question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I want to cluster <em>Facebook</em> user based on the number of mutual friends. If two users have more number of mutual friends then they are designated more closer to each other. I am thinking about using k-medoids clustering algorithm. In R I can use PAM for k-medoid clustering which needs data as a distance matrix.But How can I have mutual friend as similarity criteria? How can I convert this similarity to a distance matrix? </p>
74,408
[ -0.061929259449243546, -0.0025869254022836685, 0.009002922102808952, 0.01721707358956337, 0.032172344624996185, -0.007984261028468609, -0.028275366872549057, -0.004995472729206085, 0.014021184295415878, -0.030572133138775826, 0.006434293929487467, 0.04485706239938736, 0.03389555215835571, 0.04124777019023895, 0.029581936076283455, 0.00627047149464488, -0.026562247425317764, 0.001236524200066924, 0.0031739671248942614, -0.022555023431777954, 0.017234982922673225, 0.0080714775249362, 0.04640636965632439, -0.009232993237674236, -0.011935941874980927, 0.06228598952293396, 0.015164213255047798, -0.025284338742494583, 0.0013770689256489277, 0.030316121876239777, -0.056094393134117126, -0.03600649535655975, 0.02812502160668373, -0.005684877745807171, -0.0014557958347722888, -0.013147689402103424, -0.0627942830324173, 0.009932168759405613, -0.037175774574279785, -0.014045254327356815, 0.0008760476484894753, -0.06298793107271194, 0.03244207426905632, 0.03433549031615257, -0.017609411850571632, 0.0028280531987547874, 0.0014366552932187915, -0.04389394819736481, -0.002717088907957077, -0.011020117439329624, 0.12230928242206573, 0.02183183655142784, 0.018017470836639404, 0.030489830300211906, 0.00009267681161873043, 0.022246507927775383, 0.061899710446596146, 0.07060612738132477, 0.010429170913994312, 0.0002979117853101343, -0.04210270941257477, -0.039526600390672684, 0.01443721167743206, -0.04184174910187721, -0.01431266125291586, 0.027796512469649315, -0.02983722649514675, 0.01996026746928692, 0.021643251180648804, -0.020509660243988037, 0.003140135435387492, 0.0187523290514946, 0.052381061017513275, -0.06281089037656784, -0.013601127080619335, -0.012327579781413078, -0.044517632573843, 0.016100894659757614, 0.05855274945497513, 0.011973410844802856, -0.011585327796638012, 0.03436094895005226, 0.01265009120106697, -0.025522246956825256, 0.0326521173119545, -0.016178665682673454, 0.0355735681951046, -0.03209030628204346, -0.0005346667603589594, 0.044052496552467346, -0.031030166894197464, -0.0002930891641881317, 0.037276022136211395, 0.06378573924303055, -0.014498847536742687, 0.04140407219529152, 0.004835896193981171, 0.014463747851550579, 0.004005771595984697, -0.02222052589058876, -0.015876861289143562, -0.029348168522119522, 0.01679929345846176, 0.014549857936799526, 0.000023817114197299816, 0.010468021035194397, -0.03077576868236065, -0.021029869094491005, -0.025324976071715355, 0.011227087117731571, -0.019036607816815376, 0.033117469400167465, 0.006587485317140818, -0.01883443258702755, 0.053910162299871445, -0.048774976283311844, -0.013604160398244858, -0.0518600270152092, 0.04912690445780754, 0.08482256531715393, 0.01882297545671463, 0.028051013126969337, 0.04970445856451988, -0.0334257036447525, -0.038441404700279236, 0.018770914524793625, -0.047663867473602295, -0.02116580307483673, -0.039365291595458984, 0.043852005153894424, -0.022385887801647186, -0.0031591011211276054, -0.014647121541202068, -0.0324983075261116, 0.005084276665002108, -0.001291584107093513, -0.07709186524152756, -0.014394409954547882, 0.023820960894227028, 0.004038714338093996, 0.03635226935148239, -0.05571187287569046, 0.011238847859203815, 0.0046043479815125465, 0.07614177465438843, 0.02438003569841385, 0.011137711815536022, 0.02780463546514511, 0.038745149970054626, 0.006623001769185066, -0.021406183019280434, -0.022673575207591057, -0.058128722012043, 0.003591245971620083, -0.01889009028673172, -0.08754640817642212, 0.003745259018614888, 0.04125426709651947, -0.015505566261708736, 0.010330228134989738, 0.05487171560525894, 0.010670637711882591, -0.04028647020459175, -0.017326299101114273, -0.018657440319657326, -0.018549513071775436, 0.05033005028963089, 0.02207743562757969, 0.002127231564372778, 0.03134338557720184, -0.005368481855839491, 0.026006996631622314, 0.005403509829193354, 0.039910003542900085, 0.057245321571826935, 0.015883345156908035, -0.008273662067949772, 0.016577675938606262, 0.02246624417603016, 0.04236380010843277, -0.039028435945510864, -0.014504593797028065, 0.012965265661478043, 0.019913233816623688, 0.02833898551762104, 0.01282037515193224, -0.002094913274049759, -0.02617071010172367, 0.02854081429541111, -0.03093988448381424, -0.02961154654622078, -0.06584218889474869, -0.003378938650712371, 0.0029529291205108166, -0.007818767800927162, 0.017017580568790436, -0.0016347323544323444, -0.0361265130341053, 0.011532288044691086, -0.005263075698167086, -0.04050229862332344, -0.01824318990111351, 0.06154473125934601, -0.02085302770137787, -0.04224279522895813, 0.06573454290628433, 0.040435392409563065, 0.0028433562256395817, 0.0471193790435791, -0.04210402071475983, -0.0662931352853775, -0.024964619427919388, -0.022092653438448906, 0.00968998670578003, -0.019354358315467834, 0.017102017998695374, 0.01977897249162197, 0.02144743874669075, -0.02543777786195278, 0.012582015246152878, -0.07024750858545303, 0.06716641038656235, 0.05306016653776169, 0.02712937630712986, 0.02008712664246559, -0.03875599056482315, 0.014687709510326385, 0.0017147083999589086, -0.004265222232788801, -0.02057020552456379, -0.07437930256128311, -0.0029493626207113266, 0.010405815206468105, 0.02023860067129135, -0.061491720378398895, 0.012160190381109715, 0.028382962569594383, 0.011815080419182777, 0.0007722463342361152, 0.01768726296722889, 0.0000061658529375563376, 0.009354667738080025, 0.025621993467211723, 0.006171729415655136, -0.012497915886342525, -0.052202917635440826, 0.009143861010670662, -0.010910127311944962, 0.045434609055519104, 0.005565460305660963, -0.022826459258794785, 0.02947014756500721, 0.002028929302468896, 0.024483362212777138, 0.010782389901578426, -0.037065744400024414, 0.005794332828372717, -0.029617074877023697, -0.021001912653446198, 0.041778113692998886, 0.02121596969664097, -0.009059526026248932, 0.0037434620317071676, -0.030838994309306145, 0.007990119978785515, 0.08438290655612946, -0.041278496384620667, 0.014621760696172714, 0.0022247580345720053, -0.0640263706445694, 0.01007357519119978, 0.024388497695326805, -0.02793526090681553, -0.03522300720214844, 0.013955860398709774, 0.04253819212317467, 0.011030357331037521, 0.019882654771208763, 0.0022032533306628466, -0.005105771590024233, 0.0454837828874588, -0.011853107251226902, 0.022406641393899918, -0.003555652219802141, -0.055496327579021454, 0.004116650205105543, 0.01493381429463625, 0.0028177022468298674, -0.014403906650841236, -0.009212291799485683, -0.0056817480362951756, -0.0005296670715324581, 0.02059648372232914, -0.05187911167740822, 0.008860825560986996, -0.0009348508319817483, 0.02669203281402588, 0.019461384043097496, 0.012973944656550884, 0.029799126088619232, 0.02515021152794361, -0.0665665715932846, 0.005162529647350311, -0.03729894012212753, -0.015998685732483864, -0.02622191794216633, -0.007095219101756811, 0.015007569454610348, -0.009248930960893631, 0.0019925746601074934, 0.015132715925574303, -0.02637230046093464, 0.010706013068556786, -0.07187248021364212, -0.051882464438676834, 0.057832859456539154, 0.0025743143633008003, 0.039364494383335114, 0.0362415537238121, -0.028355930000543594, 0.061033107340335846, 0.022888805717229843, -0.03545515239238739, -0.06687650084495544, 0.020856400951743126, -0.04762734845280647, -0.04559795558452606, 0.036668963730335236, 0.037729185074567795, 0.02150309830904007, 0.022077791392803192, 0.019485117867588997, 0.011790611781179905, 0.08409281075000763, -0.03293781355023384, -0.020296085625886917, -0.003978733438998461, -0.016580069437623024, -0.00205258303321898, 0.040794115513563156, -0.033973000943660736, -0.007509217131882906, 0.02931734174489975, 0.034143779426813126, 0.012161405757069588, -0.010154811665415764, -0.031867366284132004, -0.027493061497807503, -0.01602904312312603, 0.005217562895268202, -0.04206116497516632, 0.00500267930328846, -0.008666113018989563, -0.03274551406502724, 0.0476713664829731, 0.03774494305253029, 0.0533987432718277, -0.020956657826900482, -0.015514175407588482, 0.07986827194690704, 0.03944867104291916, -0.012877301312983036, 0.006351299583911896, -0.006999654229730368, -0.019830770790576935, 0.004241281654685736, -0.026143591850996017, 0.029068952426314354, -0.01463286206126213, 0.02387838251888752, 0.010921509005129337, 0.007612483110278845, -0.01667940802872181, 0.035964690148830414, -0.02235601283609867, -0.022979525849223137, -0.02140980027616024, 0.038455840200185776, -0.027819352224469185, 0.01939854957163334, 0.006651404779404402, -0.049437712877988815, 0.011053334921598434, -0.02297274023294449, -0.051575373858213425, 0.01459795143455267, -0.02776670828461647, 0.005356451962143183, 0.01520189642906189, -0.023760471493005753, -0.017402151599526405, -0.0012815534137189388, 0.02739856392145157, -0.004345095716416836, 0.029566127806901932, -0.04319655895233154, -0.0053862156346440315, -0.03822356462478638, -0.004146347288042307, -0.002843327820301056, 0.018658285960555077, 0.04402951896190643, 0.008753973990678787, 0.027655992656946182, -0.0013549445429816842, -0.013255348429083824, -0.01218703854829073, 0.002175925998017192, -0.0033677290193736553, 0.037453219294548035, 0.04608830437064171, 0.004450078122317791, 0.01691988855600357, -0.0043018958531320095, 0.0008285063086077571, 0.005402895621955395, 0.042470283806324005, 0.034477122128009796, -0.017974959686398506, -0.019039934501051903, -0.06439749896526337, -0.04546743631362915, -0.028139345347881317, 0.037570495158433914, -0.005089680198580027, -0.036312852054834366, 0.032761793583631516, 0.02190323732793331, -0.045063771307468414, 0.010249930433928967, 0.07829242944717407, 0.03159349411725998, -0.044755250215530396, -0.00946770329028368, -0.02572494000196457, 0.04112067073583603, 0.003071463666856289, 0.03978473320603371, 0.018816370517015457, 0.018925271928310394, 0.017000744119286537, 0.03549601882696152, -0.03474413976073265, -0.04341016337275505, -0.017009690403938293, -0.023234155029058456, 0.029605576768517494, -0.029215916991233826, -0.016736898571252823, -0.02607642114162445, 0.05670611560344696, 0.06669573485851288, -0.01029298547655344, 0.004536835942417383, -0.09449528157711029, 0.025169963017106056, 0.03497841954231262, 0.03955297917127609, -0.008410941809415817, 0.0014545513549819589, -0.041025757789611816, 0.004334552679210901, 0.048406973481178284, -0.015775924548506737, 0.02730952762067318, -0.008090369403362274, 0.036452509462833405, -0.006186351645737886, 0.0069648572243750095, -0.02588934451341629, 0.003884684294462204, -0.01743173785507679, 0.01913408935070038, -0.008586510084569454, -0.007160073611885309, -0.03498418256640434, 0.03468476980924606, 0.03556681424379349, 0.051795218139886856, -0.004290875978767872, -0.008886916562914848, 0.036095030605793, -0.010825132019817829, 0.001916454522870481, -0.049214642494916916, 0.012316872365772724, 0.022958865389227867, -0.011161239817738533, 0.02719152346253395, 0.010151753202080727, 0.016666581854224205, 0.028864558786153793, -0.006580768618732691, -0.01791369915008545, 0.018607061356306076, -0.04439539089798927, 0.05626818537712097, 0.01418326236307621, -0.0016401347238570452, 0.043135449290275574, 0.057813458144664764, 0.008155814372003078, 0.015158661641180515, -0.06112390756607056, -0.0049898396246135235, -0.02430768497288227, -0.027606815099716187, -0.03765551745891571, -0.0075326962396502495, -0.04260813817381859, -0.008837678469717503, -0.017650263383984566, 0.029956642538309097, -0.011298215948045254, -0.01939653605222702, 0.00597007479518652, 0.0175565667450428, -0.031320057809352875, 0.031187033280730247, 0.039576455950737, 0.0022990878205746412, 0.0018516907002776861, -0.009527130052447319, 0.039555873721838, 0.00015694141620770097, 0.01615970954298973, 0.005578731652349234, -0.019385917112231255, -0.008206923492252827, -0.03124852105975151, -0.024980736896395683, 0.040645401924848557, -0.02760905586183071, 0.03403085470199585, -0.019635038450360298, -0.02008606307208538, 0.015521969646215439, -0.02887481264770031, 0.014675956219434738, 0.0194862000644207, -0.05371244251728058, -0.00313789420761168, -0.018224216997623444, -0.005759409628808498, 0.017394790425896645, -0.03229426592588425, -0.03741002827882767, -0.011290999129414558, 0.031350027769804, -0.03424917161464691, -0.013967240229249, -0.07276397943496704, 0.005057459697127342, -0.03455859422683716, 0.005630826577544212, 0.0048167407512664795, 0.0427936315536499, 0.0011575095122680068, -0.0009866548934951425, -0.030921323224902153, 0.0068918559700250626, 0.045781783759593964, 0.03903529793024063, -0.011401539668440819, 0.01538141444325447, 0.0028392805252224207, 0.006589322816580534, -0.025057325139641762, 0.012033132836222649, -0.02163349650800228, 0.002541385591030121, -0.06254179775714874, -0.006480435840785503, 0.05379384756088257, -0.006990976631641388, -0.019369928166270256, 0.002070134971290827, 0.015948737040162086, 0.015068532899022102, -0.021147677674889565, 0.0033403034321963787, -0.018068889155983925, 0.006335021462291479, -0.053010426461696625, 0.0118488734588027, 0.015975072979927063, 0.008611823432147503, 0.027069952338933945, -0.010115326382219791, 0.030717652291059494, -0.022490549832582474, 0.08478914946317673, 0.0116012804210186, 0.029772503301501274, 0.024095704779028893, -0.027630029246211052, 0.0493411086499691, -0.01724664866924286, -0.0005193495308049023, -0.029834885150194168, 0.06729405373334885, 0.00566109549254179, -0.007188086397945881, -0.013333121314644814, 0.0016040195478126407, 0.054696083068847656, -0.005717286840081215, 0.003982485271990299, 0.03548853099346161, 0.011821480467915535, -0.0012665782123804092, -0.011323148384690285, -0.01237460970878601, -0.022577689960598946, -0.0035327591467648745, 0.06412270665168762, -0.013536155223846436, -0.0043827835470438, 0.028100181370973587, 0.0074729048646986485, -0.032466571778059006, 0.052650950849056244, 0.04088772088289261, 0.02478991076350212, -0.021610770374536514, -0.0022959867492318153, -0.02878202684223652, -0.013392346911132336, -0.027563923969864845, 0.00484226131811738, -0.03077833354473114, -0.04431140795350075, 0.05891614779829979, 0.04311100021004677, 0.032140929251909256, 0.0183833297342062, -0.025142870843410492, -0.049140553921461105, 0.00830015353858471, 0.034364789724349976, -0.009276150725781918, 0.0477648600935936, -0.0034535506274551153, 0.04761780425906181, 0.01603790372610092, 0.024442624300718307, -0.026993434876203537, -0.034979674965143204, -0.021363994106650352, -0.012874610722064972, -0.03934669494628906, 0.03750932961702347, 0.00135664117988199, -0.07114534080028534, 0.0383182093501091, 0.010751294903457165, -0.0018842576537281275, 0.0024622762575745583, 0.03973417729139328, -0.014500238932669163, 0.03778303414583206, 0.02044130302965641, -0.013642420060932636, 0.014068862423300743, -0.005354280583560467, 0.1300186961889267, 0.08504849672317505, 0.025500480085611343, -0.07488103955984116, 0.013394832611083984, -0.02269359678030014, -0.049477118998765945, -0.0485440194606781, 0.05223807692527771, -0.026534777134656906, 0.005467185750603676, 0.040971752256155014, 0.06194174289703369, 0.005266597960144281, 0.017903292551636696, 0.07490146160125732, -0.0070469374768435955, -0.03411759063601494, 0.026487259194254875, -0.018645841628313065, -0.028183966875076294, -0.014255842193961143, -0.05154890939593315, 0.04711359739303589, 0.02164701744914055, 0.00033198873279616237, -0.025850210338830948, -0.0013957872288301587, 0.02043122425675392, -0.045888472348451614, 0.00477565685287118, 0.000974723428953439, 0.01932409405708313, -0.002637978410348296, 0.015741562470793724, 0.02365286834537983, 0.028236176818609238, -0.028598826378583908, -0.010418673045933247, -0.0027656916063278913, 0.010859793983399868, 0.004126093816012144, -0.022467361763119698, -0.02083476260304451, -0.02439064532518387, -0.022056279703974724, -0.03431903198361397, 0.034390512853860855, 0.01535402424633503, 0.025390643626451492, 0.03189500421285629, 0.021662568673491478, -0.014471753500401974, -0.024118686094880104, -0.0007766850758343935, 0.04068777710199356, 0.06884980946779251, 0.032854143530130386, -0.027061620727181435, -0.035698339343070984, 0.05560575798153877, -0.021176129579544067, -0.012569192796945572, 0.028582878410816193, -0.011631923727691174, 0.006863734684884548, -0.02893524430692196, 0.056314557790756226, -0.04321899265050888, -0.0002242007030872628, -0.035643503069877625, -0.03477539122104645, 0.009173326194286346, -0.03573913127183914, 0.0014286530204117298, -0.005948031321167946, 0.019282929599285126, 0.005943563766777515, 0.013857209123671055, 0.0108687374740839, -0.023724975064396858, -0.0014381204964593053, -0.015455634333193302, -0.03045150265097618, -0.02576727792620659, 0.010236547328531742, 0.05939476937055588, 0.028522344306111336, 0.002196971559897065, -0.00001049349066306604, -0.03287018835544586, -0.00023006675473880023, -0.03393593430519104, -0.035011593252420425, 0.004814035724848509, 0.013718265108764172, -0.049291353672742844, 0.013039466924965382, -0.05467304587364197, 0.008568404242396355, 0.04265801981091499, -0.006662949454039335, -0.012204882688820362, 0.0028415031265467405, -0.021125268191099167, 0.02399330772459507, 0.03034226782619953, -0.03305262699723244, 0.002013240475207567, 0.005511419847607613, 0.01599734090268612, -0.03412216529250145, -0.020635759457945824, -0.035051386803388596, -0.062155988067388535, 0.009820401668548584, -0.016977323219180107, -0.001306447316892445, -0.007569546345621347, -0.037676021456718445, -0.0006384101579897106, -0.04146020859479904, -0.018044177442789078, -0.04447536915540695, 0.0031631707679480314, -0.041246868669986725, -0.03318724408745766, -0.028759194537997246, 0.014595318585634232, -0.013523157685995102, 0.026355570182204247, 0.05277565121650696, -0.015097033232450485, 0.032001130282878876, 0.0025216564536094666, 0.00961457472294569, -0.0404554083943367, 0.047640781849622726, -0.02717527747154236, -0.021402152255177498, 0.05737436190247536, -0.06995096802711487, -0.05857361853122711, 0.0041851140558719635, -0.011863143183290958, 0.04537629336118698, -0.00490127969533205, -0.018454425036907196, -0.009231088683009148, 0.05445593595504761, -0.0465027317404747, -0.014718417078256607, -0.021208742633461952, 0.0030609872192144394, 0.022784138098359108, 0.01722240261733532, 0.006638643331825733, -0.010765708982944489, -0.032047901302576065, -0.009596140123903751, 0.005104172974824905, -0.01891961880028248, -0.004295372869819403, 0.017382431775331497, -0.005244947038590908, -0.005218802019953728, 0.005041542928665876, 0.022591939195990562, 0.05774529278278351, 0.04484916478395462, -0.00725578935816884, 0.027778564020991325, -0.031127123162150383, 0.024070918560028076, -0.058240342885255814, 0.03284773230552673, -0.011907999403774738, 0.0009344586869701743, 0.05987153202295303, -0.08204412460327148, -0.015416386537253857, 0.020733390003442764, -0.06107465550303459, 0.027019185945391655, 0.010023063980042934, -0.039718080312013626, -0.016357598826289177, 0.025131894275546074, -0.00836257915943861, 0.06445902585983276, 0.013724763877689838, 0.043012022972106934, -0.0003660414076875895, 0.02159680426120758, 0.00831984356045723, -0.02194805257022381, -0.015046867541968822, 0.009051824919879436, -0.006656019017100334, -0.06166822090744972, 0.05961420387029648, -0.00026176735991612077, -0.05292323976755142, 0.013746721670031548, -0.027969928458333015, -0.003685633884742856, 0.06101233512163162, 0.049406472593545914, 0.007307171821594238, 0.05344444140791893, -0.010723819956183434, -0.009392062202095985, -0.020582174882292747, -0.022282199934124947, -0.022503750398755074, 0.02474590204656124, 0.01604427956044674, 0.0038531480822712183, 0.03854108601808548, -0.008391235955059528, -0.015549389645457268, -0.01577731780707836, -0.03982749953866005, -0.048422932624816895, -0.03987811133265495, -0.011220534332096577, 0.014164989814162254, -0.02005166932940483, -0.017285175621509552, 0.002443005796521902, -0.024523960426449776, 0.05176546424627304, 0.03884943202137947, 0.01383232232183218, 0.048169512301683426, -0.015919525176286697, -0.06519166380167007, 0.02132577635347843, -0.003010887885466218, 0.005202540662139654, -0.028108377009630203, 0.001923242467455566, -0.010394301265478134, -0.003240510355681181, -0.013221071101725101, 0.01314383465796709, -0.00687837228178978, 0.08739551156759262, -0.05024337023496628, 0.009617560543119907, 0.04170621186494827, -0.0032837740145623684, 0.015402869321405888, -0.03713681548833847, 0.01957113854587078, 0.006496689282357693, -0.019401464611291885, 0.0008936867234297097, -0.00009081001917365938, -0.026546644046902657, -0.007988362573087215, 0.05880079045891762, 0.0271300058811903, 0.012447844259440899, -0.04562435671687126, 0.026773186400532722, 0.008479106239974499, -0.06755305826663971, 0.028543680906295776, -0.0012175512965768576, -0.05120489001274109, -0.005620642565190792, -0.017118746414780617, -0.0026037709321826696, 0.007490604650229216, -0.003873575711622834, -0.0043164691887795925, -0.025700518861413002, 0.03273483365774155, -0.003838129574432969, 0.030504213646054268, 0.001568178995512426, -0.003304535523056984, 0.00562532152980566, 0.02126331813633442, 0.011236978694796562, 0.03733617812395096, 0.022575613111257553, -0.02160877361893654, 0.03731398284435272, -0.054009705781936646, -0.04363830015063286, 0.010790613479912281, -0.03461400046944618, -0.004793220665305853, -0.08531992137432098, -0.020822208374738693, 0.05817723646759987, -0.036593589931726456, 0.020982589572668076, 0.03182915225625038, 0.025226779282093048, 0.030202092602849007, 0.0032420074567198753, 0.05880049243569374, -0.008922254666686058, -0.04411720111966133, 0.052402086555957794, 0.010747363790869713, 0.005485657136887312, -0.00015774024359416217, 0.011341657489538193, -0.002523568458855152, -0.02755150943994522, 0.02357155829668045, -0.033541012555360794, 0.011875427328050137, 0.00043932232074439526, -0.007268483750522137, 0.002579593099653721, -0.025764048099517822, 0.04160112515091896, 0.00854417309165001, -0.010875980369746685, 0.03213125094771385, -0.05211625248193741, 0.01775607466697693, -0.038193702697753906, -0.041926681995391846, -0.026922650635242462, 0.049205075949430466, 0.009289776906371117, -0.0022320339921861887, -0.009492389857769012, 0.02600945346057415, 0.016747094690799713, -0.04805247485637665, -0.009534458629786968, 0.0236952044069767, 0.018528364598751068, 0.014599972404539585, -0.005530418362468481, 0.017979847267270088, 0.00883493572473526, -0.04540668800473213, -0.0066346824169158936, 0.014624394476413727, 0.045901909470558167, 0.025979503989219666, 0.0026739276945590973, -0.01835932955145836, -0.0021198727190494537, 0.014068149030208588, -0.08028458803892136, -0.028908023610711098, -0.07866118848323822, -0.01895185559988022, -0.009916562587022781, 0.0012059963773936033 ]
<p>I need to do a weighted multiple linear regression. If I want to weigh certain observations differently, am I correct that I simply have to multiply the y(i) of that observation, and the corresponding row in X, with that weight?</p>
74,409
[ -0.03746643289923668, 0.02416042983531952, -0.025068672373890877, -0.025286629796028137, 0.04942544549703598, 0.031130600720643997, -0.016715290024876595, -0.006852410733699799, 0.013502446003258228, -0.014664986170828342, 0.017826028168201447, 0.05186418816447258, 0.06085692718625069, -0.03383787348866463, 0.048046741634607315, 0.03264138847589493, -0.0009898390853777528, 0.033247511833906174, -0.006228521000593901, -0.008025508373975754, -0.008108851499855518, 0.042306676506996155, 0.004133717622607946, 0.017425773665308952, -0.014419829472899437, 0.054160621017217636, 0.015671664848923683, -0.01541481539607048, 0.02730429545044899, 0.053278326988220215, 0.00026884188991971314, -0.012673048302531242, 0.006047142669558525, 0.05606376379728317, 0.051893450319767, -0.0077952430583536625, -0.022643163800239563, -0.021772978827357292, -0.023975707590579987, 0.04973890632390976, -0.013771723955869675, -0.031206170096993446, -0.004250285215675831, 0.03985513374209404, 0.0045455326326191425, 0.040191490203142166, -0.014915293082594872, -0.012122463434934616, -0.001316581736318767, -0.05095095559954643, 0.13961003720760345, -0.009674472734332085, 0.032594189047813416, 0.06551361829042435, -0.030757931992411613, 0.003538206685334444, 0.06813259422779083, 0.06953448802232742, -0.010219228453934193, 0.0008797649061307311, -0.00504309544339776, 0.0025472696870565414, 0.02152726985514164, -0.028383824974298477, -0.03590215742588043, -0.048032235354185104, 0.00569349667057395, -0.02486623451113701, 0.014682210050523281, -0.01383784506469965, 0.022101229056715965, 0.03189420327544212, 0.04733055457472801, -0.03225696459412575, -0.025452639907598495, -0.02897297590970993, 0.022439811378717422, 0.030114177614450455, 0.056511640548706055, 0.0003489964874461293, 0.010193188674747944, 0.045589033514261246, 0.037515196949243546, 0.027771703898906708, 0.010749253444373608, -0.009828077629208565, 0.05840460583567619, -0.0014748669927939773, 0.048347439616918564, 0.03532753512263298, -0.01085455808788538, -0.00959096197038889, 0.04818020761013031, -0.011664859019219875, -0.017194151878356934, 0.01333179697394371, -0.0067284428514540195, 0.020067034289240837, 0.02320469357073307, 0.007784863002598286, -0.008813419379293919, -0.03525567427277565, -0.013102898374199867, 0.03353099524974823, -0.01707753725349903, 0.009150203317403793, 0.014905285090208054, 0.024249667301774025, 0.01589159108698368, -0.029637882485985756, -0.0014345262898132205, 0.018093353137373924, 0.007434961851686239, -0.04358183592557907, 0.02381417155265808, -0.01932680234313011, 0.006201671902090311, 0.007038007490336895, 0.03996394947171211, 0.06884922087192535, 0.009700008668005466, -0.06073088198900223, 0.03442917391657829, -0.026453174650669098, -0.03847680240869522, 0.04551323875784874, 0.0035124775022268295, -0.030858511105179787, -0.047367338091135025, 0.037733741104602814, 0.01664094813168049, -0.02419980987906456, 0.024002373218536377, -0.007341952063143253, 0.007763479836285114, -0.0062860725447535515, -0.10989861190319061, -0.056810855865478516, -0.01615697517991066, -0.0488830991089344, -0.02330348640680313, -0.017772652208805084, -0.009904867969453335, 0.04090176150202751, 0.07609209418296814, 0.03278609365224838, 0.03174012526869774, 0.033349040895700455, 0.03245606645941734, -0.013791093602776527, -0.003527698339894414, -0.03888028487563133, -0.026072584092617035, -0.06647545099258423, 0.014167241752147675, -0.10400066524744034, -0.007286056410521269, 0.018986007198691368, -0.0015394497895613313, 0.009630221873521805, 0.04233817383646965, -0.007805259898304939, -0.014105400070548058, 0.015637150034308434, 0.007987693883478642, -0.038574978709220886, 0.05448748916387558, -0.005505475681275129, 0.03410232067108154, 0.0005097259418107569, 0.015922565013170242, 0.0347510427236557, 0.0035455876495689154, 0.08863018453121185, 0.07126810401678085, -0.01268804632127285, -0.000341600039973855, -0.06363002210855484, 0.03643921762704849, 0.0044617606326937675, -0.0368628054857254, -0.05990567430853844, -0.007978053763508797, -0.0308887530118227, 0.029355019330978394, 0.0606670007109642, 0.013331578113138676, -0.015184051357209682, 0.037453971803188324, -0.02884545363485813, -0.018148209899663925, -0.045634519308805466, -0.011411717161536217, -0.02282431162893772, -0.0021760573145002127, -0.001240606070496142, 0.002665862673893571, 0.00952630303800106, -0.010663772001862526, -0.03266176953911781, -0.023698806762695312, 0.00846472941339016, 0.018834833055734634, -0.03945409506559372, -0.0016849092207849026, 0.04371514543890953, 0.0377177819609642, 0.010908479802310467, 0.03180287033319473, -0.060288771986961365, -0.02432289719581604, 0.03326733410358429, -0.028843725100159645, -0.004517455119639635, 0.0018779146485030651, -0.014010066166520119, 0.018304388970136642, -0.006716587580740452, -0.024076305329799652, 0.05287948250770569, -0.04606933519244194, 0.07876075059175491, 0.10430190712213516, -0.01781393401324749, -0.02667594514787197, 0.0038939251098781824, 0.02006552368402481, 0.016628323122859, -0.023047316819429398, -0.04815685376524925, -0.03284120559692383, -0.009981201030313969, -0.008163831196725368, -0.004582145716995001, -0.024772077798843384, 0.021315723657608032, 0.05240226164460182, 0.04196590185165405, 0.0007741770823486149, 0.032292336225509644, 0.002925288397818804, -0.01140485517680645, -0.005403317045420408, -0.013207856565713882, 0.025581911206245422, 0.02139952965080738, 0.0076207187958061695, 0.033916350454092026, 0.03240206092596054, -0.013140606693923473, 0.015995949506759644, 0.048597127199172974, -0.012008368037641048, 0.013851003721356392, 0.016896042972803116, -0.04347997531294823, 0.02308381348848343, -0.0552787184715271, 0.03666624799370766, 0.03317401185631752, -0.01972283609211445, -0.012821456417441368, 0.0237684715539217, -0.010489264503121376, -0.016945509240031242, 0.007996343076229095, -0.04720942676067352, 0.038468699902296066, 0.033345747739076614, -0.04442029446363449, 0.03286932036280632, -0.010300892405211926, -0.0009383544675074518, 0.006092534400522709, 0.01115074660629034, 0.025824852287769318, 0.0035712316166609526, 0.007046366576105356, -0.03110678493976593, -0.03225821256637573, -0.031951598823070526, -0.026641689240932465, -0.02079717628657818, -0.005366151686757803, -0.062777578830719, -0.01093715988099575, -0.07155848294496536, -0.040532227605581284, 0.03323998674750328, -0.013386945240199566, -0.0016852016560733318, 0.03015577606856823, 0.009023020975291729, -0.03648016229271889, -0.04238048195838928, -0.035294465720653534, 0.00021745679259765893, -0.012364042922854424, -0.01415913924574852, 0.03626280277967453, 0.015517635270953178, -0.06542161852121353, -0.0017455938505008817, -0.03103957138955593, -0.005311938002705574, -0.05373963713645935, 0.007736069615930319, -0.0018748634029179811, 0.013006589375436306, 0.025885194540023804, 0.032469842582941055, -0.0308709517121315, -0.03074556589126587, -0.029221542179584503, -0.04296932369470596, 0.041930411010980606, -0.010919560678303242, 0.020202023908495903, 0.011224835179746151, -0.049728021025657654, 0.09084948152303696, 0.029640067368745804, -0.02071435935795307, -0.04597153142094612, 0.0029452014714479446, -0.03185276314616203, -0.009424546733498573, 0.030396630987524986, -0.027949243783950806, -0.02419772371649742, 0.02301998808979988, 0.01037951372563839, -0.025447390973567963, 0.05045560002326965, 0.026763128116726875, -0.0032245528418570757, 0.01830325648188591, 0.0048745907843112946, -0.0013753523817285895, 0.05923984944820404, 0.002299718325957656, 0.016239602118730545, 0.013809551484882832, 0.0213308148086071, 0.009461406618356705, -0.014554794877767563, -0.026565993204712868, 0.027725469321012497, 0.00011733636347344145, 0.016324786469340324, -0.02802494913339615, 0.04207460582256317, 0.018781645223498344, 0.008273078128695488, 0.015407020226120949, 0.0032448668498545885, 0.011611046269536018, -0.021073199808597565, 0.0017929282039403915, 0.03542633354663849, 0.026307089254260063, 0.020619593560695648, -0.0008033924386836588, 0.011037766933441162, -0.005741146858781576, 0.039845213294029236, -0.06118651106953621, -0.01945658028125763, 0.009746353141963482, 0.026348136365413666, -0.005363295320421457, -0.01827908121049404, -0.059315841645002365, 0.004233852494508028, -0.05967465043067932, -0.004816017579287291, 0.013301999308168888, 0.03658502548933029, 0.013661034405231476, 0.04373900219798088, 0.005233642179518938, -0.027906466275453568, 0.019710225984454155, -0.04165825620293617, -0.03983919695019722, 0.023192213848233223, 0.004055466968566179, 0.0030811866745352745, 0.030518870800733566, -0.027506884187459946, 0.011219763197004795, -0.05133935436606407, 0.032822802662849426, -0.022543562576174736, -0.012516056187450886, -0.03509008511900902, 0.013457246124744415, -0.018891386687755585, -0.026951370760798454, 0.0076619284227490425, -0.0014801749493926764, 0.02928122505545616, -0.04193064197897911, 0.01863400638103485, 0.01493008341640234, -0.03309006989002228, -0.000719364732503891, -0.02729964442551136, 0.011421900242567062, 0.025327643379569054, 0.04592106491327286, -0.0011027760338038206, 0.043677691370248795, -0.05966577306389809, 0.016350604593753815, 0.001389944925904274, 0.03442269191145897, 0.029953904449939728, -0.059555795043706894, -0.03673752024769783, -0.017181435599923134, -0.03163806349039078, 0.011126687750220299, 0.027088934555649757, -0.0048187910579144955, -0.0061424607411026955, 0.06043919175863266, 0.024159729480743408, -0.0769486054778099, 0.012330259196460247, 0.05467725172638893, 0.026865247637033463, 0.004520535469055176, -0.02067522145807743, 0.04220353439450264, -0.006385676097124815, -0.00864306092262268, 0.017177080735564232, -0.003930620849132538, 0.006315588019788265, -0.03366443142294884, 0.02868330292403698, -0.015190891921520233, 0.002264228882268071, 0.034221913665533066, 0.024520810693502426, 0.04417353868484497, -0.008802336640655994, -0.026882430538535118, 0.026160286739468575, 0.029179738834500313, 0.012273309752345085, 0.045854728668928146, 0.0019094315357506275, -0.09366264194250107, -0.013431995175778866, 0.028900904580950737, 0.048360977321863174, -0.03152748569846153, -0.01181994192302227, 0.009850983507931232, -0.01711270585656166, 0.03705386072397232, -0.036729153245687485, 0.012355746701359749, -0.013317674398422241, 0.010249616578221321, -0.003430712968111038, -0.015167775563895702, -0.054697614163160324, 0.040317170321941376, -0.03905133157968521, 0.031060555949807167, -0.001307171187363565, -0.037271663546562195, -0.04603087902069092, 0.025040267035365105, -0.0009173898724839091, 0.058864060789346695, -0.026555757969617844, -0.015941297635436058, 0.004907554015517235, 0.04532156139612198, -0.03798369690775871, -0.04417560249567032, -0.015617640689015388, 0.021175451576709747, -0.006408986635506153, 0.04213005676865578, -0.001400839420966804, -0.04746492952108383, 0.025975147262215614, 0.015543622896075249, -0.015214847400784492, 0.0009007247281260788, -0.027199700474739075, 0.02392890304327011, 0.05354622006416321, -0.00863347202539444, 0.061592426151037216, 0.028257964178919792, -0.004775784909725189, 0.011376812122762203, -0.039723023772239685, -0.00026393786538392305, -0.033061202615499496, -0.03872327134013176, -0.019536703824996948, 0.023403050377964973, -0.0011033945484086871, 0.01773548685014248, 0.016225168481469154, 0.033969417214393616, -0.023825770244002342, -0.051710452884435654, -0.0073275137692689896, 0.021044300869107246, -0.0022839924786239862, -0.03461328148841858, -0.005049681290984154, 0.018295247107744217, -0.014119434170424938, -0.03532552719116211, -0.009638026356697083, 0.012401191517710686, 0.0013883757637813687, -0.004372145514935255, -0.02037041448056698, 0.011404607445001602, -0.020892690867185593, 0.003831401700153947, 0.002481169765815139, -0.03490506485104561, 0.03091399557888508, -0.0037969714030623436, -0.0032293801195919514, -0.01140525471419096, -0.055822063237428665, -0.008547250181436539, 0.01828926056623459, -0.005661128554493189, 0.022727157920598984, -0.025042209774255753, 0.02952241525053978, -0.018533146008849144, 0.0026553829666227102, -0.07084699720144272, -0.03594692051410675, -0.01826326735317707, -0.003948844503611326, 0.02714638225734234, -0.0347650870680809, 0.00624605780467391, -0.03274741768836975, -0.03934701532125473, -0.040959618985652924, 0.038246072828769684, -0.025944074615836143, -0.015030620619654655, -0.0000657212731312029, 0.01952032372355461, 0.06029697507619858, -0.009085608646273613, -0.013476517982780933, 0.008738159202039242, -0.03616897016763687, -0.013772854581475258, 0.01031371857970953, 0.0056937020272016525, -0.03261978551745415, -0.001575543312355876, -0.021542470902204514, -0.03037676215171814, 0.04639645293354988, -0.014670182019472122, 0.008608115836977959, 0.02414068393409252, 0.009335131384432316, -0.023346006870269775, -0.013017282821238041, 0.015439009293913841, -0.015180278569459915, -0.004403348080813885, -0.01638309471309185, 0.027218956500291824, -0.00573230953887105, 0.021602246910333633, 0.04494086280465126, 0.011848103255033493, -0.009226097725331783, 0.025274910032749176, 0.0769270732998848, 0.022031491622328758, 0.011656501330435276, -0.016579311341047287, -0.036772292107343674, 0.01272177416831255, -0.011188891716301441, -0.02491055242717266, 0.010977222584187984, 0.04797535389661789, -0.020990969613194466, -0.014116157777607441, -0.0501922108232975, 0.030384745448827744, 0.058291785418987274, -0.017182903364300728, 0.04245506227016449, 0.06955774873495102, 0.006957315839827061, -0.015915192663669586, -0.01585306227207184, -0.008133321069180965, 0.0006581033812835813, -0.02775612473487854, 0.06146571412682533, 0.015429016202688217, -0.016101453453302383, 0.027629097923636436, -0.0017172209918498993, 0.022399822250008583, 0.02288702316582203, 0.02011774107813835, 0.01763506606221199, 0.03235868737101555, 0.018075216561555862, -0.05568217113614082, 0.023206505924463272, -0.018644677475094795, -0.019763799384236336, -0.05307380482554436, -0.063254214823246, 0.042098257690668106, 0.03937694802880287, 0.016166632995009422, -0.06212146580219269, -0.06638114899396896, -0.029757769778370857, 0.008354895748198032, -0.014736459590494633, 0.0015442277071997523, 0.04114283621311188, 0.03868092969059944, 0.029745440930128098, 0.025796670466661453, 0.010071109049022198, -0.035128820687532425, -0.08598656952381134, -0.03948681801557541, -0.029222974553704262, -0.02964339777827263, -0.017630958929657936, -0.003468720242381096, -0.03891504183411598, 0.01522247213870287, -0.02032325603067875, -0.004485129378736019, 0.0162253025919199, 0.04691549763083458, -0.0013216654770076275, 0.04081493243575096, -0.021117500960826874, -0.018025413155555725, 0.018127305433154106, -0.01025830116122961, 0.10791245847940445, 0.0816817656159401, 0.0321178063750267, -0.07524864375591278, 0.011689710430800915, -0.033958129584789276, -0.045975200831890106, -0.02544979564845562, -0.001571413828060031, 0.0035788347013294697, 0.009587549604475498, 0.012576221488416195, 0.0624106228351593, -0.0195598267018795, -0.0006403726292774081, 0.043870531022548676, -0.013511727564036846, -0.019883722066879272, 0.0062008025124669075, -0.006917394232004881, 0.013726760633289814, -0.023176034912467003, -0.07131925970315933, 0.019433384761214256, -0.009617878124117851, -0.01240538526326418, 0.0011549416230991483, -0.01271930430084467, 0.00675084488466382, -0.007805634289979935, -0.01764131523668766, 0.02584894374012947, 0.018488973379135132, -0.002671726979315281, -0.03265174850821495, 0.03524552285671234, 0.051703471690416336, -0.024250991642475128, 0.012116805650293827, -0.01723293401300907, -0.02253902517259121, 0.010295401327311993, -0.022703008726239204, -0.007756615057587624, -0.05203289911150932, -0.00990306492894888, -0.022936517372727394, 0.02303624153137207, 0.005845478270202875, -0.02095903269946575, 0.0358593724668026, 0.02281363494694233, 0.007768453098833561, -0.08523218333721161, 0.0032984178978949785, 0.04432713985443115, 0.04121493548154831, -0.027040110900998116, -0.016727404668927193, -0.006410160101950169, 0.000717758375685662, 0.01869644597172737, 0.02645249105989933, 0.06462867558002472, -0.0538722462952137, -0.031754642724990845, -0.029860204085707664, 0.03227311000227928, 0.012357249855995178, -0.005413533188402653, 0.0018667160766199231, -0.02948669157922268, -0.0016738389385864139, -0.04939284920692444, 0.015006333589553833, -0.014441384933888912, 0.014310377649962902, -0.010396079160273075, 0.016025003045797348, -0.029981808736920357, -0.051505476236343384, 0.00851461198180914, -0.014876320958137512, -0.0036562865134328604, -0.05188798904418945, 0.010662599466741085, 0.026797713711857796, 0.05145779624581337, 0.023895613849163055, 0.013701966032385826, -0.00530774611979723, 0.03085682913661003, 0.002593638375401497, -0.05485745146870613, 0.013983220793306828, 0.003940176218748093, -0.019037192687392235, 0.01970525272190571, -0.002444179030135274, 0.06075282394886017, 0.01691940799355507, 0.009332425892353058, -0.021153593435883522, 0.04276416450738907, -0.007259597536176443, 0.01085529662668705, -0.005149851553142071, -0.07975850254297256, 0.03706541284918785, 0.012369172647595406, -0.016302959993481636, -0.06122780218720436, -0.01462146919220686, -0.062174875289201736, -0.04825844243168831, 0.0007008124375715852, -0.008892253041267395, -0.023908095434308052, 0.019528839737176895, -0.011517207138240337, 0.021136250346899033, -0.021292567253112793, -0.016653092578053474, -0.041679657995700836, -0.007636209484189749, -0.0014848308637738228, -0.02817804366350174, -0.015710489824414253, -0.03244587406516075, -0.036060478538274765, 0.029222065582871437, 0.05892479792237282, -0.011615046299993992, 0.020112987607717514, -0.006607738323509693, 0.01900539919734001, -0.02642921730875969, 0.06098126247525215, -0.03195933625102043, -0.02351481281220913, 0.025424836203455925, -0.012912304140627384, 0.03550886735320091, 0.036297257989645004, -0.015102864243090153, 0.04946642369031906, 0.03173850476741791, -0.00011859517690027133, -0.0378422774374485, 0.05247785523533821, -0.029776811599731445, 0.0020421624649316072, -0.02013508789241314, 0.006373472046107054, 0.0325561985373497, 0.019306786358356476, 0.014370197430253029, 0.004734240937978029, -0.0025987878907471895, 0.024017823860049248, 0.029508208855986595, 0.010916091501712799, -0.006412125192582607, -0.016939526423811913, 0.05274872109293938, 0.07999623566865921, 0.0016096055041998625, -0.0180791188031435, 0.0465635284781456, 0.0005608409410342574, -0.06645524501800537, 0.04285012558102608, 0.010862288996577263, 0.009175573475658894, -0.06171955168247223, -0.030819224193692207, 0.0008875529165379703, -0.005429227836430073, 0.04470805823802948, -0.03377456218004227, 0.0069452738389372826, 0.019842393696308136, -0.02450437657535076, -0.007703438866883516, 0.013224867172539234, -0.009065855294466019, -0.0026061739772558212, 0.02851458638906479, 0.010381038300693035, -0.0016030482947826385, 0.036649055778980255, 0.03539426624774933, 0.027691982686519623, 0.026395512744784355, 0.028556548058986664, -0.02186913974583149, 0.00859801098704338, 0.016140099614858627, 0.011161393485963345, -0.053729765117168427, 0.043725162744522095, -0.04990364983677864, -0.03760896250605583, 0.054881948977708817, 0.0021601710468530655, 0.03460546210408211, 0.009613500908017159, 0.05255744978785515, 0.016049696132540703, 0.0450359471142292, 0.01278979517519474, 0.002263809787109494, 0.012006834149360657, 0.021121621131896973, 0.014672459103167057, 0.010560069233179092, -0.0415312759578228, 0.04687744751572609, 0.02497696876525879, -0.016807973384857178, -0.01753326691687107, 0.015803957358002663, -0.0005917789530940354, 0.006087773479521275, -0.022908741608262062, 0.004361832980066538, -0.0017288908129557967, -0.026497328653931618, 0.018681764602661133, -0.027647489681839943, -0.0014796837931498885, 0.039604391902685165, 0.000021104733605170622, -0.03680092468857765, 0.004391621798276901, 0.017399311065673828, -0.06596685200929642, 0.006296214647591114, -0.011291785165667534, -0.021927224472165108, -0.0841953381896019, 0.028142929077148438, 0.02861897647380829, -0.04871615394949913, -0.04859796166419983, -0.024918505921959877, -0.06002426519989967, 0.014513394795358181, -0.026140373200178146, -0.0036185698118060827, 0.03477964922785759, -0.026696009561419487, 0.008728038519620895, -0.08629080653190613, 0.0709192305803299, 0.0329446904361248, -0.014515222050249577, -0.03181832283735275, -0.010071058757603168, -0.02614058181643486, 0.0028441278263926506, 0.0521690808236599, 0.019573887810111046, 0.014906383119523525, 0.00804587360471487, 0.011286701075732708, -0.03291997313499451, -0.026215607300400734, 0.034743476659059525, -0.005680389236658812, -0.023396380245685577, -0.03353029489517212, 0.007720891386270523, 0.004629375878721476, -0.005140949506312609, -0.003460284788161516, -0.03226770833134651, 0.0026397057808935642, 0.01079061720520258, 0.02546808496117592, 0.020749874413013458, -0.000394967821193859, -0.004790253471583128, 0.04098081588745117, 0.02515815943479538, 0.01655842550098896, 0.057553570717573166, -0.004381826613098383, -0.06666278094053268, 0.01770581118762493, -0.045055095106363297, -0.009742497466504574, 0.030240904539823532, -0.013581963256001472, -0.010258616879582405, -0.06622888147830963, 0.0014819360803812742, 0.02230052463710308, -0.021896323189139366, -0.01783338375389576, 0.02987075224518776, 0.04966946691274643, 0.04839950054883957, 0.03827228024601936, 0.029367659240961075, -0.0005991643411107361, -0.02361488528549671, 0.018980959430336952, 0.024970879778265953, 0.04609891027212143, 0.022343942895531654, 0.0070214117877185345, 0.004454795736819506, -0.004139437805861235, 0.02117105759680271, 0.0013956705806776881, 0.022275200113654137, -0.02458471991121769, -0.016382725909352303, -0.01563076116144657, -0.020731473341584206, 0.01390479039400816, -0.03078095056116581, -0.014378311112523079, 0.027328800410032272, -0.04085009545087814, -0.010234699584543705, -0.02802066132426262, -0.005961347837001085, -0.004267811309546232, 0.004572281148284674, 0.010340034030377865, 0.05024851858615875, -0.003936432767659426, -0.009427472949028015, -0.00380514282733202, -0.02522174082696438, 0.008617189712822437, -0.019118716940283775, 0.030248742550611496, -0.022680161520838737, -0.0051401592791080475, -0.0257396437227726, -0.029754284769296646, -0.04770810157060623, 0.019335560500621796, 0.012980462051928043, 0.03354404866695404, 0.035112492740154266, -0.01104611437767744, 0.0015935092233121395, -0.013782544992864132, 0.0033272297587245703, -0.06980475783348083, -0.02214658260345459, -0.039527133107185364, 0.011387577280402184, 0.021798932924866676, -0.011702829040586948 ]
<p>I have been running a linear regression where my dependent variable is a composite. By this I mean that it is built up of components that are added and multiplied together. Specifically, for the composite variable A:</p> <pre><code>A = (B*C + D*E + F*G + H*I + J*K + L*M)*(1 - N)*(1 + O*P) </code></pre> <p>None of the component variables are used as independent variables (the only independent variables are dummy variables). The component variables are mostly (though not completely) independent of one another.</p> <p>Currently I just run a regression with A as the DV, to estimate each dummy variable's effect on A. But I would also like to estimate each dummy variable's effect on the separate components of A (and in the future I hope to try applying separate priors for each component). To do this I have been running several separate regressions, each with a different one of the components as the DV (and using the same IVs for all the regressions). If I do this, should I expect that for a given dummy IV, I could recombine the coefficient estimates from all the separate regressions (using the formula listed above) and get the same value as I get for that IV when I run the composite A regression? Am I magnifying the coefficient standard errors by running all these separate regressions and then trying to recombine the values (there is a lot of multicollinearity in the dummy variables)? Is there some other structure than linear regression that would be better for a case like this?</p>
49,090
[ -0.0062982081435620785, 0.03052617609500885, -0.019824910908937454, -0.006211572326719761, 0.05246743932366371, 0.012133017182350159, -0.036869894713163376, -0.018249720335006714, 0.028386706486344337, -0.04545292630791664, 0.0228371974080801, 0.009569907560944557, 0.08022745698690414, 0.0023751554545015097, 0.02365022525191307, -0.020861100405454636, 0.008636780083179474, 0.006774034351110458, 0.019737550988793373, -0.010134273208677769, -0.01034343522042036, 0.018764108419418335, 0.0036305775865912437, 0.002455134177580476, 0.03168085217475891, 0.05559268221259117, -0.012500235810875893, -0.025538241490721703, 0.023690801113843918, 0.04465075582265854, -0.005514469463378191, -0.026419704779982567, 0.007779482286423445, 0.055714454501867294, -0.002397051313892007, 0.017056502401828766, 0.0007306763436645269, -0.02579651027917862, -0.01744779385626316, 0.029168378561735153, -0.006855757441371679, -0.03306667134165764, -0.044847387820482254, 0.021411415189504623, 0.00816328451037407, 0.01926649920642376, 0.004495043307542801, -0.014272545464336872, 0.04818972945213318, -0.047886237502098083, 0.0747380331158638, 0.02892819046974182, 0.04670400172472, 0.04205874353647232, -0.04188956692814827, -0.009504024870693684, 0.05993366241455078, 0.05367496609687805, 0.025623846799135208, -0.0382235124707222, -0.008336987346410751, -0.027462102472782135, 0.0276201032102108, 0.019683249294757843, -0.0369417667388916, 0.03727184608578682, -0.023218616843223572, -0.03837548941373825, -0.0009605815284885466, -0.06710834056138992, 0.037031758576631546, 0.026953693479299545, 0.03253473713994026, -0.012044808827340603, -0.015909161418676376, -0.02573840506374836, 0.0376492403447628, 0.0369793064892292, 0.038294896483421326, 0.0200116615742445, -0.015394055284559727, 0.010096332058310509, 0.04302636906504631, 0.03426821529865265, 0.011240720748901367, 0.029550107195973396, 0.0477977991104126, -0.054607734084129333, 0.04248006269335747, -0.01734302006661892, -0.005179912783205509, 0.02351348288357258, 0.07330800592899323, 0.04945571348071098, -0.051071010529994965, 0.004816107451915741, -0.020887581631541252, 0.02998117357492447, 0.0051779188215732574, -0.006856655701994896, -0.046744849532842636, -0.01946204900741577, -0.009915058501064777, 0.033927056938409805, 0.003802303224802017, 0.02034054696559906, -0.043466318398714066, -0.010227461345493793, 0.022219371050596237, -0.04682547226548195, -0.01783875748515129, -0.03076455183327198, -0.025997977703809738, -0.027094503864645958, -0.000639961042907089, -0.032663650810718536, -0.03402610123157501, -0.0018710960866883397, 0.08039984107017517, 0.0679575502872467, 0.038881316781044006, -0.054202932864427567, 0.018035991117358208, -0.021081604063510895, -0.07283580303192139, 0.03753877431154251, -0.0029260856099426746, -0.018890593200922012, -0.06109507009387016, 0.051217421889305115, 0.011797986924648285, -0.04208920896053314, 0.03191433846950531, -0.003244113875553012, 0.0015386000741273165, -0.0162710789591074, -0.055473800748586655, -0.05627253279089928, 0.005637251306325197, -0.06957449018955231, 0.031674910336732864, -0.05483309552073479, 0.0033208339009433985, 0.009485817514359951, 0.08447381108999252, 0.008015931583940983, 0.048781853169202805, 0.046256087720394135, 0.040770187973976135, 0.014128465205430984, -0.03864958509802818, -0.04699661582708359, -0.029019350185990334, -0.04816053435206413, -0.017593752592802048, -0.09578307718038559, 0.03340433910489082, 0.005039443261921406, -0.018575776368379593, 0.025365112349390984, 0.07439862936735153, 0.01270496379584074, -0.025443850085139275, 0.048559557646512985, 0.004319482948631048, -0.032324083149433136, 0.03359129652380943, 0.002014743397012353, 0.022848302498459816, 0.0170805212110281, 0.011657202616333961, -0.005853372626006603, 0.009103350341320038, 0.076090008020401, 0.016143862158060074, -0.04288502037525177, 0.019633786752820015, -0.026376698166131973, 0.023083187639713287, -0.02188185416162014, -0.046654000878334045, -0.055554699152708054, -0.004666295368224382, -0.026188384741544724, 0.022761808708310127, 0.0416351817548275, 0.012977123260498047, -0.03079148940742016, 0.02822372131049633, -0.051617883145809174, -0.03355397284030914, -0.07773179560899734, 0.0023094122298061848, 0.013336527161300182, -0.02561339922249317, 0.03418438136577606, -0.018593790009617805, 0.045111171901226044, 0.0142348138615489, -0.018799301236867905, 0.005788014270365238, 0.005292855203151703, 0.03598443791270256, -0.019296826794743538, 0.030790410935878754, 0.026626311242580414, 0.06946780532598495, -0.0036058721598237753, 0.05787365883588791, 0.0029650344513356686, -0.03539114445447922, 0.0061239441856741905, -0.0479750894010067, 0.027778208255767822, -0.006089067552238703, -0.031956080347299576, 0.023415887728333473, -0.03544052317738533, -0.015429151244461536, 0.02095618285238743, -0.06182289123535156, 0.06476297974586487, 0.07043161988258362, -0.0034707533195614815, -0.018858104944229126, 0.043251026421785355, 0.011677660048007965, 0.01825295388698578, -0.04324021935462952, -0.0029143912252038717, -0.04224273934960365, 0.02032945491373539, 0.04768456891179085, 0.017389293760061264, -0.04785815253853798, 0.030684953555464745, 0.06018904596567154, -0.0027516542468219995, 0.017063848674297333, 0.020216932520270348, -0.0032234119717031717, -0.024301914498209953, 0.015212396159768105, 0.016323383897542953, 0.023196153342723846, 0.002412345726042986, -0.011679952964186668, 0.03400054946541786, 0.036751072853803635, -0.02660202421247959, 0.0015414919471368194, 0.03453716263175011, 0.021040217950940132, 0.00133536069188267, -0.02598513849079609, -0.02805164083838463, 0.051145851612091064, -0.010791288688778877, 0.0236407071352005, 0.02802826650440693, 0.010190760716795921, -0.015319809317588806, 0.00039001795812509954, -0.025807062163949013, 0.013269133865833282, 0.03091306984424591, -0.051209088414907455, 0.014843217097222805, -0.0032657685223966837, -0.01982770301401615, 0.03184681013226509, -0.03774398937821388, 0.017055869102478027, -0.034477122128009796, 0.01361856795847416, -0.005478244740515947, -0.028542332351207733, 0.044653356075286865, -0.025893857702612877, -0.026075445115566254, -0.018521057441830635, -0.00818749237805605, 0.01824367791414261, 0.0020213222596794367, -0.06129182130098343, -0.02644810453057289, -0.035620369017124176, -0.014123024418950081, 0.04036755859851837, 0.0005818390054628253, -0.016166292130947113, 0.04184481501579285, -0.0034568740520626307, -0.045444510877132416, -0.027526455000042915, -0.004894698038697243, -0.005333299282938242, -0.039293792098760605, -0.0212487131357193, 0.05342623218894005, -0.0026379066985100508, -0.016769496724009514, 0.0020441969390958548, -0.02600232884287834, 0.001161272288300097, -0.020307723432779312, -0.010730824433267117, 0.0019965048413723707, -0.0010559852235019207, 0.010872154496610165, -0.00403240229934454, -0.018585480749607086, 0.005281682591885328, -0.05785120651125908, -0.06201300024986267, 0.0016036295564845204, 0.038898952305316925, 0.009852209128439426, 0.026981720700860023, -0.057469066232442856, 0.027852443978190422, 0.0007342984317801893, -0.06197052821516991, -0.061534542590379715, 0.005215550772845745, -0.004634656012058258, -0.028899066150188446, 0.04628933593630791, -0.00002200752896897029, -0.008788563311100006, 0.03190023824572563, -0.005626404192298651, -0.004966991022229195, 0.049642134457826614, -0.0008567859185859561, 0.012022940441966057, 0.03635545074939728, 0.000042014413338620216, -0.03084973618388176, 0.021432025358080864, -0.012913760729134083, -0.01011032797396183, -0.024358324706554413, -0.015001194551587105, 0.024274596944451332, 0.011433856561779976, -0.03594972938299179, 0.025463225319981575, 0.003918229602277279, 0.0007995518972165883, -0.03193956986069679, 0.025213031098246574, 0.005991433747112751, -0.019173797219991684, -0.01827068254351616, 0.02130168303847313, 0.004519070498645306, -0.04311634972691536, 0.01615254394710064, 0.00839739665389061, 0.04159162566065788, 0.018024766817688942, 0.008959610015153885, -0.031833529472351074, -0.01015238743275404, -0.010367320850491524, -0.022698521614074707, 0.008267740719020367, 0.05847438424825668, 0.02568819560110569, 0.02177266590297222, 0.00023497387883253396, -0.053253497928380966, 0.006971690803766251, -0.08210476487874985, 0.00835214089602232, -0.022205518558621407, 0.03331664204597473, -0.017560560256242752, 0.03004617430269718, 0.014349430799484253, -0.019445175305008888, 0.0026776441372931004, -0.00143461546394974, -0.08334875106811523, 0.0037389465142041445, 0.015521244145929813, -0.005926529876887798, -0.016274604946374893, -0.0042609646916389465, 0.008495631627738476, -0.02249242551624775, 0.008806257508695126, 0.02128675952553749, 0.034841105341911316, -0.016878396272659302, 0.002732435939833522, -0.0064249057322740555, -0.010982082225382328, 0.02593926340341568, 0.01938641257584095, 0.02296336553990841, -0.007490257732570171, 0.03937579318881035, 0.036753054708242416, -0.032364070415496826, 0.02199007011950016, -0.03275490179657936, 0.0285663940012455, 0.004334642551839352, 0.05143743380904198, 0.04978412389755249, 0.026273934170603752, -0.030578698962926865, 0.02053915150463581, -0.011976147070527077, 0.047305118292570114, 0.06016705930233002, -0.027222683653235435, -0.031479693949222565, -0.026898587122559547, -0.033301472663879395, 0.03768051415681839, 0.014984790235757828, -0.0004480623174458742, -0.008350375108420849, 0.06678321957588196, 0.04419106990098953, -0.023088904097676277, 0.017511466518044472, 0.10447860509157181, -0.010753404349088669, -0.04734327644109726, -0.02194548211991787, 0.009434071369469166, -0.008827773854136467, -0.008165563456714153, 0.033209994435310364, 0.018450966104865074, 0.0030711754225194454, -0.013269573450088501, 0.019252672791481018, -0.024787811562418938, -0.004600841552019119, 0.036900900304317474, 0.03669023886322975, 0.035904694348573685, -0.012390010058879852, -0.06280471384525299, 0.009183987975120544, 0.03661239147186279, 0.00017380373901687562, 0.01224921178072691, -0.023993302136659622, -0.10204950720071793, 0.02034624107182026, 0.01959877647459507, 0.03042321279644966, -0.05863476172089577, 0.0005110499914735556, -0.005206748843193054, -0.017436886206269264, 0.0004821439506486058, -0.028336426243185997, -0.00987847987562418, 0.003532995004206896, 0.04425662010908127, 0.007534588221460581, -0.024796055629849434, -0.04050319641828537, 0.05342661961913109, 0.005085856653749943, -0.0023902079556137323, -0.041233453899621964, 0.017252808436751366, -0.019991833716630936, 0.042804162949323654, 0.021702712401747704, 0.05694309622049332, -0.008345382288098335, -0.03977331519126892, 0.017712034285068512, 0.01390512939542532, -0.0065386430360376835, -0.03350916504859924, -0.0164632685482502, -0.024558108299970627, -0.04269668459892273, 0.07350465655326843, -0.017252245917916298, -0.03835079446434975, 0.027442220598459244, 0.025903245434165, 0.0036725816316902637, 0.015530107542872429, -0.022098563611507416, 0.04156842455267906, 0.0164505448192358, -0.0036327089183032513, 0.040929362177848816, -0.024875234812498093, -0.01229160837829113, 0.02084231749176979, -0.001366619486361742, 0.04456191509962082, -0.006402119062840939, -0.020496467128396034, -0.016322406008839607, -0.0005570943467319012, -0.007860626094043255, 0.0462723933160305, 0.018843889236450195, 0.015770386904478073, -0.020303530618548393, -0.017114466056227684, 0.013618056662380695, 0.016228094696998596, -0.0089301448315382, 0.023404786363244057, 0.02256469614803791, 0.02649509906768799, 0.0137063292786479, -0.042532749474048615, 0.008819340728223324, 0.009194490499794483, 0.008168783970177174, 0.029395226389169693, -0.017611749470233917, -0.009564001113176346, -0.03502974659204483, -0.027767620980739594, -0.0010483653750270605, -0.05446002259850502, 0.0012636908795684576, 0.03383580595254898, 0.05487625673413277, 0.015754159539937973, -0.05507548898458481, -0.005601688753813505, 0.0043111625127494335, -0.002351471222937107, 0.029542308300733566, -0.03944219648838043, 0.00977310910820961, -0.014613496139645576, 0.003982168156653643, -0.062194738537073135, -0.053187593817710876, 0.008992481045424938, -0.0005910095060244203, -0.016995813697576523, -0.019862547516822815, 0.016217514872550964, -0.054240331053733826, -0.03121192753314972, -0.01731380634009838, 0.05617969110608101, -0.03809907287359238, 0.009330331347882748, -0.006039331201463938, 0.03774886578321457, 0.07765992730855942, -0.006359981372952461, -0.009251702576875687, 0.020339855924248695, -0.02348439022898674, -0.03610719367861748, 0.007326294668018818, -0.020098377019166946, -0.039678290486335754, 0.01785162463784218, -0.033788684755563736, 0.018975265324115753, 0.03709078207612038, -0.005189427174627781, -0.026533465832471848, 0.017505038529634476, -0.0031847325153648853, 0.0141775943338871, -0.04557502269744873, 0.041359856724739075, -0.014442697167396545, -0.003222595201805234, 0.015018731355667114, 0.038049861788749695, 0.012733870185911655, -0.0032741965260356665, 0.009900047443807125, -0.014880477450788021, -0.03574307635426521, -0.01890561729669571, 0.0629117339849472, 0.02904799021780491, 0.02305222675204277, -0.013005453161895275, -0.003990489989519119, 0.052214615046978, 0.013445932418107986, -0.005132431164383888, 0.019989849999547005, -0.0015379819087684155, -0.049181777983903885, -0.03125827759504318, -0.028140725567936897, -0.00020696863066405058, 0.050193604081869125, -0.048732858151197433, 0.027577582746744156, 0.05223790183663368, 0.026840541511774063, 0.01987319253385067, -0.042493756860494614, -0.003178211161866784, 0.008390765637159348, -0.0035222945734858513, 0.07098594307899475, -0.008368703536689281, -0.03347419574856758, 0.02669679932296276, 0.004148540087044239, 0.018625933676958084, 0.031333908438682556, 0.00858475361019373, 0.05736299976706505, 0.016487613320350647, -0.004073745105415583, -0.02876518853008747, 0.017008936032652855, -0.04557204991579056, -0.009598148986697197, -0.08162552118301392, -0.023826496675610542, 0.04348126798868179, 0.07266201823949814, 0.01586569845676422, -0.0629626139998436, -0.047325704246759415, -0.03359861671924591, 0.011067832820117474, 0.017003517597913742, -0.01929406449198723, 0.04514797404408455, 0.013356667011976242, 0.012431129813194275, 0.022567445412278175, 0.059159908443689346, -0.022004948928952217, -0.086035817861557, -0.053039900958538055, 0.0014357095351442695, -0.0259720366448164, -0.0003434362297412008, -0.01710369996726513, -0.06496787071228027, 0.06566926836967468, -0.04083429276943207, 0.006514101754873991, -0.019361499696969986, 0.021227536723017693, 0.022171778604388237, 0.07676487416028976, -0.008433288894593716, 0.012935289181768894, -0.009540440514683723, -0.005293234251439571, 0.10398503392934799, 0.07793235778808594, 0.03626299649477005, -0.03711356967687607, 0.022405410185456276, 0.0178995318710804, 0.010241657495498657, -0.020679684355854988, 0.0060276733711361885, 0.0012359375832602382, -0.024240046739578247, 0.04302234202623367, 0.03798408806324005, -0.00975333247333765, 0.003170291194692254, 0.011701385490596294, -0.009875132702291012, 0.005025655496865511, -0.0009417685796506703, 0.018941452726721764, 0.01095682755112648, -0.030463051050901413, -0.05412479490041733, -0.01709298975765705, -0.014331988990306854, -0.002143420511856675, -0.0008614708785898983, 0.03539768606424332, -0.017145119607448578, 0.009281951934099197, -0.018253464251756668, 0.013466298580169678, 0.037289101630449295, 0.039310622960329056, -0.013753530569374561, 0.012577306479215622, 0.033625878393650055, -0.03355211392045021, -0.007527701556682587, 0.010255920700728893, -0.01046175230294466, 0.0036611491814255714, 0.01440507359802723, -0.004467172548174858, -0.05250027775764465, -0.01920589990913868, -0.0344461090862751, 0.06463436037302017, -0.0009473278187215328, -0.016615577042102814, -0.02472294121980667, -0.003251498332247138, 0.01721959374845028, -0.048781950026750565, -0.02418658882379532, 0.0318378284573555, 0.024359416216611862, -0.029585612937808037, -0.02004334144294262, -0.01701022870838642, 0.010197705589234829, 0.006725838407874107, 0.018809489905834198, -0.005378559697419405, -0.026279686018824577, -0.032825686037540436, -0.0157909132540226, 0.04194297268986702, 0.013978936709463596, -0.018361127004027367, 0.020043274387717247, -0.010816405527293682, -0.00915916170924902, -0.019350022077560425, 0.005080982111394405, 0.004194139968603849, 0.03143089637160301, -0.017849067226052284, -0.008408570662140846, -0.033981941640377045, -0.02673635259270668, 0.0061474996618926525, -0.04256751388311386, 0.010700338520109653, -0.07196162641048431, 0.015108386985957623, 0.033350132405757904, 0.02312072180211544, 0.003236281219869852, 0.022146277129650116, -0.013620657846331596, 0.061658699065446854, -0.007491599768400192, -0.040992408990859985, -0.01885618083178997, 0.00669514387845993, -0.025522751733660698, 0.00164514291100204, -0.008687013760209084, 0.06315638870000839, -0.016611944884061813, 0.03252094238996506, -0.028890252113342285, 0.05410132184624672, 0.003921884577721357, 0.049122098833322525, 0.02444489300251007, -0.05833733081817627, 0.016251783818006516, -0.026466311886906624, -0.002589512849226594, 0.019264018163084984, 0.0069617475382983685, -0.03995779529213905, -0.0087616927921772, 0.003809921443462372, -0.020481035113334656, -0.035371191799640656, 0.041027482599020004, -0.01208279188722372, 0.013472299091517925, -0.004180692136287689, -0.00031130851130001247, -0.013579529710114002, -0.002623707987368107, 0.0030993404798209667, -0.0389004647731781, 0.012123704887926579, 0.036280591040849686, -0.00975164957344532, -0.007149821612983942, 0.040883373469114304, 0.01919088512659073, 0.041779134422540665, -0.04646148905158043, -0.004947594832628965, 0.025252409279346466, 0.05543854832649231, -0.01599087566137314, -0.03525799140334129, 0.0022054018918424845, -0.01713779754936695, -0.02295805886387825, 0.006416338961571455, 0.00645361328497529, 0.03438868746161461, 0.046906471252441406, -0.0029739392921328545, -0.05161277577280998, 0.0630129724740982, -0.04122278094291687, -0.01493003312498331, -0.012581504881381989, -0.007771842181682587, 0.021124808117747307, -0.011374298483133316, -0.000945072271861136, 0.023109234869480133, -0.027283595874905586, 0.03388766199350357, 0.05983656644821167, -0.013234945945441723, 0.002574869431555271, 0.03047339990735054, -0.0012483312748372555, 0.02159230224788189, 0.030558248981833458, -0.0036391885951161385, 0.00683447252959013, 0.030594220384955406, -0.013460488989949226, 0.027951642870903015, 0.006384673062711954, 0.03333859145641327, -0.07235964387655258, -0.02619791589677334, -0.025165153667330742, 0.03052699565887451, 0.016847889870405197, -0.054125312715768814, -0.011733828112483025, 0.016049064695835114, -0.036221884191036224, -0.004065771587193012, 0.00392224732786417, -0.009544875472784042, -0.00835341401398182, -0.0192430280148983, -0.009954076260328293, 0.009655465371906757, 0.03677595034241676, -0.0013845391804352403, 0.05694946274161339, 0.028606407344341278, 0.02487208880484104, -0.03516727313399315, -0.019303862005472183, -0.0034917849116027355, 0.02522035874426365, -0.03838549926877022, 0.05086478218436241, -0.0394289493560791, -0.0803341418504715, 0.0074068293906748295, -0.00661438750103116, 0.04549482464790344, -0.0043233768083155155, 0.02087789587676525, 0.03417627885937691, 0.028042633086442947, 0.012181729078292847, 0.01065070740878582, 0.014596130698919296, 0.01821054331958294, 0.02422069013118744, -0.02088996022939682, -0.0432082824409008, 0.037463635206222534, 0.027594391256570816, -0.014978968538343906, -0.03697386384010315, 0.014515598304569721, 0.0018153154524043202, -0.026742268353700638, -0.06154898181557655, 0.02646910771727562, 0.02068859152495861, -0.009390093386173248, -0.004026259761303663, -0.07132729142904282, -0.007546501699835062, 0.030139463022351265, 0.027755646035075188, -0.008797951973974705, -0.024296393617987633, -0.014321431517601013, -0.01892228238284588, 0.01934817060828209, -0.0061628795228898525, -0.007633333094418049, -0.07960280030965805, -0.006205774378031492, 0.02218683622777462, -0.02115039899945259, -0.021600110456347466, -0.011323722079396248, -0.01964659057557583, 0.04189250245690346, -0.02754683792591095, 0.025158006697893143, -0.00969033595174551, -0.004133902490139008, 0.025494810193777084, -0.061163708567619324, 0.06018172204494476, -0.011386452242732048, -0.04361862316727638, -0.0055658710189163685, -0.004589864052832127, -0.01936604455113411, 0.017944030463695526, 0.048994340002536774, 0.0070852553471922874, 0.006048186682164669, 0.01806688867509365, 0.013967381790280342, 0.01614772528409958, -0.05598026141524315, 0.039326682686805725, -0.0029809786938130856, -0.023067070171236992, -0.041611313819885254, 0.0019118200289085507, 0.015725839883089066, -0.005842443089932203, 0.02257697470486164, -0.02471097931265831, -0.009193339385092258, 0.0012130627874284983, 0.011665800586342812, 0.021474990993738174, -0.029283897951245308, -0.024796390905976295, 0.050338029861450195, -0.0033747232519090176, 0.026257233694195747, 0.04576613008975983, 0.011094078421592712, -0.04605713114142418, 0.02987782470881939, -0.015025564469397068, -0.043975017964839935, -0.007723520509898663, 0.016850121319293976, -0.011540544219315052, -0.04234929755330086, 0.008919806219637394, 0.01683913543820381, -0.07966724038124084, -0.003383007599040866, 0.04641810804605484, 0.000842701003421098, 0.012606012634932995, -0.013165191747248173, 0.018453681841492653, 0.028082696720957756, -0.01853671856224537, 0.009297657757997513, 0.0362861230969429, 0.054824359714984894, 0.01959114335477352, -0.012874025851488113, -0.006371807307004929, -0.046116121113300323, 0.04888724908232689, -0.03828109800815582, 0.04015131667256355, -0.020667532458901405, -0.002082690130919218, 0.02710467018187046, -0.009457685984671116, 0.023532811552286148, -0.011903221718966961, -0.012843671254813671, 0.044973503798246384, -0.041378870606422424, -0.01090238243341446, -0.02186651900410652, 0.006489632651209831, 0.00023112844792194664, -0.00019334520038682967, -0.00783713348209858, 0.04802529141306877, 0.006394634023308754, -0.012277684174478054, 0.001326465280726552, -0.05681786313652992, 0.02750525064766407, -0.0483909547328949, -0.010058192536234856, -0.0393681675195694, -0.016679687425494194, 0.0052990904077887535, -0.031874556094408035, -0.029601259157061577, -0.0623934268951416, 0.005320007912814617, 0.01611507125198841, -0.0017228851793333888, -0.05566834285855293, -0.05359466373920441, 0.008236473426222801, 0.04693169146776199, -0.01872711069881916, 0.0041882009245455265, -0.025731369853019714, 0.02334050089120865, 0.0244583897292614, 0.004625990986824036 ]
<p>I need some guidance on the appropriate level of pooling to use for difference of means tests on time series data. I am concerned about temporal and sacrificial pseudo-replication, which seem to be in tension on this application. This is in reference to a mensural study rather than a manipulative experiment.</p> <p><strong>Consider a monitoring exercise</strong>: A system of sensors measures dissolved oxygen (DO) content at many locations across the width and depth of a pond. Measurements for each sensor are recorded twice daily, as DO is known to vary diurnally. The two values are averaged to record a daily value. Once a week, the daily results are aggregated spatially to arrive at a single weekly DO concentration for the whole pond.</p> <p>Those weekly results are reported periodically, and further aggregated – weekly results are averaged to give a monthly DO concentration for the pond. The monthly results are averaged to give an annual value. The annual averages are themselves averaged to report decadal DO concentrations for the pond.</p> <p>The goal is to answer questions such as: Was the pond's DO concentration in year X higher, lower, or the same as the concentration in year Y? Is the average DO concentration of the last ten years different than that of the prior decade? The DO concentrations in a pond respond to many inputs of large magnitude, and thus vary considerably. A significance test is needed. The method is to use a T-test comparison of means. Given that the decadal values are the mean of the annual values, and the annual values are the mean of the monthly values, this seems appropriate.</p> <p><strong>Here’s the question</strong> – you can calculate the decadal means and the T-values of those means from the monthly DO values, or from the annual DO values. The mean doesn’t change of course, but the width of the confidence interval and the T-value does. Due to the order of magnitude higher N attained by using monthly values, the CI often tightens up considerably if you go that route. This can give the opposite conclusion vs using the annual values with respect to the statistical significance of an observed difference in the means, using the same test on the same data. <strong>What is the proper interpretation of this discrepancy?</strong></p> <p>If you use the monthly results to compute the test stats for a difference in decadal means, are you running afoul of temporal pseudoreplication? If you use the annual results to calc the decadal tests, are you sacrificing information and thus pseudoreplicating?</p>
37,281
[ 0.0050270576030015945, -0.004765049088746309, 0.012257241643965244, -0.014671381562948227, 0.04374905675649643, 0.00881777610629797, -0.006470860447734594, -0.02737732231616974, 0.01672947034239769, -0.017431216314435005, 0.04624899849295616, 0.010229351930320263, 0.0337090827524662, 0.003844210645183921, 0.0029729222878813744, 0.012807761318981647, -0.018428785726428032, -0.014931712299585342, 0.01046446617692709, -0.061889175325632095, 0.016459623351693153, 0.03489730507135391, -0.014635243453085423, -0.0003594743611756712, -0.03923867642879486, 0.024856554344296455, -0.010104835033416748, -0.030368506908416748, -0.042627859860658646, 0.06341857463121414, -0.037564314901828766, -0.04602426663041115, -0.015206469222903252, 0.04209115728735924, -0.010380635038018227, -0.013508502393960953, 0.01864618994295597, -0.04041038453578949, 0.02356240712106228, 0.0414763018488884, -0.019112680107355118, -0.02828696370124817, -0.010755292139947414, 0.041596848517656326, 0.012699373066425323, 0.025543486699461937, 0.020441250875592232, 0.01696159690618515, 0.0417088158428669, -0.024940554052591324, 0.04070974513888359, 0.0006657376070506871, 0.03895581141114235, 0.029696106910705566, -0.030537281185388565, -0.02043914794921875, 0.05042340233922005, 0.0050874138250947, 0.003256489522755146, -0.036469392478466034, 0.0038825692608952522, -0.03588376194238663, 0.02311227284371853, 0.0017934530042111874, -0.009515918791294098, -0.016186421737074852, 0.05375981330871582, -0.003997646737843752, 0.008968411013484001, -0.03608149662613869, 0.009080321528017521, -0.020399125292897224, 0.01104311179369688, 0.018539095297455788, -0.006167425308376551, -0.040314849466085434, 0.02064335159957409, 0.036308467388153076, 0.03140954300761223, 0.027743512764573097, -0.004617125261574984, 0.04492152854800224, -0.0007791027892380953, -0.023889072239398956, 0.019898056983947754, -0.02719121426343918, 0.03634399175643921, -0.030096115544438362, 0.004340352024883032, 0.018828924745321274, 0.005058357026427984, -0.027964765205979347, 0.0692160502076149, 0.000024665230739628896, -0.026744360104203224, 0.022338351234793663, -0.018834132701158524, -0.0002845481794793159, -0.04457969591021538, 0.03086133673787117, -0.005167759023606777, -0.051824647933244705, 0.022360457107424736, 0.0420716255903244, 0.003568907966837287, 0.0013452660059556365, -0.022566458210349083, -0.005190854426473379, -0.016670169308781624, -0.02243935689330101, -0.04645078256726265, 0.023479577153921127, -0.011566380970180035, 0.007730196695774794, 0.05575431510806084, 0.014295495115220547, 0.002612021518871188, -0.015532237477600574, 0.04239806905388832, 0.03501110523939133, 0.06828103959560394, -0.03726767748594284, -0.027905426919460297, -0.028030484914779663, -0.04781189188361168, 0.06860096007585526, -0.0017594584496691823, 0.01733590103685856, -0.014615650288760662, 0.06663907319307327, 0.011704395525157452, -0.02195161208510399, 0.040772631764411926, -0.005299959797412157, 0.00895784143358469, 0.03892364725470543, -0.09630820155143738, -0.08715753257274628, 0.050853509455919266, -0.02720453590154648, 0.00224089901894331, -0.07085464894771576, -0.0015013680094853044, 0.0006617183680646122, 0.03165573626756668, 0.031141536310315132, 0.0411064438521862, 0.01298073772341013, 0.033078886568546295, 0.00779673783108592, 0.006948378868401051, -0.007134309038519859, 0.030686719343066216, -0.022254692390561104, -0.02081414870917797, -0.050981566309928894, 0.014976938255131245, 0.0033313471358269453, 0.015495502389967442, 0.02893218956887722, 0.06546495854854584, 0.0247684046626091, -0.03137702867388725, 0.02322501130402088, 0.028455836698412895, -0.03903765603899956, 0.06043218448758125, -0.02275862544775009, 0.0428461879491806, 0.026472268626093864, -0.008966946974396706, 0.05505678802728653, 0.018717903643846512, 0.05654807388782501, 0.03972860053181648, -0.01931045949459076, 0.02775518223643303, -0.06219087913632393, 0.004571361932903528, 0.017564909532666206, -0.0341680534183979, -0.00782264955341816, -0.0723605826497078, -0.03287378326058388, 0.018510326743125916, 0.05234897509217262, -0.005963468924164772, -0.01690129190683365, -0.005739149171859026, -0.07061608135700226, -0.03795073553919792, -0.04501759633421898, 0.0003419927379582077, -0.028439126908779144, -0.012033747509121895, -0.009404315613210201, -0.04003885015845299, 0.049291472882032394, 0.002307320712134242, -0.020696284249424934, 0.006634329911321402, 0.0020400506909936666, 0.04526667669415474, -0.05956711247563362, 0.04830827936530113, 0.018987348303198814, 0.042292144149541855, -0.01846637763082981, 0.002896092366427183, -0.04558725282549858, 0.0025628383737057447, -0.010299114510416985, -0.04676705226302147, 0.031241612508893013, 0.00938541628420353, -0.046671681106090546, 0.011311870999634266, -0.022472810000181198, -0.04239170253276825, 0.0276388768106699, -0.05495932698249817, 0.07479862868785858, 0.03961252048611641, 0.0057962932623922825, 0.002163948956876993, 0.044163480401039124, 0.0198257714509964, -0.0013072401052340865, -0.015500437468290329, -0.0219879150390625, -0.05622129887342453, 0.01192521769553423, 0.029572609812021255, 0.03366852179169655, 0.01572219282388687, 0.0599052831530571, 0.03444213792681694, 0.010890623554587364, 0.0010811296524479985, 0.018821829929947853, 0.009261398576200008, 0.0018066474003717303, 0.013173487037420273, 0.037314992398023605, 0.012813511304557323, 0.02795897051692009, 0.03721008822321892, -0.012459649704396725, 0.035417020320892334, 0.015562489628791809, 0.0030555762350559235, 0.020044438540935516, 0.009198425337672234, 0.03824580833315849, -0.023077618330717087, -0.02441011369228363, 0.027256259694695473, -0.035444848239421844, -0.023534324020147324, 0.0353085957467556, 0.004986894316971302, 0.011288590729236603, -0.01789357140660286, -0.035677485167980194, 0.02196114882826805, 0.016577906906604767, -0.06732974946498871, -0.027348892763257027, 0.004335555247962475, -0.020079564303159714, 0.026872508227825165, -0.057820092886686325, -0.06341154873371124, -0.023809421807527542, -0.03601162135601044, -0.005766134709119797, 0.004311862867325544, 0.01722257398068905, -0.009714390151202679, 0.05249528959393501, -0.016523482277989388, 0.013558626174926758, 0.016007987782359123, 0.0009330434259027243, -0.030851993709802628, 0.000038693509850418195, 0.021364644169807434, -0.021726440638303757, 0.04331203177571297, -0.026321105659008026, -0.022883212193846703, 0.04113910719752312, 0.016662446781992912, -0.05617446452379227, -0.03337445482611656, -0.03150459751486778, -0.0318184457719326, -0.02413705363869667, -0.02589751034975052, 0.02692227251827717, -0.032754991203546524, -0.05432005226612091, 0.038597237318754196, -0.023165250197052956, -0.03363434597849846, -0.03557216003537178, -0.020760836079716682, -0.009488631039857864, -0.04538258537650108, -0.0020058751106262207, 0.0010311902733519673, -0.06459501385688782, -0.009984158910810947, -0.0337212011218071, -0.05144546553492546, 0.053671032190322876, -0.028859229758381844, 0.060320399701595306, 0.0045194970443844795, -0.007222307845950127, 0.060091543942689896, 0.012911004014313221, -0.027313880622386932, -0.03860222548246384, 0.02678987942636013, -0.021492434665560722, -0.042150694876909256, 0.01601695455610752, 0.02178826928138733, 0.014678575098514557, 0.017314758151769638, 0.0038262982852756977, 0.024643581360578537, 0.0034816842526197433, -0.023125628009438515, -0.007900231517851353, 0.012678827159106731, 0.023801472038030624, -0.029385454952716827, 0.018229994922876358, 0.03552170842885971, -0.015366852283477783, -0.0063081770204007626, -0.029036998748779297, -0.0006662165396846831, 0.040506988763809204, -0.035345982760190964, 0.019072335213422775, -0.03765391185879707, -0.0018457487458363175, -0.005892041139304638, 0.027156248688697815, 0.0150330550968647, -0.019877588376402855, -0.02478662133216858, 0.014474507421255112, 0.02392960898578167, -0.021601255983114243, -0.019830306991934776, 0.06084287166595459, 0.057125985622406006, -0.002763005206361413, -0.00405604112893343, 0.014880280010402203, 0.007511074189096689, 0.027930788695812225, -0.04611654952168465, -0.03111627697944641, 0.036359768360853195, 0.044618431478738785, -0.01598186604678631, -0.015342365950345993, -0.006973032373934984, -0.01564817875623703, -0.06206909194588661, -0.012141207233071327, 0.008349588140845299, 0.043112870305776596, -0.008361606858670712, 0.01188627164810896, 0.027259113267064095, -0.005621158052235842, -0.03088032454252243, 0.0037094580475240946, 0.009390748105943203, 0.0007327445782721043, -0.019185133278369904, 0.017029793933033943, -0.011147656477987766, -0.047649085521698, 0.008197464048862457, -0.024111531674861908, 0.030857713893055916, -0.028936514630913734, 0.05563804507255554, -0.028342870995402336, 0.02635127119719982, 0.001769751193933189, -0.0325433574616909, -0.035634011030197144, -0.0023063858970999718, 0.02192257158458233, 0.006989661604166031, 0.06659635156393051, -0.0002467384038027376, 0.000251331424806267, -0.026336606591939926, -0.012496397830545902, 0.00814052578061819, 0.00092188676353544, 0.021059101447463036, 0.02117021381855011, 0.03847184777259827, -0.06712678074836731, -0.011283190920948982, 0.005233221687376499, 0.030399244278669357, 0.02517741546034813, -0.00966707244515419, -0.044372111558914185, -0.040210992097854614, -0.00632568821310997, 0.057749293744564056, 0.015227990224957466, 0.0320652574300766, 0.00030625471845269203, 0.023402828723192215, -0.03979800269007683, -0.04436228424310684, 0.03041355311870575, 0.0020100099500268698, -0.004231310449540615, -0.027598632499575615, -0.03693973645567894, -0.06706029921770096, -0.023181715980172157, -0.0245228074491024, 0.06064984202384949, 0.040030431002378464, 0.041090305894613266, 0.011083255521953106, 0.0436527244746685, -0.009146194905042648, -0.04612870141863823, -0.004028128460049629, 0.02145889215171337, 0.04264621064066887, -0.011097236536443233, -0.005663389340043068, 0.03561205789446831, 0.018419405445456505, 0.04279318451881409, 0.044540271162986755, 0.035766489803791046, -0.07077287137508392, -0.05183858796954155, 0.06124650314450264, 0.062297143042087555, -0.017662672325968742, 0.015744391828775406, -0.05917806178331375, -0.020784730091691017, 0.04196200519800186, -0.030826834961771965, 0.0014018883230164647, -0.009323850274085999, 0.018551211804151535, -0.03712301701307297, -0.03456192463636398, -0.025515275076031685, 0.018595675006508827, -0.00219250051304698, 0.03389955312013626, -0.02977968379855156, -0.05244079977273941, -0.02304447628557682, 0.01974215731024742, 0.02918124943971634, 0.008742486126720905, -0.02123384177684784, -0.008600305765867233, -0.008331621065735817, -0.010752113536000252, -0.017340295016765594, -0.057791486382484436, 0.026351533830165863, 0.0007729479693807662, 0.048668503761291504, 0.01795221120119095, 0.014052847400307655, -0.01885339990258217, 0.016730358824133873, 0.02302302047610283, -0.03414628654718399, -0.010574670508503914, -0.005018263589590788, 0.05458785966038704, 0.053039390593767166, 0.008006755262613297, 0.06070734187960625, 0.03802097961306572, -0.03207862004637718, 0.025287369266152382, -0.0606050044298172, 0.007939860224723816, -0.02683987282216549, -0.00939050130546093, -0.04026728495955467, -0.025514252483844757, 0.011672722175717354, -0.0036745842080563307, -0.004942643456161022, 0.010618872009217739, 0.014692718163132668, -0.012742248363792896, 0.0478704534471035, -0.01074590440839529, -0.00038652491639368236, 0.024248605594038963, 0.00043893096153624356, 0.021690940484404564, 0.006799568422138691, -0.0032042269594967365, -0.01277274638414383, -0.015923289582133293, 0.001613025669939816, -0.007123937364667654, -0.05101602151989937, 0.020915169268846512, -0.017189010977745056, 0.00016780725854914635, -0.020945820957422256, -0.02243608422577381, 0.029811464250087738, -0.02592911757528782, -0.012349612079560757, -0.004256872925907373, -0.0016037252498790622, -0.012730748392641544, 0.0190194770693779, -0.006486246827989817, 0.021365316584706306, -0.041295573115348816, 0.008908688090741634, 0.0227370522916317, 0.016243169084191322, -0.04247128963470459, -0.01890895701944828, 0.0437692292034626, 0.014686929993331432, -0.00019248132593929768, -0.034159258008003235, -0.01735619828104973, -0.012060214765369892, -0.003980238456279039, -0.04694218561053276, 0.05467388778924942, -0.023587437346577644, -0.03301708400249481, -0.02905304543673992, 0.031098587438464165, 0.08716952055692673, -0.06412611156702042, 0.0442395955324173, -0.0007407395169138908, -0.009269071742892265, -0.055607374757528305, -0.024989519268274307, -0.022246386855840683, -0.051260821521282196, 0.03230242058634758, -0.006163748446851969, -0.006690708454698324, 0.057275544852018356, -0.04733862355351448, -0.06360046565532684, 0.03384434059262276, -0.011202344670891762, 0.013227654621005058, -0.03063366748392582, 0.05336173251271248, -0.043032560497522354, 0.019486945122480392, -0.0010506013641133904, 0.016597149893641472, 0.006166538689285517, -0.0257197767496109, -0.02783234789967537, -0.021690625697374344, -0.03177390992641449, 0.02884812466800213, 0.023793574422597885, 0.012292781844735146, 0.013180223293602467, -0.023309921845793724, -0.015409356914460659, 0.04062197729945183, 0.008873133920133114, -0.006580283399671316, 0.015691423788666725, -0.014078838750720024, -0.03808482736349106, -0.034075021743774414, -0.007560273166745901, 0.0015914891846477985, 0.07322519272565842, 0.0350959375500679, 0.02441500872373581, 0.04267876222729683, 0.024431707337498665, 0.03895600512623787, -0.033556289970874786, 0.014190822839736938, 0.026914989575743675, 0.003066003555431962, 0.0598968043923378, -0.043027907609939575, -0.026791486889123917, 0.04427550360560417, 0.002751057967543602, 0.010486734099686146, 0.06575743854045868, 0.03139296919107437, 0.007494661025702953, 0.02529829554259777, -0.04359559714794159, -0.06692615151405334, 0.009189180098474026, -0.060444071888923645, 0.0031629197765141726, -0.015599207952618599, 0.032156869769096375, 0.02447556145489216, 0.02017272636294365, -0.026725558564066887, -0.058921776711940765, -0.0374501571059227, -0.10173012316226959, 0.002469174563884735, 0.028773419559001923, -0.0052594575099647045, -0.01510174386203289, 0.026469137519598007, 0.07971733808517456, 0.01137258019298315, -0.00788864865899086, -0.040356606245040894, -0.026856036856770515, -0.007467520423233509, -0.02858874574303627, -0.04549285024404526, 0.04248231649398804, -0.025290371850132942, -0.04230266436934471, -0.007112031802535057, -0.029027633368968964, 0.01240958459675312, -0.0005763398949056864, 0.010117770172655582, -0.005326334852725267, 0.05460207164287567, -0.00199623079970479, 0.02672904171049595, -0.0011968851322308183, -0.05090094730257988, 0.12540750205516815, 0.052067965269088745, 0.020721163600683212, -0.0492248497903347, 0.010497428476810455, 0.04316377267241478, 0.005964743439108133, 0.01744488812983036, -0.028242144733667374, 0.03917195275425911, -0.026526261121034622, 0.04224421828985214, 0.020327452570199966, -0.0068456134758889675, -0.032911136746406555, 0.06499353051185608, 0.00041383758070878685, -0.008936312049627304, 0.0407949760556221, 0.015557635575532913, 0.011214549653232098, -0.024909790605306625, -0.014305716380476952, 0.02597815729677677, 0.036386314779520035, 0.005974943283945322, -0.005187760107219219, -0.02535100094974041, 0.008982817642390728, 0.03927698731422424, -0.046931445598602295, 0.013622884638607502, 0.024026060476899147, -0.0007856909651309252, -0.039290864020586014, -0.023769093677401543, 0.011107389815151691, -0.030885301530361176, 0.006214674096554518, 0.031945958733558655, 0.0022076519671827555, 0.010435610078275204, 0.004506681114435196, 0.014764546416699886, -0.027319295331835747, -0.011753400787711143, -0.05001601204276085, 0.029040807858109474, -0.009200112894177437, -0.01951095275580883, 0.00089549261610955, -0.018272072076797485, -0.01354953832924366, -0.007195986807346344, -0.01902136206626892, 0.03282933309674263, 0.04130852594971657, -0.016319047659635544, -0.002593214390799403, -0.00955379381775856, 0.0130647337064147, -0.03267998248338699, 0.022359415888786316, 0.07299859821796417, -0.0030117069836705923, -0.05078510940074921, -0.029255317524075508, 0.0860411673784256, 0.012902683578431606, 0.006524043623358011, -0.005855870433151722, 0.019002413377165794, -0.004162847530096769, 0.007276875898241997, -0.0015781163237988949, -0.014827667735517025, 0.022652089595794678, 0.005271204747259617, -0.00463768420740962, 0.014724908396601677, -0.05212899670004845, 0.006534924264997244, -0.009380032308399677, -0.011288781650364399, -0.04955774545669556, 0.02919696271419525, 0.010550775565207005, 0.02381744608283043, 0.029573343694210052, 0.035201944410800934, 0.020388972014188766, 0.04324799031019211, 0.034508563578128815, -0.022507552057504654, -0.03300409018993378, -0.041751474142074585, -0.02565871737897396, -0.025601649656891823, -0.015115531161427498, 0.04144268110394478, 0.0360073484480381, -0.0014156302204355597, 0.034159641712903976, 0.02477272041141987, 0.014951396733522415, 0.012643893249332905, 0.0014472386101260781, -0.02415301278233528, -0.007366043981164694, -0.013068804517388344, 0.013326596468687057, -0.020507153123617172, 0.006816925015300512, -0.04265526309609413, -0.023022493347525597, 0.03204233571887016, -0.0032297333236783743, -0.026241878047585487, -0.0004385650099720806, -0.01622731238603592, 0.011280180886387825, 0.011566542088985443, -0.009845948778092861, -0.07684298604726791, -0.02448292449116707, 0.00400666194036603, 0.011406343430280685, -0.003959025256335735, 0.021279016509652138, -0.027299266308546066, -0.024221472442150116, 0.057744357734918594, -0.008928489871323109, -0.0007474134326912463, -0.02043161913752556, 0.010715261101722717, -0.004524520132690668, 0.021837309002876282, -0.007999392226338387, -0.05212549492716789, 0.0499098002910614, -0.011897075921297073, 0.011640165001153946, 0.016767073422670364, -0.003176207421347499, -0.0053231134079396725, 0.005075540393590927, -0.01991548389196396, -0.029158085584640503, 0.017064325511455536, -0.0453806035220623, 0.017484011128544807, -0.04034214839339256, -0.0005100089474581182, 0.052299682050943375, -0.007101838476955891, 0.015026774257421494, 0.03121201880276203, -0.0087633291259408, -0.02156161516904831, 0.006680568214505911, 0.021129591390490532, 0.02833542600274086, -0.003688101191073656, -0.033785682171583176, -0.015112952329218388, -0.007482412736862898, -0.01577315479516983, 0.009210003539919853, 0.10535561293363571, -0.047439783811569214, 0.011520862579345703, -0.02145656943321228, -0.02531782165169716, -0.07837238907814026, -0.005569602362811565, 0.020519442856311798, 0.051909059286117554, 0.009335474111139774, -0.024161923676729202, 0.01666436716914177, 0.024098185822367668, -0.04945462569594383, 0.01385610830038786, -0.059486307203769684, -0.009372885338962078, -0.021728532388806343, 0.009916670620441437, -0.016203289851546288, -0.004738565534353256, 0.007284740451723337, 0.01571623794734478, -0.018651729449629784, 0.022314997389912605, 0.009494179859757423, -0.054827626794576645, -0.024858856573700905, -0.006335732061415911, 0.022666677832603455, -0.05049724131822586, 0.02425611950457096, -0.019819505512714386, -0.02818741276860237, 0.030438359826803207, -0.03707094117999077, 0.03148315101861954, -0.02277188003063202, 0.027299106121063232, 0.009228616952896118, 0.07202047109603882, 0.024877652525901794, 0.01936022937297821, -0.032891206443309784, -0.01873110793530941, 0.010543876327574253, -0.00790527556091547, -0.01709108240902424, 0.021609151735901833, 0.040063612163066864, 0.008740170858800411, 0.00006533979467349127, 0.030112653970718384, 0.00644161319360137, -0.01503658201545477, 0.022631017491221428, -0.031242476776242256, 0.004935262259095907, 0.034923844039440155, 0.0005179911968298256, -0.01986246183514595, 0.02220257557928562, 0.019905999302864075, 0.042147912085056305, -0.04834924638271332, 0.011588478460907936, -0.008762766607105732, -0.03786908835172653, -0.01364497747272253, -0.009877992793917656, 0.022536471486091614, -0.0436885729432106, 0.0012313458137214184, -0.03758282959461212, 0.019823890179395676, 0.003134846920147538, 0.003185349516570568, -0.051224686205387115, 0.044125959277153015, 0.017252031713724136, -0.011521649546921253, -0.007109679747372866, -0.009064356796443462, 0.03380359336733818, -0.0751391127705574, 0.06479355692863464, 0.04756791889667511, 0.0059169200249016285, -0.00850629061460495, -0.01148399617522955, -0.026936301961541176, 0.02677023783326149, 0.046930793672800064, 0.04354137182235718, -0.0022245936561375856, 0.018413983285427094, 0.036569952964782715, -0.009792914614081383, -0.06066384166479111, 0.05288729444146156, -0.02523980289697647, -0.027144882827997208, 0.020276237279176712, 0.004744458943605423, 0.012006865814328194, -0.027558544650673866, 0.018457792699337006, 0.0024645368102937937, 0.04447949305176735, 0.03609262779355049, 0.03922107815742493, 0.05561603233218193, -0.0010739901335909963, -0.011671825312077999, 0.04682450741529465, 0.030219100415706635, 0.030855592340230942, 0.006937779486179352, -0.00841029454022646, -0.06243384629487991, 0.01226813904941082, -0.023411553353071213, -0.01665312610566616, 0.027381151914596558, 0.0437067486345768, -0.007602112367749214, -0.0747549906373024, 0.005852791480720043, 0.011489516124129295, -0.03369943052530289, 0.011085228063166142, 0.06476393342018127, -0.0016557694179937243, 0.01633966527879238, 0.033156927675008774, 0.022981347516179085, 0.0014211868401616812, -0.00030069149215705693, -0.01205894909799099, 0.010448293760418892, 0.047185931354761124, -0.00669873645529151, 0.003745022928342223, 0.030246084555983543, -0.013491482473909855, 0.04683630168437958, -0.002414209069684148, 0.012957746163010597, 0.007369999308139086, -0.03413260728120804, 0.023549452424049377, 0.01326434500515461, -0.019068708643317223, 0.047296300530433655, 0.005153833422809839, 0.07778846472501755, -0.03552105650305748, -0.01241121906787157, 0.0012912952806800604, -0.04417744278907776, -0.0059568979777395725, 0.02345074713230133, 0.030191581696271896, 0.026891648769378662, -0.010581029579043388, 0.007780879270285368, -0.005984978750348091, 0.0176182109862566, -0.01014686468988657, -0.02224750444293022, 0.03062465228140354, -0.0014291944680735469, -0.0003549558750819415, 0.023743152618408203, 0.021132444962859154, -0.0796082615852356, -0.03810705989599228, 0.039879508316516876, -0.02315228246152401, 0.026944177225232124, 0.013771461322903633, -0.07584234327077866, -0.004303277004510164, 0.0307653546333313, -0.06865657866001129, -0.051475804299116135, -0.028155608102679253, 0.013951691798865795, 0.01709754392504692, -0.04950261488556862 ]
<p>I am fitting a few time series using <code>fitdistr</code> in R. To see how different distributions fit the data, I compare the log likelihood from the <code>fitdistr</code> function. Also, I am fitting both the original data, and the standardized data (ie. (x-mean)/sd).</p> <p>What I am confused about is that, the original and standardized data generate log likelihood of different signs.</p> <p>For example,</p> <p>original:</p> <pre><code> loglik m s df t 1890.340 0.007371982 0.05494671 2.697321186 cauchy 1758.588 0.006721215 0.04089592 0.006721215 logistic 1787.952 0.007758433 0.04641496 0.007758433 </code></pre> <p>standardized:</p> <pre><code> loglik m s df t -2108.163 -0.02705098 0.5469259 2.69758567 cauchy -2239.915 -0.03361670 0.4069660 -0.03361670 logistic -2210.552 -0.02328445 0.4619152 -0.02328445 </code></pre> <p>How can I interprete this? Is larger loglik better or smaller better?</p> <p>Thank you!</p>
5,353
[ -0.03277067840099335, 0.00801137275993824, -0.002364685293287039, 0.01298852264881134, 0.005269120447337627, 0.015080773271620274, 0.004970849491655827, -0.0388479083776474, 0.01387978345155716, -0.05202821269631386, 0.021561522036790848, 0.029553862288594246, 0.036328524351119995, 0.0341825969517231, 0.04852880537509918, 0.009818948805332184, -0.03287645801901817, 0.01049201563000679, -0.0035404374357312918, -0.018563583493232727, -0.005081044975668192, 0.018365854397416115, 0.015993226319551468, -0.018310142681002617, -0.03137430548667908, 0.05583249777555466, 0.01766439713537693, -0.009988273493945599, 0.048776187002658844, 0.044973332434892654, -0.04300545156002045, 0.0033615666907280684, -0.030028576031327248, 0.020576536655426025, -0.0009163268259726465, 0.022775068879127502, -0.00474945455789566, -0.012268222868442535, -0.016699841246008873, 0.047528594732284546, -0.018860045820474625, -0.0256515983492136, -0.0056164986453950405, 0.03774426132440567, 0.010696680285036564, 0.03439471498131752, -0.02313849702477455, 0.00454862043261528, 0.0301851574331522, -0.030863212421536446, 0.05583517625927925, -0.00162023538723588, 0.009059672243893147, 0.03503761440515518, -0.016369730234146118, -0.021871408447623253, 0.059054940938949585, 0.06965634226799011, -0.014279620721936226, -0.07540862262248993, -0.02249261364340782, -0.02140761725604534, -0.0005257981829345226, -0.03777765855193138, -0.007652248255908489, 0.02089681290090084, 0.022209856659173965, -0.02852652035653591, 0.07713976502418518, -0.022752391174435616, 0.036572378128767014, 0.051554273813962936, 0.030355922877788544, -0.02050090953707695, 0.04254094138741493, -0.06017904356122017, 0.005468941293656826, 0.005030233412981033, 0.027346991002559662, 0.018994754180312157, 0.035173386335372925, 0.00407084496691823, -0.012076438404619694, 0.025080766528844833, 0.0192289836704731, 0.001678127096965909, 0.09379315376281738, -0.022603590041399002, 0.035148583352565765, 0.013376881368458271, -0.005384961608797312, 0.04818866774439812, 0.06411819905042648, 0.031178589910268784, 0.00019233547209296376, 0.026213008910417557, -0.018345195800065994, 0.022678807377815247, 0.021816397085785866, -0.004503521136939526, -0.018119769170880318, -0.07091587036848068, 0.015601268969476223, 0.04990178719162941, -0.0019217698136344552, -0.0048261722549796104, -0.015348506160080433, 0.009916114620864391, -0.01605195552110672, -0.0447712279856205, -0.008408069610595703, 0.005443836096674204, 0.008475103415548801, 0.004184104967862368, 0.0053568328730762005, -0.02264273166656494, -0.04257640615105629, -0.00047540178638882935, 0.06248411163687706, 0.0428815595805645, 0.038548048585653305, -0.02523037977516651, 0.023893313482403755, -0.039588216692209244, -0.05084430053830147, 0.018023883923888206, -0.0029704379849135876, 0.017042603343725204, -0.028193572536110878, 0.04892734810709953, -0.018170377239584923, -0.048611659556627274, 0.03993363678455353, 0.0289676021784544, 0.031506169587373734, 0.009718315675854683, -0.06622657179832458, -0.04791467636823654, 0.04196938872337341, 0.012272566556930542, 0.02453756518661976, -0.04265972226858139, -0.015546564944088459, 0.022176310420036316, 0.015333319082856178, 0.023198045790195465, 0.03530775010585785, -0.002859575906768441, 0.022466382011771202, 0.015599912963807583, -0.026039065793156624, -0.01811552420258522, -0.04008851572871208, -0.033082038164138794, -0.0180920772254467, -0.06504224240779877, -0.017405562102794647, -0.011737369932234287, -0.01647915691137314, -0.010778302326798439, 0.0665135607123375, -0.013752524740993977, -0.0008615567930974066, -0.03118746355175972, -0.0038940904196351767, -0.0328093059360981, 0.08819535374641418, -0.006005770526826382, 0.0039459518156945705, 0.014701828360557556, -0.020131446421146393, -0.03076287917792797, 0.008676723577082157, 0.034142158925533295, 0.04319204390048981, -0.011995207518339157, 0.014176729135215282, -0.028422696515917778, 0.0560254231095314, -0.012245884165167809, -0.006794865243136883, -0.007533810567110777, -0.043293580412864685, -0.054504308849573135, 0.00487729674205184, 0.06453926861286163, 0.02432461455464363, 0.007862680591642857, 0.04579416289925575, -0.05674898624420166, -0.06530846655368805, -0.04625490680336952, -0.022866815328598022, -0.013185236603021622, -0.02440342865884304, 0.03499441593885422, 0.008817947469651699, 0.03671378269791603, 0.005718677770346403, -0.00926923006772995, -0.009772359393537045, -0.02043096348643303, 0.02484414540231228, 0.0075388215482234955, 0.02928921952843666, 0.02474556677043438, 0.043147653341293335, -0.013352952897548676, 0.032947052270174026, 0.013942176476120949, -0.029000120237469673, 0.03169912472367287, -0.040278784930706024, -0.0011042162077501416, 0.028451919555664062, -0.02681223303079605, 0.01720627211034298, 0.01573806069791317, -0.03165009990334511, 0.04428573697805405, -0.06780003011226654, 0.03795889765024185, 0.06033008173108101, 0.02324529178440571, -0.0014985711313784122, 0.003919037524610758, -0.011162888258695602, 0.05331922695040703, -0.02362748049199581, -0.024753576144576073, -0.05316551774740219, -0.04710843414068222, 0.04415613412857056, 0.00962999276816845, -0.02309575118124485, 0.0037171063013374805, 0.046447549015283585, -0.038666095584630966, 0.01921810396015644, 0.04609218239784241, -0.007097573019564152, -0.01097877137362957, -0.00935260858386755, 0.022628862410783768, 0.023873429745435715, -0.025954311713576317, 0.03884723782539368, 0.007545615080744028, 0.060695964843034744, -0.008030686527490616, -0.020266255363821983, 0.036365773528814316, -0.029008394107222557, 0.005755014251917601, -0.033978354185819626, 0.007157765794545412, 0.025805631652474403, 0.0034896661527454853, 0.024943362921476364, 0.02781156450510025, -0.020643621683120728, -0.011433649808168411, 0.003945736214518547, 0.012599523179233074, 0.04461546242237091, 0.054766733199357986, -0.009316534735262394, -0.03293278440833092, -0.010632985271513462, -0.04563522711396217, 0.0003863311721943319, -0.007415303494781256, -0.035032570362091064, -0.015277804806828499, 0.004560362081974745, 0.003816650016233325, 0.02963126264512539, 0.02187403477728367, -0.029489176347851753, -0.03748881071805954, -0.028168853372335434, -0.02688140794634819, 0.039338670670986176, 0.007844255305826664, -0.025458112359046936, 0.0018004013691097498, -0.024830767884850502, 0.0032513942569494247, 0.03264806419610977, -0.026602890342473984, 0.0014985987218096852, 0.03516441956162453, -0.030647944658994675, -0.02111601084470749, -0.015942975878715515, -0.02977016381919384, 0.022473054006695747, 0.0004933132440783083, 0.0015937802381813526, 0.056555699557065964, -0.006792191881686449, -0.024659140035510063, 0.013432727195322514, -0.09310026466846466, -0.01784684881567955, -0.019710170105099678, -0.003237958298996091, -0.0006266721757128835, 0.00041915717883966863, 0.0016382044414058328, 0.01111895963549614, -0.04268733784556389, -0.003792078699916601, -0.06021476164460182, -0.04743625596165657, 0.008449533954262733, -0.03249640017747879, 0.0220783818513155, -0.006030083168298006, -0.03289097547531128, 0.03339824080467224, 0.02190598100423813, -0.024914376437664032, -0.054570477455854416, 0.04476192593574524, -0.0710720419883728, 0.005460360087454319, 0.014373641461133957, 0.026159606873989105, 0.03239080309867859, 0.05146468058228493, 0.014828773215413094, 0.027043214067816734, 0.018533911556005478, -0.001000529038719833, 0.021324628964066505, 0.026952357962727547, -0.011438870802521706, -0.040657464414834976, 0.04297085851430893, 0.006805841811001301, 0.00039102608570829034, 0.01422342099249363, -0.01333740632981062, 0.0075856465846300125, 0.016571516171097755, -0.03217577934265137, 0.0004327190690673888, 0.025822561234235764, 0.013893145136535168, -0.03836990147829056, 0.015612071380019188, -0.004861812107264996, -0.06666069477796555, -0.003962785936892033, 0.01626177877187729, 0.009895130060613155, -0.014573890715837479, 0.011449654586613178, 0.0298035629093647, 0.04230745509266853, -0.02042808011174202, -0.001168495393358171, 0.0008759695338085294, -0.04140378162264824, 0.04544330760836601, -0.04617554321885109, -0.07230731099843979, 0.0514124371111393, 0.012726439163088799, 0.020403355360031128, -0.027119312435388565, -0.03780653327703476, 0.014620600268244743, -0.04972812905907631, -0.003709778655320406, -0.0004412964917719364, 0.05357557535171509, 0.028981810435652733, 0.005688958801329136, 0.01876113750040531, -0.021814357489347458, 0.023323876783251762, -0.02345804125070572, -0.04725872725248337, 0.05961175262928009, -0.007988112047314644, -0.00046312808990478516, -0.011086384765803814, -0.04899701848626137, 0.029376033693552017, -0.020980229601264, 0.02567541040480137, 0.04140477627515793, -0.006342235021293163, -0.019243624061346054, 0.004185098689049482, -0.02656709961593151, -0.014899009838700294, -0.013459078967571259, 0.006010358687490225, -0.0232210922986269, 0.027354462072253227, 0.03610922768712044, 0.03186846151947975, -0.0028523742221295834, 0.013936568051576614, -0.013505734503269196, 0.028367649763822556, 0.016483867540955544, 0.030728666111826897, 0.04025815427303314, 0.0021549095399677753, -0.030929509550333023, 0.03574442118406296, 0.01776283048093319, 0.046094492077827454, 0.0345376692712307, -0.03490622341632843, -0.012963948771357536, -0.04825574904680252, -0.009532211348414421, 0.0011457318905740976, 0.01865861378610134, 0.01945420913398266, -0.024382008239626884, 0.04733351245522499, 0.015769904479384422, -0.05105622485280037, 0.027442604303359985, 0.05433754622936249, 0.00655902735888958, -0.014145362190902233, -0.016182059422135353, -0.02589184232056141, 0.015732308849692345, 0.00750383548438549, 0.04906252771615982, 0.02045644260942936, -0.019894052296876907, -0.018113229423761368, 0.03697142377495766, -0.030451102182269096, -0.0333232544362545, -0.004559781868010759, 0.04207819700241089, 0.0656978189945221, -0.013385375961661339, -0.042832087725400925, 0.012041368521749973, 0.0334758535027504, 0.025121713057160378, 0.011058766394853592, 0.02631594054400921, -0.07665179669857025, 0.004251398611813784, 0.011973991058766842, 0.03997446596622467, -0.0228025671094656, -0.011415856890380383, -0.04928574338555336, 0.0025181255768984556, 0.03939228132367134, -0.03645149618387222, 0.03058212250471115, -0.016054291278123856, 0.04472257196903229, -0.04781753197312355, -0.022403700277209282, -0.07930731028318405, 0.018099462613463402, -0.00992059800773859, 0.007188297342509031, -0.03494539111852646, -0.046128880232572556, -0.05450154468417168, 0.015741515904664993, 0.004805487580597401, 0.03228692710399628, -0.052387919276952744, -0.0060660382732748985, 0.030844194814562798, 0.021571509540081024, -0.013707287609577179, -0.04159872233867645, 0.022720608860254288, -0.005219635553658009, -0.005946483928710222, 0.02009565941989422, 0.007893504574894905, -0.03919929638504982, 0.00621039280667901, 0.017058666795492172, -0.021770263090729713, 0.026280580088496208, -0.005845409352332354, 0.026053013280034065, 0.030193449929356575, 0.010168824344873428, 0.01486631017178297, 0.023373613134026527, -0.028336796909570694, 0.007482453249394894, -0.07432452589273453, 0.001730645657517016, -0.04110637679696083, -0.04724503681063652, -0.03896490857005119, 0.018409159034490585, -0.027686472982168198, 0.02679176814854145, 0.0005864990525878966, 0.016614440828561783, -0.05206234008073807, 0.01679317280650139, 0.018296169117093086, 0.00587049312889576, 0.00791598204523325, 0.007609508465975523, 0.05644019693136215, 0.02605288103222847, 0.01956769824028015, -0.011499257758259773, -0.00688656372949481, -0.01620601676404476, 0.00410733837634325, 0.00742588983848691, -0.02754363790154457, 0.02118024230003357, 0.016917070373892784, 0.005653697997331619, 0.04641484096646309, -0.020635223016142845, -0.01755051128566265, 0.0368671640753746, 0.012014340609312057, 0.012510775588452816, -0.030545515939593315, 0.006049877032637596, -0.0024860266130417585, -0.012234053574502468, 0.0422607846558094, -0.07691147923469543, 0.07897081971168518, 0.015622120350599289, -0.03268619254231453, -0.05562562867999077, -0.02909032441675663, 0.01596895232796669, 0.00018438560073263943, -0.05407470464706421, -0.0605279766023159, -0.023245517164468765, -0.009848375804722309, -0.007387653458863497, -0.011975053697824478, -0.004814491141587496, 0.004758621100336313, -0.021337660029530525, -0.060878753662109375, 0.026976563036441803, 0.059132203459739685, -0.0008311706478707492, 0.005157072562724352, 0.006808190606534481, -0.019606787711381912, -0.00466095982119441, -0.0013936639297753572, 0.06176165118813515, -0.004017116967588663, -0.0289931520819664, -0.012990206480026245, 0.02883566915988922, 0.03034115396440029, -0.025161439552903175, -0.026849787682294846, -0.01659020222723484, -0.018191536888480186, 0.04609335958957672, -0.011775425635278225, 0.007306563202291727, -0.026731200516223907, 0.024974916130304337, -0.010416720993816853, -0.005158216692507267, 0.0038070171140134335, -0.044273898005485535, 0.01963980309665203, -0.0023565292358398438, -0.02928396500647068, 0.03192172572016716, 0.06047709658741951, -0.015720484778285027, 0.014002865180373192, -0.02132757194340229, -0.023199856281280518, 0.04948306456208229, 0.007089866790920496, -0.02186509780585766, 0.03715631738305092, 0.03611673787236214, -0.002485336037352681, -0.02302919141948223, -0.04609423130750656, 0.014431490562856197, 0.05200417339801788, 0.01604006253182888, 0.044763945043087006, 0.052652277052402496, -0.020596422255039215, 0.03402579948306084, -0.03584541752934456, -0.034739602357149124, -0.014060677960515022, 0.0017175090033560991, 0.04120725393295288, -0.029238656163215637, -0.01738552749156952, 0.049138639122247696, -0.009521832689642906, 0.014477774500846863, 0.030144689604640007, 0.014881487004458904, 0.02108026295900345, 0.017107322812080383, -0.005367036908864975, -0.021965496242046356, 0.045082591474056244, -0.01227984856814146, 0.028180228546261787, -0.02970297634601593, 0.029352018609642982, 0.039921823889017105, 0.03429902717471123, -0.003973990213125944, -0.042919427156448364, -0.00837053544819355, -0.07850009948015213, -0.0021877216640859842, 0.05273596569895744, -0.020245851948857307, 0.02655574306845665, 0.016305651515722275, 0.045026421546936035, 0.03151845559477806, 0.016115356236696243, -0.04358525574207306, -0.0727427750825882, -0.04461752250790596, -0.007230283226817846, -0.0029258308932185173, 0.04026981070637703, -0.021291831508278847, -0.043572068214416504, 0.00421844283118844, -0.05838669463992119, 0.017951449379324913, 0.0066186003386974335, 0.028048446401953697, 0.016417693346738815, 0.07378270477056503, 0.013173244893550873, 0.013718625530600548, -0.010783262550830841, -0.05690036714076996, 0.14624512195587158, 0.061627600342035294, 0.03790855035185814, -0.05371106415987015, -0.03309175744652748, 0.015816912055015564, 0.002430186839774251, -0.011602629907429218, -0.005820141173899174, -0.00892647635191679, -0.004930809605866671, 0.08175704628229141, 0.04851068556308746, 0.01754869893193245, -0.03128001466393471, 0.03480164334177971, -0.040829937905073166, -0.016356825828552246, 0.017505543306469917, -0.000885595625732094, -0.009635546244680882, -0.003341009607538581, -0.07534059882164001, 0.026125723496079445, -0.013228168711066246, 0.005902513861656189, -0.02631971798837185, -0.007844001054763794, -0.0006947017391212285, 0.0187628585845232, 0.005753010977059603, -0.0097523033618927, 0.020645566284656525, 0.021172674372792244, -0.004595556296408176, 0.0280498918145895, 0.031666502356529236, -0.019614918157458305, 0.015330145135521889, 0.02397911809384823, -0.0006233675521798432, 0.010859140194952488, -0.02440498024225235, -0.0011754730949178338, -0.02923540025949478, -0.023913303390145302, -0.05326567217707634, 0.04664313420653343, 0.022682825103402138, -0.008577659726142883, 0.011370973661541939, 0.004128387663513422, 0.0034688657615333796, -0.019730819389224052, -0.005572611931711435, 0.027008051052689552, 0.008685528300702572, -0.020709604024887085, -0.0014208470238372684, -0.027472421526908875, 0.0368473194539547, 0.0031642303802073, 0.025178898125886917, 0.03091675229370594, -0.001308572944253683, -0.013189906254410744, -0.04345855861902237, 0.07939877361059189, -0.008266645483672619, 0.015325094573199749, 0.01524894405156374, -0.005078176502138376, -0.03668537735939026, -0.0145490113645792, 0.04240059107542038, -0.02613849565386772, 0.04874919354915619, -0.006858007982373238, 0.013765006326138973, -0.024112671613693237, -0.007873100228607655, 0.01705985702574253, -0.016326095908880234, 0.00429704412817955, -0.056164730340242386, -0.029597267508506775, 0.01494014821946621, 0.03115657903254032, 0.021886814385652542, 0.05123910680413246, 0.015012349002063274, 0.06769822537899017, 0.003972318023443222, -0.08041314780712128, -0.024585111066699028, 0.008097762241959572, -0.009126238524913788, -0.028445135802030563, -0.04007875546813011, 0.05175343155860901, 0.028341220691800117, 0.02811996079981327, 0.015673013404011726, 0.029018007218837738, 0.0034598223865032196, -0.00723391305655241, -0.0038579690735787153, -0.03400196135044098, -0.02549857087433338, 0.0009731719037517905, -0.02419455535709858, -0.009709478355944157, -0.02502923645079136, -0.056806523352861404, -0.0680718943476677, 0.01915661059319973, -0.008456073701381683, -0.04232970252633095, 0.02468847669661045, 0.0002671651600394398, -0.02948962152004242, -0.02603466995060444, -0.01609284058213234, -0.02254922315478325, 0.00400939304381609, -0.035651836544275284, -0.0369827002286911, 0.016773764044046402, -0.004653481300920248, -0.043727196753025055, -0.024404292926192284, 0.032826147973537445, 0.012675371952354908, 0.0021141073666512966, -0.026730045676231384, 0.036669593304395676, -0.004593416582792997, 0.032317087054252625, -0.036043934524059296, -0.01268590148538351, 0.017615478485822678, -0.010316926054656506, -0.028131932020187378, 0.027872614562511444, -0.023787090554833412, 0.02730954810976982, 0.01440420001745224, 0.03617650642991066, -0.03440777212381363, 0.06109505891799927, -0.012424927204847336, 0.0111054927110672, -0.025091098621487617, -0.034463610500097275, 0.015396145172417164, 0.01645461469888687, 0.016235020011663437, 0.015591416507959366, -0.02162715047597885, 0.028287580236792564, 0.02048097550868988, -0.022379888221621513, 0.03157461807131767, -0.009417075663805008, -0.0025694400537759066, 0.03480406105518341, -0.0002773776068352163, -0.024091556668281555, 0.03653491288423538, 0.05279639735817909, -0.00011454157356638461, 0.016973081976175308, -0.008495165966451168, 0.011171405203640461, -0.08779246360063553, -0.015243212692439556, 0.0028594417963176966, 0.01727820187807083, 0.0042040422558784485, -0.07875191420316696, -0.035738300532102585, 0.009721137583255768, -0.012949315831065178, 0.002365383319556713, -0.01911742053925991, 0.002864949870854616, -0.038388289511203766, -0.01589328981935978, -0.013568663038313389, 0.05389327183365822, 0.050904348492622375, 0.03143678605556488, 0.03092924878001213, 0.009700647555291653, 0.008965782821178436, -0.01251973956823349, -0.05533900111913681, 0.015358030796051025, 0.02586929127573967, -0.06662905961275101, 0.040193431079387665, -0.03258587047457695, -0.02255217917263508, 0.03179487958550453, 0.03063260391354561, 0.01769368164241314, 0.017551664263010025, 0.014774559997022152, 0.01268894411623478, 0.03915614262223244, 0.037346433848142624, 0.006818552501499653, -0.04351794347167015, 0.010824539698660374, 0.023724112659692764, 0.004224899224936962, -0.03366454690694809, 0.015951378270983696, -0.007337104994803667, -0.0341336652636528, -0.018254755064845085, 0.011644938960671425, 0.004736955743283033, 0.0067340717650949955, -0.061333172023296356, 0.007070951163768768, 0.04106238856911659, -0.03490294888615608, 0.03448810800909996, -0.03379734233021736, 0.04551970958709717, 0.039677854627370834, 0.057095471769571304, -0.020106324926018715, 0.023333806544542313, -0.02555481158196926, -0.0220964178442955, -0.006832876242697239, -0.0033680705819278955, 0.025973128154873848, 0.002684075850993395, -0.013601332902908325, -0.038834087550640106, -0.019261298701167107, -0.037484992295503616, -0.0036613638512790203, -0.04417875409126282, 0.06569414585828781, 0.005860606208443642, 0.02293889783322811, 0.03922966495156288, -0.041156988590955734, -0.020394351333379745, -0.10625985264778137, 0.05069180577993393, -0.019505159929394722, -0.05228668451309204, -0.06842222064733505, -0.007951747626066208, -0.06797904521226883, 0.043426789343357086, 0.01967701129615307, 0.054004888981580734, 0.0014274516142904758, -0.00246481504291296, 0.01637852191925049, -0.0007114638574421406, -0.06549511849880219, 0.054504700005054474, 0.0011804858222603798, -0.030274730175733566, 0.02168574184179306, 0.004461892880499363, 0.023989517241716385, 0.03552417457103729, -0.004911899566650391, -0.039609406143426895, -0.011080823838710785, -0.013820817694067955, -0.05212338641285896, 0.02139262855052948, -0.01696108467876911, -0.006396478973329067, 0.08655974268913269, 0.018170297145843506, 0.01254581194370985, 0.008948734030127525, 0.009871519170701504, -0.040872469544410706, 0.038113780319690704, 0.0029961466789245605, -0.013553091324865818, 0.036418717354536057, -0.012677657417953014, 0.001420544576831162, -0.047083862125873566, -0.005030714441090822, 0.022682953625917435, -0.00846625305712223, 0.0011482146801427007, 0.009195621125400066, 0.0498785637319088, 0.04662639647722244, -0.017908023670315742, -0.0029202743899077177, -0.009920555166900158, -0.029593277722597122, 0.019857442006468773, -0.011957550421357155, 0.004766580183058977, 0.012405011802911758, -0.02976248972117901, 0.0021968979854136705, -0.03720397502183914, 0.0007927821134217083, -0.014629245735704899, 0.06685277819633484, -0.027323102578520775, -0.03129343315958977, 0.0030417165253311396, 0.013697909191250801, 0.028992420062422752, -0.016192393377423286, -0.021411128342151642, 0.0362258143723011, -0.016156047582626343, 0.016184130683541298, -0.015779295936226845, -0.020825674757361412, -0.023623205721378326, -0.01639316976070404, 0.008530449122190475, 0.013802824541926384, 0.011572649702429771, 0.002700718818232417, 0.033962544053792953, -0.009662357158958912, 0.029143450781702995, -0.007411001715809107, 0.0035768423695117235, -0.014565832912921906, -0.012460099533200264, 0.0046913232654333115, 0.007198034320026636, -0.03708065301179886, -0.026294030249118805, -0.004972544033080339, 0.011608300730586052, 0.04196743667125702, -0.021887551993131638, -0.049536678940057755, 0.017216622829437256, 0.03474416211247444, -0.06300189346075058, -0.0016386572970077395, -0.040701039135456085, 0.005128283053636551, 0.027593549340963364, -0.062009092420339584 ]
<p>Let us take two formulations of the $\ell_{2}$ SVM optimization problem, one constrained: </p> <p>$\min_{\alpha,b} ||w||_2^2 + C \sum_{i=1}^n {\xi_{i}^2}$ </p> <p>s.t $ y_i(w^T x_i +b) \geq 1 - \xi_i$<br> and $\xi_i \geq 0 \forall i$</p> <p>and one unconstrained: </p> <p>$\min_{\alpha,b} ||w||_2^2 + C \sum_{i=1}^n \max(0,1 - y_i (w^T x_i + b))^2$</p> <p>What is the difference between those two formulations of the optimization problem? Is one better than the other?</p> <p>Hope I didn't make any mistake in the equations. Thanks.</p> <p>Update : I took the unconstrained formulation from <a href="http://www.kyb.mpg.de/publications/attachments/primal_%5b0%5d.pdf" rel="nofollow">Olivier Chapelle's work</a>. It seems that people use the unconstrained optimization problem when they want to work on the primal and the other way around when they want to work on the dual, I was wondering why?</p>
74,410
[ -0.010760968551039696, -0.03365330770611763, -0.015087242238223553, -0.03413614258170128, -0.0005072669591754675, 0.016689177602529526, -0.0345151424407959, -0.022243516519665718, 0.03921808302402496, -0.013451822102069855, 0.02713317796587944, 0.042990267276763916, 0.06357844918966293, 0.004961168859153986, 0.038409363478422165, -0.016202419996261597, -0.00017818572814576328, -0.03611721098423004, -0.002869349904358387, 0.029578065499663353, -0.015764987096190453, 0.012597720138728619, -0.012033430859446526, -0.004415654111653566, -0.033419735729694366, 0.031812168657779694, -0.00771922804415226, 0.011492862366139889, -0.008285846561193466, 0.03571867570281029, -0.032555676996707916, -0.018231036141514778, -0.006468485575169325, 0.015172927640378475, 0.034095872193574905, 0.01419676374644041, -0.03530343621969223, -0.026014041155576706, -0.009551716968417168, -0.000824715883936733, 0.007952441461384296, -0.03255278617143631, -0.026578346267342567, 0.025566134601831436, -0.0008339344640262425, 0.04149070382118225, 0.029893940314650536, -0.053983017802238464, -0.0019140586955472827, -0.04641985148191452, 0.10369254648685455, 0.024928120896220207, 0.019407419487833977, 0.00956585630774498, -0.024913055822253227, -0.023942383006215096, 0.02148527093231678, 0.08893477916717529, 0.05594545975327492, -0.04610981047153473, -0.007219970691949129, 0.019417114555835724, -0.0037832874804735184, -0.01771668717265129, -0.02474908158183098, 0.09484631568193436, 0.03529287874698639, -0.012059126049280167, 0.02601366862654686, -0.03849353268742561, 0.0036136037670075893, -0.030905280262231827, 0.03554969280958176, -0.027742639183998108, 0.007060626987367868, 0.0007567359716631472, 0.0035186910536140203, 0.0487934835255146, 0.046316418796777725, -0.005774840712547302, 0.03223896771669388, 0.023089641705155373, 0.05482444167137146, 0.02700313925743103, -0.01841415837407112, -0.007839752361178398, 0.07384296506643295, 0.012842824682593346, -0.01618330366909504, 0.024131426587700844, -0.0030383688863366842, 0.02953924424946308, 0.04628424346446991, -0.021013230085372925, -0.028289858251810074, 0.037950530648231506, 0.0037126506213098764, 0.03913499414920807, 0.02367323264479637, -0.04990239068865776, -0.0039013326168060303, -0.03444642946124077, -0.021476415917277336, 0.06352128833532333, -0.008810242637991905, -0.005247622262686491, -0.026290753856301308, 0.04843787103891373, -0.04472167789936066, -0.05350922793149948, -0.05449772998690605, -0.013436678797006607, -0.03316071629524231, 0.014776594005525112, 0.027234407141804695, -0.015386765822768211, 0.005469891242682934, -0.0007316764676943421, 0.01674400269985199, 0.04332653433084488, 0.018092075362801552, 0.003877471201121807, 0.024101432412862778, -0.05859839916229248, -0.03288956731557846, 0.010099822655320168, 0.05486739054322243, -0.030283557251095772, -0.058010656386613846, 0.016831940039992332, 0.03110123984515667, -0.015391906723380089, 0.003102675313130021, -0.002147024031728506, -0.015717562288045883, -0.014958595857024193, -0.0925501212477684, -0.0768476277589798, 0.0484812967479229, -0.05255446955561638, 0.03493291884660721, -0.03215990215539932, 0.009255507960915565, 0.018829457461833954, 0.04787333682179451, -0.0009723532130010426, 0.03651874512434006, 0.0487171970307827, 0.010736845433712006, -0.006422579754143953, -0.020491233095526695, 0.0025946928653866053, -0.022890951484441757, -0.027493668720126152, -0.011024381034076214, -0.0871221274137497, 0.0043505155481398106, 0.02464774064719677, -0.010621992871165276, 0.009785054251551628, 0.0664595365524292, 0.00029348654788918793, -0.024093009531497955, 0.007921514101326466, -0.010945841670036316, 0.0032657531555742025, 0.05063120648264885, 0.029738007113337517, 0.06129108741879463, 0.050875820219516754, -0.012517712078988552, -0.0042898873798549175, 0.006710432935506105, 0.00750080868601799, 0.06031147018074989, 0.0001026375248329714, 0.014807075262069702, -0.015652967616915703, 0.0224447101354599, 0.053836192935705185, -0.05874314531683922, -0.030684133991599083, -0.014816517941653728, 0.028677139431238174, 0.02233942598104477, 0.062362756580114365, 0.011094477027654648, -0.024447308853268623, 0.012081797234714031, -0.01245976984500885, -0.013087721541523933, -0.06233140453696251, 0.027580853551626205, 0.018256738781929016, -0.03451849892735481, 0.05444502830505371, -0.010288666933774948, -0.020752692595124245, 0.0050386399962008, -0.01337521243840456, 0.007629569619894028, 0.041507478803396225, 0.0354841947555542, -0.011139344424009323, 0.005708427634090185, 0.0383085235953331, 0.03454377502202988, 0.0037384030874818563, 0.03157937899231911, -0.0070718699134886265, -0.0689922422170639, 0.004037749022245407, 0.00033157909638248384, 0.021940793842077255, 0.01938135363161564, 0.015076985582709312, 0.01536623202264309, -0.01542152650654316, -0.04715687781572342, -0.015247694216668606, -0.04839883744716644, 0.033840250223875046, 0.07477785646915436, 0.01636522077023983, -0.004425809718668461, 0.04181933403015137, -0.013165989890694618, 0.02864050678908825, 0.007231962867081165, 0.0019790020305663347, -0.026922404766082764, 0.017607809975743294, 0.054376427084207535, 0.051676470786333084, -0.031908269971609116, 0.03902045264840126, 0.02314421534538269, 0.028048276901245117, 0.015287556685507298, 0.013784204609692097, -0.01383071020245552, -0.01701938733458519, 0.033571526408195496, -0.003515289630740881, 0.019212177023291588, 0.013265456072986126, -0.022985069081187248, -0.02203758992254734, 0.012511524371802807, -0.03209730610251427, -0.04306931793689728, 0.05094994977116585, -0.01417633332312107, -0.02022785134613514, 0.004126337822526693, -0.016335614025592804, 0.03339564800262451, -0.034855183213949203, -0.019102465361356735, 0.05052820220589638, -0.008737901225686073, -0.02316970005631447, -0.005516290199011564, -0.025589941069483757, 0.022870326414704323, -0.01843566820025444, -0.02360014244914055, 0.0020712516270577908, 0.024071786552667618, -0.05273312330245972, -0.011239073239266872, -0.03246930241584778, -0.033005546778440475, -0.05845008045434952, -0.012331927195191383, 0.027408862486481667, -0.011620452627539635, 0.016557691618800163, -0.05354591831564903, -0.02184661291539669, -0.01186011079698801, -0.04547205567359924, 0.03148931637406349, -0.011418200097978115, -0.024510448798537254, 0.03386319801211357, -0.06384921818971634, -0.01308632642030716, 0.03284364566206932, 0.013338861055672169, 0.016538189724087715, -0.005866341758519411, -0.0005435864441096783, -0.039720501750707626, -0.06613308936357498, -0.0359826385974884, 0.025451799854636192, 0.03712683916091919, -0.016854118555784225, 0.04937621206045151, 0.018954064697027206, -0.047020137310028076, 0.01587463542819023, -0.0399673692882061, -0.03162727504968643, -0.04644475132226944, -0.01729726605117321, 0.016546038910746574, -0.03509711101651192, 0.004706895910203457, 0.03832125663757324, -0.011376568116247654, 0.04037180170416832, -0.08391710370779037, -0.018513236194849014, 0.017902681604027748, -0.03481872379779816, 0.010624540969729424, 0.029465021565556526, -0.0027173387352377176, 0.11484722048044205, 0.057366564869880676, -0.04432148113846779, -0.04743553698062897, 0.01676415652036667, -0.03624146431684494, 0.008272194303572178, -0.006523047108203173, 0.02761375904083252, 0.022893119603395462, 0.010368932969868183, -0.05255850404500961, 0.012018409557640553, 0.05329512432217598, 0.019152265042066574, 0.00040177610935643315, 0.025053508579730988, -0.022266527637839317, -0.01159967016428709, 0.04101534187793732, 0.004682466853410006, 0.02329436130821705, -0.01909489929676056, 0.02788197062909603, -0.0176696814596653, -0.005710126832127571, -0.028622198849916458, 0.00435633584856987, -0.0016504009254276752, 0.015234907157719135, -0.03229439631104469, 0.06494936347007751, 0.002751910826191306, -0.020149381831288338, 0.01771492324769497, 0.0015347815351560712, -0.005379716865718365, -0.057313527911901474, -0.032716043293476105, 0.03775468096137047, 0.025383392348885536, -0.036982156336307526, 0.0023849071003496647, -0.014869616366922855, 0.009366728365421295, 0.03773392364382744, 0.00654625752940774, -0.04112254083156586, 0.045075975358486176, 0.03188406676054001, 0.008590339682996273, 0.028181733563542366, -0.06395091861486435, -0.017989808693528175, -0.09436893463134766, 0.019834451377391815, -0.019665898755192757, 0.0868605449795723, 0.015062525868415833, 0.029768316075205803, 0.009029633365571499, 0.006501259282231331, 0.0174044668674469, 0.00717851473018527, -0.09937575459480286, 0.02087174728512764, -0.008937190286815166, -0.0020828007254749537, 0.0060129305347800255, -0.027471426874399185, 0.040599316358566284, -0.02648782730102539, 0.012831361964344978, -0.013982832431793213, 0.031156305223703384, -0.051438309252262115, 0.03320595994591713, -0.02857072278857231, 0.009269065223634243, 0.0006530563114210963, -0.020725606009364128, 0.016516922041773796, -0.039571747183799744, 0.03296803683042526, 0.030416877940297127, -0.012706143781542778, 0.02099740318953991, -0.0070408922620117664, 0.004085180815309286, 0.01201656274497509, -0.0035726623609662056, -0.019300254061818123, 0.05774815008044243, -0.014637474901974201, 0.01234462670981884, 0.007469664793461561, 0.041749291121959686, 0.028557278215885162, -0.00864304881542921, -0.016422569751739502, -0.06588316708803177, -0.01198852900415659, 0.002770619001239538, 0.001831859233789146, 0.023452037945389748, 0.01661563664674759, 0.04052143916487694, 0.0074602640233933926, -0.021907469257712364, -0.01828298717737198, 0.045378826558589935, 0.006104323081672192, -0.016881661489605904, -0.042055610567331314, -0.016261983662843704, -0.0059136138297617435, -0.00041959327063523233, 0.038392841815948486, -0.03668602183461189, -0.024167286232113838, -0.04671991989016533, 0.03711656481027603, -0.06189224123954773, -0.010675349272787571, 0.02952105738222599, 0.04497671499848366, -0.0023608733899891376, 0.0004161682154517621, -0.028966793790459633, 0.024856608361005783, 0.0358373187482357, 0.058377448469400406, 0.02049417607486248, -0.0043108584359288216, -0.05863809585571289, -0.05279135704040527, 0.031211936846375465, 0.007198255974799395, -0.03807029500603676, -0.009003207087516785, -0.051240961998701096, -0.0536038763821125, -0.0086849145591259, -0.02471225894987583, 0.05094126611948013, 0.018454037606716156, -0.009185533970594406, -0.02294076234102249, -0.04835598170757294, -0.023252960294485092, 0.012251519598066807, -0.011049223132431507, 0.055439677089452744, 0.0034646231215447187, -0.03418654203414917, -0.03611280769109726, 0.0006666484987363219, 0.019647514447569847, 0.03725934401154518, -0.02242828719317913, 0.0005955192027613521, 0.012021329253911972, 0.039326686412096024, -0.027480021119117737, -0.07682777941226959, -0.009523855522274971, 0.028969576582312584, -0.04275813698768616, 0.04125403240323067, -0.02826857753098011, -0.08347993344068527, 0.028360750526189804, 0.02103053592145443, -0.03800777718424797, -0.011752385646104813, -0.00885880459100008, 0.0539807491004467, 0.05764508247375488, -0.0003165934467688203, 0.04554762318730354, 0.007275359705090523, -0.0321783609688282, -0.042861808091402054, -0.03456338867545128, 0.038381148129701614, 0.009794887155294418, -0.023060044273734093, -0.04558909311890602, -0.03209952265024185, 0.014877615496516228, 0.040269531309604645, -0.0031129210256040096, 0.053451940417289734, -0.013840092346072197, -0.05110339820384979, -0.0005034711211919785, 0.03811279684305191, 0.0014866091078147292, -0.03246752917766571, 0.009572472423315048, 0.053479913622140884, -0.003194160293787718, -0.022121652960777283, 0.0030677232425659895, -0.0466308519244194, 0.015618675388395786, 0.042955182492733, -0.05488627031445503, 0.007785127032548189, -0.01189232338219881, -0.03168473765254021, -0.011268934234976768, -0.014191160909831524, 0.04108418896794319, 0.007404412142932415, 0.054208457469940186, 0.024473320692777634, -0.040853872895240784, -0.016662731766700745, -0.04526549205183983, -0.021132517606019974, 0.00962921790778637, -0.07170489430427551, 0.04150025174021721, 0.040131524205207825, -0.019785968586802483, -0.05642494186758995, -0.046404775232076645, 0.006648533511906862, 0.022686488926410675, -0.03991458937525749, -0.01848028600215912, 0.03611835464835167, -0.008129219524562359, -0.03988073393702507, -0.046490561217069626, 0.06989594548940659, -0.027380509302020073, -0.0036049121990799904, 0.006934206932783127, 0.04571158438920975, 0.039224978536367416, -0.0037781985010951757, 0.009888123720884323, 0.04331757873296738, -0.015422509983181953, 0.023597585037350655, 0.02337111346423626, 0.04063337668776512, -0.029841003939509392, -0.005860289558768272, -0.031912125647068024, 0.014874087646603584, 0.03678164258599281, 0.01172862108796835, 0.0273171067237854, 0.0486888661980629, 0.002265782793983817, -0.0036994866095483303, -0.00033449140028096735, -0.033588215708732605, 0.021174786612391472, 0.021531615406274796, 0.003320063930004835, -0.03261270001530647, 0.00550420954823494, -0.012672599405050278, 0.02111406996846199, 0.023093901574611664, -0.03751213476061821, -0.008699106983840466, 0.08009182661771774, -0.041758570820093155, 0.017850341275334358, -0.014988439157605171, -0.004304615315049887, 0.01481865905225277, 0.006121641490608454, 0.042179811745882034, 0.00798369012773037, 0.028773630037903786, -0.02971435897052288, 0.025885943323373795, -0.021750276908278465, 0.06405728310346603, 0.08099017292261124, -0.01811494305729866, 0.0438256673514843, 0.029133271425962448, -0.005349884741008282, -0.0032186093740165234, -0.06613951176404953, 0.0051339054480195045, -0.022981319576501846, -0.008541150018572807, 0.04064815863966942, -0.022920217365026474, -0.027563318610191345, 0.0872478187084198, -0.0023262507747858763, 0.009039211086928844, -0.017532099038362503, 0.017958220094442368, 0.054667629301548004, 0.023845523595809937, -0.03947187215089798, -0.03485308587551117, 0.041143082082271576, -0.01309308409690857, 0.03626900538802147, 0.008901395834982395, -0.04199691489338875, 0.031847033649683, 0.01350520458072424, 0.010733837261795998, -0.03888310119509697, -0.01551500428467989, -0.008379433304071426, 0.04759631305932999, 0.01233475748449564, -0.021041641011834145, 0.011740868911147118, 0.013247496448457241, 0.03456132858991623, -0.007710466627031565, 0.010430192574858665, -0.01929512992501259, -0.07107263058423996, -0.004034426063299179, -0.030642613768577576, -0.02041815221309662, 0.03582168370485306, 0.04653264209628105, -0.0375574566423893, 0.014771656133234501, -0.03759457916021347, 0.012819473631680012, -0.0036451651249080896, 0.0440361462533474, 0.017521148547530174, 0.053892020136117935, 0.004120945930480957, -0.0217339638620615, -0.0021891447249799967, -0.003375296713784337, 0.10272222757339478, 0.06964203715324402, 0.05228103697299957, -0.06962309032678604, 0.040841422975063324, -0.01169203594326973, 0.009672860614955425, -0.014604886993765831, 0.014260306023061275, -0.004368049092590809, 0.00031995694735087454, 0.036369454115629196, 0.0159190334379673, 0.04662574827671051, -0.00923618208616972, 0.039995767176151276, -0.05523700267076492, -0.011723849922418594, 0.03874396160244942, 0.004071124363690615, 0.016091594472527504, 0.006982842460274696, -0.041312068700790405, 0.0009042751626111567, 0.00026459520449861884, -0.020567618310451508, -0.0055265347473323345, -0.017398776486516, 0.014221789315342903, 0.0001233608927577734, -0.011311058886349201, -0.013917475007474422, 0.023879708722233772, -0.0025094880256801844, -0.01172178890556097, 0.0249876007437706, -0.025881512090563774, -0.02916908822953701, 0.025844836607575417, 0.024136578664183617, -0.0001464679226046428, -0.01934771053493023, 0.008198782801628113, -0.010605806484818459, -0.05087897926568985, -0.01545756310224533, -0.043751683086156845, 0.05427958071231842, 0.0060803648084402084, -0.01659202016890049, 0.0038787703961133957, -0.012974266894161701, 0.006906298454850912, -0.04313097149133682, 0.0006234530010260642, 0.007588142994791269, 0.02085885964334011, -0.0004517054767347872, 0.012820569798350334, -0.02246677689254284, 0.03753374516963959, -0.0027871134225279093, 0.019346296787261963, 0.020770803093910217, -0.06111416220664978, -0.02674439735710621, 0.017473416402935982, 0.02623690478503704, -0.015267232432961464, 0.009163905866444111, -0.011423438787460327, -0.022258907556533813, -0.02226240374147892, -0.049639228731393814, 0.028085745871067047, -0.018423063680529594, 0.03290397301316261, -0.05750773847103119, -0.02057543955743313, -0.0554078184068203, -0.08976820111274719, -0.003947770223021507, -0.006179311312735081, -0.005686252377927303, -0.0026636351831257343, 0.01644231751561165, 0.0291818305850029, 0.019964857026934624, -0.0017270642565563321, -0.021513761952519417, 0.017337637022137642, 0.048646535724401474, 0.016615429893136024, -0.025320636108517647, -0.05362841859459877, 0.004864315502345562, 0.016086814925074577, 0.013726670295000076, 0.010208962485194206, 0.02639712765812874, 0.025278497487306595, 0.010008667595684528, -0.02552814409136772, 0.03682605177164078, 0.008866632357239723, 0.001167259062640369, -0.007325262762606144, -0.06426731497049332, -0.008642044849693775, 0.05705471336841583, 0.004884717520326376, -0.03809620812535286, 0.025036441162228584, -0.0004790087405126542, -0.030147962272167206, 0.006884073372930288, -0.014371147379279137, -0.025954771786928177, 0.017509188503026962, 0.004166390746831894, 0.022566601634025574, -0.015524485148489475, -0.0318007692694664, 0.006265618838369846, 0.04659045487642288, -0.02400720678269863, -0.00954856164753437, -0.01944608800113201, 0.04309486225247383, -0.028183232992887497, -0.006697908975183964, 0.014984161593019962, 0.02731366641819477, 0.01629488542675972, -0.015198013745248318, -0.016459764912724495, 0.01867927610874176, 0.04398668184876442, -0.010869212448596954, -0.03637367859482765, -0.0023002985399216413, -0.01065655518323183, -0.05273498594760895, 0.021000973880290985, 0.005615893751382828, -0.000997465569525957, 0.009097963571548462, 0.0051167928613722324, -0.01769093982875347, 0.046791836619377136, -0.041571538895368576, 0.026155348867177963, 0.01266181468963623, -0.021489569917321205, 0.014894913882017136, -0.019196607172489166, 0.037162166088819504, -0.005086131859570742, -0.002947174711152911, 0.012148045934736729, 0.03692904859781265, -0.035926517099142075, -0.012731680646538734, -0.008866206742823124, 0.0014895356725901365, 0.03974199295043945, 0.02979159727692604, -0.03015887551009655, 0.030477140098810196, 0.029347486793994904, -0.022762058302760124, 0.033044617623090744, -0.006615927442908287, 0.018471792340278625, -0.07694624364376068, -0.004920268431305885, 0.007004760205745697, -0.0015207362594082952, 0.06435167044401169, -0.043266456574201584, 0.049490079283714294, 0.00470026396214962, -0.06483422964811325, 0.024866988882422447, 0.00328973401337862, -0.009210459887981415, -0.032512664794921875, -0.008090822026133537, -0.03565831854939461, 0.04485750570893288, 0.0001632368948776275, -0.0022810481023043394, 0.017979079857468605, 0.003566655796021223, -0.013437758199870586, -0.035304002463817596, -0.027367975562810898, 0.016591889783740044, 0.008444652892649174, -0.03675070405006409, 0.01562032476067543, -0.01876278966665268, -0.010639524087309837, 0.012233439832925797, -0.022125568240880966, 0.017137987539172173, 0.021800760179758072, 0.05890558660030365, 0.02803179807960987, 0.025822695344686508, 0.028463706374168396, 0.004810134880244732, -0.012123395688831806, -0.009126568213105202, 0.021792853251099586, -0.002457010094076395, 0.0031634867191314697, 0.026926059275865555, -0.009207548573613167, 0.003227532608434558, 0.0036407012958079576, 0.01711861975491047, 0.014201123267412186, -0.045483723282814026, -0.0038244007155299187, 0.017304353415966034, 0.021957095712423325, -0.04004151001572609, 0.0018604887882247567, -0.023754557594656944, -0.03468038886785507, 0.004430730361491442, 0.034085534512996674, -0.01000957004725933, 0.0029839971102774143, -0.000997399678453803, -0.04173178970813751, 0.03916402533650398, -0.0009554560529068112, -0.01527573075145483, -0.04183937609195709, -0.02060036174952984, 0.024934835731983185, -0.01995236985385418, -0.03094552829861641, -0.02991817146539688, -0.0013456696178764105, 0.04368315264582634, 0.012447547167539597, 0.015852514654397964, -0.018277021124958992, 0.009685994125902653, -0.01674306020140648, -0.06051521375775337, 0.06104264780879021, -0.010896215215325356, -0.012001493945717812, 0.0174568984657526, -0.002694954862818122, -0.012811633758246899, -0.00738484738394618, 0.035890236496925354, -0.0008753071306273341, 0.004385721869766712, -0.00972870085388422, -0.006569921039044857, 0.005763464607298374, 0.005912077147513628, 0.025392984971404076, 0.013321854174137115, -0.0003817372489720583, -0.02056356705725193, -0.031638842076063156, 0.004516973160207272, -0.01062927208840847, 0.02094125561416149, 0.012838834896683693, -0.024886084720492363, 0.029370419681072235, 0.020781798288226128, 0.025075547397136688, 0.009418092668056488, 0.015671737492084503, 0.06607643514871597, -0.011249653995037079, 0.011494996026158333, 0.007335093338042498, -0.01647399552166462, -0.0623755119740963, 0.026162058115005493, -0.04289118945598602, -0.02077534794807434, -0.0014085978036746383, -0.019319387152791023, 0.03031926602125168, -0.04509509354829788, -0.02285940945148468, 0.01745276339352131, -0.018798703327775, -0.017982250079512596, 0.022198418155312538, -0.0005832097958773375, 0.005346100311726332, 0.03083524852991104, 0.02167176827788353, 0.010425998829305172, 0.011882392689585686, -0.01730688475072384, -0.007865045219659805, 0.028744066134095192, 0.032987453043460846, -0.0021270187571644783, 0.03799315541982651, -0.02135438658297062, 0.058349378407001495, 0.0008988245972432196, -0.005854134447872639, -0.021786125376820564, -0.05593382939696312, -0.0013737520202994347, -0.004962021019309759, -0.047454796731472015, -0.03683587163686752, -0.036846235394477844, 0.07891504466533661, -0.05641841143369675, -0.004576259292662144, -0.008201990276575089, 0.004566553980112076, -0.02121412754058838, 0.01136036403477192, 0.026062272489070892, 0.052634138613939285, 0.000020828212655032985, -0.018168002367019653, 0.004543706774711609, -0.020022431388497353, 0.043116889894008636, -0.007050654385238886, 0.02404957078397274, -0.03882059454917908, -0.01174364984035492, 0.021254342049360275, -0.043172914534807205, -0.012639150023460388, -0.019281845539808273, 0.006366700399667025, 0.06436816602945328, -0.003309418447315693, -0.018811021000146866, -0.022535983473062515, -0.000025801871743169613, 0.03765521198511124, -0.039875902235507965, -0.03364678472280502, -0.007057957351207733, -0.011632673442363739, 0.019025398418307304, 0.001228701206855476 ]
<p>(redirected here from mathoverflow.net) Hello, </p> <p>At work I was asked the probability of a user hitting an outage on the website. I have some following metrics. Total system downtime = 500,000 seconds a year. Total amount of seconds a year = 31,556,926 seconds. Thus, p of system down = 0.159 or 1.59% We can also assume that downtime occurs evenly for a period of approximately 2 hours per week.</p> <p>Now, here is the tricky part. We have a metric for amount of total users attempting to use the service = 16,000,000 during the same time-frame. However, these are subdivided, in the total time spent using the service. So, lets say we have 7,000,000 users that spend between 0 - 30 seconds attempting to use the service. So for these users what is the probability of hitting the system when it is unavailable? (We can assume an average of 15 seconds spent total if this simplifies things)</p> <p>I looked up odds ratios and risk factors, but I am not sure how to calculate the probability of the event occurring at all.</p> <p>Thanks in advance!</p> <p>P.S. I was given a possible answer, at <a href="http://mathoverflow.net/questions/52816/probability-calculation-system-uptime-likelihood-of-occurence" rel="nofollow">http://mathoverflow.net/questions/52816/probability-calculation-system-uptime-likelihood-of-occurence</a> and was following the advice on posting the question in the most appropriate forum.</p>
74,411
[ -0.011798851191997528, -0.06980329006910324, -0.015660542994737625, -0.042349983006715775, 0.028474384918808937, -0.02414637804031372, 0.03891662508249283, -0.04286873713135719, 0.022612176835536957, 0.020561132580041885, 0.03228946775197983, 0.052972178906202316, 0.03768949583172798, 0.0058316634967923164, 0.0010744367027655244, -0.02067813277244568, -0.007379794493317604, -0.01632094383239746, -0.01679101027548313, -0.003171639982610941, 0.03101218119263649, -0.01630106009542942, 0.000033544889447512105, -0.04645261913537979, -0.03374536335468292, -0.004929522983729839, 0.0247466079890728, -0.04100840166211128, -0.02074076049029827, 0.04192763939499855, -0.02463580295443535, -0.023406893014907837, 0.03481850400567055, 0.053248580545186996, 0.03298193961381912, 0.038924891501665115, -0.052274323999881744, -0.01634649559855461, -0.02976752445101738, -0.007425522897392511, -0.03226226568222046, 0.012594266794621944, 0.004644917324185371, 0.0457821860909462, -0.03540197014808655, -0.016053730621933937, -0.0020704823546111584, -0.02132113091647625, 0.009103523567318916, -0.027577504515647888, 0.05401306971907616, -0.047782983630895615, 0.055465929210186005, -0.017838062718510628, 0.0017109903274104, 0.004803944379091263, 0.0729699581861496, 0.07700106501579285, -0.02254730835556984, -0.0489225760102272, -0.057346709072589874, -0.01691790111362934, -0.028927762061357498, -0.032183099538087845, -0.009513099677860737, 0.032201673835515976, -0.027944540604948997, -0.049978844821453094, 0.09158989787101746, -0.01614409126341343, -0.0032761062029749155, 0.005434456281363964, 0.03033948503434658, -0.00811268761754036, 0.03590349480509758, -0.05041400343179703, 0.07665886729955673, 0.0007881899364292622, 0.021923763677477837, 0.04027634859085083, -0.008981785736978054, 0.004868115298449993, -0.008556158281862736, 0.04290825128555298, 0.022066332399845123, -0.03813418000936508, 0.08491482585668564, -0.017338315024971962, 0.0348096527159214, 0.006653294432908297, 0.007791625801473856, -0.001933361287228763, 0.0208649393171072, -0.01842304691672325, -0.05407954379916191, 0.035500939935445786, 0.0029413660522550344, 0.031682852655649185, 0.008968792855739594, 0.007573979906737804, 0.004094172269105911, -0.057600606232881546, 0.022689858451485634, 0.07117929309606552, 0.004017755389213562, 0.0031488887034356594, -0.03591153025627136, -0.01774786412715912, -0.040307968854904175, -0.04552732780575752, -0.03720567747950554, 0.037658944725990295, -0.02016499824821949, -0.010002628900110722, 0.03254605829715729, -0.024789409711956978, -0.011991317383944988, -0.01857691816985607, 0.05643988028168678, 0.04594404995441437, 0.03975782170891762, 0.020287012681365013, 0.03147204965353012, -0.07855307310819626, -0.009176555089652538, 0.019385071471333504, 0.004831735044717789, -0.03481947258114815, -0.051732517778873444, 0.0072622885927557945, -0.027450421825051308, -0.010866430588066578, 0.026894506067037582, 0.004099847748875618, 0.06411449611186981, -0.010548173449933529, -0.08786065876483917, -0.042676281183958054, 0.025235390290617943, 0.0008871267782524228, 0.007009576074779034, -0.03596837446093559, 0.008180594071745872, 0.018584253266453743, 0.03013622760772705, 0.009246036410331726, 0.02571587637066841, 0.0015996369766071439, 0.022621626034379005, 0.03943559527397156, -0.019571935757994652, 0.007122936192899942, -0.05149742588400841, -0.027402838692069054, 0.018355699256062508, -0.07882776856422424, 0.05283696576952934, 0.028932079672813416, 0.018671564757823944, -0.03840024396777153, 0.026489488780498505, 0.05325932055711746, -0.028116276487708092, -0.009826199151575565, -0.0049873339012265205, -0.038572732359170914, 0.09075499325990677, 0.025278106331825256, -0.0025525856763124466, 0.035798292607069016, -0.00681932782754302, -0.006309862248599529, 0.0003376944223418832, 0.03167904540896416, 0.06412288546562195, -0.01790764182806015, -0.02237033098936081, -0.02486785687506199, -0.005482451058924198, 0.024568526074290276, -0.025485489517450333, 0.01125295553356409, -0.025116877630352974, 0.0005155950202606618, 0.03886909410357475, -0.006493946071714163, 0.014750480651855469, -0.009417874738574028, 0.004731581546366215, -0.003980231937021017, -0.06061667576432228, -0.03637268394231796, 0.02864040434360504, -0.017354069277644157, -0.014652394689619541, -0.009599067270755768, -0.012277161702513695, -0.012881929986178875, -0.041111741214990616, 0.00105472921859473, 0.0003193540615029633, -0.02525695040822029, 0.03156685829162598, -0.04209335520863533, -0.01965864561498165, 0.06315251439809799, 0.019705144688487053, 0.0002839909284375608, 0.04290120676159859, -0.0855068564414978, -0.04858063533902168, -0.04785861447453499, -0.009510989300906658, 0.0245595034211874, 0.01043962687253952, -0.01938333548605442, 0.02392987161874771, 0.006215504836291075, 0.02657782845199108, -0.000668382563162595, -0.04451414942741394, 0.027094751596450806, 0.0815538838505745, 0.03945890814065933, 0.024701496586203575, -0.03416769951581955, 0.0023215136025100946, -0.005537770688533783, 0.014510844834148884, -0.03120678849518299, -0.06780436635017395, -0.0036002863198518753, 0.0353701189160347, -0.0383552648127079, 0.01026592031121254, 0.029334301128983498, 0.09855010360479355, 0.0005376248736865819, -0.005097353830933571, 0.04142201691865921, 0.0012222606455907226, -0.005344865377992392, 0.0027703566011041403, 0.02478332817554474, 0.028588369488716125, 0.02243523672223091, -0.015654180198907852, -0.00728307431563735, -0.01470076385885477, 0.01221509464085102, -0.022517848759889603, 0.0195353701710701, -0.002691376954317093, 0.04955514892935753, -0.04268341511487961, 0.008578739129006863, 0.05975184589624405, 0.003618374466896057, -0.010659419931471348, 0.018743552267551422, -0.0065913028083741665, 0.012415389530360699, -0.00832438189536333, -0.005741852335631847, 0.015496037900447845, -0.016310423612594604, -0.09150348603725433, -0.04291127622127533, 0.012758529745042324, -0.0030266065150499344, 0.012930366210639477, 0.0019589988514781, -0.024535903707146645, -0.010654022917151451, -0.0009602483478374779, 0.05478919669985771, -0.011615784838795662, 0.04278893023729324, -0.007897109724581242, -0.02142992988228798, 0.021763622760772705, -0.00251160585321486, 0.007062816061079502, -0.034148868173360825, -0.04568814858794212, -0.010504597797989845, 0.035860124975442886, -0.019432460889220238, 0.03296148404479027, -0.014849049970507622, 0.008848000317811966, -0.027068719267845154, 0.029369138181209564, -0.01148644182831049, -0.01137132290750742, -0.03874213621020317, 0.0259074904024601, -0.03659919276833534, -0.01805119961500168, 0.04975813999772072, 0.020741473883390427, -0.015927476808428764, 0.01760553941130638, -0.03148844093084335, -0.043314557522535324, -0.047849200665950775, 0.027370959520339966, 0.0005410800222307444, -0.0453927107155323, 0.0008306532981805503, 0.0033185069914907217, -0.0015664465026929975, 0.03281686455011368, -0.07267725467681885, -0.10379243642091751, -0.00382509408518672, -0.008676009252667427, 0.054901372641325, 0.004583426285535097, -0.02454494684934616, 0.06581722944974899, 0.03096548467874527, -0.022643212229013443, 0.02334016002714634, -0.0037259485106915236, -0.021294444799423218, 0.0005105490563437343, 0.0072324275970458984, 0.028081370517611504, -0.0260666124522686, 0.04854021966457367, -0.008556900545954704, 0.0011367428814992309, 0.05045734718441963, 0.02569926157593727, -0.024810751900076866, 0.01587708480656147, -0.011192680336534977, 0.007985679432749748, 0.02295868843793869, 0.029288899153470993, 0.014458058401942253, 0.005861247889697552, -0.031014205887913704, 0.05825309082865715, -0.007172377314418554, -0.04213450476527214, -0.0012036769185215235, -0.022761929780244827, -0.01854000985622406, -0.018538445234298706, 0.02689351513981819, -0.0037286863662302494, -0.020022006705403328, 0.018628189340233803, 0.0023297439329326153, 0.04350338876247406, -0.0479239784181118, 0.0014990197960287333, 0.058515749871730804, 0.08166734874248505, -0.038108572363853455, -0.08365540206432343, -0.009150698781013489, -0.03369331732392311, -0.03262338414788246, -0.010900366120040417, -0.03969600051641464, 0.0136094456538558, 0.02772781066596508, 0.030285140499472618, -0.034479133784770966, -0.011316819116473198, 0.021792622283101082, -0.07828297466039658, -0.003907548263669014, -0.034788940101861954, 0.01968570426106453, 0.0074763125739991665, -0.0037663031835108995, 0.005947108380496502, -0.033233486115932465, -0.038117099553346634, 0.007882620207965374, -0.051158107817173004, 0.056097954511642456, 0.020920341834425926, -0.038934752345085144, -0.010954165831208229, 0.0009745500865392387, 0.04121250659227371, -0.0312739722430706, -0.02468329481780529, -0.003396191168576479, 0.046633001416921616, -0.05728030204772949, 0.01694364845752716, -0.022921735420823097, 0.02124122530221939, -0.016474101692438126, -0.00799417495727539, 0.021487588062882423, 0.009989291429519653, 0.0562346875667572, 0.05047174543142319, -0.0011970511404797435, -0.022329768165946007, 0.005233293864876032, -0.007450730539858341, 0.017843050882220268, 0.006619565654546022, 0.031068027019500732, 0.043346110731363297, -0.0045659239403903484, 0.00273981224745512, -0.004817741457372904, 0.0013803975889459252, 0.04034273326396942, -0.012613385915756226, -0.01139495987445116, -0.04887985810637474, -0.02468004636466503, 0.005413494072854519, 0.015395290218293667, -0.012514644302427769, 0.03801864758133888, 0.04528992250561714, -0.010489938780665398, -0.05174370855093002, 0.016470862552523613, 0.07081621140241623, -0.020539429038763046, 0.005685680545866489, -0.019629618152976036, -0.002788832411170006, -0.027966538444161415, -0.014817073941230774, -0.0012689311988651752, 0.04986654967069626, -0.02011803165078163, -0.01944529078900814, 0.018285103142261505, -0.019515186548233032, -0.006587241776287556, 0.05155009776353836, -0.0022428862284868956, 0.005445575807243586, 0.022869592532515526, -0.017146963626146317, 0.04110227897763252, 0.040373336523771286, 0.04759510979056358, 0.030362306162714958, -0.02165944315493107, -0.06289229542016983, -0.011401618830859661, 0.01720169559121132, 0.03612326830625534, 0.01328642200678587, -0.007913600653409958, -0.03569059818983078, 0.0111907459795475, 0.024649603292346, -0.045087553560733795, 0.016037367284297943, 0.025619227439165115, -0.005435631610453129, 0.0007061795331537724, -0.04797763749957085, 0.0011995285749435425, -0.00419792952015996, -0.011742901057004929, 0.045007869601249695, -0.018436094745993614, -0.00015000849089119583, -0.03046022541821003, -0.0005029422463849187, 0.05066923052072525, 0.043972697108983994, -0.001215161755681038, 0.009192376397550106, -0.0242017675191164, 0.00075647042831406, -0.0334097295999527, -0.04505410045385361, 0.0186008233577013, -0.028081558644771576, -0.014485841616988182, 0.008354774676263332, -0.021306360140442848, 0.006843211129307747, 0.06292998045682907, 0.04438738524913788, -0.02463260106742382, 0.012455867603421211, -0.04087464511394501, 0.02156112901866436, 0.03614884242415428, -0.002845591399818659, 0.06258034706115723, 0.013101005926728249, -0.02900751866400242, 0.009943841956555843, -0.0163093414157629, 0.03375152871012688, -0.02714904025197029, -0.004358891397714615, -0.01761159673333168, -0.021269408985972404, 0.02544187381863594, 0.035710956901311874, 0.008276977576315403, 0.06076483055949211, -0.01678059995174408, 0.0019526553805917501, -0.027376992627978325, 0.007698778063058853, 0.003364825388416648, 0.011022151447832584, -0.015257567167282104, 0.013097909279167652, 0.0008598803542554379, 0.022869326174259186, 0.005852692294865847, -0.061286382377147675, 0.021291140466928482, -0.006166763603687286, -0.01580391637980938, 0.021448614075779915, -0.009436025284230709, -0.05945902317762375, 0.03301648423075676, -0.03512287512421608, 0.03818821534514427, 0.0009643472149036825, 0.0052887313067913055, 0.024706315249204636, -0.0009615576127544045, -0.019702192395925522, 0.00869632139801979, 0.012739182449877262, 0.03789461776614189, -0.03473319485783577, 0.029142649844288826, -0.027248693630099297, -0.022857706993818283, -0.09759964793920517, -0.016370505094528198, 0.05439294874668121, 0.02039700374007225, -0.037909816950559616, -0.02059863694012165, -0.01419378723949194, -0.005725638009607792, -0.012896114028990269, -0.02172062173485756, 0.01678543910384178, -0.03720777854323387, -0.05719535052776337, -0.021048635244369507, 0.008743458427488804, 0.04759388417005539, 0.0008421115926466882, 0.023059489205479622, 0.0065135592594742775, -0.00877319648861885, -0.030244803056120872, -0.027651546522974968, 0.058406054973602295, -0.03719066455960274, -0.036268848925828934, -0.008052176795899868, -0.015929579734802246, 0.01505229901522398, -0.05291147530078888, -0.021443549543619156, -0.013853084295988083, 0.03601408004760742, 0.017675595358014107, 0.0007066320395097136, 0.01655695028603077, 0.01991688460111618, 0.018703792244195938, -0.007644521072506905, -0.019470086321234703, -0.01794540509581566, 0.043444566428661346, -0.020243395119905472, 0.00436796760186553, 0.0028912441339343786, 0.04057084396481514, 0.06551240384578705, -0.0077832480892539024, -0.011164768598973751, 0.011458097025752068, 0.005119686014950275, 0.028810741379857063, 0.005869142711162567, -0.04708274453878403, 0.008877405896782875, -0.018535878509283066, -0.019643541425466537, -0.020171675831079483, -0.052216269075870514, -0.015439043752849102, 0.040521375834941864, -0.04680090397596359, 0.018067512661218643, -0.006574978120625019, 0.009510766714811325, -0.009815334342420101, 0.02230905555188656, -0.008051687851548195, -0.005112500861287117, 0.007186571601778269, 0.011124277487397194, -0.02208237163722515, -0.026560168713331223, 0.03589676693081856, 0.01961185224354267, 0.015572166070342064, 0.06017912179231644, 0.02660423517227173, 0.008950639516115189, 0.05522855743765831, -0.033022232353687286, -0.0017768838442862034, -0.0028201723471283913, -0.02975969947874546, 0.012858672067523003, -0.0013410013634711504, -0.03199732303619385, 0.07798038423061371, -0.00018942983297165483, -0.03741772845387459, -0.009087692946195602, 0.00025364666362293065, -0.04194320738315582, 0.0000267267350864131, 0.031469229608774185, 0.009184526279568672, 0.03833601251244545, 0.023148123174905777, 0.039667658507823944, 0.014981954358518124, 0.018675941973924637, 0.0026104350108653307, -0.06421162933111191, -0.05139831826090813, -0.01741635426878929, -0.06398685276508331, 0.018392210826277733, 0.028757158666849136, -0.012491319328546524, -0.014619282446801662, -0.026937689632177353, 0.018292928114533424, -0.016209999099373817, 0.07635807991027832, -0.02860242687165737, 0.12313538044691086, 0.01700638420879841, 0.014907567761838436, -0.004040045198053122, 0.003060507820919156, 0.0873698964715004, 0.06466539204120636, 0.034771233797073364, -0.050243817269802094, 0.0038889728020876646, -0.013690794818103313, 0.021724022924900055, -0.042776837944984436, 0.02945205383002758, 0.020692823454737663, -0.008525196462869644, 0.0925605297088623, 0.0036572625394910574, 0.029067249968647957, -0.03502652794122696, 0.07607299089431763, -0.03585875406861305, -0.014093552716076374, 0.0002914454380515963, 0.024418432265520096, 0.007760081440210342, -0.02150217443704605, -0.008617812767624855, 0.0110674062743783, -0.021763209253549576, 0.04329928010702133, 0.028566649183630943, -0.018146488815546036, -0.022690443322062492, -0.009557487443089485, -0.006467820145189762, 0.013581925071775913, 0.043069399893283844, -0.019252127036452293, 0.017440494149923325, -0.018354840576648712, 0.0022487917449325323, -0.006828374695032835, 0.014933804050087929, 0.019776100292801857, 0.012267335318028927, -0.02069137990474701, 0.051472682505846024, 0.0426858551800251, -0.06058988720178604, -0.018078753724694252, -0.048006657510995865, 0.004816512577235699, 0.018141617998480797, 0.038557425141334534, -0.021866941824555397, -0.0060684652999043465, -0.0046671596355736256, -0.031431715935468674, -0.009393859654664993, 0.030491480603814125, 0.028825432062149048, -0.018087130039930344, -0.0144501943141222, 0.0034295690711587667, 0.025451013818383217, 0.009510132484138012, 0.021570971235632896, 0.03959492966532707, -0.02974126674234867, -0.021419566124677658, -0.005748508498072624, 0.02765565738081932, -0.0035426609683781862, 0.010224232450127602, -0.031403131783008575, -0.035028330981731415, -0.014782809652388096, 0.02007107064127922, 0.007049614563584328, -0.023673513904213905, 0.02092810533940792, -0.008604778908193111, 0.017491064965724945, -0.019360283389687538, -0.014981063082814217, 0.047858551144599915, -0.009856338612735271, -0.02244305983185768, -0.02724788710474968, -0.01231064647436142, -0.02140778675675392, -0.0007085188408382237, 0.006558800116181374, 0.01587633043527603, -0.005747328046709299, 0.047734178602695465, 0.021138494834303856, -0.034122295677661896, 0.011687724851071835, -0.006714031100273132, -0.02008303441107273, -0.02899603173136711, -0.012239967472851276, 0.030895868316292763, 0.0017365649109706283, -0.0023493447806686163, 0.001027349615469575, -0.016156813129782677, -0.03617556765675545, -0.03240884467959404, -0.012476074509322643, -0.04598644748330116, -0.006116404663771391, -0.00561869191005826, 0.036753248423337936, -0.014225844293832779, -0.040765345096588135, 0.02669289894402027, -0.01807829551398754, 0.0237050149589777, 0.022137131541967392, -0.024453168734908104, 0.001966595882549882, -0.020423648878932, -0.02082814648747444, 0.02494671940803528, 0.020437760278582573, -0.010344254784286022, -0.02255895733833313, -0.015260283835232258, -0.012701625935733318, 0.00708506815135479, 0.00936596654355526, 0.0023234912659972906, -0.02466956526041031, -0.00416274880990386, 0.04039661958813667, 0.01992771402001381, 0.012658178806304932, 0.016721943393349648, -0.033396072685718536, 0.027287805452942848, -0.046601198613643646, -0.024741675704717636, 0.07744710892438889, -0.03716709837317467, -0.014225483871996403, 0.04254838824272156, 0.02683093771338463, 0.06076066941022873, 0.004188000690191984, 0.00004983209873898886, -0.0024348064325749874, 0.0761207863688469, -0.054129499942064285, -0.0023540628608316183, -0.012586874887347221, 0.02436557598412037, 0.029670709744095802, 0.005836073774844408, -0.04354654997587204, 0.02132401242852211, 0.002703806385397911, -0.020385313779115677, 0.06898275762796402, -0.02248743176460266, 0.020493635907769203, 0.001963430317118764, -0.0033147053327411413, 0.0010625217109918594, -0.015570687130093575, -0.017708946019411087, 0.03247779980301857, 0.043869372457265854, 0.006422366481274366, 0.011674001812934875, -0.01103125512599945, 0.01941484771668911, -0.0636553168296814, 0.0017188136698678136, 0.03897852078080177, -0.0028327463660389185, 0.05494290217757225, -0.04714835435152054, 0.00592933502048254, 0.03501683473587036, -0.05213145539164543, 0.025317363440990448, -0.025969956070184708, -0.010556998662650585, -0.039027173072099686, 0.0354975126683712, -0.011603109538555145, 0.029303863644599915, 0.037842053920030594, 0.007745777722448111, 0.03555182367563248, 0.010351918637752533, -0.003269060980528593, -0.013392552733421326, -0.006551340688019991, 0.058169666677713394, 0.015491294674575329, -0.05589378997683525, 0.04694882780313492, -0.04166296124458313, 0.0020613681990653276, 0.002556766849011183, -0.032911501824855804, -0.013921426609158516, -0.0007510262075811625, 0.01773970201611519, 0.01069692987948656, 0.024947015568614006, 0.06516662240028381, -0.004418797325342894, -0.00018700407235883176, -0.013260179199278355, 0.020836427807807922, 0.02383102849125862, 0.001354495296254754, -0.004974101670086384, 0.04532060772180557, -0.013922824524343014, -0.03678759187459946, 0.016822127625346184, 0.012187596410512924, 0.02110442705452442, 0.01685997284948826, -0.02187173254787922, 0.0409541130065918, -0.03531678020954132, 0.0035327631048858166, -0.05035271495580673, 0.018101409077644348, 0.03950149938464165, -0.001188215333968401, -0.0016319614369422197, -0.005238398909568787, -0.04616965353488922, -0.0477115735411644, 0.022962413728237152, -0.016916127875447273, -0.03752705454826355, -0.05910805985331535, -0.01162717491388321, -0.032616302371025085, 0.020084811374545097, 0.022521907463669777, 0.003714063437655568, -0.030585726723074913, 0.04336883872747421, 0.018277261406183243, 0.012510252185165882, 0.027162032201886177, -0.020911285653710365, 0.014978745020925999, -0.0676412433385849, 0.04152723401784897, -0.00453639542683959, 0.023478543385863304, -0.05302908271551132, -0.0240276288241148, -0.0011869005393236876, 0.005923071876168251, 0.0214704480022192, 0.00022005460050422698, -0.020863648504018784, -0.04348819702863693, 0.012722201645374298, 0.014856254681944847, -0.0655076801776886, 0.012294117361307144, 0.003535338444635272, -0.05060194060206413, -0.012015748769044876, -0.0035628722980618477, 0.026087842881679535, -0.03944883123040199, 0.029931142926216125, -0.013589051552116871, 0.01867574267089367, 0.037318628281354904, -0.03980792686343193, 0.004795008338987827, -0.010425383225083351, -0.011355193331837654, 0.052481092512607574, -0.00207215896807611, 0.00019758737471420318, 0.01830218732357025, -0.0001993994228541851, -0.043493710458278656, 0.05462677776813507, -0.04054401069879532, 0.0288387443870306, 0.02228945679962635, -0.012733522802591324, 0.012449489906430244, -0.0795058161020279, -0.02377445623278618, 0.04600319266319275, -0.02598493918776512, -0.026000667363405228, 0.025606410577893257, -0.0004484675300773233, 0.031761329621076584, -0.02683161199092865, 0.03781841695308685, 0.039238251745700836, 0.010947008617222309, -0.02281622402369976, 0.01325163058936596, -0.0019524148665368557, -0.05156032368540764, 0.04333556815981865, 0.008900231681764126, -0.011673489585518837, 0.04198792576789856, -0.0016255188966169953, 0.00454532029107213, -0.04033820703625679, -0.004440802615135908, 0.032101795077323914, 0.01986261084675789, -0.04008897393941879, 0.03606054559350014, -0.04164057597517967, 0.044934745877981186, 0.04160419851541519, 0.047709833830595016, -0.04078468680381775, -0.014184355735778809, -0.026550251990556717, 0.02379280887544155, 0.024013830348849297, 0.005649825558066368, -0.025694578886032104, 0.0012963496847078204, 0.05061427876353264, 0.03995062783360481, 0.035839445888996124, -0.028093352913856506, 0.02875034138560295, 0.009080861695110798, -0.00836991798132658, -0.010724995285272598, -0.0412161760032177, -0.024674121290445328, -0.011412467807531357, 0.009405381046235561, 0.010968401096761227, -0.0003049093356821686, 0.02251650020480156, -0.013566681183874607, 0.009926867671310902, 0.04629728943109512, -0.012756030075252056, -0.013038258999586105, -0.05101177468895912, 0.037682365626096725, -0.0007862923084758222, -0.038392167538404465 ]
<p>I need some help here.</p> <p>I have some data in which every entry can take one or more levels of a categorical variable. for example, I have a category with 3 levels:</p> <pre><code>entry category 1 A, B, C 2 B 3 C, A, B </code></pre> <p>How should I organized it into a file in order to easily let R discriminate among levels in order to do my analysis. Something like this:</p> <pre><code>Categories entries other_results A 2 ~ B 3 ~ C 2 ~ </code></pre> <p>I thought about doing a comma separated list, as shown in the example 1. But then what should I do in R in order to transform those string into categories?</p> <p>CLARIFICATION: I'd like to avoid creating a column for every level. This variable has many levels and many other variables are already present. This would make the file uselessly big and not readable easily by humans.</p> <p>thanks!</p>
74,412
