033638, 0.015554213896393776, -0.024098731577396393, 0.021598489955067635, -0.052253980189561844, 0.024128351360559464, 0.04428577795624733, 0.03542163223028183, 0.027131451293826103, -0.015779156237840652, -0.011021551676094532, 0.04035412520170212, 0.03135969862341881, -0.058941446244716644, -0.02394135482609272, -0.01056179404258728, -0.01539340615272522, -0.018631163984537125, -0.03628791496157646, 0.017798447981476784, 0.010340225882828236, 0.006647156085819006, -0.014309960417449474, 0.013894669711589813, -0.02987181767821312, 0.03936796635389328, 0.004893491975963116, -0.03424939885735512, -0.016854962334036827, 0.02235037460923195, 0.0177192110568285, 0.01353372074663639, -0.005281923338770866, -0.01449856348335743, -0.01589852385222912, -0.014310185797512531, 0.004651196766644716, -0.05196737125515938, 0.007076960988342762, -0.02340298891067505, 0.0029181656427681446, -0.05407368764281273, 0.013873371295630932, -0.015511914156377316, 0.015127891674637794, -0.012613961473107338, -0.00990571454167366, -0.02004193887114525, 0.013774644583463669, -0.04957115277647972, 0.0016774636460468173, 0.03675214946269989, 0.04374295100569725, 0.0005682757473550737, -0.01545635238289833, 0.017392655834555626, -0.02005583606660366, 0.023072687909007072, -0.048648569732904434, -0.03598972037434578, 0.018654555082321167, -0.011928998865187168, -0.0467248409986496, 0.03053029254078865, 0.002789351623505354, 0.038288284093141556, 0.007960567250847816, 0.014343755319714546, -0.03556365519762039, 0.04109170287847519, -0.009430340491235256, 0.0076835970394313335, 0.0002085398737108335, -0.02394787035882473, 0.015768734738230705, -0.004753436893224716, 0.042674604803323746, 0.020337656140327454, -0.0020862368401139975, 0.016181761398911476, 0.03716440126299858, -0.013528242707252502, 0.004176441114395857, -0.01835179328918457, -0.004202490672469139, 0.04050864279270172, 0.00776697788387537, -0.011809119954705238, 0.052604369819164276, 0.05058624595403671, -0.02320384979248047, -0.013586506247520447, 0.002349302638322115, 0.010417094454169273, -0.05148043483495712, -0.011765864677727222, -0.01786019653081894, 0.026709064841270447, 0.030156563967466354, -0.04299522563815117, 0.01792997680604458, 0.0069574760273098946, -0.014006726443767548, -0.003579534124583006, -0.027047613635659218, -0.012705462984740734, -0.027844171971082687, -0.010276451706886292, -0.04040316864848137, 0.022256342694163322, 0.07367058843374252, 0.030784351751208305, 0.014515918679535389, 0.02516888454556465, 0.05245973914861679, -0.013068731874227524, -0.0013840805040672421, 0.0053595444187521935, 0.03734184801578522, -0.04243147373199463, 0.04451959952712059, -0.05200505629181862, -0.005462089087814093, 0.041541386395692825, -0.015337647870182991, 0.034430623054504395, -0.008304394781589508, 0.01445664931088686, 0.015270130708813667, 0.03622514754533768, 0.000460446608485654, -0.012929349206387997, -0.03111748956143856, -0.021349603310227394, 0.0080797728151083, -0.00434543052688241, -0.011080498807132244, -0.014687824994325638, 0.010536215268075466, -0.012875654734671116, -0.01865684799849987, -0.00551439868286252, 0.00898426678031683, -0.020939616486430168, -0.029722748324275017, 0.01804635487496853, 0.027986660599708557, 0.003132214304059744, 0.02570945955812931, -0.07390831410884857, 0.003721098881214857, 0.030937258154153824, -0.006401554681360722, -0.053656987845897675, -0.0019552246667444706, -0.020347274839878082, -0.04037056490778923, 0.04622098058462143, -0.019105909392237663, -0.008371779695153236, -0.0815441906452179, -0.03302992507815361, 0.020293470472097397, -0.04225168377161026, -0.027781324461102486, 0.004853950347751379, -0.009740056470036507, 0.05009707808494568, -0.019543757662177086, 0.005905788391828537, -0.007281722966581583, -0.007588321343064308, 0.021984964609146118, -0.0576411709189415, 0.04778989404439926, -0.00039654879947192967, -0.03262342885136604, -0.0013683054130524397, -0.03172776848077774, -0.04232107475399971, 0.006326459348201752, 0.06926704943180084, -0.01734902523458004, -0.007113134954124689, 0.04028186947107315, 0.005335902329534292, -0.033308323472738266, -0.004835674539208412, 0.004562187474220991, -0.01926782913506031, -0.03800530731678009, 0.006417272612452507, -0.026853594928979874, 0.009851183742284775, 0.007381007075309753, 0.03490523248910904, -0.02448461763560772, 0.008769024163484573, 0.021822458133101463, 0.01267825998365879, 0.012377751991152763, -0.007739202119410038, -0.0073027294129133224, 0.061214495450258255, 0.01159608643501997, 0.02286539599299431, 0.0011220021406188607, 0.000026161536879953928, -0.07154609262943268, 0.01546789426356554, -0.000831330253276974, -0.030620422214269638, -0.022723184898495674, 0.0073000723496079445, -0.010908538475632668, -0.01585053838789463, -0.028673391789197922, 0.02399095706641674, -0.02658918872475624, 0.0018142330227419734, 0.03098156489431858, 0.007306116167455912, 0.024396425113081932, -0.004894800949841738, -0.002485360484570265, 0.04552408307790756, 0.012850708328187466, 0.02688019722700119, -0.017933227121829987, 0.018869148567318916, 0.031635742634534836, -0.016866115853190422, -0.0033832225017249584, -0.017140332609415054, 0.031404055655002594, -0.042189955711364746, 0.028955671936273575, -0.020378874614834785, -0.028149770572781563, 0.013128207996487617, -0.017143715173006058, 0.007663678843528032, 0.008294194005429745, 0.010703761130571365, 0.04470159858465195, -0.013144762255251408, -0.014409895986318588, -0.018252920359373093, -0.023309631273150444, -0.021895453333854675, 0.0046182493679225445, 0.00727382767945528, 0.008645513094961643, -0.0131171690300107, 0.026374420151114464, 0.005633281543850899, -0.025444597005844116, -0.004973365925252438, -0.0725645124912262, -0.012645712122321129, -0.008416778407990932, -0.034873686730861664, -0.019565392285585403, -0.035446714609861374, -0.043625831604003906, -0.027705036103725433, 0.012222858145833015, 0.06439609080553055, 0.03771468624472618, -0.0337182879447937, -0.02636566199362278, 0.011301344260573387, 0.06321245431900024, -0.08068671077489853, -0.011472361162304878, -0.015690602362155914, -0.009450562298297882, 0.016490623354911804, -0.05975908786058426 ]
<p>Consider a kind of auction where you are presented with, say, 1000 prospective clients. Based on information about these prospectives--age, sex, race, income, educational achievement and the like--you may 'bid' to pitch your product to some fraction of them, say 250. (Ignore the cost of bidding.) To maximize your chances of selecting the right subset, I would probably use a model of our product's 'likability' built using logistic regression. I can fumble my way through this part well enough.</p> <p>However, to <em>build</em> the model of product likability, I have to do some market research, testing the product pitch on subjects that we may recruit from the population at large. This is actually fairly costly. Moreover, it should probably be tuned to the demographics of the population from which the prospectives are drawn. For example, a factorial design, say, might ask us to recruit test subjects in equal proportion across the levels of the race factor, when in reality we are likely to encounter very few Native Americans, say, in the 1000 prospectives, and can simply choose not to pitch to them at all as a rule. (Sad, but true.)</p> <p>How should such an experiment be designed? To be concrete, the design variables are all categorical and ordinal factors, the bidding fraction is an input parameter (1/4 in the example quoted above), as is the maximum number of subjects that can be recruited. It seems like maybe some mix of experimental design and random sampling might be appropriate, but I am open to all reasonable suggestions and pointers. </p> <p>I should also note that given the likely small effect sizes and the small sample recruitment pools that we can afford, it is unlikely that the market research will yield statistically significant regression coefficients. And so overoptimizing the experimental design is probably silly, and any reasonably non-insane procedure will suffice. </p>
31,335
[ -0.009072678163647652, -0.020947465673089027, 0.022240422666072845, -0.019336916506290436, 0.02500784769654274, 0.005189624615013599, -0.016912203282117844, -0.022242149338126183, 0.033256903290748596, 0.009979890659451485, 0.02061275765299797, 0.0363563634455204, 0.009999619796872139, -0.0032261775340884924, 0.013691343367099762, 0.012859586626291275, -0.026028288528323174, -0.007151059340685606, 0.005458966828882694, 0.01155239250510931, 0.0529492124915123, 0.01440439559519291, -0.017385438084602356, -0.0008965440792962909, -0.017813796177506447, 0.03130878880620003, 0.001298408256843686, -0.05537773668766022, -0.0002297389437444508, 0.050469789654016495, -0.0315011702477932, -0.01770368590950966, 0.01764843985438347, 0.001600567251443863, 0.05187215656042099, 0.029623020440340042, -0.008798092603683472, -0.04527781531214714, -0.031165102496743202, -0.0009160921326838434, -0.06898520886898041, 0.005018122028559446, -0.0003731219912879169, 0.0010952563025057316, -0.007714345119893551, 0.0022312947548925877, -0.006492969114333391, -0.04625975713133812, 0.02093791961669922, -0.06655285507440567, 0.03033500723540783, -0.002671264810487628, 0.004511828534305096, 0.004957655910402536, -0.026531845331192017, -0.022269167006015778, 0.04727105423808098, 0.05783237889409065, -0.022203143686056137, -0.013615023344755173, -0.011921428143978119, -0.027128439396619797, 0.010270205326378345, -0.018369391560554504, -0.026534317061305046, -0.008447526022791862, 0.0016465903026983142, -0.004259936977177858, 0.02787608467042446, -0.058334335684776306, 0.04731040447950363, 0.01865602843463421, 0.01185661368072033, 0.030582526698708534, 0.0035753948614001274, -0.011920769698917866, 0.01127586979418993, 0.0332176499068737, 0.03157758712768555, 0.027901630848646164, -0.031982965767383575, -0.010765875689685345, -0.01124363299459219, 0.058827079832553864, 0.003937869798392057, -0.014533882029354572, 0.03521496057510376, -0.055670782923698425, 0.019525017589330673, 0.041002705693244934, -0.02013072371482849, 0.00031880461028777063, 0.05207596719264984, 0.016385246068239212, -0.0496411994099617, 0.022157324478030205, -0.007105981465429068, 0.0549832358956337, -0.02380823902785778, -0.03365917131304741, -0.014402355067431927, -0.019510645419359207, -0.04849477484822273, 0.06851530820131302, -0.015944737941026688, -0.02987169660627842, 0.01104696374386549, -0.006532761733978987, 0.02621186338365078, -0.0318288691341877, 0.007057493086904287, 0.02146049216389656, -0.027378443628549576, -0.015100555494427681, 0.011426315642893314, -0.01674541085958481, 0.006846922915428877, -0.017930220812559128, 0.07644128054380417, 0.02756429836153984, 0.03001871146261692, -0.026246005669236183, 0.049793925136327744, 0.02398630604147911, -0.018729154020547867, 0.03942987695336342, 0.0221742894500494, -0.0009415145614184439, -0.02255639061331749, 0.005681601352989674, 0.03723366931080818, 0.003331274725496769, 0.03638860583305359, 0.017852116376161575, 0.005305781494826078, 0.01488589309155941, -0.0710740014910698, -0.05483047664165497, 0.022414792329072952, -0.00744755519554019, 0.024508612230420113, -0.09042126685380936, 0.004748333711177111, 0.012780943885445595, 0.07094735652208328, 0.007642603479325771, 0.04854296147823334, 0.009173725731670856, 0.014031774364411831, 0.04867388308048248, -0.030989371240139008, -0.01917380467057228, -0.0421094112098217, 0.000461926800198853, -0.029821861535310745, -0.06719322502613068, 0.015485723502933979, 0.00929251592606306, 0.0073484149761497974, -0.006031605415046215, 0.03397553414106369, 0.006430531851947308, -0.0217788927257061, -0.007640652824193239, 0.026656338945031166, -0.008329303003847599, 0.06493302434682846, -0.004551067017018795, 0.013460340909659863, 0.01850481703877449, -0.011245828121900558, 0.033681731671094894, 0.01747642271220684, 0.03338668867945671, 0.044922683387994766, -0.03570534288883209, 0.02728407084941864, -0.017842547968029976, 0.038423746824264526, -0.018405647948384285, -0.006309857591986656, -0.01508890651166439, -0.005290396977216005, -0.011072359047830105, 0.028590822592377663, 0.019494034349918365, 0.007525715511292219, -0.006545661017298698, 0.05680025368928909, -0.0561029426753521, -0.08126967400312424, -0.07191233336925507, -0.000960238219704479, 0.02709771692752838, -0.029672691598534584, 0.03355824574828148, -0.025803515687584877, -0.003360394388437271, -0.0004298481799196452, -0.013308686204254627, -0.03674100339412689, 0.005549192428588867, 0.0650787353515625, -0.008073358796536922, -0.005627048201858997, 0.09553498774766922, 0.005072016268968582, -0.02363862842321396, 0.02490539476275444, -0.014363388530910015, -0.07973548024892807, -0.029977232217788696, -0.0015957297291606665, 0.03130991756916046, 0.003248757217079401, -0.009922396391630173, 0.025135133415460587, 0.009913248009979725, -0.017378346994519234, 0.06773693859577179, -0.07300358265638351, 0.07491286844015121, 0.0365406759083271, -0.0118583794683218, -0.0058151050470769405, 0.039664093405008316, 0.029580295085906982, -0.009050674736499786, 0.0065447138622403145, 0.0022392470855265856, -0.043256454169750214, 0.004997607786208391, 0.05763373523950577, -0.00497968727722764, -0.031109269708395004, 0.017531944438815117, 0.07729548215866089, 0.0437309630215168, 0.04065996780991554, 0.027163822203874588, -0.001611548475921154, -0.013042225502431393, 0.0055407024919986725, 0.019475964829325676, 0.012117200531065464, 0.0325981080532074, 0.021074289456009865, -0.01154085248708725, -0.000004337496648076922, 0.021905425935983658, 0.01790507510304451, 0.03497213497757912, 0.039389342069625854, 0.0045909034088253975, -0.002845093607902527, 0.015970740467309952, 0.007875368930399418, -0.02282128855586052, -0.017652949318289757, -0.012045076116919518, 0.015119287185370922, 0.0033360635861754417, -0.03297990933060646, -0.036350224167108536, 0.01888931915163994, 0.04917595908045769, -0.009075074456632137, 0.04389554634690285, 0.01568019390106201, -0.05542178079485893, -0.017450809478759766, -0.03288672864437103, -0.02190306782722473, -0.04218266159296036, -0.000511344987899065, 0.014435517601668835, 0.01051560789346695, 0.020755618810653687, -0.014079923741519451, -0.02007438801229, -0.004086857195943594, 0.02304725907742977, 0.0015571063850075006, 0.021658405661582947, -0.06743134558200836, -0.07013823091983795, -0.014631732366979122, -0.028148364275693893, 0.05243833363056183, 0.02931961789727211, -0.027637530118227005, 0.043213218450546265, -0.0007727546035312116, -0.031665705144405365, -0.015767915174365044, -0.034108687192201614, -0.000501519360113889, -0.04520121589303017, -0.02641133777797222, 0.031265053898096085, 0.042632538825273514, -0.024152036756277084, 0.020009571686387062, -0.013339566998183727, -0.05121361091732979, -0.04366888105869293, -0.027520613744854927, 0.00890106800943613, -0.019379176199436188, 0.0026027767453342676, 0.005723052658140659, 0.005996862426400185, -0.011342735029757023, -0.0813400149345398, -0.09861239045858383, 0.0021941042505204678, -0.01202380657196045, 0.02172122709453106, 0.025485308840870857, 0.011425262317061424, 0.08245640993118286, 0.012101676315069199, -0.011640983633697033, -0.05081932619214058, -0.00885856430977583, -0.0039628348313272, -0.026158563792705536, 0.028087113052606583, 0.04821253940463066, -0.01781635731458664, 0.04434371739625931, -0.0062503330409526825, 0.011927835643291473, 0.028728162869811058, -0.00573302386328578, -0.006218979600816965, 0.021843766793608665, -0.014125789515674114, -0.002545965136960149, 0.022217558696866035, 0.04783304035663605, -0.04386579990386963, 0.062748022377491, -0.013015655800700188, 0.0022325320169329643, 0.02674185112118721, -0.05249488353729248, 0.010154739022254944, -0.04036741331219673, -0.02838693931698799, 0.023347770795226097, 0.011001423001289368, -0.028117630630731583, -0.033506929874420166, -0.021883925423026085, 0.03952303156256676, 0.03941255807876587, -0.005723494570702314, 0.010706320405006409, 0.041479457169771194, 0.03419005125761032, -0.024522054940462112, 0.008584843017160892, -0.00381888123229146, -0.028259344398975372, 0.0078370226547122, 0.005221120081841946, 0.026999488472938538, 0.005500100553035736, 0.032072991132736206, 0.04642127826809883, -0.004206337500363588, -0.01401581335812807, -0.0073168231174349785, -0.03768657520413399, -0.01801859773695469, -0.06320303678512573, 0.04500875622034073, -0.00906513910740614, 0.04802854731678963, 0.00007244827429531142, 0.0133442971855402, -0.03632828965783119, 0.018078738823533058, -0.0804189071059227, 0.03659223020076752, -0.010780539363622665, 0.04168960452079773, -0.00019043889187742025, -0.011629673652350903, 0.06626170128583908, -0.015568873845040798, -0.004034065641462803, -0.02186366729438305, 0.045889273285865784, -0.0015394166111946106, 0.02069661021232605, -0.020021487027406693, -0.033002059906721115, 0.010910163633525372, 0.021946066990494728, -0.009948506020009518, 0.004997421056032181, 0.008610470220446587, 0.019032007083296776, 0.008395785465836525, -0.024668073281645775, -0.005298054777085781, 0.002271906938403845, -0.006850751582533121, 0.06080015003681183, -0.013314160518348217, 0.003602644195780158, -0.04249594360589981, 0.03308017551898956, 0.0028535022865980864, 0.06765396147966385, 0.01331303734332323, 0.033833228051662445, -0.03578132018446922, -0.02848576381802559, -0.03507855907082558, 0.02800222858786583, 0.011105101555585861, 0.005365678574889898, -0.025877924636006355, 0.055954709649086, 0.04793267324566841, -0.037422992289066315, 0.0027301697991788387, 0.06173257157206535, 0.020957069471478462, -0.01251451950520277, -0.0032367121893912554, -0.0028411815874278545, 0.021119367331266403, 0.008352011442184448, 0.0023582533467561007, 0.022877801209688187, -0.019682101905345917, -0.010726287961006165, 0.03701971098780632, 0.006637029815465212, -0.05593693628907204, 0.016598135232925415, -0.014466775581240654, 0.07491513341665268, -0.03322731703519821, -0.026740146800875664, -0.029397448524832726, 0.052304863929748535, 0.011713172309100628, 0.015348145738244057, -0.020665673539042473, -0.09341078996658325, 0.000005543591669265879, 0.03441813215613365, 0.03805588558316231, -0.040928613394498825, 0.006013330537825823, -0.003272764617577195, 0.026388121768832207, -0.0009759081294760108, -0.019484998658299446, 0.030217573046684265, -0.02527429349720478, 0.027800455689430237, -0.051892101764678955, 0.017272375524044037, -0.02777712605893612, -0.005304214544594288, 0.015202410519123077, 0.010250448249280453, 0.014080297201871872, 0.000859198858961463, -0.03821387514472008, 0.05415455624461174, 0.03856610506772995, 0.07423140108585358, -0.05019824579358101, -0.03983538597822189, 0.03518395498394966, -0.039663057774305344, -0.036138392984867096, -0.05814439803361893, 0.010510464198887348, 0.009669541381299496, 0.013070862740278244, 0.050466179847717285, 0.013022979721426964, -0.036204852163791656, 0.03985485062003136, 0.007051809225231409, 0.003681923495605588, 0.03715462610125542, -0.05267363414168358, -0.00810836162418127, 0.014345310628414154, 0.03677548095583916, 0.04718909412622452, 0.023532787337899208, -0.012284770607948303, 0.049018532037734985, 0.013797547668218613, -0.011149105615913868, -0.016608543694019318, -0.03447999060153961, -0.037397727370262146, -0.002006387338042259, -0.020653851330280304, 0.015650631859898567, 0.007873713038861752, -0.0030117779970169067, -0.05367371067404747, -0.05465159937739372, -0.04602887108922005, 0.002362751867622137, 0.022248759865760803, -0.023995868861675262, 0.056316543370485306, 0.017021555453538895, 0.0071878195740282536, -0.0009515791316516697, 0.004808231722563505, -0.02307775430381298, 0.035523559898138046, 0.022846989333629608, -0.04524173587560654, 0.007401648908853531, -0.05054355785250664, -0.026484237983822823, 0.007293961010873318, -0.014603344723582268, 0.06321045756340027, -0.019588513299822807, 0.048845093697309494, 0.006666929926723242, -0.06117117404937744, -0.00586629007011652, 0.03432735428214073, 0.030679848045110703, 0.030769584700465202, 0.008114580065011978, -0.010350128635764122, -0.026729026809334755, -0.005451628938317299, -0.052756648510694504, -0.0012430482311174273, 0.0252833291888237, 0.02975223772227764, -0.013510772958397865, -0.01457411888986826, 0.005119481589645147, -0.016738131642341614, -0.032528575509786606, -0.0008143938612192869, 0.0739196240901947, -0.011062628589570522, 0.036722615361213684, -0.022080978378653526, 0.029072625562548637, 0.028397101908922195, 0.03800511732697487, -0.02704273909330368, 0.030200930312275887, -0.009078023955225945, 0.018547555431723595, -0.03395261615514755, -0.019189054146409035, -0.027778636664152145, -0.014363684691488743, -0.02258058823645115, -0.00833188183605671, 0.009631723165512085, 0.0027494574896991253, -0.00285635725595057, 0.006647361908107996, -0.009443117305636406, 0.02631247229874134, -0.03080642782151699, -0.0005882910918444395, -0.002406775951385498, -0.0033140883315354586, -0.012240433134138584, 0.02190307341516018, -0.007475258782505989, 0.0020600587595254183, 0.010399376042187214, 0.015465621836483479, -0.0002188979124184698, 0.02303609438240528, 0.048072706907987595, 0.010739690624177456, -0.04389353096485138, 0.02495223470032215, -0.005240400787442923, 0.07473906129598618, 0.034676965326070786, 0.0032271004747599363, -0.021588480100035667, 0.0505855455994606, 0.027860822156071663, -0.0362529493868351, -0.017594102770090103, -0.003420490538701415, 0.04623686522245407, -0.023420818150043488, 0.04229900985956192, 0.07661817967891693, -0.024134045466780663, -0.028965996578335762, -0.0069159395061433315, 0.018481388688087463, -0.016127901151776314, -0.02449776977300644, 0.03424752131104469, 0.026030413806438446, 0.00741958012804389, 0.00901272613555193, 0.007624330464750528, 0.037258442491292953, 0.029178746044635773, 0.03275154531002045, 0.07155688107013702, -0.003374650841578841, -0.08752951771020889, -0.025263071060180664, 0.04791731759905815, -0.0796198919415474, 0.04372887313365936, -0.05600043758749962, -0.025909552350640297, 0.0015078174183145165, 0.023929189890623093, 0.02763894945383072, -0.04374440759420395, -0.01611185073852539, -0.018904488533735275, -0.001112747355364263, 0.026655027642846107, -0.02304585836827755, 0.031171957030892372, -0.010652662254869938, 0.005557273514568806, 0.0031011435203254223, 0.01836615987122059, -0.011177759617567062, -0.03961383178830147, -0.030276630073785782, -0.006721756421029568, -0.06916438043117523, 0.036161091178655624, 0.012950886972248554, 0.026560481637716293, 0.029820213094353676, -0.0479036346077919, -0.03350568562746048, 0.010618703439831734, -0.024690482765436172, -0.03372343257069588, 0.022731108590960503, 0.04022330418229103, 0.030068835243582726, -0.02939026616513729, 0.03163529932498932, 0.14915676414966583, 0.09264924377202988, 0.029813338071107864, -0.028292382135987282, 0.044132404029369354, -0.019713614135980606, -0.00908865686506033, -0.0063589951023459435, 0.0063596139661967754, -0.02483089081943035, 0.02187304012477398, 0.017116952687501907, 0.03447137400507927, 0.006330056581646204, 0.032912254333496094, 0.026553619652986526, -0.04418913647532463, -0.02512870542705059, 0.032202549278736115, -0.006824258714914322, 0.012803706340491772, -0.014782029204070568, -0.017180368304252625, -0.00913836807012558, -0.007626635488122702, -0.004000119864940643, 0.019529549404978752, -0.053706731647253036, 0.004812745843082666, 0.0014071994228288531, 0.026796147227287292, 0.00996408611536026, 0.01365337148308754, 0.010354682803153992, -0.004758903291076422, -0.022097116336226463, 0.010687058791518211, -0.05183956399559975, 0.004265747033059597, 0.009784214198589325, 0.01283255871385336, 0.006190251559019089, 0.016685795038938522, 0.03178447484970093, -0.03184916079044342, -0.014696506783366203, -0.03635725378990173, 0.010136655531823635, -0.0444161519408226, -0.028233235701918602, -0.04867769777774811, 0.034157078713178635, -0.00968342274427414, -0.04482068121433258, -0.040221985429525375, 0.044600293040275574, 0.026523254811763763, -0.006211985368281603, -0.026005716994404793, 0.036271337419748306, 0.01875484175980091, -0.0029768208041787148, -0.0020452579483389854, 0.021183036267757416, -0.039257317781448364, -0.01860140636563301, -0.012050322256982327, 0.025750163942575455, 0.024408847093582153, -0.036540184170007706, -0.019228650256991386, -0.022260840982198715, -0.04594457894563675, -0.014942568726837635, -0.03360752388834953, -0.011033088900148869, 0.00884322077035904, -0.01903083547949791, 0.017610982060432434, -0.05256491154432297, 0.016764041036367416, -0.020088786259293556, -0.0024779655504971743, -0.026305975392460823, -0.05847290903329849, -0.018051421269774437, -0.01613716036081314, 0.00026816813624463975, -0.018526658415794373, 0.011754481121897697, -0.0033796224743127823, 0.06019997596740723, 0.0023593436926603317, -0.036518171429634094, -0.0213340912014246, -0.020456286147236824, -0.043216753751039505, 0.019640464335680008, -0.005762344226241112, 0.057114023715257645, -0.037875235080718994, 0.01366729848086834, 0.035373128950595856, -0.020786715671420097, -0.02597939968109131, 0.011629405431449413, 0.06732264161109924, -0.07344779372215271, -0.023886390030384064, 0.0054941326379776, -0.016298562288284302, -0.02993648499250412, -0.05327543616294861, -0.029551982879638672, -0.019697681069374084, -0.013781723566353321, -0.02518831565976143, -0.0050115021876990795, 0.017833247780799866, -0.028904378414154053, 0.02587002143263817, -0.03903154656291008, -0.01745438575744629, -0.055488478392362595, 0.0249014962464571, -0.0234085563570261, 0.03989288583397865, 0.009365491569042206, -0.028033532202243805, -0.00673945527523756, 0.0038145920261740685, 0.011670079082250595, 0.012998980470001698, -0.025312354788184166, -0.013457834720611572, 0.016544928774237633, 0.005173049867153168, 0.0064511653035879135, -0.016046181321144104, -0.030425552278757095, 0.04457250237464905, -0.05828044191002846, -0.03253954276442528, -0.013598625548183918, -0.032803598791360855, 0.05045272037386894, 0.015692219138145447, -0.002144542522728443, 0.005380733869969845, 0.055804941803216934, -0.0013234138023108244, -0.03812793269753456, 0.02376122958958149, 0.035633210092782974, 0.04583943262696266, -0.02815754897892475, 0.006679421290755272, 0.000805365911219269, -0.021590011194348335, 0.07881257683038712, 0.00804851669818163, -0.011228719726204872, -0.02939211204648018, -0.003545294748619199, -0.008143440820276737, 0.007334612775593996, -0.0030924545135349035, -0.025520671159029007, 0.008898978121578693, -0.006809592712670565, -0.02796231023967266, 0.01657976396381855, -0.002362519968301058, 0.010302691720426083, -0.07069644331932068, -0.02942873165011406, 0.0046415370889008045, 0.014149042777717113, 0.036708611994981766, -0.04320000484585762, 0.00330385472625494, 0.0009013235685415566, -0.057704418897628784, 0.00787566602230072, 0.015878649428486824, 0.02007659338414669, -0.04852672293782234, -0.002224209951236844, -0.026536524295806885, -0.006790591403841972, 0.023770371451973915, 0.0043846177868545055, 0.0040902323089540005, 0.00726630724966526, 0.00018174432625528425, -0.010297097265720367, 0.008407738991081715, 0.03959274664521217, -0.026219114661216736, -0.05137704312801361, 0.06592422723770142, -0.021132558584213257, -0.022814804688096046, 0.03520464897155762, 0.03495346009731293, 0.039545245468616486, 0.030070748180150986, 0.01817314885556698, -0.01203911378979683, 0.03227965533733368, 0.0331251360476017, 0.05086991563439369, 0.04219566658139229, 0.0334247462451458, 0.02363058552145958, 0.044623829424381256, -0.006061346735805273, 0.02393164485692978, 0.031583573669195175, 0.0022238793317228556, -0.01551172137260437, 0.020458178594708443, -0.04960227012634277, -0.017690815031528473, 0.029830994084477425, 0.0007641341653652489, 0.011291662231087685, -0.004619474522769451, 0.03549536317586899, -0.0478607602417469, -0.027690540999174118, 0.009703078307211399, 0.024487055838108063, 0.014370144344866276, -0.002381129190325737, -0.036769893020391464, -0.012027110904455185, 0.038389042019844055, 0.005642856936901808, 0.014638401567935944, -0.06875746697187424, 0.0037734804209321737, 0.011798253282904625, -0.00937635451555252, -0.03589882329106331, -0.015751253813505173, 0.00305670453235507, 0.018436666578054428, -0.05875467136502266, 0.027644678950309753, 0.012998512014746666, -0.00739109143614769, 0.026780420914292336, -0.1005755290389061, 0.0649891346693039, 0.015163233503699303, 0.05143071338534355, -0.04147936776280403, -0.028001168742775917, -0.0033293012529611588, -0.011235755868256092, 0.030007533729076385, -0.02960261143743992, -0.028108106926083565, -0.00638711079955101, 0.0006881259614601731, -0.011386160738766193, 0.01293431967496872, 0.0345396026968956, 0.007620744872838259, 0.0035181003622710705, -0.022297237068414688, 0.013721048831939697, 0.020347699522972107, -0.01975761540234089, 0.010826132260262966, 0.0181814506649971, 0.023111240938305855, -0.004515392705798149, -0.002953722607344389, 0.015854384750127792, 0.012574698776006699, -0.024225011467933655, 0.02526569366455078, 0.0075826216489076614, 0.035280946642160416, -0.004969853907823563, -0.025744527578353882, -0.0635434240102768, 0.04552469030022621, -0.02115481160581112, -0.013269857503473759, -0.027174586430191994, 0.02706432156264782, -0.016464004293084145, -0.03129624202847481, 0.019516389816999435, 0.026534155011177063, -0.06105964630842209, -0.00813442375510931, 0.0067292130552232265, 0.058381080627441406, -0.007862125523388386, -0.004522882867604494, 0.007481452077627182, -0.01939692534506321, -0.023287180811166763, -0.03690026327967644, -0.020004967227578163, 0.05466069281101227, 0.031514428555965424, 0.025856630876660347, 0.03353545442223549, 0.01774054579436779, 0.03339947387576103, 0.016940003260970116, 0.032735053449869156, -0.051863718777894974, 0.01718563586473465, 0.010387766174972057, 0.011289125308394432, 0.009354664012789726, -0.02132152020931244, -0.005558626726269722, 0.07465742528438568, 0.029930632561445236, -0.017567399889230728, -0.07607343792915344, 0.022494055330753326, -0.0034864109475165606, 0.03763843700289726, -0.007280595600605011, 0.038295626640319824, -0.033450596034526825, -0.0071485829539597034, -0.041749127209186554, -0.0006473601679317653, 0.034928057342767715, -0.030166149139404297, -0.02280297316610813, -0.01681792177259922, -0.010202767327427864, -0.057696565985679626, -0.004109950736165047, -0.026529546827077866, -0.029273640364408493, 0.01832444779574871, -0.0028562250081449747, 0.014320667833089828, 0.014353143982589245, -0.006873654201626778, -0.018159816041588783, -0.0010541019728407264, -0.07239483296871185, -0.010513313114643097, -0.021929310634732246, 0.01778152585029602, -0.027014954015612602, 0.019167164340615273 ]
<p>I'm trying to fashion survey experiments for which the demographic composition of the samples needs to be as close as possible to a 'golden' composition. For concreteness, let's say the 'golden' composition is <code>14% middle class, 35% upper-middle class, and 51% upper class</code>.</p> <p>I have a whole bunch of samples, each with slightly different compositions. For example:</p> <pre><code>S1 = 10% middle class, 41% upper-middle class, 49% upper class S2 = 33% middle class, 33% upper-middle class, 34% upper class </code></pre> <p>I'm trying to find a good statistical measure to describe how close the distribution in each sample is to the ideal, 'golden' composition. Is there a simple metric here that I could use?</p>
74,371
[ -0.04676947742700577, -0.03520956635475159, -0.010402783751487732, 0.0030620682518929243, 0.021326834335923195, -0.002264768583700061, 0.02359798364341259, -0.006627226714044809, 0.007127109449356794, -0.013972385786473751, 0.041492559015750885, 0.019063837826251984, 0.04961997643113136, -0.0033741556107997894, 0.04099823907017708, -0.026474041864275932, 0.000622320338152349, 0.014084979891777039, -0.00893367175012827, 0.0027484025340527296, 0.0004847455711569637, -0.0168193019926548, 0.015475637279450893, -0.02432880736887455, -0.04404396191239357, -0.0008329386473633349, 0.006915610749274492, -0.02564636431634426, -0.00022366932535078377, 0.01267952285706997, -0.03312898427248001, -0.018076632171869278, -0.005976113490760326, 0.04912598058581352, 0.026861319318413734, 0.031044570729136467, -0.026035843417048454, -0.010448653250932693, -0.04222710430622101, 0.016666315495967865, -0.0639534443616867, 0.012303567491471767, -0.01869717799127102, -0.0066870637238025665, 0.015246782451868057, -0.01998993195593357, 0.020693348720669746, -0.050886210054159164, 0.020622795447707176, -0.04451855272054672, 0.07050022482872009, 0.04299020767211914, 0.01103678997606039, 0.00918048620223999, -0.01082222256809473, -0.025479070842266083, 0.043186116963624954, 0.07984954863786697, -0.017721083015203476, -0.038243621587753296, -0.010057379491627216, -0.04772985726594925, -0.0076882606372237206, -0.025682292878627777, -0.02553943358361721, 0.04105185717344284, -0.026952359825372696, -0.023300811648368835, 0.06007509306073189, -0.018796708434820175, 0.0004018826293759048, 0.02604079060256481, 0.04441892355680466, -0.008845943957567215, 0.012283229269087315, -0.03202001005411148, 0.017685355618596077, 0.03274328261613846, 0.03197333961725235, 0.0011445735581219196, -0.01394149474799633, -0.0014094418147578835, -0.010646315291523933, 0.059418488293886185, -0.0028660951647907495, -0.029312750324606895, 0.04972020909190178, -0.04591374844312668, 0.010158341377973557, 0.039170537143945694, -0.0017035965574905276, -0.006873570382595062, 0.031772613525390625, 0.04956836253404617, -0.06383344531059265, 0.03337656334042549, -0.01478640642017126, 0.028054196387529373, -0.017198165878653526, -0.002225900301709771, -0.005766323767602444, -0.045709941536188126, -0.005644036922603846, 0.035869695246219635, 0.00036580266896635294, 0.004631740041077137, -0.05707547441124916, -0.05109861120581627, 0.020497938618063927, -0.007697982247918844, -0.009936169721186161, -0.0008718871977180243, 0.023491237312555313, -0.0018916188273578882, 0.02076607383787632, -0.03768540546298027, 0.013306177221238613, -0.019727792590856552, 0.06373206526041031, 0.03129425272345543, 0.04539147764444351, 0.0035815471783280373, 0.046349894255399704, -0.0075034270994365215, -0.04969162866473198, 0.04316078871488571, 0.015873221680521965, -0.018375976011157036, -0.019731830805540085, 0.03386111184954643, -0.008301988244056702, -0.00818484928458929, 0.03496880084276199, -0.012960998341441154, 0.008681201376020908, -0.02545941434800625, -0.06387495994567871, -0.06483376026153564, -0.003979737404733896, -0.01196791511029005, 0.002141418633982539, -0.07571175694465637, 0.006502437870949507, -0.0024574999697506428, 0.014032565988600254, 0.01877107284963131, 0.04315942898392677, 0.0026290526147931814, 0.04033077880740166, 0.05862881615757942, -0.03904318809509277, 0.0044439611956477165, -0.007960757240653038, -0.012578369118273258, -0.003870970569550991, -0.055512528866529465, 0.0009615275776013732, 0.007764138281345367, -0.002737577073276043, -0.024375494569540024, 0.0073821088299155235, 0.016474632546305656, -0.037268172949552536, 0.007524972781538963, 0.03224997967481613, 0.002181018004193902, 0.07808838039636612, 0.02244986593723297, 0.005608011968433857, 0.0043756719678640366, -0.03326709195971489, 0.024307116866111755, 0.03538849949836731, 0.0371018685400486, 0.024264732375741005, -0.0017468148143962026, 0.0012321972753852606, -0.006872908677905798, 0.027780361473560333, 0.036863844841718674, -0.010277928784489632, -0.031092364341020584, -0.025030316784977913, 0.016229860484600067, -0.0041307262144982815, 0.025045625865459442, 0.0031214728951454163, -0.018029987812042236, 0.047173094004392624, -0.05570858344435692, -0.04634193703532219, -0.059603720903396606, -0.002583496505394578, 0.005948018282651901, -0.06916878372430801, 0.017489532008767128, 0.012328184209764004, 0.027100326493382454, -0.015326342545449734, -0.03786320239305496, -0.00833355262875557, -0.015604543499648571, 0.03862786293029785, -0.023428762331604958, -0.002485509729012847, 0.05353444069623947, 0.031241916120052338, -0.038797277957201004, 0.06493434309959412, 0.001014194218441844, -0.051531367003917694, -0.028480634093284607, -0.012087292969226837, 0.03492386266589165, -0.020267220214009285, 0.01910417526960373, 0.01136068906635046, -0.00864413846284151, -0.007294526323676109, 0.03682246431708336, -0.0557236447930336, 0.09078472852706909, 0.046284716576337814, 0.011149820871651173, -0.00356272398494184, 0.012909620068967342, -0.013204993680119514, 0.02946733869612217, -0.022580919787287712, 0.0340111069381237, -0.024006783962249756, -0.0011132284998893738, 0.05105127394199371, 0.015262050554156303, -0.022788072004914284, 0.00018710190488491207, 0.05947202444076538, 0.007412334904074669, 0.038261618465185165, 0.02699172869324684, 0.0032835493329912424, -0.00873023271560669, 0.0071103982627391815, -0.0292966328561306, 0.03137490525841713, 0.02410304918885231, 0.03768327087163925, 0.03431287407875061, -0.022202670574188232, -0.006209727842360735, 0.03428269550204277, 0.051188986748456955, 0.02497633546590805, 0.0037077758461236954, -0.03996656462550163, 0.003110903315246105, 0.028317492455244064, -0.02411457896232605, -0.006344400811940432, 0.07718627154827118, 0.00044176020310260355, -0.010753645561635494, 0.007570676971226931, -0.0173228420317173, -0.011261366307735443, 0.0454074926674366, 0.004824132192879915, -0.015459198504686356, 0.009937296621501446, -0.02903814986348152, 0.02826467528939247, -0.0028780901338905096, -0.00045705062802881, -0.03983590751886368, 0.033404648303985596, 0.030026055872440338, 0.0022559778299182653, 0.04514576122164726, 0.0037868982180953026, -0.04225991293787956, 0.006824052892625332, 0.03579942137002945, 0.02208981104195118, -0.004887568764388561, -0.04616770148277283, -0.01152687706053257, -0.008430426008999348, -0.021316122263669968, 0.006776970811188221, -0.0008020998793654144, -0.023578045889735222, 0.013157584704458714, 0.004700963385403156, -0.007839092053472996, 0.003724392969161272, 0.005851794499903917, 0.009633940644562244, -0.034416794776916504, -0.003941056318581104, 0.026055404916405678, 0.009068045765161514, -0.0321478396654129, 0.017492219805717468, -0.017118141055107117, -0.05652102082967758, -0.06663565337657928, 0.004659077152609825, 0.008463776670396328, 0.006976956967264414, 0.03533511608839035, 0.08313436806201935, -0.0076750521548092365, -0.015346349216997623, -0.06623706966638565, -0.059585072100162506, 0.013237757608294487, 0.03169197216629982, 0.04576611891388893, 0.03650936111807823, -0.03942345455288887, 0.07738212496042252, -0.003928418271243572, -0.031286951154470444, -0.03745974600315094, -0.020923156291246414, 0.0004366980865597725, 0.05006137490272522, 0.03941886126995087, 0.06398272514343262, 0.0054838513024151325, 0.007503763306885958, 0.012289253994822502, -0.007061759941279888, 0.049292631447315216, -0.03292027860879898, 0.019892919808626175, 0.045649122446775436, -0.026632294058799744, -0.0031413384713232517, 0.03862309455871582, 0.0264880433678627, -0.046859726309776306, 0.013843419961631298, 0.003534078598022461, 0.011370381340384483, 0.02126152627170086, -0.0641537681221962, 0.017859673127532005, -0.02105690911412239, -0.005271685775369406, -0.01591699756681919, -0.01235771644860506, 0.023971468210220337, -0.040644578635692596, 0.00097986392211169, 0.02987300604581833, 0.028448104858398438, -0.012173524126410484, -0.008118965663015842, 0.07738450169563293, 0.05919283628463745, 0.003093125531449914, 0.00950712338089943, -0.021152671426534653, -0.0010793650289997458, -0.016484294086694717, -0.024946248158812523, -0.010783779434859753, 0.028035897761583328, 0.051767747849226, 0.04365590587258339, -0.01315127033740282, -0.06936439126729965, 0.013818454928696156, -0.09009943157434464, 0.011278610676527023, -0.04138877987861633, 0.055654048919677734, -0.0002983737795148045, 0.06333541870117188, 0.00361250969581306, 0.024918057024478912, 0.013816910795867443, -0.003739209845662117, -0.06539873778820038, 0.020234892144799232, -0.0007526476983912289, -0.010782865807414055, 0.002922319807112217, -0.009958152659237385, 0.00008616429840913042, -0.027361135929822922, -0.0017886360874399543, -0.014967004768550396, 0.021551495417952538, 0.009309166111052036, 0.01814236119389534, 0.0014881204115226865, -0.00272276159375906, 0.02398911863565445, 0.03247015178203583, 0.00007564663974335417, -0.007032491732388735, 0.025780292227864265, 0.020945874974131584, -0.009007629938423634, -0.03393732011318207, -0.026998354122042656, 0.03064156323671341, -0.01602325774729252, 0.0620717816054821, 0.02381052076816559, 0.048783283680677414, -0.03835603967308998, 0.0056930710561573505, 0.007589502260088921, 0.04129815846681595, 0.013667479157447815, -0.003157844766974449, -0.018979890272021294, -0.0235506072640419, -0.06892170757055283, 0.0063941762782633305, 0.02748459205031395, 0.0035186242312192917, -0.010457031428813934, 0.033079780638217926, 0.041830625385046005, -0.05284170061349869, 0.011004207655787468, 0.060576748102903366, 0.015426688827574253, -0.02111446112394333, -0.026958461850881577, -0.024009760469198227, -0.01035567931830883, 0.016125613823533058, -0.005713191349059343, -0.0007738637505099177, 0.020015249028801918, 0.000760145194362849, 0.012169667519629002, -0.014376376755535603, -0.049192506819963455, 0.010754460468888283, -0.021437419578433037, 0.01950584352016449, -0.00506975082680583, -0.061229463666677475, -0.009262151084840298, 0.048888642340898514, 0.04280942305922508, 0.022061564028263092, 0.007002659607678652, -0.09199455380439758, 0.014058377593755722, 0.04009143263101578, 0.02000374160706997, -0.06853208690881729, -0.022024741396307945, -0.040687788277864456, -0.024345625191926956, 0.050654053688049316, -0.031155526638031006, 0.030734501779079437, -0.013307729735970497, -0.0140874357894063, -0.04172994941473007, -0.018334032967686653, -0.04035972058773041, 0.03197535127401352, 0.04369976744055748, -0.02316576987504959, 0.002702347468584776, -0.012244937941432, -0.06485061347484589, 0.010886390693485737, 0.036255352199077606, 0.03419198468327522, -0.06247678026556969, -0.0008439148659817874, 0.0035120819229632616, 0.014754915609955788, -0.01609700545668602, -0.06540493667125702, 0.01904468610882759, -0.010019822977483273, -0.029717741534113884, 0.02992659993469715, -0.014209365472197533, -0.027249881997704506, -0.015036281198263168, 0.00009370485349791124, -0.001250218483619392, 0.028235826641321182, -0.006560811772942543, 0.0382772795855999, 0.03414896875619888, 0.004772340413182974, 0.0017778255278244615, -0.019644785672426224, -0.007942963391542435, 0.015709111467003822, -0.03568620607256889, -0.006689087022095919, -0.020848508924245834, -0.03505268692970276, -0.03786168247461319, -0.023971667513251305, -0.022766316309571266, 0.022901667281985283, -0.0004252647631801665, 0.046899378299713135, -0.03973805904388428, -0.05605018511414528, -0.009696533903479576, 0.028072068467736244, 0.005961900111287832, 0.02098623663187027, -0.0011132516665384173, 0.00482905050739646, 0.01114469114691019, -0.01947607286274433, 0.01779739372432232, -0.0363452173769474, 0.014243854209780693, 0.02029366046190262, -0.07356376200914383, -0.0016023128991946578, -0.05403558164834976, -0.04483713582158089, 0.01839747652411461, -0.030290406197309494, 0.034955039620399475, -0.030434509739279747, 0.04656881093978882, 0.02891918458044529, -0.02198939397931099, -0.0007385563221760094, 0.04354957863688469, 0.013725493103265762, 0.05735340714454651, 0.004743718076497316, 0.03028351068496704, 0.03326936811208725, -0.0174571480602026, -0.10666929930448532, -0.0380612276494503, -0.012665820308029652, 0.0036669354885816574, -0.034048452973365784, -0.07049014419317245, -0.00784602202475071, 0.01459184568375349, -0.03461768105626106, -0.0032354488503187895, 0.04517059400677681, 0.0028673617634922266, -0.055866651237010956, -0.0602208711206913, 0.023640228435397148, 0.078485406935215, -0.011094896122813225, 0.012237558141350746, 0.017401279881596565, -0.016084842383861542, -0.018055513501167297, 0.00836897175759077, 0.021998979151248932, -0.03886094689369202, -0.011959599331021309, -0.016292471438646317, 0.025272874161601067, 0.04732031747698784, -0.0043264697305858135, -0.017176644876599312, -0.04593079909682274, -0.03428526595234871, 0.035246722400188446, -0.004925350192934275, 0.0017196373082697392, -0.027914298698306084, -0.029590757563710213, -0.05766668543219566, 0.0090533047914505, -0.022465363144874573, -0.0030395120847970247, 0.05377192050218582, -0.01969067007303238, -0.04965532198548317, 0.02328520454466343, 0.07495176047086716, 0.021999353542923927, -0.0069944243878126144, 0.019145390018820763, -0.023321371525526047, 0.05116334557533264, 0.02176631987094879, 0.0015384843572974205, 0.03128187730908394, 0.01864475943148136, -0.01634024828672409, -0.027163073420524597, -0.024280695244669914, -0.02801133319735527, 0.044322334229946136, -0.0011466112919151783, 0.06134019419550896, 0.025801215320825577, -0.010021507740020752, 0.016758032143115997, 0.0019196561770513654, 0.02016736939549446, 0.008737836964428425, -0.010595088824629784, 0.05493051931262016, -0.013925767503678799, -0.0143763842061162, 0.018577268347144127, -0.0002240803005406633, 0.02305668033659458, 0.04371362924575806, 0.018160346895456314, 0.03897438570857048, 0.036390937864780426, -0.052003756165504456, -0.026839472353458405, 0.029835224151611328, -0.049046069383621216, 0.017488861456513405, -0.046341899782419205, -0.025248052552342415, 0.0201432965695858, 0.015431305393576622, -0.005374874919652939, -0.0011490389006212354, -0.037342604249715805, -0.019759777933359146, -0.0012433299561962485, 0.025385165587067604, -0.019167941063642502, 0.019305028021335602, -0.011883351020514965, 0.026165131479501724, 0.011091035790741444, 0.05584206059575081, -0.0013821625616401434, -0.05083809047937393, -0.008357605896890163, -0.04847734794020653, -0.0639091432094574, 0.031534794718027115, 0.0077514490112662315, -0.008626949042081833, 0.03122478350996971, -0.02169959247112274, -0.025261692702770233, 0.005151080898940563, -0.0015191648853942752, -0.00436960207298398, 0.04710344225168228, 0.001081456197425723, 0.03827264532446861, -0.002226155484095216, -0.015271681360900402, 0.1107611283659935, 0.08504033833742142, 0.02663029357790947, -0.005541021469980478, 0.02641003578901291, 0.007190108764916658, -0.02938167378306389, -0.0033080684952437878, 0.0035011987201869488, 0.016289347782731056, -0.01242776121944189, 0.03932536765933037, 0.042488470673561096, 0.016173793002963066, 0.018883967772126198, 0.05333036184310913, -0.012886435724794865, -0.00013424975622911006, 0.023676646873354912, -0.002079849597066641, -0.014496022835373878, -0.03679710626602173, -0.07145633548498154, 0.0037920044269412756, 0.00901514571160078, 0.007133490405976772, -0.015733877196907997, -0.007334340829402208, -0.004430276807397604, -0.001939344685524702, -0.008875506930053234, 0.021610723808407784, 0.01926526613533497, 0.02367633581161499, 0.010427488945424557, -0.05132586136460304, 0.003304363926872611, -0.02730107679963112, -0.004778729751706123, 0.019385138526558876, -0.004350011702626944, 0.006671087350696325, -0.0009957969887182117, 0.03081420436501503, -0.04066780209541321, -0.01883704401552677, -0.04114719480276108, -0.001524951308965683, -0.014546231366693974, -0.02576030045747757, -0.03901495039463043, 0.013816868886351585, -0.022476745769381523, -0.024163346737623215, -0.02792804315686226, -0.000678514305036515, 0.03839762881398201, 0.004377509467303753, -0.03201064467430115, 0.0031755752861499786, 0.014017601497471333, -0.0155594851821661, 0.0005364163080230355, 0.0021592979319393635, -0.01973889023065567, -0.03188084810972214, -0.018010707572102547, 0.043902959674596786, 0.016323396936058998, -0.06057664379477501, -0.010242963209748268, -0.010050917975604534, -0.06489859521389008, 0.014472044073045254, -0.009582527913153172, 0.00815101433545351, 0.05196912959218025, -0.0039224326610565186, -0.007704171352088451, -0.01777895726263523, 0.004815274849534035, 0.03729334846138954, -0.03703757002949715, -0.01692236214876175, -0.03604383021593094, -0.028470812365412712, 0.013938947580754757, 0.04189392179250717, -0.01238732598721981, 0.027397340163588524, -0.0013742396840825677, 0.07438762485980988, 0.006153617519885302, -0.023557640612125397, 0.04042089730501175, -0.001604524441063404, -0.052006982266902924, 0.0035471823066473007, -0.040537480264902115, 0.08176787197589874, 0.01464446634054184, -0.00653991661965847, 0.01648634672164917, -0.008685577660799026, -0.017811037600040436, 0.03788429871201515, 0.026750538498163223, -0.04692545160651207, -0.034572720527648926, 0.008126773871481419, 0.0035649104975163937, -0.03663704916834831, 0.010968111455440521, -0.027471615001559258, -0.019501416012644768, -0.017976107075810432, 0.004454484209418297, -0.011854180134832859, 0.012025109492242336, -0.0028171385638415813, -0.03131086006760597, -0.04485795274376869, -0.02837795950472355, 0.016113758087158203, 0.01141718402504921, -0.040875885635614395, 0.0060195280238986015, 0.0003512515395414084, 0.02991211600601673, 0.02398575469851494, -0.01957407407462597, 0.04033876582980156, 0.008458203636109829, 0.03188779577612877, 0.006949202157557011, 0.020538194105029106, -0.008077641949057579, 0.060390446335077286, -0.021398363634943962, -0.007379067596048117, 0.05683382973074913, -0.059894949197769165, -0.054516151547431946, 0.010406645946204662, -0.017334971576929092, 0.04339788109064102, 0.010615894570946693, -0.009688621386885643, 0.01456375326961279, 0.044407155364751816, -0.0064313034527003765, -0.02449726313352585, -0.0284234918653965, 0.041397906839847565, 0.026748551055788994, -0.04030134156346321, -0.03555400297045708, -0.03363112732768059, -0.03411789610981941, 0.024165164679288864, 0.07007572054862976, -0.011281317099928856, -0.0005384795949794352, 0.0019719626288861036, -0.01962505280971527, -0.013851949945092201, -0.011442258954048157, 0.014060999266803265, 0.041773028671741486, 0.03529958799481392, -0.05639972910284996, 0.023025883361697197, -0.015683675184845924, -0.01667378656566143, -0.060165438801050186, -0.04258370399475098, 0.009312824346125126, -0.005974756553769112, 0.034234367311000824, -0.0693105086684227, 0.004551259335130453, 0.0044744848273694515, -0.027615854516625404, 0.0170593224465847, 0.012746707536280155, 0.01304000522941351, -0.0470927432179451, 0.0053896354511380196, -0.021162427961826324, 0.023236367851495743, 0.01871580071747303, 0.047451987862586975, 0.03100278414785862, 0.021858373656868935, 0.014612962491810322, -0.02266615815460682, -0.0058970022946596146, 0.004425494931638241, 0.006176528055220842, -0.05735526978969574, 0.019935503602027893, 0.0012095983838662505, -0.01091496180742979, 0.04640313610434532, -0.0011086497688665986, 0.046274036169052124, 0.02844814583659172, 0.05578494817018509, 0.01979457028210163, 0.068384550511837, 0.03351665288209915, 0.00861331820487976, -0.06786537915468216, 0.015477042645215988, 0.03338858485221863, 0.03029816225171089, -0.042553167790174484, 0.006529445759952068, 0.10185135900974274, -0.004318695515394211, -0.00554463779553771, -0.005968031939119101, 0.013677140697836876, 0.0004629843751899898, 0.00565328961238265, -0.020290885120630264, 0.04240521788597107, -0.016378549858927727, 0.030102510005235672, -0.037930093705654144, 0.014846470206975937, 0.03759659454226494, 0.05322646722197533, -0.007023980375379324, 0.009852323681116104, -0.009736616164445877, -0.02399974875152111, -0.009592174552381039, 0.003873636480420828, -0.017602287232875824, -0.017944756895303726, -0.041315194219350815, -0.026853106915950775, 0.03158632293343544, 0.007671385537832975, -0.030514633283019066, -0.008719118312001228, 0.0509682223200798, 0.007574430666863918, 0.004522619303315878, 0.0006289680022746325, 0.021789291873574257, 0.023994028568267822, -0.058277275413274765, 0.05197547376155853, -0.021093085408210754, 0.02963675558567047, -0.01375840324908495, 0.025027422234416008, -0.07419515401124954, 0.0036563624162226915, 0.08505141735076904, 0.005911981221288443, 0.005556817632168531, -0.019201433286070824, -0.004020248539745808, 0.04831511527299881, -0.054901063442230225, 0.06046685203909874, 0.000013986545127409045, -0.025570083409547806, -0.04237131401896477, 0.0042167236097157, 0.004571570083498955, -0.005761360749602318, 0.0191950686275959, -0.01925564743578434, -0.02818337455391884, 0.0025482724886387587, -0.03015402890741825, 0.02857101522386074, 0.013116374611854553, -0.015634946525096893, 0.04967573285102844, -0.0316559299826622, 0.011473226360976696, 0.02047896571457386, -0.011202002875506878, -0.07906212657690048, 0.03065619245171547, 0.006811265368014574, -0.04663649573922157, -0.005953027401119471, 0.01938324049115181, -0.0018538498552516103, -0.027470694854855537, -0.01588434725999832, 0.032572634518146515, -0.0757005512714386, -0.03690626844763756, 0.005585799925029278, 0.03189029172062874, 0.03550656512379646, -0.0415320098400116, -0.003144189715385437, -0.0075600468553602695, -0.004792514257133007, -0.008140170946717262, 0.019679302349686623, 0.02929801680147648, 0.014095716178417206, 0.005460107699036598, 0.03860745579004288, -0.013830742798745632, 0.03342471644282341, 0.014962754212319851, 0.02385585755109787, 0.012346218340098858, -0.0035237520933151245, 0.05133700370788574, -0.005378691479563713, 0.05042476952075958, -0.0084157669916749, 0.007246268447488546, 0.05087289586663246, -0.027299050241708755, -0.01473057921975851, -0.05012126266956329, -0.031121311709284782, -0.04164751246571541, -0.026702331379055977, 0.014568742364645004, 0.003713405691087246, -0.0167861208319664, 0.026926985010504723, -0.01075308583676815, 0.0036236585583537817, 0.028603311628103256, -0.00719837099313736, 0.027505718171596527, -0.038744039833545685, -0.0023730534594506025, -0.006487404461950064, 0.010243508964776993, -0.03013303503394127, 0.015297670848667622, 0.00537129258736968, 0.04667321965098381, 0.011688455007970333, 0.02210412360727787, -0.02349734865128994, 0.026824992150068283, 0.0356559120118618, -0.0635421946644783, -0.06706415861845016, -0.058790337294340134, -0.025643663480877876, -0.014767905697226524, -0.009525679051876068 ]
<p>I would like to compare the effect of one IV ("sensation seeking") on a DV ("intended infidelity") based on another IV ("gender"). Actually I really just want to compare the means. So I would like to compare the mean effect of sensation seeking (a continuous variable with 5 levels) for males and females on intended infidelity (a continuous variable with 4 levels). Why can't I seem to do this in SPSS? Do I have to do a moderation analysis? Can I re-compute the variables and into what? Thanks very much for any suggestions! </p>
74,372
[ -0.07293713092803955, 0.001073783845640719, 0.02015160210430622, 0.049399372190237045, 0.021593937650322914, 0.013540510088205338, -0.01307363249361515, -0.010113470256328583, 0.019549105316400528, 0.02531912922859192, 0.013829156756401062, 0.05897319316864014, 0.051212579011917114, 0.020718036219477654, -0.011285695247352123, -0.02461375668644905, -0.00039908464532345533, 0.03401138260960579, 0.02466702274978161, 0.013784828595817089, -0.0356828048825264, 0.03632223233580589, 0.02643667533993721, -0.029271738603711128, 0.023649368435144424, 0.04797160625457764, 0.05409058928489685, -0.04813264310359955, -0.025610577315092087, 0.006104724016040564, -0.012621920555830002, -0.015191016718745232, 0.02280588261783123, -0.01756048947572708, 0.03801703453063965, 0.023253925144672394, -0.04300060123205185, 0.03837878257036209, -0.0190208088606596, 0.03523753210902214, 0.010633942671120167, 0.02784259244799614, -0.02712688036262989, 0.03609878569841385, -0.01770767755806446, 0.011249580420553684, -0.005076004192233086, 0.003668807912617922, 0.012466013431549072, -0.0586371086537838, 0.061859749257564545, -0.024076854810118675, 0.012255050241947174, 0.026081861928105354, 0.00316193257458508, 0.013018392026424408, 0.06302187591791153, 0.055370911955833435, -0.02354959398508072, -0.061962440609931946, -0.01879962906241417, -0.004399309866130352, 0.002351130358874798, 0.002178950235247612, -0.01056361012160778, -0.006398250348865986, -0.022460751235485077, -0.018196970224380493, 0.02011028863489628, 0.03935739025473595, 0.03617604449391365, 0.0016076466999948025, 0.039121292531490326, 0.02242366597056389, 0.0020486805588006973, -0.03415181487798691, 0.04547794908285141, 0.020108919590711594, 0.04064636677503586, 0.02639356255531311, 0.02609262615442276, -0.002968298038467765, -0.004234312567859888, 0.02507888711988926, -0.016572516411542892, -0.03378324583172798, 0.045570239424705505, -0.030220964923501015, -0.019716966897249222, 0.049709029495716095, -0.03454574942588806, -0.0033806010615080595, 0.01025915052741766, 0.07384530454874039, -0.04141980782151222, -0.013622736558318138, -0.017166484147310257, 0.03377499803900719, 0.0031784989405423403, -0.0017760557821020484, -0.013815172016620636, -0.03333941847085953, 0.045882973819971085, 0.031178345903754234, -0.026655172929167747, 0.014584510587155819, -0.017892634496092796, -0.013890265487134457, -0.005251402501016855, -0.02838652767241001, -0.04374491795897484, 0.006841461174190044, 0.03599631041288376, 0.010171680711209774, 0.014490706846117973, 0.013410914689302444, -0.010602284222841263, -0.019811514765024185, 0.04972819611430168, 0.06326881796121597, 0.055728912353515625, -0.024120377376675606, 0.029628030955791473, -0.028216198086738586, -0.044853098690509796, 0.0033489966299384832, 0.01108647882938385, -0.023064792156219482, -0.00960837583988905, 0.017297379672527313, 0.01970824971795082, -0.010880333371460438, 0.03926412761211395, 0.003965039271861315, 0.004471071995794773, -0.02724209800362587, -0.06465336680412292, -0.05334530398249626, 0.019750576466321945, 0.03422686830163002, 0.01566128619015217, -0.08845116943120956, -0.029125269502401352, 0.014893238432705402, 0.03328971564769745, 0.017206372693181038, 0.04509587958455086, 0.034063611179590225, 0.04852193966507912, 0.039995741099119186, -0.042687006294727325, -0.0027855944354087114, -0.03660654276609421, -0.04369404539465904, -0.04793733358383179, -0.07832349836826324, 0.048518069088459015, 0.0069186873733997345, -0.032250575721263885, 0.03039354830980301, 0.007230995688587427, 0.006353072356432676, -0.03504828363656998, 0.000379621924366802, 0.012288251891732216, 0.025817658752202988, 0.06042454019188881, -0.0035414407029747963, 0.03276582062244415, -0.01398018840700388, -0.030905110761523247, -0.021881477907299995, -0.0001465861569158733, 0.03338858112692833, 0.05055592954158783, -0.003339585615321994, -0.03756263852119446, 0.003035247791558504, 0.02147367037832737, -0.019865982234477997, -0.0337417870759964, -0.019458895549178123, 0.004476931877434254, -0.0009397976682521403, -0.003363946918398142, 0.02785102277994156, 0.0006421941798180342, -0.02021668665111065, -0.018194332718849182, -0.02109106443822384, -0.06952972710132599, -0.046572666615247726, 0.00618739565834403, -0.0010445829248055816, -0.04755723848938942, -0.009013323113322258, -0.009290704503655434, 0.03964509442448616, -0.011017153970897198, -0.014023011550307274, -0.04991289973258972, -0.018374593928456306, 0.0702604278922081, -0.06630128622055054, -0.016727089881896973, 0.025961462408304214, 0.015856217592954636, -0.01696024090051651, 0.01791083812713623, -0.020008299499750137, -0.01932072639465332, 0.009023129940032959, -0.04074229672551155, 0.006764586549252272, 0.03780973330140114, -0.014903907664120197, 0.011679906398057938, 0.012545986101031303, -0.04171769320964813, 0.02339053899049759, -0.021465308964252472, 0.08051703870296478, 0.10795329511165619, 0.033478379249572754, -0.00994137767702341, -0.001091234851628542, 0.021626634523272514, -0.001966984011232853, 0.0017747350502759218, -0.04029252380132675, -0.018426569178700447, 0.020079201087355614, 0.0019481262424960732, -0.013472623191773891, -0.044243693351745605, 0.0005860139499418437, 0.0743851289153099, -0.01692550629377365, 0.023163266479969025, 0.019115621224045753, 0.010525466874241829, -0.025154486298561096, 0.019419101998209953, 0.02751472406089306, 0.012439443729817867, 0.04281248152256012, 0.001471546827815473, -0.00047343000187538564, 0.028087595477700233, 0.0016037945169955492, 0.03328075259923935, 0.037256546318531036, 0.009060298092663288, 0.01672043465077877, -0.015515601262450218, 0.002302826615050435, 0.03259633481502533, -0.03853486850857735, 0.022501835599541664, 0.06402870267629623, 0.0040386756882071495, 0.0018347311997786164, 0.04238832741975784, -0.005091582890599966, 0.03522608056664467, 0.0695071816444397, 0.00573368277400732, 0.002799281617626548, 0.018024718388915062, 0.0006108088418841362, 0.004485751502215862, 0.0037669220473617315, 0.017661618068814278, -0.05098974332213402, -0.005837548989802599, 0.010433071292936802, -0.012294591404497623, 0.017262384295463562, -0.005039800424128771, 0.02694716677069664, -0.00553883146494627, 0.014832842163741589, 0.002029776806011796, -0.02658468298614025, -0.04804248735308647, -0.03787030279636383, 0.0006938179722055793, -0.024059275165200233, 0.019878288730978966, -0.03034738264977932, -0.017995400354266167, 0.045758288353681564, 0.0000838813284644857, -0.02663557603955269, 0.002980186138302088, -0.0034075488802045584, -0.012501424178481102, 0.010369076393544674, -0.04290109872817993, 0.009713022969663143, -0.006809369660913944, -0.03334832936525345, 0.007985701784491539, -0.018357248976826668, 0.0006985807558521628, -0.020550791174173355, -0.008469745516777039, 0.03549265116453171, 0.022756027057766914, -0.0021877179387956858, 0.004635070450603962, -0.03902271017432213, 0.016860106959939003, -0.061507850885391235, -0.038613542914390564, -0.00014722187188453972, 0.03402377665042877, 0.02262277528643608, -0.015745162963867188, 0.004273112863302231, 0.04207158833742142, 0.03666888177394867, -0.045647941529750824, -0.08760577440261841, -0.03541257232427597, -0.055583685636520386, -0.023985952138900757, 0.03882870078086853, 0.027230974286794662, 0.013751080259680748, -0.00840840209275484, -0.010958217084407806, 0.010903407819569111, 0.0462852381169796, -0.0068094730377197266, -0.02197984978556633, 0.03290459141135216, 0.01628103479743004, -0.012471734546124935, 0.029422808438539505, 0.03285738825798035, -0.04366028308868408, -0.011862140148878098, 0.010620221495628357, 0.06396700441837311, 0.001232628826983273, -0.029250111430883408, -0.009339947253465652, -0.00018839882977772504, 0.0006161769852042198, -0.016913527622818947, 0.0003391325590200722, 0.017047163099050522, -0.010761341080069542, -0.02796136401593685, 0.026975354179739952, 0.025987735018134117, -0.06193339824676514, 0.013526186347007751, 0.043477535247802734, 0.035860542207956314, -0.00986721832305193, -0.0026067723520100117, -0.006136379204690456, 0.03868687525391579, 0.03040626272559166, -0.015262534841895103, -0.049786604940891266, 0.03605164960026741, 0.027663767337799072, 0.017190515995025635, 0.01414459478110075, -0.048164840787649155, 0.009700579568743706, -0.07679007202386856, -0.013818196021020412, -0.03861209377646446, 0.049737319350242615, 0.017172930762171745, 0.0315837562084198, 0.043638791888952255, 0.022064993157982826, -0.019638435915112495, -0.015159700997173786, -0.03335844725370407, 0.03818141296505928, -0.011663575656712055, 0.0026831901632249355, 0.014205001294612885, -0.002331740688532591, 0.016775308176875114, -0.030159572139382362, 0.001511763664893806, 0.02444833144545555, 0.023941094055771828, -0.015816660597920418, 0.01539660058915615, -0.013726514764130116, 0.0027764623519033194, 0.010532476007938385, 0.025132767856121063, 0.036982644349336624, -0.05532469600439072, 0.0619334876537323, 0.006304167211055756, -0.02095060795545578, -0.030454399064183235, -0.0474855974316597, 0.0002657898876350373, 0.018931802362203598, 0.025060109794139862, -0.016683433204889297, 0.011184233240783215, -0.02082899771630764, 0.05353494733572006, 0.0031203783582895994, 0.030498391017317772, 0.07414883375167847, 0.007112585939466953, -0.06866790354251862, -0.0011669616214931011, 0.022024575620889664, 0.008617830462753773, 0.010436897166073322, -0.008923670276999474, 0.0036049990449100733, 0.03435043618083, 0.03940385580062866, -0.04003826156258583, 0.017768561840057373, 0.05656130984425545, 0.01905655302107334, 0.0005967558245174587, -0.019404970109462738, -0.02713543362915516, -0.0324992835521698, -0.050331324338912964, 0.04315517097711563, 0.06778740137815475, 0.027714891359210014, -0.0035735629498958588, 0.04712839797139168, -0.0128076933324337, -0.04796334356069565, 0.03280153125524521, -0.00660610431805253, 0.049271997064352036, -0.014093739911913872, -0.04148324206471443, 0.01743319444358349, 0.031205065548419952, 0.02445906214416027, -0.006589410826563835, 0.0224986020475626, -0.08027905225753784, 0.013841413892805576, 0.0477127805352211, 0.03908556327223778, -0.018498772755265236, -0.04598755016922951, -0.00463911471888423, -0.0231337733566761, 0.036465536803007126, -0.062269970774650574, 0.01628386601805687, -0.04003576561808586, 0.02373453788459301, -0.034057993441820145, 0.013992824591696262, -0.030914733186364174, 0.014851146377623081, 0.0013046417152509093, 0.03363275155425072, 0.00935413222759962, -0.021770277991890907, -0.03270065784454346, -0.03981156647205353, 0.030216289684176445, 0.03876680135726929, -0.006186189129948616, -0.036922942847013474, 0.009432142600417137, 0.008381185121834278, -0.02638004533946514, -0.04681319743394852, 0.006560243666172028, -0.007419189438223839, 0.0004752576642204076, 0.08424887806177139, 0.004214123357087374, 0.0028939542826265097, 0.0005741666536778212, 0.0016739352140575647, -0.024997305124998093, 0.013983448036015034, -0.02254565618932247, 0.054116442799568176, 0.03030628152191639, -0.012059824541211128, 0.021354161202907562, 0.02415340207517147, -0.007332919165492058, 0.008856361731886864, -0.0190849918872118, 0.014109548181295395, -0.01968923583626747, -0.05453631654381752, -0.06960589438676834, -0.004202657844871283, -0.03461337834596634, 0.036393314599990845, 0.01451310608536005, -0.005571715533733368, -0.05858776345849037, -0.02195499837398529, 0.013154374435544014, 0.043711528182029724, -0.0023968438617885113, -0.017004314810037613, -0.008665760979056358, 0.0028133506420999765, -0.0002316083846380934, -0.010749752633273602, 0.009683819487690926, -0.02769532799720764, -0.012421982362866402, 0.024277225136756897, -0.06602107733488083, 0.006805647164583206, -0.017833787947893143, -0.05510878935456276, 0.01707172766327858, -0.0531654991209507, 0.030695563182234764, -0.01957920379936695, 0.04527679458260536, 0.0089430445805192, -0.04392077028751373, 0.03495872765779495, 0.02586425468325615, 0.018653273582458496, 0.02998485416173935, -0.052520934492349625, 0.05422299727797508, -0.05063238367438316, -0.03306861221790314, -0.06814571470022202, -0.011536786332726479, 0.03977936878800392, -0.03208747133612633, -0.06955141574144363, -0.03240778669714928, 0.0013643618440255523, -0.010023318231105804, -0.026328878477215767, -0.03120940737426281, 0.021041464060544968, -0.018435657024383545, -0.032635439187288284, -0.027429932728409767, 0.04190807044506073, 0.060180459171533585, 0.013350607827305794, 0.03929264470934868, 0.0014848698629066348, -0.011908735148608685, -0.017636165022850037, -0.006926779169589281, 0.00854482688009739, -0.03181217610836029, -0.04195261001586914, -0.03202894702553749, 0.014725611545145512, 0.016651367768645287, -0.010512134060263634, 0.0005802083178423345, -0.005590650252997875, -0.02523830719292164, 0.025020558387041092, -0.056102048605680466, -0.02846701443195343, -0.03552206605672836, 0.014712518081068993, -0.02252458594739437, 0.03596408665180206, -0.05411963909864426, 0.03790434077382088, 0.016360292211174965, -0.0031307574827224016, 0.007071707397699356, 0.0035936722997576, 0.05557195097208023, 0.020363789051771164, 0.017026830464601517, 0.0018124732887372375, 0.00926231313496828, 0.0026415432803332806, -0.010054699145257473, -0.008751184679567814, 0.019348226487636566, 0.06625401973724365, -0.03428284078836441, -0.010331742465496063, -0.0348777137696743, 0.035248301923274994, 0.06443319469690323, -0.01977844163775444, 0.023287076503038406, 0.03408731520175934, 0.0036726549733430147, -0.01998983509838581, -0.04164524003863335, -0.0006760914693586528, 0.009164511226117611, 0.02976212650537491, 0.03713008016347885, -0.03167755901813507, 0.007411245256662369, 0.029953202232718468, 0.028660058975219727, 0.014450904913246632, 0.07385500520467758, 0.033886268734931946, 0.04585426673293114, 0.02828855626285076, -0.02886858955025673, -0.03420228138566017, 0.0002116526011377573, -0.02720084972679615, 0.010255183093249798, -0.0486004613339901, -0.01520114578306675, 0.016812779009342194, 0.04197349026799202, -0.026120439171791077, -0.0521710030734539, -0.019410667940974236, -0.047604892402887344, -0.009866645559668541, 0.02405490167438984, -0.029001323506236076, 0.024871552363038063, 0.030440926551818848, 0.038300592452287674, -0.01417784858494997, -0.004869475960731506, -0.0426376610994339, -0.035171471536159515, -0.029102370142936707, 0.005014928989112377, -0.03909248113632202, 0.06362821906805038, -0.04740932211279869, -0.01134624145925045, -0.0018615417648106813, -0.03838392347097397, 0.006013624835759401, -0.027619805186986923, 0.031841032207012177, 0.01677170768380165, 0.04889049008488655, -0.02686498872935772, 0.017317242920398712, -0.01318741962313652, 0.0516120046377182, 0.14077217876911163, 0.049078699201345444, 0.03945158049464226, -0.05037461593747139, 0.00326331565156579, -0.00856967642903328, 0.026470309123396873, -0.008980631828308105, 0.019668355584144592, 0.03973696008324623, -0.028579462319612503, 0.04799933731555939, 0.07496567815542221, 0.053528640419244766, -0.002628895454108715, 0.05995498597621918, -0.004569632466882467, 0.016886303201317787, -0.00886497925966978, -0.030291106551885605, 0.0018301107920706272, -0.023991724476218224, -0.02400529570877552, -0.00941239669919014, 0.024301249533891678, -0.02024025470018387, -0.029167164117097855, -0.0042523713782429695, 0.007057176437228918, 0.01898912899196148, -0.028455916792154312, -0.0008917038794606924, 0.008700720965862274, 0.05002281069755554, -0.020114228129386902, -0.040518321096897125, 0.04240927845239639, -0.07631804794073105, -0.0039543453603982925, 0.04204234853386879, -0.008022650144994259, 0.025939710438251495, 0.0009765152935869992, -0.007820473983883858, -0.014462767168879509, -0.04485223814845085, 0.004478978458791971, 0.031121404841542244, 0.029494425281882286, -0.06954147666692734, -0.01229441910982132, 0.01802503876388073, -0.012328333221375942, -0.022783925756812096, -0.04584487900137901, -0.010450088419020176, 0.025689560920000076, -0.03164106234908104, 0.019254270941019058, 0.003657703287899494, 0.010442105121910572, -0.003202775027602911, 0.046349529176950455, 0.00233530648984015, -0.031240100041031837, -0.048707619309425354, -0.03162055090069771, 0.026795674115419388, -0.005015985574573278, -0.034284163266420364, 0.0028584711253643036, 0.007025344297289848, -0.03983820602297783, 0.00006107457738835365, -0.0023198460694402456, 0.031115330755710602, -0.003164254827424884, -0.04705311730504036, -0.010856563225388527, -0.018695823848247528, -0.01665700413286686, 0.010163450613617897, -0.015525739639997482, -0.0056111011654138565, -0.0024875684175640345, -0.005184269044548273, 0.04352904483675957, -0.014786243438720703, 0.0047766659408807755, -0.012593806721270084, 0.014914529398083687, 0.024883605539798737, 0.04914197325706482, -0.03999758139252663, -0.014254959300160408, -0.020330898463726044, -0.04150829836726189, 0.024228597059845924, -0.025841856375336647, 0.04617611691355705, 0.013298246078193188, 0.023303093388676643, -0.01022438146173954, -0.0021959312725812197, -0.022681115195155144, 0.016314927488565445, 0.013630000874400139, -0.058961499482393265, -0.02326579950749874, 0.004342589993029833, 0.020443487912416458, -0.0011219759471714497, 0.006982620805501938, -0.07019511610269547, 0.012782539241015911, 0.03286907449364662, -0.02562202699482441, -0.01719806343317032, 0.009560172446072102, -0.004474173299968243, 0.013211837969720364, -0.03273005038499832, 0.0005897485534660518, -0.04440517723560333, 0.0030004882719367743, 0.01801585592329502, 0.04100654646754265, -0.0005894516361877322, 0.023306014016270638, -0.026660993695259094, 0.03675946220755577, 0.025067824870347977, 0.005240354686975479, 0.020572518929839134, -0.008662481792271137, 0.004923620261251926, 0.008053905330598354, 0.06391936540603638, 0.0014387101400643587, -0.005479305051267147, 0.05045842006802559, -0.04818401485681534, -0.04804382473230362, 0.004492195788770914, 0.029333436861634254, 0.024438388645648956, 0.03268184885382652, 0.020528951659798622, -0.0386807918548584, 0.08909577876329422, 0.018664058297872543, -0.010303283110260963, 0.017501452937722206, 0.018263641744852066, 0.0020310126710683107, -0.011490237899124622, -0.007635945454239845, 0.013809356838464737, -0.01785123348236084, 0.0215651486068964, 0.05005866289138794, 0.023740502074360847, 0.022348949685692787, -0.0005407383432611823, -0.012536438181996346, 0.008189171552658081, 0.00045762426452711225, -0.013805674389004707, 0.07691111415624619, 0.038287509232759476, 0.0029734123963862658, 0.0015733748441562057, 0.0034185382537543774, 0.0240053441375494, -0.08390870690345764, 0.000918395584449172, 0.009577525779604912, 0.022962918505072594, 0.019022192806005478, -0.04261253401637077, 0.04475299268960953, 0.0018692571902647614, -0.06559497863054276, -0.0038380406331270933, -0.03191728889942169, -0.02050045318901539, -0.06553161144256592, 0.014230040833353996, -0.05054018273949623, 0.01577417366206646, 0.01679028756916523, 0.002589074894785881, 0.0426127053797245, -0.0006807917961850762, -0.010475276969373226, -0.032280344516038895, -0.021731866523623466, 0.02532963640987873, 0.021027959883213043, -0.05570580065250397, 0.01297294907271862, -0.06948661804199219, -0.030509144067764282, 0.018575826659798622, -0.005297473631799221, 0.021623393520712852, 0.007750982418656349, 0.016299085691571236, 0.01087969820946455, 0.05729193240404129, 0.015437998808920383, -0.004475254565477371, 0.023362720385193825, 0.000601377512793988, -0.026775706559419632, 0.03174503520131111, -0.02087787538766861, 0.02171412482857704, 0.02186238020658493, -0.0498025082051754, -0.01885727420449257, -0.028488941490650177, -0.00001855364826042205, -0.02959890104830265, -0.0014969222247600555, -0.04784102737903595, 0.06645610928535461, -0.027072235941886902, 0.014747053384780884, -0.04134926572442055, 0.007469134405255318, 0.0351061150431633, 0.0047102030366659164, 0.02223837748169899, -0.0029590430203825235, 0.00077257544035092, -0.052467864006757736, -0.054514359682798386, 0.00842450000345707, 0.01427613664418459, -0.04940817505121231, 0.027141055092215538, -0.00467145349830389, -0.010019094683229923, -0.0324832983314991, 0.015779772773385048, 0.002076327335089445, 0.059193629771471024, -0.054736845195293427, 0.004793278407305479, -0.014469564892351627, 0.011469815857708454, -0.00608502421528101, -0.09346089512109756, 0.049128901213407516, -0.004806254059076309, -0.06494095176458359, -0.027427896857261658, -0.0014364027883857489, -0.0363633893430233, 0.004014153964817524, 0.04812590405344963, -0.035960566252470016, -0.018914902582764626, 0.010824033059179783, 0.04828290268778801, -0.007385644596070051, -0.04310077801346779, 0.06131896376609802, 0.005695921368896961, -0.02823363058269024, 0.0002319954801350832, -0.02151123806834221, -0.034806977957487106, -0.0037663697730749846, -0.006486017722636461, -0.01589862070977688, 0.0029610281344503164, 0.017982369288802147, -0.020857226103544235, -0.002749052830040455, 0.015797480940818787, -0.03278031945228577, 0.014021913520991802, -0.004987613297998905, -0.0022849515080451965, 0.026341229677200317, 0.02035589888691902, -0.011775469407439232, 0.03975404053926468, -0.046120282262563705, -0.01555001363158226, -0.007656807545572519, 0.004058435093611479, -0.05276886746287346, -0.060489095747470856, 0.01895579695701599, 0.026368146762251854, -0.0198740866035223, 0.006043791305273771, 0.024523580446839333, 0.011552373878657818, 0.021639812737703323, -0.006035479251295328, 0.04122777283191681, -0.0057889549061656, -0.028573935851454735, 0.016949957236647606, 0.032635755836963654, 0.02908996120095253, 0.002199976472184062, -0.027568139135837555, 0.020844552665948868, -0.0061841923743486404, 0.053658515214920044, -0.005492981988936663, 0.022842280566692352, -0.006862792186439037, -0.005118902772665024, 0.003342576324939728, -0.015797503292560577, 0.025129040703177452, 0.03213944286108017, -0.007028509862720966, 0.02923816628754139, -0.02975551411509514, -0.002137866336852312, -0.040384482592344284, 0.0014088575262576342, -0.04490893706679344, 0.00017234822735190392, 0.04151255637407303, 0.0007180266547948122, 0.030940700322389603, -0.007612875197082758, 0.02737347036600113, -0.0016705351881682873, 0.029068347066640854, -0.023155083879828453, 0.011046289466321468, -0.01462916936725378, -0.009889518842101097, -0.013599064201116562, -0.04823458939790726, -0.035369519144296646, 0.037645261734724045, 0.07048854231834412, 0.0062929620034992695, -0.008325931616127491, -0.013404068537056446, -0.05438068509101868, 0.017484726384282112, 0.047953806817531586, -0.05822503939270973, -0.06531492620706558, -0.024832166731357574, 0.027482224628329277, 0.00815526768565178, -0.03511979430913925 ]
<p>I am drafting a literature review on a current public health issue where data are confounded: </p> <p><strong>What are common historical case-studies that are used in public health/epidemiology education where invalid or confounded relationships or inferences were intentionally or erroneously employed in public health policy and legislation?</strong> </p> <p>The automobile fatality surge of the 1960s and subsequent evidence-based, government-led study which determined seatbelts and eventually airbags should be required by law is a great example of <strong>HOW</strong> public health policy should be driven by statistically powerful inferences and models. </p> <p>I am looking more for examples of cases of the opposite type (bad science to make policy hastily). However, if nothing else I would like to learn of more cases similar to the previous example of powerful studies for successful public health benefit.</p> <p>I want to use these as examples to demonstrate how evidence-based statistical public health research is important to the making of policy.</p>
74,373
[ -0.060770172625780106, -0.0578530877828598, 0.012382392771542072, -0.02942458726465702, 0.045873623341321945, 0.009534716606140137, 0.009480446577072144, -0.010041214525699615, 0.04191542789340019, 0.028865305706858635, 0.0372714139521122, 0.05151036009192467, 0.02173687517642975, -0.0012181730708107352, 0.012926430441439152, 0.008954564109444618, 0.02766260877251625, 0.048895277082920074, -0.004222997929900885, -0.00850934162735939, 0.007831612601876259, 0.004387320950627327, -0.025326579809188843, -0.012182439677417278, -0.003819623962044716, 0.030494563281536102, 0.014511599205434322, -0.015171918086707592, -0.014055741019546986, 0.02741432934999466, -0.052401237189769745, 0.0063516851514577866, 0.01700536720454693, -0.01895827427506447, 0.000832890800666064, 0.017796959728002548, -0.02108367532491684, -0.02940828539431095, 0.01010080799460411, 0.08040637522935867, -0.027475370094180107, -0.015237954445183277, -0.009424138814210892, 0.03800676017999649, -0.04172542318701744, 0.044230006635189056, -0.006363561376929283, -0.03406362235546112, 0.009041567333042622, -0.05509093403816223, 0.03685735538601875, -0.015224178321659565, 0.02815687656402588, 0.07459130138158798, -0.04164475202560425, -0.02937433496117592, 0.0499957874417305, 0.0667242556810379, -0.006543670315295458, -0.07162825763225555, -0.0010844254866242409, -0.018135257065296173, -0.011062695644795895, 0.010178330354392529, -0.038387589156627655, 0.03017871454358101, -0.02419973909854889, -0.058805085718631744, 0.03876969963312149, -0.027347376570105553, 0.012256719172000885, -0.007133906241506338, -0.01668538711965084, 0.0062865084037184715, 0.022939063608646393, -0.02614317461848259, 0.0006626337417401373, -0.0031813171226531267, 0.0588877834379673, 0.04463380202651024, -0.021674292162060738, 0.003676875028759241, 0.02563280053436756, 0.03516792133450508, -0.016922391951084137, -0.02308041788637638, 0.07230425626039505, -0.02137083187699318, -0.00042041795677505434, -0.015981405973434448, -0.004712397698312998, -0.02114872634410858, 0.011850045993924141, -0.0007488808478228748, 0.007868089713156223, 0.03315066918730736, -0.015284049324691296, 0.060814473778009415, -0.01425572857260704, -0.004251161124557257, -0.02756888046860695, -0.023005785420536995, 0.005985170602798462, 0.00924015324562788, -0.013443182222545147, -0.06452320516109467, 0.01008723583072424, 0.005835404619574547, -0.007026794366538525, -0.004266388714313507, -0.044355329126119614, 0.03343336656689644, 0.015281002968549728, -0.010084554553031921, -0.014456542208790779, -0.01072736456990242, -0.00992300733923912, 0.005180332809686661, 0.08030729740858078, 0.03036241978406906, 0.06755726039409637, -0.028950190171599388, 0.017804954200983047, -0.04432136192917824, -0.039223458617925644, -0.004471864551305771, 0.019621027633547783, -0.015143691562116146, -0.01963917538523674, 0.06393584609031677, 0.05067715421319008, 0.0004542754031717777, 0.015940258279442787, -0.024949021637439728, 0.047408025711774826, -0.010505852289497852, -0.07392098754644394, -0.05200602486729622, 0.05312373861670494, 0.039487335830926895, -0.040973104536533356, -0.05686979368329048, 0.0016851009568199515, 0.000018803779312293045, 0.027065355330705643, 0.004296515602618456, 0.014105034060776234, -0.019209416583180428, 0.05310773849487305, -0.005135818384587765, -0.0044795675203204155, 0.002876678016036749, 0.024257034063339233, 0.019203972071409225, -0.027032651007175446, -0.10979745537042618, 0.039867062121629715, 0.024335285648703575, -0.009027666412293911, -0.010223274119198322, 0.06100869178771973, -0.024317167699337006, -0.015431812964379787, -0.02596297115087509, 0.006361749488860369, -0.001912808045744896, 0.06451506912708282, 0.016774112358689308, -0.02681645192205906, 0.037521056830883026, -0.006865750532597303, 0.05310560762882233, 0.043099891394376755, -0.007202138192951679, -0.01435241661965847, -0.03425455093383789, 0.008619477041065693, 0.005510326940566301, 0.02402365207672119, -0.005653386935591698, -0.020994294434785843, -0.00034066365333274007, -0.025015735998749733, 0.0070561859756708145, 0.014043315313756466, 0.04455208033323288, -0.0022767880000174046, 0.0037741076666861773, 0.05972151458263397, -0.06143629923462868, -0.06207171082496643, -0.06873758882284164, -0.013390867970883846, -0.04666312783956528, -0.05118193477392197, 0.04375382512807846, -0.05963968113064766, 0.047333959490060806, -0.023246852681040764, 0.03403828665614128, 0.014399840496480465, -0.007489420473575592, 0.04046076908707619, -0.015433846972882748, -0.022108055651187897, 0.030120231211185455, 0.03020578995347023, -0.010218760930001736, 0.04133522883057594, -0.03965646028518677, -0.0461411327123642, -0.015832195058465004, -0.04406743869185448, -0.0023053535260260105, -0.01643148995935917, 0.01324391644448042, -0.0010199857642874122, -0.06306774169206619, -0.009768166579306126, 0.032778892666101456, -0.040452439337968826, 0.052953705191612244, 0.0662069097161293, -0.017562679946422577, 0.006220150273293257, 0.04211461916565895, 0.016495879739522934, -0.03408341109752655, 0.011140730232000351, -0.03377033770084381, -0.07475151866674423, 0.0032338148448616266, 0.022823922336101532, 0.008702290244400501, -0.004802787210792303, -0.011570258066058159, 0.016268497332930565, 0.05039140209555626, -0.005625785794109106, 0.033553414046764374, -0.004792063031345606, -0.048405252397060394, 0.02886970341205597, 0.012751197442412376, 0.018203986808657646, -0.0014331972924992442, -0.01541183702647686, 0.0019036942394450307, -0.0007427482632920146, 0.005859688390046358, 0.00465682428330183, 0.040189195424318314, -0.007470428943634033, 0.01425120048224926, 0.006703744176775217, 0.003992211073637009, 0.02646874077618122, -0.03844166547060013, 0.03243675082921982, 0.007437917869538069, -0.0125902583822608, 0.0161295086145401, -0.011014414951205254, -0.027349991723895073, 0.015676595270633698, 0.040722303092479706, -0.014286520890891552, 0.03755892813205719, 0.029359200969338417, -0.022215504199266434, -0.004797817207872868, -0.03907094895839691, -0.062262438237667084, -0.009209543466567993, 0.01827462948858738, 0.0022434829734265804, 0.012723767198622227, 0.03631577268242836, -0.03413540497422218, -0.0012409290065988898, -0.042773209512233734, -0.027675054967403412, -0.006364630069583654, 0.03806963935494423, -0.033857088536024094, 0.02390308678150177, -0.046414680778980255, -0.00968366302549839, 0.036286696791648865, -0.04345812276005745, -0.016663143411278725, 0.04836714640259743, -0.004265379160642624, -0.03530630096793175, -0.014446900226175785, -0.024426396936178207, 0.003917227499186993, -0.002039581537246704, -0.016775136813521385, -0.008135601878166199, 0.00015434781380463392, -0.03611460328102112, 0.021223802119493484, -0.01722791977226734, -0.015415317378938198, -0.003976340405642986, -0.011584240943193436, 0.028294768184423447, 0.03404496610164642, -0.0012046288466081023, -0.0033929592464119196, -0.015450987033545971, -0.04019847512245178, -0.0338151715695858, -0.0419139489531517, 0.03863179683685303, 0.0020471259485930204, 0.046450380235910416, -0.004974774084985256, 0.02118963934481144, 0.04123071953654289, 0.01767728663980961, -0.006894482299685478, -0.01597129926085472, -0.011356600560247898, -0.03297032043337822, -0.0037478164304047823, 0.031893808394670486, 0.021963922306895256, 0.0018295632908120751, 0.04237641021609306, 0.023681581020355225, 0.030226463451981544, 0.05800320953130722, 0.0009920999873429537, -0.017292605713009834, 0.030108507722616196, -0.01846281997859478, 0.009232955984771252, 0.016443902626633644, 0.04449289292097092, -0.0533355176448822, 0.012836749665439129, -0.006885422393679619, -0.0028530736453831196, 0.009074492380023003, -0.08547960221767426, 0.04033506661653519, 0.0025715501978993416, -0.00818180013448, -0.03503270819783211, 0.02285914495587349, -0.0003393300576135516, 0.003113714512437582, -0.029835762456059456, 0.03512062877416611, 0.002887312090024352, -0.04279250651597977, 0.026585742831230164, 0.01488554384559393, 0.05965469777584076, -0.0398922935128212, -0.013442046009004116, -0.0062457784079015255, 0.013764254748821259, 0.03740358352661133, -0.028085241094231606, 0.008844561874866486, 0.05257580056786537, 0.05024491995573044, 0.028865305706858635, -0.026874786242842674, -0.04717917740345001, -0.005710738245397806, -0.08809328824281693, 0.003906500060111284, -0.04683898761868477, 0.013833827339112759, -0.015380659140646458, 0.003926885314285755, -0.01586763747036457, 0.001600948628038168, -0.011688102036714554, -0.021444696933031082, -0.04659653827548027, 0.01633603312075138, -0.04827922210097313, -0.010259107686579227, -0.005331858526915312, -0.020330563187599182, 0.05059238523244858, -0.019607659429311752, 0.017475856468081474, -0.04249214008450508, 0.05728718638420105, -0.030890682712197304, -0.027748066931962967, -0.01982402801513672, -0.03454090654850006, -0.016331253573298454, -0.02032702974975109, 0.021547729149460793, 0.004602425266057253, 0.03377210721373558, 0.026858780533075333, 0.0006395043455995619, -0.04043673723936081, -0.08476701378822327, 0.009964175522327423, 0.028163615614175797, 0.03688207268714905, -0.01757889799773693, 0.024352051317691803, -0.05099404975771904, 0.03556342422962189, 0.028435925021767616, 0.053499531000852585, 0.037030354142189026, 0.01413996983319521, -0.05209306627511978, -0.013389361090958118, -0.04283939674496651, 0.006696256808936596, 0.03593125194311142, 0.017695914953947067, -0.01610066369175911, 0.046613361686468124, 0.004571857862174511, -0.015646839514374733, 0.04452759400010109, 0.05025416985154152, -0.0020663924515247345, 0.05755123496055603, -0.01853247731924057, -0.03835303336381912, -0.011102646589279175, -0.008334863930940628, 0.025925781577825546, 0.04374361410737038, 0.004315434955060482, -0.01141378190368414, 0.031723834574222565, 0.04758123308420181, -0.04286833480000496, 0.005030924454331398, 0.006813721731305122, 0.009440101683139801, 0.03511254861950874, -0.0024765857961028814, 0.03550850227475166, 0.012730415910482407, 0.0590297169983387, 0.04087632894515991, 0.026988668367266655, -0.05793245881795883, 0.021871643140912056, 0.05072619020938873, 0.0044613732025027275, -0.04466768726706505, 0.0066683911718428135, -0.04665142297744751, 0.005412887781858444, 0.03934137895703316, -0.01849428005516529, 0.02156563475728035, -0.0749911442399025, 0.034453947097063065, -0.0010548834688961506, -0.0687464103102684, -0.034860868006944656, 0.00971109140664339, -0.015829691663384438, 0.03821954503655434, -0.003358971094712615, -0.013416009955108166, -0.03464929014444351, 0.005286795552819967, 0.05142303183674812, 0.03204910084605217, -0.02088339440524578, -0.06352236866950989, 0.0157940611243248, 0.018478283658623695, -0.06647425144910812, -0.07401271164417267, -0.0001763870968716219, -0.028768625110387802, 0.0281804371625185, 0.04834555462002754, -0.0018009280320256948, -0.00933692418038845, 0.004676140379160643, -0.020672032609581947, -0.042807139456272125, -0.009940399788320065, -0.009942346252501011, 0.0059648542664945126, -0.009869612753391266, 0.01869908533990383, 0.01003253273665905, 0.033202122896909714, -0.00208640075288713, 0.014488505199551582, -0.020664580166339874, 0.017789533361792564, -0.03580639511346817, 0.004016771446913481, -0.052774909883737564, -0.022043025121092796, -0.041802555322647095, 0.018047792837023735, 0.03402893245220184, 0.022221341729164124, -0.04386526718735695, 0.008545472286641598, 0.04878900572657585, 0.040313005447387695, 0.0035272743552923203, 0.022961566224694252, -0.04012642428278923, 0.022204166278243065, -0.011657170951366425, -0.00032765266951173544, 0.04915085807442665, 0.036296114325523376, -0.017725011333823204, 0.007686166558414698, -0.07054267823696136, 0.008031899109482765, -0.018777169287204742, -0.017206396907567978, 0.019776104018092155, -0.015151028521358967, 0.046723511070013046, -0.008670015260577202, 0.010938210412859917, -0.0013245168374851346, -0.0535980761051178, -0.038204822689294815, 0.035136956721544266, 0.011718356050550938, 0.06127999350428581, -0.04153204709291458, 0.022956663742661476, -0.01793280988931656, 0.00444797333329916, -0.02807844989001751, -0.018268154934048653, 0.03845618665218353, 0.017911944538354874, -0.0360153503715992, -0.027627645060420036, 0.031065167859196663, -0.03351429104804993, -0.034613560885190964, -0.026037346571683884, 0.06530235707759857, -0.038605596870183945, -0.023770133033394814, -0.00999398436397314, -0.016747821122407913, 0.05819360166788101, -0.045196861028671265, -0.003446254413574934, 0.021088536828756332, -0.05944138392806053, -0.010614519938826561, -0.03273776173591614, -0.009075707755982876, -0.01645728573203087, -0.03177587687969208, -0.038161296397447586, 0.015354370698332787, 0.010084117762744427, -0.038862720131874084, -0.0077386475168168545, 0.04374861344695091, -0.0217454731464386, 0.019428908824920654, -0.013282106257975101, 0.03644362464547157, -0.05086728557944298, -0.018666205927729607, -0.010590910911560059, 0.026097189635038376, -0.0036916795652359724, -0.03592425957322121, 0.021144013851881027, -0.025443127378821373, -0.038749534636735916, 0.037054818123579025, 0.018240679055452347, -0.01612408459186554, 0.032352264970541, 0.00970575213432312, -0.03642769902944565, 0.06461788713932037, -0.0027467976324260235, -0.02697318233549595, 0.011621525511145592, 0.020921435207128525, -0.010055458173155785, -0.030146215111017227, -0.0020129552576690912, -0.012280715629458427, 0.057134658098220825, -0.011089915409684181, 0.019687915220856667, 0.030012451112270355, -0.04235297068953514, -0.0013802151661366224, -0.004819046705961227, 0.013822603039443493, 0.01658514328300953, -0.016918420791625977, 0.01810513809323311, -0.04727271944284439, 0.010504874400794506, 0.06818778067827225, 0.005073058884590864, 0.015398872084915638, -0.017098242416977882, 0.009899686090648174, 0.01056209858506918, 0.017936967313289642, -0.013490540906786919, -0.027967682108283043, 0.026754746213555336, -0.0551905632019043, -0.005138092674314976, -0.04139459505677223, -0.004855609964579344, 0.038141727447509766, -0.013304624706506729, -0.013899369165301323, -0.01431380957365036, -0.03133271262049675, -0.05624959617853165, 0.03751962631940842, -0.00007393348641926423, -0.008424339815974236, 0.031346626579761505, -0.006052981596440077, 0.04053104296326637, -0.003319112118333578, 0.007327225524932146, -0.06375308334827423, -0.08495044708251953, -0.045844294130802155, -0.012343872338533401, 0.014613890089094639, 0.041145313531160355, -0.012339827604591846, -0.01651570573449135, 0.022337201982736588, -0.01349014975130558, -0.01006433553993702, 0.05927010625600815, 0.01433966401964426, -0.005594766233116388, 0.06425897032022476, 0.028176812455058098, 0.0068137310445308685, 0.003689413657411933, -0.0030134182889014482, 0.14634910225868225, 0.03921365737915039, 0.048748910427093506, -0.0379127636551857, 0.009191899560391903, 0.02863733097910881, 0.0076427762396633625, -0.012449834495782852, 0.010117825120687485, 0.028290588408708572, 0.014118015766143799, -0.0044489228166639805, 0.05458800494670868, 0.00748383579775691, -0.019710049033164978, 0.04424087703227997, -0.004198548849672079, -0.04693067818880081, -0.0033061476424336433, -0.007845786400139332, 0.005824098363518715, 0.0003358235117048025, -0.0276037510484457, -0.03798241540789604, 0.0008732400019653141, -0.013567130081355572, -0.012514603324234486, 0.0239189974963665, 0.012286689132452011, 0.024886682629585266, 0.009844094514846802, 0.013537716120481491, 0.046481065452098846, 0.04565734416246414, -0.024826297536492348, -0.05598610267043114, 0.012382588349282742, -0.007220537401735783, 0.00470677250996232, 0.05604537948966026, -0.002167730825021863, 0.007572609465569258, 0.005495887249708176, 0.04803699254989624, -0.041718740016222, -0.016348378732800484, -0.03842611610889435, 0.05434277281165123, -0.00305266585201025, 0.01867641881108284, 0.005650569684803486, -0.030617861077189445, -0.02002255991101265, -0.005146567244082689, -0.028601564466953278, -0.0020979568362236023, 0.01926688477396965, -0.04673830792307854, 0.00022793773678131402, -0.025309981778264046, 0.01892039366066456, 0.00478553818538785, 0.026340043172240257, 0.06379305571317673, -0.01463442761451006, -0.028497792780399323, -0.034082457423210144, 0.0409155897796154, -0.020141059532761574, 0.008608431555330753, 0.009107694961130619, -0.0036687112879008055, -0.05804308131337166, -0.00509866327047348, 0.005197525955736637, 0.0200330913066864, 0.04270795360207558, 0.026846138760447502, -0.0004997733049094677, -0.049692440778017044, -0.0446120947599411, 0.01983390748500824, -0.022242490202188492, -0.01413844432681799, -0.05236073583364487, -0.015164028853178024, 0.023886211216449738, 0.016578491777181625, -0.011337543837726116, 0.005543095991015434, 0.0025379599537700415, 0.008453215472400188, 0.006392495706677437, -0.04723614454269409, -0.008012291975319386, -0.036649588495492935, -0.024830317124724388, 0.00702657550573349, -0.009287465363740921, 0.061673734337091446, 0.024614837020635605, 0.02743745781481266, 0.03643080219626427, 0.04205094277858734, 0.027129486203193665, -0.01753810979425907, 0.02757752686738968, -0.05133245140314102, -0.022363224998116493, 0.002360493876039982, 0.06377919763326645, -0.050141170620918274, -0.022635791450738907, -0.0178900808095932, -0.04054063558578491, -0.007304325699806213, -0.04797227308154106, 0.002662995597347617, 0.02470715530216694, 0.020496001467108727, 0.03501226380467415, -0.008378439582884312, 0.039643414318561554, -0.06973477452993393, -0.06755959987640381, -0.01347037497907877, -0.04949904605746269, -0.016816599294543266, 0.024061139672994614, -0.025021225214004517, 0.020645473152399063, 0.001049818005412817, 0.039231106638908386, -0.02259654738008976, -0.020406845957040787, -0.0020521439146250486, 0.012309063225984573, 0.0161923598498106, 0.0134928859770298, 0.024600088596343994, 0.012080803513526917, -0.03690262511372566, -0.03030344471335411, -0.011455900967121124, -0.006770664360374212, 0.004448660649359226, 0.017581870779395103, 0.023648390546441078, 0.0013879365287721157, 0.039804041385650635, -0.032539334148168564, -0.0009328168234787881, 0.02104869857430458, 0.014146707020699978, -0.023913241922855377, 0.001814023358747363, 0.010090808384120464, 0.01719774305820465, -0.01901855133473873, 0.021837441250681877, 0.05752348154783249, 0.018263084813952446, 0.026077287271618843, 0.018394455313682556, 0.013942698016762733, 0.04308457672595978, -0.029845470562577248, 0.020429981872439384, 0.05203225463628769, 0.05284956097602844, -0.013916398398578167, 0.02738865464925766, 0.0002356198529014364, 0.030731720849871635, -0.09889650344848633, 0.00012560360482893884, 0.028708769008517265, -0.023794816806912422, 0.034704308956861496, -0.0376925989985466, 0.026311514899134636, -0.012358615174889565, -0.04517050459980965, -0.014404578134417534, -0.02957017533481121, -0.004202666692435741, -0.05045069381594658, 0.022719044238328934, -0.044775884598493576, 0.033356763422489166, 0.00722730066627264, 0.04264901578426361, -0.006861758418381214, 0.018429957330226898, 0.008929536677896976, 0.00524218799546361, -0.03299904614686966, 0.023917973041534424, 0.01799721084535122, -0.03620928153395653, 0.04677664488554001, -0.029865790158510208, -0.01002765353769064, 0.03299183398485184, -0.012989883311092854, 0.05126476287841797, 0.0036404780112206936, -0.014136861078441143, -0.00926111824810505, 0.011344119906425476, 0.04504983499646187, 0.017550261691212654, 0.001221651560626924, -0.023328209295868874, 0.0040215421468019485, 0.03434335067868233, -0.024939004331827164, 0.034431882202625275, 0.041044361889362335, -0.043567340821027756, -0.021120542660355568, -0.020255379378795624, 0.006957740522921085, -0.019783908501267433, 0.001750921132043004, 0.009065231308341026, 0.011044690385460854, -0.010572788305580616, 0.04286567121744156, -0.048000406473875046, 0.010739129036664963, 0.0389067567884922, 0.04058148339390755, 0.019835039973258972, 0.05366523563861847, -0.03922739624977112, 0.004662632942199707, -0.009494964964687824, -0.0466664656996727, -0.0008333203149959445, -0.03974146768450737, 0.016669560223817825, -0.008130013011395931, -0.005357859656214714, -0.035190027207136154, -0.005728431511670351, -0.007887852378189564, 0.0421554371714592, -0.024381814524531364, 0.004690517205744982, 0.03611035645008087, 0.01967620849609375, 0.021659716963768005, -0.047925423830747604, 0.05408933386206627, 0.002449285238981247, 0.021841123700141907, -0.02125089056789875, -0.010411600582301617, 0.03117235191166401, 0.018515240401029587, 0.026548076421022415, -0.019878732040524483, 0.0171090979129076, 0.0036012930795550346, 0.014518407173454762, -0.04267082363367081, -0.004326581954956055, 0.07079721987247467, -0.014989226125180721, 0.0018892131047323346, 0.008834646083414555, 0.023050457239151, 0.022503480315208435, 0.013372552581131458, 0.004194745793938637, 0.02817540243268013, -0.0017739222384989262, 0.05405092611908913, -0.0026195773389190435, 0.02032133750617504, -0.003738903673365712, -0.018717339262366295, 0.0250380951911211, 0.02273363620042801, 0.051522064954042435, 0.005217131692916155, -0.0027350520249456167, -0.06891518831253052, 0.03066711314022541, -0.020815324038267136, -0.05823981389403343, 0.024656392633914948, 0.007492790464311838, -0.00357614504173398, -0.05306144058704376, 0.015655549243092537, -0.02629431150853634, -0.04754771664738655, 0.027240494266152382, 0.019809987396001816, 0.026106497272849083, 0.02352484129369259, -0.010495045222342014, -0.007397845387458801, 0.003522985614836216, -0.0036782699171453714, -0.0035059265792369843, 0.04015125334262848, 0.05388974770903587, 0.004029702860862017, -0.004361164290457964, 0.04540596529841423, -0.017326371744275093, 0.011074749752879143, 0.017749669030308723, 0.020019957795739174, -0.026058249175548553, -0.008512856438755989, -0.009557376615703106, 0.00821919646114111, -0.003281083656474948, 0.04193342477083206, 0.011957383714616299, 0.07157309353351593, 0.03593843802809715, 0.02767707221210003, 0.0027778116054832935, -0.017331290990114212, -0.013529499992728233, 0.004251569975167513, -0.032162267714738846, 0.02770240046083927, 0.016275368630886078, 0.017336521297693253, -0.027562830597162247, 0.0042076632380485535, 0.01792183890938759, 0.0029536362271755934, 0.008863854221999645, -0.030613770708441734, -0.037089258432388306, -0.017524631693959236, -0.012719179503619671, -0.002510946011170745, -0.010321056470274925, 0.02414044737815857, 0.047316774725914, -0.0050736237317323685, -0.04716473072767258, -0.017357580363750458, -0.013906310312449932, 0.05635642632842064, -0.08513347804546356, -0.02104308269917965, -0.043003275990486145, 0.0018142233602702618, -0.042573779821395874, -0.003755844896659255 ]
<p>I am estimating a linear probability model with a hierarchical structure. I am bootstrapping standard errors to test the significance of the coefficients in order to double check the parametric estimates of the standard errors. </p> <p>In the bootstrapping process I am finding that the coefficients are all positive (which I expected) but there are a few extreme positive outliers. The outliers make the standard errors huge and subsequent t-statistics small. This is misleading because an empirical p-value has a value under 0.01. </p> <p>My questions are</p> <ol> <li><p>What is the best way to convey that this coefficient is statistically different from zero? </p></li> <li><p>What would be the best way to report these results? Normally in a LaTex table I report coefficients plus standard errors. </p></li> </ol>
37,240
[ -0.008660190738737583, 0.005314564798027277, -0.005212970077991486, 0.026375768706202507, 0.0057577150873839855, 0.048504624515771866, 0.021122772246599197, 0.012760750949382782, 0.022928686812520027, -0.011393251828849316, 0.06098056584596634, 0.028620941564440727, 0.03976421803236008, 0.010311106219887733, 0.016580844298005104, -0.017055857926607132, -0.03163500130176544, -0.009424799121916294, 0.01217236090451479, 0.0006007372285239398, -0.022931216284632683, 0.03043651580810547, -0.022398438304662704, 0.006906263064593077, 0.009914166294038296, 0.023218709975481033, 0.009595826268196106, 0.022422371432185173, 0.01565597765147686, 0.061740268021821976, -0.035490501672029495, -0.009835767559707165, -0.0025764566380530596, -0.029174979776144028, 0.045204803347587585, -0.006758171133697033, -0.01923704706132412, -0.04291917756199837, 0.014997465535998344, 0.02772609516978264, -0.0409163199365139, -0.03270420432090759, 0.024510646238923073, 0.05215127766132355, -0.0030849440954625607, 0.0028159581124782562, 0.0010441512567922473, -0.010242946445941925, 0.047869548201560974, -0.03220973163843155, 0.0026420559734106064, -0.006354887038469315, 0.04009215161204338, 0.06054467335343361, -0.03203657269477844, -0.0011353562586009502, 0.007941811345517635, 0.04798099398612976, 0.0022642582189291716, -0.026042023673653603, -0.01008913666009903, -0.03123195469379425, -0.00463615357875824, -0.02408697083592415, -0.02610672079026699, 0.016826661303639412, 0.0015488055068999529, -0.04764539375901222, 0.028457986190915108, -0.054201189428567886, 0.00019601215899456292, 0.008973334915935993, 0.01733080856502056, -0.035157885402441025, 0.03410056605935097, -0.053867194801568985, 0.012246291153132915, 0.010818115435540676, 0.04704161733388901, 0.04407155141234398, 0.0074522243812680244, 0.010479156859219074, 0.00023921403044369072, 0.014172594994306564, 0.01467305701225996, -0.012308567762374878, 0.04784267395734787, -0.02091902494430542, 0.021137606352567673, 0.019273851066827774, -0.03764325752854347, -0.02026042342185974, 0.05241525173187256, 0.013860020786523819, -0.025327466428279877, 0.009195888414978981, 0.000517109059728682, 0.016284886747598648, 0.021604254841804504, 0.019836287945508957, -0.010679888539016247, -0.026170138269662857, 0.011892233975231647, 0.057356320321559906, -0.0017547613242641091, 0.0408361479640007, -0.030111875385046005, -0.02793179638683796, -0.008394109085202217, -0.01927119493484497, -0.014547038823366165, -0.009221870452165604, -0.002816941821947694, 0.023284124210476875, 0.008292097598314285, -0.0022159763611853123, 0.03680649772286415, -0.02439970150589943, 0.043928492814302444, 0.027975624427199364, 0.039426039904356, -0.030001560226082802, 0.036878954619169235, -0.008715980686247349, -0.03656437247991562, 0.03050435334444046, 0.028637196868658066, -0.02115575224161148, -0.04503514617681503, 0.034282390028238297, 0.03632732480764389, 0.010245098732411861, 0.030783001333475113, -0.021502729505300522, 0.017135772854089737, 0.010908211581408978, -0.07750539481639862, -0.10664595663547516, 0.04593374580144882, 0.006085605826228857, -0.037824030965566635, -0.03968428075313568, -0.059164997190237045, 0.04231053963303566, 0.05826335400342941, 0.018135229125618935, 0.024245353415608406, 0.015800178050994873, 0.04060402512550354, 0.020395303145051003, -0.030627237632870674, 0.021248994395136833, -0.017294494435191154, -0.03148787468671799, -0.019048325717449188, -0.09151201695203781, 0.018631353974342346, 0.018587246537208557, -0.013653554953634739, -0.003171781310811639, 0.04416105896234512, -0.03827788308262825, 0.0082029327750206, 0.0001226436288561672, -0.013000176288187504, -0.011009104549884796, 0.08132786303758621, -0.004261460620909929, 0.01745770312845707, 0.01995568349957466, 0.007726410403847694, 0.06258761882781982, 0.005660126451402903, 0.027164068073034286, 0.01844726875424385, -0.011971588246524334, 0.004534938372671604, -0.021995188668370247, 0.01598638854920864, -0.015329611487686634, -0.052021559327840805, -0.023840539157390594, -0.007378970272839069, -0.0040033417753875256, 0.006599359214305878, 0.01683981716632843, -0.0001149118397734128, -0.04402317851781845, 0.05317312851548195, -0.01390041969716549, -0.06642003357410431, -0.052557580173015594, 0.018531760200858116, 0.012073872610926628, -0.0021587752271443605, 0.04615363851189613, -0.018039211630821228, -0.0030032366048544645, -0.02993580512702465, 0.04038798436522484, -0.004822095390409231, 0.00017943793500307947, 0.040730226784944534, -0.04490939527750015, 0.023663781583309174, 0.04557046666741371, 0.08623035252094269, 0.035746973007917404, 0.006206853315234184, -0.002207129029557109, 0.016319217160344124, -0.0020832864101976156, -0.04104459658265114, -0.019373949617147446, -0.0255241971462965, -0.01624060794711113, 0.016652382910251617, -0.00015134345449041575, 0.010626600123941898, 0.02399446628987789, -0.012798435986042023, 0.07375592738389969, 0.05344073101878166, 0.0050702947191894054, -0.016188420355319977, 0.0077673690393567085, 0.009843077510595322, 0.02333846502006054, 0.0001549997105030343, 0.011239810846745968, -0.0597267709672451, -0.02099311724305153, 0.03089466318488121, 0.021201960742473602, -0.02358006127178669, 0.03347303345799446, 0.0743740051984787, -0.01996694505214691, -0.012339356355369091, 0.01972213014960289, -0.015506291761994362, -0.034161973744630814, 0.023631669580936432, -0.032273344695568085, 0.01912856474518776, 0.042653102427721024, 0.01586778461933136, 0.015279796905815601, 0.03912218287587166, 0.023077739402651787, 0.016237137839198112, 0.0005911055486649275, -0.018016593530774117, 0.020050223916769028, -0.04964607581496239, -0.026086900383234024, 0.04939793795347214, -0.021596506237983704, 0.011638833209872246, 0.02208116464316845, -0.013703707605600357, 0.012336216866970062, -0.005583537742495537, -0.01962560974061489, 0.012630699202418327, 0.039667464792728424, -0.043432753533124924, -0.015602832660079002, 0.03718487545847893, -0.025142258033156395, 0.01667875237762928, -0.06934824585914612, -0.03057696297764778, -0.02640427090227604, -0.003382309339940548, 0.027591804042458534, -0.02225550077855587, 0.043112706393003464, -0.006436839234083891, -0.03100612759590149, -0.011330456472933292, 0.0036813158076256514, 0.07236219197511673, 0.009965329430997372, -0.04020636901259422, -0.00908744614571333, -0.05838935822248459, -0.03941403701901436, 0.04166729375720024, 0.0124037591740489, -0.010171936824917793, -0.0029609138146042824, -0.019850673153996468, 0.0004181996046099812, -0.035660549998283386, -0.03486788272857666, -0.010738003998994827, -0.03403960168361664, -0.0302512776106596, 0.029414573684334755, -0.02555588074028492, 0.0038736702408641577, 0.019007286056876183, -0.06387221068143845, -0.009447897784411907, -0.03939124941825867, 0.020554745569825172, -0.009608574211597443, 0.015148874372243881, -0.003720714710652828, -0.027831684798002243, -0.00104911916423589, -0.021322641521692276, -0.0930967926979065, -0.03573436662554741, -0.02796277590095997, 0.003548271721228957, 0.07008703798055649, -0.03277576342225075, -0.02248033508658409, 0.06875418871641159, 0.051704421639442444, -0.00408089067786932, -0.017740892246365547, -0.04618731513619423, -0.059585247188806534, -0.04735112562775612, 0.025371702387928963, 0.007996567524969578, 0.03458312526345253, 0.03997174650430679, -0.05090600997209549, -0.011919399723410606, 0.032449111342430115, 0.0023572153877466917, 0.019693076610565186, -0.010251895524561405, -0.019645435735583305, -0.037609636783599854, 0.031985264271497726, 0.0537065826356411, -0.007972397841513157, 0.03581596165895462, 0.005204472690820694, 0.03448835760354996, 0.028223268687725067, -0.021111398935317993, -0.01945142261683941, 0.004483549389988184, -0.013598174788057804, -0.04728202521800995, 0.024644430726766586, 0.029849011451005936, 0.0134933115914464, -0.013601727783679962, -0.016321726143360138, 0.0039246827363967896, -0.022196326404809952, 0.02041935734450817, 0.03791528567671776, 0.04917434975504875, -0.011654051952064037, -0.016935644671320915, -0.03683192655444145, 0.0218399278819561, 0.014895192347466946, -0.025323938578367233, -0.0004340733867138624, 0.04125509411096573, 0.04666499048471451, -0.011092700995504856, -0.0015667948173359036, -0.05341337248682976, -0.004689228720963001, -0.029261130839586258, -0.00333777884952724, -0.011696262285113335, 0.06287556886672974, -0.037534501403570175, -0.0007311140652745962, -0.01795228384435177, 0.009170062839984894, 0.0065427180379629135, 0.012645439244806767, -0.08149561285972595, 0.01794274151325226, -0.017967380583286285, -0.004578847438097, 0.018178999423980713, -0.009329943917691708, 0.018017848953604698, -0.038780953735113144, 0.008844214491546154, 0.026716535910964012, 0.02859269455075264, 0.015927797183394432, 0.02754729799926281, -0.003692605532705784, 0.000711838947609067, -0.007799332030117512, -0.02274087443947792, 0.025372251868247986, 0.0046957917511463165, 0.016832347959280014, 0.029907619580626488, 0.006318932864814997, 0.009098811075091362, -0.05672306939959526, -0.009830292314291, 0.016978153958916664, 0.02947138249874115, 0.01246925350278616, 0.007465191651135683, -0.06911984086036682, 0.05652604252099991, -0.013387179933488369, 0.04929409176111221, 0.04031907394528389, -0.002536558313295245, -0.02682316116988659, -0.02254679799079895, -0.03561178222298622, 0.010572717525064945, 0.0037857445422559977, -0.024680795148015022, -0.009442971087992191, 0.056120745837688446, 0.03713388368487358, -0.03626213222742081, 0.04548710212111473, 0.02556024305522442, 0.029074007645249367, -0.011710298247635365, 0.017863081768155098, -0.03853417560458183, -0.004387933760881424, -0.03824259713292122, -0.0125380028039217, 0.03530517593026161, -0.005066308658570051, -0.005801053252071142, 0.014875657856464386, 0.025474268943071365, -0.05042321979999542, 0.012539896182715893, 0.010402295738458633, 0.018674539402127266, -0.027245748788118362, -0.013868140988051891, 0.02235722355544567, 0.02832512930035591, 0.005303109064698219, 0.029894361272454262, -0.02002154290676117, -0.07949668169021606, -0.02664175257086754, 0.07093261182308197, 0.05848531424999237, -0.020091859623789787, -0.0008865849231369793, -0.03189548850059509, -0.010973810218274593, 0.03157490864396095, -0.04190918058156967, 0.030847027897834778, -0.022872714325785637, -0.023022014647722244, -0.020339081063866615, -0.012569191865622997, -0.051562391221523285, -0.015778126195073128, 0.0022570681758224964, 0.050928786396980286, -0.014702188782393932, -0.03586781769990921, -0.055107876658439636, 0.009344096295535564, 0.018799180164933205, 0.04848317429423332, -0.034972790628671646, -0.02030993439257145, 0.024843761697411537, -0.0004466582031454891, 0.005275221075862646, -0.06603360921144485, 0.030344609171152115, 0.021573176607489586, 0.01908509060740471, 0.056546181440353394, 0.0011538349790498614, -0.056469738483428955, 0.007616495713591576, 0.011747331358492374, -0.02528860606253147, 0.010735342279076576, -0.021922871470451355, 0.012899252586066723, 0.019389918074011803, 0.023833181709051132, 0.055152036249637604, 0.03683295473456383, -0.02353644371032715, 0.049142152070999146, -0.06610678136348724, 0.00793179776519537, -0.04075898230075836, -0.010595899075269699, -0.05191878229379654, -0.004947366192936897, -0.056426338851451874, 0.03142111748456955, 0.014608805999159813, 0.042829480022192, -0.0038771224208176136, -0.01821131445467472, 0.03182993084192276, 0.07469415664672852, -0.014841852709650993, 0.02603903040289879, 0.01687607541680336, -0.0008553153020329773, -0.00007791307871229947, -0.03280194476246834, 0.004594588652253151, -0.025194404646754265, 0.0006863335729576647, -0.012080956250429153, -0.04927508905529976, 0.02215258963406086, -0.027500499039888382, -0.046214450150728226, -0.010053248144686222, -0.03569059818983078, 0.021984659135341644, 0.024486633017659187, 0.03670613467693329, -0.015929318964481354, -0.008864415809512138, -0.02244735322892666, 0.04943879321217537, -0.02422782965004444, 0.019132869318127632, -0.05009619519114494, 0.02839367464184761, -0.02079096995294094, -0.007328115403652191, -0.0634569525718689, -0.045888155698776245, 0.024994710460305214, 0.04567087069153786, -0.011715270578861237, -0.006692727096378803, -0.02378888800740242, -0.016003746539354324, -0.022105276584625244, -0.0017221326706930995, 0.06459274142980576, -0.01419108361005783, -0.008928213268518448, 0.013770327903330326, 0.01729334518313408, 0.08555574715137482, -0.015369841828942299, -0.029541492462158203, 0.009222363121807575, 0.008177146315574646, -0.004997047130018473, 0.020758168771862984, -0.011300635524094105, -0.035049501806497574, -0.07339414954185486, -0.052677471190690994, 0.01813007891178131, 0.007460801396518946, -0.006835802923887968, 0.018241045996546745, 0.008134476840496063, -0.014206836000084877, 0.017784148454666138, -0.014930667355656624, 0.028604984283447266, -0.031054990366101265, -0.0019564833492040634, -0.026296792551875114, -0.0013040502090007067, -0.0004199770337436348, -0.04743406921625137, 0.025806298479437828, -0.029995445162057877, -0.03184956684708595, -0.003093875013291836, 0.07671055942773819, 0.02321048639714718, 0.007729073520749807, -0.019634943455457687, -0.030358385294675827, 0.07141370326280594, 0.028619591146707535, -0.018813973292708397, -0.00451806653290987, -0.005107274278998375, -0.028137804940342903, -0.03463583439588547, -0.005969335790723562, -0.018036361783742905, 0.027068397030234337, 0.03833572939038277, 0.04559684544801712, 0.05447402223944664, -0.0033804993145167828, 0.003022623946890235, -0.01393518503755331, -0.0034197038039565086, 0.00822136178612709, 0.024537188932299614, 0.029492706060409546, -0.010611889883875847, 0.04893767088651657, 0.03017701581120491, -0.021547703072428703, -0.009251665323972702, 0.04486177861690521, 0.015871120616793633, -0.009812538512051105, 0.015568864531815052, -0.04178443178534508, -0.022298937663435936, 0.05311015620827675, -0.06805164366960526, 0.034585319459438324, -0.01508844643831253, -0.03363419324159622, -0.0013286088360473514, 0.02459312044084072, 0.019095340743660927, -0.050569016486406326, -0.0014039784437045455, -0.07520058006048203, -0.0027023646980524063, 0.04760033264756203, -0.027840934693813324, 0.0022642698604613543, -0.01644458994269371, 0.045789457857608795, -0.01853173039853573, 0.006728467531502247, -0.05800245329737663, -0.0615534633398056, -0.023569509387016296, -0.04653507471084595, -0.05904305726289749, 0.021563109010457993, -0.03991350904107094, 0.012687219306826591, 0.015131315216422081, -0.054527249187231064, -0.009137655608355999, 0.033178988844156265, 0.040481459349393845, -0.03505062684416771, 0.01061471551656723, -0.0026541894767433405, -0.0006595894228667021, 0.009993359446525574, -0.005088724661618471, 0.10706081986427307, 0.08660788089036942, 0.03689611703157425, -0.05520588904619217, 0.024442151188850403, -0.021115565672516823, 0.029926419258117676, -0.02280350960791111, 0.007205464411526918, -0.008890606462955475, -0.010515894740819931, 0.0034201208036392927, 0.07762745022773743, -0.01844078116118908, 0.01736089587211609, 0.03710273653268814, -0.03790805861353874, 0.013338571414351463, -0.020012399181723595, 0.018909351900219917, -0.0048684715293347836, 0.023659024387598038, -0.041763126850128174, 0.0006352150812745094, 0.008513277396559715, 0.00039034371729940176, -0.023574987426400185, -0.03367137536406517, 0.00964240450412035, 0.013188670389354229, -0.05267820879817009, -0.001956942956894636, 0.056975435465574265, 0.020661240443587303, 0.026602299883961678, -0.025854922831058502, -0.010683468542993069, -0.032341789454221725, 0.010295597836375237, 0.05347754806280136, -0.00026278497534804046, -0.02698793075978756, 0.039328206330537796, 0.029131300747394562, -0.05951469764113426, -0.05853128060698509, -0.012768826447427273, 0.035449303686618805, -0.02172151394188404, -0.00410435488447547, -0.019053682684898376, 0.02464778907597065, -0.008904917165637016, -0.036352384835481644, 0.014439667575061321, 0.023847972974181175, 0.014431105926632881, -0.03958924859762192, -0.04175301641225815, -0.006359973922371864, 0.00798772368580103, -0.014496431685984135, -0.011366740800440311, 0.0327313095331192, -0.00489959679543972, 0.017487751320004463, -0.020262427628040314, 0.02558548003435135, -0.0005379944923333824, -0.006248661316931248, 0.002186552621424198, 0.0019433991983532906, -0.030981454998254776, 0.004904677160084248, 0.010193145833909512, -0.02332097850739956, 0.015337257646024227, 0.021479804068803787, 0.018087690696120262, -0.031869035214185715, -0.035099077969789505, 0.04832202196121216, -0.02082926779985428, 0.003429718781262636, -0.0304707121104002, -0.024185560643672943, -0.014141980558633804, 0.00956354197114706, 0.021747440099716187, 0.024242039769887924, 0.02288839779794216, 0.06265507638454437, 0.021380210295319557, -0.056228574365377426, -0.016832400113344193, 0.013872343115508556, -0.034242503345012665, -0.007783176843076944, 0.015720585361123085, 0.0719231441617012, 0.031205257400870323, 0.008810341358184814, 0.012243086472153664, 0.026381840929389, -0.003796997480094433, -0.014673481695353985, 0.03916705399751663, -0.023393496870994568, 0.0015237508341670036, 0.029013605788350105, -0.00003773608841584064, -0.00047822852502577007, -0.012835869565606117, -0.03991067409515381, -0.025485815480351448, -0.002510191174224019, 0.044307246804237366, -0.031963225454092026, 0.024419348686933517, -0.03119547851383686, 0.0010943476809188724, -0.026598596945405006, -0.01982584036886692, -0.027602043002843857, -0.02252720668911934, 0.05107634887099266, -0.016844002529978752, 0.006471110507845879, 0.0019064521184191108, -0.012329845689237118, 0.041372429579496384, 0.02970741130411625, 0.01507264282554388, 0.01346522755920887, 0.00394768500700593, -0.007997897453606129, 0.0031631896272301674, 0.03581124171614647, -0.0022464098874479532, -0.005335859023034573, 0.04290357232093811, 0.013649128377437592, -0.046752966940402985, 0.036078840494155884, -0.0004132402245886624, 0.01509137824177742, -0.0014341834466904402, 0.006872674450278282, -0.021007800474762917, 0.02147297002375126, -0.03005574829876423, -0.02098832093179226, -0.02926822192966938, 0.001661960850469768, -0.008553817868232727, 0.0244661383330822, 0.005112356506288052, -0.0088661452755332, -0.051599692553281784, 0.022183720022439957, 0.06437861919403076, 0.00619535194709897, -0.03464747592806816, -0.027605652809143066, 0.003942959941923618, 0.016850154846906662, -0.014300360344350338, 0.018198277801275253, 0.017424872145056725, 0.04748374968767166, -0.053999558091163635, 0.03902106732130051, -0.008603314869105816, 0.02579585835337639, -0.08969831466674805, -0.066918283700943, 0.00543231749907136, 0.028653278946876526, 0.008387584239244461, -0.03854016214609146, -0.027066519483923912, 0.07227572798728943, -0.013948911800980568, 0.04927689582109451, -0.0100909024477005, -0.029292156919836998, -0.02896161749958992, -0.02951752580702305, -0.023239029571413994, 0.04791340231895447, 0.03313218057155609, 0.03843728080391884, 0.003365085693076253, 0.042857155203819275, 0.01595805585384369, -0.030939193442463875, -0.009522316977381706, 0.007450208533555269, -0.004015808459371328, -0.05468257889151573, 0.013891717419028282, -0.03535029664635658, -0.010286279022693634, 0.03726561740040779, -0.006618492305278778, -0.00723764393478632, 0.021199433133006096, 0.0026962491683661938, 0.00493982806801796, 0.08970177918672562, 0.020343080163002014, 0.0020166945178061724, -0.018265554681420326, -0.034915145486593246, 0.02927326038479805, 0.018944574519991875, -0.031672004610300064, 0.04068181291222572, 0.01866278238594532, -0.021143026649951935, -0.014073084108531475, 0.031032267957925797, -0.01342260092496872, 0.010348646901547909, -0.0029671171214431524, 0.0032112998887896538, 0.019276704639196396, -0.006366177927702665, -0.0023810691200196743, -0.03840286657214165, 0.030835336074233055, 0.010099542327225208, 0.05830007046461105, -0.01102723553776741, 0.02520415000617504, -0.03950363025069237, -0.023344600573182106, -0.0071061584167182446, 0.00920279324054718, -0.056467343121767044, -0.0658259317278862, -0.011397733353078365, -0.0187192652374506, 0.01519082859158516, 0.011665546335279942, -0.019830355420708656, -0.055103275924921036, 0.015432430431246758, -0.037197403609752655, 0.013828501105308533, 0.009849250316619873, -0.014807436615228653, 0.013312391005456448, -0.10264088213443756, 0.047954149544239044, 0.014699527062475681, 0.017700856551527977, -0.010330429300665855, -0.016347086057066917, -0.0407402478158474, 0.0309599619358778, 0.05800090730190277, 0.050974760204553604, -0.0261065773665905, 0.008891576901078224, 0.028231846168637276, 0.00725945271551609, -0.028743967413902283, 0.0362493172287941, 0.029497690498828888, -0.0038663027808070183, 0.009667724370956421, -0.020941929891705513, 0.030396148562431335, 0.01399537455290556, 0.03550722450017929, -0.021133635193109512, 0.042842067778110504, 0.002585646463558078, -0.008388460613787174, 0.06087696552276611, -0.000454252352938056, -0.04338216409087181, 0.07537154853343964, 0.00007432082202285528, -0.03212335333228111, 0.0374748632311821, -0.0023302631452679634, -0.03001175820827484, 0.01660655438899994, 0.010323826223611832, -0.04920599237084389, 0.0056927939876914024, 0.011791810393333435, -0.014698414131999016, -0.07538016885519028, -0.007439437787979841, 0.03661920502781868, -0.004772811662405729, -0.013833527453243732, 0.02854706160724163, 0.05272699519991875, 0.059061408042907715, -0.025088153779506683, 0.0036940223071724176, 0.02870558761060238, -0.04281610995531082, 0.028657427057623863, 0.029363717883825302, 0.06580519676208496, 0.008789252489805222, 0.06587209552526474, 0.01872233860194683, -0.029049726203083992, 0.03784015402197838, -0.024416223168373108, 0.04461948946118355, -0.05152048543095589, -0.00816512294113636, 0.02739284560084343, -0.0016361592570319772, 0.03924519568681717, -0.0012109829112887383, 0.003793324576690793, 0.02153816632926464, 0.0008778618066571653, -0.0275082066655159, -0.05060858651995659, 0.024574793875217438, -0.035594724118709564, 0.009578016586601734, 0.022027796134352684, 0.0573599599301815, -0.008702483028173447, -0.0006581619963981211, -0.018309812992811203, 0.005927706602960825, 0.014312738552689552, -0.02312394045293331, 0.013082211837172508, -0.04900522902607918, 0.005953911226242781, -0.022390281781554222, -0.03171120211482048, -0.03260882571339607, -0.012092886492609978, 0.019213546067476273, 0.041173920035362244, 0.023945193737745285, -0.019650738686323166, -0.04645893722772598, 0.0011294842697679996, 0.017410816624760628, -0.0330662727355957, -0.004433986730873585, -0.017873689532279968, 0.01048015896230936, -0.04239233583211899, -0.0427408404648304 ]
<p>I have a set of data for companies in a certain industry. The data set spans two consecutive years, 2000 and 2001. </p> <p>Let's say I have 100 unique companies in the dataset and I calculate average service time for each company and for each year. </p> <p>How do I test whether the average waiting time for company x in 2001 is less than the average waiting time for company x in 2000?</p> <p>The data set contains all service transactions performed by company x in 2000 and 2001, and this is what confuses me. The way I understand hypothesis test is that you test the null hypothesis using sample mean. However, with this data I have the population mean so what does it mean when your professor ask you to test whether the average service time in 2001 is less than the average service time in 2000 using "simple mean comparison test such as t-statistic"?</p>
74,374
[ -0.0337965190410614, -0.06591566652059555, -0.00672886474058032, 0.01898258924484253, 0.029140818864107132, 0.02287859097123146, 0.024900561198592186, 0.02797529846429825, -0.012170367874205112, 0.03134657442569733, 0.054646775126457214, 0.06772179156541824, 0.036803700029850006, 0.005407249089330435, 0.06343089789152145, 0.015779780223965645, -0.05035160109400749, -0.0066496930085122585, -0.009932774119079113, 0.0050756786949932575, 0.011677337810397148, -0.002870499389246106, 0.02298106998205185, -0.027732841670513153, -0.019238153472542763, 0.04390533268451691, 0.027345331385731697, -0.0068426961079239845, 0.025260651484131813, 0.0381879098713398, -0.06048905849456787, -0.06053386256098747, 0.0003283629775978625, 0.021799184381961823, 0.025705240666866302, 0.005156965460628271, -0.04237576201558113, -0.03281931206583977, 0.01783318817615509, 0.03277503326535225, -0.03882738947868347, -0.009288165718317032, 0.035675227642059326, 0.033575061708688736, -0.032253921031951904, 0.01290973275899887, 0.015982598066329956, -0.012433064170181751, 0.011699257418513298, -0.029896186664700508, 0.057863179594278336, -0.016096636652946472, 0.05378406122326851, 0.016636554151773453, 0.00555749237537384, 0.010219999589025974, 0.022406037896871567, 0.016334932297468185, -0.04042131081223488, -0.04038971662521362, -0.00578267453238368, -0.04357519373297691, -0.026964249089360237, -0.020881248638033867, -0.03593845292925835, -0.0032915680203586817, -0.03167828172445297, -0.007942439056932926, 0.04697639122605324, -0.005223351065069437, 0.027360547333955765, 0.0006175764137879014, 0.0056022172793745995, 0.01763773523271084, 0.00223208824172616, -0.042907923460006714, 0.061235442757606506, -0.006102391052991152, 0.04227830469608307, 0.06513255834579468, 0.01818111166357994, 0.0316329151391983, -0.007865864783525467, 0.05536387860774994, 0.02104123681783676, -0.029420511797070503, 0.08836095035076141, -0.008793379180133343, 0.01399766094982624, 0.020976345986127853, 0.011603975668549538, 0.0035251714289188385, 0.027922889217734337, 0.013609854504466057, -0.031308259814977646, 0.017348356544971466, -0.04274940863251686, 0.026831841096282005, -0.0023902885150164366, 0.0022670705802738667, 0.013386419042944908, -0.04627331718802452, 0.07610737532377243, 0.018913544714450836, -0.011897401884198189, 0.012740198522806168, -0.025390304625034332, 0.008581995032727718, -0.027511902153491974, 0.005854402668774128, -0.035492192953825, -0.004142762161791325, 0.015845706686377525, 0.019032737240195274, 0.0036596099380403757, 0.021731100976467133, -0.01895817555487156, 0.0019169843290001154, 0.04285409301519394, 0.04425925016403198, 0.06805309653282166, -0.01801040768623352, 0.05021021142601967, -0.010953281074762344, -0.06261292845010757, 0.04294826462864876, -0.020311720669269562, -0.01271137036383152, -0.003530303481966257, 0.061984773725271225, -0.0020670832600444555, -0.004342970438301563, 0.013389714062213898, 0.009830217808485031, 0.09182215481996536, -0.007439544890075922, -0.09547093510627747, -0.050996411591768265, 0.020497245714068413, 0.021936681121587753, 0.016187941655516624, -0.04227520897984505, 0.00811388622969389, 0.006750547327101231, 0.020834967494010925, 0.013047335669398308, 0.05406465008854866, -0.001037957496009767, 0.013311898335814476, 0.040259797126054764, -0.03178832679986954, -0.05214490741491318, 0.02976417914032936, -0.000034739525290206075, 0.010798324830830097, -0.0965927243232727, 0.0038076285272836685, 0.013907907530665398, -0.010434222407639027, -0.03447781875729561, 0.009454026818275452, -0.0051574986428022385, -0.02170955203473568, 0.0002980843128170818, 0.015344842337071896, -0.015881232917308807, 0.05720282718539238, -0.002408273983746767, 0.047518204897642136, 0.010008334182202816, -0.012185740284621716, 0.01620328240096569, -0.01444307528436184, 0.056029368191957474, 0.036751508712768555, -0.025477124378085136, 0.002874670783057809, -0.01002327911555767, 0.00009198719635605812, 0.015541968867182732, -0.024989819154143333, -0.007166435942053795, -0.0025772301014512777, 0.0021342034451663494, 0.006006411276757717, 0.028994642198085785, 0.006505823694169521, -0.0008048323797993362, 0.006590656936168671, -0.04854269698262215, -0.09071095287799835, -0.08563847094774246, 0.0039551700465381145, -0.017915571108460426, -0.0542350709438324, -0.0005399803631007671, 0.004918812774121761, 0.012156577780842781, -0.06022810563445091, -0.017568470910191536, -0.031091000884771347, -0.016454150900244713, 0.06261727213859558, -0.04996617138385773, 0.04657125473022461, 0.06910931318998337, 0.07620950788259506, -0.01677544228732586, 0.03214908763766289, -0.05713538080453873, -0.01308263000100851, 0.02525949664413929, -0.03003709577023983, 0.002406124258413911, 0.040155939757823944, -0.028301866725087166, 0.016695242375135422, 0.0027980913873761892, -0.030518431216478348, 0.057658541947603226, -0.05882743373513222, 0.06795262545347214, 0.06653623282909393, 0.01465687807649374, 0.01704498752951622, -0.022473476827144623, -0.01026717945933342, -0.015614376403391361, 0.007458035834133625, -0.00038664849125780165, -0.03777255117893219, 0.0002861657121684402, 0.014292730949819088, -0.018208611756563187, -0.009457450360059738, 0.0061861732974648476, 0.08307274430990219, -0.014576444402337074, 0.018379857763648033, 0.0066137127578258514, 0.023455234244465828, -0.009826156310737133, 0.04745756834745407, 0.036549169570207596, 0.0032846403773874044, 0.005503631196916103, 0.05092667415738106, 0.013973206281661987, 0.0656953677535057, 0.02225358597934246, 0.010372371412813663, 0.04135102778673172, -0.021760007366538048, 0.020597370341420174, -0.025357211008667946, -0.017610818147659302, 0.017373692244291306, -0.017846105620265007, -0.007943248376250267, 0.028259366750717163, 0.002733788685873151, 0.026529110968112946, -0.011385631747543812, -0.01740632764995098, 0.008322024717926979, 0.01720527559518814, -0.012475292198359966, -0.006541287060827017, 0.01596725359559059, -0.03881014138460159, 0.010226350277662277, 0.002649103756994009, -0.054282527416944504, -0.05534430220723152, 0.005955205298960209, 0.03914887085556984, -0.0018643492367118597, 0.047510042786598206, -0.04127148538827896, -0.0274642426520586, -0.03240480646491051, -0.02905709482729435, -0.001982838148251176, -0.007282705511897802, -0.05650848150253296, -0.008710461668670177, -0.0028204508125782013, -0.05798625200986862, 0.03163326159119606, -0.00014657796418759972, 0.002703452715650201, 0.016683636233210564, -0.003687616204842925, -0.015270054340362549, -0.009638258256018162, -0.007861953228712082, -0.0027361884713172913, -0.016557056456804276, 0.0024703387171030045, 0.03417675942182541, -0.005222331266850233, -0.006572146434336901, 0.03283483162522316, -0.057047490030527115, -0.039043109863996506, -0.04121220111846924, -0.04539324343204498, 0.010385759174823761, -0.015475437045097351, 0.015986865386366844, -0.00852636806666851, 0.00044541151146404445, -0.029256464913487434, -0.040308550000190735, -0.04905010387301445, 0.006618199869990349, 0.00003613835360738449, 0.03642253950238228, 0.0009725328418426216, -0.03919190913438797, 0.07048483937978745, 0.020562054589390755, -0.02614601142704487, -0.030181007459759712, 0.0017268471419811249, -0.04851969704031944, -0.03969946131110191, 0.0392189659178257, 0.06284373253583908, -0.022849256172776222, 0.013668366707861423, 0.02782989665865898, 0.031965307891368866, 0.05289517715573311, 0.02113978937268257, -0.007519688922911882, -0.013536972925066948, 0.019076216965913773, -0.005637061782181263, 0.0637490302324295, 0.01889694482088089, -0.04061920568346977, 0.010907372459769249, -0.02017519250512123, 0.03726976737380028, 0.023286862298846245, -0.04562141001224518, 0.021872151643037796, -0.03385455906391144, -0.0062380204908549786, -0.03906170278787613, 0.035932596772909164, -0.011224117130041122, -0.0021758107468485832, 0.01325689535588026, -0.015190859325230122, -0.0034816947299987078, -0.02283972129225731, -0.0049163587391376495, 0.014348732307553291, 0.049089621752500534, -0.05682000145316124, -0.004714134614914656, -0.018333451822400093, -0.04560820758342743, 0.016384446993470192, -0.032403115183115005, -0.0593804270029068, 0.047529492527246475, 0.048131827265024185, 0.015418577007949352, -0.001311844913288951, -0.03496405854821205, -0.007114745210856199, -0.050243936479091644, 0.006310030352324247, -0.01432823296636343, 0.04725813493132591, 0.0065310923382639885, 0.04142279177904129, 0.043136436492204666, -0.01237024087458849, 0.013678857125341892, -0.03429718315601349, -0.027839209884405136, 0.05031827092170715, -0.009615612216293812, -0.03181026503443718, -0.0021790412720292807, -0.03297443687915802, 0.038789570331573486, -0.029365457594394684, 0.027293693274259567, 0.003152213292196393, 0.047289248555898666, -0.01923087239265442, 0.002379324520006776, -0.006587178912013769, -0.0032137564849108458, -0.011777578853070736, 0.01973876729607582, 0.018269868567585945, 0.0062286220490932465, -0.00023749505635350943, 0.02804342284798622, -0.0034254733473062515, -0.010758109390735626, -0.0063493684865534306, -0.01639324426651001, 0.024954630061984062, 0.03574451059103012, 0.03510499745607376, 0.029429534450173378, -0.0404684878885746, 0.033386193215847015, 0.03195944428443909, 0.05357484146952629, 0.03765919804573059, 0.0019287598552182317, -0.001961956499144435, -0.014677606523036957, -0.023591535165905952, 0.006894485559314489, 0.04614611342549324, 0.01012874674052, -0.015233563259243965, 0.0208197683095932, 0.02354854717850685, -0.060640785843133926, 0.026480577886104584, 0.0634942576289177, 0.0152506148442626, 0.03669107332825661, -0.05069828778505325, -0.026645995676517487, -0.058930739760398865, 0.016684379428625107, 0.05149310827255249, 0.0007979878573678434, 0.0023164371959865093, 0.005582267418503761, 0.020327752456068993, -0.023052096366882324, -0.04596232995390892, -0.024167468771338463, 0.0056412918493151665, 0.03779449686408043, 0.00856006145477295, -0.0457291416823864, 0.049371421337127686, 0.031501609832048416, 0.010117904283106327, 0.03383798524737358, 0.029296686872839928, -0.12084027379751205, -0.012865095399320126, 0.04087970405817032, 0.011998800560832024, -0.01820499077439308, -0.01643921621143818, -0.04454171657562256, 0.0428650788962841, 0.018911685794591904, -0.0363127663731575, 0.012021621689200401, -0.040761277079582214, -0.004227336961776018, -0.03675951063632965, 0.009443599730730057, -0.030846893787384033, 0.029372207820415497, -0.0049759759567677975, 0.024967698380351067, 0.020415280014276505, -0.01695934124290943, -0.044245507568120956, -0.03627908229827881, 0.017091723158955574, 0.027981989085674286, -0.02534465491771698, 0.003451088210567832, 0.02878206968307495, 0.0363907590508461, -0.016807764768600464, -0.03775447607040405, 0.016919774934649467, -0.00033568390063010156, 0.027677735313773155, 0.0391157865524292, -0.010023161768913269, -0.015958573669195175, 0.023409908637404442, 0.002442840486764908, -0.02618967555463314, -0.03006034344434738, -0.005012867972254753, 0.004982502665370703, 0.026395438238978386, 0.02422371506690979, 0.05956157296895981, -0.008274072781205177, 0.011251531541347504, 0.005734369158744812, -0.013307658955454826, 0.01953311823308468, -0.04814543575048447, -0.008421052247285843, -0.042971380054950714, -0.03784306347370148, 0.00450151227414608, 0.03406997397542, -0.0026265722699463367, 0.005334112793207169, -0.0497506707906723, 0.006455679424107075, -0.0038410143461078405, 0.009175609797239304, 0.0148013886064291, -0.014798304997384548, -0.015158937312662601, -0.01247332151979208, 0.0036618183366954327, -0.0216600950807333, 0.027410438284277916, -0.01870729960501194, 0.016961487010121346, -0.007767561823129654, 0.003535972209647298, 0.033894769847393036, -0.021907908841967583, -0.05277397856116295, 0.0357249453663826, -0.03467210754752159, 0.01867729052901268, -0.028386570513248444, 0.024016188457608223, 0.021895425394177437, 0.001314690918661654, -0.003340312745422125, -0.0029234536923468113, -0.0026052144821733236, 0.0075577134266495705, -0.034910205751657486, 0.06744790822267532, 0.016285941004753113, -0.010388204827904701, -0.07788436859846115, -0.06189610809087753, 0.02210189215838909, 0.011574340984225273, -0.039977651089429855, -0.018504025414586067, -0.005885445978492498, -0.026580940932035446, 0.009022049605846405, -0.011046839877963066, 0.04335987940430641, 0.009022659622132778, -0.01414885651320219, 0.011879952624440193, -0.009371031075716019, 0.08884529024362564, -0.01296049915254116, -0.023638669401407242, -0.0025054223369807005, -0.010716655291616917, -0.03142126277089119, -0.03323495388031006, 0.00945412740111351, -0.034987665712833405, -0.006308069918304682, -0.04997491091489792, 0.016374723985791206, 0.028241032734513283, -0.0372798778116703, -0.01270660012960434, -0.003919094800949097, -0.010063506662845612, 0.0141878891736269, -0.046535369008779526, 0.009845859371125698, -0.027134181931614876, 0.016197549179196358, -0.016832923516631126, -0.0035800188779830933, 0.007429747376590967, -0.010619631968438625, 0.03453473001718521, 0.02582261525094509, -0.02066192775964737, 0.04577946662902832, 0.06631932407617569, -0.02189936675131321, 0.015133370645344257, -0.02635267935693264, -0.04261317849159241, 0.008919858373701572, 0.004984202794730663, -0.05566692352294922, 0.004634413402527571, 0.004075332544744015, -0.03685799986124039, 0.020457254722714424, -0.008564733900129795, -0.00833551399409771, 0.05082876607775688, -0.011769035831093788, 0.08268940448760986, 0.07414901256561279, 0.005896472372114658, 0.006180092692375183, -0.04468388855457306, -0.04448932781815529, 0.023783564567565918, 0.02416028454899788, 0.021006453782320023, 0.017321741208434105, -0.0026192867662757635, 0.050110287964344025, 0.0029001201037317514, 0.012551886960864067, 0.02196172997355461, 0.03261953219771385, 0.0025264322757720947, 0.023783529177308083, -0.0020223644096404314, -0.008078607730567455, 0.02197784185409546, -0.012547221966087818, 0.01749280095100403, -0.04584312438964844, 0.039850864559412, 0.032415375113487244, 0.024419894441962242, -0.008652238175272942, -0.0620279461145401, -0.002693627495318651, -0.07725170254707336, -0.010435707867145538, 0.011493985541164875, -0.012652200646698475, 0.058699797838926315, 0.03370434790849686, 0.010179218836128712, 0.01584787294268608, 0.022167420014739037, 0.007534912787377834, -0.021715005859732628, -0.042021654546260834, -0.02795061655342579, -0.03044085018336773, -0.01012188009917736, 0.0011171606602147222, -0.018293458968400955, 0.0000713946355972439, -0.06634422391653061, 0.008504150435328484, 0.014001200906932354, 0.00859659444540739, -0.026195116341114044, 0.07699226588010788, 0.04713677614927292, 0.05961146205663681, 0.02665138989686966, -0.00040898832958191633, 0.10140484571456909, 0.036651670932769775, 0.02110818214714527, -0.06585156917572021, 0.01010109018534422, 0.00017929263412952423, -0.012739866971969604, -0.042510781437158585, -0.001333300257101655, 0.0008367642294615507, 0.022420549765229225, 0.06633666157722473, 0.024717921391129494, 0.004135659895837307, -0.020146088674664497, 0.04897024855017662, -0.02447929047048092, -0.022735072299838066, 0.004648809786885977, 0.01571749709546566, -0.026279840618371964, -0.005175458267331123, -0.05208934471011162, 0.03171505779027939, -0.028718918561935425, 0.006004897877573967, -0.015503175556659698, -0.025639185681939125, -0.014030875638127327, 0.026845797896385193, -0.028071196749806404, 0.029609497636556625, 0.04527983441948891, -0.023886969313025475, -0.05548960343003273, -0.03702237829566002, -0.012357737869024277, -0.021163595840334892, -0.003467896953225136, 0.03627530112862587, -0.0040570516139268875, -0.013343535363674164, -0.0025854979176074266, 0.028588905930519104, -0.047959595918655396, 0.023444948717951775, -0.011077274568378925, 0.05429461970925331, 0.002152353757992387, -0.018346883356571198, -0.028180288150906563, -0.014107808470726013, -0.03596282750368118, -0.020302100107073784, 0.010208134539425373, 0.005217194091528654, 0.020940551534295082, -0.022599300369620323, -0.013217075727880001, -0.07249362766742706, -0.006548259407281876, -0.027790892869234085, 0.04917486011981964, 0.04175886511802673, -0.004583606030791998, 0.009441258385777473, -0.0316583551466465, 0.03304966911673546, -0.05497611686587334, -0.017847739160060883, 0.0026031588204205036, 0.004384875297546387, -0.04007183015346527, 0.009137305431067944, 0.031050270423293114, -0.012215999886393547, -0.003900382202118635, 0.015232658945024014, -0.040185607969760895, 0.015594006516039371, -0.006245085038244724, 0.00730356527492404, -0.0073569598607718945, -0.021023452281951904, -0.03275662288069725, -0.013625888153910637, 0.014375242404639721, 0.039037834852933884, -0.00028694121283479035, 0.008427218534052372, 0.027796365320682526, 0.052706070244312286, 0.018465567380189896, -0.04219380393624306, -0.05067262798547745, -0.0017847431590780616, -0.019759787246584892, -0.013063971884548664, -0.01769011840224266, 0.05199025198817253, 0.061022352427244186, -0.012585515156388283, -0.0021910122595727444, 0.0043998355977237225, -0.030563822016119957, 0.017715491354465485, -0.008826935663819313, -0.061309847980737686, -0.0032689836807549, 0.010848809033632278, 0.0005247274530120194, -0.034279949963092804, -0.05019835755228996, -0.026527971029281616, -0.014496673829853535, 0.041883498430252075, -0.01400410570204258, 0.001671906909905374, 0.014355093240737915, -0.0219255480915308, 0.04402223229408264, -0.032957371324300766, 0.012953663244843483, -0.051773153245449066, -0.025738094002008438, 0.00617334945127368, 0.009960430674254894, -0.0055598849430680275, -0.01973005011677742, -0.013189214281737804, 0.00756427738815546, 0.04030798003077507, 0.00432980852201581, -0.005115102510899305, 0.027024395763874054, 0.014802735298871994, 0.0029986759182065725, 0.03449195250868797, -0.02199457958340645, -0.01232813484966755, 0.08359169214963913, -0.04115128889679909, -0.0009753245394676924, 0.02601913921535015, 0.036587584763765335, 0.0384930782020092, -0.006969784386456013, -0.0003621549694798887, -0.006921176798641682, 0.04059804603457451, -0.08067057281732559, -0.0033867915626615286, -0.038670577108860016, -0.02980905771255493, 0.02624506503343582, -0.0040414282120764256, 0.0017486256547272205, 0.01885152794420719, -0.01617959886789322, 0.012371707707643509, 0.02578643709421158, -0.027629513293504715, -0.010954316705465317, -0.03355834260582924, 0.028564956039190292, 0.03641917183995247, 0.0131426602602005, -0.006967989262193441, 0.022879399359226227, 0.05487439036369324, -0.014395884238183498, 0.01994379423558712, -0.019037559628486633, -0.013312233611941338, -0.09005162864923477, 0.008351383730769157, 0.014386361464858055, -0.023615136742591858, 0.049446891993284225, -0.04973937198519707, -0.019280152395367622, -0.0016080635832622647, -0.015235894359648228, 0.030918950214982033, -0.011306429281830788, -0.06334570050239563, -0.03304572403430939, -0.002412080764770508, 0.020474368706345558, 0.032845690846443176, 0.01661980338394642, 0.035902123898267746, 0.026834040880203247, 0.017078211531043053, 0.03552577272057533, -0.017853716388344765, -0.010322712361812592, 0.03660159185528755, 0.012073537334799767, -0.048317454755306244, 0.02368246018886566, -0.023585351184010506, -0.02842637710273266, 0.049247730523347855, -0.008781091310083866, 0.046556249260902405, 0.030582118779420853, 0.01508701778948307, -0.01184918824583292, 0.02210533432662487, 0.07044468075037003, -0.0025395103730261326, -0.004546841140836477, 0.015566029585897923, 0.03317522630095482, 0.03506872430443764, 0.0015613028081133962, -0.005814018659293652, 0.037507716566324234, -0.025241060182452202, -0.008826901204884052, 0.02389623410999775, -0.007168293464928865, -0.02204306796193123, -0.0007425279472954571, -0.007233556360006332, 0.004862039349973202, -0.006415665149688721, 0.025896834209561348, -0.005403342191129923, 0.021587712690234184, 0.06340485066175461, 0.04122341051697731, -0.03647582232952118, 0.028471408411860466, -0.012960413470864296, -0.030639121308922768, 0.013217713683843613, 0.02083723247051239, -0.012090018019080162, -0.04860258847475052, 0.007148155942559242, -0.007253671996295452, -0.005037637427449226, -0.03332303836941719, -0.004281975794583559, -0.027123065665364265, 0.04653460532426834, 0.014801272191107273, 0.000864100584294647, 0.022448666393756866, -0.015157699584960938, 0.005645903293043375, -0.06745326519012451, 0.03959786519408226, 0.01049261074513197, 0.0053741405718028545, -0.0363037995994091, -0.021098481491208076, -0.06789110600948334, -0.027308396995067596, 0.05135047808289528, 0.04066669940948486, 0.03097478300333023, -0.009755592793226242, 0.0009048026404343545, -0.01236140076071024, -0.07440877705812454, 0.034060172736644745, -0.04737156629562378, -0.06534796208143234, 0.008297714404761791, 0.009808644652366638, 0.0185682512819767, -0.008542010560631752, 0.012916521169245243, 0.00500054657459259, 0.04208855330944061, 0.023766012862324715, -0.0030884109437465668, 0.01985321380198002, 0.011403568089008331, -0.008027270436286926, 0.040411822497844696, -0.00213829823769629, 0.0021598138846457005, 0.007720326539129019, 0.02259071171283722, -0.0540337972342968, 0.033485766500234604, -0.038875170052051544, 0.0025660679675638676, 0.012464996427297592, 0.012685761786997318, -0.025090022012591362, -0.060181330889463425, -0.014552073553204536, 0.013561783358454704, -0.009380626492202282, 0.015756435692310333, 0.022262439131736755, 0.037202756851911545, 0.03764203563332558, -0.060247305780649185, 0.00045467863674275577, -0.02677343226969242, -0.031778521835803986, 0.0011649620719254017, -0.008414268493652344, 0.02500414103269577, -0.006466335617005825, 0.010406585410237312, 0.0226144976913929, -0.02452431619167328, -0.000002094478759318008, -0.045433223247528076, 0.038240946829319, -0.008737817406654358, -0.04780924320220947, 0.006305280141532421, -0.005788790062069893, 0.015010738745331764, 0.026448750868439674, 0.01710938662290573, 0.07505172491073608, -0.05286840721964836, 0.02878965064883232, -0.027738943696022034, -0.016108648851513863, -0.037384264171123505, -0.009984439238905907, 0.021575918421149254, -0.014353741891682148, -0.014546291902661324, 0.023857520893216133, 0.02367676980793476, 0.013228117488324642, 0.01699615642428398, 0.002881668508052826, 0.015910644084215164, -0.02329867333173752, -0.034515634179115295, -0.028274081647396088, 0.0035836377646774054, -0.01736851967871189, 0.0050654541701078415, 0.007898322306573391, 0.022846629843115807, 0.012931790202856064, 0.019306892529129982, -0.02217980846762657, 0.02174597606062889, 0.0065259141847491264, -0.08521462976932526, -0.02159457467496395, -0.08680223673582077, -0.022379912436008453, 0.004204990342259407, -0.04385438933968544 ]
<p>I currently have a gradient boosting model that uses the <code>gbm</code> package in R that classifies observations at the end of a year. Daily behaviors are logged for each observation (with most of them zero). The model is built on observations which have a year's worth of complete data and performs well out of sample. </p> <p>For illustrative purposes, assume the complete data look like this:</p> <pre><code>id day1 day2 day3 day4 day5, ..., day365 1 1 1 2 0 0, ..., 0 2 3 0 1 0 0, ..., 0 3 1 1 2 0 0, ..., 0 4 1 0 0 0 0, ..., 1 </code></pre> <p>However, I want to predict the probability of each class for new individuals who have not yet been in the sampling frame for a year. Thus, all of the days past the present day will be NA. This precludes the use of many algorithms, but treating them as 0s also implies having more information than I actually have.</p> <p>What is the best way to treat the unobserved, but observable missing data when making predictions? I will not be re-estimating the model on a daily basis but rather using the model fit from the existing training set.</p>
74,375
[ -0.0032800633925944567, -0.026028094813227654, -0.0008090464398264885, 0.016442567110061646, 0.014726951718330383, 0.003502609906718135, -0.006758664734661579, -0.01873575709760189, 0.03638840839266777, 0.0128472950309515, 0.01761898212134838, 0.05074942484498024, 0.005731121636927128, 0.0321895070374012, 0.015123819001019001, 0.0010070757707580924, -0.017160942777991295, -0.04524851590394974, 0.02018294669687748, 0.0070242793299257755, -0.03037017583847046, 0.021863829344511032, 0.02516256272792816, -0.026118416339159012, -0.035026539117097855, 0.021253783255815506, 0.01687539555132389, -0.019438492134213448, -0.005138352047652006, 0.041763000190258026, -0.06635846942663193, -0.0390978641808033, -0.027207644656300545, 0.06263884902000427, 0.0006558934110216796, 0.017560215666890144, -0.024717507883906364, -0.046226948499679565, -0.009199793450534344, 0.018493136391043663, -0.02428077906370163, -0.0207833219319582, 0.0004807140212506056, 0.05799393728375435, 0.007843011990189552, 0.015181371942162514, -0.013358767144382, 0.014141217805445194, 0.04800903797149658, -0.009840089827775955, 0.048085395246744156, -0.02737625688314438, 0.02759852632880211, 0.012137679383158684, -0.018343832343816757, -0.03104284405708313, 0.043504491448402405, 0.06384671479463577, 0.00045808785944245756, -0.026840301230549812, -0.0027029942721128464, -0.05456862598657608, 0.01035278756171465, -0.045281752943992615, 0.013311554677784443, 0.03112521395087242, -0.020936893299221992, -0.04309926927089691, 0.039053674787282944, -0.049357105046510696, 0.01750408485531807, 0.015909070149064064, 0.0006792095373384655, -0.006287507247179747, 0.025657691061496735, -0.022156795486807823, -0.005468225572258234, 0.027734115719795227, 0.054631855338811874, 0.016291942447423935, -0.030747156590223312, 0.011782114394009113, 0.043269116431474686, 0.03290362283587456, 0.02545339986681938, -0.0339164212346077, 0.05718333274126053, -0.017849832773208618, 0.026572970673441887, 0.025472087785601616, -0.030247772112488747, 0.0186814796179533, 0.03440655767917633, 0.016088150441646576, -0.044389061629772186, 0.049888234585523605, 0.0024049505591392517, 0.01862911507487297, 0.009697743691504002, 0.007816944271326065, -0.017347518354654312, -0.04475470632314682, 0.006176691502332687, 0.07000590115785599, -0.0593411922454834, -0.030341489240527153, -0.018185894936323166, -0.041663337498903275, 0.006445738021284342, -0.022366683930158615, -0.013284954242408276, 0.020844943821430206, 0.017986483871936798, -0.04795575514435768, 0.019972611218690872, -0.04760679975152016, -0.026502512395381927, -0.030437244102358818, 0.01712931878864765, 0.06200622767210007, 0.04612196981906891, -0.041483815759420395, 0.03562707081437111, -0.04459965229034424, -0.05520891770720482, 0.017776774242520332, 0.0016927644610404968, -0.034025080502033234, -0.03686203435063362, 0.02800150029361248, -0.003048957558348775, -0.03217632696032524, 0.04981204867362976, -0.04068402200937271, 0.03547690063714981, -0.00853617675602436, -0.0642579197883606, -0.02736816555261612, 0.02970040962100029, -0.05006135255098343, 0.02401483990252018, -0.06388172507286072, -0.01973010040819645, 0.009676344692707062, 0.047631312161684036, 0.00023239280562847853, 0.027745723724365234, -0.00017540824774187058, 0.020601779222488403, 0.024531610310077667, -0.009825348854064941, 0.014222849160432816, -0.05490490421652794, -0.0031361207365989685, -0.0673070102930069, -0.07196127623319626, 0.05056163668632507, 0.017393527552485466, -0.002405789913609624, -0.02409975416958332, 0.049133457243442535, 0.003461980726569891, 0.000601467676460743, -0.01645856909453869, 0.015529720112681389, -0.03809687867760658, 0.07974821329116821, 0.03172045946121216, 0.06556583940982819, 0.05392313003540039, -0.01005579810589552, 0.01433865912258625, 0.036325905472040176, 0.052461761981248856, 0.06437771022319794, 0.0033070154022425413, 0.0048010023310780525, -0.04919229820370674, 0.015218091197311878, 0.0013731601648032665, -0.01390752848237753, -0.039260782301425934, -0.022779906168580055, -0.023277556523680687, 0.00818529911339283, 0.012204152531921864, 0.014711041003465652, -0.018625915050506592, 0.03738729655742645, -0.044001851230859756, -0.055501438677310944, -0.09329106658697128, 0.03293685242533684, 0.02621535025537014, 0.0085093779489398, 0.01545384805649519, -0.016336390748620033, 0.019765187054872513, 0.013394190929830074, -0.004122742917388678, -0.011580769903957844, -0.019137484952807426, -0.0020183217711746693, -0.08722472190856934, -0.03260579705238342, 0.039470985531806946, 0.0508456714451313, -0.005225528497248888, 0.09131421148777008, -0.035144414752721786, -0.041175663471221924, 0.005493250209838152, -0.03168090432882309, 0.03737816959619522, -0.04115566983819008, 0.0009088078513741493, 0.0324971079826355, -0.010511566884815693, -0.009241652674973011, 0.01452996488660574, -0.03441432863473892, 0.019944310188293457, 0.06886880844831467, -0.015788376331329346, 0.0005592471570707858, -0.025554899126291275, 0.013914920389652252, 0.02714669145643711, -0.041092801839113235, 0.009325467050075531, -0.05550450086593628, 0.0049635739997029305, 0.028343049809336662, -0.015236190520226955, 0.003177426988258958, 0.035159654915332794, 0.050914935767650604, 0.01937713660299778, 0.005334936548024416, 0.013450547121465206, -0.02041476033627987, -0.0016510538989678025, 0.03790183365345001, 0.010025658644735813, 0.026728687807917595, -0.007337471935898066, 0.029575815424323082, -0.011468915268778801, 0.004274814855307341, 0.017423082143068314, -0.014593174681067467, 0.03500434756278992, 0.024188857525587082, 0.0031077908352017403, -0.05773109942674637, -0.041179411113262177, 0.038614217191934586, 0.004198828712105751, -0.010267741046845913, 0.06602662801742554, 0.002127951942384243, -0.020485196262598038, 0.012993370182812214, -0.032029010355472565, -0.0002307695831404999, 0.039869360625743866, -0.030547359958291054, 0.015667220577597618, 0.014913161285221577, -0.06356342881917953, 0.03240904584527016, -0.012970720417797565, -0.034102536737918854, -0.07023968547582626, 0.03718740865588188, 0.04027768597006798, 0.032306376844644547, 0.05326062813401222, -0.04466508701443672, -0.018470996990799904, 0.015376230701804161, 0.015104948543012142, 0.050575967878103256, 0.05983428657054901, -0.06693748384714127, 0.022181469947099686, -0.03250977396965027, -0.037490539252758026, 0.01730162464082241, 0.00038977194344624877, -0.03575998172163963, 0.02380916103720665, -0.023724809288978577, -0.0182314645498991, -0.015196233056485653, 0.0012009761994704604, -0.020698077976703644, -0.015190225094556808, -0.0285368412733078, 0.04703602194786072, 0.015977708622813225, -0.04403966665267944, -0.03850942105054855, -0.06467795372009277, -0.02119959518313408, -0.000042965675675077364, -0.012251708656549454, 0.024173717945814133, -0.01337813027203083, 0.023827603086829185, 0.03281226381659508, 0.023568859323859215, 0.018602197989821434, -0.07109449058771133, -0.06105709820985794, 0.008161617442965508, 0.005740939639508724, -0.02538209594786167, 0.02796015329658985, 0.041591133922338486, 0.08067598938941956, 0.03294586390256882, -0.01873522251844406, -0.012317107990384102, -0.02532374858856201, -0.0062959762290120125, -0.019298553466796875, 0.015460941009223461, -0.001987660303711891, 0.04900209233164787, -0.007583201862871647, -0.03526400774717331, -0.016482427716255188, 0.05791435390710831, 0.046969473361968994, 0.0032108775340020657, 0.029499970376491547, -0.0059555210173130035, -0.005488593131303787, 0.002706041792407632, 0.01803327538073063, -0.021276475861668587, 0.016507664695382118, -0.042854875326156616, -0.014164908789098263, 0.008847050368785858, -0.04108046740293503, 0.0394926518201828, -0.00823042169213295, 0.040248263627290726, 0.013716223649680614, 0.03044818714261055, -0.006596790626645088, -0.06212542578577995, -0.015149440616369247, 0.004107971675693989, 0.0351484939455986, -0.03128155320882797, -0.006174251437187195, 0.04834574833512306, 0.0022794026881456375, 0.0009116122964769602, -0.009513552300632, -0.03860114514827728, 0.005731707438826561, 0.02842896804213524, -0.02691657282412052, -0.01596185564994812, 0.012189731001853943, 0.0578375905752182, 0.01827051304280758, -0.0008005601121112704, -0.008829526603221893, 0.006559934467077255, -0.04685717076063156, 0.024556035175919533, -0.015053963288664818, 0.05332368612289429, 0.005979219917207956, 0.0016752852825447917, 0.004949183668941259, 0.017767347395420074, 0.01293427124619484, 0.04334613308310509, -0.07402314245700836, 0.049159109592437744, 0.023298265412449837, 0.0008106649038381875, -0.002030924428254366, -0.008508830331265926, 0.049252185970544815, 0.0003560338809620589, -0.0091584213078022, -0.022812463343143463, 0.02543356828391552, -0.04362700879573822, -0.010867608711123466, -0.020245401188731194, -0.013203466311097145, -0.014664716087281704, -0.005214812699705362, -0.0015142010524868965, 0.011568297632038593, 0.023241037502884865, 0.024145890027284622, 0.034296877682209015, -0.02366575412452221, -0.0006980831967666745, 0.01839844137430191, -0.01691087894141674, 0.04859568923711777, 0.04202306643128395, 0.046900343149900436, -0.06366133689880371, -0.0030604125931859016, 0.03333020582795143, 0.0345371849834919, 0.02037149667739868, -0.0023970999754965305, -0.0029414210002869368, -0.03274144232273102, -0.0058792950585484505, 0.029147157445549965, 0.015564298257231712, 0.0026974938809871674, -0.00044080367661081254, 0.06462504714727402, 0.039750080555677414, -0.045462120324373245, -0.022948667407035828, 0.0961570292711258, 0.023784777149558067, -0.028222009539604187, -0.043253302574157715, 0.003015289781615138, 0.005105084273964167, 0.0329805389046669, 0.023908620700240135, -0.0009257230558432639, 0.012399839237332344, -0.029789356514811516, -0.008883161470293999, -0.000042946823668899015, -0.00652287807315588, -0.016605479642748833, 0.022566072642803192, 0.07020726054906845, 0.007706487085670233, -0.0027036077808588743, 0.001578782917931676, 0.07707392424345016, 0.04051787033677101, 0.03365299850702286, 0.005304539110511541, -0.08886987715959549, -0.004311723168939352, 0.06842005252838135, 0.05067518725991249, -0.026671484112739563, 0.0006756827933713794, -0.054480258375406265, -0.01848580874502659, 0.016816388815641403, 0.00024816146469675004, -0.012489333748817444, 0.005577413365244865, -0.0011153363157063723, 0.008606353774666786, -0.021379545331001282, -0.04175669699907303, 0.02316989004611969, -0.051098503172397614, 0.057071469724178314, -0.009416150860488415, -0.0314822643995285, -0.034248288720846176, 0.03695205599069595, -0.007450460456311703, 0.0941869392991066, -0.03559363633394241, -0.02670983038842678, 0.04764242470264435, 0.01762925460934639, 0.00033595901913940907, -0.040928225964307785, 0.019014306366443634, 0.009133024141192436, -0.031923405826091766, 0.024448582902550697, -0.019453026354312897, -0.05285027623176575, -0.0007602701080031693, 0.019287366420030594, -0.04532421752810478, -0.0391816720366478, -0.04288933053612709, -0.017458846792578697, -0.04739078879356384, -0.003779376856982708, 0.03096603974699974, 0.027702627703547478, 0.02375652641057968, 0.0011916251387447119, -0.05032394081354141, -0.003701220266520977, 0.007838222198188305, -0.02091255597770214, -0.024607082828879356, -0.028912942856550217, 0.001018783776089549, 0.0483667366206646, 0.03086136281490326, 0.03486425429582596, 0.014711515977978706, -0.05636444315314293, 0.0018906367477029562, 0.015154222026467323, -0.03430682793259621, -0.01779843680560589, -0.01898903213441372, 0.009258623234927654, -0.007261777296662331, 0.02852131612598896, -0.010315879248082638, -0.03267355635762215, 0.015073249116539955, 0.013724424876272678, -0.03735671192407608, 0.04039676859974861, -0.026901355013251305, 0.004288694355636835, 0.018220555037260056, -0.014684412628412247, -0.015826495364308357, 0.009021854028105736, 0.057466261088848114, -0.0015439486596733332, -0.031441591680049896, -0.01678716018795967, -0.0010589942103251815, -0.005829652305692434, 0.038171567022800446, -0.02275305613875389, 0.023732710629701614, 0.012030936777591705, -0.00835893303155899, -0.05509064719080925, -0.05571863055229187, 0.015121468342840672, -0.00045173545368015766, -0.03573547303676605, -0.03583736717700958, -0.001649611396715045, -0.009416740387678146, 0.004654071293771267, -0.018665006384253502, 0.05217950418591499, -0.02327876165509224, -0.018218932673335075, -0.009679857641458511, 0.008175475522875786, 0.045361828058958054, 0.01199621707201004, -0.0013631375040858984, 0.037191037088632584, -0.019992295652627945, -0.0468527153134346, 0.013438841328024864, 0.0020293944980949163, -0.023310406133532524, -0.012499868869781494, -0.012028583325445652, 0.00583980418741703, 0.05678023397922516, -0.0219222754240036, -0.017135433852672577, 0.01925564743578434, -0.018180208280682564, 0.0096063744276762, -0.024157727137207985, 0.019226795062422752, 0.013703430071473122, -0.02545054256916046, -0.0036502175498753786, 0.014583510346710682, 0.022241367027163506, -0.01458237785845995, 0.02130011096596718, -0.011021384969353676, 0.001627135556191206, 0.01867196336388588, 0.01958850957453251, -0.02067137137055397, -0.018422573804855347, 0.027642298489809036, -0.03923604264855385, 0.05517381802201271, 0.02222234569489956, 0.041786078363657, 0.016039466485381126, 0.0009418109548278153, -0.0474943071603775, -0.0130764776840806, -0.02376922219991684, -0.028244787827134132, 0.04357294365763664, -0.0044868383556604385, 0.029685134068131447, 0.012608050368726254, 0.03935673460364342, 0.006670318078249693, -0.016249390318989754, 0.011153320781886578, -0.0029505775310099125, 0.005624404642730951, 0.018328499048948288, -0.023703807964920998, -0.023264054208993912, 0.024021822959184647, -0.02068421244621277, 0.01739352010190487, 0.0629950612783432, 0.010682005435228348, 0.02889392338693142, 0.03273086994886398, -0.021822409704327583, -0.03793288767337799, 0.01655656285583973, -0.02118968963623047, -0.013214782811701298, 0.008986279368400574, -0.0383879728615284, 0.05738294869661331, 0.007372051943093538, 0.02103031426668167, -0.015704812481999397, -0.044935163110494614, -0.06163320690393448, 0.007745213340967894, 0.05358955264091492, -0.006070858333259821, 0.018514979630708694, 0.005611027590930462, 0.026473499834537506, 0.006760267075151205, 0.041248809546232224, -0.036069124937057495, -0.09810058772563934, -0.04744841530919075, -0.018548205494880676, -0.048613011837005615, 0.01933753490447998, 0.007552763447165489, 0.006568696815520525, -0.0032399408519268036, 0.0084041403606534, 0.010580792091786861, 0.005698410328477621, 0.08418238908052444, 0.00401285057887435, 0.042858585715293884, 0.016091035678982735, -0.015652142465114594, -0.011791594326496124, -0.027145950123667717, 0.15075956284999847, 0.08618251234292984, 0.055366382002830505, -0.07289469987154007, -0.02293943613767624, 0.012400771491229534, -0.022087983787059784, -0.0054279412142932415, 0.0028560336213558912, -0.0035597195383161306, -0.02138633467257023, 0.013351165689527988, 0.010401871986687183, -0.01653033122420311, -0.009588821791112423, 0.03144636005163193, -0.02930396981537342, -0.004992765374481678, 0.007512909360229969, 0.018085902556777, 0.027860496193170547, -0.0362880602478981, -0.04818892106413841, 0.004633734934031963, 0.052742160856723785, -0.014839909970760345, 0.005829759407788515, 0.007314931135624647, -0.03376782685518265, -0.004837361164391041, -0.03301949054002762, 0.00561006972566247, 0.024700544774532318, 0.05539916828274727, 0.037199683487415314, 0.0006008914206176996, 0.005200407933443785, -0.02152175083756447, 0.015206988900899887, 0.01204522605985403, -0.0016216662479564548, -0.02097690850496292, 0.019423957914114, -0.012537846341729164, -0.03703779727220535, -0.04141996428370476, -0.024127384647727013, 0.05836998671293259, -0.018564965575933456, -0.011050231754779816, 0.009157257154583931, -0.00159147207159549, 0.0004467859398573637, -0.05009903758764267, -0.033847253769636154, 0.05234597995877266, 0.05929549038410187, -0.002675288822501898, -0.007720401510596275, 0.005846718791872263, 0.009205816313624382, 0.008622030727565289, 0.03492653742432594, 0.03034058026969433, -0.0015656768810003996, -0.011041296645998955, -0.012754439376294613, 0.051690682768821716, 0.008801905438303947, -0.0038934051990509033, 0.021068139001727104, -0.02789086103439331, -0.03358307108283043, 0.0010183528065681458, 0.01786413975059986, -0.029922692105174065, 0.028614500537514687, -0.029207240790128708, -0.0012686531990766525, 0.0021026725880801678, -0.03892504423856735, -0.0070444331504404545, 0.0004696703399531543, 0.031246410682797432, -0.023423265665769577, 0.025778241455554962, -0.003216453827917576, 0.05245682969689369, 0.015857867896556854, -0.0035428134724497795, -0.006299841683357954, 0.07467659562826157, -0.0013324656756594777, -0.011745844967663288, -0.03334205970168114, -0.023754553869366646, -0.04665762186050415, 0.013568860478699207, -0.010190692730247974, 0.05352680757641792, 0.003697640961036086, 0.008112328127026558, -0.009928212501108646, 0.019217411056160927, 0.01591682992875576, 0.01945202425122261, -0.011599445715546608, -0.05313107371330261, -0.0056518809869885445, -0.0020966825541108847, -0.007105430122464895, -0.04313065856695175, -0.03380337730050087, -0.01836901344358921, -0.014077454805374146, -0.010987167246639729, -0.04005863517522812, -0.03542623296380043, 0.01275562308728695, 0.039288610219955444, 0.008116265758872032, 0.007062699180096388, 0.004292821045964956, -0.026923902332782745, -0.01691090129315853, -0.0005025736754760146, -0.053702544420957565, 0.02423659898340702, 0.015887266024947166, -0.009654630906879902, -0.022983258590102196, 0.04655418172478676, -0.03532838076353073, -0.01480983104556799, -0.0007563642575405538, 0.006920936983078718, -0.033796992152929306, 0.0534232035279274, -0.015490914694964886, -0.027037879452109337, 0.02397187054157257, -0.04484466835856438, -0.04085776209831238, 0.0481133759021759, -0.0013623539125546813, 0.035642486065626144, -0.03900047019124031, -0.042231373488903046, -0.02736145257949829, 0.001116498140618205, -0.05248809605836868, 0.016043134033679962, -0.0408179834485054, 0.04881097376346588, -0.023977642878890038, 0.02674156054854393, -0.0209698136895895, 0.04602488502860069, -0.020863555371761322, 0.013111494481563568, 0.009250957518815994, 0.03122960962355137, -0.0239814855158329, 0.017314430326223373, -0.0037177945487201214, -0.012623216956853867, 0.007164580747485161, 0.017061347141861916, 0.004548182711005211, 0.0658024400472641, -0.024415258318185806, 0.035074230283498764, -0.03055095672607422, 0.021896295249462128, -0.0821143090724945, -0.035920578986406326, 0.021661415696144104, 0.015322798863053322, 0.03680926933884621, -0.07784873992204666, 0.01376764290034771, 0.0031578056514263153, -0.023306643590331078, 0.020752055570483208, 0.02586345374584198, -0.0047629703767597675, -0.01747730001807213, 0.020858215168118477, -0.021164942532777786, -0.022218305617570877, 0.05552651733160019, -0.01931721530854702, 0.02904665283858776, 0.027559926733374596, -0.00522884214296937, -0.047696370631456375, -0.03472983464598656, 0.01315111294388771, 0.019926518201828003, -0.07314440608024597, 0.039173275232315063, -0.024250973016023636, 0.010329973883926868, 0.040602538734674454, -0.04395396634936333, 0.021242447197437286, 0.04070562496781349, 0.0032841337379068136, -0.005733828991651535, 0.060520343482494354, 0.032943256199359894, -0.018537025898694992, 0.0064795129001140594, 0.015291009098291397, 0.007748023606836796, 0.011606807820498943, -0.03616825491189957, 0.030613452196121216, -0.0029469553846865892, -0.027180703356862068, -0.03722260892391205, 0.0023659514263272285, 0.004890515934675932, 0.002705877646803856, -0.003401758149266243, 0.021468281745910645, -0.028943588957190514, -0.03757922723889351, -0.017561765387654305, -0.03678840398788452, 0.025340987369418144, 0.02710133045911789, 0.0578388050198555, -0.027792055159807205, -0.0021560334134846926, -0.0330359973013401, -0.017983969300985336, -0.003827290143817663, -0.012842077761888504, 0.006066317670047283, -0.025354206562042236, -0.026616884395480156, -0.011550764553248882, -0.014651080593466759, -0.006926227360963821, -0.016638698056340218, -0.044833097606897354, 0.03411627188324928, -0.009709660895168781, 0.03279266506433487, 0.02961033210158348, 0.0016892870189622045, -0.012801330536603928, -0.07326558977365494, 0.05865289643406868, 0.01662876456975937, 0.01866784691810608, -0.0022404256742447615, -0.01460806094110012, -0.02961183898150921, 0.0012816399103030562, 0.06204821914434433, -0.007874526083469391, -0.010295205749571323, -0.014409780502319336, 0.027465341612696648, -0.006008891388773918, 0.0008731053676456213, 0.03537493571639061, 0.013057260774075985, -0.010950515978038311, -0.025924554094672203, -0.015440043993294239, 0.001358644338324666, 0.010086163878440857, -0.01813560537993908, 0.011595262214541435, -0.005573440343141556, 0.018980732187628746, -0.020674481987953186, 0.04017563909292221, 0.01143974345177412, -0.008183573372662067, 0.03777181729674339, -0.0018781401449814439, -0.0009804688161239028, 0.0244510006159544, -0.022183112800121307, -0.07491844892501831, 0.033511046320199966, -0.03358300030231476, -0.0469786673784256, 0.017578035593032837, 0.00738439941778779, -0.0004933609161525965, -0.040510956197977066, -0.006527632474899292, 0.0133130494505167, 0.008390302769839764, 0.05155930295586586, 0.02469555474817753, 0.023881036788225174, 0.053565263748168945, -0.014574176631867886, -0.005253600887954235, 0.010073523968458176, 0.04107551649212837, 0.000861428736243397, -0.00269707222469151, -0.02288796566426754, -0.00440169358626008, 0.03392680734395981, 0.0467369519174099, 0.009028181433677673, 0.014438936486840248, 0.0005288004758767784, 0.015401584096252918, -0.03093431517481804, -0.015878776088356972, 0.03593190386891365, 0.027742989361286163, 0.002291579032316804, 0.020377757027745247, -0.003089558333158493, 0.03149719908833504, -0.05596056580543518, -0.00744817266240716, -0.0406956784427166, -0.025687826797366142, 0.0023802537471055984, 0.046346597373485565, -0.022452130913734436, 0.039721522480249405, 0.0166627187281847, 0.028302082791924477, 0.029454855248332024, -0.008583568967878819, 0.0349455326795578, -0.03669613227248192, 0.0118814492598176, 0.006445746403187513, 0.021379435434937477, 0.01416696049273014, -0.03237805515527725, -0.004005596041679382, -0.029661590233445168, -0.016798678785562515, 0.03811027109622955, 0.03201882913708687, -0.054929327219724655, -0.00703088566660881, -0.03527640923857689, 0.020845241844654083, -0.012859581038355827, -0.0003907693026121706, -0.07469567656517029, 0.0022269294131547213, -0.01592235639691353, -0.04247942194342613 ]
<ol> <li><p>What is the difference between quasi-likelihood estimating equations, and GEE?</p> <p>From <a href="http://www.biostat.umn.edu/~xianghua/8452/note/05GEE.pdf" rel="nofollow">a note</a></p> <blockquote> <p>Quasi-score function is for independent, over-dispersed data (Poisson or binomial), while GEE1 is for correlated data.</p> </blockquote> <p>But it seems to me that in the note, their equations both don't take into account the correlation between different responses. So how shall I understand them correctly?</p></li> <li>How is independence estimating equations (IEE) different from the above two?</li> </ol> <p>Thanks!</p>
1,035
[ -0.059254713356494904, -0.01514824852347374, 0.019665127620100975, 0.018540620803833008, 0.013436204753816128, -0.004510938189923763, -0.02627168968319893, 0.016824956983327866, 0.07526998221874237, -0.023607777431607246, 0.04771142452955246, 0.05355660617351532, 0.06718733161687851, -0.025234311819076538, 0.02427625097334385, 0.028759781271219254, -0.010182510130107403, 0.06754763424396515, 0.003164597088471055, 0.01078531239181757, -0.015271764248609543, 0.010201629251241684, 0.010182210244238377, 0.012986916117370129, -0.01791074313223362, 0.060606699436903, 0.04422708973288536, -0.010085118003189564, 0.015856986865401268, 0.056527767330408096, -0.03462032973766327, -0.0012486972846090794, 0.018341753631830215, 0.035117991268634796, 0.005253046751022339, -0.04356304928660393, -0.021670380607247353, -0.0020869974978268147, 0.006395751144737005, 0.022513778880238533, -0.04971204698085785, -0.040788017213344574, -0.0182784590870142, 0.017220664769411087, -0.020199771970510483, 0.019483277574181557, -0.026813311502337456, -0.03436467424035072, 0.03535160422325134, -0.05166536942124367, 0.044481903314590454, -0.010179536417126656, 0.02524472586810589, 0.04180692508816719, -0.007503887638449669, 0.034932833164930344, 0.0556018203496933, 0.03879999369382858, -0.02878524176776409, -0.039610378444194794, 0.011381654068827629, -0.03979947417974472, 0.029798343777656555, -0.01880672387778759, 0.0026069802697747946, 0.04161997511982918, 0.002055473392829299, -0.009437444619834423, 0.041354961693286896, -0.015323379077017307, 0.04553190618753433, 0.04438505694270134, 0.046611230820417404, 0.015012649819254875, 0.024084536358714104, -0.02115562930703163, 0.01537178736180067, 0.019077321514487267, 0.052914440631866455, 0.05887548252940178, -0.0034053658600896597, -0.008034596219658852, 0.03781687468290329, 0.0010165917919948697, 0.01792534440755844, -0.025060756132006645, 0.0676242932677269, -0.006679960992187262, 0.009702803567051888, 0.022572489455342293, 0.002896042773500085, 0.005221272353082895, 0.04609452560544014, 0.005472827702760696, -0.01347613800317049, 0.03153643384575844, -0.016564469784498215, 0.02356075681746006, 0.007946685887873173, -0.003764908527955413, -0.02131924219429493, -0.06607864052057266, 0.0184312891215086, 0.0411674864590168, -0.018525971099734306, -0.024452343583106995, -0.03746173158288002, 0.023314571008086205, -0.026939159259200096, -0.031554609537124634, 0.025788061320781708, 0.028098631650209427, -0.0030748427379876375, -0.005371060222387314, 0.01911361888051033, 0.0171513594686985, -0.01920461654663086, 0.005047628190368414, 0.06594814360141754, 0.08212392032146454, 0.047299694269895554, -0.056861139833927155, -0.0000404338316002395, -0.006042417138814926, -0.03998173028230667, -0.003909222315996885, 0.03878575563430786, -0.018902577459812164, -0.0139179527759552, 0.04318828880786896, -0.011484751477837563, -0.0025323389563709497, 0.05513285845518112, 0.017808860167860985, 0.0016428375383839011, -0.014314226806163788, -0.11203915625810623, -0.049009568989276886, 0.03453226014971733, 0.0006007504998706281, 0.007575474213808775, -0.06486313790082932, -0.014850355684757233, 0.018097426742315292, 0.048606205731630325, 0.008509941399097443, 0.0445752814412117, -0.035318125039339066, 0.0017306754598394036, -0.002500613685697317, -0.028008311986923218, -0.04141198471188545, -0.044769059866666794, -0.015611988492310047, 0.0036824194248765707, -0.06687084585428238, 0.017719177529215813, -0.00012735446216538548, 0.0007082490483298898, -0.006469658575952053, 0.03213644400238991, 0.04268505051732063, -0.03369508683681488, -0.03404014930129051, 0.027929317206144333, -0.0009574940195307136, 0.05942528322339058, 0.0043929629027843475, 0.002125480445101857, 0.05845163017511368, -0.031755149364471436, 0.028546759858727455, -0.001020208466798067, 0.02618272416293621, -0.00187362777069211, -0.007702144794166088, -0.026162849739193916, -0.043345678597688675, 0.009350002743303776, -0.007975967600941658, -0.044901955872774124, -0.007954138331115246, 0.013976157642900944, -0.021668819710612297, 0.03990485146641731, 0.026100443676114082, 0.008822161704301834, -0.014938443899154663, 0.021847011521458626, -0.013706350699067116, -0.08368861675262451, -0.05527956783771515, 0.009143760427832603, -0.0003801748971454799, 0.0003975073341280222, 0.01615288108587265, 0.02257899008691311, 0.009390696883201599, -0.006330700591206551, -0.007619782816618681, -0.010056840255856514, 0.04425988346338272, 0.004177722614258528, -0.020002756267786026, 0.01704411953687668, 0.033047884702682495, 0.040480151772499084, -0.028685564175248146, 0.027476415038108826, -0.0444740429520607, -0.05887463688850403, 0.01177320908755064, -0.06573496013879776, 0.04436039924621582, -0.006896419450640678, -0.025190750136971474, 0.014464127831161022, -0.004123147111386061, -0.058624040335416794, 0.011129975318908691, -0.05948782339692116, 0.06228151544928551, 0.06203577294945717, 0.02018720842897892, 0.007704387418925762, 0.018543101847171783, 0.003455825848504901, 0.02363765612244606, -0.021100077778100967, -0.01943565532565117, -0.05317699909210205, -0.021533066406846046, 0.0539097785949707, -0.014429154805839062, -0.012089460156857967, 0.01231088861823082, 0.06932399421930313, 0.012695379555225372, 0.009240307845175266, 0.01716741733253002, -0.009857501834630966, -0.027365602552890778, 0.02657870389521122, 0.020528698340058327, -0.024316798895597458, 0.0013732750667259097, 0.03816705942153931, -0.016180159524083138, 0.03687967732548714, -0.020555801689624786, -0.012536794878542423, 0.05037447810173035, 0.029344145208597183, -0.011511292308568954, -0.017019763588905334, -0.035787034779787064, 0.061115626245737076, -0.016343677416443825, 0.036675941199064255, 0.02880125492811203, 0.009352415800094604, 0.01210029423236847, 0.039926495403051376, -0.00885624811053276, 0.002379370154812932, -0.0009161817142739892, -0.028743725270032883, 0.001661389833316207, -0.0035602147690951824, -0.03462544083595276, 0.031278084963560104, -0.03797561302781105, -0.015380808152258396, -0.05577779933810234, 0.00272004515863955, 0.02688097208738327, 0.046989016234874725, 0.03329561650753021, -0.028879782184958458, -0.03668355196714401, 0.0016693056095391512, -0.0017062348779290915, 0.009504475630819798, 0.017329512163996696, -0.05031857267022133, -0.013053907081484795, -0.03255138173699379, 0.0033080431167036295, 0.005779466591775417, -0.009705936536192894, -0.03459608554840088, 0.009659418836236, 0.015503903850913048, -0.05780620872974396, -0.01037848275154829, -0.020119117572903633, 0.020251978188753128, -0.016541985794901848, -0.0630224421620369, 0.04981926456093788, -0.029340434819459915, -0.017998388037085533, 0.03111403062939644, -0.0640774518251419, -0.02936055138707161, 0.02073676697909832, 0.026204122230410576, 0.027817649766802788, -0.014853095635771751, -0.006495738867670298, 0.02595551311969757, -0.038381487131118774, -0.04840032011270523, -0.06798684597015381, -0.06206695735454559, 0.007921581156551838, 0.018971646204590797, 0.026154350489377975, -0.0003326169098727405, -0.03982466459274292, 0.041733089834451675, 0.012804515659809113, -0.007932832464575768, -0.04182844236493111, -0.014157455414533615, -0.030700573697686195, 0.002080713864415884, 0.004061139188706875, 0.0006101782782934606, 0.003295554080978036, 0.020376082509756088, 0.01157366018742323, 0.04004404693841934, 0.03550993651151657, 0.015002837404608727, 0.014653635211288929, -0.013652406632900238, 0.05640626326203346, -0.027787648141384125, 0.03844554349780083, 0.03519158437848091, -0.03360692784190178, -0.010863538831472397, 0.001764698070473969, 0.029206570237874985, -0.003712761215865612, -0.031309824436903, 0.027728941291570663, 0.002848769770935178, -0.027106819674372673, -0.07966364920139313, 0.047013889998197556, 0.024865515530109406, -0.021401621401309967, -0.011903218924999237, 0.0019087500404566526, 0.0332551933825016, -0.012477229349315166, -0.012062685564160347, 0.03495796397328377, 0.06138124316930771, -0.019068703055381775, 0.0034203645773231983, -0.043897148221731186, -0.00415066909044981, 0.04192217066884041, -0.029999326914548874, 0.004307572264224291, 0.05954999476671219, 0.026682604104280472, -0.00042744295205920935, -0.03292940929532051, -0.033930957317352295, -0.023435138165950775, -0.09973547607660294, 0.04173180088400841, -0.04576823487877846, 0.06158653274178505, 0.041234008967876434, 0.08084014058113098, -0.001407457748427987, -0.020978912711143494, -0.00562782259657979, 0.010820318013429642, -0.034021880477666855, 0.03938409686088562, -0.03219978138804436, 0.021632060408592224, -0.003868725150823593, -0.007206987123936415, 0.0040545957162976265, -0.012279435992240906, 0.007851634174585342, -0.005215794313699007, 0.02357097715139389, 0.005030364263802767, -0.004619999323040247, -0.008527333848178387, -0.010294942185282707, 0.01594487763941288, 0.014509929344058037, -0.04104391485452652, -0.03168748691678047, 0.028459778055548668, 0.0791092962026596, -0.008783174678683281, -0.014006842859089375, 0.0037528686225414276, -0.025452468544244766, 0.011494391597807407, 0.004858012776821852, 0.03179473802447319, 0.025080617517232895, -0.0019474664004519582, -0.0015537070576101542, 0.033118829131126404, 0.040724582970142365, 0.04993394762277603, -0.006024346221238375, -0.016352590173482895, -0.007666309364140034, -0.01526905968785286, -0.01567194052040577, -0.001526513951830566, 0.024043582379817963, 0.023462219163775444, 0.0716179832816124, 0.023808429017663002, -0.02089020609855652, -0.0022472015116363764, 0.04197344928979874, 0.03967363387346268, 0.027319729328155518, -0.043798498809337616, -0.0012804518919438124, 0.009801626205444336, -0.002322438172996044, 0.024658916518092155, 0.013144714757800102, 0.0444401279091835, 0.008005053736269474, 0.038153015077114105, -0.04036269709467888, -0.012968550436198711, -0.056419625878334045, 0.016844360157847404, 0.01395394280552864, 0.00015864438319113106, -0.029143700376152992, -0.018263332545757294, 0.03282373026013374, 0.022810686379671097, 0.0013886794913560152, -0.016592077910900116, -0.04409683495759964, -0.01677103340625763, 0.038433123379945755, 0.016913603991270065, -0.04836752265691757, -0.009341360069811344, -0.04500214010477066, -0.010610765777528286, -0.0021507092751562595, -0.00952786672860384, -0.008219697512686253, -0.02578306943178177, 0.007990589365363121, 0.025474436581134796, -0.026810718700289726, -0.059630099684000015, 0.027867978438735008, 0.00271285860799253, 0.0062920511700212955, 0.009356469847261906, -0.019381536170840263, -0.02202167734503746, 0.005019217263907194, 0.00638218130916357, 0.08072676509618759, -0.022190473973751068, 0.004737889394164085, 0.03724094107747078, 0.01506161317229271, 0.005040297284722328, -0.07869652658700943, 0.01498585194349289, -0.01168876700103283, 0.01756586693227291, 0.055499810725450516, -0.024896766990423203, -0.046279799193143845, -0.013468308374285698, -0.0008444060222245753, -0.03039437346160412, -0.008432787843048573, -0.03753579780459404, 0.0630185455083847, 0.04639878496527672, 0.008792649023234844, 0.06484398990869522, 0.012720296159386635, -0.03243091329932213, -0.0037502776831388474, -0.061920247972011566, 0.008446089923381805, -0.030782708898186684, -0.005056106485426426, -0.012404811568558216, 0.0016849538078531623, -0.033544089645147324, 0.0002592261880636215, -0.0023824090603739023, 0.022440118715167046, -0.05466260015964508, -0.02597380056977272, 0.013171287253499031, 0.026192152872681618, 0.013412442989647388, 0.02121649868786335, 0.002039518905803561, 0.0036992193199694157, 0.010157877579331398, -0.03683949634432793, 0.046649668365716934, -0.02796822041273117, -0.019970057532191277, 0.021267134696245193, -0.012168330140411854, -0.004201733972877264, -0.008532270789146423, -0.029744621366262436, 0.041717804968357086, 0.00007475212623830885, 0.040090858936309814, -0.02370515838265419, 0.022268038243055344, 0.03306315094232559, -0.03933019936084747, -0.03348153457045555, 0.011776656843721867, 0.0035039542708545923, 0.032250672578811646, 0.013894565403461456, 0.04080316424369812, -0.0050218976102769375, -0.015549945645034313, -0.08274880796670914, -0.014699986204504967, 0.02710796520113945, -0.02856207825243473, -0.02178705856204033, -0.07198593020439148, -0.003480092855170369, -0.03087560459971428, -0.010258074849843979, -0.004360267426818609, 0.030181484296917915, 0.009116512723267078, -0.01205881405621767, -0.018665242940187454, 0.03738128021359444, 0.054816704243421555, -0.005637000314891338, -0.012540771625936031, 0.02356349676847458, -0.026555493474006653, -0.013176953420042992, 0.021042441949248314, 0.018176743760704994, -0.02825373224914074, -0.009969200938940048, -0.027920447289943695, -0.03384566307067871, -0.0032448829151690006, -0.02213510125875473, -0.06655266135931015, 0.007478236686438322, -0.0034543233923614025, 0.01097100879997015, -0.0065217348746955395, 0.0000034653439797693864, -0.0229000486433506, 0.02123149298131466, -0.024149268865585327, 0.009431126527488232, -0.04353274032473564, 0.017866864800453186, 0.038891006261110306, -0.008464829064905643, -0.02554824948310852, 0.030302168801426888, 0.07757767289876938, -0.017632288858294487, 0.0071874926798045635, 0.03486547991633415, -0.0064849467016756535, 0.047158654779195786, -0.0010252862703055143, -0.015571389347314835, 0.04536018520593643, 0.04796234145760536, -0.04543017968535423, -0.01926041767001152, -0.03733089566230774, 0.005262712482362986, 0.07748620212078094, -0.019308490678668022, 0.02910262905061245, 0.03755748271942139, -0.017386693507432938, -0.0021292660385370255, -0.061106450855731964, 0.035059090703725815, 0.00010079723142553121, -0.018966900184750557, 0.010331813246011734, -0.04143767058849335, 0.005894110072404146, 0.03417154401540756, 0.031000036746263504, 0.015989679843187332, 0.005249377805739641, -0.006675093900412321, 0.03708745166659355, -0.009659046307206154, -0.0407712385058403, -0.037735000252723694, 0.07811006158590317, -0.028721682727336884, -0.0008645504130981863, -0.04712767153978348, -0.018309911713004112, 0.0528128445148468, 0.05698370933532715, -0.01502258237451315, -0.06151195615530014, 0.008065841160714626, -0.03389008343219757, 0.0424429215490818, 0.03337491303682327, -0.009359024465084076, 0.023124372586607933, -0.010617953725159168, 0.039674535393714905, -0.014515450224280357, 0.032567597925662994, -0.005725347902625799, -0.09839136153459549, -0.011581426486372948, -0.00233691418543458, -0.0472768098115921, -0.0021271584555506706, 0.008481154218316078, -0.00510376738384366, 0.0254905354231596, -0.04319740831851959, -0.005034946370869875, 0.01821555569767952, 0.03058605268597603, -0.0389370322227478, 0.06632331758737564, -0.009816141799092293, -0.003148992545902729, -0.025196989998221397, -0.017919162288308144, 0.10462139546871185, 0.05838271602988243, 0.024483511224389076, -0.05628250911831856, -0.007696625776588917, 0.03564881160855293, 0.00028836235287599266, -0.0021748209837824106, -0.004961373284459114, -0.0029176080133765936, 0.00897596962749958, 0.07167674601078033, 0.06652764976024628, 0.0145405363291502, -0.03552655875682831, 0.0721099004149437, -0.0032962183468043804, -0.060320764780044556, -0.026096276938915253, -0.009624280966818333, 0.00988122820854187, -0.012522404082119465, -0.004063387867063284, -0.004896893631666899, 0.0009532023104839027, -0.019221672788262367, -0.06975018978118896, -0.027770718559622765, -0.0277341827750206, 0.03244704008102417, -0.04029868543148041, -0.03083774819970131, 0.023671690374612808, 0.015117231756448746, -0.009848582558333874, 0.014982691034674644, 0.026865584775805473, -0.05594731867313385, 0.0203754473477602, 0.03696111962199211, -0.0250718891620636, -0.006156941410154104, 0.030275043100118637, 0.017659645527601242, -0.060300055891275406, -0.012216874398291111, -0.016132934018969536, 0.0680716335773468, -0.0068291425704956055, -0.004576562903821468, -0.028660757467150688, 0.007731239311397076, 0.006609100382775068, -0.026770688593387604, -0.011798269115388393, 0.010080656036734581, 0.000017273348930757493, -0.0338391475379467, -0.007897906005382538, -0.041087806224823, 0.030409492552280426, -0.010580036789178848, 0.05269848182797432, 0.04189427196979523, -0.03704172372817993, -0.005265821237117052, -0.025301093235611916, 0.04689599946141243, -0.013493318110704422, -0.018084147945046425, -0.0046152700670063496, -0.03624113276600838, -0.03380002826452255, -0.004579384811222553, 0.00004065675602760166, -0.0005444639828056097, 0.05915394052863121, -0.00809321179986, 0.004116277676075697, -0.029822586104273796, -0.03886566311120987, -0.004255617968738079, -0.03282705694437027, -0.014421114698052406, -0.03872482106089592, 0.011923414655029774, 0.03193754330277443, 0.01938195340335369, 0.05448685586452484, 0.03634518384933472, -0.006471970118582249, 0.015532845631241798, 0.0028363734018057585, -0.021658089011907578, -0.03213680535554886, -0.00026469503063708544, -0.018655534833669662, -0.00671152351424098, -0.03636198863387108, 0.038275592029094696, 0.023902319371700287, 0.021011004224419594, 0.0034844677429646254, -0.013372671790421009, -0.021800870075821877, 0.006536243017762899, -0.005067151505500078, -0.020142149180173874, -0.008968614973127842, -0.004794666543602943, 0.01952959969639778, -0.000897601421456784, 0.005452906247228384, -0.03634374588727951, -0.007930644787847996, 0.005399680696427822, -0.04504726454615593, -0.0281288530677557, 0.009664171375334263, 0.0082944855093956, 0.03343891352415085, -0.013805431313812733, -0.029424259439110756, -0.027914628386497498, -0.01341250166296959, 0.00754128210246563, -0.006612051744014025, 0.0435732938349247, -0.003699634224176407, -0.02883465215563774, -0.0004516023036558181, 0.02013055980205536, 0.015382462181150913, -0.0046719517558813095, 0.00930305290967226, 0.019710786640644073, 0.01771577075123787, 0.04223857447504997, -0.00899164006114006, 0.0072991689667105675, 0.01728089526295662, -0.03496253117918968, -0.03397978097200394, 0.022371355444192886, -0.0003301413671579212, 0.061327967792749405, 0.011846688576042652, -0.017168866470456123, -0.023127084597945213, 0.02070898562669754, -0.04062122851610184, -0.03436507284641266, -0.01847623847424984, -0.002269446151331067, -0.00015861370775382966, -0.03858635202050209, -0.039019834250211716, 0.000870359770487994, -0.028186863288283348, 0.033192384988069534, 0.027769355103373528, 0.012181936763226986, -0.027000293135643005, 0.018656225875020027, -0.013379611074924469, 0.003795237047597766, -0.008791671134531498, 0.02468397654592991, 0.018259599804878235, 0.05091681331396103, 0.00034307283931411803, 0.058013688772916794, -0.005178986582905054, 0.020982934162020683, -0.08662376552820206, -0.03284486383199692, 0.005369630176573992, -0.0009165488299913704, 0.03625401481986046, -0.05207120254635811, -0.02936227060854435, 0.01409077737480402, -0.06561516225337982, 0.040928542613983154, 0.018064823001623154, -0.01878722757101059, -0.012137852609157562, 0.05813702568411827, 0.011902963742613792, 0.0060461778193712234, 0.030617332085967064, 0.015722384676337242, 0.04210188612341881, 0.026042848825454712, 0.009705755859613419, -0.03100642003118992, -0.027317000553011894, -0.0014767565298825502, 0.017931947484612465, -0.0626705065369606, 0.03154755383729935, -0.04082312062382698, -0.01527049858123064, 0.03328021243214607, -0.005862978287041187, 0.030993817374110222, 0.013953727670013905, -0.012324675917625427, 0.004308868199586868, 0.01325892098248005, 0.04531050845980644, -0.04821830987930298, -0.012331106700003147, 0.0023251024540513754, -0.0074003953486680984, 0.015032544732093811, -0.028835982084274292, -0.010398170910775661, 0.015451851300895214, -0.002008679322898388, -0.022109778597950935, 0.04538069665431976, -0.013721028342843056, -0.017720747739076614, 0.014850429259240627, 0.016125794500112534, -0.008549797348678112, 0.012630109675228596, 0.024853641167283058, -0.06018676981329918, 0.010727076791226864, 0.041020672768354416, 0.02131642960011959, 0.0017467186553403735, 0.018976088613271713, 0.015905488282442093, 0.004731636494398117, 0.03229307755827904, 0.011394767090678215, -0.0022960652131587267, -0.06631208956241608, -0.002235404448583722, -0.0447453074157238, 0.017385849729180336, 0.012089955620467663, -0.0018306148704141378, -0.029509199783205986, 0.029395245015621185, -0.015170427039265633, -0.025037964805960655, 0.03203519433736801, -0.0078100706450641155, 0.013967277482151985, -0.0634085088968277, 0.029089804738759995, 0.029892398044466972, -0.030692236497998238, -0.062476303428411484, -0.04707617685198784, -0.011079372838139534, 0.004257844295352697, 0.06675618141889572, 0.00346118095330894, -0.005703614559024572, -0.009791585616767406, 0.03888719528913498, 0.0017110134940594435, -0.0412655808031559, 0.03273811936378479, 0.0024018469266593456, 0.009803622961044312, -0.016877276822924614, 0.005356772802770138, 0.0076863630674779415, 0.02012757584452629, 0.049635935574769974, -0.04234319180250168, 0.038360174745321274, -0.02339768595993519, -0.00802469253540039, 0.04629024863243103, 0.018036605790257454, -0.052151717245578766, 0.07704244554042816, -0.02076365053653717, 0.025950584560632706, 0.015438891015946865, -0.014724455773830414, -0.0489005446434021, 0.042751945555210114, -0.019448624923825264, -0.03046482242643833, 0.02997242473065853, 0.022490663453936577, 0.010303075425326824, -0.07312402129173279, -0.01730688475072384, 0.01580839231610298, -0.05385373532772064, -0.016693860292434692, 0.025285562500357628, 0.05750040337443352, 0.021723438054323196, -0.01788858324289322, -0.010154135525226593, -0.007497178390622139, -0.02880164235830307, 0.014110500924289227, 0.03795487433671951, 0.015623573213815689, 0.016940345987677574, 0.0204766895622015, 0.019185366109013557, 0.01590687781572342, 0.004350236617028713, -0.006989834830164909, 0.07330194860696793, -0.03494469076395035, 0.0046101887710392475, 0.0033685127273201942, -0.004346924833953381, 0.022469045594334602, 0.028831414878368378, -0.011688217520713806, 0.028725547716021538, -0.05906040593981743, -0.017190007492899895, 0.019492296501994133, -0.017738470807671547, -0.051041170954704285, -0.013329603709280491, -0.013077988289296627, 0.028020629659295082, 0.041145484894514084, -0.006022918503731489, -0.005103930830955505, -0.018047457560896873, 0.01633499190211296, -0.022413216531276703, 0.0032772331032902002, 0.021473197266459465, 0.003604491939768195, -0.007304210215806961, -0.0288364440202713, -0.023968270048499107, -0.021115539595484734, 0.03039512224495411, 0.010314161889255047, 0.018968366086483, -0.05412781611084938, -0.025213573127985, -0.0012819879921153188, 0.08940812200307846, -0.06852941960096359, -0.032374586910009384, -0.04255141690373421, -0.012000232003629208, -0.0030887967441231012, -0.0017204256728291512 ]