[ -0.07576494663953781, 0.015402033925056458, -0.015991082414984703, 0.020901205018162727, 0.0010322867892682552, 0.00024072916130535305, 0.010015222243964672, -0.010748801752924919, 0.0446300283074379, -0.01703556813299656, 0.016839854419231415, 0.04557732865214348, 0.052169617265462875, 0.029676541686058044, 0.031191948801279068, 0.006728655193001032, 0.013828695751726627, 0.0027455014642328024, 0.01231585443019867, 0.02130044996738434, -0.017481548711657524, 0.012878257781267166, -0.0036611345130950212, 0.01717587374150753, 0.009509559720754623, 0.04615508019924164, 0.03811877965927124, 0.006885992828756571, 0.016737807542085648, 0.036033473908901215, -0.029436171054840088, -0.055073194205760956, 0.01463390327990055, 0.01233059260994196, 0.043515268713235855, 0.0003076893335673958, -0.04592333734035492, -0.02096419408917427, -0.005273480899631977, 0.00395507225766778, -0.033772166818380356, 0.005766256246715784, 0.015644202008843422, 0.05542649328708649, -0.0030928233172744513, 0.011195425875484943, -0.0021895193494856358, 0.03235887736082077, -0.023997027426958084, -0.05573251098394394, 0.06434161216020584, 0.008411123417317867, 0.03104165755212307, 0.01622186414897442, -0.02986196242272854, 0.017328863963484764, 0.03754212707281113, 0.06833023577928543, 0.007687008008360863, -0.02336777187883854, -0.037926264107227325, -0.04626135528087616, 0.013026255182921886, -0.02743278443813324, -0.0437389612197876, 0.03850181773304939, -0.0019431402906775475, 0.01832040585577488, 0.03706813231110573, -0.04874591901898384, 0.027148569002747536, -0.004533623810857534, 0.033913504332304, -0.03220098093152046, -0.004133736249059439, -0.02431618608534336, 0.04862554371356964, -0.013399994000792503, 0.03660804033279419, 0.04651792719960213, -0.012633247300982475, 0.029374806210398674, -0.007333156652748585, 0.01476313080638647, 0.002091052243486047, 0.02004682831466198, 0.06328367441892624, -0.025753693655133247, 0.014353646896779537, 0.025246283039450645, 0.024794109165668488, -0.004001892637461424, 0.060743298381567, 0.040452998131513596, -0.021307095885276794, 0.027794040739536285, -0.0026402377989143133, 0.0346064418554306, -0.013582714833319187, 0.006022236775606871, 0.011263508349657059, -0.019205784425139427, 0.028360063210129738, 0.023881975561380386, -0.00940481573343277, 0.03939669579267502, -0.05953754484653473, -0.030904021114110947, -0.008518398739397526, -0.004955579526722431, 0.028013821691274643, 0.017969366163015366, 0.02008488029241562, -0.004531850107014179, 0.027131956070661545, -0.06295541673898697, -0.005773481447249651, 0.003955860156565905, 0.04783730208873749, 0.061980221420526505, 0.05638581141829491, -0.0546049140393734, 0.06465520709753036, -0.03460503742098808, -0.0502048023045063, -0.020302223041653633, 0.016089512035250664, 0.013777749612927437, -0.03467528522014618, 0.039386626332998276, -0.04704352468252182, -0.033202819526195526, 0.053726717829704285, -0.034260839223861694, 0.0015281109372153878, -0.01400110311806202, -0.09208916872739792, -0.05164334177970886, 0.010768057778477669, -0.01569070667028427, -0.021863244473934174, -0.06169319525361061, 0.028817985206842422, 0.006013868842273951, 0.015179659239947796, 0.000056072236475301906, 0.025451989844441414, 0.07490811496973038, 0.002283309120684862, 0.015116220340132713, -0.011850849725306034, -0.013827887363731861, -0.02820386178791523, -0.003455675905570388, -0.006784835364669561, -0.052148252725601196, 0.02969687059521675, -0.013392871245741844, -0.004357098136097193, 0.012332429178059101, 0.03508574888110161, -0.03644637390971184, 0.01639334112405777, -0.019881414249539375, 0.027491537854075432, 0.01290958933532238, 0.03721487149596214, -0.005911364685744047, 0.016012415289878845, 0.03715747594833374, 0.0049750059843063354, 0.010252639651298523, 0.026784345507621765, 0.02159779891371727, 0.03785628080368042, -0.02582889050245285, 0.011736338958144188, -0.007510821800678968, 0.015722818672657013, -0.0016920238267630339, -0.009766303934156895, -0.039964381605386734, 0.007940609008073807, 0.0013355272822082043, 0.04915040358901024, 0.019789038226008415, -0.01681014895439148, -0.06835120916366577, 0.04806233569979668, -0.043149467557668686, -0.0272165909409523, -0.06305144727230072, 0.004146959632635117, -0.025074465200304985, -0.03156936541199684, 0.014365848153829575, 0.03385511040687561, 0.03938997536897659, -0.011105089448392391, -0.0037881226744502783, -0.03449143469333649, -0.014636696316301823, -0.007092115003615618, -0.03082405775785446, -0.032255806028842926, 0.03983459621667862, 0.05832170695066452, -0.014962108805775642, 0.0154139194637537, 0.0056222062557935715, 0.00165103271137923, 0.015038725920021534, -0.018780233338475227, 0.039482295513153076, -0.04946969449520111, 0.019432734698057175, 0.03603554889559746, 0.03531372919678688, -0.027526872232556343, 0.026947680860757828, -0.06192833185195923, 0.04583277553319931, 0.04777414724230766, 0.03685346618294716, -0.012218380346894264, -0.038475919514894485, 0.027947239577770233, 0.022084835916757584, -0.021371711045503616, 0.007138569839298725, -0.0643923357129097, 0.01809975691139698, 0.03787355497479439, -0.0017086118459701538, -0.04832588508725166, 0.004979660268872976, 0.027128076180815697, 0.006893767975270748, 0.026856334879994392, 0.05201759934425354, -0.006299028173089027, 0.007668102625757456, 0.01062825322151184, 0.00624672370031476, 0.0015469574136659503, -0.0013967708218842745, 0.03038065880537033, 0.00931566022336483, 0.04108139127492905, 0.003758899634703994, -0.009499847888946533, 0.0467321015894413, -0.013867801055312157, 0.021565936505794525, -0.0010741022415459156, -0.056800805032253265, 0.05147022381424904, -0.051913462579250336, 0.026703784242272377, 0.08047202974557877, 0.018988527357578278, -0.022298920899629593, 0.04990765452384949, -0.002605767920613289, 0.006956667173653841, 0.07371672987937927, -0.050500813871622086, -0.01647915132343769, 0.015207142569124699, -0.04091036319732666, 0.03262221813201904, -0.00595229072496295, -0.03328721597790718, -0.0765451043844223, 0.011052342131733894, 0.014948819763958454, -0.04450789839029312, 0.023072445765137672, -0.033272821456193924, -0.02781224437057972, 0.011764108203351498, -0.030355999246239662, 0.04407187178730965, -0.024156687781214714, -0.05307851731777191, -0.012777489610016346, -0.0004975281190127134, -0.0350240021944046, 0.05079209432005882, -0.011015236377716064, -0.05864562466740608, 0.02472284436225891, -0.014936355873942375, -0.06276171654462814, -0.006049232091754675, 0.007429540157318115, 0.00990175362676382, -0.02082083187997341, -0.026603158563375473, 0.02693590521812439, 0.002123001031577587, -0.014058700762689114, -0.023640751838684082, -0.06137611344456673, -0.032183192670345306, -0.0009688233258202672, 0.02689298614859581, -0.001335791777819395, -0.010220721364021301, -0.005330616142600775, 0.013646487146615982, -0.02488216571509838, 0.012263013049960136, -0.06344690918922424, -0.060318369418382645, 0.014918390661478043, 0.02194148860871792, 0.015650225803256035, 0.012162675149738789, -0.020352104678750038, 0.050757765769958496, -0.0006699619698338211, -0.06396037340164185, -0.06189023330807686, -0.02673846296966076, -0.013593117706477642, 0.016269877552986145, -0.016648069024086, -0.00013837327423971146, 0.018534423783421516, -0.024008791893720627, 0.004435302224010229, 0.04296102747321129, 0.038686465471982956, 0.01655023731291294, -0.020459009334445, 0.017392728477716446, 0.009420891292393208, 0.00013879161269869655, 0.008520646020770073, 0.03322944417595863, -0.01275234017521143, 0.0409713014960289, -0.03804878145456314, -0.003073015483096242, -0.005034237634390593, -0.025878408923745155, -0.02316664345562458, 0.004735710099339485, 0.016497526317834854, -0.017447927966713905, 0.004432087764143944, 0.00006706387648591772, -0.02711968682706356, 0.027649087831377983, 0.042441703379154205, 0.0361311212182045, -0.02758519910275936, 0.014304427430033684, 0.04213663935661316, 0.040682122111320496, -0.037141844630241394, 0.020224623382091522, 0.010920977219939232, -0.01712483912706375, 0.022694816812872887, -0.025079919025301933, -0.0020930967293679714, 0.05916140601038933, 0.021966207772493362, 0.014175666496157646, 0.014287159778177738, -0.026106158271431923, 0.032218221575021744, -0.04447382315993309, 0.019128326326608658, -0.001804160070605576, 0.05228187143802643, -0.006704256404191256, 0.08165521174669266, 0.011165007017552853, -0.03843598812818527, 0.021081682294607162, -0.00025327393086627126, -0.04863511025905609, -0.014197575859725475, 0.002799827605485916, 0.0837317556142807, 0.008230665698647499, -0.009109833277761936, 0.01348356157541275, -0.00400397228077054, -0.016828082501888275, 0.03557440638542175, 0.02215748280286789, -0.006310656666755676, -0.010137884877622128, 0.003114720107987523, 0.011158853769302368, -0.015960659831762314, 0.02397702820599079, 0.027436513453722, 0.021669814363121986, 0.01937357895076275, 0.03139190748333931, -0.016270460560917854, -0.01657218299806118, -0.012708998285233974, -0.0397665798664093, 0.03006560541689396, 0.023011257871985435, 0.001431321376003325, 0.0076028513722121716, -0.00326617737300694, 0.006313320714980364, -0.0440201535820961, 0.008975416421890259, 0.03347466140985489, -0.014379284344613552, 0.020032504573464394, -0.03056998737156391, -0.0021642541978508234, -0.006572868674993515, 0.02236825041472912, 0.002587413415312767, 0.0037435118574649096, 0.031098628416657448, 0.04048594459891319, -0.05379781126976013, 0.053476978093385696, 0.09581556916236877, 0.022154157981276512, -0.023311404511332512, -0.0068833669647574425, -0.03631029278039932, -0.011738037690520287, -0.018826652318239212, 0.03215824067592621, 0.0067541515454649925, -0.012777410447597504, 0.02902328595519066, 0.009335963055491447, -0.03339199721813202, -0.047003112733364105, 0.002547892741858959, -0.006859607063233852, 0.021864833310246468, -0.03705085068941116, -0.042425934225320816, -0.0019635315984487534, 0.06170085817575455, 0.04328541457653046, 0.01115341018885374, -0.025206144899129868, -0.09571921825408936, -0.004221438895910978, 0.03433878347277641, 0.07149209082126617, -0.030321108177304268, -0.00775457127019763, -0.029332701116800308, -0.02527572028338909, 0.056515950709581375, -0.05300043523311615, 0.012142221443355083, -0.02923896536231041, 0.005547010339796543, -0.02007102034986019, -0.026355309411883354, -0.022861257195472717, -0.017323564738035202, -0.04443706199526787, 0.020426219329237938, 0.034878138452768326, -0.02359398826956749, -0.05893193185329437, 0.025191891938447952, 0.004566129297018051, 0.01053023524582386, -0.022778570652008057, -0.010773525573313236, 0.029482752084732056, 0.002365873660892248, -0.05791087448596954, -0.02219511568546295, 0.004494904074817896, 0.01370565127581358, 0.01967044547200203, 0.04608018323779106, 0.008415274322032928, -0.05693647265434265, -0.02958127297461033, 0.01890968531370163, 0.003537704236805439, -0.0018623137148097157, -0.017160633578896523, 0.04040436074137688, -0.012845381163060665, 0.029908034950494766, 0.071494460105896, 0.01580827683210373, 0.0007528164424002171, 0.03046041913330555, -0.031794223934412, 0.034227728843688965, -0.0021552082616835833, -0.04374285414814949, -0.06746642291545868, -0.0008484887075610459, -0.01595357060432434, 0.024085083976387978, -0.025582514703273773, 0.006407684646546841, -0.068336620926857, -0.03923949599266052, 0.03057852014899254, 0.03171061351895332, -0.006322978530079126, -0.031905390322208405, 0.006789047736674547, 0.015155285596847534, 0.00456275325268507, -0.07488872855901718, 0.02256852760910988, -0.02582547999918461, -0.005518642719835043, -0.0041691605001688, -0.05173782631754875, 0.0013538443017750978, -0.025775013491511345, -0.03591608256101608, 0.0254538394510746, -0.03352390602231026, 0.02850211225450039, -0.019975073635578156, 0.059274714440107346, -0.0013155762571841478, -0.06281328201293945, -0.009259594604372978, 0.06479711830615997, -0.02403009682893753, 0.01250434573739767, -0.04879969358444214, 0.04867277294397354, -0.02439044415950775, -0.000031681658583693206, -0.06622989475727081, -0.09477057307958603, 0.017316661775112152, 0.005264999810606241, -0.028274694457650185, -0.03141337260603905, -0.0032841430511325598, -0.012809679843485355, 0.026630522683262825, -0.03866378217935562, 0.032919686287641525, -0.041117891669273376, 0.016868598759174347, 0.007969147525727749, -0.00471344031393528, 0.06140958517789841, 0.05405508726835251, 0.0011065303115174174, -0.006460370030254126, 0.0326959565281868, 0.030148455873131752, -0.027754072099924088, -0.04566698893904686, 0.011829678900539875, -0.04406847804784775, -0.02186710201203823, 0.0144670270383358, 0.026726113632321358, -0.02439914643764496, 0.03188629448413849, -0.0018756706267595291, -0.004926852881908417, -0.018370555713772774, -0.04276779294013977, 0.02758149616420269, -0.014947963878512383, -0.021210405975580215, -0.04591178894042969, 0.021979933604598045, -0.04205869138240814, -0.0015716605121269822, 0.0017484892159700394, -0.017466548830270767, -0.03700453042984009, 0.03915427625179291, 0.057496000081300735, 0.02379228174686432, 0.01285647228360176, -0.020998448133468628, -0.033359818160533905, 0.025967296212911606, 0.031047401949763298, -0.012348095886409283, 0.019564751535654068, 0.03830348700284958, 0.01869509369134903, -0.006106995046138763, -0.004344727378338575, -0.028138041496276855, 0.04151038080453873, 0.02533808909356594, 0.002411874709650874, 0.049732550978660583, 0.007668233942240477, 0.0061379545368254185, -0.036624498665332794, -0.029440810903906822, -0.001988914329558611, 0.041479986160993576, 0.06299345940351486, 0.011261330917477608, 0.04831288754940033, 0.01770682819187641, 0.004694389645010233, -0.006505214609205723, 0.05150608718395233, 0.017384450882673264, -0.01321389339864254, -0.00857139565050602, -0.027689848095178604, -0.05382336676120758, 0.00903997477144003, -0.03691155090928078, 0.007040868513286114, -0.005465326830744743, -0.05215499922633171, 0.0307875107973814, -0.005849302746355534, -0.029902195557951927, -0.05571306496858597, -0.020823044702410698, -0.06026626005768776, 0.06087631359696388, 0.033252108842134476, 0.0037983120419085026, 0.001601836527697742, 0.02501358650624752, 0.040751609951257706, -0.009516817517578602, 0.018066609278321266, -0.009204368107020855, -0.0373430997133255, -0.032337527722120285, -0.05948638916015625, -0.04045579582452774, 0.037448734045028687, 0.04235931858420372, 0.0091084660962224, -0.006059215869754553, -0.04011749103665352, 0.0054154288955032825, 0.0012799063697457314, 0.03824123740196228, -0.013623068109154701, 0.023119531571865082, 0.021482251584529877, -0.0010201805271208286, 0.014152493327856064, 0.010750599205493927, 0.10969758033752441, 0.10655669867992401, 0.058819159865379333, -0.08786933124065399, 0.031991515308618546, 0.03058936819434166, 0.001066718832589686, -0.0008443079423159361, -0.004000226501375437, -0.0057089184410870075, -0.003779672784730792, 0.04537689685821533, 0.06633614748716354, 0.021015865728259087, 0.06261369585990906, 0.07947151362895966, -0.03466668352484703, 0.0066832201555371284, 0.0017599115381017327, -0.0068348124623298645, -0.019760005176067352, -0.005323166958987713, -0.048218030482530594, -0.00427460391074419, 0.05969691276550293, -0.050423964858055115, -0.026978470385074615, 0.016105853021144867, 0.016651354730129242, 0.0010562915122136474, -0.03400498628616333, 0.004322596359997988, -0.0062459004111588, 0.012119216844439507, -0.014032154344022274, -0.005399823654443026, 0.012435447424650192, -0.027172839269042015, -0.002230738988146186, 0.012325998395681381, 0.013423323631286621, 0.01281627919524908, -0.032832179218530655, 0.007950198836624622, -0.048778314143419266, -0.015713738277554512, -0.022351494058966637, 0.007441340479999781, -0.022284185513854027, -0.0012748745502904058, -0.017429480329155922, 0.047156922519207, 0.023124966770410538, -0.01627037487924099, -0.01367215346544981, 0.03925289586186409, 0.017882222309708595, 0.00396051025018096, -0.008035902865231037, -0.03641544654965401, 0.031857628375291824, -0.0400572344660759, 0.031356360763311386, -0.014458464458584785, -0.031064247712492943, -0.006861329544335604, -0.054635971784591675, 0.009545772336423397, 0.008415923453867435, 0.0097566619515419, 0.0018759159138426185, 0.0029735772404819727, -0.021480076014995575, -0.030177827924489975, 0.004985323641449213, 0.008918116800487041, -0.011047138832509518, 0.010239126160740852, -0.018177341669797897, 0.019072111696004868, -0.009215853177011013, 0.006101238541305065, 0.006659434176981449, -0.01268429309129715, -0.011877022683620453, 0.013835527002811432, 0.005082682240754366, -0.0029868020210415125, 0.01951850764453411, 0.053830672055482864, -0.004646593239158392, 0.029442748054862022, -0.0014956826344132423, -0.059850409626960754, -0.0246700718998909, 0.021022483706474304, -0.0342811681330204, -0.00013706415484193712, -0.007738572079688311, 0.05255761370062828, -0.002735784510150552, -0.021165966987609863, 0.019129391759634018, 0.045787129551172256, -0.017262857407331467, 0.0192768145352602, 0.015786364674568176, -0.042817797511816025, 0.04690425470471382, 0.028952693566679955, 0.014946226961910725, -0.018852947279810905, -0.015740783885121346, -0.02362785115838051, -0.026247037574648857, 0.0021777513902634382, -0.03902029991149902, -0.04016575589776039, 0.04467164725065231, -0.025535976514220238, 0.0157148577272892, -0.007873768918216228, 0.013589845038950443, -0.053730182349681854, -0.0035293102264404297, 0.0009112533298321068, -0.06443937867879868, -0.018268894404172897, 0.018054796382784843, -0.029928436502814293, 0.002985126804560423, 0.002558220410719514, 0.020255854353308678, -0.013097367249429226, 0.018152497708797455, 0.025964684784412384, 0.01272371131926775, 0.054269175976514816, -0.008628950454294682, -0.025527825579047203, -0.01626734435558319, -0.06372887641191483, -0.03405141457915306, -0.00465098163112998, -0.030001195147633553, 0.055482108145952225, 0.00963823776692152, -0.010101104155182838, -0.0007399273454211652, 0.06728460639715195, 0.0069423881359398365, -0.03563806414604187, -0.030675770714879036, -0.0027580063324421644, 0.002598241437226534, 0.02119913510978222, -0.021751079708337784, 0.014522512443363667, -0.040764205157756805, 0.023817477747797966, 0.04089618846774101, 0.018581103533506393, -0.030355732887983322, 0.002233062405139208, 0.012152508832514286, 0.039661556482315063, 0.016798023134469986, -0.009815285913646221, 0.03604966402053833, 0.038672756403684616, -0.04847652092576027, 0.0330837219953537, -0.008044382557272911, 0.024038447067141533, -0.07485154271125793, -0.045797377824783325, -0.004583811853080988, -0.012403756380081177, 0.03483607992529869, -0.07223179191350937, -0.010637783445417881, 0.036056265234947205, -0.036075249314308167, 0.02301493100821972, -0.011987719684839249, 0.006054991390556097, 0.0165645033121109, 0.03162815794348717, -0.04937685653567314, 0.009188315831124783, 0.015412848442792892, 0.04641924425959587, 0.04902975261211395, -0.017927315086126328, -0.005364253185689449, -0.05734691023826599, -0.006583218462765217, 0.011364186182618141, 0.0323515310883522, -0.0700899064540863, 0.04285533353686333, -0.021180083975195885, -0.020328249782323837, 0.01853657327592373, -0.024436045438051224, 0.025697367265820503, 0.08289727568626404, -0.00038934178883209825, -0.00044498793431557715, 0.04668152704834938, -0.0027672587893903255, -0.005425780545920134, -0.03456733003258705, 0.0029307741206139326, 0.007524372544139624, 0.008631865493953228, 0.0006432021618820727, -0.013678409159183502, 0.034642066806554794, 0.015561758540570736, -0.018519002944231033, 0.029508167877793312, -0.03828822076320648, 0.028187299147248268, -0.04172263666987419, 0.0053177750669419765, -0.023780161514878273, -0.03397203981876373, 0.0034581529907882214, -0.04617534205317497, 0.05699058994650841, 0.031127793714404106, -0.0038275686092674732, 0.03590460121631622, 0.02448272705078125, -0.012793335132300854, -0.02915407530963421, -0.029955582693219185, 0.016263853758573532, -0.011425716802477837, -0.03048705868422985, 0.0011250486131757498, -0.010896856896579266, -0.026647716760635376, -0.023013129830360413, -0.01515384390950203, -0.01675754226744175, 0.03762729838490486, -0.021413499489426613, 0.011002342216670513, 0.018766630440950394, 0.0015978680457919836, 0.036235373467206955, -0.08107183873653412, 0.0549175962805748, 0.030366066843271255, 0.008776106871664524, -0.05688514932990074, -0.0037234309129416943, -0.0325963981449604, 0.019028956070542336, 0.04331699013710022, -0.014212153851985931, -0.005544483661651611, -0.031471896916627884, 0.04117431491613388, 0.008765575475990772, -0.05408841744065285, 0.019780747592449188, 0.0032079480588436127, -0.02308761328458786, -0.0016528780106455088, -0.026919128373265266, 0.009278944693505764, -0.0016787811182439327, 0.009256652556359768, 0.011173364706337452, -0.019553324207663536, -0.011039438657462597, 0.0012420291313901544, -0.010856644250452518, -0.016223667189478874, -0.01751595549285412, 0.036703355610370636, 0.007023594807833433, -0.014941711910068989, 0.052422862499952316, 0.005687399301677942, -0.02395833469927311, 0.028328321874141693, -0.0273115374147892, -0.002782507799565792, 0.001140186912380159, 0.02558019571006298, 0.014693222008645535, -0.06797061115503311, 0.05606693774461746, -0.01350066065788269, -0.023669157177209854, 0.012357811443507671, 0.05163048207759857, 0.03084835223853588, 0.06946966797113419, 0.0007839896716177464, 0.0196115430444479, 0.006377281621098518, -0.02933264710009098, 0.02252143621444702, 0.02055596373975277, 0.018321072682738304, -0.005494090728461742, 0.026514485478401184, 0.022317606955766678, -0.004626485984772444, 0.010989326983690262, 0.02230723202228546, 0.06086530163884163, -0.017169123515486717, 0.014440353959798813, -0.020516039803624153, -0.02527063898742199, 0.01015343889594078, 0.0031130374409258366, -0.03537134826183319, 0.01608259230852127, -0.03849193826317787, -0.010963711887598038, -0.054156344383955, -0.0024376839864999056, -0.04594535008072853, 0.007833989337086678, -0.017348095774650574, 0.029694372788071632, -0.022335391491651535, 0.036685626953840256, -0.0038938820362091064, 0.00483659515157342, 0.027079539373517036, 0.0001097795320674777, 0.010979794897139072, -0.042613435536623, -0.007368575315922499, -0.003510760609060526, -0.0015785936266183853, -0.030556298792362213, -0.03179125487804413, 0.04130685701966286, 0.00426574656739831, 0.01699165627360344, -0.013861131854355335, 0.018573660403490067, -0.008267716504633427, -0.0006300882087089121, -0.03972441330552101, -0.023465381935238838, -0.0429106168448925, 0.01947624795138836, -0.014854428358376026, -0.005466662812978029 ]
<p>I am trying to analyze a set of nonnegative continuous non-integer data (i.e. the data points are not counts) that are mostly between 0 and 3 whose distribution is highly right-skewed even after log transformation. I am thinking that one possibility may be hurdle model to model the zeros and positive data points separately, but could anyone please suggest other possible choices? Covariates include categorical and non-negative continuous variables.</p>
74,413
[ -0.007192614953964949, -0.006847240962088108, 0.02760113589465618, 0.008410380221903324, 0.035204749554395676, 0.012054424732923508, 0.02452629618346691, -0.0006983637576922774, 0.013926312327384949, -0.052221231162548065, 0.045601584017276764, 0.00230890023522079, 0.003822683123871684, -0.021765265613794327, 0.02553476393222809, 0.012762179598212242, -0.019796550273895264, -0.03003942035138607, -0.03293010592460632, 0.014881053939461708, -0.009035482071340084, 0.009621407836675644, -0.0006177839240990579, 0.020961090922355652, -0.03861207887530327, 0.02115599438548088, 0.04686783254146576, -0.013810399919748306, -0.012924340553581715, 0.030405381694436073, -0.06155358999967575, 0.012668020091950893, -0.033017806708812714, 0.017402738332748413, -0.03006417490541935, 0.037213169038295746, -0.040103040635585785, -0.022682400420308113, -0.03906094655394554, 0.010864230804145336, -0.05567850172519684, 0.0022531282156705856, -0.008064646273851395, 0.010676196776330471, -0.009190277196466923, -0.0005289294058457017, 0.0019353211391717196, -0.02218703366816044, 0.024902287870645523, -0.0389179065823555, 0.09338431805372238, -0.04872437193989754, 0.03618692234158516, 0.03722050413489342, 0.03282822668552399, -0.02388940565288067, 0.05337304249405861, 0.08293125033378601, 0.010274898260831833, -0.031608812510967255, -0.03480629250407219, -0.052277617156505585, -0.006950214505195618, -0.04255783557891846, 0.005900877062231302, 0.011490130797028542, 0.016276448965072632, -0.0629306212067604, 0.02106902003288269, 0.012094448320567608, 0.04214370995759964, 0.00895274244248867, 0.02577660046517849, -0.021066896617412567, 0.020846355706453323, -0.041968535631895065, -0.012362304143607616, 0.025974521413445473, 0.023960864171385765, 0.031299687922000885, -0.008598333224654198, -0.01317876111716032, 0.017662430182099342, 0.028882505372166634, -0.008061621338129044, -0.02559146285057068, 0.06253379583358765, -0.04418517276644707, 0.027017096057534218, 0.029673252254724503, -0.05155419558286667, -0.05441095679998398, 0.05260942131280899, -0.005489277187734842, -0.061885036528110504, 0.045907627791166306, -0.0043879016302526, 0.041492998600006104, 0.007340188603848219, 0.017142267897725105, -0.01409048493951559, -0.02540472336113453, -0.009052693843841553, 0.06409469246864319, -0.006511993706226349, 0.08084588497877121, 0.005519047845155001, -0.012717296369373798, 0.0013870508410036564, -0.023049065843224525, -0.02828625962138176, -0.00031708338065072894, 0.04578034207224846, 0.006101277656853199, 0.01689339429140091, -0.005940482951700687, -0.001439179526641965, -0.05205705016851425, 0.05400116369128227, 0.05466454103589058, 0.030729135498404503, -0.02127527818083763, 0.024464838206768036, -0.007033316418528557, -0.06542802602052689, -0.01707569882273674, 0.0009923860197886825, -0.01263675931841135, -0.025145094841718674, 0.04735954850912094, 0.02226998656988144, -0.02416021004319191, 0.09804321825504303, -0.02099013328552246, 0.04249545931816101, 0.009921741671860218, -0.06031853333115578, -0.05009601637721062, 0.011401309631764889, -0.04622562602162361, 0.005043254233896732, -0.03146626055240631, -0.027170294895768166, 0.016693079844117165, 0.040501125156879425, 0.012990147806704044, 0.007627915591001511, -0.0002868884475901723, 0.023672839626669884, 0.012001709081232548, 0.0021509029902517796, 0.010016930289566517, -0.05788709595799446, -0.012795522809028625, -0.04410553351044655, -0.06877361238002777, 0.024702467024326324, 0.009909624233841896, -0.021509379148483276, -0.02002723701298237, 0.020171483978629112, -0.010846155695617199, -0.01912226900458336, 0.00006023317837389186, 0.01788177713751793, -0.014422186650335789, 0.07848513871431351, -0.006812672596424818, 0.027600198984146118, 0.004358613397926092, 0.04244629666209221, 0.04438359662890434, 0.039976734668016434, 0.07296371459960938, 0.05098961666226387, -0.04642067104578018, 0.008137430995702744, -0.021268466487526894, 0.041183844208717346, 0.009233503602445126, -0.025470079854130745, 0.01412428729236126, -0.01850706897675991, -0.007952294312417507, -0.0027963800821453333, 0.03734511882066727, -0.02067437767982483, -0.028611959889531136, 0.05746755376458168, -0.0431634820997715, -0.009268702939152718, -0.04289231076836586, -0.008624535985291004, -0.009049654006958008, -0.015703851357102394, 0.08030500262975693, 0.01028787437826395, 0.024259844794869423, -0.017358794808387756, 0.013931579887866974, -0.016847528517246246, -0.020645052194595337, 0.03135569766163826, -0.060976292937994, 0.029853099957108498, 0.024026643484830856, 0.035015229135751724, -0.020562421530485153, 0.027996374294161797, -0.01585172861814499, -0.02098105289041996, -0.015758562833070755, -0.023700572550296783, 0.022295303642749786, -0.0019952503498643637, 0.0015913499519228935, 0.009390702471137047, 0.005734364967793226, -0.01977221854031086, 0.015353526920080185, -0.06513307988643646, 0.049040812999010086, 0.0815051719546318, -0.004125687293708324, 0.011725146323442459, 0.0013639152748510242, 0.004843491595238447, 0.017357641831040382, -0.025760583579540253, -0.04196089506149292, -0.02105448767542839, 0.032998111099004745, 0.05964715778827667, 0.01452812273055315, -0.023771990090608597, -0.0017819564091041684, 0.04311957210302353, 0.01574752852320671, 0.0075349099934101105, 0.041699737310409546, -0.02463885396718979, -0.004776134621351957, 0.040025874972343445, -0.005053387023508549, 0.02485169656574726, -0.014933370053768158, 0.022986115887761116, -0.02770032361149788, 0.05214834213256836, -0.02041313238441944, -0.028096899390220642, 0.05455737188458443, 0.025668863207101822, 0.010642736218869686, -0.01658868044614792, -0.008157579228281975, 0.022598419338464737, -0.029462924227118492, -0.008739659562706947, 0.06589603424072266, 0.008581736125051975, -0.0021374572534114122, 0.03166346997022629, -0.017673861235380173, 0.032238710671663284, 0.05337982997298241, -0.03180113434791565, 0.04096922278404236, 0.030062301084399223, -0.0423901341855526, 0.03782955929636955, -0.0032859384082257748, -0.05785873904824257, -0.02221948839724064, -0.004134224262088537, 0.02799871563911438, 0.016874199733138084, 0.02702106535434723, -0.0329572893679142, -0.00759265897795558, 0.017214305698871613, 0.005903980229049921, 0.04707794636487961, 0.039084527641534805, -0.042820725589990616, -0.02233661338686943, -0.024092810228466988, 0.0015784614952281117, 0.04515902325510979, -0.016456829383969307, -0.01777016744017601, 0.0028209795709699392, -0.03906593099236488, -0.012497993186116219, -0.015208377502858639, 0.00820772722363472, -0.02815873734652996, -0.020110605284571648, -0.025478031486272812, 0.051318950951099396, 0.016816304996609688, -0.04035251960158348, 0.020211681723594666, -0.055490683764219284, -0.036768991500139236, -0.024715108796954155, 0.008323678746819496, 0.04205803573131561, -0.0006921302992850542, 0.05210156366229057, -0.0019737468101084232, -0.005165631417185068, 0.021833457052707672, -0.06325677782297134, -0.052882734686136246, -0.002054839162155986, -0.016479620710015297, -0.0016611943719908595, -0.033145125955343246, -0.008797483518719673, 0.033602263778448105, 0.04547939822077751, -0.022928951308131218, -0.05007854849100113, -0.013869991526007652, -0.043589700013399124, 0.0043490249663591385, -0.0009350365144200623, -0.008853113278746605, 0.021575892344117165, 0.008235693909227848, -0.04870644584298134, 0.03969940170645714, -0.0024908825289458036, 0.03356428071856499, -0.024581637233495712, 0.041537605226039886, -0.02283371053636074, -0.0063333348371088505, 0.006237261928617954, 0.02929360419511795, -0.012167994864284992, 0.037546880543231964, -0.010184060782194138, -0.00878708716481924, 0.015337145887315273, -0.05023017153143883, -0.02781645767390728, -0.005428132601082325, 0.011899072676897049, -0.0005037709488533437, 0.006380382459610701, 0.023326711729168892, -0.06132815033197403, -0.04068868234753609, 0.03760971873998642, 0.018284812569618225, -0.019555717706680298, 0.015233664773404598, 0.035299502313137054, 0.037126991897821426, -0.014137517660856247, -0.02476147748529911, 0.004201085772365332, 0.004119160119444132, 0.03142029419541359, -0.004814519081264734, 0.00932630617171526, 0.0019384046318009496, 0.02084301970899105, -0.001732837874442339, 0.010447906330227852, -0.043320514261722565, -0.00917188823223114, -0.018531829118728638, 0.006009378004819155, -0.011271574534475803, 0.03555503487586975, 0.007315979339182377, 0.007371219806373119, 0.013501078821718693, 0.011385442689061165, -0.008927695453166962, 0.02667064219713211, -0.05200601741671562, 0.02314666286110878, -0.013057118281722069, 0.05144105851650238, 0.027765383943915367, 0.022272031754255295, 0.025329407304525375, -0.02841261960566044, 0.0023370180279016495, -0.00029312531114555895, 0.04247656837105751, 0.009452873840928078, -0.015853937715291977, -0.027584198862314224, -0.021654197946190834, -0.016551457345485687, 0.020089130848646164, -0.018530070781707764, -0.04471347853541374, 0.019088221713900566, 0.02084251306951046, 0.005001903045922518, -0.000988452578894794, -0.010868335142731667, 0.0036321666557341814, 0.009269717149436474, 0.08388417214155197, -0.002924382919445634, 0.027246957644820213, -0.0009420650312677026, 0.029801422730088234, -0.019192881882190704, 0.02570774219930172, 0.023069463670253754, 0.01437295600771904, -0.032654304057359695, -0.06766778975725174, -0.05319413170218468, -0.015442995354533195, 0.01836472377181053, 0.049977194517850876, 0.005204569548368454, 0.07564201951026917, 0.02842373214662075, -0.08170007169246674, -0.01671503856778145, 0.07988548278808594, 0.05535620078444481, -0.030615152791142464, 0.0030757419299334288, -0.019847631454467773, 0.009053721092641354, -0.0012260943185538054, 0.017854616045951843, 0.034552209079265594, -0.028103068470954895, -0.01657448336482048, 0.08407168835401535, 0.011951376684010029, -0.0188119038939476, 0.004364664200693369, 0.03178403526544571, 0.07240019738674164, -0.020159823819994926, -0.04288122430443764, 0.048270728439092636, 0.00897776149213314, 0.01930137723684311, 0.017704946920275688, 0.016907406970858574, -0.08841975778341293, 0.028486570343375206, 0.03619839623570442, 0.012518403120338917, -0.03928140550851822, -0.03098488040268421, -0.03337273746728897, -0.0018250492867082357, -0.010694385506212711, -0.06310069561004639, 0.002686037216335535, -0.015525872819125652, 0.02885083295404911, -0.01884102262556553, 0.0030528774950653315, -0.048357535153627396, 0.004065064247697592, -0.007633162662386894, 0.020492399111390114, -0.008180210366845131, -0.021733231842517853, -0.04340057820081711, 0.04346848651766777, 0.0058656479232013226, 0.05564010143280029, -0.005802415776997805, -0.03484252467751503, 0.03906245529651642, 0.030017653480172157, -0.006744413636624813, -0.06198565661907196, 0.0046149748377501965, 0.009591873735189438, 0.009821806102991104, 0.04004747420549393, 0.004506124183535576, -0.048587530851364136, -0.0372835248708725, -0.02018659934401512, -0.00434980820864439, 0.038507360965013504, -0.008471076376736164, 0.02123134955763817, -0.011022278107702732, -0.010109875351190567, 0.055016253143548965, 0.06490600109100342, 0.002361958846449852, -0.006152729503810406, -0.04151764512062073, 0.02422168478369713, -0.028412671759724617, -0.0003914083063136786, -0.056992657482624054, -0.0007424859213642776, -0.02450455166399479, 0.034759946167469025, -0.010768144391477108, 0.06315954029560089, 0.0016988596180453897, 0.001908005098812282, 0.021613502874970436, -0.009278621524572372, 0.013761220499873161, -0.014066891744732857, 0.004940113052725792, 0.011369593441486359, 0.000712954846676439, -0.014324141666293144, 0.016154052689671516, -0.009192788042128086, 0.008232787251472473, -0.010634235106408596, -0.04380907863378525, -0.006239521317183971, -0.048314470797777176, -0.03245086222887039, 0.009277152828872204, -0.027471354231238365, 0.049402955919504166, 0.01451727282255888, 0.01761145517230034, -0.004789920058101416, -0.04787195846438408, -0.003781859064474702, 0.033228110522031784, 0.0034759400878101587, 0.06767973303794861, -0.07073122262954712, 0.011427324265241623, -0.011331163346767426, -0.0016234326176345348, -0.06316252052783966, -0.05087757483124733, 0.021427486091852188, -0.0021540659945458174, 0.0037035697605460882, -0.058701734989881516, -0.016454489901661873, 0.0018744422122836113, -0.02997124381363392, -0.01703827641904354, 0.0873199850320816, -0.01033493410795927, -0.02435513213276863, -0.009224331937730312, 0.03859299048781395, 0.04972729831933975, 0.019583504647016525, -0.014821571297943592, 0.04117026552557945, 0.008786014281213284, -0.014893461018800735, 0.0227301474660635, 0.027002813294529915, 0.0013523834059014916, 0.010582084767520428, -0.027537118643522263, -0.022700373083353043, 0.023073142394423485, -0.056533899158239365, -0.01086269412189722, 0.02880067378282547, 0.018067030236124992, -0.003134054597467184, -0.018686482682824135, 0.018559005111455917, 0.02125045843422413, -0.003252721158787608, -0.03435890004038811, -0.014131935313344002, -0.06332144886255264, -0.01816665753722191, 0.05555311217904091, -0.014576161280274391, -0.020958352833986282, 0.04853363707661629, 0.053320370614528656, 0.053418587893247604, -0.002540007932111621, 0.0055642081424593925, -0.027566587552428246, 0.03042946383357048, 0.001566622988320887, -0.0016830615932121873, 0.001600144780240953, 0.03315780684351921, -0.02481193095445633, -0.0289884302765131, -0.03649097681045532, -0.002810209523886442, 0.04467238113284111, -0.007824101485311985, 0.05767316371202469, 0.03153344988822937, 0.03821892663836479, -0.029871270060539246, -0.002170333405956626, 0.019171176478266716, -0.009960577823221684, 0.008318144828081131, 0.04455207660794258, -0.027500977739691734, 0.03871157765388489, -0.0005527696921490133, 0.009960099123418331, 0.01776370033621788, 0.08910130709409714, 0.00381595641374588, 0.025731896981596947, 0.04873521625995636, -0.022846918553113937, -0.04447462037205696, 0.034939032047986984, -0.052008967846632004, 0.04707501083612442, -0.012470763176679611, -0.03804534301161766, 0.03309432789683342, 0.023131797090172768, 0.01395896915346384, -0.06280143558979034, -0.0222291499376297, -0.08204399794340134, 0.029139848425984383, 0.01940188556909561, -0.03704724460840225, 0.0077353911474347115, 0.003056878689676523, 0.04743842035531998, -0.013379033654928207, 0.0033046468161046505, -0.03822077810764313, -0.06493017822504044, -0.010885938070714474, -0.02536432445049286, -0.021633869037032127, -0.014035406522452831, -0.002799482084810734, 0.00006304663838818669, 0.006333550438284874, -0.006090093404054642, 0.014628349803388119, -0.0020687340293079615, 0.018730653449892998, -0.016697591170668602, 0.030227458104491234, -0.012606651522219181, -0.019725870341062546, -0.007473194971680641, 0.010998918674886227, 0.11285229027271271, 0.11481375992298126, 0.05290086567401886, -0.08626352250576019, -0.007066563703119755, 0.0054579004645347595, 0.020780302584171295, -0.005872729700058699, 0.0079796202480793, 0.029875298961997032, -0.00012131100811529905, 0.03198932483792305, 0.05744070187211037, 0.014884608797729015, 0.029412269592285156, 0.06697877496480942, -0.01035411935299635, -0.04116447642445564, -0.006922293454408646, -0.009409497492015362, 0.029015520587563515, -0.03538715839385986, -0.050829846411943436, 0.027038825675845146, 0.016078399494290352, -0.04520794376730919, -0.010043306276202202, -0.006687894929200411, 0.022618509829044342, -0.008453941904008389, -0.02849196270108223, -0.004189397674053907, 0.02171981893479824, 0.020344169810414314, -0.008785408921539783, -0.0341179221868515, -0.009242155589163303, -0.017075469717383385, 0.02202296443283558, 0.00140922493301332, 0.003423746908083558, -0.0005176662234589458, -0.005162626504898071, 0.015308789908885956, -0.02303077094256878, -0.03171951323747635, -0.0381413996219635, 0.0036278257612138987, -0.011848949827253819, 0.00992320105433464, -0.009478245861828327, 0.008653496392071247, -0.0003927986545022577, -0.030079716816544533, -0.01283103134483099, 0.010966747999191284, 0.039484940469264984, -0.030444489791989326, -0.04236333444714546, 0.004351233132183552, 0.0032227409537881613, 0.007014482747763395, 0.01884947158396244, 0.04642162099480629, -0.05197020620107651, 0.0031972548458725214, -0.016536962240934372, 0.08602713793516159, -0.0039031708147376776, -0.012478302232921124, 0.04513423144817352, -0.01820833794772625, -0.0006069511291570961, 0.025511765852570534, -0.009210251271724701, -0.018178505823016167, 0.018037134781479836, -0.026245510205626488, 0.01064024306833744, -0.03418607637286186, -0.004160337615758181, -0.011021583341062069, -0.03561779111623764, 0.022492563351988792, -0.0370449535548687, -0.03357839211821556, -0.008494539186358452, 0.049198102205991745, 0.026148147881031036, 0.034562088549137115, -0.02186594344675541, 0.041279587894678116, 0.015924137085676193, -0.07435660064220428, 0.00046911928802728653, 0.0004124621336814016, -0.051987744867801666, 0.00459707248955965, -0.03882522135972977, 0.08275681734085083, -0.019412623718380928, 0.016631346195936203, -0.02944941446185112, 0.043544672429561615, -0.002756222616881132, 0.004952036309987307, 0.018976455554366112, -0.05984364449977875, 0.02075406350195408, 0.009429641999304295, 0.02312834933400154, -0.027956122532486916, -0.023638799786567688, 0.008328629657626152, -0.045315004885196686, -0.022635631263256073, 0.009839131496846676, -0.013359325006604195, -0.0035977724473923445, -0.013497967272996902, -0.001631113700568676, -0.022383639588952065, 0.018799936398863792, -0.03165929391980171, 0.013155912049114704, -0.015122713521122932, -0.00457152770832181, 0.016611825674772263, 0.013266444206237793, 0.0171363428235054, 0.0014219617005437613, 0.03984517231583595, -0.018697023391723633, 0.00417971471324563, 0.006736538372933865, -0.003125909250229597, -0.013568999245762825, 0.01428760215640068, -0.03651237487792969, 0.008870460093021393, 0.04285738617181778, -0.03511245176196098, -0.039124030619859695, 0.016321936622262, 0.012303420342504978, 0.026389528065919876, -0.04314923286437988, -0.01723436638712883, -0.017911989241838455, 0.03721398860216141, -0.012620597146451473, -0.04339410364627838, -0.00825212150812149, 0.02130112238228321, -0.038983412086963654, -0.02094760164618492, 0.0006279813824221492, 0.024517014622688293, -0.03395363315939903, 0.05448384955525398, 0.047435224056243896, 0.004689008928835392, -0.00684550404548645, 0.024300547316670418, -0.0072361016646027565, 0.014819401316344738, 0.013515784405171871, 0.02903177961707115, 0.02346225455403328, 0.04634769260883331, -0.05706346780061722, 0.05755332112312317, -0.03980385512113571, 0.023044638335704803, -0.03358864784240723, -0.04547406733036041, 0.04506200924515724, 0.01396454032510519, 0.054414719343185425, -0.06028793007135391, -0.004212650004774332, 0.0028185308910906315, -0.03445575758814812, 0.0008395439945161343, 0.00010689602640923113, -0.014355594292283058, -0.037332769483327866, -0.02876339480280876, -0.0027239699847996235, -0.006100045051425695, 0.03880832716822624, 0.03115236386656761, -0.004405705723911524, 0.04075241833925247, -0.032950785011053085, -0.014260184951126575, -0.0028183157555758953, 0.014631181955337524, 0.01921520195901394, -0.06573835015296936, 0.022245023399591446, -0.06242993474006653, -0.006150784902274609, 0.03533784672617912, -0.006098899058997631, -0.013723775744438171, 0.03181632235646248, 0.02166210487484932, -0.01832558773458004, 0.06519248336553574, 0.04395970329642296, -0.0009478030842728913, -0.006889121141284704, 0.030221233144402504, -0.005727867595851421, 0.029634185135364532, -0.022537577897310257, 0.035439036786556244, 0.041751425713300705, -0.03793805465102196, 0.006984548177570105, 0.005785022862255573, -0.009249298833310604, 0.0077336132526397705, 0.017814766615629196, -0.015934670343995094, 0.021098501980304718, -0.04223279654979706, 0.02971726842224598, -0.05133209750056267, 0.0033394768834114075, 0.028085296973586082, 0.012353749014437199, 0.003221036633476615, 0.002497148234397173, -0.06163312867283821, -0.07088696211576462, -0.01766868866980076, 0.003378282766789198, 0.005394834093749523, -0.05069301649928093, -0.023618659004569054, 0.002217954723164439, -0.02369675785303116, -0.0470244362950325, -0.025586584582924843, -0.0277862586081028, 0.061177026480436325, -0.07746227085590363, 0.0213641170412302, 0.059259239584207535, -0.009575259871780872, 0.010203314013779163, -0.08231951296329498, 0.04736218973994255, 0.02484297566115856, 0.04041711986064911, -0.008926843293011189, 0.0104763712733984, -0.047462329268455505, -0.007961686700582504, 0.04510287195444107, -0.009321251884102821, -0.007329736370593309, -0.021714119240641594, 0.014232034794986248, -0.005193225108087063, -0.012733982875943184, -0.00566214369609952, -0.011741827242076397, -0.02871002070605755, -0.045451756566762924, 0.00043313606875017285, 0.009865906089544296, -0.013385884463787079, 0.0012970217503607273, -0.004895778838545084, 0.0020029270090162754, -0.014955434948205948, -0.026030436158180237, -0.00865986105054617, -0.005492863245308399, -0.023414738476276398, 0.05050177127122879, -0.03548867255449295, -0.00929529219865799, 0.012465198524296284, 0.008106670342385769, -0.05108772963285446, 0.046997372061014175, 0.002452058717608452, -0.03904210031032562, 0.0014395960606634617, 0.0006944884662516415, -0.0006754103233106434, -0.046489279717206955, 0.028634395450353622, 0.019146060571074486, -0.023811638355255127, 0.04768892377614975, 0.018940579146146774, 0.03175005689263344, 0.0323224738240242, -0.005317842122167349, -0.009900746867060661, 0.03342002257704735, 0.0064101628959178925, 0.019573476165533066, 0.008572328835725784, 0.03310146555304527, 0.014981593005359173, -0.004966272506862879, -0.004185413476079702, -0.05887050926685333, 0.053999777883291245, 0.010851157829165459, 0.027987247332930565, -0.00032002406078390777, -0.014002423733472824, 0.03450107201933861, 0.027664287015795708, 0.028696877881884575, -0.019937122240662575, 0.01445423997938633, 0.02833755686879158, 0.008273512125015259, 0.002265756716951728, -0.03114681877195835, -0.022873494774103165, -0.02436414547264576, 0.005208007991313934, -0.01301280315965414, 0.01514498982578516, 0.018991941586136818, -0.013858690857887268, 0.0008281400660052896, -0.03311484307050705, -0.007456577382981777, -0.05356957018375397, 0.028030868619680405, -0.016509918496012688, -0.0005342139047570527, -0.0033051008358597755, -0.03483517840504646, -0.017936300486326218, -0.004682342987507582, -0.009278485551476479, 0.0026317699812352657, 0.03727349266409874, -0.031554803252220154, -0.02172374725341797, -0.016681727021932602, 0.024268023669719696, -0.03233744576573372, -0.02327500283718109, -0.021663689985871315, 0.006948443129658699, 0.009664628654718399, -0.008777392096817493 ]
<p>I am working on a project which requires me to watch video of athletes and measure the straightness/smoothness/waviness, whatever term is acceptable, of their spine. Dividing the spine into segments may also be acceptable if it provides the best results.</p> <p>Right now I can plot x and y points on still images. Not sure what my next step should be. Simple measures like curvature and radius if I made little circles don't work because the subject may be near or far in the image, skewing the results. I would like the output to be some sort of ratio.</p>
37,283
[ -0.010250043123960495, 0.014330733567476273, -0.009532461874186993, -0.021363604813814163, 0.024410467594861984, 0.024649983271956444, -0.04705547168850899, -0.01326263789087534, -0.011720441281795502, 0.012444077990949154, 0.05568208172917366, 0.018307240679860115, 0.028727766126394272, 0.0802343487739563, 0.007456185296177864, -0.015134506858885288, 0.002745075151324272, 0.0035188114270567894, -0.013056033290922642, -0.023115303367376328, 0.014217175543308258, -0.011956349946558475, -0.019242161884903908, -0.028511514887213707, -0.013373100198805332, 0.020217716693878174, 0.03458046168088913, -0.023455198854207993, -0.00728651974350214, 0.05472668260335922, -0.03375984728336334, -0.04276471212506294, 0.01086505874991417, 0.004631868563592434, 0.023950926959514618, -0.01332763396203518, -0.02663414739072323, -0.016944080591201782, -0.02425396628677845, 0.033503398299217224, -0.011036771349608898, 0.01966460421681404, 0.0007645038422197104, 0.04140390828251839, -0.01385500468313694, 0.017846541479229927, -0.02304590865969658, -0.048537276685237885, 0.01708959974348545, -0.030920274555683136, 0.10864847153425217, 0.009706291370093822, 0.03630274534225464, -0.02175750769674778, 0.0064631677232682705, 0.011196923442184925, 0.06067868322134018, 0.06470604240894318, 0.01722142845392227, -0.07072219997644424, -0.016397271305322647, -0.013867143541574478, 0.0014863370452076197, -0.012901689857244492, -0.016297483816742897, -0.018093440681695938, -0.019144145771861076, -0.025437694042921066, 0.05085214599967003, -0.01555405743420124, -0.03339465335011482, 0.0308150015771389, 0.05101614445447922, -0.03608199208974838, -0.009299016557633877, -0.0373455248773098, 0.014051505364477634, -0.0016677664825692773, 0.061955712735652924, 0.010515033267438412, -0.008764409460127354, 0.005428335163742304, -0.007091599516570568, 0.07043495774269104, 0.01446598581969738, -0.0002685711660888046, 0.07040547579526901, -0.04271183907985687, 0.005775790195912123, 0.03526687249541283, 0.011631348170340061, -0.021405715495347977, 0.03524581342935562, 0.023770302534103394, -0.026104772463440895, 0.04968375340104103, -0.015528419986367226, 0.03884943202137947, 0.0003696207713801414, -0.026797132566571236, 0.0025691583286970854, -0.019153812900185585, 0.03015996515750885, 0.0427490696310997, -0.026225782930850983, -0.000012083753063052427, -0.016832780092954636, -0.02675689198076725, 0.0008828257559798658, 0.0007535518379881978, -0.034731507301330566, -0.012731590308248997, 0.01888146996498108, 0.026631632819771767, 0.026293596252799034, -0.016704995185136795, -0.009115614928305149, -0.009059449657797813, 0.0362112931907177, 0.04301390424370766, 0.06645742058753967, -0.026968687772750854, 0.030154826119542122, 0.0026720373425632715, -0.058368019759655, 0.035718414932489395, 0.0020910920575261116, -0.003720281645655632, 0.0125072430819273, 0.04301061853766441, -0.012133155018091202, 0.014138790778815746, 0.049152303487062454, -0.018889857456088066, 0.014766315929591656, 0.00001975969826162327, -0.07223989814519882, -0.04815664514899254, 0.05047006160020828, 0.06161276996135712, -0.007135288789868355, -0.06797249615192413, 0.02976284734904766, 0.035031743347644806, 0.0299457386136055, 0.01739262230694294, 0.04269201308488846, 0.008459904231131077, 0.02376139909029007, -0.03274357318878174, -0.01998777873814106, -0.043768852949142456, -0.014781713485717773, -0.020763276144862175, 0.008549205027520657, -0.03898455202579498, 0.003631426952779293, 0.04840667173266411, -0.012024730443954468, -0.031162597239017487, 0.018328210338950157, 0.001753668300807476, 0.022564494982361794, 0.03557761758565903, -0.0377793051302433, -0.014849544502794743, 0.045883987098932266, -0.03608294576406479, 0.021814770996570587, 0.017133165150880814, -0.01804256998002529, 0.0182227473706007, 0.024294402450323105, -0.008802056312561035, 0.10465782880783081, 0.002233711304143071, 0.008423996157944202, 0.019136633723974228, -0.01103072427213192, 0.05789001286029816, -0.03129313886165619, -0.0660337284207344, -0.022988880053162575, 0.0018219302874058485, 0.0416710190474987, 0.05124583840370178, 0.013365051709115505, -0.02816443331539631, 0.06922696530818939, -0.061218008399009705, -0.02322896383702755, -0.04451948404312134, -0.009270074777305126, -0.006934179924428463, -0.04542969539761543, -0.004386027809232473, 0.0007075928151607513, 0.0005354568129405379, -0.025082305073738098, -0.04747886210680008, 0.012347414158284664, 0.010004482232034206, 0.04602738469839096, -0.02145042084157467, -0.036351706832647324, 0.06480877846479416, 0.027715081349015236, 0.006946411915123463, 0.04357657581567764, -0.020413702353835106, -0.03634662553668022, -0.036253031343221664, -0.050827860832214355, 0.024258218705654144, 0.005924514960497618, 0.026556551456451416, 0.015076405368745327, 0.024396467953920364, -0.03805295750498772, 0.01047982182353735, -0.03222409263253212, 0.08696698397397995, 0.052538853138685226, -0.02782801166176796, -0.0015199037734419107, -0.033832572400569916, 0.016527466475963593, 0.03242717683315277, -0.009983270429074764, -0.027387544512748718, -0.06053999066352844, 0.014716626144945621, 0.025114232674241066, 0.014695496298372746, -0.04404330998659134, 0.007347642909735441, 0.04329085722565651, -0.004095884971320629, 0.042476583272218704, 0.014366135001182556, -0.018041405826807022, -0.006045505404472351, 0.0039812130853533745, -0.00044572068145498633, 0.012469947338104248, 0.014646249823272228, -0.007676173001527786, 0.03796305134892464, 0.04452056437730789, -0.006882599554955959, 0.013748726807534695, 0.030926160514354706, -0.027691448107361794, 0.012277782894670963, 0.014715438708662987, -0.02475043758749962, 0.041778627783060074, 0.02379612810909748, 0.013289770111441612, 0.02641494758427143, 0.0006734664784744382, -0.04552791267633438, 0.019155923277139664, -0.011478503234684467, 0.013034104369580746, 0.09710253030061722, -0.03084462136030197, -0.03413594886660576, 0.030391721054911613, -0.02792920544743538, 0.0010542686795815825, -0.04715091362595558, -0.006374704651534557, -0.05408739671111107, -0.013327647000551224, 0.04879128560423851, 0.04197332635521889, 0.02443351224064827, -0.027026625350117683, -0.009571289643645287, 0.018485333770513535, -0.015833595767617226, 0.013599580153822899, 0.02512930892407894, -0.07300347834825516, 0.0038348259404301643, 0.010729166679084301, -0.015617975033819675, -0.01314147561788559, 0.006927108857780695, 0.016078317537903786, 0.012254860252141953, 0.031056443229317665, -0.04574313014745712, -0.034334078431129456, -0.011975234374403954, 0.04556524008512497, -0.02977924793958664, 0.0012177402386441827, 0.01749216392636299, 0.004114564973860979, -0.028917526826262474, 0.054332002997398376, -0.04542266204953194, -0.013325533829629421, -0.03303897753357887, 0.014385220594704151, 0.0416233204305172, -0.010536889545619488, -0.0005068138125352561, 0.043775398284196854, 0.006017392035573721, -0.006165255326777697, -0.08414007723331451, -0.04351777583360672, 0.05616219341754913, 0.028329873457551003, 0.02313908003270626, 0.027751337736845016, -0.03330739215016365, 0.09665258228778839, 0.003331954125314951, -0.030224628746509552, -0.06373424082994461, 0.011652419343590736, -0.018599309027194977, -0.032092925161123276, 0.007961131632328033, 0.0043190522119402885, -0.023881232365965843, 0.019882865250110626, 0.01381762232631445, 0.026843849569559097, 0.0623149648308754, 0.012624355964362621, -0.007849936373531818, -0.002494586631655693, -0.005648202728480101, -0.018868738785386086, 0.029141854494810104, 0.05644766241312027, -0.03212307393550873, 0.01422740425914526, -0.004239023197442293, 0.009632819332182407, -0.009254834614694118, -0.020177427679300308, 0.018472038209438324, -0.027585593983530998, -0.01468255277723074, -0.0009486318449489772, 0.01747552677989006, 0.013544521294534206, 0.007811696268618107, -0.0055078063160181046, 0.02758319303393364, 0.035295333713293076, -0.0010548651916906238, -0.011921806260943413, 0.07191761583089828, 0.020626820623874664, -0.002585203154012561, -0.012402637861669064, -0.01309295929968357, 0.01277350913733244, 0.009009520523250103, -0.04517189785838127, -0.021877501159906387, 0.04707648232579231, 0.025554819032549858, 0.02721698209643364, 0.019752176478505135, -0.03423145040869713, 0.023296386003494263, -0.03539779782295227, -0.006112928967922926, -0.016496485099196434, 0.056690629571676254, 0.018150918185710907, 0.04647916182875633, 0.044197242707014084, 0.03177640587091446, 0.010022098198533058, -0.01830248348414898, -0.027909807860851288, 0.05625660717487335, -0.007471755146980286, -0.008718104101717472, 0.0029744708444923162, -0.0012280447408556938, 0.009944810532033443, -0.03999722748994827, -0.020985886454582214, -0.002575369318947196, 0.031477104872465134, -0.014229335822165012, -0.02986643835902214, -0.024759972468018532, -0.03289734944701195, -0.015128386206924915, 0.0000280233180092182, 0.012274238280951977, -0.045351069420576096, 0.0250095147639513, 0.006435723043978214, 0.013028867542743683, -0.01949547789990902, -0.03739985078573227, 0.040647756308317184, -0.007529808208346367, 0.037829603999853134, -0.018025506287813187, 0.033457912504673004, -0.03291050344705582, 0.023105114698410034, -0.009365320205688477, 0.04848567396402359, 0.004350550938397646, -0.02819919027388096, -0.02702859230339527, -0.06069359555840492, -0.030891720205545425, -0.007917245849967003, 0.04140482470393181, -0.01202840730547905, -0.05048767104744911, 0.001968903001397848, 0.011161667294800282, -0.05777306482195854, 0.0062722573056817055, 0.060294345021247864, 0.007156641688197851, -0.02513258159160614, -0.07783588021993637, -0.06781985610723495, 0.014465817250311375, -0.01750197820365429, 0.026437317952513695, 0.011095470748841763, 0.01576169952750206, -0.008808569051325321, 0.058438658714294434, -0.000037906156649114564, -0.018664104864001274, 0.025718340650200844, -0.01747511699795723, 0.05822616443037987, -0.0011917827650904655, 0.008777243085205555, 0.0013233430217951536, 0.04329732060432434, 0.08168033510446548, 0.020767875015735626, -0.025817731395363808, -0.0923854187130928, -0.006032336037606001, 0.03804601728916168, 0.024951200932264328, -0.036197587847709656, -0.04340599849820137, -0.05800410732626915, 0.009988648816943169, 0.05399075150489807, -0.01544718723744154, 0.013943306170403957, -0.01918679289519787, 0.002536746207624674, -0.0016709583578631282, 0.007363899145275354, -0.04040374606847763, 0.03209598734974861, -0.011257263831794262, 0.007350703235715628, -0.0180412158370018, -0.033802587538957596, -0.02669135108590126, 0.013345816172659397, 0.012946062721312046, 0.04920599237084389, 0.01838800683617592, -0.0018004075391218066, 0.02347516641020775, 0.0349893793463707, -0.04756007343530655, -0.08109636604785919, 0.013372714631259441, 0.0196831114590168, 0.011973036453127861, 0.032222356647253036, 0.0325193777680397, -0.009867042303085327, 0.0015229610726237297, -0.028408680111169815, -0.006943198852241039, 0.04170409217476845, -0.03351183608174324, 0.05000429227948189, 0.0201418474316597, 0.035153914242982864, 0.0438983291387558, 0.038052938878536224, -0.015508686192333698, -0.01495902519673109, -0.03706705942749977, 0.03275187313556671, 0.013025968335568905, -0.016551880165934563, -0.038293033838272095, -0.022967562079429626, -0.05290235951542854, -0.0015264438698068261, -0.03578183799982071, 0.03903631120920181, -0.03920478746294975, -0.03841239959001541, 0.019649147987365723, 0.021037733182311058, 0.0238802470266819, -0.013056933879852295, 0.046405255794525146, 0.03092322312295437, 0.013210052624344826, -0.009375952184200287, -0.005040642339736223, -0.008095099590718746, 0.003640736686065793, 0.017049673944711685, -0.03975098580121994, -0.0275905542075634, -0.042597781866788864, -0.027360128238797188, -0.011410570703446865, -0.04597108066082001, 0.04952135682106018, -0.0252420362085104, 0.0036370204761624336, 0.042379554361104965, -0.024015814065933228, -0.0009630960412323475, 0.03764953091740608, -0.028408382087945938, 0.023598739877343178, -0.041755326092243195, -0.0060438839718699455, -0.0327964723110199, 0.023841816931962967, -0.03683915361762047, -0.04918559268116951, 0.007261475548148155, -0.026256103068590164, -0.004139597062021494, -0.005605506245046854, 0.014568842016160488, 0.02987625077366829, -0.028938420116901398, 0.007548101246356964, 0.0009450309444218874, -0.033556800335645676, -0.005370659753680229, -0.005895421840250492, 0.017428554594516754, 0.06702670454978943, -0.009387517347931862, -0.0072952513583004475, -0.006894287187606096, 0.01492365077137947, -0.03913382813334465, 0.003935204818844795, 0.04365142062306404, -0.0243007093667984, -0.03561855107545853, -0.010814479552209377, 0.026098111644387245, 0.038535211235284805, 0.010742602869868279, 0.0016395961865782738, -0.02553603984415531, 0.025421451777219772, 0.0036302756052464247, -0.004399982746690512, 0.03029026836156845, 0.004382497631013393, -0.04339870810508728, -0.026969939470291138, 0.018262915313243866, -0.008556006476283073, -0.019408848136663437, 0.05235781893134117, 0.05652439966797829, -0.0016419381136074662, -0.000004640829956770176, 0.05435255914926529, -0.003459151601418853, -0.023122312501072884, 0.02182367444038391, -0.016254333779215813, 0.03752129524946213, 0.044205114245414734, 0.0028366430196911097, 0.010702584870159626, 0.043775662779808044, -0.0500236451625824, 0.0016696907114237547, 0.0009966405341401696, -0.037060849368572235, 0.0790637731552124, 0.037247832864522934, 0.054006367921829224, 0.04828457161784172, 0.003601696342229843, 0.031986333429813385, 0.011521178297698498, -0.026205208152532578, -0.006914603058248758, 0.00833363737910986, 0.05736412853002548, -0.018593087792396545, -0.023897545412182808, 0.000734856235794723, 0.019522249698638916, -0.014009933918714523, 0.022452358156442642, 0.009329365566372871, 0.010222211480140686, 0.032968711107969284, 0.0031335598323494196, -0.0343051515519619, 0.015370113775134087, -0.01017754152417183, 0.05428309738636017, -0.04776629060506821, -0.014847478829324245, 0.059262268245220184, -0.006528237834572792, -0.012463792227208614, -0.013785125687718391, -0.0279643964022398, -0.05075610429048538, 0.0010388505179435015, 0.0382552407681942, -0.05849909037351608, -0.025227978825569153, 0.02971586585044861, 0.029531514272093773, -0.0332246869802475, 0.03506221994757652, -0.026780864223837852, -0.052021484822034836, -0.015493076294660568, -0.0469837412238121, -0.04816651716828346, 0.037304237484931946, 0.02254103310406208, -0.005253502167761326, 0.04874091595411301, -0.005438602063804865, 0.03794097527861595, 0.026237765327095985, 0.0433216467499733, -0.024328675121068954, 0.016443807631731033, -0.010083124972879887, 0.018137887120246887, 0.00006128673703642562, 0.013300534337759018, 0.11762680858373642, 0.07596298307180405, 0.00842052511870861, -0.03891696408390999, 0.0384870283305645, -0.007968062534928322, -0.008435206487774849, -0.004928028676658869, 0.03618602827191353, 0.021953850984573364, -0.007498978171497583, 0.023637190461158752, 0.015491374768316746, -0.005429912358522415, 0.005856985691934824, 0.08497877418994904, -0.0013778816210106015, 0.003737528808414936, 0.01325603574514389, -0.00023964376305229962, -0.008591119199991226, 0.04078078642487526, -0.039111241698265076, 0.047707002609968185, -0.02452724054455757, -0.025550082325935364, -0.03433825820684433, -0.04032811522483826, 0.021921755746006966, 0.011661463417112827, -0.05376509204506874, 0.008447034284472466, 0.003445425070822239, 0.013664735481142998, -0.029798926785588264, -0.008062590844929218, 0.023749124258756638, -0.008122594095766544, -0.006199827883392572, 0.009529750794172287, 0.04201841726899147, 0.02441273257136345, -0.03127073496580124, 0.009450908750295639, -0.007335491478443146, -0.040390633046627045, -0.019050724804401398, 0.013493318110704422, 0.009200402535498142, -0.012477632611989975, -0.03583739697933197, 0.020935699343681335, -0.0003640438080765307, -0.07109463214874268, 0.023376408964395523, 0.016995659098029137, 0.011189119890332222, 0.0001644570002099499, -0.013912733644247055, -0.001537458854727447, 0.005285648163408041, -0.0217918548732996, -0.0000010559009524513385, -0.00613698735833168, -0.016590848565101624, -0.04498882591724396, -0.006400616839528084, 0.035839762538671494, 0.00727097550407052, -0.01812666840851307, -0.0006885884795337915, 0.0058756861835718155, 0.011402595788240433, 0.008234186097979546, -0.0110221728682518, 0.002079224679619074, -0.005128953140228987, 0.02262757532298565, -0.04352226108312607, 0.0054332963190972805, -0.01448204554617405, 0.030399352312088013, -0.011435362510383129, 0.008072376251220703, -0.034988533705472946, -0.0024414360523223877, 0.03659091144800186, 0.03753434121608734, -0.01946214772760868, 0.00842136237770319, -0.03277083486318588, 0.045886728912591934, 0.015155579894781113, -0.009705519303679466, -0.02971035987138748, 0.05087120085954666, -0.032251592725515366, 0.014176741242408752, -0.005419443361461163, 0.09602335095405579, 0.036968741565942764, 0.017337743192911148, -0.010069728828966618, 0.010678336024284363, -0.0018378226086497307, 0.0034301686100661755, -0.00504994997754693, -0.0832611620426178, -0.014031609520316124, -0.019013626500964165, -0.018749510869383812, -0.07390853017568588, 0.009210056625306606, -0.030362343415617943, -0.037119701504707336, -0.030230144038796425, -0.012331550009548664, 0.03223460540175438, 0.0043317233212292194, -0.02891622669994831, -0.0031078625470399857, -0.02597859501838684, -0.00981125421822071, -0.01621428318321705, -0.019960133358836174, -0.0038243138696998358, 0.038975298404693604, -0.023490145802497864, 0.0027487475890666246, 0.014921311289072037, -0.005330014042556286, 0.01786598563194275, -0.01594889909029007, 0.0355699360370636, -0.0005239643505774438, 0.011372318491339684, 0.03836236149072647, 0.025875389575958252, 0.010085337795317173, -0.033877190202474594, 0.005142319947481155, -0.04713786765933037, -0.03953627869486809, 0.01995597779750824, -0.006016582250595093, 0.006776683032512665, 0.010192828252911568, -0.06219681352376938, -0.0006709819426760077, 0.048941511660814285, 0.016401302069425583, -0.029727427288889885, -0.02128947712481022, -0.007957098074257374, -0.010025162249803543, -0.005672528874129057, 0.006585726048797369, -0.03634180873632431, -0.007163104135543108, 0.04338078573346138, -0.005844388622790575, -0.013395051471889019, -0.017553357407450676, -0.021872153505682945, -0.007475151680409908, 0.0026504448615014553, 0.006497151684015989, 0.01659027673304081, 0.06614778935909271, 0.011831224896013737, -0.02965421788394451, 0.027521386742591858, -0.017410261556506157, 0.02272452414035797, -0.051298756152391434, -0.012734468095004559, -0.053701434284448624, -0.011211108416318893, 0.03213492035865784, -0.05851108953356743, -0.016060946509242058, 0.02185312658548355, -0.047811221331357956, 0.034307509660720825, 0.0014364738017320633, -0.0330832414329052, -0.05697881057858467, 0.0062579005025327206, 0.0012100843014195561, 0.02149735577404499, 0.03589291498064995, 0.017585299909114838, 0.022279074415564537, -0.014715964905917645, -0.01616915501654148, -0.017927806824445724, -0.010649750009179115, 0.010316834785044193, 0.02892923727631569, -0.10330758988857269, 0.03850878030061722, -0.007352524437010288, -0.03131620213389397, -0.0007528591086156666, -0.04493388533592224, 0.02192055992782116, 0.0488312654197216, 0.011140822432935238, -0.004854227416217327, 0.03601992875337601, -0.02805451676249504, 0.011925831437110901, -0.011100329458713531, -0.02631712332367897, 0.017789138481020927, 0.0026129570323973894, -0.040530215948820114, 0.010902348905801773, 0.06562220305204391, -0.060754843056201935, -0.05680496618151665, 0.004544898401945829, -0.020475583150982857, -0.026369815692305565, -0.015347328037023544, 0.012574980035424232, 0.01083831675350666, -0.06528817117214203, -0.005122701171785593, -0.036757033318281174, 0.030972551554441452, 0.003129516262561083, -0.04122775048017502, -0.029032420367002487, 0.028066452592611313, 0.01191352866590023, -0.009472712874412537, -0.018553273752331734, 0.015162351541221142, -0.021551333367824554, -0.05588315799832344, 0.018182339146733284, -0.016571398824453354, 0.00313018960878253, 0.008002725429832935, 0.004578214604407549, 0.004587280098348856, 0.012432334944605827, 0.012117737904191017, 0.016412964090704918, 0.04521944746375084, 0.023423371836543083, -0.0746113732457161, -0.07955102622509003, 0.04932117462158203, 0.03456820175051689, -0.04091046005487442, -0.026722654700279236, 0.01860875077545643, -0.03657914325594902, 0.011786338873207569, 0.01590106636285782, 0.013396811671555042, -0.001151768141426146, -0.020659463480114937, 0.03003215789794922, -0.00674288347363472, -0.053899362683296204, -0.0003321142285130918, -0.03156290948390961, -0.050128404051065445, 0.014663244597613811, 0.022964173927903175, -0.016678640618920326, -0.02078160084784031, 0.01371007040143013, -0.001970541663467884, 0.004313071258366108, -0.011517759412527084, -0.005075575318187475, 0.024558546021580696, -0.00107285485137254, -0.03259268403053284, 0.042375557124614716, -0.026296723634004593, -0.008137039840221405, 0.01369852852076292, -0.03270407021045685, -0.03685370460152626, 0.041445162147283554, -0.018724506720900536, -0.014801944606006145, -0.03711437061429024, -0.02934037521481514, 0.008919291198253632, -0.07474446296691895, -0.006863582879304886, 0.03586408495903015, -0.021435577422380447, 0.02748846635222435, 0.02307252585887909, 0.02818121761083603, 0.008043455891311169, -0.03799104318022728, 0.012923900969326496, 0.040231313556432724, -0.049600668251514435, 0.03694264963269234, 0.0162480641156435, 0.01817293092608452, 0.010421876795589924, -0.026384465396404266, 0.00036578011349774897, 0.004621583502739668, 0.05194365233182907, 0.006558327004313469, 0.05169057473540306, 0.0009683764073997736, -0.02181445062160492, -0.016363108530640602, -0.02857285924255848, 0.02949555404484272, 0.010458074510097504, -0.0309276320040226, 0.04746421426534653, -0.02047310583293438, -0.02052423357963562, -0.03877860680222511, -0.023051252588629723, -0.011367692612111568, 0.0075805895030498505, 0.06599176675081253, 0.05081785097718239, -0.023217270150780678, -0.00177468650508672, -0.010694090276956558, -0.006160758435726166, 0.04304167255759239, -0.03496771305799484, 0.035945504903793335, 0.006811243947595358, 0.012800212018191814, 0.04490809887647629, -0.022066181525588036, -0.024956168606877327, -0.003022981807589531, 0.03267444670200348, 0.018423205241560936, 0.005836312659084797, 0.016929050907492638, -0.011315726675093174, -0.043198637664318085, 0.012629610486328602, -0.08481889963150024, -0.06440569460391998, 0.008478202857077122, 0.021693764254450798, 0.020410845056176186, -0.009604053571820259 ]
<p>I have a general question regarding a varying intercept / varying slope model in jags/stan:</p> <p>I have data from a psychophysics experiment, with one covariate, one within-subjects factor and several subjects:</p> <p>The response variable y is binary, and I want to model the probability of giving a response as a function of the (centred) covariate x in all conditions. I think the lme4 model should be:</p> <pre><code>glm_fit &lt;- glmer(formula = y ~ x + (1 | cond/subject), data = df, family = binomial(probit)) </code></pre> <p>where the slope and intercept vary among conditions and among subjects within conditions.</p> <p>The probit link function could be replaced by a logit link.</p> <p>My question is: how do I correctly model the correlations between subjects' interecepts and slopes in all conditions in jags or stan?</p> <p>The data are in long format, and the jags model uses nested indexing for the condition factor. The jags model is:</p> <pre><code>model { # likelihood for (n in 1:N) { # loop over N observations # varying intercept/slope for every condition*subject combination probit(theta[n]) &lt;- alpha[cond[n], subject[n]] + beta[cond[n], subject[n]] * x[n] y[n] ~ dbern(theta[n]) } # priors for (j in 1:J) { # loop over J conditions for (s in 1:S) { # loop over S subjects # each subjects intercept/slope in each condition comes from a # group-level prior alpha[s, j] ~ dnorm(mu_a[j], tau_a[j]) beta[s, j] ~ dnorm(mu_b[j], tau_b[j]) } # non-informative group level priors mu_a[j] ~ dnorm (0, 1e-03) mu_b[j] ~ dnorm (0, 1e-03) tau_a[j] &lt;- pow(sigma_a[j], -2) tau_b[j] &lt;- pow(sigma_b[j], -2) sigma_a[j] ~ dunif (0, 100) sigma_b[j] ~ dunif (0, 100) } } </code></pre> <p>I have left out all correlations between the parameters on purpose. The problem I'm having is that the intercepts and slope are correlated for each subject in each condition, and the intercept/slope pairs are correlated across conditions.</p> <p>Does anyone have any ideas? What is the best way to implement this? </p>
74,414
[ -0.0430595837533474, 0.006796541158109903, 0.03560106083750725, -0.01848548650741577, 0.04791167005896568, 0.034688618034124374, -0.006193956825882196, 0.00953145232051611, 0.023809943348169327, -0.012769085355103016, 0.05566207692027092, 0.0421101450920105, 0.05878950655460358, 0.03275873884558678, 0.04451747611165047, 0.010469891130924225, -0.0068924929946660995, 0.004126298241317272, 0.0011499515967443585, -0.0012062330497428775, -0.019413046538829803, 0.013710281811654568, -0.01805281452834606, -0.023727823048830032, -0.00752321956679225, 0.04856749251484871, 0.006213388871401548, -0.051265813410282135, -0.0007688477053306997, 0.047221072018146515, -0.025567304342985153, -0.014261385425925255, -0.015083758160471916, 0.01251895073801279, -0.02210860513150692, 0.016841283068060875, -0.002327005146071315, 0.012507623992860317, 0.0017689787782728672, 0.03403589874505997, -0.031834181398153305, -0.010822299867868423, -0.023668553680181503, 0.02894114889204502, -0.0009793215431272984, -0.0035588701721280813, -0.0033717683982104063, 0.020676160231232643, 0.0353669635951519, -0.025187455117702484, 0.08863303065299988, 0.001033385400660336, 0.04150647670030594, 0.03064420260488987, -0.04719148948788643, -0.02322058565914631, 0.0722973644733429, 0.05772625654935837, 0.019024508073925972, -0.060123078525066376, -0.01017298549413681, -0.06793765723705292, 0.018791452050209045, -0.02200491353869438, -0.022414974868297577, -0.02119644731283188, 0.024078872054815292, -0.014560364186763763, 0.056313708424568176, -0.011503159068524837, 0.017945418134331703, -0.008593305945396423, 0.02514507621526718, -0.006618228275328875, 0.041893500834703445, -0.04443446919322014, 0.009563202038407326, 0.012642850168049335, 0.016823042184114456, 0.05136342719197273, -0.0416242890059948, 0.016703907400369644, -0.01791289635002613, 0.021326376125216484, 0.019195659086108208, -0.03002275340259075, 0.05111868679523468, -0.028927333652973175, 0.016597986221313477, 0.016908982768654823, -0.05195712670683861, 0.03540962561964989, 0.03918534517288208, 0.035282302647829056, -0.04733690991997719, 0.04012184962630272, -0.0130020035430789, 0.035877663642168045, 0.017881400883197784, -0.01406869851052761, -0.019672678783535957, -0.04289214313030243, -0.02726754918694496, 0.06594465672969818, -0.03425244987010956, -0.008079256862401962, -0.0034369865898042917, -0.014580095186829567, -0.0028956348542124033, -0.04895307868719101, -0.016884107142686844, 0.011313069611787796, -0.026173382997512817, 0.0024248422123491764, 0.024164551869034767, -0.0913185328245163, -0.014598759822547436, 0.007047327701002359, 0.034741904586553574, 0.06755679100751877, 0.03399183973670006, -0.03758513927459717, 0.012168383225798607, -0.006987298838794231, -0.05134056881070137, 0.0067886109463870525, 0.010491721332073212, -0.0031337586697191, -0.008246161043643951, 0.01080248225480318, 0.0034714180510491133, -0.03920841962099075, 0.02719677984714508, 0.016376227140426636, 0.021143831312656403, -0.009071476757526398, -0.059922441840171814, -0.06434161961078644, 0.0253347959369421, -0.021880503743886948, 0.02873443253338337, -0.06449685245752335, -0.006939580198377371, 0.007420326117426157, 0.042088355869054794, -0.005373598542064428, 0.06028717756271362, 0.027103004977107048, 0.023983214050531387, 0.012822402641177177, -0.049620892852544785, -0.013495616614818573, -0.05155763402581215, -0.013744570314884186, -0.02056007646024227, -0.09074127674102783, 0.0533309206366539, -0.008782166987657547, 0.003573254682123661, 0.022562287747859955, 0.04796960949897766, -0.011397306807339191, -0.013700711540877819, -0.022525887936353683, 0.002762097865343094, 0.006636524572968483, 0.03542410582304001, -0.007290471810847521, 0.04527248814702034, 0.018615402281284332, 0.0038226062897592783, 0.007047080900520086, -0.022677797824144363, 0.047416117042303085, 0.012579303234815598, -0.04770265519618988, 0.013491656631231308, 0.004585929214954376, -0.013816827908158302, 0.01054005604237318, -0.022509612143039703, -0.03365283086895943, -0.03633711487054825, -0.04046104475855827, 0.016896717250347137, 0.014588367193937302, -0.00277664209716022, -0.015830298885703087, 0.04651849716901779, -0.017679475247859955, -0.026135306805372238, -0.05518592521548271, 0.0032107625156641006, -0.013118579983711243, -0.040859561413526535, 0.015073060058057308, -0.01080839429050684, 0.04846419394016266, 0.011844035238027573, -0.004225035663694143, -0.0509815476834774, 0.009528574533760548, 0.0273482296615839, -0.01672641560435295, 0.007471758406609297, 0.013302761130034924, 0.03027726337313652, -0.029925283044576645, 0.04438997432589531, -0.011328758671879768, -0.016694266349077225, 0.01647174544632435, -0.009284112602472305, 0.007808214519172907, -0.008430197834968567, -0.014361201785504818, -0.031182214617729187, 0.00016521371435374022, -0.02250279299914837, 0.04616580531001091, -0.08259010314941406, 0.045496728271245956, 0.08113721013069153, -0.029291987419128418, 0.002114664064720273, 0.006249281577765942, -0.018836811184883118, 0.03838689625263214, -0.034645069390535355, -0.004075049888342619, -0.0910584107041359, -0.004971629474312067, 0.051341790705919266, -0.01828727498650551, -0.0072509353049099445, 0.023240864276885986, 0.016658620908856392, -0.012907645665109158, 0.01646200753748417, 0.03025846928358078, -0.003830358851701021, -0.013931425288319588, -0.005595656111836433, 0.01006716676056385, 0.01910572312772274, -0.003500991966575384, 0.016126589849591255, -0.00813104398548603, 0.03628704696893692, -0.0692676231265068, -0.02731718309223652, 0.04364847391843796, -0.007917349226772785, -0.017742618918418884, -0.04863844811916351, -0.024970265105366707, 0.03334866091609001, 0.0036057899706065655, 0.030464177951216698, 0.05018456652760506, 0.01683329977095127, -0.023177308961749077, -0.003051436273381114, -0.03579481318593025, 0.015721255913376808, 0.054495919495821, -0.03319151699542999, -0.018257252871990204, 0.011426465585827827, -0.018451526761054993, 0.045976102352142334, -0.01679062470793724, -0.03264797106385231, -0.032100383192300797, 0.01789676956832409, 0.02339567057788372, -0.014010146260261536, 0.001008758437819779, -0.0727025717496872, -0.0007928643026389182, 0.01545555517077446, -0.011394134722650051, 0.03436260670423508, -0.0027040583081543446, -0.07235178351402283, -0.049584049731492996, -0.03467273712158203, -0.007195407524704933, 0.018523143604397774, 0.012917119078338146, -0.03601394221186638, 0.017940398305654526, -0.015482221730053425, -0.047932934015989304, -0.04626423493027687, -0.010292469523847103, -0.009451056830585003, -0.017752010375261307, -0.02872329019010067, 0.04674481973052025, 0.019620265811681747, -0.048786405473947525, 0.0221870020031929, -0.05402415618300438, -0.028780216351151466, 0.007474766578525305, -0.042297977954149246, 0.023446399718523026, 0.012588058598339558, 0.02346464991569519, 0.03682004660367966, -0.01225170399993658, 0.010533598251640797, -0.07030203193426132, -0.050123024731874466, 0.01611359417438507, 0.023047136142849922, 0.011119105853140354, 0.024113085120916367, 0.012744292616844177, 0.07697170227766037, 0.04305959865450859, -0.014247814193367958, -0.09145548939704895, 0.0068199667148292065, -0.021390024572610855, -0.013675039634108543, 0.015000689774751663, 0.012050345540046692, 0.02989715151488781, -0.00015100918244570494, -0.01648205704987049, 0.017297467216849327, 0.035899966955184937, 0.005239162128418684, -0.0023355823941528797, 0.034122955054044724, 0.007652526255697012, -0.02496398612856865, 0.020497556775808334, 0.034828122705221176, -0.018253188580274582, 0.02943442389369011, 0.0011387511622160673, -0.0005425496492534876, -0.05722374841570854, -0.020234594121575356, 0.022767197340726852, 0.008545455522835255, 0.014752307906746864, -0.06073332577943802, 0.0268692709505558, 0.034200120717287064, -0.051777761429548264, 0.004694478120654821, 0.006865417119115591, 0.05468057096004486, -0.020592888817191124, 0.011580919846892357, 0.04997210577130318, 0.012595906853675842, -0.061101414263248444, 0.010737597942352295, -0.01463725883513689, -0.0021125723142176867, 0.011621752753853798, -0.06379642337560654, 0.014795912429690361, 0.03909466788172722, 0.012688876129686832, -0.010422997176647186, 0.003359355265274644, -0.048484474420547485, 0.0014839792856946588, -0.02495052106678486, -0.006076662335544825, -0.031170375645160675, 0.049645937979221344, 0.038224589079618454, 0.04702884703874588, 0.003486204193904996, -0.018027937039732933, -0.002530293073505163, 0.025272011756896973, -0.06359253823757172, 0.03886568173766136, -0.0181808490306139, 0.006643274333328009, 0.032526757568120956, -0.03806508705019951, 0.036830417811870575, -0.024731699377298355, 0.005133267492055893, 0.014550141990184784, 0.03134984150528908, 0.017767826095223427, -0.005068190861493349, -0.015654731541872025, -0.005908878054469824, -0.018085429444909096, 0.027639606967568398, 0.03008287400007248, 0.020117923617362976, 0.039608776569366455, 0.019916819408535957, 0.014003099873661995, 0.027433671057224274, -0.008532830514013767, -0.004437563940882683, 0.024843309074640274, 0.04220512881875038, 0.003922361880540848, 0.02497732825577259, -0.028355393558740616, 0.004056053701788187, 0.019588273018598557, 0.047227464616298676, 0.08301109075546265, -0.013276243582367897, 0.016658468171954155, -0.035942621529102325, -0.005945668090134859, 0.016583798453211784, 0.0050615957006812096, -0.007627135142683983, -0.008920487016439438, 0.059994518756866455, 0.03576674684882164, -0.04383566975593567, 0.00980913732200861, 0.04995955154299736, 0.018392289057374, -0.0044545563869178295, -0.001676105079241097, -0.0071764676831662655, -0.011164701543748379, 0.025023600086569786, 0.027426503598690033, 0.018354469910264015, -0.01551811397075653, -0.01176918763667345, 0.01975429058074951, -0.020561398938298225, -0.03194562345743179, 0.018881846219301224, 0.027263542637228966, -0.012692960910499096, 0.031643182039260864, -0.04834647849202156, -0.018118467181921005, 0.03680627420544624, 0.01808963343501091, -0.0023095947690308094, -0.011694930493831635, -0.08294150233268738, 0.015600395388901234, 0.05308223515748978, 0.055354222655296326, -0.03561357036232948, 0.0000013689023035112768, -0.047949131578207016, -0.02311798185110092, -0.02547486685216427, -0.04682726040482521, 0.034638818353414536, -0.001278558513149619, 0.038821782916784286, -0.009365294128656387, -0.04545463249087334, -0.07973191887140274, 0.02633783221244812, -0.04134831577539444, 0.012439195066690445, 0.005579423159360886, -0.029225992038846016, -0.006524333264678717, 0.002169705228880048, 0.019648782908916473, 0.049195125699043274, -0.06966635584831238, -0.036585837602615356, 0.03220321610569954, -0.006995766889303923, 0.006131329108029604, -0.0415213443338871, 0.014334616251289845, -0.004486377816647291, -0.004295875318348408, 0.05344056338071823, 0.021164484322071075, -0.02406153455376625, 0.010101697407662868, -0.0011820821091532707, 0.036205798387527466, 0.0025290765333920717, 0.0033774578478187323, 0.05772559344768524, 0.02692635916173458, 0.009093881584703922, 0.023636648431420326, 0.010751173831522465, -0.006984613835811615, -0.0017263272311538458, -0.07056917995214462, -0.000984049984253943, -0.007754683960229158, -0.039524100720882416, -0.05933898314833641, -0.017000263556838036, 0.010262084193527699, 0.04889560863375664, -0.025954676792025566, 0.016909349709749222, -0.050478968769311905, -0.015295188874006271, 0.0016589041333645582, 0.015753572806715965, -0.012113222852349281, -0.013842866756021976, 0.028239384293556213, 0.002738397801294923, 0.0005087750032544136, -0.0213273074477911, 0.036119502037763596, -0.050227027386426926, -0.009737524203956127, -0.008683246560394764, -0.07344309985637665, -0.04870595037937164, -0.007641641888767481, -0.0161878764629364, -0.02176809310913086, -0.035976652055978775, 0.007971788756549358, 0.016754288226366043, 0.051069777458906174, 0.0053252121433615685, -0.037119410932064056, 0.0054437946528196335, 0.02565297856926918, -0.009667182341217995, 0.01613846980035305, -0.014591149054467678, 0.002150089479982853, -0.007097729481756687, 0.008104830048978329, -0.0756862610578537, -0.028339318931102753, 0.02267877385020256, -0.025035344064235687, -0.01963808387517929, -0.030245546251535416, -0.04332250356674194, -0.02227943204343319, 0.022891812026500702, -0.0056211985647678375, 0.030438721179962158, -0.04795437306165695, 0.04828450083732605, -0.037686388939619064, 0.03976525366306305, 0.06500820815563202, 0.010097771883010864, -0.01658754236996174, 0.02121397852897644, -0.03112962283194065, 0.011744430288672447, 0.022581562399864197, -0.035757966339588165, -0.025836646556854248, -0.01476768497377634, -0.014428962953388691, 0.04129888489842415, 0.06558015197515488, 0.014891265891492367, -0.03658778592944145, -0.006549554411321878, -0.008637604303658009, -0.0018104307819157839, -0.0308089479804039, -0.007016652729362249, -0.0015326504362747073, 0.009523885324597359, -0.026796020567417145, 0.006554331164807081, 0.014922574162483215, 0.009938197210431099, 0.011054488830268383, 0.0021974474657326937, -0.007831375114619732, 0.026303492486476898, 0.07677975296974182, 0.007724188268184662, 0.028474897146224976, -0.0037320468109101057, -0.014838592149317265, 0.05305944010615349, 0.013370235450565815, -0.00712914764881134, 0.010942854918539524, 0.010869414545595646, -0.005693495739251375, -0.032065339386463165, -0.04567546769976616, 0.016973495483398438, 0.05368299037218094, -0.007176440674811602, 0.009613461792469025, 0.06972095370292664, -0.014262093231081963, 0.022259676828980446, -0.03544671833515167, 0.0056837317533791065, 0.000972147099673748, 0.02194312773644924, 0.06123129650950432, -0.020622679963707924, -0.02822142280638218, 0.04867400601506233, 0.004359712824225426, 0.043101899325847626, 0.001139455707743764, 0.011980189941823483, 0.0029125588480383158, 0.010416601784527302, 0.03198644891381264, -0.027917098253965378, 0.03137305751442909, -0.039825983345508575, 0.012824933044612408, -0.04994050785899162, -0.050593942403793335, 0.009753233753144741, 0.05295839160680771, 0.01655077561736107, -0.06067677587270737, -0.036562480032444, -0.023936986923217773, 0.01584591343998909, 0.05246035009622574, -0.027011806145310402, 0.016148466616868973, 0.05170350894331932, 0.018637415021657944, -0.018179507926106453, -0.009411477483808994, -0.022819625213742256, -0.10890734940767288, -0.011304782703518867, -0.013500211760401726, -0.007760584354400635, 0.035576898604631424, 0.019359830766916275, -0.022375117987394333, 0.03457585722208023, -0.03404303640127182, 0.031046463176608086, 0.015873683616518974, 0.03604535385966301, 0.005693646147847176, 0.04959526285529137, -0.01296179462224245, 0.03529009222984314, -0.027017632499337196, -0.026059750467538834, 0.13613015413284302, 0.06776676326990128, 0.0272422656416893, -0.06048477068543434, 0.014703771099448204, 0.024263406172394753, -0.023121559992432594, -0.01638917438685894, -0.029998354613780975, 0.025684859603643417, -0.03774944320321083, 0.022160299122333527, 0.02102712355554104, 0.044265419244766235, 0.016362402588129044, 0.04183553531765938, -0.04223053902387619, 0.01480107195675373, -0.014475611038506031, -0.010653404518961906, -0.013865277171134949, 0.0001332293322775513, -0.06916571408510208, 0.011573603376746178, 0.007073338143527508, -0.013226080685853958, -0.057926714420318604, 0.01830737665295601, -0.005203644745051861, 0.008936080150306225, -0.02662271074950695, -0.004081520717591047, -0.0024375703651458025, 0.012600310146808624, 0.0286344513297081, 0.007220134139060974, 0.036281563341617584, -0.03035670891404152, 0.016990486532449722, 0.0326840803027153, -0.029878415167331696, 0.005909041967242956, 0.00480001512914896, -0.013203520327806473, -0.010359132662415504, -0.034960757941007614, -0.01870984025299549, 0.04045916721224785, -0.0046906853094697, -0.036771927028894424, 0.01611855812370777, 0.02212720550596714, 0.04712936282157898, -0.0323755219578743, -0.029916392639279366, 0.03243459761142731, 0.020051976665854454, -0.017461562529206276, -0.005220658611506224, 0.016780823469161987, 0.021525442600250244, 0.015614119358360767, 0.03473459556698799, 0.03562946245074272, -0.00556548498570919, -0.0312638096511364, -0.051302168518304825, 0.02515508234500885, 0.03595466539263725, 0.0037146364338696003, 0.022709310054779053, 0.003250580281019211, -0.017358141019940376, -0.036520816385746, 0.009418736211955547, 0.011761232279241085, 0.018410446122288704, 0.02426992915570736, 0.006059484090656042, -0.034150127321481705, 0.0061305915005505085, -0.01127589400857687, -0.0018789259484037757, 0.002349536633118987, -0.020163316279649734, -0.00006237617344595492, 0.0259966142475605, 0.027261679992079735, 0.016928505152463913, 0.014310624450445175, -0.029415082186460495, 0.052898306399583817, 0.01893313229084015, -0.054897554218769073, -0.0397670641541481, -0.005180047824978828, -0.004764991346746683, -0.026527345180511475, 0.018812913447618484, 0.0535133071243763, 0.014027399010956287, 0.044854454696178436, -0.025176528841257095, 0.053737301379442215, -0.01580650731921196, -0.01681867614388466, 0.023754967376589775, -0.0123139014467597, 0.03275393694639206, -0.02322065643966198, 0.008889051154255867, 0.011834955774247646, -0.008108483627438545, -0.04443410411477089, -0.03521399945020676, 0.012631675228476524, -0.029909595847129822, -0.03108566254377365, -0.0035553097259253263, 0.024664251133799553, -0.00930072646588087, 0.01253932062536478, 0.0009466310730203986, -0.00942279677838087, -0.04024607315659523, -0.023603517562150955, -0.03071470744907856, 0.0011852830648422241, 0.03946194052696228, -0.031282275915145874, -0.023922955617308617, 0.014904122799634933, 0.05640796571969986, 0.03229501470923424, -0.028113743290305138, 0.023566164076328278, -0.004908394068479538, 0.058894265443086624, 0.006631080061197281, -0.040160875767469406, -0.024885332211852074, -0.042165376245975494, -0.01626751758158207, 0.009982564486563206, -0.005227931775152683, 0.01228702999651432, 0.008941464126110077, -0.02638443000614643, -0.014869648031890392, 0.007253128103911877, -0.05010960251092911, 0.01871238835155964, -0.017271073535084724, -0.004117351956665516, 0.008577754721045494, -0.02638617902994156, 0.009700425900518894, 0.04763184115290642, 0.031229421496391296, 0.03964301198720932, 0.04568692669272423, -0.014556185342371464, 0.019690953195095062, 0.021910829469561577, -0.03456892445683479, 0.006325028836727142, -0.008906872943043709, -0.001562414225190878, 0.013299177400767803, 0.05480460822582245, -0.009846245869994164, 0.046708084642887115, -0.01657027192413807, 0.07025910913944244, -0.10093571245670319, -0.042360831052064896, 0.010994967073202133, 0.024550268426537514, 0.058923643082380295, -0.05854048207402229, -0.009213635697960854, 0.038457125425338745, -0.008455089293420315, 0.019043751060962677, 0.03293861448764801, 0.02136286348104477, -0.02543286234140396, 0.01873454637825489, -0.025711538270115852, -0.0034966743551194668, 0.007621087599545717, 0.008044230751693249, 0.016486557200551033, -0.010732418857514858, 0.04944530129432678, -0.021121475845575333, -0.019877102226018906, -0.015865430235862732, 0.03040352277457714, -0.04135965183377266, 0.02668578177690506, -0.0005747133982367814, -0.03797737509012222, 0.012033181264996529, 0.014771557413041592, 0.013008656911551952, 0.018397631123661995, 0.047310300171375275, 0.027087362483143806, 0.0700395330786705, -0.016075868159532547, 0.02617630362510681, 0.016572006046772003, 0.026288000866770744, 0.023365801200270653, 0.036759957671165466, -0.031700458377599716, 0.010921226814389229, 0.0013952096924185753, -0.005985403433442116, -0.03384788706898689, 0.011728089302778244, -0.021322522312402725, -0.015445253811776638, -0.04074336215853691, -0.013763799332082272, -0.017163047567009926, -0.07152238488197327, -0.024253571406006813, -0.05739688128232956, -0.004786656238138676, 0.05703157186508179, 0.04469475895166397, 0.0010887009557336569, -0.01570962928235531, -0.010930786840617657, -0.010847591795027256, -0.009425606578588486, -0.002456397982314229, -0.015678653493523598, -0.01661623641848564, -0.015206283889710903, -0.04646685719490051, 0.003665388561785221, -0.004197039175778627, 0.01576463133096695, -0.07483574002981186, 0.0027053216472268105, -0.041417863219976425, 0.009896229952573776, -0.004678301978856325, 0.008774940855801105, 0.025201670825481415, -0.08421235531568527, 0.05546747148036957, -0.02965836599469185, -0.02997531369328499, -0.056281693279743195, 0.03110598959028721, -0.037019938230514526, 0.037235770374536514, 0.053706079721450806, -0.005388906691223383, 0.05099698156118393, 0.021701687946915627, 0.03650891035795212, 0.01829620636999607, -0.019092582166194916, 0.027072422206401825, 0.02159973233938217, -0.015146015211939812, -0.022515861317515373, 0.0077059147879481316, 0.00769853638485074, 0.0194751787930727, -0.009649253450334072, 0.0016392568359151483, 0.01525928359478712, -0.008178489282727242, -0.011832130141556263, 0.018836110830307007, -0.01986357569694519, -0.026568999513983727, 0.01606554538011551, -0.004812891129404306, 0.015189317986369133, 0.034233417361974716, 0.015184084884822369, -0.05532195419073105, 0.03201815485954285, -0.023651255294680595, -0.03043992817401886, 0.04540504142642021, -0.002318466082215309, 0.010031850077211857, -0.05099281668663025, 0.046006109565496445, 0.023163774982094765, -0.05191771313548088, 0.002352113137021661, 0.0353563129901886, 0.0075031486339867115, 0.04077786207199097, -0.03817935660481453, 0.007732342462986708, 0.010099378414452076, -0.031248806044459343, 0.015142141841351986, 0.020722264423966408, 0.04573153704404831, -0.030084891244769096, 0.008842295035719872, 0.029681742191314697, 0.014233685098588467, 0.0032712272368371487, -0.030605748295783997, 0.04582502692937851, 0.005158199928700924, -0.012529119849205017, 0.041766174137592316, -0.0049985116347670555, -0.005768441595137119, 0.01652708277106285, 0.0024178887251764536, 0.03166583180427551, -0.07464049011468887, -0.0035528631415218115, -0.012001064606010914, -0.010080224834382534, -0.053123537451028824, 0.018451247364282608, 0.020171044394373894, 0.032876014709472656, 0.041077740490436554, 0.0143800750374794, 0.023617004975676537, -0.06327851861715317, -0.00850620400160551, -0.015401261858642101, 0.006123244762420654, 0.03196580335497856, -0.0031880352180451155, 0.00951472856104374, -0.015114285983145237, -0.024477019906044006, -0.031174860894680023, 0.04676041007041931, -0.008365399204194546, 0.010970612056553364, -0.06917429715394974, -0.010872886516153812, 0.0013666328741237521, 0.04935704171657562, -0.039914876222610474, -0.01989876478910446, -0.026112955063581467, 0.030214590951800346, 0.037315092980861664, 0.005260794889181852 ]
<p>If polynomial regression models nonlinear relationships, how can it be considered a special case of multiple linear regression?</p> <p>Wikipedia notes that "Although polynomial regression fits a nonlinear model to the data, as a statistical estimation problem it is linear, in the sense that the regression function $\mathbb{E}(y | x)$ is linear in the unknown parameters that are estimated from the data."</p> <p>How is polynomial regression linear in the unknown parameters if the parameters are coefficients for terms with order $\ge$ 2?</p>
74,415
[ -0.041279736906290054, -0.01218385249376297, 0.012087461538612843, 0.011935276910662651, 0.03059469163417816, 0.042013801634311676, -0.014025941491127014, 0.0005357250920496881, 0.022205332294106483, -0.055232781916856766, 0.03573218360543251, -0.013936556875705719, 0.044151950627565384, -0.023174183443188667, 0.020797112956643105, 0.02504662051796913, -0.024277102202177048, 0.028092142194509506, 0.006493062246590853, 0.02174532040953636, -0.022920727729797363, 0.032939065247774124, 0.009590131230652332, 0.020823203027248383, -0.030687790364027023, 0.05530848726630211, 0.027928367257118225, 0.0014862463576719165, 0.041765209287405014, 0.04524996876716614, -0.0007800398161634803, -0.03263791278004646, 0.020755896344780922, 0.06215270236134529, 0.024997945874929428, 0.011817913502454758, -0.022969281300902367, -0.038467779755592346, -0.0019760895520448685, 0.0570940226316452, -0.03016008622944355, -0.06672050058841705, -0.00024220001068897545, -0.005572140216827393, -0.009802957065403461, -0.002033993136137724, 0.019476143643260002, -0.04144285246729851, 0.017299402505159378, -0.020226173102855682, 0.09162909537553787, 0.000322412553941831, 0.014474555850028992, 0.02723868563771248, -0.031278714537620544, 0.026014110073447227, 0.059797871857881546, 0.08820939064025879, -0.023950008675456047, -0.046199094504117966, -0.0001438378676539287, 0.010911257937550545, 0.019290616735816002, -0.006806548684835434, -0.04342888295650482, 0.02341684140264988, 0.002238677581772208, 0.005237707868218422, -0.013217874802649021, -0.012514868751168251, -0.010892899706959724, -0.0001554147165734321, 0.03661688044667244, -0.02816268987953663, -0.011928441934287548, 0.0007482676883228123, 0.006454318296164274, 0.055439867079257965, 0.051733747124671936, 0.02374996989965439, 0.0002497066743671894, 0.013388496823608875, 0.017811253666877747, 0.022460199892520905, 0.013705994002521038, 0.016319507732987404, 0.050999633967876434, -0.016431527212262154, 0.06262590736150742, -0.009281313978135586, -0.00489870784804225, 0.00963036622852087, 0.02224147878587246, -0.030933914706110954, -0.035935331135988235, 0.020187808200716972, 0.0012544110650196671, 0.015226852148771286, 0.053668826818466187, -0.013704679906368256, 0.015424031764268875, -0.024756401777267456, 0.005321861710399389, 0.047726985067129135, -0.02699027955532074, -0.00812163669615984, -0.021574687212705612, 0.035619594156742096, 0.00269953440874815, -0.018896503373980522, -0.005675887688994408, 0.03895016387104988, 0.011422434821724892, -0.012609710916876793, 0.0066279880702495575, -0.010501210577785969, 0.0255582332611084, -0.015205850824713707, 0.07040604948997498, 0.07857824116945267, 0.0025839628651738167, -0.05604181066155434, 0.033335305750370026, 0.005118541419506073, -0.033362966030836105, 0.016276977956295013, 0.005609837360680103, -0.016972804442048073, -0.041840557008981705, 0.020487762987613678, 0.025649787858128548, 0.011497622355818748, 0.0007050325511954725, 0.013869859278202057, 0.024691786617040634, -0.013457641005516052, -0.10894999653100967, -0.060771334916353226, 0.004643894266337156, -0.013599233701825142, 0.006920186337083578, -0.059068478643894196, 0.02120615728199482, 0.06023537740111351, 0.07752159237861633, -0.009403891861438751, 0.016327790915966034, 0.03686193749308586, 0.023727821186184883, -0.0047481730580329895, -0.020920924842357635, -0.013464481569826603, 0.005182221531867981, -0.048328425735235214, 0.02433929778635502, -0.09095718711614609, 0.013381022028625011, 0.016611848026514053, 0.013456345535814762, 0.0015243574744090438, 0.059997886419296265, -0.009213276207447052, -0.02346755564212799, 0.017480386421084404, 0.03417642414569855, -0.011445622891187668, 0.057472147047519684, -0.008427202701568604, 0.06345362216234207, 0.020780110731720924, 0.024340111762285233, 0.02524469420313835, 0.026013411581516266, 0.08807464689016342, 0.03994142636656761, -0.025696909055113792, -0.03214496374130249, 0.011217914521694183, 0.022803863510489464, 0.03615952655673027, -0.08852031826972961, -0.007075289264321327, 0.015167059376835823, 0.034049659967422485, 0.0012145808432251215, 0.05061360076069832, 0.014946650713682175, -0.00978291966021061, 0.023926828056573868, -0.05296948924660683, -0.02882470190525055, -0.036178912967443466, 0.030839500948786736, -0.028742535039782524, -0.021828141063451767, 0.011063874699175358, -0.006885348353534937, 0.012376639060676098, -0.024731380864977837, -0.02221665345132351, -0.002935737371444702, 0.025102397426962852, 0.034070104360580444, -0.040615689009428024, -0.003133084625005722, 0.051953818649053574, 0.052347972989082336, 0.0017011587042361498, 0.017087286338210106, -0.028325054794549942, -0.03378933295607567, 0.0053672571666538715, -0.05067400261759758, 0.016565660014748573, -0.03865678235888481, -0.04039432853460312, -0.015845248475670815, -0.031437817960977554, -0.029950924217700958, 0.062302421778440475, -0.03869212418794632, 0.03156061843037605, 0.06761367619037628, 0.004806128330528736, -0.020012076944112778, 0.014513971284031868, -0.009874762035906315, 0.006425974424928427, -0.03937418758869171, -0.04336307942867279, -0.04931587725877762, -0.005659600719809532, -0.000011486858966236468, 0.0733146145939827, -0.06205350533127785, 0.03758701682090759, 0.04487438127398491, 0.04686807096004486, 0.00043697169166989625, 0.019055843353271484, -0.015720505267381668, -0.012197835370898247, 0.020221451297402382, 0.019584013149142265, 0.02677295170724392, 0.011041972786188126, 0.02000265195965767, 0.01745867170393467, 0.018243908882141113, 0.006006481591612101, 0.015736259520053864, 0.07308453321456909, -0.010433465242385864, -0.011049419641494751, 0.0014685381902381778, -0.01628676801919937, 0.03452055901288986, -0.03921236842870712, 0.006863792892545462, 0.013841548003256321, 0.011931588873267174, -0.001543235033750534, 0.02867257222533226, 0.036732159554958344, 0.0075444732792675495, -0.0011725155636668205, -0.050720348954200745, -0.00032611776259727776, 0.02015010267496109, -0.05356140807271004, 0.020463941618800163, -0.06466522812843323, -0.02043168433010578, -0.020840534940361977, 0.005274954717606306, 0.005520629230886698, 0.0021408386528491974, 0.03484410420060158, -0.018135998398065567, -0.04548588767647743, -0.0062916455790400505, -0.033923495560884476, 0.019053354859352112, -0.03552619367837906, -0.047142188996076584, 0.0063121868297457695, -0.011863788589835167, 0.011255626566708088, 0.041824474930763245, -0.018955348059535027, 0.014010568149387836, 0.00003212304727640003, -0.040614474564790726, -0.0466151125729084, -0.047998204827308655, -0.059218600392341614, 0.004498662427067757, -0.020779727026820183, -0.05568820610642433, 0.01758747175335884, -0.01934141293168068, -0.036819152534008026, 0.030079523101449013, -0.03895844891667366, -0.004143846221268177, -0.016138501465320587, -0.007935881614685059, 0.012630491517484188, -0.029026901349425316, 0.03509403392672539, 0.010182879865169525, -0.027224982157349586, -0.015624907799065113, -0.07442261278629303, -0.07229641824960709, 0.011535611934959888, -0.014855188317596912, 0.0069294520653784275, 0.01631019078195095, -0.062416981905698776, 0.07146530598402023, 0.030162788927555084, -0.011447840370237827, -0.03625740855932236, 0.01853719726204872, -0.03848008066415787, -0.02434898354113102, 0.04546026140451431, 0.012868926860392094, 0.03167347237467766, 0.04423774033784866, -0.021397531032562256, 0.0042104944586753845, 0.049051981419324875, -0.00645844591781497, 0.008443864993751049, 0.0034862817265093327, 0.013886062428355217, -0.01398274302482605, 0.006374485790729523, 0.03484237566590309, -0.0032951293978840113, 0.04235711693763733, 0.008564263582229614, -0.008610489778220654, 0.013454667292535305, -0.011576518416404724, 0.026172811165452003, -0.024607308208942413, -0.017961042001843452, -0.03668874502182007, 0.02399803325533867, 0.03623300418257713, -0.030720720067620277, 0.0052033597603440285, -0.02293434552848339, 0.008194880560040474, -0.01649666018784046, 0.011966525577008724, 0.00341583788394928, 0.037798333913087845, -0.01665733940899372, -0.010194447822868824, -0.012428749352693558, -0.0038747128564864397, 0.0226579736918211, 0.004836169071495533, 0.0041369120590388775, 0.051682524383068085, 0.012674311175942421, -0.005818613339215517, -0.007882931269705296, -0.004865976981818676, -0.007232612930238247, -0.033476877957582474, 0.004476596601307392, -0.01019348856061697, 0.031121820211410522, -0.007978828623890877, 0.03757883608341217, -0.004581446759402752, -0.014164028689265251, 0.03820224851369858, 0.015896616503596306, -0.07636671513319016, 0.0018812157213687897, -0.02834644354879856, -0.008667565882205963, 0.014054734259843826, -0.025265902280807495, 0.01848611794412136, -0.022665906697511673, 0.0053414516150951385, -0.015407358296215534, -0.018671708181500435, -0.024047423154115677, 0.01731315813958645, -0.016569625586271286, -0.030259914696216583, 0.015495110303163528, 0.012467860244214535, -0.0036561035085469484, -0.043341875076293945, 0.009626854211091995, 0.05668288841843605, -0.022077033296227455, -0.006901613436639309, -0.032586921006441116, -0.00038101538666523993, 0.04236150160431862, 0.02757631056010723, 0.01607643812894821, 0.007544495165348053, -0.02471575140953064, 0.031723085790872574, -0.00022663157142233104, 0.04830515757203102, 0.061408285051584244, -0.004778850357979536, -0.01412363350391388, 0.0006415476673282683, -0.016991909593343735, -0.007877388969063759, -0.006876990664750338, 0.02758045308291912, 0.0022904176730662584, 0.03242996707558632, 0.019184887409210205, -0.049516461789608, 0.032082270830869675, 0.01793019473552704, 0.01563682034611702, 0.0043896702118217945, -0.020933112129569054, -0.008628882467746735, 0.01425099279731512, -0.002407965948805213, 0.0077971708960831165, -0.02345094084739685, -0.017786119133234024, -0.016873955726623535, 0.03922664374113083, -0.029045280069112778, -0.01589502952992916, -0.00754820741713047, 0.03265759348869324, 0.04505818709731102, -0.00951788853853941, -0.033832646906375885, 0.00019057959434576333, 0.03014286980032921, 0.043665822595357895, 0.016077637672424316, -0.005051353480666876, -0.09859131276607513, 0.007569227367639542, 0.008373056538403034, 0.0345742367208004, -0.0420110747218132, -0.001347700017504394, -0.0023564656730741262, -0.004916645586490631, -0.0007434440776705742, 0.0155214574187994, 0.009849884547293186, -0.0031479448080062866, 0.015656495466828346, -0.013359984382987022, -0.03202129900455475, -0.059956952929496765, 0.02334028296172619, -0.007833747193217278, -0.004569344688206911, -0.01618693582713604, -0.003420492634177208, -0.05071539804339409, 0.021835286170244217, 0.02434248849749565, 0.07539293169975281, -0.006790208164602518, -0.008499598130583763, 0.006290027406066656, 0.019651154056191444, -0.02795621193945408, -0.04143083095550537, 0.0435645617544651, 0.010059111751616001, -0.014730826951563358, 0.03684264048933983, -0.010213136672973633, -0.04803546518087387, -0.0006865743198432028, 0.019665630534291267, -0.014884671196341515, 0.005675655324012041, -0.0048649003729224205, 0.0028223663102835417, 0.03288685530424118, 0.02918715588748455, 0.07516982406377792, 0.018850984051823616, -0.016761820763349533, -0.02511552907526493, -0.03830379992723465, 0.033310417085886, -0.04321930930018425, -0.06870651245117188, -0.010611542500555515, 0.006826216820627451, -0.026245875284075737, 0.05607595667243004, 0.008119088597595692, 0.009560073725879192, -0.016189277172088623, -0.023730477318167686, -0.024645576253533363, 0.03175866976380348, -0.003654580796137452, -0.005759531632065773, -0.029216980561614037, 0.0341356061398983, -0.005929739214479923, -0.03775918111205101, 0.0037817901466041803, 0.008971946313977242, 0.024818552657961845, 0.021481908857822418, 0.010645180009305477, 0.012122122570872307, 0.020138071849942207, -0.016720525920391083, 0.013028289191424847, -0.015711655840277672, 0.043263569474220276, -0.016249001026153564, -0.0063417949713766575, -0.0030549459625035524, -0.07075276970863342, -0.010092535056173801, 0.014757208526134491, 0.01462162658572197, 0.00999125000089407, -0.0381125807762146, 0.025368843227624893, -0.008874324150383472, -0.020678333938121796, -0.05448198318481445, -0.07161177694797516, -0.0031654771883040667, -0.01147598959505558, -0.0004105710831936449, -0.007346524391323328, -0.0030394834466278553, -0.028018087148666382, -0.031698282808065414, -0.028015585616230965, 0.05843479931354523, -0.02614242024719715, -0.032509177923202515, 0.005753379315137863, 0.010407598689198494, 0.016102101653814316, -0.003738628700375557, -0.022923575714230537, 0.024390267208218575, -0.024949822574853897, -0.0003859329444821924, -0.0029045073315501213, 0.029524916782975197, -0.01061336975544691, 0.01925850287079811, -0.035598497837781906, -0.024613305926322937, 0.04384317994117737, -0.004878567531704903, -0.022110188379883766, 0.026823611930012703, 0.01746104471385479, -0.0023132909554988146, 0.0041220905259251595, -0.014900143258273602, 0.003957533277571201, 0.035204946994781494, 0.0022320132702589035, -0.026103679090738297, -0.013194139115512371, -0.004800886381417513, 0.056950997561216354, -0.016364531591534615, -0.049867093563079834, 0.011884384788572788, 0.07973503321409225, -0.0006591514684259892, 0.022870786488056183, -0.016659455373883247, -0.013119984418153763, 0.031202424317598343, 0.01594463177025318, 0.0035973787307739258, 0.00509827584028244, 0.0526018925011158, -0.03940342366695404, -0.027901461347937584, -0.030746424570679665, -0.0003883419558405876, 0.0800791084766388, -0.04551498591899872, 0.044954899698495865, 0.04768511280417442, 0.0016590558225288987, 0.005146501120179892, -0.03776209428906441, 0.00896761566400528, -0.005137552507221699, 0.00989355705678463, 0.04182577505707741, -0.015772057697176933, -0.006744490470737219, 0.04155653715133667, 0.00766140129417181, 0.010265117511153221, 0.03174451366066933, -0.009044500067830086, 0.04347250238060951, -0.004306505899876356, -0.013416792266070843, -0.07605008780956268, 0.04179399833083153, -0.022707706317305565, 0.006493132561445236, -0.009252578020095825, -0.041250698268413544, 0.06698095053434372, 0.02966739796102047, 0.034320130944252014, -0.07287298142910004, -0.04441211000084877, -0.03416075557470322, 0.02168998494744301, 0.023697100579738617, 0.015884999185800552, 0.03935050219297409, -0.019734857603907585, 0.01409192755818367, 0.0011305537773296237, 0.05533250793814659, -0.005755837541073561, -0.06916347146034241, -0.024638915434479713, -0.01629852131009102, -0.02562185376882553, 0.014801455661654472, 0.002651972696185112, -0.05530218780040741, 0.004147023893892765, -0.026232343167066574, -0.005847818683832884, 0.032610878348350525, 0.03953781723976135, -0.006571984384208918, 0.04392630606889725, -0.005691192112863064, -0.0363134928047657, -0.015366524457931519, -0.014138591475784779, 0.09886191040277481, 0.08572471886873245, 0.014510154724121094, -0.08237588405609131, 0.013858973979949951, -0.011485397815704346, -0.017044326290488243, -0.04217170551419258, 0.0024181429762393236, -0.000273657962679863, 0.01876409910619259, 0.0383736714720726, 0.0792783722281456, -0.0032546576112508774, -0.012168681249022484, 0.07296666502952576, -0.02012428641319275, -0.026865189895033836, -0.004978811834007502, -0.003318329341709614, 0.007336864713579416, 0.028886983171105385, -0.018614254891872406, -0.00003792706775129773, -0.01756548509001732, 0.0016540338983759284, -0.015096035785973072, -0.02909517101943493, 0.013709185644984245, -0.007817007601261139, -0.03178301453590393, 0.006054151337593794, 0.030146846547722816, -0.012728400528430939, -0.04312315955758095, 0.032366469502449036, -0.005591925699263811, -0.02349162846803665, -0.008033167570829391, 0.010744746774435043, -0.006637150421738625, -0.0051867361180484295, 0.011861616745591164, 0.0009428401244804263, -0.07738624513149261, -0.004284671973437071, -0.03256479278206825, 0.022389965131878853, -0.00047040177742019296, -0.02546520344913006, -0.018042391166090965, -0.002484942553564906, -0.02321208082139492, -0.024097055196762085, -0.03753574937582016, 0.04092496261000633, 0.03859519958496094, -0.0418706052005291, -0.04924629628658295, -0.014806393533945084, -0.010778706520795822, 0.0059666819870471954, 0.011763443239033222, 0.03222697600722313, -0.06520693749189377, 0.0052395593374967575, -0.01662641577422619, 0.016078291460871696, -0.02065919153392315, 0.027733642607927322, 0.006640065927058458, 0.002022496657446027, 0.004376126918941736, -0.0387895293533802, 0.04770351201295853, 0.013028373010456562, 0.023826459422707558, 0.015333476476371288, -0.03288428485393524, -0.01040710136294365, -0.049627915024757385, 0.027567602694034576, -0.005800141021609306, 0.041297491639852524, -0.07252804934978485, -0.008184174075722694, 0.06165900453925133, 0.03803349658846855, 0.017116952687501907, 0.006785318721085787, -0.03481925651431084, 0.006761419586837292, 0.008064419962465763, -0.04086190462112427, -0.0008228978840634227, 0.004876458086073399, -0.005738572683185339, 0.0030430229380726814, -0.00025837839348241687, 0.06209513545036316, 0.055772047489881516, 0.039050184190273285, -0.04115385562181473, 0.0391586497426033, -0.012271152809262276, 0.0013682723511010408, 0.024022269994020462, -0.03744368627667427, 0.03391827642917633, 0.02525620348751545, 0.016731703653931618, -0.030497819185256958, -0.02566404826939106, -0.04241795837879181, -0.031107058748602867, 0.01561747957020998, -0.027839308604598045, -0.030777204781770706, 0.01675969734787941, -0.00836933869868517, 0.03123227320611477, -0.03467467427253723, -0.02531299740076065, -0.04048167169094086, 0.026428237557411194, 0.008083735592663288, -0.0394616536796093, -0.0010646552545949817, -0.018364351242780685, -0.04458263888955116, -0.002009766409173608, 0.06888046860694885, 0.008352282457053661, 0.01492989994585514, 0.006739072501659393, 0.03324111923575401, -0.03184229135513306, 0.043542224913835526, -0.01880665495991707, -0.02546325884759426, 0.048268865793943405, -0.048300839960575104, -0.005368271842598915, 0.01873626932501793, 0.014944863505661488, 0.034493256360292435, 0.025342872366309166, 0.03061283379793167, -0.022863119840621948, 0.009700853377580643, -0.03206871822476387, 0.015395785681903362, -0.014253620989620686, 0.010190439410507679, 0.000311662326566875, -0.04941039904952049, -0.0033666540402919054, -0.009154537692666054, 0.001477847807109356, 0.018361374735832214, 0.057310331612825394, 0.028273990377783775, -0.01543749962002039, 0.017046071588993073, -0.011525556445121765, 0.04410528764128685, 0.019416166469454765, 0.035581860691308975, 0.03676313906908035, 0.029897352680563927, -0.03403966873884201, 0.06933757662773132, 0.011234385892748833, 0.01806442253291607, -0.09414020925760269, -0.018480094149708748, 0.0029997879173606634, 0.009174281731247902, 0.0331568606197834, -0.025422219187021255, -0.03418229892849922, 0.034418992698192596, -0.035353418439626694, -0.023976922035217285, -0.02794739417731762, -0.017246384173631668, 0.0002758855698630214, -0.01802043616771698, -0.05176327005028725, 0.03174261376261711, 0.06006794050335884, 0.02963889017701149, 0.03965279459953308, -0.0017883370164781809, 0.016169177368283272, 0.0018456554971635342, -0.001818479155190289, -0.005062561947852373, -0.011749306693673134, -0.06034407392144203, 0.05060053989291191, -0.02228485979139805, -0.007453994359821081, 0.04861496016383171, -0.019436804577708244, 0.021374745294451714, 0.0507497601211071, 0.010378573089838028, 0.019914496690034866, 0.04432930424809456, 0.015200912021100521, -0.019311565905809402, -0.05015890300273895, -0.006769437808543444, 0.01065477542579174, 0.037003327161073685, -0.03087916411459446, 0.014228221029043198, 0.025523405522108078, -0.003191382857039571, -0.021930469200015068, 0.0004537204513326287, -0.015665458515286446, -0.013821541331708431, 0.0026454529725015163, 0.026317819952964783, -0.02221701666712761, -0.02127349190413952, 0.02702607959508896, -0.035219356417655945, -0.019529854878783226, 0.006362291984260082, 0.058096472173929214, -0.038646623492240906, 0.006677533034235239, 0.006108890287578106, -0.057200103998184204, 0.03852519765496254, -0.004925630521029234, -0.006715431343764067, -0.09381524473428726, 0.002464751247316599, 0.016735868528485298, -0.06269527226686478, -0.023630382493138313, -0.018058521673083305, -0.05949828773736954, 0.06036306172609329, 0.0026181903667747974, -0.010730925016105175, 0.004307708237320185, -0.05783650279045105, -0.012140566483139992, -0.0803896114230156, 0.08626869320869446, 0.021517276763916016, -0.0091890012845397, -0.04116947203874588, 0.01844707876443863, -0.021763363853096962, -0.020315557718276978, 0.03050381876528263, -0.0007778994040563703, 0.014690900221467018, 0.020596997812390327, 0.06402138620615005, -0.004795844200998545, -0.026663506403565407, 0.020514801144599915, -0.006406285800039768, -0.015408959239721298, -0.03153762221336365, -0.025347908958792686, -0.007862400263547897, 0.01107898447662592, 0.01653064414858818, -0.030396386981010437, 0.01809285394847393, 0.011069875210523605, 0.01267214398831129, 0.026363521814346313, 0.016253497451543808, -0.014212201349437237, 0.04785681888461113, -0.010715270414948463, 0.022309163585305214, 0.03749995678663254, 0.003727583447471261, -0.06595348566770554, 0.010711871087551117, -0.005340580828487873, -0.015108210034668446, -0.014883240684866905, 0.005133881699293852, -0.0051207877695560455, -0.03555325046181679, -0.006455897353589535, 0.02819792553782463, -0.04971221834421158, -0.017939532175660133, 0.035619717091321945, -0.004450657870620489, 0.011577853001654148, 0.004216048400849104, 0.006744903977960348, 0.025749480351805687, -0.013955751433968544, 0.028212614357471466, -0.0013386892387643456, 0.05724585801362991, 0.02815549261868, 0.0005071242921985686, 0.017922300845384598, -0.008516781963407993, 0.028635535389184952, 0.004891617689281702, 0.03334246203303337, -0.07984032481908798, -0.03224291652441025, 0.02260994166135788, -0.003096595173701644, 0.02212672308087349, -0.04008368030190468, -0.0058873482048511505, 0.05477772653102875, -0.02808360569179058, -0.016235480085015297, -0.012645837850868702, 0.02065431885421276, -0.015982910990715027, -0.022131863981485367, 0.04563147574663162, 0.03444330394268036, 0.011527586728334427, 0.02483913116157055, -0.01784159056842327, -0.0022870090324431658, 0.048417314887046814, 0.0019175312481820583, -0.013146976009011269, -0.0012251518201082945, -0.04302347078919411, -0.04171813651919365, -0.03772135078907013, -0.026023361831903458, -0.028569327667355537, 0.03675870597362518, 0.022766463458538055, 0.03139137849211693, -0.010209832340478897, -0.0017877720529213548, -0.014749166555702686, 0.05917166545987129, -0.12260472774505615, -0.019642798230051994, -0.023698264732956886, -0.005789760500192642, 0.02364847995340824, -0.03872673586010933 ]
<p>I have been studying Statistics recently, using a few introductory texts. </p> <p>My issue is these texts only seem to provide analysis methods that are suitable to linear relationships: Pearson r correlation coefficients etc. Additionally all the Statistical methods presented seem to be based on the normal Gaussian distribution.</p> <p>My question is what tools, methods and techniques are applicable to the analysis of non-linear, non-Gaussian statistics, with the related question of what resources (particularly books/textbooks) can I use to become acquainted with these procedures?</p>
37,284
[ -0.02934260666370392, -0.0504927895963192, -0.01327499933540821, 0.0094412537291646, 0.05546390265226364, 0.03372800722718239, -0.0062690493650734425, -0.023754674941301346, -0.0012186586391180754, -0.027133800089359283, 0.03576555475592613, 0.01634058728814125, 0.023473748937249184, 0.006744638551026583, 0.02085535041987896, -0.014866270124912262, -0.016597025096416473, -0.01848825439810753, -0.015282169915735722, 0.007206800393760204, 0.0015699375653639436, 0.017309613525867462, -0.016787003725767136, -0.0232914537191391, -0.030291130766272545, 0.053025729954242706, 0.030491281300783157, -0.014953063800930977, 0.036095600575208664, 0.0349997840821743, -0.04130014777183533, 0.015032332390546799, -0.023556869477033615, 0.04522262513637543, 0.01331909280270338, 0.01476045697927475, -0.016562066972255707, -0.046902406960725784, -0.010145902633666992, 0.029387980699539185, -0.073031947016716, -0.04204350709915161, 0.0007995018968358636, 0.040581248700618744, -0.030916918069124222, 0.0260396096855402, 0.021938934922218323, -0.045100077986717224, 0.013867431320250034, -0.05412454530596733, 0.06236350163817406, 0.024273060262203217, 0.040510594844818115, 0.016339261084794998, 0.034165337681770325, 0.02680845372378826, 0.05193401128053665, 0.02693055011332035, -0.02590189501643181, -0.08414602279663086, 0.00027352545293979347, -0.026700245216488838, -0.017699772492051125, -0.042885009199380875, -0.024360157549381256, 0.02912072278559208, -0.015570128336548805, -0.0061952401883900166, 0.0714484453201294, 0.005953863728791475, 0.009991565719246864, 0.04927155375480652, 0.048085253685712814, -0.0061935363337397575, -0.02155078388750553, -0.01607525162398815, 0.007439100183546543, -0.03212806582450867, 0.038695093244314194, 0.04263336583971977, 0.02169819362461567, -0.00512179359793663, -0.016847776249051094, 0.04596853256225586, 0.019734421744942665, -0.03434508666396141, 0.0698222890496254, -0.046096064150333405, 0.014021341688930988, -0.00012803077697753906, -0.011744958348572254, -0.014412778429687023, 0.006122779566794634, 0.013691647909581661, -0.06552567332983017, 0.0404205396771431, -0.017893752083182335, 0.05497143417596817, 0.006476724054664373, -0.028927315026521683, 0.001944629941135645, -0.03277882933616638, 0.024661000818014145, 0.05802907422184944, -0.02730228193104267, -0.05820188671350479, -0.018144525587558746, 0.027215927839279175, -0.005752868950366974, -0.038891978561878204, -0.02080460637807846, 0.013588580302894115, 0.03148013353347778, 0.016013531014323235, 0.0628415197134018, -0.006678280886262655, 0.011363479308784008, -0.033116765320301056, 0.06621161848306656, 0.0846911296248436, 0.019465848803520203, -0.03126133605837822, 0.036080796271562576, 0.002527309115976095, -0.019017815589904785, 0.04144074767827988, 0.021659331396222115, -0.01635950617492199, -0.01995294727385044, 0.06366603076457977, 0.005364041775465012, 0.0025050234980881214, 0.011070339009165764, -0.007890197448432446, 0.02741337940096855, 0.007181265857070684, -0.07079257816076279, -0.045630648732185364, 0.06257643550634384, -0.03587643802165985, -0.018275439739227295, -0.04438423365354538, -0.004652631469070911, 0.023583397269248962, 0.011517081409692764, 0.0139669980853796, 0.03755798563361168, -0.007015652488917112, 0.030240360647439957, 0.006512579973787069, -0.023662293329834938, -0.02364160493016243, -0.009320031851530075, -0.0245919581502676, 0.01395669486373663, -0.1012696772813797, 0.05045415833592415, -0.004759632982313633, 0.014107171446084976, -0.03090166673064232, 0.052062373608350754, 0.010917657986283302, -0.03152204677462578, 0.013757538981735706, -0.003517006291076541, -0.0019246081355959177, 0.08167500793933868, -0.026367854326963425, 0.0501144640147686, 0.017899295315146446, -0.0029762994963675737, 0.04260662943124771, 0.03336913511157036, 0.0393713116645813, 0.07302790880203247, -0.00848350953310728, -0.01621350273489952, -0.00469754496589303, 0.00823211669921875, 0.004623207729309797, -0.028445011004805565, -0.019841015338897705, 0.002727128565311432, 0.00020238329307176173, -0.0006578942411579192, 0.0498913899064064, 0.016864947974681854, -0.018968427553772926, 0.0306500643491745, -0.060329370200634, -0.004364236257970333, -0.06573007255792618, 0.01899014227092266, -0.023615065962076187, -0.0258697047829628, 0.06827674061059952, 0.010006627067923546, 0.03568696230649948, -0.031245972961187363, -0.04028508439660072, -0.0042813615873456, -0.006605811417102814, 0.028220251202583313, -0.0514884777367115, 0.013560938648879528, 0.03255214914679527, 0.03366681560873985, -0.036387570202350616, 0.01444255281239748, -0.04899930581450462, -0.06048853322863579, -0.003147101728245616, -0.03316482529044151, 0.021276824176311493, -0.00413441751152277, -0.023008588701486588, -0.006224968936294317, 0.0193635206669569, -0.027164658531546593, 0.023038147017359734, -0.038275886327028275, 0.04672379419207573, 0.06633465737104416, -0.005183815956115723, -0.03049522079527378, 0.010677117854356766, 0.013640163466334343, 0.017807023599743843, 0.002040086081251502, 0.016255207359790802, -0.04778789356350899, 0.023930484429001808, 0.04813722148537636, 0.03428661450743675, -0.05509049817919731, 0.0062441700138151646, 0.049631476402282715, 0.04274943843483925, 0.015879811719059944, 0.02748659998178482, -0.011950230225920677, -0.054565656930208206, -0.015150132589042187, 0.0000576561942580156, 0.01626805029809475, 0.0005715957377105951, -0.0005220143357291818, 0.023402636870741844, 0.03069279156625271, 0.017848283052444458, -0.011685077100992203, 0.04747610166668892, -0.0148919140920043, -0.010961896739900112, -0.018525106832385063, -0.028835240751504898, 0.0346946120262146, -0.02208089455962181, 0.023047590628266335, 0.026685155928134918, -0.004384803120046854, -0.009900030680000782, 0.026346296072006226, -0.02916020154953003, 0.0014145243912935257, 0.0004650775226764381, -0.0301203615963459, 0.014498566277325153, 0.024359511211514473, -0.055311381816864014, 0.013188466429710388, 0.0018791158217936754, -0.02479741908609867, -0.04472416639328003, -0.02065286971628666, 0.004594489000737667, 0.03035275638103485, 0.03442695736885071, -0.00805354118347168, -0.023308465257287025, 0.011336040683090687, -0.019014915451407433, -0.008196035400032997, 0.008819001726806164, -0.023870043456554413, 0.023114606738090515, -0.0273531973361969, 0.0007175359642133117, 0.018359193578362465, -0.05028125271201134, 0.015670863911509514, 0.01580055058002472, -0.008213751949369907, -0.06046118214726448, -0.02495577558875084, -0.005457710940390825, -0.015236702747642994, -0.04022637754678726, -0.017703374847769737, 0.022130781784653664, -0.03832479566335678, -0.022054312750697136, 0.04743659123778343, -0.06571266055107117, -0.042025238275527954, -0.024164725095033646, 0.016586605459451675, 0.0051032002083957195, -0.03471461683511734, 0.01293354295194149, 0.011724996380507946, -0.029754888266324997, 0.006571189034730196, -0.05565542355179787, -0.047849658876657486, -0.010060627944767475, 0.04164084047079086, 0.0310063436627388, 0.007212852127850056, -0.02159459888935089, 0.047326263040304184, 0.023709861561655998, -0.02997715398669243, -0.033506907522678375, 0.01457825768738985, -0.034596942365169525, -0.007636353839188814, 0.034173306077718735, 0.029255082830786705, 0.014319838024675846, 0.012695909477770329, 0.032639775425195694, -0.005727218464016914, 0.04919609799981117, 0.016868464648723602, 0.018373660743236542, 0.0009821895509958267, -0.022333532571792603, -0.008451363071799278, 0.03294049948453903, 0.029716894030570984, -0.039671365171670914, 0.04203769564628601, 0.020204788073897362, -0.00042450285400263965, 0.03642364591360092, -0.03286019340157509, 0.019121773540973663, -0.012589757330715656, -0.016735706478357315, -0.056265972554683685, 0.003224818268790841, 0.012101474218070507, -0.00860739964991808, 0.045883651822805405, -0.002019016072154045, -0.016268691048026085, -0.01617659255862236, 0.03473498299717903, 0.05163400620222092, 0.033286336809396744, -0.020393503829836845, -0.014119746163487434, -0.014392610639333725, -0.013174117542803288, 0.018467828631401062, -0.01172947883605957, 0.0031867725774645805, 0.059752196073532104, 0.024369124323129654, -0.013977857306599617, -0.0006218533962965012, -0.02357838675379753, 0.0007829474634490907, -0.05383908376097679, -0.007695375941693783, -0.02221197448670864, 0.027391597628593445, -0.006649657152593136, 0.03532325103878975, 0.006782460026443005, 0.0052391355857253075, 0.05718974024057388, -0.013271539472043514, -0.07580549269914627, 0.049213819205760956, -0.03337790071964264, -0.03936871886253357, 0.012149438261985779, 0.00502084381878376, 0.011988108977675438, 0.006461275275796652, 0.026206905022263527, -0.009605943225324154, 0.018268249928951263, -0.0069869509898126125, -0.006825690623372793, -0.031004877761006355, -0.0645359680056572, -0.007582529913634062, 0.010397063568234444, -0.017057623714208603, -0.03584963083267212, 0.0014575456734746695, 0.025351515039801598, 0.015288487076759338, -0.03721228986978531, -0.015089163556694984, 0.017531218007206917, 0.031178796663880348, 0.020416975021362305, 0.02009880729019642, 0.0228673554956913, -0.02286958321928978, 0.03402300179004669, 0.008477119728922844, 0.056263573467731476, 0.008901195600628853, -0.0004510635044425726, 0.0029339848551899195, -0.011514175683259964, -0.012833992950618267, -0.02761463262140751, 0.0023243194445967674, 0.03249255195260048, -0.008820065297186375, 0.05799556523561478, 0.033955950289964676, -0.05346743389964104, 0.024856196716427803, 0.03311977908015251, -0.00854240171611309, -0.0030410061590373516, -0.02999087981879711, -0.036745600402355194, -0.006902010180056095, 0.002135342452675104, 0.03299863263964653, 0.028230931609869003, 0.0003370767808519304, 0.006945434492081404, 0.06091746687889099, 0.014073843136429787, -0.03276749327778816, -0.025338267907500267, 0.0009829308837652206, 0.025441190227866173, 0.006019259802997112, -0.033060599118471146, 0.03795759379863739, 0.04447378218173981, 0.047053027898073196, 0.011734389699995518, 0.00571172870695591, -0.06922672688961029, 0.04326583072543144, 0.03536594286561012, 0.028252841904759407, -0.028021790087223053, 0.003125840565189719, -0.04098612070083618, -0.01606748066842556, 0.040673527866601944, -0.014533155597746372, 0.0020821455400437117, 0.005192533601075411, 0.0017193761887028813, -0.03906329721212387, 0.0077549307607114315, -0.05706487223505974, -0.011723026633262634, 0.002070266753435135, -0.007375655230134726, -0.011951935477554798, -0.020652389153838158, -0.07068246603012085, 0.015000585466623306, 0.010590821504592896, 0.06509982794523239, -0.01909872144460678, -0.009630080312490463, 0.015836063772439957, 0.05075348541140556, 0.015067335218191147, -0.053562190383672714, 0.013709974475204945, 0.02839015983045101, -0.015786536037921906, 0.05898458510637283, -0.022206366062164307, -0.047519102692604065, -0.018734723329544067, -0.013667973689734936, -0.024798361584544182, 0.0004478042828850448, -0.010455706156790257, 0.02436700463294983, 0.010083237662911415, 0.030896365642547607, 0.08154214918613434, 0.011691740714013577, -0.024481499567627907, -0.04570867121219635, -0.0220878217369318, 0.04689955711364746, -0.027396582067012787, -0.021336346864700317, -0.045376040041446686, -0.01092779915779829, -0.020036606118083, 0.050729166716337204, -0.014739498496055603, 0.02570907399058342, -0.025183746591210365, -0.008176556788384914, 0.017056377604603767, 0.04161452502012253, 0.01051181461662054, 0.010531751438975334, 0.011095740832388401, 0.003682146780192852, -0.007603979203850031, -0.016014503315091133, 0.007570893503725529, 0.019566770642995834, 0.003432909958064556, 0.025297239422798157, -0.025927403941750526, 0.017017081379890442, -0.06242246553301811, -0.02996642142534256, 0.010639709420502186, -0.026101239025592804, 0.056187909096479416, 0.021438904106616974, 0.029602553695440292, 0.02464999444782734, -0.03724563866853714, -0.019469276070594788, 0.05683595687150955, -0.00302132498472929, 0.045790474861860275, -0.021742507815361023, 0.013828875496983528, -0.055308375507593155, -0.0054945326410233974, -0.06099492684006691, -0.07985113561153412, 0.01096439454704523, -0.014125766232609749, -0.029170965775847435, -0.036733582615852356, 0.02850855328142643, 0.006576523184776306, 0.0026631648652255535, -0.004975862335413694, 0.05181443318724632, -0.0075682345777750015, -0.008706108666956425, -0.002417690120637417, -0.007630088832229376, 0.08655053377151489, -0.019626634195446968, -0.04603421315550804, 0.03558669984340668, 0.018991366028785706, 0.014116819016635418, -0.0182961318641901, 0.028560882434248924, -0.029851127415895462, -0.0023002321831882, -0.02498142421245575, 0.0032476400956511497, 0.05584435537457466, -0.02498026378452778, -0.022301476448774338, 0.03380018100142479, 0.026928456500172615, -0.019727498292922974, -0.015423905104398727, 0.000317977654049173, 0.0016265847953036427, -0.02028506249189377, -0.014199440367519855, -0.030763259157538414, -0.006160158663988113, -0.012577627785503864, 0.06988491863012314, 0.013296253979206085, -0.01879289001226425, 0.04969329759478569, 0.049730587750673294, 0.020257577300071716, 0.016818080097436905, 0.01523741427809, -0.029931385070085526, 0.019559120759367943, 0.025548430159687996, 0.012810315005481243, 0.005709948018193245, 0.0046294331550598145, -0.03719232231378555, -0.0563858337700367, -0.011761301197111607, 0.004807780962437391, 0.07864989340305328, -0.0063514080829918385, 0.05554664134979248, 0.059428345412015915, 0.009685633704066277, -0.02771650440990925, -0.028833013027906418, -0.015161995775997639, -0.01990850642323494, 0.03156771883368492, 0.049934934824705124, -0.016720931977033615, 0.012082141824066639, 0.0067774890922009945, 0.00008072900527622551, 0.019946960732340813, 0.04782402142882347, 0.008048318326473236, 0.04653763771057129, 0.03416662663221359, -0.004533899016678333, -0.025757363066077232, 0.04114304110407829, -0.03588036447763443, 0.029676834121346474, -0.018389124423265457, -0.01361645944416523, 0.024307981133461, 0.04309261590242386, 0.022849014028906822, -0.04210842773318291, -0.01824253611266613, -0.03823365271091461, 0.018001681193709373, 0.03536759316921234, -0.028827965259552002, 0.006154978182166815, 0.042538776993751526, 0.042658377438783646, -0.026981476694345474, 0.04376840218901634, -0.012654452584683895, -0.055019352585077286, -0.040810663253068924, -0.02492125704884529, -0.030573448166251183, 0.033657122403383255, -0.002065802924335003, -0.04838960990309715, -0.0016431657131761312, -0.05346721038222313, 0.02801455929875374, 0.00978454202413559, 0.0025517214089632034, -0.01805497333407402, 0.08893100172281265, -0.018434584140777588, -0.028000378981232643, 0.007599654141813517, -0.013186275027692318, 0.11331475526094437, 0.06132056936621666, 0.021797029301524162, -0.07443399727344513, 0.028787735849618912, -0.033807478845119476, 0.01012161560356617, -0.037371765822172165, 0.025916345417499542, -0.013012325391173363, -0.014674191363155842, 0.03455613553524017, 0.07540581375360489, 0.0055205863900482655, -0.007794475182890892, 0.08327978104352951, -0.029514238238334656, -0.02823619730770588, 0.004143676720559597, -0.011948983184993267, -0.01197813916951418, 0.0029393061995506287, -0.05114368349313736, 0.031586654484272, -0.011561323888599873, -0.02128404565155506, -0.03605465963482857, -0.03959190472960472, 0.008298044092953205, 0.011289822869002819, -0.04372534900903702, 0.013104097917675972, 0.014891523867845535, 0.027967756614089012, 0.009076904505491257, -0.0038332678377628326, 0.026053687557578087, -0.031141260638833046, 0.01682453788816929, -0.0036503628361970186, 0.018883496522903442, -0.013353935442864895, 0.018304983153939247, -0.017088985070586205, -0.017585737630724907, -0.049615904688835144, -0.034167010337114334, 0.03263357654213905, -0.029581906273961067, -0.005917120724916458, -0.014679515734314919, 0.016538221389055252, -0.0009115090942941606, -0.03702851012349129, -0.00871589221060276, 0.009565250016748905, 0.026142556220293045, -0.03050171211361885, 0.017548108473420143, -0.03270520269870758, 0.0039045391604304314, -0.012411829084157944, 0.03548501804471016, 0.027408413589000702, -0.01668102666735649, 0.010282730683684349, -0.037704821676015854, 0.043738652020692825, -0.013129114173352718, -0.01203396450728178, -0.031673863530159, 0.014348314143717289, -0.02451007254421711, 0.00580357713624835, 0.030459027737379074, 0.0006311594625003636, 0.029154997318983078, 0.010880616493523121, -0.015397747047245502, 0.020436977967619896, -0.04643519967794418, 0.04322033375501633, -0.016440507024526596, 0.0062720272690057755, -0.012021406553685665, -0.045181311666965485, 0.05872797220945358, 0.041009511798620224, 0.03301849961280823, 0.022545287385582924, -0.024222945794463158, -0.009459204971790314, 0.04015810787677765, -0.04241166263818741, -0.0107528455555439, 0.002279855776578188, 0.0011202130699530244, -0.012333338148891926, -0.015081509947776794, 0.032808687537908554, 0.05770648643374443, 0.028579697012901306, 0.003245170461013913, 0.0271969735622406, 0.011049828492105007, -0.002160697476938367, 0.00712796114385128, -0.06408534944057465, -0.0015088650397956371, 0.023365575820207596, 0.0393870547413826, -0.028643229976296425, -0.03778819739818573, -0.013122833333909512, -0.008511196821928024, -0.00686307530850172, 0.0075006443075835705, 0.002861110959202051, 0.0009502698085270822, -0.0036978076677769423, 0.0066820913925766945, -0.03856990113854408, 0.003285204991698265, -0.02329806424677372, -0.005532857496291399, -0.016468266025185585, -0.0012952748220413923, -0.00988067127764225, 0.005297029856592417, -0.0032264261972159147, 0.016358857974410057, 0.016344543546438217, -0.0037921119946986437, 0.02862241119146347, -0.0014135397505015135, -0.009394942782819271, -0.05983224883675575, 0.0422029048204422, -0.05647442117333412, -0.013205775991082191, 0.02974775619804859, -0.043833617120981216, -0.05306568369269371, -0.0006206451798789203, 0.0036503130104392767, -0.007607062812894583, -0.0007354309782385826, 0.019814109429717064, -0.04026511684060097, 0.04799012094736099, -0.017206301912665367, 0.004440873861312866, -0.03583737462759018, -0.014052633196115494, -0.02619514800608158, 0.00458830501884222, 0.012791457585990429, -0.013644997961819172, -0.02643785998225212, 0.026070229709148407, 0.060615140944719315, 0.0023732271511107683, 0.02884306199848652, 0.02612118236720562, -0.010850452817976475, 0.0054918695241212845, 0.005971838720142841, -0.016516393050551414, 0.07039441913366318, 0.06867529451847076, -0.029096396639943123, 0.04076920077204704, -0.007273074239492416, 0.010624298825860023, -0.09972227364778519, -0.008733420632779598, -0.012402882799506187, 0.007962184026837349, 0.043599799275398254, -0.08691813796758652, -0.05529891327023506, 0.026854272931814194, -0.049528587609529495, 0.0066720834001898766, -0.016607334837317467, -0.03551122546195984, 0.0010242394637316465, 0.011909017339348793, -0.00041659007547423244, 0.0357992947101593, 0.019843747839331627, 0.027051113545894623, 0.016393745318055153, 0.01879464089870453, -0.007820039056241512, 0.0318477526307106, 0.00043630317668430507, 0.003013259032741189, 0.02694535255432129, -0.053971268236637115, 0.02642412856221199, -0.013648652471601963, -0.041284799575805664, 0.03532559424638748, -0.031562019139528275, 0.021338503807783127, 0.025156090036034584, 0.0036447858437895775, -0.04491551220417023, 0.04250513017177582, 0.0422762930393219, -0.01560299564152956, -0.019238654524087906, -0.017031550407409668, 0.02792312577366829, 0.06396213173866272, -0.040022991597652435, -0.008364412002265453, 0.018290815874934196, -0.04742836207151413, -0.03735583648085594, 0.03513769060373306, -0.038706518709659576, -0.037162911146879196, 0.022284725680947304, 0.021059853956103325, 0.014752908609807491, -0.02239920012652874, 0.03383603319525719, -0.05733928456902504, 0.01675065979361534, 0.014483552426099777, 0.024524983018636703, -0.0027301814407110214, 0.022759737446904182, -0.0364438071846962, -0.030984973534941673, 0.008766241371631622, 0.005306092556566, 0.000478231260785833, -0.05957895144820213, -0.00023055801284499466, -0.005122798029333353, -0.05600534752011299, -0.009891899302601814, -0.016556553542613983, -0.03961438685655594, 0.06342241913080215, -0.01406706403940916, 0.01259619276970625, 0.0188690684735775, -0.037526462227106094, 0.03295157849788666, -0.05812843516469002, 0.07663337141275406, 0.0021186594385653734, -0.028079712763428688, -0.04027895629405975, 0.020980965346097946, -0.032277900725603104, -0.02872350811958313, 0.05648138374090195, -0.03969230875372887, 0.02859802357852459, -0.0010846956865862012, 0.016451850533485413, -0.0016391705721616745, -0.02139592543244362, 0.03085719794034958, -0.024879014119505882, -0.03909560292959213, -0.008000119589269161, -0.02352055162191391, 0.0026563508436083794, 0.003633568063378334, -0.0040189605206251144, -0.002217743545770645, 0.033327702432870865, -0.0010999212972819805, -0.013761686161160469, 0.05829794332385063, 0.0442538857460022, -0.02324642613530159, 0.019523756578564644, -0.02281418815255165, 0.01764138787984848, 0.0390348955988884, -0.018240099772810936, -0.03962085768580437, 0.04591602459549904, -0.004945843480527401, -0.05322204530239105, -0.024415848776698112, -0.012674148194491863, 0.0031697144731879234, -0.06594406068325043, 0.02419714629650116, 0.043891847133636475, -0.014238783158361912, 0.03542632982134819, 0.029426101595163345, 0.028557926416397095, 0.03301110118627548, -0.00100134767126292, -0.03714410215616226, 0.03155573457479477, 0.008313973434269428, -0.0033592197578400373, 0.01347148697823286, 0.02254548668861389, 0.018749598413705826, -0.021183591336011887, 0.0285418052226305, -0.022733429446816444, 0.025995561853051186, -0.01960103027522564, 0.017076123505830765, -0.04089340195059776, -0.0029097627848386765, -0.00051491754129529, -0.01544654555618763, 0.027831079438328743, -0.012548308819532394, -0.012299306690692902, 0.05147244781255722, -0.05750277638435364, 0.0001038321788655594, -0.024114472791552544, 0.01716315746307373, -0.05286353453993797, -0.04055142402648926, -0.01889236643910408, 0.025757016614079475, -0.0053017400205135345, 0.018525512889027596, -0.0077173104509711266, 0.003447347553446889, 0.0708138570189476, -0.009335310198366642, 0.03531978651881218, -0.021309148520231247, -0.0032477614004164934, 0.005368995014578104, -0.03440883010625839, -0.020648036152124405, -0.03447061777114868, 0.015544874593615532, 0.007824169471859932, 0.02272486314177513, -0.024127790704369545, -0.015420560725033283, -0.011606104671955109, 0.0735921710729599, -0.06453064829111099, -0.014542048797011375, -0.037766072899103165, -0.0004580212407745421, -0.008891365490853786, -0.02218494936823845 ]
<p>Given $T=G+A$ where $A$ and $G$ are independent random variables, I'd like to estimate the distribution of $G$ given empirical (measured) distributions of $T$ and $A$. Of note: all three random variables are guaranteed to be bounded on $[0,\infty]$ (unlike the more studied case where $A$ would be a zero mean gaussian). </p> <p>I understand this is a deconvolution, and I've tried two different deconvolutions with little success. Before deconvolving, most references recommend converting the empirical densities (in this case, $T$ and $A$) into smoother forms using kernel density estimation. I'll call these $P_T$ (black) and $P_A$ (red) respectively.</p> <p>Then I've tried two deconvolution approaches. </p> <p>(1) Computing $\mathcal{F}^{-1}(\mathcal{F}(P_T)/\mathcal{F}(P_A))$ using matlab's fft and ifft functions. (green)</p> <p>(2) Computing the deconvolution matrix for $A$ and using a truncated SVD method to solve for $P_G$. (blue)</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/S0mLe.jpg" alt="Deconvolution"></p> <p>Almost certainly the general shape of both solutions is correct, except.. (1) both oscillate significantly, whereas the correct $P_G$ will not, and (2) both deconvolutions give me negative numbers. Seems like there should be a way to enforce that $G$ is positive but I'm not sure how. Thoughts?</p>
74,416
[ -0.009161073714494705, 0.010311370715498924, 0.019136546179652214, -0.0072973002679646015, 0.015178891830146313, -0.020429987460374832, -0.06497863680124283, -0.018134402111172676, 0.036417704075574875, -0.004751345608383417, 0.037127234041690826, 0.04112807661294937, 0.034223005175590515, 0.03258422762155533, 0.029222959652543068, -0.022142527624964714, -0.006190647836774588, -0.013406430371105671, -0.03981989622116089, -0.027414681389927864, 0.001821247162297368, 0.02657460607588291, -0.025210577994585037, -0.011497033759951591, -0.031098397448658943, 0.01071495097130537, -0.011876092292368412, 0.004596678540110588, -0.0026757935993373394, 0.07261823117733002, -0.026445096358656883, -0.028645971789956093, -0.021418480202555656, 0.051848024129867554, 0.001455470803193748, 0.015456678345799446, -0.04872223362326622, -0.004285506438463926, -0.0033983380999416113, 0.03128763660788536, -0.03476300090551376, 0.0028441292233765125, -0.032166775315999985, 0.05707831680774689, -0.009985353797674179, 0.015069343149662018, 0.03746626153588295, -0.04644537717103958, 0.02596229314804077, -0.05144406482577324, 0.06699231266975403, 0.009549889713525772, 0.011973743326961994, 0.013955147936940193, -0.017135966569185257, -0.024183005094528198, 0.02640816941857338, 0.07621680200099945, 0.0333826020359993, -0.08375752717256546, 0.010249454528093338, -0.011949035339057446, -0.014483919367194176, 0.028658466413617134, -0.017740365117788315, 0.03800120949745178, -0.010731782764196396, -0.06977352499961853, 0.011757789179682732, -0.06802195310592651, 0.028985606506466866, 0.006182328797876835, 0.04345241189002991, 0.013011089526116848, 0.01522709522396326, -0.029149772599339485, 0.012128124013543129, 0.032209936529397964, 0.06960327923297882, -0.0036335496697574854, 0.014462729915976524, 0.024896318092942238, 0.008446341380476952, 0.020603278651833534, 0.0026203012093901634, 0.017820710316300392, 0.09947516024112701, -0.002909653354436159, 0.01038889680057764, 0.012264523655176163, -0.026050280779600143, 0.0018765213899314404, 0.04633230343461037, -0.0033623715862631798, -0.008674520067870617, 0.04603862017393112, -0.013365582562983036, 0.03822360560297966, -0.0008319713524542749, -0.03003847971558571, -0.017867811024188995, -0.03399256616830826, -0.003989263903349638, 0.09096737951040268, -0.026724740862846375, 0.0076362984254956245, -0.03804432600736618, 0.01565674878656864, -0.020565275102853775, -0.055621400475502014, -0.01259534526616335, 0.001958959037438035, 0.012530987150967121, -0.008910040371119976, 0.02459883876144886, 0.028668344020843506, -0.03352679684758186, -0.010642540641129017, 0.024421969428658485, 0.05957362800836563, 0.03777656704187393, -0.037885263562202454, 0.01955519989132881, -0.04503636434674263, -0.0640929564833641, 0.007550159934908152, 0.029741091653704643, 0.007021777797490358, -0.06926333159208298, 0.05461176484823227, 0.008070733398199081, -0.045053523033857346, 0.07815250009298325, -0.03170587867498398, -0.005045225378125906, -0.023802628740668297, -0.06295133382081985, -0.04363406077027321, 0.06404943019151688, -0.015930412337183952, 0.018067270517349243, -0.055656302720308304, -0.030066831037402153, 0.028841888532042503, 0.06170966476202011, -0.006587064824998379, 0.023936420679092407, 0.01751464605331421, 0.07240094244480133, -0.0010019615292549133, 0.0023119610268622637, -0.006751524284482002, -0.05842949077486992, -0.013074185699224472, -0.019047679379582405, -0.04212738201022148, 0.04377152770757675, 0.013824178837239742, 0.0010786824859678745, -0.008280858397483826, 0.08117976784706116, 0.02714693546295166, -0.03068581223487854, 0.02057878114283085, 0.014858686365187168, -0.023856451734900475, 0.020473157986998558, 0.01101040281355381, -0.0028633358888328075, 0.028741726651787758, -0.01755763217806816, 0.005779927130788565, 0.004735078662633896, 0.011064804159104824, 0.01949118636548519, -0.048480965197086334, 0.01827499456703663, -0.02904832735657692, 0.01622704416513443, 0.03565594181418419, 0.009721854701638222, -0.00391842145472765, -0.002568416530266404, -0.03565381467342377, 0.06830509752035141, 0.04444337636232376, -0.0018981220200657845, 0.005318003240972757, 0.010905896313488483, -0.01848915033042431, -0.033360712230205536, -0.03768562898039818, 0.0009421614813618362, 0.024334749206900597, -0.03560696914792061, 0.07645829021930695, 0.004706290550529957, -0.0017636172706261277, 0.006441302131861448, -0.021135913208127022, 0.02103341370820999, 0.010099269449710846, 0.021249517798423767, -0.017733486369252205, 0.006916915997862816, 0.05441625416278839, 0.0713924914598465, 0.001072363113053143, 0.042727839201688766, -0.013317733071744442, -0.034908477216959, 0.0019885420333594084, -0.01895073801279068, 0.05302455648779869, 0.004302558954805136, 0.012500365264713764, 0.007014484144747257, 0.006305681075900793, 0.01159205473959446, 0.010565057396888733, -0.06234186142683029, 0.0004261042922735214, 0.06670702993869781, 0.0031379065476357937, 0.014079442247748375, 0.008635293692350388, -0.0008196137496270239, 0.02735075354576111, -0.007618627045303583, 0.0033204322680830956, -0.037952736020088196, -0.02096395008265972, 0.05668434873223305, 0.04796072095632553, -0.02092546597123146, 0.007226448971778154, 0.06715083122253418, 0.027605056762695312, 0.03527696430683136, 0.02185988426208496, -0.018244082108139992, -0.024417998269200325, 0.02268591895699501, 0.02861994318664074, -0.002622509840875864, -0.012319520115852356, -0.005189609248191118, 0.004244789946824312, 0.015245603397488594, -0.003413558006286621, -0.02082236111164093, 0.015214218758046627, 0.017312590032815933, 0.025207016617059708, -0.028215188533067703, 0.02107156813144684, 0.025155073031783104, -0.010523897595703602, -0.0350426509976387, -0.01009058952331543, -0.04705170542001724, -0.005896597635000944, 0.007862464524805546, -0.019868897274136543, 0.03855215385556221, 0.018455367535352707, -0.0219927579164505, 0.004714407958090305, 0.013406525366008282, -0.009660010226070881, -0.01402050070464611, -0.008243093267083168, 0.015820419415831566, -0.027392655611038208, 0.05061686784029007, 0.03336264565587044, -0.0027355297934263945, 0.0275129247456789, -0.06559006124734879, -0.022533947601914406, 0.018724093213677406, -0.02151428908109665, 0.05753065645694733, 0.00944660697132349, -0.050295062363147736, 0.039489712566137314, -0.04879722744226456, -0.01762598194181919, 0.0242310743778944, 0.028543874621391296, 0.01644301787018776, -0.02105743996798992, 0.007785240653902292, -0.05381156504154205, -0.03408687934279442, -0.06217710301280022, 0.017408769577741623, -0.026303606107831, -0.009700387716293335, 0.07374200224876404, 0.03245844319462776, -0.026378922164440155, 0.02821888029575348, -0.00971248373389244, -0.023504337295889854, -0.006884150207042694, -0.02607344090938568, 0.011575623415410519, -0.018649093806743622, 0.016712307929992676, 0.029605811461806297, -0.021934151649475098, 0.0036142899189144373, -0.07584837079048157, -0.036013051867485046, 0.01070635486394167, 0.018968839198350906, 0.028415873646736145, 0.04227011650800705, -0.021599888801574707, 0.05680704489350319, 0.043851301074028015, -0.002898294711485505, -0.005831202492117882, 0.0008595103281550109, -0.027394931763410568, 0.007230024319142103, -0.00271376664750278, 0.01175753679126501, 0.02119590900838375, 0.05691014975309372, -0.014251535758376122, -0.0053071435540914536, 0.05509263649582863, 0.04877202957868576, -0.035985175520181656, 0.06390418857336044, 0.010718660429120064, 0.015643905848264694, 0.03581413999199867, -0.003625869285315275, -0.0077615282498300076, -0.01062678825110197, -0.006529852282255888, -0.00010665354056982324, 0.011350743472576141, -0.01612592674791813, -0.024916859343647957, -0.011439292691648006, 0.01305647473782301, -0.06019270047545433, 0.017172308638691902, 0.023727841675281525, -0.011971213854849339, 0.005354869645088911, 0.04629994183778763, 0.046832624822854996, -0.04206441342830658, 0.019208747893571854, -0.0012994614662602544, 0.00018695526523515582, 0.02186611481010914, -0.04733032360672951, -0.0039959801360964775, -0.03955414146184921, 0.033120762556791306, 0.006097051780670881, -0.01737108826637268, 0.039017386734485626, 0.037628624588251114, 0.04015665128827095, -0.03741865232586861, -0.012942807748913765, 0.004406588152050972, -0.08715607225894928, 0.023103240877389908, -0.0090889111161232, 0.04572805017232895, 0.039194103330373764, 0.03486922010779381, 0.008568167686462402, 0.0032355275470763445, -0.017133047804236412, 0.02879517525434494, -0.06727305799722672, 0.0015846150927245617, 0.02367483451962471, -0.03868122026324272, -0.03166760876774788, 0.009786432608962059, 0.04336043819785118, -0.03199315816164017, 0.01661064848303795, 0.011809807270765305, -0.005256728734821081, -0.04609329625964165, -0.02164507657289505, -0.02542511560022831, -0.019246762618422508, -0.006174484733492136, 0.007209049072116613, 0.02373625338077545, -0.01885250024497509, 0.02418501302599907, 0.05936595797538757, 0.009259836748242378, -0.005691960453987122, -0.030965056270360947, -0.0008259370806626976, 0.0014331704005599022, 0.03287919983267784, 0.01820644736289978, 0.05889834463596344, 0.010165722109377384, 0.042982183396816254, -0.01267277356237173, 0.07769932597875595, 0.03260326012969017, -0.01253455225378275, -0.016515256837010384, -0.03370140120387077, -0.037613462656736374, 0.03528668358922005, 0.0034356829710304737, -0.022637533023953438, 0.026061339303851128, 0.03278731927275658, 0.011879021301865578, -0.01771789789199829, 0.009275571443140507, 0.03412468358874321, 0.00030524388421326876, 0.01050762739032507, -0.05676451325416565, -0.013133324682712555, -0.005528269801288843, -0.004662433639168739, 0.043223604559898376, 0.005309161730110645, 0.013394556939601898, -0.008587849326431751, 0.07240601629018784, 0.01437830924987793, 0.0033134035766124725, 0.007453936617821455, 0.018815362825989723, 0.031752340495586395, 0.0068491860292851925, -0.020720450207591057, 0.03655420243740082, 0.05939992517232895, 0.03677379712462425, -0.003572463756427169, -0.018144499510526657, -0.10696115344762802, 0.0015558513114228845, 0.037956517189741135, 0.036695413291454315, 0.019392171874642372, 0.006019913125783205, -0.06719570606946945, -0.03266570344567299, 0.023647306486964226, -0.02207317389547825, 0.030780235305428505, 0.011513270437717438, -0.007087975740432739, -0.004088292829692364, -0.04903410002589226, -0.011238111183047295, 0.010679964907467365, -0.0050279321148991585, -0.034001339226961136, -0.025765435770154, -0.021288160234689713, -0.007381469011306763, 0.0385984405875206, 0.0340418815612793, 0.05847380682826042, 0.014666390605270863, -0.04407339170575142, 0.003646013792604208, 0.016155090183019638, -0.018895795568823814, -0.10253708809614182, 0.026862991973757744, -0.001970856450498104, -0.036142684519290924, 0.06123392656445503, -0.03153705224394798, -0.04910155013203621, 0.020785102620720863, 0.0046257562935352325, -0.013192069716751575, 0.01841234602034092, -0.03421761095523834, 0.05245397984981537, -0.0030756485648453236, 0.015721013769507408, 0.04912899434566498, 0.04574963450431824, 0.007156147621572018, -0.03638596832752228, -0.027878733351826668, 0.018918827176094055, -0.04020765796303749, 0.007562769111245871, -0.024074861779808998, 0.029199151322245598, -0.009297408163547516, 0.040797729045152664, 0.03250410780310631, 0.045022379606962204, 0.015027312561869621, -0.021736858412623405, 0.05772191658616066, 0.012709327973425388, -0.05360044911503792, 0.03394858539104462, 0.014655926264822483, 0.019595012068748474, -0.006969761569052935, -0.03738255426287651, -0.01804361678659916, -0.004705572500824928, 0.010317903943359852, 0.04168103635311127, -0.07020817697048187, 0.026678109541535378, -0.030758332461118698, -0.01923426054418087, 0.009300671517848969, -0.04900727421045303, 0.06369010359048843, -0.016493715345859528, 0.04526462405920029, 0.018031496554613113, 0.01693148724734783, 0.005985636729747057, -0.03444509208202362, 0.01253467332571745, 0.06258790194988251, -0.053863801062107086, 0.042320381850004196, 0.011146430857479572, -0.01166312862187624, -0.09698232263326645, -0.004514036234468222, 0.01913551613688469, 0.03381720557808876, -0.017740394920110703, -0.06674949824810028, -0.000429417792474851, -0.02604897879064083, -0.012226086109876633, -0.01608945243060589, 0.03917606920003891, -0.004389510024338961, -0.025504309684038162, -0.018757926300168037, 0.03054249845445156, 0.06293483823537827, -0.03313400223851204, 0.02034865692257881, 0.02353018894791603, -0.013917826116085052, -0.04063127562403679, 0.036329470574855804, 0.02471359260380268, -0.05157693475484848, -0.006990017369389534, -0.030281471088528633, -0.01954256370663643, 0.03759719803929329, -0.0009771636687219143, -0.04732198640704155, 0.03792285546660423, 0.005079797003418207, 0.038888975977897644, -0.031569041311740875, 0.005564429797232151, -0.0032032537274062634, -0.020995039492845535, -0.011432928033173084, -0.025430645793676376, -0.0028270063921809196, 0.003513069124892354, 0.02487923391163349, 0.017354054376482964, -0.062280043959617615, 0.007907754741609097, 0.07658746093511581, -0.017236335203051567, -0.005950090009719133, 0.015229371376335621, 0.03900229185819626, 0.036606527864933014, -0.036591194570064545, 0.0225063543766737, 0.022618291899561882, 0.005536287557333708, -0.060080207884311676, -0.03547278046607971, -0.07014385610818863, -0.015321826562285423, 0.04746919870376587, -0.0031542929355055094, 0.053475864231586456, 0.010244790464639664, -0.015944473445415497, -0.006478590425103903, -0.00937112607061863, -0.0017907815054059029, 0.03419869765639305, -0.014230601489543915, 0.022162506356835365, -0.022243604063987732, -0.03364913538098335, 0.0354054793715477, -0.0056732469238340855, -0.005630488973110914, 0.04729430377483368, -0.02423333190381527, 0.005493457429111004, 0.015187137760221958, -0.044762514531612396, -0.037743568420410156, 0.010355643928050995, -0.020791511982679367, 0.04537193849682808, -0.018632592633366585, 0.015147130005061626, 0.0360584631562233, 0.04170011729001999, -0.03060532920062542, -0.05290970578789711, -0.014351245015859604, -0.053266867995262146, 0.023968735709786415, 0.029829861596226692, -0.04959561675786972, 0.043544232845306396, -0.018324902281165123, 0.009359637275338173, 0.008207506500184536, 0.032170020043849945, -0.03349330276250839, -0.046200379729270935, -0.006161688361316919, -0.03509092330932617, -0.04793213680386543, 0.05687165632843971, 0.0009311995236203074, -0.03588197007775307, 0.041193265467882156, -0.036750566214323044, 0.04596500098705292, 0.001554699381813407, 0.030661258846521378, -0.008318617008626461, 0.08942567557096481, 0.005893754307180643, 0.03477044403553009, 0.01211282517760992, -0.031049514189362526, 0.10660209506750107, 0.06675998121500015, 0.03479829430580139, -0.052551865577697754, 0.0019357651472091675, -0.007075668778270483, -0.006725342012941837, -0.03600050136446953, 0.0438113771378994, -0.03877851739525795, -0.006109181325882673, 0.006994482129812241, 0.04706275835633278, -0.0059074279852211475, -4.2477589090594847e-7, 0.0185766089707613, -0.012793030589818954, -0.005368119105696678, 0.012191121466457844, -0.006842694245278835, 0.02269587107002735, -0.011774104088544846, -0.0417918935418129, 0.013736403547227383, -0.016171367838978767, -0.022836102172732353, -0.06523358821868896, -0.03356485441327095, -0.010099158622324467, -0.0025699110701680183, -0.035912640392780304, 0.02805478498339653, 0.03513410687446594, 0.0024228785187005997, 0.001581283868290484, 0.02603495493531227, -0.02258317545056343, -0.02709251455962658, 0.01269746758043766, 0.04815066233277321, -0.007503822445869446, -0.018126824870705605, 0.03087591752409935, -0.02401183545589447, -0.045765966176986694, -0.03287026286125183, -0.024027129635214806, 0.060427963733673096, -0.0347793884575367, -0.024737952277064323, -0.014665894210338593, -0.010658818297088146, -0.014446078799664974, -0.039246395230293274, -0.035802990198135376, -0.020089706405997276, 0.04313337057828903, -0.030980318784713745, 0.00024133735860232264, -0.0035195061936974525, 0.018408674746751785, 0.01579548791050911, 0.05134497955441475, 0.007202104199677706, -0.0035302978940308094, 0.003422350622713566, 0.02182265929877758, 0.08548060059547424, 0.011406397446990013, -0.020819401368498802, -0.015097353607416153, -0.05299181863665581, 0.0049826898612082005, -0.039242155849933624, 0.04743923246860504, 0.03277692571282387, -0.0029389983974397182, 0.0017687530489638448, -0.012724247761070728, -0.02930799312889576, -0.04636926203966141, -0.004724754486232996, -0.02317705936729908, -0.0038668406195938587, -0.02489815279841423, -0.03475812450051308, 0.002276822691783309, 0.03151373192667961, -0.011695371940732002, -0.00038236385444179177, 0.034318480640649796, 0.0607854500412941, 0.02181812934577465, -0.028912771493196487, -0.029604120180010796, 0.005460906308144331, -0.022523358464241028, 0.003841626225039363, 0.010821439325809479, 0.04456579312682152, -0.0010156551143154502, -0.0028727331664413214, 0.0156455859541893, 0.007949182763695717, -0.022542089223861694, -0.017151284962892532, -0.021789226680994034, -0.03669712692499161, 0.001169399474747479, -0.02017524093389511, 0.012465540319681168, 0.006869342643767595, 0.00885402038693428, 0.008970636874437332, 0.002038658829405904, 0.00499217351898551, 0.018390892073512077, -0.013524932786822319, -0.006476912181824446, -0.03740368038415909, 0.023484082892537117, -0.03764002397656441, 0.01731649972498417, -0.006314242724329233, 0.006075877696275711, -0.030354006215929985, -0.03866872936487198, -0.017585035413503647, 0.009124810807406902, -0.0044083562679588795, 0.01575731858611107, 0.03341111168265343, 0.013561679050326347, 0.02932390756905079, -0.010213960893452168, 0.005689528305083513, -0.011534119956195354, 0.04517669603228569, 0.027841798961162567, -0.02842111699283123, 0.03714599832892418, -0.04883641377091408, -0.007662527728825808, 0.040648289024829865, 0.008063090965151787, 0.04729017615318298, -0.008214062079787254, -0.0275841373950243, -0.025088513270020485, 0.04188985005021095, -0.012996535748243332, -0.009217682294547558, -0.01493771094828844, -0.022280488163232803, 0.0342528261244297, 0.013406994752585888, 0.03267085179686546, -0.026311401277780533, -0.026825908571481705, 0.01316414400935173, 0.016481200233101845, -0.01979878731071949, -0.0003424326132517308, 0.00786910392343998, -0.019929511472582817, -0.0038050254806876183, 0.013373052701354027, 0.007853737100958824, 0.02888328768312931, 0.0387919545173645, 0.022267408668994904, 0.0007490870775654912, 0.0030934291426092386, 0.025777403265237808, -0.06937611103057861, 0.006411529611796141, 0.032352060079574585, -0.01278227660804987, 0.025880606845021248, -0.06734471023082733, -0.011101124808192253, 0.010567323304712772, -0.04048595950007439, 0.018359661102294922, -0.0286423172801733, -0.006528089288622141, -0.02883172035217285, 0.019271282479166985, -0.033793944865465164, -0.008568501099944115, -0.00930738728493452, 0.024694986641407013, 0.03624795749783516, 0.016743723303079605, -0.04317726194858551, -0.017041394487023354, -0.004822374787181616, 0.003840871388092637, 0.0476093627512455, -0.0448000468313694, 0.04557514563202858, -0.023588690906763077, -0.012620039284229279, 0.010274319909512997, -0.012155305594205856, 0.017633482813835144, -0.015759343281388283, 0.01847960613667965, -0.02685244381427765, 0.007730087265372276, 0.03908281773328781, 0.012232707813382149, -0.0005474074860103428, 0.008617205545306206, 0.02103794366121292, 0.008888095617294312, -0.03244286775588989, 0.011402959935367107, 0.008327659219503403, -0.02445933409035206, -0.015916667878627777, 0.021831398829817772, -0.01285931933671236, -0.0069563682191073895, -0.022537287324666977, -0.022701721638441086, 0.0038533478509634733, -0.023200854659080505, 0.010628028772771358, -0.03501756861805916, -0.04206712171435356, -0.0024648478720337152, 0.029219435527920723, -0.041547778993844986, 0.02352951280772686, -0.048186104744672775, -0.059045303612947464, -0.000526835210621357, -0.01476643979549408, 0.002449923427775502, -0.038173552602529526, -0.026139603927731514, 0.00016231060726568103, -0.017364557832479477, -0.04245098680257797, -0.03628198802471161, -0.028188029304146767, 0.06358198821544647, 0.01085575670003891, 0.007933359593153, -0.02788396179676056, -0.004654265008866787, -0.01743120141327381, -0.0778568834066391, 0.009096159599721432, 0.006834681145846844, -0.049981143325567245, 0.008365873247385025, -0.028483198955655098, -0.021032903343439102, 0.015418569557368755, 0.04356566444039345, -0.011123784817755222, -0.023135965690016747, 0.03248460590839386, -0.039301104843616486, 0.01488136313855648, -0.0670110359787941, 0.04109877720475197, -0.003923490643501282, 0.000019813820472336374, 0.011401442810893059, -0.01991952210664749, -0.022932084277272224, -0.002218837384134531, 0.014436811208724976, 0.009450606070458889, -0.01550719141960144, 0.02048439159989357, -0.010288519784808159, 0.08065369725227356, -0.017031444236636162, -0.010220891796052456, 0.04847551882266998, 0.006026174873113632, -0.0015570108080282807, 0.011917691677808762, -0.011540576815605164, -0.039598822593688965, 0.013596351258456707, -0.004662343300879002, -0.03329748287796974, -0.008966458030045033, 0.00935529824346304, 0.002118402160704136, -0.0360049344599247, -0.04905224218964577, 0.019478216767311096, -0.04716087132692337, -0.014625034295022488, 0.03185427933931351, -0.024366678670048714, 0.03736739978194237, -0.011269424110651016, 0.008326812647283077, 0.030368570238351822, -0.01300223171710968, -0.0171145498752594, 0.025488439947366714, -0.0009462800226174295, -0.02550315484404564, -0.011382353492081165, -0.019081732258200645, -0.019258325919508934, 0.025067387148737907, -0.0060753123834729195, 0.030354073271155357, -0.043014924973249435, -0.04425759240984917, 0.0329202376306057, -0.02575344778597355, -0.03236895799636841, -0.038429148495197296, -0.02761230804026127, 0.05882452800869942, 0.03300578519701958, -0.000989951891824603, -0.009619368240237236, 0.021166237071156502, -0.005471054930239916, 0.03897785395383835, 0.008941431529819965, 0.02295708656311035, 0.0028284594882279634, 0.0030219126492738724, -0.019836556166410446, -0.037954412400722504, -0.00047458612243644893, -0.049356669187545776, 0.0030787589494138956, -0.010779825039207935, 0.004597279243171215, 0.013855150900781155, -0.03872212395071983, -0.016282876953482628, -0.03800775110721588, 0.006954932119697332, 0.026897329837083817, 0.02554628811776638, -0.041867148131132126, 0.009016470052301884, -0.008505628444254398, 0.09669168293476105, -0.04557212442159653, -0.0300021693110466, 0.015142712742090225, -0.004563972819596529, 0.0338580422103405, -0.008063649758696556 ]
<p>I have a sample $x=(4, 3, 1, 2, 2, 2, 2, 5, 7, 3, 1, 2, 3, 4, 3, 2, 3, 3, 3, 4)$ of size $n=20$. from a binomial distribution with 10 trials and probability of success $p$. I am asked to construct the asymptotic 95% confidence interval based on the likelihood. I think this should be the set $$ C = \left\{ p \in (0,1) : \prod_{i=1}^{n} p^{x_i} (1-p)^{10-x_i}\geq \exp(-q/2) \prod_{i=1}^{n} (\overline{x}_n/10)^{x_i} (1-\overline{x}_n/10)^{10-x_i} \right\} $$ where q is the $0.95$ quantile of the $\chi^2_1$ distribution. If I take logs of both sides, the inequality becomes \begin{align*} &amp;n\overline{x}_n\log p + (n10 - n\overline{x}_n)\log(1-p) \\ &amp;\quad \quad \geq -q/2 + n\overline{x}_n\log(\overline{x}_n/10) + (n10 - n\overline{x}_n)\log(1-\overline{x}_n/10) \end{align*} If I plug in the data, it becomes $$ 59\log p + 141\log(1-p) \geq -123.2343 $$</p> <p>The problem is that this inequality is not satisfied for any $p \in (0,1)$, implying that the confidence set $C$ is empty.</p> <p>EDIT: The previous sentence is false. I was plotting the function on too large a scale to notice that it does indeed poke above $-123.2343$ briefly. I suppose the question in the title still stands.</p> <p>Am I doing something wrong?</p> <p>EDIT: Is something like this <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/41003/42850">http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/41003/42850</a> going on here?</p>
37,285
[ 0.015377838164567947, -0.03336780145764351, 0.02633221447467804, 0.005768008064478636, 0.0044545927084982395, 0.022721603512763977, 0.014781288802623749, -0.004553595557808876, -0.022783063352108, -0.05879348888993263, 0.06510350853204727, 0.047630030661821365, 0.015788795426487923, 0.023040397092700005, -0.007130671292543411, 0.030289722606539726, -0.03765341639518738, 0.03914137929677963, 0.016628645360469818, -0.02359423227608204, 0.019981855526566505, 0.05084056407213211, 0.0019695828668773174, 0.018576623871922493, -0.033743880689144135, 0.030872434377670288, 0.036415912210941315, -0.035961754620075226, -0.03473502770066261, 0.1023479625582695, -0.02279595285654068, -0.017076151445508003, 0.0262454841285944, 0.022751212120056152, -0.007786657195538282, 0.0011075662914663553, -0.009704040363430977, -0.03621897101402283, -0.00011850708688143641, 0.02636503055691719, -0.027316555380821228, 0.01057725865393877, 0.025785628706216812, -0.008864409290254116, 0.019291546195745468, 0.03215342015028, 0.016006065532565117, -0.04945385083556175, 0.019553761929273605, -0.048150379210710526, 0.032936256378889084, 0.017208140343427658, 0.010922444052994251, 0.015591051429510117, -0.007078738883137703, -0.07530580461025238, 0.0414251945912838, 0.07873348146677017, 0.0016015174333006144, -0.1039537563920021, -0.05219154432415962, -0.027359765022993088, 0.009873038157820702, -0.038165219128131866, -0.039860259741544724, -0.00917972344905138, 0.012411831878125668, 0.021360620856285095, 0.006359855644404888, -0.03887670114636421, 0.014229193329811096, 0.05258137732744217, 0.03772672638297081, 0.018032802268862724, -0.029524751007556915, -0.025189606472849846, -0.002743515884503722, 0.030885981395840645, 0.06652161478996277, 0.025373205542564392, 0.013511935248970985, 0.022730883210897446, 0.016305234283208847, 0.023301970213651657, 0.014039873145520687, 0.005136727821081877, 0.09341593831777573, -0.03851350396871567, 0.021991141140460968, 0.014431624673306942, -0.009960712864995003, 0.011344535276293755, 0.04433012008666992, -0.03635064885020256, -0.007437414024025202, 0.02137850783765316, -0.07656480371952057, -0.014117774553596973, 0.017164118587970734, -0.024335412308573723, -0.02737109363079071, -0.05761495232582092, 0.028480786830186844, 0.06829819828271866, -0.00157248810864985, 0.011091933585703373, 0.015454402193427086, -0.0034313781652599573, 0.012538602575659752, 0.007130136247724295, 0.010368951596319675, 0.07109986245632172, 0.021944157779216766, 0.015115393325686455, -0.006504418794065714, -0.024500202387571335, -0.005341419950127602, -0.037116773426532745, 0.038763005286455154, 0.008521242998540401, 0.033938828855752945, 0.005681325681507587, 0.013909014873206615, -0.011023098602890968, -0.02181456983089447, -0.005438200198113918, 0.015141521580517292, 0.03204438462853432, -0.04332435876131058, 0.02107021026313305, 0.00711799506098032, -0.006238030269742012, 0.016453636810183525, 0.058625396341085434, 0.06224428117275238, -0.004544067662209272, -0.06515472382307053, -0.02494768425822258, 0.09330421686172485, 0.0025758882984519005, 0.022628867998719215, -0.05029037967324257, -0.014247879385948181, 0.07207594066858292, 0.02152225933969021, 0.010780631564557552, 0.027153773233294487, -0.005390350706875324, 0.00845064502209425, 0.013873551972210407, -0.014598297886550426, 0.027903031557798386, -0.01917852833867073, -0.0036222811322659254, -0.00705758947879076, -0.0521252304315567, 0.056713901460170746, 0.03218786418437958, -0.021640367805957794, -0.03285541012883186, 0.021611183881759644, -0.008136361837387085, -0.01646101288497448, -0.053558554500341415, 0.004718333948403597, -0.03260119631886482, 0.0638602003455162, 0.028264453634619713, -0.002936079865321517, 0.00585944764316082, -0.009565036743879318, -0.010800361633300781, 0.003721123095601797, 0.027826962992548943, 0.05992879718542099, -0.04169435799121857, 0.007178491912782192, -0.06937222927808762, 0.015752922743558884, 0.035888928920030594, -0.028774090111255646, -0.0010923856170848012, -0.05614566057920456, 0.0012242902303114533, 0.03282774239778519, 0.015693243592977524, 0.012256011366844177, -0.01435421034693718, 0.04382408410310745, -0.016330670565366745, -0.03874562308192253, -0.02652645856142044, -0.008293423801660538, 0.06347619742155075, -0.03816547617316246, 0.010578998364508152, -0.004870581440627575, -0.02722252532839775, 0.018459074199199677, -0.020875554531812668, -0.0007753405952826142, 0.01289316825568676, 0.042592860758304596, -0.03866056352853775, 0.004867372568696737, 0.044976916164159775, 0.05761221423745155, -0.04195919632911682, 0.0718092992901802, -0.0388278067111969, -0.02509366348385811, 0.01801135390996933, -0.003300321754068136, -0.00940680131316185, 0.029304496943950653, -0.0011360177304595709, 0.03231319785118103, -0.019425030797719955, 0.012341647408902645, 0.04279515519738197, -0.02119549922645092, 0.040914908051490784, 0.04126796871423721, 0.034980181604623795, -0.008386533707380295, -0.005276561714708805, -0.023022964596748352, 0.03525003790855408, -0.026113472878932953, -0.014984934590756893, -0.0303205456584692, -0.01368962973356247, 0.024121174588799477, 0.032774657011032104, -0.019734418019652367, -0.017122596502304077, 0.039729710668325424, 0.010464790277183056, 0.028889475390315056, 0.022412706166505814, -0.02889413759112358, -0.05426032468676567, -0.0025357718113809824, 0.033348750323057175, 0.01652274839580059, 0.023918956518173218, 0.008330860175192356, -0.00032105715945363045, 0.00840903539210558, 0.016421249136328697, -0.005337822251021862, -0.008652877062559128, 0.03403809294104576, -0.012790176086127758, -0.04442206397652626, 0.011622650548815727, 0.05515333637595177, -0.012389819137752056, -0.015806008130311966, -0.007175943814218044, -0.0017234886763617396, 0.03643610700964928, -0.005588399711996317, -0.035609327256679535, 0.03811531141400337, 0.03899609297513962, -0.03531273826956749, -0.03677288815379143, -0.004810374230146408, -0.03576766327023506, -0.03479393944144249, -0.050479695200920105, -0.06250729411840439, 0.03377804905176163, 0.02216959558427334, 0.022997595369815826, -0.007076994050294161, -0.00027349902666173875, -0.0219908207654953, -0.03339366242289543, -0.008085209876298904, 0.013661324046552181, 0.05035998299717903, 0.00882225763052702, -0.04999377205967903, -0.04513121396303177, 0.011022515594959259, 0.0035173501819372177, 0.005635758861899376, -0.03476861119270325, 0.02143835462629795, 0.00317846005782485, -0.030979381874203682, 0.014643070288002491, -0.013135874643921852, -0.04024382680654526, -0.035854071378707886, -0.04967886209487915, -0.026055194437503815, 0.060660962015390396, 0.02767857350409031, -0.05314410850405693, 0.03871822729706764, -0.025460291653871536, -0.013033542782068253, -0.04527406021952629, 0.02014327235519886, 0.01352093368768692, -0.0077958968468010426, 0.009470262564718723, 0.011754087172448635, 0.07747898250818253, 0.0019914007280021906, -0.06353454291820526, -0.07899270206689835, -0.023331765085458755, -0.036141905933618546, 0.027383187785744667, 0.00470837252214551, -0.0007903025834821165, 0.0786818116903305, 0.030640466138720512, -0.013498784974217415, -0.03576742857694626, 0.03812684491276741, -0.026012323796749115, -0.009431320242583752, 0.00204227352514863, 0.00006684879917884246, 0.012664294801652431, 0.05734792351722717, -0.005181322805583477, 0.00989578478038311, 0.011232655495405197, -0.004142853431403637, 0.009297228418290615, 0.033905722200870514, -0.01287194062024355, -0.00965450145304203, 0.009989148005843163, -0.007132527884095907, -0.030631428584456444, 0.0000056940866670629475, -0.013335620053112507, 0.002734328154474497, 0.030079195275902748, -0.054085902869701385, 0.029593678191304207, -0.020505093038082123, 0.014577080495655537, -0.030733227729797363, 0.05163102224469185, 0.008165232837200165, -0.03242350369691849, 0.020253848284482956, 0.02113625966012478, 0.061534952372312546, -0.03715670108795166, 0.002316991565749049, 0.037948139011859894, 0.013883738778531551, -0.028271766379475594, 0.009832843206822872, -0.013804025948047638, -0.03930548205971718, 0.013580397702753544, -0.0375344343483448, 0.004448364023119211, -0.0029880132060498, 0.06200689077377319, 0.004671490751206875, -0.01906242035329342, -0.016842346638441086, 0.002142005367204547, -0.014060541987419128, -0.021026479080319405, 0.0036152005195617676, 0.05780798941850662, 0.01751052401959896, 0.03407612070441246, 0.008374468423426151, -0.06909722089767456, 0.002102533122524619, 0.034693289548158646, -0.06708107888698578, 0.05119938403367996, -0.014240335673093796, -0.023703886196017265, 0.0006185203674249351, -0.038759298622608185, 0.04905230179429054, -0.008579544723033905, 0.01306341215968132, -0.005832864437252283, 0.03228498622775078, -0.017829909920692444, 0.008326645940542221, -0.046096496284008026, -0.009981478564441204, 0.022385863587260246, 0.02856595441699028, -0.020835181698203087, 0.006572806742042303, 0.03778843581676483, 0.014852284453809261, 0.034547626972198486, 0.011748937889933586, -0.015178973786532879, 0.016022399067878723, 0.02426930144429207, 0.050121959298849106, -0.021495332941412926, -0.008008910343050957, -0.017874881625175476, 0.0021244126837700605, -0.035468555986881256, 0.024100378155708313, 0.06433655321598053, 0.01663392409682274, 0.01566188596189022, -0.03232875093817711, 0.005215799435973167, 0.005051120184361935, -0.0001586530706845224, 0.003541469108313322, 0.006927158683538437, 0.07090970128774643, 0.012676062062382698, -0.044898584485054016, 0.008328440599143505, 0.056408073753118515, -0.026777183637022972, 0.014084327034652233, 0.00452844426035881, -0.00895580742508173, -0.04287717491388321, 0.0227777399122715, -0.020167654380202293, -0.012302088551223278, -0.005345887970179319, 0.0007591141038574278, 0.058219168335199356, -0.006580742076039314, -0.0503682866692543, -0.008980585262179375, 0.03370574861764908, 0.058864738792181015, -0.004636658355593681, -0.020447826012969017, 0.07189610600471497, -0.01948319561779499, 0.05016416683793068, -0.005537960212677717, 0.012179769575595856, -0.06318387389183044, -0.007711796090006828, 0.024234481155872345, 0.06707752496004105, -0.025362450629472733, 0.0012024183524772525, -0.07555223256349564, 0.032386597245931625, -0.0018823076970875263, -0.05093231424689293, 0.02951539307832718, -0.040653422474861145, 0.05260947719216347, -0.016074031591415405, -0.047579146921634674, -0.043088216334581375, -0.02959505096077919, -0.032705869525671005, -0.02634303644299507, -0.04306446760892868, -0.02159338817000389, -0.031092243269085884, -0.010263282805681229, 0.011518553830683231, 0.08291351795196533, -0.018351620063185692, -0.06087015941739082, -0.00585220567882061, 0.009460829198360443, 0.00459190271794796, -0.03433419391512871, 0.07499042898416519, -0.054139066487550735, 0.022551873698830605, 0.04473244026303291, -0.0056368689984083176, -0.049942877143621445, 0.026618624106049538, -0.004335127770900726, -0.03374592214822769, 0.0206768698990345, -0.02074011042714119, 0.035274848341941833, 0.017422767356038094, -0.00916885957121849, 0.023155730217695236, 0.04356751963496208, -0.03903602808713913, 0.014969573356211185, -0.05352727323770523, 0.008548945188522339, -0.050291866064071655, 0.015205169096589088, -0.03790487349033356, 0.03669542074203491, -0.0234365351498127, 0.017653945833444595, -0.02804928459227085, 0.015591604635119438, 0.0009444713359698653, -0.008186154067516327, 0.014332639053463936, -0.02461046539247036, 0.0035881786607205868, 0.03572617843747139, 0.0005990225472487509, 0.006532053463160992, 0.013644558377563953, 0.024310478940606117, 0.019468199461698532, 0.005842006765305996, -0.010331155732274055, -0.006434299051761627, -0.00842474214732647, -0.023331565782427788, -0.033660802990198135, -0.01272627804428339, -0.017706912010908127, -0.0045124744065105915, 0.020708700641989708, 0.015553358010947704, 0.008994085714221, -0.029213661327958107, -0.021502569317817688, -0.022312624379992485, 0.027421243488788605, -0.0061582038179039955, 0.03338519483804703, -0.045340754091739655, 0.0044580320827662945, 0.021233435720205307, -0.002864642534404993, -0.06571175903081894, 0.010638865642249584, 0.02591976895928383, -0.013768665492534637, -0.023782452568411827, 0.004608944058418274, -0.07128972560167313, 0.05580916628241539, -0.017194565385580063, -0.006612470373511314, 0.031685587018728256, -0.00029020162764936686, -0.01206295657902956, -0.032546721398830414, 0.030159443616867065, 0.047993097454309464, -0.017444264143705368, -0.009253371506929398, 0.01082978118211031, -0.021879572421312332, -0.013330972753465176, 0.005429535638540983, -0.05031207948923111, 0.009167714044451714, 0.005656746681779623, -0.020343132317066193, 0.019927052780985832, -0.009212532080709934, -0.026328666135668755, -0.04128020256757736, 0.005272055510431528, 0.015360686928033829, 0.000702854071278125, -0.017588119953870773, -0.029262280091643333, -0.0007007782114669681, 0.029720712453126907, -0.021276116371154785, -0.01595269702374935, 0.03578096255660057, -0.031698696315288544, 0.03466849774122238, -0.00952184945344925, -0.0071585047990083694, -0.013505629263818264, 0.09938132017850876, -0.04525025188922882, -0.06000639498233795, -0.014314419589936733, -0.0016997611382976174, 0.04896727576851845, 0.009020557627081871, -0.02568279206752777, 0.001331070438027382, -0.009557867422699928, -0.046356819570064545, 0.0003732146287802607, -0.019000668078660965, 0.013914299197494984, 0.017909463495016098, 0.030674120411276817, 0.04188402742147446, -0.02529323473572731, 0.0009937051218003035, 0.00029846359393559396, -0.011776609346270561, -0.03203876316547394, 0.030411317944526672, 0.03305305540561676, 0.007095291279256344, -0.02005542255938053, -0.0016643753042444587, 0.013985367491841316, 0.019072437658905983, 0.013215271756052971, 0.04609629511833191, -0.010647210292518139, 0.005662988871335983, -0.01160481758415699, -0.01626485213637352, -0.026926128193736076, 0.04181446135044098, -0.03311758488416672, -0.004597849678248167, -0.046220362186431885, -0.012482957914471626, 0.0021136216819286346, 0.02719879522919655, 0.02562219463288784, 0.004432267043739557, -0.028332965448498726, -0.025642402470111847, -0.009989972226321697, -0.005635400302708149, 0.012442775070667267, 0.03484870120882988, -0.011189057491719723, -0.0036297317128628492, 0.029466062784194946, 0.04081118106842041, -0.016679802909493446, -0.06052035093307495, -0.041758373379707336, 0.014217519201338291, -0.049475882202386856, 0.016198577359318733, -0.012437770143151283, -0.03566710278391838, 0.044107645750045776, -0.018358862027525902, 0.00901056732982397, 0.0192412156611681, 0.01374126598238945, 0.018032260239124298, 0.060560211539268494, 0.02349003031849861, 0.03446386381983757, -0.02002423070371151, -0.027196703478693962, 0.13549548387527466, 0.04055026173591614, 0.02060430496931076, -0.0195806622505188, 0.019507290795445442, -0.026448126882314682, 0.0038319893646985292, -0.025529133155941963, 0.011650118045508862, 0.017113547772169113, -0.05155053734779358, 0.03719527646899223, 0.052184704691171646, -0.008392510004341602, -0.026895884424448013, 0.03196104243397713, -0.021010275930166245, -0.03339298814535141, -0.006073882337659597, 0.012687540613114834, -0.042985949665308, -0.023752426728606224, -0.015097670257091522, 0.0307534821331501, 0.0012973357224836946, -0.007235113065689802, -0.04703427106142044, -0.03418951854109764, 0.004035231191664934, 0.005049444735050201, -0.018930979073047638, -0.04179508611559868, 0.012863308191299438, -0.03846310079097748, -0.02994454838335514, -0.014460391364991665, -0.03460495546460152, -0.020927540957927704, 0.008100311271846294, 0.023624010384082794, 0.003383286064490676, 0.026522044092416763, 0.021854178979992867, 0.007374016102403402, -0.0736139714717865, -0.05232454463839531, -0.04659907519817352, 0.055792637169361115, -0.00920641329139471, -0.0026712764520198107, 0.004972511436790228, -0.0017639124998822808, -0.006388245616108179, 0.013552318327128887, -0.02491643652319908, 0.01691463403403759, 0.023347998037934303, -0.017001831904053688, -0.02533944509923458, -0.017090262845158577, 0.03186372295022011, 0.0075981165282428265, 0.03047025017440319, 0.04174468666315079, -0.04548080638051033, -0.01354913879185915, -0.010996132157742977, 0.03409351408481598, 0.00883804727345705, 0.019339678809046745, 0.003842939855530858, -0.009403947740793228, -0.016328059136867523, -0.03327354043722153, 0.006737733259797096, -0.025954950600862503, 0.05476748198270798, 0.008994042873382568, -0.014935918152332306, 0.0046516042202711105, -0.020428640767931938, 0.005079066846519709, -0.04470723867416382, 0.009714881889522076, -0.048587966710329056, -0.03842182829976082, -0.014311546459794044, 0.045003000646829605, -0.0018289333675056696, 0.020552776753902435, -0.026350490748882294, 0.10120188444852829, -0.006986570544540882, -0.01725967973470688, -0.019979871809482574, -0.023319434374570847, -0.04270569235086441, -0.008865383453667164, 0.006983387283980846, 0.04420289769768715, 0.015899647027254105, 0.028402304276823997, 0.020658329129219055, 0.012536444701254368, -0.010671594180166721, -0.007885550148785114, 0.024466099217534065, -0.022915633395314217, 0.004946957807987928, 0.03378519415855408, 0.03129617124795914, -0.04506688565015793, -0.03978460654616356, -0.05490404739975929, -0.029421215876936913, 0.01843232475221157, -0.044786080718040466, -0.035391442477703094, -0.0249969232827425, 0.008913639932870865, -0.01472474541515112, 0.014700924046337605, -0.025978319346904755, -0.035248901695013046, -0.004199315793812275, -0.027626311406493187, -0.0015494378749281168, -0.01314590871334076, -0.0015760187525302172, -0.019086739048361778, 0.007797125726938248, 0.06290636211633682, -0.009574615396559238, 0.01842975802719593, -0.042839083820581436, 0.0003543991770129651, 0.036033857613801956, 0.05250318720936775, -0.029216943308711052, -0.014185680076479912, 0.05286688730120659, -0.05663440749049187, -0.08292882889509201, 0.05879350006580353, 0.00639067217707634, 0.03176203742623329, 0.03507259115576744, 0.011667575687170029, -0.014423112384974957, 0.011674607172608376, -0.026544690132141113, 0.003388013457879424, -0.008138572797179222, -0.004278325475752354, 0.019804049283266068, -0.013001373037695885, -0.03182496130466461, -0.004239893518388271, 0.02359163761138916, 0.025357086211442947, 0.07681591063737869, -0.007278888951987028, 0.0032096821814775467, 0.012627661228179932, 0.018773509189486504, 0.02196391671895981, 0.00586126372218132, -0.010515309870243073, -0.026399381458759308, 0.029986398294568062, -0.04462708160281181, 0.04992443695664406, -0.013443013653159142, -0.005521951708942652, -0.09341506659984589, -0.03579334542155266, -0.01677810028195381, 0.06081834435462952, 0.020188746973872185, -0.05550066754221916, 0.019481796771287918, 0.02833731658756733, -0.043826423585414886, 0.03374413773417473, -0.02943704091012478, 0.010364284738898277, -0.03603124991059303, -0.009894322603940964, -0.023152533918619156, -0.028413262218236923, 0.029295213520526886, 0.04534478858113289, 0.04458928853273392, 0.0383790023624897, -0.020772939547896385, -0.008465910330414772, -0.012691278010606766, 0.011598783545196056, 0.013990879990160465, -0.03504259139299393, -0.001752600190229714, -0.02961994893848896, -0.002381635596975684, 0.05855727940797806, 0.012071983888745308, 0.01709006167948246, 0.01978049799799919, 0.04841996356844902, 0.022420553490519524, 0.03935163840651512, 0.03409011662006378, 0.016430692747235298, 0.0022884232457727194, 0.00567209254950285, 0.04210904613137245, 0.010111010633409023, -0.035645630210638046, 0.01277528703212738, 0.0436575748026371, -0.00041448595584370196, -0.05122324824333191, 0.05710091441869736, -0.004955867771059275, 0.023264216259121895, -0.007844558916985989, 0.00048685542424209416, -0.029408786445856094, -0.02536906488239765, 0.014238459058105946, -0.027625204995274544, -0.003497290425002575, -0.015916910022497177, 0.056115906685590744, -0.023251891136169434, -0.014089767821133137, -0.01709436997771263, -0.023516185581684113, 0.006275921128690243, 0.01899966411292553, -0.0001281608856515959, -0.05498867854475975, -0.0032365387305617332, -0.047399796545505524, 0.0215823482722044, 0.012519181706011295, -0.009263806976377964, -0.07216324657201767, 0.046079784631729126, -0.012496902607381344, 0.0098283551633358, -0.008189198561012745, 0.01521696150302887, 0.004208396654576063, -0.1113283634185791, 0.040813203901052475, 0.0010284376330673695, -0.004933884367346764, -0.027135737240314484, -0.005303050857037306, -0.018555890768766403, 0.012795022688806057, 0.03341022506356239, 0.034589432179927826, -0.04758468270301819, 0.003398716216906905, 0.03246058523654938, 0.005362717900425196, -0.011705045588314533, 0.04017067700624466, -0.04398170858621597, -0.014090416952967644, -0.033349696546792984, -0.01545645110309124, 0.01078615989536047, 0.03677220642566681, 0.018237872049212456, -0.002123026642948389, -0.009433455765247345, 0.005020671058446169, -0.014736237935721874, 0.04993605986237526, 0.0025100824423134327, 0.002764054574072361, 0.040817536413669586, 0.005557365249842405, -0.01632653921842575, 0.03896696865558624, 0.021332859992980957, -0.06851045787334442, 0.020469345152378082, -0.007998364046216011, -0.02140727825462818, -0.004039411898702383, 0.04656281694769859, -0.0031448621302843094, -0.036349453032016754, -0.003781871637329459, 0.03452885523438454, -0.018655899912118912, -0.009840778075158596, 0.011976671405136585, 0.04851461574435234, 0.03790625184774399, -0.0003774740034714341, 0.0384933240711689, -0.03951194882392883, -0.02151484228670597, 0.02916652150452137, -0.03405265137553215, -0.003603524062782526, -0.017612192779779434, 0.037223491817712784, 0.024170950055122375, -0.017633112147450447, 0.025966184213757515, 0.02528388984501362, 0.03401617705821991, 0.0033923352602869272, -0.014172427356243134, 0.029391657561063766, -0.004961068741977215, 0.002294255420565605, 0.008593919686973095, -0.015418821014463902, 0.05693254992365837, -0.006469582673162222, 0.056690067052841187, -0.014418051578104496, -0.010523762553930283, -0.018587978556752205, 0.014486493542790413, 0.0060129021294415, -0.005898274481296539, -0.01061343215405941, 0.0036656069569289684, 0.02318625897169113, -0.0043992274440824986, 0.01771651580929756, -0.009833044372498989, 0.004907006397843361, 0.019509034231305122, -0.017269069328904152, -0.046774499118328094, -0.0694204643368721, 0.008456222712993622, -0.01074263546615839, -0.004244402516633272, 0.04126608744263649, 0.019533738493919373, 0.008990131318569183, -0.021705012768507004, 0.01979544572532177, 0.07200556248426437, -0.0372530035674572, 0.008321871981024742, -0.015981420874595642, -0.004932793788611889, 0.017830034717917442, -0.03257335349917412 ]
<p>I am trying to test whether there is a significant interaction between an ordinal (<code>A</code>) and categorical variable (<code>B</code>) in R using <code>glm</code>. When I create a model that only includes the interaction term <code>A:B</code>, the model runs fine and I get a reasonable estimate. When I run the "full" model <code>X ~ A+B+A*B</code>, I get an unreasonably high standard error. However, when I run each term on its own <code>X ~ A</code> or <code>X ~ B</code>, I also get reasonable estimates. I suspect it might have something to do with near-perfect fit for one combination of my ordinal and categorical variables but I'm not sure. Any ideas on what is going on? Is it bad form to just have a model with only an interaction term <code>A:B</code> and not the <code>A+B+A*B</code>?</p> <pre><code>model1 &lt;- glm(X~A:B, family=binomial(logit)) model2 &lt;- glm(X~A, family=binomial(logit)) model3 &lt;- glm(X~B, family=binomial(logit)) model4 &lt;- glm(X~A+B+A*B, family=binomial(logit)) summary(model1) Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Int) 3.4320 1.1497 2.985 0.00283 ** A:B [no] -1.3857 0.6813 -2.034 0.04195 * A:B [yes] -2.2847 0.8017 -2.850 0.00437 ** summary(model2) Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) 2.9572 1.0792 2.740 0.00614 ** A -1.5221 0.6495 -2.343 0.01911 * summary(model3) Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) 1.2809 0.5055 2.534 0.0113 * B[yes] -1.1268 0.6406 -1.759 0.0786 . summary(model4) Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) 36.66 4125.28 0.009 0.993 A -18.10 2062.64 -0.009 0.993 B[yes] -34.24 4125.28 -0.008 0.993 A:B[yes] 16.46 2062.64 0.008 0.994 &gt; dput(my.data) structure(list(X = structure(c(2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L), .Label = c("0", "1"), class = "factor"), A = structure(c(1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 1L), .Label = c("1", "2"), class = "factor"), B = structure(c(1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 2L), .Label = c("no","yes"), class = "factor")), .Names = c("X", "A", "B"), row.names = c(NA, -49L), class = "data.frame") </code></pre>
74,417
[ -0.02516714483499527, 0.0307979304343462, 0.004555169027298689, 0.03623785823583603, 0.022234203293919563, 0.017208123579621315, -0.007340593729168177, -0.03983079642057419, 0.03188560903072357, -0.017091481015086174, 0.06185132637619972, 0.028138507157564163, 0.06524154543876648, 0.0156999658793211, 0.052169159054756165, -0.008640441112220287, 0.02267628349363804, -0.005195718724280596, 0.022419283166527748, -0.010593773797154427, -0.048833295702934265, 0.006120177451521158, -0.0037512974813580513, -0.009046041406691074, 0.02808777429163456, 0.043845467269420624, 0.023220771923661232, -0.00746492063626647, 0.0038394981529563665, 0.04616907611489296, -0.02545125223696232, -0.018909990787506104, -0.02558508887887001, 0.019373450428247452, 0.01673239655792713, 0.06089804321527481, 0.013558641076087952, -0.025881435722112656, 0.013317648321390152, 0.015322200953960419, -0.01650966890156269, 0.01094425842165947, 0.0009198862826451659, 0.004139058757573366, 0.0007068017148412764, 0.015669073909521103, -0.02679562382400036, 0.03073428012430668, 0.06367744505405426, -0.005997399799525738, 0.011472849175333977, -0.00803879089653492, 0.025694550946354866, 0.02530030906200409, -0.03308340534567833, -0.008758334442973137, 0.05976582691073418, 0.07009689509868622, 0.010321042500436306, -0.040836527943611145, -0.0114738242700696, -0.03233535215258598, 0.0170659888535738, -0.01689303293824196, -0.04684407263994217, 0.019262630492448807, 0.04205199331045151, -0.02303912490606308, 0.0635237768292427, -0.02663355879485607, 0.005500942934304476, -0.007953482680022717, 0.023284485563635826, -0.012496995739638805, 0.02627250738441944, 0.00968774314969778, -0.008006077259778976, -0.0019820125307887793, 0.03028533235192299, 0.03542964160442352, -0.03960903733968735, 0.004022297449409962, 0.010022727772593498, 0.021886970847845078, 0.030094334855675697, -0.006166255567222834, 0.022113004699349403, 0.008321364410221577, 0.00439475430175662, 0.005832228809595108, -0.024783682078123093, 0.020140821114182472, 0.061243489384651184, 0.029459722340106964, -0.016896897926926613, 0.06834360212087631, -0.027882125228643417, 0.010587667115032673, 0.050026796758174896, -0.011241542175412178, -0.046054936945438385, -0.05498391017317772, -0.00124818691983819, 0.04789160192012787, -0.040335919708013535, -0.025085261091589928, -0.03374360874295235, -0.01651795767247677, -0.006793047767132521, -0.05845261737704277, 0.01090002991259098, 0.029672060161828995, -0.003068810561671853, 0.01665322296321392, 0.005864778067916632, -0.07192957401275635, -0.01260013785213232, 0.019299736246466637, 0.05863882973790169, 0.020826606079936028, 0.04860156029462814, -0.010167742148041725, -0.010750159621238708, -0.018492741510272026, -0.011790864169597626, -0.0382748581469059, -0.003189596813172102, -0.02473781444132328, -0.03524952754378319, 0.04796924442052841, 0.023589540272951126, -0.044246573001146317, -0.0019539890345185995, 0.01392252929508686, 0.031155094504356384, -0.01619700714945793, -0.04819456487894058, -0.02756214141845703, 0.03619036078453064, 0.001037554582580924, 0.009609220549464226, -0.05536700040102005, -0.017714455723762512, 0.030293883755803108, 0.06991472095251083, 0.02675541676580906, 0.022653352469205856, 0.03327793627977371, 0.026721568778157234, 0.04677147418260574, -0.02020854689180851, -0.009308086708188057, -0.02577432245016098, 0.0028829299844801426, -0.01914198324084282, -0.077573262155056, 0.021428631618618965, 0.0059489235281944275, -0.019579537212848663, 0.018248241394758224, 0.04501938819885254, 0.050860535353422165, -0.006187190301716328, -0.014436358585953712, -0.003724962007254362, -0.002069358481094241, 0.01931392401456833, -0.04674200341105461, 0.0400625541806221, 0.05105330049991608, 0.00021686009131371975, 0.021908624097704887, -0.003458066377788782, 0.04996785521507263, 0.02167205512523651, -0.029066992923617363, 0.020231381058692932, -0.0726795643568039, 0.015564600005745888, 0.00023518537636846304, -0.032600224018096924, -0.04123998433351517, -0.045105788856744766, -0.019640780985355377, 0.02165728248655796, 0.03277679532766342, -0.0005673803971149027, -0.04057721421122551, 0.05950506404042244, -0.016248593106865883, -0.05558192729949951, -0.028549205511808395, -0.02075101248919964, 0.007562120910733938, -0.07093510031700134, 0.010019896551966667, 0.011032872833311558, 0.04323872923851013, -0.0026691982056945562, 0.0030077171977609396, -0.041199930012226105, -0.00791744701564312, 0.03489578887820244, -0.0007433536811731756, 0.011287993751466274, 0.03653755784034729, 0.06698307394981384, -0.028674591332674026, 0.03493836894631386, -0.00835818238556385, -0.03862489387392998, 0.00784493051469326, -0.012037583626806736, -0.013012222945690155, -0.018245218321681023, -0.04268541932106018, 0.000601641193497926, -0.0020323279313743114, -0.010233682580292225, 0.039000868797302246, -0.07693041115999222, 0.06510303914546967, 0.05026629567146301, -0.004452881403267384, -0.0033599918242543936, 0.002673160983249545, 0.0112528707832098, 0.03645138442516327, -0.04226559028029442, 0.022319858893752098, -0.04472082108259201, -0.03765629604458809, 0.08277257531881332, -0.0061015780083835125, -0.03640269115567207, 0.0018049633363261819, 0.0423334501683712, -0.024724658578634262, 0.0032170601189136505, 0.055644690990448, 0.005116788670420647, -0.019693227484822273, 0.03225018084049225, 0.03148973360657692, 0.022517172619700432, 0.013179675675928593, 0.037353407591581345, -0.026890870183706284, 0.03885472193360329, -0.021274015307426453, -0.023541348055005074, 0.049843039363622665, 0.013234199956059456, -0.010022305883467197, -0.02546621859073639, 0.009831925854086876, 0.041323769837617874, 0.0075190747156739235, 0.01026799064129591, 0.05592336133122444, 0.017043326050043106, -0.003928164951503277, 0.011364963836967945, -0.016690988093614578, 0.002555073704570532, 0.04726802930235863, -0.03805164247751236, -0.03729003295302391, 0.010032285936176777, -0.030536377802491188, 0.01561910193413496, -0.04063446447253227, -0.048947516828775406, -0.03675386682152748, 0.0025986398104578257, -0.0018966427305713296, -0.01101236417889595, 0.02641570009291172, -0.030815837904810905, -0.03843742609024048, -0.0009583840146660805, -0.031381379812955856, 0.04571256414055824, -0.023495284840464592, -0.046239010989665985, -0.030803821980953217, -0.04159462824463844, 0.005393738858401775, 0.048997361212968826, -0.012727495282888412, -0.03500033915042877, 0.0427127331495285, 0.001666479860432446, -0.019626861438155174, -0.020117050036787987, -0.03241134434938431, -0.015195469371974468, -0.015224556438624859, -0.016339246183633804, 0.013295694254338741, 0.020517529919743538, -0.0584038570523262, -0.004480598494410515, -0.012162772938609123, 0.0017977840034291148, -0.025474410504102707, -0.030505897477269173, 0.038513801991939545, 0.024576343595981598, 0.02335408516228199, 0.009172393009066582, -0.03265898674726486, -0.011432564817368984, -0.07158683985471725, -0.03870296850800514, -0.00045543446321971714, -0.0027287795674055815, 0.0217243991792202, 0.0027789620216935873, -0.024363039061427116, 0.05934204161167145, 0.02086293324828148, 0.02092820033431053, -0.026247717440128326, -0.006221842486411333, -0.03473911061882973, -0.013431842438876629, 0.03899483010172844, -0.008081872016191483, 0.03942510485649109, 0.044278185814619064, -0.028325365856289864, 0.03318668156862259, -0.01353234238922596, 0.005095658823847771, 0.009099693037569523, 0.03415786474943161, -0.004600402899086475, -0.038272637873888016, 0.027689265087246895, 0.02428477443754673, -0.012652664445340633, 0.006066444795578718, 0.0018950027879327536, 0.0013266847236081958, -0.005787585396319628, -0.030375655740499496, 0.008633855730295181, -0.008868991397321224, 0.012575360015034676, -0.026890482753515244, 0.02647389844059944, 0.008728522807359695, -0.05137811228632927, -0.014692864380776882, 0.004660524893552065, 0.049875691533088684, 0.0021546389907598495, 0.020679017528891563, 0.045497093349695206, 0.02691446989774704, -0.030627235770225525, 0.050213418900966644, 0.0029742850456386805, -0.03090299479663372, 0.00010384411871200427, -0.004816797561943531, 0.009753820486366749, 0.03918860852718353, 0.057235945016145706, 0.000447297643404454, -0.0353768952190876, -0.01779661886394024, -0.022623460739850998, -0.038445163518190384, 0.01701374724507332, -0.08682899177074432, 0.0230387132614851, 0.006422745529562235, 0.033897414803504944, -0.016606297343969345, -0.012486935593187809, -0.02423887513577938, -0.00668543204665184, -0.03902488946914673, 0.01907290704548359, -0.011113036423921585, -0.039285484701395035, 0.02015690505504608, -0.029479973018169403, 0.01720302924513817, -0.03221781551837921, 0.01765633001923561, -0.026786139234900475, -0.0049459058791399, 0.004244119394570589, 0.0014986060559749603, -0.03280845284461975, -0.018444716930389404, 0.023083236068487167, -0.011942471377551556, -0.019442539662122726, 0.0019961423240602016, -0.0020984732545912266, 0.06200806424021721, -0.012566685676574707, -0.02328670211136341, -0.04955821856856346, 0.0021599812898784876, 0.011439572088420391, 0.060611020773649216, 0.010604322887957096, 0.016235388815402985, -0.04127217456698418, 0.04727573320269585, 0.024177899584174156, 0.03687120974063873, 0.047742243856191635, -0.006572536192834377, -0.005795294884592295, -0.03957267850637436, -0.03313427418470383, 0.011657732538878918, 0.01808110438287258, -0.009218575432896614, -0.004594711121171713, 0.06435375660657883, 0.061088401824235916, -0.011104512959718704, -0.0015711174346506596, 0.05043971911072731, 0.00013633522030431777, 0.008225316181778908, -0.017128000035881996, -0.019829807803034782, -0.03843986243009567, 0.001022036769427359, 0.03769979253411293, 0.00944485142827034, -0.020271960645914078, -0.012063666246831417, 0.022781912237405777, -0.0406542532145977, -0.03591546043753624, 0.04297371581196785, 0.03643108531832695, -0.005901124328374863, -0.00033205063664354384, -0.061657439917325974, -0.012502278201282024, 0.03888843208551407, 0.019582878798246384, 0.0058219884522259235, 0.02235393412411213, -0.07219506800174713, 0.002303210087120533, 0.06795303523540497, 0.05821618437767029, -0.0383312925696373, -0.01675456017255783, -0.040071625262498856, -0.007404542062431574, -0.004579067695885897, -0.0367223359644413, 0.04448358342051506, -0.046401381492614746, 0.051971208304166794, -0.023126527667045593, -0.03468146175146103, -0.08824710547924042, -0.008294498547911644, -0.030180787667632103, 0.006702144164592028, -0.009861542843282223, -0.031019045040011406, -0.017515236511826515, 0.04839498922228813, 0.013773510232567787, 0.027559755370020866, -0.0505986362695694, -0.04642501100897789, 0.04534120857715607, 0.010107138194143772, -0.007632407825440168, -0.04210978373885155, 0.019285496324300766, -0.028824124485254288, -0.02384941652417183, 0.04675721004605293, -0.02340121567249298, -0.04477937892079353, 0.016973234713077545, 0.033973049372434616, 0.013800580985844135, 0.0020593819208443165, -0.0010422485647723079, 0.030902555212378502, 0.00888960249722004, -0.012244082055985928, 0.047784775495529175, 0.0312032513320446, -0.021808497607707977, 0.01494598388671875, -0.04490847513079643, -0.0396568700671196, -0.022881517186760902, -0.043364934623241425, -0.03214399516582489, -0.015898006036877632, 0.00035468192072585225, 0.0008962647407315671, -0.0248212032020092, -0.007974364794790745, -0.045367807149887085, 0.0063839559443295, -0.00795056950300932, -0.002551660407334566, -0.01604817435145378, -0.014447233639657497, 0.002588618779554963, 0.011603222228586674, 0.0008787413244135678, -0.006891890428960323, 0.017372746020555496, -0.02032245136797428, -0.02447383664548397, -0.002671483438462019, -0.04354851320385933, 0.009640277363359928, 0.011910179629921913, -0.02299274131655693, -0.027405478060245514, 0.007067980244755745, 0.0034615062177181244, 0.025230154395103455, 0.05958932265639305, -0.023410003632307053, -0.03169946372509003, -0.034936707466840744, 0.007785790134221315, 0.0033396196085959673, 0.008361533284187317, -0.017820460721850395, 0.0186613742262125, -0.010492449626326561, -0.022819656878709793, -0.04091556370258331, -0.046074286103248596, 0.035413410514593124, -0.0307155828922987, -0.0135204391553998, -0.034544698894023895, -0.034678682684898376, -0.0031323442235589027, -0.0025331531651318073, -0.008097116835415363, 0.04417259991168976, -0.04783155396580696, 0.0039586229249835014, -0.03905219957232475, 0.02331933006644249, 0.04660331457853317, 0.032494839280843735, 0.010870690457522869, 0.03457221761345863, -0.03167188540101051, -0.025107065215706825, 0.03670797497034073, -0.054422974586486816, -0.005998100619763136, -0.019265277311205864, 0.008251265622675419, 0.012875850312411785, 0.029546568170189857, -0.00309307430870831, -0.020053600892424583, 0.011642975732684135, -0.031227365136146545, 0.04306242614984512, -0.017550110816955566, -0.005073350854218006, 0.0021112544927746058, 0.014199075289070606, -0.035418447107076645, 0.019840970635414124, 0.009192608296871185, 0.028592633083462715, 0.04855448380112648, -0.03153523802757263, -0.041840288788080215, -0.018498938530683517, 0.0733468160033226, 0.03688991442322731, 0.001939490670338273, -0.010127893649041653, -0.02870767004787922, 0.05032247677445412, -0.0038805585354566574, -0.023806702345609665, 0.03160666674375534, 0.052749115973711014, -0.03306975215673447, -0.01493455097079277, -0.01956782117486, 0.017306512221693993, 0.02428395301103592, -0.014957362785935402, 0.03419318422675133, 0.057507216930389404, -0.031185567378997803, -0.003658521454781294, -0.049838125705718994, -0.01724144257605076, 0.02200823277235031, 0.023872079327702522, 0.052549708634614944, -0.022217003628611565, -0.007362075615674257, 0.051294177770614624, 0.0050404188223183155, 0.022828835994005203, 0.01166451070457697, 0.003916529007256031, -0.0018064066534861922, -0.0010229735635221004, -0.015719210729002953, -0.046528901904821396, 0.061421364545822144, -0.06372679769992828, 0.013705792836844921, -0.045494627207517624, -0.020205501466989517, 0.028821511194109917, 0.0377177856862545, 0.005914461333304644, -0.062201377004384995, -0.03802303969860077, -0.04942600801587105, -0.013702662661671638, 0.003955318592488766, -0.03143106773495674, 0.06015312671661377, -0.001142849214375019, 0.0026445311959832907, -0.010002488270401955, 0.023888282477855682, -0.03435591980814934, -0.10119438916444778, -0.013250418938696384, 0.013430925086140633, -0.020709089934825897, 0.07121902704238892, 0.0007515523466281593, 0.0027281721122562885, 0.02588118426501751, -0.057127270847558975, -0.002454531379044056, 0.017081143334507942, 0.01289826538413763, 0.006838832050561905, 0.028819644823670387, -0.003237274708226323, -0.005848910193890333, 0.02232433669269085, -0.0004714174719993025, 0.15897518396377563, 0.036775387823581696, 0.025538736954331398, -0.0590876080095768, 0.029292460530996323, 0.013344801962375641, 0.015934433788061142, -0.023549610748887062, -0.04172689840197563, 0.014925242401659489, -0.02041744813323021, 0.06881775707006454, 0.025015832856297493, 0.05371691659092903, -0.026548776775598526, 0.026364387944340706, -0.040090590715408325, 0.001028544967994094, 0.002034873701632023, 0.022735169157385826, -0.028679698705673218, -0.02142678201198578, -0.023584643378853798, -0.04678905010223389, 0.005151181947439909, -0.004371053073555231, -0.02880546636879444, 0.02968488447368145, -0.03696996718645096, -0.006994310766458511, -0.0225574541836977, 0.0061712865717709064, 0.004025367554277182, 0.013481665402650833, 0.010519680567085743, -0.04023485258221626, 0.008895760402083397, -0.02601976878941059, -0.0030723942909389734, 0.014532063156366348, -0.04445330426096916, 0.01666456274688244, 0.017402702942490578, 0.031702056527137756, -0.05505787208676338, -0.04477721452713013, -0.015633221715688705, 0.044101644307374954, 0.0016573426546528935, 0.010872732847929, -0.0007878412143327296, 0.0025884145870804787, 0.04395611956715584, -0.030244363471865654, -0.03790571168065071, 0.015969691798090935, 0.021195564419031143, -0.03601088747382164, 0.010907712392508984, 0.008193454705178738, 0.046518318355083466, 0.019862383604049683, 0.03854997456073761, 0.018754413351416588, -0.03485525771975517, -0.009586145170032978, -0.03557993844151497, 0.04782826453447342, 0.018518831580877304, 0.0018027424812316895, 0.03389521688222885, -0.010630456730723381, 0.015585502609610558, 0.004785807337611914, -0.0035133843775838614, -0.0068746390752494335, 0.024048184975981712, 0.0032290301751345396, 0.00024361576652154326, -0.019527435302734375, -0.023731263354420662, 0.004253549966961145, -0.04121546819806099, 0.010913052596151829, -0.05888351798057556, -0.004281435161828995, 0.0014534819638356566, 0.005301900673657656, 0.028382563963532448, 0.03600773587822914, -0.008116375654935837, 0.08004465699195862, -0.016312161460518837, -0.031966857612133026, -0.020649777725338936, 0.03580373153090477, -0.03026195429265499, -0.026617374271154404, 0.009422018192708492, 0.07121139764785767, 0.021657370030879974, 0.044995374977588654, 0.019913753494620323, 0.01772310584783554, -0.0051233964040875435, 0.009625625796616077, 0.0443468876183033, -0.00695764971897006, -0.010552055202424526, -0.02164366841316223, 0.006752412300556898, -0.003386374795809388, 0.0076086511835455894, -0.0458538681268692, -0.045350320637226105, 0.02891690656542778, -0.03183355554938316, -0.054887935519218445, -0.00787521805614233, -0.0052949124947190285, 0.019098376855254173, -0.022434256970882416, -0.02321997657418251, -0.043966393917798996, -0.016704628244042397, -0.006136920303106308, -0.015368025749921799, -0.0000840876018628478, 0.02445833384990692, -0.013926612213253975, 0.015356207266449928, 0.03662167489528656, 0.009551949799060822, -0.014904863201081753, -0.007148363161832094, 0.02408451773226261, 0.054870765656232834, 0.046953119337558746, 0.020803961902856827, -0.024705417454242706, 0.029002202674746513, -0.028144484385848045, -0.040960509330034256, 0.013809015974402428, -0.005019391421228647, 0.024391425773501396, 0.022038469091057777, -0.0006227328558452427, -0.06326385587453842, 0.034181859344244, -0.01228308118879795, 0.008647159673273563, -0.028953837230801582, 0.0074764275923371315, -0.007811827585101128, -0.02336171083152294, -0.0015839185798540711, 0.025637075304985046, -0.03264341875910759, 0.021641813218593597, 0.061675023287534714, -0.04086834937334061, -0.017136842012405396, 0.026682090014219284, -0.044156190007925034, 0.017874743789434433, -0.0036782831884920597, -0.017315363511443138, 0.004577756859362125, 0.06023883819580078, -0.023065384477376938, 0.05294830724596977, -0.00839941669255495, 0.046210113912820816, -0.10334310680627823, -0.05141037702560425, -0.01946154236793518, 0.04254819080233574, 0.019245263189077377, -0.05815945938229561, 0.015032804571092129, -0.002368154237046838, -0.010938643477857113, 0.0050385333597660065, 0.014616734348237514, -0.015102079138159752, -0.07823580503463745, 0.011257181875407696, -0.028531549498438835, -0.028884563595056534, 0.03612454980611801, 0.007560977712273598, 0.03907196596264839, 0.019420502707362175, 0.007267124019563198, -0.03724100440740585, -0.026607144623994827, -0.020908616483211517, -0.02021101675927639, -0.047623880207538605, -0.008883164264261723, -0.029402615502476692, -0.01502543780952692, 0.016131803393363953, 0.029093213379383087, 0.009200328029692173, 0.013750932179391384, 0.05248637497425079, 0.06441406160593033, 0.0791541188955307, 0.046228695660829544, 0.015875879675149918, -0.0032826093956828117, 0.005109196994453669, 0.038658514618873596, 0.02039954625070095, -0.048519112169742584, 0.015868155285716057, -0.0071572852320969105, 0.006913818418979645, -0.01630663499236107, 0.005254570860415697, -0.00782658252865076, -0.0027016764506697655, -0.035327792167663574, 0.03062121570110321, -0.005941917188465595, -0.03344656154513359, 0.0249367356300354, -0.051905423402786255, -0.0005893370835110545, 0.03487686440348625, 0.05074125528335571, -0.03003515489399433, -0.020144082605838776, -0.027814636006951332, 0.03701821342110634, 0.01263795793056488, 0.0024748172145336866, 0.006640651263296604, -0.003875321475788951, -0.022675862535834312, -0.023024335503578186, 0.005430579651147127, -0.01092336792498827, 0.006782803684473038, -0.0562564879655838, 0.05073615908622742, -0.04818194359540939, 0.031358376145362854, -0.01205256674438715, -0.005428343079984188, 0.06011420860886574, -0.1006292924284935, 0.05309969186782837, 0.02544267289340496, 0.005466408561915159, -0.05429108068346977, 0.027277955785393715, -0.05960679426789284, -0.003161290194839239, 0.04531112685799599, 0.010036317631602287, -0.010388427414000034, 0.006595902610570192, 0.06548852473497391, 0.024107376113533974, -0.016360865905880928, 0.024950172752141953, 0.01577010564506054, -0.027793021872639656, -0.019141433760523796, -0.00832116324454546, 0.014959066174924374, 0.027251221239566803, 0.004655946511775255, -0.015501408837735653, 0.0011529219336807728, -0.0010957071790471673, -0.041580721735954285, 0.05776098370552063, 0.0015812054043635726, -0.027397863566875458, 0.026805102825164795, 0.010872106067836285, 0.04808976501226425, 0.07223959267139435, 0.009396783076226711, -0.030849315226078033, 0.00766201363876462, 0.0022334023378789425, -0.020350301638245583, 0.01762213185429573, 0.02124597877264023, -0.012849313206970692, -0.0370563305914402, 0.03806650638580322, 0.026419062167406082, -0.02045607939362526, 0.005867376457899809, 0.012958805076777935, 0.017781339585781097, 0.06522471457719803, -0.026389598846435547, 0.02304888144135475, -0.008476738817989826, -0.014566482976078987, 0.055036649107933044, 0.022778896614909172, 0.012675218284130096, -0.010371871292591095, 0.01638679765164852, 0.010726476088166237, -0.019262991845607758, 0.016312414780259132, -0.008076171390712261, 0.04951808601617813, 0.012361614964902401, -0.033346690237522125, 0.011694669723510742, -0.015950484201312065, 0.04893575608730316, 0.034721363335847855, 0.012250328436493874, 0.06357493251562119, -0.03150970861315727, 0.007614585570991039, -0.0171293206512928, 0.01089395396411419, 0.008530539460480213, 0.00566372973844409, -0.017362747341394424, -0.0037225764244794846, 0.007170849479734898, 0.005320638883858919, 0.023937230929732323, -0.043843068182468414, -0.011186875402927399, -0.012970197014510632, 0.033597733825445175, -0.021320845931768417, 0.00015065578918438405, -0.02583734504878521, -0.0002060331025859341, -0.0062884436920285225, -0.035461414605379105, 0.06034215912222862, 0.059006959199905396, -0.011317972093820572, -0.07544918358325958, 0.004295032005757093, 0.011553296819329262, 0.0318063460290432, -0.017566563561558723, -0.016482064500451088, -0.025660527870059013, 0.026158994063735008, -0.01149262860417366, -0.05140247941017151 ]
<p>Following are the results from Fisher-type unit-root test for RDI (dependent variable). <strong>How do you interpret it?</strong> </p> <pre><code>Based on Phillips-Perron tests: Ho: All panels contain unit roots Number of panels = 100 Ha: At least one panel is stationary Avg. number of periods = 10.74 AR parameter: Panel-specific Asymptotics: T -&gt; Infinity Panel means: Included Time trend: Included Newey-West lags: 1 lag Statistic p-value Inverse chi-squared(196) P 207.1519 0.2788 Inverse normal Z 2.0005 0.9773 Inverse logit t(389) L* 0.5211 0.6987 Modified inv. chi-squared Pm 0.5633 0.2866 P statistic requires number of panels to be finite. Other statistics are suitable for finite or infinite number of panels. </code></pre>
49,932
[ 0.012574110180139542, -0.014028382487595081, -0.004532605409622192, 0.009298311546444893, 0.04347260296344757, -0.012857851572334766, -0.02082376554608345, -0.04602751508355141, 0.02234775759279728, -0.07986181974411011, 0.030463695526123047, 0.013035506010055542, 0.06560204178094864, 0.01996699720621109, 0.05674968659877777, 0.015296921133995056, -0.00733474176377058, 0.015668241307139397, 0.005903671029955149, -0.005580227356404066, 0.013544806279242039, 0.03414371237158775, 0.022825587540864944, 0.0037968188989907503, -0.026593057438731194, 0.03879591077566147, -0.01919252797961235, 0.03616413101553917, -0.0189213789999485, 0.048982419073581696, -0.017581002786755562, -0.026194361969828606, 0.0036868250463157892, 0.001644234056584537, -0.027368510141968727, 0.008860534988343716, -0.015432685613632202, -0.04899415001273155, 0.0022949494887143373, 0.03875451907515526, 0.0024668406695127487, -0.003227920038625598, -0.0006579947075806558, 0.0427788645029068, -0.003986582159996033, 0.041560098528862, -0.0017267438815906644, -0.009281223639845848, 0.07386398315429688, -0.016296016052365303, 0.06306208670139313, 0.033366717398166656, 0.03544049710035324, -0.0026086459401994944, -0.029085367918014526, -0.028253350406885147, 0.05292338877916336, 0.04025276377797127, -0.05593280494213104, -0.05723251774907112, -0.023022495210170746, -0.02486041933298111, 0.0304951723664999, -0.0390314944088459, -0.04636126384139061, -0.002008923329412937, -0.03576783090829849, -0.014063927344977856, 0.03127950802445412, -0.02377774566411972, 0.020492028445005417, 0.02020324394106865, 0.04512295499444008, 0.01158416923135519, -0.006774610839784145, -0.05281510949134827, -0.0019511292921379209, 0.05394674465060234, 0.0138443224132061, 0.055526018142700195, 0.0063451011665165424, 0.03160654753446579, 0.010077747516334057, 0.07531263679265976, 0.031223639845848083, -0.020026501268148422, 0.06675256788730621, -0.015464606694877148, 0.047881368547677994, 0.022930752485990524, -0.033237334340810776, -0.009916296228766441, 0.03650204464793205, 0.03487345203757286, -0.05106452852487564, 0.05110631883144379, -0.018644575029611588, 0.05315256863832474, -0.012725544162094593, -0.022465461865067482, -0.023470979183912277, -0.029770245775580406, 0.024740859866142273, 0.019730323925614357, -0.010761384852230549, -0.007713868748396635, -0.0420222245156765, 0.008104821667075157, -0.002409406239166856, -0.03122531622648239, -0.007881158031523228, 0.017132731154561043, -0.04051100090146065, -0.047562070190906525, 0.049544189125299454, 0.008731850422918797, -0.010761630721390247, -0.014187309890985489, 0.046471621841192245, 0.05290193483233452, 0.050477270036935806, 0.0014721222687512636, 0.00535525381565094, -0.010015454143285751, -0.05308547243475914, 0.03617636114358902, -0.007486716844141483, 0.0012635564198717475, -0.0239759162068367, 0.04750830680131912, -0.011049490422010422, -0.03151656314730644, 0.021682817488908768, 0.003792659379541874, 0.0784892663359642, 0.006774310953915119, -0.06640304625034332, -0.09364073723554611, 0.05703206732869148, -0.003474820638075471, 0.02282380871474743, -0.05301543325185776, 0.026631534099578857, 0.004532005172222853, 0.04786128178238869, -0.020153231918811798, 0.01650712825357914, 0.019444003701210022, 0.013540374115109444, 0.037144314497709274, -0.06074589863419533, -0.012366116046905518, 0.0018438906408846378, -0.022358613088726997, 0.0074818329885602, -0.06519433110952377, -0.01861594244837761, 0.03203039616346359, -0.053661271929740906, 0.005911251995712519, 0.043406758457422256, 0.01871774159371853, -0.011268042027950287, 0.011116521432995796, -0.029563572257757187, -0.03817399963736534, 0.053626928478479385, 0.007377258967608213, 0.027759255841374397, 0.018603986129164696, 0.01337579358369112, 0.019710926339030266, 0.012467860244214535, 0.04700259119272232, 0.02417576313018799, -0.030797412618994713, 0.014636382460594177, -0.029981467872858047, 0.0013770933728665113, -0.01417015865445137, -0.10599786788225174, -0.03279947489500046, -0.039930202066898346, -0.038004759699106216, 0.013285267166793346, 0.030513543635606766, -0.014246939681470394, -0.0317547470331192, 0.03564001992344856, -0.09075399488210678, -0.06282532215118408, -0.043653521686792374, -0.0011097854003310204, 0.023513970896601677, -0.032258592545986176, -0.015825511887669563, 0.008971288800239563, 0.019211994484066963, 0.004948856774717569, -0.027199793606996536, -0.047596275806427, 0.010881040245294571, 0.011664917692542076, -0.0008980651036836207, 0.03180212900042534, 0.047726549208164215, 0.03485655412077904, 0.0013830388197675347, 0.03651733323931694, -0.040091622620821, -0.016558704897761345, 0.038078468292951584, -0.025298520922660828, 0.019002197310328484, 0.006480194628238678, -0.04294189438223839, 0.02798672392964363, -0.0334988497197628, -0.018013983964920044, 0.056900400668382645, -0.05287928134202957, 0.052128635346889496, 0.057563666254282, 0.02806677296757698, -0.004283097572624683, 0.014406036585569382, 0.00244584190659225, 0.02915537916123867, -0.048549190163612366, 0.015146879479289055, -0.06672479212284088, -0.013857243582606316, 0.048089347779750824, -0.002584453672170639, -0.045973584055900574, 0.05312817916274071, 0.03509785607457161, 0.008327113464474678, -0.015213172882795334, 0.040191832929849625, -0.005832004360854626, -0.03184468299150467, 0.02209792286157608, -0.0056982627138495445, -0.0045000831596553326, 0.008199467323720455, -0.011697731912136078, 0.006886438000947237, 0.040016163140535355, -0.0165615975856781, 0.029981428757309914, 0.02921796217560768, -0.00888223759829998, 0.0059220073744654655, 0.007599810138344765, -0.005160286091268063, 0.005402801092714071, 0.01168816164135933, 0.010013931430876255, -0.006535214371979237, 0.0152211869135499, -0.002957613207399845, -0.007971365936100483, -0.012943440116941929, -0.004094754811376333, 0.009345047175884247, -0.028273047879338264, -0.03092767484486103, 0.027263274416327477, -0.015595602802932262, 0.011784560978412628, -0.043959829956293106, -0.016943875700235367, -0.03238160163164139, -0.021297762170433998, 0.00782107189297676, 0.030895980075001717, 0.00790164154022932, 0.008940341882407665, 0.0021706547122448683, 0.0010825725039467216, -0.013110512867569923, -0.0016267248429358006, -0.00371000193990767, -0.028702387586236, -0.00045055992086417973, 0.014914672821760178, -0.0015216467436403036, 0.026676397770643234, -0.010521824471652508, -0.030260657891631126, 0.05799120292067528, -0.03682507574558258, -0.060236744582653046, -0.045272018760442734, -0.020315425470471382, 0.03782396763563156, 0.005237068980932236, -0.04029418155550957, 0.05891954153776169, -0.04398614913225174, 0.04378707706928253, 0.027210524305701256, -0.05526641383767128, -0.017996137961745262, -0.03497576713562012, 0.006796997040510178, 0.004904753528535366, 0.006084545515477657, 0.007859811186790466, 0.01245313324034214, -0.06875951588153839, -0.006292584352195263, -0.05256738141179085, -0.08073931932449341, 0.030626961961388588, 0.024115141481161118, 0.0345756970345974, -0.012619828805327415, -0.0603276789188385, 0.04652032256126404, 0.013401966542005539, -0.007831048220396042, -0.049766723066568375, -0.0013083566445857286, -0.032114043831825256, -0.04664824530482292, 0.002535162726417184, 0.025793207809329033, 0.016565632075071335, 0.05302782729268074, 0.042122721672058105, 0.03642234951257706, 0.039719149470329285, 0.02738620713353157, 0.015506095252931118, 0.0022041620686650276, -0.025918154045939445, -0.021213464438915253, 0.03448726236820221, -0.011642024852335453, -0.017711510881781578, 0.0017571075586602092, -0.020460160449147224, 0.024929355829954147, 0.022919001057744026, -0.03221647068858147, 0.03925733640789986, 0.004700017627328634, 0.011979552917182446, -0.05427923426032066, 0.023941338062286377, -0.013748632743954659, 0.008023830130696297, -0.031437646597623825, -0.012812146916985512, 0.009395756758749485, 0.00996111985296011, -0.010264933109283447, 0.011553443968296051, -0.006275616120547056, 0.01599268615245819, 0.029577726498246193, -0.016610855236649513, -0.03717716038227081, 0.028620390221476555, -0.03073442541062832, -0.007782243192195892, 0.06888293474912643, 0.024249045178294182, 0.025344451889395714, -0.031597401946783066, -0.01437472179532051, 0.019015729427337646, -0.0467451736330986, 0.025089040398597717, -0.009898075833916664, 0.0716291293501854, -0.016634726896882057, 0.05676078051328659, 0.027148418128490448, -0.008235571905970573, 0.020624354481697083, -0.04722004756331444, -0.038089293986558914, 0.04019424319267273, -0.020901361480355263, 0.01126871444284916, -0.009326080791652203, -0.02136467583477497, 0.002534568542614579, -0.03754980489611626, 0.053563401103019714, 0.03687937557697296, 0.009923343546688557, -0.037654101848602295, 0.01461070403456688, 0.010886873118579388, 0.011056407354772091, -0.03315155953168869, 0.007762526627629995, 0.01572113111615181, -0.007627234328538179, 0.041964076459407806, 0.09186557680368423, -0.005434858612716198, 0.021171940490603447, -0.010555454529821873, -0.02882404811680317, 0.03805757313966751, 0.02863265760242939, 0.07093378156423569, -0.006773404311388731, -0.04372132942080498, 0.04024229571223259, 0.015019873157143593, 0.013262073509395123, 0.051515329629182816, -0.00859052874147892, -0.02228606306016445, -0.027931204065680504, 0.007037945091724396, 0.016656752675771713, 0.047612808644771576, 0.019812747836112976, 0.009021899662911892, 0.060936421155929565, 0.025816554203629494, -0.027182722464203835, 0.012138338759541512, 0.06940174102783203, -0.018484098836779594, -0.00018602440832182765, -0.0242468174546957, -0.01931433193385601, 0.007433828432112932, 0.0034055709838867188, 0.04004396125674248, -0.015624603256583214, -0.020887508988380432, 0.004026053473353386, 0.06903484463691711, -0.024106059223413467, -0.009157146327197552, 0.020200947299599648, -0.01915149576961994, 0.05386972799897194, 0.009908386506140232, -0.04690562188625336, 0.025043318048119545, 0.0436951145529747, 0.049095794558525085, 0.053913895040750504, -0.022208521142601967, -0.07682100683450699, 0.024655774235725403, 0.05148998647928238, 0.04151791334152222, -0.027653777971863747, 0.028939291834831238, -0.0679507702589035, -0.010875745676457882, 0.009793463163077831, -0.04831094667315483, 0.015677226707339287, -0.0375235341489315, -0.0025062798522412777, -0.04321211576461792, -0.03595726564526558, -0.024356523528695107, 0.01999114267528057, 0.013123683631420135, 0.053509533405303955, -0.04360916092991829, -0.02801435813307762, -0.018043069168925285, 0.0012095705606043339, -0.016529060900211334, 0.008393730968236923, -0.012563556432723999, 0.005682558752596378, -0.0058885375037789345, 0.04197171702980995, -0.02102702483534813, -0.06844611465930939, 0.006669195368885994, 0.004412600304931402, 0.012202395126223564, 0.06184928119182587, -0.02149246446788311, -0.03988788649439812, -0.013440814800560474, 0.019312376156449318, 0.009331238456070423, -0.006749194581061602, -0.04477008804678917, 0.035741258412599564, 0.014228876680135727, -0.024540074169635773, 0.04134804382920265, 0.013665793463587761, -0.019189145416021347, 0.0010062967194244266, -0.02389947697520256, -0.0011724072974175215, -0.01169595681130886, 0.020327001810073853, -0.019357332959771156, -0.002060259459540248, 0.00664776936173439, 0.033606868237257004, 0.03161978721618652, 0.013353473506867886, -0.07043067365884781, 0.00992460548877716, -0.02580989897251129, 0.014198212884366512, -0.011459452100098133, -0.006657131016254425, -0.002868606708943844, -0.004975257441401482, 0.01643022708594799, -0.01582668535411358, 0.0011708404636010528, -0.024408524855971336, -0.007727392017841339, 0.04259172081947327, 0.0021016530226916075, 0.04394939914345741, 0.006387987639755011, -0.024145349860191345, 0.01880144700407982, -0.021917281672358513, 0.0036432493943721056, -0.03384377062320709, 0.014397899620234966, 0.015230057761073112, -0.031168201938271523, -0.002332330448552966, 0.02970968373119831, 0.018339527770876884, 0.06055290624499321, -0.008359482511878014, 0.05084255710244179, -0.002130915177986026, -0.014816542156040668, -0.06240999326109886, -0.05508073419332504, 0.017464522272348404, 0.014469326473772526, -0.055761855095624924, -0.011186053045094013, -0.051898516714572906, -0.014543646015226841, -0.0279691219329834, -0.012600541114807129, 0.0569508895277977, -0.02262905240058899, -0.013286043889820576, -0.0031117303296923637, 0.026995597407221794, 0.06556573510169983, -0.03591093420982361, 0.014389592222869396, 0.01730877347290516, -0.015343603678047657, -0.03173939138650894, -0.014829645864665508, 0.0051952386274933815, -0.028109317645430565, -0.0017228638753294945, -0.01515843253582716, 0.01311551220715046, 0.023120000958442688, 0.009385636076331139, -0.02550126425921917, 0.022483080625534058, -0.02880457416176796, -0.044723737984895706, -0.0034517929889261723, 0.036695368587970734, -0.02206767536699772, 0.022388139739632607, 0.002917966339737177, 0.026637334376573563, -0.05060373619198799, -0.01564607210457325, 0.04272102937102318, -0.03186160326004028, -0.03555823490023613, 0.023967400193214417, 0.08309876918792725, -0.008021600544452667, 0.016514310613274574, 0.009891195222735405, -0.005256954580545425, 0.03171534836292267, 0.0025966393295675516, 0.014992118813097477, -0.01565028913319111, 0.0008599857683293521, -0.029200460761785507, -0.021299300715327263, -0.01833837293088436, -0.008298037573695183, 0.04244581609964371, 0.016980454325675964, 0.00280870427377522, 0.04004267230629921, 0.0026784378569573164, -0.011562285013496876, -0.003407436655834317, 0.0003663856186904013, 0.026025185361504555, 0.010583979077637196, 0.029651347547769547, -0.029807941988110542, 0.004153682384639978, 0.038329094648361206, 0.046274930238723755, 0.004069425165653229, 0.0015128657687455416, 0.02617928944528103, -0.0019427256193012, 0.014655628241598606, -0.03091682307422161, -0.03807270526885986, 0.03970988467335701, 0.0064038001000881195, 0.02999897301197052, -0.05435533821582794, -0.001907799392938614, 0.05154339596629143, 0.069776751101017, 0.009469914250075817, -0.042192474007606506, -0.004579158965498209, -0.050325751304626465, 0.004698776639997959, -0.005638833157718182, 0.000682179699651897, 0.013324161991477013, 0.007583878468722105, 0.037806712090969086, 0.015566815622150898, 0.043289657682180405, 0.00026594681548886, -0.04379865899682045, -0.04186416044831276, -0.01940523087978363, -0.013395926915109158, 0.04337945953011513, -0.0021166468504816294, -0.009618869051337242, 0.03331967070698738, -0.055878907442092896, -0.010973003692924976, 0.0015799998072907329, 0.023376764729619026, -0.0013199447421357036, 0.101839579641819, -0.01424303837120533, 0.042275071144104004, -0.018809299916028976, -0.026316557079553604, 0.09798584878444672, 0.04165906831622124, -0.02180803380906582, -0.053969111293554306, 0.02356412447988987, 0.0033545189071446657, 0.0241486057639122, -0.03767239674925804, -0.012280195951461792, 0.049032580107450485, -0.026831744238734245, 0.0705639123916626, 0.06163724511861801, -0.0047365655191242695, 0.025854449719190598, 0.007171023171395063, -0.03649715334177017, -0.0338602289557457, -0.0014006819110363722, 0.037425149232149124, 0.0179771538823843, -0.05013979971408844, -0.03365948796272278, -0.03779256343841553, -0.000749661005102098, -0.019677024334669113, -0.008814241737127304, -0.02593914046883583, 0.006690467242151499, -0.025569221004843712, -0.0056167724542319775, -0.012003874406218529, 0.00398669857531786, -0.0023968941532075405, -0.026309587061405182, -0.03612599894404411, 0.018129969015717506, -0.012504643760621548, 0.0316435843706131, 0.0381615124642849, 0.00556149473413825, -0.037429917603731155, -0.0016580639639869332, 0.014805161394178867, -0.01713770627975464, -0.018036305904388428, -0.0008965206798166037, 0.03667936101555824, 0.0006910639931447804, -0.029713576659560204, -0.028481565415859222, 0.025648847222328186, 0.000759012415073812, -0.029633332043886185, -0.011612423695623875, 0.02300429344177246, 0.026672793552279472, -0.053198158740997314, 0.0018903189338743687, -0.06624411046504974, -0.018446993082761765, -0.025421734899282455, 0.05509499832987785, 0.003992901183664799, -0.022840822115540504, 0.018580224364995956, -0.01125253550708294, 0.03857049718499184, -0.05605926737189293, 0.006438442971557379, 0.016986822709441185, 0.007836746983230114, -0.005667513236403465, -0.006472359877079725, 0.005900134798139334, 0.018273020163178444, 0.015156848356127739, -0.0308497603982687, 0.014994276687502861, -0.008350769057869911, -0.019819265231490135, 0.05235102027654648, -0.06330158561468124, -0.028083303943276405, -0.08125810325145721, 0.0170796737074852, 0.009703473187983036, 0.033951111137866974, -0.011413159780204296, 0.026824073866009712, -0.05465235933661461, 0.0503661073744297, 0.03572387620806694, -0.0627269446849823, -0.0001853736612247303, -0.006989233195781708, -0.04268273711204529, -0.02940923534333706, -0.03115248680114746, 0.02596374787390232, 0.02708892524242401, 0.0028012797702103853, -0.011138158850371838, 0.023632559925317764, -0.027295025065541267, -0.003699482884258032, 0.042765092104673386, -0.042433399707078934, -0.017117680981755257, 0.007181800436228514, -0.021826472133398056, -0.035722944885492325, 0.010473337024450302, -0.02806057408452034, -0.021631009876728058, -0.025452233850955963, 0.005172176752239466, -0.06356947869062424, -0.010760183446109295, -0.01467728428542614, 0.03154689818620682, -0.03909138962626457, 0.004598261788487434, -0.04304027184844017, -0.023483779281377792, -0.00017559410480316728, -0.011335746385157108, -0.030376821756362915, 0.03312012925744057, -0.020020034164190292, -0.006868408992886543, 0.03493079915642738, 0.004757717717438936, 0.008533668704330921, 0.007804930210113525, -0.0018100924789905548, 0.009208853356540203, 0.02257968671619892, 0.0017681550234556198, -0.05787837505340576, 0.0064998590387403965, -0.01816265471279621, -0.04978408291935921, 0.007903117686510086, -0.004210432525724173, 0.041694607585668564, -0.022635826840996742, 0.011230647563934326, -0.026113687083125114, 0.009042498655617237, -0.014127803035080433, 0.02332448773086071, 0.011626537889242172, 0.013184399344027042, 0.02883949689567089, -0.020267263054847717, -0.017280960455536842, 0.008996623568236828, -0.009923253208398819, 0.0054314411245286465, 0.08968428522348404, -0.03047393634915352, 0.02310977503657341, 0.032079074531793594, -0.03387562930583954, 0.020507071167230606, 0.022837799042463303, -0.00116927910130471, 0.03884110599756241, 0.04910622164607048, -0.02621564269065857, 0.020945584401488304, -0.03652065619826317, 0.00461183674633503, -0.03276575356721878, -0.013545932248234749, -0.011615818366408348, 0.002798793138936162, 0.02146247588098049, -0.04193469136953354, -0.009903782978653908, -0.006120994687080383, -0.042936116456985474, 0.01868833228945732, -0.018028609454631805, -0.0075975339859724045, -0.016025936231017113, -0.02599938213825226, 0.015022216364741325, 0.053932469338178635, 0.05960077419877052, 0.0044521247036755085, 0.027368417009711266, 0.022325774654746056, 0.023532476276159286, -0.026397891342639923, -0.004455295391380787, 0.014690461568534374, 0.038270458579063416, -0.04580364748835564, 0.0362931527197361, -0.0058602746576070786, -0.009429057128727436, 0.008419190533459187, -0.009266081266105175, 0.036435119807720184, -0.01216201763600111, 0.03201717883348465, 0.015617597848176956, 0.05366668477654457, 0.028838489204645157, 0.01052150595933199, -0.046872060745954514, -0.014749521389603615, 0.02858712710440159, 0.002983364975079894, -0.0023393509909510612, 0.024264348670840263, -0.022060452029109, -0.007751918863505125, -0.0033474189694970846, 0.003665634896606207, -0.028499998152256012, 0.017059093341231346, -0.0018947646021842957, -0.04607664793729782, -0.006927259266376495, -0.008180608041584492, 0.03261146321892738, -0.024456683546304703, -0.03480936586856842, 0.05421130359172821, 0.0031911013647913933, -0.018326668068766594, 0.016216624528169632, 0.0028586741536855698, -0.025865718722343445, 0.03940156474709511, -0.01698063500225544, -0.026919730007648468, -0.052377089858055115, -0.03810327500104904, 0.025565126910805702, -0.04999992623925209, -0.0671498030424118, 0.018357207998633385, -0.028168652206659317, 0.016831310465931892, 0.042895521968603134, -0.0368601530790329, 0.010894794948399067, -0.010814318433403969, 0.04226171597838402, -0.05484803766012192, 0.05852854251861572, 0.014418862760066986, -0.02709479257464409, -0.02566545084118843, -0.04846782237291336, -0.03324082866311073, -0.018241332843899727, 0.056706640869379044, -0.020089847967028618, -0.008402056060731411, 0.0076995366252958775, 0.014099336229264736, 0.0047238231636583805, -0.058246999979019165, 0.06700719892978668, -0.0257900208234787, -0.009822072461247444, -0.007845744490623474, -0.0023252260871231556, 0.01629093661904335, -0.015180173330008984, 0.06279492378234863, -0.006104955915361643, -0.0004151519970037043, 0.01046478096395731, -0.0016670809127390385, 0.015086090192198753, -0.008100239560008049, 0.012633942998945713, 0.05303001403808594, -0.033623892813920975, 0.001872409600764513, 0.05470975860953331, -0.02070464938879013, -0.025966932997107506, 0.018456853926181793, -0.01955072022974491, -0.00904308445751667, 0.018778124824166298, 0.0037297443486750126, 0.034200843423604965, -0.0710970014333725, -0.008766217157244682, -0.020352041348814964, -0.02792890928685665, -0.027542253956198692, 0.037162866443395615, 0.030778106302022934, 0.03397377207875252, 0.005160708446055651, -0.008262692019343376, 0.016794653609395027, 0.000855968683026731, 0.000784119765739888, 0.04866126924753189, 0.024697158485651016, 0.002084512962028384, -0.0015552911208942533, 0.006274693179875612, -0.03707359358668327, 0.013395793735980988, -0.0418112576007843, 0.0778638944029808, -0.040757693350315094, -0.03844861313700676, 0.027391251176595688, -0.02177916280925274, 0.020025528967380524, 0.042215220630168915, -0.008117285557091236, 0.055762678384780884, -0.016589004546403885, 0.030108395963907242, 0.03951643407344818, -0.021279824897646904, -0.03161131218075752, 0.010659564286470413, 0.03156463801860809, 0.014673338271677494, -0.01870904117822647, 0.022793592885136604, 0.02418448217213154, -0.008894335478544235, 0.014515373855829239, -0.03979448229074478, -0.0021865852177143097, -0.004713580012321472, -0.023862771689891815, -0.0039062208961695433, -0.03027782402932644, -0.01087590679526329, -0.018184419721364975, 0.03696255013346672, 0.032083358615636826, 0.029791416600346565, -0.04609733074903488, -0.010128715075552464, 0.026572633534669876, 0.057497311383485794, -0.058552950620651245, 0.02087380737066269, -0.020316114649176598, 0.005914010107517242, -0.009189658798277378, -0.026544693857431412 ]
<p>Following the question <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/24516/interaction-of-categorical-and-continuous-variable-using-glm-in-spss">here</a>, how to I refer to GLM in my project? </p> <p>Just a recap:</p> <p>GLM is a general model that includes a number of regression techniques. I have used it to test the main effects of IVs (continuous and categorical) on the DV and also the IV-IV interactive effect on the DV.</p> <p>I am confused about whether I should just say that I used GLM for data analysis, or is there a specific method to mention with GLM (e.g. I used SSI in GLM for data analysis). </p> <p>This is necessary (in my mind) because names of other statistical tests are precise (e.g. ANOVA). I know GLM is general but there has to be some way to communicate precise information on this technique.</p> <p>Many thanks for any pointers.</p>
74,418
[ -0.03678359463810921, 0.027667347341775894, -0.0038794272113591433, 0.03084736503660679, 0.03667446970939636, 0.03557505086064339, -0.006178290583193302, -0.03939903900027275, 0.039780959486961365, 0.00998504739254713, 0.044922973960638046, 0.028593003749847412, 0.05671269819140434, 0.004785929806530476, 0.0038160975091159344, 0.021617360413074493, -0.012510208413004875, -0.016255095601081848, 0.005521280691027641, 0.022551340982317924, -0.02118910849094391, 0.024512868374586105, -0.026315033435821533, 0.011539486236870289, 0.0016386362258344889, 0.055995140224695206, 0.012610274367034435, -0.04313042759895325, -0.01789659820497036, 0.018343208357691765, -0.037473250180482864, -0.00612805038690567, -0.0061841667629778385, 0.026453830301761627, 0.0022843373008072376, 0.027411654591560364, -0.04900887981057167, -0.015694357454776764, -0.004264858551323414, 0.021348685026168823, -0.0232449471950531, 0.001176766469143331, -0.0009455690742470324, 0.04900115728378296, -0.004306092858314514, 0.003168230876326561, -0.024545276537537575, 0.0019542158115655184, 0.011690857820212841, -0.04437006637454033, 0.033181045204401016, -0.03456765040755272, 0.05236060544848442, 0.04337725788354874, 0.018737345933914185, 0.02742069959640503, 0.04746321961283684, 0.03786208853125572, -0.005796060897409916, -0.042174290865659714, -0.0024245164822787046, -0.038629550486803055, 0.02513575181365013, -0.036141492426395416, 0.005981960333883762, 0.007707545533776283, 0.0007566410349681973, -0.012488327920436859, 0.04745533689856529, -0.035413388162851334, 0.015015612356364727, 0.014812886714935303, 0.033369045704603195, 0.004008999560028315, 0.0350673571228981, -0.0411633662879467, 0.025080963969230652, 0.014953087083995342, 0.04351276159286499, 0.024550192058086395, -0.020611906424164772, 0.005560805555433035, 0.0157750453799963, 0.03370550274848938, -0.005304367281496525, -0.023494848981499672, 0.04893283173441887, -0.012179073877632618, 0.023212891072034836, 0.032007064670324326, -0.008380111306905746, 0.0007207071175798774, 0.022956982254981995, 0.04639901593327522, -0.05213911458849907, 0.043891824781894684, -0.03621562197804451, 0.01178773958235979, -0.01277180016040802, 0.0003565525694284588, -0.003705191658809781, -0.04053115472197533, 0.012920625507831573, 0.056593164801597595, -0.04238403961062431, 0.00825453456491232, -0.02134091593325138, -0.0017663926118984818, -0.021105119958519936, -0.06927038729190826, -0.011063842102885246, 0.014795593917369843, 0.012416728772222996, -0.004259652458131313, 0.0005479130777530372, -0.02159368433058262, 0.007629362866282463, 0.010757263749837875, 0.05165860429406166, 0.04883978143334389, 0.07746360450983047, -0.06194554641842842, 0.01847328059375286, -0.024505125358700752, -0.02953999862074852, 0.0003083128249272704, 0.039591964334249496, -0.03556320071220398, -0.04031405970454216, 0.05488724634051323, 0.034872137010097504, -0.009580154903233051, -0.00822378508746624, -0.00781616847962141, 0.001908083795569837, 0.0028973380103707314, -0.07593020051717758, -0.0875694677233696, 0.043119240552186966, -0.02738250605762005, 0.03340061381459236, -0.03458385169506073, -0.014689392410218716, 0.012289639562368393, 0.05095987766981125, -0.0018692039884626865, 0.012683330103754997, -0.007062092889100313, 0.03969036787748337, 0.0030578526202589273, -0.014857976697385311, -0.057136185467243195, -0.012835121713578701, -0.06110221892595291, -0.01760496199131012, -0.07054320722818375, 0.04699055105447769, 0.03563753142952919, 0.0034132639411836863, -0.0037957243621349335, 0.04158276319503784, 0.004625525325536728, 0.02499294839799404, 0.018007826060056686, 0.009914043359458447, 0.003261289792135358, 0.0491788312792778, -0.034704696387052536, 0.05790230259299278, 0.027020594105124474, 0.010854699648916721, -0.0070006391033530235, 0.02694922313094139, 0.05728676915168762, 0.03410078212618828, -0.03623538836836815, 0.00515309302136302, -0.02538290247321129, -0.033878836780786514, -0.0036683958023786545, -0.057891763746738434, -0.06487756222486496, -0.01684458740055561, -0.00487980991601944, 0.04088112711906433, 0.03417957201600075, 0.006861175410449505, -0.001814462710171938, 0.033105041831731796, -0.0439668633043766, -0.05757288634777069, -0.0516824871301651, 0.038408614695072174, -0.022032488137483597, -0.05251274257898331, -0.004511524923145771, -0.0251000989228487, 0.03426399827003479, -0.018559332937002182, -0.0230947807431221, -0.006805505603551865, -0.012916059233248234, 0.020782945677638054, -0.018875818699598312, -0.019179807975888252, 0.02541353553533554, 0.03577617555856705, -0.07702945172786713, 0.038645368069410324, -0.04265936464071274, -0.035084180533885956, 0.007942100055515766, -0.02000153250992298, 0.03371179476380348, -0.005700973328202963, -0.025030385702848434, -0.015714947134256363, 0.035713791847229004, -0.053692374378442764, 0.0539255365729332, -0.04786641150712967, 0.07933079451322556, 0.08796263486146927, -0.011174773797392845, 0.0387120395898819, 0.022306382656097412, 0.028236422687768936, -0.002500673523172736, -0.0031794013921171427, 0.00025436884607188404, -0.04772186279296875, -0.021380174905061722, 0.05706804245710373, -0.02483760379254818, -0.01788136176764965, -0.0251753069460392, 0.05134545639157295, -0.014495798386633396, 0.019268037751317024, 0.03705659881234169, -0.01947958953678608, -0.02141892910003662, 0.017135288566350937, 0.017931874841451645, 0.030958235263824463, 0.00021298804495017976, 0.024194715544581413, 0.011554526165127754, 0.04781690612435341, -0.004751069005578756, 0.01317792572081089, 0.07731183618307114, 0.021723387762904167, -0.005930643994361162, 0.009394831024110317, -0.0059874518774449825, 0.04036850854754448, -0.019717402756214142, 0.021134203299880028, 0.07324180006980896, -0.008772550150752068, -0.027094822376966476, 0.0215223990380764, -0.006668012589216232, 0.0397239588201046, 0.04157464951276779, -0.06994645297527313, -0.003851227695122361, 0.01872221753001213, -0.042034607380628586, 0.025944946333765984, -0.029527463018894196, -0.04188059642910957, -0.04916766658425331, 0.025743471458554268, -0.019146965816617012, -0.012808150611817837, 0.018842585384845734, -0.01904120296239853, 0.0005624651093967259, -0.014048089273273945, -0.0035345295909792185, 0.00930025801062584, -0.001946232165209949, -0.03531252592802048, -0.005940539296716452, -0.02308296225965023, -0.002971849637106061, 0.013489438220858574, -0.03328690305352211, -0.045301031321287155, 0.038408223539590836, 0.00047816504957154393, -0.05646393820643425, -0.017631255090236664, -0.025274567306041718, 0.017638856545090675, 0.017740823328495026, -0.04335176944732666, 0.021070457994937897, -0.002478895243257284, -0.030218180269002914, 0.005210123490542173, -0.02217009663581848, -0.013057938776910305, -0.015056286938488483, 0.008361984975636005, 0.060541782528162, -0.006257310044020414, -0.0074617816135287285, -0.019190896302461624, -0.028887569904327393, -0.0362510122358799, -0.05213409289717674, -0.06761827319860458, 0.044281188398599625, 0.02780100889503956, 0.045230403542518616, -0.028221117332577705, -0.010500100441277027, 0.09648826718330383, 0.0116380974650383, -0.023718761280179024, -0.06351295858621597, -0.06528908014297485, -0.016056964173913002, -0.023970959708094597, 0.0077523235231637955, -0.0036245740484446287, 0.021139340475201607, 0.012701236642897129, 0.010236375033855438, 0.0180819071829319, 0.004883267916738987, 0.03911963850259781, -0.0012972665717825294, -0.0005720036569982767, -0.004603875335305929, -0.020553404465317726, 0.011707962490618229, 0.05888538435101509, -0.04409555718302727, -0.004156829323619604, -0.02569110132753849, 0.023823974654078484, -0.0060921842232346535, -0.04144177958369255, -0.005874048452824354, -0.031742967665195465, 0.005604790523648262, -0.013570534996688366, 0.015384691767394543, 0.01430519949644804, -0.035400643944740295, -0.0025356756523251534, 0.028911877423524857, 0.01523555163294077, -0.02595055103302002, -0.014728900045156479, 0.03559419885277748, 0.04325079172849655, -0.038184210658073425, -0.029037609696388245, -0.0023353626020252705, -0.017198612913489342, 0.022487923502922058, -0.026985574513673782, -0.02840697392821312, 0.03332588076591492, 0.06817544251680374, 0.008275427855551243, -0.004452917724847794, -0.06701964139938354, 0.011790305376052856, -0.08987874537706375, 0.028034986928105354, -0.031231790781021118, 0.04813520237803459, -0.0029282905161380768, 0.05221659317612648, 0.04056964069604874, -0.013868199661374092, 0.007915382273495197, 0.013069718144834042, -0.03792744502425194, 0.031769972294569016, -0.007717981934547424, -0.024526558816432953, 0.05534323304891586, 0.005725590046495199, 0.031191786751151085, -0.0009332445915788412, 0.013668323867022991, 0.02442561835050583, -0.009339007548987865, -0.029144329950213432, 0.001069301855750382, -0.023284217342734337, -0.024150177836418152, -0.023457877337932587, -0.004029356874525547, -0.005571581423282623, -0.02037801593542099, 0.04983370751142502, 0.01719295047223568, -0.008725875057280064, -0.012820360250771046, -0.03788001090288162, -0.014410936273634434, 0.02121817320585251, 0.03423712030053139, 0.030439630150794983, 0.02811216190457344, -0.047414377331733704, 0.05426551774144173, 0.008509228006005287, 0.009821096435189247, 0.015089445747435093, -0.014707289636135101, -0.026802627369761467, -0.037082940340042114, 0.009202199056744576, -0.002962470520287752, 0.04715132713317871, -0.007594150956720114, -0.016723792999982834, 0.04867982864379883, 0.04817585647106171, -0.029795682057738304, 0.035725995898246765, 0.05602685734629631, 0.003943245857954025, -0.0072667645290493965, -0.0005676072323694825, 0.014906688593327999, -0.012148702517151833, -0.021705612540245056, 0.034753214567899704, 0.024976089596748352, 0.025536280125379562, -0.002966988366097212, -0.005022474564611912, -0.03705741837620735, -0.01933666691184044, 0.004045374225825071, 0.022836633026599884, 0.025872955098748207, 0.03517995402216911, -0.06423921138048172, -0.009736690670251846, 0.04097747430205345, 0.01035219058394432, 0.012202870100736618, -0.0010892824502661824, -0.07967250794172287, -0.0009771184995770454, 0.06987805664539337, 0.0688752606511116, -0.03886747732758522, -0.036166656762361526, 0.0033158776350319386, -0.022064950317144394, 0.01210388820618391, -0.030754581093788147, 0.020188776776194572, -0.04387529194355011, 0.025331947952508926, -0.04033510014414787, -0.005101007409393787, -0.043308015912771225, 0.028781061992049217, -0.026149015873670578, 0.0361342579126358, 0.010987418703734875, -0.016376573592424393, -0.036820922046899796, 0.000252783065661788, -0.0007289878558367491, 0.03162597864866257, 0.0014564316952601075, -0.01566213369369507, 0.024508744478225708, 0.047288574278354645, -0.04524124041199684, -0.04642389714717865, 0.00717152701690793, 0.004131481051445007, 0.00047733692917972803, 0.04033317789435387, 0.0004332214593887329, -0.02784949354827404, -0.002845768816769123, 0.008581156842410564, -0.01500605046749115, -0.016613880172371864, -0.0031206239946186543, 0.052506085485219955, 0.030767293646931648, -0.029366910457611084, 0.05478818714618683, 0.026192568242549896, 0.022752350196242332, 0.010233906097710133, -0.005060325376689434, 0.007918532006442547, -0.0297697801142931, -0.08823853731155396, -0.023528680205345154, 0.027445850893855095, -0.043521419167518616, 0.011492743156850338, -0.010401499457657337, 0.01628716289997101, -0.03352725878357887, -0.028829438611865044, 0.0121074877679348, 0.032551638782024384, 0.01948176696896553, -0.01992558315396309, 0.00585629977285862, -0.02417435497045517, 0.0068506523966789246, -0.0018966400530189276, 0.018254293128848076, 0.011913233436644077, -0.023429404944181442, 0.0032187458127737045, -0.029337363317608833, 0.01767500303685665, 0.008684045635163784, -0.04153617471456528, -0.004561132751405239, -0.04401429742574692, 0.025863638147711754, 0.012841956689953804, 0.023478791117668152, -0.010001599788665771, -0.062238629907369614, -0.006162966135889292, 0.033194251358509064, 0.02974151261150837, 0.0199171993881464, -0.07393588870763779, 0.043243300169706345, -0.031823061406612396, 0.018377037718892097, -0.05240532383322716, -0.05462417006492615, 0.038608770817518234, -0.012228226289153099, -0.01711576245725155, -0.021556710824370384, 0.01367354765534401, -0.024260802194476128, 0.008023170754313469, -0.01606117933988571, 0.042086631059646606, -0.029474377632141113, -0.014044648967683315, -0.035097479820251465, 0.03677751123905182, 0.07156422734260559, 0.011856339871883392, 0.0016109601128846407, -0.0026134499348700047, -0.0038776355795562267, -0.016424810513854027, 0.027756227180361748, 0.0034034615382552147, -0.020020704716444016, -0.02217158116400242, -0.04126114025712013, 0.016034308820962906, 0.013503323309123516, 0.0051814797334373, 0.004538067150861025, 0.00531316502019763, -0.02490302547812462, 0.0026953723281621933, -0.028000125661492348, 0.00013108967687003314, -0.01926889643073082, -0.005524774547666311, -0.03098607063293457, 0.011649621650576591, -0.02850307896733284, 0.015259628184139729, 0.03873690590262413, -0.020709266886115074, -0.0378543920814991, -0.005375836975872517, 0.08201807737350464, 0.008629401214420795, 0.041340481489896774, 0.02890286222100258, -0.007635457441210747, 0.035173140466213226, 0.0005272291600704193, 0.02317996136844158, -0.004915526602417231, 0.028491554781794548, -0.029141707345843315, 0.024675970897078514, -0.023898709565401077, -0.03042546845972538, 0.06191254407167435, -0.03191696107387543, 0.04187270253896713, 0.04276791587471962, -0.022089581936597824, 0.004787316080182791, -0.044515449553728104, 0.013002753257751465, -0.01685987040400505, 0.03354040905833244, 0.07620462030172348, 0.0118452999740839, -0.0035442267544567585, 0.009403458796441555, 0.03567184880375862, 0.013604627922177315, 0.023487800732254982, 0.00581517955288291, 0.00603194534778595, 0.023229315876960754, -0.03399085998535156, -0.033830638974905014, 0.05400266870856285, -0.07291964441537857, 0.009139490313827991, -0.03013485297560692, -0.041581086814403534, 0.026617754250764847, 0.0426468700170517, 0.013259777799248695, -0.042461588978767395, -0.03712442144751549, -0.05154439061880112, 0.019778279587626457, 0.025083204731345177, -0.03648824617266655, 0.021350888535380363, -0.009688353165984154, 0.025653894990682602, -0.024416327476501465, 0.0021505914628505707, -0.06449195742607117, -0.06738285720348358, -0.027924826368689537, -0.04677152633666992, -0.00848847534507513, 0.05912477523088455, -0.011188052594661713, -0.02458851970732212, -0.031845223158597946, -0.041667599231004715, -0.008600850589573383, 0.004982613492757082, 0.0002809889556374401, 0.022474057972431183, 0.08750517666339874, -0.02736159972846508, 0.01560505386441946, 0.00941084697842598, -0.017849856987595558, 0.09176977723836899, 0.03939777612686157, 0.037408486008644104, -0.0662609338760376, 0.02417749911546707, 0.030997181311249733, 0.01895724982023239, -0.006514803506433964, -0.02179683931171894, 0.010573008097708225, -0.04693245515227318, 0.07165291905403137, 0.05105255916714668, 0.019837969914078712, -0.013244107365608215, 0.06760168820619583, -0.01440038625150919, 0.006062434986233711, 0.01317537110298872, -0.006843062583357096, -0.01928369328379631, -0.004874533973634243, 0.0018420423148199916, 0.021718641743063927, 0.033975228667259216, 0.004573776386678219, 0.003330014878883958, -0.015422027558088303, 0.016582554206252098, 0.031121907755732536, -0.017175182700157166, -0.004989494103938341, 0.03066123090684414, 0.05011686310172081, -0.040773384273052216, -0.08150991797447205, 0.01230321079492569, -0.028356969356536865, 0.006695627234876156, 0.053531546145677567, -0.011102741584181786, -0.012482662685215473, -0.003099344205111265, 0.02329183928668499, -0.04250873252749443, -0.034364648163318634, 0.017706293612718582, 0.043714482337236404, -0.0042304652743041515, -0.04245591163635254, -0.052991632372140884, 0.014621076174080372, 0.006034157704561949, -0.043836113065481186, -0.031792931258678436, 0.004612177610397339, 0.03139783442020416, -0.03712420538067818, -0.008225919678807259, -0.03690734878182411, 0.00002363049497944303, -0.0041910866275429726, 0.017219949513673782, 0.021315963938832283, -0.040140699595212936, 0.009664518758654594, -0.02691098302602768, 0.004205884877592325, -0.007603317033499479, 0.015483010560274124, 0.017000066116452217, 0.005999146495014429, -0.04421374946832657, -0.009274635463953018, 0.015099285170435905, -0.0029255112167447805, -0.01442426536232233, -0.016041886061429977, 0.02481379546225071, -0.050631191581487656, -0.06172309070825577, 0.015311743132770061, 0.023493606597185135, 0.02364390529692173, -0.035229217261075974, 0.010763125494122505, 0.023614924401044846, 0.02264993079006672, 0.005009654443711042, 0.016993289813399315, -0.004119746387004852, 0.033708877861499786, 0.01789242960512638, -0.04201072081923485, -0.02415170706808567, 0.015085273422300816, -0.039540644735097885, -0.0001546444691484794, -0.025288265198469162, 0.032621368765830994, 0.018833691254258156, 0.02576267160475254, -0.015246210619807243, 0.04001832380890846, 0.010502509772777557, 0.034596920013427734, 0.006081154104322195, -0.029834244400262833, -0.011711141094565392, 0.014839730225503445, -0.0006155888549983501, 0.005376160144805908, -0.006761554162949324, -0.06543717533349991, -0.027449842542409897, 0.022005217149853706, -0.02765887975692749, -0.030610734596848488, 0.0144868865609169, -0.036101825535297394, 0.010577031411230564, -0.07744202017784119, -0.009684770368039608, -0.0776829645037651, -0.00834560114890337, 0.0045264712534844875, -0.030953673645853996, 0.029100103303790092, 0.012703415006399155, -0.017472023144364357, 0.028828833252191544, 0.04721563681960106, 0.006860305089503527, 0.004666769877076149, 0.01145766768604517, 0.0158788301050663, 0.006245629861950874, 0.07445678859949112, -0.008253495208919048, 0.004145713057368994, 0.043362900614738464, -0.014224830083549023, -0.004332209471613169, 0.01925046741962433, 0.009485363028943539, 0.03761736676096916, 0.03757072240114212, 0.017124567180871964, -0.022979268804192543, 0.04945717751979828, -0.0034717577509582043, 0.0031093177385628223, -0.03262781724333763, 0.006513890810310841, -0.02738935872912407, -0.018936801701784134, 0.018029505386948586, 0.02839803509414196, 0.00020055376808159053, 0.027007753029465675, 0.050827160477638245, 0.0036322628147900105, -0.006964435335248709, 0.03928534314036369, -0.018501058220863342, -0.0011115116067230701, 0.04603579267859459, -0.005110695492476225, 0.048086315393447876, 0.038132671266794205, -0.022577309980988503, 0.009117484092712402, 0.002671309979632497, 0.01506045088171959, -0.06784790009260178, -0.03130561485886574, -0.003610900603234768, 0.03191576525568962, -0.000016859597963048145, -0.031822171062231064, 0.018847081810235977, 0.0016573989996686578, -0.034884773194789886, -0.014293870888650417, -0.006799084134399891, -0.03088688850402832, -0.029338153079152107, 0.02412676252424717, 0.012889974750578403, 0.011564197950065136, 0.0018935786793008447, 0.006599418353289366, 0.015133102424442768, 0.013219894841313362, 0.017664525657892227, -0.022259386256337166, -0.0006455682450905442, 0.01513239461928606, 0.01627066731452942, -0.06619805097579956, 0.03280962258577347, 0.0013028897810727358, -0.016771430149674416, 0.03610896319150925, 0.024033352732658386, 0.03272392228245735, 0.07052194327116013, 0.01969238929450512, -0.0049033332616090775, 0.03200886771082878, 0.03720215708017349, 0.012279781512916088, -0.027333542704582214, 0.014245543628931046, 0.04454994574189186, 0.048979777842760086, 0.0023729822132736444, 0.029549235478043556, 0.008760061115026474, -0.013437001034617424, -0.017181001603603363, 0.018700314685702324, -0.0266363974660635, -0.03130195289850235, -0.014718919061124325, -0.03740283474326134, 0.019711503759026527, -0.023005912080407143, 0.016803346574306488, -0.05896211788058281, 0.012274336069822311, 0.03043384663760662, -0.011326316744089127, -0.0015798903768882155, 0.00981171801686287, -0.0063047572039067745, -0.028455501422286034, -0.002555245766416192, -0.01585291139781475, -0.004171572159975767, -0.04681948572397232, -0.022146139293909073, -0.018253793939948082, -0.012645878829061985, -0.025264957919716835, -0.00904773361980915, -0.031248459592461586, 0.08000228554010391, -0.014411717653274536, 0.009523499757051468, 0.0346931517124176, -0.026082424446940422, 0.0607241615653038, -0.054493919014930725, 0.054634805768728256, 0.03669388219714165, -0.022679118439555168, -0.04023149982094765, 0.021634232252836227, -0.03217675909399986, 0.019317178055644035, 0.07034873217344284, -0.005809027235955, 0.016780618578195572, -0.0017918782541528344, 0.06863956898450851, -0.0037360854912549257, -0.04884212836623192, 0.018779568374156952, 0.008912846446037292, -0.05330333858728409, -0.045391760766506195, -0.03846122324466705, -0.025237679481506348, -0.005098119843751192, 0.028240064159035683, 0.02533075027167797, 0.024617580696940422, 0.008045455440878868, -0.037659697234630585, 0.021763134747743607, 0.039005305618047714, -0.0352923683822155, 0.049008265137672424, -0.026717131957411766, -0.011986687779426575, 0.036555737257003784, 0.002762645948678255, -0.0446871742606163, 0.028665104880928993, -0.04045063257217407, -0.002198347356170416, 0.005828038323670626, 0.010701860301196575, -0.0029375196900218725, -0.07674471288919449, 0.0026167354080826044, 0.0169843640178442, -0.041725996881723404, 0.017206471413373947, 0.014160115271806717, 0.0395442359149456, 0.04024811089038849, -0.030491892248392105, -0.0032765234354883432, 0.012845350429415703, -0.015924422070384026, 0.0118976766243577, 0.04011103883385658, 0.016825830563902855, 0.0015467870980501175, -0.01988266222178936, 0.04859672486782074, 0.021339958533644676, 0.032829392701387405, -0.011456897482275963, 0.015356147661805153, -0.051472943276166916, 0.006536457221955061, 0.012530814856290817, 0.01356135681271553, 0.0007603327394463122, 0.044770631939172745, -0.023126166313886642, 0.047356508672237396, -0.03779100626707077, -0.014479532837867737, 0.000121208286145702, 0.0108639532700181, -0.03696151822805405, -0.026414690539240837, 0.03757673501968384, 0.03767079859972, 0.010723876766860485, 0.014067674987018108, 0.013272012583911419, -0.04558926448225975, 0.014735221862792969, 0.005558266770094633, 0.015713995322585106, -0.015257192775607109, 0.0032084989361464977, -0.039950717240571976, -0.022756652906537056, -0.0352211631834507, -0.006204030942171812, 0.08317393064498901, 0.02676910161972046, 0.00187117257155478, -0.04657699540257454, -0.030564235523343086, 0.0015997214941307902, 0.024293171241879463, -0.0686802789568901, -0.0026607979089021683, -0.014852989464998245, 0.023962154984474182, 0.0038530915044248104, -0.019476471468806267 ]
<p>I'm fitting a multiple linear regression model between 4 categorical variables (with 4 levels each) and a numerical output. My dataset has 43 observations.</p> <p>R gives me the following $p$-values from the $t$-test for every slope coefficient: $.15, .67, .27, .02$. Thus, the coefficient for the 4th predictor is significant at $\alpha = .05$ confidence level.</p> <p>On the other hand, R gives me a $p$-value from an $F$-test of the null hypothesis that all my slope coefficients are equal to zero. For my dataset, this $p$-value is $.11$.</p> <p>My question: how should I interpret these results? Which $p$-value should I use and why? Is the coefficient for the 4th variable significantly different from $0$ at the $\alpha = .05$ confidence level?</p> <p>I've seen a related question, <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/f-and-t-statistics-in-a-regression">$F$ and $t$ statistics in a regression</a>, but there was an opposite situation: high $t$-test $p$-values and low $F$-test $p$-value. Honestly, I don't quite understand why we would need an $F$-test in addition to a $t$-test to see if linear regression coefficients are significantly different from zero.</p>
49,368
[ -0.023151664063334465, 0.020291322842240334, -0.03630056604743004, 0.03236692026257515, 0.023423733189702034, 0.029230261221528053, 0.02355542965233326, 0.010644200257956982, 0.005499700549989939, -0.008316628634929657, -0.007285617757588625, 0.015140674076974392, 0.009545532986521721, -0.03421512991189957, 0.030646519735455513, 0.007953220047056675, -0.018279407173395157, 0.015727821737527847, -0.004660118371248245, -0.007994516752660275, -0.010807233862578869, 0.037117425352334976, -0.003395105479285121, -0.0050806161016225815, -0.00601318059489131, 0.05937209725379944, 0.013692367821931839, 0.004410864319652319, -0.000010237249625788536, 0.01908162608742714, -0.006966904271394014, -0.022125644609332085, -0.011967392638325691, 0.026729688048362732, -0.00883704237639904, 0.00443691061809659, -0.013675142079591751, -0.019192127510905266, 0.0030096867121756077, 0.05602483078837395, -0.019064217805862427, -0.050342630594968796, 0.0007131057791411877, 0.03487546369433403, 0.015179955400526524, -0.016466185450553894, 0.0015567621449008584, -0.010660543106496334, 0.04566268250346184, -0.033696554601192474, 0.0574524886906147, 0.03459560126066208, 0.038631927222013474, 0.03591344133019447, 0.00453326478600502, -0.020979521796107292, 0.03331204876303673, 0.06144702807068825, -0.05163073167204857, -0.07425300031900406, -0.04217684268951416, -0.06829174607992172, 0.01793540082871914, -0.029577484354376793, -0.04099196568131447, -0.0025826706551015377, -0.00165274809114635, -0.017754336819052696, 0.03831151872873306, -0.049865785986185074, -0.0005194692057557404, 0.022988222539424896, 0.03730075806379318, -0.006187535356730223, 0.02304254099726677, -0.006709842011332512, 0.03208165615797043, 0.02207656018435955, 0.08255904912948608, 0.03524334728717804, -0.0046470435336232185, 0.018500393256545067, 0.0072197820991277695, 0.03290605545043945, 0.0011604424798861146, -0.00015339170931838453, 0.056184690445661545, -0.02882007695734501, 0.04914966970682144, -0.004829808138310909, -0.03926337882876396, -0.019825007766485214, 0.043939247727394104, 0.014035386964678764, -0.04211229830980301, 0.03466825559735298, -0.025072859600186348, 0.02914118766784668, 0.03952369466423988, 0.017978785559535027, 0.010935744270682335, -0.046960972249507904, 0.016473880037665367, 0.04712338745594025, -0.0042471191845834255, 0.01431993767619133, -0.035044267773628235, -0.010677306912839413, 0.0017015471821650863, -0.03853783756494522, -0.005715505685657263, 0.029259860515594482, -0.002343731466680765, -0.019040046259760857, 0.023565946146845818, -0.03517574444413185, -0.003880420932546258, -0.020056990906596184, 0.07820010185241699, 0.024641674011945724, 0.036703817546367645, -0.026918180286884308, 0.02066357433795929, 0.003839293261989951, -0.011340980418026447, -0.01608150266110897, -0.0014833081513643265, -0.029228437691926956, -0.012174153700470924, 0.06199979409575462, -0.020517541095614433, -0.0024444558657705784, 0.013179122470319271, 0.0005473376950249076, 0.01782221533358097, 0.0185408815741539, -0.07296694070100784, -0.06205479055643082, 0.04839210584759712, -0.03595142439007759, -0.025670219212770462, -0.052760083228349686, -0.029350904747843742, 0.015486476942896843, 0.05426812171936035, -0.013258721679449081, 0.030031798407435417, 0.007253959774971008, 0.052826546132564545, 0.012731443159282207, -0.04197138920426369, 0.010297548957169056, -0.06214795261621475, -0.02121231146156788, -0.023823898285627365, -0.06781879812479019, 0.002451873617246747, -0.005002794787287712, 0.006561656016856432, -0.00038201326970010996, 0.03695591166615486, 0.0012605554657056928, -0.020761506631970406, 0.03267975151538849, 0.0070686801336705685, 0.015584124252200127, 0.04495781287550926, -0.027165543287992477, 0.02592233009636402, 0.0185565035790205, 0.0011026678839698434, 0.025484353303909302, 0.018395235762000084, 0.0696972906589508, 0.03640732169151306, -0.029596982523798943, -0.0036501935683190823, -0.024187209084630013, 0.02879914455115795, -0.009168777614831924, -0.06111276149749756, -0.020367013290524483, -0.000144412464578636, -0.025426719337701797, -0.002002463676035404, 0.05254411697387695, -0.002794507425278425, -0.02646099403500557, 0.04447757080197334, -0.03107699751853943, -0.05064166709780693, -0.05769376456737518, 0.004353133495897055, 0.0097941430285573, -0.020087959244847298, 0.05182110145688057, 0.015375669114291668, -0.0009334605420008302, -0.018691686913371086, 0.01778278313577175, -0.005510963033884764, 0.02242625132203102, 0.01161799393594265, -0.056667521595954895, 0.06318590044975281, 0.06948533654212952, 0.04479018226265907, -0.02138356678187847, 0.04451122507452965, -0.03046112321317196, -0.04354497790336609, 0.02569984272122383, -0.03956002742052078, 0.01184083428233862, -0.013146261684596539, -0.007772346027195454, -0.011784232221543789, -0.021929260343313217, -0.0335480198264122, 0.05996518209576607, -0.07321936637163162, 0.06474032998085022, 0.03409180790185928, 0.01718733087182045, -0.006831605918705463, 0.002463524229824543, 0.004530586767941713, 0.015925228595733643, -0.062274400144815445, 0.0029925613198429346, -0.050844233483076096, -0.018046190962195396, 0.047934640198946, 0.02866264060139656, -0.04663616418838501, 0.04501357302069664, 0.05923186242580414, 0.02065136842429638, -0.001108747674152255, 0.045327089726924896, 0.00969778187572956, -0.020827801898121834, -0.011493810452520847, 0.025696104392409325, 0.009718750603497028, 0.03873739019036293, 0.01644059270620346, 0.029323868453502655, 0.043372657150030136, -0.00871236901730299, 0.014533856883645058, 0.05696508288383484, -0.018793538212776184, 0.007681301794946194, -0.020034080371260643, 0.015452506020665169, 0.016977563500404358, -0.04632638022303581, -0.0165721345692873, 0.04607773572206497, 0.02323846146464348, 0.0005582296871580184, 0.012179140001535416, -0.039300426840782166, 0.03431856632232666, 0.05175910145044327, -0.03381988778710365, 0.018664710223674774, 0.013456190936267376, -0.04126811400055885, 0.0035510084126144648, -0.059466466307640076, -0.01877017691731453, 0.0056648217141628265, 0.004334308207035065, 0.017525166273117065, -0.017374025657773018, 0.024555522948503494, -0.03939264267683029, -0.0005148203927092254, 0.009018567390739918, -0.026160312816500664, 0.040027257055044174, -0.029888393357396126, -0.07839851081371307, -0.020210115239024162, -0.0525549054145813, -0.027143068611621857, 0.0431596115231514, 0.0011511124903336167, 0.00969074945896864, 0.011020343750715256, -0.03925574570894241, -0.04312290623784065, -0.0511222742497921, -0.005966892931610346, -0.006031122524291277, -0.014182787388563156, -0.02109948731958866, 0.02160780131816864, -0.037563350051641464, -0.023299112915992737, 0.018778569996356964, -0.05033489316701889, 0.0008183196187019348, -0.008022311143577099, -0.030462313443422318, 0.00399247370660305, 0.018817679956555367, 0.018240809440612793, 0.0081362659111619, -0.04372553899884224, 0.008671681396663189, -0.06537789851427078, -0.053772006183862686, 0.026195384562015533, -0.0088123744353652, 0.0237724706530571, -0.017575806006789207, -0.04078413173556328, 0.08121921122074127, 0.06639296561479568, -0.0045426818542182446, -0.05717160180211067, -0.00034808937925845385, -0.048793938010931015, -0.01946566253900528, 0.008007286116480827, 0.0160969290882349, 0.045748207718133926, 0.043910589069128036, -0.04412705823779106, 0.016672322526574135, 0.02346445433795452, 0.0050524696707725525, 0.01690506935119629, 0.037466857582330704, 0.009842811152338982, -0.012150231748819351, 0.018620816990733147, 0.010819931514561176, -0.0009371942142024636, 0.02434372343122959, -0.02150515653192997, 0.02450091391801834, -0.006414028350263834, -0.007942679338157177, 0.025494828820228577, 0.005066792014986277, -0.009535199962556362, -0.023434709757566452, 0.01807965151965618, -0.0013004395877942443, -0.009484455920755863, -0.013447919860482216, 0.005719692446291447, 0.04079515114426613, -0.02389604039490223, 0.009746483527123928, 0.04848289489746094, 0.03714567422866821, -0.011180865578353405, -0.00490881223231554, -0.018953712657094002, -0.012288116849958897, 0.03178945556282997, -0.008266802877187729, -0.014247827231884003, 0.0791303962469101, 0.03126891702413559, 0.02734450250864029, -0.0043141343630850315, -0.037907786667346954, 0.005394295323640108, -0.031263548880815506, 0.009185208939015865, -0.009387806989252567, 0.05323588475584984, -0.01679566688835621, 0.04036790505051613, 0.009430509060621262, -0.0017073655035346746, 0.0019294512458145618, 0.01789950393140316, -0.06419830769300461, 0.01786869950592518, -0.025098111480474472, -0.02739066444337368, -0.003054451895877719, 0.006848975550383329, 0.028772050514817238, -0.012917705811560154, 0.011926854960620403, -0.015700308606028557, 0.019849373027682304, 0.0009183284128084779, -0.0024685596581548452, -0.020738476887345314, -0.028876198455691338, -0.014855630695819855, 0.017015190795063972, 0.007241804152727127, -0.025892332196235657, 0.02314644493162632, 0.03606681525707245, -0.018023723736405373, 0.006548414938151836, -0.03073330782353878, -0.0034423726610839367, 0.024791279807686806, 0.020457863807678223, 0.06596532464027405, 0.016739631071686745, -0.03822063282132149, -0.00807782169431448, -0.004644094035029411, 0.07131343334913254, 0.03078244812786579, -0.012070998549461365, -0.019699815660715103, -0.035143591463565826, -0.01396216731518507, -0.015086398459970951, 0.018852999433875084, -0.022129787132143974, 0.003577855648472905, 0.0650990828871727, 0.03733447566628456, -0.05899664759635925, 0.04666299372911453, 0.035002123564481735, 0.0273000355809927, -0.010760711506009102, -0.030021721497178078, -0.024355536326766014, -0.020366771146655083, 0.0070499456487596035, 0.024292344227433205, -0.004116359632462263, 0.008940206840634346, -0.024035129696130753, 0.04863188415765762, -0.0296090729534626, -0.025486933067440987, -0.015812307596206665, 0.027529843151569366, 0.017950810492038727, 0.0039205956272780895, -0.04337646812200546, 0.003743657609447837, 0.028745638206601143, 0.008707387372851372, 0.02782466448843479, 0.011569777503609657, -0.09244022518396378, 0.004785573109984398, -0.011455774307250977, 0.07348219305276871, -0.05389026179909706, -0.027674894779920578, -0.017558036372065544, -0.008458534255623817, 0.034724727272987366, -0.03497665002942085, 0.029601920396089554, -0.01090930961072445, 0.008079884573817253, -0.015503163449466228, 0.003606771817430854, -0.06180879473686218, 0.027433063834905624, 0.01516716554760933, 0.01701641082763672, -0.037565287202596664, -0.03741064295172691, -0.05657432973384857, -0.007912173867225647, 0.008296582847833633, 0.04586830362677574, -0.02565240114927292, -0.02544422075152397, 0.018099011853337288, 0.012172616086900234, 0.009884575381875038, -0.03731517121195793, 0.014597388915717602, -0.005016399547457695, -0.0022122717928141356, 0.0338936448097229, -0.007048610132187605, -0.026453252881765366, 0.024240227416157722, 0.007959006354212761, 0.00598523486405611, 0.014774452894926071, -0.016680223867297173, 0.014043694362044334, 0.007249387912452221, 0.016211561858654022, 0.08123204857110977, 0.023269006982445717, -0.029834629967808723, -0.0013906533131375909, -0.035056132823228836, 0.005238670855760574, -0.004414978437125683, -0.05507697910070419, -0.03837069869041443, -0.015570852905511856, 0.00413973955437541, 0.0294811949133873, -0.0033776923082768917, 0.000667241052724421, -0.018818246200680733, -0.018153470009565353, 0.017714928835630417, 0.010809560306370258, 0.009279086254537106, 0.017287664115428925, 0.010029054246842861, 0.00818170141428709, -0.036083925515413284, -0.023583974689245224, 0.0022929420229047537, -0.0139295170083642, 0.037380658090114594, 0.029143143445253372, -0.015462584793567657, 0.037271738052368164, 0.03893044963479042, -0.03509875759482384, -0.012879997491836548, -0.021882127970457077, 0.018034202978014946, 0.0008445220883004367, -0.0015769785968586802, -0.03121044486761093, -0.03193460777401924, -0.009014761075377464, 0.01766301319003105, -0.004059946164488792, 0.06664314866065979, -0.02422214485704899, 0.05318228155374527, -0.0030428569298237562, -0.003438986372202635, -0.059996526688337326, -0.050296686589717865, -0.011163201183080673, 0.04058045521378517, -0.04627446457743645, 0.009242681786417961, -0.023850496858358383, -0.05017327889800072, 0.00655027199536562, -0.021893519908189774, 0.07271188497543335, -0.0289895199239254, -0.029593901708722115, -0.002442988334223628, 0.022875742986798286, 0.06368539482355118, 0.001249111257493496, -0.03514507785439491, 0.007724404335021973, -0.007406336721032858, -0.0068804980255663395, 0.011851556599140167, -0.021667493507266045, -0.0352751687169075, 0.00014791471767239273, 0.0020077084191143513, -0.009544430300593376, 0.024989552795886993, 0.01627156138420105, -0.0097154276445508, 0.008375277742743492, 0.013103815726935863, 0.02720668353140354, -0.0214671827852726, 0.03395288437604904, -0.023935575038194656, 0.010987468995153904, -0.02364994026720524, 0.0147006306797266, 0.0016024983488023281, -0.005622977390885353, 0.034388720989227295, -0.03405991569161415, -0.041332487016916275, 0.007970132865011692, 0.09644892811775208, -0.0032517972867935896, 0.04257875680923462, -0.03827471286058426, -0.0006616917671635747, 0.03770395740866661, 0.05780220404267311, -0.016608357429504395, -0.022686192765831947, 0.02614336460828781, -0.04020966961979866, -0.027844801545143127, -0.015345737338066101, -0.004882787354290485, 0.036440152674913406, -0.014676825143396854, 0.05213399603962898, 0.0624607689678669, 0.012782071717083454, 0.01774628274142742, -0.006656003184616566, -0.012515862472355366, 0.030250288546085358, 0.028750283643603325, 0.03056899644434452, -0.0033484448213130236, -0.014998995698988438, 0.047611694782972336, -0.024256844073534012, 0.014410133473575115, 0.04205867648124695, 0.02575424499809742, 0.015494203194975853, 0.041172850877046585, -0.03653781861066818, -0.05697585269808769, 0.03293324634432793, -0.03647778555750847, -0.00222378084436059, -0.016621384769678116, -0.037714678794145584, 0.03983299806714058, 0.043623365461826324, 0.029606277123093605, -0.07359727472066879, 0.007521690335124731, -0.04246371611952782, 0.015264150686562061, 0.019468039274215698, -0.017914026975631714, 0.028086965903639793, -0.020702997222542763, 0.010300793685019016, 0.009309045039117336, 0.0621192567050457, -0.020884661003947258, -0.04111149534583092, -0.06431256979703903, -0.02972433716058731, -0.0275958813726902, 0.03920672461390495, -0.024993855506181717, -0.05868375673890114, 0.008429166860878468, -0.11077231913805008, 0.01476120762526989, -0.009069735184311867, 0.020936744287610054, -0.03133644908666611, 0.03555331006646156, -0.033019229769706726, 0.023308686912059784, 0.006748435087502003, -0.04186558350920677, 0.11104770749807358, 0.1180584505200386, 0.03873896971344948, -0.083677276968956, 0.008391312323510647, -0.004220734816044569, 0.017346708104014397, -0.03171955421566963, 0.0013010840630158782, 0.019454272463917732, -0.01025110762566328, 0.04124196618795395, 0.0888739600777626, 0.0006440904107876122, 0.004717524163424969, 0.06503274291753769, -0.0347406230866909, -0.0015560236060991883, -0.0028989475686103106, -0.0020273448899388313, 0.020884349942207336, -0.027899324893951416, -0.03231269493699074, -0.0163173358887434, -0.008988125249743462, 0.013532676734030247, -0.019043296575546265, 0.0061901286244392395, -0.02077099308371544, -0.011433734558522701, -0.056468769907951355, 0.0014174210373312235, 0.026316706091165543, -0.0037101705092936754, -0.04532903805375099, 0.01955517940223217, 0.006132717709988356, -0.018994923681020737, -0.01599014177918434, 0.04820625111460686, -0.04774712026119232, -0.020250311121344566, 0.01821940392255783, 0.0027781235985457897, -0.04702790826559067, -0.041638366878032684, -0.0284116268157959, 0.03904299810528755, -0.009569988586008549, -0.0180122721940279, -0.015611528418958187, 0.010139460675418377, -0.006928200833499432, -0.022228430956602097, -0.02139514498412609, 0.016398420557379723, 0.04155834764242172, -0.022133152931928635, -0.011589232832193375, -0.018137959763407707, 0.030319834128022194, -0.0010254016378894448, -0.00012475134280975908, 0.04818184673786163, -0.028139904141426086, -0.015427917242050171, -0.000056609685998409986, 0.0626705139875412, 0.010547787882387638, 0.018773680552840233, 0.030899813398718834, -0.005179922096431255, -0.04137115925550461, -0.022706791758537292, 0.02886202372610569, -0.009842629544436932, 0.01035961415618658, 0.016473596915602684, -0.009875122457742691, 0.002126911887899041, -0.022448871284723282, 0.0044133299961686134, -0.01859540306031704, 0.026367312297225, -0.044669099152088165, -0.028451532125473022, 0.010626494884490967, 0.017336087301373482, 0.0136316092684865, 0.00836394913494587, -0.014707417227327824, 0.043573737144470215, 0.0071832300163805485, -0.07285703718662262, -0.01900939829647541, 0.020240653306245804, -0.005870358552783728, -0.0014050432946532965, -0.019764890894293785, 0.04675695672631264, 0.03476180508732796, 0.02825147658586502, 0.022114818915724754, 0.02104027569293976, -0.006777531001716852, -0.01720612682402134, 0.0005195761332288384, -0.04989686235785484, -0.009862174279987812, 0.06869635730981827, -0.0065374113619327545, -0.02553219348192215, -0.03547362983226776, -0.06035387143492699, -0.031617045402526855, 0.01570441573858261, -0.032223206013441086, -0.041584983468055725, -0.0012630777200683951, -0.013504976406693459, 0.01291697658598423, -0.03887379169464111, -0.025240901857614517, -0.06036798283457756, -0.002684246050193906, 0.008019495755434036, -0.01620493084192276, -0.000018531556634115987, 0.03641146793961525, -0.022161761298775673, -0.004717539064586163, 0.03769051283597946, 0.028800541535019875, 0.010344894602894783, 0.01965991035103798, 0.01590958796441555, 0.009374351240694523, 0.041813094168901443, 0.012088431976735592, -0.03737695887684822, 0.024585142731666565, -0.018855268135666847, -0.04148117080330849, 0.026816757395863533, 0.015864679589867592, 0.006780862808227539, 0.009241282008588314, 0.01656876690685749, -0.02528800629079342, 0.05768633633852005, -0.037541911005973816, 0.029217544943094254, -0.0543614998459816, 0.0021306185517460108, -0.013292750343680382, 0.014951399527490139, 0.006307583302259445, 0.00814418401569128, 0.013957960531115532, -0.005439392756670713, 0.06785212457180023, -0.012156163342297077, 0.015763800591230392, 0.014802437275648117, -0.012401933781802654, 0.04429382085800171, 0.005515122786164284, -0.004092628136277199, 0.015314226970076561, 0.04136582463979721, 0.013478260487318039, 0.023932188749313354, -0.0053851911798119545, 0.05245716869831085, -0.1112380251288414, -0.0289883054792881, 0.010889505036175251, 0.013377741910517216, 0.014141633175313473, -0.06283936649560928, -0.03312324732542038, 0.03848346322774887, -0.04699919372797012, 0.011077080853283405, -0.0008095279335975647, -0.005498744081705809, -0.005720646120607853, -0.04253089055418968, 0.011241449974477291, 0.04063258320093155, 0.023202691227197647, 0.0074119665659964085, 0.010012251324951649, 0.02201925963163376, 0.017000989988446236, -0.0005022697732783854, -0.0010930499993264675, 0.015957918018102646, 0.00887459609657526, -0.06394901126623154, 0.02336445450782776, -0.0059051658026874065, -0.049251146614551544, 0.0034418944269418716, 0.008724948391318321, 0.02590285986661911, 0.04060392826795578, 0.04587987810373306, 0.005578013136982918, 0.07370816916227341, 0.015483565628528595, 0.01621371880173683, -0.034972865134477615, 0.010790511034429073, -0.0004251883365213871, 0.015088198706507683, -0.02196534536778927, -0.00756142009049654, 0.004877234809100628, 0.00007689001358812675, -0.020499050617218018, -0.021862326189875603, -0.031679753214120865, 0.01712643913924694, 0.017038173973560333, 0.020888715982437134, -0.0203244648873806, -0.04326174408197403, 0.00011473580525489524, -0.025525197386741638, -0.017656613141298294, 0.0338599756360054, 0.061218515038490295, -0.007044995203614235, 0.00007133100007195026, -0.04180394485592842, -0.03178292140364647, 0.01954757794737816, -0.03050987422466278, -0.009318128228187561, -0.06681393831968307, 0.016409222036600113, -0.021229878067970276, -0.009317699819803238, -0.03173799812793732, -0.02538503333926201, -0.04507065564393997, 0.016663093119859695, -0.0177560206502676, -0.015570982359349728, -0.0026664314791560173, -0.02184494212269783, 0.01713738963007927, -0.09429159760475159, 0.05686206370592117, -0.012459855526685715, 0.00387576618231833, -0.007895566523075104, 0.03913252428174019, -0.06196945533156395, 0.020470386371016502, 0.037789493799209595, 0.0350017175078392, 0.019610032439231873, 0.02842300944030285, 0.024561269208788872, 0.01631954126060009, -0.06701532006263733, 0.04895650967955589, 0.005351882893592119, -0.02520129643380642, -0.02427026443183422, -0.0038819427136331797, 0.01780291087925434, 0.013922508805990219, 0.009555630385875702, -0.01119615975767374, -0.0018022967269644141, -0.007921603508293629, 0.02766929194331169, 0.051525648683309555, 0.010973449796438217, -0.02106911689043045, 0.05322452634572983, 0.042659640312194824, 0.021299928426742554, 0.024249406531453133, 0.01745433919131756, -0.03295310586690903, 0.025607001036405563, 0.013500891625881195, -0.008552120067179203, 0.023068688809871674, 0.014150531031191349, -0.010967125184834003, -0.05626664310693741, 0.012682382017374039, 0.03526407480239868, -0.02912747487425804, -0.007423302624374628, 0.014976412989199162, 0.029308250173926353, 0.03939840570092201, 0.012492673471570015, 0.0242154598236084, 0.008941085077822208, -0.044557247310876846, 0.006181675475090742, -0.003160436637699604, 0.043211713433265686, 0.00014821591321378946, 0.026740852743387222, 0.04014182463288307, -0.027099890634417534, 0.011086365208029747, 0.0011662773322314024, 0.04504938796162605, -0.01287307869642973, -0.023314623162150383, 0.04264193773269653, 0.02889588102698326, 0.021662015467882156, -0.025086872279644012, 0.00500402832403779, 0.06871762126684189, -0.06342043727636337, -0.030926493927836418, -0.030822090804576874, -0.0014508928870782256, -0.007356666494160891, -0.02157200500369072, 0.008287418633699417, 0.014850775711238384, -0.007266212720423937, 0.016406171023845673, -0.012291868217289448, -0.026407893747091293, 0.03396676480770111, 0.007569347973912954, -0.012051324360072613, -0.02797158807516098, -0.02549034170806408, -0.030820436775684357, -0.02212022989988327, -0.05862648785114288, -0.052197374403476715, 0.0070400480180978775, 0.05025380849838257, 0.01410660706460476, -0.04939586669206619, -0.040027521550655365, -0.011247490532696247, 0.042427681386470795, -0.04121297225356102, -0.0349767729640007, -0.0029115069191902876, 0.030425332486629486, 0.045708294957876205, -0.029556505382061005 ]
<p>I'm working with a dataset consisting of degradation rates for proteins in an organism, a total of approx 3750 rates in total. Obtaining these rates is difficult, so the majority of rates are reported with only n=1, however a small subset have been reported with n=2, so the sample standard deviation for each protein can be (poorly) estimated from this.</p> <p>The rates are sampled from a large population of cells so, it's reasonable to say that any variance is experimental rather than due to variance between cells. </p> <p>My question is: if all the errors are due to experimental error, and thus probably drawn from the same distribution, is it reasonable to attempt to infer the error distribution and then extrapolate this to the proteins whose rate has only been sampled once?</p> <p>Alternatively, am I missing a trick, and should really be doing something completely different! I don't have much formal statistical training, so am at a bit of a loss here.</p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p>
74,419
[ -0.039006367325782776, -0.0090292664244771, -0.025835512205958366, -0.015590393915772438, 0.0052941711619496346, 0.0024912382941693068, 0.003715347498655319, -0.006824049167335033, -0.006810169201344252, -0.008127470500767231, 0.036741070449352264, 0.048215754330158234, 0.05847743898630142, 0.0392572246491909, 0.005682040471583605, 0.009862611070275307, -0.016953393816947937, -0.006767047569155693, -0.019409865140914917, -0.0008305956143885851, 0.01570052281022072, 0.025118323042988777, -0.02389357052743435, -0.019614290446043015, -0.06191908195614815, 0.0006869250210002065, 0.02799784392118454, -0.022747118026018143, 0.01768328994512558, 0.06598162651062012, -0.02800658717751503, 0.006585319526493549, 0.026679398491978645, 0.055296678096055984, 0.0384964756667614, 0.018083935603499413, -0.03467896580696106, -0.047373756766319275, 0.0075336722657084465, 0.053754571825265884, -0.05669645965099335, 0.010558830574154854, -0.008486575447022915, 0.021153712645173073, 0.018062274903059006, 0.013256940059363842, -0.034595660865306854, -0.025660449638962746, 0.015293920412659645, -0.04817644879221916, 0.07801347970962524, -0.0060854386538267136, 0.014304875396192074, 0.012738908641040325, -0.032160867005586624, 0.021194742992520332, 0.06569492071866989, 0.05482570454478264, 0.012704777531325817, -0.0419004000723362, -0.004328455310314894, -0.010611244477331638, 0.0006514798733405769, -0.00861966423690319, -0.026238689199090004, -0.0038843825459480286, -0.005855386611074209, -0.02613825909793377, 0.04945799708366394, 0.015211230143904686, 0.0019653767812997103, 0.01004565879702568, 0.03499933332204819, 0.007189089432358742, -0.00727381557226181, -0.01716483198106289, 0.028214063495397568, -0.011275248602032661, 0.015450747683644295, 0.047732848674058914, -0.00933342520147562, 0.024760225787758827, 0.05931643024086952, 0.04910930618643761, 0.029039178043603897, -0.021742815151810646, 0.04216191545128822, -0.03812259063124657, 0.015535151585936546, 0.027226276695728302, 0.01822933368384838, -0.00006937787838978693, 0.06269412487745285, 0.004704541526734829, -0.050269484519958496, -0.0035353591665625572, -0.009156442247331142, 0.036997172981500626, -0.017596323043107986, -0.029596548527479172, -0.02068745344877243, -0.055292364209890366, 0.011390838772058487, 0.05048876255750656, -0.036922115832567215, -0.01717943698167801, 0.01413981057703495, 0.0038148013409227133, -0.039804842323064804, -0.012095306999981403, -0.0050685410387814045, -0.01203982438892126, 0.02169477567076683, 0.02260318025946617, 0.014468537643551826, 0.01181423757225275, -0.02015724591910839, 0.015127071179449558, 0.06903231889009476, 0.07397422194480896, 0.0139206787571311, -0.057495951652526855, 0.05153226852416992, 0.008413180708885193, -0.031274281442165375, 0.024235673248767853, 0.038499049842357635, -0.04672730341553688, -0.048635680228471756, 0.04295676574110985, -0.0016549949068576097, -0.037087541073560715, 0.07096237689256668, 0.002933954121544957, 0.036062609404325485, 0.002488991478458047, -0.11476971209049225, -0.07921431213617325, 0.024060796946287155, -0.02970827929675579, -0.014758167788386345, -0.08641406148672104, -0.006671466398984194, 0.03324403613805771, 0.01989535242319107, 0.03151184320449829, 0.038566842675209045, 0.0034907276276499033, 0.009138481691479683, -0.00021528829529415816, 0.006193791050463915, 0.002425841288641095, 0.021299635991454124, -0.020327048376202583, -0.02115653268992901, -0.03843341022729874, 0.03219056501984596, 0.01185656152665615, 0.036770060658454895, 0.012361539527773857, 0.016999078914523125, -0.0038893066812306643, 0.017740648239850998, -0.010645410977303982, 0.055155761539936066, -0.015013025142252445, 0.07767008244991302, 0.0055299075320363045, 0.026289019733667374, -0.006335938815027475, -0.008046787232160568, -0.007706546224653721, 0.0018738958751782775, 0.021090205758810043, 0.049024391919374466, -0.05103577673435211, -0.011262341402471066, -0.0006475757691077888, 0.014633126556873322, -0.0003503202460706234, -0.02104099839925766, 0.00761764170601964, 0.011029587127268314, -0.020674770697951317, 0.03502415865659714, 0.030913731083273888, -0.010808342136442661, -0.017241841182112694, 0.040613770484924316, -0.0275422353297472, -0.020314309746026993, -0.05215057358145714, -0.027088632807135582, -0.03180783987045288, -0.02681894227862358, 0.002719430485740304, -0.016545910388231277, -0.01119434367865324, -0.018032973632216454, 0.022206759080290794, -0.028862589970231056, -0.023245740681886673, 0.033005841076374054, -0.026413913816213608, -0.002079758094623685, 0.028121955692768097, 0.023642733693122864, 0.0015877775149419904, 0.059881966561079025, -0.013031627051532269, -0.04710156470537186, 0.001350653008557856, -0.0595124326646328, 0.011861789971590042, 0.01687464863061905, -0.0036209530662745237, 0.045118384063243866, -0.02543117292225361, -0.017635585740208626, 0.030386347323656082, -0.031572774052619934, 0.07799738645553589, 0.04946901276707649, -0.0015981713077053428, -0.00783555582165718, -0.00403551384806633, 0.025848621502518654, 0.012990718707442284, -0.020060189068317413, -0.005003537051379681, -0.035724665969610214, -0.01938166655600071, 0.04209556430578232, 0.008806666359305382, -0.025657813996076584, -0.0009726877906359732, 0.04699938744306564, -0.012043907307088375, 0.00492505170404911, 0.017816435545682907, -0.027512548491358757, -0.031172052025794983, 0.033479779958724976, 0.028519337996840477, 0.04358779639005661, 0.03817212954163551, 0.010012637823820114, -0.002574624726548791, 0.02160007506608963, 0.011811265721917152, 0.0392770878970623, 0.015073384158313274, -0.020500190556049347, -0.01208262424916029, 0.011292780749499798, -0.00004108576467842795, 0.042110785841941833, -0.004518589470535517, 0.03921985253691673, 0.023466242477297783, -0.01353287324309349, 0.011653585359454155, 0.013305097818374634, -0.019713550806045532, 0.04678480699658394, -0.005940315779298544, -0.03478887304663658, -0.01345501746982336, 0.007201863918453455, -0.018875926733016968, -0.009174956008791924, -0.030727528035640717, -0.05061034485697746, 0.02191934548318386, 0.006915717385709286, 0.023493481799960136, 0.0005250323447398841, 0.014981722459197044, -0.013765387237071991, -0.010319801047444344, 0.00404623057693243, -0.00715258251875639, 0.023020461201667786, 0.01349328551441431, -0.03104853443801403, 0.0234716534614563, 0.016432156786322594, -0.058312613517045975, 0.05460141599178314, -0.0048418473452329636, 0.02199041098356247, 0.051082734018564224, 0.022511087357997894, -0.029503637924790382, -0.02745880000293255, -0.02996869571506977, 0.012591882608830929, -0.004115793853998184, -0.016679443418979645, 0.03702098876237869, -0.004864349029958248, -0.016419680789113045, 0.04506922885775566, -0.04948560893535614, -0.011118044145405293, -0.0391094796359539, 0.017787562683224678, 0.017374105751514435, -0.024871233850717545, -0.013296348974108696, 0.05730930343270302, 0.008481988683342934, -0.0280217994004488, -0.06908658146858215, -0.07606173306703568, 0.000576838559936732, 0.012773735448718071, 0.02409287355840206, 0.01635165885090828, -0.011761186644434929, 0.10969310253858566, 0.032360561192035675, -0.056067805737257004, 0.028750743716955185, 0.014524342492222786, -0.013741577044129372, -0.03405437245965004, 0.04687764123082161, -0.024025212973356247, -0.015492179431021214, 0.014493582770228386, 0.013885500840842724, 0.02678997442126274, 0.04871316999197006, -0.027592966333031654, 0.0070045641623437405, 0.008608723059296608, 0.015688663348555565, 0.005286265164613724, 0.021153703331947327, 0.03148369863629341, -0.03962664678692818, 0.015786441043019295, 0.015310420654714108, 0.026862019672989845, 0.013264195993542671, -0.057086993008852005, 0.026074331253767014, -0.018296265974640846, 0.028073865920305252, -0.019885480403900146, 0.012509206309914589, 0.054897308349609375, -0.017446620389819145, 0.02373923361301422, 0.01212568674236536, 0.024435827508568764, -0.009668922051787376, 0.009015612304210663, 0.07158338278532028, 0.043211929500103, 0.009089278988540173, -0.039891425520181656, -0.021571075543761253, -0.015717143192887306, 0.013740317896008492, -0.008861444890499115, -0.031574830412864685, 0.03966284543275833, 0.04784339666366577, -0.00036514311796054244, -0.03000730834901333, -0.05616483464837074, 0.029095498844981194, -0.07910006493330002, -0.014405880123376846, -0.0010001780465245247, 0.02751801535487175, 0.0037303597200661898, 0.04615060240030289, -0.008950848132371902, -0.010774894617497921, -0.011924202553927898, 0.04020656272768974, -0.06134328991174698, 0.010951889678835869, 0.018317248672246933, -0.0441240631043911, -0.017938533797860146, -0.0463380366563797, 0.05047675594687462, -0.03502186760306358, 0.023691769689321518, 0.026189429685473442, 0.02087114006280899, -0.032627590000629425, 0.008890731260180473, -0.0200129933655262, 0.013473636470735073, -0.026927148923277855, 0.02822146937251091, -0.011497881263494492, -0.013187446631491184, 0.008512476459145546, 0.026470094919204712, -0.013163657858967781, -0.025934549048542976, -0.0335204117000103, 0.022598158568143845, 0.019584015011787415, 0.05810604244470596, 0.0016610798193141818, 0.04833441227674484, -0.040101442486047745, 0.0586136095225811, -0.029913675040006638, 0.027747679501771927, 0.069379061460495, 0.004008012358099222, -0.021373268216848373, -0.0389452762901783, -0.021089237183332443, 0.028611309826374054, 0.012660648673772812, 0.01957794278860092, -0.014482611790299416, 0.039559442549943924, 0.031881868839263916, -0.05782290920615196, 0.010388067923486233, 0.05800333619117737, -0.014482283964753151, 0.003585666185244918, -0.04075078293681145, -0.03126048669219017, -0.001099556335248053, -0.002938322490081191, 0.024824930354952812, 0.02698430046439171, 0.01585216261446476, 0.006826793774962425, 0.0026279217563569546, 0.030892951413989067, -0.02906067855656147, -0.001018302165903151, 0.01622839830815792, 0.03982121869921684, 0.010914661921560764, 0.01398497074842453, 0.027110612019896507, 0.003840486751869321, 0.07205898314714432, 0.030266543850302696, -0.006330243777483702, -0.09039443731307983, -0.002674235263839364, 0.032078035175800323, 0.025901829823851585, -0.054198019206523895, -0.011909479275345802, -0.012806721962988377, -0.004345316905528307, 0.023365749046206474, -0.036634426563978195, 0.0029431565199047327, 0.01206835824996233, 0.016388824209570885, -0.024436192587018013, -0.02324986830353737, -0.019283166155219078, -0.0054076663218438625, -0.025648359209299088, 0.04171796143054962, -0.014330255798995495, -0.013800475746393204, -0.035289764404296875, -0.003727990435436368, 0.021217036992311478, 0.10854986310005188, -0.015683162957429886, -0.017950069159269333, -0.0044618756510317326, 0.0278110783547163, -0.041225455701351166, -0.05518701300024986, 0.03852834179997444, -0.01735864207148552, 0.0005077483947388828, 0.025492621585726738, -0.024504495784640312, -0.07210975140333176, 0.05389291048049927, 0.002097400138154626, -0.023657076060771942, -0.00971292145550251, -0.00665188068524003, 0.015175169333815575, 0.05003531277179718, 0.006730931345373392, 0.06286157667636871, 0.035969678312540054, 0.005997711326926947, 0.011734473519027233, -0.05309431999921799, 0.03681664541363716, -0.04830218106508255, -0.0436401329934597, -0.05821739137172699, -0.01964268460869789, 0.003692544996738434, -0.014506705105304718, 0.023968417197465897, 0.061579883098602295, -0.009033485315740108, -0.03787098452448845, 0.037293486297130585, 0.012221978977322578, 0.02717231959104538, -0.014755905605852604, -0.029678454622626305, 0.025955386459827423, -0.046619854867458344, -0.021112065762281418, -0.024557605385780334, -0.01391406636685133, 0.003574735252186656, 0.037149153649806976, -0.047358617186546326, -0.029490875080227852, -0.06284120678901672, -0.03576863184571266, 0.028164666146039963, -0.0242508202791214, 0.04051440581679344, -0.002580018946900964, 0.04649687930941582, -0.006574313621968031, -0.03192468732595444, -0.01507229171693325, 0.03186576068401337, -0.02380182594060898, 0.04346198961138725, -0.05003418028354645, 0.024523943662643433, -0.04802021011710167, 0.030215859413146973, -0.09551160782575607, -0.030100928619503975, 0.041853807866573334, 0.008219095878303051, -0.034833747893571854, -0.02389436773955822, -0.01963052712380886, 0.014925875701010227, -0.012346602976322174, -0.002384259831160307, 0.04167230427265167, -0.02200128883123398, -0.011928346939384937, -0.009594508446753025, 0.02963417023420334, 0.08045884221792221, -0.028391283005475998, 0.032895199954509735, 0.022279789671301842, -0.02036626636981964, -0.015244191512465477, -0.011102323420345783, 0.02527735009789467, -0.014162576757371426, 0.004159712232649326, -0.019669296219944954, -0.001306793186813593, 0.02767927013337612, -0.036011431366205215, -0.0025693506468087435, 0.030476829037070274, -0.007607550360262394, 0.0320109948515892, -0.02124086208641529, 0.043449517339468, -0.020911868661642075, 0.002358888741582632, -0.00662633590400219, 0.024430638179183006, 0.025566494092345238, 0.03386978805065155, 0.023527495563030243, 0.03942467272281647, -0.0186317078769207, 0.053059328347444534, 0.03543848544359207, -0.027236664667725563, -0.04243668168783188, -0.0027893048245459795, -0.06332781910896301, 0.03009244240820408, 0.0033394559286534786, 0.027567707002162933, -0.008078616112470627, 0.009729118086397648, -0.04747537150979042, -0.027882009744644165, -0.051432084292173386, 0.008530900813639164, 0.06468919664621353, 0.018714044243097305, 0.021234139800071716, 0.0195750892162323, 0.04385837912559509, -0.013964335434138775, -0.037017956376075745, -0.019003843888640404, -0.014105004258453846, -0.005107903853058815, 0.04272231459617615, -0.004114057868719101, -0.0052155680023133755, 0.011251406744122505, -0.006303291767835617, 0.014782982878386974, 0.059933967888355255, -0.005094979889690876, -0.006778530776500702, 0.011900457553565502, -0.004892042372375727, -0.06047680974006653, 0.016190890222787857, -0.039061155170202255, 0.035536862909793854, -0.02887527272105217, -0.022410625591874123, 0.05474385619163513, 0.026318753138184547, 0.018270578235387802, -0.0419156551361084, -0.022445445880293846, -0.05796970799565315, 0.01727081462740898, -0.01733008399605751, 0.006787401158362627, 0.014179157093167305, -0.020229846239089966, 0.05224385857582092, -0.0062758103013038635, 0.04635440185666084, -0.023928815498948097, -0.10344351828098297, 0.00770356273278594, -0.028292523697018623, -0.03649135306477547, 0.03162367269396782, 0.007061798591166735, -0.01838555932044983, 0.00015683882520534098, -0.01502373069524765, 0.054139021784067154, 0.014806914143264294, 0.07756529748439789, -0.029310183599591255, 0.05641080066561699, 0.001810704474337399, -0.002074264455586672, -0.010981932282447815, 0.03231440857052803, 0.11295496672391891, 0.04831559956073761, 0.04265063628554344, -0.04230972006917, 0.001454562647268176, -0.034564848989248276, -0.0021347706206142902, 0.009506303817033768, -0.000055158143368316814, 0.0029123949352651834, 0.01016522478312254, 0.022102806717157364, 0.013376599177718163, 0.00958859734237194, -0.010875320993363857, 0.05913551151752472, 0.011391881853342056, -0.009708043187856674, 0.01621263101696968, 0.01990245096385479, 0.015838777646422386, -0.016874665394425392, -0.014190698973834515, 0.03260717913508415, 0.03651335462927818, -0.01824052445590496, -0.025309139862656593, -0.0029912549071013927, -0.0408773310482502, -0.003154993988573551, -0.02225220948457718, -0.008259087800979614, -0.007985984906554222, 0.0029739406891167164, -0.02648652158677578, -0.0034838905557990074, -0.025911957025527954, -0.019579043611884117, 0.021454166620969772, 0.030615974217653275, 0.030883649364113808, 0.009790278971195221, 0.03778005763888359, 0.018685834482312202, -0.04167257994413376, -0.03770852088928223, -0.04093027859926224, 0.04270165413618088, -0.05845848470926285, -0.0073822843842208385, -0.0024279672652482986, -0.042136792093515396, -0.004606946837157011, -0.044862739741802216, -0.014098837971687317, 0.015507391653954983, -0.008420909754931927, -0.03280583769083023, -0.005829522851854563, -0.02432416006922722, 0.024405792355537415, -0.029465556144714355, 0.0023057153448462486, 0.04499064385890961, -0.03576156869530678, -0.03582959249615669, -0.00048425307613797486, 0.006521822419017553, 0.0074598160572350025, -0.003035667585209012, 0.0008782401564531028, -0.019373992457985878, -0.03296376392245293, 0.013199938461184502, 0.03678399696946144, -0.007357215508818626, 0.05135419964790344, -0.02555515430867672, -0.006078924052417278, -0.0038960573729127645, -0.06342591345310211, 0.03476306423544884, 0.006155857350677252, -0.006012562662363052, -0.052304577082395554, 0.024362832307815552, 0.010299592278897762, 0.01860794983804226, 0.024952124804258347, 0.04858742654323578, -0.0005640809540636837, 0.07548985630273819, 0.0007616318762302399, -0.04244768247008324, 0.030307374894618988, -0.015360688790678978, -0.011445662938058376, -0.027521153911948204, 0.01629820466041565, 0.06181088462471962, 0.00492172222584486, 0.02361837401986122, 0.009952899999916553, 0.011136231012642384, 0.0398983433842659, 0.015133869834244251, 0.014354085549712181, -0.052965130656957626, 0.015838483348488808, -0.0007769227377139032, 0.037345971912145615, -0.02851066179573536, -0.008088181726634502, -0.04559095948934555, -0.04736463725566864, -0.012076756916940212, 0.013252097181975842, -0.024989917874336243, -0.013078253716230392, -0.01944606378674507, -0.017809733748435974, 0.005765351001173258, 0.013561279512941837, 0.0018414114601910114, -0.0014356293249875307, -0.017980720847845078, 0.013101092539727688, -0.019314546138048172, 0.0028276443481445312, -0.012593695893883705, -0.02128930203616619, 0.0377068817615509, -0.010980754159390926, 0.011759735643863678, -0.020939581096172333, 0.010206496343016624, 0.0157711710780859, 0.025078408420085907, -0.05713481456041336, -0.00938011147081852, 0.01917910948395729, -0.06532333046197891, -0.015411259606480598, 0.019105495885014534, -0.005898690782487392, 0.016295161098241806, 0.007524025160819292, -0.038577839732170105, -0.00911030825227499, 0.04677077755331993, -0.04866364970803261, -0.009577885270118713, -0.016920851543545723, -0.0019856630824506283, -0.01579376496374607, 0.02019227296113968, 0.047053560614585876, -0.006844662595540285, 0.03674063831567764, 0.03663074970245361, 0.015370645560324192, 0.00957383494824171, 0.0019200231181457639, 0.018181271851062775, -0.014293108135461807, -0.012344876304268837, -0.0022329052444547415, -0.012082676403224468, 0.005466869566589594, 0.06798373907804489, -0.03885171562433243, 0.02406349405646324, -0.02076108567416668, 0.009114854037761688, -0.09397456049919128, -0.04330107569694519, 0.0007238052785396576, 0.017946045845746994, 0.019399216398596764, -0.048635490238666534, 0.038016386330127716, 0.018176529556512833, -0.0527275875210762, -0.011831694282591343, -0.018120072782039642, -0.047283392399549484, -0.022972209379076958, 0.010199036449193954, -0.04054709151387215, -0.008836738765239716, 0.009660277515649796, 0.005458505358546972, 0.02647385559976101, 0.03045865334570408, 0.015242583118379116, -0.013718873262405396, -0.029667317867279053, 0.028686219826340675, 0.02809864655137062, -0.06439723074436188, 0.024562561884522438, -0.033073414117097855, -0.05086203292012215, 0.03012283891439438, -0.01712576113641262, 0.008060977794229984, 0.024145131930708885, 0.03199286386370659, -0.003907173406332731, 0.04334801435470581, 0.0159097071737051, -0.03969990834593773, -0.025238830596208572, -0.014073805883526802, 0.02316819690167904, 0.010305223055183887, -0.04798133671283722, 0.03027706779539585, 0.0456986166536808, -0.0028389350045472383, -0.03798529505729675, 0.006030657794326544, -0.006300883833318949, -0.02991071157157421, 0.020756026729941368, -0.00540930638089776, 0.032470669597387314, -0.00587076460942626, 0.012862098403275013, -0.03288983553647995, 0.03354956582188606, 0.01472853496670723, 0.04072342440485954, -0.045213647186756134, 0.013327355496585369, -0.009761596098542213, -0.018076591193675995, -0.029101574793457985, 0.023289864882826805, -0.042816054075956345, -0.045019492506980896, -0.009984289295971394, -0.019059162586927414, -0.018575036898255348, -0.016052866354584694, -0.05910884216427803, -0.035643529146909714, 0.057374753057956696, -0.007811971474438906, 0.042543794959783554, 0.030936868861317635, -0.010483445599675179, -0.011643326841294765, -0.09280277043581009, 0.04903187230229378, 0.0034979823976755142, 0.02614275924861431, -0.03631281107664108, 0.0022428606171160936, -0.03921231999993324, 0.011925644241273403, 0.05005345866084099, -0.0006205923273228109, -0.0017206169432029128, 0.008855513297021389, 0.030077416449785233, -0.013980982825160027, -0.05607884004712105, 0.059446703642606735, -0.04912082105875015, -0.03547060117125511, -0.05151762440800667, 0.014407936483621597, -0.008456438779830933, 0.006572014186531305, -0.005499054212123156, -0.024862471967935562, 0.012687607668340206, 0.008743924088776112, -0.0013188720913603902, 0.04231109097599983, -0.010520903393626213, -0.009898860938847065, 0.05543448030948639, -0.024733100086450577, 0.027242498472332954, 0.027234621345996857, 0.00834660790860653, -0.062442123889923096, 0.028732772916555405, -0.017595862969756126, -0.01599067635834217, 0.0021603144705295563, 0.022487232461571693, -0.010961528867483139, -0.04949098452925682, -0.011990087106823921, 0.009055884554982185, -0.045069899410009384, -0.002689650747925043, 0.007237726356834173, 0.01575237698853016, 0.010270236991345882, -0.0019386514322832227, 0.03638859838247299, 0.00643734959885478, 0.0005394913023337722, -0.008557802066206932, 0.02716023102402687, 0.008187715895473957, 0.00035561458207666874, 0.05217143893241882, -0.004624119959771633, -0.0371166430413723, -0.005953723564743996, -0.002105506369844079, 0.06840074807405472, -0.049894701689481735, -0.006388636771589518, -0.015702180564403534, -0.023727228865027428, -0.007400267291814089, -0.014774752780795097, -0.022568147629499435, 0.051027655601501465, -0.013471555896103382, 0.006478960160166025, -0.02695639058947563, -0.01828259788453579, -0.008598824962973595, -0.02284340187907219, -0.009290735237300396, 0.05272354930639267, -0.00609594164416194, -0.010445923544466496, -0.01941399648785591, 0.05036969855427742, 0.03245331719517708, -0.05545513704419136, 0.03008711338043213, -0.02557598240673542, 0.008550419472157955, -0.051428377628326416, 0.0018005719175562263, -0.03437652438879013, -0.009078851900994778, -0.003634193679317832, 0.023362314328551292, 0.02603207342326641, -0.02186511643230915, -0.013622761704027653, 0.006299379747360945, 0.041243113577365875, -0.03132292628288269, -0.04431485757231712, -0.012299551628530025, 0.026968806982040405, -0.016735326498746872, -0.037499453872442245 ]
<p>Normally when I do factor analysis, I have a whole bunch of variables that need to be reduced. But here I only have two binary variables (yes/no) that I need to reduce into one interval factor. Is Principle Components / Factor Analysis appropriate for this? When I do it, my extraction communalities are really high. I might need a reference to back this up with reviewers.</p>
49,110
[ 0.023630445823073387, 0.04247457534074783, -0.029192132875323296, 0.040330421179533005, 0.05317259579896927, -0.008063118904829025, -0.018834775313735008, -0.02589794062077999, 0.014593482948839664, -0.04121190309524536, 0.022308308631181717, 0.016481375321745872, 0.03504224121570587, 0.01712794229388237, -0.009606977924704552, -0.01796906813979149, -0.0033312684390693903, -0.009178802371025085, -0.022045094519853592, -0.013464377261698246, -0.019886747002601624, 0.026912808418273926, 0.02461271546781063, -0.0302995927631855, -0.010342621244490147, 0.08099963515996933, 0.013626395724713802, -0.03132421895861626, 0.009531473740935326, 0.042983315885066986, -0.044165488332509995, -0.03476535528898239, -0.027079010382294655, 0.019688421860337257, 0.016441239044070244, 0.01677577942609787, -0.008998237550258636, 0.011035710573196411, -0.02093561366200447, 0.028199464082717896, -0.03552169352769852, -0.003905040677636862, 0.002310478826984763, -0.017623145133256912, -0.033712197095155716, -0.004455777816474438, 0.018813228234648705, -0.005418455693870783, 0.008662513457238674, -0.05399544537067413, 0.07469645887613297, 0.03036283329129219, 0.019373448565602303, 0.0262888353317976, 0.00140070216730237, 0.0139413271099329, 0.05170115455985069, 0.04385778307914734, 0.00032296142308041453, -0.05407288670539856, -0.018585123121738434, -0.02991275116801262, -0.020093996077775955, -0.0033863645512610674, -0.017623446881771088, 0.033546991646289825, 0.01953841932117939, -0.013052486814558506, 0.006406695581972599, 0.0011559058912098408, -0.005756151396781206, -0.019736550748348236, 0.05052713304758072, -0.03777628391981125, 0.010972721502184868, -0.042672645300626755, 0.039807792752981186, 0.00018954805273097008, 0.0003052229294553399, 0.06928563117980957, -0.02762182056903839, 0.03429543226957321, -0.031831663101911545, 0.025917144492268562, 0.02188560739159584, -0.025880223140120506, 0.03223134204745293, -0.06486675888299942, -0.02283506840467453, 0.011911150068044662, -0.01168233435600996, 0.030226489529013634, 0.045686446130275726, 0.02825671248137951, -0.0219223964959383, 0.016600074246525764, 0.011356234550476074, 0.027458693832159042, 0.005563879385590553, -0.03211585804820061, -0.019614247605204582, 0.010598868131637573, 0.012884998694062233, 0.05927573889493942, -0.030408794060349464, 0.036735787987709045, -0.05805531144142151, 0.015985198318958282, -0.004056484904140234, -0.019985653460025787, -0.023832552134990692, -0.011121765710413456, 0.013695880770683289, 0.007609478197991848, 0.04530944302678108, -0.007200899999588728, 0.012740700505673885, -0.022123197093605995, 0.07136078923940659, 0.047775931656360626, 0.019780412316322327, -0.02584850788116455, 0.04540117830038071, 0.006092913448810577, -0.07124503701925278, 0.0070715597830712795, 0.0048204571940004826, 0.004925515037029982, -0.0486132986843586, 0.032510291785001755, -0.006140438839793205, -0.04106896370649338, 0.045279309153556824, 0.0012743837432935834, -0.017449041828513145, 0.028360456228256226, -0.08104830235242844, -0.035943225026130676, -0.0027599716559052467, -0.04025714099407196, -0.003930720500648022, -0.0618240088224411, 0.027656128630042076, 0.04171619564294815, 0.043575871735811234, -0.005249712150543928, 0.02656405419111252, 0.005941413808614016, 0.030736802145838737, 0.03208451345562935, -0.058323003351688385, -0.02955346181988716, -0.029084350913763046, -0.04097546637058258, -0.058014679700136185, -0.06500981003046036, 0.040175508707761765, 0.021242152899503708, 0.016468187794089317, 0.020894723013043404, 0.03021373599767685, 0.02339049056172371, -0.03033691644668579, 0.005606810562312603, 0.003300653537735343, -0.02316884696483612, 0.037336673587560654, -0.06791234761476517, 0.051542993634939194, 0.004477445501834154, 0.021576618775725365, 0.02080860733985901, 0.03407725319266319, 0.05581256002187729, 0.04741821438074112, 0.011951395310461521, -0.025239108130335808, -0.031943537294864655, 0.026675565168261528, 0.015411432832479477, -0.05007293447852135, -0.04295814782381058, -0.03171275556087494, 0.01168423518538475, 0.009329335764050484, 0.055499810725450516, -0.01931028440594673, -0.0667455866932869, 0.056450631469488144, -0.015545562840998173, -0.04340023174881935, -0.0608004555106163, 0.01801602728664875, 0.021488457918167114, -0.017875373363494873, -0.014234473928809166, 0.0001320720330113545, 0.003993897698819637, -0.006049595307558775, -0.03533203527331352, -0.03937457501888275, 0.010283580049872398, 0.03745349496603012, -0.039860546588897705, 0.01176124531775713, 0.0019458269234746695, 0.019563043490052223, -0.01608847826719284, 0.037346482276916504, -0.035636574029922485, -0.051442913711071014, -0.0014075067592784762, -0.0232852753251791, 0.043061263859272, -0.020129647105932236, 0.012035188265144825, 0.036973144859075546, 0.022811485454440117, -0.030256744474172592, 0.014114601537585258, -0.038237400352954865, 0.09888686239719391, 0.03030054084956646, -0.014763323590159416, 0.0028458796441555023, 0.004699345678091049, 0.06741472333669662, 0.0035466989502310753, 0.00217532180249691, 0.005379214882850647, -0.0461140014231205, 0.007713362108916044, 0.0514586865901947, 0.0034431235399097204, -0.04179129749536514, 0.006254976615309715, 0.023727059364318848, 0.022317752242088318, 0.039604414254426956, 0.006211781874299049, 0.031400565057992935, 0.006023747846484184, 0.012612193822860718, 0.043515581637620926, 0.007627633400261402, -0.021002329885959625, 0.01892407238483429, -0.007640611380338669, 0.030826464295387268, 0.008623560890555382, 0.0185550507158041, 0.029109647497534752, 0.03732088580727577, 0.010669862851500511, -0.02913549169898033, -0.01908591017127037, 0.03750179708003998, -0.025944393128156662, 0.05445016920566559, 0.052493877708911896, 0.014918053522706032, -0.023851223289966583, 0.005516041535884142, -0.036245424300432205, 0.0033441483974456787, 0.02884664572775364, -0.06020315736532211, 0.019103659316897392, 0.029340893030166626, -0.015504146926105022, 0.010884921066462994, -0.04774615541100502, -0.007088045589625835, -0.04672788456082344, 0.009623279795050621, 0.05037272721529007, -0.008501495234668255, 0.09430914372205734, -0.012780779041349888, -0.01061912439763546, -0.006092822179198265, 0.016645198687911034, -0.013683252036571503, 0.008326501585543156, -0.0696975588798523, -0.021217061206698418, -0.03841758146882057, -0.020750677213072777, 0.015116218477487564, -0.025702351704239845, 0.011721674352884293, 0.01915697194635868, 0.006491917185485363, -0.02585637755692005, 0.001968474593013525, 0.008407260291278362, 0.004664189647883177, -0.021072622388601303, -0.006534426473081112, 0.03312595933675766, 0.0035020941868424416, -0.03113122656941414, -0.04521789774298668, -0.026141751557588577, -0.011871477589011192, -0.030221696943044662, 0.006381642539054155, 0.01271079108119011, 0.008402353152632713, -0.021725157275795937, 0.03128821402788162, -0.029848352074623108, 0.020725412294268608, -0.0789201632142067, -0.09023306518793106, -0.005303169135004282, 0.0177923496812582, 0.04222210496664047, 0.022635318338871002, -0.000376084353774786, 0.06283161044120789, 0.05352071300148964, -0.033621106296777725, -0.0434718020260334, -0.01933717168867588, -0.011190030723810196, -0.019720865413546562, 0.007675512693822384, 0.004592014476656914, 0.03842667490243912, 0.029300136491656303, -0.014353164471685886, 0.016994524747133255, 0.07169514149427414, 0.07054322957992554, -0.008489778265357018, 0.02978544682264328, 0.02076830342411995, -0.022478457540273666, 0.015183094888925552, 0.018326200544834137, -0.03114815428853035, 0.025279393419623375, 0.03458211570978165, 0.05603238195180893, 0.02671276591718197, -0.032961998134851456, -0.009936708956956863, -0.05094777047634125, 0.020837288349866867, -0.0019276937237009406, -0.01059874240309, 0.02026810497045517, -0.006519222632050514, 0.02265920676290989, 0.020791195333003998, 0.031735002994537354, -0.020102156326174736, -0.004753452260047197, 0.053055290132761, 0.03085334785282612, -0.0021151911932975054, 0.017312249168753624, 0.01659788377583027, -0.004025856498628855, 0.025857558473944664, -0.007500091101974249, 0.018290527164936066, 0.0504734143614769, 0.023509860038757324, 0.0621054545044899, -0.0067650312557816505, -0.03614065796136856, 0.01736193709075451, -0.08999176323413849, 0.01249565277248621, -0.0279513169080019, 0.04464474320411682, -0.019740603864192963, 0.0394788458943367, 0.008360140956938267, 0.009584267623722553, -0.048311226069927216, 0.015313699841499329, -0.049144621938467026, -0.018793286755681038, -0.052846040576696396, -0.0060318103060126305, 0.009629817679524422, 0.006502341013401747, 0.010941702872514725, 0.0015454769600182772, -0.03375367447733879, -0.018731148913502693, 0.051368072628974915, -0.027786098420619965, 0.0259979460388422, -0.020356712862849236, -0.018685171380639076, -0.014220026321709156, 0.019634079188108444, 0.035896461457014084, -0.01932045817375183, 0.045177675783634186, 0.03247324377298355, -0.009032833389937878, 0.01405297964811325, 0.007884543389081955, -0.007776943035423756, 0.003564616432413459, 0.03830881416797638, -0.02705073170363903, 0.06879929453134537, -0.0057763527147471905, 0.020540641620755196, -0.00012206558312755078, 0.05944047495722771, -0.0024696511682122946, -0.028169525787234306, -0.00004752996755996719, -0.021051881834864616, -0.06528131663799286, 0.006732804700732231, 0.022611629217863083, -0.031461745500564575, -0.00037373631494119763, 0.016862910240888596, 0.03967154026031494, -0.05118091404438019, 0.03224572166800499, 0.07720355689525604, 0.018924197182059288, -0.046396784484386444, -0.027027970179915428, -0.031342633068561554, -0.011405889876186848, -0.0020392616279423237, 0.013732139021158218, 0.018955424427986145, -0.03263276070356369, -0.04448297619819641, 0.06147291138768196, 0.005658635403960943, -0.025202978402376175, -0.004942396190017462, -0.0048885284923017025, 0.033302098512649536, 0.003924916032701731, -0.027641046792268753, 0.007836000062525272, 0.03933512046933174, 0.03675830364227295, 0.012010693550109863, 0.004798704758286476, -0.07316157966852188, 0.025519398972392082, 0.039027515798807144, 0.050166189670562744, -0.019911490380764008, 0.027948081493377686, -0.023082340136170387, -0.023040875792503357, 0.022184912115335464, -0.02407638169825077, 0.046660520136356354, 0.0012351376935839653, 0.024333300068974495, -0.017726315185427666, 0.001252632704563439, -0.010497200302779675, 0.02383343316614628, -0.011390126310288906, 0.021335458382964134, -0.0058114174753427505, -0.03865277022123337, -0.05583854019641876, 0.03740854933857918, -0.007689592428505421, 0.04925774037837982, 0.023897873237729073, -0.03108641505241394, -0.0011117050889879465, 0.008303954266011715, -0.02542559802532196, -0.059555187821388245, -0.022216904908418655, 0.014630848541855812, 0.009373269975185394, 0.06806980073451996, 0.01518778782337904, -0.07431556284427643, -0.013153879903256893, 0.005360845942050219, -0.009365973062813282, 0.013003531843423843, -0.0367809496819973, 0.04924226552248001, 0.0018823860445991158, -0.01129615306854248, 0.05338652804493904, 0.015384386293590069, -0.037027694284915924, 0.0029722596518695354, -0.04592270404100418, 0.013997837901115417, -0.05873490124940872, 0.013189069926738739, -0.011471846140921116, 0.00656402762979269, -0.025496629998087883, 0.026266466826200485, -0.0018641500500962138, 0.04950910434126854, -0.0065543134696781635, -0.034384191036224365, -0.02957361750304699, 0.014650307595729828, -0.03673682361841202, 0.020270319655537605, -0.016014842316508293, 0.003561325604096055, -0.029001623392105103, -0.014444771222770214, 0.007692327257245779, -0.01928624138236046, -0.00301634194329381, 0.01500954944640398, -0.019836660474538803, 0.031881630420684814, -0.05932632088661194, -0.05130870267748833, 0.00020385475363582373, -0.018713245168328285, 0.04037086293101311, -0.03883920982480049, 0.0006785051082260907, -0.0011485419236123562, -0.009107336401939392, 0.0022129297722131014, 0.01112187746912241, 0.029215512797236443, 0.0523018017411232, -0.025476163253188133, 0.06634041666984558, -0.04832235723733902, -0.008652926422655582, -0.08357942849397659, -0.05679946765303612, -0.010230558924376965, -0.020949814468622208, -0.020514454692602158, -0.042142752557992935, 0.012915477156639099, -0.012817397713661194, -0.025163164362311363, -0.0001924483076436445, 0.06616613268852234, -0.023982957005500793, 0.004924173466861248, -0.00795756746083498, 0.026901980862021446, 0.05592072755098343, 0.01925279013812542, -0.004215318709611893, 0.014473741874098778, -0.03990676626563072, -0.010884727351367474, -0.02713823691010475, -0.0022769193165004253, -0.028157958760857582, 0.0055477009154856205, -0.0517997108399868, -0.0028859912417829037, 0.0331566147506237, -0.010079382918775082, -0.01210169866681099, 0.025180988013744354, -0.02031794935464859, -0.01412693690508604, 0.002832861617207527, -0.011998996138572693, -0.010999954305589199, -0.011463288217782974, 0.0025378491263836622, 0.008668475784361362, -0.028381528332829475, -0.014130877330899239, 0.004700739402323961, -0.03180890157818794, -0.039847083389759064, 0.020968446508049965, 0.06366711854934692, 0.025355318561196327, 0.032837625592947006, 0.006716967560350895, -0.02621794119477272, 0.03816276043653488, 0.01854819245636463, -0.023946883156895638, 0.009136851876974106, -0.024240145459771156, -0.018786776810884476, -0.028391247615218163, -0.009286663495004177, -0.017987065017223358, 0.048471372574567795, 0.011282444931566715, 0.017326021566987038, 0.07277581095695496, 0.00033619330497458577, -0.01019347831606865, -0.03834149241447449, 0.018879925832152367, 0.0019110882421955466, 0.005838313139975071, 0.037049300968647, -0.023042107000947, -0.035347338765859604, 0.025096016004681587, 0.035268306732177734, 0.014271506108343601, 0.06377949565649033, 0.025138067081570625, 0.04057195410132408, 0.014895145781338215, -0.020502494648098946, -0.06014981493353844, -0.010775311850011349, -0.06026969850063324, 0.0011354628950357437, -0.004627784714102745, -0.046770837157964706, 0.030444491654634476, 0.05317695438861847, -0.02663239650428295, -0.06600046157836914, -0.01910630241036415, 0.007777921389788389, 0.017855564132332802, 0.009829794988036156, -0.001717677223496139, -0.002548248041421175, -0.03181120753288269, 0.034931592643260956, 0.015359381213784218, 0.04340486600995064, 0.01406461838632822, -0.03930595889687538, -0.04106581583619118, -0.009073633700609207, -0.02543356455862522, 0.003718249499797821, -0.03466867655515671, -0.02740279585123062, 0.04445888102054596, -0.038907572627067566, -0.011463028378784657, -0.020915480330586433, 0.026972416788339615, -0.004950564354658127, 0.024838509038090706, -0.0007041885983198881, -0.005254872143268585, 0.047622352838516235, 0.0047326297499239445, 0.14176835119724274, 0.08871454000473022, 0.019115731120109558, -0.07062828540802002, 0.06082800030708313, 0.019739147275686264, 0.0076376753859221935, -0.008295441046357155, 0.01859154924750328, -0.017675908282399178, -0.016641641035676003, 0.049221571534872055, 0.05658832937479019, -0.029986048117280006, -0.003658463479951024, 0.051607828587293625, -0.015269046649336815, -0.016752438619732857, 0.019182896241545677, 0.027850739657878876, -0.004921640735119581, -0.0464167594909668, 0.003242808161303401, 0.0202665776014328, 0.007299521937966347, -0.02577144093811512, -0.01640080288052559, -0.0022601706441491842, 0.001622841227799654, -0.020636791363358498, -0.032541994005441666, 0.013806253671646118, 0.020314479246735573, 0.02210046723484993, 0.026924259960651398, -0.020289205014705658, 0.00337044894695282, -0.03125626966357231, -0.015170944854617119, 0.01899954304099083, -0.014124484732747078, -0.016349634155631065, 0.045446813106536865, 0.010539336130023003, -0.05322788655757904, -0.03580247238278389, -0.026426345109939575, 0.03211202472448349, -0.0032629065681248903, 0.017378894612193108, -0.04060232639312744, -0.023303549736738205, 0.007547156885266304, -0.030394867062568665, -0.024356942623853683, 0.03372998163104057, 0.03419472277164459, 0.017925618216395378, -0.04296628385782242, -0.038798730820417404, 0.017242081463336945, -0.01062758732587099, 0.03247610479593277, 0.012905064970254898, -0.0042880442924797535, -0.01543180551379919, 0.014475947245955467, 0.039153676480054855, 0.026307765394449234, -0.025317752733826637, -0.01645626872777939, 0.0019955600146204233, -0.025036880746483803, -0.03396366536617279, -0.012737265788018703, 0.0329495333135128, 0.012234221212565899, -0.021445833146572113, -0.005635167937725782, -0.03676300495862961, -0.016155380755662918, -0.00813306588679552, -0.01634378172457218, -0.0074614412151277065, -0.014124528504908085, -0.008899879641830921, -0.008680801838636398, 0.01681026630103588, -0.0023098252713680267, 0.008180552162230015, -0.030845124274492264, 0.07482893019914627, 0.0024874985683709383, -0.040341440588235855, 0.0018982518231496215, -0.040393467992544174, -0.015503606759011745, 0.02065584622323513, 0.005859823897480965, 0.03205008804798126, -0.016281161457300186, -0.0009912761161103845, 0.005241024307906628, 0.02431335113942623, -0.006864496041089296, 0.011676199734210968, 0.039727047085762024, -0.06739994883537292, 0.028615619987249374, 0.017383337020874023, 0.015576781705021858, -0.04345759004354477, -0.004756316542625427, -0.03377608582377434, 0.00409155385568738, 0.005094557534903288, -0.009217743761837482, -0.019128555431962013, -0.018160197883844376, 0.0020439340732991695, 0.04190819710493088, -0.05359803885221481, -0.0009013321832753718, -0.029574859887361526, -0.0010801212629303336, 0.017353784292936325, -0.012259782291948795, -0.021084528416395187, 0.00863061472773552, 0.006982574239373207, 0.013025783002376556, 0.06427029520273209, -0.0026848497800529003, 0.008638457395136356, -0.03936675190925598, 0.013422491028904915, -0.002349325455725193, 0.018489068374037743, -0.02057965286076069, 0.017036473378539085, 0.01800503581762314, -0.05529351159930229, 0.03246326744556427, 0.029184937477111816, 0.005511763505637646, 0.03737630695104599, 0.008187053725123405, 0.0060322480276227, 0.0086750453338027, 0.041270554065704346, -0.01187359169125557, -0.031280018389225006, 0.029962966218590736, 0.043459661304950714, -0.034402135759592056, 0.015411611646413803, -0.028795409947633743, 0.03171878680586815, -0.03613383322954178, 0.07804413139820099, 0.03253452107310295, 0.011800301261246204, -0.02481760084629059, 0.016090968623757362, -0.01722775027155876, -0.01912677101790905, -0.005881992168724537, -0.008393749594688416, 0.03759511187672615, 0.03826550021767616, -0.006942667532712221, 0.04112500324845314, -0.031033609062433243, 0.03832217678427696, -0.06996168941259384, -0.010685482993721962, -0.003440349129959941, 0.018578488379716873, 0.0451943539083004, -0.03215659037232399, 0.022343412041664124, 0.022040795534849167, -0.014277268201112747, 0.005897094029933214, 0.0016904477961361408, -0.01109402347356081, -0.012240271084010601, -0.026174362748861313, -0.026968859136104584, 0.00024363474221900105, 0.018086915835738182, -0.00009671903535490856, 0.030490189790725708, 0.016161281615495682, -0.012096471153199673, -0.04475167393684387, 0.004984704311937094, -0.003442381741479039, -0.022078819572925568, -0.062304865568876266, 0.04549751430749893, -0.05814669281244278, -0.047497741878032684, 0.012389210984110832, -0.02532190829515457, 0.03182334452867508, 0.013323992490768433, 0.045359086245298386, 0.015357683412730694, 0.06265319883823395, 0.05157392472028732, -0.00788409449160099, 0.0008185372571460903, 0.005745990201830864, -0.015924932435154915, 0.037256188690662384, -0.003347693709656596, 0.019942594692111015, 0.05872296914458275, -0.023289380595088005, -0.04317379742860794, -0.008120876736938953, -0.0037370806094259024, -0.022013256326317787, -0.0156883355230093, -0.013705319724977016, -0.015977544710040092, -0.023815007880330086, 0.029776830226182938, -0.07049940526485443, -0.013502421788871288, 0.055418651551008224, -0.015160772949457169, -0.007289682514965534, 0.012111996300518513, -0.016873840242624283, -0.06023244559764862, -0.003194158896803856, 0.03815517574548721, 0.0051822783425450325, -0.0631379559636116, -0.03616153448820114, 0.03718020021915436, -0.03994109109044075, -0.03576072305440903, 0.009001490660011768, -0.014933248050510883, 0.020422903820872307, -0.0575915165245533, 0.029740341007709503, 0.01164249051362276, -0.017979085445404053, 0.00808168575167656, -0.0400010347366333, 0.05250095576047897, 0.026809701696038246, 0.012944141402840614, -0.031597934663295746, -0.013193224556744099, -0.03203790262341499, -0.02440202608704567, 0.03758886456489563, 0.0026106545701622963, 0.022191757336258888, -0.02763396129012108, 0.011057017371058464, 0.006712605245411396, -0.03386014699935913, 0.05146540701389313, -0.0223089549690485, 0.013969369232654572, -0.03833695873618126, -0.015146810561418533, -0.004486576188355684, -0.02829883247613907, 0.005372575484216213, -0.02200380340218544, 0.006620964501053095, -0.01022825762629509, 0.003853750415146351, 0.035112567245960236, -0.009308570995926857, -0.010760240256786346, 0.026057595387101173, -0.002321583451703191, 0.05226600170135498, 0.039561208337545395, -0.012072785757482052, -0.06365525722503662, 0.04795614629983902, -0.017516501247882843, -0.014549477025866508, 0.009323718026280403, 0.06607341021299362, -0.004230125341564417, -0.07209577411413193, 0.04698256775736809, 0.04138999059796333, -0.05606153607368469, 0.018918653950095177, 0.05551213026046753, 0.009384220466017723, 0.028292762115597725, -0.010709988884627819, 0.034915681928396225, 0.028231995180249214, -0.0384899340569973, 0.02516905404627323, 0.01865405961871147, 0.03288663923740387, 0.02855026349425316, -0.021558457985520363, 0.017827879637479782, -0.02124255709350109, 0.01323182787746191, -0.016207823529839516, 0.015318849124014378, -0.021845344454050064, -0.013438821770250797, 0.04458988085389137, 0.011181307025253773, 0.06685370951890945, 0.012815194204449654, 0.0026924714911729097, 0.03068091720342636, -0.027522660791873932, -0.011893724091351032, -0.05941549688577652, -0.020671620965003967, -0.058824025094509125, 0.0007123469840735197, 0.03833974897861481, 0.06809806078672409, 0.006573543418198824, -0.004668650683015585, -0.03390350565314293, -0.029722439125180244, -0.017686601728200912, -0.0466141477227211, 0.03535112738609314, 0.0007810599636286497, 0.020008977502584457, -0.005723423324525356, -0.020462993532419205, -0.04053901880979538, -0.028945835307240486, -0.0056084380485117435, 0.03984741494059563, 0.000010345685041102115, -0.0025838837027549744, -0.024146314710378647, -0.005699650384485722, 0.030009226873517036, -0.03621692210435867, -0.024050137028098106, -0.02249782904982567, 0.018375098705291748, -0.010695978999137878, -0.001824749750085175 ]
<p>A set is said to be fully-symmetric if for every x in it, negating one of its components results in y such that y is in the set as well.</p> <p>A set is said to be semi-symmetric if for every x in it, negating all of its components (at once) results in y such that y is in the set as well.</p> <p>Now examine the optimal solution of the Kmeans objective with K=2d+1 for d-dimensional unique observations that are fully-symmetric.</p> <p>Suppose it is known that the optimal means set w.r.t the above setup is unique and contains the zero vector. Prove or give a counter example to the following claim: The set of optimal means is semi-symmetric</p>
49,111
[ -0.029583435505628586, -0.022751566022634506, -0.00790558010339737, 0.017734292894601822, 0.043100353330373764, 0.034031279385089874, -0.0073624770157039165, 0.0028708591125905514, -0.007692885119467974, -0.034262824803590775, 0.017579808831214905, -0.006967457942664623, 0.029168155044317245, 0.0635342001914978, 0.02523135021328926, -0.0074578505009412766, -0.025959614664316177, 0.001084740273654461, -0.031048795208334923, -0.028461379930377007, -0.016179008409380913, 0.038966163992881775, 0.01782063953578472, -0.005959889851510525, -0.03178051859140396, 0.0033046624157577753, -0.009092388674616814, -0.0315154492855072, 0.023457655683159828, 0.05079818144440651, -0.044196825474500656, -0.004377193748950958, -0.003464572364464402, 0.02784804441034794, 0.017765017226338387, -0.012052759528160095, -0.011754726059734821, -0.007151331752538681, -0.013014817610383034, -0.005037312861531973, -0.004095475655049086, -0.004659018944948912, 0.023482006043195724, -0.00015034680836834013, -0.009165308438241482, 0.03382899984717369, -0.011253579519689083, -0.017220182344317436, -0.0020290098618716, -0.04792604222893715, 0.07716388255357742, 0.0008692755945958197, 0.06788789480924606, 0.033791691064834595, -0.017088033258914948, 0.037220291793346405, -0.0010637021623551846, 0.0797768160700798, 0.020160671323537827, -0.03861667960882187, -0.00726113747805357, -0.021873347461223602, 0.020132137462496758, 0.0005162613815627992, -0.06900838762521744, 0.07381584495306015, 0.04152492806315422, -0.026305366307497025, 0.022947432473301888, 0.0049452041275799274, -0.01134543213993311, -0.010005628690123558, 0.024716440588235855, -0.023906338959932327, -0.02257891371846199, -0.02320672571659088, -0.02187328413128853, 0.02303946204483509, 0.04989525303244591, -0.01035815104842186, 0.039109259843826294, -0.0002916842931881547, 0.00572047708556056, 0.0439702533185482, 0.020607594400644302, 0.015170750208199024, 0.06253492832183838, 0.0044851661659777164, 0.011107994243502617, 0.032494861632585526, 0.024077996611595154, -0.013101199641823769, 0.03818117454648018, -0.02303772233426571, -0.04127708077430725, 0.030153358355164528, -0.02629460021853447, 0.06058463454246521, -0.034578777849674225, -0.02925504744052887, 0.006405170075595379, -0.021153636276721954, 0.024494046345353127, 0.05465555563569069, 0.0379817858338356, 0.02830256149172783, -0.009165596216917038, 0.023289572447538376, -0.022710096091032028, 0.01785312592983246, 0.010316433385014534, 0.01208279374986887, 0.014254969544708729, -0.007838734425604343, 0.01624828390777111, -0.020399847999215126, -0.014797952026128769, -0.03986930847167969, 0.011193480342626572, 0.08230510354042053, 0.038040321320295334, -0.008044276386499405, -0.019263779744505882, -0.015532500110566616, -0.07136435806751251, 0.049817778170108795, -0.013326164335012436, -0.014035134576261044, -0.032245565205812454, 0.058243729174137115, 0.028028931468725204, -0.015253118239343166, 0.03992165997624397, -0.030182532966136932, 0.05235036835074425, -0.027803055942058563, -0.06108218804001808, -0.04778628796339035, 0.045982085168361664, 0.027055634185671806, 0.01637180708348751, -0.05746781453490257, -0.018210217356681824, 0.04286639764904976, 0.049051884561777115, -0.030481083318591118, 0.00443222327157855, 0.025504814460873604, 0.01356416940689087, 0.031181124970316887, -0.01919575035572052, -0.04446537420153618, -0.015351026318967342, -0.04247358441352844, -0.05230943486094475, -0.07326332479715347, 0.008753103204071522, 0.01864030584692955, -0.007932347245514393, -0.006940511055290699, 0.024291280657052994, 0.014878544956445694, 0.00812126137316227, -0.0031388236675411463, -0.021800238639116287, -0.01236653421074152, 0.03201505169272423, 0.03188936412334442, 0.042137037962675095, 0.015770865604281425, -0.0006675677141174674, 0.04957614466547966, -0.005823597777634859, 0.03601560369133949, 0.0179342869669199, -0.032817911356687546, 0.005219233687967062, -0.017130691558122635, 0.04062807187438011, 0.014816631563007832, 0.0010644267313182354, -0.006704045459628105, -0.028251908719539642, 0.025558965280652046, 0.0659923329949379, 0.05091714486479759, -0.0001824856735765934, 0.00595362763851881, 0.03913978487253189, -0.013617380522191525, -0.022323252633213997, -0.024189932271838188, 0.021718310192227364, -0.019253741949796677, -0.04887931048870087, 0.010022158734500408, -0.03081202320754528, 0.00973711721599102, -0.024516139179468155, 0.0076758721843361855, 0.010135548189282417, -0.011849364265799522, 0.05415783450007439, -0.02649555169045925, 0.015381877310574055, 0.051664259284734726, 0.06786094605922699, -0.01682312786579132, 0.019277889281511307, -0.010956075973808765, -0.03157994523644447, -0.02810703217983246, 0.010528781451284885, -0.0350663885474205, 0.01211202796548605, 0.011526058427989483, 0.013066912069916725, 0.01511905062943697, -0.02726193703711033, 0.02656080387532711, -0.08509713411331177, 0.04448600858449936, 0.07313498854637146, -0.0014797241892665625, 0.014752641320228577, -0.014627338387072086, 0.012481377460062504, 0.015315786004066467, -0.013407215476036072, -0.012088391929864883, -0.0581057071685791, 0.01543936412781477, -0.008075661025941372, 0.042141642421483994, -0.03679158538579941, 0.012757628224790096, 0.04270843416452408, -0.003470848547294736, 0.003670724108815193, -0.043281909078359604, -0.014164564199745655, -0.003799878293648362, 0.06183808669447899, -0.004775053355842829, 0.02800031192600727, 0.002345727290958166, 0.015994932502508163, -0.022974831983447075, 0.016535688191652298, 0.020825572311878204, 0.00962068047374487, 0.04118768498301506, 0.015764107927680016, 0.018184583634138107, -0.009808199480175972, -0.03785794600844383, 0.03129487857222557, 0.009563997387886047, 0.005344418343156576, 0.025873253121972084, 0.005386661272495985, 0.010907938703894615, -0.00788159854710102, 0.013539498671889305, -0.016933269798755646, 0.00865450780838728, 0.012494147755205631, 0.009210355579853058, 0.016166379675269127, -0.009082213044166565, 0.00202355463989079, -0.025921497493982315, -0.037562593817710876, -0.033361151814460754, -0.030854709446430206, 0.061370715498924255, -0.02271328493952751, 0.03222892805933952, -0.06451407074928284, 0.016276562586426735, -0.026119574904441833, -0.016511982306838036, 0.01400973740965128, 0.03399517759680748, -0.0814245194196701, -0.0033340887166559696, -0.03694821149110794, -0.01804722473025322, 0.015452315099537373, -0.004843174479901791, 0.007444645278155804, 0.04275841265916824, -0.0032088402658700943, -0.05200889706611633, -0.002399885095655918, -0.03781560808420181, 0.02149112895131111, -0.029667172580957413, 0.0038091540336608887, -0.0034670874010771513, 0.058499526232481, -0.04645942896604538, 0.01455467939376831, -0.025003131479024887, -0.05057656019926071, -0.06000589206814766, -0.050811950117349625, 0.0408010259270668, 0.002070646034553647, 0.009611968882381916, 0.02951967902481556, -0.014389373362064362, -0.0393403023481369, -0.06911735236644745, -0.10654550790786743, 0.02371794357895851, -0.016696784645318985, 0.02616514265537262, -0.00449482724070549, -0.031037645414471626, 0.04280129075050354, 0.06387443840503693, 0.0008801707881502807, -0.02902194671332836, -0.001967093674466014, -0.05340392142534256, -0.0442655086517334, 0.03240729495882988, -0.02769925631582737, 0.022007010877132416, 0.05035478621721268, 0.009111025370657444, 0.030466953292489052, 0.060336772352457047, -0.024908561259508133, -0.0552528090775013, -0.0207994282245636, 0.024577753618359566, 0.008125409483909607, 0.04531995579600334, 0.046447984874248505, -0.025686265900731087, 0.019780486822128296, 0.021444423124194145, -0.0027672285214066505, 0.010002019815146923, -0.06789938360452652, 0.04216102883219719, -0.05806294456124306, 0.046344224363565445, -0.0477476604282856, 0.03894945606589317, 0.007815438322722912, 0.006466086022555828, -0.016191678121685982, 0.014690089039504528, 0.0291315745562315, -0.04417989030480385, -0.0317232720553875, 0.04210243746638298, 0.01657988503575325, -0.03437669947743416, 0.009305444546043873, 0.007139348890632391, -0.005482853390276432, 0.01937848888337612, -0.02720477618277073, 0.006555076688528061, 0.006119959056377411, 0.049688488245010376, 0.01584574393928051, 0.04484669491648674, -0.0021024576853960752, -0.0178619883954525, -0.06876281648874283, 0.030733799561858177, -0.018349140882492065, 0.04335644096136093, -0.008441307581961155, 0.027840634807944298, 0.05328960716724396, 0.0011959349503740668, -0.06192377209663391, 0.021488385275006294, -0.06316567957401276, 0.03172523155808449, -0.018439197912812233, 0.03251674026250839, 0.01929498091340065, -0.04387909173965454, 0.03535820543766022, -0.020182495936751366, -0.00727001391351223, 0.029632827267050743, 0.03938157483935356, -0.0613994263112545, -0.004411790985614061, -0.020904110744595528, -0.014123203232884407, 0.0023408944252878428, 0.011185673996806145, 0.053220223635435104, -0.0016299199778586626, 0.03537377715110779, 0.01132010668516159, -0.016895322129130363, -0.00422306265681982, 0.014910903759300709, 0.025097042322158813, 0.03150881081819534, 0.033541176468133926, -0.019695164635777473, 0.013309705071151257, -0.0023046142887324095, 0.0349426344037056, 0.013905867002904415, 0.06900595128536224, -0.04059525206685066, 0.0017754449509084225, -0.02635628916323185, -0.03706418722867966, -0.03676163777709007, 0.0018722586100921035, 0.015088583342730999, -0.011019675992429256, 0.0006768362945877016, 0.06685731559991837, 0.05510088801383972, -0.06303854286670685, 0.004113772418349981, 0.05168626457452774, 0.03141540288925171, -0.001861807657405734, -0.01409965381026268, -0.014784444123506546, -0.040677621960639954, -0.006477676797658205, 0.028054729104042053, -0.027480507269501686, -0.01285418402403593, 0.049155447632074356, 0.04093374311923981, 0.04267166182398796, -0.01409218180924654, 0.025735720992088318, 0.01945587992668152, 0.053675971925258636, -0.03772396221756935, 0.0046331388875842094, 0.010117058642208576, 0.06443560868501663, 0.03609035909175873, -0.007361959666013718, -0.01418435387313366, -0.0434889979660511, 0.007032112218439579, 0.017979297786951065, 0.05134129896759987, -0.022172529250383377, 0.018385661765933037, -0.05991128832101822, -0.02573462761938572, -0.007408263627439737, -0.02030048705637455, 0.07528077065944672, -0.027519183233380318, -0.0023273774422705173, -0.036832474172115326, -0.027141567319631577, -0.040005866438150406, -0.021831944584846497, -0.013272173702716827, 0.044037722051143646, 0.02598315104842186, -0.012057311832904816, -0.03567325323820114, -0.020879536867141724, 0.02655501663684845, 0.026275889948010445, -0.010556410066783428, -0.012375051155686378, 0.03323431685566902, 0.004736794158816338, -0.014629927463829517, -0.05723142623901367, 0.024333883076906204, 0.014853511936962605, -0.009008515626192093, 0.021815024316310883, -0.027203306555747986, -0.02791615203022957, 0.045205313712358475, -0.009294268675148487, -0.014999445527791977, -0.0035979857202619314, -0.007410133723169565, 0.008306731469929218, 0.058586928993463516, 0.0006424494204111397, 0.03583281487226486, 0.005511813331395388, -0.01753092184662819, -0.0033305103424936533, -0.031727615743875504, 0.012058576568961143, -0.03880764916539192, -0.016240473836660385, -0.03510783240199089, -0.006462540943175554, -0.032881930470466614, 0.029538879171013832, 0.010486813262104988, 0.04249878600239754, -0.024451453238725662, 0.016032535582780838, -0.0032841044012457132, 0.03962050750851631, 0.005193938966840506, 0.007971893064677715, -0.009878979064524174, 0.04702659696340561, 0.010058319196105003, -0.01831045188009739, 0.026971930637955666, -0.028688393533229828, -0.0035461296793073416, -0.005505056120455265, -0.01923045702278614, 0.01133027020841837, -0.042348843067884445, -0.04487622156739235, 0.00018956995336338878, -0.001968034077435732, 0.004419113975018263, -0.023278789594769478, 0.00454657431691885, 0.04963601008057594, -0.054610345512628555, 0.010176418349146843, 0.029284540563821793, -0.024489663541316986, -0.023929379880428314, -0.03201695904135704, 0.021816961467266083, 0.04050128906965256, 0.0031923046335577965, -0.10248589515686035, 0.01406120602041483, -0.01960069313645363, 0.014431221410632133, -0.007415961939841509, -0.021680982783436775, -0.0067977504804730415, 0.002640706254169345, -0.02044674940407276, -0.01793532259762287, 0.05985989794135094, -0.013658527284860611, -0.04951116815209389, -0.003691413439810276, 0.038166388869285583, 0.04269563779234886, -0.008745775558054447, -0.008237333968281746, 0.01162695698440075, -0.04732602462172508, -0.0011633906979113817, -0.003295776667073369, 0.029188405722379684, -0.01012561284005642, 0.009594210423529148, -0.03255068138241768, 0.025054601952433586, 0.01929720863699913, -0.0005697080632671714, -0.00454770727083087, 0.01759977452456951, -0.04293312877416611, -0.039398130029439926, -0.027117211371660233, -0.03158187121152878, -0.06009351834654808, 0.001752724638208747, 0.02776363678276539, 0.032075509428977966, -0.03225826099514961, -0.003450518473982811, 0.02681158296763897, -0.030663158744573593, 0.0021079976577311754, -0.006588106043636799, 0.07499296218156815, 0.026712404564023018, -0.023752132430672646, -0.01726246252655983, -0.029861867427825928, 0.051268644630908966, -0.006620663683861494, -0.015478615649044514, -0.019691824913024902, 0.03629591688513756, -0.02514207735657692, -0.016806386411190033, -0.010957488790154457, 0.04329274594783783, 0.08834799379110336, -0.014156656339764595, 0.033313535153865814, 0.045262474566698074, -0.0010567429708316922, -0.04092130810022354, -0.06552127748727798, 0.0480390302836895, -0.013479667715728283, 0.014823105186223984, 0.06672798842191696, 0.0016947017284110188, -0.0233869981020689, 0.020162079483270645, 0.023305319249629974, 0.017691468819975853, -0.003490364644676447, 0.037221603095531464, 0.03294667974114418, 0.030164415016770363, -0.049475766718387604, -0.019503850489854813, 0.03390821814537048, -0.017231617122888565, 0.025648605078458786, 0.003978760913014412, -0.0061532421968877316, 0.026011979207396507, 0.021975163370370865, 0.04049510508775711, -0.042854778468608856, -0.040215957909822464, -0.040445201098918915, 0.022695790976285934, 0.005347674712538719, -0.004031667020171881, 0.010714980773627758, 0.014413797296583652, 0.01819494180381298, -0.005791808478534222, 0.004938927944749594, -0.052783433347940445, -0.06421923637390137, -0.05084734782576561, -0.014154812321066856, -0.021488437429070473, 0.002359082456678152, 0.020758936181664467, -0.013118816539645195, 0.007718640845268965, -0.023509323596954346, 0.01648566871881485, 0.03017403371632099, -0.0014574264641851187, -0.028309112414717674, 0.01326488982886076, 0.005364603828638792, 0.039106305688619614, -0.007947680540382862, -0.04282508045434952, 0.11846178025007248, 0.0634385347366333, 0.03288508579134941, -0.03985961899161339, 0.022156158462166786, 0.01357690617442131, 0.005802208092063665, -0.01923314295709133, 0.0333738699555397, 0.010198636911809444, 0.004035981837660074, 0.025920020416378975, 0.05245862901210785, -0.01234819833189249, 0.00819396786391735, 0.022026389837265015, -0.08822504431009293, -0.015848077833652496, -0.006039315834641457, -0.01247254479676485, 0.0003565824299585074, -0.037223294377326965, -0.07116503268480301, 0.0309661366045475, -0.0014155898243188858, -0.03935040533542633, -0.016334576532244682, -0.02115558832883835, 0.011392530985176563, 0.01871362514793873, -0.014532862231135368, 0.011200402863323689, 0.005780891049653292, -0.006520675029605627, -0.020247692242264748, -0.00040221703238785267, 0.01729133352637291, -0.04530586302280426, 0.03238958120346069, 0.029503727331757545, 0.009317665360867977, 0.0002917358942795545, 0.007660032249987125, -0.0015555877471342683, -0.04513042792677879, 0.004892670549452305, -0.04441535100340843, 0.07572199404239655, -0.033993419259786606, 0.02253801003098488, 0.016188282519578934, -0.021755799651145935, -0.018733084201812744, -0.03631823882460594, -0.03459811583161354, 0.02440801076591015, 0.04434061795473099, -0.03193342313170433, -0.007012675981968641, -0.0036362549290060997, 0.008320326916873455, -0.01916327141225338, 0.05008517950773239, 0.03114050254225731, -0.016651839017868042, -0.01071680523455143, -0.025351354852318764, 0.06347920745611191, 0.00975360069423914, 0.006796830799430609, -0.025535332038998604, -0.04633873328566551, -0.004413837566971779, -0.0015304674161598086, -0.007005938794463873, -0.056881386786699295, 0.05649149417877197, -0.039311423897743225, -0.005664296913892031, -0.014643258415162563, -0.05241423472762108, 0.0036864473950117826, -0.03761172667145729, 0.004430785309523344, -0.03051137365400791, -0.0020779315382242203, 0.01980471983551979, 0.06535794585943222, -0.01586206629872322, 0.013458975590765476, 0.03976082801818848, 0.04908736050128937, -0.020047226920723915, -0.042752768844366074, -0.02217838726937771, -0.01985970325767994, -0.05347686633467674, 0.002843341324478388, -0.01085225772112608, 0.06697870790958405, 0.040781326591968536, 0.0677386224269867, 0.007082855794578791, 0.03270232304930687, -0.030653342604637146, 0.0064850482158362865, 0.01382681354880333, -0.03699682652950287, -0.0016188957961276174, 0.006295246072113514, 0.0008609818760305643, -0.08415929973125458, -0.02070300281047821, -0.03641252964735031, -0.027032146230340004, 0.04573871195316315, -0.025202026590704918, -0.04095275700092316, 0.034952159970998764, -0.02633223496377468, 0.022280486300587654, -0.009728282690048218, -0.02099527232348919, -0.01914275996387005, -0.006005956791341305, -0.022681675851345062, 0.02090436965227127, 0.010550805367529392, 0.006917863618582487, -0.026517944410443306, -0.002056289464235306, 0.03144276514649391, 0.003921784460544586, 0.02202061004936695, 0.02239253558218479, 0.008804340846836567, 0.0021715087350457907, 0.04754871875047684, -0.01597382314503193, 0.014894974417984486, 0.022352533414959908, -0.062432654201984406, -0.014441478997468948, -0.004433481488376856, -0.004965286701917648, 0.029228735715150833, 0.0013618580996990204, -0.012616361491382122, -0.05192560330033302, -0.00021066846966277808, 0.0024069901555776596, -0.02009310945868492, 0.022689010947942734, 0.007299751043319702, -0.013357655145227909, -0.018811607733368874, -0.003379776608198881, 0.008225717581808567, -0.024464396759867668, 0.01488937996327877, -0.013813829980790615, -0.01926368474960327, -0.04773026704788208, 0.029474418610334396, 0.008969317190349102, 0.0005103103467263281, 0.025397000834345818, 0.0020873507019132376, 0.00474358256906271, 0.043297722935676575, -0.044483453035354614, 0.05221033841371536, -0.009695631451904774, 0.009951349347829819, -0.07590438425540924, -0.006582697853446007, -0.012525655329227448, 0.003241786966100335, 0.036621976643800735, -0.059108395129442215, 0.006172575522214174, 0.06472792476415634, -0.07823343575000763, 0.031522564589977264, -0.016592321917414665, 0.026146724820137024, -0.06198573112487793, 0.022403305396437645, -0.032821472734212875, 0.05183529108762741, 0.037849146872758865, 0.02082776091992855, 0.036815617233514786, 0.020408112555742264, 0.002635456621646881, -0.05675014108419418, -0.013842619955539703, 0.03309309482574463, 0.028781812638044357, -0.053387194871902466, 0.06315506994724274, 0.004305936861783266, -0.02300083637237549, -0.0007753127138130367, -0.03849520906805992, -0.017844662070274353, 0.012116615660488605, 0.013832628726959229, -0.009794363752007484, 0.038312800228595734, 0.007900000549852848, 0.03214404731988907, 0.025901643559336662, -0.02523897774517536, 0.0258110910654068, 0.03368022292852402, -0.014201787300407887, -0.00022915209410712123, 0.03710297495126724, -0.019615670666098595, -0.0001974982733372599, -0.013549075461924076, 0.0019885594956576824, -0.033911049365997314, 0.027738310396671295, 0.02250984124839306, -0.04254310950636864, -0.028916921466588974, 0.006073942873626947, -0.02226436696946621, -0.013041221536695957, 0.026823770254850388, 0.025736168026924133, -0.010340013541281223, 0.0049563320353627205, 0.01191263273358345, -0.04680133983492851, 0.030010385438799858, 0.009290381334722042, -0.004417782183736563, -0.08351992815732956, 0.011146310716867447, 0.008593722246587276, -0.005969692952930927, -0.030853459611535072, -0.020862707868218422, -0.02245514653623104, 0.062173206359148026, 0.002285744296386838, 0.022732030600309372, -0.022988026961684227, -0.015367938205599785, -0.0067904675379395485, -0.07776663452386856, 0.060637764632701874, 0.028666600584983826, 0.00602627033367753, 0.025413066148757935, -0.01175683829933405, -0.03262289613485336, 0.02269718050956726, 0.045208439230918884, 0.017171630635857582, -0.01114467903971672, 0.0064658490009605885, 0.009130574762821198, 0.0023871632292866707, -0.01856166683137417, 0.014739777892827988, -0.029824666678905487, -0.03675764054059982, 0.010102348402142525, -0.024643486365675926, 0.03225758671760559, -0.011815356090664864, 0.03157908096909523, -0.05852014943957329, 0.03088521584868431, 0.002511837985366583, -0.017487935721874237, 0.010552654042840004, -0.020519781857728958, -0.020215246826410294, 0.022619228810071945, -0.003079548943787813, -0.002202053088694811, 0.00982020702213049, 0.012252832762897015, -0.07971812039613724, 0.021491406485438347, -0.040647391229867935, -0.01666773296892643, 0.019663002341985703, 0.02312500774860382, 0.027181308716535568, -0.021196816116571426, -0.006730030756443739, 0.020216403529047966, -0.029949674382805824, -0.01877993904054165, 0.04459172487258911, 0.011020852252840996, 0.03343724086880684, 0.016728898510336876, 0.023351311683654785, 0.012653093785047531, 0.005733383819460869, 0.05333873629570007, 0.02883802354335785, 0.00110418233089149, 0.005181832239031792, -0.041181620210409164, 0.02464376762509346, -0.033000022172927856, 0.06562252342700958, -0.018204914405941963, 0.021020574495196342, -0.00004831336627830751, -0.005950078368186951, -0.0062476047314703465, 0.01696898229420185, 0.014773828908801079, -0.033727869391441345, 0.009046128951013088, 0.043694525957107544, -0.008799043484032154, 0.015332755632698536, -0.017920253798365593, -0.03196175396442413, -0.02612459473311901, 0.011569680646061897, -0.003648546524345875, 0.024708712473511696, -0.005812438204884529, -0.0062089525163173676, 0.0060975090600550175, -0.01541813276708126, 0.011865595355629921, -0.009377493523061275, 0.03276708349585533, -0.01324071642011404, -0.010972199030220509, -0.0015970946988090873, -0.007143570575863123, 0.007160323206335306, -0.04183308780193329, 0.009206644259393215, 0.03947329521179199, 0.004606455098837614, -0.0036880546249449253, -0.006234964355826378, -0.06372995674610138, 0.060777369886636734, -0.05111566558480263, -0.03858238831162453, -0.04707508534193039, 0.006673429161310196, -0.006720301229506731, -0.032037701457738876 ]
<p>Suppose I have <em>repeated</em> time observations for 800 meter sprint for a group of athletes over the course of a season. <strong>I would like to test the hypothesis that all the times are drawn from the same unspecified distribution (i.e., that the distributions of each athlete's finishing times are all the same).</strong> The number of trials for each athlete may be somewhat different. I am willing to assume that athletes do not influence one another through some sort of competitive effect (Bob doesn't run faster because Bill is ahead), but that each athlete's performances are correlated over time.</p> <p>Are there any simple hypothesis tests that can handle this? My first inclination was a k-sample Anderson Darling test or the Kruskal-Wallis equality-of-populations rank test, but I am not sure if these can be used on panel data since each athlete's performance over time is not independent. I have only seen these tests applied to groups within a cross-section, like testing for the equality of the median income distribution across all <a href="http://www.i-italy.org/files/55image/where%20we%20live/US%20Census%20Regions%20and%20Divisions.png" rel="nofollow">four census regions</a> simultaneously with US state-level data. Instead, could I use these to test whether the distribution for each state's median income over time looks like all the other states' distributions?</p>
74,420