<p>The method that I'm familiar with for constructing a random forest is as follows: (from <a href="http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~breiman/RandomForests/cc_home.htm" rel="nofollow">http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~breiman/RandomForests/cc_home.htm</a>)</p> <p>To build a tree in the forest we:</p> <ol> <li> Bootstrap a sample of size N where N is the size of our training set. Use this bootstrapped sample as the training set for this tree. </li> <li>At each node of the tree randomly select m of our M features. Select the best of these m features to split on. (where m is a parameter of our Random Forest)</li> <li>Grow each tree to largest extent possible -- i.e. no pruning. </li> </ol> <p>While this algorithm makes sense at a procedural level and certainly produces good results, I'm not clear what the theoretical motivation is behind the steps 1, 2, and 3. Could someone explain what motivated someone to come up with this procedure and why it works so well?</p> <p>For example: why do we need to perform step 1? It doesn't seem like we're bootstrapping for its usual purpose of variance-reduction.</p>
74,376
[ -0.0082203708589077, 0.003431708784773946, 0.004622365813702345, -0.007255140226334333, 0.009384572505950928, 0.006760217249393463, -0.006375761702656746, -0.02553192526102066, 0.04478190466761589, -0.026672041043639183, 0.020178629085421562, 0.045751240104436874, 0.03973650932312012, 0.015701178461313248, -0.005653322674334049, -0.01043551042675972, 0.0051012588664889336, -0.002079081255942583, -0.004397059790790081, -0.025443213060498238, -0.010395565070211887, 0.03237248584628105, 0.008402804844081402, -0.011235433630645275, -0.025803184136748314, 0.028668273240327835, 0.009331833571195602, 0.021144744008779526, 0.017522385343909264, 0.06074747070670128, -0.06683540344238281, -0.004187174141407013, 0.0035874343011528254, 0.049241840839385986, 0.01568574085831642, -0.037122637033462524, -0.02153972163796425, -0.03209704905748367, -0.006990915164351463, 0.0032423671800643206, -0.02076992392539978, -0.0218332689255476, -0.035778697580099106, 0.034090641885995865, -0.01866273023188114, 0.02436981536448002, -0.032848894596099854, -0.042904023081064224, 0.01214300561696291, -0.05764837935566902, 0.053222205489873886, -0.03472580760717392, 0.049118779599666595, 0.05517459288239479, 0.0006813116488046944, -0.01377421896904707, 0.02445138990879059, 0.06179888918995857, -0.01788388006389141, -0.010379135608673096, -0.008947976864874363, -0.039983030408620834, 0.008969690650701523, 0.04894614592194557, -0.037703320384025574, 0.03334568813443184, 0.018949413672089577, -0.0035396895837038755, 0.041469886898994446, -0.00760362483561039, 0.0057543241418898106, -0.006083886604756117, 0.04953105002641678, -0.0033281310461461544, 0.010849334299564362, 0.014358745887875557, -0.0015158202731981874, -0.002209143480286002, 0.03793046623468399, 0.021324552595615387, 0.007148026954382658, 0.005426439922302961, 0.014022094197571278, 0.01896439678966999, 0.026698138564825058, 0.008390406146645546, 0.0769142135977745, -0.030202271416783333, 0.028746087104082108, 0.01734713464975357, -0.005459201987832785, 0.007328632287681103, 0.037904415279626846, -0.0224605742841959, -0.0309454258531332, 0.03867854177951813, -0.00002092590875690803, 0.028267649933695793, 0.007974376901984215, 0.006249504163861275, 0.022990383207798004, -0.012166502885520458, 0.02647613361477852, 0.009538637474179268, -0.045296505093574524, -0.016890250146389008, -0.06338319927453995, 0.018325235694646835, -0.000831319484859705, 0.006306949071586132, -0.03153153136372566, 0.005907144863158464, 0.004528512246906757, -0.011137187480926514, 0.04265682399272919, -0.01581885665655136, 0.005400249268859625, 0.010373524390161037, 0.0339396633207798, 0.05177117884159088, 0.008598165586590767, -0.02153252437710762, 0.022648073732852936, -0.018413811922073364, -0.04582953825592995, 0.03612903878092766, 0.00541874673217535, -0.0206459928303957, -0.012613239698112011, 0.04839669167995453, -0.014843410812318325, -0.020421678200364113, 0.053905267268419266, 0.02112129144370556, 0.03450506925582886, 0.010943952016532421, -0.12812605500221252, -0.06353964656591415, 0.04726037383079529, -0.04465475305914879, 0.04570361599326134, -0.03738919273018837, 0.026086345314979553, 0.00463547557592392, 0.05695761367678642, -0.006820311304181814, 0.05908508598804474, -0.002325245877727866, 0.02357320301234722, 0.006296924781054258, -0.022787101566791534, -0.01562628149986267, -0.0344821996986866, 0.011461809277534485, -0.022678473964333534, -0.1227850466966629, 0.048986099660396576, 0.003422687528654933, -0.0179595947265625, -0.03058161959052086, 0.02212895266711712, -0.023287644609808922, -0.0016668166499584913, 0.0037796893157064915, -0.016368526965379715, 0.008460797369480133, 0.08330778032541275, 0.0066013638861477375, 0.03589190915226936, 0.027991143986582756, -0.020685013383626938, 0.001149164279922843, 0.03121226653456688, 0.0339864082634449, 0.039721764624118805, -0.010619434528052807, -0.030875489115715027, 0.0032319116871804, 0.018644604831933975, -0.005985544994473457, 0.014679883606731892, -0.025205308571457863, 0.003695061430335045, 0.006786573212593794, 0.024655284360051155, 0.04341647028923035, -0.006814477499574423, -0.02201664447784424, 0.051213208585977554, -0.04414106532931328, -0.03628750145435333, -0.0707816630601883, 0.007157632149755955, -0.023125026375055313, 0.005346204154193401, 0.020423639565706253, 0.017558062449097633, 0.017992470413446426, 0.0018664507661014795, -0.019051911309361458, -0.06653871387243271, -0.022860605269670486, 0.04143862798810005, -0.028982792049646378, 0.011611657217144966, 0.04168160632252693, 0.01678028702735901, -0.036304011940956116, 0.05122772231698036, -0.03554500639438629, -0.06390543282032013, 0.02461104467511177, -0.027828462421894073, -0.01382964663207531, -0.05352524667978287, -0.02611147053539753, 0.04605559632182121, 0.002672569127753377, -0.006352887488901615, 0.007039537187665701, -0.06289117783308029, 0.058916494250297546, 0.083977609872818, 0.011939207091927528, -0.00801483541727066, 0.02401323989033699, 0.011204482987523079, 0.014731371775269508, 0.007672962266951799, 0.003922948148101568, -0.05643262714147568, -0.07840876281261444, 0.06800369918346405, 0.009998239576816559, -0.017150145024061203, 0.0161728598177433, 0.0716593787074089, 0.046817537397146225, 0.029730653390288353, 0.06610500067472458, -0.021388646215200424, 0.021461093798279762, -0.0047172922641038895, 0.035303957760334015, 0.01249203272163868, -0.008313089609146118, -0.000054334363085217774, 0.0027120267041027546, 0.010139797814190388, 0.03562835976481438, -0.030708257108926773, 0.02617487870156765, 0.014270826242864132, 0.005438110325485468, -0.006242324598133564, -0.045036181807518005, 0.012818675488233566, -0.031870219856500626, 0.012264580465853214, 0.039781030267477036, 0.015921730548143387, 0.024430423974990845, -0.04647180438041687, -0.014668874442577362, 0.039221808314323425, 0.052647143602371216, -0.038708269596099854, 0.02133306860923767, 0.008953992277383804, -0.038616351783275604, 0.012028948403894901, -0.01684757135808468, -0.04801126942038536, -0.056050654500722885, 0.04613909870386124, 0.007465542759746313, -0.019042817875742912, 0.051658909767866135, 0.0037668398581445217, -0.030561132356524467, -0.019204113632440567, -0.04882816597819328, 0.020458748564124107, 0.012081649154424667, -0.01232996117323637, -0.03217095509171486, 0.0009784642606973648, -0.004411374218761921, 0.04949120804667473, 0.007569203153252602, -0.025336885824799538, -0.016003312543034554, 0.007766445633023977, -0.03729724884033203, -0.03910793736577034, -0.027289891615509987, 0.034107837826013565, 0.01838424988090992, -0.02646687999367714, 0.034602321684360504, 0.035618413239717484, -0.014687915332615376, 0.027865411713719368, -0.036827243864536285, -0.021975906565785408, -0.03904682770371437, -0.01526192668825388, 0.023208050057291985, -0.0009703618125058711, -0.003527973545715213, 0.02523232251405716, -0.036497510969638824, 0.01404752116650343, -0.04272257164120674, -0.07483571767807007, 0.011998417787253857, 0.015192309394478798, 0.0337425097823143, 0.0077272881753742695, -0.023789627477526665, 0.07323358952999115, 0.011510588228702545, -0.04801017791032791, -0.031216848641633987, -0.013120782561600208, -0.007564302999526262, -0.00499255396425724, 0.0036740985233336687, 0.028816748410463333, 0.00008881435496732593, 0.0401269868016243, -0.00910928938537836, 0.043136633932590485, 0.07116801291704178, -0.014246033504605293, 0.00018807406013365835, 0.006116967182606459, -0.0016142139211297035, -0.031041407957673073, 0.016078373417258263, 0.0038435994647443295, -0.03136865049600601, 0.028697531670331955, -0.0238486360758543, -0.008191640488803387, 0.010587135329842567, -0.0527200810611248, 0.008188444189727306, -0.04104553535580635, 0.027780286967754364, -0.047625232487916946, 0.03613732382655144, -0.0157514289021492, -0.0324341244995594, 0.0010301799047738314, 0.01024026982486248, 0.016133295372128487, -0.03406158834695816, -0.021365178748965263, -0.01496199332177639, 0.0294441320002079, 0.0008038289379328489, -0.012110590003430843, -0.01531323790550232, -0.02659551426768303, 0.014447405003011227, 0.0027286959812045097, 0.019681548699736595, 0.041179172694683075, 0.05557547137141228, 0.04676958546042442, 0.006875970400869846, -0.0441841259598732, 0.00824655406177044, -0.03202737122774124, 0.020934568718075752, -0.020428402349352837, 0.03341638669371605, -0.02726956270635128, 0.09272447973489761, -0.011943558230996132, 0.014400873333215714, 0.029562409967184067, 0.01643427088856697, -0.07861634343862534, 0.007699246983975172, -0.0125522930175066, -0.00693830382078886, 0.005717146676033735, -0.01781478337943554, 0.03559539094567299, -0.008775522001087666, -0.005071194376796484, -0.017770878970623016, 0.013217763043940067, -0.029221713542938232, 0.012332690879702568, -0.009484920650720596, 0.004505062010139227, -0.026655135676264763, -0.0031178381759673357, 0.023892398923635483, 0.0030340957455337048, 0.023598555475473404, 0.030492007732391357, 0.022011922672390938, 0.004991107154637575, -0.006384820677340031, 0.0028383333701640368, 0.015407211147248745, 0.043552324175834656, 0.03842703253030777, -0.011781097389757633, -0.02985263802111149, 0.024924185127019882, -0.00917073991149664, 0.05365750938653946, 0.03333894908428192, 0.017150837928056717, 0.013496027328073978, -0.011899267323315144, -0.0050522563979029655, -0.0060715279541909695, -0.02276010438799858, 0.002718819770962, -0.0028278299141675234, 0.06426956504583359, 0.01580520160496235, -0.07243698090314865, -0.007280492223799229, 0.07660924643278122, -0.025445662438869476, -0.013522579334676266, -0.05287374183535576, 0.010956632904708385, 0.0012339618988335133, -0.02223781868815422, 0.06563985347747803, 0.010513686574995518, -0.03437479957938194, 0.002761904150247574, 0.06015787646174431, -0.04335126280784607, -0.02958194725215435, 0.010956558398902416, 0.028915978968143463, 0.042276788502931595, 0.004035080783069134, -0.03285364434123039, -0.009525873698294163, 0.01945115439593792, 0.016019806265830994, 0.010328537784516811, -0.04203255474567413, -0.08362387120723724, 0.020123140886425972, 0.034517280757427216, 0.01968461647629738, -0.0700194239616394, 0.0012182780774310231, -0.04257670044898987, -0.01725751720368862, 0.03455932438373566, -0.04310888424515724, 0.023724626749753952, -0.007274715229868889, -0.007468373514711857, -0.03685277700424194, -0.0126182921230793, -0.016715483739972115, 0.02279612608253956, -0.024361606687307358, 0.043681975454092026, 0.007131858728826046, -0.03372645005583763, -0.05875527113676071, 0.0011140021961182356, -0.015880590304732323, 0.07346024364233017, -0.033416155725717545, 0.00863929558545351, -0.027846332639455795, 0.027909554541110992, -0.005502454005181789, -0.044619280844926834, -0.0062844473868608475, 0.03394916653633118, -0.011754131875932217, 0.015632985159754753, -0.031881824135780334, -0.06735888868570328, 0.0056814453564584255, 0.013631870038807392, -0.04413651302456856, -0.0281742624938488, 0.014014862477779388, 0.011540563777089119, 0.03701316937804222, -0.008099179714918137, 0.07881361246109009, 0.03323258087038994, 0.0003584634105209261, -0.0004301494045648724, -0.018995201215147972, 0.04380521923303604, -0.045454055070877075, -0.017279453575611115, -0.04658837616443634, 0.010375609621405602, -0.041449930518865585, 0.008248567581176758, 0.008977467194199562, 0.031207099556922913, -0.02816169336438179, -0.009735222905874252, -0.01960940659046173, 0.03767918050289154, -0.03125673905014992, -0.004688370041549206, 0.003933491185307503, 0.042860835790634155, -0.0009062273311428726, -0.006480139214545488, 0.023865627124905586, 0.005192122887820005, 0.01411727536469698, 0.0000836877225083299, -0.010635322891175747, -0.006986737716943026, -0.07447759062051773, -0.022135889157652855, 0.02024480327963829, -0.03210718184709549, 0.04321758821606636, 0.0017955469666048884, 0.021435029804706573, 0.013851296156644821, -0.06637117266654968, -0.015028824098408222, 0.0019213652703911066, -0.021650666370987892, 0.03599775955080986, -0.04298282414674759, 0.03465142101049423, -0.03617933765053749, 0.003122108755633235, -0.0568900890648365, -0.037113215774297714, 0.022387105971574783, 0.025555212050676346, -0.012105992995202541, -0.04199427366256714, 0.015930810943245888, -0.0010501992655918002, -0.026686783879995346, -0.021238010376691818, 0.06835252046585083, -0.004734738729894161, -0.004673474468290806, 0.02086128294467926, 0.01294702384620905, 0.06409067660570145, 0.010119177401065826, 0.007231045048683882, 0.014633583836257458, -0.024841295555233955, 0.0058112964034080505, 0.03176221624016762, 0.03132270649075508, -0.02798471786081791, -0.012017504312098026, -0.05803512781858444, 0.027187764644622803, 0.02686665765941143, -0.00221227016299963, 0.010546465404331684, -0.0036907976027578115, 0.011489244177937508, 0.010748421773314476, -0.0442696213722229, -0.0059166825376451015, -0.010700495913624763, 0.010228674858808517, -0.02699086256325245, 0.017266880720853806, -0.001963390503078699, -0.002204777905717492, 0.026682274416089058, -0.01754610985517502, 0.03842760995030403, 0.020541004836559296, 0.04418342933058739, -0.05711948871612549, 0.026568610221147537, 0.01196818333119154, -0.04910587519407272, 0.025725366547703743, 0.014184588566422462, 0.016152985394001007, 0.030688343569636345, 0.020427698269486427, -0.02209348790347576, 0.0034215799532830715, -0.01638014242053032, 0.0009779785759747028, 0.06298910081386566, -0.02294931374490261, 0.059045225381851196, 0.04555673524737358, -0.017618589103221893, 0.02168869413435459, -0.021946677938103676, 0.003038982395082712, -0.009313687682151794, -0.010669131763279438, 0.06644190102815628, 0.024504998698830605, 0.020384201779961586, 0.05144781246781349, -0.0077710566110908985, 0.03170958161354065, 0.049542419612407684, 0.021979795768857002, 0.03163091093301773, 0.03692006319761276, -0.021446360275149345, -0.016543874517083168, 0.04243279621005058, -0.03952714428305626, 0.002089517889544368, 0.004714666400104761, -0.015420357696712017, 0.05900069326162338, 0.02564002387225628, -0.007313092239201069, -0.041670892387628555, 0.014608753845095634, -0.01824895851314068, 0.020714469254016876, -0.006946406327188015, -0.0376010499894619, 0.024964498355984688, -0.008990869857370853, -0.013018316589295864, -0.0043974099680781364, -0.0031203755643218756, -0.026440732181072235, -0.07512678951025009, -0.0369977168738842, -0.020698674023151398, -0.06081118434667587, 0.028470559045672417, -0.0040167211554944515, -0.05704636126756668, 0.027558239176869392, -0.030349520966410637, -0.004668711218982935, -0.0050274403765797615, 0.05692208558320999, -0.026736322790384293, 0.0647539421916008, 0.0479208268225193, 0.030987586826086044, 0.028939371928572655, -0.02002743072807789, 0.10067672282457352, 0.07518205791711807, 0.043369028717279434, -0.07006922364234924, 0.027139948680996895, -0.009131023660302162, -0.01889704167842865, -0.03437371179461479, 0.0022015308495610952, 0.014498420991003513, 0.0076838224194943905, 0.020066052675247192, 0.025476476177573204, 0.010601836256682873, -0.014436282217502594, 0.05553620681166649, -0.04293665289878845, -0.021370092406868935, 0.02354397252202034, -0.002718397881835699, -0.00959866400808096, -0.010950138792395592, -0.07032801955938339, 0.0031234005000442266, -0.009033781476318836, -0.012247791513800621, 0.0087794354185462, -0.046666987240314484, 0.02018371969461441, 0.015652723610401154, 0.017202133312821388, -0.0040519279427826405, 0.029959795996546745, -0.011348381638526917, 0.011548633687198162, 0.018344897776842117, -0.01089357491582632, -0.013170331716537476, 0.004651401191949844, 0.02967432700097561, 0.029711099341511726, -0.022199980914592743, -0.010408934205770493, 0.02387411892414093, -0.040863342583179474, -0.031725164502859116, -0.05235367640852928, 0.04106011986732483, -0.01700242981314659, -0.006017992738634348, -0.03567347675561905, 0.0029338893946260214, 0.01363502535969019, -0.047380946576595306, 0.0010163582628592849, 0.007066441234201193, 0.042257145047187805, -0.02325516939163208, -0.04788202419877052, -0.04303358867764473, 0.013569759204983711, -0.050689633935689926, 0.021012168377637863, -0.0034289893228560686, -0.00036483476287685335, -0.001352765946649015, -0.022154279053211212, -0.008147272281348705, -0.002243704628199339, -0.010577312670648098, -0.027293402701616287, 0.009864868596196175, -0.048180028796195984, 0.015290836803615093, 0.017741061747074127, -0.022574102506041527, 0.0429120771586895, -0.041854601353406906, -0.01686995103955269, -0.02224470116198063, -0.008829338476061821, 0.001808149623684585, -0.03663553670048714, -0.01637636125087738, -0.05888372287154198, -0.004773573949933052, -0.0021881198044866323, 0.0568421371281147, 0.03485354036092758, 0.009400898590683937, 0.0034278682433068752, 0.022340314462780952, -0.020745880901813507, -0.053246404975652695, -0.043367184698581696, -0.013417002744972706, -0.027051754295825958, 0.010597627609968185, -0.0036020318511873484, 0.06209052726626396, 0.02944541722536087, 0.03611914440989494, 0.002401108853518963, 0.026294993236660957, -0.01073107123374939, 0.034259818494319916, 0.030036665499210358, -0.05353665351867676, -0.011291565373539925, -0.0033889575861394405, -0.023323819041252136, -0.02912726253271103, -0.017549041658639908, 0.008766010403633118, -0.023958170786499977, 0.003679100191220641, 0.01747756265103817, -0.04262830317020416, -0.004795409739017487, -0.021586356684565544, 0.03248962387442589, -0.05756513401865959, -0.0216122567653656, -0.02617248333990574, 0.028859375044703484, -0.015420718118548393, -0.028548557311296463, -0.018384017050266266, 0.00938432477414608, 0.001551067573018372, 0.002856283215805888, 0.02745852805674076, 0.019352402538061142, 0.011815765872597694, 0.0086592398583889, 0.015532172285020351, -0.007788500748574734, 0.03901704028248787, -0.04523587226867676, 0.023786455392837524, 0.04761412367224693, -0.056683432310819626, -0.03143724426627159, 0.006255755666643381, -0.01756003499031067, 0.03884159028530121, -0.001185334287583828, -0.0402192585170269, -0.025279155001044273, 0.04954725131392479, -0.013735477812588215, -0.03086489997804165, -0.0299848522990942, 0.011810487136244774, 0.03135748207569122, 0.012719384394586086, -0.007749511860311031, -0.006839307490736246, -0.01073121465742588, 0.026152143254876137, 0.03954754024744034, 0.015702005475759506, 0.0002098514378303662, 0.024619266390800476, 0.008362649008631706, 0.005924141965806484, -0.003817035350948572, -0.0052154590375721455, 0.029995713382959366, 0.07793368399143219, -0.03249455243349075, 0.03839028999209404, -0.015581771731376648, -0.0009300060919485986, -0.07216960936784744, -0.014136466197669506, 0.0028402062598615885, -0.002459905343130231, 0.018803995102643967, -0.05187080800533295, 0.011443497613072395, 0.036656055599451065, -0.0454377681016922, 0.02501837909221649, -0.0020669493824243546, -0.021901529282331467, -0.028416641056537628, -0.01284568291157484, -0.03724382072687149, 0.0283585824072361, 0.06508336216211319, -0.007307135965675116, 0.015634112060070038, 0.016619395464658737, -0.007446838077157736, -0.013097625225782394, -0.02809465490281582, 0.04836566373705864, -0.001851340988650918, -0.06003540754318237, 0.029173968359827995, -0.018971355631947517, -0.03266885131597519, 0.029521944001317024, -0.02747270092368126, 0.0121078472584486, 0.06629223376512527, 0.013970421627163887, 0.012584037147462368, 0.013176368549466133, 0.02811259590089321, 0.0034376715775579214, -0.0028389636427164078, -0.002805824391543865, 0.033403635025024414, -0.015318138524889946, 0.02011089399456978, 0.026492899283766747, 0.016656704246997833, -0.007993456907570362, -0.015427625738084316, 0.05319350212812424, -0.008026628755033016, -0.03096267208456993, 0.0054356856271624565, 0.002014315454289317, -0.0011848644353449345, -0.0018223701044917107, -0.019427862018346786, -0.036870986223220825, 0.005124403163790703, 0.054083194583654404, -0.0001691562356427312, -0.006706859450787306, 0.01704440638422966, -0.016791729256510735, -0.0492735393345356, 0.010304199531674385, 0.013646206818521023, -0.017319511622190475, -0.07605881989002228, 0.0019530884455889463, 0.0207518320530653, -0.009922608733177185, -0.006395129486918449, -0.009952970780432224, 0.03310033679008484, 0.02514585480093956, -0.006138923577964306, 0.022942112758755684, 0.01754714362323284, -0.03255049139261246, 0.002707710489630699, -0.10074824094772339, 0.113128162920475, 0.013622000813484192, -0.03611873462796211, -0.0661408007144928, 0.011445986106991768, -0.0237270575016737, -0.00048431253526359797, 0.03481680899858475, 0.0022530746646225452, 0.017914753407239914, -0.040079422295093536, 0.06392193585634232, 0.019343234598636627, -0.051385968923568726, 0.0163231510668993, -0.0007280184072442353, -0.029333626851439476, -0.017163855955004692, -0.034408751875162125, 0.03516610339283943, 0.013492091558873653, -0.0023719314485788345, -0.0009420804562978446, -0.006768127903342247, 0.011016533710062504, 0.03680445998907089, 0.002393984468653798, -0.017973022535443306, -0.004115923773497343, 0.062281787395477295, -0.021106762811541557, -0.0010828980011865497, 0.04015851020812988, 0.00548010878264904, -0.006533392705023289, 0.023105202242732048, -0.030580822378396988, -0.02511432208120823, -0.04265672340989113, 0.007382040377706289, 0.03365270793437958, -0.07860557734966278, -0.01446429081261158, 0.0160078052431345, -0.02513653039932251, 0.03165838494896889, 0.05082644149661064, -0.005638065282255411, 0.04611154645681381, 0.023866746574640274, -0.014309628866612911, -0.012912824749946594, -0.026804983615875244, -0.011228109709918499, 0.023437947034835815, 0.01488824374973774, -0.02257283218204975, 0.043067172169685364, 0.0148733826354146, -0.02036410942673683, 0.02997879683971405, -0.017755111679434776, 0.03687792271375656, -0.013235164806246758, -0.025531955063343048, 0.012774094939231873, -0.04018380865454674, 0.03490160405635834, 0.0013059746706858277, -0.019011013209819794, 0.07908078283071518, -0.0492234006524086, 0.005343608092516661, -0.0036244005896151066, -0.019345279783010483, -0.04524843767285347, 0.00381446722894907, 0.002780846320092678, 0.03651028126478195, 0.008969992399215698, 0.02891540713608265, 0.011140288785099983, 0.01581941358745098, 0.021673062816262245, -0.010434690862894058, 0.053014613687992096, -0.03281232342123985, -0.020939983427524567, 0.011465583927929401, -0.002571187913417816, -0.026581933721899986, -0.03060302697122097, -0.000774616317357868, 0.045255668461322784, 0.02043365128338337, 0.011697107926011086, -0.04698866978287697, 0.010161520913243294, 0.02509843185544014, -0.0468331016600132, 0.010751836933195591, -0.06340550631284714, 0.0035550673492252827, -0.0149659039452672, -0.03297438472509384 ]
<p>Suppose I have repeated observations on individuals, which I've analyzed using a generalized estimating equation (GEE). What is the procedure for computing the prediction interval for future observations given values of the predictors? I would appreciate either instructions or references. Thank you.</p>
74,377
[ -0.03888528421521187, -0.03797134384512901, -0.009635304100811481, 0.03350671008229256, -0.0016536397160962224, 0.009926696307957172, 0.0005027680308558047, -0.03003668412566185, 0.03232427313923836, -0.026953933760523796, 0.024477334693074226, 0.044165100902318954, 0.07413412630558014, 0.005631893873214722, 0.004855731967836618, 0.007979241199791431, -0.031192688271403313, 0.023088805377483368, -0.004109092056751251, -0.03364526852965355, 0.0008787832339294255, 0.020284080877900124, -0.02421143651008606, -0.014097621664404869, -0.010297338478267193, 0.046182796359062195, 0.06640668213367462, -0.014357774518430233, 0.019300023093819618, 0.07031673192977905, -0.04060225933790207, -0.04476898908615112, 0.008921091444790363, 0.07149474322795868, 0.022206712514162064, 0.00008006930147530511, -0.030765367671847343, -0.042568374425172806, -0.01210002601146698, -0.0008999050478450954, -0.04866565763950348, -0.012757477350533009, 0.02594842202961445, 0.02885778248310089, -0.0019580081570893526, -0.014031471684575081, -0.0481974259018898, -0.051283929497003555, 0.024695608764886856, -0.032862093299627304, 0.10393427312374115, -0.035116687417030334, 0.027582138776779175, 0.008595326915383339, -0.02893778309226036, 0.0244511216878891, 0.06982588022947311, 0.05606446415185928, -0.008994488045573235, -0.04525017738342285, 0.026984000578522682, -0.023983225226402283, 0.021010559052228928, 0.00504600815474987, -0.017161935567855835, 0.009569630958139896, -0.024953611195087433, -0.03795035928487778, 0.005053084343671799, -0.03932978957891464, 0.02419533208012581, 0.028313007205724716, 0.07721216231584549, -0.020803416147828102, 0.020007366314530373, -0.02833251655101776, 0.004537930712103844, 0.033918045461177826, 0.040425412356853485, 0.030240897089242935, -0.014918600209057331, 0.032482121139764786, 0.03101804107427597, 0.03830485790967941, -0.01305375900119543, -0.0039049729239195585, 0.031958144158124924, -0.01751093938946724, 0.019287534058094025, 0.024434424936771393, -0.021808575838804245, 0.0127756642177701, 0.040080659091472626, -0.0314335823059082, -0.03032771497964859, 0.03818732500076294, -0.0025000902824103832, 0.042739927768707275, -0.0006315084174275398, -0.004164572339504957, 0.052525606006383896, -0.04333595186471939, -0.008447670377790928, 0.051456134766340256, -0.025314776226878166, -0.025932565331459045, -0.026952048763632774, -0.021377887576818466, 0.034690555185079575, -0.01748708449304104, 0.031122544780373573, 0.006955917924642563, -0.0278831347823143, -0.005349786952137947, 0.0207256730645895, 0.01890593208372593, -0.02640026994049549, -0.01701570861041546, 0.0297989659011364, 0.056968823075294495, 0.022894827648997307, -0.04280867427587509, 0.0403895229101181, -0.008820480667054653, -0.04570407047867775, 0.016228895634412766, 0.030985452234745026, -0.04923556372523308, -0.03855990618467331, 0.04175342246890068, -0.017821945250034332, -0.04241391271352768, 0.051559027284383774, 0.006186056882143021, 0.005313136149197817, -0.010473561473190784, -0.06423867493867874, -0.059314876794815063, -0.016014939174056053, -0.035361938178539276, 0.004622234031558037, -0.09387615323066711, -0.005083323922008276, 0.038501184433698654, 0.03061937913298607, 0.05374317243695259, 0.02129657380282879, 0.017356686294078827, 0.013462790288031101, 0.028162093833088875, -0.0460503026843071, -0.022286688908934593, -0.027059104293584824, -0.015975186601281166, -0.03489129990339279, -0.07422709465026855, 0.0072966162115335464, 0.0018168012611567974, -0.013402175158262253, -0.005813627038151026, 0.03809183090925217, 0.005093683488667011, -0.011768685653805733, -0.026594238355755806, 0.012559333816170692, -0.04305442050099373, 0.08138800412416458, 0.013531899079680443, 0.0013127947458997369, 0.021928194910287857, 0.02686449885368347, 0.015201202593743801, -0.023359552025794983, 0.028063517063856125, 0.06682156771421432, -0.019426198676228523, 0.024105964228510857, -0.03875016048550606, 0.006557790096849203, -0.011980299837887287, -0.039662208408117294, -0.0326978862285614, 0.019079793244600296, -0.02097352407872677, 0.023658588528633118, -0.017467424273490906, -0.010215540416538715, -0.005084552802145481, 0.017258942127227783, -0.05504904314875603, -0.0223760474473238, -0.05753408744931221, 0.0029313841369003057, 0.025929437950253487, 0.007898155599832535, -0.00855842512100935, -0.0020316082518547773, 0.03430289775133133, -0.034420423209667206, -0.02384565956890583, -0.0268403347581625, -0.0011359609197825193, 0.039317406713962555, -0.06825214624404907, -0.004442028235644102, 0.03558779135346413, 0.07364048063755035, -0.016688330098986626, 0.061796169728040695, -0.04228300228714943, -0.02447574958205223, 0.029708022251725197, -0.05038617551326752, 0.029471267014741898, -0.025977203622460365, -0.01939377747476101, -0.0022273771464824677, -0.0050198910757899284, 0.013801776804029942, 0.015580671839416027, -0.06731844693422318, 0.04659970477223396, 0.07426072657108307, 0.02619367092847824, -0.03131785988807678, 0.0020123193971812725, 0.011505951173603535, 0.022905174642801285, -0.06060563400387764, -0.04113813489675522, -0.04859616979956627, -0.013501170091331005, 0.009415213949978352, 0.006214503664523363, -0.00652514910325408, 0.017836173996329308, 0.06360245496034622, 0.015820395201444626, 0.00445167813450098, 0.05995618924498558, 0.028438245877623558, 0.0027082383166998625, -0.0013824946945533156, 0.03578590229153633, 0.00931800901889801, 0.003699541324749589, 0.020835980772972107, 0.03435396030545235, 0.006618826650083065, 0.0011982449796050787, 0.012188167311251163, 0.05140725150704384, 0.01619591750204563, 0.005268735345453024, -0.012278192676603794, -0.05344295874238014, 0.04018646478652954, -0.04435829818248749, 0.015686525031924248, 0.04309742897748947, 0.004054074175655842, -0.015409487299621105, 0.01771240122616291, -0.014659836888313293, 0.0033648572862148285, 0.0357125960290432, -0.07178525626659393, 0.018148457631468773, 0.020257458090782166, -0.03376955911517143, 0.030980253592133522, -0.025642087683081627, 0.005730896256864071, -0.040161434561014175, -0.006224428303539753, 0.036138638854026794, 0.0055287862196564674, 0.018768467009067535, 0.010623793117702007, -0.03896214812994003, -0.0054748100228607655, -0.002918106270954013, 0.010571499355137348, 0.01264613401144743, -0.05571118742227554, -0.00968695804476738, 0.033661313354969025, -0.036974649876356125, 0.01730114221572876, -0.0006627163966186345, -0.026349877938628197, 0.05213726684451103, 0.00638696551322937, -0.04187830910086632, -0.00539394561201334, 0.0006488750805146992, -0.00987107865512371, -0.022509682923555374, -0.03158975765109062, 0.06542655825614929, 0.025353850796818733, -0.04340984672307968, 0.01188222598284483, -0.04716293141245842, -0.0048924102447927, -0.043490931391716, 0.008653469383716583, 0.02424021065235138, -0.021610621362924576, 0.04533439502120018, 0.005676974542438984, -0.008874149061739445, -0.016227055341005325, -0.06194125488400459, -0.06757113337516785, 0.009838899597525597, 0.03206643462181091, 0.038516659289598465, 0.007666668854653835, 0.008573825471103191, 0.07725130021572113, -0.007161456625908613, -0.009012877009809017, -0.06608572602272034, -0.007935779169201851, 0.03354855626821518, -0.042703695595264435, -0.007302284240722656, -0.008721867576241493, 0.013084356673061848, 0.011020228266716003, 0.009589560329914093, 0.04799821227788925, 0.04921792075037956, 0.03405223786830902, 0.009598299860954285, -0.006489295046776533, 0.022168699651956558, -0.0006067591020837426, 0.006335878279060125, 0.020700179040431976, -0.022084224969148636, 0.0088639035820961, 0.0004058194172102958, 0.024474158883094788, 0.007538513746112585, -0.029973935335874557, 0.007413605228066444, -0.0434873066842556, -0.0232652947306633, -0.011389666236937046, 0.045312635600566864, 0.013815006241202354, -0.014210364781320095, -0.03583342581987381, -0.0009901245357468724, 0.03812896087765694, -0.030202025547623634, 0.0022088622208684683, 0.04912738502025604, 0.03404036536812782, 0.003836199175566435, 0.0002751168794929981, -0.013140563853085041, -0.01902858540415764, 0.037556082010269165, -0.05144766345620155, -0.014310592785477638, 0.03407847136259079, 0.02507769875228405, -0.010230902582406998, 0.0071890344843268394, -0.033869508653879166, 0.026264812797307968, -0.0541297122836113, 0.008082770742475986, -0.02975292131304741, 0.0468413420021534, 0.019666075706481934, 0.07261886447668076, 0.02191895805299282, -0.023553144186735153, 0.049126360565423965, 0.03456290811300278, -0.053133897483348846, 0.06700316071510315, -0.014661801047623158, -0.0018373086350038648, 0.003986785188317299, 0.008984999731183052, 0.05498693138360977, 0.003554467810317874, 0.004894956946372986, 0.01146824099123478, 0.02764720655977726, -0.06332612037658691, 0.010637268424034119, -0.020405707880854607, -0.009617372415959835, -0.014134918339550495, 0.0072898538783192635, 0.01742502674460411, -0.032126493752002716, 0.008914466015994549, 0.03870396688580513, -0.025894952937960625, -0.010495156981050968, 0.01777634024620056, -0.017734702676534653, 0.020858822390437126, 0.03956505283713341, 0.05522770434617996, 0.013248578645288944, -0.057986531406641006, 0.008178441785275936, -0.014916457235813141, 0.04615152254700661, 0.04941924661397934, -0.004572620615363121, -0.02236715704202652, 0.012819970026612282, 0.00039514375384896994, 0.03766249865293503, 0.014799905940890312, 0.009429807774722576, 0.02689523808658123, 0.06796566396951675, 0.028074251487851143, -0.03776952624320984, 0.023384492844343185, 0.08203783631324768, 0.01640738733112812, -0.007341989781707525, -0.028573015704751015, 0.04105958715081215, 0.009998893365263939, -0.015695342794060707, 0.021381493657827377, -0.00799843855202198, 0.014176581054925919, 0.00260463310405612, 0.01860923320055008, 0.0007622193079441786, -0.009695908986032009, -0.021973716095089912, 0.018537625670433044, 0.05699428543448448, 0.01606472209095955, -0.058304041624069214, -0.01856468804180622, 0.02605064958333969, 0.044251732528209686, 0.048834607005119324, 0.00400974927470088, -0.07925038039684296, -0.007210751995444298, 0.04980611428618431, 0.019485395401716232, -0.047727279365062714, -0.0118888970464468, -0.017546670511364937, 0.012321106158196926, 0.026729773730039597, -0.04241807386279106, 0.006947258487343788, -0.0023943353444337845, -0.01570729911327362, 0.007140712812542915, -0.015290030278265476, -0.027601776644587517, 0.026308389380574226, -0.030723389238119125, 0.03514852374792099, -0.0006766247097402811, -0.01231994479894638, -0.041046589612960815, -0.008305053226649761, -0.004435101058334112, 0.07707913964986801, 0.028777703642845154, 0.011598772369325161, 0.03560928627848625, 0.00745189655572176, -0.022752709686756134, -0.03994646668434143, 0.023807888850569725, 0.018730707466602325, 0.006965306121855974, 0.02977845072746277, -0.033454529941082, -0.025828523561358452, 0.019506683573126793, 0.03294554352760315, -0.030637001618742943, -0.0422525480389595, -0.04878798872232437, 0.02270667813718319, -0.0027537972200661898, -0.018999334424734116, 0.07692921906709671, 0.009345246478915215, -0.009190619923174381, 0.01614302583038807, -0.01815759763121605, -0.012096364982426167, -0.02059873566031456, -0.026722973212599754, 0.018795710057020187, -0.00029708811780437827, -0.007892598398029804, 0.0017383949598297477, -0.02448135055601597, 0.02427550032734871, -0.026312658563256264, -0.019887620583176613, 0.016984358429908752, 0.022059366106987, -0.03383819758892059, 0.0118752745911479, 0.02130594663321972, 0.014087089337408543, -0.00290033221244812, -0.028404459357261658, 0.01592702604830265, -0.01670006476342678, 0.002096783369779587, 0.008280587382614613, -0.028049936518073082, -0.0005272875423543155, -0.024808119982481003, -0.041690826416015625, 0.041821304708719254, -0.017696088179945946, 0.05103040859103203, -0.04386619105935097, 0.018239956349134445, 0.02980363555252552, -0.06058833748102188, -0.02023637667298317, 0.02515343204140663, 0.009245414286851883, 0.047709640115499496, -0.014933381229639053, 0.016791794449090958, -0.007123333401978016, 0.01725730113685131, -0.08375541120767593, -0.04335898905992508, 0.06358183175325394, -0.001683792914263904, -0.045143965631723404, -0.01583654060959816, 0.008603237569332123, -0.047414083033800125, -0.009182491339743137, -0.019072577357292175, -0.007397655863314867, 0.004366920329630375, -0.005015100352466106, -0.013733669184148312, 0.030515924096107483, 0.07693413645029068, 0.02180270478129387, 0.023669349029660225, 0.010599474422633648, -0.02340899594128132, -0.0275531355291605, -0.0009121427428908646, -0.03299584984779358, -0.044780466705560684, 0.0018257101764902472, -0.01438188273459673, 0.027188895270228386, 0.011902989819645882, -0.009243601933121681, -0.03293022885918617, 0.011082836426794529, 0.002893411321565509, 0.02573462948203087, -0.04451105743646622, 0.0037516076117753983, -0.06016836315393448, -0.0061624194495379925, 0.011695735156536102, 0.002162227174267173, -0.011430466547608376, 0.026890549808740616, 0.017691902816295624, 0.010335288941860199, 0.008133447729051113, -0.004787888377904892, 0.03293333575129509, 0.017274459823966026, -0.01937546581029892, 0.016262151300907135, -0.03381330519914627, 0.027059953659772873, 0.03250962495803833, 0.010584946721792221, 0.04887712374329567, 0.03779619559645653, -0.03868753835558891, -0.010657766833901405, -0.043985191732645035, -0.030412184074521065, 0.09013446420431137, -0.01968732476234436, 0.037578146904706955, 0.053985726088285446, 0.03355979174375534, -0.010693622753024101, -0.03340025618672371, 0.007008911110460758, 0.014640889130532742, 0.0031961267814040184, 0.041454069316387177, -0.009330354630947113, -0.0019316842081025243, -0.017969166859984398, 0.02042648196220398, 0.00418868800625205, 0.04743455722928047, -0.02273419126868248, 0.030859487131237984, 0.022309623658657074, -0.029502078890800476, -0.02525554969906807, 0.029233252629637718, -0.005811444949358702, 0.0033967059571295977, -0.04205240681767464, -0.0014272381085902452, 0.02473747543990612, 0.05904557555913925, 0.01755554974079132, -0.029705950990319252, -0.027797609567642212, -0.01890297792851925, 0.0136396000161767, 0.015673285350203514, -0.01454080082476139, 0.009708327241241932, 0.03984438255429268, -0.006190072279423475, 0.0024928823113441467, 0.012237569317221642, -0.046306271106004715, -0.08283160626888275, -0.009494878351688385, -0.03729752078652382, -0.04841330274939537, 0.015037364326417446, 0.04180034622550011, -0.019786573946475983, -0.004965208936482668, -0.017271706834435463, -0.016050614416599274, -0.002374163130298257, 0.05800614506006241, 0.0011037354124709964, 0.1048215702176094, -0.01365807093679905, -0.005214440170675516, 0.01832732744514942, 0.007898291572928429, 0.09907513856887817, 0.07989604026079178, 0.0227336548268795, -0.09816101938486099, 0.021899640560150146, 0.0024018227122724056, -0.024451717734336853, 0.004987519700080156, 0.005529077257961035, 0.006099188234657049, -0.03634992241859436, 0.06341177225112915, 0.04194468632340431, -0.010265512391924858, -0.008304901421070099, 0.08190424740314484, -0.022017478942871094, -0.010102645494043827, 0.015732116997241974, -0.005496614146977663, -0.0043672826141119, -0.017960842698812485, 0.027966221794486046, 0.031718093901872635, -0.02537814900279045, -0.008637840859591961, -0.03790056332945824, -0.024642542004585266, 0.007764211855828762, 0.013590008951723576, -0.03712692856788635, -0.003767599817365408, -0.01916913315653801, 0.016112562268972397, -0.013525190763175488, -0.008810590952634811, -0.0015720087103545666, -0.005712820217013359, 0.0017667134525254369, 0.023105306550860405, -0.023678148165345192, 0.0069373296573758125, 0.010707023553550243, -0.002975995885208249, -0.020770998671650887, -0.04525412991642952, -0.020237745717167854, 0.04952123388648033, 0.017081059515476227, -0.0376197025179863, -0.0017719055758789182, 0.023783192038536072, 0.012431902810931206, -0.048720914870500565, -0.038548003882169724, 0.025514774024486542, -0.000985560705885291, -0.05522773042321205, -0.025765350088477135, 0.0007429505349136889, 0.02100558392703533, -0.013532916083931923, 0.0372452475130558, 0.014074948616325855, -0.04894217103719711, -0.022363729774951935, -0.05831166356801987, 0.011372679844498634, -0.001596987247467041, -0.03128916025161743, 0.007238995749503374, -0.04809240251779556, -0.04159817099571228, -0.03135182708501816, 0.025408154353499413, 0.01012331061065197, 0.009402072057127953, -0.0268778745085001, 0.007674335967749357, -0.003999216482043266, -0.030309222638607025, 0.005873033311218023, -0.03468583524227142, -0.008952823467552662, -0.04353175684809685, 0.0258400347083807, 0.02352253533899784, 0.056361403316259384, -0.009050719439983368, 0.018876690417528152, -0.03780675306916237, 0.013095451518893242, 0.020328477025032043, -0.04237549379467964, -0.018674436956644058, -0.002827924909070134, -0.05657241865992546, 0.0046534049324691296, -0.020804274827241898, 0.04372444748878479, 0.01446070522069931, 0.028720693662762642, 0.00833717081695795, 0.008055273443460464, -0.01305569801479578, 0.03305738419294357, 0.009744120761752129, -0.02601596899330616, 0.016685782000422478, -0.01118605025112629, 0.01514784712344408, -0.02747511863708496, -0.008220949210226536, -0.027552364394068718, -0.029567720368504524, 0.03022056631743908, -0.015369163826107979, -0.02678835764527321, 0.03498002141714096, -0.001352923340164125, 0.01715298369526863, -0.01563115045428276, -0.026779236271977425, -0.044241487979888916, -0.008134801872074604, 0.0010542243253439665, -0.027926849201321602, 0.0071032061241567135, 0.005821744445711374, -0.017919987440109253, -0.02843455597758293, 0.06293953210115433, 0.010677876882255077, 0.0070064184255898, -0.003327956423163414, 0.006523796357214451, -0.03764974698424339, 0.0706915557384491, -0.006730712950229645, -0.05446904897689819, 0.004759299103170633, -0.07235286384820938, 0.0009539138991385698, 0.04060935229063034, -0.0061116814613342285, 0.04127073287963867, 0.023345835506916046, -0.010991480201482773, -0.0019939341582357883, 0.03098519891500473, -0.016442568972706795, -0.014546303078532219, -0.016469988971948624, 0.024319222196936607, -0.005554992705583572, 0.021660227328538895, 0.02762003056704998, 0.03455571085214615, -0.013450809754431248, 0.005834678653627634, 0.02952004410326481, 0.02245129644870758, -0.021647268906235695, 0.012872608378529549, 0.012735093012452126, -0.0023835257161408663, 0.010051545687019825, 0.0194499921053648, 0.029202021658420563, 0.06330548226833344, -0.00539004011079669, 0.025436965748667717, -0.027391629293560982, -0.005304928403347731, -0.08202255517244339, 0.004086397122591734, -0.008709798566997051, 0.010115224868059158, 0.030850891023874283, -0.021435851231217384, -0.005150341894477606, 0.026811538264155388, -0.026655416935682297, 0.03371343016624451, 0.038897931575775146, 0.003490293398499489, -0.0063508981838822365, 0.012572809122502804, 0.00884152390062809, 0.006502670235931873, 0.04929780215024948, -0.010859477333724499, 0.01711316406726837, -0.007041796576231718, -0.023479487746953964, -0.06871136277914047, -0.0004934194730594754, 0.025522038340568542, 0.01771445944905281, -0.06539158523082733, -0.0034663428086787462, -0.04281264543533325, -0.0016968488926067948, 0.022660359740257263, -0.024136438965797424, 0.039063889533281326, 0.028222860768437386, 0.008764545433223248, -0.016265060752630234, 0.052554160356521606, 0.023606030270457268, 0.0028142868541181087, 0.020924942567944527, 0.006932191085070372, -0.030793052166700363, 0.0069952053017914295, -0.02413441427052021, 0.01727369613945484, 0.02531968615949154, -0.002102791564539075, -0.0716758668422699, 0.04509034752845764, -0.010968009941279888, -0.030640622600913048, -0.0007954055909067392, 0.018694207072257996, -0.0412677638232708, -0.03693874180316925, 0.0111327413469553, -0.02260749228298664, -0.007711181417107582, 0.05807308107614517, 0.047399044036865234, 0.00642677117139101, 0.005598808638751507, 0.005393755156546831, -0.046821363270282745, 0.010359195061028004, -0.016720857471227646, -0.018861576914787292, -0.07270272076129913, -0.013405832462012768, -0.003797882702201605, -0.023273438215255737, -0.0028319195844233036, -0.02440689131617546, -0.04101133346557617, 0.010467595420777798, -0.023755650967359543, 0.0049560642801225185, 0.03195131942629814, -0.011572691611945629, 0.023080579936504364, -0.056582752615213394, 0.07051148265600204, 0.007784051820635796, -0.015073969960212708, -0.038928501307964325, -0.008978338912129402, -0.013813609257340431, -0.01287064142525196, 0.051669880747795105, 0.005805141758173704, -0.02988532930612564, -0.00993254128843546, 0.056546639651060104, -0.017152929678559303, -0.05194969102740288, 0.011509687639772892, -0.0009663336095400155, -0.016476361081004143, -0.04930375516414642, -0.01085754856467247, -0.003984741400927305, 0.024171022698283195, -0.006303726229816675, -0.024972455576062202, 0.0540054626762867, 0.0033614998683333397, -0.0022621273528784513, 0.00793951191008091, 0.020079420879483223, 0.01682714931666851, 0.05780065804719925, -0.03989400714635849, -0.0002941240672953427, 0.04343564435839653, 0.0018225410021841526, -0.0855700671672821, 0.035671416670084, -0.05883185192942619, -0.009282884187996387, 0.019454356282949448, 0.006834185216575861, 0.007905620150268078, -0.04820135235786438, 0.0035616334062069654, 0.020456966012716293, -0.029263971373438835, 0.01871448941528797, 0.06422535330057144, 0.05596774071455002, 0.004822360351681709, -0.019493039697408676, -0.023072760552167892, 0.004953615367412567, 0.008307546377182007, -0.0022032910492271185, 0.012420453131198883, 0.020132768899202347, 0.014047248288989067, 0.0354839526116848, 0.01289899367839098, -0.017062455415725708, 0.039409339427948, -0.0015605544904246926, 0.02237882651388645, -0.017019787803292274, 0.019378267228603363, -0.013058897107839584, -0.03193288668990135, 0.038036808371543884, 0.01361472811549902, -0.018235614523291588, 0.03552637994289398, -0.06290974467992783, -0.018120242282748222, -0.016829919070005417, -0.032507747411727905, -0.05010121315717697, 0.006493300199508667, 0.01348075456917286, 0.037391748279333115, 0.0202594343572855, 0.049880269914865494, 0.020794127136468887, -0.01573093980550766, 0.015005686320364475, -0.014187753200531006, 0.016609126701951027, 0.021445346996188164, -0.0022461540065705776, -0.043861180543899536, -0.0352763794362545, -0.05060024932026863, -0.03551569581031799, 0.012455505318939686, 0.01921251229941845, 0.011494871228933334, -0.008529393933713436, -0.005700983107089996, -0.031530626118183136, 0.04807727783918381, -0.052146732807159424, -0.024017566815018654, -0.06446857005357742, 0.017983073368668556, -0.010239300318062305, -0.03246378153562546 ]
<p>When should I use weights when performing a logistic regression? The weights I'm referring to are sampling weights from a survey? Or should I just use the unweighted data?</p>
74,378
[ -0.017167260870337486, -0.0174269936978817, -0.021795468404889107, -0.021196987479925156, 0.041414160281419754, 0.0015695897163823247, -0.009631023742258549, -0.026769068092107773, 0.03380252793431282, -0.017251979559659958, 0.006582639180123806, 0.06927821785211563, 0.020989811047911644, -0.0023993414361029863, 0.03606234863400459, 0.01874438486993313, 0.008068396709859371, 0.015190410427749157, -0.012722082436084747, 0.007707295473664999, 0.010616274550557137, 0.014946645125746727, 0.02677738107740879, 0.0018380270339548588, -0.0451427660882473, 0.04194965586066246, 0.03443505987524986, -0.03160054609179497, 0.032371122390031815, 0.05015784874558449, -0.027085857465863228, 0.004799294751137495, -0.007266534958034754, 0.048141881823539734, 0.02540844865143299, 0.003180722240358591, -0.03983588144183159, -0.00006138560274848714, -0.03655228763818741, 0.022942615672945976, -0.04303310438990593, -0.02163109928369522, 0.0216439887881279, -0.021732309833168983, -0.00688910111784935, 0.03775738924741745, -0.0010925402166321874, -0.042161185294389725, 0.010120066814124584, -0.04812496528029442, 0.04936793074011803, -0.008129284717142582, 0.010409594513475895, 0.03838478773832321, -0.009508042596280575, 0.00617692107334733, 0.05614837631583214, 0.04647066071629524, -0.01958552934229374, -0.029717886820435524, -0.019013524055480957, 0.001993792597204447, -0.005232039373368025, -0.023929178714752197, -0.013226965442299843, 0.03877134621143341, 0.02784670516848564, -0.014617187902331352, 0.07305953651666641, -0.001548275351524353, 0.00769371772184968, 0.019992321729660034, 0.03131231293082237, 0.007897418923676014, -0.015704482793807983, -0.04009963572025299, 0.004989972338080406, 0.03474128618836403, 0.06474745273590088, 0.01848676986992359, 0.0019872249104082584, 0.008419398218393326, 0.04501808434724808, 0.011370467953383923, 0.008895767852663994, -0.031200235709547997, 0.07884268462657928, 0.010662512853741646, 0.01398911140859127, 0.008992503397166729, -0.022848589345812798, -0.01787419058382511, 0.022684136405587196, -0.027067286893725395, 0.00032172311330214143, 0.015407712198793888, -0.03674723207950592, 0.025235189124941826, 0.015930315479636192, -0.00859253853559494, -0.00846144836395979, -0.05508290231227875, 0.01338931918144226, 0.04685571417212486, -0.022295944392681122, -0.010224651545286179, -0.0009450181969441473, -0.007316772360354662, 0.02966967225074768, -0.06848853826522827, -0.01908963732421398, -0.0090154018253088, 0.003622044576331973, -0.02434169501066208, 0.04064401239156723, -0.001444379799067974, 0.019975418224930763, -0.0014713848941028118, 0.01964721456170082, 0.0368364155292511, 0.026561515405774117, -0.040099550038576126, 0.028254298493266106, -0.031144879758358, -0.047306839376688004, 0.024420063942670822, 0.024868614971637726, -0.01119050569832325, -0.04855098947882652, 0.025611937046051025, -0.004072075244039297, -0.05397774651646614, 0.03668048977851868, 0.00896158441901207, -0.0029890642035752535, 0.032868314534425735, -0.07729627937078476, -0.060009971261024475, 0.004613282158970833, -0.039099838584661484, 0.009599745273590088, -0.024586841464042664, -0.011016585864126682, 0.032430004328489304, 0.02600305899977684, 0.04045947641134262, 0.040542297065258026, 0.01618899032473564, 0.04514139145612717, 0.006058961618691683, -0.006589104421436787, -0.012478725053369999, -0.0417865589261055, -0.023375295102596283, 0.016238197684288025, -0.08240058273077011, 0.009340598247945309, 0.026485081762075424, -0.01087215542793274, -0.04651014879345894, 0.014355343766510487, -0.013094712048768997, -0.020737847313284874, 0.0011121107963845134, 0.002872976241633296, -0.008888524025678635, 0.053780291229486465, -0.0031983593944460154, 0.05186821520328522, 0.02698110230267048, -0.0023806362878531218, 0.02095312811434269, 0.023342281579971313, 0.04514523595571518, 0.03796326369047165, 0.005317340604960918, 0.004938624799251556, -0.05495145916938782, 0.02450130507349968, 0.005532130133360624, -0.023738836869597435, -0.023251762613654137, 0.02466222271323204, -0.024746470153331757, 0.028116589412093163, 0.05303383246064186, 0.015760691836476326, -0.035328082740306854, 0.048396557569503784, -0.039017368108034134, -0.03361472487449646, -0.04270532354712486, 0.021105363965034485, -0.011636701412498951, 0.001334210392087698, 0.052785951644182205, -0.0006597347091883421, 0.03553461655974388, -0.017990484833717346, 0.002772805979475379, -0.026729295030236244, 0.016819432377815247, 0.027263419702649117, -0.06357628107070923, 0.010106907226145267, 0.052561793476343155, 0.036354970186948776, -0.012060126289725304, 0.05011427029967308, -0.05277127027511597, -0.05147016420960426, 0.011746468022465706, -0.006851685233414173, -0.013449573889374733, -0.02650841884315014, -0.006928859278559685, -0.01162145845592022, -0.005147704388946295, -0.04264890402555466, 0.03436163067817688, -0.07006910443305969, 0.1056884303689003, 0.07863043993711472, -0.03095661662518978, -0.024166276678442955, 0.025746233761310577, -0.0030726674012839794, 0.02908289059996605, -0.012095334008336067, -0.0027408248279243708, -0.050677742809057236, 0.012981366366147995, 0.0073500098660588264, -0.010752891190350056, -0.03864854946732521, 0.011968710459768772, 0.04884308576583862, 0.02046978287398815, 0.005715836305171251, 0.01113093737512827, -0.02620449848473072, -0.026610728353261948, 0.018515415489673615, 0.0020144397858530283, 0.01133369654417038, 0.01131361909210682, 0.0111545380204916, 0.014822653494775295, 0.034077081829309464, 0.010222429409623146, -0.00980215985327959, 0.05890418589115143, -0.01050901971757412, 0.009740296751260757, -0.0031933255959302187, -0.04548686370253563, 0.026620211079716682, -0.053697843104600906, 0.019690299406647682, 0.05192684009671211, 0.000502892246004194, 0.0025189027655869722, 0.025738408789038658, -0.017752045765519142, 0.0185080599039793, 0.04087112843990326, -0.03807942196726799, 0.03898407891392708, 0.028620868921279907, -0.04233533516526222, 0.022793279960751534, -0.008949382230639458, -0.05776321887969971, -0.013538052327930927, 0.011284752748906612, 0.0159742534160614, 0.0007599144009873271, -0.005246957764029503, -0.0005825081025250256, -0.07445497810840607, -0.011675096116960049, 0.0007370202802121639, -0.0266733281314373, 0.008544187061488628, -0.07889942079782486, -0.014835946261882782, -0.04636354744434357, -0.034060344099998474, 0.03903308883309364, -0.017801668494939804, 0.011689206585288048, 0.010379845276474953, 0.010146299377083778, -0.036106426268815994, -0.005457947961986065, -0.020483292639255524, 0.0002427887375233695, 0.00434705289080739, -0.0124474773183465, 0.05618106573820114, 0.011154514737427235, -0.048412393778562546, 0.0035676355473697186, -0.03998234495520592, -0.03293701261281967, -0.03850385174155235, -0.008302117697894573, 0.007540777325630188, -0.017860030755400658, 0.0033259796909987926, 0.007139663212001324, -0.04257809370756149, 0.0035760931205004454, -0.061093974858522415, -0.051211342215538025, 0.03074040822684765, -0.009246241301298141, 0.01752646639943123, 0.017142178490757942, -0.03346574679017067, 0.08415959030389786, 0.04516690969467163, -0.019095955416560173, -0.0154230035841465, -0.017033739015460014, -0.029355593025684357, 0.0046724583953619, 0.008159547112882137, -0.0014818960335105658, 0.008265861310064793, 0.008510274812579155, 0.00004948770219925791, 0.009415521286427975, 0.046742185950279236, 0.027814926579594612, 0.02381623163819313, 0.02324102632701397, 0.014316694810986519, -0.03205037862062454, 0.041436538100242615, 0.000357602461008355, -0.04997112974524498, 0.039067890495061874, 0.01089266873896122, 0.03854205459356308, -0.011740200221538544, -0.03556712344288826, 0.0057654064148664474, 0.004222930409014225, 0.02381105162203312, -0.026259182021021843, 0.04679814353585243, 0.009638012386858463, 0.002070767106488347, 0.009545881301164627, 0.017764095216989517, 0.02142699621617794, -0.03116541914641857, -0.010806344449520111, 0.02351045422255993, 0.049210481345653534, -0.021058252081274986, -0.006838700268417597, 0.011246929876506329, -0.024825548753142357, 0.046687569469213486, -0.029192019253969193, -0.002036510733887553, 0.02898303233087063, 0.052161943167448044, -0.008519411087036133, -0.026377325877547264, -0.06344947963953018, 0.009583340026438236, -0.0668419897556305, 0.0048222728073596954, 0.009510733187198639, 0.04795418307185173, -0.00828930176794529, 0.06192446127533913, 0.031023629009723663, -0.008999244309961796, 0.005319592542946339, 0.005896505434066057, -0.045733802020549774, 0.04155983030796051, 0.015760330483317375, 0.018677208572626114, 0.01601622998714447, -0.06026168912649155, -0.001474129967391491, -0.04402458667755127, 0.024732710793614388, -0.024862486869096756, -0.0012534712441265583, -0.006904236506670713, 0.005587608553469181, -0.0022144687827676535, 0.0032325880602002144, -0.01626167632639408, -0.0042173289693892, -0.001853241235949099, -0.0050441306084394455, 0.014709380455315113, 0.05285787209868431, 0.012871966697275639, -0.013947141356766224, -0.017530087381601334, 0.006421322468668222, 0.026908261701464653, 0.05866697058081627, 0.003112465376034379, -0.0043093366548419, -0.0440860390663147, 0.04627017676830292, 0.006175980903208256, 0.045399826020002365, 0.0012584520736709237, -0.0543026439845562, -0.029067598283290863, -0.02370261400938034, -0.04355742037296295, -0.005710653029382229, -0.004011095967143774, -0.03034374490380287, 0.008928606286644936, 0.07599058002233505, -0.005798586644232273, -0.05434148386120796, 0.0012914083199575543, 0.05236800014972687, 0.04648532718420029, -0.008955592289566994, -0.018585843965411186, 0.03739576041698456, -0.03395078331232071, -0.0014911552425473928, 0.029798706993460655, -0.0009258186328224838, 0.00931608211249113, 0.009614931419491768, 0.023009659722447395, -0.01793855056166649, -0.03189227730035782, 0.0023808800615370274, 0.03912350535392761, 0.036703940480947495, -0.002527943579480052, -0.08235502243041992, 0.053330760449171066, 0.05111642926931381, 0.049380335956811905, 0.023654388263821602, -0.0037856814451515675, -0.07896698266267776, -0.009145115502178669, 0.05561801791191101, 0.029514720663428307, -0.055890798568725586, -0.023186830803751945, 0.0016387810464948416, 0.01399767491966486, 0.015801921486854553, -0.0355277843773365, -0.005142493639141321, -0.037738654762506485, 0.03592553734779358, -0.011886462569236755, -0.035433754324913025, -0.024706179276108742, 0.04179966449737549, -0.02190830372273922, 0.01365804485976696, -0.004544069059193134, -0.021907111629843712, -0.020341793075203896, 0.03130704164505005, -0.006645982153713703, 0.08062660694122314, -0.03725213184952736, -0.019557178020477295, 0.020890144631266594, 0.03474495932459831, -0.011513283476233482, -0.038902025669813156, -0.040626853704452515, 0.010562032461166382, -0.0013065693201497197, 0.035599056631326675, 0.004230370279401541, -0.0695297122001648, 0.006333660800009966, 0.01504105981439352, -0.0013065080856904387, -0.00067318812943995, -0.043276626616716385, 0.020771311596035957, 0.0010050925193354487, 0.00548455398529768, 0.06580714881420135, 0.05355793982744217, -0.00564304506406188, -0.00937341246753931, -0.040359579026699066, 0.02496141381561756, -0.03637579083442688, -0.03170863911509514, -0.015932071954011917, 0.0004028113035019487, -0.017255999147892, 0.0074707320891320705, 0.017226804047822952, 0.02972983941435814, -0.0013500661589205265, -0.032579343765974045, -0.020954910665750504, 0.009337923489511013, 0.04040827602148056, 0.007504837587475777, 0.0015819895779713988, 0.011926991865038872, 0.006772960070520639, 0.0021433376241475344, 0.014149129390716553, -0.010644213296473026, 0.03213052824139595, 0.0008912445046007633, -0.04817303270101547, 0.00004547983917291276, -0.03665463626384735, -0.004873983096331358, 0.05549393594264984, -0.024117475375533104, 0.045461591333150864, 0.01728484220802784, 0.007247000467032194, -0.03165525943040848, -0.0869361162185669, -0.013819861225783825, 0.007227882277220488, 0.0015865322202444077, 0.04456247761845589, -0.050982169806957245, 0.03712112084031105, -0.004343122709542513, 0.01561423297971487, -0.0695859044790268, -0.03130171447992325, 0.015959376469254494, 0.019392432644963264, -0.020206844434142113, 0.006549006327986717, 0.0506393201649189, -0.007437624502927065, -0.03816959261894226, -0.03751131519675255, 0.09354802221059799, -0.0060304924845695496, -0.008549566380679607, -0.030238384380936623, 0.007913763634860516, 0.0727481096982956, 0.0128349419683218, -0.021798649802803993, 0.005842986050993204, -0.038797277957201004, 0.011868882924318314, -0.00015512722893618047, -0.011363397352397442, -0.027448633685708046, -0.014652904123067856, -0.0016969094285741448, -0.013658340089023113, 0.04211466759443283, -0.0039542424492537975, 0.00005655937275150791, 0.020216284319758415, -0.013465792872011662, -0.011154701001942158, 0.0068190922029316425, 0.015490230172872543, -0.04816995561122894, 0.023662514984607697, -0.03267873451113701, 0.0026799130719155073, -0.015452485531568527, 0.01661597192287445, 0.07241705805063248, 0.015761183574795723, 0.0029171020723879337, 0.023078806698322296, 0.06475260108709335, 0.014312454499304295, 0.009210530668497086, -0.04393846541643143, -0.036026693880558014, 0.04190995916724205, -0.004518021363765001, -0.0187271386384964, 0.04212285578250885, 0.0700279176235199, 0.005312283057719469, -0.020390870049595833, -0.051708683371543884, 0.008816936984658241, 0.07800235599279404, -0.004903135821223259, 0.06425438821315765, 0.06092563271522522, -0.011443030089139938, 0.024358149617910385, -0.028798850253224373, -0.022437242791056633, -0.02035236917436123, -0.027352314442396164, 0.027961235493421555, 0.012563319876790047, -0.005549485329538584, 0.022468049079179764, -0.03413064405322075, 0.032750509679317474, 0.004516583867371082, 0.022437430918216705, 0.03400615230202675, 0.00459651742130518, -0.02639111876487732, -0.04709663242101669, 0.0026394387241452932, -0.045389413833618164, 0.012592446058988571, -0.01585131697356701, -0.05466226860880852, 0.05180982127785683, 0.004240207374095917, 0.01483940239995718, -0.04169680178165436, -0.024325791746377945, -0.03233668580651283, -0.0011394150787964463, -0.013456273823976517, -0.013315453194081783, 0.03056773543357849, 0.0211854949593544, 0.010511556640267372, -0.013313169591128826, -0.0034227301366627216, -0.022081362083554268, -0.10073236376047134, -0.05700685456395149, -0.012514143250882626, -0.046806931495666504, -0.006436771247535944, 0.006828256417065859, -0.021595599129796028, 0.016958648338913918, -0.03248739242553711, -0.00010388596274424344, 0.011233470402657986, 0.017970824614167213, -0.029645666480064392, 0.06257755309343338, -0.009421512484550476, -0.012892799451947212, -0.0012332313926890492, -0.015179157257080078, 0.11565576493740082, 0.07365214824676514, 0.054522156715393066, -0.08759478479623795, 0.03750038892030716, 0.002727267798036337, 0.004793351050466299, 0.0037346493918448687, -0.013541119173169136, -0.000553560967091471, 0.015366500243544579, 0.03572602942585945, 0.0017618064302951097, -0.009620933793485165, 0.005802826955914497, 0.06751476973295212, -0.04033885896205902, -0.003316251328215003, 0.023593680933117867, 0.004975428339093924, -0.008360486477613449, -0.019433574751019478, -0.044568225741386414, 0.02579372189939022, 0.015572327189147472, -0.026970455422997475, 0.014635374769568443, -0.020804155617952347, -0.01108343806117773, -0.016320133581757545, 0.021912263706326485, 0.0011403091484680772, 0.01408352144062519, 0.005997281055897474, -0.023827211931347847, -0.0014741942286491394, 0.012069187127053738, -0.06336955726146698, -0.011127755977213383, 0.011252016760408878, -0.03840487822890282, -0.004021947737783194, -0.03657550737261772, 0.01947442814707756, -0.041474319994449615, -0.009179077111184597, -0.04133325442671776, 0.004110535606741905, 0.0013748673954978585, 0.012102550826966763, 0.03372582048177719, 0.023296808823943138, 0.010570003651082516, -0.04949641227722168, -0.005613510496914387, 0.03387315571308136, 0.030523743480443954, -0.03063037246465683, -0.03332221880555153, -0.02297629788517952, 0.010936785489320755, 0.02982366643846035, 0.05503573268651962, 0.05497527867555618, -0.04838021844625473, -0.00914805568754673, -0.018282290548086166, -0.004832009319216013, -0.009085554629564285, 0.024592524394392967, 0.027143919840455055, -0.013293106108903885, -0.04400593042373657, -0.02609645575284958, 0.009650478139519691, -0.006138316821306944, 0.04610387235879898, -0.025043554604053497, -0.01794550195336342, -0.05078883096575737, -0.06457563489675522, 0.01043720357120037, -0.02065933495759964, -0.011194955557584763, -0.06751443445682526, 0.0265022162348032, 0.016695117577910423, 0.016013778746128082, 0.04495442658662796, 0.016340719535946846, -0.006570226978510618, 0.03399694710969925, -0.03259638696908951, -0.06248884275555611, 0.035088956356048584, 0.01169019378721714, -0.04355774447321892, 0.006372467149049044, 0.0017454613698646426, 0.04507656767964363, 0.021367762237787247, 0.012448280118405819, -0.021468251943588257, 0.025315267965197563, 0.0014868658035993576, 0.012999718077480793, -0.0013926532119512558, -0.059831518679857254, -0.013954145833849907, 0.022018317133188248, -0.0022193824406713247, -0.03319717198610306, -0.015360000543296337, -0.06034933030605316, -0.0752222016453743, 0.02229280024766922, -0.01159190759062767, -0.04688756912946701, 0.031742241233587265, -0.00849461555480957, 0.043942201882600784, -0.00890758540481329, -0.014045669697225094, -0.03154386579990387, -0.004834361374378204, -0.021157067269086838, -0.03520236536860466, 0.005875673610717058, -0.013550474308431149, -0.0008963950676843524, 0.003838535165414214, 0.053903937339782715, -0.009560438804328442, 0.035463422536849976, 0.028733622282743454, 0.029570845887064934, -0.01611200161278248, 0.019670087844133377, -0.00909805204719305, -0.01211807131767273, 0.03816383704543114, 0.00638041365891695, 0.012411382980644703, 0.031232764944434166, -0.026484837755560875, 0.024267351254820824, 0.0356316938996315, -0.0060816435143351555, -0.009692192077636719, 0.023099958896636963, -0.042021993547677994, -0.015402143821120262, -0.03737518563866615, 0.007726441137492657, 0.0036891927011311054, 0.019289130344986916, -0.000984684331342578, 0.01904415898025036, 0.011019044555723667, 0.002913274336606264, 0.04158791899681091, -0.009676553308963776, -0.009633418172597885, 0.00851990096271038, 0.03237165883183479, 0.04919135570526123, 0.011485819704830647, -0.021356767043471336, 0.021734891459345818, 0.0378551185131073, -0.011049481108784676, 0.030642066150903702, -0.019562216475605965, -0.003465961432084441, -0.07495436817407608, -0.04649856686592102, 0.030522160232067108, -0.026529954746365547, 0.02078193984925747, -0.04723961651325226, 0.002837963169440627, 0.014666038565337658, -0.021382510662078857, 0.0295381061732769, 0.023966791108250618, -0.018959946930408478, -0.0008773353765718639, 0.026542842388153076, 0.0006873661768622696, 0.007541768718510866, 0.0027186020743101835, -0.0012119986349716783, -0.019553152844309807, 0.02953273616731167, 0.028272222727537155, -0.01925645023584366, 0.009860220365226269, 0.021652162075042725, 0.0015769134042784572, -0.052623201161623, 0.03532721847295761, -0.02513478696346283, -0.016054917126893997, 0.06519156694412231, 0.03183361142873764, 0.01926889456808567, 0.03800049051642418, 0.047297362238168716, 0.004415964707732201, 0.036109793931245804, 0.0491558238863945, -0.0026629699859768152, -0.03216608986258507, 0.012370062060654163, 0.02493286319077015, 0.0367620624601841, -0.03323091194033623, 0.04669316112995148, 0.00557540450245142, -0.004433145746588707, -0.0387946255505085, 0.025956137105822563, -0.024303898215293884, -0.00864324253052473, -0.020240100100636482, -0.031134720891714096, -0.016828779131174088, -0.030062485486268997, 0.029508139938116074, -0.04694901406764984, 0.03434072434902191, 0.04505782946944237, -0.019114093855023384, -0.04347488284111023, 0.0363607332110405, 0.00531173637136817, -0.05213160440325737, 0.008716749027371407, -0.017409905791282654, -0.02896104007959366, -0.043668925762176514, 0.03427775949239731, 0.030775118619203568, -0.01681663654744625, -0.05645148083567619, 0.018494144082069397, -0.06600487232208252, 0.03932558000087738, -0.03829120099544525, -0.01525811292231083, 0.03201941028237343, -0.033469878137111664, 0.029157957062125206, -0.08759279549121857, 0.08463944494724274, -0.0003813568619079888, -0.021761761978268623, -0.04814894124865532, -0.027555925771594048, -0.003679591231048107, 0.031475625932216644, 0.07160604745149612, 0.008999228477478027, -0.004645404871553183, -0.009649294428527355, 0.021591929718852043, -0.01925509050488472, 0.0028748842887580395, 0.02118794433772564, -0.006762890610843897, -0.039024002850055695, -0.026825586333870888, -0.004598613362759352, 0.00039240982732735574, 0.022451061755418777, 0.00999327190220356, -0.02208910882472992, 0.03543178364634514, 0.014808440580964088, 0.045756954699754715, 0.061869386583566666, 0.013948526233434677, 0.022514240816235542, 0.033849481493234634, -0.00030405845609493554, 0.022765010595321655, 0.035939306020736694, -0.02686488628387451, -0.08690071851015091, 0.03130461648106575, -0.019047824665904045, -0.030286110937595367, 0.025766396895051003, 0.012978928163647652, 0.0026248868089169264, -0.04972914233803749, -0.0011863253312185407, 0.029732709750533104, -0.03277480602264404, 0.010707647539675236, 0.01488427072763443, 0.029750006273388863, 0.01535851787775755, -0.000048002537369029596, 0.020747456699609756, -0.010734335519373417, -0.042999763041734695, -0.0046311672776937485, 0.019369956105947495, 0.03644735366106033, -0.001312882057391107, 0.008069291710853577, -0.0007077127229422331, 0.01031072624027729, 0.046246740967035294, 0.011570567265152931, 0.0606476292014122, -0.051953282207250595, -0.03126555681228638, -0.021137936040759087, 0.0004373340925667435, 0.024391192942857742, 0.010415579192340374, -0.015200750902295113, 0.05074191465973854, -0.026147443801164627, 0.007480999920517206, -0.026716502383351326, -0.04667684808373451, -0.034274786710739136, -0.039017513394355774, 0.02863123081624508, 0.04688464105129242, 0.008263139985501766, 0.005563793703913689, 0.006272588856518269, -0.032170336693525314, 0.0008565139723941684, 0.0063943336717784405, 0.04788921773433685, -0.01696017198264599, 0.019041497260332108, -0.049785513430833817, -0.03385289013385773, -0.017564447596669197, 0.0010098251514136791, -0.00795054528862238, 0.03353038430213928, 0.02478829398751259, -0.010376951657235622, -0.006200170144438744, -0.002071069786325097, 0.009207982569932938, -0.059255894273519516, -0.0018191405106335878, -0.039379097521305084, 0.002798088826239109, 0.027556035667657852, -0.027031993493437767 ]
<p>It is clear to me, and well explained on multiple sites, what information the values on the diagonal of the hat matrix give for linear regression.</p> <p>The hat matrix of a logistic regression model is less clear to me. Is it identical to the information you get out of the hat matrix applying linear regression? This is the definition of the hat matrix I found on another topic of CV (source 1):</p> <p>$H=VX ( X'V X)^-1 X' V$</p> <p>with X the vector of predictor variables and V is a diagonal matrix with $\sqrt{(π(1−π))}$.</p> <p>Is it, in other words, also true that the particular value of the hat matrix of an observation also just presents the position of the covariates in the covariate space, and has nothing to do with the outcome value of that observation?</p> <p>This is written in the book "Categorical data analysis" of Agresti:</p> <blockquote> <p>The greater an observation’s lever- age, the greater its potential influence on the fit. As in ordinary regression, the leverages fall between 0 and 1 and sum to the number of model parameters. Unlike ordinary regression, the hat values depend on the fit as well as the model matrix, and points that have extreme predictor values need not have high leverage.</p> </blockquote> <p>So out of this definition, it seems we can not use it as we use it in ordinary linear regression?</p> <p>Source 1: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/8126/how-to-calculate-the-hat-matrix-for-logistic-regression-in-r">How to calculate the hat matrix for logistic regression in R?</a></p>
74,379
[ -0.033961936831474304, 0.00037614896427839994, 0.0015907594934105873, -0.02677236683666706, 0.021872825920581818, -0.021392926573753357, -0.040760189294815063, 0.002689226297661662, 0.045465774834156036, -0.04231909662485123, 0.0006614300073124468, 0.061841677874326706, 0.03400402143597603, 0.02309522219002247, 0.018180102109909058, 0.024507654830813408, 0.0030261659994721413, 0.0055333087220788, -0.0028772950172424316, 0.01966816559433937, 0.01623511128127575, 0.05889246612787247, 0.02435813844203949, 0.014349754899740219, -0.014090187847614288, 0.05841852352023125, 0.04337671771645546, -0.016067642718553543, -0.014552932232618332, 0.03454092517495155, -0.02187994495034218, -0.020820220932364464, 0.0385279580950737, 0.045793868601322174, 0.005948799196630716, -0.01592947542667389, 0.003064265474677086, -0.024901220574975014, 0.021301792934536934, 0.04594295099377632, -0.032088298350572586, -0.04561299830675125, -0.01739770732820034, 0.06767409294843674, -0.01269230805337429, 0.0134122334420681, -0.02479754574596882, -0.029689772054553032, 0.029122808948159218, -0.028865551576018333, 0.0682540312409401, 0.00897227693349123, 0.024870356544852257, 0.035702623426914215, -0.03258587419986725, 0.017263274639844894, 0.04610063508152962, 0.06334085762500763, -0.005520763341337442, -0.06969811022281647, -0.029091237112879753, -0.05375975742936134, -0.0022597021888941526, -0.00837626215070486, -0.011919236741960049, 0.04598213732242584, 0.021113505586981773, -0.03699977323412895, 0.03276461735367775, -0.037758853286504745, 0.0048488955944776535, -0.004202785901725292, 0.010331657715141773, 0.01743042841553688, 0.03255414217710495, -0.04062918946146965, -0.0133352754637599, 0.015654508024454117, 0.06118703633546829, 0.034693244844675064, 0.03704066574573517, -0.016640091314911842, 0.04542572796344757, 0.04695665091276169, 0.01678348146378994, -0.0022166601847857237, 0.069291852414608, -0.03212624415755272, 0.04385688528418541, 0.03580356389284134, -0.013642788864672184, 0.02785043977200985, 0.011725935153663158, -0.02419128268957138, -0.043434787541627884, 0.024813329800963402, -0.019305285066366196, 0.04673604294657707, 0.030761463567614555, 0.0015208966797217727, -0.0006275962805375457, -0.03520006313920021, 0.0036286618560552597, 0.04143199697136879, 0.017515694722533226, 0.007316263392567635, -0.031079532578587532, -0.0017761356430128217, 0.002610581461340189, -0.07588411867618561, -0.04655640572309494, 0.04590825363993645, -0.014329610392451286, 0.0007980117807164788, -0.0012465170584619045, -0.05360906571149826, 0.011365029029548168, -0.013995873741805553, 0.04738975316286087, 0.04803221672773361, 0.01687113381922245, -0.02907317690551281, 0.0019770620856434107, -0.04525063931941986, -0.05772728845477104, 0.045869454741477966, 0.02378958836197853, 0.0008673390257172287, -0.03270581737160683, 0.025240587070584297, 0.01315443217754364, -0.0360739603638649, 0.04065466672182083, 0.01572922058403492, -0.01933418959379196, 0.007575415540486574, -0.08829217404127121, -0.03516075015068054, 0.018647022545337677, 0.012562653981149197, -0.005033591762185097, -0.0691692903637886, 0.016672441735863686, 0.029286283999681473, 0.02231680415570736, 0.0064210062846541405, 0.037117354571819305, 0.022994888946413994, 0.023753611370921135, 0.010019243694841862, -0.04183128476142883, 0.002573290141299367, -0.035528577864170074, -0.04285271465778351, -0.04585431516170502, -0.06861162930727005, 0.030865395441651344, 0.03628816455602646, 0.017831550911068916, 0.004634372424334288, 0.04627075418829918, 0.007889880798757076, -0.019924214109778404, 0.015354158356785774, -0.009577258490025997, -0.013464624062180519, 0.04454599320888519, -0.012061373330652714, 0.033960405737161636, 0.04517646133899689, -0.004437621682882309, 0.026900755241513252, 0.020474741235375404, 0.060344330966472626, 0.030956687405705452, -0.0021625624503940344, -0.00025352754164487123, -0.01591372676193714, 0.0006587071111425757, -0.010406495071947575, -0.07626327127218246, -0.056772902607917786, -0.026109181344509125, 0.0000529386852576863, 0.023469943553209305, 0.036422789096832275, -0.029676994308829308, -0.015459194779396057, 0.036623045802116394, -0.036015965044498444, -0.05483400076627731, -0.05784415826201439, 0.015266737900674343, -0.01690570078790188, -0.00884292647242546, 0.026603244245052338, -0.0004775135894306004, 0.027936996892094612, -0.008189822547137737, -0.012827415950596333, -0.020751651376485825, 0.0015763728879392147, 0.05769149586558342, -0.03414157032966614, -0.0030514749232679605, 0.03954758122563362, 0.03519823029637337, -0.006609329022467136, 0.025603100657463074, -0.05471132695674896, -0.05875546857714653, 0.03362943232059479, -0.004208505619317293, 0.01926903985440731, -0.017293719574809074, 0.005726286675781012, 0.01029979158192873, -0.02072541043162346, -0.01822510175406933, 0.038048338145017624, -0.05630049481987953, 0.07254575192928314, 0.059844326227903366, 0.022162070497870445, 0.006646983791142702, 0.032347023487091064, 0.007872366346418858, 0.011011959984898567, -0.020082976669073105, 0.005668697413057089, -0.04930345341563225, -0.017595520243048668, 0.029078306630253792, 0.028692375868558884, -0.018223974853754044, 0.024129638448357582, 0.04552292823791504, 0.026881959289312363, 0.0022475493606179953, -0.012357480823993683, -0.012045666575431824, -0.0037833184469491243, -0.031695276498794556, 0.00018430480849929154, -0.014884836040437222, -0.011264506727457047, 0.005754390731453896, 0.015988457947969437, 0.060021281242370605, 0.029445957392454147, -0.020797519013285637, 0.08298952132463455, -0.04275860637426376, -0.04210234805941582, -0.025084808468818665, 0.004862265661358833, 0.052846334874629974, -0.030355002731084824, 0.010522414930164814, 0.03650704771280289, 0.007161857560276985, -0.0034680801909416914, -0.015181372873485088, -0.0030199713073670864, 0.03301743417978287, 0.056784968823194504, -0.050972044467926025, 0.008533162996172905, 0.0015788215678185225, -0.05404287576675415, 0.046174053102731705, -0.03314287215471268, -0.04869892820715904, -0.0030183836352080107, 0.0136031499132514, 0.03361603617668152, 0.000462341500679031, 0.024276599287986755, -0.02726973034441471, -0.03625108301639557, -0.01214220654219389, -0.024169504642486572, -0.00017559260595589876, 0.006674343254417181, -0.03804248571395874, -0.04004007950425148, -0.07958239316940308, -0.026029076427221298, 0.03574938699603081, -0.01661721244454384, -0.024441255256533623, -0.02578938938677311, 0.000020814255549339578, -0.057088591158390045, -0.04220953583717346, 0.001215252559632063, 0.023671766743063927, -0.040960513055324554, -0.04205428063869476, 0.017508702352643013, 0.0168936625123024, -0.03992047533392906, 0.03996147960424423, -0.002618688391521573, -0.05434644967317581, -0.004044858273118734, -0.028781713917851448, 0.029299624264240265, 0.0055123730562627316, 0.018645217642188072, 0.03138243034482002, -0.005727032665163279, -0.00044357634033076465, -0.07963284850120544, -0.05067235231399536, 0.03899364545941353, 0.014389736577868462, 0.03679870814085007, 0.007984685711562634, -0.004648467060178518, 0.07412757724523544, 0.018244564533233643, 0.012004176154732704, -0.07470095902681351, 0.0013439746107906103, -0.023776056244969368, -0.006061546504497528, 0.0005946257733739913, 0.01980450190603733, 0.045361943542957306, 0.02864605374634266, -0.017695320770144463, 0.009986295364797115, 0.042327627539634705, -0.008907776325941086, 0.00010444717190694064, 0.019862692803144455, -0.009291633032262325, -0.03590606898069382, 0.02085261046886444, 0.022017212584614754, 0.009682957082986832, 0.013159959577023983, 0.03335035219788551, 0.03731325641274452, -0.02623305469751358, -0.04711709916591644, 0.02165614441037178, -0.02791924588382244, 0.0012618738692253828, 0.008602404966950417, 0.005689694080501795, -0.0029478734359145164, -0.007256095763295889, -0.012555751018226147, 0.04309403523802757, 0.0267029982060194, -0.045627519488334656, 0.012020944617688656, 0.043437108397483826, 0.012899933382868767, -0.000500334077514708, 0.021001018583774567, 0.00880832877010107, -0.0019655621144920588, 0.026402072980999947, -0.06059761345386505, -0.013546762987971306, 0.03612042963504791, 0.04879740625619888, -0.016417156904935837, -0.01109938696026802, -0.05291975662112236, 0.03798181563615799, -0.04316943883895874, 0.022785920649766922, -0.009209135547280312, 0.035528071224689484, -0.011350084096193314, 0.02596343867480755, 0.027339251711964607, -0.011311677284538746, 0.028302481397986412, 0.014390695840120316, -0.06060929596424103, -0.027843937277793884, -0.011026158928871155, -0.009483872912824154, 0.003968589473515749, -0.03713289648294449, 0.0461970791220665, 0.010694555006921291, 0.004058123100548983, 0.017644695937633514, 0.01484485249966383, -0.005970063153654337, 0.03646361082792282, -0.004086134023964405, -0.02018672600388527, -0.024797312915325165, -0.021350380033254623, 0.06826797872781754, -0.017141394317150116, 0.01628882810473442, 0.07373850792646408, 0.002923376625403762, 0.038400325924158096, -0.009215498343110085, 0.029627740383148193, 0.042159631848335266, 0.0481547974050045, 0.03378214314579964, -0.022012079134583473, -0.023702917620539665, 0.014486991800367832, -0.009259392507374287, 0.04682360962033272, 0.038704294711351395, -0.03312242776155472, 0.012770859524607658, -0.028616059571504593, 0.0021434330847114325, -0.019995905458927155, -0.010550028644502163, -0.01351515855640173, 0.02376946061849594, 0.10369910299777985, 0.019829481840133667, -0.022960178554058075, 0.03306218981742859, 0.05365707725286484, 0.039576657116413116, -0.001876315101981163, -0.039679814130067825, 0.013274512253701687, -0.02285579778254032, -0.009159114211797714, 0.008624612353742123, 0.0038547092117369175, -0.017768606543540955, -0.013888086192309856, 0.03564539551734924, -0.005924532655626535, -0.024430682882666588, -0.020152205601334572, 0.031248988583683968, 0.042236894369125366, -0.047041721642017365, -0.02147846668958664, 0.015219616703689098, 0.05784694850444794, 0.02743743732571602, 0.0309514869004488, 0.0016137113561853766, -0.09023408591747284, 0.001233528251759708, 0.015451543033123016, 0.05364213138818741, -0.048020485788583755, -0.019360339269042015, -0.04470013454556465, 0.017429644241929054, 0.060518570244312286, -0.0450398325920105, 0.028989538550376892, -0.022548379376530647, 0.0011973315849900246, -0.05724942311644554, -0.02867399901151657, -0.06034543737769127, 0.029011119157075882, -0.01115008071064949, 0.012621157802641392, -0.006866643205285072, -0.02434263564646244, -0.0227439533919096, 0.023216724395751953, 0.010874466970562935, 0.05434942618012428, 0.0009830920025706291, -0.018283139914274216, 0.01403256319463253, 0.03098410554230213, -0.01745394617319107, -0.09267695248126984, 0.0006386557943187654, 0.027578789740800858, -0.03203786164522171, 0.027598999440670013, -0.02064279466867447, -0.021775566041469574, 0.006441046949476004, 0.024576609954237938, -0.0007439898326992989, 0.01154953520745039, -0.015620318241417408, 0.054794345051050186, -0.002439383650198579, -0.013417832553386688, 0.06509408354759216, 0.033119142055511475, 0.016378095373511314, 0.01832936331629753, -0.033216893672943115, 0.0035319135058671236, -0.0013383354526013136, -0.06748642772436142, -0.04489105939865112, -0.01570293866097927, -0.02737068198621273, 0.03201926127076149, 0.03271719440817833, 0.040263671427965164, -0.003701492678374052, -0.021942568942904472, -0.0029571938794106245, 0.03924742713570595, -0.012358742766082287, -0.0018609310500323772, 0.006005886010825634, 0.025267742574214935, 0.013927370309829712, -0.002829509787261486, 0.0033411115873605013, -0.011852676048874855, 0.03573478013277054, 0.007477437611669302, -0.05638057738542557, -0.011418629437685013, -0.011476879939436913, 0.009000333026051521, 0.027639994397759438, -0.019460003823041916, 0.03414453566074371, -0.025553084909915924, 0.024042196571826935, -0.005768498871475458, -0.05434458330273628, -0.02602306567132473, 0.0009195382590405643, -0.025618424639105797, 0.05349160358309746, -0.00709375599399209, -0.01288578286767006, -0.011831356212496758, -0.016176823526620865, -0.025354309007525444, -0.008004015311598778, -0.013179981149733067, 0.007093943655490875, -0.027149241417646408, -0.004833766724914312, 0.01025222335010767, -0.01853073574602604, -0.022178178653120995, -0.019327951595187187, 0.07093438506126404, -0.014185161329805851, 0.0007949121063575149, -0.030419107526540756, 0.0263665821403265, 0.06635971367359161, -0.014495406299829483, 0.001335331704467535, 0.0018836760427802801, 0.011156698688864708, -0.0066090659238398075, 0.035222526639699936, 0.010984629392623901, -0.0098277498036623, -0.017538895830512047, -0.029068881645798683, -0.0007157521322369576, 0.030387913808226585, 0.0060353875160217285, -0.023389799520373344, -0.0033971841912716627, -0.02506929822266102, 0.023085400462150574, -0.03529421612620354, -0.0001035712703014724, -0.020961320027709007, 0.009821735322475433, 0.0014008483849465847, 0.015985403209924698, -0.010328804142773151, -0.016321750357747078, 0.02884175255894661, -0.021212376654148102, -0.009645565412938595, 0.00931077916175127, 0.047914598137140274, 0.02520141750574112, 0.06594356894493103, -0.02476814016699791, -0.03223612904548645, 0.054564498364925385, 0.045986101031303406, -0.010264748707413673, 0.03162325546145439, 0.02379300631582737, -0.016473066061735153, -0.04138055816292763, -0.06318458914756775, 0.03990625590085983, 0.03766858950257301, 0.0072935037314891815, 0.010381722822785378, 0.030771881341934204, -0.009456071071326733, -0.02660680003464222, -0.022419398650527, -0.0041290391236543655, -0.01933508925139904, -0.008820033632218838, 0.044781602919101715, -0.03375660628080368, -0.0028786282055079937, 0.05466272309422493, 0.01923753134906292, 0.005027075298130512, 0.00038653527735732496, 0.02070184424519539, 0.02993117645382881, 0.024813212454319, -0.030566558241844177, -0.019610201939940453, 0.0346599780023098, -0.029419267550110817, -0.02269075997173786, -0.027268128469586372, -0.032376572489738464, 0.026523802429437637, 0.013497861102223396, 0.02633749321103096, -0.05557163059711456, -0.03902716934680939, -0.03456588461995125, 0.02151854708790779, 0.0169205404818058, -0.02454984188079834, 0.010676246136426926, 0.005876933690160513, 0.010511253960430622, -0.001905306475237012, 0.02127050794661045, -0.038228586316108704, -0.08068244904279709, -0.04464530944824219, -0.021085722371935844, -0.010710770264267921, 0.002249086042866111, 0.024251600727438927, -0.0542345754802227, 0.02443419024348259, -0.07541471719741821, -0.024679681286215782, 0.004744960926473141, 0.028454648330807686, -0.0007501046056859195, 0.09257172793149948, 0.0073321363888680935, -0.02275315299630165, -0.007490043994039297, -0.007642962038516998, 0.11555720865726471, 0.09569965302944183, 0.025834880769252777, -0.046989958733320236, 0.005715124309062958, 0.010983474552631378, 0.021058600395917892, -0.03447398543357849, -0.02501487545669079, -0.012689592316746712, -0.022681014612317085, 0.05030997842550278, 0.028893951326608658, 0.02188504859805107, 0.023379068821668625, 0.03571157529950142, -0.06847827136516571, 0.005948513746261597, 0.006346793845295906, -0.006216668989509344, -0.007157169282436371, 0.01604204624891281, -0.027310894802212715, 0.024063074961304665, 0.018784983083605766, -0.000431488617323339, 0.0047312513925135136, 0.004298952408134937, -0.02073914185166359, -0.031014135107398033, -0.026442741975188255, -0.0015216321917250752, 0.0177196953445673, 0.024468913674354553, -0.010471529327332973, 0.029285216704010963, -0.020810851827263832, -0.0009056160924956203, 0.011494195088744164, -0.0027353500481694937, -0.01842857524752617, 0.0019371757516637444, 0.018379392102360725, 0.024585802108049393, -0.03264681249856949, -0.03379266336560249, -0.03836978226900101, 0.06229521334171295, -0.022553063929080963, -0.013109787367284298, -0.005790776573121548, -0.02246904745697975, 0.005735263228416443, -0.05367129296064377, -0.003103142837062478, 0.02806881070137024, 0.04843137413263321, -0.04264315590262413, -0.03452695906162262, -0.05855761468410492, -0.004527951590716839, 0.015069038607180119, 0.053944382816553116, -0.011774919927120209, -0.038572635501623154, -0.009690082632005215, -0.05180171877145767, 0.054453104734420776, 0.02147914096713066, -0.015724467113614082, 0.031645890325307846, -0.012204739265143871, -0.05445890873670578, -0.0382145494222641, 0.012953205034136772, -0.01787206158041954, 0.03114176355302334, -0.01987871713936329, 0.013674836605787277, -0.027091605588793755, -0.06196221336722374, 0.006865394301712513, -0.021574240177869797, -0.022052081301808357, -0.025969846174120903, 0.0069403331726789474, 0.03790752962231636, 0.04315786063671112, -0.011911965906620026, 0.0111079728230834, -0.02478681690990925, 0.035038840025663376, -0.022068792954087257, -0.04693243280053139, -0.019819939509034157, 0.026338335126638412, -0.01842263713479042, -0.02666521444916725, -0.017776329070329666, 0.05123405531048775, 0.0420369952917099, -0.0002697276941034943, -0.015238450840115547, 0.03960346430540085, -0.010987766087055206, -0.009270512498915195, 0.021284380927681923, -0.013825441710650921, 0.02333194389939308, 0.014496996998786926, -0.001169865601696074, -0.01805221661925316, -0.02894412726163864, -0.07974060624837875, -0.052076056599617004, -0.024649227038025856, -0.013615347445011139, -0.033670976758003235, 0.006442941725254059, -0.023081380873918533, 0.024855460971593857, -0.03012256510555744, -0.01826012320816517, -0.05223608762025833, 0.020761819556355476, -0.008797448128461838, -0.05417998135089874, 0.025753673166036606, 0.020903678610920906, -0.02028418332338333, 0.005699948873370886, 0.025647925212979317, 0.0341876819729805, 0.017067009583115578, -0.00863594003021717, -0.02562367543578148, 0.02402624301612377, 0.0366450771689415, -0.031816545873880386, -0.06019427254796028, 0.022912904620170593, 0.004539974499493837, -0.01727166585624218, 0.026541033759713173, 0.001759447273798287, 0.030725765973329544, 0.0255564134567976, 0.019168853759765625, 0.000422346725827083, 0.023436248302459717, -0.002666439861059189, -0.0015594841679558158, -0.02282514050602913, -0.029643837362527847, -0.01777902990579605, 0.008376572281122208, 0.011766535229980946, 0.006680910475552082, 0.011239508166909218, 0.02406364120543003, 0.04992898926138878, 0.008050497621297836, -0.0005355211906135082, 0.025606533512473106, 0.012366579845547676, 0.03195587918162346, 0.0153826167806983, -0.00331194419413805, 0.055307287722826004, 0.04693250358104706, -0.04027486592531204, 0.048405762761831284, 0.025715894997119904, 0.04687463492155075, -0.10241082310676575, -0.03768913447856903, 0.001984887756407261, 0.03109169937670231, 0.03206079080700874, -0.07628297060728073, -0.025956299155950546, 0.026111263781785965, -0.048235729336738586, 0.05204951390624046, 0.009966423735022545, -0.0023381412029266357, -0.004888675641268492, 0.017818931490182877, 0.007965678349137306, 0.03481493517756462, 0.022789010778069496, -0.007544113788753748, 0.008711468428373337, 0.02448020689189434, 0.02557225525379181, -0.04040291905403137, 0.0005240963655523956, 0.02517031505703926, 0.003632242325693369, -0.05707063525915146, 0.049892354756593704, -0.00023270495876204222, -0.035842735320329666, 0.021486597135663033, 0.011079411953687668, 0.01572023704648018, 0.06446318328380585, 0.009440102614462376, 0.01458528358489275, 0.02654774859547615, 0.04727602005004883, 0.011238602921366692, -0.012033016420900822, -0.013039780780673027, 0.0048286826349794865, 0.027895702049136162, 0.0010247379541397095, 0.019994286820292473, -0.007230956573039293, -0.01503368467092514, -0.022504087537527084, -0.029063165187835693, -0.03358311578631401, -0.008067172951996326, 0.00010302149166818708, -0.00889119878411293, -0.0327933169901371, -0.03298725187778473, 0.0477878674864769, -0.0563071183860302, -0.01800205372273922, 0.03817465156316757, 0.014292269013822079, -0.03162086009979248, 0.02171885222196579, -0.03182876110076904, -0.011595584452152252, -0.003582891309633851, 0.01762731559574604, -0.03180902823805809, -0.09002288430929184, 0.004227085039019585, -0.004012675955891609, -0.016589242964982986, -0.03018866293132305, 0.012360622175037861, -0.09148187190294266, 0.04646427184343338, -0.014169924892485142, -0.010821339674293995, 0.015415968373417854, -0.0046920799650251865, 0.01365929376333952, -0.08413317054510117, 0.06347484886646271, 0.016981789842247963, -0.027353016659617424, -0.03673594444990158, 0.011913410387933254, -0.007307372521609068, 0.006401351653039455, 0.06113671511411667, 0.0011301137274131179, 0.010269103571772575, -0.0023755934089422226, 0.014583553187549114, -0.026885423809289932, -0.022868065163493156, 0.03627471625804901, -0.003356871660798788, -0.018917320296168327, -0.009503087028861046, -0.02135675773024559, 0.0036826839204877615, 0.0004765620396938175, 0.03387594595551491, -0.044552307575941086, 0.025084782391786575, 0.011586959473788738, -0.007041716482490301, 0.01226408313959837, 0.025005118921399117, -0.03222193568944931, 0.051013823598623276, 0.026207435876131058, 0.010701819323003292, 0.01860952004790306, -0.010662535205483437, -0.05640995875000954, 0.012947045266628265, -0.012869942933321, -0.051469385623931885, 0.0032091366592794657, 0.015962183475494385, 0.007501701358705759, -0.03806813433766365, -0.0061842347495257854, 0.03983302786946297, -0.02647406794130802, -0.0016846500802785158, 0.01714492216706276, 0.00673683313652873, 0.03375554457306862, 0.009061126969754696, -0.00312048546038568, 0.03378152474761009, -0.04191111400723457, -0.012232641689479351, 0.01633545197546482, 0.06242535263299942, -0.013964465819299221, 0.012096218764781952, 0.008549444377422333, 0.008121786639094353, 0.03682180494070053, 0.010719243437051773, 0.052037905901670456, -0.02774886041879654, -0.01962844468653202, -0.02734103612601757, -0.00978140253573656, 0.02430972456932068, -0.006278004962950945, 0.004755773115903139, 0.03389984741806984, -0.01769879274070263, 0.003310475731268525, -0.020160000771284103, -0.010645054280757904, -0.06156180799007416, 0.006518837995827198, 0.016226110979914665, 0.038034386932849884, -0.017952481284737587, -0.006255368702113628, 0.001068645971827209, -0.010333183221518993, 0.01347396057099104, -0.006217266898602247, 0.009347796440124512, 0.012120453640818596, -0.0027683665975928307, -0.020563771948218346, -0.01511339284479618, -0.006862547714263201, -0.021757952868938446, 0.03147110715508461, 0.027311833575367928, 0.03052636608481407, -0.011332781054079533, -0.02679944969713688, -0.018715310841798782, 0.044066172093153, -0.06295499950647354, -0.02093375101685524, -0.01426770817488432, 0.012876622378826141, 0.0016715433448553085, -0.015193838626146317 ]
<p>I'm trying to model a real-world random variable that behaves approximately as a Gaussian, so a Normal distribution fit is reasonable but far from perfect.</p> <p>However, I only care about its tail, that is, I only care about finding $x$ such as $P(X &gt; x) &lt; p$, with $p$ anywhere between 1% and 5%. I'm modelling the random variable as $X\sim\mathcal{N}(\mu, \sigma^2)$, with parameters estimated from all the samples.</p> <p>I tried to search for specific ways to handle this and I got a lot of results regarding Extreme Value Theory, but it seems to apply mostly to even smaller probabilities than I care or to a heavy-tailed distributions, which is not my case.</p> <p>Any pointers?</p>
74,380
[ -0.007542022503912449, -0.025424504652619362, 0.003308309242129326, -0.001869055675342679, 0.03085140325129032, 0.03916357085108757, -0.02137589268386364, -0.032717932015657425, 0.005664311349391937, -0.04322380572557449, 0.051079779863357544, 0.0851706862449646, 0.041298143565654755, 0.0181509368121624, 0.02104007638990879, -0.013392866589128971, -0.03327406570315361, -0.033727291971445084, -0.01525252964347601, -0.01396125927567482, 0.005686999764293432, 0.038169976323843, 0.02111688069999218, -0.03951941058039665, -0.019394733011722565, 0.03828065097332001, 0.03141755610704422, -0.007393100298941135, 0.030868839472532272, 0.06263960897922516, -0.03333713486790657, -0.03490126505494118, 0.015761403366923332, 0.06694275140762329, 0.028680799528956413, 0.009802627377212048, -0.031191915273666382, -0.013909859582781792, 0.00032209258642978966, 0.0016260314732789993, -0.03861771896481514, -0.012011555023491383, 0.015302983112633228, -0.010320954024791718, 0.019811203703284264, 0.0192362442612648, -0.026129739359021187, -0.07974423468112946, 0.044967446476221085, -0.044091496616601944, 0.0627114325761795, 0.040898989886045456, 0.05242021754384041, 0.036529604345560074, 0.02711077593266964, -0.045130856335163116, 0.06080351397395134, 0.08624871075153351, -0.007235008291900158, -0.07501957565546036, -0.009959603659808636, -0.06685929000377655, -0.004385687876492739, -0.028985507786273956, -0.01969008333981037, 0.006773026660084724, -0.029520424082875252, -0.02406870760023594, 0.019626222550868988, 0.01825031451880932, 0.03110169619321823, 0.04128189757466316, 0.024859562516212463, 0.0012420243583619595, 0.02353750914335251, -0.025186026468873024, 0.02237330749630928, 0.0039339191280305386, 0.06600997596979141, 0.03021419420838356, 0.009971381165087223, 0.004837967921048403, -0.027138954028487206, 0.032170187681913376, -0.01236905436962843, -0.014429140836000443, 0.0832386463880539, -0.009721679612994194, -0.0063391090370714664, 0.01682746596634388, -0.04846026003360748, -0.009743253700435162, 0.0693485289812088, -0.014215213246643543, -0.0596073754131794, 0.04915078729391098, -0.010939417406916618, 0.014648530632257462, -0.009699524380266666, 0.006375598255544901, -0.046772219240665436, -0.045958347618579865, -0.0012270379811525345, 0.05647461488842964, -0.02024145796895027, -0.014807170256972313, 0.005991360638290644, -0.028574150055646896, -0.022613728418946266, -0.04498783126473427, -0.02448972314596176, 0.028527501970529556, 0.018744107335805893, 0.03419599309563637, 0.0469742976129055, -0.004029037430882454, -0.017241958528757095, -0.07368618249893188, 0.035089313983917236, 0.09014196693897247, 0.03359843045473099, -0.0025076137389987707, 0.027141796424984932, -0.049406565725803375, -0.043275896459817886, 0.006338302977383137, 0.023622792214155197, -0.008772161789238453, -0.05886200815439224, 0.029054032638669014, -0.0022093167062848806, 0.017233915627002716, 0.0631987601518631, -0.008044037967920303, 0.0362691693007946, -0.027610134333372116, -0.08346564322710037, -0.022729238495230675, 0.01829717308282852, -0.002184458076953888, -0.027338827028870583, -0.08512859791517258, -0.038922037929296494, 0.05960166081786156, 0.02480126917362213, 0.024103447794914246, 0.026163069531321526, 0.0010783664183691144, 0.028927147388458252, 0.0017278167651966214, -0.018562952056527138, -0.020166097208857536, -0.01896260678768158, 0.00653101084753871, -0.01746966503560543, -0.05492985621094704, 0.020766988396644592, 0.033703114837408066, -0.032884903252124786, -0.025899071246385574, 0.04934697598218918, -0.014109180308878422, -0.03441955894231796, -0.03305470198392868, 0.042578477412462234, -0.015563021413981915, 0.0766749233007431, 0.013311967253684998, 0.03569076582789421, 0.01187132578343153, 0.002697721356526017, -0.006939511280506849, 0.023814303800463676, 0.03330487385392189, 0.05461985617876053, -0.026762207970023155, 0.022327320650219917, -0.037405889481306076, 0.013119212351739407, 0.045530375093221664, -0.021754471585154533, -0.0030759621877223253, -0.0007672471692785621, -0.011578233912587166, -0.008321724832057953, 0.005824081599712372, 0.0215107761323452, -0.027062134817242622, 0.05062401294708252, -0.07018238306045532, -0.04402674734592438, -0.0539768822491169, 0.02047114260494709, 0.029892463237047195, -0.0034060096368193626, 0.029097022488713264, -0.008581276051700115, 0.03221743553876877, -0.012917238287627697, -0.011447497643530369, 0.00876725371927023, 0.015408171340823174, 0.039809588342905045, -0.05599421262741089, 0.00023249429068528116, 0.05340813472867012, 0.02338900975883007, -0.02089756354689598, 0.04081254452466965, -0.004761090036481619, -0.07319170236587524, -0.010649138130247593, -0.05620426684617996, -0.007452755700796843, -0.009805252775549889, -0.01575845666229725, -0.0007549950387328863, -0.028506089001893997, 0.0108666205778718, 0.017521768808364868, -0.02042657695710659, 0.0644664317369461, 0.07505413144826889, 0.004656147677451372, -0.002501346170902252, -0.021518941968679428, 0.004289936739951372, -0.013137172907590866, -0.05101234093308449, -0.028849711641669273, -0.03715980052947998, 0.012324625626206398, 0.05063234269618988, 0.05066132918000221, -0.06844747811555862, 0.00982216838747263, 0.043503180146217346, 0.011305083520710468, 0.05542862042784691, 0.04635213688015938, -0.004141845274716616, -0.006409376859664917, 0.024489715695381165, 0.011778858490288258, 0.013316008262336254, 0.02169898897409439, -0.0014368914999067783, 0.03338402509689331, 0.026634272187948227, -0.02316516824066639, 0.0019913678988814354, 0.03333112969994545, 0.011827425099909306, 0.006797087844461203, -0.031458012759685516, -0.02055693045258522, 0.01819780096411705, -0.026829918846488, 0.0012798539828509092, 0.04106806963682175, -0.010890965349972248, 0.014736030250787735, -0.03024478442966938, -0.044688109308481216, 0.024524088948965073, 0.035956066101789474, -0.044165175408124924, -0.009181381203234196, 0.02558084763586521, 0.015581399202346802, 0.004233601503074169, -0.024794751778244972, -0.030453158542513847, -0.021779468283057213, 0.04330839216709137, 0.03924288600683212, 0.0036172757390886545, 0.009046207182109356, 0.028687728568911552, -0.05448400229215622, 0.02734338492155075, -0.002770879538729787, -0.00579875661060214, 0.005460796412080526, -0.056602105498313904, 0.004279318731278181, -0.011004962027072906, -0.002473721979185939, 0.010615156032145023, 0.006535783875733614, 0.03757844492793083, 0.0019688953179866076, -0.008928850293159485, -0.05157756432890892, 0.01554879266768694, -0.0010743974708020687, -0.017872920259833336, -0.022255655378103256, -0.03996459022164345, 0.035540275275707245, 0.009054410271346569, -0.021290792152285576, 0.07310598343610764, -0.038300104439258575, -0.033970464020967484, -0.06166253238916397, 0.009745394811034203, 0.00513887032866478, 0.009366425685584545, 0.04706811159849167, 0.03102746233344078, -0.01546637061983347, 0.0046516829170286655, -0.05188789591193199, -0.042135532945394516, -0.01733214780688286, 0.010280945338308811, 0.02991948090493679, 0.017611917108297348, -0.009922211989760399, 0.061374273151159286, 0.06264394521713257, -0.009665608406066895, -0.00451050465926528, -0.00352203450165689, -0.0048086680471897125, -0.03997959569096565, 0.0017135732341557741, 0.01738126575946808, -0.020219795405864716, -0.008277224376797676, -0.02036391571164131, -0.009421787224709988, 0.011710994876921177, 0.031942807137966156, -0.013618839904665947, 0.027985531836748123, -0.011329099535942078, 0.026808062568306923, 0.022960850968956947, 0.01639758050441742, -0.009873024187982082, 0.030885620042681694, 0.004262225702404976, 0.003124029142782092, 0.022318441420793533, -0.020278185606002808, -0.005740272346884012, -0.04651344195008278, -0.008716401644051075, -0.02344038523733616, 0.01247002650052309, 0.02450386993587017, -0.062243588268756866, -0.0009983641793951392, 0.022458259016275406, 0.0018624046351760626, -0.010302709415555, 0.021583568304777145, 0.04584215581417084, 0.03414236009120941, -0.015531615354120731, -0.0226253904402256, -0.01649162359535694, -0.012584837153553963, -0.004478227347135544, -0.0007703304290771484, -0.0204530730843544, 0.030371319502592087, 0.04123036935925484, 0.029336979612708092, -0.034007344394922256, -0.02405027486383915, -0.016509905457496643, -0.06415027379989624, 0.019380493089556694, -0.020299624651670456, 0.037022534757852554, 0.032831136137247086, 0.03354286402463913, 0.027816371992230415, 0.004692377056926489, 0.003412324469536543, 0.03427921235561371, -0.06517887115478516, 0.03257191926240921, -0.04258355125784874, -0.0034376303665339947, -0.02882552705705166, -0.007525979075580835, 0.0356401652097702, -0.0054142894223332405, 0.02300236001610756, -0.008563295006752014, 0.014988888055086136, -0.02311406284570694, -0.010476980358362198, -0.05793658271431923, -0.030699830502271652, 0.010432254523038864, 0.004273633938282728, 0.002532697981223464, -0.044028062373399734, -0.008808869868516922, 0.03488633409142494, -0.012836671434342861, -0.03368083015084267, -0.02177954837679863, 0.008845067583024502, -0.0021628043614327908, 0.05648168921470642, 0.03803630173206329, 0.019099818542599678, -0.028442395851016045, 0.05234253406524658, 0.011224508285522461, 0.07372847944498062, 0.0595647431910038, -0.00831560231745243, 0.013430764898657799, -0.056324996054172516, -0.03304843604564667, 0.021495362743735313, 0.00976596213877201, -0.01693401113152504, -0.017896223813295364, 0.06973002851009369, -0.01493521686643362, -0.04325149580836296, 0.0030812155455350876, 0.045040640980005264, 0.02244887873530388, 0.00233721942640841, -0.009344413876533508, 0.0030039751436561346, -0.03336828202009201, 0.017853135243058205, 0.00138537073507905, -0.018744610249996185, -0.0015858785482123494, -0.004155428614467382, 0.03683978691697121, -0.02799847163259983, -0.017554407939314842, -0.014493214897811413, 0.044289447367191315, 0.06718256324529648, 0.030409080907702446, -0.033403944224119186, 0.01170451007783413, 0.03933242708444595, 0.01303989626467228, 0.045802753418684006, 0.0124431774020195, -0.06187041103839874, -0.011839081533253193, 0.042404208332300186, 0.042748741805553436, 0.0019216820364817977, -0.028905149549245834, -0.03998354822397232, 0.009108880534768105, 0.05319484323263168, -0.023847604170441628, -0.007869127206504345, 0.00496511859819293, -0.014673902653157711, 0.0032701329328119755, -0.011856825090944767, -0.06455570459365845, -0.008597728796303272, -0.040308188647031784, 0.008391049690544605, -0.0469801165163517, -0.02743680775165558, -0.07264763861894608, 0.039856210350990295, 0.007137052249163389, 0.054488133639097214, -0.0020380355417728424, -0.020722171291708946, 0.016028204932808876, 0.03781188651919365, 0.006826853379607201, -0.07551019638776779, 0.0014434674521908164, -0.004820400848984718, -0.00785515271127224, 0.024862347170710564, -0.015545796602964401, -0.05074675753712654, 0.051737040281295776, -0.011306552216410637, -0.019804738461971283, 0.01608927547931671, -0.011449211277067661, 0.03244462609291077, 0.004706653766334057, 0.017425592988729477, 0.03846084326505661, 0.040756311267614365, 0.024880720302462578, -0.01710604317486286, -0.015783825889229774, 0.02599092200398445, 0.008645049296319485, -0.016809232532978058, -0.06345424801111221, -0.03746422007679939, -0.025300703942775726, 0.03571769595146179, 0.0038960289675742388, 0.057475507259368896, -0.011163309216499329, -0.014871137216687202, 0.013420741073787212, 0.03530053049325943, 0.01113651879131794, -0.005249949637800455, 0.01367900613695383, 0.04688011109828949, 0.007482150569558144, -0.0016983188688755035, -0.017125770449638367, 0.014901724644005299, 0.009939543902873993, -0.0026623839512467384, -0.035173699259757996, 0.021015841513872147, -0.050367895513772964, -0.02967456541955471, -0.0011169003555551171, -0.023515503853559494, 0.0348140224814415, -0.02641306072473526, 0.004394989926367998, 0.006921866443008184, -0.02525128424167633, 0.008409383706748486, 0.02918550744652748, 0.046376265585422516, 0.04320504888892174, -0.018987879157066345, 0.012042207643389702, -0.029389740899205208, 0.014886349439620972, -0.06624914705753326, -0.04642895236611366, 0.013130958192050457, -0.018977627158164978, -0.017868295311927795, -0.05816888064146042, 0.0366516150534153, -0.041578516364097595, -0.02610638178884983, -0.009881285950541496, 0.04023957997560501, 0.0041868314146995544, -0.00792236439883709, -0.023490548133850098, 0.012061327695846558, 0.0697941929101944, -0.036559924483299255, -0.023088550195097923, 0.04090631753206253, 0.014625037088990211, -0.016920311376452446, 0.0029146906454116106, 0.0291624516248703, -0.03580861911177635, 0.007711581885814667, -0.01398757565766573, -0.03627727925777435, 0.02621023915708065, -0.006162713747471571, -0.008884009905159473, 0.032633088529109955, 0.001848462037742138, 0.0025195071939378977, 0.012228181585669518, -0.005207270849496126, 0.014802028425037861, 0.015590067952871323, 0.0062535903416574, 0.0008286127122119069, 0.013719553127884865, -0.03372903913259506, 0.04223757982254028, 0.01280850637704134, 0.009886062704026699, 0.025916671380400658, 0.050964515656232834, -0.017997728660702705, 0.015246637165546417, -0.007513344753533602, -0.010955626145005226, 0.018850592896342278, 0.041782721877098083, -0.015794968232512474, 0.020448001101613045, 0.015901248902082443, -0.029905302450060844, -0.03548160940408707, -0.05694236233830452, -0.04704183712601662, 0.048535674810409546, -0.015947911888360977, 0.037202805280685425, 0.01733352243900299, 0.03584420308470726, -0.013418597169220448, -0.004737179260700941, -0.02831435389816761, -0.009471995756030083, -0.009554293937981129, 0.042341653257608414, -0.006802641320973635, 0.010846639052033424, 0.014044261537492275, -0.013500602915883064, 0.023146498948335648, 0.061667803674936295, 0.005257986951619387, 0.018089596182107925, 0.024333128705620766, -0.02567458339035511, -0.02187097631394863, 0.028118204325437546, -0.049137260764837265, 0.02904101088643074, -0.020152444019913673, -0.02071462944149971, 0.024123957380652428, 0.030687090009450912, -0.013725417666137218, -0.03257450461387634, 0.00032346820808015764, -0.03824784979224205, -0.003878918942064047, 0.037477102130651474, -0.03923710808157921, 0.035176027566194534, 0.006925128400325775, 0.009544954635202885, 0.00032549790921621025, 0.05878109112381935, -0.04056409373879433, -0.05812988430261612, -0.02557438053190708, -0.005010461434721947, -0.06316497921943665, 0.01012139767408371, 0.01992386020720005, -0.018438003957271576, 0.019900847226381302, -0.05393984913825989, 0.02503889799118042, -0.013111515901982784, 0.021894151344895363, 0.008750482462346554, 0.07570408284664154, 0.0034304677974432707, -0.013412032276391983, 0.007677611894905567, -0.01703473925590515, 0.10554015636444092, 0.08554382622241974, 0.04069359973073006, -0.0506526343524456, 0.012294645421206951, -0.054925259202718735, 0.003929785452783108, -0.027215084061026573, 0.002875222358852625, 0.01089435163885355, -0.03350694850087166, 0.022785324603319168, 0.040837254375219345, 0.011636349372565746, -0.00786183774471283, 0.07108576595783234, -0.049074169248342514, -0.026346635073423386, 0.007417983841150999, 0.0007243267609737813, -0.01802087016403675, -0.012452414259314537, -0.0426243431866169, 0.042525239288806915, -0.018645385280251503, -0.012833386659622192, -0.02483326755464077, -0.013486424461007118, -0.0051044682040810585, -0.011412029154598713, -0.012334851548075676, -0.018959470093250275, -0.004039807245135307, -0.011692535132169724, 0.040826503187417984, -0.004493748303502798, 0.0066642859019339085, -0.0037457130383700132, 0.002262683818116784, 0.005698001477867365, 0.001988309435546398, 0.02975919097661972, 0.04080759361386299, -0.0033342267852276564, -0.03829620033502579, -0.07601408660411835, -0.027819614857435226, 0.050357867032289505, 0.004870584700256586, 0.0136265829205513, 0.0037844395264983177, 0.01797161065042019, 0.008341345004737377, -0.04801895096898079, -0.017060643061995506, 0.013773703016340733, 0.06764521449804306, -0.03048209846019745, -0.007575469557195902, 0.010310031473636627, 0.05469539761543274, 0.007160211447626352, 0.04578956589102745, 0.030648548156023026, -0.049347035586833954, -0.019368700683116913, -0.010856159031391144, 0.045474544167518616, -0.004036259837448597, -0.01670219376683235, 0.03070059046149254, -0.021483363583683968, -0.012339628301560879, -0.0021071038208901882, 0.04810324311256409, -0.02277255244553089, 0.006362132728099823, -0.0012805502628907561, 0.016995996236801147, -0.0391530767083168, 0.0014031411847099662, 0.037480439990758896, -0.028116820380091667, 0.0036443693097680807, -0.02950829640030861, -0.031150227412581444, -0.004705547820776701, 0.032262515276670456, 0.03339022397994995, 0.01369996927678585, -0.026949066668748856, 0.044965099543333054, 0.025455636903643608, -0.05217491835355759, -0.008792271837592125, -0.017742125317454338, -0.048953719437122345, 0.029461003839969635, 0.032396480441093445, 0.07780987024307251, 0.012708914466202259, 0.0157468281686306, -0.0079148318618536, 0.025482257828116417, -0.02350684255361557, 0.020901745185256004, 0.005364500917494297, -0.06447991728782654, 0.007634823210537434, 0.012081921100616455, 0.019401172176003456, -0.02809162251651287, -0.048000629991292953, -0.03129693493247032, -0.009836305864155293, 0.0006743133999407291, -0.00241819373331964, -0.016460109502077103, -0.008611313998699188, -0.004384060390293598, 0.017594145610928535, -0.008386971428990364, -0.014147724024951458, -0.02216949127614498, -0.015057436190545559, -0.02916623093187809, -0.017302969470620155, 0.011781701818108559, 0.011106750927865505, -0.01584136113524437, -0.007643101271241903, 0.033378101885318756, 0.012852531857788563, 0.02063276246190071, 0.013365719467401505, -0.006764775607734919, -0.019639940932393074, 0.05760814994573593, -0.046158138662576675, -0.00826890580356121, 0.061452716588974, -0.04033740609884262, -0.024751897901296616, 0.021575571969151497, 0.0036981164012104273, 0.03938315808773041, 0.004194912500679493, -0.0027221895288676023, -0.04743507504463196, 0.015865493565797806, -0.024100221693515778, -0.008867381140589714, 0.004225304815918207, 0.03772564232349396, -0.005674558691680431, -0.005326133221387863, 0.020093010738492012, -0.01262806449085474, -0.009172364138066769, 0.026876233518123627, 0.02357163466513157, -0.001201518694870174, 0.011955623514950275, 0.04272579774260521, 0.0022877196315675974, 0.01763175241649151, -0.005818654783070087, 0.025260601192712784, 0.03878708556294441, 0.04149151220917702, -0.019811226055026054, 0.0188734270632267, -0.057690393179655075, 0.026704352349042892, -0.07506226748228073, -0.013138942420482635, 0.02653954178094864, 0.0003734370693564415, 0.02661019377410412, -0.03337904065847397, -0.05576715245842934, 0.016757620498538017, -0.03835929185152054, 0.024648025631904602, 0.011281720362603664, -0.02825601026415825, -0.030141163617372513, 0.0056816404685378075, -0.018525075167417526, 0.0027118290308862925, 0.00017710121755953878, 0.030306845903396606, 0.055074214935302734, 0.02522963099181652, -0.004801272414624691, -0.03933655843138695, 0.017957529053092003, 0.014340510591864586, -0.00033587770303711295, -0.04119178280234337, 0.02283523418009281, -0.032008010894060135, -0.0353182889521122, 0.05782195180654526, 0.007015453185886145, 0.028973454609513283, -0.010452166199684143, 0.020996782928705215, -0.015790753066539764, 0.07818105071783066, 0.06910741329193115, 0.007636964321136475, 0.026067085564136505, 0.001667243312112987, 0.024009525775909424, 0.02718122862279415, -0.05096745863556862, 0.007584383245557547, 0.010943092405796051, -0.0214169230312109, -0.04103414714336395, 0.03236309811472893, 0.008854768238961697, -0.030936961993575096, -0.023001816123723984, -0.011032119393348694, 0.0070189302787184715, -0.04242469742894173, 0.028416497632861137, -0.03988108038902283, -0.003043626667931676, 0.027779437601566315, 0.009679191745817661, -0.012592032551765442, 0.01456049270927906, -0.004829972516745329, -0.03746504336595535, -0.014362862333655357, 0.015975750982761383, -0.03500787913799286, -0.059754740446805954, -0.01033653412014246, 0.01068622525781393, -0.014737928286194801, -0.013500625267624855, -0.025718851014971733, -0.018697792664170265, 0.03804093971848488, -0.018454082310199738, 0.0479501448571682, 0.01693987473845482, 0.0003176786412950605, -0.004839808214455843, -0.08981503546237946, 0.06037963926792145, -0.02194857783615589, 0.016420908272266388, -0.024553492665290833, -0.003763107117265463, 0.0010222129058092833, -0.026159608736634254, 0.0646900087594986, 0.013696417212486267, 0.007581164129078388, 0.01436598226428032, 0.042440056800842285, -0.0149319376796484, -0.06389684230089188, 0.0009040912264026701, -0.025501349940896034, -0.03227085992693901, -0.04999848082661629, -0.013557925820350647, 0.022595932707190514, 0.00663719093427062, -0.010636317543685436, 0.02125854231417179, -0.006073277909308672, -0.005415374878793955, -0.011781563051044941, 0.04272802174091339, 0.016509132459759712, -0.03409929946064949, 0.03946738690137863, -0.032164257019758224, 0.003025830490514636, 0.024083878844976425, -0.004797125700861216, -0.024537820369005203, 0.029997436329722404, -0.0326271578669548, -0.07804922014474869, -0.0033771293237805367, 0.04214987903833389, -0.0034954524599015713, -0.06730147451162338, -0.00444959569722414, 0.01984528824687004, -0.052175432443618774, 0.008278708904981613, 0.013152937404811382, 0.00012208679981995374, 0.022369369864463806, 0.020438581705093384, -0.008098699152469635, 0.041015494614839554, 0.018046079203486443, -0.00959538109600544, -0.017981277778744698, 0.02075042575597763, -0.039722293615341187, 0.02349737659096718, 0.022421622648835182, -0.04292795807123184, 0.025078624486923218, -0.017616277560591698, 0.009820573031902313, -0.04730192571878433, -0.03311746567487717, 0.021245386451482773, -0.004512422252446413, 0.030011091381311417, -0.031989216804504395, -0.008485584519803524, 0.05841125175356865, 0.0057385144755244255, -0.0023247951176017523, -0.04066219553351402, 0.005842022132128477, 0.009313722141087055, 0.017678547650575638, -0.010772167704999447, 0.0105140944942832, -0.024435486644506454, -0.003520539030432701, 0.011414998210966587, 0.01173664815723896, 0.0391920730471611, -0.01228757482022047, 0.019203107804059982, -0.01762421429157257, 0.02983037382364273, -0.04010748863220215, -0.03265063464641571, -0.03184645250439644, -0.001011551357805729, 0.004254368599504232, 0.013592847622931004, 0.02847985364496708, -0.0008862796239554882, -0.03697187826037407, 0.011341247707605362, 0.06661775708198547, -0.0882062166929245, 0.014370093122124672, -0.038361556828022, -0.022467095404863358, -0.024935565888881683, -0.017142485827207565 ]
<p>Is the power of a logistic regression and a t-test equivalent? If so, they should be "data density equivalent" by which I mean that the same number of underlying observations yields the same power given a fixed alpha of .05. Consider two cases:</p> <ol> <li>[The parametric t-test]: 30 draws from a binomial observation are made and the resulting values are averaged. This is done 30 times for group A (which has a binomial Pr of .70 of occurring) and 30 times for group B (which has a binomial Pr of .75 of occurring). This yields 30 means per group that represent a summary of 1,800 draws from a binomial distribution. A 58df t-test is performed to compare the means.</li> <li>[The logistic regression]: A logistic regression is performed with a dummy coded slope representing group membership and each of the 1,800 draws.</li> </ol> <p>My question has two parts:</p> <ol> <li>Given a set alpha of .05, will the power of these methodologies be the same or different? Why? How can I prove it?</li> <li>Is the answer to question 1 is sensitive to the sample sizes going into the t-test, sample size of each group in the t-test, underlying binomial probabilities, or some other factor? If so, how can I know (without simulation) that the power is indeed different and what sort of changes will produce what sort of changes in power? Alternatively, provide worked out R code that solves the issue using simulation.</li> </ol>
74,381
[ -0.0581580214202404, 0.008280846290290356, -0.012246712110936642, -0.02734602801501751, 0.03498312458395958, 0.027246695011854172, -0.02333027869462967, -0.020119737833738327, 0.03614769130945206, -0.007396973203867674, 0.02161075361073017, 0.029323654249310493, 0.026282018050551414, 0.017488431185483932, 0.01061242911964655, -0.03557274863123894, -0.02744966931641102, -0.0012635268503800035, 0.0037601341027766466, -0.009868094697594643, 0.017158817499876022, 0.013051697984337807, 0.03425327688455582, -0.005365835502743721, -0.03338366746902466, 0.06352947652339935, -0.004138869233429432, -0.008408145979046822, -0.02364090271294117, 0.06846869736909866, -0.009010124020278454, -0.007965863682329655, 0.026616061106324196, 0.02890283241868019, -0.005443767178803682, -0.0013566112611442804, -0.026727115735411644, -0.026088662445545197, -0.012052683159708977, 0.029844066128134727, -0.05544459819793701, -0.021185994148254395, 0.01027699001133442, 0.0094301113858819, -0.015163550153374672, 0.0188607145100832, -0.016016487032175064, -0.03398752585053444, 0.0100173931568861, -0.029614057391881943, 0.03428545966744423, 0.031011531129479408, 0.06306621432304382, 0.021559560671448708, -0.0242724921554327, -0.03122212551534176, 0.04339690878987312, 0.0415351539850235, -0.013232043012976646, -0.023607874289155006, 0.004320098087191582, -0.03334584832191467, -0.005503870081156492, -0.007424453739076853, -0.03297785297036171, 0.011269009672105312, -0.0188487209379673, -0.008551797829568386, 0.029062680900096893, -0.029834117740392685, 0.03405245393514633, 0.025891046971082687, 0.024019816890358925, 0.015780938789248466, 0.023025251924991608, 0.0013944702222943306, 0.024580536410212517, 0.002410585293546319, 0.0773039311170578, 0.07548775523900986, -0.005331697408109903, 0.01829513907432556, 0.04460955038666725, 0.07245974242687225, 0.03365575522184372, -0.022180035710334778, 0.050503432750701904, -0.01487752702087164, -0.01733124628663063, 0.016131749376654625, -0.012471677735447884, -0.0016223749844357371, 0.06326433271169662, -0.006809896323829889, -0.027724098414182663, 0.007013868540525436, -0.04780089110136032, 0.023687437176704407, -0.008482578210532665, 0.029882406815886497, 0.012863692827522755, -0.048807889223098755, 0.017909862101078033, 0.02789750136435032, -0.01190267875790596, -0.011213067919015884, -0.018229017034173012, -0.014783338643610477, 0.00023163844889495522, -0.023280713707208633, 0.02024073898792267, 0.014234057627618313, 0.03166967257857323, -0.007308096159249544, 0.006064555607736111, -0.0458967499434948, -0.01067610364407301, -0.01631859503686428, 0.05601029098033905, 0.044318459928035736, 0.04654334485530853, -0.025217439979314804, 0.0047226413153111935, -0.031142355874180794, -0.009650464169681072, 0.007318608462810516, -0.00900830328464508, -0.03133075311779976, -0.07852119207382202, 0.04717782884836197, 0.03229235112667084, -0.03133310377597809, 0.036781542003154755, -0.020436501130461693, 0.03923654928803444, 0.0372457429766655, -0.07686135172843933, -0.03879617527127266, 0.023402463644742966, 0.00628873473033309, 0.012566217221319675, -0.05744439363479614, -0.017143862321972847, 0.02744072861969471, 0.014866861514747143, -0.0009644196252338588, 0.05130782723426819, 0.004792764317244291, 0.07325752824544907, 0.018164390698075294, -0.04333782196044922, 0.007520155981183052, -0.038729652762413025, -0.018729252740740776, -0.00328340707346797, -0.10245438665151596, 0.020995382219552994, -0.0006261633825488389, -0.03570019453763962, 0.0037399150896817446, 0.056636661291122437, -0.0009872355731204152, -0.004496529698371887, -0.016315050423145294, 0.013259966857731342, 0.00016708204930182546, 0.03850468620657921, -0.017169715836644173, 0.0352049246430397, 0.014774459414184093, -0.012068524956703186, 0.028737861663103104, 0.021979795768857002, 0.058449115604162216, 0.03366499021649361, -0.05288901552557945, -0.004919916857033968, -0.04509074613451958, 0.02146814577281475, 0.029037855565547943, -0.038338206708431244, 0.013524598442018032, -0.011472709476947784, -0.023392202332615852, 0.02083771862089634, 0.04344971105456352, -0.009405436925590038, 0.002076138276606798, 0.03937547653913498, -0.014463545754551888, -0.09456086158752441, -0.054370176047086716, 0.02577710710465908, -0.005942234303802252, -0.018868686631321907, 0.015339810401201248, 0.010607313364744186, 0.053465165197849274, -0.004661634564399719, 0.021713409572839737, -0.00008674608397996053, -0.004072397015988827, 0.043901875615119934, -0.039685703814029694, 0.017763985320925713, 0.05363932251930237, 0.0654873251914978, -0.016447121277451515, 0.011026870459318161, -0.034515704959630966, -0.06782525032758713, 0.01879369653761387, -0.04143917188048363, 0.011281467974185944, -0.030761437490582466, -0.027295265346765518, 0.0044096726924180984, -0.014854458160698414, -0.015711704269051552, 0.06220126152038574, -0.056112565100193024, 0.05120965093374252, 0.0501745231449604, 0.010892610065639019, 0.015326214022934437, 0.017983917146921158, -0.04736319184303284, -0.0009613973088562489, -0.0278853140771389, -0.041313864290714264, -0.042912062257528305, -0.010884595103561878, 0.036402322351932526, -0.008081872947514057, -0.02330593578517437, 0.03805668652057648, 0.04877585545182228, -0.048201706260442734, 0.0063933683559298515, 0.05892450734972954, 0.014753877185285091, -0.004236925859004259, -0.01291569136083126, 0.040079690515995026, 0.02431412786245346, 0.011164187453687191, 0.03709985688328743, -0.0023120481055229902, 0.031822431832551956, 0.0017335459124296904, -0.0014892262406647205, 0.03034217096865177, -0.005107696168124676, -0.024197226390242577, -0.020128121599555016, -0.015237067826092243, 0.022396061569452286, -0.05115624517202377, -0.0122905932366848, 0.0428173653781414, 0.027730148285627365, -0.0065546040423214436, -0.02348725125193596, -0.015210285782814026, 0.03246983140707016, 0.07157719880342484, -0.021331695839762688, 0.020479023456573486, -0.004386596381664276, -0.03195467218756676, 0.011051480658352375, -0.007353365421295166, -0.05405811965465546, -0.028881974518299103, 0.020568450912833214, 0.0019722150173038244, -0.02303910441696644, 0.025148333981633186, -0.059687137603759766, -0.019600704312324524, -0.01877201907336712, 0.017249224707484245, -0.009449419565498829, 0.0040600113570690155, -0.09814738482236862, -0.02661190740764141, -0.05313839390873909, -0.003966392017900944, 0.021973157301545143, -0.014928095042705536, -0.010160813108086586, 0.02721349708735943, 0.009559670463204384, -0.059547774493694305, 0.0027116474229842424, -0.0430288091301918, -0.021018384024500847, -0.02083536610007286, -0.003074123291298747, 0.034875623881816864, -0.00024190683325286955, -0.04502524062991142, 0.04218091443181038, -0.03805896267294884, -0.015892576426267624, 0.002330163726583123, -0.0126203503459692, 0.027385596185922623, -0.0033816879149526358, 0.013641489669680595, 0.01213043462485075, -0.05072639510035515, -0.005161422770470381, -0.04406672716140747, -0.04383542388677597, 0.013818858191370964, -0.004818806424736977, 0.06761207431554794, 0.010160301811993122, -0.03505931422114372, 0.0562412291765213, 0.0432906299829483, -0.03731038048863411, -0.04068927839398384, 0.004264078103005886, -0.048485610634088516, 0.0012136262375861406, 0.026514127850532532, 0.02176668681204319, -0.005696676671504974, 0.004692613147199154, -0.0211113803088665, 0.02068970538675785, 0.06612903624773026, 0.01943882182240486, -0.008941162377595901, 0.02846090868115425, 0.046030376106500626, -0.021994009613990784, 0.03717420995235443, 0.00037615461042150855, -0.04918553680181503, 0.015424384735524654, 0.0006632616859860718, 0.013787462376058102, -0.0018840793054550886, -0.028909146785736084, 0.019637446850538254, 0.0285811610519886, 0.017274240031838417, -0.022964805364608765, 0.028263963758945465, 0.009559521451592445, -0.04153316468000412, 0.0017427809070795774, 0.05343605577945709, 0.0015296092024073005, -0.029351046308875084, 0.008975722827017307, 0.03724941238760948, 0.07491244375705719, -0.027652179822325706, -0.025889581069350243, -0.0064925928600132465, -0.01887143962085247, 0.015935592353343964, -0.024076692759990692, -0.03359152004122734, 0.037239644676446915, 0.03270140290260315, 0.02529943361878395, -0.02491840161383152, -0.026064356788992882, -0.005132821388542652, -0.03955785185098648, 0.0026690277736634016, -0.03912394121289253, 0.06569637358188629, -0.0143857067450881, 0.03773568570613861, -0.004378237761557102, 0.01015207264572382, 0.0041457489132881165, -0.0021511942613869905, -0.04668349400162697, 0.035812120884656906, -0.0405476950109005, -0.0221444983035326, 0.02756238915026188, 0.013112477026879787, 0.03493661433458328, 0.007123899646103382, 0.03512878343462944, -0.00209550722502172, 0.04191947728395462, -0.025656607002019882, -0.009734904393553734, -0.028400234878063202, -0.03908748924732208, -0.0018302950775250793, 0.02866428531706333, -0.028723271563649178, -0.023463957011699677, 0.05186636373400688, 0.01945643685758114, -0.00720939552411437, 0.014939401298761368, -0.007894243113696575, 0.0274824108928442, -0.014584572985768318, 0.04542629048228264, 0.03253158926963806, 0.04859475418925285, -0.039547283202409744, 0.0014716009609401226, 0.019485265016555786, 0.03693508729338646, 0.019816990941762924, -0.030954521149396896, -0.011461212299764156, -0.026844780892133713, -0.02642734907567501, 0.0064907195046544075, -0.0028394977562129498, -0.00039854954229667783, -0.02858148142695427, 0.03229690343141556, 0.032707322388887405, -0.046178288757801056, 0.026416128501296043, 0.008853987790644169, 0.023253094404935837, 0.01734527386724949, -0.06318242847919464, 0.012084688991308212, -0.005964203272014856, -0.0341542549431324, 0.00930340401828289, 0.020650893449783325, 0.02853502333164215, 0.019691376015543938, 0.03167065605521202, -0.03333313763141632, -0.04126659408211708, -0.014992427080869675, 0.020135482773184776, 0.005768751725554466, 0.017435047775506973, -0.03865842521190643, 0.007432837039232254, 0.030300812795758247, 0.0036511379294097424, 0.04249061271548271, 0.022460296750068665, -0.04764397442340851, 0.009370872750878334, 0.014630123972892761, 0.03614657372236252, -0.0272841714322567, 0.010913210920989513, -0.00047468673437833786, 0.013968492858111858, -0.0008879299275577068, -0.05640258267521858, 0.023942718282341957, -0.02280978113412857, 0.033094484359025955, -0.02965623512864113, -0.01649339497089386, -0.05045387148857117, 0.0030137544963508844, -0.017798002809286118, 0.0022175037302076817, -0.008073489181697369, -0.016124997287988663, -0.04284321516752243, 0.04055594652891159, 0.010304962284862995, 0.07725825160741806, -0.09008123725652695, -0.03806999698281288, -0.014683786779642105, 0.017740143463015556, 0.00590211246162653, -0.05986931174993515, -0.008996709249913692, -0.02047966606914997, -0.004930747672915459, 0.0365026630461216, -0.0006357121746987104, -0.047838352620601654, 0.03767523169517517, -0.029933691024780273, -0.03388803079724312, 0.006726864259690046, -0.03595487028360367, 0.042223576456308365, 0.026065507903695107, 0.018936624750494957, 0.06397417932748795, 0.040099333971738815, 0.011926287785172462, 0.0097240274772048, -0.04705516993999481, -0.003842615522444248, -0.017346389591693878, -0.020858678966760635, -0.056313566863536835, -0.021621914580464363, -0.0011955351801589131, 0.04020533710718155, 0.0018583848141133785, 0.005055215675383806, -0.008362987078726292, -0.0004014959267806262, 0.014123399741947651, 0.021615782752633095, 0.007409266661852598, 0.04248836636543274, -0.0037960191257297993, 0.01698462665081024, -0.011088397353887558, 0.00023101430269889534, 0.05449770390987396, -0.008386025205254555, 0.002534541767090559, 0.006112575996667147, -0.061696503311395645, 0.016911735758185387, 0.011156288906931877, 0.019732534885406494, 0.013442318886518478, -0.009779137559235096, 0.03785666823387146, -0.00621383311226964, 0.02821226604282856, 0.011411498300731182, -0.056144535541534424, -0.00174384331330657, 0.0156758651137352, -0.01809176430106163, 0.033517513424158096, -0.011228920891880989, 0.009305506013333797, 0.004519242327660322, -0.029514824971556664, -0.06862890720367432, -0.01781046949326992, 0.01169362012296915, 0.0010600575478747487, 0.01058186125010252, -0.007667058147490025, 0.01006503775715828, -0.0071906656958162785, -0.025847990065813065, -0.022594790905714035, 0.060213495045900345, -0.002852963749319315, -0.015387967228889465, -0.020741235464811325, 0.006832026410847902, 0.10031241178512573, -0.00659124506637454, -0.03540829196572304, -0.00577554339542985, -0.014476888813078403, -0.02833017148077488, 0.008566218428313732, -0.011022628284990788, -0.01560530811548233, -0.01779431663453579, -0.0006555755971930921, -0.022518085315823555, 0.04173669591546059, -0.02129044570028782, -0.02053454890847206, -0.007609781809151173, -0.020184418186545372, 0.023118507117033005, -0.03760802000761032, 0.011149127967655659, -0.011195838451385498, 0.053716886788606644, -0.05769183114171028, 0.006561239715665579, -0.008164177648723125, 0.014889729209244251, -0.014861362986266613, 0.019485728815197945, -0.021996457129716873, 0.047462254762649536, 0.06696806102991104, -0.022228145971894264, 0.044906649738550186, -0.021273434162139893, -0.025762129575014114, 0.05930972844362259, 0.025221439078450203, -0.026167120784521103, 0.011392490938305855, -0.0031565683893859386, -0.002435563364997506, -0.03119637630879879, -0.035463448613882065, 0.0236155167222023, 0.009465573355555534, 0.003940162248909473, 0.05149541050195694, 0.06748577952384949, 0.009184680879116058, 0.02503674291074276, -0.014151989482343197, 0.02148251049220562, -0.01546438317745924, 0.015515833161771297, 0.04770293086767197, -0.0248453039675951, -0.03950541839003563, 0.07177507877349854, -0.0060706413350999355, 0.0289174672216177, 0.05805918574333191, 0.012445081025362015, 0.029991313815116882, 0.045986805111169815, -0.03927163407206535, -0.02408861555159092, 0.022839823737740517, -0.04768761992454529, 0.000988844665698707, -0.049775440245866776, -0.0029967629816383123, 0.047820135951042175, 0.010827424935996532, 0.01807093620300293, -0.06755140423774719, -0.0395645909011364, -0.06611214578151703, -0.02708456851541996, 0.002783717354759574, 0.01571463979780674, 0.05363791435956955, -0.016766192391514778, -0.011454381048679352, -0.020554909482598305, 0.023930786177515984, -0.0029948693700134754, -0.07669124752283096, -0.06126171350479126, -0.014790265820920467, -0.04679063707590103, 0.034134622663259506, -0.02158721350133419, -0.052442003041505814, 0.011062795296311378, -0.08994006365537643, 0.010588878765702248, 0.006771505810320377, 0.016496511176228523, -0.0048967394977808, 0.0919206291437149, -0.010216716676950455, 0.07169914245605469, -0.012912464328110218, -0.027999088168144226, 0.10921727120876312, 0.0661565437912941, 0.04485742375254631, -0.04571838304400444, 0.019189268350601196, -0.01574886590242386, -0.0034870957024395466, -0.009475721046328545, 0.0016391660319641232, 0.02824358269572258, 0.0008724339422769845, 0.03944200277328491, 0.07225462049245834, -0.00030287366826087236, 0.0009223719243891537, 0.055508390069007874, -0.049300290644168854, 0.02703155018389225, 0.034729115664958954, 0.02949352189898491, 0.02399749495089054, -0.04328526556491852, -0.011179709807038307, -0.005114759784191847, 0.009058045223355293, -0.005422049667686224, 0.0019867541268467903, 0.013366661965847015, -0.03626806288957596, -0.014421618543565273, -0.05371499061584473, -0.00854266807436943, 0.03668859228491783, 0.008958798833191395, -0.034734152257442474, -0.004839915782213211, 0.0068389372900128365, -0.04617464542388916, -0.026082681491971016, 0.07059523463249207, -0.03410163149237633, 0.005113205872476101, 0.004114415496587753, 0.014844574965536594, -0.034320611506700516, 0.00001003842226054985, -0.03921790048480034, 0.010147623717784882, -0.014806890860199928, 0.02986912429332733, 0.01009224820882082, -0.00808763224631548, -0.02671269327402115, -0.04645022004842758, -0.025227529928088188, 0.014036394655704498, 0.007076133508235216, -0.02098686993122101, -0.03146860748529434, -0.027890322729945183, 0.02395162731409073, 0.001086797215975821, 0.04932929202914238, 0.0015300740487873554, -0.01230657659471035, -0.03093753755092621, -0.0235825777053833, 0.07493984699249268, -0.004638628102838993, 0.0026512956246733665, -0.011327540501952171, 0.0004936658078804612, -0.043420061469078064, 0.013756748288869858, -0.018397916108369827, -0.012298054993152618, 0.01409922819584608, 0.005102764815092087, 0.012413247488439083, -0.031321797519922256, -0.0375053696334362, 0.006974897813051939, -0.021871104836463928, 0.019135024398565292, -0.010924826376140118, -0.0047553423792123795, 0.03763910382986069, 0.019463369622826576, 0.03323123976588249, 0.024877220392227173, 0.007559775374829769, 0.023334724828600883, -0.007386265322566032, -0.09875020384788513, -0.0037358407862484455, 0.002683856524527073, -0.022233420982956886, -0.025566240772604942, 0.007750336546450853, 0.03184021636843681, 0.008638044819235802, 0.009982225485146046, 0.006543781608343124, 0.009616493247449398, 0.03288034722208977, -0.0005800910876132548, -0.022767847403883934, -0.03926253318786621, -0.02093394286930561, 0.01870790123939514, 0.004370752722024918, -0.004598728846758604, -0.01565036177635193, -0.058815013617277145, -0.04983403906226158, 0.03140892833471298, -0.05301360413432121, 0.005106576718389988, -0.038676559925079346, 0.006462267134338617, 0.039543863385915756, -0.012453816831111908, 0.009435290470719337, -0.02255932241678238, -0.014724953100085258, 0.002406747778877616, -0.006905034184455872, -0.013070455752313137, 0.049530573189258575, -0.0035266221966594458, -0.016372250393033028, 0.05971047654747963, 0.030909035354852676, 0.020170919597148895, 0.008593461476266384, -0.008420814760029316, 0.03387664258480072, 0.0331176295876503, -0.010134050622582436, -0.02353270724415779, 0.06050584465265274, -0.019121620804071426, -0.03330559656023979, 0.0451393648982048, -0.028485119342803955, 0.020637989044189453, 0.01390098500996828, 0.022937312722206116, -0.03274835646152496, 0.032844409346580505, -0.045799002051353455, -0.0076073938980698586, -0.0031396157573908567, 0.0016183111583814025, -0.010295585729181767, 0.010292687453329563, 0.01792733371257782, 0.03508128598332405, -0.0025390477385371923, 0.009983955882489681, 0.049079567193984985, -0.00689345970749855, 0.004716471768915653, 0.02253533899784088, 0.019938476383686066, 0.004667780362069607, -0.005058289971202612, -0.012432500720024109, 0.044754110276699066, 0.06190129742026329, -0.006768288556486368, 0.007266886066645384, -0.029594046995043755, 0.03688444942235947, -0.10917185246944427, -0.014176170341670513, 0.01570982113480568, -0.003971979487687349, 0.028955424204468727, -0.04642779007554054, 0.002774499822407961, 0.004997448064386845, -0.06393637508153915, 0.014402022585272789, 0.00686292489990592, 0.003462032414972782, -0.05753607302904129, 0.03239370509982109, -0.012102358974516392, 0.008855612948536873, 0.012914294376969337, 0.020615221932530403, 0.007866010069847107, 0.05299954488873482, 0.017044199630618095, -0.0039009058382362127, -0.03677236661314964, 0.024745728820562363, -0.008897521533071995, -0.03422729671001434, 0.025571102276444435, -0.020923705771565437, -0.03985612466931343, 0.00968245416879654, 0.017138438299298286, 0.05031305178999901, 0.000971212750300765, 0.006528428290039301, 0.004830901976674795, 0.025895370170474052, 0.05709824338555336, -0.006040345877408981, -0.023299144580960274, 0.01463012583553791, 0.0170169398188591, 0.0055557731539011, -0.027622558176517487, -0.009687976911664009, 0.051136959344148636, -0.006376376375555992, 0.011630749329924583, -0.005935564171522856, -0.0007783259497955441, -0.029300643131136894, -0.031130578368902206, 0.021001126617193222, -0.02434460259974003, 0.01437833346426487, -0.0072730849497020245, -0.07879786938428879, -0.018044494092464447, 0.05009407550096512, 0.021038075909018517, -0.04099385067820549, 0.0372476652264595, -0.002715321024879813, -0.0006131704431027174, 0.020188748836517334, -0.013727204874157906, -0.0008769069099798799, -0.012571374885737896, 0.029893197119235992, -0.02402256429195404, 0.01767444983124733, -0.00972436647862196, -0.015486651100218296, -0.05420662835240364, 0.014079746790230274, -0.023045828565955162, -0.0013164224801585078, 0.024327412247657776, -0.018803060054779053, 0.009670653380453587, -0.08477949351072311, 0.059473916888237, -0.022589901462197304, -0.00617177551612258, -0.02832380123436451, 0.0032044402323663235, -0.0368197001516819, 0.004846386611461639, 0.0692460834980011, 0.03356041759252548, 0.008939365856349468, 0.02303384803235531, 0.016224950551986694, -0.000591557938605547, -0.05881761759519577, 0.003150558564811945, 0.019681677222251892, -0.022262776270508766, -0.023874692618846893, -0.01664382591843605, 0.04059236869215965, 0.03517159819602966, 0.02454417571425438, -0.009412289597094059, 0.007339348550885916, 0.003963911440223455, 0.011434759944677353, 0.059515781700611115, -0.0030316293705254793, -0.01937132142484188, 0.04771799594163895, 0.023594411090016365, 0.014817398972809315, -0.0180805791169405, -0.01523497886955738, -0.05153282359242439, 0.04945967718958855, -0.0013665604637935758, -0.0422237329185009, -0.0010960419895127416, 0.0070408983156085014, -0.010153894312679768, -0.046422138810157776, 0.01139955036342144, 0.026323989033699036, -0.01575707644224167, 0.018131576478481293, 0.02455689013004303, 0.031266968697309494, 0.018832100555300713, -0.024709293618798256, 0.03425659239292145, -0.014784947037696838, -0.009540091268718243, -0.0334513895213604, -0.0022122974041849375, 0.04708757624030113, -0.02007286436855793, -0.012461991049349308, 0.006387598812580109, 0.0018611103296279907, 0.030590685084462166, 0.003752106102183461, 0.047707997262477875, 0.004315768834203482, -0.03297823667526245, 0.004798268899321556, 0.006318259984254837, 0.013651049695909023, 0.01393233984708786, 0.012119702063500881, 0.07572595030069351, -0.02688070572912693, 0.020888982340693474, -0.0031367752235382795, -0.027887769043445587, -0.019052039831876755, -0.02811899036169052, -0.0011746694799512625, 0.03167299926280975, 0.014087502844631672, 0.020820315927267075, -0.001805016421712935, -0.03059971332550049, -0.004366001114249229, 0.002934211166575551, 0.014422592706978321, -0.02369908057153225, -0.032117635011672974, -0.037352871149778366, -0.0387900248169899, -0.05028756335377693, -0.06421752274036407, 0.0288767721503973, 0.02069753222167492, 0.0156426839530468, -0.004397439304739237, -0.06582966446876526, 0.03045380301773548, 0.061392828822135925, -0.034070421010255814, -0.034552447497844696, -0.026565641164779663, 0.025247249752283096, 0.027696259319782257, -0.04011739417910576 ]
<p>Basically, I want to manually compute what <code>predict(princomp(somedata))</code> produces.</p> <p>In order to do that I need to have coefficients matrix so that</p> <pre><code>newdata %*% coefficients </code></pre> <p>would produce the predicted values of each component.</p> <p>Can anybody give me a clue to get the coefficients?</p>
74,382
[ 0.009830641560256481, 0.005309881176799536, -0.023262975737452507, -0.0020739890169352293, 0.01053775753825903, 0.007986950688064098, -0.04150042682886124, -0.015218201093375683, 0.025704380124807358, -0.028765631839632988, 0.004521534778177738, 0.03768669068813324, 0.059990331530570984, 0.03693867847323418, 0.0172401275485754, 0.02247406728565693, -0.018405936658382416, 0.0036332060117274523, 0.016466446220874786, -0.03501388803124428, -0.014079415239393711, -0.005893734283745289, 0.0020674942061305046, -0.01732938550412655, 0.009266706183552742, 0.06524495035409927, 0.005217475816607475, 0.003249493893235922, -0.005844932049512863, 0.04326782003045082, -0.0247629564255476, -0.07354657351970673, 0.009286502376198769, 0.013443231582641602, 0.041468072682619095, 0.01443479210138321, 0.002075738040730357, -0.0402350090444088, -0.014675898477435112, 0.025186678394675255, 0.00637902831658721, 0.0012371782213449478, 0.007163058966398239, 0.04035945236682892, -0.0004918884951621294, 0.019268516451120377, 0.010477283969521523, 0.0011704647913575172, 0.053551726043224335, -0.04697040840983391, 0.08435074239969254, -0.01779840886592865, 0.04608853906393051, -0.002468700287863612, -0.04057364910840988, -0.004563331604003906, 0.04796846583485603, 0.08161051571369171, 0.005578323733061552, -0.055751003324985504, -0.011853671632707119, -0.021040981635451317, 0.004910632967948914, -0.0050252522341907024, -0.05236935243010521, 0.009290956892073154, -0.025069337338209152, -0.04057224094867706, 0.0054955752566456795, -0.03873123601078987, -0.004653880838304758, -0.0005076436209492385, 0.0342274084687233, -0.046568650752305984, -0.005562886595726013, -0.02643323503434658, 0.006500080693513155, 0.014412621036171913, 0.008661098778247833, 0.014256302267313004, -0.03348986804485321, 0.08048321306705475, -0.00622746255248785, -0.011755580082535744, 0.021695701405405998, 0.014518250711262226, 0.04139887914061546, -0.061370495706796646, 0.03893499821424484, -0.002629399998113513, -0.003228848334401846, 0.012349062599241734, 0.03483876958489418, 0.024708950892090797, -0.0225644763559103, 0.027241988107562065, -0.00007966418343130499, 0.06331071257591248, 0.03953224793076515, -0.030762294307351112, 0.0012699420331045985, 0.013976527377963066, -0.02700456604361534, 0.05392519757151604, -0.02312603034079075, 0.005718930624425411, -0.04350779205560684, -0.033142685890197754, -0.022223111242055893, -0.052594251930713654, 0.024282146245241165, 0.027767349034547806, 0.0009163309587165713, -0.04502564296126366, -0.001934268744662404, -0.037166494876146317, 0.0010475695598870516, 0.010695778764784336, 0.02723092958331108, 0.057163044810295105, 0.02026807703077793, -0.030136190354824066, 0.024652676656842232, -0.020678695291280746, -0.03522232547402382, 0.0005122841103002429, -0.010189889930188656, -0.026826148852705956, -0.0492057278752327, 0.04978330433368683, -0.054351557046175, -0.05761689320206642, 0.03467149659991264, -0.009123560972511768, -0.0201687254011631, -0.02572028711438179, -0.05212317034602165, -0.05805664509534836, 0.018367432057857513, -0.04165057837963104, 0.013562606647610664, -0.03928903490304947, 0.028050268068909645, 0.010543459095060825, 0.06281626969575882, 0.007401543669402599, 0.026588931679725647, 0.025599028915166855, 0.03674843907356262, 0.006215932313352823, -0.036770548671483994, -0.02666017785668373, -0.014193035662174225, -0.004886089824140072, -0.02822708524763584, -0.028302131220698357, 0.006010598503053188, 0.011304166167974472, -0.03154543414711952, 0.012751186266541481, 0.013056030496954918, -0.013803593814373016, -0.02475806511938572, 0.00005132667502039112, -0.019992632791399956, -0.05639338120818138, 0.06560663878917694, 0.014385617338120937, 0.011008785106241703, 0.018474765121936798, -0.004819974303245544, 0.012435879558324814, -0.016431644558906555, 0.032897450029850006, 0.07939868420362473, 0.012095140293240547, -0.02295028604567051, -0.007012610789388418, 0.060101915150880814, -0.023970860987901688, -0.042546678334474564, -0.05029285326600075, -0.001807343796826899, -0.007562809158116579, 0.029029151424765587, 0.03490445762872696, 0.013731911778450012, -0.030307356268167496, 0.036267101764678955, -0.014436624944210052, -0.027389245107769966, -0.05443454906344414, -0.003703390946611762, 0.024703431874513626, -0.037960268557071686, -0.024751216173171997, 0.03543080389499664, 0.003347305813804269, 0.05035052448511124, -0.03333716839551926, -0.0383579283952713, -0.02557668276131153, 0.04769977927207947, -0.04181073233485222, -0.02691737189888954, 0.03847145289182663, 0.06442252546548843, -0.046373412013053894, 0.06084924191236496, -0.034379154443740845, -0.017989102751016617, 0.025216953828930855, -0.06302303075790405, -0.0010783441830426455, -0.042985957115888596, -0.01388859748840332, 0.02092532254755497, 0.005080261267721653, 0.018963363021612167, 0.0048343404196202755, -0.05108625441789627, 0.05068306624889374, 0.06233813613653183, 0.029089726507663727, 0.005814561154693365, -0.02412070333957672, -0.014870774000883102, 0.031224442645907402, -0.013090920634567738, -0.009967166930437088, -0.020157065242528915, -0.014134357683360577, 0.013938418589532375, 0.03921468183398247, -0.052277181297540665, -0.0006091360119171441, 0.05553196743130684, -0.005794421304017305, 0.02921106480062008, 0.05801748111844063, 0.009276378899812698, 0.008457890711724758, -0.014509853906929493, 0.010527278296649456, 0.012407190166413784, 0.0005443297559395432, 0.013039668090641499, 0.063846156001091, 0.04230581969022751, 0.0245949849486351, 0.012041682377457619, 0.054441727697849274, 0.020437272265553474, -0.01107332855463028, -0.010598705150187016, -0.05609583109617233, 0.05067969858646393, 0.011244961060583591, -0.009518411010503769, -0.009459257125854492, 0.024452025070786476, -0.00476915342733264, 0.006246853619813919, -0.054026346653699875, -0.03537505120038986, 0.04520295932888985, -0.07562587410211563, 0.01770712248980999, 0.03759545460343361, -0.03870955482125282, 0.05632588639855385, 0.02222658134996891, 0.00729193864390254, -0.045690905302762985, 0.012232297100126743, 0.04434790834784508, -0.020262625068426132, 0.03147417679429054, -0.04113820195198059, -0.04448289796710014, 0.01781642809510231, -0.0022554730530828238, 0.03878961130976677, -0.004746723920106888, -0.07933763414621353, -0.012838008813560009, -0.01894487999379635, -0.039268363267183304, 0.03284762427210808, 0.009678224101662636, -0.06000098958611488, 0.04326644912362099, -0.05181011185050011, -0.06319992244243622, -0.013088725507259369, -0.008331685326993465, 0.03676457330584526, -0.02327396161854267, 0.009973549284040928, 0.029944639652967453, -0.012010731734335423, -0.027204714715480804, -0.01680963672697544, -0.023065323010087013, -0.007177214603871107, -0.029757678508758545, -0.020380763337016106, 0.018705442547798157, -0.00504053570330143, 0.01562974788248539, 0.030153144150972366, -0.03695492446422577, -0.0072294375859200954, -0.03643956035375595, -0.054049503058195114, 0.0373903252184391, 0.014860246330499649, 0.0009031138033606112, 0.028820928186178207, 0.004375488962978125, 0.03982040658593178, -0.0032549810130149126, -0.07549320161342621, -0.01774575747549534, 0.006634360644966364, -0.0012023996096104383, -0.05559249222278595, 0.022897059097886086, 0.0025947566609829664, -0.02205883525311947, 0.030145801603794098, -0.012544786557555199, -0.005101573187857866, 0.04648618400096893, -0.003165000583976507, 0.0032962863333523273, 0.02070709317922592, 0.006962999235838652, -0.03607869893312454, 0.017830010503530502, 0.0007740618311800063, -0.0049108038656413555, 0.007477083709090948, -0.02242632582783699, 0.022930601611733437, -0.004258996341377497, -0.0026375548914074898, -0.02942933514714241, -0.01778576523065567, 0.014214104041457176, -0.032894521951675415, 0.03198860213160515, -0.04140111058950424, -0.016618357971310616, -0.008327600546181202, 0.05209949612617493, 0.022482305765151978, -0.012260755524039268, 0.024154014885425568, 0.0486200787127018, -0.0038761161267757416, -0.0098896948620677, 0.026159079745411873, -0.0077757518738508224, -0.021500643342733383, 0.018554696813225746, -0.008749762549996376, 0.0013759132707491517, 0.06386591494083405, 0.044740982353687286, 0.02480958215892315, 0.023409973829984665, -0.030681515112519264, 0.02626793645322323, -0.05442085862159729, 0.007341028191149235, -0.015235673636198044, 0.058443836867809296, -0.013302543200552464, 0.09042076021432877, 0.007799835875630379, 0.03248199075460434, 0.03595125302672386, -0.00399112980812788, -0.0886007621884346, 0.04111069440841675, 0.007856852374970913, -0.023550385609269142, 0.0031724958680570126, -0.0023207049816846848, 0.05742084980010986, -0.014683305285871029, -0.000844316091388464, 0.02010701410472393, 0.007436132058501244, -0.053750742226839066, 0.02091882936656475, -0.009679717943072319, -0.006797355599701405, -0.027402685955166817, 0.0011044007260352373, 0.04313282296061516, -0.026555456221103668, -0.002672698115929961, 0.024861298501491547, -0.03457951173186302, -0.013167284429073334, -0.03884495794773102, -0.00044339991291053593, 0.006715781521052122, 0.024071117863059044, 0.06698399037122726, 0.03714634105563164, -0.06519132107496262, 0.046145789325237274, -0.019395861774683, 0.03957776725292206, 0.033264514058828354, -0.0029579377733170986, -0.02839437872171402, -0.01936429552733898, 0.004948384128510952, 0.007585558108985424, 0.007260692305862904, -0.01159598957747221, 0.023077797144651413, 0.026391739025712013, 0.022966770455241203, -0.03518037870526314, 0.029967643320560455, 0.08764675259590149, 0.023059995844960213, -0.005926767364144325, -0.014806953258812428, 0.01727764494717121, -0.0030947711784392595, -0.0008336405153386295, 0.0015993795823305845, 0.00953939650207758, 0.004587517119944096, -0.0008068482275120914, 0.005997647065669298, -0.02432825043797493, 0.025721075013279915, 0.03879709541797638, 0.0014069773023948073, 0.06860105693340302, 0.013056250289082527, -0.019596830010414124, 0.009967418387532234, 0.037077732384204865, 0.012047331780195236, 0.01659216359257698, 0.011257403530180454, -0.10378991812467575, 0.02277677319943905, 0.031219592317938805, 0.0683094784617424, -0.07288922369480133, -0.019684147089719772, -0.02160348743200302, -0.026191646233201027, 0.0429544672369957, -0.02250797115266323, 0.03856053575873375, -0.0008464010898023844, 0.00030459483969025314, -0.004494101274758577, 0.015731653198599815, -0.05033675581216812, 0.01653340831398964, -0.06825708597898483, 0.03515755385160446, -0.03441353142261505, -0.05272796377539635, -0.035279203206300735, 0.02091001532971859, 0.022404983639717102, 0.0601717010140419, 0.0005898167146369815, -0.01713535003364086, 0.002810946898534894, 0.020784126594662666, -0.0034680585376918316, -0.026967283338308334, 0.010276071727275848, 0.003077130764722824, -0.04489552974700928, 0.05775987356901169, -0.028646577149629593, 0.00011876886856043711, 0.011566951870918274, 0.025776101276278496, -0.018224135041236877, -0.018369100987911224, -0.0308412816375494, -0.0005654121050611138, -0.015141066163778305, -0.0144772594794631, 0.04855163395404816, 0.03621303662657738, 0.005300429649651051, 0.00013829114323016256, -0.042008914053440094, -0.006022327579557896, -0.022431083023548126, -0.023046543821692467, -0.04329654574394226, 0.006107155699282885, -0.00654616579413414, 0.012557236477732658, 0.0029571172781288624, 0.012720371596515179, -0.02061096765100956, 0.01797444000840187, -0.018633954226970673, 0.06093632057309151, -0.05299576744437218, 0.0017216759733855724, 0.007765756454318762, 0.021335642784833908, -0.0059464238584041595, -0.03432329744100571, 0.008096836507320404, 0.016620464622974396, -0.009349317289888859, -0.002916139317676425, -0.0047317189164459705, -0.0017545883310958743, -0.037418439984321594, -0.04546406865119934, 0.01501009427011013, -0.02546171098947525, -0.01172850001603365, 0.017693255096673965, 0.06679167598485947, 0.008555948734283447, -0.04979543015360832, -0.0208135973662138, 0.04632788896560669, -0.009603757411241531, 0.009724028408527374, -0.045614853501319885, 0.010675753466784954, -0.027237074449658394, -0.01248579565435648, -0.03860181197524071, -0.07938180863857269, 0.04388529807329178, 0.015820123255252838, 0.004488922189921141, -0.03068925440311432, -0.042842742055654526, -0.04682866111397743, 0.0020797892939299345, 0.017795933410525322, 0.03430873900651932, -0.03044785000383854, 0.03129063919186592, 0.015240665525197983, -0.03336343914270401, 0.06295469403266907, 0.015241716988384724, 0.019850237295031548, 0.027289487421512604, 0.015269025228917599, -0.013304417952895164, 0.015052981674671173, -0.028109442442655563, -0.040755972266197205, -0.0003616748726926744, -0.019250087440013885, 0.029977334663271904, 0.08039513975381851, 0.042027901858091354, 0.05497484654188156, -0.017774997279047966, 0.03635153919458389, -0.006024149712175131, -0.03818722814321518, -0.00027821955154649913, -0.04536723718047142, -0.011271500028669834, -0.026607202365994453, -0.0038950119633227587, -0.04068277031183243, 0.01046434510499239, -0.019258473068475723, 0.0039038266986608505, 0.010245731100440025, 0.004650638438761234, 0.05444485321640968, 0.0070389206521213055, -0.0007888489635661244, 0.01443492528051138, -0.007878146134316921, 0.03995490446686745, 0.026937244459986687, 0.026228323578834534, 0.01593897119164467, 0.014221804216504097, -0.014978566206991673, -0.051397714763879776, -0.028565024957060814, -0.01628994569182396, 0.05631853640079498, -0.021303096786141396, 0.07171748578548431, 0.020963726565241814, 0.027069633826613426, -0.005946807097643614, -0.00850667990744114, -0.012825052253901958, 0.04945097863674164, 0.018923457711935043, 0.07597072422504425, 0.0010676290839910507, -0.0157356858253479, 0.010522731579840183, -0.01788606308400631, 0.014776622876524925, 0.042222555726766586, -0.0009192634606733918, -0.00022035971051082015, 0.027166243642568588, -0.02175016701221466, 0.0017126797465607524, -0.006532718427479267, -0.025181379169225693, 0.018076946958899498, -0.04172030836343765, -0.007934018969535828, 0.04183095693588257, 0.04004402831196785, -0.004341063089668751, -0.03490760549902916, -0.011676204390823841, -0.029117239639163017, -0.005503572523593903, 0.019995329901576042, 0.01604018174111843, 0.027762170881032944, 0.0133663946762681, 0.02296748198568821, -0.01815270446240902, 0.04880509525537491, 0.001950732315890491, -0.0670614093542099, -0.027659382671117783, -0.03562702238559723, -0.025461679324507713, 0.05496418848633766, 0.03269001096487045, -0.015636350959539413, 0.04385171830654144, -0.0037373192608356476, 0.015872275456786156, 0.013874656520783901, 0.06798689067363739, 0.01745862141251564, 0.0687338188290596, -0.00583652826026082, -0.0000550668737560045, 0.013038729317486286, -0.012873781844973564, 0.10733286291360855, 0.07769902050495148, 0.04816312715411186, -0.048336468636989594, 0.0066904909908771515, 0.00410475954413414, -0.04568164795637131, -0.00845866184681654, 0.02087954618036747, 0.024965494871139526, -0.02038646675646305, 0.03616950660943985, 0.02654065564274788, 0.02637641876935959, 0.05078532174229622, 0.014653745107352734, -0.011222342029213905, 0.010206727311015129, 0.024657201021909714, -0.005996250547468662, -0.015678415074944496, -0.027895612642169, -0.04311184585094452, 0.019738757982850075, -0.013864662498235703, -0.03257735073566437, -0.03820720314979553, -0.013615671545267105, -0.01581764966249466, -0.01296299323439598, -0.018810108304023743, -0.007337523624300957, 0.018288500607013702, 0.03318314626812935, 0.014593935571610928, 0.018261929973959923, 0.02506149187684059, 0.022916259244084358, -0.01811152882874012, 0.006022415589541197, -0.006698885466903448, -0.00721230823546648, -0.00704658729955554, 0.021295446902513504, -0.035842496901750565, 0.010148509405553341, -0.039615828543901443, 0.02970622479915619, -0.008141725324094296, -0.022442787885665894, -0.021674666553735733, 0.017454521730542183, 0.011763355694711208, -0.055991318076848984, 0.005180544685572386, 0.05977063998579979, 0.002668809611350298, -0.042258910834789276, -0.011419807560741901, -0.03241824358701706, -0.01846756972372532, -0.014964661560952663, -0.00682108523324132, -0.014605427160859108, -0.017935190349817276, 0.014023957774043083, -0.04152541980147362, 0.06526488065719604, -0.021631939336657524, 0.005764089059084654, 0.02402525767683983, -0.05100774019956589, -0.027188552543520927, -0.046707361936569214, 0.01634242944419384, -0.015673859044909477, -0.0028184878174215555, -0.007240654900670052, -0.00348119018599391, -0.014521145261824131, -0.032784149050712585, 0.007430214900523424, -0.03701647371053696, -0.0002700007753446698, -0.05525229498744011, 0.014826633036136627, 0.04249821603298187, 0.05988488718867302, 0.010201637633144855, 0.02247137948870659, 0.004470807500183582, 0.029399007558822632, -0.01416180282831192, -0.07834474742412567, -0.05007599666714668, 0.02598652057349682, -0.009056035429239273, 0.027513111010193825, 0.023777544498443604, 0.09180111438035965, 0.034569866955280304, 0.0091741057112813, -0.036334481090307236, 0.03394879773259163, -0.028002185747027397, 0.02808099053800106, 0.010837921872735023, -0.013736002147197723, -0.007676346227526665, 0.0005445329006761312, -0.0024577444419264793, -0.022904695942997932, 0.019943498075008392, -0.01856938935816288, -0.04633408412337303, 0.011168629862368107, 0.004870009142905474, -0.03360789269208908, 0.016272014006972313, -0.017599988728761673, -0.005260062403976917, -0.025419024750590324, 0.007429621182382107, -0.03683719411492348, -0.006509617902338505, -0.01369745284318924, -0.03986753895878792, -0.04278509318828583, -0.008590729907155037, -0.05360645428299904, 0.0030417044181376696, 0.05664398521184921, 0.019656158983707428, 0.012209770269691944, -0.01784217357635498, -0.007559504825621843, 0.002025798661634326, 0.06531111896038055, -0.013932953588664532, -0.02053377963602543, 0.037865228950977325, -0.03580423444509506, -0.04019904509186745, 0.010356208309531212, -0.015464873984456062, 0.05084763839840889, 0.02661905065178871, 0.02948439121246338, -0.017134588211774826, 0.056997958570718765, -0.02934196963906288, 0.0008847801364026964, -0.003091051010414958, 0.02141067199409008, 0.02199101261794567, 0.00898505374789238, 0.0017714672721922398, -0.0011584849562495947, -0.025094209238886833, 0.03323706239461899, 0.048365283757448196, 0.024083148688077927, -0.02071346342563629, 0.0485474169254303, 0.04001013934612274, -0.01115854736417532, 0.04975976049900055, -0.0046488698571920395, 0.011558054015040398, 0.024037102237343788, -0.021972501650452614, 0.015127517282962799, -0.002570114564150572, 0.016584889963269234, -0.06520146876573563, -0.016202062368392944, -0.03957931324839592, -0.009242701344192028, 0.021145189180970192, -0.06856326758861542, 0.010829100385308266, 0.028008492663502693, -0.035712830722332, 0.03208471089601517, 0.022218231111764908, -0.009405958466231823, 0.025797264650464058, 0.030415084213018417, -0.03204519674181938, 0.016768652945756912, 0.06823024898767471, 0.009668850339949131, 0.05630653351545334, -0.014144363813102245, 0.048579275608062744, -0.04356527328491211, -0.04402291774749756, -0.0131298266351223, 0.0018541563767939806, -0.032694261521101, 0.040418416261672974, -0.036326948553323746, -0.03278306499123573, 0.019519511610269547, -0.027994077652692795, 0.018801216036081314, 0.011552014388144016, 0.006467089522629976, 0.0006521362229250371, 0.038536351174116135, 0.004449386615306139, 0.006522849667817354, 0.010959303006529808, 0.015093761496245861, -0.004810913000255823, 0.014136180281639099, -0.0006273911567404866, 0.04901467263698578, 0.00966870877891779, 0.019951608031988144, -0.0089025367051363, 0.025766151025891304, -0.03360987827181816, -0.021967506036162376, -0.031160837039351463, -0.009398411959409714, -0.017595306038856506, -0.04080018028616905, -0.009450847283005714, -0.033158596605062485, 0.004186240956187248, 0.018145764246582985, 0.01569322496652603, -0.009825404733419418, 0.00577190425246954, -0.005966342519968748, -0.03149811550974846, 0.0365741141140461, 0.001277512521483004, -0.0239085853099823, -0.06096351146697998, -0.02923395298421383, 0.035570740699768066, -0.016165154054760933, -0.0018395681399852037, -0.008273853920400143, -0.03875551372766495, 0.04047102853655815, 0.020116640254855156, -0.001988237490877509, 0.026538198813796043, -0.024201393127441406, 0.04811178147792816, -0.05735883116722107, 0.04452216252684593, -0.006711992435157299, -0.0358675979077816, -0.03470567241311073, -0.00859460886567831, -0.011860889382660389, 0.03526543080806732, 0.029743285849690437, -0.009180094115436077, 0.0027245632372796535, -0.024845514446496964, 0.0038641849532723427, -0.004086334258317947, -0.06757815182209015, 0.049137573689222336, 0.014116846956312656, -0.035365812480449677, -0.01698782481253147, -0.02433610148727894, 0.011435490101575851, 0.030941981822252274, 0.022848883643746376, 0.03617246821522713, -0.010779399424791336, -0.030689459294080734, -0.0226985402405262, 0.025620894506573677, 0.02145977132022381, 0.008796273730695248, 0.05285691097378731, 0.0030487370677292347, 0.007995912805199623, 0.0544024296104908, 0.004883019719272852, -0.039034079760313034, 0.0001544351689517498, -0.0373879075050354, -0.011594422161579132, -0.017121756449341774, -0.028059253469109535, 0.01604929380118847, -0.06794001162052155, 0.020203111693263054, 0.01957046426832676, -0.04846203699707985, -0.007765443529933691, 0.05283385142683983, 0.023709386587142944, 0.06385136395692825, -0.027856752276420593, 0.04622704163193703, 0.010909836739301682, -0.03418128937482834, 0.0272917952388525, 0.03532247245311737, 0.0333721898496151, -0.031113389879465103, 0.023810839280486107, 0.02987121231853962, -0.02245006337761879, -0.006341416854411364, -0.013864926062524319, 0.013543106615543365, -0.034533627331256866, -0.006351706106215715, 0.01905165985226631, -0.05205581709742546, 0.029504651203751564, -0.00498233875259757, 0.002592338714748621, 0.04299749433994293, -0.056302666664123535, -0.023633183911442757, -0.0775943398475647, 0.008135195821523666, -0.02025553025305271, -0.013619436882436275, -0.00785527192056179, 0.022516902536153793, 0.006082694046199322, 0.00923011265695095, 0.03702692314982414, -0.0350349061191082, 0.015016984194517136, -0.00926100742071867, -0.003193204989656806, -0.023012064397335052, 0.0028648236766457558, -0.022993577644228935, -0.021536245942115784, 0.005289784632623196, -0.0504121258854866, 0.03582955151796341, 0.03182552382349968, -0.002416052855551243, -0.014830909669399261, -0.029758907854557037, -0.014543772675096989, 0.007883270271122456, -0.029208827763795853, -0.00395521055907011, -0.0619351863861084, 0.021712947636842728, -0.019953301176428795, -0.0073571596294641495 ]
<p>As you know, there are many password generators out there to increase computer security.</p> <p>Suppose I am given such a password (say, a string of letters, numbers, symbols, etc.), is there a way for me to test how random it is? Is there some sort of index for this measurement?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
37,247
[ -0.047947145998477936, -0.016666505485773087, -0.0016055954620242119, -0.040962737053632736, 0.03318197280168533, 0.03727083280682564, -0.004066552501171827, -0.03611014410853386, 0.002011552220210433, -0.02990814298391342, 0.06741432100534439, 0.04770074039697647, 0.03271079808473587, 0.051265425980091095, 0.01769542507827282, -0.016896864399313927, -0.036771368235349655, 0.016516605392098427, -0.01240759901702404, -0.01211378164589405, 0.02338361367583275, 0.0194977018982172, -0.013719321228563786, -0.032178767025470734, -0.025365877896547318, 0.008680815808475018, 0.02061595395207405, -0.05280637741088867, 0.02716544270515442, 0.06702187657356262, -0.016784759238362312, -0.03207353875041008, 0.05586177110671997, 0.032769013196229935, 0.04650717228651047, -0.02431027963757515, -0.019029943272471428, -0.043742939829826355, -0.02225928194820881, 0.041192200034856796, -0.006051116622984409, -0.025501850992441177, -0.018759243190288544, 0.042417436838150024, 0.010328514501452446, 0.01983392797410488, -0.03974365070462227, -0.021482735872268677, -0.0040264311246573925, -0.04670865461230278, 0.0842801183462143, 0.006083467975258827, 0.021007588133215904, 0.03415447473526001, -0.0260159969329834, -0.028950702399015427, 0.03935687243938446, 0.07043571770191193, -0.0491359680891037, -0.018690967932343483, -0.006484452169388533, -0.02566547691822052, 0.0020173992961645126, -0.04432474076747894, -0.04917113110423088, 0.030458344146609306, 0.007600450422614813, -0.029203418642282486, 0.053043805062770844, -0.0422910712659359, -0.006281127687543631, 0.013173420913517475, 0.042110491544008255, -0.009614693932235241, 0.023035632446408272, -0.030168402940034866, 0.03593624383211136, 0.027878180146217346, 0.035029467195272446, 0.05226539820432663, -0.00883482862263918, -0.00470051309093833, 0.020702524110674858, 0.025960179045796394, 0.047994352877140045, -0.008774515241384506, 0.04477069899439812, -0.024763086810708046, 0.017111346125602722, 0.041921503841876984, 0.02058527246117592, -0.018589552491903305, 0.00442995922639966, 0.006667514331638813, -0.06299951672554016, -0.00014921920956112444, -0.02774987742304802, 0.04923676699399948, -0.0018819546094164252, -0.004227170255035162, 0.012350069358944893, -0.02895926684141159, 0.03882278874516487, 0.04806302487850189, -0.025339309126138687, -0.018087318167090416, -0.002808860968798399, 0.011574718169867992, 0.0032256687991321087, 0.00033234196598641574, 0.01268846821039915, 0.01481558009982109, -0.0031390313524752855, -0.013218119740486145, 0.03306339681148529, 0.00861485954374075, -0.04476293548941612, -0.02681574411690235, 0.03486248478293419, 0.04058258235454559, 0.0013559553772211075, -0.01715472899377346, 0.030591271817684174, -0.05519399419426918, -0.002153437351807952, 0.017711658030748367, 0.0356854684650898, 0.00022258947137743235, -0.048586323857307434, 0.066674143075943, -0.031541384756565094, -0.038815680891275406, 0.05714493617415428, -0.0019320218125358224, 0.05998501181602478, 0.010905877687036991, -0.12386883050203323, -0.06353407353162766, 0.03598634526133537, -0.016368845477700233, -0.010695182718336582, -0.05541563406586647, 0.030488552525639534, 0.026192763820290565, 0.02455434948205948, 0.0037018589209765196, 0.055282630026340485, -0.020291389897465706, -0.008416503667831421, 0.0162764023989439, -0.04091224819421768, -0.015977632254362106, 0.032482169568538666, -0.03489898145198822, 0.0112279849126935, -0.03728900104761124, 0.038732659071683884, 0.022480202838778496, -0.007418860215693712, -0.020557468757033348, 0.015452364459633827, 0.011160902678966522, -0.01823762059211731, 0.01791420392692089, 0.0007208219612948596, -0.0457007959485054, 0.08762034773826599, 0.027214037254452705, 0.017103297635912895, 0.017169289290905, 0.01098655629903078, 0.02171703800559044, 0.027880243957042694, -0.007426893338561058, 0.09123209118843079, -0.035318076610565186, -0.0200845617800951, 0.006139405071735382, 0.04440375417470932, 0.011595050804316998, -0.03469126299023628, -0.026359811425209045, 0.019412118941545486, 0.033834293484687805, 0.03808067739009857, -0.008665818721055984, 0.003097197273746133, -0.012587006203830242, 0.014264113269746304, -0.03505929186940193, -0.024465439841151237, -0.05986576899886131, 0.029895124956965446, -0.0007192917400971055, -0.030294300988316536, 0.013495937921106815, 0.0017339722253382206, 0.031125042587518692, -0.03417220339179039, -0.02135983482003212, -0.0631629228591919, -0.018071919679641724, 0.014218402095139027, -0.03459005057811737, -0.045597635209560394, 0.036133382469415665, 0.026885412633419037, -0.02942018210887909, 0.06515991687774658, -0.02267363667488098, -0.05982571095228195, -0.012499544769525528, -0.046188127249479294, 0.012155607342720032, -0.015521753579378128, -0.000517719192430377, 0.04831414297223091, 0.010809004306793213, 0.021309616044163704, 0.004158839583396912, -0.006212181877344847, 0.052492573857307434, 0.025925032794475555, 0.07612151652574539, 0.01472301036119461, -0.017159199342131615, 0.023747213184833527, -0.025791876018047333, -0.00729404715821147, -0.03858039900660515, -0.032820675522089005, -0.014864874072372913, 0.013621634803712368, 0.01821807399392128, -0.053753647953271866, 0.02980426885187626, 0.07409831881523132, 0.03231709077954292, 0.01907600834965706, 0.05286983773112297, -0.0008143544546328485, 0.02889503352344036, -0.04116010293364525, 0.029501216486096382, 0.00467835646122694, 0.029271479696035385, 0.02042129449546337, 0.017851462587714195, -0.003672921098768711, 0.017706891521811485, -0.009988950565457344, 0.02155827358365059, 0.00575238186866045, 0.01847686618566513, -0.060068752616643906, -0.0655284896492958, 0.03377550467848778, -0.02051573060452938, -0.008319106884300709, 0.00700749084353447, 0.002229298697784543, 0.010550501756370068, 0.006354156881570816, -0.03598969057202339, 0.014497688040137291, 0.014659334905445576, -0.020197004079818726, -0.04237635061144829, 0.037634894251823425, 0.0029584867879748344, 0.040868960320949554, -0.016962187364697456, 0.029254721477627754, -0.04805903881788254, 0.03814542666077614, 0.030142273753881454, -0.029789850115776062, 0.007976398803293705, -0.032120075076818466, -0.034481149166822433, -0.0008161139558069408, -0.026116400957107544, -0.022216107696294785, 0.003820236772298813, -0.05981507897377014, -0.006642480380833149, 0.02180308662354946, -0.031847864389419556, 0.034141261130571365, -0.01269396673887968, 0.011321676895022392, 0.03646799921989441, -0.0280819870531559, -0.04387485980987549, -0.007779640611261129, -0.03618212789297104, 0.0005953270592726767, -0.02973165735602379, -0.019068658351898193, 0.016527708619832993, -0.00843697227537632, -0.048434097319841385, 0.0404944010078907, -0.0332636684179306, -0.01700718328356743, -0.021592386066913605, -0.03185269236564636, 0.02562478929758072, -0.016120633110404015, 0.017117317765951157, 0.038742128759622574, -0.021851101890206337, -0.021302856504917145, -0.06115896999835968, -0.05839575454592705, 0.02885403111577034, -0.008553672581911087, 0.03475691005587578, 0.01549341157078743, -0.04516902565956116, 0.06245128810405731, 0.01803627982735634, -0.047294262796640396, -0.02031050994992256, -0.03339630365371704, -0.014945685863494873, -0.04514370486140251, -0.007600678596645594, 0.009524357505142689, -0.031186996027827263, 0.00876796804368496, 0.004309382289648056, -0.002785676158964634, 0.07615851610898972, -0.03173007816076279, -0.011224323883652687, 0.03932712972164154, 0.01321222074329853, -0.0054730819538235664, 0.07179030030965805, 0.014464505948126316, -0.04612916707992554, -0.01396973803639412, 0.040271300822496414, 0.0351271815598011, 0.009334183298051357, -0.014041713438928127, 0.022078735753893852, -0.0015280040679499507, 0.03991955146193504, -0.04583409056067467, 0.055144332349300385, -0.02217062935233116, -0.002075622323900461, -0.004724262282252312, 0.042702965438365936, 0.019599054008722305, -0.012634685263037682, 0.03318440541625023, 0.035826459527015686, 0.04333910718560219, -0.01547933742403984, -0.016338244080543518, -0.01630411110818386, -0.004691725131124258, -0.005281725898385048, -0.003245512256398797, -0.013127140700817108, 0.025766676291823387, 0.050879236310720444, 0.06903418153524399, 0.007921488024294376, -0.013449311256408691, 0.004356239922344685, -0.059924639761447906, -0.025835763663053513, -0.014632712118327618, 0.08573830127716064, -0.0039019305258989334, 0.03702062368392944, 0.028948897495865822, -0.02061590552330017, 0.012045422568917274, 0.015294152311980724, -0.07628455758094788, 0.022652072831988335, -0.04274166747927666, -0.045036133378744125, 0.006563523784279823, -0.03630466386675835, 0.004092082381248474, -0.04116760939359665, -0.034046612679958344, 0.04081643372774124, 0.014465130865573883, -0.05958138406276703, 0.013026540167629719, -0.01750822551548481, -0.0061044939793646336, 0.028524121269583702, 0.04109682887792587, -0.012026879005134106, -0.030953053385019302, 0.007986261509358883, 0.028899312019348145, -0.001020623603835702, 0.0025929659605026245, 0.00755809061229229, 0.012762609869241714, -0.0019711079075932503, 0.02960354834794998, 0.01944289356470108, 0.007528398185968399, -0.0384552925825119, 0.0036768505815416574, -0.03364446014165878, 0.05225077271461487, 0.04056207835674286, 0.006170213688164949, -0.00032415747409686446, -0.050205472856760025, -0.0160050205886364, 0.023558788001537323, -0.02281155250966549, -0.019656188786029816, 0.028048163279891014, 0.024073198437690735, 0.022573664784431458, -0.05661962181329727, 0.024320919066667557, 0.08003354072570801, -0.0020051412284374237, -0.010444799438118935, -0.004625435918569565, -0.0013421844923868775, 0.008742445148527622, -0.012932791374623775, -0.03985774144530296, 0.019513260573148727, 0.01059325598180294, 0.02236987091600895, 0.010671337135136127, -0.042250871658325195, -0.052353180944919586, 0.002971382113173604, 0.014682523906230927, 0.034406863152980804, 0.0031122490763664246, 0.02138591557741165, 0.05267508327960968, -0.014839621260762215, -0.017623333260416985, 0.021588383242487907, -0.04185870289802551, -0.0594714917242527, 0.024881651625037193, 0.07515396177768707, 0.019527383148670197, -0.03632977977395058, -0.006544602103531361, -0.04547083377838135, -0.017756063491106033, 0.055721208453178406, -0.011849143542349339, 0.037352144718170166, 0.005051400512456894, -0.011310800909996033, -0.047681599855422974, 0.012180322781205177, -0.01895434968173504, 0.05929829552769661, -0.006660897750407457, 0.01737469807267189, -0.040506280958652496, 0.011116432026028633, -0.03628004714846611, 0.020041167736053467, 0.03552180901169777, 0.046064797788858414, -0.04843621328473091, 0.02208658494055271, 0.02182265929877758, 0.024835333228111267, -0.023175228387117386, -0.04369065538048744, 0.034650351852178574, 0.017198791727423668, -0.004165976773947477, 0.03426920250058174, -0.02637985534965992, -0.03753635659813881, 0.004476877860724926, -0.0449124351143837, 0.0072066159918904305, 0.03569365292787552, -0.02506125159561634, 0.05267735943198204, 0.04832804575562477, 0.04295210912823677, 0.04311704635620117, 0.05791879817843437, 0.03664766997098923, -0.0013549593277275562, -0.031427353620529175, 0.010979815386235714, -0.05194469168782234, -0.0014051452744752169, -0.03474428132176399, 0.020076347514986992, -0.03884410113096237, 0.0461483895778656, 0.005098132416605949, 0.019599923864006996, -0.008052845485508442, -0.024706903845071793, -0.043686967343091965, 0.007265802472829819, 0.027458559721708298, -0.0015449259663000703, 0.028510507196187973, -0.010947144590318203, -0.03974317014217377, -0.02899135649204254, 0.0008767760009504855, 0.0016834267880767584, 0.025169193744659424, -0.0031662997789680958, -0.019908852875232697, -0.003278717864304781, 0.007819080725312233, -0.018232809379696846, 0.008489974774420261, -0.013990642502903938, 0.08940523117780685, -0.022423377260565758, -0.002047277055680752, 0.004333848599344492, -0.041392307728528976, 0.03315570205450058, 0.02042737789452076, -0.0019928112160414457, 0.052457403391599655, -0.0024645018856972456, 0.05568638816475868, -0.05468988046050072, -0.02516072802245617, -0.04661976546049118, -0.03391708806157112, 0.011273881420493126, -0.005439904984086752, 0.004376009572297335, -0.024627437815070152, 0.029929740354418755, -0.03110499307513237, -0.011248292401432991, -0.002463047858327627, 0.025183644145727158, 0.012253262102603912, -0.0020942636765539646, 0.000356155214831233, -0.013558933511376381, 0.09615550190210342, 0.04559064656496048, -0.01320731732994318, 0.020548449829220772, -0.026819130405783653, 0.022674864158034325, -0.010133394971489906, -0.0035629835911095142, -0.022683829069137573, -0.027798155322670937, 0.013361126184463501, 0.020703159272670746, 0.06441309303045273, -0.009858805686235428, 0.02830141969025135, -0.007587803062051535, -0.015858955681324005, -0.016447344794869423, -0.05455644801259041, 0.00016401642642449588, 0.01818281225860119, 0.007325052283704281, -0.03686244785785675, -0.0019567140843719244, -0.032285045832395554, 0.02023482322692871, 0.018678193911910057, 0.023602060973644257, -0.002346097258850932, -0.020960573107004166, 0.06903672963380814, -0.007603023201227188, -0.010877465829253197, -0.02442457713186741, -0.00925315823405981, -0.00247924099676311, 0.02847220003604889, -0.0027939127758145332, 0.021977698430418968, -0.002717940602451563, -0.028957992792129517, -0.034512266516685486, -0.03356849402189255, -0.047301035374403, 0.05282847583293915, -0.0006900466978549957, 0.043813079595565796, 0.05530513823032379, 0.0017034990014508367, 0.022286266088485718, 0.034863416105508804, -0.016023196280002594, -0.029696688055992126, 0.002909447532147169, 0.031268712133169174, 0.009710054844617844, 0.02190002053976059, 0.010556424036622047, -0.0025287282187491655, 0.03461182862520218, 0.03296859562397003, 0.027713479474186897, 0.03881637006998062, 0.04312615841627121, -0.020163455978035927, -0.01966792717576027, 0.03397909551858902, -0.05502646043896675, 0.0032533847261220217, 0.005705457180738449, -0.007102865260094404, 0.02962033450603485, -0.00674684951081872, -0.02715209871530533, 0.0029357275925576687, -0.007850268855690956, -0.015463187359273434, 0.028142578899860382, 0.04027455672621727, -0.010737012140452862, 0.0204220712184906, -0.020721064880490303, 0.02839438058435917, -0.02261296659708023, 0.014374947175383568, 0.001090509002096951, -0.09099988639354706, 0.028729109093546867, -0.007988396100699902, -0.07086708396673203, 0.008963827975094318, 0.02517065964639187, 0.0001991696481127292, -0.002786165801808238, -0.03256913274526596, 0.04826050624251366, 0.017412573099136353, 0.058946944773197174, -0.025789331644773483, 0.06374402344226837, -0.009821433573961258, 0.007296777330338955, -0.007025136612355709, 0.00091890140902251, 0.0715736448764801, 0.041744522750377655, 0.03397378697991371, -0.09233909100294113, -0.022237367928028107, -0.019464479759335518, 0.03170216828584671, 0.002682177582755685, 0.030024578794836998, 0.009861518628895283, -0.0037262840196490288, 0.02261578105390072, 0.006565315183252096, -0.037047769874334335, 0.01927294209599495, 0.05932334065437317, -0.037307728081941605, -0.005924207624047995, 0.014319155365228653, 0.028285857290029526, 0.004438413307070732, -0.0014057495864108205, -0.04327290877699852, 0.011406034231185913, 0.0002779683272819966, -0.030970606952905655, -0.002131089800968766, -0.019599828869104385, 0.03645876795053482, 0.012262584641575813, -0.003721383400261402, 0.0025663753040134907, 0.024343525990843773, 0.011350411921739578, 0.021665865555405617, -0.015532548539340496, 0.01357555016875267, -0.0027302014641463757, -0.009346824139356613, 0.0723256915807724, 0.02703329548239708, -0.01314596552401781, -0.0010861706687137485, 0.0353274792432785, -0.02712244912981987, -0.043112821877002716, -0.013266549445688725, 0.00928391795605421, -0.002769750077277422, -0.008353373035788536, -0.01948457583785057, -0.005916777066886425, -0.026491105556488037, -0.03947652876377106, -0.026936158537864685, -0.0018041968578472733, 0.039879024028778076, -0.03979010879993439, -0.032094936817884445, -0.029513422399759293, 0.03518625721335411, -0.058833539485931396, 0.019723499193787575, 0.004481139127165079, -0.030608784407377243, 0.032732076942920685, -0.015393158420920372, 0.007483541965484619, 0.020018665120005608, -0.03332772105932236, -0.011516621336340904, -0.033606961369514465, -0.04903632402420044, -0.01007699966430664, -0.010132539086043835, -0.013401071541011333, 0.01681039109826088, 0.01237172819674015, 0.0038256680127233267, 0.02521555870771408, 0.002497087698429823, 0.039200395345687866, -0.02357291802763939, -0.0008421286474913359, -0.049204327166080475, -0.02000518888235092, 0.06621572375297546, 0.04554362595081329, 0.004587054718285799, -0.013306423090398312, 0.01642041839659214, 0.01713423803448677, 0.015174450352787971, -0.013038101606070995, 0.023794138804078102, 0.000018368395103607327, -0.02857217751443386, 0.035218190401792526, -0.01343154814094305, 0.04689900577068329, 0.07238774001598358, -0.012985235080122948, -0.008476879447698593, 0.033588707447052, -0.03867317736148834, -0.0162282083183527, -0.003096861531957984, -0.060403235256671906, -0.051254428923130035, -0.014241565950214863, -0.020616965368390083, -0.013301664032042027, -0.036947283893823624, -0.0318945087492466, -0.015003113076090813, 0.005538857541978359, 0.00987928919494152, -0.014309268444776535, -0.020769229158759117, -0.008770156651735306, -0.0002655664866324514, -0.03803184628486633, -0.008851069957017899, -0.0012777047231793404, -0.03903966769576073, 0.02459293231368065, 0.002951643895357847, -0.02243727073073387, 0.004686558153480291, -0.012973851524293423, 0.012653672136366367, 0.04507707059383392, 0.027737563475966454, 0.012387522496283054, -0.00222034752368927, 0.012343844398856163, -0.017367294058203697, 0.05249761790037155, -0.03692421317100525, -0.03338688984513283, 0.017915403470396996, -0.06925466656684875, -0.00026963267009705305, 0.03477645292878151, -0.030556293204426765, 0.01097418274730444, 0.05709925293922424, -0.03369278833270073, 0.023541653528809547, 0.04359922185540199, -0.012853492982685566, -0.018142927438020706, -0.018459338694810867, 0.009168097749352455, 0.011774145998060703, 0.03706128150224686, -0.01494416780769825, -0.015512053854763508, -0.014834195375442505, -0.012674057856202126, 0.02680116705596447, 0.011171182617545128, -0.015301988460123539, 0.02551107294857502, 0.047199469059705734, -0.045301977545022964, 0.015012240968644619, -0.034056391566991806, -0.013051060028374195, 0.014334888197481632, -0.013079709373414516, 0.030904805287718773, 0.007718240842223167, -0.006073773372918367, -0.07808449864387512, 0.00008071024058153853, 0.02430695854127407, -0.008604256436228752, 0.02614164724946022, -0.021929841488599777, -0.025212764739990234, 0.03226567432284355, -0.06380479037761688, 0.00619934406131506, -0.008621945045888424, -0.02644689939916134, -0.04687092453241348, 0.013383121229708195, 0.0013043261133134365, 0.015583084896206856, 0.002086133696138859, 0.045168619602918625, 0.03598126769065857, 0.012971742078661919, -0.0271596722304821, -0.0036502948496490717, 0.0012242755619809031, 0.03266368433833122, 0.0019954207818955183, -0.022653095424175262, 0.022635480388998985, -0.03194814175367355, -0.02741389162838459, 0.0187892597168684, -0.020389804616570473, 0.033438071608543396, 0.021680885925889015, 0.03965693339705467, 0.02617770805954933, 0.04763439670205116, 0.04560486972332001, 0.003277538577094674, -0.04288335517048836, -0.011479303240776062, -0.012584742158651352, 0.04366607964038849, 0.016371918842196465, 0.008282923139631748, 0.01467100903391838, 0.0060586873441934586, 0.019855132326483727, 0.01733514852821827, -0.01616881787776947, -0.012235729955136776, 0.009102936834096909, -0.02020365186035633, 0.00702457781881094, -0.01036052592098713, 0.010442014783620834, -0.03890227898955345, 0.0121909873560071, 0.008733958005905151, -0.012453597038984299, -0.0348941907286644, 0.023396072909235954, 0.006176261231303215, -0.025185806676745415, 0.03337955102324486, 0.012699109502136707, -0.005010846070945263, -0.07955332845449448, -0.004775728099048138, -0.02147296629846096, 0.011272624135017395, 0.012057292275130749, -0.012001239694654942, 0.011110189370810986, 0.047932736575603485, 0.006959059275686741, -0.03578856214880943, -0.011510803364217281, -0.009412483312189579, -0.02382022887468338, -0.05076500028371811, 0.06306849420070648, -0.009580460377037525, 0.004692964721471071, -0.07948780059814453, 0.03258752077817917, -0.013341247104108334, 0.014309336431324482, 0.042582351714372635, -0.05303508788347244, -0.018664725124835968, -0.043617866933345795, 0.03735959529876709, 0.03491581976413727, -0.055658500641584396, 0.010328888893127441, -0.027191905304789543, -0.05385853350162506, -0.03345032408833504, -0.026393594220280647, 0.0024098714347928762, -0.0020917747169733047, 0.011303374543786049, -0.03946336358785629, -0.044002994894981384, -0.02090744860470295, -0.005219236481934786, 0.03852739557623863, 0.010292678140103817, 0.006646609399467707, 0.0025626278948038816, -0.03818386420607567, 0.037891775369644165, 0.01421742420643568, 0.032604657113552094, -0.04476764053106308, 0.014482307247817516, -0.017618833109736443, -0.04653996229171753, -0.0060332720167934895, 0.015316716395318508, -0.013089579530060291, -0.024628184735774994, -0.04032432660460472, -0.0028419981244951487, -0.05747225135564804, -0.0020116877276450396, 0.06390153616666794, -0.022816672921180725, 0.03240576386451721, -0.03724268078804016, 0.03749250993132591, 0.032536253333091736, -0.02120744064450264, -0.00044022174552083015, 0.035334181040525436, 0.019890302792191505, -0.03549207001924515, 0.03686165064573288, 0.020696667954325676, -0.02712932415306568, 0.02410222217440605, 0.05816168338060379, 0.020938165485858917, -0.05172659456729889, -0.019107623025774956, 0.01869395561516285, -0.03989211097359657, -0.0004405069339554757, 0.0028983503580093384, -0.04919316992163658, 0.0510777086019516, -0.0046030860394239426, 0.009517219848930836, -0.06059793010354042, 0.0016920813359320164, -0.013141382485628128, 0.00962250865995884, 0.019222119823098183, 0.010158896446228027, -0.02153628133237362, 0.026798775419592857, -0.01246369443833828, 0.029744314029812813, 0.04161018133163452, -0.052597593516111374, 0.028729407116770744, 0.008026525378227234, 0.014582573436200619, -0.031723134219646454, -0.02133103832602501, -0.039443232119083405, -0.031462110579013824, 0.05164032056927681, 0.031412310898303986, 0.017143694683909416, 0.006529491860419512, -0.005513401702046394, 0.012457641772925854, 0.04120982810854912, -0.005870680324733257, 0.02043924108147621, -0.04897847771644592, 0.05525839328765869, -0.03404835984110832, -0.011202443391084671 ]