[ -0.04381030425429344, -0.024254085496068, -0.010033578611910343, -0.005083001218736172, 0.02011089213192463, 0.022335728630423546, -0.015370935201644897, -0.018723053857684135, 0.008737865835428238, -0.019319241866469383, 0.04234243184328079, -0.0132106002420187, 0.03786921128630638, -0.008948764763772488, 0.02235695719718933, -0.006907291244715452, -0.01749279722571373, 0.024854613468050957, -0.028927816078066826, -0.036557406187057495, -0.007805198896676302, 0.016791610047221184, -0.016064459457993507, -0.022721365094184875, -0.043075039982795715, 0.028228744864463806, -0.013113591820001602, -0.029927633702754974, -0.0004669461923185736, 0.07416611164808273, -0.038632769137620926, -0.009723256342113018, -0.011361749842762947, 0.026366975158452988, -0.003384361742064357, -0.013262880966067314, -0.034797802567481995, -0.037791907787323, 0.014464931562542915, 0.04487264156341553, -0.06622333824634552, -0.004311517346650362, 0.010419182479381561, 0.03372340276837349, -0.015457012690603733, 0.024721218273043633, 0.004688065033406019, -0.024180883541703224, 0.042169492691755295, -0.023082517087459564, 0.06102880835533142, 0.012383844703435898, 0.025760836899280548, 0.0021416214294731617, -0.04394904524087906, -0.00790003314614296, 0.02010381408035755, 0.06581801176071167, 0.03267516568303108, -0.006276640575379133, 0.003395406762138009, -0.030486034229397774, 0.0012902605812996626, -0.02994692698121071, -0.04793795198202133, 0.0010685560991987586, -0.018541835248470306, 0.0028664651326835155, 0.01872941665351391, -0.036631204187870026, 0.032858528196811676, 0.036054421216249466, 0.07241383194923401, 0.029583889991044998, -0.005660811439156532, -0.02048182114958763, 0.03319394588470459, -0.018669722601771355, 0.06043716147542, 0.03731292486190796, -0.020796852186322212, 0.01119412574917078, 0.008897075429558754, 0.02729756385087967, 0.0577208548784256, -0.04115666449069977, 0.037682995200157166, -0.053347986191511154, -0.0065996996127069, 0.022248215973377228, -0.051197636872529984, -0.030329527333378792, 0.03942986950278282, 0.03786976635456085, -0.06537844240665436, 0.023748023435473442, -0.028271066024899483, 0.012556358240544796, -0.026990357786417007, 0.0024320855736732483, -0.00918865017592907, -0.05788475275039673, 0.009832697920501232, 0.03768439218401909, 0.017563197761774063, -0.0024352343752980232, -0.027580494061112404, 0.005415796302258968, -0.0087560024112463, 0.008208689279854298, -0.048000454902648926, -0.004511027596890926, 0.010425613261759281, 0.026324452832341194, 0.032071784138679504, 0.024968884885311127, -0.004096094518899918, 0.03094465099275112, 0.05972783640027046, 0.060787901282310486, 0.055540282279253006, -0.029692964628338814, -0.01173218060284853, -0.04054107144474983, -0.029062947258353233, 0.04432966187596321, -0.028589557856321335, -0.028956416994333267, -0.005608015228062868, 0.059549059718847275, 0.013168133795261383, -0.011785435490310192, 0.026737196370959282, -0.0148240365087986, 0.049315840005874634, -0.00011945061851292849, -0.09390714019536972, -0.06784240156412125, 0.0019169023726135492, 0.01804381236433983, -0.037550125271081924, -0.046722523868083954, -0.008630101568996906, -0.02746443636715412, 0.04642070457339287, -0.026611149311065674, 0.06740758568048477, -0.00016856288129929453, 0.04613780602812767, 0.04842396825551987, -0.009283565916121006, -0.03007875196635723, -0.025415150448679924, -0.006232653744518757, 0.017970653250813484, -0.07841971516609192, -0.0031874182168394327, 0.0030570088420063257, -0.020885201171040535, 0.021162791177630424, 0.06685180962085724, 0.06147458031773567, -0.013228505849838257, -0.009844121523201466, 0.023452017456293106, 0.01639750227332115, 0.06518343836069107, -0.004598227795213461, 0.026611998677253723, -0.014735021628439426, 0.007943547330796719, 0.02400536648929119, 0.021556276828050613, 0.04537376016378403, 0.01458406075835228, -0.028247619047760963, 0.02899555303156376, 0.006391450297087431, -0.022346297279000282, -0.0059355334378778934, -0.021476024761795998, 0.013656058348715305, -0.024773750454187393, -0.03887610137462616, 0.029874706640839577, 0.02329956367611885, 0.016352325677871704, 0.014431101270020008, 0.06410395354032516, -0.06435979157686234, -0.046625856310129166, -0.05539899319410324, -0.007234345655888319, 0.03204844519495964, -0.05108519271016121, 0.04594961926341057, -0.0037299967370927334, 0.05176522955298424, -0.027280088514089584, -0.046928152441978455, -0.018649466335773468, 0.004011174198240042, 0.02096174657344818, 0.0043187313713133335, -0.004458004608750343, 0.030200432986021042, 0.05899161100387573, -0.025379350408911705, 0.0470065213739872, -0.014741620980203152, -0.04255169257521629, 0.02322624996304512, -0.0338110588490963, 0.02385115809738636, 0.005384619813412428, 0.07539565116167068, -0.01737820915877819, 0.012230630964040756, -0.020378869026899338, 0.03780674561858177, -0.06526076048612595, 0.048889610916376114, 0.05795108899474144, -0.027847401797771454, -0.002947369823232293, 0.013186022639274597, 0.03479936346411705, 0.005705937743186951, -0.01688212715089321, -0.04406704008579254, -0.04799579083919525, -0.006573053542524576, 0.003689468139782548, -0.013430843129754066, -0.04468270391225815, 0.03904709592461586, 0.0718291848897934, 0.0371844619512558, -0.009699342772364616, 0.015027791261672974, 0.028631988912820816, -0.010692620649933815, 0.02856648899614811, -0.013712461106479168, 0.008571880869567394, 0.02978254109621048, 0.041258491575717926, 0.00313078542239964, -0.0031406960915774107, -0.014809973537921906, 0.03499945253133774, 0.02095027267932892, 0.029504062607884407, 0.03717171773314476, -0.006036927457898855, -0.015561782754957676, 0.07820151746273041, 0.008090748451650143, 0.01625361107289791, 0.024389278143644333, 0.024455683305859566, 0.013758230023086071, 0.0011834350880235434, -0.04251415282487869, 0.02336154505610466, 0.031016556546092033, -0.020189372822642326, -0.029955755919218063, 0.017498785629868507, -0.02796759642660618, 0.016467055305838585, -0.027329519391059875, -0.029126986861228943, -0.04542071372270584, -0.011177276261150837, 0.05443733185529709, 0.007565305568277836, 0.008787623606622219, -0.03519470989704132, -0.007019840180873871, 0.012828999198973179, 0.006258297245949507, 0.01727050356566906, 0.011077869683504105, -0.04810114577412605, 0.030705688521265984, -0.013935008086264133, -0.0352218896150589, 0.026613688096404076, 0.008470667526125908, -0.029112545773386955, 0.044824957847595215, 0.018538279458880424, -0.006715892348438501, -0.02349938079714775, -0.03747336566448212, 0.004623345099389553, -0.0561729297041893, 0.0016952021978795528, 0.07299748063087463, -0.0003502982435747981, -0.03703674301505089, 0.029192430898547173, -0.02668650448322296, 0.01838967204093933, -0.01494737807661295, -0.0010505731916055083, 0.023190712556242943, 0.02870124578475952, 0.03385549038648605, 0.034334696829319, -0.0006220501963980496, -0.02906028740108013, -0.07357167452573776, -0.08284828066825867, 0.04915284365415573, -0.009410503320395947, 0.044759705662727356, 0.005639712791889906, -0.021423133090138435, 0.04817657172679901, 0.05218649283051491, 0.02350306697189808, -0.025982586666941643, -0.017168495804071426, -0.009493883699178696, -0.018246322870254517, 0.03648318350315094, -0.00230897543951869, -0.030186187475919724, 0.011867683380842209, 0.011604896746575832, 0.05023617669939995, 0.04221838712692261, -0.010984465479850769, 0.000119723379611969, 0.015760697424411774, -0.00008486089791404083, 0.0036462382413446903, 0.038397904485464096, 0.025251641869544983, -0.016599351540207863, -0.0027107917703688145, 0.0035556755028665066, -0.009376256726682186, 0.012619571760296822, -0.035971127450466156, 0.030001308768987656, -0.005811397917568684, -0.01950329728424549, -0.06613601744174957, 0.043126337230205536, 0.012001041322946548, -0.027274910360574722, -0.0015119655290618539, 0.011359297670423985, 0.026951177045702934, 0.025015778839588165, 0.03517952188849449, 0.03423222899436951, 0.026501409709453583, -0.022552048787474632, -0.018642660230398178, -0.056533340364694595, 0.0004848028183914721, 0.013190031982958317, -0.046340834349393845, -0.008601357229053974, 0.005224008113145828, 0.021635878831148148, 0.01424578670412302, -0.021983452141284943, -0.051032356917858124, 0.005331188440322876, -0.06665420532226562, 0.0009105773060582578, -0.019084647297859192, 0.03937780112028122, -0.005829704459756613, 0.03708482161164284, 0.0361943282186985, 0.009949921630322933, 0.006406663917005062, -0.0069325631484389305, -0.002193294931203127, -0.002140062628313899, -0.03105378895998001, -0.031089089810848236, 0.0020466551650315523, -0.026875052601099014, 0.04232433810830116, 0.0024955773260444403, -0.005789805203676224, 0.032717008143663406, 0.02782258950173855, -0.034102700650691986, -0.023124171420931816, -0.006310460157692432, -0.05946790799498558, 0.027758033946156502, -0.004133512731641531, 0.007970010861754417, -0.008376853540539742, 0.01117214560508728, 0.03352916240692139, 0.011914004571735859, -0.027111060917377472, -0.04132672771811485, 0.006843718234449625, -0.005844946950674057, 0.035934727638959885, 0.025917835533618927, 0.028493192046880722, -0.05462845787405968, 0.03660521283745766, -0.016105514019727707, 0.053942643105983734, 0.007520378101617098, -0.015706339851021767, -0.04126863181591034, -0.030207468196749687, -0.019641200080513954, 0.005218380596488714, 0.02153630368411541, 0.04163774102926254, -0.02427290752530098, 0.02148902788758278, 0.04945097863674164, -0.036720164120197296, 0.021040398627519608, 0.021224500611424446, -0.0005387525307014585, 0.031223785132169724, -0.01561741717159748, -0.05438650771975517, -0.0035440048668533564, -0.009335668757557869, 0.02713494561612606, -0.008343026973307133, 0.01858660578727722, 0.023656044155359268, 0.05289344862103462, 0.01632273942232132, -0.0072453501634299755, 0.037162572145462036, 0.002947933739051223, 0.05803080275654793, -0.03294221684336662, -0.022948887199163437, 0.026752399280667305, 0.02465365082025528, 0.016615869477391243, 0.04705897718667984, 0.014621347188949585, -0.07589113712310791, 0.026630587875843048, 0.03855625167489052, 0.014669707976281643, -0.02482980489730835, 0.01498209498822689, -0.03729155287146568, 0.014946915209293365, 0.03559113293886185, -0.01988617330789566, 0.01658211089670658, 0.02009202353656292, 0.0027397486846894026, -0.044899534434080124, -0.005117547698318958, -0.01076589711010456, 0.0094124311581254, -0.01423205528408289, 0.002391582587733865, -0.02587486058473587, -0.021101852878928185, -0.03752142935991287, 0.001451051328331232, 0.0355154313147068, 0.028936319053173065, -0.009328976273536682, -0.015592028386890888, 0.022536152973771095, -0.011507034301757812, -0.052131287753582, -0.0588369183242321, 0.014803689904510975, -0.016567949205636978, 0.02742992527782917, 0.040073856711387634, -0.008802151307463646, -0.0318828821182251, 0.019475765526294708, -0.039057694375514984, -0.014056814834475517, 0.01976477913558483, -0.01180391013622284, 0.044675666838884354, 0.019341278821229935, 0.02621217630803585, 0.011072894558310509, 0.0016800654120743275, 0.011548394337296486, 0.020187614485621452, -0.024778014048933983, 0.004975852556526661, -0.02130819484591484, -0.03303078934550285, -0.00884325336664915, -0.03628062456846237, -0.013138617388904095, -0.001450562966056168, -0.041202615946531296, 0.031030643731355667, -0.008349545300006866, -0.02402586303651333, -0.03370361402630806, 0.010394820012152195, -0.004463814198970795, -0.0072254883125424385, -0.009748492389917374, 0.016327522695064545, -0.01053202711045742, -0.02385924570262432, 0.0150881577283144, 0.0010017286986112595, -0.008451824076473713, -0.030917048454284668, -0.019668951630592346, 0.03929053992033005, -0.034945499151945114, 0.0017901754472404718, -0.011989454738795757, -0.01660272665321827, 0.02744927443563938, -0.009684865362942219, 0.02417147159576416, 0.006888118572533131, -0.012434002012014389, -0.027857426553964615, 0.0391661711037159, 0.007404572330415249, 0.027919834479689598, -0.0016349180368706584, 0.017844004556536674, -0.005893255118280649, -0.0013732933439314365, -0.11160209029912949, -0.00019212068582419306, 0.012051896192133427, 0.003028923412784934, 0.007869292981922626, -0.05016036331653595, 0.006817573215812445, -0.006714513059705496, 0.0026274542324244976, -0.009274601005017757, 0.06859583407640457, -0.015468762256205082, -0.01215802039951086, -0.006948197726160288, 0.07508346438407898, 0.10811770707368851, -0.028603211045265198, -0.009356481023132801, 0.024396225810050964, -0.02610565721988678, -0.011341758072376251, -0.0251967441290617, 0.005139373708516359, -0.026920853182673454, 0.010989360511302948, -0.01470042672008276, 0.020106784999370575, 0.02860102429986, -0.006944986060261726, -0.03209856152534485, 0.018643604591488838, -0.025734012946486473, 0.043246012181043625, -0.04493070766329765, 0.019039439037442207, -0.03948509693145752, 0.004916943144053221, -0.03712720796465874, 0.02055286057293415, -0.0011023784754797816, -0.023853307589888573, 0.04300810024142265, -0.008886617608368397, -0.050400640815496445, 0.017223801463842392, 0.07034198939800262, -0.015322193503379822, -0.0010919177439063787, 0.0051364596001803875, -0.01263200119137764, 0.0564788319170475, -0.0038506954442709684, -0.03825627639889717, -0.019269682466983795, 0.02075117453932762, -0.038066305220127106, -0.018488090485334396, -0.01753736473619938, -0.0023593008518218994, 0.037643615156412125, 0.009369425475597382, 0.03557100519537926, 0.09615321457386017, 0.0017277374863624573, 0.04692428931593895, -0.03781330585479736, 0.037186771631240845, -0.029598623514175415, -0.008100226521492004, 0.03895052894949913, 0.008787739090621471, -0.0008433531620539725, 0.040392521768808365, 0.040702935308218, 0.010179908946156502, 0.005954124499112368, 0.013941071927547455, 0.016246292740106583, 0.0410173125565052, -0.04136545956134796, -0.031051894649863243, 0.04190608859062195, -0.03521067649126053, 0.0030810979660600424, -0.046444762498140335, -0.00018040317809209228, 0.028731949627399445, 0.05498072877526283, -0.0028707643505185843, -0.03644059598445892, -0.050832103937864304, -0.07204028964042664, 0.02826899103820324, 0.012733610346913338, 0.00017019014921970665, 0.012253218330442905, 0.029959728941321373, 0.06697594374418259, 0.027447663247585297, 0.031093833968043327, -0.047120776027441025, -0.02496909908950329, -0.00810644868761301, -0.018573932349681854, -0.03599293902516365, 0.006997097749263048, -0.0125392721965909, -0.00591310067102313, 0.020503753796219826, -0.03654228895902634, 0.029382184147834778, 0.005327919032424688, 0.021676303818821907, -0.02391192503273487, 0.06998646259307861, 0.001880584517493844, 0.03355519101023674, -0.003626264166086912, -0.010341908782720566, 0.13044364750385284, 0.04921671748161316, 0.05258076637983322, -0.02049308642745018, 0.0036512671504169703, 0.01769060268998146, 0.015485170297324657, -0.03595921769738197, -0.023901047185063362, 0.02280760370194912, -0.004750881809741259, 0.04468417540192604, 0.0710272490978241, -0.0004214597574900836, 0.002621482592076063, 0.04436459392309189, 0.002613871358335018, 0.028070984408259392, 0.006881870329380035, 0.004445586819201708, 0.008317233063280582, -0.015942823141813278, -0.011513604782521725, 0.02653009071946144, -0.013707481324672699, 0.004338629078119993, -0.008342409506440163, -0.038976654410362244, -0.007454144302755594, 0.03626113012433052, -0.03459494560956955, -0.00993036013096571, 0.041932109743356705, -0.01343435887247324, -0.05120662972331047, -0.036319028586149216, -0.028668375685811043, -0.03433538228273392, 0.03852497413754463, 0.019116342067718506, 0.0005418348591774702, -0.00509638013318181, -0.024767206981778145, 0.014830187894403934, -0.019549131393432617, -0.012387556955218315, -0.0313742570579052, 0.023960210382938385, -0.060266170650720596, -0.03340267762541771, -0.02060995250940323, -0.0036798124201595783, -0.029223309829831123, -0.03359224274754524, -0.041030485183000565, -0.012763509526848793, 0.009215329773724079, -0.04192293435335159, -0.010153353214263916, -0.020955968648195267, 0.017965828999876976, 0.0024069135542958975, 0.008502601645886898, 0.01654241792857647, -0.032763224095106125, -0.025511233136057854, -0.055563319474458694, 0.02651285193860531, 0.0097764628008008, -0.059078942984342575, -0.01792043447494507, -0.021904312074184418, -0.048008762300014496, -0.0037750848568975925, 0.007564035709947348, 0.00556056946516037, 0.01694609597325325, 0.025220481678843498, -0.02537464164197445, 0.0005838526994921267, -0.00892197247594595, -0.03774028271436691, -0.05196637287735939, 0.024324936792254448, -0.030045904219150543, -0.0014819275820627809, 0.06990345567464828, 0.019050033763051033, -0.01629953272640705, 0.012987198308110237, -0.00030207811505533755, 0.06877072900533676, -0.004288091789931059, -0.05296128988265991, -0.006965475622564554, -0.07061131298542023, -0.024901963770389557, -0.00022528949193656445, -0.02969806268811226, 0.05684864893555641, 0.023575633764266968, 0.02449350245296955, -0.004828454926609993, 0.0104721300303936, -0.01097448542714119, 0.026455799117684364, 0.01565581187605858, -0.07119647413492203, -0.00963735580444336, 0.020890874788165092, 0.007464999333024025, -0.03704245761036873, -0.02208472415804863, -0.05994950234889984, -0.020698148757219315, 0.007557111792266369, -0.0757700651884079, -0.05038730800151825, 0.0037997188046574593, -0.043975815176963806, 0.02999531850218773, -0.018338659778237343, 0.004302315879613161, -0.03369100019335747, -0.03096736967563629, -0.048594143241643906, 0.028005842119455338, 0.021088633686304092, 0.003175419755280018, -0.01348442304879427, -0.014504222199320793, 0.03397226706147194, -0.014946824871003628, -0.01908644288778305, 0.013665955513715744, 0.02047426626086235, 0.004626387730240822, 0.04124472290277481, 0.01987992413341999, 0.0010706352768465877, 0.07107315212488174, -0.0357731357216835, -0.01565471850335598, 0.016466448083519936, -0.00888783298432827, 0.04848405346274376, -0.0005196918500587344, -0.03182217478752136, -0.004556025378406048, -0.008433092385530472, -0.03363579139113426, 0.020689871162176132, -0.027206329628825188, 0.01415174175053835, 0.06715454161167145, -0.003465021727606654, 0.009680531919002533, 0.0200810544192791, -0.033326976001262665, 0.003969123587012291, 0.03372053802013397, 0.0007540663355030119, -0.0191376693546772, -0.0015943687176331878, -0.03012734092772007, 0.00903212558478117, 0.01377363782376051, -0.018305454403162003, 0.0436863899230957, 0.08009613305330276, -0.01200126763433218, 0.014324340969324112, -0.03255724161863327, 0.005405861418694258, -0.08008366078138351, -0.04194886237382889, 0.016531802713871002, 0.01271470170468092, 0.02404806576669216, -0.01959434524178505, -0.01408690121024847, 0.022253580391407013, -0.06213100254535675, 0.06755662709474564, -0.004974792245775461, 0.010249619372189045, -0.06246550381183624, 0.014304366894066334, -0.004639236722141504, 0.04262666031718254, 0.015395508147776127, 0.01374166551977396, -0.0010847141966223717, 0.049257438629865646, 0.008127361536026001, 0.008456542156636715, -0.0045144143514335155, -0.00019859180611092597, 0.03460495173931122, -0.0706629529595375, 0.03334726393222809, -0.03919705003499985, -0.01567794755101204, 0.03398067131638527, -0.04496579244732857, 0.02485174685716629, -0.0027708522975444794, 0.004397077951580286, -0.012026552110910416, 0.034394703805446625, 0.0031354976817965508, -0.01047032792121172, -0.027797428891062737, -0.006879530381411314, 0.01632128655910492, 0.03747711703181267, -0.035718757659196854, 0.008658740669488907, 0.015739325433969498, -0.023623038083314896, -0.004540720023214817, 0.005898324307054281, 0.003112894482910633, -0.023266663774847984, 0.05113385617733002, -0.013479029759764671, 0.014239015989005566, 0.0580676905810833, 0.04780515655875206, -0.022309115156531334, 0.015905437991023064, -0.0019176043570041656, 0.024270912632346153, -0.037671636790037155, 0.02925003319978714, -0.0074509200640022755, -0.03248503431677818, 0.01696845144033432, -0.007638242095708847, -0.019696811214089394, -0.02165747806429863, 0.007047946099191904, -0.03802938014268875, 0.00986773893237114, -0.05527699738740921, -0.026770254597067833, -0.008451411500573158, 0.014585671946406364, -0.00026904832338914275, -0.02221442572772503, 0.012713545002043247, 0.022337712347507477, 0.0024386574514210224, -0.11351042985916138, 0.046351559460163116, 0.03824533149600029, -0.015380768105387688, -0.01805722527205944, -0.016569966450333595, -0.025363843888044357, -0.019318925216794014, 0.04104192182421684, -0.0027533681131899357, 0.01280335895717144, 0.027651352807879448, 0.014153681695461273, -0.009821590036153793, -0.016956938430666924, 0.044160131365060806, -0.014822381548583508, -0.048404350876808167, -0.024422962218523026, 0.032659899443387985, 0.0002864862035494298, -0.0337025411427021, 0.01114033255726099, -0.029032306745648384, -0.009804600849747658, 0.02721628174185753, 0.010071084834635258, 0.04044927656650543, 0.01105636078864336, -0.012011011131107807, 0.01388033851981163, 0.0028746360912919044, 0.022516466677188873, -0.011030288413167, -0.0059991320595145226, -0.028420690447092056, 0.04458662495017052, -0.05228840932250023, -0.08435416221618652, -0.004753714893013239, 0.033005405217409134, -0.03507457301020622, -0.026986604556441307, 0.013953804038465023, -0.011491903103888035, -0.017278805375099182, 0.016764964908361435, 0.03340158984065056, 0.03217560797929764, 0.023853808641433716, -0.00004070092472829856, -0.011316894553601742, 0.0063788630068302155, -0.022174745798110962, 0.01182461902499199, 0.003588485298678279, 0.027997516095638275, 0.02046535722911358, -0.021875152364373207, 0.054727211594581604, -0.02114471048116684, 0.0356239452958107, -0.026583325117826462, 0.04982432350516319, -0.027367670089006424, -0.018525712192058563, 0.025428270921111107, 0.012754187919199467, 0.01578986831009388, 0.021080557256937027, 0.011351690627634525, 0.059409964829683304, -0.0007565569248981774, 0.02771255560219288, -0.047574155032634735, -0.013378135859966278, 0.0026731316465884447, 0.007447215728461742, 0.01267686951905489, -0.004151551052927971, -0.03925497457385063, -0.01683810167014599, 0.005337424576282501, -0.01938394457101822, 0.011320785619318485, -0.005080597009509802, 0.021977093070745468, -0.027824489399790764, -0.017582980915904045, -0.0008937701932154596, -0.02312026545405388, -0.01443501003086567, -0.03719661757349968, 0.02452586404979229, 0.033341243863105774, 0.04261178523302078, -0.024215059354901314, -0.023486753925681114, 0.028295552358031273, 0.04953945055603981, -0.09476691484451294, -0.03919178247451782, -0.043834004551172256, 0.054823726415634155, 0.024935344234108925, 0.019703207537531853 ]
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/1vzQ1.jpg" alt="Table"></p> <p>I am trying to come up with a method for deciding the winner from among eight student groups competing for a prize.</p> <p>The raw data and corresponding percentages measure participation per group in a campus program. </p> <p>The current rules say that the students who have the highest participation by percent of their population in the group win a prize.</p> <p>However, I have received complaints that this scoring system unfairly benefits small groups because it is supposedly easier to coordinate smaller groups of people and get a larger percentage of successes.</p> <p>I am not a mathematician, obviously, so I hope my description of the problem makes sense. </p> <p>As you can see, one of the student groups has 341 students and another has ony 11.</p> <p>Any help you can give will be very much appreciated and may keep a riot from breaking out among the winners/losers.</p>
74,421
[ -0.023766901344060898, -0.02895122580230236, -0.022219764068722725, -0.06387630850076675, 0.02346588671207428, 0.009976675733923912, -0.020751766860485077, -0.03299836814403534, 0.026932964101433754, -0.00595884770154953, 0.03839437663555145, 0.013683815486729145, 0.02955264039337635, 0.07834601402282715, 0.016576362773776054, -0.018613683059811592, -0.019270868971943855, 0.039046987891197205, 0.0008429848239757121, -0.012063884176313877, 0.0011652554385364056, 0.0004811990074813366, 0.004136628936976194, -0.026925398036837578, -0.028381912037730217, 0.008377869613468647, 0.04391415789723396, 0.016000743955373764, 0.018054967746138573, 0.05060102045536041, -0.039899688214063644, -0.011894488707184792, 0.032804667949676514, 0.011003030464053154, 0.016443701460957527, 0.027313677594065666, -0.04410271346569061, 0.008847353979945183, -0.008208154700696468, -0.026572000235319138, -0.03866814076900482, -0.0011821468360722065, -0.005789107643067837, 0.031465236097574234, 0.007409578189253807, 0.04636469483375549, -0.016428163275122643, -0.03116481937468052, 0.02328481897711754, -0.07735434174537659, 0.05008651688694954, 0.0748559907078743, 0.04328995943069458, 0.010365430265665054, -0.02287709154188633, 0.019236279651522636, 0.01613120548427105, 0.1101338192820549, -0.008568416349589825, -0.018864905461668968, -0.02124570496380329, -0.036997999995946884, -0.013116235844790936, -0.040948569774627686, -0.026537081226706505, 0.02467253990471363, -0.020335519686341286, -0.0031922520138323307, 0.028177188709378242, -0.010300399735569954, 0.0035653237719088793, 0.07752019912004471, 0.03032478503882885, -0.03471601754426956, 0.036697931587696075, -0.03685755655169487, 0.040414292365312576, -0.006385189015418291, 0.04134352505207062, 0.02597442828118801, 0.008001886308193207, 0.00658923527225852, 0.024742491543293, 0.05160347744822502, 0.01360974833369255, -0.0307038351893425, 0.01968885213136673, -0.03183009847998619, 0.032966408878564835, 0.006599390413612127, -0.04904302582144737, -0.012475989758968353, 0.06765781342983246, 0.01793208159506321, -0.04378762096166611, 0.042625222355127335, -0.012517916038632393, 0.041740093380212784, 0.03173726424574852, -0.034902423620224, 0.0030403377022594213, -0.028923649340867996, 0.008462263271212578, 0.07660185545682907, -0.01585308276116848, -0.026291264221072197, -0.0672382190823555, -0.0011023924453184009, -0.0033114857506006956, 0.003974431194365025, -0.011434904299676418, 0.0027092902455478907, 0.005170484073460102, 0.02152976207435131, 0.028425132855772972, -0.03650909662246704, -0.0211295485496521, -0.004547084216028452, 0.044140882790088654, 0.02832319214940071, 0.034728460013866425, -0.017197145149111748, 0.033632274717092514, -0.016751499846577644, -0.005095301661640406, 0.023777354508638382, 0.021159911528229713, 0.012070695869624615, -0.025061650201678276, 0.047343090176582336, -0.003471690695732832, -0.01643386296927929, 0.03809347748756409, -0.021447306498885155, 0.044902052730321884, -0.00989715475589037, -0.07738926261663437, -0.02963479422032833, 0.08622781932353973, 0.02556321769952774, 0.01308249868452549, -0.0520278662443161, -0.008890335448086262, 0.015020019374787807, 0.07090360671281815, -0.00865054689347744, 0.03192918002605438, -0.005674099083989859, 0.07618868350982666, 0.03163402900099754, -0.0002856738865375519, 0.012892389670014381, -0.016002442687749863, -0.025827061384916306, 0.015542601235210896, -0.057332199066877365, 0.006247617769986391, 0.01349905226379633, 0.01278176810592413, 0.0146429892629385, 0.023729853332042694, 0.011937115341424942, 0.010291779413819313, -0.024915410205721855, 0.04226318746805191, 0.0042760977521538734, 0.044629693031311035, 0.022644685581326485, -0.009637497365474701, -0.009373660199344158, 0.0014727180823683739, 0.05224289000034332, 0.009825755842030048, 0.028931666165590286, 0.03531404212117195, -0.0463077574968338, 0.010805128142237663, -0.008931807242333889, -0.014745375141501427, -0.008865484967827797, -0.03135271742939949, -0.025953209027647972, -0.02928825281560421, 0.02057606726884842, -0.006039215251803398, 0.046642933040857315, -0.006623381283134222, -0.0014453751500695944, 0.04712042957544327, -0.011466562747955322, -0.05969144403934479, -0.07392307370901108, -0.01680869609117508, -0.015840914100408554, -0.029615331441164017, 0.007073518354445696, 0.012223497033119202, 0.0055708857253193855, -0.011963768862187862, -0.022985471412539482, -0.01024594809859991, -0.00026189416530542076, 0.032139260321855545, 0.020337598398327827, -0.004802662879228592, 0.04269150644540787, 0.026789290830492973, -0.012987143360078335, 0.04700450971722603, -0.011237485334277153, -0.032133523374795914, -0.0005487988819368184, 0.0044756196439266205, 0.031476326286792755, -0.015302157029509544, -0.00470258854329586, -0.015158015303313732, 0.01413643267005682, 0.014961274340748787, 0.05801423266530037, -0.06366859376430511, 0.09573721885681152, 0.05761559307575226, 0.007557090371847153, 0.028895311057567596, -0.007320994511246681, 0.02617005445063114, 0.012693602591753006, 0.011037583462893963, -0.032478660345077515, -0.06029807776212692, 0.014088740572333336, 0.019291527569293976, 0.007028885185718536, -0.053920987993478775, 0.037198930978775024, 0.045514438301324844, 0.0318961963057518, 0.029567398130893707, 0.010424644686281681, -0.02441880851984024, 0.030200833454728127, 0.0038232828956097364, 0.04434804990887642, -0.010869676247239113, 0.0337018184363842, 0.007939254865050316, 0.02056119777262211, -0.007569762412458658, 0.025581324473023415, -0.03273129090666771, 0.03355497494339943, -0.0024297768250107765, 0.020398637279868126, -0.005178794730454683, -0.01973961479961872, 0.03609630838036537, -0.009594365023076534, 0.028391383588314056, 0.0301180649548769, 0.00031879774178378284, -0.005109307821840048, 0.0005338806076906621, -0.04369528219103813, 0.003504485357552767, 0.031859058886766434, -0.057603105902671814, 0.006028543226420879, 0.02201084792613983, -0.01258314773440361, 0.010882746428251266, -0.014115740545094013, 0.001971253426745534, -0.05255094915628433, 0.019303957000374794, 0.02971835993230343, -0.003804432926699519, -0.012280761264264584, -0.019129831343889236, 0.015076878480613232, 0.007895645685493946, -0.008391543291509151, 0.012587292119860649, 0.027297070249915123, -0.07256412506103516, -0.018740450963377953, -0.018678970634937286, 0.011155097745358944, 0.061520978808403015, 0.019626958295702934, -0.005634397733956575, 0.0024010806810110807, -0.001593809574842453, -0.01345102209597826, 0.002151262015104294, -0.038063958287239075, 0.022116608917713165, -0.02657405659556389, 0.005982473026961088, 0.012072418816387653, 0.03790665417909622, -0.040481287986040115, 0.043679337948560715, -0.012640932574868202, -0.005609339568763971, -0.03357936441898346, 0.022577863186597824, 0.03264649212360382, 0.0011297786841169, 0.004542802460491657, -0.0024628019891679287, -0.004565602168440819, -0.025230254977941513, -0.08117496967315674, -0.0889441967010498, -0.030053356662392616, -0.018079811707139015, 0.03335818648338318, 0.02435183711349964, -0.023191707208752632, 0.048099130392074585, 0.014949331060051918, -0.021085118874907494, -0.021059444174170494, 0.006050487048923969, -0.03368527442216873, 0.016411667689681053, 0.03128254786133766, 0.02817465178668499, -0.014386727474629879, 0.01826864667236805, -0.003679037094116211, 0.017693210393190384, 0.08747538924217224, -0.01961337774991989, -0.03508557006716728, -0.008331981487572193, -0.00025677253142930567, -0.027334045618772507, 0.03782175853848457, 0.00912041962146759, -0.03575247898697853, 0.008442770689725876, 0.023103462532162666, 0.02498795837163925, 0.0071068392135202885, -0.04481840133666992, -0.018468135967850685, -0.006855491083115339, 0.029991786926984787, -0.018699001520872116, 0.02290891855955124, -0.0005685945507138968, -0.05116541311144829, 0.03953235596418381, -0.004149677697569132, 0.03266925364732742, -0.0359678715467453, -0.008933843113481998, 0.06544683128595352, 0.021503321826457977, -0.005552026443183422, -0.03704807534813881, -0.031325019896030426, -0.002199934795498848, 0.03292035311460495, -0.026323549449443817, 0.013945493847131729, 0.0028561600483953953, 0.01797032542526722, 0.010832336731255054, -0.014746136963367462, -0.03291551023721695, -0.022370541468262672, -0.09189137816429138, 0.008173002861440182, -0.04167810082435608, 0.06344080716371536, -0.020777923986315727, 0.04663110896945, -0.005200603976845741, -0.006158418953418732, 0.006181658245623112, 0.0062590171582996845, -0.05565103888511658, 0.028471553698182106, -0.01984565332531929, 0.01496662013232708, -0.0005735074519179761, -0.003613690147176385, 0.004027157090604305, -0.020951325073838234, -0.04042516648769379, 0.0011912737973034382, 0.031477492302656174, -0.00772168580442667, 0.04662342742085457, -0.05922294035553932, 0.02033352293074131, 0.003629977349191904, 0.021443435922265053, 0.02777150832116604, -0.011317582800984383, 0.05955018103122711, 0.060449209064245224, -0.0301887895911932, -0.031511079519987106, -0.0320451594889164, 0.0115635572001338, 0.05326751247048378, 0.022833755239844322, -0.00469787186011672, 0.0492909774184227, -0.03943650797009468, 0.003695110324770212, -0.012763122096657753, 0.046225015074014664, 0.005187124013900757, -0.021304093301296234, -0.018575001507997513, -0.028029458597302437, -0.033558476716279984, 0.0073920078575611115, 0.010274683125317097, -0.00035333496634848416, -0.0044276537373661995, 0.027750983834266663, 0.0409468337893486, -0.03493122383952141, 0.01844661310315132, 0.016107024624943733, 0.0004951678565703332, -0.04629975184798241, -0.010808072052896023, 0.00543115334585309, 0.012695280835032463, -0.02146327681839466, 0.004455717746168375, 0.05293958634138107, -0.0072221639566123486, 0.0012750596506521106, 0.04383520781993866, 0.008037687279284, -0.0733918696641922, 0.024405844509601593, -0.04841061681509018, 0.04671894386410713, -0.011242787353694439, -0.009570199064910412, 0.013886054046452045, 0.042717330157756805, 0.03242560476064682, 0.0032094689086079597, -0.011664050631225109, -0.05782773718237877, -0.03778654336929321, 0.010147754102945328, 0.07410816103219986, -0.016961894929409027, -0.0013493865262717009, -0.04938264936208725, -0.004758166614919901, 0.0460132397711277, -0.05607219040393829, 0.049294572323560715, 0.010320444591343403, -0.021034473553299904, -0.003981771878898144, 0.005017443094402552, -0.043812721967697144, 0.009079907089471817, -0.0028099033515900373, 0.047806594520807266, -0.001502273022197187, -0.020457711070775986, -0.03517432138323784, 0.015546189621090889, 0.060591232031583786, 0.03949884697794914, 0.007967608980834484, -0.04534842073917389, 0.02080249972641468, 0.009373731911182404, -0.04565350338816643, -0.06463898718357086, 0.027826715260744095, -0.0005508750327862799, 0.01945202797651291, 0.034752823412418365, -0.025655152276158333, -0.039457470178604126, 0.017935562878847122, -0.02066442184150219, -0.0052785868756473064, 0.003436532337218523, -0.018547067418694496, 0.04911298304796219, 0.08135546743869781, 0.0099807633087039, 0.010410452261567116, 0.038935013115406036, -0.03391680866479874, -0.00702451728284359, -0.04807322844862938, -0.011933826841413975, 0.010312267579138279, -0.00579798361286521, -0.010768907144665718, -0.014972280710935593, -0.01981719769537449, 0.004036208614706993, -0.005009641405194998, 0.041070546954870224, -0.05744564160704613, -0.02257605828344822, -0.00004733738023787737, -0.013876091688871384, -0.01234620064496994, 0.03297019749879837, 0.026696275919675827, 0.008962630294263363, 0.040460553020238876, -0.012704070657491684, 0.04676073417067528, -0.047394562512636185, -0.022260354831814766, -0.020256638526916504, -0.05928852781653404, 0.011247058399021626, -0.04467923194169998, -0.03486635908484459, 0.007596686482429504, -0.048356134444475174, 0.03427835553884506, -0.030291296541690826, 0.028230588883161545, -0.020511992275714874, -0.0325917974114418, -0.05674280971288681, 0.009679686278104782, -0.0032143646385520697, 0.03034694492816925, -0.023229440674185753, 0.04430942237377167, 0.02499094419181347, -0.03258829191327095, -0.0660112202167511, -0.04176145792007446, -0.013274152763187885, 0.03155714273452759, -0.022874170914292336, -0.061573125422000885, -0.013192460872232914, 0.011881189420819283, 0.011424335651099682, -0.0012947041541337967, 0.04389697313308716, -0.02338693104684353, -0.009913048706948757, -0.007639910560101271, -0.04063504934310913, 0.09169238060712814, -0.002075933152809739, -0.005582793615758419, -0.012823591940104961, -0.011823208071291447, 0.012572180479764938, -0.008242355659604073, 0.020266856998205185, -0.03743283823132515, -0.04913097247481346, 0.0013053083093836904, 0.020659422501921654, 0.01815842278301716, -0.01418562512844801, 0.010016387328505516, 0.023635488003492355, 0.002739180577918887, -0.014487175270915031, -0.02548299916088581, 0.0009227156988345087, -0.01685735397040844, -0.03358089551329613, -0.019612586125731468, -0.008313794620335102, -0.00581357441842556, -0.007486423011869192, 0.011434171348810196, 0.022112634032964706, -0.020463496446609497, -0.026178553700447083, 0.06418589502573013, -0.0200789961963892, -0.01714509166777134, 0.01544010080397129, -0.03192450478672981, 0.04424748569726944, 0.02587812766432762, -0.0012254019966349006, -0.006206383928656578, 0.06083608418703079, -0.026095682755112648, -0.014935125596821308, -0.02829859033226967, 0.029758203774690628, 0.04942822828888893, -0.01745893619954586, 0.005474291741847992, 0.05767339468002319, 0.03284516930580139, 0.033224672079086304, -0.0018453674856573343, 0.012225356884300709, -0.0026147293392568827, -0.005380448419600725, 0.02996283583343029, -0.03101690113544464, -0.03849395737051964, 0.012265206314623356, 0.007827368564903736, 0.01899968460202217, 0.025271601974964142, 0.04142889007925987, 0.0027675882447510958, -0.007676585111767054, -0.018186666071414948, -0.014992309734225273, 0.02300081215798855, -0.06294386088848114, 0.028388582170009613, -0.03022727370262146, -0.05721045657992363, 0.049260303378105164, 0.0026738622691482306, -0.0019852397963404655, -0.012135651893913746, 0.006975278258323669, -0.04037822410464287, 0.0074174548499286175, 0.01301412284374237, -0.008664779365062714, 0.041674353182315826, 0.028382334858179092, 0.04010072723031044, 0.01829252764582634, 0.01567782089114189, -0.07204043865203857, -0.0648825615644455, 0.008098350837826729, -0.026295656338334084, -0.10046956688165665, 0.020076945424079895, -0.0000020313812001404585, -0.008762052282691002, 0.036862023174762726, 0.018736740574240685, -0.021077843382954597, -0.023568563163280487, 0.04038528725504875, -0.037917621433734894, 0.0683644637465477, 0.02906135283410549, 0.013922267593443394, 0.009413708001375198, -0.002624492160975933, 0.1194770559668541, 0.02317195013165474, -0.0016645359573885798, -0.04788577929139137, 0.04906437173485756, -0.020806176587939262, -0.021223263815045357, -0.027905147522687912, -0.002030764240771532, 0.03871382400393486, -0.009538017213344574, 0.07076092064380646, 0.046146661043167114, 0.037576429545879364, 0.009700549766421318, 0.06625252962112427, -0.01922702044248581, -0.06293392926454544, 0.017750678583979607, -0.013599962927401066, 0.025480274111032486, -0.016276326030492783, -0.03291986882686615, 0.030251160264015198, 0.018976693972945213, -0.021745558828115463, -0.041845981031656265, -0.010643602348864079, 0.01575329527258873, 0.004291560035198927, 0.007489779964089394, 0.012302855029702187, 0.025116272270679474, -0.0007223034044727683, -0.04955073818564415, -0.010430575348436832, 0.005059998482465744, -0.04928077757358551, 0.04346084222197533, 0.023101065307855606, 0.014053575694561005, -0.011447403579950333, 0.011309248395264149, 0.043534643948078156, -0.033731456845998764, -0.016518060117959976, -0.03148767352104187, 0.04660162329673767, 0.003636713372543454, 0.000812691287137568, -0.03127855807542801, 0.020533807575702667, -0.02705923467874527, -0.0588134303689003, -0.046077463775873184, 0.022287296131253242, 0.0073555088602006435, -0.031179487705230713, -0.05094832926988602, 0.01644553802907467, 0.030509084463119507, -0.0228005051612854, -0.01291592512279749, 0.0067512039095163345, -0.002640443854033947, -0.04191090166568756, -0.04202006384730339, 0.016714559867978096, 0.04232386499643326, -0.012721432372927666, -0.005159873981028795, -0.01967640593647957, -0.012417127378284931, 0.009197589010000229, -0.03268047422170639, -0.00328288646414876, 0.022780150175094604, 0.027455642819404602, 0.03584500029683113, 0.0030167277436703444, -0.00429623993113637, 0.017630208283662796, -0.003753974102437496, -0.001240601995959878, -0.02349283918738365, -0.009062698110938072, 0.005281959194689989, 0.009077566675841808, 0.002326233545318246, -0.0006936423596926033, 0.01236690767109394, 0.021699311211705208, -0.02263590507209301, -0.000788315141107887, -0.037887927144765854, -0.05142855644226074, -0.05295250564813614, 0.003617372829467058, -0.026924729347229004, 0.09073730558156967, 0.02185153216123581, -0.037968382239341736, 0.0006252626189962029, 0.0230907890945673, -0.013506701216101646, 0.023940490558743477, 0.010732385329902172, -0.06519143283367157, -0.03876807168126106, 0.005332416854798794, -0.0009513683617115021, -0.06347460299730301, -0.002573901554569602, -0.0433298759162426, -0.011246906593441963, -0.0038518551737070084, -0.020758863538503647, -0.0226181298494339, -0.0008543537696823478, -0.03310408815741539, -0.02288428507745266, 0.00024572722031734884, 0.005405383184552193, 0.01620445027947426, -0.027976863086223602, -0.010531347244977951, 0.006225008051842451, -0.01730968803167343, 0.001693897182121873, 0.033282630145549774, 0.023568665608763695, 0.038143109530210495, -0.013819471932947636, 0.022457048296928406, -0.03541164845228195, 0.02346903644502163, 0.010792250744998455, 0.07161898165941238, -0.015928952023386955, 0.012509134598076344, 0.0728612169623375, -0.018300849944353104, -0.05771603062748909, 0.0006427386542782187, -0.02146783284842968, 0.051668472588062286, 0.002442375523969531, -0.027660347521305084, 0.009191012941300869, 0.03396829217672348, -0.02643752284348011, -0.04060559347271919, 0.014519578777253628, -0.01713060960173607, 0.036645155400037766, -0.02648399956524372, -0.05624052509665489, -0.020208487287163734, -0.03167950361967087, -0.03811532258987427, 0.018437815830111504, -0.006981153506785631, -0.0027580419555306435, -0.02684810943901539, -0.005339649971574545, 0.007313753943890333, 0.021119967103004456, 0.004673476796597242, -0.004590067081153393, 0.0136551009491086, -0.04240141436457634, -0.01884920336306095, 0.00350156775675714, -0.004435881972312927, -0.06880402565002441, -0.03940161317586899, 0.02481146901845932, -0.02702442742884159, 0.031310368329286575, -0.04940137639641762, 0.020592698827385902, 0.0439501591026783, -0.02571791410446167, 0.036110199987888336, -0.015110660344362259, 0.007851514965295792, -0.04144367203116417, 0.023203479126095772, -0.01910257898271084, 0.042028091847896576, 0.004230038728564978, 0.05564960464835167, 0.028779488056898117, 0.014506150037050247, -0.013629743829369545, -0.019822843372821808, 0.003232179908081889, 0.006290229968726635, -0.015219736844301224, -0.08403076976537704, 0.04704737663269043, -0.0026394149754196405, -0.05771952494978905, 0.03201160579919815, -0.021340159699320793, -0.011230316944420338, 0.01880943588912487, -0.003453895915299654, 0.004104688297957182, 0.05051006004214287, 0.02803097479045391, 0.005841110832989216, -0.02304142341017723, -0.017190836369991302, 0.022991396486759186, 0.015633627772331238, -0.0068243457935750484, -0.006568925455212593, 0.07618646323680878, 0.016048898920416832, -0.013507318682968616, 0.05197443440556526, -0.001626606099307537, -0.007228318601846695, 0.017805976793169975, -0.03134866803884506, 0.011052148416638374, -0.06899154931306839, -0.010142466053366661, -0.030255893245339394, -0.011075250804424286, 0.03532608970999718, -0.0027719142381101847, 0.009038034826517105, -0.01755826734006405, 0.015634810552001, -0.014848285354673862, -0.03930836543440819, 0.006421786732971668, 0.023729877546429634, -0.04431872069835663, 0.05025110021233559, 0.011818500235676765, -0.007483463268727064, 0.0007339576841332018, -0.025874728336930275, 0.005365085322409868, 0.03162431716918945, -0.00741517823189497, 0.006594739854335785, 0.014158741571009159, -0.02551542967557907, 0.004559720866382122, -0.10748036950826645, -0.0023088413290679455, 0.014262694865465164, 0.011660478077828884, -0.03750499710440636, -0.009395957924425602, -0.047150786966085434, 0.015779897570610046, 0.025043953210115433, 0.028266197070479393, -0.013641499914228916, 0.02254822663962841, -0.015639888122677803, 0.03485821187496185, -0.023759853094816208, 0.03672066703438759, -0.015530772507190704, 0.02025376446545124, -0.01538960263133049, -0.004012960474938154, -0.01222520973533392, -0.011123493313789368, 0.02534298226237297, -0.023687247186899185, -0.010435855947434902, -0.011100252158939838, -0.030916176736354828, 0.029815753921866417, -0.01598423905670643, -0.019677313044667244, 0.02541903592646122, -0.03130960837006569, -0.01195419393479824, 0.016524920240044594, -0.0036024905275553465, -0.0462762825191021, -0.0027436676900833845, -0.05867350101470947, -0.04727013036608696, 0.004701718222349882, 0.023374708369374275, 0.006654698867350817, -0.04000039026141167, 0.006114444229751825, 0.02762533910572529, -0.03509901836514473, -0.037978630512952805, 0.008457213640213013, 0.019787175580859184, 0.006899161264300346, -0.012891621328890324, 0.027686823159456253, 0.002681971527636051, -0.020465727895498276, 0.004479605238884687, 0.029617026448249817, 0.03153771907091141, 0.02598823979496956, 0.019816622138023376, 0.005822545848786831, -0.004607201553881168, 0.04909202456474304, 0.028374217450618744, 0.020521705970168114, 0.0035766686778515577, 0.016809998080134392, 0.026187187060713768, -0.03206098452210426, 0.03413374349474907, 0.01336675975471735, 0.018537387251853943, 0.05470222234725952, 0.01025373674929142, 0.033624861389398575, -0.08661433309316635, 0.007900990545749664, -0.00969216600060463, 0.01607862301170826, 0.02277369052171707, 0.0591840036213398, -0.03428099676966667, -0.0006059950101189315, -0.004640859551727772, 0.015093212947249413, 0.050665076822042465, -0.0020098912063986063, 0.0588456429541111, -0.017733054235577583, -0.00482519157230854, -0.0037025283090770245, -0.015174447558820248, -0.014878937043249607, -0.00018380915571469814, 0.075507253408432, 0.052922092378139496, 0.012144056148827076, 0.0029799898620694876, -0.03144393488764763, -0.004818353336304426, 0.05138646438717842, -0.04615328088402748, -0.0493876077234745, -0.044077325612306595, 0.04328523203730583, -0.018675023689866066, -0.028341198340058327 ]
<p>Is there a way of investigating publications bias in a meta-analysis of single case studies? Usually one can assess publication bias using funnel plots or Egger's test to assess funnel plot asymmetry. However those methods require some estimate of the individual studies' variance. In case of single case studies such measure of variance is usually not available. So is there any way to assess publication bias in this case?</p> <p>Here i provide a dummy example in R. In a meta-analysis of single case studies, all studies investigating a change in symptom score following a treatment have been assessed:</p> <pre><code># change_score &lt;- c(-3,-2,-1,-7,-8,-11,-1,-10,-4,-11) </code></pre>
74,422
[ -0.06468851119279861, 0.0015846948372200131, -0.051861442625522614, 0.00816265307366848, 0.06880372017621994, 0.058719929307699203, -0.028217103332281113, -0.014224802143871784, 0.0110571114346385, -0.03593600168824196, 0.038939401507377625, 0.019343093037605286, 0.01844530738890171, -0.028946520760655403, -0.003268847241997719, 0.03806929290294647, -0.018281951546669006, 0.015552345663309097, 0.026740487664937973, 0.01703997515141964, 0.020687907934188843, 0.030675122514367104, -0.01049116998910904, 0.05135525390505791, -0.012180071324110031, 0.016332494094967842, 0.030074467882514, -0.039897553622722626, -0.009001725353300571, 0.03289894387125969, -0.04725182056427002, 0.008355082012712955, 0.032905369997024536, 0.004604935646057129, -0.007179325446486473, -0.02184465155005455, -0.009345928207039833, -0.026427295058965683, -0.0006602160865440965, 0.028334859758615494, -0.0013901462079957128, -0.010732348076999187, -0.026087686419487, 0.04047427326440811, -0.024001209065318108, 0.013890054076910019, -0.007225219625979662, -0.029483240097761154, 0.02267182245850563, -0.041373416781425476, 0.0628155916929245, -0.012827243655920029, 0.05915817990899086, 0.01020680833607912, -0.03746235743165016, 0.030647287145256996, 0.041203275322914124, 0.03508789464831352, 0.024771798402071, -0.028007440268993378, -0.030016673728823662, -0.042762164026498795, 0.03426540270447731, -0.03233513608574867, -0.06412720680236816, 0.042875245213508606, 0.010648978874087334, -0.030857933685183525, 0.04649133235216141, -0.030206920579075813, 0.0035679000429809093, -0.022662613540887833, -0.008104445412755013, -0.008743769489228725, 0.012858101166784763, -0.04553324729204178, -0.01227485854178667, 0.036357372999191284, 0.04100935533642769, 0.024843646213412285, 0.0078097498044371605, -0.0039922986179590225, 0.04586668312549591, 0.04199562221765518, 0.0005253384006209671, -0.010355471633374691, 0.07163900882005692, 0.0007127624121494591, 0.05056145414710045, 0.018561260774731636, -0.00266841403208673, -0.004194274544715881, 0.02816818654537201, 0.030373355373740196, -0.06052311137318611, 0.025164591148495674, 0.007229624781757593, 0.04770723730325699, -0.025083482265472412, -0.029914267361164093, -0.011178359389305115, -0.04742947220802307, 0.037044283002614975, 0.04926282912492752, -0.011614364571869373, -0.006917158141732216, -0.02598886750638485, -0.011286520399153233, -0.023713188245892525, -0.0005730402772314847, -0.002326245652511716, -0.009259073995053768, -0.010781894437968731, -0.0306045264005661, 0.019038572907447815, -0.01280574407428503, -0.022059768438339233, 0.003994182217866182, 0.052797216922044754, 0.039904166013002396, 0.08490092307329178, -0.04989928752183914, 0.012740862555801868, -0.006293545477092266, -0.034549303352832794, -0.0029195682145655155, 0.018538642674684525, -0.019763033837080002, -0.044126298278570175, 0.012205859646201134, 0.02877662517130375, -0.03278418257832527, 0.05934666097164154, 0.02548854984343052, 0.03950369730591774, 0.006192950997501612, -0.056688547134399414, -0.0813601016998291, 0.027628272771835327, -0.015101551078259945, 0.001202767132781446, -0.04994269460439682, -0.01739051565527916, 0.013122770003974438, 0.052646342664957047, 0.011662068776786327, 0.03062197007238865, 0.016692718490958214, 0.03778519108891487, 0.020721692591905594, 0.021672135218977928, 0.013857272453606129, 0.005770720075815916, -0.02427879348397255, -0.0443253293633461, -0.0931706354022026, 0.01110875140875578, 0.015960166230797768, -0.017171751707792282, -0.010803664103150368, 0.039557620882987976, 0.0010151219321414828, 0.014711826108396053, -0.011672046966850758, 0.0008938572136685252, 0.019847387447953224, 0.07434935867786407, 0.011940446682274342, -0.0200093574821949, 0.004050618037581444, -0.01674039103090763, 0.02311747334897518, 0.01907835714519024, 0.045683398842811584, 0.028514988720417023, -0.04561772570014, 0.005753614474087954, -0.02536170929670334, -0.0002520520647522062, 0.008672777563333511, -0.058417003601789474, -0.02976016141474247, -0.04149441421031952, -0.018403146415948868, 0.024324946105480194, 0.04218927398324013, -0.043387848883867264, -0.008114326745271683, 0.04621409997344017, -0.052114613354206085, -0.02501639537513256, -0.09346731007099152, 0.004599719773977995, 0.0019672270864248276, -0.050014421343803406, 0.03231913968920708, 0.023693464696407318, 0.06654208898544312, -0.03448345884680748, -0.0036545749753713608, -0.0022816017735749483, -0.02130996808409691, 0.02820555865764618, -0.02221967838704586, 0.007623271085321903, 0.034925151616334915, 0.05214642360806465, -0.05356038361787796, 0.02680972032248974, -0.03442032262682915, -0.050058357417583466, 0.039002709090709686, -0.017270784825086594, 0.0017432624008506536, 0.017253758385777473, -0.02819528989493847, 0.00015629890549462289, -0.007880382239818573, -0.01574447937309742, 0.030356131494045258, -0.06528257578611374, 0.07627856731414795, 0.06174187734723091, 0.007217444013804197, 0.012541025876998901, -0.0072699422016739845, 0.03286825492978096, 0.008558948524296284, -0.023938989266753197, -0.01382680144160986, -0.04378350451588631, -0.02930421754717827, 0.03993019834160805, 0.00925199594348669, -0.03860349580645561, -0.0021658798214048147, 0.026770103722810745, 0.011658407747745514, 0.02187260612845421, 0.03460594639182091, 0.010505877435207367, -0.07213333994150162, 0.02536667324602604, 0.05011073127388954, -0.0017448418075218797, 0.01869061402976513, 0.0327785462141037, 0.005421256646513939, 0.060488373041152954, 0.02837146259844303, -0.03623637557029724, 0.050856441259384155, -0.023569360375404358, 0.0073432400822639465, -0.015312809497117996, -0.037989940494298935, 0.02417510561645031, -0.042450912296772, 0.0008750082342885435, 0.03986348956823349, 0.014662015251815319, 0.06363565474748611, 0.003953274339437485, -0.005766566842794418, 0.03583826869726181, 0.03788857161998749, -0.03691565990447998, 0.0033729937858879566, 0.0027149904053658247, -0.0116084273904562, 0.01300362590700388, -0.026489388197660446, -0.026343729346990585, -0.002887600800022483, 0.017498772591352463, 0.011101196520030499, -0.006306875962764025, 0.013964679092168808, 0.01441157329827547, 0.020350627601146698, 0.0046545593068003654, -0.0007684660376980901, -0.01007976196706295, -0.0007486706599593163, -0.05744446441531181, 0.016849283128976822, -0.05089724808931351, -0.006218346301466227, 0.04940402880311012, -0.02009802684187889, -0.03885405883193016, 0.036436717957258224, 0.010469751432538033, -0.036871206015348434, -0.032076988369226456, -0.02481505647301674, 0.009315593168139458, -0.0170939639210701, -0.01804431714117527, 0.028991004452109337, 0.01015604380518198, -0.03476623445749283, 0.0247777309268713, 0.00022261439880821854, -0.02023867703974247, 0.04036211222410202, -0.0055317990481853485, 0.02475525252521038, -0.007839921861886978, 0.004512081854045391, -0.0113452710211277, -0.021468618884682655, -0.026179324835538864, -0.06709910929203033, -0.023083731532096863, 0.04022040590643883, -0.023778192698955536, 0.030501028522849083, -0.0004463715013116598, -0.02757941372692585, 0.07163800299167633, 0.025554081425070763, -0.007963026873767376, -0.03612962365150452, 0.04045891389250755, -0.03016420267522335, -0.010905045084655285, -0.021927349269390106, 0.020723864436149597, 0.01282621268182993, 0.033967990428209305, 0.013977029360830784, 0.0061110639944672585, 0.02599720098078251, 0.0100631695240736, -0.037833862006664276, 0.0023201373405754566, 0.025024302303791046, -0.008135640062391758, 0.0016136267222464085, 0.02997671626508236, -0.00518635381013155, 0.007241691928356886, -0.00021319543884601444, 0.030649574473500252, -0.03665202856063843, -0.037912312895059586, 0.025487462058663368, 0.013416038826107979, 0.0007077706977725029, -0.03090236522257328, 0.047048892825841904, 0.008463853038847446, 0.008163620717823505, -0.02998732030391693, 0.038827210664749146, 0.014265477657318115, -0.003348866244778037, 0.013640616089105606, 0.03976239264011383, -0.007020425982773304, 0.0017177158733829856, -0.019030503928661346, -0.010060735046863556, -0.018574105575680733, 0.02276853285729885, -0.03139270842075348, -0.029517102986574173, 0.04022980481386185, 0.07901006191968918, 0.019931163638830185, -0.01572316884994507, -0.03655031695961952, 0.0357760414481163, -0.04447682201862335, -0.007572991773486137, -0.002450774423778057, 0.02725365199148655, -0.00592393521219492, 0.016516877338290215, 0.01199325080960989, -0.017109667882323265, 0.005607294850051403, -0.017298124730587006, -0.06896045058965683, 0.02849133312702179, -0.05237139016389847, 0.0017884436529129744, -0.004793024621903896, 0.01155792735517025, 0.019224539399147034, 0.0022444254718720913, 0.013535972684621811, 0.014026952907443047, 0.036022745072841644, 0.00474654883146286, -0.0043010530062019825, 0.01235678419470787, 0.013480397872626781, -0.01489549782127142, 0.03442564979195595, 0.020617641508579254, -0.023976165801286697, 0.02158701792359352, 0.00032054309849627316, 0.008132259361445904, -0.022796275094151497, -0.035701509565114975, 0.024590469896793365, 0.010589885525405407, 0.01921740360558033, 0.04492272809147835, 0.017006002366542816, -0.044751428067684174, 0.08293378353118896, -0.010982641950249672, 0.016143018379807472, 0.029223572462797165, -0.02929491363465786, -0.017014378681778908, -0.037301670759916306, 0.01300544012337923, 0.019404446706175804, -0.002111745998263359, 0.03169913589954376, 0.0049844300374388695, 0.06454679369926453, 0.02015214040875435, -0.057626716792583466, -0.026838339865207672, 0.03196302056312561, 0.025454413145780563, 0.010828527621924877, -0.03746577352285385, 0.00880338717252016, -0.0028437229339033365, -0.013657248578965664, 0.031043341383337975, 0.018810100853443146, 0.005451600067317486, 0.011834224686026573, 0.03904249519109726, 0.00023254092957358807, -0.07173782587051392, -0.024410003796219826, 0.026603803038597107, 0.06140286475419998, 0.02211310714483261, -0.030388137325644493, 0.04395642876625061, 0.07508242875337601, 0.045089248567819595, -0.010495733469724655, -0.018291905522346497, -0.06446618586778641, 0.04903589189052582, 0.04969295114278793, 0.07940754294395447, -0.028281526640057564, 0.003759084502235055, -0.015766842290759087, 0.031046193093061447, 0.05433572083711624, -0.013282506726682186, 0.02339053526520729, -0.022576572373509407, 0.021094253286719322, 0.0029588148463517427, -0.019755013287067413, -0.033803440630435944, 0.05106916278600693, -0.02171190083026886, 0.026030922308564186, -0.0416378453373909, -0.020816165953874588, -0.0010167259024456143, -0.004706560634076595, -0.004442567937076092, 0.05061671510338783, -0.02011333964765072, 0.010772847570478916, 0.0014271603431552649, 0.021874789148569107, -0.020539820194244385, -0.07835020869970322, 0.005949866026639938, 0.005801479332149029, 0.008548535406589508, 0.055262453854084015, -0.01756272464990616, 0.01719498448073864, 0.015041346661746502, 0.010601027868688107, -0.04882054403424263, -0.029110688716173172, -0.0056405505165457726, 0.005934614222496748, 0.04829612746834755, 0.004965189844369888, 0.08841798454523087, 0.028329413384199142, 0.0023394902236759663, -0.02369501069188118, 0.0027601616457104683, 0.021982546895742416, -0.020537016913294792, -0.02367573417723179, -0.051411762833595276, 0.012443608604371548, -0.007428153418004513, 0.02655651606619358, -0.0024099440779536963, 0.04233753681182861, 0.014802654273808002, 0.018228787928819656, 0.014332660473883152, 0.022070465609431267, 0.014823525212705135, -0.0027782851830124855, -0.007612750865519047, 0.011492620222270489, 0.00798533484339714, -0.02913137897849083, 0.00583221297711134, -0.03171904385089874, -0.0027687810361385345, 0.024103207513689995, -0.07947468757629395, 0.008808759041130543, -0.019871259108185768, -0.04134582355618477, 0.005793224088847637, -0.06349896639585495, 0.009585367515683174, -0.04227042198181152, -0.023829948157072067, 0.0029923757538199425, -0.057225242257118225, -0.007837150245904922, 0.046772319823503494, -0.00938436295837164, 0.015206590294837952, -0.053300704807043076, 0.001144997077062726, 0.02876080386340618, -0.0025533726438879967, -0.09403960406780243, -0.025458665564656258, 0.044681139290332794, 0.008188987150788307, -0.05759306252002716, -0.025416560471057892, -0.01920916885137558, -0.012766233645379543, -0.012516600079834461, -0.012717529200017452, 0.047492749989032745, -0.030284762382507324, -0.009177522733807564, -0.02727663144469261, -0.00029585175798274577, 0.07875369489192963, -0.01681600697338581, -0.024823488667607307, 0.009875382296741009, -0.04891786351799965, -0.005435894709080458, -0.006572580896317959, -0.011929187923669815, -0.030139537528157234, 0.0055664158426225185, -0.05259421467781067, 0.004317919258028269, 0.03092990815639496, 0.007173080462962389, -0.012081908993422985, 0.01398477889597416, -0.011372139677405357, 0.010418456979095936, -0.03977762535214424, -0.01006352063268423, -0.04865116998553276, 0.02890660986304283, -0.025318840518593788, 0.027715357020497322, 0.015285156667232513, -0.002289515919983387, 0.024509457871317863, -0.002248586155474186, -0.06983662396669388, 0.014724473468959332, 0.06764557957649231, -0.00952460803091526, 0.019403677433729172, -0.02814740501344204, -0.026975171640515327, 0.00047580627142451704, 0.017178818583488464, -0.0010754803661257029, -0.007574945222586393, -0.00028805408510379493, -0.025287985801696777, -0.012823943980038166, -0.027363291010260582, 0.05055854469537735, 0.054330211132764816, 0.026198090985417366, 0.024816857650876045, 0.08323956280946732, 0.002500921720638871, -0.030577925965189934, -0.00034422086901031435, -0.0009024054161272943, -0.001557565527036786, 0.01365196518599987, 0.06607665866613388, -0.017923200502991676, 0.018781449645757675, 0.052923813462257385, 0.013014771975576878, 0.016166895627975464, 0.047075625509023666, 0.006295772735029459, 0.006285146810114384, 0.015073311515152454, -0.024826936423778534, 0.0022871207911521196, 0.0320286825299263, -0.05080603063106537, 0.016014281660318375, -0.04188301041722298, -0.041095733642578125, 0.051938746124506, 0.018861129879951477, 0.007571750786155462, -0.03872589394450188, -0.020304512232542038, -0.04949839785695076, 0.0008426858694292605, 0.015788638964295387, -0.009646150283515453, 0.035969506949186325, 0.041510798037052155, 0.04500623419880867, 0.005404666531831026, 0.025111140683293343, -0.03413602337241173, -0.07587405294179916, -0.015274880453944206, 0.012217085808515549, -0.005285879131406546, 0.007061634678393602, 0.022975239902734756, -0.035431843250989914, 0.03052235022187233, -0.016365157440304756, 0.017029866576194763, 0.03690280020236969, 0.02214421145617962, -0.019410038366913795, 0.057049710303545, -0.0027885721065104008, 0.03047674149274826, 0.046119000762701035, -0.03662683442234993, 0.1111544519662857, 0.08864638954401016, 0.024175697937607765, -0.08506935089826584, 0.03646953031420708, 0.03425729647278786, 0.015552801080048084, -0.023077907040715218, 0.01914241537451744, 0.007299596443772316, -0.02770865149796009, 0.0408596508204937, 0.058737464249134064, 0.04784241318702698, -0.07060494273900986, 0.05569038912653923, -0.045142658054828644, -0.0369146391749382, -0.004096148069947958, -0.0104213273152709, -0.007766248192638159, -0.04851958155632019, -0.049483928829431534, 0.027730699628591537, 0.03269476443529129, -0.010016700252890587, -0.02679644152522087, -0.007918115705251694, -0.027713585644960403, 0.022588299587368965, -0.02260170504450798, -0.009312557056546211, 0.01871967874467373, -0.00850152038037777, -0.02955411560833454, -0.03177192062139511, 0.02754165418446064, -0.03049236536026001, 0.030430881306529045, 0.047766316682100296, 0.005336706060916185, 0.006954148877412081, -0.0000714440320734866, 0.0421326719224453, -0.03886112570762634, -0.01176680251955986, -0.017394190654158592, 0.018961817026138306, -0.0058686090633273125, 0.03155605494976044, -0.004793725907802582, -0.021359730511903763, -0.02087615802884102, -0.04272942990064621, -0.008423183113336563, 0.015826303511857986, -0.0006692357128486037, -0.013564229011535645, -0.02550637535750866, -0.023026546463370323, 0.024334324523806572, -0.0054396288469433784, 0.03287724405527115, 0.07088612020015717, -0.04934285953640938, -0.028643706813454628, -0.015165291726589203, 0.01117627415806055, 0.01197661180049181, -0.004432201385498047, 0.0121420007199049, 0.009793095290660858, -0.032323338091373444, -0.009770161472260952, 0.0006138735334388912, -0.02112695761024952, 0.04506149888038635, 0.0002907312591560185, 0.008726741187274456, -0.005338533315807581, -0.03737645596265793, -0.01589025929570198, -0.025059640407562256, -0.0028918187599629164, -0.05054210498929024, 0.012837276794016361, 0.055164095014333725, -0.008863009512424469, -0.01622183993458748, -0.003304151352494955, -0.02328754961490631, 0.037043265998363495, 0.012590570375323296, -0.031938228756189346, -0.020924348384141922, -0.015661126002669334, -0.031593937426805496, -0.029973125085234642, -0.04754703864455223, 0.05246967822313309, 0.005478591192513704, -0.0172274187207222, 0.006130545400083065, 0.011125658638775349, -0.009743102826178074, -0.007772504352033138, 0.037395179271698, -0.02912904880940914, -0.005664724390953779, 0.005591907538473606, -0.009692725725471973, -0.04414375498890877, 0.00034656902425922453, -0.04124688729643822, -0.009268954396247864, 0.0543808676302433, -0.013960925862193108, -0.03520005941390991, 0.008634558878839016, -0.016353439539670944, 0.0011718356981873512, -0.018093449994921684, -0.025434376671910286, -0.059961967170238495, -0.02454393357038498, 0.0019782520830631256, -0.008019457571208477, 0.02625529281795025, 0.014070000499486923, 0.003351376159116626, 0.004274103790521622, 0.03396764025092125, 0.008940476924180984, -0.017495404928922653, 0.04811575636267662, 0.03572120890021324, 0.013451376929879189, 0.04419538378715515, 0.0002630181552376598, -0.03673649579286575, 0.03705950453877449, -0.05335003882646561, -0.011925434693694115, 0.02092711254954338, -0.014673728495836258, -0.008006802760064602, 0.011839459650218487, -0.005003690719604492, -0.015265540219843388, 0.046036481857299805, -0.025503605604171753, -0.019001401960849762, -0.020437877625226974, -0.01823338307440281, -0.025762012228369713, -0.021603824570775032, 0.010506662540137768, 0.0008199149160645902, -0.02704906091094017, 0.02964702807366848, 0.05675610527396202, 0.0322006456553936, 0.0014016353525221348, 0.015147588215768337, -0.004006538540124893, 0.00815883930772543, 0.013482230715453625, -0.012127687223255634, 0.037536464631557465, 0.040941424667835236, -0.03860477730631828, 0.024279922246932983, -0.0035036616027355194, 0.01595652848482132, -0.1125895157456398, -0.02279057539999485, 0.01960737630724907, 0.032365284860134125, 0.004065477289259434, -0.06934445351362228, 0.039234649389982224, -0.0025385746266692877, -0.01284213736653328, -0.0026117046363651752, -0.011144055984914303, -0.03766587749123573, -0.023386789485812187, 0.010657066479325294, -0.020258821547031403, 0.020345602184534073, 0.04155790060758591, 0.023441771045327187, 0.001662322087213397, 0.031891196966171265, 0.00879895780235529, -0.024841226637363434, -0.03383804112672806, 0.031880490481853485, -0.0017910492606461048, -0.05399496853351593, 0.01683664694428444, -0.022897785529494286, -0.08146678656339645, 0.014600344002246857, 0.007127814460545778, -0.008738698437809944, 0.025503242388367653, 0.06786075979471207, -0.0029706237837672234, 0.054623980075120926, 0.03064013086259365, 0.011311361566185951, -0.029375016689300537, -0.00827808864414692, 0.0055853379890322685, 0.02756117284297943, -0.03995482996106148, 0.04715574160218239, 0.010295514017343521, -0.023541051894426346, -0.005543673411011696, -0.010782727971673012, -0.043447963893413544, -0.0232571791857481, -0.03414194658398628, -0.03829536959528923, 0.015885405242443085, -0.012532919645309448, 0.014815926551818848, -0.0364573635160923, 0.02164439484477043, 0.05404721572995186, 0.02950345352292061, 0.004641221836209297, 0.0062462096102535725, -0.007422878872603178, -0.03113359771668911, 0.02939276210963726, -0.02052733302116394, 0.004769270308315754, -0.09374294430017471, 0.0018765163840726018, -0.0024112991522997618, -0.027896689251065254, -0.031109381467103958, -0.01552958507090807, -0.025477534160017967, 0.015645723789930344, -0.03749305382370949, -0.022001929581165314, 0.003272093366831541, 0.0052703386172652245, 0.05060796067118645, -0.08547098934650421, 0.04184750095009804, -0.015009681694209576, -0.018161900341510773, -0.02095676213502884, -0.004489663522690535, -0.04893151670694351, 0.008458763360977173, 0.03934912011027336, -0.018792659044265747, -0.002939858241006732, 0.007820461876690388, 0.03296926990151405, -0.004954318515956402, -0.06386783719062805, 0.049738846719264984, -0.017101433128118515, -0.014232034794986248, -0.0029252541717141867, -0.02069205418229103, 0.006081567611545324, 0.02358298934996128, 0.02616359293460846, -0.015195869840681553, 0.005632503889501095, 0.013802296482026577, -0.020152805373072624, 0.06324031949043274, 0.03638962283730507, -0.012358658015727997, 0.06152200326323509, 0.007811684161424637, 0.026928719133138657, 0.03619007766246796, 0.024932581931352615, -0.03461413457989693, 0.03126831352710724, -0.008876603096723557, -0.01003679446876049, 0.016546523198485374, -0.02613481879234314, -0.016619352623820305, -0.055399004369974136, 0.0026304787024855614, -0.0016886577941477299, -0.04284406080842018, 0.01794547773897648, 0.011867638677358627, -0.005269297864288092, -0.005557443015277386, -0.011512153781950474, -0.0002562334411777556, 0.021139468997716904, -0.0007342316675931215, -0.024917516857385635, 0.0015681043732911348, 0.0027245045639574528, 0.01605975441634655, 0.011846065521240234, 0.024695971980690956, -0.04537574574351311, 0.050280530005693436, -0.003290102817118168, 0.03641657158732414, -0.02506384812295437, -0.0029424296226352453, 0.0005693225539289415, -0.023139463737607002, 0.01317144650965929, 0.0026465062983334064, 0.0001387099619023502, 0.02344265580177307, -0.019674915820360184, 0.058396317064762115, -0.03753870353102684, -0.009228797629475594, -0.030942631885409355, -0.007375402841717005, 0.0003395424864720553, 0.040103644132614136, 0.029521096497774124, -0.007320379372686148, 0.026711836457252502, -0.021088916808366776, 0.00841500610113144, -0.020239971578121185, 0.044176116585731506, -0.03450317680835724, 0.00724390335381031, -0.02458016574382782, 0.0037266244180500507, -0.026888974010944366, -0.041345108300447464, 0.006556747015565634, 0.011429891921579838, 0.05233420059084892, -0.03650681674480438, -0.02153945155441761, -0.01678234152495861, 0.06519205868244171, -0.06493500620126724, -0.04638165980577469, -0.014305579476058483, 0.0009732578764669597, 0.007829735986888409, -0.017838068306446075 ]
<p>I have started with a time series of 5000 random numbers drawn from uniform distribution with mean 0 and variance of 1.</p> <p>I then construct a Variance-Covariance matrix and use this to induce correlation into the random series.</p> <p>I want the correlated series to have an acf of the form exp(-mk), where m is, say 0.1.</p> <p>My problem is this: I ought to be able to calculate the resulting variance of the correlated time series, as I know the variance of the random series, and I have the Variance-Covariance matrix. However, my answers are a factor of 2 larger than they should be.</p> <p>For example: in the case described above - Uniform distribution, mean 0, variance 1, with autocorrelation of exp(-0.1*k), the variance of the correlated series should be 20, but it is only 10.....</p> <p>I am sure I must be missing something really simple or doing something very silly, but I just can't see it. Help please! </p>
74,423
[ -0.021707862615585327, -0.006083564832806587, -0.001393499318510294, -0.009702732786536217, 0.06589092314243317, -0.02707804925739765, -0.043435074388980865, -0.011008559726178646, 0.006355639081448317, -0.048108719289302826, 0.04261268302798271, 0.05012337490916252, 0.04799456149339676, 0.08566205948591232, 0.018447309732437134, 0.005761048756539822, -0.030502542853355408, 0.010174705646932125, 0.021771129220724106, -0.03184918686747551, -0.0036459914408624172, 0.02437976934015751, 0.007520928513258696, -0.006305804010480642, -0.036092646420001984, 0.04456743225455284, 0.05209590122103691, -0.016460096463561058, 0.013219794258475304, 0.05929870530962944, -0.08054585009813309, -0.0063751470297575, 0.04625040292739868, 0.014146503992378712, 0.0451018325984478, 0.017698289826512337, -0.044505245983600616, -0.035976946353912354, -0.003533925162628293, 0.04675754904747009, -0.012013208121061325, -0.031879834830760956, 0.006630658637732267, 0.012948567979037762, 0.005412534810602665, 0.01703655533492565, 0.008738990873098373, -0.0051870630122721195, 0.03849756345152855, -0.04444236308336258, 0.09829089045524597, -0.0008436011266894639, 0.04284009709954262, 0.004701942205429077, -0.023034095764160156, -0.015955792739987373, 0.038092587143182755, 0.025720374658703804, 0.010689669288694859, -0.026639629155397415, 0.022905513644218445, -0.03443588688969612, -0.019444981589913368, -0.025526557117700577, -0.0011115423403680325, -0.011910207569599152, -0.027304602786898613, -0.005371851846575737, 0.02390550822019577, -0.01888333447277546, 0.04787633195519447, 0.019535688683390617, 0.017975015565752983, -0.014803342521190643, -0.011860314756631851, -0.03522013872861862, 0.00920520257204771, -0.008565152995288372, 0.04521387442946434, 0.04066934436559677, 0.018070073798298836, 0.0589715875685215, 0.027750959619879723, 0.02421078272163868, 0.014293357729911804, 0.021757030859589577, 0.049587372690439224, -0.01235576905310154, 0.030689185485243797, 0.06740590184926987, -0.030588246881961823, 0.0029637941624969244, 0.07260758429765701, 0.025405870750546455, -0.0660426989197731, 0.01791665516793728, -0.025600433349609375, 0.07376658171415329, 0.009034192189574242, 0.008397847414016724, -0.033145248889923096, -0.027774391695857048, 0.034949880093336105, 0.035338860005140305, -0.017745090648531914, -0.0021780128590762615, 0.019074171781539917, -0.01107989251613617, -0.0007225355948321521, -0.05737846717238426, -0.021296851336956024, -0.013245810754597187, -0.0211083572357893, -0.02182738110423088, 0.03548625856637955, -0.012901143170893192, -0.0027093698736280203, -0.01714983396232128, 0.026237325742840767, 0.08598040789365768, 0.03489154204726219, 0.0033517188858240843, 0.016917767003178596, -0.03125705197453499, -0.04333788529038429, 0.022471899166703224, 0.02129749208688736, 0.010220942087471485, -0.05815698951482773, 0.0745030865073204, -0.0012415738310664892, -0.06284463405609131, 0.010793112218379974, 0.0009776288643479347, 0.0348353385925293, -0.0151664512231946, -0.11690124869346619, -0.05894412845373154, 0.02718193456530571, -0.031140390783548355, 0.02667071670293808, -0.07784445583820343, 0.051132045686244965, 0.029807068407535553, 0.04880658909678459, 0.021151406690478325, 0.03713537007570267, -0.011976580135524273, 0.03382909297943115, 0.020283812656998634, -0.005724788177758455, -0.020319316536188126, -0.04129025340080261, -0.006691809743642807, -0.014232991263270378, -0.0603848434984684, 0.021144291386008263, 0.0064805494621396065, 0.007026436738669872, 0.007800283841788769, 0.01764695718884468, 0.01000383123755455, -0.017519721761345863, -0.012288294732570648, -0.010530398227274418, -0.031093107536435127, 0.07824351638555527, 0.04269944503903389, -0.01612984947860241, -0.023446867242455482, -0.011033845134079456, -0.015331643633544445, -0.007655703462660313, 0.037515789270401, 0.04673252999782562, -0.016322508454322815, -0.00518108531832695, 0.024882331490516663, 0.014098973013460636, 0.0013702543219551444, -0.02569562941789627, -0.023517509922385216, -0.005154514219611883, -0.03155222907662392, 0.0562293566763401, 0.0005379428621381521, -0.008042878471314907, 0.014074863865971565, 0.010690045543015003, -0.0497993528842926, -0.05186481028795242, -0.03180483356118202, -0.0029046095442026854, -0.011784045025706291, -0.016107216477394104, 0.011704925447702408, -0.026631617918610573, 0.07300957292318344, 0.00714088836684823, -0.05592653527855873, -0.018333636224269867, -0.020113110542297363, 0.028756745159626007, -0.029807431623339653, 0.03319542109966278, -0.0008893820340745151, 0.05246204882860184, -0.035111963748931885, 0.05442114546895027, -0.00995445903390646, -0.03650481253862381, -0.018046582117676735, -0.031110994517803192, 0.010652678087353706, 0.043021902441978455, 0.00015982949116732925, 0.015550284646451473, -0.0111141512170434, 0.004297230858355761, -0.0014307930832728744, -0.0049659935757517815, 0.05608222261071205, 0.08526617288589478, 0.017163794487714767, 0.029006142169237137, 0.021274538710713387, 0.025840820744633675, -0.024147704243659973, -0.04160318896174431, -0.022314904257655144, -0.04677460342645645, 0.004122057929635048, 0.036686744540929794, 0.06462191790342331, -0.020932460203766823, -0.0054565309546887875, 0.07273092865943909, 0.023634903132915497, 0.03447069227695465, 0.04530642554163933, 0.012473713606595993, 0.0010652280179783702, -0.004221729002892971, 0.014106170274317265, -0.0009014870156534016, -0.015493618324398994, -0.005316735710948706, -0.006424940191209316, 0.02378741279244423, 0.0000074777831287065055, -0.05325008183717728, 0.008405019529163837, -0.0035063461400568485, 0.034518513828516006, -0.03428468480706215, -0.02471398003399372, 0.00856932532042265, 0.002414463786408305, -0.011840470135211945, 0.03840583562850952, 0.013787047937512398, 0.01636115461587906, 0.021274201571941376, -0.03883702680468559, 0.007436628919094801, 0.0072312625125050545, -0.011951219290494919, -0.009159991517663002, -0.00018040604481939226, -0.005139684304594994, 0.027078788727521896, 0.012791977263987064, -0.005042775068432093, -0.03805586323142052, -0.007015803828835487, 0.021090351045131683, 0.025000009685754776, 0.031193077564239502, -0.021815160289406776, -0.018588265404105186, -0.015903107821941376, 0.013704922050237656, 0.0038472888991236687, 0.011526431888341904, -0.05516621470451355, 0.01632368192076683, 0.006504051387310028, 0.0036434491630643606, 0.01902078278362751, -0.012354554608464241, 0.02263868972659111, 0.030260704457759857, -0.005431162193417549, -0.05879060551524162, -0.013036341406404972, -0.020950475707650185, -0.021886378526687622, -0.028660260140895844, -0.0265117809176445, 0.054845187813043594, 0.022272154688835144, -0.07907118648290634, 0.011185487732291222, -0.04763602837920189, -0.006139899604022503, -0.07785461097955704, -0.02597089111804962, 0.01418796181678772, -0.05758936330676079, 0.03172144293785095, -0.013290767557919025, -0.007513717748224735, -0.011629557237029076, -0.023297207430005074, -0.05250212922692299, 0.005189860705286264, 0.023243840783834457, 0.013994958251714706, -0.002744375728070736, -0.03724230080842972, 0.049440279603004456, 0.01896011084318161, -0.013635052368044853, -0.052166569977998734, -0.012963413260877132, 0.006348805967718363, -0.07861796021461487, 0.015179840847849846, 0.03576437756419182, -0.025951197370886803, 0.054392315447330475, 0.0003609262639656663, 0.016649279743433, 0.06259369105100632, -0.023581888526678085, -0.00826540868729353, 0.011387469246983528, -0.026849396526813507, 0.02516132779419422, 0.05530316010117531, 0.007125142961740494, -0.036149002611637115, 0.010480734519660473, -0.009215794503688812, 0.004549901932477951, 0.013218012638390064, -0.016402356326580048, -0.0025483618956059217, -0.03331845998764038, 0.020129427313804626, -0.06790535151958466, 0.03217972815036774, 0.009834108874201775, -0.0056825196370482445, -0.046378377825021744, 0.02661048248410225, 0.019085528329014778, -0.025221088901162148, 0.00994417816400528, 0.0733800157904625, 0.036855172365903854, 0.0006434159586206079, -0.03114982135593891, -0.019106101244688034, -0.020852096378803253, 0.01893468014895916, -0.04661685973405838, -0.019836902618408203, 0.06980348378419876, 0.009925128892064095, 0.031462252140045166, -0.009920240379869938, -0.07597638666629791, 0.0038760416209697723, -0.02930324524641037, 0.005363964010030031, -0.015478934161365032, 0.08089503645896912, 0.007607185281813145, 0.04859841614961624, 0.03597443178296089, -0.028581121936440468, 0.01662590354681015, -0.004783077165484428, -0.06294248253107071, 0.04091230779886246, -0.0023560512345284224, -0.019919825717806816, 0.009608658030629158, -0.03671475499868393, 0.030548078939318657, 0.01393269281834364, 0.014611650258302689, 0.024291513487696648, -0.0006352607742883265, -0.02746778167784214, 0.0050016832537949085, -0.02641267515718937, -0.007528993766754866, -0.022178949788212776, 0.00841178186237812, 0.04457651078701019, -0.04198669642210007, 0.07047049701213837, 0.032190948724746704, -0.009299106895923615, 0.006209913641214371, -0.013096753507852554, 0.04554719105362892, 0.0386526919901371, 0.04172747954726219, 0.02103985659778118, -0.01649959199130535, -0.05150261148810387, 0.021307017654180527, 0.0029166799504309893, 0.03117322362959385, 0.031135283410549164, 0.019141172990202904, 0.0036452847998589277, -0.023497091606259346, -0.013778256252408028, 0.04644360765814781, -0.011099550873041153, 0.016582319512963295, 0.007067774888128042, 0.06236151233315468, 0.010385825298726559, -0.05552829056978226, 0.02164445072412491, 0.05862513929605484, -0.0044405278749763966, 0.029703721404075623, -0.01013883389532566, -0.01909569278359413, -0.0020378371700644493, -0.011173319071531296, 0.026696475222706795, -0.011817462742328644, -0.005341973155736923, 0.005770995747298002, 0.033247657120227814, -0.05295561999082565, 0.0032113189809024334, -0.007956918329000473, 0.02944885566830635, 0.0568929947912693, 0.01758662797510624, -0.033979207277297974, 0.007800041697919369, 0.004321237560361624, 0.025138499215245247, 0.028906511142849922, -0.002037507016211748, -0.06671612709760666, 0.005588104482740164, 0.03946812450885773, 0.05701079219579697, -0.021486932411789894, 0.0020076811779290438, -0.05468493700027466, -0.04948567971587181, 0.050129834562540054, -0.03264999017119408, 0.028714990243315697, -0.025378985330462456, 0.025501610711216927, 0.01270655170083046, -0.04313087835907936, -0.06657105684280396, 0.019669990986585617, -0.000017123260477092117, 0.05868474394083023, -0.026408445090055466, -0.02600737288594246, -0.028429148718714714, 0.004428801126778126, 0.031064141541719437, 0.09174829721450806, -0.017869949340820312, -0.016008224338293076, 0.0016793619142845273, 0.05001969635486603, 0.020618494600057602, -0.06539329141378403, 0.014151772484183311, -0.022781500592827797, 0.006799774710088968, 0.0478951595723629, -0.0071142613887786865, -0.02371588908135891, -0.005775306839495897, -0.0074267033487558365, 0.0003935024724341929, -0.00344010628759861, -0.009133714251220226, 0.06771476566791534, 0.020271221175789833, -0.013362855650484562, 0.08149036020040512, 0.0226117093116045, -0.007503919769078493, 0.036804378032684326, -0.012734485790133476, 0.019275767728686333, -0.016105689108371735, 0.005735564045608044, -0.06407218426465988, 0.009396359324455261, -0.0397089421749115, 0.02589707262814045, -0.008741362951695919, 0.03280627354979515, -0.033135753124952316, 0.017354091629385948, 0.016286950558423996, 0.03323562070727348, -0.020634716376662254, -0.0198427252471447, -0.0009505496709607542, 0.0006127051892690361, -0.026239346712827682, -0.01663779281079769, 0.024007797241210938, -0.0005364695098251104, -0.005277238320559263, -0.006384534295648336, -0.021134018898010254, -0.02666989341378212, -0.0192573182284832, -0.009046162478625774, -0.02985810674726963, -0.03052400052547455, 0.03623035550117493, 0.0010807464132085443, 0.053394217044115067, 0.009417302906513214, -0.04708192124962807, 0.010434858500957489, 0.032885607331991196, -0.01224125549197197, 0.039868611842393875, -0.052218012511730194, 0.03320622444152832, 0.01705109514296055, -0.0012906307820230722, -0.07582081854343414, -0.05113886669278145, 0.0025371331721544266, -0.000006625696642004186, -0.007890126667916775, -0.02409692294895649, -0.03570825234055519, -0.023178838193416595, 0.011562933214008808, -0.0036384500563144684, 0.013117179274559021, -0.009824595414102077, -0.01664573699235916, 0.01153787411749363, 0.009659801609814167, 0.07161371409893036, -0.005284513346850872, -0.024140531197190285, 0.051510266959667206, -0.023833857849240303, -0.06215590983629227, 0.02480977773666382, 0.0001898170739877969, -0.012604383751749992, -0.01553166750818491, -0.025744013488292694, 0.005476581864058971, 0.05979115515947342, -0.031241491436958313, -0.0047211917117238045, 0.025898225605487823, 0.01124105416238308, 0.04585787281394005, -0.03981982544064522, 0.035062745213508606, -0.0014140419661998749, 0.008093557320535183, 0.005121069494634867, -0.04394581541419029, -0.04469198361039162, -0.00703467009589076, 0.013794947415590286, 0.02170616388320923, -0.013382546603679657, 0.015854135155677795, 0.02447192743420601, -0.026413381099700928, -0.020089756697416306, 0.02708391472697258, 0.004112275317311287, 0.020892154425382614, 0.01158178597688675, 0.013172092847526073, 0.024187559261918068, 0.007902771234512329, -0.058769069612026215, -0.03250117227435112, -0.03326722979545593, -0.013550951145589352, 0.08137918263673782, -0.03261974826455116, 0.06779661774635315, 0.019712073728442192, 0.029618410393595695, 0.0008564539602957666, -0.025582103058695793, -0.011482645757496357, -0.0289992094039917, -0.0020645540207624435, 0.03295827656984329, -0.025921950116753578, 0.04387569800019264, -0.023889217525720596, 0.03271736577153206, 0.0171424001455307, 0.027521973475813866, 0.013377192430198193, 0.028775082901120186, 0.0030853627249598503, -0.007856765761971474, -0.03216136246919632, 0.031827088445425034, -0.01976563036441803, 0.017176076769828796, -0.0048780315555632114, 0.005339887924492359, 0.03432295843958855, 0.037264905869960785, -0.002682659775018692, -0.023176999762654305, -0.03280528634786606, -0.03288114443421364, 0.007421406917273998, 0.009623152203857899, -0.023231223225593567, 0.02385822869837284, 0.01713174395263195, 0.043547045439481735, -0.0357421413064003, 0.016868311911821365, -0.055856846272945404, -0.08112223446369171, -0.01650635525584221, -0.039536360651254654, -0.014058382250368595, 0.03314263001084328, 0.028736330568790436, -0.04366196691989899, -0.0006337002851068974, 0.003016592003405094, -0.005964598618447781, -0.006975000258535147, 0.02221662923693657, 0.010564113967120647, 0.0862957090139389, 0.033181365579366684, 0.020631123334169388, -0.017244646325707436, 0.02275335229933262, 0.09840044379234314, 0.01184014417231083, 0.013910608366131783, -0.02429307997226715, -0.004784660879522562, -0.03839828819036484, 0.0044156406074762344, -0.033930279314517975, 0.035976942628622055, -0.027393318712711334, -0.024804778397083282, 0.03326258063316345, 0.042402785271406174, 0.017400672659277916, -0.011233271099627018, 0.050947438925504684, -0.018123626708984375, -0.024816960096359253, -0.037691108882427216, 0.006302927620708942, 0.006093451753258705, -0.008731430396437645, -0.031083788722753525, 0.03942522034049034, -0.0420297235250473, -0.01629362255334854, -0.040918152779340744, 0.017525291070342064, 0.01823117770254612, -0.012870866805315018, 0.004189930856227875, 0.012531877495348454, 0.028206633403897285, 0.02169496938586235, 0.009141123853623867, -0.011868970468640327, 0.05128579959273338, -0.0034748828038573265, 0.0344766229391098, 0.001976924715563655, 0.015309689566493034, -0.0021228615660220385, 0.005414524581283331, -0.02521834522485733, -0.02164825052022934, -0.032484281808137894, -0.03784067928791046, 0.07295902073383331, -0.001431301119737327, -0.024978389963507652, -0.026715736836194992, 0.0125512620434165, -0.0046871500089764595, -0.039606381207704544, 0.013980785384774208, -0.0016712959622964263, 0.020301027223467827, -0.055015675723552704, -0.02527575194835663, -0.03652914986014366, 0.02216039039194584, 0.0020496330689638853, 0.04174147918820381, 0.04514859616756439, -0.026052314788103104, -0.021641407161951065, -0.023037806153297424, 0.046581774950027466, -0.01946331560611725, -0.032331038266420364, -0.012297725304961205, -0.010902886278927326, -0.034009113907814026, 0.012390794232487679, 0.02829778753221035, -0.02191086672246456, 0.011934515088796616, 0.0005920145194977522, 0.01632673665881157, -0.0020191550720483065, -0.04859460890293121, 0.008120963349938393, 0.0001093891478376463, -0.03509518504142761, -0.0027746602427214384, -0.00446557579562068, 0.013678464107215405, 0.020971983671188354, 0.01731269806623459, 0.011710148304700851, -0.0020256810821592808, 0.060682184994220734, 0.017632288858294487, -0.02567661739885807, -0.023734426125884056, -0.02824251353740692, -0.03096853755414486, 0.009061668999493122, 0.016066933050751686, 0.05686736851930618, 0.04210241883993149, 0.011460067704319954, 0.0005799365462735295, 0.027166055515408516, -0.03581851348280907, 0.003130021970719099, 0.02425180748105049, -0.016853459179401398, -0.003587719053030014, -0.020519359037280083, -0.023208828642964363, -0.030426837503910065, 0.005000905133783817, -0.022977622225880623, -0.029582442715764046, -0.02490987814962864, 0.019175413995981216, -0.010368668474256992, 0.0011721339542418718, -0.03206537663936615, 0.004407844971865416, -0.0677574872970581, 0.0021583845373243093, -0.027891937643289566, 0.01651720330119133, -0.007025460712611675, -0.006439142860472202, -0.0017059140373021364, 0.03291754052042961, -0.03600834310054779, 0.017248092219233513, 0.05522485822439194, 0.042008355259895325, 0.025483526289463043, -0.030185243114829063, -0.01966695301234722, -0.005516803823411465, 0.06796190142631531, -0.03990022465586662, -0.003396142041310668, 0.04945607855916023, -0.053510233759880066, -0.019722897559404373, 0.009067905135452747, 0.016788410022854805, 0.04557811841368675, 0.021264573559165, -0.017432162538170815, -0.05180450901389122, 0.04434638097882271, -0.010349705815315247, -0.007229935377836227, -0.03226347267627716, 0.020864048972725868, 0.025652825832366943, -0.004776856862008572, 0.013964701443910599, -0.014850023202598095, 0.02020375430583954, 0.019025709480047226, 0.06273143738508224, -0.024148020893335342, 0.0029339531902223825, 0.022765787318348885, 0.025679778307676315, -0.010301878675818443, 0.01927161030471325, -0.023123351857066154, 0.005175670143216848, 0.05499913915991783, -0.023496534675359726, -0.002957449061796069, -0.005234607961028814, 0.013020086102187634, -0.06119729205965996, -0.03064560890197754, -0.023700011894106865, -0.0015084181213751435, 0.0492393784224987, -0.049399759620428085, -0.035587333142757416, 0.03249610215425491, -0.0738769993185997, -0.00519138528034091, -0.025344133377075195, -0.006172026041895151, -0.014527357183396816, -0.00877227634191513, -0.02508552372455597, 0.02341522090137005, 0.043372154235839844, 0.03702177107334137, 0.043142471462488174, 0.04011443257331848, 0.015268974006175995, -0.031843703240156174, -0.045047130435705185, 0.0061514913104474545, 0.02217985689640045, -0.03675519675016403, 0.03937782347202301, -0.030014576390385628, -0.015281850472092628, 0.03012801706790924, -0.044550541788339615, 0.008004874922335148, -0.00700138695538044, 0.018394535407423973, -0.028289970010519028, 0.04969406500458717, -0.002061532810330391, -0.020849019289016724, 0.056852832436561584, -0.013655131682753563, 0.025080397725105286, -0.009134321473538876, -0.012015757150948048, 0.02947077713906765, 0.02837214432656765, 0.01582297310233116, -0.019243547692894936, 0.020248305052518845, -0.016757003962993622, -0.010147512890398502, -0.027621394023299217, 0.020603694021701813, 0.011087105609476566, -0.0412166602909565, 0.03153826668858528, -0.021606050431728363, -0.033153582364320755, 0.038010165095329285, 0.03978634625673294, -0.02515248768031597, -0.04112847521901131, -0.008589444682002068, -0.04592984542250633, 0.025001397356390953, 0.013053624890744686, -0.024086954072117805, -0.05684028938412666, -0.03576468676328659, -0.0149708716198802, -0.0026458462234586477, 0.009413416497409344, -0.03623345121741295, -0.04334456846117973, 0.04986214637756348, 0.009623689576983452, 0.0030627583619207144, 0.015389502048492432, -0.011844375170767307, 0.007022098638117313, -0.06386465579271317, 0.024756234139204025, -0.006551370956003666, -0.01715896651148796, -0.018666168674826622, -0.004581235349178314, -0.012525763362646103, 0.04829447343945503, 0.02386132813990116, -0.017316244542598724, 0.017621513456106186, 0.00563810346648097, 0.032663580030202866, -0.014829600229859352, -0.022099493071436882, 0.06793079525232315, -0.01971881091594696, -0.04701731353998184, 0.026916615664958954, -0.023560646921396255, 0.016342662274837494, 0.01403843518346548, -0.023036684840917587, -0.04039376974105835, -0.024879390373826027, -0.004729622974991798, -0.05212290585041046, 0.01443554274737835, 0.01960170641541481, -0.02860124595463276, 0.03370294347405434, 0.0027829164173454046, 0.014547284692525864, 0.010193528607487679, 0.03732363507151604, -0.05891601741313934, 0.02909260056912899, -0.05255800858139992, -0.01756863482296467, -0.01823069527745247, 0.03678841516375542, -0.0023074576165527105, -0.047131698578596115, -0.021669719368219376, 0.05653391778469086, -0.05716780945658684, 0.006397276185452938, 0.03420957922935486, -0.010781451128423214, 0.02521262876689434, 0.010103495791554451, 0.02247660420835018, -0.00948119256645441, -0.013873276300728321, -0.013497985899448395, -0.005292003974318504, 0.042638249695301056, -0.022938616573810577, 0.002254247199743986, 0.008116316050291061, -0.04333609342575073, -0.0009502266184426844, -0.029034316539764404, -0.001116744359023869, -0.041286952793598175, 0.00240702903829515, 0.0017615689430385828, -0.017208458855748177, 0.013970546424388885, 0.0060250405222177505, -0.027730681002140045, 0.04777373746037483, -0.047495611011981964, -0.010200951248407364, -0.028378501534461975, 0.013820653781294823, -0.01753520779311657, 0.018345586955547333, 0.0059127202257514, 0.03247993439435959, 0.001701020635664463, 0.012835877947509289, -0.007070391904562712, -0.005950502119958401, 0.0464261956512928, -0.06553275138139725, 0.004835875239223242, -0.027182135730981827, -0.008302615955471992, -0.017436441034078598, 0.009405521675944328, -0.060695212334394455, -0.04297453910112381, 0.03143103048205376, 0.030306795611977577, 0.005425978917628527, -0.03458619862794876, -0.03327298164367676, 0.011679664254188538, 0.046689439564943314, -0.04134898632764816, -0.012854039669036865, -0.011264033615589142, 0.0201735682785511, -0.013526211492717266, 0.029514707624912262 ]
<p>Assume we have two variables A and B, and we are trying to find the Mutual Information between them. Can the mutual information enable us to find if there exists a positive or negative relationship between two variables?</p>
74,424
[ -0.012403549626469612, 0.014420435763895512, -0.023598292842507362, 0.02634248696267605, 0.02793114259839058, 0.06729860603809357, -0.01915147714316845, 0.01354031078517437, 0.023791320621967316, -0.047085195779800415, 0.007982884533703327, 0.03130844607949257, 0.026736320927739143, 0.04717228561639786, 0.0030883573926985264, 0.010056023485958576, -0.021436814218759537, 0.016071375459432602, -0.007633777800947428, -0.007592891342937946, 0.0066710528917610645, 0.01846102997660637, 0.05935148894786835, 0.024351350963115692, -0.02476726472377777, 0.06107734143733978, 0.03728866204619408, -0.0452335961163044, -0.014860616065561771, 0.06744400411844254, -0.006648894399404526, -0.029237855225801468, 0.01817226968705654, 0.09138578921556473, 0.04681643843650818, -0.023980628699064255, -0.042265988886356354, -0.013545419089496136, -0.004771443083882332, 0.028562385588884354, -0.011341468431055546, -0.04212729632854462, 0.01754114218056202, 0.04901399090886116, -0.05119452252984047, -0.0025551256258040667, 0.0035737163852900267, -0.034831222146749496, -0.00865804124623537, -0.04817632585763931, 0.0797026976943016, -0.02536468766629696, 0.0489303395152092, 0.02905404195189476, -0.04734284058213234, 0.0007822817424312234, 0.04356226697564125, 0.07293953746557236, 0.025412818416953087, -0.04981236904859543, -0.023811304941773415, -0.004699387587606907, -0.009679475799202919, -0.004293026868253946, -0.049857884645462036, 0.03549601137638092, 0.0053903586231172085, 0.007757851388305426, 0.03321053087711334, 0.009957541711628437, -0.008914089761674404, 0.013008395209908485, 0.042607031762599945, -0.02116982638835907, 0.014985904097557068, -0.03176931291818619, 0.029020605608820915, 0.0009984805947169662, 0.013646257109940052, 0.06950519233942032, -0.008208432234823704, 0.003619228024035692, 0.03317420929670334, 0.022120531648397446, 0.035369642078876495, -0.021450655534863472, 0.04812537878751755, -0.02035084180533886, 0.00746330339461565, 0.011174887418746948, -0.03390336036682129, -0.009463923051953316, 0.005396754015237093, -0.021306393668055534, -0.044415395706892014, 0.015055535361170769, -0.04696633294224739, 0.03203870356082916, 0.02236924134194851, -0.07545880228281021, -0.008015381172299385, -0.005863735917955637, 0.028917457908391953, 0.050049714744091034, -0.024663416668772697, -0.004127750638872385, -0.024484269320964813, 0.04588666185736656, -0.012000522576272488, -0.015406666323542595, -0.0022027059458196163, 0.006284278817474842, -0.00281717162579298, 0.0023850963916629553, 0.05639952793717384, -0.04924558103084564, -0.00820155069231987, -0.027790682390332222, 0.058091431856155396, 0.07532855123281479, 0.043088145554065704, -0.04525955766439438, 0.03764426335692406, 0.014968298375606537, -0.044181548058986664, 0.0181441530585289, 0.008975495584309101, 0.0030789501033723354, -0.035890161991119385, 0.05884437635540962, 0.002610219409689307, -0.0034004494082182646, 0.02547064982354641, -0.000933221890591085, 0.02229221910238266, 0.030888568609952927, -0.09818320721387863, -0.043010395020246506, 0.03798653185367584, -0.0055792671628296375, -0.022213039919734, -0.0553566999733448, 0.006844923831522465, 0.06105341389775276, 0.06152799725532532, 0.00997067615389824, 0.02666778489947319, 0.013971407897770405, 0.03241324424743652, 0.02443179488182068, -0.016196036711335182, -0.03034353069961071, -0.014888972043991089, -0.011490115895867348, -0.03264625743031502, -0.08281433582305908, 0.01637001521885395, 0.005288539920002222, -0.018310990184545517, -0.010033279657363892, 0.028850246220827103, -0.006273133680224419, -0.0012861116556450725, 0.028447620570659637, -0.014401373453438282, -0.024168236181139946, 0.04661210626363754, 0.006206710822880268, 0.011809193529188633, 0.04142599180340767, 0.021813595667481422, 0.03128693997859955, 0.007078978698700666, 0.040122948586940765, 0.04758647084236145, -0.022905688732862473, -0.04776374623179436, 0.0146757448092103, 0.04373295232653618, -0.023582806810736656, -0.012263013049960136, -0.040590256452560425, -0.05238129571080208, 0.02003602311015129, 0.031064685434103012, 0.04872588813304901, 0.012166078202426434, -0.01300638448446989, 0.055170707404613495, -0.03871576488018036, -0.022467713803052902, -0.05653928592801094, 0.020995445549488068, -0.0030446103774011135, -0.054252028465270996, 0.02679961919784546, 0.043103501200675964, 0.004724086262285709, -0.03168255090713501, -0.01807457022368908, -0.03982461988925934, 0.014362611807882786, 0.016821231693029404, -0.0228579118847847, 0.02516767755150795, 0.028406256809830666, 0.03648478165268898, -0.029001254588365555, 0.044051334261894226, -0.057136524468660355, -0.10086534172296524, 0.0027033723890781403, -0.014056185260415077, 0.017857925966382027, 0.005944503471255302, -0.026918910443782806, 0.019719919189810753, 0.02464935928583145, -0.014652837999165058, -0.017279798164963722, -0.04879586026072502, 0.05014913156628609, 0.035899437963962555, 0.04139351844787598, 0.006773572415113449, 0.005460517946630716, 0.05200012028217316, 0.004736335016787052, 0.0028169683646410704, -0.0029791099950671196, -0.06588982790708542, -0.003869808977469802, -0.00043835886754095554, 0.0575324185192585, -0.040199778974056244, 0.032033517956733704, 0.030553828924894333, 0.01438223384320736, -0.0008936080266721547, 0.030751533806324005, -0.014290960505604744, -0.03410514071583748, 0.0032785742077976465, 0.0313706248998642, 0.029235810041427612, 0.009669051505625248, 0.03839685395359993, 0.04101332649588585, 0.015223865397274494, -0.02289196103811264, -0.025643160566687584, 0.04693234711885452, -0.015584471635520458, 0.01534638274461031, 0.004961560945957899, -0.03568870201706886, 0.014673525467514992, -0.03866525739431381, 0.021191827952861786, -0.0205270666629076, -0.003895920468494296, -0.012834054417908192, 0.017417531460523605, -0.017396271228790283, -0.011178551241755486, 0.02380237728357315, -0.013248177245259285, 0.00731990160420537, 0.026008430868387222, -0.06395290791988373, 0.0014506884617730975, 0.022650159895420074, -0.01416759192943573, 0.006448476109653711, -0.016224002465605736, 0.04671572893857956, -0.011624014936387539, 0.041503291577100754, 0.003856409341096878, -0.021825941279530525, 0.005161549896001816, -0.04655786603689194, -0.030437318608164787, 0.0023376757744699717, -0.03923209011554718, -0.006718205288052559, 0.004146625753492117, -0.0070049394853413105, 0.01671694405376911, -0.029628949239850044, 0.014831830747425556, 0.0018529541557654738, -0.02761068567633629, -0.06635167449712753, -0.022495651617646217, -0.04942404851317406, -0.007003871724009514, -0.019133955240249634, 0.002565624425187707, 0.004312256816774607, -0.012820356525480747, -0.04081154614686966, -0.025737905874848366, -0.035996247082948685, -0.05925380438566208, -0.012693970464169979, -0.025578780099749565, 0.024591892957687378, 0.0031063484493643045, 0.012754656374454498, 0.020159469917416573, -0.04665965586900711, -0.012822884134948254, -0.0952058658003807, -0.07755198329687119, 0.05401143804192543, 0.006555486004799604, 0.003993580117821693, -0.027465013787150383, -0.027244383469223976, 0.04060608893632889, -0.0012627913383767009, 0.0010452084243297577, -0.04166804626584053, -0.02618209458887577, -0.020641827955842018, 0.0037554865702986717, 0.011106780730187893, -0.006491775158792734, 0.04676658287644386, 0.057092469185590744, 0.04232878237962723, -0.00444402452558279, 0.032270703464746475, 0.0247483067214489, -0.03346002846956253, 0.02943871170282364, -0.011866552755236626, -0.011845952831208706, 0.016583604738116264, 0.03559846803545952, -0.02427421323955059, 0.0296943336725235, 0.03788108751177788, 0.02125435322523117, 0.010063203983008862, -0.005753128323704004, 0.02387668937444687, -0.011214601807296276, 0.05197134613990784, -0.04612896218895912, 0.036153580993413925, -0.01529363077133894, 0.030873913317918777, -0.031019579619169235, 0.017448846250772476, 0.054883796721696854, 0.014862263575196266, 0.01195861678570509, 0.08196332305669785, 0.006020975299179554, -0.018539436161518097, -0.0004129599255975336, -0.024933520704507828, -0.02621539868414402, 0.013263417407870293, -0.015418860130012035, 0.004043964669108391, 0.02188701368868351, 0.036341290920972824, 0.009918331168591976, 0.004363236483186483, -0.03657757118344307, 0.004392824601382017, -0.035201091319322586, -0.03791332244873047, -0.04050150513648987, 0.005300688091665506, 0.00996789988130331, 0.05417744070291519, 0.003738709492608905, 0.0074487351812422276, 0.010197642259299755, -0.013629923574626446, -0.078789122402668, 0.008551016449928284, -0.04932023957371712, 0.005545732565224171, 0.023082375526428223, -0.03568287566304207, 0.03889921307563782, -0.054084744304418564, 0.0004397676675580442, -0.015228338539600372, 0.027786875143647194, -0.06012016907334328, -0.0068053556606173515, -0.02986304834485054, -0.03119022585451603, -0.020245075225830078, 0.009499811567366123, 0.035268671810626984, -0.005645152181386948, 0.061487212777137756, 0.045456476509571075, -0.008694964461028576, 0.011331628076732159, -0.004431252367794514, -0.02825494483113289, 0.008965998888015747, 0.039593711495399475, -0.0021242175716906786, 0.027053670957684517, -0.01322826836258173, 0.037514664232730865, 0.005106463097035885, 0.057292722165584564, 0.03235650435090065, -0.031545981764793396, -0.012446845881640911, -0.0117671899497509, -0.01633324846625328, -0.04068760946393013, 0.021021461114287376, 0.0037810495123267174, 0.01511442195624113, 0.03837602213025093, 0.015599389560520649, -0.041763994842767715, 0.018903633579611778, 0.08831845968961716, 0.035251084715127945, 0.006030921824276447, -0.010396244004368782, -0.024572890251874924, -0.02497326396405697, -0.023993492126464844, 0.04024311900138855, -0.0040353103540837765, -0.02768494002521038, -0.013485781848430634, 0.041491929441690445, 0.032836347818374634, -0.02293882705271244, 0.009212261065840721, -0.02143995277583599, 0.045725129544734955, -0.001072510378435254, -0.0053758700378239155, 0.017848988994956017, 0.028510965406894684, 0.0019094799645245075, 0.00520278001204133, -0.01483973115682602, -0.10436588525772095, 0.020550429821014404, 0.04611138626933098, 0.04556310176849365, -0.01764499954879284, 0.0055230120196938515, -0.03923897072672844, -0.038979582488536835, 0.05818796902894974, -0.004476111847907305, 0.04499414190649986, -0.030111251398921013, 0.032594721764326096, -0.02024085633456707, -0.017266303300857544, -0.03550774231553078, 0.026506805792450905, -0.005505985114723444, -0.010444208048284054, 0.004153009038418531, -0.01143261045217514, -0.044253814965486526, 0.014458907768130302, 0.034262582659721375, 0.05261196568608284, 0.0006914506084285676, -0.004753867629915476, 0.001941200695000589, 0.019761743023991585, 0.006289365701377392, -0.08366920799016953, 0.04588804766535759, 0.003392887767404318, -0.03344002738595009, 0.03483409807085991, -0.008627932518720627, -0.022793276235461235, 0.023870263248682022, -0.02213929034769535, -0.013008557260036469, 0.0016983128152787685, 0.00001891304782475345, 0.02259538136422634, 0.01939457282423973, -0.005625378806143999, 0.049383047968149185, 0.026043526828289032, -0.0045401789247989655, 0.003309599356725812, -0.020305262878537178, 0.02508222497999668, -0.025272347033023834, 0.0044645206071436405, -0.002748094731941819, -0.008782059885561466, -0.00006930532254045829, 0.00288311461918056, 0.005168461706489325, 0.02185356244444847, -0.019794581457972527, 0.0012233131565153599, -0.052486855536699295, 0.005994823295623064, -0.01115708239376545, -0.014047340489923954, 0.007502537686377764, 0.012218956835567951, -0.03452601283788681, -0.04957227408885956, 0.0019839678425341845, -0.034183233976364136, -0.01744493842124939, 0.023584403097629547, -0.027068298310041428, 0.004602345637977123, -0.026294220238924026, -0.029355468228459358, -0.016483958810567856, 0.003916559740900993, 0.04040160030126572, 0.006110443267971277, -0.0077943094074726105, 0.016247831284999847, -0.03520935773849487, -0.008135340176522732, 0.06449896097183228, 0.0009361853590235114, 0.02986823581159115, -0.013995801098644733, 0.04210096597671509, 0.0008854816551320255, -0.033028073608875275, -0.06923487782478333, -0.029850495979189873, -0.019404252991080284, 0.022556232288479805, 0.0028759643901139498, -0.042069874703884125, 0.01321869995445013, -0.009764584712684155, -0.010308989323675632, -0.002156874630600214, 0.0506085567176342, -0.025333859026432037, -0.006755091715604067, -0.001974697457626462, -0.03379299119114876, 0.04581010341644287, 0.0007893558358773589, -0.011449501849710941, 0.03733227774500847, -0.001959960674867034, -0.006450057961046696, 0.002522533992305398, 0.005902816075831652, 0.0007000562618486583, -0.01596500165760517, -0.01442654337733984, -0.03233645111322403, 0.04123039171099663, -0.001008290215395391, -0.03192301467061043, -0.011171325109899044, 0.02381065860390663, -0.0037120229098945856, -0.015704046934843063, 0.0029450946021825075, -0.01821143366396427, 0.003541117999702692, -0.013640233315527439, 0.024023612961173058, -0.023978928104043007, 0.007844945415854454, 0.03500329703092575, 0.008207296952605247, -0.06880123913288116, -0.00642444659024477, 0.05329801142215729, -0.007162454538047314, 0.013820956461131573, -0.008718173019587994, 0.03458268940448761, 0.016765788197517395, -0.048912644386291504, 0.04930004104971886, -0.004365427885204554, 0.04164780676364899, -0.04048081114888191, -0.031488966196775436, -0.02629583515226841, -0.028259363025426865, 0.07560025155544281, -0.014747725799679756, 0.06340327858924866, 0.034498970955610275, 0.009710798971354961, -0.03621421754360199, -0.02236061915755272, -0.0004889948759227991, 0.00782692339271307, -0.005977134220302105, 0.04880237951874733, -0.031770676374435425, 0.023663323372602463, 0.03956275060772896, 0.017155157402157784, -0.022915400564670563, 0.009629273787140846, -0.0070804390124976635, 0.03610048070549965, 0.03237820044159889, -0.010865963064134121, -0.06729913502931595, 0.0378289632499218, -0.07090539485216141, 0.02558232843875885, -0.02389378473162651, -0.028716787695884705, 0.04241221025586128, 0.024132050573825836, 0.011088680475950241, -0.05359741672873497, -0.035075150430202484, -0.028409462422132492, 0.011388258077204227, -0.005698953289538622, 0.012878824956715107, 0.03324514254927635, -0.025595765560865402, 0.01509393285959959, -0.02129778079688549, 0.0068590762093663216, -0.017703792080283165, -0.10251381993293762, -0.008049619384109974, -0.020739249885082245, -0.002918762620538473, 0.043302714824676514, 0.017723653465509415, -0.0381849929690361, 0.028495818376541138, -0.006949616130441427, 0.015008009038865566, 0.006326716393232346, 0.018351441249251366, -0.05372329428792, 0.06208978220820427, 0.005028876010328531, 0.020302439108490944, 0.032122839242219925, 0.004234274383634329, 0.10975299030542374, 0.03763928636908531, -0.0007889577536843717, -0.07380978763103485, 0.02546214684844017, 0.015705609694123268, -0.01757923886179924, -0.022283466532826424, 0.04709745943546295, 0.001189373666420579, 0.021219918504357338, 0.04436181113123894, 0.028424905613064766, 0.022362278774380684, -0.013568193651735783, 0.05146492272615433, -0.01994718611240387, -0.04098983481526375, -0.0018750670133158565, 0.0010468736290931702, -0.018379177898168564, -0.009858625009655952, 0.009306196123361588, -0.012157757766544819, -0.02882097102701664, 0.003720838576555252, -0.012870131060481071, 0.0031278771348297596, 0.03794669732451439, -0.0002703324717003852, -0.027683498337864876, 0.02302427962422371, 0.03141249716281891, 0.03349102661013603, 0.002434041118249297, -0.009162846021354198, 0.040812745690345764, -0.0035249735228717327, -0.008643599227070808, -0.005654522217810154, -0.014566881582140923, -0.025264082476496696, -0.0031090204138308764, 0.002941213082522154, -0.06538688391447067, -0.014207905158400536, -0.01696639694273472, 0.023708973079919815, 0.003556221956387162, -0.01244202721863985, -0.02901538647711277, -0.012157506309449673, -0.009604526683688164, 0.008875682018697262, -0.013287455774843693, 0.019386570900678635, 0.054318249225616455, -0.05738859623670578, -0.014966823160648346, -0.010163339786231518, 0.015449351631104946, -0.031868379563093185, 0.03287850320339203, 0.030546026304364204, -0.030148306861519814, 0.006325540132820606, 0.010219328105449677, 0.06984730809926987, 0.010777748189866543, -0.02830495871603489, -0.03172806277871132, -0.027606826275587082, -0.01033019833266735, -0.025784673169255257, 0.006137416232377291, 0.020743107423186302, -0.003174395766109228, 0.01896015554666519, -0.0016787220956757665, -0.02143895998597145, -0.034914758056402206, 0.00823404360562563, -0.01922232285141945, -0.007109718397259712, -0.031694743782281876, 0.014932357706129551, 0.07090173661708832, 0.04880914092063904, -0.005934934597462416, 0.008372963406145573, 0.017243320122361183, 0.012827994301915169, 0.02151724323630333, -0.040294013917446136, -0.013843447901308537, 0.007308224681764841, -0.047611724585294724, -0.015136729925870895, -0.012683077715337276, 0.020522430539131165, 0.0236019529402256, 0.07080525159835815, 0.010748866014182568, 0.011721021495759487, -0.033146146684885025, 0.026138069108128548, 0.03340555727481842, -0.025479506701231003, -0.008825737051665783, 0.024131203070282936, 0.00333041837438941, -0.006188714411109686, 0.01190863735973835, 0.004928600043058395, 0.003114716848358512, 0.02331962250173092, 0.008517241105437279, -0.016797974705696106, -0.014619721099734306, 0.027219723910093307, 0.020131602883338928, -0.045577265322208405, -0.008753552101552486, -0.07945147901773453, -0.007364838384091854, 0.016141286119818687, -0.010330556891858578, 0.009008617140352726, 0.026267845183610916, -0.002101906342431903, -0.0072226617485284805, 0.04030993953347206, 0.021832555532455444, -0.002735439222306013, -0.017556464299559593, 0.030228879302740097, -0.0023282181937247515, 0.07212111353874207, -0.01687326841056347, -0.025933800265192986, 0.036666594445705414, -0.04396616667509079, 0.004059552680701017, 0.02049115300178528, -0.003709913231432438, 0.03986708074808121, 0.009921704418957233, -0.002258076798170805, -0.012932928279042244, 0.02695843018591404, -0.011521107517182827, 0.011890282854437828, 0.005105454940348864, -0.013839253224432468, 0.006570853292942047, -0.026155386120080948, 0.0044162156991660595, -0.0020578380208462477, -0.025599142536520958, 0.03765210136771202, 0.02310853824019432, 0.002297420985996723, -0.01318325474858284, 0.030677950009703636, 0.013328440487384796, 0.021865908056497574, 0.014942258596420288, -0.030543338507413864, 0.054827358573675156, 0.01643694005906582, -0.010179317556321621, 0.04276198148727417, 0.029606183990836143, 0.024183452129364014, -0.11140464246273041, -0.016289353370666504, 0.025470828637480736, 0.012593850493431091, 0.030280642211437225, -0.047134608030319214, 0.03494846075773239, 0.026441412046551704, -0.050390832126140594, 0.010883861221373081, -0.009534927085042, -0.03053606115281582, -0.011937559582293034, 0.026094328612089157, -0.04210764914751053, 0.027230484411120415, 0.02604505978524685, 0.042243827134370804, 0.014384478330612183, 0.010693825781345367, -0.04052276164293289, -0.01084329467266798, -0.03806770220398903, -0.020005304366350174, -0.02061977982521057, -0.05004909262061119, 0.04703689366579056, -0.05231466144323349, -0.033478595316410065, 0.02350054308772087, -0.044235534965991974, 0.016705168411135674, 0.006898251362144947, 0.04971937835216522, 0.02191045694053173, 0.03612265735864639, 0.029210250824689865, -0.021397527307271957, -0.036995287984609604, -0.010596944950520992, 0.0027522582095116377, 0.044403232634067535, -0.008245903067290783, 0.007415092550218105, -0.022065740078687668, -0.0008869349840097129, -0.041410963982343674, 0.00772129138931632, -0.024539818987250328, -0.031462088227272034, -0.026338228955864906, -0.012937934137880802, -0.01617501676082611, -0.020737629383802414, 0.02073281817138195, -0.030489077791571617, -0.02303958684206009, 0.03890369459986687, 0.042961157858371735, -0.046462975442409515, -0.04155999794602394, -0.011865782551467419, -0.05179077386856079, 0.03382319211959839, 0.013797609135508537, 0.024539481848478317, -0.06119781732559204, -0.006555721629410982, -0.007940870709717274, 0.009984700940549374, -0.03615011274814606, -0.0298704132437706, -0.04782715439796448, 0.05544828996062279, -0.0211620032787323, 0.004313093144446611, 0.03744390234351158, -0.046715833246707916, -0.03159315139055252, -0.0773952379822731, 0.035148732364177704, 0.03873073682188988, 0.01063518412411213, -0.026994209736585617, -0.013023699633777142, -0.049976497888565063, -0.04938152804970741, 0.03604491427540779, -0.0023130462504923344, 0.021088629961013794, -0.012168497778475285, 0.02027232013642788, 0.02398436702787876, -0.014145370572805405, 0.018234893679618835, -0.05177416652441025, -0.03423069044947624, -0.0032597766257822514, -0.028872745111584663, 0.003629500512033701, 0.01130655501037836, -0.025717662647366524, -0.0299894567579031, -0.012776294723153114, 0.01708250865340233, -0.006426554638892412, 0.06211793050169945, -0.006809731014072895, -0.03546928986907005, 0.033965591341257095, 0.025147084146738052, 0.060170453041791916, 0.0105942627415061, 0.02325119636952877, -0.04255475848913193, 0.04631209746003151, -0.009109302423894405, -0.02078411355614662, 0.0039964416064321995, 0.013798588886857033, -0.019253700971603394, -0.027199041098356247, -0.04126451909542084, 0.04430213198065758, -0.06610630452632904, 0.03363718464970589, 0.019529124721884727, 0.0013356372946873307, 0.024697279557585716, 0.02126772329211235, 0.027161791920661926, 0.016390597447752953, -0.02406509593129158, 0.008304855786263943, 0.03240545466542244, 0.025234483182430267, -0.005832978989928961, -0.025381430983543396, 0.054927751421928406, -0.02705921232700348, 0.015474152751266956, -0.00868108682334423, 0.013165313750505447, -0.017270641401410103, -0.016806932166218758, 0.007499354891479015, -0.006399715319275856, 0.025889722630381584, 0.009579021483659744, -0.00439838832244277, 0.06732494384050369, -0.04635963588953018, 0.01970501057803631, -0.057318199425935745, -0.0071056378073990345, -0.027023613452911377, 0.016324635595083237, 0.04153044894337654, 0.01291024498641491, 0.05188890919089317, -0.03891319781541824, 0.022870343178510666, -0.0334247387945652, 0.008410362526774406, -0.045330069959163666, 0.021868137642741203, -0.018447525799274445, 0.012580729089677334, 0.003363803494721651, 0.01774746924638748, -0.06167662888765335, -0.041130516678094864, 0.0634169727563858, 0.0600208044052124, 0.04039760306477547, -0.010726862587034702, -0.020307930186390877, -0.031918965280056, 0.040163420140743256, -0.043524034321308136, -0.007518314756453037, -0.053298331797122955, -0.00819909293204546, 0.01103387214243412, -0.023732909932732582 ]
<p><strong>Background:</strong> I asked hundreds of participants in my survey how much they are interested in selected areas (by five point Likert scales with 1 indicating "not interested" and 5 indicating "interested").</p> <p>Then I tried PCA. The picture below is a projection into first two principal components. Colors are used for genders and PCA arrows are original variables (i.e. interests).</p> <p>I noticed that: </p> <ul> <li>Dots (respondents) are quite well separated by the second component.</li> <li>No arrow points left.</li> <li>Some arrows are much shorter than others.</li> <li>Variables tend to make clusters, but not observations.</li> <li>It seems that arrows pointing down (to males) are mainly males' interests and arrows pointing up are mainly females' interests.</li> <li>Some arrows point neither down nor up.</li> </ul> <p><strong>Questions:</strong> How to correctly interpret relationships between dots (respondents), colors (genders) and arrows (variables)? What other conclusions about respondents and their interests can be mined from this plot? </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/FHYKO.jpg" alt="PCA analysis"></p>
74,425
[ -0.02728336490690708, -0.004894953686743975, 0.017829619348049164, 0.021522462368011475, 0.061631686985492706, 0.009351746179163456, -0.029347093775868416, -0.03329231217503548, 0.01324948389083147, -0.04781431332230568, 0.02710271067917347, 0.025895923376083374, 0.0592675618827343, 0.0177223552018404, -0.016805890947580338, 0.010095053352415562, 0.0017926250584423542, 0.0166060421615839, -0.004378556273877621, 0.009090190753340721, 0.00646330276504159, 0.015735361725091934, 0.021255973726511, 0.01200316846370697, 0.015268655493855476, 0.0989765152335167, 0.027321213856339455, -0.023077556863427162, -0.0024136838037520647, 0.041117340326309204, -0.01222697552293539, 0.000621268292888999, -0.0007606084109283984, 0.005641377996653318, 0.03030453808605671, -0.0052680280059576035, 0.017128990963101387, -0.0070441653952002525, 0.011386268772184849, 0.018427463248372078, 0.006855214014649391, -0.011429926380515099, 0.005799288861453533, 0.053404550999403, -0.010530669242143631, 0.00858509074896574, 0.005255159456282854, -0.05864258110523224, 0.04124670848250389, -0.04594222828745842, 0.061025701463222504, 0.026675250381231308, 0.02425253391265869, 0.00937818456441164, -0.016489407047629356, -0.0038910778239369392, 0.03431696817278862, 0.06082605943083763, -0.013604146428406239, -0.0790436789393425, -0.003264111001044512, 0.0063070980831980705, 0.003250434063374996, -0.010531040839850903, -0.05580670014023781, 0.01296134665608406, -0.026752550154924393, 0.00902651995420456, 0.046688150614500046, -0.025890549644827843, 0.009170827455818653, 0.040234100073575974, 0.033751990646123886, 0.0036165344063192606, -0.024702243506908417, -0.03975910693407059, -0.00015553037519566715, 0.024239037185907364, 0.040562890470027924, 0.025842217728495598, 0.007629863452166319, 0.00285376887768507, -0.008344115689396858, -0.0031635817140340805, 0.01573295146226883, -0.018188297748565674, 0.06186768412590027, -0.03786192461848259, -0.009034866467118263, -0.009638921357691288, -0.019719872623682022, 0.015734978020191193, 0.03588572517037392, 0.03648275136947632, -0.03952163830399513, 0.038830481469631195, -0.0006228690035641193, 0.04291031137108803, -0.0011858755024150014, -0.03154631704092026, -0.03352474048733711, -0.009716607630252838, 0.017031483352184296, 0.04061143100261688, -0.0019933131989091635, -0.010236566886305809, -0.050990793853998184, 0.008904922753572464, -0.023359188809990883, -0.04546298831701279, -0.0017784921219572425, 0.03934413939714432, 0.04399213194847107, 0.008805666118860245, -0.016182096675038338, -0.005242692306637764, 0.016527818515896797, -0.01745183952152729, 0.055329252034425735, 0.05323916673660278, 0.01909554935991764, -0.0009061146411113441, 0.03606521710753441, -0.004088292829692364, -0.07241516560316086, 0.016306981444358826, 0.012912495993077755, -0.018846960738301277, -0.008980603888630867, 0.05895942822098732, -0.0007027580868452787, 0.018719984218478203, 0.03530900552868843, 0.012005109339952469, 0.028326330706477165, 0.02684311382472515, -0.06590153276920319, -0.03829905390739441, 0.025910915806889534, 0.01715940423309803, -0.010468551889061928, -0.056841108947992325, -0.022259797900915146, 0.036998603492975235, 0.045179203152656555, -0.037373922765254974, -0.0032357918098568916, 0.018978601321578026, 0.017472224310040474, 0.01883905567228794, -0.050719913095235825, -0.0260163526982069, -0.04031515493988991, -0.011002926155924797, -0.03747900202870369, -0.06192115694284439, 0.022120583802461624, 0.02797316387295723, 0.011356406845152378, -0.009999096393585205, 0.026136640459299088, 0.017517201602458954, -0.04197285696864128, -0.03830258920788765, -0.012008844874799252, 0.007993312552571297, 0.06846971064805984, -0.023121127858757973, 0.0003859125426970422, 0.00030341005185618997, -0.0003597679315134883, 0.05269720032811165, -0.005173785146325827, 0.04325076937675476, 0.0817255824804306, 0.029034655541181564, 0.004275751765817404, 0.015210608951747417, -0.01535035576671362, -0.016146518290042877, -0.04790302738547325, -0.0668594017624855, -0.05018368363380432, -0.01921245828270912, 0.015302708372473717, 0.059036172926425934, 0.006362349726259708, -0.08188088983297348, 0.012454896233975887, -0.04113881289958954, -0.0630108192563057, -0.10062295198440552, -0.0007023577927611768, -0.02334115467965603, -0.014534304849803448, 0.011241736821830273, 0.0033461314160376787, -0.01497798040509224, 0.01569749414920807, -0.01634868048131466, -0.027509331703186035, 0.009404176846146584, 0.05264732614159584, -0.053677331656217575, -0.04715877026319504, 0.04450654238462448, -0.006068381946533918, -0.0010716667165979743, 0.013883039355278015, -0.03742976859211922, -0.03732413053512573, 0.014429636299610138, -0.05307796970009804, 0.015866685658693314, -0.010923163034021854, 0.00817103497684002, -0.00670647295191884, 0.04228125512599945, -0.04038909822702408, 0.015079004690051079, -0.04398588836193085, 0.06916343420743942, 0.04052882641553879, -0.039794325828552246, -0.0044357976876199245, 0.003958132117986679, 0.028599387034773827, 0.03351322188973427, -0.011951870284974575, -0.004141228273510933, -0.061614908277988434, 0.015609356574714184, 0.04199977591633797, 0.02288404293358326, -0.05965688079595566, 0.04197349771857262, 0.02832495979964733, 0.06563534587621689, -0.016155961900949478, 0.01565013825893402, -0.010341232642531395, -0.02166411280632019, -0.0009906850755214691, 0.024605153128504753, -0.02906361222267151, 0.02643527276813984, 0.006976173724979162, -0.004568092059344053, 0.051931023597717285, 0.006809782702475786, 0.018821317702531815, 0.042828213423490524, -0.02849607542157173, -0.006666603963822126, 0.014288379810750484, -0.006183607038110495, 0.030890265479683876, -0.007851706817746162, -0.032627008855342865, 0.0415680818259716, 0.002240839647129178, -0.0033423849381506443, 0.004409838933497667, -0.01233399473130703, -0.02675427682697773, 0.03019300289452076, -0.04057232290506363, -0.001657866407185793, 0.007783545646816492, -0.013460846617817879, 0.023107605054974556, -0.05573518946766853, -0.04653448984026909, -0.02282995544373989, -0.009880879893898964, 0.042151451110839844, 0.031792134046554565, 0.01161767914891243, -0.012399417348206043, -0.007363388780504465, 0.009512681514024734, -0.003107763361185789, -0.003416111459955573, 0.026960836723446846, -0.08580686151981354, -0.048789553344249725, -0.012856291607022285, -0.0039855414070189, -0.0058778757229447365, -0.01621054857969284, 0.016271250322461128, 0.05266634747385979, -0.02507038787007332, -0.02315220795571804, -0.014828908257186413, 0.01290087029337883, 0.01327618956565857, -0.03412684053182602, -0.06645612418651581, 0.022882089018821716, 0.02106715738773346, 0.013023370876908302, 0.025476008653640747, 0.008502152748405933, -0.026806434616446495, 0.008977912366390228, 0.013492275960743427, 0.023432303220033646, 0.044424787163734436, 0.009241451509296894, -0.012069032527506351, 0.00200353330001235, -0.02060730941593647, -0.054471634328365326, -0.050697147846221924, -0.02005119062960148, 0.03131953999400139, 0.019479556009173393, -0.0009626687387935817, -0.008055989630520344, 0.06682777404785156, 0.021163824945688248, -0.023477831855416298, -0.07731883227825165, -0.021529793739318848, -0.06575321406126022, 0.0029874590691179037, 0.022359570488333702, 0.01603083498775959, 0.02527483180165291, 0.017678234726190567, -0.009341125376522541, 0.05464769899845123, 0.025651879608631134, -0.00394225399941206, -0.015670128166675568, 0.05584293231368065, -0.003573280293494463, 0.0028864506166428328, 0.013355673290789127, 0.03796796128153801, -0.03600883111357689, 0.00576778594404459, -0.009593278169631958, -0.003997179679572582, 0.02989087998867035, -0.03380771353840828, -0.008305610157549381, -0.06849092990159988, 0.01771295815706253, -0.02274559624493122, -0.0022987553384155035, 0.034208670258522034, -0.03459632024168968, -0.03267168998718262, 0.011332930065691471, 0.04817818105220795, -0.025085467845201492, -0.00402270769700408, 0.04691314324736595, 0.020840831100940704, 0.016664862632751465, 0.010958855040371418, -0.00638188561424613, -0.003927007783204317, 0.03843320533633232, -0.016484426334500313, -0.010638264007866383, 0.06546802073717117, 0.03105149045586586, 0.003727391827851534, 0.02723625674843788, -0.057962048798799515, 0.038285598158836365, -0.07008471339941025, 0.013605832122266293, -0.052320752292871475, 0.03179660066962242, -0.0032313226256519556, 0.05507319048047066, 0.046368177980184555, 0.032104846090078354, -0.02029094658792019, 0.003971593454480171, -0.056001514196395874, -0.0059396508149802685, -0.005331427790224552, 0.03416595235466957, 0.0021292841993272305, 0.01782972365617752, 0.024856995791196823, -0.0013257752871140838, 0.002483995398506522, -0.007091901730746031, 0.032098740339279175, -0.04706033691763878, 0.02396104857325554, -0.037124086171388626, 0.0037948335520923138, 0.0010019009932875633, 0.0011915870709344745, 0.042153503745794296, -0.012615121901035309, 0.054866403341293335, 0.009168327786028385, -0.012982821092009544, -0.024090975522994995, -0.03701140731573105, -0.021452447399497032, 0.024794336408376694, 0.0396355539560318, 0.003142793197184801, 0.01328357309103012, -0.006204316858202219, 0.024128390476107597, -0.0261777825653553, 0.031717825680971146, 0.03209042549133301, -0.00700034573674202, -0.004034120589494705, -0.009934601373970509, 0.009954887442290783, -0.03762178495526314, 0.021017340943217278, -0.022596897557377815, 0.017842086032032967, 0.05971922725439072, 0.05096559226512909, -0.02931087650358677, 0.016072329133749008, 0.019959472119808197, 0.07467862218618393, 0.01631244085729122, -0.04589777812361717, -0.0009604712249711156, -0.026887793093919754, 0.009975758381187916, 0.02060571312904358, -0.027781082317233086, -0.004733382724225521, -0.029136670753359795, 0.05595463886857033, -0.0019305074820294976, -0.06584404408931732, 0.018399855121970177, -0.03678765892982483, 0.030886974185705185, -0.03756975755095482, -0.02121969684958458, 0.015149024315178394, 0.03135096654295921, 0.05552801862359047, 0.004753814544528723, -0.017456969246268272, -0.10055741667747498, -0.0016211152542382479, 0.032070498913526535, 0.0707501545548439, -0.01694907620549202, -0.03276991471648216, -0.028086597099900246, 0.02881944552063942, 0.017832275480031967, -0.04044348746538162, 0.024231834337115288, -0.028660491108894348, 0.025174209848046303, -0.03398020565509796, -0.0003292083856649697, -0.05216281861066818, -0.024706922471523285, -0.013301294296979904, 0.028013771399855614, -0.02539694309234619, -0.06235332414507866, -0.04372073709964752, 0.011710941791534424, 0.011481878347694874, 0.0237886942923069, -0.004579341039061546, 0.022556353360414505, 0.007018570322543383, -0.02439165860414505, 0.0009510862291790545, -0.08649027347564697, 0.03262000530958176, 0.03852694109082222, -0.023549387231469154, 0.11856631934642792, -0.03154134750366211, -0.007069143932312727, -0.012608692049980164, -0.01387343555688858, 0.014730261638760567, -0.011317584663629532, -0.04920142889022827, 0.05272893235087395, 0.025705203413963318, -0.015415160916745663, 0.05033774673938751, -0.0021647277753800154, -0.031206335872411728, -0.015369594097137451, -0.028269633650779724, -0.008736192248761654, 0.00038785443757660687, 0.009774013422429562, -0.006864676717668772, -0.002541655208915472, 0.0009196700411848724, 0.008247976191341877, -0.006421220023185015, 0.026880450546741486, -0.022063277661800385, -0.03323441743850708, -0.001166081172414124, 0.039475176483392715, -0.004612242337316275, 0.021076779812574387, 0.009061053395271301, 0.03367635980248451, 0.03641835227608681, 0.0021577405277639627, 0.030057420954108238, -0.03207030147314072, 0.012126326560974121, 0.021266791969537735, 0.01303283404558897, -0.014260767959058285, -0.05698152258992195, -0.012179898098111153, 0.014338437467813492, -0.020351706072688103, 0.03386346995830536, -0.029103919863700867, 0.004801641684025526, 0.06449457257986069, -0.05991225317120552, 0.006110348738729954, 0.01870439574122429, 0.012105722911655903, 0.05004093050956726, 0.024283163249492645, 0.061262816190719604, -0.03506394848227501, 0.03223244100809097, -0.046610672026872635, -0.06099795550107956, -0.00208122911863029, 0.036726921796798706, -0.03406934440135956, -0.010583071038126945, -0.025548750534653664, 0.012915127910673618, -0.007682752329856157, 0.04603405296802521, 0.019366305321455002, -0.0652308315038681, -0.016010645776987076, -0.0076676602475345135, 0.01857825182378292, 0.12130365520715714, 0.00554855540394783, 0.0031711370684206486, 0.010453762486577034, -0.011209158226847649, 0.00001332741157966666, -0.007199139799922705, 0.0028579540085047483, -0.043892644345760345, -0.0237127672880888, -0.01725398190319538, 0.023805418983101845, 0.06565061956644058, -0.006168413907289505, -0.025405775755643845, -0.012289916165173054, -0.004980132915079594, -0.011396038345992565, -0.0032602837309241295, -0.013833467848598957, -0.02963913604617119, -0.03458471968770027, -0.008539257571101189, 0.006324417423456907, -0.002101688180118799, -0.011437592096626759, 0.016469426453113556, 0.030468303710222244, -0.02996574155986309, 0.011509123258292675, 0.05106358975172043, 0.0031224293634295464, 0.022795019671320915, -0.019461648538708687, -0.010170944035053253, 0.0332612618803978, 0.04074722155928612, -0.00983425322920084, -0.006451115012168884, 0.025307418778538704, -0.036275122314691544, -0.04525414854288101, -0.04355810582637787, -0.016366641968488693, 0.06227326765656471, 0.014539586380124092, 0.03071150742471218, 0.02168896421790123, -0.021589260548353195, -0.014526954852044582, -0.02063301019370556, 0.030944254249334335, -0.004261361435055733, 0.01836887188255787, 0.012167398817837238, -0.03459728881716728, -0.007745048496872187, 0.018013019114732742, 0.03456728532910347, 0.00552413472905755, 0.02429123967885971, 0.041841886937618256, 0.02766641601920128, 0.0026835897006094456, -0.030932553112506866, -0.07075798511505127, 0.03552106022834778, -0.007622459437698126, 0.04118384048342705, -0.020090376958251, -0.0628373995423317, 0.022281378507614136, 0.04390807822346687, -0.03197222203016281, -0.02252223901450634, 0.0090223653241992, -0.028555328026413918, -0.032666467130184174, 0.023703990504145622, -0.006641631945967674, -0.0019169662846252322, -0.028254181146621704, 0.032569222152233124, 0.007598974276334047, 0.00015198935579974204, -0.02500923164188862, -0.04851950705051422, -0.02201479859650135, 0.002825226169079542, -0.06119735538959503, 0.010587494820356369, -0.01302975881844759, -0.03702857717871666, 0.029117509722709656, -0.027730150148272514, -0.03251286968588829, -0.010733317583799362, 0.038707684725522995, 0.00513445632532239, 0.03241945058107376, -0.03844544291496277, 0.003364807227626443, -0.002825689036399126, -0.023633800446987152, 0.12407146394252777, 0.09039977937936783, 0.021228453144431114, -0.047740232199430466, 0.08425963670015335, 0.00182878109626472, -0.0009503453620709479, -0.0283210352063179, 0.02430383302271366, 0.0064142439514398575, 0.0034049791283905506, 0.027216147631406784, 0.05568305775523186, 0.008017235435545444, 0.035067666321992874, 0.05567702278494835, -0.012234656140208244, -0.03386199474334717, 0.013128139078617096, 0.010075700469315052, -0.034752581268548965, -0.019631406292319298, -0.04609178751707077, -0.004251308739185333, -0.027557656168937683, -0.011417499743402004, 0.010966332629323006, -0.031003301963210106, 0.028644109144806862, -0.03127423673868179, -0.00954618863761425, -0.0023800989147275686, 0.01934523694217205, 0.030974870547652245, -0.021347004920244217, 0.018285879865288734, 0.005577856209129095, -0.025733161717653275, 0.017175184562802315, 0.02894003875553608, -0.012303301133215427, -0.01219202671200037, 0.0015617007156834006, 0.019666526466608047, -0.05031513795256615, -0.06599340587854385, -0.03792553395032883, 0.023889319971203804, -0.0109802121296525, -0.005158393178135157, -0.04898924380540848, 0.021378805860877037, 0.00769312959164381, -0.02785188890993595, -0.0038892067968845367, 0.023744288831949234, 0.014800199307501316, 0.010243084281682968, -0.013159094378352165, -0.04164314642548561, -0.03555334731936455, -0.02260798029601574, 0.020507577806711197, 0.019682060927152634, -0.016328932717442513, -0.02564222924411297, 0.011217880062758923, 0.02994513139128685, -0.006901300512254238, -0.0013471710262820125, -0.007285716012120247, 0.0075422921217978, -0.022495072335004807, -0.021203380078077316, -0.004139317665249109, 0.033291298896074295, -0.004403884056955576, -0.0030020703561604023, -0.025297775864601135, -0.022548364475369453, -0.03927915543317795, -0.00942204613238573, -0.024455642327666283, 0.0029175439849495888, -0.03598041832447052, 0.03623682260513306, 0.017703451216220856, 0.03329240158200264, 0.001385010895319283, 0.0016332851955667138, -0.020800789818167686, 0.08174075186252594, -0.002810191595926881, -0.03521529957652092, -0.04385359585285187, -0.023806307464838028, -0.04620881751179695, -0.010473276488482952, 0.0242308359593153, 0.08998729288578033, 0.002343002939596772, -0.005941617302596569, 0.003779676277190447, 0.000032367403036914766, 0.010141820646822453, 0.01773805357515812, 0.029652666300535202, -0.04809725657105446, 0.006181193049997091, -0.003241326194256544, -0.010501868091523647, -0.07296258956193924, -0.04474436864256859, -0.020412659272551537, 0.004993085749447346, 0.04557936266064644, 0.000289473362499848, -0.012891457416117191, -0.0006330176256597042, -0.030802251771092415, 0.016787851229310036, -0.031752582639455795, -0.020285189151763916, -0.06951267272233963, -0.023810110986232758, -0.01686800830066204, -0.0013414196437224746, -0.01081293448805809, 0.014728614129126072, 0.007442356087267399, 0.055923864245414734, 0.05032610893249512, -0.004588891752064228, 0.004110260866582394, -0.029883574694395065, 0.03853633627295494, 0.0030244565568864346, 0.034032613039016724, -0.022223128005862236, -0.028575168922543526, 0.04924844205379486, -0.04557197168469429, -0.05285303294658661, -0.005502579268068075, -0.0023155026137828827, 0.036225996911525726, -0.006031225435435772, 0.008769125677645206, 0.04026293009519577, 0.01885678991675377, -0.037367939949035645, -0.03661245107650757, -0.01585526205599308, 0.025296714156866074, 0.014530779793858528, -0.007295562420040369, 0.024685002863407135, -0.009290332905948162, 0.006148774176836014, 0.05562232807278633, 0.03430359065532684, -0.013586854562163353, -0.041335735470056534, -0.00986506137996912, -0.0444108247756958, 0.0032496550120413303, -0.005938789341598749, -0.007751906756311655, 0.0369807668030262, 0.0044799731113016605, -0.026841720566153526, 0.023272452875971794, -0.02079482190310955, 0.03201007843017578, -0.04278772696852684, -0.013304676860570908, -0.024205772206187248, -0.0007462468347512186, -0.0017297172453254461, -0.05319773778319359, 0.0019103529630228877, 0.02419465035200119, -0.061992958188056946, 0.04083725064992905, 0.0071518924087285995, -0.007349531631916761, -0.040858007967472076, 0.0035286538768559694, -0.023941777646541595, 0.01606730744242668, 0.056699976325035095, 0.005556649528443813, 0.031062671914696693, 0.03936386480927467, 0.003470042021945119, -0.009328759275376797, 0.0043161241337656975, 0.04063434153795242, -0.011368189938366413, -0.07170170545578003, 0.04371628537774086, -0.02266404777765274, -0.014178465120494366, 0.015352453105151653, -0.020943615585565567, 0.03436112776398659, 0.07139641791582108, 0.005092165898531675, 0.00044350139796733856, 0.03700963407754898, 0.02634832076728344, 0.00014042940165381879, -0.0262764822691679, -0.022218044847249985, 0.004349470138549805, 0.02251529134809971, -0.016765909269452095, 0.021499164402484894, 0.0221118051558733, -0.0229764636605978, 0.004190259613096714, -0.01551572885364294, -0.03857140988111496, 0.00047897209879010916, 0.008141282014548779, -0.04660883545875549, -0.005414352752268314, -0.016729600727558136, 0.04938625171780586, -0.03751285746693611, -0.0064531597308814526, 0.006180123426020145, -0.022172346711158752, -0.01773923635482788, 0.01655426435172558, 0.0012975250137969851, -0.07009439915418625, 0.0018681129440665245, 0.04265877231955528, 0.003769097151234746, -0.05236389487981796, 0.004106750246137381, 0.00006588072574231774, 0.014044756069779396, -0.021420495584607124, -0.005059677641838789, 0.004719633609056473, 0.055883314460515976, -0.01346523780375719, -0.01584515906870365, 0.020120862871408463, -0.04843877628445625, 0.01593400351703167, -0.09178995341062546, 0.056917231529951096, -0.011384837329387665, -0.023516172543168068, -0.04556892067193985, -0.013469257391989231, -0.0358089879155159, 0.01087087020277977, 0.02876576967537403, -0.0282899122685194, 0.007661124691367149, -0.0028808715287595987, 0.01506058033555746, -0.005943862721323967, -0.008735773153603077, 0.006802069954574108, 0.0037718310486525297, 0.02819562703371048, 0.02425292506814003, -0.024712927639484406, 0.014397460967302322, 0.0204613134264946, 0.051077909767627716, 0.002403037156909704, -0.01740819588303566, -0.0014123207656666636, 0.005428154021501541, 0.021629484370350838, -0.003953042905777693, -0.02638177201151848, 0.0456683412194252, 0.0020945025607943535, 0.018448278307914734, 0.012883222661912441, -0.019767317920923233, -0.009317376650869846, 0.045967746526002884, -0.026791095733642578, -0.01215143408626318, 0.026268547400832176, -0.0025414947886019945, 0.016138801351189613, -0.07429429143667221, -0.0006199424969963729, 0.03209811449050903, 0.008587469346821308, -0.013647668063640594, 0.033976782113313675, 0.022856539115309715, -0.017070995643734932, 0.007141970098018646, 0.048649437725543976, 0.027338234707713127, -0.03935300558805466, 0.007666179910302162, 0.027640551328659058, 0.030004160478711128, 0.003997561056166887, 0.02167968638241291, 0.019121289253234863, 0.005804894957691431, 0.01999647729098797, -0.0040229265578091145, 0.0419975183904171, -0.012380608357489109, 0.023936806246638298, 0.0219297856092453, -0.003265639767050743, 0.029499219730496407, 0.008709554560482502, -0.012808019295334816, 0.05770435184240341, -0.022973809391260147, -0.019171178340911865, -0.05346005782485008, -0.001421056455001235, -0.02509305253624916, 0.007485515903681517, 0.018504459410905838, 0.01182779110968113, 0.03242788463830948, 0.021659834310412407, -0.019376464188098907, -0.010906191542744637, 0.041039809584617615, 0.001393656712025404, 0.012890181504189968, -0.007217514328658581, 0.04340043291449547, 0.01986587978899479, -0.03056870400905609, -0.03372373431921005, 0.0243452750146389, 0.07775881886482239, 0.020156675949692726, 0.00667749485000968, -0.00037913909181952477, -0.009974226355552673, 0.005034029483795166, 0.06058221682906151, -0.03816331550478935, -0.041015151888132095, -0.033895835280418396, -0.006846715230494738, 0.052978429943323135, -0.01331512350589037 ]
<p>I am trying to perform a multiple regression in <code>R</code>. However, my dependent variable has the following plot:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/AMXDm.jpg" alt="DV"></p> <p>Here is a scatterplot matrix with all my variables (<code>WAR</code> is the dependent variable):</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/qKsGL.jpg" alt="SPLOM"></p> <p>I know that I need to perform a transformation on this variable (and possibly the independent variables?) but I am not sure of the exact transformation required. Can someone point me in the right direction? I am happy to provide any additional information about the relationship between the independent and dependent variables.</p> <p>The diagnostic graphics from my regression look as follows:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/sduyK.jpg" alt="Diagnostic plots"></p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong></p> <p>After transforming the dependent and independent variables using Yeo-Johnson transformations, the diagnostic plots look like this:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/6WZTC.jpg" alt="After transforming"></p> <p>If I use a GLM with a log-link, the diagnostic graphics are:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/SjfdK.jpg" alt="GLM with log-link"></p>
74,426
[ -0.03972046077251434, 0.0024464749731123447, 0.014950353652238846, -0.0015861504944041371, 0.04397601634263992, -0.02024601399898529, -0.04272378608584404, -0.005782643798738718, 0.03396448865532875, -0.03384261578321457, 0.04747138172388077, 0.03185047209262848, 0.06754419952630997, 0.001088446006178856, 0.038141824305057526, 0.004281006753444672, -0.026220496743917465, 0.045330584049224854, 0.01642817072570324, -0.01308431290090084, -0.010454608127474785, -0.017915336415171623, 0.0015959721058607101, 0.00944757740944624, -0.017904773354530334, 0.05868620425462723, -0.012747881934046745, 0.007479986175894737, 0.03548911213874817, 0.064276784658432, -0.018758663907647133, -0.014880095608532429, -0.013471774756908417, 0.033557794988155365, -0.011853944510221481, 0.0006780031835660338, -0.016763130202889442, -0.0012156966840848327, -0.011028020642697811, 0.024368902668356895, 0.002282966859638691, -0.00867669377475977, -0.005077661015093327, 0.05345714092254639, 0.00882825069129467, 0.019127534702420235, -0.009668602608144283, -0.0009253777679987252, 0.05691199377179146, -0.015197612345218658, 0.1236785277724266, -0.025976363569498062, 0.03476167097687721, 0.060189954936504364, -0.032860852777957916, -0.0071352394297719, 0.10054095089435577, 0.06598298251628876, -0.03205851465463638, -0.045665573328733444, -0.007276736665517092, -0.04429241642355919, 0.0008469216991215944, -0.01982886716723442, -0.02556351013481617, 0.0008228549268096685, -0.03128804266452789, -0.013855325058102608, 0.030898941680788994, -0.04567274823784828, 0.03090989589691162, 0.007794511970132589, 0.0474008247256279, -0.025519773364067078, 0.018570328131318092, -0.02408882975578308, 0.03794199228286743, 0.025303196161985397, 0.027112234383821487, 0.022294936701655388, 0.018395254388451576, 0.04815831035375595, -0.0004708707856480032, 0.018691426143050194, -0.012042579241096973, -0.0018996713915839791, 0.09681525826454163, -0.026145027950406075, 0.02570919692516327, 0.06207728758454323, -0.007887394167482853, 0.010539277456700802, 0.0602799728512764, 0.027684034779667854, -0.030027061700820923, 0.03419869765639305, -0.004348859190940857, 0.03178360313177109, -0.0060728928074240685, 0.004357062745839357, -0.02551211416721344, -0.03301553428173065, 0.00685387896373868, 0.002426558407023549, -0.02091715671122074, 0.005565990228205919, -0.019414901733398438, 0.001755335251800716, -0.01030644029378891, -0.07587385922670364, -0.010958248749375343, 0.02842586673796177, -0.017228230834007263, 0.005001801066100597, 0.004350184928625822, -0.0642649307847023, -0.0171443372964859, 0.024386370554566383, 0.0195552259683609, 0.03812326118350029, 0.04913708567619324, -0.01780744642019272, -0.005534999538213015, 0.003137522377073765, -0.05883915722370148, 0.026497678831219673, 0.017140815034508705, -0.006801017094403505, -0.05163363739848137, 0.04031175747513771, -0.0243377648293972, -0.038288846611976624, 0.027615142986178398, -0.005718839354813099, 0.025974871590733528, -0.042411573231220245, -0.08983226120471954, -0.02869829162955284, 0.01999448984861374, -0.02904312126338482, 0.03495538607239723, -0.07266663014888763, -0.023556673899292946, 0.024913307279348373, 0.04688946530222893, 0.002211289945989847, 0.03840202838182449, 0.037901218980550766, 0.044373687356710434, -0.014347108080983162, -0.010808155871927738, -0.019452892243862152, -0.0559823140501976, -0.04779813811182976, 0.016125893220305443, -0.07807555049657822, -0.016802659258246422, 0.03569028899073601, -0.028982529416680336, 0.03282906487584114, 0.06610929220914841, 0.01966371387243271, -0.028217418119311333, -0.0029429802671074867, -0.008309416472911835, -0.016513608396053314, 0.060960449278354645, -0.015713924542069435, 0.027333438396453857, 0.03617897257208824, -0.013213264755904675, 0.02548234350979328, 0.009031909517943859, 0.0901523157954216, 0.019363712519407272, -0.010295553132891655, -0.003046916564926505, -0.020494747906923294, 0.012367988005280495, -0.002688419306650758, -0.061362091451883316, -0.04658454656600952, -0.03500920161604881, -0.02811986394226551, 0.03819593787193298, 0.05869153141975403, -0.021756526082754135, -0.018271928653120995, 0.02942570112645626, -0.06846985220909119, -0.05587875470519066, -0.01974647305905819, 0.009423156268894672, -0.006983926985412836, -0.0018284699181094766, 0.0013653014320880175, 0.010391362011432648, 0.049339938908815384, 0.012817089445888996, -0.03863253816962242, 0.02294931560754776, -0.01736793853342533, 0.02175963670015335, -0.018175635486841202, -0.014030078426003456, 0.0032354514114558697, 0.05947871878743172, -0.05357910692691803, 0.0056849149987101555, -0.0659380853176117, 0.02045460045337677, 0.04987654462456703, -0.014526650309562683, 0.0017358058830723166, -0.036306604743003845, -0.006524710450321436, 0.0011791264405474067, 0.02001640945672989, -0.024160990491509438, 0.009769970551133156, -0.04070963338017464, 0.02615533024072647, 0.0723671242594719, -0.006163350306451321, -0.01812570169568062, 0.018422245979309082, 0.018807850778102875, 0.04852413758635521, -0.04095599800348282, -0.011522205546498299, -0.05590845271945, -0.016586175188422203, 0.03810020908713341, 0.020164847373962402, -0.019915619865059853, -0.00535372830927372, 0.056584715843200684, 0.025177765637636185, -0.022545617073774338, 0.0379909947514534, 0.010003384202718735, 0.0238706786185503, -0.013438835740089417, 0.036319341510534286, 0.020335279405117035, -0.008747261948883533, 0.007587091997265816, 0.0016373636899515986, 0.03632860258221626, -0.0016789541114121675, -0.05825461819767952, 0.060229428112506866, -0.001302457763813436, 0.008060014806687832, -0.0071409596130251884, -0.0031663216650485992, 0.05309160053730011, -0.03197302296757698, 0.004428238142281771, 0.06829559057950974, 0.023629477247595787, -0.03454188257455826, 0.027644911780953407, 0.025454657152295113, 0.007574498653411865, 0.0354808010160923, -0.0021559984888881445, 0.00229891249909997, -0.020907532423734665, -0.03288080543279648, 0.016908811405301094, -0.005318055860698223, -0.0038367526140064, -0.03157637640833855, 0.04772914573550224, 0.0009581721969880164, 0.010429879650473595, 0.003176836296916008, -0.025145703926682472, -0.06764284521341324, 0.016054842621088028, -0.02037915214896202, 0.017982082441449165, 0.0010105061810463667, -0.04121647775173187, 0.01376553438603878, -0.03782838210463524, 0.016359863802790642, 0.01796017400920391, -0.039757341146469116, -0.03475450724363327, -0.00509860971942544, -0.005886200815439224, -0.043554287403821945, -0.043696776032447815, -0.012068714946508408, 0.02238105610013008, -0.011194232851266861, 0.006761418655514717, 0.062126077711582184, 0.0061684115789830685, -0.03331590071320534, -0.020781757310032845, -0.04285309463739395, -0.008912748657166958, -0.019410904496908188, 0.0010722539154812694, 0.0017022425308823586, 0.016535501927137375, 0.030157586559653282, -0.005269758403301239, -0.040544260293245316, -0.031897906213998795, -0.06099042668938637, -0.07898082584142685, 0.041814301162958145, 0.048635561019182205, 0.013463655486702919, -0.006845236290246248, -0.06460118293762207, 0.06994138658046722, 0.02487208880484104, -0.03552916273474693, -0.09415362030267715, -0.02430059388279915, -0.004244683776050806, -0.05997878685593605, 0.03510972484946251, 0.013249378651380539, 0.049689725041389465, 0.0744161605834961, 0.01139903999865055, 0.04185894876718521, 0.03162510320544243, -0.017852336168289185, -0.009895667433738708, 0.012702686712145805, 0.002194260945543647, -0.0068251644261181355, 0.022057218477129936, 0.022098848596215248, -0.007123783230781555, 0.026671027764678, -0.007489005569368601, 0.005075139459222555, -0.0038702154997736216, -0.060251157730817795, 0.007413389626890421, 0.01805371232330799, 0.019093960523605347, -0.05691341683268547, 0.020857637748122215, 0.04265178367495537, -0.024924475699663162, -0.001976617146283388, 0.019795678555965424, 0.05023855343461037, -0.01845056191086769, 0.009706280194222927, 0.038966111838817596, 0.0035266007762402296, 0.02413167618215084, 0.009178053587675095, -0.010900048539042473, -0.042351532727479935, 0.033724356442689896, -0.01702520065009594, -0.02560361661016941, 0.03527091071009636, -0.005201939959079027, 0.027530530467629433, -0.005245622713118792, -0.03752182424068451, 0.04828863590955734, -0.04176359996199608, -0.0016262044664472342, -0.00448969379067421, 0.02887224592268467, 0.02685999684035778, 0.038059934973716736, 0.019975628703832626, 0.0037505270447582006, 0.010534366592764854, -0.012432009913027287, -0.037429578602313995, 0.030571311712265015, -0.007386236917227507, 0.02643144689500332, 0.040686026215553284, -0.00543152866885066, 0.02851039543747902, -0.02761000767350197, 0.010105282068252563, 0.03471897169947624, 0.016432642936706543, -0.040218889713287354, 0.025672154501080513, -0.013332098722457886, -0.0027507811319082975, -0.024632098153233528, 0.027153940871357918, 0.032173871994018555, -0.026873772963881493, -0.0006318688974715769, 0.057417720556259155, -0.01750902831554413, -0.016328508034348488, -0.020882878452539444, 0.01086011528968811, 0.04039968177676201, 0.06464820355176926, 0.019803019240498543, -0.0051420689560472965, -0.02375790849328041, 0.030598647892475128, -0.012734406627714634, -0.01063008513301611, 0.02971712499856949, -0.04018034785985947, -0.017883526161313057, -0.042107127606868744, 0.006660980172455311, 0.0042310720309615135, 0.02021026238799095, 0.022357596084475517, 0.033638376742601395, 0.049923330545425415, 0.03262041509151459, -0.03445678949356079, 0.043212682008743286, 0.0673827975988388, 0.01749182678759098, -0.00033560971496626735, 0.0076287491247057915, 0.01161391194909811, 0.020899301394820213, 0.007250509224832058, 0.011721363291144371, 0.007136677857488394, -0.010610552504658699, -0.01735742948949337, 0.04485560953617096, -0.02201135829091072, 0.010186959989368916, 0.01911039464175701, 0.01957310177385807, 0.0629192441701889, 0.006169792730361223, -0.02336389198899269, -0.02023337595164776, 0.03468632698059082, 0.025928542017936707, 0.017217764630913734, -0.031596265733242035, -0.0717301294207573, 0.02641003578901291, 0.039331745356321335, 0.029220206663012505, -0.044747378677129745, -0.01620066910982132, -0.003411862999200821, -0.011859065853059292, 0.018606945872306824, -0.05099698528647423, 0.03572860360145569, 0.023373713716864586, 0.03360474109649658, -0.008803262375295162, -0.05680891498923302, -0.057293642312288284, 0.025022808462381363, -0.021442534402012825, 0.02754199504852295, -0.029623735696077347, -0.02355307899415493, -0.02060908079147339, 0.016484186053276062, -0.0014939503744244576, 0.035106442868709564, -0.0007782276370562613, -0.030833862721920013, -0.006153438240289688, 0.020680591464042664, -0.04435053840279579, -0.03507404774427414, 0.021389668807387352, -0.006120661273598671, -0.016046611592173576, 0.06184845790266991, 0.004754616413265467, -0.031127477064728737, 0.010006244294345379, 0.03157350793480873, -0.003235554788261652, -0.020542211830615997, -0.00422475952655077, 0.0216167364269495, 0.03357990086078644, -0.025010548532009125, 0.05271824449300766, 0.01276249997317791, -0.0022162951063364744, -0.004461678210645914, -0.036487504839897156, 0.014365383423864841, -0.0394059456884861, -0.03375454992055893, -0.01080916915088892, 0.020393768325448036, -0.008214366622269154, 0.01343032717704773, -0.03471818193793297, 0.012575840577483177, -0.055054906755685806, 0.007867689244449139, 0.018126167356967926, 0.011946920305490494, -0.012853720225393772, -0.006571340374648571, 0.035557787865400314, 0.013620645739138126, -0.018770160153508186, -0.04055165871977806, 0.005124927032738924, -0.0424177385866642, -0.007801123894751072, 0.024668604135513306, -0.035513173788785934, 0.02934553101658821, 0.009468971751630306, -0.007503686007112265, -0.011427360586822033, -0.05019458383321762, 0.007076445966959, -0.01357063464820385, 0.03843878209590912, 0.027044089511036873, -0.04439718276262283, 0.0023818272165954113, -0.009678037837147713, 0.001738742575980723, 0.008719846606254578, -0.012417775578796864, 0.009161434136331081, -0.0043301391415297985, 0.0013958967756479979, -0.03755723312497139, -0.06977467983961105, 0.017651990056037903, -0.016468936577439308, -0.012966071255505085, -0.020486915484070778, -0.03930625319480896, -0.041288554668426514, -0.00982901081442833, -0.005158137064427137, 0.032090604305267334, -0.04641643539071083, -0.037167008966207504, -0.005249590612947941, 0.025703242048621178, 0.06579176336526871, 0.004269231576472521, 0.02729947119951248, -0.010123666375875473, -0.0018257728079333901, -0.04172791168093681, 0.0292897317558527, 0.002902753185480833, -0.008080401457846165, -0.02846539206802845, -0.05157598480582237, 0.0050906166434288025, 0.02361731417477131, -0.025888999924063683, -0.011409030295908451, 0.0005308094550855458, 0.0429193377494812, 0.011808192357420921, -0.0030428566969931126, 0.000271910015726462, -0.01814029924571514, 0.004175824113190174, -0.013996320776641369, 0.01590432971715927, -0.01760900393128395, -0.026103224605321884, 0.03554074466228485, 0.0002805072581395507, 0.003973759710788727, 0.027952145785093307, 0.07492805272340775, 0.006462708581238985, -0.0018441908759996295, 0.009665355086326599, -0.024983461946249008, -0.009129675105214119, 0.0023451228626072407, 0.024526741355657578, -0.006842703092843294, 0.010904217138886452, -0.050932105630636215, -0.032403454184532166, -0.046038780361413956, -0.003235738491639495, 0.04523545131087303, -0.048110369592905045, 0.027514129877090454, 0.0531717911362648, -0.0082738371565938, 0.015334910713136196, -0.05412774533033371, -0.008885039016604424, 0.017078274860978127, 0.0026767756789922714, 0.05324616655707359, -0.014250697568058968, -0.029536468908190727, 0.00826384499669075, 0.05600201338529587, 0.017335133627057076, 0.04267982020974159, -0.003206593217328191, -0.010233004577457905, -0.001218099845573306, -0.02045445889234543, -0.056264687329530716, 0.040533676743507385, -0.008550738915801048, 0.05164589732885361, -0.017379963770508766, -0.028665710240602493, 0.03135032579302788, 0.06262270361185074, -0.010220145806670189, -0.030593188479542732, -0.04129744693636894, -0.04353952035307884, -0.0002520381531212479, 0.0319451242685318, -0.006599452346563339, -0.004528407007455826, 0.03339953348040581, 0.05734028294682503, -0.01838105171918869, 0.019880857318639755, -0.042867645621299744, -0.07006004452705383, -0.015082201920449734, -0.023761112242937088, -0.008107051253318787, 0.03537100926041603, -0.034535907208919525, -0.026316283270716667, -0.010450292378664017, -0.0412757582962513, -0.017884783446788788, 0.0015590961556881666, 0.05941326543688774, 0.038900889456272125, 0.07520003616809845, 0.008997543714940548, -0.012568686157464981, -0.018514081835746765, -0.030732570216059685, 0.1193288192152977, 0.07632274925708771, 0.03480065241456032, -0.08538225293159485, -0.008415217511355877, -0.00331631931476295, 0.011691226623952389, -0.025769410654902458, -0.004969430156052113, -0.00788027048110962, -0.010286114178597927, 0.024851975962519646, 0.06667998433113098, 0.009704343974590302, -0.014200858771800995, 0.05318301171064377, -0.013618780300021172, -0.0047902800142765045, -0.00013996954658068717, -0.006426126230508089, -0.04443584010004997, -0.007469067815691233, -0.06956682354211807, -0.008753187954425812, 0.00585809163749218, -0.02613922208547592, -0.012891006655991077, -0.012981957755982876, 0.003913580439984798, 0.014223035424947739, -0.010097943246364594, 0.0007034219452179968, 0.04491763189435005, 0.02239169552922249, -0.012576154433190823, 0.014839141629636288, 0.019783953204751015, -0.02398965321481228, 0.017594151198863983, 0.05266517773270607, 0.020651157945394516, 0.002480067079886794, 0.022364743053913116, -0.030045486986637115, -0.027449842542409897, -0.028308289125561714, -0.004182733595371246, 0.04236889258027077, -0.008855480700731277, -0.008654334582388401, -0.03947124630212784, -0.0035607756581157446, -0.010539176873862743, -0.05568018555641174, -0.008284296840429306, 0.03720587119460106, 0.037723835557699203, -0.02637946419417858, -0.020293336361646652, -0.025549205020070076, -0.012919912114739418, 0.01893394999206066, 0.06414248794317245, 0.04069185629487038, 0.001550458138808608, -0.013218341395258904, -0.045842066407203674, 0.04352342337369919, -0.019056759774684906, 0.011161033064126968, 0.010154020972549915, -0.029234668239951134, 0.0011097780661657453, -0.03704297915101051, 0.03560730069875717, 0.010630880482494831, 0.02542608231306076, 0.00291937543079257, 0.01224423386156559, -0.013611763715744019, -0.05129115656018257, -0.004237663466483355, -0.018970437347888947, -0.017039215192198753, -0.041872601956129074, -0.004533783532679081, 0.02783530205488205, 0.05543292686343193, 0.009643158875405788, 0.0018220115453004837, -0.03954026848077774, 0.027941305190324783, 0.005839430261403322, -0.06607574224472046, -0.018189435824751854, 0.030825233086943626, -0.01784181408584118, -0.05153248459100723, -0.02818586863577366, 0.08869528770446777, 0.024240586906671524, 0.0283295176923275, -0.0078627560287714, 0.051216740161180496, -0.009483550675213337, 0.00480576790869236, 0.03593927621841431, -0.028198646381497383, 0.02978731505572796, -0.00481219170615077, -0.040466438978910446, -0.004859603010118008, 0.007202445063740015, -0.029387319460511208, -0.04659011960029602, 0.041900161653757095, -0.022328242659568787, -0.024980392307043076, 0.01497657410800457, -0.04095413535833359, 0.05318964272737503, -0.02764132060110569, 0.008275633677840233, -0.05034392699599266, 0.0014707299415022135, 0.009207867085933685, -0.049824997782707214, -0.0023537937086075544, 0.016332417726516724, -0.011340519413352013, 0.021569252014160156, 0.06261949986219406, 0.035360563546419144, 0.026722775772213936, -0.011215541511774063, -0.007625377271324396, 0.00848898384720087, 0.028490345925092697, -0.016023581847548485, -0.014898027293384075, 0.0011231948155909777, -0.03172493353486061, 0.03073693998157978, 0.028032934293150902, 0.012846988625824451, 0.031341303139925, 0.01736358180642128, -0.005379115231335163, -0.06141461804509163, 0.051335107535123825, -0.008957235142588615, 0.01078273355960846, -0.011335906572639942, -0.01287844404578209, 0.007531438488513231, 0.01243016216903925, 0.010144347324967384, 0.008297950960695744, -0.007687766570597887, 0.03896968439221382, 0.044717367738485336, 0.014578352682292461, 0.005082925781607628, 0.0038420327473431826, 0.01161431334912777, 0.022006070241332054, -0.011682959273457527, 0.0022926561068743467, 0.044804107397794724, 0.04018818214535713, -0.009964624419808388, -0.002427141647785902, -0.0008744769729673862, 0.05378199368715286, -0.07846233993768692, -0.014003974385559559, -0.013978228904306889, 0.02158871665596962, 0.054049331694841385, -0.07571683824062347, 0.0005495689692907035, 0.0349765308201313, -0.047985151410102844, -0.05476053059101105, -0.009938575327396393, -0.02379431016743183, -0.011857427656650543, -0.005981100257486105, 0.021186187863349915, 0.02562413178384304, 0.05659515783190727, 0.015740573406219482, 0.027090322226285934, 0.01947120577096939, -0.005597345065325499, -0.005605330225080252, -0.034855812788009644, -0.011567742563784122, 0.03147983178496361, -0.04765988513827324, 0.025561677291989326, -0.020471302792429924, -0.01944536343216896, 0.028769057244062424, -0.005897089373320341, 0.04896753281354904, 0.020610934123396873, 0.013077948242425919, 0.02870306558907032, 0.053430285304784775, -0.007134063169360161, -0.021438339725136757, 0.003991434816271067, 0.004141027573496103, -0.010532274842262268, 0.0008842958486638963, -0.016651669517159462, 0.007196484133601189, -0.010784067213535309, -0.045141708105802536, -0.02257353439927101, -0.011308620683848858, -0.020378660410642624, 0.009251026436686516, -0.0023738141171634197, 0.019845671951770782, 0.0035629598423838615, -0.010615518316626549, 0.013242430053651333, -0.05464561656117439, -0.021579572930932045, 0.04648812115192413, -0.0018490016227588058, -0.013733875937759876, 0.007180158048868179, -0.007296167779713869, -0.02574102021753788, -0.010607724077999592, -0.01396268978714943, -0.031437553465366364, -0.06536559015512466, 0.010013717226684093, -0.037643589079380035, -0.025644468143582344, -0.01551462896168232, 0.02235916443169117, -0.022542662918567657, 0.04939946159720421, -0.009454836137592793, 0.019352613016963005, 0.026722116395831108, -0.02915327250957489, 0.012119664810597897, -0.033449266105890274, 0.04470101743936539, 0.0335264652967453, -0.05155755952000618, -0.04653491452336311, -0.026501644402742386, -0.030889684334397316, 0.021558083593845367, 0.03702414780855179, -0.013117142952978611, 0.013000314123928547, -0.039844635874032974, 0.018169036135077477, -0.009735357947647572, -0.031202390789985657, 0.022063666954636574, 0.0013090693391859531, -0.008056032471358776, 0.009228358045220375, -0.023590534925460815, 0.004708015359938145, 0.020183509215712547, 0.010854541324079037, -0.04088683798909187, -0.03099737875163555, 0.011863591149449348, -0.03355061262845993, -0.022503674030303955, -0.0021318807266652584, -0.042029969394207, 0.026725953444838524, 0.011027541942894459, -0.006643062457442284, 0.06688802689313889, 0.028850384056568146, -0.03787057474255562, 0.03233532980084419, -0.03714830428361893, -0.005525540094822645, 0.02159963920712471, 0.003171611577272415, 0.006375737953931093, -0.05064401775598526, 0.029514465481042862, -0.01158618088811636, -0.007240825332701206, -0.02679581567645073, 0.04017942398786545, 0.01717742718756199, 0.013214215636253357, -0.011593629606068134, 0.007339558098465204, -0.0034610864240676165, -0.010643620043992996, 0.03416084125638008, 0.014952278696000576, 0.003075974527746439, 0.05443382263183594, -0.05250117555260658, 0.030073368921875954, 0.001360652269795537, 0.048269663006067276, -0.011912578716874123, 0.027174094691872597, -0.030227962881326675, -0.0032504673581570387, 0.020465334877371788, -0.018831193447113037, 0.01604597456753254, -0.007691643200814724, -0.026073787361383438, 0.004643137101083994, -0.03434376046061516, 0.0019297541584819555, -0.00734978960826993, -0.023470383137464523, -0.01618972048163414, 0.041242845356464386, 0.012449480593204498, 0.015125018544495106, -0.010716947726905346, 0.031117761507630348, 0.008675428107380867, -0.04492836818099022, -0.012966802343726158, 0.004209619946777821, -0.0013614236377179623, -0.03458913043141365, -0.027738643810153008, 0.016063213348388672, -0.012386945076286793, -0.03078112006187439, -0.009865103289484978, 0.006467193365097046, 0.034068625420331955, -0.010053830221295357, -0.07522888481616974, -0.038158319890499115, -0.021759698167443275, 0.048255037516355515, -0.06830637156963348, -0.04092373698949814, -0.01894449256360531, 0.02168183960020542, 0.04467551037669182, -0.025630632415413857 ]
<p>I recently did some experimenting comparing some common method of internal validation. In my field, the use of a single 1:1 holdout validation is extremely common, even with very small datasets, and I wanted to show my colleagues that there might sometimes be alternatives.</p> <p>I had a large dataset of approx 30,000 observations. I took 1,000 at random, fitted a model, and then performed the 4 methods of internal validation below to estimate the error. I compared this against the 'true' rate of error from the remaining 29,000 observations. I repeated this whole process 500 times, each time re-sampling 1,000 observations and re-fitting the model etc. The model was an OLS regression with 10 variables.</p> <p>The results were largely as I had expected: the resubstitution error was optimistically biased, bias and variance in the bootstrap and cross-validation methods was low, and the variance of the single holdout validation method was very high; what I hadn't expected (and what I am at a loss to explain) is the bias I observe in the holdout method. I had assumed it would be high variance, but with low bias. Has anyone else seen this kind of behaviour? Or is it perhaps a consequence of my experimental design?</p> <p><strong>Clockwise from top left: optimism-corrected bootstrap, resubstitution error, 10-fold CV, single 1:1 holdout</strong><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/PdVzd.png" alt="Results"></p> <p>I should note, I'm not concerned here about model selection here - the model had been previously published, and I'm just interested in how it performs when applied to my data.</p>
74,427
[ -0.037614233791828156, 0.015468152239918709, -0.009408416226506233, -0.015507645905017853, 0.029537582769989967, 0.021491115912795067, -0.013013599440455437, -0.0064953588880598545, 0.0050495946779847145, -0.020007723942399025, 0.027861090376973152, 0.05691537633538246, 0.06775251775979996, -0.0055828215554356575, -0.007767567876726389, -0.0009634672896936536, 0.03702300414443016, 0.004295684397220612, 0.015099317766726017, -0.029429974034428596, -0.016573457047343254, 0.019946372136473656, -0.003950898535549641, -0.022184068337082863, 0.0018801480764523149, 0.007559545338153839, 0.03472130000591278, 0.004325476009398699, 0.02786114253103733, 0.024010825902223587, -0.038927651941776276, -0.00703476183116436, -0.029994366690516472, 0.04741990938782692, 0.006415678653866053, 0.004090214613825083, 0.03978729620575905, -0.08765610307455063, 0.006877860985696316, 0.0621609203517437, -0.046753209084272385, 0.00924359168857336, -0.04375631362199783, 0.04310224950313568, 0.021589497104287148, 0.02683398686349392, 0.011612468399107456, 0.0013887881068512797, 0.07183288782835007, -0.021561533212661743, 0.030536936596035957, -0.007399978581815958, 0.04583451524376869, 0.06728006899356842, -0.02075611613690853, 0.02377617172896862, 0.023808445781469345, 0.05122750997543335, -0.008605950511991978, -0.04312542453408241, -0.0012433339143171906, -0.044563744217157364, -0.0010310058714821935, 0.030971849337220192, -0.004154650494456291, 0.030469076707959175, 0.026778973639011383, -0.05801086127758026, 0.04181007668375969, -0.006128606852144003, 0.022183047607541084, 0.01364942267537117, 0.021139919757843018, -0.010816230438649654, 0.023592254146933556, 0.003832347923889756, -0.007902641780674458, 0.019317856058478355, 0.0519087053835392, 0.05193087086081505, -0.011326952837407589, -0.018877634778618813, -0.011080175638198853, 0.03821549564599991, 0.017659716308116913, -0.01601150818169117, 0.08270394802093506, -0.03661533072590828, 0.024612275883555412, 0.013448890298604965, -0.049218326807022095, 0.009419442154467106, 0.035956010222435, 0.0018350286409258842, -0.04611638933420181, 0.05982179939746857, 0.004098685458302498, 0.03643473610281944, -0.027881436049938202, -0.002647110726684332, 0.002312555443495512, -0.010065771639347076, 0.006875456310808659, 0.07020632177591324, -0.0011028427397832274, -0.019297050312161446, -0.0005021454417146742, 0.011325417086482048, -0.003985815681517124, -0.03140592575073242, -0.012914695776998997, 0.0219540037214756, 0.003947317134588957, 0.015154842287302017, 0.020992310717701912, -0.014179270714521408, -0.008064334280788898, -0.019600946456193924, 0.057380639016628265, 0.021585773676633835, 0.02757665328681469, -0.008574123494327068, -0.00769778760150075, -0.01906878687441349, -0.031533610075712204, 0.009961550123989582, 0.04225612059235573, -0.013030926696956158, -0.04240770265460014, 0.0794706866145134, 0.023586265742778778, -0.062495093792676926, 0.042482826858758926, -0.001877256203442812, 0.04148632660508156, 0.03732616454362869, -0.08683719485998154, -0.09908980876207352, 0.04326567426323891, -0.0033961860463023186, 0.024653039872646332, -0.03871379792690277, -0.006531083025038242, 0.021869828924536705, 0.07438886910676956, 0.009178911335766315, 0.022718282416462898, 0.006920079234987497, 0.02131948247551918, 0.03282133862376213, -0.029286319389939308, -0.015829626470804214, -0.01003222819417715, 0.019989974796772003, -0.05200083926320076, -0.08277738094329834, 0.017041098326444626, -0.008934253826737404, 0.012064200825989246, -0.004815463442355394, 0.009617496281862259, -0.01289052702486515, -0.0119094867259264, -0.01391408871859312, 0.023422395810484886, -0.05166736617684364, 0.06624792516231537, -0.025757547467947006, 0.03673310577869415, 0.025540748611092567, -0.025183817371726036, -0.004551462363451719, 0.023641452193260193, 0.004978975281119347, 0.02448265813291073, -0.027830880135297775, 0.03151809051632881, -0.03497975319623947, 0.014821766875684261, 0.0005948769394308329, -0.027385370805859566, 0.023439854383468628, -0.01895727403461933, -0.02231728844344616, 0.0031355915125459433, 0.026759523898363113, -0.0047665927559137344, -0.016288425773382187, 0.047003354877233505, -0.0689346119761467, -0.04235948994755745, -0.04932596534490585, 0.018429353833198547, 0.0011571430368348956, 0.024476610124111176, 0.017028093338012695, 0.00706252409145236, -0.007209008559584618, -0.0012515356065705419, -0.026606913655996323, -0.03147415816783905, -0.02092045545578003, 0.03571150824427605, -0.029992079362273216, 0.015306630171835423, 0.010064356960356236, 0.0062423767521977425, -0.041699931025505066, 0.02636595256626606, 0.00093746097991243, -0.05002046376466751, 0.006933718454092741, -0.048774149268865585, 0.018815400078892708, -0.012836214154958725, -0.03370969370007515, 0.006471986882388592, 0.009171053767204285, -0.012270955368876457, 0.04509188234806061, -0.012440364807844162, 0.051610298454761505, 0.03409293293952942, 0.0032883062958717346, -0.028680965304374695, 0.0500158965587616, 0.017472926527261734, 0.009508907794952393, -0.03358520194888115, -0.006605678237974644, -0.03523748368024826, -0.037418048828840256, 0.0433262437582016, 0.011143416166305542, -0.00995364785194397, -0.0009806457674130797, 0.05239159241318703, 0.017085786908864975, 0.03490016236901283, 0.00003319067764095962, 0.0037266185972839594, -0.054872315376996994, 0.01711352728307247, 0.0321049802005291, 0.05084310472011566, 0.042284462600946426, -0.009373024106025696, -0.019099900498986244, 0.031504545360803604, 0.03626801446080208, 0.030632294714450836, -0.000321223953505978, -0.0017010103911161423, -0.026271168142557144, -0.025365134701132774, -0.021479617804288864, 0.014666760340332985, -0.03307101130485535, -0.010683974251151085, 0.037620048969984055, 0.0009856696706265211, 0.02497434802353382, -0.039914630353450775, 0.016806388273835182, 0.037864357233047485, 0.0258394293487072, -0.03297866880893707, 0.00953570194542408, 0.0168642308562994, -0.0210561640560627, -0.003086188342422247, -0.06715340912342072, -0.02698179893195629, -0.016211802139878273, 0.024073226377367973, 0.018045062199234962, 0.0010241514537483454, 0.043735794723033905, -0.05091771110892296, -0.00957325380295515, -0.025815589353442192, -0.021429596468806267, 0.046872928738594055, -0.004885989706963301, -0.014932604506611824, -0.0038468700367957354, -0.017046933993697166, -0.020008224993944168, 0.02732834964990616, 0.007849641144275665, -0.03543093055486679, 0.012903723865747452, 0.004780672490596771, -0.0331590473651886, -0.04587507247924805, -0.026513822376728058, -0.01076122373342514, -0.004841011483222246, -0.05995911359786987, 0.04910273104906082, 0.0314384400844574, -0.045948613435029984, 0.02383890189230442, -0.005544934421777725, -0.022650718688964844, -0.010876104235649109, 0.0032671496737748384, -0.02719711698591709, -0.008929049596190453, 0.008992500603199005, 0.011685915291309357, -0.002811787184327841, -0.01653824746608734, -0.07639180123806, -0.06424729526042938, -0.0026814485900104046, -0.020658962428569794, 0.030186127871274948, -0.005828886292874813, 0.01062759105116129, 0.09039731323719025, 0.03918037563562393, 0.022182811051607132, -0.03398987650871277, 0.03040296956896782, -0.05269782245159149, -0.012515885755419731, -0.004121900070458651, -0.013758014887571335, 0.013623684644699097, 0.04756961390376091, -0.0474214069545269, 0.008408769965171814, 0.027661867439746857, -0.01894955337047577, -0.00698763458058238, 0.0024082628078758717, -0.03668312728404999, -0.020616671070456505, 0.03259972482919693, 0.019450977444648743, -0.007162525784224272, -0.013783665373921394, -0.0010235710069537163, 0.048072658479213715, 0.023228049278259277, -0.06353079527616501, 0.02832936868071556, -0.00522852735593915, 0.032046832144260406, -0.039768557995557785, 0.011210034601390362, -0.0029621999710798264, -0.025390177965164185, -0.022283237427473068, 0.011919999495148659, 0.04617289453744888, -0.022116029635071754, 0.027178805321455002, 0.008509990759193897, 0.03088291361927986, 0.03187565505504608, -0.026741182431578636, -0.026819996535778046, -0.010908817872405052, 0.04881608858704567, -0.01963210664689541, -0.03779926151037216, 0.040907055139541626, 0.02916891500353813, 0.008771191351115704, -0.015274731442332268, -0.04930759593844414, 0.01318174134939909, -0.04496260732412338, 0.019214434549212456, -0.008081545121967793, 0.021551385521888733, 0.02446344681084156, 0.025388266891241074, -0.007548329886049032, -0.024525729939341545, -0.020166750997304916, 0.019934257492423058, -0.07164325565099716, 0.009573934599757195, -0.027812190353870392, 0.0005178069695830345, -0.006058379076421261, -0.0005387336714193225, 0.04330786317586899, -0.02357126958668232, 0.01858261600136757, -0.014977657236158848, 0.039346806704998016, -0.02381717972457409, 0.01174138393253088, -0.02917114831507206, 0.006329494994133711, -0.021693790331482887, -0.012332129292190075, 0.005945916753262281, -0.017442910000681877, 0.010485111735761166, 0.007642905227839947, -0.007565752603113651, -0.012155293487012386, -0.05715217813849449, 0.016953151673078537, 0.03392428904771805, 0.031120436266064644, 0.03375730291008949, 0.042787592858076096, -0.05573209002614021, 0.006450963206589222, 0.01414480246603489, 0.030031263828277588, 0.060258302837610245, 0.044285353273153305, -0.013257193379104137, -0.04259730130434036, -0.004086163826286793, 0.011877191253006458, -0.019727861508727074, -0.0029732733964920044, -0.01857724040746689, 0.07484409213066101, 0.013353493064641953, -0.05118674784898758, -0.02584536373615265, 0.035613104701042175, 0.02900715544819832, -0.01173641812056303, -0.00043346418533474207, -0.003117968561127782, 0.00151057040784508, 0.01403947826474905, 0.012549282051622868, -0.0016509696142747998, -0.02911248803138733, -0.024428851902484894, 0.06450232118368149, -0.02620813623070717, -0.02473093569278717, 0.009639468975365162, -0.03318236023187637, 0.05025038868188858, 0.0010527485283091664, 0.021326160058379173, 0.053016599267721176, 0.03903387486934662, 0.053755953907966614, 0.03669164702296257, 0.002359791425988078, -0.07551266252994537, 0.00277488655410707, 0.04027433693408966, 0.03050260618329048, -0.02981993556022644, 0.002865827875211835, -0.03561031073331833, -0.01327031571418047, 0.054553259164094925, -0.06777580827474594, 0.034178491681814194, 0.023173481225967407, 0.004695223178714514, -0.031828783452510834, -0.013035077601671219, -0.033573683351278305, -0.02412964031100273, -0.01551278680562973, 0.017048636451363564, -0.011175760067999363, -0.023147771134972572, -0.03780053183436394, 0.02296179160475731, -0.016862163320183754, 0.006314846221357584, -0.03748476505279541, -0.012958243489265442, 0.0024465916212648153, 0.005483387969434261, -0.017153246328234673, -0.06751234084367752, -0.0023774155415594578, 0.017210857942700386, -0.013861468061804771, 0.027390480041503906, -0.006398361641913652, -0.05230140686035156, -0.013380680233240128, -0.018848301842808723, -0.03268687427043915, -0.03050261363387108, -0.029504166916012764, 0.013726012781262398, 0.01601685769855976, -0.008142541162669659, 0.07095762342214584, 0.06760632246732712, 0.0017677051946520805, -0.0119943767786026, -0.021599173545837402, -0.011718068271875381, -0.04776372015476227, -0.06975307315587997, -0.030008262023329735, -0.011302446946501732, -0.03406082093715668, 0.028053222224116325, 0.04802965000271797, 0.04758281260728836, -0.0023401351645588875, -0.014796268194913864, -0.002496902598068118, 0.033365581184625626, -0.012251189909875393, 0.016927966848015785, -0.0022791449446231127, 0.02332763560116291, -0.037914443761110306, 0.006411214824765921, -0.01960015669465065, -0.04163767769932747, -0.02328333631157875, 0.020099546760320663, -0.057160958647727966, -0.00047405442455783486, -0.033157654106616974, -0.018591124564409256, 0.02061915025115013, -0.030157197266817093, 0.025800831615924835, -0.011017024517059326, 0.0394541472196579, -0.03474542126059532, -0.028594989329576492, 0.0014444964472204447, 0.023765992373228073, 0.001195437042042613, 0.03476330637931824, 0.0021239491179585457, 0.017517955973744392, -0.015194161795079708, 0.005703114904463291, -0.06405904144048691, -0.05157866328954697, 0.02530701644718647, 0.034713756293058395, -0.0439947247505188, -0.02161163091659546, -0.019826097413897514, 0.015850387513637543, -0.03379522264003754, -0.03070307895541191, 0.056296199560165405, -0.039880961179733276, -0.002656857715919614, -0.010223086923360825, 0.03801124170422554, 0.04525037109851837, -0.026895197108387947, 0.013440223410725594, 0.011789968237280846, -0.035065583884716034, 0.011280565522611141, 0.03278036415576935, -0.0031642906833440065, -0.04080960899591446, -0.029692577198147774, -0.05842931568622589, 0.015396433882415295, 0.031069690361618996, -0.0038387503009289503, -0.006978682707995176, 0.0562954880297184, -0.030431699007749557, 0.011433487758040428, 0.02021132782101631, -0.017031237483024597, -0.0519879087805748, -0.014757324941456318, 0.015529134310781956, 0.009590016677975655, 0.0015758189838379622, -0.03381175547838211, 0.04203741252422333, 0.005242335144430399, -0.049488987773656845, 0.001569497981108725, 0.07428174465894699, -0.03671342134475708, 0.005697076208889484, -0.017130950465798378, -0.05532608553767204, 0.026526333764195442, 0.020090539008378983, 0.012387936003506184, 0.021927393972873688, 0.02722371742129326, -0.02847074717283249, -0.04001271724700928, 0.011968657374382019, 0.022678742185235023, 0.038929205387830734, -0.022199807688593864, 0.035421837121248245, 0.048585452139377594, -0.01744343340396881, -0.02574041672050953, -0.01151295006275177, 0.0024634934961795807, -0.004824908450245857, -0.0044439807534217834, 0.06820501387119293, 0.008613800629973412, -0.011601586826145649, 0.04372808337211609, 0.025656135752797127, 0.048062726855278015, 0.020352888852357864, 0.004663115367293358, 0.05012299120426178, 0.021156543865799904, -0.024934349581599236, -0.007161163724958897, 0.05536133050918579, -0.048128485679626465, 0.01226123794913292, 0.011950455605983734, -0.01749804988503456, 0.017115488648414612, 0.015836795791983604, 0.02971617504954338, -0.022056160494685173, -0.01269854512065649, -0.04245602339506149, 0.022119585424661636, -0.002765959594398737, -0.008328011259436607, 0.02145693637430668, -0.018918797373771667, -0.0005619936273433268, 0.03857804834842682, 0.02729281224310398, -0.057784952223300934, -0.05698390305042267, -0.013529055751860142, 0.011307663284242153, -0.007552134804427624, 0.023171214386820793, 0.020784953609108925, -0.006080940365791321, 0.010897057130932808, -0.03316175192594528, 0.000683467835187912, 0.006982844322919846, 0.021065881475806236, -0.018145833164453506, 0.015901882201433182, 0.01445440761744976, 0.014881659299135208, -0.03586994856595993, -0.045601122081279755, 0.15671002864837646, 0.09458412975072861, 0.039749979972839355, -0.026960469782352448, 0.03657356649637222, -0.019082624465227127, 0.007385325152426958, -0.026015490293502808, 0.023852242156863213, 0.033791761845350266, -0.0131106898188591, 0.014758259057998657, 0.05985938757658005, -0.005676543805748224, -0.02518528141081333, 0.05791938677430153, 0.0011419971706345677, -0.017777210101485252, 0.02702593430876732, -0.018889015540480614, 0.014258967712521553, -0.07427065074443817, 0.016217345371842384, 0.00011800145875895396, 0.004587108269333839, -0.039948537945747375, -0.019448403269052505, -0.011566135101020336, 0.013929500244557858, 0.0020943263079971075, 0.005875019822269678, -0.004429535940289497, -0.009628655388951302, 0.020944394171237946, -0.006407582201063633, -0.0009168752003461123, 0.006700260564684868, -0.003035305766388774, 0.04216344654560089, 0.054806794971227646, -0.0033352014143019915, 0.016410820186138153, -0.019712604582309723, 0.00907844677567482, -0.024067264050245285, -0.04045524820685387, -0.042232122272253036, 0.0642300397157669, -0.020391231402754784, 0.025345832109451294, -0.04046209156513214, -0.007555931340903044, 0.02446097508072853, -0.009684370830655098, -0.0073986048810184, 0.008196299895644188, -0.016910705715417862, -0.02323623187839985, -0.043140772730112076, -0.039411645382642746, -0.0222441628575325, 0.022380834445357323, -0.0039435094222426414, -0.01544100046157837, -0.049272697418928146, -0.024019861593842506, 0.0067583476193249226, 0.030402492731809616, 0.018217720091342926, 0.00501154875382781, -0.011889238841831684, 0.008232352323830128, -0.0285932719707489, -0.018275192007422447, 0.026864873245358467, -0.018632370978593826, 0.03241459280252457, -0.010314458049833775, 0.016584845259785652, -0.04008735343813896, -0.03135102242231369, -0.023557761684060097, -0.0270109660923481, 0.011255497112870216, -0.03516305983066559, -0.043016936630010605, -0.004997377749532461, -0.0024996392894536257, 0.02361423522233963, 0.016947509720921516, 0.004487515427172184, 0.05141592025756836, -0.05206167325377464, -0.07072833180427551, -0.049916308373212814, -0.029327327385544777, -0.06425129622220993, -0.00564066506922245, -0.017759008333086967, 0.05564725399017334, -0.006965610198676586, 0.03776714578270912, 0.008044425398111343, 0.042826272547245026, 0.010745702311396599, 0.009538043290376663, 0.06279997527599335, -0.0614657886326313, -0.016929354518651962, 0.02780754864215851, -0.01987750269472599, -0.014432490803301334, -0.03655155003070831, -0.015701521188020706, -0.011758788488805294, -0.013168870471417904, -0.0012271585874259472, -0.04252621531486511, -0.022545021027326584, 0.012534127570688725, 0.03146966174244881, -0.00009527212387183681, -0.011978011578321457, -0.05511648207902908, -0.030020924285054207, -0.03777815401554108, -0.009152933955192566, 0.023834174498915672, -0.037903234362602234, 0.011039651930332184, 0.011700328439474106, 0.0517892986536026, -0.00751221040263772, 0.011967928148806095, -0.005721257068216801, -0.006806662771850824, 0.04506409168243408, 0.04051797837018967, -0.06482803076505661, -0.03030947409570217, 0.03685814514756203, -0.013029089197516441, -0.06807070970535278, 0.009754435159265995, 0.002911137882620096, 0.03340502828359604, 0.010104908607900143, 0.014790687710046768, -0.004033609293401241, 0.053920481353998184, -0.018623480573296547, 0.00005371416773414239, -0.003005104837939143, 0.007045247126370668, 0.028131544589996338, -0.005145075730979443, -0.012788565829396248, 0.03354014456272125, 0.011088341474533081, 0.07624038308858871, 0.016301630064845085, -0.0029453206807374954, -0.0146050238981843, -0.02251223288476467, -0.030051693320274353, -0.004365306347608566, -0.0030291383154690266, -0.0025525365490466356, -0.03316408395767212, 0.03575555235147476, -0.04721635952591896, 0.03303155675530434, 0.03527647256851196, 0.034958843141794205, -0.07408256828784943, -0.020506344735622406, -0.0025864108465611935, 0.05618409812450409, -0.008357768878340721, -0.022582337260246277, 0.025614796206355095, 0.04455685243010521, -0.028772471472620964, -0.006080008577555418, -0.017538512125611305, -0.002509320853278041, -0.025769853964447975, -0.016172442585229874, -0.013562005013227463, 0.004672351758927107, 0.020055295899510384, -0.031997691839933395, -0.009361776523292065, 0.029618224129080772, 0.017855066806077957, -0.011201266199350357, -0.020011475309729576, 0.04625459015369415, -0.008902672678232193, -0.028425946831703186, 0.02053239196538925, -0.061570897698402405, -0.016193369403481483, 0.027123741805553436, -0.012578312307596207, -0.001389531185850501, 0.021291552111506462, 0.05330198258161545, -0.03511398658156395, 0.058031581342220306, 0.08032143115997314, 0.026213012635707855, -0.0029076957143843174, -0.0008382399682886899, 0.04382659122347832, 0.03982897847890854, 0.001908821170218289, 0.015987498685717583, 0.031925592571496964, -0.013647699728608131, 0.00285396259278059, 0.03710360452532768, 0.0020052038598805666, 0.01045677624642849, -0.009559744969010353, 0.015151004306972027, 0.00414646090939641, -0.013390940614044666, -0.0012187834363430738, -0.03898593410849571, 0.004058486316353083, 0.056586652994155884, 0.021650513634085655, -0.04020485281944275, 0.021212594583630562, -0.014370529912412167, -0.01890537515282631, 0.015623892657458782, -0.01613023318350315, -0.005197803024202585, -0.057120565325021744, -0.004456421360373497, 0.027459753677248955, -0.022862661629915237, -0.00034174794564023614, 0.0014975324738770723, -0.008850239217281342, 0.060814741998910904, -0.04226105660200119, 0.03540407866239548, 0.02359246276319027, -0.033589307218790054, -0.012807614170014858, -0.10873489826917648, 0.10735489428043365, -0.028238287195563316, -0.020029135048389435, -0.02505897730588913, -0.006472532171756029, -0.010633728466928005, -0.012848328799009323, 0.051702529191970825, 0.0335628017783165, -0.029436444863677025, 0.01020867470651865, 0.02019629068672657, -0.021611148491501808, -0.03403373435139656, 0.06263245642185211, 0.0026701686438173056, 0.02557453140616417, 0.030368471518158913, 0.00006462312012445182, 0.02469300478696823, -0.010362859815359116, 0.03150865063071251, -0.01604122668504715, 0.020024927332997322, 0.038609202951192856, -0.002392436610534787, 0.05007878690958023, 0.008476119488477707, -0.026514289900660515, 0.07469877600669861, 0.030259720981121063, 0.011196999810636044, 0.010601647198200226, -0.016185879707336426, -0.03316900506615639, 0.012299192138016224, -0.015100295655429363, -0.013629023917019367, -0.029623035341501236, 0.019613858312368393, 0.010700136423110962, -0.04166107997298241, -0.011073043569922447, 0.026843363419175148, -0.02537788636982441, 0.02980913780629635, 0.00762026384472847, 0.03185814246535301, 0.0022018051240593195, -0.019829146564006805, 0.028693558648228645, -0.00804662611335516, 0.0065215048380196095, -0.02045457623898983, 0.012088308110833168, 0.052633244544267654, 0.014334635809063911, 0.018516473472118378, 0.05395744368433952, -0.032254718244075775, 0.037677835673093796, -0.000542284979019314, 0.019586846232414246, -0.058211252093315125, -0.03695280849933624, 0.00940429326146841, -0.014032409526407719, 0.009403390809893608, -0.0452263243496418, 0.012805390171706676, 0.07521605491638184, -0.05235927924513817, -0.003959874622523785, -0.02538870833814144, -0.010951416566967964, 0.02401244267821312, 0.022297026589512825, 0.03340529650449753, 0.027045387774705887, 0.028485650196671486, -0.021744251251220703, -0.007226923946291208, 0.027277303859591484, 0.0269179530441761, -0.023337524384260178, 0.014006245881319046, -0.0035502570681273937, -0.016111500561237335, -0.041016511619091034, -0.007599555887281895, -0.021055016666650772, -0.01629094034433365, 0.02145046927034855, 0.012076297774910927, -0.010914472863078117, -0.021906178444623947, -0.0586891695857048, 0.019165528938174248, 0.05174475908279419, -0.04148492589592934, -0.0156555213034153, -0.034868162125349045, 0.029338544234633446, -0.030335471034049988, -0.029454253613948822 ]
<p>I have a correlated multivariate Bernoulli random variable $\textbf{X} = (X_1, ..., X_N)$, where the $X_i$ are Bernoulli random variables with parameters $p_i$ and $N \times N$ covariance matrix $\textbf{C}$.</p> <p>How do choices of $p_i$ constrain choices of $C$ and vice-versa?</p> <p>In one extreme case, where the $X_i$ are all independent, all choices of $p_i$ are valid. In another extreme case, where the $X_i$ are all perfectly correlated, the $p_i$ must be identical. But I would like to better understand the intermediate cases; both intuitive and more rigorous answers would be much appreciated.</p>
74,428
[ -0.04468117281794548, 0.0037534988950937986, 0.008745387196540833, -0.025444628670811653, 0.06991415470838547, 0.030768217518925667, -0.008882875554263592, -0.014661712571978569, 0.028843658044934273, -0.06360772252082825, 0.020128052681684494, 0.07316054403781891, 0.03612254559993744, 0.022153286263346672, 0.06016527861356735, 0.015783797949552536, -0.018091514706611633, -0.0014021010138094425, -0.0013576094061136246, -0.0040847607888281345, -0.0027590410318225622, 0.04687698185443878, 0.03705715388059616, -0.009059762582182884, -0.016487348824739456, 0.019948197528719902, -0.00839654915034771, -0.02730460651218891, 0.05562027916312218, 0.040546782314777374, -0.051417283713817596, -0.007450414355844259, -0.014373579993844032, 0.05450413376092911, 0.021617623046040535, -0.005401325412094593, -0.012657969258725643, -0.015682337805628777, 0.014298330061137676, 0.019048649817705154, -0.06554846465587616, -0.04742566868662834, -0.0057348343543708324, 0.0025570914149284363, 0.008446346037089825, 0.027162816375494003, -0.0002936547389253974, -0.04540859907865524, 0.05721442028880119, -0.015330127440392971, 0.09221026301383972, 0.023250635713338852, 0.028228387236595154, 0.07727006822824478, -0.011504577472805977, -0.022304637357592583, 0.06479048728942871, 0.04538664221763611, -0.012971799820661545, -0.04104756563901901, -0.022095929831266403, -0.008785000070929527, 0.02650425210595131, -0.033857863396406174, -0.04861140251159668, 0.01747819222509861, 0.012873300351202488, -0.01781255193054676, 0.024028299376368523, -0.019469505175948143, -0.0013753918465226889, 0.0104893883690238, 0.03713775426149368, -0.014767732471227646, 0.026967007666826248, -0.01893024705350399, 0.049596093595027924, 0.030126890167593956, 0.036985863000154495, 0.005987454205751419, 0.0046545518562197685, 0.03271957486867905, -0.00775721063837409, 0.014499408192932606, 0.021267397329211235, -0.003440805245190859, 0.05322058126330376, -0.013283217325806618, 0.026106100529432297, 0.0006225561955943704, -0.031046321615576744, -0.011797868646681309, 0.034533288329839706, 0.020838795229792595, -0.0507563091814518, 0.026607563719153404, -0.03325486183166504, 0.0046756272204220295, -0.026000482961535454, -0.001968981232494116, -0.03268299624323845, -0.03032435104250908, -0.012160280719399452, 0.03765535727143288, 0.00011203317262697965, -0.0033048244658857584, -0.028729237616062164, 0.00987109262496233, -0.03485250473022461, -0.025278443470597267, -0.03567487746477127, 0.03418147563934326, -0.007302101235836744, 0.008243593387305737, 0.04401195049285889, -0.027430051937699318, -0.021085018292069435, -0.0331779345870018, 0.07630385458469391, 0.07793023437261581, 0.0690668448805809, -0.01266058161854744, 0.03738243505358696, -0.04183105006814003, -0.04931119829416275, 0.008815282955765724, 0.018891068175435066, -0.032015297561883926, -0.0336250476539135, 0.038655947893857956, -0.003917608875781298, -0.020010631531476974, 0.002386316889896989, 0.03194563090801239, 0.001270213513635099, -0.02044694870710373, -0.11965614557266235, -0.023560253903269768, 0.03983664885163307, -0.04342028498649597, -0.02667059935629368, -0.08087930828332901, 0.04295792430639267, 0.04331424832344055, 0.09265543520450592, -0.052447833120822906, 0.03684696927666664, -0.0038564337883144617, 0.0338919460773468, 0.04926316440105438, -0.009898025542497635, -0.01961173303425312, -0.01733727566897869, -0.008251595310866833, -0.002178589114919305, -0.07380295544862747, 0.0003415954124648124, 0.024466561153531075, 0.008873365819454193, -0.019652435556054115, 0.06465085595846176, -0.00025883992202579975, -0.03848620131611824, -0.025424374267458916, 0.04731030762195587, -0.020777929574251175, 0.05288851633667946, -0.003255156334489584, 0.0410270057618618, 0.038523267954587936, 0.0016277360264211893, -0.007448593154549599, 0.008900867775082588, 0.05367276817560196, 0.036273520439863205, -0.011985243298113346, 0.013686629943549633, 0.021158404648303986, 0.0013681979617103934, 0.020151358097791672, -0.049817949533462524, -0.003767624031752348, -0.028834842145442963, -0.012883991003036499, 0.010549463331699371, 0.018098551779985428, 0.015835830941796303, 0.0016162641113623977, 0.005528874695301056, -0.029681533575057983, -0.00522421533241868, -0.06249331682920456, -0.008162484504282475, 0.018918491899967194, -0.062379684299230576, 0.09355705231428146, -0.017043083906173706, 0.007481098175048828, 0.02192653901875019, -0.018140045925974846, -0.0401095375418663, 0.010827910155057907, 0.027542592957615852, -0.021351110190153122, 0.0029089997988194227, 0.015348267741501331, 0.050848573446273804, 0.009780479595065117, 0.03298979252576828, 0.003233585273846984, -0.040869880467653275, 0.0107859643176198, -0.04501238465309143, 0.022589247673749924, 0.0058533805422484875, -0.02173989824950695, -0.003252575406804681, -0.01951480656862259, -0.009388919919729233, 0.05961594358086586, -0.05229954421520233, 0.03597381338477135, 0.0448959656059742, -0.0037612225860357285, 0.0018587402300909162, 0.03023693338036537, 0.00022411449754144996, 0.009782291017472744, -0.05380180478096008, -0.03664664924144745, -0.043653715401887894, -0.01497495174407959, -0.00031024235067889094, 0.06917861849069595, -0.030494604259729385, 0.027057262137532234, 0.022939708083868027, 0.05804850161075592, -0.02121627889573574, 0.04828394576907158, 0.013066662475466728, -0.01019994355738163, 0.011100932024419308, 0.0010013600112870336, 0.025133727118372917, 0.018345287069678307, -0.023803647607564926, -0.022723492234945297, 0.056070476770401, -0.019696641713380814, -0.021895231679081917, 0.04404694214463234, -0.029016712680459023, 0.0017762846546247602, -0.017465557903051376, -0.004932175390422344, 0.024455908685922623, -0.012553458102047443, 0.015042715705931187, 0.04023417457938194, 0.03165842965245247, -0.02397887036204338, 0.006702695973217487, -0.027119001373648643, 0.03905371204018593, 0.008040793240070343, -0.05468160659074783, -0.03351666405797005, 0.0072550843469798565, -0.015900205820798874, 0.011566732078790665, -0.031650982797145844, -0.033630743622779846, 0.023776721209287643, 0.02414621040225029, 0.026477104052901268, -0.006608679890632629, 0.03185085579752922, -0.036090996116399765, -0.05989373102784157, -0.018072448670864105, -0.0074524120427668095, 0.01647242344915867, -0.013012497685849667, -0.053434714674949646, 0.000710739812348038, -0.04943125322461128, 0.024101361632347107, 0.033923082053661346, -0.027542220428586006, 0.00467387679964304, 0.035069938749074936, 0.0005431989557109773, -0.0437476746737957, -0.01432564202696085, -0.008768051862716675, 0.014904947020113468, -0.05454127490520477, -0.057365093380212784, 0.057955242693424225, -0.0013882936909794807, -0.0563490055501461, 0.006487639620900154, -0.030416179448366165, -0.029183732345700264, -0.0266796313226223, -0.021272068843245506, 0.010751808062195778, 0.0073666940443217754, 0.03791806101799011, 0.026381725445389748, -0.005668660160154104, -0.015084147453308105, -0.05859451740980148, -0.07248223572969437, 0.01873437501490116, -0.007653967943042517, 0.03775253891944885, -0.0036012115888297558, -0.005836659111082554, 0.07115106284618378, 0.031309548765420914, -0.007546085398644209, -0.022971680387854576, 0.000009984107236959971, -0.020297059789299965, -0.02090114913880825, 0.018084846436977386, 0.04077859967947006, -0.03953901678323746, 0.05659383535385132, 0.029467565938830376, 0.02023644745349884, 0.0427500382065773, -0.016992181539535522, 0.041789185255765915, 0.01473882608115673, 0.009425334632396698, 0.00687691755592823, 0.009288784116506577, 0.0188523568212986, -0.008295036852359772, -0.012285160832107067, 0.013015903532505035, -0.010248865932226181, 0.009586237370967865, -0.017109179869294167, 0.00474053667858243, -0.02586173266172409, 0.012247968465089798, -0.06740451604127884, 0.02583092451095581, 0.039789386093616486, -0.022253399714827538, 0.005257227923721075, 0.044722817838191986, 0.03835401311516762, -0.060490161180496216, 0.036924805492162704, 0.03442450612783432, 0.0286315456032753, -0.009405424818396568, -0.01314911525696516, 0.005515764467418194, -0.0014555432135239244, 0.02900034561753273, -0.026745818555355072, -0.008171281777322292, 0.02816350758075714, 0.02545463666319847, 0.0008974266820587218, -0.017351873219013214, -0.03439856693148613, 0.03426248952746391, -0.03877560794353485, 0.03149852901697159, -0.016796469688415527, 0.03172338008880615, -0.01608015038073063, 0.06623698025941849, 0.00773207750171423, -0.01837044209241867, -0.016054032370448112, 0.02398323267698288, -0.06884118169546127, 0.008605876937508583, -0.021789517253637314, 0.010098150931298733, -0.0036487355828285217, -0.041563667356967926, 0.04360289126634598, -0.009653326123952866, 0.01229796838015318, -0.003474174067378044, 0.030792728066444397, -0.0013467828975990415, -0.0070895240642130375, -0.06138238683342934, -0.04345707595348358, 0.014966278336942196, 0.021814623847603798, 0.0022494052536785603, -0.01992402784526348, 0.04613245278596878, 0.015356996096670628, -0.011579332873225212, 0.0034507124219089746, 0.007892301306128502, 0.006852972321212292, 0.02439497970044613, 0.03177040070295334, 0.0008460083045065403, 0.04386851191520691, 0.02303973399102688, 0.00010779796866700053, 0.02230594865977764, 0.03660976514220238, 0.053085796535015106, -0.0017990702763199806, -0.0003955691063310951, -0.07600834965705872, -0.01298956386744976, -0.010287820361554623, 0.012643550522625446, 0.01355682872235775, -0.01544667687267065, 0.07884661853313446, 0.041322965174913406, -0.05311126634478569, 0.030523331835865974, 0.0184490866959095, 0.02958666905760765, -0.00297848554328084, 0.01218411698937416, -0.004569702781736851, -0.010998313315212727, 0.025413058698177338, 0.016773996874690056, 0.0005581899895332754, -0.01992339827120304, 0.010936806909739971, 0.02612627111375332, -0.028418710455298424, -0.011680272407829762, 0.01469966396689415, 0.024570707231760025, 0.04542538896203041, -0.002761667361482978, -0.05033279210329056, 0.000471060979180038, 0.013701353222131729, 0.024684399366378784, 0.037838954478502274, 0.018161077052354813, -0.020717471837997437, 0.0116725480183959, 0.030858799815177917, 0.024572843685746193, -0.03335072845220566, 0.006478535942733288, -0.02159934677183628, -0.024220675230026245, 0.03186573460698128, 0.0008362727239727974, 0.027433261275291443, 0.0020050425082445145, 0.01023296918720007, -0.013634136877954006, -0.046361565589904785, -0.04649486392736435, -0.009582904167473316, -0.011426855809986591, 0.05677328258752823, -0.014503872022032738, -0.01544899120926857, -0.034356195479631424, -0.013838029466569424, 0.02898949570953846, 0.04960005730390549, -0.00024255378230009228, -0.003556335112079978, -0.000235102153965272, 0.02673485316336155, 0.034070201218128204, -0.07434608787298203, 0.024123577401041985, -0.003394479164853692, -0.03519245237112045, 0.05783814936876297, -0.03186453506350517, -0.04933140054345131, 0.022169465199112892, -0.006979093886911869, 0.011793910525739193, 0.03604932129383087, 0.0005414937622845173, 0.05641888454556465, 0.015366045758128166, 0.0034448106307536364, 0.022317176684737206, 0.0060712313279509544, -0.003244338557124138, -0.013924257829785347, -0.010899956338107586, 0.0047151134349405766, -0.035276398062705994, -0.0020044150296598673, -0.06841842085123062, -0.017760688439011574, -0.0052908011712133884, 0.03267095237970352, 0.02863086760044098, 0.022309549152851105, -0.004001835361123085, -0.014147275127470493, 0.006862071342766285, 0.06385575234889984, -0.004503282718360424, 0.017312921583652496, 0.0004861183697357774, -0.005016287788748741, -0.008029167540371418, -0.02132284641265869, 0.025716260075569153, -0.00894730631262064, 0.025267500430345535, 0.010055151768028736, -0.025143008679151535, -0.0052496325224637985, -0.039603956043720245, -0.006161368452012539, -0.034528426826000214, -0.03153840824961662, 0.023480579257011414, 0.03094453178346157, 0.05377823859453201, -0.002356077777221799, -0.018899820744991302, -0.013172820210456848, 0.014760578982532024, -0.033500220626592636, 0.0307165440171957, -0.00858671311289072, 0.02231418713927269, -0.03361239656805992, -0.007781322114169598, -0.03899012878537178, -0.05051129311323166, 0.0016744680469855666, 0.016789579764008522, -0.00562766008079052, -0.016355331987142563, 0.009252515621483326, -0.032921627163887024, -0.038863684982061386, -0.03007667139172554, 0.052271518856287, -0.0049077351577579975, -0.0298828836530447, -0.013803775422275066, 0.04026780277490616, 0.07625535875558853, -0.03959760442376137, 0.003918198868632317, 0.03446391597390175, -0.053406719118356705, 0.015415080823004246, 0.00577474944293499, 0.016827614977955818, -0.004260880406945944, -0.01082485169172287, -0.02151786908507347, 0.02792639657855034, 0.032501012086868286, -0.028618354350328445, -0.003647778183221817, 0.0466131865978241, -0.019133955240249634, -0.0192701555788517, 0.01782076805830002, -0.03435543179512024, 0.008130142465233803, 0.02430088073015213, -0.003658006200566888, -0.010704048909246922, -0.009714937768876553, -0.0638524517416954, 0.03599826246500015, 0.0322309285402298, -0.0042572892270982265, 0.037311576306819916, 0.04467820003628731, -0.01306090410798788, 0.019869079813361168, -0.022493386641144753, -0.008011857978999615, 0.05318937823176384, 0.005804150830954313, -0.018329041078686714, 0.014602908864617348, 0.0009180110646411777, -0.00564779806882143, -0.03983311727643013, -0.03960618004202843, 0.02513815462589264, 0.057231705635786057, -0.008429227396845818, 0.035402584820985794, 0.06100542098283768, -0.009558438323438168, -0.012429395690560341, -0.045408111065626144, -0.009637805633246899, -0.04132149741053581, -0.005410301499068737, 0.02584957703948021, -0.03516102209687233, -0.05666631832718849, 0.04641234129667282, 0.016076166182756424, 0.0197344571352005, -0.00954787153750658, 0.02210361696779728, 0.021152963861823082, -0.0001247497129952535, -0.024950042366981506, -0.01699092797935009, 0.035977549850940704, -0.051620595157146454, -0.005201318301260471, -0.006891021970659494, -0.01793971098959446, 0.0219098087400198, 0.03342314064502716, -0.018931224942207336, -0.041153352707624435, -0.04485032334923744, -0.047122612595558167, 0.007484653498977423, 0.020987266674637794, -0.012058901600539684, 0.025531629100441933, -0.003633315907791257, 0.042494017630815506, -0.016720000654459, 0.030761562287807465, -0.01993214152753353, -0.05552460253238678, -0.052604012191295624, 0.020735343918204308, 0.00894109345972538, -0.009233170188963413, -0.0009992318227887154, -0.020835207775235176, 0.01339807640761137, -0.04849415645003319, -0.00586826354265213, -0.00501585379242897, -0.0026328940875828266, -0.02353997528553009, 0.038053762167692184, 0.02029372937977314, 0.0032665501348674297, 0.024517053738236427, -0.014593705534934998, 0.10085564851760864, 0.067989282310009, 0.016638636589050293, -0.07929140329360962, 0.01936752162873745, -0.01535911113023758, -0.01014628540724516, -0.06093797832727432, 0.0315045490860939, 0.038109950721263885, -0.014579204842448235, 0.05543358996510506, 0.04128456860780716, 0.004004687070846558, -0.017856016755104065, 0.0491720549762249, -0.04314730688929558, -0.024611946195364, 0.023282479494810104, 0.008572263643145561, -0.028271935880184174, -0.028374381363391876, -0.016512371599674225, -0.014632398262619972, -0.009638868272304535, -0.019864514470100403, -0.02691645361483097, -0.03443095088005066, 0.007597810123115778, 0.0033650032710283995, 0.023607788607478142, -0.012477482669055462, 0.024820886552333832, 0.00463485112413764, 0.002737966366112232, 0.04190296679735184, -0.0041843135841190815, -0.014109109528362751, 0.022809386253356934, -0.011402158066630363, -0.018313832581043243, 0.0273718424141407, 0.02849584072828293, -0.012719601392745972, -0.03866792842745781, -0.046249546110630035, -0.05467887222766876, 0.017756963148713112, 0.002643140498548746, -0.02122326008975506, -0.026505008339881897, 0.014902414754033089, 0.024806300178170204, -0.034190110862255096, -0.012754322029650211, 0.0473802387714386, 0.049224238842725754, -0.03631448745727539, -0.017481375485658646, -0.020768648013472557, 0.01303293276578188, 0.005408922675997019, 0.01930627040565014, -0.007324885576963425, -0.0818236842751503, 0.0017311442643404007, -0.042838335037231445, 0.06105173006653786, 0.04456370323896408, -0.005401836708188057, 0.00018239952623844147, -0.016320912167429924, -0.016731180250644684, -0.016334988176822662, 0.02896980009973049, -0.02364303544163704, 0.03862975537776947, 0.018860241398215294, 0.008280654437839985, -0.015703456476330757, -0.026016348972916603, -0.017739633098244667, -0.006968239787966013, 0.007541273720562458, -0.014598234556615353, -0.01781788468360901, 0.023018728941679, 0.050460439175367355, 0.03148919716477394, 0.00418743584305048, -0.023292431607842445, 0.0447809100151062, -0.010159280151128769, -0.030999209731817245, -0.02618025802075863, -0.03563433885574341, -0.045432671904563904, 0.01691185124218464, -0.014382051303982735, 0.050877515226602554, 0.022787295281887054, 0.036857690662145615, 0.002531585516408086, 0.03022131510078907, 0.0033194615971297026, 0.0076681883074343204, 0.047470010817050934, -0.03373676910996437, 0.024551188573241234, 0.05574225261807442, 0.007662161253392696, -0.041497357189655304, -0.02913047932088375, -0.04319221153855324, 0.0005222123581916094, 0.0042389146983623505, -0.042634230107069016, -0.05051277205348015, -0.028239388018846512, -0.01109082531183958, 0.01575530879199505, -0.02404368855059147, -0.008398063480854034, -0.07723228633403778, 0.028135262429714203, 0.0006114415591582656, 0.008685454726219177, 0.009956632740795612, -0.012313169427216053, -0.048925481736660004, -0.040149662643671036, 0.03649508208036423, -0.005180742591619492, 0.026166079565882683, -0.043614111840724945, -0.00780312716960907, 0.013873574323952198, 0.05055085942149162, -0.045118119567632675, -0.017381101846694946, 0.024859489873051643, -0.024697357788681984, -0.029817631468176842, -0.011512060649693012, 0.029161449521780014, 0.017533916980028152, -0.00366097129881382, 0.00038872568984515965, -0.046370573341846466, 0.06240944564342499, -0.032914191484451294, 0.021308060735464096, -0.020222531631588936, 0.061828531324863434, -0.0009974469430744648, -0.006322033703327179, 0.04244525358080864, -0.0038694022223353386, 0.0006095086573623121, 0.02879534289240837, 0.05852161720395088, 0.004199143964797258, 0.0013153926702216268, 0.005393180530518293, 0.013997877947986126, 0.008883318863809109, -0.0005028757150284946, 0.006729742977768183, 0.029886242002248764, 0.06122513860464096, -0.021581238135695457, 0.04650067538022995, 0.009921235963702202, 0.02645810879766941, -0.08667450398206711, -0.037242524325847626, 0.010867728851735592, -0.006580650340765715, 0.05468600615859032, -0.02713722735643387, 0.014730040915310383, 0.04430737718939781, -0.07037006318569183, 0.01640878990292549, -0.005143029149621725, 0.004727412946522236, -0.03810388222336769, 0.02933504991233349, -0.043900180608034134, 0.06560620665550232, 0.02895139530301094, -0.012585537508130074, 0.03709261864423752, 0.028377460315823555, -0.0036559649743139744, -0.02531416155397892, -0.013728928752243519, 0.028055578470230103, 0.010964596644043922, -0.04620175436139107, 0.045130692422389984, -0.03778686746954918, -0.05618605390191078, 0.044343315064907074, 0.01974799670279026, -0.02252529375255108, -0.018320592120289803, 0.0072206468321383, 0.006711038760840893, 0.057161420583724976, 0.024279242381453514, -0.030658390372991562, 0.014036403968930244, 0.01656523533165455, 0.03285082429647446, 0.004130666144192219, -0.007578246295452118, -0.009244404733181, 0.006448056548833847, -0.016436373814940453, -0.043121110647916794, -0.022036410868167877, 0.015242169611155987, -0.0321451760828495, -0.003621678566560149, 0.0028127890545874834, 0.04094817861914635, -0.0011892709881067276, 0.058385226875543594, -0.07395707815885544, -0.05979602038860321, 0.031160349026322365, 0.027711832895874977, -0.031007995828986168, -0.0067795137874782085, -0.02950308658182621, -0.03121933527290821, -0.009132222272455692, 0.028688156977295876, -0.019141966477036476, -0.04900796711444855, -0.030597198754549026, 0.01593436487019062, -0.009445752948522568, -0.013648145832121372, -0.02272738702595234, -0.057857904583215714, 0.04796529561281204, 0.011853956617414951, 0.004647911060601473, -0.05598710849881172, -0.04782148450613022, -0.016783859580755234, -0.04879583418369293, 0.03816128149628639, -0.01848163828253746, 0.004558145068585873, -0.04610993713140488, -0.01243932731449604, -0.01852954737842083, -0.00788065418601036, 0.04734914377331734, -0.007726472336798906, 0.024770157411694527, -0.01184152439236641, 0.03386692702770233, -0.0161299891769886, -0.035100389271974564, 0.04671104997396469, 0.012494932860136032, -0.01675352267920971, -0.03555477410554886, -0.017291001975536346, 0.04016895219683647, 0.0025895838625729084, -0.014603757299482822, -0.017876340076327324, 0.03104114532470703, 0.011746199801564217, 0.0021415262017399073, 0.05831661820411682, 0.0031317591201514006, -0.0230109766125679, 0.05202016979455948, 0.009205237030982971, 0.011289393529295921, 0.011126200668513775, 0.0021828419994562864, -0.06317207217216492, 0.025798790156841278, -0.041876841336488724, -0.03281569480895996, -0.018546350300312042, 0.04422503337264061, -0.004998690448701382, -0.05420473590493202, 0.022669898346066475, 0.004310394171625376, -0.04568956792354584, -0.021797984838485718, 0.002314959652721882, 0.011960889212787151, 0.032515719532966614, 0.008778287097811699, 0.005491395480930805, 0.007194852456450462, -0.012422511354088783, 0.011568318121135235, -0.007925006560981274, 0.05084432661533356, 0.0010357589926570654, 0.019869785755872726, 0.005944111850112677, -0.03822609782218933, 0.037552282214164734, -0.03304030001163483, -0.009832825511693954, -0.03852664679288864, -0.027458002790808678, 0.027653446421027184, -0.008584309369325638, 0.023244284093379974, -0.024089161306619644, -0.0018097766442224383, 0.04362601786851883, -0.029501795768737793, 0.00012910636723972857, -0.007686424534767866, 0.03446182608604431, 0.00476447120308876, -0.024564089253544807, -0.03574926406145096, 0.028902869671583176, -0.0054397862404584885, -0.0038925064727663994, 0.004906515125185251, -0.02281343936920166, -0.0035160784609615803, -0.024211006239056587, 0.01467874739319086, 0.00021340422972571105, 0.002833888167515397, -0.0489359050989151, -0.014061820693314075, -0.05299364775419235, 0.0033218967728316784, 0.026180027052760124, 0.0708782747387886, 0.013997710309922695, -0.0034624733962118626, -0.04005998745560646, -0.006801567040383816, 0.041438989341259, -0.053282707929611206, 0.014203940518200397, -0.02845323272049427, 0.023868883028626442, -0.007491907570511103, 0.04673566296696663 ]
<p>I have a longitudinal data set of individuals and some of them were subject to a treatment and others were not. All individuals are in the sample from birth until age 18 and the treatment happens at some age in between that range. The age of the treatment may differ across cases. Using propensity score matching I would like to match treated and control units in pairs with exact matching on the year of birth such that I can track each pair from their birthyear until age 18. All in all there are about 150 treated and 4000 untreated individuals. After the matching the idea is to use a difference-in-differences strategy to estimate the effect of the treatment.</p> <p>The problem I face at the moment is to do the matching with panel data. I am using Stata's <code>psmatch2</code> command and I match on household and individual characteristics using propensity score matching. In general with panel data there will be different optimal matches at each age. As an example: if A is treated, B and C are controls, and all of them were born in 1980, then A and B may be matched in 1980 at age 0 whilst A and C are matched in 1981 at age 1 and so on. Also A may be matched with its own pre-treatment values from previous years.</p> <p>To get around this issue, I took the average of all time-varying variables such that the matching can identify individuals who are on average the most similar over the duration of the sample and I do the matching separately for each age group 0 to 18. Unfortunately this still matches a different control unit to each treated unit per age group.</p> <p>If someone could direct me towards a method to do pairwise matching with panel data in Stata this would be very much appreciated.</p>
74,429
[ -0.04323311150074005, -0.04217115044593811, -0.02234368771314621, 0.031154505908489227, 0.004345451947301626, -0.009105873294174671, -0.0045464965514838696, -0.019032366573810577, 0.06357868015766144, -0.02807173691689968, 0.013759090565145016, 0.028670117259025574, 0.058158013969659805, -0.020247213542461395, 0.0301192756742239, -0.0050773415714502335, 0.005599686875939369, -0.010375680401921272, -0.012763123959302902, -0.007724246941506863, 0.00926228053867817, 0.03388076275587082, -0.013416503556072712, 0.011208618991076946, 0.001211674651131034, 0.04792885482311249, -0.008379125036299229, -0.014415990561246872, -0.049638014286756516, 0.048763398081064224, -0.0335455946624279, -0.0734793171286583, -0.006256584078073502, -0.004937059246003628, 0.019986193627119064, -0.004219796508550644, -0.014019200578331947, -0.06538522243499756, -0.0025841319002211094, 0.034523021429777145, -0.06830088794231415, 0.002135109854862094, -0.020333755761384964, 0.05904029682278633, -0.006735044531524181, 0.026710325852036476, 0.00465768575668335, 0.001679999171756208, 0.02717476151883602, -0.04089030250906944, 0.054149072617292404, 0.0009742202237248421, 0.03493056818842888, 0.00720586720854044, -0.06650063395500183, -0.049774255603551865, 0.0501057468354702, 0.05224424973130226, 0.026127779856324196, -0.02032981440424919, -0.015855640172958374, -0.039294179528951645, 0.01776112988591194, -0.022289812564849854, -0.048445072025060654, 0.0326266773045063, -0.006168798077851534, -0.017236119136214256, 0.02817598730325699, -0.07143941521644592, 0.01567230187356472, 0.011935306712985039, 0.05301680043339729, 0.001394978491589427, -0.007154157385230064, -0.010227900929749012, 0.014959052205085754, 0.02792150154709816, 0.048698101192712784, 0.0067969621159136295, -0.019011812284588814, 0.00458143837749958, 0.03272610530257225, 0.06134871020913124, 0.01153474859893322, -0.004322246182709932, 0.04557529464364052, -0.05901646614074707, 0.021492712199687958, 0.022399386391043663, -0.031507689505815506, 0.019652554765343666, 0.03441447764635086, -0.0036702307406812906, -0.007169440854340792, 0.022862732410430908, 0.007757510058581829, 0.05438290536403656, 0.017930876463651657, 0.015574009157717228, -0.01076627615839243, -0.03591614589095116, -0.01342341210693121, 0.024307718500494957, 0.023591047152876854, 0.007261275313794613, -0.058764681220054626, -0.01201243419200182, 0.012048488482832909, -0.004002248402684927, -0.014293803833425045, 0.02232629433274269, -0.02711200900375843, -0.005865647457540035, 0.0465347096323967, -0.0008012499311007559, -0.029776550829410553, -0.01797564886510372, 0.054583869874477386, 0.04729384556412697, 0.018148647621273994, -0.049294453114271164, 0.02324099838733673, -0.012040447443723679, -0.044793881475925446, 0.004963624756783247, 0.02983209118247032, -0.009701406583189964, -0.03174948692321777, 0.006401518359780312, 0.046231143176555634, -0.04806134104728699, 0.029537510126829147, -0.021410714834928513, 0.009687654674053192, -0.006893638987094164, -0.024531414732336998, -0.0529022216796875, 0.009735532104969025, 0.006581389810889959, 0.01373856607824564, -0.06296040117740631, 0.01358428131788969, -0.00902246031910181, 0.08177133649587631, -0.038816388696432114, 0.03708730265498161, 0.050155557692050934, 0.038640096783638, 0.038278594613075256, 0.001459087710827589, -0.01882856711745262, -0.020528029650449753, -0.024636225774884224, -0.0029547265730798244, -0.07142143696546555, 0.015467938035726547, 0.03667670860886574, -0.01940148137509823, -0.00506239477545023, 0.0799565389752388, -0.010828048922121525, -0.06638525426387787, 0.021464886143803596, 0.007623041048645973, -0.009528063237667084, 0.05731003358960152, 0.011858025565743446, 0.04091205820441246, 0.03204856067895889, -0.0200879517942667, 0.01467183418571949, 0.0258853230625391, 0.054434362798929214, 0.01321062445640564, -0.00706395972520113, -0.012604833580553532, 0.032830607146024704, -0.022063087671995163, 0.016516517847776413, -0.03573693707585335, -0.02565494179725647, -0.030827173963189125, -0.025284234434366226, 0.021999578922986984, 0.023035837337374687, 0.01373056136071682, 0.016400976106524467, 0.010769183747470379, -0.036714278161525726, -0.07570187747478485, -0.0629734992980957, 0.02263091690838337, -0.001022293814457953, -0.024734532460570335, 0.03636115789413452, -0.023066505789756775, 0.0076283556409180164, -0.004299430176615715, -0.0262583140283823, -0.0003520635364111513, -0.02135343849658966, 0.03269750997424126, -0.02057173289358616, -0.004980205092579126, 0.03471660241484642, 0.07717370986938477, -0.006050884258002043, 0.04159857705235481, -0.0635552853345871, -0.020453225821256638, 0.018077528104186058, -0.028840744867920876, 0.04306580871343613, -0.03312632441520691, 0.011822151951491833, -0.0022013592533767223, -0.029826179146766663, -0.011443926952779293, 0.04442495480179787, -0.06647069752216339, 0.055830877274274826, 0.06898096948862076, -0.010160575620830059, 0.008550478145480156, 0.010051494464278221, -0.0007788499933667481, 0.0337737612426281, -0.006106831599026918, -0.01711772009730339, -0.03813910484313965, -0.03890063986182213, -0.003843255341053009, 0.015902213752269745, -0.024424513801932335, 0.03125527501106262, 0.06625422090291977, -0.004060561768710613, 0.004675698932260275, 0.019727271050214767, 0.031128672882914543, -0.0075046769343316555, 0.022124743089079857, -0.0024045887403190136, -0.008126416243612766, 0.00912370253354311, 0.031371764838695526, 0.0006649471470154822, 0.03077780455350876, 0.025661608204245567, 0.009856831282377243, 0.04959949851036072, 0.020953409373760223, 0.046393685042858124, -0.021795934066176414, -0.05099153891205788, 0.04648847505450249, -0.006667047739028931, 0.014994576573371887, 0.02542736381292343, 0.02339828386902809, -0.030875645577907562, 0.010816589929163456, -0.018495481461286545, 0.02375834807753563, 0.044680044054985046, -0.009121306240558624, -0.007353804539889097, -0.005776253063231707, -0.029326574876904488, 0.04694526270031929, -0.005135482642799616, -0.04573321342468262, -0.010514678433537483, 0.006274481303989887, 0.026367492973804474, 0.00012394844088703394, -0.020042452961206436, -0.03699948638677597, 0.01065122988075018, -0.013283602893352509, -0.003083069110289216, 0.055026669055223465, 0.029558977112174034, -0.04262650012969971, -0.005822007078677416, -0.04739026352763176, -0.008177079260349274, 0.03092869557440281, 0.014266048558056355, -0.017616325989365578, 0.033977676182985306, -0.0031302710995078087, -0.03712509572505951, -0.01996516063809395, -0.026086173951625824, -0.0010799274314194918, -0.024058526381850243, 0.002470363862812519, 0.02959008328616619, 0.04353431984782219, -0.009021181613206863, 0.0015938751166686416, -0.025070413947105408, -0.015040482394397259, 0.009430660866200924, 0.0072302864864468575, -0.009459956549108028, 0.006660972721874714, 0.015720685943961143, 0.04493941366672516, -0.0005126692121848464, 0.005099159199744463, -0.05288511887192726, -0.053971532732248306, 0.02634320594370365, 0.03838499262928963, 0.040970928966999054, 0.015158776193857193, 0.011567305773496628, 0.052057910710573196, 0.0025998151395469904, 0.01281366590410471, -0.030724115669727325, -0.008910617791116238, -0.014971918426454067, 0.011148851364850998, 0.039524488151073456, 0.027118965983390808, -0.002003238769248128, 0.016366073861718178, 0.01368552166968584, 0.01995621994137764, 0.0682486891746521, 0.008601872250437737, 0.017534520477056503, -0.004953519441187382, 0.028787370771169662, -0.012621603906154633, 0.01176981907337904, 0.013070406392216682, -0.028684379532933235, 0.006262362934648991, -0.011303462088108063, -0.010141086764633656, -0.006074387114495039, -0.04517161846160889, -0.00035882071824744344, -0.025827817618846893, -0.01024989876896143, -0.038455527275800705, 0.003656771034002304, 0.004891777411103249, -0.016102973371744156, -0.03652986139059067, -0.00674408907070756, 0.0018997329752892256, -0.013846319168806076, 0.014509467408061028, 0.03231436386704445, 0.0060096918605268, 0.009919247590005398, -0.001311197062022984, 0.01429761853069067, -0.019900228828191757, 0.03495416417717934, -0.047996822744607925, -0.05287758633494377, 0.01127089373767376, 0.02107728272676468, 0.04753364250063896, 0.02039027400314808, -0.039545223116874695, 0.024094507098197937, -0.06327113509178162, 0.006086185108870268, -0.024101505056023598, 0.06983275711536407, -0.0055479747243225574, 0.020793970674276352, -0.0014006419805809855, 0.013672630302608013, 0.0030146241188049316, -0.026694271713495255, -0.08152766525745392, -0.02300681173801422, -0.0068357656709849834, -0.004069444723427296, 0.026277707889676094, -0.023882845416665077, 0.034226033836603165, 0.0038807173259556293, 0.011307853274047375, -0.00883767195045948, 0.04418683424592018, 0.028992915526032448, -0.02325538359582424, -0.02593313343822956, -0.009196399711072445, -0.012613729573786259, -0.017713110893964767, -0.03498326241970062, -0.01906842738389969, 0.030635608360171318, 0.03293433040380478, 0.026620570570230484, 0.002181139076128602, -0.0441863052546978, 0.036815714091062546, 0.044303540140390396, 0.03766871988773346, 0.04860559105873108, 0.0024266005493700504, -0.06115202605724335, -0.005426093470305204, -0.015739744529128075, 0.01190713606774807, 0.04569971188902855, 0.015722354874014854, -0.05112225189805031, -0.009048739448189735, -0.04831276088953018, 0.003880575532093644, 0.021950509399175644, 0.019991392269730568, -0.0051959059201180935, 0.031611036509275436, 0.041162095963954926, -0.050090499222278595, 0.012238437309861183, 0.08713928610086441, 0.025120362639427185, 0.01924680359661579, -0.04401763901114464, -0.030799375846982002, -0.0002983443846460432, 0.0414118617773056, 0.016528630629181862, 0.02030400186777115, -0.0003798246616497636, -0.0013733673840761185, 0.07021464407444, 0.020267993211746216, -0.05366441234946251, 0.033044684678316116, 0.008909235708415508, 0.04546911641955376, 0.013315634801983833, -0.02088756673038006, 0.014031908474862576, 0.05151717737317085, 0.024293599650263786, 0.026954999193549156, 0.002604055218398571, -0.06125117465853691, 0.015474840067327023, 0.021009890362620354, 0.0463753417134285, -0.035635486245155334, -0.05473655089735985, -0.00002680154466361273, -0.022415926679968834, 0.02888667583465576, -0.013742122799158096, 0.016256848350167274, -0.040377695113420486, -0.03540024906396866, -0.01349985133856535, -0.053982365876436234, -0.045938700437545776, 0.03062381036579609, -0.024594085291028023, 0.007206396199762821, 0.018269900232553482, -0.05356487259268761, -0.012059449218213558, 0.031484346836805344, -0.008263886906206608, 0.021089233458042145, -0.014472606591880322, 0.009817155078053474, 0.04948727786540985, 0.009858757257461548, -0.024042963981628418, -0.06651142239570618, 0.03206147253513336, -0.00244872341863811, -0.038002461194992065, 0.02157910354435444, -0.016658658161759377, 0.012177803553640842, -0.019036175683140755, -0.0133507726714015, 0.0072647277265787125, -0.015424509532749653, -0.03068048693239689, 0.0432472825050354, 0.003965374547988176, -0.021523548290133476, 0.06702594459056854, 0.04860614985227585, -0.029309073463082314, 0.01602618396282196, -0.02611619047820568, -0.002481973497197032, -0.019970979541540146, -0.018131108954548836, -0.03251795843243599, -0.019811132922768593, 0.005681273993104696, 0.03039049543440342, 0.0049747745506465435, 0.02587796002626419, -0.06254567205905914, 0.018679270520806313, 0.005298079457134008, 0.06081033870577812, -0.056566476821899414, -0.020201999694108963, 0.015104657970368862, 0.04201182350516319, 0.005419053602963686, -0.040418535470962524, 0.04915020987391472, -0.010977167636156082, 0.0282956063747406, -0.009481878019869328, -0.02205822430551052, 0.022800028324127197, -0.015171839855611324, -0.016533678397536278, -0.004584859125316143, -0.01242856215685606, 0.03609999641776085, -0.009825915098190308, 0.019678296521306038, -0.0014250202802941203, -0.021241320297122, 0.020497765392065048, 0.03617792949080467, -0.011928296647965908, 0.03242997080087662, -0.04024825990200043, 0.03587915375828743, 0.0019645572174340487, -0.040224719792604446, -0.08084370195865631, -0.04088140279054642, 0.014080187305808067, 0.01839347369968891, -0.0044561512768268585, -0.024782635271549225, -0.018905118107795715, 0.005386092700064182, 0.015915462747216225, -0.013594145886600018, 0.07074877619743347, -0.01254133228212595, -0.031091611832380295, -0.02187259867787361, 0.04514267295598984, 0.040929846465587616, -0.03735937550663948, -0.00907655619084835, -0.013884875923395157, -0.04353700205683708, 0.0017544638831168413, -0.020285427570343018, 0.011140593327581882, -0.03237549215555191, -0.009932204149663448, -0.03541065752506256, 0.03358177840709686, 0.06871592998504639, 0.008820007555186749, -0.006160321645438671, 0.00004428566535352729, -0.04395759478211403, 0.01427585817873478, -0.025933973491191864, 0.016007253900170326, -0.050465360283851624, -0.022577643394470215, -0.048120733350515366, 0.024142656475305557, -0.013483952730894089, -0.039642464369535446, 0.041768476366996765, -0.029897388070821762, -0.034601885825395584, -0.010751403868198395, 0.0453939214348793, -0.03313742205500603, -0.0016374614788219333, 0.024725262075662613, -0.018649451434612274, 0.0516698956489563, -0.017600201070308685, -0.015789760276675224, -0.02040380798280239, -0.02141123265028, -0.03783608227968216, -0.04029851406812668, -0.049246322363615036, 0.011349828913807869, 0.06832367181777954, 0.024616174399852753, 0.08020985871553421, 0.08211606740951538, -0.029186390340328217, 0.005057368893176317, -0.029776662588119507, 0.015269734896719456, -0.0014236270217224956, -0.011942783370614052, 0.05937281623482704, -0.015821047127246857, 0.0013653093483299017, 0.05248647555708885, 0.035436324775218964, 0.031719375401735306, 0.032055627554655075, 0.01933370530605316, -0.014671907760202885, 0.07235115766525269, -0.03446236252784729, -0.020413167774677277, -0.02097485587000847, -0.03852028772234917, -0.011097260750830173, -0.04770883917808533, -0.03338615223765373, 0.00926877185702324, 0.05012665316462517, -0.00971608329564333, -0.019704626873135567, -0.032996293157339096, -0.07105319947004318, 0.02151929773390293, 0.04244393855333328, -0.009198932908475399, 0.09927303344011307, 0.031160447746515274, 0.04430604726076126, 0.007842447608709335, -0.00015278330829460174, -0.04610639065504074, -0.011668859049677849, -0.03234131634235382, -0.032632119953632355, -0.017945697531104088, 0.04137643799185753, 0.019999107345938683, 0.021369842812418938, -0.008520775474607944, -0.03460901975631714, -0.02118251845240593, 0.008224680088460445, 0.005270855501294136, -0.028676506131887436, 0.0714123398065567, 0.023354293778538704, 0.002796765184029937, -0.013471496291458607, 0.009061056189239025, 0.1309662163257599, 0.03960490971803665, 0.014899825677275658, -0.07179946452379227, 0.0269949771463871, 0.039815548807382584, -0.04493678733706474, -0.04659028723835945, -0.012222385965287685, 0.018494507297873497, -0.05596846714615822, 0.035628534853458405, 0.058415625244379044, 0.039621151983737946, 0.008363334462046623, 0.04238611459732056, -0.026534484699368477, 0.005198257509618998, 0.016019945964217186, 0.0013653550995513797, 0.026538588106632233, 0.031102368608117104, -0.025264261290431023, 0.013885467313230038, 0.015594790689647198, -0.007799604907631874, -0.023213395848870277, -0.01742519997060299, -0.01944234035909176, 0.014257967472076416, 0.02196781523525715, 0.028972378000617027, 0.011207638308405876, -0.0003538677410688251, -0.03467602655291557, 0.001707688206806779, 0.01898140087723732, -0.0018194598378613591, 0.012548013590276241, -0.0016003957716748118, -0.0012939318548887968, 0.011947941966354847, -0.007767013739794493, -0.01975090429186821, -0.026564346626400948, -0.02785237692296505, -0.03206164017319679, 0.04984540864825249, 0.0047200946137309074, -0.05313284322619438, 0.006203042343258858, 0.006098646204918623, 0.037650421261787415, -0.05204438045620918, -0.021365460008382797, 0.042898036539554596, 0.04033179208636284, -0.04709961637854576, 0.015981344506144524, -0.0006101045291870832, -0.009946256875991821, -0.01893410086631775, 0.04420742392539978, 0.016717802733182907, -0.04257531091570854, 0.015990160405635834, -0.06564866751432419, 0.027876731008291245, -0.01691443845629692, -0.02243996597826481, 0.04987581819295883, -0.012705533765256405, -0.03154600039124489, -0.038170404732227325, 0.01132423710078001, 0.0333758182823658, 0.039894331246614456, -0.0358525849878788, -0.008441513404250145, -0.03324434533715248, -0.05630245804786682, -0.002314297715201974, -0.06849861890077591, 0.010427544824779034, -0.029209502041339874, -0.0044175321236252785, 0.05347653105854988, 0.024833621457219124, -0.05051061511039734, 0.02193775586783886, -0.02511988952755928, 0.02276613935828209, 0.021106252446770668, -0.05277734622359276, -0.0018124909838661551, -0.00604595011100173, -0.05414244905114174, -0.011994407512247562, -0.03198743239045143, 0.06406783312559128, 0.011458306573331356, 0.014669911004602909, 0.006076228339225054, 0.021110907196998596, -0.03959822654724121, 0.03181670233607292, 0.05858524143695831, -0.054238565266132355, -0.017960254102945328, -0.01474872324615717, 0.01951052062213421, 0.004987035412341356, 0.002972941379994154, -0.03323366865515709, -0.014837565831840038, 0.026977572590112686, -0.041559938341379166, -0.023107705637812614, 0.0403825007379055, -0.0573544017970562, 0.01437048427760601, -0.041800618171691895, -0.0028752144426107407, -0.055512938648462296, 0.005044019315391779, -0.0080360546708107, -0.01983845978975296, -0.001711312448605895, 0.03424609452486038, -0.029875939711928368, -0.0046958839520812035, -0.0002619812439661473, -0.0021263507660478354, 0.0032690935768187046, 0.01821397989988327, 0.02895304746925831, -0.018902653828263283, 0.03531370311975479, -0.004833906423300505, -0.03541107103228569, 0.009031564928591251, -0.038966454565525055, -0.0562625378370285, 0.024779798462986946, -0.006177814211696386, 0.02803896740078926, 0.018572838976979256, 0.005527425091713667, -0.02124902792274952, 0.0460439957678318, -0.0026189915370196104, -0.026250846683979034, -0.009203234687447548, -0.0013069086708128452, 0.03484903275966644, 0.0046138763427734375, -0.018109049648046494, 0.016497092321515083, -0.042265329509973526, 0.0048607406206429005, 0.050093669444322586, 0.010901208966970444, 0.0005665789358317852, -0.04961366206407547, -0.0020160002168267965, 0.022625325247645378, 0.025987466797232628, 0.007248810958117247, 0.027426864951848984, 0.052380166947841644, 0.0033789281733334064, 0.016100259497761726, -0.020588645711541176, -0.00015087179781403393, -0.036276817321777344, -0.006263189949095249, -0.0087012629956007, 0.019804291427135468, 0.011026873253285885, -0.05578725039958954, 0.01049131155014038, 0.002032272983342409, -0.009258800186216831, 0.03715059533715248, -0.004734305664896965, 0.011236554943025112, -0.021205736324191093, 0.030773142352700233, -0.028088627383112907, 0.015024635009467602, 0.008651703596115112, 0.010869034565985203, 0.00494325952604413, 0.02515251189470291, 0.028561173006892204, -0.051522351801395416, -0.0387568324804306, -0.006165492348372936, 0.04109559953212738, -0.0498516820371151, 0.035359591245651245, -0.03291744366288185, -0.0308196023106575, 0.023293938487768173, -0.030008656904101372, 0.012098981998860836, 0.0017116402741521597, 0.018540898337960243, 0.000538049906026572, 0.025828903540968895, 0.03719763457775116, 0.041959166526794434, 0.027605179697275162, -0.0443708598613739, 0.016599999740719795, 0.030941644683480263, -0.041180435568094254, 0.03986208885908127, -0.012484584003686905, 0.0255731213837862, 0.0004914946621283889, -0.004630934447050095, 0.008332157507538795, -0.017205484211444855, -0.013900592923164368, -0.03295307978987694, 0.03287838399410248, 0.029401639476418495, -0.016211185604333878, -0.02660512924194336, -0.0006232807645574212, 0.023378724232316017, 0.01840725913643837, 0.01125736441463232, 0.03872975707054138, -0.030477633699774742, 0.003312229411676526, 0.021068397909402847, -0.007013903930783272, 0.014644390903413296, -0.07209444046020508, -0.05030163750052452, 0.024571536108851433, -0.006175349932163954, -0.041636694222688675, -0.0015683198580518365, 0.0007051036227494478, 0.02136719785630703, -0.02995830960571766, -0.0499807707965374, 0.009819405153393745, 0.005065194796770811, 0.038012757897377014, -0.07329221814870834, 0.08319693058729172, -0.011010934598743916, -0.04303745925426483, -0.013415046036243439, -0.05374586209654808, -0.027200326323509216, 0.028028320521116257, 0.029894035309553146, -0.013070867396891117, -0.021563004702329636, -0.01646944135427475, -0.005178460851311684, 0.01448394451290369, -0.005737492348998785, 0.07551638036966324, -0.0026511135511100292, 0.012563989497721195, 0.015735283493995667, 0.02200106531381607, -0.01858007162809372, 0.009741190820932388, 0.02011396549642086, -0.03132963553071022, 0.0017349256668239832, 0.043202392756938934, -0.022365408018231392, 0.030916716903448105, 0.005782695021480322, -0.018143819645047188, 0.0007821879698894918, 0.051577214151620865, -0.001520565478131175, 0.053880758583545685, -0.014670077711343765, -0.06683836132287979, 0.00851626880466938, -0.06131184101104736, -0.016069749370217323, 0.005239964462816715, -0.007425396237522364, -0.009190008975565434, -0.0681026354432106, 0.031975146383047104, 0.018431544303894043, -0.012591039761900902, 0.011451938189566135, 0.07270722836256027, 0.019330963492393494, 0.009508650749921799, 0.008259308524429798, 0.005751210264861584, -0.002262016525492072, 0.014311128295958042, 0.017385276034474373, 0.011860881000757217, 0.04759138077497482, -0.022833319380879402, 0.014619117602705956, 0.011170278303325176, 0.015745485201478004, 0.0026438531931489706, -0.007322341203689575, 0.037977397441864014, -0.017157860100269318, -0.01479286327958107, -0.00035906519042328, 0.0026496180798858404, -0.011005396023392677, 0.01715737208724022, -0.025328926742076874, 0.04932578280568123, -0.012181906029582024, 0.005709209479391575, -0.01503863837569952, 0.025480760261416435, -0.025406064465641975, -0.014708900824189186, 0.013043301180005074, 0.03883250802755356, -0.014735870994627476, 0.010257847607135773, 0.023748695850372314, -0.044983528554439545, 0.006116706877946854, 0.009589902125298977, 0.005179196130484343, -0.026256097480654716, 0.02322772704064846, -0.009096422232687473, -0.014348942786455154, -0.022165630012750626, -0.034801408648490906, 0.023801911622285843, 0.020389676094055176, 0.02197861671447754, -0.05694621056318283, -0.00020347423560451716, 0.012528395280241966, 0.05240670219063759, -0.07028012722730637, -0.018305493518710136, -0.044073525816202164, -0.03701041638851166, -0.050664082169532776, 0.017590751871466637 ]
<p>I have the following histogram of count data. And I would like to fit a discrete distribution to it. I am not sure how I should go about this. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/C3up0.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Should I first superimpose a discrete distribution, say Negative Binomial distribution, on the histogram so that I would obtain the parameters of the discrete distribution and then run a Kolmogorov–Smirnov test to check the p-values? </p> <p>I am not sure if this method is correct or not. </p> <p>Is there a general method to tackle a problem like this?</p> <p>This is a frequency table of the count data. In my problem, I am only focusing on non-zero counts. </p> <pre><code> Counts: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 9 10 Frequency: 3875 2454 921 192 37 11 1 1 2 </code></pre> <p><strong>UPDATE:</strong> I would like to ask: I used the fitdistr function in R to obtain the parameters for fitting the data.</p> <pre><code>fitdistr(abc[abc != 0], "Poisson") lambda 1.68147852 (0.01497921) </code></pre> <p>I then plot the probability mass function of Poisson distribution on top of the histogram. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/djIBz.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>However, it seems like the Poisson distribution fails to model the count data. <strong>Is there anything I can do?</strong></p>
74,430
[ -0.033835090696811676, -0.029857758432626724, 0.014048293232917786, -0.014710413292050362, -0.001381180016323924, 0.0013211999321356416, 0.006496659014374018, -0.009640241973102093, 0.027931302785873413, -0.006617430131882429, 0.046727877110242844, 0.05412949621677399, 0.05165457725524902, -0.004108097869902849, 0.020648043602705002, -0.001888357219286263, -0.026001131162047386, -0.03286308795213699, -0.01596650294959545, -0.011859817430377007, -0.008408778347074986, 0.017616232857108116, 0.006922545377165079, -0.004553038626909256, -0.005779997445642948, 0.015490591526031494, 0.022173922508955002, -0.007994739338755608, 0.03355840966105461, 0.07180691510438919, -0.07147524505853653, -0.02216157875955105, 0.023928992450237274, 0.044511258602142334, 0.02739924192428589, 0.02222064509987831, -0.03546908497810364, -0.03089495562016964, -0.0270541962236166, 0.014206795021891594, -0.0505097322165966, 0.007888110354542732, 0.032101552933454514, 0.060325995087623596, 0.0014928145101293921, 0.04695511609315872, 0.0007792749092914164, -0.014090550132095814, 0.03505530580878258, -0.0381331630051136, 0.0576007254421711, 0.008418528363108635, 0.04506011679768562, 0.05047917366027832, -0.018361182883381844, -0.05710519105195999, 0.051831476390361786, 0.06448198854923248, -0.014483052305877209, -0.06475318223237991, -0.003048781305551529, -0.03816327080130577, -0.025063805282115936, -0.04102306813001633, -0.003271672409027815, 0.02276262827217579, -0.008405943401157856, -0.054612405598163605, 0.023022854700684547, -0.011387793347239494, 0.012494371272623539, 0.012285668402910233, 0.048800304532051086, -0.03880317881703377, 0.02620018646121025, -0.016466554254293442, 0.019149959087371826, 0.0029509987216442823, 0.0188575629144907, 0.004858044441789389, -0.0296497605741024, 0.0006367411115206778, 0.01806543581187725, 0.03430696576833725, 0.009548468515276909, -0.045339468866586685, 0.05963118374347687, -0.0024793886113911867, 0.03476700931787491, 0.004076171200722456, -0.061447709798812866, 0.004248057492077351, 0.051198430359363556, -0.0057617914862930775, -0.02820105291903019, 0.03783915191888809, 0.0012094246922060847, 0.045810602605342865, -0.03001021035015583, -0.02896922454237938, -0.01846933551132679, -0.03493727371096611, 0.04153692349791527, 0.07737443596124649, -0.026771197095513344, 0.005603428930044174, -0.012176934629678726, -0.03507264330983162, -0.03120209462940693, -0.013084976002573967, -0.014012321829795837, 0.017427032813429832, 0.039159536361694336, -0.06297191232442856, 0.00018732754688244313, 0.005593276582658291, 0.025055358186364174, -0.010954116471111774, 0.03777230903506279, 0.07099850475788116, 0.0017762075876817107, -0.008782384917140007, 0.030648397281765938, -0.025980787351727486, -0.059526797384023666, -0.02547193318605423, 0.009259163402020931, 0.015208078548312187, -0.016358284279704094, 0.040063947439193726, 0.0025419348385185003, -0.007655569817870855, 0.08303296566009521, 0.010408674366772175, 0.05159097537398338, -0.04600977897644043, -0.06962765753269196, -0.03115764446556568, -0.0015880810096859932, -0.01362951472401619, 0.011081780306994915, -0.03085900843143463, -0.008671116083860397, 0.014636394567787647, 0.022212686017155647, 0.03283225744962692, -0.0030612233094871044, -0.03306713327765465, 0.03724680095911026, 0.0026017671916633844, -0.027918318286538124, 0.014138804748654366, -0.03969400376081467, -0.027029497548937798, -0.04829277843236923, -0.05678210034966469, 0.00022516283206641674, -0.0001719446445349604, -0.0060129547491669655, -0.02003518119454384, 0.04523203521966934, -0.012574010528624058, -0.004586647730320692, -0.022984175011515617, 0.0267570149153471, -0.025169149041175842, 0.03928174078464508, 0.005659423302859068, 0.018693696707487106, -0.02253764308989048, -0.037614770233631134, 0.03638956695795059, 0.03019901178777218, 0.010366427712142467, 0.048225197941064835, -0.019055750221014023, 0.005972883198410273, -0.060237541794776917, 0.04021848365664482, 0.010475605726242065, -0.0008357976912520826, -0.005658084526658058, 0.0032494545448571444, -0.02395867183804512, 0.019403133541345596, 0.041362278163433075, 0.032254114747047424, 0.006264268886297941, 0.04672839865088463, -0.04837705194950104, -0.05826735123991966, -0.06572528928518295, 0.0010179630480706692, -0.009990562684834003, -0.029187820851802826, 0.008835650980472565, 0.04058760032057762, 0.003950896672904491, 0.020702684298157692, -0.006345106288790703, -0.017280085012316704, -0.04403568059206009, 0.018385818228125572, 0.003231034381315112, -0.002226948505267501, 0.07830171287059784, 0.05744059383869171, -0.018914926797151566, 0.0389842614531517, -0.03372965380549431, -0.028866343200206757, -0.0032413688022643328, -0.03249252587556839, 0.011961530894041061, -0.016023341566324234, 0.029086915776133537, 0.03712671995162964, 0.01711544394493103, -0.018589887768030167, 0.04746098816394806, -0.02359696663916111, 0.047629665583372116, 0.08619502931833267, 0.018171127885580063, 0.024816716089844704, -0.011165937408804893, 0.010260619223117828, 0.009589713998138905, -0.018931029364466667, -0.012640981934964657, -0.07711426913738251, 0.010584532283246517, 0.013346806168556213, 0.025727001950144768, -0.047442831099033356, -0.019754324108362198, 0.052471380680799484, -0.009371064603328705, 0.02540178969502449, 0.029860299080610275, -0.026005128398537636, -0.010411336086690426, 0.025540666654706, 0.029219023883342743, 0.028568260371685028, -0.02153017371892929, 0.06280609220266342, 0.007336923386901617, 0.08721530437469482, -0.010357130318880081, -0.04311938211321831, 0.04485992342233658, -0.011075210757553577, 0.007856755517423153, -0.03853905200958252, -0.026699267327785492, 0.03813977539539337, -0.006695983000099659, 0.015260851942002773, 0.02753952331840992, -0.026808297261595726, 0.027280312031507492, 0.019357286393642426, -0.02595878206193447, 0.011746888980269432, 0.05389193072915077, -0.024389145895838737, -0.023343615233898163, 0.015002542175352573, -0.07193189859390259, 0.012010378763079643, 0.0008820713846944273, -0.051821768283843994, -0.02473561465740204, 0.03209203481674194, 0.02562149614095688, 0.047296419739723206, 0.02045048028230667, -0.036518778651952744, -0.0474979504942894, -0.04209986329078674, -0.004197262693196535, 0.012956300750374794, 0.028874915093183517, -0.023519214242696762, -0.0355067141354084, 0.0009565396467223763, -0.033265724778175354, -0.010115999728441238, 0.007584067992866039, -0.012991250492632389, -0.004940708167850971, -0.030634285882115364, 0.0017901762621477246, -0.013303598389029503, -0.009545387700200081, 0.02558561973273754, -0.046412836760282516, -0.029033903032541275, 0.053240060806274414, 0.035475168377161026, -0.02683320641517639, 0.0016185069689527154, -0.03125668317079544, -0.032500796020030975, -0.040373172610998154, 0.006126886699348688, 0.02947509102523327, 0.0035405673552304506, 0.009641879238188267, 0.0032904536928981543, -0.01565302535891533, 0.03315788507461548, -0.058003608137369156, -0.05593496561050415, 0.02208610624074936, -0.02551831677556038, 0.05021807551383972, -0.001228685025125742, 0.005553059745579958, 0.06453783810138702, 0.034330155700445175, -0.02048279158771038, -0.017525525763630867, 0.019967248663306236, -0.04113294184207916, -0.013048408553004265, 0.03787167742848396, -0.027358373627066612, 0.030364075675606728, 0.018797660246491432, -0.000025490893676760606, 0.014455306343734264, 0.026795778423547745, -0.008887399919331074, -0.0319778211414814, 0.032305240631103516, 0.027129121124744415, -0.0225009024143219, 0.033614080399274826, -0.00872736144810915, 0.006392146460711956, 0.040243104100227356, -0.04948893189430237, -0.00020043690165039152, -0.006878896150738001, -0.05128638446331024, -0.011612738482654095, 0.01432754471898079, 0.0001322809257544577, -0.041310351341962814, 0.027874834835529327, 0.0058471765369176865, -0.08095850050449371, -0.003649585647508502, 0.042647067457437515, 0.03560137748718262, -0.03633955121040344, -0.031119845807552338, 0.05180693790316582, 0.02948135696351528, -0.019123228266835213, -0.015463419258594513, -0.003623216412961483, -0.014418622478842735, -0.009014856070280075, -0.011732031591236591, 0.0077017564326524734, 0.009048935025930405, 0.04394421726465225, 0.04817516729235649, -0.03930792957544327, -0.03961215913295746, 0.015384511090815067, -0.03534390777349472, -0.00011734472354874015, -0.009138458408415318, 0.06474870443344116, 0.018603576347231865, 0.05144454538822174, 0.029405485838651657, 0.009909780696034431, -0.009395413100719452, -0.0006687897839583457, -0.07593704760074615, 0.028217434883117676, 0.011161704547703266, 0.007682652212679386, -0.009438795037567616, -0.041664332151412964, 0.025183670222759247, -0.027332931756973267, 0.010743298567831516, 0.018894780427217484, 0.018429052084684372, -0.022506244480609894, -0.02092529460787773, -0.000166446014191024, 0.003703588619828224, -0.006556386593729258, -0.010209381580352783, 0.03256247192621231, 0.0015710762236267328, 0.0061590406112372875, 0.03112676925957203, 0.004272358492016792, -0.023923911154270172, -0.04950283095240593, 0.022523866966366768, -0.007185547612607479, 0.04103073850274086, 0.01730429381132126, 0.016833212226629257, -0.012030228972434998, 0.030290821567177773, 0.0024766873102635145, 0.059027619659900665, 0.045378997921943665, -0.028518304228782654, 0.016854703426361084, -0.034064751118421555, -0.029903162270784378, -0.043788790702819824, 0.016506297513842583, -0.007375567220151424, -0.007539853919297457, 0.08461598306894302, 0.016696391627192497, -0.022849591448903084, 0.02927584759891033, 0.04817085713148117, 0.04889094829559326, 0.02826058678328991, -0.02572321705520153, 0.001912174397148192, -0.0453239344060421, 0.047876499593257904, 0.02345352992415428, -0.0010233158245682716, -0.0012460708385333419, 0.013517620973289013, 0.02819007635116577, -0.023904675617814064, -0.017580734565854073, 0.017644990235567093, 0.02752484194934368, 0.06091377139091492, -0.04184386134147644, -0.01726471446454525, 0.0159470122307539, 0.0181526318192482, 0.018261337652802467, -0.006083175539970398, -0.011032767593860626, -0.09837058931589127, -0.01510741375386715, 0.04001598805189133, 0.051070213317871094, 0.006176506634801626, 0.009990125894546509, -0.07048007845878601, -0.002512297360226512, 0.0382072851061821, -0.044532615691423416, -0.0015159648610278964, -0.032947707921266556, 0.021446486935019493, -0.02762278914451599, -0.03654125705361366, -0.07429026812314987, 0.0031875018030405045, -0.03572810813784599, 0.03415002301335335, -0.05495666712522507, -0.045350831001996994, -0.03222382068634033, 0.051482513546943665, -0.004948416259139776, 0.032165028154850006, -0.010500641539692879, -0.01683708466589451, 0.02777988649904728, -0.030370669439435005, -0.012738902121782303, -0.06647519767284393, 0.010135406628251076, 0.013640502467751503, 0.04500741884112358, 0.03843283653259277, -0.007882625795900822, -0.03756232559680939, 0.01274900883436203, 0.018438957631587982, -0.039202503859996796, -0.005818131845444441, -0.03259797394275665, 0.018805846571922302, 0.0038287080824375153, -0.006783387158066034, 0.04532979428768158, 0.05777478963136673, -0.021135371178388596, 0.021351400762796402, -0.060048338025808334, -0.0015879011480137706, 0.0056092101149261, -0.026415426284074783, -0.054989881813526154, 0.004859301261603832, -0.024995259940624237, 0.0055487193167209625, -0.005058608017861843, 0.00396894384175539, -0.022489206865429878, 0.015598266385495663, 0.04688344523310661, 0.060697127133607864, 0.014561490155756474, 0.002550913253799081, 0.0031634734477847815, 0.00845363549888134, 0.02636774070560932, -0.024874623864889145, 0.00919309351593256, -0.003564395010471344, -0.011781875044107437, -0.00926635880023241, -0.04641791433095932, 0.01664607785642147, -0.03370293974876404, -0.02809935435652733, 0.02849474921822548, -0.061785344034433365, 0.025231435894966125, -0.010624944232404232, 0.017987394705414772, -0.01303014438599348, -0.05963797867298126, -0.004095730371773243, -0.018349265679717064, 0.010196392424404621, 0.03488614037632942, -0.02445034869015217, 0.014750299975275993, 0.0032039261423051357, -0.000424557103542611, -0.06685076653957367, -0.03939570114016533, -0.0031760982237756252, -0.010042891837656498, -0.0340765155851841, -0.04224235564470291, -0.015704359859228134, -0.0008368247072212398, -0.02561117708683014, 0.01916179433465004, 0.034948792308568954, -0.014985703863203526, -0.009631198830902576, 0.01727381721138954, -0.01630857214331627, 0.07826828211545944, 0.01487539242953062, 0.0011108602629974484, 0.02669626846909523, 0.003448686795309186, -0.03108692355453968, 0.04923834651708603, -0.006845444440841675, -0.02010236494243145, -0.011911100707948208, 0.014702528715133667, 0.009728183038532734, 0.023841561749577522, -0.009306676685810089, -0.01596926525235176, -0.020593347027897835, -0.005361206363886595, 0.04044611006975174, -0.034856248646974564, -0.005047899205237627, -0.01655258797109127, -0.002275597071275115, -0.020611179992556572, 0.019591841846704483, -0.02000470459461212, -0.0009838818805292249, 0.037109144032001495, -0.0274145919829607, 0.004280341323465109, 0.033799782395362854, 0.08096890896558762, 0.00046210590517148376, 0.01650744304060936, -0.022237639874219894, -0.031845081597566605, 0.035077087581157684, -0.010209866799414158, -0.02602090686559677, 0.05532148480415344, 0.04813259467482567, -0.0019113164162263274, -0.004376044496893883, -0.06392629444599152, -0.012185757048428059, 0.02843518741428852, 0.006391318514943123, 0.06796509772539139, 0.024236636236310005, 0.01852920837700367, 0.01660008914768696, 0.0016587934223935008, -0.01239332091063261, -0.0036087369080632925, 0.013941731303930283, 0.04158933833241463, 0.006149145308881998, 0.03999331593513489, 0.05277349799871445, 0.003162225941196084, 0.04263973981142044, 0.04499838501214981, 0.009117339737713337, 0.030233722180128098, 0.04873846843838692, -0.02188107743859291, -0.01062745414674282, 0.018612388521432877, -0.040750544518232346, 0.03692947328090668, -0.014887149445712566, -0.06257050484418869, 0.021641995757818222, 0.042460400611162186, -0.0002679850731510669, 0.00003723770350916311, -0.007266825530678034, -0.043473370373249054, 0.03693264722824097, 0.039176095277071, 0.03275694698095322, 0.03196290507912636, -0.003950569778680801, 0.034414954483509064, -0.0016599781811237335, 0.045219991356134415, -0.023817863315343857, -0.0573047511279583, -0.02329179272055626, -0.014238998293876648, -0.042225826531648636, 0.016844328492879868, -0.007724866736680269, 0.006076319608837366, 0.01566806621849537, -0.01733672432601452, 0.0418521910905838, 0.0033237270545214415, 0.03153263032436371, -0.008459322154521942, 0.08340797573328018, -0.01797552965581417, -0.012381467968225479, 0.017263757064938545, 0.017357341945171356, 0.1358078122138977, 0.06869635730981827, 0.045212991535663605, -0.06699401140213013, -0.021823838353157043, 0.018553435802459717, 0.005227086134254932, -0.022342173382639885, 0.017455168068408966, 0.0251582283526659, 0.006478301249444485, 0.0463448204100132, 0.03099880740046501, 0.007647034712135792, 0.000025773180823307484, 0.06268756091594696, -0.004244731739163399, -0.022847451269626617, -0.016435673460364342, -0.007908705621957779, 0.01173507422208786, 0.00410793861374259, -0.05175039544701576, 0.012777398340404034, -0.0016138320788741112, -0.010559475980699062, -0.01431732065975666, 0.024981455877423286, -0.05853796750307083, 0.03390251845121384, -0.02256464585661888, -0.019199416041374207, 0.038741935044527054, -0.028192197903990746, 0.019215067848563194, -0.014885740354657173, -0.030792171135544777, -0.014979842118918896, -0.00654177600517869, 0.028706539422273636, -0.02184644713997841, 0.0003333692438900471, 0.019689565524458885, 0.028995895758271217, -0.026081720367074013, -0.001322709140367806, -0.03358326852321625, 0.035892512649297714, -0.018694300204515457, 0.0054298765026032925, 0.026259642094373703, 0.0034032382536679506, 0.022458093240857124, -0.02941993996500969, 0.0010713201481848955, -0.009129435755312443, 0.023816915228962898, -0.050144799053668976, -0.025892550125718117, -0.05476761609315872, 0.001404574024491012, 0.009022366255521774, 0.029180828481912613, 0.04434860125184059, 0.0064911553636193275, -0.043439727276563644, -0.025291752070188522, 0.05649532005190849, -0.028011443093419075, -0.014922614209353924, 0.0578884594142437, -0.059416208416223526, -0.019050033763051033, -0.0011059127282351255, 0.004760397598147392, 0.002672875300049782, 0.04335324466228485, 0.014909525401890278, 0.008291392587125301, 0.003633511019870639, -0.05157315731048584, -0.012322580441832542, -0.04317646473646164, -0.002713211812078953, -0.030865229666233063, -0.031935401260852814, 0.03371990844607353, 0.0462474599480629, -0.00608479930087924, 0.006089052185416222, 0.0040013049729168415, 0.07058775424957275, 0.010756720788776875, -0.037563472986221313, -0.008916749618947506, 0.019042346626520157, -0.018886767327785492, 0.02203395403921604, -0.0291113443672657, 0.02187105268239975, -0.013722991570830345, 0.014119759202003479, 0.007598640862852335, 0.018975133076310158, -0.011939962394535542, 0.04921780899167061, -0.02431117184460163, -0.0362776555120945, 0.00479490589350462, 0.006615431047976017, 0.0017136334208771586, -0.01422504149377346, -0.01792159304022789, -0.02567899040877819, -0.0401146300137043, 0.003213458228856325, -0.0030898076947778463, -0.06899573653936386, 0.0022645252756774426, -0.021884910762310028, -0.037247467786073685, 0.011624936945736408, -0.0010881064226850867, -0.03677254915237427, -0.04453298822045326, -0.02550218440592289, -0.026235239580273628, 0.014270325191318989, -0.02066064439713955, -0.014479790814220905, 0.03319750726222992, 0.015037760138511658, 0.022985335439443588, 0.0015071193920448422, 0.03423314914107323, 0.04643901064991951, 0.02668881230056286, 0.057239484041929245, -0.0042024352587759495, -0.001855985028669238, 0.0629911944270134, -0.05360324680805206, -0.01766553334891796, 0.015638362616300583, -0.021691838279366493, 0.024325449019670486, 0.00954755675047636, -0.009507758542895317, 0.01286351215094328, 0.009878241457045078, -0.0355699248611927, -0.005873543210327625, -0.01859474554657936, -0.026073606684803963, 0.009443748742341995, 0.021748477593064308, -0.008195620961487293, 0.027804428711533546, -0.02424950711429119, 0.061566613614559174, 0.025450384244322777, 0.032369986176490784, 0.024598656222224236, 0.0020896103233098984, -0.036648187786340714, 0.010211892426013947, 0.003481115447357297, -0.00422042328864336, 0.022605685517191887, 0.05290234833955765, -0.02167554758489132, 0.013441330753266811, -0.07291698455810547, -0.026886792853474617, -0.0921943411231041, -0.0073174177668988705, 0.03153887018561363, -0.005091452039778233, 0.03294286131858826, -0.03746308013796806, -0.01557580754160881, -0.0003007968480233103, 0.016663890331983566, 0.020612014457583427, 0.0022707541938871145, -0.018117861822247505, -0.020527465268969536, -0.028875984251499176, -0.03974117338657379, 0.034780461341142654, 0.028698446229100227, 0.03664042055606842, 0.020467007532715797, 0.021876690909266472, 0.016880707815289497, -0.012398628517985344, 0.0014698478626087308, 0.020038094371557236, 0.014080164022743702, -0.0655038133263588, 0.036035969853401184, -0.04981444403529167, -0.014230716042220592, 0.0039196009747684, -0.0196071844547987, 0.015491975471377373, 0.038876913487911224, 0.015189239755272865, -0.014270009472966194, 0.07168375700712204, 0.05143813416361809, 0.0265213456004858, -0.01684720814228058, 0.016315439715981483, -0.0111891720443964, 0.04185079038143158, -0.03536621108651161, 0.029194936156272888, 0.04182732477784157, -0.017728516831994057, -0.04043760523200035, -0.002617674646899104, 0.0035650120116770267, -0.005033467896282673, 0.014327012933790684, -0.0037980738561600447, 0.010342951864004135, -0.0019046962261199951, 0.015563223510980606, -0.06784762442111969, 0.03452128544449806, 0.027841730043292046, 0.029762353748083115, -0.019190240651369095, -0.007172700483351946, -0.02012452483177185, -0.05416150763630867, -0.009045679122209549, -0.012769874185323715, -0.03701402246952057, -0.027453139424324036, 0.004727233201265335, -0.024727830663323402, 0.037344641983509064, -0.03146008402109146, 0.014949580654501915, -0.008408109657466412, 0.021952977403998375, -0.07367837429046631, 0.017430337145924568, 0.04369509592652321, -0.026840832084417343, 0.020727651193737984, -0.09828345477581024, 0.038165315985679626, 0.008975514210760593, -0.018467187881469727, -0.051181361079216, -0.028619401156902313, -0.012880304828286171, -0.0009368006139993668, 0.01535245031118393, 0.027157850563526154, -0.021074719727039337, -0.014972513541579247, 0.010409216396510601, 0.01058831438422203, -0.04228592291474342, 0.004932614509016275, -0.04694671183824539, -0.04846496134996414, -0.0012589298421517015, -0.009477481245994568, 0.005850081332027912, 0.03624087572097778, -0.009143118746578693, -0.011541335843503475, 0.017703546211123466, 0.007921192795038223, -0.06632179021835327, 0.020105870440602303, -0.015802713111042976, -0.012424436397850513, 0.04009510949254036, 0.031173212453722954, 0.009650526568293571, 0.02067854441702366, -0.013621397316455841, -0.04678284004330635, 0.036948949098587036, -0.022345390170812607, -0.014102935791015625, 0.01763496920466423, 0.003362771589308977, 0.011158127337694168, -0.05277220159769058, 0.02614770643413067, -0.01856115087866783, -0.0383489616215229, 0.014329920522868633, 0.0026319827884435654, 0.017090966925024986, 0.03665309399366379, -0.0023523285053670406, 0.019438251852989197, 0.0052145603112876415, -0.02311478741466999, 0.021400325000286102, 0.00903892982751131, 0.01810402236878872, -0.022153299301862717, 0.030304640531539917, 0.031178565695881844, -0.006076994352042675, -0.00969192385673523, 0.007366267964243889, 0.045136719942092896, -0.006860743742436171, -0.009998846799135208, 0.01811748929321766, -0.002573688980191946, -0.005880889482796192, 0.007922184653580189, -0.016137927770614624, 0.04981295019388199, -0.021093277260661125, 0.021494030952453613, 0.0025555347092449665, -0.06889267265796661, -0.015802891924977303, 0.04816067963838577, 0.0073790219612419605, 0.02881441079080105, -0.010840392671525478, -0.0015693589812144637, -0.019634170457720757, -0.006695107091218233, 0.01812148280441761, -0.021835733205080032, 0.002523662755265832, 0.0032673359382897615, 0.014090401120483875, -0.017824500799179077, -0.014715499244630337, 0.017043137922883034, -0.031223120167851448, 0.012484368868172169, 0.010251493193209171, 0.009404675103724003, -0.023666946217417717, -0.00978357158601284, 0.009924555197358131, 0.05616896227002144, -0.08616726100444794, -0.03194519504904747, -0.07248730212450027, -0.02660226635634899, 0.0017141778953373432, -0.024768106639385223 ]
<p>Suppose I have a data set, and have trained up a regression model (happens to be a bayesian linear model, I'm just using the R package). The model outputs a wide range of values, greater than 0 and less than 0, although the actual output can only be greater than 0.</p> <p>Is there an accepted away to apply bounds to the output of a model to "force" it into a possible value? Or is it perhaps an indicator that I'm doing something wrong or applying the wrong technique to my problem?</p>
37,295
[ -0.011171427555382252, 0.029421720653772354, -0.020946597680449486, 0.006209531333297491, 0.03222300112247467, 0.008375945501029491, -0.01635275036096573, 0.0007611340843141079, 0.022821925580501556, -0.00580903934314847, 0.03312953934073448, 0.015157537534832954, 0.06139126792550087, -0.01677289977669716, 0.021429739892482758, 0.022016573697328568, -0.042120277881622314, -0.02844472974538803, -0.019630854949355125, 0.00819474272429943, 0.007900583557784557, 0.060612525790929794, -0.000051462495321175084, -0.018591446802020073, -0.016588790342211723, 0.020014427602291107, 0.06105731055140495, 0.010572290979325771, 0.0030121251475065947, 0.05500471591949463, -0.011749173514544964, -0.03491104394197464, 0.017073191702365875, 0.05019741505384445, 0.058759309351444244, 0.0035630303900688887, 0.006955134682357311, -0.0552077516913414, -0.019702034071087837, 0.02719350904226303, -0.024270974099636078, -0.019129902124404907, 0.032630983740091324, 0.025923116132616997, -0.0037291287444531918, 0.0022074650041759014, 0.020147040486335754, -0.023439818993210793, 0.04914599657058716, -0.02008696272969246, 0.07665281742811203, -0.004544628784060478, -0.01623990200459957, 0.06751084327697754, 0.010268461890518665, -0.004662733059376478, 0.08116308599710464, 0.06093660742044449, -0.02138897031545639, -0.056924428790807724, -0.02639068476855755, -0.0644964799284935, -0.005665802396833897, -0.003762825159355998, -0.014637765474617481, 0.017553767189383507, 0.017199022695422173, -0.011458578519523144, 0.002554692793637514, -0.02162652648985386, 0.00023667869390919805, 0.027852637693285942, 0.02240978181362152, -0.01868262141942978, 0.04282371699810028, -0.031101884320378304, 0.02404111996293068, 0.01713346689939499, 0.012221241369843483, 0.05013919249176979, 0.004578074440360069, 0.02104858309030533, 0.033299319446086884, 0.06666389107704163, 0.017520178109407425, -0.012560018338263035, 0.052039794623851776, -0.05057197064161301, 0.030352281406521797, 0.024989347904920578, -0.033574383705854416, 0.011730422265827656, 0.03900410979986191, -0.02002626471221447, -0.042505450546741486, 0.028110144659876823, 0.01819782331585884, 0.04742790758609772, -0.015512172132730484, -0.04386094585061073, -0.01823686622083187, -0.04326493665575981, -0.023320110514760017, 0.056190866976976395, -0.04362683370709419, -0.01796206831932068, 0.003785561304539442, -0.015532400459051132, -0.011356943286955357, -0.01873202621936798, -0.01599089987576008, 0.023630885407328606, 0.006122032646089792, 0.008501065894961357, -0.019623177126049995, -0.02462189644575119, -0.010283342562615871, -0.045368511229753494, 0.043139152228832245, 0.03888625651597977, 0.05711248889565468, -0.03917185217142105, 0.04344736784696579, -0.012721355073153973, -0.0460316464304924, -0.008907796815037727, 0.013199208304286003, -0.0448140911757946, -0.06534989178180695, 0.048549920320510864, 0.01316823624074459, -0.03283248096704483, 0.048807814717292786, 0.0016885575605556369, 0.03320565074682236, -0.022315988317131996, -0.06751399487257004, -0.05776824429631233, 0.020140431821346283, -0.010314583778381348, 0.002406703308224678, -0.05011966824531555, -0.005310246255248785, 0.01773998886346817, 0.05158684030175209, 0.02886335551738739, 0.039347175508737564, 0.0069230785593390465, 0.016209693625569344, -0.044711675494909286, -0.012653738260269165, -0.010585577227175236, -0.024077029898762703, -0.030545253306627274, -0.02456866391003132, -0.08042307198047638, 0.0271749310195446, 0.007427038624882698, -0.019492316991090775, 0.0006310075987130404, 0.059948209673166275, -0.032625436782836914, -0.01286255195736885, -0.005294533912092447, -0.021146288141608238, -0.009884375147521496, 0.08682963252067566, 0.003702800488099456, 0.04585810378193855, 0.02230127714574337, 0.017307188361883163, 0.0068692355416715145, 0.02234983630478382, 0.062283292412757874, 0.06162373349070549, -0.02684801258146763, -0.01700650341808796, -0.054267190396785736, 0.041517045348882675, 0.021723588928580284, -0.03763202205300331, 0.01883200742304325, -0.020774025470018387, 0.011396393179893494, -0.005740607623010874, 0.001222483697347343, -0.021355394273996353, -0.010602620430290699, 0.03869485855102539, -0.05012303963303566, -0.020500585436820984, -0.07420355826616287, 0.012647991068661213, 0.009002321399748325, -0.015728646889328957, 0.027196040377020836, -0.0063404212705791, 0.020754417404532433, -0.04775594174861908, -0.018341809511184692, -0.04836120828986168, -0.04160623624920845, 0.026057694107294083, -0.02038106694817543, -0.0023461049422621727, 0.059492629021406174, 0.04763060808181763, -0.01863238215446472, 0.029665963724255562, -0.08622977882623672, -0.06083344295620918, -0.006769758183509111, -0.004051550291478634, -0.0049985237419605255, -0.01374633889645338, 0.01798303611576557, 0.005071363877505064, -0.029482441022992134, -0.022826453670859337, 0.028017938137054443, -0.041122809052467346, 0.062020860612392426, 0.10379208624362946, 0.027177095413208008, -0.024912100285291672, 0.0060674580745399, 0.0019635530188679695, 0.019040219485759735, -0.061823755502700806, -0.02379656210541725, -0.04814087972044945, -0.00042336422484368086, 0.00037732734926976264, 0.022646429017186165, -0.009810643270611763, 0.017555978149175644, 0.03239968419075012, 0.010308288037776947, 0.021254347637295723, 0.02748042717576027, -0.022164147347211838, 0.02552139014005661, 0.008082065731287003, 0.004667193628847599, 0.052700333297252655, 0.031423360109329224, 0.013434788212180138, 0.008922414854168892, 0.03796882554888725, 0.00020806340035051107, 0.010503256693482399, 0.018664181232452393, -0.009618224576115608, -0.00903325155377388, 0.006738070398569107, -0.0061700185760855675, 0.017315726727247238, -0.034821104258298874, 0.013302219100296497, 0.015949713066220284, 0.014593467116355896, 0.0005363949458114803, 0.0050963107496500015, 0.009706500917673111, 0.013612057082355022, 0.03266089782118797, -0.03880007937550545, 0.00028288623434491456, 0.03929086774587631, -0.04916819557547569, 0.007395773660391569, -0.004741481970995665, -0.04234065115451813, -0.0689915344119072, 0.04321715980768204, 0.07591287046670914, 0.006137647666037083, 0.041065480560064316, -0.04889894276857376, -0.01436811126768589, -0.009933635592460632, -0.011217711493372917, -0.0024473979137837887, -0.010947377420961857, -0.02212974801659584, 0.01927068829536438, -0.01550163421779871, -0.030098816379904747, 0.041435182094573975, -0.027455514296889305, 0.01851392351090908, 0.02997809648513794, -0.02981513924896717, -0.012757519260048866, -0.04665878415107727, -0.04451378062367439, -0.01904834248125553, 0.003056761808693409, -0.03400714695453644, 0.045185625553131104, 0.02232256904244423, -0.06730403006076813, 0.0028102793730795383, -0.025321420282125473, 0.00739102391526103, -0.07492950558662415, -0.0021377711091190577, 0.01143801212310791, 0.018081819638609886, 0.06068875640630722, 0.028211621567606926, -0.022618761286139488, 0.017481975257396698, -0.07539569586515427, -0.043220408260822296, 0.00016832182882353663, -0.0011347619583830237, 0.014216549694538116, 0.011391112580895424, 0.012983091175556183, 0.1026192158460617, 0.03909759595990181, 0.0015318820951506495, -0.03875550255179405, -0.022680938243865967, -0.011415747925639153, -0.03984514996409416, -0.02031916007399559, -0.005593935493379831, 0.002086721593514085, 0.03702276945114136, -0.03784921392798424, 0.056086815893650055, 0.009411009028553963, -0.0001287656050408259, -0.029413655400276184, 0.016232052817940712, 0.012348756194114685, -0.01342547032982111, 0.005099749192595482, 0.05411219969391823, 0.022324373945593834, 0.04021316394209862, -0.026033444330096245, 0.06907341629266739, 0.017586197704076767, -0.014833576045930386, -0.007841551676392555, 0.010897085070610046, 0.030384721234440804, -0.008699229918420315, 0.0548241063952446, 0.0056729125790297985, -0.018757013604044914, -0.02320893481373787, 0.025042198598384857, 0.02533983252942562, -0.023747803643345833, 0.012120893225073814, 0.055131204426288605, 0.011306876316666603, -0.003936262335628271, -0.008953330107033253, 0.004782788455486298, 0.021040214225649834, 0.009914943017065525, 0.0027100176084786654, -0.019315451383590698, 0.04311611130833626, -0.001002420554868877, 0.025311555713415146, -0.0010171987814828753, -0.048924677073955536, 0.0027713028248399496, -0.04229157418012619, -0.026508362963795662, 0.005599811673164368, 0.04447450861334801, 0.007413060870021582, 0.01686922088265419, 0.028192495927214622, 0.016237309202551842, 0.03415463864803314, 0.003261103993281722, -0.051108844578266144, 0.01917842961847782, -0.01015633437782526, -0.025603100657463074, -0.01304232981055975, -0.019862137734889984, 0.008277477696537971, -0.03671685978770256, 0.00833469070494175, -0.006474101450294256, 0.03610561415553093, -0.020942848175764084, -0.009186810813844204, -0.03690877556800842, -0.010399510152637959, 0.0009389586048200727, -0.024755235761404037, 0.042066168040037155, -0.02464853785932064, 0.03862150013446808, 0.030953260138630867, -0.012143440544605255, -0.01755823940038681, -0.007279726676642895, 0.015334010124206543, -0.0011994921369478106, 0.06374873965978622, 0.007508584763854742, 0.043984830379486084, -0.05961073562502861, 0.022146865725517273, 0.007755419705063105, 0.037313733249902725, 0.0452914796769619, -0.021978402510285378, -0.03807521611452103, -0.03298301622271538, -0.033316608518362045, 0.00413375161588192, 0.0020205634646117687, -0.013402898795902729, 0.005211911164224148, 0.04560272768139839, 0.004113312810659409, -0.04547576978802681, 0.026834014803171158, 0.07962214201688766, 0.020739169791340828, -0.01110131200402975, -0.002104668878018856, -0.009903721511363983, -0.00002472559572197497, 0.010385233908891678, -0.005962241441011429, -0.016522597521543503, -0.00983016099780798, -0.005893427412956953, 0.01651412434875965, 0.009407436475157738, -0.0222453773021698, -0.020463721826672554, 0.01774250902235508, 0.044874757528305054, 0.004169095307588577, -0.018170785158872604, 0.046910952776670456, 0.029494930058717728, 0.016667528077960014, 0.02713535912334919, 0.008481229655444622, -0.11317497491836548, -0.004739050753414631, 0.042666587978601456, 0.031622376292943954, -0.007788101211190224, 0.005489524453878403, -0.05348525196313858, -0.016624530777335167, 0.036655861884355545, -0.05335211008787155, 0.032094262540340424, 0.0006758045055903494, 0.048885248601436615, -0.003391494508832693, -0.007408041972666979, -0.03442531079053879, 0.025435999035835266, -0.029268192127346992, 0.059310879558324814, -0.009794739075005054, -0.037488363683223724, -0.053782280534505844, 0.030081873759627342, -0.015441564843058586, 0.05521124228835106, -0.029611431062221527, -0.02255779504776001, 0.03479594737291336, -0.025815386325120926, -0.00258434540592134, -0.05357181280851364, 0.01146154198795557, 0.013015604577958584, -0.019904538989067078, 0.02963942475616932, -0.025960242375731468, -0.03838861361145973, 0.011095330119132996, -0.013618114404380322, -0.0323745422065258, -0.013042648322880268, -0.012808029539883137, 0.03245307505130768, 0.007653510197997093, 0.009469018317759037, 0.05201619863510132, 0.03687511384487152, 0.03369569405913353, 0.000850628362968564, -0.027776120230555534, 0.01958201266825199, -0.013739379122853279, -0.021728208288550377, -0.06819303333759308, -0.024722035974264145, -0.00552613427862525, 0.013688430190086365, 0.014669187366962433, 0.04114042595028877, 0.017126956954598427, -0.02572054974734783, -0.00843110028654337, 0.0509459525346756, -0.020172081887722015, -0.013935266993939877, -0.030276188626885414, 0.04007180780172348, -0.06764654070138931, -0.024093661457300186, 0.024255182594060898, 0.012870952486991882, 0.014671181328594685, 0.03436468169093132, -0.041367582976818085, 0.02688787505030632, 0.006421108264476061, -0.012502133846282959, 0.00043695009662769735, -0.040287792682647705, 0.04349852353334427, 0.0028951908461749554, 0.0000691162931616418, -0.026337938383221626, -0.01715831644833088, 0.02518133632838726, 0.0013763461029157043, -0.014491153880953789, 0.011554109863936901, -0.06425463408231735, 0.03665980324149132, -0.03673878684639931, 0.016638338565826416, -0.0509849488735199, -0.05152609571814537, -0.003350603161379695, -0.0036789197474718094, -0.017997069284319878, -0.017896078526973724, -0.014024121686816216, -0.008515548892319202, -0.0042892806231975555, -0.024942979216575623, 0.051361072808504105, -0.02823437750339508, 0.006362110376358032, -0.00675818370655179, -0.02038179151713848, 0.06980834156274796, 0.0030515892431139946, 0.007880283519625664, 0.036991335451602936, -0.003453006036579609, -0.0011946101440116763, 0.027497319504618645, -0.0011557849356904626, -0.039919815957546234, 0.0011370191350579262, -0.0303950272500515, 0.008485889993607998, 0.048485539853572845, 0.024693047627806664, 0.017048489302396774, 0.03164009004831314, 0.016954287886619568, 0.019591549411416054, -0.024346811696887016, 0.005761382635682821, -0.020915236324071884, -0.04056050628423691, -0.025250764563679695, 0.0037816897965967655, -0.015022898092865944, -0.03909088671207428, 0.04010144993662834, -0.009505035355687141, 0.011213465593755245, -0.019569281488656998, 0.056274645030498505, 0.016176816076040268, 0.013093262910842896, -0.003862188197672367, -0.007175599690526724, 0.054368410259485245, 0.04054643213748932, -0.011743695475161076, -0.015357468277215958, 0.009039151482284069, -0.050845492631196976, -0.05185863748192787, -0.0341041199862957, -0.04254460707306862, 0.05345333740115166, -0.04699670150876045, 0.07416035979986191, 0.050684764981269836, 0.019137706607580185, -0.0021442528814077377, -0.04565456509590149, -0.009347761049866676, -0.03590859845280647, 0.04133964329957962, 0.036969367414712906, -0.009161285124719143, 0.006424599327147007, 0.027904633432626724, -0.0012916242703795433, 0.023440245538949966, 0.016942577436566353, -0.016324643045663834, 0.028194380924105644, 0.05689599737524986, -0.02024957165122032, -0.026399023830890656, 0.03192153945565224, -0.02348644658923149, -0.0014467354631051421, -0.010236050002276897, -0.04484352096915245, 0.013725917786359787, 0.03507281094789505, 0.03188234940171242, -0.04956085607409477, -0.05048119276762009, -0.032908596098423004, 0.03660557046532631, 0.014775008894503117, -0.005087861325591803, 0.0394829660654068, -0.040412649512290955, 0.020952854305505753, 0.006238370668143034, 0.005068692844361067, -0.041144609451293945, -0.07082851231098175, -0.042711835354566574, -0.03760014846920967, 0.0007627923623658717, -0.0031673964112997055, 0.024710919708013535, 0.006193247158080339, 0.005764547269791365, -0.027839768677949905, 0.009235914796590805, 0.004468635190278292, 0.04793156310915947, 0.015476955100893974, 0.027061110362410545, -0.011701418086886406, -0.019317425787448883, 0.009405557997524738, 0.01512241829186678, 0.1123775914311409, 0.08040742576122284, 0.02332121692597866, -0.08315282315015793, 0.01056088786572218, -0.022473588585853577, -0.038407135754823685, -0.014188176020979881, 0.0030439456459134817, 0.025684896856546402, -0.003353677224367857, 0.007912366650998592, 0.024009712040424347, -0.0006592892459593713, 0.00469579454511404, 0.05552889034152031, -0.037419553846120834, 0.0042321691289544106, 0.023043399676680565, 0.04477328062057495, 0.01187436655163765, -0.006830098107457161, -0.03837168589234352, -0.006130265537649393, -0.004920173902064562, -0.04273774474859238, 0.0063373916782438755, -0.003787105903029442, 0.01209841575473547, -0.009633689187467098, -0.03672633320093155, -0.004003515001386404, 0.007291961461305618, 0.029720386490225792, 0.01407478004693985, -0.010584719479084015, 0.0025534704327583313, 0.003382776863873005, -0.05185795947909355, 0.03357064723968506, -0.01710629090666771, 0.007989033125340939, -0.007239935453981161, -0.013006124645471573, -0.03193378075957298, -0.05580911412835121, -0.01945255696773529, 0.037289224565029144, -0.024586938321590424, -0.011676707305014133, 0.021578524261713028, 0.014030656777322292, 0.0038007437251508236, -0.04566975682973862, -0.005061344709247351, 0.05070327967405319, 0.03723643347620964, 0.008621477521955967, -0.027176005765795708, 0.00771814351901412, 0.03515131026506424, 0.014713935554027557, 0.012974881567060947, 0.03219392150640488, -0.0260770246386528, -0.0010127451969310641, -0.028784632682800293, 0.0798943042755127, -0.009988101199269295, 0.008492760360240936, 0.025384513661265373, -0.0017920609097927809, -0.04721083119511604, -0.009532861411571503, 0.03191210329532623, -0.006374578922986984, -0.01537617202848196, 0.0016426121583208442, -0.007849699817597866, -0.03159778192639351, -0.03550088033080101, -0.00027483547455631196, -0.030239276587963104, 0.012191100046038628, -0.03749328851699829, -0.014383196830749512, 0.016444116830825806, 0.04165763035416603, 0.022420184686779976, -0.017678622156381607, -0.006171778775751591, 0.03996393457055092, 0.008019492961466312, -0.044358979910612106, -0.022531623020768166, 0.006246168632060289, -0.07376978546380997, 0.04382815957069397, 0.048860762268304825, 0.07753047347068787, 0.01187953632324934, 0.03026886284351349, -0.01939724199473858, 0.028812283650040627, -0.011971116997301579, 0.02197960577905178, 0.03288807347416878, -0.03850468993186951, 0.029397180303931236, 0.0058273314498364925, -0.0009859685087576509, -0.03147083520889282, -0.01859692856669426, -0.026952024549245834, -0.04952910542488098, 0.0011105976300314069, 0.0010249112965539098, -0.014944522641599178, 0.03258547559380531, 0.027595361694693565, 0.014103995636105537, -0.007579323835670948, 0.01368645764887333, -0.034764260053634644, 0.002100949641317129, 0.02209884114563465, -0.03969643637537956, 0.008689513429999352, -0.0007928941631689668, -0.04398859292268753, -0.012807007879018784, 0.03513135761022568, 0.00886654295027256, 0.03798258677124977, -0.022207161411643028, 0.01723850890994072, 0.005152126774191856, 0.0278845876455307, -0.046208176761865616, -0.034700293093919754, 0.02445782721042633, -0.0413641594350338, -0.028032474219799042, 0.021540142595767975, -0.015469974838197231, 0.033175233751535416, 0.018878431990742683, -0.013069961220026016, -0.03524639084935188, 0.061042044311761856, 0.005930239334702492, 0.01661638356745243, 0.008170947432518005, 0.005982933100312948, -0.009345225989818573, 0.005603958386927843, 0.04586869478225708, -0.0015106217470020056, 0.01775641180574894, -0.021876011043787003, 0.02837475948035717, 0.02653208002448082, -0.036951981484889984, -0.0036575873382389545, 0.012535124085843563, -0.013679688796401024, -0.030680902302265167, -0.027705548331141472, 0.022395864129066467, 0.02188306488096714, -0.02018016204237938, 0.045044515281915665, 0.017213478684425354, 0.03863496333360672, -0.11401757597923279, -0.0335722342133522, 0.00870688259601593, -0.01822495274245739, 0.02731410041451454, -0.0548844039440155, 0.018648464232683182, 0.006692081689834595, -0.03615352138876915, -0.015279250219464302, 0.001398736727423966, -0.005443343427032232, -0.006340928841382265, 0.020775504410266876, -0.01979426108300686, 0.01096371840685606, 0.025449540466070175, 0.01953572779893875, 0.009386430494487286, -0.005581853911280632, 0.010483497753739357, -0.025758011266589165, 0.010326200164854527, 0.052187204360961914, 0.0012890787329524755, -0.03987777233123779, 0.019551442936062813, -0.03540981188416481, -0.03089580126106739, 0.016678405925631523, -0.015849962830543518, 0.010810397565364838, 0.012528203427791595, 0.03488831967115402, 0.02796800620853901, 0.0628368929028511, 0.03476542979478836, 0.007083625998347998, -0.018843336030840874, 0.02443225495517254, -0.03211475536227226, -0.0012196042807772756, -0.03376409038901329, 0.03389875963330269, 0.028299527242779732, -0.01206522062420845, -0.024856042116880417, 0.019397540017962456, -0.030570384114980698, -0.007345117162913084, 0.01780451461672783, 0.01050423551350832, -0.009233550168573856, -0.052398014813661575, 0.027431420981884003, -0.02244637906551361, 0.011504482477903366, 0.023664813488721848, 0.04448138549923897, -0.059375930577516556, -0.016375847160816193, -0.030239665880799294, -0.05997716635465622, 0.02171342819929123, -0.0010119369253516197, -0.0383504293859005, -0.07185416668653488, 0.01667802408337593, -0.0009265356929972768, -0.03325323760509491, -0.04204116761684418, -0.009849403984844685, -0.0591217577457428, 0.03374859690666199, -0.011809182353317738, 0.02474772371351719, 0.03359226882457733, -0.023356812074780464, -0.009967582300305367, -0.07377733290195465, 0.1034831628203392, -0.015884824097156525, 0.04201864078640938, -0.03625127300620079, 0.0030429561156779528, -0.013033892959356308, -0.01197864767163992, 0.022749627009034157, 0.013737819157540798, 0.012108445167541504, -0.013835837133228779, 0.023263538256287575, -0.03515997901558876, 0.004907116759568453, 0.03113214485347271, 0.021621711552143097, -0.005965587683022022, -0.01872476004064083, -0.01275414228439331, -0.04098969325423241, 0.008191816508769989, -0.015803338959813118, 0.020240075886249542, 0.015853578224778175, 0.02093430794775486, -0.021166305989027023, 0.0390043668448925, 0.024376409128308296, 0.030807187780737877, 0.053436633199453354, 0.02343602105975151, 0.012160282582044601, 0.020377006381750107, 0.0036335294134914875, -0.04987787455320358, 0.05386851727962494, -0.03524399548768997, -0.03952900320291519, -0.007092994637787342, 0.019903454929590225, -0.017600229009985924, -0.014787520281970501, -0.0033378140069544315, 0.047447964549064636, -0.03312968090176582, 0.020280061289668083, 0.018042871728539467, 0.019191278144717216, 0.0449053980410099, -0.048570990562438965, 0.010909110307693481, -0.0047604902647435665, 0.013363663107156754, 0.007579604163765907, -0.00829318631440401, 0.05760956555604935, 0.009013005532324314, 0.05943286418914795, 0.053437698632478714, -0.02679351530969143, -0.0029353450518101454, -0.0007336457492783666, 0.01890614628791809, -0.017522843554615974, 0.014545624144375324, -0.00028191349701955914, -0.018403036519885063, -0.01397760771214962, -0.03876112028956413, 0.009023495949804783, 0.023861873894929886, -0.028778813779354095, -0.007968788966536522, -0.05157678201794624, 0.009544889442622662, 0.01621263287961483, 0.023040054365992546, -0.01489715650677681, 0.028408531099557877, 0.003275093389675021, -0.00004984484621672891, 0.004183261655271053, -0.010304323397576809, 0.03279818966984749, -0.021789100021123886, -0.007386138662695885, -0.005078771151602268, -0.008338998071849346, -0.025952545925974846, -0.047828979790210724, -0.03715105354785919, -0.0014277496375143528, 0.025829140096902847, 0.0320223905146122, 0.00028589501744136214, -0.018682902678847313, -0.03305048495531082, 0.002578413113951683, 0.017489681020379066, -0.0695439875125885, -0.026863574981689453, -0.04416080564260483, 0.041073717176914215, -0.03649450093507767, -0.0514073446393013 ]
<p><strong>I have logs from an autocomplete form, which I would like to leverage to increase the intelligence of the results it returns.</strong></p> <p>I have a project that revolves around users selecting opera characters from a database of ~15,000 unique characters. My difficulty is that each character appears in the database as only one name but it may also be known to the public by any number of other colloquial names.</p> <p>I have had been lucky enough to receive a modest amount of traffic and currently have ~20,000 rows of logs of strings which my users have typed and the opera character they ended up selecting.</p> <p>If a user doesn't find the character they are searching for with their first string, they will often try the character by another name. When they are successful, this data correlates the characters' colloquial names with the character itself. I am hoping to leverage this data to enable my autocomplete form to match against these colloquial names.</p> <p>Unfortunately along with the useful correlations there are many (perhaps more) random correlations. Often when a user's attempt(s) do not return the result they are looking for, instead of trying the character by another name, they simply try (and locate) a completely different character.</p> <p>I have read a number of scholarly papers on the subject of using search logs to improve natural language search queries, but none of the methods seem to have much application in this narrow case.</p> <p>Are there known methods that would be useful for this application?</p> <p>My project can be viewed at <a href="http://fachme.com" rel="nofollow">http://fachme.com</a></p>
37,298
[ -0.04587722569704056, -0.018802789971232414, 0.0033908230252563953, -0.022139374166727066, 0.033733267337083817, 0.018266860395669937, 0.0038534486666321754, -0.025954455137252808, 0.014755567535758018, -0.01456372532993555, 0.014907349832355976, 0.06348280608654022, 0.045905184000730515, 0.022298837080597878, 0.003726336872205138, -0.019876640290021896, -0.028129078447818756, 0.006705420091748238, 0.013328716158866882, -0.03394462540745735, -0.006343391258269548, 0.0009089570376090705, -0.02345440536737442, 0.022291898727416992, 0.0039106691256165504, 0.011794750578701496, -0.025196176022291183, -0.07351238280534744, -0.006831102538853884, 0.007203654386103153, -0.034052517265081406, 0.020289044827222824, 0.002389422385022044, 0.04458116367459297, 0.002577634295448661, 0.012614951469004154, -0.023767659440636635, -0.0005086984019726515, 0.003184929955750704, 0.05786307156085968, -0.04588763043284416, -0.002728556515648961, 0.008160571567714214, 0.024725237861275673, -0.015002272091805935, -0.00830826722085476, -0.032417017966508865, -0.03121229261159897, -0.031195921823382378, -0.028645437210798264, 0.03587149456143379, -0.014190612360835075, 0.031227633357048035, 0.020783081650733948, -0.030635861679911613, 0.006281693000346422, 0.051696959882974625, 0.04643499106168747, 0.019603051245212555, -0.04130128398537636, 0.0019008801318705082, -0.04054754972457886, -0.008721419610083103, 0.013600618578493595, -0.027084559202194214, 0.04751460626721382, 0.009214437566697598, -0.0038677265401929617, 0.055748797953128815, -0.04137137159705162, -0.000634902564343065, 0.020893126726150513, 0.044400107115507126, 0.011154702864587307, 0.021554749459028244, -0.07983077317476273, 0.002929199021309614, 0.012833258137106895, 0.06307990103960037, 0.0036540112923830748, -0.005663820542395115, -0.0027299069333821535, 0.001999367494136095, 0.026811718940734863, 0.03566605597734451, 0.029042525216937065, 0.07246179133653641, -0.08086597919464111, -0.003456317586824298, 0.052708785980939865, 0.028671110048890114, 0.0005957742687314749, 0.014967013150453568, 0.03441046178340912, -0.06461449712514877, 0.02196069061756134, -0.006103259511291981, 0.015345131978392601, 0.01623854972422123, -0.010725212283432484, -0.056423306465148926, -0.04124065861105919, 0.013456136919558048, 0.07179716974496841, -0.056275274604558945, -0.01736324280500412, -0.04721152409911156, -0.03845836594700813, -0.025827627629041672, -0.007280987221747637, 0.021603263914585114, -0.002810531063005328, 0.0015987773658707738, 0.002850158140063286, 0.007157450541853905, -0.02395831234753132, -0.015619958750903606, -0.022757386788725853, 0.07226227968931198, 0.07251079380512238, -0.0154352355748415, -0.025574371218681335, 0.009991112165153027, -0.03534063696861267, -0.0023202982265502214, -0.007372780703008175, 0.0022089527919888496, -0.008617090992629528, -0.03713199496269226, 0.07899824529886246, -0.01679038628935814, -0.008473585359752178, 0.019496247172355652, -0.06942140311002731, 0.023373525589704514, 0.023085979744791985, -0.06545939296483994, -0.027062909677624702, 0.07184377312660217, 0.012493668124079704, 0.008844854310154915, -0.048503924161195755, -0.01948186196386814, 0.019897012040019035, 0.06558320671319962, 0.03870733082294464, 0.034376803785562515, 0.03613317757844925, -0.0238654688000679, 0.010323911905288696, -0.029860706999897957, 0.009571489877998829, -0.0026847454719245434, 0.015596001408994198, -0.010830714367330074, -0.06305232644081116, 0.02184288203716278, 0.004483708646148443, 0.012081794440746307, 0.01691310480237007, 0.0499742366373539, 0.0390043705701828, -0.04779810830950737, -0.035298027098178864, 0.04854108765721321, -0.05070960894227028, 0.09598297625780106, 0.02345382235944271, -0.0030113684479147196, -0.021616728976368904, -0.03275062143802643, 0.006407634355127811, 0.03396531194448471, -0.01263241097331047, 0.056735288351774216, -0.026816602796316147, 0.02668338268995285, 0.010211911983788013, 0.01868528313934803, -0.01838337443768978, 0.02401791512966156, -0.06871014833450317, -0.040036097168922424, 0.006718279328197241, 0.021458018571138382, 0.05107841640710831, -0.007114038802683353, 0.0020421987865120173, 0.053074005991220474, -0.04550986737012863, 0.015659581869840622, -0.062268152832984924, 0.0092396792024374, 0.00961148738861084, -0.017223455011844635, 0.08443789929151535, -0.017144883051514626, 0.011210237629711628, -0.005410497076809406, -0.013185124844312668, -0.01764671318233013, 0.01951204426586628, 0.07504571229219437, -0.023677587509155273, 0.000529971846845001, 0.003846157109364867, -0.029339132830500603, -0.01955670677125454, 0.018675902858376503, -0.01546578761190176, -0.03627663850784302, 0.00015163517673499882, -0.005845434498041868, 0.029245758429169655, -0.020730912685394287, 0.02584298513829708, 0.019055314362049103, 0.006476531736552715, -0.010722720064222813, -0.021863814443349838, -0.022484179586172104, 0.012544278986752033, 0.017548460513353348, 0.03821960464119911, 0.004265097435563803, 0.028093667700886726, 0.013054901733994484, 0.0016477027675136924, 0.0002606420894153416, -0.052436668425798416, -0.0773269385099411, -0.05017727240920067, 0.053789347410202026, 0.021460868418216705, -0.0812191367149353, -0.002679265569895506, 0.013289441354572773, 0.03697994723916054, 0.014587107114493847, 0.05723041668534279, -0.034894417971372604, 0.00017248188669327646, -0.00551817798987031, 0.049177613109350204, 0.031039051711559296, 0.005715693347156048, 0.03570767119526863, -0.0020463522523641586, 0.025857403874397278, -0.016247697174549103, -0.0037172026932239532, 0.010726242326200008, 0.04763668030500412, -0.00008030577737372369, -0.04694262519478798, -0.04715799167752266, 0.06540773063898087, -0.015025217086076736, -0.008748501539230347, 0.04107573255896568, 0.01708311215043068, 0.009812915697693825, 0.010321047157049179, -0.014392327517271042, -0.0030781999230384827, 0.017033951357007027, 0.00039861604454927146, -0.016322622075676918, 0.007655815687030554, -0.036792874336242676, 0.014719241298735142, -0.04297095537185669, -0.001782029401510954, -0.0358082540333271, 0.025852832943201065, -0.0009302215185016394, -0.00754623394459486, 0.03766310214996338, -0.00960064772516489, -0.0341588519513607, 0.004429232329130173, -0.004292202182114124, -0.0516086220741272, 0.03267638385295868, -0.06475597620010376, -0.011138970032334328, 0.008600444532930851, 0.02082616277039051, 0.013563123531639576, 0.01708165742456913, 0.020965425297617912, 0.006785040255635977, -0.038158152252435684, -0.07955560833215714, -0.019883954897522926, -0.017443282529711723, 0.01687619648873806, -0.013799705542623997, 0.01064618956297636, 0.05835249647498131, -0.0007041166536509991, -0.06076602265238762, 0.0562865324318409, -0.009368634782731533, -0.026435283944010735, -0.01968618854880333, -0.01863282546401024, -0.012976361438632011, -0.05108889192342758, -0.010627328418195248, -0.003774588229134679, 0.006930758245289326, 0.008151282556355, -0.06616391986608505, -0.05301542207598686, 0.0381893664598465, 0.001690389821305871, 0.049993421882390976, 0.015567491762340069, -0.013481730595231056, 0.04146426171064377, 0.011545727029442787, -0.07549068331718445, -0.06104636192321777, -0.009743181057274342, -0.05483199283480644, -0.027779461815953255, 0.00377110717818141, 0.010957758873701096, -0.06609529256820679, 0.01779668778181076, 0.008615664206445217, 0.03743109852075577, 0.0251847542822361, 0.02703067660331726, -0.01737051084637642, 0.03478730469942093, 0.00016574477194808424, -0.00405679177492857, 0.010276991873979568, 0.02803642302751541, -0.04634607583284378, 0.0065247667953372, -0.014939093962311745, -0.014591226354241371, 0.02767222560942173, -0.0534345842897892, -0.0015633110888302326, -0.000038398047763621435, -0.021790452301502228, -0.02486339583992958, -0.002552224090322852, 0.02514747530221939, -0.025523463264107704, -0.026209931820631027, 0.018162420019507408, 0.03583212196826935, -0.019021067768335342, 0.00558360805734992, 0.06150266155600548, 0.040697984397411346, -0.01675768755376339, -0.03181169927120209, -0.010832902044057846, -0.022078093141317368, -0.0006216578767634928, -0.035757582634687424, 0.008528466336429119, 0.026143519207835197, 0.04775096848607063, -0.011545225977897644, 0.010099800303578377, -0.05303189903497696, 0.024053655564785004, -0.07117015868425369, 0.011479969136416912, -0.02092927321791649, 0.042976073920726776, -0.024856088683009148, 0.020408187061548233, 0.030291082337498665, -0.005801141262054443, 0.002533076796680689, 0.04875056445598602, -0.08882670849561691, 0.010462780483067036, -0.033296916633844376, 0.005957047920674086, 0.04548916965723038, -0.07554005831480026, 0.05350106954574585, -0.022937001660466194, 0.01227815356105566, 0.004675309173762798, 0.03593780845403671, -0.020389674231410027, 0.00800094474107027, -0.02357153780758381, -0.015732167288661003, -0.016971919685602188, 0.01935986615717411, 0.013988949358463287, 0.04475671052932739, 0.036483004689216614, 0.03032747469842434, 0.005754359066486359, 0.008332348428666592, -0.04217272624373436, 0.004625093657523394, 0.021896852180361748, 0.055073510855436325, -0.016669608652591705, -0.0018622049828991294, -0.0614532046020031, 0.014981218613684177, -0.016699418425559998, -0.001001247437670827, 0.03796441853046417, 0.008083087392151356, -0.0030990787781774998, -0.05389266088604927, -0.03360589221119881, 0.0017807242693379521, 0.011815458536148071, -0.03879712522029877, 0.02679109200835228, 0.018359513953328133, 0.016727104783058167, -0.06537620723247528, 0.036462824791669846, 0.0515863411128521, 0.026951182633638382, -0.02601741813123226, 0.002791536971926689, 0.029137665405869484, 0.03416559100151062, 0.013518862426280975, -0.01891924999654293, 0.01585146225988865, -0.032186590135097504, -0.03144172206521034, 0.03153279423713684, -0.029224956408143044, -0.05563945695757866, 0.01061251387000084, 0.02679130807518959, 0.018565012142062187, -0.018116556107997894, 0.006924626883119345, 0.006860570050776005, 0.02405427023768425, 0.011487459763884544, 0.010183492675423622, 0.0021413909271359444, -0.07456899434328079, -0.016625098884105682, 0.06640224158763885, 0.06465930491685867, -0.014342322014272213, -0.0037140892818570137, -0.03672215715050697, -0.02432255633175373, 0.015859272330999374, -0.021880794316530228, 0.008912330493330956, -0.013550354167819023, 0.0058721317909657955, -0.02477162890136242, -0.046790383756160736, -0.02779042348265648, 0.032061345875263214, -0.02079463005065918, 0.01874501071870327, -0.041222915053367615, -0.0073381513357162476, -0.034151531755924225, 0.028176987543702126, 0.0009559685713611543, 0.01758805848658085, -0.019656680524349213, -0.008011741563677788, 0.012435429729521275, -0.009469002485275269, -0.020007606595754623, -0.056807588785886765, -0.0002779117785394192, -0.032616812735795975, -0.028713826090097427, 0.026805303990840912, 0.002612781710922718, -0.021131057292222977, -0.0009968337835744023, 0.023761792108416557, -0.021155547350645065, -0.014402615837752819, -0.013831429183483124, 0.04285481944680214, 0.05239338427782059, 0.004902404733002186, 0.03853287547826767, 0.02175912819802761, 0.025739137083292007, -0.003017345443367958, 0.01395393442362547, 0.015315921977162361, -0.005194118712097406, 0.021966535598039627, -0.04463021084666252, 0.011682231910526752, -0.03086630068719387, 0.041705548763275146, 0.03925229609012604, 0.04222453385591507, -0.04120546951889992, 0.0016256788512691855, -0.006763611454516649, 0.009844571352005005, -0.0024961456656455994, 0.01918758451938629, 0.02121439017355442, 0.017274225130677223, -0.00536655867472291, 0.003296999493613839, -0.012977449223399162, -0.03230501711368561, -0.004687350708991289, 0.004173212219029665, -0.02172812446951866, 0.014953919686377048, -0.021745290607213974, 0.02218695357441902, 0.03301803022623062, -0.02136272005736828, 0.06704124808311462, 0.013371573761105537, 0.014405268244445324, 0.03113863803446293, -0.06684495508670807, 0.007552275434136391, 0.013171891681849957, -0.011572069488465786, 0.034682027995586395, -0.0173058919608593, 0.0457216240465641, 0.00024084925826173276, -0.026285648345947266, -0.02462899312376976, -0.01819375529885292, 0.04157688096165657, -0.012651398777961731, -0.029135897755622864, -0.011009723879396915, -0.017390724271535873, 0.008377976715564728, 0.023770922794938087, -0.04466366395354271, 0.019426589831709862, 0.019207928329706192, -0.029677433893084526, 0.05059890076518059, 0.005850278772413731, 0.06287802755832672, 0.0217311829328537, -0.027415134012699127, 0.008858155459165573, 0.04510204866528511, 0.004495201166719198, -0.007368304766714573, -0.006592826917767525, -0.028127700090408325, -0.0751836895942688, -0.050509653985500336, 0.016591891646385193, 0.03933250904083252, -0.0052078524604439735, 0.029662342742085457, -0.005971382837742567, -0.0029812781140208244, 0.02349184826016426, -0.023988010361790657, 0.017998235300183296, 0.0381302572786808, -0.0006561870686709881, 0.0019121345831081271, 0.007678295951336622, 0.010608198121190071, 0.02321559563279152, 0.004407061263918877, 0.00965078640729189, -0.029204292222857475, 0.0023826323449611664, 0.06364302337169647, -0.027703288942575455, 0.0005554931121878326, -0.006950560957193375, 0.012322102673351765, 0.042341507971286774, 0.013597012497484684, 0.0013389097293838859, -0.00463106157258153, 0.03967086970806122, -0.021271303296089172, -0.05192863941192627, 0.008239773102104664, -0.026127545163035393, 0.04785355553030968, -0.028886085376143456, 0.03349079191684723, 0.05857142433524132, 0.009268992580473423, -0.009814362041652203, 0.010554555803537369, -0.023858685046434402, -0.027070757001638412, 0.005967645440250635, 0.014348865486681461, -0.0024910843931138515, 0.04261483624577522, 0.014602265320718288, 0.008652511052787304, 0.03560900315642357, 0.009465779177844524, 0.025469951331615448, 0.03885496407747269, 0.02471597120165825, -0.04257922247052193, -0.03992924094200134, 0.011212101206183434, -0.06262330710887909, -0.0002993051602970809, 0.02607288397848606, -0.0221076812595129, 0.03717765212059021, 0.011977478861808777, 0.0002646924986038357, 0.00257115694694221, -0.02659640647470951, -0.0133185600861907, 0.02939692884683609, 0.029437784105539322, -0.02359526976943016, 0.03255428746342659, 0.003727179253473878, 0.07605692744255066, 0.019017770886421204, 0.027263300493359566, 0.018243979662656784, -0.07412295043468475, 0.01116259302943945, -0.017480868846178055, -0.04009533300995827, 0.07366489619016647, 0.010042771697044373, -0.03591709956526756, 0.027042316272854805, -0.012720516882836819, 0.017507726326584816, 0.04209275171160698, 0.020723097026348114, -0.020684998482465744, 0.0812690258026123, 0.00510331429541111, 0.01173505187034607, 0.005052140913903713, -0.025188064202666283, 0.1014355942606926, 0.07185700535774231, 0.04946295917034149, -0.06862320005893707, -0.015899071469902992, 0.019499290734529495, -0.0069746472872793674, -0.043646711856126785, -0.0030205368530005217, -0.011693144217133522, 0.0015324217965826392, 0.04731845110654831, 0.011776037514209747, -0.03971843793988228, -0.004673918709158897, 0.046037666499614716, -0.07780437171459198, -0.014674888923764229, 0.05283059924840927, 0.011056524701416492, 0.02140435017645359, 0.001380161615088582, -0.03125998005270958, 0.021658074110746384, 0.00253636809065938, -0.013419898226857185, 0.0163272712379694, -0.04986783489584923, -0.002981750760227442, 0.011146225035190582, -0.013722880743443966, 0.022264963015913963, 0.0462837889790535, 0.046764519065618515, 0.07288137078285217, 0.019434932619333267, 0.006774046458303928, -0.008933854289352894, 0.024578386917710304, 0.01224191952496767, 0.018560055643320084, -0.02252778597176075, 0.007343646138906479, 0.003348780795931816, -0.03401864320039749, -0.029924681410193443, -0.018577931448817253, 0.017752809450030327, -0.028547968715429306, 0.023489665240049362, -0.03552951291203499, -0.025177355855703354, -0.024241097271442413, 0.017039665952324867, -0.03837260976433754, 0.027148498222231865, 0.05348416045308113, 0.0024379172828048468, -0.04401053860783577, -0.020215466618537903, 0.0019147105049341917, -0.008401107974350452, 0.018490523099899292, 0.04139616712927818, -0.01254922803491354, -0.006325227674096823, -0.0439135767519474, 0.0001380655012326315, 0.03855521231889725, -0.0030249743722379208, -0.01889452338218689, -0.00635033193975687, -0.06295032054185867, -0.0024717291817069054, -0.011916116811335087, 0.0013575163902714849, 0.025631308555603027, 0.014181696809828281, -0.009899609722197056, -0.026210464537143707, -0.031172506511211395, 0.031580012291669846, -0.03524438664317131, -0.016773618757724762, -0.04283364489674568, 0.00565686309710145, 0.04106339439749718, 0.02488635666668415, 0.01615159399807453, 0.012494317255914211, 0.005908073391765356, 0.04224278777837753, 0.030307812616229057, -0.03150201961398125, -0.07507646828889847, 0.02007036656141281, -0.026835864409804344, -0.016082387417554855, 0.03283544257283211, 0.027355145663022995, 0.004547554533928633, -0.0004033230652566999, 0.02218802645802498, -0.0028233143966645002, 0.004716458730399609, -0.014618203975260258, 0.036327652633190155, -0.04115398973226547, -0.04061587527394295, -0.03303362801671028, -0.0025244075804948807, -0.022559141740202904, -0.03163941577076912, -0.03196578845381737, 0.003333867760375142, 0.040445972234010696, -0.0033535375259816647, -0.008981093764305115, 0.006191070657223463, -0.035103946924209595, 0.019567595794796944, -0.03855683282017708, 0.005990566685795784, -0.03171601891517639, -0.018128734081983566, -0.03249102830886841, -0.03808123990893364, -0.0031450982205569744, 0.016265520825982094, 0.003627961967140436, 0.0012738583609461784, 0.03801852837204933, 0.03434392064809799, -0.005595676600933075, 0.0013358028372749686, 0.0035281507298350334, -0.016047315672039986, 0.046785153448581696, -0.04511988162994385, -0.02923531085252762, 0.008568192832171917, -0.045827269554138184, -0.014593919739127159, 0.015596135519444942, -0.03181454911828041, 0.009319392032921314, 0.004905128851532936, 0.005769611801952124, 0.00576024129986763, 0.03808846324682236, -0.033654145896434784, -0.0359296016395092, -0.015981504693627357, 0.022443754598498344, 0.055959124118089676, 0.030788803473114967, 0.009931469336152077, 0.0032879882492125034, -0.028986763209104538, -0.011950148269534111, 0.08014131337404251, 0.04214327409863472, 0.008537973277270794, 0.021294601261615753, 0.011768018826842308, 0.003896726993843913, -0.005617293529212475, -0.03606772422790527, 0.009792886674404144, 0.0052607497200369835, -0.018384689465165138, 0.010943702422082424, 0.024391023442149162, 0.004233108833432198, -0.06749323755502701, 0.010381008498370647, 0.04154938831925392, 0.042029161006212234, 0.044116463512182236, -0.026838723570108414, -0.01033370103687048, 0.024445008486509323, -0.041459862142801285, 0.03388771042227745, 0.024928756058216095, 0.007741034030914307, -0.042815133929252625, 0.011213403195142746, -0.024216635152697563, 0.029297960922122, 0.0522267110645771, 0.05606658756732941, 0.03042672388255596, 0.030250633135437965, -0.020360130816698074, -0.022898085415363312, -0.01573655754327774, 0.03326908126473427, 0.023765074089169502, -0.00876284297555685, 0.018300924450159073, -0.03406950458884239, -0.049307890236377716, 0.03777473047375679, -0.022685306146740913, 0.03760097175836563, 0.02160130813717842, 0.0007959608919918537, -0.017307056114077568, -0.002308169612661004, 0.03719978779554367, -0.019474640488624573, -0.0015519184526056051, 0.045687075704336166, 0.013158641755580902, 0.08559911698102951, -0.008718196302652359, 0.011679115705192089, -0.005769641138613224, -0.019800156354904175, -0.04563095048069954, 0.06567512452602386, -0.002725962083786726, 0.022991519421339035, 0.001439740532077849, -0.015448850579559803, -0.0036197814624756575, 0.02257997915148735, -0.009121636860072613, -0.03178626298904419, 0.024934548884630203, 0.01236697006970644, 0.030869781970977783, 0.008480564691126347, 0.026675939559936523, 0.024573370814323425, -0.03657267987728119, 0.02641225792467594, -0.012208235450088978, -0.0562453456223011, -0.02755657397210598, 0.019552189856767654, 0.015817422419786453, -0.015182548202574253, -0.001180908177047968, 0.000621883082203567, 0.02979164570569992, 0.06590292602777481, -0.023124156519770622, -0.013096118345856667, 0.029731284826993942, -0.02504878118634224, -0.02102331817150116, -0.04955434799194336, 0.0421905517578125, 0.006708623841404915, -0.012809140607714653, -0.04819013550877571, -0.017470844089984894, -0.012451796792447567, 0.0290090199559927, 0.03973313421010971, -0.09150660783052444, 0.009202361106872559, -0.04075402393937111, -0.028604863211512566, -0.00476188026368618, -0.019794272258877754, 0.03518509864807129, -0.032397788017988205, -0.008488372899591923, 0.0035296243149787188, 0.02087988331913948, -0.019560223445296288, -0.01104008499532938, 0.028482530266046524, -0.041549909859895706, -0.029395222663879395, -0.007291886489838362, -0.013090687803924084, 0.06545866280794144, 0.007821774110198021, -0.007681298069655895, 0.017026860266923904, 0.016032498329877853, -0.000945490610320121, 0.016064325347542763, -0.00584439467638731, -0.06252071261405945, 0.05932929366827011, -0.016825707629323006, -0.06772130727767944, 0.017949843779206276, 0.025889573618769646, -0.004864165093749762, -0.05321456491947174, -0.004615854471921921, 0.023610569536685944, -0.005620644427835941, -0.0194248016923666, 0.022270023822784424, -0.0004270573554094881, 0.03401391580700874, -0.014877770096063614, 0.019754208624362946, 0.0027399775572121143, -0.022291522473096848, -0.00472450815141201, 0.0016636605141684413, 0.005184689536690712, 0.0023248675279319286, 0.014461008831858635, 0.009848762303590775, -0.0016850207466632128, 0.02808406949043274, 0.0016080276109278202, 0.057175349444150925, -0.07970020174980164, 0.017102358862757683, 0.03603441268205643, 0.0022532474249601364, 0.015649588778614998, -0.008515100926160812, -0.032292574644088745, 0.0762379989027977, -0.03145848214626312, 0.01883372850716114, -0.07210427522659302, -0.0022332114167511463, -0.015433036722242832, -0.03926384821534157, -0.01797862909734249, -0.0008056384394876659, -0.008076938800513744, 0.043716076761484146, 0.04413377493619919, -0.017145484685897827, 0.03650517016649246, -0.03359735384583473, -0.02801676280796528, -0.014422919601202011, -0.010967710986733437, -0.017894484102725983, -0.02393709495663643, -0.04027338698506355, -0.03490212559700012, -0.001979675143957138, 0.022318629547953606, -0.021308692172169685, -0.03393067046999931, -0.017208915203809738, -0.019079621881246567, 0.02844679355621338, -0.03747870773077011, 0.03801128268241882, -0.05049579218029976, 0.036540254950523376, 0.003219573525711894, -0.03093428537249565 ]
<p>I am looking for a simple code example of how to run a Particle Filter in R. The pomp package appears to support the state space math bit, but the examples are a little tricky to follow programmatically for a simple OO developer such as myself, particularly how to load the observed data into a pomp object.</p> <ul> <li>Examples here: <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/pomp/vignettes/intro_to_pomp.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/pomp/vignettes/intro_to_pomp.pdf</a></li> </ul> <p>Lets say I have a csv file with 1 column of noisy data as input, and I would like to run it through a Particle Filter in order to hopefully clean it up, with the output being the estimations, to another csv file.</p> <pre><code> y &lt;- read.csv("C:/Dev/VeryCleverStatArb/inputData.csv", header=FALSE) #CSV to Pomp object ??? #Run Particle Filter #Write estimates to csv. </code></pre> <p>The main difficulty with the examples is loading csv data into a pomp object. </p> <p>A very simple state space model should be good enough for now.</p> <p>Any ideas for the R-curious?</p>
49,125
[ 0.004282035864889622, -0.0004580630047712475, 0.027195466682314873, -0.024148255586624146, 0.00724820839241147, 0.008586028590798378, 0.0011300834594294429, -0.0018659367924556136, 0.04118862748146057, -0.009393076412379742, 0.01836864836513996, 0.08387333899736404, 0.06661367416381836, 0.012318011373281479, -0.008184848353266716, -0.011199800297617912, -0.0022970978170633316, -0.022839313372969627, -0.02771393023431301, -0.006475794594734907, -0.02922844886779785, -0.011364804580807686, 0.01565050706267357, -0.032531850039958954, 0.019432714208960533, 0.032798271626234055, 0.010206435807049274, 0.0001083883544197306, -0.0006423997110687196, 0.056688688695430756, -0.025914756581187248, -0.03214119002223015, -0.007010163273662329, 0.015520242974162102, 0.0016294996021315455, -0.0032103778794407845, -0.009795046411454678, -0.019676877185702324, -0.004888796713203192, 0.012684104964137077, -0.04184911400079727, -0.02555238828063011, 0.002637712052091956, 0.05423896759748459, -0.0016609318554401398, 0.03756182640790939, 0.025701850652694702, 0.027836177498102188, 0.0437387116253376, -0.05478537455201149, 0.059134338051080704, 0.0025517118629068136, 0.026877660304307938, 0.06281635165214539, -0.016405699774622917, -0.04236121103167534, 0.0492127351462841, 0.06981870532035828, -0.011566813103854656, -0.059655532240867615, -0.03096577525138855, -0.04532962292432785, -0.021709244698286057, -0.033487528562545776, -0.05998867005109787, 0.0013765605399385095, -0.006308670621365309, -0.006862465292215347, 0.016038332134485245, -0.03302321955561638, 0.02701725624501705, 0.001824402017518878, 0.044254131615161896, -0.004890089854598045, 0.015206478536128998, -0.029553674161434174, 0.013260126113891602, 0.02398422732949257, 0.00737773859873414, 0.03738004341721535, -0.028763817623257637, -0.0064648170955479145, 0.0034944694489240646, 0.03651298210024834, 0.009411799721419811, -0.02965625375509262, 0.06969064474105835, -0.028498323634266853, 0.018208064138889313, 0.022376228123903275, -0.005390041507780552, -0.0005569296190515161, 0.05559319257736206, 0.06563021242618561, -0.04036693274974823, 0.04780828580260277, 0.00385267217643559, 0.042571771889925, -0.023119725286960602, -0.02445707656443119, 0.008864917792379856, -0.036853108555078506, 0.010547525249421597, 0.044716738164424896, -0.04478058964014053, 0.017498334869742393, -0.030373044312000275, -0.014875596389174461, -0.04125859588384628, -0.011530265212059021, -0.05140584334731102, 0.03589795157313347, -0.0008944558794610202, -0.003308642189949751, 0.03484619781374931, -0.021170061081647873, 0.0026194704696536064, -0.0355885773897171, 0.047246284782886505, 0.06673398613929749, 0.07455065846443176, -0.015211564488708973, 0.022137168794870377, -0.019083570688962936, -0.050090204924345016, 0.0007941672811284661, 0.009554686024785042, -0.04256657510995865, -0.07224342972040176, 0.02206416055560112, -0.017417704686522484, -0.029153048992156982, 0.07673507183790207, 0.014224009588360786, 0.03443725407123566, -0.011336649768054485, -0.10001405328512192, -0.050456710159778595, 0.03651854395866394, -0.02725178748369217, 0.031044641509652138, -0.07324841618537903, 0.01498030312359333, 0.02261154167354107, 0.044404398649930954, -0.013861854560673237, 0.006948534399271011, 0.05097886919975281, 0.013261314481496811, -0.03717120736837387, -0.046116553246974945, 0.01852669194340706, -0.02912171557545662, -0.02616908587515354, -0.019631188362836838, -0.06874256581068039, 0.022296879440546036, 0.039164215326309204, 0.01419204194098711, -0.007082170806825161, 0.02507195807993412, -0.004349712748080492, -0.013504267670214176, -0.017519673332571983, 0.009082536213099957, -0.03263320028781891, 0.04823623597621918, 0.016063479706645012, 0.0381544791162014, 0.006600378081202507, -0.0357607901096344, 0.036448314785957336, 0.008767352439463139, 0.013468465767800808, 0.04133394733071327, -0.042291030287742615, -0.016105659306049347, 0.007493298966437578, -0.00013212402700446546, 0.007953489199280739, -0.026606380939483643, -0.026620810851454735, 0.021954642608761787, -0.04969331994652748, 0.008313916623592377, 0.03368823602795601, 0.019940828904509544, -0.036118388175964355, 0.041513923555612564, -0.0824338048696518, -0.04258429631590843, -0.08892598748207092, -0.0023794479202479124, -0.01780010759830475, 0.002237532986328006, 0.04516028240323067, 0.01766023598611355, 0.02400876209139824, 0.010670184157788754, -0.0040838285349309444, -0.03342102840542793, -0.0022942088544368744, 0.020478950813412666, -0.013873899355530739, -0.03581778332591057, 0.04864398017525673, 0.03666308522224426, -0.01317802257835865, 0.029225880280137062, -0.006267260760068893, -0.025133846327662468, -0.03556499630212784, -0.04685267433524132, 0.010049221105873585, -0.029287388548254967, 0.006195619702339172, 0.056141436100006104, 0.01566966436803341, -0.006683806423097849, 0.008039576932787895, -0.04518156871199608, 0.024213513359427452, 0.09170098602771759, 0.009777630679309368, -0.010186830535531044, -0.010630589909851551, 0.0072250342927873135, 0.024619510397315025, -0.03122119791805744, -0.006647442001849413, -0.03986801579594612, -0.028364507481455803, 0.023920981213450432, -0.008642475120723248, -0.008523372933268547, 0.0057816230691969395, 0.03324446082115173, -0.017446912825107574, 0.012744669802486897, 0.0450018048286438, -0.01994856633245945, -0.0064964802004396915, 0.026637958362698555, 0.01184773724526167, 0.03422113135457039, -0.002198834903538227, 0.023634498938918114, 0.0144963338971138, 0.04908519238233566, 0.01699136383831501, -0.03275609761476517, 0.03323177620768547, -0.015389245934784412, -0.010239047929644585, -0.025736819952726364, -0.03057713806629181, 0.056075215339660645, -0.013042490929365158, 0.018488673493266106, 0.015696844086050987, -0.027225499972701073, -0.001416137907654047, 0.012046747840940952, -0.0193944089114666, -0.019969681277871132, 0.04384154453873634, -0.00409340113401413, -0.01271902583539486, 0.021035293117165565, -0.030649136751890182, 0.023395434021949768, -0.01283793430775404, -0.04463495314121246, -0.05452665314078331, 0.050026409327983856, -0.003927062265574932, 0.023743459954857826, 0.0316082201898098, -0.021353833377361298, -0.051984753459692, 0.015196842141449451, 0.00214382610283792, 0.02568887360394001, 0.03695867583155632, -0.04460074007511139, 0.01117636077105999, 0.01177938375622034, -0.044901829212903976, 0.004316441714763641, 0.002089484827592969, -0.021554579958319664, 0.009260621853172779, -0.007365876343101263, -0.04491330310702324, -0.012145241722464561, -0.006696426775306463, -0.029614748433232307, -0.026068508625030518, -0.00564770121127367, -0.016601724550127983, 0.03910962864756584, -0.029985172674059868, -0.013458679430186749, -0.07650697976350784, -0.047564491629600525, -0.06132049486041069, -0.00891417171806097, 0.007281536236405373, 0.0019242458511143923, 0.03493581712245941, 0.012299242429435253, -0.04350414127111435, 0.008151115849614143, -0.06709243357181549, -0.03711568936705589, 0.01757854036986828, 0.0012530599487945437, -0.004661695100367069, 0.003317072056233883, -0.013005019165575504, 0.0581146664917469, -0.00519544817507267, -0.06413312256336212, -0.0017566557507961988, -0.00024188340466935188, -0.02273310348391533, -0.03405766561627388, 0.008855399675667286, 0.00894598662853241, 0.006973410490900278, 0.006388765759766102, -0.029230192303657532, -0.015767646953463554, 0.028656315058469772, 0.0006305019487626851, -0.0002640002057887614, -0.027750438079237938, 0.0015246531693264842, -0.007513759657740593, 0.020667443051934242, -0.004896174650639296, 0.01333210151642561, 0.023742318153381348, -0.023117506876587868, 0.007685177493840456, 0.014739268459379673, -0.04550779238343239, -0.000696027185767889, 0.005956095177680254, 0.009709760546684265, -0.0733051747083664, 0.0328567773103714, 0.00021558438311330974, -0.03484662249684334, 0.028194846585392952, 0.02163553237915039, 0.03624312952160835, 0.003869263455271721, -0.029802484437823296, 0.0330672562122345, 0.03782016783952713, -0.0012983311899006367, 0.0006262954557314515, -0.013993550091981888, -0.0013610613532364368, 0.004325718618929386, 0.003189225448295474, -0.010105124674737453, 0.03336720913648605, 0.037968989461660385, 0.010795975103974342, -0.022823385894298553, 0.00884385034441948, 0.026265287771821022, -0.0627031996846199, 0.005709050688892603, -0.016875112429261208, 0.03006410226225853, 0.045881710946559906, 0.03786610811948776, 0.01949545368552208, 0.002757070353254676, 0.044084809720516205, -0.032287053763866425, -0.10664685815572739, 0.026813780888915062, 0.00712051335722208, -0.013967725448310375, -0.037606462836265564, -0.006810860708355904, 0.03972923383116722, -0.024650814011693, 0.0335221067070961, -0.002264395821839571, 0.00963590294122696, -0.04761366546154022, -0.038085803389549255, 0.0036051757633686066, 0.018186887726187706, -0.023502467200160027, -0.002437412738800049, 0.042610038071870804, -0.030093032866716385, 0.029962163418531418, 0.04896483197808266, -0.034067824482917786, -0.0073357075452804565, 0.0005363629315979779, -0.004666169174015522, 0.013163096271455288, 0.0429290272295475, 0.02469388023018837, 0.03296688199043274, -0.03285251930356026, 0.07579358667135239, -0.012988757342100143, 0.03548300266265869, 0.028250979259610176, -0.032396845519542694, -0.0245209950953722, -0.04041868448257446, 0.00012938633153680712, 0.0026877811178565025, 0.002397970063611865, 0.010574749670922756, 0.009962154552340508, 0.04526980221271515, 0.01983204111456871, -0.02693597972393036, 0.023462790995836258, 0.07308570295572281, 0.02075016126036644, 0.03248506784439087, -0.0025681701954454184, -0.027355648577213287, 0.016067024320364, 0.028156710788607597, 0.0654064416885376, 0.03248269855976105, 0.0037159472703933716, 0.026339644566178322, 0.01677868887782097, 0.00697717210277915, -0.026375509798526764, 0.021230362355709076, 0.027007337659597397, 0.04832730069756508, 0.001383063499815762, -0.007556067779660225, 0.027525553479790688, 0.04508844390511513, 0.034104544669389725, -0.024369750171899796, -0.03046286664903164, -0.0970468819141388, -0.008807197213172913, 0.044337037950754166, 0.006099717691540718, -0.009375880472362041, -0.01663128100335598, -0.050996456295251846, -0.04525487869977951, 0.0684945359826088, -0.013489526696503162, 0.02682548388838768, -0.017829112708568573, -0.0030669691041111946, -0.007868252694606781, -0.017186639830470085, -0.030975552275776863, 0.003679991466924548, -0.04509986191987991, 0.0156209422275424, -0.012296420522034168, -0.036768507212400436, -0.053351711481809616, 0.026660168543457985, -0.010204545222222805, 0.054284557700157166, -0.04081656411290169, 0.00551148084923625, 0.015460814349353313, -0.0191763024777174, -0.04373801499605179, -0.01651417464017868, 0.014042207039892673, -0.005239665042608976, -0.011008122004568577, 0.030793003737926483, -0.010371256619691849, -0.022377479821443558, 0.01089978776872158, 0.004035686142742634, -0.01571137085556984, -0.039001476019620895, -0.04982458055019379, 0.022573618218302727, 0.007741011679172516, 0.005971111357212067, 0.06040973961353302, 0.01181765180081129, -0.027043474838137627, 0.01770794205367565, -0.027124032378196716, 0.020078428089618683, -0.020565086975693703, -0.00023741452605463564, -0.0366000197827816, -0.015596596524119377, -0.022256195545196533, 0.028256239369511604, 0.01808709092438221, 0.04160504415631294, -0.034244440495967865, 0.010126749984920025, 0.02774827927350998, 0.04892558604478836, -0.02353360690176487, -0.02182500623166561, -0.03329525887966156, 0.03431396558880806, 0.00926412083208561, -0.022610684856772423, 0.015871871262788773, -0.013530584052205086, -0.027034344151616096, -0.035915717482566833, -0.05263475701212883, 0.02463071420788765, -0.04576697573065758, -0.005005993880331516, 0.03514521196484566, -0.027526196092367172, 0.018974309787154198, -0.041609007865190506, 0.027113713324069977, 0.00874319951981306, -0.08051152527332306, -0.018814079463481903, 0.04088409245014191, -0.026706842705607414, -0.01209547184407711, -0.016858166083693504, 0.04129743576049805, -0.030703263357281685, 0.006831327453255653, -0.022914664819836617, -0.05974074453115463, 0.016164535656571388, -0.010790912434458733, -0.023195676505565643, -0.07047608494758606, -0.0015030760550871491, -0.031232258304953575, -0.002293383004143834, -0.014795972965657711, 0.011899208649992943, -0.03963760659098625, 0.024785611778497696, 0.03412557765841484, 0.010908974334597588, 0.050636306405067444, 0.027837267145514488, -0.00659317709505558, 0.06391379237174988, -0.03217434510588646, -0.031087473034858704, 0.004262781236320734, 0.013322544284164906, -0.014271506108343601, 0.01557899359613657, 0.009941057302057743, -0.029380081221461296, 0.038092419505119324, -0.0033956479746848345, -0.017035838216543198, 0.0014244428602978587, -0.010047774761915207, -0.010904809460043907, -0.04472660273313522, -0.014020051807165146, -0.03780294209718704, 0.022379443049430847, -0.05218063294887543, -0.017566541209816933, 0.010970322415232658, -0.015865735709667206, 0.034507736563682556, 0.009864390827715397, -0.018294479697942734, 0.021191872656345367, 0.04362006485462189, -0.010393008589744568, 0.0025866921059787273, -0.013150646351277828, 0.004379466641694307, 0.018901200965046883, 0.0028841302264481783, 0.016080021858215332, 0.019507458433508873, 0.019011564552783966, -0.027163425460457802, -0.032234594225883484, -0.06110936403274536, -0.05710205063223839, 0.05767549201846123, -0.018617667257785797, 0.05136682093143463, 0.013595779426395893, 0.016695167869329453, 0.01373483706265688, -0.019818557426333427, -0.010537855327129364, 0.0071365609765052795, 0.04877053201198578, 0.02465224452316761, 0.003390669357031584, 0.029508445411920547, 0.01576712355017662, 0.00677214190363884, 0.030451888218522072, 0.056524332612752914, -0.008957453072071075, 0.041442885994911194, 0.041483864188194275, -0.023436401039361954, -0.026700245216488838, 0.05255875363945961, -0.02487707883119583, 0.027258437126874924, -0.04641273617744446, -0.0534542091190815, 0.02795802615582943, 0.05121893063187599, -0.031123444437980652, -0.021257562562823296, -0.023798750713467598, -0.05739700049161911, 0.05326434224843979, 0.030157458037137985, -0.02544580027461052, 0.0007407085504382849, 0.010161169804632664, 0.021998299285769463, 0.022376252338290215, 0.04318270459771156, -0.0348108746111393, -0.08527596294879913, -0.012753969989717007, -0.027979109436273575, -0.03177987411618233, 0.06048690900206566, 0.030361389741301537, -0.016183003783226013, 0.022878721356391907, -0.008108721114695072, 0.055503301322460175, 0.0316191092133522, 0.042249854654073715, -0.01628309302031994, 0.04214940965175629, -0.034588366746902466, 0.014383561909198761, -0.04289328679442406, 0.01886698044836521, 0.13627320528030396, 0.057385511696338654, 0.05473795160651207, -0.054814618080854416, 0.023599350824952126, 0.014505385421216488, -0.01719696819782257, -0.01300228014588356, 0.03131445497274399, 0.03278956934809685, -0.019405443221330643, 0.00026129768230021, 0.039746105670928955, 0.031437911093235016, 0.02259742096066475, 0.02480102702975273, -0.055221058428287506, -0.04344702512025833, -0.014136961661279202, 0.021097052842378616, -0.023225165903568268, -0.034622859209775925, -0.04663119837641716, 0.012493562884628773, -0.017913352698087692, -0.034548815339803696, -0.018788032233715057, -0.033437490463256836, -0.009241347201168537, 0.01506026554852724, -0.006605593953281641, 0.03953852504491806, 0.005883101839572191, -0.0030392231419682503, 0.027230355888605118, 0.025258604437112808, 0.020005512982606888, -0.052285172045230865, 0.02449866198003292, 0.0395033098757267, 0.028070461004972458, 0.005227496847510338, -0.007531317882239819, 0.03874429687857628, -0.02123154327273369, -0.029480602592229843, -0.027430396527051926, 0.07336153835058212, -0.04364833980798721, -0.0013042781502008438, -0.02701115421950817, 0.040482956916093826, 0.027477560564875603, -0.05066891387104988, -0.03425762429833412, -0.017415665090084076, 0.03555813059210777, -0.003432360477745533, -0.008010610938072205, -0.034004420042037964, -0.013376777060329914, -0.03173616901040077, 0.03076840564608574, 0.0454099215567112, -0.027444522827863693, -0.008338363841176033, -0.015200650319457054, 0.05936439707875252, -0.039710503071546555, 0.030565738677978516, -0.005591319873929024, -0.010336647741496563, -0.02117975614964962, -0.00723921088501811, 0.050890564918518066, 0.0076346490532159805, 0.028116850182414055, -0.030978446826338768, -0.005799409467726946, -0.030886080116033554, -0.03613227978348732, 0.014748813584446907, -0.014489763416349888, -0.012658425606787205, -0.025211157277226448, -0.020358918234705925, 0.06573803722858429, 0.04625194892287254, -0.004834731575101614, -0.008234037086367607, -0.03201555833220482, 0.0175551176071167, -0.0013544955290853977, -0.019909974187612534, -0.033935628831386566, -0.00655184593051672, -0.00666338624432683, 0.02360878698527813, -0.0008287347154691815, 0.08892553299665451, 0.024971071630716324, 0.011371321976184845, 0.0007538798963651061, 0.042928025126457214, -0.017038248479366302, 0.002332912990823388, 0.04367678984999657, -0.041433677077293396, 0.005887045059353113, -0.01125485822558403, 0.002105505671352148, -0.024211475625634193, 0.00770955765619874, -0.029369456693530083, -0.008987988345324993, 0.0058359368704259396, -0.02283938229084015, -0.047840800136327744, 0.02893746830523014, -0.025416437536478043, -0.007010817527770996, 0.0013173159677535295, -0.0023751077242195606, -0.02994108386337757, 0.01003311388194561, -0.052105940878391266, 0.006881745997816324, -0.012469379231333733, 0.0053029446862638, -0.03431876748800278, 0.001947720069438219, 0.01124351006001234, -0.0024789152666926384, 0.04525264725089073, 0.0072691780515015125, 0.05515468493103981, -0.007728321012109518, 0.02299259789288044, 0.006005777511745691, -0.01362635474652052, 0.033496491611003876, -0.019585110247135162, -0.014834622852504253, -0.0025667452719062567, 0.039220958948135376, 0.03503132984042168, 0.020258618518710136, -0.03125755116343498, -0.01646367460489273, 0.08655142784118652, -0.009686298668384552, -0.0013870898401364684, 0.028723951429128647, -0.030612975358963013, -0.036855749785900116, 0.01305164024233818, 0.02499457262456417, -0.021395476534962654, -0.05197877436876297, 0.04979483783245087, 0.03973059728741646, 0.019073255360126495, -0.0008884091512300074, -0.005543529987335205, -0.028003474697470665, -0.0006622005603276193, -0.0010919715277850628, -0.03598940744996071, 0.04300936684012413, 0.050635240972042084, -0.014032701961696148, 0.013028254732489586, 0.002924584783613682, 0.007655668538063765, -0.0976337194442749, -0.011950529180467129, -0.012102387845516205, -0.0033451796043664217, 0.023210173472762108, -0.048713330179452896, 0.04158670827746391, 0.06825247406959534, -0.03920740261673927, -0.0061019849963486195, -0.017130183055996895, 0.016400093212723732, -0.011093000881373882, 0.018590528517961502, -0.02538193389773369, 0.05090711638331413, 0.025318648666143417, -0.0407533273100853, 0.024595841765403748, 0.010315945371985435, 0.017690999433398247, -0.031548477709293365, -0.006256893277168274, 0.03810909762978554, 0.043614935129880905, -0.04183337837457657, 0.039059631526470184, -0.03680430352687836, 0.03058740496635437, 0.0011373086599633098, -0.015718627721071243, 0.02837408520281315, 0.00754367234185338, 0.05637679249048233, 0.020136600360274315, 0.05558505654335022, 0.02481558918952942, 0.015243224799633026, -0.004685043822973967, -0.018371831625699997, 0.041520942002534866, 0.002617622958496213, -0.025699257850646973, -0.005596779752522707, 0.0004788343794643879, 0.019874688237905502, -0.01304653286933899, 0.03845054283738136, 0.01675291359424591, 0.004109901376068592, -0.00759462732821703, -0.014058545231819153, -0.0038975588977336884, 0.004130681976675987, 0.021595677360892296, -0.03436370939016342, 0.03204828500747681, 0.006424290593713522, 0.0011983959702774882, -0.0498172901570797, 0.019255956634879112, -0.008011669851839542, -0.030599890276789665, 0.019236154854297638, -0.007238405756652355, 0.01270818430930376, -0.04351633042097092, 0.017404254525899887, 0.015306797809898853, -0.014386960305273533, -0.02651997283101082, -0.000017101807316066697, -0.04474255442619324, 0.04065325856208801, 0.005852201487869024, -0.012337236665189266, 0.05351695790886879, 0.004031754098832607, 0.012313087470829487, -0.04963469132781029, 0.05545089766383171, 0.01200295053422451, 0.005010710097849369, -0.02255829982459545, 0.0360000878572464, 0.015392783097922802, 0.03570709377527237, 0.04890146106481552, -0.007729863282293081, 0.004668939858675003, 0.03700288012623787, 0.04122381657361984, 0.0031675181817263365, -0.047319285571575165, -0.004498607013374567, -0.011300859972834587, -0.013686106540262699, 0.023153414949774742, -0.005284506361931562, -0.00030381468241102993, 0.0031986169051378965, 0.038151323795318604, -0.010519358329474926, 0.008372713811695576, 0.01673746667802334, -0.024919070303440094, 0.010452463291585445, 0.005419235676527023, -0.005604588892310858, 0.019340697675943375, -0.011291720904409885, 0.02234264463186264, 0.04411693289875984, 0.018035167828202248, -0.00799164641648531, 0.019041385501623154, -0.059678807854652405, -0.017160717397928238, 0.03843770921230316, -0.05571562424302101, -0.0026081225369125605, -0.0933564230799675, 0.011947626248002052, -0.007013718597590923, -0.03814276307821274, 0.03491997346282005, 0.045746635645627975, 0.014852698892354965, 0.06254816800355911, 0.01347892265766859, 0.026367809623479843, 0.012195570394396782, 0.02706507034599781, 0.013045832514762878, 0.022535737603902817, -0.007976612076163292, -0.015932351350784302, -0.00008761439676163718, 0.0418374203145504, -0.0032478885259479284, -0.010472375899553299, 0.024334575980901718, 0.03314373269677162, -0.013505612500011921, 0.014594439417123795, -0.02976926416158676, -0.01856815814971924, -0.005258975084871054, -0.002951645292341709, -0.008148906752467155, 0.05654193088412285, -0.06322754919528961, 0.009222862310707569, -0.01420623529702425, 0.01762300729751587, -0.030489899218082428, 0.02516295574605465, -0.0513773076236248, 0.063874252140522, 0.0018958557629957795, 0.026631824672222137, -0.002869852352887392, -0.008407149463891983, -0.012792382389307022, -0.0324878953397274, -0.013611145317554474, -0.007620011921972036, -0.013395964168012142, 0.01173254195600748, -0.008965418674051762, -0.014723706059157848, -0.0013092280132696033, 0.009721003472805023, 0.02332671731710434, 0.0049747624434530735, -0.04486037790775299, 0.00400829641148448, -0.020084941759705544, 0.039829496294260025, -0.06334731727838516, 0.006468010134994984, -0.03013906255364418, -0.00090786162763834, -0.06418872624635696, -0.002174644498154521 ]
<p>I would like to find a <em>hierarchical-clustering</em> method useful to assign a group membership into <em>k</em> groups for all individuals in my dataset. I have considered several classic ordination methods, PCA, NMDS, "mclust", etc., but three of my variables are categorical (<em>see data description below</em>). Further, I was wondering if it is preferable to a method that reports a posterior probability of group membership for each individual? I am using R.</p> <p><strong>Data description</strong>: I have sampled almost 2000 individual birds (single species representing two subspecies or phenotypes) across Sweden. All individuals are adult males. Although this is one species, in middle of Sweden there is a (migratory) divide where the southern individuals presumably migrate to West Africa and north of the divide they presumably migrate to East Africa. There is a zone of overlap approximately 300 km wide at the migratory divide.</p> <p><strong>Variables</strong>:</p> <ul> <li>Wing (mm) - continuous</li> <li>Tail (mm) - continuous</li> <li>Bill-head (mm) - continuous </li> <li>Tarsus (mm) - continuous</li> <li>Mass (g) - continuous</li> <li>Colour (9 levels) - categorical</li> <li>Stable carbon-isotopes (parts per mil) - continuous</li> <li>Stable nitrogen-istopes (parts per mil) - continuous</li> <li>SNP WW1 (0, 1, 2) - molecular marker, 0 and 2 are fixed and 1 is heterozygote</li> <li>SNP WW2 (0, 1, 2) - molecular marker, 0 and 2 are fixed and 1 is heterozygote</li> </ul> <p>Description of the colour variable: (brightest yellow) S+, S, S-, M+, M (medium), M-, N+, N, N- (dullest yellow-grey)</p>
49,126
[ -0.031706973910331726, -0.031649746000766754, -0.009774402715265751, -0.002967249369248748, -0.004515753593295813, -0.0025639738887548447, -0.023626750335097313, -0.02362857386469841, 0.010152927599847317, -0.05886372923851013, 0.05168534442782402, 0.040499284863471985, 0.035289615392684937, 0.06081095337867737, 0.0022409919183701277, -0.014415627345442772, -0.03207632526755333, -0.021115195006132126, -0.008132836781442165, -0.029333828017115593, -0.010884714312851429, 0.0015994564164429903, 0.026121865957975388, -0.02985863946378231, -0.015538478270173073, 0.02879014052450657, 0.002518334658816457, -0.00048655387945473194, 0.0039655896835029125, 0.026617202907800674, -0.05359047278761864, -0.030497882515192032, 0.014335205778479576, 0.034151166677474976, -0.017343824729323387, -0.014943012967705727, 0.004377518780529499, -0.040385931730270386, -0.03504155948758125, 0.0438755601644516, -0.04584186524152756, -0.0030279692728072405, -0.01626480743288994, 0.029944879934191704, 0.036464840173721313, 0.031284086406230927, 0.015110001899302006, -0.006234611850231886, 0.018415184691548347, -0.017703287303447723, 0.04262595251202583, 0.036883484572172165, 0.018467606976628304, 0.01720329374074936, 0.002772374078631401, -0.012906299903988838, 0.026704462245106697, 0.044512782245874405, -0.003372178878635168, -0.02374272421002388, -0.015926875174045563, -0.06728233397006989, 0.01840425282716751, -0.013523507863283157, -0.010725113563239574, 0.029789529740810394, 0.011971533298492432, -0.014377228915691376, 0.06308311223983765, -0.012965040281414986, 0.035589415580034256, 0.009142073802649975, 0.05865943431854248, 0.011377271264791489, 0.015416410751640797, -0.029529457911849022, -0.016772210597991943, 0.04021257534623146, 0.049896057695150375, 0.017317745834589005, -0.018456868827342987, 0.012564798817038536, -0.014381218701601028, 0.009386350400745869, 0.042238906025886536, -0.030427206307649612, 0.05889656022191048, -0.025579378008842468, -0.015635352581739426, 0.028571484610438347, -0.010467655956745148, -0.028880884870886803, 0.06416191160678864, 0.030953986570239067, -0.04315517470240593, 0.048889826983213425, -0.018160918727517128, 0.018929019570350647, -0.01695033721625805, -0.021686647087335587, -0.01399318128824234, -0.07438420504331589, 0.0396028570830822, 0.06163613498210907, -0.0022604032419621944, 0.01499342080205679, -0.04881303012371063, -0.05609814077615738, -0.0024220480117946863, -0.01163533702492714, -0.002050709445029497, -0.0012208010302856565, 0.001499392674304545, -0.009368936531245708, 0.013998104259371758, -0.011320076882839203, -0.0005391095764935017, -0.031562235206365585, 0.07726366072893143, 0.10083195567131042, 0.04443887248635292, -0.03054952621459961, 0.0079110749065876, 0.011816495098173618, -0.06403093785047531, -0.0072052874602377415, 0.0044351122342050076, 0.004109015688300133, -0.014085731469094753, 0.040992338210344315, 0.011623910628259182, -0.01143566146492958, 0.08290298283100128, -0.0305003859102726, 0.009103391319513321, -0.002506764605641365, -0.061517566442489624, -0.06249189376831055, 0.009408125653862953, -0.014926176518201828, 0.04953864961862564, -0.06570149958133698, 0.00047675095265731215, 0.02794085256755352, 0.04766799136996269, -0.010562737472355366, 0.034634750336408615, 0.02248317003250122, 0.008220617659389973, -0.01439608633518219, -0.03209426999092102, -0.022338612005114555, -0.026470432057976723, -0.025413040071725845, -0.009858584962785244, -0.051815129816532135, 0.010220385156571865, -0.002598943654447794, 0.0004914927994832397, -0.018003806471824646, 0.05467040091753006, -0.024790436029434204, 0.007614122703671455, -0.01470900233834982, 0.02608439512550831, -0.0037853242829442024, 0.054588060826063156, 0.01075081154704094, 0.01261788047850132, 0.017581721767783165, 0.01864144392311573, 0.006569972727447748, 0.048679277300834656, 0.06394914537668228, 0.020574625581502914, -0.011450272053480148, 0.01918785832822323, -0.019294580444693565, 0.00071864970959723, 0.010942916385829449, -0.030393579974770546, -0.024112043902277946, -0.01670016162097454, -0.00522948382422328, 0.08596844226121902, 0.02145741879940033, -0.006233678665012121, -0.021696684882044792, 0.07555858045816422, -0.038952335715293884, -0.04645252227783203, -0.023411838337779045, 0.0027789936866611242, -0.025770356878638268, -0.017339440062642097, 0.033840157091617584, -0.01692669652402401, -0.005975889042019844, 0.0026971176266670227, 0.005412906873971224, -0.05522162839770317, -0.005948830395936966, 0.06213690713047981, 0.00010737742559285834, -0.029276425018906593, 0.022939959540963173, 0.021176926791667938, -0.006269311998039484, 0.025026565417647362, 0.01519506424665451, -0.06055745854973793, 0.013267378322780132, -0.03631574660539627, 0.004483913071453571, -0.025394856929779053, 0.005863547790795565, 0.019127601757645607, 0.008557605557143688, -0.011954003013670444, 0.017104826867580414, -0.05328761413693428, 0.05435856431722641, 0.03630715236067772, 0.0003153732686769217, 0.013461461290717125, 0.02221725694835186, -0.009757828898727894, 0.013223925605416298, -0.01133479829877615, -0.013453232124447823, -0.05406617373228073, 0.008309198543429375, 0.05015936121344566, 0.012095973826944828, -0.02491234987974167, 0.035040758550167084, 0.011549105867743492, 0.010127278044819832, 0.015586805529892445, 0.008641766384243965, 0.010994735173881054, -0.024084733799099922, 0.0017936535878106952, -0.0053738923743367195, 0.021320899948477745, 0.009076624177396297, 0.021511277183890343, -0.020815832540392876, 0.06994251906871796, -0.045759037137031555, -0.013370816595852375, 0.0379229299724102, -0.003482543397694826, -0.009986723773181438, -0.014520668424665928, -0.012387728318572044, 0.0596308633685112, -0.021550634875893593, 0.03341429680585861, 0.05810336396098137, 0.020048195496201515, -0.028897708281874657, 0.03279149532318115, -0.00013637333177030087, 0.01799432933330536, 0.06489239633083344, -0.03376659005880356, 0.030684486031532288, 0.01014022622257471, -0.022034723311662674, 0.028558555990457535, -0.03739524260163307, -0.025606906041502953, -0.029241235926747322, -0.0044593000784516335, 0.0437864251434803, -0.007360632531344891, 0.02219587191939354, -0.033385783433914185, -0.019543852657079697, -0.029333079233765602, 0.002787619596347213, 0.013949024491012096, -0.027324054390192032, -0.06631781160831451, 0.009627865627408028, -0.012009499594569206, 0.018112866207957268, -0.010602139867842197, 0.011354805901646614, -0.0621911846101284, 0.006552720908075571, -0.02907523699104786, -0.06410729885101318, -0.03091723471879959, -0.012924731709063053, -0.027112510055303574, 0.010374602861702442, 0.010442214086651802, 0.0119450269266963, -0.0024055989924818277, 0.015253135934472084, 0.011128452606499195, -0.050852030515670776, 0.0039047577884048223, -0.05683153495192528, -0.0012136867735534906, -0.018491527065634727, 0.027247101068496704, 0.010801512748003006, 0.02243511751294136, -0.01754620671272278, -0.0009247306152246892, -0.08067886531352997, -0.0776766985654831, 0.02694275975227356, 0.025338998064398766, 0.04996887966990471, -0.010344728827476501, 0.008193652145564556, 0.040997494012117386, 0.023101910948753357, -0.010668618604540825, -0.047853779047727585, 0.0079175541177392, -0.036110565066337585, 0.006965972017496824, -0.017922258004546165, -0.02654813416302204, 0.04010215401649475, 0.01592458412051201, 0.020330626517534256, -0.018864750862121582, 0.028628112748265266, -0.02142299711704254, -0.02969023399055004, 0.0669163167476654, -0.021816512569785118, -0.0035270110238343477, 0.06236038729548454, 0.04054030030965805, -0.047897059470415115, 0.019955262541770935, -0.05521608516573906, -0.02672392502427101, 0.0518156923353672, -0.0371457003057003, -0.008070782758295536, 0.008242486044764519, 0.003898672293871641, -0.022374209016561508, 0.018207814544439316, 0.03935356065630913, -0.05120847746729851, 0.02357390709221363, 0.020582398399710655, 0.06876453012228012, 0.024682804942131042, -0.015284682624042034, 0.08131422102451324, 0.0370817631483078, -0.0023061500396579504, 0.007072215899825096, 0.0037300263065844774, -0.01409702468663454, 0.006374760530889034, -0.0428018681704998, -0.017984678968787193, 0.003921010065823793, 0.028252016752958298, 0.026920342817902565, 0.03320668265223503, -0.014366506598889828, -0.01257255394011736, -0.07068075239658356, 0.0086908470839262, -0.027336062863469124, 0.04604947566986084, 0.005370164290070534, 0.04326006770133972, 0.005682214163243771, 0.013177530840039253, -0.0014973388751968741, 0.022685356438159943, -0.08381329476833344, -0.025357520207762718, 0.028012674301862717, -0.007531095761805773, 0.020491980016231537, -0.03714347630739212, 0.020597495138645172, -0.01971718855202198, 0.023049678653478622, -0.012854392640292645, 0.035580798983573914, -0.037422630935907364, 0.005287963431328535, -0.021867824718356133, -0.034538477659225464, -0.008673395030200481, -0.016112498939037323, 0.03774663433432579, 0.008236080408096313, 0.050393905490636826, 0.01889761909842491, -0.00233830651268363, -0.005609272513538599, -0.007769675459712744, 0.024866744875907898, 0.004445093683898449, 0.006276993080973625, 0.025459760800004005, 0.05385351926088333, -0.061004117131233215, -0.015441864728927612, 0.043681804090738297, 0.05340784788131714, 0.013562416657805443, -0.00030134382541291416, -0.007224591448903084, -0.0455133356153965, -0.005249235779047012, 0.03392741084098816, 0.01745750568807125, -0.027090178802609444, -0.048582401126623154, 0.037717171013355255, 0.032991424202919006, -0.04422439634799957, 0.024677440524101257, 0.04378483071923256, 0.019473878666758537, -0.020227743312716484, 0.013783309608697891, -0.006498387549072504, 0.03346680477261543, -0.017887508496642113, 0.031157055869698524, 0.033843185752630234, 0.015555220656096935, -0.03090609423816204, 0.04160358011722565, -0.006756799295544624, -0.02118648774921894, -0.001888050464913249, -0.014301364310085773, 0.032403767108917236, -0.021403536200523376, -0.03040180914103985, -0.007532769348472357, 0.0313529372215271, 0.032721202820539474, 0.009008086286485195, -0.029247703030705452, -0.10253798961639404, 0.008699212223291397, 0.024045486003160477, 0.03623644635081291, -0.04606480151414871, 0.0028608913999050856, -0.035987384617328644, -0.033476147800683975, 0.0439181886613369, -0.0296370517462492, 0.011215820908546448, -0.031471483409404755, -0.008425747975707054, -0.010094665922224522, -0.0300164595246315, -0.01604854129254818, 0.05155489593744278, 0.008571943268179893, -0.002799886278808117, -0.01760663464665413, -0.0008742463542148471, -0.033983685076236725, 0.06744786351919174, 0.02093067578971386, 0.03977739438414574, -0.01025367435067892, -0.015634575858712196, 0.012198377400636673, -0.024938181042671204, -0.023840345442295074, -0.03202919661998749, 0.02661369927227497, -0.0006478758878074586, -0.006924936547875404, 0.036929406225681305, 0.01046669576317072, -0.04996799677610397, 0.0241861455142498, 0.013907676562666893, -0.04741977900266647, 0.002848756732419133, -0.014835383743047714, 0.07069793343544006, 0.05159066617488861, -0.0012741571990773082, 0.04289643466472626, 0.05679178610444069, -0.029946042224764824, 0.03268341347575188, -0.07041695713996887, -0.02681542932987213, 0.0009981952607631683, -0.005109826102852821, -0.049106769263744354, 0.003713662037625909, -0.00955054722726345, -0.0036805819254368544, 0.005848494824022055, 0.0274801142513752, -0.04086174815893173, -0.016216941177845, 0.01351473480463028, 0.04672737047076225, 0.0035569604951888323, 0.01053972914814949, -0.0006588938413187861, 0.0029018635395914316, -0.003919968381524086, 0.002352339681237936, 0.042384251952171326, 0.0024366199504584074, -0.012949241325259209, -0.015598613768815994, -0.0154235465452075, 0.007413722109049559, -0.03058667853474617, -0.023756269365549088, -0.00444734888151288, 0.0033999665174633265, 0.02557177096605301, 0.010348426178097725, 0.05195562168955803, -0.0009876342955976725, -0.047610118985176086, -0.040665920823812485, 0.023114128038287163, -0.01962783746421337, 0.008198271505534649, -0.00577855110168457, 0.043728336691856384, 0.015469029545783997, 0.019126353785395622, -0.044088978320360184, -0.0316825807094574, -0.031584277749061584, 0.028821062296628952, -0.039435822516679764, -0.07194400578737259, 0.00222426513209939, 0.01188720017671585, 0.004148042760789394, 0.020726671442389488, 0.052478641271591187, -0.045066848397254944, -0.007583263795822859, -0.030096808448433876, 0.0459490567445755, 0.0720425695180893, 0.023543749004602432, 0.01326807588338852, 0.001611818908713758, 0.023777611553668976, -0.010877198539674282, 0.005237220786511898, -0.0006725364946760237, -0.03353343531489372, -0.025286167860031128, 0.004181262571364641, 0.034472618252038956, 0.0632987916469574, 0.0034435775596648455, -0.026495415717363358, -0.013655050657689571, -0.010523876175284386, 0.010635877028107643, -0.013175591826438904, -0.003467836882919073, -0.04331235960125923, -0.006458951625972986, -0.05005844682455063, 0.04060034826397896, 0.009839224629104137, -0.0549614280462265, 0.03298210725188255, 0.020407482981681824, -0.010540816001594067, 0.003676029620692134, 0.09450899064540863, -0.012572200037539005, 0.02540825866162777, 0.013034761883318424, -0.00979667529463768, 0.03535190969705582, 0.006122643128037453, 0.000387703999876976, -0.019716043025255203, 0.01795252040028572, 0.007257392164319754, 0.011167393997311592, -0.035932473838329315, -0.05254600942134857, 0.04286929592490196, 0.02664179354906082, 0.03706139698624611, 0.038590360432863235, 0.011716770939528942, 0.014411762356758118, -0.038936879485845566, -0.015659814700484276, -0.021770143881440163, 0.03374621272087097, 0.08462858945131302, -0.00960928201675415, -0.03802363574504852, 0.011546985246241093, 0.0110666798427701, -0.0017327367095276713, 0.04921063035726547, 0.01990523189306259, 0.0024886445607990026, 0.033137477934360504, -0.04477563500404358, -0.058056216686964035, 0.00905619002878666, -0.03251868858933449, 0.005516903009265661, -0.05530069023370743, -0.023180866613984108, 0.01767253875732422, 0.07610620558261871, -0.012989606708288193, -0.039145566523075104, -0.04601426050066948, -0.06466600298881531, 0.054127998650074005, 0.02099902741611004, -0.005856156349182129, 0.0074030510149896145, -0.0051512629725039005, 0.03615562990307808, -0.013524696230888367, 0.008051292970776558, -0.05050990730524063, -0.012064684182405472, -0.0217693243175745, -0.04748881608247757, -0.035565584897994995, 0.01943803019821644, -0.025547273457050323, -0.05178624391555786, 0.01082511804997921, -0.017741044983267784, 0.008669460192322731, -0.0050309449434280396, 0.029686423018574715, -0.03689010813832283, 0.054434314370155334, 0.015708956867456436, -0.008441728539764881, -0.019173452630639076, -0.00950708333402872, 0.1309078186750412, 0.08176867663860321, 0.061657633632421494, -0.028273077681660652, 0.018409688025712967, 0.01139683648943901, -0.0010783756151795387, -0.011489489115774632, -0.002278208499774337, 0.03829430788755417, -0.037289008498191833, 0.02364921011030674, 0.02693977765738964, 0.0009000083082355559, 0.009473035112023354, 0.051224514842033386, -0.03259006887674332, -0.008847308345139027, -0.0060755303129553795, -0.010168046690523624, -0.04924551397562027, 0.00627095578238368, -0.013197435066103935, 0.002493814332410693, 0.07107505202293396, -0.02806815877556801, -0.04380131512880325, -0.01886858232319355, -0.007998290471732616, 0.029617825523018837, -0.06914690136909485, -0.02141258679330349, 0.009471513330936432, 0.03534886613488197, -0.009425168856978416, -0.039629846811294556, 0.010536341927945614, -0.025251390412449837, 0.018189743161201477, 0.026682447642087936, 0.004972940776497126, -0.022116510197520256, -0.009538337588310242, 0.024123696610331535, -0.036191459745168686, -0.0766199454665184, -0.03336687386035919, 0.01885797455906868, -0.005478445440530777, -0.036689743399620056, -0.014036363922059536, 0.008695141412317753, 0.01757952943444252, -0.02683422900736332, -0.001182833220809698, 0.006639025639742613, 0.030774567276239395, -0.0013988121645525098, -0.0506821870803833, -0.036375194787979126, -0.01159188337624073, -0.014236584305763245, -0.032235145568847656, 0.03103102184832096, -0.02813185751438141, -0.023301586508750916, -0.0171896331012249, 0.03599831089377403, 0.00339540746062994, -0.003899763338267803, -0.011472991667687893, -0.012774151749908924, -0.018072664737701416, -0.021557806059718132, 0.037559255957603455, -0.007256187964230776, -0.0016236770898103714, -0.017683284357190132, -0.015478154644370079, 0.036057859659194946, -0.04359755292534828, -0.0060441032983362675, -0.01544924359768629, -0.04183407127857208, 0.013651710003614426, -0.015563007444143295, -0.0018350353930145502, -0.00033544772304594517, -0.016408776864409447, 0.059452883899211884, -0.02344360575079918, 0.059690553694963455, -0.009628006257116795, -0.05646423250436783, -0.05535818636417389, 0.009257558733224869, -0.026766052469611168, 0.014524378813803196, -0.0017367147374898195, 0.07504972070455551, 0.004695341922342777, 0.040330950170755386, 0.008317297324538231, 0.017764553427696228, 0.015885107219219208, 0.05362280085682869, 0.00154740025755018, -0.08601917326450348, 0.009129141457378864, -0.026098953559994698, 0.006405069027096033, -0.016764508560299873, -0.027577809989452362, -0.018551519140601158, 0.006493857130408287, -0.018116872757673264, -0.03440089151263237, -0.07133258134126663, -0.010737169533967972, -0.025732433423399925, -0.00882501620799303, -0.03570856899023056, 0.018248917534947395, -0.01920917257666588, -0.0035903987009078264, -0.03804181516170502, -0.011714817956089973, 0.004186813719570637, -0.0015187602257356048, -0.007486472837626934, 0.018185865134000778, 0.024336325004696846, 0.008176444098353386, 0.04240899160504341, 0.023153001442551613, 0.0009218856575898826, 0.008822839707136154, 0.05229846015572548, -0.0034611003939062357, -0.01914050243794918, 0.0018985909409821033, -0.030401557683944702, -0.018216948956251144, 0.013843676075339317, 0.007303806487470865, 0.024839529767632484, 0.014910019002854824, 0.020887069404125214, -0.013016846962273121, 0.04053494706749916, 0.001283308258280158, -0.03413080424070358, 0.03584158048033714, 0.017417751252651215, -0.005377512890845537, -0.023338889703154564, -0.01584138721227646, 0.011603004299104214, -0.01774529740214348, 0.043666671961545944, 0.01477766502648592, 0.003427698742598295, -0.03316374868154526, 0.008943638764321804, -0.06832442432641983, 0.014520079828798771, 0.0014145791064947844, -0.03693501651287079, 0.021852761507034302, 0.05450745299458504, -0.009125902317464352, 0.04974346607923508, -0.014583168551325798, -0.004400597419589758, -0.06358654797077179, -0.052958838641643524, -0.011366920545697212, 0.03522635996341705, 0.00252213841304183, -0.054220426827669144, 0.02990465611219406, 0.05988122895359993, -0.030516555532813072, -0.013438183814287186, 0.006302341818809509, 0.01671944186091423, -0.03998136147856712, -0.018877070397138596, -0.026390710845589638, 0.008003556169569492, -0.000521784124430269, 0.030839836224913597, 0.034907713532447815, 0.021571310237050056, 0.027027476578950882, -0.06832417845726013, -0.039331354200839996, -0.011007756926119328, 0.010898075997829437, -0.07310346513986588, 0.044793501496315, 0.003557257354259491, -0.032066989690065384, 0.01176440715789795, -0.023976115509867668, 0.037575613707304, 0.04584460332989693, 0.04017112776637077, -0.0049059148877859116, 0.014197763055562973, 0.036307193338871, 0.01750524342060089, -0.0397079661488533, -0.013062615878880024, 0.027127454057335854, 0.02224436029791832, -0.040160149335861206, -0.009094320237636566, 0.010690412484109402, -0.026655547320842743, -0.019619617611169815, 0.03959842398762703, -0.05842847749590874, 0.0016805912600830197, 0.026394203305244446, 0.0010651045013219118, 0.005030657630413771, -0.0027847953606396914, -0.010196175426244736, -0.03553847223520279, -0.006527636665850878, 0.009547669440507889, 0.041084643453359604, -0.010335734114050865, 0.029360130429267883, 0.008531225845217705, -0.04360427334904671, -0.0214771069586277, -0.0026429665740579367, 0.01145942509174347, -0.0206185020506382, -0.012340672314167023, 0.006476762238889933, 0.0015010011848062277, -0.02439534105360508, 0.005966890137642622, -0.023908736184239388, 0.06471692770719528, -0.05321454629302025, -0.005760748405009508, -0.0017624585889279842, 0.019674627110362053, 0.05622107535600662, -0.07589317858219147, 0.08480674773454666, -0.009367013350129128, 0.01755085587501526, -0.04485702887177467, -0.0056843883357942104, -0.04976873844861984, 0.02052255906164646, 0.047085560858249664, 0.0009600080666132271, -0.007915935479104519, -0.033615559339523315, 0.024514924734830856, 0.027802636846899986, 0.008081110194325447, 0.046317897737026215, -0.022194020450115204, -0.020850984379649162, -0.003703848924487829, -0.015068106353282928, 0.00787736289203167, 0.03665753826498985, 0.05725661665201187, -0.005277973599731922, 0.004449260886758566, 0.01517440378665924, 0.025281323119997978, 0.019103936851024628, -0.01850532554090023, -0.02998991869390011, 0.024625936523079872, 0.02204071916639805, -0.03814759850502014, 0.04637041687965393, 0.0001996737119043246, -0.026020528748631477, 0.05733133479952812, -0.023198595270514488, -0.027735494077205658, 0.02100115269422531, 0.03630039840936661, 0.006842269096523523, -0.0642256960272789, 0.04741152003407478, 0.0030903059523552656, -0.0038451238069683313, -0.015085659921169281, 0.048112984746694565, 0.02853115275502205, 0.03928268328309059, 0.007854794152081013, -0.042054638266563416, 0.02877839095890522, 0.01686899922788143, 0.03134754300117493, 0.008225839585065842, 0.03786804527044296, 0.0006315074278973043, 0.0018717125058174133, -0.04151889309287071, -0.004620746243745089, 0.04068176820874214, 0.01039004698395729, 0.018005259335041046, 0.007889552973210812, 0.02367287129163742, 0.037765275686979294, 0.016021618619561195, 0.036607615649700165, -0.006029470358043909, 0.003016370814293623, 0.048980310559272766, -0.003381116082891822, -0.0036739350762218237, -0.03429713100194931, 0.004335197154432535, -0.02975369803607464, 0.016644950956106186, 0.02067113108932972, 0.011721551418304443, 0.04544086754322052, 0.027378752827644348, -0.03276313096284866, -0.005410795100033283, 0.03966490179300308, -0.02708737924695015, 0.013014307245612144, -0.024773718789219856, 0.012006810866296291, 0.012955202721059322, 0.006645639892667532, 0.006781227886676788, -0.005369750317186117, -0.00032287207432091236, 0.015545430593192577, 0.01893182285130024, -0.029735533520579338, -0.034664370119571686, -0.011028765700757504, 0.015315409749746323, -0.040403541177511215, -0.027689440175890923, -0.022896528244018555, -0.009090668521821499, 0.019917774945497513, -0.038084760308265686 ]