<p>I know PCA and PLS are considered as alternative method to each other. But I am thinking about a kind of combination of the two in case of lots of predictors with little variability.</p> <p>In that case, when I run 1-component PLS with original predictors, it does not produce a meaningful model in terms of prediction. But if I first compute 10-20 PCA components and run 1-component PLS with those PC scores as predictors, practically, the model is quite good in terms of prediction power. But I would like to know why.</p> <p>Can anybody explain why this is better than 1-component PLS with original predictors?</p>
74,383
[ -0.019549190998077393, 0.02018110454082489, -0.016836315393447876, -0.030365442857146263, 0.051470931619405746, -0.010250169783830643, 0.00420052045956254, -0.030549267306923866, 0.022592583671212196, -0.02666713483631611, 0.011784939095377922, -0.005804154556244612, 0.040191225707530975, 0.0004821530601475388, -0.005410166457295418, -0.00433820765465498, 0.020526885986328125, 0.029824428260326385, -0.0015484124887734652, -0.0037664598785340786, -0.000337436911650002, 0.04124921187758446, 0.020472586154937744, -0.00900533702224493, 0.007870991714298725, 0.0507904477417469, 0.02615063451230526, -0.01439285185188055, 0.019444147124886513, 0.034128449857234955, -0.03022758662700653, -0.0066381338983774185, 0.00024393066996708512, 0.06528278440237045, 0.02434856817126274, -0.03593279793858528, -0.023581190034747124, -0.006304566748440266, -0.007086916361004114, 0.05557956546545029, -0.02594378963112831, -0.0403212234377861, -0.0009080759482458234, 0.009519781917333603, 0.00012377453094813973, 0.02753273956477642, -0.00881184171885252, -0.04708223044872284, 0.025842970237135887, -0.05525157228112221, 0.0813201516866684, 0.0033995972480624914, 0.03050912916660309, -0.008918045088648796, -0.02134181559085846, 0.0111691327765584, 0.07880764454603195, 0.08066406846046448, -0.02205168455839157, -0.08130203932523727, -0.00034757860703393817, 0.023355362936854362, 0.027917295694351196, -0.009951439686119556, -0.02289072424173355, 0.038150232285261154, 0.005856918636709452, -0.013741407543420792, 0.03136586397886276, -0.025692444294691086, 0.023927895352244377, -0.014117680490016937, 0.01370753813534975, 0.013660335913300514, -0.01817888580262661, 0.00352220656350255, -0.0005773774464614689, 0.01833871752023697, 0.048209965229034424, 0.022968757897615433, 0.03676849976181984, 0.028041934594511986, 0.0164084043353796, 0.031971655786037445, 0.027264704927802086, 0.004490911960601807, 0.04406695440411568, -0.014228838495910168, -0.007594861555844545, 0.00565370125696063, -0.012415035627782345, 0.016311902552843094, 0.04686478525400162, 0.03188950940966606, -0.018474603071808815, 0.012926710769534111, -0.008098230697214603, 0.03162708133459091, 0.009864836931228638, -0.013708601705729961, 0.0007149981101974845, -0.03458237648010254, -0.008306173607707024, 0.040047723799943924, -0.014000692404806614, -0.04375816881656647, -0.03168218210339546, -0.02486477792263031, 0.004581885877996683, -0.018031349405646324, 0.023332344368100166, 0.04611637815833092, 0.009032427333295345, -0.0019652044866234064, 0.0029005680698901415, 0.007745938841253519, 0.015398661606013775, -0.02498459815979004, 0.018592827022075653, 0.0675470381975174, -0.0051805004477500916, -0.03168719261884689, 0.021734174340963364, -0.018456321209669113, -0.02094053477048874, -0.014405513182282448, -0.0013463798677548766, -0.0031517271418124437, -0.04009147733449936, 0.05177442356944084, -0.014334648847579956, -0.048106849193573, 0.05934973061084747, 0.02684258483350277, 0.019020654261112213, 0.03002389520406723, -0.11807417869567871, -0.013469777069985867, 0.04511401057243347, -0.06712888181209564, 0.023399554193019867, -0.050674453377723694, 0.010761207900941372, 0.025217445567250252, 0.04689207300543785, 0.0001401050976710394, 0.034930597990751266, 0.023987457156181335, 0.02901821956038475, -0.0021173860877752304, -0.03011002019047737, -0.029273366555571556, -0.013459683395922184, -0.03958658128976822, -0.03157082200050354, -0.08976013958454132, 0.009148454293608665, 0.0474681630730629, 0.0053932215087115765, 0.0003983596106991172, -0.0052213724702596664, 0.001931675593368709, -0.012918543070554733, -0.033339839428663254, 0.00908102560788393, 0.00035881533403880894, 0.031504783779382706, -0.010956774465739727, 0.04027262702584267, 0.01808283105492592, -0.003397925291210413, -0.015827488154172897, 0.03671355918049812, 0.05603738874197006, 0.012857569381594658, 0.019945068284869194, -0.025375941768288612, -0.005408930126577616, 0.008728895336389542, 0.0014857780188322067, -0.04991210997104645, -0.03279514238238335, -0.020461758598685265, 0.03566977381706238, 0.01965576410293579, 0.052983757108449936, -0.0026690198574215174, -0.052387770265340805, 0.040845490992069244, -0.019474731758236885, -0.042943406850099564, -0.07212208956480026, 0.023767339065670967, -0.0011191496159881353, -0.014593617990612984, 0.03410988301038742, 0.01088765263557434, 0.009058983996510506, -0.0024587754160165787, 0.002983130980283022, -0.06268935650587082, 0.0067191096022725105, 0.01166953518986702, -0.0421464703977108, -0.003730255179107189, 0.04992608726024628, 0.008721559308469296, -0.029134903103113174, 0.033337753266096115, -0.045251961797475815, -0.07153227180242538, 0.015172133222222328, -0.07583609968423843, 0.02138051576912403, -0.004128142725676298, -0.03103865310549736, 0.008432296104729176, 0.0016568161081522703, -0.03617732971906662, 0.03395500034093857, -0.07867109775543213, 0.07559241354465485, 0.06597719341516495, 0.01186590176075697, 0.006775094196200371, -0.004833715036511421, 0.025223033502697945, 0.01106161717325449, -0.0357961542904377, 0.0053898729383945465, -0.035451412200927734, 0.020341113209724426, 0.07078314572572708, 0.05020270496606827, -0.05678101256489754, 0.012655890546739101, 0.06061835214495659, 0.014113204553723335, 0.03994100168347359, 0.037401750683784485, 0.0348898246884346, -0.045417845249176025, 0.014314549043774605, 0.011343574151396751, -0.017776180058717728, 0.005574164446443319, 0.0026793950237333775, 0.007417123764753342, 0.0288733821362257, 0.020164206624031067, -0.024834634736180305, 0.054279375821352005, 0.002862120745703578, 0.015298394486308098, -0.012247712351381779, -0.02969999425113201, 0.023063471540808678, -0.029093891382217407, 0.013801045715808868, -0.007445633411407471, 0.04873605817556381, -0.0030672072898596525, -0.029967792332172394, -0.025989213958382607, 0.010276352986693382, 0.03992866724729538, -0.05597633495926857, 0.00661061517894268, 0.017796257510781288, -0.058858372271060944, 0.001650634570978582, -0.010776398703455925, -0.03905082494020462, -0.05581394582986832, 0.00725935772061348, 0.08969950675964355, 0.00847118441015482, 0.051802314817905426, -0.015099971555173397, -0.056020401418209076, 0.033036038279533386, -0.005898407194763422, -0.016330793499946594, -0.005629577208310366, -0.061774566769599915, -0.02018357627093792, -0.026187509298324585, 0.0029260562732815742, 0.026293696835637093, -0.008884447626769543, -0.02492121048271656, 0.020953254774212837, -0.008012835867702961, -0.06748485565185547, -0.016730278730392456, -0.022825222462415695, 0.017469456419348717, 0.005264632869511843, -0.06413213908672333, 0.029549386352300644, 0.03635096549987793, -0.062259599566459656, 0.0026974512729793787, -0.020617516711354256, -0.004741874523460865, 0.007584373466670513, -0.019136769697070122, -0.023277733474969864, -0.018499059602618217, -0.00409637251868844, 0.044359661638736725, -0.028418229892849922, -0.012515994720160961, -0.027090201154351234, -0.050648778676986694, 0.007129594683647156, -0.028755132108926773, 0.04772791638970375, 0.006719636265188456, -0.039959151297807693, 0.08323733508586884, -0.0013569460716098547, -0.011370209977030754, -0.046586550772190094, 0.023696094751358032, -0.06511896103620529, -0.013768226839601994, 0.02374010533094406, 0.017634784802794456, 0.015821808949112892, 0.024974174797534943, -0.012575381435453892, -0.008958907797932625, 0.07522454112768173, 0.02275897189974785, 0.006337971892207861, 0.006655754055827856, -0.0004263374721631408, -0.012520155869424343, -0.01700422912836075, -0.0012774427887052298, -0.03496229276061058, -0.010326959192752838, 0.0008068355964496732, -0.0053077819757163525, 0.00830737967044115, -0.01593368873000145, 0.01495677325874567, -0.02974781021475792, 0.049189772456884384, -0.04789356142282486, 0.001336926594376564, 0.014864885248243809, -0.014844580553472042, -0.03509978950023651, 0.04871140420436859, 0.02177152782678604, -0.00918976217508316, -0.03766065463423729, 0.033612798899412155, 0.028732961043715477, 0.011231934651732445, -0.004755297210067511, 0.008175442926585674, 0.0067926389165222645, 0.048401448875665665, 0.039209187030792236, 0.00300172483548522, 0.07541067898273468, 0.01952069252729416, 0.016769209876656532, 0.01793437823653221, -0.033078454434871674, 0.03536922484636307, -0.07831089943647385, 0.02623564936220646, -0.01979721337556839, 0.05426415055990219, 0.004489220213145018, 0.07975129038095474, 0.02891860529780388, -0.017669662833213806, -0.00839069951325655, 0.017096247524023056, -0.06086718291044235, -0.0008528419421054423, 0.013485499657690525, 0.006440525874495506, -0.020196888595819473, -0.009697629138827324, 0.01862700656056404, 0.0029927678406238556, 0.002123950282111764, 0.003522560466080904, 0.02317708171904087, -0.049476493149995804, 0.019884547218680382, -0.018128344789147377, 0.00011939727846765891, -0.015031001530587673, 0.025009222328662872, 0.02156214229762554, -0.020385416224598885, 0.03662080690264702, 0.033028218895196915, -0.026076408103108406, -0.02280779555439949, -0.017056623473763466, 0.011137313209474087, 0.025724463164806366, 0.033804457634687424, 0.004692078102380037, 0.031364187598228455, -0.022846156731247902, 0.04454409331083298, -0.004387380555272102, 0.06469037383794785, 0.031907182186841965, 0.010202179662883282, -0.0014833364402875304, -0.04030952975153923, -0.02204333245754242, 0.011805509217083454, 0.0035602645948529243, -0.013701822608709335, -0.01732596568763256, 0.005531901028007269, -0.0014898768858984113, -0.045931246131658554, -0.019563138484954834, 0.06107514724135399, 0.028338061645627022, 0.015746239572763443, -0.04749724268913269, -0.005610412452369928, -0.01106035616248846, -0.011271352879703045, 0.026082511991262436, -0.010229665786027908, -0.0067355758510529995, -0.008319893851876259, 0.027068866416811943, -0.04274897277355194, -0.022476190701127052, -0.025774547830224037, 0.025213420391082764, 0.071797214448452, -0.005019426345825195, -0.015652867034077644, 0.013960255309939384, 0.07007252424955368, 0.05683793127536774, 0.01780485361814499, 0.007424843031913042, -0.06282132118940353, -0.0030055067036300898, 0.02581627108156681, 0.04311057925224304, -0.05531458556652069, -0.028427688404917717, -0.012697960250079632, -0.0143034802749753, 0.017261099070310593, -0.015408101491630077, 0.025258608162403107, 0.016595950350165367, -0.015104323625564575, -0.048670221120119095, -0.021299678832292557, -0.03494971618056297, -0.007183848414570093, -0.04587522894144058, 0.04303351044654846, -0.023257430642843246, -0.04529668390750885, -0.03707151487469673, 0.006648818962275982, 0.014776636846363544, 0.06091805547475815, -0.03167181462049484, -0.020492663607001305, -0.004070532042533159, 0.04590926691889763, -0.013775336556136608, -0.06919790059328079, 0.0021221551578491926, 0.017028575763106346, -0.024924004450440407, 0.048892952501773834, -0.01097092591226101, -0.06073889881372452, -0.00398664828389883, -0.007944494485855103, -0.013071834109723568, -0.029374968260526657, -0.01296045072376728, 0.026889115571975708, 0.013227890245616436, -0.034026309847831726, 0.06582041829824448, -0.006109646521508694, -0.010427857749164104, -0.023944489657878876, -0.007144353352487087, 0.014228691346943378, -0.047210611402988434, -0.03503075987100601, -0.022497400641441345, -0.012152399867773056, -0.026090815663337708, 0.022642023861408234, 0.02746693603694439, 0.05683169513940811, -0.038973331451416016, 0.0029280472081154585, -0.012246141210198402, 0.042249616235494614, 0.002327853115275502, 0.005451655946671963, -0.019053084775805473, 0.024350494146347046, 0.03255018591880798, 0.020422425121068954, 0.024448426440358162, -0.00947925727814436, 0.01883867010474205, 0.02523178607225418, 0.00810008030384779, -0.012511000968515873, -0.03895864635705948, -0.009215099737048149, 0.03157749027013779, -0.0065976707264781, 0.043342627584934235, -0.02108665555715561, 0.05212194100022316, 0.060760747641325, -0.09678500145673752, 0.00045252087875269353, 0.012098908424377441, -0.025743288919329643, 0.04470869526267052, -0.05000442638993263, 0.027903633192181587, -0.050969794392585754, -0.018344642594456673, -0.07633320242166519, -0.05644397437572479, 0.03080788068473339, 0.01982974261045456, -0.015015632845461369, -0.029490139335393906, -0.0017605047905817628, -0.009300442412495613, -0.01706909015774727, -0.035611651837825775, 0.01086944155395031, -0.02365831658244133, -0.004036758095026016, 0.03163634240627289, 0.007472409401088953, 0.06145821884274483, -0.005249615292996168, 0.004023022949695587, 0.02296070009469986, -0.05145791545510292, -0.01453288085758686, -0.01575993187725544, -0.010029006749391556, -0.04043716564774513, 0.0047253151424229145, -0.037619106471538544, 0.0000826321920612827, 0.0355263277888298, -0.010063848458230495, 0.0027329223230481148, 0.01568739302456379, -0.003467647125944495, 0.008633351884782314, -0.0014582967851310968, -0.0008002604590728879, -0.03991685062646866, -0.017804255709052086, -0.00991770438849926, 0.016591141000390053, -0.016617881134152412, -0.01574898138642311, -0.0015587195521220565, 0.029565680772066116, -0.024074338376522064, 0.010424750857055187, 0.05118953064084053, -0.01726476475596428, -0.015152433887124062, -0.016460513696074486, -0.0342705100774765, 0.012942166067659855, 0.043574847280979156, 0.04154614359140396, 0.02356400154531002, 0.037781815975904465, -0.026348771527409554, -0.029260974377393723, -0.011724058538675308, 0.0019003518391400576, 0.022508228197693825, 0.010194264352321625, 0.04036077484488487, 0.05038325861096382, 0.00663601653650403, -0.03583027794957161, -0.02815287746489048, 0.003083965042605996, 0.020502813160419464, -0.023451833054423332, 0.059520162642002106, -0.020845631137490273, -0.01611991599202156, 0.01819544844329357, 0.0069977338425815105, 0.034412674605846405, 0.032218050211668015, 0.01937669701874256, 0.015010721981525421, 0.0023778530303388834, -0.00031669341842643917, -0.05004110932350159, 0.00482184486463666, -0.03591236472129822, -0.02379380352795124, -0.02056105248630047, -0.0013384312624111772, 0.05693954601883888, 0.02931535243988037, 0.0030380142852663994, -0.07456182688474655, -0.012022794224321842, -0.0017032312462106347, 0.0008224225603044033, 0.02459637261927128, 0.02804804965853691, 0.04794261232018471, -0.02003137394785881, 0.038807060569524765, 0.02595318853855133, 0.04127455875277519, -0.014139745384454727, -0.07865913957357407, -0.06242267042398453, 0.013451394625008106, -0.05042035132646561, 0.00596525426954031, 0.0007805670611560345, -0.02567862719297409, 0.009695618413388729, -0.032349176704883575, 0.0077711837366223335, -0.023717664182186127, 0.02096644975244999, -0.018085390329360962, 0.053681064397096634, 0.015735864639282227, 0.010262556374073029, 0.02021079882979393, -0.014250675216317177, 0.1200614795088768, 0.090955950319767, 0.05191309377551079, -0.05763830617070198, 0.05257852375507355, 0.015359888784587383, 0.005211568903177977, -0.02806079387664795, 0.025971654802560806, 0.015492011792957783, 0.0046659489162266254, 0.009533337317407131, 0.04353892803192139, 0.014282740652561188, -0.0026130410842597485, 0.04917836934328079, -0.06201647222042084, 0.0006499451119452715, 0.0016629862366244197, -0.017120597884058952, -0.0003135971201118082, -0.027813147753477097, 0.004707748536020517, 0.004822857212275267, 0.0027731559239327908, -0.040014609694480896, -0.008975418284535408, -0.009838850237429142, 0.0033574693370610476, -0.03785449638962746, -0.027548043057322502, -0.011308162473142147, 0.00504516065120697, 0.010069680400192738, -0.022217290475964546, 0.02759707346558571, 0.00042230705730617046, -0.015519560314714909, 0.004820949397981167, 0.045881737023591995, -0.013159367255866528, -0.04574039950966835, 0.01845538429915905, 0.022887159138917923, -0.061702582985162735, -0.005689686164259911, -0.06734741479158401, 0.036747533828020096, -0.004129304084926844, 0.043351802974939346, 0.005642573814839125, -0.00862811878323555, 0.008388867601752281, -0.03291315212845802, -0.02343684434890747, 0.03987641632556915, 0.04194216430187225, -0.006677856668829918, -0.027749955654144287, -0.04344577342271805, 0.007052296306937933, -0.01199681218713522, 0.04863279312849045, 0.01007943693548441, -0.03346775844693184, -0.01733889989554882, -0.011820372194051743, 0.03233097493648529, 0.022123079746961594, 0.026318684220314026, 0.00864608958363533, 0.01706448197364807, -0.023850547149777412, 0.0020577912218868732, 0.019168123602867126, -0.006712106056511402, 0.01130787841975689, -0.012424880638718605, -0.022268136963248253, -0.04230600222945213, -0.026232855394482613, 0.010525429621338844, -0.04192419722676277, 0.007118023466318846, -0.03846810385584831, 0.03439357504248619, 0.017450733110308647, 0.050399210304021835, 0.023778904229402542, 0.014859958551824093, -0.008549883030354977, 0.04603515937924385, 0.011906545609235764, -0.052121058106422424, -0.012466337531805038, -0.012241249904036522, -0.031898677349090576, 0.01764499768614769, 0.02566216140985489, 0.04748572036623955, 0.045593999326229095, 0.001098883105441928, -0.047582924365997314, 0.04288318008184433, -0.011438949964940548, 0.013853498734533787, -0.0026513952761888504, -0.027569452300667763, 0.011979373171925545, 0.022601023316383362, 0.016577212139964104, -0.03218105062842369, -0.019656091928482056, 0.0003876674163620919, -0.050131794065237045, 0.032132431864738464, -0.04030098766088486, -0.01804373972117901, 0.0042001428082585335, 0.016710050404071808, 0.04206325486302376, -0.03248516842722893, -0.008080676198005676, -0.028385480865836143, 0.014185206033289433, -0.014446783810853958, -0.04504772648215294, 0.001071695238351822, 0.00879339687526226, 0.0005552169168367982, -0.017077386379241943, 0.05588164180517197, 0.0037191922310739756, 0.013068615458905697, -0.034866947680711746, -0.013459267094731331, -0.009913599118590355, 0.035193800926208496, -0.028351712971925735, -0.02709457464516163, 0.038317617028951645, -0.07251138240098953, -0.03822415694594383, 0.01547026913613081, 0.014205007813870907, 0.06415465474128723, 0.036836687475442886, 0.021489234641194344, -0.02572750300168991, 0.060504000633955, -0.017385918647050858, -0.034389518201351166, -0.01548825018107891, 0.06923483312129974, -0.0010669606272131205, -0.0025808364152908325, -0.0009253269527107477, -0.0006357061793096364, -0.009276597760617733, 0.024703629314899445, 0.02590896375477314, 0.008255159482359886, -0.037866849452257156, 0.026209382340312004, -0.028157934546470642, 0.028909051790833473, 0.01741831935942173, -0.012292390689253807, 0.03826143965125084, 0.012453227303922176, -0.02801595628261566, 0.01644071750342846, -0.004301536828279495, 0.00030401666299439967, -0.054730165749788284, -0.03954571112990379, -0.026820866391062737, -0.002603496192023158, 0.03501562029123306, -0.05189664661884308, 0.014223653823137283, 0.02084996923804283, -0.046967070549726486, 0.021635903045535088, 0.026075143367052078, -0.0028206398710608482, -0.007597847376018763, 0.0007301573641598225, -0.05506666377186775, 0.034150175750255585, 0.02889992855489254, -0.0070777153596282005, 0.03572520613670349, 0.02251906506717205, -0.000928141176700592, -0.011948042549192905, -0.0002504794392734766, 0.01859663799405098, -0.008890165947377682, -0.03871997073292732, 0.048234403133392334, -0.043536264449357986, -0.040394436568021774, 0.0029326402582228184, -0.02849348820745945, 0.023262010887265205, 0.0285808052867651, 0.048161499202251434, 0.004468472208827734, 0.031293630599975586, 0.01817908138036728, -0.031286682933568954, -0.015673907473683357, 0.0016255703521892428, 0.026829048991203308, 0.018084129318594933, -0.016590172424912453, 0.013645661994814873, 0.04719782993197441, -0.013982286676764488, -0.015046443790197372, -0.01783854141831398, -0.011085351929068565, -0.021962450817227364, -0.013815165497362614, 0.01656201295554638, -0.029790271073579788, -0.02424800395965576, -0.012226727791130543, -0.03979862108826637, -0.013286850415170193, 0.03572285920381546, 0.007054165471345186, -0.023476041853427887, 0.024033870548009872, -0.013557886704802513, -0.04021180048584938, 0.02061604894697666, 0.003801704617217183, -0.010683191940188408, -0.06478196382522583, -0.023842385038733482, 0.029034996405243874, -0.03687576577067375, -0.04392639920115471, -0.010272402316331863, -0.01863284222781658, 0.02784988284111023, -0.003887712024152279, 0.029226889833807945, 0.03995148465037346, -0.03466781973838806, 0.0007589282467961311, -0.06155279651284218, 0.08011043816804886, -0.02116261050105095, -0.03659791871905327, -0.008602864108979702, -0.04805964604020119, -0.028240909799933434, 0.003469355870038271, 0.06049709394574165, 0.014079228043556213, 0.0034423344768583775, -0.021803298965096474, 0.012302864342927933, 0.003239364828914404, -0.01739545725286007, 0.04587296396493912, 0.005486073438078165, -0.004693793132901192, -0.010091452859342098, -0.011843528598546982, 0.036716166883707047, 0.02483307383954525, 0.015174767933785915, -0.04305555298924446, 0.008937831036746502, 0.0004878816253039986, 0.011851158924400806, 0.04765838012099266, -0.01615258678793907, -0.005974635016173124, 0.05292939394712448, 0.010864048264920712, 0.02188376896083355, -0.00652034068480134, -0.015290177427232265, -0.05031856149435043, -0.008121312595903873, -0.037128835916519165, 0.02207615226507187, 0.013051477260887623, 0.031404558569192886, -0.016251951456069946, -0.061709076166152954, -0.010429193265736103, 0.019995028153061867, -0.04175187647342682, 0.039931971579790115, 0.05071353539824486, -0.015974441543221474, -0.00602927478030324, -0.01558482926338911, 0.030625246465206146, 0.007597886025905609, -0.007796714548021555, -0.01452215388417244, -0.00768704479560256, 0.04953589290380478, 0.010182359255850315, -0.0011365505633875728, 0.030766945332288742, 0.001491865492425859, 0.03228556737303734, 0.0042490060441195965, 0.05288476124405861, -0.05240610986948013, 0.016756951808929443, 0.021395985037088394, -0.009641129523515701, 0.05148094519972801, -0.015820350497961044, -0.047838348895311356, 0.08129012584686279, -0.052287839353084564, -0.032300978899002075, -0.06218376010656357, -0.028867017477750778, -0.004471116699278355, -0.03725114092230797, 0.018783055245876312, 0.05402615666389465, 0.026519522070884705, -0.0037681187968701124, 0.010450143367052078, -0.04137483239173889, 0.02409462071955204, -0.024145284667611122, 0.009755057282745838, -0.005395192187279463, 0.013970596715807915, -0.017380671575665474, -0.02118733525276184, -0.002356500132009387, -0.004066728986799717, 0.040851641446352005, 0.0459224134683609, 0.053027763962745667, 0.014198994264006615, -0.026391340419650078, 0.010829591192305088, 0.0383991003036499, -0.0407056026160717, -0.005314176436513662, -0.0257249865680933, 0.008965172804892063, 0.008114536292850971, -0.014170849695801735 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/25211/simple-combination-probability-question-based-on-string-length-and-possible-char">Simple combination/probability question based on string-length and possible-characters</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>Suppose I have a collection of 1,000,000 unique strings where each string is exactly 10 characters long, the characters being A-Z, a-z, 0-9. What is the probability of having a string colliding with existing data -- and -- how do I calculate this probability.</p>
49,931
[ -0.052081044763326645, -0.054414212703704834, -0.003815466072410345, -0.03288691118359566, 0.02225198782980442, 0.025020377710461617, -0.01047422830015421, -0.0005704737268388271, -0.012853526510298252, 0.001448618364520371, 0.0843045637011528, 0.07281734049320221, 0.029017653316259384, 0.01701553352177143, 0.027396148070693016, 0.021708251908421516, -0.009907220490276814, -0.002925897017121315, 0.001867781043983996, 0.017964188009500504, 0.019946839660406113, 0.006237304303795099, 0.029030416160821915, -0.012020139954984188, -0.05112496018409729, 0.017826447263360023, 0.022634398192167282, -0.06385757029056549, 0.031347520649433136, 0.06102028489112854, -0.03042381815612316, -0.022617099806666374, 0.0884893611073494, 0.0842473953962326, 0.007343720644712448, -0.006445709150284529, -0.017844388261437416, -0.03451525792479515, -0.04063772037625313, 0.02164369262754917, -0.06890784204006195, -0.03214725852012634, -0.016097627580165863, 0.061953336000442505, -0.048380669206380844, 0.0025340791326016188, -0.03809680789709091, -0.01737874187529087, -0.00447659520432353, -0.030911553651094437, 0.048289015889167786, -0.013571619987487793, 0.07174468040466309, 0.015264508314430714, -0.010820346884429455, -0.02727062627673149, 0.03686664253473282, 0.07802775502204895, -0.002015161793678999, -0.03696640953421593, -0.008036422543227673, -0.017840897664427757, -0.017141837626695633, -0.0027928149793297052, -0.022654954344034195, 0.060842711478471756, -0.024085400626063347, 0.009576800279319286, 0.01387313473969698, -0.03637336939573288, -0.002689649583771825, 0.022791871801018715, 0.02832893840968609, -0.0016919892514124513, 0.029805349186062813, -0.023417804390192032, 0.021341795101761818, 0.009466241113841534, 0.04429532587528229, 0.060626618564128876, -0.04094577953219414, 0.024060958996415138, 0.04241010546684265, 0.027220936492085457, 0.048589929938316345, -0.03116593323647976, 0.05250930413603783, -0.008955668658018112, -0.0019165248377248645, 0.030498741194605827, 0.0072576203383505344, -0.013138176873326302, 0.054942209273576736, 0.008302184753119946, -0.030846960842609406, 0.023381521925330162, -0.006914361380040646, 0.050272438675165176, 0.00011930338951060548, -0.018671855330467224, -0.021480683237314224, -0.058697909116744995, 0.04566812142729759, 0.07692497968673706, -0.03227190673351288, -0.004323695320636034, -0.002962792757898569, -0.018045863136649132, -0.07917226105928421, -0.0033404093701392412, 0.013820192776620388, 0.026442542672157288, -0.004464936908334494, -0.0017915088683366776, 0.026340559124946594, -0.011350567452609539, 0.010421451181173325, -0.00007436631858581677, 0.060014329850673676, 0.033781468868255615, 0.019298596307635307, -0.036617718636989594, 0.04165191575884819, -0.019195647910237312, 0.0038844444788992405, -0.034479010850191116, 0.0016677257372066379, -0.012559393420815468, -0.04232866317033768, 0.0678415447473526, -0.057306043803691864, -0.04440055415034294, 0.021349525079131126, -0.024149199947714806, 0.04697878658771515, 0.011151767335832119, -0.08154255896806717, -0.0166645310819149, 0.060809213668107986, -0.02014108933508396, -0.05261034145951271, -0.06004971265792847, 0.0323522724211216, 0.01341019943356514, 0.03267720714211464, 0.0011256457073614001, 0.053423922508955, 0.03772151842713356, 0.023255599662661552, 0.04250382259488106, -0.010098419152200222, -0.0011021159589290619, -0.024807024747133255, -0.02107490599155426, 0.01823512651026249, -0.05087453871965408, 0.03420501574873924, 0.033621352165937424, -0.004391513764858246, -0.01102796196937561, 0.01875140331685543, 0.024250950664281845, 0.009410951286554337, -0.007676548790186644, 0.02728259563446045, -0.031119491904973984, 0.06815354526042938, 0.048946529626846313, -0.0006019655265845358, 0.0025812466628849506, -0.028733547776937485, 0.004428070038557053, 0.019266530871391296, -0.009264790453016758, 0.05216062441468239, -0.03857912868261337, 0.004099871497601271, -0.01736871711909771, 0.014285022392868996, 0.00941802654415369, -0.0011455563362687826, -0.025856172665953636, -0.012363944202661514, -0.022506188601255417, 0.0664457306265831, 0.02707381546497345, 0.005623737815767527, -0.022127658128738403, 0.0007474062731489539, 0.00594020402058959, -0.04930172115564346, -0.05604741349816322, 0.007608529180288315, -0.03265172615647316, -0.03562566265463829, 0.023964233696460724, -0.01131548173725605, -0.006636739708483219, -0.014479642733931541, 0.0014357785694301128, -0.0441676527261734, -0.0035224331077188253, 0.0015535639831796288, -0.0361887589097023, -0.04803473502397537, 0.07896102964878082, 0.060937006026506424, -0.04357480630278587, 0.029918402433395386, -0.029409820213913918, -0.05272768810391426, -0.0014713883865624666, -0.014179161749780178, 0.030069028958678246, 0.006686982698738575, 0.004250294528901577, 0.0506109818816185, 0.015531126409769058, 0.011646383441984653, 0.01930083893239498, -0.010533136315643787, 0.03720200061798096, 0.05135919526219368, -0.003147267969325185, 0.0359816811978817, 0.009179435670375824, -0.004304669797420502, -0.030570771545171738, 0.03346766158938408, -0.013565221801400185, -0.07003084570169449, 0.0029278164729475975, 0.07065656036138535, 0.00394230242818594, -0.03833312168717384, -0.00014254669076763093, 0.051772017031908035, 0.0010417242301627994, -0.018292635679244995, 0.042423974722623825, -0.05412692949175835, -0.017062891274690628, -0.005104503128677607, 0.018374640494585037, -0.005862775724381208, -0.028196096420288086, -0.0008006609277799726, 0.019540201872587204, -0.005167841911315918, -0.005427356343716383, -0.03462442010641098, 0.014718848280608654, 0.018538357689976692, 0.040279846638441086, -0.048004042357206345, -0.04420430213212967, 0.0506083182990551, -0.020772423595190048, -0.004989255219697952, 0.027227157726883888, -0.009768987074494362, 0.0031771862413734198, -0.014788954518735409, 0.03547099605202675, -0.03525596857070923, 0.009065999649465084, -0.012245971709489822, -0.019362347200512886, 0.006042147520929575, -0.026853088289499283, 0.008288835175335407, -0.003684012917801738, -0.002767313504591584, 0.017963247373700142, 0.038732387125492096, 0.034562449902296066, -0.008551670238375664, 0.06779563426971436, -0.053531892597675323, -0.035960812121629715, 0.013686368241906166, -0.01732979528605938, -0.036867156624794006, 0.0006211731233634055, -0.062470097094774246, 0.01726926676928997, -0.020888734608888626, -0.0599556490778923, 0.06938918679952621, -0.02069012261927128, 0.003783636959269643, 0.019059687852859497, 0.004530457779765129, -0.024476967751979828, -0.004157337360084057, -0.030412988737225533, 0.00017342533101327717, -0.08529828488826752, -0.030227750539779663, 0.03147290274500847, 0.019778886809945107, -0.06658659130334854, 0.030552471056580544, -0.025810174643993378, -0.044561032205820084, -0.008560752496123314, -0.009832416661083698, 0.03242247551679611, -0.0799429714679718, -0.011099410243332386, -0.032572854310274124, 0.02766941674053669, 0.013557584956288338, -0.06040864437818527, -0.03966653347015381, -0.0010275065433233976, -0.017071127891540527, 0.0803302749991417, 0.010546828620135784, -0.0487387478351593, 0.0364372693002224, 0.0034036485012620687, -0.030074652284383774, -0.013540427200496197, 0.005136444233357906, -0.01940685138106346, -0.016780724748969078, 0.009692554362118244, 0.0429035909473896, -0.03882940858602524, 0.0018194930162280798, 0.03159014880657196, 0.003412992460653186, 0.05174584686756134, -0.006291535682976246, -0.0061556147411465645, 0.0022307075560092926, 0.01210890430957079, -0.0002855619532056153, 0.02820378914475441, 0.02104322426021099, -0.045341312885284424, 0.0287572480738163, -0.01760794222354889, -0.0005391410086303949, 0.002992479596287012, -0.05008327215909958, 0.029898226261138916, 0.01797281578183174, -0.0013049240224063396, -0.04661807417869568, 0.06138233095407486, 0.0016222791746258736, -0.021382778882980347, 0.036835238337516785, 0.0016912161372601986, 0.04143748804926872, -0.033312760293483734, -0.002988276071846485, -0.008068706840276718, 0.04856230318546295, -0.02266613207757473, -0.04598500207066536, -0.04719884693622589, -0.010203509591519833, -0.010303287766873837, -0.02713211625814438, -0.02699270471930504, 0.014017792418599129, 0.05759457126259804, 0.018799053505063057, 0.001255064969882369, -0.035901740193367004, -0.005527828354388475, -0.05649395287036896, -0.0439436212182045, -0.0329023115336895, 0.023540757596492767, -0.021179674193263054, 0.033694446086883545, 0.007177852094173431, -0.027490003034472466, -0.007782790809869766, 0.02452900819480419, -0.06658376008272171, 0.04618081450462341, -0.025664765387773514, -0.013485901057720184, -0.007994415238499641, -0.04738007113337517, 0.024207860231399536, -0.014148926362395287, 0.013423227705061436, -0.001615310669876635, 0.012989007867872715, -0.037403713911771774, 0.005281019024550915, -0.009956084191799164, 0.024525627493858337, 0.012793585658073425, 0.06849092990159988, 0.00484256399795413, 0.00450871093198657, 0.04854082688689232, 0.034794434905052185, -0.006862625479698181, -0.005186488851904869, -0.004510995466262102, 0.03120845928788185, 0.023068947717547417, 0.03229114040732384, -0.000252634403295815, 0.013211770914494991, 0.006902360823005438, -0.030885396525263786, -0.007731828838586807, 0.023056792095303535, 0.026112349703907967, 0.007952096872031689, -0.014964846894145012, -0.084063820540905, 0.014058640226721764, -0.032657768577337265, 0.003173979464918375, -0.026369141414761543, 0.03847077116370201, 0.057228777557611465, 0.01916138455271721, -0.04639824107289314, 0.03697514161467552, 0.05272269248962402, 0.014870482496917248, -0.007819194346666336, -0.010926381684839725, 0.002936182776466012, -0.003672037273645401, 0.022971078753471375, -0.021792283281683922, 0.02633371390402317, 0.0018079830333590508, 0.020394783467054367, 0.014029870741069317, -0.017951173707842827, -0.041670460253953934, 0.02053915522992611, -0.010606683790683746, 0.011242850683629513, 0.008407549932599068, -0.01862829551100731, -0.009344368241727352, 0.025918785482645035, -0.0003721898247022182, 0.005882648751139641, -0.03261765465140343, -0.03390774130821228, 0.03602634370326996, 0.04105333611369133, 0.041106365621089935, -0.0437440387904644, 0.014553993009030819, -0.02302764356136322, -0.01916288584470749, -0.0029429043643176556, -0.04296933487057686, 0.03175739943981171, 0.005484455265104771, 0.03061821311712265, -0.007830433547496796, -0.0356738343834877, -0.02749006450176239, 0.015480447560548782, 0.0028366975020617247, 0.02574474737048149, -0.019317684695124626, 0.03400909900665283, -0.03140664100646973, 0.00727272592484951, 0.041859179735183716, 0.029277658089995384, -0.04294149577617645, 0.00856815092265606, -0.00041155327926389873, 0.004519176669418812, -0.027187658473849297, -0.053963758051395416, 0.013812361285090446, -0.033361781388521194, -0.02123778685927391, 0.025648681446909904, -0.04914434254169464, -0.028092578053474426, 0.02662057988345623, 0.014072590507566929, -0.014644011855125427, 0.005963122937828302, -0.016214197501540184, 0.05456020310521126, 0.02828763984143734, 0.01928316242992878, 0.04286327213048935, -0.01863095350563526, -0.025039594620466232, 0.017964450642466545, -0.008010152727365494, 0.01334318146109581, -0.018557701259851456, -0.021249081939458847, -0.04741237312555313, 0.03813594952225685, -0.027107402682304382, 0.04529508575797081, 0.006849643308669329, -0.024138981476426125, -0.026114478707313538, -0.014897674322128296, -0.0278228260576725, -0.005274318158626556, -0.003669328987598419, 0.00571247935295105, -0.013480132445693016, 0.02889350987970829, -0.0014851319137960672, -0.0012050359509885311, 0.02104789763689041, -0.004773437045514584, -0.006685257889330387, -0.023585105314850807, -0.039239734411239624, 0.005568766500800848, -0.04369376227259636, -0.020921185612678528, 0.04346273094415665, -0.048291295766830444, 0.07038310170173645, -0.007246352266520262, 0.014165421947836876, 0.025646772235631943, -0.060839466750621796, -0.054831117391586304, -0.002426509978249669, 0.00025947694666683674, 0.07946933060884476, -0.010980878956615925, 0.0255544725805521, -0.026250343769788742, -0.03220758214592934, -0.03780185058712959, -0.02138775773346424, 0.028668751940131187, 0.023834463208913803, -0.010952072218060493, -0.00680925976485014, 0.029411278665065765, -0.01162358932197094, -0.021493755280971527, -0.04466770216822624, 0.02416335791349411, 0.011109385639429092, -0.020104367285966873, -0.010769063606858253, -0.03629176318645477, 0.05256079137325287, 0.02032903954386711, -0.0032732279505580664, 0.015819957479834557, -0.044817280024290085, 0.010638165287673473, -0.03581941872835159, 0.008298303931951523, -0.029993698000907898, -0.0619191937148571, -0.006748517043888569, -0.04333953559398651, 0.04156837239861488, -0.04316534847021103, 0.025797637179493904, -0.013266036286950111, -0.018792442977428436, 0.017863929271697998, 0.008771642111241817, 0.026959259063005447, -0.006032629404217005, 0.03736308217048645, -0.01816512644290924, 0.0022624190896749496, -0.007742741145193577, 0.03315909951925278, 0.03310314193367958, 0.03879254311323166, -0.03368024900555611, 0.008754659444093704, 0.05025472119450569, -0.008837462402880192, -0.041069306433200836, -0.04529653489589691, -0.010330414399504662, 0.0455426461994648, -0.013916830532252789, -0.04730881750583649, 0.034074313938617706, 0.007703275885432959, -0.03954644873738289, -0.01679229363799095, -0.02601412869989872, 0.03637995198369026, 0.03325127065181732, -0.041913952678442, 0.05401093512773514, 0.03454192727804184, 0.007054462097585201, 0.0011534973746165633, -0.008430150337517262, 0.016387438401579857, -0.014004755765199661, 0.023552268743515015, 0.030686786398291588, 0.016884826123714447, 0.02274143137037754, 0.041576892137527466, 0.005112535320222378, 0.041145358234643936, 0.011313792318105698, 0.034682776778936386, 0.002041771775111556, 0.02018985152244568, -0.030807456001639366, -0.01755453646183014, 0.03405851870775223, -0.06616900116205215, 0.009565341286361217, 0.01778283901512623, -0.0059505486860871315, 0.03575758635997772, 0.02269214391708374, -0.007788926362991333, -0.012346353381872177, -0.011790525168180466, -0.02612454630434513, 0.031667888164520264, 0.01604015752673149, 0.007725158240646124, 0.025558561086654663, 0.025335928425192833, 0.013156709261238575, 0.00296318088658154, 0.01814325340092182, -0.002638876670971513, -0.05771178752183914, 0.012238632887601852, -0.008725958876311779, -0.04148434102535248, 0.02626550756394863, 0.06978921592235565, -0.01684369146823883, -0.0024988462682813406, -0.0022806567139923573, 0.03740817308425903, 0.03772955387830734, 0.04542533680796623, -0.048118408769369125, 0.09821785986423492, 0.005645492114126682, 0.03985321894288063, -0.01718013547360897, 0.01671524904668331, 0.1159760057926178, 0.04760628193616867, 0.048044294118881226, -0.03781317546963692, 0.018937844783067703, 0.024002816528081894, -0.011153501458466053, -0.0074759856797754765, 0.020125538110733032, 0.05518081784248352, 0.0042838845402002335, 0.04331507533788681, 0.03070075623691082, -0.027717225253582, -0.026732726022601128, 0.05181154981255531, -0.028146034106612206, -0.018804671242833138, -0.03576338291168213, 0.0006157305906526744, 0.034275609999895096, -0.004991045221686363, -0.02486071176826954, -0.0023987835738807917, -0.034128520637750626, -0.00771939055994153, -0.05149424076080322, -0.05703207477927208, 0.0018433332443237305, 0.013829191215336323, -0.013529538176953793, -0.0061594839207828045, 0.03042997606098652, -0.02311526983976364, 0.00981967058032751, -0.026883799582719803, -0.01944286748766899, -0.027018753811717033, 0.002993084955960512, 0.021473627537488937, -0.0011055701179429889, 0.01660957559943199, -0.003957160748541355, 0.01728871464729309, -0.05298902466893196, -0.02388111874461174, -0.031124357134103775, 0.022426879033446312, -0.006897143088281155, 0.020050369203090668, -0.02757447026669979, -0.003212332958355546, -0.0029191707726567984, -0.029527798295021057, -0.007887608371675014, 0.021061107516288757, 0.04656028747558594, 0.004308454226702452, -0.021244408562779427, -0.04137998819351196, 0.030862241983413696, -0.01806626096367836, 0.028406349942088127, 0.04263484105467796, -0.013447600416839123, -0.00553120719268918, 0.008814160712063313, 0.007147170137614012, 0.024110980331897736, -0.009795743972063065, -0.04854203015565872, -0.019246598705649376, -0.050130318850278854, -0.016784319654107094, 0.005501893348991871, 0.021013490855693817, 0.027979662641882896, 0.018191657960414886, 0.0283836480230093, 0.0110573535785079, 0.011143447831273079, 0.02785510942339897, -0.022563908249139786, 0.025365496054291725, -0.07081746309995651, 0.0028250962495803833, 0.010395697318017483, 0.03955081105232239, 0.0005795193137601018, 0.042732883244752884, -0.03985614329576492, 0.0748666524887085, -0.020930927246809006, -0.014497030526399612, -0.0031483136117458344, -0.021167583763599396, -0.03967897593975067, 0.02834925428032875, 0.011392763815820217, 0.04899708554148674, 0.028426537290215492, 0.024149132892489433, 0.023869263008236885, 0.035983774811029434, -0.03301282972097397, -0.0050340257585048676, -0.010865247808396816, -0.04527786374092102, -0.021055005490779877, 0.009083262644708157, -0.00462123891338706, -0.03484148904681206, -0.020227160304784775, 0.024768048897385597, -0.02026735246181488, 0.06013309955596924, -0.00120929058175534, -0.041607245802879333, 0.0064616999588906765, -0.03618791326880455, -0.030924148857593536, 0.008025774732232094, 0.007833583280444145, -0.028029849752783775, 0.0076035247184336185, -0.031460437923669815, -0.017864860594272614, -0.016340764239430428, -0.029204055666923523, -0.020822223275899887, -0.00888555496931076, -0.0039210147224366665, 0.02449026331305504, 0.021635349839925766, 0.013193372637033463, 0.03807183355093002, 0.006744537968188524, 0.031571369618177414, -0.02889069728553295, -0.017665062099695206, 0.041620295494794846, -0.05060206726193428, -0.020335949957370758, 0.0518827810883522, -0.02748763933777809, 0.03376971557736397, 0.043494243174791336, 0.0013229643227532506, 0.01026947982609272, 0.06343862414360046, -0.020679399371147156, -0.04033004492521286, -0.010129863396286964, 0.011173305101692677, 0.026664916425943375, 0.01851475052535534, -0.015054451301693916, 0.015142192132771015, -0.019937176257371902, -0.002194006461650133, 0.041234102100133896, -0.0006613568402826786, 0.009430183097720146, 0.02544441446661949, 0.03898340463638306, -0.0225322637706995, 0.03246619552373886, -0.0430610254406929, -0.01773507334291935, 0.053544845432043076, 0.02089850790798664, 0.050283730030059814, -0.021674495190382004, 0.011763417162001133, -0.0943135991692543, 0.006646361202001572, 0.05854816362261772, 0.014038356952369213, 0.042012181133031845, -0.03493933379650116, -0.00910043716430664, 0.03785025328397751, -0.0559520460665226, -0.0034671518951654434, -0.024500740692019463, -0.004568745382130146, -0.03736259043216705, 0.0039282930083572865, -0.014483272098004818, 0.026871338486671448, 0.0252603180706501, 0.03878331929445267, 0.047286927700042725, 0.017762022092938423, -0.049722712486982346, -0.004336578771471977, -0.005461076740175486, 0.034721191972494125, 0.0002794250031001866, 0.002483382122591138, 0.058138929307460785, -0.01350112073123455, -0.03763855993747711, 0.00456792488694191, 0.0016256251838058233, -0.006808666978031397, 0.036715034395456314, 0.00655039306730032, 0.03591622784733772, 0.025009842589497566, 0.031148670241236687, 0.003623858094215393, -0.017369363456964493, 0.01983334869146347, 0.016447151079773903, 0.022720659151673317, -0.019555408507585526, -0.003152097575366497, 0.007573611102998257, -0.015215056017041206, -0.033043913543224335, 0.005639081820845604, 0.008457752875983715, 0.021796636283397675, -0.006540549919009209, -0.0022599254734814167, -0.014862672425806522, -0.005118970293551683, -0.0208663921803236, -0.02814868837594986, 0.021786853671073914, 0.01650426536798477, 0.02328730933368206, -0.005153271835297346, 0.03835887834429741, -0.014216765761375427, -0.015031297691166401, 0.0011144366580992937, 0.00042968738125637174, -0.018684621900320053, -0.027991611510515213, -0.008204901590943336, -0.0010018612956628203, 0.021418891847133636, 0.024685923010110855, -0.014805469661951065, -0.023076090961694717, 0.05442722141742706, -0.016158169135451317, 0.022270381450653076, 0.034286949783563614, -0.03806394338607788, -0.001569012994877994, -0.06720378994941711, 0.027216535061597824, 0.01538133155554533, 0.043384797871112823, -0.06284340471029282, -0.040614835917949677, 0.013475541956722736, 0.010801117867231369, 0.024095693603157997, -0.040924280881881714, 0.005834595765918493, -0.04264164716005325, -0.001989013282582164, 0.005785217974334955, -0.058810219168663025, -0.024040857329964638, -0.019796881824731827, -0.024462947621941566, -0.011327642016112804, 0.010495941154658794, 0.04306090995669365, -0.03023400343954563, 0.016316698864102364, -0.08340639621019363, -0.03521886467933655, 0.000897455494850874, -0.014744332060217857, 0.04265274852514267, -0.001687346724793315, 0.026610728353261948, 0.011521999724209309, 0.010983936488628387, 0.04243779182434082, 0.018698738887906075, 0.003657343564555049, -0.020745374262332916, 0.03329477459192276, -0.0433545745909214, -0.03529670834541321, -0.005353687796741724, 0.04808716103434563, 0.03637410327792168, -0.0587715283036232, -0.011758589185774326, 0.012860225513577461, -0.02320406399667263, -0.01492573693394661, 0.03813928738236427, -0.03363695740699768, 0.06880909949541092, -0.0016843545017763972, 0.009309769608080387, -0.014673487283289433, -0.03747890517115593, -0.011928227730095387, -0.04749593138694763, 0.004826855380088091, -0.007102544419467449, 0.01766160875558853, 0.002639008453115821, -0.0032260059379041195, 0.023865049704909325, -0.005260159727185965, 0.024312885478138924, -0.030360836535692215, -0.016070997342467308, 0.015633944422006607, -0.0015071199741214514, 0.014921197667717934, 0.016717666760087013, -0.011563529260456562, 0.09326210618019104, -0.010581721551716328, 0.030731989070773125, -0.03903299942612648, -0.02287445403635502, -0.029890280216932297, 0.010254842229187489, -0.001965428004041314, 0.007389912847429514, -0.023924384266138077, -0.009445568546652794, 0.023898037150502205, 0.040347620844841, 0.060480039566755295, -0.03862163797020912, 0.006696935743093491, -0.007048211991786957, 0.016798565164208412, -0.05905649811029434, -0.005182676482945681, -0.012286297045648098, -0.026921138167381287, 0.02211856283247471, -0.005960730370134115, -0.004003230948001146, 0.012989990413188934, -0.006935900077223778, -0.01950879953801632, 0.033007554709911346, 0.014848485589027405, 0.0009460501605644822, -0.08232688158750534, 0.05305444821715355, -0.03732042387127876, -0.021607380360364914 ]
<p>The alpha-expansion algorithm described <a href="http://books.google.co.in/books?id=7dzpHCHzNQ4C&amp;pg=PA592&amp;lpg=PA592&amp;dq=alpha+expansion+algorithm&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=pu1CCm--AR&amp;sig=PIN3b33Wm02_FWi3f1dJO_np0W8&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ei=Z2d8T4veCsrnrAetw6THAg&amp;redir_esc=y#v=onepage&amp;q=alpha%20expansion%20algorithm&amp;f=false" rel="nofollow">here</a> (Probabilistic Graphical Models: Principles and Techniques By Daphne Koller, Nir Friedman, Page 593: algorithm 13.5), is designed for graphs where each vertex has the same set of labels. I am interested in a more general problem where each vertex can have different set of labels having different cardinalities.</p> <p>Can the alpha-expansion algorithm be used in such cases?</p> <p>For example, let the graph have 3 vertices. The first vertex can assume labels (a1, a2, a3). The second vertex can assume labels (b1, b2) and the third one can have (c1, c2, c3, c4, c5). The node and edge potentials are defined accordingly. Can alpha-expansion still help me in finding an optimal (approximate) label combination?</p>
74,384
[ -0.027253495529294014, -0.004942475352436304, 0.03328613191843033, -0.019281554967164993, 0.030268095433712006, 0.009432550519704819, -0.010596195235848427, -0.021831413730978966, 0.01987519860267639, -0.004218577407300472, 0.008207849226891994, -0.00407744525000453, 0.05767805501818657, 0.021042227745056152, 0.019063008949160576, 0.007490283809602261, 0.02007916383445263, -0.013358412310481071, -0.02461375668644905, -0.022309843450784683, 0.03690973296761513, 0.046450257301330566, 0.00822004210203886, -0.0068634687922894955, -0.023531006649136543, 0.021791573613882065, -0.0015671037836000323, -0.039500895887613297, -0.0012966307112947106, 0.03513742983341217, -0.06485837697982788, 0.02554524503648281, 0.04077799245715141, 0.05044349655508995, 0.03243907541036606, -0.005927487276494503, 0.014230533502995968, -0.04142850264906883, -0.037062868475914, -0.008849304169416428, -0.06426908075809479, -0.008366759866476059, 0.0056547909043729305, 0.03299500793218613, -0.013924969360232353, -0.003690336598083377, -0.030285822227597237, -0.0319448858499527, 0.00408934336155653, -0.04253467917442322, 0.0849856585264206, -0.014673907309770584, 0.03953216224908829, 0.04713573306798935, -0.028812848031520844, -0.014626494608819485, 0.03313484415411949, 0.10980795323848724, 0.006567707750946283, -0.003369828686118126, -0.01561677921563387, -0.010622430592775345, 0.025131091475486755, -0.037094417959451675, -0.05767021328210831, 0.045078299939632416, 0.029065271839499474, -0.007885287515819073, 0.03801995888352394, 0.021271055564284325, -0.054740797728300095, 0.009037954732775688, 0.07550154626369476, -0.005770605523139238, 0.041822951287031174, -0.010946163907647133, 0.02043996751308441, 0.023320138454437256, 0.037147168070077896, 0.03674209490418434, -0.023103976622223854, 0.02788439579308033, 0.0443284846842289, 0.05207592993974686, -0.013733760453760624, -0.018788447603583336, 0.05802246183156967, -0.06287327408790588, -0.023319944739341736, -0.011006537824869156, -0.03139951452612877, 0.008090341463685036, 0.05056709796190262, -0.02344498783349991, -0.03635052964091301, 0.01219889335334301, 0.007113017141819, 0.004505815450102091, -0.006129724904894829, -0.004785917233675718, 0.013432309031486511, -0.01562151312828064, -0.019478296861052513, 0.04848979786038399, -0.012182717211544514, 0.0031829620711505413, -0.04809017851948738, -0.013088235631585121, -0.009266503155231476, -0.012111973948776722, -0.01914358139038086, 0.042298465967178345, -0.024598971009254456, 0.005297547206282616, -0.002463676268234849, -0.05658634006977081, -0.020325951278209686, -0.01173559483140707, 0.03476675972342491, 0.07319070398807526, 0.011521701700985432, -0.04739420861005783, 0.036498621106147766, -0.030990688130259514, -0.038587767630815506, -0.0117288026958704, -0.015822121873497963, -0.026617279276251793, -0.03935622423887253, 0.04879155382514, -0.001666700467467308, -0.025547541677951813, 0.02685483545064926, -0.029898017644882202, -0.000016159699953277595, -0.007907452061772346, -0.058030322194099426, -0.033146437257528305, 0.03638985753059387, -0.016589544713497162, 0.012185358442366123, -0.04331198334693909, 0.024851977825164795, 0.048003315925598145, 0.029946530237793922, 0.011923926882445812, 0.03083213046193123, 0.0006547577795572579, 0.0030669618863612413, 0.01986103691160679, -0.04030618071556091, 0.011558723635971546, -0.01890479028224945, -0.014493430964648724, -0.018774522468447685, -0.09391521662473679, -0.0037746913731098175, 0.02037055976688862, 0.011085179634392262, -0.00911392830312252, 0.05098776891827583, 0.010515760630369186, -0.009951366111636162, -0.0049088988453149796, 0.028745098039507866, 0.005438107997179031, 0.0624508298933506, 0.012403481639921665, 0.030384421348571777, 0.04207269474864006, -0.03845185041427612, 0.027600804343819618, 0.024849582463502884, 0.008454271592199802, 0.056689776480197906, 0.007743635214865208, -0.02613699808716774, -0.03164063021540642, 0.032620836049318314, 0.03198723867535591, 0.021756840869784355, -0.01974649913609028, -0.06014227867126465, 0.00593867851421237, 0.048209965229034424, 0.05282313749194145, 0.019903438165783882, -0.03155418485403061, 0.03719618171453476, -0.03248707577586174, -0.03512043505907059, -0.06431763619184494, -0.011510338634252548, -0.02529558166861534, 0.01507585123181343, 0.058248620480298996, -0.020844591781497, -0.01609811931848526, 0.014686287380754948, 0.012709593400359154, -0.03148343414068222, -0.006065044552087784, 0.0006474159308709204, -0.016285885125398636, 0.016503477469086647, 0.07764772325754166, 0.036619335412979126, 0.006808592472225428, 0.028550952672958374, -0.06742239743471146, -0.08343484252691269, 0.01243190374225378, -0.014156564138829708, 0.004335707053542137, -0.003110941732302308, 0.0162661112844944, -0.00770171545445919, 0.04308664798736572, 0.003775570308789611, 0.020801128819584846, -0.04131751134991646, 0.03040841780602932, 0.08179043233394623, 0.019015057012438774, 0.00406260322779417, 0.035284530371427536, 0.0054672169499099255, 0.02529252879321575, 0.004484007600694895, -0.01634424552321434, -0.05915035679936409, -0.022675368934869766, 0.027370980009436607, -0.0024306965060532093, -0.020971832796931267, -0.015008397400379181, 0.0556781105697155, 0.014445792883634567, 0.013443214818835258, 0.037408407777547836, -0.01611608825623989, 0.018074477091431618, 0.03509972617030144, 0.04402966797351837, 0.04053240269422531, 0.02590419538319111, 0.0023571413476020098, 0.005694434978067875, 0.04833267629146576, -0.0336463488638401, 0.00820009782910347, 0.00032014254247769713, -0.05370389297604561, -0.00941777229309082, -0.006800512317568064, -0.019744541496038437, 0.023006724193692207, -0.027727339416742325, 0.029637642204761505, 0.04624755680561066, -0.004452122375369072, -0.008669506758451462, -0.016970351338386536, -0.0315888449549675, 0.014984074980020523, 0.0006007340853102505, -0.013835471123456955, -0.04681699350476265, 0.010618013329803944, -0.04634414240717888, 0.029082760214805603, -0.011696096509695053, -0.015180162154138088, -0.028739234432578087, 0.03196105360984802, 0.019192546606063843, -0.024761145934462547, 0.02041284181177616, -0.06343300640583038, -0.04388277605175972, 0.00855062436312437, -0.005369491409510374, 0.016606418415904045, 0.010602816008031368, -0.025946861132979393, -0.004267058335244656, -0.03723108023405075, -0.04351763427257538, 0.027805302292108536, 0.0015207057585939765, -0.01433514803647995, 0.002551739802584052, 0.006627629045397043, -0.021619852632284164, -0.0094721969217062, -0.0280890055000782, 0.034343868494033813, -0.030373262241482735, -0.036517806351184845, 0.0328204445540905, 0.03512013703584671, -0.05886923149228096, -0.009547607973217964, -0.05396919324994087, -0.03736327588558197, 0.02843560464680195, -0.006973769515752792, -0.002682540100067854, -0.01057334616780281, 0.029929202049970627, 0.076323501765728, -0.0019430225947871804, -0.014336854219436646, -0.05810044705867767, -0.04394695162773132, 0.0029591883067041636, 0.020525401458144188, -0.01813567988574505, 0.02593650110065937, -0.025222450494766235, 0.10076858103275299, 0.017279483377933502, -0.04549352824687958, 0.0037223866675049067, 0.002526304218918085, -0.021579721942543983, -0.0020951193291693926, 0.0070365602150559425, 0.014971300959587097, -0.012729523703455925, -0.00202168058604002, 0.029206428676843643, 0.03628375753760338, 0.04466470703482628, 0.00529920170083642, 0.020906860008835793, 0.054181307554244995, 0.05449708551168442, -0.01999346725642681, 0.034160271286964417, -0.021065067499876022, -0.03218686953186989, -0.017353875562548637, 0.010924305766820908, -0.010209782049059868, -0.016069352626800537, -0.04412328451871872, 0.042170729488134384, -0.007712444290518761, 0.0257724542170763, -0.03928535804152489, 0.023513412103056908, 0.042890869081020355, -0.05830070748925209, -0.01040932908654213, 0.028049159795045853, 0.055581945925951004, -0.03370233625173569, 0.012665885500609875, 0.06429868191480637, 0.02802453748881817, -0.03810558840632439, -0.03779107332229614, -0.019202345982193947, -0.003250936744734645, 0.010451475158333778, -0.013380375690758228, -0.01425321027636528, 0.012060551904141903, 0.013126641511917114, -0.01688757911324501, 0.021641556173563004, -0.008084500208497047, 0.019420048221945763, -0.048648372292518616, -0.006067163776606321, -0.05817004293203354, 0.03515363857150078, 0.04733878746628761, 0.04800764098763466, -0.002315482357516885, -0.0035232286900281906, -0.01566464640200138, 0.04136357456445694, -0.0898996889591217, 0.004329407121986151, 0.0045008170418441296, -0.007175919599831104, 0.015784787014126778, -0.01081031933426857, 0.01585732400417328, -0.050276100635528564, -0.015940601006150246, 0.005604902282357216, 0.015274261124432087, -0.035997822880744934, -0.009998355060815811, -0.008744664490222931, 0.0003259980003349483, -0.027361290529370308, 0.01608162373304367, 0.020362555980682373, -0.009222537279129028, 0.04215070232748985, 0.0022661364637315273, -0.020155668258666992, -0.0016728965565562248, -0.036784809082746506, 0.039125289767980576, 0.013288382440805435, 0.04167346656322479, 0.013279148377478123, 0.06195838749408722, 0.0214132871478796, -0.02970101870596409, 0.020734691992402077, 0.03130204230546951, 0.018456382676959038, -0.013075127266347408, 0.019590815529227257, -0.05066853016614914, -0.01625472493469715, 0.0023982245475053787, 0.031454019248485565, 0.01213717833161354, 0.03209767863154411, 0.031540460884571075, 0.006330554839223623, -0.05574827268719673, 0.011395974084734917, 0.08781854808330536, -0.013130620121955872, -0.032991282641887665, -0.02629445306956768, -0.002578573767095804, -0.031664811074733734, 0.011655209586024284, 0.014175552874803543, -0.0030832390766590834, -0.02104717306792736, -0.0007194746867753565, 0.004578839521855116, -0.020241782069206238, -0.03213416039943695, -0.026079420000314713, 0.025856075808405876, 0.026063594967126846, 0.013637596741318703, -0.023526016622781754, 0.010036607272922993, 0.01173566933721304, 0.021567022427916527, 0.006397715769708157, -0.014909199438989162, -0.054841894656419754, 0.003720523091033101, 0.05578172579407692, 0.038390181958675385, -0.016227778047323227, 0.009303606115281582, -0.06868617981672287, -0.023233607411384583, 0.010762716643512249, -0.025811806321144104, 0.027692295610904694, -0.01232422050088644, -0.020122133195400238, -0.01796429418027401, -0.058956462889909744, -0.003378814086318016, 0.013281937688589096, -0.02831006422638893, -0.0038825920782983303, -0.025390038266777992, 0.019465796649456024, -0.04207345470786095, -0.0074008069932460785, 0.03385782986879349, 0.06267809122800827, 0.0018036580877378583, -0.024166258051991463, 0.011633207090198994, -0.0010473693255335093, -0.06935489177703857, -0.05472153052687645, 0.01089221891015768, 0.007180764339864254, 0.002074733842164278, 0.021668795496225357, -0.006703159771859646, -0.045891571789979935, 0.013156498782336712, -0.032061874866485596, -0.044162411242723465, -0.030055727809667587, 0.02368706837296486, 0.027321787551045418, 0.07843244075775146, -0.022689329460263252, 0.07044070959091187, 0.050931576639413834, -0.013179169036448002, 0.006387406960129738, -0.035204172134399414, 0.03503549098968506, -0.017024466767907143, -0.0008797022746875882, -0.03308846428990364, 0.02780001424252987, -0.024661462754011154, 0.050633590668439865, -0.024722138419747353, 0.053799405694007874, -0.0074457405135035515, -0.007980267517268658, -0.04020087420940399, 0.03910970315337181, 0.005008055828511715, 0.015123862773180008, 0.030994556844234467, 0.04522649943828583, 0.020841233432292938, 0.0024230522103607655, 0.028325729072093964, -0.04366292431950569, 0.02117692306637764, -0.006310587748885155, -0.021285850554704666, 0.029616422951221466, -0.03218195587396622, 0.003872510977089405, -0.004741795361042023, -0.04384533315896988, 0.060939669609069824, 0.006852729711681604, 0.04321398213505745, -0.014101676642894745, -0.05365483835339546, -0.06609795242547989, 0.006074816454201937, -0.0042591216042637825, 0.020431412383913994, -0.029426055029034615, 0.01681213453412056, -0.04431470111012459, -0.03820367902517319, -0.05008964240550995, -0.018656112253665924, 0.01751585304737091, 0.045429736375808716, -0.03669511154294014, -0.02552689239382744, 0.02263786643743515, 0.002433217130601406, -0.015596269629895687, -0.02086871862411499, 0.056029822677373886, -0.02337183617055416, -0.028882984071969986, 0.0004671775095630437, 0.012481953017413616, 0.037659358233213425, 0.038703277707099915, -0.0012775990180671215, 0.0013755150139331818, -0.011182015761733055, 0.006940184626728296, -0.01959400624036789, -0.007457534782588482, -0.029054809361696243, -0.02658158726990223, -0.014873141422867775, 0.0517122857272625, 0.04599327966570854, -0.013014881871640682, 0.0001299157302128151, -0.033829621970653534, 0.004121330101042986, -0.018770132213830948, -0.015613937750458717, -0.016855444759130478, 0.023706359788775444, -0.0031895011197775602, -0.005046620033681393, 0.036255449056625366, 0.00977608934044838, 0.019137630239129066, 0.0257779061794281, -0.014478747732937336, -0.03231087327003479, 0.030116578564047813, 0.09837429225444794, 0.014793812297284603, 0.015632588416337967, -0.012659161351621151, -0.012532039545476437, 0.03554718568921089, -0.030286747962236404, 0.0011518613900989294, 0.013051405549049377, -0.015232434496283531, -0.03769570589065552, -0.004988125525414944, -0.05639830604195595, 0.02637876197695732, 0.03102036938071251, 0.003125992836430669, 0.012726474553346634, 0.030531834810972214, 0.01691226102411747, 0.016496114432811737, -0.04051722586154938, -0.00025199755327776074, -0.014783194288611412, -0.015090450644493103, 0.036063820123672485, -0.034894831478595734, -0.04643455520272255, 0.054647453129291534, -0.010357504710555077, 0.03133649751543999, 0.015947513282299042, 0.03958086669445038, 0.038372430950403214, 0.012715687975287437, -0.014034729450941086, -0.02838689275085926, 0.04685604199767113, -0.03818754106760025, -0.015932489186525345, -0.009384403005242348, -0.09150533378124237, 0.053340792655944824, 0.025105606764554977, -0.01360105536878109, -0.01879679597914219, -0.03294416517019272, -0.031064096838235855, 0.03468530625104904, -0.0035456866025924683, 0.027609946206212044, 0.011454831808805466, -0.020040111616253853, -0.02238943986594677, 0.012753503397107124, 0.03699464723467827, -0.0044099194929003716, -0.0892181247472763, -0.03908529132604599, -0.021247858181595802, -0.019474616274237633, 0.030712544918060303, 0.004568526986986399, -0.020412659272551537, 0.05034448206424713, -0.011687771417200565, 0.028329545632004738, 0.020141461864113808, 0.06507094949483871, 0.004761760588735342, 0.042940717190504074, 0.0023691696114838123, 0.06309127062559128, -0.010616295970976353, -0.05020054802298546, 0.13991782069206238, 0.08610708266496658, 0.06210055947303772, -0.05692590773105621, 0.012525432743132114, 0.018525561317801476, -0.03742948919534683, -0.045488715171813965, -0.011926166713237762, -0.0031165238469839096, -0.006433147005736828, -0.004604461137205362, 0.06152525544166565, 0.004472413100302219, 0.0015689469873905182, 0.0672760158777237, -0.0678313747048378, -0.02483285777270794, 0.04875843599438667, 0.00833734218031168, 0.012764211744070053, -0.03146154806017876, -0.05341920629143715, -0.014755653217434883, -0.01738685742020607, -0.02231483906507492, -0.028658928349614143, 0.0053522889502346516, 0.04035570099949837, 0.003918361850082874, 0.03068067505955696, 0.013078417629003525, 0.0020372571889311075, -0.005004328675568104, 0.017070965841412544, 0.020220773294568062, 0.006562508642673492, -0.006786274258047342, 0.008960663340985775, 0.03007229045033455, 0.0000041140569919662084, 0.009733394719660282, 0.008266681805253029, -0.0038993859197944403, -0.04129593074321747, -0.06418532133102417, -0.014812714420258999, 0.03661579266190529, -0.031029222533106804, -0.002416404662653804, -0.005164610221982002, -0.012921849265694618, -0.012300754897296429, -0.027270115911960602, -0.007407986558973789, 0.018589291721582413, 0.022892098873853683, -0.001180055900476873, -0.008246729150414467, -0.04192739352583885, 0.033815961331129074, -0.004305584821850061, 0.02055756188929081, -0.017142677679657936, -0.031842246651649475, 0.00602312944829464, -0.01932273805141449, 0.05676713585853577, 0.030614107847213745, -0.03989943489432335, 0.02970707230269909, 0.01678062602877617, -0.04813750460743904, -0.036002691835165024, -0.02835007756948471, 0.010146190412342548, 0.032564613968133926, -0.02959655225276947, 0.0047698612324893475, -0.02850421890616417, -0.007823002524673939, 0.007103269919753075, -0.01912541687488556, -0.015029903501272202, -0.03811294212937355, 0.003301022807136178, 0.05148161202669144, 0.03422568738460541, 0.014151130802929401, 0.021448008716106415, -0.02713324874639511, 0.011654472909867764, 0.014511719346046448, -0.0005151450750418007, -0.021636513993144035, -0.041579749435186386, -0.010191651992499828, 0.01553149614483118, 0.009531548246741295, 0.03330936282873154, 0.014934074133634567, 0.0011051070177927613, -0.019041717052459717, 0.017415402457118034, 0.026117339730262756, 0.003047534031793475, -0.023358479142189026, -0.052991192787885666, 0.010738315060734749, 0.04057672247290611, -0.0016374863917008042, -0.04352659359574318, -0.04415988177061081, 0.0121443597599864, -0.030357619747519493, 0.026905586943030357, -0.017372513189911842, -0.032681457698345184, -0.013776415027678013, -0.0180721003562212, 0.02482902631163597, -0.03436340391635895, -0.0037107993848621845, -0.0005188481300137937, 0.0075987959280610085, -0.048189520835876465, -0.04249686375260353, -0.011743010953068733, 0.035264384001493454, 0.007917404174804688, -0.015365799888968468, 0.031283650547266006, 0.040217455476522446, -0.0015294898767024279, -0.006834154482930899, 0.008531829342246056, -0.011817979626357555, 0.04860736057162285, -0.055728472769260406, -0.02818995527923107, 0.011332898400723934, -0.0506734661757946, -0.018853554502129555, -0.01319067645817995, -0.026864925399422646, 0.05338728800415993, 0.020770983770489693, -0.007525934837758541, -0.013958487659692764, 0.03499884903430939, -0.026214929297566414, -0.03832225129008293, 0.014030378311872482, 0.030154867097735405, 0.0141710564494133, -0.009521354921162128, -0.011814398691058159, 0.03238542377948761, -0.004015761893242598, 0.018152929842472076, -0.0038299658335745335, 0.02277436852455139, -0.020524395629763603, 0.033094584941864014, 0.0053789750672876835, 0.018562639132142067, 0.015526825562119484, -0.020956430584192276, 0.03701818361878395, 0.030275743454694748, -0.021320190280675888, 0.05694809928536415, 0.04037555679678917, 0.0016743004089221358, -0.04936869069933891, -0.020176514983177185, 0.0002136973344022408, -0.0030712145380675793, 0.05630473792552948, -0.06671904027462006, 0.07214350253343582, 0.01381044089794159, -0.055523816496133804, 0.05228593200445175, 0.019926344975829124, 0.015752054750919342, -0.019108328968286514, 0.02517634630203247, -0.0197870172560215, 0.016264207661151886, 0.03325604647397995, 0.02458236552774906, -0.007405189331620932, -0.02584986202418804, -0.027888454496860504, -0.020788973197340965, -0.028762707486748695, 0.020673556253314018, 0.005006319843232632, -0.026286790147423744, 0.034453071653842926, -0.03606636822223663, -0.08929898589849472, 0.0227140374481678, 0.030468804761767387, -0.02373315766453743, 0.023028507828712463, 0.015482140704989433, 0.0041931490413844585, 0.022117573767900467, 0.05462225154042244, 0.014017852954566479, -0.01608283258974552, -0.0023426846601068974, -0.025242893025279045, 0.03105146996676922, -0.00006427208427339792, 0.017102075740695, 0.020937087014317513, -0.06538377702236176, -0.03976983577013016, 0.040971823036670685, 0.029863696545362473, -0.03203461691737175, -0.012961025349795818, -0.00926167331635952, 0.019333383068442345, -0.027525080367922783, -0.008653238415718079, -0.044513605535030365, -0.011687369085848331, -0.011903863400220871, 0.04052606597542763, 0.03210942819714546, -0.00837037991732359, -0.0122683672234416, -0.056854233145713806, 0.006004451774060726, 0.0010734864044934511, -0.024961190298199654, -0.06687499582767487, 0.007328518200665712, 0.002215082524344325, -0.0031429871451109648, -0.00014451323659159243, -0.03326563909649849, -0.00843886099755764, 0.01858142763376236, -0.036682043224573135, 0.023523740470409393, 0.01372948195785284, -0.00878987368196249, -0.007192826364189386, -0.07425720989704132, 0.060434598475694656, 0.015953466296195984, 0.022022927179932594, -0.02618691883981228, 0.028921203687787056, -0.0209666658192873, 0.013397647067904472, 0.028500398620963097, -0.01159295067191124, -0.02063876762986183, -0.024588674306869507, -0.008099750615656376, 0.02006414905190468, -0.019491741433739662, 0.0322556309401989, -0.006714757531881332, 0.025546304881572723, -0.012834958732128143, -0.001112800557166338, 0.014871053397655487, 0.045930150896310806, -0.034980446100234985, -0.03921094536781311, -0.03390905633568764, 0.004535219632089138, -0.027455607429146767, 0.022289099171757698, -0.009804833680391312, 0.00788753479719162, 0.04408487677574158, 0.014172224327921867, 0.030183572322130203, -0.011452337726950645, 0.029131365939974785, -0.046295758336782455, 0.06304316967725754, -0.03600294515490532, -0.021226724609732628, -0.004120638594031334, 0.008318252861499786, -0.019272608682513237, -0.050528012216091156, 0.029976600781083107, 0.013311382383108139, -0.04699522629380226, -0.0003879154974129051, 0.023038947954773903, -0.012109809555113316, 0.0712742805480957, 0.010415666736662388, 0.010485497303307056, 0.011636991985142231, -0.048456449061632156, 0.00881091970950365, 0.010390960611402988, -0.021413126960396767, 0.014128705486655235, 0.037554774433374405, -0.00019637166406027973, 0.015059984289109707, 0.005116790998727083, 0.03562191501259804, 0.0226729828864336, 0.013900053687393665, -0.005507370922714472, 0.04704984650015831, 0.012380437925457954, 0.0005865845596417785, 0.006728919688612223, -0.027399156242609024, 0.045941099524497986, -0.024488160386681557, 0.03599187359213829, -0.030693737789988518, -0.014063050970435143, 0.009090997278690338, 0.028310293331742287, -0.028095610439777374, 0.04309547692537308, -0.0247952863574028, -0.016093336045742035, -0.04643752798438072, -0.0034019220620393753, 0.016455132514238358, -0.046493642032146454, 0.02252175472676754, -0.027288081124424934, -0.034304141998291016, 0.014117574319243431, -0.00502364058047533, -0.02372271940112114, -0.010926510207355022, 0.017680129036307335, 0.05850198492407799, 0.043842021375894547, 0.017095394432544708, -0.029697654768824577, -0.006169282365590334, 0.019262170419096947, -0.022167887538671494, -0.004122961312532425, -0.03132868558168411, -0.01610841043293476, 0.01239012647420168, -0.003104920731857419 ]
<p>It's well known that members of the public have difficulty comprehending numbers over a certain size. A common tricky issue for people communicating demographic trends is helping people make sense of rates out of 100,000. This is an important issue in helping people make sense of changing health and crime statistics, for example.</p> <p>For those of you who do statistical communication for the public, what frames of reference or other analogies and aids have you found to be successful in helping people to put rates out of 100,000 in perspective? There's <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/12810/why-do-demographers-give-rates-per-100-000-people">another question with a discussion alluding to 100,000 people being a small to medium sized city</a>, and it seems there's disagreement over whether this analogy is helpful or not. </p> <p>Answers citing evidence would be great, personal experience and ideas are helpful too.</p> <p><em>(p.s. I'm also <a href="http://meta.stats.stackexchange.com/questions/1099/statistical-communications-questions">starting a discussion on meta</a> on whether to tag/allow/encourage stats communications questions like this on this site)</em></p>
74,385
[ -0.052340809255838394, -0.04031911864876747, 0.007737424224615097, -0.00404146546497941, 0.025816652923822403, 0.0055288937874138355, 0.010955531150102615, 0.009020309895277023, 0.03616674244403839, -0.01704375073313713, 0.05187768116593361, 0.049252331256866455, 0.05751284584403038, 0.01955999620258808, 0.029421744868159294, 0.05223356932401657, 0.009783407673239708, 0.037740644067525864, 0.0008612696547061205, 0.01173741277307272, 0.045112501829862595, 0.02384956367313862, 0.007102263625711203, 0.008274526335299015, -0.00973785575479269, 0.014349236153066158, 0.04093402996659279, -0.03912241384387016, 0.0024974809493869543, 0.028074245899915695, -0.005188031122088432, -0.001639045774936676, 0.06391985714435577, 0.05492139235138893, 0.01290169171988964, 0.029329007491469383, -0.02949601039290428, -0.011687135323882103, 0.02915780618786812, 0.047028787434101105, -0.05259740352630615, -0.010744643397629261, 0.0215627271682024, 0.024312680587172508, -0.050506941974163055, -0.01336776651442051, -0.0131297018378973, -0.011186286807060242, 0.015194136649370193, -0.015731021761894226, 0.016380826011300087, 0.003609999781474471, 0.018508736044168472, 0.055993933230638504, -0.04129072651267052, -0.019956188276410103, 0.054657548666000366, 0.03675370290875435, -0.03436335548758507, -0.05043495073914528, -0.009341558441519737, 0.0033351543825119734, -0.0334329791367054, -0.03575281798839569, 0.014199258759617805, 0.030324432998895645, -0.014090636745095253, -0.013056835159659386, 0.026572315022349358, -0.020848389714956284, -0.010536675341427326, 0.0018414320657029748, 0.03320305421948433, 0.019298648461699486, -0.0075541273690760136, -0.0544036328792572, 0.0036187968216836452, -0.02210383303463459, 0.05270669609308243, 0.059397708624601364, -0.05332447960972786, 0.0021804433781653643, 0.04993465542793274, 0.04988084360957146, 0.02016753889620304, -0.016504360362887383, 0.07836713641881943, -0.02049359492957592, -0.011709707789123058, 0.01997092179954052, -0.01571759209036827, -0.0029828744009137154, 0.012308242730796337, 0.0037509435787796974, -0.03402068093419075, 0.035634372383356094, -0.04381479695439339, 0.054872047156095505, 0.027158968150615692, 0.005676680710166693, -0.03769850358366966, -0.036578141152858734, 0.04609590023756027, 0.023525085300207138, -0.040390659123659134, -0.010501491837203503, -0.0477042980492115, -0.031117375940084457, -0.04629333317279816, -0.025360742583870888, -0.04062654450535774, -0.038759637624025345, 0.026975145563483238, 0.008140584453940392, -0.0018966959323734045, -0.008962147869169712, 0.010097098536789417, 0.008957636542618275, 0.0337321013212204, 0.05312366783618927, 0.05917738750576973, -0.0398995615541935, 0.043846260756254196, -0.0047442796640098095, -0.032595377415418625, 0.02801422029733658, -0.02759324386715889, -0.01338170189410448, -0.04405293986201286, 0.040617458522319794, 0.015872208401560783, -0.02180110476911068, -0.010893024504184723, -0.029884757474064827, 0.0430179238319397, 0.017958372831344604, -0.07817661017179489, -0.038557421416044235, 0.024968650192022324, 0.04533182084560394, -0.03042842261493206, -0.037307679653167725, -0.00018156241276301444, -0.01249375194311142, 0.00646411906927824, 0.01496793795377016, 0.013916200958192348, -0.005197104532271624, 0.03413986414670944, 0.02606949768960476, 0.004903527908027172, -0.00128623575437814, -0.00005459878229885362, -0.0008231670944951475, 0.003753652097657323, -0.06656055152416229, 0.013820302672684193, 0.03665119782090187, -0.007875315845012665, -0.013401416130363941, 0.04028287157416344, 0.009383872151374817, -0.018660742789506912, -0.030903490260243416, 0.000044851058191852644, 0.004048379138112068, 0.08663953840732574, -0.005387225653976202, 0.007878870703279972, 0.03849240764975548, -0.026320811361074448, 0.03246259316802025, 0.024203116074204445, -0.004455254878848791, 0.042301345616579056, -0.017716730013489723, 0.01018625870347023, -0.0011302700731903315, -0.029686562716960907, 0.014517010189592838, -0.03079318441450596, -0.024966644123196602, -0.008578358218073845, -0.016783535480499268, 0.03009960614144802, 0.03424225375056267, -0.0026936568319797516, -0.005187098402529955, 0.021668653935194016, -0.05375836789608002, -0.05468757450580597, -0.06285887956619263, 0.011310880072414875, -0.03894619271159172, 0.026503434404730797, 0.01527524832636118, -0.0521964468061924, -0.01383746787905693, -0.03758310154080391, -0.012088439427316189, -0.017499465495347977, 0.01571371965110302, 0.0747433751821518, -0.02353605441749096, -0.002432679058983922, 0.04245266318321228, 0.043635036796331406, -0.032711517065763474, 0.029074274003505707, -0.06374594569206238, -0.03623209521174431, 0.015465470030903816, 0.02593950927257538, 0.0506223700940609, -0.002582968445494771, -0.0056717367842793465, -0.026003124192357063, -0.0033072077203541994, -0.036686740815639496, 0.02064814232289791, -0.07559751719236374, 0.061667028814554214, 0.05860196799039841, -0.017326518893241882, -0.005750487558543682, 0.036353468894958496, 0.029896749183535576, -0.004693571478128433, 0.021226059645414352, -0.04144252836704254, -0.04780082404613495, 0.02764890156686306, 0.03429992124438286, 0.009467057883739471, -0.0332840271294117, -0.0013656392693519592, 0.019611001014709473, 0.041141264140605927, -0.028328312560915947, -0.01633547991514206, -0.012939161621034145, -0.024713020771741867, 0.00542587973177433, -0.007165709510445595, -0.022318817675113678, 0.007113832980394363, 0.039273593574762344, 0.026887891814112663, -0.01173058245331049, 0.03218811750411987, -0.0023834670428186655, 0.04711027070879936, -0.038920484483242035, 0.001974549377337098, -0.009193981997668743, 0.015349991619586945, 0.07426199316978455, -0.0679565817117691, -0.007862784899771214, 0.03135724738240242, 0.006299438886344433, 0.03761181980371475, 0.00209458963945508, -0.017688671126961708, -0.028227580711245537, 0.0527908094227314, -0.008281606249511242, 0.01612503081560135, 0.013683518394827843, -0.040328461676836014, -0.003910886123776436, -0.03438431769609451, -0.036778371781110764, -0.039939794689416885, 0.00818153191357851, 0.018599197268486023, 0.03617822006344795, 0.002569940872490406, -0.06060698255896568, -0.018171196803450584, 0.009977768175303936, 0.001491302507929504, -0.006943579763174057, 0.0236500296741724, -0.037725843489170074, 0.015505444258451462, 0.0068500954657793045, -0.02447773888707161, 0.021731074899435043, -0.007364700082689524, -0.016786035150289536, 0.002378697507083416, 0.009752274490892887, -0.04965171217918396, 0.013360589742660522, -0.013538606464862823, 0.031886786222457886, -0.010045873001217842, -0.0011976087698712945, 0.03343536704778671, -0.009157338179647923, -0.041799165308475494, -0.018494009971618652, -0.0258333683013916, -0.044030364602804184, -0.03594769909977913, 0.011227322742342949, 0.003853532252833247, 0.020296575501561165, -0.006227060221135616, 0.020611288025975227, 0.002593506593257189, -0.009326412342488766, -0.052192751318216324, -0.05233723670244217, -0.0033888223115354776, 0.01922859437763691, 0.07362298667430878, 0.005447120405733585, 0.000007893899237387814, 0.043187327682971954, 0.0154647845774889, -0.01967974379658699, -0.03687714785337448, -0.03170359134674072, 0.01417392399162054, -0.0029350160621106625, 0.008837560191750526, 0.03635471314191818, 0.0024895076639950275, 0.015241232700645924, 0.051611050963401794, 0.03860482573509216, 0.03462715819478035, 0.019610265269875526, 0.008718166500329971, -0.01031744759529829, -0.014924060553312302, -0.018017422407865524, 0.0453178770840168, 0.0350877083837986, -0.09302635490894318, 0.022034836933016777, -0.038937896490097046, 0.02266504429280758, 0.04156443104147911, -0.055792633444070816, 0.025818469002842903, 0.023060539737343788, -0.007913382723927498, -0.039524342864751816, 0.021961623802781105, -0.00037920012255199254, -0.015500102192163467, -0.009306110441684723, 0.010162074118852615, 0.04673324525356293, -0.02983926795423031, -0.03433519974350929, 0.02858109399676323, 0.06452582776546478, -0.009146083146333694, -0.003654351457953453, -0.014699894934892654, 0.0038984674029052258, 0.01292301993817091, -0.004315855447202921, 0.008858862332999706, 0.01650763303041458, 0.06155211105942726, 0.015004507265985012, -0.004994267597794533, -0.056096553802490234, 0.03940265625715256, -0.07216934859752655, -0.015528475865721703, -0.030255066230893135, 0.03378741443157196, -0.0257679745554924, 0.02297697775065899, 0.030850844457745552, 0.017161862924695015, -0.02689734473824501, 0.046171292662620544, -0.061382465064525604, -0.0037691816687583923, -0.042315416038036346, -0.006354601122438908, 0.014243771322071552, -0.01865547150373459, 0.04107392206788063, 0.014965256676077843, -0.003564834361895919, -0.022910943254828453, 0.03218892589211464, 0.007100550923496485, -0.0026558726094663143, -0.006348358932882547, -0.04246718809008598, -0.02201092429459095, -0.011023673228919506, -0.00006065269553801045, 0.03619420900940895, 0.0353814996778965, 0.019271843135356903, 0.033550702035427094, -0.05386943370103836, -0.021055761724710464, 0.007594681344926357, -0.0033999725710600615, 0.017616165801882744, -0.004855874460190535, 0.002507369499653578, -0.03620290756225586, 0.025459513068199158, 0.01571691781282425, 0.029075222089886665, 0.009066048078238964, -0.019478516653180122, -0.01599114201962948, -0.00015730372979305685, -0.016070757061243057, -0.030053356662392616, 0.028091205283999443, -0.033288877457380295, -0.005903417710214853, 0.06914857774972916, -0.006420433521270752, -0.010180569253861904, 0.07033374905586243, 0.040245722979307175, -0.012333248741924763, -0.005900919903069735, -0.01449879165738821, -0.009328787215054035, 0.02393311820924282, 0.03343428671360016, 0.011444021947681904, 0.04766407608985901, 0.04237520322203636, 0.011169442906975746, 0.028548650443553925, -0.022777823731303215, -0.008305298164486885, 0.019795814529061317, -0.021682683378458023, 0.050137098878622055, 0.008900626562535763, -0.024090047925710678, -0.01519295945763588, 0.02200278826057911, 0.03920193389058113, 0.025366496294736862, -0.005435089580714703, -0.11174057424068451, -0.027928214520215988, 0.027804072946310043, 0.05807337164878845, -0.03166109696030617, 0.031395912170410156, -0.06049339473247528, 0.0008247460355050862, 0.027660928666591644, -0.025287669152021408, -0.012964654713869095, -0.043863445520401, 0.03217383101582527, -0.004064199980348349, -0.0649069994688034, -0.0005064920405857265, 0.018648412078619003, -0.012005284428596497, 0.013846867717802525, -0.006463329773396254, 0.022871363908052444, -0.04104005545377731, 0.018651612102985382, 0.025814268738031387, 0.051946017891168594, -0.012608414515852928, -0.03996529057621956, 0.010616889223456383, 0.006295380648225546, -0.04981689155101776, -0.043171901255846024, 0.03788714110851288, 0.044261716306209564, -0.007935828529298306, 0.01652592234313488, -0.004333951976150274, -0.01852232962846756, 0.013049131259322166, 0.005235457327216864, -0.04176132380962372, 0.020564330741763115, -0.025041285902261734, 0.04695236682891846, 0.010752703063189983, 0.02792873978614807, 0.028967123478651047, 0.028379321098327637, -0.008296124637126923, 0.02862674929201603, -0.029475316405296326, 0.024188701063394547, -0.0021074649412184954, -0.0034167496487498283, -0.01722956821322441, 0.016403712332248688, -0.015165952034294605, 0.030836639925837517, 0.004408243577927351, 0.0035334983840584755, -0.04600740969181061, -0.03398420289158821, -0.002344792941585183, 0.009524377062916756, -0.0081658735871315, 0.024552254006266594, 0.009196409955620766, 0.025207137688994408, -0.006183157209306955, -0.008217528462409973, 0.0350930355489254, -0.04802175611257553, -0.006085473112761974, 0.0411696620285511, -0.032304540276527405, 0.005500525701791048, -0.06117047742009163, -0.027227208018302917, 0.02075658179819584, -0.06835804134607315, 0.04416700452566147, 0.005360966548323631, 0.031262945383787155, 0.006702113430947065, -0.027343889698386192, -0.009357734583318233, -0.008404410444200039, 0.010142453946173191, 0.044226326048374176, -0.0096031678840518, 0.04941646009683609, -0.016483966261148453, -0.004620035644620657, -0.04725835472345352, -0.0204424150288105, 0.03923160582780838, 0.013746322132647038, -0.03144519031047821, -0.02823842130601406, 0.008270717225968838, -0.023908408358693123, -0.011134970933198929, -0.001207795925438404, 0.042623188346624374, -0.03302105516195297, -0.0027691065333783627, -0.0037639224901795387, -0.006251875311136246, 0.11089862138032913, -0.06382329761981964, -0.01736380159854889, 0.024603914469480515, 0.013014041818678379, 0.012275965884327888, -0.03145017474889755, 0.029197730123996735, -0.052164431661367416, -0.032357342541217804, -0.009698275476694107, -0.03849406912922859, 0.0308128222823143, -0.023301364853978157, 0.02129254676401615, 0.016260700300335884, -0.026717716827988625, 0.01631210558116436, -0.0024321654345840216, 0.019939107820391655, -0.01801225170493126, 0.021318860352039337, -0.05890486389398575, 0.04910633713006973, 0.0097816688939929, 0.01976040005683899, 0.03261943161487579, 0.022226130589842796, -0.003544267499819398, 0.014303423464298248, 0.04960501194000244, -0.05566644296050072, 0.05278896167874336, 0.012901759706437588, 0.015978343784809113, 0.06972599029541016, 0.006338890176266432, -0.011790173128247261, -0.004233907908201218, 0.0002613461983855814, -0.0004030541458632797, -0.04054022952914238, -0.031282760202884674, -0.010350901633501053, 0.03849345073103905, 0.004544755909591913, 0.022515982389450073, -0.003816870041191578, -0.05352795869112015, 0.028377555310726166, -0.04355340078473091, 0.007635347545146942, -0.03194054961204529, 0.0198346097022295, 0.022671833634376526, -0.015605814754962921, -0.015568956732749939, 0.0354088619351387, 0.06246095523238182, 0.015103225596249104, 0.019638296216726303, 0.022933367639780045, 0.021115921437740326, 0.032332003116607666, -0.04204986244440079, -0.016096336767077446, 0.038872040808200836, -0.046143412590026855, -0.004450592678040266, -0.04517749324440956, -0.05793532356619835, 0.05235499143600464, 0.00040877037099562585, 0.016349278390407562, -0.04438311606645584, 0.006401205435395241, -0.058150582015514374, -0.02087516337633133, 0.014469998888671398, 0.01620173640549183, 0.012686719186604023, -0.0562063492834568, -0.004312445875257254, 0.01794004626572132, 0.02824173867702484, -0.02937397174537182, -0.06061149016022682, -0.00733540952205658, -0.021614111959934235, -0.05411328375339508, 0.013829277828335762, 0.01113224122673273, 0.0110856294631958, 0.015085363760590553, -0.025507081300020218, 0.007828515022993088, 0.005723420064896345, -0.02010979689657688, -0.01826605200767517, 0.08182269334793091, 0.03794242441654205, 0.021669132634997368, -0.010072869248688221, -0.029703082516789436, 0.12805622816085815, 0.05961696058511734, 0.011076640337705612, -0.024102210998535156, 0.018589433282613754, 0.04361261427402496, 0.01612408645451069, -0.00708400271832943, -0.0239707101136446, 0.020985545590519905, 0.012344052083790302, 0.0634729266166687, 0.07188750803470612, 0.014363409020006657, -0.017585039138793945, 0.06126902252435684, -0.007724307011812925, -0.024880368262529373, -0.0013322895392775536, 0.013283534906804562, 0.002015759004279971, -0.0006631315918639302, -0.024421997368335724, 0.008852777071297169, 0.011507092043757439, 0.018545668572187424, -0.029774392023682594, -0.013255911879241467, -0.01277678832411766, 0.02242070809006691, -0.030903300270438194, -0.00933370552957058, 0.033339034765958786, -0.03170626610517502, -0.013016077689826488, -0.03525690734386444, 0.029933735728263855, -0.04900259152054787, -0.014893601648509502, 0.031864751130342484, -0.04639993607997894, 0.03555656224489212, -0.02101271227002144, 0.00007035670569166541, -0.06938600540161133, -0.015313439071178436, -0.007916746661067009, 0.012624282389879227, -0.017896370962262154, 0.002790490398183465, -0.03502931445837021, -0.012315659783780575, -0.016546132043004036, -0.00923684798181057, 0.03582383319735527, 0.012240122072398663, 0.03216357156634331, 0.011704515665769577, -0.01669788919389248, -0.013536750338971615, 0.041539985686540604, -0.031099440529942513, 0.01005427073687315, 0.04859820380806923, -0.03664080798625946, -0.04633161425590515, -0.03136320412158966, 0.006198062561452389, -0.008318719454109669, -0.0031283365096896887, -0.0042514195665717125, 0.022562524303793907, -0.06353701651096344, -0.014287673868238926, -0.016397878527641296, 0.020236296579241753, 0.03987481817603111, 0.03132365643978119, 0.012347964569926262, -0.02555249258875847, -0.0381259061396122, 0.008774463087320328, 0.01561944279819727, 0.016941986978054047, -0.014902453869581223, -0.012743807397782803, 0.0007885239901952446, 0.008477013558149338, 0.005378983449190855, 0.03059476800262928, -0.02927607111632824, 0.06873784959316254, 0.007043040357530117, -0.03531903401017189, 0.004122079815715551, -0.0022079988848417997, -0.027298560366034508, 0.014796278439462185, -0.012229051440954208, 0.055570244789123535, -0.011806981638073921, 0.009145357646048069, 0.04109230637550354, 0.025645188987255096, 0.005731898359954357, 0.0026345206424593925, 0.007128261961042881, -0.05978604406118393, -0.008295178413391113, 0.009330106899142265, -0.019780663773417473, -0.03487224876880646, -0.029949363321065903, -0.032923419028520584, -0.0007830084068700671, 0.0006230483413673937, 0.002442639786750078, -0.03698527812957764, 0.05157947540283203, -0.03852124512195587, -0.022499490529298782, -0.012369800359010696, -0.05178532004356384, -0.024324623867869377, -0.04465219005942345, -0.03260160610079765, -0.043152716010808945, -0.00899034459143877, -0.004129457753151655, -0.013008324429392815, 0.007729714270681143, 0.021696830168366432, -0.002233658917248249, -0.019305305555462837, 0.02437186986207962, 0.009880290366709232, 0.018867023289203644, 0.04498034343123436, -0.05375665798783302, 0.00042377947829663754, 0.032685477286577225, -0.002139396732673049, -0.037126027047634125, 0.013811234384775162, -0.0046194070018827915, 0.020507147535681725, 0.011185958981513977, -0.008920571766793728, -0.0019690850749611855, 0.038607846945524216, -0.006347279995679855, 0.004941558465361595, -0.000607194728218019, 0.009055091999471188, 0.0563986636698246, -0.027399085462093353, -0.000832315650768578, -0.00020142247376497835, 0.01089394185692072, -0.015484385192394257, 0.04185087978839874, -0.018137063831090927, 0.015320492908358574, 0.012497328221797943, -0.021423058584332466, 0.006322623696178198, -0.019900310784578323, 0.02184036746621132, 0.02543579414486885, 0.024674493819475174, -0.053652919828891754, 0.027381915599107742, -0.026680875569581985, 0.016668692231178284, -0.12674200534820557, 0.014228371903300285, 0.017175640910863876, 0.0007841290207579732, 0.019631855189800262, -0.054429806768894196, 0.022831380367279053, -0.018542373552918434, -0.07783805578947067, 0.011610202491283417, -0.0022877641022205353, 0.00825699046254158, -0.02338353544473648, 0.015272898599505424, -0.008701622486114502, 0.03866942971944809, 0.015287532471120358, 0.0316009521484375, -0.03513271361589432, 0.03371390700340271, 0.016490647569298744, -0.025698529556393623, -0.020463675260543823, 0.009622780606150627, -0.0011893098708242178, 0.004648793488740921, 0.08880265057086945, -0.0167533066123724, -0.026148151606321335, 0.055702999234199524, -0.01715950481593609, 0.056205108761787415, 0.03385861590504646, 0.028891269117593765, 0.006240124814212322, 0.01543167419731617, 0.03845233842730522, -0.0047583142295479774, -0.0882176011800766, -0.019060330465435982, -0.01452487614005804, 0.04823652654886246, -0.020347854122519493, 0.016845611855387688, 0.06624750047922134, -0.004875963553786278, -0.02430855669081211, 0.029346918687224388, -0.04652689769864082, -0.0340685099363327, 0.012399784289300442, -0.03891395404934883, 0.024217942729592323, 0.007426498923450708, 0.036241475492715836, -0.03235293924808502, -0.02313910238444805, 0.0369146466255188, 0.010860903188586235, -0.01107336301356554, 0.014392453245818615, -0.025249769911170006, -0.04193693771958351, -0.032040152698755264, -0.02223447896540165, 0.00013736553955823183, -0.04832480102777481, -0.04586952179670334, 0.002884546061977744, 0.03582384064793587, -0.030293181538581848, -0.02125377766788006, -0.03286970406770706, 0.05493352934718132, 0.003017295617610216, 0.024587510153651237, 0.0376378670334816, 0.004048777744174004, 0.00318219349719584, -0.058680545538663864, -0.006603850983083248, 0.01383802480995655, 0.019399218261241913, -0.039643168449401855, -0.06645452231168747, -0.0002624396001920104, 0.01889529824256897, 0.07288707047700882, 0.04558431729674339, 0.01283943559974432, 0.004606566391885281, 0.0044417306780815125, 0.0061764465644955635, -0.02631806954741478, 0.04087269306182861, 0.0021711676381528378, -0.012705101631581783, 0.010295042768120766, 0.002804212272167206, 0.02230192720890045, -0.0342092365026474, 0.03961222618818283, 0.0015710206935182214, -0.007424796465784311, -0.0014557556714862585, 0.0011008448200300336, 0.015230103395879269, 0.061497319489717484, -0.0021322891116142273, 0.01091001182794571, 0.003362514078617096, 0.011661791242659092, 0.028638526797294617, 0.017775453627109528, -0.040440354496240616, 0.03470670059323311, -0.027754109352827072, -0.02810150757431984, 0.02437790483236313, -0.03817690536379814, 0.0044565824791789055, -0.04175842925906181, 0.0009989176178351045, 0.0028957738541066647, -0.016104625537991524, 0.004058367572724819, 0.025983721017837524, 0.06493452191352844, 0.0024867504835128784, 0.007784903980791569, -0.008388160727918148, 0.0024818414822220802, -0.04434957727789879, -0.021499983966350555, -0.003686237381771207, 0.010234106332063675, -0.02170991525053978, 0.015388323925435543, 0.05246914550662041, 0.023962104693055153, 0.015304003842175007, -0.007874097675085068, 0.01216218713670969, -0.019947292283177376, -0.02491000108420849, 0.0009413413354195654, 0.014904390089213848, -0.0127134183421731, 0.07710771262645721, 0.014801827259361744, 0.06840625405311584, 0.023065805435180664, 0.014364509843289852, -0.013870825991034508, 0.0011762733338400722, -0.07057903707027435, -0.05087198317050934, -0.015227038413286209, 0.012266101315617561, -0.02093755640089512, -0.02720051072537899, 0.017768176272511482, -0.013334988616406918, 0.029387084767222404, -0.014100255444645882, -0.009323385544121265, -0.050143271684646606, 0.01197756640613079, -0.010569826699793339, -0.007576885167509317, -0.003498679958283901, -0.026628902181982994, 0.03267713263630867, 0.031216200441122055, 0.04832787439227104, 0.0139088723808527, -0.0641632154583931, 0.004748115781694651, 0.020214978605508804, -0.06572860479354858, -0.00596772413700819, -0.05810653045773506, -0.03218434378504753, 0.01048275176435709, -0.06139689311385155 ]
<p>Let's say I have a $m \times n$ matrix where $m$ is the number of points and $n$ is the number of dimensions. I would like to give a target dimension parameter which is let's say d. d can be a set of values like $\{2,4,6,\ldots,n\}$. I would then approach the problem using Fisher's linear discriminant analysis to give me output matrix in $m \times d$. Is this possible to do? I still don't understand how LDA reduces dimensions from let's say 10,000 to 1,000.</p>
74,386
[ -0.027986302971839905, 0.00004035871461383067, 0.013507859781384468, -0.03162305802106857, 0.052915483713150024, -0.0006111829425208271, -0.0699530765414238, -0.01944676786661148, 0.029538344591856003, -0.0658644512295723, 0.020738517865538597, 0.005727041978389025, 0.049888040870428085, 0.013289342634379864, 0.0062636155635118484, 0.030702581629157066, -0.03913439065217972, 0.022453662008047104, -0.009608220309019089, -0.004705291241407394, 0.010352609679102898, 0.03924327716231346, 0.03885664790868759, -0.01845521107316017, -0.01393918227404356, 0.06897249072790146, 0.031671494245529175, -0.03374044597148895, 0.01708162948489189, 0.045965004712343216, -0.026206152513623238, -0.016592038795351982, 0.02488252893090248, 0.06864623725414276, 0.003536982461810112, -0.02461264282464981, -0.017444511875510216, -0.04880145937204361, -0.0023083777632564306, 0.02014167234301567, -0.02355687879025936, -0.042184874415397644, 0.013245568610727787, 0.05775472894310951, -0.012631482444703579, 0.04087520018219948, -0.001457958947867155, -0.05488498881459236, 0.005238559562712908, -0.04169049486517906, 0.11440028250217438, 0.022905392572283745, 0.011738439090549946, 0.00021290087897796184, -0.01574065163731575, -0.006079775281250477, 0.033130768686532974, 0.0695149227976799, 0.003118733875453472, -0.0014663926558569074, -0.0024036129470914602, -0.004030859097838402, 0.022707808762788773, -0.019731301814317703, -0.0157400444149971, 0.02046380564570427, -0.002672666683793068, 0.02700706012547016, 0.0019889320246875286, -0.007058955263346434, -0.018809495493769646, 0.0035426386166363955, 0.04374374449253082, 0.0031443743500858545, -0.004578042775392532, -0.03692927584052086, 0.003114853287115693, 0.017143072560429573, 0.04047944024205208, 0.03229526802897453, -0.0029766440857201815, 0.058020155876874924, -6.870394031466276e-7, 0.033067405223846436, 0.03059973567724228, -0.015102128498256207, 0.030441245064139366, -0.029419858008623123, 0.013315805234014988, 0.036008819937705994, -0.01256138738244772, -0.028922665864229202, 0.0573759488761425, -0.009962686337530613, -0.03349507600069046, 0.025919688865542412, -0.009256850928068161, 0.042936310172080994, 0.03124970942735672, -0.0315830372273922, -0.0196660328656435, -0.01919286884367466, -0.0064162337221205235, 0.012257566675543785, -0.010400932282209396, 0.012621506117284298, -0.036767154932022095, 0.010937843471765518, -0.03490707650780678, 0.004706387408077717, -0.013061430305242538, 0.02495587058365345, 0.03178005293011665, -0.005443076137453318, 0.03407266363501549, 0.014321623370051384, -0.013336130417883396, -0.029513176530599594, 0.03796960040926933, 0.08553555607795715, -0.004578510764986277, -0.029609721153974533, 0.009235081262886524, -0.0212072916328907, -0.05538761988282204, -0.010723273269832134, 0.005785803776234388, 0.009820614941418171, -0.018666254356503487, 0.03756208345293999, -0.02382895164191723, -0.01688086986541748, 0.0583672933280468, -0.004069891758263111, 0.024257520213723183, 0.003955733496695757, -0.07735991477966309, -0.04245106130838394, 0.039370663464069366, -0.006103822495788336, 0.024927619844675064, -0.058815889060497284, 0.030947977676987648, 0.026329075917601585, 0.02726774290204048, 0.02968369610607624, 0.0404091440141201, 0.057272057980298996, 0.01772449165582657, -0.007684458512812853, -0.015114428475499153, -0.03238312155008316, -0.039902422577142715, -0.002628015587106347, 0.01967913657426834, -0.05100397393107414, 0.029963869601488113, 0.029125014320015907, -0.019423246383666992, -0.021013464778661728, 0.03294553607702255, 0.01088281162083149, -0.02618081122636795, -0.002095114206895232, -0.003333647735416889, -0.005431096535176039, 0.051019925624132156, -0.024913113564252853, 0.025870362296700478, 0.009590108878910542, -0.012234759517014027, 0.009537748992443085, 0.03743578866124153, 0.07166711241006851, 0.047634419053792953, 0.010977720841765404, -0.03435652703046799, -0.028299426659941673, 0.03485577180981636, -0.01765425316989422, -0.05006467178463936, -0.0640396997332573, 0.0031644999980926514, 0.027531638741493225, 0.017073575407266617, 0.03443970903754234, 0.0016288685146719217, -0.0026565107982605696, -0.03850780054926872, -0.02134455367922783, -0.03213679417967796, -0.04923265054821968, 0.01544412411749363, 0.017101697623729706, -0.021308699622750282, 0.03388908877968788, 0.0227569080889225, -0.006983607541769743, -0.004703865386545658, -0.024930238723754883, -0.0584978312253952, -0.023344503715634346, 0.03708711639046669, -0.05434158816933632, -0.020215576514601707, 0.05972914397716522, 0.05830325186252594, -0.02966216951608658, 0.0666278749704361, -0.039985597133636475, -0.020653732120990753, -0.011250382289290428, -0.011906472966074944, 0.027584608644247055, -0.0010252081556245685, -0.00485429260879755, 0.03186645731329918, -0.019533522427082062, -0.04782542586326599, 0.04189836606383324, -0.03857336565852165, 0.08231566846370697, 0.058145154267549515, -0.018755290657281876, 0.028759637847542763, -0.002997810486704111, -0.013497428968548775, 0.0028883132617920637, -0.01897975243628025, -0.02003726176917553, -0.0317053496837616, -0.008568915538489819, 0.03013751283288002, 0.038737036287784576, -0.08671238273382187, 0.02148866094648838, 0.06395058333873749, 0.023171402513980865, 0.03174785152077675, 0.03202352300286293, -0.02761934883892536, 0.010034735314548016, 0.0018181829946115613, 0.02530848979949951, -0.045122262090444565, -0.01941271871328354, 0.016174698248505592, 0.01816490851342678, 0.03376508504152298, -0.01133607979863882, 0.009986608289182186, 0.025615321472287178, -0.018357358872890472, -0.018881240859627724, 0.012062338180840015, 0.0210670605301857, 0.03688812255859375, 0.0009378297254443169, 0.004470942076295614, 0.05245251581072807, 0.009004700928926468, 0.016079679131507874, -0.025969842448830605, -0.014504710212349892, 0.021500688046216965, 0.053688496351242065, -0.015048565343022346, 0.004120186902582645, 0.025067519396543503, -0.05925377458333969, 0.022448206320405006, 0.011087673716247082, 0.006574518047273159, -0.022269202396273613, 0.029774175956845284, 0.05769196152687073, 0.004577577579766512, -0.00925486721098423, 0.0031611076556146145, -0.05983671918511391, 0.00321595324203372, -0.010944164358079433, 0.02684667333960533, 0.015464836731553078, -0.060255058109760284, -0.01926710270345211, -0.025358695536851883, -0.0211515910923481, 0.0266041811555624, -0.018215039744973183, -0.005106187425553799, 0.027491308748722076, -0.02993699163198471, -0.08571558445692062, -0.04615343362092972, -0.012517294846475124, 0.07245030999183655, -0.020819667726755142, -0.007151235360652208, 0.04054176062345505, 0.007960211485624313, -0.021798590198159218, -0.014238006435334682, -0.028288710862398148, -0.014403020031750202, -0.055713169276714325, -0.03146309033036232, 0.006348039489239454, -0.006100656930357218, -0.00608625216409564, 0.038859281688928604, -0.01602097973227501, 0.039502862840890884, -0.06956254690885544, -0.025399159640073776, 0.026531247422099113, 0.03637439012527466, 0.07042606174945831, -0.005268702283501625, -0.02663622610270977, 0.06795517355203629, 0.04913519695401192, -0.03408123925328255, -0.01814267225563526, 0.02353343740105629, -0.05888096243143082, -0.06614936143159866, 0.03763663396239281, 0.00557701988145709, -0.007889932952821255, 0.03489450737833977, -0.01985786110162735, 0.020776180550456047, 0.08170410990715027, 0.007844485342502594, -0.007667020428925753, 0.03159844130277634, -0.007243034895509481, 0.021016307175159454, 0.005206074099987745, 0.005090734455734491, -0.06714332848787308, 0.032533399760723114, -0.00047467160038650036, 0.022909758612513542, -0.0041384086944162846, -0.028822168707847595, -0.0015179031761363149, -0.03594750165939331, 0.02266577072441578, 0.0033091988880187273, -0.023258812725543976, 0.03208913654088974, 0.009604441933333874, -0.008092531003057957, 0.030835287645459175, 0.022778097540140152, -0.038379374891519547, -0.01814144477248192, 0.020705334842205048, -0.009371669963002205, -0.008470448665320873, 0.03336270898580551, 0.027242910116910934, -0.0054639484733343124, 0.0007723085582256317, 0.019644053652882576, 0.011524191126227379, 0.025097331032156944, 0.016329215839505196, 0.009856846183538437, 0.010140166617929935, 0.001051259459927678, 0.021826520562171936, -0.0462506040930748, 0.0012073065154254436, -0.03602335602045059, 0.06183270364999771, -0.016440896317362785, 0.032114122062921524, 0.03736076503992081, 0.0017707550432533026, -0.007887052372097969, 0.014896822161972523, -0.0459902286529541, -0.010228397324681282, -0.03386343643069267, 0.00757444417104125, -0.0014675395796075463, -0.032420262694358826, 0.013012229464948177, -0.018378054723143578, -0.010409374721348286, 0.028378475457429886, 0.05354037508368492, -0.05564510077238083, 0.00912739522755146, -0.004963716492056847, -0.009628464467823505, -0.048154547810554504, 0.04553283751010895, 0.01901783049106598, -0.020326530560851097, 0.009234679862856865, 0.06329125910997391, -0.016965124756097794, -0.010680564679205418, -0.02656543254852295, 0.001539937686175108, -0.011758282780647278, 0.0513935312628746, 0.002350440016016364, 0.03805788233876228, -0.03324541822075844, 0.0368800014257431, -0.01689770072698593, 0.04670236259698868, 0.01579197309911251, 0.011612660251557827, -0.006679779849946499, -0.07984637469053268, -0.023262886330485344, 0.001939609064720571, 0.03188391774892807, -0.017568988725543022, -0.0415627583861351, 0.02641000784933567, 0.019819555804133415, -0.059086088091135025, 0.034191906452178955, 0.04766513779759407, 0.006952766794711351, -0.01956801861524582, -0.02655237913131714, -0.00942130759358406, -0.00020179283455945551, -0.011772424913942814, 0.020584341138601303, -0.002685338258743286, 0.008523372933268547, 0.0013915437739342451, 0.04387609288096428, -0.018522776663303375, -0.03448491543531418, -0.00658554257825017, 0.024823997169733047, 0.05172630771994591, -0.010806665755808353, 0.011999077163636684, 0.008979997597634792, 0.05359846353530884, 0.008137534372508526, 0.014898684807121754, 0.03075745888054371, -0.08918818086385727, -0.006236767861992121, 0.017319094389677048, 0.04772940278053284, -0.04331769421696663, 0.013741965405642986, -0.04420865327119827, -0.022391825914382935, 0.00969775952398777, -0.026232870295643806, 0.027326339855790138, 0.01077634934335947, 0.013299155980348587, -0.02023199014365673, 0.04978112876415253, -0.05461762100458145, -0.017931776121258736, -0.0029851209837943316, 0.03176945447921753, -0.029352450743317604, -0.019496267661452293, -0.05200308933854103, 0.025499453768134117, 0.028950320556759834, 0.04795100539922714, 0.030034352093935013, -0.018936235457658768, 0.004520623479038477, 0.029929475858807564, -0.009686777368187904, -0.052498843520879745, 0.014768112450838089, 0.059776678681373596, -0.008637933060526848, 0.02075200155377388, -0.021209973841905594, -0.033604782074689865, 0.012229657731950283, 0.021745823323726654, 0.00776577228680253, 0.015713941305875778, -0.0057067363522946835, 0.03358279541134834, 0.005428570322692394, -0.013288271613419056, 0.05211304500699043, -0.0009469049400649965, -0.012508781626820564, 0.0036548373755067587, -0.013851041905581951, 0.04268383979797363, -0.021769268438220024, -0.012129333801567554, -0.02354281023144722, 0.0411001592874527, -0.009940968826413155, 0.03362884372472763, -0.010281382128596306, 0.03391522169113159, -0.0069820452481508255, -0.03673733398318291, -0.04005711153149605, 0.03750111907720566, -0.010504820384085178, -0.035996533930301666, 0.002787935081869364, 0.03521154448390007, 0.01823071762919426, -0.008287018164992332, 0.029903573915362358, -0.014831701293587685, -0.0002212069375673309, 0.017392972484230995, -0.027429990470409393, -0.017823301255702972, -0.03469131141901016, -0.010426553897559643, 0.02769680693745613, -0.0217360220849514, 0.0550825372338295, -0.010780341923236847, 0.02037959173321724, 0.021129367873072624, -0.05542625114321709, 0.013801523484289646, -0.005444188602268696, -0.014045724645256996, 0.0337667278945446, -0.03513067588210106, -0.009456831030547619, -0.046857282519340515, 0.012093823403120041, -0.07307855039834976, -0.019210699945688248, -0.01884005032479763, 0.0045569590292871, -0.006669403985142708, -0.005706147290766239, -0.02781757339835167, -0.0075630322098731995, -0.023930832743644714, -0.016625626012682915, 0.056778669357299805, -0.02350609377026558, 0.010872658342123032, 0.032852284610271454, 0.03125390410423279, 0.03810767084360123, -0.021255509927868843, -0.0011754109291359782, 0.0038364625070244074, -0.013237610459327698, 0.024716520681977272, -0.03467424958944321, 0.057711221277713776, -0.044021859765052795, -0.011628839187324047, -0.02470817044377327, -0.011070729233324528, 0.048369765281677246, -0.03347572684288025, 0.005018507596105337, -0.00939753744751215, -0.00420524924993515, 0.020738303661346436, -0.02954676002264023, -0.019758770242333412, -0.008168078027665615, -0.017917955294251442, -0.014138116501271725, 0.016060633584856987, -0.02931453473865986, -0.009746839292347431, 0.0274041835218668, 0.0008594350656494498, 0.05050458014011383, 0.00413309782743454, 0.05258245766162872, -0.0007456165621988475, 0.005485442467033863, 0.003664562711492181, -0.03212364763021469, 0.029903700575232506, -0.019991695880889893, 0.0038371861446648836, 0.010330794379115105, 0.011897001415491104, -0.02242029830813408, -0.08728334307670593, -0.03017115779221058, 0.02200832962989807, 0.04700183868408203, 0.021622829139232635, 0.03858994320034981, 0.041068073362112045, 0.004303470253944397, 0.017826687544584274, -0.05675562843680382, -0.005282944533973932, 0.012341429479420185, -0.003350647399201989, 0.07260111719369888, 0.03579845651984215, -0.02362704835832119, 0.03897096961736679, 0.00010365721391281113, 0.028652217239141464, 0.06326691061258316, 0.019633956253528595, 0.0031154032330960035, 0.014872508123517036, -0.04789752513170242, -0.05193571001291275, 0.017545942217111588, -0.05476315692067146, 0.011632673442363739, -0.009459592401981354, -0.010636407881975174, 0.03992082178592682, 0.0347122922539711, 0.001782611245289445, -0.045464806258678436, -0.021969886496663094, -0.0666256994009018, 0.051421064883470535, 0.0653298944234848, 0.03302297368645668, 0.03874436020851135, -0.0005440341774374247, 0.043243538588285446, -0.025421161204576492, 0.0009972749976441264, 0.032144173979759216, -0.011794653721153736, -0.05417032912373543, -0.04597826302051544, -0.03837904706597328, -0.004303507972508669, 0.007812417112290859, -0.022931471467018127, -0.002331558847799897, -0.033998820930719376, 0.03276386484503746, -0.005293194204568863, 0.008893569931387901, -0.009100868366658688, 0.06692656129598618, 0.016233909875154495, 0.014110793359577656, 0.01533058937638998, 0.005950962658971548, 0.1064266711473465, 0.08991308510303497, 0.021603628993034363, -0.07491512596607208, 0.011204150505363941, -0.00006323026900645345, -0.046299222856760025, -0.058336347341537476, 0.025510970503091812, -0.004605399444699287, 0.0005948927719146013, -0.0039015922229737043, 0.045233577489852905, -0.0007847102242521942, 0.015129943378269672, 0.04490947723388672, -0.030114956200122833, -0.017683129757642746, 0.015180658549070358, -0.012733200564980507, -0.0012368878815323114, 0.011107467114925385, -0.016393005847930908, 0.03409915789961815, 0.0064707486890256405, -0.030295830219984055, -0.03550777584314346, 0.010526985861361027, 0.0076775625348091125, -0.03675214573740959, -0.03940748795866966, -0.000024354398192372173, 0.028153343126177788, 0.02175169624388218, 0.004472651518881321, 0.008162173442542553, -0.013800838962197304, -0.022742977365851402, -0.012844692915678024, 0.019513608887791634, -0.013775444589555264, 0.01384405791759491, -0.02781384065747261, -0.02151857689023018, -0.009940329939126968, -0.043898310512304306, -0.029567504301667213, 0.03768555447459221, -0.009214431047439575, -0.012147958390414715, -0.004134533926844597, 0.0024932820815593004, -0.029726985841989517, -0.05163060873746872, -0.004556621890515089, 0.0355837456882, 0.061842452734708786, -0.001933836261741817, -0.03168116509914398, -0.022542566061019897, 0.03249945491552353, -0.034423839300870895, 0.03010689467191696, 0.016846565529704094, 0.006274964194744825, 0.012287936173379421, -0.029734615236520767, 0.0395580418407917, 0.0285634845495224, 0.0081106498837471, -0.05414547026157379, 0.011193430982530117, 0.007484159432351589, -0.05585863068699837, 0.009402052499353886, 0.015137499198317528, 0.012590579688549042, 0.012894593179225922, -0.024694301187992096, -0.022432327270507812, -0.04590729624032974, -0.0073641506023705006, -0.033048611134290695, -0.030756475403904915, -0.026834042742848396, 0.027123289182782173, 0.024908754974603653, 0.04024343937635422, -0.0074356188997626305, -0.01820775307714939, -0.026831917464733124, 0.031063932925462723, 0.018533451482653618, -0.05740376189351082, 0.0008593624806962907, 0.004622452426701784, -0.012037325650453568, 0.05251265689730644, -0.005538643803447485, 0.0528770387172699, 0.03239256516098976, -0.0100265983492136, 0.004348661284893751, 0.04775407165288925, -0.03180621936917305, -0.009074890986084938, 0.01228336151689291, -0.06734206527471542, 0.03273912891745567, 0.0036898013204336166, -0.03037695772945881, -0.04264987260103226, -0.024569690227508545, -0.05358709394931793, -0.021139882504940033, 0.00654697185382247, 0.004891061224043369, -0.0013201336842030287, -0.0052886465564370155, -0.02688407525420189, -0.007459178101271391, -0.02933160588145256, -0.027588576078414917, -0.008192609064280987, 0.003332384629175067, -0.031117083504796028, -0.006328057497739792, 0.0020048869773745537, -0.0033248651307076216, -0.037572018802165985, 0.00983466301113367, 0.02308347076177597, 0.03711152449250221, 0.019471919164061546, 0.006270839367061853, 0.0031473084818571806, -0.00015008308400865644, 0.059336550533771515, -0.03101743385195732, -0.01310877688229084, 0.0384402833878994, -0.07481112331151962, -0.01276033092290163, 0.03102732077240944, -0.020892493426799774, 0.051793452352285385, 0.04995178058743477, 0.035101842135190964, -0.035576265305280685, 0.023326564580202103, -0.0012595528969541192, -0.023183980956673622, 0.010129737667739391, 0.00029103938140906394, -0.015997111797332764, -0.004886346403509378, 0.007865412160754204, -0.023651940748095512, -0.0030901592690497637, -0.005257439333945513, 0.008897410705685616, 0.008871525526046753, -0.03977257013320923, 0.045245859771966934, -0.00833098404109478, 0.04800691828131676, 0.0014417213387787342, -0.0014618183486163616, 0.007214151788502932, 0.056555163115262985, 0.0032346032094210386, 0.006533988751471043, 0.03046121634542942, 0.004659838974475861, -0.13213297724723816, -0.004096759017556906, 0.000924730091355741, -0.005117784254252911, 0.06312331557273865, -0.07505550980567932, 0.007217599079012871, 0.017956756055355072, -0.061369795352220535, 0.020559098571538925, -0.026538539677858353, 0.018900848925113678, -0.03851548954844475, -0.0030642261262983084, -0.016806934028863907, 0.021545376628637314, 0.05032682791352272, 0.022114768624305725, 0.06481634080410004, 0.03309152275323868, -0.00300957472063601, -0.0184970423579216, 0.02064211294054985, 0.028244169428944588, -0.010894563049077988, -0.07521788775920868, 0.059640608727931976, -0.044710807502269745, -0.05488109216094017, 0.014270201325416565, -0.0018664513481780887, 0.016491858288645744, 0.006846334785223007, 0.013050297275185585, 0.027314884588122368, 0.047731831669807434, 0.044156018644571304, 0.004728516098111868, 0.0099587831646204, 0.010723738931119442, -0.003333499887958169, -0.03672249615192413, -0.0009170533739961684, 0.02170519158244133, 0.012143757194280624, -0.019522445276379585, -0.028347626328468323, -0.0022263883147388697, -0.027789544314146042, -0.015539046376943588, 0.027265500277280807, -0.019308751448988914, 0.005727265030145645, -0.04774881899356842, 0.025184905156493187, -0.016224702820181847, -0.028623828664422035, 0.01643180102109909, -0.018057791516184807, -0.020767517387866974, 0.036279451102018356, -0.008362027816474438, -0.04497841000556946, 0.02234867960214615, 0.018096229061484337, -0.031786054372787476, -0.0984387993812561, 0.009227265603840351, 0.020645208656787872, -0.04250378906726837, -0.04722502455115318, -0.004849153570830822, -0.04400160536170006, 0.056821588426828384, -0.03630416467785835, 0.04856349527835846, 0.038183290511369705, -0.031417008489370346, -0.01633845828473568, -0.0859636515378952, 0.06342030316591263, 0.028135837987065315, -0.027371903881430626, -0.013032457791268826, -0.009770144708454609, -0.023267319425940514, -0.016783978790044785, 0.04509963467717171, -0.013454830273985863, 0.002763652941212058, -0.0065210298635065556, 0.013752315193414688, -0.0015655128518119454, -0.03938300907611847, 0.01751125417649746, -0.03549719229340553, -0.024128751829266548, -0.05513812229037285, -0.01155953761190176, 0.01683945767581463, -0.0015207332326099277, 0.009705133736133575, 0.00240835128352046, -0.012877349741756916, 0.0009513197583146393, -0.012264588847756386, 0.019032493233680725, -0.0007871515699662268, 0.020985757932066917, 0.03375885263085365, 0.006394988391548395, 0.03758292272686958, -0.008279210887849331, 0.0017331436974927783, -0.03198103979229927, 0.008293047547340393, -0.03896906599402428, -0.029672760516405106, -0.010960259474813938, 0.03659075126051903, 0.01739930361509323, -0.033486008644104004, 0.001537508680485189, 0.03104981780052185, 0.0029318758752197027, 0.0006393616204150021, 0.020299604162573814, 0.011808540672063828, 0.03293729946017265, 0.004178767558187246, 0.010137376375496387, 0.027647463604807854, -0.01617494970560074, 0.011964711360633373, 0.005098692607134581, 0.01795029267668724, -0.021216705441474915, 0.019227581098675728, 0.011653253808617592, 0.004584556445479393, 0.021742042154073715, -0.028093138709664345, 0.0688171237707138, -0.040744803845882416, -0.014888517558574677, 0.0006754493806511164, -0.02300507016479969, 0.025299524888396263, -0.014497370459139347, -0.015776531770825386, 0.052893947809934616, -0.030545134097337723, -0.03053615801036358, -0.04898759350180626, -0.028072068467736244, -0.02758755162358284, 0.011633239686489105, -0.026763783767819405, 0.047930873930454254, -0.03136394917964935, 0.02359456941485405, 0.01408524252474308, -0.011570329777896404, 0.02858487330377102, -0.018899887800216675, 0.038686614483594894, 0.010721400380134583, -0.025544315576553345, 0.0022395900450646877, 0.0019193399930372834, 0.00047924034879542887, -0.03921862319111824, 0.021645821630954742, 0.019746121019124985, 0.021716700866818428, 0.0008337893523275852, -0.02378406561911106, 0.003927539102733135, 0.01283172145485878, -0.07081643491983414, -0.04336073622107506, -0.034684762358665466, 0.00629134988412261, -0.023202454671263695, 0.005931783467531204 ]
<p>From <em>Robert (The Bayesian Choice, 2001)</em>, it is proposed that the Bayes Estimator associated with the prior distribution $\pi$ and the multilinear loss is a $(k_2/(k_1+k_2))$ fractile of $\pi(\theta|x)$.</p> <p>The proof follows that</p> <p>$$ E^\pi[L_{k_1,k_2}(\theta,d|x)] = k_1\int\limits_{-\infty}^{d} (d-\theta)\pi(\theta|x)d\theta + k_2\int\limits_{d}^{+\infty}(\theta-d)\pi(\theta|x)d\theta $$</p> <p>Then, using the identity</p> <p>$$ \int\limits_{c&lt;y} (y-c)f(y)dy = P(y&gt;c) $$</p> <p>I would get to</p> <p>$$ E^\pi[L_{k_1,k_2}(\theta,d|x)] = k_2P^\pi(\theta&gt;d|x) - k_1P^\pi(\theta&lt;d|x) $$</p> <p>But he gets to</p> <p>$$ E^\pi[L_{k_1,k_2}(\theta,d|x)] = k_1\int\limits_{-\infty}^{d} P^\pi(\theta&lt;y|x)dy + k_2\int\limits_{d}^{+\infty} P^\pi(\theta&gt;y|x)dy $$</p> <p>And then takes the derivative in $d$. What am I'm missing, and why he does this last step? Thanks!</p>
49,050
[ -0.02615840546786785, 0.0032359804026782513, 0.02366221509873867, -0.023284155875444412, 0.02404167316854, 0.03371071442961693, -0.004567157942801714, -0.0338369645178318, 0.022072583436965942, -0.02891150861978531, 0.0062681459821760654, 0.03866982087492943, 0.09318862110376358, 0.02308555692434311, 0.018293926492333412, 0.015676841139793396, -0.030398570001125336, 0.006094195879995823, 0.007273809984326363, -0.022936975583434105, 0.0012822136050090194, 0.05008485168218613, 0.005804792977869511, -0.0447920560836792, -0.01632249355316162, 0.029347117990255356, 0.024499204009771347, 0.004239301197230816, 0.0033202534541487694, 0.10219872742891312, -0.0025218925438821316, -0.03912873938679695, -0.00883121881633997, 0.0634768158197403, 0.008252759464085102, 0.0011189550859853625, -0.02331528067588806, -0.01672336272895336, 0.013441774994134903, 0.043198853731155396, 0.002208957215771079, -0.047374069690704346, 0.004023257177323103, 0.03617106378078461, -0.032396841794252396, -0.02601482719182968, 0.021832913160324097, -0.06586670130491257, 0.05470870062708855, -0.04069289192557335, 0.053877342492341995, 0.009652191773056984, 0.006710787303745747, 0.050178445875644684, -0.013343020342290401, -0.04042740911245346, 0.04521962255239487, 0.09242526441812515, -0.011545144952833652, -0.06941022723913193, -0.020537326112389565, -0.029196299612522125, 0.018902670592069626, 0.017259269952774048, -0.013722440227866173, 0.0019397805444896221, 0.031058156862854958, -0.041759565472602844, -0.00035899438080377877, -0.014357957057654858, 0.013123600743710995, 0.017740262672305107, 0.02645757794380188, 0.011404832825064659, 0.01845555007457733, 0.01601482182741165, -0.014878284186124802, 0.0658741295337677, 0.02241525985300541, 0.027773993089795113, 0.00920143723487854, -0.012963490560650826, 0.02729230560362339, 0.036966148763895035, -0.01027352549135685, 0.03281036391854286, 0.11080013960599899, -0.02259359322488308, 0.023284759372472763, 0.002263706410303712, -0.041429754346609116, 0.044317618012428284, -0.007358024828135967, -0.046629633754491806, -0.05623903125524521, 0.07204995304346085, -0.016612445935606956, 0.0381137989461422, -0.0009426097967661917, -0.04055080562829971, -0.0003198742924723774, -0.03919169679284096, -0.013681774027645588, 0.03167997673153877, 0.00023558270186185837, 0.005073932930827141, -0.02217715233564377, 0.021600034087896347, -0.03700975328683853, -0.04419593885540962, -0.06165332719683647, 0.04305379465222359, -0.007266807835549116, 0.017979076132178307, -0.020829500630497932, -0.012520341202616692, -0.030229689553380013, 0.02189101278781891, 0.0524122416973114, 0.05871317908167839, 0.04937773197889328, 0.013720430433750153, 0.032430097460746765, -0.03403501212596893, -0.0701557844877243, 0.061012085527181625, -0.0057394071482121944, -0.0070828646421432495, -0.033304810523986816, 0.03138888627290726, 0.010355551727116108, 0.03629367798566818, 0.02789890021085739, 0.047729674726724625, -0.012409879826009274, 0.00009550594404572621, -0.0562434047460556, -0.012150555849075317, 0.027101850137114525, 0.00007011115667410195, 0.03250083699822426, -0.06936455518007278, -0.012916017323732376, 0.05741727724671364, 0.02238970622420311, -0.02053060568869114, 0.044993091374635696, 0.00576058030128479, -0.013273618184030056, -0.018893452361226082, -0.02790481597185135, -0.031029874458909035, 0.028445033356547356, 0.01933273859322071, -0.049330297857522964, -0.07929681986570358, 0.017130693420767784, 0.05133955180644989, -0.03226500377058983, -0.01318010687828064, 0.05216740071773529, 0.0025313026271760464, -0.03978608548641205, -0.007366106379777193, 0.04519372433423996, -0.0350693054497242, 0.09363115578889847, 0.05773986130952835, 0.020717855542898178, 0.02764604240655899, 0.03467237576842308, 0.020738784223794937, -0.015148759819567204, 0.04026945307850838, 0.04947556555271149, -0.019262418150901794, -0.02447977475821972, -0.05988149344921112, -0.002605089684948325, 0.018837273120880127, -0.028776580467820168, -0.002591256983578205, -0.02999906614422798, -0.009475533850491047, -0.020784586668014526, 0.010934947058558464, 0.029640639200806618, -0.012938781641423702, 0.014513155445456505, -0.052541665732860565, -0.028419051319360733, -0.04416560381650925, 0.026421567425131798, -0.00041732253157533705, -0.035448215901851654, 0.05343736335635185, -0.03865247964859009, 0.00043458337313495576, 0.019363295286893845, -0.02839364856481552, -0.024232272058725357, -0.022512687370181084, 0.010362294502556324, -0.014055533334612846, 0.004684447310864925, 0.06128441542387009, 0.04685957729816437, 0.019027573987841606, -0.002539122011512518, -0.012690987437963486, -0.017623981460928917, 0.0035887344274669886, -0.01746515929698944, 0.011471223086118698, -0.04249199479818344, -0.03963549807667732, 0.02644963003695011, 0.0031808153726160526, -0.02206294611096382, 0.023128805682063103, -0.08722660690546036, 0.05655563995242119, 0.08667366951704025, 0.00902930274605751, -0.018389394506812096, 0.016963956877589226, -0.005410781595855951, 0.04226817563176155, -0.0453219972550869, -0.0010651648044586182, -0.031502865254879, -0.024589305743575096, 0.021017132326960564, 0.01637050323188305, -0.0024347412399947643, 0.037243567407131195, 0.028924619778990746, 0.016253624111413956, 0.006920107640326023, 0.009306221269071102, 0.013500940054655075, -0.016414834186434746, 0.0434839129447937, -0.020527254790067673, -0.002177030313760042, 0.006304295267909765, 0.023765932768583298, -0.03205633908510208, 0.034940194338560104, -0.010560321621596813, -0.019073687493801117, 0.0011604399187490344, -0.050772275775671005, 0.017764298245310783, 0.011690468527376652, 0.018960895016789436, 0.016636908054351807, -0.013935836963355541, 0.026612630113959312, 0.039273060858249664, 0.0203249529004097, -0.02281615324318409, -0.007742677815258503, -0.0031661028042435646, 0.05648532137274742, 0.022283095866441727, -0.05357537418603897, 0.004918002989143133, 0.020683716982603073, -0.027238227427005768, -0.004014559090137482, 0.0033472536597400904, -0.05019398033618927, -0.004529651720076799, 0.012303452007472515, 0.014344657771289349, -0.006751552689820528, 0.006340028718113899, -0.01735655590891838, -0.023897189646959305, 0.005525439046323299, 0.012952422723174095, 0.014062158763408661, -0.014040696434676647, -0.028214106336236, 0.0014312710845842957, -0.00842099916189909, 0.02820693328976631, 0.02052759751677513, -0.017634475603699684, -0.007205905392765999, -0.019101262092590332, -0.006299161352217197, -0.05143246054649353, -0.026819638907909393, -0.015428414568305016, 0.025009453296661377, -0.023144597187638283, -0.022976338863372803, 0.010362544097006321, 0.041789595037698746, -0.027192339301109314, 0.053448617458343506, -0.02301412634551525, -0.029328176751732826, -0.012911454774439335, -0.005200063809752464, -0.008626843802630901, -0.017817268148064613, 0.022037111222743988, 0.020789915695786476, -0.02728869765996933, -0.004305543843656778, -0.06523435562849045, -0.08314494043588638, 0.0340634323656559, 0.00852970127016306, -0.0022028896491974592, -0.026864664629101753, -0.02145226113498211, 0.06531506776809692, 0.01089391391724348, -0.028020653873682022, 0.003752190386876464, 0.04113389179110527, -0.04261091351509094, -0.0068285344168543816, -0.03968485817313194, 0.016081715002655983, -0.013722437433898449, 0.025342071428894997, -0.009258246049284935, -0.01810545288026333, 0.0631752759218216, -0.022132519632577896, 0.022177038714289665, 0.06006164103746414, -0.005985744297504425, 0.0014103275025263429, 0.024708881974220276, 0.04958387836813927, -0.01276362407952547, 0.009705042466521263, -0.0033802080433815718, 0.024768322706222534, 0.013371407054364681, -0.024270473048090935, 0.011388816870748997, -0.01848413608968258, -0.020172465592622757, -0.010101337917149067, 0.016029663383960724, 0.014233277179300785, -0.03819417208433151, 0.004704557359218597, -0.015565203502774239, 0.049392618238925934, -0.03058130294084549, 0.0034075435250997543, 0.021311700344085693, 0.010235920548439026, -0.011514311656355858, -0.014980830252170563, -0.019936222583055496, 0.02419581077992916, -0.0032813954167068005, -0.02542956918478012, -0.0024523825850337744, -0.0009188435506075621, 0.014618164859712124, -0.0026205689646303654, -0.025654882192611694, -0.05412501096725464, 0.018232565373182297, -0.04463017359375954, 0.017828209325671196, -0.04055366292595863, 0.04573521390557289, 0.041739240288734436, 0.009358237497508526, 0.04938054829835892, -0.017950790002942085, -0.0060643781907856464, 0.013765827752649784, -0.07921886444091797, 0.010856518521904945, -0.002626360859721899, -0.021495161578059196, -0.0013032711576670408, -0.021394001320004463, 0.06912802159786224, -0.02814670279622078, -0.0035502712707966566, -0.024907946586608887, -0.015421323478221893, -0.05356503650546074, 0.007367679849267006, -0.05932866409420967, -0.0071778083220124245, -0.018585022538900375, 0.026140766218304634, 0.06668021529912949, -0.014101910404860973, -0.00099350290838629, 0.052405040711164474, 0.000316658231895417, 0.01172955147922039, -0.012989928014576435, -0.014716530218720436, 0.020012982189655304, 0.0029729283414781094, 0.024540023878216743, 0.013998833484947681, 0.01860949583351612, 0.01887267827987671, -0.02312587946653366, 0.08582023531198502, 0.05643591284751892, -0.027215881273150444, -0.027399232611060143, -0.05242495983839035, -0.018057802692055702, 0.008350035175681114, 0.035993341356515884, 0.000982331926934421, -0.023682430386543274, 0.04313293844461441, 0.033751990646123886, -0.01068961713463068, 0.01949898526072502, 0.014209556393325329, -0.010113582946360111, -0.040954940021038055, -0.009286454878747463, -0.0054811518639326096, 0.0029470743611454964, -0.015011025592684746, 0.008587624877691269, 0.004121892619878054, -0.02134057506918907, -0.006723739672452211, 0.03984532505273819, 0.0018518882570788264, 0.0037222029641270638, 0.007836255244910717, 0.014949314296245575, 0.016680892556905746, -0.007591292727738619, -0.01456400379538536, 0.029149919748306274, 0.029577337205410004, 0.03297963738441467, 0.013929018750786781, 0.006583652924746275, -0.06067860871553421, -0.005319096148014069, -0.0028746677562594414, 0.04690010845661163, -0.02320176735520363, -0.004783748183399439, -0.06846123188734055, -0.015988804399967194, 0.02307746931910515, -0.010169240646064281, 0.019275955855846405, -0.05378595367074013, 0.00528002018108964, 0.007658297661691904, -0.06876908987760544, -0.024558313190937042, -0.01172911748290062, -0.018656540662050247, 0.022065458819270134, -0.015899688005447388, 0.0017860304797068238, -0.037268828600645065, 0.0230060126632452, 0.014723182655870914, 0.07189628481864929, -0.010576903820037842, -0.07389400899410248, -0.00933815911412239, 0.006469545885920525, 0.020566701889038086, -0.06479158997535706, 0.026010675355792046, -0.03973006084561348, -0.007685807067900896, 0.02454698458313942, -0.04461512714624405, -0.03774850070476532, 0.028338326141238213, 0.026752348989248276, -0.04706212133169174, 0.06554371118545532, -0.027650605887174606, 0.030447943136096, 0.034156519919633865, 0.05187266319990158, 0.04069799929857254, -0.018809452652931213, 0.008247006684541702, 0.00794672779738903, -0.022042013704776764, 0.047995731234550476, -0.03217124193906784, 0.011830873787403107, -0.04004305601119995, -0.02327628619968891, -0.030691761523485184, 0.00940984021872282, 0.009807083755731583, -0.007506486028432846, -0.05390241742134094, -0.03482567146420479, 0.0087591502815485, 0.017573505640029907, 0.00577075919136405, 0.0017623358871787786, -0.022381579503417015, 0.054092250764369965, 0.032394714653491974, 0.03193335980176926, 0.006727957632392645, -0.01403005514293909, 0.02858271822333336, 0.001648874836973846, -0.02209710143506527, 0.00129679124802351, -0.03287468105554581, -0.038896508514881134, 0.02229432761669159, -0.016652120277285576, 0.01702558808028698, -0.009361032396554947, 0.022340456023812294, -0.013751212507486343, 0.004676672164350748, -0.02318357117474079, -0.013264958746731281, -0.02922510728240013, 0.038077306002378464, -0.05838317051529884, -0.01736937277019024, -0.02530532144010067, -0.005053206346929073, -0.07091134041547775, 0.014886168763041496, 0.017711305990815163, -0.008889671415090561, -0.03981124237179756, -0.016098110005259514, 0.011370637454092503, 0.011911130510270596, -0.046611685305833817, -0.01053633913397789, 0.040243882685899734, -0.007427412085235119, -0.011378028430044651, -0.02175435982644558, 0.04970847815275192, 0.04152759909629822, -0.00906689465045929, 0.02725251019001007, 0.02523239701986313, -0.03552675247192383, -0.0067236172035336494, 0.0006758980453014374, 0.03457239270210266, -0.020087094977498055, 0.012793302536010742, -0.0003872048982884735, 0.027167553082108498, 0.02287149615585804, 0.0027544887270778418, -0.04712008684873581, 0.011730041354894638, 0.01814330369234085, -0.020063674077391624, -0.0284945797175169, -0.02359992451965809, -0.011350313201546669, 0.02940431237220764, -0.026514200493693352, -0.005003835540264845, -0.012386645190417767, -0.0022793321404606104, 0.015263710170984268, -0.009455399587750435, 0.012761655263602734, -0.002139986027032137, 0.06946155428886414, -0.024356257170438766, 0.011993380263447762, 0.014336580410599709, 0.003624881384894252, 0.08360669761896133, -0.013226959854364395, 0.0034242195542901754, -0.0055260383524000645, -0.008726213127374649, -0.061818528920412064, -0.00787168275564909, -0.04851473867893219, -0.001148086041212082, 0.0625620111823082, -0.025825077667832375, 0.046676527708768845, 0.004964683670550585, -0.006616001483052969, -0.010372116230428219, -0.04456150904297829, -0.041837435215711594, 0.0006483316537924111, -0.02155051752924919, 0.038423966616392136, -0.006917508319020271, -0.013463371433317661, 0.033709678798913956, -0.00511498237028718, 0.00051485700532794, 0.004484772216528654, 0.01286022737622261, 0.015367073938250542, 0.03017960861325264, -0.052996255457401276, -0.007862393744289875, 0.03276548534631729, 0.0009140946203842759, 0.010765421204268932, -0.037690188735723495, -0.04938855767250061, 0.053708236664533615, 0.035216644406318665, -0.006536346394568682, -0.028422273695468903, -0.01596655324101448, -0.014591489918529987, 0.020324138924479485, 0.024613073095679283, 0.01282911840826273, 0.040854666382074356, -0.0323471836745739, 0.023396886885166168, 0.029777204617857933, 0.0038334494456648827, -0.017779652029275894, -0.05924465134739876, -0.05155202001333237, -0.017091283574700356, -0.00035245128674432635, -0.029834795743227005, -0.0018967926735058427, -0.011438273824751377, 0.019107744097709656, -0.035823456943035126, 0.03400377184152603, 0.007125264964997768, 0.00951048731803894, -0.02692200243473053, 0.06187252327799797, -0.005086650140583515, 0.0277099609375, -0.03566558659076691, -0.030389908701181412, 0.11187754571437836, 0.05539257079362869, 0.02261178568005562, -0.051267772912979126, 0.022556520998477936, 0.0017976477975025773, 0.01998254284262657, -0.0638347864151001, 0.022782009094953537, 0.0265213530510664, 0.006518449168652296, 0.003044626209884882, 0.04068795591592789, 0.007929904386401176, -0.034513209015131, 0.00893782451748848, -0.02810549922287464, -0.03279869258403778, 0.04847274348139763, 0.004060279577970505, -0.023012995719909668, -0.0015697828494012356, -0.06320492923259735, 0.028712674975395203, -0.01868402026593685, 0.022560426965355873, -0.04926557466387749, -0.01661178469657898, -0.020154759287834167, 0.025684425607323647, -0.006213575601577759, -0.035694725811481476, 0.0057195620611310005, -0.003329208353534341, 0.025732675567269325, -0.010492231696844101, 0.017132265493273735, 0.0037172725424170494, 0.005707916337996721, 0.04029269143939018, 0.041553013026714325, -0.030926059931516647, 0.007520696613937616, -0.011753497645258904, -0.022246351465582848, -0.05850054696202278, -0.016703883185982704, 0.07944528758525848, 0.00840914249420166, 0.002453327178955078, -0.007894574664533138, -0.020295776426792145, -0.0024467408657073975, -0.05148772522807121, 0.02305757626891136, 0.012995939701795578, 0.01988404430449009, -0.023181937634944916, 0.003005593316629529, 0.013676625676453114, 0.028839057311415672, -0.002982603618875146, 0.040931496769189835, -0.01032289583235979, -0.05218932032585144, -0.03842712193727493, 0.004215206019580364, 0.049759022891521454, 0.0503820963203907, 0.041738297790288925, -0.005533371586352587, -0.007116593420505524, -0.03516358509659767, -0.017180802300572395, -0.00730444910004735, -0.024560119956731796, 0.034133635461330414, -0.03345739096403122, -0.02729913219809532, -0.018594058230519295, -0.025655247271060944, 0.01616966538131237, -0.037807948887348175, -0.008028444834053516, -0.03433888778090477, -0.00934388767927885, 0.015188053250312805, 0.030120348557829857, 0.025393549352884293, 0.005321729928255081, 0.0061394572257995605, 0.04624933376908302, -0.0038170276675373316, -0.05173657834529877, -0.004499115981161594, -0.006186699029058218, -0.033675674349069595, -0.015045247972011566, -0.018396815285086632, 0.05526934564113617, 0.030149230733513832, 0.06616146117448807, -0.020228423178195953, 0.00615633325651288, -0.04206649586558342, 0.0244134534150362, -0.003842462319880724, -0.03289710357785225, 0.0009099127491936088, -0.017085464671254158, 0.021744990721344948, -0.03198038786649704, 0.007851198315620422, -0.047452498227357864, 0.005750342272222042, 0.004969963803887367, 0.003164220368489623, -0.05744318664073944, -0.006410735193639994, 0.02301136404275894, 0.024498753249645233, 0.009087121114134789, 0.024698633700609207, 0.025835447013378143, 0.013865958899259567, -0.03094029240310192, 0.005686554592102766, -0.03777226060628891, 0.02494877204298973, -0.016440948471426964, -0.0360279306769371, 0.016455264762043953, -0.000479069072753191, -0.0021113690454512835, -0.02084612287580967, 0.00697528850287199, -0.01297717448323965, 0.03842516988515854, -0.04063643515110016, -0.061640750616788864, 0.02159956470131874, -0.04124695435166359, -0.05148820951581001, 0.013556617312133312, 0.03634397312998772, 0.01787734217941761, -0.01797337643802166, 0.025767391547560692, -0.030673876404762268, 0.02917075715959072, -0.005125428084284067, -0.02610289491713047, 0.00128061359282583, -0.017905883491039276, 0.02296801656484604, -0.010675228200852871, 0.023889370262622833, -0.009715420193970203, 0.05724669620394707, 0.043643850833177567, -0.0021387978922575712, 0.02810962125658989, -0.014234671369194984, 0.025917593389749527, -0.02011706680059433, 0.027116287499666214, -0.0018061547307297587, 0.02835630066692829, 0.05285990610718727, 0.02653854340314865, -0.007510730996727943, 0.026206636801362038, -0.02054893784224987, 0.0008375810575671494, -0.0883343368768692, 0.0011764995288103819, -0.01697639748454094, 0.03783294931054115, 0.03320343419909477, -0.04431981220841408, 0.021195385605096817, 0.029152169823646545, -0.05563965439796448, 0.0180366151034832, 0.0056985062547028065, 0.007980630733072758, -0.06683266162872314, -0.005134196020662785, -0.032322369515895844, 0.030044199898838997, 0.02814575470983982, 0.04722828418016434, 0.028844168409705162, 0.006155564449727535, -0.003948151133954525, -0.006781208794564009, -0.01530531607568264, 0.031058717519044876, 0.004222267307341099, -0.044903337955474854, 0.07490488886833191, 0.0071838172152638435, -0.025372421368956566, 0.050352755934000015, 0.04135879874229431, 0.016683056950569153, -0.008982517756521702, 0.02784455195069313, 0.07277559489011765, 0.01671222783625126, 0.02818671055138111, 0.005127551965415478, 0.02389061450958252, 0.007447330746799707, 0.0058343312703073025, 0.0006228425190784037, -0.025171319022774696, -0.012051164172589779, 0.030390869826078415, -0.014436486177146435, -0.02541228197515011, 0.03209034353494644, -0.005534656345844269, -0.0004199058166705072, 0.01481572538614273, -0.03209525719285011, 0.011559886857867241, -0.02131294086575508, 0.03276748210191727, -0.024302229285240173, -0.039335332810878754, 0.05849069729447365, 0.00521263899281621, 0.013319856487214565, -0.011579055339097977, -0.03381210193037987, -0.07365395873785019, 0.04344756901264191, -0.006864465307444334, -0.012859697453677654, -0.0370611697435379, 0.030167831107974052, 0.00881027989089489, 0.02936834841966629, -0.0007832215051166713, -0.013399611227214336, -0.09231353551149368, -0.01416105031967163, -0.028033306822180748, 0.012695316225290298, -0.012816321104764938, -0.0005146400653757155, 0.0028836997225880623, -0.0822417289018631, 0.08154109120368958, -0.005844000726938248, -0.05210031196475029, -0.005635606124997139, -0.01077045314013958, -0.025269387289881706, -0.011389616876840591, 0.052791282534599304, 0.007705389056354761, -0.015427397564053535, 0.01555552612990141, 0.016939762979745865, 0.008461220189929008, -0.06557031720876694, 0.018942702561616898, -0.008198247291147709, 0.02448013611137867, -0.024035373702645302, -0.004100315272808075, 0.013665971346199512, 0.025839362293481827, 0.018496768549084663, -0.001280793221667409, 0.04621179774403572, -0.002861541463062167, -0.00859085749834776, -0.0023907762952148914, -0.04108557105064392, -0.0006307113799266517, 0.04486260190606117, -0.01657119393348694, 0.00544115761294961, 0.0028843616601079702, -0.029723381623625755, -0.06336008757352829, 0.0334501676261425, -0.018189480528235435, -0.022349832579493523, -0.010512186214327812, -0.009389485232532024, 0.016324402764439583, -0.01784641668200493, -0.00898214802145958, 0.047255173325538635, -0.05432555079460144, -0.022776372730731964, 0.04533948749303818, 0.025488903746008873, 0.06341934949159622, 0.04436904564499855, 0.03308497741818428, 0.00571311404928565, -0.0075925420969724655, 0.024232450872659683, 0.013810019940137863, 0.042604368180036545, 0.012420938350260258, 0.016261693090200424, 0.04191075265407562, -0.048843253403902054, 0.013899112120270729, -0.05164385959506035, 0.02114221453666687, -0.028963135555386543, -0.016996337100863457, -0.003239579498767853, -0.008571125566959381, -0.006425216794013977, -0.009831814095377922, -0.01830981858074665, 0.07396630942821503, -0.015915999189019203, 0.04853342846035957, -0.008517441339790821, 0.004584724083542824, -0.03407659754157066, 0.011349707841873169, 0.027730874717235565, 0.016241056844592094, -0.00941131729632616, 0.003787162946537137, -0.002182229422032833, -0.044515084475278854, 0.01955445483326912, -0.033851150423288345, -0.014740712009370327, -0.0061628567054867744, 0.0032915084157139063, 0.037619348615407944, -0.035378143191337585, -0.013094568625092506, -0.019764943048357964, -0.004002639092504978, 0.031032714992761612, 0.08213040232658386, -0.018893569707870483, -0.031107500195503235, 0.004074960481375456, 0.05848453938961029, -0.058902569115161896, 0.05619994178414345, -0.005334065295755863, 0.005968886893242598, 0.023778187111020088, -0.007705476135015488 ]
<p>Since OLS tries to measure E[Y|X], and regression trees try to partition the data into different branches, then take means of the response under different branches, is it reasonable to say that regression trees strictly dominate OLS in prediction? Also, since OLS is not robust to outliers, would it be reasonable to say that regression trees are a better first, off-the-shelf algorithm to try in a prediction problem?</p> <p>For interpretation, it definitely makes sense to me that knowing $R^2$, regression coefficients, p-values, etc. are more useful than seeing the tree structure.</p>
1,036
[ -0.007414063438773155, 0.006830104626715183, -0.03842746466398239, -0.024923138320446014, 0.01653258502483368, 0.026867428794503212, 0.004313896410167217, -0.024107730016112328, 0.07053986191749573, -0.008115297183394432, 0.015587451867759228, 0.009243408218026161, 0.05554238706827164, -0.01883217692375183, 0.002874394180253148, 0.0184938982129097, -0.020548874512314796, 0.035058941692113876, 0.012845125049352646, 0.007495657075196505, -0.027950674295425415, 0.034976910799741745, 0.0023024326656013727, -0.010042143985629082, -0.04471636563539505, 0.04929263889789581, 0.04706951603293419, 0.027023740112781525, 0.002356033306568861, 0.03720758110284805, -0.023105377331376076, -0.01610104739665985, -0.006642626132816076, 0.07320233434438705, 0.022713033482432365, -0.0006140368641354144, 0.00238539045676589, -0.020614031702280045, -0.0016883071511983871, 0.04268074408173561, 0.003524336963891983, -0.049229804426431656, 0.006277705542743206, 0.029040519148111343, 0.00177712831646204, 0.028150754049420357, -0.03155006095767021, -0.03583541512489319, 0.02930818684399128, -0.02080279402434826, 0.06546678394079208, -0.031064588576555252, 0.00026383926160633564, 0.05300886929035187, -0.03426205366849899, 0.004536387510597706, 0.04422023147344589, 0.06578997522592545, -0.02476828172802925, -0.0555996373295784, -0.01720530539751053, -0.0033873014617711306, 0.020433465018868446, 0.04307015612721443, -0.0601927787065506, 0.0162075012922287, 0.007973786443471909, -0.01690143533051014, 0.04340413585305214, -0.004554010462015867, -0.015137926675379276, 0.030454106628894806, 0.029750533401966095, 0.02620379813015461, -0.0033285620156675577, 0.02217213436961174, -0.015467285178601742, 0.006939826998859644, 0.04220903292298317, 0.000019348806745256297, 0.03686314448714256, -0.00042597734136506915, 0.0464765839278698, 0.04448091238737106, -0.0012451354414224625, 0.006913055665791035, 0.06728078424930573, -0.03545736148953438, 0.022307725623250008, 0.01631339080631733, 0.015814809128642082, -0.016258295625448227, 0.032257117331027985, -0.037056904286146164, -0.04025758430361748, 0.05354917049407959, -0.02176528610289097, 0.01820157654583454, 0.059677980840206146, 0.02197176218032837, 0.0048850723542273045, -0.04253800958395004, -0.0018169916002079844, 0.03856309503316879, 0.00784334447234869, -0.03543037548661232, -0.02786642126739025, 0.017745859920978546, 0.0031161087099462748, -0.027456704527139664, -0.005389019381254911, 0.03866218402981758, -0.027827758342027664, 0.03140677884221077, 0.03450349345803261, -0.004280375316739082, 0.03942769765853882, -0.007636505179107189, 0.029663298279047012, 0.041157420724630356, -0.006002558395266533, -0.03885505720973015, -0.004218264017254114, 0.03517836704850197, -0.03999186307191849, 0.00033780865487642586, 0.020789816975593567, -0.028224341571331024, -0.06878793239593506, 0.026413487270474434, -0.004438524134457111, -0.02323300577700138, 0.046458445489406586, 0.006360216531902552, 0.05362734943628311, 0.01922425627708435, -0.0856289267539978, -0.0500163733959198, 0.027486542239785194, 0.010043278336524963, 0.03631017357110977, -0.0434902049601078, -0.017190486192703247, 0.015646524727344513, 0.026804089546203613, 0.005767617374658585, 0.05537119135260582, 0.027602573856711388, 0.04066784679889679, -0.00015105924103409052, -0.04856245964765549, -0.01578262820839882, -0.005592992529273033, -0.03445760905742645, 0.005719899665564299, -0.06849437206983566, -0.008648534305393696, 0.039934176951646805, -0.010247870348393917, -0.004194478038698435, 0.0227908156812191, -0.014132265001535416, -0.007353163789957762, 0.0013331020018085837, 0.0013182570692151785, -0.023987067863345146, 0.055120788514614105, 0.011512384749948978, 0.06538430601358414, 0.030977750197052956, -0.004193343222141266, 0.011218192987143993, 0.0482046902179718, 0.024218806996941566, 0.05254882946610451, 0.0062862965278327465, -0.02156900428235531, -0.00966364424675703, 0.021145692095160484, -0.008127295412123203, -0.08089437335729599, -0.03780254349112511, -0.03886312246322632, 0.0029881310183554888, -0.004430457483977079, 0.04583588242530823, -0.004861745052039623, -0.027235498651862144, 0.03736713528633118, -0.06208932399749756, -0.020972879603505135, -0.03047396056354046, 0.006525359582155943, -0.011029243469238281, 0.00858611986041069, 0.013780861161649227, 0.0024588487576693296, -0.01457515824586153, -0.012677359394729137, 0.0014708333183079958, -0.02341167815029621, 0.033734649419784546, 0.03789554908871651, -0.02503640204668045, 0.018185142427682877, 0.07343704998493195, 0.03770291432738304, 0.004149995278567076, 0.019336508587002754, -0.041643623262643814, -0.08525563776493073, 0.03732853755354881, -0.030954260379076004, 0.01495269127190113, -0.025533057749271393, -0.023367473855614662, 0.027870584279298782, -0.006160209886729717, -0.03671720623970032, 0.05252161622047424, -0.07570673525333405, 0.05897395685315132, 0.07483851909637451, 0.03394347429275513, 0.008701943792402744, 0.0010339028667658567, -0.021149368956685066, 0.007173113524913788, -0.014180623926222324, -0.016821539029479027, -0.04081370308995247, -0.001009590458124876, 0.020450446754693985, 0.06150764971971512, -0.03648727014660835, 0.013008643873035908, 0.04925709217786789, 0.0376364141702652, -0.0031377181876450777, 0.02803535759449005, -0.03611382469534874, -0.028340812772512436, 0.007820136845111847, 0.007274067495018244, 0.01929447241127491, 0.014434808865189552, -0.021959370002150536, -0.004953968338668346, 0.02247220277786255, -0.0019963039085268974, 0.007798757869750261, 0.03892524540424347, 0.01166195422410965, -0.011372106149792671, 0.004511801525950432, -0.011955098249018192, 0.025121888145804405, -0.023989632725715637, -0.020506741479039192, 0.017220979556441307, 0.005374216008931398, 0.015569775365293026, 0.0007744694012217224, -0.013501778244972229, 0.034086234867572784, 0.03493518754839897, -0.055241577327251434, 0.02321988344192505, 0.04309313744306564, -0.034048814326524734, 0.02620949037373066, -0.056148890405893326, -0.03849401697516441, -0.055970173329114914, 0.03151434287428856, 0.014000858180224895, -0.020817242562770844, 0.0052397423423826694, -0.02341412752866745, -0.015304980799555779, -0.0184789951890707, -0.01223971601575613, 0.004231662955135107, -0.012482121586799622, -0.04231134429574013, -0.027964917942881584, -0.07435516268014908, -0.024058232083916664, 0.023706382140517235, -0.020457174628973007, -0.00440325029194355, 0.0010549966245889664, -0.0050657675601542, -0.04298112168908119, -0.06877262890338898, -0.022746562957763672, 0.04150903970003128, -0.006720354314893484, -0.07129893451929092, 0.01871090568602085, -0.01534046046435833, -0.007707987911999226, -0.008639046922326088, -0.03542354702949524, -0.011376762762665749, -0.022609462961554527, -0.002638627775013447, -0.006970573216676712, 0.007061277516186237, 0.042974937707185745, 0.008031322620809078, -0.06197582557797432, -0.02906283177435398, -0.05875499173998833, -0.053473442792892456, 0.015230800956487656, 0.006733770947903395, 0.016016604378819466, 0.020724989473819733, -0.005263646598905325, 0.05289008840918541, 0.001608830294571817, -0.04221363738179207, -0.02911500632762909, 0.009088832885026932, -0.03158380091190338, -0.008763892576098442, 0.015123811550438404, -0.004181193187832832, 0.036985863000154495, -0.0021994381677359343, 0.007680312730371952, 0.007474738173186779, 0.044969089329242706, 0.00379354995675385, -0.003094935789704323, 0.021806949749588966, 0.025660114362835884, 0.0020131005439907312, 0.015574847348034382, 0.04712655022740364, -0.023878926411271095, 0.0332181416451931, -0.005491513758897781, 0.009775185026228428, 0.025767890736460686, -0.046337030827999115, 0.0468834713101387, -0.03212388604879379, 0.02173297479748726, -0.010441581718623638, 0.009247789159417152, 0.01318818237632513, -0.0017797874752432108, -0.019800832495093346, -0.020304804667830467, -0.00021526518685277551, -0.0008751493878662586, -0.015147020108997822, 0.01368458941578865, 0.02936597540974617, 0.0033438534010201693, 0.018645573407411575, -0.013318311423063278, -0.018218109384179115, 0.03283732011914253, 0.016573302447795868, -0.013844306580722332, 0.053523045033216476, 0.042897049337625504, -0.009391014464199543, -0.006639902479946613, -0.06920365244150162, -0.00503307580947876, -0.045137397944927216, 0.018866751343011856, -0.027467714622616768, 0.05274564400315285, -0.0003703123074956238, 0.04591478407382965, -0.015135067515075207, -0.015403824858367443, 0.02111124061048031, 0.014514480717480183, -0.08341874182224274, 0.0032401385251432657, -0.02505258284509182, 0.0069743734784424305, -0.023535972461104393, -0.009059793315827847, 0.02486111968755722, -0.03200407698750496, 0.01716563105583191, -0.03057609312236309, 0.015150235965847969, -0.017348531633615494, -0.005622341297566891, -0.017585471272468567, 0.005036653019487858, -0.011950867250561714, -0.007058886345475912, -0.009522405453026295, -0.03208816796541214, 0.029541943222284317, 0.05068453401327133, -0.01964414305984974, -0.00008809696009848267, -0.01641693152487278, 0.03896890953183174, 0.03627639636397362, 0.030120620504021645, 0.0402916818857193, -0.015589997172355652, -0.014221398159861565, 0.009685035794973373, 0.03116120770573616, 0.03178843855857849, 0.021556681022047997, -0.018629688769578934, -0.011983458884060383, -0.02894456498324871, -0.03491522744297981, -0.011332903988659382, 0.016897547990083694, 0.019644854590296745, -0.009274435229599476, 0.0791545882821083, 0.00017671762907411903, -0.0136747220531106, 0.011222261004149914, 0.044240184128284454, 0.00973179005086422, -0.04054265841841698, -0.014117025770246983, 0.0058284904807806015, 0.009395627304911613, 0.005491313524544239, 0.03061031736433506, 0.011974229477345943, -0.02125096321105957, -0.01703987456858158, 0.018613584339618683, 0.002974625676870346, -0.02618800848722458, 0.01874571666121483, 0.038873977959156036, 0.05680610612034798, -0.04141909256577492, -0.007344669662415981, 0.01887889951467514, 0.04932732880115509, 0.03865833207964897, 0.04219998046755791, -0.00022506495588459074, -0.07178716361522675, 0.02077908255159855, 0.02785060741007328, 0.03290729597210884, -0.044598985463380814, -0.017448801547288895, -0.022916926071047783, 0.00007570609159301966, 0.017952769994735718, -0.0031322117429226637, 0.02049838937819004, -0.031213613227009773, -0.014741521328687668, -0.030173400416970253, -0.02277386002242565, -0.017752960324287415, -0.01757344789803028, 0.00867454707622528, 0.056865788996219635, -0.0180041640996933, -0.028333555907011032, -0.06681988388299942, 0.0013690602499991655, -0.0156953614205122, 0.03388810157775879, -0.019801311194896698, -0.05105769634246826, 0.009961571544408798, 0.05303437262773514, -0.013038435019552708, -0.06272482126951218, -0.025089949369430542, 0.04112370312213898, -0.021328048780560493, 0.022843822836875916, -0.004749702755361795, -0.08479329943656921, 0.013031801208853722, 0.0035523218102753162, -0.016478653997182846, -0.012212725356221199, 0.0037143852096050978, 0.034133244305849075, 0.029338931664824486, 0.007973895408213139, 0.06881042569875717, 0.06248493865132332, -0.002292466117069125, -0.013629639521241188, -0.01147180050611496, 0.0017361093778163195, -0.03975007310509682, -0.02738133817911148, -0.0015808817697688937, -0.0232003815472126, -0.014056268148124218, -0.014521238394081593, -0.0037976736202836037, 0.03810466080904007, -0.04058489948511124, -0.015964321792125702, -0.010959556326270103, 0.057509150356054306, -0.004721205215901136, -0.007760653737932444, -0.027864811941981316, 0.031835366040468216, -0.01508917473256588, 0.004337905906140804, 0.00576749024912715, -0.0048743425868451595, 0.040003128349781036, 0.01937294937670231, -0.023268211632966995, 0.01361553743481636, -0.03533093258738518, -0.011796675622463226, 0.008310032077133656, 0.00293012335896492, 0.0403490848839283, 0.005127467680722475, 0.03070520982146263, 0.005601549055427313, -0.05485285073518753, -0.007523088250309229, 0.015903152525424957, 0.014766817912459373, 0.024122951552271843, -0.05519983544945717, 0.042423639446496964, -0.05492572858929634, -0.03077452816069126, -0.054271697998046875, -0.03897613659501076, -0.004251793492585421, 0.013288850896060467, -0.026875130832195282, -0.0013448648387566209, 0.009983413852751255, -0.04499754682183266, -0.025180496275424957, -0.046649932861328125, 0.06971731036901474, -0.03011368028819561, -0.007083401549607515, 0.005657294299453497, 0.009844277985394001, 0.05730583518743515, -0.01553685124963522, 0.005434948019683361, 0.008108745329082012, -0.016919992864131927, 0.013522113673388958, -0.0035530247259885073, 0.029476327821612358, -0.021618058905005455, 0.01410346757620573, -0.032455626875162125, 0.023165404796600342, 0.05491572245955467, 0.0017998982220888138, -0.020603105425834656, 0.032858602702617645, 0.01659369096159935, 0.006303772795945406, -0.007071527186781168, -0.0001821662881411612, -0.009841118939220905, 0.005746068432927132, -0.008999481797218323, 0.006041691638529301, 0.016748135909438133, -0.000016652958947815932, -0.00194186728913337, -0.0039003747515380383, 0.01958947815001011, 0.039400141686201096, 0.05130981281399727, -0.03796982392668724, 0.01747916266322136, -0.015942929312586784, -0.05504736676812172, 0.04197072982788086, -0.009103871881961823, 0.002560963621363044, 0.03845864161849022, 0.07073844224214554, -0.053945887833833694, -0.0842723697423935, -0.004403220489621162, -0.010762400925159454, 0.032736726105213165, -0.03157520666718483, 0.06349609047174454, 0.058330047875642776, -0.007484819274395704, 0.0018602878553792834, -0.07580002397298813, -0.018906980752944946, 0.005923647433519363, -0.010520564392209053, 0.03365502506494522, -0.005568746477365494, 0.021554220467805862, 0.04235711321234703, 0.005978238303214312, -0.009127018041908741, 0.028390269726514816, 0.007429332938045263, -0.003971359692513943, 0.014506097882986069, -0.03254874795675278, -0.04318457469344139, 0.03287147358059883, -0.06206609681248665, -0.021431779488921165, -0.03227587789297104, -0.02383453957736492, 0.0600581057369709, 0.03066335804760456, 0.04362565279006958, -0.05684345215559006, 0.01450857799500227, -0.04409155622124672, 0.015379560180008411, -0.021441712975502014, 0.015534957870841026, 0.012756502255797386, 0.026755383238196373, 0.006813334301114082, 0.005668545141816139, -0.009708150289952755, 0.00347154657356441, -0.10270609706640244, -0.06722928583621979, -0.0030105719342827797, -0.040656015276908875, 0.03606564551591873, 0.01563338376581669, -0.042541515082120895, 0.03710279241204262, -0.054289594292640686, -0.004057590384036303, 0.015611795708537102, 0.06666847318410873, -0.02816241793334484, 0.06520431488752365, -0.012485460378229618, -0.019840193912386894, -0.010329265147447586, -0.03370857238769531, 0.11263949424028397, 0.08367980271577835, 0.03263693302869797, -0.0676603764295578, 0.03054962493479252, -0.00042150626541115344, -0.021668143570423126, -0.016381775960326195, -0.015240886248648167, 0.020064229145646095, -0.012563460506498814, -0.001338635222055018, 0.0379926972091198, 0.004520808346569538, -0.04986809939146042, 0.01639135554432869, -0.034115057438611984, -0.007485237903892994, -0.00014488297165371478, 0.01768704317510128, -0.0023104744032025337, 0.005963516887277365, -0.04226316139101982, 0.010713666677474976, -0.031454745680093765, 0.004337599966675043, -0.010392987169325352, -0.019623208791017532, 0.021765315905213356, -0.03804807737469673, -0.050643838942050934, -0.0016403852496296167, 0.027989981696009636, -0.0017165675526484847, -0.03416365385055542, 0.030702657997608185, 0.006843840703368187, -0.015171772800385952, 0.009345179423689842, 0.01709759421646595, -0.008676660247147083, -0.005043040029704571, -0.0001314367400482297, 0.02418460324406624, -0.06717289984226227, -0.00855321530252695, -0.01605389080941677, 0.01894790679216385, 0.031806062906980515, -0.008079548366367817, -0.02527446486055851, -0.01661660522222519, 0.03624971956014633, -0.03279938921332359, 0.004777240101248026, 0.03230736404657364, 0.044357750564813614, -0.04373812675476074, -0.0376887284219265, -0.02064247988164425, 0.01971614733338356, -0.02960619330406189, 0.029812932014465332, -0.009683939628303051, -0.043126244097948074, -0.0034603443928062916, -0.004174761474132538, 0.011271219700574875, -0.0103030726313591, 0.02950456365942955, -0.016307055950164795, 0.027369748800992966, -0.02666492573916912, 0.012604196555912495, 0.03991192951798439, -0.004830915480852127, 0.039190225303173065, -0.00415851129218936, -0.000828527205158025, -0.015742648392915726, -0.031186595559120178, 0.009709024801850319, -0.04027390107512474, -0.00669802026823163, -0.05144824832677841, 0.016425788402557373, 0.03635178878903389, 0.06310472637414932, 0.017184285447001457, 0.005078329239040613, -0.0019633350893855095, 0.0046621947549283504, -0.007061517331749201, -0.059774406254291534, -0.004840171430259943, -0.0018887667683884501, -0.03902457281947136, 0.010782434605062008, 0.006009808275848627, 0.06744226813316345, 0.022225413471460342, 0.055192168802022934, -0.046553365886211395, 0.03535112738609314, 0.002232189755886793, 0.014413305558264256, 0.008133620023727417, -0.0401541031897068, -0.0029097108636051416, 0.018127067014575005, 0.0032592597417533398, -0.050900157541036606, -0.02739105001091957, -0.02267439477145672, -0.01875593140721321, 0.009146892465651035, -0.026172678917646408, -0.019690750166773796, 0.043495576828718185, -0.011184051632881165, 0.039495065808296204, -0.032350923866033554, -0.0419364869594574, -0.013785351999104023, -0.03383154794573784, 0.037892863154411316, -0.0660538375377655, 0.0013612138573080301, -0.005491926800459623, 0.015633877366781235, -0.03536045178771019, 0.033306319266557693, 0.044936034828424454, 0.010009986348450184, -0.017350807785987854, -0.0055860066786408424, -0.018095510080456734, 0.06098679080605507, -0.03342157229781151, -0.011666318401694298, 0.04465482383966446, -0.015786707401275635, -0.028956640511751175, 0.041308749467134476, -0.007109412923455238, 0.027481431141495705, -0.006765544414520264, 0.02282552607357502, -0.05176622048020363, 0.03972896561026573, -0.03755147010087967, 0.017913643270730972, 0.002907601883634925, -0.013980585150420666, 0.0020872571039944887, -0.0022676324006170034, 0.027644410729408264, -0.007927300408482552, -0.020017344504594803, 0.01235792227089405, 0.020180262625217438, 0.02111739106476307, -0.019488785415887833, 0.014942060224711895, -0.007098081521689892, 0.03239184990525246, -0.00276611908338964, -0.004308960400521755, 0.048842787742614746, 0.02944778837263584, -0.047856204211711884, 0.0633862316608429, 0.008157743141055107, 0.03412381187081337, -0.08723592758178711, -0.02929290384054184, 0.01619706302881241, 0.017664391547441483, 0.038310807198286057, -0.04183731600642204, -0.02026977948844433, 0.04658225178718567, -0.05432960018515587, 0.007105991244316101, 0.010143736377358437, -0.0062188333831727505, -0.04519430920481682, -0.022171450778841972, -0.028317097574472427, -0.003548974869772792, 0.057729221880435944, 0.050006575882434845, -0.0027938680723309517, 0.023205088451504707, 0.01058623380959034, -0.014444251544773579, -0.02546530030667782, 0.029438147321343422, -0.027084307745099068, -0.04868607223033905, 0.04130277410149574, -0.028542781248688698, -0.024193597957491875, 0.02841387316584587, 0.013302971608936787, 0.03087744675576687, 0.03233727812767029, -0.016092272475361824, 0.02755741961300373, 0.05756109952926636, 0.046668607741594315, -0.027996793389320374, 0.0134671526029706, -0.00481584994122386, 0.0014682519249618053, -0.0016170535236597061, -0.017219876870512962, 0.030226215720176697, -0.007965590804815292, -0.01716027408838272, -0.029901515692472458, 0.030087916180491447, -0.0022707220632582903, -0.02589191310107708, -0.0016044011572375894, 0.00952958408743143, -0.030255597084760666, -0.016309114173054695, -0.011810640804469585, -0.024782883003354073, 0.015402736142277718, 0.03201764076948166, 0.01705366000533104, 0.0013114227913320065, 0.003538944525644183, 0.002287112409248948, -0.04092678055167198, 0.008859666995704174, 0.004961313214153051, 0.014758615754544735, -0.06954086571931839, 0.0020438984502106905, 0.008561240509152412, -0.02754301205277443, -0.024484196677803993, -0.022414829581975937, 0.0025101492647081614, 0.033163346350193024, -0.00974278524518013, 0.007495846599340439, 0.06143653020262718, -0.02308036759495735, -0.02346048504114151, -0.08862925320863724, 0.1105457991361618, 0.008960067294538021, 0.0006871568621136248, -0.05457942560315132, 0.003575304290279746, -0.031088976189494133, -0.0016837493749335408, 0.06568551063537598, -0.011775938794016838, 0.01080108992755413, -0.01832996867597103, 0.031800054013729095, 0.027730563655495644, -0.0511702299118042, 0.01784561574459076, -0.005221450701355934, 0.007376654073596001, -0.02113870158791542, -0.04768429324030876, 0.016944624483585358, 0.020790942013263702, 0.021484622731804848, 0.0006489654770120978, 0.007215388119220734, -0.00019398167205508798, 0.02672790177166462, 0.053511012345552444, 0.009714184328913689, -0.0030820765532553196, 0.04287507012486458, 0.003171866061165929, 0.008797985501587391, 0.04655546694993973, -0.026770468801259995, -0.02556828036904335, 0.028939174488186836, -0.005712393205612898, -0.02210129424929619, -0.03616070747375488, 0.007970398291945457, -0.006330742035061121, -0.03408398851752281, -0.015428464859724045, 0.054317209869623184, -0.012366127222776413, 0.009532453492283821, 0.05011880025267601, -0.01288282684981823, 0.03795085847377777, -0.00014415425539482385, 0.026026526466012, 0.06620531529188156, -0.016526123508810997, 0.00970095582306385, -0.0016305828467011452, 0.055489107966423035, 0.029249776154756546, -0.0007272338261827826, 0.013456559740006924, -0.0070861284621059895, 0.024164261296391487, -0.02561516873538494, 0.050227485597133636, -0.04741934686899185, -0.025928327813744545, 0.020695138722658157, -0.022984571754932404, 0.033009517937898636, 0.011737687513232231, -0.030815109610557556, 0.051138587296009064, -0.08591724932193756, -0.02316637896001339, -0.04234025999903679, -0.024176012724637985, 0.0064191678538918495, -0.016709476709365845, 0.03346556797623634, -0.010543186217546463, -0.00014255389396566898, 0.035162556916475296, -0.00007351741805905476, 0.01369378063827753, 0.0570719838142395, -0.008298616856336594, 0.012203681282699108, -0.00286443205550313, -0.036308079957962036, -0.020667394623160362, -0.021245555952191353, -0.02341192401945591, -0.0065312813967466354, 0.016407353803515434, 0.05871936306357384, 0.04211299493908882, 0.008610885590314865, -0.0037418061401695013, -0.028820307925343513, 0.020201999694108963, -0.07943779230117798, 0.013906683772802353, -0.015710478648543358, 0.0028194368351250887, 0.013593313284218311, -0.061886344105005264 ]
<p>I use Andrew F. Hayes' macro for SPSS (HCREG at <a href="http://www.afhayes.com/spss-sas-and-mplus-macros-and-code.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.afhayes.com/spss-sas-and-mplus-macros-and-code.html</a>) to perform multiple regression analyses with robust standard errors.</p> <p>The information I get in the output is limited compared to the one SPSS provides when applying multiple regression. For example, there are no standardized coefficients (Beta) for predictors and there is no adjusted R-squared.</p> <p>Can I assume that the standardized coefficients will be the same as in the model without robust standard errors? If not, does anyone know how can I go about computing them by hand?</p> <p>I have the same question for the adjusted R-squared.</p> <p>Any help would be greatly appreciated! Thank you very much in advance.</p>
1,037
[ -0.02775939181447029, 0.005117007065564394, -0.009947777725756168, 0.005652883555740118, 0.007849602960050106, 0.01595519855618477, 0.01453586295247078, -0.040089163929224014, 0.041531894356012344, -0.019481102004647255, 0.015805311501026154, 0.02438579499721527, 0.08474662899971008, -0.012073778547346592, -0.008962648920714855, -0.019401872530579567, -0.005663745570927858, 0.0020666546188294888, 0.004818540532141924, 0.024200329557061195, 0.002117545809596777, 0.00258176913484931, -0.017090437933802605, -0.01014419924467802, -0.013727008365094662, 0.06897895038127899, 0.05609946325421333, -0.005637327674776316, 0.02898118644952774, 0.04633058235049248, -0.02308812364935875, -0.01676725037395954, -0.008049765601754189, 0.03290027379989624, 0.0021792687475681305, 0.0204689409583807, -0.0014542258577421308, -0.014268760569393635, -0.03151371702551842, 0.042618367820978165, -0.03291235864162445, -0.017317382618784904, -0.009196349419653416, 0.0500144436955452, -0.026209620758891106, 0.0015572193078696728, -0.035050299018621445, 0.016408968716859818, 0.05272142216563225, -0.03463616222143173, 0.08756548911333084, 0.005608892533928156, 0.05340651422739029, 0.04622010141611099, -0.04254717752337456, 0.0025959229096770287, 0.0621972531080246, 0.04894574359059334, -0.012515961192548275, -0.04649052396416664, 0.036441024392843246, -0.016753388568758965, 0.006293355952948332, -0.005933940410614014, -0.05865415930747986, -0.014339198358356953, -0.01623034104704857, -0.020094426348805428, 0.06043541431427002, 0.012693262659013271, 0.01076528150588274, 0.03720936179161072, 0.02664429508149624, -0.007060148287564516, 0.006299728527665138, -0.05126217007637024, -0.0030855757649987936, 0.024618888273835182, 0.02092902548611164, 0.036298055201768875, 0.02070585824549198, -0.007171344477683306, 0.013708625920116901, 0.04107016697525978, 0.021172450855374336, -0.027312682941555977, 0.06100989133119583, -0.012402672320604324, 0.027285372838377953, 0.020248958840966225, 0.0013357216957956553, 0.01783374696969986, 0.05240936204791069, 0.007110269740223885, -0.04066934809088707, 0.015199997462332249, 0.01072219293564558, 0.0488448292016983, -0.0021862334106117487, -0.009304310195147991, 0.015161474235355854, -0.031186196953058243, -0.004744784906506538, 0.018337130546569824, -0.023334408178925514, -0.003040278796106577, -0.029433410614728928, -0.006364759989082813, 0.02851138636469841, -0.050220128148794174, -0.017018383368849754, 0.018458127975463867, -0.027340224012732506, -0.051687173545360565, 0.019584784284234047, -0.021682970225811005, -0.012630747631192207, 0.011255468241870403, 0.07223665714263916, 0.06989172101020813, 0.029903344810009003, -0.04239939525723457, 0.013110621832311153, -0.004389204550534487, -0.03405168280005455, 0.026639817282557487, 0.010800941847264767, -0.025375571101903915, -0.04001130536198616, 0.05627061054110527, 0.002112909220159054, -0.01443990133702755, 0.0349566750228405, -0.007078772410750389, 0.004044308327138424, -0.0015805267030373216, -0.07618394494056702, -0.08969543129205704, 0.006663805339485407, 0.008094997145235538, 0.005257712677121162, -0.058019429445266724, -0.011973797343671322, 0.0006513523403555155, 0.04454774409532547, 0.020492015406489372, 0.04720916599035263, 0.03629862517118454, 0.016950948163866997, 0.01806345209479332, -0.05401472747325897, -0.000982337980531156, -0.006642123684287071, -0.04006887227296829, -0.03278777748346329, -0.10038883239030838, -0.011259232647716999, 0.0187334306538105, -0.018572665750980377, 0.017885727807879448, 0.05058152973651886, 0.03721684589982033, -0.026972515508532524, 0.019273659214377403, -0.006698005832731724, -0.03155369311571121, 0.05160372331738472, -0.020374417304992676, -0.005089981481432915, 0.035882618278265, -0.009128346107900143, 0.009780403226613998, -0.01636655069887638, 0.04094269126653671, 0.03822897747159004, -0.011575005948543549, -0.005578275304287672, 0.013126379810273647, 0.002900905441492796, 0.021924879401922226, -0.11386708170175552, -0.023169323801994324, -0.019776271656155586, -0.0031698206439614296, -0.009155180305242538, 0.07131420075893402, -0.01666514202952385, -0.01613389141857624, 0.029602868482470512, -0.03906875103712082, -0.04254544898867607, -0.07769771665334702, 0.021854206919670105, 0.003231871174648404, -0.03875018283724785, -0.0010256781242787838, 0.012866145931184292, 0.018948037177324295, 0.023280257359147072, -0.0006163448560982943, -0.04242340847849846, 0.004172875080257654, 0.05647169426083565, -0.033167533576488495, -0.004118118900805712, 0.03452258184552193, 0.07036744803190231, -0.022968348115682602, 0.028069395571947098, -0.019252926111221313, -0.00805733073502779, 0.039320699870586395, -0.05959295108914375, 0.009269777685403824, -0.026021594181656837, -0.026642240583896637, 0.02561722882091999, -0.006009019911289215, 0.011852262541651726, 0.05381728708744049, -0.03997344896197319, 0.038899995386600494, 0.03735579922795296, 0.026130998507142067, 0.0020450192969292402, 0.011541560292243958, 0.006290649529546499, 0.027787748724222183, -0.05452343821525574, 0.0016350822988897562, -0.03096584789454937, -0.015785720199346542, 0.004461427219212055, -0.0037445840425789356, -0.0700182393193245, -0.008630640804767609, 0.08035536110401154, 0.008510102517902851, 0.014046123251318932, 0.014222406782209873, -0.008730068802833557, -0.01983487792313099, -0.012162204831838608, 0.017027370631694794, 0.021473173052072525, 0.028420841321349144, -0.012312965467572212, 0.03491067886352539, 0.015234211459755898, 0.022229619324207306, 0.04568302258849144, 0.06265884637832642, -0.008862615562975407, 0.002404366619884968, -0.028260869905352592, -0.007355411536991596, 0.05653248354792595, 0.0014212771784514189, 0.026634221896529198, 0.04109705239534378, 0.009601999074220657, -0.022662006318569183, 0.03752467408776283, -0.00634780153632164, 0.018363941460847855, -0.0055681923404335976, -0.025576692074537277, 0.0031154509633779526, -0.003665609285235405, -0.040520116686820984, -0.00020658878202084452, -0.04933568835258484, 0.002735778456553817, -0.05232050642371178, -0.009525815024971962, 0.012676856480538845, -0.01984470710158348, 0.022867467254400253, -0.02532290481030941, 0.0030064901802688837, 0.016399309039115906, 0.020776182413101196, 0.021148765459656715, -0.0053675128147006035, -0.03385148197412491, -0.022043732926249504, -0.04514189064502716, -0.0204766932874918, 0.028717169538140297, -0.012860095128417015, -0.05762020871043205, 0.05429890379309654, 0.006075774785131216, -0.049822673201560974, -0.015330657362937927, -0.016912072896957397, 0.0038947993889451027, -0.030312346294522285, -0.05082441493868828, 0.01959780789911747, 0.0059144324623048306, -0.04913250729441643, 0.03600040450692177, -0.039153750985860825, -0.0003884217294398695, -0.011800076812505722, -0.0008334621670655906, -0.005399999208748341, -0.006110744085162878, 0.016468891873955727, -0.007384205237030983, -0.031408533453941345, -0.01159608829766512, -0.023356549441814423, -0.0393611378967762, -0.00005075804074294865, 0.010360457934439182, 0.05167374387383461, 0.0038146222941577435, -0.018842309713363647, 0.06570552289485931, 0.006021248176693916, -0.0315023809671402, -0.08186652511358261, 0.00362602761015296, -0.025259289890527725, -0.03152656555175781, 0.007153256330639124, 0.0021649696864187717, 0.008828436955809593, 0.0016869844403117895, -0.021623574197292328, 0.015255531296133995, 0.03702878952026367, 0.02073991484940052, 0.005717267747968435, 0.010782243683934212, -0.022441627457737923, -0.026496825739741325, 0.056952472776174545, 0.02077976055443287, -0.009252544492483139, -0.0026288062799721956, 0.025487493723630905, 0.00810811948031187, 0.0005213390104472637, -0.04126124456524849, 0.027117621153593063, -0.04800155758857727, -0.008930429816246033, -0.04017556458711624, 0.0008102879510261118, 0.03528624773025513, -0.0025954521261155605, -0.01052064262330532, -0.0307167936116457, -0.0055349357426166534, -0.024913784116506577, -0.0010087970877066255, 0.05027415603399277, 0.05049992725253105, 0.024325985461473465, -0.011464071460068226, -0.03107554465532303, -0.006937313824892044, 0.022137481719255447, -0.01721375249326229, -0.02807452902197838, 0.05052017793059349, 0.048012636601924896, 0.0169371347874403, 0.018261151388287544, -0.05730902776122093, 0.0323186032474041, -0.09642136842012405, 0.012288669124245644, -0.04698440432548523, 0.05709211900830269, 0.007870752364397049, 0.03403870388865471, 0.010722629725933075, -0.022192157804965973, 0.008810551837086678, -0.0069466885179281235, -0.0388922244310379, 0.047054585069417953, -0.028533365577459335, -0.000023430095097864978, 0.03181575611233711, -0.008928131312131882, 0.024848269298672676, -0.030427606776356697, 0.02036232315003872, -0.01136381272226572, 0.021239010617136955, -0.0414438471198082, 0.006324014160782099, -0.0017711333930492401, -0.001322246273048222, -0.025269703939557076, 0.023435737937688828, 0.011850235983729362, -0.020139845088124275, 0.013339320197701454, 0.04242798686027527, -0.027093499898910522, 0.022571668028831482, -0.03012467734515667, 0.001201645820401609, 0.005823301151394844, 0.03689350560307503, 0.08446811884641647, 0.0311482734978199, -0.022915709763765335, -0.0024414584040641785, -0.0077223521657288074, 0.04345918446779251, 0.037341393530368805, 0.03191661462187767, -0.027012526988983154, -0.02565222978591919, -0.006037920247763395, 0.013958774507045746, -0.006956246681511402, -0.014641507528722286, 0.005419155582785606, 0.09233483672142029, 0.0055298651568591595, -0.06919518858194351, 0.013124789111316204, 0.048758912831544876, 0.007291208952665329, -0.00010922051296802238, -0.03695499897003174, -0.0009484753827564418, -0.018131908029317856, -0.023678917437791824, 0.03221989795565605, 0.01885664090514183, -0.009893299080431461, 0.00047577888472005725, 0.032227300107479095, -0.01689286157488823, -0.013057171367108822, -0.006016816943883896, 0.02974170632660389, 0.07097426056861877, 0.008806371130049229, -0.03143351525068283, -0.013948660343885422, 0.03710747882723808, 0.0065930988639593124, 0.011957813054323196, -0.007434088736772537, -0.06967132538557053, -0.002162935445085168, 0.004677998833358288, 0.04849342629313469, -0.03286411613225937, 0.010044210590422153, -0.0048928698524832726, 0.017645498737692833, 0.07149854302406311, -0.05964672565460205, 0.008381959982216358, 0.0034373877570033073, -0.003850140841677785, -0.015180165879428387, 0.012946493923664093, -0.04489310085773468, 0.007882822304964066, -0.005058905575424433, 0.024012073874473572, -0.021658651530742645, -0.011008454486727715, -0.04779544100165367, -0.019947374239563942, -0.0020773846190422773, 0.05162174999713898, -0.0027034140657633543, -0.008455641567707062, 0.0047410763800144196, 0.041653797030448914, -0.01267885323613882, -0.05942084267735481, 0.005009012296795845, 0.006101833190768957, 0.000855376769322902, 0.057411372661590576, 0.001343047246336937, -0.03063874877989292, 0.01389406155794859, 0.0301373153924942, -0.008448176085948944, -0.0007425585645250976, -0.02057977020740509, -0.0010185445426031947, 0.046447623521089554, 0.015003864653408527, 0.06880159676074982, 0.023174120113253593, 0.0017575002275407314, -0.01306436862796545, -0.00886492244899273, 0.009110002778470516, -0.025097813457250595, -0.06948496401309967, -0.01506964024156332, 0.020083822309970856, -0.010377517901360989, 0.03652516379952431, 0.0013535772450268269, 0.02594630792737007, -0.004444872960448265, -0.027444373816251755, 0.0423298217356205, 0.041156597435474396, -0.01566038839519024, 0.040035270154476166, 0.028798483312129974, 0.0008910315227694809, -0.004868104588240385, -0.056034669280052185, 0.01154854241758585, 0.01010063011199236, -0.020908663049340248, -0.005979750771075487, -0.04302888736128807, 0.04850646108388901, 0.01469204481691122, -0.03759106993675232, -0.0011007634457200766, -0.018486477434635162, 0.0313972644507885, -0.018687522038817406, 0.05247989296913147, -0.026837138459086418, -0.041655611246824265, -0.02183857001364231, 0.011151758022606373, -0.006039096508175135, 0.017935041338205338, 0.005120466463267803, 0.06899940222501755, -0.001283861231058836, -0.017820093780755997, -0.05948634818196297, -0.04411821439862251, -0.0008218445582315326, 0.01138657983392477, -0.024755699560046196, -0.0015702807577326894, 0.005006532184779644, -0.019282566383481026, -0.005967959761619568, -0.03983386978507042, 0.0517754890024662, -0.023686440661549568, -0.01578262448310852, -0.0037295606452971697, 0.018431739881634712, 0.02558457851409912, -0.020603692159056664, 0.007645382080227137, 0.007767105009406805, -0.010184691287577152, -0.04793358966708183, 0.01851612515747547, 0.02673756331205368, -0.029146792367100716, -0.04407393932342529, -0.0450885184109211, -0.014325792901217937, 0.04643100127577782, -0.005309592466801405, -0.02174026519060135, 0.0031455843709409237, -0.010001000948250294, 0.020108016207814217, -0.025497552007436752, -0.0005781958461739123, -0.011728690937161446, 0.0062027606181800365, -0.017304783686995506, -0.004348532762378454, -0.024678628891706467, 0.03359820693731308, 0.0037593452725559473, 0.01304580457508564, -0.007242830004543066, -0.012311160564422607, 0.08734726905822754, 0.016777973622083664, 0.021544648334383965, 0.009897058829665184, -0.02591395005583763, 0.04447031766176224, 0.027405329048633575, 0.030039137229323387, 0.003786705434322357, 0.029474005103111267, -0.013217405416071415, -0.03333861753344536, -0.039888665080070496, 0.02389337122440338, 0.05359900742769241, -0.029064763337373734, 0.029124243184924126, 0.0705445185303688, -0.038720421493053436, -0.023564107716083527, -0.057076916098594666, -0.023782726377248764, 0.010805992409586906, 0.023662399500608444, 0.05331441015005112, -0.0047620185650885105, -0.0019766162149608135, 0.005257862154394388, 0.0402398407459259, 0.007991817779839039, 0.05347541347146034, 0.033826522529125214, 0.022022197023034096, 0.015782522037625313, -0.014247543178498745, -0.037766214460134506, 0.02844475954771042, -0.005098662804812193, -0.008022498339414597, -0.01895192638039589, -0.022615110501646996, 0.014698208309710026, 0.016144495457410812, 0.0020179697312414646, -0.05729014798998833, -0.011869275942444801, -0.00979514978826046, 0.02007363736629486, -0.01986204832792282, -0.05020606890320778, 0.009399905800819397, 0.00019655399955809116, 0.030727654695510864, -0.004496957175433636, 0.04161600023508072, -0.06832749396562576, -0.07468924671411514, 0.0020972094498574734, 0.005925912410020828, -0.009521660394966602, 0.025633934885263443, -0.006862129084765911, -0.03397781774401665, 0.014929350465536118, -0.03614869341254234, -0.001597701571881771, 0.020178576931357384, 0.03858982026576996, 0.018132556229829788, 0.07397644966840744, -0.01436709612607956, -0.01796518824994564, 0.0004941254737786949, -0.017204442992806435, 0.10031777620315552, 0.09830521792173386, 0.05023445188999176, -0.06891659647226334, -0.0060156285762786865, -0.023041963577270508, 0.023035669699311256, 0.006422705017030239, -0.002718784147873521, -0.019024135544896126, -0.04111238196492195, 0.0372658371925354, 0.07998467981815338, 0.0008731855778023601, 0.008813293650746346, 0.03252723067998886, -0.010383127257227898, -0.037383176386356354, -0.006323663517832756, 0.008587886579334736, 0.009642823599278927, -0.007157237734645605, -0.01679478958249092, 0.012188827618956566, -0.023087153211236, -0.013302196748554707, -0.0316455215215683, 0.002463789889588952, -0.008173171430826187, 0.017287636175751686, -0.02908051759004593, -0.0010565220145508647, 0.004998392425477505, 0.024559874087572098, -0.03876292333006859, -0.0012036936823278666, 0.02805970050394535, -0.03932106867432594, 0.008614765480160713, 0.0231857281178236, -0.005091032478958368, 0.012162579223513603, 0.026726072654128075, 0.009885205887258053, -0.08783308416604996, -0.0262173879891634, -0.022184254601597786, 0.05602647736668587, -0.03189216926693916, -0.05169571563601494, -0.004952976480126381, 0.003945859614759684, -0.005807708948850632, -0.027825282886624336, -0.03329886496067047, 0.03833376243710518, 0.016647106036543846, -0.028687860816717148, -0.03161843121051788, -0.04156992956995964, -0.02628595381975174, -0.011162901297211647, -0.0033892556093633175, 0.0029150662012398243, -0.06480328738689423, -0.03240792825818062, -0.04075407236814499, 0.04532736912369728, -0.01691400073468685, -0.009944094344973564, -0.0006089576054364443, -0.01890433207154274, -0.03315745294094086, -0.011552209034562111, 0.04774845391511917, 0.030568357557058334, 0.01751679740846157, -0.0009174626902677119, 0.01814061589539051, -0.01662277989089489, -0.060883790254592896, 0.027170253917574883, -0.06490746885538101, 0.015088675543665886, -0.06364810466766357, -0.0031564917881041765, 0.03508627787232399, 0.056051433086395264, 0.014258315786719322, 0.011377616785466671, -0.009922424331307411, 0.03959096968173981, 0.028626546263694763, -0.07419136166572571, -0.025466885417699814, -0.004232889041304588, -0.057047855108976364, 0.007817813195288181, -0.021521909162402153, 0.0634092316031456, 0.016450731083750725, 0.06034005433320999, -0.022807469591498375, 0.038753293454647064, 0.01643223874270916, 0.01105845533311367, -0.013903288170695305, -0.06496506929397583, -0.00426890142261982, -0.001148282433860004, 0.023113014176487923, -0.012067980132997036, 0.021830052137374878, -0.05172771215438843, -0.05774953216314316, 0.008436139672994614, -0.02316110022366047, -0.04922054708003998, 0.04568944498896599, -0.0045426832512021065, 0.027217116206884384, -0.04234743118286133, 0.014969350770115852, -0.025264210999011993, -0.035251718014478683, -0.0034230074379593134, -0.014381595887243748, 0.00040286072180606425, -0.017370032146573067, -0.01879362389445305, 0.020283712074160576, 0.06461276113986969, -0.021457089111208916, 0.02796197682619095, -0.019370470196008682, -0.02635917253792286, 0.020000435411930084, 0.05890757218003273, -0.022395629435777664, -0.010381825268268585, 0.016572674736380577, -0.024696804583072662, 0.008131101727485657, 0.005228623282164335, 0.008541618473827839, 0.050562161952257156, 0.03726314753293991, 0.003913309890776873, -0.026988761499524117, 0.07308410108089447, -0.011493507772684097, -0.0006636654725298285, -0.041210778057575226, 0.02073758840560913, 0.030635561794042587, 0.0260302871465683, 0.007453983649611473, -0.0008506611920893192, -0.012838232330977917, 0.03752991557121277, 0.0660025030374527, -0.010720680467784405, -0.017870895564556122, -0.004025069065392017, -0.003528730943799019, -0.00181088678073138, 0.024738697335124016, 0.030331673100590706, 0.008888625539839268, 0.014956770464777946, -0.02568063512444496, 0.04309377074241638, -0.016354773193597794, 0.02783863991498947, -0.06636345386505127, -0.02443583309650421, -0.017222009599208832, 0.0258464515209198, -0.0029482608661055565, -0.03909910470247269, 0.0006502599571831524, 0.046618055552244186, -0.03786235675215721, -0.03566209226846695, -0.014036627486348152, 0.000906393863260746, -0.01660257577896118, 0.009817700833082199, -0.022602388635277748, 0.024943698197603226, 0.014398486353456974, 0.02286584861576557, 0.018453922122716904, 0.010931666009128094, -0.0227730143815279, -0.029895402491092682, 0.004110877867788076, 0.009525147266685963, 0.032359667122364044, -0.04621953144669533, 0.0061124046333134174, -0.034668777137994766, -0.012907628901302814, 0.008976344019174576, -0.009725636802613735, 0.05043533444404602, 0.024844519793987274, 0.014726482331752777, 0.027418479323387146, 0.035626962780952454, 0.0026292852126061916, 0.016039155423641205, 0.028055492788553238, 0.011398661881685257, -0.013930760324001312, 0.02755400724709034, -0.04546323046088219, 0.007203057408332825, 0.010379438288509846, -0.02783806249499321, -0.04665793478488922, 0.027443207800388336, -0.026242023333907127, -0.012047188356518745, -0.0174003504216671, -0.008472450077533722, 0.017439695075154305, -0.03980535641312599, 0.05319501459598541, -0.06330469250679016, 0.011258027516305447, 0.05419839173555374, 0.043727144598960876, -0.04073747247457504, 0.010514073073863983, -0.003328407183289528, -0.008272092789411545, 0.007644589990377426, -0.028184503316879272, -0.01998872682452202, -0.06176178157329559, -0.027319444343447685, 0.017374936491250992, 0.012794984504580498, -0.028806617483496666, -0.00951410923153162, -0.017202675342559814, 0.02955501712858677, -0.012125629931688309, -0.009152635931968689, 0.05158524960279465, -0.022609125822782516, 0.01764841377735138, -0.04666679725050926, 0.04568903148174286, 0.029562754556536674, -0.03462987393140793, -0.014931519515812397, -0.028938814997673035, -0.02386222593486309, -0.002496434608474374, 0.050938379019498825, -0.004761622287333012, -0.0028477588202804327, 0.015246612951159477, 0.05686602368950844, 0.00275884079746902, -0.02673158422112465, 0.0493488647043705, 0.04054591804742813, -0.007677438203245401, -0.015863459557294846, -0.0060103400610387325, 0.027001621201634407, 0.010756302624940872, 0.02463172934949398, -0.02482503280043602, 0.004162787925451994, 0.006386668421328068, -0.036295097321271896, -0.011244113557040691, -0.021785570308566093, -0.038861099630594254, 0.0562216080725193, 0.003108659293502569, 0.000958976917900145, 0.059629760682582855, 0.023371772840619087, -0.007059699390083551, 0.043997202068567276, -0.009533128701150417, -0.00023617036640644073, 0.007519028149545193, 0.01548414584249258, -0.012962842360138893, -0.06003408879041672, 0.02100539393723011, 0.008382540196180344, -0.015691809356212616, -0.025647012516856194, 0.051450781524181366, 0.016861364245414734, 0.029110495001077652, 0.015294513665139675, 0.018910015001893044, 0.01519936416298151, -0.05316416546702385, 0.04642774909734726, 0.004567110911011696, 0.042493343353271484, 0.03998410329222679, 0.0085814343765378, 0.031338170170784, -0.014523784630000591, 0.055999305099248886, -0.010577380657196045, 0.01184285432100296, -0.03321872651576996, -0.031878210604190826, -0.011925981380045414, -0.01894867792725563, 0.03553413599729538, -0.02455415204167366, -0.01054864190518856, 0.05203288421034813, -0.043088074773550034, -0.0016327094053849578, -0.04824546352028847, 0.005323285236954689, -0.04838479310274124, -0.0010842392221093178, -0.01951855793595314, 0.019453896209597588, -0.022935472428798676, 0.007600622717291117, 0.004014481790363789, -0.004059077240526676, 0.059342432767152786, 0.025051657110452652, 0.016340244561433792, -0.014859707094728947, -0.014432123862206936, -0.026599491015076637, -0.03573231399059296, 0.018223416060209274, 0.014091772958636284, 0.02411617524921894, 0.04454144835472107, 0.027007652446627617, -0.0430547371506691, -0.036545734852552414, 0.025383105501532555, 0.06887997686862946, -0.06017394736409187, -0.011055102571845055, -0.04646266624331474, -0.003899716306477785, -0.03400220721960068, -0.0376216396689415 ]
<p>I have seen many places where they have input/output datasets where they first create a linear regression line, correct the bias, and then only use that data for their model. I didn't get what this bias correction is?</p>
74,387
[ -0.03199305757880211, 0.019512545317411423, -0.032759908586740494, 0.028119826689362526, 0.010805771686136723, 0.054506391286849976, -0.002468531485646963, 0.004333773627877235, 0.027854206040501595, -0.016293523833155632, 0.0358208604156971, 0.034448254853487015, 0.03399166092276573, -0.003739582374691963, 0.03559190034866333, 0.03228209540247917, -0.02054346539080143, 0.04279810190200806, 0.00913994200527668, -0.0046385591849684715, -0.011747229844331741, 0.02518177404999733, 0.0010347443167120218, 0.006149898283183575, -0.012587394565343857, 0.02363639697432518, 0.016702504828572273, 0.007817765697836876, 0.05144425481557846, 0.023037975654006004, -0.002882028929889202, -0.04067898914217949, 0.028054935857653618, 0.03616524860262871, -0.006392179988324642, -0.021465448662638664, 0.03025241382420063, -0.05810984969139099, 0.0075670029036700726, 0.05670362338423729, -0.044641975313425064, 0.013098486699163914, 0.02977154217660427, 0.03641447424888611, -0.005345288198441267, 0.029580008238554, 0.00971903558820486, -0.07023563981056213, 0.033770233392715454, -0.0337865874171257, 0.0752824991941452, -0.019084198400378227, 0.05314427241683006, 0.046543437987565994, 0.01890888437628746, 0.04179481789469719, 0.07478001713752747, 0.058075498789548874, 0.002970538567751646, -0.037182316184043884, -0.008248403668403625, -0.032957665622234344, 0.015847913920879364, 0.005952831357717514, -0.025753343477845192, 0.010759305208921432, 0.013582761399447918, -0.04147620499134064, 0.038981903344392776, -0.0004682014405261725, 0.020841948688030243, 0.02957800403237343, 0.011349622160196304, -0.025326501578092575, -0.025058727711439133, -0.02071528136730194, 0.004726365674287081, -0.0015746356220915914, 0.028169933706521988, 0.002523945877328515, 0.02506459876894951, 0.009130788035690784, 0.043957971036434174, 0.0453866608440876, 0.010827437043190002, 0.008725984953343868, 0.07342261075973511, -0.002171062398701906, 0.04367287456989288, 0.019183505326509476, -0.030839120969176292, -0.0050201574340462685, 0.03959396481513977, -0.026168448850512505, -0.00919834803789854, 0.04438459873199463, 0.004667371977120638, 0.03923717513680458, 0.023969391360878944, -0.008174191229045391, -0.00040791669744066894, -0.03155645728111267, -0.020669221878051758, 0.034923188388347626, -0.023718014359474182, -0.01910235732793808, -0.022523608058691025, 0.021840663626790047, -0.0250546857714653, -0.0109027661383152, -0.020618649199604988, -0.004542327951639891, -0.0021666211541742086, 0.013685470446944237, 0.0433473065495491, -0.0006285751587711275, 0.007399579044431448, -0.0013179507805034518, 0.01685386337339878, 0.04502437263727188, 0.02307465486228466, -0.021885378286242485, 0.0390821136534214, 0.03402305394411087, -0.03295731917023659, 0.010991615243256092, 0.012041829526424408, -0.043437328189611435, -0.05923871323466301, 0.04062514752149582, -0.03301076963543892, -0.06480216234922409, 0.04394427314400673, 0.020546242594718933, 0.04134412109851837, -0.016513129696249962, -0.0699058547616005, -0.0717821940779686, 0.033267732709646225, -0.011813181452453136, 0.0005919434479437768, -0.08232895284891129, -0.018284905701875687, 0.0611310712993145, 0.08377731591463089, 0.007111796643584967, 0.018221355974674225, 0.03257995843887329, -0.02553466148674488, -0.008003449998795986, -0.00520346499979496, -0.02645011804997921, -0.004726487211883068, -0.05055232718586922, 0.003157701576128602, -0.06621351093053818, 0.015942741185426712, 0.02905404008924961, -0.030117889866232872, -0.027488166466355324, 0.0016490741400048137, -0.016552474349737167, -0.013053975068032742, 0.049796294420957565, -0.018614571541547775, -0.014093506149947643, 0.0782366544008255, -0.008856873959302902, 0.02556540071964264, 0.04067786782979965, -0.017544887959957123, 0.03903486952185631, 0.0299773458391428, 0.06844677031040192, 0.03699521720409393, -0.0190255306661129, 0.0032748738303780556, -0.02148270234465599, 0.006446222309023142, -0.01452132873237133, -0.046598367393016815, -0.0213911235332489, 0.02324768342077732, 0.0032237195409834385, 0.018209336325526237, 0.07825364172458649, -0.00989651307463646, -0.01923551969230175, 0.03792570158839226, -0.05980105325579643, -0.013222402893006802, -0.06363090872764587, 0.014432371594011784, -0.05517769232392311, -0.0018661950016394258, 0.004872129764407873, -0.0030457426328212023, 0.010624431073665619, -0.020891834050416946, -0.05533955246210098, -0.026897219941020012, -0.024671899154782295, 0.06201196834445, -0.02544175274670124, 0.022606398910284042, 0.04722592979669571, 0.050055284053087234, -0.00554238585755229, 0.03122340887784958, -0.06208125874400139, -0.023765403777360916, 0.004556176718324423, -0.026464175432920456, 0.02702200971543789, -0.04034805670380592, -0.030119024217128754, -0.018561724573373795, 0.0038890514988452196, -0.02199297398328781, 0.03379661589860916, -0.03338386490941048, 0.0334797278046608, 0.07816150039434433, 0.009336823597550392, -0.02955535426735878, 0.007630142383277416, -0.004656865261495113, 0.022236505523324013, -0.027427207678556442, -0.02966504730284214, -0.05066531524062157, -0.0025752552319318056, 0.024370336905121803, -0.004171973094344139, -0.03161272406578064, -0.01924278400838375, 0.056715697050094604, 0.05276454612612724, 0.010374782606959343, 0.02184898406267166, -0.02372162416577339, -0.0004802845942322165, 0.00038174865767359734, -0.003811969654634595, 0.022320924326777458, 0.025211704894900322, 0.030668746680021286, 0.028967805206775665, 0.06179850175976753, 0.028922872617840767, -0.006151446606963873, 0.05967365950345993, -0.028829073533415794, -0.009805573150515556, 0.005724192131310701, -0.01086659450083971, 0.015234203077852726, -0.03861686587333679, 0.02606295794248581, 0.039560720324516296, -0.00848357379436493, -0.003244842169806361, 0.016552120447158813, 0.02010096237063408, 0.003374760504812002, 0.03781319409608841, -0.00034516488085500896, 0.0042087119072675705, 0.04062347114086151, -0.003997058141976595, 0.027984341606497765, -0.029889851808547974, -0.013015640899538994, -0.027986064553260803, 0.013927670195698738, 0.040414705872535706, 0.03318704664707184, 0.020051809027791023, -0.026505175977945328, -0.024073898792266846, -0.017699332907795906, -0.03347833827137947, 0.009464741684496403, -0.010182523168623447, -0.04382707178592682, -0.01667245849967003, -0.04145341366529465, -0.03696442395448685, 0.03007235936820507, 0.03436196967959404, -0.0009707175777293742, 0.010770926252007484, -0.019633987918496132, -0.021260544657707214, -0.052859533578157425, -0.04006272554397583, 0.004256883170455694, 0.008260685950517654, -0.031061183661222458, 0.03165889158844948, 0.003129068296402693, -0.012602931819856167, 0.019807247444987297, -0.06838397681713104, -0.011460020206868649, -0.043732207268476486, -0.028979981318116188, 0.00885187741369009, 0.005303665064275265, 0.05805104598402977, 0.009616000577807426, -0.02371097356081009, -0.0013740367721766233, -0.058496274054050446, -0.028308667242527008, 0.016093550249934196, -0.005466669797897339, 0.0011352278525009751, 0.016098497435450554, -0.023596012964844704, 0.06740104407072067, 0.017553461715579033, -0.029949072748422623, -0.01660868525505066, 0.0016903459327295423, -0.02437007986009121, -0.05875879153609276, -0.0022119064815342426, 0.019977355375885963, 0.014486565254628658, 0.012209238484501839, -0.01732962764799595, 0.012995155528187752, 0.0189155712723732, 0.006211678963154554, 0.030632788315415382, -0.004741891752928495, -0.016113463789224625, -0.0028542664367705584, 0.011906801722943783, 0.02274206466972828, 0.013284263201057911, 0.017507445067167282, -0.0014168258057907224, 0.04397083446383476, 0.017920488491654396, -0.037742435932159424, 0.021439161151647568, -0.014837593771517277, 0.0012583797797560692, -0.0340772345662117, 0.030973974615335464, -0.015143558382987976, 0.005271476227790117, -0.014543564058840275, -0.017360663041472435, 0.018254272639751434, -0.010831203311681747, 0.0040060607716441154, -0.005358681548386812, 0.011534788645803928, -0.025005949661135674, -0.015485342592000961, 0.010494104586541653, -0.012944065034389496, 0.01089053601026535, -0.003128361189737916, -0.021220991387963295, 0.06478480249643326, 0.042273640632629395, -0.0041509526781737804, -0.011832372285425663, -0.05275082588195801, 0.026887748390436172, -0.05726531147956848, 0.014944798313081264, 0.02534162998199463, 0.005102804861962795, -0.01146569661796093, 0.05030499026179314, 0.005185521673411131, -0.005162721499800682, 0.027389802038669586, -0.01447368785738945, -0.04457870498299599, 0.03635335713624954, -0.0234543364495039, -0.04971868544816971, -0.004031235817819834, -0.03933580592274666, 0.023457659408450127, -0.06833826005458832, 0.006602014880627394, -0.0026350999251008034, -0.008585457690060139, -0.021002644672989845, -0.0002661788312252611, 0.006223942153155804, 0.001192256691865623, -0.014860130846500397, -0.015388126485049725, 0.005325799807906151, -0.015033876523375511, 0.003161114174872637, 0.01135967392474413, 0.030781438574194908, -0.0367991141974926, -0.04376644641160965, 0.011098561808466911, 0.05595431476831436, 0.023183928802609444, 0.04108913987874985, 0.012137054465711117, -0.05994584783911705, 0.05033175274729729, 0.014666114933788776, 0.0668039321899414, 0.03145606070756912, 0.005277857184410095, -0.023864056915044785, -0.05383020639419556, -0.029608499258756638, 0.004762956872582436, 0.009207680821418762, 0.0022000952158123255, 0.004592834040522575, 0.05274951085448265, 0.043582238256931305, -0.04584768787026405, 0.010591343976557255, 0.06603263318538666, 0.04708476364612579, 0.038110021501779556, -0.045436982065439224, 0.014883892610669136, -0.004028430674225092, 0.007826250046491623, 0.01925596036016941, -0.005013549234718084, 0.019747614860534668, 0.03228219226002693, 0.05587117373943329, -0.012899198569357395, -0.029684627428650856, -0.009106622077524662, 0.03663203865289688, 0.06926704198122025, 0.018695106729865074, -0.013209313154220581, 0.048677824437618256, 0.05986039713025093, 0.0278413537889719, 0.033630553632974625, 0.006564112845808268, -0.12558497488498688, 0.02653243951499462, 0.013675836846232414, 0.011001823469996452, -0.04943077266216278, -0.044311828911304474, -0.0350724421441555, 0.006416885647922754, 0.03567524254322052, -0.005936793051660061, 0.046842433512210846, -0.023614412173628807, 0.026881899684667587, -0.015998251736164093, -0.025064978748559952, -0.049757931381464005, 0.03419403359293938, -0.025834647938609123, 0.039600927382707596, -0.012374146841466427, -0.026717200875282288, -0.030848369002342224, -0.0069125499576330185, 0.003061725990846753, 0.05457337200641632, -0.04094860330224037, -0.013680767267942429, 0.037291593849658966, 0.05638659745454788, -0.024917159229516983, -0.07968270033597946, -0.025768624618649483, 0.021204981952905655, -0.016675671562552452, 0.03633540868759155, -0.021515872329473495, 0.0009589928085915744, 0.00962730310857296, 0.012564481236040592, -0.024016663432121277, -0.05611731484532356, -0.02378002367913723, 0.025707460939884186, 0.04016018658876419, -0.011358441784977913, 0.08891598880290985, 0.029900847002863884, -0.020256154239177704, -0.02721434086561203, -0.03837656229734421, 0.03243403136730194, -0.02061012014746666, -0.019626284018158913, -0.03506043925881386, 0.004634495824575424, 0.002826959127560258, 0.004790510982275009, 0.008381156250834465, 0.021723689511418343, 0.009363721124827862, -0.020701829344034195, 0.0002496610104572028, 0.03358539193868637, -0.009113804437220097, -0.026966648176312447, 0.0009107918594963849, 0.027385542169213295, -0.025463277474045753, -0.02445591427385807, -0.00392557680606842, 0.000018081182133755647, 0.035247381776571274, 0.023500682786107063, -0.003610883839428425, 0.015619568526744843, -0.025355679914355278, -0.025178825482726097, 0.02082383632659912, -0.032231833785772324, 0.008886448107659817, -0.014110908843576908, -0.01134178601205349, -0.017077166587114334, -0.05527940392494202, 0.0013141731033101678, 0.035173624753952026, -0.024093979969620705, 0.0103369215503335, -0.040358733385801315, 0.0422537662088871, -0.014829921536147594, 0.02435431070625782, -0.056189630180597305, -0.0539841428399086, 0.01070556789636612, -0.014086488634347916, -0.02279072068631649, -0.030788488686084747, -0.02158709429204464, -0.001518774195574224, -0.04446481540799141, -0.0013817819999530911, 0.05229577794671059, -0.031277455389499664, -0.052225496619939804, -0.02144293114542961, 0.00554257957264781, 0.03788341209292412, -0.02882923185825348, -0.028877925127744675, 0.003540409728884697, -0.04196273535490036, -0.0035296855494379997, -0.010609649121761322, 0.0016797141870483756, -0.035725172609090805, 0.0420951209962368, -0.03387141227722168, -0.003909130115061998, 0.03069651499390602, -0.01607966423034668, 0.01013184804469347, -0.011595211923122406, 0.0274555254727602, 0.002538061933591962, -0.0064954860135912895, 0.008108651265501976, -0.045665860176086426, -0.004323706962168217, -0.0073853591457009315, -0.0030355695635080338, -0.016562964767217636, -0.0018240601057186723, 0.07797861099243164, 0.0007346873753704131, 0.005595494993031025, 0.012689641676843166, 0.07147589325904846, -0.010229021310806274, 0.008196843788027763, -0.029671983793377876, -0.019687654450535774, 0.04406072944402695, 0.04099993035197258, 0.0017518175300210714, -0.0032076253555715084, 0.02186434529721737, -0.041996028274297714, -0.003444999223574996, -0.04188092425465584, 0.010036410763859749, 0.08083100616931915, -0.027889756485819817, 0.04918379709124565, 0.058371737599372864, 0.013104875572025776, 0.004643334075808525, -0.0453244112432003, -0.029360946267843246, 0.008103717118501663, -0.030811430886387825, 0.05050819367170334, 0.02976452000439167, -0.02161659672856331, 0.015822065994143486, 0.021937374025583267, 0.006910724099725485, 0.020864995196461678, 0.011199228465557098, 0.029892371967434883, 0.02447175234556198, 0.01147637888789177, -0.04868701100349426, 0.0519157312810421, -0.019423048943281174, 0.0023989363107830286, -0.02353721484541893, -0.026924069970846176, 0.04312144219875336, 0.026907997205853462, 0.013788964599370956, -0.06231505423784256, -0.008522474206984043, -0.03214108943939209, 0.005802496336400509, -0.0058251554146409035, -0.024503882974386215, 0.010749771259725094, 0.021964499726891518, 0.012772588059306145, -0.020216457545757294, 0.008068596944212914, -0.00870934035629034, -0.07044979929924011, -0.04098321497440338, -0.017247987911105156, -0.008203276433050632, 0.013648470863699913, 0.0025045659858733416, -0.02583170123398304, 0.022339943796396255, -0.033669568598270416, 0.005738702602684498, 0.01478702761232853, 0.03539951518177986, -0.004099844954907894, 0.06082427501678467, -0.005889399442821741, 0.021928725764155388, -0.024431629106402397, -0.025757208466529846, 0.11711546033620834, 0.11588089913129807, 0.021286651492118835, -0.10060801357030869, 0.0026351013220846653, -0.01966210827231407, -0.018246905878186226, -0.03557565063238144, 0.01874120719730854, 0.034323614090681076, 0.015994945541024208, 0.014120768755674362, 0.03647656738758087, 0.03136804699897766, -0.00176252203527838, 0.03909533843398094, -0.03663041070103645, -0.042936746031045914, 0.03441784530878067, -0.013772540725767612, -0.009022618643939495, -0.017548397183418274, -0.0760616734623909, -0.029953893274068832, 0.009349205531179905, -0.034181736409664154, -0.006304844282567501, -0.011606764048337936, 0.023449471220374107, 0.017890578135848045, -0.03180747106671333, 0.02334144152700901, 0.003491541836410761, -0.0053128888830542564, -0.03878344967961311, 0.004529590252786875, 0.022707205265760422, -0.017239732667803764, -0.008790693245828152, 0.009279482997953892, -0.0074029117822647095, 0.004430647473782301, -0.01066109910607338, -0.009053054265677929, -0.039283670485019684, -0.005427455995231867, -0.0362117663025856, 0.03739959001541138, -0.02103513479232788, -0.019153840839862823, -0.012149904854595661, 0.027070775628089905, 0.012458670884370804, -0.002706012688577175, -0.009828586131334305, 0.021026423200964928, 0.009841068647801876, 0.00013704641605727375, -0.0048499805852770805, -0.027934784069657326, -0.002894698642194271, 0.00454596895724535, 0.030737055465579033, 0.03916645050048828, -0.03786094859242439, 0.02509562484920025, -0.018478557467460632, 0.05078495293855667, -0.002765650162473321, -0.011135443113744259, 0.008183038793504238, 0.009904528968036175, -0.028445683419704437, -0.02902991883456707, 0.053498897701501846, 0.02221863903105259, 0.020740795880556107, -0.0037959888577461243, -0.00031822934397496283, -0.008813198655843735, -0.08165804296731949, 0.0259645264595747, 0.0040187225677073, -0.024398047477006912, -0.05708274990320206, 0.013072192668914795, 0.029246004298329353, 0.052639950066804886, 0.038220517337322235, 0.015850981697440147, -0.0073320213705301285, 0.02732744626700878, 0.0036498503759503365, -0.05471742898225784, -0.03604867681860924, 0.02064753882586956, -0.03611847013235092, 0.0019914943259209394, -0.010980131104588509, 0.08095931261777878, 0.040505990386009216, 0.015402136370539665, -0.01813707873225212, 0.024372173473238945, -0.009991217404603958, 0.025306591764092445, 0.020075509324669838, -0.05518205463886261, -0.004357791505753994, 0.002503917785361409, 0.007424139883369207, -0.05902421101927757, -0.05154997855424881, -0.01628349907696247, -0.05749386548995972, 0.01821543462574482, 0.004167675506323576, -0.04318069666624069, 0.011610595509409904, -0.011360302567481995, 0.02171150967478752, -0.003210607450455427, -0.021176684647798538, -0.06079372018575668, -0.01223756279796362, -0.0007340286392718554, -0.0036653191782534122, 0.02287803590297699, -0.028096787631511688, -0.007832827046513557, 0.04059779271483421, 0.02318725548684597, 0.015599965117871761, 0.01742427982389927, 0.0006813343497924507, 0.028254114091396332, -0.0025190969463437796, 0.026929344981908798, -0.05062320828437805, -0.03164847195148468, 0.03922858089208603, -0.01842780038714409, -0.03266390785574913, 0.029459035024046898, 0.017810124903917313, 0.04499506205320358, -0.01053796149790287, -0.012985097244381905, -0.022306174039840698, 0.047360289841890335, -0.031184878200292587, -0.03316777944564819, -0.02572932466864586, -0.034730471670627594, 0.016694314777851105, 0.012077920138835907, 0.011465536430478096, -0.0021488433703780174, 0.02139436826109886, 0.00011209784861421213, 0.03703320026397705, 0.022256776690483093, -0.01312255859375, -0.008177029900252819, 0.0029008511919528246, 0.026027025654911995, -0.011077217757701874, 0.0022629781160503626, -0.015320404432713985, 0.011237815022468567, -0.03472209349274635, 0.01918765902519226, 0.03670203313231468, -0.005797382444143295, -0.07071932405233383, -0.02059854380786419, 0.00924922339618206, -0.008151206187903881, 0.026050908491015434, -0.040623988956213, 0.03133896365761757, 0.04153558239340782, -0.03318877890706062, 0.001475576777011156, -0.014504754915833473, -0.01357538066804409, -0.04272150248289108, -0.0018979522865265608, 0.007868302054703236, 0.024826806038618088, 0.022472839802503586, -0.006312056910246611, 0.0024129527155309916, 0.006110013462603092, 0.03870605304837227, -0.025980498641729355, 0.007483653258532286, -0.004271448589861393, 0.007919044233858585, -0.04321785643696785, 0.02224848046898842, -0.016113173216581345, -0.02580287680029869, 0.04563590884208679, 0.0009116692817769945, -0.002033431548625231, 0.013823186978697777, 0.042306866496801376, -0.016378197818994522, 0.01836530864238739, 0.017080098390579224, 0.014617147855460644, 0.004822282586246729, -0.004283793270587921, 0.03205415979027748, 0.032069459557533264, -0.02627399191260338, -0.0021937331184744835, -0.04629836976528168, -0.02477729320526123, -0.032927703112363815, 0.030996331945061684, -0.01308394130319357, 0.005615745205432177, 0.036829929798841476, 0.006403949111700058, 0.0212282482534647, -0.053183089941740036, 0.02767418697476387, -0.0427866131067276, 0.006903917994350195, 0.036644574254751205, 0.006206884980201721, -0.029704218730330467, 0.014972143806517124, -0.015986977145075798, -0.018302397802472115, 0.023819437250494957, -0.0030177112203091383, -0.01543557457625866, -0.09092788398265839, 0.011365070007741451, 0.0002794194733723998, -0.06252409517765045, -0.03606633096933365, -0.02460625395178795, -0.02170172892510891, 0.06152023747563362, -0.0008305216324515641, -0.014902931638062, -0.007140330504626036, -0.08272174000740051, -0.00829579122364521, -0.07915839552879333, 0.10572708398103714, 0.02728358656167984, -0.017968257889151573, -0.007371479645371437, 0.005394441541284323, -0.04760671406984329, -0.00846922304481268, 0.03596987947821617, 0.032512933015823364, -0.016132844612002373, -0.012030783109366894, 0.025225892663002014, -0.006426941603422165, -0.029173506423830986, 0.054646480828523636, 0.02124655432999134, -0.028020473197102547, -0.013625431805849075, -0.022714639082551003, -0.03681780397891998, 0.004191131796687841, -0.010291635990142822, 0.007198495324701071, 0.027705876156687737, 0.014689232222735882, 0.0026370901614427567, 0.023639732971787453, 0.040856584906578064, 0.020785341039299965, 0.06232612580060959, 0.024004677310585976, 0.0016550155123695731, 0.04193289577960968, 0.010477813892066479, -0.0812080055475235, 0.010377991013228893, -0.020792178809642792, 0.043881382793188095, -0.046861521899700165, -0.01291160099208355, 0.013400017283856869, -0.04937358945608139, 0.012981977313756943, -0.016758428886532784, -0.020406970754265785, -0.010700388811528683, 0.0175339262932539, 0.009342383593320847, 0.033376291394233704, -0.012654926627874374, 0.02416289784014225, -0.031488511711359024, 0.008865726180374622, 0.015503610484302044, -0.0020208326168358326, 0.040059056133031845, 0.004406783729791641, 0.03446551412343979, 0.040578145533800125, -0.007166024297475815, 0.05060010030865669, -0.016128413379192352, 0.05319197103381157, -0.0463666208088398, -0.025640958920121193, -0.026149285957217216, -0.02795090526342392, 0.028666947036981583, -0.019481226801872253, -0.008519787341356277, 0.03445005789399147, -0.05285930633544922, 0.01076897419989109, -0.024271851405501366, -0.009367959573864937, 0.01383821852505207, -0.024078266695141792, -0.004290207754820585, 0.03387381136417389, 0.017901938408613205, 0.01689298264682293, 0.006711781024932861, -0.005322280805557966, 0.020618220791220665, -0.0023899918887764215, 0.036907631903886795, 0.009986376389861107, -0.013249047100543976, -0.03113779053092003, -0.019081030040979385, -0.005385545548051596, -0.03450735658407211, 0.014504186809062958, 0.06181061267852783, 0.035309650003910065, -0.0489664189517498, -0.03774402663111687, -0.016515320166945457, 0.02271692082285881, -0.08458653092384338, -0.03263656422495842, -0.03824707120656967, 0.023636536672711372, 0.0034668794833123684, -0.013190426863729954 ]
<p>A person is trying to claim that psychics exist by flipping a coin 10 times for each person behind a screen. n=10 p=1/2 Its created into a one tailed test with significance level at .001. The first 999 people do not get enough right to reject the null hypothesis. But the 1000th person gets all 10 right. if Y is the number of people out of 1000 who get all 10 coin flips right, would the distribution of y be binomial too?</p> <p>Probability that one or more of the 1000 people would correctly guess 10 coin flips?</p>
74,388
[ -0.031355977058410645, -0.0686081275343895, 0.008615141734480858, -0.03398159146308899, 0.0697450116276741, -0.02072393149137497, 0.005365163553506136, 0.008173150010406971, 0.004195916932076216, -0.03167874738574028, 0.0882096141576767, 0.04117036983370781, 0.018576733767986298, 0.026227205991744995, 0.022564617916941643, 0.04928942024707794, -0.02454185299575329, 0.04818727821111679, 0.01890254020690918, -0.023684877902269363, 0.013096502050757408, 0.010562371462583542, 0.01322499942034483, 0.027113569900393486, -0.04927552491426468, -0.0006997405434958637, 0.03539364039897919, 0.004751109983772039, 0.03779938071966171, 0.06428536027669907, -0.04876603186130524, -0.028117584064602852, 0.012749586254358292, 0.031103400513529778, 0.010108577087521553, -0.018096711486577988, -0.02469904161989689, -0.017746618017554283, -0.023609228432178497, 0.0017289560055360198, 0.010222586803138256, 0.02279270812869072, 0.023201867938041687, 0.03995902091264725, -0.014217676594853401, -0.03153189271688461, 0.0043592434376478195, -0.04302430525422096, 0.027741117402911186, -0.05350003391504288, 0.06075340881943703, -0.005970834754407406, 0.010149883106350899, 0.01384111400693655, 0.00926972460001707, -0.013002852909266949, 0.06443644315004349, 0.05582081899046898, -0.018341045826673508, -0.08731929957866669, -0.011818230152130127, -0.05162537097930908, 0.006491499487310648, 0.00923912227153778, -0.030230697244405746, 0.014438129030168056, -0.01807257905602455, -0.026446787640452385, 0.01067475974559784, 0.0005399563815444708, 0.04315945506095886, 0.04400818422436714, 0.06553027778863907, 0.0071900091134011745, 0.005671340506523848, -0.010825272649526596, 0.010038584470748901, -0.014757686294615269, 0.057108182460069656, 0.03341815620660782, 0.03128699213266373, 0.03460107371211052, 0.0262087881565094, 0.04829759523272514, 0.04616844654083252, 0.001946937758475542, 0.0774666965007782, -0.02667113021016121, 0.03818419203162193, 0.03518916293978691, -0.003221870167180896, -0.036438826471567154, 0.06644337624311447, 0.002341607818379998, -0.04671521857380867, 0.019691389054059982, -0.02920997142791748, 0.05131220445036888, 0.02859586663544178, -0.039434853941202164, -0.008016648702323437, -0.030053311958909035, 0.01769666001200676, 0.05220591649413109, -0.026857538148760796, -0.014955508522689342, -0.037261348217725754, 0.009236115030944347, -0.04197912663221359, -0.011291571892797947, 0.009277245961129665, 0.06672293692827225, 0.025843922048807144, 0.024754654616117477, 0.00816990528255701, -0.004769138526171446, 0.004833388142287731, -0.011168943718075752, 0.05906474590301514, 0.015183591283857822, 0.038205571472644806, 0.008128042332828045, -0.0012243924429640174, 0.013286714442074299, -0.02070322073996067, 0.013587553054094315, -0.024863461032509804, -0.016641147434711456, -0.08095961064100266, 0.045073915272951126, -0.02239895612001419, -0.014278300106525421, 0.054785460233688354, -0.009822498075664043, 0.03710510954260826, -0.02419753186404705, -0.10685750097036362, -0.025910237804055214, -0.02734001912176609, -0.023876294493675232, 0.027118302881717682, -0.03766966238617897, 0.03091290220618248, 0.008800731971859932, 0.03249465301632881, -0.028357485309243202, 0.0478610023856163, -0.0314471535384655, 0.03158579021692276, -0.007287178188562393, -0.017131227999925613, -0.0017321213381364942, -0.019274890422821045, -0.034259602427482605, 0.004205727018415928, -0.08561761677265167, 0.05311102047562599, 0.019258378073573112, -0.032388560473918915, -0.060152869671583176, -0.0012817117385566235, 0.01923995092511177, 0.005076272878795862, -0.05834459140896797, 0.002689461689442396, -0.00031186165870167315, 0.07945307344198227, 0.03367528319358826, 0.03857124596834183, 0.0401114784181118, -0.026308000087738037, 0.06876308470964432, -0.005714563187211752, 0.04602152854204178, 0.005479432642459869, -0.05993323028087616, 0.015104261226952076, -0.02991778962314129, 0.04625312611460686, 0.024245260283350945, -0.003409741912037134, -0.0003408860065974295, -0.026107870042324066, -0.005409084260463715, 0.003498983336612582, -0.010807933285832405, 0.000052916002459824085, -0.010774923488497734, 0.02216283045709133, -0.039473652839660645, -0.039433855563402176, -0.04519603028893471, -0.009090295992791653, 0.009496474638581276, -0.016288308426737785, 0.028098145499825478, 0.010959161445498466, 0.01891321875154972, -0.02278369478881359, 0.024419663473963737, -0.05702221393585205, -0.007055714726448059, 0.05850943177938461, -0.033681802451610565, -0.00523650785908103, 0.08358193933963776, 0.026320472359657288, -0.013469129800796509, 0.045459285378456116, -0.046766944229602814, -0.024749167263507843, -0.015939466655254364, 0.0037909881211817265, 0.040533412247896194, 0.03357373923063278, -0.003657363122329116, 0.0441061407327652, 0.033916424959897995, -0.033816106617450714, 0.050937727093696594, -0.054831765592098236, 0.027853604406118393, 0.05455489084124565, -0.00026409130077809095, 0.015748146921396255, 0.011705495417118073, 0.0024299765937030315, -0.00953668262809515, -0.004209974780678749, -0.02797868102788925, -0.09702582657337189, -0.0009310672176070511, 0.03865321725606918, 0.023151446133852005, -0.038929179310798645, 0.011468353681266308, 0.04692578688263893, 0.03383812680840492, 0.023652231320738792, 0.004237821325659752, -0.018416190519928932, -0.023368187248706818, -0.031400468200445175, 0.0183030366897583, -0.0019752676598727703, 0.021264979615807533, 0.041669197380542755, -0.031107962131500244, 0.015509123913943768, 0.009733893908560276, -0.015208751894533634, 0.004306151065975428, 0.004503408446907997, 0.012359554879367352, 0.003412444842979312, 0.00556870037689805, 0.03347449377179146, -0.031812019646167755, -0.017810514196753502, 0.012013572268188, -0.001077501685358584, -0.009724828414618969, -0.00925163459032774, -0.036427970975637436, 0.024380674585700035, 0.010363190434873104, -0.036159075796604156, -0.01607794500887394, 0.025978783145546913, -0.05674077942967415, -0.024858610704541206, 0.0017193619860336185, -0.024889519438147545, -0.022225329652428627, 0.02307451330125332, 0.023546449840068817, 0.035595472902059555, 0.029326744377613068, -0.01819908805191517, -0.03844771906733513, 0.026097875088453293, -0.018433617427945137, -0.011711175553500652, -0.0323600210249424, -0.08993621915578842, -0.01522171963006258, -0.030037647113204002, -0.017705261707305908, 0.031100401654839516, -0.012129880487918854, 0.000024170005417545326, 0.02578086405992508, -0.01695128343999386, -0.00581077067181468, 0.015667354688048363, -0.02830532379448414, 0.013480107299983501, -0.050183240324258804, -0.01796977035701275, 0.0323842391371727, 0.046212535351514816, -0.045224905014038086, 0.039203304797410965, -0.04648502171039581, -0.0591522753238678, -0.021686814725399017, -0.02323288843035698, 0.017469318583607674, -0.004849129356443882, 0.005883991252630949, -0.009434853680431843, 0.0029759530443698168, 0.012844654731452465, -0.05929676815867424, -0.1048751175403595, -0.006182945799082518, -0.01403337623924017, 0.04673616588115692, -0.000219897017814219, -0.004196069203317165, 0.07356622815132141, 0.04886511340737343, -0.0012914019171148539, -0.025443408638238907, 0.02676200307905674, -0.018486585468053818, -0.033494770526885986, 0.04173329472541809, -0.001638817135244608, -0.028393065556883812, 0.026109619066119194, -0.003195123514160514, -0.008724026381969452, 0.037535425275564194, -0.011216412298381329, -0.0320143848657608, 0.026948314160108566, 0.009370669722557068, 0.013051336631178856, 0.01158279087394476, 0.00697765126824379, -0.036167800426483154, 0.02531816065311432, -0.020149949938058853, 0.02044363133609295, -0.01476268656551838, 0.01756388321518898, 0.06456665694713593, -0.02395455166697502, 0.02928595431149006, -0.029444921761751175, 0.01955311931669712, -0.018192313611507416, -0.04517711326479912, 0.020944170653820038, 0.013417095877230167, 0.04992932081222534, -0.0009845016757026315, 0.009557886980473995, 0.032683584839105606, 0.009525896981358528, -0.013671492226421833, -0.04879311844706535, -0.0074494075961411, -0.015939688310027122, 0.02042577974498272, -0.04139571636915207, -0.019101541489362717, 0.023498566821217537, 0.0442369319498539, 0.05170448496937752, -0.01250444632023573, -0.010618853382766247, 0.005283246748149395, -0.034765779972076416, 0.0016789165092632174, -0.005958665627986193, 0.03277800604701042, -0.013198409229516983, 0.035159360617399216, 0.020994797348976135, -0.011010128073394299, -0.023400047793984413, 0.022613607347011566, -0.04583624005317688, 0.03696785494685173, -0.006489476654678583, -0.0004836836305912584, -0.010293558239936829, -0.0019322932930663228, 0.02212909236550331, -0.02914535067975521, 0.065623939037323, 0.014669609256088734, 0.017068104818463326, -0.032794199883937836, -0.012827510945498943, 0.007574093993753195, -0.027086298912763596, 0.0070075360126793385, 0.028829528018832207, -0.018632253631949425, 0.018607232719659805, 0.032366298139095306, 0.025649908930063248, -0.0032776985317468643, 0.011845440603792667, -0.026847245171666145, 0.009234347380697727, 0.03731631860136986, 0.05516766011714935, 0.0077970908023417, 0.0039766994304955006, -0.029754703864455223, 0.01584363915026188, -0.008290247060358524, 0.043075911700725555, 0.062148597091436386, -0.0024681834038347006, -0.03288235887885094, -0.06401149183511734, -0.01346938032656908, -0.010756775736808777, 0.014595198445022106, -0.004560402594506741, -0.02698565274477005, 0.054116569459438324, 0.022154446691274643, -0.022204749286174774, 0.015036270022392273, 0.039423808455467224, -0.02914842776954174, 0.006062618922442198, 0.0023927197325974703, 0.03819328173995018, 0.002487897640094161, 0.002113557420670986, -0.030146144330501556, 0.04281690716743469, -0.023847607895731926, 0.0032961880788207054, 0.05170188844203949, -0.023641852661967278, -0.032193150371313095, 0.03571881353855133, 0.025806451216340065, 0.0530356802046299, -0.0045907264575362206, -0.035027697682380676, 0.01230076514184475, 0.04397350922226906, -0.00006407104956451803, -0.004421025048941374, -0.06150055304169655, -0.04003499075770378, 0.02173461765050888, 0.06389965862035751, 0.06886686384677887, -0.029395252466201782, -0.008128946647047997, -0.035218723118305206, 0.019848397001624107, 0.018992077559232712, -0.053667571395635605, 0.018729791045188904, -0.008557482622563839, 0.028887812048196793, 0.006066547706723213, -0.032281797379255295, -0.062447238713502884, 0.011823680251836777, -0.028853652998805046, 0.04228384792804718, -0.043105900287628174, -0.016162140294909477, -0.049148861318826675, 0.006739898584783077, 0.024306608363986015, 0.05247962474822998, -0.04522257298231125, 0.009453988634049892, 0.0017432733438909054, -0.004799454007297754, 0.010136243887245655, -0.06216181069612503, 0.041528284549713135, -0.026596160605549812, -0.012008046731352806, 0.047058962285518646, -0.009527408517897129, -0.04673173278570175, 0.007027381099760532, -0.011792751960456371, -0.017339548096060753, 0.011579181998968124, -0.026660272851586342, 0.05237537622451782, 0.04854057356715202, 0.02988310717046261, 0.011831529438495636, 0.02889399789273739, -0.029285548254847527, 0.016935257241129875, -0.026891998946666718, -0.018849460408091545, 0.012066705152392387, 0.027527209371328354, -0.033480532467365265, 0.014232940040528774, -0.025367239490151405, 0.04444117099046707, -0.00900204386562109, -0.016686270013451576, -0.016568690538406372, -0.0411185622215271, -0.03677596151828766, 0.004747290629893541, 0.026367980986833572, 0.01341948937624693, -0.029317589476704597, -0.02753736823797226, -0.002996720839291811, 0.010799011215567589, 0.011466390453279018, -0.009853738360106945, 0.015841728076338768, 0.009222650900483131, 0.01134948618710041, -0.012589182704687119, -0.08727970719337463, -0.025965731590986252, 0.018825596198439598, -0.04205475002527237, 0.05447743460536003, -0.014849705621600151, 0.06872764229774475, 0.016809703782200813, -0.04729391261935234, -0.01928870379924774, -0.004047765862196684, -0.008059990592300892, 0.007658758200705051, -0.023552672937512398, -0.014400053769350052, -0.00967472605407238, 0.00782053917646408, -0.06351529061794281, -0.011018372140824795, 0.014621713198721409, 0.005801295395940542, -0.013856555335223675, -0.010326310992240906, -0.012814144603908062, -0.03338631987571716, -0.014093301258981228, -0.007829240523278713, -0.01965789496898651, -0.005877068266272545, 0.0010065861279144883, 0.006842324510216713, -0.03180066868662834, 0.08563612401485443, 0.007483466062694788, -0.04729269817471504, 0.03642408549785614, -0.024742046371102333, 0.0031666357535868883, -0.026320021599531174, 0.010361638851463795, -0.01664041168987751, 0.0026339644100517035, -0.005914018955081701, -0.007486672606319189, 0.05035040155053139, -0.06653887778520584, -0.017366880550980568, 0.028716856613755226, -0.01219169981777668, 0.01946130022406578, -0.028757566586136818, 0.015355897136032581, -0.008476748131215572, 0.0002661330217961222, -0.009949000552296638, -0.01913810707628727, 0.020184341818094254, 0.010285601019859314, 0.03212408721446991, 0.04682808741927147, -0.018812600523233414, 0.02930399775505066, 0.08394692093133926, 0.00225357199087739, -0.030261442065238953, -0.018373960629105568, -0.026128284633159637, 0.013599438592791557, -0.00019454500579740852, -0.021799417212605476, 0.008194321766495705, 0.030980302020907402, -0.019255928695201874, -0.0033947748597711325, -0.0277631226927042, 0.012653927318751812, 0.014373475685715675, 0.048194121569395065, -0.0017068802844733, -0.024200279265642166, -0.0006920943269506097, 0.0024002594873309135, -0.021540474146604538, 0.0007645813748240471, -0.019574938341975212, 0.016637174412608147, 0.03566807508468628, 0.020970160141587257, 0.017024246975779533, 0.05237210541963577, 0.05138804018497467, 0.020242176949977875, 0.05504355579614639, 0.019693648442626, 0.02080603316426277, 0.03723520785570145, -0.018015487119555473, -0.0194484181702137, 0.047894418239593506, -0.053327687084674835, 0.026674671098589897, -0.016464661806821823, -0.019427811726927757, 0.03926139324903488, 0.01382099837064743, 0.024404991418123245, -0.01651460863649845, -0.01878235675394535, -0.03430500254034996, -0.01666938327252865, 0.03090761788189411, 0.06767909973859787, 0.012416858226060867, -0.023899665102362633, 0.027283035218715668, 0.022056201472878456, 0.044435229152441025, -0.015283513814210892, -0.03867622837424278, -0.049906179308891296, 0.022417087107896805, -0.039931654930114746, 0.00048573751701042056, 0.0040803225710988045, 0.006910234689712524, 0.036731842905282974, -0.02020617388188839, 0.018993083387613297, 0.01290811225771904, 0.042822714895009995, -0.006535501219332218, 0.07301715761423111, 0.02466142550110817, 0.055417418479919434, -0.008020234294235706, -0.0007594594499096274, 0.11083056777715683, 0.05480481684207916, 0.030175449326634407, -0.025451818481087685, 0.005183313973248005, -0.03687826544046402, 0.010613683611154556, 0.012843848206102848, 0.011585035361349583, 0.0040788790211081505, 0.007595550734549761, 0.07361063361167908, 0.023093899711966515, -0.01399068720638752, 0.008675862103700638, 0.02829628810286522, -0.028432292863726616, -0.034451719373464584, 0.008558659814298153, 0.01482508797198534, -0.049329496920108795, -0.019052835181355476, -0.04205235838890076, 0.01653321273624897, -0.014136053621768951, -0.03283447399735451, -0.009486275725066662, -0.00344610633328557, 0.00975906103849411, 0.010472540743649006, -0.00304811866953969, -0.001992239849641919, -0.006397073622792959, -0.03286227583885193, -0.016026264056563377, -0.01587030477821827, 0.022216971963644028, -0.03464293107390404, 0.03670407086610794, 0.02168477326631546, -0.006830117199569941, 0.012599372304975986, 0.007662879303097725, 0.012467785738408566, -0.055508121848106384, -0.010882570408284664, -0.012861314229667187, 0.042051054537296295, -0.03422505781054497, -0.032000914216041565, -0.01659446209669113, -0.02389674074947834, 0.030360016971826553, -0.03624975308775902, -0.025739463046193123, 0.03187921643257141, 0.011943156830966473, -0.020157556980848312, -0.05137850344181061, -0.02655406855046749, 0.004691322334110737, 0.009840024635195732, 0.03920384496450424, 0.011491898447275162, 0.002019153442233801, -0.053621310740709305, -0.0047956835478544235, 0.03561980649828911, 0.017378496006131172, -0.020876536145806313, -0.025945603847503662, -0.033811792731285095, -0.04202670976519585, -0.008650693111121655, 0.01390374731272459, -0.013186443597078323, 0.03598099574446678, 0.029675889760255814, -0.015772230923175812, -0.010948632843792439, -0.005259145051240921, 0.0036393599584698677, -0.028573833405971527, -0.0008610682561993599, -0.003098434302955866, -0.029843632131814957, 0.003277429612353444, 0.04063672944903374, -0.0281353872269392, -0.038780130445957184, -0.008672443218529224, 0.04212094470858574, -0.008953798562288284, -0.030529072508215904, -0.021162303164601326, -0.021440990269184113, -0.0252069141715765, -0.014798186719417572, -0.013189917430281639, 0.06742774695158005, 0.00860688742250204, 0.015802938491106033, 0.018821092322468758, -0.010985528118908405, -0.03058270551264286, 0.013771125115454197, -0.017452653497457504, -0.06376703828573227, -0.015626784414052963, 0.013435157015919685, -0.0032370169647037983, -0.03038194589316845, -0.05604704096913338, -0.011864393018186092, 0.020459314808249474, 0.04135905206203461, 0.0070211743004620075, -0.007698319386690855, -0.025961900129914284, 0.001621645293198526, -0.001973106060177088, -0.019190186634659767, -0.009180319495499134, -0.01853431761264801, -0.019531425088644028, -0.007343573030084372, -0.00931621715426445, 0.02251843735575676, -0.017420237883925438, 0.010350123979151249, -0.01620129682123661, 0.029472699388861656, -0.00046978305908851326, 0.0028021461330354214, -0.018817512318491936, 0.0064515299163758755, 0.0017370169516652822, 0.035364266484975815, -0.06362583488225937, 0.011907381936907768, 0.04154926910996437, -0.05668478459119797, -0.05566713958978653, 0.03924030810594559, 0.0010468318359926343, 0.053157154470682144, 0.04753447324037552, 0.009376165457069874, -0.023019911721348763, 0.007515686564147472, -0.04233846813440323, -0.012926715426146984, 0.023600751534104347, 0.003558017313480377, 0.027599385008215904, -0.009677175432443619, 0.023371689021587372, 0.0030775652267038822, -0.004420786630362272, 0.018200377002358437, 0.04843594506382942, 0.02356509491801262, -0.008326446637511253, 0.0013269918272271752, -0.00386561150662601, 0.007318652700632811, 0.010922303423285484, -0.03804038092494011, 0.006599268410354853, 0.023393644019961357, -0.03736061975359917, 0.06461974233388901, -0.062295157462358475, 0.022263817489147186, -0.08896990120410919, -0.05777440220117569, 0.004973617848008871, 0.006950812879949808, 0.03991449996829033, -0.05118492990732193, -0.008623690344393253, 0.010158774442970753, -0.05742601305246353, 0.015752270817756653, 0.012751988135278225, -0.03112100064754486, -0.06469674408435822, 0.05918869748711586, -0.00737134600058198, 0.030224574729800224, 0.05055490881204605, 0.03646961227059364, 0.015493077225983143, -0.0023039449006319046, -0.013292674906551838, -0.01773335598409176, -0.0076020765118300915, 0.00541849248111248, -0.0228696558624506, -0.04263351485133171, 0.04405108466744423, -0.04200427606701851, -0.026202436536550522, 0.05067120119929314, 0.0072112237103283405, 0.01744185760617256, -0.013277670368552208, 0.03075471892952919, 0.028121650218963623, 0.010384642519056797, 0.018207604065537453, -0.006219860166311264, 0.02680155448615551, 0.05549180507659912, 0.04253248870372772, 0.04963661730289459, 0.00013349638902582228, -0.06511029601097107, 0.018453076481819153, -0.012094591744244099, -0.01088595762848854, 0.018826937302947044, 0.027256108820438385, -0.024049028754234314, 0.0003435497637838125, 0.009407845325767994, -0.023300228640437126, -0.024944134056568146, 0.021765846759080887, -0.06270023435354233, -0.03206722065806389, 0.023038411512970924, 0.008276918902993202, -0.05334523320198059, 0.009474718011915684, -0.014463409781455994, -0.0757666677236557, 0.0013789990916848183, -0.007887709885835648, -0.02104330062866211, -0.01654033549129963, 0.017335109412670135, -0.004891118500381708, 0.04055306687951088, 0.04033130779862404, -0.02814340777695179, -0.03723996877670288, 0.009317668154835701, -0.019098572432994843, -0.004085115622729063, 0.0302403774112463, -0.02051500417292118, -0.027929693460464478, -0.07315918058156967, 0.05183754116296768, -0.0012527587823569775, 0.0004411545523907989, -0.054029665887355804, 0.01478077843785286, -0.02689138613641262, -0.018977660685777664, 0.05105934292078018, 0.0021907398477196693, -0.011615226976573467, 0.0007105396362021565, 0.007274816744029522, -0.007083815056830645, -0.0732254683971405, 0.001921537215821445, -0.011749235913157463, -0.04966086149215698, -0.043133001774549484, -0.004803466144949198, 0.020288366824388504, 0.005003844387829304, 0.017657049000263214, 0.014524753205478191, -0.0007499703788198531, 0.0016809620428830385, -0.03905804827809334, 0.034923188388347626, 0.0043897428549826145, 0.018907589837908745, 0.012050758115947247, 0.012791761197149754, 0.015246140770614147, -0.011360767297446728, 0.009943298064172268, -0.04584398865699768, 0.0069266268983483315, -0.028454838320612907, -0.015437046065926552, 0.000775773311033845, 0.010150198824703693, 0.011384123004972935, -0.06617230921983719, 0.0065111881121993065, 0.019143996760249138, -0.02187063731253147, -0.021532567217946053, 0.04374746233224869, 0.01316121406853199, 0.015337243676185608, -0.014891145750880241, 0.0217837356030941, -0.013819926418364048, -0.0018334517953917384, 0.0319669172167778, 0.028744203969836235, -0.030191069468855858, 0.00021467567421495914, 0.053513482213020325, 0.017129095271229744, 0.013899212703108788, 0.05516812950372696, 0.01829012669622898, 0.06379628926515579, -0.01094106025993824, 0.007780331186950207, 0.00906822457909584, -0.02128727175295353, -0.022638419643044472, 0.031228575855493546, 0.0039026548620313406, 0.07520315051078796, -0.04299527034163475, 0.0285151619464159, -0.011809424497187138, -0.0053766993805766106, 0.025115055963397026, -0.006885302718728781, 0.06385335326194763, 0.012218604795634747, -0.03600018844008446, -0.031930793076753616, 0.017098763957619667, 0.026881830766797066, 0.05072718486189842, -0.04978467524051666, 0.009141606278717518, -0.022744575515389442, -0.008976628072559834, -0.039894767105579376, -0.016499141231179237, -0.038146041333675385, -0.012470418587327003, 0.010832245461642742, 0.004409790970385075, 0.014455361291766167, -0.02450755424797535, -0.017012909054756165, 0.01942669227719307, 0.059195008128881454, -0.034420035779476166, -0.0007852580747567117, -0.016551606357097626, 0.047055963426828384, -0.00567989144474268, -0.0507754385471344 ]
<p>These are the values:</p> <pre><code>18.2 17.6 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 18.9 18.6 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 20 19.7 19.8 19.6 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 21.4 20.6 21 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 21.9 22.1 22.2 22.2 21.6 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 23.1 22.6 23.2 23 22.9 23.2 23.2 23 22.5 22.5 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 23.8 24.1 23.8 23.6 24.3 23.7 24 24.2 24.4 23.8 23.5 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 24.7 24.9 25 25.4 25.1 25.3 25.3 25.2 25.2 24.7 24.6 24.5 24.5 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 25.6 26 25.6 25.6 25.6 25.7 25.6 26.3 26.3 26.2 26 25.9 26.2 26 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 27 27.2 27 27.2 26.7 27 26.6 27.3 26.8 26.6 26.9 27 26.5 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 28.2 27.7 28.1 27.9 27.6 27.7 28.1 28.2 27.5 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 28.6 29.1 28.7 29.1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 30.3 29.6 29.7 29.5 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 30.9 31 31 30.5 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 32.3 31.6 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ </code></pre> <p><br></p> <p>These are the groups:</p> <pre><code> - 17.5 - 18.5 - 18.5 - 19.5 - 19.5 - 20.5 - 20.5 - 21.5 - 21.5 - 22.5 - 22.5 - 23.5 - 23.5 - 24.5 - 24.5 - 25.5 - 25.5 - 26.5 - 26.5 - 27.5 - 27.5 - 28.5 - 28.5 - 29.5 - 29.5 - 30.5 - 30.5 - 31.5 - 31.5 - 32.5 </code></pre> <p>I'm supposed to calculate the standard deviation and the expected value ... How is it different comparing to having only 15 values and not divided them into groups? If I only have 15 values, I know how to calculate the stand.deviation and the exp.value. I use the formulas that are well-known: </p> <pre><code>Exp.value: ............(1/n)*Sum(xi)..................where xi = all the 15 values &lt;br&gt; Stand.deviation: ...(1/(n-1))*Sum( xi - u)^2...where xi = all the 15 values and u = exp.value </code></pre>
49,053
[ -0.0012710881419479847, -0.010912349447607994, -0.01905800960958004, 0.036171115934848785, 0.04458175227046013, 0.011851510964334011, -0.0011253447737544775, -0.06575994193553925, -0.0004488210252020508, -0.028892766684293747, 0.051994889974594116, 0.01694050058722496, 0.02721250243484974, 0.045377377420663834, 0.017444882541894913, -0.0022802124731242657, -0.011389450170099735, -0.009156101383268833, 0.03900190070271492, -0.022793404757976532, 0.027607565745711327, 0.005978728644549847, 0.02660427615046501, 0.028228003531694412, -0.039744921028614044, 0.028205446898937225, 0.0399988554418087, 0.012644869275391102, -0.013961883261799812, 0.03091087006032467, -0.02932768687605858, -0.055133335292339325, 0.002384522929787636, 0.03391345590353012, -0.0007719463901594281, 0.00076104054460302, -0.022853076457977295, -0.04796886816620827, -0.02872074954211712, 0.034406501799821854, -0.01825479231774807, -0.014812100678682327, 0.010002072900533676, 0.028603795915842056, 0.025411315262317657, 0.02138376049697399, 0.006279113236814737, 0.02258484624326229, 0.03841479495167732, -0.024112364277243614, 0.06538162380456924, -0.0028496121522039175, 0.0370427742600441, 0.013642758131027222, -0.031150206923484802, -0.010116539895534515, 0.04213322699069977, 0.06919100135564804, -0.002048899419605732, -0.06540787220001221, 0.007924714125692844, -0.02705463394522667, 0.005246865097433329, -0.03412747010588646, -0.02427992783486843, 0.023645387962460518, -0.04867494851350784, -0.03250012546777725, -0.00760926678776741, -0.0399831086397171, -0.006149521563202143, 0.019823402166366577, 0.029800979420542717, -0.01926652528345585, 0.0195437204092741, -0.007533262949436903, 0.004422863479703665, 0.007146778982132673, 0.022211449220776558, 0.005987911950796843, 0.007205651141703129, -0.0077642700634896755, 0.014740575104951859, 0.018359636887907982, 0.03383488208055496, 0.014902698807418346, 0.04177940636873245, -0.025668896734714508, 0.023951951414346695, 0.0030494367238134146, 0.008592217229306698, -0.015478450804948807, 0.047494933009147644, 0.04763161018490791, 0.001653627143241465, 0.00391725217923522, 0.02351807989180088, 0.006432021502405405, -0.020492013543844223, -0.02161364071071148, 0.008527365513145924, -0.02788941189646721, -0.0036838797386735678, 0.029800886288285255, -0.016145192086696625, -0.013191226869821548, -0.033666979521512985, -0.0376102589070797, -0.00841909646987915, 0.0015196517342701554, 0.010974551551043987, 0.024057334288954735, -0.017373768612742424, -0.03563240170478821, -0.00006512190884677693, -0.04317759722471237, -0.024123353883624077, -0.015063095837831497, 0.029448185116052628, 0.047061044722795486, 0.049071211367845535, -0.007925323210656643, 0.007736071944236755, 0.006571678910404444, -0.09786021709442139, -0.004681591875851154, -0.02384595200419426, 0.006339314393699169, -0.02486586757004261, 0.020249556750059128, -0.03334060311317444, -0.0035441131331026554, 0.05339191481471062, -0.02215898223221302, 0.02949552610516548, 0.017934288829565048, -0.07140346616506577, -0.05010085925459862, 0.06416294723749161, -0.0386359728872776, 0.013132107444107533, -0.04218598082661629, 0.016289182007312775, -0.006009414792060852, 0.03904873505234718, 0.024512387812137604, 0.003034847555682063, 0.019290199503302574, -0.011070691049098969, 0.02994016744196415, -0.015837013721466064, 0.0017536879749968648, -0.0274281594902277, 0.00010141313396161422, -0.03997683525085449, -0.07514370232820511, -0.012617501430213451, -0.0002713181311264634, -0.023145318031311035, -0.0207322146743536, 0.03186469152569771, -0.025895267724990845, 0.017325179651379585, 0.014061756432056427, -0.0639968141913414, -0.04012961685657501, 0.0872216448187828, 0.06515085697174072, 0.02275150455534458, 0.01676960662007332, 0.015819355845451355, -0.0003176581230945885, -0.010208338499069214, -0.00893983244895935, 0.05012955144047737, 0.0015849004266783595, 0.030742023140192032, -0.030515331774950027, 0.02583492174744606, 0.056274957954883575, -0.04569714143872261, -0.04539842531085014, -0.018618080765008926, -0.0008659561281092465, 0.029847385361790657, 0.021819457411766052, 0.0002742819197010249, -0.04421277716755867, 0.04784597083926201, -0.0928608700633049, 0.0009520318126305938, -0.050476279109716415, 0.042761243879795074, -0.02535097859799862, -0.006653361022472382, -0.015649432316422462, 0.025303056463599205, 0.013458644039928913, 0.018093818798661232, 0.0051859160885214806, 0.00907742790877819, 0.015224884264171124, 0.06345464289188385, -0.03288668394088745, -0.00613737665116787, 0.045024748891592026, 0.03997429832816124, -0.003636956447735429, 0.04388740658760071, 0.022121012210845947, -0.0026235957629978657, 0.01257065124809742, -0.04723530262708664, 0.001988072879612446, -0.05156640335917473, -0.04370107501745224, -0.006867707706987858, 0.00025533352163620293, -0.001107036485336721, 0.012686474248766899, -0.08192875236272812, 0.08218760788440704, 0.04230881109833717, 0.051402315497398376, -0.016672013327479362, -0.011251319199800491, -0.0003242954844608903, 0.0752679705619812, -0.008368125185370445, -0.01463885884732008, -0.029225802049040794, 0.012247473001480103, 0.05850686877965927, 0.0034999733325093985, -0.04094269871711731, -0.02519761584699154, 0.09930736571550369, 0.006001025903970003, 0.010926641523838043, 0.045278798788785934, 0.013734860345721245, -0.002420083386823535, 0.05235695093870163, -0.002414541319012642, 0.0382179357111454, -0.013045413419604301, 0.0015543241752311587, 0.03461292013525963, 0.03326381370425224, -0.033784378319978714, 0.022968081757426262, 0.032570336014032364, -0.0009331254404969513, -0.0149161322042346, -0.04484952986240387, -0.03065226972103119, 0.05879036337137222, -0.016340702772140503, -0.0036328420974314213, 0.03696984425187111, 0.025178847834467888, -0.030801258981227875, 0.01264179963618517, -0.03535857051610947, 0.007757814135402441, 0.017869440838694572, -0.023417536169290543, -0.009294573217630386, 0.03581435605883598, -0.015404297970235348, 0.015131001360714436, -0.024143192917108536, -0.040250860154628754, -0.05924379453063011, -0.01388269942253828, 0.04753681272268295, 0.0021320858504623175, 0.018893377855420113, -0.021449526771903038, 0.004190872423350811, -0.03451165184378624, 0.0006047568167559803, 0.01849460043013096, -0.040094830095767975, -0.04107614606618881, 0.013179748319089413, 0.04092106223106384, -0.020897170528769493, 0.07490048557519913, 0.005180935375392437, -0.04765387624502182, 0.026457464322447777, -0.0034672061447054148, 0.0025185858830809593, -0.009954245761036873, -0.032182782888412476, 0.026474032551050186, -0.026985809206962585, -0.010417974554002285, 0.06189478188753128, -0.035417672246694565, -0.055615395307540894, 0.05618993565440178, -0.05253741145133972, 0.007749969605356455, -0.01077217236161232, 0.009780770167708397, -0.011667728424072266, -0.0017412130255252123, -0.002785337856039405, 0.015622347593307495, -0.03275473415851593, -0.01914135552942753, -0.051288630813360214, -0.0434194952249527, -0.012014618143439293, -0.0022705504670739174, 0.012792267836630344, 0.014977017417550087, -0.03599483147263527, 0.05583391338586807, 0.006557505577802658, -0.03950105607509613, -0.036342915147542953, -0.00046743510756641626, -0.013991585932672024, -0.026907233521342278, 0.00042995819239877164, -0.007712249178439379, -0.010790886357426643, 0.013595250435173512, 0.027202531695365906, 0.03618156537413597, 0.05734846740961075, -0.03437483683228493, 0.010592425242066383, 0.034708160907030106, 0.025971267372369766, -0.021771958097815514, 0.032844021916389465, 0.024738507345318794, -0.01380880270153284, 0.002806519391015172, -0.006004269700497389, -0.008390900678932667, 0.013074810616672039, -0.03456034138798714, 0.029165612533688545, 0.006371145602315664, 0.01803525909781456, -0.02203458920121193, -0.011467729695141315, -0.003000689670443535, -0.003996285144239664, -0.047345977276563644, 0.03750961273908615, 0.04250757768750191, -0.03364584222435951, -0.006710653193295002, 0.06264777481555939, 0.03328874334692955, 0.005570305045694113, 0.005225104745477438, 0.010465392842888832, -0.018922733142971992, 0.027339408174157143, -0.044697221368551254, -0.03907365724444389, 0.044863153249025345, 0.05184220150113106, 0.0334407202899456, 0.0015640832716599107, -0.017971394583582878, 0.010686744004487991, -0.08118648827075958, -0.0062645976431667805, -0.04784166067838669, 0.06163591146469116, 0.015465633943676949, 0.04025097191333771, -0.0031032792758196592, 0.0010533315362408757, 0.00683709466829896, 0.018185153603553772, -0.07590273022651672, 0.0014838771894574165, 0.0068562948144972324, 0.034355394542217255, 0.01250317133963108, -0.016200782731175423, 0.007821955718100071, 0.007554659619927406, 0.02774866484105587, 0.025645805522799492, -0.0017336488235741854, -0.030813710764050484, 0.04793425276875496, -0.0023988683242350817, 0.023108620196580887, -0.04578675702214241, 0.03752497583627701, 0.02499794401228428, 0.012110543437302113, 0.018458353355526924, 0.038727663457393646, -0.0026615571696311235, -0.0040614367462694645, -0.03398009389638901, 0.02988610602915287, -0.0052986182272434235, 0.04165227338671684, 0.009382938034832478, -0.004026459995657206, -0.03351166099309921, -0.005520694423466921, -0.02138158679008484, 0.04178999364376068, 0.02608395740389824, 0.0013745151227340102, 0.010628272779285908, -0.01030911598354578, -0.022459013387560844, -0.002603387925773859, 0.025749096646904945, 0.01251424290239811, -0.009560746140778065, 0.007293339818716049, 0.006151399575173855, 0.0033304174430668354, 0.02418474107980728, 0.0857948437333107, 0.01579543575644493, 0.005453293677419424, -0.06130114942789078, -0.02974245510995388, -0.003038714872673154, -0.015996938571333885, -0.02295077219605446, 0.01748345047235489, 0.014407715760171413, 0.01575879007577896, 0.027345415204763412, 0.00022764678578823805, -0.029425200074911118, 0.01711896061897278, 0.006349885370582342, 0.03720543906092644, -0.00922295730561018, -0.009103820659220219, 0.026736781001091003, 0.021288856863975525, 0.034764427691698074, -0.015047159977257252, 0.01284044235944748, -0.1294941008090973, -0.028660250827670097, 0.004820513539016247, 0.05863037705421448, -0.02027140185236931, 0.00338763277977705, -0.061780307441949844, 0.006000780034810305, 0.04969415441155434, -0.03603376820683479, 0.03680136427283287, -0.006679723039269447, 0.017096979543566704, -0.024113796651363373, -0.017111623659729958, -0.02056325413286686, -0.0052106608636677265, -0.00812066812068224, 0.014058763161301613, -0.03290176019072533, -0.031825002282857895, 0.004890059120953083, 0.028338076546788216, -0.0005188249051570892, 0.04733079671859741, -0.033086881041526794, 0.0038093344774097204, -0.023209024220705032, 0.010226009413599968, -0.018602538853883743, -0.04484157636761665, 0.013638141565024853, 0.020143816247582436, 0.03638271242380142, 0.09537217766046524, -0.008760196156799793, -0.019743110984563828, 0.05096464976668358, 0.01786993443965912, 0.006432605907320976, -0.004112152848392725, -0.02910148724913597, 0.04309379681944847, 0.028349215164780617, 0.015993773937225342, 0.03267541155219078, 0.032593194395303726, -0.04713713750243187, -0.007041957229375839, -0.042041897773742676, 0.0019796930719166994, -0.025147926062345505, -0.018046485260128975, -0.052009180188179016, 0.023040978237986565, -0.02061033807694912, 0.03807796537876129, -0.005640357732772827, -0.00984957255423069, -0.03015817329287529, 0.004697677679359913, 0.019708771258592606, 0.056042443960905075, 0.00530129112303257, -0.01203695498406887, -0.0008535163942724466, 0.004804471042007208, -0.03761487826704979, -0.01741100288927555, 0.0373372882604599, -0.033053986728191376, 0.0015203709481284022, 0.0016805367777124047, -0.039441391825675964, -0.010316256433725357, -0.001974682789295912, 0.02111506462097168, 0.0069290813989937305, -0.01461530476808548, -0.002634350210428238, 0.026326859369874, 0.02865416370332241, 0.02409547008574009, -0.05532911792397499, 0.012192250229418278, 0.039769917726516724, -0.00739644281566143, 0.013587112538516521, -0.019801480695605278, 0.04766298457980156, 0.034159041941165924, 0.011279736645519733, -0.07699817419052124, -0.02754766307771206, 0.05687323585152626, 0.023910610005259514, -0.06614213436841965, -0.04700545221567154, -0.020473070442676544, -0.020179351791739464, -0.0030802078545093536, -0.0038410581182688475, 0.025410562753677368, -0.026118174195289612, -0.006037826184183359, 0.02086612395942211, 0.01647859439253807, 0.09383159875869751, 0.002149131614714861, 0.01807248592376709, 0.03819885104894638, -0.00029444953543134034, -0.06146445870399475, 0.005871042609214783, -0.0011901833349838853, -0.04894335940480232, 0.012912661768496037, -0.05034460499882698, 0.011532094329595566, 0.06887651979923248, 0.0046617803163826466, 0.0018377917585894465, -0.04060309752821922, -0.0065958998166024685, 0.000497934001032263, -0.016364753246307373, 0.01694943942129612, -0.019311092793941498, -0.00007410401303786784, -0.04092258960008621, 0.004238471854478121, -0.03145816549658775, 0.0020039931405335665, -0.0031701880507171154, -0.025203164666891098, -0.062026940286159515, -0.0008774021989665926, 0.0748613029718399, -0.02579139545559883, -0.009768474847078323, 0.013524875044822693, 0.009299242869019508, 0.03497062250971794, 0.022635355591773987, 0.03102884069085121, 0.018025953322649002, 0.005061868112534285, -0.05415107682347298, -0.009099209681153297, -0.04768325015902519, -0.02457306906580925, 0.07123742997646332, -0.0023871471639722586, 0.011661903001368046, 0.001968502067029476, -0.01278457511216402, 0.021048935130238533, -0.008657228201627731, -0.023864086717367172, -0.0018531839596107602, 0.017614996060729027, 0.04326885566115379, -0.020176945254206657, -0.01551466342061758, 0.02560531720519066, -0.01657453551888466, 0.024877138435840607, -0.013032005168497562, 0.0035602706484496593, -0.022522494196891785, -0.0009879500139504671, -0.044848933815956116, -0.0010881798807531595, 0.03625132516026497, -0.01593211106956005, 0.04502067342400551, -0.007623473182320595, -0.011746777221560478, 0.06742869317531586, -0.011169054545462132, -0.01887577772140503, -0.020855512470006943, -0.015174397267401218, -0.04611876979470253, -0.005877799354493618, 0.014779775403439999, -0.035197265446186066, -0.00040167232509702444, 0.022475702688097954, 0.0217134952545166, -0.010207172483205795, 0.049586616456508636, -0.039377834647893906, -0.08042637258768082, -0.03885946050286293, -0.008769605308771133, -0.03823655843734741, 0.0916057676076889, 0.008235049434006214, -0.010450675152242184, 0.02385174296796322, -0.040155936032533646, 0.03136090189218521, -0.005439584143459797, 0.009819675236940384, -0.02606860175728798, 0.06419262290000916, 0.008620101027190685, -0.025338321924209595, -0.01129927672445774, -0.05608552321791649, 0.1978396624326706, 0.07396533340215683, 0.018487198278307915, -0.04333587735891342, 0.013363819569349289, 0.04996153339743614, -0.0020955016370862722, -0.006320649292320013, -0.0017910563619807363, 0.011616593226790428, -0.023450808599591255, 0.05061350390315056, 0.007512953598052263, -0.002026426373049617, 0.014823965728282928, 0.03345127031207085, -0.016788316890597343, -0.033242471516132355, 0.012319760397076607, 0.02170397900044918, -0.033792369067668915, 0.02645460143685341, -0.06811947375535965, -0.007319167722016573, 0.03910578787326813, 0.008739260956645012, -0.036176636815071106, -0.018808409571647644, -0.020019959658384323, 0.025146743282675743, -0.02128247357904911, 0.02281082049012184, -0.015481946989893913, 0.0020456481724977493, -0.03701033443212509, -0.015386817045509815, 0.018894728273153305, -0.0016074544982984662, -0.010123947635293007, 0.06064314767718315, 0.02298951894044876, -0.017935020849108696, -0.03070131689310074, 0.04153895750641823, -0.06591308861970901, 0.0010057081235572696, -0.029395101591944695, 0.036641720682382584, -0.0007812465191818774, -0.037328943610191345, -0.002290134085342288, 0.01708165556192398, 0.0013482188805937767, -0.030394019559025764, -0.010466277599334717, 0.003930823411792517, -0.004111520946025848, -0.005222439765930176, 0.007367707323282957, -0.03740663453936577, -0.024246888235211372, -0.03178311884403229, 0.016682757064700127, -0.006665780674666166, -0.011200089007616043, -0.014028961770236492, -0.006353624165058136, 0.07729972898960114, -0.00859231036156416, 0.031168272718787193, -0.011489775031805038, -0.019643770530819893, -0.004659359343349934, -0.010291002690792084, 0.028737308457493782, 0.00613471819087863, 0.019970454275608063, 0.03284931182861328, -0.0289301760494709, -0.022567862644791603, -0.023595565930008888, 0.04811660945415497, -0.04254324361681938, -0.02376626245677471, -0.08115755021572113, -0.008180888369679451, -0.0009842189028859138, 0.00997423566877842, 0.04232028126716614, 0.028977014124393463, -0.02003047615289688, 0.0532258115708828, -0.008342097513377666, -0.05428026616573334, -0.04720739647746086, 0.008189776912331581, -0.0142838628962636, 0.013103382661938667, 0.002743968740105629, 0.06748449057340622, 0.025552455335855484, 0.0005072972271591425, 0.010418746620416641, 0.04500536993145943, -0.020251430571079254, -0.0019213842460885644, -0.02780756913125515, -0.012510846368968487, -0.04411515220999718, 0.025312338024377823, -0.0016406255308538675, 0.0001359836314804852, 0.0373808890581131, -0.012397046200931072, -0.06425211578607559, 0.017285581678152084, -0.031755536794662476, -0.060447029769420624, 0.011974584311246872, -0.038719240576028824, -0.03636044263839722, -0.015423370525240898, 0.015929194167256355, -0.041610296815633774, -0.04699910432100296, -0.01650535687804222, -0.0020005435217171907, -0.027291279286146164, 0.02655971795320511, -0.055613696575164795, 0.006916684564203024, 0.052586063742637634, -0.006262365262955427, 0.0014572413638234138, 0.0014881901443004608, -0.010787791572511196, 0.019240789115428925, 0.03529810160398483, -0.021956197917461395, -0.04212881624698639, -0.023151209577918053, -0.020956074818968773, -0.015487384982407093, 0.014767312444746494, -0.01921096444129944, 0.050241272896528244, -0.018853748217225075, 0.007820144295692444, -0.005054408684372902, 0.08884655684232712, -0.02402127906680107, 0.024194028228521347, -0.021516378968954086, -0.03760067746043205, 0.01713705062866211, 0.0028752286452800035, 0.009089671075344086, -0.0015641085337847471, 0.020672015845775604, -0.0025169800501316786, 0.04761087894439697, 0.01903926581144333, -0.022176647558808327, 0.009858133271336555, -0.016104169189929962, 0.012567594647407532, 0.002803116338327527, -0.005706388968974352, 0.015068127773702145, -0.014797584153711796, -0.017109399661421776, 0.0248724278062582, -0.006355981342494488, 0.002878714120015502, -0.05284752696752548, -0.008384168148040771, 0.015833895653486252, 0.015046223998069763, 0.004716246388852596, -0.05084999278187752, -0.013193618506193161, 0.0014486918225884438, -0.038962360471487045, 0.01960490457713604, 0.015709878876805305, 0.025953400880098343, -0.013205249793827534, 0.02749735489487648, -0.01918407343327999, 0.04874766245484352, 0.021133743226528168, 0.027872642502188683, 0.046463459730148315, 0.019003596156835556, 0.019186390563845634, -0.03143418952822685, -0.012681563384830952, 0.004439108073711395, 0.00697940681129694, -0.03524879738688469, 0.019006408751010895, -0.02002694085240364, -0.002293818164616823, 0.022777510806918144, -0.022357312962412834, 0.006729518994688988, 0.0024377016816288233, 0.003122773254290223, -0.0008321609348058701, 0.03178206458687782, 0.06267394870519638, 0.03963535651564598, -0.02023126929998398, -0.02023465745151043, -0.03044624626636505, -0.000027196983864996582, -0.026719706133008003, 0.025728166103363037, 0.02550606243312359, -0.010605672374367714, -0.0001570090389577672, -0.006309227552264929, -0.04189419373869896, 0.023220596835017204, -0.052868086844682693, 0.0013751722872257233, 0.018010953441262245, -0.06150474399328232, -0.0138399638235569, -0.0688696801662445, -0.0007768801297061145, 0.03412804752588272, -0.03552292287349701, 0.000029485629056580365, 0.026950541883707047, 0.005741163156926632, 0.0012294906191527843, -0.05077780783176422, 0.030528293922543526, 0.00996246188879013, -0.04893948510289192, 0.008714296855032444, -0.016155755147337914, -0.014544338919222355, -0.0016704951412975788, 0.010574080981314182, -0.017281310632824898, 0.026400940492749214, 0.009034364484250546, -0.005537829827517271, 0.04003085941076279, 0.011448841542005539, 0.05458660051226616, -0.04492461681365967, 0.020217329263687134, -0.0022247079759836197, -0.018860502168536186, -0.014650233089923859, -0.04904458671808243, -0.01950029470026493, 0.021427839994430542, 0.026741426438093185, 0.015214916318655014, 0.0016213475028052926, -0.04920618608593941, 0.044819969683885574, 0.019009213894605637, -0.07003232836723328, 0.06468812376260757, -0.020740078762173653, -0.004473160021007061, 0.008071848191320896, -0.02905210852622986, 0.024861859157681465, 0.010746171697974205, 0.004567161202430725, -0.016297761350870132, -0.028331948444247246, -0.012925062328577042, -0.037541892379522324, -0.007420621812343597, -0.005937858484685421, -0.007236156612634659, 0.05488381162285805, 0.030476713553071022, 0.01630907878279686, 0.04449822008609772, 0.03198019415140152, -0.04405263811349869, 0.010040977969765663, -0.013244843110442162, 0.008379906415939331, -0.01103396899998188, -0.0099127646535635, 0.021687794476747513, -0.0746963620185852, -0.016292596235871315, 0.002480628900229931, -0.019236819818615913, -0.028335951268672943, 0.038938965648412704, 0.019732754677534103, -0.0021992099937051535, -0.005837816279381514, 0.021442679688334465, -0.029837772250175476, -0.07020366191864014, 0.030556876212358475, 0.03135531023144722, 0.03220195695757866, -0.038928646594285965, 0.001074596424587071, 0.009542792104184628, -0.009420693852007389, 0.051051657646894455, -0.0022541270591318607, 0.05786998197436333, -0.008013111539185047, -0.013220413587987423, 0.04657294228672981, -0.01871529035270214, 0.021136019378900528, 0.02805245667695999, 0.0029101092368364334, 0.021435026079416275, -0.013516165316104889, 0.03286488726735115, -0.007351841311901808, -0.010730808600783348, 0.009885799139738083, -0.025324836373329163, 0.0038033307064324617, 0.01912648417055607, -0.0045988960191607475, 0.00914684496819973, 0.015259052626788616, -0.01152030285447836, -0.0018313787877559662, -0.012023926712572575, 0.013092327862977982, -0.014317934401333332, 0.01815899647772312, 0.03171711787581444, 0.005131542216986418, -0.017563529312610626, 0.010118895210325718, 0.01819138415157795, 0.039919398725032806, 0.03504130616784096, -0.041836049407720566, -0.010624591261148453, -0.050013355910778046, 0.04228539392352104, -0.010803223587572575, -0.022455960512161255, 0.01312259491533041, -0.03242425248026848, -0.005985418800264597, -0.04757162928581238 ]
<p>I have three site temperature types: cold, medium, and hot. This is a fixed effect - I am specifically am testing if temperature affects my response variable. I believe temperature type is my 'block'. </p> <p>I will have three sites for each temperature type. I think site is a random effect. Within each site, I will have a factorial design, where two other fixed factors, A and B, are crossed. </p> <p>I am interested in the interaction of all three fixed effect (tempxAxB). </p> <p>From reading my stats book, I think this is a split plot design, but my stats book does not have information about factorial design (the cross of A and B) within blocks. <strong>Is what I just described a split plot design or a three way ANOVA?</strong> And if it is a funky split plot, could someone point me to an ANOVA table (how to calculate sum of squares) with a similar set up?</p> <p>Here is a schematic of the setup: </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/E60hm.png" alt="Set up"></p>
74,389
[ -0.03567180410027504, -0.012164397165179253, -0.009954482316970825, 0.006709739565849304, 0.05176800489425659, 0.016917839646339417, 0.0078064557164907455, -0.01782452128827572, 0.03615039214491844, -0.020914839580655098, 0.04830125346779823, 0.0095703499391675, 0.003154998179525137, 0.006681749131530523, 0.009919601492583752, 0.016574682667851448, 0.026644308120012283, -0.024066125974059105, 0.04266250878572464, 0.012101145461201668, -0.0006253687315620482, 0.009829012677073479, -0.0015457139816135168, 0.008657220751047134, -0.03328491374850273, 0.05412212759256363, 0.012135788798332214, -0.05641498416662216, 0.03988117352128029, 0.03596245124936104, -0.0276708472520113, -0.06415234506130219, -0.006821825634688139, 0.012508128769695759, -0.0017378010088577867, -0.0024110993836075068, -0.0034465829376131296, -0.0070383669808506966, -0.003889427287504077, 0.051624588668346405, -0.01815478317439556, -0.005371519364416599, -0.024540230631828308, 0.032330259680747986, -0.02255391888320446, -0.0060156178660690784, -0.01613699458539486, -0.03837026283144951, 0.059632718563079834, -0.07444769889116287, 0.06291938573122025, -0.014495395123958588, 0.07278591394424438, 0.0729653388261795, -0.03449898213148117, 0.005584875121712685, 0.06393652409315109, 0.022200338542461395, -0.017549477517604828, -0.05018254369497299, -0.008753822185099125, -0.03188188001513481, 0.027806634083390236, 0.0023896677885204554, -0.057486262172460556, 0.009628611616790295, -0.031740788370370865, -0.03074643202126026, 0.021944869309663773, -0.004235547035932541, 0.028071066364645958, 0.008365289308130741, 0.03414469584822655, -0.031548094004392624, -0.009447627700865269, -0.05540797859430313, -0.007117307744920254, 0.03365437313914299, 0.05565300211310387, 0.01818421110510826, -0.011756617575883865, 0.05467294901609421, 0.013233890756964684, 0.021465161815285683, -0.0008239609305746853, -0.01733456738293171, 0.06237242370843887, -0.014060352928936481, -0.012167592532932758, 0.0027281618677079678, -0.0037737684324383736, 0.009895836003124714, 0.051730237901210785, 0.014441517181694508, -0.041993461549282074, 0.009974324144423008, 0.008523489348590374, 0.022981945425271988, 0.012263281270861626, 0.023331094533205032, -0.014274682849645615, -0.0015063679311424494, 0.014122620224952698, 0.0685616210103035, -0.0023541832342743874, -0.006360629573464394, -0.025850532576441765, 0.013251406140625477, 0.009532817639410496, -0.004475781694054604, -0.024334801360964775, 0.04338614270091057, -0.0042369551956653595, -0.011622132733464241, 0.027135733515024185, -0.05377722531557083, -0.014409566298127174, -0.00023734418209642172, 0.058654896914958954, 0.012083824723958969, 0.0673457607626915, -0.018837569281458855, 0.03287985920906067, -0.009081443771719933, -0.08672215789556503, -0.017061715945601463, -0.011393792927265167, -0.002066534711048007, -0.01949683576822281, 0.09414596110582352, 0.004431309178471565, -0.004004299640655518, 0.03340946137905121, -0.019227275624871254, -0.023450763896107674, -0.005695007275789976, -0.06798289716243744, -0.04983215406537056, 0.053570326417684555, -0.03504089266061783, -0.029024869203567505, -0.0346977561712265, -0.035087671130895615, 0.022920740768313408, 0.06036117300391197, -0.01537624467164278, 0.017399370670318604, -0.02939777262508869, 0.02817072533071041, 0.02278098091483116, -0.0223909430205822, -0.01386970840394497, -0.015697017312049866, -0.030213048681616783, -0.008027462288737297, -0.06320328265428543, 0.03102778270840645, 0.015183666720986366, -0.018019312992691994, 0.025097986683249474, 0.014427957125008106, 0.03388151898980141, 0.008643600158393383, 0.02706838585436344, 0.00937671959400177, 0.0009798790561035275, 0.0994584709405899, -0.05096514895558357, 0.004362863022834063, 0.04492178559303284, -0.03459230810403824, 0.026088614016771317, -0.024181289598345757, 0.04590736702084541, 0.020974209532141685, -0.00779907638207078, 0.009230917319655418, 0.03448948636651039, -0.005064225289970636, 0.04304578900337219, -0.05795968323945999, 0.020499859005212784, -0.02014140784740448, -0.04168495535850525, 0.045620355755090714, 0.07592006027698517, -0.010393334552645683, 0.0007211352349258959, 0.06090010330080986, -0.02913251332938671, -0.03922390192747116, -0.09987229108810425, -0.024656323716044426, -0.015412581153213978, -0.04245848208665848, -0.005206494126468897, 0.03183608874678612, 0.040380045771598816, -0.0029623215086758137, -0.046281177550554276, -0.010481222532689571, 0.012836320325732231, 0.04509872943162918, -0.025351805612444878, 0.036116983741521835, 0.02898012101650238, 0.021921101957559586, -0.019724041223526, 0.027945132926106453, -0.0563584640622139, -0.017401814460754395, 0.006225234363228083, -0.07081490010023117, 0.025308389216661453, -0.03173498064279556, -0.0229682344943285, -0.012752042151987553, 0.04870017617940903, -0.03450876474380493, 0.03338906541466713, -0.06256302446126938, 0.04398347809910774, 0.028147565200924873, 0.007392992731183767, 0.0030391260515898466, 0.031196091324090958, 0.04952450096607208, 0.027025029063224792, -0.025732317939400673, -0.016462674364447594, -0.03343840688467026, -0.008455720730125904, 0.026240026578307152, 0.00031771749490872025, -0.030639011412858963, 0.02291877008974552, 0.022546030580997467, 0.01127296406775713, -0.0033420224208384752, 0.05169713497161865, 0.01187016163021326, 0.007518338970839977, -0.022582679986953735, 0.03436531126499176, 0.004164940677583218, 0.020582446828484535, -0.009615780785679817, 0.023431267589330673, 0.016878781840205193, -0.00920470617711544, 0.0010238938266411424, 0.056765321642160416, 0.022606302052736282, 0.03097880631685257, -0.04453018307685852, 0.011226808652281761, 0.05488457903265953, -0.018298430368304253, 0.04242170229554176, 0.02426179312169552, 0.02639085240662098, -0.01853347197175026, -0.004404155071824789, -0.062163226306438446, 0.012240882962942123, 0.015643887221813202, 0.01664680987596512, 0.0032251353841274977, 0.021227195858955383, -0.018231291323900223, 0.02086810953915119, -0.03172352910041809, 0.02532292529940605, 0.0001444206282030791, 0.015273631550371647, -0.0324404314160347, 0.028483163565397263, 0.015149975195527077, -0.03343300521373749, -0.018265454098582268, -0.03381313756108284, -0.009600077755749226, 0.0373556986451149, -0.0014048871817067266, -0.052823469042778015, 0.0050985198467969894, -0.05659935623407364, -0.0016306638717651367, 0.007343287114053965, -0.008842525072395802, -0.05573658645153046, 0.041381217539310455, 0.011648167856037617, -0.055649880319833755, -0.02645421214401722, -0.008046872913837433, 0.015115374699234962, -0.02803093194961548, 0.0060442672111094, -0.01394115760922432, -0.0017285323701798916, -0.009936293587088585, 0.000489475205540657, -0.05182236060500145, -0.015219060704112053, 0.012960508465766907, 0.0021192533895373344, 0.006422595586627722, 0.009511143900454044, 0.014561591669917107, 0.009587759152054787, -0.026795396581292152, -0.007145757786929607, -0.045671138912439346, -0.04891595244407654, -0.010011713020503521, 0.008780031464993954, 0.0010418451856821775, -0.013858416117727757, -0.0066162399016320705, 0.06633590906858444, 0.00039710855344310403, -0.03285627067089081, -0.04331079125404358, -0.03237432613968849, -0.032805949449539185, -0.05870660021901131, 0.04613220691680908, 0.0007429601391777396, -0.03448498621582985, 0.025554953143000603, -0.007194451987743378, 0.03705539181828499, 0.07681559771299362, 0.02581099048256874, -0.024664420634508133, 0.0242936871945858, 0.014086257666349411, -0.02681947499513626, 0.03223602473735809, 0.0017501901602372527, -0.013420796021819115, -0.025592930614948273, -0.01680239662528038, 0.01151247788220644, 0.018076688051223755, -0.052322473376989365, 0.004215519409626722, -0.015460176393389702, 0.038945622742176056, -0.0335044227540493, 0.0088479183614254, 0.011201947927474976, -0.00046421869774349034, 0.0015161257470026612, 0.029552416875958443, 0.024175802245736122, -0.0012134176213294268, 0.030676808208227158, 0.0844077542424202, 0.04637764394283295, -0.02129305712878704, -0.04305180534720421, -0.007843852043151855, 0.019852271303534508, -0.010307460092008114, 0.002511875005438924, 0.012489176355302334, 0.00539172301068902, 0.03875094652175903, 0.0017927868757396936, 0.026953939348459244, -0.017977995797991753, 0.002837233478203416, -0.052095819264650345, -0.019013065844774246, -0.01617375947535038, 0.02798512391746044, -0.01337810605764389, 0.027449287474155426, -0.018604468554258347, -0.005286244675517082, 0.01231038011610508, -0.019158830866217613, -0.04324008524417877, 0.033691082149744034, -0.00015639173216186464, -0.015328030101954937, 0.026682788506150246, -0.01763853058218956, 0.01868203654885292, -0.019970957189798355, 0.021017469465732574, 0.006592626683413982, 0.013341447338461876, -0.02566959522664547, -0.003215896664187312, 0.011203602887690067, -0.012935195118188858, -0.04341162368655205, 0.023346303030848503, 0.028144262731075287, -0.04497595876455307, 0.012019658461213112, 0.008878981694579124, -0.03392897546291351, 0.021584905683994293, 0.014320671558380127, -0.0025465930812060833, 0.005457023158669472, 0.03614608570933342, 0.01501838956028223, 0.03226585313677788, -0.03462563082575798, 0.03673981875181198, 0.012065249495208263, 0.03502622991800308, 0.018982090055942535, -0.00957051757723093, 0.004377629142254591, -0.02098463661968708, -0.042382240295410156, -0.003682236885651946, 0.010694697499275208, -0.01220030803233385, 0.0017118476098403335, 0.03831012547016144, 0.028587207198143005, -0.06589047610759735, -0.0018339293310418725, 0.06437723338603973, 0.02236410602927208, 0.014553102664649487, -0.025992179289460182, -0.019982870668172836, -0.02383267693221569, -0.004455885849893093, 0.05361677333712578, 0.029292045161128044, 0.009267215617001057, 0.017049521207809448, 0.07977079600095749, 0.006165042519569397, -0.028162110596895218, 0.03718974068760872, -0.0033541929442435503, 0.01781018078327179, 0.009411795996129513, -0.05963602662086487, -0.024153029546141624, 0.05521668121218681, -0.0002832064055837691, -0.030809693038463593, -0.019964974373579025, -0.09284825623035431, -0.0011134545784443617, 0.03299090638756752, 0.05920819565653801, 0.010560995899140835, 0.006411640904843807, -0.027906225994229317, 0.0073188417591154575, 0.0011874994961544871, -0.04767090827226639, 0.05515184998512268, -0.03372854366898537, 0.02664385735988617, -0.04465121030807495, -0.0380626916885376, -0.03041965700685978, 0.028382673859596252, 0.0011790524004027247, 0.01623806171119213, 0.001072195591405034, -0.007558396551758051, 0.01725209690630436, -0.003123162779957056, 0.041405122727155685, 0.012389957904815674, -0.02675330452620983, 0.025939086452126503, 0.015728026628494263, 0.03006472997367382, -0.0346248485147953, -0.07690297812223434, 0.004587912932038307, -0.00403786264359951, -0.0248448196798563, 0.05723366513848305, -0.023388998582959175, -0.010255685076117516, 0.019258830696344376, 0.025840552523732185, 0.011493751779198647, 0.01978858932852745, -0.00572936050593853, 0.05973653122782707, 0.030209798365831375, 0.034474585205316544, 0.08621164411306381, 0.03501582890748978, 0.018932871520519257, -0.003237285651266575, -0.04224978759884834, 0.03226345777511597, -0.027285531163215637, -0.03956667333841324, -0.0460994727909565, -0.025045424699783325, -0.0212576724588871, 0.0027933509554713964, -0.008954164572060108, 0.02497226931154728, -0.04365461692214012, -0.06302815675735474, 0.013585139065980911, -0.023992447182536125, 0.022486556321382523, -0.009840002283453941, 0.01756112650036812, 0.011591543443500996, -0.015004247426986694, -0.0385175421833992, -0.007588667795062065, 0.0007267511682584882, 0.029594745486974716, -0.0029840669594705105, -0.033534009009599686, 0.03606037423014641, -0.019237477332353592, -0.04329686984419823, -0.015170459635555744, -0.05376836284995079, 0.04953591525554657, -0.03721633180975914, 0.050081733614206314, 0.020500600337982178, -0.05714624747633934, -0.009722867980599403, 0.018148643895983696, 0.04992379993200302, 0.009859073907136917, -0.030508073046803474, 0.055728036910295486, -0.028213704004883766, -0.01478694099932909, -0.07171464711427689, -0.020878246054053307, 0.019624000415205956, 0.014824587851762772, -0.021044913679361343, -0.044912464916706085, -0.023955725133419037, -0.01936011016368866, -0.0362887866795063, -0.03264179080724716, 0.0596882589161396, 0.0008689946844242513, -0.021363720297813416, 0.027205603197216988, 0.015400427393615246, 0.04634829983115196, 0.007040467578917742, -0.018238339573144913, 0.008591952733695507, -0.010852391831576824, -0.051962390542030334, -0.015396022237837315, -0.006864693481475115, -0.03128673881292343, -0.004884057212620974, -0.015736905857920647, -0.004775593057274818, 0.046258870512247086, -0.0012247208505868912, -0.0014005344128236175, 0.00384038919582963, 0.056073013693094254, -0.0028540710918605328, -0.07257424294948578, -0.00045315243187360466, 0.03990493714809418, 0.017416460439562798, -0.0200186874717474, 0.01158551312983036, -0.051735978573560715, 0.002327900379896164, -0.02240845188498497, -0.05474315956234932, -0.05284982919692993, 0.024332398548722267, 0.07833866775035858, 0.02753743715584278, 0.025500280782580376, -0.020488020032644272, -0.0005910084000788629, 0.020351553335785866, 0.011346441693603992, -0.008488167077302933, 0.036444470286369324, 0.004433670546859503, -0.001190301962196827, -0.02206563390791416, -0.04360524192452431, 0.03119947388768196, 0.06984923034906387, -0.023225020617246628, 0.023373248055577278, 0.08565422147512436, -0.04051579535007477, -0.013971156440675259, -0.0062430123798549175, -0.006289406213909388, -0.02121761254966259, 0.014311404898762703, 0.05602644756436348, -0.006716687697917223, -0.0030916801188141108, 0.018979953601956367, 0.011233089491724968, 0.015736538916826248, 0.04402126371860504, 0.024539340287446976, 0.021837901324033737, 0.010102774947881699, -0.006801138631999493, -0.0695924311876297, 0.04104708507657051, -0.05870548263192177, 0.029173346236348152, -0.030235623940825462, -0.01464953925460577, 0.05526525154709816, 0.04164308309555054, -0.008839860558509827, -0.07631320506334305, -0.016583314165472984, -0.047504715621471405, 0.02025626227259636, 0.012909162789583206, -0.04952365905046463, 0.006176283583045006, 0.020094862207770348, 0.05461622402071953, -0.017714396119117737, 0.010021213442087173, -0.02084028720855713, -0.07652711123228073, -0.0050528282299637794, 0.0032111757900565863, -0.021145563572645187, 0.05028755962848663, -0.005339867435395718, -0.03602723777294159, 0.019313404336571693, -0.021066198125481606, 0.03791942447423935, -0.009478158317506313, 0.054260626435279846, -0.006375480443239212, 0.028680801391601562, -0.01634323224425316, 0.022354943677783012, 0.043856509029865265, 0.028380101546645164, 0.10731370002031326, 0.07050103694200516, 0.028641166165471077, -0.07954578101634979, 0.0509164035320282, -0.008817368187010288, 0.004673900548368692, 0.003283865051344037, -0.018197856843471527, 0.002171014668419957, 0.010595195926725864, 0.05612201243638992, 0.05400454252958298, 0.007022718898952007, -0.02105594612658024, 0.041277926415205, -0.02176244929432869, -0.033315978944301605, 0.024792680516839027, 0.010159210301935673, 0.01632779836654663, -0.02916346862912178, -0.032802749425172806, -0.032991599291563034, 0.014656503684818745, -0.00898304395377636, -0.035629190504550934, -0.016358789056539536, 0.013418491929769516, 0.02334107644855976, -0.008479088544845581, 0.0357193797826767, 0.01579836755990982, -0.0057623363099992275, -0.012040339410305023, -0.026525402441620827, 0.026907706633210182, -0.019847499206662178, 0.03128140792250633, 0.02697622962296009, -0.012208838947117329, -0.024260541424155235, 0.029643336310982704, 0.032477717846632004, -0.023512355983257294, -0.02856304869055748, -0.00019362603779882193, 0.021637670695781708, -0.015995459631085396, -0.031450122594833374, -0.016025938093662262, 0.009447894059121609, 0.027387341484427452, 0.009489660151302814, 0.0108609888702631, 0.005885910242795944, 0.019198531284928322, -0.04997695982456207, -0.04721427708864212, -0.03736203536391258, 0.005149387288838625, -0.004518737085163593, -0.007000824902206659, 0.05052701383829117, -0.012348094023764133, 0.0076826224103569984, -0.03929680958390236, 0.07002415508031845, 0.01037665642797947, -0.005951195489615202, -0.000954891147557646, 0.00005018320007366128, 0.012051578611135483, 0.011611000634729862, -0.016514398157596588, 0.025708358734846115, 0.017867302522063255, -0.005434525199234486, -0.011467615142464638, 0.005709588993340731, -0.05159571021795273, -0.012042543850839138, -0.05308777466416359, -0.0058377827517688274, -0.02356555685400963, 0.015049290843307972, 0.02066941186785698, 0.041931137442588806, 0.017257317900657654, -0.008211199194192886, -0.012460594065487385, 0.01492226216942072, 0.03185407817363739, -0.06216845661401749, -0.02760704606771469, 0.011185851879417896, -0.03840271010994911, -0.019527269527316093, -0.02962484583258629, 0.05400198698043823, 0.028035840019583702, -0.0017344433581456542, -0.006802458316087723, 0.02286699414253235, -0.0024587910156697035, -0.01849735714495182, 0.028808996081352234, -0.04568615183234215, 0.0179060697555542, 0.013422012329101562, -0.016543922945857048, 0.0005935959634371102, -0.00727609358727932, -0.013971657492220402, -0.005525046959519386, -0.013617261312901974, 0.010559743270277977, -0.02571585588157177, -0.015848396345973015, -0.047033410519361496, 0.010675216093659401, -0.03956085070967674, 0.008568909950554371, -0.043922729790210724, -0.028635160997509956, 0.029864519834518433, 0.013227802701294422, -0.015385333448648453, 0.019584093242883682, 0.0007238457910716534, 0.004627504851669073, -0.0024454318918287754, 0.02231312356889248, 0.017391551285982132, -0.04364174231886864, -0.00782072078436613, 0.0023792653810232878, 0.061595767736434937, 0.031056327745318413, 0.01730988919734955, 0.018089380115270615, -0.07073938846588135, 0.00003550629480741918, 0.00041213573422282934, -0.017247473821043968, 0.022308100014925003, 0.024007601663470268, -0.010447712615132332, 0.004289423581212759, 0.058440033346414566, 0.017881350591778755, -0.05839785933494568, -0.003206059103831649, 0.0029364139772951603, 0.04373646154999733, -0.011587975546717644, 0.005059556104242802, -0.0026852537412196398, -0.03867446258664131, 0.030703969299793243, 0.029375668615102768, -0.016623500734567642, -0.01546342484652996, -0.021806636825203896, 0.0027465871535241604, -0.02626034803688526, -0.007992522791028023, -0.015803970396518707, 0.03480163589119911, 0.059267912060022354, -0.02790527604520321, 0.016573263332247734, -0.026077594608068466, 0.033184394240379333, -0.07396974414587021, -0.040782615542411804, 0.027452223002910614, 0.022672299295663834, 0.056632138788700104, -0.05968599021434784, 0.010935506783425808, 0.05015545338392258, -0.06060171499848366, -0.015377343632280827, 0.010788414627313614, -0.021410757675766945, -0.041186459362506866, -0.01039380207657814, -0.023063136264681816, 0.028846081346273422, 0.011078218929469585, 0.012867596000432968, 0.017468946054577827, 0.03931710496544838, -0.03409253805875778, -0.03857981041073799, 0.021514397114515305, 0.028780829161405563, 0.040301136672496796, -0.07642859220504761, 0.014984590001404285, -0.00926833413541317, -0.01850607618689537, 0.007728171534836292, -0.03725095093250275, -0.007673028390854597, 0.04716462269425392, 0.015941733494400978, -0.005128528457134962, 0.04169164225459099, 0.009480221197009087, 0.022891394793987274, 0.02170809730887413, 0.007138659246265888, 0.022193150594830513, 0.010927162133157253, 0.0034504684153944254, 0.03578983247280121, 0.05362648144364357, -0.020209720358252525, -0.02519872970879078, -0.000564665358979255, -0.03763667121529579, -0.010124684311449528, 0.01670239120721817, -0.005170782562345266, 0.04338400065898895, -0.02025262825191021, -0.011998319998383522, -0.04389844089746475, 0.02367294207215309, 0.03471420705318451, -0.03847530111670494, -0.0026937995571643114, 0.015465185977518559, 0.007793325465172529, -0.017532777041196823, 0.006221016403287649, -0.027896001935005188, -0.02117985300719738, -0.04135295748710632, -0.03896905109286308, 0.024204544723033905, -0.011146796867251396, -0.02825450524687767, 0.010113229975104332, -0.02556084655225277, 0.03561371564865112, -0.03299122303724289, -0.021153811365365982, -0.014429558999836445, -0.01450797263532877, 0.003963354974985123, -0.07954256236553192, 0.055599913001060486, 0.020274342969059944, -0.0018071646336466074, -0.07744017243385315, -0.011057578958570957, -0.025488168001174927, 0.0018626892706379294, 0.03993667662143707, 0.019814154133200645, 0.026651019230484962, 0.0006691915914416313, 0.049080751836299896, 0.005477610044181347, -0.06154460459947586, 0.05276543274521828, 0.0027027034666389227, -0.015430878847837448, 0.009182918816804886, 0.011726240627467632, -0.004476442467421293, -0.006273607723414898, 0.020677482709288597, -0.033092204481363297, 0.026424627751111984, -0.027899688109755516, 0.0013976800255477428, 0.013715499080717564, 0.031503044068813324, -0.030058158561587334, 0.039266861975193024, -0.018217820674180984, 0.0013519939966499805, 0.04795823618769646, -0.01128433644771576, -0.03483861684799194, 0.020604107528924942, -0.027262113988399506, 0.014466239139437675, 0.0024474223610013723, -0.0097958417609334, -0.021305745467543602, -0.09536752104759216, 0.022582128643989563, 0.005640993360430002, -0.02864013984799385, -0.010386825539171696, 0.03578885272145271, 0.06407184898853302, 0.015420534648001194, -0.003390139201655984, 0.0051459623500704765, -0.011542575433850288, -0.019002819433808327, 0.021252069622278214, 0.006405001971870661, 0.02851690538227558, 0.010983780026435852, -0.020053962245583534, -0.0009330034954473376, -0.010074252262711525, 0.03746172785758972, 0.009466051124036312, 0.002013233955949545, 0.0035986220464110374, 0.001805841107852757, 0.011170259676873684, -0.0067920563742518425, 0.026944920420646667, -0.003154588397592306, -0.006907669361680746, 0.04940992593765259, -0.04535461962223053, 0.006122122053056955, -0.0426475927233696, 0.01464149821549654, 0.00954949390143156, -0.013334215618669987, 0.033752478659152985, 0.03492199629545212, -0.02529730089008808, -0.009923800826072693, -0.022506050765514374, -0.017690854147076607, -0.00029599122353829443, -0.02796301245689392, 0.028201568871736526, -0.013196352869272232, 0.013262401334941387, -0.010504795238375664, -0.01489536464214325, -0.03392104059457779, 0.007954403758049011, 0.04209946468472481, 0.028072817251086235, -0.03568294271826744, -0.017561694607138634, -0.04041346162557602, 0.025434302166104317, 0.0270692165941, -0.059053871780633926, -0.010472731664776802, -0.05021285638213158, 0.036238450556993484, 0.0038486511912196875, 0.04573911428451538 ]
<p>I don't know what such plots are called and thus I just gave this question a stupid title.</p> <p>Let's say I have an ordered dataset as follows</p> <pre><code>4253 4262 4270 4383 4394 4476 4635 ... </code></pre> <p>Each number corresponds to the amount of postings a certain user contributed to a website. I am empirically investigating the "participation inequality" phenomenon as defined <a href="http://www.nngroup.com/articles/participation-inequality/">here</a>.</p> <p>In order to make it easy to grasp I would like to produce a plot which allows the reader to quickly deduce statements such as "10% of the users contribute 50% of the data". It should probably look similar to this admittedly pretty lousy paint sketch:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ysrzN.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I have no clue how this is called thus I don't know where to look for. Also, if somebody had an implementation in <code>R</code>, that would be awesome.</p>
74,390
[ -0.0183772724121809, -0.00535845011472702, 0.021263988688588142, 0.00110046926420182, 0.024103103205561638, 0.009325128979980946, -0.0017037168145179749, -0.004394876770675182, 0.01184269692748785, -0.041860323399305344, 0.04247825965285301, 0.034635744988918304, 0.015040560625493526, 0.042282819747924805, 0.013981242664158344, 0.04330262169241905, -0.01906711794435978, 0.02069643698632717, -0.0032166517339646816, -0.023842932656407356, -0.035991210490465164, -0.018217220902442932, 0.02687567099928856, -0.01528200600296259, -0.02515897899866104, 0.02912542037665844, 0.045197706669569016, 0.02334495447576046, -0.009593868628144264, 0.09823217242956161, -0.03929657116532326, -0.01902945339679718, 0.05022745952010155, 0.05166025087237358, 0.044141873717308044, 0.016594039276242256, -0.02100229822099209, -0.032241903245449066, 0.0032042006496340036, -0.008025327697396278, -0.037906043231487274, 0.011024348437786102, 0.01674443669617176, 0.04050814360380173, 0.002544335788115859, 0.006904196925461292, -0.020579705014824867, -0.012396210804581642, 0.02539677545428276, -0.03928040340542793, 0.09708420932292938, 0.030669672414660454, 0.06881404668092728, 0.007683991454541683, -0.013338644057512283, 0.03809678182005882, 0.015774095430970192, 0.08924595266580582, 0.0025742133148014545, -0.05863181874155998, -0.004047972150146961, -0.03131260350346565, 0.0022698421962559223, -0.014455615542829037, -0.04385087639093399, 0.032106008380651474, -0.011720065027475357, 0.015338084660470486, 0.022534295916557312, -0.007619685493409634, -0.025803331285715103, 0.02695334330201149, 0.03948328271508217, -0.03911001607775688, -0.03591221943497658, -0.0427745021879673, 0.015389211475849152, -0.011257161386311054, 0.059347882866859436, 0.013520348817110062, -0.003610102226957679, -0.008436789736151695, 0.023694580420851707, 0.03824689984321594, 0.03949660435318947, -0.008188982494175434, 0.06973899155855179, -0.029124528169631958, 0.03372875228524208, 0.013501693494617939, -0.03021925501525402, -0.0037593876477330923, 0.044614795595407486, 0.037505779415369034, -0.04738810285925865, 0.02413971722126007, -0.019608085975050926, 0.03157874569296837, 0.01248626783490181, -0.02858772687613964, 0.0024570217356085777, -0.041214823722839355, 0.015815341845154762, 0.027706533670425415, -0.04714799299836159, -0.025408314540982246, -0.038170766085386276, -0.01981830596923828, -0.004533662926405668, 0.01856655441224575, 0.003028038190677762, 0.004303575027734041, 0.035946376621723175, 0.026496335864067078, 0.01786120980978012, -0.034443918615579605, 0.004467747639864683, 0.002426333259791136, 0.04865891858935356, 0.025902308523654938, 0.02735358476638794, 0.011411397717893124, 0.04102586582303047, -0.04270627349615097, -0.05508050695061684, 0.006209634710103273, 0.0065683950670063496, -0.023497743532061577, -0.03329990431666374, 0.06425733119249344, -0.066404327750206, -0.053277529776096344, 0.06656946986913681, -0.006775135174393654, 0.04871242120862007, 0.014918974600732327, -0.06434335559606552, -0.04647686332464218, 0.04402010515332222, -0.01532633975148201, 0.037677157670259476, -0.05265215039253235, 0.015587284229695797, 0.04359899088740349, 0.022265750914812088, 0.01300650555640459, 0.03811003640294075, -0.005956826265901327, 0.05248383805155754, 0.0134590407833457, -0.027450909838080406, -0.013427342288196087, -0.0024355121422559023, -0.022516783326864243, -0.02378847636282444, -0.04733264818787575, 0.004113719332963228, 0.02970585972070694, -0.030491944402456284, 0.00878928042948246, 0.012683412991464138, 0.0275379940867424, -0.007413225248456001, -0.015382222831249237, 0.01254425197839737, -0.022809233516454697, 0.07628455013036728, 0.009636709466576576, -0.0035338103771209717, -0.013512877747416496, -0.028606560081243515, 0.041251324117183685, 0.015354780480265617, 0.018608348444104195, 0.06522360444068909, 0.005459066014736891, -0.0018725451081991196, -0.0287672970443964, 0.018905363976955414, 0.046275682747364044, -0.030536215752363205, -0.02175157703459263, -0.004696885589510202, -0.022582128643989563, 0.007457572501152754, -0.006490540225058794, 0.0006145929801277816, -0.02970989979803562, 0.05138446390628815, -0.056932348757982254, -0.050289254635572433, -0.08117464184761047, -0.006072368007153273, -0.002378222066909075, -0.039293885231018066, -0.02101719379425049, 0.023149633780121803, 0.025568505749106407, -0.03358793631196022, -0.03444380685687065, -0.0003561306220944971, -0.006490801461040974, 0.0769755020737648, -0.03247297182679176, -0.04600784182548523, -0.018175074830651283, 0.03905382379889488, -0.012167730368673801, 0.03622976690530777, -0.039330825209617615, -0.020092252641916275, 0.011693580076098442, -0.014973231591284275, 0.029780669137835503, -0.021017344668507576, -0.026066428050398827, 0.014034939929842949, 0.02322058379650116, -0.017236556857824326, 0.05366107076406479, -0.06692823767662048, 0.026701780036091805, 0.0853194147348404, 0.04657268151640892, -0.010714869946241379, -0.03908216208219528, 0.00841247197240591, 0.006545100826770067, -0.059014949947595596, -0.016121208667755127, -0.05771569907665253, -0.000018207221728516743, 0.017297111451625824, 0.002980306278914213, -0.03342268988490105, -0.011746671050786972, 0.058769118040800095, 0.03258543461561203, 0.005122827365994453, 0.037926189601421356, -0.028977762907743454, 0.016297414898872375, -0.010081689804792404, 0.019124042242765427, 0.028776118531823158, 0.00524942297488451, 0.028406457975506783, 0.017498543485999107, 0.0397048220038414, 0.010520152747631073, -0.03125736117362976, 0.027991028502583504, -0.026062514632940292, -0.007121782749891281, -0.0036209842655807734, 0.01604515127837658, 0.07778473198413849, -0.024609245359897614, -0.015148998238146305, 0.0020952539052814245, 0.018732860684394836, -0.02086803875863552, 0.01648317463696003, -0.0381658673286438, -0.011539737693965435, 0.036928825080394745, -0.07414669543504715, -0.013497823849320412, 0.014242355711758137, 0.007375235669314861, 0.00324588967487216, -0.04511312022805214, -0.009978793561458588, -0.05919577181339264, 0.03091271035373211, 0.047594357281923294, 0.016644781455397606, 0.03269336745142937, -0.03369884565472603, -0.032465822994709015, 0.037196096032857895, -0.014849060215055943, 0.054518479853868484, 0.007604829501360655, -0.052371636033058167, 0.004407273605465889, 0.00519462488591671, -0.023342402651906013, -0.004017029423266649, 0.01223111990839243, -0.027128083631396294, -0.0005573099479079247, -0.009711367078125477, -0.026654217392206192, -0.029836159199476242, -0.006045783869922161, 0.017878804355859756, -0.03289399296045303, 0.002714485628530383, 0.014169670641422272, -0.025102602317929268, -0.04139101877808571, 0.018807262182235718, -0.0321047343313694, -0.010655369609594345, -0.029133254662156105, -0.019302183762192726, 0.02858070284128189, -0.013518410734832287, -0.008099214173853397, 0.00042772572487592697, 0.00033736316254362464, -0.029866809025406837, -0.04718485102057457, -0.09231474250555038, 0.009288473054766655, 0.001418356318026781, 0.006400964222848415, 0.025753993541002274, -0.021053962409496307, 0.040757615119218826, 0.013650622218847275, -0.033164918422698975, -0.05509062856435776, -0.02578083984553814, 0.010012584738433361, -0.018344927579164505, 0.006554023828357458, 0.01815871335566044, -0.0017162319272756577, 0.017410023137927055, 0.003733748337253928, 0.04595799371600151, 0.021674582734704018, -0.025699734687805176, -0.01043615397065878, 0.013998514041304588, -0.04410847648978233, 0.013180741108953953, 0.016650453209877014, 0.033132243901491165, -0.04379628226161003, 0.04790927842259407, -0.0002745593956205994, 0.036501605063676834, -0.01478560734540224, -0.04067240655422211, -0.011543427594006062, 0.01572711393237114, 0.002575603546574712, -0.01855682022869587, 0.03818310424685478, 0.026325957849621773, -0.02040897123515606, 0.0002010180614888668, 0.039440788328647614, 0.04289945587515831, -0.01253445353358984, -0.031123103573918343, 0.04797840490937233, 0.004426539875566959, -0.020791010931134224, 0.02855692058801651, -0.03827929124236107, -0.019282016903162003, -0.01204118225723505, -0.024945855140686035, -0.0199002493172884, 0.05974765121936798, 0.051482632756233215, 0.00002623820364533458, 0.0013833314878866076, -0.032738011330366135, 0.05094502121210098, -0.04944885894656181, -0.031794484704732895, -0.02266199328005314, 0.04615781456232071, 0.004131381865590811, 0.06818221509456635, -0.018610434606671333, 0.020552825182676315, 0.010417641140520573, -0.0012475629337131977, -0.04199552163481712, 0.03737596422433853, 0.0019930994603782892, 0.03361033275723457, 0.0011743373470380902, -0.017659857869148254, 0.04156968370079994, -0.01566210947930813, -0.024266168475151062, 0.01373320259153843, 0.03167201951146126, -0.03757786378264427, 0.0013403781922534108, 0.015097145922482014, 0.01827498897910118, -0.004134953487664461, 0.0024574303533881903, 0.044224631041288376, -0.02673831209540367, 0.031655095517635345, 0.03362572565674782, 0.027486305683851242, -0.040668632835149765, -0.007431729696691036, 0.005924896337091923, 0.03537902235984802, 0.024347826838493347, 0.01687289960682392, 0.012150744907557964, -0.05269278585910797, 0.021045969799160957, -0.07813216000795364, 0.06010731682181358, 0.035383906215429306, -0.014454853720963001, 0.010867893695831299, -0.016776101663708687, 0.001135605270974338, 0.002095119096338749, 0.03228866308927536, -0.02625272050499916, 0.019867325201630592, 0.04845636337995529, 0.02918410114943981, -0.053229160606861115, 0.053255680948495865, 0.042696379125118256, 0.033396556973457336, -0.025519218295812607, -0.0204364862293005, 0.009364292956888676, -0.01176923606544733, 0.0209503173828125, 0.013666932471096516, 0.02370266057550907, 0.026684900745749474, 0.03765001893043518, 0.028124868869781494, -0.04146735742688179, -0.02113577164709568, -0.00984051451086998, -0.014208441600203514, 0.04463297501206398, -0.02834297902882099, -0.06328411400318146, 0.006378938443958759, 0.016492173075675964, 0.036004431545734406, 0.01303120981901884, -0.004652569070458412, -0.12779875099658966, 0.014732819981873035, 0.04462781548500061, 0.018697330728173256, -0.019529564306139946, -0.02879561111330986, -0.031178493052721024, -0.008677180856466293, 0.045322660356760025, -0.04711184278130531, -0.002101804129779339, -0.0313248373568058, 0.011134151369333267, -0.014524808153510094, -0.02455465868115425, -0.03394400328397751, 0.027230683714151382, -0.04563505947589874, 0.028050225228071213, -0.025537697598338127, -0.025856787338852882, -0.045796193182468414, 0.03208714351058006, 0.018110590055584908, 0.05024408549070358, 0.0025053450372070074, -0.011026735417544842, 0.01351237017661333, 0.01743626594543457, -0.03805181011557579, -0.03655577823519707, 0.02883770503103733, 0.004726559855043888, 0.007164419628679752, 0.052470702677965164, 0.004530127160251141, 0.010530885308980942, 0.003915068227797747, 0.015216737985610962, -0.006418404169380665, 0.005599501542747021, -0.017508933320641518, 0.05882502347230911, 0.06751539558172226, 0.008789757266640663, 0.03519551083445549, 0.04610542207956314, 0.00813077762722969, -0.0007227042806334794, -0.019063105806708336, 0.027859777212142944, 0.022963326424360275, -0.0070116869173944, -0.06183933466672897, -0.014575809240341187, -0.029552748426795006, -0.0017545550363138318, -0.021629299968481064, 0.01886974275112152, -0.019748905673623085, 0.018169013783335686, 0.029840415343642235, 0.02143680490553379, 0.02044139802455902, -0.014240605756640434, 0.02150155045092106, 0.020787827670574188, 0.027648670598864555, -0.009986232966184616, 0.020188748836517334, -0.019325710833072662, -0.02413015626370907, -0.017692724242806435, 0.0030138404108583927, 0.01998502016067505, -0.032529450953006744, -0.027563834562897682, 0.030771752819418907, -0.022099489346146584, 0.03458612784743309, -0.023835401982069016, 0.052558593451976776, -0.014258733950555325, -0.01345451083034277, -0.03548048064112663, 0.04405694827437401, 0.02062162011861801, 0.021168440580368042, -0.03304249793291092, 0.053830891847610474, -0.009976940229535103, 0.0060035730712115765, -0.055277541279792786, -0.05366511270403862, 0.008949581533670425, -0.007881257683038712, -0.033759087324142456, -0.02806680276989937, -0.017718758434057236, -0.0020694073755294085, 0.007178854662925005, 0.020860575139522552, 0.008177540265023708, -0.03572274371981621, -0.00207292172126472, -0.03602692484855652, -0.056083567440509796, 0.08484358340501785, -0.008131470531225204, -0.0317850261926651, 0.01922268606722355, -0.0016574080800637603, -0.01854596473276615, 0.015697089955210686, 0.00442729564383626, -0.039877310395240784, 0.016025418415665627, -0.008185514248907566, -0.0101469149813056, 0.024951890110969543, -0.0035079088993370533, 0.024996019899845123, -0.012520735152065754, 0.011934447102248669, 0.04045125097036362, -0.03447243943810463, 0.0007598132942803204, -0.040119584649801254, -0.009466523304581642, -0.02244741842150688, -0.011422967538237572, 0.00429451372474432, 0.005787697620689869, 0.011061415076255798, 0.01824677176773548, -0.0214703306555748, 0.005617366172373295, 0.06720621138811111, -0.003808494657278061, 0.0004904004745185375, 0.016093537211418152, -0.012458697892725468, 0.024129154160618782, -0.0014409222640097141, 0.006225727032870054, -0.0186793003231287, 0.03728383779525757, -0.03904136270284653, -0.006644860375672579, -0.027016794309020042, -0.02600269392132759, 0.02920926734805107, -0.02880781888961792, 0.051443103700876236, 0.03707502782344818, -0.015752321109175682, 0.033561620861291885, 0.018005453050136566, -0.018086804077029228, -0.05019574612379074, 0.02432454377412796, 0.02830616943538189, -0.046632420271635056, -0.025225447490811348, 0.0316917859017849, 0.016456596553325653, 0.03922361135482788, 0.07141021639108658, -0.020676810294389725, 0.003981295973062515, 0.04135720059275627, -0.03175009787082672, -0.032747846096754074, 0.0035114053171128035, -0.01960207149386406, 0.02080075442790985, -0.03411909192800522, -0.051063742488622665, 0.04667356610298157, 0.007941583171486855, -0.003018576418980956, -0.01072653941810131, -0.010156509466469288, -0.0453600212931633, 0.02554682455956936, 0.02563663013279438, -0.025461876764893532, -0.010357310995459557, -0.025681912899017334, 0.009488941170275211, -0.037104517221450806, 0.05177197977900505, -0.027180003002285957, -0.059310656040906906, -0.016023103147745132, -0.028449084609746933, -0.0566963292658329, 0.01396679226309061, -0.015467356890439987, -0.041402045637369156, 0.03218885883688927, -0.02052408829331398, 0.009005717001855373, -0.0013644248247146606, 0.044451288878917694, 0.005087241064757109, 0.07606326788663864, -0.008601444773375988, 0.044785987585783005, 0.010160432197153568, -0.033360227942466736, 0.11986487358808517, 0.06590449810028076, 0.032786283642053604, -0.07342266291379929, 0.010645152069628239, 0.03918632119894028, 0.003990366589277983, -0.005328030791133642, 0.006928649730980396, 0.01529078558087349, -0.003687129355967045, 0.04978509619832039, 0.06210288405418396, 0.000797504442743957, 0.05002579838037491, 0.06552191078662872, -0.032497748732566833, -0.04188261553645134, 0.0009110881946980953, 0.022570449858903885, -0.004266189411282539, -0.042334992438554764, -0.09286580979824066, 0.0006378536345437169, 0.05592520534992218, -0.0007040497730486095, -0.03523404151201248, -0.028757145628333092, 0.0028464870993047953, 0.03255939111113548, -0.04081336781382561, -0.0020903043914586306, 0.023967653512954712, 0.019675951451063156, 0.015952037647366524, -0.00890722032636404, 0.02458394691348076, -0.029074804857373238, 0.009085197001695633, 0.050261158496141434, 0.012963298708200455, -0.011986171826720238, -0.01964014209806919, 0.02862330712378025, -0.014334212057292461, -0.01808248460292816, -0.047941699624061584, 0.02146216854453087, -0.028354616835713387, 0.0058655873872339725, -0.04457911103963852, 0.004778160713613033, -0.013171558268368244, -0.020083170384168625, -0.06641633808612823, 0.027740467339754105, 0.00775441387668252, 0.021897876635193825, -0.014636838808655739, -0.014013737440109253, -0.0008589192293584347, -0.016504550352692604, 0.02278248406946659, 0.027304448187351227, -0.02315385825932026, -0.024309376254677773, -0.021914193406701088, 0.044980455189943314, 0.005954834632575512, -0.03594475984573364, 0.045447707176208496, -0.0403372161090374, -0.01943359524011612, 0.009342779405415058, -0.015292593277990818, -0.006781639531254768, -0.02767913229763508, -0.006095346063375473, 0.007662332616746426, 0.012299680151045322, 0.023166926577687263, 0.024885162711143494, -0.019624434411525726, -0.01647215709090233, -0.0024009402841329575, 0.004742060322314501, 0.06968241184949875, 0.03452837094664574, 0.03511760011315346, -0.025594376027584076, 0.0158038679510355, 0.06150693818926811, -0.00418981583788991, -0.0246263574808836, -0.02173229679465294, 0.00549789285287261, -0.024881761521100998, -0.016359712928533554, -0.025944208726286888, 0.04389799013733864, 0.02394404262304306, -0.031024400144815445, 0.009998907335102558, 0.012802735902369022, -0.022865740582346916, 0.014109914191067219, 0.008687835186719894, -0.08414759486913681, 0.007199008017778397, -0.023001257330179214, -0.020223518833518028, -0.06552842259407043, -0.01202145405113697, -0.010163992643356323, 0.005736621096730232, -0.006198547780513763, -0.006052304059267044, -0.04006464034318924, 0.016420414671301842, 0.0023061048705130816, -0.009417871944606304, -0.012582052499055862, -0.019093457609415054, -0.03888964653015137, -0.03179221972823143, -0.02572740986943245, -0.006247938610613346, 0.010255859233438969, 0.009874437004327774, 0.016074787825345993, 0.028801217675209045, 0.015771184116601944, -0.0008292734273709357, 0.01556819211691618, -0.02014782838523388, 0.06642651557922363, 0.015035889111459255, 0.004489182960242033, -0.023643745109438896, -0.06449100375175476, 0.010035723447799683, -0.057736728340387344, -0.024880360811948776, 0.015460632741451263, -0.013107473030686378, 0.022163022309541702, -0.026674948632717133, -0.02999691478908062, -0.019877545535564423, 0.023523684591054916, -0.020905328914523125, -0.01210685633122921, 0.013795617036521435, 0.005664137192070484, 0.05165886878967285, 0.007054626476019621, 0.0009132945560850203, -0.03797580674290657, -0.005373063497245312, 0.008582008071243763, 0.05194853991270065, 0.0016693193465471268, -0.020082194358110428, 0.027129478752613068, 0.004468236118555069, 0.003085144329816103, 0.011190117336809635, -0.0044299098663032055, 0.012727557681500912, 0.02718275785446167, -0.07651323825120926, 0.008817778900265694, -0.020571021363139153, 0.029910674318671227, -0.07603257894515991, -0.0022977038752287626, -0.00006605786620639265, -0.002192277228459716, 0.011018019169569016, -0.07297708839178085, 0.02043657749891281, 0.01972007006406784, -0.03337859362363815, 0.04808390140533447, 0.002744140801951289, 0.0170824583619833, -0.032096702605485916, 0.0191816333681345, -0.026354463770985603, 0.041469354182481766, 0.04750273749232292, 0.06151305511593819, 0.037637997418642044, 0.0003918171569239348, 0.014917708933353424, -0.04079639911651611, -0.010493949055671692, 0.005879842676222324, -0.005224177613854408, -0.07527384907007217, 0.03091081790626049, -0.013749648816883564, -0.025881526991724968, 0.0374869778752327, -0.019069209694862366, 0.04085064306855202, 0.007687575649470091, 0.027659103274345398, -0.029746223241090775, 0.07444792240858078, -0.003912622109055519, 0.015904132276773453, -0.056929849088191986, 0.03444162756204605, 0.04237731546163559, -0.004898624029010534, 0.01675454154610634, 0.007793281693011522, 0.06328874081373215, 0.0136561943218112, 0.0038026017136871815, 0.034600529819726944, 0.016362911090254784, -0.0026175028178840876, -0.0014790324494242668, -0.026318006217479706, 0.056376129388809204, -0.041851647198200226, 0.03411560133099556, -0.05817538499832153, -0.013923264108598232, 0.010457427240908146, -0.009932244196534157, 0.005657076835632324, 0.00005610289372270927, 0.009418264031410217, -0.06133951246738434, 0.02270968072116375, 0.002538513159379363, 0.0017252943944185972, -0.057076290249824524, 0.009785762056708336, -0.008009321056306362, -0.02593741938471794, 0.0030996392015367746, -0.014342078939080238, -0.012787776999175549, 0.047793708741664886, 0.017151428386569023, 0.0038814502768218517, 0.033980339765548706, -0.02245360240340233, 0.020490281283855438, -0.06773725897073746, 0.04874124005436897, 0.0394720584154129, 0.03525719791650772, -0.037275105714797974, 0.009875040501356125, -0.024071475490927696, -0.00007252227078424767, 0.02840464934706688, 0.0042673018760979176, 0.004938420839607716, -0.022904030978679657, 0.00787582527846098, 0.02175147458910942, -0.0625934973359108, -0.0005108910845592618, -0.014111499302089214, -0.045973241329193115, -0.043410930782556534, -0.007888373918831348, -0.006827452220022678, -0.0007593153859488666, 0.004489840008318424, 0.011925781145691872, -0.04537561908364296, -0.03075920045375824, -0.0149839511141181, 0.010691848583519459, 0.004843533970415592, -0.0021857330575585365, 0.03028518706560135, 0.014630550518631935, 0.008534708991646767, 0.03778763860464096, 0.003015618771314621, -0.04604731872677803, 0.020556654781103134, -0.029885781928896904, -0.03879401087760925, -0.002153928391635418, -0.020943569019436836, -0.018153145909309387, -0.04058726504445076, -0.008240271359682083, -0.025232763960957527, -0.0023249017540365458, 0.0026763100177049637, 0.02664305828511715, 0.012367692776024342, 0.05178772658109665, -0.005801372230052948, 0.024939239025115967, -0.02601630426943302, -0.005380716174840927, 0.021086907014250755, -0.0134377246722579, 0.008634787052869797, 0.03258262202143669, 0.020889248698949814, 0.005876528564840555, -0.01777038350701332, 0.02741570957005024, -0.012457427568733692, 0.015091648325324059, 0.0015440616989508271, -0.013182386755943298, -0.010892906226217747, -0.03910909220576286, 0.04570373147726059, 0.022605663165450096, 0.013647506944835186, 0.018922124058008194, -0.02826596237719059, 0.026723666116595268, -0.05757300555706024, -0.030992556363344193, 0.0026995043735951185, -0.02703353390097618, 0.02555280737578869, 0.024356521666049957, -0.044299930334091187, -0.021564684808254242, 0.02166980318725109, -0.009045426733791828, 0.05660460889339447, 0.009489581920206547, 0.04651659354567528, -0.016405221074819565, -0.01266546081751585, 0.01897086575627327, -0.0257817842066288, 0.009333106689155102, -0.01972055993974209, 0.055257949978113174, 0.01793096773326397, -0.014199629426002502, -0.0027206391096115112, 0.010115946643054485, -0.004714008886367083, 0.036159951239824295, -0.06031413748860359, -0.034410152584314346, -0.05209444835782051, 0.02756768837571144, 0.019233180209994316, -0.03938642889261246 ]
<p>If I'm watching a series of accounts for transactions going in and transactions going out, I want to notice unusually large or transactions for any particular account on any particular day.</p> <p>So if account A typically moves a few hundred dollars and one day moves five thousand dollars, that's a clear outlier. If account B typically moves a few million dollars in or out and one day moves 20 million dollars, that's a clear outlier. </p> <p>What I'd like to do is present a measure that should highlight outliers - I was thinking number of standard deviations versus a population of the rolling last 60 days, but I'm wondering if that's correct. I'm checking to see if it's a gaussian distribution, but are there better ways to hit what I'm looking for?</p> <p>I think this poses a different set of questions than <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/1223/robust-outlier-detection-in-financial-timeseries">Robust outlier detection in financial timeseries</a>. </p>
37,254
[ -0.0345061831176281, -0.0013463407522067428, -0.008680027909576893, 0.007238158490508795, 0.04739833250641823, 0.005711898673325777, 0.007248621433973312, -0.032204121351242065, 0.024362429976463318, -0.011619209311902523, 0.05666232481598854, 0.050553563982248306, 0.052314452826976776, 0.025921009480953217, -0.015981433913111687, -0.029990186914801598, -0.03212742507457733, 0.009303687140345573, -0.006746862083673477, -0.02148141711950302, -0.0029020546935498714, 0.02571902796626091, 0.03768492490053177, -0.014925669878721237, -0.04362679272890091, 0.03771402686834335, 0.04564014822244644, -0.001623546821065247, -0.00032779513276182115, 0.05094653740525246, -0.07734296470880508, -0.028000783175230026, 0.049627333879470825, 0.022759754210710526, 0.049641720950603485, -0.006139041855931282, -0.004634343087673187, -0.02840805985033512, -0.024418914690613747, 0.02301028184592724, -0.02249339036643505, -0.02323325164616108, 0.019734807312488556, 0.0384707897901535, -0.0034572333097457886, 0.004231870174407959, -0.012358029372990131, -0.013241326436400414, 0.04555818438529968, -0.048784494400024414, 0.08602415025234222, -0.02642098255455494, 0.026565607637166977, 0.003132064361125231, 0.0061601875349879265, -0.0014269092353060842, 0.032322224229574203, 0.08270653337240219, -0.0012602981878444552, -0.05132429301738739, -0.026965662837028503, 0.0076728821732103825, -0.019168883562088013, -0.03556691110134125, -0.02774972654879093, 0.03144744038581848, -0.0029279435984790325, -0.02776379883289337, 0.03757360950112343, -0.028785811737179756, -0.01213422417640686, -0.0022940700873732567, 0.014762045815587044, 0.011370965279638767, -0.0030999307055026293, -0.04225662723183632, 0.0148417167365551, 0.01375193614512682, 0.07714197039604187, 0.04281020909547806, 0.02223578281700611, -0.005032695829868317, -0.006199135445058346, 0.01834474503993988, 0.03201746940612793, 0.0007889539701864123, 0.09160042554140091, -0.06336438655853271, 0.008098340593278408, 0.054611485451459885, 0.014091068878769875, -0.0025139746721833944, 0.02371266670525074, 0.019519442692399025, -0.06525868922472, 0.018714167177677155, -0.014065202325582504, 0.005477334838360548, -0.019903773441910744, -0.013832921162247658, -0.014791877940297127, -0.049141354858875275, 0.01545027643442154, 0.06394036114215851, -0.012750162743031979, 0.02806902676820755, 0.005524358246475458, -0.027579303830862045, -0.036364682018756866, -0.028508763760328293, -0.06374954432249069, -0.008757125586271286, -0.01259925588965416, 0.0021243926603347063, -0.002163136610761285, 0.019254842773079872, -0.0053808726370334625, -0.01988721638917923, 0.028874024748802185, 0.05706825852394104, 0.03202536329627037, 0.00696106581017375, 0.006845737807452679, -0.031420037150382996, -0.014190076850354671, 0.018802564591169357, 0.018757279962301254, 0.0019634743221104145, -0.05073801055550575, 0.04558493196964264, 0.0034344817977398634, -0.004690565634518862, 0.04654507339000702, -0.016397947445511818, 0.04090546816587448, -0.013240717351436615, -0.0928557813167572, -0.043416641652584076, 0.06912887841463089, 0.05085866525769234, -0.010059777647256851, -0.07072819024324417, -0.036590225994586945, 0.03250866010785103, -0.004725738428533077, 0.03647611662745476, 0.03542351722717285, 0.018579162657260895, 0.030617600306868553, 0.006352591328322887, -0.04502366855740547, 0.01733483374118805, -0.018007511273026466, -0.02681472711265087, -0.007121811620891094, -0.07292257994413376, 0.004090094473212957, 0.04182300344109535, -0.015322763472795486, -0.013805968686938286, -0.0034111030399799347, 0.034067731350660324, -0.018114037811756134, -0.02953181602060795, 0.024025188758969307, -0.009272766299545765, 0.0625014379620552, 0.02579948678612709, 0.046346504241228104, 0.017620135098695755, -0.016634277999401093, 0.014219891279935837, 0.04102460667490959, 0.003801961662247777, 0.04601212590932846, -0.005219475831836462, -0.01831086352467537, -0.009231340140104294, -0.011442990973591805, 0.0011478048982098699, -0.03599805757403374, -0.0396275594830513, -0.05129129812121391, -0.018118958920240402, 0.021285390481352806, 0.01723395101726055, 0.02341628074645996, -0.005985753145068884, 0.020726345479488373, -0.06458651274442673, -0.024069029837846756, -0.023502254858613014, 0.015705758705735207, -0.03618602454662323, -0.03706437349319458, -0.0010551664745435119, -0.013589184731245041, 0.0130500802770257, -0.022042326629161835, 0.0034559748601168394, 0.010083192028105259, 0.0027905660681426525, 0.03132185339927673, -0.06269747763872147, -0.003219849430024624, 0.026636088266968727, 0.032375022768974304, -0.018797894939780235, 0.017076406627893448, -0.044835373759269714, -0.036767713725566864, -0.004466560203582048, -0.06636076420545578, 0.02463386580348015, 0.02487225830554962, 0.0008060148684307933, 0.04747091233730316, 0.007085748016834259, -0.02713819220662117, 0.01711304858326912, 0.009292724542319775, 0.06287207454442978, 0.04425666108727455, 0.001712271710857749, -0.014237788505852222, -0.020332152023911476, 0.001022947602905333, -0.0038766241632401943, -0.01966439187526703, -0.0007782586035318673, -0.054168134927749634, -0.014126462861895561, 0.016115080565214157, 0.04277114197611809, -0.031139986589550972, 0.011299547739326954, 0.08502119779586792, 0.019485149532556534, -0.018623001873493195, -0.013100952841341496, -0.01842460222542286, -0.04063742980360985, -0.004948417190462351, -0.00684072682633996, 0.013675260357558727, 0.0064165834337472916, 0.03918920457363129, 0.005324618890881538, 0.03340732678771019, 0.02289365418255329, 0.03606909513473511, 0.004133168607950211, -0.002528522629290819, 0.027331756427884102, -0.05579414963722229, 0.00248144892975688, 0.02718600630760193, 0.000024863378712325357, -0.006966033019125462, 0.02917047031223774, -0.0009025183971971273, 0.022962069138884544, 0.01593751832842827, -0.03572966903448105, 0.005573068279772997, 0.011663734912872314, -0.00914133619517088, 0.01537279225885868, 0.029267223551869392, -0.0507374033331871, 0.019172303378582, -0.02262590453028679, -0.020900020375847816, -0.0302897822111845, 0.02593165822327137, 0.0414833202958107, 0.0008462899713777006, -0.0006578253814950585, -0.022942349314689636, -0.03365457430481911, -0.0047734021209180355, 0.015978172421455383, -0.005553825292736292, -0.013776533305644989, -0.07583983242511749, 0.05604059621691704, -0.004776578862220049, -0.018726827576756477, 0.007075245026499033, -0.057582300156354904, 0.038314905017614365, 0.03282827138900757, 0.02152743563055992, -0.028114883229136467, 0.012823231518268585, -0.03636699914932251, 0.056330833584070206, -0.03536480665206909, -0.03579331934452057, 0.053668636828660965, -0.00664861872792244, -0.060676272958517075, 0.008776434697210789, -0.018149586394429207, -0.022499773651361465, -0.05912712961435318, -0.005083303898572922, 0.01576134003698826, -0.029560783877968788, 0.004289745353162289, 0.013971316628158092, -0.001293419860303402, -0.02729155123233795, -0.06615350395441055, -0.05308867245912552, -0.030058935284614563, 0.003722425550222397, 0.04354335367679596, 0.005159406457096338, -0.008811469189822674, 0.038119688630104065, 0.023647326976060867, -0.024493029341101646, -0.02920798398554325, -0.02850894257426262, -0.028587892651557922, -0.04434076324105263, 0.02985045500099659, 0.016844812780618668, 0.017785537987947464, -0.0035324287600815296, 0.000358943419996649, 0.01110388245433569, 0.05008140578866005, 0.03699188306927681, -0.0322394035756588, -0.007124073337763548, -0.01854972168803215, 0.0194234699010849, 0.052475932985544205, 0.038421571254730225, -0.04929149150848389, 0.003992808051407337, 0.018501920625567436, 0.038758616894483566, 0.03749281167984009, -0.02637205831706524, 0.02194155752658844, -0.014592894352972507, -0.006499133538454771, -0.014539913274347782, 0.011809351854026318, -0.0004123601538594812, -0.001684660674072802, -0.04140539467334747, -0.0018094738479703665, 0.01172590535134077, -0.02155965007841587, 0.023195242509245872, 0.09115847200155258, 0.05988926440477371, -0.0017908420413732529, 0.008847887627780437, -0.040358807891607285, -0.014247043989598751, -0.008772457018494606, -0.018891751766204834, -0.027317911386489868, 0.030313357710838318, 0.021989760920405388, 0.018298184499144554, -0.0032852787990123034, -0.04468007758259773, -0.026184890419244766, -0.10374067723751068, -0.009933664463460445, -0.033514343202114105, 0.07253073155879974, 0.04121981933712959, 0.022852787747979164, 0.022068491205573082, -0.03110031969845295, -0.03476664423942566, -0.027281709015369415, -0.06427735090255737, 0.0490439236164093, -0.018475418910384178, -0.024497952312231064, 0.009086566045880318, -0.013801700435578823, 0.013836479745805264, -0.01658535562455654, 0.03792181238532066, -0.02514093928039074, 0.056373950093984604, -0.01867447979748249, -0.00017986726015806198, -0.0027389279566705227, -0.018714990466833115, -0.019110307097434998, -0.008676931262016296, 0.031008709222078323, -0.022011350840330124, 0.08582721650600433, 0.025786127895116806, 0.012284425087273121, -0.03271803632378578, -0.009542621672153473, 0.015091667883098125, 0.007780913263559341, 0.019591819494962692, -0.003619228955358267, 0.000039006361475912854, -0.03355463966727257, 0.05408827215433121, 0.006100357975810766, 0.026229940354824066, 0.019501160830259323, -0.008624651469290257, -0.0074373590759932995, -0.03490326926112175, -0.012552295811474323, 0.03346254676580429, -0.0020098157692700624, 0.007052651606500149, -0.003760464722290635, 0.037133414298295975, -0.0024512812960892916, -0.04861783981323242, 0.021075088530778885, 0.07957692444324493, 0.02032887004315853, -0.003446448827162385, -0.0014382802182808518, -0.04285538196563721, 0.0037629837170243263, -0.016496185213327408, -0.011272761039435863, 0.018478961661458015, 0.018286921083927155, 0.022724518552422523, 0.006113132461905479, -0.00885037425905466, -0.015417180955410004, -0.016827819868922234, 0.01670432835817337, 0.0578305758535862, 0.00599674554541707, 0.0036979697179049253, 0.02041170373558998, 0.03013545460999012, 0.05629903823137283, 0.0595865435898304, 0.00445031700655818, -0.09148188680410385, 0.005623823031783104, 0.0537918396294117, 0.03893652185797691, -0.018698930740356445, -0.022034557536244392, -0.028607679530978203, 0.011865586042404175, 0.01868617907166481, -0.04474719241261482, 0.028883831575512886, -0.023125512525439262, -0.004044880159199238, -0.010061943903565407, -0.019257446750998497, -0.03662116825580597, 0.012082584202289581, -0.0006912883254699409, 0.01773584820330143, 0.002059187740087509, -0.036114033311605453, -0.06393852829933167, -0.008653262630105019, 0.0037910002283751965, 0.06341993808746338, -0.012423427775502205, -0.011500990949571133, 0.013405418954789639, 0.03921429440379143, -0.029448527842760086, -0.07231960445642471, 0.02305024303495884, 0.0026403646916151047, -0.013672122731804848, 0.04093852639198303, -0.005280462559312582, -0.056258801370859146, 0.002181505085900426, 0.0215559471398592, 0.006268257275223732, -0.002445174613967538, -0.027867555618286133, 0.054767757654190063, 0.051367491483688354, 0.04226630926132202, 0.038426775485277176, 0.08964860439300537, 0.018800895661115646, 0.024864640086889267, -0.0012817351380363107, 0.015408669598400593, -0.02895285002887249, -0.026990989223122597, -0.0145347211509943, -0.019884636625647545, -0.05211661756038666, 0.01059700921177864, -0.025632956996560097, 0.028187783434987068, -0.018047010526061058, -0.027459165081381798, -0.0005238520679995418, 0.05464496463537216, 0.019253989681601524, -0.012024573981761932, -0.0030933632515370846, 0.015488449484109879, -0.01411889586597681, 0.010440593585371971, 0.04332394152879715, -0.016536254435777664, -0.0005750081036239862, 0.020504571497440338, -0.032234374433755875, 0.011159520596265793, -0.04638875648379326, -0.0063515109941363335, -0.019923944026231766, 0.011497778818011284, 0.06640026718378067, -0.005391795188188553, 0.04341517388820648, 0.01656448468565941, 0.011916060000658035, 0.015097828581929207, 0.054448820650577545, -0.00829098466783762, 0.01646830514073372, -0.03863638639450073, 0.02676381729543209, -0.022811641916632652, -0.02003786899149418, -0.08346612006425858, -0.038526687771081924, 0.06513988971710205, 0.02647208236157894, -0.027353808283805847, -0.01895340159535408, 0.005834910087287426, -0.015073653310537338, 0.0055894446559250355, -0.029781118035316467, 0.014420284889638424, -0.004990642424672842, -0.03719206526875496, 0.004037706647068262, 0.030420761555433273, 0.07895106077194214, -0.018658632412552834, -0.023517990484833717, -0.0026700193993747234, 0.011143136769533157, -0.029804203659296036, 0.0032443704549223185, 0.0020821401849389076, -0.03842071071267128, -0.05012578144669533, -0.04256086423993111, 0.014449033886194229, -0.021825015544891357, -0.04860933870077133, -0.012814538553357124, 0.005038473289459944, -0.04465818405151367, 0.034876298159360886, -0.013317156583070755, 0.019874224439263344, 0.012708772905170918, -0.036576613783836365, -0.027475601062178612, -0.006747149396687746, 0.026762649416923523, -0.025785570964217186, -0.007191692478954792, 0.019360708072781563, -0.03703422471880913, 0.017421282827854156, 0.037545345723629, -0.04194795340299606, 0.01781107857823372, -0.009609266184270382, -0.012334387749433517, 0.047266438603401184, -0.02918417565524578, -0.005431069992482662, 0.008360967971384525, 0.004111022688448429, -0.031739335507154465, -0.0304058026522398, -0.025319267064332962, -0.02085956372320652, 0.027442986145615578, 0.029470959678292274, 0.04374288022518158, 0.01761244237422943, 0.01909717544913292, 0.014717481099069118, -0.03228974714875221, -0.022082988172769547, -0.007910443469882011, -0.020475218072533607, 0.0032120244577527046, -0.013984841294586658, 0.06490332633256912, 0.004146946594119072, 0.0048775202594697475, 0.030284468084573746, 0.03572545573115349, 0.024482758715748787, 0.02417442947626114, 0.04423704370856285, -0.020295780152082443, -0.026741567999124527, 0.03202761337161064, -0.04251137375831604, 0.023414388298988342, -0.011923929676413536, -0.03407248109579086, 0.031475894153118134, 0.021974561735987663, -0.015003390610218048, -0.014871852472424507, 0.03189234808087349, -0.07146113365888596, 0.01137022115290165, 0.032777801156044006, -0.026546943932771683, 0.012735710479319096, -0.0004303747264202684, 0.07099422067403793, -0.017665347084403038, 0.02102866768836975, -0.037180203944444656, -0.06436246633529663, -0.015562771819531918, -0.017603758722543716, -0.06097887456417084, 0.0408574678003788, -0.01785997673869133, -0.015428733080625534, 0.003432995406910777, -0.053031306713819504, -0.016474178060889244, 0.025670332834124565, 0.012828649953007698, -0.01649121567606926, 0.07120663672685623, -0.0316687747836113, 0.007288515567779541, -0.007295959163457155, -0.0020319935865700245, 0.11910553276538849, 0.07557091116905212, 0.041892632842063904, -0.018729019910097122, -0.0004408057138789445, 0.025033075362443924, 0.016083793714642525, -0.01630423218011856, -0.010428882203996181, -0.0012654737802222371, 0.0026712515391409397, 0.03346486762166023, 0.04232785850763321, -0.00562231196090579, -0.005505376495420933, 0.059588722884655, -0.031151745468378067, 0.020128099247813225, 0.015383771620690823, 0.032930608838796616, 0.027916358783841133, 0.026282109320163727, -0.09583434462547302, 0.04311433807015419, -0.027414603158831596, -0.011483964510262012, -0.00619629118591547, -0.02395457588136196, -0.028748715296387672, 0.00873421598225832, 0.0010069012641906738, -0.012849079445004463, 0.030696658417582512, -0.015168331563472748, 0.02450358122587204, -0.02165660262107849, 0.017625631764531136, -0.04707448557019234, 0.0020946140866726637, 0.01758652552962303, -0.012603294104337692, -0.0027468970511108637, 0.02566748484969139, 0.012613620609045029, -0.053776584565639496, -0.04377276822924614, -0.034641411155462265, 0.014210200868546963, -0.0016974728787317872, -0.005718732252717018, -0.02361486852169037, -0.008232044987380505, 0.02259087562561035, -0.04570498690009117, -0.026914268732070923, 0.007826033979654312, 0.03854456543922424, -0.0055329930037260056, -0.041697897017002106, 0.001661765854805708, 0.021792519837617874, -0.0014486192958429456, 0.052766699343919754, -0.004216141067445278, -0.01796570234000683, -0.01282981876283884, 0.002566241892054677, 0.05152549222111702, 0.014179332181811333, 0.023083724081516266, 0.005932983476668596, -0.022659169510006905, -0.034246619790792465, 0.017359761521220207, 0.023354733362793922, -0.011416759341955185, -0.00361455837264657, 0.020786255598068237, 0.009599406272172928, 0.005324001424014568, -0.0030814362689852715, 0.05266920477151871, -0.02071542479097843, 0.00015925899788271636, -0.05032056197524071, 0.014639205299317837, 0.03906214237213135, 0.012357491068542004, 0.03899881988763809, 0.02646632492542267, -0.009611877612769604, 0.07412054389715195, 0.03581570088863373, -0.043060075491666794, 0.014712176285684109, 0.001268130843527615, -0.020179426297545433, -0.014138302765786648, 0.01426792237907648, 0.06092626601457596, 0.04331007972359657, -0.0010931385913863778, 0.0002736605529207736, 0.030807841569185257, -0.025636937469244003, -0.008305431343615055, 0.038102276623249054, -0.06197955831885338, -0.0370708629488945, 0.013110272586345673, -0.01701994612812996, -0.027479946613311768, -0.020329399034380913, -0.014357401989400387, 0.012435471639037132, 0.01254804152995348, 0.032814521342515945, -0.05031551048159599, 0.02735655941069126, -0.007899822667241096, 0.0314386822283268, -0.027454590424895287, 0.002575853606685996, -0.03437157720327377, -0.03665206953883171, -0.02817581780254841, 0.012368325144052505, 0.006213882938027382, 0.04248538985848427, 0.013843677006661892, 0.007463053800165653, 0.006507955491542816, 0.02703287824988365, 0.02085241675376892, -0.0012031634105369449, -0.0001266988110728562, -0.028842898085713387, 0.013702663592994213, -0.02469887211918831, -0.017973678186535835, 0.07222043722867966, 0.0023052000906318426, -0.007621050346642733, 0.03827197104692459, 0.0009610673296265304, 0.023724786937236786, -0.013383131474256516, -0.006538420915603638, -0.019248507916927338, 0.03135418891906738, -0.0024611251428723335, -0.004486844874918461, -0.02668689750134945, 0.02182103879749775, 0.0065043093636631966, -0.030710479244589806, 0.01610754430294037, 0.016198692843317986, -0.03681444376707077, 0.0019501785282045603, 0.04788803309202194, 0.006053617224097252, -0.027185704559087753, -0.016350626945495605, 0.01599622331559658, 0.021046029403805733, -0.02021617814898491, 0.0038396394811570644, 0.07305388152599335, 0.0029232571832835674, -0.03306582197546959, 0.006582650821655989, -0.05046100541949272, 0.026584357023239136, -0.07607495039701462, -0.0012687024427577853, 0.0015495482366532087, 0.0009272839524783194, 0.039751384407281876, -0.041569944471120834, -0.00319481547921896, 0.06443934142589569, -0.05875692144036293, 0.02892642840743065, -0.02269148826599121, -0.02097506634891033, -0.027903560549020767, 0.003483620472252369, 0.0008553921361453831, 0.03685082122683525, 0.0017986759776249528, 0.003681449918076396, 0.0517309308052063, 0.05004364624619484, -0.021898292005062103, -0.048389725387096405, 0.006943300366401672, 0.023460164666175842, 0.03277156874537468, -0.04499046131968498, 0.012257590889930725, -0.010682911612093449, 0.02244715206325054, 0.037628065794706345, -0.0031034047715365887, 0.03204882889986038, -0.010690167546272278, 0.022090880200266838, 0.016752192750573158, 0.04055219516158104, 0.050290659070014954, 0.033455561846494675, -0.00984437670558691, -0.013158001936972141, 0.003317669965326786, 0.04102290794253349, 0.013585899025201797, 0.0079012056812644, 0.013243954628705978, -0.022199232131242752, -0.016793925315141678, -0.009751013480126858, -0.004778358619660139, -0.01347670890390873, 0.007924281060695648, 0.017765063792467117, 0.01854514516890049, -0.03603968769311905, 0.01560896448791027, -0.010840674862265587, 0.01256620604544878, 0.018808240070939064, 0.009949009865522385, -0.02122151479125023, 0.03003944270312786, -0.00408585462719202, -0.03250110521912575, 0.005026817321777344, -0.020513635128736496, -0.020677337422966957, -0.07569487392902374, -0.026370897889137268, -0.031967125833034515, -0.01717376336455345, -0.024799680337309837, 0.008557526394724846, -0.025985749438405037, 0.056592125445604324, 0.004436233080923557, 0.028683137148618698, 0.04271495342254639, -0.013128355145454407, -0.028956562280654907, -0.08947665244340897, 0.07208309322595596, 0.016194945201277733, -0.0023512132465839386, -0.018727416172623634, -0.037270087748765945, -0.03767295181751251, -0.019662782549858093, 0.0659346729516983, 0.02038714289665222, -0.009997008368372917, 0.020342817530035973, 0.014215297996997833, -0.005702403374016285, -0.044934775680303574, 0.03433162346482277, -0.01585628092288971, -0.028167029842734337, 0.0050748661160469055, -0.049889370799064636, 0.00031839177245274186, -0.011199044063687325, 0.01940736547112465, -0.016309350728988647, -0.0007471294957213104, 0.021868016570806503, -0.02868402935564518, 0.05587045103311539, 0.025538209825754166, -0.038163475692272186, 0.019891932606697083, 0.013961965218186378, 0.003946378827095032, 0.033275455236434937, -0.015266906470060349, -0.05188428983092308, 0.03971700742840767, -0.03981112688779831, -0.05324895679950714, 0.006600324530154467, -0.004644640255719423, -0.01187771838158369, -0.07831621915102005, -0.024456670507788658, 0.026822401210665703, -0.013472989201545715, 0.029622619971632957, 0.024826092645525932, -0.005770387593656778, 0.048525888472795486, -0.010674552991986275, 0.020944790914654732, 0.009838796220719814, -0.02882770635187626, -0.00595167325809598, 0.01142489816993475, 0.020002486184239388, 0.015472924336791039, 0.013419749215245247, 0.03149230033159256, 0.01622171513736248, 0.055145252496004105, -0.024753835052251816, 0.012975146993994713, -0.024551469832658768, -0.007403993513435125, -0.00029678535065613687, -0.02031644806265831, 0.014938900247216225, 0.03213873505592346, -0.020674699917435646, 0.038711901754140854, -0.03901141881942749, -0.012961241416633129, -0.022477881982922554, 0.0035130649339407682, -0.018566496670246124, -0.0018227942055091262, 0.03531442955136299, 0.019067013636231422, -0.056031469255685806, -0.00915614329278469, 0.01297956146299839, 0.028884492814540863, 0.009351016953587532, -0.027463188394904137, 0.03839580714702606, -0.010024886578321457, 0.02847202867269516, -0.040401048958301544, -0.02424442209303379, -0.05457059666514397, -0.0003985495714005083, -0.0032372234854847193, 0.03212778642773628, 0.002315347781404853, -0.02325664460659027, -0.04226768761873245, -0.01966683566570282, 0.030802983790636063, -0.0764322578907013, 0.020776651799678802, -0.05271585285663605, 0.04300519824028015, -0.024878734722733498, -0.0611264742910862 ]
<p>I am trying to work out Example 2 from Casella and George's paper "Explaining the Gibbs Sampler" in R.</p> <p>The example is:</p> <pre><code>f(x | y) = y*exp(-yx) f(y | x) = x*exp(-xy) where x, y are defined on [0,B] </code></pre> <p>The idea is to generate the distribution of f(x).</p> <p>My code (below) works, but what I do not understand is the role of the interval on which x and y are defined. In the paper this interval is [0, B]. In their example, the authors say that their simulation uses B = 5, but I am not clear where to incorporate this into my code...</p> <pre><code>X = rep(0, 500) Y = rep(0, 500) k = 15 for (i in 1:500) { x = rep(1, k) y = rep(1, k) for (j in 2:k) { x[j] = y[j-1]*rexp(1, y[j-1]) y[j] = x[j]*rexp(1, x[j]) } X[i] = x[k] Y[i] = y[k] } print(max(X)) print(max(Y)) hist(X, breaks=40, freq=F) </code></pre>
74,391
[ 0.00591210788115859, -0.024017808958888054, 0.0342990905046463, 0.0015778056113049388, 0.03634954243898392, 0.0038339579477906227, 0.007630832958966494, -0.03564762696623802, 0.022862661629915237, -0.013492502272129059, 0.03643544390797615, 0.047388721257448196, 0.04472075030207634, 0.04664308577775955, 0.010633010417222977, 0.011897068470716476, -0.03215437009930611, -0.021842829883098602, -0.011738794855773449, -0.02078954502940178, -0.01339808851480484, 0.026385722681879997, -0.007279384881258011, -0.03802201896905899, -0.0469244047999382, 0.0322079211473465, 0.019229095429182053, -0.004166020546108484, 0.027788454666733742, 0.08376844972372055, -0.0472056083381176, -0.06030343100428581, 0.012769151479005814, 0.002238793997094035, -0.016190912574529648, 0.028568623587489128, -0.046187952160835266, -0.05050644278526306, -0.017470724880695343, -0.012858916074037552, -0.049136996269226074, 0.020322628319263458, 0.024392258375883102, -0.000999276526272297, 0.0008633340476080775, 0.032788485288619995, -0.0034521296620368958, 0.0012451924849301577, 0.03301554173231125, -0.00820112507790327, 0.07296895980834961, 0.010884981602430344, 0.01177431270480156, 0.008056598715484142, -0.02713206224143505, -0.009523333050310612, 0.04132631793618202, 0.05448837950825691, -0.0032001014333218336, -0.07764200121164322, -0.03270701691508293, -0.03814254701137543, -0.014728139154613018, 0.0019299776758998632, -0.03400082886219025, -0.020897870883345604, -0.01141159888356924, -0.03980318456888199, 0.002185727236792445, 0.03015226125717163, 0.01115717925131321, 0.054679904133081436, 0.013611111789941788, -0.06274086982011795, 0.046930089592933655, 0.009070774540305138, 0.02203487977385521, 0.014975734055042267, 0.00468463683500886, 0.01896398887038231, -0.016552003100514412, 0.006321307271718979, 0.022242190316319466, 0.023115087300539017, -0.015922853723168373, 0.019357385113835335, 0.07542704790830612, -0.028813757002353668, 0.031017903238534927, 0.006815176922827959, -0.038778502494096756, -0.0028967566322535276, 0.056744012981653214, 0.000821705674752593, -0.05512508377432823, 0.04178912937641144, 0.02695307321846485, 0.029004624113440514, -0.020712587982416153, -0.012059865519404411, -0.017229262739419937, -0.07209022343158722, 0.023770611733198166, 0.04773004353046417, -0.014171537943184376, -0.011702189221978188, -0.016019320115447044, -0.0070753260515630245, 0.0052602761425077915, -0.0070886812172830105, -0.04289684072136879, -0.005128056742250919, -0.005479087121784687, 0.00041209516348317266, 0.055187683552503586, -0.011578552424907684, 0.001555482391268015, 0.010201417841017246, 0.026192637160420418, 0.008971011266112328, 0.06312046945095062, -0.002440518233925104, 0.008703656494617462, -0.021683651953935623, -0.039875712245702744, 0.0060500530526041985, -0.014090155251324177, 0.00543448468670249, -0.02261417545378208, 0.014161924831569195, -0.04512684792280197, -0.00989016517996788, 0.02266085147857666, 0.03584487736225128, 0.01717391237616539, -0.007637691218405962, -0.08819499611854553, -0.07307526469230652, 0.061918459832668304, -0.0007230330375023186, 0.04440990835428238, -0.05023086071014404, 0.04338278993964195, 0.0013257937971502542, 0.019576333463191986, -0.009475131519138813, 0.009663539938628674, -0.017032504081726074, 0.01929924450814724, 0.016615087166428566, -0.07081528007984161, 0.005735090933740139, -0.008141525089740753, -0.0026769910473376513, -0.003913892898708582, -0.06048349663615227, 0.013303841464221478, 0.02679700404405594, -0.009146185591816902, -0.015617812052369118, 0.05109172686934471, -0.018902013078331947, -0.010461914353072643, 0.000625570653937757, -0.01485133171081543, -0.026235496625304222, 0.09581465274095535, 0.021562373265624046, 0.0394921749830246, -0.00041946483543142676, -0.015553470700979233, 0.005921961273998022, 0.003251665038987994, 0.046588413417339325, 0.03461971506476402, -0.02916363812983036, 0.012176127173006535, -0.007417474407702684, 0.024631759151816368, 0.008937756530940533, -0.035148657858371735, -0.0006237897323444486, 0.009581492282450199, -0.04047982022166252, 0.0011837681522592902, 0.011791839264333248, -0.0015692347660660744, 0.016185862943530083, 0.03394446149468422, -0.08127349615097046, -0.04853768274188042, -0.055199772119522095, -0.0023253641556948423, 0.00008523732685716823, -0.056952618062496185, -0.04059358313679695, 0.017016833648085594, 0.04653595760464668, 0.009691269136965275, -0.01260570902377367, -0.02888999506831169, -0.03349793329834938, 0.051515575498342514, 0.0063907308503985405, -0.02151511050760746, 0.04111185669898987, 0.04425351694226265, -0.0017633114475756884, 0.03969455137848854, -0.05091871693730354, -0.044581037014722824, 0.029475893825292587, -0.03015989251434803, 0.007022497244179249, 0.02649002894759178, -0.02848544530570507, -0.00827623438090086, 0.01162062305957079, -0.0035422840155661106, 0.013876430690288544, -0.04575919359922409, 0.019815469160676003, 0.06489363312721252, 0.037262339144945145, 0.004159728530794382, 0.015448175370693207, 0.0013751068618148565, 0.045959897339344025, -0.019094867631793022, 0.013469991274178028, -0.05360163375735283, -0.009225517511367798, 0.014208948239684105, 0.017093569040298462, -0.010364060290157795, 0.004866065923124552, 0.04547673463821411, -0.02995068021118641, 0.02247786708176136, 0.03832341358065605, 0.0274687297642231, -0.010710085742175579, 0.028849201276898384, 0.02013801783323288, 0.06060882657766342, -0.00646955007687211, 0.028971493244171143, -0.019168049097061157, 0.04587075114250183, -0.011549355462193489, -0.02478933520615101, 0.01696585677564144, 0.007605585735291243, 0.03247975558042526, -0.003519057994708419, -0.006452295929193497, 0.01754222810268402, -0.005064427852630615, -0.010182098485529423, 0.02988891862332821, 0.020797986537218094, 0.00005047347440267913, -0.01111405249685049, -0.011673608794808388, 0.027838535606861115, 0.050576530396938324, -0.032053254544734955, 0.0024353715125471354, 0.016673803329467773, 0.0001838493626564741, 0.028068069368600845, -0.01337660476565361, -0.039717238396406174, -0.035859186202287674, 0.001492597977630794, 0.027846431359648705, 0.013557206839323044, 0.04148820415139198, -0.008828649297356606, -0.02343408577144146, 0.008246502839028835, -0.004265814088284969, 0.032043952494859695, -0.005138888023793697, -0.048541028052568436, 0.028030220419168472, 0.005053367465734482, -0.030848989263176918, -0.023205218836665154, -0.014825379475951195, -0.03562485799193382, 0.010981215164065361, -0.02350454591214657, -0.0052635930478572845, -0.004040682688355446, -0.0038234300445765257, 0.023652812466025352, -0.0035649144556373358, -0.014944463968276978, 0.043410491198301315, 0.041592638939619064, -0.04702546447515488, 0.010265220887959003, -0.039213355630636215, -0.012787106446921825, -0.06579024344682693, 0.0038978452794253826, 0.011138993315398693, 0.04154134541749954, -0.007483558263629675, 0.039576735347509384, -0.021257147192955017, -0.036963868886232376, -0.02251904085278511, -0.06892313063144684, -0.0014099350664764643, -0.015057280659675598, 0.013804840855300426, -0.02171672321856022, 0.03275348246097565, 0.08176974952220917, 0.04255342110991478, -0.01580299437046051, -0.04453522711992264, -0.040906380861997604, 0.00426854845136404, 0.010260975919663906, 0.0128112668171525, 0.04026499763131142, 0.006102636456489563, 0.026526151224970818, 0.020437495782971382, 0.049258042126894, 0.08161814510822296, -0.03492746129631996, -0.004957216326147318, -0.030810993164777756, -0.014461592771112919, -0.03182664141058922, 0.04686965420842171, 0.005629669409245253, -0.03410624712705612, 0.004240396898239851, 0.005162883084267378, 0.035956066101789474, 0.026686042547225952, -0.037390854209661484, 0.00793787557631731, -0.05079837888479233, 0.0020071701146662235, -0.03704867511987686, 0.05086911842226982, -0.002308627823367715, -0.06865662336349487, 0.00788454245775938, 0.007855136878788471, 0.04589826986193657, -0.024910273030400276, -0.03410647064447403, 0.03889702633023262, 0.0023334252182394266, -0.04699883982539177, 0.0066924793645739555, -0.017999567091464996, -0.044403187930583954, 0.01781659573316574, -0.02316529117524624, -0.023403441533446312, 0.025653066113591194, 0.020510245114564896, 0.031688984483480453, 0.0019513025181367993, -0.05410178750753403, -0.0036312537267804146, -0.05402306094765663, 0.018660925328731537, -0.026157256215810776, 0.04587060958147049, 0.028848256915807724, 0.05428158491849899, -0.021757274866104126, 0.003351307474076748, -0.0031959661282598972, -0.02259645238518715, -0.08686172217130661, 0.024464761838316917, -0.0015526142669841647, -0.039780549705028534, -0.01073344238102436, -0.04996699094772339, 0.06872043758630753, -0.006570889614522457, 0.018734483048319817, 0.02622099593281746, -0.022982297465205193, -0.08040766417980194, -0.007014659699052572, -0.03282855451107025, -0.014144293032586575, -0.015858184546232224, -0.02317965403199196, 0.0806327611207962, -0.025411078706383705, 0.06823860853910446, 0.03941875696182251, -0.004557060543447733, 0.019605495035648346, 0.012349128723144531, 0.026106053963303566, 0.063132643699646, 0.028240812942385674, 0.05215509980916977, 0.03053106740117073, -0.004362397361546755, 0.032822251319885254, -0.003101790091022849, 0.06075777858495712, 0.07944468408823013, -0.04012536630034447, 0.006955132819712162, 0.014068587683141232, 0.01693272404372692, 0.025269590318202972, -0.00869380310177803, -0.035982705652713776, 0.020334120839834213, 0.046277377754449844, 0.021469833329319954, -0.022721795365214348, 0.016322702169418335, 0.0647314190864563, -0.02061809040606022, 0.010625762864947319, -0.03869671747088432, -0.023199183866381645, 0.003234315197914839, 0.02483668178319931, 0.02801835536956787, 0.005328993313014507, -0.0075817108154296875, 0.03391579911112785, 0.048724465072155, -0.016527054831385612, -0.028745189309120178, 0.01766805164515972, 0.04284790903329849, 0.04733353480696678, -0.03125128149986267, -0.02508113719522953, -0.01555725745856762, 0.00015320569218602031, 0.01824084110558033, 0.0035778130404651165, -0.038083020597696304, -0.07022829353809357, -0.013341636396944523, 0.04874275624752045, 0.04517865926027298, -0.0009392629726789892, 0.0015940808225423098, -0.048401422798633575, -0.006122400052845478, 0.017898425459861755, -0.05115613713860512, 0.018647460266947746, -0.035655003041028976, -0.002610662719234824, -0.006617556791752577, -0.011812412180006504, -0.05314779281616211, 0.016892239451408386, -0.03323563188314438, 0.06726040691137314, -0.008276333101093769, -0.05747894570231438, -0.015489251352846622, 0.0291700828820467, -0.01583213172852993, 0.03200092166662216, -0.05352037772536278, -0.021500585600733757, 0.007351372856646776, -0.0004547478456515819, -0.008019782602787018, -0.058239445090293884, 0.024993034079670906, 0.0014252867549657822, 0.026949673891067505, 0.03882800042629242, -0.010880104266107082, -0.05239351838827133, 0.025361234322190285, 0.015812352299690247, -0.002053943695500493, -0.001690660952590406, 0.009666972793638706, 0.03608659654855728, 0.03619749844074249, -0.017314350232481956, 0.045062314718961716, 0.043013062328100204, -0.027315467596054077, 0.000472496438305825, -0.05403181165456772, 0.03653337433934212, -0.018084611743688583, 0.019567741081118584, -0.03330831229686737, -0.013754983432590961, -0.00015393349167425185, 0.024289924651384354, 0.0011871745809912682, 0.023492759093642235, -0.04136224836111069, -0.0023654296528548002, 0.003956253174692392, 0.001599845360033214, -0.0050688013434410095, -0.022275375202298164, -0.055859167128801346, 0.018268771469593048, 0.025538964197039604, -0.011061077937483788, 0.053199753165245056, -0.017680902034044266, 0.01841682754456997, 0.01369364932179451, -0.006812632083892822, -0.015835225582122803, -0.012120145373046398, -0.04273689165711403, 0.04300051927566528, -0.03156261518597603, 0.020065460354089737, -0.04400944337248802, 0.026852715760469437, 0.03209871053695679, -0.0005449349991977215, -0.0014456490753218532, -0.0032682043965905905, -0.00211937353014946, 0.017015807330608368, -0.0450424998998642, 0.057909246534109116, -0.032554250210523605, 0.013406792655587196, -0.08135050535202026, -0.04147804528474808, 0.044420309364795685, -0.011876814067363739, -0.05605645477771759, -0.041995931416749954, -0.05156126990914345, -0.01161626074463129, 0.0010806632926687598, 0.0032522797118872404, 0.0487421378493309, -0.026198508217930794, -0.03558014705777168, -0.0033240977209061384, 0.0142300333827734, 0.0706927552819252, 0.015630578622221947, 0.004010525066405535, 0.06057009845972061, -0.017999988049268723, -0.024176547303795815, 0.011578312143683434, 0.01804407685995102, -0.016911271959543228, 0.03632928431034088, 0.014874222688376904, 0.04071534052491188, 0.005984659772366285, -0.00874361116439104, -0.016665905714035034, 0.03309658542275429, 0.011553600430488586, 0.03435490280389786, -0.04706958308815956, -0.02993857115507126, -0.006230833008885384, -0.0030648051761090755, -0.013053416274487972, -0.01993718184530735, 0.01341157779097557, -0.01903681270778179, 0.03542204946279526, -0.020916815847158432, 0.029393941164016724, 0.015759678557515144, 0.09519196301698685, -0.0029827309772372246, 0.005229757633060217, -0.002416282892227173, -0.020855160430073738, 0.04937639832496643, 0.023564636707305908, -0.026218561455607414, 0.015231011435389519, -0.00604763301089406, -0.006543128285557032, -0.000015978343071765266, -0.07707512378692627, 0.031561922281980515, 0.05665417015552521, 0.0010545752011239529, 0.03295189142227173, 0.03767003118991852, -0.015946486964821815, 0.03706768900156021, -0.028643401339650154, -0.0037772231735289097, -0.015638021752238274, -0.0186215378344059, 0.036638081073760986, 0.01163282711058855, -0.007093043066561222, 0.02836448699235916, 0.03203801438212395, -0.016523990780115128, 0.04867265000939369, 0.052332282066345215, 0.0027209697291254997, 0.000024399187168455683, -0.01149419043213129, -0.020769769325852394, 0.004573850426822901, -0.011386273428797722, 0.026673709973692894, -0.0350225456058979, -0.013804413378238678, 0.017695140093564987, 0.07188243418931961, -0.0072789969854056835, -0.037921469658613205, 0.005355535540729761, -0.03807201609015465, -0.007478952873498201, 0.04063662141561508, -0.0029979231767356396, 0.07175680249929428, 0.005892941262573004, 0.0031921430490911007, -0.01802806742489338, 0.006239143665879965, -0.054537124931812286, -0.03611130267381668, -0.0068993703462183475, -0.01820400357246399, -0.03251384571194649, 0.0165685024112463, 0.021164946258068085, -0.0131991570815444, 0.019484752789139748, -0.028038837015628815, 0.047516800463199615, 0.014469249173998833, 0.043107565492391586, 0.029352791607379913, 0.10198940336704254, 0.020094454288482666, 0.025838982313871384, -0.028941651806235313, 0.023785794153809547, 0.12425808608531952, 0.06438950449228287, 0.021630726754665375, -0.07062911987304688, 0.02985559217631817, -0.011893612332642078, 0.0002720323100220412, -0.004938947036862373, -0.003901706775650382, 0.035202816128730774, -0.018206190317869186, 0.03265845775604248, 0.0036731003783643246, 0.002386866370216012, 0.026991989463567734, 0.006571220234036446, -0.06030716374516487, -0.03275299444794655, 0.007060949224978685, 0.01117817871272564, -0.01542538683861494, -0.04957149550318718, -0.0893823578953743, -0.00806838646531105, 0.001168826944194734, -0.01632562093436718, -0.029971051961183548, -0.021576808765530586, -0.0003458390710875392, 0.03520350158214569, 0.01910889893770218, 0.016983285546302795, 0.00726127065718174, -0.02205047570168972, 0.03818708285689354, -0.013968302868306637, 0.030031245201826096, 0.021544430404901505, 0.0003850272623822093, 0.05215989425778389, 0.00126825796905905, -0.03035803511738777, -0.0011519554536789656, 0.03521355614066124, 0.009833728894591331, -0.029528718441724777, -0.049241818487644196, 0.053801529109478, 0.0030449621845036745, -0.030713636428117752, -0.006364436820149422, -0.012255873531103134, -0.005144821014255285, -0.03801044821739197, 0.018401261419057846, 0.020808793604373932, 0.04325779154896736, -0.025881420820951462, -0.017265422269701958, -0.01048008818179369, 0.032274212688207626, -0.01576833426952362, 0.015382232144474983, 0.05047246068716049, -0.009613719768822193, -0.006620911881327629, -0.015648681670427322, 0.023252900689840317, -0.03931165114045143, -0.006398266181349754, 0.015286647714674473, -0.033993761986494064, -0.047696568071842194, -0.05831689387559891, 0.012712010182440281, 0.001964982133358717, 0.008853016421198845, -0.02336873672902584, -0.029681403189897537, -0.007634698413312435, -0.04297962784767151, -0.0038385011721402407, 0.005058560520410538, -0.05428879335522652, -0.03490988910198212, 0.03618410974740982, 0.01784665137529373, 0.03623489663004875, 0.013225584290921688, -0.019770998507738113, -0.061850644648075104, 0.03489809110760689, 0.022318685427308083, -0.006597560364753008, -0.03029129095375538, 0.03187500685453415, -0.044127631932497025, -0.011399884708225727, -0.02287190407514572, 0.05561782419681549, -0.02117169089615345, -0.0011189354117959738, 0.027980025857686996, 0.03032780811190605, -0.020113348960876465, 0.030025022104382515, 0.03319172188639641, -0.03507832810282707, -0.023286791518330574, 0.04221159964799881, -0.014112531207501888, -0.0337696336209774, -0.018142901360988617, -0.021052461117506027, -0.008563575334846973, 0.024617860093712807, -0.019089747220277786, -0.031057193875312805, -0.04780685529112816, -0.017129557207226753, -0.019695879891514778, -0.03156774118542671, 0.004401199519634247, -0.023388784378767014, -0.01942906714975834, -0.01189343724399805, 0.009015738032758236, -0.029241975396871567, 0.008349534124135971, -0.010539181530475616, -0.005179451312869787, 0.03276562690734863, 0.013501983135938644, 0.02923634648323059, -0.012936877086758614, 0.00026178304688073695, -0.0025422864127904177, 0.018714571371674538, -0.019644998013973236, 0.014878923073410988, 0.03905091807246208, -0.08028875291347504, -0.01186420302838087, -0.020231226459145546, -0.013569017872214317, 0.013521753251552582, 0.011754256673157215, 0.0009205351816490293, -0.030862726271152496, 0.059095997363328934, -0.010723249055445194, -0.0378425158560276, 0.020029408857226372, 0.01550908014178276, 0.004568836186081171, 0.02097863145172596, 0.004853768274188042, 0.003525857115164399, 0.00023287093790713698, 0.037956804037094116, 0.028037995100021362, -0.00593818724155426, -0.009246330708265305, 0.038121167570352554, 0.014407575130462646, 0.02096947282552719, 0.015705900266766548, -0.05457579717040062, 0.05312176048755646, 0.05236263945698738, -0.004542591515928507, 0.021551689133048058, -0.045731041580438614, 0.024151498451828957, -0.03587306663393974, -0.01723420061171055, -0.0024815404321998358, -0.011312265880405903, 0.05444810539484024, -0.03254435956478119, -0.014532121829688549, 0.009766272269189358, -0.028698956593871117, -0.020873326808214188, 0.010779604315757751, 0.0030146667268127203, -0.05378219112753868, 0.032400280237197876, -0.03503365442156792, 0.007582177873700857, 0.033495642244815826, -0.004904240369796753, 0.03623043745756149, -0.02789764478802681, -0.010546972043812275, -0.03312164545059204, 0.005557112395763397, 0.022958070039749146, -0.004617155063897371, -0.05332811549305916, 0.03430602699518204, 0.0029021562077105045, -0.03369804844260216, 0.027772916480898857, -0.022448377683758736, -0.009123471565544605, -0.012424607761204243, 0.028627008199691772, -0.002091940026730299, 0.09584210067987442, 0.03404315933585167, -0.009840593673288822, 0.03656237944960594, -0.0152133172377944, -0.010685776360332966, -0.00948144681751728, 0.0003687181160785258, 0.02202763222157955, 0.029022615402936935, -0.01656205765902996, -0.004473039414733648, 0.02251969650387764, 0.0178033709526062, -0.0673668384552002, -0.0008796621696092188, 0.011773227714002132, 0.02374734915792942, -0.021929148584604263, 0.023153508082032204, -0.007432997692376375, 0.0137376943603158, 0.04605575650930405, 0.04462384432554245, -0.014562534168362617, -0.02745720185339451, -0.02203560806810856, -0.043814290314912796, -0.0046480074524879456, 0.0028145909309387207, -0.05579269677400589, -0.03919241204857826, -0.03373114392161369, -0.008069610223174095, 0.028870943933725357, -0.009176095016300678, -0.023976750671863556, -0.06352846324443817, 0.005761869717389345, -0.018255818635225296, 0.03214951232075691, 0.016519058495759964, 0.010375621728599072, 0.01927156373858452, -0.0905437171459198, 0.09500741958618164, -0.020887332037091255, -0.0262905303388834, -0.04003258794546127, 0.0008017789223231375, -0.026920944452285767, -0.011016921140253544, 0.032888222485780716, 0.05371969938278198, -0.00974411703646183, -0.010246125049889088, 0.019653676077723503, 0.00034808932105079293, -0.02495880238711834, 0.018141280859708786, -0.02220880426466465, -0.017890723422169685, -0.01327595952898264, 0.009332837536931038, -0.010294772684574127, 0.048636846244335175, 0.023286039009690285, -0.01005296315997839, 0.032436370849609375, -0.016242805868387222, -0.007471739314496517, -0.02254151925444603, 0.02468002401292324, -0.014849198050796986, 0.017179062590003014, 0.0024579388555139303, 0.023799626156687737, 0.027073349803686142, 0.002103629522025585, -0.0661981999874115, 0.030348222702741623, -0.05852004885673523, -0.02439735271036625, 0.018410146236419678, -0.04010044410824776, 0.023081962019205093, -0.03921452537178993, -0.013510077260434628, 0.04716766998171806, -0.04208419471979141, 0.007255595177412033, 0.006895251106470823, 0.04350396990776062, 0.033241886645555496, -0.022882571443915367, 0.0014753717696294188, -0.003727436065673828, -0.02095353975892067, -0.01670229062438011, -0.0045070708729326725, -0.02612718753516674, -0.004979589022696018, -0.014221486635506153, 0.02429436706006527, -0.052161138504743576, -0.002166275167837739, -0.012552586384117603, 0.011152232065796852, 0.01570945419371128, -0.008681715466082096, 0.006182810291647911, -0.03298918157815933, -0.0233151838183403, 0.041704338043928146, 0.0042734271846711636, 0.036138758063316345, -0.0025705979205667973, 0.0285202469676733, -0.021832743659615517, -0.015920057892799377, -0.02257242426276207, 0.03463976830244064, 0.02783278189599514, 0.003437088103964925, -0.013346528634428978, -0.012223425321280956, -0.013359984382987022, -0.006994344759732485, -0.003875325433909893, -0.018194636330008507, 0.04639403894543648, -0.014936782419681549, 0.025616701692342758, 0.00835831556469202, -0.014270039275288582, -0.00791645422577858, -0.0032195078674703836, 0.02036413550376892, 0.04381358623504639, 0.013770399615168571, -0.049850672483444214, -0.034223802387714386, 0.0034422173630446196, 0.035513587296009064, -0.03836887702345848, 0.017051780596375465, -0.02083871327340603, 0.04645485803484917, -0.009893329814076424, 0.00418489845469594 ]
<p>I have time series, for example, gdp and unemployment(<code>unemp</code>), freq= 4. </p> <p>What if I interpret it as cross-sectional data and do cross-sectional analysis instead of time series? </p> <p>My task is to test how unemployment affects gdp. </p> <p>Is it allowed to do that kind of analysis? </p> <p>Do the coefficients in the model <code>lm(gdp~unemp)</code> have an economic explanation?</p>
74,392