<p>Suppose I care about mispredicting one class much more than another. Is there a way I can communicate this information to the standard classification techniques?</p> <p>The only way I can think of is adjusting the threshold, but I wonder if there is a better way.</p>
74,431
[ -0.029800863936543465, -0.03409325331449509, -0.005246798507869244, 0.01522622350603342, 0.002910174895077944, 0.045356713235378265, -0.004923408851027489, 0.013943737372756004, 0.03479781374335289, 0.014051192440092564, 0.030810358002781868, 0.040165338665246964, 0.0327332466840744, 0.034146130084991455, -0.0036642858758568764, 0.003361330134794116, -0.019018422812223434, -0.019481724128127098, -0.0018649328267201781, -0.017247984185814857, -0.02426406368613243, 0.007822185754776001, -0.010282240808010101, -0.0135175921022892, 0.00976436585187912, 0.028661636635661125, 0.07569798827171326, -0.008524691686034203, 0.02260282076895237, 0.01974114216864109, -0.04996133968234062, -0.006163902580738068, 0.0033334202598780394, 0.04955721274018288, 0.015445233322679996, -0.011552727781236172, -0.004370438866317272, -0.028631597757339478, -0.02027016691863537, 0.017475245520472527, -0.01837260276079178, -0.009987279772758484, 0.03290904685854912, 0.06432076543569565, -0.005107514560222626, 0.019603580236434937, -0.03426583483815193, -0.0034586067777127028, 0.02123299054801464, -0.039476178586483, 0.061170902103185654, -0.016907276585698128, 0.00021543119510170072, 0.0695125013589859, -0.04079574719071388, 0.009352329187095165, 0.07632879167795181, 0.0997280403971672, -0.017356885597109795, -0.044594623148441315, -0.01190890185534954, -0.015217657200992107, 0.015138584189116955, -0.023633359000086784, -0.019704094156622887, 0.022853529080748558, 0.005796316545456648, -0.03857802599668503, 0.009545821696519852, 0.001091077458113432, -0.015618800185620785, -0.007457715924829245, 0.02616567350924015, 0.013636411167681217, 0.06900852918624878, -0.04398170858621597, -0.0022025301586836576, 0.07085251808166504, 0.03932604193687439, 0.00788787379860878, 0.04490632191300392, 0.01957656443119049, 0.02826700359582901, 0.04883788898587227, 0.008484512567520142, -0.00886262021958828, 0.04275175929069519, -0.025924310088157654, 0.005018278956413269, 0.052327580749988556, -0.016631832346320152, -0.015679866075515747, 0.046972449868917465, -0.025796663016080856, -0.015567283146083355, 0.03388860449194908, 0.008470559492707253, -0.004731996916234493, 0.027033429592847824, -0.01517946831882, 0.0011979722185060382, -0.011935917660593987, -0.005060566123574972, 0.033691078424453735, -0.04283059760928154, -0.014486611820757389, -0.05253976583480835, -0.02563781850039959, 0.01610836386680603, -0.0027144805062562227, 0.015933701768517494, 0.019998295232653618, 0.0035680171567946672, 0.017547452822327614, 0.007090665865689516, 0.018171116709709167, -0.016428112983703613, -0.03218413144350052, 0.03675270825624466, 0.04121057689189911, 0.07342714071273804, -0.050865061581134796, 0.03444351628422737, -0.005550360772758722, -0.0562157928943634, 0.006104408297687769, 0.04846414923667908, -0.03603053465485573, -0.03280901536345482, 0.02210175432264805, -0.02406691014766693, -0.02127431519329548, 0.019644184038043022, -0.03269258514046669, -0.000497383764013648, 0.012894137762486935, -0.06778616458177567, -0.04172438383102417, -0.0009764137212187052, 0.009587167762219906, -0.014724930748343468, -0.0937686637043953, -0.05004317685961723, 0.05771203711628914, 0.03385027125477791, 0.029059499502182007, 0.008136053569614887, 0.039734985679388046, 0.0242546945810318, 0.008814748376607895, -0.006639877799898386, 0.021147629246115685, -0.034684356302022934, 0.015300230123102665, -0.04434904828667641, -0.045789096504449844, 0.011817109771072865, 0.029537584632635117, -0.010783066973090172, 0.03745175153017044, 0.017678406089544296, -0.03019258752465248, -0.012636582367122173, -0.01041528582572937, 0.014082119800150394, 0.001878736773505807, 0.08401194959878922, -0.008205542340874672, 0.05188377946615219, -0.0022412026301026344, -0.002526045311242342, 0.017134249210357666, 0.026660749688744545, 0.045259471982717514, 0.060588736087083817, -0.00038098901859484613, 0.0032393094152212143, -0.011633605696260929, 0.006352841388434172, -0.04327104240655899, -0.03213351592421532, -0.041946571320295334, -0.025273118168115616, 0.003242726903408766, -0.002265287796035409, 0.01469736360013485, -0.009873422794044018, -0.002078066812828183, 0.02544187754392624, -0.03869299590587616, -0.05088171735405922, -0.05430760234594345, 0.0026934875641018152, -0.05571207404136658, -0.01215026993304491, 0.036543846130371094, -0.02256656438112259, -0.0018452316289767623, -0.0323907732963562, -0.011314306408166885, -0.01241464726626873, 0.009199257008731365, 0.04387446865439415, -0.053453829139471054, -0.01760532520711422, 0.018944397568702698, 0.011284302920103073, -0.03152512386441231, 0.04120219871401787, -0.026806583628058434, -0.07039494812488556, 0.021546227857470512, -0.018284881487488747, 0.010363585315644741, -0.003123616334050894, -0.006766489241272211, 0.005467620678246021, -0.024093104526400566, -0.025449970737099648, 0.02570711262524128, -0.023584706708788872, 0.07733526080846786, 0.041118230670690536, 0.014162302017211914, -0.010345238260924816, 0.016226276755332947, -0.013944524340331554, 0.000966754334513098, -0.020653001964092255, -0.018087368458509445, -0.05579056218266487, -0.010927003808319569, 0.027786003425717354, 0.002676154486835003, -0.04070407524704933, 0.00994144007563591, 0.052124302834272385, 0.0057469261810183525, 0.01955871284008026, 0.01619451306760311, 0.023485777899622917, -0.003471897216513753, 0.02346465177834034, 0.006754409521818161, -0.00696689123287797, 0.008304491639137268, 0.04561861976981163, 0.006422122474759817, 0.03139286860823631, -0.013956500217318535, 0.0010150562738999724, 0.054021209478378296, -0.01459395233541727, 0.02838241308927536, -0.009186159819364548, -0.014195702038705349, 0.012903095223009586, -0.0010581692913547158, 0.024361204355955124, 0.033865369856357574, -0.016766371205449104, -0.014815987087786198, 0.04703153669834137, 0.007875491864979267, 0.028528288006782532, 0.04575620964169502, -0.009367283433675766, 0.029225854203104973, 0.044515661895275116, -0.04575871676206589, 0.02147349901497364, -0.007421925663948059, -0.04432573541998863, -0.025668803602457047, 0.03500046208500862, 0.03442104905843735, 0.018047863617539406, 0.034987978637218475, -0.024882696568965912, -0.022298140451312065, 0.006981512065976858, -0.005250413436442614, 0.04070558398962021, -0.01076867152005434, -0.04550521820783615, -0.009175455197691917, -0.04452226310968399, -0.06950349360704422, 0.011916618794202805, -0.0033968398347496986, -0.025794941931962967, -0.01454645674675703, -0.017881732434034348, -0.031835995614528656, -0.036599185317754745, -0.04616919904947281, 0.03056342527270317, -0.006611625663936138, -0.04929167032241821, 0.016581961885094643, -0.026636196300387383, -0.04286763817071915, 0.00966289546340704, -0.000837641186080873, -0.02185056172311306, -0.029891395941376686, -0.022153055295348167, -0.0027672552969306707, -0.003013310255482793, -0.027902258560061455, 0.0367487370967865, -0.007131993304938078, -0.03261541947722435, -0.04714334011077881, -0.06788233667612076, 0.019299736246466637, 0.005523822735995054, 0.03551938757300377, 0.011310319416224957, 0.0306662917137146, 0.07461991161108017, 0.01564437337219715, -0.01062968373298645, -0.0105973482131958, -0.011192355304956436, -0.027668319642543793, -0.04859743267297745, 0.004251199774444103, 0.03393979370594025, 0.023723777383565903, 0.026096828281879425, 0.010993019677698612, -0.010301495902240276, 0.03474680706858635, 0.0035254673566669226, -0.07221498340368271, 0.004162132740020752, 0.010961287654936314, -0.010658590123057365, 0.018548578023910522, 0.030141681432724, -0.021132033318281174, 0.016259586438536644, -0.003177165286615491, 0.0031944040674716234, 0.03076990507543087, -0.0033932155929505825, 0.023484764620661736, -0.012519126757979393, 0.02690163441002369, -0.00249476614408195, 0.015574267134070396, 0.016300702467560768, -0.04223709926009178, -0.02948038838803768, -0.0031718644313514233, 0.0595424510538578, -0.0271433237940073, 0.011883676052093506, 0.06419026106595993, 0.08267368376255035, -0.016271553933620453, -0.019267214462161064, -0.012811180204153061, 0.002247447380796075, 0.018423153087496758, -0.02324586920440197, -0.032901566475629807, 0.03341350331902504, 0.028347183018922806, 0.005436820909380913, 0.02575405314564705, -0.04268152266740799, 0.02342350222170353, -0.08101511746644974, -0.014119306579232216, -0.03761010617017746, 0.05733157694339752, 0.025527017191052437, -0.010024049319326878, 0.033555250614881516, -0.014731848612427711, 0.02020878717303276, 0.051971230655908585, -0.06927668303251266, 0.046460069715976715, 0.0028576082549989223, -0.0018537392606958747, -0.02638673223555088, -0.03552264720201492, 0.027709683403372765, -0.032231301069259644, 0.0028976246248930693, 0.004826920572668314, 0.018070902675390244, -0.029312053695321083, -0.015084639191627502, 0.028188057243824005, -0.01682279258966446, -0.022040532901883125, 0.009066199883818626, 0.0022845088969916105, 0.006145989056676626, 0.03318170830607414, 0.028793537989258766, 0.024800756946206093, -0.02180038020014763, -0.058486342430114746, 0.033636223524808884, -0.0207874346524477, 0.04723918437957764, -0.009950768202543259, 0.020553747192025185, -0.07745607197284698, 0.018173759803175926, 0.017081957310438156, 0.04976033419370651, 0.029761821031570435, -0.014927380718290806, -0.015776226297020912, -0.042053982615470886, -0.020778343081474304, 0.013566792011260986, 0.054648127406835556, -0.046018145978450775, -0.027811763808131218, 0.029194239526987076, 0.021015606820583344, -0.0929531529545784, 0.002346857450902462, 0.042641352862119675, -0.0015012945514172316, -0.040108922868967056, -0.029250431805849075, -0.017711158841848373, -0.0026839817874133587, 0.0017329355468973517, -0.02127157524228096, 0.026038864627480507, 0.006425750907510519, -0.031222501769661903, 0.03822348639369011, -0.015957169234752655, -0.0564669668674469, -0.00830937922000885, -0.0018123729387298226, 0.004275299608707428, 0.008274195715785027, 0.029826276004314423, 0.012929894030094147, 0.02044660411775112, 0.023694146424531937, 0.015396068803966045, 0.020605966448783875, -0.10820414870977402, -0.04338054358959198, 0.04574931412935257, 0.04034719243645668, -0.04555487260222435, -0.03103255294263363, -0.047806598246097565, -0.009417393244802952, 0.05272895097732544, -0.015519877895712852, 0.032108649611473083, -0.015844808891415596, -0.0010771623346954584, -0.04607726261019707, 0.024236906319856644, -0.06893378496170044, 0.02039802260696888, -0.02341502346098423, 0.032246269285678864, 0.019145503640174866, 0.0055610621348023415, -0.06259217858314514, 0.003599847899749875, -0.006699582561850548, 0.07110819965600967, -0.009600799530744553, -0.015231114812195301, 0.021073175594210625, -0.0018283217214047909, -0.02841869369149208, -0.06506451964378357, 0.012411577627062798, -0.004071387927979231, -0.012536763213574886, 0.018978390842676163, 0.009507883340120316, -0.03357895836234093, 0.012536260299384594, 0.020296450704336166, -0.05298604071140289, -0.03668529912829399, -0.015175201930105686, 0.036332909017801285, 0.036169733852148056, 0.045613210648298264, 0.047346409410238266, 0.011279432103037834, 0.0175586249679327, -0.001733500394038856, -0.04872508719563484, 0.008750012144446373, -0.029466537758708, -0.025753600522875786, -0.006958094425499439, -0.010891936719417572, -0.032126687467098236, 0.04482310637831688, 0.029774855822324753, 0.04310888424515724, -0.00954547431319952, -0.055463243275880814, -0.018664389848709106, 0.0023220726288855076, -0.016804607585072517, -0.01975092478096485, 0.014545750804245472, -0.0028104614466428757, -0.019997993484139442, 0.04498901963233948, -0.0019204389536753297, -0.012320606969296932, 0.017480913549661636, 0.04333650320768356, -0.04152986407279968, 0.04260546341538429, -0.06462538987398148, -0.020222214981913567, -0.002200950402766466, -0.03483865037560463, 0.03306485712528229, 0.04391027241945267, 0.04581649973988533, 0.001105775940231979, -0.02234428934752941, -0.008975298143923283, 0.024753890931606293, -0.016043975949287415, 0.022736242040991783, -0.042727600783109665, 0.041509754955768585, -0.012621777132153511, 0.016226891428232193, -0.04756663739681244, -0.02925572171807289, 0.011137805879116058, 0.031670428812503815, -0.02006002515554428, -0.03197736293077469, 0.0077535174787044525, 0.022385329008102417, -0.019521750509738922, 0.0014204144245013595, 0.06023373454809189, -0.002227386925369501, -0.04258550703525543, -0.007426698692142963, 0.014969890005886555, 0.08708973228931427, -0.02087303251028061, 0.011104781180620193, 0.0246417298913002, -0.017655599862337112, -0.043668121099472046, -0.012424991466104984, 0.02565586380660534, -0.04760442301630974, -0.03594003617763519, -0.047864627093076706, 0.04282071441411972, 0.03423158451914787, 0.0033712678123265505, 0.019869856536388397, 0.011832461692392826, 0.00863783061504364, 0.01973477564752102, -0.029636705294251442, -0.0004006583767477423, -0.0007472586003132164, -0.000610476010479033, -0.01657842844724655, 0.007911326363682747, 0.013078397139906883, -0.026825793087482452, 0.0048233699053525925, 0.02213187888264656, -0.0472080260515213, 0.005220704711973667, 0.019450029358267784, -0.016017824411392212, -0.003691565478220582, -0.003195537254214287, -0.05623539909720421, 0.04981400817632675, 0.007941989228129387, 0.001525463885627687, 0.013522674329578876, 0.028126902878284454, -0.027249310165643692, -0.013945287093520164, -0.030977504327893257, -0.029004458338022232, 0.03365182876586914, 0.009894158691167831, 0.056814711540937424, 0.04108434170484543, -0.00218777428381145, -0.030374763533473015, -0.0232361052185297, -0.023800062015652657, -0.010101688094437122, 0.01086229458451271, 0.04184930399060249, -0.006716867908835411, 0.026116088032722473, -0.000009462464731768705, 0.025204747915267944, 0.01075742021203041, 0.059327755123376846, 0.017551928758621216, 0.038781989365816116, 0.027874521911144257, -0.05281982570886612, -0.03757604956626892, 0.05730537325143814, -0.05232788622379303, -0.017437778413295746, -0.018545620143413544, -0.01028122566640377, 0.03216218948364258, 0.02386006899178028, 0.010226459242403507, -0.0028988192789256573, -0.01100180298089981, -0.05665277689695358, 0.016905365511775017, 0.024636972695589066, 0.013087144121527672, 0.035547733306884766, -0.02088170498609543, 0.03691088780760765, -0.021047089248895645, 0.031025830656290054, -0.03372371196746826, -0.08351068943738937, -0.05406150221824646, -0.059298332780599594, -0.04290441423654556, 0.029661590233445168, 0.04719027504324913, -0.021209565922617912, 0.022943807765841484, -0.011453833431005478, 0.06809632480144501, 0.025736117735505104, 0.04754863306879997, -0.018142618238925934, 0.014259099029004574, 0.007899744436144829, 0.023848894983530045, 0.006018170155584812, 0.008499654941260815, 0.1518767774105072, 0.06917764246463776, 0.06170520558953285, -0.04864654690027237, 0.025461183860898018, -0.0016882841009646654, 0.008628100156784058, -0.00839318335056305, 0.026331188157200813, 0.009822950698435307, -0.01867189072072506, -0.009735485538840294, 0.023839514702558517, 0.007154520135372877, -0.02433207258582115, 0.04791959375143051, -0.01599758490920067, 0.025374218821525574, 0.04068266600370407, 0.014804421924054623, 0.035092927515506744, 0.006044899113476276, -0.03751398250460625, -0.01298912987112999, 0.00963045097887516, -0.013448541052639484, -0.023949597030878067, -0.030955709517002106, -0.004416986834257841, -0.0065730842761695385, -0.016241736710071564, -0.0010346986819058657, 0.032076846808195114, 0.009908857755362988, 0.030528061091899872, -0.0022565689869225025, -0.00840912014245987, -0.022745484486222267, -0.008528809063136578, 0.03323020040988922, 0.009519376792013645, 0.004218436311930418, -0.009501175954937935, 0.024925170466303825, -0.030137799680233, -0.03370623663067818, -0.03971720114350319, 0.0406080037355423, -0.003101861570030451, -0.043012574315071106, 0.010647408664226532, -0.01726345717906952, -0.005593845620751381, -0.05197545140981674, -0.029382891952991486, 0.04704073444008827, -0.0006937173893675208, 0.010838277637958527, -0.019424906000494957, -0.014202945865690708, 0.039086323231458664, -0.005860404577106237, 0.020288053900003433, -0.005739004351198673, -0.03862578421831131, -0.018269008025527, 0.012018014676868916, 0.019253231585025787, 0.02425595559179783, 0.02089970000088215, -0.0009461691370233893, -0.013845565728843212, -0.026916883885860443, -0.04581737890839577, -0.007964879274368286, 0.01588846929371357, -0.0010350715601816773, -0.00510797742754221, -0.024322468787431717, -0.02335176058113575, -0.04426106438040733, 0.020703455433249474, -0.023614605888724327, 0.04075739532709122, -0.02343670278787613, 0.009016405791044235, 0.03300565481185913, 0.03189621865749359, 0.03470126539468765, 0.03612734004855156, 0.03384954482316971, 0.04413373023271561, 0.018264297395944595, -0.010306542739272118, -0.028579069301486015, -0.006082430016249418, -0.0300764087587595, 0.025747355073690414, 0.02642863430082798, 0.05825400352478027, 0.015962984412908554, -0.006049702409654856, -0.0073091560043394566, 0.027156010270118713, 0.0015199334593489766, 0.0036698458716273308, 0.0006730310269631445, -0.02231764979660511, -0.025388069450855255, -0.005307340528815985, 0.025518959388136864, -0.023317527025938034, -0.03600431606173515, -0.05150377005338669, -0.05369563400745392, 0.013417842797935009, -0.0037297618109732866, -0.006847068667411804, 0.027907753363251686, -0.01773861236870289, 0.00569266127422452, -0.006315724924206734, -0.0009381021372973919, -0.034494612365961075, -0.009946984238922596, -0.04089900851249695, -0.03812554106116295, 0.003029742045328021, -0.0014328177785500884, -0.04881835728883743, 0.006747585721313953, 0.04802125692367554, -0.020242728292942047, 0.010788053274154663, 0.016623480245471, -0.009317920543253422, -0.008770962245762348, 0.0537860207259655, -0.028438925743103027, 0.0016430274117738008, 0.007225998677313328, -0.03265076130628586, -0.00758317019790411, 0.00229648663662374, -0.002863158704712987, 0.02870672196149826, 0.03833204135298729, -0.019729509949684143, -0.008111461065709591, 0.05390048399567604, -0.02105206437408924, -0.027539944276213646, 0.016193464398384094, 0.025247633457183838, -0.01744481548666954, -0.0005687942029908299, 0.03446456417441368, -0.01349595282226801, -0.03349924460053444, -0.003392700105905533, 0.006294624414294958, 0.05248526483774185, -0.038871392607688904, 0.016435934230685234, -0.006664533168077469, 0.04573586583137512, -0.038579750806093216, 0.01154337264597416, 0.023324163630604744, 0.006858528591692448, -0.01385021023452282, 0.03501737117767334, -0.0028447515796869993, 0.031159134581685066, -0.10785059630870819, -0.012795068323612213, 0.04333382844924927, 0.02619599550962448, 0.05558759346604347, -0.024989593774080276, 0.04731041565537453, 0.02731853537261486, -0.010717189870774746, 0.020165935158729553, -0.01745368167757988, -0.03361101821064949, -0.031676746904850006, 0.03709394484758377, -0.0547577366232872, 0.028066283091902733, 0.03605121746659279, 0.0004159018862992525, 0.024987658485770226, 0.0012993896380066872, -0.005196386482566595, -0.02038153074681759, -0.016118543222546577, 0.00443304656073451, -0.0032947466243058443, -0.05884920433163643, 0.034151241183280945, -0.04788542166352272, -0.04493856802582741, 0.03593447431921959, -0.009635621681809425, 0.012512358836829662, 0.06323155760765076, 0.02977231703698635, 0.025091778486967087, 0.03805208578705788, 0.006842613220214844, -0.041177231818437576, -0.006386179476976395, 0.018367256969213486, 0.029188033193349838, 0.025921249762177467, -0.02710062824189663, 0.015533018857240677, -0.011668606661260128, -0.010255824774503708, -0.0028342180885374546, 0.01268309447914362, -0.05053854361176491, -0.0442323163151741, -0.030843060463666916, 0.005103660747408867, 0.02788618579506874, -0.05041886866092682, 0.007033976726233959, -0.02330273576080799, 0.01117166317999363, 0.01302024070173502, 0.012093838304281235, 0.005479973740875721, 0.01681770384311676, -0.04010884463787079, -0.039057713001966476, -0.010488755069673061, 0.018731631338596344, -0.024649135768413544, -0.04886438697576523, -0.021215960383415222, 0.012543708086013794, -0.015696993097662926, 0.005354069638997316, -0.03491458296775818, -0.012918923981487751, 0.048330627381801605, -0.029249906539916992, 0.03914206102490425, 0.02368151769042015, -0.0009191107819788158, -0.01162902545183897, -0.08246820420026779, 0.051097579300403595, 0.02349085919559002, 0.01018337719142437, -0.028221676126122475, -0.015741491690278053, -0.0409565307199955, 0.021002041175961494, 0.0967491865158081, 0.009877176024019718, -0.01354234665632248, -0.023082761093974113, 0.0028537646867334843, 0.003490773495286703, -0.025774959474802017, 0.028904151171445847, -0.005705228075385094, -0.029841972514986992, -0.009638253599405289, -0.025053873658180237, 0.023084189742803574, 0.016327248886227608, -0.0020569604821503162, 0.003251889254897833, -0.004674673546105623, 0.005427516531199217, -0.017985433340072632, 0.029833203181624413, -0.024034623056650162, 0.015218493528664112, 0.029698580503463745, 0.016904497519135475, 0.026471152901649475, 0.02514556609094143, 0.0082350242882967, -0.04433953016996384, 0.02133992686867714, -0.04463941976428032, -0.04395784065127373, 0.018768060952425003, 0.022019606083631516, 0.0037140604108572006, -0.0620885044336319, -0.010940357111394405, 0.016816191375255585, -0.02495904639363289, 0.02132384106516838, 0.04847852885723114, 0.006540180183947086, 0.05792556330561638, -0.030213678255677223, 0.038436565548181534, 0.0183128509670496, -0.01884503848850727, 0.024805422872304916, -0.00786963663995266, -0.003538211341947317, 0.013880999758839607, 0.04320347309112549, 0.03643997758626938, -0.002972614485770464, 0.008437608368694782, 0.0003152273129671812, 0.03115096315741539, -0.03475340083241463, 0.02273290790617466, 0.011340731754899025, 0.00810229405760765, 0.015400122851133347, 0.0165041983127594, 0.013150372542440891, 0.0209346916526556, -0.0008098070393316448, -0.03979577496647835, -0.09119690209627151, -0.012557637877762318, -0.0073773968033492565, -0.008850003592669964, 0.017198096960783005, 0.0464947484433651, 0.034915659576654434, -0.0047214217483997345, 0.01505308412015438, 0.01354267168790102, 0.04271794855594635, -0.02911766804754734, 0.0199604295194149, -0.03567419946193695, -0.0243305042386055, 0.0016745834145694971, -0.0012808151077479124, -0.047168511897325516, -0.012575394473969936, 0.02405857853591442, 0.04282117635011673, 0.07389859855175018, -0.0063629718497395515, -0.039497051388025284, -0.04087873920798302, 0.0087052583694458, -0.07726232707500458, -0.008450977504253387, -0.07088448852300644, 0.011819790117442608, 0.020858779549598694, -0.07190366089344025 ]
<p>I'm a newbie so I have only basic statistical skills.</p> <p>I'm wondering if it is possible to use any stat test to analyze the previous matches between 2 tennis players to build a solid betting tip that proves to be profitable in the long run.</p> <p>I don't expect an answer that makes me billionair (lol, 4 sure I'm not the first who thought this), but some inputs, how you would approach this task and if it would be feasible.</p> <p>I'm asking this question because recently I've seen a website that makes something similar analyzing the previous matches of tennis players and giving hints to bet. [I don't know if I'm allowed to post links, if I'm not please remove this mods ;) <a href="http://www.superduper-tennis.com/" rel="nofollow">http://www.superduper-tennis.com/</a> ]</p> <p>And this seems to be profitable given his graphs: <a href="http://www.tennisinsight.com/allTimeUserEarningsSummary.php?userID=28" rel="nofollow">http://www.tennisinsight.com/allTimeUserEarningsSummary.php?userID=28</a></p> <p>Thanks in advance for any hint!</p>
37,299
[ -0.006689916364848614, -0.052975911647081375, -0.01639891043305397, 0.018296141177415848, 0.02708529867231846, 0.035040128976106644, 0.021699273958802223, -0.021389121189713478, -0.017513642087578773, -0.00428253598511219, 0.03587471321225166, 0.009315701201558113, 0.023267658427357674, 0.03608028590679169, 0.017147928476333618, -0.013759064488112926, -0.034540001302957535, -0.03011268377304077, -0.002754762303084135, 0.020232241600751877, 0.02754831686615944, 0.004414860624819994, 0.005981094669550657, 0.03362542390823364, -0.03604164347052574, 0.03150395676493645, 0.012431109324097633, -0.03239063918590546, 0.002652550581842661, 0.048755668103694916, -0.02210644632577896, -0.027093535289168358, 0.03234586864709854, 0.02991276979446411, 0.023721201345324516, -0.0013834396377205849, -0.011684740893542767, -0.022484926506876945, 0.0018132295226678252, -0.0020049086306244135, -0.035121239721775055, -0.018222946673631668, 0.006236739456653595, 0.047015249729156494, -0.007148416712880135, 0.023380737751722336, -0.012864457443356514, -0.03918325528502464, 0.04453890398144722, -0.06342288106679916, 0.07727135717868805, 0.00043771887430921197, 0.028356095775961876, 0.04285242035984993, -0.009854930453002453, 0.006605594884604216, 0.044541552662849426, 0.09375839680433273, 0.018511204048991203, -0.04632961377501488, 0.024376386776566505, -0.010885748080909252, -0.01052628643810749, 0.004719384480267763, -0.05452383682131767, 0.04414447396993637, -0.0069699836894869804, -0.02781561017036438, 0.05031205713748932, -0.035126809030771255, -0.01320453267544508, 0.04343472421169281, 0.027076613157987595, 0.005772617179900408, 0.019006434828042984, -0.02406964637339115, 0.015358003787696362, -0.0008419635123573244, 0.03149373456835747, 0.023890459910035133, -0.025481464341282845, 0.009395343251526356, 0.06313591450452805, 0.05939853936433792, 0.05971295386552811, -0.003001551842316985, 0.04635677486658096, -0.048998646438121796, -0.0005226155044510961, 0.02663767896592617, -0.011448265984654427, -0.004284082446247339, 0.01778072491288185, 0.006224006414413452, -0.06246820092201233, 0.0006444533355534077, -0.014011734165251255, 0.030527912080287933, -0.01010157074779272, -0.059327397495508194, 0.015382882207632065, -0.0388110913336277, -0.006335219833999872, 0.02908729575574398, -0.03514428064227104, -0.04857586696743965, -0.028718693181872368, -0.00828102882951498, 0.016121087595820427, 0.005271892063319683, -0.03501620888710022, 0.038679420948028564, -0.013640070334076881, -0.026060545817017555, 0.03048752434551716, -0.036343712359666824, -0.0244586244225502, 0.0236734040081501, 0.04868744686245918, 0.02365313097834587, 0.03409184142947197, -0.01566028967499733, 0.026836970821022987, -0.05259419232606888, -0.022644422948360443, -0.007639778312295675, 0.02515152096748352, -0.011324752122163773, -0.018557699397206306, 0.04885951057076454, -0.017580049112439156, -0.0004214084183331579, 0.03145764768123627, -0.003476385260000825, 0.031192736700177193, -0.02634202316403389, -0.05606795847415924, -0.012710455805063248, 0.06535501033067703, -0.03620303049683571, -0.011954190209507942, -0.06791603565216064, -0.01191015262156725, 0.005240920465439558, 0.025903940200805664, 0.035114265978336334, 0.054917313158512115, -0.0025299927219748497, 0.02010522037744522, 0.015237131156027317, -0.007389385718852282, -0.040256720036268234, -0.019246838986873627, -0.0134586775675416, 0.019197003915905952, -0.06328526139259338, -0.012832782231271267, 0.01619957759976387, -0.026038018986582756, -0.03562300279736519, 0.03420011326670647, 0.007142615970224142, -0.0097891204059124, -0.00690051494166255, 0.004757422022521496, -0.024277567863464355, 0.09481965750455856, 0.01718929037451744, 0.021497800946235657, -0.0034464041236788034, -0.008498500101268291, 0.023467542603611946, 0.04081584885716438, -0.010932281613349915, 0.049538757652044296, -0.0013294751988723874, -0.005882826168090105, 0.02410244010388851, -0.013457038439810276, -0.012940545566380024, -0.018323974683880806, -0.03780755773186684, -0.0018141698092222214, -0.014878371730446815, 0.02519909478724003, 0.04962553456425667, 0.01297290064394474, -0.0021636539604514837, 0.017161142081022263, -0.05607050657272339, -0.013712854124605656, -0.07336574047803879, -0.009674562141299248, -0.006819927599281073, -0.002695757430046797, -0.008504041470587254, -0.0030004000291228294, 0.03953646123409271, -0.009501093067228794, -0.030823566019535065, -0.016000937670469284, 0.02297190949320793, 0.039683401584625244, -0.04310910403728485, 0.005792343057692051, 0.05564971640706062, 0.041885338723659515, -0.04560279846191406, 0.024222515523433685, -0.05988940969109535, -0.054685842245817184, 0.00493792025372386, -0.028848012909293175, 0.034587401896715164, 0.03192618861794472, 0.0006720148376189172, 0.040851037949323654, 0.007102403324097395, -0.008315221406519413, -0.0010203297715634108, -0.016183771193027496, 0.05408403277397156, 0.03724366053938866, 0.009335729293525219, -0.011603591963648796, -0.007519678212702274, 0.027337761595845222, 0.02174992300570011, -0.021893149241805077, -0.0029224043246358633, -0.052010439336299896, 0.022320721298456192, 0.022989826276898384, 0.03575065732002258, -0.02531970851123333, 0.029103562235832214, 0.09662136435508728, 0.015065092593431473, -0.0049813189543783665, 0.017556462436914444, -0.035824887454509735, 0.005579888820648193, -0.025544442236423492, 0.04311477020382881, 0.005673711653798819, 0.0286184661090374, 0.03893288969993591, 0.013246866874396801, -0.01476675271987915, 0.028430594131350517, 0.012683522887527943, 0.02069615013897419, 0.0005731654819101095, 0.004969384986907244, 0.014460972510278225, -0.034875474870204926, 0.04804592207074165, -0.004123719409108162, 0.014885739423334599, 0.012076213024556637, 0.024499453604221344, -0.013614418916404247, -0.004340251442044973, -0.01715763658285141, -0.011391856707632542, 0.030931860208511353, -0.023339437320828438, 0.025817429646849632, 0.01670755259692669, -0.03881717845797539, -0.016641216352581978, 0.003088543424382806, 0.01652137190103531, -0.043359506875276566, 0.01898110657930374, -0.000015648009139113128, -0.01286911591887474, 0.02512570656836033, 0.010102180764079094, -0.04749756306409836, 0.006856982130557299, -0.011853490024805069, 0.01881938800215721, -0.016615213826298714, -0.057440079748630524, 0.014494524337351322, 0.011652646586298943, 0.01739628054201603, 0.018556831404566765, 0.002875709440559149, 0.04539146646857262, 0.051402147859334946, 0.007483119610697031, -0.046410445123910904, -0.03418271616101265, -0.02759178914129734, 0.03851316496729851, -0.03568779304623604, -0.02376403473317623, 0.050475262105464935, 0.0143935177475214, -0.02755463868379593, 0.024027030915021896, -0.015972904860973358, -0.027472184970974922, -0.04635700583457947, 0.008006218820810318, 0.0012315557105466723, -0.0005757646868005395, 0.02200358174741268, 0.005476860795170069, -0.029727313667535782, 0.005432928446680307, -0.09524497389793396, -0.0812772586941719, 0.06012486666440964, 0.030358705669641495, -0.0050218068063259125, -0.006101969163864851, -0.023373901844024658, 0.03794144093990326, 0.01691402867436409, -0.03663470596075058, -0.06211089342832565, -0.006935578770935535, -0.009552217088639736, -0.03219444677233696, -0.005324482452124357, 0.005547021050006151, -0.02587757632136345, 0.036100562661886215, -0.0025212103500962257, 0.02511109597980976, 0.02433912642300129, 0.027224160730838776, -0.007513448130339384, -0.0017092317575588822, -0.004091785755008459, 0.023307478055357933, 0.021032918244600296, -0.0007038605981506407, -0.05296853184700012, -0.021533619612455368, -0.021067602559924126, 0.02347002550959587, 0.007483021356165409, -0.029726378619670868, 0.009444447234272957, -0.01572326011955738, 0.0129292793571949, -0.008689777925610542, 0.03889540582895279, 0.021468589082360268, 0.004159067757427692, -0.04537728801369667, -0.010557963512837887, 0.01755513995885849, 0.013175003230571747, 0.0411505252122879, 0.08332288265228271, 0.010596374049782753, -0.06646052747964859, -0.019764726981520653, 0.006060655694454908, -0.023572884500026703, 0.005191036965698004, -0.03519450128078461, -0.033424921333789825, 0.015132242813706398, 0.02869192697107792, 0.025857960805296898, 0.050089407712221146, -0.034654878079891205, 0.008929547853767872, -0.04187403619289398, 0.004767501726746559, -0.026800695806741714, 0.04855586215853691, 0.004423184785991907, 0.053577084094285965, 0.024249346926808357, -0.023808177560567856, 0.0065701003186404705, 0.0012206541141495109, -0.05821390077471733, 0.0389094278216362, 0.00890440959483385, -0.02535419911146164, 0.019194459542632103, -0.03334566205739975, 0.02528718113899231, -0.021933984011411667, -0.041947998106479645, -0.024826517328619957, 0.026338497176766396, -0.057704634964466095, 0.005582811776548624, -0.05707262083888054, -0.017819829285144806, 0.001464033150114119, 0.00154218974057585, 0.0034328128676861525, -0.00519850617274642, 0.047342732548713684, 0.06034444645047188, -0.01227313932031393, -0.019793186336755753, -0.03283379226922989, 0.0293116457760334, -0.0011791452998295426, -0.01205342449247837, 0.06460501253604889, 0.047335945069789886, -0.027350857853889465, 0.029561573639512062, -0.0383237823843956, 0.01813446916639805, 0.03731641545891762, 0.005830645561218262, 0.005641401279717684, -0.03290129080414772, -0.019021043553948402, 0.0134548619389534, 0.018617922440171242, 0.028296243399381638, -0.008706626482307911, 0.025661449879407883, 0.0008143241866491735, -0.022880613803863525, 0.016938256099820137, 0.06798896938562393, 0.02173553593456745, 0.011539467610418797, -0.057827919721603394, -0.03941451013088226, -0.00505420146510005, -0.027067309245467186, 0.048866599798202515, 0.01892687939107418, 0.0034676729701459408, -0.007081424817442894, 0.04469311237335205, 0.006736265029758215, 0.006545220036059618, 0.0453680157661438, 0.022806018590927124, 0.067436583340168, -0.016476914286613464, -0.020256783813238144, 0.027946390211582184, 0.026902254670858383, 0.029625561088323593, 0.03250599652528763, -0.012303157709538937, -0.08811827003955841, -0.004530621226876974, 0.03655855730175972, 0.07165585458278656, -0.024561339989304543, 0.008338822051882744, -0.007456660270690918, 0.011215266771614552, 0.020639723166823387, -0.04040003567934036, 0.041003093123435974, -0.01405806839466095, 0.006501376163214445, -0.031160129234194756, -0.024580318480730057, -0.005768801551312208, 0.024026889353990555, -0.024923035874962807, 0.0255908090621233, -0.026525717228651047, -0.03602522984147072, -0.04163315147161484, 0.011612861417233944, 0.04382540285587311, 0.06497014313936234, -0.011464139446616173, 0.021786801517009735, -0.008321603760123253, 0.000111689034383744, -0.01601257175207138, -0.0944022685289383, 0.011898069642484188, -0.008412710390985012, 0.005968049634248018, 0.04054005816578865, -0.003909184131771326, -0.01256423257291317, 0.010682359337806702, 0.019202759489417076, -0.06234649196267128, -0.016312139108777046, -0.03831176087260246, -0.017830748111009598, 0.030541371554136276, 0.008533904328942299, 0.028546690940856934, 0.05819118395447731, 0.008490647189319134, 0.01689722202718258, -0.0015612347051501274, 0.029394512996077538, 0.004889010917395353, 0.015849491581320763, -0.03804837539792061, -0.022330842912197113, -0.029167069122195244, -0.015937181189656258, -0.031330663710832596, 0.04510582610964775, -0.024143196642398834, 0.0023944841232150793, -0.04938165470957756, 0.0071142567321658134, 0.002301859436556697, -0.019324051216244698, 0.010506139136850834, -0.00414843438193202, 0.0005518416874110699, -0.02144620567560196, 0.027625426650047302, -0.017832141369581223, 0.006038238760083914, -0.0027281318325549364, 0.01564124971628189, 0.05957699194550514, -0.043206386268138885, -0.002144305966794491, -0.020942142233252525, -0.045239128172397614, 0.0602007620036602, -0.002574390731751919, 0.03197934478521347, 0.07761795073747635, -0.04052026569843292, -0.023934317752718925, 0.01550711877644062, 0.023989729583263397, 0.012915384024381638, -0.05047968029975891, 0.040214791893959045, -0.004047051537781954, -0.05215923488140106, -0.027030911296606064, -0.013581219129264355, 0.03812342509627342, 0.01442616619169712, -0.04319259151816368, 0.010322477668523788, 0.0076856291852891445, 0.001549713546410203, 0.02983774058520794, -0.01146871130913496, 0.0024734120815992355, -0.0018636314198374748, -0.026782140135765076, 0.039215583354234695, -0.007099186070263386, 0.07127030938863754, 0.014805663377046585, -0.028063887730240822, -0.007547970861196518, 0.00040107377571985126, -0.009202826768159866, -0.016352836042642593, -0.002425203565508127, -0.025729874148964882, -0.0040733544155955315, -0.03149060532450676, 0.02290516346693039, 0.03795727342367172, -0.0006280574016273022, -0.0023385302629321814, -0.036709580570459366, 0.03772038593888283, 0.0482136607170105, -0.033582597970962524, 0.014762021601200104, 0.0017771701095625758, -0.004431980196386576, -0.022366009652614594, 0.027277212589979172, 0.0009574916330166161, -0.00717013468965888, -0.003227006644010544, 0.009004814550280571, -0.022540558129549026, 0.0019370444351807237, 0.07474324107170105, 0.0014270453248172998, -0.0329805389046669, -0.009783636778593063, -0.00890809390693903, 0.02647182159125805, 0.01637815684080124, -0.001327299396507442, -0.025064121931791306, 0.030034715309739113, -0.0304455254226923, -0.009512288495898247, -0.006601669825613499, -0.005226343870162964, 0.08667504787445068, -0.005638842936605215, 0.04189731180667877, 0.07101206481456757, 0.03431135043501854, 0.0005218416335992515, -0.03096909634768963, 0.010431613773107529, -0.03356591984629631, -0.020174048840999603, 0.03709528222680092, -0.017778649926185608, 0.045063361525535583, 0.04687062278389931, -0.0009662611992098391, 0.05275360494852066, 0.06005217880010605, 0.007228931877762079, 0.03740724176168442, 0.046688903123140335, -0.006801702082157135, -0.042874086648225784, 0.016718264669179916, -0.03980501368641853, 0.05592770129442215, -0.06150095537304878, -0.0138322152197361, 0.045821793377399445, 0.014558300375938416, -0.032897185534238815, -0.03143337368965149, -0.03764847293496132, -0.04273125156760216, 0.03019031509757042, -0.004913540557026863, -0.002079892670735717, 0.04314965754747391, 0.0367778055369854, 0.01345151662826538, -0.012900086119771004, 0.014340981841087341, -0.014043130911886692, -0.05836008861660957, -0.047131896018981934, -0.04763360321521759, -0.061728205531835556, 0.014222047291696072, 0.015049614943563938, -0.03941221162676811, 0.04225468263030052, -0.0055924952030181885, 0.0006177598261274397, -0.0053545585833489895, 0.014151680283248425, -0.027851391583681107, 0.07751066237688065, 0.012405398301780224, -0.004945371765643358, 0.021158991381525993, -0.0342724546790123, 0.1223422959446907, 0.051621582359075546, 0.017903611063957214, -0.07457014173269272, 0.00289265438914299, 0.031061429530382156, 0.012539819814264774, -0.05253301560878754, 0.012841930612921715, -0.02756698988378048, -0.00976399052888155, 0.05200541019439697, 0.05806467682123184, -0.010061990469694138, -0.02867261879146099, 0.0349908210337162, -0.005103135481476784, 0.0020302857737988234, 0.0094895726069808, 0.04294169694185257, 0.021943483501672745, -0.004543228540569544, -0.03344694897532463, 0.01642158441245556, -0.005479887593537569, -0.008181104436516762, 0.0018357207300141454, -0.05048045516014099, 0.020567450672388077, 0.03481314331293106, -0.021885782480239868, 0.023743383586406708, 0.04875294491648674, 0.005891688168048859, -0.031613804399967194, -0.017633194103837013, 0.04277033731341362, -0.043279848992824554, -0.011412154883146286, 0.00584420096129179, 0.03419916704297066, -0.04092903807759285, 0.010869387537240982, 0.005540157202631235, -0.08017142862081528, -0.03801269456744194, -0.049423303455114365, 0.0031070357654243708, -0.026458794251084328, -0.022847017273306847, -0.04006287455558777, -0.04578813537955284, -0.004658335819840431, -0.018118081614375114, -0.0395331010222435, 0.025960231199860573, 0.036477938294410706, -0.041905470192432404, -0.03551321476697922, -0.0404006652534008, -0.016256891191005707, -0.0005808950518257916, 0.039085082709789276, 0.009645462967455387, -0.0008233121479861438, -0.04775049537420273, -0.04250563681125641, 0.01655585691332817, 0.0038100036326795816, -0.04520450159907341, -0.022060252726078033, -0.014920243993401527, -0.017565470188856125, -0.015281464904546738, 0.00018703052774071693, 0.010289020836353302, -0.00242698285728693, 0.010601473972201347, -0.011258896440267563, 0.024693384766578674, -0.03196559101343155, 0.0017201225273311138, -0.04747069254517555, -0.01592453010380268, -0.024411940947175026, 0.02201324887573719, 0.044563449919223785, 0.04442857950925827, 0.0006145524093881249, 0.00980687141418457, -0.028524572029709816, 0.05107169970870018, 0.04226807504892349, -0.03580019995570183, -0.02786506712436676, -0.011474588885903358, -0.03542892634868622, -0.02317751944065094, -0.018874933943152428, 0.04640958830714226, 0.017685072496533394, -0.007357371039688587, 0.011123890057206154, -0.029286202043294907, 0.000510320533066988, 0.04113727807998657, -0.0030437849927693605, -0.074579156935215, 0.006188387982547283, -0.0029616248793900013, 0.010958041995763779, -0.010930241085588932, -0.04906647279858589, -0.017197659239172935, -0.0005450107273645699, 0.0032757993321865797, 0.0006861920701339841, -0.05733148753643036, 0.026590567082166672, -0.01833038590848446, -0.00925255473703146, -0.01978946477174759, 0.013978556729853153, -0.04536542296409607, -0.025536632165312767, -0.020785091444849968, 0.02768447808921337, 0.012405812740325928, 0.04365041106939316, -0.0005432529142126441, -0.025862235575914383, 0.05791579559445381, 0.05417894944548607, -0.022931702435016632, -0.02846399135887623, 0.031651820987463, -0.013747717253863811, 0.034981850534677505, -0.042332928627729416, -0.017060648649930954, 0.04110398516058922, -0.03672097623348236, 0.01692315563559532, -0.004179670475423336, -0.0037801580037921667, 0.046652600169181824, -0.005927400663495064, -0.018712874501943588, -0.0014339920599013567, 0.022569753229618073, -0.011610081419348717, -0.007322752382606268, 0.024691857397556305, -0.015554729849100113, 0.025894688442349434, 0.016740694642066956, -0.003188004484400153, 0.031403928995132446, -0.01773560233414173, 0.00958943646401167, 0.015877507627010345, 0.021711470559239388, -0.006929691415280104, 0.005398767534643412, 0.00953922513872385, -0.016510063782334328, -0.009217580780386925, -0.05830185487866402, 0.07842643558979034, 0.04741101711988449, -0.013708347454667091, 0.04170451685786247, -0.016778886318206787, 0.007762040477246046, -0.06853818148374557, -0.01823323406279087, 0.021694781258702278, 0.00663372315466404, 0.03150498867034912, -0.07206369936466217, 0.03443780913949013, 0.019901053979992867, -0.027844127267599106, 0.06230157986283302, 0.029802624136209488, -0.004749645479023457, -0.030283749103546143, -0.0040968735702335835, 0.000426834070822224, 0.012643570080399513, 0.044549886137247086, 0.04015376791357994, 0.021241800859570503, 0.02030804567039013, 0.03147362545132637, 0.0023982725106179714, -0.04026734456419945, 0.005798992235213518, -0.019345412030816078, -0.04823312908411026, 0.017703820019960403, -0.049830399453639984, -0.03688656538724899, 0.026136262342333794, -0.018704842776060104, 0.045205581933259964, 0.011882313527166843, 0.01708366349339485, -0.02174500748515129, 0.004559535067528486, 0.03239746391773224, 0.010151025839149952, 0.03026455268263817, -0.0019622058607637882, 0.0068566338159143925, 0.020137891173362732, -0.008742207661271095, 0.02784997969865799, 0.01658722385764122, -0.03935473412275314, -0.052019666880369186, 0.02159942500293255, -0.004298259504139423, 0.0010893333237618208, 0.035787444561719894, 0.007207498420029879, 0.038095735013484955, -0.008196000009775162, 0.00010301454312866554, -0.020306909456849098, 0.0048601385205984116, 0.035828832536935806, -0.008237619884312153, 0.02643812634050846, 0.003016449511051178, -0.009031059220433235, -0.06682410091161728, -0.001780037535354495, -0.0025807383935898542, -0.006339091807603836, -0.07092130184173584, 0.012037716805934906, 0.005487616173923016, -0.006382429972290993, -0.026852743700146675, -0.04067779332399368, -0.019030820578336716, 0.01477824430912733, 0.01592280901968479, 0.013983420096337795, 0.04374457523226738, 0.019284605979919434, 0.015711218118667603, -0.11882580071687698, 0.030864093452692032, 0.009367735125124454, -0.02499464526772499, -0.04140021651983261, 0.0017023864202201366, -0.022638434544205666, -0.048164501786231995, 0.02148543670773506, -0.04103071987628937, 0.015110132284462452, -0.017401687800884247, -0.0016824504127725959, 0.006067605689167976, -0.023658042773604393, 0.028191184625029564, -0.029616719111800194, -0.02160879224538803, 0.02461179532110691, -0.005541708320379257, 0.01987370103597641, -0.0033628421369940042, 0.0107225077226758, -0.04885884001851082, 0.00014163617743179202, 0.0019498653709888458, -0.03943091630935669, 0.011118114925920963, 0.003557560034096241, 0.01639528013765812, 0.035499460995197296, -0.007420462556183338, 0.008624897338449955, 0.027894163504242897, 0.003974744584411383, -0.05580407381057739, 0.07376686483621597, -0.04438517615199089, -0.006346131209284067, -0.014886314980685711, -0.029780803248286247, -0.038403816521167755, -0.060319866985082626, -0.01335084903985262, 0.032807640731334686, 0.02593066357076168, 0.02146979421377182, 0.02018412947654724, 0.0019079250050708652, 0.004448907449841499, -0.004081634804606438, 0.0449032187461853, -0.0007931538857519627, -0.04751692712306976, -0.02753324992954731, 0.007209151517599821, 0.05988141521811485, -0.01124707330018282, 0.030425315722823143, 0.06375596672296524, 0.04123051464557648, 0.002112859860062599, -0.009077150374650955, 0.07231827080249786, -0.011700187809765339, -0.00224842200987041, -0.013007648289203644, -0.007891925051808357, -0.0017693997360765934, 0.012090285308659077, -0.00536744948476553, 0.014725234359502792, -0.052877169102430344, 0.0077323163859546185, -0.028887759894132614, -0.036451950669288635, -0.029617872089147568, 0.0012569401878863573, 0.008535714820027351, 0.0014418457867577672, -0.02737855724990368, -0.014499833807349205, 0.022855324670672417, 0.027963243424892426, 0.03246646001935005, 0.009057425893843174, 0.04214917868375778, -0.03085399977862835, -0.019934916868805885, -0.026865379884839058, -0.02326764166355133, 0.010641447268426418, -0.022394541651010513, 0.02305024303495884, 0.05653371661901474, 0.01584337279200554, -0.03527446463704109, -0.019413301721215248, -0.02134653739631176, 0.04692220687866211, -0.0740361362695694, -0.012730670161545277, -0.08178788423538208, 0.015590953640639782, -0.0022213722113519907, -0.023253927007317543 ]
<p>Does anyone know of recommendations/references for plotting <em>binary</em> time series data? Or categorical time series data? I'm looking at win/loss records, and it seems like there should be plots that exploit the binary nature beyond just a simple line plot.</p> <p>Late edit: I'm familiar with Tufte's suggestions, especially those given in the sparklines chapter of <em>Beautiful Evidence</em> (<a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/31926/7591">see whuber's answer below</a>). I'm interested in other references, particularly those that provide justification for their recommendations.</p> <p>Second edit: To clarify some of the questions in the comment... the key issue for me is the binary nature of the series. I'd be interested in references to anything that discusses special issues that come up when plotting binary (or categorical or ordinal variables in general) time series instead of interval/quantitative variables. Highly technical papers are fine, as are nontechnical books aimed at a popular audience. It's really the binary vs. general distinction that I'm interested in, and I don't know of any references beyond those listed in the answers below. </p>
74,432
[ -0.028626322746276855, -0.038946352899074554, -0.03215702250599861, 0.01839209347963333, 0.029092809185385704, 0.03044499270617962, 0.02001197822391987, 0.006428953725844622, 0.0174185149371624, -0.004615412093698978, 0.0532076321542263, 0.05840403586626053, 0.04155494645237923, 0.039560019969940186, 0.008318949490785599, -0.018673764541745186, -0.03668671101331711, -0.012139123864471912, -0.031945887953042984, 0.0031503099016845226, 0.004008017014712095, -0.013198798522353172, 0.05725237354636192, 0.011292237788438797, -0.006463012658059597, 0.05811576545238495, 0.019861988723278046, 0.0007563453400507569, 0.012144848704338074, 0.04479615390300751, -0.03477725014090538, -0.03617289662361145, -0.021170515567064285, 0.015272107906639576, 0.014568138867616653, 0.013825667090713978, -0.01385855209082365, -0.043044351041316986, 0.007754871156066656, 0.0011853548930957913, -0.06673617660999298, -0.021641802042722702, 0.0038171776104718447, 0.014781671576201916, -0.02942184917628765, -0.006510966923087835, 0.008639506064355373, -0.0035540498793125153, 0.019326413050293922, -0.04955412819981575, 0.04380056634545326, -0.01961263082921505, 0.03993196785449982, 0.02150576189160347, -0.01449932623654604, 0.011704295873641968, 0.03206843510270119, 0.026274267584085464, 0.02140391804277897, -0.06298629194498062, 0.013922687619924545, -0.016460435464978218, -0.01543473731726408, -0.015726502984762192, -0.024172114208340645, 0.060378413647413254, 0.003125349059700966, -0.033171772956848145, 0.03011949360370636, -0.03462708368897438, 0.0012010978534817696, 0.03065202571451664, 0.03956669196486473, -0.003536044619977474, -0.01051570475101471, -0.01775963604450226, 0.036958709359169006, 0.0012077651917934418, 0.08684579282999039, 0.05112375319004059, -0.020316777750849724, 0.03342140465974808, 0.017529385164380074, 0.05077182501554489, 0.00650103110820055, 0.006641410291194916, 0.07389482855796814, -0.04135769605636597, 0.011974425055086613, 0.022473691031336784, -0.00903028529137373, 0.008378904312849045, 0.018794799223542213, 0.028605975210666656, -0.06273205578327179, 0.028414972126483917, -0.0033911175560206175, 0.0369909293949604, 0.012120655737817287, -0.024236483499407768, -0.022568153217434883, -0.026193443685770035, 0.029104197397828102, 0.07230392843484879, -0.013818048872053623, -0.01292711216956377, -0.016647756099700928, 0.01664157770574093, -0.0013605221174657345, -0.0298585444688797, -0.001981293084099889, -0.004241054877638817, 0.04218386858701706, 0.013857864774763584, -0.02632199041545391, -0.01975378952920437, 0.02213205397129059, 0.010253042913973331, 0.05568564683198929, 0.09116259217262268, 0.037564728409051895, -0.03275950625538826, 0.060137975960969925, -0.036844901740550995, -0.04920579865574837, 0.004141698125749826, 0.02065652422606945, -0.01677246205508709, -0.03747522458434105, 0.04908880963921547, -0.026539534330368042, -0.028127174824476242, 0.04894527792930603, -0.0448671393096447, 0.04710319638252258, 0.012979520484805107, -0.05849950760602951, -0.048181984573602676, 0.012638600543141365, -0.002630239352583885, -0.013467853888869286, -0.047717489302158356, 0.008231195621192455, 0.014339999295771122, 0.03204731643199921, -0.004601681604981422, 0.011217799037694931, -0.0006863964954391122, 0.05189936235547066, 0.039241332560777664, -0.026148924604058266, -0.00105412642005831, 0.0006688174325972795, -0.02778795175254345, 0.006480618380010128, -0.060304246842861176, 0.04087725654244423, 0.011763849295675755, 0.0012597754830494523, -0.03673619404435158, 0.07299665361642838, 0.04454239457845688, -0.005167899187654257, -0.01580043137073517, -0.019119620323181152, -0.009708322584629059, 0.07866108417510986, -0.02327335998415947, 0.02744748629629612, -0.004518275149166584, 0.007135148160159588, 0.03358669579029083, 0.06945913285017014, 0.038647376000881195, 0.03687590733170509, -0.02812068909406662, 0.0005245191277936101, 0.006099145393818617, -0.005261859390884638, 0.012088572606444359, -0.03233412653207779, -0.03324196860194206, -0.038321539759635925, -0.0390537865459919, 0.013633017428219318, 0.03753577917814255, -0.0034091267734766006, -0.03382779657840729, 0.06906758248806, -0.06656205654144287, -0.03156471252441406, -0.05131683871150017, -0.000612738193012774, -0.01908811368048191, -0.009242855943739414, 0.049441441893577576, -0.014271434396505356, 0.04409302771091461, -0.05983957648277283, -0.05838959664106369, 0.011901921592652798, 0.00200661551207304, 0.04338391497731209, -0.07766556739807129, 0.014111869037151337, 0.013297008350491524, 0.0030292163137346506, -0.006619201507419348, 0.007930570282042027, -0.05204186215996742, -0.04801036790013313, -0.0027317337226122618, -0.037803564220666885, 0.04020531475543976, 0.0003088408266194165, 0.0026703975163400173, 0.024743905290961266, 0.005566302686929703, 0.004347516689449549, 0.018101047724485397, -0.051366742700338364, 0.05628977715969086, 0.06093664467334747, 0.021549997851252556, -0.006032060831785202, 0.02157190628349781, 0.04785193130373955, -0.01995326578617096, 0.008955558761954308, 0.010084599256515503, -0.028074443340301514, 0.050077278167009354, 0.03637867420911789, 0.004526184871792793, -0.024073300883173943, 0.04242916777729988, 0.02186577208340168, 0.034937936812639236, -0.02633935585618019, 0.03752238675951958, -0.01312450971454382, -0.025575725361704826, -0.005297753028571606, 0.007170227821916342, 0.004405638203024864, -0.017038388177752495, 0.04755425825715065, -0.016488511115312576, 0.0068937139585614204, -0.00032995344372466207, -0.03454019874334335, 0.0132213793694973, -0.011608285829424858, 0.014576663263142109, 0.0006806509336456656, -0.05535421520471573, 0.07268419861793518, -0.05846724659204483, -0.02113668993115425, 0.015436246059834957, 0.004054171498864889, 0.014788388274610043, 0.032996855676174164, -0.004361255094408989, -0.020094720646739006, 0.027602773159742355, -0.030913667753338814, 0.022451041266322136, 0.018128415569663048, -0.02077522687613964, 0.02832002192735672, -0.01795058883726597, -0.030022911727428436, -0.06325718015432358, -0.041203614324331284, 0.02253122068941593, -0.007126003038138151, 0.016236253082752228, -0.002073503565043211, -0.055253949016332626, 0.017107097432017326, 0.01434269081801176, 0.03506480157375336, 0.01415141113102436, -0.045878320932388306, 0.0071526989340782166, -0.03154939413070679, -0.003638927126303315, 0.026007307693362236, -0.012561910785734653, -0.018549157306551933, 0.015103033743798733, 0.00789082795381546, -0.025112295523285866, -0.05263303592801094, -0.0004891438875347376, -0.022682499140501022, -0.014800992794334888, 0.004371574614197016, 0.07323580235242844, -0.005745246075093746, -0.02852892130613327, -0.002953958697617054, -0.039451371878385544, -0.0073206666857004166, -0.049099065363407135, 0.02321498654782772, 0.010102258995175362, -0.00008872016769601032, -0.0018781401449814439, 0.014502350240945816, -0.06030969321727753, -0.02573632076382637, -0.060364801436662674, -0.0751839131116867, -0.008999801240861416, 0.004954250063747168, 0.04042011499404907, 0.01770988292992115, -0.019880477339029312, 0.036991219967603683, 0.027854103595018387, 0.031408701092004776, -0.07710372656583786, -0.023110272362828255, -0.0357435941696167, -0.004815031308680773, 0.017667338252067566, 0.023921947926282883, 0.023220406845211983, 0.003337420290336013, -0.006709755398333073, 0.03890934959053993, 0.03480037674307823, 0.03834901005029678, -0.004910232499241829, 0.045643050223588943, -0.026896946132183075, -0.02621212974190712, 0.005059825722128153, 0.02750214748084545, -0.06211024895310402, 0.022654352709650993, 0.012490385212004185, 0.01936197094619274, 0.011797008104622364, -0.03690566495060921, 0.0013720542192459106, -0.01119595393538475, -0.0044078463688492775, -0.018272439017891884, 0.04642302170395851, -0.011126890778541565, -0.0024408434983342886, -0.00843190960586071, 0.03635764867067337, -0.0026361909694969654, -0.027054838836193085, 0.019930509850382805, 0.055526845157146454, 0.03275427222251892, -0.053702518343925476, -0.002086810301989317, 0.007863635197281837, -0.005121295340359211, 0.04380493238568306, -0.06797356903553009, 0.029858136549592018, 0.03897649794816971, 0.0025681518018245697, 0.02976391091942787, -0.015474449843168259, -0.05172310397028923, -0.0006007498595863581, -0.06305845081806183, -0.016080934554338455, -0.05961617827415466, 0.03738493472337723, 0.0017577263060957193, 0.0499112531542778, 0.005772746168076992, 0.00699214031919837, 0.010699461214244366, -0.017762428149580956, -0.043635882437229156, 0.020332928746938705, -0.018722090870141983, -0.024027498438954353, 0.024008210748434067, 0.0251744594424963, 0.02361917681992054, -0.012900401838123798, -0.011336168274283409, -0.009963315911591053, 0.022485386580228806, -0.032753970474004745, -0.024157218635082245, -0.048251643776893616, -0.06695631146430969, -0.0015935825649648905, -0.008412305265665054, 0.017552930861711502, -0.033692628145217896, 0.051083534955978394, 0.023920003324747086, 0.002297150669619441, -0.0423726961016655, -0.002087503904476762, -0.000896299839951098, -0.0008197228307835758, 0.0037996626924723387, 0.01005658507347107, 0.004830735735595226, -0.03186750411987305, 0.055334173142910004, -0.0030727277044206858, 0.06474879384040833, 0.02303020842373371, -0.04051431640982628, -0.011071483604609966, -0.017782576382160187, -0.005973720923066139, 0.004713146947324276, 0.017872000113129616, 0.051475346088409424, -0.01309968437999487, 0.06646641343832016, 0.033208832144737244, -0.048138029873371124, 0.018606022000312805, 0.02926117740571499, -0.00896831601858139, 0.021843651309609413, -0.013982420787215233, -0.01725851744413376, -0.011981439776718616, -0.0014893432380631566, 0.029858006164431572, 0.017291758209466934, 0.020187433809041977, 0.007639691233634949, 0.038670167326927185, -0.005045697558671236, -0.015938129276037216, -0.017648588865995407, 0.025423701852560043, 0.03372512012720108, -0.0068021803162992, -0.04962535202503204, 0.039113838225603104, 0.028823649510741234, 0.05238423869013786, 0.04916657879948616, 0.000019290171621832997, -0.09785094112157822, 0.03663700446486473, 0.06288839876651764, 0.02974015846848488, -0.0009151229751296341, -0.025409650057554245, -0.05517708882689476, 0.01556281466037035, 0.030389701947569847, -0.015809789299964905, 0.05331868678331375, -0.01842857152223587, 0.022528065368533134, -0.03879638388752937, -0.010634534060955048, -0.00628557987511158, 0.01911725103855133, -0.005330033600330353, 0.03528429567813873, 0.013129033148288727, -0.006372236646711826, -0.02974127233028412, 0.038482122123241425, 0.027056671679019928, 0.05661144480109215, -0.010084428824484348, -0.045483410358428955, 0.01726321317255497, -0.009964280761778355, -0.035944871604442596, -0.07092228531837463, -0.014861419796943665, -0.008306605741381645, 0.02332952432334423, 0.03288555145263672, 0.005214208737015724, -0.03740675747394562, -0.005644019693136215, 0.0032709171064198017, -0.031346630305051804, 0.03688698634505272, -0.02206871286034584, 0.014296908862888813, 0.007025979459285736, 0.023164549842476845, 0.04509691894054413, 0.06824781745672226, 0.015876391902565956, 0.006958719342947006, -0.0114067904651165, 0.03808599337935448, -0.0060835788026452065, -0.009150257334113121, -0.027837276458740234, -0.00883569661527872, -0.03985094279050827, 0.017105747014284134, 0.003428691066801548, -0.0005546676111407578, -0.026515480130910873, -0.02518215961754322, -0.029493195936083794, 0.020087113603949547, 0.0050443788059055805, -0.033258747309446335, 0.02003665827214718, 0.022409891709685326, -0.003398236818611622, 0.0017988000763580203, 0.03476262092590332, -0.018695948645472527, -0.008766168728470802, 0.023488759994506836, -0.02407328225672245, 0.03956298157572746, -0.04744213819503784, -0.010300256311893463, 0.010432233102619648, -0.009713200852274895, 0.04126710072159767, 0.0010031762067228556, 0.011386996135115623, -0.0113860834389925, -0.0363164097070694, -0.021826179698109627, 0.004194196313619614, 0.006705207284539938, 0.0214886162430048, -0.06342660635709763, 0.025759806856513023, -0.03086773119866848, -0.00504100788384676, -0.07067812979221344, -0.062136806547641754, 0.019071273505687714, -0.023008102551102638, -0.04438348487019539, -0.01884918473660946, 0.04596690088510513, -0.001242993283085525, -0.0046925307251513, 0.021808814257383347, 0.05492037534713745, -0.023885661736130714, -0.01037216279655695, -0.014522833749651909, 0.009232824668288231, 0.08466572314500809, 0.058294449001550674, -0.032053057104349136, 0.011297249235212803, -0.01433628797531128, 0.011990119703114033, 0.00459522008895874, 0.012866884469985962, -0.023767778649926186, 0.016157999634742737, -0.008851953782141209, 0.01954626850783825, 0.02608363702893257, -0.033971067517995834, 0.0018494045361876488, 0.05966869369149208, -0.00011901214020326734, 0.0129308570176363, -0.04879917576909065, 0.01835223287343979, -0.05424167588353157, 0.010525628924369812, -0.03584248200058937, -0.031093236058950424, 0.011047130450606346, -0.020787902176380157, -0.003796215867623687, 0.02638489194214344, -0.06948582082986832, 0.016060667112469673, 0.034900229424238205, 0.029516849666833878, -0.01684754341840744, 0.025704819709062576, -0.013756891712546349, 0.0372287817299366, 0.0035580405965447426, -0.0262686125934124, 0.020161040127277374, 0.03486056625843048, -0.0195479579269886, -0.0200212299823761, -0.024988370016217232, 0.005378796719014645, 0.02887696959078312, 0.013885417953133583, 0.04181184247136116, 0.05013447254896164, -0.0003649320569820702, 0.008814550004899502, -0.05317554622888565, 0.0015774340135976672, -0.008572294376790524, -0.004685402847826481, 0.018169982358813286, -0.0052159372717142105, 0.02209702879190445, 0.02943105436861515, -0.008268698118627071, 0.010286889970302582, 0.038449954241514206, 0.03397142142057419, -0.011282621882855892, 0.07804210484027863, -0.028848929330706596, -0.03129979968070984, 0.024404393509030342, -0.03885626792907715, 0.011450828053057194, -0.017407704144716263, -0.03274444118142128, 0.050160326063632965, 0.02356652356684208, -0.02113913744688034, -0.04591014236211777, -0.019206572324037552, -0.059393949806690216, 0.003295083064585924, 0.00805545412003994, -0.023205215111374855, 0.05718013271689415, 0.013206771574914455, 0.03872482478618622, -0.019320830702781677, -0.0026617920957505703, 0.005319615826010704, -0.017954405397176743, -0.042354267090559006, -0.013544057495892048, -0.05221853032708168, 0.038773369044065475, -0.01794315315783024, -0.025900118052959442, 0.0019087244290858507, -0.040375977754592896, -0.005310683976858854, -0.016462910920381546, 0.018475133925676346, 0.009479767642915249, 0.05568304657936096, -0.01162097230553627, -0.024539439007639885, -0.000602506275754422, -0.035932980477809906, 0.11778921633958817, 0.07028879225254059, 0.07163573056459427, -0.050205960869789124, 0.05067666992545128, 0.02335582673549652, 0.03042302280664444, -0.025312159210443497, 0.018302585929632187, -0.0023975251242518425, 0.010653368197381496, 0.058936767280101776, 0.04016178846359253, 0.006846221163868904, -0.007312209811061621, 0.06645340472459793, -0.024150017648935318, 0.028347862884402275, -0.0034580547362565994, 0.010816137306392193, -0.011610038578510284, 0.002294013276696205, -0.05321332439780235, -0.010540113784372807, 0.007399693597108126, -0.0376603938639164, 0.0036272553261369467, -0.043416645377874374, 0.0244497898966074, 0.026348328217864037, -0.02888813614845276, -0.03161131963133812, 0.05502218380570412, 0.03566062077879906, 0.002014482393860817, -0.04616866260766983, 0.012106094509363174, -0.03181217238306999, 0.027325959876179695, 0.030292155221104622, 0.007840180769562721, -0.025046134367585182, -0.008445878513157368, 0.011934183537960052, -0.049942199140787125, -0.025344286113977432, -0.06214674934744835, 0.02561936154961586, -0.013775976374745369, 0.019607478752732277, -0.01552236545830965, 0.011271339841187, 0.027433855459094048, -0.020582465454936028, -0.021602051332592964, 0.004203913267701864, 0.049399327486753464, -0.02757028304040432, -0.020251480862498283, -0.01427017617970705, -0.0036055375821888447, -0.006221366580575705, 0.030927186831831932, 0.03836912661790848, -0.04760853573679924, -0.009496933780610561, -0.006533272564411163, 0.011792377568781376, 0.0031522372737526894, -0.00620367331430316, 0.04235104098916054, -0.010513102635741234, -0.03956752270460129, -0.021723279729485512, 0.01867959089577198, 0.011895619332790375, -0.019032461568713188, 0.013331934809684753, -0.02956855297088623, 0.035583388060331345, -0.02328421361744404, 0.01051877997815609, -0.004816590342670679, -0.02875610813498497, -0.005624647252261639, 0.013519040308892727, 0.052793629467487335, -0.014742757193744183, 0.013266230002045631, 0.005129504948854446, -0.02319413796067238, 0.05794917792081833, 0.04168405011296272, -0.04348113387823105, 0.013376493938267231, -0.015381189063191414, -0.005872111767530441, -0.019040394574403763, -0.03368760645389557, 0.05368611216545105, 0.024374183267354965, 0.005010657012462616, 0.028311798349022865, -0.004798541311174631, 0.03470870479941368, 0.010833930224180222, 0.008170663379132748, -0.09152542799711227, -0.008180034346878529, -0.009905632585287094, -0.0014323591021820903, -0.008275200612843037, -0.06494562327861786, -0.06557628512382507, 0.017597002908587456, -0.03897587209939957, -0.02972884103655815, -0.06130129471421242, 0.013254525139927864, -0.00822009239345789, -0.006097796838730574, -0.03368121758103371, -0.013614865951240063, -0.04925091564655304, -0.049101777374744415, -0.03360871970653534, -0.00266493228264153, 0.022654680535197258, 0.02980365976691246, -0.0018721759552136064, 0.01001826487481594, 0.0278765968978405, 0.0039005165454000235, 0.00824340432882309, 0.011743861250579357, 0.03186042979359627, -0.011110314168035984, 0.018746303394436836, -0.025222739204764366, -0.015237964689731598, 0.02862771600484848, -0.022544769570231438, -0.006654003635048866, 0.03380179405212402, -0.010004209354519844, -0.001819511060602963, -0.021823124960064888, 0.00894068367779255, -0.008794521912932396, 0.03955385833978653, -0.0018212200375273824, 0.00020759549806825817, -0.002544454298913479, 0.010266340337693691, 0.016018537804484367, 0.02065216191112995, -0.005475771613419056, -0.006931317038834095, -0.003918934613466263, 0.00534603139385581, 0.03645608201622963, 0.024468911811709404, -0.018043799325823784, -0.01157259289175272, 0.011611070483922958, 0.03392814099788666, 0.009430613368749619, -0.04089269042015076, 0.06779282540082932, 0.04526730254292488, -0.027675440534949303, 0.02891661785542965, -0.01774422824382782, 0.000978735857643187, -0.09993351250886917, -0.009558305144309998, 0.0028572729788720608, 0.027487264946103096, 0.02458707056939602, -0.06611941009759903, -0.006243727635592222, -0.02074742130935192, -0.04530489817261696, 0.02750149555504322, 0.01004262175410986, -0.005962887313216925, -0.023243628442287445, -0.03413432464003563, -0.007499058265239, 0.028069552034139633, 0.03274005651473999, 0.013301226310431957, 0.03731408715248108, 0.007029522210359573, -0.009933875873684883, 0.00007842975901439786, -0.00012253604654688388, 0.03266599774360657, 0.015411986969411373, -0.07392007857561111, 0.016072822734713554, -0.046555936336517334, -0.0277359988540411, 0.01361681055277586, 0.03286752849817276, 0.035868898034095764, 0.010391260497272015, 0.009395638480782509, -0.020902831107378006, 0.027123643085360527, 0.03191675245761871, -0.03898278623819351, -0.008200946263968945, 0.0020656778942793608, -0.00453117024153471, 0.028393544256687164, -0.022473303601145744, 0.02890111692249775, 0.02466028742492199, -0.034970756620168686, -0.045976705849170685, -0.020752187818288803, -0.007975739426910877, -0.006928734015673399, 0.006201027426868677, -0.012217236682772636, 0.02286992035806179, 0.01240895502269268, 0.06354643404483795, -0.053410667926073074, -0.010174257680773735, 0.01612507365643978, -0.008863184601068497, 0.037924546748399734, 0.027895566076040268, -0.011546175926923752, -0.04555544629693031, -0.008012323640286922, -0.0042300354689359665, 0.025234157219529152, -0.026744361966848373, 0.0030835007783025503, -0.001123580033890903, 0.02915375307202339, -0.059362489730119705, 0.00009415295062353835, -0.018435733392834663, 0.03566223382949829, -0.019880220293998718, 0.008639490231871605, 0.031966451555490494, -0.017793990671634674, 0.023379521444439888, -0.0684739500284195, 0.057048995047807693, 0.024378396570682526, -0.009513025172054768, -0.023414304479956627, -0.027717236429452896, -0.028801871463656425, 0.0011790114222094417, 0.04493463411927223, -0.01518750935792923, -0.012128310278058052, -0.015268227085471153, 0.028639111667871475, 0.001992555567994714, -0.02892502211034298, 0.018529051914811134, -0.03658352047204971, -0.05918048322200775, 0.002165348269045353, -0.004726750776171684, -0.01286840345710516, -0.018537089228630066, 0.01117262989282608, 0.004474676679819822, -0.020186061039566994, 0.0009430396021343768, -0.020379984751343727, 0.051374901086091995, 0.012102202512323856, -0.04222993180155754, 0.039071936160326004, 0.01713627018034458, 0.008948993869125843, -0.0017891557654365897, -0.030442193150520325, -0.058011725544929504, 0.07543989270925522, -0.03476179763674736, -0.030078807845711708, -0.025307470932602882, 0.0048165288753807545, -0.010243700817227364, -0.07888519763946533, 0.04177984222769737, 0.003183858934789896, -0.01373504288494587, 0.03726845234632492, 0.04250376671552658, 0.0033079751301556826, 0.05046696215867996, -0.00398335000500083, 0.01455982681363821, -0.006660034414380789, -0.011936575174331665, 0.007185639347881079, -0.02367507480084896, 0.04859448969364166, 0.027418730780482292, -0.012639380060136318, 0.017425164580345154, -0.0316619873046875, 0.04173726215958595, -0.008969627320766449, 0.03360626474022865, 0.0008173624519258738, 0.02477431297302246, 0.04130875691771507, 0.01176078524440527, -0.0030270437709987164, 0.0435500405728817, -0.024709835648536682, 0.059468500316143036, -0.010014787316322327, 0.03794412314891815, -0.043929874897003174, -0.015897301957011223, -0.041967231780290604, -0.014154466800391674, 0.005083064083009958, 0.028808051720261574, 0.004484958481043577, 0.04667450487613678, -0.0005783861852250993, -0.011789956130087376, 0.024359269067645073, -0.007288306951522827, 0.004392242059111595, -0.01635965146124363, -0.017461497336626053, -0.018945926800370216, -0.025067778304219246, -0.02438128925859928, -0.04550395533442497, 0.018034357577562332, 0.00232956581749022, 0.0025451278779655695, -0.023905379697680473, -0.01558556780219078, -0.014899121597409248, 0.02935759909451008, -0.06541739404201508, -0.027430055662989616, -0.07254679501056671, 0.05360101908445358, 0.03217785060405731, -0.014439789578318596 ]
<p>I have a function of a dozen discrete variables, $$y = f(x_1, ..., x_n)$$ and $k$ samples of $y$ (a lot), $y$ being continuous.</p> <p>I can use Matlab to analyse the data, with the statistics toolbox. The goal is to analyse the relationship between $y$ and my variables. For example, which variables $x_m$ explain best variations of $y$? (I was thinking of using an Principal Components Analysis, but I can't think of a way to adapt the method to it) To what extent do they have an influence on $y$? Can I find clusters?</p> <p>My question is: do you have methods I should look into and hints about how to adapt them to my analysis?</p> <p>Thank you</p>
37,301
[ -0.026275228708982468, 0.02520514652132988, 0.01479403767734766, -0.0035408169496804476, 0.04433359205722809, 0.016977457329630852, 0.021848849952220917, -0.03469505533576012, 0.022003047168254852, -0.06107640266418457, 0.0255033690482378, 0.0497441291809082, 0.05390685796737671, 0.017243511974811554, 0.0270699355751276, -0.008912821300327778, -0.01827750913798809, -0.03500468283891678, 0.002935925032943487, 0.017728693783283234, -0.006886390037834644, 0.04256121814250946, 0.017098164185881615, -0.00612422451376915, -0.039229121059179306, 0.04521617293357849, 0.0021230638958513737, -0.016823695972561836, 0.053024228662252426, 0.0308066513389349, -0.023510584607720375, -0.033996399492025375, -0.025205770507454872, 0.04406873881816864, -0.01862994208931923, 0.023940546438097954, -0.02595304697751999, -0.007986399345099926, 0.008088842034339905, 0.031016608700156212, -0.0716734528541565, -0.017470581457018852, 0.002551698824390769, 0.022163843736052513, 0.005922058597207069, 0.005833487957715988, 0.008946716785430908, -0.0327892079949379, 0.04093044251203537, -0.04352322593331337, 0.12766726315021515, 0.008662697859108448, 0.011548605747520924, 0.04826606437563896, -0.009294289164245129, 0.003688914468511939, 0.054575107991695404, 0.04784063249826431, -0.016803070902824402, -0.04790695756673813, 0.000057173532695742324, -0.03078029491007328, 0.004345383960753679, -0.027375655248761177, -0.04157663509249687, 0.03805246204137802, -0.01575096882879734, -0.005522134713828564, 0.01637451723217964, -0.03627273067831993, 0.003754700068384409, 0.01837317831814289, 0.05193742364645004, 0.0043015810661017895, -0.011148958466947079, -0.02362365834414959, 0.022656606510281563, 0.023582616820931435, 0.03229213133454323, 0.033474311232566833, -0.0009422424482181668, 0.021101076155900955, -0.02402484603226185, 0.016219522804021835, -0.0068496474996209145, -0.008923923596739769, 0.058482296764850616, -0.014336883090436459, 0.04100992530584335, 0.00876966305077076, -0.016512537375092506, -0.013610237278044224, 0.05451449751853943, 0.03335122764110565, -0.05910000205039978, -0.007835849188268185, 0.007190990261733532, 0.022956619039177895, 0.015476320870220661, -0.017969321459531784, 0.012559267692267895, -0.04201815277338028, 0.011489312164485455, 0.053920164704322815, -0.03098224848508835, -0.00836896151304245, -0.026971446350216866, 0.014431181363761425, -0.02326708659529686, -0.014238878153264523, 0.0057532526552677155, 0.012575913220643997, 0.0059229526668787, 0.006233118940144777, 0.03666958212852478, 0.02244073711335659, -0.004629175178706646, -0.02832975424826145, 0.03639405593276024, 0.09706807136535645, 0.03899727761745453, -0.061490993946790695, 0.02949080802500248, -0.011444169096648693, -0.05006927624344826, 0.01116490364074707, 0.0012294647749513388, -0.007356880232691765, 0.0021853300277143717, 0.034544315189123154, -0.010094866156578064, -0.015496745705604553, 0.012091248296201229, 0.0009035211987793446, 0.02319090999662876, 0.011403638869524002, -0.08721909672021866, -0.052680470049381256, 0.028586305677890778, -0.03396415710449219, 0.0005608678329735994, -0.024783942848443985, 0.010321851819753647, 0.0105405542999506, 0.04298136383295059, -0.00772813567891717, -0.0027616028673946857, 0.03273330628871918, 0.03869462385773659, 0.020282546058297157, -0.028918787837028503, -0.003758814884349704, -0.01345630083233118, -0.020462805405259132, -0.017103780061006546, -0.07155680656433105, 0.017449533566832542, 0.03983493521809578, 0.017787016928195953, -0.026071814820170403, 0.03822522237896919, 0.011102266609668732, -0.040685176849365234, -0.015754276886582375, 0.025689642876386642, -0.005129869561642408, 0.05175793915987015, 0.01717778481543064, 0.045270126312971115, -0.002153159352019429, 0.003170232754200697, 0.01145952008664608, 0.03525959700345993, 0.056516438722610474, 0.037225499749183655, -0.016140399500727654, -0.020465048030018806, -0.01841464638710022, -0.0008812773157842457, 0.01888958364725113, -0.023028623312711716, -0.05273260548710823, -0.02727634459733963, -0.003734464757144451, -0.013059204444289207, 0.04939768835902214, -0.003326370380818844, -0.024551084265112877, 0.02973315306007862, -0.05986154079437256, -0.023560982197523117, -0.06497088819742203, 0.0069655184634029865, -0.04451536759734154, -0.009594607166945934, 0.03165092691779137, -0.005426640156656504, 0.00898460391908884, 0.0014595420798286796, -0.014817191287875175, -0.013248567469418049, -0.016601158306002617, 0.04136823117733002, -0.024370910599827766, 0.018908025696873665, 0.017205964773893356, 0.050897322595119476, 0.007600626442581415, 0.04905346781015396, -0.05106249824166298, -0.04371212422847748, 0.013159642927348614, -0.05629720166325569, 0.005532626062631607, -0.03071454167366028, -0.01784246601164341, 0.014189008623361588, -0.01194095890969038, -0.01380551140755415, -0.0017217963468283415, -0.06869429349899292, 0.07376063615083694, 0.06344877928495407, 0.010303121991455555, -0.00043201286462135613, 0.011181811802089214, 0.012177140451967716, 0.03827212005853653, 0.002933335490524769, -0.013411784544587135, -0.044661980122327805, 0.004226224031299353, 0.049052298069000244, 0.0451846718788147, -0.04726715758442879, 0.010734505951404572, 0.03199676051735878, 0.026331014931201935, -0.01326950266957283, 0.006668522953987122, -0.022681014612317085, -0.015124285593628883, 0.0037558781914412975, 0.020062142983078957, 0.014334764331579208, 0.001317451591603458, -0.004058930091559887, 0.03232111409306526, 0.030368877574801445, -0.009083610028028488, 0.009382804855704308, 0.05271226167678833, -0.024045761674642563, 0.008389221504330635, -0.00516908336430788, -0.024694565683603287, 0.04296610876917839, -0.024327239021658897, -0.0426277332007885, 0.06285861134529114, 0.0032858585473150015, 0.020032478496432304, 0.008677617646753788, -0.04401322454214096, 0.028751932084560394, 0.015163395553827286, -0.05021345987915993, 0.014991197735071182, 0.013502613641321659, -0.01596117578446865, 0.037772320210933685, -0.016776416450738907, -0.0813748687505722, -0.005458435043692589, 0.01050506066530943, 0.011997153982520103, 0.041119422763586044, -0.0006075382116250694, 0.0034092606510967016, -0.00039744703099131584, 0.015062973834574223, -0.02119237557053566, 0.016113245859742165, -0.006853299215435982, -0.02888680249452591, -0.017190147191286087, -0.02178809978067875, 0.01460347231477499, 0.010554488748311996, -0.019579770043492317, 0.004002978093922138, 0.03305070474743843, -0.03142647445201874, -0.0635685846209526, 0.021116629242897034, -0.021828899160027504, 0.030958734452724457, -0.006878193933516741, -0.016718154773116112, 0.019808292388916016, 0.0015914379619061947, 0.006910587195307016, 0.01618308573961258, -0.02683926559984684, -0.019521959125995636, -0.026437420397996902, -0.004492997657507658, 0.013463396579027176, 0.030695701017975807, -0.02611825056374073, 0.010801488533616066, -0.037798747420310974, 0.008322038687765598, -0.04376690834760666, -0.07718983292579651, 0.010228651575744152, -0.004974754992872477, 0.04112234339118004, -0.004271999467164278, -0.011621213518083096, 0.06808480620384216, 0.04519662633538246, -0.04199417307972908, -0.05010044574737549, -0.01531574223190546, -0.024258099496364594, -0.017380241304636, 0.02252565138041973, 0.02832823432981968, -0.0051438515074551105, 0.013831638731062412, 0.03267134726047516, -0.006118723191320896, 0.04447019100189209, -0.02050080895423889, -0.01977233774960041, 0.04014759883284569, -0.00460487836971879, -0.0034361244179308414, 0.01166108250617981, 0.0158572755753994, -0.034370675683021545, 0.022239621728658676, 0.006596176419407129, -0.004849173128604889, 0.03361237049102783, -0.03985988721251488, 0.007430077530443668, -0.025861278176307678, -0.030708875507116318, -0.04733801633119583, 0.015511903911828995, -0.0060890959575772285, -0.04060066118836403, 0.013541413471102715, 0.010940492153167725, 0.011159402318298817, -0.021274831146001816, 0.01075719203799963, 0.056883301585912704, 0.05061084032058716, -0.020999044179916382, -0.00791076384484768, 0.0015393374487757683, -0.012690178118646145, 0.03337481617927551, -0.03456879407167435, 0.02665514312684536, 0.027743404731154442, 0.012877908535301685, 0.043565262109041214, -0.01566411554813385, -0.03730915114283562, 0.04400641843676567, -0.06316127628087997, -0.02629268355667591, -0.040133409202098846, 0.06448132544755936, 0.0245372261852026, 0.06720193475484848, 0.011323756538331509, 0.0074736569076776505, 0.011939866468310356, -0.012995101511478424, -0.07570171356201172, 0.02043941803276539, -0.025666046887636185, 0.014239057898521423, -0.03451703116297722, -0.007728457450866699, 0.07475778460502625, -0.01487231906503439, 0.01082307007163763, 0.0074436236172914505, 0.0064429170452058315, -0.01909266971051693, -0.026358632370829582, -0.03501712158322334, -0.03711060807108879, -0.006188157480210066, 0.029507219791412354, 0.030977807939052582, -0.01611870341002941, 0.03063553012907505, -0.004807847552001476, -0.024212075397372246, -0.018151206895709038, -0.022415226325392723, -0.006419678218662739, 0.019306156784296036, 0.048726752400398254, -0.019101129844784737, 0.019429266452789307, -0.005355153698474169, 0.041781723499298096, -0.00814768485724926, 0.04138614237308502, 0.05092008039355278, 0.0034366645850241184, -0.0008414495387114584, -0.04071692377328873, -0.011384077370166779, 0.014102285727858543, 0.03710421174764633, 0.014183984138071537, -0.006332531571388245, 0.09199263900518417, 0.03115830197930336, -0.0795312151312828, -0.012768863700330257, -0.00043746380833908916, 0.02232215739786625, -0.017543531954288483, -0.02959315851330757, 0.008274569176137447, -0.010701758787035942, 0.021975690498948097, 0.014770793728530407, -0.009121259674429893, -0.00789575558155775, -0.0005454653291963041, 0.07617700845003128, -0.03154068812727928, -0.03371202200651169, -0.019260229542851448, 0.0091073764488101, 0.05372565612196922, -0.002836567349731922, -0.03225423023104668, 0.035590603947639465, 0.04117196053266525, 0.03570622578263283, 0.035338081419467926, -0.018437908962368965, -0.08501609414815903, 0.010042020119726658, 0.041079502552747726, 0.04256035387516022, -0.04291361942887306, 0.016154728829860687, -0.04137706384062767, -0.004650442861020565, 0.04966245964169502, -0.028421971946954727, 0.017747195437550545, 0.003221678314730525, 0.00031996838515624404, -0.040498651564121246, -0.017615919932723045, -0.0734686627984047, -0.00446049589663744, 0.0012256551999598742, 0.07104294747114182, -0.06567602604627609, -0.03204012289643288, -0.056617215275764465, 0.016163397580385208, 0.02321959286928177, 0.04330514743924141, 0.013299311511218548, -0.021729707717895508, 0.0023819536436349154, -0.003946320619434118, 0.008005155250430107, -0.07870373129844666, 0.05258674919605255, 0.04907774552702904, 0.006555620580911636, 0.051718536764383316, 0.003885475918650627, -0.03900899738073349, 0.012137400917708874, -0.01994091086089611, -0.007261944003403187, 0.02739793062210083, -0.004024615976959467, 0.04651488736271858, 0.032204970717430115, -0.015207456424832344, 0.011810372583568096, 0.014427815563976765, -0.005272968672215939, -0.017680706456303596, -0.01084482204169035, -0.00021306339476723224, -0.03672431781888008, -0.02289762906730175, -0.013241487555205822, -0.043856874108314514, 0.005218345206230879, 0.02252832241356373, 0.023404307663440704, 0.03915182128548622, -0.018424078822135925, 0.008947029709815979, -0.0021004623267799616, 0.04616889730095863, 0.009002108126878738, -0.00021783181000500917, 0.031794533133506775, 0.008450851775705814, 0.009175634942948818, -0.00774016696959734, 0.032970130443573, 0.014121775515377522, -0.014071079902350903, 0.01775801181793213, -0.02390529029071331, -0.01986304484307766, -0.07278228551149368, -0.02228817343711853, -0.0017054460477083921, 0.012833753600716591, 0.03943036124110222, -0.028600910678505898, 0.030640846118330956, 0.02448463626205921, -0.0420171283185482, 0.0008429004228673875, 0.03614222630858421, 0.02056323178112507, 0.06667891144752502, -0.017012380063533783, 0.03403478488326073, -0.028335092589259148, 0.02603299729526043, -0.08248516917228699, -0.06194547563791275, 0.02088502049446106, 0.006282517220824957, -0.027842340990900993, -0.05530102550983429, 0.018725156784057617, -0.020622489973902702, -0.01638321578502655, 0.008693328127264977, 0.039616066962480545, -0.0320935994386673, -0.01150536723434925, 0.013618269935250282, -0.0009769233874976635, 0.10149221867322922, -0.02015523985028267, -0.027319246903061867, 0.03195005655288696, 0.002065212931483984, 0.0012889853678643703, 0.003981125075370073, 0.009133350104093552, -0.026029592379927635, 0.02990048937499523, -0.020377997308969498, 0.01599457859992981, 0.03538750484585762, -0.049643900245428085, -0.014652579091489315, 0.03535047546029091, -0.007548587862402201, -0.003959745168685913, -0.016640368849039078, -0.0007945703691802919, -0.026512322947382927, -0.022700689733028412, -0.00007772048411425203, -0.01671726442873478, -0.026559695601463318, -0.03135132044553757, 0.016054779291152954, -0.0075051491148769855, -0.028860026970505714, 0.0647411122918129, 0.056161824613809586, 0.007181291002780199, -0.02321617864072323, -0.0009231942822225392, 0.0012047839118167758, 0.037530552595853806, 0.00030389922903850675, -0.021033471450209618, -0.015361224301159382, 0.021838568150997162, -0.01856679469347, -0.03863517940044403, -0.05253063142299652, -0.03812193125486374, 0.06436756998300552, 0.016361292451620102, 0.038052067160606384, 0.06208479776978493, 0.016406821087002754, 0.006689704023301601, -0.0167525727301836, -0.0006503498298116028, -0.007471832446753979, 0.0018548938678577542, 0.0369090735912323, 0.005342993885278702, -0.01173356082290411, 0.013054213486611843, 0.03948618471622467, -0.019775107502937317, 0.028234003111720085, -0.005456369835883379, 0.02767467498779297, 0.031305622309446335, -0.059948887676000595, -0.10092481225728989, 0.009343251585960388, -0.059355370700359344, 0.020528407767415047, -0.053138770163059235, -0.02267644926905632, 0.04924089089035988, 0.06416306644678116, 0.027147168293595314, -0.04059980809688568, -0.02963721565902233, -0.044400665909051895, -0.006048376206308603, 0.029926808550953865, 0.0035531267058104277, 0.0472106896340847, 0.030388332903385162, 0.04740704596042633, -0.01256051566451788, 0.02615697868168354, -0.01713588275015354, -0.06413882225751877, -0.03180591017007828, -0.018414610996842384, -0.04106726497411728, 0.012841896153986454, -0.020263606682419777, -0.06005866825580597, 0.02711051143705845, -0.05052023008465767, 0.03311332315206528, 0.00738070672377944, 0.00415395013988018, 0.00241107027977705, 0.04185978323221207, -0.017338277772068977, -0.010698446072638035, -0.015377712436020374, 0.009639065712690353, 0.09591084718704224, 0.056376826018095016, 0.03490408882498741, -0.07563996315002441, 0.020961567759513855, 0.005169432144612074, -0.006512162741273642, -0.041335854679346085, 0.02027319371700287, 0.029233677312731743, -0.030082257464528084, 0.035123951733112335, 0.022856805473566055, 0.01857544668018818, 0.012029457837343216, 0.055711325258016586, -0.032568518072366714, -0.023728108033537865, 0.02142135240137577, -0.012856736779212952, -0.018820835277438164, -0.03173482045531273, -0.05155974626541138, 0.031954217702150345, -0.0077884504571557045, -0.03140074759721756, -0.03353364020586014, -0.02525852434337139, 0.0021755723282694817, -0.023020852357149124, -0.004806825891137123, 0.007446091156452894, 0.011250562034547329, -0.006669260561466217, -0.017123844474554062, 0.0017774540465325117, 0.009263617917895317, -0.02915695495903492, -0.005691762547940016, 0.013670927844941616, 0.008160415105521679, -0.006494822446256876, -0.00010253541404381394, -0.017901087179780006, -0.03895382210612297, -0.03563738986849785, -0.04198098182678223, 0.020507419481873512, 0.022077515721321106, 0.003569327760487795, -0.0068978555500507355, 0.049255479127168655, -0.00820772722363472, -0.035544708371162415, 0.004616160877048969, 0.01581175997853279, 0.048034168779850006, -0.016933364793658257, -0.01831507682800293, -0.014376554638147354, 0.010524149052798748, -0.03406234458088875, -0.003458448452875018, 0.03419835492968559, -0.029511626809835434, -0.004042209126055241, -0.00423112977296114, 0.043022751808166504, -0.005468688439577818, -0.03390704095363617, -0.015046870335936546, -0.022039825096726418, 0.01960078626871109, 0.012999223545193672, 0.004092108923941851, -0.011882551945745945, 0.020330000668764114, 0.014945666305720806, -0.010787662118673325, -0.030159614980220795, -0.024159038439393044, 0.011796703562140465, -0.015256916172802448, 0.01469254121184349, -0.025585204362869263, 0.00910227932035923, 0.04169721528887749, 0.020747745409607887, 0.06529161334037781, 0.013751105405390263, -0.0280899815261364, 0.008043053559958935, 0.00966185238212347, -0.030339078977704048, -0.04771317169070244, -0.00835906621068716, -0.009925805032253265, -0.001721348031423986, -0.0024857078678905964, 0.06763336807489395, 0.014261250384151936, -0.002174902940168977, 0.04068683460354805, 0.0397084541618824, -0.021261680871248245, 0.04372803121805191, 0.02006150409579277, -0.057654812932014465, 0.002187415724620223, -0.005736729130148888, -0.026123568415641785, -0.03641923516988754, -0.05191937834024429, -0.008991081267595291, -0.005197511054575443, -0.005473477300256491, -0.006330662406980991, -0.005582332145422697, -0.006102460436522961, -0.013207540847361088, -0.0015769803430885077, -0.058289993554353714, 0.007150209508836269, -0.043824486434459686, -0.028128648176789284, -0.030871642753481865, -0.004825495649129152, 0.007875260896980762, -0.02195502631366253, -0.02075200341641903, -0.004978845827281475, 0.056641701608896255, 0.021163053810596466, 0.034504473209381104, -0.025693031027913094, -0.0038025369867682457, -0.033231478184461594, 0.05494409054517746, -0.05224734917283058, -0.00775650842115283, 0.018450869247317314, -0.06554482132196426, 0.017796149477362633, 0.004818112589418888, -0.03663770854473114, 0.016477374359965324, 0.02349410578608513, 0.016917644068598747, -0.023498207330703735, 0.024464232847094536, 0.0019868595991283655, 0.012922007590532303, -0.01586269959807396, 0.043439093977212906, 0.003463154658675194, -0.017322417348623276, 0.03861524537205696, 0.00417661014944315, -0.009380117058753967, 0.030304156243801117, 0.048682648688554764, 0.000014363202353706583, -0.01632397249341011, 0.04645123332738876, -0.004710594657808542, -0.003101241309195757, 0.0019357772544026375, -0.0021338057704269886, 0.09435810893774033, 0.04870601370930672, -0.05543079599738121, 0.024883180856704712, -0.015263433568179607, 0.03881299868226051, -0.08837916702032089, -0.002360997023060918, 0.0070500364527106285, 0.036028217524290085, 0.04130551964044571, -0.08558440953493118, -0.003381101880222559, -0.008975431323051453, -0.029352650046348572, 0.026193462312221527, 0.01240773219615221, 0.008937575854361057, -0.020218968391418457, 0.03309136629104614, -0.023404067382216454, 0.03827209770679474, 0.02058984525501728, 0.04195510223507881, 0.033048514276742935, 0.05857228860259056, 0.005382141564041376, 0.0037945378571748734, -0.008664705790579319, -0.0018559423042461276, 0.03627949208021164, -0.05421503260731697, 0.04334269464015961, -0.03179815784096718, -0.06097383797168732, 0.005376107059419155, -0.008397001773118973, 0.018830925226211548, 0.041046254336833954, 0.008277297019958496, 0.013803643174469471, 0.06259144097566605, 0.021931318566203117, -0.035545799881219864, 0.0026939869858324528, -0.01606447994709015, 0.020518742501735687, 0.020514093339443207, -0.012185150757431984, 0.02112344093620777, 0.044636745005846024, -0.03163590282201767, -0.014682980254292488, -0.018169092014431953, -0.021764609962701797, -0.02976773865520954, 0.01056668907403946, -0.0032757376320660114, 0.01577327772974968, -0.004442186560481787, 0.051561158150434494, -0.029271941632032394, -0.033990830183029175, 0.0126957381144166, 0.03467516973614693, 0.00006012230733176693, 0.006403823383152485, -0.001077641500160098, -0.06022701784968376, -0.0030295976903289557, 0.02399953454732895, -0.020482731983065605, -0.04323061183094978, 0.0065889437682926655, 0.019733194261789322, -0.004099588841199875, -0.017441632226109505, -0.024551689624786377, -0.01891900785267353, 0.024676378816366196, -0.025051657110452652, -0.039007190614938736, 0.016587860882282257, -0.03752034902572632, 0.023232825100421906, -0.07810929417610168, 0.04581960663199425, 0.005891445558518171, -0.021932734176516533, -0.008399809710681438, 0.0009198133484460413, -0.04363594949245453, -0.021562380716204643, 0.04807475954294205, -0.006862896028906107, 0.003855100367218256, -0.008793341927230358, 0.03767608106136322, 0.01501962635666132, -0.05388452485203743, 0.03085113689303398, -0.046801336109638214, -0.00716159213334322, 0.004286486189812422, -0.01883530057966709, 0.0069879209622740746, 0.011795719154179096, 0.03688359260559082, -0.014569669961929321, 0.0035001954529434443, -0.021549511700868607, -0.013776347041130066, 0.029925042763352394, -0.01980511285364628, -0.03262456879019737, 0.03226295858621597, 0.0040389373898506165, -0.006128746084868908, 0.0307445228099823, -0.0049241455271840096, -0.053255967795848846, 0.024844493716955185, -0.008831892162561417, -0.01948714628815651, 0.009406880475580692, -0.020259222015738487, 0.053173914551734924, -0.06135379523038864, 0.007049989886581898, 0.03288144990801811, -0.038406819105148315, 0.0006209973362274468, 0.03669881075620651, 0.07640130817890167, 0.01786859892308712, 0.006124078296124935, 0.005638705100864172, -0.0032028574496507645, -0.005934806074947119, -0.007552518974989653, 0.03742619976401329, 0.04999649524688721, 0.009735999628901482, -0.006430977489799261, 0.016056980937719345, -0.00699240155518055, 0.01590215414762497, -0.01534596923738718, 0.01210608147084713, -0.03963439539074898, -0.009548828937113285, 0.0308830626308918, 0.0015902618179097772, -0.013031699694693089, 0.006936080288141966, -0.03308982029557228, 0.06294963508844376, -0.030637400224804878, 0.0002586085756774992, -0.04797486960887909, -0.013510373421013355, -0.012909463606774807, -0.004398607648909092, -0.012215543538331985, 0.05203673988580704, 0.013217189349234104, 0.011993513442575932, -0.015220939181745052, -0.0027014403603971004, 0.015771571546792984, 0.007259211502969265, 0.03371408209204674, -0.0402512401342392, 0.013126389123499393, 0.0015170915285125375, -0.01860433630645275, -0.047923099249601364, -0.04182193800806999, 0.05095945671200752, 0.06804764270782471, 0.03347431868314743, 0.007110814563930035, -0.02599458582699299, -0.013795619830489159, 0.038030948489904404, -0.07986370474100113, -0.028352750465273857, -0.04805176705121994, -0.003737963270395994, 0.028877686709165573, -0.014574672095477581 ]
<p>Is the validity coefficient the same thing as $\rho$, where $\rho = \frac{COV_{XY}}{SD_X SD_Y}$?</p>
37,303
[ -0.025236163288354874, 0.007683703675866127, -0.0069518317468464375, -0.01790481060743332, 0.028790095821022987, 0.04176780581474304, -0.0400579608976841, -0.031256068497896194, 0.0403703898191452, -0.0157246645539999, 0.04337218403816223, -0.022346090525388718, 0.09185745567083359, 0.01503782533109188, 0.022520532831549644, 0.033569421619176865, -0.01235130988061428, 0.04747525975108147, 0.01078645046800375, -0.01804259419441223, -0.0006143830250948668, 0.015170091763138771, 0.0021174789872020483, -0.010708911344408989, 0.00556574109941721, 0.06860838830471039, 0.03137154504656792, -0.043677303940057755, 0.004712576512247324, 0.014069093391299248, -0.053335100412368774, -0.01594662107527256, -0.0054450854659080505, 0.036408744752407074, 0.036962974816560745, 0.026627080515027046, 0.005772960372269154, -0.025014488026499748, -0.029422421008348465, 0.03287215903401375, -0.07673168182373047, -0.011861895211040974, 0.015149984508752823, 0.0852566584944725, 0.03555237501859665, 0.02406957559287548, -0.0015410566702485085, -0.012691178359091282, 0.011635493487119675, -0.03378511220216751, 0.06039208546280861, -0.002269079675897956, 0.042173683643341064, 0.061903197318315506, 0.019090797752141953, -0.03881524130702019, 0.08640413731336594, 0.017520660534501076, -0.022153349593281746, -0.03652404993772507, -0.03682868555188179, -0.030480079352855682, -0.010031389072537422, -0.007803154643625021, -0.01541481725871563, 0.013057265430688858, 0.01887376606464386, -0.011298097670078278, 0.004797389730811119, -0.019485658034682274, -0.006504233926534653, 0.027596885338425636, -0.018422234803438187, -0.025645293295383453, 0.032959431409835815, -0.039193637669086456, 0.007969627156853676, 0.01988844946026802, -0.0010499176569283009, 0.02388613484799862, 0.022140054032206535, 0.0006647531990893185, 0.02465573512017727, 0.03623272106051445, -0.00017148353799711913, 0.01717722788453102, 0.05326159670948982, -0.039746981114149094, 0.042596619576215744, 0.004867204464972019, -0.0025386428460478783, 0.0375187024474144, 0.03231982886791229, 0.006662461441010237, 0.014642656780779362, 0.04905088618397713, -0.018283626064658165, 0.032248660922050476, 0.018080344423651695, -0.01704033650457859, -0.029918231070041656, -0.035776540637016296, 0.007979064248502254, 0.07716061919927597, 0.0035022124648094177, -0.04146149009466171, 0.010150192305445671, -0.006512918509542942, -0.02540764957666397, -0.018628908321261406, -0.030612483620643616, 0.012008290737867355, 0.01602816767990589, 0.040797311812639236, 0.01969330757856369, -0.012301650829613209, 0.013250800780951977, -0.011732789687812328, 0.05526616424322128, 0.0541936531662941, 0.026251453906297684, 0.01820669136941433, 0.012504651211202145, 0.0014016339555382729, -0.07341357320547104, 0.036648765206336975, 0.02055281773209572, -0.01873466745018959, -0.03438287228345871, 0.03682240471243858, 0.017328467220067978, -0.01670219376683235, 0.009413089603185654, -0.016966525465250015, 0.00700437743216753, -0.00030630620312877, -0.06628091633319855, -0.020409582182765007, 0.035468704998493195, 0.051881637424230576, 0.03392422944307327, -0.053052593022584915, -0.010171242989599705, 0.04264841228723526, 0.062080901116132736, 0.002346163149923086, 0.0447896309196949, -0.025567322969436646, 0.006085949018597603, 0.009385616518557072, -0.03748978301882744, -0.027321571484208107, -0.004442112985998392, -0.02017117477953434, -0.04230741411447525, -0.08849696069955826, -0.0018866915488615632, 0.03965279832482338, 0.007131124380975962, -0.012840443290770054, 0.07125760614871979, -0.008051561191678047, -0.019831029698252678, -0.01697855070233345, 0.02142813429236412, -0.0610564760863781, 0.061445046216249466, 0.027775906026363373, 0.020687131211161613, 0.0016528957057744265, -0.010642732493579388, 0.01824813336133957, 0.01592574268579483, 0.02056550793349743, 0.061475273221731186, -0.013119790703058243, -0.011759128421545029, -0.013643651269376278, 0.03223691135644913, -0.006964485626667738, -0.048682451248168945, 0.007137222681194544, -0.055428653955459595, -0.052967414259910583, -0.006895109545439482, 0.020978864282369614, 0.0062813726253807545, 0.015048868954181671, -0.012952719815075397, -0.01859375275671482, -0.001974917948246002, -0.05673212930560112, -0.01325320266187191, -0.009236834943294525, -0.030373772606253624, 0.03475120663642883, 0.013472557999193668, 0.006934689823538065, 0.023803938180208206, -0.0014130742056295276, -0.028340695425868034, 0.039444684982299805, 0.027402224019169807, -0.027636313810944557, 0.024410579353570938, 0.01427512802183628, 0.04566214233636856, 0.011452095583081245, 0.025325357913970947, -0.0030122771859169006, -0.043912891298532486, -0.02428014576435089, -0.03769638389348984, 0.0404219776391983, -0.04824061319231987, -0.013622495345771313, 0.00677393889054656, 0.0017909862799569964, -0.010157817043364048, 0.04380645230412483, -0.07054910063743591, 0.04339209198951721, 0.07775451987981796, 0.026381779462099075, 0.013460162095725536, -0.0059470864944159985, 0.009421266615390778, 0.009971767663955688, -0.019083602353930473, -0.017980877310037613, -0.004675382282584906, -0.033512238413095474, 0.021892227232456207, 0.030580570921301842, -0.002727528801187873, 0.027603741735219955, 0.020087195560336113, 0.009699261747300625, -0.000013728838894166984, -0.02123846858739853, 0.026889806613326073, -0.043461188673973083, 0.011284952983260155, 0.027034878730773926, 0.007130620535463095, -0.0018918438581749797, -0.019878897815942764, 0.014429286122322083, 0.054568100720644, -0.012482142075896263, -0.00003522624319884926, 0.07208666205406189, -0.008400630205869675, -0.025839541107416153, 0.0018824521685019135, 0.008910325355827808, 0.042762186378240585, 0.005096780601888895, 0.04892224818468094, 0.011531098745763302, -0.00018078551511280239, -0.012744881212711334, -0.035747822374105453, -0.04250863939523697, 0.028935424983501434, 0.03714051470160484, 0.014298317953944206, -0.00802826788276434, 0.02605103887617588, -0.05298371985554695, -0.00043939490569755435, -0.06427640467882156, 0.001826573978178203, 0.018432656303048134, -0.0192131195217371, 0.043146055191755295, 0.012559606693685055, 0.04342936351895332, -0.026701996102929115, -0.006873180158436298, -0.029176106676459312, -0.003366652876138687, 0.022753922268748283, 0.0032120547257363796, -0.05780505761504173, -0.013391107320785522, -0.0074405791237950325, -0.005204562563449144, -0.0014845019904896617, -0.04061896726489067, -0.02823636308312416, 0.03898824006319046, 0.012675616890192032, -0.038622498512268066, -0.01364427711814642, -0.02624865435063839, -0.01903747022151947, -0.04068100079894066, -0.02894217148423195, 0.014496328309178352, 0.0019556593615561724, -0.057560451328754425, 0.02287040464580059, -0.03125765919685364, -0.017419056966900826, -0.020919129252433777, -0.034934572875499725, 0.006976603996008635, -0.028208961710333824, 0.0293581560254097, 0.0507880374789238, -0.008639507927000523, -0.049369581043720245, -0.053360551595687866, -0.060762036591768265, 0.028111940249800682, -0.02451699785888195, 0.02256806194782257, -0.02426249533891678, -0.026577696204185486, 0.061488065868616104, 0.048132285475730896, -0.015320619568228722, -0.02800014056265354, 0.015457967296242714, -0.011874636635184288, -0.017030956223607063, -0.016203943639993668, 0.005050614010542631, 0.03786449506878853, 0.03706459701061249, 0.007433196064084768, 0.009892724454402924, 0.015034823678433895, 0.001212981645949185, 0.005708260461688042, 0.03431018441915512, 0.034763120114803314, -0.04471610486507416, 0.046150390058755875, 0.01818256825208664, -0.024382760748267174, 0.006182605400681496, -0.022689957171678543, 0.04829118028283119, 0.04260871186852455, -0.06411487609148026, 0.008131513372063637, -0.0372847244143486, 0.0053245387971401215, -0.012102700769901276, 0.019913235679268837, 0.014469340443611145, -0.01705600693821907, -0.02515251561999321, 0.013222540728747845, 0.02940433844923973, -0.009934826754033566, 0.012312592007219791, 0.04172199219465256, 0.02890019491314888, 0.0034553082659840584, -0.018264183774590492, -0.005785759538412094, -0.007826474495232105, -0.004514224361628294, -0.01402900367975235, -0.057199254631996155, 0.05935528129339218, 0.011972807347774506, -0.002218230627477169, -0.0249318964779377, -0.0340861976146698, -0.012147395871579647, -0.0625503733754158, -0.004388344474136829, -0.022582923993468285, 0.0300059225410223, -0.008188107050955296, 0.04276531562209129, 0.017248107120394707, -0.027096111327409744, 0.008442029356956482, -0.0008201054879464209, -0.08291621506214142, -0.017107388004660606, -0.04288088530302048, -0.02892233617603779, -0.0015578735619783401, -0.026264337822794914, 0.030204428359866142, 0.006711030378937721, 0.01404374185949564, -0.0077940961346030235, 0.004351780284196138, -0.001127389376051724, -0.0026728701777756214, -0.0016191285103559494, -0.05057116597890854, 0.005856122821569443, 0.03227180987596512, 0.025271372869610786, -0.006812189240008593, 0.017829185351729393, 0.05478554964065552, 0.03616439551115036, 0.025235125795006752, -0.04826740920543671, 0.013807544484734535, 0.018795646727085114, 0.03439119830727577, 0.023486895486712456, 0.05027364194393158, -0.058110788464546204, 0.0360771082341671, 0.022093256935477257, -0.0010361977620050311, 0.02314349077641964, 0.013611218892037868, -0.03220980614423752, -0.05907686799764633, -0.039917778223752975, 0.0041710068471729755, 0.0037347697652876377, -0.0156534593552351, -0.015804262831807137, 0.05106537789106369, 0.023803578689694405, -0.05886625126004219, 0.016264311969280243, 0.03201841935515404, 0.011498915031552315, -0.027395136654376984, -0.0380278155207634, 0.008336816914379597, 0.009783557616174221, -0.012947000563144684, 0.025213638320565224, 0.028671888634562492, -0.05907600373029709, -0.0014908163575455546, 0.01897723227739334, -0.012142611667513847, -0.02213197946548462, 0.061825159937143326, 0.014307830482721329, 0.04486902430653572, 0.01493438147008419, -0.01594296097755432, -0.0005462365807034075, 0.03943469002842903, -0.0023778604809194803, 0.03166661038994789, 0.022920405492186546, -0.04201546311378479, 0.017639920115470886, 0.019073044881224632, 0.026858225464820862, -0.05127495899796486, -0.04725758358836174, -0.03047139383852482, -0.024968346580863, 0.03423263877630234, -0.008361516520380974, 0.0289208572357893, -0.010781527496874332, 0.004576290957629681, -0.02443545311689377, -0.021090397611260414, -0.04755759611725807, 0.037835076451301575, 0.04390528425574303, -0.030216027051210403, -0.028556719422340393, 0.021222200244665146, 0.0024826833978295326, 0.013131250627338886, -0.004378094803541899, 0.060459960252046585, -0.02613111585378647, -0.032522305846214294, -0.01852896437048912, -0.0018904791213572025, 0.01404755562543869, -0.06552179902791977, -0.018172673881053925, 0.05015642195940018, -0.018145140260457993, 0.045069485902786255, -0.00522629264742136, -0.038244761526584625, 0.04155728220939636, 0.02265430986881256, 0.0002492797502782196, 0.019449105486273766, -0.03844621405005455, 0.07038785517215729, 0.03686017170548439, 0.008647690527141094, 0.05723399668931961, 0.006450230721384287, -0.032593030482530594, -0.006847755052149296, -0.039928603917360306, -0.02335260435938835, -0.05454165115952492, -0.01810089498758316, -0.0297906044870615, 0.02532161958515644, -0.022988472133874893, 0.004085928667336702, -0.01902570016682148, 0.017043177038431168, -0.013903060927987099, 0.0011840300867334008, -0.006200116593390703, 0.03760058432817459, -0.017093181610107422, -0.015373924747109413, 0.03967691957950592, 0.021265385672450066, 0.015348576009273529, -0.015505935996770859, -0.015015887096524239, 0.014351924881339073, 0.015543142333626747, 0.01718158833682537, -0.025844378396868706, 0.013191251084208488, -0.01861579529941082, 0.002365684602409601, -0.007457730360329151, 0.010443571954965591, 0.019343825057148933, -0.029158808290958405, 0.00903535820543766, -0.028183598071336746, -0.038798898458480835, 0.0006689414731226861, 0.03793229162693024, -0.004386247135698795, 0.04197380319237709, -0.008407042361795902, 0.005456780083477497, 0.008190557360649109, -0.020350556820631027, -0.09252392500638962, -0.011871579103171825, -0.0009062049211934209, -0.013134701177477837, 0.019720615819096565, -0.006151182577013969, -0.006438171025365591, -0.021244937554001808, -0.06709666550159454, -0.009108888916671276, 0.033884868025779724, 0.009014328941702843, -0.023507634177803993, -0.025782154873013496, -0.004412293434143066, 0.024748055264353752, -0.020260868594050407, 0.027048785239458084, 0.0074058640748262405, 0.008515090681612492, 0.004367116838693619, 0.043242197483778, 0.02883618138730526, -0.015493323095142841, -0.022686315700411797, -0.06168496608734131, -0.04739038273692131, 0.0123086366802454, -0.016280192881822586, -0.05155685544013977, 0.01502708438783884, -0.02427050657570362, -0.009343883953988552, -0.024483762681484222, 0.0009526268695481122, 0.025270523503422737, 0.015882354229688644, 0.014079825952649117, -0.012514039874076843, -0.03618492931127548, 0.017576823011040688, 0.010451870039105415, 0.011419487185776234, -0.0007589038577862084, 0.028984038159251213, 0.06529500335454941, 0.011658797040581703, -0.005652626045048237, 0.006399222183972597, 0.008817818947136402, 0.05599278211593628, 0.008867528289556503, -0.006711367983371019, 0.02581963874399662, -0.00024269001733046025, -0.06941663473844528, -0.06577685475349426, -0.06246490404009819, 0.03803803771734238, 0.060599613934755325, -0.02227514050900936, 0.03508990630507469, -0.00026465795235708356, -0.024261530488729477, -0.0265344325453043, -0.05452346429228783, 0.01387031003832817, 0.02826698310673237, -0.040427424013614655, 0.023529930040240288, -0.022850926965475082, -0.03379571810364723, 0.014435367658734322, 0.020914604887366295, 0.008516425266861916, 0.028686432167887688, 0.012283464893698692, 0.03993145003914833, 0.011111179366707802, -0.03239529952406883, -0.0326114185154438, 0.04865714907646179, -0.030248573049902916, -0.0067737209610641, -0.02879583276808262, -0.020788976922631264, 0.05708358436822891, 0.014883170835673809, -0.001408497104421258, -0.04718930646777153, -0.0000199978949240176, -0.04929893836379051, 0.019528081640601158, 0.03752100467681885, -0.011653141118586063, 0.03711346909403801, -0.015107817947864532, 0.02607918716967106, 0.012793686240911484, 0.041729576885700226, -0.012445583008229733, -0.07415489107370377, 0.015118260867893696, -0.00641337176784873, -0.02540753409266472, 0.02507561445236206, -0.006244623567909002, -0.013417891226708889, 0.0197178702801466, -0.04207665100693703, 0.005811658222228289, 0.019857963547110558, -0.0016260304255411029, -0.006999348755925894, 0.010308408178389072, -0.022128408774733543, 0.011734331957995892, -0.012920677661895752, -0.007985241711139679, 0.13993020355701447, 0.06635013967752457, 0.014316431246697903, -0.02302897348999977, -0.01227944903075695, 0.0030281885992735624, 0.02439749240875244, -0.06276414543390274, -0.003348931670188904, 0.006504858378320932, -0.025463463738560677, 0.04436749592423439, 0.06809691339731216, -0.000986543600447476, 0.019673367962241173, 0.002261054702103138, 0.022096142172813416, -0.009516202844679356, -0.01247850526124239, 0.03117271140217781, -0.014551899395883083, -0.005459257401525974, 0.015384577214717865, 0.011228879913687706, 0.009081087075173855, -0.04102654382586479, -0.026504898443818092, 0.026667816564440727, -0.011489661410450935, -0.026470841839909554, -0.04375998675823212, 0.007303837686777115, -0.005590073298662901, 0.04530548304319382, -0.013637591153383255, -0.005205513443797827, 0.030550044029951096, -0.04577022045850754, -0.013419661670923233, 0.04793829470872879, -0.02494378574192524, 0.010245680809020996, -0.0002017836959566921, 0.01148232165724039, -0.04429636523127556, -0.020902272313833237, -0.031091930344700813, 0.03324009105563164, -0.014399657025933266, 0.0036466282326728106, 0.01826437935233116, 0.0008292730781249702, 0.015889521688222885, -0.025721890851855278, -0.02477228082716465, 0.011890680529177189, 0.01694282703101635, -0.030826032161712646, -0.02229931950569153, -0.026085279881954193, -0.016752656549215317, -0.016155263409018517, 0.031975988298654556, 0.004130921326577663, -0.031032290309667587, -0.004904484376311302, 0.015926066786050797, 0.07504652440547943, -0.018660543486475945, -0.006896851118654013, -0.005285243038088083, 0.021728260442614555, -0.01796257123351097, 0.014102969318628311, 0.015724364668130875, 0.029863012954592705, 0.03419193625450134, 0.00294781057164073, 0.023280981928110123, -0.0054943677969276905, -0.07456231862306595, 0.009979305788874626, -0.044198449701070786, 0.019623884931206703, -0.046479713171720505, -0.061049893498420715, 0.030151620507240295, 0.05502699315547943, 0.005979620385915041, 0.010751442052423954, -0.015230519697070122, 0.07654204964637756, 0.03048117272555828, -0.04955931380391121, -0.07767052203416824, -0.005736444145441055, -0.07067377120256424, 0.002654444193467498, 0.0001686577161308378, 0.011818340048193932, -0.004147357307374477, 0.06915333122015, -0.005513717420399189, 0.01833301968872547, -0.02110057882964611, 0.015719730406999588, 0.008257512003183365, -0.014740316197276115, 0.008042075671255589, -0.0007164358394220471, 0.004594994708895683, 0.009700655937194824, 0.015692953020334244, -0.06665864586830139, -0.040149006992578506, 0.016805779188871384, -0.011067415587604046, -0.0228024423122406, 0.006122436374425888, -0.0005502835847437382, -0.0010498331394046545, -0.027869606390595436, 0.028843935579061508, 0.0017326476518064737, -0.014787374995648861, -0.002295403741300106, -0.03526918217539787, 0.008147125132381916, -0.0045654671266674995, -0.0018760358216241002, 0.03787646442651749, 0.03413735330104828, 0.015438147820532322, 0.006928171496838331, -0.04825284704566002, 0.004425969906151295, 0.008440090343356133, 0.0349070280790329, -0.03592093288898468, 0.011679147370159626, 0.05235130712389946, -0.04049680382013321, -0.04090388864278793, 0.011161831207573414, 0.017261214554309845, 0.03182602673768997, 0.025795718654990196, 0.03470028191804886, -0.005826951470226049, 0.06633366644382477, -0.02022711932659149, -0.023207539692521095, 0.0026567247696220875, -0.006951671559363604, 0.04543818160891533, 0.02634524740278721, 0.017765291035175323, 0.009720236994326115, 0.020494746044278145, 0.030781522393226624, 0.031830303370952606, -0.02840484492480755, -0.00107596255838871, 0.0144492881372571, 0.015762554481625557, -0.009393957443535328, 0.009264425374567509, 0.0123824467882514, -0.0328756608068943, 0.03103620558977127, -0.011141592636704445, 0.018474314361810684, 0.011018912307918072, 0.01879388839006424, -0.09052643924951553, -0.04458475485444069, 0.008959205821156502, 0.02596118673682213, 0.0038730446249246597, -0.061620667576789856, 0.013468652963638306, 0.005565150640904903, -0.08743615448474884, 0.04702213406562805, 0.018753908574581146, 0.014670945703983307, -0.06256049126386642, 0.0011750336270779371, -0.009718443267047405, 0.028130369260907173, 0.047182049602270126, 0.0037704266142100096, -0.019405070692300797, 0.04368038848042488, -0.0074156406335532665, -0.017628472298383713, -0.016886994242668152, 0.0114790890365839, -0.03342839702963829, -0.07224946469068527, 0.04548757150769234, -0.04920463636517525, -0.022426508367061615, -0.011452999897301197, 0.021625932306051254, 0.015627026557922363, -0.03765504062175751, 0.06917405128479004, -0.02492508292198181, 0.022273223847150803, 0.015459991991519928, -0.012963306158781052, 0.02606842666864395, 0.03910685330629349, -0.0033501172438263893, 0.0250628013163805, -0.03466242179274559, -0.02304898574948311, 0.029045552015304565, -0.009882135316729546, -0.058658190071582794, 0.04108763858675957, 0.013509221374988556, -0.017601437866687775, 0.0007464903173968196, -0.024168293923139572, 0.024387342855334282, -0.012204105965793133, 0.018214145675301552, -0.08967658132314682, -0.01040896587073803, 0.047603268176317215, 0.02013477496802807, -0.03488228842616081, -0.020189233124256134, -0.04465346038341522, -0.032301608473062515, 0.045086316764354706, 0.01486145704984665, -0.0018275176407769322, -0.040811795741319656, -0.005777194630354643, -0.01555910985916853, -0.007496519014239311, -0.014049043878912926, 0.027500661090016365, -0.00003964471034123562, 0.05432309955358505, 0.002027403097599745, 0.006565403658896685, 0.03757987171411514, -0.01654144562780857, -0.011898977681994438, -0.05534638836979866, 0.03119269758462906, 0.022770769894123077, -0.04812081530690193, -0.02529473789036274, -0.032159753143787384, -0.025739165022969246, -0.011390739120543003, 0.038563791662454605, 0.03386366739869118, -0.04100348800420761, 0.011495000682771206, 0.020322095602750778, -0.0023499049711972475, -0.06908779591321945, 0.06285122036933899, -0.026346052065491676, 0.02478199079632759, -0.028955258429050446, 0.026420611888170242, -0.012085964903235435, -0.008541934192180634, -0.00040876519051380455, -0.007775443140417337, 0.018361717462539673, -0.02900802716612816, -0.016564084216952324, 0.029526153579354286, 0.005955917295068502, -0.009911241941154003, 0.09840289503335953, -0.008217454887926579, -0.01970052905380726, -0.003984495531767607, 0.020923089236021042, -0.05373826250433922, 0.01690165512263775, -0.001873694360256195, -0.04196995869278908, 0.0009571723057888448, 0.0356874093413353, -0.018572838976979256, -0.0158969946205616, 0.0027383603155612946, 0.06365170329809189, -0.02970091439783573, -0.041202276945114136, 0.015514283441007137, 0.043938152492046356, 0.03035562112927437, -0.013769245706498623, 0.01947063021361828, 0.0264069065451622, -0.028600523248314857, 0.015127820894122124, 0.037043701857328415, 0.07182680815458298, 0.04537926986813545, 0.000915511860512197, 0.040435031056404114, -0.016378158703446388, 0.004958953242748976, 0.009750357829034328, 0.032307256013154984, -0.054109688848257065, 0.008649141527712345, 0.00857594609260559, -0.023900557309389114, 0.0647190660238266, -0.007474044803529978, 0.012727903202176094, 0.05766162648797035, -0.03864915296435356, -0.013256965205073357, -0.03778716176748276, 0.01809169538319111, -0.04347439482808113, 0.004689531400799751, 0.051170703023672104, 0.03527161106467247, -0.023282838985323906, -0.02295598015189171, -0.01072748750448227, -0.03558708727359772, 0.0357423834502697, -0.04425705596804619, -0.002144158584997058, 0.021773874759674072, 0.012131365947425365, -0.03758048266172409, 0.034379903227090836, -0.03608008101582527, -0.017199838533997536, -0.0078376904129982, 0.038126882165670395, 0.008825521916151047, 0.011634121648967266, -0.006111476104706526, -0.02275671623647213, 0.06024764105677605, -0.10034036636352539, -0.004826975055038929, 0.0057531362399458885, 0.012600096873939037, -0.007630460895597935, -0.0043984586372971535 ]
<p>Let $X$ and $Y$ be two i.i.d. chi-square distributed random variables with four degrees of freedom. How can we get the joint probability distribution function of the random variables $U=(X-Y)/(X+Y)$, $V=X+Y$?</p>
74,433
[ -0.010443842969834805, -0.026960644870996475, 0.037245139479637146, -0.0055184634402394295, 0.015634741634130478, 0.0382915697991848, 0.0018888079794123769, -0.008235086686909199, 0.050807349383831024, -0.029099659994244576, 0.04944509267807007, 0.047391679137945175, 0.04083229601383209, 0.00286215846426785, 0.0010591994505375624, -0.009866110049188137, -0.03331846371293068, 0.04406435415148735, -0.00960550270974636, -0.03508627787232399, -0.022795414552092552, 0.00645315321162343, 0.022019783034920692, 0.003074449487030506, -0.030555902048945427, 0.05740121379494667, 0.03517421707510948, -0.051473960280418396, -0.0010304278694093227, 0.09536709636449814, -0.02306218072772026, -0.01773800700902939, 0.0007001121994107962, 0.040195539593696594, -0.008886203169822693, -0.01418053824454546, -0.03912809118628502, -0.019743381068110466, -0.02102290466427803, 0.03670093044638634, -0.06708783656358719, 0.022510457783937454, -0.012389923445880413, 0.024218657985329628, -0.0327911376953125, -0.0008111328934319317, 0.020189784467220306, -0.05337012931704521, 0.019069921225309372, -0.055578771978616714, 0.0928712859749794, -0.0011485425056889653, 0.03789451718330383, 0.016376545652747154, 0.005145168863236904, -0.02291588857769966, 0.038927432149648666, 0.0918373093008995, 0.036310989409685135, -0.04532993212342262, -0.008521992713212967, -0.01888769119977951, -0.017202500253915787, -0.018142567947506905, -0.028916608542203903, -0.002043084939941764, -0.009177465923130512, -0.04448608681559563, -0.006143886595964432, -0.017082007601857185, 0.016846416518092155, 0.04398365691304207, 0.05192315950989723, -0.03203905001282692, 0.012598167173564434, -0.002196516143158078, 0.03372134268283844, 0.030641835182905197, 0.009346677921712399, -0.0018253022572025657, -0.004061655141413212, 0.04297169670462608, 0.01357902679592371, 0.0015525100752711296, 0.0005548298940993845, -0.015520166605710983, 0.058711789548397064, -0.009561450220644474, -0.013465515337884426, 0.022015659138560295, -0.02733013406395912, 0.024538466706871986, 0.05691040679812431, 0.014516721479594707, -0.04751727730035782, 0.0320989266037941, -0.03575138747692108, 0.04038286209106445, 0.029334524646401405, -0.0335356630384922, 0.010853047482669353, -0.027394894510507584, -0.009396987035870552, 0.10277049243450165, -0.04778123274445534, -0.010175171308219433, 0.010176606476306915, 0.038286782801151276, 0.0017757073510438204, -0.026689445599913597, -0.058358050882816315, 0.035672008991241455, 0.005628534592688084, 0.014259584248065948, 0.0481107197701931, -0.006494073662906885, 0.008298099972307682, -0.033566851168870926, 0.03069549985229969, 0.05676865577697754, 0.06589832901954651, -0.03244815021753311, 0.008403179235756397, -0.00149233837146312, -0.0075993528589606285, 0.032950352877378464, 0.0027942671440541744, 0.011499224230647087, -0.04958059638738632, 0.023835930973291397, -0.008016828447580338, -0.030392443761229515, 0.01565481536090374, 0.02058994024991989, -0.026037300005555153, 0.01433839462697506, -0.07317977398633957, -0.021960996091365814, 0.028312306851148605, -0.046763624995946884, -0.013659663498401642, -0.09136734157800674, 0.006371907889842987, 0.010789947584271431, 0.06615293771028519, -0.019276762381196022, 0.03299442678689957, -0.0027214379515498877, 0.03869017958641052, 0.016504453495144844, 0.009989701211452484, -0.011856931261718273, -0.0672527477145195, -0.033686839044094086, -0.0006562661146745086, -0.03872651234269142, 0.037030111998319626, 0.009298919700086117, -0.030863670632243156, -0.03997042402625084, 0.04298156127333641, 0.013912774622440338, -0.007796089630573988, 0.004666256718337536, 0.03149870038032532, -0.046116746962070465, 0.05496476590633392, 0.04285417124629021, 0.019665710628032684, 0.020892025902867317, 0.00014370077406056225, 0.024510368704795837, 0.0252928975969553, 0.06308991461992264, 0.04892406985163689, 0.01046453695744276, -0.022306043654680252, -0.0032204510644078255, -0.008175162598490715, 0.02504674158990383, -0.03539709374308586, -0.027878116816282272, -0.03975338488817215, -0.016001081094145775, 0.010774004273116589, 0.030641598626971245, 0.040007077157497406, -0.004138114862143993, 0.04750082269310951, -0.03821222856640816, 0.0053440844640135765, -0.07089714705944061, -0.008764340542256832, 0.03648761287331581, -0.033332087099552155, 0.0017131639178842306, 0.02935653366148472, 0.020196516066789627, -0.009923906996846199, -0.019387157633900642, -0.017416130751371384, 0.017002960667014122, 0.03314948454499245, -0.017240704968571663, -0.023165209218859673, 0.0026291145477443933, 0.06700342148542404, -0.0027678408659994602, 0.06225258857011795, -0.006074309349060059, -0.04336938261985779, 0.011373823508620262, -0.018169820308685303, 0.03267355263233185, -0.016281234100461006, -0.003319257404655218, -0.015120255760848522, 0.00909409485757351, 0.0073115588165819645, 0.021337373182177544, -0.05315379053354263, 0.04804803431034088, 0.0789356380701065, 0.011012434028089046, -0.007787251379340887, 0.025837643072009087, 0.007592812180519104, 0.0164437685161829, -0.011104095727205276, -0.022315800189971924, -0.0481259822845459, 0.0068560815416276455, 0.029627494513988495, 0.03623530641198158, -0.04253628849983215, 0.036689989268779755, 0.0311149712651968, 0.024646997451782227, 0.02631942741572857, 0.01836238242685795, -0.01949596218764782, -0.012825430370867252, 0.01191436406224966, 0.03416598215699196, -0.016257330775260925, -0.002507416997104883, -0.01653621345758438, 0.03415236622095108, -0.019815854728221893, -0.018670620396733284, -0.07789558172225952, 0.051237449049949646, -0.034399766474962234, 0.014790826477110386, -0.021815109997987747, -0.014556239359080791, 0.022543562576174736, -0.000751950079575181, -0.01481984369456768, 0.023627784103155136, -0.00244159041903913, -0.02350948378443718, 0.02671666443347931, -0.014920475892722607, 0.03948833793401718, 0.03234490007162094, -0.04075179249048233, -0.0011009331792593002, 0.03666509687900543, -0.004233002662658691, -0.001496385782957077, -0.02165408618748188, -0.029283344745635986, -0.019583657383918762, 0.017991552129387856, 0.002010633237659931, 0.009896348230540752, 0.034099698066711426, 0.009486943483352661, -0.05747407302260399, 0.03547194227576256, -0.012056384235620499, 0.008850524201989174, -0.008863075636327267, -0.03877933695912361, 0.018050024285912514, -0.05296221375465393, -0.00008689065725775436, 0.000178659800440073, 0.01444081962108612, 0.03566867113113403, -0.01815038174390793, -0.010243263095617294, -0.036322660744190216, 0.018724147230386734, -0.01500021293759346, 0.006866957992315292, -0.04379262030124664, 0.00733376108109951, 0.00947660394012928, 0.005598628893494606, -0.033276885747909546, 0.02474908158183098, -0.03209763020277023, -0.0487414114177227, -0.009947693906724453, 0.0033980279695242643, 0.031419672071933746, -0.0019298979314044118, 0.05339935049414635, 0.014849087223410606, -0.023768311366438866, -0.005230357404798269, -0.06169121712446213, -0.02915489487349987, 0.01271965354681015, -0.00030370353488251567, 0.03564060479402542, 0.05057333782315254, -0.01031991746276617, 0.025379016995429993, 0.032446131110191345, 0.0035037174820899963, -0.0028565360698848963, -0.005418545100837946, -0.01203792542219162, 0.027948103845119476, 0.025400368496775627, 0.0194969791918993, 0.0019856137223541737, 0.05009901151061058, 0.006061972584575415, -0.03905515372753143, 0.08679740130901337, 0.03583681583404541, -0.020643234252929688, -0.009499945677816868, -0.002900464227423072, -0.03104541450738907, 0.032352011650800705, -0.011786126531660557, -0.04187707602977753, -0.000763805175665766, 0.034226253628730774, 0.012334386818110943, 0.008240019902586937, -0.012126867659389973, 0.021509505808353424, -0.01700417697429657, 0.00989270955324173, -0.04101192578673363, 0.05431302636861801, 0.025710703805088997, -0.04069481045007706, 0.0022218329831957817, 0.0053055183961987495, 0.03722323477268219, -0.013663877733051777, 0.020402053371071815, 0.030864370986819267, 0.013501616194844246, 0.00027183443307876587, -0.05020657926797867, -0.05090009421110153, 0.003824919927865267, 0.04073481261730194, -0.022405710071325302, -0.013259281404316425, 0.014496903866529465, 0.030650286003947258, -0.014115256257355213, -0.007510386873036623, -0.005850748624652624, -0.016016732901334763, -0.06086283549666405, -0.00836612842977047, -0.03398031368851662, 0.007105892989784479, 0.029421133920550346, 0.038868021219968796, -0.0029113192576915026, -0.026701467111706734, 0.0019316456746309996, -0.028431981801986694, -0.06191004812717438, 0.008074533194303513, -0.027292227372527122, -0.014245280995965004, -0.022216103971004486, 0.010171848349273205, 0.03372875973582268, -0.035210829228162766, -0.005135857034474611, -0.0053512221202254295, -0.024157147854566574, -0.039726972579956055, 0.014890298247337341, -0.006308449432253838, -0.03423310071229935, -0.01796119660139084, 0.012924174778163433, 0.046917978674173355, -0.02649242989718914, 0.031357161700725555, 0.0341009758412838, 0.010407497175037861, 0.016818927600979805, -0.022151924669742584, 0.017819993197917938, 0.014562142081558704, 0.009156768210232258, -0.036856185644865036, 0.044295862317085266, 0.00730231124907732, 0.010126858949661255, -0.03150414675474167, 0.05733747035264969, 0.046514980494976044, -0.046191975474357605, -0.053503070026636124, -0.060779497027397156, -0.021694788709282875, 0.007142039015889168, 0.041445013135671616, 0.023307960480451584, 0.024659808725118637, 0.042840808629989624, 0.039863310754299164, -0.027503566816449165, 0.011626478284597397, 0.05789119750261307, 0.009039907716214657, -0.011218396946787834, -0.024067649617791176, 0.024408331140875816, -0.007191422861069441, -0.02991408482193947, 0.020163919776678085, -0.0050146374851465225, -0.022700855508446693, 0.0061609018594026566, 0.056288037449121475, 0.0133611299097538, -0.020081764087080956, 0.004773847758769989, 0.009400461800396442, 0.03267112374305725, 0.0039721522480249405, -0.047598809003829956, -0.0003829004999715835, 0.06863530725240707, 0.03128126636147499, 0.047669846564531326, -0.008322910405695438, -0.030143743380904198, 0.01910261996090412, 0.04102800786495209, 0.015211186371743679, -0.022290116176009178, 0.030495528131723404, -0.027052542194724083, -0.012232308275997639, 0.03235241770744324, -0.02986803650856018, 0.037301357835531235, 0.017812581732869148, 0.009680777788162231, 0.01917944848537445, -0.040270622819662094, -0.05233610421419144, 0.02265533059835434, -0.012347525916993618, -0.0042386301793158054, -0.0011076725786551833, -0.035114582628011703, -0.044112592935562134, 0.026298480108380318, 0.04343234747648239, 0.06366855651140213, 0.021328847855329514, -0.038135357201099396, -0.03003774955868721, 0.03294888138771057, -0.012910178862512112, -0.054819781333208084, 0.024600818753242493, 0.004321252927184105, -0.0015535526908934116, 0.050313323736190796, -0.005564878229051828, -0.03910597041249275, 0.016131548210978508, -0.014738398604094982, 0.00394362211227417, 0.04601270705461502, 0.006709659472107887, 0.04916100949048996, 0.03100278042256832, 0.00846114195883274, 0.052905622869729996, 0.0011535943485796452, -0.02705633081495762, -0.06194714084267616, -0.02484915219247341, 0.045500390231609344, -0.03574695438146591, -0.02963457629084587, 0.005994011647999287, 0.009308925829827785, 0.017916681244969368, -0.0028147236444056034, -0.046022798866033554, 0.03451839089393616, -0.04805123433470726, -0.022961469367146492, -0.040576111525297165, 0.01663891039788723, 0.009579362347722054, 0.019378794357180595, 0.020355597138404846, 0.040937650948762894, 0.00985278282314539, -0.006417741533368826, 0.01534625981003046, -0.018149511888623238, -0.01636415533721447, 0.0016238604439422488, -0.019121019169688225, 0.007284626364707947, -0.04530927166342735, -0.018165860325098038, -0.019141333177685738, -0.02899523451924324, 0.04107768088579178, -0.05038181319832802, 0.02464321441948414, 0.01073945127427578, -0.015271111391484737, -0.03760186582803726, 0.030930576846003532, 0.027903437614440918, 0.0503215566277504, -0.035645872354507446, 0.02719162218272686, -0.021787680685520172, -0.007198696956038475, -0.07000833749771118, -0.021415559574961662, -0.0034804767929017544, -0.0004761009768117219, 0.00932553131133318, -0.07415799796581268, 0.005113792605698109, -0.004351610783487558, -0.04421079531311989, -0.031587231904268265, 0.050276078283786774, 0.004477330017834902, 0.0010764505714178085, -0.0378226563334465, 0.002687322674319148, 0.052173443138599396, -0.041122376918792725, 0.010775284841656685, 0.012259467504918575, -0.029126090928912163, 0.01016138307750225, 0.01389007456600666, -0.008707971312105656, -0.035427384078502655, 0.012002265080809593, 0.02356572449207306, -0.03232605755329132, 0.02805926837027073, -0.031138168647885323, -0.00553186796605587, 0.016160940751433372, 0.009733084589242935, -0.024936821311712265, -0.0071665216237306595, 0.01153778936713934, 0.0020056094508618116, -0.002444247715175152, 0.013574954122304916, -0.029306642711162567, -0.004307291936129332, 0.006985949818044901, 0.05339882895350456, -0.029884936287999153, -0.0080110477283597, -0.027385704219341278, 0.04733947291970253, -0.009411055594682693, -0.02709249220788479, -0.012408562004566193, 0.05550703778862953, 0.009406005032360554, -0.011993881314992905, -0.020789891481399536, 0.023292073979973793, 0.0025584937538951635, -0.030177487060427666, -0.002264493377879262, -0.04318617656826973, 0.0021637531463056803, 0.06617828458547592, -0.031417571008205414, 0.08269114047288895, 0.043458230793476105, 0.012432390823960304, 0.01214803010225296, -0.012340732850134373, -0.029715733602643013, 0.00007192790508270264, -0.024665668606758118, 0.03286745771765709, 0.007677897810935974, -0.02646598592400551, 0.03827499598264694, 0.014928433112800121, -0.008718384429812431, 0.054055649787187576, 0.007137067150324583, 0.020812302827835083, 0.0531727559864521, -0.032123032957315445, -0.02402445115149021, 0.0041289180517196655, -0.036888640373945236, 0.014702906832098961, -0.0194223765283823, -0.04795767366886139, 0.045188114047050476, 0.02543427236378193, -0.018028441816568375, -0.052763618528842926, -0.012455843389034271, -0.02809661626815796, -0.021154049783945084, 0.031962327659130096, 0.011585337109863758, -0.015502424910664558, 0.04702142998576164, 0.01373597513884306, 0.000473873718874529, 0.04115213453769684, 0.004105450585484505, -0.08070314675569534, 0.0006972713745199144, 0.014429488219320774, -0.024481240659952164, 0.03149854764342308, 0.0031560759525746107, -0.020262988284230232, -0.00524524599313736, -0.023654019460082054, 0.01036820374429226, 0.008091513998806477, 0.07918474823236465, -0.024685146287083626, 0.06108909845352173, 0.009828655980527401, 0.018560439348220825, 0.0027752171736210585, 0.01960706152021885, 0.0994752049446106, 0.02356600947678089, 0.026469845324754715, -0.05507507175207138, -0.006597429048269987, -0.03159582242369652, -0.038300953805446625, -0.05566267669200897, 0.028685912489891052, 0.020752662792801857, 0.024719327688217163, 0.03874913603067398, 0.03228377550840378, 0.008938224986195564, -0.011275267228484154, 0.05754714086651802, -0.003514277283102274, -0.03695796802639961, -0.025635002180933952, 0.034270331263542175, -0.010602373629808426, 0.01653951406478882, -0.049670763313770294, -0.0015895621618255973, -0.004364804830402136, -0.029941556975245476, -0.07642794400453568, -0.05527625232934952, 0.013382014818489552, -0.022992296144366264, -0.057935960590839386, -0.025003230199217796, 0.05091145634651184, 0.007799902930855751, 0.005318686366081238, 0.023608427494764328, -0.012280466966331005, -0.05238354951143265, 0.024812480434775352, 0.018454406410455704, -0.0049405787140131, 0.007223356980830431, 0.046716634184122086, -0.00875977985560894, -0.044865913689136505, -0.027095021679997444, -0.055408477783203125, 0.0396614670753479, -0.029699627310037613, 0.006236463785171509, -0.02165680192410946, -0.007675303146243095, 0.001892901142127812, -0.03581072390079498, -0.03620108962059021, -0.0004341232997830957, 0.03485952690243721, -0.01666846126317978, -0.008809089660644531, -0.013155978173017502, 0.05599965900182724, 0.00005892514673178084, 0.02406853251159191, 0.018637964501976967, -0.02515057660639286, -0.008012638427317142, 0.009110385552048683, 0.046059656888246536, 0.007994440384209156, -0.03467473387718201, -0.007512558251619339, -0.028298892080783844, -0.010753130540251732, 0.004907837603241205, -0.020743686705827713, 0.0029632074292749166, 0.012103181332349777, 0.012311090715229511, -0.016724850982427597, -0.019266188144683838, -0.07022929936647415, 0.011288606561720371, -0.016430430114269257, 0.022832000628113747, -0.017870215699076653, 0.009048046544194221, 0.029461517930030823, 0.03284067660570145, -0.005918722599744797, -0.028928905725479126, -0.044016558676958084, 0.06356614828109741, 0.0026004554238170385, -0.03453345224261284, -0.033521562814712524, -0.025005504488945007, -0.0013122761156409979, -0.01878088153898716, -0.021738003939390182, 0.055667076259851456, 0.04907738044857979, 0.06365372985601425, -0.010263936594128609, 0.043443161994218826, -0.004870887845754623, 0.0009462500456720591, 0.031270891427993774, -0.05508036911487579, -0.005793670192360878, -0.009583250619471073, 0.03991473838686943, -0.007811418268829584, -0.00932304747402668, -0.01598132774233818, -0.0402529239654541, 0.03025100566446781, -0.03753155842423439, -0.02520296536386013, -0.05511785298585892, -0.01664138399064541, 0.036208439618349075, 0.012063714675605297, 0.03181830048561096, 0.023729532957077026, 0.03977310657501221, -0.02333010733127594, -0.030136091634631157, -0.024741098284721375, 0.003067346988245845, -0.009715166874229908, 0.01470078807324171, 0.013486604206264019, -0.013012639246881008, 0.041477881371974945, -0.00870197918266058, 0.035114046186208725, -0.019190466031432152, 0.030327508226037025, 0.008611401543021202, 0.0000047141897994151805, 0.04039964824914932, -0.04768175631761551, -0.014696215279400349, 0.015119689516723156, 0.006067166570574045, 0.040923986583948135, 0.021804388612508774, 0.005984610412269831, -0.006608754396438599, 0.019816510379314423, -0.04540828615427017, 0.0030970207881182432, 0.006045514717698097, -0.016792092472314835, -0.0026348463725298643, 0.02387017011642456, -0.02113776095211506, -0.009729079902172089, -0.02155526913702488, 0.012912965379655361, 0.01576259918510914, 0.0020721659529954195, 0.020110106095671654, 0.041148003190755844, 0.004145965911448002, 0.05077653005719185, 0.020632993429899216, -0.005822611041367054, 0.05146569013595581, 0.06573488563299179, -0.013430077582597733, 0.013840052299201488, -0.006096447817981243, 0.010644582100212574, -0.09486126154661179, -0.03604669123888016, 0.030686719343066216, 0.019294220954179764, 0.02064615674316883, -0.07572013139724731, 0.024049928411841393, 0.037823617458343506, -0.04549458250403404, 0.013067172840237617, -0.01705053448677063, -0.004609646741300821, -0.03291120380163193, 0.036179788410663605, 0.0016933211591094732, 0.06522666662931442, 0.007973804138600826, 0.0031581728253513575, 0.021065717563033104, 0.021994905546307564, -0.02445017732679844, -0.006628748029470444, -0.01974235102534294, -0.042859744280576706, -0.0015291479649022222, -0.022723758593201637, 0.08102049678564072, -0.023752646520733833, -0.048638708889484406, 0.0499018058180809, 0.01432840432971716, 0.031392354518175125, -0.006542437244206667, 0.006219176109880209, 0.0305026862770319, 0.027707038447260857, 0.021989084780216217, -0.016115525737404823, 0.01110020000487566, -0.013762526214122772, 0.01888999529182911, 0.053738851100206375, -0.05012315884232521, -0.0022989604622125626, 0.03332208842039108, -0.013345329090952873, -0.03966567665338516, 0.05054390802979469, -0.0010947055416181684, -0.044229403138160706, 0.0045990003272891045, -0.02848997339606285, 0.018986709415912628, -0.030291667208075523, 0.05213849991559982, -0.05968929082155228, -0.021321093663573265, -0.00291128340177238, 0.020131578668951988, 0.004113371949642897, 0.007463493384420872, -0.00836576521396637, -0.03679662197828293, -0.016226977109909058, -0.013859189115464687, 0.012203140184283257, -0.06603243947029114, -0.018047938123345375, 0.007955729961395264, -0.024510519579052925, 0.011805306188762188, -0.057804785668849945, -0.04650947079062462, -0.010667404159903526, 0.015617028810083866, 0.03525081276893616, -0.0011229106457903981, 0.011093458160758018, -0.027836903929710388, -0.049414318054914474, 0.013443528674542904, 0.049089785665273666, -0.042522214353084564, 0.014304731972515583, -0.005581542383879423, -0.038211390376091, -0.019011979922652245, 0.05197910964488983, 0.03542521595954895, -0.024667637422680855, 0.02322881855070591, 0.0440262034535408, 0.018424874171614647, -0.04082677885890007, -0.0013174155028536916, -0.04084952920675278, -0.006244100164622068, -0.013095756061375141, -0.014683842658996582, 0.02700023166835308, 0.006357091479003429, -0.010147339664399624, 0.0002511432103347033, -0.014058560132980347, 0.024036750197410583, -0.026106983423233032, 0.01807420887053013, 0.036830753087997437, -0.025434669107198715, 0.037889815866947174, 0.00022193983022589236, 0.006400641985237598, -0.016284290701150894, 0.008830257691442966, -0.041473183780908585, 0.02792484685778618, -0.021361347287893295, -0.035704802721738815, -0.04296126589179039, 0.016078101471066475, 0.009677461348474026, -0.07413428276777267, -0.026959626004099846, 0.0341280922293663, -0.06750962883234024, 0.006963599938899279, 0.04230443388223648, 0.017235180363059044, 0.027029840275645256, 0.029201850295066833, -0.025813549757003784, 0.007686995901167393, -0.00434278417378664, 0.014112145639955997, 0.0015847746981307864, -0.018417369574308395, -0.025488320738077164, -0.04096733033657074, 0.032976098358631134, -0.024912415072321892, 0.04062619432806969, -0.02164454385638237, -0.008575034327805042, 0.001524775056168437, 0.005097249057143927, -0.020423516631126404, -0.009651443921029568, 0.010957562364637852, 0.00826435349881649, -0.042019326239824295, 0.09327135235071182, -0.01768428087234497, 0.0018800584366545081, -0.03571872040629387, -0.0342714823782444, -0.04567943140864372, -0.020643822848796844, 0.03143658861517906, 0.044744305312633514, -0.03183848783373833, -0.012719239108264446, -0.004883601330220699, -0.05096060782670975, 0.041700102388858795, -0.015530538745224476, 0.0006781874690204859, -0.01056897733360529, 0.008149180561304092, 0.00747911399230361, -0.05435282737016678, -0.03235630318522453, -0.022624511271715164, 0.029606841504573822, 0.07842552661895752, 0.03863676264882088, -0.0018789361929520965, -0.006637683138251305, -0.0069393618032336235, 0.07164543867111206, -0.07354792207479477, -0.019300762563943863, -0.0337381474673748, 0.023600241169333458, 0.007667087484151125, -0.014944996684789658 ]
<p>If machine is viewed as function approximation, what class of functions are modeled by a neural network?</p>
74,434
[ -0.0373268760740757, -0.0306660495698452, -0.026770852506160736, -0.01097286120057106, 0.039470426738262177, -0.0017057631630450487, -0.017180215567350388, 0.0027307067066431046, 0.017936278134584427, -0.04117898643016815, 0.0026239806320518255, 0.027889858931303024, 0.0341058075428009, 0.039584334939718246, 0.016472836956381798, 0.005595659837126732, -0.04538208991289139, 0.010482720099389553, 0.008293511345982552, 0.0077682239934802055, 0.03894460201263428, 0.037975504994392395, 0.020876383408904076, 0.00130782974883914, -0.0321127288043499, 0.02541995421051979, -0.002652578055858612, -0.01923055201768875, 0.012228179723024368, 0.05338806286454201, -0.017721593379974365, -0.0025699883699417114, 0.0044609373435378075, 0.06594248861074448, -0.006892164703458548, 0.00949343666434288, -0.016306882724165916, -0.008517904207110405, -0.012320955283939838, 0.0037972647696733475, 0.0023551189806312323, -0.04697876423597336, 0.03261096775531769, 0.004203243646770716, -0.003184379544109106, 0.02838374674320221, -0.023270240053534508, -0.02685362845659256, 0.004232145380228758, -0.05701936408877373, 0.07456030696630478, -0.015746653079986572, 0.0210435651242733, 0.015415842644870281, -0.009157669730484486, -0.0008477961528114974, 0.07471556961536407, 0.07093169540166855, -0.023560911417007446, -0.06143281236290932, -0.011353199370205402, -0.0011300964979454875, 0.008181659504771233, -0.026616539806127548, -0.0360020250082016, 0.04118594527244568, -0.010125940665602684, -0.019816968590021133, 0.005054771900177002, -0.012670831754803658, -0.014613042585551739, 0.032784055918455124, 0.015847232192754745, 0.001108258031308651, 0.01626034639775753, -0.0010913611622527242, 0.016473861411213875, 0.042561646550893784, 0.020395835861563683, 0.008994879201054573, 0.01658761501312256, 0.020788971334695816, 0.019332509487867355, 0.0053990306332707405, 0.014385052025318146, 0.012476247735321522, 0.08045145869255066, -0.010007545351982117, 0.026399293914437294, 0.010984480381011963, -0.021793751046061516, 0.004880988970398903, 0.022347107529640198, -0.04414605721831322, -0.022721057757735252, 0.005886723753064871, 0.012000296264886856, -0.007214645389467478, 0.04550831764936447, -0.04086526483297348, 0.016006221994757652, -0.038983408361673355, -0.00006995442527113482, 0.06828951835632324, -0.005229837726801634, -0.004836096893996, -0.006157419644296169, 0.005372950807213783, -0.010497710667550564, 0.012409032322466373, -0.02035900391638279, 0.01713641919195652, 0.022325918078422546, 0.01820792444050312, 0.05394507944583893, 0.0007627665181644261, 0.002061262959614396, -0.01785976253449917, 0.020589014515280724, 0.08668690174818039, 0.026529723778367043, -0.03838140890002251, 0.04804355651140213, -0.01325887069106102, -0.054071489721536636, 0.00830063782632351, 0.017347410321235657, -0.032589081674814224, -0.028084373101592064, 0.012052372097969055, -0.007648976985365152, -0.06198061630129814, 0.0052773430943489075, 0.0055751800537109375, 0.0522330179810524, -0.01565622165799141, -0.058940231800079346, -0.05133557319641113, 0.030040904879570007, -0.03116822987794876, 0.012783781625330448, -0.039927732199430466, 0.03438156098127365, 0.0620727576315403, 0.046229004859924316, 0.042002346366643906, 0.013727778568863869, 0.022982368245720863, 0.018244093284010887, -0.01765691302716732, -0.014959383755922318, 0.0015935447299852967, 0.007443091832101345, 0.0002688452950678766, -0.00012913542741443962, -0.035673804581165314, 0.02121720276772976, 0.036892421543598175, -0.02940460480749607, -0.029609443619847298, 0.04436422884464264, -0.018834872171282768, -0.02256328985095024, -0.019878149032592773, 0.03213834762573242, -0.03378702700138092, 0.05228527635335922, -0.0020884089171886444, 0.06611005961894989, 0.039266832172870636, -0.022594688460230827, 0.026812700554728508, 0.02608536183834076, 0.015656372532248497, 0.05945189669728279, -0.023705175146460533, -0.08205007016658783, 0.0017267657676711679, 0.03411136940121651, 0.025050221011042595, -0.03454428166151047, -0.003711332567036152, 0.029398668557405472, 0.04413168504834175, -0.006381935440003872, 0.03128636255860329, 0.009302730672061443, -0.04625561088323593, 0.015130414627492428, -0.01084644440561533, -0.0235990472137928, -0.033727556467056274, 0.03102983348071575, -0.039802465587854385, 0.021433355286717415, -0.007284755818545818, 0.0007071803556755185, 0.009516799822449684, -0.012307770550251007, -0.005092774052172899, -0.05515335872769356, -0.017519965767860413, 0.019360221922397614, -0.007213388103991747, 0.020469993352890015, 0.030130304396152496, 0.019404219463467598, -0.029395464807748795, 0.04580066353082657, -0.03316359594464302, -0.040620073676109314, 0.016678079962730408, 0.006176655180752277, 0.012285345233976841, -0.014044142328202724, -0.009902235120534897, 0.026457972824573517, -0.02202765829861164, -0.02968035638332367, 0.05084231123328209, -0.05809267610311508, 0.02244061790406704, 0.03545553982257843, 0.021292051300406456, 0.01919575221836567, -0.0008766077226027846, 0.006151826120913029, 0.01013675332069397, -0.0014479897217825055, -0.012173503637313843, -0.059978365898132324, -0.03255916014313698, 0.012278333306312561, 0.06045946106314659, -0.049701087176799774, 0.03463829308748245, 0.03751860186457634, 0.042451418936252594, 0.008656456135213375, -0.023141009733080864, -0.04700048640370369, 0.003998416941612959, 0.03384165093302727, 0.03352339193224907, 0.025993533432483673, 0.004723946563899517, -0.0008266393560916185, 0.011420797556638718, 0.01376805454492569, -0.010389878414571285, -0.019032888114452362, 0.08219238370656967, 0.009586721658706665, -0.00507970480248332, 0.0014673372497782111, -0.031289953738451004, 0.028382929041981697, -0.02332749404013157, -0.03228458762168884, 0.00383540871553123, -0.00005872280598850921, 0.01562574692070484, 0.014866847544908524, -0.02733515202999115, 0.03950033709406853, 0.009439881891012192, -0.011271235533058643, -0.06191296502947807, 0.05277854576706886, -0.05406339839100838, 0.010818906128406525, -0.034633759409189224, 0.00903284177184105, -0.011586948297917843, 0.0495862253010273, 0.031278252601623535, 0.004121523350477219, 0.011086414568126202, -0.03575332835316658, 0.009801306761801243, -0.0010523459641262889, -0.05041063576936722, 0.019672894850373268, -0.018879255279898643, -0.04165234416723251, 0.014662925153970718, -0.01952129788696766, -0.03794421628117561, 0.030778370797634125, 0.008563256822526455, -0.0031195024494081736, -0.000871412456035614, -0.036974113434553146, -0.052718475461006165, 0.004978745244443417, -0.07057929039001465, 0.0100284144282341, -0.00781763531267643, -0.018123848363757133, 0.006846142932772636, 0.016526969149708748, -0.019210081547498703, -0.002440931275486946, -0.028600923717021942, -0.03148506581783295, -0.02640264667570591, -0.013169805519282818, 0.03457116708159447, -0.03554081916809082, 0.019282832741737366, 0.04721881076693535, -0.04768757522106171, 0.022826150059700012, -0.048350803554058075, -0.05181361734867096, 0.01132744550704956, -0.013932546600699425, -0.003005699021741748, 0.032588839530944824, -0.007209021132439375, 0.07448837161064148, 0.001813617185689509, -0.055715709924697876, -0.008148601278662682, -0.008652360178530216, -0.0008782095974311233, -0.06610056012868881, 0.035723570734262466, 0.026371540501713753, -0.008007959462702274, -0.017911627888679504, 0.02411484718322754, 0.005931307561695576, 0.052612632513046265, -0.01408589631319046, -0.009739642031490803, 0.03456050902605057, -0.009891330264508724, -0.011310833506286144, 0.019574739038944244, 0.0012052293168380857, -0.004225179087370634, 0.07297185808420181, -0.019454224035143852, 0.02039150893688202, 0.020601950585842133, 0.006083627697080374, 0.05255312845110893, -0.00810337532311678, 0.005597034469246864, -0.02799626812338829, 0.04608682543039322, 0.03305572271347046, 0.003864629426971078, -0.017962956801056862, 0.014771893620491028, 0.0483417734503746, -0.03982885181903839, 0.020992537960410118, 0.03548109903931618, 0.01456677820533514, -0.04500092938542366, -0.016664311289787292, -0.021607624366879463, -0.02656129002571106, -0.008453271351754665, -0.01332373358309269, 0.03103061020374298, 0.037231914699077606, 0.03031894750893116, 0.010204026475548744, 0.04925786703824997, -0.004439294338226318, -0.0032668050844222307, -0.051746901124715805, -0.005230841692537069, -0.016193125396966934, 0.04953894019126892, -0.0017232038080692291, 0.024791425094008446, 0.017469212412834167, -0.0016609295271337032, 0.03264743834733963, 0.035492464900016785, -0.09173259884119034, 0.027663394808769226, 0.0042289383709430695, 0.009383718483150005, -0.004819842055439949, -0.02198527567088604, 0.019359299913048744, -0.007385565899312496, -0.01630442403256893, -0.022893249988555908, -0.01583241857588291, -0.05260242521762848, 0.012432890944182873, -0.010533066466450691, -0.03599018231034279, 0.011084710247814655, -0.006882069632411003, 0.01564628817141056, -0.016271425411105156, -0.012041950598359108, 0.04488405957818031, -0.008700624108314514, -0.0023963451385498047, -0.002612991724163294, -0.0017882902175188065, -0.020422322675585747, 0.04439826309680939, 0.024236679077148438, 0.02798815444111824, -0.01990658789873123, 0.010211712680757046, 0.022058192640542984, 0.038006048649549484, 0.06781516969203949, -0.021080998703837395, -0.02828839048743248, -0.07973554730415344, -0.023701056838035583, 0.023879345506429672, 0.06239329278469086, 0.014965367503464222, -0.01561457384377718, 0.0386417992413044, -0.001967653864994645, -0.03825589269399643, 0.0010821353644132614, 0.05629228055477142, 0.015467306599020958, -0.04371345415711403, -0.03308930993080139, -0.015309921465814114, -0.02074308693408966, 0.02474554069340229, 0.04553792625665665, -0.03440457582473755, -0.015327622182667255, 0.012236502952873707, 0.028725523501634598, -0.003704122267663479, -0.041292011737823486, -0.03872004151344299, 0.046262387186288834, 0.007364432327449322, -0.036109644919633865, -0.009069761261343956, -0.009683889336884022, 0.07555891573429108, 0.05323347821831703, -0.009437003172934055, -0.02159052900969982, -0.10659889131784439, 0.007425896357744932, 0.0627528578042984, 0.00263019185513258, -0.02945084497332573, -0.029949774965643883, -0.030569734051823616, -0.020090501755475998, 0.03770788013935089, -0.010709788650274277, 0.028975235298275948, -0.029313193634152412, 0.0022425807546824217, -0.016001567244529724, -0.005420145113021135, 0.010770884342491627, -0.018461769446730614, 0.01447262056171894, 0.03081376850605011, -0.025323793292045593, 0.02055487409234047, -0.059438638389110565, -0.056685756891965866, 0.038168251514434814, 0.06272869557142258, 0.015464773401618004, 0.0048933797515928745, -0.03102237731218338, 0.028320521116256714, -0.022583231329917908, -0.06652360409498215, 0.01947702467441559, 0.027568606659770012, -0.038468632847070694, 0.0018275559414178133, -0.027559027075767517, -0.019675318151712418, 0.040113020688295364, -0.038539037108421326, -0.04178415611386299, -0.009504439309239388, -0.059617847204208374, 0.04899469390511513, 0.02800714410841465, 0.012346597388386726, 0.041763294488191605, 0.007399768568575382, 0.005593924783170223, -0.005449333693832159, -0.027532637119293213, 0.00018628865655045956, -0.02839440293610096, -0.039789922535419464, -0.014732981100678444, -0.0291740782558918, -0.0162514541298151, 0.04186572507023811, 0.009082537144422531, 0.0335022509098053, -0.029854824766516685, -0.017590494826436043, -0.03565928712487221, 0.037478767335414886, -0.012951333075761795, -0.00653777364641428, -0.027059854939579964, 0.0373217947781086, 0.013501964509487152, 0.0054812184534966946, -0.006805900484323502, -0.03942898288369179, 0.022356465458869934, 0.056774236261844635, 0.0035767462104558945, -0.00020571131608448923, -0.027238400653004646, -0.013153284788131714, 0.03217281401157379, -0.026594480499625206, 0.05305700749158859, 0.007650285493582487, -0.012200763449072838, 0.0391152985394001, -0.06853485107421875, -0.022958073765039444, 0.018794039264321327, 0.020639047026634216, 0.005248060449957848, -0.006583294831216335, 0.00922686979174614, 0.011068333871662617, -0.012626622803509235, -0.0653635635972023, -0.042312391102313995, 0.024877335876226425, 0.002365345600992441, -0.03343312069773674, -0.005630491767078638, 0.029854929074645042, -0.011683053337037563, -0.0312851257622242, 0.007551518734544516, 0.0870857909321785, -0.025877634063363075, -0.0007469809497706592, 0.02596491016447544, -0.035847391933202744, 0.06798293441534042, 0.045066576451063156, 0.0016646607546135783, 0.009719396941363811, -0.03242788091301918, 0.003938728012144566, -0.00688320305198431, 0.04746866971254349, -0.03185677528381348, 0.02537585236132145, -0.020943662151694298, -0.008723926730453968, 0.03857002407312393, 0.003401123685762286, 0.03490865230560303, 0.02226119488477707, 0.006715077906847, -0.06039217486977577, -0.01141591090708971, 0.010981820523738861, -0.005737197585403919, 0.028672214597463608, 0.01824512705206871, -0.012984346598386765, -0.008720524609088898, -0.01051380205899477, 0.03757469356060028, -0.010162866674363613, -0.026894643902778625, 0.043426513671875, 0.07373722642660141, -0.026052279397845268, 0.000754152366425842, 0.002484365366399288, -0.020202741026878357, 0.06534899026155472, -0.016542457044124603, 0.01667761243879795, -0.027694351971149445, 0.030540211126208305, -0.03163586184382439, -0.0073311408050358295, -0.050965920090675354, -0.0376119427382946, 0.059305690228939056, -0.009527569636702538, 0.04332229122519493, -0.005515992175787687, 0.008275283500552177, -0.022404607385396957, -0.03652946650981903, -0.005620529875159264, -0.02034362219274044, -0.012798730283975601, 0.04372451826930046, -0.022323139011859894, -0.002665880834683776, 0.02458670549094677, -0.03232615813612938, 0.009729258716106415, 0.021931905299425125, -0.01592937856912613, 0.034287795424461365, 0.011409762315452099, -0.03182896971702576, -0.05961193889379501, 0.0032085187267512083, -0.018016407266259193, 0.009183196350932121, 0.009248382411897182, -0.042612940073013306, 0.06481080502271652, 0.010139989666640759, 0.04567699879407883, -0.046109918504953384, -0.003449501469731331, -0.030700860545039177, -0.012311825528740883, -0.01695329323410988, 0.009793367236852646, 0.012224303558468819, 0.024103781208395958, -0.0013917020987719297, -0.026715289801359177, 0.024394679814577103, 0.01277729868888855, -0.05440138280391693, -0.03149256482720375, -0.02956412546336651, -0.03906682878732681, 0.01343640498816967, 0.015795914456248283, -0.060375358909368515, 0.02172805555164814, -0.00582918431609869, 0.04256559535861015, 0.005915120709687471, 0.038842231035232544, -0.019755715504288673, 0.0327686071395874, 0.0027804530691355467, 0.03354577720165253, 0.008145350962877274, 0.008311566896736622, 0.1236255019903183, 0.07052626460790634, 0.013715570792555809, -0.0919489711523056, 0.02099262736737728, -0.05613044276833534, -0.026712555438280106, -0.006934609264135361, 0.01102462038397789, 0.04121148958802223, -0.008445567451417446, 0.012979790568351746, 0.0006563864299096167, -0.025027310475707054, 0.02593831717967987, 0.05445805564522743, -0.03694935142993927, -0.0401962511241436, -0.0014442737447097898, 0.010830238461494446, 0.012698275037109852, 0.024576401337981224, -0.021644439548254013, -0.006999110337346792, 0.011081423610448837, -0.015527100302278996, -0.013851480558514595, -0.045099057257175446, 0.05214909091591835, -0.026877302676439285, -0.0384991392493248, 0.011727811768651009, 0.007733102887868881, -0.02362672984600067, -0.020776990801095963, 0.020328711718320847, -0.003954548854380846, -0.007962480187416077, 0.008411665447056293, 0.022115418687462807, 0.052815213799476624, -0.01227421872317791, 0.024883821606636047, -0.028227681294083595, -0.05108854919672012, -0.006617742590606213, -0.06507618725299835, 0.013784644193947315, 0.026827439665794373, 0.01979920268058777, 0.020649632439017296, 0.032313164323568344, -0.0026492481119930744, -0.043381448835134506, -0.020503539592027664, 0.01647038571536541, 0.01940974034368992, 0.002320006024092436, -0.054117392748594284, -0.010445496998727322, 0.007942098192870617, -0.005888188257813454, 0.016247134655714035, 0.010448179207742214, -0.013357369229197502, 0.023961741477251053, 0.014872581698000431, 0.041551608592271805, -0.010472201742231846, 0.013579961843788624, 0.014025097712874413, -0.0071116117760539055, 0.00015502858150284737, -0.0023829760029911995, 0.022954348474740982, 0.024514170363545418, 0.01219103392213583, 0.00032679212745279074, 0.01449180580675602, 0.005103000905364752, -0.08535698801279068, 0.027435021474957466, 0.022020557895302773, 0.026996294036507607, -0.03297049552202225, -0.031007075682282448, 0.027471907436847687, 0.043765295296907425, 0.030613726004958153, 0.043722622096538544, -0.026394503191113472, 0.005685098469257355, 0.024338629096746445, -0.04721846431493759, -0.01725115068256855, 0.021279307082295418, -0.04538969695568085, -0.0033553659450262785, -0.030165957286953926, 0.061039164662361145, 0.05623771995306015, -0.005735769402235746, -0.02308637835085392, 0.012663682922720909, -0.014164995402097702, 0.037672579288482666, -0.013677053153514862, -0.054650284349918365, 0.02029017172753811, -0.012753186747431755, 0.03542182967066765, -0.07532931864261627, -0.04216198995709419, -0.027214735746383667, -0.022345492616295815, -0.025020871311426163, 0.0324789434671402, -0.027679000049829483, -0.010178955271840096, 0.0067275878973305225, 0.009482838213443756, -0.03776663914322853, -0.011809282004833221, -0.03917331621050835, -0.009159710258245468, 0.002695587230846286, -0.040222443640232086, 0.013589941896498203, 0.02170095406472683, -0.014795397408306599, -0.016708042472600937, 0.036559976637363434, 0.003570860018953681, -0.004895031917840242, -0.0027810365427285433, -0.008018997497856617, -0.022885097190737724, 0.056060027331113815, -0.02669045515358448, -0.00818533357232809, 0.012542927637696266, -0.05946856364607811, -0.045474741607904434, 0.04162087291479111, -0.04055721312761307, 0.026904931291937828, 0.05277664586901665, -0.003022459801286459, 0.004646039102226496, 0.01651763916015625, -0.03781574219465256, 0.004832574166357517, 0.017125895246863365, -0.004166901111602783, 0.013674244284629822, -0.015195720829069614, -0.0014706398360431194, 0.013887793757021427, -0.003775562858209014, -0.015342017635703087, 0.05050009861588478, 0.01980026625096798, -0.01973709464073181, 0.03470076620578766, 0.0054031978361308575, 0.013892062939703465, -0.01041445229202509, 0.02768450230360031, -0.005233757197856903, -0.00854321289807558, -0.01518280804157257, 0.03382965549826622, 0.017388897016644478, 0.008246781304478645, -0.11394646018743515, -0.01813531294465065, -0.0006267743301577866, 0.013202468864619732, 0.06252244114875793, -0.06210673972964287, 0.0058531491085886955, -0.00826460961252451, -0.0927039384841919, 0.018277956172823906, -0.01773267425596714, -0.00005068616883363575, 0.01812896504998207, -0.0042197080329060555, -0.0070200576446950436, 0.015933630988001823, -0.005949311889708042, 0.0391353964805603, 0.012261001393198967, -0.010720767080783844, -0.008524813689291477, -0.011559944599866867, -0.036550574004650116, 0.033066410571336746, -0.013893438503146172, -0.009697558358311653, 0.04687843844294548, -0.06876010447740555, -0.05190681666135788, 0.03795590251684189, -0.0006113361450843513, 0.028907714411616325, 0.013673259876668453, -0.004149934276938438, 0.03262830153107643, 0.02473510429263115, 0.022994758561253548, -0.06246071308851242, -0.023488713428378105, 0.02698737196624279, 0.002479439601302147, 0.031339142471551895, -0.0023718848824501038, 0.020721791312098503, 0.03038526326417923, -0.01642528548836708, -0.04796351492404938, -0.00038101087557151914, 0.0012184338411316276, -0.041466038674116135, -0.006437979638576508, -0.0038817827589809895, -0.01801905781030655, -0.022157417610287666, 0.015215104445815086, -0.026235442608594894, 0.013909582979977131, 0.008767209947109222, 0.008271027356386185, -0.0359925702214241, 0.0036548394709825516, 0.004969617817550898, -0.05377677083015442, -0.004001867026090622, 0.013358063995838165, -0.034999262541532516, -0.0332394577562809, 0.033974796533584595, 0.04029792547225952, 0.02324948087334633, -0.012702066451311111, -0.07104101777076721, -0.019783461466431618, 0.042400460690259933, -0.026735736057162285, 0.006619699764996767, 0.02932141162455082, -0.05514060705900192, -0.014515872113406658, -0.0687175989151001, 0.04693783074617386, -0.012628131546080112, -0.0063856239430606365, -0.03180452808737755, 0.0067873671650886536, 0.0027821706607937813, -0.0027843881398439407, 0.07185735553503036, -0.0003942676121369004, -0.019275709986686707, -0.01486122328788042, 0.035244446247816086, 0.032828330993652344, -0.025299072265625, 0.018868766725063324, -0.011535374447703362, -0.035657573491334915, -0.020635664463043213, -0.013787670060992241, -0.029460523277521133, 0.04538476839661598, 0.021858422085642815, 0.051134172827005386, -0.006819361355155706, -0.009508163668215275, -0.050469331443309784, 0.02724679559469223, 0.042775049805641174, 0.013066070154309273, 0.06019815057516098, -0.021160874515771866, -0.025368744507431984, 0.016549883410334587, -0.01762082241475582, -0.05260441079735756, -0.007512539159506559, 0.00820638332515955, -0.0032191735226660967, -0.013116840273141861, 0.01539650745689869, 0.04255812615156174, -0.0665675476193428, -0.04299793764948845, 0.05345945060253143, -0.009293776005506516, -0.009226861409842968, 0.04929930344223976, 0.028713423758745193, 0.012461415491998196, 0.002689056098461151, 0.01902863197028637, 0.010052687488496304, 0.012152525596320629, 0.007225692272186279, 0.032474011182785034, 0.023145291954278946, -0.04498642683029175, 0.020297283306717873, 0.009817262180149555, -0.047360196709632874, 0.033946555107831955, 0.005633966531604528, 0.05206780880689621, -0.05321560427546501, -0.02637939155101776, 0.04610365629196167, 0.010718530043959618, -0.004799520596861839, 0.01722501963376999, -0.0208568274974823, 0.09231223911046982, -0.02680831588804722, 0.028229957446455956, -0.051556605845689774, -0.026256976649165154, -0.02252068743109703, -0.008225085213780403, 0.006929272320121527, 0.020947175100445747, 0.007430496159940958, 0.011780323460698128, 0.021556930616497993, 0.022024264559149742, 0.03945488855242729, -0.03856917843222618, -0.004144370090216398, -0.008127020671963692, -0.005472327582538128, -0.047736216336488724, 0.006538544315844774, -0.04245321452617645, 0.02903718315064907, 0.05023781955242157, 0.06988928467035294, 0.040670402348041534, 0.014189538545906544, 0.014355555176734924, -0.02565430849790573, 0.02490895986557007, -0.07338458299636841, 0.012120452709496021, -0.02938045933842659, 0.005515026394277811, 0.0296727754175663, -0.03816039115190506 ]
<p>I have data on about 20000 consumers who were exposed to some form of advertising. The data is in the following form.</p> <pre><code>Cookie_Id Observation_Number Ad_Id Ad_Id_Lookup Placement_Id Placement_Category Placement_Cpi Cookie_Lookup 2 1 325 Standard 3722 News 20 0 3 1 325 Standard 3722 News 20 0 4 1 325 Standard 3719 Weather 8 2 4 2 325 Standard 3719 Weather 8 2 5 1 324 Standard 3718 Weather 8 0 5 2 324 Standard 3718 Weather 8 0 6 1 327 Rich-Media 3716 Travel 20 0 6 2 327 Rich-Media 3716 Travel 20 0 6 3 327 Rich-Media 3716 Travel 20 0 6 4 327 Rich-Media 3716 Travel 20 0 7 1 324 Standard 3718 Weather 8 1 7 2 324 Standard 3718 Weather 8 1 8 1 323 Standard 3717 Weather 8 0 8 2 323 Standard 3717 Weather 8 0 9 1 325 Standard 3719 Weather 8 0 9 2 325 Standard 3719 Weather 8 0 11 1 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 11 2 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 11 3 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 11 4 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 12 1 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 12 2 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 12 3 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 12 4 324 Standard 3713 Travel 12 0 13 1 327 Rich-Media 3723 News 28 0 14 1 325 Standard 3722 News 20 0 15 1 325 Standard 3722 News 20 0 </code></pre> <p>I'm looking to model the data using a linear mixed model, with Ad_Id_Lookup and Placement_Category as input variables and Cookie_Lookup as my output variable (the states 0,1 and 2 correspond to different outcomes, such as whether someone made a purchase).</p> <p>The trouble is that many of the rows are identical to each other, other than the observation number (this ordering is a bit artificial because I don't have time stamps). I want to treat each ad exposure as a new treatment on each individual cookie ID.</p> <p>Can I do this using the nlme package in R? If not, is there another package that can deal with data of this type?</p> <p>Many thanks,</p>
74,435
[ -0.04535869508981705, -0.027733389288187027, 0.0009172548889182508, -0.003152228193357587, 0.01269957609474659, 0.01067254040390253, 0.0037547131069004536, -0.0051431842148303986, 0.04481330141425133, -0.04977695643901825, -0.0002338238264201209, 0.04844775050878525, 0.04678837209939957, 0.015959978103637695, 0.04321207478642464, 0.022997980937361717, 0.03424299508333206, 0.020518958568572998, -0.0014248379739001393, 0.0123439347371459, -0.029015498235821724, 0.01032959669828415, -0.015497765503823757, -0.01625114493072033, -0.037342485040426254, 0.03160693123936653, 0.03606882691383362, -0.001239033997990191, 0.004264375194907188, 0.05683088302612305, -0.03985220938920975, -0.023900171741843224, 0.004011738579720259, 0.017335887998342514, 0.007987922057509422, -0.015258030034601688, -0.030908089131116867, -0.0024936485569924116, -0.02131868153810501, -0.004208824131637812, -0.021644067019224167, 0.01656413823366165, 0.005095049738883972, 0.018799778074026108, 0.001219155383296311, 0.03397122398018837, 0.02546333335340023, -0.003015474881976843, 0.03288305550813675, -0.03527795523405075, 0.08179399371147156, -0.013425873592495918, 0.039431050419807434, 0.027638360857963562, -0.042808789759874344, -0.03179372474551201, 0.05732095614075661, 0.03019040822982788, 0.03475002199411392, -0.03352683410048485, -0.012047214433550835, -0.01286791730672121, 0.03117832913994789, -0.03604240342974663, -0.020102044567465782, -0.005789576563984156, 0.02669367380440235, 0.029941879212856293, -0.004526045173406601, -0.024805493652820587, -0.0015220765490084887, -0.0003503745247144252, 0.047239404171705246, -0.018289633095264435, -0.027664391323924065, -0.03041759505867958, -0.004471306223422289, 0.003497346071526408, 0.020992305129766464, 0.018473569303750992, -0.027513716369867325, 0.01685604453086853, -0.01577085256576538, 0.023605618625879288, 0.010353495366871357, -0.011188691481947899, 0.05489993840456009, -0.048048898577690125, 0.03749076649546623, 0.0474064014852047, -0.0168668981641531, 0.005765409674495459, 0.06960829347372055, 0.05344520881772041, -0.014687685295939445, 0.024771559983491898, 0.017991527915000916, 0.006671321578323841, 0.028260471299290657, 0.00600817147642374, 0.007186494302004576, -0.02330896630883217, -0.027805514633655548, 0.04001788794994354, -0.02370784617960453, -0.006455845665186644, -0.034097835421562195, -0.019609522074460983, -0.008383966982364655, 0.0037457039579749107, -0.009720413014292717, 0.01696121320128441, -0.020328262820839882, -0.015322289429605007, 0.029774989932775497, -0.050468772649765015, -0.041500698775053024, -0.013198740780353546, 0.030421603471040726, 0.07178288698196411, 0.065491683781147, -0.03441561758518219, 0.02758791483938694, -0.04128815978765488, -0.06093506142497063, -0.0023357465397566557, 0.004742739722132683, -0.01466445904225111, -0.049917787313461304, 0.06479986011981964, 0.002600320614874363, -0.044489018619060516, 0.03931837156414986, -0.028261030092835426, 0.01723567768931389, -0.008213023655116558, -0.06331215798854828, -0.03729262948036194, -0.01434232946485281, -0.044207826256752014, -0.005990458186715841, -0.060954853892326355, 0.016403062269091606, -0.014474908821284771, 0.03459746763110161, 0.0038610452320426702, 0.053586602210998535, 0.046412184834480286, 0.0032677899580448866, 0.031529393047094345, -0.029120957478880882, -0.007293615024536848, -0.0032002837397158146, -0.0026216621045023203, -0.03902202099561691, -0.10605993121862411, 0.010822794400155544, 0.0035046252887696028, -0.028585636988282204, 0.04584512487053871, 0.036650869995355606, 0.006622646935284138, -0.017658254131674767, -0.015069367364048958, -0.004856294486671686, -0.023243896663188934, 0.08378302305936813, -0.032002151012420654, 0.030026517808437347, 0.02108711749315262, -0.04452084004878998, 0.004148681182414293, -0.022910768166184425, 0.04241282492876053, 0.03090415894985199, 0.018534153699874878, 0.024847285822033882, -0.009180315770208836, 0.018200427293777466, 0.04792304337024689, -0.04908367246389389, -0.013560016639530659, -0.03207290917634964, -0.012742205522954464, 0.016435811296105385, 0.0386822335422039, -0.02057536132633686, 0.006444361060857773, 0.06996608525514603, -0.044463835656642914, -0.007962203584611416, -0.06243344768881798, -0.029641814529895782, -0.014205478131771088, 0.0013614289928227663, 0.01374067086726427, -0.0004309219657443464, 0.010271572507917881, 0.027010703459382057, 0.0028245027642697096, -0.04204471409320831, -0.0323733314871788, 0.022667787969112396, -0.04504293203353882, -0.02465752512216568, 0.017864765599370003, 0.03757524490356445, -0.05450832098722458, 0.025001177564263344, -0.026020707562565804, -0.006763858254998922, 0.002874238882213831, -0.029148804023861885, 0.017496420070528984, 0.01840991899371147, 0.020026912912726402, 0.035589009523391724, -0.009335702285170555, -0.010469977743923664, 0.06854165345430374, -0.08496899902820587, 0.015998024493455887, 0.075895294547081, -0.006057866383343935, 0.02669055387377739, 0.005706408526748419, 0.036092981696128845, 0.035380613058805466, -0.039750002324581146, -0.031682249158620834, -0.04905285686254501, -0.02266242913901806, 0.03207410126924515, -0.009416796267032623, -0.008687105029821396, 0.018509473651647568, 0.08188299089670181, 0.05892612785100937, 0.02784213423728943, 0.023908963426947594, 0.010016307234764099, -0.009299508295953274, 0.02018520049750805, 0.016183217987418175, 0.011110617779195309, 0.010348125360906124, -0.00570614542812109, 0.004459110088646412, 0.024855202063918114, 0.041182275861501694, -0.008991663344204426, 0.04594607651233673, 0.03445376455783844, 0.00400280486792326, -0.01516206469386816, -0.0017275549471378326, 0.0643700361251831, -0.026409683749079704, 0.005619956646114588, 0.06072511523962021, 0.023288484662771225, -0.02524765394628048, 0.023997921496629715, -0.0014662721659988165, -0.021439839154481888, 0.05058024451136589, -0.018083078786730766, -0.0023028410505503416, 0.0170762799680233, -0.02583931013941765, 0.023375611752271652, -0.0008005012641660869, -0.020197337493300438, -0.04875098168849945, 0.07159807533025742, 0.030649255961179733, -0.0016004190547391772, -0.018247751519083977, -0.0535387247800827, -0.03581682965159416, 0.0007511617732234299, 0.012175461277365685, 0.014929174445569515, 0.013059600256383419, -0.05943012610077858, 0.0019436097936704755, -0.023085681721568108, -0.028145886957645416, 0.05151227116584778, 0.026069477200508118, -0.005183586850762367, 0.014723623171448708, -0.024982072412967682, -0.033400118350982666, -0.022048909217119217, -0.032351505011320114, 0.03436899557709694, -0.03217586874961853, -0.01586979627609253, 0.05305437743663788, 0.04194362834095955, -0.05051838606595993, -0.023491565138101578, -0.07041389495134354, 0.004149532411247492, -0.011803830042481422, 0.0019138329662382603, 0.02249099873006344, 0.0019787675701081753, 0.007151137571781874, 0.03457462042570114, -0.00043755953083746135, 0.032801803201436996, -0.09965717792510986, -0.06470999121665955, 0.0017306150402873755, 0.006793085020035505, -0.033073198050260544, 0.05147511139512062, 0.02342050150036812, 0.07840928435325623, 0.037678010761737823, -0.05000010505318642, -0.03516698628664017, -0.006848873104900122, -0.012585765682160854, -0.03166452422738075, 0.029725462198257446, 0.0025238606613129377, -0.008132390677928925, 0.025533374398946762, -0.008632184006273746, 0.002594682155176997, 0.052505236119031906, 0.01950867474079132, -0.015803221613168716, 0.00157022918574512, 0.032057713717222214, -0.0027178386226296425, 0.02238445170223713, 0.041462309658527374, 0.0000484372467326466, 0.019720885902643204, 0.0008091346826404333, -0.0031629444565624, 0.014468926936388016, -0.021657051518559456, 0.0030382568947970867, -0.010383120737969875, 0.031145736575126648, -0.007771030068397522, 0.020077964290976524, 0.010228793136775494, 0.0006375675438903272, -0.037470247596502304, 0.01789947785437107, 0.0333479605615139, -0.018151098862290382, 0.01810338906943798, 0.059970248490571976, 0.03836885839700699, -0.028513122349977493, 0.015034282580018044, -0.018423717468976974, -0.0012214630842208862, -0.014349321834743023, -0.0532446913421154, -0.008173798210918903, -0.007427265401929617, -0.0016619793605059385, 0.040136802941560745, 0.030829068273305893, -0.042074233293533325, 0.016838477924466133, -0.05187051370739937, -0.006794997490942478, -0.034524764865636826, 0.039880186319351196, 0.014900772832334042, 0.006003423593938351, 0.007925178855657578, -0.03226587548851967, 0.04147951304912567, -0.00839008018374443, -0.08268315345048904, 0.028779780492186546, 0.04167787730693817, 0.024392876774072647, 0.022044431418180466, -0.039285436272621155, 0.03372076898813248, -0.028350695967674255, 0.024202236905694008, 0.01387850008904934, -0.004710569977760315, -0.015527288429439068, 0.0002664407656993717, -0.014188505709171295, -0.02810331992805004, -0.007040548138320446, 0.01890575885772705, 0.007856152020394802, 0.004306192044168711, 0.00222041760571301, 0.021186117082834244, -0.012335565872490406, -0.013071034103631973, -0.03509698063135147, 0.009872707538306713, -0.003515277523547411, 0.027673177421092987, 0.00046447498607449234, 0.006876642350107431, -0.06232776492834091, 0.03768280893564224, 0.001304009580053389, 0.030296165496110916, 0.02537407912313938, -0.007191269192844629, -0.05048295855522156, -0.04963727667927742, -0.0028248934540897608, -0.009627223946154118, -0.005522601772099733, 0.0281424131244421, -0.00353567348793149, 0.06668105721473694, 0.020606162026524544, -0.05480325222015381, 0.014640315435826778, 0.06439311057329178, -0.002116669435054064, -0.0018521043239161372, -0.024838414043188095, 0.01100828405469656, 0.0175479669123888, 0.025289542973041534, 0.021676210686564445, -0.028198113664984703, 0.004409445449709892, 0.029075535014271736, 0.03733034059405327, -0.03518961742520332, -0.03898319602012634, 0.03772798180580139, 0.02522742561995983, 0.0026918586809188128, -0.03774867206811905, -0.052428342401981354, -0.0041677867993712425, 0.04322655126452446, 0.004768490791320801, 0.03201548010110855, 0.007667975500226021, -0.10794589668512344, 0.039951056241989136, 0.020615827292203903, 0.040919315069913864, -0.017921213060617447, -0.02362910285592079, -0.036240171641111374, -0.010089040733873844, 0.014598784036934376, -0.007161131128668785, 0.017366740852594376, -0.027290714904665947, -0.015094256028532982, -0.0017338898032903671, -0.041945844888687134, -0.03189956769347191, 0.04987992346286774, -0.044847529381513596, 0.027161799371242523, -0.0150088956579566, -0.025621900334954262, -0.02291637472808361, 0.041872210800647736, 0.004713124129921198, 0.046703580766916275, -0.04393487423658371, -0.023693280294537544, 0.05275014787912369, 0.008151735179126263, -0.055007223039865494, -0.03342018648982048, 0.024899473413825035, 0.026756666600704193, -0.0018218449549749494, 0.04058222100138664, 0.012800510041415691, -0.015801265835762024, 0.02400677278637886, 0.03446422144770622, -0.017507361248135567, -0.015019895508885384, 0.0048453002236783504, 0.03665171191096306, 0.008352050557732582, 0.031001215800642967, 0.02407953329384327, 0.00786943081766367, -0.00039229373214766383, 0.0076822624541819096, -0.030237779021263123, 0.011066666804254055, -0.01508544571697712, -0.016505209729075432, -0.06495378166437149, -0.008048756048083305, 0.027234556153416634, 0.055753979831933975, 0.007847674190998077, 0.049964625388383865, -0.04224421828985214, -0.030273430049419403, -0.0029238967690616846, 0.0326201505959034, -0.041685670614242554, -0.03411201015114784, -0.010415120050311089, 0.019441042095422745, 0.002870680531486869, -0.0053567527793347836, 0.0027217187453061342, -0.05691327154636383, -0.011904345825314522, 0.00328807788901031, -0.015665328130126, 0.03946232795715332, 0.0022115958854556084, -0.0026931175962090492, -0.005651557818055153, -0.01802317053079605, 0.003984954208135605, 0.015512996353209019, 0.033393628895282745, -0.015794998034834862, -0.060293082147836685, -0.013490603305399418, 0.05242818966507912, -0.02757222205400467, 0.023909159004688263, -0.010158715769648552, 0.030924273654818535, 0.02389833889901638, -0.03664840757846832, -0.09034596383571625, -0.07362178713083267, 0.045733142644166946, 0.0024600860197097063, -0.006722260266542435, -0.038943320512771606, -0.017855562269687653, 0.019455550238490105, -0.0056876540184021, -0.04974702000617981, 0.023089425638318062, -0.013880162499845028, 0.01938534900546074, 0.0038251434452831745, 0.028651077300310135, 0.06972024589776993, 0.026631275191903114, -0.0037551834248006344, 0.015279386192560196, 0.01578841544687748, -0.040944620966911316, -0.009865480475127697, 0.015903333202004433, -0.04331822320818901, -0.016683168709278107, -0.0398976095020771, -0.00025749942869879305, 0.036490749567747116, 0.0069540985859930515, 0.020150721073150635, -0.003516695462167263, 0.0007226707530207932, 0.030601313337683678, -0.05050736293196678, 0.008988402783870697, 0.006616300903260708, -0.028812497854232788, -0.03415285423398018, 0.04413878172636032, -0.02690608985722065, 0.015618744306266308, 0.013138075359165668, -0.05292482674121857, 0.025317955762147903, 0.04269476234912872, 0.050301868468523026, -0.008851015008985996, -0.007156571839004755, -0.005731101147830486, 0.010956942103803158, 0.05429280549287796, -0.01265721581876278, -0.03358985483646393, -0.015119563788175583, -0.006679615471512079, -0.024644706398248672, -0.023773914203047752, -0.010799421928822994, 0.0002544159651733935, 0.04024217650294304, -0.004963872954249382, 0.022718241438269615, 0.054581765085458755, -0.0003860257857013494, -0.017055410891771317, -0.0015767329605296254, -0.023613056167960167, 0.0013363446341827512, 0.001894855871796608, 0.04935311898589134, -0.014106223359704018, -0.012337164022028446, 0.02375641092658043, 0.040255025029182434, 0.04620104283094406, 0.04812795668840408, -0.027171161025762558, 0.012032467871904373, 0.036094874143600464, -0.008836661465466022, -0.03377867117524147, 0.021356020122766495, -0.0448945127427578, -0.008535495959222317, -0.06229318305850029, -0.07572247087955475, 0.0481310598552227, 0.047458767890930176, 0.009256529621779919, -0.0239928737282753, -0.04787334427237511, -0.057655248790979385, 0.03380236029624939, 0.05275120213627815, 0.011011040769517422, 0.020746691152453423, 0.04213755577802658, 0.04854859039187431, -0.021621830761432648, 0.010449348017573357, -0.01625424064695835, -0.07009012997150421, -0.0036070793867111206, -0.022945847362279892, -0.002861038316041231, 0.01496526412665844, -0.023683248087763786, 0.028882216662168503, 0.00981039647012949, -0.06768283247947693, -0.0387067086994648, 0.026573745533823967, 0.030526187270879745, 0.02816973440349102, 0.06450586766004562, 0.012519165873527527, -0.016455521807074547, -0.024856191128492355, -0.011649317108094692, 0.1409214437007904, 0.05425696074962616, 0.045873239636421204, -0.09786427766084671, -0.007678041234612465, 0.0321798175573349, -0.02717423439025879, -0.0331612154841423, 0.008143777027726173, -0.0019503553630784154, 0.023829177021980286, 0.039080020040273666, 0.04999581351876259, 0.023681266233325005, 0.013206345960497856, 0.016398651525378227, -0.01837235875427723, 0.0023536984808743, 0.0196548979729414, -0.008489944972097874, -0.02293686755001545, -0.010392140597105026, -0.05351957306265831, -0.014492897316813469, 0.02829122729599476, 0.0003641828952822834, -0.020963948220014572, 0.008819345384836197, -0.0240144282579422, 0.027070656418800354, -0.019727695733308792, 0.0009607032989151776, -0.017161209136247635, 0.013362450525164604, 0.015216530300676823, 0.011318194679915905, 0.0428440235555172, -0.01626463048160076, 0.02289462834596634, 0.03069150075316429, -0.003258660901337862, -0.03765904903411865, -0.02675638161599636, 0.017115788534283638, -0.004907901398837566, -0.006112565752118826, -0.025722332298755646, 0.05665121600031853, -0.0399315319955349, -0.028943456709384918, 0.02124161645770073, 0.028637032955884933, -0.04594909027218819, -0.03963116183876991, -0.001918681082315743, 0.06760004907846451, -0.029115457087755203, -0.019691381603479385, -0.0169590562582016, -0.042149338871240616, -0.00470445491373539, 0.0013114764587953687, 0.014772622846066952, 0.03114033304154873, -0.02491040900349617, -0.02700379490852356, -0.056794144213199615, 0.08028151094913483, 0.04155956953763962, -0.03229937329888344, 0.010729902423918247, -0.039634350687265396, -0.04404785856604576, -0.022226696833968163, 0.02618078701198101, -0.0021769823506474495, 0.02384522370994091, -0.039002660661935806, 0.009053890593349934, -0.02544662356376648, 0.03263399004936218, 0.014035268686711788, -0.011266839690506458, -0.020039185881614685, -0.0015727971913293004, -0.008495311252772808, 0.030539119616150856, 0.04555429518222809, -0.019952842965722084, 0.001944280695170164, 0.002949137706309557, 0.0639844685792923, 0.003562870202586055, -0.055717527866363525, -0.025414932519197464, -0.0241242628544569, -0.03724156692624092, 0.02507816068828106, -0.03840012103319168, 0.06314053386449814, -0.0063685160130262375, 0.0030038298573344946, -0.010648487135767937, 0.02781299687922001, 0.013999316841363907, 0.008347450755536556, 0.03602563962340355, -0.051804475486278534, 0.025682978332042694, -0.03151150792837143, 0.009250449948012829, -0.003249621018767357, -0.01241032313555479, -0.02252565138041973, -0.017958106473088264, -0.03760877996683121, -0.024096637964248657, -0.012541376054286957, 0.036954350769519806, -0.024591581895947456, -0.020444625988602638, -0.005978748667985201, -0.004520689137279987, -0.03754647076129913, -0.0010468375403434038, -0.00824711937457323, 0.010806574486196041, -0.00821861531585455, 0.0033157917205244303, -0.039589446038007736, -0.03140483424067497, 0.019263215363025665, 0.0028520594350993633, -0.023944631218910217, -0.013064621947705746, 0.026788491755723953, -0.001681978814303875, 0.059743329882621765, -0.01027127355337143, -0.03827248141169548, 0.021820271387696266, -0.023648053407669067, -0.027092302218079567, 0.01695016212761402, -0.012962300330400467, 0.03260432928800583, 0.04244810342788696, 0.01668444275856018, -0.010976544581353664, 0.03696824982762337, 0.007103303913027048, -0.024265771731734276, -0.012012314051389694, -0.02329316921532154, 0.03350800275802612, 0.012012163177132607, 0.013685229234397411, 0.022378360852599144, -0.04868931323289871, 0.030037613585591316, 0.04858645796775818, 0.026660151779651642, 0.011080721393227577, -0.03476841375231743, 0.00017092394409701228, 0.025558125227689743, -0.0027057169936597347, -0.0009671393199823797, 0.021959152072668076, 0.011456442065536976, -0.034956663846969604, 0.012759506702423096, 0.04491275176405907, 0.013488645665347576, -0.06340062618255615, -0.02430999092757702, 0.02171342819929123, 0.01329481229186058, 0.01679568737745285, -0.06606768071651459, 0.026335451751947403, 0.006080722436308861, -0.06021429970860481, -0.010067611001431942, 0.043101392686367035, 0.048817142844200134, -0.023212196305394173, 0.04484860971570015, -0.04946646839380264, -0.0153096504509449, 0.04709327220916748, 0.030784402042627335, 0.00863775983452797, 0.012603316456079483, 0.0287551861256361, -0.04130947217345238, -0.01798642985522747, -0.02267879620194435, 0.03297979384660721, -0.05592766031622887, 0.03164173662662506, -0.051768530160188675, -0.018669340759515762, 0.0343082956969738, -0.04219511151313782, 0.009977196343243122, 0.024703701958060265, 0.0039335633628070354, -0.001524343271739781, 0.05857469141483307, 0.00716650765389204, 0.046644020825624466, -0.012704013846814632, -0.0014249696396291256, 0.025861192494630814, 0.0123685821890831, -0.011374607682228088, -0.0001695440587354824, 0.010222211480140686, 0.034579869359731674, -0.06168685480952263, 0.027753854170441628, 0.0010204928694292903, 0.01182387862354517, -0.036516621708869934, -0.0009308585431426764, 0.029825692996382713, -0.006713680922985077, 0.007848049513995647, -0.05268049240112305, 0.03197971731424332, 0.05108087882399559, -0.010648254305124283, -0.03655431047081947, -0.016635479405522346, 0.007419114466756582, -0.031897783279418945, 0.00045333581510931253, 0.01801948808133602, -0.004411135800182819, -0.04031096026301384, -0.016943687573075294, 0.03132632374763489, -0.007556035183370113, -0.014436394907534122, 0.003624951932579279, -0.06805788725614548, 0.008800549432635307, -0.020038846880197525, 0.017610613256692886, 0.02040480636060238, 0.002541889203712344, 0.05896059423685074, -0.06025094538927078, 0.055377766489982605, 0.019452298060059547, 0.02344663068652153, -0.02066141739487648, 0.001904587261378765, -0.07526866346597672, 0.03574975207448006, 0.04914499446749687, 0.004189802333712578, 0.01705966703593731, 0.0005797499907203019, 0.008019275031983852, 0.005767929367721081, -0.017537731677293777, 0.05716513842344284, 0.015550224110484123, -0.0392947793006897, -0.02554795891046524, 0.03500029817223549, -0.017581837251782417, -0.0003315587528049946, -0.009459011256694794, -0.016936609521508217, -0.028773877769708633, -0.019216738641262054, -0.021466732025146484, -0.0059458720497787, -0.01518442016094923, 0.00952137354761362, -0.0025080284103751183, 0.022190909832715988, 0.018504410982131958, 0.009937683120369911, 0.01411339920014143, -0.031678151339292526, 0.021576745435595512, -0.029801756143569946, -0.03733232244849205, 0.01127823069691658, 0.00009015704563353211, -0.036555588245391846, -0.05644160881638527, 0.024419158697128296, -0.00826976541429758, 0.0009735950734466314, 0.014667017385363579, 0.030427737161517143, 0.03762667626142502, 0.01391672994941473, 0.029874099418520927, -0.004007979761809111, -0.014734539203345776, -0.01694870926439762, 0.013387707062065601, 0.015336716547608376, -0.008567197248339653, -0.020161019638180733, -0.013516979292035103, 0.0009087754879146814, 0.03865068778395653, 0.048039961606264114, -0.022832071408629417, 0.05578354746103287, 0.014886153861880302, 0.022027714177966118, 0.05514824017882347, 0.01705322600901127, -0.0006822535651735961, -0.02648933231830597, -0.013690434396266937, 0.012683207169175148, -0.02937273308634758, 0.04892885312438011, -0.053591810166835785, 0.002959726145491004, -0.032367195934057236, -0.014986799098551273, -0.019293729215860367, 0.034909628331661224, -0.012446400709450245, -0.014607539400458336, -0.012437701225280762, -0.017752019688487053, 0.006086119916290045, -0.01481064222753048, -0.02272738702595234, -0.0380777046084404, -0.012209035456180573, 0.011716052889823914, -0.010516669601202011, -0.0017984149744734168, -0.02567943185567856, 0.0037078242748975754, 0.040137745440006256, 0.008413873612880707, -0.03118068166077137, -0.002322946209460497, 0.03336433693766594, 0.013810496777296066, -0.05852103978395462, -0.05121587589383125, -0.054218046367168427, -0.0018537467112764716, 0.008851009421050549, 0.006775200832635164 ]
<p>I have three ARMA(p,q) models for the variable X and using each model I produce forecasts for 12 months ahead. Note that in all three models the residual is normally distributed.</p> <p>Now if I want to produce an <strong><em>average forecast</em></strong> and a <strong><em>standard deviation</em></strong> for the period $T+12$ using the forecasts from the three ARMA(p,q) models, should I be doing the following:</p> <p>$$ \mu_{avg,T+12} = \frac{\mu_{model1, T+12}+ \mu_{model2, T+12}+\mu_{model3, T+12}}{3} $$</p> <p>$$ \sigma_{avg,T+12} = \sqrt{\sigma^{2}_{model1, T+12} +\sigma^{2}_{model2, T+12}+\sigma^{2}_{model3, T+12} } $$</p> <p>If not, how do I go about it?</p>
18,700
[ -0.0021809942554682493, -0.0067954459227621555, -0.021909469738602638, -0.02666400745511055, 0.02628716267645359, -0.00040641281520947814, -0.011207287199795246, -0.0028734158258885145, 0.010738538578152657, -0.01355737168341875, 0.046312686055898666, 0.018683524802327156, 0.08858824521303177, -0.00026439246721565723, 0.026818839833140373, -0.005495906807482243, 0.013266623951494694, 0.013522832654416561, 0.02155766636133194, -0.0419953279197216, 0.004903754219412804, 0.028219493106007576, -0.01966254599392414, 0.002972343238070607, -0.028699493035674095, 0.052282750606536865, 0.05003507062792778, 0.008220146410167217, 0.0007687067845836282, 0.028740596026182175, 0.00030017521930858493, -0.016736119985580444, 0.019791224971413612, 0.09595305472612381, 0.017457257956266403, 0.016292285174131393, 0.018822401762008667, -0.021517930552363396, -0.005624269135296345, 0.026881564408540726, -0.07855692505836487, 0.019661419093608856, 0.018428167328238487, 0.01019857544451952, -0.04683849960565567, -0.007312423083931208, -0.028364645317196846, -0.033607736229896545, 0.05146444961428642, -0.02344432659447193, 0.06580307334661484, 0.010483582504093647, 0.03253627195954323, 0.051997002214193344, -0.031840406358242035, -0.024775207042694092, 0.04525838792324066, 0.062424302101135254, 0.013542677275836468, -0.028317967429757118, 0.042579226195812225, -0.003210316179320216, -0.003468292998149991, -0.006119968835264444, -0.03595645725727081, 0.008808542974293232, -0.001182312611490488, -0.02670164592564106, 0.028509337455034256, -0.004020983818918467, 0.01912076584994793, 0.010166514664888382, 0.006000920664519072, -0.006172404624521732, 0.017578458413481712, -0.0025385261978954077, -0.002285168506205082, 0.015604736283421516, 0.022106679156422615, 0.017575904726982117, 0.002339194994419813, 0.020723631605505943, 0.03494893014431, 0.047238681465387344, -0.006173581816256046, 0.03845568746328354, 0.0541355162858963, -0.016919303685426712, 0.000818645057734102, 0.03275663033127785, 0.005159732419997454, 0.015423877164721489, 0.024698488414287567, -0.00945819728076458, -0.05329473316669464, 0.06082412600517273, -0.017211366444826126, 0.014537445269525051, 0.011496934108436108, 0.01551580335944891, -0.007497928570955992, -0.04562809690833092, -0.00009813926590140909, 0.04624960198998451, -0.017669089138507843, -0.0032676863484084606, 0.00508896354585886, -0.019168628379702568, -0.02889179065823555, -0.024686036631464958, -0.03285740688443184, 0.00202720845118165, -0.054281510412693024, -0.03204110264778137, 0.005459981504827738, 0.0049752723425626755, -0.033172305673360825, -0.02816145122051239, 0.04190829023718834, 0.052723076194524765, 0.045820172876119614, -0.01361260749399662, 0.01947031170129776, -0.03582748398184776, -0.05840941518545151, 0.02506202459335327, -0.02237088605761528, -0.03151296079158783, -0.08792845159769058, 0.06285887211561203, 0.022752417251467705, -0.03151671215891838, 0.016720207408070564, -0.008693828247487545, 0.023097537457942963, 0.01043650321662426, -0.058114562183618546, -0.05887844040989876, 0.019178621470928192, -0.04956284537911415, 0.02352254092693329, -0.04455568268895149, 0.0062425690703094006, 0.06015239283442497, 0.07986248284578323, 0.0011156173422932625, 0.03697613626718521, 0.019503941759467125, 0.01051316224038601, -0.000011397136404411867, -0.0024100563023239374, -0.033126458525657654, -0.019445674493908882, -0.028327561914920807, -0.02899792231619358, -0.08184146881103516, 0.009283304214477539, 0.008441091515123844, -0.0058949897065758705, 0.010467097163200378, 0.03665166720747948, 0.018025320023298264, 0.007415596395730972, -0.010251396335661411, 0.002644171006977558, -0.03415318951010704, 0.042486757040023804, 0.02872220054268837, -0.02009531296789646, 0.003575113834813237, -0.0031823182944208384, -0.007084185257554054, -0.0024403100833296776, 0.03194151446223259, 0.061354927718639374, -0.021078599616885185, 0.021506449207663536, -0.008241977542638779, -0.013073244132101536, 0.03524525463581085, -0.0371919646859169, -0.005514340475201607, -0.04563640058040619, -0.010363444685935974, 0.01869642361998558, 0.06245723366737366, -0.0022563794627785683, -0.015759238973259926, 0.02771989442408085, -0.04629439488053322, -0.030978960916399956, -0.051302678883075714, 0.0025525575038045645, -0.0371491014957428, -0.023096833378076553, -0.00008404041000176221, -0.015299606136977673, 0.04734397679567337, 0.026683753356337547, -0.0017321124905720353, -0.005505131091922522, -0.00030501990113407373, 0.01840067282319069, -0.029157154262065887, 0.004761025309562683, 0.04903194308280945, 0.04243852570652962, -0.029798338189721107, 0.03159232437610626, -0.04266985133290291, -0.029359346255660057, 0.018872417509555817, -0.06182918697595596, 0.00837665144354105, -0.016691885888576508, -0.026178738102316856, 0.00009447982301935554, -0.021752137690782547, 0.004957820754498243, 0.016483621671795845, -0.0612841434776783, 0.0477413609623909, 0.057519908994436264, -0.01534318644553423, -0.032235968858003616, 0.018675168976187706, 0.008021323010325432, 0.05653635039925575, -0.027393696829676628, 0.0010604538256302476, -0.048275772482156754, -0.0319531224668026, 0.025442199781537056, 0.04834795743227005, -0.03091258741915226, 0.05352279171347618, 0.08634497225284576, -0.006938764359802008, 0.027178388088941574, 0.053313449025154114, 0.018958110362291336, 0.023887451738119125, -0.0014888421865180135, 0.006217263638973236, 0.028004445135593414, 0.0003069874073844403, -0.012060027569532394, -0.0017173446249216795, -0.017190176993608475, 0.012088007293641567, -0.024755312129855156, 0.049043431878089905, -0.003198383143171668, 0.013458232395350933, 0.013471274636685848, -0.03995995596051216, 0.04690980166196823, -0.013795744627714157, -0.0023768781684339046, 0.004186250735074282, 0.0006305720307864249, -0.022043166682124138, 0.026022832840681076, -0.01433995459228754, -0.011721528135240078, 0.019415291026234627, -0.021140944212675095, -0.01110103353857994, 0.0074477470479905605, -0.038176484405994415, -0.01797444187104702, -0.0484866239130497, 0.0019243814749643207, -0.011279497295618057, -0.00930811371654272, 0.042806413024663925, -0.027954313904047012, 0.013626710511744022, -0.01691063866019249, -0.027575377374887466, 0.009127969853579998, -0.002954864641651511, 0.016786973923444748, 0.017942922189831734, -0.0468917079269886, 0.004073301795870066, -0.003023390658199787, -0.04391614347696304, 0.04381423443555832, -0.03692229837179184, -0.017377303913235664, 0.05563955008983612, -0.04877695068717003, -0.04997581988573074, -0.02740667201578617, -0.04526279866695404, 0.02674216963350773, -0.03688770905137062, -0.05691877752542496, 0.051248375326395035, 0.02617708407342434, -0.04407592490315437, -0.0025164384860545397, -0.03767978027462959, -0.0012064774055033922, -0.009552832692861557, 0.018679888918995857, 0.0023949388414621353, -0.006895252503454685, 0.03889409825205803, 0.05639873072504997, -0.04469596594572067, -0.01997304894030094, -0.0837327167391777, -0.024133892729878426, 0.03314724937081337, -0.004537602886557579, 0.041477423161268234, 0.0054213665425777435, -0.023869533091783524, 0.07453741878271103, 0.029648348689079285, -0.0018703071400523186, 0.006561173126101494, 0.01216169260442257, -0.005667063873261213, -0.07944735139608383, -0.011314687319099903, 0.005870366003364325, -0.029583998024463654, 0.05457805469632149, -0.010391741059720516, 0.022345205768942833, 0.04687696695327759, -0.019199294969439507, -0.02871793322265148, 0.0019944608211517334, -0.004105721600353718, -0.002399519318714738, 0.03734974563121796, 0.027422012761235237, 0.029311660677194595, -0.020536303520202637, 0.0006713092443533242, 0.0124911954626441, 0.027377497404813766, -0.013204045593738556, 0.030029969289898872, -0.03061843104660511, 0.004727549850940704, -0.036339011043310165, 0.04460735246539116, 0.001356874592602253, -0.02806519716978073, -0.03923027589917183, 0.01726139336824417, 0.01745220273733139, 0.0016120846848934889, 0.03057103231549263, 0.031173011288046837, 0.04706275835633278, -0.030363693833351135, -0.04536861553788185, -0.01991117373108864, -0.01769047975540161, 0.03925697132945061, -0.030104631558060646, 0.0029741821344941854, 0.03170205280184746, -0.005692949518561363, 0.013324524275958538, -0.007226950954645872, -0.025324802845716476, 0.0006447752821259201, -0.09665483236312866, 0.002440046751871705, -0.026805736124515533, 0.05313106253743172, 0.018786685541272163, 0.057371266186237335, -0.009885893203318119, -0.029838524758815765, 0.020034607499837875, 0.0024628525134176016, -0.038463231176137924, 0.026275185868144035, 0.004734429996460676, -0.034451063722372055, -0.009196672588586807, -0.01729734241962433, -0.0005407606950029731, -0.03304460272192955, 0.00843607448041439, -0.012357097119092941, -0.01680140011012554, -0.028035419061779976, -0.006501182913780212, -0.07349558174610138, -0.002075376221910119, -0.015074815601110458, 0.019863445311784744, 0.04566049575805664, -0.047784846276044846, 0.05094349756836891, 0.024461708962917328, -0.041940029710531235, -0.028981244191527367, -0.032274357974529266, 0.02401542291045189, -0.005646883975714445, 0.040895264595746994, 0.05965805426239967, 0.035152968019247055, -0.032516367733478546, 0.019494077190756798, 0.02021128311753273, 0.025791695341467857, 0.030477603897452354, 0.012538581155240536, -0.01432803738862276, -0.05175089091062546, -0.017119692638516426, 0.036641981452703476, 0.016676971688866615, 0.006017949897795916, -0.025931095704436302, 0.031231438741087914, 0.005402685143053532, -0.03591671586036682, 0.03965859115123749, 0.0717451423406601, -0.018512727692723274, 0.02625103108584881, -0.025881048291921616, 0.011149322614073753, 0.008440337143838406, -0.02079361490905285, 0.025957850739359856, 0.006787039805203676, -0.010613542050123215, -0.016290664672851562, 0.026450809091329575, -0.025527188554406166, -0.03027135692536831, 0.011828634887933731, 0.029437556862831116, 0.054159149527549744, 0.030200805515050888, -0.04909798502922058, 0.008716384880244732, 0.055041633546352386, 0.00531514547765255, 0.038981400430202484, -0.02389022894203663, -0.08714431524276733, 0.027182597666978836, 0.04163210466504097, 0.023075511679053307, -0.014335558749735355, -0.013414510525763035, -0.0571688637137413, -0.03414984047412872, 0.08045699447393417, -0.03147149458527565, 0.029336316511034966, 0.01428310014307499, 0.03035317361354828, 0.0050132377073168755, -0.06540947407484055, -0.0651247426867485, 0.023932939395308495, 0.018184896558523178, 0.037229716777801514, 0.009203421883285046, -0.026380440220236778, -0.021696211770176888, -0.0003133719728793949, -0.011883405968546867, 0.01751020736992359, 0.0031247218139469624, 0.0041392468847334385, -0.005844760686159134, 0.022120853886008263, 0.007476065773516893, -0.056688424199819565, -0.021344467997550964, 0.003890524385496974, -0.02904074266552925, 0.0373806431889534, -0.020157743245363235, -0.006821306888014078, -0.0006961154285818338, 0.020949432626366615, -0.003544087056070566, 0.0058783660642802715, -0.021937934681773186, 0.02852877415716648, 0.027196485549211502, 0.011331279762089252, 0.060183145105838776, 0.022786136716604233, 0.006080823019146919, 0.010830125771462917, -0.03877677768468857, -0.02440347708761692, -0.025688964873552322, -0.03978525847196579, -0.043257441371679306, -0.021836599335074425, -0.01316925510764122, 0.022948341444134712, -0.02127046138048172, 0.04811299219727516, -0.03433448076248169, -0.017184779047966003, -0.009663520380854607, -0.00861393753439188, -0.010218548588454723, -0.02531866356730461, -0.0035704229958355427, -0.00578661635518074, -0.0501345731317997, -0.006007059011608362, 0.0026013324968516827, -0.005952023435384035, -0.0017256392166018486, 0.04466822370886803, -0.04342731460928917, 0.020357126370072365, 0.0031075929291546345, -0.008031363599002361, -0.02135324850678444, -0.006527391728013754, 0.036978937685489655, -0.0199098102748394, 0.07971130311489105, 0.007435728330165148, -0.016014613211154938, 0.009798693470656872, 0.012033076956868172, 0.011098950169980526, 0.03642191365361214, -0.03661240637302399, 0.05876632779836655, -0.0006362090934999287, -0.008303527720272541, -0.06539575010538101, -0.04545474052429199, -0.00008999140845844522, 0.01582684926688671, -0.024115679785609245, -0.004589303396642208, 0.008893672376871109, -0.05097734555602074, -0.0015704346587881446, -0.037596479058265686, 0.032310616225004196, -0.022578315809369087, -0.03851160407066345, 0.022977713495492935, 0.05686557665467262, 0.07661141455173492, 0.01374574564397335, 0.007333073765039444, 0.028568947687745094, -0.0535447932779789, -0.03571486845612526, -0.0033018551766872406, 0.01295862440019846, -0.034101590514183044, -0.0063129304908216, -0.03919559717178345, -0.02492186799645424, 0.06096822768449783, -0.040246523916721344, -0.008021567948162556, 0.03395983576774597, 0.022230355069041252, 0.01610909402370453, -0.03564378246665001, 0.020177993923425674, -0.034931108355522156, 0.004031005315482616, -0.03746054321527481, 0.004748394247144461, -0.024075251072645187, 0.004735260270535946, 0.04814235866069794, 0.03812165930867195, -0.02884201519191265, 0.01366591639816761, 0.06676232814788818, 0.010363040491938591, -0.00033936146064661443, -0.0033691469579935074, 0.031369470059871674, 0.047252364456653595, 0.009306873194873333, 0.021675031632184982, 0.007736187428236008, -0.023411303758621216, 0.006664414890110493, -0.0618787482380867, -0.035752445459365845, 0.026095231994986534, 0.06937122344970703, -0.054380930960178375, 0.027546681463718414, 0.02456533908843994, 0.044171348214149475, -0.0025402759201824665, -0.058158427476882935, -0.009797995910048485, -0.01553143560886383, -0.040845807641744614, 0.10229149460792542, 0.008907132782042027, 0.024127567186951637, -0.0014441617531701922, -0.0015772734768688679, 0.018827352672815323, 0.007672716397792101, -0.008240495808422565, -0.004720612429082394, -0.013657926581799984, 0.009811295196413994, -0.016800563782453537, 0.030385110527276993, -0.04452386498451233, 0.02915000170469284, -0.012603787705302238, 0.02272462472319603, 0.022432269528508186, 0.01606394164264202, -0.018476169556379318, -0.06812923401594162, -0.04200425371527672, -0.034864943474531174, -0.018304914236068726, 0.012070758268237114, -0.011781741864979267, 0.02468106336891651, 0.02066909335553646, 0.05804583802819252, -0.0023457601200789213, 0.0334877073764801, -0.02695721760392189, -0.10372726619243622, -0.025902820751070976, 0.002968854969367385, 0.004057162906974554, 0.042157456278800964, -0.018296971917152405, 0.007229061331599951, 0.030366037040948868, -0.01432769000530243, 0.03821137174963951, 0.005050195846706629, 0.03955185040831566, 0.024324918165802956, 0.08272779732942581, 0.00421556830406189, 0.01626688428223133, 0.0037963029462844133, 0.008100258186459541, 0.11028971523046494, 0.08779250830411911, 0.045764047652482986, -0.038218945264816284, 0.019432691857218742, -0.010848692618310452, -0.009038199670612812, 0.004954405594617128, -0.0007717672269791365, -0.012223527766764164, -0.005118879489600658, 0.024013444781303406, 0.054644662886857986, -0.018620746210217476, -0.025422533974051476, 0.05796286463737488, -0.023398134857416153, -0.01174756046384573, 0.0046816193498671055, 0.03471280634403229, 0.018687333911657333, 0.02364085614681244, -0.04085017740726471, 0.02157551236450672, -0.02861938811838627, -0.015658486634492874, -0.0013095492031425238, -0.015324240550398827, -0.004598251543939114, -0.007313067093491554, -0.008429311215877533, 0.03947894647717476, 0.028016354888677597, 0.03320774435997009, 0.018560213968157768, -0.014344594441354275, -0.005382564850151539, -0.05052138864994049, 0.02413552813231945, 0.03158145397901535, -0.0035108132287859917, -0.013422626070678234, 0.0011607151245698333, 0.01226628478616476, -0.051363781094551086, -0.0344223715364933, -0.01718335598707199, 0.017545832321047783, 0.006188986357301474, -0.01189514808356762, -0.02375292032957077, -0.009377638809382915, 0.034034889191389084, -0.027985649183392525, -0.006749492604285479, 0.002415854949504137, 0.006851722486317158, -0.09219136089086533, -0.0029831521678715944, -0.02173421159386635, 0.019832948222756386, -0.003673045663163066, 0.023351062089204788, -0.0005506120505742729, -0.040187280625104904, -0.027102891355752945, -0.04550991207361221, 0.05492347851395607, -0.018528880551457405, -0.02548990771174431, -0.030252275988459587, 0.0002462129923515022, -0.019767044112086296, 0.0060793678276240826, 0.01624136231839657, 0.0034362003207206726, 0.025455588474869728, 0.0021875854581594467, 0.038721200078725815, 0.0006147075328044593, -0.038759857416152954, 0.02345295622944832, -0.035298168659210205, -0.002562335692346096, -0.02574992924928665, 0.0015192202990874648, 0.012573008425533772, 0.04301430284976959, 0.03549916669726372, -0.0002555192040745169, 0.0011912481859326363, 0.08276500552892685, 0.04607785493135452, -0.0562603659927845, -0.022993512451648712, -0.01332978717982769, -0.04557327926158905, 0.010273230262100697, -0.010813978500664234, 0.07126528024673462, 0.04592232033610344, 0.03654006868600845, -0.03124082088470459, 0.03786605969071388, -0.001419201958924532, -0.00643600570037961, 0.014122179709374905, -0.03007565066218376, 0.02468830533325672, 0.040595222264528275, -0.003212205832824111, -0.021789032965898514, 0.0027602293994277716, -0.023337392136454582, 0.013935105875134468, 0.020198052749037743, -0.006672210991382599, -0.04218866303563118, 0.03201783820986748, -0.01564045436680317, 0.024091508239507675, -0.05602912977337837, 0.018790408968925476, 0.010229524224996567, 0.0018554023699834943, -0.010926096700131893, -0.035349298268556595, -0.05880582705140114, 0.023977959528565407, -0.018212197348475456, -0.021037982776761055, 0.027353396639227867, -0.0012504900805652142, 0.01699412427842617, -0.05639418587088585, -0.01423772145062685, -0.010946578346192837, 0.043282780796289444, -0.02192707546055317, -0.02037883922457695, 0.0337318480014801, -0.02457278035581112, 0.005700613372027874, 0.0020097929518669844, 0.0158818531781435, 0.0554250068962574, 0.015343410894274712, -0.029298443347215652, -0.040614888072013855, -0.02014799229800701, -0.0012136296136304736, 0.03169418126344681, -0.02337000146508217, 0.010747370310127735, 0.04423166438937187, 0.010299820452928543, 0.032619647681713104, 0.001439491636119783, 0.005767427384853363, 0.0037833675742149353, 0.059093084186315536, -0.02161339856684208, 0.0017811619909480214, 0.01961427740752697, 0.03249863162636757, -0.0014727907255291939, -0.0190249253064394, 0.026471760123968124, 0.05186037719249725, 0.013478980399668217, -0.004646411631256342, 0.031174398958683014, -0.0050214920192956924, -0.032634712755680084, -0.06269673258066177, -0.026926474645733833, 0.028284750878810883, -0.017946986481547356, 0.01793370395898819, -0.04897492751479149, 0.025592995807528496, 0.05295887216925621, -0.02521933801472187, -0.02656947635114193, -0.012818502262234688, -0.01035495288670063, -0.019928593188524246, 0.01083245500922203, 0.030236367136240005, 0.03523118421435356, 0.01689603365957737, 0.014279641211032867, -0.008100034669041634, 0.04290520399808884, 0.04003619775176048, -0.038986414670944214, -0.02319011092185974, -0.011478499509394169, 0.009662557393312454, -0.013899287208914757, 0.050262775272130966, -0.06239238381385803, -0.030173785984516144, 0.018684161826968193, -0.015412982553243637, 0.0225331149995327, -0.015092268586158752, -0.013936961069703102, -0.007183331996202469, 0.038290344178676605, 0.0069022634997963905, 0.008934661746025085, 0.017705747857689857, -0.015417784452438354, 0.03844958543777466, 0.031202178448438644, -0.010954532772302628, -0.003155400976538658, -0.010099438019096851, -0.0067036086693406105, -0.06204487010836601, -0.009717845357954502, 0.018037233501672745, -0.04866890236735344, 0.008066444657742977, -0.0010012526763603091, -0.004156344570219517, -0.045782823115587234, 0.012419970706105232, -0.016056934371590614, 0.011385581456124783, 0.03645651414990425, 0.04555515944957733, -0.02912100777029991, -0.008381388150155544, -0.011344799771904945, -0.03896323963999748, 0.021368544548749924, -0.0018777854274958372, 0.0118295568972826, -0.03653440251946449, -0.0203741155564785, 0.025677219033241272, 0.03287515044212341, -0.07512780278921127, -0.016067374497652054, -0.05456549674272537, 0.016072439029812813, -0.031320493668317795, 0.035940658301115036, 0.015299412421882153, 0.00033120770240202546, 0.015583870932459831, -0.07342582195997238, 0.025050338357686996, 0.050903890281915665, -0.025406572967767715, -0.013229738920927048, -0.016860010102391243, -0.06721589714288712, 0.002369480673223734, 0.025264983996748924, 0.0051616099663078785, 0.00477974908426404, 0.03269905969500542, 0.015124411322176456, -0.0010187403531745076, -0.04248705878853798, 0.030763769522309303, -0.00037088774843141437, 0.000919896352570504, -0.04081786796450615, -0.009836998768150806, 0.013684824109077454, 0.00814470648765564, -0.009377211332321167, 0.007811964489519596, 0.03581100329756737, 0.03172844648361206, -0.008475259877741337, 0.012035583145916462, -0.010064312256872654, -0.030935825780034065, 0.04352310299873352, 0.006081298924982548, -0.019350500777363777, 0.050297196954488754, -0.012193579226732254, -0.03249943628907204, 0.014428333379328251, -0.03953114524483681, -0.012308611534535885, -0.006378099322319031, 0.008500713855028152, 0.010540023446083069, -0.05314028263092041, -0.04736325889825821, 0.05292428657412529, -0.018303828313946724, 0.00644272193312645, 0.06219768896698952, 0.023703178390860558, 0.04863208532333374, -0.015584997832775116, 0.015016303397715092, 0.016937026754021645, -0.028960075229406357, -0.015472149476408958, -0.020081130787730217, 0.06337123364210129, 0.023823658004403114, 0.010516328737139702, 0.019261660054326057, -0.0233578123152256, 0.00807814672589302, -0.012614818289875984, 0.05136315897107124, -0.012209352105855942, -0.01611977256834507, 0.0008401129161939025, -0.0030542195308953524, 0.030939754098653793, -0.012214048765599728, 0.0022885133512318134, 0.04682101681828499, -0.051552798599004745, -0.01530801597982645, -0.002652758965268731, 0.003153054043650627, -0.025779206305742264, -0.004305420443415642, -0.021491067484021187, 0.03033953718841076, 0.007778515107929707, 0.0013786384370177984, -0.013273205608129501, -0.005374101456254721, 0.013104094192385674, -0.032397449016571045, 0.001771259238012135, -0.0052975937724113464, -0.010652899742126465, -0.03910580277442932, -0.021888306364417076, -0.036455217748880386, 0.00030985267949290574, 0.056078169494867325, 0.07382730394601822, 0.007694064639508724, -0.037744104862213135, -0.053747374564409256, -0.008216936141252518, 0.01746867410838604, -0.05689389258623123, -0.0005538032273761928, -0.019216077402234077, -0.01833079196512699, 0.03737996518611908, -0.04316959157586098 ]
<p>I'm learning clustering analysis and one book I read says the clustering model should be applied to a disjoint data set to examine the consistency of the model. </p> <p>I think in clustering analysis we don't need to split the data into train and test sets like in supervised learning since without labels there is nothing to "train". </p> <p>So what is the possible meaning of this "consistency"? How is it evaluated? Is this disjoint data set really necessary?</p> <p>Thank you!</p> <p>Edit: There isn't really a broader context. The text talks about how to select optimal number of clusters and then mentions this. I don't think this consistency is about the number of clusters...</p>
166
[ -0.0624542161822319, 0.03021792136132717, -0.002848283154889941, -0.03277760371565819, 0.028520042076706886, 0.011390202678740025, 0.004255720414221287, -0.0007843797211535275, 0.014609506353735924, 0.011955236084759235, 0.04383671283721924, 0.046871501952409744, 0.03725217655301094, -0.016840392723679543, -0.010289453901350498, 0.014431560412049294, 0.009552694857120514, -0.002648815279826522, 0.006406585685908794, 0.010275195352733135, -0.03303159028291702, 0.028801288455724716, 0.029940510168671608, -0.041899506002664566, -0.03820477053523064, 0.04225526377558708, -0.02330864407122135, -0.013211364857852459, 0.041185833513736725, 0.019987329840660095, -0.05834105238318443, -0.0481608621776104, 0.015008244663476944, 0.039042677730321884, 0.02210109867155552, -0.024813279509544373, -0.029091045260429382, -0.03100154548883438, -0.022472912445664406, 0.00636572390794754, -0.04470260441303253, -0.03180178627371788, 0.017665307968854904, 0.041311074048280716, -0.05775487795472145, 0.01632348634302616, -0.002659156220033765, -0.07045657187700272, 0.012658748775720596, -0.017248818650841713, 0.0849306508898735, 0.0006308978772722185, 0.0610184445977211, 0.04099752753973007, 0.020291132852435112, -0.0023410446010529995, 0.06130789592862129, 0.05528262257575989, -0.006053360644727945, -0.03871813043951988, -0.03709249943494797, -0.01913648284971714, 0.02530248649418354, -0.029424680396914482, -0.03465232625603676, 0.06248444318771362, -0.0075522251427173615, -0.013386910781264305, 0.035432543605566025, 0.0023753338027745485, -0.0009627797408029437, 0.015362505801022053, 0.0649055764079094, -0.035158611834049225, 0.005713851191103458, -0.016657186672091484, 0.012629198841750622, 0.022793691605329514, 0.01791437156498432, 0.014246592298150063, 0.0240376815199852, 0.01650206185877323, 0.007003793027251959, 0.039170775562524796, 0.02818003110587597, -0.025758616626262665, 0.07877937704324722, -0.009541365318000317, -0.02124486304819584, 0.009252958931028843, -0.007398695219308138, -0.002112091751769185, 0.028175974264740944, -0.0008542854338884354, -0.025052351877093315, 0.03558773174881935, -0.021880611777305603, 0.0452556312084198, -0.025935539975762367, -0.014603061601519585, -0.0015569989336654544, -0.031001001596450806, 0.009726793505251408, 0.034672051668167114, -0.028597775846719742, -0.04699871316552162, -0.031289517879486084, 0.014169048517942429, -0.019767921417951584, 0.0267692431807518, -0.015300609171390533, 0.015848403796553612, 0.028358258306980133, 0.03160601109266281, 0.04818103089928627, 0.026147542521357536, 0.005509179085493088, 0.018117763102054596, 0.032785315066576004, 0.05788566172122955, 0.04420974850654602, -0.03129704296588898, 0.03963371366262436, -0.019453082233667374, -0.04495746269822121, -0.002106431405991316, 0.01343688927590847, 0.012311556376516819, -0.02175547182559967, 0.03902728855609894, -0.016928527504205704, 0.0010544959222897887, 0.02573622763156891, -0.018685342743992805, 0.03670395538210869, -0.01557424571365118, -0.07103773951530457, -0.02959514409303665, 0.021640872582793236, -0.04241332784295082, 0.024149680510163307, -0.057940468192100525, -0.007620180957019329, -0.004165468271821737, 0.051564089953899384, -0.0262666754424572, 0.045540716499090195, 0.007521715480834246, 0.0017470146995037794, 0.006116049829870462, -0.009896042756736279, -0.013144630938768387, 0.006651853211224079, -0.04678504541516304, -0.02114051766693592, -0.07436766475439072, 0.02292145974934101, 0.03400428220629692, -0.001571353990584612, -0.048589516431093216, -0.012169118970632553, -0.025881599634885788, 0.013351516798138618, 0.0014408623101189733, 0.010923715308308601, 0.01869112439453602, 0.03152012079954147, -0.017475675791502, 0.054949671030044556, 0.03496673330664635, 0.015366535633802414, 0.01049240306019783, 0.030531948432326317, 0.06413274258375168, 0.04585859924554825, 0.01599305309355259, -0.020890744403004646, -0.002018766710534692, 0.044498592615127563, 0.00032194791128858924, -0.0376993753015995, -0.03752961754798889, 0.016901589930057526, 0.03872939199209213, 0.0010406196815893054, 0.03233247622847557, 0.014933714643120766, -0.017833540216088295, 0.027255231514573097, -0.050891220569610596, -0.017470715567469597, -0.06622786074876785, 0.035789549350738525, -0.06004557013511658, 0.003381697228178382, 0.04997776076197624, -0.015293371863663197, -0.019917601719498634, 0.0038295923732221127, -0.02686017006635666, -0.04485241696238518, -0.027874115854501724, 0.00585137726739049, -0.0107350405305624, 0.024889754131436348, 0.030629072338342667, -0.0015142927877604961, 0.008761439472436905, 0.03596416115760803, -0.036554254591464996, -0.06827982515096664, 0.021892139688134193, -0.016092173755168915, -0.012916294857859612, -0.0024799450766295195, -0.0038335449062287807, 0.035964738577604294, 0.008911721408367157, -0.043818678706884384, 0.0334271639585495, -0.04330352693796158, 0.060374774038791656, 0.050429753959178925, -0.012292414903640747, 0.007437657564878464, 0.008578261360526085, 0.0009376604575663805, 0.0291057750582695, -0.01800760067999363, 0.0033040726557374, -0.06174341216683388, -0.0027681898791342974, 0.062435101717710495, 0.015041450969874859, -0.03973718360066414, -0.0038634962402284145, 0.052264243364334106, 0.04907744377851486, -0.023408394306898117, 0.015741679817438126, -0.048938460648059845, 0.004343061707913876, 0.048072122037410736, 0.01644369214773178, 0.021014660596847534, 0.002511231927201152, -0.009334423579275608, 0.005354294087737799, 0.027206135913729668, 0.0026919490192085505, -0.002500600414350629, 0.07798893004655838, -0.031940411776304245, -0.012040753848850727, -0.011781134642660618, -0.0019733174704015255, 0.007539819460362196, -0.020976854488253593, 0.05859055370092392, 0.007874701172113419, 0.012880062684416771, -0.01570245251059532, -0.028192413970828056, -0.011139479465782642, 0.034367844462394714, 0.02581816166639328, -0.018846122547984123, -0.003410486737266183, 0.02584432251751423, -0.05012867972254753, -0.0015118657611310482, -0.005411642603576183, -0.029647689312696457, -0.021372510120272636, 0.023782523348927498, 0.05610552802681923, -0.00028904498321935534, 0.04550345614552498, -0.02103082276880741, -0.009053727611899376, -0.03509432077407837, -0.01934775710105896, 0.0033899592235684395, -0.022531136870384216, -0.021358322352170944, -0.028597259894013405, -0.018969358876347542, 0.010461373254656792, -0.007489419542253017, -0.02333088405430317, -0.03303283452987671, -0.020861292257905006, -0.0044035534374415874, -0.022972913458943367, -0.03562673181295395, -0.02211146615445614, 0.02939659170806408, -0.00905690435320139, -0.032244402915239334, 0.02630528062582016, -0.0030953388195484877, -0.06549712270498276, 0.00027986703207716346, -0.0517343170940876, -0.022902868688106537, -0.02706907130777836, -0.0422072634100914, 0.03235327824950218, -0.030892029404640198, 0.016244949772953987, 0.05575110390782356, -0.044340912252664566, 0.0031505718361586332, -0.0471692830324173, -0.0772276297211647, 0.0013795101549476385, -0.02454426884651184, 0.020698143169283867, 0.004071658011525869, -0.029051102697849274, 0.09818508476018906, 0.02336016483604908, -0.04289396107196808, -0.0018645853269845247, 0.03276928514242172, -0.0432441309094429, -0.0100447041913867, 0.012803259305655956, 0.030649634078145027, 0.037233833223581314, -0.010102148167788982, 0.012545568868517876, 0.05814733728766441, 0.048192642629146576, -0.007881110534071922, 0.008267002180218697, -0.019678443670272827, 0.05554744228720665, -0.004392222501337528, 0.009203501977026463, 0.03711623698472977, -0.051125384867191315, 0.02653142809867859, -0.02109668031334877, 0.028823573142290115, 0.017421966418623924, -0.043991055339574814, 0.03657788410782814, -0.022729838266968727, 0.01922428607940674, -0.021415548399090767, 0.03666277974843979, 0.009160279296338558, -0.0208517424762249, -0.0024165669456124306, 0.02401902712881565, 0.03794168680906296, -0.021129468455910683, -0.055945415049791336, 0.03333041071891785, 0.003081633010879159, -0.05229222774505615, 0.006824463605880737, -0.0005761734209954739, 0.0005775858298875391, -0.0011837573256343603, -0.016978517174720764, -0.012927901931107044, 0.03732897713780403, 0.01413214672356844, 0.021171731874346733, -0.0026359260082244873, -0.06800717860460281, 0.013626215979456902, -0.05841006338596344, 0.024105608463287354, 0.014269314706325531, 0.009265703149139881, 0.0023510705213993788, 0.019805366173386574, 0.0013258776161819696, -0.01359571237117052, -0.007000298239290714, 0.007506192661821842, -0.04944142326712608, -0.0039190505631268024, 0.003644199576228857, -0.0053993109613657, -0.0235393438488245, -0.04877133667469025, 0.030342448502779007, -0.02326681651175022, 0.02098711021244526, 0.011983704753220081, 0.029695693403482437, -0.05638532340526581, 0.013634799048304558, -0.0021328493021428585, 0.008966749534010887, 0.006801592651754618, 0.014107086695730686, 0.050475411117076874, 0.007052099332213402, 0.02197103202342987, 0.006390647497028112, -0.0017453150358051062, -0.04193926230072975, -0.0022782485466450453, 0.028627587482333183, 0.025261154398322105, 0.03360362723469734, -0.010613588616251945, 0.05747329816222191, -0.008507895283401012, -0.0013031305279582739, -0.0014209740329533815, 0.05270697548985481, 0.02968325838446617, -0.03480162099003792, -0.01797938160598278, -0.04686279967427254, -0.042754434049129486, 0.012956657446920872, 0.020083598792552948, 0.004394580144435167, -0.004904147703200579, 0.03385794162750244, 0.028094569221138954, -0.06487742066383362, -0.0060676769353449345, 0.07389593124389648, 0.014165469445288181, -0.03383670374751091, -0.03151223808526993, -0.003083467250689864, -0.005881054792553186, 0.007940798066556454, 0.010740891098976135, -0.005066637881100178, 0.0017316839657723904, 0.028786493465304375, 0.03741699457168579, -0.02945454977452755, -0.04512720927596092, -0.023386765271425247, 0.017349179834127426, 0.02276797778904438, 0.003280768170952797, -0.03199617564678192, -0.0008065361762419343, 0.06697321683168411, 0.03529590740799904, 0.06418556720018387, -0.03558491915464401, -0.07348170876502991, -0.0007406219374388456, 0.0403718501329422, -0.002129186410456896, -0.035749051719903946, 0.024865470826625824, -0.03584856167435646, -0.008366460911929607, 0.014100329019129276, -0.04235793277621269, 0.05064169690012932, -0.018305733799934387, 0.03778452053666115, -0.03058665618300438, -0.018543289974331856, -0.008026812225580215, -0.0061747487634420395, 0.002968943677842617, 0.04198865219950676, 0.0008312264108099043, -0.013168864883482456, -0.04506455361843109, -0.03264613077044487, -0.008128727786242962, 0.05341891944408417, -0.02222861535847187, 0.014288099482655525, -0.017906146124005318, 0.04249781742691994, -0.007702426053583622, -0.08904266357421875, -0.027301449328660965, 0.0019787210039794445, 0.011256247758865356, 0.03017854504287243, -0.022719068452715874, -0.06356646120548248, -0.03216494247317314, 0.01512589305639267, -0.033923324197530746, 0.022672168910503387, -0.03714544326066971, 0.06454095244407654, 0.025102965533733368, -0.0014540493721142411, 0.022057410329580307, -0.006922365631908178, 0.013723117299377918, -0.005480790510773659, -0.05433676019310951, 0.019880549982190132, -0.032841142266988754, -0.01103950198739767, -0.007215465884655714, 0.022244729101657867, -0.044931359589099884, 0.047338467091321945, -0.033410076051950455, 0.0336490124464035, 0.005143677815794945, -0.02538357488811016, 0.009005703963339329, 0.04311104491353035, 0.007965505123138428, -0.013861016370356083, 0.003894720459356904, 0.04176412895321846, -0.006946076638996601, 0.008504733443260193, 0.02202705480158329, -0.0277731791138649, 0.017515456303954124, 0.007007809821516275, -0.018724491819739342, 0.005839596036821604, -0.05353417992591858, -0.041342467069625854, 0.05038239434361458, 0.010840917006134987, 0.024428267031908035, -0.006315417587757111, 0.02736753784120083, 0.004612613003700972, -0.060350850224494934, -0.020065076649188995, 0.024117549881339073, -0.031031286343932152, 0.04122922569513321, -0.05083229020237923, 0.03717106208205223, -0.006434483453631401, -0.00043104312499053776, -0.06261980533599854, -0.030271032825112343, 0.021770857274532318, -0.016967644914984703, -0.049542635679244995, -0.0688113272190094, 0.023383373394608498, 0.0019653888884931803, -0.0401194766163826, -0.020639032125473022, 0.06459742039442062, 0.001423693262040615, -0.04351143166422844, -0.006079529412090778, 0.008690919727087021, 0.06260636448860168, 0.022601811215281487, -0.029782148078083992, 0.017001142725348473, -0.008732104673981667, -0.015899676829576492, 0.020602185279130936, 0.0005283462814986706, -0.028273150324821472, 0.0036914385855197906, -0.07057400792837143, 0.02650163136422634, 0.0425630621612072, -0.04354089871048927, -0.02875322848558426, -0.021780356764793396, -0.024255920201539993, 0.020978638902306557, -0.010194536298513412, -0.018229890614748, -0.023327212780714035, -0.005373558960855007, -0.02092704549431801, 0.007982315495610237, 0.002344593172892928, -0.02564079873263836, 0.0275627002120018, -0.008882463909685612, -0.0021347159054130316, 0.02134568803012371, 0.08161148428916931, 0.019620275124907494, 0.0105463657528162, -0.02798178419470787, -0.04537809640169144, 0.034151725471019745, -0.011814671568572521, 0.01402431633323431, -0.02125689573585987, 0.041389647871255875, -0.027012474834918976, 0.012357999570667744, 0.014413476921617985, 0.010481479577720165, 0.0714900866150856, 0.000432549073593691, 0.051589008420705795, 0.08106712251901627, -0.015135953202843666, 0.0075448364950716496, -0.04211317375302315, 0.014932326041162014, -0.01602877676486969, -0.003164533758535981, 0.06690841913223267, -0.007352724205702543, -0.018844421952962875, 0.049622323364019394, 0.027425382286310196, 0.037500541657209396, 0.015088163316249847, 0.009004073217511177, -0.0023892142344266176, -0.0008688698289915919, -0.03966639190912247, -0.07493540644645691, 0.03282083943486214, -0.01467734482139349, -0.01907118409872055, -0.021052483469247818, -0.007411531172692776, 0.029083268716931343, 0.020887145772576332, 0.04653830826282501, -0.03610264137387276, -0.030562125146389008, -0.0337030366063118, 0.03255624324083328, -0.005070887506008148, -0.013386160135269165, -0.02626049518585205, -0.0033859217073768377, -0.01162903942167759, 0.01938088797032833, 0.019355952739715576, 0.02268180064857006, -0.04282105714082718, -0.06304358690977097, -0.024950044229626656, 0.002417083363980055, 0.010463214479386806, 0.021141767501831055, -0.04222681000828743, -0.010821852833032608, -0.00048525628517381847, 0.035099245607852936, 0.035616081207990646, 0.016835547983646393, -0.026021761819720268, 0.05001768469810486, 0.0140732042491436, 0.0608610175549984, -0.021177738904953003, 0.011380083858966827, 0.10941850394010544, 0.11614251136779785, 0.05879664421081543, -0.05359813570976257, 0.03439656272530556, 0.013787834905087948, -0.02020108327269554, -0.03390039503574371, 0.018821600824594498, 0.05640445649623871, 0.024557968601584435, 0.01908782497048378, 0.03837117925286293, 0.022880317643284798, -0.013428033329546452, 0.06302906572818756, -0.03554453328251839, -0.07576881349086761, 0.021554360166192055, 0.00722584780305624, -0.026148708537220955, -0.03525654599070549, -0.05782002583146095, -0.01132029015570879, 0.05811448022723198, -0.021752487868070602, 0.003356522647663951, -0.021760623902082443, 0.025250576436519623, 0.007838754914700985, 0.01694229245185852, -0.011593698523938656, 0.0009806799935176969, -0.010506471619009972, -0.06317657232284546, -0.018626710399985313, -0.021723134443163872, -0.012503488920629025, 0.011688405647873878, 0.0248862374573946, -0.006424549035727978, -0.025850430130958557, -0.011941413395106792, 0.014030101709067822, -0.029494553804397583, -0.021422840654850006, -0.027126288041472435, 0.05484643206000328, -0.022034553810954094, 0.01940399594604969, 0.009603999555110931, 0.007787773851305246, 0.02239110693335533, -0.028212007135152817, -0.012898027896881104, 0.027236467227339745, 0.024007337167859077, 0.000392869085771963, -0.0444004163146019, -0.06989194452762604, 0.005641875322908163, -0.027770500630140305, 0.02136434055864811, -0.00025441613979637623, -0.0254156943410635, -0.013899020850658417, -0.029379384592175484, 0.06245190650224686, 0.004980744794011116, 0.03566591441631317, -0.03191319853067398, -0.024469900876283646, -0.02807101421058178, -0.02148771658539772, 0.0069276681169867516, 0.017385555431246758, 0.047013573348522186, -0.0027376378420740366, -0.012969269417226315, -0.015152860432863235, -0.028523752465844154, 0.019619522616267204, -0.011621377430856228, -0.039921894669532776, -0.018017534166574478, 0.003665586933493614, 0.020143236964941025, 0.06532340496778488, 0.02155791036784649, 0.03670000284910202, 0.006302032619714737, -0.008115775883197784, -0.004966461565345526, -0.04318508133292198, -0.023234358057379723, 0.0030043201986700296, -0.06642395257949829, 0.028658322989940643, 0.009342534467577934, 0.05682751536369324, 0.011929739266633987, -0.0026428543496876955, -0.0017433754401281476, 0.037928108125925064, 0.0163600891828537, 0.018007615581154823, 0.019535405561327934, -0.059312742203474045, 0.015949796885252, 0.016886042430996895, 0.005983314942568541, -0.07059729844331741, -0.041056714951992035, 0.013289686292409897, -0.01752997189760208, 0.03833264112472534, -0.028797175735235214, -0.04503938555717468, 0.00916158128529787, 0.01008650939911604, 0.03462173417210579, -0.023607416078448296, -0.013983124867081642, -0.04607448726892471, 0.016929691657423973, -0.019704274833202362, -0.010280411690473557, 0.00023801701900083572, -0.019452566280961037, 0.006453945767134428, 0.010115314275026321, 0.04736826568841934, 0.012326851487159729, 0.02061942219734192, 0.0023300473112612963, -0.0042859818786382675, 0.012497368268668652, 0.02992985211312771, -0.019365685060620308, -0.024519890546798706, 0.03635759651660919, -0.03515787422657013, -0.038430504500865936, 0.015976812690496445, -0.011688998900353909, 0.03163501247763634, 0.023647600784897804, 0.008693724870681763, -0.03338906541466713, 0.029481450095772743, -0.031330086290836334, -0.04883267357945442, 0.006235530134290457, 0.019012711942195892, 0.03670084476470947, 0.009542655199766159, -0.00454158429056406, 0.029525471851229668, -0.029061445966362953, 0.012517827562987804, 0.037849318236112595, 0.047830965369939804, -0.04416060447692871, 0.008139516226947308, -0.008153640665113926, 0.03423233702778816, -0.00798390805721283, -0.010876944288611412, 0.008381635881960392, 0.06442572176456451, -0.059106022119522095, 0.03323462978005409, 0.03272349759936333, -0.015577267855405807, -0.05046460032463074, -0.02228034846484661, 0.017641479149460793, 0.03463752567768097, 0.03478575497865677, -0.03839055448770523, -0.008466292172670364, 0.024942709133028984, -0.03336920216679573, 0.04117133095860481, -0.015027884393930435, -0.03331993892788887, -0.0523848719894886, -0.014797110110521317, -0.042755160480737686, 0.04975605010986328, 0.031557727605104446, 0.019246092066168785, 0.01967914029955864, -0.014152717776596546, 0.0036854969803243876, 0.009822356514632702, -0.010099099017679691, 0.009714672341942787, 0.014602962881326675, -0.023600392043590546, 0.04631078615784645, -0.011597718112170696, -0.044002946466207504, 0.028980160132050514, -0.028759019449353218, -0.0013626060681417584, 0.03793219104409218, 0.01467880979180336, -0.025064554065465927, 0.03143429756164551, 0.005294200964272022, -0.008173158392310143, 0.00865539163351059, 0.01675744354724884, 0.03736282140016556, 0.030468156561255455, -0.001346150180324912, -0.009386477991938591, 0.0059987385757267475, -0.034857913851737976, -0.013122990727424622, 0.04669090732932091, -0.02336527593433857, -0.007540848106145859, 0.03196565806865692, 0.011646739207208157, 0.006592317949980497, -0.030395137146115303, -0.013526638969779015, -0.017403312027454376, 0.009772933088243008, 0.02157362550497055, 0.043025899678468704, -0.005944946315139532, 0.03380967304110527, -0.0019401224562898278, -0.05712681636214256, 0.024415038526058197, 0.01971321739256382, -0.022319912910461426, -0.06360989063978195, 0.009530093520879745, -0.008263057097792625, -0.04059065133333206, -0.018224447965621948, -0.005329273175448179, 0.024097464978694916, 0.05206577107310295, -0.02819792740046978, -0.010739844292402267, 0.02693086676299572, -0.06839469820261002, -0.001142997993156314, -0.04468231275677681, 0.07963287085294724, 0.002802003873512149, -0.0018206712557002902, -0.027555635198950768, 0.004066444933414459, -0.052457746118307114, 0.0013302534352988005, 0.053290851414203644, 0.031688619405031204, 0.011182001791894436, -0.023961901664733887, -0.008742832578718662, 0.002816508524119854, -0.019031057134270668, 0.022873958572745323, -0.019137732684612274, -0.014329561963677406, -0.02357502281665802, -0.030777962878346443, -0.010401534847915173, -0.009403107687830925, -0.0023661924060434103, -0.018884485587477684, 0.02762942761182785, 0.006804353091865778, 0.005076893605291843, 0.05677751451730728, 0.01699133962392807, 0.007236493285745382, 0.03970639407634735, -0.0016789279179647565, 0.006663807667791843, 0.032284799963235855, -0.009001274593174458, -0.06807149201631546, 0.00839449092745781, -0.04067214950919151, -0.01462394930422306, 0.02064564637839794, 0.0401245653629303, 0.044450704008340836, -0.026825787499547005, -0.006958568003028631, 0.0038280324079096317, -0.00022763230663258582, 0.0031713813077658415, 0.01783718355000019, 0.04960242286324501, 0.03627908229827881, -0.015474722720682621, 0.017909955233335495, 0.008779381401836872, -0.014550253748893738, 0.02147194929420948, 0.02643672004342079, 0.03776220232248306, 0.05078498646616936, 0.0077166263945400715, 0.01049211248755455, -0.005920769646763802, 0.035310257226228714, -0.030733153223991394, 0.04432910680770874, -0.002798725152388215, 0.008355451747775078, -0.008489875122904778, -0.009514935314655304, 0.014610019512474537, 0.029102370142936707, -0.0031337703112512827, 0.052394602447748184, -0.06451660394668579, 0.014094597660005093, -0.03468010574579239, -0.033289141952991486, -0.02091456763446331, 0.016798729076981544, 0.03109784424304962, 0.0574381984770298, -0.0015390210319310427, 0.014089073985815048, -0.017094001173973083, -0.022008130326867104, 0.032168179750442505, -0.01991947367787361, 0.025986334308981895, -0.01785198226571083, -0.02175683155655861, -0.0281771682202816, 0.0054129911586642265, -0.04569351673126221, -0.00794925820082426, -0.005295964423567057, 0.057474780827760696, 0.02596181631088257, -0.01762530580163002, -0.04424402490258217, -0.02459920383989811, 0.021490223705768585, -0.05368981137871742, -0.02386913076043129, -0.07193722575902939, 0.007696887478232384, -0.014254800975322723, -0.007072974927723408 ]
<p>I believe one major advantage of Bayesian inference is the intuitiveness of interpretation. This is my primary interest. However, it's not completely clear to me when it's OK to make such an interpretation.</p> <p>I make the potentially false assumption that fitting a probability model in the frequentist way is virtually the same as fitting the same model with a flat prior in a Bayesian way. Please nuance or correct that as interest number one (1).</p> <p>And my main interest (2) is if my assumption is true (and if a flat prior happens to be the best prior I could possibly come up with), does the posterior of the model fitted in a frequentist way, but sampled say with an MCMC sampler, allow for me to make a Bayesian type of interpretation? e.g., the probability that an individual described by some particular configuration of $X$ will have an income ($Y$) greater than $100K is 76%.</p> <p>I've read that what makes an analysis Bayesian is that it involves prior information. Is that really the essence? I've also read that you can't make such interpretations as my example about income from frequentist results. Does sampling from the posterior with MCMC methods move me away from frequentist methods sufficiently to make a Bayesian interpretation?</p> <p>I greatly appreciate your direction. Thank you.</p>
74,436
[ -0.005926104728132486, 0.006188519299030304, 0.03226601704955101, -0.03448966518044472, 0.055867452174425125, 0.00945491623133421, 0.012967999093234539, -0.01286813709884882, 0.0302671380341053, -0.06481888145208359, 0.03783849999308586, 0.03647178038954735, 0.050360068678855896, -0.012036371044814587, 0.04082686826586723, 0.00023635868274141103, -0.004687163513153791, -0.028872983530163765, -0.004096745979040861, -0.011567426845431328, 0.010738168843090534, 0.03258233144879341, 0.03513609990477562, 0.0008815318578854203, -0.03813754767179489, 0.0007485014502890408, 0.027487454935908318, -0.002138999756425619, -0.014856277965009212, 0.05142732709646225, -0.010597435757517815, -0.002417695475742221, 0.0030137598514556885, 0.0660092756152153, 0.0017401969525963068, -0.004057826474308968, -0.008128245361149311, 0.002975819166749716, 0.006525044795125723, 0.046506188809871674, -0.028114816173911095, -0.00681206863373518, 0.024817772209644318, 0.04964252561330795, -0.019777728244662285, -0.023534530773758888, 0.019327299669384956, -0.0278299693018198, 0.025920383632183075, -0.038000382483005524, 0.0594833567738533, 0.012814071960747242, 0.02626747637987137, 0.0768406018614769, -0.01044260710477829, -0.02604467235505581, 0.050306376069784164, 0.05587602034211159, -0.022897394374012947, -0.054223597049713135, -0.04167141020298004, -0.017933258786797523, 0.0023491878528147936, -0.019975019618868828, -0.024138258770108223, 0.02671145275235176, -0.031049229204654694, -0.0319744236767292, 0.03093966655433178, -0.014925390481948853, 0.02255801111459732, 0.021169451996684074, 0.03233249858021736, 0.012989263981580734, 0.028288694098591805, -0.032198335975408554, -0.008110467344522476, 0.050206754356622696, 0.027463071048259735, 0.04108164831995964, -0.007606408093124628, -0.029051337391138077, 0.030179107561707497, 0.052620306611061096, -0.008787911385297775, -0.03226272016763687, 0.06621634215116501, -0.02457982487976551, 0.03293024003505707, -0.0194508396089077, -0.016237322241067886, 0.01119760237634182, 0.05374535918235779, -0.026193372905254364, -0.04383017495274544, 0.03992277756333351, -0.017337368801236153, 0.04572923108935356, -0.003056064946576953, -0.032889507710933685, -0.01867540366947651, -0.025247886776924133, 0.02713458053767681, 0.05114782974123955, 0.0033511798828840256, -0.028181472793221474, -0.026471666991710663, 0.041453588753938675, -0.02835148759186268, -0.03755898401141167, -0.026841869577765465, 0.05553881451487541, 0.003354331012815237, 0.006912596523761749, 0.015585782006382942, -0.012714563868939877, 0.03366807848215103, -0.0625602975487709, 0.058070626109838486, 0.05418975651264191, 0.043627895414829254, -0.012646260671317577, 0.04085378721356392, -0.029324635863304138, -0.06002947315573692, -0.008475217968225479, -0.011226951144635677, -0.02371651865541935, 0.004406212829053402, 0.03168763220310211, -0.004788422957062721, -0.018805962055921555, 0.040514297783374786, 0.03953718766570091, -0.003927480895072222, -0.02268550544977188, -0.06921783834695816, -0.0316089503467083, 0.04345717281103134, 0.04871464893221855, -0.009643075987696648, -0.07862549275159836, -0.007195045240223408, 0.04480880871415138, 0.02826433628797531, -0.014065602794289589, 0.0007022620993666351, 0.006129998713731766, 0.037127528339624405, -0.020923592150211334, -0.06904267519712448, -0.032786570489406586, -0.010125584900379181, 0.009026050567626953, -0.008929001167416573, -0.09040015935897827, 0.018154529854655266, -0.0006863365997560322, 0.007485464680939913, -0.0115126958116889, 0.05813554301857948, 0.004880976863205433, -0.05138254538178444, -0.027194330468773842, -0.006521707400679588, -0.009471470490098, 0.06858977675437927, 0.01738005317747593, 0.03484183922410011, 0.038838233798742294, 0.037426821887493134, 0.020456727594137192, 0.010648791678249836, 0.054230887442827225, 0.04823305457830429, -0.03794761374592781, 0.020410669967532158, -0.012486557476222515, 0.04319716617465019, -0.021297715604305267, -0.008150478824973106, -0.00012540970055852085, -0.029939116910099983, -0.03893141448497772, 0.007251457776874304, 0.01779584400355816, 0.015405585058033466, -0.008723215200006962, 0.036437876522541046, -0.04791036993265152, -0.05822955071926117, -0.10467886179685593, -0.017141269519925117, -0.00496317446231842, -0.005497057922184467, 0.0434989407658577, -0.008402196690440178, 0.029022563248872757, -0.052514027804136276, -0.01335141435265541, -0.007914768531918526, -0.0046305241994559765, 0.03296459838747978, -0.02992093376815319, 0.013143211603164673, 0.047073692083358765, 0.02801521122455597, 0.014260956086218357, 0.037516094744205475, -0.0337010882794857, -0.06034332513809204, 0.0090422872453928, -0.00754453195258975, 0.01527355145663023, 0.001766185276210308, -0.019753003492951393, 0.012120279483497143, -0.03680339828133583, -0.05028999596834183, 0.052474312484264374, -0.0629824623465538, 0.08458881825208664, 0.059673745185136795, -0.006619439925998449, -0.019917529076337814, 0.057074204087257385, 0.00377359869889915, -0.006491275504231453, -0.02058376930654049, 0.0013425693614408374, -0.06265567988157272, 0.0004722258308902383, 0.033250149339437485, 0.025481680408120155, -0.02785525657236576, 0.042008910328149796, 0.0314801000058651, 0.03209686651825905, 0.025456374511122704, 0.016134539619088173, -0.012579014524817467, -0.009616215713322163, 0.01280694268643856, -0.004710893612354994, -0.005385332740843296, 0.017324207350611687, 0.025949688628315926, 0.013908600434660912, 0.034062158316373825, -0.025554431602358818, 0.0031118234619498253, 0.042995017021894455, -0.03352528065443039, 0.005217878147959709, 0.0010000839829444885, -0.004374336451292038, 0.016850948333740234, -0.0121865663677454, -0.011387959122657776, -0.009842491708695889, 0.002170389052480459, -0.03140159323811531, -0.029673999175429344, -0.007488993927836418, 0.034447114914655685, 0.03839899227023125, -0.051160167902708054, 0.01938018389046192, 0.020772363990545273, -0.033225592225790024, 0.012577863410115242, -0.039718616753816605, -0.036924250423908234, -0.017758775502443314, 0.04521937668323517, 0.01509582344442606, 0.008657533675432205, -0.010271070525050163, -0.021516015753149986, -0.04142574220895767, 0.017797287553548813, -0.01458948664367199, 0.026042530313134193, -0.016260402277112007, -0.06620099395513535, 0.012489935383200645, -0.037955667823553085, -0.013339298777282238, 0.010944749228656292, -0.01821981742978096, -0.008607025258243084, 0.009006992913782597, 0.008788397535681725, -0.04168865084648132, 0.009123795665800571, -0.01863251067698002, 0.0003822874277830124, -0.020130086690187454, -0.05069058761000633, 0.030345099046826363, 0.006225402466952801, -0.00001819013232307043, 0.007113211322575808, 0.009401011280715466, -0.04599881172180176, -0.022172940894961357, -0.012730101123452187, 0.02557980827987194, 0.029852671548724174, 0.049547228962183, 0.006267719902098179, -0.03746331110596657, 0.012768402695655823, -0.07640139758586884, -0.0695796012878418, 0.03922231122851372, -0.015796849504113197, 0.0007959615904837847, 0.022571595385670662, -0.02427827939391136, 0.03474575653672218, 0.014310288242995739, -0.01892218552529812, -0.0159443411976099, -0.0012896587140858173, -0.012500915676355362, 0.0008789520943537354, -0.006811955012381077, -0.009495963342487812, -0.005146541632711887, 0.02802814543247223, 0.005555499345064163, 0.03247595205903053, 0.031573791056871414, 0.002730620326474309, 0.011779537424445152, 0.03315463662147522, -0.0242515467107296, 0.01003597304224968, -0.006607585586607456, 0.0010034518782049417, -0.005349953193217516, 0.04243883118033409, -0.0025176932103931904, 0.024137435480952263, 0.020154476165771484, -0.039871737360954285, 0.02111487090587616, 0.022208277136087418, 0.0037693188060075045, -0.03344763070344925, 0.01582583785057068, 0.00982501357793808, -0.041120368987321854, 0.02365521714091301, -0.01400073990225792, 0.0006276332424022257, -0.019034884870052338, 0.026673344895243645, 0.0685032308101654, 0.02036229521036148, -0.021892614662647247, -0.027671780437231064, -0.006516616325825453, -0.020325059071183205, 0.01342078298330307, -0.007178139872848988, 0.014762054197490215, 0.01538551039993763, 0.04654470458626747, 0.037281379103660583, -0.02933593839406967, -0.05546896532177925, 0.02525707334280014, -0.0701339840888977, -0.014651943929493427, -0.01819174736738205, 0.0383012518286705, -0.00285570090636611, 0.016911087557673454, 0.015592791140079498, 0.009484217502176762, -0.005612851586192846, 0.010910650715231895, -0.04686526209115982, -0.0107559934258461, -0.03146873041987419, 0.03643135353922844, -0.03669885918498039, -0.03237452730536461, 0.04692103713750839, -0.023463016375899315, -0.009598285891115665, -0.06119146943092346, 0.01720409281551838, -0.04444875940680504, 0.009370778687298298, -0.04420984536409378, -0.032833922654390335, 0.02481684274971485, -0.00723266089335084, 0.027630042284727097, 0.008157330565154552, 0.02785332500934601, 0.03877702355384827, 0.0001909996208269149, -0.011867786757647991, -0.0030322144739329815, 0.024996470659971237, 0.01007870864123106, -0.0025144307874143124, 0.03973476588726044, 0.004885739181190729, -0.026935448870062828, 0.04749644547700882, 0.0014547703322023153, 0.08076353371143341, 0.024751286953687668, -0.054022155702114105, 0.004210716113448143, -0.043357666581869125, -0.02315332181751728, 0.006016838364303112, 0.0370291993021965, -0.005718758795410395, -0.005839732475578785, 0.07110265642404556, 0.011781137436628342, -0.04335653781890869, 0.05505719035863876, 0.038240525871515274, 0.01997804082930088, -0.020285604521632195, -0.04310379922389984, 0.002358176978304982, -0.03350286930799484, 0.00776295829564333, 0.022506510838866234, -0.015403402037918568, -0.005537801422178745, 0.006429303903132677, 0.011130567640066147, -0.0491274856030941, -0.024180414155125618, 0.013467583805322647, 0.025105029344558716, 0.052155494689941406, 0.029339391738176346, -0.027107924222946167, 0.03267050161957741, 0.035758160054683685, 0.014735549688339233, 0.02006199210882187, 0.03104688972234726, -0.07491645961999893, -0.014317058026790619, 0.0436478815972805, 0.03240194916725159, -0.04988798871636391, 0.03207813575863838, -0.04772390052676201, 0.007583813741803169, 0.05246412009000778, -0.01843942329287529, -0.010637334547936916, -0.02104797028005123, 0.011107056401669979, -0.0036590362433344126, -0.015474976971745491, -0.056115999817848206, -0.019044190645217896, -0.012649514712393284, 0.04249168559908867, -0.02539750188589096, -0.01138230785727501, -0.055994611233472824, 0.023044772446155548, -0.0326162688434124, 0.02410106547176838, -0.005062179174274206, -0.036222878843545914, -0.026650942862033844, 0.0057065729051828384, 0.003435711842030287, -0.07141275703907013, 0.02627270296216011, 0.0032498259097337723, -0.02117343433201313, 0.020476676523685455, 0.008975855074822903, -0.047120071947574615, 0.029761122539639473, -0.021173622459173203, -0.040036946535110474, 0.004953583236783743, -0.035209428519010544, 0.05898291990160942, 0.0001414393336744979, 0.017723098397254944, 0.05547087639570236, 0.012151212431490421, -0.005538046360015869, 0.004390235990285873, -0.03887906298041344, 0.021409515291452408, -0.0389607772231102, -0.00008894619531929493, -0.04793570563197136, -0.02885904721915722, -0.00874838326126337, 0.02068808674812317, -0.0006290861638262868, 0.03837635740637779, -0.003766333218663931, -0.022739268839359283, 0.01343526877462864, 0.04169727861881256, 0.039890605956315994, 0.0056980871595442295, -0.05770306661725044, 0.00253791525028646, -0.002890794537961483, -0.01324696745723486, 0.013573147356510162, -0.00573687395080924, 0.0033405425492674112, -0.013895777985453606, -0.01300561148673296, 0.029877014458179474, -0.0161200650036335, 0.007909118197858334, 0.03049839474260807, -0.03023860976099968, 0.04492277652025223, 0.018674040213227272, 0.04444713145494461, -0.017471330240368843, -0.04689144343137741, -0.019219448789954185, 0.011363128200173378, 0.007250202354043722, 0.02323293313384056, -0.02799995057284832, 0.04282773286104202, -0.017153959721326828, -0.00013431601109914482, -0.06523396074771881, -0.05230814591050148, -0.006815791595727205, 0.015822606161236763, -0.026343941688537598, -0.020766157656908035, 0.049824971705675125, 0.014427438378334045, -0.01222904771566391, -0.00003793124415096827, 0.051147133111953735, -0.034589625895023346, -0.011773232370615005, 0.0034128467086702585, 0.026494314894080162, 0.08345048874616623, -0.03745844215154648, -0.006240879185497761, 0.0140297319740057, -0.024653015658259392, -0.010701690800487995, 0.013989148661494255, 0.005695907399058342, -0.033117033541202545, -0.00802637729793787, -0.03225456178188324, -0.004659089259803295, 0.04650888964533806, -0.021982509642839432, -0.00715018343180418, 0.01518764067441225, -0.01279975101351738, 0.013871632516384125, 0.012403598986566067, -0.023885026574134827, -0.009331731125712395, 0.003395290346816182, -0.022599607706069946, -0.002217822941020131, 0.03545054420828819, -0.01940857246518135, 0.05610121786594391, -0.014117718674242496, -0.029758814722299576, 0.017950717359781265, 0.03922194615006447, -0.021602842956781387, 0.0335753932595253, -0.00006771717016818002, -0.002749528270214796, 0.03767547011375427, 0.012068603187799454, -0.011292833834886551, 0.016624821349978447, -0.007266542408615351, -0.03320273756980896, -0.04749860614538193, -0.06230472773313522, -0.006970901042222977, 0.05728112533688545, 0.013788847252726555, 0.05993671715259552, 0.01069285161793232, -0.007937140762805939, 0.030312340706586838, -0.020367467775940895, -0.015189235098659992, -0.025754190981388092, 0.012995337136089802, 0.016856076195836067, -0.04540206119418144, 0.023387417197227478, 0.04804856330156326, 0.0011351685971021652, -0.007015797775238752, 0.01828831620514393, 0.01638793759047985, 0.03212382644414902, 0.05229388549923897, -0.020709503442049026, -0.07747258991003036, 0.03808141499757767, -0.03812691569328308, 0.0006654015160165727, -0.04881182312965393, -0.07134813815355301, 0.041105955839157104, 0.05034659802913666, 0.008718782104551792, -0.04743293300271034, -0.00878979917615652, -0.025130782276391983, 0.014377185143530369, 0.02568911574780941, 0.03791166841983795, 0.03654808551073074, -0.01835225522518158, 0.03933979570865631, -0.03783506900072098, 0.02945789135992527, 0.0014149497728794813, -0.062208566814661026, -0.05382918193936348, -0.005170764867216349, -0.0016026856610551476, 0.01697406731545925, 0.008043989539146423, -0.004706047009676695, 0.017017357051372528, -0.0628543272614479, -0.0009661427466198802, 0.03159495070576668, 0.013207487761974335, -0.030286017805337906, 0.06936480849981308, -0.029013512656092644, 0.02711879462003708, 0.009218567982316017, -0.014679335057735443, 0.11567700654268265, 0.07061528414487839, 0.011494915001094341, -0.0805101990699768, 0.04263107851147652, -0.02180778607726097, -0.01079649105668068, -0.02416273020207882, 0.02524898201227188, 0.008539093658328056, -0.006845112424343824, 0.010932141914963722, 0.0410316176712513, 0.009791366755962372, 0.01803678087890148, 0.062156546860933304, -0.047029633074998856, -0.0037571797147393227, 0.011369566433131695, 0.0016294022789224982, -0.049088526517152786, -0.015684908255934715, -0.04481231048703194, 0.020753106102347374, -0.024848034605383873, -0.008780292235314846, -0.01979081518948078, -0.015926411375403404, -0.038232266902923584, 0.018295209854841232, 0.004395569674670696, -0.03827691078186035, 0.012086957693099976, -0.04311664402484894, -0.00004068503403686918, -0.028711793944239616, 0.00508282333612442, -0.03080987185239792, -0.010256377048790455, 0.04516083374619484, -0.03466174751520157, 0.011008748784661293, 0.007502341642975807, 0.02880227379500866, -0.03310982137918472, -0.008048931136727333, -0.03508546203374863, 0.029979322105646133, -0.0014992512296885252, -0.014233832247555256, -0.037286434322595596, -0.0014722292544320226, 0.008989138528704643, -0.04570988193154335, 0.00034153260639868677, 0.03983425721526146, 0.02594371885061264, -0.017263418063521385, -0.03554680198431015, 0.01251317374408245, 0.015217829495668411, -0.0002761192445177585, 0.015907516703009605, 0.024739880114793777, -0.028111975640058517, -0.03549766540527344, -0.015251701697707176, 0.04793097451329231, 0.015436398796737194, -0.02579067461192608, -0.004157290793955326, -0.003785870736464858, -0.0763029232621193, -0.014372692443430424, -0.016984865069389343, -0.007552332244813442, 0.019757963716983795, -0.020129825919866562, 0.004307760391384363, 0.015771428123116493, -0.009876949712634087, 0.008192007429897785, -0.05415092781186104, 0.002602001652121544, -0.030785107985138893, 0.04146919399499893, 0.028293242678046227, 0.02674229070544243, 0.03858928009867668, 0.031089715659618378, -0.0186820887029171, 0.05045564845204353, 0.005308411084115505, -0.04160447046160698, -0.020610816776752472, -0.012102704495191574, -0.058000702410936356, -0.00940741691738367, 0.0022091332357376814, 0.04231373220682144, 0.033584628254175186, 0.020984932780265808, -0.016851870343089104, 0.012486990541219711, -0.015339224599301815, 0.017732417210936546, -0.0229515228420496, -0.0678410455584526, 0.017833132296800613, 0.010980078019201756, 0.008789309300482273, -0.022326063364744186, -0.049806300550699234, -0.025640543550252914, -0.0008312352001667023, 0.02128966525197029, -0.029694965109229088, -0.04572533816099167, 0.03880975395441055, 0.00486723892390728, 0.03141651302576065, -0.00984670128673315, 0.015311053954064846, -0.026460018008947372, -0.0031611525919288397, -0.026855716481804848, 0.008817651309072971, 0.016348399221897125, 0.025523193180561066, -0.030243322253227234, -0.017175139859318733, 0.03804059699177742, 0.009539325721561909, 0.02114391140639782, -0.040337271988391876, 0.05123893916606903, -0.00927646178752184, 0.032055824995040894, -0.0169849656522274, -0.03427867218852043, 0.01546412706375122, -0.003668535267934203, -0.014112225733697414, 0.004250138066709042, 0.0005090340855531394, 0.024859854951500893, 0.006269697565585375, 0.020219143480062485, -0.04006584733724594, -0.005543540697544813, -0.025735776871442795, 0.022769279778003693, 0.008271886967122555, 0.010239695198833942, -0.02060326375067234, -0.021704286336898804, 0.013793856836855412, 0.026998568326234818, 0.01604810170829296, 0.020147137343883514, 0.024750731885433197, -0.0005120945279486477, -0.03864354267716408, 0.016140710562467575, -0.016802320256829262, 0.00687916437163949, 0.0006465559126809239, -0.002429066225886345, 0.046727269887924194, 0.050565946847200394, -0.0243622325360775, 0.058382220566272736, -0.020325632765889168, 0.005973337683826685, -0.11455876380205154, -0.02024766616523266, 0.0013023002538830042, 0.02690521441400051, 0.02354651317000389, -0.027640074491500854, 0.011031417176127434, 0.011459567584097385, -0.019447246566414833, 0.017523137852549553, 0.013262119144201279, 0.016708405688405037, -0.03797640651464462, 0.023228805512189865, -0.02960936352610588, 0.018400084227323532, 0.01936536841094494, 0.015716934576630592, 0.019301442429423332, 0.03773907572031021, 0.024100229144096375, -0.0034091980196535587, 0.009867542423307896, 0.018881995230913162, -0.025857025757431984, -0.047672342509031296, 0.07544346153736115, -0.024154238402843475, -0.05199158191680908, 0.027104316279292107, 0.06353186815977097, 0.03921172767877579, 0.026072703301906586, 0.029863854870200157, 0.03827427327632904, 0.04105427488684654, 0.05630727484822273, 0.026694336906075478, -0.05542469024658203, 0.010325564071536064, -0.006512179505079985, 0.05065375566482544, 0.0061756703071296215, -0.013492139056324959, -0.00964361522346735, -0.03620051220059395, -0.000010768397260108031, 0.015208657830953598, -0.01635425165295601, -0.0024570832028985023, -0.00028096939786337316, -0.009308195672929287, 0.005795180331915617, -0.014010310173034668, 0.07485966384410858, -0.031312040984630585, -0.0017947443993762136, 0.07248151302337646, 0.023504555225372314, -0.022434500977396965, -0.00326777552254498, -0.012045948766171932, -0.03562339022755623, 0.022358255460858345, -0.0008666562498547137, -0.02326621674001217, -0.04832076281309128, -0.0006846345495432615, 0.014255247078835964, -0.03124214895069599, -0.0010723626473918557, -0.011633063666522503, -0.04349353536963463, 0.012470811605453491, -0.03438813239336014, 0.005119080655276775, 0.02222391404211521, -0.01841423474252224, -0.017833571881055832, -0.06452653557062149, 0.09628043323755264, -0.02087354101240635, -0.02130233496427536, -0.029086023569107056, -0.014378413558006287, -0.01175941713154316, -0.03055504523217678, 0.06801330298185349, 0.007596866227686405, -0.011414825916290283, -0.009437790140509605, 0.028070654720067978, 0.03499256446957588, -0.03896522521972656, 0.05342124402523041, -0.0016379356384277344, -0.019180841743946075, -0.022495444864034653, -0.039724286645650864, -0.00718392850831151, 0.058316752314567566, 0.03182651475071907, -0.02402784302830696, 0.018632395192980766, -0.005493088625371456, 0.007585049141198397, 0.04137485846877098, 0.0010237336391583085, 0.004059297032654285, 0.035914234817028046, 0.008378693833947182, 0.02473091334104538, 0.03637201711535454, -0.012402288615703583, -0.04930540546774864, 0.014899577014148235, -0.03979778289794922, -0.03551101312041283, 0.02487923577427864, -0.0012967829825356603, 0.007591479457914829, -0.04450351372361183, -0.006971018388867378, 0.017593661323189735, -0.04537390172481537, 0.02159273996949196, 0.05205462500452995, 0.0009362648124806583, 0.013130542822182178, 0.017333421856164932, 0.018765132874250412, 0.01997019164264202, -0.027370713651180267, -0.0015131670515984297, 0.0004658159159589559, 0.07651913911104202, -0.007853152230381966, 0.0315447598695755, 0.07827205210924149, 0.010699497535824776, 0.009617066010832787, -0.013081652112305164, 0.055534183979034424, -0.05334458127617836, -0.023106390610337257, -0.0026734203565865755, 0.013594938442111015, -0.010201561264693737, -0.020482471212744713, -0.0012196466559544206, 0.08086273819208145, -0.011646117083728313, -0.005654481239616871, -0.013197128660976887, -0.001254818867892027, -0.044864803552627563, -0.008607486262917519, -0.010290354490280151, 0.024353986606001854, -0.011069759726524353, 0.0021028928458690643, 0.002550606383010745, -0.013896932825446129, 0.047768231481313705, -0.02500864490866661, -0.01269406545907259, -0.0029890500009059906, -0.01324621494859457, -0.008045773021876812, -0.010980544611811638, -0.016608377918601036, -0.015263132750988007, 0.0036436100490391254, 0.05161960422992706, 0.05133344605565071, 0.0032857186160981655, -0.0386103130877018, -0.017774241045117378, 0.040800563991069794, -0.09212333709001541, 0.022223614156246185, -0.040650077164173126, -0.009678196161985397, 0.0028686230070888996, -0.026449905708432198 ]
<p>I am doing a research on two groups, one experimental and one control, which are not randomly selected. In fact the two groups are <em>intact groups</em>. The purpose is to find the effect of the number of languages that the learners know on their academic achievement. The selected design is <a href="http://www.socialresearchmethods.net/kb/quasnegd.php" rel="nofollow">Pretest Posttest Nonequivalent Group</a>. </p> <p>Which statistical method should I use to analyze the data?</p>
74,437
[ -0.04221656918525696, -0.01623639278113842, -0.03585280850529671, -0.017812034115195274, 0.049833033233881, 0.055547188967466354, -0.013496351428329945, -0.0343601256608963, 0.02252926677465439, -0.0016160537488758564, 0.05521624907851219, 0.036973536014556885, 0.01739543117582798, 0.010807634331285954, 0.0034803394228219986, 0.019653156399726868, -0.024811990559101105, 0.010982428677380085, -0.008359245955944061, 0.04013274237513542, -0.049961578100919724, 0.01386234350502491, -0.013590078800916672, -0.005609803833067417, -0.037899866700172424, 0.040135908871889114, 0.01938481256365776, -0.041877202689647675, 0.013930456712841988, 0.01199403777718544, 0.01223257277160883, -0.02322239987552166, -0.004766276106238365, 0.025359421968460083, 0.005838359706103802, 0.05355348810553551, -0.01471197884529829, -0.007678639143705368, 0.009119002148509026, 0.04373550787568092, -0.04414856433868408, -0.011656219139695168, 0.0030459496192634106, 0.018193833529949188, -0.03184649720788002, 0.038707539439201355, 0.0005891034961678088, -0.040128741413354874, 0.022557713091373444, -0.03931361436843872, 0.04843788221478462, -0.0026726892683655024, 0.009218566119670868, 0.04542500153183937, -0.002682268852367997, 0.007409222424030304, 0.016361718997359276, 0.03294581174850464, -0.009395317174494267, -0.030770305544137955, -0.021531952545046806, -0.02243633009493351, -0.002503533847630024, 0.014694923534989357, -0.04004311189055443, 0.03443829342722893, -0.001117359264753759, -0.014243872836232185, 0.03410825878381729, 0.0005454755737446249, 0.029833707958459854, -0.005692634731531143, 0.02774004638195038, -0.01990460231900215, 0.011836118996143341, -0.0013957907212898135, 0.0025493563152849674, 0.061002761125564575, 0.04757392778992653, 0.05478988215327263, 0.029016714543104172, -0.008588786236941814, 0.025586744770407677, 0.0425044484436512, 0.035793621093034744, -0.02268366329371929, 0.04944099485874176, 0.018743766471743584, -0.0035068707074970007, 0.029946351423859596, -0.006298581138253212, -0.03853327035903931, 0.03179438039660454, 0.03713559731841087, -0.04825959727168083, 0.009974859654903412, -0.027354028075933456, 0.06949040293693542, 0.026333505287766457, -0.037990421056747437, -0.0012616395251825452, -0.036215975880622864, 0.06605290621519089, 0.047968681901693344, -0.02540322206914425, -0.0008610159275121987, -0.04652068763971329, -0.004761436488479376, -0.005975755862891674, -0.005460552871227264, 0.02525428496301174, 0.038720693439245224, 0.003920422866940498, 0.004005859140306711, 0.050060540437698364, 0.02518385462462902, -0.03590013459324837, -0.014633295126259327, 0.10371249914169312, 0.060331497341394424, 0.020016826689243317, -0.01822676695883274, 0.04546923562884331, 0.00037600091309286654, -0.03256998211145401, 0.014857043512165546, 0.005278485361486673, 0.00909404270350933, -0.010835830122232437, 0.08143927901983261, -0.026855042204260826, 0.006702503189444542, 0.014023104682564735, -0.01581384427845478, 0.01632029190659523, 0.028314130380749702, -0.0717700719833374, -0.05685044452548027, 0.06878717988729477, -0.020531371235847473, 0.019004657864570618, -0.06113133952021599, -0.013481495901942253, -0.008565736934542656, 0.06979942321777344, -0.011804376728832722, 0.04408850148320198, 0.022693408653140068, 0.010259440168738365, 0.013384949415922165, 0.008306469768285751, 0.0016216732328757644, -0.01751307025551796, -0.005494340322911739, -0.005306682549417019, -0.07556041330099106, 0.025081096217036247, 0.02698390558362007, 0.020240193232893944, 0.013735556043684483, 0.009267392568290234, 0.012102589011192322, -0.021033186465501785, 0.0035900066141039133, 0.030166655778884888, -0.014696812257170677, 0.03699449449777603, 0.010406505316495895, 0.030911467969417572, 0.020633893087506294, 0.02247735857963562, 0.034117940813302994, 0.006187899503856897, 0.012742888182401657, 0.03819873556494713, -0.01530259195715189, 0.018150193616747856, 0.023715130984783173, 0.005177369341254234, -0.026401329785585403, -0.03304034471511841, -0.017196835950016975, 0.0037810611538589, 0.02441052533686161, 0.03939615562558174, 0.03894943743944168, 0.04419846460223198, 0.005017851013690233, 0.028515776619315147, -0.013491600751876831, -0.05823703110218048, -0.08453357219696045, 0.020748822018504143, 0.013157437555491924, -0.07318176329135895, 0.01696140132844448, 0.006916910409927368, 0.007892506197094917, -0.009784484282135963, 0.016830502077937126, -0.019546927884221077, -0.04130672290921211, 0.030893148854374886, -0.013394857756793499, 0.00977928563952446, 0.053656935691833496, 0.023831462487578392, -0.00615901593118906, 0.046342577785253525, -0.005524841137230396, -0.041018255054950714, -0.01928132027387619, -0.01677568070590496, 0.012076440267264843, -0.005494940560311079, -0.025973865762352943, 0.02014373056590557, 0.021721307188272476, -0.023169275373220444, 0.03352060914039612, -0.059878215193748474, 0.0850231945514679, 0.05016736313700676, -0.009936206042766571, 0.041181281208992004, 0.0026375860907137394, -0.004555177874863148, 0.045167043805122375, 0.034971412271261215, -0.005182135384529829, -0.03201983869075775, -0.003352680243551731, 0.048906564712524414, -0.031622301787137985, -0.05893852189183235, 0.00470401206985116, 0.034733232110738754, 0.013635003939270973, -0.027205806225538254, 0.032511115074157715, -0.006895864848047495, -0.03346189484000206, -0.023289131000638008, 0.046502333134412766, 0.013013263233006, 0.015884466469287872, 0.034820735454559326, 0.013510736636817455, 0.008863374590873718, 0.016704391688108444, 0.02254670299589634, 0.051719553768634796, 0.05050043389201164, 0.02060171589255333, -0.019535856321454048, -0.0030477321706712246, 0.017461637035012245, -0.002267268020659685, 0.012412057258188725, 0.006451450753957033, -0.013067319057881832, -0.014456899836659431, 0.03996323421597481, -0.019039904698729515, 0.0145112918689847, 0.0007781463209539652, -0.008660473860800266, 0.02316930703818798, 0.02177419140934944, -0.05845129117369652, -0.0007569576846435666, -0.01990860514342785, -0.04448722302913666, -0.017536580562591553, 0.0007953827152960002, 0.03406862914562225, -0.020604707300662994, 0.02018950879573822, -0.035097040235996246, -0.006320912856608629, -0.000782355316914618, -0.006425836123526096, 0.02034866064786911, 0.020589955151081085, -0.0645335391163826, -0.009702969342470169, -0.03716735169291496, 0.006994904484599829, 0.01872899942100048, -0.023681530728936195, -0.002262915950268507, 0.06045874208211899, -0.008803518489003181, -0.06153257563710213, -0.03250376507639885, -0.0513790026307106, 0.013983712531626225, -0.006245821248739958, -0.025895850732922554, 0.024869924411177635, 0.04186829924583435, -0.008455723524093628, 0.03448249772191048, -0.0320502370595932, -0.029786821454763412, -0.0020567902829498053, -0.0017801655922085047, -0.020562794059515, -0.03121386654675007, -0.007836071774363518, -0.022348111495375633, -0.03207322955131531, -0.014707091264426708, -0.06908030062913895, -0.07985304296016693, 0.027838224545121193, -0.0025329540949314833, 0.023101121187210083, -0.030390648171305656, -0.020366741344332695, 0.07578813284635544, 0.0038971854373812675, -0.03436485305428505, -0.06397005915641785, -0.004873708356171846, -0.019911035895347595, 0.022611141204833984, 0.03284267708659172, 0.02600139193236828, -0.006513345055282116, 0.010406914167106152, 0.01088931318372488, 0.04112379625439644, 0.04739644378423691, 0.0031331516802310944, -0.004947484005242586, 0.013943701051175594, 0.0019834814593195915, -0.016395799815654755, 0.05250050127506256, 0.02530817687511444, -0.04849677532911301, 0.039607755839824677, -0.0010255130473524332, 0.014558176510035992, 0.049144938588142395, -0.06641815602779388, -0.0073992242105305195, 0.008907056413590908, -0.01933845691382885, -0.0402471162378788, 0.028616879135370255, 0.028130482882261276, -0.007074092980474234, 0.010667172260582447, 0.002625441877171397, 0.0015722744865342975, -0.0325733907520771, 0.00050917430780828, 0.04441124200820923, 0.06812058389186859, -0.016477061435580254, -0.025747066363692284, -0.02467944286763668, -0.005367893725633621, 0.029969045892357826, -0.02364441007375717, -0.005697957705706358, 0.0023014431353658438, 0.04788215085864067, 0.02103068307042122, -0.02121090516448021, -0.0331781841814518, -0.0322074256837368, -0.0785054862499237, 0.032792892307043076, -0.025140851736068726, 0.07130526006221771, -0.004751973785459995, 0.032136689871549606, -0.00887400470674038, -0.0162675678730011, -0.03027946874499321, -0.012919863685965538, -0.08644083887338638, 0.03504186496138573, 0.005494242999702692, -0.007805207744240761, 0.02863139472901821, -0.007470454089343548, 0.0417574942111969, -0.02243076264858246, -0.0023162569850683212, -0.011309669353067875, 0.008773494511842728, 0.002543552778661251, 0.008128133602440357, -0.06445770710706711, -0.013340226374566555, -0.00021245401876512915, 0.029502013698220253, -0.009633779525756836, 0.0014167882036417723, 0.009113812819123268, 0.006517330650240183, -0.008025039918720722, -0.02373644709587097, -0.029630830511450768, -0.007971874438226223, 0.02173306606709957, 0.0377742201089859, 0.005340421572327614, 0.06345491111278534, -0.050529878586530685, 0.0370899923145771, -0.025084596127271652, 0.009377391077578068, 0.039379995316267014, 0.009339068084955215, -0.0025583684910088778, -0.023761549964547157, 0.005743851885199547, 0.01621219702064991, 0.013269118033349514, -0.013740726746618748, 0.005864015314728022, 0.05924766883254051, 0.02852628566324711, -0.05398039147257805, 0.014588958583772182, 0.01265379786491394, 0.010547676123678684, 0.019980641081929207, -0.021150387823581696, 0.03054831363260746, 0.009814663790166378, -0.005804336629807949, 0.021340012550354004, 0.01620754972100258, -0.007692639250308275, -0.01857992261648178, 0.05118516460061073, 0.033489905297756195, -0.06119031086564064, 0.00842303317040205, -0.006950339302420616, 0.009010689333081245, 0.0028777557890862226, -0.050968870520591736, 0.0012075814884155989, 0.06652885675430298, 0.026004156097769737, -0.0032327587250620127, -0.018573712557554245, -0.09220358729362488, -0.015605526976287365, 0.04477937892079353, 0.042041633278131485, -0.05382478982210159, 0.0400993786752224, -0.00862045492976904, 0.00939974281936884, -0.015635687857866287, -0.03024083562195301, 0.030150897800922394, -0.018208390101790428, 0.0320725291967392, -0.07218509912490845, -0.010500376112759113, -0.028689797967672348, -0.0006711774622090161, 0.011384427547454834, 0.01636187545955181, 0.002853215439245105, 0.0008144045132212341, -0.03151777386665344, 0.004365337546914816, 0.015256296843290329, 0.020885208621621132, -0.004588422365486622, -0.01663510873913765, 0.03487842530012131, 0.00346778123639524, -0.027551958337426186, -0.04080755263566971, 0.03474249318242073, -0.008268430829048157, 0.02158207818865776, 0.052902866154909134, -0.02754371426999569, -0.053174689412117004, 0.0051516080275177956, -0.005665827076882124, -0.013259592466056347, -0.014064127579331398, -0.007134980987757444, 0.03856487199664116, 0.04084508866071701, 0.032029811292886734, 0.050261203199625015, 0.0001998080115299672, 0.040550507605075836, 0.010890539735555649, -0.018797175958752632, -0.004851353354752064, -0.06114553287625313, -0.013110381551086903, -0.035446248948574066, -0.016366230323910713, -0.02771705947816372, 0.03602038323879242, -0.00339076342061162, 0.03663605451583862, -0.019803036004304886, -0.010351128876209259, 0.03160575404763222, -0.007761829998344183, 0.02523232251405716, -0.001569280051626265, -0.008074456825852394, -0.012603281997144222, -0.008645475842058659, -0.014215352945029736, 0.047068387269973755, -0.03448650613427162, 0.007236842066049576, -0.0025875731371343136, -0.05615614727139473, -0.011742380447685719, -0.04539689049124718, -0.053232066333293915, 0.015538445673882961, -0.030628284439444542, 0.0037572358269244432, 0.00476989708840847, 0.06528504937887192, -0.004912353120744228, -0.020487699657678604, -0.016759490594267845, 0.029368143528699875, 0.01990078203380108, 0.009855563752353191, -0.04601820558309555, 0.0658859983086586, -0.01046661101281643, -0.01994280517101288, -0.0927167758345604, -0.05789783224463463, 0.023116249591112137, -0.0011865043779835105, -0.027758263051509857, -0.017205815762281418, 0.03456491231918335, -0.008376391604542732, -0.00619851890951395, -0.0057910229079425335, 0.07817217707633972, -0.015101313591003418, -0.0035118290688842535, -0.009525058791041374, 0.012178527191281319, 0.05929822474718094, 0.019165823236107826, -0.036690909415483475, 0.014237272553145885, -0.03189581632614136, 0.008405675180256367, -0.025504838675260544, -0.014318589121103287, -0.03348001092672348, -0.010589697398245335, -0.05630626901984215, 0.01750067248940468, 0.010652986355125904, -0.04466012865304947, 0.02324947901070118, 0.024924680590629578, 0.005242320708930492, 0.00817855354398489, -0.028191769495606422, -0.0006893756217323244, -0.01914612017571926, 0.006558638997375965, -0.008996274322271347, 0.0321013405919075, -0.030721109360456467, 0.011440222151577473, 0.01560867577791214, 0.02192523702979088, -0.06008531153202057, -0.016520362347364426, 0.07318189740180969, 0.009653366170823574, 0.005031885113567114, 0.014179768972098827, -0.01795881986618042, 0.018803441897034645, 0.000014054754501557909, 0.005246173124760389, 0.028658296912908554, 0.029987994581460953, -0.046145692467689514, -0.010705054737627506, -0.03627883642911911, -0.012155324220657349, 0.07353581488132477, 0.011644452810287476, 0.059751421213150024, 0.08550726622343063, 0.01523592323064804, 0.0014086196897551417, 0.005494618322700262, 0.018094971776008606, -0.03223101794719696, 0.047161951661109924, 0.045334815979003906, -0.029236197471618652, -0.0236754659563303, 0.041033729910850525, 0.028328787535429, 0.020700732246041298, 0.05608954280614853, 0.047851111739873886, 0.0003100029134657234, -0.010353409685194492, -0.0788235142827034, -0.04729609191417694, 0.019829552620649338, -0.07501287758350372, 0.035417430102825165, -0.035930220037698746, -0.0012654907768592238, 0.021969087421894073, 0.026246560737490654, 0.04186004027724266, -0.04166935756802559, -0.0009898904245346785, -0.046319589018821716, 0.011940788477659225, -0.0002514909429010004, -0.0029191412031650543, 0.016142353415489197, -0.004685134626924992, 0.04081384092569351, -0.004374837968498468, 0.040876343846321106, -0.0356728732585907, -0.09310801327228546, 0.0007185989525169134, 0.003223382169380784, -0.014872184954583645, 0.01430831290781498, -0.02013879083096981, -0.058185361325740814, 0.020194750279188156, -0.03958190232515335, -0.0020956883672624826, 0.0014785261591896415, 0.019145270809531212, -0.028911840170621872, 0.07629703730344772, -0.002357858931645751, 0.013410012237727642, 0.026367591693997383, -0.0025651659816503525, 0.10525862872600555, 0.06685493141412735, 0.044336024671792984, -0.05661851167678833, 0.03898807242512703, 0.04304783418774605, 0.02126045525074005, -0.013431363739073277, -0.01814240962266922, -0.013356808573007584, 0.005990590900182724, 0.027404645457863808, 0.05479149520397186, -0.008238780312240124, -0.03488084673881531, 0.04091114178299904, -0.0243381317704916, -0.04946903884410858, 0.008896385319530964, -0.016803812235593796, 0.016489550471305847, -0.03820627182722092, 0.005370229948312044, 0.016970962285995483, 0.02593902125954628, -0.028868038207292557, -0.005771803203970194, -0.027665983885526657, -0.0006230399012565613, 0.006117194425314665, 0.010176446288824081, 0.0012544719502329826, 0.0188005268573761, 0.03794724866747856, -0.07387246936559677, -0.02801540307700634, 0.0032442498486489058, -0.08358737081289291, 0.01637495495378971, 0.0227659959346056, -0.012113211676478386, -0.04105052351951599, -0.012216630391776562, 0.03149513155221939, -0.07243011891841888, -0.03405057266354561, -0.011717953719198704, 0.06148713082075119, 0.021826060488820076, -0.025902219116687775, -0.03468259051442146, 0.016486357897520065, 0.003832222893834114, -0.028732964769005775, -0.05939438194036484, 0.02715974859893322, 0.015594575554132462, -0.04082261398434639, -0.055311162024736404, -0.03441620618104935, -0.004620723892003298, -0.01851401850581169, 0.002550128847360611, 0.02462807483971119, -0.01186847873032093, -0.02361798658967018, -0.016432195901870728, -0.015092778950929642, 0.015717869624495506, -0.005854148417711258, 0.015131697058677673, -0.014824417419731617, -0.035072438418865204, 0.02069328911602497, 0.002405612263828516, 0.042751118540763855, 0.03903979808092117, -0.025723038241267204, -0.03388673812150955, -0.03354014456272125, -0.00271903770044446, 0.0031224479898810387, -0.03885158151388168, -0.018224695697426796, -0.0226773489266634, 0.006294223479926586, -0.022805484011769295, 0.039521723985672, -0.00767504284158349, 0.0021002870053052902, 0.06123727187514305, 0.00002788378878904041, 0.022128693759441376, -0.048594217747449875, -0.024909930303692818, -0.029506728053092957, -0.026560276746749878, -0.02645636908710003, -0.0406220406293869, 0.049372632056474686, -0.012348097749054432, -0.0016172731993719935, 0.0009964066557586193, 0.027055367827415466, -0.02089609019458294, 0.013760189525783062, 0.017337119206786156, -0.060010820627212524, -0.02455671690404415, -0.0031129755079746246, 0.019766120240092278, -0.01967693865299225, -0.0202974621206522, -0.004934166092425585, -0.02078446000814438, 0.012931974604725838, -0.046091265976428986, -0.014430856332182884, 0.04855997487902641, -0.01102837547659874, 0.049491822719573975, -0.02642112225294113, 0.005251322872936726, -0.028849095106124878, -0.04297293350100517, -0.026367299258708954, -0.007183857262134552, -0.02415921352803707, 0.0027263665106147528, 0.006473984103649855, 0.020214790478348732, 0.015793753787875175, -0.012146079912781715, 0.02435264177620411, -0.01890925131738186, 0.02789810113608837, -0.02341325208544731, 0.022606903687119484, 0.0006235411856323481, 0.002785495249554515, 0.01580321416258812, -0.05211971700191498, 0.0019961423240602016, 0.01227334700524807, -0.0025319543201476336, 0.02721795253455639, -0.01333631668239832, 0.0023028042633086443, 0.02213352359831333, 0.022472240030765533, -0.019554171711206436, -0.07641774415969849, -0.016657695174217224, -0.016416996717453003, 0.0183284729719162, 0.005416670814156532, -0.044511374086141586, 0.027307623997330666, -0.013396747410297394, 0.04507775604724884, 0.06971347332000732, 0.010431278496980667, -0.018453609198331833, 0.007257755380123854, -0.01218083593994379, 0.029656045138835907, 0.02588846907019615, -0.008296176791191101, -0.0035017607733607292, 0.03533422574400902, -0.01742943748831749, 0.0145985446870327, -0.02026289701461792, -0.0067370180040597916, -0.06910402327775955, -0.0393618568778038, 0.01857302151620388, 0.02228742465376854, 0.04643964767456055, -0.057328298687934875, -0.0006140390178188682, 0.041791364550590515, -0.037912674248218536, 0.016202928498387337, -0.029698103666305542, -0.021689098328351974, -0.05445381999015808, -0.002291531767696142, -0.03339817002415657, 0.03645143657922745, -0.003301288466900587, 0.054199520498514175, 0.03936735540628433, 0.032219048589468, -0.012012170627713203, -0.004364873748272657, 0.0043482244946062565, -0.010253304615616798, 0.031478118151426315, -0.04335552081465721, 0.015137945301830769, -0.006929495371878147, -0.03583693131804466, 0.03631698340177536, 0.002464771270751953, 0.059362057596445084, 0.032442618161439896, -0.01639760285615921, -0.01688780076801777, 0.0034374988172203302, 0.038319095969200134, -0.010377486236393452, -0.0047184182330966, -0.013877763412892818, -0.009458075277507305, 0.04221014678478241, 0.021250437945127487, 0.006565176881849766, 0.012809406034648418, -0.006885955110192299, 0.0020365542732179165, 0.03100011870265007, -0.0027059547137469053, -0.02725221961736679, 0.014680411666631699, -0.010713319294154644, -0.02125043235719204, -0.028544653207063675, -0.028347060084342957, -0.05484964698553085, 0.005596731789410114, 0.011334660463035107, 0.012147732079029083, -0.04849560558795929, 0.04005153104662895, -0.023745058104395866, -0.001275739399716258, -0.019888905808329582, -0.010560027323663235, 0.04357049614191055, -0.06172771751880646, -0.0034278531093150377, 0.005043803248554468, 0.002902708016335964, -0.023384712636470795, -0.019787631928920746, -0.012636384926736355, 0.03756622225046158, -0.041647132486104965, -0.0014597336994484067, -0.009750128723680973, -0.02818467654287815, 0.025760961696505547, -0.052890483289957047, 0.06408537179231644, 0.010697386227548122, -0.012148595415055752, -0.05506700649857521, -0.0021741301752626896, -0.06007642671465874, 0.03220481425523758, 0.06743364036083221, 0.011477066203951836, 0.020840788260102272, -0.03135502338409424, 0.031428031623363495, 0.0002599037834443152, -0.0384368821978569, 0.045429978519678116, -0.0008728591492399573, 0.002318604616448283, -0.021777914837002754, -0.005678835790604353, 0.014740430749952793, 0.0132858045399189, 0.0226132869720459, -0.0069507090374827385, 0.028240859508514404, 0.021205836907029152, -0.04176589846611023, 0.04758341982960701, 0.017210578545928, -0.004614222329109907, -0.0012758434750139713, -0.02898895926773548, 0.005588796455413103, 0.05551714822649956, -0.015709416940808296, -0.07502550631761551, 0.010169192217290401, -0.0074739959090948105, -0.026087984442710876, -0.0113461809232831, -0.0006317438674159348, 0.012979911640286446, -0.022827574983239174, 0.012742769904434681, 0.0335581935942173, -0.023938409984111786, 0.00729829166084528, 0.016335513442754745, 0.042475465685129166, 0.017795896157622337, -0.05127168074250221, 0.039054837077856064, -0.011329726316034794, -0.008900443091988564, 0.01446650642901659, 0.023451702669262886, 0.014574271626770496, 0.010470785200595856, -0.005943475291132927, 0.004849588964134455, 0.0017573065124452114, 0.027558233588933945, 0.009239030070602894, 0.04805688560009003, -0.03706364333629608, 0.024591850116848946, -0.0025552893057465553, 0.010288389399647713, -0.004385559819638729, -0.01233183778822422, 0.010819323360919952, 0.06611467897891998, -0.057351842522621155, 0.007850891910493374, -0.048549819737672806, -0.026777824386954308, -0.04980398714542389, -0.0013389193918555975, 0.003800664097070694, 0.029378555715084076, 0.0020666944328695536, 0.03598411753773689, -0.021742278710007668, -0.03792932629585266, 0.03041651099920273, -0.0006472152308560908, 0.035904429852962494, -0.008576643653213978, -0.03507159650325775, -0.02619396708905697, -0.019712412729859352, -0.0210062637925148, -0.01743939518928528, 0.06393870711326599, 0.03274540975689888, -0.000054947766329860315, -0.07057691365480423, -0.03384360671043396, -0.009415887296199799, 0.05619938299059868, -0.021398913115262985, -0.023849794641137123, -0.029657945036888123, 0.005330041516572237, 0.003411863697692752, 0.014464338310062885 ]
<p>I have been working with fuzzy logic (FL) for years and I know there are differences between FL and probability specially concerning the way FL deals with uncertainty. However, I would like to ask what more differences exist between FL and probability?</p> <p>In other words, if I deal with probabilities (fusing information, aggregating knowledge), can I do the same with FL? </p>
74,438
[ -0.005408697761595249, -0.038996707648038864, -0.001829983084462583, -0.021528057754039764, 0.04868360981345177, 0.01746116764843464, -0.00873811449855566, -0.008281943388283253, 0.02538198046386242, 0.01783590577542782, 0.0172975305467844, 0.04762173816561699, 0.04825669154524803, 0.0019560556393116713, 0.0275729987770319, -0.009110677987337112, 0.018640469759702682, 0.0035149368923157454, -0.02618921920657158, -0.003378472989425063, 0.0047045862302184105, 0.033185772597789764, 0.013916647993028164, -0.0003589479601942003, -0.03259383141994476, 0.04206371679902077, 0.025952119380235672, 0.0013765412149950862, 0.04931998997926712, 0.09533039480447769, -0.002640151884406805, -0.032210823148489, -0.018733825534582138, 0.03440803661942482, 0.024265924468636513, -0.02330891601741314, -0.024371163919568062, 0.0029960141982883215, -0.03198710456490517, -0.005246714223176241, -0.04621162265539169, -0.018178505823016167, -0.00037454336415976286, 0.04175138100981712, -0.027998751029372215, 0.003280472243204713, -0.03433719277381897, -0.0448254831135273, 0.0037765291053801775, -0.03489627689123154, 0.036404088139534, -0.010564262047410011, 0.017099017277359962, 0.04614250361919403, 0.023291949182748795, 0.012532709166407585, 0.06230588257312775, 0.0905977115035057, -0.02848251350224018, -0.05603514239192009, -0.009479524567723274, -0.03538041189312935, 0.021446406841278076, -0.04293966665863991, -0.014897102490067482, 0.023216187953948975, -0.040711842477321625, -0.028413204476237297, 0.010960960760712624, 0.030638938769698143, -0.005670540500432253, 0.02439577877521515, 0.021729251369833946, -0.012998060323297977, 0.029500218108296394, -0.019214749336242676, 0.008612960577011108, 0.01865401677787304, 0.04152974113821983, 0.04179546609520912, 0.010667173191905022, 0.017170362174510956, 0.000051317489123903215, 0.01452399417757988, 0.025671841576695442, -0.04619821533560753, 0.04543016850948334, -0.024203268811106682, -0.0035314466804265976, -0.026072056964039803, -0.025492453947663307, -0.008024862967431545, 0.023870231583714485, -0.0009122675401158631, -0.03231531381607056, 0.0285473745316267, 0.0035922282841056585, 0.02875903993844986, 0.004369622562080622, -0.002205655677244067, 0.01336889248341322, -0.041000984609127045, 0.0573405884206295, 0.03374265134334564, -0.034443449229002, -0.0259863268584013, 0.005245687905699015, -0.004233939573168755, -0.009778827428817749, 0.012120183557271957, 0.0014285604702308774, 0.04321730136871338, 0.019077442586421967, 0.016612868756055832, 0.020551631227135658, -0.014250162988901138, 0.008131257258355618, -0.021535325795412064, 0.04307346045970917, 0.056747786700725555, 0.031995125114917755, -0.0394052155315876, 0.01221858337521553, 0.0011354116722941399, -0.046729352325201035, 0.015319093130528927, 0.025148335844278336, -0.003509124740958214, -0.033766619861125946, 0.05608086287975311, -0.014806145802140236, -0.011837712489068508, 0.040997885167598724, 0.015886258333921432, 0.0372127965092659, 0.016503438353538513, -0.08258112519979477, -0.012962495908141136, 0.04221082478761673, -0.042663976550102234, -0.025228068232536316, -0.07030409574508667, 0.0420583039522171, 0.0408175066113472, 0.06130604445934296, 0.041820574551820755, 0.03618248924612999, -0.003120589070022106, 0.010638685896992683, 0.009564864449203014, -0.035408344119787216, -0.026729585602879524, 0.010741915553808212, -0.013831592164933681, -0.003189642680808902, -0.07674285024404526, 0.026536447927355766, 0.012684747576713562, -0.005991675890982151, -0.05083712562918663, 0.04670482501387596, -0.008248496800661087, -0.026087045669555664, 0.011239690706133842, 0.013104896061122417, 0.010623086243867874, 0.08721593022346497, 0.0041222297586500645, 0.025244299322366714, 0.06669531017541885, -0.001757016172632575, 0.015388868749141693, 0.022533098235726357, 0.041283827275037766, 0.08122668415307999, -0.014545921236276627, -0.04423438385128975, -0.005136149935424328, 0.017658041790127754, -0.019171379506587982, -0.027505353093147278, 0.004254074301570654, -0.01693687029182911, -0.008268013596534729, 0.02044045738875866, 0.022653726860880852, 0.01875581592321396, -0.04384680464863777, 0.023323405534029007, -0.044315118342638016, -0.033745698630809784, -0.09041076898574829, 0.017115600407123566, -0.03133140876889229, -0.012849714607000351, 0.031098762527108192, 0.02547278068959713, 0.01352457795292139, -0.06815331429243088, -0.010910059325397015, -0.04849610477685928, 0.011738097295165062, -0.030690768733620644, -0.038868267089128494, 0.006522602867335081, 0.08138822764158249, 0.007979073561728, -0.03289433568716049, 0.022229185327887535, -0.05837190896272659, -0.09186503291130066, -0.004704258870333433, -0.03284740820527077, -0.0022063320502638817, -0.00935383141040802, -0.024882307276129723, 0.008517833426594734, 0.0009475003462284803, -0.03748708218336105, 0.01069051306694746, -0.02144608460366726, 0.05322835221886635, 0.05941411852836609, -0.0010408936068415642, 0.017979906871914864, 0.038290396332740784, 0.012328076176345348, -0.0237777978181839, 0.013138215988874435, -0.023015059530735016, -0.039956651628017426, 0.006888076197355986, 0.04510483145713806, 0.022279780358076096, -0.0017256371211260557, 0.011337668634951115, 0.032397761940956116, 0.00924677960574627, 0.03737227991223335, 0.03776250034570694, -0.00970719289034605, -0.0030561259482055902, -0.0015878148842602968, 0.021207276731729507, 0.04496365785598755, -0.015168041922152042, -0.01811935193836689, 0.036216460168361664, 0.003503009444102645, -0.0350177101790905, -0.05805620923638344, 0.07425972819328308, -0.019233863800764084, 0.03341316431760788, 0.00931493565440178, -0.018860146403312683, -0.013156427070498466, -0.026095042005181313, -0.012754551135003567, -0.007726224139332771, -0.03161153197288513, -0.006588002201169729, -0.004448235500603914, -0.04287867993116379, 0.006753466557711363, 0.028320008888840675, -0.048849377781152725, 0.002214993117377162, 0.02059650979936123, -0.0000029212487788754515, -0.013467002660036087, 0.016246935352683067, -0.013656056486070156, -0.01805279217660427, 0.03365449607372284, 0.03233011066913605, -0.04321522265672684, 0.042011212557554245, -0.0011508342577144504, -0.04733112454414368, -0.013677784241735935, -0.039594024419784546, 0.005980139132589102, -0.02545774169266224, -0.06311716884374619, 0.018287474289536476, -0.00577558483928442, -0.038364555686712265, 0.04063815250992775, -0.04398394003510475, 0.027213837951421738, -0.02030095085501671, -0.003534108167514205, -0.058453891426324844, 0.001360783469863236, -0.041853807866573334, 0.007124345283955336, 0.020141247659921646, -0.04038957506418228, -0.0018000671407207847, -0.030074145644903183, -0.04085155576467514, 0.015677353367209435, -0.026060568168759346, -0.03490172699093819, -0.042433153837919235, 0.01916881650686264, 0.01877923123538494, -0.014062640257179737, 0.01902025192975998, 0.02710604853928089, -0.04807324334979057, 0.009053844027221203, -0.0173172727227211, -0.05378906428813934, 0.023862343281507492, 0.006926632486283779, 0.03631197288632393, -0.022425640374422073, -0.018238062039017677, 0.06434036046266556, 0.040066421031951904, -0.05113769322633743, 0.007793355733156204, -0.0015603252686560154, -0.009015040472149849, 0.012663591653108597, -0.012315554544329643, -0.014727477915585041, -0.018781522288918495, 0.05819524824619293, 0.021552041172981262, -0.007210070267319679, 0.03196568414568901, 0.04545899108052254, -0.0021842445712536573, 0.009664571844041348, 0.013089204207062721, -0.012654331512749195, 0.050855766981840134, 0.022249620407819748, -0.028518686071038246, 0.011873344890773296, 0.0023321679327636957, 0.0018800084944814444, 0.0031308881007134914, -0.021197961643338203, 0.049503784626722336, -0.002396905329078436, 0.03519490733742714, -0.04277528449892998, 0.057005178183317184, 0.000605098030064255, 0.00924629159271717, 0.02624247781932354, 0.01305170264095068, 0.04926290363073349, -0.03881518915295601, 0.019787834957242012, 0.04119299352169037, 0.03344837948679924, -0.03385089337825775, -0.030596621334552765, -0.014040226116776466, -0.04422888904809952, 0.03538132086396217, -0.00960385799407959, -0.010841945186257362, 0.04249536618590355, 0.05471571162343025, 0.004335570149123669, 0.027282601222395897, 0.0009272372699342668, -0.02622746303677559, -0.05321630463004112, -0.038680147379636765, 0.002204685704782605, 0.06397514045238495, 0.019133538007736206, 0.04007032886147499, 0.004788451362401247, -0.013157288543879986, -0.011881708167493343, 0.008319198153913021, -0.09586582332849503, 0.036729518324136734, -0.027400005608797073, 0.030059507116675377, -0.040334951132535934, -0.03455132991075516, 0.028313539922237396, -0.025217637419700623, -0.023824995383620262, -0.048617180436849594, 0.014735700562596321, -0.046377554535865784, 0.005653514992445707, -0.03108532540500164, -0.01560349203646183, 0.01136756781488657, 0.009698382578790188, -0.017798027023673058, -0.0030881687998771667, 0.056709010154008865, 0.04504372924566269, -0.023751454427838326, -0.02290995419025421, -0.006567857693880796, 0.014696420170366764, 0.032936014235019684, 0.024626389145851135, 0.03796263411641121, 0.05159933492541313, -0.03238785266876221, 0.039144307374954224, 0.03832722455263138, 0.07814361155033112, 0.039422884583473206, -0.0291706845164299, -0.035556770861148834, -0.06525817513465881, -0.03490603342652321, -0.004243840929120779, 0.033231157809495926, -0.007302175275981426, 0.012165980413556099, 0.0365954264998436, -0.012695249170064926, -0.029164109379053116, 0.02953614480793476, 0.043946459889411926, -0.0068715717643499374, -0.02920840121805668, -0.035360369831323624, -0.0320102833211422, -0.0396827757358551, -0.035744667053222656, 0.04613320529460907, 0.0013951794244349003, -0.0020150027703493834, 0.006596557330340147, 0.031525593250989914, -0.04110105708241463, -0.024287808686494827, -0.019117843359708786, 0.005107978358864784, -0.023151058703660965, 0.024548353627324104, -0.031198564916849136, 0.005220041610300541, 0.034938350319862366, 0.005158667918294668, 0.060321636497974396, 0.016349561512470245, -0.04235706478357315, 0.022676406428217888, 0.06119291111826897, 0.03853306174278259, -0.05491042882204056, -0.00015359261306002736, -0.03649131953716278, -0.030212335288524628, 0.06054212525486946, -0.016787275671958923, 0.016384229063987732, -0.03126551955938339, -0.018107719719409943, -0.01905658096075058, -0.01594918966293335, 0.030321847647428513, 0.023112302646040916, 0.011999555863440037, 0.02887651138007641, 0.0024533772375434637, 0.012822385877370834, -0.04629013314843178, 0.013049349188804626, 0.05007488280534744, 0.030458079650998116, 0.027464579790830612, -0.003764036111533642, -0.02466268464922905, 0.027219735085964203, 0.018513377755880356, -0.057472869753837585, 0.006843553390353918, 0.0008185738115571439, -0.005917591508477926, 0.03925983980298042, 0.001070524798706174, -0.036819200962781906, 0.016954390332102776, -0.014061094261705875, -0.014274837449193, 0.009330930188298225, 0.0026039949152618647, 0.03247569128870964, 0.029407238587737083, 0.018107382580637932, 0.052916545420885086, -0.006018702872097492, -0.01473209634423256, -0.001485742861405015, -0.0035406460519880056, -0.0025218233931809664, -0.051862191408872604, 0.002905291737988591, -0.03631380945444107, 0.017184240743517876, -0.006304564885795116, 0.0497259795665741, 0.023886190727353096, 0.025317685678601265, -0.026552623137831688, -0.026402654126286507, -0.05618390068411827, 0.01682751066982746, 0.04981932044029236, -0.009182480163872242, -0.007896837778389454, -0.005089092999696732, -0.009134307503700256, -0.01844700239598751, -0.0017882958054542542, 0.005429794080555439, 0.02988189272582531, -0.03546753525733948, -0.029465386644005775, 0.026032472029328346, -0.04769293963909149, -0.0014272840926423669, 0.020886586979031563, -0.0049072857946157455, 0.03938189521431923, 0.006957483012229204, 0.01653890497982502, 0.019845841452479362, -0.06305602937936783, -0.03194349631667137, -0.002840447472408414, 0.008552913554012775, 0.033679571002721786, -0.058756228536367416, 0.062009334564208984, -0.007040009833872318, -0.0415620282292366, -0.05518864840269089, -0.05150718614459038, -0.021968713030219078, 0.021603431552648544, -0.052808962762355804, -0.02299794927239418, 0.03478052467107773, -0.03492916002869606, -0.02535705827176571, -0.03797602653503418, 0.05964883044362068, 0.00024081372248474509, -0.028646891936659813, 0.0042474581860005856, -0.02144104801118374, 0.07443161308765411, 0.011065485887229443, -0.0005123778828419745, 0.013312785886228085, -0.036444034427404404, 0.006464137230068445, -0.020920028910040855, 0.01428276114165783, -0.026479274034500122, -0.00009448074706597254, -0.002045007422566414, -0.022571992129087448, 0.026425907388329506, -0.001127407536841929, 0.011762884445488453, 0.004021449945867062, 0.031175032258033752, -0.01365154329687357, 0.026406899094581604, 0.01770307682454586, -0.008217128925025463, 0.029462497681379318, 0.01879039593040943, 0.009919148869812489, 0.017540303990244865, -0.011556608602404594, 0.052256740629673004, -0.0060511864721775055, 0.0034339092671871185, 0.021997908130288124, 0.03423256054520607, -0.02591901645064354, 0.021120481193065643, -0.017083771526813507, -0.01856219209730625, 0.027204742655158043, -0.03765999153256416, -0.0056702205911278725, 0.024710681289434433, 0.02806992456316948, -0.019921470433473587, -0.004068273119628429, -0.020547829568386078, -0.039814166724681854, 0.03809335455298424, -0.04114566743373871, 0.05835989490151405, 0.04167339950799942, 0.020942887291312218, -0.019726203754544258, -0.01839347369968891, -0.02035781927406788, 0.01463937759399414, 0.0011135839158669114, 0.050803765654563904, -0.026906661689281464, 0.007507839240133762, 0.04619430750608444, 0.023968974128365517, 0.030340075492858887, 0.011246241629123688, 0.018218766897916794, 0.06810677796602249, 0.01711706630885601, -0.01870736852288246, -0.049719419330358505, 0.04228924959897995, -0.05480756610631943, 0.013588344678282738, 0.008944095112383366, -0.036505088210105896, 0.07097813487052917, 0.009461779147386551, -0.03890755772590637, -0.027537496760487556, 0.014937990345060825, -0.02111099474132061, 0.012837952002882957, -0.01276220753788948, 0.0300943274050951, 0.015204092487692833, -0.035771891474723816, 0.012494280003011227, 0.007303403224796057, -0.007554143667221069, -0.0381101593375206, -0.07624451816082001, -0.051854100078344345, -0.030597800388932228, -0.06096397340297699, 0.010467596352100372, 0.011138753965497017, -0.0486275814473629, 0.000814086408354342, -0.019388707354664803, 0.03071138635277748, 0.014754231087863445, 0.017045235261321068, -0.003983522765338421, 0.05533783510327339, -0.009575063362717628, 0.04014686122536659, -0.0050945584662258625, 0.01115307305008173, 0.10801900178194046, 0.041119497269392014, 0.010686051100492477, -0.06722703576087952, 0.00788760557770729, -0.01573758013546467, 0.01221504621207714, -0.033778466284275055, 0.04392401501536369, 0.03198947012424469, 0.03566785529255867, 0.040183503180742264, 0.05098936706781387, -0.004000256769359112, -0.033612608909606934, 0.07115212827920914, -0.03968674689531326, -0.030071834102272987, -0.009966379031538963, 0.024765878915786743, -0.005318955518305302, -0.02280706726014614, -0.04156859964132309, -0.02002006769180298, 0.00276817474514246, 0.019904593005776405, -0.0138405067846179, -0.01343903224915266, 0.023097816854715347, -0.006020939443260431, -0.03118111751973629, -0.013785969465970993, 0.021184898912906647, -0.004285515286028385, -0.022593246772885323, 0.020860956981778145, -0.00882674939930439, -0.044223472476005554, -0.014077835716307163, 0.039856284856796265, 0.04148538410663605, -0.0323571115732193, -0.02176991105079651, 0.01635701209306717, -0.04349377751350403, -0.010210176929831505, -0.02803369238972664, -0.010266466997563839, -0.016662554815411568, 0.028513502329587936, -0.005212084855884314, 0.01347897294908762, 0.02598397061228752, -0.04380688816308975, -0.028583912178874016, 0.022404741495847702, 0.058624327182769775, 0.003875213209539652, -0.03176478296518326, -0.04366461560130119, 0.044851601123809814, -0.03694940730929375, 0.03752211108803749, 0.03030736744403839, -0.04436104744672775, -0.014938456006348133, -0.0009367146412841976, -0.00473667262122035, 0.0020027628634124994, -0.0013424062635749578, -0.01858433149755001, 0.008481002412736416, -0.01887407712638378, -0.01009535975754261, -0.00219065323472023, -0.008596619591116905, 0.034994110465049744, -0.013028807938098907, -0.000951215683016926, 0.005690700840204954, -0.02999093383550644, 0.03209058567881584, -0.027851669117808342, 0.006879813969135284, -0.019555589184165, 0.02048010565340519, 0.049552932381629944, 0.01846863143146038, 0.007397148292511702, 0.027052579447627068, -0.030835073441267014, -0.02127671055495739, 0.007340520154684782, -0.0436304435133934, 0.011590712703764439, -0.005294112488627434, -0.02811995893716812, 0.008246992714703083, -0.04912609979510307, 0.0351848378777504, 0.043163154274225235, 0.008841893635690212, -0.01872318983078003, 0.02519761398434639, 0.015564602799713612, -0.0013085631653666496, 0.005524901673197746, -0.051711492240428925, -0.02798859030008316, 0.01466973964124918, 0.045309145003557205, -0.031240448355674744, -0.054848864674568176, -0.015722692012786865, -0.015556967817246914, 0.02139286883175373, -0.026403535157442093, -0.017598386853933334, -0.003569958731532097, 0.016583163291215897, 0.048609234392642975, 0.008018968626856804, -0.0005692907143384218, -0.025745010003447533, 0.005359949544072151, 0.02350657619535923, -0.060001250356435776, -0.0224252138286829, 0.016992418095469475, -0.013415679335594177, -0.030820081010460854, 0.010221211239695549, 0.011589200235903263, -0.010131805203855038, 0.010789402760565281, 0.025478024035692215, -0.020802471786737442, 0.031630393117666245, -0.05302593857049942, -0.0015860693529248238, 0.05590805411338806, -0.02629224769771099, -0.034787558019161224, 0.028470071032643318, 0.017341913655400276, 0.03363591432571411, 0.06945554912090302, -0.021246718242764473, -0.02212510071694851, 0.05923260748386383, -0.023658985272049904, -0.00010660471161827445, -0.017225652933120728, 0.02729581482708454, -0.0237396452575922, 0.014085650444030762, -0.003071649931371212, -0.026267869397997856, -0.02479925937950611, -0.003984513692557812, 0.05781487375497818, -0.00585695868358016, -0.010106365196406841, 0.03194122388958931, -0.009540289640426636, 0.008662926033139229, 0.014972837641835213, 0.010900313034653664, 0.023571692407131195, 0.021364882588386536, -0.005997456144541502, 0.03077038750052452, -0.010655837133526802, 0.03068576194345951, -0.09100910276174545, -0.00852788332849741, 0.04816586524248123, -0.0019244231516495347, 0.027704481035470963, -0.031537845730781555, -0.014586801640689373, 0.013390373438596725, -0.039880506694316864, -0.029010675847530365, -0.023701591417193413, -0.006235118955373764, 0.0014971725177019835, 0.026261139661073685, -0.03676101565361023, 0.053867921233177185, 0.009132465347647667, 0.016657955944538116, 0.026976393535733223, 0.000499063462484628, -0.004204242955893278, -0.001315720030106604, -0.05011232942342758, 0.037801023572683334, -0.020422089844942093, -0.02540384605526924, 0.07590990513563156, -0.07191795855760574, -0.030115028843283653, 0.02488548308610916, 0.013592180795967579, 0.02053876593708992, 0.007586004212498665, 0.014241429977118969, 0.021694088354706764, 0.011561990715563297, -0.0025750580243766308, -0.0031685293652117252, -0.018520770594477654, 0.03902474790811539, 0.029301799833774567, 0.026715008541941643, -0.0520811453461647, -0.016466716304421425, 0.039680518209934235, -0.023112116381525993, -0.03668206185102463, 0.02844977378845215, -0.007903754711151123, -0.02191401645541191, 0.011557338759303093, 0.0001661151909502223, 0.016351329162716866, -0.022768521681427956, 0.011821209453046322, -0.009535758756101131, 0.0036182377953082323, 0.019424475729465485, 0.0015696397749707103, 0.014358123764395714, -0.0017399971839040518, 0.013226094655692577, -0.04476248100399971, 0.010252861306071281, -0.011287517845630646, -0.015419106930494308, -0.036682773381471634, 0.017695656046271324, 0.0005883651319891214, -0.033721115440130234, 0.031949613243341446, -0.04521385207772255, -0.06718038022518158, 0.017532048746943474, -0.03810996562242508, 0.020472876727581024, 0.024527952075004578, -0.004906186368316412, -0.02975606918334961, -0.08652155846357346, 0.04688460752367973, -0.009986127726733685, -0.00861608050763607, -0.07593057304620743, 0.0015337483491748571, -0.042500127106904984, 0.016030926257371902, 0.012692549265921116, -0.010532299056649208, 0.0011654975824058056, -0.012356890365481377, -0.009464455768465996, 0.06289996206760406, -0.0062044705264270306, -0.004006255883723497, -0.04158257320523262, -0.010140536352992058, -0.04451167955994606, -0.021991029381752014, -0.01219431683421135, 0.010861228220164776, 0.021278105676174164, -0.008888369426131248, 0.028403660282492638, -0.01849602535367012, -0.0034546074457466602, 0.07132524251937866, 0.009641275741159916, 0.000011684172022796702, 0.04717940837144852, -0.045259684324264526, 0.02553941123187542, -0.006570207420736551, 0.00041633681394159794, -0.030813448131084442, 0.07953057438135147, -0.009543371386826038, -0.020521944388747215, 0.0057930657640099525, 0.015053787268698215, 0.006131442729383707, -0.0650825947523117, -0.016908304765820503, 0.03536337986588478, -0.04630899429321289, 0.013555552810430527, 0.03565831482410431, 0.004976741038262844, 0.04780378192663193, 0.01020196545869112, 0.000733525084797293, -0.01729826256632805, 0.006420286372303963, -0.005668360739946365, -0.013495488092303276, 0.05554463714361191, 0.006240174639970064, 0.023727746680378914, 0.03679409623146057, -0.01981690153479576, 0.04010417312383652, -0.0019625492859631777, 0.04519578814506531, -0.03466726094484329, -0.02154730260372162, -0.0013388680526986718, 0.03907272219657898, 0.013479609042406082, 0.009922949597239494, -0.03327923268079758, 0.0631500706076622, -0.04328093305230141, 0.008950520306825638, -0.048013750463724136, 0.017610648646950722, -0.03439059853553772, -0.012771649286150932, 0.024815022945404053, 0.06537394970655441, 0.015499532222747803, 0.0027172386180609465, -0.01564457267522812, 0.018050318583846092, 0.06448017805814743, -0.018697038292884827, 0.02787405624985695, -0.017521509900689125, -0.023114515468478203, -0.04362069070339203, -0.01463147159665823, -0.03456263244152069, 0.009910362772643566, 0.013766121119260788, 0.05758769437670708, 0.05509282648563385, 0.015272838063538074, -0.04562631994485855, -0.003239303594455123, 0.049439385533332825, -0.05497279763221741, -0.008003244176506996, -0.044507525861263275, 0.015357094816863537, 0.00810431968420744, -0.03665680065751076 ]
<p>I was thinking this may be similar to a Mark and recapture problem where there is a known upper bound, hence the title.</p> <p>I am doing a proportion but sometimes the estimate is larger than the known upper bound. Is there a way to restrict the possible answers to be between the two bounds?</p> <p>Example: Assume out of a known population (U=10,000) a total of (X=8,505) people made (T=25,916) purchases. Of those, only (A=4,697) of them recorded anything with (R=8,632) recorded purchases. </p> <p>The only unknown value is X and we wish to estimate it. </p> <p>Most of the time the ratio estimate works great but does usually over-estimate the true size - and in some cases it is greater than the known population. In this case (X_est/T)=(A/R) which yielded X_est=14,102 which is larger than the known population.</p> <p>Is there a way to incorporate the known population size to limit the estimate between 0 and U? Currently I am just censoring anything above U as U which seems ad hoc as the bounds should be 'built in' to the formula (hopefully).</p>
74,439
[ 0.0009059402509592474, -0.03751362860202789, 0.041327811777591705, 0.017816562205553055, -0.01715567708015442, 0.002146812854334712, -0.01518021896481514, -0.01274961605668068, 0.007225973065942526, -0.045098718255758286, 0.0016931311693042517, 0.03937511518597603, 0.03117917664349079, 0.03578820452094078, 0.02993764355778694, 0.009865373373031616, -0.056609153747558594, 0.007259246427565813, 0.019863268360495567, -0.029967589303851128, 0.0223864559084177, 0.021418770775198936, 0.023599255830049515, -0.03297265246510506, -0.014864827506244183, 0.0341336615383625, 0.052910711616277695, -0.019465258345007896, 0.02022194117307663, 0.07296333461999893, 0.00704164570197463, -0.05626353621482849, 0.02032316103577614, 0.044072769582271576, 0.04417479783296585, 0.011522872373461723, -0.04286902770400047, -0.028542496263980865, -0.03518769145011902, 0.006692111492156982, -0.045203376561403275, 0.002159685594961047, 0.03480152040719986, 0.004054829943925142, 0.01947573386132717, 0.029442114755511284, -0.0037048007361590862, -0.07524926960468292, 0.013953515328466892, -0.04937025532126427, 0.08106163144111633, 0.015916867181658745, 0.041076067835092545, 0.006096506025642157, -0.0033265610691159964, -0.010223758406937122, 0.058078620582818985, 0.10203853249549866, -0.010651522316038609, -0.012093503028154373, -0.01250148843973875, -0.030641639605164528, -0.035155948251485825, -0.01858016662299633, -0.02260715514421463, 0.003363389987498522, -0.05894506350159645, -0.02023298665881157, 0.02913745492696762, -0.03470359370112419, 0.024328215047717094, 0.023886919021606445, 0.007539171725511551, 0.019162436947226524, 0.018043886870145798, -0.03341209515929222, -0.013031861744821072, 0.039933864027261734, 0.05750536173582077, 0.04990777000784874, -0.0002500629343558103, 0.013482930138707161, 0.04686002433300018, 0.0443052239716053, 0.022222312167286873, -0.02744017355144024, 0.04502301663160324, -0.03719598427414894, 0.022924145683646202, 0.03176319971680641, -0.028741218149662018, -0.01821819692850113, 0.055735670030117035, -0.022672506049275398, -0.05840910226106644, 0.03515778109431267, -0.015700289979577065, 0.045144014060497284, -0.04315321519970894, -0.01549429353326559, -0.020589230582118034, -0.03950844332575798, -0.01135981734842062, 0.06799373030662537, -0.03207138180732727, -0.026141678914427757, -0.04128223657608032, -0.039769496768713, 0.02345304749906063, -0.004103217273950577, 0.002036773134022951, -0.010125385597348213, 0.008119245059788227, -0.014909109100699425, -0.009486973285675049, 0.0030470413621515036, -0.003713179612532258, -0.04421577230095863, 0.0609855093061924, 0.05296200141310692, 0.06122997775673866, -0.023137332871556282, 0.03978773206472397, 0.008246981538832188, -0.047830112278461456, 0.030412305146455765, 0.017548227682709694, 0.0031843779142946005, -0.057421330362558365, 0.06767796725034714, 0.0011413280153647065, -0.0015512482495978475, 0.06092663109302521, -0.0018008440965786576, 0.023118913173675537, 0.0022515130694955587, -0.07310812175273895, -0.06200537458062172, 0.02341686747968197, 0.008499721996486187, 0.004348597023636103, -0.0442359559237957, 0.017365295439958572, 0.036364439874887466, 0.020127376541495323, 0.028337353840470314, 0.033069103956222534, 0.009709219448268414, -0.00849517248570919, 0.01947159878909588, -0.0025157032068818808, -0.0004528604622464627, -0.030027449131011963, -0.015470110811293125, -0.01599782146513462, -0.06964601576328278, 0.02290712483227253, -0.009704817086458206, -0.022901730611920357, -0.03413931652903557, 0.04530180245637894, 0.046997927129268646, -0.02191336266696453, -0.013969679363071918, 0.03326749429106712, -0.02358142100274563, 0.07092095166444778, -0.010788033716380596, 0.010833495296537876, -0.0012094313278794289, 0.01353395450860262, 0.0317181758582592, 0.024751653894782066, -0.0029234744142740965, 0.03957647457718849, -0.036234740167856216, 0.00048185259220190346, -0.007524361368268728, 0.0011605049949139357, 0.08117175847291946, 0.010057206265628338, -0.006918611470609903, -0.007251910865306854, -0.0011961646378040314, 0.044062674045562744, 0.007399893831461668, 0.019487936049699783, -0.053356096148490906, 0.005701799876987934, -0.0768418237566948, -0.04582088813185692, -0.06163867935538292, -0.028540238738059998, 0.034515630453825, 0.007012030575424433, 0.011604033410549164, -0.009191405028104782, -0.0006919329753145576, -0.013003535568714142, -0.03716490790247917, -0.018783342093229294, 0.0036867393646389246, 0.021625421941280365, -0.050664424896240234, -0.006778557784855366, 0.04123237356543541, 0.04757725074887276, -0.03375351056456566, 0.054789766669273376, -0.019324563443660736, -0.04274484142661095, -0.00712725892663002, -0.023862561210989952, 0.027732668444514275, -0.00004847914169658907, -0.007357454858720303, 0.014160924591124058, -0.009790563024580479, -0.022942770272493362, 0.03294026851654053, -0.05865217000246048, 0.036192864179611206, 0.05315505340695381, 0.008593137376010418, 0.010359864681959152, -0.0025179714430123568, 0.019050443544983864, -0.003989267162978649, -0.051028087735176086, -0.04771595820784569, -0.07638205587863922, 0.023796018213033676, 0.03555949404835701, 0.0015251957811415195, -0.03727109357714653, 0.01672215946018696, 0.06048291176557541, -0.01614345982670784, 0.021752139553427696, 0.02784719504415989, 0.03441985324025154, -0.0025641079992055893, 0.012242658995091915, 0.024804076179862022, 0.021083993837237358, 0.023782849311828613, -0.006144098937511444, -0.008846117183566093, 0.02530888095498085, -0.01950262114405632, -0.018199071288108826, 0.00007753987301839516, 0.02408197894692421, 0.050986506044864655, -0.005634935572743416, -0.0030541596934199333, 0.028568265959620476, -0.03872514143586159, 0.04359035566449165, 0.0042356643825769424, 0.01573587954044342, -0.01434234157204628, 0.020664092153310776, -0.015588182955980301, 0.027437061071395874, 0.049049586057662964, -0.04846876487135887, 0.011536930687725544, 0.010625144466757774, -0.014919701032340527, -0.02182231843471527, -0.010866059921681881, -0.011505518108606339, -0.03750728443264961, 0.011462612077593803, 0.03930529206991196, 0.010404585860669613, 0.048618003726005554, -0.021149534732103348, -0.006522372830659151, -0.015243744477629662, 0.003927174489945173, 0.009774191305041313, 0.0012848033802583814, -0.06342747807502747, 0.0034827375784516335, 0.020158832892775536, -0.04178618639707565, 0.027946557849645615, 0.022808976471424103, 0.0024611526168882847, 0.011619566939771175, -0.013516683131456375, -0.03590536117553711, -0.01388794369995594, -0.030727362260222435, -0.019170992076396942, 0.003961464390158653, 0.006136270705610514, 0.056520022451877594, 0.03777297958731651, -0.022969339042901993, 0.019038615748286247, -0.04936954751610756, -0.00953498762100935, -0.06655203551054001, 0.008259107358753681, 0.003973339218646288, 0.01024595182389021, 0.032291021198034286, 0.0052036079578101635, 0.007877519354224205, 0.007242690771818161, -0.06527668982744217, -0.055590856820344925, 0.000650641683023423, -0.008152810856699944, 0.04027498513460159, 0.028897106647491455, 0.023882491514086723, 0.05982785299420357, 0.015057793818414211, 0.013015136122703552, -0.01747632957994938, -0.015048724599182606, 0.041701871901750565, 0.006253612227737904, 0.002498827176168561, 0.04481242224574089, -0.024217378348112106, 0.02031722106039524, 0.007863391190767288, 0.03636113926768303, 0.016715120524168015, 0.025438468903303146, -0.009716976433992386, 0.0058554732240736485, 0.014076916500926018, 0.013600463978946209, 0.021545184776186943, 0.03474393114447594, 0.0029089218005537987, 0.02397586591541767, -0.034485846757888794, 0.04853323847055435, -0.0014775920426473022, -0.03752594068646431, -0.03350232169032097, -0.013621718622744083, -0.015823356807231903, -0.006029440090060234, 0.011045346967875957, 0.026394980028271675, -0.030718112364411354, -0.01024333480745554, 0.014131508767604828, 0.03699476644396782, -0.0017481058603152633, -0.01615976355969906, 0.04395204782485962, 0.04183608666062355, -0.0018630174454301596, -0.0023806984536349773, -0.039910152554512024, -0.020673338323831558, 0.008705073967576027, -0.006661808118224144, -0.004922325257211924, 0.0387127660214901, 0.03186940401792526, 0.03608101233839989, 0.006952262949198484, -0.0033133209217339754, -0.007683421019464731, -0.061728399246931076, -0.03278603404760361, -0.02826354093849659, 0.040430136024951935, -0.0035842307843267918, 0.010043416172266006, 0.027317602187395096, -0.01254745852202177, -0.0072889490984380245, 0.05312192440032959, -0.08473248034715652, 0.006663856562227011, -0.02347288466989994, -0.0022336968686431646, -0.0015304632252082229, -0.059845708310604095, 0.023340417072176933, -0.008495143614709377, -0.014937386848032475, -0.01769518107175827, 0.03251981735229492, -0.04171861708164215, 0.012552991509437561, 0.020344726741313934, -0.00047031501890160143, -0.0040739900432527065, -0.0012055335100740194, -0.015553595498204231, -0.00036623195046558976, 0.032482344657182693, 0.013191090896725655, 0.009675214998424053, -0.031896233558654785, -0.026220252737402916, -0.004517844878137112, 0.004634529817849398, 0.06726507097482681, -0.007113612722605467, 0.01645812578499317, -0.07265480607748032, 0.009838541969656944, 0.008998853154480457, 0.045027151703834534, 0.012762202881276608, -0.016193125396966934, -0.04880655184388161, -0.011447340250015259, -0.03482462093234062, 0.01266073901206255, 0.006112904287874699, -0.023156022652983665, 0.00014690618263557553, 0.05706050992012024, -0.002099216217175126, -0.05989506095647812, 0.0004971460439264774, 0.07849778980016708, 0.02662626840174198, 0.04835372418165207, -0.0022254707291722298, 0.025500554591417313, -0.011293171904981136, 0.006220541894435883, -0.008138177916407585, 0.020934972912073135, 0.014613951556384563, -0.004230472259223461, 0.033303745090961456, 0.0053557888604700565, -0.07201052457094193, 0.013358231633901596, 0.013544032350182533, 0.03989651799201965, -0.018844807520508766, -0.04093072935938835, 0.03028842806816101, 0.006844590418040752, 0.03913123905658722, 0.015090062282979488, 0.022009091451764107, -0.09975213557481766, -0.017804989591240883, 0.04088074341416359, 0.05164504423737526, -0.011970472522079945, -0.007756983861327171, -0.061365604400634766, -0.0025581251829862595, 0.014609090983867645, -0.04425846040248871, 0.012827182188630104, -0.05149361118674278, -0.011365750804543495, 0.024964870885014534, -0.02922544628381729, -0.025961806997656822, -0.004215011838823557, -0.030900543555617332, -0.0017372177680954337, 0.0198102667927742, 0.02142479084432125, -0.03122783452272415, 0.011457821354269981, 0.05553481727838516, 0.06811580061912537, 0.003119807690382004, -0.042457375675439835, 0.03156653046607971, 0.012764913029968739, -0.0630059763789177, -0.0644916296005249, 0.016319815069437027, -0.016442298889160156, 0.028805170208215714, 0.04433688521385193, 0.0019846870563924313, -0.017620904371142387, 0.039692558348178864, 0.005915499292314053, -0.02361028641462326, 0.007536763790994883, -0.04034979268908501, 0.02098933234810829, 0.031621091067790985, -0.013509979471564293, 0.031699925661087036, 0.037064600735902786, 0.03900530934333801, 0.014185482636094093, 0.0033611971884965897, -0.01152593083679676, -0.035781197249889374, -0.013730495236814022, -0.051253728568553925, 0.021024083718657494, -0.00829729251563549, 0.01595163531601429, 0.007399086840450764, 0.02904416248202324, -0.03798554465174675, -0.044819362461566925, -0.004679824225604534, 0.021801438182592392, -0.005365260411053896, 0.02608807384967804, -0.011852595955133438, 0.034248724579811096, -0.019285844638943672, -0.006680049933493137, 0.003907793201506138, -0.03313448652625084, -0.0017822278896346688, 0.03155793622136116, -0.03893810883164406, 0.030308492481708527, 0.009949932806193829, -0.059623900800943375, 0.02998669259250164, -0.06400188058614731, 0.05741044878959656, -0.02837000973522663, 0.0196231696754694, -0.03272528946399689, 0.009833539836108685, 0.01312850322574377, 0.05329972505569458, 0.010503321886062622, 0.06065049022436142, -0.01004746649414301, 0.06534606963396072, 0.023410392925143242, 0.0053776041604578495, -0.07061819732189178, -0.009869222529232502, 0.00019534060265868902, 0.040097225457429886, -0.004618612118065357, -0.028613341972231865, 0.001285181613638997, -0.007835987955331802, -0.016731640323996544, -0.048964519053697586, 0.05252066254615784, -0.011683071032166481, -0.019039923325181007, -0.048405639827251434, 0.06293955445289612, 0.07485970854759216, -0.01979893259704113, 0.0029317031148821115, 0.0325431302189827, 0.006127914879471064, -0.010759133845567703, 0.007818853482604027, -0.004924269858747721, -0.04679315537214279, -0.023982636630535126, -0.03037472628057003, -0.003417659318074584, 0.05211232975125313, -0.025374751538038254, -0.02098141796886921, 0.018135325983166695, 0.016179487109184265, 0.02883259579539299, -0.012782988138496876, -0.01686120219528675, -0.029339415952563286, -0.0301227830350399, -0.021414561197161674, -0.0010326753836125135, -0.01418234407901764, 0.007810982409864664, 0.05774115398526192, 0.003582913661375642, -0.02916976995766163, -0.008784698322415352, 0.07784026116132736, -0.012580418027937412, -0.023840101435780525, -0.008504056371748447, -0.019817309454083443, 0.025709964334964752, 0.0026203517336398363, 0.011807199567556381, 0.03785177320241928, 0.02552983909845352, -0.056889139115810394, -0.028526127338409424, -0.03681983798742294, -0.011563831008970737, 0.02331993170082569, -0.010865939781069756, 0.029908668249845505, 0.018699072301387787, 0.005425147246569395, -0.011909140273928642, -0.030358752235770226, -0.026667151600122452, -0.0023515112698078156, -0.0193280428647995, 0.032767534255981445, -0.0006653585005551577, -0.0020000196527689695, 0.009255305863916874, -0.016206974163651466, 0.06373319774866104, 0.018581222742795944, -0.006593676749616861, 0.04183103144168854, 0.01186880562454462, -0.03266288712620735, -0.018028346821665764, 0.001399211585521698, -0.02692577801644802, -0.019790036603808403, -0.03551572188735008, -0.025472799316048622, 0.012682278640568256, 0.03101436421275139, -0.004884706810116768, -0.030173972249031067, -0.06358034908771515, -0.05361684411764145, 0.016627175733447075, 0.0017331921262666583, 0.004390540532767773, 0.07857082039117813, 0.0023398911580443382, 0.02218703180551529, -0.026412785053253174, 0.015288380905985832, -0.02165347896516323, -0.05390869826078415, -0.035929422825574875, -0.04436524584889412, -0.042486611753702164, 0.012117233127355576, 0.00896406639367342, 0.016265876591205597, 0.0403776690363884, -0.0135219506919384, -0.01628321036696434, 0.01753179356455803, 0.03465617075562477, -0.0183577723801136, 0.048340898007154465, 0.0442487858235836, 0.03572237864136696, -0.02741922438144684, 0.03134628385305405, 0.11385989189147949, 0.10284736007452011, 0.0053801038302481174, -0.03388959914445877, 0.00982748530805111, 0.007725683506578207, -0.025322971865534782, -0.05896050110459328, 0.0017507312586531043, 0.019482752308249474, -0.033271659165620804, 0.03573175519704819, 0.0537385419011116, -0.0005774629535153508, -0.011956047266721725, 0.0988955944776535, -0.007101862225681543, -0.011189333163201809, 0.03656204417347908, 0.013159279711544514, 0.001774659613147378, -0.026319844648241997, -0.035078246146440506, 0.03747505694627762, 0.007042048964649439, -0.0196377020329237, -0.04956160485744476, -0.004555619787424803, -0.018271803855895996, 0.014934615232050419, -0.0188001599162817, 0.012141875922679901, -0.005798155441880226, -0.007380797527730465, 0.009251588024199009, -0.04927327483892441, -0.005559696815907955, -0.01660085655748844, -0.010926594026386738, 0.04207311198115349, -0.008899534121155739, 0.017468033358454704, -0.015832621604204178, 0.04967903718352318, -0.04928536340594292, 0.006897120736539364, -0.015510772354900837, 0.017912061884999275, -0.034895528107881546, -0.004086755681782961, -0.026371002197265625, -0.021738167852163315, -0.04169151559472084, -0.01617603190243244, -0.025843612849712372, 0.048778943717479706, 0.027349935844540596, -0.00392987672239542, -0.05201162397861481, 0.014224090613424778, 0.03344963490962982, 0.001931633916683495, 0.01280258223414421, 0.05533825233578682, -0.018356990069150925, -0.018032943829894066, -0.0368066281080246, 0.012527316808700562, 0.01612122543156147, -0.01918306201696396, 0.03550415486097336, -0.021252088248729706, -0.007256131153553724, -0.00643837358802557, -0.011878954246640205, -0.014215849339962006, 0.021961456164717674, -0.006712856702506542, 0.020287787541747093, -0.01773993857204914, -0.02393384836614132, 0.009271524846553802, -0.037524741142988205, -0.018686940893530846, -0.050674937665462494, -0.016077211126685143, -0.01638338901102543, 0.008757952600717545, -0.013523152098059654, 0.021751519292593002, -0.000049005149776348844, 0.08328099548816681, -0.0004965619882568717, 0.010264374315738678, -0.017282633110880852, -0.011205603368580341, -0.06944439560174942, 0.02940286509692669, 0.0445677675306797, 0.05311909317970276, 0.009742917492985725, 0.018490010872483253, 0.010927185416221619, -0.021060459315776825, -0.02300022915005684, 0.034553077071905136, 0.005764366127550602, -0.06442983448505402, -0.021043770015239716, -0.01841745711863041, -0.005802953615784645, -0.008825408294796944, -0.024337751790881157, -0.01841302402317524, -0.041576698422431946, 0.0023028019350022078, -0.015038860961794853, -0.013959941454231739, 0.021263757720589638, -0.027163244783878326, -0.0001901396899484098, 0.02686122991144657, -0.021348580718040466, -0.020246371626853943, -0.03251970559358597, -0.043553028255701065, -0.03700914978981018, -0.018866650760173798, 0.016033463180065155, 0.010819902643561363, 0.0004204533761367202, -0.009176804684102535, -0.003689064644277096, -0.01905711181461811, -0.00873231329023838, 0.0033440834376960993, 0.02532610483467579, 0.03407705947756767, -0.013348094187676907, -0.00309520261362195, 0.06576971709728241, -0.055106621235609055, -0.011577190831303596, 0.013620549812912941, -0.01059158518910408, 0.04602888226509094, 0.011389109306037426, -0.011949148029088974, 0.01016655657440424, 0.03501684218645096, -0.01480180211365223, -0.011738629080355167, 0.01092484500259161, 0.042679257690906525, 0.00811698753386736, -0.03391357883810997, -0.01490052416920662, -0.004635114688426256, -0.03083866275846958, 0.019544806331396103, 0.06003464013338089, 0.0024229842238128185, -0.01343664713203907, 0.028838854283094406, 0.020454298704862595, 0.028062498196959496, -0.007979094050824642, 0.02157641388475895, 0.021895749494433403, 0.020925497636198997, -0.013419621624052525, 0.02237224392592907, -0.003714609192684293, 0.00006569496326847002, -0.0671243667602539, -0.034338049590587616, -0.001864263671450317, 0.003807233413681388, 0.012675900012254715, -0.03966432809829712, -0.014645155519247055, 0.0054877218790352345, -0.010030594654381275, 0.01185667049139738, -0.033878304064273834, 0.023745790123939514, -0.01874721236526966, 0.0006285046110861003, -0.044635169208049774, -0.013874749653041363, 0.027121156454086304, 0.02415388822555542, 0.031808141618967056, 0.006490861997008324, -0.03181762620806694, -0.08929818123579025, -0.008220808580517769, 0.004738405346870422, 0.012566429562866688, -0.07481284439563751, 0.04887378215789795, -0.03201480582356453, 0.004072173498570919, 0.0388188511133194, -0.013728215359151363, 0.03599755838513374, 0.03346613049507141, 0.026230864226818085, 0.0026019432116299868, 0.03389652073383331, 0.034471333026885986, 0.03694678097963333, 0.0323915034532547, 0.0073959981091320515, -0.006459367461502552, 0.003215591423213482, -0.013174755498766899, 0.002200390212237835, 0.06575984507799149, 0.00037450125091709197, -0.018346566706895828, 0.04476990923285484, -0.008882035501301289, 0.036860544234514236, 0.00670655770227313, 0.010597031563520432, 0.005639882758259773, -0.059714607894420624, 0.037726469337940216, -0.007659559138119221, 0.003905936609953642, 0.043674446642398834, 0.024565497413277626, -0.006929760333150625, -0.011536596342921257, -0.003166611073538661, -0.021694960072636604, 0.017751924693584442, 0.006325540132820606, -0.008006913587450981, -0.05119000002741814, 0.013877290301024914, -0.034490812569856644, -0.00020603070151992142, -0.0047470564022660255, 0.01626928523182869, -0.026416325941681862, 0.045412324368953705, -0.01646829955279827, 0.004585134796798229, 0.03824446350336075, 0.048782385885715485, -0.005960238631814718, -0.09518405050039291, 0.057647645473480225, 0.017474738880991936, 0.03399419039487839, -0.013603314757347107, -0.04989520460367203, 0.0035780323669314384, -0.03170613572001457, 0.06264995783567429, 0.01204642839729786, -0.005791117437183857, 0.023849789053201675, 0.029242143034934998, -0.005174881778657436, -0.021198302507400513, 0.03680430352687836, -0.010928461328148842, -0.03378959372639656, -0.003675605868920684, -0.005784413777291775, 0.009099970571696758, -0.01602828875184059, -0.015084296464920044, 0.01602989062666893, -0.024705639109015465, 0.01175578311085701, 0.02138807810842991, 0.023883530870079994, 0.03234393522143364, 0.03542820364236832, 0.026334194466471672, 0.005885981023311615, 0.026560915634036064, 0.004321528133004904, 0.01528667751699686, -0.07269513607025146, 0.043614767491817474, -0.06400512903928757, -0.03601415455341339, -0.019443880766630173, 0.0074420953169465065, -0.006767740473151207, 0.003309168154373765, -0.02810034342110157, 0.034515902400016785, -0.052906401455402374, -0.010248545557260513, 0.013855120167136192, -0.023243268951773643, 0.044704534113407135, -0.024514056742191315, 0.019226323813199997, 0.01107776165008545, -0.02742382511496544, -0.005947073921561241, -0.01977057382464409, 0.007390220183879137, -0.02915334329009056, 0.006065869703888893, 0.05471426993608475, 0.02479134500026703, 0.013715374283492565, -0.013986765407025814, 0.021679261699318886, -0.041295818984508514, -0.031037285923957825, 0.017936676740646362, -0.04396727308630943, 0.030963296070694923, -0.02115156501531601, -0.035773683339357376, 0.04992249235510826, 0.01461780071258545, 0.014881391078233719, -0.07324058562517166, -0.002954669063910842, -0.010902549140155315, 0.011680479161441326, 0.018898596987128258, 0.01009919960051775, -0.0008168116910383105, 0.023356247693300247, -0.023801684379577637, 0.025514036417007446, 0.03457237035036087, -0.029182033613324165, 0.005835814401507378, -0.019604576751589775, -0.017860734835267067, -0.023455729708075523, -0.055303994566202164, -0.0134408138692379, 0.0002657331060618162, 0.025725917890667915, 0.03465200960636139, 0.022859349846839905, 0.010578624904155731, -0.03689152002334595, 0.029211146757006645, 0.03973143547773361, -0.08758774399757385, -0.03461848944425583, -0.039603836834430695, -0.02253713086247444, -0.01685555838048458, -0.05311184003949165 ]
<p>I've been analysing some data using linear mixed effect modelling in R. I'm planning to make a poster with the results and I was just wondering if anyone experienced with mixed effect models could suggest which plots to use in illustrating the results of the model. I was thinking about residual plots, plot of fitted values vs original values, etc. </p> <p>I know this will very much depend on my data but I was just trying to get a feel for the best way to illustrate results of linear mixed effect models. I'm using the nlme package in R.</p> <p>Thanks</p>
74,440
[ -0.041799940168857574, -0.019116761162877083, -0.0022360379807651043, 0.0034183545503765345, 0.01325658056885004, 0.018313024193048477, 0.0010933378944173455, -0.002000137697905302, 0.03636300191283226, -0.03160596638917923, 0.029379459097981453, 0.04163884371519089, 0.04797965660691261, 0.0004918443155474961, -0.007939457893371582, 0.011682447977364063, -0.017782412469387054, -0.04154428094625473, -0.009939968585968018, 0.01379593275487423, -0.022397499531507492, -0.016492214053869247, 0.003344892291352153, 0.007642120122909546, -0.029024040326476097, 0.048867594450712204, 0.06089336425065994, 0.011922783218324184, 0.02427072823047638, 0.04766514152288437, -0.043354056775569916, -0.027277842164039612, 0.021934209391474724, 0.012927046045660973, -0.003975553438067436, -0.028717588633298874, -0.008056365884840488, -0.01257716678082943, 0.030922016128897667, 0.03836212679743767, -0.026133282110095024, 0.01980125904083252, 0.03249238803982735, 0.01677992194890976, -0.016848400235176086, 0.01997707411646843, 0.008252596482634544, -0.01647193171083927, 0.05538127198815346, -0.054957568645477295, 0.05766115337610245, 0.02237718179821968, 0.027928391471505165, 0.03705471009016037, 0.0025628237053751945, 0.025587111711502075, 0.03716147691011429, 0.041501935571432114, 0.02939576841890812, -0.07272907346487045, 0.0035826393868774176, -0.027047714218497276, 0.006518749054521322, -0.02016606740653515, -0.033303625881671906, 0.03136739134788513, 0.038903094828128815, 0.005593004170805216, 0.04766989126801491, 0.007607972715049982, -0.015097047202289104, 0.036914195865392685, 0.06431126594543457, 0.004286373965442181, -0.0006735988426953554, -0.016391821205615997, 0.0026926209684461355, -0.001109166769310832, 0.041952043771743774, 0.023047126829624176, -0.016342289745807648, 0.021060019731521606, 0.008841079659759998, 0.027296634390950203, -0.02737242542207241, -0.016071675345301628, 0.05658586323261261, 0.006747877690941095, 0.032275885343551636, 0.03196777403354645, -0.02859673462808132, 0.009946618229150772, 0.04796404018998146, 0.03614351153373718, -0.05415385589003563, 0.00813822541385889, -0.0033714529126882553, 0.06732556968927383, 0.030849959701299667, -0.014418454840779305, -0.048512544482946396, -0.013487603515386581, 0.00348076899535954, 0.04723955690860748, -0.01705271378159523, -0.008432148955762386, -0.029567144811153412, 0.007065084297209978, -0.0029882933013141155, -0.01792583055794239, -0.029652763158082962, 0.024410702288150787, 0.02319950796663761, 0.0025660600513219833, 0.013990712352097034, -0.06118146702647209, 0.009063915349543095, -0.011000502854585648, 0.08797772228717804, 0.0649305060505867, 0.03727874904870987, -0.0180637426674366, 0.03451511263847351, -0.0016867259982973337, -0.049819063395261765, -0.0012445421889424324, -0.00029264125623740256, -0.026094583794474602, -0.038628753274679184, 0.08008461445569992, 0.0035170174669474363, -0.027758225798606873, 0.039656978100538254, -0.02411867491900921, 0.0578109472990036, -0.01185669843107462, -0.053592607378959656, -0.052897341549396515, 0.008010643534362316, -0.02294127829372883, 0.021685784682631493, -0.017964158207178116, -0.025911277160048485, 0.022541118785738945, 0.027287522330880165, 0.012628338299691677, -0.01312196347862482, 0.0065383026376366615, 0.034432314336299896, 0.0023421149235218763, -0.01912790723145008, 0.03477587178349495, -0.014650652185082436, -0.04102398827672005, -0.026558756828308105, -0.08779598027467728, -0.011420341208577156, 0.028342779725790024, -0.011002907529473305, -0.005023959092795849, 0.03355573117733002, -0.006828388199210167, 0.022291842848062515, -0.014586849138140678, -0.006000909488648176, 0.0027102369349449873, 0.09201215207576752, -0.05368424952030182, 0.026484159752726555, 0.005041675642132759, -0.031179822981357574, 0.03108767792582512, 0.036780230700969696, 0.012057285755872726, 0.02410089410841465, -0.009319148026406765, 0.034968726336956024, 0.014035307802259922, -0.008049077354371548, 0.037067215889692307, -0.05124110355973244, -0.010663093999028206, -0.035106997936964035, -0.018343741074204445, -0.003258185228332877, 0.038342077285051346, -0.03176681324839592, -0.03319535031914711, 0.06917889416217804, -0.03486143797636032, -0.036396581679582596, -0.07469478249549866, 0.035887736827135086, 0.005110953003168106, -0.029026160016655922, 0.013725269585847855, 0.01895791105926037, 0.02904609963297844, 0.007235788274556398, -0.006075436249375343, -0.028689401224255562, 0.012770723551511765, 0.02985038235783577, -0.02851274609565735, -0.008014513179659843, 0.008698568679392338, 0.03920663893222809, -0.023691188544034958, 0.0015231140423566103, -0.030876323580741882, -0.015406735241413116, 0.0016378974542021751, -0.02360941469669342, 0.005701030138880014, -0.011805924586951733, 0.002467368496581912, -0.022664964199066162, 0.02094840072095394, -0.004696905612945557, 0.027614234015345573, -0.045111559331417084, 0.08170373737812042, 0.06448570638895035, -0.01219240017235279, -0.020897239446640015, -0.010974151082336903, 0.011255147866904736, 0.011434693820774555, -0.03994426876306534, 0.02002618834376335, -0.020195234566926956, 0.011865580454468727, 0.050270408391952515, 0.029088566079735756, -0.024754445999860764, 0.035352639853954315, 0.04334745928645134, -0.01392344105988741, 0.016701968386769295, 0.03584616631269455, -0.01866343803703785, -0.015480601228773594, -0.0131729356944561, 0.05054431036114693, 0.0012177202152088284, -0.0010813423432409763, 0.04695340618491173, -0.030938806012272835, 0.027538398280739784, 0.009548846632242203, -0.029623141512274742, 0.05272325500845909, -0.028706857934594154, 0.0059114801697432995, -0.044251516461372375, -0.03419388085603714, 0.06045002117753029, -0.02131841331720352, -0.007337947841733694, 0.02788521535694599, 0.007787476293742657, -0.007919617928564548, 0.018129538744688034, -0.003319439012557268, 0.022575004026293755, 0.016580568626523018, -0.0057356394827365875, 0.007876843214035034, 0.024223772808909416, -0.04630805924534798, 0.01973244547843933, -0.042578816413879395, -0.01760707050561905, -0.043033819645643234, 0.016180286183953285, 0.004872889723628759, 0.009141524322330952, -0.003195712808519602, -0.026646872982382774, -0.027887362986803055, 0.013615528121590614, 0.0028769769705832005, 0.034258875995874405, 0.0022792331874370575, -0.055845633149147034, 0.005113345570862293, -0.06481513381004333, -0.03034888207912445, 0.02807578258216381, 0.011198866181075573, -0.011769304983317852, 0.017939290031790733, -0.03593156859278679, -0.053756993263959885, -0.06389893591403961, -0.014315946027636528, 0.02146122418344021, -0.000011770755008910783, -0.01532123051583767, 0.03251989185810089, -0.00854445993900299, -0.008416174910962582, -0.0036173807457089424, -0.052944958209991455, 0.007661629002541304, 0.018276816233992577, 0.013061875477433205, 0.03267261013388634, 0.03207651898264885, 0.0021954120602458715, 0.0022935327142477036, -0.03210965543985367, -0.013296808116137981, -0.0651872456073761, -0.034379296004772186, 0.016211973503232002, 0.019761253148317337, 0.0010886825621128082, -0.018050666898489, -0.02891595847904682, 0.07175274193286896, 0.03715517744421959, -0.021129067987203598, -0.0735478326678276, -0.00006453193782363087, -0.024314021691679955, 0.0005252345581538975, 0.025095175951719284, -0.0025800862349569798, -0.014343641698360443, 0.03945464640855789, -0.025922326371073723, -0.003913320600986481, 0.018157707527279854, 0.030467631295323372, -0.02051977813243866, 0.00365032278932631, -0.031541503965854645, -0.026060596108436584, 0.016685819253325462, 0.015799209475517273, -0.03829144686460495, 0.03012174367904663, -0.012742478400468826, 0.040759678930044174, -0.02727702260017395, -0.07284460961818695, 0.0043800147250294685, -0.017078278586268425, -0.012452343478798866, -0.011602615006268024, 0.0054044038988649845, 0.021372368559241295, 0.005587008316069841, -0.0004800814494956285, 0.0069398581981658936, 0.01480439119040966, -0.0321323499083519, 0.026791473850607872, 0.02566937915980816, 0.03841651976108551, -0.03898171707987785, 0.00039089328492991626, 0.0010246685706079006, 0.009227815084159374, 0.030644822865724564, -0.031549811363220215, 0.03048279881477356, 0.02977268025279045, -0.020149189978837967, 0.0010263912845402956, -0.00540832057595253, -0.031267471611499786, 0.015734022483229637, -0.08534327894449234, -0.00040912252734415233, -0.03221162036061287, 0.017045045271515846, 0.013813987374305725, 0.027432547882199287, -0.01768292486667633, -0.01555426325649023, -0.014782601036131382, -0.031146517023444176, -0.01992470771074295, 0.07497859001159668, 0.013465618714690208, -0.007611451670527458, 0.03104131482541561, 0.012774418108165264, 0.012775751762092113, -0.017598558217287064, 0.005642250645905733, -0.0059762876480817795, 0.023808609694242477, -0.0009011078509502113, -0.034256432205438614, -0.007041645236313343, -0.05820724368095398, -0.03324791043996811, 0.018296927213668823, -0.004543784540146589, -0.00782801117748022, -0.01293729618191719, 0.015614218078553677, -0.006323149893432856, -0.04434625431895256, 0.008686024695634842, -0.030207902193069458, 0.01086210273206234, 0.04283756762742996, 0.02593662403523922, -0.011474561877548695, -0.023046938702464104, 0.07814851403236389, -0.00486026331782341, 0.05844610929489136, 0.013565730303525925, -0.006578403990715742, 0.024883097037672997, -0.02041417360305786, 0.008555809035897255, -0.029005050659179688, 0.007958156988024712, 0.008225329220294952, -0.005419792607426643, 0.045832790434360504, 0.012143543921411037, -0.022381657734513283, 0.021049873903393745, 0.04545801505446434, 0.00752888573333621, 0.020233215764164925, -0.026609264314174652, -0.013109280727803707, -0.0024285658728331327, 0.02230658009648323, 0.06803485006093979, 0.01286049373447895, 0.03505313768982887, 0.01165839284658432, 0.07281593233346939, -0.01862960495054722, -0.044922009110450745, 0.0017523944843560457, 0.0222660880535841, 0.03640742227435112, -0.00008997982513392344, -0.042216844856739044, 0.012541847303509712, 0.047629520297050476, 0.03110700659453869, 0.012238086201250553, -0.012161067686975002, -0.10029274225234985, 0.009250616654753685, 0.06011331081390381, 0.03221281245350838, -0.00921902060508728, 0.008857051841914654, -0.0330892875790596, -0.023864373564720154, 0.001010152162052691, -0.028464846312999725, -0.001650648657232523, -0.005367592442780733, 0.026575196534395218, -0.028381045907735825, -0.016247352585196495, -0.045661378651857376, 0.011890818364918232, -0.01207050122320652, 0.02242039330303669, -0.02521231770515442, -0.010840019211173058, 0.015223846770823002, 0.029101349413394928, 0.014891676604747772, 0.04673779010772705, 0.002874881960451603, -0.006559526082128286, 0.06653840094804764, 0.011945606209337711, -0.051546595990657806, -0.03261319920420647, 0.042664553970098495, 0.00963200069963932, 0.0022014761343598366, 0.06584477424621582, -0.010537848807871342, -0.016952700912952423, 0.0008632123935967684, 0.012159811332821846, -0.029286818578839302, -0.005709993652999401, -0.024724820628762245, 0.02215953916311264, 0.017856774851679802, 0.016101008281111717, 0.05947824567556381, 0.03844825178384781, 0.015565751120448112, -0.010216041468083858, -0.024820813909173012, 0.05427602306008339, -0.019372951239347458, -0.04549043998122215, -0.07831939309835434, -0.038880009204149246, -0.016753261908888817, 0.052771683782339096, -0.023637041449546814, 0.024038199335336685, -0.03890574723482132, -0.05767650157213211, 0.0186900831758976, 0.04380983114242554, 0.01237693801522255, 0.01242439728230238, 0.025539914146065712, -0.0071679879911243916, 0.01942622661590576, -0.016818737611174583, 0.006970311049371958, -0.00778384180739522, -0.019491340965032578, 0.036792054772377014, -0.04715564846992493, 0.020661601796746254, 0.013161220587790012, -0.023832127451896667, 0.008075406774878502, -0.028597241267561913, 0.03854823485016823, 0.023489419370889664, 0.022823818027973175, -0.0023799953050911427, -0.06859391927719116, -0.018753329291939735, 0.03343762829899788, -0.0024509623181074858, 0.0521632581949234, -0.014839538373053074, 0.017571721225976944, -0.004004699643701315, -0.007520981598645449, -0.05685242637991905, -0.07466589659452438, 0.03155713900923729, -0.014994424767792225, -0.02558022178709507, -0.01588159240782261, -0.011490629985928535, 0.012459360994398594, 0.002382471226155758, -0.003534942166879773, 0.0563708171248436, -0.03038015216588974, 0.018503207713365555, -0.02222287841141224, -0.013861224055290222, 0.0832037702202797, -0.0009432631195522845, -0.02389833889901638, -0.0026275706477463245, -0.03095107525587082, -0.033942811191082, -0.013422352261841297, 0.026419131085276604, -0.033648762851953506, 0.02772047184407711, -0.04628225415945053, 0.03597308322787285, 0.07367868721485138, -0.024953361600637436, 0.015139114111661911, 0.037013232707977295, 0.016726745292544365, -0.004085418302565813, -0.048664990812540054, -0.03032779134809971, -0.04890697821974754, 0.013135600835084915, -0.00017684063641354442, 0.022753624245524406, 0.02831382304430008, -0.03529614582657814, 0.022788766771554947, -0.021480252966284752, -0.032173871994018555, 0.026225967332720757, 0.07463248074054718, 0.014066684059798717, -0.016702573746442795, 0.015404008328914642, -0.015451529063284397, 0.0215858593583107, -0.022075112909078598, 0.007059914059937, 0.0056481389328837395, 0.029138166457414627, -0.0367719829082489, -0.024865640327334404, -0.02149391546845436, -0.00423612492159009, 0.057213783264160156, 0.014678268693387508, 0.04339734464883804, 0.06347764283418655, -0.008386689238250256, 0.0004268986522220075, -0.03940447419881821, -0.006788056809455156, -0.036801498383283615, 0.0019529074197635055, 0.04655005410313606, -0.034779056906700134, 0.0036952104419469833, 0.014678732492029667, 0.014116620644927025, 0.020862804725766182, 0.03375142440199852, 0.0058496855199337006, 0.0012016507098451257, 0.055050838738679886, 0.015259130857884884, -0.053618162870407104, -0.012009788304567337, -0.038459185510873795, 0.039858538657426834, -0.041342079639434814, -0.011695857159793377, 0.012768102809786797, 0.0353231281042099, 0.003036672715097666, -0.029250096529722214, -0.012478468008339405, -0.06333401054143906, 0.002443576231598854, 0.02625042013823986, -0.029355162754654884, 0.030978407710790634, 0.015962708741426468, 0.08565368503332138, -0.03749946877360344, 0.02842000126838684, -0.04526000842452049, -0.07482267916202545, -0.04434124380350113, 0.006882671266794205, 0.01097327284514904, 0.015247301198542118, -0.008062847889959812, -0.0179611649364233, 0.00992054957896471, -0.06604528427124023, -0.004976687021553516, 0.0031345391180366278, 0.03657182306051254, 0.016172531992197037, 0.053326793015003204, -0.02918088436126709, -0.024574609473347664, -0.002074695657938719, -0.01714102178812027, 0.12790003418922424, 0.05525599792599678, 0.046615537256002426, -0.1163107380270958, 0.050801511853933334, 0.0444900207221508, 0.017618538811802864, 0.012403445318341255, 0.03699280321598053, 0.007389391772449017, 0.014916447922587395, 0.058391034603118896, 0.04815887287259102, -0.004500013776123524, -0.00015006244939286262, 0.038922861218452454, 0.0006466747145168483, -0.03573117405176163, -0.026588596403598785, -0.02708444558084011, -0.036716315895318985, -0.004006810951977968, -0.10498975217342377, 0.008987950161099434, 0.025400009006261826, -0.02659871056675911, -0.019511165097355843, -0.0390186570584774, 0.0167006216943264, 0.04883124679327011, -0.004435644950717688, 0.008234714157879353, -0.01632460579276085, 0.026081020012497902, -0.0005059667746536434, -0.03400145098567009, 0.013646350242197514, -0.009064020588994026, 0.02691170945763588, 0.05443437024950981, -0.0040889885276556015, -0.00651672063395381, -0.005999322049319744, -0.004387811291962862, -0.030997153371572495, -0.03656498342752457, -0.025980040431022644, 0.06934792548418045, 0.006798857357352972, -0.015786826610565186, -0.0051077185198664665, 0.02696586586534977, -0.033092085272073746, -0.02273576892912388, -0.03046444244682789, 0.02337668277323246, 0.0052257864736020565, 0.0066156527027487755, -0.002592195523902774, -0.033109817653894424, 0.030867574736475945, 0.0016052236314862967, 0.019956154748797417, 0.052370477467775345, -0.024964461103081703, -0.015669308602809906, -0.0348539799451828, 0.04149211198091507, 0.029990214854478836, -0.0066252658143639565, 0.011493757367134094, -0.015709947794675827, -0.014471896924078465, 0.006228780839592218, 0.014958241954445839, 0.04390040785074234, 0.019697735086083412, -0.007377524860203266, -0.016443943604826927, -0.003596759866923094, -0.06230441480875015, 0.02274378389120102, 0.003920195624232292, -0.03604183346033096, -0.012827662751078606, -0.005757002625614405, 0.0690135732293129, 0.010670391842722893, -0.004092132207006216, -0.023069461807608604, -0.025914698839187622, 0.0506792776286602, 0.011009410955011845, -0.07425565272569656, -0.0030538481660187244, 0.0368637777864933, -0.02855290099978447, -0.048849090933799744, -0.031443651765584946, 0.05853327736258507, 0.02310173399746418, 0.006286158226430416, 0.004974254406988621, 0.034541528671979904, 0.032121315598487854, 0.0032447739504277706, 0.017120059579610825, -0.07174781709909439, 0.002294752513989806, -0.03788207471370697, -0.011117331683635712, -0.01703980378806591, -0.002433370565995574, -0.01203765720129013, -0.02700815349817276, -0.016075007617473602, -0.01823309250175953, -0.010662478394806385, 0.05005396902561188, -0.025213997811079025, -0.002833741018548608, -0.0282290056347847, -0.00017770964768715203, -0.04907470569014549, -0.03408609703183174, 0.04262005165219307, -0.025684554129838943, 0.002935622585937381, -0.015296380035579205, -0.0026146869640797377, -0.007719318848103285, 0.01287764497101307, 0.00637073814868927, 0.01311539951711893, -0.029900113120675087, 0.04166695848107338, 0.008473839610815048, 0.022713612765073776, 0.015318209305405617, 0.002377517055720091, 0.012013662606477737, -0.03358803689479828, -0.011052826419472694, -0.010912532918155193, -0.0025149048306047916, -0.02030257135629654, -0.008956613019108772, 0.01898861862719059, -0.03304794058203697, 0.03450028970837593, -0.014867744408547878, -0.038627393543720245, -0.009309825487434864, -0.009098827838897705, -0.00747259333729744, 0.01579888164997101, 0.015848299488425255, -0.01223959494382143, 0.0006732741603627801, 0.030884316191077232, 0.0437721349298954, -0.005890455562621355, 0.011034445837140083, -0.01280512847006321, -0.03465010225772858, 0.05449488386511803, -0.0005987316835671663, -0.011981843039393425, 0.05201791226863861, 0.039024703204631805, -0.03388194367289543, 0.03929712623357773, -0.009625617414712906, 0.014858647249639034, -0.08672786504030228, -0.03141236677765846, 0.008526014164090157, 0.024959975853562355, 0.030909651890397072, -0.055283673107624054, 0.006786743178963661, 0.06717323511838913, -0.048989877104759216, -0.00910324789583683, -0.00676144752651453, -0.011293593794107437, -0.012557792477309704, -0.003466417081654072, -0.006268731318414211, 0.016435574740171432, -0.0038412425201386213, 0.04923001676797867, 0.010165483690798283, -0.0022333478555083275, 0.012269114144146442, -0.00013457884779199958, 0.015484703704714775, 0.015536914579570293, 0.03251182660460472, -0.07522719353437424, 0.03833983838558197, -0.0003754388017114252, -0.05283132940530777, 0.013880816288292408, 0.0028423627372831106, 0.0364021360874176, 0.00908547081053257, 0.01640056073665619, -0.02089214324951172, 0.059822116047143936, 0.00010747428314061835, -0.016425546258687973, -0.008528466336429119, -0.035950418561697006, 0.023213069885969162, 0.0063299317844212055, -0.02560790814459324, 0.01896202191710472, 0.0027484658639878035, -0.0009775512153282762, -0.03158613294363022, 0.008228844031691551, -0.00502845598384738, -0.07530391961336136, -0.01181965135037899, 0.006450635381042957, 0.027750838547945023, -0.03282735124230385, 0.030236952006816864, -0.041110552847385406, 0.03662342578172684, 0.04046738147735596, -0.0018545199418440461, -0.018502287566661835, 0.024825118482112885, -0.02008420042693615, -0.025058098137378693, -0.016627652570605278, -0.011190277524292469, -0.034177135676145554, -0.05397640913724899, -0.011551948264241219, -0.001097365515306592, 0.023372290655970573, -0.02354251779615879, 0.01784113049507141, -0.0386069118976593, 0.010711866430938244, -0.030359815806150436, 0.004056660924106836, -0.014875911176204681, -0.04029818996787071, 0.006313004065304995, -0.05727880075573921, 0.05991203710436821, 0.019773803651332855, -0.016712788492441177, -0.0651107057929039, 0.012979781255126, -0.004019996616989374, 0.032909370958805084, 0.04174598678946495, 0.00966945942491293, -0.011941834352910519, -0.0409916527569294, 0.010219852440059185, 0.014944707974791527, -0.044887758791446686, 0.0478285551071167, -0.014667619951069355, -0.016199180856347084, -0.019431544467806816, 0.023357659578323364, 0.010650010779500008, 0.030310258269309998, 0.03076324053108692, -0.007467750459909439, 0.017783161252737045, -0.040215205401182175, -0.0061734626069664955, 0.02826080471277237, 0.02635321579873562, -0.037552908062934875, 0.05617915466427803, 0.011532511562108994, 0.006980569567531347, 0.02440958097577095, -0.005769768264144659, -0.018252979964017868, 0.0315110981464386, -0.0035459052305668592, -0.002065387787297368, -0.0035305453930050135, -0.04257558286190033, -0.003090527607128024, -0.10376067459583282, 0.030905816704034805, -0.012785017490386963, 0.01223127730190754, -0.007422300986945629, 0.01647528074681759, 0.019792506471276283, 0.03952178731560707, 0.009882588870823383, 0.02805454470217228, -0.003769242437556386, -0.0008805014658719301, -0.0029725534841418266, -0.0032386991661041975, 0.015897514298558235, 0.015683533623814583, -0.03342418745160103, 0.0224695336073637, -0.027545589953660965, 0.053507786244153976, -0.022959714755415916, 0.05947810038924217, -0.02537018433213234, 0.024492882192134857, 0.003043183358386159, -0.013104821555316448, 0.015023954212665558, 0.0035187797620892525, 0.001718933810479939, 0.03951358422636986, -0.0760088562965393, 0.03453811630606651, -0.058719705790281296, -0.06024874374270439, -0.02805275097489357, -0.007863293401896954, 0.010613893158733845, 0.05127689614892006, 0.0014792039291933179, 0.010414354503154755, -0.0261867456138134, -0.021185846999287605, 0.02762667089700699, -0.0013729092897847295, 0.023171037435531616, -0.024539824575185776, -0.021863218396902084, -0.017622029408812523, -0.0175948403775692, 0.003225533990189433, -0.008784730918705463, 0.045514337718486786, 0.013834171928465366, -0.017186321318149567, -0.04027029499411583, -0.04524194076657295, 0.002120157703757286, 0.03348881006240845, -0.07761620730161667, -0.0408107228577137, -0.01711691915988922, -0.0038471603766083717, 0.041841696947813034, 0.01795821078121662 ]