[ -0.016947714611887932, 0.0018533774418756366, -0.010333830490708351, 0.012107071466743946, 0.04563235118985176, 0.0050522335804998875, -0.009598976001143456, -0.010872039012610912, 0.042710043489933014, -0.011863277293741703, 0.03101537935435772, -0.0002677441225387156, 0.07586628198623657, -0.009264753200113773, 0.022207163274288177, 0.03174924477934837, -0.0011451519094407558, 0.015373891219496727, -0.026584280654788017, 0.024309486150741577, 0.005566742271184921, 0.02309351973235607, -0.02753520756959915, -0.004735925234854221, -0.008910410106182098, 0.03196468949317932, 0.028561869636178017, -0.021627964451909065, 0.0028621528763324022, 0.0472087562084198, -0.029381038621068, -0.006868636701256037, 0.001971503486856818, 0.037642765790224075, 0.0017893752083182335, 0.037435948848724365, -0.034628015011548996, -0.026047483086586, 0.006223063450306654, 0.02756776660680771, -0.04006209596991539, 0.00038451931322924793, 0.01192743144929409, 0.016493186354637146, -0.013574623502790928, 0.03782543167471886, 0.009005829691886902, 0.024967320263385773, 0.0225452221930027, -0.009616381488740444, 0.08606623858213425, -0.02887117862701416, 0.013833526521921158, 0.009571756236255169, -0.020670762285590172, -0.012714308686554432, 0.06600312888622284, 0.0462445393204689, -0.00016047750250436366, -0.05842137709259987, -0.012467517517507076, 0.005260072648525238, 0.0193936824798584, -0.06646989285945892, -0.04733624309301376, 0.026137040928006172, -0.006559301633387804, -0.015683630481362343, 0.030937639996409416, -0.031082356348633766, 0.03310014680027962, 0.03172984719276428, 0.02535078302025795, -0.007889237254858017, 0.024726269766688347, -0.03874295577406883, 0.024865703657269478, -0.010071930475533009, 0.017467843368649483, 0.059891942888498306, -0.007396801374852657, 0.017744578421115875, 0.05095015466213226, 0.03632267564535141, 0.03939100354909897, 0.0011682371841743588, 0.08748256415128708, 0.00480617256835103, 0.04366524517536163, 0.0059831407852470875, 0.02420201152563095, -0.007536286022514105, 0.05828068405389786, 0.011927141807973385, -0.031393133103847504, 0.03716795891523361, 0.0037690650206059217, 0.028853513300418854, 0.029936885461211205, -0.015594931319355965, -0.02266952209174633, -0.011381168849766254, 0.021489830687642097, 0.020226983353495598, 0.002497889567166567, 0.01369219645857811, -0.02501382678747177, 0.002508691744878888, 0.013918758369982243, -0.056992057710886, -0.01947748474776745, 0.03241036832332611, -0.006851947866380215, -0.031141560524702072, 0.02117362804710865, 0.024073908105492592, 0.014115734025835991, -0.020270727574825287, 0.030780650675296783, 0.04935409501194954, 0.05112716928124428, -0.01945396140217781, 0.014343840070068836, -0.028730114921927452, -0.06965561211109161, -0.005934388842433691, -0.002704162383452058, -0.00971300434321165, -0.04584316164255142, 0.06465156376361847, -0.010494271293282509, -0.026201393455266953, 0.008628848008811474, -0.0022763286251574755, 0.056866247206926346, 0.00944718811661005, -0.0934469997882843, -0.05806988105177879, 0.03542459383606911, 0.023936446756124496, 0.0163454357534647, -0.04603519290685654, -0.007844536565244198, 0.005186604801565409, 0.06356654316186905, -0.01652909629046917, 0.051476385444402695, 0.017192646861076355, 0.008304685354232788, -0.000636074342764914, -0.013064732775092125, -0.029658593237400055, -0.01785857044160366, -0.021386466920375824, 0.026084579527378082, -0.0713941678404808, -0.006885990966111422, 0.03467598557472229, -0.025426311418414116, 0.01548681315034628, 0.028456484898924828, 0.0492643266916275, -0.016623560339212418, 0.0037661390379071236, -0.02929656021296978, -0.02425815351307392, 0.051215238869190216, 0.007090143859386444, 0.04148301109671593, 0.015202060341835022, -0.009854375384747982, 0.03611753508448601, -0.010608933866024017, 0.07214950025081635, 0.019120385870337486, -0.0070560891181230545, -0.032639309763908386, -0.017487460747361183, 0.024620020762085915, -0.013037707656621933, -0.06107717379927635, -0.028731299564242363, -0.020411748439073563, -0.016724660992622375, 0.01790490373969078, 0.03390492871403694, 0.029018402099609375, -0.00870785303413868, 0.029323481023311615, -0.04737905412912369, -0.08631030470132828, -0.04259087145328522, 0.015613710507750511, -0.034497808665037155, -0.00872401800006628, 0.010780668817460537, -0.008938797749578953, 0.048328984528779984, -0.04379252344369888, -0.028311116620898247, -0.04175123572349548, 0.015734568238258362, 0.020571190863847733, -0.01391926221549511, -0.007161607965826988, 0.02036585472524166, 0.010726537555456161, -0.0034507892560213804, 0.05679190158843994, -0.015719447284936905, -0.04305142164230347, 0.009283668361604214, -0.034846801310777664, 0.017948294058442116, 0.009310645051300526, -0.0043185921385884285, 0.015011164359748363, 0.0146574005484581, -0.03414992615580559, 0.060012951493263245, -0.033707112073898315, 0.06145501881837845, 0.06677135825157166, -0.024446185678243637, 0.018040906637907028, -0.005506590474396944, 0.053915899246931076, 0.06299526989459991, -0.02384585328400135, 0.017873674631118774, -0.08205970376729965, 0.0033411027397960424, 0.039903879165649414, 0.017263490706682205, -0.028305193409323692, 0.015072589740157127, 0.07378996163606644, 0.007387508638203144, -0.002100796438753605, 0.001460026134736836, 0.00022231267939787358, -0.02495708130300045, 0.0031684034038335085, 0.010446207597851753, 0.003936377819627523, -0.005871434696018696, 0.037759531289339066, -0.011193342506885529, 0.030740225687623024, -0.002435373840853572, 0.014137385413050652, 0.07710690051317215, -0.023228062316775322, 0.021641617640852928, 0.023378366604447365, 0.010248052887618542, 0.05586354061961174, 0.008041036315262318, 0.023019596934318542, -0.0021786231081932783, 0.01546250469982624, 0.002881944179534912, 0.02253674529492855, -0.004683610517531633, 0.007584053091704845, 0.021654276177287102, -0.014921652153134346, -0.013650923036038876, 0.0380718894302845, -0.044740643352270126, -0.00458733644336462, -0.01927119866013527, -0.04717746004462242, -0.06759216636419296, 0.027680031955242157, 0.043949827551841736, 0.030991636216640472, 0.053170349448919296, -0.02863607555627823, -0.023494327440857887, 0.03723616153001785, -0.0032646069303154945, 0.029360519722104073, -0.01781504414975643, -0.035567525774240494, 0.0439462885260582, -0.04075018689036369, -0.0016004175413399935, 0.033905189484357834, -0.004398885648697615, -0.00295852217823267, 0.01383994985371828, 0.004657732788473368, -0.0029129781760275364, -0.03034764528274536, -0.03432545065879822, 0.037411343306303024, -0.04999630153179169, -0.025763727724552155, 0.05950773507356644, -0.013788084499537945, -0.031097328290343285, 0.004252774175256491, -0.05488297715783119, 0.004379043821245432, -0.0257431510835886, -0.009065324440598488, 0.01558372937142849, 0.005559786222875118, 0.0050940727815032005, -0.007240798324346542, -0.017876574769616127, 0.015962257981300354, -0.07657304406166077, -0.07333691418170929, 0.014845536090433598, -0.019485605880618095, 0.01295027881860733, 0.010236854664981365, -0.03412339836359024, 0.03782349452376366, 0.015910843387246132, -0.04701954498887062, -0.05532665550708771, -0.01794414035975933, -0.03710274398326874, -0.04745076224207878, 0.04535144567489624, 0.008174792863428593, 0.003161665517836809, 0.017765497788786888, 0.007337035145610571, 0.05685802176594734, 0.016875404864549637, -0.0007226792513392866, -0.01598956063389778, 0.010866030119359493, -0.0014170159120112658, -0.011578735895454884, 0.021825095638632774, -0.018160507082939148, 0.0014859496150165796, 0.019594117999076843, 0.02312495745718479, 0.025768183171749115, 0.02654370665550232, -0.034536607563495636, 0.02829005755484104, -0.005745950620621443, 0.004477457609027624, -0.05858932062983513, 0.037096716463565826, 0.006667894311249256, -0.03010893054306507, -0.01720534823834896, -0.024387339130043983, 0.0250100027769804, -0.0021551463287323713, 0.013837071135640144, 0.030496686697006226, 0.047433335334062576, -0.03782031685113907, -0.04001079499721527, -0.01728755794465542, 0.011970755644142628, 0.04470273107290268, 0.0002142599696526304, -0.008716820739209652, 0.04742767661809921, 0.05608922615647316, 0.03314646705985069, -0.01362429279834032, -0.06776661425828934, -0.026369763538241386, -0.09903281182050705, -0.003198501653969288, -0.03404155373573303, 0.05996054783463478, 0.016182448714971542, 0.0344514399766922, 0.03405727073550224, -0.01504596322774887, 0.006942790932953358, -0.015775641426444054, -0.0727117583155632, 0.051058486104011536, 0.0009089744416996837, 0.009035791270434856, 0.02749604545533657, 0.016237065196037292, 0.040095239877700806, -0.023172104731202126, 0.01511319074779749, 0.008510872721672058, -0.010480308905243874, -0.04595361649990082, -0.002968750661239028, 0.007996617816388607, -0.0285293310880661, 0.016201844438910484, -0.009287340566515923, 0.011137481778860092, -0.00896622147411108, 0.00862615741789341, 0.04453921690583229, 0.02656942419707775, -0.009061228483915329, -0.011224041692912579, 0.013939808122813702, -0.0030984741169959307, 0.06009754538536072, 0.006386471446603537, -0.013673600740730762, -0.036755505949258804, 0.07677128911018372, 0.041203491389751434, 0.01718929037451744, 0.00827986840158701, 0.009449844248592854, -0.044543616473674774, -0.053168971091508865, -0.005302113480865955, 0.025454631075263023, 0.018145550042390823, 0.011792258359491825, -0.021510209888219833, 0.04984191060066223, 0.04676685109734535, -0.04528282582759857, 0.014682600274682045, 0.08950445055961609, 0.01696285791695118, 0.0072186109609901905, -0.025410760194063187, -0.04908532276749611, -0.013062898069620132, 0.023341236636042595, 0.017008114606142044, 0.016788803040981293, -0.022012321278452873, 0.03515194356441498, 0.0229742880910635, -0.009176451712846756, -0.048563018441200256, -0.009664629586040974, 0.04483938217163086, 0.06283322721719742, -0.006457039620727301, -0.03717668354511261, 0.06578945368528366, 0.04029013589024544, 0.044376060366630554, 0.026650307700037956, -0.0012109089875593781, -0.11873330175876617, 0.0012924782931804657, 0.0434100441634655, 0.007674782071262598, -0.03558778762817383, -0.018127532675862312, -0.04819688946008682, 0.017752710729837418, 0.004157835152000189, -0.03757496178150177, 0.0032688004430383444, -0.014009136706590652, 0.02612316980957985, -0.018781248480081558, 0.011760595254600048, -0.04332560673356056, 0.017449241131544113, 0.0035642171278595924, 0.06082512438297272, -0.010667114518582821, -0.043207813054323196, -0.04903804510831833, 0.04833339527249336, 0.024332141503691673, 0.02147994004189968, -0.034079939126968384, -0.015314782038331032, 0.006021425127983093, 0.01719193160533905, -0.03354129567742348, -0.059745173901319504, 0.011506560258567333, 0.009055837988853455, 0.02226262167096138, 0.027423880994319916, 0.02798711322247982, -0.01639535464346409, -0.009685819037258625, -0.0013337896671146154, 0.02172837220132351, -0.004296162631362677, -0.020763996988534927, 0.030909977853298187, 0.02756780944764614, 0.016505537554621696, 0.04664185270667076, 0.04356466978788376, 0.013597984798252583, 0.01770918443799019, -0.047661252319812775, 0.014095096848905087, -0.04593665152788162, 0.013450789265334606, -0.02183595858514309, -0.034337595105171204, -0.02295740693807602, 0.003561793128028512, 0.0033369099255651236, 0.03823892027139664, -0.03425472974777222, -0.023961301892995834, -0.030930696055293083, 0.005832222755998373, -0.0051904283463954926, -0.032208431512117386, -0.009688552469015121, 0.0019200020469725132, -0.02633984200656414, -0.02510942704975605, 0.007288639433681965, -0.013390949927270412, -0.012782623060047626, -0.011769657954573631, -0.019320622086524963, -0.0022002547048032284, -0.004789592698216438, -0.019152645021677017, 0.011649961583316326, -0.029330208897590637, 0.013729974627494812, 0.014160383492708206, 0.03196602687239647, 0.005605486687272787, -0.03427863121032715, 0.018311528488993645, 0.03055218979716301, 0.027892114594578743, 0.006659094709903002, -0.031439799815416336, 0.046216271817684174, -0.0036070803180336952, -0.028770070523023605, -0.07427677512168884, -0.04291703552007675, 0.021788988262414932, -0.003764790715649724, -0.034979116171598434, -0.015967674553394318, -0.01565125398337841, 0.016290945932269096, -0.006613390054553747, -0.03422226384282112, 0.05423025041818619, -0.036369677633047104, 0.001127188210375607, 0.015283129177987576, 0.006583282258361578, 0.10609559714794159, -0.006822460331022739, 0.012125970795750618, 0.031115423887968063, -0.018886446952819824, -0.015687372535467148, -0.007527467794716358, 0.022561468183994293, -0.015428382903337479, 0.007480820175260305, -0.02881075069308281, -0.01937217265367508, 0.03330254927277565, -0.04134936258196831, -0.02768443338572979, 0.030168062075972557, -0.005829914007335901, 0.008012623526155949, -0.0341140553355217, 0.019620422273874283, -0.02208767645061016, -0.0055992319248616695, -0.031088434159755707, -0.001304810750298202, -0.043143924325704575, -0.02466265857219696, 0.04131739214062691, -0.04413025081157684, -0.022439273074269295, 0.05248920992016792, 0.05719137564301491, 0.00458636786788702, -0.006227963138371706, 0.03679732605814934, -0.004355542827397585, 0.03602580726146698, -0.009341654367744923, -0.0036630320828408003, 0.009928102605044842, 0.029661966487765312, -0.03404219076037407, -0.0650777816772461, -0.020216230303049088, -0.029600394889712334, 0.04125630855560303, 0.019555464386940002, 0.029389122501015663, 0.07363497465848923, 0.000934865209273994, 0.021947462111711502, -0.03462216258049011, 0.001430783304385841, -0.001924544689245522, 0.024450484663248062, 0.034553539007902145, 0.0022134557366371155, -0.012207988649606705, 0.022129548713564873, -0.006946721114218235, 0.0057076262310147285, 0.01619342342019081, 0.01835423894226551, -0.0004491951840464026, 0.002299639629200101, -0.01434099767357111, -0.059401605278253555, 0.04067938029766083, -0.055444683879613876, 0.02218712866306305, -0.05511583387851715, -0.0102456733584404, 0.02097182720899582, 0.0754731222987175, 0.009718559682369232, -0.017406223341822624, 0.020826736465096474, -0.05577011778950691, 0.022441571578383446, 0.040011268109083176, -0.004884005524218082, 0.050727684050798416, -0.003558224765583873, 0.0714854747056961, -0.02466030977666378, 0.02471875585615635, -0.02446412667632103, -0.05642584338784218, -0.03611651062965393, -0.015175228007137775, -0.01539075467735529, 0.0479176826775074, -0.02347220852971077, -0.011955061927437782, 0.04141008481383324, -0.06330957263708115, 0.023779351264238358, 0.010619360953569412, 0.03884762525558472, -0.008317386731505394, 0.03706386312842369, -0.02083149552345276, -0.0017393305897712708, -0.03482294827699661, 0.006041938439011574, 0.11586394160985947, 0.036741502583026886, 0.03709899261593819, -0.06584176421165466, -0.003591101849451661, -0.007695681881159544, 0.026420949026942253, -0.014491601847112179, -0.008884115144610405, -0.0037875953130424023, 0.009740246459841728, 0.023551685735583305, 0.043531112372875214, -0.0040894667617976665, -0.0004469992418307811, 0.0747346505522728, -0.02574835903942585, -0.002407621592283249, -0.0139772342517972, 0.0047138710506260395, 0.006786924321204424, 0.007640366442501545, -0.06293205916881561, 0.0038782034534960985, -0.023440932855010033, -0.03948080167174339, -0.015413807705044746, -0.03935491666197777, -0.011840340681374073, -0.031005101278424263, -0.036857351660728455, 0.0173464547842741, -0.0011531701311469078, 0.01041086670011282, -0.038747143000364304, -0.02181699313223362, -0.024764150381088257, -0.04437613487243652, 0.013361188583076, 0.038094863295555115, 0.011562800034880638, -0.0036001994740217924, -0.011466478928923607, 0.024237407371401787, -0.058390695601701736, -0.0014564041048288345, -0.023401185870170593, 0.049913324415683746, 0.003786897286772728, -0.039948221296072006, -0.012763531878590584, 0.052161697298288345, 0.0073052141815423965, -0.03318782523274422, -0.02473362348973751, -0.01368055958300829, 0.02514912374317646, -0.03265127167105675, -0.026482511311769485, -0.05391794815659523, 0.0037884730845689774, 0.006113069131970406, 0.021422643214464188, 0.0447239950299263, -0.020701799541711807, 0.026404526084661484, -0.01958240009844303, 0.017665915191173553, -0.04158741980791092, -0.0008385193650610745, 0.01943553052842617, 0.022195838391780853, -0.03925120830535889, -0.015133564360439777, 0.046310216188430786, 0.005761104170233011, 0.016981834545731544, 0.00702055124565959, 0.0000724111232557334, -0.025136638432741165, -0.018080636858940125, 0.014241952449083328, -0.006422637961804867, -0.007684790063649416, -0.02883237414062023, 0.0026930535677820444, 0.011014836840331554, 0.014194822870194912, 0.025509007275104523, -0.0347629189491272, -0.004113908391445875, 0.035846639424562454, 0.02108420990407467, -0.05501224473118782, -0.020929766818881035, -0.009046209044754505, -0.00044184509897604585, 0.02493441104888916, -0.026417093351483345, 0.03578263893723488, 0.03354792669415474, 0.0023254549596458673, -0.048110850155353546, 0.03715209662914276, -0.04604014754295349, -0.019393837079405785, 0.029944494366645813, -0.07418253272771835, -0.0205042976886034, 0.028628256171941757, 0.01030859723687172, -0.031117038801312447, -0.03981611132621765, -0.05687985196709633, -0.027365803718566895, -0.015304622240364552, 0.010517467744648457, -0.04327516630291939, 0.04262639582157135, -0.0024314194452017546, 0.02842695452272892, -0.03627923130989075, 0.017647769302129745, -0.05753278732299805, -0.03373197838664055, -0.019687477499246597, -0.06721748411655426, 0.031648483127355576, -0.003177399979904294, -0.014386889524757862, 0.006673403549939394, 0.01642528548836708, 0.005445088259875774, -0.007997685112059116, 0.007740556728094816, 0.03794872760772705, -0.036987800151109695, 0.02739497274160385, 0.015682119876146317, -0.025153962895274162, 0.04795891419053078, -0.0198043342679739, -0.008746332488954067, 0.0033940612338483334, -0.03233858942985535, 0.06954742968082428, 0.0021934318356215954, -0.005087536294013262, 0.0070227449759840965, 0.021385526284575462, -0.005771439056843519, 0.02935273014008999, -0.01836378313601017, 0.003360362956300378, 0.013768725097179413, -0.0014027542201802135, -0.005969920661300421, -0.002917818957939744, -0.021695662289857864, 0.013637595809996128, 0.07044006884098053, 0.03025147318840027, -0.021895278245210648, 0.03625119477510452, -0.0009380111587233841, 0.013952132314443588, -0.005926529876887798, 0.019191911444067955, 0.026183467358350754, 0.027571678161621094, 0.011422188952565193, 0.014424876309931278, -0.020588044077157974, 0.00005450205208035186, -0.08228383213281631, -0.000374090566765517, 0.005522222723811865, 0.00406620092689991, 0.035928886383771896, -0.0375051312148571, 0.0011583836749196053, -0.010760542936623096, -0.03429236263036728, 0.026549823582172394, -0.03478461876511574, -0.0036478438414633274, -0.010791799053549767, -0.010280449874699116, -0.02773040346801281, 0.023534538224339485, 0.051725368946790695, -0.004690269939601421, 0.011533313430845737, 0.03186709061264992, 0.018380561843514442, -0.007260455284267664, -0.0015987014630809426, -0.005593334790319204, -0.009265098720788956, -0.04827940836548805, 0.04592249542474747, -0.07569673657417297, -0.007730040233582258, -0.002908783033490181, -0.03381335362792015, 0.019098514690995216, 0.03354446589946747, -0.027855314314365387, 0.03258835896849632, 0.022010793909430504, 0.04720843955874443, -0.009264321997761726, -0.025763506069779396, -0.024807125329971313, 0.00020261557074263692, 0.02431378699839115, -0.008380257524549961, 0.003229490015655756, -0.008820528164505959, -0.02249273657798767, 0.008103463798761368, -0.01992395520210266, -0.010450776666402817, 0.0022640719544142485, 0.005052404012531042, 0.002479592803865671, -0.03982822969555855, -0.027042945846915245, 0.047576043754816055, -0.0008675991557538509, 0.02344464138150215, 0.027255181223154068, 0.03221870958805084, -0.03815675526857376, -0.004255019593983889, -0.0015462388982996345, -0.0330793559551239, 0.03865424916148186, -0.010730801150202751, -0.026783812791109085, -0.04293243959546089, 0.004922059364616871, 0.016679400578141212, -0.02182270959019661, -0.050483688712120056, 0.01043944712728262, -0.016579903662204742, 0.02190461754798889, -0.012278628535568714, -0.017183681949973106, 0.018797077238559723, -0.04538315162062645, -0.002487262710928917, -0.09494570642709732, 0.04695136100053787, 0.02267165295779705, -0.01181984692811966, -0.04460088908672333, -0.03187987580895424, -0.046003568917512894, 0.012123367749154568, 0.039509668946266174, -0.005647069774568081, -0.00008950608753366396, 0.003294814843684435, 0.033494383096694946, -0.015688635408878326, -0.017273440957069397, 0.05899237096309662, -0.025649309158325195, -0.03672853112220764, -0.0006201029755175114, -0.016464095562696457, -0.02738589234650135, -0.0028112740255892277, 0.032641369849443436, -0.006258049514144659, 0.015250075608491898, -0.006773448083549738, -0.04474165663123131, 0.011106986552476883, -0.0026788560207933187, -0.018687738105654716, 0.022462718188762665, 0.022088507190346718, 0.023287449032068253, 0.018698306754231453, -0.035171616822481155, -0.06775401532649994, 0.029756268486380577, -0.02827923186123371, -0.04370945692062378, -0.01934688724577427, 0.00004119060395169072, 0.033867914229631424, -0.042619187384843826, -0.03210384026169777, 0.03922751545906067, -0.0323522612452507, 0.00268466304987669, 0.027965858578681946, 0.06962160021066666, 0.025706058368086815, -0.040237296372652054, 0.009034858085215092, 0.0059301722794771194, -0.03517341986298561, 0.03068973682820797, -0.0005372922169044614, 0.046155136078596115, -0.010735942982137203, -0.018386729061603546, 0.038969945162534714, -0.006543285679072142, 0.022388122975826263, -0.02015317976474762, 0.08181288093328476, -0.03467928245663643, -0.03146911412477493, 0.013847140595316887, 0.03559679165482521, -0.0007812458788976073, 0.038677919656038284, -0.017589744180440903, 0.03360296040773392, -0.0024911370128393173, 0.026720399037003517, -0.011324448511004448, -0.023574847728013992, -0.04448245093226433, 0.001727284281514585, 0.027639638632535934, 0.016773734241724014, 0.015843788161873817, 0.00494005624204874, -0.022250190377235413, -0.01912534050643444, 0.024580227211117744, -0.01276122871786356, -0.0039061831776052713, 0.017758959904313087, -0.022981831803917885, -0.009238678961992264, -0.027332214638590813, -0.036312285810709, -0.038680434226989746, 0.0738455206155777, 0.02466290071606636, -0.008228915743529797, -0.034714650362730026, -0.024693414568901062, 0.003275297349318862, 0.0419764518737793, -0.06060721352696419, -0.02822740562260151, -0.025766897946596146, 0.020018134266138077, 0.012130011804401875, 0.010261289775371552 ]
<p>I have a spectrum. Specifically, my data is relative intensity $[I_{\tilde{\nu}}]$ versus wavenumbers $[\tilde{\nu}]$. The wavenumbers are equally sampled so that ${d\tilde{\nu}} = c$, where $c$ is some constant.</p> <p>However, I need the data to be given in terms of wavelength $\lambda = \frac{1}{\tilde{\nu}}$. When I perform this transformation, the step size of wavelength $d \lambda$ decreases with increasing wavelength. However, I need the step size to remain constant for the entire spectrum.</p> <p>I am guessing this calls for some kind of interpolation or fitting. How can an even sampling of wavelengths $\lambda$ be accomplished?</p>
74,393
[ 0.015390589833259583, -0.011943819932639599, -0.008406474255025387, -0.021103035658597946, 0.030007092282176018, 0.025710662826895714, -0.0191383995115757, -0.03844050318002701, 0.03427208587527275, -0.038345035165548325, 0.096257284283638, 0.05358148738741875, 0.08030415326356888, 0.009570172987878323, 0.015322098508477211, 0.015182741917669773, -0.011139276437461376, 0.0040622674860060215, -0.0477369986474514, -0.019020209088921547, 0.005718844011425972, 0.0212586410343647, 0.0005358110647648573, -0.012825247831642628, -0.045643676072359085, 0.0291924849152565, 0.03255242854356766, 0.015795521438121796, -0.004600943997502327, 0.049821607768535614, -0.023434676229953766, -0.033278774470090866, 0.013311619870364666, 0.06763433665037155, 0.0063371495343744755, 0.0009878437267616391, -0.03880982846021652, -0.051084429025650024, 0.01780259981751442, 0.01742146722972393, -0.058452058583498, 0.030568253248929977, -0.02852875180542469, 0.025825904682278633, 0.047813016921281815, 0.05244461074471474, 0.008338486775755882, -0.050622064620256424, 0.01915760338306427, -0.012453772127628326, 0.08159171789884567, -0.022860947996377945, 0.04467557743191719, 0.017167236655950546, -0.031775448471307755, -0.01660553365945816, 0.05823098123073578, 0.07760593295097351, 0.005494399927556515, -0.007168347015976906, -0.013352703303098679, -0.053513359278440475, 0.007384848315268755, 0.03872299939393997, -0.0470881313085556, 0.005549152847379446, -0.00008700929174665362, -0.012755341827869415, 0.002383971819654107, -0.0293127354234457, 0.013151724822819233, 0.004793989472091198, 0.0428033322095871, -0.06360069662332535, -0.009096871130168438, -0.04414046183228493, 0.007401672657579184, 0.04987591877579689, 0.04105417802929878, 0.02784040942788124, 0.007307499181479216, 0.007600131910294294, -0.012679179199039936, 0.0052737523801624775, 0.003915165551006794, -0.012940904125571251, 0.057172127068042755, -0.015298832207918167, 0.0001545644918223843, 0.028022637590765953, 0.016953395679593086, 0.033767219632864, 0.06877012550830841, 0.021399477496743202, -0.006548942532390356, -0.0028576692566275597, -0.006428205408155918, 0.004615165758877993, -0.016047384589910507, -0.023603171110153198, 0.0053776707500219345, -0.03165966644883156, 0.025726109743118286, 0.03871571645140648, -0.008953606709837914, 0.020600054413080215, -0.027934907004237175, -0.010635941289365292, -0.0064043281599879265, -0.032003339380025864, 0.023357104510068893, 0.012228728272020817, 0.02325635589659214, 0.012674346566200256, 0.027845226228237152, -0.0052997153252363205, 0.0003347908495925367, -0.020653430372476578, 0.05823296308517456, 0.0959407314658165, 0.032519061118364334, -0.01821787841618061, 0.050546642392873764, -0.013835516758263111, -0.053400516510009766, 0.0031662348192185163, 0.021322116255760193, -0.010933061130344868, -0.053620584309101105, 0.008954972960054874, -0.0023616072721779346, -0.03935050964355469, 0.024237435311079025, -0.02652440220117569, 0.012925181537866592, 0.015493495389819145, -0.06467025727033615, -0.059902843087911606, 0.003971760626882315, -0.032589323818683624, -0.022730089724063873, -0.08594032377004623, 0.0009369511972181499, 0.035830724984407425, 0.08844394981861115, 0.040105633437633514, 0.024617977440357208, -0.01681290939450264, 0.007294759154319763, 0.012999645434319973, -0.0007951834122650325, -0.03505527600646019, -0.009201406501233578, -0.024126073345541954, -0.013636467978358269, -0.0276330579072237, 0.014244869351387024, 0.04795904457569122, -0.008065585047006607, -0.00023030376178212464, 0.044033877551555634, 0.025458358228206635, -0.02544148452579975, 0.02167365700006485, 0.036730822175741196, -0.02440035715699196, 0.05045311525464058, 0.01882309839129448, 0.0013846051879227161, -0.003382687922567129, -0.024465400725603104, 0.007227763999253511, 0.006760738790035248, 0.032724495977163315, 0.06909960508346558, -0.005616209469735622, -0.0035406453534960747, -0.01908193528652191, 0.02115686796605587, 0.045017026364803314, -0.008529935963451862, -0.02230321243405342, -0.003044790355488658, -0.02597167156636715, 0.05251264572143555, 0.003195900470018387, 0.010989644564688206, -0.012421192601323128, 0.011282317340373993, -0.07408139109611511, 0.009836558252573013, -0.01945720985531807, 0.034345999360084534, 0.06422728300094604, -0.028309378772974014, 0.04787026345729828, 0.017626170068979263, 0.006841701455414295, 0.0017526823794469237, -0.04982265830039978, 0.018790246918797493, -0.025101065635681152, 0.025213021785020828, -0.018631383776664734, 0.00835447758436203, 0.06447086483240128, 0.04593397304415703, 0.0010712340008467436, 0.06924280524253845, -0.008497724309563637, 0.013524113222956657, -0.001130782999098301, -0.046149663627147675, 0.014089210890233517, -0.02113618701696396, 0.03843802586197853, -0.00849370751529932, -0.03079965151846409, 0.025209801271557808, 0.041814666241407394, -0.01751061901450157, 0.0429365336894989, 0.06954725086688995, -0.020345482975244522, 0.009126827120780945, 0.022107187658548355, 0.007815217599272728, 0.038248952478170395, 0.004881579428911209, -0.09800844639539719, -0.05846122279763222, 0.008253796026110649, 0.026883816346526146, 0.03879745677113533, -0.046862781047821045, -0.02299397438764572, 0.0672914907336235, 0.03623369336128235, 0.06479386985301971, 0.03866482898592949, -0.02893950790166855, -0.02813481166958809, 0.014617974869906902, 0.01045151986181736, 0.01987016387283802, -0.03593691438436508, -0.01967031881213188, 0.005366776138544083, 0.03547085076570511, 0.0009985507931560278, -0.001461994950659573, 0.027747008949518204, -0.00128080730792135, 0.006580017507076263, 0.00022702648129779845, -0.010010309517383575, 0.020707840099930763, -0.029747940599918365, 0.012666051276028156, 0.049121659249067307, -0.02241327427327633, -0.01160610280930996, 0.008501367643475533, -0.0015007158508524299, 0.008546767756342888, 0.028525248169898987, -0.040743812918663025, 0.030950913205742836, 0.02385159581899643, -0.02327681891620159, 0.020688172429800034, -0.051177870482206345, -0.03380698710680008, -0.06913737207651138, -0.003586884355172515, 0.03993205726146698, 0.03997287154197693, 0.034111138433218, -0.08738734573125839, -0.028756994754076004, 0.01178748905658722, -0.01070096530020237, 0.04323197156190872, 0.02012401819229126, -0.015221790410578251, -0.011077211238443851, -0.018968848511576653, -0.037378065288066864, 0.010225940495729446, -0.0033032738137990236, 0.018970631062984467, -0.0030338203068822622, 0.009536751545965672, -0.06970053911209106, 0.007228427100926638, 0.02452143467962742, -0.007477175910025835, -0.020456673577427864, -0.009330426342785358, 0.04716305807232857, 0.01899380423128605, -0.03726378455758095, 0.028148164972662926, -0.006233250722289085, -0.004967523273080587, -0.03890571370720863, 0.04331795498728752, 0.040333982557058334, -0.009827131405472755, 0.03808460012078285, 0.013339358381927013, 0.012767462059855461, 0.013703512959182262, -0.052018675953149796, -0.0741787925362587, 0.023816999047994614, 0.02615051157772541, 0.05697442218661308, 0.028840431943535805, -0.0030891401693224907, 0.05987387150526047, 0.04380412399768829, -0.028653191402554512, -0.04635770991444588, -0.0072896950878202915, 0.008587338961660862, -0.04594667628407478, 0.011204688809812069, -0.0011367106344550848, -0.03153857961297035, 0.05240635946393013, -0.009778648614883423, 0.04275095462799072, 0.05833500996232033, -0.0017133299261331558, 0.0017071401234716177, 0.06085965782403946, 0.012201976962387562, 0.026096420362591743, 0.0320606455206871, 0.010501988232135773, -0.0328323133289814, 0.034473925828933716, -0.03678656741976738, -0.014870437793433666, 0.028456054627895355, -0.02683178335428238, 0.019806217402219772, 0.03073788434267044, -0.020915687084197998, -0.044237613677978516, 0.026846902444958687, 0.031728345900774, -0.01385265402495861, -0.02012183703482151, 0.0898144394159317, 0.02592352032661438, -0.018457598984241486, 0.0011649476364254951, 0.02893204428255558, 0.019051535055041313, 0.007350662723183632, 0.019230838865041733, 0.01391557976603508, -0.009805870242416859, 0.013235202990472317, -0.05280999839305878, -0.036768484860658646, 0.029311547055840492, 0.061016201972961426, 0.028836805373430252, -0.03333866223692894, -0.03843670338392258, 0.015950754284858704, -0.03896941617131233, -0.014408046379685402, -0.002685397397726774, 0.0688919946551323, -0.004164428450167179, 0.06560245901346207, 0.07097242027521133, 0.01699843630194664, 0.034814078360795975, 0.011961380019783974, -0.09951139986515045, 0.031716521829366684, -0.0071185799315571785, 0.033285826444625854, -0.026495477184653282, 0.0065855057910084724, -0.01794745959341526, -0.04566240683197975, -0.019742239266633987, 0.0032950732856988907, 0.014486941508948803, -0.030448079109191895, 0.03668923303484917, -0.029658880084753036, -0.0152055062353611, -0.024156151339411736, 0.0608711838722229, 0.03337041661143303, -0.041094277054071426, -0.010577305220067501, 0.007540761027485132, -0.0027283469680696726, -0.011442000046372414, -0.0038364476058632135, 0.003420233726501465, -0.022843513637781143, 0.054605744779109955, 0.03477036952972412, 0.034525372087955475, -0.02433857135474682, 0.012668292969465256, -0.01271252240985632, 0.04382890462875366, 0.026587050408124924, -0.031805362552404404, 0.006862179841846228, -0.04689379408955574, 0.012886827811598778, -0.003142913104966283, 0.0591188408434391, -0.0063931806944310665, -0.031001513823866844, 0.040274977684020996, -0.0036933363880962133, -0.07228127866983414, 0.04911426454782486, 0.06524011492729187, 0.0067396629601716995, -0.008041460998356342, -0.038385942578315735, 0.015436514280736446, 0.0009067520732060075, -0.008029048331081867, 0.017029237002134323, 0.0015817388193681836, 0.020591985434293747, 0.00024549910449422896, 0.04006745666265488, -0.011040319688618183, -0.012819492258131504, -0.004042371641844511, -0.016466708853840828, 0.03947443887591362, -0.013093431480228901, -0.03327291086316109, -0.008816243149340153, 0.027422834187746048, 0.05079902708530426, 0.02690916508436203, 0.0029298544395715, -0.08825743198394775, -0.004189852625131607, 0.0025865172501653433, 0.041553255170583725, -0.050839003175497055, 0.02331922948360443, -0.045402247458696365, -0.04013398289680481, 0.06258700788021088, -0.022109337151050568, 0.025662068277597427, -0.00957177672535181, -0.0356418676674366, -0.019252697005867958, -0.0076205432415008545, -0.0377298966050148, 0.016942022368311882, -0.02722347527742386, 0.01601393334567547, -0.03670996055006981, -0.03356100618839264, -0.019927674904465675, 0.02849060297012329, 0.013598254881799221, 0.05918736010789871, -0.028716936707496643, -0.020706864073872566, 0.03287980332970619, 0.02375311590731144, -0.0014638352440670133, -0.030270231887698174, 0.02097952365875244, 0.007115315645933151, 0.023457027971744537, 0.010112560354173183, -0.01988818682730198, -0.04703483358025551, 0.030494248494505882, 0.047457143664360046, -0.0043507893569767475, -0.010211498476564884, 0.003552101319655776, 0.062516950070858, 0.0030367583967745304, -0.003771277144551277, 0.057236555963754654, 0.056073158979415894, 0.01532361377030611, 0.013384239748120308, -0.0006452507805079222, 0.04887307435274124, -0.06106887757778168, -0.013521110638976097, -0.011804542504251003, -0.0030819145031273365, -0.0464126355946064, 0.038978997617959976, 0.012127851136028767, 0.032306063920259476, -0.007022626232355833, -0.028429865837097168, 0.04324151575565338, 0.02039124257862568, -0.012547120451927185, -0.0035720004234462976, 0.017252853140234947, 0.04127926751971245, -0.00954420119524002, -0.018969208002090454, 0.007141153793781996, -0.021641451865434647, -0.014849724248051643, -0.008613772690296173, -0.018380308523774147, 0.043907977640628815, -0.08326904475688934, -0.0011308658868074417, 0.028542768210172653, -0.04270113259553909, 0.016676343977451324, -0.03587328642606735, 0.05344511196017265, -0.0035700101871043444, -0.023967253044247627, -0.0015626846579834819, 0.012656047008931637, -0.038306236267089844, 0.03089015744626522, -0.04622301459312439, 0.01396726630628109, -0.0021743837278336287, 0.025029204785823822, -0.08033839613199234, -0.024313516914844513, 0.01945265755057335, -0.0010855599539354444, 0.00769397709518671, -0.04575251415371895, -0.004339235834777355, 0.0012490075314417481, 0.0030182162299752235, -0.02198750525712967, 0.0162920244038105, 0.027339041233062744, -0.03223969787359238, -0.005765371955931187, 0.02043541520833969, 0.028555339202284813, -0.04239603132009506, 0.029624298214912415, -0.0027286801487207413, -0.004682854283601046, -0.0117787541821599, 0.023466330021619797, 0.01675480790436268, -0.050078798085451126, -0.04174155741930008, -0.0237691942602396, -0.025137219578027725, 0.024221263825893402, -0.02814333513379097, -0.042305245995521545, 0.014397723600268364, 0.016089027747511864, 0.017279863357543945, -0.008346722461283207, 0.0027051055803894997, -0.024524018168449402, 0.01047905907034874, -0.03019644506275654, -0.0024510014336556196, -0.02788485586643219, -0.032377567142248154, -0.02451264299452305, 0.001850663567893207, 0.015837784856557846, 0.01670522801578045, 0.04591190814971924, -0.02672625705599785, 0.002885777037590742, 0.03554194048047066, -0.03596707805991173, -0.0072589414194226265, -0.01920662261545658, -0.004750301595777273, 0.02081218734383583, 0.00930037721991539, -0.03465428948402405, -0.056700803339481354, -0.02976055257022381, 0.002804511459544301, 0.0351935550570488, -0.008899841457605362, 0.057048626244068146, 0.05480382964015007, -0.005193156655877829, -0.008687260560691357, -0.015825306996703148, -0.036708980798721313, -0.03487778827548027, -0.008781250566244125, 0.03165239095687866, -0.0012940160231664777, -0.03182627633213997, 0.009459566324949265, 0.045150160789489746, 0.014942760579288006, 0.0516534298658371, -0.005080058705061674, 0.015226750634610653, 0.0015733076725155115, -0.0396881029009819, -0.03671112656593323, 0.0006686293054372072, -0.018347522243857384, 0.03764255344867706, 0.01979822851717472, 0.0141595508903265, 0.049587395042181015, 0.03021811507642269, -0.00261590164154768, -0.023033907637000084, -0.004885334055870771, -0.07978968322277069, 0.029060058295726776, 0.029696887359023094, 0.01209993939846754, 0.009225621819496155, 0.004014365840703249, 0.031011441722512245, -0.021853120997548103, 0.013172280974686146, -0.01973314955830574, -0.018399227410554886, -0.038804374635219574, -0.04433388262987137, -0.07259290665388107, 0.05780867487192154, -0.022660238668322563, -0.03643421828746796, -0.001753461081534624, 0.007140251342207193, 0.012676646001636982, -0.01439917366951704, 0.030792683362960815, -0.015359064564108849, 0.06298172473907471, 0.009567228145897388, -0.008758253417909145, -0.0009498296421952546, 0.009645003825426102, 0.12382590770721436, 0.07523288577795029, 0.011085470207035542, -0.04992734640836716, -0.007672733627259731, -0.01767001487314701, -0.034598637372255325, 0.010333073325455189, 0.005355847533792257, 0.027310175821185112, -0.0018269902793690562, -0.023447731509804726, 0.050257764756679535, -0.013298684731125832, 0.019404547289013863, 0.02940531075000763, -0.013768782839179039, 0.026336483657360077, 0.03924670070409775, -0.0024880722630769014, -0.002998169045895338, 0.03635746240615845, -0.05948900431394577, 0.0012412723153829575, -0.012186981737613678, -0.013527726754546165, -0.055835068225860596, -0.031218435615301132, 0.010172397829592228, 0.03813392296433449, -0.05733432620763779, 0.009235876612365246, 0.012795116752386093, 0.014722218737006187, -0.01389063335955143, 0.029312007129192352, 0.005273038055747747, -0.010482625104486942, -0.005130419973284006, 0.023093510419130325, 0.03140585124492645, 0.020637331530451775, -0.021795300766825676, -0.006995209492743015, -0.006117051932960749, -0.02136826701462269, -0.05027257278561592, 0.020466553047299385, -0.006588612217456102, -0.010268120095133781, -0.0010515025351196527, 0.02038116380572319, 0.006435323506593704, -0.0719219520688057, 0.013314696960151196, 0.040262553840875626, 0.017228713259100914, -0.03282278776168823, -0.02195892482995987, -0.007622651755809784, -0.0036521460860967636, -0.01620575599372387, -0.0005318247131071985, 0.015767063945531845, -0.04196939989924431, -0.04463113471865654, 0.008850247599184513, 0.046571534126996994, 0.000168142476468347, -0.026339028030633926, 0.016037294641137123, -0.029987942427396774, -0.030316557735204697, -0.015001470223069191, 0.012238794937729836, 0.013021817430853844, 0.043318115174770355, -0.006889075506478548, -0.034253135323524475, -0.02115274965763092, -0.07196207344532013, 0.007007544860243797, 0.006943963002413511, -0.030620472505688667, 0.011084290221333504, -0.03816630318760872, 0.02035418525338173, 0.015965914353728294, -0.0011096760863438249, 0.003117668442428112, -0.0025076596066355705, 0.00635621789842844, 0.04570811986923218, -0.05288346856832504, -0.03363975137472153, 0.010213760659098625, -0.006811286322772503, 0.043983668088912964, 0.0037155302707105875, 0.05199581757187843, 0.0025856962893158197, -0.011919583193957806, 0.005365501157939434, 0.05654459074139595, -0.06449993699789047, 0.017450502142310143, -0.010127401910722256, -0.03302233666181564, 0.033579133450984955, -0.007816758006811142, -0.006678763777017593, -0.043299756944179535, -0.011848676949739456, -0.07031744718551636, -0.011719112284481525, 0.0102760698646307, -0.033308714628219604, -0.03330090641975403, 0.03179130703210831, -0.017642345279455185, -0.005034574773162603, -0.0042281080968678, -0.038897208869457245, -0.053384847939014435, -0.011394673027098179, -0.030062710866332054, 0.023622028529644012, 0.005152407567948103, 0.0037867736537009478, -0.03482268378138542, -0.04570974409580231, 0.053268879652023315, 0.014883155934512615, 0.03040945529937744, -0.010118072852492332, -0.012118949554860592, -0.0017608950147405267, 0.06886188685894012, -0.038657668977975845, -0.011006521992385387, 0.030437767505645752, -0.020721441134810448, -0.024054843932390213, 0.030164793133735657, -0.030273884534835815, 0.033777181059122086, 0.03685362637042999, -0.0023420164361596107, 0.0023385717067867517, 0.01882367953658104, -0.013099770992994308, -0.0076111420057713985, -0.03625995293259621, -0.004698651842772961, 0.019301604479551315, -0.01641320437192917, -0.005051938351243734, -0.009340614080429077, -0.018467659130692482, 0.04953519627451897, 0.010450152680277824, -0.003319192212074995, -0.0010197574738413095, -0.021831931546330452, -0.011045638471841812, 0.005341576412320137, 0.02631356753408909, 0.007198058068752289, 0.01639307290315628, 0.026574596762657166, -0.0562884658575058, 0.0228007473051548, -0.00638618366792798, -0.008100708946585655, -0.07632162421941757, -0.019180241972208023, -0.014898567460477352, -0.002876624930649996, -0.001410695374943316, -0.044266313314437866, -0.008951087482273579, 0.012647832743823528, -0.06830333173274994, 0.0230414979159832, -0.04681108891963959, 0.010916334576904774, -0.04063812270760536, 0.011167282238602638, -0.05245707184076309, -0.019118253141641617, 0.044849708676338196, 0.055753037333488464, 0.031595468521118164, 0.002521019894629717, -0.011662375181913376, -0.009202955290675163, -0.009449386037886143, 0.020020904019474983, 0.006390370428562164, -0.04325424134731293, 0.00831835437566042, -0.02019563317298889, -0.01137042697519064, 0.030167585238814354, -0.03896603733301163, 0.02690502628684044, -0.0024907749611884356, -0.005599468946456909, -0.012322659604251385, 0.019781071692705154, 0.008068658411502838, -0.01883907988667488, -0.005191371776163578, -0.00023346357920672745, 0.03250101953744888, 0.019025590270757675, 0.008560210466384888, 0.010223831981420517, 0.0407329797744751, -0.04019030183553696, -0.025344811379909515, 0.03361726179718971, 0.0021806436125189066, 0.006366967689245939, 0.03384871780872345, -0.012922629714012146, 0.00836760550737381, -0.027473390102386475, 0.025952009484171867, -0.024990150704979897, 0.0030787172727286816, -0.004606091883033514, 0.021053258329629898, 0.010999869555234909, -0.012040969915688038, -0.017617732286453247, -0.05567832291126251, -0.00874409731477499, 0.022672219201922417, -0.05070369690656662, -0.038035035133361816, -0.014955839142203331, -0.006348504219204187, -0.03129205480217934, 0.007415891624987125, -0.007606958504766226, -0.054338984191417694, 0.03817140683531761, -0.03095526434481144, -0.003109333571046591, -0.02653435803949833, -0.016217008233070374, -0.031021276488900185, -0.06524816900491714, 0.0471104197204113, 0.012303255498409271, -0.0156545452773571, -0.02464456297457218, -0.011555369012057781, 0.003720832522958517, 0.05184999480843544, 0.061586931347846985, 0.018872521817684174, -0.029992247000336647, -0.013259513303637505, -0.015003173612058163, 0.01724928803741932, -0.0325576514005661, -0.004919819999486208, -0.024485578760504723, -0.024127064272761345, 0.014852783642709255, -0.010795725509524345, -0.021426988765597343, 0.038221314549446106, -0.011615762487053871, -0.000764128053560853, 0.00864149909466505, 0.010196415707468987, -0.015950724482536316, 0.018312886357307434, -0.02638409286737442, -0.009425929747521877, 0.01866215094923973, 0.025489548221230507, -0.01781618967652321, 0.005579749122262001, -0.012502167373895645, -0.0742686316370964, 0.044032491743564606, -0.06043114513158798, -0.04660995304584503, 0.007774054072797298, 0.03685838356614113, 0.018353290855884552, -0.04718635231256485, 0.009480789303779602, 0.006439256016165018, -0.02844255417585373, -0.005115804728120565, 0.02383984997868538, -0.005948234349489212, -0.006774206180125475, 0.02215035818517208, 0.01581377163529396, 0.013513325713574886, 0.009420102462172508, 0.01633109711110592, -0.0011106519959867, -0.003304834244772792, -0.014300449751317501, 0.043943509459495544, 0.03353997692465782, -0.014779504388570786, -0.007196010556071997, 0.016210315749049187, 0.019949549809098244, 0.0020681913010776043, -0.03019261173903942, 0.029870683327317238, -0.02166912890970707, 0.005916920956224203, 0.032943204045295715, -0.006302140187472105, 0.053868722170591354, 0.0035975337959825993, 0.04381166025996208, -0.049442898482084274, -0.005756152793765068, -0.030847733840346336, 0.0037464802153408527, -0.03262822702527046, 0.01515625324100256, -0.023252544924616814, -0.00043250093585811555, -0.017047857865691185, -0.001592573244124651, 0.01659581810235977, -0.046821873635053635, 0.020678440108895302, 0.020544324070215225, -0.04081599414348602, -0.007449394091963768, -0.002300808671861887, -0.011171720921993256, -0.044501736760139465, 0.017095321789383888, 0.043276090174913406, 0.019317159429192543, 0.03647040203213692, -0.005114673171192408, -0.012940897606313229, 0.03229708969593048, -0.07369328290224075, -0.03993678092956543, -0.019405696541070938, 0.0005985302268527448, 0.0008371878648176789, -0.010043056681752205 ]
<p>I am trying to find out if I can somehow assess if one model fits my data significantly better than another model? They are both ordinal regressions and we have introduced an additional interaction term in the second model. Now we want to know if the model has improved. Do I only look at the model fit indices? How do I know if the model has significantly improved?</p>
37,261
[ -0.0170318353921175, 0.012624739669263363, -0.034701064229011536, 0.027560535818338394, 0.02734077349305153, 0.03962194547057152, -0.007380768656730652, -0.04605751112103462, 0.061621345579624176, 0.002014030236750841, 0.03171006590127945, 0.023000027984380722, 0.05286566913127899, 0.009139799512922764, -0.005427038297057152, 0.012866104952991009, -0.02918371558189392, 0.015711436048150063, 0.004120259545743465, -0.006964575033634901, -0.03547622635960579, 0.019924664869904518, -0.0029213689267635345, -0.006040097214281559, -0.01971861906349659, 0.04211705923080444, 0.05258725956082344, -0.04570886120200157, 0.008455994538962841, 0.01114035863429308, -0.013384931720793247, -0.03214755654335022, 0.00786587968468666, 0.04953321814537048, 0.008611153811216354, -0.0014127913163974881, -0.005121419206261635, -0.018729159608483315, -0.014877626672387123, 0.038923367857933044, -0.013881235383450985, -0.051019374281167984, 0.002444776240736246, 0.02659720927476883, -0.02407674863934517, 0.016970129683613777, -0.026960480958223343, -0.0330047681927681, 0.03815235197544098, -0.022728223353624344, 0.07311511784791946, -0.012182241305708885, 0.033852770924568176, 0.0586717464029789, -0.019894033670425415, -0.02083309181034565, 0.05457150191068649, 0.0726354792714119, -0.0038752646651118994, -0.03243262693285942, -0.027820654213428497, -0.016921164467930794, 0.03165057674050331, -0.0036602546460926533, -0.05033981427550316, 0.034026555716991425, 0.012485013343393803, -0.03466137871146202, 0.03365088254213333, -0.008592712692916393, -0.014084219932556152, 0.013231588527560234, 0.07911744713783264, -0.0192605871707201, 0.01445678435266018, -0.05848316103219986, -0.013001924380660057, 0.03682919591665268, 0.048442091792821884, 0.051108218729496, -0.02999759465456009, 0.015395749360322952, 0.024326443672180176, 0.035604361444711685, 0.03149168938398361, -0.03886254131793976, 0.041036367416381836, -0.004348740912973881, 0.00805266760289669, 0.03098350204527378, -0.03186989948153496, -0.008053580299019814, 0.0570523701608181, -0.017647111788392067, -0.006991070229560137, 0.024568499997258186, -0.00771111948415637, 0.011383546516299248, 0.042643893510103226, 0.009599733166396618, -0.013207892887294292, -0.02480616793036461, -0.0012929104268550873, 0.05081111937761307, -0.007558859419077635, -0.019948666915297508, -0.03446440026164055, -0.018790120258927345, -0.022943757474422455, -0.016405925154685974, 0.005110845435410738, 0.024574991315603256, 0.009494020603597164, 0.026110440492630005, 0.04743693023920059, -0.014313302002847195, -0.017863338813185692, -0.03612474352121353, 0.07704479247331619, 0.0670967623591423, 0.044683367013931274, -0.039195749908685684, 0.01926160603761673, -0.034817587584257126, -0.024996023625135422, 0.003427792340517044, 0.0026412063743919134, -0.01334476936608553, -0.04120487719774246, 0.04298083484172821, -0.016905441880226135, -0.020484957844018936, -0.004422641824930906, -0.004304176662117243, 0.02421833761036396, 0.017919527366757393, -0.06360473483800888, -0.037592433393001556, 0.02563030831515789, 0.009071302600204945, 0.007192774675786495, -0.05366735905408859, -0.004804534837603569, 0.03413941711187363, 0.07577411830425262, 0.042576730251312256, 0.02186530828475952, 0.02780667319893837, 0.007514413446187973, -0.0071599846705794334, -0.022856635972857475, -0.03983016312122345, -0.027097012847661972, -0.030958961695432663, 0.008130857720971107, -0.12189633399248123, -0.011952011846005917, 0.030409008264541626, -0.03762398287653923, -0.006694054696708918, 0.07855208218097687, 0.02798737771809101, -0.008731221780180931, -0.002120734192430973, 0.04541303589940071, 0.009776003658771515, 0.053423166275024414, -0.07645438611507416, 0.024670863524079323, 0.025597764179110527, 0.0021127033978700638, 0.009667686186730862, 0.047219980508089066, 0.04209763556718826, 0.03312072902917862, 0.0052736238576471806, 0.005376637913286686, -0.04656992480158806, 0.00452872971072793, -0.0016043356154114008, -0.035966020077466965, -0.04238026216626167, -0.052544064819812775, -0.013612328097224236, 0.01263524778187275, 0.0520286038517952, 0.005107440520077944, -0.025443345308303833, 0.04116753488779068, -0.0471530482172966, -0.04406337812542915, -0.05987405776977539, -0.03810812532901764, 0.020463215187191963, -0.03805343434214592, 0.03961997479200363, 0.011958246119320393, 0.027978897094726562, -0.004914339166134596, 0.01276008877903223, -0.045103494077920914, 0.004018479026854038, 0.029732130467891693, -0.022534769028425217, 0.02932155318558216, 0.050407905131578445, 0.06381721794605255, -0.03875324875116348, 0.03666166588664055, -0.05500774830579758, -0.0557694211602211, 0.038256555795669556, -0.022131379693746567, -0.034269481897354126, -0.016789134591817856, -0.011052723973989487, 0.02875553071498871, -0.015741173177957535, -0.017527492716908455, 0.02775091864168644, -0.04451281949877739, 0.08556071668863297, 0.0476226843893528, 0.01695508509874344, -0.0031522728968411684, 0.020591961219906807, 0.007497488986700773, 0.023907871916890144, -0.026713106781244278, -0.008328370749950409, -0.03627004101872444, -0.05197929963469505, 0.06129983812570572, 0.021600116044282913, -0.02497258596122265, 0.02746851183474064, 0.07010190188884735, -0.003347608260810375, -0.0026159677654504776, 0.05234364792704582, -0.02144223265349865, -0.015541121363639832, 0.01391616091132164, -0.0003330254403408617, 0.027083879336714745, 0.019894100725650787, 0.006561050657182932, 0.022585242986679077, 0.04226914793252945, -0.0022740194108337164, 0.03122740611433983, 0.03651333972811699, 0.02762899361550808, 0.0033119323197752237, -0.021007608622312546, 0.005716298241168261, 0.020916061475872993, -0.007354272995144129, 0.006227791775017977, 0.043292202055454254, -0.0076846047304570675, -0.013881956227123737, 0.03362559154629707, 0.021881291642785072, 0.026187323033809662, 0.03375875949859619, -0.02055143564939499, -0.0054485793225467205, 0.03401073068380356, -0.03415640443563461, 0.024705657735466957, -0.012100831605494022, -0.025262009352445602, -0.034216973930597305, -0.008564358577132225, 0.012962554581463337, 0.02771422453224659, 0.02883519046008587, -0.02034950442612171, -0.004809178877621889, 0.019463496282696724, -0.0383361391723156, 0.01859794743359089, -0.019047152251005173, -0.03698122873902321, 0.010763750411570072, -0.04481954127550125, 0.0018433291697874665, -0.0023000456858426332, -0.029500851407647133, 0.0013158434303477407, 0.02954300493001938, -0.008643069304525852, -0.03010936826467514, -0.04088253155350685, -0.01034237165004015, 0.011129364371299744, -0.010915659368038177, -0.04233444109559059, 0.01681496575474739, 0.01353411003947258, -0.032965656369924545, -0.0019024136709049344, -0.018749257549643517, -0.013871912844479084, -0.049037154763936996, 0.01747705787420273, 0.0160948745906353, 0.031142931431531906, 0.030913617461919785, 0.013133557513356209, -0.023276351392269135, -0.008522897958755493, -0.1020459532737732, -0.03286535292863846, 0.03908376768231392, -0.02572677657008171, 0.019073104485869408, -0.014063502661883831, -0.023952951654791832, 0.05274854227900505, 0.010255820117890835, -0.00824851356446743, -0.04720957949757576, 0.015937305986881256, -0.0455281138420105, 0.027499191462993622, 0.01400071196258068, 0.008606496267020702, 0.009893765673041344, 0.022957611829042435, 0.007557980250567198, 0.03434046730399132, 0.04326430708169937, 0.010191245004534721, -0.000711019616574049, 0.029314083978533745, 0.023494845256209373, -0.03415829315781593, 0.013250085525214672, 0.004669406451284885, -0.01347301620990038, 0.02537316456437111, 0.005753283388912678, -0.02362186089158058, 0.028982151299715042, -0.03405946120619774, 0.007371352985501289, 0.01258431188762188, 0.009244991466403008, -0.011555636301636696, 0.03800714388489723, 0.007517486345022917, 0.0037817314732819796, -0.02252563089132309, 0.06071089953184128, 0.03953488543629646, -0.006508910097181797, 0.023218024522066116, 0.06477975100278854, -0.006771716754883528, -0.017522355541586876, 0.03949309512972832, -0.014117964543402195, -0.03814731538295746, -0.0024427208118140697, -0.023594042286276817, -0.03006523661315441, 0.05100129544734955, 0.02653665468096733, 0.01889834739267826, -0.021395806223154068, -0.039227936416864395, -0.0015931897796690464, -0.04624537006020546, -0.013839097693562508, -0.05240394547581673, 0.027974361553788185, -0.006270624231547117, 0.01180729828774929, -0.010168383829295635, 0.00464966194704175, 0.02599993906915188, -0.018375804647803307, -0.05514821782708168, 0.05417800694704056, -0.00796604622155428, -0.004386082757264376, 0.019694827497005463, -0.022799640893936157, 0.007287719752639532, -0.025734245777130127, 0.025921901687979698, -0.007305549457669258, 0.016294017434120178, -0.016411760821938515, 0.007234030868858099, -0.06939343363046646, -0.018410582095384598, 0.023597104474902153, 0.020144598558545113, -0.012111281044781208, -0.021556058898568153, 0.015716422349214554, 0.02724662981927395, -0.01717076450586319, -0.021388718858361244, -0.028895702213048935, 0.015216498635709286, 0.013559206388890743, 0.020626258105039597, 0.01232985220849514, 0.014807935804128647, -0.04697723686695099, 0.09185022115707397, 0.012123716995120049, 0.05022750794887543, 0.02008466236293316, -0.019824236631393433, -0.02637411467730999, -0.03831753879785538, -0.033392954617738724, -0.018923643976449966, 0.04310982674360275, -0.003519396996125579, -0.020980434492230415, 0.046365153044462204, 0.036888591945171356, -0.06375685334205627, 0.017780812457203865, 0.07243998348712921, 0.03461213409900665, 0.006579860579222441, -0.007846453227102757, -0.038768522441387177, -0.016932835802435875, -0.015273391269147396, 0.023905638605356216, -0.01935260370373726, -0.019091282039880753, 0.0029631226789206266, 0.029510054737329483, -0.032246243208646774, -0.02486000768840313, -0.011967302300035954, 0.007261565420776606, 0.014366766437888145, -0.011602900922298431, -0.05438609421253204, -0.006025508511811495, 0.050979238003492355, 0.02234645187854767, 0.005016630049794912, 0.010894691571593285, -0.10488881915807724, 0.03144633024930954, 0.07140029966831207, 0.04264494776725769, -0.07649850845336914, -0.024558475241065025, -0.04378967732191086, -0.015627646818757057, 0.057167667895555496, -0.01686589978635311, 0.03558773547410965, 0.015162418596446514, 0.007860712707042694, -0.047683920711278915, -0.00962732918560505, -0.0555875226855278, 0.046342261135578156, -0.008369160816073418, 0.0127567108720541, -0.021935436874628067, -0.0005733121652156115, -0.052293453365564346, 0.030406326055526733, 0.004419555887579918, 0.03543756529688835, -0.02138364687561989, -0.00010069323616335168, 0.02773369662463665, -0.004949311725795269, -0.024704543873667717, -0.05581231042742729, 0.023035265505313873, 0.018303334712982178, -0.036204174160957336, 0.031222017481923103, 0.0010587632423266768, -0.022878605872392654, 0.008833092637360096, -0.005206648260354996, -0.009573644027113914, -0.004174879752099514, -0.021718444302678108, 0.05698661506175995, 0.010398736223578453, -0.010347714647650719, 0.027732903137803078, 0.05340850353240967, 0.017102092504501343, -0.014481019228696823, -0.010506350547075272, 0.026094699278473854, -0.031112752854824066, -0.028251081705093384, -0.006817067041993141, -0.015404630452394485, -0.02690168283879757, 0.02493618056178093, 0.008547313511371613, 0.05052538961172104, -0.032820992171764374, 0.0011560546699911356, -0.008543489500880241, 0.04376020282506943, -0.0353194996714592, -0.026641054078936577, 0.025858158245682716, 0.004444463644176722, 0.0037512972485274076, -0.040425315499305725, 0.0029272655956447124, -0.017705626785755157, -0.02750987559556961, 0.015427502803504467, -0.02160242572426796, 0.01589701697230339, -0.0277847982943058, -0.025863945484161377, -0.00674101896584034, 0.00023583266010973603, 0.036465369164943695, -0.01955820433795452, 0.034807007759809494, -0.02565641887485981, -0.009930087253451347, -0.014511922374367714, 0.014604880474507809, 0.01212221197783947, 0.009524432942271233, -0.026463879272341728, 0.06544583290815353, -0.0049865394830703735, -0.047905083745718, -0.056974656879901886, -0.04670406132936478, 0.031897883862257004, 0.007927756756544113, -0.013830245472490788, -0.029065854847431183, 0.01812911406159401, -0.013780785724520683, 0.0010888705728575587, -0.02077348530292511, 0.04730578884482384, -0.011769886128604412, -0.013330216519534588, -0.02356126718223095, 0.01475601177662611, 0.056950926780700684, 0.027223752811551094, 0.0071899546310305595, 0.025394385680556297, -0.005555467214435339, -0.009742368943989277, 0.02814929001033306, 0.009743917733430862, -0.02631308138370514, -0.010454334318637848, -0.06601087003946304, 0.018795279785990715, 0.06612767279148102, -0.010462397709488869, -0.010242619551718235, 0.024832481518387794, -0.03866719827055931, 0.031603820621967316, -0.026633739471435547, -0.01875283196568489, 0.016284983605146408, 0.00590468617156148, -0.027306586503982544, 0.019147338345646858, 0.02568933367729187, -0.021995875984430313, 0.023872405290603638, -0.023532219231128693, -0.03320242092013359, -0.016188647598028183, 0.0868300125002861, 0.024700356647372246, 0.025641195476055145, 0.002716382499784231, 0.008611575700342655, 0.028832362964749336, -0.01311204582452774, -0.016190866008400917, -0.02605387382209301, 0.060284219682216644, -0.06406619399785995, -0.05616923049092293, -0.019499728456139565, -0.028383813798427582, 0.04616528004407883, -0.0016711141215637326, 0.02437828667461872, 0.0537702701985836, -0.01145864836871624, -0.020716099068522453, -0.041941285133361816, -0.030832573771476746, 0.0004561286186799407, -0.014452761970460415, 0.04568342864513397, -0.019225437194108963, 0.017755622044205666, 0.05322074517607689, 0.03864021599292755, 0.023547513410449028, 0.027555959299206734, 0.01470179483294487, 0.024377858266234398, 0.058417417109012604, -0.03786677122116089, -0.043902575969696045, 0.05642875283956528, -0.04854711890220642, 0.002968298736959696, -0.04202843829989433, 0.0030371365137398243, 0.04879753664135933, 0.0811171904206276, 0.008500877767801285, -0.03788287565112114, -0.02286846935749054, -0.06813053786754608, -0.0006493800901807845, 0.03433922678232193, -0.005514975171536207, 0.045225102454423904, 0.010847547091543674, 0.036489229649305344, -0.007308662869036198, -0.010557539761066437, -0.030207738280296326, -0.103108249604702, -0.01294447761029005, -0.0016001930925995111, -0.018507862463593483, 0.012674486264586449, 0.004185158293694258, -0.029253197833895683, 0.027256321161985397, -0.030261803418397903, -0.03491457924246788, 0.006541982758790255, 0.042964741587638855, -0.00825374573469162, 0.0535549595952034, -0.01449193712323904, 0.0007520986837334931, 0.05122651532292366, -0.0013014836004003882, 0.10430169850587845, 0.07661087065935135, 0.01407410204410553, -0.05387024208903313, 0.0503205731511116, 0.002942869206890464, 0.005016585811972618, -0.02178148180246353, 0.012748544104397297, 0.020625725388526917, -0.013935104012489319, 0.015546970069408417, 0.04652877897024155, 0.023573994636535645, -0.007938950322568417, 0.0448777861893177, -0.019276060163974762, -0.022378649562597275, 0.03421797603368759, 0.005295791197568178, -0.01411473099142313, -0.020425692200660706, -0.017134450376033783, 0.006261855363845825, -0.015864018350839615, 0.03048880770802498, 0.007362921256572008, 0.010210752487182617, 0.005839621648192406, 0.020724663510918617, -0.02364356257021427, 0.024473631754517555, 0.015650035813450813, 0.047738853842020035, -0.02513778954744339, 0.023781199008226395, 0.010440892539918423, -0.003367141354829073, 0.0031265821307897568, 0.03607684746384621, -0.014757329598069191, -0.015987001359462738, -0.0002830980811268091, 0.017534276470541954, -0.05604894086718559, -0.0301178228110075, -0.03643004223704338, 0.030366718769073486, 0.02683800831437111, -0.00013176385255064815, -0.011600583791732788, 0.010766052640974522, -0.008198746480047703, -0.049249839037656784, -0.027665596455335617, 0.016214992851018906, 0.018369264900684357, -0.03528676554560661, 0.0074296570383012295, -0.039078645408153534, 0.0023977828677743673, -0.019785240292549133, 0.03253764286637306, 0.042353030294179916, -0.0359770767390728, -0.009793913923203945, -0.02750677801668644, 0.05533929169178009, 0.02020079642534256, 0.0014953825157135725, 0.013228521682322025, -0.031197989359498024, -0.022695712745189667, -0.0009385842713527381, -0.01627308689057827, 0.003945365082472563, 0.02173999324440956, 0.009426431730389595, -0.011492373421788216, -0.0750550776720047, -0.03953060880303383, 0.008560527116060257, -0.00526915118098259, -0.012090946547687054, -0.04653353989124298, -0.002220571506768465, 0.044960033148527145, 0.012599614448845387, 0.039639927446842194, 0.03466102480888367, -0.017633095383644104, 0.02237754501402378, 0.020895030349493027, -0.0461045578122139, -0.046919189393520355, -0.00672569964081049, -0.04753369092941284, 0.006731679197400808, -0.01825929619371891, 0.05696568265557289, -0.012440457940101624, -0.008326908573508263, -0.004575999919325113, 0.03174421563744545, -0.025528287515044212, 0.06292911618947983, 0.021585166454315186, -0.04355141893029213, 0.004739533644169569, -0.02590516209602356, -0.001174028031527996, 0.007429128512740135, -0.009524265304207802, -0.05074780434370041, -0.04478604719042778, 0.021775389090180397, -0.005278782453387976, -0.045224692672491074, 0.014072070829570293, -0.008043956942856312, 0.035965725779533386, -0.047232504934072495, -0.024173887446522713, -0.05208978429436684, -0.03280089050531387, 0.05099143087863922, -0.013330112211406231, 0.0017890527378767729, 0.013069035485386848, -0.022180983796715736, 0.00042474817018955946, 0.04098670184612274, 0.021452613174915314, -0.013006695546209812, -0.03333369642496109, 0.00028350597131066024, 0.010188979096710682, 0.08261129260063171, -0.03202788904309273, -0.041873712092638016, 0.0331827737390995, -0.011541338637471199, -0.02229630947113037, 0.023570435121655464, -0.02473776414990425, 0.04469069093465805, 0.011910815723240376, -0.01600208319723606, -0.03934628143906593, 0.040545590221881866, -0.032932382076978683, -0.012128790840506554, -0.035414934158325195, 0.004184357821941376, -0.003658485831692815, 0.0002939965925179422, -0.0023107551969587803, 0.01852751150727272, -0.04141690954566002, 0.024502839893102646, 0.051014795899391174, 0.004903715569525957, 0.0014059423701837659, 0.005820487160235643, -0.0014370466815307736, 0.03139198198914528, -0.006110304035246372, -0.032612383365631104, 0.0304010771214962, 0.056865278631448746, -0.029034879058599472, 0.022552194073796272, 0.003060783026739955, 0.025512132793664932, -0.07776853442192078, -0.02687874808907509, -0.02230016142129898, 0.028625577688217163, 0.03195219486951828, -0.04394077509641647, 0.05490037053823471, 0.03589184582233429, -0.017841877415776253, 0.01798493228852749, 0.003016193164512515, 0.02349536493420601, -0.05098973214626312, -0.00303038302809, -0.026887409389019012, -0.006893736310303211, 0.05648477002978325, 0.040177904069423676, 0.0180318932980299, 0.014230330474674702, 0.009754537604749203, -0.03326768800616264, -0.009154455736279488, 0.0026126140728592873, -0.006189643405377865, -0.05996771156787872, 0.006579903420060873, -0.06701774895191193, -0.02736477181315422, 0.0353095568716526, -0.020553939044475555, 0.02407113090157509, 0.022055238485336304, 0.020011862739920616, 0.006835202686488628, 0.051626354455947876, 0.008725124411284924, -0.015677427873015404, -0.02424975484609604, -0.009896175004541874, -0.016793694347143173, 0.01166480127722025, -0.016056574881076813, 0.024181367829442024, 0.017565062269568443, -0.02332938089966774, -0.023441119119524956, -0.00900756474584341, 0.007143590599298477, -0.025660701096057892, -0.007875807583332062, -0.020165104418992996, 0.010509118437767029, -0.022328756749629974, 0.0020555644296109676, -0.043613288551568985, 0.01944866217672825, 0.0233315397053957, 0.05482150986790657, -0.02913721278309822, -0.0031884051859378815, -0.005151812918484211, 0.004734946880489588, 0.026674749329686165, -0.005932787898927927, 0.016132107004523277, -0.049927663058042526, -0.012495769187808037, -0.010066339746117592, -0.0077154869213700294, -0.01652676984667778, -0.015049993991851807, -0.024195607751607895, 0.05177592858672142, -0.049609676003456116, -0.02038389816880226, 0.022701222449541092, -0.05311853811144829, 0.003530857851728797, -0.0792810395359993, 0.06547436118125916, 0.005702852737158537, -0.04257133603096008, -0.04081044718623161, 0.024415776133537292, -0.0630800798535347, -0.014269075356423855, 0.06682904809713364, -0.006991881877183914, -0.013480158522725105, -0.014013866893947124, 0.020594144240021706, 0.022437861189246178, -0.026655403897166252, 0.014315025880932808, -0.02107514813542366, -0.017186276614665985, 0.0050332192331552505, -0.020961111411452293, 0.01773953065276146, 0.03174063563346863, 0.008770763874053955, -0.01624257303774357, 0.02169274352490902, 0.008862382732331753, -0.009700058959424496, 0.008422654122114182, -0.0006958670564927161, 0.01782856695353985, 0.06381122022867203, 0.01698228530585766, 0.03198095038533211, 0.031946055591106415, 0.0200075414031744, -0.020699962973594666, 0.05515141040086746, -0.017711428925395012, -0.004271709360182285, -0.005167677067220211, 0.013257891871035099, -0.04657735303044319, -0.04928074777126312, -0.012354888021945953, 0.03766912966966629, -0.008591367863118649, -0.005059683229774237, 0.028870873153209686, 0.027455488219857216, 0.013175698928534985, -0.014983843080699444, 0.026782115921378136, 0.014435706660151482, 0.004719816148281097, 0.00006813420623075217, 0.022667668759822845, 0.05010620504617691, 0.03133021295070648, -0.005323455203324556, 0.019641628488898277, -0.012339922599494457, 0.004314440302550793, -0.013730661012232304, 0.01075392123311758, -0.006514313165098429, -0.01583784446120262, 0.02143235318362713, -0.0328291654586792, 0.02906581573188305, 0.015516445972025394, -0.0002851418685168028, 0.026905180886387825, -0.06796326488256454, -0.0015199503395706415, -0.04945678636431694, -0.01077775377780199, -0.024723650887608528, -0.00582081638276577, 0.033714644610881805, -0.03079414740204811, 0.02799288183450699, 0.003598860464990139, 0.0035260471049696207, -0.006343459710478783, 0.0009525861823931336, -0.0340418703854084, 0.019879842177033424, -0.025758342817425728, -0.0002973756636492908, -0.04038591682910919, 0.01672627031803131, -0.026648741215467453, -0.014598225243389606, 0.04430652782320976, 0.029365848749876022, 0.03713615983724594, -0.032280776649713516, -0.025602152571082115, -0.024450749158859253, 0.034808963537216187, -0.06519310176372528, -0.02306186407804489, -0.057252660393714905, -0.011686593294143677, 0.009512227959930897, -0.03897060826420784 ]
<p>So I've been reading various online tutorials and I've not come across and example which is similar to what I'm trying to do. I've thought up this example because I was struggling to explain with words alone. It's really basic but hopefully illustrates the concept:</p> <pre><code>movie_eg=data.frame(score_children=c(1.1,2.5,3.9,1.5,4.3), score_adults=c(12.5,13.1,18.1,13.1,18.8), brad_hrs=c(0.1,0.2,0.3,0.1,0.6), angelina_hrs=c(0.2,0.6,0.8,0.9,0.1), cgi_budget=c(0.9,0.1,0.2,0.3,0.8), seat_cost=c(0.1,0.3,0.6,0.1,0.9)) rownames(movie_eg)=c("shrek","bourne","lockstock","scream","sharknado") </code></pre> <p>So in reality I have over 400 "movies" each with 2 continuous outcomes ("scores") and 4 predictive measurements ("brad","ang","budget","seats") which are also continuous. The two "scores" are moderately correlated across "movies".</p> <p>I'd like to see if there is a strong connection between any/all of the predictive values and the two outcomes - so here, what (if anything) influences both "scores"?</p> <p>Therefore, I believe that the "dependent variables" are the two outcomes and the "independent variables" are the four predictions.</p> <p>So I would do: <code>summary.aov(manova(cbind(brad_hrs,angelina_hrs,cgi_budget,seat_cost)~cbind(score_children,score_adults),data=movie_eg))</code></p> <p>and then see all P values are greater than 0.05, so nothing had a strong effect on score? But that seat_cost was the best predictor (although still not significant)? </p> <pre><code>Response seat_cost : Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(&gt;F) cbind(score_children, score_adults) 2 0.45417 0.227085 17.583 0.05381 . Residuals 2 0.02583 0.012915 </code></pre> <p>(Probably worth mentioning in reality the "scores" are measures of drug response and the predictions are measures of different cellular functions, so really nothing to do with movies!)</p>
74,394
[ -0.04463908076286316, -0.01944466307759285, 0.015582402236759663, 0.04430385306477547, 0.014786763116717339, -0.004711099434643984, -0.030720368027687073, -0.010342972353100777, 0.025972384959459305, -0.021001899614930153, 0.009214065968990326, 0.029151931405067444, 0.04568842425942421, 0.036789558827877045, 0.018471406772732735, -0.014878693968057632, 0.006513633299618959, -0.014677025377750397, 0.0463242344558239, -0.023015715181827545, 0.0033456168603152037, 0.014676554128527641, 0.01146206445991993, -0.02833644673228264, -0.007732523139566183, 0.09293566644191742, 0.0007834045682102442, -0.047969210892915726, -0.009343252517282963, 0.01560800801962614, -0.0011816906044259667, -0.05797700956463814, 0.027483204379677773, 0.03083750233054161, 0.015776395797729492, 0.02343246154487133, -0.024004485458135605, -0.013634973205626011, 0.0029156887903809547, 0.023260336369276047, -0.018048139289021492, -0.03809608519077301, 0.03291093930602074, 0.02960542030632496, -0.0031401454471051693, 0.021338455379009247, -0.022341635078191757, -0.005035856273025274, 0.025672337040305138, -0.010929274372756481, 0.083123579621315, -0.04393676295876503, 0.02415955811738968, 0.017904365435242653, -0.04155484586954117, -0.009527099318802357, 0.05611767619848251, 0.047114599496126175, 0.011381439864635468, -0.04552773758769035, 0.018225520849227905, -0.0005587878986261785, -0.0016209329478442669, -0.004113050643354654, -0.024918055161833763, 0.03403986245393753, 0.0035427692346274853, 0.006931368261575699, 0.049278609454631805, -0.00782725028693676, -0.02468312717974186, -0.004845390561968088, 0.06682942807674408, 0.007617620285600424, 0.02172274701297283, 0.007573613431304693, 0.027060450986027718, 0.00003716693026944995, 0.04144519567489624, 0.0111982561647892, -0.00046556914458051324, 0.020048493519425392, 0.01504406239837408, 0.05968401953577995, 0.010894814506173134, 0.009533663280308247, 0.04204374551773071, -0.04735642671585083, 0.014600805006921291, 0.03874104097485542, 0.012779934331774712, -0.005833814386278391, 0.04981668293476105, 0.04401378333568573, -0.04912136122584343, 0.03362521529197693, -0.0024760179221630096, 0.04744406044483185, 0.01409792061895132, 0.023206008598208427, -0.014108879491686821, -0.021521346643567085, 0.0017355310264974833, 0.025652237236499786, -0.03521733358502388, -0.007119295187294483, -0.05716882273554802, -0.015415758825838566, -0.010919956490397453, -0.011437256820499897, -0.041280798614025116, 0.01981503516435623, -0.01342789176851511, -0.028031544759869576, 0.03153079375624657, -0.05848139151930809, -0.021120289340615273, -0.0009241661173291504, 0.07698135823011398, 0.04577390477061272, 0.04181743413209915, -0.014583323150873184, -0.004407843109220266, 0.009562286548316479, -0.06424917280673981, -0.016746724024415016, 0.017336830496788025, -0.004020560532808304, 0.01612793654203415, 0.07298401743173599, -0.017650559544563293, -0.03176696598529816, 0.00019265997980255634, 0.02129419334232807, 0.00023396812321152538, 0.012939408421516418, -0.07012990117073059, -0.03520992398262024, -0.0030558223370462656, -0.027785003185272217, -0.029185334220528603, -0.05591361224651337, 0.012682709842920303, 0.00955174770206213, 0.0420844592154026, -0.041115984320640564, 0.02769223414361477, 0.039474572986364365, 0.027941768988966942, 0.02681814506649971, -0.018859602510929108, 0.01360053475946188, -0.02759547159075737, -0.008174268528819084, -0.05356262996792793, -0.08633982390165329, 0.0027046401519328356, 0.012939517386257648, -0.014694040641188622, 0.021004430949687958, 0.015535825863480568, 0.016215559095144272, -0.020320923998951912, -0.002112483372911811, 0.03732410818338394, -0.04305524006485939, 0.01124604046344757, -0.012769732624292374, 0.006871872581541538, 0.018466459587216377, -0.03119712881743908, -0.007303891237825155, 0.007790237665176392, 0.03192991390824318, 0.01166167389601469, 0.010711471550166607, -0.025266213342547417, -0.023311594501137733, -0.010568824596703053, 0.007909383624792099, -0.046667445451021194, -0.057335015386343, -0.07221729308366776, -0.01793728955090046, 0.018606409430503845, 0.04993711784482002, 0.001233714516274631, -0.009428100660443306, 0.06059757620096207, -0.024506207555532455, -0.04707098752260208, -0.08621792495250702, 0.01356066856533289, 0.0104938680306077, -0.04321315884590149, 0.05237541347742081, -0.019682761281728745, 0.04404762387275696, -0.013429133221507072, 0.012345336377620697, -0.0649956688284874, -0.011641518212854862, 0.024870142340660095, -0.050626251846551895, 0.031287599354982376, 0.012564410455524921, 0.020085090771317482, -0.008466672152280807, 0.02374604530632496, -0.0484570637345314, -0.022940848022699356, 0.005951805040240288, -0.028156736865639687, 0.015127555467188358, -0.013759944587945938, -0.030778728425502777, 0.015574677847325802, 0.004472621250897646, -0.0002596165577415377, 0.029376281425356865, -0.08324171602725983, 0.04410051554441452, 0.06913889199495316, -0.007528938818722963, 0.019598161801695824, 0.018743474036455154, -0.00431154714897275, 0.007661411538720131, -0.05379112809896469, 0.001901741954497993, -0.01744251511991024, 0.013248768635094166, 0.04592727869749069, -0.0002890487958211452, -0.0015679129865020514, 0.0077028111554682255, 0.03349689021706581, -0.009437941014766693, 0.014079803600907326, 0.027924058958888054, 0.034406039863824844, -0.004903254099190235, 0.017065681517124176, 0.01018327847123146, -0.003979549277573824, -0.00312789436429739, -0.006924627348780632, -0.0023956981021910906, 0.08144661039113998, -0.006220980081707239, 0.013684512116014957, 0.034556105732917786, 0.04922616481781006, 0.03791939094662666, -0.057966575026512146, -0.000533589452970773, 0.03968152403831482, -0.023593617603182793, 0.02078457549214363, 0.09141723811626434, 0.04069780930876732, -0.030245544388890266, 0.006757830735296011, -0.0428345650434494, -0.009480434469878674, 0.018165893852710724, -0.02261977083981037, 0.02817011997103691, 0.005345465149730444, -0.029020637273788452, 0.031815994530916214, 0.027374330908060074, -0.026186374947428703, -0.04374033212661743, -0.008148351684212685, 0.0029579426627606153, -0.0005156797706149518, 0.0222725011408329, -0.023803511634469032, -0.024627700448036194, 0.02768070623278618, -0.022624870762228966, -0.008615951985120773, -0.0016866555670276284, -0.0482756607234478, 0.0066071683540940285, -0.012024236842989922, 0.014439664781093597, 0.020284797996282578, 0.021407827734947205, -0.0567442886531353, 0.05039922147989273, -0.0009577107266522944, -0.029141196981072426, -0.03361926227807999, -0.011992341838777065, 0.030896423384547234, -0.014796027913689613, -0.036411456763744354, 0.05434723198413849, 0.010483809746801853, -0.07123874127864838, -0.008013589307665825, -0.012993469834327698, -0.02452361211180687, -0.008042875677347183, -0.0365188829600811, -0.009649036452174187, 0.033654022961854935, 0.021113499999046326, 0.044335685670375824, -0.01985963061451912, 0.006104085594415665, -0.07485464960336685, -0.057633113116025925, 0.05522751435637474, 0.012765268795192242, 0.026758452877402306, 0.000488456804305315, -0.006370755843818188, 0.053178414702415466, 0.031485047191381454, -0.01800457388162613, -0.07938090711832047, -0.009286170825362206, -0.05092722550034523, -0.02540803886950016, 0.007782388478517532, 0.04580550640821457, 0.003670677077025175, 0.022603638470172882, 0.010286692529916763, 0.043817128986120224, 0.03182709217071533, 0.007985505275428295, 0.054349709302186966, -0.0038194432854652405, 0.007957792840898037, -0.03383585065603256, 0.033435478806495667, 0.04038018360733986, -0.01699477806687355, -0.0017989366315305233, -0.003005784470587969, -0.02810366451740265, -0.0091881537809968, -0.014407387934625149, -0.01503557339310646, 0.0037642326205968857, -0.015268009155988693, -0.04061334580183029, 0.005862636025995016, 0.0065055908635258675, -0.03423083573579788, -0.026143359020352364, -0.008406939916312695, 0.054323356598615646, -0.020857756957411766, 0.02392994984984398, 0.034261975437402725, 0.013242906890809536, 0.011746793054044247, 0.005694064311683178, -0.016588861122727394, -0.007352311164140701, 0.00841620285063982, -0.05202356353402138, -0.02163330651819706, 0.03707332909107208, 0.014001061208546162, -0.015691883862018585, 0.005796866957098246, -0.04601212218403816, 0.04573754966259003, -0.04109446704387665, -0.015654709190130234, -0.07601255923509598, 0.04102727398276329, 0.012222949415445328, 0.07311689853668213, 0.013415704481303692, -0.0060808248817920685, 0.007930389605462551, -0.0050936355255544186, -0.024295147508382797, 0.02663462609052658, 0.005842073354870081, -0.006431668531149626, 0.023985521867871284, -0.03793357312679291, 0.01832551509141922, -0.027533650398254395, 0.021951526403427124, 0.022494345903396606, 0.004390841815620661, -0.01303020492196083, -0.016036925837397575, 0.008311736397445202, -0.02918083406984806, 0.01049893070012331, 0.0014901080867275596, 0.022372327744960785, -0.015311445109546185, 0.04533790051937103, 0.021192260086536407, -0.0076004499569535255, -0.016874495893716812, -0.019146034494042397, -0.02432231418788433, 0.01499518658965826, 0.05867449566721916, 0.06717025488615036, 0.008493284694850445, -0.020658742636442184, 0.04453153908252716, 0.026416022330522537, 0.013898628763854504, 0.024894772097468376, 0.0008263339404948056, -0.006311073433607817, -0.010435400530695915, -0.014492055401206017, 0.012545861303806305, -0.008756150491535664, 0.012857477180659771, -0.03778251260519028, 0.03477512300014496, 0.042290668934583664, -0.043956026434898376, 0.0010775545379146934, 0.08706271648406982, 0.023926686495542526, -0.0014416800113394856, -0.008676091209053993, 0.016842737793922424, -0.024537093937397003, 0.0012013341765850782, 0.04953635111451149, 0.025905191898345947, -0.014609714969992638, 0.0029991641640663147, 0.06702778488397598, -0.013763906434178352, -0.06204422190785408, -0.004063296597450972, -0.016987115144729614, 0.026351038366556168, -0.03455856442451477, -0.04237716645002365, -0.0033049280755221844, 0.037013474851846695, 0.0016123976092785597, 0.0019207482691854239, -0.004253861028701067, -0.07236149907112122, 0.01158819254487753, 0.03800192475318909, 0.038521621376276016, -0.011019772849977016, -0.006847759243100882, -0.04899820312857628, -0.0008703265921212733, 0.01897883601486683, -0.02216963656246662, 0.05821343511343002, 0.018594976514577866, 0.03091602958738804, -0.028732923790812492, -0.01883869245648384, -0.052465274930000305, 0.018905039876699448, -0.04573094844818115, -0.020474452525377274, -0.01675667241215706, -0.04492301493883133, -0.030251244083046913, -0.005498618818819523, -0.007157139480113983, 0.05361602455377579, -0.02395004592835903, -0.05785039812326431, 0.013360085897147655, 0.004448521416634321, 0.003929879050701857, -0.028158895671367645, 0.04946557432413101, -0.03036590851843357, -0.012226593680679798, 0.07753162086009979, 0.019405828788876534, -0.0023071886971592903, -0.019016927108168602, 0.048105597496032715, -0.01876820996403694, 0.01204304862767458, -0.01913823001086712, 0.012577933259308338, 0.02851596474647522, 0.0014795663300901651, 0.018214723095297813, 0.02299392595887184, 0.0035918205976486206, 0.021960727870464325, -0.026839138939976692, 0.018174873664975166, 0.005854303482919931, -0.03849361836910248, -0.0383504256606102, -0.00884389691054821, -0.0011590654030442238, 0.007096084766089916, -0.003111995989456773, 0.03885970264673233, -0.05164528638124466, -0.0035403668880462646, 0.013459165580570698, 0.013077063485980034, -0.004451666492968798, -0.036960698664188385, -0.012912139296531677, -0.026422757655382156, -0.010344977490603924, -0.030530406162142754, 0.046611588448286057, -0.027323167771100998, 0.04099545627832413, 0.01256124023348093, -0.04345259815454483, 0.011742238886654377, -0.014246215112507343, 0.0012239632196724415, 0.040899649262428284, -0.03768312186002731, -0.008257534354925156, -0.00971989892423153, 0.07357165962457657, -0.008139941841363907, -0.03499462082982063, -0.042450033128261566, 0.023876570165157318, -0.012795071117579937, 0.03755999356508255, 0.007089879829436541, 0.025581639260053635, -0.003356523811817169, -0.021813396364450455, -0.023416312411427498, -0.00517733208835125, 0.01841670274734497, 0.011522086337208748, -0.027000578120350838, -0.018492702394723892, -0.004853914026170969, -0.03470001369714737, -0.0028960451018065214, -0.02721056155860424, 0.03163016960024834, -0.058239687234163284, -0.013373549096286297, 0.030530164018273354, 0.025335542857646942, 0.07398214191198349, 0.0256220530718565, -0.014348084107041359, 0.033572398126125336, 0.028027113527059555, 0.010221044532954693, 0.0012984336353838444, -0.0024338597431778908, -0.010190011002123356, 0.010356511920690536, -0.03570989519357681, 0.016199275851249695, 0.04087444767355919, -0.0005315439775586128, 0.01555200107395649, -0.023870816454291344, 0.01662784442305565, 0.04367392137646675, -0.05261385440826416, -0.015895342454314232, 0.00006142869824543595, 0.017302002757787704, -0.053132276982069016, 0.016984615474939346, -0.016671866178512573, -0.02468820847570896, 0.015830181539058685, 0.018919488415122032, -0.04557116702198982, 0.011543888598680496, 0.05761853978037834, 0.008237245492637157, -0.016267240047454834, 0.004689755383878946, -0.02688116393983364, 0.03637539595365524, 0.031033635139465332, -0.005113741382956505, -0.008958883583545685, 0.05074525624513626, -0.04819478094577789, -0.007040739059448242, -0.07114765048027039, 0.017403794452548027, 0.05346759781241417, -0.01515149511396885, 0.062153782695531845, 0.05435819923877716, -0.0016243072459474206, 0.0032224669121205807, -0.032548993825912476, -0.022775959223508835, 0.013231423683464527, 0.005932019557803869, 0.06275642663240433, -0.018913021311163902, 0.013278723694384098, 0.02285502292215824, -0.00921213161200285, 0.025700097903609276, 0.02379051223397255, -0.0157111044973135, -0.026762397959828377, 0.020037340000271797, -0.023740418255329132, -0.01334882527589798, 0.05116431415081024, -0.04705798998475075, 0.007052698638290167, -0.06262584030628204, 0.01079476810991764, 0.03792201355099678, 0.06380946934223175, -0.05607505515217781, -0.06169157475233078, -0.045934490859508514, -0.03767847642302513, 0.0004046090762130916, 0.007804434280842543, -0.0397530123591423, 0.034033942967653275, 0.03466736525297165, 0.040152423083782196, 0.003982169553637505, 0.03357303515076637, -0.05262129381299019, -0.0331437848508358, -0.011730578728020191, -0.021828042343258858, -0.018868891522288322, 0.030593998730182648, 0.014834444969892502, -0.005778873804956675, 0.020799433812499046, -0.025440150871872902, 0.024381205439567566, 0.007883798331022263, 0.023029156029224396, -0.007328101433813572, 0.02680826559662819, -0.0130577702075243, -0.009035103023052216, 0.008146987296640873, -0.0061714439652860165, 0.15232565999031067, 0.05604034289717674, 0.0228350181132555, -0.07228801399469376, 0.03782115504145622, 0.0347725972533226, 0.02323424443602562, -0.028876114636659622, 0.0054955449886620045, 0.009120606817305088, -0.014600480906665325, 0.04471529275178909, 0.03533455356955528, 0.059607796370983124, -0.007172218058258295, 0.011063365265727043, -0.024935193359851837, 0.011601526290178299, -0.007939673960208893, 0.01604439504444599, -0.024536287412047386, -0.03490985184907913, -0.035553012043237686, 0.03234381973743439, -0.006721085403114557, 0.010907944291830063, -0.052204739302396774, -0.016338588669896126, -0.0026887294370681047, 0.00010788440704345703, -0.0029102182015776634, -0.013397285714745522, -0.0039030767511576414, 0.01092181820422411, 0.04650435596704483, -0.02685016766190529, 0.05304422974586487, -0.05804942175745964, -0.007275647949427366, 0.019952641800045967, -0.02263594977557659, 0.0027267211116850376, -0.01433084812015295, 0.028851013630628586, -0.05676773190498352, -0.033041812479496, -0.03156498819589615, 0.03857475146651268, 0.04508033022284508, -0.0016724230954423547, -0.04836254194378853, 0.031514722853899, 0.02049122005701065, -0.045964471995830536, 0.0051153237000107765, 0.02980668656527996, 0.010216738097369671, -0.07172726094722748, 0.0003842688165605068, -0.012308869510889053, -0.023808108642697334, -0.0019215630600228906, -0.011717423796653748, 0.017349880188703537, -0.03096408024430275, -0.02811594493687153, -0.06277789920568466, 0.05111966282129288, -0.0012771239271387458, -0.030053425580263138, 0.03283949941396713, 0.019369522109627724, -0.000052297520596766844, 0.011663592420518398, -0.01666218601167202, 0.04045486077666283, 0.0050682625733315945, 0.030549898743629456, -0.029360994696617126, -0.05562714859843254, -0.02123824879527092, 0.032873738557100296, -0.03615771606564522, -0.0377892404794693, -0.04532432556152344, -0.0067885760217905045, 0.02963123470544815, 0.058212317526340485, 0.017124256119132042, -0.006898710038512945, 0.0017543863505125046, 0.07295366376638412, 0.017520032823085785, -0.03437011316418648, -0.013970116153359413, 0.0027568500954657793, -0.04193137213587761, -0.04532052204012871, -0.008901476860046387, 0.08913885802030563, -0.002265079878270626, 0.01302393525838852, -0.009717416018247604, 0.03346153721213341, -0.020772304385900497, 0.007506252266466618, 0.022677244618535042, -0.02081923373043537, 0.026064790785312653, -0.0066367993131279945, -0.015041545033454895, -0.03862540051341057, 0.013048159889876842, -0.01092499028891325, -0.04320896789431572, 0.0032974614296108484, -0.05396800860762596, -0.01455036923289299, 0.011628365144133568, -0.041324432939291, 0.038051538169384, -0.08157403767108917, -0.003926809411495924, -0.03984251245856285, -0.007227062247693539, -0.015166823752224445, -0.046329252421855927, 0.00026941171381622553, -0.010693243704736233, -0.010260083712637424, -0.030580390244722366, 0.009224871173501015, 0.024478798732161522, -0.012241249904036522, -0.022614462301135063, 0.013281917199492455, 0.0011830576695501804, 0.021636230871081352, 0.043409474194049835, -0.02126270718872547, 0.00104349828325212, -0.036611832678318024, -0.045143406838178635, -0.0005427657742984593, -0.01096052210777998, 0.05027206242084503, 0.011402126401662827, 0.00988698098808527, -0.027274498715996742, 0.06049041822552681, 0.002940584672614932, -0.000742700940463692, -0.02570509724318981, -0.01640266738831997, 0.035017821937799454, 0.015864349901676178, 0.009755837731063366, 0.021218765527009964, -0.01637158915400505, -0.005226442124694586, 0.034197285771369934, 0.0035361982882022858, 0.022229015827178955, -0.015860864892601967, -0.013032176531851292, -0.03568312153220177, 0.0011127482866868377, -0.013761006295681, 0.04572368413209915, 0.06765228509902954, -0.0014539374969899654, 0.03859200328588486, 0.001817487645894289, 0.028538422659039497, -0.06494183838367462, -0.007275022566318512, 0.004955743905156851, 0.0042987000197172165, 0.050115443766117096, -0.05152968689799309, -0.015712587162852287, 0.0391458161175251, -0.04250513017177582, 0.00962533988058567, 0.02120603807270527, 0.03160592168569565, -0.06337010860443115, 0.018302178010344505, -0.015986349433660507, 0.020887484773993492, 0.018556704744696617, 0.001696469378657639, 0.024083837866783142, 0.032872505486011505, 0.0006145526422187686, 0.005761400796473026, -0.018490755930542946, -0.010609755292534828, -0.006998830940574408, -0.029262807220220566, 0.010937769897282124, -0.03592560067772865, -0.0024655810557305813, 0.014555281028151512, -0.009170646779239178, 0.008607534691691399, 0.02942231297492981, 0.0006401012069545686, 0.02551068551838398, 0.04341874271631241, -0.023755431175231934, 0.009912263602018356, -0.006158214062452316, 0.013811022974550724, -0.0059888302348554134, 0.005453165154904127, -0.023597603663802147, 0.004315003287047148, 0.025032958015799522, -0.0011189691722393036, -0.0035516000352799892, 0.02262345515191555, 0.002867360832169652, -0.02691204845905304, -0.01515481248497963, -0.013256111182272434, -0.00943638663738966, -0.04776860773563385, 0.009776110760867596, -0.04696105793118477, -0.04237132892012596, 0.02563542313873768, 0.0321643091738224, 0.0036191565450280905, -0.008853900246322155, -0.015330935828387737, -0.07079508900642395, 0.003596613882109523, -0.015180598944425583, 0.009822634980082512, -0.003194347955286503, -0.02017558179795742, -0.02566106617450714, -0.02391914278268814, -0.04022098705172539, 0.0021870152559131384, -0.03215811401605606, 0.024291126057505608, -0.02386762760579586, -0.011268369853496552, 0.04254067316651344, 0.014057300053536892, -0.0030909464694559574, -0.09088291227817535, 0.07130523771047592, 0.041111283004283905, 0.01325906254351139, -0.042713116854429245, 0.010939309373497963, -0.02193734049797058, 0.020965928211808205, 0.07013247907161713, -0.008676265366375446, 0.028484290465712547, 0.008830812759697437, 0.00612581567838788, -0.0052162278443574905, -0.012426534667611122, 0.054241545498371124, 0.013494202867150307, 0.019891580566763878, -0.01527084968984127, 0.036931250244379044, 0.017104998230934143, -0.0023590477649122477, -0.0052497414872050285, -0.04964355751872063, 0.00020725897047668695, 0.0024415254592895508, 0.015257102437317371, 0.006737497169524431, 0.017877068370580673, -0.0007691318751312792, 0.02229447476565838, -0.019692037254571915, -0.02369576320052147, 0.04656030982732773, -0.01938214898109436, -0.060184601694345474, 0.02483048476278782, -0.005012192763388157, -0.013592394068837166, -0.009643597528338432, -0.009860767982900143, -0.02747381664812565, -0.03159394860267639, 0.0076159462332725525, 0.024110479280352592, -0.04267111048102379, -0.01882275752723217, 0.04831612482666969, 0.01886889897286892, 0.023161908611655235, -0.04322641342878342, 0.01848842203617096, 0.004800592549145222, -0.05876537412405014, 0.02680221013724804, 0.004220976959913969, 0.047524917870759964, 0.039872393012046814, -0.006090778391808271, 0.04169514402747154, -0.025998488068580627, 0.007131477352231741, -0.029086649417877197, 0.0636591985821724, -0.007599314674735069, -0.010537929832935333, -0.04011140763759613, 0.033210638910532, 0.017052600160241127, 0.029907256364822388, -0.016636772081255913, 0.07576256990432739, -0.04895712435245514, 0.017127083614468575, -0.020483387634158134, 0.02447878196835518, -0.06390266120433807, -0.0013979043578729033, 0.01655804179608822, 0.00647015729919076, 0.016859397292137146, -0.005449901334941387, 0.00853283517062664, -0.01651589944958687, -0.007031321991235018, -0.02125145122408867, 0.003960003610700369, -0.03395660221576691, 0.0016955051105469465, 0.04597404599189758, -0.000024804216081975028, -0.0020743049681186676, -0.013653917238116264, 0.06487435102462769, 0.021329659968614578, 0.02381768450140953, -0.02693621627986431, -0.04661254957318306, -0.014829909428954124, 0.0749536082148552, -0.07867969572544098, -0.02529774233698845, -0.00389042473398149, 0.04558228701353073, 0.029765482991933823, -0.0015494389226660132 ]
<p>I have read several textbook descriptions on RVM and none of them provide an adequate (plain English) explanation of how RVM achieves sparsity.</p> <p>I am left feeling like the authors left out a paragraph of text that would have connected the dots and instead decided to replace (rather than supplement) it with mathematical derivations.</p> <p>Could someone please explain the basic idea as to how RVM works in relation to learning sparse regression models?</p>
37,263
[ -0.007789397146552801, -0.006338193081319332, 0.0065319412387907505, -0.0444352962076664, 0.012122184038162231, -0.006210801657289267, -0.006927462760359049, -0.004752402659505606, 0.07094655930995941, -0.036959391087293625, 0.008164496161043644, 0.04248762130737305, 0.05907011777162552, -0.04280928522348404, 0.008223159238696098, -0.019779466092586517, -0.018621673807501793, -0.019165489822626114, 0.02819410152733326, -0.005076984874904156, -0.0055327583104372025, 0.01334297377616167, 0.03949170559644699, -0.004766540136188269, -0.002074511256068945, 0.05947209894657135, 0.026198439300060272, 0.013281856663525105, 0.0008834425243549049, 0.05303874611854553, -0.025933347642421722, 0.0024384220596402884, -0.041006989777088165, 0.0506768524646759, 0.020200861617922783, 0.0033291252329945564, -0.02393033541738987, -0.021680923178792, 0.015233381651341915, 0.03918202221393585, 0.00259680044837296, -0.03529878705739975, 0.00913291983306408, 0.06140962243080139, -0.04155895113945007, 0.01195264421403408, 0.03368496894836426, -0.0327514223754406, 0.017465317621827126, -0.05161404237151146, 0.0793246403336525, 0.021580612286925316, 0.05135076493024826, 0.04466532915830612, -0.012580734677612782, 0.03422979637980461, 0.059582971036434174, 0.08388818055391312, 0.004160674754530191, -0.02165689505636692, -0.01647261530160904, -0.037978582084178925, -0.018540753051638603, -0.027341770008206367, -0.04956897720694542, 0.03583654761314392, -0.0079265171661973, -0.0011016635689884424, 0.05078446865081787, -0.0006395482341758907, 0.004626543261110783, 0.0026972531341016293, 0.022298334166407585, -0.008273934945464134, 0.03201283514499664, 0.012464474886655807, 0.005362040363252163, 0.01436800416558981, 0.03799515962600708, 0.010428913868963718, 0.020568430423736572, 0.018764309585094452, 0.0387895293533802, 0.029466310515999794, -0.0010556125780567527, -0.00006285005656536669, 0.06419696658849716, 0.017995795235037804, 0.02197357639670372, 0.020388560369610786, -0.018660880625247955, 0.024226363748311996, 0.031234297901391983, -0.01306953001767397, -0.04811541736125946, 0.04166955500841141, -0.0005107703036628664, 0.02529229409992695, 0.017550399526953697, -0.050702791661024094, -0.010121474973857403, -0.009417452849447727, -0.004823034629225731, 0.04935135319828987, -0.04361893981695175, -0.04755218327045441, -0.036640144884586334, 0.03643278405070305, -0.026263270527124405, -0.030998103320598602, -0.04447439685463905, 0.030446616932749748, 0.013081164099276066, 0.005843028426170349, 0.0426933690905571, -0.011008938774466515, 0.014016389846801758, -0.042387500405311584, 0.04355341196060181, 0.0430741012096405, 0.020512161776423454, -0.042852140963077545, 0.02103598602116108, -0.038600802421569824, -0.022552330046892166, 0.026298735290765762, 0.0017584740417078137, -0.02811063826084137, -0.024661993607878685, 0.03947640210390091, -0.0037515272852033377, -0.05514126271009445, 0.045094624161720276, 0.02067645452916622, 0.018992379307746887, -0.012965637259185314, -0.09892748296260834, -0.010776393115520477, 0.0629807710647583, -0.00997028686106205, 0.023230692371726036, -0.06189802289009094, 0.018514396622776985, 0.029089277610182762, 0.045259565114974976, 0.01533554494380951, 0.027186429128050804, 0.04219454899430275, -0.005382935516536236, -0.02048858068883419, -0.007854712195694447, -0.03408588096499443, -0.014496201649308205, -0.012343021109700203, 0.0020638892892748117, -0.07447931170463562, 0.004450161475688219, 0.02260003425180912, -0.015246165916323662, -0.009924182668328285, 0.05191483721137047, 0.00024494779063388705, -0.023589560762047768, 0.014007527381181717, -0.016873763874173164, 0.005218937061727047, 0.03894961625337601, 0.0051024304702878, 0.019255461171269417, 0.05687722936272621, 0.01042751781642437, -0.017378097400069237, 0.04536524415016174, 0.06646227091550827, 0.03409375995397568, -0.014438258484005928, -0.008864912204444408, -0.021834999322891235, 0.019173352047801018, 0.017067255452275276, -0.058781400322914124, -0.054065655916929245, 0.010232135653495789, 0.016971530392766, 0.02870357036590576, 0.05997063219547272, 0.008991504088044167, -0.014548735693097115, 0.01568431407213211, -0.024629736319184303, -0.017023175954818726, -0.050518326461315155, 0.01590871997177601, -0.014609305188059807, -0.01751888543367386, 0.027028528973460197, 0.019667401909828186, -0.001979468623176217, -0.003999253269284964, -0.023682119324803352, -0.006808294449001551, -0.01241489127278328, 0.015782419592142105, -0.022481823340058327, 0.013326921500265598, 0.03845267742872238, 0.031243836507201195, -0.0067673069424927235, 0.0403253547847271, -0.021539771929383278, -0.04585281386971474, 0.004501677583903074, 0.007404030300676823, 0.005184098146855831, -0.030602507293224335, -0.02458152361214161, 0.02764543890953064, -0.01464050728827715, 0.0036124989856034517, 0.01729537732899189, -0.0336405411362648, 0.04281845688819885, 0.053150903433561325, 0.04440438374876976, -0.03157944232225418, 0.024261387065052986, -0.01487678848206997, 0.003831930458545685, -0.008027618750929832, -0.02753586880862713, -0.03381693363189697, -0.039342138916254044, 0.06106690317392349, 0.01970861293375492, -0.007995185442268848, 0.025437455624341965, 0.05291471630334854, 0.0797387957572937, 0.03788373991847038, 0.03391449898481369, -0.042675986886024475, 0.0027815455105155706, 0.021531272679567337, 0.0174880251288414, -0.008117593824863434, -0.02500552125275135, -0.04799748212099075, 0.038103148341178894, 0.030459722504019737, 0.002096401294693351, -0.01575998216867447, 0.06709562242031097, 0.00469462014734745, -0.026681620627641678, -0.021113023161888123, -0.024585938081145287, 0.0030843184795230627, -0.03626168891787529, -0.005875757429748774, 0.038160815834999084, 0.0010620717657729983, 0.022470537573099136, -0.031471047550439835, -0.028090517967939377, 0.04029116779565811, 0.024131303653120995, -0.009169848635792732, 0.0047909715212881565, 0.017920570448040962, -0.0514780692756176, 0.006861782167106867, -0.048355016857385635, -0.039787422865629196, -0.06064238026738167, -0.018856864422559738, 0.04489636793732643, 0.0005162712768651545, 0.010161706246435642, 0.0024377168156206608, -0.020256103947758675, 0.01193345058709383, -0.03720112144947052, 0.015540084801614285, 0.015077624469995499, -0.02888643741607666, 0.017867377027869225, -0.03806478530168533, 0.013534588739275932, 0.02002997323870659, 0.01595444791018963, -0.03023790381848812, -0.014746224507689476, -0.02866450697183609, -0.09383447468280792, -0.0244334414601326, -0.04419979825615883, 0.03900660201907158, -0.02120017074048519, -0.0006653845775872469, 0.057021643966436386, -0.009627806022763252, -0.03268803656101227, 0.001862765522673726, -0.01773371547460556, -0.025152618065476418, -0.026011846959590912, -0.0211282130330801, 0.023180481046438217, -0.018307805061340332, 0.0003933363768737763, 0.023935485631227493, -0.047342218458652496, 0.013787290081381798, -0.05903487280011177, -0.058818571269512177, 0.016642408445477486, -0.010085195302963257, 0.0007952513406053185, 0.030739154666662216, -0.041315749287605286, 0.08734016120433807, 0.015253703109920025, -0.014986073598265648, -0.03643420711159706, 0.030552227050065994, -0.0064910477958619595, -0.01697971671819687, 0.03220585733652115, 0.0060387649573385715, 0.018610592931509018, 0.02316845767199993, -0.002672414993867278, 0.019881045445799828, 0.07413928955793381, 0.011915940791368484, 0.0060546123422682285, 0.009095747023820877, 0.0018473153468221426, -0.011806368827819824, 0.012628109194338322, 0.012589002028107643, -0.021909845992922783, 0.0075378334149718285, -0.010995278134942055, 0.0338863879442215, 0.006242961622774601, -0.04427381604909897, -0.011912673711776733, -0.002797130960971117, 0.023108428344130516, -0.0450347438454628, 0.00540708564221859, 0.002632097341120243, -0.024327844381332397, -0.001483796862885356, 0.017358897253870964, 0.034633535891771317, -0.03311451897025108, -0.010716122575104237, 0.013956011272966862, 0.037848345935344696, -0.02784223109483719, -0.0002487169113010168, -0.004749643616378307, -0.035613615065813065, 0.016540300101041794, -0.011543288826942444, 0.019819188863039017, 0.06491228193044662, 0.00581087963655591, 0.0033047969918698072, -0.016240809112787247, -0.07418188452720642, -0.003153895027935505, -0.05582823231816292, 0.012270038016140461, 0.0005084556760266423, 0.033346161246299744, -0.002987909596413374, 0.05147234722971916, 0.011562791652977467, -0.001330351922661066, 0.01894247718155384, -0.0178774893283844, -0.05947354808449745, 0.011998869478702545, -0.0308353491127491, -0.008520020171999931, 0.0069666774943470955, -0.012334761209785938, 0.028439054265618324, -0.01259783748537302, -0.018530648201704025, -0.03570624813437462, 0.006315934006124735, -0.05755912512540817, 0.008082837797701359, 0.013510911725461483, -0.004100199323147535, -0.03370995074510574, 0.004370756447315216, 0.05726972967386246, -0.03136187791824341, 0.023196594789624214, 0.07033909857273102, 0.0027803173288702965, 0.0007367880316451192, -0.02671736665070057, 0.016461487859487534, 0.0372246578335762, 0.013880355283617973, 0.031735874712467194, 0.015881942585110664, -0.031297244131565094, 0.03937539458274841, -0.007218621671199799, 0.04532881826162338, 0.02810370922088623, -0.01863666996359825, -0.03621583431959152, -0.0426538921892643, -0.029762830585241318, 0.017553867772221565, 0.01866900362074375, -0.008179196156561375, 0.024298187345266342, 0.06010052561759949, 0.03733004629611969, -0.057748712599277496, -0.0011634064139798284, 0.04834241047501564, -0.005228231195360422, -0.013953303918242455, -0.056221552193164825, 0.0012387853348627687, -0.0012221031356602907, 0.003981103654950857, 0.03506392613053322, -0.02141883410513401, -0.04301797226071358, -0.019614823162555695, 0.03253256529569626, -0.038340941071510315, -0.029172370210289955, -0.028889615088701248, 0.02633172646164894, 0.025119850412011147, -0.038303688168525696, -0.03542196378111839, -0.02221151813864708, 0.04540814086794853, 0.038317568600177765, 0.02954382635653019, -0.009745020419359207, -0.07865341752767563, -0.028319792822003365, 0.024067027494311333, 0.0281656663864851, -0.034564059227705, 0.014781416393816471, -0.05935607850551605, -0.027326373383402824, 0.04408850148320198, -0.025855040177702904, 0.04155995696783066, 0.0037312833592295647, 0.0013162040850147605, -0.013997846283018589, -0.015911344438791275, -0.012347017414867878, -0.0036346684210002422, -0.039791759103536606, 0.06205765902996063, 0.007017869036644697, -0.03673308342695236, -0.07443223893642426, 0.008335616439580917, -0.0056861951015889645, 0.06514459103345871, -0.010123543441295624, 0.00017635391850490123, -0.012342247180640697, 0.03088054247200489, 0.0020925505086779594, -0.07513309270143509, 0.01031175721436739, -0.004899610299617052, -0.028586216270923615, 0.05614379048347473, -0.004982371348887682, -0.0664733350276947, 0.005700393114238977, 0.04311603680253029, -0.030456382781267166, -0.013973100110888481, -0.032320402562618256, 0.031877804547548294, 0.037987347692251205, -0.001086270553059876, 0.06786487251520157, 0.006163360550999641, 0.029040496796369553, 0.0006296717911027372, -0.020347101613879204, 0.048573482781648636, -0.038042690604925156, -0.031888604164123535, -0.03215743228793144, -0.007315775379538536, 0.00009444131137570366, 0.02442130632698536, 0.0034532956779003143, 0.04964594915509224, -0.010502289980649948, -0.014495955780148506, -0.023478813469409943, 0.0346648208796978, -0.015135525725781918, -0.01246656384319067, 0.01979418471455574, 0.04921053349971771, -0.003179276594892144, 0.0018203885992988944, 0.007425511255860329, -0.022541875019669533, -0.0007808344671502709, 0.012695549055933952, 0.007087375968694687, 0.01674623414874077, -0.009467009454965591, -0.02497914806008339, 0.04153032228350639, -0.026820030063390732, 0.05498013272881508, -0.04149449244141579, 0.021477382630109787, -0.017652135342359543, -0.07596887648105621, -0.04470647871494293, -0.019751623272895813, -0.03377408906817436, 0.03874319791793823, -0.04670802503824234, 0.008125610649585724, -0.0033214385621249676, -0.011563282459974289, -0.06515854597091675, -0.06553873419761658, 0.03177738934755325, -0.0025764540769159794, -0.01881510764360428, -0.02299271710216999, 0.02323516458272934, 0.007932265289127827, -0.020411666482686996, 0.010184118524193764, 0.039233043789863586, -0.022316889837384224, 0.004276718012988567, -0.012369025498628616, 0.0023365190718322992, 0.061460498720407486, 0.01660211943089962, -0.0015468719648197293, 0.01664278656244278, -0.013268057256937027, -0.018553227186203003, 0.007578074000775814, 0.04435010254383087, -0.04437766224145889, -0.012211508117616177, -0.08042598515748978, 0.0033170515671372414, 0.047609180212020874, -0.022273562848567963, 0.021042002364993095, 0.020581835880875587, 0.023678241297602654, 0.01690652407705784, -0.04224810004234314, 0.0057883658446371555, 0.009051940403878689, 0.016278576105833054, 0.009043266996741295, -0.020123764872550964, -0.007753186859190464, 0.004661100450903177, 0.03575245290994644, 0.005843937862664461, 0.008877811022102833, 0.00028909181128256023, 0.06990739703178406, -0.029439594596624374, 0.025752736255526543, -0.0070735989138484, -0.02875155210494995, 0.006324481684714556, -0.01908380165696144, 0.028522253036499023, 0.01215193048119545, 0.007181735709309578, -0.05424629896879196, -0.008932465687394142, -0.06541590392589569, 0.018409451469779015, 0.0839696153998375, -0.03976454585790634, 0.04950649291276932, 0.040293384343385696, -0.03455408290028572, 0.004892829339951277, -0.050403621047735214, -0.024282878264784813, -0.015509320423007011, -0.016300000250339508, 0.05153822526335716, -0.01313478872179985, -0.005523722153156996, 0.02909526415169239, -0.0015925909392535686, 0.006865642499178648, 0.014859776012599468, 0.003648245707154274, 0.021263988688588142, 0.02085251919925213, -0.014454301446676254, -0.03868107497692108, 0.013591100461781025, -0.0019537878688424826, 0.00410377187654376, 0.012238530442118645, -0.011560848914086819, 0.04925830662250519, 0.020194046199321747, 0.026761170476675034, -0.033425573259592056, -0.030931204557418823, -0.036041226238012314, 0.038140878081321716, 0.019179919734597206, -0.008483211509883404, 0.006712151225656271, 0.013252513483166695, -0.004818054847419262, -0.0020425086840987206, 0.036932818591594696, -0.00552190700545907, -0.06543896347284317, -0.05339404568076134, 0.0063371555879712105, 0.004208396654576063, 0.0356668084859848, 0.03763170167803764, -0.06264389306306839, 0.01696621999144554, -0.04047274962067604, 0.010785219259560108, 0.016941389068961143, 0.04916004836559296, 0.00038059725193306804, 0.07736410200595856, 0.028726909309625626, 0.01059660129249096, -0.005636477377265692, -0.01560774352401495, 0.1067558079957962, 0.08396683633327484, 0.020907290279865265, -0.07483723759651184, -0.005540953017771244, -0.015279063023626804, -0.03769760578870773, -0.021681344136595726, 0.010374643839895725, 0.000535516650415957, 0.021056946367025375, 0.02580655738711357, -0.0028986185789108276, -0.0007348700310103595, 0.01330750435590744, 0.01935003697872162, -0.03910944610834122, -0.037396449595689774, -0.005776630248874426, -0.0032020295038819313, 0.03133316710591316, 0.004791155457496643, -0.06371784210205078, 0.006601497530937195, -0.020927628502249718, -0.07216916978359222, -0.019969239830970764, -0.004802575334906578, 0.025056470185518265, -0.01927252858877182, 0.013539997860789299, 0.010284753516316414, 0.01222457829862833, 0.0056526255793869495, 0.021097524091601372, 0.028848839923739433, 0.025608450174331665, -0.01781659573316574, 0.017029209062457085, -0.006395695731043816, 0.025247765704989433, 0.0059298183768987656, -0.02002551034092903, 0.00915195606648922, -0.04612014815211296, -0.005058661103248596, -0.01668497361242771, 0.054854728281497955, -0.0093105873093009, 0.01791980303823948, -0.0020876892376691103, 0.028307506814599037, 0.00009772928024176508, -0.07558318972587585, 0.008256422355771065, 0.060137707740068436, 0.03570739924907684, -0.037789832800626755, -0.008810852654278278, -0.016696829348802567, 0.013575265184044838, -0.01980544999241829, 0.022519920021295547, 0.006102553103119135, -0.0356740765273571, -0.01719982549548149, -0.057429391890764236, 0.02468680590391159, -0.012850817292928696, 0.00808618776500225, -0.02270602248609066, -0.013156277127563953, 0.008034569211304188, -0.028896216303110123, 0.037364520132541656, 0.016429152339696884, 0.04164879769086838, -0.03840016946196556, -0.0069831302389502525, -0.004253860097378492, -0.05673685669898987, 0.027761321514844894, -0.028540540486574173, -0.022350646555423737, -0.02995004877448082, -0.011958273127675056, 0.01763226091861725, 0.05651114508509636, 0.004760344512760639, 0.009692779742181301, -0.030802149325609207, 0.021935800090432167, -0.0009755210485309362, -0.040260158479213715, -0.02427542768418789, -0.004496878944337368, -0.02324761264026165, -0.0004124243278056383, 0.04236553981900215, 0.043591197580099106, 0.06214508041739464, 0.005818976555019617, -0.026608597487211227, 0.03964995965361595, -0.019993407651782036, 0.0033326519187539816, 0.0025405280757695436, -0.05100894719362259, 0.03403468802571297, 0.012289132922887802, -0.005678436253219843, -0.047208521515131, -0.0008884801063686609, -0.011067324317991734, -0.00412831362336874, 0.0058726235292851925, -0.011612357571721077, -0.03454802930355072, 0.006997804623097181, 0.012660547159612179, 0.06062430515885353, -0.015401971526443958, -0.024077417328953743, -0.01880345679819584, 0.030054735019803047, -0.007910854183137417, -0.04002523049712181, 0.009097136557102203, 0.00974865909665823, -0.00987662747502327, -0.001981194596737623, 0.021378371864557266, -0.001915631233714521, 0.040756579488515854, -0.0014214080292731524, 0.021778350695967674, -0.0034085146617144346, 0.06959892064332962, -0.035351287573575974, -0.0631144791841507, 0.032936129719018936, -0.04355565086007118, -0.05159347504377365, 0.012062011286616325, -0.014501652680337429, 0.04442592337727547, 0.021429620683193207, 0.0031148670241236687, -0.05691259354352951, 0.03021504171192646, -0.021139856427907944, -0.006910883821547031, -0.00480818934738636, 0.020156746730208397, 0.02751672826707363, -0.020755527541041374, 0.0030186958611011505, -0.011523168534040451, -0.0023731293622404337, 0.015886642038822174, 0.04201531410217285, 0.00036033731885254383, -0.000541787245310843, 0.048235584050416946, -0.014665091410279274, 0.025981655344367027, 0.00403513852506876, 0.003740586107596755, 0.04909665882587433, 0.03300899267196655, -0.012534205801784992, 0.033617619425058365, -0.004501651506870985, 0.009940553456544876, -0.09991537034511566, -0.020732762292027473, -0.005714755970984697, 0.006803743075579405, 0.025024686008691788, -0.07272955030202866, 0.0019404764752835035, 0.03188171982765198, -0.039290089160203934, 0.021499119699001312, -0.010746103711426258, -0.009064210578799248, -0.03258960321545601, 0.016104359179735184, -0.010302755050361156, 0.012403029017150402, 0.020556924864649773, 0.019040867686271667, 0.032365284860134125, 0.017003394663333893, -0.005281419027596712, -0.009058740921318531, -0.029122846201062202, 0.018973829224705696, -0.013143865391612053, 0.0005924709257669747, 0.02996554598212242, -0.008716846816241741, 0.01172642968595028, 0.0163346566259861, -0.010487605817615986, 0.01194293424487114, 0.03852997347712517, 0.01993154175579548, 0.012717580422759056, 0.017482081428170204, 0.01981482096016407, -0.014784295111894608, 0.010109988041222095, -0.023035259917378426, 0.022315947338938713, 0.03358132764697075, 0.01180929783731699, 0.005249558482319117, 0.021839389577507973, -0.047392427921295166, -0.009661545976996422, 0.023876799270510674, 0.008031511679291725, -0.022511877119541168, 0.013456943444907665, 0.008052722550928593, 0.005415677558630705, -0.05415039509534836, 0.020778145641088486, -0.04959176853299141, -0.0172722265124321, 0.04655800014734268, -0.0079870680347085, -0.025308329612016678, 0.04174240306019783, -0.010109133087098598, -0.035689081996679306, 0.0014588290359824896, 0.0026369080878794193, -0.017030689865350723, -0.06976918131113052, 0.021027090027928352, 0.057767353951931, -0.01915416307747364, -0.02936815284192562, -0.016971250995993614, -0.008655230514705181, 0.011793923564255238, 0.027461746707558632, 0.007940555922687054, 0.018985606729984283, -0.046121444553136826, -0.025042861700057983, -0.08680172264575958, 0.08925483375787735, 0.017363768070936203, -0.07505086809396744, -0.03756885603070259, -0.027883613482117653, -0.018672052770853043, -0.0024530712980777025, 0.06825114786624908, -0.006738381460309029, 0.019877780228853226, -0.030602067708969116, 0.03416967764496803, 0.012403745204210281, -0.02446087636053562, 0.02991042658686638, 0.012715033255517483, -0.010660097002983093, -0.006182436365634203, -0.026261797174811363, -0.014174037612974644, -0.0006863846210762858, 0.009420357644557953, 0.00811399519443512, -0.014581810683012009, -0.011726923286914825, -0.014470287598669529, 0.03128606826066971, 0.014246394857764244, 0.0017136072274297476, 0.03975827246904373, -0.0014515306102111936, 0.024777458980679512, 0.03341696411371231, 0.007536565884947777, -0.06224171444773674, 0.0032501311507076025, -0.051580771803855896, -0.026119856163859367, 0.023391693830490112, 0.010981728322803974, 0.02719402126967907, -0.05925583094358444, -0.015497377142310143, 0.03942938894033432, -0.05061076581478119, 0.003193540032953024, 0.04368367791175842, 0.019447509199380875, 0.0713806003332138, 0.022227898240089417, -0.016431046649813652, 0.03265443444252014, -0.016298191621899605, -0.03143671527504921, 0.04461574926972389, 0.004420748911798, 0.012134549207985401, 0.009064890444278717, 0.036272961646318436, -0.01969505473971367, 0.04246349632740021, 0.0029585962183773518, 0.03272439166903496, -0.06483107805252075, -0.021224847063422203, -0.02320539392530918, -0.057558126747608185, -0.016405800357460976, 0.0014741149498149753, -0.01523402240127325, 0.10408847033977509, -0.024159610271453857, -0.0034739328548312187, -0.01697259023785591, -0.0015185159863904119, -0.025455163791775703, 0.034887805581092834, -0.0033267566468566656, 0.01510201022028923, -0.003524484345689416, 0.0276048444211483, -0.0032302679028362036, -0.011814093217253685, 0.0344412699341774, 0.004208927974104881, 0.029101813212037086, -0.006399022415280342, -0.008102333173155785, -0.011127457953989506, -0.025652656331658363, -0.006163114681839943, -0.030701523646712303, 0.0054637412540614605, 0.03569023311138153, 0.02708841674029827, 0.012725808657705784, -0.0011885198764503002, -0.04215163365006447, 0.03854283690452576, -0.10161321610212326, -0.006553660146892071, -0.0455918125808239, 0.02573014609515667, -0.011329952627420425, -0.014581513591110706 ]
<p>I have run an online poll on two candidates. Participants are shown both candidates and are asked to determine which one they like better. Here are the labels on my Likert scale:</p> <ul> <li>Strongly for Romney</li> <li>Leaning towards Romney</li> <li>Neutral</li> <li>Leaning towards Obama</li> <li>Strongly for Obama</li> </ul> <p>I want run hypothesis testing on the results and see which candidate is more desirable. What is the proper way of designing the analysis? So far I have been just comparing the ones that are strongly for either candidate and reported the count value as the winner. But I want to be more systematic and do more rigorous hypothesis testing. The distribution of votes is like a binomial distribution. </p>
74,395
[ -0.02553574927151203, -0.023482050746679306, -0.016162054613232613, 0.010954270139336586, 0.02399032562971115, 0.0025698509998619556, 0.04178818687796593, -0.024150926619768143, 0.02950349822640419, 0.01091807708144188, 0.04572606459259987, 0.017716217786073685, 0.04382811486721039, 0.03161975368857384, -0.0041748820804059505, 0.0165104903280735, 0.006470667663961649, -0.004173967521637678, -0.02176326885819435, 0.011371961794793606, -0.02718237228691578, -0.01923730969429016, 0.0231908168643713, 0.00006946834764676169, -0.004451894201338291, 0.02314479649066925, 0.025114616379141808, -0.005427338182926178, 0.016215113922953606, 0.0492287203669548, -0.04563341662287712, -0.05356631428003311, 0.0005685463547706604, 0.019726259633898735, 0.02515927143394947, -0.002072869101539254, -0.004817974288016558, -0.001921839895658195, -0.011923992075026035, 0.01907278597354889, -0.036770857870578766, -0.010210230946540833, 0.02137787640094757, 0.018683498725295067, 0.000319059647154063, -0.008210108615458012, -0.03310754522681236, -0.04100358858704567, 0.016833627596497536, -0.040480054914951324, 0.05308109149336815, 0.00620188657194376, 0.022697046399116516, 0.06085292994976044, 0.008644863963127136, -0.016245689243078232, 0.055950481444597244, 0.08265648782253265, 0.007830897346138954, -0.047707635909318924, -0.02149955928325653, -0.05108166113495827, -0.03541423752903938, -0.005859885364770889, -0.046402618288993835, 0.025506630539894104, -0.021000102162361145, -0.004222529008984566, 0.048890210688114166, -0.0024853087961673737, -0.007271495182067156, 0.023877590894699097, 0.033075083047151566, -0.03465236350893974, 0.015466776676476002, -0.020333120599389076, 0.03032415173947811, 0.03083335980772972, 0.05189487710595131, 0.02039312571287155, 0.0348157063126564, 0.0370752178132534, 0.016870371997356415, 0.05808592215180397, 0.01536103617399931, -0.026684924960136414, 0.022784143686294556, -0.036282990127801895, -0.01698363572359085, 0.04741209000349045, -0.008763433434069157, -0.007334533147513866, 0.014568458311259747, 0.021373998373746872, -0.030902178958058357, 0.0071147228591144085, -0.03910224512219429, 0.0444415807723999, 0.024033471941947937, -0.020576056092977524, -0.004910449963063002, -0.005841097794473171, 0.014444573782384396, 0.05136536434292793, 0.003611984895542264, -0.01703515462577343, -0.008872772566974163, -0.009353077970445156, -0.014535673893988132, 0.00035838503390550613, 0.0074005224741995335, 0.05134950578212738, 0.012880363501608372, 0.02681548520922661, 0.03144749253988266, -0.013721472583711147, -0.021222449839115143, -0.031708359718322754, 0.06246373429894447, 0.04656187817454338, 0.026053378358483315, 0.0014495522482320666, 0.0561857707798481, -0.029678914695978165, -0.006362462881952524, 0.008563073351979256, 0.01665685325860977, 0.02946777641773224, -0.01950650103390217, 0.05494455248117447, -0.01520634163171053, 0.010322470217943192, 0.02486967109143734, -0.019682174548506737, 0.02848651446402073, 0.025893807411193848, -0.08059998601675034, -0.03674979507923126, 0.015084188431501389, -0.003615867579355836, -0.0035572974011301994, -0.06845156103372574, -0.018373481929302216, 0.017847783863544464, 0.015383366495370865, 0.01633375510573387, 0.049105770885944366, 0.004382571671158075, 0.021652687340974808, 0.008996577002108097, -0.04139300063252449, -0.02380366250872612, -0.058697838336229324, -0.017497442662715912, -0.049608904868364334, -0.05050889775156975, 0.002057560021057725, -0.0015193705912679434, -0.006724629085510969, -0.008536971174180508, 0.02932022139430046, 0.011037122458219528, -0.0275161974132061, -0.00980247650295496, 0.025573354214429855, 0.012531796470284462, 0.04636911675333977, 0.02996112033724785, 0.017962437123060226, 0.021300822496414185, -0.007985026575624943, 0.03660592809319496, 0.030166147276759148, 0.010249301791191101, 0.0425715409219265, -0.018395110964775085, 0.011097699403762817, -0.04490266740322113, 0.013752644881606102, -0.0016438823658972979, -0.017317717894911766, -0.016212839633226395, -0.051413942128419876, -0.005139355082064867, 0.013619378209114075, 0.0542435497045517, 0.028516901656985283, -0.012249509803950787, 0.04532846435904503, -0.08183427155017853, -0.07059364020824432, -0.08543271571397781, -0.02407076023519039, 0.016754982993006706, -0.03838697820901871, 0.04804996773600578, 0.001461712527088821, 0.01758621446788311, -0.010130089707672596, 0.028713177889585495, -0.02349730022251606, 0.003014238551259041, 0.05237674340605736, -0.041422899812459946, 0.0019638969097286463, 0.0720008835196495, 0.02006538026034832, -0.013416371308267117, 0.03432995453476906, -0.043254315853118896, -0.06425256282091141, -0.0027777592185884714, -0.03844207525253296, -0.039845630526542664, 0.04360727220773697, -0.011837188154459, -0.011800936423242092, 0.01750505343079567, 0.006253070197999477, 0.013911309652030468, -0.03753026947379112, 0.09345227479934692, 0.03459906578063965, -0.017770281061530113, 0.0248943492770195, 0.01137208566069603, 0.014756555669009686, 0.0015468881465494633, -0.02328021079301834, -0.014647678472101688, -0.08575249463319778, 0.038321785628795624, 0.05528108403086662, 0.03212999925017357, -0.028690388426184654, 0.023679953068494797, 0.0503777340054512, 0.02815585769712925, -0.020267829298973083, 0.022752482444047928, -0.043615564703941345, -0.006168003659695387, 0.026929285377264023, 0.03806143254041672, 0.020552918314933777, 0.01958794705569744, 0.01877850480377674, 0.023635555058717728, 0.012727716006338596, 0.0272869523614645, -0.0006177584291435778, 0.04573789983987808, 0.008587746880948544, 0.010505220852792263, 0.004377228207886219, -0.017299596220254898, 0.025376033037900925, -0.01445672195404768, -0.031214050948619843, 0.04427548125386238, -0.005749402102082968, -0.013258661143481731, 0.010525275021791458, 0.00006053705874364823, 0.02661266177892685, 0.04704473912715912, -0.015180098824203014, 0.0004083857929799706, 0.025856539607048035, -0.021726710721850395, 0.040820442140102386, -0.028782878071069717, -0.023917976766824722, -0.02188478223979473, 0.007657796610146761, 0.02378026582300663, 0.0026559580583125353, 0.0065123592503368855, -0.004633856471627951, -0.024422410875558853, 0.017654594033956528, -0.028795797377824783, -0.0007191416225396097, 0.009622909128665924, -0.05634812265634537, -0.013501989655196667, -0.055967412889003754, -0.01061692088842392, 0.03046397492289543, -0.0011027524014934897, -0.01670052483677864, 0.0090898172929883, 0.005157234147191048, -0.04872780665755272, -0.033117085695266724, 0.0020845369435846806, -0.007232519332319498, -0.00440453365445137, -0.04107087105512619, 0.05625220388174057, 0.011626383289694786, -0.021098902449011803, 0.04316737875342369, -0.038073256611824036, -0.02349192090332508, -0.01668609119951725, 0.014390910975635052, 0.0005846869898959994, 0.04451395943760872, 0.04069472849369049, 0.036685761064291, -0.04664907604455948, -0.019621746614575386, -0.0966503843665123, -0.03542310371994972, 0.02914358116686344, -0.018278297036886215, 0.04476479813456535, -0.014193822629749775, -0.011264742352068424, 0.07223393768072128, 0.048273444175720215, -0.010801947675645351, -0.04070569574832916, 0.013891158625483513, -0.044267438352108, -0.006898214109241962, 0.029033981263637543, 0.017134450376033783, -0.02681730128824711, 0.013378609903156757, 0.032509759068489075, 0.01880882866680622, 0.016310783103108406, 0.00433101411908865, -0.03507440537214279, 0.017894115298986435, 0.04669812321662903, 0.004194906912744045, 0.026152443140745163, 0.040388986468315125, -0.036914512515068054, 0.02292647957801819, -0.02741478569805622, 0.0036363662220537663, -0.004965637344866991, -0.04929013550281525, 0.021067924797534943, -0.004366131499409676, -0.028201749548316002, -0.03035786934196949, 0.035178788006305695, 0.01417960599064827, -0.024020615965127945, -0.009963233955204487, -0.030039681121706963, 0.017937466502189636, -0.040100254118442535, 0.006080152001231909, 0.059396468102931976, 0.06188272312283516, -0.028160694986581802, -0.05188470706343651, -0.009364472702145576, -0.0014317033346742392, 0.004380418453365564, -0.021235914900898933, -0.001825326238758862, 0.03730885311961174, 0.04484941065311432, 0.043218258768320084, 0.011580473743379116, -0.01518702320754528, 0.004136316012591124, -0.07053805142641068, 0.004122243262827396, -0.020643193274736404, 0.0502634234726429, -0.00849705096334219, 0.0657292976975441, 0.03282034397125244, 0.004353190306574106, -0.02244880422949791, 0.009037565439939499, -0.043259523808956146, 0.06656137108802795, -0.005618467926979065, -0.009126725606620312, 0.022634796798229218, -0.0045042335987091064, 0.02726835571229458, -0.027304163202643394, 0.015454426407814026, -0.01875651814043522, 0.043111301958560944, -0.011379501782357693, 0.0003642308583948761, -0.02374151721596718, -0.03152244910597801, 0.02113906666636467, 0.007341108750551939, 0.00547836534678936, -0.040462128818035126, 0.037004828453063965, 0.020673824474215508, 0.004886395763605833, -0.014546623453497887, -0.022138206288218498, 0.005716967862099409, 0.0022546055261045694, 0.060698896646499634, 0.014115191996097565, 0.010619478300213814, -0.0006730101304128766, 0.047740787267684937, 0.024878310039639473, 0.07100825756788254, 0.041778165847063065, -0.007257387973368168, -0.026141710579395294, -0.044066186994314194, -0.02849217690527439, -0.006061755120754242, 0.017356663942337036, -0.008628460578620434, -0.02588895708322525, 0.062463272362947464, 0.04999819025397301, -0.03281926363706589, 0.019582631066441536, 0.05062323436141014, 0.012281023897230625, -0.00821289699524641, -0.06376965343952179, 0.0018564325291663408, -0.0013549156719818711, -0.005231986287981272, 0.04449734836816788, 0.023514075204730034, 0.006499831099063158, -0.012652790173888206, 0.0886581614613533, -0.0070692403241992, -0.0636332780122757, 0.03720704838633537, -0.02185492031276226, 0.026884905993938446, -0.013771197758615017, -0.03267024829983711, 0.025937862694263458, 0.0655854344367981, 0.02980772964656353, 0.03710751235485077, -0.0041899592615664005, -0.09799639135599136, 0.031199922785162926, 0.05930105224251747, 0.024155231192708015, -0.06375723332166672, -0.024351634085178375, -0.015194471925497055, 0.013179454952478409, 0.04499301686882973, -0.049503155052661896, 0.04010846093297005, -0.025701750069856644, 0.038818079978227615, -0.034695640206336975, 0.024724366143345833, -0.06999184191226959, 0.0019888668321073055, -0.01843349263072014, 0.049720603972673416, -0.025400837883353233, -0.04714134708046913, -0.0838717669248581, -0.010007651522755623, 0.01595960184931755, 0.07615510374307632, -0.01155615784227848, -0.03228595107793808, 0.03695555031299591, -0.03349095210433006, -0.014726590365171432, -0.05173073709011078, 0.0027663412038236856, -0.0018737606005743146, 0.004908049013465643, 0.0453689768910408, 0.014675432816147804, -0.019295362755656242, -0.021077224984765053, -0.02730366215109825, -0.022617215290665627, 0.024588370695710182, -0.01837027072906494, 0.0420835055410862, -0.0021152179688215256, 0.01785089820623398, 0.03470321744680405, 0.02481948584318161, -0.002772444160655141, 0.018300963565707207, -0.034329697489738464, 0.016468601301312447, 0.004947911016643047, 0.02664853259921074, -0.05129479989409447, -0.038739413022994995, -0.023354530334472656, -0.013160956092178822, 0.03190527483820915, 0.03371167182922363, -0.03694150224328041, -0.04891137406229973, -0.0075663672760128975, 0.009370077401399612, 0.008048719726502895, -0.0010049851844087243, 0.006819330621510744, 0.007876958698034286, -0.000815834675449878, -0.03178950399160385, 0.021260948851704597, -0.033881209790706635, 0.004943891428411007, -0.017635248601436615, -0.035041049122810364, 0.025318242609500885, -0.0538136288523674, -0.05282088741660118, 0.006723529659211636, -0.013579477556049824, 0.06012839823961258, 0.011518732644617558, 0.04207722842693329, 0.012493672780692577, -0.04930296912789345, -0.019058139994740486, 0.04078129306435585, 0.009277052246034145, 0.02448907308280468, -0.013679370284080505, 0.00939980335533619, -0.007696185726672411, -0.01501868199557066, -0.0650583878159523, -0.00008238944428740069, 0.018562350422143936, 0.003113444661721587, -0.016995063051581383, -0.008648482151329517, 0.02297077514231205, -0.003058335278183222, -0.02134851925075054, -0.050853922963142395, 0.031404707580804825, -0.009936416521668434, -0.025319794192910194, -0.010452618822455406, 0.005942989606410265, 0.0876719057559967, 0.001328849233686924, -0.022970203310251236, -0.008716516196727753, -0.012138050980865955, -0.022304974496364594, 0.014034334570169449, -0.016385212540626526, -0.033972352743148804, -0.027047809213399887, -0.044328417629003525, 0.04152723774313927, 0.014473277144134045, 0.0035199939738959074, 0.008312728255987167, -0.005292195826768875, -0.0005932446219958365, -0.014601754024624825, -0.045640140771865845, -0.0011084272991865873, -0.020220445469021797, 0.0047389972023665905, -0.006352597381919622, -0.0005015599308535457, -0.00833364762365818, -0.008444176986813545, -0.01088571734726429, 0.017985213547945023, -0.027958152815699577, 0.023366080597043037, 0.04871845245361328, 0.0028796137776225805, 0.0005747408140450716, 0.024124078452587128, -0.02307278662919998, 0.02749517373740673, 0.011582198552787304, -0.023061852902173996, 0.030292144045233727, 0.023976203054189682, -0.02424751967191696, -0.005652389023452997, -0.013829200528562069, -0.050497692078351974, 0.03224722668528557, 0.02707815356552601, 0.08411498367786407, 0.055200036615133286, -0.026243330910801888, 0.009133676066994667, -0.020886028185486794, -0.01612388901412487, -0.045003414154052734, 0.05442087724804878, 0.04102756455540657, 0.0011347903637215495, 0.03900821506977081, 0.03023398667573929, 0.006585963536053896, 0.046395402401685715, 0.027360009029507637, 0.041796036064624786, 0.02961415983736515, 0.046723637729883194, -0.04918616637587547, -0.045250896364450455, -0.004403380677103996, -0.08215268701314926, 0.039622288197278976, -0.055304691195487976, -0.042477454990148544, 0.010285395197570324, 0.013011264614760876, -0.0469047985970974, -0.045646581798791885, -0.031781986355781555, -0.04259638488292694, 0.01856202818453312, 0.043371330946683884, 0.004411162342876196, 0.023651646450161934, 0.016633199527859688, 0.03644218295812607, 0.019502045586705208, 0.013464892283082008, -0.008806859143078327, -0.06755029410123825, -0.03540903702378273, 0.007948143407702446, -0.04302028566598892, 0.023469440639019012, -0.006867486983537674, -0.015099689364433289, 0.03667433559894562, -0.002514216350391507, 0.0034161992371082306, 0.032969988882541656, 0.0031967402901500463, -0.011818130500614643, 0.07050454616546631, -0.028276899829506874, -0.01391238160431385, 0.04218505695462227, 0.0017375710885971785, 0.11264238506555557, 0.09144925326108932, 0.06048526614904404, -0.0639558956027031, 0.04571342095732689, 0.022510455921292305, 0.015237568877637386, -0.020108016207814217, 0.02614506706595421, 0.0035901712253689766, 0.01177386473864317, 0.041714198887348175, 0.00328810210339725, 0.0019363691098988056, 0.0048244115896523, 0.09586568176746368, -0.00006464761827373877, -0.02561763860285282, 0.018529215827584267, 0.0028897509910166264, -0.027322961017489433, -0.036895137280225754, -0.05401204898953438, 0.004798919893801212, -0.016797173768281937, 0.0015137979062274098, 0.018775591626763344, -0.04849889874458313, 0.0013670566258952022, -0.001911667175590992, 0.010793373920023441, -0.002792590530589223, 0.029162565246224403, 0.011762070469558239, -0.01285532210022211, -0.043502599000930786, 0.0063796634785830975, -0.04254414513707161, 0.024311214685440063, 0.004158580210059881, 0.00014135372475720942, -0.031116558238863945, 0.016057642176747322, 0.034495092928409576, -0.06624853610992432, 0.0062494417652487755, -0.031973350793123245, 0.002225134987384081, 0.014141972176730633, -0.013545661233365536, -0.015610028989613056, 0.01937553845345974, -0.007106803357601166, -0.03220279887318611, -0.014913316816091537, 0.01139303483068943, 0.01626979187130928, -0.04175854101777077, -0.039324745535850525, -0.04075468331575394, -0.0012705078115686774, -0.006805423181504011, 0.01500261016190052, 0.03367069736123085, 0.023387501016259193, -0.05147787928581238, -0.02617010474205017, 0.02964947000145912, 0.013745365664362907, -0.012564331293106079, 0.010211778804659843, -0.027857519686222076, -0.061174411326646805, 0.03332258015871048, -0.00787400547415018, -0.008945570327341557, 0.022771349176764488, 0.01178059447556734, 0.0023283876944333315, -0.007772656623274088, -0.014339277520775795, -0.0055703711695969105, -0.021741535514593124, 0.004775435198098421, -0.030997753143310547, -0.0022978391498327255, 0.00954710878431797, 0.026711730286478996, 0.006688683293759823, 0.010965941473841667, 0.00889683049172163, 0.002327951369807124, 0.012436593882739544, -0.05219445750117302, -0.02823270857334137, -0.012477735057473183, -0.07335745543241501, -0.05189443379640579, -0.013065612874925137, 0.04193109646439552, 0.0034366948530077934, -0.001887223101221025, 0.01905256137251854, 0.0013913175789639354, -0.02129245363175869, 0.02276730164885521, 0.023485327139496803, -0.05397907644510269, -0.06280923634767532, -0.020764123648405075, -0.01802908629179001, -0.023779135197401047, -0.034816499799489975, -0.042361561208963394, -0.01264887023717165, 0.047585733234882355, -0.017152680084109306, -0.0043903617188334465, -0.01393971685320139, 0.00730465492233634, 0.02979918196797371, -0.028119847178459167, -0.02581319957971573, -0.040922440588474274, -0.05027950555086136, -0.001554887625388801, 0.016940703615546227, 0.008750426582992077, 0.07187628746032715, -0.0002209534723078832, -0.007189808413386345, 0.033019743859767914, 0.009247945621609688, -0.007261256687343121, -0.006420572753995657, 0.03252305090427399, -0.009464887902140617, 0.04454174265265465, -0.008529272861778736, -0.022929122671484947, 0.04616793245077133, -0.06818980723619461, 0.006084584631025791, 0.0014968325849622488, 0.008709995076060295, 0.021148020401597023, -0.01976051554083824, -0.044947583228349686, 0.04794525355100632, 0.010140230879187584, -0.026881471276283264, -0.06046203896403313, -0.029986385256052017, 0.006628701463341713, 0.03640080988407135, -0.005246770102530718, 0.015257976949214935, -0.010806494392454624, 0.00039740122156217694, 0.04839567095041275, 0.02246701344847679, -0.0143040856346488, 0.007088469807058573, -0.036279238760471344, -0.0011714792344719172, 0.006582930218428373, -0.004698546137660742, -0.005197096150368452, 0.011913365684449673, 0.07445754110813141, -0.031025603413581848, 0.011190779507160187, -0.02830589935183525, 0.016363222151994705, -0.03280147910118103, -0.03926007077097893, 0.0050055598840117455, -0.015901006758213043, 0.043133433908224106, -0.054030973464250565, 0.018136300146579742, 0.02799978293478489, -0.00846500601619482, -0.013369172811508179, 0.006086898036301136, -0.025690613314509392, -0.05961817502975464, -0.005145143251866102, 0.0019544027745723724, 0.038797538727521896, 0.005611930042505264, 0.056175991892814636, 0.041542887687683105, 0.019077109172940254, 0.014358670450747013, 0.00666907150298357, -0.025222983211278915, -0.004803669173270464, 0.02858475036919117, -0.07474187016487122, -0.0003912458196282387, -0.015553811565041542, -0.05580931156873703, 0.029360521584749222, -0.017644112929701805, 0.028715958818793297, 0.02578500658273697, 0.0191987045109272, -0.02105364203453064, 0.028383230790495872, -0.0010477167088538408, -0.041492756456136703, -0.0033699648920446634, 0.0029802974313497543, 0.014496929943561554, 0.08150374889373779, -0.006061559543013573, 0.0012318042572587729, 0.05164502561092377, -0.027578556910157204, 0.020207000896334648, 0.003686031326651573, -0.011932272464036942, -0.022748813033103943, 0.011662020348012447, -0.032262250781059265, 0.03990821912884712, -0.029391858726739883, 0.025402052327990532, -0.030886981636285782, 0.012746764346957207, 0.02315058559179306, -0.004621563944965601, -0.0033005657605826855, 0.0016289851628243923, -0.02839166671037674, -0.020919468253850937, 0.002556953812018037, -0.0134769007563591, 0.007087650243192911, -0.03356077894568443, -0.007160175126045942, -0.04461165890097618, 0.01770801655948162, -0.020792238414287567, -0.014037222601473331, 0.000783255323767662, 0.027816521003842354, -0.0750313475728035, -0.0015354626812040806, 0.019427474588155746, -0.019888844341039658, 0.02937866561114788, -0.06560026109218597, 0.026751864701509476, 0.019736824557185173, -0.004098666366189718, -0.021884966641664505, 0.0018387193558737636, -0.05864737927913666, 0.0107780946418643, 0.031366050243377686, 0.026258481666445732, -0.016873961314558983, -0.017120489850640297, -0.013006646186113358, -0.0007126822019927204, -0.0771506205201149, -0.00001735776459099725, -0.010291382670402527, -0.017065782099962234, 0.0027441252022981644, -0.01142860297113657, 0.03849663957953453, 0.010591711848974228, 0.012985462322831154, 0.018823087215423584, -0.02570251002907753, 0.01547688152641058, -0.031152600422501564, 0.033773273229599, -0.02961028926074505, 0.008996276184916496, 0.04389650747179985, -0.016114236786961555, 0.008634410798549652, 0.021243618801236153, -0.009882323443889618, -0.036667533218860626, 0.058728959411382675, -0.03145056962966919, -0.030987834557890892, 0.011949161067605019, 0.006554698571562767, -0.014805841259658337, -0.05125925689935684, -0.03716571256518364, 0.020761581137776375, -0.025644931942224503, 0.028867075219750404, 0.012848650105297565, 0.021401111036539078, 0.050492431968450546, -0.032684892416000366, 0.02489812672138214, -0.02936100773513317, -0.00904641579836607, -0.0022407842334359884, 0.021225644275546074, 0.025205843150615692, 0.030353520065546036, 0.037853483110666275, 0.006884036585688591, -0.023267202079296112, 0.03772260993719101, 0.021195122972130775, 0.052171170711517334, 0.0028233688790351152, -0.009397178888320923, 0.026076829060912132, 0.004561855923384428, 0.0032351710833609104, 0.0006281256792135537, 0.0042655328288674355, 0.05067235976457596, -0.0022084377706050873, -0.00889011099934578, -0.047445546835660934, -0.018189724534749985, -0.03397410735487938, 0.03706229478120804, 0.0342763252556324, -0.006815087515860796, 0.01587788760662079, 0.014852848835289478, 0.013271178118884563, 0.022433705627918243, 0.017651882022619247, 0.0036412719637155533, 0.02212468907237053, -0.02220417745411396, -0.029450703412294388, -0.011567971669137478, -0.020213216543197632, -0.019641989842057228, -0.012644118629395962, 0.02355552278459072, 0.012930137105286121, 0.02423892170190811, -0.01161099411547184, -0.029488004744052887, -0.02317081019282341, 0.024201663210988045, -0.027862822636961937, -0.06517788022756577, -0.07739519327878952, 0.02095872163772583, 0.021953793242573738, -0.0304720439016819 ]
<p>I have a dependent variable that includes four categories. I also have four continuous independent variables. The 3rd category covers the largest group in the sample. Is it important to choose the category covering largest group as a reference factor or can I choose another one that would make sense for comparisons?</p> <p>Many thanks for response</p>
37,264
[ -0.03417214751243591, 0.02172279730439186, -0.002674892544746399, 0.019557809457182884, 0.03871292248368263, 0.0063546267338097095, -0.004886898677796125, -0.005249722395092249, 0.02156936563551426, -0.03951723873615265, 0.0258009135723114, 0.021951155737042427, 0.0808582454919815, -0.009842158295214176, -0.01943066343665123, 0.00780008640140295, -0.02489844150841236, 0.017657620832324028, 0.019207818433642387, 0.01134274248033762, -0.02731185406446457, 0.028999103233218193, 0.008021000772714615, 0.0036292022559791803, -0.03708420321345329, 0.05232641473412514, 0.016221949830651283, 0.0034364217426627874, 0.0263726357370615, 0.010354683734476566, -0.02599780447781086, -0.034614600241184235, -0.017610665410757065, 0.03079562447965145, -0.0027637595776468515, 0.004469116684049368, -0.025767698884010315, 0.006911532953381538, -0.03517768532037735, 0.021573012694716454, -0.08574598282575607, 0.014020790345966816, 0.006564137525856495, 0.01514414232224226, -0.017308855429291725, 0.03374608978629112, -0.011829085648059845, -0.009186811745166779, 0.039058879017829895, -0.021390670910477638, 0.09523674845695496, -0.018657444044947624, 0.011709222570061684, 0.02422167919576168, 0.0016722498694434762, -0.019965697079896927, 0.04567932337522507, 0.06336576491594315, -0.009586851112544537, -0.01111813634634018, -0.03016778640449047, -0.01491603534668684, -0.005219367332756519, -0.03344373032450676, -0.004759468138217926, 0.04139013588428497, -0.015491984784603119, -0.01404557004570961, 0.020565953105688095, 0.0060765063390135765, 0.014860310591757298, -0.0014176840195432305, 0.056738123297691345, 0.00376721890643239, 0.01763731800019741, -0.009800435975193977, 0.03765435889363289, 0.026160800829529762, 0.019398098811507225, 0.05007561668753624, -0.012907923199236393, 0.010469882749021053, -0.00770107377320528, 0.05215512961149216, 0.035606399178504944, -0.001361596747301519, 0.04597824439406395, -0.028607521206140518, 0.014702362939715385, 0.03957351669669151, -0.03220248594880104, -0.010698708705604076, 0.045817892998456955, 0.020481906831264496, -0.01138064730912447, 0.020670665428042412, -0.03864810988306999, 0.024535072967410088, 0.001510862959548831, 0.06659682095050812, -0.02130240760743618, -0.03128989785909653, 0.031063782051205635, 0.029961014166474342, -0.02069459669291973, 0.016595572233200073, -0.059165097773075104, 0.006597073748707771, -0.007374986074864864, -0.024446306750178337, -0.023458490148186684, -0.026466038078069687, 0.005720621440559626, -0.00812553334981203, 0.044913314282894135, -0.0072550647892057896, 0.013419894501566887, 0.007174965925514698, 0.027367832139134407, 0.04537274315953255, 0.0698467344045639, -0.05651717260479927, 0.009896966628730297, -0.005138088949024677, -0.03456119820475578, 0.04208994656801224, 0.02091861143708229, 0.014138810336589813, -0.02933545783162117, 0.05399717390537262, 0.011114002205431461, 0.027167614549398422, 0.019536687061190605, 0.0029849219135940075, 0.0076479315757751465, -0.009990229271352291, -0.11673977971076965, -0.03130222111940384, 0.046807583421468735, -0.04813531041145325, 0.007841015234589577, -0.07863504439592361, 0.02158352918922901, 0.016557374969124794, 0.03733702376484871, -0.007024369202554226, 0.03079189546406269, -0.007101184688508511, 0.011936185881495476, 0.012995005585253239, -0.02046382613480091, -0.011221039108932018, -0.03543609380722046, -0.04514271020889282, -0.02460702508687973, -0.07148192822933197, 0.007360383868217468, -0.002771110273897648, 0.030661627650260925, 0.0033572381362318993, 0.03262496367096901, -0.01566227711737156, -0.009563828818500042, 0.01800830103456974, 0.021956954151391983, 0.02079538255929947, 0.049816928803920746, -0.03886839747428894, 0.04176241531968117, -0.037708841264247894, 0.015461280941963196, 0.039540182799100876, 0.042316701263189316, 0.052333567291498184, 0.0410536527633667, 0.0014615197433158755, -0.013031110167503357, -0.035489004105329514, 0.004107234999537468, -0.019528208300471306, -0.03126588463783264, -0.04365735501050949, -0.02154410257935524, -0.029608944430947304, 0.012533188797533512, 0.027316829189658165, 0.005172147415578365, -0.03935423493385315, 0.025722838938236237, -0.04237616807222366, -0.05691448226571083, -0.05532534793019295, 0.0050517963245511055, -0.013744653202593327, -0.05205581709742546, 0.04730168357491493, 0.04266274720430374, 0.031349264085292816, -0.029246779158711433, 0.004870939534157515, -0.02825121395289898, -0.03581378608942032, -0.022095372900366783, -0.024347946047782898, 0.0356207974255085, 0.018996933475136757, 0.05131381005048752, -0.032619964331388474, 0.018074795603752136, -0.01179601065814495, -0.04401177912950516, 0.03574467822909355, -0.011897453106939793, 0.045361727476119995, 0.003987145610153675, -0.015804652124643326, -0.012755144387483597, 0.03781510889530182, -0.049827124923467636, 0.06926006078720093, -0.06000633165240288, 0.10733301937580109, 0.012830980122089386, -0.021751530468463898, 0.007868760265409946, 0.017795760184526443, 0.005499773193150759, 0.014840109273791313, 0.007872581481933594, -0.0033054633531719446, -0.06832028180360794, -0.00043623941019177437, 0.03898927941918373, 0.010469124652445316, -0.046623580157756805, 0.013877403922379017, 0.017383692786097527, 0.014093111269176006, 0.05795850604772568, 0.027181686833500862, 0.019723480567336082, -0.019605781883001328, 0.026044094935059547, 0.0423051156103611, 0.02194296382367611, 0.00046723621198907495, 0.029213329777121544, -0.003621151903644204, 0.054571256041526794, -0.014791860245168209, -0.009889135137200356, 0.04041595384478569, -0.015236051753163338, 0.034859854727983475, 0.027465414255857468, -0.035582784563302994, 0.023112168535590172, -0.047014448791742325, 0.025734279304742813, 0.05867644026875496, 0.019384656101465225, -0.022434448823332787, 0.034340646117925644, -0.05248839408159256, 0.0074279895052313805, 0.039351485669612885, -0.07750405371189117, 0.03031161241233349, 0.021113554015755653, -0.03932077810168266, 0.00751192681491375, -0.006241191644221544, -0.05018909275531769, -0.041354961693286896, -0.0026806797832250595, 0.0035236941184848547, -0.011892184615135193, 0.026014328002929688, 0.02186633087694645, 0.001348125166259706, -0.023566078394651413, -0.00768104987218976, 0.006686884444206953, 0.00249874172732234, -0.025594357401132584, -0.03222690522670746, -0.019280284643173218, -0.010032737627625465, 0.022262239828705788, -0.018945686519145966, -0.035415079444646835, 0.017391592264175415, 0.008020707406103611, -0.05563142150640488, -0.0017261113971471786, -0.013697230257093906, 0.038275714963674545, -0.02019565738737583, -0.025471745058894157, 0.005959158763289452, 0.02161131612956524, -0.02374362014234066, -0.012607146985828876, -0.06633548438549042, -0.014280743896961212, 0.005697296466678381, 0.008029402233660221, -0.003640958108007908, 0.02493874542415142, -0.02297179214656353, 0.0174871776252985, -0.00765171367675066, -0.018090108409523964, -0.030851751565933228, -0.0800844207406044, 0.04653878137469292, 0.015428601764142513, 0.04041847214102745, -0.0025678558740764856, -0.017327293753623962, 0.07691008597612381, 0.0655011385679245, -0.03975691646337509, -0.029820458963513374, -0.0628410130739212, -0.04270703345537186, -0.028068654239177704, 0.05069681257009506, 0.02769046276807785, 0.013105262070894241, -0.008068809285759926, 0.04131621494889259, 0.024359870702028275, 0.021713001653552055, -0.01775486022233963, 0.02579455077648163, 0.010208501480519772, 0.01945433020591736, -0.03306453302502632, 0.045726142823696136, 0.03827850893139839, -0.026333792135119438, -0.013525394722819328, -0.006646974012255669, 0.05022779107093811, -0.00490554329007864, -0.012390141375362873, 0.033914171159267426, -0.0006315389182418585, 0.004594604950398207, -0.018414756283164024, 0.036762651056051254, 0.05074305087327957, -0.002870956202968955, 0.029233010485768318, 0.015615473501384258, 0.0077444566413760185, -0.021538790315389633, 0.0051213037222623825, 0.0736401379108429, 0.035831764340400696, -0.04892296344041824, 0.02008291706442833, -0.03187192231416702, -0.03274218738079071, 0.06246902421116829, -0.0024385505821555853, -0.03430692106485367, 0.018660366535186768, 0.024736741557717323, 0.04955082759261131, -0.01606745459139347, -0.054654400795698166, 0.024239441379904747, -0.08555044233798981, 0.014548939652740955, -0.007126690354198217, 0.03596913442015648, 0.002190768253058195, 0.05947491154074669, -0.009282371029257774, 0.01089585479348898, -0.019481979310512543, 0.012752801179885864, -0.057826753705739975, 0.024679865688085556, -0.02984757162630558, 0.034449540078639984, 0.03910614922642708, -0.025192834436893463, 0.056114260107278824, -0.0015037625562399626, 0.01472560130059719, 0.011017989367246628, 0.007550406735390425, -0.007223745342344046, -0.012693995609879494, -0.013950373977422714, 0.0006037387065589428, 0.023314619436860085, -0.005857884883880615, 0.015412452630698681, -0.00849375780671835, 0.06248728558421135, 0.04291662573814392, -0.030295271426439285, 0.008453382179141045, -0.02531304396688938, -0.00841889064759016, 0.01415240578353405, 0.06075950711965561, -0.020807284861803055, 0.012075071223080158, -0.007528412155807018, 0.023057812824845314, 0.018917981535196304, 0.007231398951262236, 0.01194531936198473, -0.028165124356746674, -0.026983799412846565, -0.07611555606126785, -0.027581851929426193, -0.03605799749493599, 0.02929447777569294, 0.007685527205467224, -0.04117407277226448, 0.0604860782623291, 0.012339523062109947, -0.03585556894540787, 0.008365778252482414, 0.042403411120176315, 0.035911545157432556, -0.028275292366743088, -0.017071666195988655, -0.009552703239023685, -0.031311847269535065, -0.002355672884732485, 0.03478188067674637, 0.017550047487020493, -0.037971142679452896, -0.0008629676885902882, 0.019894665107131004, -0.005728446878492832, -0.029712112620472908, 0.01760924980044365, 0.02763666957616806, 0.01852346397936344, 0.000006681116246909369, -0.053756266832351685, 0.006974503397941589, 0.04174839332699776, 0.02561309188604355, 0.017956307157874107, -0.036395374685525894, -0.07968646287918091, 0.0243096724152565, 0.04739456623792648, 0.048860374838113785, -0.050684090703725815, 0.0017331410199403763, -0.020181013271212578, -0.016044678166508675, 0.039979707449674606, -0.0401005856692791, 0.02552720159292221, -0.07267334312200546, 0.028904851526021957, -0.03192701190710068, -0.035605933517217636, -0.013083199970424175, 0.015179762616753578, -0.0041970135644078255, 0.008457818068563938, 0.020305102691054344, -0.006381550338119268, -0.04982892796397209, 0.03866538405418396, 0.02278430201113224, 0.04862174764275551, 0.0066709332168102264, -0.004428455140441656, 0.03494866564869881, 0.02075209654867649, -0.04270017147064209, -0.03284691274166107, 0.0033309077844023705, 0.005047923419624567, -0.0023066720459610224, 0.03380110487341881, 0.01933642290532589, -0.040951840579509735, 0.002110565546900034, -0.007420231122523546, -0.039616212248802185, 0.01303686574101448, -0.0003474490949884057, 0.03271021321415901, 0.021233147010207176, -0.06280948966741562, 0.046130552887916565, 0.037643738090991974, -0.0012901539448648691, 0.006077145226299763, -0.016913577914237976, 0.040218502283096313, -0.015701256692409515, -0.009342011064291, -0.01612726040184498, -0.02691219374537468, -0.01414291001856327, 0.03560927137732506, -0.04242219403386116, 0.04275646060705185, -0.0417381227016449, -0.031121810898184776, 0.01960090920329094, 0.004034394398331642, 0.02630849927663803, -0.02208714745938778, 0.005890140775591135, 0.010079086758196354, -0.000010864566320378799, -0.04709826782345772, 0.008181305602192879, -0.011051940731704235, 0.011443091556429863, 0.02954675815999508, -0.023929165676236153, -0.001022313954308629, -0.03962044417858124, -0.03941383212804794, 0.009852137416601181, -0.03365057706832886, 0.013823390007019043, -0.0014596477849408984, 0.03429747000336647, -0.0001751143718138337, -0.031451743096113205, -0.02733234129846096, 0.04373559355735779, -0.01869797892868519, 0.05724146589636803, -0.04712932929396629, 0.05247301608324051, -0.012768374755978584, 0.015014570206403732, -0.08921225368976593, -0.060918178409338, 0.0031113699078559875, 0.0223860926926136, -0.02364584617316723, -0.03921574354171753, 0.006425871513783932, -0.020207177847623825, -0.009149267338216305, -0.030751490965485573, 0.08755914866924286, 0.016086142510175705, -0.021777525544166565, -0.026391224935650826, -0.005120947491377592, 0.09223473817110062, 0.021080229431390762, -0.022538505494594574, -0.007197316735982895, -0.01227613352239132, -0.001217395649291575, -0.036280617117881775, -0.010334198363125324, -0.03897767513990402, 0.00258849048987031, -0.002605446381494403, 0.022974248975515366, 0.04111389443278313, -0.04464306682348251, -0.014943994581699371, 0.03862177953124046, -0.0012138297315686941, -0.014218615368008614, -0.06427069753408432, -0.005941739305853844, -0.02908424660563469, 0.009588932618498802, -0.016870690509676933, 0.026988336816430092, -0.031711094081401825, -0.025731906294822693, 0.02269274741411209, -0.028186623007059097, -0.037757329642772675, 0.038966502994298935, 0.09861504286527634, 0.010258919559419155, 0.03157360106706619, -0.012834387831389904, -0.03992379829287529, 0.015108603984117508, -0.03762465715408325, -0.013037768192589283, 0.014255372807383537, 0.03943420201539993, -0.01130933128297329, 0.012703273445367813, -0.02173781394958496, -0.006456267088651657, 0.04186025634407997, -0.012147585861384869, 0.025882158428430557, 0.04871056228876114, -0.015933571383357048, 0.014298912137746811, -0.03922109305858612, 0.00039645167998969555, -0.01833679899573326, -0.013476270250976086, 0.04946381598711014, 0.0010441148187965155, 0.044754911214113235, 0.016656722873449326, -0.015455261804163456, -0.003293523332104087, 0.024776849895715714, 0.0481085479259491, 0.012826351448893547, 0.015001087449491024, -0.031020063906908035, -0.03366190195083618, 0.027016369625926018, -0.07062108814716339, 0.019370170310139656, -0.04781832918524742, -0.06183040514588356, 0.025676527991890907, 0.006361231207847595, -0.024654407054185867, -0.0736093744635582, -0.04017942026257515, 0.0025743809528648853, 0.03685683012008667, 0.018590273335576057, 0.031328022480010986, 0.028097355738282204, -0.010364738292992115, 0.05680583417415619, 0.01826857589185238, 0.02729639783501625, -0.030319513753056526, -0.052353110164403915, -0.03590450808405876, 0.0027026794850826263, -0.033898431807756424, -0.011690021492540836, -0.023887552320957184, -0.040952812880277634, 0.007882257923483849, -0.03899192437529564, 0.02345394156873226, -0.012883448973298073, 0.03330560028553009, 0.01416945829987526, 0.05249739810824394, 0.03561888635158539, 0.021818403154611588, 0.021424775943160057, 0.03031187877058983, 0.11914700269699097, 0.07605592906475067, 0.004226351156830788, -0.04178519919514656, 0.029057355597615242, 0.0035957074724137783, -0.0049370210617780685, -0.04164844751358032, 0.011800169944763184, -0.008499414660036564, -0.002109357388690114, 0.03426836431026459, 0.07096198201179504, 0.015858711674809456, 0.013255437836050987, 0.06107662245631218, -0.02260756492614746, -0.005736364051699638, 0.02790437452495098, 0.024907957762479782, 0.005233348812907934, -0.030314503237605095, 0.004636209923774004, 0.0265301875770092, 0.03192475065588951, -0.002504135947674513, -0.027090929448604584, -0.0011180845322087407, 0.00550601352006197, 0.011172207072377205, 0.001514721312560141, 0.022341124713420868, 0.020348133519291878, 0.014888470061123371, -0.054601944983005524, -0.020465807989239693, 0.002266746247187257, -0.043955929577350616, -0.005352768115699291, -0.014360759407281876, -0.018578900024294853, 0.013746329583227634, 0.006868424825370312, 0.009010452777147293, -0.03175504878163338, 0.006715995259582996, -0.022314073517918587, -0.009223796427249908, -0.0066066947765648365, 0.02520184963941574, -0.027990344911813736, 0.0275631844997406, 0.020019106566905975, -0.042094483971595764, -0.052958860993385315, 0.022244689986109734, 0.02983541041612625, -0.03914778679609299, -0.05076315626502037, -0.022140802815556526, 0.045493196696043015, 0.00931865070015192, 0.027872582897543907, 0.004869192373007536, -0.016901623457670212, 0.01496077235788107, -0.05299459770321846, 0.0003671368467621505, 0.014966695569455624, -0.011536852456629276, 0.013357115909457207, -0.03370758146047592, -0.054728347808122635, -0.005592838395386934, -0.017933227121829987, 0.03407873213291168, 0.04213752970099449, -0.02706899680197239, -0.01816549152135849, -0.005698055494576693, -0.054711006581783295, -0.024613715708255768, -0.0004743570170830935, -0.017335472628474236, -0.023392420262098312, 0.008734711445868015, 0.018881989642977715, 0.0048768604174256325, 0.013234231621026993, 0.0006366736488416791, 0.010098959319293499, 0.0295379851013422, 0.009907735511660576, -0.0731193795800209, 0.018792245537042618, 0.01690060831606388, -0.029974207282066345, 0.030297745019197464, -0.02936249040067196, 0.0687553808093071, -0.005895265378057957, -0.0029805945232510567, 0.014381464570760727, 0.030159488320350647, -0.011921936646103859, 0.04477786645293236, 0.0508100688457489, -0.05935193970799446, 0.008532230742275715, 0.052603621035814285, -0.0002908064052462578, -0.02360524795949459, -0.0324910543859005, -0.0570978969335556, -0.007617663592100143, -0.029455572366714478, -0.043781694024801254, -0.029567968100309372, 0.006732805632054806, -0.00023469877487514168, 0.02852639928460121, -0.03744570165872574, -0.02663675881922245, -0.06090264022350311, 0.007307285442948341, 0.002686105202883482, 0.0024576885625720024, -0.022760391235351562, 0.013497065752744675, 0.004612305201590061, 0.014993889257311821, 0.010736516676843166, -0.009837670251727104, -0.015234607271850109, -0.0046210093423724174, -0.019008098170161247, -0.002392581896856427, 0.07004205882549286, 0.011293480172753334, 0.037533171474933624, 0.018498433753848076, -0.040518999099731445, 0.004687972832471132, -0.018483959138393402, -0.0035545441787689924, 0.012548628263175488, 0.03421987593173981, 0.020516782999038696, 0.01592736504971981, 0.031554125249385834, -0.0077995057217776775, -0.0129585275426507, -0.033325307071208954, -0.01142534613609314, 0.04248150438070297, -0.02827693521976471, -0.00202422053553164, 0.030339116230607033, -0.013490092940628529, 0.030777348205447197, 0.018251588568091393, 0.017377424985170364, -0.05080796033143997, 0.022740449756383896, -0.019682541489601135, -0.013537927530705929, -0.0017984029836952686, -0.011232978664338589, 0.054439693689346313, 0.046496354043483734, -0.03641064837574959, 0.02712162584066391, 0.009489303454756737, 0.012519941665232182, -0.08991344273090363, -0.04772992804646492, 0.018831131979823112, 0.009476171806454659, 0.05003087967634201, -0.041534703224897385, 0.045361846685409546, 0.02452058717608452, -0.03398643806576729, 0.02233266271650791, -0.005323031451553106, -0.016130607575178146, -0.03260048106312752, -0.004022850655019283, 0.009237340651452541, 0.015516996383666992, -0.0038455124013125896, 0.0038367449305951595, 0.008888835087418556, -0.016765503212809563, -0.010980147868394852, -0.04033898934721947, -0.0027807278092950583, 0.023191355168819427, 0.028966905549168587, -0.05648159980773926, 0.040416378527879715, 0.010249639861285686, -0.04322827234864235, 0.05452492833137512, 0.002435362199321389, 0.018305104225873947, 0.0265045203268528, 0.00003119938264717348, 0.011408758349716663, 0.04079008474946022, 0.047476667910814285, -0.020999399945139885, -0.02738858200609684, 0.013993725180625916, -0.0013159278314560652, 0.022958479821681976, 0.02939474955201149, -0.010902644135057926, 0.028608860448002815, -0.034705810248851776, -0.03253449872136116, 0.011854980140924454, -0.0019149812869727612, -0.009657574817538261, 0.008940857835114002, 0.005693281535059214, -0.0033671564888209105, -0.0024161303881555796, -0.016448263078927994, -0.05143614858388901, -0.022619251161813736, 0.03941839933395386, -0.034092653542757034, 0.005609086714684963, -0.022170690819621086, -0.003405991243198514, -0.02228463441133499, -0.017979439347982407, 0.026188040152192116, 0.008217168971896172, -0.028972027823328972, -0.005998885724693537, -0.026243960484862328, -0.0294811874628067, -0.04220791161060333, -0.027833551168441772, -0.03341447934508324, 0.0462380014359951, -0.04820219799876213, -0.0029433753807097673, 0.0012149214744567871, -0.01811840943992138, -0.004778487142175436, -0.06591655313968658, 0.034643471240997314, 0.021796083077788353, -0.03822290524840355, -0.014869182370603085, -0.020823201164603233, -0.04574612155556679, 0.023151617497205734, 0.059589285403490067, -0.01274808682501316, -0.010328065603971481, -0.013757526874542236, 0.01360011100769043, 0.005810251925140619, -0.03980039060115814, 0.015817899256944656, 0.015620951540768147, -0.006543971598148346, -0.05381525307893753, 0.017028160393238068, -0.0032798415049910545, -0.012753643095493317, -0.021668262779712677, 0.007425188552588224, 0.037850458174943924, 0.007460396736860275, 0.031188827008008957, 0.06257881969213486, 0.016045141965150833, -0.046052757650613785, 0.043147455900907516, -0.005844553001224995, -0.004016542807221413, 0.02336205542087555, -0.03042301908135414, -0.03446368873119354, 0.005455784499645233, -0.026013530790805817, -0.011058416217565536, 0.0049547310918569565, 0.03593011572957039, 0.009620269760489464, -0.048307958990335464, 0.00162390130572021, 0.02804352343082428, -0.043827272951602936, 0.018039776012301445, 0.0035553493071347475, 0.025202574208378792, 0.03934164717793465, -0.030165070667862892, 0.014508438296616077, 0.003699707332998514, -0.03789904713630676, 0.009257063269615173, 0.027613962069153786, -0.0016870911931619048, 0.03246486932039261, 0.0011968017788603902, 0.030313484370708466, -0.006624764762818813, -0.012136699631810188, 0.011062909848988056, 0.02152855508029461, -0.026900475844740868, -0.015249509364366531, 0.019437279552221298, 0.01070550549775362, 0.02335098758339882, 0.01421278901398182, 0.014181515201926231, 0.013089308515191078, -0.037584226578474045, 0.005104959011077881, -0.02744341269135475, 0.04158725589513779, -0.052213404327631, 0.006460074335336685, 0.005193969700485468, 0.015524075366556644, -0.0009651277796365321, -0.0001942596718436107, -0.01633957400918007, -0.025329099968075752, 0.005153424106538296, -0.013468986377120018, 0.03148486837744713, -0.01633543148636818, 0.014332517050206661, -0.029923778027296066, -0.004143359139561653, -0.04931730777025223, -0.025846043601632118, 0.0221053808927536, 0.0768711194396019, 0.017039863392710686, 0.026315415278077126, -0.028677605092525482, 0.018004441633820534, 0.030568668618798256, -0.051179189234972, -0.04037243872880936, -0.04435840621590614, 0.011340143159031868, 0.022842923179268837, 0.009203328751027584 ]
<p>I am using proc mixed for multilevel hierarchical data. What should be the acceptable range for Standard Error values for Fixed Effects?</p>
74,396
[ -0.05027324706315994, -0.008751663379371166, -0.014965532347559929, -0.004566290881484747, 0.032732706516981125, -0.00041607185266911983, 0.02218424528837204, -0.028169598430395126, 0.037998758256435394, -0.052251625806093216, 0.040955912321805954, 0.02452411875128746, 0.04273389279842377, 0.012960094027221203, 0.04068566858768463, -0.017804313451051712, -0.004572895355522633, 0.0025778210256248713, -0.005762643180787563, 0.005716504063457251, -0.03194960579276085, -0.0007753303507342935, -0.007141296751797199, -0.027546053752303123, -0.014717770740389824, 0.04209214448928833, 0.0316375195980072, -0.03797611594200134, 0.04610295221209526, 0.04429309070110321, -0.003206160617992282, -0.04386487603187561, 0.01005700882524252, 0.016182055696845055, 0.017628338187932968, -0.021366538479924202, -0.015718936920166016, -0.02577579952776432, -0.01493156235665083, 0.037334904074668884, -0.052661553025245667, 0.0005115577368997037, 0.0029189614579081535, 0.024048306047916412, -0.005290384404361248, 0.01799614727497101, -0.013138008303940296, 0.015615475364029408, 0.0504906065762043, -0.014571395702660084, 0.056281302124261856, -0.02531796135008335, 0.04223882034420967, 0.028042767196893692, -0.055598776787519455, 0.002486387500539422, 0.04835469648241997, 0.01449060719460249, 0.003281697863712907, -0.013773995451629162, -0.031760960817337036, -0.034695543348789215, -0.010987245477735996, -0.009403259493410587, -0.02048479951918125, -0.004921820014715195, -0.017103038728237152, -0.01863853633403778, 0.008422932587563992, -0.013749339617788792, 0.04164924472570419, 0.009681910276412964, 0.04278791695833206, -0.023799529299139977, 0.03263936564326286, -0.0853530690073967, 0.03775899484753609, 0.010765839368104935, 0.02332483045756817, 0.03878697380423546, 0.017284320667386055, -0.002122746780514717, 0.024030975997447968, 0.019724244251847267, -0.012959317304193974, 0.0027870191261172295, 0.03457451984286308, -0.015152999199926853, 0.018037069588899612, 0.0032806075178086758, 0.0014962159330025315, 0.02242625318467617, 0.0671599879860878, 0.04325294867157936, -0.06953258812427521, 0.003889799816533923, -0.0077277920208871365, 0.01258548442274332, -0.0034039486199617386, 0.017478695139288902, 0.021193398162722588, -0.027956945821642876, 0.03454164043068886, 0.05571715533733368, 0.009108750149607658, 0.016146158799529076, -0.016715778037905693, 0.014477504417300224, 0.0029411765281111, -0.012664468958973885, 0.0022105269599705935, -0.009272436611354351, -0.037708647549152374, 0.012365367263555527, 0.025693349540233612, -0.022553788498044014, -0.010511141270399094, -0.032411087304353714, 0.07797844707965851, 0.032790154218673706, 0.0526231974363327, -0.040727775543928146, 0.042454227805137634, -0.011850656941533089, -0.05119850113987923, 0.01881125196814537, -0.0030217913445085287, -0.026670774444937706, -0.05718269199132919, 0.05014641955494881, 0.0561348982155323, -0.013414843007922173, 0.03899636119604111, -0.03367440029978752, 0.004237569402903318, -0.01849181577563286, -0.042211249470710754, -0.08086070418357849, -0.012178564444184303, 0.004250648431479931, 0.013812807388603687, -0.07402602583169937, -0.020085914060473442, 0.020439734682440758, 0.01900586485862732, 0.022966453805565834, 0.017680924385786057, 0.028577491641044617, 0.05550871789455414, 0.0006029591895639896, -0.026169249787926674, -0.01052299328148365, -0.018158046528697014, -0.037676338106393814, -0.03868665546178818, -0.08860301226377487, 0.0346641018986702, -0.0038847681134939194, -0.013604170642793179, 0.011901965364813805, -0.009048479609191418, -0.017869900912046432, 0.006304668728262186, -0.009185944683849812, 0.03471451997756958, -0.030056510120630264, 0.03855641931295395, -0.035652801394462585, 0.04698412865400314, 0.024656658992171288, -0.010611290112137794, 0.03772474080324173, -0.013882980681955814, 0.03443850576877594, 0.0021330348681658506, -0.01922418177127838, 0.04419076442718506, -0.011556737124919891, 0.01679789088666439, 0.025985248386859894, -0.0340256504714489, -0.00413973955437541, 0.005292336922138929, -0.02644839882850647, 0.043331220746040344, 0.018967362120747566, -0.020611809566617012, -0.0063816849142313, 0.0478835329413414, -0.04175036773085594, -0.054424628615379333, -0.08102989941835403, 0.015190410427749157, 0.00431313319131732, -0.03375714644789696, 0.020366385579109192, -0.03801100328564644, 0.03520970046520233, -0.020011695101857185, -0.0071067605167627335, -0.030804991722106934, -0.012495484203100204, 0.046034637838602066, -0.045709867030382156, 0.022521277889609337, 0.055034056305885315, 0.06318677216768265, 0.0009186154347844422, 0.010971409268677235, -0.015599706210196018, -0.03171012923121452, -0.01105966791510582, -0.02796759642660618, -0.021600810810923576, 0.008632178418338299, -0.011662187054753304, -0.01720215007662773, -0.0036022027488797903, -0.008098462596535683, 0.03288664296269417, -0.04200118035078049, 0.08573031425476074, 0.0630803033709526, -0.010947414673864841, -0.0004271369252819568, 0.007956009358167648, 0.014399511739611626, -0.02647850103676319, -0.03772757574915886, -0.03114156611263752, -0.04244542866945267, -0.004782558418810368, 0.015242131426930428, 0.007708523888140917, -0.031782619655132294, 0.01284709945321083, 0.07555472105741501, -0.019909130409359932, 0.031068218871951103, 0.015833808109164238, -0.011102963238954544, -0.04214779660105705, 0.01361051481217146, 0.00948687456548214, 0.014324655756354332, 0.039025239646434784, 0.017239989712834358, 0.015231473371386528, 0.010233135893940926, 0.013600106351077557, 0.025921260938048363, 0.04774878919124603, 0.0004882325592916459, 0.05366211384534836, -0.0064653800800442696, -0.035248659551143646, 0.04894338548183441, -0.02670830860733986, 0.023171745240688324, 0.04991457611322403, 0.004678784403949976, -0.006647958420217037, 0.010622235015034676, -0.0032131203915923834, 0.03517608344554901, 0.025379890576004982, -0.01915166899561882, -0.003698021173477173, 0.02247030846774578, 0.0076989419758319855, 0.00934696290642023, -0.047369278967380524, -0.017989465966820717, -0.027577044442296028, -0.019980425015091896, 0.02033209428191185, -0.0450669527053833, 0.04652801528573036, -0.05545739829540253, -0.002988508203998208, -0.014807464554905891, -0.011355985887348652, 0.0337195098400116, -0.014363371767103672, -0.03662985563278198, -0.013596777804195881, 0.0022188511211425066, -0.013659547083079815, 0.01679997704923153, 0.012033641338348389, -0.03243357688188553, 0.05158829316496849, 0.015723342075943947, -0.00785711221396923, -0.013912239111959934, -0.01958857662975788, -0.025915659964084625, -0.0325690396130085, -0.053791482001543045, 0.04412693902850151, -0.007291607093065977, -0.008823735639452934, 0.011571371927857399, -0.03052801825106144, -0.012950514443218708, -0.011892490088939667, -0.006173913832753897, -0.0037221768870949745, 0.015988823026418686, -0.0017817053012549877, 0.0038043044041842222, -0.016209285706281662, 0.0003094499697908759, -0.05072807893157005, -0.08613685518503189, 0.03903571888804436, 0.001803307794034481, 0.034629546105861664, -0.01114119216799736, -0.02317274548113346, 0.06401204317808151, 0.01658749021589756, -0.02101306803524494, -0.06598105281591415, -0.0383518785238266, -0.01464883517473936, -0.0003232389863114804, 0.042992327362298965, 0.021252566948533058, 0.010225506499409676, 0.019242992624640465, -0.023079251870512962, 0.021227175369858742, 0.03672241419553757, 0.004932897165417671, -0.022873234003782272, 0.03459645435214043, -0.01019250601530075, -0.04839073494076729, 0.003542351769283414, -0.008525504730641842, -0.018057774752378464, -0.012108461000025272, -0.010860174894332886, 0.013824490830302238, -0.012638249434530735, -0.028001930564641953, 0.0045796968042850494, -0.05186431109905243, 0.0021130340173840523, -0.031682178378105164, 0.04862367361783981, 0.03369249403476715, 0.0011549186892807484, 0.0026248754002153873, -0.019396960735321045, 0.0034705058205872774, -0.06149899587035179, 0.03197065368294716, 0.05470946431159973, 0.059624433517456055, 0.017715992406010628, -0.016649259254336357, 0.011200813576579094, -0.021993039175868034, -0.00022387427452486008, -0.01515500433743, -0.014577898196876049, 0.015460013411939144, 0.03676920011639595, 0.02130446396768093, 0.008650295436382294, -0.05549516901373863, 0.039650823920965195, -0.06600966304540634, 0.023721912875771523, -0.04175231233239174, 0.028707846999168396, -0.015359834767878056, 0.03812788426876068, 0.020239796489477158, -0.039893314242362976, 0.004089036025106907, 0.0057318867184221745, -0.016358528286218643, 0.010837078094482422, -0.03173802047967911, 0.04414476081728935, -0.005024869926273823, -0.0499298982322216, -0.009740344248712063, -0.022834762930870056, -0.0016238472890108824, -0.0002946144959423691, 0.04772298038005829, 0.015594170428812504, -0.013140750117599964, 0.0003472803218755871, -0.010280920192599297, -0.005692214705049992, -0.01613776758313179, 0.011149667203426361, 0.009624624624848366, -0.015986144542694092, 0.022096026688814163, -0.005060437135398388, -0.027827324345707893, -0.05429024621844292, -0.028838980942964554, -0.01779978722333908, 0.05526391789317131, 0.016912950202822685, -0.011030497029423714, -0.06737560033798218, 0.04926517978310585, -0.013881227001547813, 0.041005395352840424, 0.07338476926088333, -0.015564867295324802, -0.010709903202950954, 0.004067284986376762, -0.04779917746782303, 0.04657793417572975, -0.007294541224837303, -0.006238086149096489, -0.007269011810421944, 0.036664143204689026, 0.01705390214920044, -0.07947082817554474, 0.04436875134706497, 0.09580634534358978, 0.0318315252661705, 0.009493616409599781, -0.05203825607895851, -0.017194483429193497, -0.02518586255609989, -0.021481333300471306, 0.043081920593976974, -0.0033972884994000196, -0.003094633109867573, 0.0006647512782365084, 0.03754766657948494, -0.012185188010334969, -0.04434676840901375, 0.04676039516925812, 0.015474919229745865, 0.031513314694166183, 0.02040383219718933, -0.03202925622463226, 0.020992040634155273, 0.03058631159365177, 0.040341828018426895, 0.022033851593732834, -0.0026047066785395145, -0.09872978925704956, 0.000397668918594718, 0.05703582242131233, 0.03333388268947601, -0.031487610191106796, 0.01376856304705143, -0.020950254052877426, 0.009381577372550964, 0.01591111533343792, -0.04627209156751633, 0.02144995890557766, -0.031499575823545456, 0.025786036625504494, -0.05315177142620087, -0.042866844683885574, -0.044022999703884125, 0.022370602935552597, 0.009278463199734688, 0.00962873362004757, 0.010022664442658424, 0.007461309898644686, -0.03201894462108612, 0.00928014051169157, 0.01762784831225872, 0.05045035481452942, 0.009235597215592861, -0.02870994620025158, 0.036566466093063354, 0.01796279102563858, -0.014801773242652416, -0.05099024251103401, 0.03505880385637283, -0.005387688986957073, 0.03126731887459755, 0.03765302523970604, -0.002559021580964327, -0.00868616346269846, 0.007237731944769621, 0.027031751349568367, -0.0002447848382871598, -0.022787950932979584, -0.011544525623321533, 0.06058305874466896, 0.0010395365534350276, 0.04267376661300659, 0.05208767578005791, -0.01300121285021305, 0.02128186821937561, 0.0082651162520051, -0.03278611600399017, 0.04121735319495201, -0.044634781777858734, -0.02033322863280773, -0.04258471727371216, -0.015546523965895176, -0.03295605629682541, 0.03424414247274399, 0.0026240902952849865, 0.006195658352226019, -0.019686929881572723, -0.02831423468887806, 0.03669137880206108, 0.026797525584697723, 0.02280011586844921, -0.005970303434878588, 0.022533472627401352, -0.0040803709998726845, -0.020205052569508553, -0.03361032158136368, 0.04751380905508995, -0.021761132404208183, 0.015142536722123623, -0.015464861877262592, -0.07330480962991714, 0.015685131773352623, -0.012577865272760391, -0.04074477776885033, -0.002605720888823271, -0.03629258647561073, 0.019182251766324043, -0.0053917160257697105, 0.04078041389584541, -0.0019426081562414765, -0.03800179809331894, 0.021997418254613876, 0.04326198995113373, -0.018528053537011147, 0.041213903576135635, -0.005417782813310623, 0.03292648121714592, -0.000429046485805884, 0.020889252424240112, -0.050420861691236496, -0.03903431445360184, -0.0016093876911327243, 0.004768416751176119, 0.02138826809823513, -0.02184484712779522, 0.00270134792663157, -0.016579482704401016, -0.0010217254748567939, -0.013378734700381756, 0.08580877631902695, -0.038180120289325714, 0.008313694968819618, -0.012010968290269375, -0.00915879849344492, 0.05459422990679741, -0.004553052131086588, 0.011365818791091442, 0.01815440133213997, -0.02088269591331482, -0.004291053861379623, -0.03323178365826607, 0.010812024585902691, -0.032829757779836655, 0.003147934563457966, -0.03708590194582939, -0.008671076036989689, 0.044602129608392715, -0.004773699678480625, -0.013011924922466278, 0.001524735358543694, -0.011843918822705746, 0.023320743814110756, 0.007758434861898422, 0.03678395226597786, -0.04376601800322533, 0.025001680478453636, -0.021070944145321846, 0.027852091938257217, -0.03920925781130791, 0.0013368964428082108, 0.022465091198682785, -0.007420720066875219, -0.015869265422225, 0.03157668933272362, 0.07734504342079163, 0.017730923369526863, 0.001022828510031104, -0.003902768949046731, -0.012175370939075947, 0.045813482254743576, 0.016861509531736374, -0.010881668888032436, 0.029481315985322, 0.013290639035403728, -0.009283582679927349, -0.015735682100057602, -0.00879152212291956, 0.012254955247044563, 0.07308518886566162, 0.004418892320245504, 0.014984188601374626, 0.037677157670259476, -0.02998633123934269, -0.0017171066720038652, -0.035192638635635376, -0.009740889072418213, 0.00026688739308156073, 0.01835770718753338, 0.0461626872420311, -0.04499748721718788, 0.0012136019067838788, -0.026138197630643845, 0.017774786800146103, 0.009431484155356884, 0.04304523766040802, 0.03272700682282448, 0.011999628506600857, -0.007439752575010061, -0.053857993334531784, -0.03806525096297264, 0.01787852682173252, -0.049997225403785706, 0.010961535386741161, -0.04467065632343292, -0.01012494508177042, 0.0541992262005806, 0.041114699095487595, 0.019488099962472916, -0.03572879731655121, -0.013986081816256046, -0.023513197898864746, -0.02002612128853798, 0.013434474356472492, -0.036497924476861954, 0.012032921425998211, 0.005316105671226978, 0.06877666711807251, -0.02269611321389675, 0.04537321254611015, -0.05422022566199303, -0.07788432389497757, -0.014090251177549362, -0.02422330528497696, -0.043203700333833694, 0.004533964209258556, -0.019779954105615616, -0.03220224007964134, -0.017072051763534546, -0.04072316735982895, -0.019900158047676086, -0.006907836999744177, 0.016194185242056847, 0.030193902552127838, 0.04279398173093796, 0.009757223539054394, 0.012173454277217388, 0.009369591251015663, 0.018076088279485703, 0.13921721279621124, 0.10300641506910324, 0.013192739337682724, -0.08090521395206451, 0.050847943872213364, 0.0008629048825241625, 0.0020522731356322765, 0.02786356210708618, 0.003787353867664933, -0.04194599762558937, -0.04075838625431061, 0.051920026540756226, 0.0776166021823883, 0.020003024488687515, 0.010035674087703228, 0.043449725955724716, -0.03802209720015526, -0.0243559367954731, 0.04239734634757042, -0.004499621689319611, -0.03196481987833977, -0.01992032676935196, 0.004832396283745766, -0.011123951524496078, -0.014892294071614742, -0.030879110097885132, 0.007541244849562645, 0.0355859212577343, -0.0031162952072918415, 0.03261365368962288, -0.019253138452768326, -0.008675612509250641, -0.0045257024466991425, 0.015599408186972141, -0.017230162397027016, -0.051759984344244, 0.0012457985430955887, -0.019548261538147926, 0.005210230126976967, 0.047271326184272766, -0.0020459529478102922, -0.031090082600712776, 0.003293421817943454, -0.008578655309975147, -0.0482528880238533, -0.021167946979403496, -0.01148205902427435, 0.022776545956730843, -0.02435058169066906, -0.006459963507950306, 0.010322047397494316, 0.007370432838797569, -0.041766371577978134, -0.04173392057418823, 0.024016007781028748, 0.028087439015507698, 0.018835972994565964, 0.004191734362393618, -0.028176013380289078, -0.029127540066838264, 0.008862510323524475, -0.02053689770400524, 0.022972319275140762, 0.024953939020633698, 0.0015293677570298314, -0.01556059718132019, -0.05031753331422806, 0.0626886785030365, 0.01232242677360773, -0.01615842804312706, 0.02126941829919815, -0.013633981347084045, -0.027245275676250458, 0.030090542510151863, 0.018786894157528877, 0.005970656406134367, 0.028795555233955383, 0.013697220012545586, -0.021721625700592995, -0.012699564918875694, -0.05939836427569389, 0.022404907271265984, -0.016831910237669945, -0.016034428030252457, -0.08206291496753693, -0.0050471266731619835, 0.018551232293248177, 0.03319860249757767, 0.009779680520296097, 0.04152495414018631, -0.01848955824971199, 0.06689433753490448, -0.002244992181658745, -0.07754552364349365, 0.0009279189398512244, 0.01589787006378174, -0.03714574873447418, -0.015845688059926033, 0.014985144138336182, 0.05020848289132118, -0.01939414069056511, 0.03571150451898575, -0.0007819645688869059, 0.03940753638744354, 0.019062109291553497, 0.003797238925471902, 0.03154544159770012, -0.0440402589738369, 0.035785917192697525, -0.03228846564888954, 0.006388213951140642, -0.0010515853064134717, -0.0038746728096157312, -0.07010181993246078, -0.0303389560431242, -0.0025022535119205713, 0.007522598374634981, -0.005620009731501341, 0.01371929980814457, -0.036322735249996185, -0.021129556000232697, -0.028166785836219788, -0.014905835501849651, -0.007686386816203594, -0.0006272019236348569, 0.042404402047395706, 0.027698466554284096, 0.01995091140270233, -0.00938994251191616, 0.0007482573855668306, 0.01314324140548706, 0.014766866341233253, 0.01971443183720112, 0.02869514934718609, -0.010412975214421749, -0.008480628952383995, 0.012726922519505024, 0.05955138057470322, -0.014103172346949577, -0.016123313456773758, 0.006235191132873297, -0.03332284465432167, -0.006782087497413158, 0.006769906263798475, 0.0005598103743977845, -0.0005915560177527368, 0.036769766360521317, 0.006686684675514698, 0.0071975779719650745, 0.02914970926940441, -0.029779141768813133, -0.04900331422686577, 0.011648104526102543, 0.008445262908935547, 0.00018758277292363346, 0.04369182512164116, 0.01710856519639492, 0.050247713923454285, -0.011456344276666641, 0.042626429349184036, 0.026933783665299416, -0.004787965677678585, -0.004947620909661055, -0.026318654417991638, -0.01351881492882967, -0.005633909720927477, 0.02658754400908947, -0.01811862736940384, 0.035672396421432495, 0.04623246192932129, -0.04768846184015274, 0.028476903215050697, -0.006484861485660076, -0.007517160382121801, -0.07365129888057709, -0.02997996285557747, 0.01298145204782486, 0.030795088037848473, 0.0019108285196125507, -0.038458727300167084, 0.001104504568502307, 0.0421665757894516, -0.031995657831430435, -0.015323057770729065, -0.001204065978527069, -0.004841843619942665, -0.029966773465275764, 0.00009880136349238455, -0.03697426617145538, 0.004672111943364143, -0.00031266090809367597, 0.025620948523283005, 0.00855790451169014, 0.015725087374448776, 0.025546569377183914, -0.031376421451568604, -0.016254259273409843, 0.003967877943068743, 0.025287242606282234, -0.058996569365262985, -0.01552939135581255, -0.012707804329693317, -0.02631925791501999, 0.04865741729736328, 0.034148477017879486, 0.02323661930859089, 0.019425394013524055, 0.04254088178277016, -0.005861685145646334, 0.04664251580834389, 0.010048122145235538, 0.009474377147853374, 0.014821238815784454, 0.007171027362346649, 0.011056952178478241, 0.040865641087293625, -0.06305085867643356, -0.012107407674193382, 0.02102559618651867, -0.0059340475127100945, -0.03035825490951538, 0.026557883247733116, -0.049964532256126404, -0.0468590073287487, -0.012996390461921692, -0.026712728664278984, 0.004147660452872515, -0.012214901857078075, 0.03616861626505852, 0.0025919312611222267, 0.04875306040048599, 0.05070773512125015, 0.03607264161109924, -0.034936923533678055, 0.012393541634082794, 0.0037985043600201607, -0.015531412325799465, -0.0390801839530468, 0.017181266099214554, -0.02784024551510811, -0.04768982529640198, 0.006574373692274094, -0.01301106158643961, 0.02641001157462597, -0.023184074088931084, 0.02249433845281601, -0.04700557142496109, 0.0321444571018219, -0.062101174145936966, -0.007620661985129118, 0.012746475636959076, -0.02312942035496235, -0.0005554271047003567, -0.054594043642282486, 0.07328338176012039, 0.021662268787622452, 0.006029156036674976, -0.03808331489562988, -0.027116060256958008, -0.019454561173915863, 0.03423377871513367, 0.05288102477788925, 0.028140287846326828, -0.019800493493676186, -0.025672169402241707, 0.051510997116565704, 0.012655297294259071, -0.07239510118961334, 0.06401197612285614, -0.007239671424031258, -0.030532915145158768, -0.0407060869038105, -0.0020743601489812136, 0.03484273701906204, -0.00012936176790390164, -0.0021670828573405743, -0.01162052247673273, 0.03265008702874184, -0.01855841651558876, 0.01255793496966362, 0.01804897002875805, 0.019935399293899536, -0.027939556166529655, 0.05099412798881531, 0.0005087953759357333, -0.030887117609381676, 0.03951915726065636, -0.00424142787232995, -0.018692689016461372, 0.027879878878593445, -0.004081691615283489, -0.01169081125408411, 0.008814013563096523, 0.019620191305875778, -0.030119311064481735, -0.05877474322915077, 0.045532308518886566, 0.022448021918535233, -0.07795025408267975, -0.005959485657513142, 0.021163463592529297, 0.04715106263756752, 0.027308227494359016, 0.03604516014456749, 0.03525977581739426, 0.016604049131274223, -0.02242378517985344, 0.06505617499351501, 0.031056951731443405, 0.049580562859773636, -0.03385182470083237, -0.0003198253980372101, 0.017447253689169884, -0.013570253737270832, 0.030757801607251167, -0.003816524287685752, 0.07599962502717972, -0.0012915374245494604, -0.04262961074709892, -0.0022825358901172876, 0.004906419664621353, 0.007622926030308008, 0.0007635391084477305, 0.0065976339392364025, 0.05853786692023277, -0.00808920431882143, 0.009156343527138233, -0.06803460419178009, -0.027572711929678917, -0.040600720793008804, 0.00873227883130312, -0.011400721967220306, 0.03679811209440231, 0.0005364115349948406, 0.0036444817669689655, -0.013853014446794987, -0.020353449508547783, 0.03743995353579521, -0.02602466568350792, 0.021226083859801292, -0.026663733646273613, 0.024380085989832878, -0.04113873094320297, -0.017113640904426575, -0.05482698604464531, -0.01970522478222847, 0.019785551354289055, 0.005130347330123186, 0.006290295626968145, 0.006434501148760319, -0.03638674318790436, 0.04949400573968887, 0.013586622662842274, -0.09185679256916046, -0.01943514123558998, -0.03578946366906166, -0.013842487707734108, -0.024536579847335815, 0.030490286648273468 ]
<p>I have a question regarding the best practice for dealing with cross-loadings on factors after conducting an exploratory factor analysis using a promax rotation. Just to give a bit of background information, I am trying to determine the factor structure of a set of 20 questions that I created about spirituality (based on PCA which identified 4 components). After conducting the EFA with 184 participants, I noticed that quite a few of the questions are cross-loading onto two or three factors. I read online that you should eliminate questions whose cross-loadings are less than or equal to .2, but I am confused because doesn't an oblique rotation (promax) imply that there is inter-correlation? For example, if question 2 loads onto factor 1 (.234), factor 2 (.346), and factor 3 (.212), what should I do?</p>
47,975
[ -0.031192362308502197, -0.00012090287782484666, -0.052390728145837784, 0.015436306595802307, 0.07069970667362213, -0.0046707214787602425, 0.02286570519208908, -0.013688594102859497, 0.026382114738225937, -0.01741695962846279, -0.009533633477985859, 0.012771199457347393, 0.03996563330292702, -0.02271893061697483, 0.019965365529060364, 0.0455024391412735, 0.023270748555660248, 0.0074067916721105576, 0.0058471872471272945, -0.006993459537625313, 0.014802730642259121, -0.010380619205534458, -0.004406836815178394, -0.026637278497219086, -0.018347833305597305, 0.04229966178536415, 0.045945823192596436, -0.03736487776041031, 0.023923486471176147, -0.0005300858174450696, -0.007553371135145426, 0.014463786035776138, 0.015628861263394356, 0.024580156430602074, -0.012156435288488865, -0.002072245581075549, 0.00495877955108881, -0.00382523937150836, -0.0026767344679683447, 0.04483719915151596, -0.019775403663516045, 0.004273002035915852, -0.056298233568668365, 0.030586928129196167, -0.00651851762086153, 0.017763245850801468, -0.014592825435101986, 0.011163385584950447, 0.04090393707156181, -0.05769697576761246, 0.09331446886062622, -0.01222657598555088, -0.006020746193826199, 0.046731337904930115, 0.000015807887393748388, -0.011534976772964, 0.09016008675098419, 0.047837283462285995, -0.02230643853545189, -0.05319424718618393, -0.05970825254917145, -0.04113474115729332, 0.017813168466091156, -0.014689452946186066, -0.028502127155661583, 0.03924475610256195, 0.04416609928011894, -0.012191209010779858, 0.05918116495013237, 0.011642847210168839, 0.015048502944409847, 0.009884237311780453, 0.0314507931470871, -0.027399681508541107, -0.005122990347445011, -0.020293843001127243, 0.010344872251152992, 0.014939729124307632, 0.030402937904000282, 0.03627811372280121, -0.03247012570500374, 0.012191932648420334, -0.01579129509627819, 0.03907396271824837, 0.015771586447954178, 0.017106490209698677, 0.0714978575706482, -0.020272502675652504, -0.0020616103429347277, 0.010854098945856094, -0.01138176117092371, -0.006017959211021662, 0.019254840910434723, 0.002921552397310734, -0.024482225999236107, 0.04667934030294418, -0.015874873846769333, 0.02169705741107464, -0.012333368882536888, 0.02044457197189331, -0.0355914868414402, 0.0008400579681620002, 0.036613769829273224, 0.02543388120830059, -0.017527660354971886, 0.03801237419247627, -0.049721214920282364, 0.011129988357424736, -0.016924232244491577, -0.02145077846944332, -0.007398270536214113, 0.0032628753688186407, 0.012640456669032574, -0.01306022610515356, 0.0512055866420269, -0.0019730778876692057, -0.030319221317768097, -0.0023189338389784098, 0.09620404988527298, 0.07538064569234848, 0.045087698847055435, -0.03997610881924629, 0.029502807185053825, -0.0030403027776628733, -0.07277824729681015, -0.024383800104260445, 0.0240626260638237, 0.0001959483342943713, -0.03871621936559677, 0.03634039685130119, 0.031731992959976196, -0.030030157417058945, 0.018096566200256348, -0.034475792199373245, 0.015747126191854477, 0.03128299489617348, -0.1111602857708931, -0.024640940129756927, 0.02548665553331375, -0.027403254061937332, -0.023687448352575302, -0.05496067926287651, -0.02933969348669052, 0.02005920559167862, 0.08446944504976273, -0.009847378358244896, 0.017648495733737946, -0.01855321228504181, 0.06601782143115997, 0.006683970335870981, -0.04245174303650856, -0.01488889567553997, -0.08017291128635406, -0.015132014639675617, -0.04216762259602547, -0.049189407378435135, -0.009462293237447739, 0.017395146191120148, 0.017835082486271858, -0.016211800277233124, 0.015196788124740124, -0.0038219732232391834, -0.02504158392548561, -0.011827465146780014, 0.035153914242982864, 0.01368595939129591, 0.03241711109876633, -0.023757021874189377, -0.010836182162165642, 0.022338761016726494, -0.012858331203460693, 0.008786358870565891, 0.02349008433520794, 0.04169578105211258, 0.04328502342104912, -0.018362391740083694, 0.021433230489492416, -0.0005512243369594216, 0.017352227121591568, -0.01733417995274067, 0.0010848317760974169, -0.039520714432001114, 0.005362525582313538, -0.016036229208111763, 0.03126971423625946, 0.03535459563136101, -0.02459557168185711, -0.045708805322647095, 0.010248745791614056, -0.01998000033199787, 0.002323729218915105, -0.006937268190085888, 0.02338407374918461, 0.005874952767044306, -0.024334730580449104, 0.026194903999567032, 0.0052251690067350864, 0.015533366240561008, 0.0011365810642018914, -0.021874509751796722, -0.016945429146289825, 0.0014128693146631122, 0.012767626903951168, -0.02616068534553051, -0.0056484052911400795, 0.00986021850258112, -0.023679979145526886, 0.0022948274854570627, 0.004919005557894707, -0.003325836732983589, -0.041664186865091324, 0.016852205619215965, -0.02852572500705719, 0.03310878947377205, -0.019696742296218872, -0.024552159011363983, -0.039603717625141144, 0.04213453456759453, -0.047348182648420334, 0.022413508966565132, -0.016011448577046394, 0.09607451409101486, 0.05123932659626007, -0.037869732826948166, 0.020358078181743622, 0.005424804985523224, 0.07044454663991928, 0.03154692426323891, -0.01339585892856121, -0.0057600028812885284, -0.03573925793170929, -0.03305855393409729, 0.03863221034407616, -0.030509578064084053, -0.07232865691184998, -0.013692846521735191, 0.06989841163158417, 0.04069610685110092, -0.02881256677210331, 0.06749439984560013, -0.0041358210146427155, -0.04162102937698364, 0.003054473316296935, 0.057153068482875824, 0.002015775768086314, -0.0025793297681957483, -0.005933010950684547, 0.003109097247943282, 0.004057258367538452, 0.019910695031285286, -0.025109870359301567, 0.06380754709243774, 0.00900910422205925, 0.005683338735252619, -0.0026373385917395353, 0.0018008137121796608, 0.03279756009578705, 0.008639771491289139, 0.028660912066698074, 0.015706339851021767, 0.015811458230018616, -0.03790775313973427, 0.013181754387915134, -0.00973500870168209, 0.018880007788538933, 0.024110663682222366, -0.017488470301032066, 0.015530411154031754, 0.022908518090844154, -0.035911332815885544, -0.009666651487350464, -0.027346376329660416, -0.01346294954419136, -0.02075096033513546, -0.028984500095248222, 0.03657933324575424, 0.03384719789028168, 0.019326847046613693, -0.025023654103279114, 0.009546241723001003, -0.020343782380223274, -0.006456896662712097, -0.01759440265595913, -0.05436963587999344, -0.06682959944009781, -0.008916071616113186, -0.016711674630641937, -0.01069311797618866, 0.027555886656045914, -0.030895357951521873, -0.02648562379181385, 0.056298721581697464, 0.01581389084458351, -0.02124352753162384, -0.01858467236161232, -0.01677391678094864, 0.008939585648477077, -0.01868266612291336, -0.019848084077239037, 0.05872763693332672, 0.018253346905112267, -0.07887530326843262, -0.03166554495692253, -0.013008790090680122, -0.009790700860321522, 0.0455140620470047, -0.007937533780932426, 0.032757554203271866, 0.019442861899733543, -0.03799157217144966, 0.023693732917308807, -0.03839808702468872, 0.03504816070199013, -0.05028485134243965, -0.06549022346735, -0.007243683561682701, 0.009468941017985344, 0.025996776297688484, 0.035448383539915085, -0.035722073167562485, 0.049722447991371155, -0.0012682205997407436, -0.07076598703861237, -0.06487631052732468, -0.02299942634999752, -0.028192326426506042, -0.030007079243659973, 0.003560825018212199, 0.023600054904818535, 0.023934127762913704, 0.06773997098207474, -0.006268053315579891, 0.03372417762875557, 0.02838590182363987, 0.03243769332766533, -0.0218728706240654, 0.03865322098135948, 0.011993044055998325, -0.005420968867838383, -0.010252278298139572, 0.03174837306141853, -0.02270354889333248, 0.03511684015393257, 0.00971398875117302, 0.0429922491312027, -0.026493001729249954, -0.02605658955872059, 0.029567407444119453, -0.049039337784051895, 0.020484020933508873, -0.029532872140407562, 0.007533118594437838, 0.007936992682516575, 0.0095101622864604, -0.003177239326760173, 0.03743133321404457, 0.04010463505983353, -0.004361172206699848, 0.010146966204047203, 0.05001850053668022, 0.021912692114710808, -0.015267161652445793, 0.02058178000152111, -0.03325168415904045, 0.007409205194562674, 0.052930355072021484, 0.007186888251453638, -0.010320290923118591, 0.041319429874420166, 0.047832611948251724, 0.04573050141334534, -0.004923616535961628, -0.024429703131318092, 0.0201346967369318, -0.06741601973772049, 0.006255303509533405, -0.05111059173941612, 0.029881007969379425, -0.010471920482814312, 0.04576275125145912, 0.012320155277848244, -0.022737188264727592, -0.016175121068954468, 0.01713644713163376, -0.04086729511618614, 0.0004916030447930098, -0.03428046777844429, 0.04163544997572899, 0.028084982186555862, 0.03193246200680733, 0.005521356128156185, -0.020019138231873512, 0.0031214156188070774, 0.015251110307872295, 0.01566377468407154, -0.011666704900562763, 0.016117004677653313, -0.03992898762226105, 0.044030338525772095, -0.04190566763281822, 0.05271794646978378, 0.0339621976017952, -0.007662366610020399, 0.03640242666006088, 0.04891149327158928, -0.01710670255124569, 0.023282267153263092, -0.015308747999370098, 0.01690826565027237, -0.0028709410689771175, 0.06165223941206932, 0.0015676852781325579, -0.0006587356328964233, -0.028996452689170837, 0.030313007533550262, -0.020800955593585968, 0.026137521490454674, 0.04844793304800987, -0.025791184976696968, -0.03336501121520996, -0.02646883763372898, -0.011006013490259647, -0.060605261474847794, 0.03869783133268356, -0.010805067606270313, 0.03737185522913933, 0.05120464041829109, 0.057224903255701065, -0.046300046145915985, 0.019426722079515457, 0.08774516731500626, 0.03848506882786751, -0.02586561255156994, -0.0360545814037323, -0.02238576114177704, 0.026073848828673363, -0.010637874715030193, 0.004563167691230774, 0.011870290152728558, -0.011662164703011513, -0.02958337590098381, 0.04596075788140297, -0.04266870766878128, -0.03158889710903168, 0.07176841795444489, -0.035753581672906876, 0.02444843389093876, 0.013675808906555176, -0.04810277745127678, -0.0024333216715604067, 0.030866965651512146, 0.085671067237854, -0.005522002000361681, 0.020392421633005142, -0.068865567445755, -0.007524112239480019, 0.0592239648103714, 0.04534738510847092, -0.05747618526220322, 0.013944165781140327, -0.01647379994392395, 0.0030157368164509535, 0.005963904783129692, -0.051005829125642776, 0.01101108081638813, -0.011883714236319065, 0.0407416857779026, -0.025522075593471527, -0.013618474826216698, -0.02741975523531437, 0.022818487137556076, -0.011065014638006687, 0.02223450131714344, -0.010654700919985771, -0.008898284286260605, -0.04657686501741409, 0.024084975942969322, 0.044471632689237595, 0.026202740147709846, -0.03351723402738571, -0.02682609297335148, 0.0012183396611362696, 0.03687585890293121, 0.0030369809828698635, -0.0860268846154213, 0.008094069547951221, 0.01658307947218418, -0.01003938727080822, 0.06145564466714859, -0.005294712260365486, -0.055947672575712204, 0.011537793092429638, -0.001002419157885015, 0.01723768189549446, 0.0022049101535230875, -0.051409900188446045, 0.04355725273489952, 0.015416460111737251, -0.008391995914280415, 0.07025846838951111, 0.043715935200452805, -0.0041915918700397015, -0.007369894068688154, -0.006210201419889927, 0.020096441730856895, -0.053845178335905075, 0.007230367511510849, -0.036680083721876144, -0.0029185637831687927, -0.03471985459327698, 0.010257158428430557, -0.021737931296229362, 0.0152064748108387, -0.02472912147641182, -0.0050684064626693726, -0.0029983005952090025, 0.023121565580368042, -0.03908435255289078, 0.0018144948408007622, 0.030604250729084015, 0.031297486275434494, -0.03372417762875557, -0.03320536017417908, -0.010736721567809582, -0.015127453953027725, -0.022074736654758453, -0.0013243925059214234, 0.006167619489133358, -0.003587698098272085, -0.05115479230880737, -0.028650812804698944, -0.041547030210494995, -0.034370213747024536, 0.05094471573829651, -0.012615986168384552, 0.02716904506087303, -0.003040664130821824, -0.024615028873085976, 0.0185397956520319, 0.0456673800945282, 0.014720858074724674, 0.02626977674663067, -0.03550839424133301, 0.02115992270410061, -0.016337037086486816, -0.023847386240959167, -0.08695283532142639, -0.046558674424886703, 0.01188218779861927, 0.032506681978702545, -0.01613461598753929, -0.027465298771858215, -0.019092202186584473, -0.02829151414334774, 0.01907298155128956, -0.016194947063922882, 0.03486551344394684, -0.029443709179759026, -0.010555966757237911, -0.003896513720974326, 0.031684987246990204, 0.0664607509970665, -0.044001903384923935, -0.020901290699839592, 0.028225192800164223, -0.00397269893437624, -0.011593407951295376, -0.01669444516301155, -0.03675016015768051, -0.02421150729060173, -0.017324281856417656, -0.03598150238394737, 0.016140837222337723, 0.060503873974084854, -0.05376299098134041, -0.028462743386626244, -0.04540284723043442, -0.05008809641003609, -0.020215976983308792, -0.007948385551571846, 0.011625860817730427, -0.008814996108412743, 0.02771867625415325, -0.00962998066097498, 0.010278994217514992, -0.041115764528512955, -0.01776406355202198, 0.02026289515197277, 0.0012527800863608718, -0.007013298571109772, 0.04320954531431198, 0.05162082239985466, -0.01456335186958313, -0.01104270201176405, -0.0013569240691140294, -0.014075024984776974, 0.038942765444517136, 0.014188875444233418, 0.01321608666330576, 0.008989928290247917, 0.019298130646348, -0.022322632372379303, -0.05315718799829483, -0.013216674327850342, -0.006006644573062658, 0.03965214639902115, -0.021769817918539047, 0.04359554126858711, 0.03743049129843712, 0.015407373197376728, -0.03992338106036186, -0.020720742642879486, 0.05213816091418266, 0.011637259274721146, 0.009779877960681915, 0.0515737421810627, -0.025844573974609375, -0.005241082049906254, 0.005784456618130207, 0.04116931930184364, 0.010188965126872063, 0.006126637104898691, 0.03098512813448906, 0.06341177225112915, 0.0014548093313351274, -0.007721495348960161, -0.013294072821736336, -0.004251811653375626, -0.03280854597687721, 0.0007813921547494829, 0.025540778413414955, -0.043831951916217804, 0.009484553709626198, 0.06810081750154495, 0.019901877269148827, -0.04174848645925522, -0.060700491070747375, -0.013493146747350693, 0.016921402886509895, 0.025538861751556396, 0.017398381605744362, -0.007418968249112368, -0.00436686584725976, 0.031444862484931946, 0.013659280724823475, 0.007589817978441715, 0.0009207724360749125, -0.07083724439144135, -0.04961360618472099, -0.012359009124338627, -0.032422080636024475, 0.006450224667787552, -0.012700589373707771, -0.021532300859689713, 0.04325685650110245, -0.02079819329082966, 0.007321895565837622, -0.03057168424129486, 0.04035761207342148, -0.020666101947426796, 0.04128267988562584, 0.0020310559775680304, 0.021896377205848694, 0.004175327718257904, -0.004889737814664841, 0.12849709391593933, 0.09083662927150726, 0.04509246349334717, -0.05778194218873978, 0.016150804236531258, 0.010809765197336674, 0.00039285479579120874, -0.05640709027647972, 0.034483786672353745, 0.010672460310161114, 0.05450946465134621, 0.0028358432464301586, 0.06349265575408936, 0.044206585735082626, -0.04653903841972351, 0.04662799835205078, -0.018579207360744476, -0.02606579102575779, -0.007250695489346981, 0.012233374640345573, -0.0027053982485085726, -0.015354142524302006, -0.027761323377490044, 0.018930228427052498, 0.002754365326836705, -0.020602146163582802, 0.000674906128551811, -0.016981860622763634, -0.015292134135961533, -0.05025662109255791, 0.010284190066158772, 0.008891450241208076, -0.007318813819438219, -0.0006415063398890197, -0.019208921119570732, -0.02551184594631195, 0.033937226980924606, -0.0033186697401106358, 0.00946842972189188, -0.0035706579219549894, -0.014952871017158031, -0.00451170327141881, 0.010331797413527966, 0.00021962399478070438, -0.03166959434747696, -0.02623472549021244, -0.03130774199962616, -0.010047913528978825, -0.011784368194639683, -0.01657848060131073, -0.008996492251753807, -0.0016327413031831384, 0.0018803521525114775, -0.056299153715372086, -0.03249610587954521, 0.03135015070438385, -0.009116582572460175, 0.0005860204109922051, -0.03728796914219856, -0.0497049055993557, 0.016666674986481667, 0.02733784168958664, 0.04675397649407387, -0.009720913134515285, -0.0022310244385153055, 0.012659250758588314, -0.04168645665049553, 0.026201197877526283, -0.000447929953224957, 0.002271895529702306, -0.0013890458503738046, 0.0062783258035779, -0.04305903613567352, -0.015627237036824226, 0.013942931778728962, -0.0004303518508095294, 0.04241415485739708, -0.005978355649858713, -0.012698493897914886, -0.05145980790257454, 0.016558807343244553, -0.05329793691635132, -0.019617591053247452, -0.03773651272058487, -0.029871515929698944, 0.009914782829582691, -0.0038264384493231773, 0.007902216166257858, -0.0016033079009503126, 0.01233061496168375, 0.0005770300631411374, 0.03750525042414665, 0.00995990913361311, -0.03502638265490532, -0.01229422353208065, 0.00040115820593200624, -0.024984916672110558, -0.0012897724518552423, -0.029823407530784607, 0.022291501984000206, 0.015278669074177742, 0.019002212211489677, -0.03890101984143257, 0.03967489302158356, 0.03038199059665203, 0.012347421608865261, 0.03585648164153099, -0.028928140178322792, 0.005144358146935701, 0.02920723520219326, -0.01488184928894043, -0.013990988954901695, -0.016608893871307373, -0.010972523130476475, -0.03760144114494324, 0.017467694357037544, 0.01915331557393074, -0.04279552772641182, 0.011638344265520573, -0.0248566884547472, 0.03810204192996025, -0.018849913030862808, -0.012851377949118614, -0.04746989905834198, 0.02901618368923664, 0.006976411212235689, -0.021175798028707504, 0.0019537261687219143, 0.003952549304813147, -0.018855344504117966, 0.002580985426902771, 0.04581312835216522, -0.011533725075423717, -0.006831896957010031, -0.03260581195354462, 0.03726812079548836, -0.009800988249480724, 0.04059149697422981, -0.0044298297725617886, -0.0004084400425199419, 0.00807054154574871, -0.02576029673218727, -0.031172269955277443, -0.007591466885060072, -0.03792111575603485, 0.02974805235862732, 0.009934656322002411, -0.023773478344082832, 0.007205250207334757, 0.044111113995313644, -0.02267543040215969, -0.007691319566220045, 0.0043034981936216354, 0.037914786487817764, -0.016153136268258095, -0.0197145976126194, 0.021068774163722992, -0.00498858280479908, 0.004364033695310354, 0.058067116886377335, 0.07185857743024826, -0.02283942513167858, -0.035539474338293076, -0.004180101677775383, -0.039617106318473816, -0.03395518288016319, -0.003095377003774047, -0.022346237674355507, 0.015576937235891819, 0.0368056520819664, 0.0001822840131353587, 0.03306799754500389, -0.005824794061481953, 0.036837831139564514, -0.07161451131105423, -0.014795755036175251, 0.002248741453513503, 0.0023398404009640217, 0.04443778842687607, -0.01592264696955681, 0.02324112504720688, 0.027567151933908463, -0.04827865958213806, 0.01383420079946518, 0.0059179640375077724, -0.01505047082901001, -0.020016252994537354, -0.0014969832263886929, 0.006278332322835922, -0.014129566960036755, 0.041691143065690994, 0.02722475491464138, -0.00808000098913908, -0.005210154689848423, -0.01837889850139618, -0.02831248939037323, 0.05380253121256828, 0.03763696178793907, -0.038359303027391434, -0.04358794912695885, 0.03642956167459488, -0.0023612137883901596, -0.052204523235559464, 0.011861251667141914, -0.0031562214717268944, -0.0006673175957985222, 0.05370992794632912, 0.04878683388233185, -0.000778723566327244, 0.007241780404001474, 0.032532405108213425, -0.024982556700706482, 0.005085845477879047, 0.015867311507463455, -0.011995167471468449, 0.030041281133890152, -0.04659849405288696, 0.03616714105010033, 0.015227393247187138, 0.02641226164996624, -0.006673953961580992, 0.005300131626427174, -0.07614222913980484, 0.0025955878663808107, -0.031884241849184036, -0.019657228142023087, -0.00538360932841897, -0.04666682705283165, 0.024848362430930138, -0.03585183992981911, 0.002449899446219206, 0.041264597326517105, -0.0021506487391889095, 0.014148753136396408, -0.014755930751562119, 0.013858715072274208, -0.0591932088136673, 0.0068594166077673435, 0.01514425314962864, -0.00046736819786019623, -0.06108454614877701, -0.016959941014647484, 0.004613016732037067, -0.044736944139003754, -0.03979785740375519, 0.0012113201664760709, -0.04976804554462433, 0.05212896317243576, -0.0287714172154665, 0.009000799618661404, 0.0015356065705418587, -0.03482357785105705, 0.018460195511579514, -0.08076874911785126, 0.020766977220773697, -0.01572784036397934, -0.003631928702816367, -0.025425031781196594, 0.006016141269356012, -0.016049770638346672, 0.0004849220858886838, 0.028684884309768677, -0.0065497737377882, 0.02160356566309929, -0.025723153725266457, 0.028186626732349396, -0.015880635008215904, -0.03744548559188843, 0.06788027286529541, 0.02485986426472664, 0.00378953805193305, -0.01362242829054594, -0.02087041735649109, 0.02622644416987896, -0.030216669663786888, -0.020806055516004562, -0.0026945078279823065, 0.01468246802687645, 0.014355702325701714, -0.00862883497029543, 0.019123945385217667, -0.010317880660295486, 0.01987234316766262, 0.02454700693488121, 0.007160324137657881, 0.0031206244602799416, 0.053736612200737, -0.011715526692569256, -0.038985878229141235, 0.05976773798465729, -0.022143231704831123, -0.02257465571165085, 0.042871471494436264, 0.05482248589396477, 0.028791911900043488, -0.06356653571128845, 0.0017303450731560588, 0.03346678242087364, -0.07500232011079788, -0.005908755119889975, 0.032447006553411484, 0.025132419541478157, 0.01418802235275507, 0.007647425401955843, 0.0270482636988163, 0.052139513194561005, -0.0311425793915987, 0.03927215188741684, 0.030441569164395332, 0.04078523814678192, 0.03051411733031273, 0.03632340580224991, 0.011033672839403152, 0.0018150079995393753, 0.00901276059448719, -0.001805508160032332, 0.04636729881167412, -0.023260490968823433, -0.014653218910098076, 0.02952706441283226, 0.02545277588069439, 0.0189967043697834, -0.034696314483881, 0.009853202849626541, 0.050995439291000366, -0.031091952696442604, -0.002574729500338435, -0.04686904698610306, -0.005086734890937805, -0.016123319044709206, -0.0007889581611379981, 0.01959586888551712, 0.04171536862850189, 0.02010929398238659, -0.027130067348480225, -0.05046069249510765, -0.02635670267045498, -0.016386039555072784, 0.0034934822469949722, 0.030704116448760033, 0.008163348771631718, 0.01711921952664852, -0.011033767834305763, -0.03272179141640663, -0.06477167457342148, -0.025439845398068428, 0.0022794653195887804, 0.015719683840870857, 0.026290416717529297, -0.04536614567041397, -0.0013319377321749926, 0.01370746549218893, 0.053449977189302444, -0.023275019600987434, -0.041891876608133316, -0.033710259944200516, 0.019902311265468597, 0.005252309609204531, 0.041412513703107834 ]
<p>I am looking to do a linear regression on two independent variables that will be present in varying proportions.</p> <p>For example trying to do a linear regression on $Y$ which is payment behavior (payback rate) of customers based on the the quality (let's say Gini coefficient) of the new and existing customer credit scores ($X_1$ and $X_2$, respectively) adjusted for the proportion of new and existing customers in the sample.</p> <p>Existing customers will be present in proportion $p$ and new customers in proportion $1-p = q$.</p> <p>$Y$, payback rate is the percentage of total customers who pay back. It could be expressed as the weighted average $Y = Y_1q + Y_2p$ where $Y_i$ is the payback rate of new/existing customers.</p> <p>In general more new customers, $q$, has a negative effect. Better scoring ($X_1, X_2$) and more existing customers p have a positive effect.</p> <p>What is a good way to model this? </p> <p>Would something like the following be a good solution trying to use $p$ and $q$ as some sort of interaction effect? </p> <p>$Y = X_1+X_2+\frac{X_1}{q}+X_2 p$</p> <p>Would it be better to include p and q as variables themselves as well?</p>
37,266
[ 0.013999124057590961, 0.01855509541928768, 0.0268674548715353, 0.013742615468800068, 0.027979129925370216, 0.011912385933101177, -0.007331364788115025, -0.024660224094986916, 0.03179877996444702, 0.002374021802097559, 0.03154557943344116, 0.018821414560079575, 0.06691422313451767, -0.0018874752568081021, 0.027595920488238335, 0.02327140048146248, -0.012796769849956036, -0.0026481114327907562, -0.007372954860329628, 0.009589280933141708, -0.02191067673265934, 0.005432875826954842, 0.013125871308147907, -0.017064230516552925, -0.03405885770916939, 0.04497763514518738, 0.008396102115511894, -0.0295596681535244, 0.0006063136970624328, 0.049229707568883896, 0.045169465243816376, -0.024436267092823982, 0.011691072024405003, 0.04796059429645538, 0.02683953568339348, 0.009430580772459507, -0.04059932380914688, -0.018292084336280823, 0.03037993051111698, 0.025058679282665253, -0.06359114497900009, -0.014347769320011139, 0.031222689896821976, -0.01784307137131691, 0.0031347775366157293, 0.036585453897714615, 0.027591176331043243, -0.05813554674386978, 0.020512068644165993, -0.03681261092424393, 0.07197548449039459, 0.015386510640382767, 0.043196916580200195, 0.024834759533405304, -0.007250432390719652, -0.01222627516835928, 0.04666297882795334, 0.07219269871711731, -0.0009752899641171098, -0.04194129258394241, 0.005927278194576502, 0.008831546641886234, -0.008068935945630074, -0.017559299245476723, -0.05932540073990822, 0.02056204155087471, -0.01849798858165741, -0.0162742231041193, 0.02496754191815853, -0.030243897810578346, 0.014131111092865467, 0.04705221951007843, 0.025950219482183456, 0.00023900408996269107, -0.018623914569616318, -0.02341843582689762, -0.002522879047319293, 0.03918331116437912, 0.022918041795492172, -0.015047501772642136, 0.014161641709506512, -0.0054372986778616905, 0.020180825144052505, 0.039961375296115875, 0.005835105665028095, -0.008115398697555065, 0.07809677720069885, -0.04571646451950073, 0.03784938529133797, 0.028683336451649666, -0.021972892805933952, 0.00034740613773465157, 0.052541427314281464, 0.02560233324766159, -0.03616518899798393, 0.021980328485369682, -0.024470597505569458, 0.033433347940444946, 0.03679093345999718, 0.021670222282409668, -0.025614790618419647, -0.04698401689529419, -0.0357670858502388, 0.049699533730745316, -0.016590455546975136, -0.0626027062535286, -0.005298913922160864, 0.0059278360567986965, 0.00492246774956584, -0.03603798896074295, -0.027893833816051483, 0.02750544622540474, -0.006341105792671442, -0.02632160484790802, 0.02179703675210476, -0.04433178901672363, -0.0167952012270689, -0.02916726842522621, 0.0456698052585125, 0.058990154415369034, 0.032181136310100555, -0.056022241711616516, 0.017415670678019524, 0.01715574413537979, -0.0032101294491440058, 0.013137536123394966, 0.018521660938858986, -0.030352076515555382, -0.041770245879888535, 0.03599057346582413, -0.014382099732756615, -0.02482517436146736, 0.015321697108447552, 0.019807210192084312, 0.004925725981593132, 0.021159449592232704, -0.054166652262210846, -0.019512970000505447, 0.028464803472161293, -0.03535066172480583, 0.035266607999801636, -0.04291863739490509, -0.010434647090733051, 0.06173728406429291, 0.09711036831140518, 0.012578283436596394, 0.009542535059154034, 0.024822860956192017, 0.02799464948475361, 0.029551343992352486, -0.013316788710653782, -0.047956112772226334, -0.038968320935964584, -0.03813391551375389, 0.005846035201102495, -0.07386484742164612, 0.004589473828673363, 0.0401303693652153, -0.023556534200906754, -0.0017528466414660215, 0.04585615172982216, 0.028863269835710526, -0.022571472451090813, 0.02885339967906475, 0.013609114103019238, 0.0006266973214223981, 0.07688416540622711, -0.0115895327180624, 0.036730408668518066, -0.002550147008150816, 0.0035108630545437336, -0.005888420157134533, 0.021756859496235847, 0.04097232595086098, 0.04377248138189316, -0.0008399156504310668, -0.013969487510621548, -0.010409937240183353, -0.0018853199435397983, 0.02250720001757145, -0.07538214325904846, -0.06127990037202835, -0.04747655987739563, -0.008536091074347496, 0.004945230204612017, 0.030343178659677505, -0.003659025300294161, -0.03900826722383499, 0.03296876698732376, -0.010890724137425423, -0.0497710295021534, -0.07050590217113495, -0.0020383656956255436, -0.0017550046322867274, -0.03523026034235954, 0.022860631346702576, 0.015868889167904854, 0.002610566560178995, 0.008493028581142426, -0.02842371165752411, -0.015699373558163643, -0.0007217788370326161, 0.02004033885896206, -0.03208218142390251, 0.014791433699429035, 0.029562614858150482, 0.028301607817411423, -0.01841418258845806, 0.03474394604563713, -0.07901831716299057, -0.045316364616155624, 0.026209061965346336, -0.031326889991760254, 0.025922192260622978, -0.04270363599061966, -0.017200954258441925, -0.006077028810977936, -0.021804526448249817, -0.010765483602881432, 0.01054692268371582, -0.059500355273485184, 0.07066230475902557, 0.10719797760248184, 0.013459756039083004, 0.0006831256323494017, -0.01362709328532219, 0.010971798561513424, 0.03155505657196045, -0.040353547781705856, -0.022135188803076744, -0.0585334412753582, 0.024246471002697945, 0.025130486115813255, 0.013679323717951775, -0.047652363777160645, 0.007056760136038065, 0.08558961749076843, 0.018374385312199593, -0.016332043334841728, 0.03053390048444271, -0.005127264186739922, -0.011351397261023521, 0.01991480216383934, -0.00806905422359705, 0.021804025396704674, -0.010466431267559528, 0.010496721602976322, -0.0030198264867067337, 0.025738468393683434, 0.00733174430206418, 0.015865936875343323, 0.020941784605383873, 0.019983643665909767, 0.03993803262710571, -0.0055222581140697, -0.03570954501628876, 0.04242965951561928, -0.005296061281114817, 0.020884042605757713, 0.026477644219994545, -0.013565543107688427, -0.011907227337360382, 0.00641974713653326, 0.0043261488899588585, -0.006138915196061134, 0.0136864697560668, -0.06254111975431442, 0.019515810534358025, 0.01190470065921545, -0.04547322541475296, 0.007832030765712261, -0.0019878107123076916, -0.03331891819834709, -0.05185608193278313, -0.011024932377040386, 0.04293818026781082, 0.017672106623649597, 0.029774604365229607, -0.023829281330108643, -0.01779296062886715, 0.0043877484276890755, -0.010465787723660469, -0.006078577134758234, 0.004515001084655523, -0.06911042332649231, 0.003480404382571578, -0.037419393658638, 0.0026815736200660467, 0.01619831472635269, -0.012169699184596539, -0.003072756342589855, -0.0015923075843602419, -0.030635321512818336, -0.04677807539701462, -0.03040621429681778, -0.04817115515470505, 0.019465534016489983, 0.010519318282604218, -0.06019612401723862, 0.03757671266794205, 0.029808491468429565, -0.041054677218198776, 0.011271145194768906, -0.037189047783613205, -0.0025916979648172855, -0.02393871732056141, -0.007065261714160442, 0.0056575289927423, 0.02100488729774952, -0.006950788665562868, 0.04638431966304779, -0.009506762027740479, -0.01515420712530613, -0.09639779478311539, -0.07523451000452042, 0.04059584438800812, 0.00017960587865673006, 0.030957164242863655, 0.006733804475516081, -0.01800723187625408, 0.04813923314213753, 0.02351452223956585, 0.001055183238349855, -0.03147673234343529, -0.00012767358566634357, -0.027810821309685707, -0.019345134496688843, 0.020601827651262283, 0.022803623229265213, -0.016315724700689316, 0.03040909767150879, 0.012399635277688503, 0.01948574371635914, 0.03114437498152256, 0.0029177702963352203, -0.002843326423317194, 0.026275180280208588, 0.00044436033931560814, 0.006742142606526613, 0.028998341411352158, 0.03225095942616463, -0.029349757358431816, 0.012903670780360699, 0.004856358747929335, 0.03491361811757088, 0.01724075898528099, -0.030305886641144753, 0.0038087163120508194, -0.0009152485872618854, -0.023192869499325752, -0.013913644477725029, 0.031054062768816948, -0.010916891507804394, -0.020122041925787926, -0.02065088599920273, -0.007223376072943211, 0.02831636555492878, -0.010707970708608627, 0.01798180304467678, 0.04406983405351639, 0.03897819295525551, 0.02182023786008358, -0.00492577301338315, 0.0015376736409962177, -0.019938595592975616, 0.01791071705520153, -0.0421198308467865, 0.016634101048111916, 0.029268663376569748, 0.015638886019587517, 0.001075233332812786, -0.0023736809380352497, -0.02110058069229126, -0.002172261942178011, -0.10252436250448227, 0.0027660238556563854, -0.0155279990285635, 0.0617680698633194, 0.02672751434147358, 0.041562385857105255, -0.0022221612744033337, -0.058192815631628036, 0.036534205079078674, -0.010552150197327137, -0.08826636523008347, 0.04192508012056351, 0.0061873397789895535, 0.009474337100982666, -0.0018234484596177936, -0.02590283192694187, 0.030863303691148758, -0.046228837221860886, 0.008928364142775536, -0.0035092299804091454, -0.015080825425684452, -0.014440606348216534, -0.011605583131313324, -0.046172451227903366, -0.02868112362921238, 0.023287836462259293, 0.012352420948445797, 0.005435319151729345, -0.02709394507110119, -0.0022521803621202707, 0.04951842501759529, 0.011498047038912773, -0.02154543250799179, -0.024052606895565987, 0.012527788057923317, 0.06107782945036888, 0.042107392102479935, 0.01991448551416397, 0.020748954266309738, -0.026799198240041733, 0.04168887063860893, 0.005550418049097061, 0.02752770110964775, 0.04132101684808731, -0.01478780247271061, -0.02235746569931507, -0.016790583729743958, -0.017664816230535507, -0.01782243140041828, 0.013997472822666168, -0.0031551988795399666, -0.0013511929428204894, 0.05340759828686714, 0.037841226905584335, -0.042003732174634933, 0.012019263580441475, 0.07833626866340637, 0.012349754571914673, -0.009091607294976711, -0.0314180962741375, 0.018874917179346085, -0.0016175581840798259, -0.02357291802763939, 0.016861580312252045, 0.013612933456897736, 0.006245596334338188, -0.0018662142101675272, 0.027285976335406303, 0.008047949522733688, -0.01185417827218771, 0.026148315519094467, 0.018347010016441345, 0.03900935873389244, 0.01127450168132782, -0.08917193114757538, 0.009994390420615673, 0.03682466596364975, 0.021578460931777954, 0.024861572310328484, 0.0018108808435499668, -0.09456457942724228, 0.027620499953627586, 0.03890417888760567, 0.059077486395835876, -0.053189706057310104, -0.03188154101371765, -0.04167643561959267, -0.017458055168390274, 0.023123133927583694, -0.0219294261187315, 0.0200033038854599, 0.00851269531995058, -0.03028833121061325, -0.007480021566152573, -0.04294135048985481, -0.06102456897497177, 0.04202182590961456, -0.03001905232667923, 0.0074567776173353195, -0.015525140799582005, -0.03399606794118881, -0.02191329561173916, 0.03126998618245125, 0.030234167352318764, 0.05963874235749245, -0.03972656652331352, -0.03497113659977913, 0.00517226243391633, 0.03344421461224556, -0.001813687733374536, -0.06502557545900345, 0.036032188683748245, -0.00011634000111371279, -0.02888936921954155, 0.022664731368422508, -0.002728608436882496, -0.029036950320005417, 0.011539227329194546, 0.02161043882369995, 0.0030237340833991766, 0.003581557422876358, -0.0034901686012744904, 0.05401819944381714, 0.04305822402238846, 0.026341544464230537, 0.07130532711744308, 0.04150047525763512, -0.023579290136694908, -0.009852582588791847, -0.0031044178176671267, -0.0055170790292322636, -0.005327974446117878, -0.028104079887270927, -0.053911689668893814, 0.005200025159865618, -0.006091717630624771, 0.04478646442294121, 0.0035098050720989704, 0.032484956085681915, -0.08065304905176163, -0.011770669370889664, -0.013356923125684261, 0.023274283856153488, 0.006022776011377573, -0.01852431893348694, -0.026953300461173058, -0.00908793043345213, -0.009638573974370956, -0.011309206485748291, 0.03414563834667206, -0.02600489929318428, 0.003042645286768675, -0.010971056297421455, -0.012602563947439194, 0.01837671548128128, -0.0029429541900753975, -0.02956549823284149, -0.029837461188435555, 0.009152756072580814, 0.03663197532296181, -0.0009753177873790264, 0.03980955481529236, -0.006078616250306368, -0.01719845086336136, 0.005934399552643299, 0.042911384254693985, 0.010147280059754848, 0.0035870950669050217, -0.04502102732658386, 0.05689262971282005, -0.018539955839514732, -0.024609806016087532, -0.061926789581775665, -0.062271684408187866, 0.025263125076889992, -0.031270772218704224, 0.008531070314347744, -0.03469490632414818, 0.012111595831811428, -0.014537951909005642, -0.0206683948636055, -0.008650640957057476, 0.02864581160247326, -0.022736622020602226, -0.019611625000834465, -0.015010276809334755, 0.03138529136776924, 0.030507294461131096, 0.0032590075861662626, 0.017548818141222, 0.001639125170186162, -0.013332927599549294, 0.005099652335047722, -0.021662814542651176, -0.018927643075585365, -0.04627897962927818, -0.005569258704781532, -0.06283406913280487, -0.020236317068338394, 0.047547321766614914, -0.017058078199625015, -0.03605658560991287, 0.0004013850702904165, 0.027139445766806602, 0.007869654335081577, -0.02243015356361866, -0.01541756372898817, 0.009050301276147366, -0.015047312714159489, -0.008162456564605236, 0.0049419105052948, -0.003897076705470681, 0.014499302953481674, 0.03304724767804146, 0.0427672453224659, -0.07058419287204742, 0.00047049493878148496, 0.08818838000297546, 0.00022583147801924497, 0.0015476401895284653, 0.012675073929131031, -0.018995119258761406, 0.07782695442438126, 0.003943052142858505, -0.02850656770169735, 0.014056445099413395, 0.037322405725717545, -0.009719526395201683, -0.02676623873412609, -0.03351226821541786, -0.012006154283881187, 0.05635235086083412, -0.049353718757629395, 0.0386020801961422, 0.06514926254749298, 0.0037833014503121376, -0.021139875054359436, -0.007537313736975193, -0.011659936979413033, -0.010545730590820312, -0.03663979843258858, 0.05202560871839523, -0.02008933760225773, -0.03420371189713478, 0.04538152739405632, 0.019746573641896248, 0.011549496091902256, 0.020993227139115334, 0.0010493373265489936, 0.011693194508552551, 0.01468785759061575, -0.038755036890506744, -0.043995488435029984, 0.01428536232560873, -0.06235073506832123, -0.004809205885976553, -0.06508791446685791, -0.04479892551898956, 0.05786819010972977, 0.04590597748756409, -0.01037439052015543, -0.05135144293308258, -0.021398119628429413, -0.04339456930756569, -0.0031468519009649754, 0.01186335738748312, 0.010154171846807003, 0.06451553851366043, 0.005691469646990299, 0.0376691035926342, 0.0017727402737364173, 0.03976082056760788, -0.017200235277414322, -0.09854370355606079, -0.025394871830940247, -0.023467199876904488, 0.000491200597025454, 0.012820611707866192, -0.0007843615021556616, -0.020577318966388702, 0.03989244997501373, -0.028016148135066032, -0.0007775463163852692, 0.004497462883591652, 0.02072654478251934, -0.01910969614982605, 0.054918769747018814, -0.004203145857900381, -0.011048092506825924, -0.01410709135234356, -0.011519341729581356, 0.10711431503295898, 0.06841275095939636, 0.0234220027923584, -0.04164232686161995, 0.053510747849941254, -0.007238033227622509, -0.003887036582455039, -0.007183105684816837, 0.00048469187458977103, 0.011740445159375668, -0.0117228664457798, 0.05882158875465393, 0.0490182563662529, 0.006903808563947678, -0.022844431921839714, 0.05107862874865532, -0.04145852103829384, -0.007560459431260824, 0.029725724831223488, -0.009841018356382847, -0.008516848087310791, 0.021175185218453407, -0.05298709496855736, -0.011440976522862911, 0.00892553385347128, -0.018612561747431755, -0.006183157674968243, -0.010334260761737823, -0.01516743190586567, 0.04557060822844505, -0.003728433046489954, 0.026610059663653374, 0.020055027678608894, 0.021470429375767708, 0.016202326864004135, 0.002300060587003827, 0.014652763493359089, -0.06731845438480377, 0.010840856470167637, 0.01950124464929104, -0.012416326440870762, -0.023339124396443367, 0.021241482347249985, 0.031530991196632385, -0.07705862075090408, -0.01515023224055767, -0.047716736793518066, 0.029918629676103592, 0.016369374468922615, -0.00017622605082578957, -0.018695207312703133, 0.03129573538899422, 0.018093997612595558, -0.01564933732151985, -0.031900469213724136, 0.06505283713340759, 0.02880372852087021, -0.01501605287194252, 0.04352802410721779, -0.006078981328755617, 0.02252131700515747, 0.010549349710345268, 0.014364114962518215, 0.06820747256278992, -0.04925946146249771, -0.014385293237864971, -0.0016939420020207763, 0.03483685106039047, -0.008929025381803513, -0.0005787251284345984, -0.013579144142568111, -0.02624933421611786, -0.024021772667765617, -0.016998689621686935, -0.02870945632457733, 0.011948256753385067, 0.01720229536294937, -0.027249926701188087, 0.006089980248361826, -0.04003959149122238, -0.01914536952972412, 0.04158668592572212, 0.005576936062425375, 0.026305116713047028, -0.06755486130714417, -0.009737325832247734, -0.0005157940904609859, 0.016455277800559998, -0.015021348372101784, -0.008627297356724739, 0.016801832243800163, 0.06357112526893616, 0.013708681799471378, -0.017894458025693893, -0.0003086424258071929, -0.017727850005030632, -0.0442899726331234, -0.00904992874711752, -0.0021531591191887856, 0.06196203455328941, -0.003836409654468298, 0.016831791028380394, -0.008898265659809113, 0.0023037116043269634, -0.028920162469148636, 0.0349263995885849, 0.04578027129173279, -0.06525420397520065, 0.002822027076035738, 0.005424519535154104, 0.05003393441438675, -0.007039680611342192, 0.015622827224433422, 0.023145323619246483, -0.03401500731706619, 0.001302789431065321, -0.02688506245613098, -0.030906619504094124, -0.00664037698879838, -0.02010609395802021, 0.004199613817036152, -0.028150498867034912, -0.003690333105623722, -0.05146601423621178, 0.003829791909083724, 0.013989920727908611, -0.012378756888210773, 0.015258134342730045, 0.006212353240698576, -0.022574396803975105, 0.009741408750414848, 0.037633493542671204, 0.02774926647543907, 0.029251672327518463, -0.019339723512530327, 0.014771286398172379, -0.009783192537724972, 0.02976922318339348, -0.054250568151474, -0.030322222039103508, 0.0316288135945797, -0.04010332003235817, -0.0275262538343668, -0.021727697923779488, 0.020508132874965668, 0.05801794305443764, 0.0287261214107275, 0.017973676323890686, -0.043414413928985596, 0.02398017607629299, 0.009073467925190926, -0.021669404581189156, -0.002601616783067584, 0.0080361757427454, -0.01876281574368477, -0.045624732971191406, -0.0002719555632211268, 0.01823178119957447, -0.011764343827962875, 0.017083749175071716, 0.04604758322238922, -0.018977953121066093, 0.0005342675722204149, 0.0005974539672024548, 0.006296694278717041, 0.00452039297670126, 0.005263184662908316, -0.012658637948334217, 0.05960133299231529, 0.003505115397274494, -0.03545418754220009, 0.006178316194564104, -0.016814181581139565, 0.007737304549664259, -0.06149863079190254, -0.03012392856180668, 0.02969503402709961, 0.005684322211891413, -0.0033544094767421484, -0.03847435861825943, 0.017327118664979935, 0.003622612217441201, -0.029384849593043327, 0.026704147458076477, 0.007468753028661013, 0.014835232868790627, -0.0223494041711092, 0.03736256808042526, -0.01919085718691349, -0.0016968145500868559, 0.03789285197854042, 0.03792369365692139, 0.043750032782554626, 0.027080712839961052, 0.045100659132003784, -0.000985876889899373, -0.01998952031135559, -0.028811849653720856, -0.013441265560686588, -0.06122170016169548, 0.020133156329393387, -0.021820953115820885, -0.014031938277184963, 0.04740073159337044, -0.015109267085790634, 0.047228727489709854, 0.013891174457967281, 0.026199953630566597, 0.007311810273677111, 0.019419444724917412, 0.04565490409731865, 0.005010280758142471, 0.013255211524665356, -0.021943189203739166, 0.03701050207018852, 0.007271622773259878, 0.003373919054865837, 0.0017550578340888023, 0.06075769290328026, 0.022060668095946312, -0.014488997869193554, -0.031040750443935394, -0.009646744467318058, -0.008851997554302216, -0.009675866924226284, 0.022106442600488663, 0.028729883953928947, -0.03280285373330116, 0.01596233807504177, -0.040059760212898254, -0.010375317186117172, 0.02289658971130848, 0.012993873097002506, -0.020500533282756805, 0.002103372709825635, -0.008768914267420769, -0.0414552241563797, -0.007253879681229591, -0.014803248457610607, 0.03585832566022873, -0.071061871945858, -0.015373991802334785, -0.0024089564103633165, -0.023809382691979408, -0.0435330867767334, -0.025966644287109375, -0.04093055799603462, 0.05609564855694771, -0.04378848150372505, 0.014471523463726044, 0.018268249928951263, -0.017100824043154716, 0.030663656070828438, -0.07251277565956116, 0.0749400183558464, 0.026827750727534294, -0.022799989208579063, 0.007117392495274544, -0.0012285028351470828, -0.056035276502370834, -0.00926611851900816, 0.08900263905525208, 0.006627936381846666, 0.004265269730240107, -0.011270076036453247, 0.012074357829988003, 0.04001631960272789, 0.006331982556730509, 0.028182292357087135, -0.014517034403979778, 0.0011063017882406712, -0.005016641691327095, 0.010586829856038094, 0.019748885184526443, 0.00769068906083703, 0.01980574242770672, -0.012839068658649921, 0.029416222125291824, -0.005734293721616268, -0.021203549578785896, 0.013333497568964958, -0.013132859952747822, -0.020292751491069794, 0.044792622327804565, 0.0009114625281654298, 0.042760130017995834, 0.028785161674022675, -0.0404413640499115, -0.09772012382745743, 0.024824703112244606, -0.04900443181395531, -0.02741752192378044, -0.00917307659983635, 0.003494699252769351, -0.03431236743927002, -0.06292001157999039, 0.008873797953128815, 0.025973370298743248, -0.04794233292341232, -0.018403327092528343, 0.012938273139297962, 0.013360329903662205, 0.03306860849261284, -0.016658637672662735, 0.031209830194711685, -0.017107680439949036, -0.024424612522125244, 0.009379248134791851, 0.0030432885978370905, 0.013655304908752441, 0.03647955507040024, 0.036160361021757126, 0.05158568546175957, 0.014320805668830872, 0.0035363833885639906, -0.011485687457025051, 0.001684611546806991, -0.02908550389111042, 0.004427785985171795, 0.03599242866039276, -0.003688546596094966, 0.03455477952957153, 0.017370283603668213, 0.006052710115909576, 0.049888789653778076, -0.04521489515900612, 0.01794872060418129, -0.03432724252343178, -0.01230014767497778, -0.008882821537554264, -0.0353204682469368, -0.028145041316747665, 0.03902088478207588, 0.02243845723569393, -0.02047809213399887, -0.00100595538970083, -0.03811036795377731, 0.01995769701898098, 0.005993615370243788, 0.013258885592222214, -0.02435588277876377, -0.009112082421779633, -0.008555038832128048, -0.029623793438076973, -0.01208246685564518, -0.0502818338572979, 0.059626273810863495, 0.06891332566738129, 0.030055753886699677, -0.01554953958839178, -0.041591938585042953, 0.019354820251464844, 0.057201653718948364, -0.052057184278964996, -0.020758027210831642, -0.027048785239458084, -0.009545037522912025, 0.017644811421632767, -0.024263842031359673 ]
<p>I am trying to implement the ID3 algorithm on a data set. However, all attributes are continuous and can have values between 1-10. I found that we have to specify the bin intervals for discretization but couldn't understand how to do this exactly. </p> <p>Can some one explain on how to do this? The <a href="http://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/machine-learning-databases/breast-cancer-wisconsin/breast-cancer-wisconsin.data" rel="nofollow">data set</a> I am using is Breast Cancer Data from Wisconsin hospitals.</p>
74,397
[ -0.03257422149181366, -0.05207079276442528, -0.0010201954282820225, 0.004232586827129126, 0.023060260340571404, -0.012460313737392426, -0.05294585973024368, -0.004463121294975281, 0.06451329588890076, -0.00931758712977171, 0.07009202241897583, 0.006471474654972553, 0.030453843995928764, 0.016907475888729095, 0.02414136566221714, -0.0017516902880743146, 0.02226427011191845, -0.012296841479837894, -0.009834112599492073, -0.020012689754366875, 0.021566813811659813, 0.016042478382587433, 0.012920267879962921, -0.01691434346139431, -0.042849987745285034, 0.029483571648597717, 0.019836653023958206, -0.023598860949277878, 0.02077500894665718, 0.05268608406186104, -0.05930662155151367, -0.05131334066390991, 0.03629715368151665, 0.03741323947906494, 0.005945210810750723, 0.013978520408272743, -0.033558789640665054, -0.01774410530924797, -0.01304277777671814, 0.02288477122783661, -0.02426416054368019, 0.008502515964210033, -0.026453550904989243, 0.012052956968545914, -0.014825554564595222, 0.005540043115615845, 0.00243272609077394, -0.027937037870287895, 0.01930055022239685, -0.027052948251366615, 0.06404473632574081, -0.03989311307668686, 0.05975298583507538, 0.03812427446246147, -0.029095545411109924, -0.015608561225235462, 0.05041803419589996, 0.04650374874472618, -0.003350182669237256, -0.04935864731669426, -0.008207336068153381, -0.02792113460600376, -0.005546088330447674, -0.002108829328790307, 0.025280766189098358, 0.026808563619852066, 0.011288966983556747, -0.012309253215789795, 0.0022234171628952026, -0.016801830381155014, 0.013384075835347176, 0.017244789749383926, 0.0239426176995039, -0.026697048917412758, 0.04413306340575218, -0.01747697964310646, 0.02381618320941925, 0.0001414921134710312, 0.04182634875178337, 0.012987606227397919, -0.02893548458814621, 0.01470352802425623, 0.02156677097082138, 0.03157578408718109, 0.02909376658499241, -0.015603610314428806, 0.043941643089056015, -0.024534426629543304, 0.015300523489713669, 0.03610581159591675, -0.042387887835502625, 0.02399512752890587, 0.024966448545455933, 0.04359673336148262, -0.021675238385796547, 0.08598069101572037, -0.0010351384989917278, 0.03076828084886074, -0.016297560185194016, 0.001407523755915463, 0.013072553090751171, -0.012555176392197609, -0.003446098417043686, 0.050841160118579865, -0.049455273896455765, -0.003326964331790805, -0.052583809942007065, 0.010661584325134754, -0.03815358504652977, -0.005354583263397217, -0.02606780268251896, 0.03261958435177803, 0.000898801430594176, -0.02680039405822754, 0.009641909971833229, -0.008887946605682373, -0.011057044379413128, -0.012012690305709839, -0.0001220915000885725, 0.028224697336554527, 0.014955072663724422, -0.037729617208242416, 0.04036630317568779, -0.008078029379248619, -0.07375403493642807, 0.030685188248753548, 0.0011538872495293617, -0.026835231110453606, -0.01791902631521225, 0.03956696018576622, 0.0012497046263888478, -0.026312537491321564, 0.069954052567482, 0.01715102046728134, 0.012699735350906849, -0.02128036692738533, -0.04383271560072899, -0.05347105488181114, -0.03332816809415817, -0.013952952809631824, 0.013684915378689766, -0.05023191124200821, -0.0068669929169118404, 0.0689115896821022, 0.02898525819182396, 0.022727908566594124, 0.020747661590576172, 0.0073287286795675755, -0.010127941146492958, 0.014379230327904224, -0.029256023466587067, -0.03592841327190399, -0.04333094134926796, 0.022172873839735985, -0.04914942756295204, -0.056394968181848526, 0.06262330710887909, 0.021029964089393616, -0.013433459214866161, -0.032064542174339294, -0.02345229871571064, -0.0035309831146150827, 0.000905170978512615, -0.010241607204079628, -0.014109117910265923, 0.005656140390783548, 0.06042337790131569, -0.008753478527069092, 0.08365171402692795, 0.006167175248265266, 0.0033674919977784157, 0.025947559624910355, 0.004744226578623056, 0.05313199758529663, 0.06010231748223305, -0.0014036690117791295, -0.02974116988480091, -0.06009042263031006, 0.034118056297302246, 0.028377695009112358, 0.019859937950968742, -0.060388676822185516, -0.014358553104102612, -0.005472380202263594, -0.00526296766474843, 0.003258004318922758, 0.005674933083355427, -0.011114387772977352, 0.03786247968673706, -0.06907422095537186, -0.017068659886717796, -0.055111490190029144, 0.02395802177488804, 0.016915539279580116, -0.020522097125649452, -0.024730635806918144, 0.01662866212427616, 0.005929437465965748, -0.020191993564367294, 0.008709956891834736, -0.05625757575035095, -0.01939329318702221, 0.07559845596551895, -0.04105682671070099, -0.006021098233759403, 0.0327664390206337, 0.031516704708337784, -0.026956748217344284, 0.05990026146173477, -0.006362420041114092, -0.011663505807518959, -0.003113074228167534, -0.027543991804122925, 0.011335276067256927, -0.003778687445446849, 0.0032654409296810627, 0.023945888504385948, -0.016429457813501358, -0.04458385333418846, 0.028571877628564835, -0.04198206961154938, 0.08132541924715042, 0.06845874339342117, 0.012929367832839489, 0.02290220744907856, -0.012284661643207073, -0.012993652373552322, 0.02802319824695587, -0.0032428118865936995, -0.05297418683767319, -0.0514821819961071, -0.0002060827537206933, 0.01711495779454708, 0.021548708900809288, -0.028392881155014038, 0.024018285796046257, 0.0636974573135376, 0.007799210958182812, 0.06503427028656006, 0.014433501288294792, -0.013372298330068588, 0.04757629707455635, 0.0373668409883976, -0.004842288326472044, 0.004396830685436726, 0.001090527861379087, 0.03328609839081764, -0.025761812925338745, 0.049865443259477615, -0.009376047179102898, 0.01925530470907688, 0.013112618587911129, 0.01192274410277605, 0.03275866433978081, -0.03868703171610832, -0.029769334942102432, 0.04846348613500595, -0.05403628200292587, -0.020009255036711693, 0.035987842828035355, 0.002740041585639119, -0.004431247711181641, 0.008793821558356285, 0.002828308381140232, 0.001560477539896965, 0.07467314600944519, -0.03938115015625954, 0.008488149382174015, 0.01918487809598446, -0.028211617842316628, 0.03407621011137962, -0.028014466166496277, -0.023471206426620483, -0.08654304593801498, -0.0030439298134297132, 0.025328589603304863, 0.01555764488875866, 0.006608482450246811, -0.03278461843729019, 0.009852742776274681, 0.004582373891025782, -0.001913630054332316, 0.012405458837747574, -0.020459551364183426, -0.034414514899253845, 0.007505134213715792, 0.018304599449038506, -0.0042030238546431065, 0.02148718386888504, 0.0033139053266495466, -0.042628321796655655, 0.02103111892938614, 0.002874133177101612, -0.03707513585686684, 0.014127408154308796, -0.010010860860347748, 0.03533410653471947, -0.012041577138006687, -0.02478412725031376, 0.033252689987421036, 0.05070500448346138, -0.06560085713863373, 0.014294912107288837, -0.027999797835946083, -0.02757403440773487, -0.05625336989760399, -0.002419954864308238, 0.036803051829338074, 0.014842385426163673, 0.020644648000597954, 0.03490005061030388, -0.030029723420739174, 0.033479999750852585, -0.06415142118930817, -0.08210695534944534, 0.02920503355562687, 0.020726537331938744, 0.01758868619799614, 0.010468153282999992, -0.00009001878061098978, 0.0717397928237915, 0.054940275847911835, -0.033879950642585754, -0.04429955780506134, -0.01680062897503376, -0.004399279598146677, -0.0167364701628685, 0.0268455408513546, 0.01030041091144085, 0.03607267513871193, -0.039155568927526474, -0.032096538692712784, 0.040523167699575424, 0.06654492765665054, -0.03168058022856712, -0.02034730091691017, 0.03165873885154724, 0.024044208228588104, -0.025690479204058647, 0.02397969923913479, 0.0375395230948925, -0.015235908329486847, 0.028512684628367424, -0.03417826443910599, 0.005907154176384211, 0.018566202372312546, -0.03568723425269127, 0.03634241223335266, -0.030748289078474045, 0.023009104654192924, -0.011271370574831963, -0.01389386784285307, 0.01663571037352085, -0.044940076768398285, 0.019379204139113426, 0.027473531663417816, 0.07110092043876648, -0.045536838471889496, -0.042020730674266815, 0.034855954349040985, 0.017045510932803154, -0.023640668019652367, 0.003064435441046953, 0.028971834108233452, -0.03345147520303726, 0.043415483087301254, -0.03326895087957382, -0.02182505652308464, 0.02943437173962593, 0.049566902220249176, 0.00993043091148138, 0.0017683000769466162, -0.026837829500436783, 0.015170353464782238, -0.0666864886879921, 0.004653998650610447, 0.0049401395954191685, 0.04801679775118828, 0.017586924135684967, 0.043776798993349075, 0.032650984823703766, -0.0264296755194664, 0.042092178016901016, -0.015531008131802082, -0.05126342922449112, 0.031166017055511475, 0.030485453084111214, 0.011427897028625011, -0.0023605464957654476, -0.04961192235350609, -0.008136446587741375, -0.011872978881001472, -0.0050668357871472836, -0.02062235213816166, 0.01692504808306694, -0.014322958886623383, 0.0111530227586627, -0.022208834066987038, 0.023115506395697594, -0.022011052817106247, 0.028286779299378395, 0.009137076325714588, -0.011241132393479347, 0.013291114941239357, 0.0047959559597074986, 0.030597664415836334, -0.031319741159677505, -0.006809544749557972, -0.01328249927610159, -0.005499888677150011, 0.036316074430942535, 0.03570874035358429, 0.01656804047524929, -0.024946538731455803, 0.016943668946623802, -0.01853051409125328, 0.050398409366607666, 0.06568311899900436, -0.010426756925880909, -0.017931826412677765, -0.035883426666259766, 0.02023712918162346, 0.011224950663745403, 0.023065079003572464, 0.00540406396612525, -0.007631324231624603, 0.04358401894569397, 0.0062288567423820496, -0.06635935604572296, -0.0024205618537962437, 0.10257907211780548, 0.013250167481601238, -0.019053708761930466, -0.06063546985387802, 0.00881330668926239, 0.016556190326809883, -0.034782830625772476, 0.043022483587265015, 0.054089613258838654, 0.023298699408769608, 0.04880618304014206, 0.05367569625377655, -0.040640369057655334, -0.01883150264620781, -0.025082092732191086, 0.01524438802152872, 0.04219602420926094, -0.00338726001791656, -0.04612930119037628, 0.01944660395383835, 0.02775932475924492, 0.06835854798555374, 0.043823279440402985, 0.021272921934723854, -0.11789225786924362, 0.0013603877741843462, 0.03277295082807541, 0.03610345721244812, -0.029192131012678146, -0.021729031577706337, -0.09935114532709122, 0.00998198427259922, 0.04426565766334534, -0.044200558215379715, -0.003097968176007271, -0.04675418883562088, 0.00697930995374918, -0.001494379248470068, -0.012048108503222466, -0.0294342078268528, 0.023673156276345253, -0.0243001040071249, 0.0501922145485878, -0.017988217994570732, -0.013497409410774708, -0.016869602724909782, 0.024875180795788765, 0.024397267028689384, 0.07157225161790848, -0.03181619197130203, 0.0033836045768111944, 0.04854203388094902, 0.014698133803904057, -0.03279132768511772, -0.05773133039474487, 0.011296376585960388, 0.0006910075899213552, 0.040971539914608, 0.01102555450052023, 0.012295407243072987, -0.010617775842547417, -0.0431942455470562, 0.06091286614537239, -0.021056929603219032, -0.010509968735277653, -0.04161408171057701, 0.014599288813769817, -0.00045551187940873206, -0.006663779262453318, 0.018086107447743416, 0.036776185035705566, -0.030475445091724396, -0.02542918175458908, -0.058694060891866684, 0.038347840309143066, 0.004951478447765112, 0.012132254429161549, -0.033919256180524826, -0.007978128269314766, -0.015872273594141006, 0.018871748819947243, 0.012741639278829098, 0.04549437761306763, -0.011213961988687515, -0.005882604513317347, -0.01422616746276617, 0.02809358760714531, -0.020723367109894753, -0.01835031621158123, -0.06352803111076355, 0.0020119419787079096, 0.0017272521508857608, -0.01632136106491089, 0.026074619963765144, -0.036233969032764435, 0.004553715232759714, 0.01211229246109724, -0.04489123821258545, 0.023454932495951653, -0.024376969784498215, -0.03701895847916603, 0.015954501926898956, -0.01883118227124214, 0.028965946286916733, -0.04412969946861267, 0.04830110818147659, -0.0002279384498251602, -0.006292027421295643, 0.01608278602361679, -0.00884886085987091, 0.007158058229833841, 0.0616513192653656, -0.02646031230688095, 0.03407736122608185, -0.02604050375521183, 0.01196722500026226, -0.04292267560958862, -0.06865691393613815, 0.04916200041770935, 0.01820688508450985, -0.0348367840051651, -0.04249747097492218, 0.01596212387084961, 0.003075899789109826, -0.02763890102505684, -0.0203158650547266, 0.043778132647275925, -0.021696262061595917, -0.0003776185039896518, -0.012552105821669102, -0.005492295138537884, 0.07847729325294495, 0.01363884937018156, 0.02130432054400444, 0.032981038093566895, -0.014100538566708565, -0.029290825128555298, -0.008834155276417732, 0.01944863609969616, -0.017101386561989784, -0.015619601123034954, -0.030988596379756927, 0.0003682148817460984, 0.03360497206449509, -0.013075923547148705, -0.02635716088116169, -0.036232203245162964, 0.009958944283425808, -0.0014333163853734732, -0.023406440392136574, 0.0028851397801190615, -0.009707472287118435, -0.017749935388565063, -0.054045356810092926, -0.0040448387153446674, -0.04636049270629883, 0.008286448195576668, 0.011437129229307175, 0.021933674812316895, 0.018163394182920456, 0.005857703275978565, 0.06229887530207634, -0.018646089360117912, 0.0005260066245682538, -0.0081327548250556, -0.011977331712841988, 0.04084951430559158, -0.01322497334331274, -0.0004638224490918219, -0.008476920425891876, 0.03664732724428177, -0.02437983639538288, 0.03358547389507294, -0.05817133188247681, 0.015689393505454063, 0.04044608399271965, -0.002123606391251087, 0.047852661460638046, 0.03236598148941994, 0.011751244775950909, -0.005526712629944086, -0.04994579777121544, 0.0005828299908898771, 0.005019573960453272, -0.0018746162531897426, 0.03805069252848625, 0.008201057091355324, -0.007428624201565981, 0.0229745265096426, 0.04154759645462036, 0.009301649406552315, 0.02897261641919613, -0.022228732705116272, 0.007810883689671755, -0.02144726738333702, 0.02150014229118824, -0.05929451808333397, 0.0343661904335022, -0.016221951693296432, 0.004658660851418972, -0.006144983693957329, -0.023048309609293938, 0.03359858691692352, 0.04323747381567955, -0.010020196437835693, -0.02781406044960022, -0.01367875374853611, -0.04879197105765343, 0.03224039822816849, 0.03697388246655464, -0.016546685248613358, 0.023418843746185303, 0.026248790323734283, 0.0017166767502203584, -0.02973046526312828, -0.006128228269517422, -0.017904769629240036, -0.008878517895936966, -0.027936000376939774, -0.08307947963476181, -0.03144565224647522, 0.0036758582573384047, 0.037825655192136765, -0.01916230469942093, 0.005724173504859209, -0.02331547811627388, 0.03888809308409691, 0.0019553890451788902, 0.03575694188475609, 0.03097694367170334, 0.0676598995923996, 0.01808934099972248, 0.005241129547357559, -0.012061475776135921, 0.01546399388462305, 0.12431859225034714, 0.09578681737184525, 0.03381304442882538, -0.0736914873123169, -0.006502473261207342, 0.011156639084219933, -0.0331696942448616, -0.022795839235186577, 0.026546688750386238, 0.05631323531270027, -0.023359140381217003, 0.008021844550967216, -0.0021989953238517046, 0.012838718481361866, 0.047442007809877396, 0.05011335760354996, -0.012024974450469017, -0.005118431989103556, 0.03654538467526436, 0.037995725870132446, -0.007717518601566553, -0.040493350476026535, -0.04764454439282417, 0.022524885833263397, 0.03576148673892021, -0.01947849988937378, 0.00039592935354448855, -0.024476688355207443, 0.01739300601184368, 0.002048735274001956, -0.031043116003274918, 0.004408382810652256, 0.00963007565587759, -0.000011339034244883806, 0.01450995821505785, -0.022815044969320297, -0.004726782441139221, -0.021838653832674026, -0.005016128998249769, 0.007486132439225912, 0.042426947504282, -0.016628189012408257, -0.05709270387887955, 0.013208120130002499, -0.02523273229598999, -0.015222901478409767, -0.02909727953374386, 0.052512552589178085, 0.01226557232439518, -0.06783715635538101, -0.011009425856173038, 0.035068925470113754, 0.011849561706185341, -0.04512876272201538, 0.008537501096725464, 0.017495308071374893, -0.010587728582322598, -0.010868189856410027, -0.0034478723537176847, -0.027353057637810707, -0.002103569218888879, -0.04065978527069092, 0.01688346266746521, -0.014725057408213615, -0.010701281018555164, -0.010580445639789104, -0.05064450576901436, 0.002994820475578308, 0.004077760968357325, -0.006642664782702923, 0.029421832412481308, -0.061423614621162415, -0.016766302287578583, -0.011996220797300339, -0.012535740621387959, -0.012539777904748917, 0.0050399452447891235, 0.003706984920427203, -0.01966063864529133, -0.01727931946516037, -0.011077913455665112, -0.0074029783718287945, -0.001491624629124999, -0.012769118882715702, -0.007067016791552305, -0.0003717406652867794, -0.0010062725050374866, 0.05996029078960419, 0.014189053326845169, 0.02946101687848568, -0.022037453949451447, 0.009890011511743069, 0.007636406924575567, -0.01853163354098797, -0.003560880199074745, -0.014673915691673756, -0.010904599912464619, 0.05416315421462059, -0.014489193446934223, 0.06322848051786423, -0.016321878880262375, 0.0007476411992684007, -0.019766230136156082, 0.06368762254714966, 0.014328924007713795, 0.04221757501363754, 0.0075353882275521755, -0.05515047162771225, 0.02236686460673809, 0.023149406537413597, -0.005201368592679501, -0.057214658707380295, -0.020645027980208397, -0.01974393241107464, -0.03571738302707672, -0.030641768127679825, -0.022953270003199577, -0.03287988528609276, -0.023232989013195038, 0.009431113488972187, 0.017374588176608086, -0.016155805438756943, -0.010323097929358482, -0.05089905485510826, 0.008776722475886345, -0.017957525327801704, 0.025978391990065575, 0.008354416117072105, -0.006119898054748774, -0.008003298193216324, -0.00008597096893936396, 0.03297704458236694, -0.010215400718152523, 0.007713824976235628, 0.009523156099021435, 0.026153061538934708, 0.022475816309452057, 0.031538110226392746, -0.03394163027405739, -0.03226381167769432, 0.006542837712913752, -0.03707636520266533, 0.020545559003949165, -0.0022081402130424976, 0.003467205911874771, 0.016706563532352448, 0.03274298086762428, -0.01897483691573143, -0.0066827889531850815, 0.01955569162964821, -0.004224298521876335, -0.032157666981220245, 0.003267093328759074, 0.014775331132113934, -0.017920302227139473, 0.024804091081023216, -0.0036374509800225496, 0.022134656086564064, -0.03781017288565636, 0.008016448467969894, 0.014843214303255081, -0.009327689185738564, -0.011251671239733696, -0.0048556700348854065, 0.007351565640419722, -0.018442999571561813, -0.00936146080493927, 0.023166337981820107, 0.012246694415807724, 0.06325138360261917, -0.01748703606426716, 0.055550914257764816, 0.008785483427345753, 0.0162814948707819, -0.09000254422426224, -0.016671132296323776, -0.011062389239668846, -0.021369315683841705, 0.025618018582463264, -0.049942322075366974, 0.0012515645939856768, -0.01342230848968029, -0.041668932884931564, 0.014074933715164661, 0.002263008151203394, -0.001586983329616487, -0.023362696170806885, 0.014008956030011177, -0.011928529478609562, -0.008292587473988533, 0.024882161989808083, -0.005005373619496822, 0.042649950832128525, 0.00476249773055315, -0.023604702204465866, -0.021256472915410995, -0.024404549971222878, 0.010862368158996105, 0.03940065577626228, -0.04756111651659012, 0.024351980537176132, -0.035372331738471985, -0.04959037899971008, 0.020871853455901146, -0.02447355166077614, -0.0279455054551363, 0.06687576323747635, 0.012263479642570019, 0.01558128371834755, 0.08375397324562073, 0.03757714852690697, 0.005670786369591951, 0.011874492280185223, -0.01205145101994276, 0.0322919636964798, 0.0026955793146044016, -0.005149112548679113, 0.03102346509695053, 0.07610608637332916, -0.013484137132763863, -0.029584795236587524, 0.01834498904645443, -0.02308359369635582, -0.009057600051164627, 0.00957421213388443, -0.010939354076981544, -0.018175730481743813, -0.03659803792834282, 0.004607802722603083, -0.007701170165091753, 0.004773636814206839, 0.02268597111105919, 0.0125449663028121, 0.017976554110646248, 0.008408388122916222, -0.0033894863445311785, -0.0516500398516655, -0.025538304820656776, 0.034880489110946655, -0.05326748266816139, -0.05480469390749931, -0.012472028844058514, -0.022190367802977562, -0.03179139271378517, -0.026674220338463783, 0.04898509755730629, -0.06789785623550415, 0.06253426522016525, -0.037971287965774536, -0.032572582364082336, 0.05498054623603821, -0.008906654082238674, -0.018106786534190178, -0.07747644931077957, 0.02384253218770027, 0.01574096828699112, -0.019980747252702713, -0.048724107444286346, -0.003380801994353533, -0.056664299219846725, -0.019516214728355408, 0.0470195896923542, 0.012002036906778812, 0.0204518660902977, -0.03346862643957138, 0.01286051981151104, -0.02039082907140255, -0.028530333191156387, 0.029828425496816635, -0.03580763190984726, 0.000621720333583653, -0.03239767625927925, -0.014292453415691853, 0.01411331258714199, -0.011829406954348087, -0.015925027430057526, 0.0043982649222016335, 0.04209335148334503, 0.040054790675640106, -0.003199012018740177, -0.021148359403014183, -0.03703170269727707, 0.005267305765300989, 0.0591912567615509, -0.005347056780010462, 0.006507935933768749, -0.0013038699980825186, 0.016301142051815987, -0.045967187732458115, 0.035674747079610825, -0.024655761197209358, -0.009452340193092823, 0.0044511049054563046, 0.01852519065141678, 0.00014883882249705493, -0.06776048243045807, 0.012649395503103733, 0.0353056974709034, -0.022674307227134705, 0.04057305306196213, 0.038173336535692215, -0.008984185755252838, 0.03634463623166084, 0.03910834714770317, 0.01385291013866663, -0.016285032033920288, -0.031400009989738464, 0.003680591471493244, -0.01680729165673256, -0.014661338180303574, -0.03148801252245903, 0.01853332482278347, 0.03856085240840912, 0.009236032143235207, -0.0005272289272397757, 0.025942562147974968, 0.04773316904902458, 0.013515678234398365, -0.04797123000025749, -0.01707622967660427, -0.01649692840874195, 0.010764815844595432, 0.022995423525571823, 0.006674274802207947, 0.04139735922217369, -0.022362368181347847, 0.005923865828663111, -0.012784945778548717, -0.048723697662353516, -0.05368487536907196, 0.015958230942487717, 0.04362739622592926, 0.06584828346967697, 0.012971953488886356, -0.018067628145217896, -0.000788310484495014, 0.019600579515099525, 0.03698711097240448, -0.0029594830702990294, -0.0009457585401833057, 0.025763940066099167, -0.014358141459524632, 0.0025417706929147243, 0.013945954851806164, -0.0005337153561413288, -0.026565784588456154, -0.004123082850128412, 0.035746973007917404, 0.022152284160256386, 0.023920297622680664, -0.03342091664671898, -0.018894914537668228, 0.0037817719858139753, -0.03520413115620613, -0.0008053078199736774, -0.041524406522512436, 0.0085093779489398, -0.002180753042921424, -0.03621537610888481 ]
<p>What are some typical approaches to handling incomplete data in the Kalman Filter? I'm talking about the situation where some elements of the observed vector $y_t$ are missing, distinct from the case where an entire observed vector $y_t$ is missed. Another way of thinking about this would be that the dimension $p$ of the observed vector is different for each time point.</p> <p>To explain my context a bit further, the observations are estimated parameters from a logistic regression performed at each time point. While each logistic regression includes the same covariates, sometimes the estimates are undefined due to collinearities in the data for that time point.</p>
4,246
[ 0.013780476525425911, 0.014596965163946152, -0.014376369304955006, 0.029979940503835678, 0.04451636224985123, 0.016189154237508774, -0.026874378323554993, -0.01827017217874527, 0.02343408763408661, -0.01786418817937374, 0.0026349471881985664, 0.028056928887963295, 0.03447779268026352, -0.0013419364113360643, 0.017403962090611458, -0.010938662104308605, -0.0011006523855030537, -0.02684330940246582, 0.002479907823726535, -0.008818532340228558, -0.0022778750862926245, 0.01528216153383255, -0.007419331930577755, 0.0006709438166581094, -0.006919823121279478, 0.032208580523729324, 0.030621889978647232, 0.008053339086472988, 0.03672442212700844, 0.05581951141357422, -0.04936722293496132, -0.03913664072751999, -0.02816874161362648, 0.05770372599363327, -0.03220372647047043, -0.007162044290453196, -0.01902884989976883, -0.030921122059226036, -0.0016078741755336523, 0.046979695558547974, -0.07509279251098633, -0.0230137687176466, -0.025976471602916718, 0.03766513243317604, -0.006925171706825495, 0.033217109739780426, 0.024880291894078255, -0.020910417661070824, 0.03983679786324501, -0.020066535100340843, 0.05742097273468971, 0.0007153659244067967, 0.0430772490799427, 0.007014577742666006, -0.003559653414413333, 0.025061121210455894, 0.06703637540340424, 0.08656492829322815, -0.010421054437756538, -0.020656339824199677, -0.014837388880550861, -0.015196211636066437, 0.024814540520310402, -0.030332015827298164, 0.008316932246088982, 0.050029952079057693, -0.014056245796382427, -0.04389166831970215, 0.021487297490239143, -0.016690470278263092, -0.004520478192716837, -0.005300944205373526, 0.02716916985809803, -0.01859631948173046, 0.01047112699598074, -0.07127517461776733, -0.018705081194639206, 0.04282762482762337, 0.034249357879161835, 0.00454709492623806, 0.011014587245881557, -0.03205772116780281, 0.02838742546737194, 0.050066277384757996, -0.018506309017539024, -0.015430014580488205, 0.07677395641803741, -0.030987756326794624, 0.03913291171193123, 0.00375779764726758, -0.042935777455568314, -0.0034566428512334824, 0.019960248842835426, -0.002388909924775362, -0.06815508008003235, 0.02482542209327221, -0.009520666673779488, 0.041982777416706085, 0.015326907858252525, 0.007125466596335173, 0.03595665097236633, -0.025280429050326347, 0.0027198814786970615, 0.04377365484833717, -0.01043226569890976, 0.014276553876698017, 0.001153692719526589, -0.008279492147266865, -0.005761272273957729, -0.032777342945337296, -0.011754568666219711, 0.014133764430880547, 0.012619047425687313, 0.0009527119691483676, 0.0480383075773716, -0.0220569409430027, -0.03082953207194805, -0.033602356910705566, 0.026185110211372375, 0.07948356121778488, 0.06575316190719604, -0.020722700282931328, 0.005069992505013943, -0.017999351024627686, -0.07173801958560944, 0.01405426673591137, 0.015092519111931324, -0.0337156318128109, -0.05990799516439438, 0.0539117269217968, -0.02264704555273056, -0.02756076119840145, 0.06479018181562424, -0.03153228387236595, 0.03393838554620743, 0.010748789645731449, -0.07760927081108093, -0.012258614413440228, 0.0173776987940073, -0.020614296197891235, 0.02422737330198288, -0.07326128333806992, 0.008064397610723972, 0.028979860246181488, 0.04312146455049515, -0.019704118371009827, 0.0025363408494740725, 0.02680865116417408, 0.022757429629564285, 0.0006655011093243957, -0.018914347514510155, -0.017719674855470657, -0.0007523411768488586, -0.0179918110370636, -0.003477635560557246, -0.06817498803138733, 0.028499729931354523, 0.043959058821201324, -0.01030920259654522, -0.013130414299666882, 0.06714540719985962, 0.027865763753652573, -0.030778290703892708, 0.014127231203019619, 0.01883774995803833, -0.033516786992549896, 0.05297798290848732, -0.018279550597071648, 0.05223303288221359, 0.018643857911229134, 0.029813067987561226, 0.009984558448195457, 0.019454827532172203, 0.044086188077926636, 0.06783991307020187, -0.020673494786024094, -0.007072151638567448, 0.013340173289179802, 0.0031187471468001604, 0.017480242997407913, -0.04614001512527466, -0.039312541484832764, 0.01779698207974434, 0.012759895995259285, 0.022521648555994034, 0.05414886400103569, -0.0141670610755682, 0.00412475923076272, 0.054912883788347244, -0.017565475776791573, -0.007245004177093506, -0.0298427976667881, 0.01231330819427967, -0.011531236581504345, -0.012163598090410233, 0.08362457156181335, -0.0026975974906235933, 0.015217944048345089, -0.0029973380733281374, -0.027256976813077927, -0.010544764809310436, -0.03444857522845268, -0.01114103477448225, -0.0542856827378273, 0.005002167075872421, 0.03189363330602646, 0.05344413220882416, 0.033586323261260986, 0.048331260681152344, -0.01717655174434185, -0.016409622505307198, -0.05058301240205765, -0.002693429822102189, 0.022016262635588646, -0.03215267136693001, -0.03753828629851341, -0.023073863238096237, -0.027528708800673485, -0.04358271509408951, -0.009407796896994114, -0.05336722359061241, 0.052660174667835236, 0.08857610076665878, -0.011653791181743145, 0.007148520555347204, 0.03494799882173538, 0.015159426257014275, 0.021213306114077568, -0.01973254792392254, -0.04324986785650253, -0.05329111963510513, 0.0065239774994552135, 0.026337089017033577, 0.002676493488252163, -0.042385000735521317, 0.02339600771665573, 0.04034162685275078, -0.004248681012541056, 0.012704490683972836, 0.008746021427214146, -0.01660146936774254, -0.007440113462507725, 0.025990569964051247, -0.003760005347430706, 0.005762128625065088, -0.03047226369380951, 0.00365678989328444, 0.00590615626424551, 0.014713101089000702, -0.002770519582554698, -0.014588942751288414, 0.023451125249266624, -0.0052089267410337925, 0.01063272450119257, -0.015738267451524734, -0.04846511036157608, 0.03987854719161987, 0.0020686169154942036, 0.015479412861168385, 0.039881542325019836, 0.012493424117565155, 0.011031177826225758, 0.02477044239640236, 0.013551288284361362, 0.0002632541873026639, 0.033170800656080246, -0.036367084830999374, -0.002092998940497637, 0.0023133689537644386, -0.017740992829203606, 0.01718306355178356, -0.04249308630824089, -0.04823307693004608, -0.03428100049495697, -0.005023912061005831, 0.0776313841342926, -0.01139247976243496, 0.0289455633610487, -0.03435711935162544, -0.03377377614378929, -0.03732109069824219, -0.011735050939023495, 0.04544992372393608, 0.05124134197831154, -0.02703959494829178, 0.024680590257048607, -0.002987893996760249, 0.0075723580084741116, -0.0033303056843578815, -0.02364850416779518, 0.033846933394670486, -0.0012350783217698336, -0.04495000094175339, -0.04833897203207016, -0.024683574214577675, -0.0272101778537035, 0.016616690903902054, -0.006781511940062046, -0.032058753073215485, 0.03442223742604256, 0.020664533600211143, -0.042056407779455185, -0.0022379576694220304, -0.06726353615522385, -0.02534339390695095, -0.02112768031656742, -0.01767950877547264, 0.012551204301416874, -0.008379469625651836, 0.012837479822337627, 0.061985477805137634, -0.03801119327545166, 0.010613055899739265, -0.07561209052801132, -0.08275579661130905, 0.033918362110853195, -0.004893499892205, 0.033904075622558594, 0.012210594490170479, -0.0011978903785347939, 0.09110607206821442, 0.008300979621708393, -0.017826706171035767, -0.013297047466039658, -0.006741296034306288, -0.014571255072951317, -0.01056840643286705, -0.023813320323824883, -0.019238492473959923, 0.027323676273226738, 0.03563428297638893, -0.012407965958118439, 0.02345620095729828, 0.047173094004392624, 0.052514735609292984, 0.014151941984891891, 0.0028106372337788343, 0.010335590690374374, 0.022177578881382942, 0.02836526371538639, 0.04116549715399742, 0.004953155759721994, -0.004935284610837698, -0.005769288167357445, 0.03860187903046608, 0.015225982293486595, -0.06517254561185837, -0.02653321996331215, -0.044053737074136734, 0.0038047730922698975, -0.03180385008454323, 0.0053693498484790325, 0.03283563256263733, -0.01074480451643467, -0.005226473789662123, 0.05372445285320282, 0.043251682072877884, -0.010114788077771664, 0.017409009858965874, 0.04364532232284546, -0.001502245431765914, -0.0024955659173429012, -0.008569224737584591, 0.004817288368940353, -0.004538653418421745, 0.03471708670258522, -0.013216459192335606, -0.020012730732560158, 0.02977144718170166, 0.014555370435118675, -0.020394885912537575, -0.030519092455506325, -0.016075197607278824, 0.02425982430577278, -0.10053841024637222, -0.004399177618324757, -0.007973238825798035, 0.05739308521151543, 0.003478351514786482, -0.011657021939754486, 0.03174680471420288, 0.006210664752870798, 0.007477783132344484, 0.044427208602428436, -0.03825210779905319, 0.004925565328449011, -0.00689431419596076, -0.0026737023144960403, 0.001045895740389824, 0.010862605646252632, 0.06075528264045715, -0.06789977103471756, 0.015481380745768547, 0.008606637828052044, 0.009131623432040215, -0.038339950144290924, -0.013394488021731377, -0.02295806258916855, 0.024242646992206573, -0.016670281067490578, -0.01453776378184557, 0.04402892664074898, -0.012397805228829384, 0.015232580713927746, 0.0611204132437706, 0.006554137449711561, -0.002317670965567231, -0.010036729276180267, -0.014257164672017097, 0.013510121032595634, 0.060961559414863586, 0.013946492224931717, 0.02161114476621151, -0.042325105518102646, 0.030598051846027374, 0.013327495194971561, 0.07381486892700195, -0.010767198167741299, 0.027608836069703102, -0.008801491931080818, -0.020721368491649628, -0.004438660107553005, -0.029329923912882805, 0.020161619409918785, 0.0009780059335753322, 0.008480335585772991, 0.045523710548877716, 0.04637681320309639, -0.05201178789138794, 0.001604441786184907, 0.0322522334754467, 0.0346226803958416, 0.0000757580273784697, -0.012105675414204597, 0.006809794809669256, 0.012787263840436935, 0.023654960095882416, 0.0012955907732248306, 0.011709574609994888, -0.0022299925331026316, 0.0009993077255785465, 0.01445628609508276, -0.013816647231578827, -0.022886333987116814, -0.0020203895401209593, 0.054402366280555725, 0.04802084341645241, 0.02618669532239437, -0.03029409609735012, 0.030373254790902138, 0.06072648614645004, 0.030522724613547325, 0.049768511205911636, 0.017598548904061317, -0.07023759186267853, 0.0164969339966774, 0.04473463445901871, 0.016584297642111778, -0.018990516662597656, -0.025508679449558258, -0.07205494493246078, -0.03157063573598862, 0.06422098726034164, 0.003536524251103401, -0.000281870539765805, -0.020478492602705956, -0.003189328359439969, -0.02088344469666481, -0.058216601610183716, -0.029527204111218452, 0.011036987416446209, -0.004307286348193884, 0.011888972483575344, -0.008963617496192455, -0.020575925707817078, -0.02184111997485161, 0.03157419711351395, 0.026556944474577904, 0.05894890055060387, 0.03589065745472908, -0.01656533032655716, 0.017577117308974266, 0.028199277818202972, -0.013971869833767414, -0.024514280259609222, -0.013949365355074406, 0.011930202133953571, -0.02955063432455063, 0.013902868144214153, -0.000011615886251092888, -0.02527291513979435, 0.016534430906176567, -0.0066934144124388695, -0.02611846663057804, -0.029432673007249832, -0.015844853594899178, 0.0293625108897686, -0.008949555456638336, 0.0043378714472055435, 0.046427104622125626, 0.03277742117643356, 0.025335166603326797, -0.002617770340293646, -0.030832290649414062, 0.018053192645311356, -0.03934993967413902, -0.012334666214883327, -0.051466114819049835, -0.0058585782535374165, -0.01990964636206627, 0.04790849983692169, 0.007207835558801889, 0.03864458575844765, -0.01949508860707283, -0.03285921365022659, 0.010151182301342487, 0.05363546311855316, 0.015010274946689606, -0.023373503237962723, -0.0005617195274680853, 0.02574460208415985, -0.008649890311062336, 0.016735687851905823, 0.010929906740784645, -0.014278232119977474, -0.014586417004466057, -0.0065667941235005856, -0.05884852632880211, 0.006751564331352711, -0.02992267906665802, -0.01283544022589922, 0.0339827686548233, -0.0009081264142878354, -0.0063240546733140945, -0.03514760732650757, 0.009477146901190281, -0.003893377026543021, -0.057750996202230453, 0.013454239815473557, -0.0272569190710783, -0.029467890039086342, 0.043758824467659, -0.047801434993743896, 0.003120608627796173, -0.010432077571749687, 0.012975530698895454, -0.09379679709672928, -0.04256271943449974, 0.04177900031208992, -0.010259980335831642, -0.05098981782793999, -0.018774399533867836, 0.024645188823342323, -0.028317242860794067, -0.02530495449900627, -0.031142277643084526, 0.054585181176662445, -0.0015879800776019692, -0.04159901663661003, -0.042087431997060776, 0.040632300078868866, 0.05220469832420349, -0.014336366206407547, 0.019918225705623627, 0.02915361151099205, -0.0556146577000618, -0.032831184566020966, -0.006391285452991724, 0.024515265598893166, 0.0028003742918372154, -0.027780598029494286, -0.0276931319385767, 0.01737193390727043, 0.02845364809036255, -0.05791157856583595, -0.005066488403826952, 0.02490278147161007, -0.011313040740787983, -0.0230653528124094, -0.009070833213627338, 0.002671596361324191, -0.027892639860510826, 0.013411954045295715, -0.0018568562809377909, -0.006407030858099461, 0.018270861357450485, -0.014138098806142807, 0.03222615644335747, -0.030050355941057205, -0.006334380246698856, -0.004102242644876242, 0.03702397271990776, -0.019461140036582947, 0.0003296497743576765, 0.02195960283279419, -0.02277197502553463, 0.05097232013940811, 0.018877632915973663, -0.011276350356638432, 0.011356988921761513, 0.020550884306430817, -0.06210646405816078, -0.044272858649492264, -0.016207868233323097, 0.002983813639730215, 0.08784812688827515, -0.028739720582962036, 0.005026120226830244, 0.014843839220702648, 0.0060383351519703865, 0.018394825980067253, -0.010913047008216381, -0.010604601353406906, 0.019575750455260277, 0.012390804477036, 0.03911921754479408, 0.027717141434550285, -0.007790809031575918, 0.019147226586937904, 0.0323559008538723, 0.0264174472540617, -0.008731123059988022, -0.018993131816387177, 0.06660506129264832, 0.012821649201214314, -0.03586828336119652, -0.05483110249042511, 0.0051539018750190735, -0.018633032217621803, 0.0022495335433632135, -0.0029246972408145666, -0.023595429956912994, 0.031652990728616714, 0.028736673295497894, 0.020139528438448906, -0.04094667360186577, -0.014758750796318054, -0.056872524321079254, 0.02049129642546177, 0.02852611429989338, -0.002231821184977889, 0.028843194246292114, -0.00039795233169570565, 0.05963662639260292, 0.003039039671421051, -0.0008918610401451588, -0.026300108060240746, -0.11315082013607025, -0.046693332493305206, 0.0007387649966403842, 0.005062776617705822, 0.018512485548853874, 0.024434709921479225, -0.014498886652290821, -0.0018638549372553825, 0.020416218787431717, 0.040906716138124466, 0.0010598970111459494, 0.05268339067697525, -0.029637333005666733, 0.06032392755150795, 0.01745610684156418, 0.023164041340351105, -0.03719315305352211, 0.0020140977576375008, 0.10728252679109573, 0.06478606909513474, 0.046569496393203735, -0.07873562723398209, 0.026668574661016464, 0.02519586868584156, 0.002564110793173313, -0.01843729428946972, 0.04987125098705292, 0.02906651794910431, -0.006573509890586138, 0.026496965438127518, 0.018214890733361244, -0.0010893294820562005, 0.005317561328411102, 0.04593164101243019, -0.05043825879693031, -0.005028429441154003, -0.004492426756769419, 0.0004924366367049515, 0.01607544720172882, -0.0006479417206719518, -0.05663647502660751, 0.03658737614750862, 0.005824672058224678, -0.044426895678043365, -0.015424995683133602, -0.01714596152305603, 0.008349255658686161, -0.0262512918561697, -0.009138445369899273, 0.028823360800743103, 0.023572204634547234, 0.029508385807275772, -0.013527849689126015, 0.025028351694345474, -0.027284817770123482, -0.012400530278682709, 0.016229938715696335, 0.004313699901103973, -0.01023196242749691, 0.0017631141236051917, -0.019007906317710876, -0.026298392564058304, -0.0022680144757032394, -0.04474766179919243, -0.023789260536432266, 0.07193859666585922, -0.02364262379705906, 0.03380610793828964, -0.037084657698869705, 0.018943175673484802, -0.00038709392538294196, -0.04674578458070755, -0.03160756081342697, 0.024923143908381462, 0.034146059304475784, -0.005282166413962841, -0.028012128546833992, -0.02124607563018799, 0.027726884931325912, 0.01679188758134842, 0.058170463889837265, 0.03234635293483734, -0.030764656141400337, -0.0031038925517350435, -0.014391892589628696, 0.05358213931322098, -0.006720724515616894, 0.006476141046732664, 0.008620010688900948, 0.0010648701572790742, 0.019927551969885826, -0.03985604643821716, 0.045212943106889725, -0.009773334488272667, 0.023324565961956978, -0.034978460520505905, -0.0036474112421274185, -0.023255905136466026, -0.047692351043224335, -0.015037840232253075, -0.019770577549934387, 0.0055524082854390144, -0.027089208364486694, -0.019274068996310234, 0.03433682769536972, 0.04921179637312889, -0.005969988647848368, -0.01127595454454422, -0.008530785329639912, 0.04837707430124283, -0.012692579999566078, -0.050836753100156784, 0.006438407115638256, 0.0025280932895839214, -0.05045372620224953, 0.006995561067014933, -0.03180036321282387, 0.04847376421093941, 0.0432010255753994, 0.052411969751119614, -0.03624831140041351, 0.04009726643562317, -0.012356171384453773, -0.0023286305367946625, -0.0002496645611245185, -0.047953855246305466, -0.02698282152414322, -0.02584953047335148, 0.02711424231529236, -0.04055451229214668, -0.018843667581677437, -0.014130671508610249, -0.02335858717560768, 0.007481316104531288, -0.02535635232925415, -0.02432900480926037, 0.03229184076189995, -0.0018175176810473204, 0.02071937918663025, -0.019748952239751816, 0.03221239149570465, -0.022346079349517822, -0.006634953897446394, -0.02494783140718937, -0.04653660207986832, -0.022066792473196983, -0.010899082757532597, -0.013531013391911983, 0.005631363485008478, 0.015524677000939846, -0.016511671245098114, 0.033683035522699356, -0.002718268660828471, 0.011481457389891148, -0.01760551892220974, 0.04751356691122055, -0.0505046583712101, -0.03100324049592018, -0.002336404984816909, -0.01543574407696724, -0.05361951142549515, 0.04799073934555054, -0.001114564947783947, 0.019332796335220337, 0.016487810760736465, -0.021530527621507645, -0.0346653126180172, 0.015055703930556774, -0.0076529537327587605, -0.007399506401270628, -0.016976336017251015, 0.029292793944478035, -0.050249092280864716, -0.008670779876410961, 0.03264566883444786, 0.0005839732475578785, -0.01235274039208889, 0.010945852845907211, 0.05542019382119179, 0.006706965155899525, -0.01753820665180683, 0.042746927589178085, 0.022956909611821175, 0.039578888565301895, 0.02778206206858158, 0.012182888574898243, 0.016599658876657486, 0.0481431782245636, 0.0065749408677220345, 0.026172978803515434, 0.023645740002393723, 0.040796950459480286, -0.08017552644014359, -0.02219795249402523, 0.04555272310972214, 0.011465542949736118, 0.03107890672981739, -0.06176083907485008, -0.03286737576127052, 0.0718911811709404, -0.04383181408047676, 0.01335124485194683, -0.015785381197929382, -0.003703193971887231, -0.012867734767496586, 0.02055412344634533, -0.015582944266498089, 0.03920694440603256, 0.04763041064143181, -0.00854236725717783, 0.005783393979072571, 0.01891835778951645, 0.02863306924700737, -0.03987513482570648, -0.007275344803929329, 0.022222701460123062, 0.04344715178012848, -0.05906040966510773, 0.05592319741845131, -0.026315493509173393, -0.029787352308630943, 0.013282214291393757, 0.0046965619549155235, 0.022009436041116714, -0.006270267069339752, 0.04260571673512459, -0.029888998717069626, 0.04672796651721001, 0.029092101380228996, -0.017580125480890274, -0.00295923906378448, 0.005651270970702171, 0.004903861321508884, 0.018252231180667877, -0.0015850472263991833, 0.02743537351489067, -0.0002194604167016223, -0.008583593182265759, -0.023971159011125565, -0.015269983559846878, 0.007744838483631611, -0.015509812161326408, -0.00008896931103663519, -0.005242051091045141, -0.010387091897428036, -0.04814867675304413, -0.004385137930512428, -0.02482578158378601, -0.0014483417617157102, 0.022598672658205032, -0.015312722884118557, -0.030254201963543892, -0.008448917418718338, -0.036859918385744095, -0.0435514859855175, 0.021667523309588432, -0.002215228509157896, -0.005952723324298859, -0.07296974211931229, 0.011922505684196949, -0.022339222952723503, -0.03030172362923622, -0.043262701481580734, -0.01334918849170208, -0.04638683423399925, 0.09862697124481201, 0.01582542061805725, -0.018497738987207413, 0.007172340527176857, -0.03137056902050972, -0.01820315234363079, -0.04982191324234009, 0.05533413216471672, 0.022663595154881477, -0.023935554549098015, 0.033318083733320236, 0.015162404626607895, 0.005114560481160879, 0.026642775163054466, 0.045012932270765305, -0.02838132157921791, -0.01441830676048994, 0.019048672169446945, 0.0030860095284879208, -0.0026596023235470057, -0.05649620294570923, 0.029348915442824364, -0.015085621736943722, -0.018060844391584396, -0.005290572065860033, -0.05269848555326462, -0.01908656395971775, -0.018752478063106537, 0.027437154203653336, 0.008476793766021729, 0.03002701699733734, 0.020873606204986572, 0.015115558169782162, 0.040546171367168427, 0.025960728526115417, -0.01770162396132946, 0.0272522009909153, -0.010607029311358929, 0.014253846369683743, 0.025446316227316856, -0.013405685313045979, -0.08376959711313248, 0.01490564551204443, -0.05958472937345505, -0.026361368596553802, -0.01334189623594284, -0.012339917942881584, 0.02469993568956852, -0.07052519172430038, 0.0034633693285286427, 0.017446113750338554, -0.04581092670559883, 0.023654403164982796, 0.01825082115828991, -0.010360748507082462, 0.047237835824489594, -0.002521650865674019, 0.006695577874779701, 0.061687763780355453, 0.046771466732025146, 0.028616173192858696, 0.02530907467007637, 0.016567250713706017, 0.012675493024289608, -0.01756928116083145, -0.030747830867767334, -0.008965537883341312, 0.024456962943077087, -0.03818192705512047, 0.04673109948635101, -0.02900044061243534, -0.020516585558652878, -0.017056843265891075, 0.000019521832655300386, -0.016818026080727577, -0.02108328975737095, -0.011012300848960876, 0.04673364385962486, -0.029264073818922043, -0.012013973668217659, -0.040279559791088104, -0.0026113383937627077, 0.013367745094001293, 0.011508437804877758, -0.032967496663331985, 0.0366421602666378, -0.02528427541255951, -0.0002091699279844761, 0.023931296542286873, -0.009246885776519775, -0.006654473952949047, -0.03727416321635246, 0.0011988558107987046, -0.01578846387565136, 0.004127064719796181, 0.023262158036231995, -0.04432649165391922, -0.0555792935192585, -0.02924378030002117, 0.004924328997731209, 0.024964582175016403, 0.05812843143939972, -0.035327594727277756, -0.04276026040315628, -0.03831024467945099, 0.044843100011348724, -0.07147181034088135, 0.016745002940297127, -0.044689737260341644, 0.011296093463897705, -0.012881086207926273, 0.0037006838247179985 ]
<p>I want to evaluate a Gaussian PDF that does not exist because the determinant of sigma is either approx 0 or -inf (depends on parameters), and the condition number is of order 10^20.</p> <p>I need this density because I want to find the posterior mixing coefficients in an inverse problem with a Gaussian mixture prior. The formula for the posterior mixing coefficients looks like this:</p> <p>$\lambda_{(x|y)}^ j= \frac{\pi_j N(\mathbf{y}; \mu_{yj}, \Sigma_{yj})}{\sum_{k=1}^n\pi_k N(\mathbf{y}; \mu_{yk}, \Sigma_{yk})}$</p> <p>Does anyone have a tip on how I can approximate these coefficients/densities?</p> <p>I do not have a sample from (x|y). But I know $\mu_{x|y}^i$ and $\Sigma_{x|y}^i$.</p> <p>The full form of the posterior is</p> <p>$f(x|y)=\sum \lambda_{(x|y)}^ j N_m( \mathbf{\boldsymbol \mu_{x|y}^j,\boldsymbol \Sigma_{x| y}^j})$</p> <p>Where</p> <p>$\boldsymbol \mu_{x|y}^i =\boldsymbol \mu_{x}^i + \Gamma_{xy}^i (\Sigma_y^i )^{-1}(y-\mu_{y}^i)$</p> <p>$\boldsymbol \Sigma_{x|y}^i =\boldsymbol \Sigma_{x}^i + \Gamma_{xy}^i (\Sigma_y^i )^{-1}(\Gamma_{xy}^i)^T$</p>
74,398
[ -0.017852790653705597, -0.0028015642892569304, 0.03288471698760986, -0.024800129234790802, 0.02741672284901142, 0.004618010483682156, -0.02731390856206417, -0.020850570872426033, 0.023808151483535767, -0.07081101834774017, 0.03669745847582817, 0.06413675099611282, 0.09529666602611542, 0.02249886654317379, -0.012738039717078209, -0.004647768568247557, -0.02804279327392578, 0.0017816529143601656, -0.022785227745771408, -0.025234892964363098, 0.026167534291744232, 0.030894827097654343, 0.006774867884814739, -0.012840540148317814, -0.04237765446305275, 0.03593919053673744, 0.020531371235847473, -0.06054432690143585, -0.012200168333947659, 0.08746062219142914, -0.0387628898024559, -0.001677187392488122, 0.01998179592192173, 0.00827892404049635, 0.019513731822371483, -0.0031407938804477453, -0.03909038007259369, -0.028515515848994255, -0.01278624963015318, 0.017624996602535248, -0.043315447866916656, -0.051969897001981735, 0.0028522515203803778, 0.04418933391571045, 0.00874750129878521, 0.009763993322849274, -0.003779610386118293, -0.015583289787173271, 0.027476688846945763, -0.030821453779935837, 0.07508119940757751, 0.028968606144189835, 0.0379016138613224, 0.06029535457491875, -0.03564360737800598, -0.013888966292142868, 0.0303901769220829, 0.05977289751172066, 0.04648679867386818, -0.05790657550096512, 0.003320160089060664, -0.07815130054950714, 0.013781341724097729, -0.03555922955274582, -0.013520884327590466, -0.0032128894235938787, 0.02271616831421852, -0.03247322514653206, -0.016718877479434013, -0.02043113112449646, 0.025922589004039764, 0.01735498011112213, 0.02404305897653103, -0.0341658890247345, -0.00028693696367554367, -0.025348860770463943, 0.020447617396712303, 0.045318540185689926, 0.027260152623057365, 0.020850472152233124, 0.012604854069650173, 0.003708770265802741, 0.005804525222629309, 0.013992094434797764, -0.018390066921710968, 0.008616979233920574, 0.09373139590024948, 0.0007946813711896539, 0.03289784863591194, 0.0028827479109168053, -0.028099002316594124, 0.01775277592241764, 0.037766847759485245, 0.002872019074857235, -0.06324729323387146, 0.04101482406258583, -0.042089857161045074, 0.0569617822766304, 0.014395798556506634, -0.015432413667440414, -0.025671714916825294, -0.03294713422656059, 0.02671927772462368, 0.054798223078250885, -0.055883996188640594, -0.01472514122724533, -0.004999414086341858, -0.0031920361798256636, -0.02346174418926239, -0.034075137227773666, -0.03777899965643883, 0.02060794271528721, -0.027537589892745018, -0.021452225744724274, 0.01783214509487152, -0.013194303028285503, 0.008281957358121872, -0.02589460089802742, 0.01800118014216423, 0.10190623998641968, 0.043096963316202164, -0.014437040314078331, 0.0011025677667930722, -0.05974956974387169, -0.03493719547986984, -0.0184596199542284, 0.007992725819349289, -0.005052742548286915, -0.026967892423272133, 0.03732561692595482, 0.008591722697019577, 0.01364403311163187, 0.06314060837030411, 0.015487122349441051, -0.0023118427488952875, -0.02906905673444271, -0.05410628020763397, -0.059365928173065186, 0.0786767229437828, -0.01300844643265009, 0.027889061719179153, -0.05989951267838478, 0.008436879143118858, 0.03727920353412628, 0.014780052937567234, -0.0035106136929243803, 0.02416328527033329, -0.022454867139458656, 0.019203420728445053, -0.01778467185795307, -0.0155267883092165, -0.04749593511223793, -0.013748767785727978, -0.0044168890453875065, -0.028269192203879356, -0.08161500096321106, 0.03905804082751274, 0.028399264439940453, -0.011095385998487473, -0.007531340699642897, 0.04698186367750168, 0.01377982459962368, -0.01415620744228363, 0.0005977318505756557, 0.0028191478922963142, -0.06613145768642426, 0.06162456050515175, 0.026333719491958618, 0.04415310546755791, 0.03097422420978546, -0.032695721834897995, -0.011828129179775715, 0.01631699688732624, 0.021486451849341393, 0.05164908990263939, -0.058554910123348236, -0.0038670673966407776, -0.021939951926469803, 0.01717083528637886, 0.03050139918923378, -0.002316071419045329, 0.001605796511285007, -0.04122760519385338, -0.025898942723870277, 0.06160428002476692, -0.007617990951985121, 0.0277789905667305, -0.015044569969177246, 0.03956703841686249, -0.07907047867774963, -0.014044410549104214, -0.039495158940553665, -0.0045273215509951115, 0.0023842742666602135, -0.03829237446188927, 0.03940487653017044, -0.005960180424153805, 0.03984125703573227, 0.04729820787906647, -0.028411678969860077, -0.020257171243429184, -0.03456457704305649, 0.06254754215478897, 0.012519841082394123, -0.0040200441144406796, 0.001814132439903915, 0.07580505311489105, -0.02591225877404213, 0.03640962019562721, -0.035230603069067, -0.06264628469944, -0.034626007080078125, -0.025639021769165993, 0.017274804413318634, 0.021121591329574585, -0.053129177540540695, 0.017284071072936058, -0.0026502020191401243, 0.0012254964094609022, 0.014793885871767998, -0.045310746878385544, 0.023030148819088936, 0.102203369140625, 0.026417355984449387, -0.017324982210993767, -0.013447367586195469, -0.014141758903861046, 0.0313686728477478, 0.0018118106527253985, 0.016383111476898193, -0.025179950520396233, -0.03831772133708, 0.03872620686888695, 0.03172379359602928, -0.047357380390167236, 0.009143239818513393, 0.032835278660058975, 0.019488850608468056, 0.026883888989686966, 0.00928452517837286, -0.01935056410729885, -0.06075514480471611, 0.012398380786180496, -0.003203979227691889, 0.02099110372364521, 0.010385478846728802, 0.025928687304258347, -0.012111946009099483, 0.041955314576625824, 0.0008442648686468601, -0.01913723535835743, 0.03795471787452698, -0.005510034970939159, -0.01566937193274498, -0.038124337792396545, -0.03137477487325668, 0.061883848160505295, -0.011550216004252434, 0.00852967519313097, 0.016355548053979874, -0.026678720489144325, 0.006546394433826208, -0.01005924865603447, -0.02175036072731018, 0.015192028135061264, 0.011408483609557152, -0.03937526047229767, 0.007386482320725918, 0.014604803174734116, -0.04021089896559715, 0.01874341443181038, -0.0009418681729584932, -0.004428906366229057, -0.04271708428859711, 0.0012911563972011209, 0.010550431907176971, 0.010042417794466019, 0.004532478284090757, -0.007728001102805138, -0.029946304857730865, 0.017707519233226776, 0.039791788905858994, 0.02286330610513687, -0.002795563079416752, -0.052913080900907516, -0.005552543327212334, -0.0182451494038105, 0.03277270123362541, 0.0122888945043087, 0.018877273425459862, -0.048641033470630646, -0.018460532650351524, -0.01974998041987419, -0.05896330624818802, -0.014073221944272518, 0.00850744266062975, 0.0006168197724036872, -0.011088280007243156, -0.01200710516422987, 0.023386726155877113, 0.003934918902814388, -0.018268989399075508, 0.028779784217476845, -0.01541922241449356, -0.03759082034230232, -0.032374363392591476, -0.011429278180003166, 0.004542680457234383, -0.010904954746365547, 0.030544985085725784, 0.04717063903808594, -0.009607202373445034, 0.02381172589957714, -0.09915521740913391, -0.040594760328531265, 0.008409674279391766, 0.004053732380270958, 0.025806564837694168, 0.023469554260373116, -0.025780009105801582, 0.08600660413503647, 0.052810221910476685, -0.021706705912947655, -0.0204174742102623, -0.005209526978433132, 0.00003740496322279796, -0.039825230836868286, 0.02160319685935974, 0.0074651483446359634, -0.018763000145554543, 0.04824661463499069, 0.006116144824773073, -0.019581040367484093, 0.07272385060787201, -0.005821045488119125, 0.000593370757997036, 0.024465037509799004, -0.029132241383194923, -0.0198470801115036, 0.04809200018644333, -0.0053222584538161755, -0.02630499005317688, 0.013822041451931, -0.01710686646401882, 0.02393423579633236, 0.020542658865451813, -0.04133385792374611, -0.013581005856394768, 0.009794891811907291, -0.006066408473998308, -0.058118198066949844, 0.055000849068164825, 0.006378707475960255, -0.06741522252559662, 0.008541992865502834, 0.03036416694521904, 0.024071941152215004, -0.016829580068588257, -0.004976788070052862, 0.048912398517131805, 0.019162284210324287, -0.03238075226545334, 0.00014806083345320076, 0.013041083700954914, -0.010695400647819042, -0.007372352760285139, -0.02183466963469982, 0.004803904332220554, 0.023985527455806732, 0.014406027272343636, 0.00037169974530115724, -0.04770807549357414, -0.016535727307200432, 0.0096129160374403, -0.03962039202451706, 0.018374336883425713, -0.0056744893081486225, 0.04103289917111397, 0.038528922945261, 0.0415027029812336, -0.012961355037987232, -0.006535575725138187, -0.001187658286653459, -0.027178457006812096, -0.055434808135032654, 0.015483175404369831, 0.006359686143696308, -0.009533842094242573, 0.025617465376853943, -0.013286018744111061, 0.06212054193019867, -0.022440219298005104, 0.028585361316800117, -0.0010617994703352451, 0.032082267105579376, -0.010487167164683342, -0.012564588338136673, -0.039106354117393494, -0.009493897669017315, 0.0051566059701144695, -0.00047817977610975504, 0.040208227932453156, 0.02457716129720211, 0.01587100140750408, 0.01944889687001705, -0.0028876245487481356, -0.018121395260095596, -0.013474582694470882, 0.05134459584951401, -0.0007221445557661355, 0.02534371241927147, 0.008814647793769836, 0.0069008865393698215, -0.03808751702308655, 0.052425771951675415, 0.024112924933433533, 0.054148416966199875, 0.037437308579683304, 0.019950054585933685, 0.019673388451337814, -0.012971251271665096, -0.03873370960354805, 0.020223122090101242, 0.01221613958477974, -0.009378788061439991, 0.01822248101234436, 0.036705564707517624, 0.02482079155743122, -0.03840945288538933, 0.01688144914805889, 0.04758422449231148, -0.0012640641070902348, 0.013913540169596672, -0.031576793640851974, -0.013741259463131428, -0.0035294746048748493, 0.014246872626245022, 0.008645782247185707, 0.03248841315507889, -0.010255123488605022, -0.0048249284736812115, 0.01810838282108307, -0.015471207909286022, 0.022563008591532707, -0.008466572500765324, 0.014589754864573479, 0.05716973543167114, 0.013049791567027569, -0.004479837138205767, 0.018835080787539482, 0.05636998638510704, 0.04698564484715462, 0.016996044665575027, -0.013196375221014023, -0.060957491397857666, 0.006394857075065374, 0.03979898616671562, 0.06054488196969032, -0.0003096859436482191, 0.006335293408483267, -0.077081598341465, -0.03358349949121475, 0.032359108328819275, -0.010389787144958973, 0.009095460176467896, -0.014194450341165066, 0.0068974569439888, 0.01583036594092846, -0.041058968752622604, -0.042774707078933716, 0.0036566774360835552, -0.040343277156353, 0.04574142396450043, -0.043456804007291794, -0.018262190744280815, -0.047309137880802155, 0.021295776590704918, 0.0020869062282145023, 0.050738926976919174, -0.02680537849664688, -0.03030637465417385, 0.005879194010049105, 0.006451851688325405, 0.020991338416934013, -0.07446756958961487, 0.03778883442282677, -0.0009314999915659428, -0.012370244599878788, 0.04713375121355057, -0.015506588853895664, -0.03086209110915661, 0.03084641695022583, 0.009950931183993816, -0.007931907661259174, 0.020989881828427315, -0.037164073437452316, 0.05008334293961525, 0.04825090989470482, -0.006106297019869089, 0.02829977124929428, 0.03296983987092972, 0.005901302210986614, 0.024770906195044518, -0.06675946712493896, 0.008757345378398895, -0.010896080173552036, 0.027382157742977142, -0.061735525727272034, 0.011998250149190426, 0.02816581539809704, 0.05321198329329491, -0.0039802491664886475, 0.04132861644029617, 0.02224969118833542, -0.02034040167927742, 0.015991967171430588, 0.048586178570985794, 0.00308025861158967, -0.00956003088504076, 0.03919883444905281, 0.02026204578578472, 0.01506088674068451, 0.015353336930274963, 0.030517535284161568, 0.005336387548595667, 0.04116581380367279, -0.025552932173013687, -0.014180263504385948, 0.03354768455028534, -0.03235454484820366, -0.019181430339813232, 0.03407876566052437, -0.026184994727373123, 0.05349578708410263, -0.01317216083407402, 0.04792089760303497, -0.0029338132590055466, -0.01268646027892828, 0.005899686831980944, 0.013474778272211552, 0.0014031125465407968, 0.02932691015303135, -0.04691072553396225, -0.02220185659825802, -0.014849265106022358, 0.025708001106977463, -0.055736251175403595, -0.023799069225788116, 0.0029138450045138597, -0.008984565734863281, -0.048231858760118484, -0.0654214397072792, 0.002618080470710993, -0.015034818090498447, -0.031719449907541275, 0.0029936032369732857, 0.026092328131198883, 0.00713671650737524, -0.024960746988654137, -0.001702766981907189, 0.01675545796751976, 0.024639597162604332, -0.011102824471890926, -0.022152261808514595, 0.0348573662340641, -0.013919241726398468, 0.002491193125024438, 0.02220373973250389, 0.004757169168442488, -0.008363448083400726, 0.023921262472867966, -0.011107434518635273, 0.016377048566937447, 0.01926557533442974, -0.012694157660007477, -0.0060821156948804855, 0.01905207335948944, 0.0008512846543453634, 0.0007781589520163834, -0.020984556525945663, -0.016944143921136856, -0.03337566554546356, 0.0035741841420531273, -0.034265294671058655, 0.007841357961297035, -0.016724588349461555, -0.005657729227095842, 0.07043452560901642, 0.0022863957565277815, -0.007213908713310957, -0.0006918985163792968, 0.1046769842505455, -0.017458124086260796, 0.0073868450708687305, 0.025602351874113083, 0.030537934973835945, 0.06542593985795975, 0.03369656577706337, 0.009644248522818089, 0.031199410557746887, -0.016938654705882072, -0.04951868951320648, 0.010590740479528904, -0.07312273979187012, 0.021211393177509308, 0.05307531729340553, -0.010811899788677692, 0.03377871960401535, 0.011017663404345512, -0.024083159863948822, -0.0031656816136091948, -0.030002014711499214, -0.027030210942029953, 0.015686701983213425, -0.03188619390130043, 0.041830986738204956, -0.012588190846145153, -0.022893797606229782, 0.03907202184200287, 0.016727635636925697, -0.008823970332741737, 0.013563336804509163, 0.019193314015865326, 0.013387830927968025, 0.04185069352388382, -0.03293124586343765, -0.03052418865263462, 0.02342532016336918, -0.04794899746775627, 0.014047883450984955, -0.013195459730923176, -0.04827353358268738, 0.06102718412876129, 0.037952300161123276, 0.018678974360227585, -0.0017885126871988177, -0.006430258043110371, -0.009791508316993713, 0.011242564767599106, 0.04951104521751404, -0.01637951098382473, 0.008978906087577343, 0.013983015902340412, 0.047902438789606094, -0.018631702288985252, 0.037387777119874954, -0.04607464745640755, -0.0732155591249466, -0.03461772948503494, 0.006060837302356958, -0.042616453021764755, -0.0074163153767585754, -0.020921656861901283, -0.013246234506368637, 0.009779484942555428, 0.0029842702206224203, 0.01961042359471321, -0.0054228100925683975, -0.009763430804014206, -0.02198573388159275, 0.04348810762166977, 0.027526158839464188, 0.015476849861443043, -0.027524979785084724, 0.012208416126668453, 0.12523235380649567, 0.033312972635030746, 0.04473230615258217, -0.03436090424656868, 0.014628209173679352, -0.010783056728541851, 0.0028161462396383286, -0.03650794178247452, 0.007189382333308458, 0.018834033980965614, -0.044229935854673386, 0.037171561270952225, 0.05312031880021095, 0.02888721227645874, 0.006126551888883114, 0.019540227949619293, -0.069141685962677, -0.035156071186065674, 0.01789669133722782, -0.03970940783619881, -0.03245773911476135, -0.03682762384414673, -0.03627290576696396, 0.029596326872706413, -0.0040522231720387936, -0.03746568784117699, -0.04999524727463722, -0.02340497262775898, -0.01804845966398716, 0.016612257808446884, 0.013815773651003838, -0.029656417667865753, 0.011643118225038052, 0.01281893439590931, 0.046436890959739685, -0.005321172997355461, 0.0441017784178257, -0.0322679802775383, 0.013912447728216648, 0.03510269895195961, 0.01500862929970026, 0.013126485981047153, 0.0035802973434329033, 0.005072755739092827, -0.03610381484031677, -0.04147149994969368, -0.01232482772320509, 0.07081292569637299, -0.02071371115744114, -0.007161922287195921, -0.014448698610067368, 0.012790231965482235, 0.009799888357520103, -0.02886035107076168, -0.0003954598505515605, 0.011338647454977036, 0.05369490012526512, -0.008604100905358791, -0.012853609398007393, -0.004233372397720814, 0.022321008145809174, 0.012926003895699978, 0.060035571455955505, 0.021707436069846153, -0.02000044845044613, -0.024505581706762314, -0.00797991268336773, 0.042305100709199905, 0.002825539093464613, 0.011142211966216564, -0.04168204218149185, -0.030433179810643196, 0.0048440867103636265, -0.04350164532661438, 0.02731824852526188, -0.04595716670155525, 0.007068350911140442, -0.03323163092136383, 0.016037067398428917, -0.0026742706540971994, -0.0618552640080452, 0.0080188550055027, -0.04670014604926109, 0.027742670848965645, -0.010637300089001656, -0.00784367322921753, 0.015220006927847862, 0.029816454276442528, 0.028513632714748383, -0.0012972622644156218, 0.013159510679543018, 0.04029596596956253, 0.01600269041955471, -0.016573188826441765, -0.07068123668432236, -0.0061995708383619785, 0.0036106922198086977, -0.02212001197040081, 0.011378752067685127, 0.050771359354257584, 0.02283254638314247, 0.08869440108537674, 0.022570481523871422, 0.02127782814204693, -0.03656964376568794, -0.011227096430957317, -0.0016768616624176502, -0.055240288376808167, -0.015046949498355389, -0.011491863057017326, 0.03304332122206688, -0.015250366181135178, -0.0024368492886424065, -0.02112126536667347, 0.018455367535352707, 0.02858966588973999, -0.01390771009027958, -0.04581555724143982, -0.046250320971012115, 0.01114376075565815, -0.028520340099930763, 0.006046193186193705, 0.019128765910863876, 0.022144358605146408, -0.000645048450678587, -0.021783258765935898, -0.0060019418597221375, 0.013918598182499409, -0.011557045392692089, -0.061186064034700394, -0.014513425529003143, 0.04223845526576042, 0.01600135862827301, 0.0235190037637949, -0.010507134720683098, 0.010306248441338539, 0.010518643073737621, 0.02737085334956646, -0.02511684037744999, -0.03839605301618576, -0.0014610993675887585, -0.05799751356244087, -0.06564414501190186, 0.014892018400132656, 0.020407933741807938, 0.05831530690193176, 0.00128833984490484, -0.0034518607426434755, -0.06269442290067673, 0.020499764010310173, -0.005161589942872524, -0.005313019268214703, -0.019969027489423752, 0.0098423445597291, 0.0017383694648742676, -0.02498272806406021, 0.01921854354441166, -0.008651676587760448, 0.009133683517575264, 0.0038822523783892393, 0.02748274616897106, -0.013415052555501461, -0.017438607290387154, 0.04978213831782341, -0.0067896051332354546, -0.014025949873030186, -0.02892991714179516, -0.004180212039500475, -0.01774773932993412, 0.0603276863694191, -0.014202909544110298, 0.0513431653380394, -0.021230211481451988, 0.03575067222118378, -0.10135533660650253, -0.01618799939751625, 0.011411719024181366, 0.034285012632608414, 0.023461533710360527, -0.08704716712236404, 0.03363191708922386, 0.006080843508243561, -0.025171050801873207, 0.02285751886665821, 0.009726415388286114, 0.01267809048295021, -0.03134164959192276, 0.0293236393481493, -0.012785185128450394, 0.02130802720785141, 0.023416470736265182, 0.02782333828508854, 0.03811132162809372, 0.04249998927116394, 0.012648760341107845, -0.03830686956644058, -0.014884041622281075, 0.0028376698028296232, 0.04010321572422981, -0.06038873642683029, 0.04848795011639595, -0.02342558093369007, -0.034772153943777084, 0.00722862733528018, 0.003905241610482335, 0.011151844635605812, -0.021142810583114624, 0.03686298802495003, -0.01870586723089218, 0.05135398730635643, 0.03437292203307152, 0.020631516352295876, 0.023674078285694122, 0.006764549762010574, 0.009092207066714764, 0.01507500745356083, -0.034322187304496765, 0.016070012003183365, 0.019454581663012505, -0.011591166257858276, -0.02542034536600113, 0.017828721553087234, -0.01727847196161747, -0.01750083453953266, 0.011224289424717426, 0.008014114573597908, -0.0002605050685815513, -0.01481659896671772, 0.026440870016813278, -0.05490003153681755, -0.014466584660112858, 0.001734304940328002, 0.015834040939807892, -0.01541908923536539, 0.024227933958172798, -0.01885717175900936, -0.054481279104948044, -0.0004486460529733449, -0.03509068861603737, 0.007711916230618954, -0.03529900684952736, 0.004310017917305231, -0.01194735523313284, 0.008687319234013557, 0.008571330457925797, -0.003982649650424719, -0.055173058062791824, 0.041466955095529556, -0.01580897718667984, -0.013896789401769638, 0.01968085579574108, 0.01194741576910019, 0.02185637131333351, -0.06278770416975021, 0.0043539670296013355, 0.01803390309214592, -0.05491369217634201, 0.015969762578606606, -0.00666812201961875, -0.032407816499471664, -0.03876292705535889, 0.062048908323049545, -0.00422356091439724, -0.012761039659380913, -0.011185355484485626, 0.041332025080919266, -0.012645702809095383, -0.05160893127322197, 0.023782601580023766, -0.014304805546998978, -0.014944070018827915, -0.01300404965877533, -0.004202038515359163, 0.013233489356935024, 0.013180293142795563, 0.04216068983078003, -0.005900613497942686, -0.02340441755950451, -0.028978506103157997, -0.028330978006124496, 0.02874487079679966, -0.014360327273607254, -0.007339525036513805, 0.040961816906929016, 0.01844022050499916, -0.01619659923017025, 0.014407590962946415, 0.013263543136417866, -0.07746979594230652, -0.009814132004976273, 0.00629449961706996, -0.026874497532844543, -0.0018465190660208464, -0.02381272241473198, 0.013087107799947262, -0.05122542753815651, 0.0012605327647179365, 0.017568282783031464, -0.03249826282262802, 0.016062630340456963, 0.04913312569260597, 0.047041911631822586, 0.05550277605652809, 0.032188400626182556, 0.016551246866583824, -0.0007764280890114605, -0.0001479888887843117, 0.015429404564201832, 0.024592723697423935, 0.01998620107769966, -0.020689988508820534, 0.002337636658921838, -0.0000633808522252366, -0.029810383915901184, 0.0178694985806942, -0.03261103481054306, 0.02052248641848564, -0.027387816458940506, -0.027846431359648705, 0.01393677107989788, -0.02838992141187191, 0.010081962682306767, -0.041745178401470184, -0.021966101601719856, 0.06252563744783401, -0.04082316905260086, -0.016042280942201614, -0.03834737092256546, 0.009139197878539562, -0.045469753444194794, 0.022744929417967796, -0.002456067129969597, 0.03045356646180153, 0.03279825299978256, -0.0010470974957570434, -0.01986449956893921, -0.05958114564418793, 0.014979435130953789, -0.05580318719148636, -0.0074918936006724834, -0.018518751487135887, 0.01138011459261179, 0.021656055003404617, -0.02127019315958023, -0.01747307926416397, -0.01869194209575653, 0.00004584206544677727, -0.007250388152897358, 0.0517905168235302, -0.05437330901622772, -0.05296541750431061, -0.010462398640811443, 0.05196986719965935, -0.014160916209220886, 0.031298305839300156, -0.021972155198454857, 0.008191530592739582, -0.020281460136175156, -0.048817481845617294 ]
<p>I want to estimate the survival function $S(t_0)=1-F(t_0)$, at a specific point $t_0$ where $F$ is a continuous cumulative distribution function, based on an uncensored sample $x_1,..,x_n$ and a nonparametric estimator. So far, I am considering two estimators $\hat S(t_0)=1-\hat F(t_0)$, where $\hat F$ is</p> <p>(1) Kernel density estimator</p> <p>(2) The empirical CDF.</p> <p>What other methods could I consider using?</p>
37,268
[ -0.020501654595136642, -0.07007905840873718, 0.02630145475268364, 0.020551297813653946, -0.021587949246168137, 0.0048808082938194275, 0.0245372261852026, -0.009753933176398277, 0.030865458771586418, -0.03660202398896217, 0.026641547679901123, 0.06635896116495132, 0.014877237379550934, 0.00706608546897769, 0.024610400199890137, -0.022606410086154938, -0.014937611296772957, 0.0006005584145896137, -0.008429192006587982, -0.017629943788051605, -0.0032563244458287954, 0.026358390226960182, 0.0028354055248200893, -0.008368815295398235, -0.03134533017873764, 0.038673512637615204, 0.015309966169297695, -0.007203694898635149, -0.01830497570335865, 0.08462518453598022, -0.01340425293892622, -0.046818312257528305, -0.008898526430130005, 0.04017038643360138, -0.008482304401695728, -0.004024834837764502, -0.06741909682750702, -0.07035687565803528, -0.023134130984544754, 0.0426177941262722, -0.03848586603999138, -0.048659153282642365, -0.03707101196050644, 0.022266512736678123, 0.01823330670595169, 0.04575725272297859, 0.004736049100756645, -0.04655642434954643, 0.009541705250740051, -0.04664061591029167, 0.03418012335896492, 0.0007649034960195422, 0.03631812706589699, 0.0076232170686125755, -0.012462104670703411, -0.007947266101837158, 0.04161475971341133, 0.0735386535525322, -0.0006067918729968369, -0.028807852417230606, -0.05424801632761955, -0.05146488919854164, -0.015137644484639168, -0.01532058510929346, -0.010593120008707047, 0.01749095693230629, -0.01515959482640028, -0.024105891585350037, -0.004060383420437574, -0.040926311165094376, 0.011863425374031067, -0.006774186156690121, 0.029974747449159622, 0.015432052314281464, -0.006497036665678024, -0.027989406138658524, 0.010744071565568447, 0.020493431016802788, 0.06872658431529999, 0.01597539335489273, 0.030671775341033936, -0.02140306495130062, 0.029498249292373657, 0.06165469065308571, 0.008695218712091446, 0.03251159191131592, 0.07729680836200714, 0.0337885282933712, 0.0255273450165987, 0.06731010973453522, -0.020911889150738716, -0.02356952615082264, 0.027998968958854675, -0.04535043239593506, -0.03083048202097416, 0.013013704679906368, -0.009542537853121758, 0.039529748260974884, 0.003136095590889454, -0.0022799945436418056, -0.016352619975805283, -0.04738812521100044, 0.02219417504966259, 0.020331788808107376, -0.0023937809746712446, 0.0053507136180996895, 0.016723977401852608, 0.00161764828953892, 0.0333646722137928, 0.005061743315309286, -0.06150718033313751, 0.026271458715200424, 0.020204557105898857, -0.0065758125856518745, 0.037951450794935226, 0.02623124234378338, -0.03022807650268078, -0.01807764545083046, 0.052780456840991974, 0.0631367564201355, 0.046060364693403244, -0.0008416459313593805, 0.01603667624294758, -0.018573777750134468, -0.06336145102977753, 0.010634682141244411, 0.04490647464990616, -0.006905423477292061, -0.019272278994321823, 0.03095020167529583, 0.003851967630907893, -0.03721429780125618, 0.04991226643323898, 0.006054750178009272, 0.027546918019652367, 0.015825452283024788, -0.05439825728535652, -0.04390215128660202, 0.016264894977211952, 0.007089103106409311, 0.0131523497402668, -0.02553771249949932, 0.00010328934149583802, 0.033615972846746445, 0.04038942977786064, 0.0202278234064579, 0.028198935091495514, 0.013068530708551407, 0.036151811480522156, -0.006076782010495663, -0.007185652852058411, -0.01387857086956501, -0.014353916980326176, -0.0008719152538105845, -0.06077764928340912, -0.057680632919073105, 0.051829155534505844, 0.03608018904924393, 0.0037249322049319744, -0.05288269370794296, 0.08347893506288528, -0.025260446593165398, 0.019028060138225555, -0.016745872795581818, 0.01296892762184143, -0.02236652374267578, 0.0741768330335617, 0.005641881842166185, 0.013800833374261856, 0.018904155120253563, 0.026533016934990883, 0.04641680791974068, 0.013457645662128925, 0.02485697530210018, 0.028653116896748543, -0.050457730889320374, -0.014814610593020916, -0.025132451206445694, 0.010988201946020126, 0.009942950680851936, 0.006971719674766064, 0.006062787491828203, 0.007826291024684906, -0.013930042274296284, 0.040505923330783844, 0.048727795481681824, 0.0006907103233970702, -0.01460349466651678, -0.0014618607237935066, -0.013012941926717758, -0.03128662332892418, -0.05434149131178856, 0.006219181697815657, 0.0015149908140301704, -0.015697607770562172, 0.05514012649655342, -0.006040251813828945, 0.015297327190637589, -0.04409201070666313, 0.006418434903025627, -0.0010204465361312032, -0.007762300781905651, 0.028428494930267334, -0.049854256212711334, -0.010143258608877659, 0.04473507031798363, 0.05682413652539253, -0.016776297241449356, 0.05483556166291237, -0.046490177512168884, -0.03389551863074303, -0.04187401011586189, -0.06813618540763855, 0.017537347972393036, -0.037856556475162506, -0.005387277342379093, 0.027831649407744408, -0.022036399692296982, -0.0031829006038606167, 0.011616813950240612, -0.04800988361239433, 0.06132005155086517, 0.05609990656375885, 0.0565471351146698, 0.019108843058347702, 0.006983103230595589, 0.02082866244018078, -0.01621297001838684, -0.009279968217015266, -0.019077423959970474, -0.018139075487852097, -0.004419143311679363, 0.06656169891357422, -0.013156029395759106, -0.019218098372220993, 0.025134628638625145, 0.05653341859579086, -0.01125096995383501, 0.02191608026623726, 0.006318658124655485, -0.025003619492053986, 0.0005185901536606252, 0.03580984100699425, 0.004335569683462381, -0.01038214098662138, -0.027822770178318024, 0.048045143485069275, 0.004857669584453106, 0.04578220844268799, 0.005424517672508955, -0.013569077476859093, 0.06832558661699295, -0.011934179812669754, 0.01249030139297247, -0.011153600178658962, -0.035135477781295776, 0.017824118956923485, -0.05709383264183998, -0.022210855036973953, 0.018212970346212387, -0.014032069593667984, 0.02155434340238571, 0.012296156026422977, -0.014974619261920452, 0.04809147119522095, 0.016537053510546684, -0.04228312894701958, 0.011748461984097958, 0.012960243038833141, -0.05833124369382858, -0.007820283994078636, -0.002971083391457796, -0.04904349520802498, -0.02062832936644554, -0.02021665871143341, 0.03373734652996063, -0.008326868526637554, 0.015388436615467072, -0.017467183992266655, -0.03679432347416878, 0.0016967406263574958, -0.029706498607993126, 0.032825224101543427, 0.024275386705994606, -0.05200948566198349, 0.0017507822485640645, -0.011204911395907402, -0.03654770180583, 0.04968477785587311, 0.02114735171198845, -0.0032645855098962784, -0.008755306713283062, -0.012484663166105747, -0.052822571247816086, -0.009671208448708057, -0.03233414143323898, 0.0016236933879554272, -0.041016750037670135, -0.029720783233642578, 0.05834006145596504, 0.029086237773299217, -0.037364840507507324, 0.05942026153206825, -0.034672923386096954, -0.033508699387311935, -0.022980714216828346, 0.034944526851177216, 0.03151481971144676, -0.013385854661464691, 0.030827155336737633, -0.0005376816843636334, -0.010395989753305912, 0.02220277301967144, -0.06018460914492607, -0.03220156207680702, 0.022691603749990463, 0.010270321741700172, 0.01913636364042759, 0.02145754173398018, 0.000173788852407597, 0.061745960265398026, 0.04492589086294174, -0.024843813851475716, -0.04749375954270363, -0.009652482345700264, -0.016216842457652092, 0.024341987445950508, -0.0352739617228508, 0.004275750368833542, 0.014893408864736557, 0.0029563060961663723, -0.017632272094488144, -0.01802331954240799, 0.06998558342456818, 0.01968359388411045, -0.0006984352949075401, 0.01579279825091362, 0.005062666721642017, -0.011447099037468433, 0.058004382997751236, 0.01923348754644394, 0.006886746268719435, -0.0025122580118477345, -0.007331580854952335, -0.039619870483875275, 0.019173284992575645, -0.02693246118724346, 0.01099700853228569, -0.002023147651925683, -0.023225706070661545, -0.02574632130563259, 0.006479873321950436, 0.029939761385321617, -0.02009957656264305, -0.007028793450444937, 0.02329227142035961, 0.060755420476198196, -0.05920075625181198, 0.039877600967884064, 0.02433866262435913, 0.050029680132865906, -0.01553216390311718, -0.007729297038167715, -0.029909824952483177, 0.005616490729153156, 0.029597332701086998, -0.01889694668352604, -0.04857794567942619, 0.026015963405370712, 0.06521836668252945, 0.018504653126001358, -0.01895022764801979, -0.027972182258963585, -0.0008484389400109649, -0.056489091366529465, 0.010501338168978691, -0.006563588511198759, 0.09325101226568222, 0.017807813361287117, 0.012345226481556892, 0.054440487176179886, -0.03772507607936859, 0.01092788577079773, 0.05813773348927498, -0.08793336898088455, 0.04782428219914436, 0.00007588261360069737, -0.023989804089069366, -0.025904003530740738, 0.026182686910033226, 0.052386749535799026, 0.02143407054245472, 0.022885266691446304, 0.0010778947034850717, 0.03014262020587921, -0.0040534501895308495, -0.022979311645030975, -0.0466754324734211, -0.0067398399114608765, -0.028987163677811623, 0.013416679576039314, 0.019140010699629784, -0.01133999414741993, 0.010091596283018589, 0.048387955874204636, 0.006233331747353077, 0.01960679516196251, -0.03325596824288368, 0.007732235360890627, 0.02720954269170761, 0.04316869378089905, 0.02961653284728527, 0.03466223180294037, -0.03631778061389923, 0.020751595497131348, 0.006790884770452976, 0.052291758358478546, 0.043648798018693924, 0.002470269100740552, -0.0075872913002967834, -0.035341776907444, -0.007502011954784393, 0.0023211538791656494, 0.02889333665370941, -0.017176281660795212, 0.012005501426756382, 0.09730303287506104, 0.005518755409866571, -0.06945238262414932, 0.000792746723163873, 0.035487160086631775, 0.030911345034837723, 0.037611961364746094, -0.036624643951654434, -0.005831692833453417, -0.005124504212290049, -0.01811067946255207, 0.02610928565263748, 0.04853729531168938, 0.005338617134839296, 0.004452450666576624, 0.03909873589873314, -0.0019560647197067738, -0.023669905960559845, -0.02912038564682007, 0.03278017044067383, 0.08107863366603851, -0.0003010313957929611, -0.03287377953529358, 0.048464588820934296, 0.032255809754133224, 0.05008428171277046, 0.01929013803601265, 0.024623019620776176, -0.08435992896556854, -0.0060366299003362656, 0.05104738846421242, 0.03732314333319664, 0.007580296136438847, -0.027004726231098175, -0.04640009254217148, -0.023950669914484024, 0.023222994059324265, -0.015897784382104874, -0.001992078498005867, -0.007897835224866867, -0.016482066363096237, -0.006669326685369015, -0.03667770326137543, -0.04384442791342735, 0.025296833366155624, -0.0011950446059927344, 0.009478616528213024, -0.026691466569900513, 0.004999320488423109, -0.021763242781162262, 0.03436202183365822, -0.00005086789315100759, 0.08048569411039352, -0.0030666447710245848, -0.019821027293801308, 0.005931659135967493, 0.034535881131887436, 0.0023907374124974012, -0.03758106753230095, 0.014790312387049198, -0.010511000640690327, -0.014932794496417046, 0.03961243852972984, -0.001306464895606041, -0.028985770419239998, 0.02676176093518734, 0.010900232009589672, -0.044170625507831573, 0.034174609929323196, -0.015064029023051262, 0.029934702441096306, -0.005586443468928337, 0.01737206242978573, 0.05388147756457329, 0.045755352824926376, 0.03197534754872322, 0.000031704250432085246, -0.001189923263154924, -0.019092490896582603, -0.05783238261938095, -0.011488168500363827, -0.03400197625160217, -0.023362835869193077, -0.04091816395521164, -0.008228830993175507, 0.009896163828670979, 0.04739415645599365, -0.018540790304541588, -0.0027628240641206503, 0.04633784666657448, 0.015274429693818092, 0.021869445219635963, -0.00705404719337821, 0.01437634788453579, 0.018134646117687225, 0.0012277303030714393, -0.005517994984984398, -0.012990212067961693, -0.0032615000382065773, 0.008866135030984879, -0.00002470921208441723, -0.03996343910694122, 0.004646721296012402, -0.0475194975733757, -0.03902708739042282, 0.018555454909801483, -0.028249330818653107, 0.0456743948161602, -0.0072242217138409615, 0.05547705665230751, -0.011810904368758202, -0.03852945566177368, 0.006511635612696409, 0.041597411036491394, -0.005701515357941389, 0.0679827332496643, -0.07311748713254929, 0.06505925208330154, 0.02032853290438652, -0.044508881866931915, -0.0547652430832386, -0.02894565649330616, 0.04025580734014511, 0.010824641212821007, -0.02802448160946369, -0.04014930501580238, 0.02996358834207058, -0.035371121019124985, -0.032253000885248184, -0.007109921891242266, 0.011759753338992596, 0.011269223876297474, -0.011251344345510006, -0.011173389852046967, 0.028634630143642426, 0.05351210758090019, 0.00087520363740623, -0.015055098570883274, 0.015259996987879276, -0.00787152536213398, -0.04846924543380737, 0.005156958010047674, -0.01959408074617386, -0.022634726017713547, 0.022609302774071693, -0.01674760691821575, -0.017411958426237106, 0.011276831850409508, -0.010892977938055992, -0.018022730946540833, 0.02558722533285618, -0.0018667879048734903, 0.003580728778615594, 0.0020919840317219496, -0.014284534379839897, -0.0314217135310173, -0.014633347280323505, -0.003253950271755457, 0.003491913666948676, -0.006114240735769272, -0.018906377255916595, 0.03399087116122246, -0.016795262694358826, -0.020672950893640518, 0.008773398585617542, 0.03193548694252968, 0.01675921119749546, 0.0004980673547834158, -0.015819517895579338, 0.002970124362036586, 0.0513601079583168, -0.0027433650102466345, 0.007315970957279205, 0.043186962604522705, 0.0158773735165596, -0.061319246888160706, -0.006271410267800093, -0.026505494490265846, -0.033074621111154556, 0.05185756832361221, -0.007402939256280661, 0.05838523432612419, 0.009165874682366848, 0.007230614777654409, -0.008511645719408989, 0.015331484377384186, 0.004384168889373541, -0.010371504351496696, -0.008991311304271221, 0.047706324607133865, -0.014907223172485828, 0.007521068677306175, 0.031197046861052513, -0.01968865469098091, 0.03743113577365875, 0.06795220822095871, -0.013904375955462456, 0.023915592581033707, 0.062415894120931625, -0.03745102509856224, -0.025693949311971664, 0.04801838845014572, -0.057599861174821854, 0.025521088391542435, -0.01905696652829647, -0.04870542138814926, 0.0372181162238121, 0.007944080047309399, 0.023997347801923752, -0.029063502326607704, -0.05021485313773155, -0.03735319897532463, 0.006466361228376627, -0.00798673927783966, -0.028782326728105545, 0.046260200440883636, 0.013673115521669388, 0.02953396737575531, 0.02293708734214306, 0.028156498447060585, -0.011972807347774506, -0.06660132110118866, -0.02188936434686184, -0.05887109413743019, -0.050990331918001175, 0.002874665893614292, 0.009031067602336407, -0.04029696434736252, 0.04339808598160744, -0.025106992572546005, 0.01793307438492775, 0.008468003943562508, 0.02876749075949192, -0.019247153773903847, 0.0674925372004509, 0.02046448551118374, -0.007073633372783661, -0.0013415039284154773, 0.007742773275822401, 0.10184410959482193, 0.1043870821595192, 0.05050009861588478, -0.06714761257171631, -0.0505201555788517, -0.013835486955940723, 0.03931998461484909, -0.02394874021410942, 0.02138512022793293, 0.017429787665605545, -0.030396705493330956, 0.031409118324518204, 0.03076052851974964, 0.01319038961082697, 0.011913247406482697, 0.052837688475847244, -0.031717825680971146, -0.00952957570552826, -0.015383862890303135, 0.023239776492118835, 0.03704863786697388, -0.01969851739704609, -0.058230116963386536, 0.03469544276595116, 0.003225070657208562, -0.03767676278948784, -0.03720872849225998, -0.035833220928907394, 0.0028368060011416674, -0.009733210317790508, -0.022987430915236473, -0.026980284601449966, 0.010161231271922588, 0.0038653609808534384, -0.009977243840694427, -0.015959741547703743, -0.014813740737736225, -0.02735552377998829, 0.025658071041107178, 0.04081052169203758, 0.031515609472990036, -0.014253157190978527, 0.0005502664134837687, -0.02272769622504711, -0.032181065529584885, -0.02159479446709156, -0.029084570705890656, 0.019052112475037575, -0.022644128650426865, 0.011599386110901833, -0.0011429771548137069, -0.018859198316931725, 0.02053629234433174, -0.036573514342308044, -0.04448820278048515, 0.004240164067596197, 0.037082575261592865, -0.025810638442635536, -0.021711356937885284, -0.031433310359716415, 0.00213941209949553, -0.02338804490864277, 0.01547711156308651, 0.037329867482185364, -0.06076103821396828, -0.01635025441646576, -0.020480696111917496, 0.024636806920170784, -0.024890927597880363, -0.01762201264500618, 0.010005136020481586, -0.042204540222883224, -0.017798099666833878, -0.002478615380823612, 0.04410693794488907, -0.009972682222723961, 0.04949144646525383, -0.00644856970757246, 0.024113597348332405, -0.033273980021476746, -0.02665991708636284, 0.024869831278920174, -0.01002618670463562, -0.008973890915513039, -0.04289038106799126, -0.007195902056992054, 0.022948039695620537, 0.023003054782748222, -0.004100356251001358, -0.004786232020705938, 0.021030237898230553, 0.028829379007220268, 0.02877957932651043, -0.05787722393870354, -0.016220400109887123, -0.010708603076636791, 0.0297982320189476, -0.002945789135992527, -0.03492235764861107, 0.05693640559911728, 0.028844140470027924, 0.007781089749187231, -0.01984288915991783, 0.022300301119685173, -0.014096311293542385, 0.02478601597249508, -0.04298024997115135, -0.05396866425871849, -0.006970288697630167, -0.0013804581249132752, 0.019182849675416946, -0.005600182339549065, -0.03453206270933151, -0.028630731627345085, -0.01251159142702818, 0.007472354918718338, -0.008153880946338177, -0.017859214916825294, -0.011838599108159542, -0.0033628339879214764, 0.024368172511458397, -0.012373446486890316, 0.0017175760585814714, -0.007983420044183731, -0.012338090687990189, -0.01590137369930744, -0.015565394423902035, -0.0025686302687972784, 0.004478156566619873, -0.004682483151555061, 0.014817849732935429, 0.009637661278247833, 0.010198458097875118, -0.004676837008446455, -0.0053937798365950584, 0.008403625339269638, -0.024675974622368813, 0.010801400057971478, -0.012661069631576538, -0.00017064851999748498, 0.04782368987798691, -0.06540939211845398, -0.04667382314801216, 0.026131652295589447, 0.006877146661281586, 0.038044486194849014, 0.018934939056634903, -0.011406435631215572, -0.006202946417033672, 0.021086309105157852, -0.060965098440647125, -0.018377067521214485, -0.027137799188494682, -0.019011331722140312, -0.0014027240686118603, 0.007811564486473799, -0.023235006257891655, -0.006312890909612179, -0.022730913013219833, 0.008208048529922962, 0.02302577532827854, -0.00048018828965723515, 0.002677649026736617, 0.030298948287963867, 0.021697521209716797, 0.009323219768702984, 0.015724796801805496, -0.006357871927320957, 0.043770384043455124, 0.06708310544490814, -0.04306095838546753, 0.04388575628399849, -0.008498062379658222, 0.01752719283103943, -0.05337649583816528, -0.016975276172161102, 0.023629136383533478, -0.003037145594134927, 0.02665426954627037, -0.021210288628935814, -0.027832772582769394, 0.023033276200294495, -0.01753110997378826, 0.04250866174697876, -0.0240608099848032, -0.009938564151525497, -0.04329325631260872, 0.010334935039281845, -0.0016207931330427527, 0.014854731038212776, 0.01426618080586195, 0.01374045480042696, 0.015326142311096191, 0.026665009558200836, -0.023810289800167084, -0.014711088500916958, -0.017311429604887962, 0.00592415127903223, 0.013811643235385418, -0.08509629219770432, 0.0526873953640461, -0.05052180215716362, -0.02560555189847946, 0.01857292652130127, -0.00372116407379508, -0.02202025055885315, 0.03994448855519295, 0.02027720771729946, -0.010895337909460068, 0.020032551139593124, 0.04545608535408974, -0.013890805654227734, -0.01344557385891676, -0.017205610871315002, 0.030969807878136635, 0.007596167735755444, -0.04920094087719917, 0.01995650865137577, 0.02266598865389824, -0.011343610472977161, -0.040744539350271225, 0.005962667055428028, -0.0020576068200170994, -0.04531968757510185, -0.013818786479532719, -0.006329977884888649, 0.044445887207984924, -0.008269701153039932, 0.03521157056093216, -0.042518485337495804, -0.005583369173109531, -0.015417195856571198, 0.0192047618329525, -0.014356913976371288, 0.030613673850893974, -0.01987471617758274, -0.06976763904094696, 0.04306329786777496, 0.007954681292176247, -0.003139268374070525, -0.04677646607160568, 0.010884159244596958, 0.004165190737694502, 0.023081649094820023, -0.05124419555068016, -0.02922406792640686, -0.01970619522035122, 0.0402802899479866, -0.02320253476500511, -0.023334786295890808, 0.053834035992622375, -0.0014699349412694573, -0.005339502822607756, -0.08418620377779007, 0.05451293662190437, 0.00325234467163682, -0.007560889236629009, -0.00450975401327014, -0.012064028531312943, -0.05002060532569885, -0.016497313976287842, 0.06866318732500076, -0.01673801988363266, 0.027247969061136246, 0.024037621915340424, 0.03783131763339043, -0.00733068585395813, -0.052915625274181366, -0.0003674803883768618, -0.024432502686977386, -0.0665406882762909, -0.025079067796468735, 0.014758127741515636, -0.023904234170913696, 0.017597632482647896, 0.02538292482495308, -0.020934682339429855, 0.013988991267979145, 0.02888847514986992, 0.0005515958764590323, 0.024926455691456795, 0.00975995697081089, -0.011952795088291168, 0.06327493488788605, 0.011262759566307068, 0.011115992441773415, 0.007527179084718227, -0.005501627456396818, -0.05742426961660385, 0.04264487698674202, -0.007739327382296324, -0.05873820185661316, -0.014787152409553528, -0.009409877471625805, -0.03527996316552162, -0.046753305941820145, -0.04399709776043892, 0.0006611214485019445, -0.03985509276390076, 0.02529023215174675, 0.014271784573793411, 0.020601211115717888, 0.043346699327230453, -0.019513679668307304, 0.0029796347953379154, 0.017349205911159515, 0.009627189487218857, -0.009624402970075607, -0.002376035088673234, 0.038958486169576645, -0.024843478575348854, 0.03701625391840935, 0.011493410915136337, -0.036883819848299026, 0.026619311422109604, -0.016394853591918945, 0.07550757378339767, -0.04424966499209404, -0.04938657954335213, 0.0008431660244241357, 0.00690738158300519, -0.012010599486529827, -0.03876061737537384, -0.04913901537656784, 0.04226795583963394, -0.0123897735029459, 0.005495555233210325, -0.025343112647533417, -0.0314883291721344, -0.030875777825713158, 0.03002813085913658, 0.012668742798268795, 0.04752550646662712, -0.014284987933933735, 0.012784719467163086, 0.014762047678232193, 0.0005162995657883584, 0.026513908058404922, -0.021442929282784462, 0.03675819933414459, -0.031676359474658966, -0.0036501740105450153, -0.032973870635032654, -0.05028552561998367, 0.013765520416200161, -0.04126065969467163, -0.0006338802049867809, 0.04768569767475128, 0.034004613757133484, -0.017360910773277283, -0.019673148170113564, 0.006889785639941692, 0.06051557883620262, -0.07193062454462051, -0.030659489333629608, -0.005524022039026022, -0.006908036302775145, -0.00027927328483201563, -0.008368749171495438 ]
<p>I am having the following problem. I have a group of words which are all permutations of each other. On a random dataset of DNA sequences I can calculate the distribution of the number of word occurrences. On my biological dataset I would like to compare the word occurrences with the distribution of those on random data. My final result should a list of permutations that are significantly enriched. (the tail of the real-data distribution versus the random data distribution will be slightly different)</p> <p>Given the random distribution (type unknown, basically a positive valued function with extremum around 1 and a long tail on the right side) I would be able to calculate p-values for any word in the group, but I think this might imply that I need a multiple hypothesis correction, although you can state that the hypotheses are clearly dependent.</p> <p>We can cast this problem into a dice problem. Suppose we have a die with N sides and we roll it a large number T of times. Next we try to assess whether some of the sides occur much more then expected. This leads to N hypotheses where we check if the occurrence of side N is much higher than expected. These hypothesis are not independent since the occurrence of one side influences the other. In this case is it possible to state that the die has a bias towards a subset of sides? If it's not possible use the p-values, (due to multiple hyp corr), would it make sense to use the p-value simply as a ranking mechanism?</p> <p>Thanks a lot for any help provided!</p>
37,269
[ -0.030884746462106705, -0.02187904343008995, 0.00951041653752327, 0.00883917324244976, 0.022582797333598137, 0.052960820496082306, 0.0036397043149918318, 0.019893648102879524, 0.02410879358649254, -0.05407185107469559, 0.013198145665228367, 0.028786111623048782, 0.02710256166756153, 0.016894744709134102, 0.0324569046497345, 0.011759039014577866, -0.017153901979327202, -0.018610088154673576, -0.0005952404462732375, 0.0026319713797420263, 0.014100664295256138, 0.03559745475649834, 0.026582447811961174, -0.015570979565382004, -0.02038211189210415, 0.03353003039956093, 0.03170229122042656, -0.0013912132708355784, 0.04707237705588341, 0.07318048924207687, -0.035665616393089294, -0.017830492928624153, 0.04844062402844429, 0.05123020336031914, 0.01783664897084236, 0.005442404188215733, -0.02125703915953636, 0.005479751154780388, -0.014119486324489117, 0.04618954285979271, -0.04501941800117493, -0.02258014865219593, 0.01107669249176979, 0.030917171388864517, 0.0018374414648860693, 0.025722667574882507, -0.025163164362311363, -0.04059169813990593, 0.02715933881700039, -0.05500040575861931, 0.08683270961046219, 0.013287324458360672, 0.02797011472284794, 0.012448571622371674, 0.010416025295853615, 0.004495497327297926, 0.04501977562904358, 0.08422563970088959, 0.014110466465353966, -0.050362423062324524, 0.005581530276685953, -0.02820803038775921, 0.029034089297056198, -0.009389642626047134, -0.040227197110652924, 0.037561457604169846, -0.016528861597180367, -0.010613640770316124, 0.0384281761944294, 0.03549594059586525, 0.007486168760806322, 0.004542159847915173, 0.04177328571677208, 0.00950970035046339, 0.003947916440665722, -0.0390806570649147, 0.03329746797680855, -0.01825885847210884, 0.007918416522443295, 0.03177500516176224, 0.007953889667987823, 0.0031166360713541508, 0.015336746349930763, 0.06190628930926323, 0.009967315010726452, -0.01828734576702118, 0.05128135532140732, -0.06551665812730789, 0.02889864146709442, 0.028880896046757698, -0.027651023119688034, -0.04059753939509392, 0.05269430950284004, -0.008896860294044018, -0.07860619574785233, 0.01240436639636755, -0.027620989829301834, 0.03523145988583565, 0.015426293015480042, -0.00019979695207439363, -0.010620670393109322, -0.04824088513851166, 0.022924860939383507, 0.03095220774412155, -0.018949050456285477, -0.004522859584540129, -0.031098274514079094, 0.017802691087126732, 0.001905773184262216, 0.01565181091427803, -0.01514512300491333, 0.045851971954107285, -0.020848164334893227, 0.010170427151024342, 0.022356096655130386, -0.0034318685065954924, -0.0070986258797347546, 0.026673845946788788, 0.06568576395511627, 0.06812568753957748, 0.026027288287878036, -0.04116472601890564, 0.029470298439264297, -0.0259231086820364, -0.060895394533872604, -0.0001373899867758155, 0.031551167368888855, 0.0010889656841754913, -0.03345905616879463, 0.056923411786556244, -0.015417988412082195, -0.012270077131688595, 0.06225501373410225, -0.007557133212685585, 0.05651218444108963, 0.004850934259593487, -0.11319614946842194, -0.04230112209916115, 0.03568020090460777, -0.010658989660441875, -0.004348783753812313, -0.06015549600124359, -0.006703754886984825, 0.051023051142692566, 0.0436844639480114, -0.016763361170887947, 0.0554858036339283, -0.008813499473035336, 0.038711871951818466, 0.014008745551109314, 0.0022705940064042807, -0.007814428769052029, -0.003009876236319542, 0.004710755776613951, -0.023502780124545097, -0.08587776124477386, 0.03029184602200985, -0.006108354311436415, 0.024812784045934677, -0.013398620299994946, 0.019565768539905548, -0.013895879499614239, -0.007454735692590475, -0.03504030406475067, 0.04216145724058151, -0.001052142702974379, 0.07259322702884674, 0.00932501070201397, 0.036065034568309784, -0.0018292551394551992, -0.00019928623805753887, 0.04567036032676697, -0.000427061429945752, 0.03136260434985161, 0.032685909420251846, -0.048968974500894547, 0.004801235161721706, -0.013959144242107868, 0.026848189532756805, 0.003094769548624754, 0.02649994194507599, 0.0055177900940179825, -0.014528981409966946, 0.02383708581328392, 0.017959801480174065, 0.001477608340792358, 0.015986710786819458, 0.0002770151768345386, 0.05832758545875549, -0.05743787810206413, -0.014473150484263897, -0.06263241171836853, -0.03194766119122505, -0.008372072130441666, -0.056158363819122314, 0.0482829287648201, 0.014908231794834137, 0.012561661191284657, -0.013181455433368683, -0.014268777333199978, -0.03405424579977989, 0.013555950485169888, 0.08481170237064362, -0.047183483839035034, -0.021721361204981804, 0.06201564520597458, 0.020672131329774857, -0.03157028183341026, 0.04761819913983345, -0.011393467895686626, -0.03639281541109085, 0.03981323167681694, -0.04523048177361488, 0.027580834925174713, 0.009298568591475487, 0.021728413179516792, 0.032625071704387665, 0.005005208775401115, -0.005820354912430048, 0.03627730533480644, -0.030752353370189667, 0.047836028039455414, 0.08124998211860657, 0.0209291260689497, 0.017359841614961624, 0.021293114870786667, 0.028254074975848198, 0.0036493956577032804, -0.05605152249336243, 0.028662752360105515, -0.05700001120567322, 0.007182775530964136, 0.006911851931363344, 0.0296311154961586, -0.04360782355070114, -0.0019268884789198637, 0.06199442222714424, -0.0008816646295599639, 0.01914452202618122, 0.054432462900877, -0.014845202676951885, -0.0204498078674078, 0.02869105152785778, 0.041241999715566635, 0.06104696914553642, -0.017447076737880707, 0.004075960256159306, -0.01622920297086239, 0.040471673011779785, 0.015953341498970985, 0.0002444127749186009, 0.03292729705572128, 0.020937778055667877, -0.020121246576309204, -0.0024985463824123144, -0.0105943838134408, 0.014749222435057163, -0.04109165072441101, -0.008956046774983406, 0.03167659044265747, -0.021704282611608505, -0.010552250780165195, 0.005791706498712301, -0.03175242245197296, 0.0022858146112412214, 0.02649822272360325, -0.027254179120063782, -0.0020174637902528048, 0.011936701834201813, -0.0378715917468071, -0.01304115541279316, 0.007715520914644003, -0.029107727110385895, 0.004937733989208937, 0.04244435206055641, 0.0038075714837759733, -0.008979643695056438, 0.03163968399167061, -0.014116254635155201, -0.004044366534799337, 0.015607476234436035, -0.013000701554119587, -0.010245027020573616, -0.011593149043619633, -0.08701886981725693, 0.009226546622812748, -0.015148760750889778, -0.05481458455324173, 0.02846384420990944, 0.0034682461991906166, -0.009828249923884869, 0.007691714446991682, 0.01179067324846983, -0.018648000434041023, -0.030463367700576782, -0.05138764902949333, 0.019080733880400658, -0.057149071246385574, -0.04104895144701004, 0.0391845740377903, 0.018818465992808342, -0.034612495452165604, 0.0260645542293787, -0.019592462107539177, -0.03394831344485283, -0.017475496977567673, -0.018731549382209778, -0.005750242620706558, 0.012499905191361904, -0.026072856038808823, 0.0014156331308186054, 0.011568693444132805, -0.04098764806985855, -0.04332612082362175, -0.0630023181438446, 0.022228192538022995, -0.015365741215646267, 0.026445360854268074, 0.014759392477571964, -0.019451020285487175, 0.048970431089401245, 0.050324179232120514, -0.032836128026247025, -0.033787842839956284, -0.0063711972907185555, -0.02203477919101715, -0.014536053873598576, 0.007673679385334253, 0.029375828802585602, -0.004781714174896479, 0.028310872614383698, 0.029303021728992462, 0.017614515498280525, 0.05445855110883713, -0.02071828581392765, -0.04029402509331703, 0.024629466235637665, 0.013361409306526184, 0.0030491510406136513, 0.029174458235502243, 0.04363837093114853, -0.008696654811501503, 0.03664209321141243, -0.006616564933210611, 0.011187301017343998, 0.010209434665739536, -0.030748918652534485, 0.01824726164340973, 0.010662384331226349, -0.005846929270774126, -0.025876225903630257, 0.015975043177604675, 0.052539125084877014, -0.02808295004069805, -0.009600467048585415, 0.024073300883173943, 0.04594901204109192, -0.03388698399066925, 0.032575372606515884, 0.06163464114069939, 0.03816148266196251, -0.024165965616703033, -0.02858283929526806, -0.018908992409706116, 0.007930714637041092, 0.0026229736395180225, -0.034359753131866455, -0.02066430076956749, 0.026002250611782074, 0.04437168687582016, 0.02499999664723873, 0.012749779038131237, -0.04984166473150253, 0.03831719979643822, -0.05178147554397583, 0.019460150972008705, -0.017673473805189133, 0.045749861747026443, -0.011692016385495663, 0.04387656971812248, 0.015891071408987045, -0.03825131431221962, -0.008244922384619713, 0.031711507588624954, -0.04529023543000221, 0.068440280854702, -0.02495758980512619, 0.00895537156611681, -0.027180176228284836, -0.018747840076684952, 0.026381991803646088, -0.04939465597271919, 0.005241377279162407, 0.022884884849190712, -0.004320373293012381, -0.027244174852967262, 0.014706447720527649, -0.03885380178689957, -0.003942865412682295, -0.00080251251347363, 0.06022864580154419, 0.024471452459692955, -0.021254101768136024, 0.00792168639600277, 0.03937076777219772, -0.026742734014987946, 0.025358250364661217, -0.005035110283643007, 0.023842329159379005, 0.02996087074279785, 0.03990185633301735, 0.005531244445592165, 0.04373973235487938, -0.04077555611729622, 0.042484693229198456, -0.009761561639606953, 0.019003434106707573, 0.05844376981258392, -0.004085100721567869, 0.01346054021269083, -0.06111421063542366, -0.01944861188530922, -0.010281901806592941, 0.022038906812667847, -0.019939903169870377, -0.012614484876394272, 0.05202976614236832, 0.024446982890367508, -0.08728687465190887, -0.004125090781599283, 0.04619774594902992, 0.03676355630159378, -0.031018933281302452, -0.05385884270071983, -0.019353561103343964, 0.01684640906751156, -0.02779368683695793, -0.005627167411148548, 0.020577002316713333, -0.00641619274392724, 0.0027779273223131895, 0.039491936564445496, -0.02059481292963028, -0.04340898245573044, 0.009444487281143665, -0.00232666521333158, 0.05001414567232132, 0.012925870716571808, -0.004097640514373779, 0.0013198289088904858, 0.012073642574250698, -0.01010868325829506, 0.00003541187470545992, -0.004544554743915796, -0.08184829354286194, 0.03658093139529228, 0.04593715816736221, 0.07305456697940826, -0.02395356260240078, 0.00797795969992876, -0.021824155002832413, 0.019257912412285805, 0.03125903755426407, -0.04056583717465401, 0.029139764606952667, -0.010321912355720997, -0.0223558247089386, -0.01882389932870865, -0.019226733595132828, -0.06154928356409073, 0.04107316583395004, -0.030316699296236038, 0.0016750477952882648, -0.03168288618326187, -0.016408689320087433, -0.054794445633888245, 0.009802312590181828, 0.031601402908563614, 0.0466017946600914, -0.041294969618320465, -0.008091206662356853, 0.012148319743573666, 0.025667831301689148, -0.0018282127566635609, -0.04334627836942673, 0.013367274776101112, -0.020613055676221848, 0.007664680015295744, 0.028927084058523178, -0.035593174397945404, -0.02979380451142788, 0.022657040506601334, 0.0050965906120836735, -0.03520888090133667, 0.004653551150113344, 0.007470530457794666, 0.04661031812429428, 0.042885228991508484, -0.01841166615486145, 0.05704035982489586, 0.0619034618139267, 0.0029063953552395105, -0.009606895968317986, -0.01346069946885109, 0.015620995312929153, -0.01512907724827528, 0.014168376103043556, -0.04292323812842369, -0.0067125423811376095, -0.040735505521297455, 0.005614032968878746, -0.004602454602718353, 0.02306288853287697, 0.0187517162412405, 0.048971712589263916, -0.024665467441082, 0.0022203903645277023, 0.0047987704165279865, -0.013464666903018951, 0.000546502647921443, 0.01284673810005188, -0.008943670429289341, -0.010353543795645237, 0.02468971163034439, -0.019470801576972008, -0.01904798112809658, 0.010035707615315914, -0.04133645445108414, 0.0055342502892017365, -0.018942004069685936, -0.03710227459669113, -0.010105561465024948, -0.010393149219453335, 0.049534231424331665, -0.020642761141061783, 0.024394728243350983, -0.001775922835804522, -0.03883880376815796, -0.032039303332567215, 0.03300730511546135, 0.013497648760676384, 0.015464292839169502, -0.03197450190782547, 0.03706490248441696, -0.04290105402469635, 0.0022989853750914335, -0.06616242974996567, 0.005208378657698631, 0.023282937705516815, 0.033225301653146744, -0.021003950387239456, -0.03672279044985771, -0.007142405491322279, -0.022371850907802582, -0.0008278214372694492, -0.002886048750951886, 0.04017870873212814, -0.018861666321754456, -0.00864576455205679, -0.018599875271320343, -0.022394806146621704, 0.09253270924091339, -0.007610808592289686, -0.02340920828282833, 0.017528129741549492, -0.014181914739310741, 0.030651109293103218, -0.030126824975013733, -0.01846061460673809, -0.012266084551811218, 0.006696726661175489, 0.005821943748742342, 0.02502707950770855, 0.029102621600031853, -0.0006472688401117921, -0.012895476073026657, -0.0016911578131839633, -0.035340018570423126, -0.008558393456041813, -0.032055798918008804, -0.04241998866200447, -0.055001284927129745, 0.007231471128761768, -0.017066294327378273, 0.032583680003881454, -0.015266249887645245, -0.017037099227309227, 0.014286111108958721, -0.009868250228464603, -0.01811426877975464, 0.0012654854217544198, 0.06667719781398773, -0.04090655967593193, -0.0134105384349823, -0.03754897788167, -0.035550400614738464, 0.01006942056119442, -0.007571689784526825, -0.032414957880973816, -0.022998526692390442, 0.008376309648156166, -0.04743708297610283, -0.014539623633027077, 0.005458887200802565, -0.012881582602858543, 0.05863413214683533, -0.0032012995798140764, 0.0142975440248847, 0.05709487572312355, 0.013873850926756859, -0.0053884973749518394, 0.019683806225657463, -0.00288895214907825, -0.02508063055574894, -0.007772533688694239, 0.035068612545728683, 0.005993645638227463, 0.0009274595649912953, 0.05693533644080162, -0.0024936033878475428, 0.006553043145686388, 0.08157491683959961, 0.03950796648859978, -0.012997008860111237, 0.031780242919921875, -0.007048673462122679, -0.022694937884807587, 0.04150912165641785, -0.0889630988240242, 0.009359035640954971, -0.04745202884078026, -0.04991421476006508, 0.021969402208924294, 0.04807405546307564, 0.015100933611392975, -0.050349775701761246, -0.044752780348062515, -0.04592796787619591, 0.04136619716882706, -0.012382887303829193, -0.01073315180838108, 0.009513686411082745, -0.03634179010987282, 0.04221078008413315, 0.00724204583093524, 0.03599323704838753, -0.03587276488542557, -0.06141039729118347, 0.007139044348150492, -0.04712379723787308, -0.06189718842506409, 0.02035839855670929, 0.0011319087352603674, -0.026394573971629143, 0.03203202039003372, 0.0009334380156360567, 0.049643341451883316, 0.00167410250287503, 0.05938926711678505, -0.04432009160518646, 0.07147438079118729, 0.008160070516169071, 0.043825663626194, 0.021297359839081764, -0.0590926818549633, 0.12055931985378265, 0.0715404525399208, 0.03827434405684471, -0.06165740266442299, 0.03180398792028427, -0.02793266624212265, 0.004704603925347328, -0.025998571887612343, 0.006909445393830538, 0.02394675649702549, 0.0007496342295780778, 0.004261776339262724, 0.037306372076272964, -0.0006872612284496427, -0.013525234535336494, 0.07576414197683334, -0.049286164343357086, -0.025123996660113335, 0.009866571053862572, 0.032412007451057434, -0.007887855172157288, -0.023654937744140625, -0.0590595081448555, -0.01564297080039978, 0.014242483302950859, -0.02292681112885475, -0.022277621552348137, -0.038360387086868286, -0.0024033456575125456, 0.01890067756175995, -0.011428624391555786, -0.03362683951854706, 0.018226508051156998, 0.0042040226981043816, -0.014794452115893364, -0.043322671204805374, 0.0002638119040057063, -0.0348159484565258, -0.00748862000182271, 0.029497424140572548, 0.027205681428313255, 0.019948560744524002, 0.030882975086569786, 0.04685395583510399, -0.04059568792581558, -0.022122565656900406, -0.01239974144846201, 0.04423931613564491, -0.042257361114025116, 0.014253420755267143, -0.0032524685375392437, -0.026682883501052856, -0.016362395137548447, -0.0387202724814415, -0.026270169764757156, 0.0061117783188819885, 0.034101858735084534, -0.031667523086071014, -0.04402390122413635, -0.012683376669883728, 0.037529222667217255, -0.02851398102939129, 0.035072848200798035, 0.03242868185043335, -0.0374690406024456, -0.025996863842010498, -0.023633109405636787, 0.04451058804988861, -0.031220220029354095, -0.010475987568497658, -0.031834740191698074, -0.01163220964372158, -0.038289546966552734, -0.0016106478869915009, 0.010304688476026058, -0.012079935520887375, 0.022526733577251434, -0.013384484685957432, -0.03236787021160126, -0.0025618223007768393, 0.044547077268362045, 0.01817259192466736, -0.05180961638689041, -0.01584647223353386, -0.03587698936462402, -0.031157977879047394, 0.045526739209890366, 0.016501933336257935, -0.0297363493591547, 0.003919918555766344, -0.0061997901648283005, 0.0037676359061151743, -0.024787286296486855, -0.0771367996931076, -0.0028033016715198755, -0.024553880095481873, -0.042342834174633026, -0.011942015960812569, 0.015197432599961758, 0.05840732157230377, 0.011277452111244202, -0.0045105041936039925, 0.0023918389342725277, 0.02274155803024769, -0.005799657665193081, 0.0021490203216671944, 0.010459823533892632, -0.07614126056432724, -0.017865590751171112, 0.013574875891208649, -0.014812218025326729, -0.03452722728252411, -0.04736530780792236, -0.014848440885543823, -0.008798209950327873, 0.04274960607290268, -0.011219540610909462, -0.029376696795225143, -0.03110981173813343, -0.04933014512062073, -0.006979203782975674, -0.0012044808827340603, 0.02829327993094921, -0.04835684224963188, -0.002365174237638712, 0.0067645781673491, -0.012826050631701946, 0.008227815851569176, -0.028725333511829376, -0.011309518478810787, -0.0037968598771840334, 0.041875679045915604, 0.039123792201280594, 0.04207238554954529, 0.005062257405370474, 0.03818950802087784, 0.02546714060008526, 0.03414482623338699, 0.005952263250946999, 0.0002969155029859394, 0.020593194290995598, -0.05668548494577408, -0.031464964151382446, 0.042391881346702576, -0.0016929093981161714, 0.03932971879839897, -0.000808170938398689, 0.003974054008722305, -0.014645857736468315, 0.014042663387954235, -0.041710156947374344, -0.026164358481764793, 0.019089316949248314, -0.011764581315219402, -0.00412528682500124, -0.02202996425330639, 0.009808586910367012, 0.010841687209904194, -0.011000864207744598, 0.02802990935742855, 0.024344826117157936, 0.038780875504016876, -0.012177640572190285, 0.01576409488916397, 0.012998316437005997, 0.033487506210803986, -0.029563259333372116, -0.018875662237405777, 0.021634837612509727, 0.050198521465063095, -0.05547882989048958, 0.04786549508571625, -0.004178923554718494, 0.016858182847499847, -0.04601236432790756, 0.003614950692281127, 0.04100564494729042, -0.013977470807731152, 0.030767425894737244, -0.046024225652217865, -0.014627492055296898, -0.008387746289372444, -0.02104775980114937, 0.00697878934442997, -0.004008641000837088, 0.006384348496794701, -0.043350569903850555, 0.017249638214707375, -0.043482884764671326, 0.016389556229114532, 0.02188073843717575, 0.028776194900274277, 0.05719883367419243, -0.003376307897269726, -0.020723825320601463, -0.02308107540011406, 0.004415628965944052, 0.05648020654916763, 0.0007534883334301412, -0.0585763193666935, 0.01798444241285324, -0.031827185302972794, -0.04556947574019432, 0.026801949366927147, -0.011185751296579838, 0.03754192963242531, 0.01490080077201128, 0.03047063574194908, 0.011277270503342152, 0.025040121749043465, 0.05382552370429039, -0.01128171756863594, -0.04147251322865486, 0.026174718514084816, 0.032497722655534744, 0.017154159024357796, -0.028758635744452477, 0.010508699342608452, 0.009989459998905659, 0.008700685575604439, 0.006454768590629101, 0.04166685417294502, -0.0037237938959151506, -0.005005410872399807, -0.015594364143908024, 0.006646948866546154, 0.045793816447257996, -0.007021517492830753, 0.021771704778075218, -0.047969795763492584, -0.006712550763040781, -0.009676222689449787, 0.02399487793445587, -0.030225953087210655, 0.035639096051454544, -0.0048258425667881966, -0.056679617613554, -0.02433321811258793, 0.00403465935960412, -0.010911811143159866, -0.047248728573322296, 0.01318556908518076, -0.013753516599535942, -0.0020206726621836424, -0.04270046204328537, -0.025732995942234993, -0.029143983498215675, 0.029630281031131744, -0.01213413942605257, 0.037503354251384735, 0.010827234946191311, 0.012511564418673515, 0.018730610609054565, -0.058478713035583496, 0.0699506402015686, -0.0027998939622193575, 0.053228262811899185, -0.02896914817392826, 0.0019413206027820706, -0.0045308819971978664, 0.00857551209628582, 0.05224571004509926, -0.011831720359623432, -0.008824443444609642, -0.0020048068836331367, 0.020335525274276733, 0.003644011216238141, -0.06622588634490967, 0.028027310967445374, -0.04719717055559158, -0.03091312199831009, -0.06597009301185608, 0.0014213212998583913, 0.018880730494856834, 0.01574835553765297, 0.001192515017464757, -0.029340021312236786, 0.01199862640351057, -0.008074663579463959, -0.004622515756636858, 0.008758372627198696, 0.005463935434818268, -0.028531059622764587, 0.01108531653881073, 0.03186216577887535, 0.021214794367551804, 0.005109906662255526, 0.02377968281507492, -0.03435102105140686, 0.07672915607690811, -0.020118780434131622, -0.0599360466003418, 0.01893661543726921, 0.03637060523033142, -0.0008619095897302032, -0.04223235324025154, -0.001012281165458262, 0.00593103701248765, -0.03570515289902687, 0.011162200942635536, 0.0070123812183737755, -0.00932160671800375, 0.009351598098874092, -0.038800787180662155, 0.027405815199017525, -0.002066639717668295, -0.038090553134679794, 0.0009597818716429174, 0.010770009830594063, -0.008719062432646751, 0.018406694754958153, 0.04593953490257263, 0.02722639963030815, -0.04114912822842598, 0.009921814315021038, 0.016252726316452026, -0.015109779313206673, -0.02003045566380024, -0.0002353822928853333, -0.0026683995965868235, 0.014945977367460728, 0.005513311829417944, -0.00968089047819376, 0.008878926746547222, 0.04131607711315155, 0.0015476037515327334, 0.032982051372528076, -0.025154687464237213, -0.04668527841567993, 0.0024350977037101984, -0.03216458857059479, 0.006228880025446415, -0.0060623278841376305, -0.002517056418582797, -0.020410045981407166, 0.020250653848052025, 0.027431810274720192, 0.024557972326874733, -0.019517065957188606, 0.007320475298911333, -0.029729532077908516, -0.006177316885441542, -0.0129212886095047, -0.023838384076952934, -0.052615199238061905, -0.02120153419673443, 0.007671584375202656, -0.012607799842953682, 0.04370070993900299, -0.02031942643225193, 0.0024503052700310946, 0.0006455000257119536, 0.061382923275232315, -0.04675915092229843, -0.018042339012026787, -0.06640841066837311, 0.0041279722936451435, 0.0015559335006400943, 0.003759835148230195 ]
<p>I've successfully implemented a RBM and trained it with CD-k, but I now have some issues doing the same with Convolutional RBM. </p> <p>The visible and hidden biases gradients are easy to compute: v1 - v2 for visible bias and h1_k - h2_k for the hidden bias. But I failed to see how to compute the gradients for the weights. The weights are NH x NH matrices. In RBM it was easy since the weight matrix was NH * NV dimension and with multiplication of h1 * v1 - h2 * v2 we could have the gradients, but the dimension are not equivalent in CRBM. </p> <p>What is the rule to compute the gradients ? Or is there a different way to update the weights ? It's probably a convolution, but I fail to see how...</p>
74,399
[ -0.01735580340027809, 0.0012492048554122448, 0.011095642112195492, -0.0008705327054485679, 0.041962116956710815, -0.0035439375787973404, -0.037545979022979736, -0.03792975842952728, 0.05313980206847191, -0.07167689502239227, 0.020851071923971176, 0.039888348430395126, 0.041341282427310944, 0.033913400024175644, 0.015146829187870026, -0.023733558133244514, 0.015004079788923264, -0.049158234149217606, 0.023759882897138596, -0.012632668018341064, 0.01697337068617344, 0.04975469782948494, -0.0003558014577720314, -0.04027123749256134, -0.017649374902248383, 0.06011522561311722, 0.015311259776353836, -0.02431296557188034, 0.04626889154314995, 0.03814476728439331, -0.02271287888288498, -0.007151166442781687, 0.00688684219494462, 0.018589328974485397, 0.009283328428864479, 0.0005902103148400784, -0.01816224493086338, -0.06458412110805511, -0.05133203789591789, -0.008047639392316341, -0.009543792344629765, -0.03824346512556076, 0.006706587038934231, 0.055338021367788315, -0.029993407428264618, -0.01312948390841484, 0.0009866059990599751, 0.011873466894030571, 0.033034346997737885, -0.04806699603796005, 0.09708437323570251, 0.01886937953531742, 0.044196538627147675, 0.03550606593489647, -0.04548847675323486, 0.005234741140156984, 0.03417590633034706, 0.08261369913816452, 0.05275849997997284, 0.0020570189226418734, 0.003447449766099453, -0.0440257303416729, 0.008532832376658916, -0.02735813334584236, -0.011068799532949924, 0.031104719266295433, 0.016088224947452545, -0.005408171564340591, 0.04056859761476517, -0.02472851425409317, 0.030124438926577568, -0.014414810575544834, 0.027356846258044243, 0.01049243938177824, 0.005840891506522894, -0.011133729480206966, 0.0036550385411828756, 0.006936400197446346, 0.02019539475440979, 0.009392649866640568, 0.001516292104497552, 0.019235890358686447, 0.017821304500102997, 0.03859322890639305, 0.007895116694271564, -0.0042220791801810265, 0.06586712598800659, -0.003049633000046015, 0.020794741809368134, 0.033338163048028946, 0.006601573899388313, 0.03664388135075569, 0.03779560327529907, 0.005586767103523016, -0.021975859999656677, 0.05797431245446205, -0.029725968837738037, 0.0343969501554966, -0.00003457450293353759, -0.031077805906534195, -0.022021854296326637, -0.04576149210333824, 0.0009014431270770729, 0.047515612095594406, -0.03186056762933731, -0.03882975876331329, 0.019833270460367203, 0.016654042527079582, -0.018525967374444008, 0.01630391553044319, -0.03180024400353432, 0.019892729818820953, -0.001624702475965023, -0.024620676413178444, 0.0011434528278186917, -0.04359555244445801, -0.0154622383415699, -0.02674693800508976, 0.019023148342967033, 0.060480523854494095, 0.03395021706819534, -0.0212726891040802, 0.0015303896507248282, -0.03281470760703087, -0.04044797644019127, 0.0002717998286243528, 0.02716650627553463, -0.03742729127407074, -0.04014682024717331, 0.02357594110071659, 0.009133885614573956, -0.061177972704172134, 0.023648569360375404, -0.03053188882768154, 0.021632065996527672, -0.009465967305004597, -0.06009828671813011, -0.07129824161529541, 0.030013035982847214, -0.031748633831739426, 0.01941360905766487, -0.04053715988993645, 0.020477164536714554, 0.05748259648680687, 0.049852706491947174, 0.028173858299851418, 0.027800511568784714, 0.05777595192193985, -0.012058048509061337, 0.037959471344947815, -0.017289308831095695, -0.039423078298568726, -0.02512955293059349, 0.02766081690788269, -0.049308519810438156, -0.08302552253007889, 0.026755930855870247, 0.017024658620357513, 0.0037058661691844463, -0.001117041101679206, 0.06080290302634239, -0.009332028217613697, -0.014228399842977524, -0.01377752237021923, -0.0007790133240632713, -0.027595601975917816, 0.04429334029555321, 0.007147050928324461, 0.09473804384469986, 0.0276862271130085, 0.010206468403339386, -0.007561165373772383, 0.029854251071810722, 0.042062755674123764, 0.019586095586419106, -0.004394165705889463, -0.003072216175496578, -0.0534517839550972, 0.016127048060297966, 0.009737029671669006, -0.019845955073833466, -0.06688722223043442, -0.03433813899755478, 0.021156715229153633, -0.013287312351167202, 0.006128668785095215, -0.007841876707971096, -0.008357766084372997, 0.01437628734856844, -0.010592153295874596, 0.033446334302425385, -0.06778108328580856, -0.0015755763743072748, -0.03596833348274231, 0.008421380072832108, 0.0322604700922966, -0.009622795507311821, -0.00024161294277291745, 0.01900467462837696, -0.026327034458518028, -0.048131585121154785, 0.007243906147778034, 0.02663526125252247, -0.023174716159701347, -0.016937242820858955, 0.013424818404018879, 0.012201257981359959, 0.024721993133425713, 0.05973648652434349, -0.03136580064892769, -0.03686339780688286, 0.020107967779040337, -0.0021817628294229507, -0.016462093219161034, -0.01363113522529602, -0.003982584923505783, 0.005888322833925486, -0.012608978897333145, -0.026369132101535797, -0.0024668804835528135, -0.05523943156003952, 0.036172471940517426, 0.041723884642124176, 0.0036553589161485434, 0.022997379302978516, 0.04707302898168564, 0.009009351022541523, -0.0163098331540823, -0.010387631133198738, -0.007123555988073349, -0.036950163543224335, -0.015236908569931984, 0.05088016018271446, -0.015544245019555092, -0.02591106854379177, 0.03148900717496872, 0.024212947115302086, 0.0470532551407814, 0.0573413148522377, 0.016082480549812317, -0.03563426807522774, -0.010329346172511578, 0.018236743286252022, 0.008839227259159088, -0.005496989004313946, -0.02541734091937542, -0.01184004545211792, -0.001165541005320847, 0.06831681728363037, -0.011528801172971725, -0.0003711936587933451, 0.02066194638609886, 0.022541187703609467, -0.009112694300711155, -0.032334547489881516, -0.021361183375120163, 0.04155292361974716, -0.011071487329900265, -0.01117884274572134, 0.041605085134506226, 0.0006840915884822607, 0.0029596276581287384, -0.002185588236898184, -0.04291936010122299, -0.0006784764700569212, 0.05856448411941528, -0.028688423335552216, 0.01653154380619526, 0.02214403636753559, -0.040142472833395004, 0.033489663153886795, -0.007990093901753426, 0.00550460210070014, -0.011217446066439152, 0.02064037136733532, -0.016036441549658775, -0.02136210910975933, -0.0049429601058363914, -0.029147593304514885, -0.0039016674272716045, 0.01872342824935913, -0.0035703242756426334, 0.03712037205696106, 0.0008081152336671948, -0.05053111910820007, 0.0240861214697361, -0.03320864588022232, 0.009292068891227245, 0.05341004207730293, 0.019639059901237488, -0.030546173453330994, 0.01832837611436844, 0.0030046214815229177, -0.0013817502185702324, -0.03866427019238472, -0.04277684912085533, 0.04168800637125969, -0.030309688299894333, -0.0020952438935637474, 0.08592373132705688, 0.011409280821681023, -0.027739526703953743, 0.03286871314048767, -0.0021295549813658, -0.02633644826710224, -0.03774240240454674, -0.017756236717104912, -0.04002686217427254, -0.021835193037986755, 0.01743227057158947, 0.03695732355117798, 0.00601713452488184, 0.011043640784919262, -0.06633660197257996, -0.05683448910713196, 0.06953827291727066, -0.011993578635156155, 0.025119198486208916, 0.046899713575839996, 0.009929616004228592, 0.08654234558343887, 0.03763392195105553, -0.016299718990921974, -0.03412248566746712, 0.006094468757510185, -0.015951531007885933, -0.06390756368637085, -0.009340072982013226, -0.0003600642958190292, 0.02903362177312374, -0.012270564213395119, 0.023181553930044174, -0.002302085515111685, 0.09502508491277695, -0.0001399611064698547, -0.030142299830913544, 0.012510768137872219, -0.011309864930808544, -0.009462528862059116, 0.053395505994558334, 0.009314477443695068, 0.0017909377347677946, 0.017868485301733017, 0.021898658946156502, 0.022566920146346092, 0.0015351641923189163, -0.04306115582585335, 0.006818361580371857, -0.043240565806627274, 0.01671629212796688, -0.031553659588098526, 0.02800789102911949, 0.007750562857836485, -0.011408009566366673, -0.013375845737755299, -0.012432779185473919, 0.01763966865837574, -0.061950575560331345, 0.0070514013059437275, 0.043419383466243744, 0.016924651339650154, 0.025915276259183884, 0.0022959806956350803, 0.023462442681193352, -0.02023128978908062, 0.005555974319577217, -0.01666460558772087, -0.004989950451999903, 0.026797281578183174, 0.020978150889277458, 0.00784320943057537, 0.048428382724523544, -0.04158303141593933, 0.0032018348574638367, -0.053871363401412964, 0.03450653702020645, -0.0046595060266554356, 0.05983992666006088, -0.022109249606728554, 0.043005939573049545, 0.03183639422059059, 0.01351306214928627, 0.031003836542367935, -0.04275469109416008, -0.0806109830737114, 0.02142861858010292, 0.01571572758257389, 0.004659845493733883, 0.023691905662417412, -0.06689681857824326, -0.001860421383753419, -0.0350632518529892, -0.020284291356801987, -0.030253471806645393, -0.002931145951151848, -0.009961146861314774, 0.010757424868643284, -0.00871608592569828, -0.03345376253128052, -0.01892632059752941, -0.01682208850979805, 0.054762840270996094, -0.004903755150735378, 0.034055061638355255, 0.014209202490746975, 0.024996988475322723, -0.0010491907596588135, -0.05426328629255295, 0.01690160669386387, -0.008750014007091522, 0.0693313255906105, 0.022010860964655876, 0.029260102659463882, -0.03182557225227356, 0.03270091488957405, 0.019138844683766365, 0.027059966698288918, 0.0221646036952734, 0.0037500131875276566, -0.03222436085343361, -0.08788462728261948, -0.009771091863512993, 0.009194228798151016, 0.015241759829223156, -0.04032297059893608, 0.004990621004253626, 0.03215549513697624, 0.015172007493674755, -0.05226120352745056, -0.026407673954963684, 0.06010553985834122, 0.013498607091605663, -0.030722621828317642, -0.05730339512228966, 0.0387655571103096, -0.011451950296759605, -0.004191504325717688, 0.036908626556396484, 0.02351599559187889, 0.010807599872350693, 0.006211459636688232, 0.044344209134578705, -0.0028950623236596584, 0.013980523683130741, 0.011299780569970608, 0.027083439752459526, 0.03013712167739868, -0.0033717795740813017, 0.011733930557966232, 0.002368281129747629, 0.033888909965753555, 0.023172488436102867, 0.0014116995735093951, 0.00902750063687563, -0.08019182085990906, 0.025065205991268158, 0.03917629271745682, 0.023077117279171944, -0.03615071624517441, -0.023365475237369537, -0.06884434074163437, -0.05588023364543915, 0.02585660107433796, -0.004550250247120857, 0.0389024093747139, -0.005106579512357712, 0.01868574321269989, -0.01784815825521946, 0.003994784317910671, 0.011029268614947796, 0.01569855585694313, -0.023902634158730507, 0.05433022230863571, 0.0010994634358212352, -0.017981836572289467, -0.03897211328148842, 0.0208122618496418, 0.007332043722271919, 0.053798284381628036, -0.010124590247869492, -0.0014167226618155837, 0.015734123066067696, 0.020945658907294273, -0.011632208712399006, -0.08826769143342972, -0.011515190824866295, -0.018788153305649757, -0.028284890577197075, 0.029108218848705292, -0.024704406037926674, -0.034563470631837845, 0.04327694699168205, 0.02471340447664261, -0.008767351508140564, -0.01340416818857193, -0.02945752441883087, 0.07854223251342773, 0.06156126409769058, -0.02741246484220028, 0.04015044495463371, 0.0038689160719513893, 0.027299894019961357, 0.024254051968455315, 0.008921912871301174, 0.00729327043518424, -0.006037518847733736, -0.005283484235405922, -0.0073850746266543865, -0.011349515058100224, 0.01008286327123642, 0.009018424898386002, 0.021743059158325195, 0.06648639589548111, 0.013751674443483353, -0.002042869571596384, -0.02503366209566593, 0.03643059730529785, -0.029605623334646225, -0.02130320854485035, 0.0008229843806475401, -0.0029057729989290237, -0.009225292131304741, -0.021233025938272476, -0.010329913347959518, -0.03705597296357155, -0.015920843929052353, 0.0007748287171125412, -0.04311639815568924, 0.0027794630732387304, -0.04807288572192192, 0.021734073758125305, 0.017644500359892845, -0.0028978311456739902, 0.0251291636377573, -0.016441747546195984, 0.05474831908941269, 0.005970923695713282, -0.031241776421666145, -0.015131000429391861, 0.019444270059466362, -0.041632093489170074, 0.00564856082201004, -0.016369307413697243, 0.029097318649291992, 0.006204291246831417, -0.0002497925015632063, -0.06433787941932678, -0.03577353432774544, 0.015589398331940174, 0.0016910594422370195, -0.012827950529754162, -0.01428922824561596, 0.011273940093815327, 0.019647013396024704, -0.04778943210840225, 0.0024494577664881945, 0.06949494034051895, -0.028009383007884026, 0.02654767781496048, -0.017588108777999878, 0.00768952677026391, 0.050037819892168045, -0.013200540095567703, 0.006876645144075155, 0.0029859060887247324, -0.028126224875450134, -0.038760337978601456, 0.031233355402946472, -0.00565893342718482, -0.017154335975646973, 0.019110921770334244, -0.025890134274959564, 0.019138680770993233, 0.09185026586055756, -0.015028003603219986, 0.010974611155688763, 0.03086089715361595, 0.003973847720772028, -0.01822469010949135, -0.05150613188743591, -0.017832642421126366, 0.004350172821432352, -0.02440079115331173, -0.04753418266773224, -0.030783770605921745, 0.004981708712875843, -0.021966436877846718, 0.010735813528299332, 0.04166014492511749, -0.02157451957464218, -0.012681965716183186, 0.05081968009471893, -0.036916669458150864, -0.006761325988918543, -0.024807974696159363, -0.05258161574602127, 0.03205683082342148, -0.04399660974740982, 0.005404049064964056, -0.0023808854166418314, -0.0023963137064129114, -0.049269840121269226, -0.019053315743803978, -0.05174751579761505, 0.02964393049478531, 0.054483190178871155, -0.032192524522542953, 0.040557991713285446, 0.00680877547711134, -0.0062818075530231, 0.00476397480815649, -0.021192146465182304, -0.05738934502005577, 0.015418505296111107, -0.017084047198295593, 0.05693165585398674, 0.016095736995339394, 0.020999200642108917, 0.015465316362679005, 0.04527224600315094, 0.029941001906991005, 0.008893518708646297, 0.007526774425059557, 0.02766648679971695, 0.006987161468714476, -0.0054439157247543335, -0.012696178629994392, 0.024349305778741837, -0.013040500693023205, 0.008792135864496231, -0.02342645637691021, -0.03479994088411331, 0.06253499537706375, 0.01689046621322632, -0.003784672822803259, -0.011932712979614735, -0.05063384771347046, -0.03784280642867088, -0.004494581371545792, -0.00130020035430789, -0.00841931626200676, 0.0055907112546265125, 0.06028923764824867, 0.0377596914768219, -0.029844971373677254, -0.0007853778079152107, -0.028877615928649902, -0.05869709700345993, -0.051259856671094894, -0.04492231085896492, -0.037799522280693054, 0.01377287320792675, 0.019917232915759087, -0.06339777261018753, 0.0495113879442215, -0.0028212973847985268, 0.023267734795808792, 0.018920522183179855, 0.021621689200401306, 0.03810914233326912, 0.01943984627723694, -0.0030559771694242954, 0.04099727421998978, 0.018915893509984016, -0.01676151156425476, 0.11878716200590134, 0.06446300446987152, 0.04627100005745888, -0.05833422392606735, -0.016927745193243027, -0.014790992252528667, -0.009872416965663433, -0.03618549555540085, 0.03388015180826187, 0.001250003115274012, 0.005304135847836733, -0.02579224295914173, 0.0039331731386482716, 0.02916981652379036, 0.008650464937090874, -0.003384575480595231, -0.036541376262903214, -0.021498452872037888, 0.034578341990709305, 0.020451616495847702, 0.009814430959522724, 0.002780175767838955, -0.0503210574388504, 0.004629070870578289, 0.02030147984623909, -0.06320549547672272, -0.041637733578681946, -0.014928565360605717, 0.0255086999386549, -0.027337858453392982, -0.011715072207152843, 0.01909833960235119, -0.025664005428552628, -0.012968592345714569, 0.0172224510461092, 0.029839733615517616, 0.022370459511876106, -0.03753029182553291, 0.006309751886874437, -0.01793762482702732, 0.043187811970710754, -0.01837986707687378, -0.03030356764793396, -0.010755482129752636, -0.014319031499326229, -0.017470408231019974, -0.039570555090904236, 0.05012951046228409, -0.01455832552164793, 0.009289402514696121, 0.0701146200299263, -0.02433852292597294, -0.0017694588750600815, -0.07992246001958847, 0.01162257231771946, 0.056904491037130356, 0.011015339754521847, 0.029668545350432396, -0.018013527616858482, -0.016515491530299187, 0.00639147125184536, -0.0021571703255176544, -0.012114998884499073, -0.0011525528971105814, -0.04184744879603386, -0.0018935174448415637, -0.04913780465722084, 0.06235220283269882, -0.0038666727486997843, 0.0018179495818912983, -0.0023696450516581535, -0.02753540873527527, -0.003012297209352255, -0.04617695137858391, -0.002229878678917885, -0.014193031005561352, 0.035150498151779175, -0.013073485344648361, -0.037371087819337845, -0.020690400153398514, -0.04960256442427635, 0.004555569961667061, 0.001454108627513051, 0.012315524742007256, -0.03461410477757454, 0.02011021226644516, 0.02709304727613926, 0.04952402785420418, 0.04820913076400757, 0.009799637831747532, 0.040101319551467896, -0.015187649987637997, 0.030429814010858536, -0.058048006147146225, -0.013912059366703033, 0.005794989876449108, -0.05353475362062454, -0.023388544097542763, 0.000495452550239861, 0.05755893141031265, -0.0027843371499329805, 0.02080819196999073, -0.022682785987854004, 0.0696999579668045, 0.00511328736320138, 0.02918655425310135, -0.013413474895060062, -0.05440983548760414, 0.027364827692508698, -0.04086314141750336, 0.011417034082114697, -0.06512710452079773, -0.024829892441630363, -0.053748514503240585, -0.05437293276190758, 0.03642544522881508, -0.028491640463471413, -0.02287076599895954, -0.0006491834647022188, 0.005644083954393864, 0.0673733726143837, 0.00457613542675972, 0.015388617292046547, -0.006657869089394808, 0.011685781180858612, -0.017264079302549362, -0.032569918781518936, -0.02687928080558777, 0.032320667058229446, 0.016337310895323753, 0.011313045397400856, 0.04761221632361412, 0.0011111657368019223, 0.024589281529188156, 0.0000786023010732606, 0.016476554796099663, 0.005400387104600668, 0.03745022416114807, -0.018400833010673523, -0.05976063385605812, 0.023400185629725456, -0.012089955620467663, 0.002159165684133768, 0.0054419576190412045, 0.010539386421442032, 0.014505250379443169, 0.011781156994402409, -0.028509991243481636, -0.021658895537257195, 0.023297835141420364, -0.032183434814214706, -0.005401742644608021, -0.0028569239657372236, -0.00946837104856968, -0.030062539502978325, -0.011593366973102093, 0.029789378866553307, 0.0012148615205660462, -0.011118249036371708, 0.028300873935222626, 0.023549897596240044, 0.005950809456408024, 0.000853676232509315, 0.020613931119441986, -0.0018903951859101653, 0.03337512165307999, 0.011077549308538437, 0.0030555082485079765, 0.028945069760084152, -0.002942756051197648, -0.02740844525396824, 0.03306560963392258, 0.0014037409564480186, 0.009740889072418213, -0.08592380583286285, -0.006854532286524773, 0.01788046956062317, -0.02589036524295807, 0.017826735973358154, -0.07207012921571732, 0.05516491085290909, 0.004759378731250763, -0.05711369961500168, 0.021287070587277412, -0.0039616734720766544, -0.008897283114492893, -0.03217543661594391, 0.04057149216532707, 0.011168952099978924, -0.02103089727461338, -0.01319174189120531, 0.013352668844163418, 0.01045369915664196, 0.02531874179840088, -0.007635819260030985, -0.05109443888068199, -0.01724616251885891, 0.0013748831115663052, 0.026953978464007378, -0.0019819128792732954, 0.025468014180660248, -0.038403574377298355, -0.010204829275608063, 0.009783778339624405, -0.003953220788389444, 0.000009043104910233524, 0.02492709644138813, 0.0560239739716053, 0.025393910706043243, 0.03109728731215, -0.007674310356378555, -0.002314853947609663, 0.022787339985370636, -0.015616717748343945, 0.021226994693279266, -0.00010746940824901685, -0.020470859482884407, 0.04637637734413147, 0.014195763505995274, -0.010918229818344116, -0.02583705075085163, 0.051134053617715836, -0.04685726389288902, -0.02841201052069664, -0.019383979961276054, -0.019877279177308083, 0.017631400376558304, -0.02903645671904087, 0.012779604643583298, -0.02222779020667076, 0.03744899854063988, 0.005191213451325893, -0.009230171330273151, -0.039815012365579605, 0.030283231288194656, 0.006578017491847277, -0.02407796122133732, 0.023285645991563797, -0.002899808343499899, -0.029918568208813667, -0.048731692135334015, -0.011240003630518913, 0.037546556442976, -0.007712722755968571, -0.03590623661875725, -0.007513596676290035, -0.050524234771728516, 0.04572570323944092, -0.007550027221441269, 0.021808993071317673, 0.01597810909152031, -0.006611485965549946, -0.003972318023443222, -0.08663555979728699, 0.012988480739295483, 0.02268107794225216, -0.04512267932295799, 0.003867406165227294, -0.005632385145872831, -0.029967939481139183, -0.014120640233159065, 0.08231453597545624, -0.02263307385146618, 0.012964138761162758, -0.0433821901679039, 0.01409787405282259, -0.0015499945729970932, -0.039871565997600555, 0.031708844006061554, -0.0011533508077263832, -0.024772923439741135, -0.02709813229739666, -0.03446323424577713, -0.016202837228775024, 0.02098696492612362, 0.013467428274452686, 0.01419833954423666, 0.012502793222665787, 0.001179978484287858, 0.026172645390033722, 0.02134508080780506, 0.010852101258933544, -0.012382532469928265, 0.03245506435632706, 0.012982429005205631, -0.01160399429500103, 0.029536742717027664, 0.01435273140668869, -0.057715632021427155, 0.047491464763879776, -0.004821437876671553, -0.021802326664328575, 0.02889222651720047, -0.02741897664964199, 0.05505179241299629, -0.07328710705041885, -0.029813652858138084, 0.044967930763959885, -0.042779590934515, 0.053618837147951126, 0.07774556428194046, -0.012439245358109474, 0.01863611303269863, 0.03173702210187912, 0.024919481948018074, -0.018597319722175598, 0.014497675932943821, 0.024281896650791168, 0.01686335727572441, 0.0007316798437386751, -0.010012965649366379, 0.08291557431221008, 0.016410959884524345, -0.06536925584077835, 0.04319846257567406, -0.03122197650372982, 0.0165981687605381, -0.026286693289875984, -0.0152432294562459, -0.0041982862167060375, -0.024794144555926323, 0.02048429101705551, -0.029482398182153702, -0.04140346869826317, 0.09437181055545807, -0.022078214213252068, 0.0173140037804842, -0.033789217472076416, -0.022057564929127693, -0.0024591407272964716, -0.004692045506089926, 0.01101846992969513, 0.03555293008685112, 0.02262433059513569, -0.00006960501923458651, 0.01299199927598238, -0.0008708802051842213, -0.001206206507049501, -0.03582748770713806, 0.021105822175741196, -0.015666751191020012, 0.001937340246513486, -0.006677287630736828, -0.04047862067818642, 0.00108042499050498, -0.018166348338127136, -0.0177384614944458, 0.02741125598549843, 0.02643805928528309, 0.016034135594964027, -0.0247084628790617, 0.010697842575609684, -0.005683108698576689, -0.06081121042370796, 0.015965361148118973, -0.02952754497528076, 0.012842257507145405, -0.0008489622268825769, -0.0167421605437994 ]
<p>I have a series of descriptors, some continuous, some discrete and an output variable which is dichotomous.</p> <p>I have several parameters, but for the sake of simplicity let's say my data look like:</p> <pre><code> Sex | Age | Genotype | Dose 1 | Dose 2 | Outcome ------|-------|------------|---------|-----------|------------ M | 32 | AABB | 150 | 30 | YES F | 65 | aaBb | 110 | 30 | YES M | 42 | AaBb | 200 | 50 | NO ... </code></pre> <p>I would like to make a predictive model to determine the optimal combination of <code>Dose 1</code> and <code>Dose 2</code> to have a desired outcome.</p> <p>So my question is, if I have a new male subject of given genotype and age, what is the best combination of doses that will give a positive outcome with the highest probability? Or, to see things the other way around, given the other parameters, what are the odds of having a positive outcome with a given set of doses?</p> <p>I thought I could use R to generate a linear model with <code>glm</code>, and then use <code>predict</code> to predict the outcome. However, I never really dealt with this type of problems before and I am a bit confused on how to use these functions and interpret their results. Also, I am not sure if this is the correct way to deal with the problem.</p> <p>For instance, let's generate some random data:</p> <pre><code>set.seed(12345) num.obs &lt;- 50 sex &lt;- sample(c("M", "F"), num.obs, replace=T) age &lt;- sample(20:80, num.obs, replace=T) genotype &lt;- sample(LETTERS[1:8], num.obs, replace=T) dose.1 &lt;- sample(100:200, num.obs, replace=T) dose.2 &lt;- sample(30:70, num.obs, replace=T) outcome &lt;- sample(0:1, num.obs, replace=T) data &lt;- data.frame(sex=sex, age=age, genotype=genotype, dose.1=dose.1, dose.2=dose.2, outcome=outcome) </code></pre> <p>Which gives 50 observation such as</p> <pre><code>&gt; head(data) sex age genotype dose.1 dose.2 outcome 1 F 78 C 183 54 0 2 F 70 E 156 66 1 3 F 39 H 180 35 0 4 F 32 E 135 51 0 5 M 64 E 121 57 1 6 M 50 H 179 61 1 </code></pre> <p>Now, I generate a model with</p> <pre><code>model &lt;- glm(outcome ~ sex + age + genotype + dose.1 + dose.2, data=data, family="binomial") </code></pre> <p>First question: without any <em>a priori</em> knowledge of the interactions between the descriptors, <strong>how do I choose the correct formula</strong>? Should I try various interactions and see which models gives the best fit e.g. looking at residual deviance or AIC? Are there functions to do this for me or should I try all of the combinations manually? </p> <p>OK, let's say I found the model is good, now I use <code>predict</code></p> <pre><code>new.data &lt;- list(sex=factor("M", levels=c("M", "F")), age=35, genotype=factor("C", levels=LETTERS[1:8]), dose.1=150, dose.2=30) outcome &lt;- predict(model, new.data, se=T) </code></pre> <p>Which gives:</p> <pre><code>$fit 1 -2.774538 $se.fit [1] 1.492594 $residual.scale [1] 1 </code></pre> <p>So... what do I do with this? <code>?predict.glm</code> says <code>$fit</code> is the prediction but obviously that is not a yes/no type of prediction... what I would ideally need is something on the lines of "89% YES / 11% NO".</p> <p><strong>How do I interpret the result of <code>predict</code> and how would I go about having the type of result I want?</strong></p> <p>Finally, <strong>are there functions to explore the parameter space so that I get a graph with the outcome in the dose1 vs dose2 space?</strong></p> <p>EDIT: just to clarify: I do not have a specific reason to use a generalized linear model, it is just something that came to my mind as a possible solution. If anyone can think of other ways to solve this type of problem I would gladly welcome their suggestion!</p>
49,250
[ -0.03461582213640213, -0.03126586601138115, 0.03250541538000107, -0.03525537997484207, -0.006658329628407955, 0.010195310227572918, -0.017170371487736702, -0.030170580372214317, 0.028167832642793655, -0.012937498278915882, 0.044851332902908325, 0.03285251185297966, 0.060347460210323334, 0.013150855898857117, 0.029602419584989548, 0.009362957440316677, -0.003884522709995508, -0.003157493658363819, -0.03307555988430977, 0.011700736358761787, 0.0019895900040864944, 0.04548434168100357, 0.011930846609175205, -0.04054001346230507, -0.008941459469497204, 0.0835714116692543, 0.023561671376228333, -0.03573229908943176, -0.013217012397944927, 0.07348594069480896, -0.043945636600255966, -0.052396632730960846, 0.004823476541787386, 0.011157087981700897, 0.032709505409002304, 0.018354225903749466, -0.010373392142355442, -0.03662393242120743, -0.010016351006925106, 0.04158918559551239, -0.019318321719765663, -0.008637304417788982, 0.0023521066177636385, 0.01640038937330246, -0.013161669485270977, 0.039581503719091415, -0.016475899145007133, -0.01391621120274067, 0.05278633162379265, -0.06143207848072052, 0.05796518176794052, -0.012921580113470554, 0.06244172155857086, 0.02638573944568634, -0.03184220939874649, -0.032974135130643845, 0.05735042318701744, 0.06452637165784836, 0.024974161759018898, -0.03691580519080162, -0.004613316617906094, -0.04592588543891907, 0.006639935076236725, 0.006367226596921682, -0.021562403067946434, -0.0031809667125344276, -0.002172520849853754, -0.005553976632654667, 0.012110680341720581, -0.034769196063280106, 0.03044806234538555, 0.017744995653629303, 0.015602795407176018, -0.026437969878315926, 0.019595695659518242, 0.015285308472812176, 0.005915321409702301, -0.004669478163123131, 0.024076879024505615, -0.003406420350074768, -0.01921992190182209, 0.031166652217507362, -0.005288970656692982, 0.052479133009910583, 0.006484460551291704, -0.04705330356955528, 0.02319527603685856, -0.029133008792996407, 0.04276391118764877, 0.0030197433661669493, -0.026906754821538925, 0.0034362925216555595, 0.05129844695329666, 0.020134808495640755, -0.06984324753284454, 0.038351770490407944, 0.003478705184534192, 0.020509378984570503, 0.014319033361971378, 0.018734335899353027, -0.03420877456665039, -0.05004759505391121, -0.01732085645198822, 0.060559630393981934, -0.0396200567483902, -0.034266844391822815, -0.016230419278144836, -0.036488115787506104, -0.011571540497243404, -0.02069016918540001, 0.015554067678749561, 0.043229032307863235, 0.01136197429150343, -0.009696018882095814, 0.012041877955198288, -0.04505763575434685, 0.00005541669816011563, -0.017965368926525116, 0.057934150099754333, 0.036783114075660706, 0.009391598403453827, -0.017722750082612038, 0.02794194407761097, 0.00794925820082426, -0.0063218167051672935, -0.02792954258620739, 0.017927099019289017, 0.05194569379091263, -0.028451887890696526, 0.036080896854400635, -0.004752174951136112, -0.03734583035111427, 0.04222260043025017, 0.009505161084234715, -0.0016574133187532425, -0.039541225880384445, -0.06645933538675308, -0.03289398178458214, 0.0073849353939294815, -0.054834429174661636, 0.004191618412733078, -0.05800534784793854, -0.00372591451741755, 0.024880949407815933, 0.04143349453806877, -0.0037959718611091375, 0.041377194225788116, 0.0036939699202775955, 0.014519779942929745, 0.026237759739160538, -0.025199878960847855, -0.0018752770265564322, -0.008245849050581455, 0.006135590374469757, -0.041230928152799606, -0.10664668679237366, 0.00869816169142723, 0.007725749164819717, 0.012056034058332443, -0.0015191043494269252, 0.01737184077501297, -0.03310791775584221, 0.010954594239592552, -0.0060508595779538155, -0.017644938081502914, -0.008650724776089191, 0.049452800303697586, 0.019979732111096382, 0.037385180592536926, 0.05045327544212341, -0.009937469847500324, 0.010978818871080875, 0.02318998984992504, 0.05450551584362984, 0.04948800057172775, -0.011620067059993744, -0.0072916182689368725, -0.03385717049241066, 0.01407864224165678, 0.02513640560209751, -0.010073120705783367, -0.022173309698700905, -0.037627432495355606, 0.0007226340239867568, 0.049529872834682465, -0.027557548135519028, 0.007714988198131323, 0.016111431643366814, 0.05042937397956848, -0.026178855448961258, -0.018659451976418495, -0.0810316726565361, -0.011263860389590263, 0.009253346361219883, -0.03343233838677406, -0.0023973232600837946, 0.009842654690146446, 0.022477133199572563, 0.02198823355138302, -0.008609380573034286, -0.038659170269966125, 0.001763930544257164, 0.030411988496780396, -0.02378121204674244, -0.023823626339435577, 0.08075598627328873, 0.026348086073994637, -0.04348812252283096, 0.031152842566370964, -0.03392000496387482, -0.039568182080984116, 0.00551612488925457, -0.02970263920724392, 0.018811367452144623, -0.022393599152565002, -0.018277853727340698, 0.012293688952922821, -0.002529794117435813, 0.0050548529252409935, -0.010105558671057224, -0.07780145853757858, 0.05431272089481354, 0.09204211086034775, -0.008894190192222595, 0.007488828618079424, 0.0004450632550287992, -0.0099675003439188, 0.02075587399303913, -0.03484230488538742, -0.019061191007494926, -0.03888660669326782, 0.008948486298322678, 0.012629262171685696, 0.027510810643434525, 0.005578876007348299, 0.011029873974621296, 0.01944933831691742, -0.004080906976014376, 0.028459209948778152, 0.05312153324484825, 0.016853904351592064, 0.004272491671144962, 0.02755865827202797, -0.010082979686558247, 0.01250329241156578, 0.009027324616909027, 0.03967146947979927, -0.015834132209420204, 0.012489310465753078, -0.03981650248169899, -0.01666110008955002, 0.06434237957000732, 0.012110110372304916, -0.019739093258976936, -0.03975115343928337, -0.02755705825984478, 0.01615176536142826, -0.02902921289205551, 0.018219511955976486, 0.05945737659931183, 0.014559915289282799, -0.0367213599383831, 0.0021166973747313023, -0.016502883285284042, -0.02454504556953907, 0.07597905397415161, -0.010574721731245518, -0.023420944809913635, 0.016280489042401314, -0.060972120612859726, 0.01392863504588604, 0.03736842796206474, -0.04258543252944946, -0.02396385744214058, 0.0026574688963592052, 0.0411049909889698, -0.013902409933507442, 0.01723865233361721, -0.03389652073383331, -0.029885562136769295, -0.01214304007589817, -0.0289451964199543, 0.037798620760440826, 0.0068286871537566185, -0.06597849726676941, -0.0476323738694191, -0.06324682384729385, -0.008887305855751038, 0.02962474711239338, 0.013417710550129414, -0.08570562303066254, 0.015157723799347878, -0.004303911700844765, -0.05219441279768944, -0.0525587797164917, -0.03896636143326759, 0.02282349206507206, -0.013697911985218525, -0.010389790870249271, 0.035093508660793304, 0.014536281116306782, -0.04534732177853584, -0.005471930839121342, -0.026864944025874138, 0.005114865954965353, 0.0032388740219175816, 0.007772146258503199, 0.023914532735943794, 0.013401114381849766, 0.008520761504769325, 0.02639019675552845, -0.009485957212746143, 0.004330158699303865, -0.0851057916879654, -0.02734634093940258, 0.027843846008181572, 0.01407893281430006, 0.014059314504265785, 0.027902841567993164, -0.0008374314056709409, 0.06260038912296295, 0.05211815983057022, -0.008899613283574581, -0.04392457380890846, -0.004762027878314257, -0.014405406080186367, -0.027028314769268036, 0.0691361203789711, 0.03699643909931183, 0.030784808099269867, 0.034852154552936554, -0.028643185272812843, 0.010636662133038044, 0.03347901254892349, 0.0019744024612009525, 0.022905318066477776, 0.03293821960687637, -0.01846422627568245, -0.013351480476558208, 0.022853095084428787, 0.031136002391576767, -0.02893752232193947, 0.03834417089819908, -0.01546253077685833, -0.027064915746450424, -0.012380745261907578, -0.0469992458820343, -0.0043505108915269375, -0.0001508413115516305, 0.012889619916677475, -0.030108334496617317, 0.011745594441890717, -0.015624403022229671, -0.050324611365795135, -0.0030597904697060585, -0.02016221545636654, 0.05180858448147774, -0.02923629619181156, 0.009143184870481491, 0.022927843034267426, 0.05087042227387428, -0.009846615605056286, 0.014326348900794983, 0.002050357172265649, 0.01552367489784956, -0.016197795048356056, -0.04756379500031471, 0.0006274165934883058, 0.0075041260570287704, 0.05872602015733719, -0.005917808972299099, 0.011966358870267868, -0.014932600781321526, 0.0030805845744907856, -0.04214674234390259, -0.018065815791487694, -0.028663398697972298, 0.04111380875110626, 0.012377740815281868, 0.06348074227571487, 0.014477184042334557, 0.0008585822070017457, 0.017846733331680298, -0.0070546274073421955, -0.06262648850679398, 0.05684102326631546, 0.04371054098010063, -0.010158096440136433, -0.009225192479789257, -0.0397920124232769, 0.03985421732068062, -0.020349843427538872, -0.051074668765068054, 0.004762515425682068, 0.0193006731569767, -0.02237679623067379, 0.006081036292016506, -0.005571254063397646, -0.027302123606204987, 0.010790614411234856, 0.036557815968990326, -0.014082915149629116, -0.013419547118246555, 0.012898039072751999, 0.008726500906050205, -0.025589659810066223, -0.007037047296762466, -0.007050851825624704, 0.052271537482738495, 0.035140927881002426, 0.04122575744986534, 0.010850407183170319, 0.01650938391685486, -0.04774559289216995, 0.01950182020664215, 0.015573783777654171, 0.06535189598798752, 0.061856627464294434, -0.019157378003001213, -0.014152025803923607, -0.008723916485905647, 0.009023182094097137, 0.007115380372852087, -0.020603861659765244, 0.0022327241022139788, -0.021173547953367233, 0.07604341208934784, 0.018237100914120674, -0.05216186121106148, -0.0013279261766001582, 0.05783567950129509, -0.0117881391197443, 0.014118063263595104, -0.03767148032784462, -0.015318378806114197, -0.008579714223742485, 0.024706866592168808, 0.04262726008892059, -0.02941407635807991, -0.01353858970105648, -0.014882085844874382, 0.04221107438206673, -0.030833885073661804, -0.049302540719509125, 0.0012526105856522918, -0.009878508746623993, 0.04170744866132736, 0.02860313281416893, -0.04683304578065872, -0.023936711251735687, 0.05396319553256035, 0.021888669580221176, 0.040948040783405304, 0.006216124631464481, -0.07549236714839935, -0.00709815276786685, 0.021930143237113953, 0.06024174392223358, -0.05737258866429329, -0.0238344706594944, -0.024878716096282005, -0.017587732523679733, -0.008952602744102478, -0.036372195929288864, 0.012087207287549973, -0.005081593990325928, -0.0020583781879395247, -0.02518414705991745, -0.040411874651908875, -0.07565084099769592, 0.018590345978736877, -0.0198136568069458, 0.006819020491093397, -0.003398674540221691, -0.03265394642949104, -0.04625234380364418, 0.008082601241767406, 0.02258126623928547, 0.04454812407493591, -0.06907197088003159, -0.047014426440000534, 0.014494429342448711, 0.030321655794978142, 0.015555034391582012, -0.04807533323764801, 0.014978817664086819, -0.02371177449822426, -0.022141387686133385, 0.062456417828798294, 0.005436526145786047, 0.011103163473308086, 0.0045912242494523525, 0.04997772350907326, -0.004129349719733, 0.03007117100059986, -0.037749357521533966, 0.021809812635183334, 0.0038502654060721397, -0.01580391265451908, 0.026835596188902855, 0.008913460187613964, -0.022670956328511238, 0.014425358735024929, -0.07866442948579788, -0.01460670493543148, -0.036116503179073334, -0.03476019576191902, -0.03771621361374855, 0.012790558859705925, 0.012486645020544529, 0.010246196761727333, 0.004890257027000189, 0.031791068613529205, -0.02150837332010269, -0.009937731549143791, 0.031086936593055725, 0.03361336141824722, 0.009722313843667507, -0.027431633323431015, 0.011678959242999554, 0.02982226572930813, 0.015120968222618103, -0.019049853086471558, 0.029612965881824493, 0.004659651778638363, 0.03514445200562477, -0.013382738456130028, -0.0596621073782444, 0.0044495039619505405, -0.009826713241636753, 0.009230578318238258, -0.009143696166574955, 0.007638829294592142, 0.030765675008296967, 0.0239415243268013, 0.034122709184885025, 0.02345888689160347, -0.04631539806723595, -0.018765930086374283, 0.056098271161317825, -0.005637200083583593, 0.01617038995027542, 0.0006929130759090185, 0.05809513479471207, -0.042319405823946, -0.004174805711954832, -0.01749163493514061, -0.04787351191043854, 0.009205030277371407, -0.027710556983947754, -0.020806580781936646, -0.020496683195233345, 0.007133736740797758, -0.03615449741482735, 0.0012926158960908651, -0.0025911147240549326, 0.04290260002017021, -0.033385105431079865, 0.013241089880466461, -0.0179337989538908, 0.008531652390956879, 0.05318824574351311, 0.0005738956388086081, -0.013194015249609947, 0.05284467339515686, -0.02941427193582058, -0.02294335700571537, 0.009372910484671593, -0.01172611117362976, -0.025351133197546005, -0.013362595811486244, -0.0039269267581403255, 0.03100804053246975, 0.06370916217565536, 0.039845701307058334, -0.029461929574608803, 0.010096888057887554, -0.006453677546232939, 0.009091611951589584, -0.039088089019060135, -0.0019540321081876755, -0.02235354483127594, 0.004569760989397764, -0.02322639897465706, 0.017002126201987267, -0.02875952422618866, -0.007327803876250982, 0.05958046019077301, 0.002566614421084523, -0.0009742668480612338, 0.047289296984672546, 0.046915896236896515, -0.028911162167787552, 0.021635502576828003, -0.02754157967865467, -0.03393135592341423, 0.03745055943727493, 0.01931017078459263, 0.013132892549037933, 0.010908074676990509, 0.030782613903284073, -0.035185739398002625, -0.008576826192438602, -0.07122840732336044, -0.006040587555617094, 0.051401253789663315, 0.014424065127968788, 0.06105088070034981, 0.04988997429609299, 0.0117743369191885, 0.020824871957302094, -0.013388360850512981, 0.021189620718359947, -0.0037373765371739864, 0.0014871204039081931, 0.06449364125728607, -0.0004535407351795584, -0.01874803565442562, 0.026557322591543198, -0.008594674058258533, 0.03085017390549183, 0.02284766361117363, 0.00904583279043436, -0.022086182609200478, 0.013667757622897625, -0.038989849388599396, -0.008453572168946266, 0.024900265038013458, -0.06618402898311615, 0.01027089636772871, -0.057075560092926025, -0.01440893393009901, 0.033848486840724945, 0.05554487183690071, -0.002471514279022813, -0.04780711233615875, -0.013775572180747986, -0.05015452206134796, -0.011991916224360466, 0.05119197443127632, -0.05800025165081024, 0.04682081565260887, 0.00006498986476799473, 0.06803532689809799, -0.014249510131776333, 0.01978999748826027, -0.05194415524601936, -0.06962025165557861, 0.0023885199334472418, -0.025083027780056, -0.038438063114881516, 0.025325508788228035, 0.006609220523387194, 0.002956309588626027, -0.010846919380128384, -0.04090407118201256, 0.010477361269295216, -0.003951732534915209, 0.027132023125886917, 0.01165815070271492, 0.04913292080163956, -0.012089514173567295, 0.00700802356004715, 0.0030247720424085855, -0.029193637892603874, 0.13611292839050293, 0.07261814922094345, 0.05034838244318962, -0.059053681790828705, 0.023650050163269043, 0.031491003930568695, -0.01520460844039917, 0.017514795064926147, -0.028868909925222397, 0.046503957360982895, -0.008576786145567894, 0.05548003315925598, -0.02309338189661503, 0.04838856682181358, 0.010085008107125759, 0.035840149968862534, -0.05660498887300491, -0.037625089287757874, -0.006441242061555386, -0.011157182976603508, 0.010181562043726444, -0.009356786496937275, -0.0307723768055439, 0.015306992456316948, 0.02408849261701107, -0.003480037674307823, -0.04062763974070549, -0.021371904760599136, 0.004209074191749096, -0.0069417087361216545, -0.0028434975538402796, -0.00542868860065937, 0.0024117545690387487, 0.010703387670218945, 0.023442616686224937, -0.018198737874627113, 0.007532182615250349, -0.025071755051612854, -0.008252416737377644, 0.039405059069395065, 0.0008896470535546541, 0.025477252900600433, 0.004111524671316147, 0.0011562177678570151, -0.044614244252443314, -0.018390430137515068, -0.03369738906621933, 0.021078171208500862, -0.01151890680193901, -0.04362648352980614, -0.012871949933469296, 0.03822658956050873, 0.00777098536491394, -0.03670681267976761, -0.015913408249616623, 0.04640268161892891, 0.05369577184319496, -0.02387143112719059, -0.005549609661102295, -0.01638847589492798, 0.04033948853611946, -0.0160189438611269, 0.00926416926085949, 0.05055706948041916, -0.011138223111629486, -0.027863971889019012, -0.04409279301762581, 0.05277932807803154, 0.028093278408050537, 0.025323033332824707, 0.006368240341544151, -0.005853850394487381, -0.006834324449300766, -0.026854876428842545, 0.02295076847076416, -0.009175614453852177, 0.014913712628185749, 0.00522629963234067, -0.005877015180885792, -0.015783455222845078, -0.026244359090924263, 0.05199500545859337, -0.025587769225239754, 0.00787328276783228, -0.04769345745444298, 0.007253355346620083, -0.006170419976115227, 0.04838021099567413, 0.01640981063246727, 0.0400434248149395, -0.0066027264110744, 0.025139525532722473, -0.01053899060934782, -0.03656531125307083, -0.017137713730335236, 0.03394322097301483, -0.0029894679319113493, 0.006550246383994818, -0.007725484203547239, 0.07805023342370987, -0.0033667325042188168, 0.05241268873214722, -0.015601761639118195, 0.022438449785113335, -0.004025367554277182, -0.02670525386929512, 0.014701757580041885, -0.045438893139362335, 0.0051189688965678215, -0.012128797359764576, -0.00760686257854104, -0.023838719353079796, -0.006639539729803801, -0.006460853386670351, -0.029636560007929802, 0.03800869733095169, -0.06413301080465317, 0.0032912003807723522, 0.0028401589952409267, -0.0043997145257890224, 0.004301175940781832, -0.01628050208091736, -0.041555099189281464, 0.004758824128657579, 0.01682407408952713, 0.0056617711670696735, -0.043020009994506836, 0.017905475571751595, 0.002439754083752632, -0.01442012283951044, -0.01726904697716236, 0.021858634427189827, 0.022481659427285194, 0.006911097560077906, -0.007499346975237131, 0.022863661870360374, 0.005993711296468973, 0.057175830006599426, 0.008351598866283894, -0.012394128367304802, -0.0010839028982445598, -0.059690773487091064, -0.0030314112082123756, -0.008439222350716591, 0.009090296924114227, 0.03599702566862106, 0.006836134009063244, -0.0009468897478654981, -0.011811543256044388, 0.06348629295825958, -0.03367466479539871, -0.015951067209243774, -0.027311226353049278, 0.02602698653936386, 0.03750493749976158, -0.008789410814642906, -0.02196616679430008, 0.019051197916269302, -0.006250605918467045, 0.0301840640604496, 0.04370686784386635, 0.01796582341194153, 0.028445178642868996, 0.014084788970649242, -0.011192713864147663, 0.01199176162481308, 0.006151028908789158, -0.013326004147529602, 0.007261896971613169, 0.05122051760554314, -0.021990997716784477, 0.05000331252813339, -0.002358398400247097, -0.003118070773780346, -0.08900871872901917, -0.021264778450131416, 0.03370237350463867, -0.014776377938687801, 0.052896324545145035, -0.04762494936585426, -0.04202546924352646, 0.027885325253009796, -0.001032886328175664, 0.002456911141052842, 0.01668267510831356, 0.0007604757556691766, -0.05442348122596741, 0.04723353683948517, -0.03539245203137398, 0.021993419155478477, 0.023708682507276535, 0.016255101189017296, 0.058996669948101044, 0.012884079478681087, -0.001297440961934626, -0.025517811998724937, -0.019048498943448067, 0.0211455300450325, 0.033535853028297424, -0.05326761305332184, 0.033260442316532135, -0.0507519356906414, 0.0005314619629643857, -0.0014825166435912251, 0.006802763789892197, 0.03006931021809578, 0.04201791435480118, 0.05737687274813652, 0.010434813797473907, 0.08429795503616333, -0.001082972506992519, 0.0071591041050851345, -0.023366698995232582, 0.007368315942585468, 0.030073292553424835, 0.0057644592598080635, -0.0411880798637867, 0.040183261036872864, 0.035220518708229065, 0.006289998069405556, -0.013420851901173592, 0.010341445915400982, -0.004847611766308546, -0.02322349138557911, 0.0027776688802987337, -0.00449833320453763, -0.005578714422881603, -0.021235572174191475, -0.013352102600038052, -0.03277499973773956, 0.013518627732992172, 0.04499552771449089, 0.03465890511870384, 0.035729411989450455, 0.018680792301893234, -0.033984772861003876, -0.040021102875471115, 0.0020430346485227346, 0.018520059064030647, 0.00869646854698658, -0.02732722833752632, -0.0008807609556242824, -0.012584484182298183, 0.02089531160891056, -0.01660306006669998, -0.005795266013592482, -0.0242460947483778, 0.006231832783669233, -0.0193413645029068, 0.0054771737195551395, 0.028895102441310883, 0.01742001250386238, 0.028683936223387718, -0.08669481426477432, 0.06014421582221985, -0.021632656455039978, -0.021401382982730865, -0.06542205065488815, -0.04052302613854408, -0.041191622614860535, 0.04230771213769913, 0.0056847454980015755, 0.016529731452465057, -0.005001147277653217, -0.029043249785900116, 0.03634225204586983, 0.016864649951457977, -0.0500129796564579, 0.06905721127986908, 0.015451077371835709, -0.022377265617251396, -0.049681805074214935, 0.031779222190380096, -0.008437469601631165, 0.0335552878677845, -0.0038169720210134983, -0.0480511412024498, 0.00418360298499465, -0.005961100570857525, 0.0005568983033299446, 0.021847620606422424, 0.004265296272933483, -0.010057524777948856, 0.019727420061826706, -0.019992532208561897, -0.006313364952802658, 0.035326581448316574, -0.004915498662739992, -0.054213378578424454, 0.03172897920012474, -0.026507562026381493, -0.0004199468530714512, 0.006188001483678818, 0.006423788610845804, -0.0025074912700802088, -0.04855415225028992, 0.024380842223763466, 0.007446604780852795, -0.04051254689693451, -0.002753764856606722, 0.039742063730955124, 0.006220418494194746, 0.05619385093450546, -0.040818411856889725, 0.003933089319616556, -0.025644958019256592, -0.02844379097223282, -0.008672109805047512, -0.004888833034783602, 0.03351651877164841, -0.014253649860620499, 0.013195264153182507, 0.021014580503106117, -0.006940314080566168, 0.012962465174496174, -0.0011269421083852649, 0.04080234840512276, -0.03116014413535595, 0.005965260323137045, 0.023994233459234238, 0.014814319089055061, -0.012095294892787933, -0.010716019198298454, -0.018258139491081238, 0.03340437263250351, -0.06447116285562515, -0.04381965473294258, -0.04062093421816826, -0.03660276159644127, -0.05105428770184517, -0.014255281537771225, 0.00898436177521944, 0.060659732669591904, 0.017910022288560867, 0.030898507684469223, 0.0023478034418076277, -0.023332007229328156, 0.038745421916246414, -0.03267334774136543, 0.05586158484220505, -0.007132932543754578, -0.037483710795640945, -0.0054372637532651424, -0.020542843267321587, -0.0030110576190054417, -0.0672658383846283, 0.0070463563315570354, 0.03506976366043091, 0.010217742063105106, -0.049549400806427, -0.015957480296492577, -0.012552275322377682, 0.0077564166858792305, -0.007577068172395229, -0.01920599304139614, -0.06278479099273682, 0.02687806449830532, 0.009413034655153751, -0.0003257491043768823 ]
<p>I have dependent variable matrix $Y_{i,j}$ and feature matrix $X_{i,k}$. My objective is to predict each element of the vector $[y_{i,0},...,y_{i,J}]$ by using new observations of the features, $[x_{i,0},...,x_{i,K}]$, i.e. to estimate $Y_{i,j} = f(X_{i,k})$.</p> <p>In my problem, all the dependent variables are closely related, and any given dependent variable is explained by a large number of the available features (so for any dependent variable, there aren't many redundant features). In addition, interactions between the features are likely to be important in predicting the response vector.</p> <p>An example of the type of problem I'm facing would be if each dependent variable was the expected life span of various species of fish, and the features were water temperature, salt/fresh water binary, lake/ocean binary, binary for existence of particular predators, etc etc. We want a fast model that can mix these to predict each element of the vector.</p> <p>There are many ways to tackle this problem. What I am interested in is what multivariate models exist that are both fast at run time (it's for a real time application) and can handle interactions. I am also looking for a model that is automated; automated variable selection and automated interaction selection. I am also looking an approach where the multivariate version generalizes better than simply fitting separate models for each $y_{.,j}$ (which could be achieved with splines, glms, etc).</p> <p>The obvious answer is multivariate forests or multi-output neural nets, and so on. I'm looking for a faster approach; i.e. a model that doesn't have any sort of "deep" or iterative architecture that is computationally burdensome for large data (a multivariate model that's additive in transforms of features or feature interactions is ideal). A good answer is multivariate splines, looking for others.</p>
37,270
[ -0.02879304252564907, -0.004779771436005831, 0.02383141778409481, 0.007752793375402689, 0.032876525074243546, -0.00893047172576189, -0.015644825994968414, -0.0281590074300766, 0.05108453333377838, -0.05633999779820442, 0.031170152127742767, 0.0522724911570549, 0.05263625085353851, 0.015642914921045303, 0.009116348810493946, 0.014723536558449268, -0.018817860633134842, -0.01863228715956211, 0.014579806476831436, 0.000175754728843458, 0.010839380323886871, 0.008227329701185226, 0.04974975436925888, 0.0036594232078641653, -0.014451144263148308, 0.05012785270810127, 0.006111317779868841, -0.022060969844460487, -0.023675383999943733, 0.04094759002327919, -0.019007841125130653, -0.06147311255335808, -0.025078652426600456, 0.07549969106912613, 0.004708527587354183, -0.01135979499667883, -0.01293916068971157, -0.02681281790137291, 0.0029087241273373365, 0.03936076909303665, -0.028473272919654846, -0.0595511831343174, -0.008964696899056435, -0.006506291218101978, 0.015054110437631607, 0.03518170118331909, -0.01740357093513012, -0.0419551357626915, 0.02095402404665947, -0.02884894795715809, 0.09476053714752197, 0.029224414378404617, 0.05480370670557022, 0.03384258970618248, -0.03351353481411934, 0.004176114685833454, 0.06717623025178909, 0.08657083660364151, 0.013738048262894154, -0.05619093403220177, 0.0006792121566832066, -0.013482742011547089, 0.017153646796941757, -0.004190452862530947, -0.03889482095837593, 0.026233812794089317, -0.03522759675979614, -0.004584355279803276, 0.0006508357473649085, -0.039097148925065994, 0.01717265322804451, -0.006332489661872387, 0.039149560034275055, 0.02962678112089634, -0.026549799367785454, 0.010864251293241978, -0.0017195135587826371, 0.033129435032606125, 0.023345237597823143, 0.018209006637334824, -0.007189219351857901, 0.01814422756433487, -0.006922946777194738, 0.019759107381105423, 0.034184180200099945, -0.012400229461491108, 0.06828875839710236, -0.021934829652309418, 0.01135728508234024, 0.01658627577126026, -0.016677845269441605, 0.010668384842574596, 0.06392394751310349, -0.0004297968989703804, -0.05807880312204361, 0.015423201955854893, 0.013216035440564156, 0.017465662211179733, 0.040341056883335114, -0.004296247381716967, 0.003269671695306897, -0.03382425755262375, -0.04390989616513252, 0.04195334017276764, -0.0031055626459419727, 0.01220108475536108, -0.04207395762205124, -0.016255659982562065, -0.010546674020588398, -0.02436784654855728, 0.015001093037426472, 0.013287678360939026, 0.0037199915386736393, -0.024652304127812386, 0.014103997498750687, -0.03411748632788658, 0.006131023168563843, -0.029851270839571953, 0.05155816301703453, 0.08994545787572861, 0.022644922137260437, -0.054548248648643494, 0.03223932906985283, -0.019876087084412575, -0.05432404205203056, 0.0011825410183519125, -0.0005674494314007461, -0.04005691036581993, -0.037187155336141586, 0.05660874396562576, -0.002332643372938037, -0.02497301995754242, 0.04359395056962967, -0.010207105427980423, 0.02112383395433426, -0.020568782463669777, -0.07004431635141373, -0.062255676835775375, 0.019154280424118042, -0.041905540972948074, 0.05419456958770752, -0.03481902554631233, 0.02924773469567299, 0.0256178081035614, 0.06613704562187195, 0.0009639672352932394, 0.015337765216827393, 0.05168898403644562, 0.03461320698261261, -0.02378753386437893, -0.023278892040252686, -0.032679274678230286, -0.010391324758529663, 0.019608916714787483, -0.005808363668620586, -0.08983395248651505, 0.034654561430215836, 0.023936670273542404, -0.011229774914681911, 0.03956937417387962, 0.04521295055747032, 0.009510258212685585, -0.019373329356312752, 0.012840029783546925, 0.02514205500483513, -0.0200585275888443, 0.026662368327379227, -0.04611317440867424, 0.06883833557367325, 0.02927316166460514, 0.007100346498191357, 0.014014647342264652, 0.03773815929889679, 0.062319066375494, 0.027600212022662163, -0.014273545704782009, -0.0018341542454436421, 0.015841029584407806, -0.020553896203637123, 0.02717568166553974, -0.035471513867378235, -0.05005902051925659, -0.032186318188905716, -0.02783883735537529, 0.028087832033634186, 0.08149220049381256, -0.013778681866824627, -0.04069770127534866, 0.02262043207883835, -0.03605290502309799, -0.02961626835167408, -0.053721290081739426, 0.010331224650144577, -0.009662996977567673, 0.0006146751111373305, 0.05898049473762512, -0.016741951927542686, 0.014469941146671772, 0.02985629439353943, -0.03503001853823662, -0.02845129743218422, 0.001212384202517569, 0.05443986877799034, -0.03414205089211464, 0.006283636204898357, 0.03230864554643631, 0.007881603203713894, -0.04230091720819473, 0.04255606606602669, -0.025322549045085907, -0.07230720669031143, 0.0005015588831156492, -0.042379822582006454, 0.028316160663962364, -0.03659683093428612, -0.022124039009213448, 0.022761313244700432, -0.024379322305321693, -0.012036535888910294, 0.01958376355469227, -0.047536205500364304, 0.055679213255643845, 0.043564263731241226, -0.00930379331111908, 0.016458872705698013, 0.03182660788297653, 0.022280439734458923, 0.016077807173132896, -0.018871337175369263, -0.023221828043460846, -0.06334953755140305, -0.0020575847011059523, 0.044658221304416656, 0.038743872195482254, -0.026653097942471504, 0.0437331460416317, 0.037127818912267685, 0.038474392145872116, 0.017753010615706444, 0.0227882768958807, -0.021461769938468933, 0.024350620806217194, 0.04990905523300171, 0.008165794424712658, -0.001756455865688622, -0.02862207219004631, 0.012064382433891296, 0.026118019595742226, 0.057980455458164215, 0.005630983971059322, -0.02349669672548771, 0.040450893342494965, 0.02409416250884533, -0.009300312027335167, -0.011822151020169258, -0.008944323286414146, 0.0257320124655962, -0.01743978075683117, 0.002892408287152648, 0.05556856840848923, 0.025792133063077927, -0.004725966136902571, 0.013039330951869488, -0.012628274969756603, 0.021766019985079765, 0.010388676077127457, -0.04286165535449982, 0.007496079429984093, 0.021394802257418633, -0.05715131387114525, 0.06677308678627014, -0.016866791993379593, -0.02351938560605049, -0.029206259176135063, 0.039518315345048904, 0.027697719633579254, 0.009939300827682018, 0.025814523920416832, 0.0030491456855088472, 0.0133941899985075, 0.027815522626042366, -0.03973803669214249, 0.030964918434619904, 0.029031459242105484, -0.053441792726516724, -0.014346080832183361, -0.03412365913391113, -0.006335154641419649, 0.04299183189868927, -0.01842423714697361, -0.02492525614798069, 0.006607753690332174, -0.0174949262291193, -0.060845907777547836, -0.034432727843523026, -0.016331955790519714, 0.0342593751847744, 0.003784812754020095, -0.012984099797904491, 0.021644357591867447, -0.008271666243672371, -0.04955141246318817, 0.0034253939520567656, -0.02730809524655342, -0.006014875136315823, -0.060598187148571014, -0.01708686351776123, 0.004686076659709215, 0.006434052251279354, -0.02127836085855961, 0.06411149352788925, -0.03738778084516525, 0.01503843441605568, -0.06844092905521393, -0.05867139995098114, 0.020871177315711975, 0.017601069062948227, 0.046935033053159714, 0.035577453672885895, 0.015190300531685352, 0.029339062049984932, 0.011704090051352978, -0.020670875906944275, -0.060887206345796585, 0.0017009598668664694, -0.04777221381664276, -0.03870046138763428, 0.025225672870874405, -0.01367737166583538, 0.0061011239886283875, 0.0379473939538002, 0.0002209926606155932, -0.004788411781191826, 0.030105095356702805, 0.016947172582149506, -0.004753668326884508, 0.03440791368484497, -0.007057079114019871, 0.03025335818529129, -0.010592913255095482, 0.025508616119623184, 0.003892507404088974, 0.0029913880862295628, -0.0013432418927550316, -0.02649364061653614, 0.04270049184560776, -0.045153118669986725, 0.005358878988772631, -0.03015056811273098, -0.011641319841146469, -0.023543115705251694, -0.00835345033556223, 0.013205905444920063, -0.03434304520487785, -0.02107156254351139, 0.053081411868333817, 0.055528368800878525, -0.034412410110235214, 0.02038622833788395, 0.0313267782330513, 0.028426488861441612, -0.023542698472738266, 0.045479319989681244, -0.04898892715573311, -0.004590414930135012, 0.009077672846615314, -0.012554455548524857, 0.007943596690893173, 0.028923457488417625, 0.0003946575161535293, 0.03535979613661766, -0.021108880639076233, -0.01989150233566761, 0.042801085859537125, -0.07324637472629547, 0.01479987520724535, -0.03242582455277443, 0.05261307209730148, 0.0064872861839830875, 0.04190554842352867, -0.0008980240672826767, -0.024965496733784676, 0.017901727929711342, 0.01766742393374443, -0.04987027496099472, 0.010106782428920269, -0.05573675408959389, 0.05241220071911812, 0.02251371182501316, 0.013139629736542702, 0.04460795596241951, -0.01250466238707304, -0.006089088972657919, -0.019334634765982628, 0.047951098531484604, -0.04269091784954071, -0.0024609665852040052, -0.0341915637254715, -0.04014630988240242, -0.017459271475672722, -0.01308278739452362, 0.01832055114209652, -0.050021421164274216, 0.03510337695479393, 0.01424202136695385, -0.008529534563422203, 0.0008872446487657726, -0.018849657848477364, 0.011361071839928627, 0.015394358895719051, 0.032964661717414856, 0.02035215124487877, 0.04935489967465401, -0.024080567061901093, -0.006364841945469379, 0.006580285727977753, 0.03463874012231827, 0.03282688930630684, -0.0013906185049563646, -0.021289562806487083, -0.06613478809595108, -0.012742076069116592, 0.014335909858345985, 0.05187346041202545, 0.01900637149810791, -0.018217720091342926, 0.027194350957870483, 0.02128167636692524, -0.07855114340782166, 0.04212379455566406, 0.030419863760471344, 0.014009150676429272, -0.017170406877994537, -0.00017369171837344766, -0.005237250588834286, 0.007312737870961428, 0.005703598260879517, 0.026017365977168083, 0.030920831486582756, 0.007575205527245998, -0.03146137297153473, 0.010860344395041466, -0.04780591279268265, 0.006863326765596867, -0.0019904826767742634, 0.037175253033638, 0.04212874919176102, -0.01766103133559227, -0.03401605039834976, -0.024622919037938118, 0.06240563467144966, 0.04288268834352493, 0.002620088402181864, 0.03754982724785805, -0.09198804944753647, 0.030955959111452103, 0.041867125779390335, 0.026365747675299644, -0.017533153295516968, -0.010379983112215996, -0.03386246785521507, -0.05027259886264801, 0.039582058787345886, 0.0033743453677743673, 0.011331818997859955, 0.012726119719445705, -0.022123554721474648, -0.006455771625041962, -0.0095045892521739, -0.04737033322453499, 0.011432691477239132, -0.028341220691800117, 0.03512336686253548, -0.009694059379398823, -0.03861873969435692, -0.02410160005092621, 0.011942856945097446, 0.02558653987944126, 0.036613885313272476, 0.03214365988969803, -0.035897716879844666, 0.024451347067952156, 0.015984706580638885, 0.014081785455346107, -0.04816459119319916, 0.005249363835901022, 0.027970246970653534, -0.06380468606948853, 0.04377174749970436, -0.012931457720696926, -0.05572539195418358, 0.04246978089213371, 0.0177064910531044, -0.004226471297442913, -0.02216367796063423, 0.004972626455128193, 0.024294009432196617, 0.014418001286685467, 0.02849998138844967, 0.04271338880062103, 0.022676890715956688, -0.026832180097699165, 0.0035476002376526594, -0.02870851382613182, 0.008206881582736969, -0.006568020675331354, -0.03481635823845863, -0.024511966854333878, -0.007627858314663172, -0.009651382453739643, 0.028369897976517677, -0.016593635082244873, 0.01874520257115364, -0.05846674367785454, -0.008583283051848412, -0.006117716897279024, 0.011893162503838539, -0.027796266600489616, -0.036563146859407425, 0.015978369861841202, 0.02643749862909317, -0.018262404948472977, -0.0016298705013468862, 0.0337224081158638, -0.001402469933964312, -0.015590615570545197, 0.007865417748689651, -0.02227875590324402, -0.019117968156933784, -0.04887126386165619, -0.02150474674999714, 0.009714335203170776, 0.019451001659035683, 0.04246387258172035, -0.01914430782198906, 0.05249118432402611, 0.039382316172122955, -0.07845278084278107, 0.014748334884643555, 0.012607304379343987, 0.0197012759745121, 0.022701000794768333, 0.0002809080178849399, 0.01956094801425934, -0.06631354242563248, 0.003313989844173193, -0.04261958599090576, -0.032158445566892624, 0.020876875147223473, 0.0040192315354943275, 0.006289631128311157, -0.06045622006058693, 0.022552836686372757, -0.0595921091735363, -0.010870053432881832, -0.03269617259502411, 0.02247045189142227, -0.03300578147172928, -0.0017664167098701, 0.021587297320365906, 0.03756866604089737, 0.006041162647306919, 0.0030455775558948517, 0.03158307448029518, 0.03795546293258667, -0.019069211557507515, 0.014611845836043358, -0.0002521385613363236, 0.002821421017870307, -0.023823874071240425, 0.054351091384887695, -0.03029404953122139, -0.005841872189193964, 0.03318974748253822, -0.0024251644499599934, 0.014370275661349297, 0.03217729926109314, -0.021160788834095, -0.014499370008707047, -0.005704584065824747, 0.00809408351778984, 0.015584810636937618, -0.006224426906555891, -0.018051374703645706, -0.006056253798305988, 0.012258751317858696, -0.027202775701880455, 0.0116123016923666, -0.014137288555502892, -0.03157994896173477, 0.012090975418686867, 0.028617560863494873, -0.017615094780921936, 0.012573406100273132, -0.008645200170576572, -0.0023182453587651253, 0.06430388987064362, 0.010154356248676777, 0.009714107029139996, -0.0011033802293241024, 0.023284543305635452, -0.02477024868130684, -0.05395613983273506, -0.023088939487934113, -0.005836153868585825, 0.06334036588668823, -0.03435169905424118, 0.02829914167523384, 0.02227131836116314, 0.011902859434485435, -0.01326791476458311, -0.040868114680051804, -0.021885713562369347, 0.03248598426580429, 0.011216890998184681, 0.06291908770799637, 0.006577927619218826, 0.0020187085028737783, 0.034414079040288925, 0.015037325210869312, 0.031722065061330795, 0.054892078042030334, -0.01107883546501398, 0.02697853185236454, 0.021813511848449707, -0.04246441274881363, -0.056411586701869965, 0.02759500779211521, -0.04434116557240486, -0.015736380591988564, -0.03810287266969681, -0.030964231118559837, 0.06583151966333389, 0.05518924444913864, 0.0038033986929804087, -0.04799489676952362, -0.03372453153133392, -0.016176322475075722, 0.016260042786598206, 0.012305397540330887, 0.0028012185357511044, 0.008098836988210678, 0.00632074661552906, 0.013240993022918701, 0.0007520257495343685, 0.017823291942477226, -0.010030273348093033, -0.08431299775838852, -0.0007891345885582268, -0.033339936286211014, -0.047406453639268875, 0.039072778075933456, 0.037967000156641006, -0.03705300763249397, 0.012578967958688736, 0.003682988928630948, 0.006384369917213917, 0.0011171121150255203, 0.019535908475518227, 0.005560585763305426, 0.07257504016160965, 0.005606581456959248, -0.004775932990014553, 0.0016834839479997754, -0.019003259018063545, 0.1099732518196106, 0.0722118392586708, 0.04422711580991745, -0.057563167065382004, 0.005302226636558771, -0.027432110160589218, -0.0339108407497406, -0.03976713865995407, -0.001693217665888369, 0.04271158576011658, -0.016329538077116013, 0.012206333689391613, 0.022011984139680862, 0.03004993125796318, 0.013059406541287899, 0.04190407320857048, -0.06041059270501137, 0.012633226811885834, 0.005776791833341122, -0.01550178974866867, -0.0016281332354992628, 0.0008833343163132668, -0.02102789655327797, 0.0010870668338611722, -0.007096762768924236, -0.01905170828104019, -0.009683514945209026, -0.017069710418581963, 0.030303247272968292, 0.003653882071375847, -0.029048170894384384, -0.0008612283854745328, 0.018794408068060875, 0.03189203888177872, -0.003973629791289568, 0.04483519122004509, 0.029837649315595627, -0.01832265406847, 0.01129593513906002, 0.01234144251793623, -0.010929279960691929, 0.010605470277369022, 0.012861493043601513, -0.008488043211400509, -0.02746487222611904, -0.05841059982776642, -0.049496639519929886, 0.031088607385754585, 0.003240754595026374, -0.013122444041073322, -0.03901904076337814, -0.0028108630795031786, 0.029454415664076805, -0.039181992411613464, -0.04364141449332237, 0.024921352043747902, 0.05972007289528847, -0.03045799769461155, -0.00944546703249216, -0.009714131243526936, 0.02226467803120613, -0.0009101046598516405, 0.05171986296772957, 0.02706248313188553, -0.04071204736828804, -0.021763283759355545, -0.03243523836135864, 0.051098719239234924, 0.007544705178588629, 0.011084775440394878, 0.008284780196845531, -0.01896847039461136, 0.010205995291471481, -0.017211467027664185, 0.030175331979990005, -0.010611266829073429, -0.00011271012772340328, -0.03460489585995674, -0.024879472330212593, -0.036914337426424026, -0.038569375872612, 0.005357715766876936, -0.03091583214700222, -0.016149349510669708, -0.043992601335048676, -0.00663453945890069, 0.01407267153263092, 0.02184324711561203, 0.025915546342730522, 0.020371349528431892, -0.04667385667562485, 0.021489018574357033, 0.02372252568602562, -0.0665532723069191, -0.05445571616292, -0.026768095791339874, -0.02766336314380169, 0.005218275357037783, -0.00932337623089552, 0.03559524193406105, 0.012211372144520283, 0.023516252636909485, -0.02386331371963024, 0.05175948515534401, -0.006196795031428337, 0.005005829036235809, 0.00752358278259635, -0.03899821639060974, 0.012769343331456184, -0.014340219087898731, 0.006589385215193033, -0.026862086728215218, -0.007297787815332413, -0.04703603312373161, -0.030204428359866142, 0.01610717549920082, -0.007494754157960415, -0.022802241146564484, 0.009953306056559086, -0.02803829498589039, 0.025134848430752754, -0.0201917365193367, 0.008353077806532383, -0.05482720583677292, 0.010210851207375526, 0.003763243556022644, -0.028348829597234726, 0.004372011870145798, -0.021304668858647346, -0.035647954791784286, -0.00510932132601738, 0.03967312350869179, -0.0008575099054723978, 0.0003164081717841327, -0.01401324663311243, -0.009526102803647518, -0.018063854426145554, 0.031319376081228256, -0.039781633764505386, -0.0388861708343029, -0.004821568261831999, -0.04904892295598984, -0.00028484067297540605, 0.014852172695100307, -0.03807305544614792, 0.062188658863306046, 0.02676054649055004, 0.014119623228907585, -0.05769406259059906, 0.04431283101439476, -0.0005142029840499163, 0.013305000960826874, 0.010122030973434448, 0.018852483481168747, -0.02822500467300415, 0.007180393673479557, 0.008597157895565033, -0.014732763171195984, -0.046555452048778534, 0.010225789621472359, 0.01919420249760151, 0.012613627128303051, -0.00993350613862276, 0.022605396807193756, -0.015460328198969364, 0.04623594135046005, 0.029012538492679596, -0.025901589542627335, 0.06197132542729378, 0.04888686537742615, -0.0035904073156416416, 0.0478326790034771, 0.019570592790842056, 0.02887856960296631, -0.07399334758520126, 0.02092013508081436, -0.011375831440091133, 0.025811821222305298, 0.04418123513460159, -0.02544998936355114, 0.007995152845978737, 0.030172953382134438, -0.055777158588171005, 0.02042391151189804, -0.012545556761324406, -0.00011519980034790933, -0.0007800360908731818, -0.009119450114667416, -0.027542438358068466, -0.0275272186845541, 0.03179744631052017, -0.005672507453709841, 0.05913534760475159, 0.04529871046543121, 0.014730465598404408, -0.03821805492043495, -0.031457558274269104, 0.029654890298843384, 0.015485619194805622, -0.048496849834918976, 0.04895146191120148, -0.06439428776502609, -0.02102770283818245, 0.00876659993082285, -0.0015176663873717189, 0.01398004125803709, 0.014878959394991398, 0.034508198499679565, 0.019802190363407135, 0.04327108711004257, 0.047864802181720734, -0.03516339883208275, 0.009754651226103306, 0.022404396906495094, 0.005886713974177837, -0.005615017842501402, -0.035220906138420105, 0.05274755880236626, 0.0005938707035966218, -0.023669810965657234, -0.02368008717894554, -0.012621842324733734, 0.0042110648937523365, -0.02308327704668045, 0.003514581825584173, -0.022302106022834778, 0.007076204754412174, -0.018191885203123093, -0.022314120084047318, -0.02865823358297348, -0.008090155199170113, 0.01764405146241188, -0.0003673810278996825, -0.007552505470812321, 0.02146480232477188, -0.003861859207972884, -0.02728254720568657, -0.024219980463385582, -0.029070211574435234, 0.03331764042377472, -0.07434259355068207, -0.03462013602256775, 0.021597664803266525, -0.0224961806088686, -0.054483503103256226, -0.016786333173513412, -0.05847340449690819, 0.05664940923452377, -0.01167083065956831, 0.02418828196823597, 0.061626970767974854, -0.011386417783796787, 0.008653982542455196, -0.04643915966153145, 0.05761381983757019, 0.026979580521583557, 0.004193493630737066, 0.006964095868170261, -0.0015111571410670877, 0.003720397362485528, -0.006125341635197401, 0.053400926291942596, -0.02921632118523121, 0.019463540986180305, -0.007543916814029217, 0.031364358961582184, -0.010480380617082119, -0.029982637614011765, 0.04080447554588318, -0.0247800350189209, -0.048915717750787735, -0.02124849334359169, -0.018644027411937714, 0.032936856150627136, -0.019099650904536247, 0.02271951176226139, 0.008749597705900669, -0.026327909901738167, 0.030158506706357002, -0.002114251023158431, 0.015614321455359459, -0.005447561386972666, -0.011014633812010288, 0.02451324462890625, 0.0019218763336539268, 0.027436507865786552, 0.009308894164860249, 0.0014047414297237992, -0.0519917830824852, 0.036570772528648376, -0.049759525805711746, -0.022663945332169533, -0.01582547277212143, 0.026272395625710487, -0.00862201675772667, -0.06721347570419312, 0.048286471515893936, 0.024994147941470146, -0.036698345094919205, -0.022907933220267296, 0.044388145208358765, -0.004255716223269701, 0.04859541356563568, 0.007200644817203283, 0.029567424207925797, 0.017965547740459442, 0.020703289657831192, 0.033213596791028976, 0.007591515313833952, 0.058914173394441605, -0.006536130327731371, 0.007715720683336258, -0.00772522110491991, -0.020876336842775345, 0.05267629399895668, -0.022225147113204002, 0.011887072585523129, -0.025811055675148964, -0.01945473626255989, 0.047215983271598816, -0.02257704734802246, 0.009672291576862335, -0.013122359290719032, -0.024145763367414474, 0.06842637062072754, -0.06347353011369705, -0.039719488471746445, -0.038686398416757584, -0.03596179932355881, 0.0014861100353300571, -0.02142728492617607, -0.020187029615044594, 0.029344910755753517, -0.00440191151574254, 0.035886481404304504, 0.0038877518381923437, -0.03223450481891632, 0.0017349214758723974, -0.02550121210515499, 0.010340127162635326, -0.028959104791283607, 0.008322035893797874, 0.004626457579433918, 0.0004190065956208855, 0.001558017684146762, -0.029640421271324158, 0.029268475249409676, 0.04977227374911308, 0.01728944107890129, -0.044124845415353775, -0.01129092462360859, 0.002093265997245908, 0.04680314660072327, -0.09016891568899155, 0.003144007408991456, -0.036569640040397644, -0.0074324291199445724, 0.010697634890675545, -0.008089367300271988 ]
<p>I don't really know what's possible, and would like a pointer in the right direction. Many thanks.</p> <p>I have measurements of time and position which could be anything from a person walking, a vehicle on a road, or in a car park, or a printer in an office. I need to work out journey times for vehicles between two points. It may be they take a meandering route, or even take days to get from A to B. Or they may be a pedestrian, or an emergency service vehicle.</p> <p>I want the estimated journey time for a normal vehicle along the main route.</p> <p>The detections are whenever someone is near enough to the detector, which has a particular radius. Sometimes there are very few detections, which probably means the road is empty and journey time would be good, although it could indicate the road is closed, and the journey time would be terrible. Or there could be lots of detections showing traffic not moving, and it could be queueing to turn off the road, but other vehicles are travelling at normal speeds.</p> <p>The plots look like random noise.</p> <p>EDIT:</p> <p>At the moment I am looking at two methods:</p> <ol> <li>Use the interquartile range to discard outliers</li> <li>Use a Kalman filter.</li> </ol> <p>I think the filter is the wrong way to go as I don't have a model for the journey time other than from moment to moment I don't expect it to change much.</p>
49,251
[ 0.02526669017970562, -0.004606521222740412, 0.014782872051000595, -0.003846482839435339, 0.04973795637488365, -0.015151876956224442, -0.026194119825959206, 0.00046592747094109654, 0.015693675726652145, -0.002000275067985058, 0.04200006276369095, 0.05528003349900246, 0.06809373199939728, 0.001061757793650031, 0.002533064689487219, -0.017394019290804863, 0.012732827104628086, -0.018287645652890205, -0.01116768829524517, -0.08375094085931778, -0.014700605534017086, 0.015838759019970894, 0.06935200840234756, -0.020457418635487556, -0.06158642843365669, 0.032551005482673645, 0.011963669210672379, 0.0030067393090575933, 0.0021849675104022026, 0.04666220024228096, -0.0601220577955246, -0.027757935225963593, -0.010439001955091953, 0.041274309158325195, 0.04907622188329697, 0.017720935866236687, -0.028311582282185555, -0.04131661728024483, -0.003038136288523674, 0.0023437116760760546, -0.049021992832422256, 0.022782085463404655, 0.00949199590831995, 0.06528855115175247, 0.01959679089486599, 0.04006115347146988, 0.016716239973902702, -0.016497528180480003, 0.03770451247692108, -0.04888354614377022, 0.10225436091423035, -0.01079292967915535, 0.03631750866770744, 0.013438989408314228, 0.0015429570339620113, -0.014336280524730682, 0.047991301864385605, 0.06866186857223511, -0.013628865592181683, -0.025440940633416176, -0.013714389875531197, -0.006812518462538719, -0.004781866446137428, 0.0019829892553389072, -0.015071083791553974, -0.009129284881055355, -0.02446538582444191, -0.03228523209691048, 0.028605103492736816, 0.011489108204841614, -0.02645370550453663, -0.00991128571331501, 0.041291072964668274, -0.01711399294435978, 0.023041578009724617, -0.03126441314816475, -0.002203649375587702, 0.007831222377717495, 0.07133979350328445, 0.004932810552418232, -0.008480055257678032, -0.002415178343653679, -0.007961945608258247, 0.03227945789694786, 0.006792354863137007, -0.03234909102320671, 0.05983436480164528, -0.027029074728488922, -0.014123870059847832, 0.03575480356812477, -0.03442579507827759, 0.04066367819905281, 0.060185614973306656, 0.039697110652923584, -0.0013356024865061045, 0.028736626729369164, -0.012811829335987568, 0.01721780374646187, -0.014563747681677341, -0.008023668080568314, -0.0019883562345057726, -0.04074801877140999, 0.015011577866971493, 0.054993268102407455, -0.01762441359460354, 0.007073441985994577, -0.01543691661208868, -0.022466294467449188, -0.02228589728474617, 0.018039582297205925, -0.02853844128549099, -0.004490269348025322, 0.019654948264360428, 0.023179788142442703, 0.01710166037082672, -0.019081443548202515, -0.010502712801098824, -0.024584170430898666, 0.008927133865654469, 0.0569380447268486, 0.02802289091050625, -0.025449279695749283, -0.01527316216379404, -0.023122016340494156, -0.06094405800104141, 0.0027516018599271774, 0.03089321218430996, 0.01740485243499279, -0.01574588380753994, 0.045060377568006516, 0.00444716215133667, -0.03694158419966698, 0.03747409209609032, -0.007971149869263172, 0.05002207309007645, -0.003472017589956522, -0.09466710686683655, -0.06517257541418076, 0.04607221484184265, 0.000979475094936788, 0.038224782794713974, -0.06159016862511635, -0.013324428349733353, 0.03151906281709671, 0.042616937309503555, 0.03842002525925636, 0.011620205827057362, 0.035718243569135666, 0.011454774998128414, -0.0163537859916687, -0.037778954952955246, -0.02034263126552105, -0.02781461738049984, -0.004937447141855955, -0.017328117042779922, -0.07880515605211258, 0.03398244082927704, 0.016523191705346107, -0.01080377958714962, -0.006283982191234827, 0.024242360144853592, 0.005549132823944092, -0.026657231152057648, 0.007282838225364685, 0.028764981776475906, -0.010565279051661491, 0.08446616679430008, 0.041961051523685455, 0.02795741707086563, -0.0051620034500956535, 0.026500551030039787, -0.0010863050119951367, 0.012310976162552834, 0.009895184077322483, 0.055319786071777344, 0.00024358487280551344, -0.015462800860404968, 0.016501031816005707, 0.002381261670961976, 0.011146281845867634, -0.01600775122642517, -0.06282010674476624, -0.033298805356025696, 0.001775873824954033, 0.02162105403840542, 0.03457679599523544, -0.03677378222346306, 0.00820380263030529, 0.05183751881122589, -0.04431634023785591, 0.005304963327944279, -0.022293146699666977, -0.0025193861220031977, 0.015898726880550385, 0.0029963140841573477, 0.01965874247252941, -0.0042985049076378345, 0.013264749199151993, -0.02409205585718155, -0.027809811756014824, -0.011248874478042126, -0.013249168172478676, 0.037594787776470184, -0.053445376455783844, -0.023600434884428978, 0.049154531210660934, 0.03635606914758682, 0.006748839281499386, 0.05053618177771568, -0.01032894104719162, 0.0052913180552423, -0.013764595612883568, -0.024951249361038208, 0.01708342507481575, -0.008436845615506172, -0.021301448345184326, 0.010258626192808151, 0.04169168695807457, 0.0020795881282538176, 0.005164586938917637, -0.0392187274992466, 0.0737689882516861, 0.08042938262224197, -0.019166694954037666, 0.012385375797748566, 0.02866535820066929, 0.00785086303949356, 0.036255139857530594, -0.011021895334124565, -0.06137097626924515, -0.05478368699550629, -0.024086054414510727, 0.004662551451474428, 0.002741282107308507, -0.031521275639534, 0.03263959661126137, 0.05429847911000252, 0.009668629616498947, 0.029049711301922798, -0.0015690317377448082, -0.01053461991250515, -0.008232804015278816, 0.05134439840912819, 0.03218046575784683, -0.010376431979238987, -0.03820934146642685, 0.008659816347062588, -0.02612132951617241, 0.049779947847127914, -0.04109681397676468, -0.004720073193311691, -0.011025049723684788, 0.007539537735283375, 0.014592830091714859, -0.016377592459321022, -0.009852664545178413, 0.0203560683876276, 0.02057064138352871, 0.007240633014589548, 0.05107424408197403, -0.011971011757850647, 0.010351639240980148, 0.03267114982008934, -0.03346480429172516, 0.016247497871518135, 0.030892785638570786, -0.033162921667099, 0.004124249331653118, 0.01887107454240322, -0.013879324309527874, 0.037526246160268784, -0.03967701643705368, -0.035493601113557816, -0.0023573243524879217, 0.023407962173223495, 0.051049962639808655, 0.006594239268451929, -0.010310919024050236, -0.016485881060361862, -0.00038342332118190825, -0.02291916497051716, 0.003213532269001007, 0.02037222869694233, 0.0396493636071682, -0.026604460552334785, 0.010172504931688309, -0.01735103875398636, -0.02425708808004856, 0.040278058499097824, -0.004019998945295811, 0.02783196046948433, 0.005142823792994022, -0.004078684840351343, -0.06479859352111816, -0.019002245739102364, -0.05933602154254913, 0.003700567875057459, -0.012778590433299541, -0.023830097168684006, 0.043225448578596115, 0.005270091351121664, -0.03358164057135582, 0.02170007862150669, -0.04659425467252731, 0.01428160909563303, -0.02446918562054634, 0.002425489481538534, 0.005804867949336767, -0.012789743952453136, 0.01702066697180271, 0.036826398223638535, -0.024238718673586845, -0.0007876698509790003, -0.08984363079071045, -0.06394951790571213, 0.03753669559955597, 0.005126060917973518, 0.0531008280813694, 0.023605940863490105, -0.0066678449511528015, 0.06483267992734909, 0.041726790368556976, 0.001041838200762868, -0.01336914673447609, -0.029116084799170494, -0.0016429172828793526, -0.02808043360710144, 0.011152723804116249, 0.019459960982203484, -0.046431638300418854, 0.013719223439693451, -0.019787920638918877, 0.03178738057613373, 0.035364869982004166, 0.01141538005322218, -0.02677362784743309, 0.02779797837138176, -0.017178745940327644, 0.005301173310726881, 0.045412130653858185, 0.0806259885430336, -0.038869231939315796, -0.02013561688363552, 0.0013526328839361668, 0.012020202353596687, 0.0050351545214653015, -0.06502135843038559, 0.007903659716248512, -0.012292254716157913, 0.004467001184821129, -0.04271634295582771, 0.005344541743397713, 0.007750166114419699, -0.015178634785115719, -0.03857022896409035, 0.035599976778030396, 0.05072130635380745, 0.010930451564490795, -0.001055440166965127, 0.05438010022044182, 0.03905121982097626, 0.021257324144244194, -0.007715086918324232, -0.025299498811364174, -0.009490706026554108, -0.013737539760768414, -0.02938871644437313, -0.01797030307352543, 0.041691508144140244, 0.012977859936654568, -0.02154751680791378, -0.008662271313369274, -0.027211319655179977, -0.014371817000210285, -0.08731529116630554, -0.02295837737619877, 0.009955679066479206, 0.06416147202253342, 0.04506607726216316, -0.01832820661365986, 0.013762851245701313, -0.012089955620467663, -0.02956024929881096, -0.008867035619914532, -0.06517466902732849, 0.032107558101415634, 0.009401158429682255, -0.02965649962425232, -0.009027612395584583, -0.0384816937148571, -0.00519173126667738, -0.04027978330850601, 0.027493499219417572, -0.007119579240679741, 0.038643114268779755, -0.04837753623723984, -0.03751635178923607, -0.0015190079575404525, -0.005073040723800659, -0.029063787311315536, -0.008177777752280235, 0.02608552761375904, -0.05022917687892914, 0.04738285019993782, 0.03191331401467323, -0.015700243413448334, -0.06133497506380081, -0.012899385765194893, -0.0012237392365932465, 0.018481161445379257, 0.027432497590780258, 0.011115968227386475, 0.0008133284864015877, -0.06244712695479393, 0.033826861530542374, -0.014308185316622257, 0.0686877965927124, 0.00451677618548274, -0.0060208141803741455, 0.00046782352728769183, -0.014520068652927876, -0.03746110945940018, 0.04608656093478203, 0.038713935762643814, -0.025064842775464058, -0.02205250971019268, 0.017336755990982056, 0.01138627715408802, -0.04452349245548248, -0.0067008910700678825, 0.03585515171289444, 0.010971710085868835, 0.010876452550292015, -0.003442666959017515, -0.05520588532090187, 0.03398049250245094, -0.00618324289098382, 0.04360170289874077, 0.01615898683667183, 0.017982231453061104, 0.004793440457433462, 0.01862180233001709, 0.0024256687611341476, -0.01834532432258129, 0.0038411845453083515, 0.030139390379190445, 0.048909131437540054, -0.0028195581398904324, -0.007418668828904629, 0.03802378848195076, 0.002514876425266266, 0.03692625090479851, 0.06687019765377045, 0.009308593347668648, -0.14068512618541718, 0.00020112437778152525, 0.04752922058105469, 0.05758821219205856, -0.0032689115032553673, -0.030944861471652985, -0.05434811860322952, -0.026790598407387733, 0.03273871913552284, -0.02876562811434269, 0.028980078175663948, -0.0031213872134685516, -0.017695359885692596, 0.0041320184245705605, -0.045320913195610046, -0.04007759317755699, 0.021016063168644905, -0.009849369525909424, -0.0007575927884317935, -0.007572193164378405, -0.027377985417842865, -0.026250207796692848, 0.012503930367529392, 0.041659869253635406, 0.06315287202596664, 0.016061875969171524, 0.0011208290234208107, 0.017428016290068626, 0.0222709272056818, -0.04064107686281204, -0.041697584092617035, 0.01595320925116539, 0.011286725290119648, 0.0167471244931221, 0.05690871551632881, 0.002016429789364338, -0.011813852936029434, 0.0062802014872431755, -0.008827759884297848, 0.019430037587881088, -0.01381965633481741, -0.041184697300195694, 0.03616766259074211, 0.02896493300795555, 0.0005677599110640585, 0.01934131607413292, 0.05320921167731285, 0.015440772287547588, 0.004530078265815973, -0.0033716540783643723, 0.027898583561182022, 0.0018975911661982536, -0.0326797217130661, -0.007160242181271315, -0.026001162827014923, -0.05011941120028496, 0.002507368102669716, 0.02392757497727871, 0.03786784037947655, -0.017834970727562904, -0.033466532826423645, -0.009120514616370201, 0.05188107490539551, 0.011655551381409168, 0.029213299974799156, -0.03506799414753914, 0.03373858705163002, 0.009699343703687191, -0.009426114149391651, 0.0034659705124795437, -0.008421579375863075, 0.009067068807780743, 0.010001422837376595, -0.01074809581041336, -0.00160452991258353, -0.07459858804941177, 0.011262149550020695, 0.008968165144324303, 0.006795520428568125, 0.05203629285097122, -0.022952675819396973, 0.025033013895154, 0.015657717362046242, -0.004785111173987389, 0.010033894330263138, 0.05178312957286835, -0.0272622462362051, 0.03949714079499245, -0.013343559578061104, 0.029293591156601906, -0.018148472532629967, -0.009317549876868725, -0.10207430273294449, -0.04167637974023819, 0.023689379915595055, 0.010925233364105225, -0.015892667695879936, -0.048341866582632065, -0.0057412427850067616, -0.033788058906793594, -0.031166257336735725, -0.024225670844316483, 0.0477847158908844, -0.011428775265812874, -0.019521409645676613, -0.03419455885887146, 0.00847947783768177, 0.06412528455257416, 0.012046730145812035, 0.02666090428829193, 0.05746522545814514, 0.005883632693439722, -0.04493136331439018, 0.00557667063549161, 0.02287883497774601, -0.025075232610106468, -0.00912343617528677, -0.043341051787137985, 0.01150602474808693, 0.05097617581486702, -0.021996965631842613, 0.0009596015443094075, 0.02269905060529709, -0.008108604699373245, -0.018018975853919983, -0.007943179458379745, -0.025428593158721924, -0.028643175959587097, -0.015899447724223137, -0.03184138610959053, 0.029082126915454865, -0.012159396894276142, -0.021032484248280525, 0.003805037820711732, -0.004166835453361273, -0.04855899512767792, -0.051193345338106155, 0.024839377030730247, 0.017841322347521782, 0.01490869466215372, 0.023819876834750175, -0.00961268413811922, 0.01080473605543375, -0.036440156400203705, -0.022172540426254272, 0.017902115359902382, -0.0005374597385525703, -0.050994500517845154, 0.0035456866025924683, -0.04453638568520546, -0.03737824037671089, 0.02242116630077362, -0.018406705930829048, 0.03981493413448334, 0.04784554988145828, 0.020718960091471672, 0.005809580907225609, -0.04627519100904465, -0.05258144438266754, 0.010353521443903446, 0.005886012688279152, 0.03681578114628792, 0.014577065594494343, -0.0031636329367756844, 0.00038508762372657657, 0.018197517842054367, 0.019327936694025993, -0.01996401883661747, 0.005542703438550234, 0.04858924075961113, 0.017606671899557114, -0.002326988149434328, -0.03052784875035286, -0.014880161732435226, -0.028805140405893326, 0.03129495680332184, -0.015186133794486523, -0.016922656446695328, 0.025957372039556503, 0.03241753578186035, -0.005245570093393326, -0.00675622746348381, -0.004903928376734257, -0.07969538867473602, 0.035740263760089874, 0.03954058885574341, -0.04190931096673012, -0.006761218421161175, 0.029968420043587685, 0.04595058783888817, -0.009394574910402298, 0.006492310669273138, -0.04853169620037079, -0.05346662551164627, -0.0313870869576931, -0.03319745883345604, -0.062098681926727295, 0.024226056411862373, -0.03265954181551933, -0.04512113332748413, 0.03895653039216995, -0.013560589402914047, 0.01797524467110634, 0.014351926743984222, 0.045214347541332245, -0.008497567847371101, 0.05958382785320282, 0.0006849190685898066, -0.004021065309643745, -0.02155229263007641, 0.004746089223772287, 0.12551677227020264, 0.034260343760252, 0.03945985436439514, -0.04965449497103691, 0.007503522094339132, 0.009361104108393192, 0.01305718719959259, -0.043221112340688705, 0.033163320273160934, 0.02713399939239025, -0.009311556816101074, 0.026442917063832283, -0.022457286715507507, 0.004651477560400963, -0.00761615764349699, 0.057539232075214386, -0.0034114383161067963, -0.004502581898123026, -0.005189551040530205, 0.04035336524248123, 0.015831144526600838, -0.0001256094838026911, -0.07595579326152802, 0.05849093198776245, -0.04473407566547394, -0.042984798550605774, -0.029568782076239586, -0.04172274097800255, -0.00533421291038394, -0.00600896030664444, -0.03413783386349678, 0.03904983773827553, 0.030542684718966484, -0.031981661915779114, 0.01787981204688549, 0.02264774963259697, 0.001945691299624741, -0.019385766237974167, 0.008327660150825977, 0.036086346954107285, 0.02668706700205803, -0.02646517939865589, 0.01213870756328106, 0.006166911218315363, -0.06162111833691597, -0.021340643987059593, -0.039325132966041565, 0.056415408849716187, -0.015716111287474632, 0.00615078816190362, -0.010411541908979416, 0.020681291818618774, 0.002459540031850338, -0.07771515101194382, -0.007795596960932016, -0.0007251299102790654, 0.014185016974806786, 0.016737455502152443, -0.006762191653251648, -0.028082571923732758, 0.013095755130052567, 0.024605795741081238, -0.005669722333550453, 0.07126176357269287, -0.0011456204811111093, -0.014809533953666687, -0.0204877108335495, 0.030196288600564003, 0.011772217229008675, 0.006473778281360865, 0.02466409094631672, -0.021075354889035225, -0.03076898120343685, 0.023633087053894997, 0.018354292958974838, -0.020017720758914948, 0.008103352971374989, -0.0006898067076690495, -0.025965958833694458, -0.01450636051595211, -0.07019302994012833, -0.003324068384245038, -0.031762734055519104, -0.021556392312049866, -0.013376067392528057, -0.004568534437566996, 0.029688982293009758, 0.02276265062391758, 0.014226222410798073, 0.021370459347963333, -0.024852171540260315, 0.04580490663647652, -0.007163403555750847, -0.03388861194252968, 0.00892625655978918, 0.001773559837602079, -0.019652141258120537, 0.009254420176148415, 0.006486731115728617, 0.07104773074388504, 0.009186578914523125, -0.020472893491387367, -0.004687180742621422, 0.03955569863319397, -0.024014407768845558, 0.012659657746553421, -0.0001469465933041647, -0.06716115027666092, -0.0008950350456871092, -0.002058641752228141, 0.01569540984928608, -0.020896052941679955, -0.017290223389863968, -0.0008846347918733954, 0.0016870936378836632, -0.02246399223804474, -0.03213060274720192, 0.0016230294713750482, 0.003980378154665232, -0.02775467373430729, 0.019875315949320793, -0.016798289492726326, 0.040901027619838715, 0.0017145753372460604, -0.023225754499435425, -0.057785388082265854, 0.011285300366580486, 0.0011201335582882166, 0.02465333603322506, 0.022893734276294708, 0.00742364814504981, 0.02352130226790905, 0.016516536474227905, 0.013115944340825081, 0.009182710200548172, 0.0037513303104788065, -0.007006408646702766, 0.037947338074445724, -0.03516584634780884, 0.004353691823780537, 0.029016241431236267, 0.0041222646832466125, -0.040317438542842865, 0.03244640305638313, 0.026527920737862587, -0.018506929278373718, 0.020517682656645775, 0.009909382089972496, 0.01440831646323204, 0.03989403694868088, -0.010874445550143719, -0.034195635467767715, -0.0039342171512544155, 0.017596013844013214, 0.004625164438039064, -0.03084687516093254, 0.026445994153618813, -0.009042817167937756, -0.025376249104738235, 0.028865240514278412, 0.03184710070490837, -0.02134476974606514, 0.02804848551750183, -0.036535464227199554, 0.011197684332728386, -0.009412059560418129, -0.007369337137788534, -0.004187408369034529, 0.05722567439079285, 0.0329587459564209, -0.030601950362324715, -0.03473539277911186, -0.02235320396721363, 0.013795152306556702, -0.0714767575263977, -0.022424276918172836, 0.019763439893722534, 0.015583891421556473, 0.05987335368990898, -0.083388552069664, 0.00392652302980423, 0.06594338268041611, -0.041732460260391235, 0.016545336693525314, 0.004473384004086256, -0.007759480737149715, -0.04542350023984909, 0.011547635309398174, -0.03620977699756622, 0.030902136117219925, 0.034438490867614746, 0.02909264713525772, 0.0352579765021801, 0.03847449645400047, 0.01794198714196682, -0.04532930627465248, 0.03815874829888344, 0.020632170140743256, 0.03750663995742798, -0.03433169424533844, 0.007515044882893562, -0.050107695162296295, 0.05155379697680473, 0.06553684920072556, -0.04989399388432503, 0.03330565616488457, -0.020536577329039574, 0.03883342072367668, 0.014395901001989841, 0.05404634401202202, 0.046496279537677765, 0.015531925484538078, 0.002973120426759124, -0.010652429424226284, -0.02762756496667862, 0.012480738572776318, -0.03258168324828148, 0.02489055134356022, -0.013506215997040272, -0.023468807339668274, -0.03458792343735695, 0.014463432133197784, 0.02418292686343193, 0.019566629081964493, 0.02919338084757328, -0.001696792314760387, -0.0036142654716968536, -0.05942918732762337, -0.014961100183427334, -0.018464241176843643, 0.017241422086954117, 0.003480748739093542, -0.007468042429536581, -0.035039979964494705, -0.024849558249115944, -0.05673786997795105, -0.026112429797649384, -0.007724474184215069, -0.0024349926970899105, -0.02511012740433216, -0.0841645747423172, -0.01264671515673399, -0.027396971359848976, -0.007965898141264915, -0.0374310277402401, 0.027064550668001175, -0.02628035470843315, 0.03400852903723717, 0.013772540725767612, 0.006206877995282412, 0.03666340559720993, 0.041311461478471756, -0.046668052673339844, -0.06879473477602005, 0.06464997678995132, 0.015259230509400368, -0.007826737128198147, -0.03087921440601349, -0.02994764968752861, -0.012455201707780361, 0.0008544069714844227, 0.04435094818472862, 0.015284903347492218, 0.018257606774568558, 0.005007623694837093, 0.00037567754043266177, 0.007719052955508232, -0.022440152242779732, 0.04000922292470932, -0.053928449749946594, -0.03146941959857941, -0.006262312177568674, -0.01188809983432293, -0.04084039852023125, 0.0027346990536898375, 0.026924114674329758, -0.009486470371484756, 0.020148200914263725, 0.010223748162388802, -0.006634856108576059, 0.026780685409903526, 0.020800620317459106, -0.0023535664658993483, 0.023031290620565414, 0.0018290957668796182, 0.023282237350940704, 0.03711319714784622, -0.022647317498922348, -0.05649183318018913, 0.03213094547390938, -0.019264141097664833, -0.023402655497193336, -0.031883154064416885, -0.017411764711141586, 0.015622271224856377, -0.05231538787484169, -0.01003507524728775, -0.011579872108995914, -0.011546551249921322, 0.016026640310883522, 0.022835910320281982, -0.010656123049557209, 0.07809993624687195, -0.015115700662136078, 0.01989736780524254, 0.01888500712811947, -0.004200588446110487, 0.016477372497320175, 0.010606586001813412, 0.011570295318961143, -0.022197967395186424, -0.001396133447997272, 0.030581219121813774, -0.0005862432299181819, 0.03847936913371086, -0.033557966351509094, 0.0359005406498909, -0.0010850861435756087, -0.0017469763988628983, 0.010930679738521576, 0.00824409443885088, 0.03538970649242401, 0.011772354133427143, -0.011109213344752789, 0.049283210188150406, -0.044371411204338074, -0.008302712813019753, -0.04499531537294388, -0.034322913736104965, -0.013281772844493389, 0.05714135617017746, 0.035841986536979675, 0.02815103717148304, -0.0037768997717648745, 0.01626955345273018, 0.020785147324204445, 0.014918362721800804, 0.007763467263430357, -0.04017026349902153, 0.05451785773038864, -0.026874812319874763, -0.010947735980153084, -0.03382449969649315, -0.0025826513301581144, -0.002295303624123335, -0.005355899687856436, -0.03447800502181053, 0.07894985377788544, 0.0019438033923506737, -0.019650716334581375, -0.01710817776620388, -0.00121587875764817, 0.042291246354579926, -0.05413637310266495, -0.01376673486083746, -0.07799969613552094, -0.006429338362067938, -0.014238051138818264, -0.007337720599025488 ]
<p>I injected three different cRNAs constructs (construct A,B and C) into oocytes and the oocytes expressed the respective cRNAs as respective ion channels (ion channel A,B and C). My aim was to test whether these ion channels function similarly or not. Then, I measured the concentration-response relationships to determine EC50 for each ion channel (x-axis is cAMP concentration (µM) , y-axis is I/Imax; I is the the actual current amplitude Imax is the maximum current amplitude at saturating cAMP</p> <p>I got the results EC50 for ion channel A = 59.01 ion channel B = 56.17 ion channel C = 61.24 which test should I use to find out whether they are statistically different ? In theory, they should not be different. Can I use one way ANOVA.</p> <p>Thanks in advance,</p>
74,400
[ -0.03681524842977524, 0.009802352637052536, -0.0422913059592247, 0.0017245322233065963, 0.03083031065762043, 0.02503141202032566, 0.0011660625459626317, -0.020116861909627914, 0.03391363099217415, -0.004152257926762104, 0.10867879539728165, 0.044453173875808716, 0.03917323052883148, 0.006503474898636341, 0.02070494368672371, -0.018355337902903557, -0.005045290570706129, -0.02521084062755108, -0.0002891414915211499, -0.019624605774879456, -0.027867963537573814, 0.03234579786658287, -0.010310548357665539, -0.00393516244366765, -0.019940748810768127, 0.025136297568678856, 0.04231288656592369, -0.049189720302820206, -0.014288709498941898, 0.04714880511164665, -0.02506163902580738, -0.03390613943338394, 0.011215459555387497, 0.03800881654024124, 0.015849320217967033, 0.01120764296501875, -0.02195221558213234, -0.012923031114041805, -0.024440882727503777, 0.04262515529990196, -0.0009802973363548517, 0.007205024361610413, 0.004399953410029411, 0.03931405022740364, 0.001891974825412035, 0.0020905458368360996, 0.03260750696063042, -0.003861993784084916, 0.004338086117058992, -0.05900640785694122, 0.07069092243909836, 0.011970555409789085, -0.018449192866683006, 0.05471013858914375, -0.01946379244327545, -0.01154438965022564, 0.016057798638939857, 0.027340218424797058, -0.011580923572182655, -0.08164528757333755, -0.005140465218573809, -0.014929135330021381, 0.008360096253454685, -0.036579012870788574, -0.0408158078789711, 0.03390447795391083, 0.025596901774406433, -0.05283127352595329, 0.0615570992231369, -0.024046946316957474, 0.03594940900802612, 0.010817984119057655, 0.01203870214521885, -0.01781727373600006, -0.033573001623153687, -0.025383595377206802, -0.01957360841333866, 0.054221898317337036, 0.033900175243616104, 0.04706799238920212, -0.06732591986656189, 0.03006688877940178, 0.0012690911535173655, 0.034304868429899216, 0.016921725124120712, -0.039065636694431305, 0.049000274389982224, -0.0466957725584507, -0.024295171722769737, 0.005155267659574747, -0.03502583131194115, 0.002947077853605151, 0.06596703082323074, 0.030120152980089188, -0.027793269604444504, -0.002568915020674467, 0.010524860583245754, 0.06432443857192993, -0.03266015276312828, -0.018190564587712288, -0.013102047145366669, -0.020421532914042473, 0.01567961648106575, 0.037195444107055664, -0.021831566467881203, 0.015198486857116222, -0.014872398227453232, 0.00726621737703681, -0.006692806724458933, 0.039270058274269104, -0.05601007491350174, 0.027414588257670403, 0.01357800979167223, 0.0583483912050724, 0.055872999131679535, 0.020185470581054688, -0.04517426714301109, 0.005557064898312092, 0.05987650156021118, 0.037753816694021225, 0.037166185677051544, -0.029099714010953903, 0.027453400194644928, -0.012015516869723797, -0.00791794341057539, -0.004671553615480661, -0.01474618911743164, 0.026485178619623184, 0.0014806532999500632, 0.06937821209430695, -0.02788250520825386, -0.006847759708762169, -0.03858734667301178, -0.029223360121250153, 0.004894542042165995, -0.019775046035647392, -0.09472716599702835, -0.06312445551156998, 0.062789186835289, -0.04572327435016632, -0.026961684226989746, -0.07076629996299744, -0.002400544937700033, 0.0256524495780468, 0.05534115433692932, 0.021159378811717033, 0.030073383823037148, -0.019252123311161995, 0.018703460693359375, 0.03444838523864746, 0.005136892665177584, 0.007835425436496735, -0.037582024931907654, -0.011851717717945576, -0.02045269124209881, -0.055600475519895554, -0.01296277716755867, -0.00201973132789135, 0.01494369562715292, 0.00530209019780159, -0.01013349648565054, -0.022545799612998962, -0.0014231917448341846, -0.00954053271561861, 0.03094133548438549, -0.022312726825475693, 0.07472994178533554, -0.040982164442539215, 0.008684491738677025, 0.030702875927090645, -0.052936065942049026, 0.037125926464796066, -0.011621556244790554, -0.004071411676704884, 0.07495462894439697, -0.0033709576819092035, -0.0016124957473948598, -0.024528853595256805, 0.01671188324689865, 0.038824789226055145, -0.018735790625214577, -0.02154460735619068, -0.02345326915383339, -0.01870407909154892, 0.012408903799951077, 0.026990685611963272, -0.013179254718124866, -0.03299976512789726, 0.03467138856649399, -0.020241254940629005, 0.015128676779568195, -0.06359061598777771, 0.02430904656648636, 0.006150728091597557, -0.043128106743097305, 0.019992249086499214, 0.012365413829684258, 0.02160011976957321, -0.025632161647081375, -0.028155729174613953, -0.07761021703481674, -0.0326155424118042, 0.010286698117852211, 0.012128552421927452, 0.03280457481741905, 0.028937427327036858, 0.004290150478482246, -0.06280733644962311, 0.03952035680413246, -0.00409522233530879, -0.00018062877643387765, -0.008608438074588776, -0.0021404295694082975, 0.03268011286854744, 0.03190980106592178, -0.022120213136076927, 0.008045201189815998, 0.06346316635608673, -0.01903911679983139, 0.04534154012799263, -0.07817667722702026, 0.09642672538757324, 0.05074828118085861, 0.009106729179620743, 0.07312940061092377, 0.01147734746336937, 0.03752416744828224, 0.0029754103161394596, 0.011276667937636375, -0.011846087872982025, -0.03861727565526962, -0.013782260939478874, 0.024805542081594467, -0.014426324516534805, -0.03840995579957962, -0.010006525553762913, 0.06437386572360992, -0.014815552160143852, 0.011146585457026958, 0.03935357555747032, 0.010846488177776337, -0.05432872846722603, 0.0330316424369812, 0.03235264867544174, -0.0014545948943123221, -0.0057992227375507355, 0.026716770604252815, -0.01836584322154522, 0.035349342972040176, -0.018464308232069016, 0.012130670249462128, 0.015320641919970512, -0.022840315476059914, -0.008417640812695026, -0.04751540720462799, 0.01710665412247181, 0.047583553940057755, -0.018848134204745293, -0.009936788119375706, 0.03188484534621239, 0.011342528276145458, 0.014428160153329372, -0.0019909022375941277, -0.027780544012784958, 0.00844704732298851, 0.026424553245306015, -0.010638647712767124, -0.009885460138320923, 0.02637757733464241, -0.007268592249602079, -0.01614086702466011, -0.0373881459236145, -0.002492189174517989, -0.04416375979781151, 0.0025621862150728703, 0.03530888259410858, 0.006803262047469616, 0.022664962336421013, -0.01201498880982399, 0.017602641135454178, -0.005713231861591339, -0.008212333545088768, 0.03795338794589043, 0.014690197072923183, -0.03694598004221916, 0.016704702749848366, -0.0012457132106646895, -0.042417384684085846, -0.009052933193743229, -0.03574291989207268, -0.028378769755363464, 0.04252107813954353, -0.017045114189386368, -0.032412465661764145, -0.0010076911421492696, 0.010549645870923996, 0.037974536418914795, -0.007375163957476616, -0.02169944904744625, 0.05125631019473076, 0.008167476393282413, -0.0034112189896404743, 0.034087419509887695, -0.0067522162571549416, 0.002905795117840171, 0.07949084043502808, -0.00014388200361281633, 0.002608561422675848, -0.016525711864233017, 0.01269804872572422, 0.0391208752989769, -0.02983318828046322, -0.02537539042532444, -0.04186916723847389, -0.06012331321835518, 0.021306827664375305, -0.03463471680879593, 0.013564524240791798, 0.010060012340545654, -0.01324774045497179, 0.049527447670698166, 0.0244720708578825, -0.044416990131139755, -0.004096060525625944, -0.0021015452221035957, -0.042288873344659805, -0.02300320938229561, 0.02813151478767395, -0.00032512363395653665, -0.0077207437716424465, 0.026001781225204468, 0.017828401178121567, 0.030399492010474205, 0.0244595929980278, -0.003293848829343915, 0.018742011860013008, 0.03766394406557083, 0.018638430163264275, -0.046747587621212006, 0.04973767325282097, 0.04818231984972954, 0.015499324537813663, 0.003281357930973172, 0.009992648847401142, 0.015176638960838318, 0.03459663316607475, -0.03716170787811279, 0.01193441916257143, -0.022975042462348938, -0.00801866501569748, 0.0013558762148022652, -0.026071913540363312, -0.011494133621454239, 0.037739645689725876, -0.0024961938615888357, 0.0458981916308403, 0.038388609886169434, -0.03543825447559357, -0.032076943665742874, 0.04940897226333618, 0.05390635132789612, -0.0013209461467340589, -0.012200976721942425, -0.009249099530279636, 0.009821790270507336, 0.05936594679951668, -0.015504734590649605, -0.028506454080343246, 0.035621367394924164, 0.0035941372625529766, 0.015529864467680454, -0.004609252326190472, -0.05239681154489517, 0.000290227762889117, -0.08391503244638443, -0.013513238169252872, -0.07916876673698425, 0.0441959947347641, -0.003990225028246641, 0.03035775013267994, -0.0032550652977079153, 0.00014601118164137006, -0.020857064053416252, -0.02492326870560646, -0.10387793183326721, 0.01838148757815361, 0.0055279191583395, -0.05698378011584282, 0.01153682079166174, -0.03829704597592354, 0.04568145051598549, -0.022674646228551865, 0.014386110007762909, 0.005407211370766163, -0.0032702006865292788, -0.017344392836093903, 0.019382359459996223, -0.0039045512676239014, -0.021375320851802826, -0.029094237834215164, 0.040996797382831573, -0.030374247580766678, -0.010618962347507477, 0.0177127905189991, 0.026391983032226562, -0.013910148292779922, -0.01374341081827879, 0.014547298662364483, 0.034469980746507645, 0.010504210367798805, 0.03231898695230484, 0.05330021679401398, 0.02150440216064453, -0.03640736639499664, 0.002078584162518382, -0.00043074475252069533, 0.023726321756839752, 0.027031565085053444, 0.005401355680078268, -0.03705008327960968, -0.07523951679468155, -0.007983402349054813, -0.019957033917307854, 0.04310557246208191, 0.05442197248339653, -0.03418496623635292, 0.015461084432899952, 0.02996154874563217, 0.009835263714194298, 0.021679112687706947, 0.049683861434459686, 0.01105623971670866, -0.013845706358551979, -0.022253388538956642, -0.01670086197555065, -0.03451155126094818, 0.0012228218838572502, 0.06438387930393219, 0.016092728823423386, 0.022757727652788162, -0.008430416695773602, 0.05887215584516525, 0.03604031354188919, -0.06097426265478134, 0.017214106395840645, -0.023707188665866852, 0.01620866358280182, -0.022625749930739403, -0.02497042715549469, -0.0004297035629861057, 0.0005243121413514018, 0.031226858496665955, 0.0030698853079229593, -0.012651671655476093, -0.0858614519238472, -0.021587545052170753, 0.04926532134413719, 0.03355330973863602, -0.0472109317779541, -0.02862512692809105, -0.014464548788964748, 0.0024396537337452173, 0.022361084818840027, -0.023214124143123627, 0.02802913822233677, 0.023317066952586174, 0.01987369917333126, -0.047213114798069, -0.004127583000808954, -0.017519738525152206, 0.008492627181112766, 0.00557280145585537, 0.004061222542077303, -0.04623902216553688, -0.01366632990539074, -0.027002790942788124, -0.021220136433839798, 0.01535328570753336, 0.057510241866111755, -0.04911106452345848, -0.02729281596839428, 0.04052993655204773, -0.000843212241306901, -0.004974754527211189, -0.05656756833195686, 0.07406715303659439, 0.0020047491416335106, -0.022610893473029137, 0.06791810691356659, -0.020759182050824165, -0.010305453091859818, 0.04432244598865509, -0.0037477773148566484, -0.011069606989622116, -0.013422846794128418, -0.027101604267954826, 0.028620798140764236, 0.011765076778829098, -0.0016297181136906147, 0.04617142677307129, 0.011197407729923725, -0.025254791602492332, -0.017958493903279305, -0.010469239205121994, 0.030816689133644104, -0.06988033652305603, -0.019148968160152435, 0.0005101385759189725, 0.02361711859703064, 0.013173411600291729, 0.015965821221470833, 0.028502393513917923, 0.048110511153936386, -0.026013273745775223, -0.02349977381527424, 0.05022795870900154, 0.02973572164773941, -0.017063036561012268, -0.006353698205202818, 0.022485630586743355, 0.018175575882196426, -0.019518816843628883, -0.005660093855112791, -0.0008969074697233737, -0.04539567977190018, -0.0035977670922875404, 0.018959973007440567, -0.03283219039440155, 0.015817590057849884, -0.042921632528305054, -0.013275726698338985, 0.03475895896553993, -0.058203112334012985, 0.05414241924881935, -0.027107594534754753, 0.01943231001496315, 0.011396463960409164, -0.04399673640727997, -0.02311386726796627, 0.04177584499120712, -0.013179226778447628, 0.0507710799574852, -0.054508138447999954, 0.040733467787504196, -0.002304760506376624, -0.016835711896419525, -0.07447371631860733, -0.02990560792386532, 0.015743836760520935, 0.01183654647320509, 0.017456501722335815, -0.005319052841514349, 0.00281066307798028, 0.008934897370636463, 0.00735001266002655, -0.019669272005558014, 0.05541754886507988, -0.009181920439004898, -0.008388010784983635, -0.008181944489479065, 0.024071214720606804, 0.09004126489162445, 0.036641765385866165, -0.005844199098646641, 0.03246427699923515, -0.02296861819922924, -0.025763021782040596, -0.01856096088886261, 0.0026345527730882168, -0.02793765626847744, -0.020018702372908592, -0.005561786703765392, -0.012775358743965626, 0.0316067673265934, -0.015251493081450462, -0.029906244948506355, 0.03229347616434097, -0.010483815334737301, -0.02270320989191532, -0.08416960388422012, -0.0393846295773983, -0.027100009843707085, -0.020978182554244995, -0.00566623080521822, -0.0074690827168524265, -0.0004136368224862963, -0.006401166319847107, 0.013680479489266872, 0.009711195714771748, -0.0445282943546772, 0.0010900418274104595, 0.0524761863052845, 0.010323368944227695, -0.005669976118952036, -0.00268901907838881, -0.014725989662110806, 0.028150340542197227, -0.031997401267290115, 0.03513539955019951, 0.0029398459009826183, 0.008414224721491337, -0.03960235044360161, -0.021396448835730553, -0.0648571029305458, 0.030438469722867012, 0.051021456718444824, 0.014457179233431816, 0.044591862708330154, 0.01834668219089508, 0.04724309220910072, -0.02777055837213993, 0.0031657617073506117, 0.004207050893455744, 0.012125452049076557, 0.030533192679286003, 0.0027190488763153553, -0.021451156586408615, -0.02102900668978691, 0.015591463074088097, 0.025314822793006897, 0.004672839771956205, 0.021538356319069862, 0.024842359125614166, 0.03587085008621216, 0.010843117721378803, 0.004083604551851749, -0.0605844147503376, 0.031816866248846054, -0.05792082101106644, 0.06866791099309921, -0.052287664264440536, 0.00043530503171496093, 0.028612520545721054, 0.015094478614628315, 0.006035616621375084, -0.04718820005655289, -0.030384205281734467, -0.05797160044312477, 0.03718237206339836, 0.012104138731956482, -0.014105310663580894, 0.00009358959505334496, 0.02526194043457508, 0.054340116679668427, -0.00566395977512002, 0.04002651199698448, -0.031892772763967514, -0.06822112947702408, 0.00005905936995986849, -0.004624492023140192, -0.03931683301925659, 0.051424894481897354, -0.0026411572471261024, -0.05478455126285553, 0.021657876670360565, -0.02507847175002098, 0.03825802356004715, 0.003994669299572706, 0.02982708066701889, -0.005046676378697157, 0.07315138727426529, -0.0214410200715065, 0.0059083872474730015, 0.014365092851221561, -0.0038967167492955923, 0.09528809040784836, 0.048695873469114304, 0.01834625005722046, -0.047128964215517044, 0.060821887105703354, 0.005154178943485022, 0.012664435431361198, 0.011801745742559433, 0.002160614123567939, 0.03445223718881607, -0.005138632375746965, 0.02761783078312874, 0.023620031774044037, 0.01952398382127285, -0.00030142415198497474, 0.04807356745004654, 0.030369102954864502, -0.03537752106785774, 0.01321139745414257, -0.0053567662835121155, 0.007349626626819372, -0.01751440390944481, -0.024722982197999954, -0.002242038957774639, 0.01912088505923748, 0.017187928780913353, -0.01738886721432209, -0.01894194260239601, 0.020734990015625954, 0.04247897490859032, -0.01825316995382309, 0.010501996614038944, -0.00122933485545218, 0.034586720168590546, -0.03280811011791229, 0.0021742708049714565, -0.012095623649656773, -0.04280247539281845, -0.009020167402923107, 0.05878587067127228, 0.0700388103723526, -0.03035387396812439, 0.01463914941996336, 0.038213085383176804, -0.02685902640223503, -0.030528895556926727, -0.028518494218587875, 0.033702198415994644, -0.015692563727498055, -0.04690374433994293, -0.013851349242031574, 0.013325733132660389, 0.02366841398179531, -0.04993782564997673, -0.033838577568531036, -0.013952217064797878, -0.0009835221571847796, -0.020056625828146935, -0.010049920529127121, -0.06103967875242233, 0.03239067643880844, -0.01942915841937065, 0.03012034110724926, -0.026605073362588882, -0.0006535014254041016, -0.03669973090291023, -0.03540397062897682, 0.0520695298910141, -0.013446384109556675, -0.02240942046046257, -0.00045373220928013325, -0.006554963532835245, -0.025297239422798157, -0.00025204126723110676, -0.006850397679954767, 0.015993919223546982, 0.03946169093251228, 0.015482114627957344, -0.04249293729662895, 0.013145132921636105, -0.04216349497437477, -0.005242805927991867, -0.011806592345237732, -0.019656099379062653, -0.039948705583810806, -0.0005347582045942545, 0.023435337468981743, 0.03538167476654053, 0.038814477622509, 0.015779776498675346, 0.02553342469036579, 0.0399666503071785, 0.02252974733710289, -0.057691000401973724, -0.016578160226345062, -0.012427890673279762, -0.0523519366979599, -0.03709664195775986, -0.03273358568549156, 0.03945733606815338, -0.007315403316169977, 0.01676742359995842, 0.008088546805083752, 0.00820216629654169, 0.003518729005008936, -0.008760363794863224, -0.000030458308174274862, -0.03508950024843216, -0.020975559949874878, 0.0010896367020905018, 0.03583817183971405, -0.013310416601598263, -0.013185516931116581, -0.0567978136241436, 0.001326363766565919, 0.03644660487771034, -0.049150582402944565, -0.004519924987107515, -0.0032858303748071194, -0.028050845488905907, -0.027845704928040504, -0.03722183406352997, 0.007432035636156797, -0.008601082488894463, -0.021644068881869316, -0.00617518974468112, 0.004438098985701799, -0.010503138415515423, 0.02009003795683384, -0.01657208986580372, 0.0016235640505328774, 0.005057050380855799, -0.018958071246743202, 0.021064909175038338, -0.01852874457836151, 0.017433369532227516, -0.005174016114324331, 0.041750457137823105, -0.01092220377177, -0.013140919618308544, 0.02549816481769085, -0.029781412333250046, 0.005874670576304197, -0.01256517879664898, -0.04233025014400482, 0.012884186580777168, 0.012394918128848076, 0.005242337007075548, 0.011728798970580101, 0.05799683555960655, 0.016567643731832504, -0.014811201952397823, -0.015543653629720211, -0.02832438424229622, -0.005720955785363913, 0.017196698114275932, -0.026522791013121605, -0.004350736271589994, 0.007655646186321974, 0.04680066928267479, 0.04496517404913902, 0.0023290750104933977, -0.03607837110757828, 0.012715766206383705, 0.006714756600558758, -0.008435314521193504, -0.0069837248884141445, -0.04043922945857048, 0.02525077573955059, 0.05389693006873131, 0.0055905552580952644, 0.032449979335069656, -0.036971211433410645, 0.029859671369194984, -0.03461980074644089, -0.026884570717811584, -0.006536063738167286, 0.02369999885559082, 0.008408546447753906, -0.01829639822244644, 0.022440988570451736, 0.02610439620912075, -0.08253259211778641, 0.0012338716769590974, -0.0022639031521975994, -0.022912781685590744, -0.04622914269566536, -0.014608684927225113, -0.013555130921304226, 0.012947237119078636, -0.016159364953637123, -0.005005082115530968, -0.003138085827231407, 0.006899872329086065, 0.008016137406229973, -0.00949487742036581, 0.01598365418612957, 0.040388379245996475, 0.04819347336888313, -0.057351503521203995, 0.027439245954155922, -0.027113188058137894, -0.045853227376937866, 0.042729854583740234, -0.027783473953604698, 0.017375055700540543, 0.06068897619843483, 0.02102823369204998, 0.01635773852467537, 0.07803910970687866, -0.03312208130955696, -0.013167183846235275, -0.03381072357296944, 0.002040077466517687, -0.0013552556047216058, 0.02598300576210022, 0.002035086741670966, 0.05062609538435936, 0.05994516611099243, 0.02329358272254467, -0.002919748891144991, -0.004106907639652491, -0.020255345851182938, -0.027519704774022102, -0.005656572990119457, -0.036120664328336716, -0.006353822071105242, 0.03573619946837425, -0.023032085970044136, -0.052694447338581085, 0.016873186454176903, -0.014935082755982876, 0.0017524280119687319, -0.010299930348992348, -0.011091593652963638, -0.032862305641174316, -0.029603753238916397, 0.0016488282708451152, 0.0028965978417545557, 0.001640448346734047, -0.034127771854400635, -0.008856767788529396, -0.011391335166990757, -0.01074744388461113, -0.02352653257548809, -0.061218298971652985, 0.0022423951886594296, 0.0488056018948555, 0.006106451153755188, -0.03907548263669014, -0.01079978235065937, 0.015893105417490005, 0.030298741534352303, -0.06527689844369888, 0.042897339910268784, 0.025509199127554893, -0.008718262426555157, -0.06066872924566269, -0.01633438840508461, -0.033929117023944855, 0.04098302870988846, 0.057867445051670074, 0.010928399860858917, -0.0010874212021008134, -0.009859162382781506, 0.045217402279376984, 0.0042686257511377335, -0.04301045462489128, 0.03860396519303322, 0.012231259606778622, -0.024648163467645645, 0.01938564144074917, 0.013010337948799133, 0.004611426033079624, 0.035492803901433945, 0.04758059233427048, 0.018667487427592278, 0.03672325983643532, 0.0013569077709689736, 0.0029422969091683626, 0.027523664757609367, -0.028795285150408745, 0.0070083667524158955, 0.08699068427085876, 0.014258070848882198, -0.012047498486936092, 0.0019598095677793026, 0.004723004996776581, -0.04021286964416504, 0.038834650069475174, -0.041154004633426666, 0.018213028088212013, 0.019950607791543007, -0.03186805918812752, -0.01851729117333889, -0.08556164801120758, -0.013858805410563946, 0.025203734636306763, -0.01615086756646633, 0.010455290786921978, 0.03304632380604744, 0.015315363183617592, 0.0014637669082731009, -0.00625943299382925, 0.011029659770429134, -0.003933717031031847, 0.034598350524902344, -0.020174691453576088, 0.042468905448913574, 0.04227163642644882, -0.0051710885018110275, -0.0076323337852954865, -0.0013081756187602878, -0.050894252955913544, 0.015551825985312462, 0.01829119399189949, 0.030910063534975052, -0.00005504759610630572, -0.013267233036458492, 0.05828428268432617, -0.025886118412017822, -0.004639837425202131, 0.003530978923663497, -0.005452601704746485, 0.06501611322164536, -0.08161397278308868, 0.008103781379759312, -0.008558971807360649, -0.01482541672885418, -0.046363916248083115, 0.022596385329961777, 0.019201576709747314, -0.011034863069653511, 0.007013391237705946, -0.01937687024474144, 0.013941524550318718, -0.026388805359601974, 0.003988661803305149, -0.046882323920726776, 0.020105652511119843, -0.0072139110416173935, 0.0003769277245737612, -0.01757654920220375, 0.008309355936944485, -0.05530751496553421, -0.025519562885165215, 0.01819961704313755, -0.008990834467113018, 0.006075647193938494, -0.002613392425701022, -0.029998483136296272, 0.008512808009982109, 0.07269525527954102, -0.009224457666277885, -0.018651455640792847, 0.0037364668678492308, 0.02475222386419773, -0.0006212876178324223, -0.037593163549900055 ]
<p>I'm stuck with this problem on quality control and p-charts. </p> <p>There is a given process, monitored periodically taking samples of 100 items each and counting the number that are defective. In the last 50 samples we found a total of 622 defective items.</p> <p>I'm OK for the 3-sigma limits of the p-chart and in particular: $$\bar{p} = \frac{622}{50*100} = 0.1244$$ $$\text{UCL} = \bar{p} + 3\sqrt{\frac{\bar{p}(1-\bar{p})}{n}} = 0.1244+ 3\sqrt{\frac{0.1244 (1-0.1244)}{100}} = 0.2234$$ $$\text{LCL} = \bar{p} - 3\sqrt{\frac{\bar{p}(1-\bar{p})}{n}} = 0.1244+ 3\sqrt{\frac{0.1244 (1-0.1244)}{100}} = 0.0254$$ where $\bar{p}$ represents the estimated proportion of defects from the process, used to calculate the control limits.</p> <p>Now, how am I supposed to find the <em>average number of samples</em> before having a point falling outside the control limits (signaling an of out-of-control), given an actual shift of the estimated proportion of defects from $\bar{p}$ to $p' = \bar{p} + 0.06 = 0.1844$ due, for example, to something new that is now influencing the process?</p> <p>I think this has to do with the average run length $\text{ARL}_1 = \frac{1}{1-\beta}$, but I'm not quite sure on the steps leading to its value.</p>
74,401
[ 0.002348152920603752, -0.024711139500141144, -0.005109196528792381, 0.004903858527541161, 0.021499885246157646, -0.0033406440634280443, 0.01615455187857151, -0.012743978761136532, 0.02973531000316143, -0.019810011610388756, 0.04606263339519501, 0.048429206013679504, 0.07772630453109741, 0.021613985300064087, -0.0033714345190674067, 0.0008740237099118531, -0.017977824434638023, 0.014013423584401608, 0.01059296540915966, -0.05423181504011154, 0.015851059928536415, 0.00888217706233263, 0.0030833869241178036, -0.033667150884866714, -0.06721258908510208, 0.03482580557465553, 0.04679283872246742, 0.015309791080653667, -0.02253231219947338, 0.05633463338017464, -0.05277629941701889, -0.05222558602690697, 0.050049617886543274, 0.023604197427630424, 0.049934256821870804, 0.012751421891152859, -0.009235243313014507, -0.029307803139090538, -0.027339931577444077, 0.024952532723546028, -0.04505963623523712, -0.027418427169322968, 0.021789440885186195, -0.0012564167845994234, 0.005626223981380463, -0.030328353866934776, 0.005582386627793312, -0.029905471950769424, 0.04591446369886398, -0.020759763196110725, 0.07646754384040833, -0.017579754814505577, 0.015018416568636894, -0.004264305345714092, -0.016155671328306198, -0.01773178018629551, 0.04348953440785408, 0.04089460149407387, -0.022922655567526817, -0.01957082375884056, -0.021201660856604576, -0.03586664795875549, 0.013426263816654682, -0.0171301681548357, -0.0162384994328022, -0.004044228233397007, -0.0415702760219574, -0.007692866958677769, 0.01868167147040367, -0.020791606977581978, 0.0438319630920887, 0.03389783203601837, 0.022746965289115906, -0.020896684378385544, 0.002157013863325119, -0.02583097480237484, -0.004190378822386265, -0.007735639810562134, 0.025991100817918777, 0.06098935008049011, -0.0011629429645836353, 0.017287008464336395, 0.03537872061133385, 0.05447494983673096, 0.0002423781988909468, -0.04859359934926033, 0.11989197880029678, -0.03899611905217171, 0.02724091336131096, 0.017740702256560326, -0.00751868449151516, -0.007129986304789782, 0.05219082534313202, 0.029235996305942535, -0.06429686397314072, 0.0469207763671875, -0.033954206854104996, 0.04276195168495178, -0.006743378471583128, 0.0313032902777195, 0.03849078714847565, -0.05475718528032303, 0.03428869694471359, 0.0426766574382782, -0.013441978022456169, -0.009498084895312786, -0.011569926515221596, 0.01100043673068285, 0.015360052697360516, -0.009158112108707428, -0.020803017541766167, 0.05163965001702309, 0.014254337176680565, 0.00009621009667171165, 0.0015773382037878036, 0.026129478588700294, -0.023230480030179024, -0.020238379016518593, 0.022715700790286064, 0.05361397564411163, 0.04398550093173981, -0.006012705620378256, 0.022437499836087227, -0.02066228725016117, -0.08241241425275803, 0.03220927715301514, 0.016372093930840492, -0.0318543016910553, -0.06272795796394348, 0.04715018346905708, -0.0038438495248556137, -0.01728307083249092, 0.04042750597000122, -0.022079449146986008, 0.032796021550893784, 0.029136953875422478, -0.07779957354068756, -0.02692306786775589, 0.01191403903067112, 0.018508080393075943, -0.01532046403735876, -0.05118647590279579, 0.006865986622869968, 0.05601533502340317, 0.054224319756031036, 0.013975721783936024, 0.022326121106743813, 0.01670176163315773, 0.0017689679516479373, -0.003184978850185871, -0.021284643560647964, 0.006198789458721876, -0.009842358529567719, -0.009804089553654194, -0.0030976198613643646, -0.0550759993493557, 0.031400416046381, 0.022123320028185844, 0.007018981501460075, -0.028628259897232056, -0.019842762500047684, 0.02069726400077343, 0.003314156550914049, 0.006240950431674719, 0.01221999991685152, -0.010984551161527634, 0.09274604916572571, -0.008987359702587128, 0.005194752477109432, 0.048428867012262344, 0.038927868008613586, 0.01843196339905262, -0.01971210539340973, 0.02739615924656391, 0.07118170708417892, -0.006845084950327873, 0.013225898146629333, -0.018006235361099243, 0.002053936943411827, 0.02906724624335766, -0.020876755937933922, 0.018170343711972237, -0.01672939583659172, 0.053800664842128754, 0.03382507711648941, -0.0046117110177874565, -0.0074287354946136475, -0.021439703181385994, 0.018987242132425308, -0.06211844086647034, -0.04127116873860359, -0.07423699647188187, 0.0029695136472582817, -0.012006562203168869, -0.016611630097031593, 0.02635267935693264, -0.01844852790236473, 0.0029811642598360777, 0.009591112844645977, -0.04501290246844292, -0.005975294858217239, 0.016293589025735855, 0.0555434450507164, -0.06801620125770569, 0.012028251774609089, 0.07472005486488342, 0.04184005409479141, 0.017395002767443657, 0.055236104875802994, -0.07184501737356186, -0.014691595919430256, 0.001977271167561412, -0.053606051951646805, -0.010321560315787792, -0.007111238315701485, -0.01691240817308426, 0.012688377872109413, -0.014275871217250824, 0.004020324908196926, 0.007328561041504145, -0.04332587495446205, 0.05804098770022392, 0.06454657018184662, -0.0009223235538229346, 0.0029678174760192633, -0.0019396123243495822, 0.007567843422293663, 0.023392360657453537, -0.013554703444242477, -0.03710351511836052, -0.019868899136781693, -0.04065173119306564, -0.011300547979772091, 0.012739480473101139, 0.0065959542989730835, -0.024713771417737007, 0.08267909288406372, -0.010677782818675041, -0.0064865173771977425, 0.030237946659326553, 0.016808150336146355, 0.029097905382514, -0.011578998528420925, 0.007914342917501926, -0.009341184981167316, -0.002429510932415724, -0.02702280320227146, 0.01828807219862938, 0.008854323998093605, -0.01090871263295412, 0.006157779134809971, 0.001621720613911748, -0.0209182258695364, 0.027279376983642578, -0.010962269268929958, -0.0024079112336039543, 0.0631919801235199, -0.0060804905369877815, 0.0018194223521277308, 0.034585192799568176, 0.014113625511527061, 0.02326171100139618, 0.052359405905008316, -0.04218371957540512, 0.012269943952560425, 0.06514603644609451, -0.043589796870946884, -0.019762441515922546, 0.009719396941363811, -0.04959431290626526, 0.011093680746853352, -0.030216282233595848, -0.03458675742149353, -0.015583985485136509, 0.02583506517112255, 0.006247194018214941, 0.036341071128845215, 0.022110221907496452, -0.05507969483733177, -0.02773912250995636, -0.013340481556952, 0.013396162539720535, 0.03152337297797203, 0.00357760745100677, -0.0627526119351387, -0.015908703207969666, 0.012020335532724857, -0.016245964914560318, 0.011422022245824337, -0.007398689165711403, -0.05933434143662453, 0.04545404762029648, 0.0021274893078953028, -0.04607846587896347, -0.040035493671894073, -0.023222215473651886, 0.011527391150593758, -0.0330139696598053, -0.038503631949424744, 0.0779472142457962, 0.02498198114335537, -0.03887370228767395, 0.03014279343187809, -0.033974144607782364, -0.011863477528095245, -0.05235420539975166, 0.026000740006566048, -0.010765223763883114, -0.011351882480084896, 0.008027252741158009, 0.01044862437993288, 0.0036275230813771486, 0.0017597588011994958, -0.0378958135843277, -0.07703132927417755, -0.02750171348452568, -0.01058072131127119, 0.02646341547369957, 0.024823317304253578, -0.0013399908784776926, 0.09705306589603424, 0.025967156514525414, -0.047430142760276794, -0.000055329041060758755, -0.029231777414679527, 0.004782672040164471, -0.02745169587433338, 0.007661502342671156, 0.031241539865732193, -0.0010531008010730147, 0.02003452740609646, -0.015067996457219124, 0.053317829966545105, 0.016948053613305092, 0.037093549966812134, 0.004569134674966335, 0.011564704589545727, -0.009532490745186806, -0.007909675128757954, 0.024790555238723755, 0.033333972096443176, -0.022956449538469315, 0.032961778342723846, 0.009093324653804302, 0.04012000188231468, 0.04664802551269531, -0.06138439103960991, -0.013831493444740772, -0.016252437606453896, -0.022461237385869026, 0.018186528235673904, 0.03067273274064064, 0.010060545057058334, -0.03784818574786186, -0.021303823217749596, 0.012205500155687332, 0.04657472297549248, -0.039191823452711105, 0.0056475442834198475, 0.056559961289167404, 0.049062006175518036, -0.0012157351011410356, -0.01684742607176304, 0.009739651344716549, -0.040844887495040894, 0.018793486058712006, -0.04307989031076431, -0.040923651307821274, 0.036078110337257385, 0.06274636834859848, 0.03880021348595619, -0.03800225630402565, -0.010860942304134369, 0.002701804507523775, -0.05290045961737633, -0.007787666749209166, -0.06485950946807861, 0.04185647889971733, 0.02080557309091091, 0.03944466635584831, 0.01682305335998535, -0.03891943022608757, 0.04788368195295334, 0.007973221130669117, -0.06464671343564987, 0.032705504447221756, -0.011950423009693623, -0.03201792761683464, -0.03778090700507164, -0.01208857074379921, 0.041863471269607544, -0.01932518742978573, 0.020562464371323586, -0.004700466990470886, 0.011809263378381729, -0.035488806664943695, -0.008203704841434956, -0.056454792618751526, 0.05533467233181, -0.0186281930655241, 0.00022568728309124708, 0.014904244802892208, -0.008396458812057972, -0.010905340313911438, 0.01954718679189682, -0.040411826223134995, -0.0003025651094503701, -0.05651171877980232, 0.0068771010264754295, 0.00011483449634397402, 0.07201171666383743, 0.053179532289505005, 0.02853776328265667, -0.06282301992177963, 0.016695436090230942, 0.00388751900754869, 0.023191506043076515, 0.02543751336634159, 0.01097528450191021, -0.018789956346154213, -0.01746649108827114, 0.0053731584921479225, 0.02433237060904503, 0.008926707319915295, 0.01077417004853487, 0.010349859483540058, 0.06912509351968765, -0.02293243072926998, -0.06969655305147171, 0.03773965686559677, 0.03799806907773018, 0.02151474542915821, 0.009897686541080475, -0.04966062679886818, 0.0023405367974191904, 0.025166615843772888, -0.0003146981471218169, 0.005772606935352087, 0.017961496487259865, 0.028251390904188156, 0.007179181557148695, 0.044859930872917175, -0.0232706218957901, -0.004071245435625315, -0.01743093505501747, 0.004181279335170984, 0.030766740441322327, -0.020040780305862427, -0.01803882047533989, 0.054380591958761215, 0.04816282540559769, 0.06404968351125717, 0.024782512336969376, 0.03155063837766647, -0.0786699429154396, 0.006345145404338837, 0.015036191791296005, 0.03594924136996269, -0.039056044071912766, -0.012331230565905571, -0.03880641236901283, -0.006574329454451799, 0.05427205562591553, -0.06694202870130539, -0.003949745558202267, -0.0053682285360991955, 0.002317458391189575, -0.006791239604353905, -0.05506376922130585, -0.05641277879476547, -0.007939745672047138, -0.006974104326218367, -0.014126340858638287, -0.013478158973157406, -0.0007539945654571056, -0.02629793994128704, -0.0019515665480867028, 0.012750484980642796, 0.048969510942697525, -0.053634606301784515, -0.0030310319270938635, -0.019252678379416466, 0.00915625412017107, -0.022246049717068672, -0.04814476892352104, 0.0031143692322075367, -0.008979856967926025, 0.0052455416880548, 0.021046731621026993, -0.020027045160531998, -0.0046583544462919235, 0.03577570989727974, 0.05135952681303024, 0.019773226231336594, -0.0567103736102581, -0.019619978964328766, 0.061885684728622437, 0.07059860229492188, -0.0022371357772499323, 0.07249206304550171, 0.008519934490323067, 0.006188520230352879, 0.008465709164738655, -0.005929712671786547, 0.02049187198281288, -0.020706400275230408, -0.0031662569381296635, -0.02330966480076313, 0.03186219185590744, -0.005068608094006777, 0.05962055176496506, -0.006778582464903593, 0.02957911603152752, -0.034216925501823425, 0.006389876827597618, 0.01811870001256466, -0.008883098140358925, 0.003176516154780984, -0.018225714564323425, -0.005016092676669359, 0.013952696695923805, 0.036593176424503326, -0.012341640889644623, -0.0025366991758346558, -0.03906755894422531, 0.027462946251034737, 0.0008922283304855227, 0.015130965039134026, -0.016283491626381874, -0.05339130759239197, -0.0336182601749897, 0.0015437313122674823, 0.010731429792940617, 0.04653463885188103, -0.03435642272233963, 0.04576396569609642, -0.021597130224108696, 0.026924317702651024, -0.04124065116047859, 0.01693054661154747, -0.020756913349032402, 0.029569260776042938, -0.023496564477682114, 0.061941731721162796, -0.03811607509851456, 0.017896616831421852, -0.0729484036564827, -0.04526825621724129, 0.03755495324730873, 0.03225468099117279, -0.05008421465754509, -0.01443910039961338, -0.04023348540067673, 0.0044366237707436085, -0.05715808644890785, -0.016605718061327934, 0.04100140556693077, -0.04262945055961609, -0.0328240841627121, 0.013239525258541107, 0.040138278156518936, 0.06529910862445831, -0.04354499280452728, -0.02116275019943714, 0.014016310684382915, 0.008619368076324463, -0.04527173191308975, 0.011390640400350094, 0.020347584038972855, -0.020041653886437416, -0.02290789596736431, 0.00025302707217633724, -0.01055547408759594, 0.013251377269625664, -0.06596639752388, -0.020165730267763138, 0.013011734932661057, 0.04890614375472069, 0.002927596215158701, -0.021318132057785988, -0.036649059504270554, 0.010969186201691628, 0.011714723892509937, 0.016702402383089066, -0.02926388755440712, -0.019920285791158676, -0.015883540734648705, 0.0368770994246006, 0.052926912903785706, -0.017803790047764778, 0.032744135707616806, 0.05448480695486069, -0.007193740922957659, 0.0008506275480613112, -0.011672546155750751, -0.03171129524707794, 0.02800869382917881, 0.0189509280025959, 0.02408733032643795, 0.020593764260411263, -0.0293754730373621, -0.016997117549180984, -0.020258240401744843, -0.03780685365200043, -0.021314844489097595, 0.03260061889886856, 0.013405049219727516, 0.009126853197813034, 0.0012661698274314404, 0.024148205295205116, 0.017505016177892685, -0.010001856833696365, -0.056180860847234726, 0.003942013252526522, 0.03911072388291359, 0.038949061185121536, -0.01253869105130434, -0.008774896152317524, 0.015042269602417946, 0.01132681593298912, 0.0015787011943757534, 0.019619468599557877, -0.015515473671257496, 0.02189909666776657, 0.00915811862796545, -0.0559929795563221, -0.017410878092050552, 0.04663847014307976, -0.028739338740706444, 0.0031566403340548277, -0.003438274608924985, -0.017962248995900154, 0.03466762602329254, 0.040453147143125534, -0.021313058212399483, -0.026471156626939774, -0.021993570029735565, -0.05795611813664436, -0.007841662503778934, 0.011426321230828762, -0.01534204836934805, 0.061519742012023926, -0.01564258709549904, 0.019023634493350983, -0.027827976271510124, 0.025982890278100967, -0.014778858050704002, -0.031174009665846825, -0.06070941686630249, -0.03810293972492218, -0.03030093014240265, 0.028419166803359985, -0.01825910061597824, 0.018002577126026154, -0.009499790146946907, -0.0074724312871694565, 0.0504801981151104, 0.006842189468443394, 0.05616305395960808, -0.024037685245275497, 0.06655368208885193, 0.01083739846944809, 0.059498198330402374, -0.011341976001858711, -0.011087968945503235, 0.1080513671040535, 0.08000762015581131, 0.0441843718290329, -0.06959855556488037, -0.019426744431257248, -0.011999571695923805, 0.0033960570581257343, -0.0015750692691653967, 0.040512338280677795, -0.006886130664497614, 0.002566424896940589, 0.0278538279235363, 0.05491061136126518, 0.02492554672062397, 0.026961110532283783, 0.06219993531703949, -0.022296810522675514, 0.002153050620108843, 0.020904460921883583, -0.004591239150613546, -0.034150123596191406, -0.03197955712676048, -0.007875482551753521, 0.0453423336148262, -0.011249874718487263, -0.052025601267814636, -0.04043692350387573, -0.026464348658919334, -0.014126517809927464, -0.011050257831811905, 0.014974053017795086, 0.003903366392478347, 0.013604527339339256, -0.015939775854349136, 0.0077415877021849155, -0.02235378511250019, -0.009228517301380634, -0.020995881408452988, 0.023031175136566162, 0.06718403100967407, 0.03520504757761955, 0.011384693905711174, 0.002275465289130807, 0.04080173000693321, -0.054123327136039734, -0.03358783200383186, -0.009380782954394817, 0.022421935573220253, -0.019653722643852234, -0.026690900325775146, -0.004779035225510597, -0.024652734398841858, 0.01150811742991209, -0.022084461525082588, 0.004174100700765848, 0.0022799845319241285, -0.0018542101606726646, -0.04049773886799812, -0.0037217396311461926, 0.02561322972178459, 0.0032503963448107243, 0.021970590576529503, 0.0019205372082069516, 0.0064708394929766655, -0.03172028064727783, -0.024984246119856834, 0.02733970433473587, 0.07177960872650146, 0.005666431970894337, -0.008008603006601334, -0.0055030896328389645, 0.030857205390930176, -0.02889726497232914, 0.015006783418357372, 0.022963548079133034, 0.01772199384868145, 0.036997366696596146, 0.0020035156048834324, 0.003449240932241082, -0.011103182099759579, -0.05093324929475784, 0.014121024869382381, -0.009627610445022583, 0.019503457471728325, -0.015245801769196987, -0.001194617711007595, 0.014788413420319557, 0.05656375363469124, 0.01898612454533577, -0.0043652234598994255, 0.03151337057352066, 0.07535390555858612, 0.03167121857404709, -0.03123456798493862, 0.009579501114785671, -0.004572649952024221, -0.04777206853032112, 0.05095122382044792, -0.008693602867424488, 0.10276111960411072, 0.020307673141360283, 0.021151119843125343, 0.005844125524163246, 0.013012547045946121, -0.02557341381907463, -0.012781845405697823, 0.015182219445705414, -0.034846171736717224, 0.001457865466363728, 0.014350560493767262, 0.003528496716171503, -0.025210700929164886, -0.057775646448135376, -0.025963228195905685, -0.02660842053592205, 0.015958206728100777, 0.0012453784001991153, -0.005463811103254557, -0.007017843890935183, -0.0058151548728346825, -0.01506032794713974, -0.006828784476965666, 0.009754139930009842, -0.018184922635555267, -0.01654328964650631, -0.018223755061626434, 0.026555359363555908, -0.027253149077296257, -0.01596386730670929, -0.019417403265833855, -0.0053491415455937386, 0.011141006834805012, 0.03713604435324669, 0.00782102532684803, -0.0432518869638443, -0.03862420842051506, 0.018405400216579437, -0.011833328753709793, -0.02974664978682995, -0.0023616449907422066, 0.040687188506126404, -0.04091820865869522, -0.045902591198682785, 0.0365847609937191, 0.020309731364250183, 0.02937832660973072, -0.004507771693170071, -0.02603531815111637, -0.011089798994362354, 0.004573507700115442, -0.011578156612813473, -0.023831374943256378, -0.03334959223866463, 0.032005880028009415, 0.007208275143057108, -0.009007755666971207, 0.03443266078829765, 0.003428030526265502, 0.005421495530754328, 0.0034320272970944643, 0.05728650093078613, -0.02470066025853157, 0.0377090722322464, 0.001297103357501328, 0.010369616560637951, -0.009694446809589863, -0.01258134562522173, 0.04824250563979149, -0.014124770648777485, 0.01933080144226551, 0.00635552080348134, 0.00839470699429512, -0.005453518591821194, 0.0023807401303201914, -0.08652427792549133, -0.004444667603820562, -0.0069770063273608685, 0.013210861943662167, 0.03809864819049835, -0.05518348142504692, 0.02174508012831211, 0.017657075077295303, -0.03891713544726372, 0.025663815438747406, -0.04676523432135582, -0.0027809874154627323, -0.03414113074541092, 0.007179147098213434, -0.038857195526361465, 0.005085980053991079, 0.035137537866830826, -0.013477127067744732, 0.014533231034874916, 0.031313456594944, -0.006459588650614023, -0.014036240987479687, 0.019080303609371185, -0.00258931377902627, -0.0001612905180081725, -0.05872729420661926, -0.00017779943300411105, -0.0714545026421547, -0.0003332797787152231, 0.01663987524807453, -0.026085473597049713, 0.006674993317574263, -0.010934306308627129, -0.007547697983682156, -0.020980192348361015, 0.0490603968501091, 0.024837374687194824, -0.008452015928924084, 0.021580830216407776, -0.022394955158233643, 0.03219706192612648, 0.012605315074324608, -0.030013184994459152, 0.026903759688138962, 0.006640088278800249, -0.014513207599520683, -0.0640139952301979, -0.0029518103692680597, 0.008555947802960873, 0.006993407849222422, 0.015670832246541977, 0.02963435649871826, -0.027013933286070824, -0.048334840685129166, 0.022437088191509247, -0.02759573608636856, 0.008824820630252361, 0.01295382622629404, 0.03362790495157242, -0.010467002168297768, 0.001969560282304883, -0.03437855839729309, -0.0500481016933918, 0.007501733023673296, 0.013810972683131695, -0.03803402930498123, -0.05632597580552101, 0.003128467593342066, -0.013940413482487202, 0.0400334931910038, 0.0007082581287249923, -0.006824450567364693, -0.04370346665382385, 0.026038499549031258, -0.005851535592228174, -0.0439208447933197, 0.015339057892560959, -0.001248720334842801, 0.024162231013178825, -0.06698169559240341, 0.028232460841536522, 0.007314872927963734, 0.006406271364539862, -0.02604292891919613, -0.03666386380791664, -0.031486015766859055, 0.022849544882774353, 0.05852890387177467, 0.038180917501449585, -0.019675979390740395, -0.016055846586823463, 0.015921249985694885, 0.002812399761751294, -0.06167418509721756, 0.02764103002846241, -0.023710018023848534, 0.0027179457247257233, -0.05636575073003769, -0.014041362330317497, 0.02842055819928646, 0.00489593343809247, 0.004694472532719374, 0.028626559302210808, 0.04024549946188927, -0.00271013961173594, -0.012332074344158173, 0.003556640353053808, -0.0036637403536587954, -0.01835164986550808, 0.05974240228533745, 0.013675677590072155, 0.027814818546175957, 0.05122483894228935, -0.02230556309223175, -0.0667274072766304, 0.033736634999513626, -0.016275295987725258, 0.0072254310362041, -0.01772236078977585, 0.005578724201768637, 0.004422341473400593, -0.06072244420647621, 0.00030744506511837244, 0.0022317590191960335, -0.034065086394548416, 0.020707370713353157, 0.015492395497858524, 0.0065999808721244335, 0.043678268790245056, -0.025514749810099602, 0.018086887896060944, -0.006952357012778521, 0.0154221560806036, 0.004206757992506027, 0.0022843359038233757, 0.01742762327194214, 0.00407237047329545, -0.0001079460489563644, 0.028814129531383514, 0.000025590721634216607, -0.008341341279447079, 0.0014693309785798192, 0.0005777974729426205, -0.0104755200445652, -0.02878996916115284, -0.011398998089134693, -0.037907037883996964, 0.0013052016729488969, 0.006748905871063471, -0.007269419264048338, 0.047084178775548935, -0.03130253404378891, 0.027828717604279518, -0.03212782368063927, -0.008847068063914776, 0.0021984181366860867, -0.00800203438848257, -0.026579178869724274, 0.023495333269238472, -0.03297154977917671, 0.004974913317710161, -0.012297247536480427, 0.027504872530698776, -0.011940640397369862, -0.01197764091193676, 0.011813548393547535, -0.0060380594804883, 0.00414366414770484, -0.027081476524472237, -0.05212375521659851, -0.0437287874519825, -0.001999542349949479, 0.024472150951623917, 0.01158810406923294, 0.028671585023403168, 0.024342378601431847, -0.039982546120882034, 0.02897462248802185, 0.022667283192276955, -0.008612392470240593, -0.023141205310821533, -0.04450148716568947, 0.016390446573495865, -0.05623940750956535, -0.035952597856521606 ]
<p><strong>Brief intro:</strong> I'm not really sure how to appropriately treat the dependent variables in a set of hierarchical linear models that I'm trying to run. In my models, Level 1 units are children and Level 2 units are schools (we don't have classroom info so there is no nesting level for this).</p> <p><strong>Background:</strong> There are five sets of models, one for each dependent variable. The DVs are all behavioral or cognitive outcome measures that are measured at Level 1. I'm using the HLM 7 software, but I could just as easily use Mplus or R. Each of the five DVs were assessed in the same way. Let's take depression as an example of one: this construct had about 6-8 items (presented to the children as scenarios), and for each item there were 2 response options that could be classified as "the depression options," and 2 response options that could be classified as "not the depression options." The 2 items in each set are treated as equivalent in terms of measurement -- that is, no ordinal ranking from least-to-most depressed. The final form of the depression outcome (as with the other 4 outcomes) is a proportion, which can be interpreted as the proportion of items/scenarios to which the child responded in a way indicative of being depressed. Personally, I hate that the assessment was done in this way, but there's nothing I can do about it now.</p> <p><strong>Problem:</strong> However, I may be able to get permission to score the assessments in a different way, provided I can get access to the item-level data. Right now I only have access to the final proportions. Obviously the default in HLM and in other software is to treat the outcomes as normally distributed. The only distribution appropriate for the [0,1] interval that I know of is the beta, and I do not know of any R packages to implement HLM for beta-distributed variables, nor do I think Mplus or HLM can handle this. I tried using the logit transformation to put the proportions back onto a scale that I could theoretically treat as normal, but with only 6-8 items per DV I still get something that is rather discrete. Not to mention that the 0 and 1 responses, even when converted first to .0001 and .9999 before logit transforming, give me these extreme values that are quite far away from the other transformed values. I've attached histograms to illustrate what I mean.</p> <p><strong>Question:</strong> What are some appropriate ways to treat an outcome variable on the [0,1] interval that takes on only a small handful of observed values when I want to run a set of hierarchical linear models? I'd REALLY like to use the HLM 7 software for this (the P.I. prefers it), but if the best way to treat these types of variables can only be implemented in R then I'm comfortable with that option as well.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/K6YT1.png" alt="Distribution of depression on original scale"></p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/R2hh9.png" alt="Distribution of depression after logit transformation"></p>
74,402
[ -0.04285893216729164, 0.00412699393928051, 0.01145888026803732, -0.02753996104001999, 0.05257488787174225, 0.01283775269985199, -0.004490792751312256, -0.03880660608410835, 0.059291377663612366, -0.039402857422828674, 0.027619965374469757, -0.0007486061076633632, 0.0586167573928833, 0.021382290869951248, 0.03682685270905495, 0.015196510590612888, 0.00500605208799243, 0.014882859773933887, -0.00726286368444562, 0.01778383180499077, -0.006642022170126438, 0.0022040053736418486, -0.007264793384820223, -0.03820428252220154, -0.020928971469402313, 0.06794968992471695, 0.030964763835072517, -0.047454189509153366, -0.0030390534084290266, 0.06344905495643616, -0.03653205186128616, -0.022655600681900978, -0.021846987307071686, 0.0012573492713272572, 0.003928952384740114, 0.0058049485087394714, -0.024746770039200783, -0.016872189939022064, -0.033964332193136215, 0.0201803520321846, -0.00007038900366751477, -0.05320832505822182, -0.027705639600753784, 0.04119443520903587, -0.026112064719200134, -0.024388911202549934, -0.00882187020033598, 0.00015199602057691664, 0.028796983882784843, -0.013424559496343136, 0.04130183532834053, -0.0002994933456648141, 0.021092459559440613, 0.02603982575237751, -0.023230724036693573, -0.0224103145301342, 0.05434183403849602, 0.09375113248825073, 0.018441006541252136, -0.05865580216050148, -0.06508077681064606, -0.013836684636771679, -0.0372372567653656, -0.014349962584674358, -0.023774489760398865, 0.008003556169569492, 0.040976107120513916, -0.012064644135534763, 0.07795539498329163, -0.021286804229021072, 0.01447583269327879, 0.06225154921412468, 0.07098270952701569, -0.006177786737680435, 0.020124798640608788, -0.045014336705207825, 0.0022625660058110952, -0.013814694248139858, 0.04518481343984604, 0.03750934451818466, -0.025287197902798653, 0.008614212274551392, 0.014121798798441887, 0.05252056568861008, 0.0010762455640360713, -0.02514456771314144, 0.06534864753484726, -0.02179913967847824, 0.011202883906662464, 0.01975790224969387, -0.016561467200517654, 0.0015404238365590572, 0.05838308855891228, 0.05109696462750435, -0.04438481479883194, 0.047449395060539246, -0.01683017425239086, 0.0698062852025032, 0.024175899103283882, 0.007498632185161114, 0.013149748556315899, -0.010395725257694721, 0.020892806351184845, 0.0336751751601696, 0.021695300936698914, -0.021152524277567863, -0.016882624477148056, 0.028363263234496117, 0.012310902588069439, -0.045857083052396774, 0.006780282128602266, 0.057742681354284286, 0.002966729225590825, -0.0006605886737816036, 0.02708626165986061, -0.03585151210427284, -0.03393499180674553, -0.042530886828899384, 0.060662057250738144, 0.049152351915836334, 0.023534202948212624, -0.017907004803419113, 0.0013797811698168516, -0.023152152076363564, -0.03758891671895981, 0.025536758825182915, 0.025575943291187286, -0.03202267363667488, -0.03715534880757332, 0.01651839353144169, 0.007353750988841057, -0.004114365670830011, 0.073306143283844, 0.017102353274822235, -0.010593278333544731, -0.013399437069892883, -0.02996136248111725, -0.0695059671998024, -0.0020344785880297422, 0.022549018263816833, -0.02585148997604847, -0.012336082756519318, -0.01757632941007614, 0.03622332215309143, 0.034718938171863556, 0.0021776435896754265, 0.05580737814307213, 0.032133981585502625, 0.04068226367235184, 0.0019452499691396952, -0.0073047843761742115, 0.004377042409032583, -0.04982111230492592, -0.03127980977296829, -0.00959863793104887, -0.06705353409051895, 0.028973452746868134, 0.040569305419921875, -0.004391835071146488, 0.017646975815296173, 0.021625280380249023, 0.007550867274403572, -0.05190558731555939, -0.01276472955942154, 0.03681496903300285, 0.007878520525991917, 0.03793206810951233, -0.05049276724457741, 0.018135445192456245, 0.0200638510286808, -0.027250872924923897, 0.017359597608447075, -0.0073343985714018345, 0.05157747119665146, 0.01989293284714222, 0.00008736849122215062, -0.012955589219927788, -0.04041179642081261, -0.0005739014013670385, -0.004977209959179163, -0.014337255619466305, -0.016601059585809708, -0.038570284843444824, -0.012660250067710876, 0.02129848673939705, 0.023722251877188683, -0.00017122155986726284, -0.03541437163949013, 0.038183651864528656, 0.004283672198653221, -0.07340352237224579, -0.050566431134939194, 0.009134971536695957, -0.030182955786585808, -0.0380365289747715, 0.022051136940717697, -0.013703360222280025, 0.047249142080545425, -0.002809147583320737, -0.008183333091437817, 0.0019160155206918716, -0.0440678671002388, -0.002768175443634391, -0.012008597142994404, -0.0033551882952451706, 0.05802028253674507, 0.04671470448374748, -0.044133301824331284, 0.025423351675271988, -0.02769983559846878, -0.02241794764995575, -0.026062285527586937, -0.021160371601581573, 0.04059430956840515, -0.008295220322906971, -0.041264608502388, -0.002284206682816148, -0.029563264921307564, -0.027172714471817017, 0.006134829018265009, -0.07024245709180832, 0.06611593812704086, 0.060326360166072845, -0.0419243723154068, 0.027383901178836823, 0.012070964090526104, -0.013074541464447975, 0.0027844083961099386, -0.010509857907891273, 0.01609593816101551, -0.05487700179219246, 0.009574788622558117, 0.0429912768304348, -0.012889904901385307, -0.031567465513944626, 0.033167798072099686, 0.05136876553297043, 0.01612851582467556, 0.01174871064722538, 0.00599134573712945, 0.00895809754729271, 0.0014234839472919703, 0.007320762611925602, 0.012844249606132507, 0.022238129749894142, -0.004503211937844753, -0.026684654876589775, 0.025794614106416702, 0.025309326127171516, 0.008810602128505707, -0.0020069514866918325, 0.017905229702591896, 0.03266287222504616, 0.03194953501224518, -0.01822427660226822, -0.018046265468001366, 0.049957916140556335, -0.02481640689074993, 0.03070496954023838, 0.076296865940094, 0.003444673027843237, -0.0012505229096859694, 0.01783035509288311, -0.02969035878777504, 0.014452492818236351, 0.05904464051127434, -0.026784513145685196, -0.004206257406622171, 0.02904241532087326, -0.019859014078974724, 0.04481029883027077, -0.0235833041369915, -0.0418936163187027, -0.016335057094693184, -0.008687738329172134, 0.029351571574807167, 0.030461078509688377, 0.009440732188522816, -0.03589916229248047, 0.01026221178472042, 0.014603445306420326, 0.005925037432461977, 0.01728501357138157, 0.013438137248158455, -0.0587085485458374, -0.029169248417019844, -0.03704843670129776, -0.0016243925783783197, 0.02972901053726673, 0.012749348767101765, -0.05710814893245697, 0.03346043825149536, -0.014325457625091076, -0.06755124777555466, -0.05472106859087944, -0.04533805698156357, -0.03259551152586937, -0.03682255372405052, -0.019841698929667473, 0.06846161931753159, 0.032225701957941055, -0.04809609800577164, 0.010412480682134628, 0.010638580657541752, -0.0021812247578054667, -0.04015931859612465, -0.021428953856229782, -0.004226217977702618, 0.04180138185620308, -0.0010854360880330205, -0.0009328797459602356, -0.0061592720448970795, 0.003687784541398287, -0.08596940338611603, -0.042606715112924576, 0.02338409051299095, 0.02022513747215271, 0.06230222061276436, 0.021126409992575645, -0.003321535885334015, 0.09061384201049805, 0.03903695195913315, 0.013782240450382233, -0.07271870225667953, 0.008660328574478626, 0.004870313219726086, -0.018598811700940132, 0.01672096736729145, 0.023432958871126175, 0.02920902520418167, 0.02923084981739521, -0.013380298390984535, 0.041030582040548325, 0.024875568225979805, 0.02101168781518936, -0.01045868918299675, 0.007220810279250145, -0.024261247366666794, -0.037942156195640564, 0.023592587560415268, 0.005399792920798063, 0.001992978388443589, -0.018622690811753273, -0.017760101705789566, 0.014097737148404121, 0.007161606568843126, -0.02789703942835331, -0.009415976703166962, 0.0017644336912781, -0.0108024338260293, -0.032917194068431854, 0.0042161280289292336, 0.010528573766350746, -0.03807868808507919, 0.008056101389229298, -0.006151665933430195, 0.03488056734204292, -0.02993095852434635, 0.009902853518724442, 0.053431250154972076, 0.02880486100912094, -0.012098278850317001, -0.030166540294885635, 0.015575376339256763, -0.008435113355517387, 0.015505841933190823, -0.021317731589078903, 0.021743478253483772, 0.05166222155094147, 0.040265005081892014, 0.038246482610702515, -0.04323335364460945, -0.046413637697696686, 0.011684875003993511, -0.048745375126600266, 0.010643599554896355, -0.05049040913581848, 0.033965568989515305, 0.02084779366850853, 0.02743980474770069, 0.012107820250093937, -0.008019312284886837, 0.024988064542412758, 0.010712794959545135, -0.04458526149392128, 0.00993332825601101, -0.041047532111406326, 0.019135447219014168, 0.0235733762383461, 0.005922582000494003, 0.01282645482569933, -0.008569124154746532, -0.012557596899569035, -0.018859755247831345, 0.013834876008331776, -0.011831337586045265, 0.012315703555941582, -0.026387205347418785, -0.04052651301026344, -0.0017486404394730926, -0.00030522982706315815, -0.03312753513455391, -0.011315799318253994, 0.005929828155785799, 0.020936019718647003, 0.023938098922371864, 0.03912980854511261, -0.06442388147115707, -0.011404812335968018, 0.0243147611618042, 0.06317657232284546, 0.002814311534166336, 0.01410625223070383, -0.02791782282292843, 0.017698390409350395, 0.0305358674377203, 0.022295737639069557, 0.05622148513793945, -0.03865526616573334, -0.03009468875825405, -0.0036779153160750866, -0.02183830551803112, -0.009122040122747421, 0.013340339995920658, -0.015258525498211384, 0.03633373975753784, 0.044183265417814255, 0.03957141190767288, -0.03558582812547684, 0.03992387279868126, 0.04197677969932556, -0.010063248686492443, -0.020626215264201164, -0.013440614566206932, -0.0004434709844645113, -0.017509227618575096, -0.022020084783434868, 0.01153976283967495, 0.012736495584249496, -0.002886950969696045, -0.00502336211502552, 0.043817222118377686, -0.017361218109726906, -0.03105175867676735, 0.05506100878119469, -0.039533648639917374, 0.017866862937808037, 0.02563582733273506, -0.05293208733201027, 0.0020861949305981398, 0.05354946851730347, 0.052441246807575226, 0.010060306638479233, 0.024675238877534866, -0.07966281473636627, 0.008648189716041088, 0.015242451801896095, 0.009008889086544514, 0.012650001794099808, 0.022617874667048454, -0.03111344575881958, -0.020029790699481964, 0.024210801348090172, -0.046104345470666885, 0.008253853768110275, 0.002883263397961855, 0.018159471452236176, -0.03381214290857315, -0.023043924942612648, -0.06587963551282883, 0.03246038034558296, -0.007803487591445446, 0.02964981272816658, 0.022403031587600708, 0.008690974675118923, -0.054148562252521515, 0.002663512248545885, -0.012566260993480682, 0.048815712332725525, -0.010915055871009827, -0.04535035043954849, 0.03150816634297371, -0.03917239233851433, -0.057082243263721466, -0.05302054062485695, 0.018887195736169815, -0.007235843688249588, 0.007986790500581264, 0.07209419459104538, -0.029890472069382668, -0.031073808670043945, 0.015378177165985107, 0.005607317667454481, 0.015384999103844166, 0.011738665401935577, -0.040073130279779434, 0.046359170228242874, 0.03723869472742081, 0.017370475456118584, 0.052795156836509705, 0.04206135869026184, -0.012869376689195633, -0.009764582850039005, -0.004154256545007229, -0.018497895449399948, -0.06816501170396805, -0.04418155178427696, -0.04496780410408974, -0.024699600413441658, 0.005925834644585848, 0.029678519815206528, -0.00025100811035372317, 0.03136170282959938, 0.008217991329729557, -0.025107137858867645, 0.004926922731101513, 0.012910525314509869, -0.012456738390028477, 0.016750402748584747, -0.018723472952842712, -0.007696337997913361, 0.009161503985524178, -0.021953433752059937, 0.0371505469083786, -0.009762955829501152, 0.02908402308821678, -0.002280601765960455, -0.05229594185948372, 0.0021737595088779926, -0.003864911152049899, -0.005365366116166115, 0.0009126784862019122, -0.03383393585681915, 0.020659055560827255, -0.035813070833683014, 0.02667044848203659, -0.022452833130955696, -0.0027764730621129274, -0.01112631056457758, 0.034392695873975754, -0.018404506146907806, 0.005363177508115768, 0.028490694239735603, 0.006624859757721424, -0.00027927636983804405, -0.0010721876751631498, -0.06457242369651794, -0.041916873306035995, 0.005657779052853584, -0.01914614625275135, -0.0064634098671376705, 0.004946473985910416, -0.022016245871782303, 0.04189402237534523, -0.010163076221942902, 0.015862764790654182, 0.06088988110423088, -0.04009752348065376, -0.0005031767068430781, -0.03218723461031914, 0.03139783814549446, 0.06401607394218445, -0.006206436548382044, -0.0036565675400197506, 0.019536159932613373, -0.005460047163069248, -0.00874757207930088, -0.008287753909826279, 0.01624862290918827, -0.042607199400663376, -0.019056059420108795, -0.021165966987609863, 0.022715158760547638, 0.056711599230766296, 0.014661047607660294, -0.04679618403315544, 0.014965154230594635, -0.018357109278440475, -0.035106636583805084, -0.030460694804787636, 0.020662257447838783, -0.028835926204919815, -0.04477939009666443, -0.042291976511478424, 0.013908752240240574, -0.04692121595144272, -0.005530559457838535, 0.06244722753763199, 0.0018303487449884415, -0.005902386736124754, -0.02155858278274536, 0.06017421931028366, 0.009361278265714645, -0.004819477442651987, 0.016851043328642845, -0.0754040777683258, 0.032599855214357376, 0.033805038779973984, 0.022359834983944893, 0.022223033010959625, 0.031459465622901917, 0.00328951352275908, -0.010542734526097775, -0.048264045268297195, 0.027316875755786896, 0.031998056918382645, 0.01672464609146118, -0.020945915952324867, 0.026005810126662254, -0.029299946501851082, 0.012954801321029663, -0.029790814965963364, -0.009233955293893814, 0.00572512811049819, 0.050113461911678314, 0.09333028644323349, -0.01840919628739357, 0.000616556266322732, 0.029929304495453835, 0.02324649877846241, 0.0015164650976657867, 0.0034884659107774496, 0.019719425588846207, -0.024196062237024307, 0.042703475803136826, -0.03338790312409401, -0.05128315091133118, 0.029756855219602585, -0.05734524130821228, -0.010334855876863003, -0.010669488459825516, -0.06142623722553253, 0.034410133957862854, 0.01521418895572424, -0.002670910907909274, -0.0743282362818718, -0.003817017190158367, -0.03503338247537613, 0.0037770296912640333, 0.028695378452539444, -0.016957508400082588, 0.03620441257953644, 0.019257748499512672, 0.03295275941491127, -0.008668533526360989, 0.027045367285609245, -0.05276434123516083, -0.05690760165452957, -0.02992493100464344, -0.031797461211681366, -0.07369386404752731, 0.027254760265350342, -0.025979723781347275, -0.01819690130650997, -0.008092481642961502, -0.041283268481492996, 0.011379552073776722, 0.025682605803012848, 0.022875070571899414, -0.0012558787129819393, 0.047597549855709076, -0.0007699928828515112, -0.0020112753845751286, -0.014584306627511978, -0.03559861704707146, 0.13988271355628967, 0.08054052293300629, 0.04373341426253319, -0.07678858935832977, 0.014982596039772034, 0.01498089637607336, 0.017184294760227203, -0.0275275819003582, 0.005154258105903864, -0.0015990177635103464, -0.06543596088886261, 0.041697725653648376, 0.10503939539194107, 0.045146651566028595, 0.019317343831062317, 0.08732550591230392, 0.003025598591193557, -0.008297492749989033, 0.012705577537417412, 0.0019621567334979773, 0.0014334069564938545, -0.010406173765659332, -0.013676876202225685, 0.014672049321234226, 0.03590124845504761, -0.002991955727338791, -0.003125848714262247, 0.0017722498159855604, 0.011025617830455303, -0.029120102524757385, -0.023520199581980705, 0.0037585310637950897, -0.006411364302039146, 0.010790244676172733, 0.04799778014421463, -0.026062551885843277, 0.037989772856235504, -0.051841605454683304, 0.009303386323153973, 0.0441288948059082, -0.018284281715750694, 0.005880669690668583, 0.0013183121336624026, 0.001446796813979745, -0.04545646905899048, -0.030722087249159813, -0.018823344260454178, 0.041556842625141144, -0.020120156928896904, -0.0647333487868309, 0.0005249400855973363, 0.007236764300614595, -0.008005332201719284, -0.05554070323705673, -0.01611381582915783, 0.015248680487275124, 0.021451225504279137, -0.007084124721586704, -0.027517983689904213, 0.01743805594742298, 0.0009398343390785158, 0.002388642868027091, 0.023779964074492455, 0.006640709936618805, -0.017272714525461197, -0.03715866804122925, -0.05944784730672836, 0.04693838581442833, 0.026534058153629303, -0.000633787305559963, 0.04089362174272537, 0.014440972357988358, 0.004564695060253143, -0.016054056584835052, -0.018036697059869766, 0.018088126555085182, 0.010601361282169819, 0.004270197357982397, -0.005237920675426722, -0.052344899624586105, -0.00883450172841549, -0.0011280830949544907, -0.044800929725170135, -0.005534880328923464, -0.04612800478935242, -0.005204411223530769, -0.007010775618255138, 0.07405411452054977, 0.0383833609521389, 0.034299470484256744, -0.02018827013671398, 0.032626766711473465, -0.025190185755491257, -0.06018979847431183, 0.016340069472789764, 0.00724573340266943, -0.05803743749856949, 0.0025736403185874224, 0.008506855927407742, 0.04671945422887802, -0.017241407185792923, 0.004989550448954105, -0.03429265692830086, 0.04185739532113075, 0.011899183504283428, -0.0009755439823493361, 0.004288836382329464, -0.06911374628543854, -0.006376098375767469, -0.011622713878750801, 0.02998279221355915, -0.02012648992240429, 0.005690335296094418, -0.07560044527053833, -0.014643329195678234, 0.0044816890731453896, -0.023495284840464592, -0.021013576537370682, -0.007656292524188757, -0.014065434224903584, 0.010418693535029888, -0.011993419378995895, 0.024145396426320076, -0.012559236958622932, -0.01497949194163084, 0.0015749844023957849, -0.017567601054906845, 0.03525029495358467, -0.001057854387909174, -0.02940794825553894, 0.010516276583075523, 0.021642902866005898, 0.00367081630975008, -0.006902336608618498, -0.00420289346948266, 0.030737226828932762, 0.04384174942970276, 0.028469068929553032, 0.025161590427160263, -0.028908398002386093, 0.03592219576239586, -0.02130855619907379, -0.034494172781705856, -0.003939245827496052, 0.04049290716648102, 0.029321366921067238, 0.021044587716460228, 0.016209803521633148, -0.03614843636751175, 0.04673481732606888, -0.04432510584592819, -0.02233916148543358, -0.005555919371545315, -0.022816766053438187, 0.03698863461613655, -0.008768130093812943, -0.003941681236028671, 0.045664310455322266, -0.004121987149119377, 0.041222427040338516, 0.025101574137806892, 0.012493359856307507, 0.03088514134287834, 0.00613506929948926, -0.04540148004889488, 0.05927414074540138, 0.007132949307560921, -0.004132811911404133, 0.02978323958814144, 0.03282305598258972, -0.04355906322598457, 0.03141746297478676, 0.008777991868555546, 0.009956683032214642, -0.08302518725395203, -0.008685139007866383, 0.006579860579222441, 0.027587436139583588, 0.042054183781147, -0.033740315586328506, 0.007963016629219055, 0.028775420039892197, -0.028463179245591164, 0.028823234140872955, 0.012972012162208557, 0.019752848893404007, 0.0039023945573717356, 0.017423084005713463, -0.05509967356920242, 0.029038812965154648, 0.013338081538677216, -0.00840988289564848, 0.0018130706157535315, 0.028441978618502617, 0.016042187809944153, -0.01775464415550232, -0.01270647905766964, -0.03329196572303772, 0.02098056860268116, -0.038983020931482315, 0.020785506814718246, -0.03768107667565346, -0.018247047439217567, 0.03753865137696266, 0.007742337882518768, 0.024700503796339035, 0.010079986415803432, 0.02704945206642151, 0.03006681054830551, 0.054670535027980804, 0.0067757111974060535, 0.00705348514020443, -0.013437802903354168, -0.017161406576633453, 0.01104513555765152, 0.06391896307468414, -0.026206929236650467, -0.014390328899025917, 0.039654869586229324, -0.029119083657860756, -0.021335462108254433, 0.020843323320150375, -0.039350178092718124, -0.01850058138370514, -0.04553939774632454, -0.04401310905814171, 0.0062960912473499775, -0.021898575127124786, 0.016755005344748497, -0.045795001089572906, -0.010801373049616814, 0.037539225071668625, 0.0025362102314829826, -0.009771198034286499, -0.0027765161357820034, -0.01812361180782318, -0.010981710627675056, -0.001049768179655075, -0.03160695359110832, -0.00035766526707448065, -0.06434717029333115, 0.002740381518378854, -0.04307417571544647, 0.005066379904747009, -0.00546333147212863, 0.01965983398258686, -0.0468265563249588, 0.043315526098012924, -0.055345553904771805, 0.010921814478933811, -0.006477725692093372, -0.01950213499367237, 0.037702739238739014, -0.0804852768778801, 0.08080758154392242, 0.0267271026968956, -0.018304772675037384, -0.010127059184014797, 0.040682051330804825, -0.019404565915465355, 0.006879155058413744, 0.04243907332420349, -0.01694352552294731, 0.002980130957439542, 0.006173767615109682, 0.03593461215496063, -0.0004648901813197881, -0.04486662521958351, 0.018302833661437035, 0.018010031431913376, -0.0008337380131706595, -0.007804618217051029, -0.0141207966953516, -0.011679518967866898, -0.02102483995258808, 0.016429999843239784, -0.006472301669418812, 0.007031756918877363, -0.006840538699179888, 0.02191215194761753, -0.0015648688422515988, 0.017097361385822296, -0.0349915586411953, 0.03193499147891998, -0.021046452224254608, 0.015985822305083275, 0.03382847085595131, -0.00807219184935093, -0.058619897812604904, 0.016291767358779907, -0.017013942822813988, -0.035198722034692764, -0.0068039423786103725, -0.00008150799840223044, 0.0028309195768088102, -0.03861493989825249, -0.0034807855263352394, -0.004293687641620636, -0.023442475125193596, -0.015474253334105015, 0.033050719648599625, -0.00444791791960597, 0.03238876163959503, -0.005003033205866814, 0.006337678525596857, 0.029147030785679817, -0.02116708643734455, 0.029626747593283653, 0.03176083043217659, 0.06949083507061005, -0.005603954661637545, -0.006613569334149361, 0.03324912488460541, 0.0003319834067951888, 0.015036982484161854, 0.026147199794650078, 0.028712380677461624, -0.02343621850013733, -0.01674126461148262, 0.014083421789109707, -0.0042083547450602055, -0.007219383958727121, -0.021270079538226128, 0.0008560242131352425, 0.05703447386622429, 0.005949037615209818, -0.015783146023750305, -0.05588335543870926, -0.0463121272623539, -0.011687620542943478, 0.04553978890180588, -0.009865806438028812, 0.054583530873060226, -0.008786935359239578, 0.020216334611177444, 0.0014625575859099627, 0.009438429027795792, 0.016749709844589233, -0.01606757566332817, -0.002779595786705613, -0.01708184741437435, -0.00249097659252584, 0.009944613091647625, -0.02885710820555687, -0.03423066437244415, -0.03434957191348076, 0.037339672446250916, -0.015756214037537575, 0.023603716865181923, -0.024331865832209587, -0.01747131533920765, 0.008103303611278534, 0.05833778530359268, -0.032453812658786774, -0.017393620684742928, -0.013831915333867073, 0.01657237857580185, -0.02546198107302189, -0.035986095666885376 ]
<p>I have a posterior distribution over a set of parameters denoted by $\theta = \{w, \phi, \lambda\}$ and the posterior is the joint distribution given the observed data i.e. $P(\theta | D)$. Now, this posterior is a multivariate normal distribution (due to the approximate way it is estimated).</p> <p>Now I want to find out the marginal distributions from this joint. So, for example, $P(\lambda)$ could be found my marginalizing over $w$ and $\phi$. Is there an easy way to do this for such MVN distributions? Also, can I find the mode for this marginal distribution easily?</p>
74,403
[ -0.01612810418009758, -0.01697908528149128, 0.01600625552237034, -0.007275227922946215, 0.030070513486862183, 0.03106698952615261, -0.009613673202693462, -0.016747592017054558, 0.04845195263624191, -0.052488774061203, 0.0342525877058506, 0.051718614995479584, 0.07334674149751663, -0.0006569832912646234, 0.03048604354262352, 0.0009800359839573503, -0.035247307270765305, -0.025426937267184258, -0.0018283079843968153, -0.023831447586417198, -0.007829306647181511, 0.005263588856905699, 0.03769529610872269, -0.02157158963382244, -0.013990717940032482, 0.029689891263842583, 0.01880359649658203, -0.000459468545159325, -0.013961964286863804, 0.04932000860571861, -0.00990332942456007, -0.02742961421608925, -0.00011643308971542865, 0.04092539846897125, -0.02641938254237175, -0.01742466539144516, -0.031203215941786766, -0.032916463911533356, -0.016171829774975777, 0.02950317971408367, -0.04315200448036194, -0.03215258568525314, -0.0007710378849878907, 0.043188996613025665, -0.012253657914698124, 0.0067720660008490086, -0.028493035584688187, -0.02899869531393051, 0.028325572609901428, -0.030632425099611282, 0.08486145734786987, 0.03556877374649048, 0.053337424993515015, 0.050958335399627686, -0.02730569988489151, -0.005626719910651445, 0.046996764838695526, 0.09840806573629379, 0.02556459791958332, -0.07460061460733414, -0.016614893451333046, -0.048230092972517014, 0.009846159256994724, -0.02561153471469879, -0.040665965527296066, 0.03506261482834816, -0.020706644281744957, -0.021598156541585922, -0.004576916806399822, -0.0021216582972556353, -0.00821403507143259, 0.006887180730700493, 0.04808826744556427, 0.0038215317763388157, -0.0214081984013319, -0.013830726966261864, 0.01901027373969555, 0.06615792959928513, 0.04700595512986183, -0.0023232719395309687, -0.003096545347943902, 0.03401952236890793, -0.010846965946257114, 0.04492899775505066, -0.022829508408904076, -0.039477113634347916, 0.09762095659971237, -0.023361725732684135, -0.005614147987216711, 0.03821790590882301, -0.04442804306745529, -0.01708180457353592, 0.004479294642806053, -0.01752147451043129, -0.05591215938329697, 0.02548106759786606, -0.02554495818912983, 0.020966488867998123, 0.0034458336886018515, -0.019454697147011757, 0.00016027888341341168, -0.023392118513584137, -0.010074526071548462, 0.03974250704050064, -0.016688162460923195, -0.015075928531587124, -0.0030613301787525415, -0.00300195231102407, -0.02508571930229664, 0.0017767695244401693, -0.051815103739500046, 0.020470617339015007, -0.0000030593616884289077, -0.015645863488316536, 0.015033860690891743, 0.007772479206323624, 0.0016633950872346759, -0.07266076654195786, 0.04158661514520645, 0.08875500410795212, 0.03228994086384773, -0.03605733439326286, 0.03398420661687851, -0.05028773099184036, -0.07744971662759781, -0.010728511959314346, -0.00398147851228714, -0.03418935462832451, -0.04379943758249283, 0.0368744321167469, -0.024833079427480698, -0.03757961839437485, 0.06779029965400696, -0.004128902219235897, -0.0034085421357303858, 0.0020507080480456352, -0.054016802459955215, -0.031178956851363182, -0.004926071502268314, -0.027556229382753372, 0.010546117089688778, -0.019453706219792366, 0.005373710300773382, 0.03787378966808319, 0.01354703214019537, 0.01038307137787342, 0.07006707787513733, 0.02024018205702305, 0.022007472813129425, -0.020603585988283157, -0.02208729460835457, -0.025305891409516335, -0.03999585658311844, 0.007780943997204304, -0.007430446334183216, -0.08388052880764008, 0.005149308126419783, 0.002132844179868698, -0.010962856002151966, 0.011115717701613903, 0.05313548445701599, 0.019143324345350266, -0.04044712334871292, -0.0023636750411242247, 0.009139442816376686, -0.06053723022341728, 0.046199675649404526, 0.00034243211848661304, 0.05495148152112961, 0.011708568781614304, -0.021980704739689827, -0.025832105427980423, -0.023262619972229004, 0.06387287378311157, 0.04002926126122475, -0.015880195423960686, -0.04199078679084778, -0.016938667744398117, 0.051740862429142, 0.028918564319610596, -0.005726542789489031, -0.010713499039411545, -0.03151867911219597, 0.00009907639469020069, 0.02096807211637497, 0.05254887789487839, 0.016635430976748466, -0.026769982650876045, 0.004947916604578495, -0.05079452320933342, -0.024476928636431694, -0.03209651634097099, 0.023579442873597145, 0.004052168224006891, -0.007372382562607527, 0.04628744721412659, 0.0011803366942331195, 0.04057205840945244, 0.005388014949858189, -0.017325812950730324, -0.023912368342280388, -0.020611708983778954, 0.00674570444971323, -0.022845879197120667, -0.0100825484842062, 0.007277022581547499, 0.07735643535852432, -0.010459971614181995, 0.024395709857344627, 0.00041309584048576653, -0.05294504016637802, -0.019178012385964394, -0.033868458122015, -0.0007921746000647545, -0.01989125832915306, -0.0077035618014633656, 0.004622261039912701, -0.039245977997779846, -0.0117865651845932, -0.00005102652357891202, -0.04788431152701378, 0.03860010206699371, 0.09144482016563416, -0.02334325760602951, 0.01101201493293047, 0.013968942686915398, -0.01246012095361948, 0.004817442502826452, -0.007962658070027828, -0.00030046747997403145, -0.03708557039499283, -0.022856589406728745, 0.03178572282195091, 0.0016172906616702676, -0.04026583954691887, 0.049523454159498215, 0.0344279520213604, 0.012700371444225311, 0.03744659572839737, 0.03125210106372833, -0.02876267209649086, -0.0009531387477181852, 0.030349360778927803, 0.02666556090116501, 0.01532621867954731, 0.007386052515357733, 0.015095412731170654, 0.00493182148784399, 0.03879289701581001, -0.029389638453722, -0.011364656500518322, 0.08206053823232651, 0.018566370010375977, -0.008291741833090782, -0.03184914588928223, -0.044744111597537994, 0.05410198122262955, -0.003988563548773527, 0.030275121331214905, 0.004382695537060499, 0.015737995505332947, 0.010419661179184914, 0.023687470704317093, -0.018475262448191643, 0.039817165583372116, 0.02658483199775219, -0.04947642982006073, 0.03687034919857979, 0.03377591818571091, -0.057235751301050186, 0.04467366263270378, -0.03697013109922409, -0.015159515663981438, -0.01927874982357025, 0.01336953416466713, 0.004761192947626114, -0.015104020945727825, -0.007894850336015224, -0.009854092262685299, -0.0548577643930912, 0.04220186546444893, -0.00020718469750136137, 0.024579958990216255, 0.013077774085104465, -0.03037378191947937, 0.021723538637161255, 0.00288329366594553, -0.019009562209248543, 0.0015277750790119171, 0.017848873510956764, 0.0013644167920574546, 0.002624227898195386, -0.02602369152009487, -0.07315459102392197, -0.00483089592307806, 0.013099492527544498, 0.009908895008265972, -0.03621528297662735, 0.010544002056121826, 0.02312597818672657, 0.0389181487262249, 0.005739376414567232, -0.0016167009016498923, -0.02852231077849865, -0.03289185091853142, -0.062121037393808365, 0.006502826698124409, 0.025721479207277298, 0.006551441270858049, 0.050826095044612885, 0.07125437259674072, -0.03400465101003647, 0.01584399864077568, -0.09150422364473343, -0.021356310695409775, 0.0499933622777462, 0.019152916967868805, 0.020067449659109116, 0.0014409569557756186, -0.011373257264494896, 0.03852526471018791, 0.012768148444592953, -0.06370049715042114, 0.0014641378074884415, 0.0352788046002388, -0.01820930279791355, -0.034723177552223206, -0.0004583811096381396, -0.004385256674140692, -0.0032822422217577696, 0.025287166237831116, 0.02005777135491371, -0.01952291838824749, 0.0376957431435585, 0.05840500816702843, -0.01469472236931324, 0.04216324910521507, 0.016411682590842247, -0.023329313844442368, 0.016783688217401505, 0.03656534478068352, 0.0006053508841432631, -0.005850779823958874, 0.018564188852906227, 0.006333590019494295, -0.011100169271230698, -0.04188033193349838, 0.026337938383221626, 0.0034301932901144028, -0.007150980643928051, -0.062379688024520874, 0.03571787104010582, 0.06886021792888641, -0.02757204882800579, 0.017241664230823517, 0.03017907775938511, 0.04810655489563942, -0.02992151491343975, -0.005373996216803789, 0.06039941683411598, 0.003958158660680056, -0.01561294961720705, -0.01388468686491251, -0.021158698946237564, -0.010151995345950127, -0.017905665561556816, -0.02913070097565651, -0.013830373995006084, 0.010879497975111008, 0.008843823336064816, 0.011988870799541473, -0.01926129311323166, -0.023037562146782875, 0.011027449741959572, -0.016817158088088036, 0.027112524956464767, 0.009176750667393208, 0.022514518350362778, 0.018324559554457664, 0.0629330575466156, 0.02514052949845791, 0.015565716661512852, 0.0023612193763256073, -0.03341201692819595, -0.07948432117700577, 0.02072838693857193, -0.028528816998004913, -0.00884387269616127, -0.011908606626093388, -0.03454633429646492, 0.03749912604689598, -0.03671834245324135, 0.008436482399702072, -0.01006259210407734, 0.01368696428835392, -0.04016801714897156, 0.01466208603233099, -0.039054617285728455, -0.02496308833360672, 0.00439908541738987, -0.0038208686746656895, 0.025758372619748116, 0.011547673493623734, 0.010741322301328182, 0.04644034802913666, -0.00945387501269579, -0.013132086955010891, -0.02458012104034424, 0.011905556544661522, -0.028046535328030586, 0.042027413845062256, 0.01898810639977455, 0.04662945121526718, -0.03212674707174301, 0.030598346143960953, -0.02234739065170288, 0.06385857611894608, 0.0612567737698555, -0.019302699714899063, 0.0019095540046691895, 0.003100733971223235, -0.008738596923649311, -0.003995885606855154, 0.04298550635576248, -0.005836576223373413, -0.005622719880193472, 0.0374685637652874, 0.01098258700221777, -0.07462634891271591, 0.014652371406555176, 0.04354444891214371, 0.004894000943750143, -0.04504261538386345, -0.03797845169901848, 0.037823501974344254, -0.0007378436857834458, 0.006385708227753639, 0.00428528618067503, -0.003775589866563678, -0.0010766235645860434, -0.0015655923634767532, 0.023323260247707367, -0.050314173102378845, 0.007507608272135258, 0.003365844488143921, 0.010370742529630661, 0.044212400913238525, 0.030467186123132706, -0.020988671109080315, 0.015599713660776615, 0.05622377246618271, 0.034263890236616135, 0.018632162362337112, 0.005405607167631388, -0.09233240783214569, 0.017020944505929947, 0.03980107977986336, 0.03228317201137543, -0.00899545568972826, -0.01636049710214138, -0.015370974317193031, -0.01732131652534008, 0.06873062998056412, -0.008405132219195366, 0.0064737978391349316, 0.003639406291767955, -0.009551521390676498, -0.004931076895445585, 0.0007785350899212062, -0.057949088513851166, 0.020284676924347878, -0.017562296241521835, -0.00082443340215832, -0.03110828995704651, -0.009320694021880627, -0.056783806532621384, 0.003021419048309326, 0.00800695177167654, 0.07020893692970276, 0.016213787719607353, -0.03248737007379532, -0.004644983448088169, 0.016580479219555855, 0.018523763865232468, -0.06612249463796616, 0.04556315392255783, 0.012413742952048779, -0.0366143062710762, 0.027763543650507927, -0.012385541573166847, -0.03847388178110123, 0.07957031577825546, -0.007327938452363014, -0.004867343232035637, 0.01740269735455513, 0.003283547004684806, 0.04078146442770958, 0.006952842231839895, 0.03732413053512573, 0.04966924712061882, 0.010183161124587059, -0.0035291912499815226, -0.025725601240992546, -0.04829106479883194, 0.030333690345287323, -0.015482012182474136, -0.024167271330952644, -0.02800888940691948, 0.006717573385685682, 0.0088655985891819, 0.049339599907398224, 0.003788921982049942, 0.0279178898781538, -0.027246583253145218, -0.015735412016510963, -0.040885016322135925, 0.004804402124136686, 0.029633838683366776, -0.004545118194073439, 0.00501431105658412, -0.009184831753373146, 0.027989597991108894, 0.02280181273818016, 0.02117256075143814, -0.02761812135577202, 0.01489010825753212, -0.004349711816757917, -0.028429999947547913, 0.008358405902981758, -0.04224294051527977, -0.02378084883093834, 0.02539612166583538, -0.04489078372716904, 0.028356309980154037, -0.003143544774502516, 0.03300550952553749, 0.001214217976666987, -0.039030708372592926, -0.005308089777827263, 0.020468510687351227, 0.009280424565076828, 0.03374728560447693, -0.018010152503848076, 0.00010069653217215091, -0.02249932289123535, 0.0005011138273403049, -0.06117243319749832, -0.005688264034688473, 0.006532362662255764, -0.018381426110863686, -0.010567552410066128, -0.026852713897824287, 0.049824345856904984, -0.021833637729287148, -0.062733955681324, -0.013744046911597252, 0.029773574322462082, -0.008283743634819984, 0.009591189213097095, -0.01971491426229477, 0.025730358436703682, 0.038016434758901596, 0.009095409885048866, 0.0001929480058606714, 0.04878636822104454, -0.024651000276207924, 0.0027388078160583973, 0.017177831381559372, 0.0007688238983973861, -0.03625236824154854, 0.01198655180633068, -0.013695911504328251, 0.02060885913670063, 0.02669626660645008, -0.011941350996494293, 0.01373225636780262, 0.011218885891139507, -0.017932577058672905, -0.029213590547442436, 0.021360356360673904, -0.039620671421289444, 0.00016876644804142416, 0.010530342347919941, -0.009463261812925339, 0.0048176199197769165, 0.007292695343494415, 0.00032268636277876794, 0.06128779798746109, -0.03318318724632263, -0.0033322919625788927, -0.0014880039962008595, 0.04383664205670357, -0.02339302934706211, 0.03140455111861229, 0.0032085427083075047, 0.01674438826739788, 0.016371991485357285, -0.004255001433193684, -0.006777364294975996, 0.019747745245695114, 0.0068827285431325436, -0.03335672244429588, 0.009155298583209515, -0.06939002871513367, -0.019753245636820793, 0.09267480671405792, 0.032911788672208786, 0.061763472855091095, -0.00033883939613588154, -0.006947733461856842, -0.016120044514536858, -0.03706319257616997, -0.0358484648168087, -0.003343346528708935, 0.0018914527026936412, 0.06656777858734131, -0.03572670742869377, 0.0008066619629971683, 0.0223651435226202, -0.006748209707438946, -0.005582157988101244, 0.043746352195739746, -0.030728548765182495, 0.024511337280273438, 0.050735339522361755, -0.010730168782174587, -0.03703531250357628, 0.018391449004411697, -0.052151311188936234, -0.007226152345538139, -0.04336714744567871, -0.03303816169500351, 0.05200790613889694, 0.058987535536289215, -0.021205097436904907, -0.012575030326843262, 0.0005844482220709324, -0.012700982391834259, 0.03742407634854317, 0.03634842485189438, 0.022327004000544548, 0.018580719828605652, 0.017163904383778572, 0.046207793056964874, -0.025241035968065262, 0.03792642056941986, 0.005658370908349752, -0.043477095663547516, -0.04279055818915367, -0.014309504069387913, -0.030130332335829735, 0.018536686897277832, 0.0023426515981554985, -0.012467125430703163, 0.019178159534931183, -0.03392862156033516, 0.03510141745209694, -0.005382932256907225, 0.04921384155750275, -0.0311739481985569, 0.07206050306558609, -0.02419915981590748, 0.004227058496326208, 0.0019980526994913816, -0.007342433091253042, 0.11211998760700226, 0.06243465468287468, 0.06047884002327919, -0.05365382134914398, -0.0030981041491031647, -0.006657441146671772, -0.036859553307294846, -0.0554099902510643, 0.022472642362117767, 0.006907429546117783, -0.04312179237604141, 0.019600171595811844, 0.049505941569805145, 0.015575673431158066, 0.03271260857582092, 0.05973038077354431, -0.019436640664935112, -0.03326299414038658, -0.003000034485012293, 0.012014292180538177, -0.04385942220687866, -0.023913055658340454, -0.03155538812279701, 0.03011545166373253, -0.025959782302379608, -0.010366719216108322, -0.03391213342547417, -0.04524407908320427, -0.004787499085068703, -0.010715160518884659, 0.020734356716275215, -0.02419300004839897, 0.044250551611185074, 0.0021218650508672, 0.031835395842790604, -0.011026917025446892, 0.02320941351354122, 0.013734458014369011, 0.028229111805558205, 0.02537214756011963, -0.01610008254647255, 0.012979933060705662, 0.0026795186568051577, -0.007370069157332182, -0.025851111859083176, -0.04312394559383392, -0.007962477393448353, 0.04435402899980545, 0.03330707177519798, 0.01785910874605179, -0.025251854211091995, 0.006020345725119114, -0.004036369733512402, -0.035163357853889465, 0.013889886438846588, -0.0050477334298193455, 0.04522321745753288, -0.03144277259707451, -0.010006627067923546, 0.0018207567045465112, -0.0025524140801280737, -0.0013847091468051076, 0.05311506614089012, -0.019699955359101295, -0.0375213623046875, -0.013799347914755344, -0.023632485419511795, 0.029785072430968285, 0.008231463842093945, -0.022121673449873924, -0.005806716158986092, -0.04119962081313133, 0.012656375765800476, -0.028501762077212334, 0.04964735358953476, -0.021296916529536247, 0.015701016411185265, 0.0063896141946315765, -0.0033295333851128817, -0.015866298228502274, -0.08661580085754395, 0.016747185960412025, -0.03795180097222328, -0.01664866879582405, -0.04703664034605026, 0.00856406893581152, 0.04345184192061424, 0.05024909973144531, 0.027735231444239616, -0.01010893564671278, -0.02014022134244442, 0.06838222593069077, 0.03652942180633545, -0.02602948434650898, -0.036744341254234314, 0.0032870625145733356, -0.01328108087182045, 0.012536306865513325, -0.029276641085743904, 0.05370379611849785, 0.02340622805058956, 0.050748106092214584, -0.009835214354097843, 0.03415316715836525, -0.010302938520908356, 0.020116232335567474, 0.000498934939969331, -0.06887628883123398, -0.00875280424952507, 0.005708287004381418, 0.006749456282705069, -0.003401176305487752, -0.023180345073342323, -0.0064237420447170734, -0.021436257287859917, 0.003637943184003234, -0.01258053071796894, -0.014126637950539589, -0.02257010154426098, -0.00198812666349113, 0.020899726077914238, -0.018210425972938538, 0.00040976505260914564, 0.02495364286005497, 0.006340683437883854, -0.005507470574229956, 0.026767617091536522, -0.007871984504163265, 0.01120226364582777, -0.03712081164121628, 0.0080606359988451, 0.016434650868177414, 0.022741330787539482, 0.01969778537750244, 0.000874821562319994, 0.004682803526520729, -0.003314524656161666, 0.040425874292850494, 0.0008059716783463955, -0.020695634186267853, 0.02086690068244934, -0.04914126917719841, -0.03249362111091614, 0.014070513658225536, 0.019561639055609703, 0.07733411341905594, 0.04278862848877907, -0.009820356033742428, -0.02834116294980049, 0.013838606886565685, -0.027221975848078728, -0.0181030984967947, 0.027478788048028946, 0.005739344749599695, -0.019682638347148895, 0.017757486552000046, 0.006855236366391182, 0.004194785840809345, 0.008261838927865028, 0.019396822899580002, 0.01726628467440605, 0.027862675487995148, -0.026024408638477325, 0.03771645575761795, 0.013837413862347603, 0.025859354063868523, 0.0039037368260324, 0.010685036890208721, 0.030483918264508247, 0.05909644812345505, -0.01566537842154503, 0.051161762326955795, 0.019642019644379616, 0.015872441232204437, -0.07212802767753601, -0.02766752429306507, 0.014483809471130371, -0.004913894459605217, 0.06356925517320633, -0.0504954494535923, 0.006939388345927, 0.017214689403772354, -0.0447559729218483, 0.013762231916189194, 0.03871121257543564, 0.0006742675905115902, -0.02965163066983223, 0.01667977124452591, 0.002819649875164032, 0.06316224485635757, 0.01704803667962551, 0.01295341644436121, 0.035197265446186066, 0.017787296324968338, -0.014532031491398811, -0.040029607713222504, -0.03242538496851921, 0.031558550894260406, 0.025667743757367134, -0.051923561841249466, 0.04443513602018356, -0.06187406927347183, -0.07801578938961029, 0.03004542924463749, 0.05702798441052437, -0.023133113980293274, -0.010739440098404884, 0.047094523906707764, 0.01252712868154049, 0.042907483875751495, 0.04671340808272362, 0.0019402075558900833, -0.0026085616555064917, 0.011494242586195469, 0.027809811756014824, 0.007781225256621838, -0.051223933696746826, -0.004812648054212332, 0.01957664079964161, -0.018628843128681183, -0.02775505557656288, 0.00263857189565897, -0.0005772626609541476, -0.06597868353128433, 0.0006973728304728866, -0.04144194349646568, -0.01248134020715952, -0.03289668634533882, 0.011017976328730583, -0.08103375881910324, -0.014234401285648346, 0.054932717233896255, 0.0211214330047369, -0.0016905914526432753, 0.01320738811045885, 0.005185597576200962, -0.060998279601335526, 0.01805218681693077, -0.0012464058818295598, -0.02591155841946602, -0.07352814078330994, 0.01718057319521904, 0.012256726622581482, -0.005991797428578138, -0.023552732542157173, -0.0022315774112939835, -0.05667999014258385, 0.011085271835327148, -0.05539701506495476, 0.007511473260819912, 0.0031068280804902315, -0.008952983655035496, 0.015926958993077278, -0.051627956330776215, 0.015306861139833927, 0.03544292598962784, -0.040374014526605606, -0.009387143887579441, 0.02631021849811077, -0.012273622676730156, -0.014417199417948723, 0.054655175656080246, -0.004250490106642246, 0.002087567001581192, -0.015021855011582375, 0.044567327946424484, 0.035216785967350006, -0.0808488205075264, 0.00791469868272543, -0.05786982551217079, -0.04551330953836441, -0.007088230457156897, -0.013258600607514381, 0.018408669158816338, 0.027694564312696457, 0.03634026646614075, -0.013885562308132648, -0.01717809960246086, 0.015963762998580933, -0.001770796487107873, 0.01627665013074875, -0.0068952664732933044, -0.0006058210856281221, 0.04630658030509949, -0.035302385687828064, 0.023729635402560234, 0.0036515879910439253, 0.019050372764468193, -0.03959215059876442, 0.01300935260951519, -0.037045542150735855, -0.05804934352636337, 0.002661237958818674, 0.020877143368124962, 0.01623241789638996, -0.05061750486493111, -0.008745245635509491, 0.023930607363581657, -0.06507578492164612, 0.0116988280788064, 0.03138131648302078, 0.005682652350515127, 0.03298958018422127, 0.020125862210989, 0.013474133796989918, 0.03378355875611305, -0.008673477917909622, 0.005856975447386503, 0.022619176656007767, 0.044745396822690964, -0.042587924748659134, -0.004400693345814943, 0.0014081113040447235, -0.043202947825193405, 0.04065219685435295, -0.05431200563907623, 0.04186490550637245, -0.02241428568959236, -0.034499119967222214, -0.010568147525191307, 0.0020589912310242653, -0.022017380222678185, -0.04329701140522957, 0.005826545413583517, 0.0597945898771286, -0.036990001797676086, -0.01889374665915966, -0.04208998754620552, -0.021406225860118866, -0.02435075119137764, 0.024627313017845154, 0.009818054735660553, 0.02416573092341423, -0.014539675787091255, 0.027662184089422226, -0.0050674304366111755, -0.03664521127939224, 0.014925344847142696, -0.02555014193058014, 0.008359351195394993, -0.014415964484214783, -0.015755660831928253, 0.023206526413559914, -0.021397020667791367, -0.04668256267905235, -0.02485317550599575, -0.007717781700193882, 0.020668014883995056, 0.034853510558605194, -0.0307303536683321, -0.008355227299034595, -0.017461488023400307, 0.005366864614188671, -0.05106814205646515, -0.006502636708319187, -0.019306212663650513, -0.031573254615068436, 0.014094521291553974, -0.011687266640365124 ]
<p>I try to fit a model of the following form $$ Y = (\beta X - Z)^+ + \epsilon, $$ where $Y,Z \ge 0$ and $X,Y,Z \in \mathbb{R}$ and $(x)^+ = \max(x,0)$. Note that $Y,X$ and $Z$ come from a sample, especially $Z$ is not a constant. I did this in R in the following way: <pre><code> positivePart&lt;- function(x){ x[x&lt;0]&lt;-0 return(x) } my.optim = nls(y~ positivePart(beta*x-z) , start = list(beta=5)) </pre></code> I am getting good results, this is not the problem.</p> <p>My question: is there a name, a class for this kind of model? If so, which R function is the natural candidate to solve this problem, ie. to formulate the model in R? Thank you!</p>
49,070
[ -0.002736408030614257, -0.013640725053846836, 0.0013175236526876688, 0.007510645315051079, 0.019196460023522377, 0.011164610274136066, -0.02092037722468376, -0.009425000287592411, 0.02902810648083687, -0.023691050708293915, 0.015882669016718864, 0.045865729451179504, 0.08080273121595383, 0.019860681146383286, 0.01732366532087326, 0.019543245434761047, -0.03149285539984703, 0.006979434285312891, -0.04894205182790756, 0.015163795091211796, -0.007756167557090521, 0.02613399177789688, 0.033016882836818695, 0.003314352361485362, -0.012322602793574333, 0.03707924485206604, 0.02017151191830635, 0.023608092218637466, -0.017252705991268158, 0.04113687202334404, -0.029082581400871277, -0.018391422927379608, 0.014994910918176174, 0.04912814870476723, 0.028749477118253708, 0.005204871762543917, -0.033088576048612595, -0.047242309898138046, -0.024848125874996185, 0.019794180989265442, 0.00507689081132412, 0.0059373346157372, 0.015177758410573006, 0.01856190152466297, -0.04670092836022377, 0.009355811402201653, -0.025109056383371353, -0.024539653211832047, 0.050920017063617706, -0.02920670621097088, 0.06128571182489395, -0.0024256862234324217, 0.00448879087343812, 0.013828559778630733, -0.011483819223940372, -0.04086047038435936, 0.04373203217983246, 0.08541813492774963, -0.003254206385463476, -0.043358802795410156, -0.04048925265669823, -0.026226086542010307, 0.010972432792186737, -0.03255779296159744, -0.025757528841495514, -0.010290633887052536, -0.002504413714632392, -0.020453322678804398, 0.014262345619499683, 0.011348534375429153, 0.006477497052401304, 0.01421383861452341, 0.01370399259030819, -0.026349244639277458, 0.00884218979626894, -0.019732940942049026, -0.021914998069405556, 0.01246831938624382, -0.006546241231262684, 0.010675106197595596, -0.02558819018304348, -0.0022422929760068655, 0.002352967858314514, 0.02481810562312603, -0.02582527883350849, -0.022079870104789734, 0.06929207593202591, -0.038113784044981, 0.005503340624272823, 0.028216304257512093, -0.03734780102968216, -0.006206123623996973, 0.07124961167573929, 0.0034509433899074793, -0.047597575932741165, 0.02754628285765648, 0.01289060153067112, 0.02436426281929016, 0.026483289897441864, 0.0017270443495362997, 0.007601357996463776, -0.05473247915506363, -0.045910581946372986, 0.05969419702887535, -0.035071343183517456, -0.0406477265059948, -0.013900083489716053, -0.05308477208018303, 0.014230869710445404, -0.0016901504714041948, -0.04288513585925102, 0.02506442368030548, 0.012679425068199635, 0.0004824261413887143, 0.030400700867176056, -0.02882017008960247, -0.0207370612770319, -0.00946319755166769, 0.03008408285677433, 0.032293010503053665, 0.04841122776269913, -0.025717999786138535, 0.04610779508948326, -0.010235382243990898, -0.030505957081913948, 0.013832513242959976, 0.022217366844415665, -0.01191340759396553, -0.028177114203572273, 0.04490414634346962, 0.008798444643616676, -0.031822871416807175, 0.05901828780770302, 0.003803528379648924, 0.07985445111989975, -0.01563205197453499, -0.038038820028305054, -0.04379621520638466, 0.012612217105925083, -0.03502894937992096, 0.006963206920772791, -0.0257113054394722, -0.015637902542948723, 0.043642155826091766, 0.0727059617638588, 0.029420923441648483, 0.02520069293677807, 0.018278535455465317, 0.03143885359168053, 0.012263590469956398, -0.03274046629667282, -0.011869979090988636, -0.061463456600904465, -0.022064806893467903, -0.030787328258156776, -0.057088710367679596, 0.03807510435581207, -0.02325955592095852, -0.0029330819379538298, -0.003824047278612852, 0.03914257511496544, -0.010037796571850777, -0.0011306068627163768, -0.015520073473453522, -0.005425032693892717, -0.025247721001505852, 0.08759168535470963, 0.009919163770973682, 0.026882529258728027, 0.023380571976304054, -0.008756277151405811, 0.03291931003332138, 0.035713642835617065, 0.053357116878032684, 0.05010005459189415, -0.024459555745124817, -0.01956816576421261, -0.022308509796857834, 0.03449322655797005, 0.04638693109154701, -0.03697160631418228, -0.03326794505119324, -0.01908651739358902, -0.006958083249628544, -0.01470545306801796, 0.035920001566410065, -0.0007777140708640218, -0.023950954899191856, 0.04928964003920555, -0.037788085639476776, -0.0008214999106712639, -0.04183148220181465, -0.00028998556081205606, -0.004818376619368792, 0.03242180868983269, 0.015088126994669437, 0.02975529059767723, 0.022790001705288887, 0.0029512448236346245, -0.021867047995328903, -0.04513471573591232, -0.011618834920227528, 0.05137203261256218, -0.0031302361749112606, -0.006882594432681799, 0.03227218613028526, 0.04515952989459038, -0.023504601791501045, 0.04962558671832085, -0.041050802916288376, -0.036198459565639496, -0.02236512303352356, -0.009586318396031857, 0.04015848785638809, 0.017027121037244797, -0.005327290389686823, 0.005259022582322359, -0.025843936949968338, 0.004763117525726557, 0.03226485475897789, -0.052440788596868515, 0.055673230439424515, 0.11506067961454391, 0.0037472464609891176, -0.011034620925784111, -0.03826498985290527, 0.006284821778535843, 0.05268790200352669, -0.04302133992314339, -0.014378695748746395, -0.041283901780843735, 0.020211145281791687, 0.0684797614812851, 0.012792503461241722, -0.06469137221574783, -0.005655259825289249, 0.047267086803913116, -0.018615249544382095, 0.030911603942513466, 0.06816352903842926, -0.028383422642946243, -0.0028212890028953552, 0.0007933761808089912, 0.016268519684672356, 0.035536959767341614, 0.024546192958950996, 0.04634952172636986, -0.009923410601913929, 0.043093081563711166, -0.018871352076530457, -0.03203859552741051, 0.023155657574534416, 0.04135634005069733, -0.0030269084963947535, -0.040715157985687256, -0.037660956382751465, 0.03741075471043587, -0.019713660702109337, 0.04594840481877327, 0.05599947273731232, 0.010940104722976685, 0.0008403203682973981, 0.0049799904227256775, 0.010542608797550201, -0.013728267513215542, 0.07747412472963333, -0.034637439996004105, 0.007564823143184185, 0.02653668075799942, -0.04653407260775566, 0.014000661671161652, 0.012266757898032665, -0.025384075939655304, -0.04954126104712486, 0.005764708388596773, 0.019499091431498528, 0.056793853640556335, 0.019875893369317055, -0.015403499826788902, -0.02138068526983261, 0.014609443955123425, -0.01498295646160841, 0.06784292310476303, 0.007975022308528423, -0.05859433487057686, -0.012056982144713402, -0.02256014756858349, -0.03218501806259155, 0.014334622770547867, 0.015792684629559517, -0.009399376809597015, 0.018504537642002106, -0.04725858196616173, -0.03413259610533714, -0.012855658307671547, -0.028890404850244522, 0.002860213164240122, -0.012757811695337296, -0.010031664744019508, 0.06294553726911545, 0.01615355908870697, -0.0581667497754097, 0.0395953394472599, -0.06629551947116852, -0.018107252195477486, -0.06945747882127762, -0.009482039138674736, 0.03238234668970108, -0.0011284752981737256, 0.05322445556521416, 0.03301553428173065, -0.011556824669241905, 0.015452530235052109, -0.05019782483577728, -0.04670308530330658, -0.01062759105116129, 0.004148827865719795, -0.006806941237300634, 0.04257708042860031, 0.000922233157325536, 0.08746974915266037, 0.042160313576459885, -0.01207686122506857, -0.06382856518030167, 0.014474255964159966, -0.022337911650538445, -0.016553405672311783, 0.02531285770237446, 0.00842025876045227, 0.03137894719839096, 0.005474351812154055, -0.02304544486105442, 0.024551931768655777, 0.043924376368522644, 0.0012631837744265795, 0.012517713010311127, 0.014133647084236145, -0.03147979825735092, -0.030489852651953697, 0.020926458761096, 0.014345774427056313, -0.018887022510170937, 0.016757791861891747, -0.01614389941096306, -0.0013546883128583431, -0.0020645693875849247, -0.04419118911027908, 0.010342709720134735, -0.004798642825335264, -0.000020206765839247964, 0.0132983960211277, 0.03350258246064186, -0.007397673092782497, -0.06666821986436844, -0.03507702425122261, 0.030955607071518898, 0.02059796079993248, -0.0024862405844032764, -0.01575508899986744, 0.005227581597864628, -0.0027869255281984806, -0.0292060524225235, 0.0182975884526968, -0.033779483288526535, -0.010849805548787117, 0.009460849687457085, 0.008360286243259907, -0.03482310473918915, 0.04095782712101936, 0.01671857386827469, 0.009549213573336601, 0.01703045330941677, -0.039392367005348206, 0.008426748216152191, -0.050952646881341934, 0.012833552435040474, -0.047515589743852615, 0.039113715291023254, 0.028764700517058372, 0.010793075896799564, -0.011457747779786587, 0.011625259183347225, 0.07407630234956741, 0.004792380146682262, -0.06459901481866837, 0.044722869992256165, -0.012471569702029228, 0.00881191622465849, -0.051797062158584595, 0.010190942324697971, 0.04020959883928299, -0.026191258803009987, 0.017508521676063538, -0.00840621255338192, -0.0005761495558544993, -0.039413973689079285, -0.011977330781519413, -0.027993444353342056, 0.008561260998249054, 0.03563614562153816, 0.02682814933359623, 0.012065637856721878, -0.04657556861639023, 0.012569270096719265, 0.023775363340973854, -0.0057723610661923885, -0.007980447262525558, -0.02238558605313301, 0.016006948426365852, 0.025144819170236588, 0.011569048278033733, 0.01852494850754738, 0.05679069459438324, -0.0008882021065801382, 0.03544756397604942, -0.048642706125974655, 0.03236832469701767, 0.048700883984565735, 0.03177516162395477, -0.038425128906965256, -0.02879868634045124, 0.020457612350583076, 0.022248348221182823, 0.013160142116248608, 0.03214217349886894, 0.01383511908352375, 0.04404778778553009, 0.023829184472560883, -0.019611496478319168, -0.03302685171365738, 0.06721854209899902, 0.0068512000143527985, 0.0008748813415877521, -0.005954965483397245, 0.039747584611177444, -0.007456541061401367, 0.011711034923791885, -0.01343176793307066, 0.011789128184318542, -0.005960374604910612, -0.001046678051352501, 0.01951960101723671, -0.026298264041543007, -0.004442138597369194, 0.026363499462604523, 0.015362691134214401, 0.02748204953968525, -0.018682807683944702, -0.018955979496240616, -0.0017212730599567294, 0.03237990289926529, 0.03615567088127136, 0.02549140714108944, -0.007348758168518543, -0.0740724578499794, -0.00042904322617687285, 0.023165062069892883, 0.025496236979961395, -0.03203750401735306, 0.011561773717403412, -0.03740968555212021, -0.03395801782608032, 0.055993445217609406, -0.02798854559659958, 0.008476735092699528, -0.010980408638715744, -0.009278473444283009, -0.0031672522891312838, -0.007041552569717169, -0.06852875649929047, -0.027697019279003143, -0.018922440707683563, 0.02380453422665596, -0.011566723696887493, -0.015629632398486137, -0.03332383185625076, -0.001930782338604331, -0.03496652469038963, 0.0650286078453064, -0.013450915925204754, -0.0264915619045496, 0.03334072604775429, 0.029284214600920677, -0.007995479740202427, -0.04931553825736046, -0.0033654929138720036, 0.055191148072481155, -0.004291741643100977, 0.02617637999355793, 0.005795522127300501, -0.05624697357416153, 0.015048934146761894, -0.016252562403678894, -0.00875384546816349, 0.01700267381966114, -0.024984085932374, 0.02521764673292637, 0.06953977793455124, 0.00554353091865778, 0.05116690322756767, 0.03682570159435272, -0.0011859850492328405, -0.01912858337163925, -0.03081071563065052, 0.00621529808267951, -0.005324332043528557, -0.02205316163599491, -0.06576836109161377, -0.015952881425619125, -0.05386780574917793, 0.033576600253582, -0.013149432837963104, 0.026315711438655853, -0.04553113505244255, -0.017151065170764923, 0.017108570784330368, 0.009638456627726555, -0.027933405712246895, -0.006963782012462616, -0.010083360597491264, -0.0028222166001796722, 0.04408937320113182, -0.012480078265070915, 0.0205220989882946, -0.012324195355176926, -0.005100045818835497, 0.048923809081315994, -0.02436734549701214, -0.00839184783399105, -0.005404523108154535, -0.016222696751356125, 0.03564469888806343, -0.008393791504204273, 0.02654392458498478, 0.019426319748163223, 0.009735961444675922, 0.007290706504136324, -0.03838859125971794, -0.043680328875780106, 0.03379864618182182, -0.005697078071534634, -0.020914342254400253, -0.025538818910717964, 0.03195540979504585, 0.011526325717568398, 0.012828245759010315, -0.055591925978660583, -0.083107128739357, 0.01842098869383335, -0.029343001544475555, -0.03142455592751503, -0.05460689589381218, -0.0017041582614183426, 0.0005624729092232883, -0.030701717361807823, 0.0022423507180064917, 0.025125160813331604, -0.02345847710967064, 0.003205610904842615, -0.02783406339585781, -0.004892182070761919, 0.06337195634841919, -0.0012998743914067745, 0.011387854814529419, 0.017722412943840027, 0.004241377580910921, 0.0040950654074549675, 0.039266955107450485, 0.0035542442928999662, -0.02971477247774601, -0.025820260867476463, -0.011693509295582771, 0.014698446728289127, 0.029238445684313774, -0.019991442561149597, 0.002600480569526553, 0.0226656012237072, -0.013212766498327255, 0.006390682887285948, -0.02631102316081524, -0.014816324226558208, -0.03136071935296059, -0.03612304851412773, -0.005376144777983427, -0.026228908449411392, 0.0012721340171992779, -0.02102496288716793, 0.05655421316623688, -0.013571602292358875, -0.017841694876551628, 0.01880755089223385, 0.06261684000492096, 0.028523655608296394, -0.01508337538689375, 0.0017456318018957973, -0.0400034599006176, 0.03576751425862312, 0.032179392874240875, 0.003275173483416438, 0.01336819026619196, 0.05807800963521004, -0.06703522056341171, -0.04697265848517418, -0.04220540449023247, 0.004700383637100458, 0.03328997269272804, -0.027050942182540894, 0.036125633865594864, 0.04136292636394501, -0.017782317474484444, -0.008944437839090824, -0.009696218185126781, -0.019615402445197105, 0.0013855930883437395, 0.01337558962404728, 0.0670517086982727, -0.01394906546920538, 0.03458947315812111, 0.0037160818465054035, 0.02324911393225193, 0.014236625283956528, 0.06193561851978302, -0.011306650005280972, 0.02640262246131897, 0.046901509165763855, -0.021214423701167107, -0.037993159145116806, 0.021346915513277054, -0.03092069737613201, 0.016549257561564445, -0.054128143936395645, -0.04748820513486862, 0.016189396381378174, 0.029219847172498703, 0.03475247323513031, -0.06621511280536652, -0.014644687995314598, -0.043224308639764786, -0.006038101855665445, 0.03884902969002724, -0.009421983733773232, 0.07405049353837967, 0.014203114435076714, 0.0073814308270812035, -0.0034778499975800514, 0.05789346992969513, -0.04256216436624527, -0.06113268807530403, -0.0011891830945387483, -0.052757080644369125, -0.053817082196474075, -0.0019742718432098627, 0.029789874330163002, 0.0011913188500329852, -0.004691120237112045, -0.046420805156230927, 0.006737747695297003, 0.000007202204869827256, 0.047357987612485886, 0.005166586022824049, 0.06390440464019775, -0.02400733344256878, -0.003953024744987488, -0.006841298658400774, 0.006009247153997421, 0.13044355809688568, 0.08745720982551575, 0.06443322449922562, -0.09234249591827393, 0.016422824934124947, 0.008625856600701809, -0.02179770916700363, -0.003843260696157813, 0.014840256422758102, 0.018132776021957397, -0.025578046217560768, 0.03515734523534775, 0.06673937290906906, -0.0033386240247637033, 0.008294081315398216, 0.04673261195421219, -0.057516176253557205, -0.0030216185841709375, 0.033532269299030304, -0.009093192405998707, -0.0026117651723325253, -0.01844749040901661, -0.07313954085111618, 0.02581666223704815, 0.032210785895586014, -0.062831811606884, -0.01940092071890831, -0.025669578462839127, 0.007566159125417471, 0.007275344803929329, -0.0021546317730098963, 0.023955345153808594, -0.02305038459599018, 0.006625929847359657, 0.017284300178289413, -0.01681291125714779, 0.023754175752401352, 0.001961141126230359, 0.0292684156447649, 0.07245535403490067, -0.004496243316680193, 0.027203721925616264, 0.008718705736100674, -0.0006433019880205393, -0.014578171074390411, -0.019175367429852486, -0.04340514913201332, 0.02701365202665329, -0.00023281556786969304, 0.002899112645536661, 0.016257237643003464, 0.011734291911125183, 0.045306701213121414, -0.04314803704619408, -0.02451709285378456, 0.01386397983878851, 0.029174864292144775, -0.014331359416246414, 0.007498092018067837, -0.00003210128488717601, 0.01941869594156742, 0.015939950942993164, -0.0038320221938192844, 0.026676476001739502, -0.047897785902023315, -0.00033228599932044744, -0.021787725389003754, 0.04616975039243698, -0.007867111824452877, -0.010380464605987072, 0.07439395785331726, -0.009186221286654472, -0.016029730439186096, 0.010019339621067047, 0.009639190509915352, -0.013524207286536694, 0.007481096778064966, -0.02680179476737976, -0.01443090196698904, -0.024229902774095535, -0.02688189037144184, 0.01635311357676983, -0.044841136783361435, -0.020961107686161995, -0.0232040174305439, -0.012560328468680382, 0.017246834933757782, 0.05717708542943001, -0.018470948562026024, 0.0009258423815481365, -0.04164782911539078, 0.05597752332687378, 0.0003214688040316105, -0.058299679309129715, -0.013326085172593594, 0.011967258527874947, -0.0430389903485775, 0.020937077701091766, -0.01903892681002617, 0.08092731982469559, 0.018089301884174347, 0.016326652839779854, -0.023600632324814796, 0.028399916365742683, -0.023229679092764854, 0.03218579664826393, -0.001324361888691783, -0.039178166538476944, 0.03564038127660751, -0.012272555381059647, 0.008881596848368645, -0.05134091153740883, 0.00790049135684967, -0.018723975867033005, -0.016300324350595474, -0.0026611860375851393, -0.0015528213698416948, -0.0111751863732934, 0.029144495725631714, 0.0023807219695299864, -0.04385318607091904, -0.03576686233282089, 0.012059434317052364, -0.006453513167798519, 0.006096280179917812, -0.0011967094615101814, 0.004309223964810371, -0.014536949805915356, -0.0017450540326535702, -0.010507894679903984, -0.04169837385416031, 0.0186164528131485, 0.00036459375405684114, 0.013013288378715515, 0.01587711088359356, 0.01528905238956213, 0.01571480929851532, 0.026646669954061508, -0.042103156447410583, -0.0038875225000083447, 0.018345758318901062, -0.08429444581270218, -0.04736688360571861, 0.017292901873588562, -0.01547972671687603, 0.03585679084062576, 0.0005275056464597583, 0.015086594969034195, -0.018929027020931244, 0.022008318454027176, 0.008213181048631668, -0.020591046661138535, -0.014292503707110882, 0.0008663565386086702, -0.015501669608056545, -0.028362950310111046, -0.023062286898493767, 0.04001447930932045, -0.03525467962026596, 0.021433686837553978, 0.029316943138837814, -0.018810462206602097, 0.0028720891568809748, 0.01596478931605816, -0.025279412046074867, 0.0010989061556756496, 0.0015488177305087447, 0.005717579275369644, 0.03721068799495697, 0.02335391752421856, -0.049366578459739685, 0.03957240656018257, -0.01835738867521286, -0.00590010080486536, -0.07895918935537338, 0.0011381128570064902, 0.011018806137144566, 0.0038791687693446875, 0.0349888876080513, -0.07644227147102356, 0.042553097009658813, -0.03465019166469574, -0.017984043806791306, 0.022443603724241257, 0.01743938773870468, 0.007859247736632824, -0.02893412858247757, -0.0029801789205521345, -0.010446843691170216, -0.01822243072092533, 0.03649337589740753, 0.0447772853076458, 0.04151291772723198, -0.004177205730229616, -0.027188556268811226, -0.018009008839726448, 0.01929725706577301, -0.015470491722226143, -0.013595923781394958, -0.041738033294677734, 0.06224433332681656, -0.03967020660638809, -0.04590238630771637, 0.04345416650176048, 0.007937883026897907, 0.0019149986328557134, 0.02295132540166378, 0.03327477350831032, 0.011822895146906376, 0.06675750762224197, 0.046022165566682816, -0.017926573753356934, -0.01640637405216694, -0.0226063784211874, 0.02715439349412918, 0.009786690585315228, -0.015651123598217964, 0.03331061080098152, 0.014377251267433167, 0.0467715784907341, -0.05034708231687546, 0.01688908040523529, 0.011050849221646786, -0.03569573163986206, -0.00410018116235733, -0.018607379868626595, -0.014887787401676178, -0.049257099628448486, -0.046143583953380585, -0.05019717290997505, 0.03554428368806839, 0.05357462540268898, 0.0029976677615195513, -0.02876441739499569, -0.02141093648970127, -0.010584977455437183, -0.07548531889915466, 0.02630496583878994, -0.003935123793780804, 0.0010352913523092866, -0.033522095531225204, -0.016147904098033905, 0.018043577671051025, -0.047206588089466095, -0.004461949225515127, -0.018138548359274864, 0.009072165004909039, 0.03211485221982002, -0.06272117793560028, 0.029873676598072052, 0.007061594631522894, -0.008251896128058434, 0.027233866974711418, -0.06308755278587341, 0.06331359595060349, -0.024005204439163208, 0.025152448564767838, 0.001954595325514674, 0.017635732889175415, -0.008478408679366112, -0.01881747879087925, 0.05505404248833656, -0.005449260585010052, -0.015334127470850945, 0.008426720276474953, 0.02051113173365593, 0.007883804850280285, -0.03756255283951759, 0.029615046456456184, 0.01328838337212801, -0.047434329986572266, -0.018809502944350243, 0.009072058834135532, 0.019304240122437477, 0.02639664337038994, 0.010346643626689911, 0.00782226212322712, -0.021656112745404243, -0.029210006818175316, -0.03514259308576584, 0.02398882806301117, 0.004492136184126139, 0.007449776865541935, 0.03354142978787422, 0.001178103033453226, 0.025840209797024727, 0.020203791558742523, -0.0057395161129534245, -0.051294129341840744, 0.006743808276951313, -0.008088236674666405, -0.061204344034194946, 0.005826203152537346, -0.01672874391078949, -0.004591593984514475, -0.051136113703250885, -0.016237827017903328, 0.0393899641931057, -0.030134497210383415, 0.000896687270142138, 0.03501451015472412, -0.015554270707070827, 0.03852799907326698, -0.043627720326185226, -0.015187135897576809, -0.006611458957195282, 0.011590765789151192, -0.0046508656814694405, -0.0008506454760208726, 0.01468303706496954, -0.02447950467467308, 0.023421628400683403, 0.012764651328325272, 0.016408605501055717, 0.02042657695710659, 0.006782843731343746, 0.0364493690431118, 0.008210740052163601, 0.003323020413517952, 0.02676384150981903, -0.03004412166774273, 0.013272644020617008, -0.01351859699934721, 0.004823260009288788, 0.07925795763731003, -0.04610660672187805, 0.03376161307096481, -0.02147800661623478, 0.0017969007603824139, -0.03267454355955124, 0.014275452122092247, -0.02060660533607006, -0.019970636814832687, 0.022557074204087257, -0.005461371969431639, 0.01538991928100586, -0.030305929481983185, 0.04235835000872612, -0.041282426565885544, -0.013138976879417896, -0.008423807099461555, -0.002962957601994276, 0.028946997597813606, -0.0357290580868721, -0.028218405321240425, -0.028912141919136047, 0.03784354776144028, 0.057691559195518494, 0.024580618366599083, -0.02505011297762394, -0.009864578023552895, -0.004030757583677769, 0.03704538941383362, -0.07767146080732346, 0.0035558280069381, 0.012928446754813194, -0.022186899557709694, -0.015243242494761944, -0.004116091411560774 ]
<p><em><strong>Task:</strong></em><br> I have e.g. 1 control group and 7 experimental groups which are treated differently. All groups have a dependent <strong>binomial</strong> variable: 1 = success, 0 = no success. </p> <p>I want to conduct <strong>sequential tests</strong>, which version is "performing" better, between the control group and the experimental groups and stop the tests, when one of the experimental group is better that the control group (or it is proven, that the Null hypothesis is true). </p> <p><strong><em>Problem:</em></strong><br> So in my opinion <strong>two problems</strong> arise: <strong>alpha I error inflation</strong> by <strong>sequential testing</strong> and alpha I error inflation by testing <strong>multiple hypothesis</strong> (per timepoint)</p> <p><strong><em>My research so far:</em></strong><br> I found <strong>group sequential methods</strong>, <strong>Alpha-Spending approaches</strong> and <strong>SPRT</strong> to solve the sequential testing problem. And I read the <strong>sequential updating approach of Bayesian Methods</strong> in the book of Kruschke.</p> <p>For the multiple hypothesis testing (per time), there are some techniques which control the overall alpha error rate (per time), like <strong>Bonferroni</strong>, <strong>Hochberg's step-up procedure</strong> and others.</p> <p>But I <strong>haven't found how to combine the methods</strong>. Nevertheless, group sequential methods as well as Alpha-Spending approaches seem to be a bit inflexible. SPRT und Bayesian Updating seem to fit best for the need to have a small sample number, being able to test after every participant and not to have a predefined endpoint of the study.</p> <p><strong>Bayesian updating</strong> (with ROPE), as far a I know, does <strong>not</strong> have something like a <strong>predefinable alpha error rate</strong> (and no correction for multiple variables?). SPRT also does not support multiple variables. Please correct me if I am wrong. Do you have any suggestions where to dig deeper?</p> <p>Best Regards Andreas</p>
49,072
[ -0.03951786458492279, -0.028268877416849136, 0.004469089210033417, -0.04860939830541611, 0.028183555230498314, 0.02659379318356514, -0.007033979054540396, -0.040573298931121826, 0.022915659472346306, -0.029494328424334526, 0.04515236243605614, 0.0036837344523519278, 0.03894459083676338, -0.00043005688348785043, 0.005972797516733408, -0.011528024449944496, 0.0010396166471764445, -0.034193724393844604, -0.03896268457174301, -0.006188519764691591, -0.0014623613096773624, 0.046527788043022156, -0.020516695454716682, 0.021761516109108925, -0.005700141657143831, 0.032455939799547195, 0.0036465441808104515, -0.04567517712712288, -0.034687139093875885, 0.08095692843198776, -0.054203953593969345, 0.0025105902459472418, -0.019186940044164658, 0.008934006094932556, -0.00285642733797431, -0.02490324340760708, 0.03296992927789688, -0.018985120579600334, -0.03916994109749794, 0.010362434200942516, -0.04702507331967354, 0.021137911826372147, -0.002830544486641884, 0.030994245782494545, 0.012063036672770977, 0.02022257074713707, -0.029114101082086563, -0.03735816106200218, 0.03543268144130707, -0.016848862171173096, 0.02856404520571232, -0.015151948668062687, 0.006091447081416845, 0.02559121511876583, 0.002441076096147299, -0.04616597294807434, 0.062100861221551895, 0.04690450057387352, -0.002293503610417247, -0.008272738195955753, -0.001926074968650937, -0.02053161710500717, 0.04417908191680908, 0.003857182338833809, -0.03223579376935959, 0.016478657722473145, -0.04338264837861061, 0.02736232802271843, -0.006526210345327854, -0.03137357160449028, 0.0007500866195186973, -0.025757981464266777, 0.03308434039354324, -0.004915508441627026, -0.004210257437080145, 0.012970228679478168, -0.021783310920000076, 0.03971874713897705, 0.02745802514255047, 0.07911152392625809, -0.021195413544774055, -0.013426946476101875, 0.06466574966907501, 0.06643486022949219, 0.010187163949012756, -0.05568515509366989, 0.03427186980843544, -0.036649905145168304, 0.0015054851537570357, 0.007655819412320852, -0.06437422335147858, -0.01199987344443798, 0.04042090103030205, 0.001800062833353877, -0.04965465888381004, 0.013250274583697319, -0.02847568690776825, 0.02628033608198166, -0.04541313275694847, 0.009885400533676147, 0.03991950675845146, -0.021509159356355667, 0.0018896331312134862, 0.07310526072978973, -0.037968866527080536, -0.004852058365941048, -0.004811383783817291, -0.0174853578209877, -0.01678415760397911, -0.03968840464949608, -0.019568655639886856, 0.02433079294860363, -0.011509522795677185, -0.015161139890551567, -0.021852225065231323, -0.01320422813296318, -0.009229904972016811, -0.009998022578656673, 0.10112223029136658, 0.05778085067868233, 0.059367548674345016, -0.019744884222745895, 0.02150917798280716, -0.013176747597754002, -0.06532755494117737, 0.012297096662223339, 0.021180948242545128, -0.05504029616713524, -0.03483228012919426, 0.0519089475274086, 0.045466430485248566, -0.029564624652266502, 0.05188630893826485, 0.0073557221330702305, 0.0426124669611454, 0.021177388727664948, -0.0770849883556366, -0.023044943809509277, 0.05580649897456169, 0.003038706723600626, 0.013666806742548943, -0.04623815417289734, -0.012314300052821636, 0.029126998037099838, 0.04166056960821152, 0.012344159185886383, 0.042740583419799805, 0.027289658784866333, 0.023224344477057457, 0.03118393011391163, -0.018788132816553116, -0.016133256256580353, -0.016082169488072395, 0.020025018602609634, -0.03067118115723133, -0.09950341284275055, 0.04743621125817299, 0.008993465453386307, 0.004257973749190569, 0.033641498535871506, 0.05656801909208298, 0.011539144441485405, -0.011503135785460472, -0.03293338790535927, 0.029698312282562256, 0.01552134845405817, 0.045954521745443344, 0.004151530098170042, 0.012197709642350674, 0.007323734927922487, -0.014212507754564285, -0.01419412437826395, 0.011539900675415993, 0.045307233929634094, 0.02393886260688305, -0.05088943615555763, 0.005971652455627918, -0.02269398607313633, 0.007099110167473555, 0.010137303732335567, -0.005807083565741777, 0.017931664362549782, -0.042818449437618256, -0.029946597293019295, 0.02896006964147091, 0.04522258788347244, 0.006427043117582798, -0.006350130308419466, -0.0014973857905715704, -0.045231789350509644, -0.04779202118515968, -0.08048749715089798, -0.00914986152201891, -0.026792611926794052, -0.0378265380859375, 0.061555441468954086, -0.022547446191310883, -0.011813648976385593, -0.000656057964079082, 0.002458310918882489, -0.023879528045654297, -0.01543353870511055, 0.05038612708449364, -0.03818916901946068, 0.0026976505760103464, 0.032738398760557175, 0.03264288604259491, -0.0113780302926898, 0.012340020388364792, -0.036610621958971024, -0.029576174914836884, 0.01930374838411808, -0.03618326410651207, -0.0007500883657485247, 0.008446693420410156, -0.024937652051448822, 0.024508563801646233, 0.0010681861313059926, -0.01645025610923767, 0.03025372512638569, -0.06445453315973282, 0.05636614188551903, 0.06586030125617981, -0.01757657155394554, 0.029062695801258087, 0.03863020986318588, -0.02138291858136654, 0.022304946556687355, -0.028062423691153526, -0.032968588173389435, -0.04000980779528618, -0.022905727848410606, 0.01377229206264019, 0.004322287160903215, -0.04969295859336853, 0.03688817843794823, 0.04637674614787102, 0.028032343834638596, 0.01599087379872799, 0.0448211133480072, -0.006280362606048584, -0.033962804824113846, -0.002568732714280486, -0.0001185412984341383, 0.05745191127061844, 0.026315640658140182, -0.009756670333445072, -0.024769073352217674, 0.030650055035948753, -0.004856882616877556, 0.019554514437913895, -0.011546248570084572, -0.010841279290616512, -0.012774449773132801, -0.010752927511930466, -0.04361904785037041, -0.015941539779305458, -0.026283424347639084, 0.016822483390569687, 0.0038426287937909365, 0.014271415770053864, 0.004384660627692938, 0.013694309629499912, -0.012409345246851444, 0.03864370286464691, 0.02085527777671814, 0.0005365268443711102, 0.01115315780043602, 0.013399140909314156, -0.037355486303567886, 0.020463434979319572, -0.044786423444747925, -0.031064098700881004, -0.029094615951180458, 0.039195362478494644, 0.021109571680426598, -0.024645507335662842, 0.014165380969643593, -0.03502950444817543, 0.030902983620762825, -0.009190189652144909, 0.026769248768687248, 0.0361536405980587, 0.009838277474045753, -0.04814682900905609, -0.023781346157193184, -0.008640828542411327, -0.019526613876223564, 0.06378919631242752, 0.0033398373052477837, -0.03590657562017441, 0.0496322363615036, 0.0366208516061306, -0.03514968976378441, -0.011472906917333603, -0.03500400856137276, -0.03175969049334526, 0.0030705782119184732, -0.044058457016944885, 0.06764783710241318, 0.04279927536845207, -0.000685703125782311, 0.05368363484740257, -0.03218427672982216, 0.031677521765232086, -0.028230469673871994, -0.028447607532143593, -0.0390656404197216, -0.008783550001680851, -0.004070939030498266, -0.00011333898146403953, -0.03839482367038727, -0.006822981406003237, -0.06345813721418381, -0.08003126084804535, 0.00040066707879304886, 0.017027072608470917, 0.03442443534731865, -0.006675012409687042, -0.0008135325624607503, 0.04330235719680786, 0.017995009198784828, -0.00236428901553154, -0.0250210240483284, 0.01653166674077511, -0.027523696422576904, -0.006569060496985912, 0.016745124012231827, 0.0010730632347986102, -0.002826744457706809, 0.02272780053317547, -0.02262435108423233, 0.004348175600171089, 0.06766482442617416, 0.023202653974294662, 0.010715903714299202, 0.013920892030000687, 0.053138457238674164, 0.008805498480796814, 0.00569302961230278, 0.027324290946125984, 0.001816048752516508, -0.0327891930937767, 0.0022105092648416758, 0.021003730595111847, 0.020004412159323692, -0.023730650544166565, 0.023987995460629463, 0.007671368308365345, -0.02043321542441845, -0.002211330458521843, 0.029733862727880478, 0.04419456049799919, -0.07837066799402237, -0.011178197339177132, 0.028091466054320335, 0.011008105240762234, -0.002049177885055542, 0.035693030804395676, 0.05134960263967514, 0.05381903052330017, -0.05930238217115402, -0.05150866135954857, -0.0453886054456234, -0.00329568050801754, 0.04523549973964691, -0.047188013792037964, -0.043073806911706924, -0.011914561502635479, 0.039554424583911896, 0.03113730251789093, -0.0011760462075471878, -0.04781775549054146, 0.0075416360050439835, -0.05004015564918518, -0.017996516078710556, -0.03321097418665886, 0.03816235810518265, -0.015266956761479378, 0.0657150149345398, 0.003990026190876961, 0.009217575192451477, 0.00519431522116065, -0.006008284632116556, -0.06631898134946823, -0.000147654049214907, 0.0036888730246573687, -0.01143372431397438, 0.05606065317988396, 0.009521521627902985, 0.015537083148956299, -0.029544053599238396, 0.011591924354434013, -0.023547008633613586, 0.039159372448921204, -0.03778902068734169, 0.016336090862751007, -0.044855907559394836, -0.00783360656350851, 0.005272498354315758, 0.021947447210550308, 0.0513455905020237, -0.023204784840345383, 0.031040901318192482, -0.01622200943529606, -0.02322801947593689, 0.0160598736256361, -0.007973210886120796, 0.021647989749908447, 0.0019219954265281558, 0.06110344082117081, 0.01285506971180439, 0.04879174008965492, -0.03964954614639282, 0.01762772537767887, 0.03771894425153732, 0.02373610809445381, 0.03931386023759842, -0.04875404015183449, 0.0018770945025607944, -0.032232701778411865, -0.01482584048062563, -0.022330986335873604, 0.031377162784338, 0.0479423925280571, -0.0288283322006464, 0.03412710502743721, 0.022686611860990524, -0.06604665517807007, 0.013785285875201225, 0.013185717165470123, -0.0015381608391180634, -0.008250357583165169, -0.015360365621745586, -0.03989792987704277, -0.015613988973200321, -0.018356800079345703, 0.02267523668706417, 0.029802294448018074, -0.019544847309589386, -0.0012717241188511252, 0.035800106823444366, 0.00048376352060586214, -0.009584001265466213, 0.018465030938386917, 0.009263942018151283, 0.015386128798127174, 0.04057428240776062, -0.019875258207321167, 0.016830570995807648, 0.006525703240185976, 0.007056491915136576, 0.014488606713712215, 0.00824206043034792, -0.04867740347981453, 0.0026927832514047623, 0.011802833527326584, 0.054832763969898224, -0.07767649739980698, 0.039801597595214844, -0.023456044495105743, -0.006690844427794218, 0.015596119686961174, -0.04298553243279457, 0.03923351690173149, -0.04036081209778786, 0.036916058510541916, -0.0915616825222969, -0.03116840124130249, -0.03779591992497444, 0.013726445846259594, -0.013829659670591354, 0.021923009306192398, -0.006898856721818447, 0.01441483199596405, -0.03193095326423645, -0.007186890579760075, 0.016817724332213402, 0.07679029554128647, -0.03607828542590141, -0.035037893801927567, 0.030383961275219917, -0.01928684674203396, -0.02856096252799034, -0.06098334118723869, 0.014705928042531013, -0.016904177144169807, -0.00768829183652997, 0.05021073296666145, -0.01226490456610918, -0.01965986378490925, 0.05418705940246582, -0.007467154413461685, -0.0335380844771862, -0.00005773282464360818, -0.017566319555044174, -0.005456923972815275, 0.06567417085170746, -0.012053783982992172, 0.049324050545692444, 0.01488643791526556, -0.0542619563639164, 0.05326782166957855, 0.0012823708821088076, -0.025800874456763268, -0.02385115996003151, 0.007462503854185343, -0.03506603464484215, 0.01051679439842701, -0.02783123590052128, 0.04316296800971031, 0.03725675866007805, 0.014611128717660904, -0.013251890428364277, -0.003157626371830702, 0.056748680770397186, 0.06724632531404495, -0.0016366890631616116, 0.016397487372159958, 0.00042891703196801245, 0.016319194808602333, 0.002238720888271928, 0.009686587378382683, 0.02669307217001915, -0.015347671695053577, 0.009645286947488785, 0.006178717128932476, -0.04682105407118797, -0.010157397016882896, -0.02962927706539631, -0.02034279890358448, 0.025933176279067993, -0.037956353276968, 0.03729842230677605, 0.003565474646165967, 0.03629618510603905, -0.03316677734255791, -0.03346729278564453, -0.011155212298035622, 0.01696438156068325, -0.03996894508600235, 0.01880095712840557, -0.009122965857386589, 0.0008971663773991168, 0.004667865112423897, 0.006293036974966526, -0.05960574746131897, -0.009677212685346603, 0.00941002368927002, -0.01571512036025524, -0.02089403010904789, -0.006142428610473871, 0.023350488394498825, -0.029952924698591232, -0.005507449619472027, -0.05215265974402428, 0.07308956235647202, -0.0016974048921838403, -0.004350657574832439, -0.013289784081280231, 0.035335224121809006, 0.042883530259132385, 0.01661592349410057, 0.006748164538294077, 0.011751960031688213, -0.029104603454470634, -0.012930450029671192, -0.007473176810890436, -0.05084571614861488, -0.026406655088067055, 0.003631787607446313, -0.03662699833512306, 0.03127182275056839, 0.0334540419280529, -0.00006438756827265024, -0.0009810057235881686, 0.041381534188985825, -0.002069824608042836, -0.006963660009205341, -0.029498977586627007, -0.012713366188108921, -0.006481678690761328, 0.027872761711478233, -0.04552064836025238, -0.0006182673387229443, 0.010876820422708988, -0.010629085823893547, 0.04484046250581741, 0.006187945604324341, -0.03765750676393509, 0.03473709523677826, 0.055316291749477386, -0.00016083507216535509, 0.007330417167395353, -0.006699925754219294, 0.01136331632733345, 0.019901925697922707, 0.022660082206130028, 0.0018389220349490643, 0.007218554150313139, -0.014427175745368004, -0.01660432107746601, -0.005222309846431017, -0.015399236232042313, 0.005461501888930798, 0.022222017869353294, 0.01801406778395176, 0.045305244624614716, 0.013596567325294018, 0.03553994745016098, -0.04039495810866356, -0.03668608516454697, 0.006442565005272627, -0.02275119163095951, 0.015401452779769897, 0.04560643061995506, -0.017052894458174706, 0.005970487836748362, 0.05938006564974785, 0.00588366249576211, 0.03197767585515976, 0.04293283447623253, -0.010154012590646744, 0.02577885240316391, 0.027682974934577942, -0.06053449586033821, -0.042270734906196594, 0.044781774282455444, -0.0684254840016365, 0.023000409826636314, -0.049824390560388565, -0.0249666515737772, 0.02147585153579712, 0.08429093658924103, -0.0001871034619398415, -0.055976614356040955, -0.018217194825410843, -0.05322882905602455, -0.001968288328498602, -0.02011488378047943, 0.0029924644622951746, 0.02573675848543644, 0.0036371268797665834, 0.03752852603793144, -0.008760569617152214, 0.05587534233927727, -0.03252198547124863, -0.07679259777069092, -0.04858621954917908, 0.0015395086957141757, -0.026709621772170067, 0.062389470636844635, -0.00838078185915947, -0.024413416162133217, -0.0025432449765503407, -0.030664287507534027, 0.023529155179858208, 0.026247777044773102, 0.04434315115213394, 0.01034954097121954, 0.022079037502408028, -0.017446888610720634, 0.08768109232187271, -0.001436539925634861, -0.0298298392444849, 0.13766364753246307, 0.06353314220905304, 0.03114449977874756, -0.02745547890663147, 0.035521410405635834, 0.01727505587041378, 0.01339317113161087, -0.02186012640595436, 0.017275342717766762, 0.0405711829662323, -0.0467168353497982, -0.00962800346314907, 0.057768985629081726, 0.006289105396717787, -0.012863385491073132, 0.044273555278778076, -0.06310827285051346, 0.010578145273029804, 0.023911019787192345, 0.021171659231185913, 0.024180438369512558, -0.012225709855556488, 0.024092257022857666, -0.0007925872341729701, -0.013561340048909187, -0.036684319376945496, 0.0018463310552760959, 0.005047803744673729, -0.0023596626706421375, 0.029304368421435356, -0.02469296008348465, 0.005977570079267025, -0.012336228042840958, -0.04008139297366142, -0.007942454889416695, 0.01983824372291565, -0.0024518962018191814, -0.03654724732041359, 0.02188444323837757, 0.031342748552560806, -0.0042077405378222466, 0.011239519342780113, -0.007709978148341179, 0.028585216030478477, -0.03949115052819252, -0.03308775648474693, 0.011243139393627644, 0.042060501873493195, -0.0282550361007452, -0.00998476892709732, -0.04019304737448692, -0.009860354475677013, -0.007921723648905754, -0.026922564953565598, -0.026481326669454575, 0.03156838193535805, -0.0028336390387266874, -0.060483649373054504, -0.031576599925756454, -0.014735432341694832, 0.02115202695131302, 0.007815003395080566, 0.015551465563476086, 0.007367080543190241, -0.05747570842504501, -0.04464472085237503, -0.04302680864930153, 0.024537725374102592, 0.02233780547976494, -0.005650159902870655, 0.016824165359139442, 0.002386923413723707, -0.029431894421577454, 0.017259452491998672, -0.018010135740041733, 0.014215747825801373, 0.004588392563164234, -0.014723621308803558, -0.011094443500041962, 0.010778214782476425, -0.022788800299167633, -0.018379267305135727, -0.06043912097811699, 0.019499758258461952, -0.027929408475756645, -0.024101655930280685, 0.031552087515592575, 0.00552609097212553, 0.013243081979453564, -0.0037491226103156805, -0.0025389217771589756, 0.055244024842977524, 0.023003900423645973, -0.03707864508032799, -0.04091595113277435, -0.03699982911348343, -0.011949353851377964, -0.0001718523562885821, -0.039334919303655624, 0.04805288836359978, 0.0026246365159749985, -0.011243181303143501, 0.0006289396551437676, 0.017096346244215965, 0.01570211537182331, -0.00096869160188362, 0.035443827509880066, -0.027084030210971832, -0.007791529409587383, 0.021629363298416138, 0.012309063225984573, -0.01809968240559101, 0.028610268607735634, -0.03258173540234566, 0.01564669795334339, 0.01022435538470745, -0.059496112167835236, -0.02287856861948967, -0.01010917779058218, -0.01085470151156187, 0.04026023671030998, 0.008072294294834137, 0.0067407977767288685, -0.00962259154766798, 0.004413783550262451, -0.061636362224817276, 0.018637031316757202, -0.023352520540356636, 0.015139170922338963, -0.007060194853693247, 0.019372379407286644, 0.027620090171694756, -0.017762573435902596, 0.0003794564981944859, -0.020850200206041336, 0.03428523615002632, 0.0079523716121912, 0.030576540157198906, 0.027734726667404175, -0.036894842982292175, 0.0038023637607693672, -0.03771394491195679, -0.04349634796380997, 0.045117855072021484, 0.02422519586980343, 0.012580928392708302, 0.01659708097577095, 0.012162947095930576, -0.01936320774257183, -0.007664256263524294, -0.04284554719924927, -0.05287766456604004, 0.0012944458285346627, 0.02855777181684971, -0.02780499868094921, -0.02882383018732071, 0.05380011349916458, 0.008180459029972553, 0.042520709335803986, 0.03574525937438011, 0.03377167508006096, 0.013967590406537056, 0.0002936125092674047, -0.013857959769666195, -0.02382677234709263, 0.012042694725096226, -0.0015761017566546798, -0.02188831940293312, 0.019861487671732903, 0.07446109503507614, 0.015048029832541943, 0.02937496453523636, 0.00490005686879158, -0.019257046282291412, -0.07362285256385803, -0.007844369858503342, 0.006884847767651081, 0.0036551090888679028, 0.04792919009923935, -0.01876639761030674, 0.041967131197452545, 0.06774624437093735, -0.035288453102111816, 0.04755552485585213, -0.02820400521159172, -0.004806654527783394, -0.055233150720596313, -0.022278934717178345, -0.039513688534498215, -0.007660063914954662, -0.0075079272501170635, 0.003310311818495393, 0.009740449488162994, 0.031618934124708176, 0.032344888895750046, -0.032139260321855545, -0.04409303143620491, 0.02994379587471485, 0.01927841268479824, -0.03675377368927002, 0.02597975917160511, -0.025488942861557007, -0.021104581654071808, 0.0205968227237463, 0.011688030324876308, 0.03135356679558754, 0.00763353705406189, 0.06342080980539322, -0.011655844748020172, 0.04933282360434532, -0.009426007978618145, 0.007118183188140392, 0.024285104125738144, 0.018540075048804283, -0.0009421327849850059, 0.03531675040721893, -0.019515613093972206, 0.030722659081220627, 0.023444410413503647, -0.026153096929192543, -0.003641589777544141, 0.02942212112247944, 0.01565878465771675, -0.000014878290130582172, 0.030692055821418762, -0.004135882947593927, 0.0237853042781353, -0.002381968079134822, -0.049061186611652374, -0.028197329491376877, -0.01302114687860012, -0.004270761273801327, 0.016283366829156876, -0.0037824565079063177, -0.016532830893993378, -0.01249298732727766, -0.02297298051416874, 0.014703252352774143, -0.03051185980439186, 0.019101034849882126, -0.0717737004160881, 0.008976696990430355, 0.0030808772426098585, -0.007396039552986622, -0.04467324912548065, 0.024110352620482445, 0.03251732885837555, 0.03635270893573761, -0.033520542085170746, 0.01133166067302227, -0.0005948506877757609, 0.009315583854913712, 0.027466800063848495, -0.07328730821609497, 0.08507924526929855, -0.008919407613575459, -0.001974660437554121, -0.0014574386877939105, -0.04561909660696983, -0.04945099353790283, -0.006352361757308245, 0.05197250843048096, -0.013648463413119316, 0.004258185159415007, 0.01318422146141529, 0.015430279076099396, 0.029038237407803535, -0.011486963368952274, 0.05037052929401398, -0.022074533626437187, 0.0025503961369395256, -0.04223368689417839, -0.011920609511435032, 0.008213265798985958, 0.02394730970263481, 0.011888481676578522, -0.022534579038619995, 0.01857277937233448, 0.01819230243563652, -0.003608615370467305, 0.0059825349599123, 0.013809478841722012, -0.01592869684100151, -0.020842913538217545, -0.06846803426742554, 0.03591242805123329, 0.031111713498830795, 0.008110914379358292, -0.07154260575771332, 0.011435273103415966, -0.005607450380921364, -0.03922909125685692, 0.00952500943094492, 0.014508859254419804, -0.05050443485379219, -0.04880284145474434, -0.020918792113661766, 0.01653393730521202, -0.05842498317360878, 0.01444237306714058, 0.05930342897772789, -0.015130133368074894, 0.010250846855342388, -0.006244799587875605, 0.03662905842065811, 0.022922910749912262, -0.010824045166373253, -0.027352532371878624, 0.01319135446101427, 0.031831786036491394, 0.03401689976453781, 0.03496496379375458, 0.023631595075130463, 0.0116440299898386, 0.0440608449280262, 0.0041694859974086285, 0.04901951923966408, -0.007913912646472454, 0.035949137061834335, -0.000072162423748523, -0.029540030285716057, -0.028830280527472496, 0.0012958917068317533, 0.007455733604729176, 0.030473094433546066, -0.029120368883013725, 0.013363727368414402, 0.010255992412567139, 0.00797510240226984, -0.03688332438468933, 0.015644967555999756, -0.03300219401717186, 0.055473022162914276, -0.012027500197291374, 0.00031821304582990706, 0.006434490904211998, 0.005363136995583773, 0.012946981936693192, -0.012985466048121452, 0.030270889401435852, 0.01209492888301611, 0.00144387676846236, -0.006543712690472603, -0.04945952445268631, -0.02985399402678013, -0.03779943287372589, 0.024405544623732567, 0.043921153992414474, 0.03747490793466568, -0.03341752663254738, -0.04832577705383301, -0.01848159171640873, 0.02298385463654995, -0.0485418327152729, 0.0027138807345181704, -0.05036646127700806, 0.014862927608191967, 0.030209651216864586, -0.007962225936353207 ]
<p>I have a short question regarding interaction variables:</p> <ol> <li><p>In a logit regression with 2 independent dichotomous variables (A and B), both variables are significant. By including the interaction (AxB) in the regression, B becomes insignificant. Is the high (0.6) and significant correlation between (AxB) and B the reason for this? And in conclusion, has B a significant influence on the dependent variable or not?</p></li> <li><p>By including demographics and their interaction variables, all initial significant variables become insignificant (enter method). Is it smarter to simply use the stepwise forward method? By doing so, the initial significant variables remain significant. However, all new added varialbes are not included in the model.</p></li> </ol> <p>Thanks a lot in advance for your help.</p>
74,404
[ -0.008065435104072094, -0.005884384736418724, 0.011346055194735527, 0.014412209391593933, 0.04254095256328583, 0.019429711624979973, -0.00042271995334886014, -0.021771633997559547, 0.044751521199941635, -0.023279044777154922, 0.011722825467586517, -0.02211024984717369, 0.060239847749471664, -0.013633857481181622, 0.05819081515073776, 0.011296098120510578, -0.021147798746824265, 0.006076523568481207, 0.03225063160061836, 0.012820391915738583, -0.05241430178284645, 0.009170246310532093, 0.053617432713508606, -0.03467096760869026, -0.013918527401983738, 0.07019992917776108, -0.0032745201606303453, -0.026077087968587875, -0.008851973339915276, 0.057768549770116806, 0.0198086965829134, -0.03529326990246773, -0.018576033413410187, 0.019577134400606155, 0.010004016570746899, 0.01099231094121933, -0.033686861395835876, -0.05418314412236214, 0.03336995467543602, -0.0005933931097388268, -0.030445562675595284, -0.011238598264753819, 0.005475939717143774, 0.010604292154312134, 0.004325062967836857, 0.021692689508199692, -0.01697632297873497, -0.012816858477890491, 0.06244831904768944, -0.00887145847082138, 0.05389835685491562, -0.02842181921005249, 0.03891909494996071, 0.027765410020947456, -0.01387866772711277, -0.05700846388936043, 0.04622846841812134, 0.0680231899023056, -0.00046570636914111674, -0.0005669957026839256, -0.0006732851616106927, 0.000888938142452389, -0.023988600820302963, -0.018620165064930916, -0.038187116384506226, 0.03562970086932182, -0.036111101508140564, -0.007402319461107254, 0.08086024969816208, -0.009819518774747849, -0.0034662559628486633, -0.007046590559184551, -0.0019890109542757273, -0.006030424498021603, 0.014109760522842407, -0.026814941316843033, 0.005737881641834974, -0.003095201449468732, 0.022870317101478577, 0.0351339615881443, -0.033486176282167435, -0.0030408105812966824, 0.03354579210281372, 0.03136749193072319, 0.04946967214345932, -0.0082693537697196, 0.020809346809983253, -0.02967517077922821, 0.015359437093138695, 0.010083149187266827, -0.04391590878367424, 0.05496790260076523, 0.05742822214961052, -0.004222020972520113, -0.027009109035134315, 0.0522538423538208, -0.04727102816104889, 0.07195793092250824, 0.03386952728033066, -0.006412428803741932, -0.03678920120000839, -0.03652073070406914, 0.010412386618554592, 0.06416323781013489, -0.0035956997890025377, 0.006987630855292082, -0.040813155472278595, 0.027359886094927788, 0.012245234102010727, -0.06428690254688263, -0.017199793830513954, 0.0025821386370807886, -0.024568069726228714, 0.01194055937230587, 0.021702757105231285, -0.06387419998645782, -0.01148196030408144, -0.01664869301021099, 0.06483159959316254, 0.03712906315922737, 0.05546188727021217, -0.03378424420952797, 0.0004719009739346802, 0.00344223459251225, -0.020750800147652626, -0.013376202434301376, 0.013370897620916367, -0.015600916929543018, -0.025245625525712967, 0.07100516557693481, 0.03775149583816528, -0.030101845040917397, -0.00035221429425291717, 0.008736391551792622, 0.026865089312195778, 0.0248955637216568, -0.0426207073032856, -0.04547747224569321, 0.028109006583690643, -0.02949965000152588, 0.039351675659418106, -0.040684863924980164, -0.01649879850447178, 0.038300998508930206, 0.0808599591255188, -0.035219866782426834, 0.008826489560306072, 0.04414942115545273, 0.025044213980436325, 0.016354264691472054, -0.0288094412535429, -0.0031113431323319674, -0.035511571913957596, -0.02310391142964363, -0.010790153406560421, -0.11928240954875946, 0.009875756688416004, 0.027930958196520805, 0.0013386462815105915, -0.030734311789274216, 0.04934147745370865, -0.004791302606463432, -0.009243867360055447, 0.007284186780452728, -0.00846212636679411, 0.0021225381642580032, 0.043007541447877884, -0.02988520637154579, 0.012981791980564594, 0.02608541026711464, 0.008055918850004673, -0.0004263457958586514, -0.010782490484416485, 0.06355132162570953, 0.02159794047474861, 0.01369898859411478, -0.004299691412597895, -0.003786402055993676, 0.002444867743179202, 0.014512887224555016, -0.07797359675168991, -0.05061710253357887, -0.03678027540445328, -0.004370145034044981, -0.0009183729998767376, 0.05970596522092819, 0.008502814918756485, -0.0034748211037367582, 0.03964577987790108, -0.04021989181637764, -0.045825980603694916, -0.06794899702072144, 0.03977980092167854, 0.02771996706724167, -0.04472820833325386, 0.02900824509561062, 0.010945018380880356, 0.035501956939697266, -0.0014472260372713208, -0.002953016897663474, -0.03052290715277195, 0.011363595724105835, 0.02746177837252617, -0.05598278343677521, 0.029039856046438217, 0.03711578622460365, 0.06302931904792786, -0.056256458163261414, 0.05406922847032547, -0.03572746738791466, 0.00015419951523654163, 0.04871656745672226, -0.004586047492921352, 0.011100578121840954, -0.0628390908241272, -0.06242840364575386, 0.024588568136096, -0.0005192949902266264, -0.03742285445332527, 0.0519820861518383, -0.06441743671894073, 0.0754072368144989, 0.03707853704690933, -0.022926416248083115, -0.0011669272789731622, 0.021330974996089935, 0.02422267757356167, 0.02139720320701599, -0.027192210778594017, -0.010243680328130722, -0.05973741412162781, -0.039003558456897736, 0.038433536887168884, -0.0100657744333148, -0.052653517574071884, 0.011110336519777775, 0.04410063475370407, -0.005276035983115435, 0.02523106522858143, 0.03702308237552643, -0.009288676083087921, -0.013792594894766808, 0.04170273244380951, 0.009227834641933441, 0.0346953310072422, -0.001793489558622241, 0.01385209709405899, 0.02029799297451973, 0.0431789830327034, 0.0004525963740888983, -0.0023610610514879227, 0.03950979933142662, 0.013331164605915546, 0.020134419202804565, -0.01709030754864216, 0.002350633265450597, 0.045074108988046646, -0.030327636748552322, 0.01741171069443226, 0.04059486836194992, 0.03183840215206146, -0.009237613528966904, 0.01673564501106739, -0.0070840842090547085, 0.017082897946238518, 0.025553999468684196, -0.03128563240170479, -0.0022864025086164474, 0.008412838913500309, -0.046507738530635834, 0.012343049049377441, -0.025201167911291122, -0.02939794398844242, -0.025226308032870293, -0.042140498757362366, 0.05464557930827141, 0.031699080020189285, 0.03765945881605148, -0.01880056969821453, -0.014831184409558773, -0.04171457514166832, -0.01900700479745865, 0.033882346004247665, 0.015546759590506554, -0.06461585313081741, -0.0037379367277026176, -0.00710197864100337, -0.012963683344423771, 0.012496593408286572, 0.0036256378516554832, -0.033663373440504074, 0.016076188534498215, -0.03584977611899376, -0.05057859420776367, -0.02410302497446537, -0.020962564274668694, -0.007408131845295429, -0.017392290756106377, -0.03104359284043312, 0.021676992997527122, 0.011470838449895382, 0.004125119652599096, -0.005373961292207241, -0.044579919427633286, -0.04409206286072731, -0.004053174052387476, -0.012206667102873325, 0.014936965890228748, 0.013130661100149155, -0.0042368401773273945, -0.014686181209981441, -0.041777629405260086, -0.0025406249333173037, -0.08454079926013947, -0.06531037390232086, 0.041456691920757294, 0.028301546350121498, 0.0286193136125803, -0.03281736373901367, 0.012499462813138962, 0.04945877194404602, 0.06538081169128418, -0.040999092161655426, -0.04925534501671791, -0.02351338416337967, -0.015048416331410408, -0.03030915930867195, 0.01770906336605549, 0.010434044525027275, 0.03175634145736694, 0.03421172499656677, -0.03452214226126671, 0.03918711096048355, 0.040824878960847855, 0.00845443457365036, 0.011673101224005222, 0.026172390207648277, 0.012662294320762157, 0.013087591156363487, 0.03241972252726555, 0.04823502153158188, -0.027303768321871758, 0.021350881084799767, -0.04668962582945824, 0.01507581677287817, 0.01351984590291977, -0.018733974546194077, 0.023706533014774323, 0.001881547155790031, -0.008755888789892197, -0.004454328678548336, 0.006590391509234905, 0.017752008512616158, -0.01160573773086071, -0.007722937036305666, -0.01102067343890667, 0.03516484424471855, -0.02660932019352913, 0.01259864866733551, 0.018206965178251266, 0.004505947232246399, -0.020391641184687614, 0.028650391846895218, 0.0042578415013849735, -0.006437335163354874, 0.023482538759708405, 0.013154329732060432, 0.012956887483596802, 0.0032296529971063137, 0.018093181774020195, -0.019657928496599197, -0.016619058325886726, -0.051028259098529816, 0.025776555761694908, -0.06081175059080124, -0.006121474783867598, -0.04212852939963341, 0.034815285354852676, -0.012552770785987377, 0.020680218935012817, -0.026988713070750237, -0.0056081186048686504, -0.009862242266535759, -0.0032811316195875406, -0.06994956731796265, 0.0380285307765007, -0.02065202407538891, 0.014433128759264946, 0.0199462678283453, -0.033589549362659454, 0.029654884710907936, -0.020359735935926437, -0.016860490664839745, -0.028636779636144638, 0.030412767082452774, -0.009498707950115204, 0.0038564286660403013, -0.05108696222305298, -0.013393349945545197, -0.014994834549725056, -0.004361481871455908, -0.016180289909243584, -0.009742830879986286, 0.04048825800418854, 0.05751457437872887, 0.0052093518897891045, -0.038102008402347565, -0.04091568663716316, -0.012673505581915379, 0.007233780808746815, 0.05848631262779236, 0.05224023014307022, 0.011527856811881065, -0.036463264375925064, 0.011065337806940079, 0.04580552503466606, 0.03662858530879021, 0.01962720975279808, -0.003712630830705166, -0.04966021329164505, -0.018782105296850204, -0.038383599370718, -0.015916215255856514, 0.0146907614544034, -0.0064737843349576, 0.012262863107025623, 0.05135822296142578, 0.010811153799295425, -0.04249496012926102, 0.02942170388996601, 0.03691378980875015, 0.015788400545716286, 0.0016857209848240018, -0.02122957818210125, -0.02319462038576603, -0.03293968364596367, -0.009266681969165802, -0.00016631357721053064, 0.004992991220206022, -0.008237592875957489, 0.01861254684627056, 0.05534091591835022, 0.01923341676592827, -0.033041734248399734, 0.04113025590777397, -0.003463317872956395, 0.020440446212887764, 0.03201764449477196, -0.07427455484867096, 0.012331667356193066, -0.0020315656438469887, 0.011364527978003025, 0.021645214408636093, 0.02418198622763157, -0.09097310155630112, 0.015181919559836388, 0.022773152217268944, 0.03898963704705238, -0.06980478018522263, 0.017738308757543564, -0.029985493049025536, -0.03193109855055809, 0.025474214926362038, -0.02516469731926918, 0.03867216780781746, -0.044910870492458344, 0.01850130409002304, -0.02182096056640148, -0.027732400223612785, -0.06963784247636795, 0.0015382654964923859, -0.02153084985911846, -0.005400574766099453, -0.05175571143627167, -0.01843223348259926, -0.06233599781990051, 0.04744516685605049, 0.029542965814471245, 0.061039458960294724, -0.04061204940080643, -0.03412961959838867, 0.021638117730617523, 0.03139343112707138, 0.00027901530847884715, -0.03558029234409332, 0.05453381687402725, 0.005616332869976759, -0.02912008948624134, 0.05098273605108261, -0.012339189648628235, -0.03905584290623665, 0.005100191105157137, 0.05543069168925285, 0.027142753824591637, -0.005390504840761423, -0.015874771401286125, 0.05595233663916588, -0.011021321639418602, -0.006958018988370895, 0.012306712567806244, 0.043679337948560715, -0.010993624106049538, 0.010935312137007713, -0.027901779860258102, 0.01713848114013672, -0.011033025570213795, -0.018425730988383293, -0.029349729418754578, -0.004123445134609938, -0.02592754177749157, 0.03688067942857742, -0.00917835719883442, -0.010368555784225464, -0.014986279420554638, -0.015954207628965378, 0.03197558969259262, 0.0010443844366818666, -0.02350146695971489, -0.00034564256202429533, -0.002190830186009407, 0.0348779559135437, -0.013566999696195126, -0.03594881668686867, 0.024391716346144676, -0.0028382388409227133, -0.008251100778579712, 0.024765852838754654, -0.04377390816807747, 0.02110462822020054, -0.04448285698890686, -0.04020422697067261, -0.023626459762454033, -0.005406845826655626, -0.017838845029473305, -0.002717558993026614, 0.02453298307955265, -0.0025576455518603325, -0.07236026972532272, 0.024412089958786964, 0.03149881213903427, 0.01556714903563261, 0.013789460994303226, -0.02314172126352787, 0.004917374812066555, 0.0022035602014511824, -0.018856288865208626, -0.03432229161262512, -0.023980606347322464, 0.0016960268840193748, -0.014818200841546059, 0.011627480387687683, -0.030168628320097923, 0.03518811613321304, -0.037284087389707565, -0.02440858632326126, -0.01086506899446249, 0.05590559542179108, -0.019565029069781303, -0.013316947966814041, 0.015187242068350315, 0.023056581616401672, 0.056454215198755264, 0.030438365414738655, -0.010552243329584599, 0.03697909414768219, -0.002716511022299528, -0.00509293656796217, -0.01673313044011593, 0.03217213228344917, 0.0003435043036006391, -0.015498612076044083, -0.01332081202417612, -0.018974903970956802, 0.025315778329968452, 0.010307933203876019, -0.033033326268196106, 0.0035442099906504154, -0.022805314511060715, 0.007584538776427507, -0.018600501120090485, -0.009084206074476242, -0.0002476869849488139, 0.01597263291478157, -0.004850348457694054, 0.0355970524251461, -0.046002257615327835, -0.007688720244914293, 0.033503446727991104, -0.02947808988392353, -0.047065623104572296, -0.011989627033472061, 0.053970661014318466, 0.030673393979668617, 0.024879086762666702, 0.007946371100842953, -0.019951598718762398, 0.042563680559396744, -0.0008889198070392013, -0.019254978746175766, 0.011657954193651676, 0.027808375656604767, 0.0012127633672207594, -0.04089256003499031, -0.02704048529267311, -0.0027191294357180595, 0.04437839612364769, -0.03936124965548515, 0.033622898161411285, 0.03317682072520256, 0.011447768658399582, -0.022413143888115883, -0.0332610122859478, 0.01728964038193226, 0.021389620378613472, 0.023479079827666283, 0.030209632590413094, -0.02822529524564743, -0.00633700005710125, 0.037119463086128235, 0.012755989097058773, 0.039924148470163345, 0.012664669193327427, 0.0392255000770092, 0.0036239991895854473, 0.02254112996160984, -0.02262185886502266, -0.04082699865102768, 0.03803955763578415, -0.029163287952542305, 0.02795282192528248, -0.04104368016123772, -0.007164230104535818, 0.057487715035676956, 0.05117807909846306, 0.021805020049214363, -0.05418343469500542, -0.031397201120853424, -0.04579216241836548, -0.03668057918548584, -0.02757016010582447, 0.006348571740090847, 0.02872290462255478, 0.014072762802243233, 0.01741078495979309, -0.014226485975086689, 0.02079201675951481, -0.02642453834414482, -0.10212220996618271, -0.0290963314473629, -0.02606005035340786, -0.016549089923501015, 0.04005429521203041, 0.009012722410261631, -0.01659749075770378, 0.0054428004659712315, -0.06072642654180527, -0.019360780715942383, -0.032936617732048035, 0.0056777223944664, 0.03069266676902771, 0.08255794644355774, -0.002338937483727932, 0.005030522122979164, 0.026058947667479515, 0.019450675696134567, 0.09507178515195847, 0.051652465015649796, -0.01323605701327324, -0.0648759976029396, 0.023245729506015778, 0.00773696880787611, -0.00838393159210682, -0.01767617277801037, -0.027019008994102478, 0.01943126879632473, -0.013802295550704002, 0.05040917545557022, 0.0113351009786129, 0.026148870587348938, 0.018609434366226196, 0.043743960559368134, -0.03648696467280388, -0.058336041867733, 0.04297700524330139, 0.029123466461896896, -0.012718390673398972, -0.026723861694335938, -0.025512399151921272, -0.04374523088335991, -0.009792037308216095, -0.011370811611413956, -0.011081768199801445, -0.011562972329556942, 0.006176783703267574, 0.005604758858680725, -0.009796549566090107, 0.024089686572551727, 0.035493746399879456, 0.026082312688231468, -0.02055201679468155, -0.019392911344766617, 0.03218155726790428, -0.03473593667149544, 0.029012219980359077, 0.020681237801909447, -0.04268459975719452, 0.011896425858139992, 0.010705479420721531, 0.005641528405249119, -0.05523338541388512, -0.02289205603301525, -0.014484859071671963, 0.0507478192448616, 0.02312954142689705, -0.022974904626607895, -0.02913491055369377, -0.008386625908315182, 0.01560007594525814, -0.008631785400211811, -0.031170746311545372, 0.06857012212276459, 0.004525976255536079, -0.04579266905784607, 0.005874768365174532, -0.049094926565885544, -0.006204335484653711, -0.0016137822531163692, 0.021068938076496124, 0.040433358401060104, -0.047287337481975555, 0.013106489554047585, -0.04055595025420189, 0.046194836497306824, -0.012717015109956264, -0.0018218321492895484, 0.021253999322652817, -0.02259826846420765, -0.020329028367996216, -0.0023515501525253057, -0.010393512435257435, 0.03569652512669563, 0.0034974482841789722, -0.010661542415618896, 0.005622777622193098, -0.06344028562307358, -0.040212489664554596, 0.02231716923415661, -0.005698401015251875, -0.017082389444112778, -0.04589931666851044, 0.010340435430407524, 0.02019827999174595, 0.009353674948215485, 0.007073372136801481, 0.006980471778661013, 0.0042472160421311855, 0.050263941287994385, 0.02560129575431347, -0.07130462676286697, -0.02126213163137436, 0.026202671229839325, -0.029339924454689026, 0.01648920774459839, -0.017083119601011276, 0.04866895079612732, 0.0028944709338247776, 0.0120699442923069, -0.015459715388715267, 0.01563706062734127, -0.011626503430306911, 0.014589567668735981, 0.04139207676053047, -0.038759514689445496, -0.0079287588596344, 0.00868256762623787, 0.009196624159812927, -0.01029918435961008, -0.00679664546623826, -0.022685624659061432, -0.016800478100776672, 0.02236860990524292, -0.023827580735087395, -0.024555765092372894, -0.017288818955421448, -0.02531089074909687, 0.02692057192325592, -0.03595820814371109, -0.029380839318037033, -0.05607746168971062, -0.007309937383979559, 0.025675464421510696, -0.0031801986042410135, 0.021161308512091637, 0.04211389645934105, -0.016674615442752838, 0.011778008192777634, 0.04607698693871498, 0.013049440458416939, 0.006877127103507519, -0.04466569423675537, 0.03408494591712952, -0.00023631768999621272, 0.04788454249501228, -0.0206584632396698, -0.033432867377996445, 0.027933765202760696, -0.024933533743023872, -0.037848424166440964, 0.01621868647634983, -0.0014646581839770079, 0.05228295177221298, 0.04304327443242073, 0.007551068905740976, 0.010238914750516415, 0.027072694152593613, 0.00008695333235664293, 0.014298588037490845, -0.00030624066130258143, -0.01513429544866085, -0.007882465608417988, -0.0007921209326013923, -0.040068525820970535, 0.03348464518785477, 0.004105472471565008, 0.046287473291158676, 0.054999519139528275, -0.002376037184149027, -0.04555673152208328, -0.002583034336566925, 0.029550844803452492, 0.02321120910346508, 0.0001198081808979623, -0.026848169043660164, 0.04002269729971886, 0.06144389882683754, -0.03371410071849823, 0.008812141604721546, 0.008230785839259624, 0.006496801506727934, -0.057889293879270554, -0.003642418421804905, 0.013706926256418228, 0.024740681052207947, 0.06011969596147537, -0.04651405289769173, 0.02783375047147274, 0.03414362668991089, -0.04516487941145897, 0.031250569969415665, 0.013224950060248375, 0.022992616519331932, -0.05659906938672066, -0.013359918259084225, -0.01008027046918869, 0.04314911365509033, 0.00483454717323184, 0.03397563472390175, 0.03228674829006195, -0.00442243367433548, -0.011862155050039291, -0.06694458425045013, -0.02442230097949505, 0.017075156792998314, -0.015864631161093712, -0.08126799762248993, 0.03591358661651611, -0.051374033093452454, -0.03286200389266014, 0.02476312592625618, -0.020842960104346275, 0.01748594455420971, 0.043837662786245346, 0.02569740079343319, 0.03647647798061371, 0.06245185062289238, 0.04211999103426933, 0.027101673185825348, 0.004416201263666153, 0.039167314767837524, 0.028507940471172333, 0.04328287020325661, 0.005876605864614248, -0.000847559655085206, -0.0027257639449089766, 0.013469267636537552, -0.016628583893179893, -0.011945408768951893, -0.026385454460978508, 0.02423643320798874, -0.021250814199447632, -0.03951863572001457, -0.0021349082235246897, -0.02394588105380535, 0.010871073231101036, -0.035589076578617096, -0.05591841787099838, 0.04367645084857941, 0.03380848839879036, -0.03759539872407913, 0.01205097883939743, -0.03998782858252525, -0.014444979839026928, 0.005007870960980654, 0.009549248963594437, 0.026330046355724335, -0.020966187119483948, -0.009355306625366211, 0.0035248142667114735, -0.029730968177318573, -0.0626053437590599, 0.029605070129036903, -0.05446617677807808, 0.05136164277791977, -0.06613941490650177, 0.0334155298769474, 0.027217354625463486, -0.0495937317609787, -0.0007415658910758793, -0.0691341683268547, 0.08211562782526016, 0.03894907981157303, -0.036114152520895004, -0.05150245875120163, -0.0005593508249148726, -0.0555640384554863, -0.0021551023237407207, 0.047038484364748, -0.024731198325753212, 0.03129078075289726, 0.005098260473459959, 0.03234780952334404, 0.01691235974431038, -0.006734997965395451, 0.03702154383063316, -0.00180881901178509, 0.0038329747039824724, 0.01628938689827919, -0.004228981677442789, -0.008846239186823368, 0.014124772511422634, -0.004231649450957775, -0.04032731428742409, 0.020219460129737854, 0.011912073940038681, -0.014192098751664162, -0.0025241479743272066, -0.005534389056265354, 0.005039767827838659, 0.013677687384188175, -0.007471928372979164, 0.0406181626021862, 0.05360334739089012, 0.007358103524893522, -0.05857495591044426, 0.029292352497577667, -0.013937653042376041, -0.015231968834996223, -0.016971200704574585, 0.007148376200348139, -0.03360970318317413, -0.02727872133255005, 0.047550417482852936, -0.007269864436239004, -0.008983961306512356, 0.02773192897439003, -0.004740455187857151, 0.011300808750092983, 0.02720092609524727, 0.005426931194961071, 0.027076182886958122, 0.019516663625836372, -0.0019197770161554217, 0.0018972671823576093, 0.015384013764560223, 0.02197609469294548, 0.029000522568821907, 0.00044235849054530263, 0.020296812057495117, 0.020932786166667938, 0.03257308900356293, 0.0030317846685647964, 0.005425787530839443, 0.007493646815419197, -0.005305013619363308, -0.010565628297626972, -0.006276129279285669, 0.0706142708659172, 0.023944389075040817, 0.004650935996323824, 0.033734481781721115, -0.047530367970466614, 0.020931478589773178, 0.0008492367924191058, 0.0010252902284264565, -0.038653191179037094, -0.02421131543815136, 0.01913362555205822, -0.026102224364876747, 0.018097395077347755, 0.0014116651145741343, 0.031089123338460922, -0.03819453716278076, -0.0299677737057209, -0.025245051831007004, 0.039933811873197556, -0.022084463387727737, -0.027758361771702766, -0.0027053102385252714, -0.02653118222951889, -0.0007927809492684901, -0.032542288303375244, 0.046687740832567215, 0.07710465043783188, 0.0048148962669074535, -0.034859515726566315, -0.015257474035024643, 0.018616048619151115, 0.05601320415735245, -0.03191947564482689, 0.02033834718167782, -0.04794801026582718, -0.008290927857160568, 0.00047179684042930603, -0.011648215353488922 ]
<p>I am performing some regression task, where I try to discover the underlying multivariate Gaussians from a set of $n$, $p$-dimensional vectors. For example, given a split of the set into $S_i$ and $S_j$ I will calculate the sample means and covariance matrices (${\sum}_{i,j}$)and decide which is the best split based on the information gain(defined by the entropy ($log(det({\sum}_{i,j}))$). And then we recurse on the subsets $S_i$ and $S_j$.</p> <p>I am trying to define some stopping criteria for this algorithm, which basically should be that when the variance of the distribution is small enough (not sure how to define this threshold) stop to avoid over-fitting to the training data. </p> <p>So, my questions are:</p> <p>1) How can I get a measure of overall variance, is it just $trace({\sum})$?</p> <p>2) How can I choose a suitable threshold?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
49,075
[ -0.0059479111805558205, 0.011586794629693031, -0.0014991037314757705, -0.019956426694989204, 0.039310846477746964, 0.022208843380212784, -0.012202290818095207, -0.0342823788523674, 0.003304192330688238, -0.04061534255743027, 0.06129556894302368, 0.04364499822258949, 0.0458623431622982, 0.049415525048971176, 0.010607382282614708, -0.014568802900612354, -0.038325730711221695, -0.017387617379426956, -0.012358102016150951, -0.01588515192270279, 0.010524013079702854, 0.0233260877430439, 0.013696813955903053, -0.021995795890688896, -0.04123397916555405, 0.024685142561793327, 0.04077478498220444, -0.0015438488917425275, -0.0014920206740498543, 0.041312891989946365, -0.041905056685209274, -0.013559527695178986, 0.029265647754073143, 0.015384390950202942, 0.01756746880710125, -0.01114863995462656, 0.006385898683220148, -0.009308907203376293, 0.01751909963786602, -0.0002751050051301718, -0.07272320985794067, -0.031594038009643555, -0.004788553342223167, 0.022420920431613922, 0.020051229745149612, 0.0121079096570611, 0.0024888047482818365, -0.03448557108640671, 0.01793227158486843, -0.0625297874212265, 0.07809415459632874, 0.009617491625249386, 0.019182853400707245, 0.002502711722627282, 0.015368727967143059, 0.013408293016254902, 0.03097185678780079, 0.09240849316120148, 0.009307900443673134, -0.05258001387119293, -0.004273230209946632, -0.002431547502055764, 0.044678397476673126, -0.01953655108809471, -0.05225231125950813, 0.0024560464080423117, 0.004409400746226311, -0.008154656738042831, 0.039778932929039, -0.018989913165569305, -0.007982884533703327, 0.0031472130212932825, 0.009648104198276997, -0.02590472251176834, 0.029673932120203972, 0.012796064838767052, 0.00753316143527627, 0.032922495156526566, 0.0512407161295414, 0.025549694895744324, 0.027449602261185646, 0.020202653482556343, -0.010809245519340038, 0.059506647288799286, 0.014026451855897903, 0.0028287353925406933, 0.0808628723025322, -0.036076270043849945, 0.019132526591420174, 0.03639819100499153, 0.013629231601953506, 0.0017298321472480893, 0.043423473834991455, 0.015233568847179413, -0.07395967841148376, 0.02838788740336895, -0.017869871109724045, 0.007952595129609108, -0.006435968913137913, -0.011229149997234344, -0.04477231949567795, -0.032465577125549316, 0.02362198755145073, 0.06003916636109352, -0.051634203642606735, 0.023186035454273224, -0.020258979871869087, -0.026672611013054848, -0.03374570608139038, -0.03613799065351486, -0.015870476141572, 0.03073444403707981, 0.0067552123218774796, 0.027853161096572876, 0.03307364881038666, 0.023333417251706123, -0.018211932852864265, -0.04788034409284592, 0.030539754778146744, 0.07831883430480957, 0.025562992319464684, 0.004350112285465002, 0.005148707889020443, -0.03643832728266716, -0.036317236721515656, 0.025405434891581535, 0.04844126105308533, 0.0009583564242348075, -0.048722535371780396, 0.027283549308776855, 0.009482497349381447, -0.02618938311934471, 0.015505059622228146, 0.008368568494915962, 0.016639940440654755, -0.010179288685321808, -0.09047416597604752, -0.04291873052716255, 0.05730295553803444, -0.042035769671201706, 0.0021890373900532722, -0.05392520874738693, -0.01136906910687685, 0.03087201900780201, 0.03622981160879135, -0.002611415460705757, 0.03163992986083031, 0.014755163341760635, 0.052608296275138855, 0.007289933506399393, -0.018882716074585915, -0.02142234332859516, -0.03669142350554466, -0.0005427894648164511, -0.007958043366670609, -0.05986475571990013, 0.03181064501404762, 0.04399009048938751, -0.031139984726905823, 0.005101358518004417, 0.010386228561401367, 0.03053593449294567, -0.006399005185812712, 0.01871778629720211, 0.008182902820408344, -0.011352279223501682, 0.06484942883253098, 0.008389473892748356, 0.0681060403585434, 0.006656117271631956, 0.019664041697978973, -0.01974606141448021, 0.013795201666653156, 0.07174726575613022, 0.05403042957186699, -0.01078680157661438, -0.0058357748202979565, -0.011489464901387691, 0.012121415697038174, -0.014674018137156963, -0.04183186590671539, -0.04512001574039459, 0.00018321418610867113, 0.002773754531517625, 0.037694111466407776, 0.03299543634057045, 0.011056946590542793, -0.017468281090259552, 0.030843105167150497, -0.038284141570329666, -0.007270435336977243, -0.034216489642858505, 0.00004514203828875907, 0.01925274357199669, -0.056271083652973175, 0.027722040191292763, -0.0031949984841048717, 0.034533482044935226, 0.010363359935581684, -0.061393555253744125, -0.042271748185157776, -0.009099435992538929, 0.02139725349843502, -0.044722288846969604, 0.012559476308524609, 0.050872452557086945, 0.044021639972925186, -0.01650438830256462, 0.08336994051933289, -0.012213066220283508, -0.06479299813508987, -0.006701033096760511, -0.004660592880100012, -0.00563352694734931, 0.012194842100143433, -0.01176451425999403, 0.01044679805636406, 0.007535947486758232, 0.003054250730201602, 0.0018998116720467806, -0.037049394100904465, 0.03643353655934334, 0.05276530981063843, 0.018930545076727867, 0.005198138765990734, -0.022502154111862183, -0.027612706646323204, 0.041384633630514145, -0.011049201712012291, -0.023920398205518723, -0.030141141265630722, 0.0025528999976813793, 0.02233634516596794, 0.05543839931488037, -0.011223278939723969, 0.014310462400317192, 0.05288921669125557, -0.008678465150296688, 0.000054701700719306245, 0.016686739400029182, -0.013694805093109608, -0.008912989869713783, -0.01543826051056385, 0.015295582823455334, 0.004376900382339954, 0.007452212739735842, -0.001304957433603704, -0.011722562834620476, 0.027227871119976044, 0.02127509005367756, -0.01563280262053013, 0.044549360871315, 0.02453388273715973, -0.003960761241614819, -0.028701044619083405, -0.022290145978331566, 0.032540079206228256, -0.0028190859593451023, 0.007717568892985582, 0.045510973781347275, 0.024677524343132973, -0.010803512297570705, -0.010010829195380211, -0.02491806447505951, 0.008941197767853737, 0.025675836950540543, -0.04079196974635124, 0.009646235965192318, 0.02064448595046997, -0.04710013046860695, 0.02574119344353676, -0.0066874269396066666, -0.004448738880455494, -0.02305336855351925, 0.03417625278234482, 0.04535924643278122, -0.02880849875509739, 0.0015677730552852154, -0.03768911957740784, -0.019418057054281235, 0.022613195702433586, -0.014977985061705112, 0.059927549213171005, 0.04396072402596474, -0.041245345026254654, 0.008856256492435932, -0.042523980140686035, 0.011193959973752499, 0.04412991926074028, -0.018887370824813843, 0.01894223503768444, 0.020800769329071045, 0.009079379960894585, -0.06773670017719269, -0.029461119323968887, 0.0007653997163288295, 0.028666283935308456, -0.013255790807306767, -0.019294457510113716, 0.01800103299319744, 0.004415398463606834, -0.051610786467790604, 0.016852963715791702, -0.03829701617360115, -0.0278448686003685, -0.05736802518367767, 0.0010293081868439913, 0.023816969245672226, 0.022941483184695244, 0.02412085048854351, 0.04765583574771881, 0.010522828437387943, -0.016961582005023956, -0.0700179785490036, -0.068352609872818, -0.007023404818028212, 0.006574725732207298, 0.03055722825229168, -0.008379395119845867, -0.022174885496497154, 0.06977517902851105, 0.033283401280641556, -0.022241653874516487, -0.0528113916516304, 0.02739897556602955, -0.03931565582752228, -0.05477415397763252, 0.04323982447385788, 0.023293618112802505, -0.0045752753503620625, 0.047382697463035583, -0.011180038563907146, 0.031100470572710037, 0.01701841503381729, -0.014384164474904537, -0.026333412155508995, 0.02080502174794674, -0.036626070737838745, -0.015358849428594112, -0.016396770253777504, 0.018029484897851944, -0.002995249116793275, -0.0003296339709777385, -0.006778249051421881, 0.026722969487309456, 0.052671708166599274, -0.026732441037893295, -0.002801228780299425, -0.027171814814209938, 0.023217733949422836, -0.01060617994517088, 0.02003149874508381, 0.06848153471946716, -0.04735017195343971, -0.0012975693680346012, 0.03569372743368149, -0.0010224854340776801, -0.020828215405344963, 0.006477511953562498, 0.042112164199352264, 0.03338473662734032, -0.00895643699914217, 0.02806749939918518, -0.020043758675456047, -0.015425940044224262, -0.006540968548506498, -0.03510940819978714, -0.035688452422618866, 0.00048297931789420545, 0.06967106461524963, -0.009729227982461452, -0.020139329135417938, -0.04797990620136261, 0.011703538708388805, -0.04603217542171478, -0.01630353555083275, -0.04402410238981247, 0.06023060157895088, -0.00734369270503521, 0.051723163574934006, 0.019686797633767128, 0.006787063553929329, 0.003071097657084465, -0.00699660973623395, -0.068982794880867, 0.02166055701673031, -0.022282203659415245, -0.02597440965473652, 0.02230653539299965, -0.001953942235559225, 0.03636647015810013, -0.01393994502723217, 0.022082313895225525, -0.01016721036285162, 0.04886407405138016, -0.03330984339118004, 0.025991560891270638, -0.060334205627441406, -0.03539515659213066, 0.015024600550532341, 0.03248218074440956, 0.02230469137430191, -0.03255801275372505, 0.027411051094532013, -0.004580622538924217, -0.025476453825831413, 0.015610097907483578, 0.009589017368853092, 0.013653738424181938, -0.0025951657444238663, 0.054110731929540634, 0.02428199164569378, 0.0201383288949728, -0.02537168562412262, 0.006578040309250355, -0.016375554725527763, 0.06382967531681061, -0.00891530979424715, 0.008080411702394485, 0.03971864655613899, -0.023063834756612778, 0.01084084901958704, 0.011584450490772724, 0.02376672625541687, -0.0038936426863074303, -0.018176529556512833, 0.03682762011885643, 0.03502591699361801, -0.09431390464305878, 0.017225544899702072, 0.0709942877292633, 0.0003502525796648115, 0.016413535922765732, -0.002595319412648678, -0.009218823164701462, -0.004805068485438824, -0.00800532940775156, 0.022294906899333, -0.005161541514098644, -0.03698702156543732, -0.013731013983488083, 0.01866382360458374, -0.018878763541579247, -0.017053423449397087, 0.0002652218099683523, 0.01755138672888279, 0.047778524458408356, -0.0010875988518819213, -0.008390620350837708, -0.00448973523452878, 0.01782980002462864, 0.01867985911667347, 0.022254925221204758, 0.021451033651828766, -0.07436415553092957, 0.008779441006481647, 0.028472814708948135, 0.06123741343617439, -0.028040731325745583, -0.0031556703615933657, -0.010343767702579498, -0.02319902740418911, 0.036297984421253204, -0.005300781223922968, 0.008191000670194626, -0.025324419140815735, 0.010348484851419926, -0.025299150496721268, 0.00333025143481791, -0.06169833987951279, 0.016155846416950226, 0.014432010240852833, 0.03744826838374138, -0.03925811126828194, -0.030525600537657738, -0.05998089164495468, -0.01578521728515625, -0.01949249766767025, 0.06495935469865799, -0.010049328207969666, -0.0009401474380865693, 0.009215198457241058, 0.04989560320973396, -0.0008215336711145937, -0.05510907247662544, 0.011432243511080742, 0.01783709228038788, -0.03399397060275078, 0.04966448247432709, -0.03188540041446686, -0.07139109075069427, 0.04779636487364769, 0.021146314218640327, 0.016511883586645126, 0.03801842778921127, 0.006620436441153288, 0.0797036662697792, 0.062212951481342316, 0.017541922628879547, 0.05144919455051422, 0.021886048838496208, 0.014454486779868603, 0.04398966580629349, -0.02033565379679203, 0.010499059222638607, 0.0044873435981571674, -0.04010290652513504, -0.047709908336400986, -0.015552111901342869, -0.02097146026790142, 0.0367341972887516, -0.016450822353363037, 0.038454584777355194, -0.02854590304195881, -0.010228204540908337, -0.0036823239643126726, 0.026454225182533264, 0.00430483790114522, -0.021237054839730263, 0.03609614819288254, 0.05771617591381073, -0.011497645638883114, -0.008594067767262459, 0.025493450462818146, 0.004357757046818733, 0.04875456914305687, 0.02659802883863449, -0.018248261883854866, -0.00004713452290161513, -0.07912088185548782, 0.0024659158661961555, 0.005056845955550671, -0.02895488776266575, 0.055333495140075684, -0.015384089201688766, 0.020892664790153503, 0.003624183125793934, -0.014361944980919361, -0.000989442691206932, 0.010846685618162155, -0.013485916890203953, 0.01521453820168972, -0.026378275826573372, 0.025073980912566185, -0.02193235419690609, 0.02108832634985447, -0.05695096030831337, -0.01133758295327425, 0.006604890804737806, 0.006163117475807667, -0.02873298153281212, -0.04084343835711479, -0.01781620644032955, -0.049260903149843216, -0.021184736862778664, -0.03430837020277977, 0.0461987666785717, -0.03194059059023857, -0.02942725643515587, 0.02058875747025013, 0.05002882331609726, 0.06121521815657616, -0.03414946794509888, -0.0007620290853083134, 0.048085976392030716, -0.011452428065240383, -0.007534386124461889, 0.019955122843384743, 0.011699957773089409, -0.009314716793596745, -0.033451586961746216, -0.030096668750047684, 0.037560537457466125, 0.02536388486623764, -0.025241130962967873, -0.0073150042444467545, 0.006900401785969734, -0.006212269421666861, -0.0002447586157359183, 0.004715208429843187, -0.032130010426044464, 0.011193973012268543, 0.004277338273823261, -0.011619089171290398, 0.01742730103433132, -0.0006516244611702859, -0.02041708491742611, 0.03125888481736183, 0.010507103987038136, 0.02270534075796604, -0.02068839594721794, 0.04958394914865494, -0.0035677950363606215, 0.00940249115228653, 0.0003005862527061254, 0.006240613292902708, 0.04298862814903259, -0.008020014502108097, 0.01693291775882244, 0.013484210707247257, 0.029613038524985313, -0.03355851396918297, -0.03336837515234947, -0.07537925243377686, -0.018358835950493813, 0.04797275736927986, -0.0149772260338068, 0.053489185869693756, 0.04301982745528221, 0.014825679361820221, 0.014100730419158936, -0.04307534545660019, -0.0017833741148933768, -0.01606805808842182, 0.0016709858318790793, 0.035637691617012024, 0.009235764853656292, -0.034919075667858124, 0.019017904996871948, -0.00910866167396307, -0.008417000062763691, 0.037673577666282654, -0.009856105782091618, 0.00916748121380806, 0.025380587205290794, -0.03141205385327339, -0.03857962042093277, 0.024328183382749557, -0.06966626644134521, -0.010600757785141468, -0.031245870515704155, -0.021334553137421608, 0.02960585057735443, 0.028574727475643158, 0.020754821598529816, -0.07028783857822418, -0.001768995658494532, -0.05936376750469208, 0.023168295621871948, 0.0327829010784626, -0.059832021594047546, 0.02318410575389862, -0.0037434883415699005, 0.041824497282505035, -0.030838755890727043, -0.0043680500239133835, -0.042246606200933456, -0.0655379593372345, -0.02472471445798874, -0.042268987745046616, -0.07040679454803467, -0.015406327322125435, 0.016988694667816162, -0.034608159214258194, 0.00412515364587307, -0.012136613018810749, 0.0451020784676075, -0.008360999636352062, 0.046007052063941956, -0.016539936885237694, 0.04947715252637863, 0.02345298044383526, 0.024170992895960808, 0.01053096167743206, -0.00883985310792923, 0.13122868537902832, 0.021775247529149055, -0.0005427011637948453, -0.05684637278318405, 0.021073244512081146, -0.0041584111750125885, -0.020527014508843422, -0.0029655976686626673, 0.017821066081523895, -0.003814740339294076, 0.00010374858538853005, 0.036349181085824966, 0.05421570688486099, 0.003138846717774868, -0.020592229440808296, 0.008266962133347988, -0.07020549476146698, -0.004024472553282976, 0.03596482798457146, 0.00797838531434536, -0.04032621905207634, -0.0006247571436688304, -0.032159473747015, 0.04862920567393303, -0.008321060799062252, -0.003179796738550067, -0.030889460816979408, -0.025290660560131073, -0.004409956745803356, 0.008985847234725952, 0.0003070370585191995, 0.011922759003937244, -0.000010621405635902192, 0.012219734489917755, 0.015318651683628559, -0.007664174772799015, 0.03676008805632591, -0.018416306003928185, -0.012636653147637844, 0.026155469939112663, -0.012751872651278973, 0.016602259129285812, 0.0014770646812394261, -0.017220232635736465, -0.03193477913737297, -0.10276848822832108, -0.029323944821953773, 0.07495073974132538, -0.006696152966469526, -0.009319912642240524, 0.004232828970998526, 0.00453458447009325, 0.024716977030038834, -0.05024451017379761, -0.02502851001918316, 0.0066471644677221775, 0.04185424745082855, -0.016212858259677887, -0.0014945237198844552, -0.006595432758331299, 0.04564553126692772, -0.008156047202646732, 0.029657278209924698, 0.015095041133463383, -0.05242956429719925, -0.009608815424144268, -0.007089096587151289, 0.04019062966108322, 0.03354651853442192, 0.02891870215535164, -0.01722933165729046, -0.03817913308739662, 0.011604247614741325, -0.018939688801765442, 0.030155761167407036, -0.03211107477545738, -0.03288963437080383, -0.012338071130216122, -0.038572557270526886, -0.0051270779222249985, -0.05484490096569061, 0.017098404467105865, -0.03758625313639641, 0.0005094332154840231, -0.01298473123461008, -0.010275175794959068, 0.019692040979862213, 0.044706568121910095, 0.049844302237033844, 0.010364937596023083, 0.027348972856998444, 0.06201205775141716, 0.043229930102825165, -0.01666758954524994, -0.01453869417309761, -0.021015610545873642, -0.004181309603154659, 0.04674787074327469, 0.0011480432003736496, 0.0459514819085598, 0.0449008010327816, 0.029414145275950432, 0.012300279922783375, 0.06217964366078377, -0.016353383660316467, -0.0045653218403458595, 0.023413056507706642, -0.0625917837023735, 0.00038924787077121437, 0.01484103873372078, -0.017082851380109787, -0.026415450498461723, 0.004431706853210926, -0.03973741829395294, -0.0013934896560385823, -0.0010566285345703363, -0.03126659244298935, -0.046099960803985596, -0.0030473130755126476, -0.006708795670419931, 0.018584376201033592, -0.028427958488464355, 0.009121243841946125, -0.017625842243433, 0.020009133964776993, -0.012977171689271927, 0.033945124596357346, 0.02940875105559826, 0.005070338025689125, -0.003520980942994356, -0.010592998936772346, 0.04239243268966675, 0.01831730641424656, 0.031500957906246185, 0.007417145185172558, -0.02143142744898796, -0.03667903319001198, 0.03403811156749725, -0.015411069616675377, 0.004972180817276239, 0.0276536513119936, -0.03739480301737785, -0.02285143919289112, -0.0075401123613119125, -0.009644872508943081, 0.03503870964050293, 0.006850885227322578, -0.0023216104600578547, -0.05243774875998497, 0.02703980542719364, -0.00395678635686636, -0.005534585565328598, -0.016089623793959618, 0.04200088232755661, -0.030421530827879906, -0.025042887777090073, 0.0514422282576561, 0.002675025025382638, 0.00842229463160038, -0.011562648229300976, 0.01607920229434967, -0.027196260169148445, -0.032342053949832916, 0.00012994339340366423, -0.028839603066444397, 0.01027559582144022, -0.008244287222623825, -0.026973804458975792, 0.01844540797173977, 0.04793145880103111, -0.005848222877830267, 0.039102163165807724, -0.006739565636962652, 0.030011804774403572, -0.08427071571350098, -0.0337212048470974, -0.01622593030333519, 0.021069305017590523, 0.016763268038630486, -0.06047733500599861, -0.01395762711763382, 0.07690480351448059, -0.04743080958724022, 0.04794631525874138, -0.018422158434987068, 0.00232194853015244, -0.02446730062365532, 0.032468296587467194, -0.026705658063292503, -0.0063915010541677475, -0.000057201799791073427, -0.00790222268551588, 0.043180473148822784, 0.0327896885573864, -0.037683941423892975, -0.04382091388106346, -0.016114072874188423, 0.021679555997252464, -0.021332131698727608, -0.05960320681333542, 0.026431899517774582, -0.02005336806178093, -0.02547725848853588, 0.014548325911164284, -0.01013758685439825, 0.010103018954396248, -0.004522832576185465, 0.03581586852669716, -0.008696814998984337, 0.03571615740656853, 0.057523343712091446, 0.010929242707788944, 0.048517853021621704, -0.0032083329278975725, -0.013794522732496262, -0.02651054412126541, -0.023062342777848244, 0.01777549274265766, 0.030809657648205757, 0.007649068254977465, -0.01115011889487505, 0.005741951987147331, -0.013226775452494621, -0.02632465772330761, 0.006406288128346205, 0.022671503946185112, -0.017092769965529442, -0.058858081698417664, 0.018285462632775307, -0.03476112708449364, -0.017297472804784775, -0.03163183107972145, 0.026413684710860252, -0.04759545624256134, -0.003222360508516431, -0.025076748803257942, -0.06877624243497849, 0.013898349367082119, 0.017134537920355797, -0.045172400772571564, -0.07576984167098999, -0.010128059424459934, -0.010007255710661411, -0.011783828027546406, -0.024324486032128334, -0.01387705560773611, -0.026643548160791397, 0.047783009707927704, -0.024667710065841675, 0.021588927134871483, -0.023302767425775528, -0.0333375409245491, -0.01728278212249279, -0.09323326498270035, 0.0490637831389904, 0.03324323892593384, -0.028878770768642426, -0.034252066165208817, -0.01345280185341835, -0.027689069509506226, 0.013273468241095543, 0.05842426419258118, 0.03494683653116226, 0.016141997650265694, -0.007027633022516966, 0.03994052857160568, 0.0490633063018322, -0.03526940941810608, 0.028984611853957176, -0.06296752393245697, -0.045238759368658066, -0.014173528179526329, -0.02628442645072937, 0.022389249876141548, 0.012631003744900227, 0.001666078227572143, -0.005054368171840906, -0.03070203773677349, 0.019168416038155556, -0.023207487538456917, 0.024800514802336693, 0.009501291438937187, -0.013135980814695358, 0.0318063423037529, -0.020688019692897797, 0.020099688321352005, 0.04039512202143669, 0.012459738180041313, -0.04812249168753624, 0.002734269481152296, -0.02120489813387394, -0.055978573858737946, -0.013447331264615059, 0.04589533805847168, 0.005411035846918821, -0.05637139081954956, -0.002464421559125185, 0.05515902489423752, -0.02116972766816616, -0.0013856790028512478, 0.047764502465724945, 0.01827343925833702, 0.015313206240534782, -0.01282432395964861, 0.05613858997821808, 0.04841679707169533, -0.014200747013092041, 0.021207524463534355, 0.06380228698253632, 0.024766653776168823, -0.0041869706474244595, 0.006554034072905779, 0.005924824625253677, -0.011893238872289658, 0.014702145010232925, -0.01724434271454811, 0.005408301018178463, -0.02065204083919525, 0.004592941142618656, 0.029916536062955856, -0.03173282742500305, -0.017637887969613075, -0.019834967330098152, -0.02461448684334755, 0.04349888116121292, -0.029692864045500755, -0.009678564965724945, -0.054539818316698074, -0.004343257751315832, -0.01783457212150097, 0.007915307767689228, 0.010293083265423775, 0.03194298595190048, 0.00267895869910717, -0.013878249563276768, -0.033018484711647034, 0.004454507492482662, 0.029401082545518875, -0.014563729986548424, 0.0673416331410408, -0.00482065649703145, 0.016854053363204002, -0.020243139937520027, -0.027607617899775505, -0.028884032741189003, -0.020032964646816254, 0.007932948879897594, 0.03926093131303787, 0.010968917049467564, 0.0016065796371549368, -0.0711766928434372, -0.014811939559876919, 0.013376764953136444, -0.03193684667348862, -0.009917720220983028, -0.05509335920214653, 0.010380374267697334, 0.0032030846923589706, 0.008744372986257076 ]
<p>I have run an ACF on a function in R and it returns:</p> <pre><code>Autocorrelations of series ‘sine.curve’, by lag </code></pre> <blockquote> <pre><code> 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 1.000 0.257 -0.712 -0.677 0.249 0.825 0.243 -0.632 -0.633 0.242 0.731 0.246 </code></pre> </blockquote> <p>My question is how can I find out where this function crosses the x axis or how to predict at what lag the correlation is equal to zero using these values</p>
37,629
[ 0.011458405293524265, 0.0025720929261296988, -0.013855913653969765, -0.004007820039987564, 0.021497005596756935, -0.008119050413370132, -0.020424319431185722, -0.003587806597352028, -0.0009174004662781954, -0.017283622175455093, 0.021688804030418396, 0.03871261700987816, 0.055382903665304184, 0.05171119049191475, 0.014785431325435638, -0.0056824530474841595, -0.00938556157052517, 0.003643943229690194, 0.0336047001183033, -0.02626529335975647, -0.007610063534229994, -0.006885737180709839, -0.0007462633075192571, -0.009587869048118591, 0.005083949770778418, 0.02273644506931305, 0.05656125769019127, 0.0019976687617599964, -0.014631572179496288, 0.055207692086696625, -0.04681861400604248, -0.02216196246445179, 0.022708909586071968, 0.019873999059200287, 0.01657496765255928, 0.006195684429258108, -0.008988641202449799, -0.025589758530259132, -0.009367136284708977, 0.05085490643978119, -0.033149149268865585, -0.031162802129983902, 0.02113400399684906, 0.04263142868876457, -0.01693337969481945, -0.0019790770020335913, 0.03068152815103531, 0.010253150016069412, 0.07270485907793045, -0.0280746016651392, 0.09279683232307434, -0.03404838591814041, 0.023001916706562042, -0.0003627966798376292, 0.007767072878777981, -0.0034964177757501602, 0.05391300469636917, -0.009037652052938938, -0.018826933577656746, -0.05478476360440254, -0.04098747298121452, -0.041533347219228745, -0.009628301486372948, 0.00011856235505547374, -0.03628379479050636, 0.01596895419061184, -0.03808044269680977, -0.04002679884433746, -0.0002608564682304859, 0.0007860504556447268, -0.013496329076588154, 0.03588171675801277, 0.02808946557343006, -0.019862845540046692, 0.015605274587869644, -0.04887416213750839, 0.006385590881109238, 0.022517994046211243, 0.013941400684416294, 0.05682731419801712, -0.00945710577070713, 0.030208464711904526, 0.01270068995654583, 0.046858787536621094, 0.0256218109279871, 0.010239336639642715, 0.041543517261743546, -0.004763034172356129, 0.06665584444999695, 0.0476066991686821, 0.0031415829434990883, 0.029151029884815216, 0.051866091787815094, 0.03499311953783035, -0.03241003677248955, 0.013338601216673851, -0.017040804028511047, 0.041557617485523224, 0.012270643375813961, -0.03988417983055115, -0.004138736054301262, -0.046148188412189484, 0.00840762723237276, 0.05146251991391182, -0.0256048571318388, 0.025601336732506752, -0.03342845290899277, -0.02039176970720291, -0.010922734625637531, -0.029021169990301132, -0.01670129783451557, 0.000008471104592899792, 0.002859137486666441, -0.00823705829679966, 0.0356273278594017, 0.00013393441622611135, -0.008019395172595978, -0.006556410808116198, 0.05096348002552986, 0.05272464081645012, 0.05672933906316757, 0.00908743217587471, 0.026574531570076942, 0.016843941062688828, -0.04173805192112923, -0.017900781705975533, 0.014097514562308788, -0.0115568358451128, -0.017215987667441368, 0.061318833380937576, -0.014383316971361637, -0.03523031994700432, -0.01009623147547245, -0.009336428716778755, 0.024596553295850754, 0.014829853549599648, -0.06782983988523483, -0.0739714726805687, 0.0397770069539547, -0.007732552010565996, 0.0425557978451252, -0.03204065188765526, 0.007654497865587473, 0.019844187423586845, 0.06660909205675125, 0.024162162095308304, 0.004038646817207336, 0.015181123279035091, 0.022885385900735855, -0.0015897142002359033, -0.0009540432947687805, 0.017354318872094154, -0.0318063423037529, -0.032097890973091125, -0.03909347206354141, -0.00795825570821762, 0.009391642175614834, 0.012142320163547993, 0.0034421368036419153, -0.04025091603398323, 0.04637427255511284, 0.015045486390590668, -0.017025688663125038, -0.017298975959420204, -0.040821608155965805, -0.03041498363018036, 0.08197449147701263, 0.015578621067106724, -0.025178058072924614, -0.017538465559482574, -0.023246660828590393, 0.00574285164475441, -0.016632743179798126, 0.014208781532943249, 0.05725008249282837, -0.018905162811279297, -0.0023583255242556334, -0.0242180023342371, 0.022175855934619904, -0.0010491475695744157, -0.011255161836743355, -0.013045109808444977, 0.0015408518956974149, -0.04734918475151062, 0.03668887913227081, 0.05458356812596321, -0.022341413423419, -0.010385194793343544, 0.058656588196754456, -0.05004265159368515, -0.01747692935168743, -0.04953059181571007, 0.023142129182815552, 0.00008407803397858515, -0.013089561834931374, 0.017761249095201492, 0.0014172402443364263, 0.015910867601633072, -0.010365006513893604, -0.02342846803367138, -0.03673020750284195, 0.009312344714999199, 0.051017407327890396, -0.017264168709516525, 0.03592228516936302, -0.008838426321744919, 0.027074631303548813, -0.013518418185412884, 0.03478849679231644, -0.027691075578331947, -0.010594011284410954, 0.015228480100631714, -0.04304568096995354, 0.0025959492195397615, -0.007074287161231041, 0.004332289099693298, -0.0006377817480824888, -0.012611065991222858, -0.002459608018398285, 0.026495518162846565, -0.06058052182197571, 0.07260406017303467, 0.05294400826096535, 0.04040331766009331, 0.04456852376461029, 0.008731215260922909, 0.007956353016197681, -0.006733551621437073, -0.04849977418780327, -0.010943830944597721, -0.04467827081680298, -0.03773944452404976, 0.035182587802410126, 0.01893128827214241, -0.018355369567871094, -0.04283273220062256, 0.07184243202209473, -0.03731526806950569, 0.041978009045124054, 0.0603492446243763, -0.0032469131983816624, -0.012565388344228268, -0.0027965460903942585, 0.0057984087616205215, -0.00875654723495245, -0.005388541147112846, 0.03828760236501694, 0.03199424222111702, 0.04190949350595474, -0.0172432791441679, -0.04744577407836914, 0.06302434951066971, -0.011638288386166096, 0.02657392993569374, -0.018909506499767303, -0.008767832070589066, 0.03996821120381355, -0.030957913026213646, -0.037310414016246796, -0.00470369029790163, 0.03559636324644089, -0.013757028616964817, 0.03357415646314621, -0.00032260053558275104, 0.02136310189962387, 0.019600434228777885, -0.03698057308793068, -0.026218198239803314, 0.015657445415854454, -0.027463994920253754, 0.05497291311621666, -0.03201023489236832, -0.01345638558268547, -0.01662525348365307, -0.0014835225883871317, 0.043812330812215805, 0.048770785331726074, 0.002703800331801176, -0.01184914167970419, -0.00399902043864131, 0.001184801454655826, -0.0037811482325196266, 0.026216022670269012, 0.010840166360139847, -0.0011840772349387407, -0.014026353135704994, -0.01763921044766903, -0.01189857441931963, -0.004558551125228405, -0.00851080846041441, -0.009892480447888374, 0.007285412400960922, -0.03824019432067871, -0.06289251148700714, -0.003944110590964556, -0.0439334511756897, -0.014859769493341446, -0.031151292845606804, -0.014054382219910622, 0.032738786190748215, -0.019299503415822983, -0.059402719140052795, -0.0003160268533974886, -0.03648989275097847, 0.058553095906972885, -0.014008663594722748, -0.0020452041644603014, 0.011043376289308071, -0.03595510125160217, 0.006291006226092577, 0.0019912661518901587, -0.01970587484538555, 0.017014238983392715, -0.04283151030540466, -0.02118668332695961, -0.012709190137684345, 0.019411852583289146, -0.04733523353934288, 0.009496386162936687, -0.012367884628474712, 0.06253226101398468, 0.03775211423635483, -0.03611142188310623, -0.052732788026332855, -0.031807757914066315, -0.02134413830935955, -0.041443247348070145, 0.006713673938065767, 0.05014711618423462, 0.03924720734357834, 0.019270434975624084, -0.02881423570215702, 0.03797014057636261, 0.04224449023604393, -0.006319750566035509, 0.04919786751270294, 0.012220974080264568, -0.033027634024620056, -0.021588630974292755, 0.06168057397007942, 0.02693784050643444, 0.005922685377299786, 0.01945880800485611, -0.008600854314863682, 0.009922384284436703, -0.013336009345948696, -0.028710616752505302, -0.02116989530622959, -0.012320823036134243, -0.005654272623360157, -0.03751341998577118, 0.027021031826734543, 0.023218149319291115, -0.003549637971445918, 0.008257681503891945, -0.0078401705250144, 0.03809785842895508, 0.018903378397226334, 0.006034760735929012, 0.02392556518316269, 0.0013773634564131498, -0.053109049797058105, -0.01633930578827858, -0.08086194097995758, -0.0014140288112685084, 0.01616761088371277, -0.045683350414037704, -0.06040777266025543, 0.02987225539982319, -0.005940763745456934, 0.01265427190810442, 0.011413349770009518, -0.025126444175839424, 0.02582903578877449, -0.06784501671791077, -0.04695257917046547, -0.005374147091060877, 0.06123087927699089, 0.0430428571999073, 0.04629657790064812, 0.032482802867889404, -0.002009374089539051, 0.004187870305031538, 0.01133738737553358, -0.08982999622821808, 0.0782640278339386, 0.006507160607725382, 0.002870635362342, -0.02682948112487793, -0.0220009908080101, 0.03324015811085701, -0.03424558416008949, 0.05040357634425163, 0.040337640792131424, -0.019380947574973106, -0.025691252201795578, -0.014643223956227303, 0.004279105458408594, 0.027101071551442146, -0.0441741980612278, -0.00432733166962862, 0.05031842365860939, -0.035679496824741364, 0.07244396209716797, 0.03722685948014259, -0.012235118076205254, -0.016769830137491226, -0.010797541588544846, 0.02586911991238594, 0.04395580291748047, 0.029888495802879333, 0.027774496003985405, -0.03601400926709175, -0.03693457320332527, 0.008691846393048763, 0.006878022104501724, 0.044084738940000534, 0.060043416917324066, -0.008696982637047768, 0.0013875493314117193, -0.014706750400364399, -0.002117785159498453, 0.015496212989091873, -0.002523294650018215, 0.011133856140077114, 0.010053740814328194, 0.07327922433614731, 0.028796087950468063, -0.05714043229818344, 0.010723450221121311, 0.053443748503923416, 0.06201876699924469, -0.005254068411886692, -0.03752201423048973, -0.04283389076590538, -0.001827611238695681, 0.02697780914604664, 0.03639838844537735, -0.005231133662164211, 0.021219290792942047, 0.01879575476050377, 0.02573360688984394, -0.012845499441027641, -0.049801334738731384, -0.0017949827015399933, 0.020446866750717163, 0.0558338426053524, -0.0015954420669004321, -0.02655225433409214, 0.03135332837700844, 0.03279989957809448, 0.006688382942229509, -0.029947910457849503, -0.026271451264619827, -0.10983315110206604, -0.024696186184883118, 0.04498353227972984, 0.0272949431091547, 0.00007760506559861824, -0.02635742537677288, -0.0667131096124649, -0.006568571552634239, 0.050743311643600464, -0.05018709599971771, 0.038720760494470596, -0.043941620737314224, 0.03178329020738602, -0.036741990596055984, -0.045217983424663544, -0.07869961857795715, 0.01807989925146103, -0.00027127080829814076, 0.010487640276551247, -0.03624599799513817, -0.02534555271267891, -0.019435470923781395, 0.014550584368407726, 0.013899939134716988, 0.03225524351000786, -0.017307642847299576, 0.020224370062351227, 0.005865613929927349, 0.03096867725253105, 0.03972729668021202, -0.02268267795443535, 0.02665550261735916, -0.046779315918684006, 0.028795983642339706, 0.09154850244522095, 0.00204957346431911, 0.0030819557141512632, 0.0031878093723207712, 0.011275481432676315, 0.0182351004332304, 0.026796573773026466, -0.07997582107782364, 0.03315825015306473, 0.02527390606701374, -0.00019291750504635274, 0.03642473742365837, -0.006167386192828417, 0.0028074756264686584, -0.012923317030072212, 0.009281602688133717, 0.0102064348757267, 0.023645857349038124, -0.001299337949603796, -0.05243605002760887, -0.04134148731827736, -0.05510883778333664, 0.01225243043154478, -0.02862592414021492, 0.021767280995845795, -0.06859385967254639, 0.025803864002227783, 0.03347749635577202, 0.014681685715913773, -0.0397917777299881, 0.009643415920436382, 0.005515404976904392, -0.011059045791625977, -0.024650925770401955, -0.0005778900813311338, 0.002251468366011977, -0.04251540079712868, 0.01348344050347805, 0.02944965474307537, -0.04601140320301056, -0.009965592995285988, -0.03498133271932602, -0.010588566772639751, -0.04249805584549904, -0.04590167850255966, -0.003282073652371764, 0.0028932378627359867, 0.003524763509631157, -0.01217055693268776, -0.03291802853345871, -0.015280569903552532, 0.04285794496536255, 0.014598164707422256, 0.034093111753463745, -0.024993430823087692, 0.020130980759859085, -0.005823848769068718, -0.008641584776341915, -0.0673472136259079, -0.07836396992206573, 0.015063848346471786, 0.046408094465732574, -0.03734905272722244, -0.031558822840452194, 0.005772693082690239, -0.02805662341415882, 0.04908549785614014, -0.012187283486127853, 0.003572299610823393, -0.03536052629351616, 0.04495370760560036, 0.012107775546610355, -0.050425298511981964, 0.050774216651916504, -0.005303495563566685, 0.000793268030975014, 0.051031772047281265, 0.002322140382602811, -0.045768458396196365, -0.013079478405416012, -0.012515724636614323, -0.03479740023612976, 0.0009487956413067877, 0.0024667703546583652, -0.008594423532485962, 0.050062235444784164, 0.0020126544404774904, -0.030355652794241905, -0.04226728901267052, 0.01318218745291233, 0.004449552856385708, -0.0018930654041469097, -0.012184182181954384, -0.017573440447449684, -0.002654017647728324, 0.010717892087996006, -0.04371955990791321, -0.012070154771208763, -0.006802104413509369, 0.0075216144323349, 0.010674707591533661, -0.02816648781299591, 0.027848755940794945, 0.04547399282455444, -0.01884971745312214, -0.02647925540804863, -0.016868192702531815, 0.01614757440984249, 0.04182926192879677, -0.002929536858573556, 0.021599983796477318, -0.02826155349612236, 0.00630407826974988, -0.047486014664173126, -0.0019789598882198334, -0.03619517385959625, -0.005778626073151827, 0.0645255297422409, -0.0016658371314406395, 0.06443484872579575, 0.004205144476145506, 0.01116402167826891, -0.01912073977291584, -0.01282404363155365, -0.009199718944728374, -0.042615942656993866, 0.011074247770011425, 0.057611722499132156, -0.0072212498635053635, 0.007604483515024185, -0.0062189726158976555, -0.01726107858121395, 0.00942470133304596, 0.03705107793211937, -0.0072951423935592175, 0.020907551050186157, 0.015633713454008102, 0.02993438020348549, -0.014593378640711308, 0.015477236360311508, -0.007359120529145002, 0.03377171978354454, -0.04467817395925522, -0.014157089404761791, 0.02552279271185398, 0.016622377559542656, 0.03619427978992462, -0.029765406623482704, -0.02579035423696041, -0.043494414538145065, -0.0018991276156157255, 0.02654087357223034, -0.019358089193701744, 0.040644239634275436, 0.07027962058782578, 0.014558623544871807, -0.03387213870882988, 0.045446909964084625, -0.01637081243097782, -0.05462348088622093, -0.011224133893847466, -0.042048629373311996, -0.026052001863718033, 0.040163248777389526, 0.01909451186656952, -0.021266909316182137, 0.018246445804834366, -0.04327166825532913, 0.003262461395934224, -0.003973646089434624, 0.041144028306007385, -0.011418938636779785, 0.11918000876903534, 0.0016022607451304793, 0.028320124372839928, -0.008687462657690048, 0.0009633299196138978, 0.11776086688041687, 0.05838577449321747, 0.006602929439395666, -0.0729103609919548, 0.017423847690224648, 0.0036464761942625046, 0.0044786385260522366, -0.051511798053979874, 0.0003343303396832198, -0.01324507687240839, -0.02679373510181904, 0.07003821432590485, 0.019211459904909134, 0.04241611436009407, -0.0020883572287857533, 0.058524880558252335, -0.04074087738990784, -0.000321589526720345, -0.014451101422309875, 0.03694482520222664, 0.014407683163881302, -0.025970539078116417, -0.04318246617913246, 0.05179382488131523, -0.060102708637714386, -0.018321294337511063, -0.024926630780100822, -0.020787963643670082, 0.02327064238488674, -0.02543805167078972, -0.02542758360505104, -0.01282449159771204, 0.02772185020148754, 0.0017178686102852225, 0.03521110117435455, -0.025106290355324745, 0.04210158437490463, -0.013347936794161797, 0.0351165272295475, 0.05169306695461273, 0.012722603976726532, 0.014618504792451859, -0.004964668769389391, -0.006748734507709742, -0.0299491249024868, -0.05030861869454384, -0.019821494817733765, 0.03598259761929512, -0.016510412096977234, -0.04764571785926819, -0.029006296768784523, 0.027147572487592697, -0.00802836287766695, -0.026588551700115204, 0.0000925449057831429, -0.0015039292629808187, -0.005365583114326, -0.03837553411722183, 0.014088084921240807, -0.03738752380013466, 0.009758836589753628, 0.005148064810782671, 0.03284100443124771, 0.040299683809280396, -0.03942377120256424, -0.021895738318562508, -0.03068392165005207, 0.07278519868850708, -0.016571523621678352, -0.023373467847704887, 0.024359937757253647, 0.0014822928933426738, -0.030666125938296318, 0.02066943421959877, 0.036372650414705276, 0.01147764828056097, -0.012235614471137524, 0.0014729364775121212, -0.01276252418756485, -0.03235672414302826, -0.011825071647763252, -0.005257643759250641, -0.0512268990278244, 0.008021419867873192, -0.00041269679786637425, -0.01604342833161354, 0.0551469586789608, 0.04623094201087952, 0.022866666316986084, -0.022566206753253937, -0.02365521900355816, 0.04917227476835251, 0.040441859513521194, -0.022008584812283516, -0.01264940109103918, 0.0010301535949110985, -0.014539011754095554, 0.0034048734232783318, -0.03094358928501606, 0.0830688625574112, 0.04659329354763031, 0.014743541367352009, -0.01895086281001568, 0.014673658646643162, -0.029107505455613136, -0.007147572003304958, 0.022726833820343018, -0.005585054866969585, -0.01956646889448166, -0.015134207904338837, -0.00916631892323494, -0.0208160150796175, -0.018576934933662415, 0.0004635512887034565, -0.021877501159906387, 0.0063944351859390736, 0.015853529796004295, -0.03668038547039032, 0.030020253732800484, 0.03490785136818886, -0.02761033922433853, -0.04760490357875824, 0.01612667180597782, -0.031703345477581024, -0.0002617959107737988, -0.0007083703530952334, -0.052950385957956314, 0.014550542458891869, 0.012192417867481709, -0.04657851904630661, -0.003152008866891265, 0.007039351388812065, -0.0016023158095777035, 0.024484097957611084, -0.01764039322733879, 0.02749771811068058, -0.011744559742510319, 0.03634420782327652, -0.0041049569845199585, -0.015201440081000328, -0.010692096315324306, -0.050329145044088364, -0.01412937417626381, 0.006392885930836201, -0.01088457740843296, 0.020186612382531166, 0.01952187903225422, 0.010681080631911755, 0.018193157389760017, 0.022116532549262047, -0.00603503966704011, 0.0037734676152467728, -0.018797198310494423, 0.020607220008969307, 0.009669880382716656, 0.05450226739048958, 0.020850863307714462, -0.001856333459727466, 0.006881732493638992, 0.005337196867913008, 0.04678116738796234, 0.008008982054889202, -0.004193746484816074, 0.02207222953438759, -0.020470501855015755, -0.027352793142199516, 0.003180165309458971, -0.0006808232283219695, 0.01728297956287861, 0.05051398649811745, 0.007368125021457672, 0.02573101595044136, -0.0008352689328603446, 0.04888385534286499, -0.07475648075342178, -0.003837170545011759, 0.025310708209872246, 0.0181304682046175, 0.04900170862674713, -0.05898229405283928, -0.007439005188643932, 0.04404841735959053, -0.05890214070677757, 0.0320708267390728, 0.006442234385758638, 0.0029654400423169136, -0.021456187590956688, -0.02738766372203827, -0.023847546428442, -0.004067841451615095, 0.07372479140758514, 0.026591312140226364, 0.031147442758083344, 0.026812097057700157, 0.0044198958203196526, -0.03652745857834816, 0.01632232405245304, 0.00005145848263055086, 0.02378866821527481, -0.03147029131650925, 0.04256661981344223, -0.011696039699018002, -0.005208213813602924, 0.03517907112836838, -0.056637778878211975, 0.015506887808442116, 0.030732804909348488, 0.00009447311458643526, 0.010070805437862873, 0.023392431437969208, -0.02334403805434704, -0.029103269800543785, -0.0028608976863324642, -0.0001528100110590458, 0.042266007512807846, 0.01648859493434429, -0.02821425348520279, 0.014081088826060295, 0.015701396390795708, 0.007547116372734308, -0.012812728993594646, 0.024740813300013542, -0.016619831323623657, 0.008211532607674599, -0.04654883220791817, 0.0033298900816589594, 0.016125844791531563, -0.05382001772522926, 0.0028045636136084795, -0.004969101399183273, 0.00026959876413457096, 0.02221023663878441, 0.062246888875961304, -0.030043072998523712, -0.029851369559764862, -0.039319828152656555, -0.032364629209041595, 0.07618429511785507, -0.014085466042160988, -0.006507163867354393, -0.03721027448773384, 0.002606684807687998, -0.0302621778100729, -0.02604556828737259, 0.008197104558348656, -0.005853740964084864, 0.01501954160630703, 0.042495012283325195, -0.017015604302287102, -0.010770199820399284, 0.025052951648831367, -0.017561092972755432, 0.01399982813745737, -0.06968393176794052, 0.03430831804871559, -0.01858706772327423, -0.028192108497023582, -0.02960939332842827, -0.019383789971470833, -0.051437750458717346, 0.010613732039928436, 0.0026220909785479307, -0.025830445811152458, 0.03425455465912819, -0.029678143560886383, 0.04567202925682068, -0.015448221005499363, -0.02614978514611721, 0.03808198124170303, -0.008307314477860928, -0.025218460708856583, 0.006389607209712267, 0.0016079673077911139, 0.012838758528232574, 0.027095869183540344, -0.036977604031562805, -0.00825123768299818, -0.017347678542137146, -0.003374936757609248, -0.04225620627403259, 0.009757187217473984, 0.013500075787305832, -0.01575837843120098, 0.06515973061323166, 0.04709501564502716, -0.019401445984840393, 0.030972350388765335, -0.012957675382494926, -0.05390661582350731, 0.028112279251217842, -0.02235187217593193, -0.01865507662296295, -0.012549974024295807, 0.014359906315803528, 0.03845211863517761, -0.05953767150640488, -0.03030684031546116, 0.019344933331012726, -0.044583454728126526, -0.00941114965826273, 0.034852150827646255, -0.022620344534516335, 0.03148128092288971, -0.012041502632200718, 0.030721651390194893, -0.019233422353863716, 0.02121916599571705, -0.014643865637481213, -0.020694077014923096, 0.011792637407779694, -0.011492332443594933, 0.0012667401460930705, 0.01725386641919613, -0.005395147483795881, 0.03860193118453026, -0.05809905752539635, 0.054633818566799164, 0.006660258863121271, -0.009537262842059135, -0.010106153786182404, 0.000049563914217287675, 0.013660048134624958, 0.010674056597054005, 0.003569613676518202, 0.035359129309654236, -0.06441986560821533, 0.014076844789087772, -0.042849134653806686, -0.018275756388902664, -0.02898356132209301, 0.009868619963526726, 0.029049089178442955, 0.016203660517930984, -0.02783077023923397, 0.017504489049315453, 0.04508823901414871, -0.004314077086746693, 0.056235939264297485, 0.0030015993397682905, -0.011005964130163193, -0.03575236722826958, -0.00794241949915886, 0.020120464265346527, -0.01319055538624525, -0.04627806320786476, -0.03139716759324074, 0.01978558674454689, 0.03217194601893425, 0.007344827521592379, -0.03349453583359718, 0.017419440671801567, 0.01023171003907919, 0.06062285602092743, -0.07054764032363892, -0.02003924921154976, -0.003411093493923545, 0.030785854905843735, 0.01755126193165779, -0.019736431539058685 ]
<pre><code>import sympy sympy.init_printing() x, y, mu, sigma, density1, density2 = sympy.symbols('x y mu sigma density1 density2') eq1 = sympy.Eq(density1, 1/(sympy.sqrt(2*sympy.pi)*sigma) *sympy.exp(-(x-mu)**2/(2*sigma**2))) # normal eq2 = sympy.Eq(y, sympy.exp(x)) # substitution eq3 = sympy.Eq(density2, 1/(y*sympy.sqrt(2*sympy.pi)*sigma) *sympy.exp(-(sympy.ln(y)-mu)**2/(2*sigma**2))) # lognormal [eq1, eq2, eq3] </code></pre> <p>Output:</p> <pre><code>⎡ 2 2⎤ ⎢ -(-μ + x) -(-μ + log(y)) ⎥ ⎢ ────────── ───────────────⎥ ⎢ 2 2 ⎥ ⎢ ___ 2⋅σ ___ 2⋅σ ⎥ ⎢ ╲╱ 2 ⋅ℯ x ╲╱ 2 ⋅ℯ ⎥ ⎢density₁ = ─────────────────, y = ℯ , density₂ = ──────────────────────⎥ ⎢ ___ ___ ⎥ ⎣ 2⋅╲╱ π ⋅σ 2⋅╲╱ π ⋅σ⋅y ⎦ </code></pre> <p>How can I tell SymPy take the first (normal) density, apply the x to y substitution and output the desired second (lognormal) density?</p>
74,405
[ -0.004938666243106127, -0.02483002468943596, -0.015689792111516, -0.007871536538004875, 0.0006702630198560655, 0.02654748037457466, -0.03825639560818672, -0.029109423980116844, 0.017085760831832886, -0.03582064062356949, 0.027020536363124847, 0.022487817332148552, 0.07350972294807434, 0.02673785760998726, 0.0503697544336319, -0.0069740330800414085, 0.01929621584713459, 0.009702378883957863, -0.013074173592031002, -0.03504682332277298, -0.02577727474272251, 0.014361567795276642, 0.029715124517679214, 0.01233433187007904, 0.011398456059396267, 0.02389720268547535, -0.0011167399352416396, -0.009207818657159805, 0.0009011899237520993, 0.05043140798807144, -0.04180873930454254, -0.028408974409103394, 0.0124020054936409, -0.0003287108556833118, 0.039809662848711014, 0.017754467204213142, -0.011995515786111355, -0.007437319960445166, -0.0013280767016112804, 0.0032005920074880123, -0.03918999060988426, 0.0071447547525167465, 0.03314365819096565, 0.023389464244246483, 0.013967571780085564, 0.023361625149846077, -0.03149334341287613, -0.045401062816381454, 0.03264173865318298, -0.023277297616004944, 0.08977853506803513, 0.004711003042757511, 0.014858216047286987, 0.014710654504597187, -0.010774954222142696, 0.0004863593203481287, 0.03673654422163963, 0.03750880807638168, -0.000782014278229326, -0.06253740191459656, -0.019007621333003044, -0.022153718397021294, 0.02538241818547249, -0.028334571048617363, -0.02227824367582798, -0.017760952934622765, 0.018317343667149544, -0.01375957764685154, 0.05540025234222412, -0.004129499662667513, 0.014039590954780579, -0.0022872474510222673, 0.04636822268366814, -0.04228052869439125, 0.05369073525071144, 0.002559846267104149, -0.024338511750102043, -0.004578930325806141, 0.007234123535454273, 0.038784533739089966, 0.03601133078336716, 0.04338720440864563, -0.0012382192071527243, 0.011116873472929, 0.011324934661388397, 0.006694590672850609, 0.04883502796292305, 0.007395538035780191, -0.013705790042877197, 0.040305595844984055, 0.03822577744722366, 0.007853064686059952, 0.04374855384230614, 0.012536589987576008, -0.03049704246222973, 0.060972824692726135, -0.005845735315233469, 0.05606016516685486, -0.002963048405945301, -0.02728646621108055, -0.028843024745583534, -0.04781334474682808, 0.040372468531131744, 0.013180430978536606, -0.02800794132053852, 0.014644144102931023, -0.037932105362415314, 0.001268989173695445, 0.011967501603066921, -0.014780896715819836, -0.0330488346517086, -0.0039794063195586205, -0.012810480780899525, 0.0023227951023727655, -0.009404790587723255, -0.02785615622997284, -0.005131104029715061, 0.007633785251528025, 0.0031319695990532637, 0.052975643426179886, 0.030432580038905144, 0.028862562030553818, 0.014528806321322918, 0.002003997564315796, -0.08040561527013779, 0.0321696475148201, 0.015118315815925598, 0.0031306652817875147, -0.06600784510374069, 0.018295466899871826, -0.016175230965018272, -0.02132713422179222, -0.002745786216109991, -0.0031992336735129356, 0.04979737848043442, 0.001955223735421896, -0.09285963326692581, -0.06279437988996506, 0.019779283553361893, 0.01983887329697609, 0.056861914694309235, -0.06629624962806702, 0.011364349164068699, 0.038131944835186005, 0.03467996045947075, 0.021428100764751434, 0.004510876256972551, 0.004106833133846521, -0.004555047489702702, 0.012345252558588982, -0.02407284826040268, -0.05810112506151199, -0.00637269439175725, -0.015821289271116257, 0.009491318836808205, -0.03734641894698143, 0.04712875187397003, 0.019346708431839943, -0.02589895948767662, -0.016154054552316666, 0.060127269476652145, 0.0141298184171319, 0.022560901939868927, -0.01166980154812336, -0.022855978459119797, -0.05493686720728874, 0.06545835733413696, 0.05528825893998146, 0.005564119201153517, -0.0005768966511823237, -0.02556958980858326, -0.0006750846514478326, -0.05918945372104645, -0.00852220132946968, 0.03890352323651314, -0.06151141598820686, -0.023064889013767242, 0.0009215758764185011, 0.07790695875883102, 0.022528324276208878, -0.030599398538470268, -0.012488317675888538, -0.03168362006545067, 0.012609881348907948, -0.02374335564672947, 0.021637875586748123, 0.03014209493994713, -0.03312843292951584, 0.029096579179167747, -0.07526196539402008, -0.04564255475997925, -0.03986275941133499, 0.015199732966721058, -0.0033719846978783607, -0.01627473346889019, 0.005733620375394821, 0.03555494174361229, 0.037029508501291275, -0.01328287459909916, -0.022227302193641663, -0.005029394291341305, -0.013103406876325607, 0.06779248267412186, 0.02643217332661152, 0.007681778632104397, 0.052399564534425735, 0.04033517464995384, -0.038480594754219055, 0.023720260709524155, -0.024631138890981674, 0.010975453071296215, 0.01152319647371769, -0.008896430023014545, -0.04063570126891136, 0.02697158418595791, -0.030836498364806175, 0.004978491459041834, 0.03100098855793476, -0.006884769070893526, 0.0014280382310971618, -0.08033791929483414, 0.04093088209629059, 0.043307479470968246, 0.01825343258678913, 0.008020110428333282, 0.008791686035692692, -0.019776031374931335, 0.041039709001779556, 0.017021419480443, -0.010953876189887524, -0.04750975966453552, -0.03977016732096672, 0.052176252007484436, 0.03779938071966171, -0.01772376336157322, -0.006362543441355228, 0.028586125001311302, -0.04178256541490555, 0.06376821547746658, 0.03600216284394264, -0.014950784854590893, -0.04316554218530655, 0.002722029108554125, 0.03741257265210152, 0.03129759430885315, 0.0040521686896681786, 0.010872913524508476, 0.01748397946357727, 0.00662261713296175, -0.012140026316046715, -0.022095104679465294, 0.04841059446334839, -0.060509491711854935, -0.009703383781015873, 0.020805925130844116, -0.040094614028930664, 0.006765663158148527, -0.04501902684569359, 0.00996921956539154, 0.00019576492195483297, -0.005939962808042765, -0.006746320053935051, -0.05461200699210167, 0.0005026886938139796, 0.0007462004432454705, 0.03218083083629608, 0.004358536098152399, 0.015175282023847103, 0.027937088161706924, -0.05046990141272545, -0.02842537872493267, -0.005008921958506107, -0.01944572851061821, -0.012372960336506367, 0.02491668425500393, 0.04752732440829277, 0.029656298458576202, 0.017412418499588966, -0.017163263633847237, -0.06232868507504463, -0.0019657511729747057, 0.003966780845075846, 0.020935337990522385, -0.013987736776471138, -0.040798358619213104, 0.005379818845540285, 0.016198277473449707, -0.04466143622994423, 0.0328005775809288, -0.00885203666985035, -0.0012373552890494466, 0.016595082357525826, -0.02226811647415161, -0.027534833177924156, -0.011677127331495285, -0.004273510538041592, 0.00211141724139452, 0.0223616361618042, 0.0059114061295986176, 0.04623379930853844, 0.015220563858747482, -0.045175354927778244, 0.02498817630112171, -0.03528652340173721, -0.03147764503955841, -0.02895030379295349, -0.0324045829474926, 0.010090554133057594, -0.026229707524180412, 0.03439613804221153, 0.011731444858014584, -0.03928987681865692, -0.006785910110920668, -0.04688994958996773, 0.002613697201013565, 0.005225478205829859, 0.015763666480779648, 0.02579456754028797, -0.008144745603203773, -0.02116161398589611, 0.06642863899469376, 0.006662288215011358, 0.005705947522073984, -0.0277333352714777, 0.06240847334265709, -0.007599744945764542, -0.022890105843544006, -0.012131750583648682, -0.004893004894256592, -0.011630618013441563, 0.029372043907642365, 0.05886859446763992, 0.0135416928678751, 0.05986576899886131, -0.030610177665948868, -0.032127510756254196, 0.01578373834490776, 0.002232217462733388, -0.039175402373075485, 0.06148839741945267, -0.024487968534231186, 0.005035689100623131, 0.016420286148786545, -0.0005038344534114003, 0.016459794715046883, 0.016530342400074005, -0.0015732810134068131, 0.061292216181755066, 0.027781222015619278, 0.023319151252508163, -0.059387266635894775, 0.019807294011116028, 0.05715815722942352, -0.07418745011091232, -0.013288225047290325, 0.04077824205160141, 0.02417166344821453, -0.016727326437830925, -0.024769693613052368, 0.0633358359336853, 0.0415523499250412, -0.03779825195670128, -0.020375551655888557, 0.005470648407936096, -0.03238501027226448, 0.0314892940223217, -0.042388930916786194, -0.050385650247335434, 0.051131512969732285, 0.03480367735028267, 0.017291398718953133, -0.014126025140285492, -0.034497782588005066, -0.019464796409010887, -0.05265194550156593, 0.009381436742842197, -0.024821309372782707, 0.049808524549007416, 0.029383258894085884, 0.04876404255628586, 0.05862085148692131, -0.017900988459587097, 0.016422608867287636, 0.007540486752986908, -0.07036291062831879, 0.012685664929449558, 0.02230115234851837, -0.015778956934809685, 0.03163238242268562, -0.022195646539330482, 0.026386912912130356, -0.04505540058016777, -0.000757901812903583, 0.01926557347178459, -0.01834762655198574, -0.026090987026691437, -0.010028833523392677, -0.046035848557949066, -0.03269375115633011, -0.026451876387000084, 0.03188958391547203, 0.024796487763524055, 0.020958540961146355, 0.04700836166739464, 0.030832495540380478, -0.0011052078334614635, 0.01655483804643154, -0.020130326971411705, 0.02255929261445999, -0.006776601076126099, 0.019510481506586075, -0.0014618629356846213, 0.0516870953142643, -0.01527197752147913, -0.005942143965512514, -0.0004807223449461162, 0.03601489216089249, 0.054972123354673386, -0.020617490634322166, -0.002525263698771596, -0.028752272948622704, -0.011714935302734375, 0.017072325572371483, 0.038953036069869995, -0.008779557421803474, 0.027092667296528816, -0.017557116225361824, -0.009406579658389091, -0.02786032110452652, 0.03609994053840637, 0.09449732303619385, -0.013293624855577946, -0.02803376317024231, 0.00026538336533121765, -0.04544246941804886, -0.009294713847339153, 0.006209386978298426, -0.002521688584238291, 0.025048259645700455, -0.03162453696131706, -0.001899483148008585, 0.013846850022673607, 0.01807647943496704, 0.011135172098875046, -0.006665010005235672, 0.05912669748067856, 0.023541824892163277, 0.0056031509302556515, -0.012180906720459461, -0.013237826526165009, 0.0490814708173275, 0.03083883412182331, -0.0003713407495524734, -0.03221132233738899, -0.0688539370894432, 0.02341076359152794, 0.04146428778767586, 0.06272098422050476, 0.017061058431863785, 0.006738724652677774, -0.05042374134063721, -0.010447755455970764, 0.03761187940835953, -0.04796600341796875, 0.029563048854470253, -0.04972038418054581, 0.015016486868262291, 0.005926091223955154, -0.009216636419296265, -0.0659189447760582, 0.04468759894371033, 0.0011852510506287217, 0.01882980950176716, -0.01353298220783472, -0.03580797091126442, -0.049821384251117706, 0.005586094222962856, -0.02157880738377571, 0.06906375288963318, -0.07173646986484528, -0.025991810485720634, -0.025566449388861656, 0.012723784893751144, 0.009970639832317829, -0.06259714812040329, 0.006520195864140987, -0.01926944963634014, 0.014281722716987133, 0.06755387037992477, 0.016558030620217323, -0.017285846173763275, 0.010288765653967857, -0.0010522573720663786, -0.03835577145218849, 0.010899483226239681, 0.003751864191144705, 0.024381546303629875, 0.08764821290969849, -0.022157885134220123, 0.029620977118611336, 0.015689050778746605, -0.003752652555704117, 0.027632489800453186, -0.06316471099853516, -0.018890704959630966, -0.01847568340599537, 0.014560599811375141, -0.05816439911723137, 0.010886345990002155, -0.02958543598651886, -0.013911347836256027, 0.03073027729988098, 0.030720913782715797, -0.03748425841331482, -0.010150826536118984, -0.008952978067100048, 0.006209841463714838, -0.04401827231049538, -0.01855652406811714, 0.0012299545342102647, 0.019870586693286896, 0.020826857537031174, 0.017281053587794304, -0.01680922880768776, -0.03951333090662956, 0.018359841778874397, 0.01608967036008835, -0.005977733992040157, 0.008000626228749752, -0.04410747438669205, -0.02749103121459484, 0.030367352068424225, -0.06853687018156052, -0.009371793828904629, -0.002942968625575304, 0.03631022572517395, 0.033428337424993515, -0.04970843717455864, 0.015292097814381123, 0.024233894422650337, -0.021755168214440346, -0.018378321081399918, -0.04755500331521034, 0.06868487596511841, 0.010359550826251507, -0.014446473680436611, -0.07330264151096344, -0.013688876293599606, 0.013437911868095398, 0.001550378859974444, -0.02337808348238468, -0.03612985834479332, -0.04575754329562187, -0.008876246400177479, -0.0010854166466742754, 0.015697499737143517, 0.0023566836025565863, -0.004418738652020693, 0.0049556768499314785, -0.015922166407108307, 0.0052490318194031715, 0.06836344301700592, -0.023593496531248093, 0.05343516543507576, -0.01448843628168106, -0.011835276149213314, -0.0233464278280735, 0.017705442383885384, 0.04810017719864845, -0.009561412036418915, -0.017634712159633636, 0.017046794295310974, -0.010245845653116703, 0.03346136584877968, -0.012266137637197971, -0.029796753078699112, -0.003420339897274971, 0.036081962287425995, 0.014553260989487171, -0.012906706891953945, -0.0002853935002349317, -0.03472573310136795, 0.04507509618997574, -0.01949823647737503, 0.02342776581645012, -0.04271731153130531, -0.0026231026276946068, 0.04325466603040695, 0.030370483174920082, 0.017317289486527443, 0.016485169529914856, 0.06190135329961777, 0.027741925790905952, 0.008673165924847126, 0.004931779112666845, 0.019121412187814713, -0.024956557899713516, -0.009952702559530735, -0.014742201194167137, 0.013152540661394596, -0.04124899208545685, -0.020708201453089714, -0.014851517044007778, -0.03621663153171539, 0.0034955672454088926, 0.03879804164171219, 0.0012698366772383451, 0.01837589405477047, 0.04958157613873482, 0.00366804888471961, -0.021306950598955154, -0.012960952706634998, -0.04238381236791611, -0.003912611864507198, -0.02128584124147892, 0.03876018524169922, -0.012934195809066296, 0.03249363228678703, 0.053311701864004135, 0.03645453229546547, 0.02883303537964821, 0.035044118762016296, 0.0040989466942846775, 0.011742588132619858, 0.005304838065057993, -0.01813230849802494, 0.0036037915851920843, 0.04199296608567238, -0.06444498896598816, 0.048937272280454636, -0.01936759240925312, 0.00048086015158332884, 0.034883975982666016, 0.036935873329639435, -0.01523386500775814, -0.025852883234620094, -0.0035520773380994797, -0.050325386226177216, -0.02074306085705757, 0.04913853853940964, -0.025364408269524574, 0.024596786126494408, 0.024679124355316162, 0.018236130475997925, -0.005839950405061245, 0.006440083496272564, -0.024625828489661217, -0.07232240587472916, -0.06848727911710739, -0.0067104739136993885, 0.0026931995525956154, 0.0820712298154831, -0.0020440001972019672, -0.041751641780138016, 0.03976261988282204, 0.02902347408235073, 0.054337941110134125, 0.05490229278802872, 0.013159060850739479, -0.012395510450005531, 0.05592608451843262, -0.026866678148508072, 0.02512107416987419, -0.014975100755691528, -0.035555288195610046, 0.12409022450447083, 0.08693996071815491, 0.039701346307992935, -0.044473472982645035, 0.0032233279198408127, -0.034550271928310394, 0.02602468430995941, -0.03320853039622307, -0.0037132236175239086, 0.021594787016510963, 0.024599764496088028, -0.007349769119173288, 0.044597551226615906, 0.03800298646092415, -0.0048545715399086475, 0.014191745780408382, -0.014551427215337753, -0.03864378109574318, -0.027308987453579903, 0.02685408666729927, 0.0021536401472985744, -0.014888969250023365, -0.09625466167926788, -0.011275812983512878, -0.012747840024530888, -0.0008514088694937527, -0.03249559551477432, -0.059430841356515884, 0.04642518609762192, -0.009596126154065132, -0.01404599193483591, 0.02008354477584362, -0.004228394012898207, 0.021498527377843857, 0.025950714945793152, 0.0068207960575819016, 0.04861991107463837, -0.019014131277799606, 0.019246777519583702, 0.04657049849629402, 0.06283573806285858, -0.0018485869513824582, -0.03446943312883377, 0.03672300651669502, -0.03448641672730446, 0.0015695581678301096, -0.01638425514101982, 0.05884285643696785, -0.01411766279488802, -0.01525554433465004, -0.009196840226650238, -0.007919943891465664, 0.030337898060679436, 0.0018540617311373353, 0.018324485048651695, 0.00721146771684289, 0.017602836713194847, 0.0049796630628407, 0.0022614977788180113, 0.008778954856097698, 0.022751038894057274, -0.01130407489836216, 0.05092750862240791, 0.016088083386421204, -0.022412458434700966, -0.04614606127142906, -0.021614914759993553, 0.013688161037862301, -0.03341282159090042, -0.002204988384619355, -0.00376883614808321, 0.0011960782576352358, -0.03022964671254158, -0.0372832752764225, 0.018948320299386978, -0.0158062856644392, 0.018010729923844337, -0.015243704430758953, -0.006239549722522497, -0.0516192801296711, -0.00152106664609164, 0.014616488479077816, 0.005584071855992079, 0.012005588971078396, 0.005638681352138519, -0.026233866810798645, 0.024187149479985237, -0.002094393130391836, 0.01670144498348236, -0.04119977355003357, -0.014805014245212078, 0.04173431918025017, 0.012391402386128902, -0.053979914635419846, -0.0837964192032814, 0.021230144426226616, -0.045410916209220886, -0.03439222276210785, 0.001507620676420629, 0.027138108387589455, 0.006314834579825401, 0.036354631185531616, 0.023967444896697998, 0.05480243265628815, -0.03247326612472534, -0.009451513178646564, 0.015530972741544247, -0.022861478850245476, -0.048629797995090485, 0.027383124455809593, 0.002760411472991109, 0.0028757601976394653, -0.0012534739216789603, -0.028962695971131325, -0.023083290085196495, 0.02347230166196823, -0.021318163722753525, -0.05235262215137482, -0.01744237169623375, -0.01141137070953846, -0.007821561768651009, 0.007588695734739304, 0.021053221076726913, -0.0045014345087111, -0.01938444934785366, -0.029295165091753006, -0.0402105413377285, -0.028913116082549095, 0.006944296881556511, -0.005993100814521313, -0.046590954065322876, 0.011761642061173916, 0.0424378328025341, 0.02703283168375492, -0.024127747863531113, 0.010775727219879627, 0.006747550331056118, -0.00812601950019598, -0.039280932396650314, -0.011148747056722641, 0.00699479877948761, -0.023879999294877052, -0.026383481919765472, 0.010372418910264969, 0.021645594388246536, 0.04205172136425972, 0.019357889890670776, -0.0026523564010858536, -0.0006550938705913723, 0.06302502751350403, -0.0181406382471323, 0.011116458103060722, -0.00774525897577405, -0.018102997913956642, -0.0034754264634102583, -0.04025090113282204, 0.00872303731739521, -0.0454719252884388, -0.017247281968593597, 0.0539068765938282, 0.013187246397137642, -0.026368899270892143, 0.018990283831954002, 0.026291245594620705, 0.009715474210679531, 0.0074877431616187096, 0.010131810791790485, 0.005495298188179731, 0.045635320246219635, 0.0014854954788461328, -0.003595639718696475, -0.013889909721910954, -0.03673959895968437, 0.015516144223511219, -0.0730760246515274, -0.009840062819421291, 0.017540521919727325, -0.04110255092382431, 0.06512859463691711, -0.06159413978457451, 0.013871001079678535, 0.00624195346608758, -0.023612232878804207, -0.014566409401595592, -0.036164406687021255, -0.004707323852926493, -0.020844679325819016, 0.030834347009658813, 0.0017220651498064399, 0.06975105404853821, 0.02657468430697918, 0.036187972873449326, 0.022844670340418816, -0.008218766190111637, 0.01534197200089693, -0.01115760300308466, -0.021243730559945107, 0.014492319896817207, 0.017966214567422867, -0.03121001087129116, 0.035485126078128815, -0.040019530802965164, 0.00488530145958066, 0.01630600355565548, -0.013716308400034904, 0.010320286266505718, -0.00615327525883913, 0.04021125286817551, 0.014261994510889053, 0.031210992485284805, 0.01570918969810009, 0.007478136569261551, -0.0034070347901433706, -0.031202176585793495, 0.042747024446725845, -0.009143772535026073, -0.04726778715848923, -0.014596687629818916, -0.003954163286834955, 0.0038461987860500813, -0.04142027720808983, 0.038652002811431885, -0.02687332034111023, -0.015388463623821735, -0.03050137497484684, 0.0029123767744749784, 0.006626466289162636, -0.03644167631864548, 0.0015728895086795092, -0.014368283562362194, 0.022188855335116386, -0.011380516923964024, 0.04459478706121445, 0.000777210749220103, 0.007355235517024994, -0.020670605823397636, -0.01823083683848381, -0.013937713578343391, -0.0008194676483981311, -0.019852077588438988, 0.014829941093921661, -0.029348691925406456, 0.009795366786420345, -0.009780004620552063, 0.04999576881527901, -0.005721990019083023, -0.08117862045764923, 0.05453479290008545, 0.003970185294747353, 0.032233305275440216, 0.020568838343024254, 0.007210524287074804, 0.010096502490341663, -0.0715988501906395, 0.029603151604533195, 0.024607140570878983, -0.0076585751958191395, -0.06029050052165985, 0.004001346882432699, -0.015576496720314026, 0.0073366728611290455, 0.04250100255012512, 0.017628522589802742, -0.010850543156266212, -0.021381551399827003, 0.059728484600782394, 0.02412397414445877, -0.05323860049247742, -0.011577235534787178, -0.026207230985164642, -0.04196818172931671, -0.01716051809489727, 0.04161578789353371, -0.01702999696135521, 0.011873048730194569, 0.023281602188944817, 0.003940974362194538, -0.026459483429789543, 0.0002711715642362833, -0.06023811921477318, 0.005072728265076876, 0.018283851444721222, -0.018489303067326546, 0.04560275375843048, -0.014358502812683582, 0.01000987272709608, 0.030172811821103096, 0.000028800510335713625, -0.06290770322084427, 0.043684158474206924, -0.025273535400629044, -0.04489729925990105, -0.05164193734526634, -0.03150705248117447, 0.036100953817367554, -0.0195650402456522, -0.014528566040098667, 0.02223202772438526, -0.047228265553712845, -0.03874000161886215, 0.021273890510201454, 0.008808323182165623, 0.05367391183972359, -0.0021102989558130503, 0.035937532782554626, 0.021788913756608963, -0.029374608770012856, 0.008057237602770329, -0.0017898286459967494, -0.020351657643914223, -0.015882529318332672, -0.01448600459843874, -0.010028984397649765, -0.04357442259788513, 0.030016176402568817, -0.014035818167030811, 0.05404213070869446, -0.018664659932255745, -0.005651895888149738, 0.023140843957662582, -0.00025764910969883204, 0.022539936006069183, -0.012810742482542992, -0.012623251415789127, 0.051354408264160156, -0.030390875414013863, 0.026118958368897438, -0.012719595804810524, -0.027353568002581596, -0.05343043804168701, -0.006862543523311615, 0.04400315880775452, 0.020790569484233856, 0.01356351375579834, 0.022056415677070618, -0.0027919516433030367, -0.00928105041384697, 0.00015215117309708148, -0.02660515531897545, -0.007424754090607166, 0.009832685813307762, -0.012084084562957287, 0.04997692629694939, 0.004635822027921677, -0.029524847865104675, -0.015614751726388931, 0.0669708177447319, 0.01733299158513546, 0.018427355214953423, -0.035750024020671844, -0.059653863310813904, -0.023607393726706505, 0.05770251154899597, -0.0397358275949955, -0.01048373058438301, 0.0024289910215884447, -0.000005026291091780877, 0.034677207469940186, -0.06764714419841766 ]
<p>So I often have the situation where I want to compare the runtime of two computer processes. Even when measuring only user+system time (as opposed to wall clock time) there is a random element in the measured time. I'm going to suppose that this randomness is poisson distributed (task switches and interrupts from random events on the computer system). </p> <p>My hypothesis is that a single program with identical input will run in some amount of time which is composed of a constant amount of time to execute the instructions and some random amount of time generated by one or more poisson process. </p> <p>So let's simplify for the moment and assume that there's one poisson process and each time it happens it accounts for the same amount of time. We don't know lambda, nor t(lambda), the time associated with it. I can, however, run the same program on the same input many many times. </p> <p>How can I estimate what the constant part of the run time is? How can I estimate lambda and t(lambda)?</p> <p>The deeper issue is...</p> <p>If I have two programs that do the same thing and I want to estimate the probability that one runs faster than the other how would I do this? It seems that blindly applying the normal distribution could be problematic. The random part is (I believe) poisson; but before applying the poisson distribution I'd have to factor out the constant portion. </p>
37,275
[ -0.017207108438014984, -0.024253007024526596, -0.0017816320760175586, -0.035572655498981476, 0.00304548442363739, 0.013880436308681965, 0.025427669286727905, -0.016184572130441666, 0.025286681950092316, 0.009138907305896282, 0.018657367676496506, 0.06569045782089233, 0.04262525960803032, 0.030900368466973305, 0.030160363763570786, -0.02204328030347824, -0.0052362168207764626, -0.018470661714673042, -0.007921195589005947, 0.0013395454734563828, 0.02444285899400711, 0.015622146427631378, 0.01975487358868122, -0.043442510068416595, 0.0036542690359055996, 0.04010689631104469, -0.008644264191389084, -0.04424930736422539, -0.0007047918625175953, 0.0575755313038826, -0.0489904023706913, -0.006650111172348261, 0.0007466704118996859, 0.05938132107257843, 0.01442813966423273, 0.018779940903186798, -0.05435865744948387, -0.039175089448690414, -0.00988568365573883, 0.02731981687247753, -0.052935536950826645, 0.006407878361642361, -0.008566051721572876, 0.03430396690964699, -0.007411183789372444, 0.03393615782260895, -0.0466802679002285, -0.048517145216464996, 0.01597360521554947, -0.036878276616334915, 0.042523231357336044, -0.023011447861790657, 0.06770066916942596, 0.0016457742312923074, -0.005476261489093304, -0.0047811525873839855, 0.06454908847808838, 0.06598538160324097, -0.017584221437573433, -0.03805450722575188, -0.02642480842769146, -0.0001366334909107536, -0.020315302535891533, -0.004318916704505682, -0.022717300802469254, -0.010561571456491947, -0.037355780601501465, -0.034106042236089706, 0.013510702177882195, -0.00784730538725853, 0.012703316286206245, 0.02452043443918228, 0.056773263961076736, -0.023074546828866005, 0.010065062902867794, -0.019048282876610756, 0.0464489683508873, 0.0223689042031765, 0.02657235786318779, 0.04435167461633682, 0.006670521106570959, -0.0035667703486979008, 0.01838577724993229, 0.0582316555082798, 0.03901538625359535, -0.01213585864752531, 0.051665905863046646, 0.001566003542393446, 0.0022299960255622864, 0.04616256430745125, -0.01321778167039156, 0.006872922647744417, 0.03797021880745888, -0.015032248571515083, -0.029462963342666626, 0.04823489114642143, -0.0075386599637568, 0.0015605746302753687, 0.018973568454384804, 0.0068306028842926025, -0.0005353231099434197, -0.05070844292640686, 0.02898215688765049, 0.05589728429913521, -0.0009439895511604846, 0.02303442172706127, -0.019213806837797165, -0.0010738628916442394, -0.01103172730654478, -0.008210442028939724, -0.048768289387226105, -0.006583893205970526, 0.026201395317912102, -0.0005258635501377285, -0.01109773013740778, 0.019445080310106277, 0.014886897057294846, -0.013644173741340637, 0.06582798063755035, 0.06815271079540253, -0.002834255574271083, -0.014052540995180607, 0.029194597154855728, -0.0361892394721508, -0.0190589539706707, 0.012752474285662174, 0.024585431441664696, -0.034783508628606796, -0.0719093605875969, 0.05548199638724327, 0.004854399710893631, -0.016769198700785637, 0.026650821790099144, -0.015798378735780716, 0.07432869076728821, -0.0077595156617462635, -0.07689196616411209, -0.0491769053041935, 0.00982331670820713, -0.0062402100302278996, -0.00826103426516056, -0.06364824622869492, 0.0019179770024493337, 0.017369406297802925, 0.04474402964115143, 0.012813976034522057, 0.023056820034980774, -0.03380146995186806, -0.005049673840403557, 0.0137369055300951, -0.04670684412121773, -0.01201749686151743, 0.0270290095359087, 0.006919903680682182, 0.01589362323284149, -0.08190366625785828, -0.014650489203631878, 0.030272623524069786, 0.0006649703718721867, 0.012631194666028023, 0.00209738384000957, 0.03468805178999901, -0.01632913574576378, -0.03879685699939728, 0.05583357438445091, -0.07696769386529922, 0.066600501537323, -0.004066078457981348, 0.03885938972234726, -0.016486430540680885, -0.003598009003326297, 0.02072744257748127, 0.010289357975125313, 0.019534707069396973, 0.05829678848385811, -0.05086120218038559, -0.03089994005858898, 0.016102613881230354, -0.0058177802711725235, 0.00563536211848259, -0.002968407701700926, -0.0057145641185343266, 0.018696293234825134, -0.013481615111231804, 0.03164484724402428, 0.03986639529466629, 0.0014077381929382682, 0.03991570696234703, 0.011740276589989662, -0.01343289203941822, -0.05136089399456978, -0.08447626978158951, -0.0015382744604721665, 0.001959403743967414, -0.029223976656794548, 0.060196779668331146, -0.003884943900629878, 0.012247280217707157, -0.00485632661730051, -0.025221936404705048, -0.01085545402020216, -0.021740306168794632, 0.04455156251788139, -0.05018123611807823, 0.00022115542378742248, 0.0794878676533699, 0.030890945345163345, -0.009334899485111237, 0.04661369323730469, -0.010920866392552853, -0.07360643893480301, 0.013213932514190674, -0.07712855935096741, 0.0004248493060003966, 0.014925205148756504, 0.016277624294161797, 0.04142078384757042, -0.00792010873556137, -0.0039308262057602406, -0.006170322187244892, -0.020095454528927803, 0.03707373887300491, 0.035791486501693726, 0.023074477910995483, -0.003086433280259371, 0.01692206785082817, 0.01843406818807125, -0.04231594502925873, -0.0008907996816560626, -0.03291705623269081, -0.03607666492462158, -0.04215569794178009, 0.03999197110533714, 0.04837419465184212, -0.012939311563968658, 0.019836435094475746, 0.060997676104307175, 0.012788154184818268, 0.03396143764257431, 0.040416739881038666, -0.023574819788336754, -0.006194051820784807, 0.013665691018104553, 0.038506198674440384, 0.011947277933359146, 0.023556387051939964, 0.025926927104592323, -0.0006506252684630454, 0.011171728372573853, -0.0036204156931489706, -0.005685950629413128, 0.047185271978378296, 0.030946822836995125, 0.03227737173438072, -0.004163790959864855, -0.03836730495095253, 0.05263383686542511, 0.010716193355619907, 0.00725625129416585, 0.018741121515631676, 0.004354679957032204, 0.0010750911897048354, 0.01585145853459835, -0.040214020758867264, -0.005182249005883932, -0.02348647639155388, -0.043060507625341415, 0.008029062300920486, 0.024171367287635803, -0.024640215560793877, 0.024144278839230537, -0.012707667425274849, -0.016890034079551697, -0.045085545629262924, 0.006348434370011091, -0.008107470348477364, 0.006450823042541742, 0.015640629455447197, -0.05481281876564026, -0.0126756327226758, 0.029646217823028564, -0.013851897791028023, -0.007954034954309464, -0.017971837893128395, -0.03894172981381416, 0.01800551265478134, 0.005713386461138725, -0.06370565295219421, 0.021181374788284302, -0.018029486760497093, 0.026809241622686386, 0.018075082451105118, -0.012754683382809162, -0.06209805607795715, 0.01608407311141491, -0.036514442414045334, 0.008368396200239658, -0.06528576463460922, -0.014433806762099266, 0.04004760459065437, 0.04694565385580063, -0.04462328180670738, 0.027891144156455994, -0.010617813095450401, -0.02549220621585846, -0.01783672533929348, 0.007509786169975996, 0.0329667404294014, -0.026905305683612823, 0.03212207183241844, 0.044097259640693665, -0.020873870700597763, -0.02937125600874424, -0.05248288810253143, -0.08739177882671356, 0.03397195413708687, 0.0007287865155376494, 0.06564580649137497, -0.016660988330841064, -0.04705865681171417, 0.08276680111885071, 0.008062462322413921, -0.01000826247036457, 0.0018786363070830703, 0.014798348769545555, -0.0192802082747221, 0.03013279289007187, 0.015316253527998924, -0.009230162017047405, -0.03507813811302185, 0.028146591037511826, 0.014157322235405445, 0.03199164569377899, 0.050989169627428055, 0.015703590586781502, 0.0027559837326407433, 0.0318494588136673, 0.01846121996641159, -0.005812357645481825, 0.03626566752791405, -0.026464754715561867, -0.0006184601807035506, -0.001045013079419732, -0.02150765433907509, -0.009859626181423664, 0.0007951465668156743, -0.05622874200344086, 0.03515153378248215, -0.01580478437244892, -0.006972014904022217, -0.050032928586006165, 0.007205802947282791, -0.022572655230760574, -0.029599962756037712, -0.000033127740607596934, 0.04694420099258423, 0.012257540598511696, -0.019271977245807648, 0.03206755965948105, 0.06922802329063416, 0.058872584253549576, -0.0060845292173326015, -0.08166037499904633, -0.060454171150922775, -0.02558521181344986, -0.0147072309628129, -0.028876161202788353, -0.04169704392552376, 0.03199327364563942, 0.04403415322303772, 0.03389997407793999, -0.015616427175700665, -0.023239977657794952, -0.028524287045001984, -0.0658295527100563, -0.008558702655136585, -0.008727826178073883, 0.0695691853761673, 0.034794360399246216, 0.05338968336582184, 0.03206457197666168, -0.0030065046157687902, 0.009186496026813984, -0.006428628694266081, -0.08695454150438309, 0.017158979550004005, -0.028676241636276245, -0.027091454714536667, -0.00828750990331173, -0.009686687029898167, 0.036667514592409134, -0.010602360591292381, 0.001958599779754877, -0.0004854399594478309, 0.021513929590582848, -0.0431983545422554, 0.029171420261263847, -0.025469541549682617, -0.045575667172670364, -0.009296792559325695, -0.007245456334203482, -0.008344097062945366, -0.012148425914347172, 0.007826515473425388, 0.015011974610388279, -0.027733521535992622, -0.031726520508527756, -0.03112064115703106, 0.01745140179991722, -0.018730152398347855, 0.02928689867258072, 0.029111631214618683, 0.052172090858221054, 0.0011845221742987633, 0.01332708727568388, 0.0011158189736306667, 0.05273912847042084, 0.05941358953714371, 0.004366907756775618, 0.0087999626994133, -0.07683111727237701, -0.03486451134085655, 0.004953738767653704, 0.026418088003993034, -0.012492837384343147, 0.005302636418491602, 0.050575822591781616, 0.05423960089683533, -0.032638683915138245, 0.014783846214413643, 0.06108938902616501, 0.015457257628440857, 0.001971873687580228, -0.02936016395688057, -0.00496855890378356, -0.02054826356470585, -0.01779339089989662, -0.011366848833858967, 0.00872093252837658, 0.008668677881360054, 0.012347233481705189, 0.007882531732320786, -0.03848380595445633, -0.013277118094265461, -0.004493958782404661, -0.000016859106835909188, 0.02819855511188507, 0.019830400124192238, -0.005054057575762272, 0.0232868455350399, 0.04381700977683067, -0.013705549761652946, 0.02301165647804737, -0.02436145581305027, -0.07257737964391708, -0.040550827980041504, 0.045727793127298355, 0.013672634959220886, -0.030328866094350815, -0.023031573742628098, -0.017178896814584732, 0.0016400138847529888, 0.05227544158697128, -0.019056281074881554, 0.02632969804108143, -0.01075618714094162, 0.00010829720122274011, -0.011987702921032906, -0.009151940234005451, -0.025717591866850853, 0.014108655042946339, 0.024007556959986687, 0.03988860175013542, -0.03191233426332474, -0.013136678375303745, -0.031288210302591324, 0.010201402008533478, 0.01973053254187107, 0.0472295768558979, -0.011112935841083527, 0.0029935825150460005, 0.0029075290076434612, 0.02253473363816738, 0.0010669877519831061, -0.0627492368221283, 0.015084444545209408, 0.012820434756577015, 0.010094869881868362, 0.04331792891025543, -0.03350955247879028, -0.021618396043777466, 0.019812997430562973, -0.01310321968048811, -0.03233403339982033, 0.00228658108972013, -0.00932885892689228, 0.06423711031675339, 0.037890952080488205, 0.004153849557042122, 0.03128470480442047, 0.0025553409941494465, -0.0065994360484182835, -0.02220887690782547, 0.0032711850944906473, 0.004350421950221062, -0.04852205142378807, 0.01426608581095934, -0.026180891320109367, -0.013370689935982227, -0.014682966284453869, 0.04407122731208801, 0.00807396974414587, 0.02980678714811802, -0.02350524812936783, -0.007173888385295868, -0.008722336031496525, 0.021920062601566315, 0.019886275753378868, 0.009663810953497887, -0.010788492858409882, -0.014280160889029503, -0.016350792720913887, -0.017531445249915123, -0.03017229028046131, -0.01651473343372345, 0.014177639968693256, -0.0013179625384509563, 0.0038674522656947374, 0.012843655422329903, -0.029558828100562096, -0.010884168557822704, 0.02458183467388153, -0.028127191588282585, 0.019359592348337173, 0.027248503640294075, 0.03673643246293068, 0.012341395951807499, -0.0435885488986969, -0.01454912405461073, 0.02187838777899742, 0.00928478129208088, 0.0187060683965683, -0.045778557658195496, 0.06622309982776642, -0.021747805178165436, -0.012566388584673405, -0.09517038613557816, -0.03966381773352623, 0.021228395402431488, -0.007561991456896067, -0.009617717005312443, -0.061025220900774, 0.022991925477981567, -0.007746624294668436, -0.013540945947170258, 0.027185408398509026, 0.008197653107345104, 0.008890848606824875, -0.01973508484661579, 0.013129067607223988, 0.007869222201406956, 0.05832838639616966, 0.021221410483121872, -0.0015217753825709224, -0.023089168593287468, -0.020584501326084137, -0.01098470576107502, -0.0006595018785446882, 0.009788893163204193, -0.005235269665718079, -0.007913703098893166, -0.003163066692650318, -0.0054266308434307575, 0.02494909055531025, -0.048644058406353, -0.006062578875571489, 0.04255026578903198, 0.019820135086774826, 0.013897568918764591, -0.012451205402612686, 0.008990153670310974, 0.024412889033555984, 0.04532545059919357, 0.007291351445019245, -0.014456165954470634, -0.02515525370836258, 0.018807988613843918, 0.047218747437000275, 0.00981946475803852, 0.009016068652272224, 0.03902798891067505, 0.04310338571667671, -0.00362721411511302, -0.025852208957076073, -0.005527150817215443, -0.016461357474327087, 0.0278477780520916, -0.029069555923342705, -0.003617482027038932, 0.04445165768265724, -0.01689503714442253, -0.03458360210061073, -0.002947229892015457, -0.057935718446969986, -0.024491863325238228, 0.03668506070971489, -0.035959869623184204, 0.07916579395532608, 0.0301112812012434, -0.007936257869005203, -0.029373008757829666, 0.004793691448867321, -0.0047278800047934055, -0.04233510047197342, -0.004476561676710844, 0.039935190230607986, -0.013606729917228222, -0.013690846040844917, 0.03972950950264931, 0.022877829149365425, 0.009775497019290924, 0.025617120787501335, -0.005388942547142506, 0.0029757425654679537, 0.042690522968769073, -0.018047010526061058, -0.021123910322785378, 0.03234633430838585, -0.038386110216379166, 0.01795291341841221, -0.015326844528317451, -0.02094283699989319, 0.0729510635137558, 0.013032497838139534, -0.010141922160983086, -0.051121968775987625, -0.014211621135473251, -0.052191175520420074, 0.03844804689288139, 0.019516443833708763, 0.01648014597594738, 0.021635333076119423, 0.033470652997493744, 0.04821962118148804, 0.008400220423936844, 0.02894776314496994, -0.03433258458971977, -0.07493782043457031, -0.014414086937904358, -0.02584828995168209, -0.03025674819946289, 0.06410275399684906, -0.014699050225317478, -0.029607567936182022, 0.03118506632745266, -0.031918611377477646, 0.023874282836914062, 0.004977426026016474, 0.03325604274868965, -0.02978350594639778, 0.11730112135410309, 0.013336436823010445, 0.019760949537158012, -0.024477312341332436, 0.02709619700908661, 0.12637515366077423, 0.07359420508146286, 0.0028702691197395325, -0.06417271494865417, -0.013515222817659378, -0.020244842395186424, -0.009625565260648727, 0.0033439667895436287, -0.008704063482582569, 0.030664799734950066, -0.018188592046499252, 0.05128077045083046, 0.012821975164115429, 0.01757689006626606, -0.013836618512868881, 0.06559380888938904, -0.015523241832852364, -0.002389739267528057, 0.012119458988308907, 0.05892493203282356, 0.04534680396318436, -0.03514789044857025, -0.023884175345301628, 0.04326152056455612, -0.03716762363910675, 0.0417429618537426, 0.006353052332997322, -0.005480360239744186, -0.02885860577225685, -0.028625428676605225, -0.022437965497374535, 0.005322489887475967, 0.06331184506416321, -0.035065311938524246, 0.029237233102321625, -0.021061863750219345, -0.011254305019974709, -0.002791754202917218, 0.01945701614022255, 0.031114311888813972, 0.016152391210198402, -0.01585548371076584, 0.025222543627023697, 0.01733367331326008, -0.0348653607070446, -0.017898665741086006, -0.042823512107133865, 0.012577689252793789, -0.02878263220191002, 0.008426065556704998, 0.01727754808962345, -0.006762522738426924, -0.010110413655638695, -0.03625969588756561, 0.010733706876635551, -0.015475401654839516, 0.021230526268482208, -0.017548104748129845, 0.014311365783214569, -0.03405191749334335, 0.03833864629268646, -0.019466446712613106, 0.021035823971033096, 0.00872107595205307, -0.020407967269420624, -0.027087625116109848, -0.023721029981970787, 0.05380598083138466, -0.009687047451734543, -0.03179387375712395, -0.026280898600816727, -0.07451269775629044, -0.021090954542160034, 0.017382362857460976, -0.0036378742661327124, -0.03015858307480812, 0.061459414660930634, 0.009503554552793503, -0.013752536848187447, -0.004867877345532179, -0.049192801117897034, 0.019610337913036346, 0.007684965617954731, 0.01915750466287136, -0.042131438851356506, -0.013981431722640991, 0.035536106675863266, 0.045309651643037796, 0.015126628801226616, 0.037858422845602036, 0.010701591148972511, 0.03814432770013809, 0.009594746865332127, -0.040537647902965546, 0.014927485957741737, -0.009579758159816265, -0.0013172191102057695, 0.0012408893089741468, -0.03373138979077339, 0.023520827293395996, 0.009639497846364975, 0.022732967510819435, -0.052763331681489944, 0.02189590595662594, -0.017010647803544998, 0.024361034855246544, -0.0037684207782149315, -0.039240650832653046, -0.045081812888383865, 0.006107049062848091, 0.009974599815905094, -0.04029858112335205, -0.009885764680802822, -0.021780498325824738, -0.0048890504986047745, -0.0016414568526670337, -0.03724246472120285, -0.021627767011523247, -0.0061552440747618675, -0.012224649079144001, 0.009894839487969875, -0.0024533618707209826, 0.010097114369273186, 0.021513069048523903, 0.01102770958095789, 0.023430583998560905, 0.013709893450140953, -0.0030086885672062635, 0.006033455487340689, 0.05693794786930084, -0.03738904744386673, 0.020458469167351723, 0.022132715210318565, 0.022441525012254715, 0.01268739253282547, 0.009964507073163986, -0.003975955303758383, 0.019765114411711693, -0.05043758451938629, -0.0000769516482250765, 0.06744355708360672, -0.043647147715091705, -0.008904204703867435, 0.05999530479311943, -0.009032093919813633, 0.025473501533269882, 0.025927243754267693, -0.0389503575861454, 0.007305476814508438, 0.01889629289507866, -0.0674145519733429, -0.018295971676707268, -0.013263060711324215, 0.006762079428881407, -0.0040049864910542965, -0.0069080232642591, 0.009767228737473488, 0.022209960967302322, -0.0061037433333694935, -0.01205141469836235, 0.010165839456021786, -0.03141583129763603, 0.025338739156723022, -0.012865694239735603, 0.010097569786012173, 0.0212877094745636, 0.010989181697368622, -0.011522280052304268, 0.03298453241586685, 0.049238648265600204, -0.025915848091244698, 0.007921005599200726, -0.04059358313679695, -0.041546981781721115, -0.08557073771953583, 0.027776697650551796, 0.0022150150034576654, -0.026738688349723816, 0.027051761746406555, -0.0019817224238067865, -0.03755009546875954, 0.004130554385483265, -0.04655277356505394, 0.008784830570220947, -0.007913908921182156, -0.008296272717416286, -0.045602962374687195, 0.013065250590443611, -0.03027937188744545, 0.015276610851287842, 0.01091540977358818, 0.005133776925504208, 0.059424884617328644, 0.06182507053017616, -0.012388475239276886, -0.022071711719036102, -0.03999369591474533, 0.020160594955086708, 0.03756257891654968, -0.04877285286784172, 0.026591885834932327, -0.0401504822075367, -0.03008808195590973, 0.026656003668904305, 0.013904871419072151, 0.011072099208831787, -0.04741543158888817, 0.020859288051724434, 0.0023313683923333883, 0.04710157588124275, 0.03122120350599289, -0.008533854968845844, 0.028445618227124214, -0.012651605531573296, 0.02547953650355339, 0.043724242597818375, -0.022099869325757027, -0.025877365842461586, 0.05193442851305008, -0.019128387793898582, -0.0253728237003088, 0.04036818817257881, 0.01273217424750328, -0.031667813658714294, 0.0313742496073246, -0.00021165407088119537, 0.014534213580191135, -0.004673134535551071, 0.010157852433621883, -0.06074286624789238, -0.0006413100636564195, 0.04344994202256203, 0.0304864514619112, -0.04698104038834572, 0.015319923870265484, -0.017308291047811508, -0.0254350733011961, 0.03693046420812607, 0.01392316073179245, -0.018994292244315147, -0.060834892094135284, -0.0071974629536271095, -0.03308667615056038, 0.048144277185201645, -0.03344001621007919, -0.04163374751806259, -0.021406851708889008, 0.02363305166363716, -0.035279400646686554, 0.0058831642381846905, -0.02925831452012062, 0.022086292505264282, 0.027632303535938263, -0.041538141667842865, 0.024710871279239655, 0.016299128532409668, -0.012826656922698021, -0.0683712363243103, -0.021948853507637978, -0.04393201693892479, -0.00778758991509676, 0.05816091224551201, 0.006004314869642258, -0.025420768186450005, -0.009335296228528023, 0.03091474436223507, 0.01820545084774494, -0.06996750086545944, -0.00582139054313302, -0.04661082848906517, -0.04513058066368103, 0.0018599919276311994, -0.06252214312553406, 0.0073044514283537865, 0.010934666730463505, 0.018725667148828506, -0.007933972403407097, -0.021805379539728165, 0.012132514268159866, -0.031715359538793564, 0.0174015574157238, 0.003202103776857257, 0.005716816987842321, 0.029555927962064743, 0.010288526304066181, 0.016802506521344185, 0.009391764178872108, 0.02461477369070053, -0.06964248418807983, 0.029562480747699738, -0.01840115152299404, -0.03606561943888664, -0.008537515997886658, 0.01715134270489216, -0.0064493343234062195, -0.07702986150979996, -0.03089229390025139, 0.025168439373373985, -0.041248563677072525, 0.002178624738007784, 0.042969539761543274, -0.0015150482067838311, 0.01949421316385269, 0.00523380609229207, 0.04061179235577583, 0.02532610483467579, 0.013402167707681656, 0.02022694982588291, 0.017993513494729996, 0.023325558751821518, -0.023651357740163803, 0.02837454527616501, 0.013740678317844868, -0.02399769052863121, 0.055773794651031494, -0.004442250821739435, 0.04676488786935806, -0.05331595987081528, -0.03790213167667389, 0.012003087438642979, 0.0004743548633996397, -0.015771394595503807, 0.04532875865697861, -0.01621878892183304, 0.06414864957332611, 0.0023748772218823433, 0.015714993700385094, -0.03177674487233162, -0.012883254326879978, -0.010646206326782703, -0.0156879760324955, 0.01808151789009571, -0.0009675862966105342, -0.03484682738780975, 0.020531445741653442, -0.02680528350174427, 0.011896476149559021, 0.030268821865320206, -0.039569318294525146, 0.006920682732015848, 0.026987703517079353, 0.006676594726741314, -0.03453681245446205, -0.0365128330886364, -0.058106228709220886, -0.015283860266208649, 0.01587863080203533, 0.036607567220926285, 0.031175024807453156, 0.006071694195270538, -0.0365012064576149, 0.02278398722410202, 0.04623774439096451, -0.08366911858320236, -0.0026455814950168133, -0.04276805371046066, 0.0038171764463186264, 0.006950008682906628, -0.001746756606735289 ]
<p>In some real-life problems such as authentication, we only have training data for one label (x is authenticated) while the other label doesn't have any data or only few entries (x is an imposter).</p> <p>What kind of changes should we do in order to adjust a classifier to deal with a label targeted for other/unknown entries?</p>
74,406
[ -0.038051787763834, -0.010120326653122902, -0.014135654084384441, 0.021253997460007668, 0.04232071340084076, 0.0024707799311727285, -0.03785613179206848, 0.006149961147457361, 0.017742052674293518, 0.0027518479619175196, 0.05253307893872261, 0.025353066623210907, 0.04598516970872879, 0.03228376805782318, -0.01614641770720482, 0.01181154977530241, 0.007005489431321621, -0.01840677671134472, -0.015572413802146912, -0.008888526819646358, -0.011809269897639751, 0.023156663402915, 0.011038672178983688, 0.010109505616128445, -0.005032925866544247, 0.032852254807949066, 0.039936378598213196, -0.032951634377241135, 0.04398462921380997, -0.015374782495200634, -0.050043147057294846, 0.0007690633065067232, 0.013369050808250904, 0.006012240424752235, 0.019251558929681778, -0.016366302967071533, -0.019680054858326912, -0.05467376857995987, -0.00348083907738328, 0.034757934510707855, -0.04130861163139343, -0.003892052685841918, 0.021051457151770592, 0.051236592233181, 0.02148088812828064, 0.031063146889209747, -0.0524383969604969, -0.0254888366907835, 0.01652463898062706, -0.020331937819719315, 0.05274393409490585, 0.0011034330818802118, 0.012247446924448013, 0.0458129420876503, -0.028257448226213455, -0.02569539286196232, 0.06118264049291611, 0.07660668343305588, -0.010738937184214592, -0.018251879140734673, -0.0016654724022373557, -0.01074533723294735, -0.019460072740912437, -0.02345009334385395, -0.0010116287739947438, 0.0319388248026371, 0.00037013698602095246, 0.0031349703203886747, 0.03578938916325569, -0.007365844212472439, 0.005275249015539885, 0.030377821996808052, 0.04081261530518532, -0.027250271290540695, 0.0422651506960392, -0.02461426332592964, 0.008710778318345547, 0.08113110810518265, 0.0535733737051487, 0.014429348520934582, 0.0587184876203537, -0.0050859106704592705, 0.049610868096351624, 0.033545926213264465, 0.03117336891591549, -0.006666886154562235, 0.059368543326854706, -0.02502332627773285, 0.013742415234446526, 0.017032498493790627, -0.011872860603034496, 0.01974809169769287, 0.05448030307888985, -0.022238710895180702, -0.040419209748506546, 0.016862304881215096, -0.018387190997600555, 0.00019837873696815223, 0.007269146386533976, -0.008237125352025032, 0.003410573583096266, -0.0038227729965001345, -0.000922017265111208, 0.048049088567495346, -0.02966023050248623, -0.010569140315055847, -0.05291008576750755, -0.04184168577194214, -0.016520924866199493, -0.01832583360373974, -0.026558982208371162, 0.03995485231280327, -0.01871310919523239, 0.04200037196278572, 0.032085105776786804, -0.010972864925861359, -0.03589420020580292, -0.0038622880820184946, 0.03242349997162819, 0.05344606935977936, 0.04497736319899559, 0.001783805200830102, 0.02756723016500473, -0.00990494154393673, -0.04134688153862953, -0.0004602800472639501, 0.014765182510018349, -0.02164999581873417, -0.04671826586127281, 0.060344066470861435, -0.019178101792931557, -0.04488417133688927, 0.02660859003663063, -0.009158732369542122, 0.015031782910227776, 0.004849907476454973, -0.11300167441368103, -0.053706102073192596, 0.0008760502096265554, -0.017182674258947372, -0.009378761053085327, -0.05529501289129257, -0.02449575439095497, 0.03450155630707741, 0.06266604363918304, 0.01811663620173931, -0.00005361927833291702, 0.03777575492858887, -0.016319021582603455, 0.013486884534358978, 0.006647615227848291, -0.017690639942884445, -0.043279439210891724, -0.006399596109986305, -0.02270502597093582, -0.03809075057506561, 0.010468720458447933, 0.036270622164011, -0.042941126972436905, -0.004990782588720322, 0.03899409994482994, 0.005944959819316864, -0.006891724653542042, -0.0157220009714365, -0.006741334218531847, -0.010446671396493912, 0.06171093136072159, 0.014274335466325283, 0.06211075559258461, 0.028370419517159462, 0.004441701341420412, 0.02340708114206791, 0.011438843794167042, 0.015265404246747494, 0.05954664200544357, 0.01072066929191351, -0.02433738484978676, -0.015383712947368622, 0.02229616604745388, -0.004774792585521936, -0.009265752509236336, -0.05521497502923012, 0.011112763546407223, 0.025036731734871864, 0.010844994336366653, -0.007452308665961027, 0.022508587688207626, -0.03035162203013897, 0.029351085424423218, -0.03402542695403099, -0.0481659397482872, -0.07900135219097137, 0.016760773956775665, -0.031383220106363297, -0.013221618719398975, 0.05150538682937622, 0.01794126071035862, 0.002810518490150571, 0.0033524835016578436, 0.0033245140220969915, -0.0374302938580513, -0.020247632637619972, 0.04577529802918434, -0.037562742829322815, 0.010862034745514393, 0.03307807445526123, 0.025644175708293915, -0.016357965767383575, 0.07087768614292145, -0.06829164922237396, -0.05552557110786438, 0.0009396017994731665, -0.03578665480017662, 0.005411120597273111, -0.01709941402077675, -0.006052492652088404, 0.010987035930156708, -0.02100345678627491, -0.024838881567120552, 0.005698826629668474, -0.05482983589172363, 0.07638264447450638, 0.056141313165426254, -0.00955934263765812, -0.004869445227086544, 0.012028257362544537, 0.006067380309104919, 0.01837112195789814, -0.016409069299697876, -0.05408501997590065, -0.05800580233335495, -0.04313741624355316, 0.0366227962076664, 0.00081552256597206, -0.03367200121283531, -0.022766858339309692, 0.04441196843981743, 0.011282102204859257, -0.007930836640298367, 0.018103478476405144, -0.005395250394940376, -0.025460267439484596, 0.02186545729637146, 0.029816625639796257, -0.003516712924465537, 0.004551128949970007, 0.026131629943847656, -0.011052452027797699, 0.018665142357349396, -0.006107575260102749, 0.02553158439695835, 0.013549617491662502, -0.022018274292349815, 0.018957512453198433, -0.006908732932060957, -0.03741241991519928, -0.0007899125921539962, -0.0342835858464241, 0.034752048552036285, 0.010166599415242672, -0.017060456797480583, -0.006465113256126642, 0.0449761264026165, 0.010608520358800888, 0.025851448997855186, 0.017063258215785027, 0.010296924039721489, -0.0029235908295959234, 0.03016003407537937, -0.05489218980073929, 0.01121448166668415, -0.014078575186431408, -0.047087568789720535, -0.009650296531617641, 0.02468711882829666, 0.031784866005182266, -0.0004519326030276716, 0.03131026029586792, -0.060285840183496475, -0.04222056269645691, -0.02030864730477333, -0.0008734057191759348, 0.016979865729808807, 0.04543568193912506, -0.039580050855875015, 0.00437637884169817, -0.021176369860768318, -0.02579030767083168, 0.018938882276415825, -0.017068957909941673, -0.04058453440666199, -0.005853825248777866, -0.003417839063331485, -0.029998386278748512, -0.013585546985268593, -0.036150719970464706, 0.03591248020529747, -0.014593484811484814, -0.015907013788819313, 0.031469590961933136, 0.026208464056253433, -0.048496928066015244, 0.0034666378051042557, -0.007701232098042965, -0.01850450597703457, -0.0349716879427433, -0.03620238974690437, 0.007639257237315178, -0.006065014749765396, -0.0003269772860221565, 0.029543008655309677, 0.008951431140303612, 0.009680966846644878, -0.03475587069988251, -0.07917691022157669, 0.019690023735165596, -0.014702139422297478, 0.0008911315817385912, 0.0076810447499156, 0.034481219947338104, 0.09402192384004593, 0.003718653693795204, -0.0005317711038514972, -0.009296739473938942, -0.03720860555768013, -0.04607951641082764, -0.0022206499706953764, -0.0360349602997303, 0.02424311265349388, 0.023838533088564873, 0.013203595764935017, -0.0018755728378891945, 0.011541100218892097, 0.05855686962604523, 0.00249677337706089, -0.01814655400812626, 0.03900058567523956, 0.03374480828642845, -0.028060700744390488, 0.044427815824747086, 0.014789773151278496, -0.018848944455385208, 0.017270337790250778, 0.010305332019925117, 0.0023455508053302765, 0.023181216791272163, -0.015385609120130539, 0.034601494669914246, -0.03524528443813324, 0.04154315963387489, -0.03981981426477432, 0.011397136375308037, 0.028453735634684563, -0.028561657294631004, -0.02849254570901394, 0.029434992000460625, 0.03641330823302269, -0.048067931085824966, 0.03200769051909447, 0.06703494489192963, 0.03346746042370796, 0.015310816466808319, -0.00308016873896122, -0.018595341593027115, -0.043382205069065094, 0.025282898917794228, -0.010270936414599419, 0.004979529418051243, 0.03163738176226616, 0.053195785731077194, -0.004376587923616171, 0.05317787081003189, -0.028903130441904068, 0.014011513441801071, -0.08908242732286453, -0.02963063307106495, -0.0018001620192080736, 0.06207909807562828, 0.01940838247537613, -0.00047230772906914353, 0.0560678094625473, -0.0036359201185405254, -0.0009335768409073353, 0.05335134640336037, -0.0840248242020607, 0.014534405432641506, 0.001199494581669569, 0.03904953598976135, -0.000030838265956845134, -0.034153640270233154, 0.05244548246264458, -0.07090408354997635, -0.005874542519450188, -0.009746192954480648, 0.019105348736047745, -0.030393049120903015, 0.03726769983768463, 0.004227421712130308, -0.02039729803800583, -0.030599180608987808, 0.026610467582941055, 0.012920833192765713, 0.026312585920095444, 0.015542346984148026, 0.024170491844415665, 0.0030035979580134153, -0.04209143668413162, -0.022756483405828476, -0.014095032587647438, 0.005169852636754513, 0.03798280283808708, -0.0038773915730416775, 0.04522758349776268, -0.0864250659942627, 0.01962886191904545, 0.029063021764159203, 0.03742567449808121, 0.01970793306827545, -0.01577582024037838, 0.004447057377547026, -0.10066664963960648, -0.05213130638003349, -0.010301713831722736, 0.04406758397817612, -0.0005652960971929133, -0.01204948965460062, 0.021921830251812935, 0.03412150219082832, -0.07669665664434433, -0.018090685829520226, 0.10054750740528107, 0.056236132979393005, -0.0021076106932014227, 0.0009636222966946661, 0.04129838943481445, -0.01219179481267929, 0.023244507610797882, 0.004192093852907419, 0.022418856620788574, 0.018329618498682976, 0.011673151515424252, 0.027806822210550308, -0.02889547124505043, -0.01725681498646736, -0.0035086008720099926, 0.011773888021707535, 0.03535601869225502, 0.01548602245748043, -0.01021626964211464, 0.011548617854714394, 0.031893882900476456, 0.05940941721200943, 0.009016408585011959, -0.001323196804150939, -0.08388231694698334, -0.02318047732114792, 0.07125606387853622, 0.04772508516907692, -0.040342576801776886, -0.05848528444766998, -0.060151223093271255, 0.003878800431266427, 0.023641379550099373, -0.04888474568724632, -0.0009409913327544928, -0.00037151595461182296, -0.014454166404902935, -0.04097316786646843, -0.016784993931651115, -0.031371261924505234, 0.023945467546582222, -0.029483167454600334, 0.053471408784389496, -0.03851655498147011, -0.004167571663856506, -0.025431063026189804, -0.002165690530091524, 0.0035134039353579283, 0.054617151618003845, 0.012826583348214626, -0.009381166659295559, 0.016480693593621254, 0.01972350664436817, -0.028132516890764236, -0.07699669897556305, -0.00749726640060544, 0.017720716074109077, 0.003414481645449996, 0.02666308358311653, 0.001035022083669901, -0.06212707236409187, -0.018995443359017372, -0.008334723301231861, -0.055382777005434036, -0.030531158670783043, -0.000293163291644305, 0.005097432527691126, 0.061581265181303024, 0.014509947970509529, 0.038147103041410446, -0.006482176948338747, 0.018903398886322975, -0.006283417344093323, -0.024403810501098633, 0.014339792542159557, -0.04685736447572708, 0.006425007712095976, -0.023432981222867966, 0.0344301238656044, -0.018702341243624687, 0.03952331840991974, 0.004071561619639397, 0.08430302888154984, -0.012563097290694714, -0.041379425674676895, -0.03200646489858627, 0.010828598402440548, -0.025591859593987465, -0.015291305258870125, 0.024002306163311005, 0.012626420706510544, -0.018542271107435226, 0.02634861320257187, 0.0023273606784641743, -0.008339759893715382, 0.029128843918442726, 0.022064676508307457, -0.011348668485879898, 0.03627727925777435, -0.023419052362442017, -0.03798939660191536, 0.007517372258007526, -0.015479229390621185, 0.05334673076868057, 0.01259046234190464, 0.03700942173600197, -0.0031287996098399162, -0.01811840943992138, 0.004773343913257122, -0.017195044085383415, -0.006482203025370836, 0.027417711913585663, -0.04770930856466293, 0.07288926094770432, -0.035105202347040176, 0.00838013831526041, -0.04281868785619736, -0.008807594887912273, -0.0030642806086689234, 0.012417676858603954, -0.02826191857457161, -0.031533382833004, 0.026171477511525154, -0.00042617894359864295, -0.04192350432276726, -0.014726255089044571, 0.03646714612841606, 0.0032724367920309305, -0.04254287853837013, -0.011455965228378773, 0.03575083240866661, 0.05734049901366234, 0.008469530381262302, 0.04064794257283211, 0.013310358859598637, -0.04587346315383911, 0.0021900590509176254, -0.002057877602055669, 0.015416539274156094, -0.021205803379416466, -0.0406850166618824, -0.03656325489282608, 0.05467607453465462, 0.02243698574602604, -0.0026293867267668247, 0.010861868038773537, 0.013080321252346039, -0.012027011252939701, -0.04999138042330742, -0.020665952935814857, -0.017493961378932, 0.02287478931248188, -0.026119904592633247, 0.014041947200894356, 0.04013006389141083, -0.006813366897404194, 0.011313588358461857, 0.02836376056075096, 0.019658159464597702, -0.012821942567825317, 0.00576707674190402, 0.06274687498807907, -0.0198274664580822, 0.028237897902727127, -0.012890158221125603, -0.04526427760720253, 0.06105584278702736, 0.0030392282642424107, 0.02903595380485058, -0.016468027606606483, 0.017109334468841553, -0.06563428044319153, 0.00821874663233757, -0.0394037626683712, -0.04065201058983803, 0.037707164883613586, 0.009307465516030788, 0.0378955602645874, 0.023713791742920876, 0.016047948971390724, 0.0005583430174738169, -0.01933709904551506, -0.022657927125692368, -0.043801773339509964, -0.005725048948079348, 0.03742997720837593, 0.015951158478856087, 0.005542638711631298, 0.041659001260995865, 0.002955164760351181, 0.05808255821466446, 0.025205474346876144, 0.019080879166722298, 0.041404880583286285, 0.009788253344595432, -0.04458553344011307, -0.029755879193544388, 0.027730990201234818, -0.019687067717313766, -0.027316125109791756, 0.00755093339830637, -0.005197870545089245, 0.0448000431060791, 0.018038837239146233, 0.018085358664393425, -0.014791254885494709, -0.012065974995493889, -0.07245166599750519, 0.027007177472114563, 0.02648317813873291, 0.009191480465233326, 0.0373871885240078, -0.005699645262211561, 0.04427759721875191, -0.024858877062797546, 0.013171925209462643, -0.03843601420521736, -0.10548876225948334, -0.05902385339140892, -0.02690613456070423, -0.0038239709101617336, 0.016335297375917435, -0.0011796336621046066, -0.05013370141386986, 0.03687958046793938, -0.01134119089692831, 0.026373641565442085, -0.029893752187490463, 0.04029076173901558, -0.01682456023991108, 0.027641484513878822, -0.014715244062244892, 0.03119664452970028, 0.013156364671885967, 0.028875578194856644, 0.11478148400783539, 0.09712260216474533, 0.07121367752552032, -0.06108077988028526, -0.018855100497603416, -0.009230350144207478, -0.004203671123832464, -0.02178468182682991, 0.004728423431515694, -0.003508633701130748, -0.0018263055244460702, -0.007111969869583845, -0.004554476588964462, 0.025220071896910667, -0.00913997646421194, 0.05681820213794708, -0.05590971186757088, -0.005616086069494486, 0.02424050308763981, 0.014681005850434303, 0.010350390337407589, -0.026995990425348282, -0.049207329750061035, 0.007904457859694958, 0.004263821057975292, -0.007153902668505907, -0.005988141987472773, -0.024180546402931213, 0.0010628275340422988, 0.004383322782814503, 0.04172972962260246, 0.03335751220583916, -0.0007840467151254416, 0.014064601622521877, 0.008094069547951221, 0.02200273983180523, -0.011039217002689838, -0.057948190718889236, 0.002099753124639392, 0.028015250340104103, 0.029879987239837646, -0.042452722787857056, 0.012890957295894623, -0.012941855005919933, -0.04442545399069786, -0.06540706753730774, -0.021193483844399452, 0.03547016158699989, 0.0002050551847787574, 0.009913289919495583, -0.0035550808534026146, 0.0009018420241773129, -0.007424316368997097, -0.03775474801659584, -0.04651634022593498, 0.03038986586034298, 0.011226951144635677, -0.013796796090900898, -0.015745796263217926, -0.006939680781215429, 0.04855596646666527, 0.013496026396751404, 0.023173948749899864, 0.022937901318073273, 0.01990949735045433, -0.006626513786613941, -0.028541475534439087, 0.06497514992952347, 0.030637769028544426, 0.0032076863572001457, 0.005554529372602701, -0.001279735704883933, 0.030046718195080757, -0.03463808074593544, 0.004718348383903503, 0.0053427815437316895, 0.027073673903942108, -0.0167875736951828, 0.009291496127843857, -0.060941632837057114, -0.03750791400671005, 0.02872268110513687, -0.033241722732782364, 0.030174143612384796, -0.03342309594154358, 0.016735220327973366, 0.03084859624505043, 0.01434903685003519, 0.02347538061439991, 0.018362674862146378, 0.04241698235273361, 0.03920990228652954, 0.025579888373613358, 0.005636758171021938, -0.008021549321711063, -0.03311819210648537, -0.039034102112054825, 0.023068636655807495, 0.0072141531854867935, 0.056582991033792496, 0.03844824805855751, 0.009049451909959316, 0.009808924980461597, 0.034131016582250595, -0.00372609356418252, 0.0013666370650753379, 0.017982615157961845, -0.03534635901451111, -0.019437365233898163, -0.02124807983636856, 0.018723173066973686, -0.06002747640013695, -0.06408568471670151, -0.020572325214743614, -0.0566597618162632, 0.006602392997592688, 0.0025208897422999144, -0.02967485785484314, 0.013806705363094807, -0.002418608171865344, 0.035095419734716415, -0.005245227366685867, -0.024494096636772156, -0.03808847814798355, -0.0370287150144577, -0.028705786913633347, -0.05990232899785042, -0.011505909264087677, 0.025194576010107994, -0.01774747297167778, 0.014830394648015499, -0.011272304691374302, -0.01435711607336998, -0.02185831405222416, 0.01231188140809536, -0.017765242606401443, -0.01203109323978424, 0.04472317174077034, -0.05132998526096344, -0.0006963012856431305, 0.007075043860822916, -0.0394277423620224, 0.008771914057433605, 0.02411026321351528, -0.01082516834139824, 0.04312369227409363, 0.022242683917284012, -0.0059013511054217815, -0.00031955071608535945, 0.013218246400356293, -0.003959475085139275, -0.038478437811136246, 0.008551690727472305, 0.023319071158766747, -0.001213172683492303, 0.03164159134030342, 0.030761482194066048, 0.015248534269630909, -0.035653673112392426, -0.011613328941166401, 0.03302017226815224, 0.0278570968657732, -0.020517682656645775, 0.021682363003492355, 0.005031713750213385, 0.03035729192197323, -0.025676580145955086, 0.029053470119833946, 0.03344687446951866, 0.009642040356993675, -0.010232399217784405, 0.008114074356853962, 0.0019584668334573507, -0.019371377304196358, -0.08942053467035294, -0.0318138562142849, 0.03514672815799713, -0.01923113875091076, 0.024008721113204956, -0.04673262685537338, 0.03314103186130524, 0.007149387151002884, -0.046694282442331314, 0.026705056428909302, -0.013500972650945187, -0.01510320883244276, -0.0043979212641716, 0.029007084667682648, -0.015450037084519863, 0.01791463978588581, 0.022640274837613106, -0.0065633635967969894, 0.01811872236430645, 0.02322075143456459, -0.026950184255838394, -0.042602717876434326, -0.047560688108205795, 0.03143087029457092, 0.004982188809663057, -0.04145132377743721, 0.02062365971505642, -0.04544984921813011, -0.030024897307157516, 0.01758507639169693, -0.002354903146624565, 0.010587177239358425, 0.03371316194534302, -0.006959322839975357, 0.022912751883268356, 0.02617933787405491, 0.029448287561535835, -0.028946861624717712, -0.0034082301426678896, 0.005425380542874336, 0.0003980324836447835, 0.03803911432623863, 0.010916254483163357, -0.01528966799378395, -0.013855854980647564, -0.0421457514166832, 0.00254626851528883, -0.010543599724769592, -0.01653851382434368, -0.012103913351893425, 0.01289375126361847, 0.01202175859361887, 0.008156153373420238, -0.01355065032839775, -0.021763868629932404, -0.0295508224517107, -0.023158535361289978, 0.012135672383010387, 0.002212995896115899, 0.006575794890522957, 0.005647251848131418, -0.03585510328412056, -0.03808404505252838, 0.006207079626619816, 0.032461874186992645, -0.027381226420402527, -0.04882737994194031, 0.017401978373527527, -0.00799951795488596, -0.004614150617271662, 0.001171759096905589, -0.016121888533234596, -0.013278419151902199, 0.04551507532596588, -0.014633094891905785, 0.03897269070148468, 0.00914289802312851, -0.039537325501441956, -0.03113499842584133, -0.06077007204294205, 0.05646660551428795, 0.018227363005280495, -0.05138138309121132, -0.013238590210676193, 0.007578384131193161, -0.040590398013591766, 0.010708966292440891, 0.07566329836845398, 0.0133986696600914, -0.015672285109758377, -0.05734973028302193, 0.003938821144402027, -0.007682761177420616, -0.05076476186513901, 0.0457046814262867, -0.0022623962722718716, -0.006105316337198019, -0.02280217967927456, -0.015943346545100212, 0.00704120472073555, 0.009619242511689663, 0.001363540650345385, -0.004038049373775721, -0.0002999176213052124, 0.04167693853378296, 0.010177412070333958, 0.02744085155427456, -0.005110371392220259, 0.03652655705809593, 0.016667475923895836, 0.04235871508717537, 0.014861823059618473, -0.0006606391398236156, -0.0001571796165080741, -0.07765453308820724, 0.019455116242170334, -0.04914189502596855, -0.02476830594241619, -0.011539462953805923, 0.012593714520335197, -0.006395314354449511, -0.06625642627477646, 0.0240787286311388, 0.03994227573275566, -0.036372870206832886, 0.016866637393832207, 0.025977125391364098, 0.019992142915725708, 0.04225107654929161, 0.004763856530189514, 0.03693808987736702, -0.004189401865005493, -0.014704998582601547, 0.015251298435032368, 0.0016977130435407162, -0.004944981541484594, 0.02988005429506302, 0.047547705471515656, 0.016946107149124146, 0.0022932460997253656, 0.028621649369597435, 0.004200974013656378, 0.015613958239555359, -0.049157366156578064, 0.01686243526637554, 0.0096968412399292, -0.012003586627542973, 0.0026630826760083437, 0.002077507320791483, -0.0017707591177895665, 0.04305921867489815, -0.049619000405073166, 0.004575503524392843, -0.04252686724066734, 0.00414624297991395, 0.02215195819735527, -0.0002678931050468236, -0.003311891108751297, 0.046874597668647766, 0.012922350317239761, -0.004121925216168165, -0.003400501562282443, 0.006914637982845306, 0.026909340173006058, -0.034878507256507874, 0.007171998266130686, -0.021498847752809525, -0.004594525787979364, -0.010206387378275394, -0.03717963770031929, -0.017596229910850525, -0.018333930522203445, 0.01005345769226551, 0.057793039828538895, 0.0619092658162117, 0.005480791907757521, -0.058885205537080765, -0.0011472590267658234, 0.01715504378080368, -0.08015992492437363, -0.0014419637154787779, -0.05154873803257942, 0.018328575417399406, 0.011205361224710941, -0.04261896759271622 ]
<p>I have a two stage model where coefficients of model 1 become the $y$-vector for model 2. I have standard errors for those coefficients, and I want to weigh the observations in model 2 according to the standard error that the corresponding coefficient had in model 1. I believe the correct way to do this is weigh the observations in 2 by 1/SE, where SE is the standard error of the corresponding coefficient in model 1. </p> <p>Now, the data for model 1 actually gets artificially created by me. I therefore know that coefficients with a SE of $\geq X$ are completely useless (I know this given my setup). Now, in model 2, giving those <em>useless</em> observations a weight of $1/\text{SE}$, with $\text{SE}\geq X$, seems like giving them too much weight, since their actual weight should be 0</p> <p>What is the best method to weigh observations in such a case?</p>
74,407
[ -0.008915720507502556, 0.015348048880696297, -0.05774299055337906, 0.0002725271915551275, 0.00593135692179203, 0.03846568614244461, 0.0040960474871098995, -0.034981146454811096, 0.02771545760333538, -0.01123827788978815, 0.0062529402785003185, 0.008993771858513355, 0.06290807574987411, 0.0027173962444067, 0.05878773331642151, 0.02365848608314991, 0.015346555970609188, 0.025042735040187836, 0.0031588319689035416, -0.023592520505189896, -0.022120965644717216, 0.02520046941936016, 0.018670514225959778, -0.017460279166698456, 0.0005870847380720079, 0.05441513657569885, 0.022937079891562462, -0.019875727593898773, -0.006023786962032318, 0.071933813393116, -0.0008923035929910839, -0.029390200972557068, -0.00853779911994934, 0.02246015891432762, 0.007487067952752113, -0.007006950676441193, -0.0027634163852781057, -0.018468890339136124, -0.02431991510093212, 0.03263480216264725, -0.05000906065106392, -0.015059752389788628, -0.020831795409321785, 0.0009573108400218189, 0.0425487644970417, 0.010900172404944897, -0.021838726475834846, -0.016196290031075478, 0.03445011377334595, -0.05790424719452858, 0.07676267623901367, 0.002162494231015444, 0.03508488088846207, 0.06355544179677963, -0.011634196154773235, -0.01097516156733036, 0.06564405560493469, 0.05463965982198715, -0.02758384682238102, -0.009752406738698483, -0.0374511256814003, -0.0034799573477357626, 0.0025974996387958527, -0.035470157861709595, 0.0005765396635979414, -0.004854252096265554, 0.0006669509457424283, 0.0036473413929343224, 0.022034376859664917, -0.04066143557429314, -0.005955443251878023, 0.00962830986827612, -0.005519091617316008, 0.01268024742603302, 0.019027024507522583, -0.02644619159400463, 0.052324943244457245, 0.03238920122385025, 0.046121880412101746, 0.047183942049741745, -0.005559409968554974, 0.016839757561683655, 0.04053514450788498, 0.0385124571621418, 0.008204823359847069, 0.013544922694563866, 0.03799111768603325, -0.011549971997737885, 0.031830914318561554, 0.010078449733555317, -0.03535756841301918, -0.015503646805882454, 0.0473245270550251, -0.016837645322084427, 0.0015425377059727907, 0.025806937366724014, 0.0011735839070752263, 0.033882662653923035, 0.03863934427499771, -0.02179696038365364, -0.024736307561397552, -0.0546739436686039, 0.03092377819120884, 0.059020210057497025, -0.020650023594498634, -0.014007660560309887, -0.008849049918353558, 0.008002706803381443, 0.00963390152901411, -0.05539008975028992, 0.028051787987351418, 0.03236675262451172, 0.013240901753306389, -0.014994978904724121, 0.05284993350505829, -0.015581320971250534, 0.007861952297389507, -0.013847672380506992, 0.0638960525393486, 0.033619049936532974, 0.06610441207885742, -0.043194618076086044, 0.03479623794555664, 0.0037137633189558983, -0.03112606704235077, 0.007973600178956985, -0.0002514101506676525, -0.06820747256278992, -0.045077137649059296, 0.022534620016813278, 0.013143994845449924, -0.031493861228227615, 0.03256998583674431, -0.029585404321551323, 0.005618502851575613, 0.021771112456917763, -0.07253125309944153, -0.06138108670711517, 0.002394284587353468, -0.03814394399523735, 0.009683559648692608, -0.05365637689828873, -0.02620541863143444, 0.04504060745239258, 0.06557278335094452, 0.045223962515592575, 0.04680830240249634, 0.022030016407370567, 0.040186721831560135, 0.009540869854390621, -0.0037244767881929874, -0.06173448637127876, -0.02694752998650074, -0.04300832375884056, -0.024559248238801956, -0.04447568580508232, -0.013145163655281067, 0.04501227289438248, -0.028090976178646088, 0.013034111820161343, 0.041423194110393524, -0.0028029445093125105, -0.026155412197113037, 0.013523449189960957, 0.03651948645710945, -0.04320089519023895, 0.05746866390109062, 0.026012388989329338, 0.0336771123111248, 0.003856128314509988, 0.002119015669450164, 0.011174590326845646, 0.027207983657717705, 0.03257935866713524, 0.045518916100263596, -0.019301041960716248, -0.012985589914023876, -0.049360163509845734, 0.02156626619398594, 0.038556840270757675, -0.024506419897079468, -0.028102748095989227, -0.034589674323797226, -0.043264422565698624, 0.021393217146396637, 0.06290930509567261, 0.004769153892993927, -0.018070347607135773, 0.040435802191495895, -0.025913873687386513, -0.04881218075752258, -0.0515696257352829, -0.03285630792379379, 0.003399450797587633, -0.006401397753506899, 0.03552272915840149, -0.0247749462723732, 0.011350170709192753, 0.00018122466281056404, 0.0013121325755491853, -0.02163681387901306, 0.027268722653388977, 0.06476867198944092, -0.0221544336527586, 0.0205454770475626, 0.03504046052694321, 0.06878454238176346, -0.012123987078666687, 0.047543834894895554, -0.03207666799426079, -0.06290185451507568, 0.013221348635852337, -0.02655060961842537, 0.015311556868255138, -0.008255957625806332, -0.016750136390328407, 0.0039383661933243275, -0.03705776482820511, -0.012477869167923927, 0.041625332087278366, -0.06231135502457619, 0.09461535513401031, 0.06831476092338562, -0.01176971010863781, -0.03345353901386261, 0.01504715345799923, 0.0248899944126606, 0.057401351630687714, -0.033263012766838074, -0.026830682530999184, -0.005008589010685682, -0.009450824931263924, 0.04284585639834404, 0.024488048627972603, -0.023488957434892654, 0.006464228965342045, 0.04039962217211723, -0.0024822421837598085, 0.009495984762907028, 0.04088045656681061, 0.04216787591576576, -0.01648569293320179, 0.017717434093356133, -0.0031789483036845922, 0.012968914583325386, 0.025641826912760735, 0.018419820815324783, 0.024561934173107147, 0.02101859822869301, 0.02963402308523655, 0.02999989502131939, 0.033766549080610275, 0.006543638184666634, 0.00394198764115572, 0.00011051861656596884, -0.035023294389247894, 0.06624279916286469, -0.02869998663663864, 0.03313199803233147, 0.03619680553674698, -0.026971453800797462, -0.0023944685235619545, 0.02261274680495262, -0.0015241865767166018, 0.0028167758136987686, 0.0034320703707635403, -0.016627352684736252, 0.03021543100476265, 0.015268942341208458, -0.03498217836022377, 0.011980471201241016, -0.011376584880053997, -0.02820403501391411, -0.02680458314716816, 0.02209366485476494, 0.04359937459230423, -0.005716847721487284, 0.012953667901456356, -0.03950871527194977, -0.04859263449907303, -0.0014267463702708483, 0.0013209732715040445, 0.022518670186400414, 0.022000711411237717, -0.051647137850522995, 0.013107290491461754, -0.04842483997344971, -0.019890733063220978, 0.0612180233001709, 0.004751324187964201, 0.01092180609703064, 0.029197903349995613, -0.010070689022541046, -0.004210223909467459, -0.023514065891504288, -0.03581564873456955, -0.02505456656217575, 0.00035131009644828737, -0.05092938616871834, 0.04542053863406181, 0.027976829558610916, -0.07953137159347534, 0.010353577323257923, -0.05430358648300171, -0.038815174251794815, -0.04255518689751625, 0.011947030201554298, -0.015428400598466396, -0.015528138726949692, 0.03112924098968506, 0.0221009012311697, -0.007439374923706055, -0.037690162658691406, -0.05653286725282669, -0.049946945160627365, 0.03936588391661644, -0.0059837037697434425, 0.014746762812137604, 0.0021881822030991316, -0.04728086665272713, 0.12738291919231415, 0.02822842448949814, 0.021695824339985847, -0.038861241191625595, 0.02355424501001835, -0.0006386142922565341, 0.004349615424871445, -0.013622571714222431, -0.008841979317367077, 0.005427277181297541, 0.02233603037893772, -0.0041085840202867985, -0.005820917896926403, 0.0502820685505867, 0.026362333446741104, 0.012149667367339134, 0.004563230089843273, 0.01120315957814455, -0.024562053382396698, 0.029351351782679558, 0.020181944593787193, -0.014426507987082005, 0.0381062775850296, 0.011295609176158905, 0.04284370690584183, 0.015203162096440792, -0.005840014200657606, -0.0012713278410956264, -0.019180843606591225, 0.013197974301874638, -0.030306285247206688, 0.024803686887025833, 0.057883746922016144, -0.018923703581094742, 0.005123455543071032, 0.0049628945998847485, -0.006525383796542883, -0.037828557193279266, -0.02238571085035801, 0.04668578505516052, 0.05084240064024925, 0.000016175677956198342, -0.036480650305747986, -0.020156048238277435, 0.00901818461716175, 0.028495484963059425, -0.003431792138144374, -0.012495995499193668, 0.03565668687224388, 0.03225000202655792, 0.013210736215114594, -0.03125808760523796, -0.020204028114676476, -0.01798330619931221, -0.06343833357095718, -0.008248500525951385, -0.009547988884150982, 0.04330473393201828, 0.004497672896832228, 0.008058919571340084, -0.003341248258948326, 0.004390724003314972, 0.008068087510764599, -0.01600673981010914, -0.062061067670583725, 0.021957118064165115, 0.00479715783149004, -0.008759653195738792, 0.01719842292368412, 0.018765514716506004, -0.001975095132365823, -0.05052710324525833, 0.006940534804016352, -0.05579004064202309, 0.03239380940794945, 0.01480959914624691, 0.005664753261953592, -0.04902349412441254, -0.018168969079852104, 0.0010483497753739357, 0.02579849399626255, 0.023806273937225342, -0.04482102021574974, -0.00375817040912807, 0.010095737874507904, -0.04656555876135826, 0.006096473895013332, -0.054854098707437515, 0.010581565089523792, 0.02449437975883484, 0.028566697612404823, 0.025213908404111862, 0.05328809469938278, -0.057323336601257324, 0.03152061253786087, 0.013703331351280212, 0.04897882789373398, 0.026222236454486847, -0.022486655041575432, -0.03858588635921478, -0.02237074077129364, -0.06241273134946823, -0.0181801188737154, 0.023307591676712036, -0.011334236711263657, -0.003925764467567205, 0.01326060388237238, 0.02057710662484169, -0.04059977829456329, 0.004657285753637552, 0.07247525453567505, 0.04565471038222313, 0.022238658741116524, -0.028224652633070946, 0.01396136824041605, -0.01759115792810917, -0.015787243843078613, 0.03440089151263237, 0.01554358471184969, 0.008850885555148125, -0.03139781579375267, 0.013044804334640503, -0.005577045027166605, -0.00252120872028172, 0.003575044684112072, 0.04444804787635803, 0.04574917256832123, 0.021693162620067596, -0.03867512196302414, 0.0037482865154743195, 0.03983106464147568, 0.022567396983504295, 0.006895003840327263, 0.0057526263408362865, -0.07664383947849274, -0.019579140469431877, 0.013070748187601566, 0.03757982701063156, -0.06402695178985596, -0.01440190989524126, 0.009899175725877285, -0.037674903869628906, 0.020948566496372223, -0.04545878246426582, 0.008124840445816517, -0.029787153005599976, -0.00044900699867866933, -0.012572751380503178, -0.009221356362104416, -0.06637474149465561, 0.03459698706865311, -0.035010382533073425, 0.046928416937589645, -0.012946132570505142, -0.04208472743630409, -0.02632952108979225, -0.008697553537786007, 0.013291869312524796, 0.059482816606760025, -0.029038840904831886, -0.0462348647415638, 0.03858020529150963, 0.03163965046405792, -0.020268360152840614, -0.05577985942363739, -0.02530195377767086, -0.0004123254620935768, -0.0067510828375816345, 0.00584571436047554, -0.017225269228219986, -0.06791123747825623, 0.046171460300683975, -0.004535682033747435, 0.010267688892781734, -0.013595135882496834, 0.010997914709150791, 0.040404073894023895, 0.04084398224949837, -0.005099979694932699, 0.03414088487625122, 0.03932412713766098, -0.010145263746380806, 0.01949486881494522, -0.05251878499984741, -0.006538119167089462, -0.039318133145570755, -0.019181665033102036, -0.043430134654045105, 0.015203882940113544, -0.035070981830358505, 0.03360096737742424, 0.017068341374397278, 0.06805936992168427, -0.02674286812543869, -0.05929054319858551, 0.01123061217367649, 0.01105452049523592, -0.01891971379518509, -0.024426471441984177, -0.01724875159561634, 0.022400744259357452, -0.004545379895716906, -0.028386136516928673, 0.0014527692692354321, -0.0016902242787182331, -0.03664431348443031, -0.03320041298866272, -0.03813819959759712, 0.04384920001029968, -0.04226898401975632, -0.011785022914409637, 0.011537867598235607, -0.022817349061369896, 0.023069925606250763, -0.036705438047647476, 0.022383684292435646, -0.025971589609980583, -0.05475758761167526, -0.004879817832261324, 0.02426815591752529, 0.026286756619811058, 0.01622230000793934, -0.0252066683024168, -0.022986426949501038, 0.024770453572273254, -0.0018083598697558045, -0.07032513618469238, -0.04191777482628822, -0.0004072927695233375, -0.026010936126112938, 0.005076532252132893, -0.033364322036504745, 0.02778218314051628, -0.013727657496929169, -0.008121926337480545, -0.020667780190706253, 0.04788433387875557, -0.002087388187646866, -0.02494729869067669, 0.011548188515007496, 0.028110064566135406, 0.06214135140180588, -0.028329577296972275, 0.000034044875064864755, -0.012868314050137997, -0.04147988185286522, -0.03089986927807331, 0.007349456660449505, -0.006659878883510828, -0.03584009036421776, -0.014634509570896626, 0.006692388094961643, -0.03170943632721901, 0.01616406813263893, -0.004027663730084896, 0.009681099094450474, 0.024275705218315125, -0.01007433794438839, -0.007013608235865831, 0.005142719950526953, 0.03284971043467522, -0.037096474319696426, 0.014427907764911652, -0.019189687445759773, 0.01757396198809147, -0.03270837664604187, -0.025732459500432014, 0.04388730600476265, -0.019084196537733078, -0.015654636546969414, -0.01871873065829277, 0.06564143300056458, 0.022892577573657036, -0.023061644285917282, 0.004886845126748085, -0.028564328327775, 0.030793271958827972, 0.037738580256700516, 0.003817352931946516, 0.027985306456685066, 0.041957173496484756, -0.0178692527115345, -0.004806023556739092, -0.031248580664396286, 0.017492592334747314, 0.07677516341209412, -0.03586895763874054, 0.02671957015991211, 0.04972679167985916, 0.020136650651693344, -0.005745277740061283, -0.005385268945246935, -0.021721621975302696, -0.014280417002737522, -0.014966187998652458, 0.05287790298461914, -0.011512087658047676, -0.011909253895282745, 0.02961447834968567, -0.0033491768408566713, 0.03437763452529907, 0.03524196892976761, 0.005616447888314724, 0.03980241343379021, 0.022203722968697548, -0.03503968194127083, -0.03723614662885666, 0.04629550501704216, 0.0006749575259163976, -0.044054534286260605, -0.035590607672929764, -0.05830828845500946, 0.06322206556797028, 0.009925812482833862, -0.004520433489233255, -0.06593963503837585, -0.07609161734580994, -0.04602634906768799, -0.016845300793647766, -0.003894717898219824, -0.03843506798148155, 0.047908131033182144, 0.01941588893532753, 0.02889634110033512, 0.01064444798976183, 0.06541620939970016, -0.023984871804714203, -0.1232343539595604, -0.03638444468379021, -0.030134355649352074, -0.02101585827767849, 0.011641710996627808, 0.01711585558950901, 0.0005898519302718341, 0.01760590448975563, -0.027964860200881958, -0.010271056555211544, 0.009399867616593838, 0.01613527350127697, -0.05728349834680557, 0.017778286710381508, -0.02385718934237957, 0.0008926670416258276, -0.009801712818443775, -0.02834230847656727, 0.10201871395111084, 0.051288582384586334, 0.0471363365650177, -0.05039290711283684, 0.04460645839571953, 0.004485708195716143, 0.002777339890599251, -0.021563773974776268, 0.013343999162316322, 0.039874181151390076, 0.00988542940467596, 0.0006319342064671218, 0.06460673362016678, -0.015946531668305397, -0.00470708729699254, 0.05937573313713074, -0.009390970692038536, 0.0016262717545032501, 0.006724218837916851, 0.003969347104430199, -0.018428213894367218, -0.02707981877028942, -0.01900705322623253, 0.007694071624428034, -0.007820580154657364, 0.0017637115670368075, -0.01199299655854702, -0.0120545644313097, -0.01144694909453392, -0.02810591086745262, -0.03109798952937126, 0.02020878903567791, -0.003068347927182913, 0.020911410450935364, -0.008118396624922752, 0.0075331213884055614, 0.025889312848448753, -0.030293459072709084, 0.016662584617733955, -0.007009884808212519, -0.018928201869130135, 0.0030810378957539797, 0.0024072788655757904, 0.04106248915195465, -0.06919164210557938, -0.045806072652339935, -0.047857582569122314, 0.053638432174921036, 0.008771318010985851, -0.004182290751487017, -0.005663348827511072, -0.004373266361653805, 0.0051255663856863976, -0.044859204441308975, -0.019602125510573387, 0.04407152533531189, 0.02146185375750065, -0.022293047979474068, -0.0023865699768066406, -0.011078454554080963, 0.01115158386528492, 0.0076521653681993484, 0.02691098116338253, 0.06214100867509842, -0.05892641469836235, -0.0400136299431324, -0.011815622448921204, 0.04795527830719948, 0.019561806693673134, -0.03110446408390999, -0.0048873210325837135, -0.04317749664187431, -0.017188021913170815, -0.02734406664967537, 0.01897241175174713, -0.006975056603550911, 0.014572354964911938, -0.01668805629014969, -0.003875077934935689, -0.028241701424121857, -0.020144717767834663, 0.013912471011281013, -0.013549971394240856, 0.0059233177453279495, -0.07347802817821503, 0.003166905138641596, 0.02656753920018673, 0.0056817722506821156, 0.033510029315948486, -0.021769480779767036, 0.02345302887260914, 0.023638075217604637, -0.00838809460401535, -0.06520572304725647, 0.006767445243895054, 0.011758788488805294, -0.02370169758796692, 0.01861966960132122, 0.016972940415143967, 0.06884078681468964, 0.02016475424170494, 0.03883850947022438, 0.0004789459053426981, 0.017455531284213066, -0.014676941558718681, 0.022617703303694725, 0.0039918990805745125, -0.06012003868818283, -0.006383251864463091, -0.006254835054278374, 0.044663555920124054, -0.051740869879722595, -0.007025693543255329, -0.03309754654765129, -0.04822644218802452, 0.006609167903661728, -0.009934579022228718, -0.035980165004730225, 0.0108459098264575, -0.040305718779563904, 0.022735709324479103, -0.04788247123360634, 0.005893537309020758, -0.032497670501470566, -0.01649356074631214, -0.025858372449874878, -0.020162593573331833, -0.028321458026766777, 0.017218923196196556, -0.0012738248333334923, 0.0034581737127155066, 0.046596065163612366, -0.005848556291311979, 0.01907484047114849, -0.018342452123761177, 0.02328224666416645, 0.0019523592200130224, 0.03451668098568916, -0.026856906712055206, -0.03679317608475685, 0.03108575940132141, -0.03043786622583866, -0.007648013997823, 0.028794027864933014, 0.004009031690657139, 0.04638524726033211, 0.03432367742061615, -0.031242040917277336, -0.01710309274494648, 0.022061647847294807, -0.032079558819532394, -0.019168948754668236, -0.009479659609496593, 0.016770625486969948, -0.03396008908748627, 0.008326604962348938, 0.011351482942700386, 0.010492525063455105, -0.005271006841212511, 0.0337771400809288, 0.052809376269578934, -0.009778063744306564, -0.03278408199548721, -0.003160333726555109, 0.02649012580513954, 0.04333219677209854, -0.001871610525995493, -0.02460472285747528, 0.02612263895571232, 0.025333339348435402, -0.04073812812566757, 0.040498457849025726, 0.005649569910019636, -0.014748409390449524, -0.051102280616760254, -0.039415281265974045, -0.010250992141664028, 0.005761610344052315, 0.04474643990397453, -0.01967843435704708, 0.012954270467162132, 0.022812241688370705, -0.04120410978794098, 0.0180189311504364, -0.007837888784706593, -0.030279623344540596, -0.022654099389910698, -0.018940012902021408, -0.015957245603203773, 0.030540790408849716, 0.018133999779820442, 0.017422687262296677, 0.016050321981310844, 0.008719648234546185, 0.03181779757142067, -0.017357496544718742, -0.03428769111633301, -0.01229783520102501, -0.023996273055672646, -0.035722583532333374, 0.04793647304177284, -0.04729815572500229, -0.020498689264059067, 0.07097447663545609, 0.01907636970281601, 0.027739912271499634, 0.021235818043351173, 0.061113618314266205, -0.015831373631954193, 0.04782984405755997, 0.013701987452805042, 0.00417301757261157, 0.015553743578493595, -0.002181221731007099, 0.017791051417589188, 0.015377631410956383, -0.039642658084630966, 0.021279463544487953, 0.032593872398138046, -0.03520428389310837, -0.005760859698057175, 0.0271759070456028, -0.01328062079846859, -0.008205262012779713, 0.00023570028133690357, 0.011795607395470142, -0.007844025269150734, -0.01921459101140499, 0.025838477537035942, -0.015195266343653202, 0.006126994267106056, 0.037527330219745636, -0.007772313430905342, -0.02247975952923298, 0.024453742429614067, 0.005556008312851191, -0.02540365606546402, 0.02141292579472065, 0.016873618587851524, -0.012121426872909069, -0.0913812518119812, -0.0024769820738583803, 0.001943360548466444, -0.024303382262587547, -0.03650591894984245, -0.039808087050914764, -0.06258030980825424, 0.08444555848836899, -0.05751958116889, 0.014302602969110012, 0.030499683693051338, -0.006981294136494398, 0.03226110711693764, -0.08623065799474716, 0.03720167651772499, 0.024503253400325775, -0.001713284058496356, -0.005577391479164362, 0.014489335007965565, -0.008405816741287708, 0.019315624609589577, 0.07800712436437607, 0.04609016701579094, -0.00012042919843224809, 0.03332841768860817, 0.027469560503959656, -0.001748833805322647, -0.039030034095048904, 0.050198640674352646, -0.003949230536818504, -0.01919717714190483, -0.012186313979327679, 0.0115159647539258, 0.029563849791884422, 0.031160948798060417, 0.00335982465185225, -0.006976040080189705, 0.005451279226690531, -0.014150600880384445, 0.007202201057225466, 0.042216185480356216, -0.027074400335550308, 0.021021628752350807, 0.03635275736451149, 0.014012017287313938, 0.025348195806145668, 0.02108820155262947, 0.004530824720859528, -0.052460797131061554, 0.03370511531829834, -0.049512725323438644, -0.029234539717435837, 0.0202432069927454, 0.015194638632237911, 0.01270284503698349, -0.035729892551898956, -0.000716762850061059, 0.01678018644452095, -0.02062847465276718, 0.00119366857688874, 0.023893462494015694, 0.02524317055940628, 0.028857234865427017, 0.015923770144581795, 0.053849052637815475, 0.0016465408261865377, 0.0045935846865177155, 0.04486497864127159, 0.01425726804882288, 0.039116427302360535, 0.01586715131998062, -0.0009243747335858643, 0.0188415739685297, -0.006831908132880926, 0.009339381940662861, -0.01574438065290451, 0.018051262944936752, 0.0008943488937802613, -0.04273787513375282, 0.0149468295276165, -0.0087119797244668, 0.003776838071644306, -0.030369244515895844, -0.020107557997107506, 0.02560953050851822, -0.022131094709038734, 0.01716291345655918, -0.04911684989929199, -0.030680999159812927, 0.0007482020300813019, 0.0013462958158925176, -0.007104799617081881, 0.036549780517816544, 0.02105366811156273, -0.020912081003189087, -0.005828282330185175, -0.004379390273243189, -0.034904275089502335, 0.007135217078030109, 0.0580192506313324, -0.0029248446226119995, -0.0018524550832808018, -0.03582877293229103, -0.04729514941573143, -0.0350983664393425, -0.010849891230463982, 0.023270489647984505, 0.06962184607982635, 0.032948095351457596, -0.02263789251446724, -0.036219436675310135, -0.011396334506571293, 0.030690548941493034, -0.052205443382263184, -0.018683966249227524, -0.013596265576779842, 0.019261684268712997, -0.020078495144844055, -0.029295792803168297 ]