<p>I have 50 measurements of 10 descriptors and 1 binary output variable.</p> <p>I want to use a classification procedure to be able to predict the output, so I split the data into a training and a test set and I can then generate my classifier (I am using a decision tree) and test it on the test set.</p> <p>Now, obviously the choice of test set is absolutely arbitrary and, whatever the result of my procedure, I cannot be certain that the result I get for that specific test set is similar to what I will get from any other test set.</p> <p>So, would I have a point in repeating my classification several times, each time with a randomly chosen test/training set, then report the distribution of misclassification errors for my classifier?</p> <p>I understand that this is a bit similar to what Random Forests are doing, but I am wondering if this procedure makes sense also when applied to other type of classifiers, not necessarily decision trees.</p>
37,315
[ -0.0343705490231514, 0.006515283603221178, -0.024386480450630188, -0.020134909078478813, 0.01660328544676304, 0.0252530574798584, -0.013183852657675743, -0.0059194182977080345, 0.013166945427656174, 0.002961702411994338, 0.02931356243789196, 0.02193554863333702, 0.02902364358305931, -0.010070674121379852, -0.011982863768935204, 0.012032133527100086, -0.03756755217909813, 0.0085070189088583, -0.012068770825862885, -0.025364600121974945, 0.0013274443335831165, 0.024546004831790924, 0.01986498385667801, -0.02950284630060196, -0.040154892951250076, 0.017369726672768593, -0.011177849024534225, -0.024509714916348457, 0.030612921342253685, 0.021441271528601646, -0.03103027306497097, -0.025472063571214676, -0.0006756997900083661, 0.06933319568634033, 0.05187635123729706, -0.0007619188982062042, -0.010659592226147652, -0.022870758548378944, -0.03855031356215477, 0.0026562924031168222, -0.019496550783514977, -0.0014929812168702483, 0.004041370004415512, 0.05454832315444946, 0.004639457445591688, -0.015601628459990025, -0.011424368247389793, -0.04382236674427986, 0.01947357878088951, -0.06773041188716888, 0.0698881596326828, -0.004680486861616373, 0.041851457208395004, 0.07327790558338165, 0.0006939310114830732, -0.018106229603290558, 0.058213166892528534, 0.07366742193698883, -0.04304119944572449, 0.0014678597217425704, 0.020588155835866928, -0.019855588674545288, 0.01832411251962185, 0.04692685231566429, -0.05230296403169632, 0.020296135917305946, 0.01817789487540722, -0.03363581374287605, 0.005851563531905413, -0.007293052040040493, 0.026919502764940262, 0.006398832891136408, 0.02350050024688244, -0.017477715387940407, 0.026569955050945282, 0.01048946101218462, 0.007853400893509388, 0.026621315628290176, 0.030317243188619614, 0.011039133183658123, 0.014808191917836666, 0.018554875627160072, 0.01720656268298626, 0.05417516455054283, 0.027306165546178818, -0.01175643689930439, 0.08401083946228027, -0.0172065868973732, 0.034416910260915756, 0.018265193328261375, 0.03136579692363739, 0.013486106880009174, 0.029980167746543884, -0.00604162085801363, -0.03243931755423546, 0.0518668033182621, -0.01817219890654087, 0.03626452758908272, 0.01666145771741867, 0.02029113657772541, 0.0005617590504698455, -0.017431804910302162, 0.011759915389120579, 0.033120736479759216, -0.05104042962193489, -0.02556542120873928, -0.03022930584847927, -0.01274989452213049, -0.0018355266656726599, -0.0005223497282713652, 0.009279631078243256, 0.036495376378297806, 0.009503860957920551, 0.018844202160835266, 0.042156342417001724, 0.009733018465340137, 0.004894115962088108, -0.004284338094294071, 0.003598547773435712, 0.042310506105422974, 0.018188416957855225, -0.06152487173676491, 0.03363119810819626, -0.04035688936710358, -0.0199741218239069, 0.014051591977477074, 0.027286911383271217, -0.018061451613903046, -0.044887475669384, 0.036995869129896164, -0.017656832933425903, -0.0014946161536499858, 0.05471247062087059, -0.02459793910384178, 0.017010530456900597, -0.0052114203572273254, -0.0983450636267662, -0.037201475352048874, -0.01230420172214508, -0.020612701773643494, 0.009494113735854626, -0.0568232424557209, -0.011404437012970448, 0.017054935917258263, 0.022407114505767822, -0.004483819007873535, 0.0535597950220108, 0.006956126540899277, 0.03172479197382927, 0.003775401972234249, 0.010163521394133568, -0.008564618416130543, 0.0007627853192389011, -0.023283889517188072, -0.034312911331653595, -0.08460494875907898, 0.01601896807551384, 0.019230369478464127, -0.011240299791097641, -0.03840243071317673, -0.026041466742753983, -0.011996905319392681, -0.0033177100121974945, 0.007204380817711353, 0.007880565710365772, -0.024790247902274132, 0.07681268453598022, 0.0180443674325943, 0.08627502620220184, 0.011026640422642231, 0.004795770160853863, -0.010073104873299599, 0.02363666705787182, 0.03747382387518883, 0.0736851617693901, -0.03580379858613014, 0.003882315242663026, -0.015802161768078804, 0.05250078812241554, -0.02596021443605423, -0.018942050635814667, -0.02197154611349106, -0.002913357689976692, -0.0036006353329867125, 0.016869142651557922, -0.019321998581290245, 0.009318270720541477, 0.017788581550121307, 0.04309285432100296, -0.053971897810697556, -0.037031978368759155, -0.043603215366601944, -0.012225281447172165, -0.054864753037691116, -0.007428604178130627, 0.03281067684292793, 0.0054360199719667435, 0.02303670346736908, -0.010014882311224937, -0.05429777875542641, -0.053315501660108566, 0.005613232031464577, 0.03130395710468292, -0.03344786539673805, -0.0035814172588288784, 0.04759140685200691, -0.009682773612439632, -0.016087152063846588, 0.06285694241523743, -0.0461980476975441, -0.08808230608701706, 0.021322499960660934, -0.015736836940050125, 0.013001170940697193, -0.02803100273013115, 0.009047397412359715, 0.05554366111755371, 0.002567974152043462, -0.019270189106464386, 0.041505105793476105, -0.05137959122657776, 0.06755184382200241, 0.10109654814004898, -0.014840370044112206, -0.008927037008106709, 0.004219048656523228, -0.004334006924182177, 0.030415615066885948, -0.03598102182149887, -0.029098626226186752, -0.06900201737880707, -0.0014591962099075317, 0.014585443772375584, 0.0030406529549509287, -0.008798959665000439, 0.01870393007993698, 0.05041001737117767, 0.000749197497498244, 0.0009079124429263175, 0.047698479145765305, 0.024838900193572044, -0.014871104620397091, 0.0050774854607880116, 0.01580687239766121, 0.02728951722383499, 0.019965125247836113, 0.02930397540330887, -0.023328082635998726, 0.018750399351119995, -0.007491663098335266, 0.0188568327575922, 0.05721066892147064, -0.01881266012787819, 0.010671308264136314, 0.0009652061853557825, -0.03797849267721176, 0.017651332542300224, -0.029335450381040573, 0.01826859824359417, 0.03385532647371292, 0.031166331842541695, -0.003620763309299946, -0.025574734434485435, -0.006849458906799555, 0.04176151752471924, 0.044136252254247665, -0.008437776006758213, -0.018422190099954605, 0.0421690009534359, -0.06296612322330475, 0.013644901104271412, -0.0007842084742151201, -0.030851364135742188, -0.033366117626428604, 0.05286652594804764, 0.021507591009140015, -0.016792336478829384, 0.021667294204235077, -0.02155218832194805, 0.009448210708796978, 0.016072236001491547, -0.03030102141201496, 0.04192929342389107, -0.0030009469483047724, -0.03689942881464958, -0.011567553505301476, -0.02925155498087406, -0.04261881858110428, 0.02849709615111351, -0.011094631627202034, -0.04125582426786423, 0.012796495109796524, 0.0095138531178236, -0.030625948682427406, -0.05960268899798393, -0.036535102874040604, 0.01098418328911066, -0.03600882738828659, -0.03600536659359932, 0.0537487231194973, 0.007653838023543358, -0.029483193531632423, 0.008968385867774487, -0.03246935456991196, -0.005419655703008175, -0.006800921633839607, -0.053530238568782806, 0.018080491572618484, -0.019157717004418373, 0.009398175403475761, 0.0496119000017643, -0.02268815226852894, -0.026299811899662018, -0.051556188613176346, -0.08458330482244492, 0.018092986196279526, -0.007019054610282183, 0.03796948119997978, 0.021982356905937195, 0.022184327244758606, 0.08507456630468369, 0.04279280826449394, -0.014521113596856594, -0.00016946224786806852, 0.01667991280555725, -0.03266632929444313, -0.03158668801188469, 0.0038273863028734922, 0.0010620219400152564, -0.027100328356027603, 0.00575588783249259, -0.005321205127984285, 0.01062561571598053, 0.04740659147500992, -0.03919830918312073, -0.01644338294863701, 0.015645500272512436, 0.0564672127366066, -0.0037986612878739834, 0.013139799237251282, 0.004395195282995701, -0.03591844066977501, -0.004768006503582001, -0.014874584041535854, 0.019670600071549416, 0.03561095893383026, -0.05971807986497879, 0.03366933763027191, -0.01926581934094429, 0.047144584357738495, -0.0022181987296789885, 0.011980893090367317, -0.003240907099097967, -0.04146847501397133, -0.031175697222352028, 0.013383574783802032, 0.04341314360499382, -0.003074072999879718, -0.020890628919005394, 0.040214017033576965, 0.037419259548187256, 0.02131856605410576, -0.03128087893128395, -0.027354994788765907, -0.010600805282592773, 0.029226865619421005, -0.014408514834940434, 0.009454239159822464, 0.02955099195241928, 0.04102078452706337, 0.036268532276153564, -0.019145479425787926, -0.051226504147052765, 0.0014132511569187045, -0.04360184818506241, -0.017986249178647995, -0.0297416802495718, 0.050618644803762436, 0.018960071727633476, 0.024382002651691437, 0.00743601331487298, -0.04070592671632767, 0.01734563522040844, 0.018974365666508675, -0.07284445315599442, 0.012071299366652966, 0.015435290522873402, -0.04017132520675659, -0.005774855148047209, -0.0399283729493618, 0.03591972589492798, -0.02838306315243244, 0.0037628381978720427, 0.015775814652442932, 0.003468702780082822, -0.052090082317590714, -0.00040952174458652735, -0.02008313499391079, -0.009390465915203094, 0.011966561898589134, 0.015508625656366348, -0.005345958285033703, 0.005058101378381252, 0.021012265235185623, -0.0024778563529253006, 0.01174596045166254, -0.005453468766063452, -0.015320620499551296, 0.028356140479445457, -0.020760415121912956, 0.04754256829619408, 0.018840264528989792, 0.021259333938360214, -0.08839724212884903, 0.025029486045241356, -0.023318009451031685, 0.04159998893737793, 0.038075849413871765, -0.025912685319781303, -0.02942475490272045, -0.050793178379535675, -0.04485844075679779, 0.016963252797722816, 0.015253929421305656, 0.023644331842660904, -0.03724800795316696, 0.04205853492021561, 0.018699724227190018, -0.06500141322612762, -0.0044317543506622314, 0.056893154978752136, -0.010237140581011772, 0.0020219990983605385, -0.01111528743058443, 0.00381001946516335, 0.005801443476229906, -0.012562394142150879, 0.012760727666318417, 0.032037414610385895, -0.038914814591407776, 0.004012277815490961, 0.038060642778873444, 0.014290345832705498, -0.03164810314774513, 0.021043621003627777, 0.015506727620959282, 0.029508136212825775, 0.00040442432509735227, -0.00038750877138227224, 0.0238123070448637, 0.0380839966237545, 0.016788402572274208, 0.03202413022518158, -0.006280538626015186, -0.07247472554445267, 0.012410162016749382, 0.05404912680387497, 0.011473880149424076, -0.05838112533092499, -0.004012019839137793, -0.03936108201742172, -0.015413299202919006, 0.006585328374058008, -0.04263081029057503, 0.01461189053952694, -0.011781697161495686, 0.008592533878982067, -0.051217276602983475, 0.0019006627844646573, -0.021272948011755943, 0.0013741246657446027, -0.06025400385260582, 0.0666576623916626, -0.0020983193535357714, -0.023602662608027458, -0.020998645573854446, 0.015069408342242241, 0.014792867936193943, 0.08989080041646957, -0.03543125092983246, -0.018089817836880684, -0.004222574178129435, 0.008500614203512669, 0.0023735782597213984, -0.056957826018333435, -0.03758426010608673, 0.0016737153055146337, 0.026878008618950844, 0.011142836883664131, -0.004270309116691351, -0.05522242188453674, 0.012064317241311073, 0.012316318228840828, -0.04546719789505005, -0.0035273870453238487, -0.005923097021877766, 0.026536449790000916, 0.034504249691963196, 0.012567831203341484, 0.04289867356419563, 0.022432047873735428, 0.027692649513483047, 0.03494846448302269, -0.012939978390932083, 0.03935971483588219, -0.06157486513257027, -0.032237615436315536, -0.026914477348327637, 0.007624750956892967, -0.020392021164298058, 0.038959261029958725, -0.014761626720428467, 0.05516565218567848, 0.004325637128204107, -0.04225163534283638, 0.002207973273470998, 0.016854334622621536, -0.015349633991718292, -0.013667653314769268, -0.021821485832333565, 0.03218326345086098, -0.01916782185435295, 0.024173369631171227, -0.015661051496863365, 0.018558289855718613, 0.024791814386844635, 0.05064954608678818, -0.049769122153520584, 0.024168286472558975, -0.049700621515512466, -0.01989586278796196, 0.026410674676299095, -0.02330741286277771, 0.025890463963150978, 0.028344914317131042, 0.037340983748435974, 0.014057177118957043, -0.03815532475709915, 0.0031075873412191868, 0.022877482697367668, -0.005062039941549301, 0.02407364919781685, -0.050526417791843414, -0.001080655725672841, -0.051511429250240326, 0.011033623479306698, -0.0869896337389946, -0.0368506982922554, 0.018626345321536064, 0.002473104977980256, -0.019594930112361908, -0.0066637941636145115, 0.01359062921255827, 0.023076176643371582, -0.009801718406379223, -0.016620801761746407, 0.06775373220443726, -0.011576196178793907, -0.03227242827415466, -0.0003974784049205482, 0.012917403131723404, 0.08521947264671326, -0.009257552213966846, 0.03288324922323227, 0.017884356901049614, -0.014887882396578789, -0.02778928354382515, 0.021782338619232178, -0.019168613478541374, -0.026291677728295326, -0.021339835599064827, -0.026889363303780556, 0.025330454111099243, 0.027592532336711884, 0.004163891542702913, 0.002237550914287567, -0.0011979590635746717, -0.011318271979689598, 0.002943706000223756, -0.03686879947781563, 0.027887964621186256, -0.021685784682631493, -0.02480275370180607, -0.030429553240537643, 0.018060576170682907, -0.022152887657284737, 0.010104184970259666, 0.014590678736567497, 0.0038884314708411694, -0.007005532272160053, 0.05240698903799057, 0.05427217110991478, -0.02271556481719017, -0.009021754376590252, -0.007742324844002724, -0.0682104304432869, 0.03105173259973526, 0.027693631127476692, -0.002492415951564908, 0.025174317881464958, 0.01896645501255989, -0.02195468544960022, 0.00797314289957285, -0.021946851164102554, -0.030411113053560257, 0.05340222641825676, 0.018192993476986885, 0.060262810438871384, 0.0521470308303833, 0.015355940908193588, 0.033796731382608414, -0.03454165160655975, 0.025826720520853996, -0.017437400296330452, 0.01449433621019125, 0.044307611882686615, 0.0357922799885273, -0.00017252004181500524, -0.002026107395067811, 0.031009603291749954, 0.043512407690286636, 0.053999949246644974, -0.0003447138296905905, 0.021367020905017853, 0.042085200548172, -0.03770960122346878, -0.031754158437252045, 0.035605449229478836, -0.04084226116538048, -0.022695163264870644, -0.03045950084924698, -0.025197448208928108, 0.028762562200427055, 0.029555469751358032, 0.02923247404396534, -0.040743909776210785, -0.01969589851796627, -0.055960413068532944, 0.04098677635192871, -0.006893704179674387, 0.004796971566975117, 0.04280277341604233, 0.010547956451773643, 0.002062374260276556, 0.006761485245078802, 0.010817939415574074, -0.007094044703990221, -0.06108776852488518, -0.0607495941221714, -0.029960010200738907, -0.051548365503549576, 0.03060501255095005, 0.00858357548713684, -0.00692756986245513, -0.005173486191779375, -0.02503374218940735, 0.047908999025821686, -0.0036168615333735943, 0.05666948854923248, -0.027260852977633476, 0.029364045709371567, 0.0073878467082977295, 0.03228136524558067, 0.012844022363424301, -0.010230761021375656, 0.12017492204904556, 0.04971747845411301, 0.04843926057219505, -0.027842560783028603, 0.02116062305867672, 0.0117570785805583, 0.012760981917381287, 0.0017865615664049983, 0.021892022341489792, 0.01427931897342205, -0.0016114793252199888, 0.013440047390758991, -0.0034779582638293505, -0.00023407126718666404, -0.01904183253645897, 0.061452317982912064, 0.007721900939941406, 0.0031536861788481474, 0.0344248041510582, 0.009172302670776844, 0.009610207751393318, 0.0017303255153819919, -0.022961581125855446, 0.02533525787293911, -0.013131972402334213, 0.006916344631463289, 0.006030516233295202, -0.005229762755334377, 0.012467429041862488, 0.01960184797644615, -0.0034623262472450733, 0.01072908565402031, 0.027821052819490433, -0.01578972302377224, 0.020220264792442322, -0.007382553070783615, -0.007335548289120197, -0.00486495066434145, 0.004043527413159609, 0.046162813901901245, 0.004406898282468319, -0.021756766363978386, -0.011367397382855415, 0.008916249498724937, -0.058017268776893616, -0.022671520709991455, -0.05099417641758919, 0.06532088667154312, -0.03919050097465515, -0.030743993818759918, -0.008080991916358471, -0.04099614545702934, 0.030142877250909805, -0.06550127267837524, -0.018716396763920784, 0.015302854590117931, 0.01081728283315897, -0.04084888845682144, -0.041188403964042664, -0.041611190885305405, 0.05266508460044861, -0.002747026039287448, 0.020680096000432968, -0.006277579814195633, -0.04737269505858421, -0.01285372395068407, -0.016282442957162857, 0.04385146498680115, 0.024981757625937462, 0.010893300175666809, -0.0019358540885150433, -0.014370582066476345, -0.037952881306409836, -0.03258755803108215, -0.01851067692041397, 0.006772636901587248, 0.014742832630872726, -0.003676836611703038, -0.01416105404496193, -0.0310736745595932, -0.024301229044795036, 0.0012213314184919, -0.03468412905931473, 0.018338823691010475, -0.04835997894406319, 0.0028145010583102703, 0.008086085319519043, 0.07434326410293579, 0.0481986440718174, -0.0006102895131334662, 0.03730080649256706, 0.025441501289606094, -0.000888944196049124, -0.043218787759542465, 0.012095248326659203, -0.006010718643665314, -0.033868659287691116, 0.04281426966190338, -0.020141202956438065, 0.05437491461634636, 0.03266754746437073, 0.022484799847006798, -0.026868857443332672, 0.010680212639272213, 0.01232742890715599, 0.02956116385757923, 0.010912042111158371, -0.04593583941459656, -0.001319117727689445, 0.0024270701687783003, 0.018321765586733818, -0.04908132553100586, -0.05680186301469803, -0.06157940626144409, -0.024696677923202515, 0.010035566054284573, -0.029386181384325027, -0.018528064712882042, 0.003174367593601346, -0.01191103458404541, 0.045294299721717834, -0.015545224770903587, -0.025667773559689522, -0.02265576273202896, -0.008129451423883438, -0.038815341889858246, -0.01506582647562027, -0.0061021712608635426, -0.01834951341152191, -0.00045592518290504813, 0.0012363502755761147, 0.06664033234119415, 0.014234008267521858, -0.009456850588321686, 0.007822124287486076, 0.014735707081854343, -0.01672820746898651, 0.0528385303914547, -0.023728152737021446, 0.024058356881141663, 0.029519492760300636, -0.04305235669016838, 0.002853712532669306, 0.05078371614217758, -0.01205749437212944, 0.035419777035713196, -0.00168943265452981, -0.016896504908800125, -0.011333570815622807, 0.053295668214559555, 0.0075493683107197285, -0.02158878743648529, -0.0198486540466547, -0.0005809374270029366, 0.01015235111117363, 0.04000069200992584, 0.040059830993413925, 0.01692885346710682, 0.00231208186596632, 0.007135923486202955, 0.021180754527449608, 0.03071812354028225, -0.017275193706154823, 0.017048029229044914, -0.0007865986553952098, 0.006994358729571104, -0.01232693251222372, -0.0022192616015672684, -0.006332273129373789, 0.041236162185668945, -0.03440731018781662, 0.05026267096400261, -0.0011174805695191026, 0.003600896568968892, -0.09372144937515259, -0.03253959119319916, 0.02244647778570652, 0.02703339233994484, -0.003517410485073924, -0.024770407006144524, -0.020067088305950165, 0.016281889751553535, -0.052759166806936264, 0.04506180062890053, -0.003493969328701496, -0.020238056778907776, -0.04829812049865723, 0.0070923143066465855, -0.04529000073671341, -0.014317055232822895, 0.06909716129302979, 0.0030395372305065393, 0.028961727395653725, 0.04308587312698364, -0.006749295629560947, -0.01074786763638258, -0.015261862426996231, 0.015913626179099083, -0.0024866184685379267, -0.043241266161203384, 0.03163091465830803, -0.030248280614614487, -0.05498574674129486, 0.021111730486154556, -0.0044721998274326324, 0.008760123513638973, 0.047882627695798874, 0.0002809040015563369, 0.0010424971114844084, 0.04652174189686775, 0.04758806154131889, -0.0014342194190248847, 0.03693731129169464, 0.0013922160724177957, 0.004972346592694521, -0.011979663744568825, -0.0038323714397847652, 0.005764869973063469, 0.024216311052441597, -0.015003678388893604, -0.01679902710020542, 0.03867185488343239, -0.004250174853950739, -0.03423009812831879, -0.025279082357883453, 0.01643000915646553, 0.009279139339923859, 0.0014165829634293914, -0.01222869660705328, -0.05618833750486374, 0.018566127866506577, 0.02763207256793976, 0.005170905962586403, 0.011595018208026886, 0.031121360138058662, -0.0369386188685894, -0.04989611357450485, -0.0012285583652555943, 0.00869139563292265, -0.008931956253945827, -0.07852482050657272, -0.0021605289075523615, 0.009613526985049248, -0.016153579577803612, -0.020952627062797546, -0.02002307027578354, 0.017200209200382233, 0.058609962463378906, -0.020010139793157578, 0.02735089510679245, 0.02005561627447605, -0.03693801537156105, -0.022993529215455055, -0.09602732211351395, 0.08609675616025925, -0.0083845229819417, -0.04743986949324608, -0.037812817841768265, 0.003805064596235752, -0.036784954369068146, 0.0017179956194013357, 0.03254607319831848, 0.01658955030143261, 0.02188257873058319, -0.033925604075193405, 0.025813903659582138, 0.01110744010657072, -0.07640930265188217, 0.024206865578889847, -0.024601010605692863, -0.046844083815813065, -0.031217584386467934, -0.017012562602758408, 0.009219937026500702, 0.0010997786885127425, 0.004698632284998894, -0.013999633491039276, -0.01074222195893526, -0.0066161868162453175, 0.0002445215650368482, 0.037866633385419846, -0.014386214315891266, 0.03698241338133812, 0.006996039301156998, -0.027335306629538536, 0.007693031802773476, 0.030694743618369102, -0.018330907449126244, -0.056047555059194565, -0.02585340104997158, -0.04271682724356651, -0.010618872009217739, -0.03102126531302929, 0.0318371020257473, 0.0030145628843456507, -0.05335712805390358, 0.008117186836898327, 0.00004891597927780822, -0.018835898488759995, 0.00008043122943490744, 0.06119401380419731, 0.0027567909564822912, 0.03368103504180908, -0.032999854534864426, 0.054648205637931824, -0.0013563723769038916, -0.0042199804447591305, 0.008822068572044373, 0.0025844962801784277, -0.001386414747685194, -0.01204763539135456, 0.022835250943899155, 0.011663375422358513, -0.017657248303294182, 0.03113238327205181, -0.0016826263163238764, 0.0725240558385849, -0.028543122112751007, 0.012706522829830647, 0.025926882401108742, -0.019274530932307243, 0.003790820250287652, 0.018465226516127586, -0.024210436269640923, 0.05883172154426575, -0.02439991571009159, -0.02287709340453148, -0.06675871461629868, -0.054455339908599854, 0.01362239383161068, 0.0068324473686516285, 0.014796714298427105, 0.051373742520809174, 0.03013400174677372, 0.04730910807847977, -0.02969675324857235, 0.003591615706682205, 0.06519768387079239, -0.0366593636572361, 0.01056133583188057, -0.018264399841427803, -0.010792667046189308, 0.0083931814879179, -0.01168543566018343, -0.030744757503271103, -0.021234823390841484, -0.00734171224758029, 0.07392958551645279, 0.011535697616636753, 0.004004085436463356, -0.029936334118247032, 0.004606227390468121, 0.005387233104556799, -0.03233855962753296, -0.012357075698673725, -0.045324116945266724, 0.02842050977051258, 0.018803272396326065, -0.04976160451769829 ]
<p>In King and Zheng's paper: <a href="http://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/0s.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/0s.pdf</a></p> <p>They mention about $\tau$ and $\bar{y}$. I already have data with 90000 0's and 450 1's. I have already fitted a logistic regression with the whole data and want to make a prior correction on the intercept. </p> <p>Or should it be that I take about 3000 0's and 450 1's and then run logistic regression and then apply the prior correction on intercept? would then $\tau$ = 450/90450 and $\bar{y}$ = 450/3450? </p> <p><strong>Edit</strong> Based on answer from <code>Scortchi</code></p> <p>I am trying to predict probability of a matchmaking happening. A match might be happening between a buyer and seller, two possible individuals in a dating site, or a job seeker and prospective employee. A 1 is when a match happens, zero for all other pair-wise interactions that have been recorded. I have real life data from one of these use cases. As said before, the rate of 1's in the data is very small (=450/(450+90000). I want to build a logistic regression model with correction from King et.al.</p> <p>The data I have can be presumed to be all possible data i.e. it is the whole universe. I would presume the rate of 1's in the universe would be 450/(450 + 90000).</p> <p>I want to sample all the 1's (450 of them) and a random 3000 0's from this data universe. This would be sampling based on 1's. Once the logistic regression is built on this, I want to make a bias correction.</p> <p>Is it right to presume here that $\tau$ = 450/(450 + 90000) and $\bar{y}$ = 450/(450+3000)?</p> <p>I am arguing that $\tau$ is indeed the universe estimates because for my use case I pretty much have all the target population data. My question is, with the current setup of the problem how would $\tau$ and $\bar{y}$ be defined? Running time is not the issue, but how to make the bias correction for a rare event is the issue.</p>
37,316
[ -0.01931575872004032, -0.012032992206513882, 0.027850698679685593, -0.00156019302085042, 0.03926527127623558, 0.0009750632452778518, -0.011550835333764553, -0.025328658521175385, -0.007038602605462074, -0.027867009863257408, 0.05707897990942001, 0.06430208683013916, 0.017318880185484886, 0.0540003776550293, 0.002921011997386813, 0.020626088604331017, 0.018219100311398506, 0.026129741221666336, -0.0011730282567441463, -0.024976924061775208, 0.011415388435125351, 0.022837119176983833, 0.015632111579179764, -0.035099372267723083, -0.04374094307422638, -0.010084428824484348, 0.008141487836837769, -0.044997990131378174, -0.026288801804184914, 0.05167068913578987, -0.015503701753914356, -0.005215322133153677, 0.021373316645622253, 0.022956840693950653, 0.006009202916175127, 0.03792780637741089, -0.028905756771564484, -0.059164393693208694, 0.011413867585361004, 0.019829314202070236, -0.015576652251183987, -0.0098639577627182, -0.0009273375035263598, 0.03705313429236412, -0.0028899682220071554, -0.013162046670913696, -0.015824278816580772, -0.0658850222826004, 0.025989726185798645, -0.018613118678331375, 0.024271110072731972, -0.019228819757699966, 0.035878848284482956, -0.02896267920732498, -0.02137238346040249, -0.016225609928369522, 0.05324855446815491, 0.056331049650907516, 0.022926384583115578, -0.03977178409695625, 0.011637941002845764, -0.04046647995710373, 0.006222842261195183, -0.000011954205547226593, -0.011331794783473015, 0.07047057896852493, -0.019003938883543015, -0.04517694190144539, 0.031040959060192108, -0.02408798597753048, 0.0475732795894146, -0.002740174764767289, 0.0128498999401927, 0.007387795485556126, 0.00531848706305027, -0.010306044481694698, -0.0180511511862278, 0.016849515959620476, 0.04782244190573692, 0.027646664530038834, -0.01508682407438755, -0.022136053070425987, 0.05838596820831299, 0.051334455609321594, 0.0316554419696331, -0.0028118633199483156, 0.05624273419380188, -0.02990090101957321, 0.016558997333049774, 0.022450629621744156, 0.0017438699724152684, 0.033895645290613174, 0.022440070286393166, -0.02221321128308773, -0.03238925710320473, 0.049168623983860016, 0.003356827422976494, 0.039241574704647064, -0.022090667858719826, -0.004532719496637583, -0.02868782728910446, -0.07976503670215607, -0.002475777408108115, 0.059792470186948776, -0.046635910868644714, -0.040985506027936935, -0.03982853516936302, -0.012897789478302002, -0.0018529128283262253, -0.0549943782389164, -0.023971417918801308, 0.02972354367375374, -0.0190940722823143, -0.006872913800179958, 0.005407753866165876, 0.01558651216328144, 0.012827066704630852, -0.009622814133763313, 0.07156409323215485, 0.01551045011729002, 0.037781257182359695, -0.040653396397829056, -0.0018929464276880026, -0.003268197877332568, -0.019490692764520645, -0.004542543552815914, 0.0020075265783816576, -0.012829517014324665, -0.048860106617212296, 0.014834405854344368, -0.021791396662592888, -0.033906739205121994, 0.026969142258167267, 0.028713904321193695, 0.04921093210577965, 0.005886290222406387, -0.0582270622253418, -0.03511969745159149, 0.048170872032642365, 0.00526345893740654, 0.022265486419200897, -0.0639556273818016, -0.018757838755846024, 0.05379493534564972, 0.043573882430791855, 0.01267104223370552, 0.04956291615962982, 0.031295474618673325, 0.021753033623099327, 0.034524187445640564, -0.05389229580760002, -0.0029662810266017914, -0.03341668099164963, -0.04221149906516075, -0.028567148372530937, -0.05330309271812439, 0.03643352538347244, 0.03471782058477402, -0.017133258283138275, 0.0022820038720965385, 0.01813972368836403, 0.017635945230722427, -0.02312542498111725, -0.0019345955224707723, -0.00338990637101233, 0.007568940054625273, 0.0870303064584732, 0.024475175887346268, 0.055044025182724, 0.014675378799438477, -0.026798220351338387, 0.020022450014948845, 0.004565043840557337, 0.0288693904876709, 0.03502875193953514, -0.023062391206622124, 0.014497336931526661, -0.004802726674824953, 0.009950317442417145, -0.013062180019915104, -0.0028364022728055716, 0.0034324144944548607, -0.009930841624736786, -0.022001884877681732, 0.0065677654929459095, 0.014872142113745213, -0.01705661416053772, 0.001310263411141932, 0.02028128132224083, -0.0532396174967289, -0.04084813594818115, -0.04576036334037781, -0.02248396910727024, 0.012306799180805683, -0.009411223232746124, 0.028076348826289177, -0.03218916431069374, -0.02719957008957863, -0.010171785019338131, -0.02614443004131317, -0.022727329283952713, -0.012575950473546982, 0.07200125604867935, -0.017859090119600296, -0.01181398332118988, 0.08107954263687134, 0.022520557045936584, -0.003812575014308095, 0.04512133076786995, -0.06559373438358307, -0.02326757274568081, 0.023370398208498955, -0.010664180852472782, 0.011723289266228676, -0.023989537730813026, 0.0005980266141705215, 0.017185844480991364, -0.039541278034448624, -0.029155658558011055, 0.02601573057472706, -0.09010682255029678, 0.04706152155995369, 0.061498094350099564, -0.013006431981921196, -0.008389908820390701, 0.01083989255130291, 0.01822545751929283, 0.004631528630852699, -0.011855117045342922, -0.006169629283249378, -0.06698471307754517, -0.021189844235777855, 0.019499177113175392, -0.00880448892712593, -0.005004739388823509, -0.015660936012864113, 0.06590206176042557, 0.016559451818466187, 0.001137955579906702, 0.009547076188027859, -0.0455828495323658, -0.015532438643276691, 0.02553621679544449, 0.015116493217647076, 0.03431222587823868, -0.0033792147878557444, 0.027312355116009712, -0.00551996473222971, 0.023996656760573387, 0.01989964209496975, -0.016163025051355362, 0.0021826946176588535, 0.009314164519309998, 0.02044461853802204, -0.018702195957303047, -0.00762234628200531, 0.024037426337599754, -0.005066862795501947, -0.009878849610686302, 0.029913654550909996, 0.02878796122968197, -0.010960869491100311, -0.0049019455909729, -0.009287712164223194, -0.01734098792076111, 0.051939237862825394, -0.02960023656487465, 0.010716023854911327, 0.015915540978312492, -0.041820935904979706, 0.017200762405991554, 0.014379081316292286, -0.07771340757608414, -0.024659816175699234, 0.006614902522414923, -0.009653174318373203, 0.04565063491463661, -0.013924979604780674, -0.06118647754192352, -0.021181384101510048, -0.02123231440782547, 0.018130093812942505, 0.03359929844737053, 0.001324362470768392, -0.08054894208908081, 0.00070651137502864, -0.022556988522410393, -0.004222439136356115, -0.0006890294025652111, 0.015360738150775433, -0.012854457832872868, 0.0477561391890049, -0.01759636215865612, -0.031166108325123787, -0.055197544395923615, -0.004956640303134918, -0.02958264946937561, -0.007318449672311544, 0.004663172177970409, 0.03162645921111107, 0.05691207945346832, -0.0345952995121479, 0.03331773355603218, -0.012266077101230621, -0.03872183710336685, -0.036324236541986465, -0.01567424088716507, -0.01946454867720604, 0.00678649777546525, 0.012891220860183239, 0.008101407438516617, 0.04811418429017067, -0.0024585591163486242, -0.12189477682113647, -0.05305826663970947, 0.02922382578253746, 0.018242238089442253, 0.035258445888757706, 0.017605092376470566, -0.008057291619479656, 0.06464840471744537, 0.0490340031683445, 0.0010073109297081828, -0.016202054917812347, 0.022116737440228462, -0.0029964798595756292, -0.039912860840559006, 0.023465102538466454, 0.019712042063474655, 0.011457919143140316, 0.026996653527021408, -0.0421438030898571, 0.019536606967449188, 0.04652275890111923, 0.006377412471920252, 0.02212231233716011, 0.026988763362169266, -0.02707470767199993, 0.016616977751255035, 0.027004264295101166, 0.025494808331131935, 0.008703906089067459, 0.04904492199420929, 0.0029932213947176933, -0.0037124764639884233, 0.017030443996191025, -0.08648625761270523, 0.022160550579428673, 0.01140561979264021, -0.0026553901843726635, -0.014809503220021725, 0.030551642179489136, 0.022568795830011368, -0.0620526485145092, -0.022160375490784645, 0.006146361120045185, 0.03597218915820122, -0.012488686479628086, -0.011599227786064148, 0.04307626932859421, 0.02172771468758583, -0.010670309886336327, 0.027129460126161575, -0.009289833717048168, -0.027970153838396072, 0.013534720987081528, -0.043824609369039536, -0.022193634882569313, 0.007830770686268806, 0.07091622799634933, 0.013995751738548279, -0.01266901008784771, -0.018404120579361916, -0.009156870655715466, -0.031030328944325447, -0.011319136247038841, -0.0126158706843853, 0.03513968735933304, 0.027861209586262703, 0.025628164410591125, -0.006820549722760916, -0.019737938418984413, -0.011107262223958969, 0.0525544136762619, -0.060433972626924515, 0.002381066558882594, -0.0001509248249931261, -0.039077889174222946, 0.028048232197761536, -0.09939368069171906, 0.057555656880140305, -0.029419399797916412, 0.01663840375840664, -0.024319222196936607, -0.022410612553358078, -0.027523107826709747, 0.027350841090083122, -0.03600451350212097, -0.010859176516532898, -0.012744003906846046, 0.0330096073448658, 0.007578667253255844, 0.04522138461470604, 0.04014252498745918, 0.03832705318927765, -0.014563259668648243, -0.01836666278541088, -0.01920316554605961, 0.018597794696688652, 0.044189807027578354, 0.0458763986825943, 0.010808326303958893, -0.004659683909267187, -0.0568590946495533, 0.02188907563686371, -0.009839726611971855, 0.02780492790043354, 0.08314921706914902, -0.03595474362373352, -0.009945697151124477, -0.015248811803758144, -0.009339965879917145, 0.0027957584243267775, 0.053206443786621094, -0.024697527289390564, -0.02098829858005047, 0.062349531799554825, 0.03530627116560936, -0.03351205214858055, 0.0048529221676290035, 0.0776931643486023, 0.028940461575984955, 0.0015964563935995102, -0.018819084390997887, -0.03520512208342552, -0.0032823430374264717, 0.02836925908923149, 0.0006203620578162372, 0.023266954347491264, 0.008082401007413864, -0.00560350064188242, 0.027222059667110443, 0.042333777993917465, -0.06362896412611008, -0.02300301194190979, 0.02520289272069931, 0.06211141124367714, -0.020091217011213303, -0.084929458796978, 0.027748847380280495, 0.06750448793172836, 0.00603724317625165, 0.0017400337383151054, 0.008240773342549801, -0.08153162151575089, 0.013860451057553291, 0.020368384197354317, 0.05730423703789711, -0.049418676644563675, -0.011044135317206383, -0.04442955553531647, -0.012665468268096447, -0.014738126657903194, -0.006177023518830538, 0.022633707150816917, -0.018581893295049667, 0.035512976348400116, -0.0050315274856984615, -0.04434525594115257, -0.07820762693881989, 0.04384845495223999, -0.029064655303955078, 0.030406715348362923, -0.019274571910500526, -0.01358725130558014, 0.0009313917253166437, 0.031918615102767944, 0.017091069370508194, 0.04788566380739212, -0.032152194529771805, -0.0025776303373277187, 0.04312765598297119, 0.014152014628052711, 0.019087014719843864, -0.059949565678834915, 0.05699882656335831, -0.012080092914402485, 0.003944645635783672, 0.055894553661346436, 0.0001614948851056397, 0.005947659723460674, 0.047756459563970566, 0.013625185936689377, -0.015549127012491226, -0.025853723287582397, -0.025502178817987442, 0.037235476076602936, 0.03579236567020416, 0.004177279770374298, 0.04678181931376457, 0.03250794857740402, -0.00880141369998455, 0.016240738332271576, -0.053235143423080444, -0.02013392560184002, 0.0059960088692605495, 0.003322592470794916, -0.047925058752298355, -0.0044610509648919106, -0.02300974726676941, 0.008128308691084385, -0.008183087222278118, 0.008212078362703323, -0.004638394806534052, -0.03434130549430847, 0.0034940815530717373, 0.014419530518352985, -0.04588969051837921, 0.03512943163514137, -0.00976577028632164, 0.001906922901980579, -0.002745347563177347, 0.042290568351745605, -0.006410272791981697, -0.04652875289320946, 0.0343051552772522, -0.004496186040341854, -0.005463877692818642, 0.013566022738814354, -0.09085430204868317, -0.021067893132567406, 0.01360120065510273, -0.02450885809957981, 0.044865984469652176, 0.027493678033351898, 0.07271333038806915, 0.025359516963362694, -0.02118745446205139, -0.01077924482524395, -0.002905072644352913, 0.013011843897402287, 0.03140224888920784, 0.009118717163801193, 0.03512192890048027, -0.012945557944476604, -0.023473825305700302, -0.03754749149084091, -0.017630379647016525, 0.01966981589794159, -0.031040314584970474, -0.016143513843417168, -0.020208576694130898, -0.02389810048043728, -0.005347021389752626, -0.005293992348015308, 0.017124919220805168, 0.05830830708146095, -0.031770508736371994, -0.029731085523962975, -0.055777017027139664, 0.03313504531979561, 0.04395502805709839, 0.036392662674188614, -0.023114273324608803, 0.03794652596116066, -0.01727178320288658, 0.02586057037115097, 0.028465978801250458, 0.006649741902947426, -0.051244497299194336, -0.03297516331076622, -0.05303962528705597, -0.0021163690835237503, 0.03392896056175232, 0.0032140682451426983, -0.0037136576138436794, -0.008258522488176823, -0.0020446544513106346, 0.006877260282635689, 0.0022041883785277605, 0.010456260293722153, 0.0205320306122303, -0.029502542689442635, -0.024868173524737358, 0.01679212972521782, 0.046312637627124786, 0.01627623848617077, 0.04357702285051346, -0.0026855499017983675, -0.0338895358145237, 0.027356168255209923, 0.0562276765704155, 0.01371872890740633, -0.0001399796747136861, -0.04131554439663887, -0.016107354313135147, 0.04785556718707085, -0.005698667839169502, -0.02043890580534935, 0.016165269538760185, 0.013359271921217442, -0.020577160641551018, -0.03191491961479187, -0.04762612283229828, 0.029877375811338425, 0.04487698897719383, 0.03780502453446388, 0.03797512874007225, 0.0338728241622448, 0.016400331631302834, -0.012482916936278343, -0.04333292320370674, 0.0036475316155701876, -0.019698403775691986, -0.026041695848107338, 0.01894208788871765, -0.04307013750076294, -0.00873968843370676, 0.02750854566693306, 0.03240176662802696, 0.03963109478354454, 0.0020640299189835787, 0.028444552794098854, -0.001101845526136458, 0.04709160700440407, -0.048673633486032486, -0.013807713985443115, 0.048163365572690964, -0.034246690571308136, 0.024979619309306145, -0.027234505861997604, -0.014279116876423359, 0.04169883951544762, 0.043282270431518555, 0.024116815999150276, -0.045401811599731445, -0.03793663904070854, -0.070530466735363, 0.008345150388777256, 0.021488917991518974, 0.0031171967275440693, 0.03513229265809059, -0.01920361816883087, 0.015152382664382458, -0.028992144390940666, 0.007086990401148796, -0.0045188539661467075, -0.07117326557636261, -0.02234574221074581, 0.011506016366183758, -0.0649571493268013, 0.007034406531602144, 0.02510899305343628, -0.03617818281054497, 0.0300846379250288, -0.04343375936150551, 0.02290014736354351, -0.0015279684448614717, 0.03500063717365265, -0.008472350426018238, 0.06432750821113586, 0.013213108293712139, 0.02019479125738144, -0.020596956834197044, -0.0013680382398888469, 0.153260737657547, 0.06081335246562958, 0.02296082302927971, -0.03379127010703087, 0.006894227582961321, -0.005491591989994049, -0.03529869765043259, -0.03449933975934982, -0.02955668233335018, -0.009644654579460621, -0.04011057689785957, 0.02587761916220188, 0.0074943117797374725, 0.03387900069355965, -0.018697742372751236, 0.039503440260887146, -0.05726420879364014, -0.021603163331747055, -0.0030397509690374136, -0.011279243044555187, 0.015390651300549507, -0.026685286313295364, -0.013771828263998032, -0.010693378746509552, 0.011220132000744343, -0.021587686613202095, -0.03287748247385025, -0.014695275574922562, 0.0018397403182461858, 0.0305309034883976, 0.011688530445098877, -0.004510156810283661, -0.0016206371365115047, -0.024353887885808945, 0.02688097581267357, -0.007205341011285782, 0.021519577130675316, -0.05446556583046913, 0.004412876442074776, 0.03417172655463219, -0.03312310203909874, 0.002861376851797104, 0.01253069844096899, -0.033366281539201736, -0.037926819175481796, -0.019513914361596107, -0.05735546723008156, 0.03464149683713913, -0.007829880341887474, -0.0020522356498986483, -0.03583558648824692, -0.003627507481724024, 0.02891472540795803, -0.023841172456741333, 0.002227559918537736, 0.05916964262723923, 0.015583950094878674, -0.015513305552303791, -0.003391754347831011, -0.008021091111004353, 0.026150628924369812, 0.02101716585457325, 0.021708765998482704, 0.0273969117552042, -0.0385298915207386, 0.011030910536646843, -0.030391983687877655, 0.03551216796040535, 0.023982636630535126, -0.001328917103819549, 0.0043947030790150166, -0.008880484849214554, -0.055820465087890625, -0.029226945713162422, -0.01284018438309431, 0.003882837947458029, 0.04542834684252739, -0.0172270517796278, 0.012807327322661877, -0.033469393849372864, -0.03182582929730415, -0.008447842672467232, -0.04514158144593239, -0.019827235490083694, -0.04852680861949921, -0.016095243394374847, 0.002265090821310878, 0.02563677355647087, 0.032989464700222015, 0.010234286077320576, -0.006057643797248602, 0.06818448007106781, 0.01296011358499527, -0.011977664195001125, -0.03284435719251633, 0.01189485751092434, -0.0508369579911232, 0.002053661737591028, -0.0014685149071738124, 0.058039940893650055, 0.055052801966667175, 0.03208007663488388, 0.050968147814273834, -0.002708396641537547, -0.01400460209697485, -0.015026256442070007, 0.044174954295158386, -0.052531898021698, 0.02153117209672928, 0.013462454080581665, -0.006328364368528128, 0.003885806305333972, -0.04294944182038307, -0.015369877219200134, -0.02968418598175049, -0.007970087230205536, -0.028640862554311752, -0.036588266491889954, 0.03597387298941612, 0.004736895207315683, -0.024063369259238243, -0.020902495831251144, -0.021894274279475212, -0.001048543374054134, 0.030394550412893295, -0.024986473843455315, 0.02052244544029236, 0.014498550444841385, 0.005219348706305027, 0.020154399797320366, 0.03781254589557648, 0.020237822085618973, -0.015735547989606857, -0.0021203772630542517, -0.0067301164381206036, 0.031964514404535294, -0.019739588722586632, -0.006488496903330088, -0.05214376747608185, -0.020406672731041908, -0.010090875439345837, -0.0522599034011364, -0.01455209031701088, 0.03600725904107094, 0.007332409732043743, 0.03146129474043846, 0.0026896849740296602, -0.01597425527870655, -0.033568985760211945, 0.01497683860361576, -0.021265743300318718, -0.022913286462426186, -0.017239132896065712, 0.01762271858751774, 0.018115533515810966, -0.018228378146886826, 0.019431980326771736, 0.02133820950984955, 0.019513793289661407, 0.007351236417889595, 0.03170613572001457, 0.0163822490721941, -0.0027447727043181658, -0.0012226294493302703, -0.006342281121760607, -0.02565647102892399, -0.012968463823199272, -0.03546232357621193, -0.005927824415266514, 0.06408118456602097, 0.0005587373743765056, 0.026583297178149223, 0.0163978673517704, 0.01921757496893406, -0.09762874990701675, -0.052349288016557693, 0.05873194709420204, 0.04182719439268112, 0.00802877452224493, -0.04666389152407646, -0.010528413578867912, 0.029443584382534027, -0.0187088456004858, 0.0018674657912924886, 0.02156894840300083, 0.0012189800618216395, -0.03354319930076599, 0.014175436459481716, -0.0077568585984408855, -0.02052786946296692, 0.03993985429406166, 0.01902531087398529, -0.0007162122055888176, 0.011416194960474968, 0.009136563166975975, -0.02261706069111824, 0.001249967492185533, 0.007440723013132811, 0.006429976783692837, -0.025889690965414047, 0.03307809680700302, -0.03594617545604706, -0.004170033615082502, 0.033251743763685226, 0.025852469727396965, -0.00996890477836132, 0.02972876839339733, 0.036214038729667664, 0.008746796287596226, 0.01931607350707054, 0.04616832733154297, 0.018537016585469246, 0.04328233376145363, 0.013122188858687878, 0.03455669432878494, 0.041300565004348755, -0.034539204090833664, 0.012682531960308552, -0.0067986962385475636, -0.024999231100082397, -0.02308717928826809, 0.022849159315228462, -0.0033917706459760666, 0.0022067714016884565, 0.007272901013493538, -0.0037117928732186556, 0.006177115719765425, -0.009475870989263058, -0.022178389132022858, -0.020470961928367615, 0.021130740642547607, 0.0272678155452013, 0.0255512073636055, -0.011824958957731724, 0.009249742142856121, -0.024276619777083397, 0.01745935156941414, 0.017475681379437447, -0.008809526450932026, -0.008139042183756828, -0.06572140008211136, -0.015786994248628616, -0.03222428634762764, -0.04189920425415039, -0.013496726751327515, 0.014970927499234676, -0.04573018103837967, 0.02089626155793667, -0.04278859496116638, -0.020994463935494423, -0.001356826163828373, 0.014201456680893898, 0.036917638033628464, -0.0792999342083931, 0.054696470499038696, 0.018340328708291054, 0.008905178867280483, -0.037381529808044434, -0.03420116379857063, -0.027719488367438316, -0.02189643681049347, 0.027204157784581184, -0.001867806538939476, -0.009546240791678429, -0.01542677078396082, 0.0213781725615263, -0.0038552707992494106, 0.0032904562540352345, 0.05691525340080261, -0.009272870607674122, -0.03760791942477226, -0.01564633473753929, 0.006661329418420792, 0.00031614062027074397, 0.04576718807220459, 0.004260411951690912, -0.01580900512635708, 0.01880801096558571, 0.00679134763777256, -0.031623002141714096, 0.06035323813557625, 0.025289790704846382, 0.0339176207780838, 0.035665713250637054, 0.010101967491209507, 0.037632305175065994, 0.055777959525585175, -0.013640146702528, -0.10487568378448486, 0.04153314605355263, -0.05160757899284363, -0.020809592679142952, 0.023139605298638344, -0.0033111320808529854, -0.018119055777788162, -0.033497828990221024, 0.03150998428463936, 0.022907400503754616, 0.005722822621464729, 0.00912348460406065, 0.011724582873284817, -0.02049853280186653, 0.03875818848609924, -0.028984511271119118, 0.04619252309203148, -0.007253739982843399, -0.020133933052420616, -0.020934950560331345, -0.027894724160432816, 0.0072693959809839725, -0.009793884120881557, 0.01978042721748352, 0.05412115156650543, 0.007300371769815683, 0.001582704484462738, 0.024462956935167313, 0.015049593523144722, 0.0012257624184712768, 0.0039970302022993565, 0.029058074578642845, 0.006753186695277691, -0.015685416758060455, 0.021739086136221886, 0.003079488640651107, 0.04175005108118057, -0.05132108926773071, 0.010779277421534061, -0.04936289042234421, -0.013627751730382442, -0.017788691446185112, 0.009038635529577732, -0.006940444931387901, 0.0001141535904025659, -0.011222071945667267, -0.009844006039202213, 0.01102530024945736, 0.0010856047738343477, 0.030169673264026642, -0.056690145283937454, 0.007724098861217499, 0.006799391936510801, 0.029321111738681793, -0.024949442595243454, -0.015833375975489616, 0.013364222832024097, -0.03988918662071228, 0.03306137025356293, 0.01772664673626423, -0.009524518623948097, -0.07728223502635956, 0.005552540998905897, 0.009825954213738441, 0.03824097663164139, -0.004462162032723427, -0.025115754455327988, -0.07154867053031921, 0.03065410442650318, -0.011779042892158031, -0.03943263366818428 ]
<p>I have two categorical variables and was looking into doing a chi-square test. I then noticed I had some low frequencies in my contingency table and thought Fisher's Exact Test may be useful. I've now come full circle after doing some reading and want to use Pearson's Chi Squared with n-1 correction. Is there a way in R to run chisq.test with the n-1 correction (discussed here: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/14230/13526">Given the power of computers these days, is there ever a reason to do a chi-squared test rather than Fisher's exact test?</a>)?</p> <p>If not, how would I apply the correction to the output of Pearson's chi-squared?</p> <p>Presuming a sample size of 80:</p> <p>(80-1)/80 = 0.9875</p> <p>Do I simply multiply the Chi-Squared statistic by 0.9875 and then use this value to derive the p value?</p> <p>2.9687 * 0.9875 = 2.931591</p> <pre><code>1-pchisq(2.931591,4) </code></pre> <p>p = 0.569338</p>
74,441
[ -0.01678367517888546, -0.024137087166309357, -0.0012612702557817101, -0.004158637020736933, 0.03690445050597191, -0.0024958038702607155, -0.007978796027600765, -0.022602813318371773, 0.03240706026554108, -0.04558243975043297, 0.017756396904587746, 0.0590827614068985, 0.01742713339626789, 0.024296682327985764, 0.013265052810311317, -0.00020170271454844624, -0.009192243218421936, -0.0023243725299835205, -0.01393909566104412, 0.014527438208460808, -0.003083343617618084, 0.016229622066020966, 0.012080970220267773, 0.0038899830542504787, -0.018839644268155098, 0.06483987718820572, 0.039364248514175415, -0.0215146467089653, 0.004754225257784128, 0.06020268797874451, -0.049724798649549484, -0.004054872784763575, 0.040458593517541885, 0.02051769569516182, 0.013377940282225609, -0.0159433763474226, -0.02088063955307007, -0.02819942682981491, 0.0038163478020578623, 0.027874842286109924, -0.026336049661040306, 0.019439490512013435, 0.004841059446334839, 0.02416354976594448, 0.01208040863275528, 0.013537557795643806, 0.005172825418412685, -0.01869501918554306, 0.03226647153496742, -0.056851886212825775, 0.07014898210763931, 0.027107153087854385, 0.02551538310945034, 0.0018344676354900002, -0.0019763759337365627, -0.009534520097076893, 0.03895493969321251, 0.024933084845542908, 0.004740510135889053, -0.06713884323835373, -0.031953662633895874, -0.04151875898241997, 0.013507617637515068, -0.03583285212516785, -0.03348967805504799, 0.01738537847995758, -0.02405356615781784, 0.0004603274865075946, 0.017418328672647476, -0.03604603186249733, 0.018025588244199753, 0.0633888840675354, 0.028108365833759308, -0.0006244388059712946, 0.027577923610806465, -0.055202823132276535, 0.011216482147574425, 0.013426071032881737, 0.02576376311480999, 0.034061577171087265, -0.00365301501005888, -0.0015901302685961127, 0.036255791783332825, 0.06209680065512657, 0.04046209901571274, -0.010764182545244694, 0.060184136033058167, -0.032784149050712585, 0.004270520526915789, 0.026754889637231827, -0.031565144658088684, 0.004537195432931185, 0.04743446409702301, 0.019969673827290535, -0.031721167266368866, 0.03466574847698212, -0.05616980418562889, 0.051430556923151016, -0.018845966085791588, -0.01928243227303028, -0.05069834366440773, -0.05577404424548149, 0.048542995005846024, 0.045721061527729034, -0.04799077659845352, -0.002318697515875101, -0.014736553654074669, 0.016284195706248283, -0.0030304661486297846, -0.04038484767079353, -0.0006808493635617197, 0.037531714886426926, -0.0072648171335458755, -0.021877378225326538, 0.012924015522003174, -0.04035232588648796, -0.023693783208727837, -0.027454029768705368, 0.04669461399316788, 0.0641358345746994, 0.04601035267114639, -0.03581367805600166, 0.004473509732633829, -0.024864807724952698, -0.027642659842967987, -0.007094917353242636, 0.016171367838978767, -0.010477770119905472, -0.05060530826449394, 0.02020464651286602, -0.042953748255968094, -0.022392822429537773, 0.020336683839559555, 0.008875416591763496, 0.0305352583527565, -0.005701265297830105, -0.09821528196334839, -0.07038160413503647, 0.035517655313014984, 0.011687624268233776, -0.014837177470326424, -0.07413902878761292, 0.03113536909222603, 0.03483716398477554, 0.05465766787528992, -0.005981821566820145, 0.039264991879463196, -0.00019631398026831448, 0.03050040453672409, 0.03785441815853119, -0.06613154709339142, -0.015186775475740433, -0.031665027141571045, -0.01107644010335207, -0.012190085835754871, -0.07230320572853088, 0.05904354527592659, 0.01688098907470703, 0.0020141275599598885, -0.010445237159729004, 0.050081465393304825, -0.007368368096649647, -0.010163895785808563, -0.024732643738389015, 0.013977566733956337, -0.009662949480116367, 0.07709575444459915, -0.012141899205744267, 0.004216903820633888, 0.01774873211979866, -0.01096677128225565, -0.013180610723793507, 0.02779831923544407, 0.041331324726343155, 0.030271418392658234, 0.01649298518896103, 0.010331477969884872, -0.020103000104427338, 0.013877063989639282, 0.016407659277319908, -0.04914658144116402, -0.007664649747312069, -0.014124988578259945, -0.02407345362007618, 0.03296913206577301, 0.031132105737924576, 0.0009367216262035072, -0.027141023427248, 0.07364159822463989, -0.050051771104335785, -0.04407942295074463, -0.06675346940755844, 0.013594799675047398, 0.009883623570203781, -0.029552550986409187, -0.00623756879940629, 0.02606351114809513, 0.005737864878028631, 0.007457465399056673, -0.023816881701350212, -0.026838457211852074, 0.014615756459534168, 0.046320512890815735, -0.06542814522981644, -0.02453833632171154, 0.04318700730800629, 0.06272110342979431, -0.04562515765428543, 0.05240938439965248, -0.02971789240837097, -0.05890246480703354, 0.018966933712363243, -0.014176536351442337, 0.02598048746585846, -0.01844128966331482, 0.0024740640074014664, 0.035521022975444794, 0.00866859219968319, -0.023435521870851517, 0.05295296385884285, -0.05725398659706116, 0.080707848072052, 0.03634396195411682, 0.006123782135546207, 0.022626839578151703, -0.013815379701554775, 0.046574823558330536, -0.01926274038851261, -0.03501174971461296, 0.024461302906274796, -0.04988108202815056, -0.02187713049352169, 0.03719150647521019, -0.010494807735085487, -0.03198317065834999, 0.019892292097210884, 0.011566289700567722, -0.005783816333860159, 0.013895180076360703, 0.015345700085163116, -0.016015788540244102, -0.03961585462093353, 0.020488973706960678, 0.015738515183329582, -0.017937583848834038, 0.01023474894464016, 0.06407207995653152, -0.006074761040508747, 0.02832464873790741, 0.009479278698563576, -0.025864925235509872, 0.03079928644001484, -0.022839844226837158, -0.006851600017398596, -0.007961326278746128, -0.03266114741563797, 0.061361588537693024, 0.00514143006876111, 0.004385467153042555, 0.012595577165484428, -0.008758665062487125, 0.0028539751656353474, 0.0010734499664977193, -0.01040778961032629, 0.030039312317967415, 0.036145929247140884, -0.049432795494794846, 0.018054883927106857, -0.00996219739317894, -0.039233218878507614, 0.020717212930321693, -0.03790458291769028, -0.04391256347298622, -0.03992412984371185, 0.03714967891573906, 0.03932434692978859, -0.002289361320436001, 0.03175590559840202, -0.030525319278240204, -0.01629910245537758, -0.007103480864316225, -0.030424652621150017, 0.0014831641456112266, 0.01674121990799904, -0.03446945920586586, -0.028085708618164062, -0.02697865106165409, -0.013162114657461643, 0.0035544983111321926, 0.0032937810756266117, -0.013605399988591671, 0.012406195513904095, -0.002045683329924941, -0.015099575743079185, -0.0016428673407062888, -0.00813722051680088, -0.012269305996596813, -0.026750480756163597, -0.015374835580587387, 0.017840392887592316, 0.0009058508439920843, -0.02113250084221363, 0.04363250732421875, -0.029640262946486473, -0.00016890824190340936, -0.010413638316094875, 0.008408181369304657, 0.01009071059525013, -0.01272269431501627, -0.014264174737036228, 0.008110400289297104, -0.013879211619496346, -0.012357627041637897, -0.06229125335812569, -0.05373728647828102, -0.012957248836755753, -0.0009733396000228822, 0.025445740669965744, 0.04136934503912926, -0.02070614881813526, 0.052916668355464935, 0.023167995736002922, 0.0037694419734179974, -0.02688043750822544, -0.010675429366528988, -0.0409046970307827, -0.03827819600701332, 0.023842595517635345, 0.028422091156244278, 0.008914925158023834, 0.01350709330290556, -0.015971947461366653, 0.013869322836399078, 0.06520728766918182, 0.024543797597289085, 0.008145000785589218, 0.03369506075978279, -0.02705712802708149, -0.01999014802277088, 0.0009567228844389319, -0.008352714590728283, -0.017412852495908737, 0.018904341384768486, 0.011547200381755829, 0.021611522883176804, -0.014914105646312237, -0.021445222198963165, 0.007692757993936539, -0.02580776996910572, 0.022300727665424347, -0.04783566668629646, 0.04039580002427101, 0.021076397970318794, -0.03549396991729736, -0.0005641928291879594, 0.02214408852159977, 0.015856856480240822, -0.03440818190574646, 0.00968374777585268, 0.05157044902443886, 0.011966160498559475, -0.004076011944562197, 0.013625292107462883, -0.008267703466117382, -0.005726560950279236, 0.044252052903175354, -0.0571393258869648, 0.010967185720801353, 0.06678737699985504, 0.05824417248368263, 0.08210066705942154, 0.0015834808582440019, -0.021072814241051674, 0.042686041444540024, -0.04568902403116226, -0.0022904311772435904, -0.04334575682878494, 0.049923721700906754, 0.009923498146235943, 0.05617330223321915, 0.02623775601387024, -0.04465995728969574, -0.0036586031783372164, -0.004278360400348902, -0.07493539154529572, 0.02566600777208805, 0.006762273609638214, -0.02022567391395569, -0.0014363967347890139, -0.026670295745134354, 0.012249608524143696, -0.006215199828147888, 0.0175327155739069, -0.007968703284859657, 0.015182120725512505, -0.008380061015486717, 0.023183559998869896, -0.007282364647835493, 0.003236924996599555, -0.011518331244587898, 0.011415291577577591, 0.020568953827023506, -0.001348051242530346, 0.016740286722779274, 0.042408209294080734, -0.009057514369487762, 0.008703350089490414, -0.009402495808899403, 0.007094793953001499, -0.0029519430827349424, 0.026851577684283257, 0.01988327130675316, 0.036638159304857254, -0.03231154754757881, 0.013230080716311932, 0.0036190226674079895, 0.030688351020216942, 0.05257462337613106, 0.0008094797376543283, -0.003262382000684738, -0.02366206794977188, -0.007017387077212334, -0.019817808642983437, 0.04454639554023743, 0.0023803545627743006, -0.0014648472424596548, 0.05623456835746765, 0.016492977738380432, -0.0521317683160305, 0.011687924154102802, 0.06399714946746826, 0.013326837681233883, -0.014847254380583763, -0.0340326763689518, 0.001664480078034103, -0.020839814096689224, 0.01117823924869299, 0.005874598864465952, 0.03329216316342354, 0.008880157954990864, -0.0002833896141964942, 0.053380660712718964, -0.013669824227690697, -0.013754604384303093, -0.03420298174023628, 0.046286337077617645, 0.03427679091691971, -0.02181074768304825, -0.03067958354949951, 0.005342871882021427, 0.049088671803474426, 0.061525411903858185, -0.0172968078404665, 0.007518789730966091, -0.0999583750963211, 0.01712745986878872, 0.03203402832150459, 0.06350640952587128, -0.04589013010263443, -0.007139872759580612, -0.02981165423989296, -0.004056847188621759, -0.010890950448811054, -0.054476022720336914, 0.016526849940419197, -0.013663137331604958, 0.01450779102742672, -0.039011627435684204, -0.012562047690153122, -0.05021406710147858, 0.03405488282442093, -0.022430019453167915, 0.03970300778746605, -0.017993615940213203, -0.03882412984967232, -0.06296799331903458, 0.0016274134395644069, 0.015596108511090279, 0.025988660752773285, -0.03846535459160805, -0.051117829978466034, 0.017570672556757927, 0.024993347004055977, -0.026866024360060692, -0.03841137886047363, 0.002582973102107644, -0.007962268777191639, -0.005872906185686588, 0.03497965261340141, -0.0003389017074368894, -0.00956916343420744, -0.0036089704371988773, 0.0010577632347121835, -0.05298680439591408, -0.03067782148718834, -0.020265180617570877, 0.05570332333445549, -0.00286057754419744, -0.0011522643035277724, 0.053298790007829666, 0.00793522410094738, -0.032782115042209625, 0.01302435714751482, -0.06583498418331146, -0.00043034489499405026, 0.006549305282533169, -0.01139573659747839, -0.01710212230682373, -0.022801542654633522, -0.0015122460899874568, 0.014970521442592144, -0.006397590972483158, 0.02976800687611103, -0.03180738165974617, 0.026960693299770355, 0.026332708075642586, 0.04318992793560028, 0.002859574044123292, 0.003683655522763729, 0.03757169097661972, 0.021939581260085106, 0.02769000642001629, -0.011978194117546082, 0.024145787581801414, -0.005649222992360592, -0.005772558972239494, 0.004784531891345978, -0.032613303512334824, 0.04561450332403183, -0.007225333712995052, -0.012257050722837448, 0.00449316157028079, 0.00810173898935318, 0.016969935968518257, -0.03219050168991089, 0.05069965496659279, -0.023343350738286972, -0.02980377897620201, -0.013051681220531464, 0.0456622950732708, -0.01699008047580719, 0.030609674751758575, -0.023793058469891548, 0.06256218254566193, -0.01816917583346367, -0.000051734114094870165, -0.04019010812044144, -0.02561276964843273, 0.012622472830116749, -0.01488774549216032, -0.022825049236416817, -0.044187869876623154, -0.05435303971171379, -0.010427728295326233, -0.017051609233021736, -0.017711542546749115, 0.06133822724223137, -0.024767164140939713, 0.010395791381597519, -0.024211319163441658, -0.012226150371134281, 0.05796907842159271, -0.003019426017999649, -0.028285333886742592, 0.02835407853126526, -0.02344706282019615, -0.01737869344651699, 0.01844952255487442, -0.006492906715720892, -0.019782481715083122, -0.019241146743297577, 0.012721606530249119, -0.0031704662833362818, 0.01182403601706028, -0.008983004838228226, -0.041040319949388504, 0.001904417877085507, -0.036539893597364426, 0.006034267134964466, -0.05525100976228714, 0.012578782625496387, -0.021387893706560135, 0.016295017674565315, -0.02490350231528282, 0.0248222965747118, -0.028032690286636353, 0.030424917116761208, 0.004066660534590483, -0.0031938583124428988, -0.03615862503647804, 0.010751689784228802, 0.07653927803039551, -0.024617675691843033, 0.02097909338772297, -0.0306424368172884, -0.018389204517006874, 0.0217055045068264, 0.05982111766934395, -0.016259731724858284, -0.017939891666173935, 0.025002745911478996, 0.006634206045418978, 0.002974072238430381, -0.0173159409314394, -0.005813311785459518, 0.04324587807059288, 0.02713051438331604, 0.05689430236816406, 0.02350705675780773, 0.03620061278343201, 0.002167679602280259, 0.015264141373336315, 0.0010337067069485784, -0.030551305040717125, 0.01300867646932602, 0.03164791688323021, 0.011318482458591461, 0.01307399570941925, 0.05858398973941803, 0.03436187282204628, 0.007843549363315105, 0.04055159538984299, 0.047988411039114, 0.014570608735084534, 0.03573105111718178, -0.044029489159584045, -0.02613481506705284, 0.05135558173060417, -0.03516194224357605, 0.017796071246266365, -0.05469398945569992, -0.025888808071613312, 0.05819644033908844, 0.039601508527994156, 0.004418464377522469, -0.02506476454436779, -0.0022474941797554493, 0.000006772440883651143, -0.025705348700284958, 0.006509680300951004, -0.024794992059469223, 0.0032304429914802313, -0.03194844350218773, 0.03406617045402527, 0.003971849102526903, 0.05616215243935585, -0.001466722460463643, -0.061167024075984955, -0.045167624950408936, 0.027715813368558884, -0.02346854656934738, 0.02160961739718914, 0.0073651643469929695, -0.05185401812195778, 0.021792452782392502, -0.05171120539307594, 0.034897927194833755, -0.01472154539078474, 0.0366482250392437, -0.012094035744667053, 0.03712742403149605, -0.003520773258060217, 0.004450908396393061, -0.005726228933781385, -0.02542075701057911, 0.11053692549467087, 0.07696475833654404, 0.04592660441994667, -0.07599624991416931, 0.022082068026065826, -0.0050684730522334576, 0.011932563036680222, -0.010345853865146637, -0.025311416015028954, -0.014708103612065315, 0.00436529191210866, 0.09312617033720016, 0.06000398471951485, 0.0529913567006588, -0.007600890006870031, 0.03766794130206108, -0.02190539613366127, -0.03803231939673424, -0.019797829911112785, 0.012585380114614964, 0.01537062507122755, -0.041398968547582626, -0.011353300884366035, -0.014954149723052979, 0.021415937691926956, -0.017217028886079788, -0.0569305382668972, -0.015098798088729382, 0.0033696761820465326, -0.0031276827212423086, -0.059360116720199585, -0.004058504477143288, 0.025026867166161537, 0.0035814568400382996, -0.00840185210108757, -0.017535191029310226, 0.0047313799150288105, -0.02288215421140194, 0.007257099263370037, 0.03751072660088539, -0.023369764909148216, -0.010023128241300583, 0.011908846907317638, 0.029681837186217308, -0.044252779334783554, -0.030512778088450432, -0.034773554652929306, 0.04809281602501869, -0.013717897236347198, -0.015467505902051926, -0.0034962515346705914, -0.00871350523084402, 0.004865009803324938, -0.01829848811030388, -0.022606506943702698, 0.025484008714556694, 0.017196128144860268, -0.02935565821826458, -0.020350884646177292, -0.054221756756305695, 0.007863339968025684, -0.012332089245319366, 0.06595572829246521, 0.003749881172552705, -0.03272577375173569, -0.027298567816615105, -0.026293331757187843, 0.04890761896967888, -0.009342540986835957, 0.02243695966899395, 0.04016284644603729, -0.011059018783271313, -0.035640958696603775, 0.003459506668150425, 0.010533650405704975, 0.021106956526637077, 0.04040870815515518, -0.03499728441238403, -0.013772604055702686, -0.021844813600182533, -0.04720909520983696, 0.0222990270704031, -0.027915701270103455, -0.0075689353980124, -0.05637861043214798, -0.017987338826060295, 0.04182916134595871, 0.023399153724312782, -0.014883087947964668, 0.025731537491083145, -0.03696904331445694, 0.0660841315984726, 0.015543500892817974, -0.02099040150642395, -0.03787101432681084, -0.01787879317998886, -0.02529841475188732, 0.017238227650523186, -0.031715452671051025, 0.0383189395070076, 0.027040131390094757, 0.009426341392099857, 0.006206990219652653, 0.028547359630465508, -0.01954137533903122, 0.0013180712703615427, 0.025265026837587357, -0.03947779908776283, -0.018004197627305984, -0.0010719478596001863, 0.0044099390506744385, -0.010139385238289833, -0.043572619557380676, -0.06658117473125458, -0.04736020043492317, 0.01169038750231266, -0.0416288822889328, -0.05642024427652359, 0.003528807545080781, -0.03759079426527023, -0.025512907654047012, -0.02460993081331253, -0.021007386967539787, -0.021667758002877235, -0.00001169472307083197, -0.014356416650116444, -0.008384847082197666, 0.004300872329622507, 0.010581228882074356, -0.03720991685986519, 0.02834334969520569, 0.028946004807949066, -0.0003556202573236078, 0.015085252933204174, 0.002239544875919819, 0.00936892069876194, 0.02435319684445858, 0.03401380777359009, 0.0030907965265214443, -0.018445920199155807, 0.062047503888607025, -0.07422198355197906, -0.051072243601083755, 0.007739825639873743, -0.021223878487944603, 0.03327202796936035, 0.01269201934337616, 0.008230159059166908, -0.009304326958954334, 0.030689941719174385, -0.009703762829303741, -0.026094242930412292, -0.0047429827973246574, 0.008991504088044167, -0.015842372551560402, 0.02507161535322666, -0.018576033413410187, -0.02155916765332222, -0.008103973232209682, 0.04436817020177841, 0.049787990748882294, 0.02838030643761158, -0.008497772738337517, 0.00979477260261774, -0.004985119216144085, 0.02487907186150551, 0.04873497039079666, -0.0403020866215229, 0.017411669716238976, 0.04353198781609535, -0.019827209413051605, 0.018100494518876076, -0.0417339913547039, 0.02386379987001419, -0.1240924820303917, -0.016583317890763283, -0.00023114580835681409, 0.025446638464927673, 0.008324874565005302, -0.07550384849309921, 0.027991702780127525, 0.0017144442535936832, -0.05663589760661125, 0.03402658924460411, -0.025490665808320045, -0.008617093786597252, -0.01739809848368168, 0.01814037747681141, -0.0037952351849526167, 0.019605500623583794, 0.021743828430771828, -0.008581696078181267, 0.03453020006418228, -0.001908788806758821, 0.028035786002874374, -0.0118472995236516, 0.0663970485329628, 0.011558791622519493, 0.021312111988663673, -0.08618372678756714, 0.02673426829278469, -0.011763573624193668, -0.030851349234580994, 0.013255244120955467, -0.026888351887464523, 0.026772158220410347, 0.046981289982795715, 0.0464225597679615, 0.018875189125537872, 0.059718549251556396, 0.04320307448506355, 0.0021318390499800444, -0.04065316915512085, 0.03818807005882263, 0.0069370814599096775, 0.03001445159316063, -0.04682871326804161, 0.008126811124384403, 0.029223734512925148, -0.0136588579043746, -0.0067651835270226, 0.037586841732263565, -0.01919803023338318, 0.020688002929091454, -0.0175173319876194, -0.004729440901428461, -0.007142387796193361, 0.020402124151587486, 0.047914836555719376, -0.05042031407356262, -0.017461908981204033, 0.023769648745656013, 0.03467175364494324, -0.0032511604949831963, 0.04369624704122543, 0.004547277465462685, -0.012523140758275986, 0.03082408383488655, 0.01370519120246172, 0.028273627161979675, -0.05387323349714279, -0.03259268030524254, 0.012050685472786427, 0.0333356074988842, -0.002398398471996188, -0.008222980424761772, -0.02219998463988304, 0.040369387716054916, -0.012964475899934769, 0.006704223807901144, 0.022989097982645035, 0.0267941914498806, 0.024409770965576172, -0.07230159640312195, 0.032411471009254456, 0.011512113735079765, -0.01198982261121273, -0.038279928267002106, 0.004619040060788393, -0.07283977419137955, 0.013576598837971687, 0.07109339535236359, 0.009276362136006355, -0.026099305599927902, -0.0017984992591664195, 0.024217259138822556, -0.005905571859329939, -0.0639791190624237, 0.03905319795012474, -0.029107701033353806, -0.03422875329852104, -0.05246578902006149, 0.003175657242536545, 0.00604075426235795, 0.03336281329393387, -0.00043302791891619563, -0.03464338928461075, 0.010268413461744785, 0.005785726942121983, -0.04564664885401726, 0.059150923043489456, 0.006973314099013805, -0.004624377004802227, 0.018610090017318726, 0.004248074721544981, 0.012770132161676884, 0.053034305572509766, -0.008571057580411434, -0.034423600882291794, 0.05002938210964203, -0.02492273785173893, 0.006763487122952938, 0.030774418264627457, 0.03206435590982437, -0.03387339413166046, -0.049304716289043427, 0.018111852928996086, 0.011297162622213364, -0.025559039786458015, -0.0017242656322196126, 0.024088291451334953, 0.039719026535749435, 0.02597297914326191, 0.012148477137088776, 0.00435729930177331, -0.004662482067942619, -0.027962228283286095, 0.017587818205356598, 0.02293572574853897, 0.005604514852166176, -0.01895490102469921, 0.014387005940079689, 0.036713823676109314, -0.027113916352391243, 0.010795417241752148, -0.02070566453039646, 0.037797264754772186, -0.01643419824540615, -0.014467524364590645, 0.03096456453204155, -0.0215375367552042, 0.053086746484041214, -0.007802075240761042, -0.04577283933758736, 0.05181004852056503, -0.029222799465060234, 0.0026085886638611555, -0.008255355060100555, -0.060828808695077896, -0.039626091718673706, -0.040402114391326904, -0.012160448357462883, 0.050601858645677567, -0.020697809755802155, 0.004930497147142887, 0.010809468105435371, -0.03308046981692314, 0.010246814228594303, -0.013400237075984478, 0.030535371974110603, -0.03264172375202179, 0.028174925595521927, -0.036750443279743195, -0.005716843064874411, 0.0013058067997917533, -0.03727153688669205, 0.04468352347612381, 0.041928425431251526, 0.037921708077192307, -0.06164461374282837, 0.008017458021640778, 0.050050023943185806, 0.035882581025362015, -0.03269282728433609, -0.0014003021642565727, -0.025674903765320778, 0.016838952898979187, -0.008107228204607964, -0.03263439983129501 ]
<p>Let suppose we are given two vectors <strong>u</strong>, <strong>v</strong> $\in \mathbb{R}^n$ and we want a function that returns $0$ if the ordering of the elements of both vectors are the same or a positive number otherwise, where the larger the number of mismatches the larger the positive value. We want to ensure that the highest values of the vector <strong>u</strong> are in the same positions of the highest values in vector <strong>v</strong>.</p> <p>For example: Lets say that <strong>u</strong> = {3.2, 1.5, -3, 0} and <strong>v</strong>={-2.1, 1, 1.1, -0.5}, so the rank of these vectors are (descending order): $r_u$={1,2,4,3} and $r_v$={4,2,1,3}. So, in this case we have two matches {2,3} and two mismatches {1,4}. Another point is that the highest value of the vectors <strong>u</strong> and <strong>v</strong> is in the mismatch set, then in this case the penalization should be harder than a mismatch in lower values. </p> <p>The simplest way to do that is by calculating the rank of each vector, $r_u$ and $r_v$, and then compute the $L_2$-norm, for example, of the difference between these ranks:</p> <p>$f(r_u,r_v) = \|r_u-r_v\|^2_2$.</p> <p>However, since this function is a term of my optimization problem, at each iteration of the optimization algorithm it will be necessary to recalculate the ranks of these vectors, once both vectors are parameters to be learned and they are going to change every iteration. So, this approach can be very expensive, computationally speaking.</p> <p>Another option is by counting the number of concordant pairs (<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concordant_pair" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concordant_pair</a>) of the vectors, however we need to recount the number of concordant (or discordant) pairs at each iteration.</p> <p>Does anybody has faced with a similar problem?</p>
74,442
[ -0.06830408424139023, -0.00025761761935427785, -0.01145453006029129, -0.01130933128297329, -0.0035102323163300753, 0.025781942531466484, 0.0022708140313625336, -0.03198409453034401, 0.05863779038190842, -0.03169628605246544, 0.007819268852472305, 0.03823684900999069, 0.060146644711494446, 0.024491852149367332, 0.00479503720998764, -0.007410906255245209, -0.00874872412532568, -0.0031086986418813467, -0.015368877910077572, 0.029134131968021393, 0.04251723736524582, 0.03121613711118698, 0.02334427461028099, 0.008069608360528946, -0.03381257876753807, 0.01388275995850563, 0.036427441984415054, -0.023770174011588097, -0.02084508165717125, 0.030043385922908783, -0.07703788578510284, 0.0006783992284908891, 0.031292855739593506, 0.0326436422765255, 0.028227081522345543, 0.03266477957367897, -0.014662785455584526, -0.016842279583215714, -0.027896560728549957, 0.018274959176778793, -0.00489573460072279, -0.026167768985033035, -0.010944380424916744, 0.033800914883613586, 0.014876741915941238, 0.050745639950037, 0.02980121038854122, -0.04470961168408394, 0.002635135781019926, -0.06812882423400879, 0.06775785982608795, 0.02564992755651474, 0.011987038888037205, 0.008447742089629173, -0.05430620536208153, -0.03050294518470764, 0.020536083728075027, 0.0643959641456604, 0.02941001020371914, -0.06376194208860397, 0.02741086669266224, -0.033690329641103745, 0.00860483106225729, -0.008260492235422134, -0.022075720131397247, 0.07321217656135559, 0.023764045909047127, 0.0286610946059227, 0.02108701877295971, -0.028229014948010445, -0.012133825570344925, -0.0009037447744049132, 0.01782664656639099, -0.027828197926282883, 0.031101208180189133, -0.0054594120010733604, -0.009968015365302563, 0.019987724721431732, -0.00039755727630108595, -0.004079575650393963, 0.005879964679479599, 0.0030010046903043985, 0.014788639731705189, 0.053833842277526855, -0.002411487977951765, 0.01892835646867752, 0.04713674634695053, -0.04768304526805878, 0.03444969654083252, 0.025266064330935478, 0.006088073831051588, -0.006165167782455683, 0.02276216261088848, -0.03283829614520073, -0.03758180886507034, 0.0007147961878217757, 0.0007703361916355789, -0.0058970460668206215, 0.004848216660320759, -0.04484088346362114, -0.017566850408911705, -0.027197714895009995, -0.03463504835963249, 0.044544804841279984, 0.00266778445802629, -0.04829731956124306, -0.03023718111217022, -0.00010517774353502318, -0.014290307648479939, 0.01328860130161047, -0.015278654173016548, 0.023190824314951897, -0.030053628608584404, 0.012127039954066277, 0.009944991208612919, -0.005079520866274834, 0.01547983754426241, -0.020246079191565514, 0.034404437988996506, 0.07098080217838287, 0.04192325845360756, -0.051624830812215805, -0.011503564193844795, -0.02835812419652939, -0.025042736902832985, 0.0013260662090033293, 0.03498569130897522, 0.006468773819506168, -0.03382347524166107, 0.029197052121162415, 0.015060219913721085, -0.017396872863173485, 0.024787671864032745, -0.0052309357561171055, -0.018519436940550804, 0.01536823995411396, -0.08025600016117096, -0.04361691698431969, 0.04652160778641701, -0.004907324444502592, 0.012852134183049202, -0.07828161865472794, 0.008541836403310299, 0.025236384943127632, 0.037859074771404266, 0.02763666771352291, 0.0667295828461647, 0.046460941433906555, 0.00896371342241764, 0.025004655122756958, 0.008595085702836514, 0.003696549218147993, -0.053542036563158035, -0.019445087760686874, -0.03177376464009285, -0.045148517936468124, -0.014127310365438461, 0.029788456857204437, -0.01853371597826481, 0.020881472155451775, 0.014148258604109287, 0.0008596538100391626, -0.04113781452178955, -0.007729317527264357, 0.005589151289314032, 0.020024042576551437, 0.02798452228307724, 0.04472413659095764, 0.030186409130692482, -0.004702392965555191, -0.0405840165913105, -0.022139279171824455, 0.029694242402911186, 0.008270426653325558, 0.05022548884153366, -0.03449050709605217, -0.02722080983221531, -0.06950552761554718, 0.01103255245834589, -0.014709553681313992, -0.008980987593531609, -0.04385899752378464, -0.018173016607761383, 0.027204914018511772, -0.005560099147260189, 0.04560794681310654, 0.011973870918154716, 0.004487350583076477, 0.04306057095527649, -0.050030872225761414, -0.0010966943809762597, -0.04426318779587746, -0.0046083321794867516, 0.017492685467004776, -0.04582826420664787, 0.06313825398683548, -0.006091632414609194, -0.03931798040866852, 0.006837025284767151, -0.011776693165302277, -0.024466851726174355, 0.006571490783244371, 0.03904815763235092, -0.005890853237360716, -0.02683989517390728, 0.05302884429693222, 0.038902416825294495, 0.004902073182165623, 0.07218172401189804, -0.029562685638666153, -0.03266148641705513, 0.01670028828084469, -0.019227618351578712, 0.010487958788871765, -0.021690651774406433, 0.022609982639551163, 0.024547915905714035, -0.04144347459077835, -0.002420301316305995, -0.01100014429539442, -0.07325068861246109, 0.058130618184804916, 0.0737295001745224, 0.00373085611499846, 0.05160337686538696, 0.021861758083105087, 0.007973170839250088, 0.01715780608355999, -0.04327572509646416, 0.011609180830419064, -0.0601261705160141, -0.03187091276049614, 0.018818270415067673, 0.07679209858179092, -0.05246182903647423, 0.014232342131435871, 0.04818964749574661, 0.027032390236854553, 0.019730696454644203, -0.002113071968778968, -0.02113332413136959, -0.03331999480724335, 0.0538475476205349, -0.0032254739198833704, -0.006836055777966976, 0.012401954270899296, -0.034528039395809174, 0.02395792491734028, 0.006437512580305338, -0.004200301598757505, -0.030214564874768257, 0.04914439842104912, 0.03377339616417885, 0.0009213135926984251, -0.028156787157058716, -0.0351308137178421, 0.003466223133727908, -0.014976255595684052, 0.030773214995861053, 0.03971488028764725, -0.01155307050794363, 0.010553844273090363, -0.0121671874076128, -0.020282985642552376, 0.018561335280537605, 0.03140062093734741, 0.0001405487855663523, 0.042884305119514465, 0.0357050858438015, -0.06835968047380447, -0.0027237741742283106, 0.0008331965073011816, -0.02961810678243637, -0.0019829398952424526, -0.01923353224992752, 0.03353919833898544, -0.01815091259777546, -0.025313887745141983, -0.011919494718313217, 0.03413758426904678, 0.026701204478740692, -0.03632724657654762, 0.03652821108698845, 0.004903694614768028, -0.0164247527718544, -0.011207770556211472, -0.011524609290063381, -0.024085750803351402, -0.007791238836944103, 0.039176806807518005, 0.004603506997227669, 0.06392072141170502, -0.01337606180459261, -0.07316070795059204, -0.05422813072800636, -0.0541166216135025, 0.01234669890254736, -0.009406451135873795, -0.021966733038425446, 0.04846379905939102, 0.025151019915938377, -0.07747913897037506, 0.004792722407728434, -0.01026869099587202, 0.018449364230036736, -0.05413966253399849, -0.01657133176922798, -0.0020067011937499046, -0.0035152514465153217, -0.018641365692019463, 0.043673302978277206, 0.014559467323124409, -0.0067498767748475075, -0.0808313712477684, -0.021322447806596756, 0.017565332353115082, 0.022275244817137718, 0.08579793572425842, 0.017205463722348213, -0.01514021772891283, 0.09754401445388794, 0.0425979308784008, -0.0054097604006528854, -0.058768708258867264, 0.0432276651263237, -0.02739611640572548, 0.0027114986442029476, 0.014403795823454857, 0.02240588515996933, 0.01733735390007496, 0.026883309707045555, -0.004423357080668211, -0.007906845770776272, 0.0824187621474266, 0.011730987578630447, -0.002621997846290469, 0.03489625081419945, 0.010707906447350979, -0.011412548832595348, 0.015024319291114807, 0.008328014984726906, -0.02195807173848152, 0.020018331706523895, 0.051233042031526566, -0.0006055857520550489, -0.0018347571603953838, -0.014885148033499718, -0.03692735359072685, -0.017743423581123352, 0.022140102460980415, -0.04270876944065094, 0.016663165763020515, 0.04011695459485054, -0.032364681363105774, -0.046736814081668854, 0.01590244472026825, 0.017835211008787155, -0.041473694145679474, -0.0026836281176656485, 0.024356389418244362, 0.04526897892355919, -0.017631225287914276, 0.0018319975351914763, -0.009656750597059727, -0.010807443410158157, 0.030864253640174866, -0.040645532310009, -0.01853979378938675, 0.03636078163981438, 0.009950808249413967, -0.019313933327794075, 0.05105450376868248, -0.025299174711108208, -0.011732828803360462, -0.01299660000950098, -0.026138300076127052, -0.03255899250507355, 0.06485148519277573, -0.01795448362827301, 0.011158865876495838, 0.006947262678295374, -0.016355404630303383, -0.008336438797414303, 0.01732044294476509, -0.104486845433712, -0.010789896361529827, -0.01602710224688053, -0.0117808161303401, 0.03672140836715698, -0.05169503763318062, 0.01408360805362463, -0.03931817412376404, -0.014470476657152176, -0.009605863131582737, 0.0628388524055481, -0.027197537943720818, 0.045205455273389816, -0.0014753562863916159, 0.001301635755226016, -0.022978581488132477, 0.02508697658777237, 0.044705312699079514, -0.0007033064030110836, 0.04080265015363693, 0.026738962158560753, -0.024708576500415802, 0.04223131388425827, -0.017902830615639687, 0.029482850804924965, 0.046113770455121994, 0.04856029897928238, -0.0162978358566761, 0.05442751199007034, 0.021106455475091934, -0.013587635941803455, -0.018425017595291138, 0.0024184416979551315, 0.053853075951337814, 0.02790016494691372, -0.02461463399231434, -0.029382068663835526, -0.053606390953063965, -0.029804149642586708, 0.02711559273302555, 0.008797039277851582, -0.027132386341691017, 0.006553212180733681, 0.026446525007486343, -0.04528001695871353, -0.012923396192491055, 0.041400130838155746, 0.03208128362894058, -0.005708039738237858, -0.025771956890821457, -0.026945890858769417, 0.006474520545452833, 0.006618610117584467, 0.011339258402585983, -0.00839569978415966, -0.039654336869716644, 0.019376149401068687, 0.07357364147901535, 0.018299240618944168, -0.03197292983531952, -0.010902292095124722, 0.015014369040727615, 0.015261709690093994, -0.04185047373175621, -0.018330886960029602, -0.03870970755815506, 0.04328300431370735, 0.03424358367919922, -0.0017795899184420705, 0.005295796785503626, -0.05250130593776703, -0.007321811746805906, 0.011922812089323997, 0.07078858464956284, -0.012334913946688175, -0.007099885959178209, -0.017533080652356148, -0.013369069434702396, 0.010038512758910656, -0.011248650029301643, 0.023861203342676163, 0.01716042496263981, -0.004577415529638529, -0.05930182337760925, -0.030714593827724457, -0.04041511192917824, 0.008984383195638657, -0.02943267673254013, 0.05051233246922493, -0.02694052830338478, -0.0488128699362278, -0.037651896476745605, -0.01252429187297821, 0.01350775733590126, 0.04343971610069275, -0.01835511066019535, 0.007848860695958138, -0.0020122684072703123, 0.00875372625887394, -0.011279054917395115, -0.05346308648586273, 0.006279165390878916, 0.01743946596980095, -0.002101803896948695, 0.015273256227374077, -0.020888878032565117, -0.038083698600530624, 0.019970539957284927, 0.016349907964468002, 0.007502517197281122, -0.0004130852175876498, -0.009825415909290314, 0.039021581411361694, 0.04320301488041878, 0.016896221786737442, 0.05373122915625572, 0.002219995716586709, 0.006579579319804907, 0.0025798652786761522, -0.03391371667385101, -0.002463570097461343, -0.007336014416068792, -0.03270650655031204, 0.003221504855901003, -0.02365698851644993, -0.018775559961795807, 0.026898561045527458, -0.020709002390503883, 0.05705563724040985, -0.012763462029397488, 0.022359559312462807, -0.030699821189045906, 0.02555464580655098, -0.030446091666817665, -0.024248698726296425, 0.020913487300276756, 0.04949469119310379, 0.012122930958867073, -0.008538380265235901, 0.02789667807519436, -0.011610018089413643, 0.026118280366063118, 0.029293326660990715, -0.04782974720001221, 0.006399599369615316, -0.03625040501356125, -0.013993474654853344, -0.0033603045158088207, 0.00017943077546078712, 0.06501466780900955, -0.009561021812260151, 0.03485812246799469, -0.021751780062913895, -0.007039208430796862, -0.026091808453202248, 0.007779294159263372, -0.03161955997347832, -0.002055211691185832, -0.017969246953725815, -0.00848338007926941, 0.018715908750891685, -0.01157398335635662, -0.03208943456411362, -0.006177158560603857, 0.03233103081583977, 0.019823485985398293, -0.024345286190509796, -0.02003687433898449, -0.005539433564990759, 0.030357956886291504, -0.02744923159480095, -0.015086071565747261, 0.04228036850690842, -0.02241835929453373, -0.04032736271619797, -0.014596043154597282, -0.005771427880972624, 0.0365123525261879, 0.0021517635323107243, 0.016130715608596802, 0.011779009364545345, -0.000635394942946732, 0.009589452296495438, -0.003997139632701874, 0.02874654158949852, -0.03661174327135086, -0.0359184592962265, -0.05438811331987381, 0.015162668190896511, 0.001496972399763763, 0.0181057658046484, -0.0052255019545555115, 0.018078522756695747, -0.0014813609886914492, -0.00939240399748087, -0.015588059090077877, -0.024677641689777374, -0.0051697115413844585, -0.0045314207673072815, 0.006682754494249821, -0.004989443346858025, 0.016094345599412918, -0.01272735558450222, -0.004174354951828718, -0.0060728141106665134, 0.01739000901579857, -0.046688783913850784, 0.05803067237138748, -0.03596125543117523, -0.022776704281568527, -0.02793928049504757, -0.03994865342974663, 0.07181180268526077, -0.004591831937432289, 0.009038198739290237, -0.003199700266122818, 0.03284984454512596, -0.05335988476872444, -0.035636670887470245, -0.06136989966034889, 0.011538559570908546, 0.08857502043247223, -0.0052115595899522305, 0.04015915468335152, 0.058602266013622284, -0.015498978085815907, 0.004576784558594227, -0.028720704838633537, -0.004772367887198925, -0.015149443410336971, -0.030558057129383087, 0.021496083587408066, 0.01561693660914898, 0.015444371849298477, 0.032899465411901474, 0.016915904358029366, 0.053699228912591934, -0.009972378611564636, -0.02353014424443245, 0.04130192846059799, 0.03976718708872795, -0.07705188542604446, -0.045626670122146606, 0.024427607655525208, -0.04635460674762726, -0.0011206567287445068, 0.0218675397336483, -0.01326810847967863, 0.012438269332051277, 0.014956191182136536, 0.04009056091308594, -0.03944719582796097, -0.03289986774325371, -0.0561085045337677, 0.05058811232447624, 0.0042228600941598415, -0.037105493247509, 0.04356114938855171, 0.011823796667158604, 0.03712143376469612, 0.012967247515916824, 0.02736918441951275, -0.021438445895910263, -0.01765955239534378, -0.02771095372736454, -0.049399785697460175, -0.0021739813964813948, 0.03434261679649353, 0.05562850087881088, -0.02490421198308468, 0.02182519994676113, -0.0034670692402869463, 0.013732616789638996, 0.03161824122071266, 0.05115557834506035, -0.057076308876276016, 0.051992349326610565, 0.012431676499545574, 0.03985267132520676, -0.019825493916869164, -0.016788559034466743, 0.16322875022888184, 0.0785079300403595, 0.04632903262972832, -0.03318959102034569, 0.02680373378098011, 0.0076296525076031685, -0.04095325618982315, -0.04367583617568016, 0.00845540314912796, -0.0032746135257184505, -0.007957298308610916, 0.004471655935049057, -0.005237467121332884, 0.02726450376212597, -0.034559980034828186, 0.005352207459509373, -0.04674595594406128, 0.0010797452414408326, 0.025950884446501732, -0.0054323067888617516, -0.02658100239932537, 0.03636690974235535, 0.010153966955840588, 0.012413968332111835, -0.015490472316741943, -0.06968133896589279, -0.01786315068602562, -0.007002587430179119, 0.02168389968574047, -0.0499989353120327, -0.02532905526459217, 0.033333271741867065, -0.005619696341454983, -0.0017511609476059675, 0.005210745148360729, 0.027524542063474655, 0.003148880321532488, -0.010022450238466263, 0.004567228257656097, -0.005889821331948042, 0.006856684572994709, 0.03849729895591736, 0.00385023420676589, -0.014654100872576237, -0.04110702499747276, -0.007180762477219105, -0.07244674861431122, 0.07436487078666687, -0.008650878444314003, -0.0044287159107625484, 0.034561291337013245, -0.002513283398002386, 0.03616411238908768, -0.03493433818221092, 0.0005195905105210841, 0.031095901504158974, 0.029507821425795555, -0.03125961124897003, 0.0015005056047812104, -0.016292205080389977, 0.060738228261470795, -0.006525081116706133, 0.0291278213262558, 0.026964111253619194, -0.02856176719069481, -0.03752133622765541, -0.024405203759670258, 0.04541899636387825, 0.012688933871686459, 0.004538395907729864, -0.03714463487267494, -0.001205971697345376, 0.008267474360764027, -0.026850426569581032, 0.010174628347158432, 0.025398362427949905, 0.03589192032814026, -0.03368659317493439, -0.04083279147744179, -0.043411143124103546, -0.07222738862037659, 0.0035994681529700756, -0.03619549050927162, -0.014944189228117466, -0.028230642899870872, -0.01222238503396511, 0.02489793673157692, 0.030289936810731888, 0.015643257647752762, -0.0027932797092944384, -0.002390811685472727, 0.04725542664527893, 0.01722339726984501, -0.021356919780373573, -0.0431259423494339, -0.03138274326920509, -0.033171962946653366, 0.018549466505646706, 0.03525286167860031, 0.06346910446882248, 0.07054222375154495, 0.018979141488671303, 0.028596891090273857, 0.02811748906970024, -0.024648349732160568, 0.0006335081998258829, 0.022898204624652863, -0.03477499634027481, -0.00022283672296907753, 0.018026968464255333, -0.016547664999961853, -0.016810892149806023, 0.014377263374626637, -0.03675585985183716, -0.011571509763598442, 0.03169969841837883, -0.008619214408099651, -0.00834082905203104, 0.015358701348304749, 0.001789171015843749, 0.0333176925778389, -0.007935706526041031, -0.016088439151644707, 0.02198748290538788, 0.029311805963516235, -0.048988234251737595, -0.011632069014012814, -0.01977396197617054, 0.0014882711693644524, 0.0008861495298333466, -0.0009883452439680696, 0.01201793272048235, 0.030350716784596443, 0.04052320495247841, 0.00018793842173181474, 0.0027990981470793486, 0.027451565489172935, 0.05930929258465767, -0.007852152921259403, -0.03506267070770264, -0.005840142257511616, -0.06916865706443787, -0.06389374285936356, 0.004534138832241297, -0.013654282316565514, 0.032590415328741074, 0.000805635703727603, -0.016592903062701225, -0.03324003517627716, 0.036835040897130966, -0.03476618230342865, 0.016328923404216766, 0.00922837108373642, 0.016795828938484192, -0.010501186363399029, -0.01413359772413969, 0.009711702354252338, -0.02783142402768135, 0.002087649656459689, -0.030321413651108742, 0.038141220808029175, -0.019565537571907043, 0.002300360705703497, 0.01774270460009575, -0.008492693305015564, 0.024996662512421608, 0.004080270882695913, -0.003889568382874131, 0.03621276840567589, 0.033731862902641296, 0.017334377393126488, 0.023083724081516266, 0.0035366262309253216, 0.0033789316657930613, -0.10109973698854446, -0.048166822642087936, 0.03971850126981735, 0.01489030010998249, 0.04032348096370697, -0.07869131118059158, 0.02023453265428543, 0.055549029260873795, -0.04435352981090546, 0.0366792231798172, -0.037113696336746216, -0.00014508375898003578, -0.03216421604156494, -0.00048121868167072535, -0.03760193660855293, -0.02306612953543663, 0.005965924821794033, 0.016461540013551712, 0.018407603725790977, 0.02923416905105114, 0.00015528341464232653, -0.020918304100632668, -0.026844937354326248, 0.011514599435031414, -0.018749583512544632, -0.05680359899997711, 0.04750615730881691, -0.020884128287434578, -0.01875879056751728, 0.013828154653310776, 0.0039237868040800095, -0.012770386412739754, 0.0254525113850832, 0.05282467231154442, 0.015159690752625465, 0.025679999962449074, -0.0016193671617656946, -0.011189458891749382, 0.006666490808129311, -0.046106968075037, 0.011691218242049217, 0.014300808310508728, -0.016772126778960228, 0.031057486310601234, 0.025638965889811516, -0.008367383852601051, -0.028106559067964554, 0.028311198577284813, -0.010012634098529816, -0.01562498603016138, 0.025340182706713676, -0.015674736350774765, 0.011304468847811222, -0.02861372008919716, -0.026922225952148438, 0.0062190815806388855, 0.008082139305770397, 0.009233938530087471, 0.012126956135034561, 0.00863105058670044, 0.009506209753453732, -0.028405454009771347, -0.01520503219217062, 0.007643355056643486, -0.008333804085850716, -0.01994895748794079, -0.07360278069972992, 0.012185657396912575, 0.02575303055346012, -0.0514984093606472, -0.0380965955555439, -0.007142978720366955, -0.004842936992645264, 0.027735408395528793, -0.00985628180205822, -0.01260480098426342, -0.03099619597196579, -0.0009142436319962144, 0.01932833157479763, -0.10095389187335968, 0.06922394037246704, 0.008421684615314007, -0.01302703283727169, -0.016900470480322838, -0.017814645543694496, -0.029331024736166, 0.05752921476960182, 0.03805634006857872, -0.014768995344638824, -0.013571292161941528, -0.02440783940255642, 0.021948490291833878, 0.04745182394981384, -0.020835377275943756, 0.025108618661761284, -0.025119539350271225, 0.012689943425357342, 0.012643281370401382, 0.016345907002687454, 0.025905506685376167, -0.006837989669293165, -0.036084119230508804, -0.026080632582306862, -0.016050849109888077, 0.02971528097987175, 0.0007118813809938729, 0.023789355531334877, -0.00744998874142766, -0.0004687073524110019, 0.06476016342639923, 0.016179313883185387, 0.033977944403886795, 0.001706457231193781, -0.010990367271006107, -0.08601076155900955, -0.02043674699962139, -0.04142247140407562, -0.03841313719749451, 0.0004864959337282926, 0.027403920888900757, 0.02615671046078205, -0.04536205530166626, 0.013837596401572227, 0.04175394028425217, -0.029509302228689194, -0.0174417681992054, 0.02107297070324421, -0.01007433608174324, 0.0459451898932457, 0.018879465758800507, 0.049524080008268356, 0.024007214233279228, -0.02551351673901081, 0.004847391042858362, -0.004718735348433256, 0.01221481990069151, -0.006502031348645687, 0.036726806312799454, 0.035438649356365204, -0.023509584367275238, 0.011672492139041424, 0.02734869346022606, 0.022362573072314262, -0.014257438480854034, -0.0028343070298433304, 0.012523970566689968, -0.024674661457538605, 0.0024257272016257048, -0.00030146935023367405, -0.0006836167885921896, 0.04374144226312637, -0.015481666661798954, 0.012905335985124111, -0.0476607084274292, 0.006769963540136814, -0.018650487065315247, 0.01512430515140295, -0.015265319496393204, 0.02839527279138565, 0.005264966282993555, 0.04105153679847717, 0.018633993342518806, 0.01901327446103096, 0.0608234778046608, -0.008851724676787853, 0.0037547345273196697, 0.021822499111294746, 0.010876189917325974, -0.024061813950538635, -0.024942336603999138, -0.025004036724567413, -0.03911313787102699, 0.0031374599784612656, 0.011685026809573174, 0.04190729185938835, -0.02064698562026024, 0.01900538057088852, -0.031098181381821632, 0.023313913494348526, -0.04945226013660431, -0.029172543436288834, -0.04512889310717583, -0.011874131858348846, -0.013235826976597309, -0.02782367914915085 ]
<p>I am evaluating the accuracy of GPS watches, taking many readings over a known distance. I've been calculating standard deviation using the mean reading, but because I know what the reading should be, I could use that instead of the mean. Would this be a reasonable thing to do?</p>
74,443
[ -0.009756561368703842, -0.003448013449087739, -0.024754809215664864, 0.017980774864554405, 0.0639803409576416, 0.043597131967544556, -0.027377942577004433, -0.026226099580526352, 0.018567081540822983, 0.010432913899421692, 0.04330714792013168, 0.031013943254947662, 0.027410920709371567, 0.023627791553735733, 0.04302080720663071, 0.001167750102467835, -0.023918088525533676, 0.0041258870624005795, -0.005424319300800562, -0.06275375932455063, -0.037029676139354706, 0.005895142909139395, -0.004979399964213371, -0.022845759987831116, -0.037793368101119995, -0.00280071166343987, 0.05187442526221275, -0.002989294473081827, 0.0022375162225216627, 0.04653802886605263, -0.029417023062705994, -0.01601652055978775, 0.03721040487289429, 0.03635616973042488, 0.02224121242761612, 0.002760370494797826, -0.008864673785865307, 0.01770164631307125, -0.03534092381596565, 0.05504012852907181, -0.004435888025909662, 0.014789990149438381, 0.025398071855306625, 0.02427886798977852, 0.0026353043504059315, 0.055922407656908035, -0.016337472945451736, -0.049930986016988754, 0.020976610481739044, -0.02953510731458664, 0.06041133776307106, -0.018874211236834526, 0.0473710261285305, 0.038258280605077744, -0.01933315396308899, 0.01896539144217968, 0.05386894568800926, 0.0452759824693203, 0.009038882330060005, -0.05555145815014839, 0.01541936956346035, -0.01710713468492031, -0.01685037463903427, -0.02575254999101162, 0.009118674322962761, -0.030870594084262848, -0.019173474982380867, -0.037142980843782425, 0.0565442219376564, 0.03015255555510521, 0.035351406782865524, 0.026774389669299126, 0.009748001582920551, -0.022359171882271767, -0.0052647036500275135, -0.025551963597536087, 0.01125528384000063, 0.022903168573975563, 0.04672513157129288, 0.013832789845764637, 0.026661287993192673, -0.019540730863809586, 0.049665965139865875, 0.032911013811826706, 0.0017432946478947997, -0.019829751923680305, 0.06837921589612961, -0.01539921946823597, -0.007873902097344398, 0.023764632642269135, 0.02840823493897915, -0.0031354513484984636, 0.029338669031858444, -0.0009279983933083713, -0.015168431214988232, 0.03942249342799187, -0.02563319355249405, 0.036560725420713425, 0.009946738369762897, 0.00790355820208788, 0.01231064461171627, -0.014266032725572586, 0.029824884608387947, 0.020747803151607513, -0.007710483390837908, -0.014519804157316685, 0.0005070831393823028, 0.039955075830221176, 0.030998017638921738, 0.003313780762255192, -0.019310450181365013, -0.026150628924369812, -0.004532161168754101, 0.021009178832173347, 0.05612075701355934, 0.01569628342986107, -0.04701882228255272, -0.01911376789212227, 0.03111954592168331, 0.05399736016988754, 0.0595942847430706, -0.04418453946709633, 0.01787501573562622, -0.024019649252295494, -0.009253179654479027, 0.026865612715482712, -0.02145674265921116, -0.02303006686270237, -0.022841399535536766, 0.025491874665021896, -0.011128337122499943, -0.002436303300783038, 0.05192092806100845, -0.013386277481913567, 0.017765263095498085, -0.00040259832167066634, -0.06449934840202332, -0.06303675472736359, 0.020377589389681816, 0.014866149984300137, -0.0050738235004246235, -0.09619901329278946, -0.004428515676409006, 0.008912719786167145, 0.00043528774403966963, 0.05424538999795914, 0.03485173359513283, 0.002872759709134698, 0.030547035858035088, -0.039705611765384674, -0.021191513165831566, -0.019605161622166634, 0.010348275303840637, -0.053559500724077225, 0.020750118419528008, -0.08478175848722458, 0.021534932777285576, 0.004961714148521423, 0.008547802455723286, -0.028475653380155563, 0.014948030933737755, 0.006981790531426668, -0.004215703345835209, 0.024420270696282387, 0.027774730697274208, -0.03473886102437973, 0.0717160776257515, 0.004135089460760355, -0.006236403249204159, -0.003796239150688052, 0.03526536747813225, 0.02133035846054554, -0.012322298251092434, 0.0001441572530893609, 0.07307644188404083, -0.020162655040621758, 0.026040416210889816, 0.013987000100314617, 0.03351866826415062, -0.020932478830218315, -0.024988509714603424, -0.00716977845877409, 0.012502376921474934, 0.012474369257688522, -0.008981247432529926, 0.055305253714323044, -0.00206767488270998, -0.004337191581726074, 0.041368547827005386, -0.019498644396662712, -0.013439027592539787, -0.024959493428468704, -0.01671265810728073, -0.025356346741318703, 0.007862894795835018, 0.026218699291348457, 0.000904902582988143, 0.05818173289299011, -0.04353783279657364, -0.02136457897722721, -0.015499106608331203, -0.0022737528197467327, 0.03850192204117775, -0.03839528560638428, 0.007936478592455387, 0.08677487075328827, 0.02275761403143406, 0.015783904120326042, 0.024413030594587326, -0.005678145680576563, -0.05726943537592888, -0.02266957424581051, -0.04971052706241608, -0.005042585544288158, 0.03327792137861252, -0.033074814826250076, -0.008126831613481045, 0.0008807003614492714, -0.0004901412758044899, 0.02897428162395954, -0.0061956183053553104, 0.07928402721881866, 0.03233534097671509, -0.00724366307258606, -0.01822943612933159, 0.020764606073498726, 0.052729617804288864, -0.003359053051099181, -0.0042292471043765545, -0.04974760487675667, -0.04539502039551735, 0.018366746604442596, 0.02700294926762581, 0.02305779419839382, -0.02573956549167633, 0.0029105229768902063, 0.07398804277181625, 0.011928612366318703, 0.032222092151641846, 0.019089169800281525, 0.011583792045712471, -0.000924265303183347, 0.007909837178885937, 0.017881210893392563, 0.025053029879927635, -0.016828373074531555, -0.004991545341908932, 0.028131937608122826, -0.02571096271276474, 0.027522338554263115, -0.012337560765445232, 0.0036182631738483906, 0.011173195205628872, 0.04862072691321373, 0.02402380295097828, -0.008553932420909405, 0.048010341823101044, -0.01943262852728367, 0.038332946598529816, 0.025423472747206688, -0.015447353944182396, -0.031062377616763115, 0.017314549535512924, -0.021133052185177803, -0.003208373673260212, 0.035016339272260666, -0.015090808272361755, 0.01455332338809967, 0.03140067309141159, -0.04024115577340126, 0.0071770246140658855, -0.06515364348888397, -0.02559668943285942, -0.013013909570872784, -0.019773121923208237, 0.02053779922425747, 0.003532007336616516, 0.03204057738184929, 0.0030348263680934906, -0.01921052485704422, -0.034435588866472244, -0.007542649749666452, -0.03761295974254608, 0.01546766422688961, -0.05528254061937332, -0.0009329496533609927, 0.00005200012674322352, -0.04661817103624344, 0.02376558817923069, -0.023345982655882835, 0.03126813471317291, 0.03888765722513199, -0.0008044858695939183, -0.034635480493307114, -0.006244016345590353, -0.036955296993255615, -0.020811859518289566, 0.030469350516796112, -0.0458248145878315, 0.015049238689243793, -0.020985949784517288, -0.037590738385915756, 0.03575542941689491, -0.0693214014172554, -0.036447811871767044, -0.04074664041399956, 0.0011266464134678245, -0.006906397640705109, 0.004641565959900618, 0.020715754479169846, 0.007652666419744492, -0.06421239674091339, 0.006986850872635841, -0.06118430569767952, -0.050900526344776154, 0.05414997413754463, 0.019974781200289726, 0.048302192240953445, -0.008505595847964287, 0.006041312590241432, 0.09788266569375992, 0.04476781189441681, -0.020094191655516624, 0.012415640987455845, 0.013814978301525116, -0.014663835987448692, -0.022743888199329376, -0.0043053706176579, 0.016889456659555435, -0.01085931621491909, 0.012172380462288857, 0.0028986253309994936, 0.03321639448404312, 0.06958945840597153, 0.018708249554038048, -0.0072709848172962666, -0.016844335943460464, 0.0033051467034965754, -0.0012008994817733765, 0.07736121118068695, 0.037500593811273575, -0.010783634148538113, -0.021627964451909065, 0.02181006222963333, 0.06652166694402695, 0.02387845329940319, -0.04611789435148239, 0.04772230237722397, -0.00998309813439846, 0.017547255381941795, -0.021373141556978226, 0.052057601511478424, 0.03987930715084076, 0.014815162867307663, 0.0021533893886953592, 0.025952961295843124, 0.018977075815200806, -0.017308669164776802, 0.0060437144711613655, 0.05297243222594261, 0.04864141717553139, 0.008609330281615257, -0.06874392181634903, 0.0017184475436806679, -0.0021015312522649765, 0.011363000608980656, 0.02089129574596882, -0.05561438575387001, 0.024471906945109367, 0.04008645936846733, 0.03183398395776749, 0.016215769574046135, -0.05642746761441231, 0.019066190347075462, -0.10284856706857681, -0.019082680344581604, 0.0012209204724058509, 0.025506682693958282, 0.02071315050125122, -0.009745320305228233, 0.024861913174390793, -0.03838042914867401, 0.0014837580965831876, 0.01494226697832346, -0.060704104602336884, 0.06844530254602432, -0.04227680340409279, -0.04461951553821564, -0.02956937998533249, -0.05921849235892296, 0.009778017178177834, -0.07170669734477997, 0.04341435432434082, -0.01253444142639637, -0.006668091751635075, -0.04019542783498764, 0.0032207367476075888, 0.010621679946780205, -0.012364225462079048, -0.032037366181612015, 0.013305305503308773, 0.03097202442586422, -0.012963438406586647, 0.03664429858326912, 0.022900260984897614, -0.007656047586351633, -0.0334794782102108, -0.026509778574109077, 0.002121551660820842, -0.0028315375093370676, 0.010915391147136688, 0.019549330696463585, 0.01225212775170803, -0.05143919959664345, 0.026981601491570473, 0.013337736949324608, 0.029294021427631378, 0.016909904778003693, -0.012580783106386662, -0.040414195507764816, -0.050683945417404175, -0.033229175955057144, 0.030895203351974487, 0.016387149691581726, -0.0007399872993119061, -0.010708536952733994, 0.06045793369412422, -0.02363857999444008, -0.055466439574956894, 0.027171986177563667, 0.05501911789178848, -0.008761024102568626, -0.021751591935753822, -0.041824985295534134, -0.031089894473552704, -0.0056379809975624084, -0.046889424324035645, 0.03505329042673111, 0.023015622049570084, -0.029593000188469887, -0.005135946441441774, 0.027402682229876518, 0.004306217655539513, -0.05333494022488594, -0.003891623578965664, 0.01599571853876114, 0.06692751497030258, -0.008091905154287815, -0.006721677724272013, 0.03184252977371216, 0.0275165643543005, 0.028373166918754578, 0.0029915268532931805, -0.006812532898038626, -0.0969635397195816, 0.020309656858444214, 0.051310885697603226, 0.0571594275534153, -0.0212263073772192, 0.0003424631431698799, -0.009477674961090088, 0.018579551950097084, 0.06948214024305344, 0.0032564797438681126, 0.0187007375061512, -0.0314791165292263, 0.00833179708570242, -0.017915144562721252, -0.005034725647419691, -0.042813293635845184, 0.0285798367112875, -0.00345798977650702, -0.0011173747479915619, -0.030310513451695442, -0.006006249692291021, -0.016876181587576866, 0.008113202638924122, 0.047278061509132385, 0.06339891254901886, 0.017083879560232162, -0.011079944670200348, -0.002201937837526202, 0.028545290231704712, -0.031706552952528, -0.05140924081206322, -0.020103860646486282, -0.006691658869385719, 0.0028651643078774214, 0.012434357777237892, 0.01229268778115511, -0.06428368389606476, 0.02994103915989399, -0.02671424299478531, -0.02295692078769207, -0.031832221895456314, -0.026748711243271828, 0.0420016348361969, 0.020922347903251648, 0.016416611149907112, 0.04664149135351181, 0.021030545234680176, -0.020342841744422913, 0.012156213633716106, -0.028490155935287476, 0.038045287132263184, -0.05531274154782295, -0.018292423337697983, -0.0037447819486260414, -0.05781514570116997, -0.028092021122574806, 0.004864413756877184, -0.0033450638875365257, 0.04848970100283623, 0.0018403544090688229, -0.03128127008676529, -0.013638926669955254, 0.010342485271394253, 0.03766326978802681, 0.0005786038818769157, -0.006679202895611525, 0.004016345366835594, -0.040362171828746796, -0.0380995087325573, 0.010851842351257801, -0.006575637962669134, 0.03836648166179657, 0.02202552743256092, -0.04343419894576073, -0.002475881017744541, -0.03891855478286743, -0.018394840881228447, 0.01927891932427883, -0.05460727959871292, 0.03905206546187401, -0.011011277325451374, -0.002971495734527707, 0.029018335044384003, -0.04095538333058357, -0.028688112273812294, 0.007280614227056503, -0.003094854298979044, 0.04108024016022682, -0.08326169103384018, 0.06705491244792938, -0.03950442001223564, 0.0041301557794213295, -0.057761527597904205, -0.023628702387213707, 0.022058775648474693, -0.003360736882314086, -0.014702539891004562, -0.011765965260565281, 0.038127947598695755, -0.03165803477168083, -0.036830488592386246, -0.05082559213042259, 0.036857686936855316, -0.00901260320097208, -0.035550426691770554, -0.012942389585077763, 0.0413835383951664, 0.11450137197971344, 0.007822077721357346, 0.004349757917225361, 0.049292948096990585, -0.013031511567533016, -0.02110615372657776, -0.042986996471881866, 0.0386938638985157, -0.03050142712891102, -0.016396809369325638, -0.016986656934022903, 0.009955001063644886, 0.02165118046104908, -0.034791845828294754, -0.01994503103196621, 0.03098602034151554, 0.012982646934688091, 0.024157827720046043, 0.009112806059420109, 0.02923111617565155, -0.004898528568446636, 0.002516381209716201, -0.029672730714082718, 0.02826748602092266, -0.012810682877898216, 0.03550080209970474, -0.0026889932341873646, 0.022301748394966125, 0.008342253975570202, -0.023355484008789062, 0.03415859490633011, -0.0139634869992733, 0.008690771646797657, 0.015123588964343071, -0.0014495126670226455, 0.01014756504446268, -0.006220306269824505, 0.007491833530366421, 0.029104173183441162, 0.017772378399968147, -0.03356846421957016, -0.012754842638969421, -0.009784623980522156, -0.0583392009139061, 0.09133205562829971, -0.012881376780569553, 0.04747075214982033, 0.0199798084795475, 0.028412261977791786, -0.001204664702527225, -0.035423148423433304, -0.02157791517674923, -0.02323761396110058, 0.012285561300814152, 0.02265947312116623, -0.010002204217016697, 0.0288709606975317, -0.007339464966207743, 0.02261526696383953, 0.00009887282794807106, 0.036579541862010956, 0.02869589999318123, 0.02179567888379097, -0.0060745105147361755, 0.025041332468390465, -0.052660778164863586, 0.004921504762023687, -0.038221120834350586, 0.007796855177730322, -0.048019252717494965, 0.013964817859232426, 0.029846711084246635, -0.011773026548326015, -0.003378522116690874, -0.008411909453570843, -0.0007610660395585, -0.025425536558032036, -0.016980929300189018, 0.015127154067158699, -0.034574512392282486, 0.012734584510326385, -0.02069462463259697, 0.024307098239660263, -0.017316658049821854, 0.02290865033864975, -0.06853830069303513, -0.08612046390771866, -0.01666109263896942, -0.020034952089190483, -0.0502358041703701, 0.05782114714384079, -0.01426213700324297, -0.015069282613694668, 0.015247038565576077, 0.0008395700715482235, 0.026839425787329674, 0.0008398190257139504, 0.023582199588418007, -0.04163680225610733, 0.09811779111623764, 0.016186168417334557, -0.01594141684472561, 0.02188153751194477, -0.02761569246649742, 0.10100401937961578, 0.0010163242695853114, 0.032098010182380676, -0.009494449011981487, 0.04385208711028099, -0.028228940442204475, 0.020369399338960648, -0.02618245780467987, 0.03241182491183281, 0.008581885136663914, 0.015438741073012352, 0.052421439439058304, 0.02656363509595394, -0.013957347720861435, -0.03780365735292435, 0.07852586358785629, -0.0009113166015595198, -0.024485178291797638, 0.021033328026533127, 0.027298513799905777, 0.009157044813036919, -0.013284475542604923, -0.012207107618451118, 0.02892199158668518, -0.05040198564529419, 0.010290313512086868, -0.015403573401272297, 0.0008138347184285522, -0.006434774491935968, 0.024003705009818077, -0.03805660456418991, -0.007594343740493059, 0.04181133210659027, 0.014251471497118473, -0.03706132993102074, -0.017304997891187668, 0.03022482804954052, -0.004334327299147844, 0.0006377243553288281, 0.00969691015779972, -0.022366845980286598, -0.009709024801850319, 0.02981492504477501, -0.006398757919669151, -0.06794995814561844, 0.00017569451301824301, -0.014125009067356586, 0.02148420549929142, 0.00020290690008550882, 0.007718411739915609, 0.004764504265040159, 0.007210100069642067, -0.02409827522933483, -0.05015462264418602, 0.011654948815703392, -0.008465277031064034, 0.0032473616302013397, -0.01920694299042225, -0.03845652565360069, -0.013176065869629383, 0.04172230884432793, 0.01184509415179491, 0.021768100559711456, 0.03339932858943939, 0.016395224258303642, -0.01686014048755169, 0.014023561030626297, 0.0267005767673254, -0.029569292441010475, -0.046418722718954086, 0.0015038345009088516, 0.012386040762066841, -0.04107676446437836, -0.014665897004306316, 0.021522341296076775, -0.013998686335980892, 0.01893003284931183, 0.0018126979703083634, 0.007059832569211721, -0.0022889026440680027, -0.056607481092214584, 0.016696825623512268, -0.050982072949409485, -0.014479942619800568, -0.05683206394314766, 0.012456662021577358, 0.028767915442585945, 0.027258239686489105, 0.007479074411094189, 0.022933566942811012, 0.01766614243388176, 0.05504533275961876, 0.018857933580875397, -0.033045247197151184, 0.022632287815213203, 0.004293431527912617, -0.05300536006689072, 0.04561368003487587, 0.0007234952645376325, 0.056950561702251434, 0.05424495413899422, 0.046299148350954056, -0.02620256319642067, 0.012802484445273876, 0.014207730069756508, 0.008125517517328262, -0.01470879651606083, -0.07334738969802856, -0.0012850261991843581, -0.006709549576044083, -0.00462817307561636, -0.01256968080997467, -0.002590237883850932, -0.04304105415940285, -0.021979933604598045, 0.008177281357347965, 0.01881694421172142, -0.004072762094438076, 0.06473014503717422, -0.036825474351644516, -0.007027314975857735, -0.0073563954792916775, 0.005313905421644449, -0.03612935543060303, -0.024917149916291237, -0.031026015058159828, -0.04380158707499504, -0.027104848995804787, 0.033991966396570206, -0.012227635830640793, 0.005469519644975662, 0.04298616200685501, 0.007300696801394224, 0.009261113591492176, -0.004646592773497105, 0.014515520073473454, -0.022775709629058838, 0.04625124856829643, -0.05436806380748749, 0.025585224851965904, 0.06385087966918945, -0.021991364657878876, -0.02792145125567913, 0.011217078194022179, 0.014652897603809834, 0.023028487339615822, -0.0008502982673235238, -0.018127616494894028, -0.007440387271344662, 0.02161763422191143, -0.03355362266302109, -0.03320639580488205, -0.003718322142958641, -0.02031845785677433, 0.034690480679273605, 0.027518169954419136, 0.02145826444029808, 0.00812001246958971, -0.0022989518474787474, 0.006367127411067486, 0.007191815879195929, 0.006799760274589062, 0.05577987805008888, 0.0026889075525105, -0.0020312382839620113, -0.015902146697044373, 0.002651233458891511, -0.012047428637742996, -0.0022283128928393126, 0.03771365061402321, -0.02046343870460987, 0.01931063085794449, -0.016088679432868958, -0.012246819213032722, -0.03384103998541832, -0.031087279319763184, 0.019906822592020035, -0.023183507844805717, 0.025853238999843597, -0.06690654903650284, -0.00602345447987318, 0.00780525291338563, -0.06504717469215393, -0.006221073213964701, -0.01985948719084263, -0.08657500892877579, -0.01572278141975403, -0.01815992407500744, 0.020922966301441193, 0.004417732823640108, 0.028064938262104988, 0.014220386743545532, -0.0037692927289754152, 0.00576520012691617, 0.015705080702900887, -0.028115468099713326, -0.028799712657928467, 0.034790195524692535, 0.026895947754383087, -0.030041327700018883, 0.003606342012062669, -0.054942358285188675, -0.03658769279718399, 0.027770914137363434, -0.017963314428925514, 0.010397039353847504, -0.04594265669584274, 0.027213966473937035, 0.008654181845486164, 0.023615580052137375, 0.019365765154361725, -0.012789618223905563, -0.035077210515737534, -0.00449204770848155, 0.009094743058085442, 0.03745590150356293, -0.027952739968895912, -0.021915456280112267, -0.001031551044434309, -0.029467381536960602, -0.07460521161556244, -0.016628021374344826, -0.004703298211097717, -0.013793406076729298, -0.009761772118508816, 0.028539925813674927, 0.0006416186806745827, -0.07287317514419556, 0.0010313551174476743, -0.028434690088033676, 0.019734814763069153, 0.032680947333574295, -0.00484952237457037, -0.041404061019420624, -0.0028137292247265577, -0.01990487240254879, -0.03052859753370285, -0.002301945583894849, -0.009916634298861027, -0.01952078938484192, -0.05711248517036438, 0.0036872397176921368, -0.016115756705403328, -0.0034655071794986725, -0.012064450420439243, -0.033869583159685135, -0.022177958860993385, 0.036326829344034195, -0.01627061329782009, 0.04262080788612366, 0.009305247105658054, -0.006009053438901901, -0.008643527515232563, -0.06349632889032364, 0.07777749747037888, 0.014674902893602848, 0.00923395436257124, -0.03568294271826744, -0.03370391204953194, -0.04339025914669037, 0.012817001901566982, 0.07132033258676529, 0.010677735321223736, 0.013825824484229088, 0.00165917060803622, 0.00020566905732266605, -0.0006487287464551628, -0.03875543177127838, 0.03876417875289917, -0.0013570496812462807, -0.0313800610601902, -0.03374447673559189, -0.017505763098597527, -0.00791745912283659, -0.017422383651137352, -0.00869763270020485, 0.008993993513286114, 0.030194614082574844, 0.025513039901852608, 0.000381812104023993, 0.07919679582118988, 0.005076760891824961, -0.022809606045484543, 0.04584427922964096, -0.016535131260752678, 0.008164817467331886, 0.03870076686143875, -0.005377988796681166, -0.05085746571421623, 0.0258888378739357, -0.04680657386779785, -0.027549218386411667, -0.025858402252197266, 0.04148847982287407, 0.010004214942455292, -0.036665450781583786, -0.008753654547035694, 0.03825169429183006, -0.04639771953225136, 0.01816720701754093, 0.043697480112314224, 0.013162962161004543, 0.015418590977787971, -0.007318103685975075, 0.02658832259476185, 0.012249992229044437, -0.018993237987160683, 0.033723268657922745, -0.004162556026130915, 0.02939487434923649, -0.005726367235183716, 0.014347118325531483, 0.04344438388943672, 0.006286003161221743, 0.021840166300535202, 0.028365833684802055, 0.07973895967006683, -0.024184202775359154, -0.037885118275880814, 0.003216981189325452, 0.004773945081979036, 0.017149971798062325, 0.028939921408891678, -0.022275740280747414, 0.04267415776848793, 0.0022707385942339897, 0.003181254956871271, -0.046424560248851776, -0.030092837288975716, -0.02974080853164196, -0.006890890654176474, 0.016905687749385834, 0.004549115430563688, 0.010536197572946548, -0.016299646347761154, 0.008297237567603588, 0.0344262532889843, 0.025186818093061447, -0.05455290898680687, 0.03337080404162407, -0.026216037571430206, 0.0150078060105443, -0.04428583383560181, -0.001972626196220517, -0.0491783432662487, -0.004744801204651594, 0.012185106985270977, 0.057637959718704224, 0.025208985432982445, -0.005756130442023277, -0.03031008504331112, -0.002184430370107293, 0.04138578847050667, -0.07963196188211441, -0.020297536626458168, -0.026136210188269615, 0.0060178423300385475, 0.008539879694581032, -0.03820868954062462 ]
<p>Usually all the tests we are using have increasing power as the sample size increases. But what if a test is not consistent? Is it not worthy to develop such a test? Or can it be justified to use an inconsistent test under some circumstances? In particular, as inconsistency is often due to the distributional model? An inconsistent test may still have nontrivial power, only increasing sample sizes don't pay off. Could it be reasonable to use an inconsistent test only for small sample sizes and an consistent test as his power beats the inconsistent one?</p> <p>(I know that there are relevance tests. They are consistent as well but they don't have the disadvantage of consistent point hypothesis tests that show even practically irrelevant effects as significant.)</p> <p>(There are inconsistent tests: E.g. for the location parameter of a shifted Cauchy distribution. As it's mean has the same distribution as a single observation, one can for all sample sizes choose the critical value from the quantile of a Cauchy distribution. But usually one would use a nonparametric consistent test.)</p>
74,444
[ -0.04532603546977043, 0.028413768857717514, 0.004877458792179823, -0.03783037140965462, 0.04920947924256325, 0.015929600223898888, -0.012000733986496925, -0.027188153937458992, -0.022420423105359077, -0.031180942431092262, 0.05385152995586395, 0.01036146841943264, 0.0686408057808876, -0.02049505151808262, -0.02620048262178898, 0.003919214941561222, -0.01007853914052248, -0.011430967599153519, -0.023235252127051353, -0.0034330873750150204, -0.015058515593409538, 0.046417053788900375, 0.019993895664811134, -0.02441965974867344, -0.04093991592526436, 0.04437436908483505, 0.004966095555573702, -0.011212260462343693, 0.0036442980635911226, 0.07054124027490616, -0.06514763087034225, -0.015411722473800182, 0.008478467352688313, 0.03878729045391083, 0.004286551382392645, 0.02116158977150917, -0.010796903632581234, -0.03709450364112854, -0.012109904550015926, 0.057583246380090714, -0.04516466706991196, -0.018558848649263382, 0.008009115234017372, 0.02071494795382023, 0.005307317711412907, 0.013492017984390259, -0.003526736982166767, -0.03135596960783005, 0.03273450955748558, -0.03803884983062744, 0.08014868944883347, 0.012937696650624275, 0.022289419546723366, 0.014128606766462326, -0.01001015119254589, -0.05678229779005051, 0.057503290474414825, 0.053693823516368866, -0.05037831887602806, -0.055548205971717834, 0.0013223390560597181, -0.038758665323257446, 0.011529538780450821, -0.04990096390247345, -0.010582423768937588, 0.04138211905956268, 0.017322277650237083, -0.007492342032492161, 0.06984289735555649, -0.017085585743188858, 0.023619193583726883, 0.008815634995698929, 0.011860824190080166, 0.009813079610466957, -0.01229371502995491, -0.02632252871990204, 0.0331992544233799, 0.013319514691829681, 0.038178395479917526, 0.08501334488391876, 0.010229995474219322, 0.01525847613811493, 0.016152385622262955, 0.006656898185610771, 0.024254558607935905, -0.02748551219701767, 0.03887002915143967, -0.02238008752465248, -0.004179227631539106, 0.018751677125692368, -0.016391566023230553, -0.04961008578538895, 0.04755908250808716, -0.045700930058956146, -0.004497000481933355, 0.006022046785801649, -0.06972838193178177, 0.021931566298007965, -0.015171144157648087, 0.030158335343003273, -0.03071480616927147, -0.0189075767993927, 0.02244396321475506, 0.016664136201143265, -0.04813867807388306, -0.010755019262433052, -0.028533844277262688, 0.005595321301370859, -0.04722282290458679, 0.010812095366418362, -0.016926441341638565, 0.05332183465361595, 0.0028429992962628603, 0.04697709530591965, 0.031617406755685806, 0.013600340113043785, 0.025956908240914345, -0.046500325202941895, 0.0646500289440155, 0.0561659075319767, 0.02236439287662506, 0.00013574218610301614, 0.007260061800479889, -0.037158649414777756, -0.017372354865074158, 0.005225804168730974, 0.014142580330371857, 0.014891843311488628, -0.027833260595798492, 0.06806839257478714, 0.002871421631425619, -0.02149352990090847, 0.034160688519477844, -0.008748823776841164, 0.06428268551826477, 0.01338057592511177, -0.06332717835903168, -0.06421566009521484, 0.042139437049627304, 0.020895056426525116, -0.013174062594771385, -0.050355177372694016, -0.014780049212276936, 0.024506816640496254, 0.034029386937618256, -0.016866344958543777, 0.024772033095359802, -0.0011601471342146397, 0.02306434139609337, 0.033028725534677505, -0.017810972407460213, -0.010466509498655796, 0.009857428260147572, -0.031273480504751205, -0.010772504843771458, -0.08959012478590012, 0.02618679217994213, 0.024437453597784042, 0.015630478039383888, -0.03405449911952019, 0.03702487424015999, -0.0198696069419384, 0.031239517033100128, -0.06846548616886139, 0.022325638681650162, 0.024646177887916565, 0.08405030518770218, -0.0077890390530228615, 0.041706301271915436, -0.0016536976909264922, 0.003963051363825798, 0.017247898504137993, 0.04245218634605408, 0.0500236451625824, 0.03712834417819977, -0.04234236478805542, -0.026537485420703888, -0.07406730949878693, 0.018718168139457703, 0.01575707457959652, -0.04872573912143707, 0.003883665893226862, -0.04915376380085945, -0.023370439186692238, 0.014407292939722538, 0.031860120594501495, -0.0017904257401823997, -0.0031631160527467728, 0.045605190098285675, -0.07054003328084946, -0.028998317196965218, -0.06842809170484543, 0.007576788309961557, -0.010488742962479591, -0.040183015167713165, 0.06892162561416626, 0.011999116279184818, 0.013393072411417961, -0.016533121466636658, 0.02505888231098652, 0.00042396149365231395, 0.0086137093603611, 0.011698673479259014, -0.034095264971256256, 0.008658808656036854, 0.04201143980026245, 0.020643817260861397, -0.014149820432066917, 0.0062469434924423695, -0.037470247596502304, -0.04931258410215378, 0.03239317610859871, -0.0445859357714653, -0.004492052830755711, -0.005924597382545471, 0.0077742659486830235, 0.028297092765569687, 0.01660827361047268, -0.034094784408807755, 0.035395924001932144, -0.03912961855530739, 0.09590940177440643, 0.07161780446767807, 0.012764625251293182, 0.01795022375881672, 0.011731727980077267, 0.001852801302447915, 0.00950988195836544, -0.022965233772993088, -0.02995665743947029, -0.08562108874320984, -0.02152884192764759, 0.02494673989713192, 0.02048523910343647, -0.03080809861421585, 0.014724072068929672, 0.06011783331632614, 0.006304585840553045, -0.005242450162768364, 0.03906470164656639, 0.0006701212259940803, -0.04480046033859253, 0.005731042008846998, -0.006328005343675613, 0.04436999186873436, 0.017695965245366096, 0.023482291027903557, 0.027272509410977364, 0.01920522376894951, -0.01148031372576952, 0.01307781133800745, 0.0013475206214934587, -0.0011114305816590786, 0.002173899207264185, -0.003917219582945108, -0.0029055634513497353, 0.00013740711438003927, -0.006827092729508877, 0.022813646122813225, 0.01612582989037037, -0.006559118628501892, 0.0271193478256464, -0.03937981277704239, -0.03987429663538933, 0.045615945011377335, 0.013043534941971302, 0.0030378990340977907, -0.013821722008287907, 0.022025050595402718, -0.04340527579188347, -0.01921279914677143, -0.05130017548799515, -0.0527663379907608, -0.021846016868948936, 0.007796630263328552, 0.006098969839513302, 0.015022698789834976, 0.030886998400092125, -0.04119544476270676, -0.009254488162696362, -0.026208432391285896, -0.019300544634461403, -0.005445447284728289, -0.007455423939973116, -0.025793567299842834, -0.006810407619923353, 0.0027430374175310135, -0.004671843256801367, 0.026066068559885025, -0.005313934292644262, 0.019351381808519363, 0.025447778403759003, -0.0010539354989305139, -0.05182148888707161, -0.005015276372432709, -0.017677422612905502, -0.0022708033211529255, -0.03880302980542183, -0.05296573415398598, 0.0623963326215744, -0.010291949845850468, -0.03224211558699608, 0.03925056383013725, -0.01152362022548914, -0.04614945501089096, -0.01836119405925274, -0.00019522695220075548, -0.004792114719748497, -0.007857908494770527, 0.012429926544427872, 0.031633730977773666, -0.029800619930028915, -0.03596655651926994, -0.04780011996626854, -0.06592017412185669, 0.033581554889678955, -0.040974210947752, 0.097061887383461, -0.03695152699947357, -0.038979846984148026, 0.05628768354654312, 0.038739919662475586, 0.005084741860628128, -0.027033960446715355, 0.022944699972867966, -0.03575607389211655, 0.007399110589176416, 0.004616052843630314, 0.01243752520531416, 0.006615826394408941, -0.006039007101207972, 0.021420743316411972, 0.0726938471198082, -0.0056248996406793594, 0.046255409717559814, -0.01153523288667202, 0.029621237888932228, 0.026337020099163055, 0.008230603300035, 0.017762044444680214, 0.0313335545361042, -0.029645292088389397, -0.0018070742953568697, 0.00009830521594267339, -0.0026908484287559986, 0.0024100018199533224, -0.028666505590081215, 0.02394535019993782, -0.0011607154738157988, 0.013984274119138718, -0.039862148463726044, 0.04604059085249901, 0.043884824961423874, -0.032075926661491394, -0.022274388000369072, 0.0361509770154953, 0.030892444774508476, 0.00971458200365305, 0.004549812991172075, 0.06801027059555054, 0.03318822756409645, -0.049569468945264816, -0.0021754081826657057, 0.004596122074872255, -0.012449456378817558, 0.04131583869457245, -0.023515259847044945, -0.030852675437927246, 0.055392295122146606, 0.013161443173885345, 0.0021619158796966076, -0.018923575058579445, -0.03763600066304207, 0.020235762000083923, -0.03413819894194603, 0.009258194826543331, -0.006756519433110952, 0.01653735153377056, -0.007116985972970724, 0.024098534137010574, 0.042711105197668076, -0.005347969010472298, -0.024585863575339317, 0.006205605808645487, -0.05525645986199379, -0.00850606244057417, -0.00636227848008275, -0.006383610889315605, -0.020939694717526436, -0.02079836279153824, 0.010854343883693218, -0.02342262864112854, 0.032791342586278915, -0.0034806302282959223, 0.05067547783255577, -0.015580941922962666, 0.025292295962572098, -0.05435781180858612, -0.05984444171190262, 0.0038645390886813402, 0.008704643696546555, 0.024634333327412605, -0.026743358001112938, 0.04314855858683586, 0.03175990656018257, -0.024185949936509132, -0.036657270044088364, 0.007232386618852615, 0.02755034528672695, 0.02256450057029724, 0.04400229454040527, -0.018756406381726265, 0.054657962173223495, -0.03209606930613518, 0.03774462640285492, 0.02530532330274582, 0.017152689397335052, 0.019177403301000595, -0.026484964415431023, -0.02315312996506691, -0.046775348484516144, -0.023863214999437332, -0.011618321761488914, 0.03125683590769768, 0.032058920711278915, -0.05599699541926384, 0.02126026153564453, -0.01765725389122963, -0.050178419798612595, -0.0006752974004484713, 0.03798535838723183, 0.03974420577287674, -0.005095337983220816, -0.044100865721702576, 0.0031954231671988964, -0.0100938081741333, 0.00023645791225135326, 0.0083932401612401, 0.015630118548870087, -0.00891982764005661, -0.02425984852015972, 0.03723003715276718, -0.014563245698809624, -0.016557494178414345, -0.024874113500118256, 0.009676529094576836, 0.018081028014421463, 0.016480600461363792, -0.017956173047423363, 0.04898853972554207, -0.002094135619699955, 0.004397368524223566, 0.06429725140333176, 0.015375467017292976, -0.058576975017786026, 0.035658929497003555, 0.08698604255914688, 0.029679879546165466, -0.013685264624655247, 0.012958486564457417, -0.017177347093820572, -0.012576909735798836, 0.03269229456782341, -0.037508778274059296, 0.008593962527811527, 0.011603361926972866, 0.010409470647573471, -0.04532855376601219, -0.03479255363345146, -0.024849139153957367, 0.0017889912705868483, -0.024554632604122162, 0.008512421511113644, -0.041388075798749924, -0.019316459074616432, -0.027058342471718788, -0.014788134023547173, 0.010448947548866272, 0.05825004354119301, -0.03244669362902641, 0.0008394029573537409, 0.013697025366127491, 0.0008544815354980528, -0.026864608749747276, -0.06940620392560959, -0.007339544594287872, 0.00014568907499779016, -0.0029974032659083605, 0.026612967252731323, 0.006252403371036053, -0.06639020889997482, -0.019937755540013313, -0.003519343910738826, -0.06276515871286392, 0.03962453454732895, -0.022479092702269554, 0.07227401435375214, 0.005343182943761349, 0.015880899503827095, 0.03669556975364685, 0.035861749202013016, -0.0057453676126897335, 0.026996469125151634, -0.008624131791293621, -0.019539272412657738, -0.022106092423200607, 0.007734435610473156, -0.030819306150078773, -0.0022119111381471157, -0.05297493562102318, 0.03540879860520363, 0.009993662126362324, 0.015178811736404896, -0.011435032822191715, 0.017545098438858986, -0.006609594449400902, 0.01138313114643097, 0.05867261439561844, 0.01914442703127861, 0.002735432703047991, 0.04245225340127945, 0.02344590798020363, 0.008815729059278965, 0.05976169556379318, 0.015941450372338295, 0.012979171238839626, 0.006422247737646103, -0.019558625295758247, 0.012150267139077187, -0.027528857812285423, -0.023931367322802544, 0.02777591533958912, -0.001801548060029745, 0.043367303907871246, 0.015090721659362316, 0.006579934153705835, 0.0033623059280216694, -0.03632591664791107, -0.008348786272108555, 0.03489729389548302, -0.00454216543585062, 0.03311994671821594, -0.023705249652266502, 0.017977086827158928, -0.006795972585678101, 0.017680659890174866, -0.07845056056976318, 0.007364915683865547, 0.017671817913651466, -0.010365241207182407, -0.0029303929768502712, -0.0030850411858409643, 0.029208673164248466, 0.006512633990496397, -0.0062275538221001625, -0.034502409398555756, 0.01732412725687027, 0.012482848018407822, -0.012414790689945221, 0.003482504514977336, 0.04642844200134277, 0.0772293284535408, -0.04334120452404022, -0.019506871700286865, 0.01468566246330738, -0.023182891309261322, -0.027826184406876564, 0.002313745440915227, -0.014702857472002506, -0.018743738532066345, -0.04336868226528168, -0.026052426546812057, -0.01784825697541237, 0.017628755420446396, -0.012016678228974342, -0.03466050326824188, -0.005682049319148064, -0.06322861462831497, 0.010672221891582012, 0.0006737999501638114, -0.0029728368390351534, -0.015632525086402893, -0.0015242198714986444, -0.01995246112346649, 0.015520783141255379, 0.010165235958993435, -0.036206383258104324, -0.000598565093241632, 0.018445562571287155, -0.041943494230508804, 0.026802649721503258, 0.04109669849276543, -0.031007088720798492, 0.007340440060943365, -0.0031171345617622137, -0.022213030606508255, 0.020419932901859283, 0.014138307422399521, -0.04619566723704338, -0.03823691979050636, -0.004917568527162075, -0.025109874084591866, -0.017558883875608444, -0.0016384371556341648, -0.005474429111927748, 0.05554840713739395, 0.029151245951652527, 0.041375838220119476, 0.036021146923303604, -0.015272017568349838, 0.012147385627031326, 0.002841028617694974, 0.008713090792298317, -0.04395805299282074, -0.009225942194461823, 0.01895194686949253, -0.030421053990721703, 0.013064224272966385, 0.07617741078138351, 0.019227389246225357, 0.0314713716506958, 0.02224479429423809, 0.030680134892463684, 0.005260861944407225, 0.05102131888270378, -0.03421058878302574, -0.05775683373212814, 0.025679681450128555, -0.06478437036275864, 0.02666325867176056, -0.012160301208496094, 0.00938525702804327, 0.008140409365296364, 0.017049439251422882, -0.008676481433212757, -0.045258939266204834, -0.023150376975536346, -0.07184064388275146, -0.00012694386532530189, -0.026784177869558334, -0.0025617992505431175, 0.007731719873845577, -0.015485513024032116, 0.04152345284819603, 0.005059092305600643, -0.00818651169538498, -0.028082087635993958, -0.07510966062545776, -0.048850156366825104, -0.008583376184105873, -0.061154838651418686, 0.05092376470565796, -0.011026343330740929, -0.018319515511393547, 0.00877421349287033, -0.03620850667357445, -0.0091611472889781, 0.04577719792723656, 0.010683131404221058, -0.026785636320710182, 0.06159716844558716, -0.012216569855809212, 0.010309288278222084, 0.007288339547812939, -0.0038757198490202427, 0.11071007698774338, 0.06842025369405746, 0.026883555576205254, -0.02872023917734623, 0.03349830210208893, -0.003449017880484462, 0.004213928710669279, -0.018810845911502838, 0.02550279162824154, 0.01936507038772106, -0.011290949769318104, 0.009976223111152649, 0.06216387078166008, -0.009405305609107018, -0.010059377178549767, 0.04931490868330002, -0.012689069844782352, -0.032474856823682785, 0.009747282601892948, 0.020786063745617867, -0.0001525731640867889, 0.007403578609228134, -0.02785022184252739, 0.015439404174685478, 0.010119866579771042, -0.028371045365929604, 0.012173805385828018, -0.020053653046488762, 0.020324114710092545, 0.0036285179667174816, -0.038748327642679214, -0.029634037986397743, 0.003646232420578599, -0.015388262458145618, -0.04579406604170799, -0.018112393096089363, -0.0014786537503823638, -0.013759243302047253, 0.01346959825605154, 0.06072084233164787, -0.019487131386995316, -0.002279754262417555, 0.011242227628827095, 0.03944661095738411, -0.028818663209676743, -0.025922641158103943, -0.009724832139909267, 0.027510058134794235, -0.02300306037068367, 0.04984154552221298, 0.005708170589059591, -0.011446712538599968, 0.0037117921747267246, -0.032987840473651886, -0.025846971198916435, 0.034539803862571716, 0.01304877270013094, 0.004747013561427593, -0.014915079809725285, -0.01812957599759102, 0.017941277474164963, 0.011138007044792175, 0.019758688285946846, 0.035664428025484085, -0.053947772830724716, -0.044362060725688934, -0.007059994153678417, 0.05912343040108681, 0.01823122799396515, -0.006332533899694681, -0.015607702545821667, 0.004814314190298319, -0.03583000600337982, 0.017762565985322, -0.0037990736309438944, -0.0110741863027215, 0.03541289642453194, -0.009792818687856197, 0.018165817484259605, -0.04960547015070915, -0.02765756845474243, 0.019705623388290405, -0.058441247791051865, -0.02876151166856289, -0.05089101940393448, 0.02179522067308426, 0.016923435032367706, 0.024060003459453583, 0.00801166146993637, 0.000854796264320612, -0.004684574902057648, 0.037906911224126816, 0.05513222515583038, -0.08891993761062622, -0.03473607450723648, -0.04036635160446167, -0.022831007838249207, -0.011414212174713612, 0.0132339121773839, 0.03335919976234436, 0.005166244693100452, 0.0038272803649306297, 0.020790718495845795, 0.010494166985154152, 0.015682080760598183, 0.01639649085700512, 0.012261399067938328, -0.047070059925317764, -0.0037922835908830166, 0.02666890248656273, -0.015899913385510445, -0.02838868647813797, -0.025922700762748718, -0.054888442158699036, -0.00008146507752826437, 0.026258140802383423, -0.009827796369791031, -0.005698028486222029, -0.023618215695023537, 0.00701884226873517, 0.03535306826233864, -0.023474358022212982, -0.003091674530878663, -0.013949131593108177, -0.03348290175199509, -0.012886567041277885, 0.010446608066558838, -0.014715738594532013, 0.011650304310023785, -0.03337109088897705, -0.003942688927054405, 0.023812614381313324, 0.020582107827067375, -0.0016377823194488883, -0.0003625440294854343, -0.0028648630250245333, 0.015870165079832077, 0.05227161571383476, -0.038985759019851685, -0.029591122642159462, 0.06539659202098846, -0.03519153222441673, -0.04276856780052185, 0.011758716776967049, -0.006817845162004232, 0.02415493130683899, 0.01498145516961813, 0.04065687209367752, -0.01980740576982498, -0.01328832283616066, -0.02280707284808159, 0.003729120595380664, -0.01767527498304844, 0.014990897849202156, 0.030593622475862503, 0.012349157594144344, 0.01835431344807148, -0.002113568829372525, -0.030434364452958107, 0.027167802676558495, 0.05241548642516136, 0.027349328622221947, 0.006450356915593147, 0.006787383928894997, -0.0172591432929039, 0.015345238149166107, 0.006216444540768862, -0.06293503195047379, 0.06034686043858528, 0.07752181589603424, -0.05179271847009659, 0.043577514588832855, -0.011877252720296383, -0.00004198998067295179, -0.08011253923177719, -0.02379012294113636, 0.03515392169356346, 0.034228548407554626, 0.016856206580996513, -0.009754891507327557, 0.012826526537537575, 0.032255787402391434, -0.06669057160615921, 0.045670051127672195, -0.03912696614861488, -0.00021686821128241718, -0.04157615080475807, -0.016630984842777252, -0.02098577469587326, 0.046032875776290894, 0.019158275797963142, 0.05820947140455246, 0.01621752604842186, 0.016600020229816437, 0.015735236927866936, 0.0039947666227817535, 0.007930664345622063, 0.012038690969347954, -0.02605186402797699, -0.06952778995037079, 0.01867375709116459, -0.031247340142726898, -0.014575199224054813, 0.02057405188679695, -0.004015629179775715, 0.03621624410152435, -0.022077079862356186, 0.003924721386283636, 0.005085269920527935, 0.06295094639062881, 0.03463128209114075, 0.010781503282487392, -0.0291917622089386, -0.012806880287826061, -0.0007325262995436788, 0.038974273949861526, 0.008364212699234486, 0.008722946047782898, 0.02533147484064102, -0.05961720645427704, 0.0035524372942745686, -0.009441599249839783, -0.012548353523015976, -0.008098093792796135, 0.01631942391395569, 0.0058453758247196674, -0.015340635553002357, 0.027806423604488373, 0.033157091587781906, -0.04817221313714981, -0.031086258590221405, 0.012137636542320251, 0.07395882159471512, -0.0009910257067531347, 0.037739817053079605, 0.02661898359656334, -0.005616903770714998, 0.028021158650517464, 0.012217638082802296, 0.005490220617502928, -0.05146924778819084, 0.009396731853485107, -0.029919708147644997, -0.01753224804997444, -0.03157884255051613, -0.03368326276540756, -0.015264070592820644, 0.03146986663341522, -0.04484472796320915, -0.0023397356271743774, 0.007207836024463177, -0.041689079254865646, 0.020801138132810593, -0.08999687433242798, 0.07778891921043396, -0.033148422837257385, 0.013311624526977539, -0.025188863277435303, -0.017404168844223022, -0.05076722055673599, 0.012895231135189533, 0.05722522363066673, 0.015101931989192963, 0.0141674242913723, 0.016428450122475624, -0.018175451084971428, 0.039315152913331985, -0.08855917304754257, 0.028640903532505035, -0.00654501561075449, 0.00993370171636343, 0.0026609250344336033, 0.01738356240093708, 0.008672459982335567, 0.007594436872750521, 0.034587644040584564, -0.015681568533182144, 0.030283721163868904, -0.002922755666077137, -0.022615954279899597, 0.06015695631504059, 0.03134613856673241, -0.025372732430696487, 0.05219574272632599, -0.004148697480559349, 0.04315810650587082, 0.024330265820026398, -0.001281907083466649, -0.07963460683822632, 0.01845204271376133, -0.003973423503339291, -0.04990428686141968, 0.0029857265762984753, 0.050517451018095016, 0.011001375503838062, -0.05586600676178932, -0.0028019254095852375, 0.03520747646689415, -0.01939515769481659, 0.0033954645041376352, 0.011610792018473148, 0.035374660044908524, 0.039557233452796936, 0.0180238988250494, -0.009062432684004307, -0.005061462055891752, 0.008259912952780724, -0.0196126289665699, 0.00020332526764832437, 0.012478876858949661, -0.015675293281674385, 0.012874634005129337, 0.014011486433446407, -0.020271362736821175, 0.010112649761140347, -0.003910860978066921, 0.04855952039361, -0.012895281426608562, -0.010385490022599697, -0.002439062809571624, 0.024960167706012726, 0.026769133284687996, 0.03024587407708168, -0.018886322155594826, 0.04716102406382561, 0.006135195028036833, 0.023193834349513054, -0.01838100515305996, -0.040800999850034714, -0.016313182190060616, 0.007458573207259178, 0.023283127695322037, -0.006759196519851685, -0.0035229395143687725, -0.0009765778668224812, 0.03946852311491966, -0.002557101659476757, 0.021368730813264847, -0.045317042618989944, 0.001821400597691536, -0.022673776373267174, -0.002809501253068447, -0.03931732103228569, -0.0014386969851329923, -0.0440819188952446, -0.003940248861908913, 0.014835582114756107, 0.027747299522161484, 0.020012740045785904, -0.004535502754151821, -0.04900307208299637, 0.003168042516335845, 0.06284058094024658, -0.06933377683162689, -0.014461781829595566, -0.025681788101792336, 0.012911779806017876, 0.013914115726947784, -0.025575103238224983 ]
<p>I'm building a logit model using R and I'm getting a result of 88.9% of accuracy (verified using the ROC [in rattle, evaluation tab] using 30% of my 34k dataset).</p> <p>What kind of tests would be interesting to do to certify myself that it's a good model?</p>
74,445
[ -0.04084182158112526, 0.016086256131529808, -0.010142515413463116, -0.001896267756819725, 0.037860892713069916, 0.009881455451250076, 0.008792359381914139, -0.004674967378377914, 0.03836185112595558, 0.011321600526571274, 0.03669428452849388, 0.036491382867097855, 0.021884407848119736, 0.03880172595381737, 0.0028126705437898636, 0.004836025182157755, -0.004345540422946215, -0.03275227174162865, -0.03351467847824097, 0.013277550227940083, -0.004992709029465914, -0.021423649042844772, 0.017432697117328644, -0.012952188961207867, -0.01276971586048603, 0.052323803305625916, 0.016222571954131126, -0.023417361080646515, 0.013260047882795334, 0.040118228644132614, -0.027862414717674255, 0.008651074022054672, 0.018348699435591698, 0.02977651357650757, 0.03741493448615074, 0.021617421880364418, -0.011665860190987587, -0.019387371838092804, -0.013923947699368, 0.020894112065434456, -0.024083653464913368, -0.004603969864547253, 0.028460294008255005, 0.025761207565665245, 0.031283967196941376, 0.013023722916841507, -0.052034903317689896, -0.008610589429736137, 0.07196832448244095, -0.02992548979818821, 0.05147942155599594, 0.02940077893435955, 0.0070844609290361404, 0.048740312457084656, 0.04169280454516411, -0.020582275465130806, 0.04508614167571068, 0.0714188739657402, -0.041626930236816406, -0.0474250391125679, -0.020583482459187508, -0.03375646471977234, -0.023207075893878937, -0.05915473774075508, -0.032774925231933594, 0.035543348640203476, -0.007886426523327827, -0.016545912250876427, 0.04609961062669754, 0.009442067705094814, -0.0028219809755682945, 0.03554433584213257, 0.007095875684171915, 0.01402298267930746, 0.029217269271612167, -0.031131677329540253, 0.018023381009697914, 0.004411524627357721, 0.014265698380768299, 0.024389706552028656, -0.02350366674363613, -0.0004503481322899461, 0.022701874375343323, 0.039850980043411255, 0.012997390702366829, -0.04560212790966034, 0.06770700216293335, 0.013257361948490143, -0.014332892373204231, 0.009156133979558945, -0.017454825341701508, -0.003842949867248535, 0.02701275236904621, 0.03603102266788483, -0.020941579714417458, 0.017804095521569252, -0.03206231817603111, 0.03770720586180687, 0.0185407642275095, -0.036600902676582336, -0.023390553891658783, -0.01617608405649662, 0.024573206901550293, 0.050135545432567596, -0.04345650598406792, 0.005781159270554781, 0.014250556007027626, -0.03977295756340027, -0.011046702973544598, -0.04374638572335243, -0.0586932934820652, 0.019179195165634155, -0.012461742386221886, 0.02266097441315651, 0.03852907940745354, -0.01119625847786665, -0.03310711681842804, -0.039442043751478195, 0.049270909279584885, 0.05303340032696724, 0.05752238631248474, -0.00693780230358243, 0.018219131976366043, -0.04951852932572365, -0.02137531153857708, 0.014087063260376453, 0.02168172225356102, -0.023090993985533714, -0.04870864748954773, 0.05940671265125275, 0.008052774704992771, -0.05921037122607231, -0.012806534767150879, -0.02033340185880661, 0.030328400433063507, 0.008020242676138878, -0.0783037468791008, -0.0880812257528305, 0.01242087222635746, 0.005948915146291256, -0.011831586249172688, -0.0300581157207489, -0.011815659701824188, 0.02656404674053192, 0.040907107293605804, 0.018152859061956406, 0.022388704121112823, 0.010867518372833729, 0.024211294949054718, -0.015354664996266365, -0.05773251876235008, -0.03820622339844704, -0.03570151701569557, -0.013791329227387905, 0.0024806009605526924, -0.07302532345056534, 0.013330189511179924, -0.00868980772793293, -0.0017012027092278004, -0.049282435327768326, 0.029041090980172157, -0.012296576984226704, -0.025292785838246346, -0.03080260194838047, -0.01326653454452753, -0.0069088926538825035, 0.06928063929080963, -0.00841728039085865, 0.007903708145022392, 0.026017609983682632, -0.003989111166447401, 0.018155721947550774, 0.0530381053686142, 0.020656302571296692, 0.0186994019895792, -0.01846364699304104, 0.020898345857858658, -0.06873094290494919, 0.006083895917981863, 0.004232050850987434, 0.005586992017924786, -0.006511588115245104, -0.03596809133887291, -0.0195844154804945, -0.009992524050176144, 0.008571731857955456, -0.0012698956998065114, -0.036137063056230545, 0.05319353565573692, -0.030933834612369537, -0.05171157047152519, -0.05876300111413002, 0.02807868830859661, -0.02315794676542282, -0.01365969143807888, -0.017919600009918213, 0.010674405843019485, 0.029516305774450302, -0.012483512051403522, 0.0019398974254727364, -0.05110955238342285, 0.02135569229722023, 0.036675699055194855, -0.02391744591295719, -0.0020337775349617004, 0.013581572100520134, 0.044464029371738434, -0.04641430824995041, 0.03545908257365227, -0.04929513856768608, -0.04836514964699745, 0.0028604997787624598, -0.04296839237213135, -0.019897032529115677, -0.01307755894958973, 0.0021189511753618717, 0.010884895920753479, -0.013394234701991081, -0.02027471736073494, 0.02565712109208107, -0.04622715711593628, 0.06366267055273056, 0.033758435398340225, 0.021882610395550728, 0.0033344505354762077, -0.015333537943661213, -0.016305536031723022, 0.0353139229118824, -0.048221293836832047, -0.01529006753116846, -0.0493696890771389, 0.011967485770583153, 0.049118272960186005, 0.0056331465020775795, -0.0015915902331471443, 0.03418398275971413, 0.03512440621852875, -0.0026329117827117443, -0.012751242145895958, -0.0010593493934720755, -0.009541370905935764, 0.013511138036847115, 0.005205502267926931, -0.00848697591573, 0.024207646027207375, 0.02477194182574749, 0.015200400725007057, -0.001845149789005518, 0.009072654880583286, 0.014102771878242493, -0.005076197441667318, 0.05314572900533676, -0.012216046452522278, -0.027853641659021378, -0.008209511637687683, -0.03422858566045761, 0.05282939597964287, -0.017741715535521507, -0.03661733493208885, 0.04550845921039581, 0.014701356180012226, 0.004988445900380611, 0.02840842865407467, -0.003776073921471834, 0.0373309850692749, 0.07276123017072678, -0.02194671705365181, -0.010182623751461506, 0.05394541099667549, -0.05508865788578987, 0.022336935624480247, -0.02146010659635067, -0.03316766768693924, -0.015253707766532898, 0.03521532937884331, 0.04582420736551285, 0.0155484015122056, 0.0252546276897192, -0.017300598323345184, -0.04007875546813011, 0.01943199895322323, -0.013415255583822727, 0.03911546990275383, 0.008714339695870876, -0.04345615208148956, 0.00547698512673378, -0.009039439260959625, -0.004535303451120853, 0.0622514970600605, -0.00831202045083046, -0.027866162359714508, 0.0338028259575367, 0.009328882209956646, -0.021371688693761826, -0.005971518345177174, -0.04028908908367157, -0.014018340036273003, -0.0029790205880999565, -0.03292878717184067, 0.00411792891100049, -0.020288212224841118, -0.028037168085575104, 0.032000910490751266, -0.03755767270922661, 0.02856186218559742, -0.015625663101673126, -0.015948498621582985, -0.01246740110218525, 0.01727878488600254, 0.033582136034965515, -0.010032204911112785, -0.03360825404524803, -0.019869139418005943, -0.09008601307868958, -0.09317471086978912, 0.0191936194896698, -0.008449818938970566, 0.04663462191820145, 0.003372756764292717, -0.02628360688686371, 0.05055404081940651, 0.04958730190992355, -0.042237672954797745, -0.04021266847848892, 0.016604183241724968, -0.05315263569355011, -0.025563912466168404, -0.002867775969207287, 0.005625722464174032, 0.00019818800501525402, 0.01812681555747986, 0.003585211234167218, 0.011477873660624027, 0.011924218386411667, 0.012572519481182098, -0.00223733764141798, 0.02642083913087845, -0.02068789303302765, -0.02090628631412983, 0.02048216387629509, 0.018249910324811935, -0.038410380482673645, -0.011992757208645344, 0.0036693732254207134, 0.02715391106903553, 0.04733164608478546, -0.04596108943223953, 0.02276868373155594, 0.014235205017030239, 0.008694589138031006, -0.0072799078188836575, 0.014632515609264374, -0.009667260572314262, -0.036276642233133316, -0.007907716557383537, 0.031590111553668976, 0.0036710617132484913, -0.005656448658555746, 0.0053375763818621635, 0.017354438081383705, 0.02860161103308201, -0.0073176221922039986, 0.007824525237083435, -0.03439473360776901, -0.010517120361328125, -0.0027433219365775585, 0.002564799739047885, 0.00820696260780096, 0.06800917536020279, 0.0035542529076337814, 0.03340597450733185, -0.025911973789334297, -0.023105617612600327, 0.0025177132338285446, -0.034155093133449554, -0.015054983086884022, -0.04653460159897804, 0.03673459216952324, 0.0029172878712415695, 0.012987989000976086, 0.013657157309353352, -0.022404279559850693, -0.0006027558702044189, 0.019347013905644417, -0.02299514040350914, 0.029140081256628036, -0.014409465715289116, -0.010461757890880108, 0.018970469012856483, -0.028849082067608833, 0.007956497371196747, -0.032919369637966156, 0.0030287334229797125, -0.022533545270562172, 0.026244929060339928, 0.0031817988492548466, -0.009694063104689121, -0.02479790896177292, -0.02759258635342121, 0.003606939921155572, -0.026399048045277596, -0.00611027330160141, 0.023826438933610916, 0.020659150555729866, 0.03869635984301567, 0.023351790383458138, -0.020497094839811325, 0.0018175712320953608, -0.016076311469078064, 0.014992635697126389, 0.06425876915454865, 0.013570821844041348, 0.014549396000802517, -0.023429671302437782, 0.0665469765663147, -0.02652985043823719, 0.04387259855866432, 0.026943296194076538, -0.016257865354418755, -0.03048989176750183, -0.05481499806046486, -0.02401297725737095, 0.04229691997170448, 0.01455945149064064, -0.0018897582776844501, -0.017757700756192207, 0.05267905443906784, 0.033696144819259644, -0.05447537079453468, -0.02029021829366684, 0.071526899933815, 0.008330341428518295, -0.0012288694269955158, -0.0013630171306431293, -0.0356990322470665, 0.012409262359142303, -0.0029556863009929657, 0.0061921291053295135, 0.01906789280474186, -0.0057838065549731255, 0.004983630962669849, 0.02027967758476734, -0.014240145683288574, -0.04807356745004654, -0.006626284681260586, -0.0008820075308904052, 0.055511120706796646, -0.013860049657523632, -0.03192339465022087, -0.01315112691372633, 0.034271884709596634, 0.015253763645887375, -0.005693402606993914, -0.015115565620362759, -0.0793876200914383, 0.026204105466604233, 0.03485843166708946, 0.0030272884760051966, -0.045909516513347626, -0.020397914573550224, -0.03987215459346771, -0.021884286776185036, 0.03725999966263771, -0.038856491446495056, 0.03804904222488403, -0.003814748954027891, 0.017667459324002266, -0.046629276126623154, 0.015071377158164978, -0.04579060524702072, 0.002087888540700078, 0.01633458025753498, 0.024696461856365204, -0.02094428613781929, -0.04565161466598511, -0.06250692158937454, 0.03340742737054825, 0.03632287681102753, 0.068633072078228, -0.02222205325961113, -0.03198467195034027, 0.02113869972527027, -0.012899336405098438, -0.023114200681447983, -0.03760913386940956, -0.016467539593577385, 0.016039803624153137, -0.04386536777019501, 0.022866958752274513, -0.0017328120302408934, -0.03621140867471695, 0.015006070956587791, -0.0021752940956503153, -0.02607390284538269, 0.03235023468732834, -0.04818121716380119, 0.034958235919475555, 0.0116101810708642, 0.06506489962339401, 0.0482608862221241, 0.018039343878626823, 0.00621368270367384, 0.029250210151076317, -0.003326824866235256, -0.0045952145010232925, -0.014392070472240448, -0.02917657233774662, -0.026197975501418114, -0.010894539766013622, -0.03817351907491684, 0.012354620732367039, 0.009761271066963673, 0.03825507313013077, -0.02984279952943325, 0.006571799982339144, 0.008934705518186092, 0.019297407940030098, -0.041528575122356415, -0.01078026369214058, 0.04680436849594116, 0.03167411684989929, -0.02048015408217907, 0.01526285894215107, 0.028196148574352264, 0.021873297169804573, -0.0030197419691830873, 0.01357938814908266, -0.04772935062646866, 0.05599193647503853, -0.030342603102326393, -0.03233373537659645, 0.00933817122131586, -0.0320892371237278, 0.06374439597129822, 0.0116540202870965, 0.04401807859539986, -0.03774459660053253, -0.03367474675178528, -0.01939651183784008, 0.030609598383307457, 0.01543158944696188, 0.0894356518983841, -0.0062485067173838615, -0.00023660574515815824, -0.0362769216299057, 0.000004790621005668072, -0.053528811782598495, -0.06272920966148376, 0.035930175334215164, 0.016553085297346115, -0.05646451935172081, -0.03899684548377991, 0.014783336780965328, -0.03432794660329819, -0.02318136766552925, -0.02081233821809292, 0.06868408620357513, -0.0032280227169394493, 0.015227627009153366, -0.009557844139635563, -0.007938933558762074, 0.09517461806535721, 0.04869001358747482, 0.014692849479615688, 0.020446278154850006, -0.037360623478889465, -0.024207986891269684, 0.008337104693055153, -0.0071769277565181255, -0.05002179369330406, -0.01648949645459652, -0.028133438900113106, 0.02497691474854946, 0.027901211753487587, -0.011825819499790668, -0.0022190921008586884, -0.00425666943192482, -0.05214053392410278, -0.024122128263115883, -0.018932782113552094, 0.032402150332927704, -0.03075498156249523, -0.015698717907071114, -0.01656133309006691, -0.001330932485871017, 0.006737894844263792, -0.028596090152859688, 0.05361371114850044, -0.018869342282414436, 0.016768498346209526, 0.0008051712065935135, 0.08573832362890244, 0.014284264296293259, 0.015091986395418644, 0.010508911684155464, -0.014736225828528404, 0.01527707464993, -0.015771258622407913, 0.0017883552936837077, 0.0012500245356932282, 0.030289407819509506, -0.06319364160299301, -0.057426415383815765, -0.026431379839777946, -0.02067023329436779, 0.05793049558997154, -0.003694110084325075, 0.041347552090883255, 0.036017175763845444, 0.015423418022692204, 0.0018474517855793238, 0.006417942699044943, -0.04026523977518082, 0.009072060696780682, 0.04163993522524834, 0.04157719761133194, 0.01623242162168026, 0.01908304914832115, 0.014533668756484985, -0.005167108960449696, 0.04504943639039993, 0.029689110815525055, 0.04130124673247337, 0.016436487436294556, 0.024716941639780998, -0.028456956148147583, -0.05917377769947052, 0.041592951864004135, -0.0729372650384903, 0.015170142985880375, -0.04439840093255043, 0.014514167793095112, 0.011850258335471153, 0.030504699796438217, -0.03131565451622009, -0.023591164499521255, -0.02455780655145645, -0.07410312443971634, 0.024809416383504868, 0.019527731463313103, -0.03285834565758705, 0.024029798805713654, -0.006806595716625452, 0.02549229934811592, -0.02184978686273098, 0.041197098791599274, -0.01484736055135727, -0.10430905967950821, 0.020973796024918556, 0.03057350404560566, -0.03531673923134804, 0.016125502064824104, 0.016809938475489616, -0.01454484835267067, -0.007292681373655796, -0.04255086928606033, 0.009523681364953518, 0.01730213314294815, 0.021857941523194313, -0.022728705778717995, 0.04923604801297188, -0.06316570937633514, 0.008632928133010864, -0.0026416447944939137, -0.0019446240039542317, 0.1223665252327919, 0.06597518920898438, 0.031073827296495438, -0.04548708721995354, 0.030395913869142532, 0.03442151099443436, 0.02678377740085125, -0.002671348862349987, 0.0005744389491155744, 0.0183466337621212, 0.03255172818899155, 0.05126805230975151, 0.01564056985080242, 0.0007874328293837607, 0.016214925795793533, 0.056148163974285126, -0.01573730818927288, -0.01894902065396309, 0.01140295248478651, 0.0024920268915593624, -0.01863406039774418, -0.048544060438871384, -0.03857409581542015, 0.029638946056365967, 0.02678217552602291, -0.02613220550119877, 0.007605643477290869, -0.00717814639210701, 0.04214073345065117, -0.0034809072967618704, 0.014187080785632133, 0.020808516070246696, -0.0008916890947148204, 0.018335383385419846, -0.027257779613137245, -0.009418169967830181, -0.0136524373665452, -0.007791414856910706, 0.01919553242623806, 0.04314354807138443, -0.012316565029323101, -0.011262263171374798, -0.03348406031727791, 0.011769518256187439, -0.031897686421871185, -0.029707564041018486, -0.05316931754350662, 0.01388487871736288, -0.007279019802808762, -0.013699748553335667, -0.007107647135853767, 0.03218116983771324, -0.00581837585195899, -0.04917270690202713, -0.052659012377262115, 0.019947070628404617, 0.017842451110482216, -0.03465085104107857, -0.021170657128095627, -0.02338593639433384, 0.03432903066277504, -0.00030835895449854434, 0.01612783968448639, 0.0405224971473217, -0.019879762083292007, -0.04165352135896683, -0.01591220125555992, 0.05009077861905098, -0.01565965823829174, 0.00579114118590951, 0.016594097018241882, -0.027439849451184273, -0.014387400820851326, -0.0013522873632609844, 0.0022150524891912937, 0.005985538009554148, -0.0037307259626686573, 0.028051912784576416, -0.021025843918323517, -0.038543201982975006, -0.009318224154412746, -0.005851222202181816, -0.012167882174253464, -0.007605773396790028, -0.07527846097946167, -0.019676292315125465, 0.019481565803289413, -0.0005754980375058949, 0.05343940481543541, 0.034714121371507645, -0.0020892738830298185, 0.03797273710370064, -0.01149902306497097, -0.02986825443804264, -0.01129923015832901, 0.025689873844385147, -0.03791467845439911, -0.0016737536061555147, -0.018045535311102867, 0.08705361932516098, 0.03430439531803131, 0.02520011179149151, 0.003016739385202527, 0.012856671586632729, -0.02603008598089218, 0.04693318530917168, 0.014088266529142857, -0.05088400840759277, -0.04761268198490143, -0.010407143272459507, 0.025258177891373634, -0.019973432645201683, -0.029993707314133644, -0.05626077950000763, -0.06103990599513054, 0.013912046328186989, -0.023351021111011505, -0.036335647106170654, 0.026745185256004333, 0.017887825146317482, 0.033346112817525864, -0.06036937236785889, 0.026654811576008797, -0.023319371044635773, -0.007114596199244261, -0.03191696107387543, -0.045225512236356735, 0.03246334567666054, 0.006475562695413828, -0.00691776629537344, 0.0004131109162699431, 0.04300466552376747, -0.006954224314540625, -0.010165686719119549, 0.00018346488650422543, 0.027399683371186256, 0.047397345304489136, 0.056991223245859146, -0.022347059100866318, 0.0118166608735919, 0.06623800843954086, -0.04015304520726204, -0.03437962755560875, -0.002576481783762574, -0.03678242117166519, 0.014376949518918991, -0.011667097918689251, -0.021960847079753876, 0.03316529467701912, 0.04471008852124214, 0.005051123443990946, -0.02363607846200466, 0.0009461629670113325, 0.01731245405972004, -0.0010419008322060108, 0.0560537613928318, 0.01836603507399559, -0.0025290255434811115, -0.0012682414380833507, 0.030316218733787537, 0.045877378433942795, -0.022324826568365097, -0.0017721990589052439, 0.014903406612575054, -0.021784158423542976, -0.000732088868971914, 0.0007644594879820943, 0.003021408338099718, 0.0011006153654307127, 0.020137038081884384, -0.012782608158886433, 0.016239114105701447, -0.03677823394536972, -0.0026385439559817314, -0.05340375751256943, -0.021721024066209793, 0.01111533585935831, -0.0028317985124886036, 0.016752079129219055, -0.04592562094330788, 0.02979358471930027, 0.055453959852457047, -0.026118038222193718, 0.03201261907815933, 0.007588847540318966, -0.01832021400332451, -0.008085484616458416, -0.008223014883697033, -0.014150060713291168, 0.009846977889537811, -0.004086023196578026, 0.018627192825078964, 0.0233834870159626, 0.017464015632867813, 0.02048421837389469, -0.0297357477247715, 0.012361588887870312, 0.05015147104859352, -0.013200238347053528, -0.025627922266721725, 0.04578272998332977, -0.024766771122813225, -0.014297042973339558, 0.05226196348667145, -0.010349160991609097, 0.05718575417995453, 0.026727691292762756, 0.03154563903808594, 0.026216989383101463, 0.07019427418708801, 0.05703875049948692, -0.0007935488829389215, -0.04801042750477791, 0.005971625912934542, 0.011721980758011341, 0.052595701068639755, -0.04937690868973732, -0.0019326364854350686, 0.023981336504220963, 0.004418845754116774, -0.02119368128478527, 0.03997208550572395, -0.008641919121146202, -0.004386786371469498, -0.010817830450832844, -0.03004402108490467, -0.011869542300701141, -0.03574523702263832, 0.009587004780769348, -0.03650860860943794, 0.0120620122179389, 0.056664593517780304, 0.0544242262840271, -0.035857174545526505, -0.015901664271950722, -0.023241395130753517, -0.037472765892744064, 0.01630030944943428, 0.01751478761434555, -0.015825368463993073, -0.057939086109399796, -0.008428676053881645, -0.006332503631711006, 0.008405334316194057, -0.01194217149168253, 0.011043132282793522, -0.040743887424468994, 0.06997751444578171, -0.03893571346998215, 0.0033735912293195724, 0.058737434446811676, -0.03216719999909401, 0.015685951337218285, -0.0971732959151268, 0.09003379195928574, 0.05326614901423454, -0.0145949712023139, -0.007337438873946667, 0.005345930811017752, -0.025984538719058037, -0.02894260734319687, 0.06639984250068665, 0.025617828592658043, -0.043564505875110626, 0.006593998521566391, -0.0002842732355929911, -0.005716795101761818, -0.055593736469745636, 0.02814321033656597, -0.04255455359816551, -0.00510621489956975, -0.03817867487668991, 0.023276766762137413, -0.005564308725297451, -0.00014123108121566474, 0.04118947312235832, 0.005630896892398596, -0.00008595026156399399, -0.027441859245300293, -0.03178351745009422, 0.05924041196703911, -0.013002872467041016, 0.00680665485560894, 0.03547190502285957, -0.01219164114445448, 0.022537507116794586, 0.01138153113424778, -0.025411467999219894, -0.01892535388469696, 0.04363676905632019, -0.015031645074486732, -0.02358950302004814, -0.0036609715316444635, 0.03597625344991684, -0.013543867506086826, -0.01753097213804722, 0.0030471356585621834, 0.024929547682404518, 0.018586037680506706, 0.025862092152237892, -0.015518801286816597, 0.01622869446873665, 0.03711731731891632, -0.015510991215705872, 0.011849522590637207, 0.013972612097859383, -0.05714547634124756, -0.012978284619748592, -0.002677548909559846, 0.059064723551273346, 0.017238102853298187, 0.01950874552130699, 0.044282443821430206, -0.017938638105988503, 0.04706542566418648, 0.012235613539814949, 0.05162794888019562, -0.054868653416633606, 0.0046346974559128284, 0.022530226036906242, -0.003945247735828161, 0.021392153576016426, -0.015424295328557491, 0.005222056992352009, 0.06490111351013184, -0.04024132341146469, -0.006938375066965818, -0.026267707347869873, -0.02149917371571064, -0.03606183081865311, 0.010432131588459015, 0.01212479081004858, 0.037804145365953445, 0.019852424040436745, 0.04427778348326683, -0.016886834055185318, 0.009218137711286545, 0.01868223026394844, -0.011878992430865765, 0.02709571272134781, 0.008668549358844757, 0.005878247786313295, -0.029778096824884415, -0.03110259585082531, -0.012491986155509949, 0.00033553893445059657, 0.03989258408546448, 0.03529708459973335, -0.003287599189206958, -0.007960903458297253, -0.023881884291768074, 0.0008858125074766576, 0.0561201311647892, -0.07806935906410217, -0.017879201099276543, -0.054498013108968735, 0.011284460313618183, 0.022538429126143456, -0.03280206397175789 ]
<p>If the outcome of a market could be expressed as a probability it might be: </p> <p>Outcome - Description - Probability as a %</p> <ol> <li>Up a lot 20% (a move of say more than 10%) </li> <li>Down a lot 20% </li> <li>Up a bit 20% (a move of between 0 and 10%) </li> <li>Down a bit 20% </li> <li>Sideways 20% </li> </ol> <p>So the probability of any single outcome is 1/5 or 20%. </p> <p>Please could some one educate me on the math of adding another and subsequent markets?</p>
37,319
[ -0.007297417148947716, -0.06571318954229355, 0.014391385950148106, -0.02239491045475006, 0.03912815824151039, 0.02698121778666973, 0.0032175807282328606, 0.008898711763322353, -0.004198266193270683, -0.004509370774030685, 0.031664423644542694, 0.055464036762714386, 0.02723594754934311, 0.004691012669354677, 0.0015642031794413924, 0.033699482679367065, 0.0072266398929059505, -0.01175297237932682, -0.008541382849216461, -0.009849082678556442, 0.015146938152611256, 0.03134164214134216, 0.02148747444152832, 0.014528780244290829, -0.026708107441663742, 0.033466678112745285, 0.06543611735105515, -0.0028619999065995216, 0.018360499292612076, 0.053544946014881134, -0.017111854627728462, -0.05054802447557449, 0.024003149941563606, 0.03611311316490173, 0.050506591796875, 0.011719977483153343, -0.03183053433895111, -0.01771998591721058, -0.028440607711672783, -0.03301917761564255, -0.028852200135588646, -0.008958064019680023, -0.01715219020843506, 0.055485937744379044, -0.008816604502499104, -0.03069719858467579, 0.0074128988198935986, -0.022196011617779732, 0.03244111314415932, -0.02536054700613022, 0.08782275766134262, -0.01854098029434681, 0.021162444725632668, 0.023698166012763977, 0.011116186156868935, 0.017840618267655373, 0.05098816379904747, 0.0628342479467392, 0.00415234686806798, -0.04152465984225273, -0.01786716841161251, 0.0012550756800919771, 0.01429759617894888, -0.014598183333873749, -0.0286706555634737, 0.025185974314808846, -0.007142701651901007, -0.022005204111337662, 0.029937107115983963, -0.01601981371641159, 0.008252392522990704, 0.008426839485764503, 0.08754917979240417, 0.006991063244640827, 0.039779871702194214, -0.020982271060347557, 0.01594136841595173, 0.018968747928738594, 0.04363938048481941, 0.041032660752534866, -0.007459001615643501, -0.003083851421251893, 0.0019942920189350843, 0.058056533336639404, 0.05915146693587303, -0.02406732365489006, 0.05608624964952469, -0.0335870198905468, 0.03957027569413185, 0.015479250811040401, -0.011911100707948208, -0.048270974308252335, 0.0492994450032711, -0.015812279656529427, -0.0567203089594841, 0.0221407450735569, -0.008004486560821533, 0.057119037955999374, 0.004740667063742876, 0.017359325662255287, -0.005921861622482538, -0.038869425654411316, -0.016120944172143936, 0.03036663681268692, -0.01652510277926922, 0.011125939898192883, -0.01979970932006836, -0.016820568591356277, -0.016846060752868652, -0.03230314329266548, 0.01004564668983221, 0.04818395525217056, 0.007021899800747633, 0.01111699640750885, -0.06179182603955269, -0.035928208380937576, -0.0060262009501457214, 0.020118461921811104, 0.029684016481041908, 0.03653354570269585, 0.01884707808494568, -0.01828780211508274, 0.0051255435682833195, 0.005619402509182692, -0.05907723307609558, 0.013103173114359379, 0.0318145751953125, -0.012405342422425747, -0.0527077354490757, 0.05342927575111389, 0.020863236859440804, 0.01580645702779293, 0.006632274016737938, -0.0060500334948301315, 0.04426557943224907, -0.01768314652144909, -0.07559517025947571, -0.042999185621738434, 0.0656016618013382, -0.044729504734277725, 0.0012346240691840649, -0.03993081673979759, 0.005797306075692177, 0.03844377398490906, 0.03298673778772354, -0.004739856347441673, 0.03705077990889549, 0.003505099331960082, 0.024804353713989258, 0.03155877813696861, -0.03683186694979668, 0.016196049749851227, -0.05872626230120659, -0.016039608046412468, -0.023876462131738663, -0.07601435482501984, 0.017557233572006226, 0.062316328287124634, -0.012063693255186081, -0.04109582304954529, 0.014061120338737965, 0.004663142375648022, -0.014572112821042538, 0.017354294657707214, -0.026316769421100616, -0.0348665751516819, 0.10090911388397217, 0.038970451802015305, -0.008517523296177387, 0.0025230194441974163, 0.0061933486722409725, -0.017217140644788742, 0.0032592208590358496, -0.002169649815186858, 0.03952626883983612, -0.04050370305776596, 0.004786178935319185, -0.011938479728996754, -0.005501472391188145, 0.0018733625765889883, -0.004664117470383644, -0.0012691799784079194, -0.04405083507299423, 0.009265272878110409, 0.024696430191397667, -0.04929674044251442, 0.004826817195862532, -0.006771262269467115, -0.011709065176546574, -0.06471849977970123, -0.0547381229698658, -0.08441176265478134, 0.03451378270983696, -0.058113206177949905, -0.016875572502613068, -0.02421150729060173, 0.01712747849524021, 0.01900596357882023, -0.023133378475904465, -0.03318539634346962, -0.013571572490036488, -0.029635516926646233, 0.023927638307213783, -0.05492647364735603, -0.021908031776547432, 0.10287585854530334, 0.02317073754966259, -0.0164943877607584, 0.035208627581596375, -0.028759660199284554, -0.02705123834311962, -0.015180033631622791, -0.0061320955865085125, 0.01807471551001072, 0.008993489667773247, -0.0166875422000885, 0.04635787010192871, -0.010595318861305714, -0.0061131552793085575, 0.027243591845035553, -0.06058850511908531, 0.06162268668413162, 0.09942241758108139, 0.0035946760326623917, 0.01158524677157402, 0.014158749021589756, 0.022311711683869362, 0.009045344777405262, 0.008372153155505657, -0.0186358280479908, -0.03026149608194828, 0.0007229158072732389, 0.012149816378951073, 0.03041975200176239, -0.0038245844189077616, -0.008229248225688934, 0.10434553027153015, 0.022113243117928505, -0.016513636335730553, 0.040376029908657074, 0.01090236660093069, 0.0019779938738793135, 0.008726735599339008, -0.008637087419629097, 0.04955060034990311, -0.01541681308299303, 0.017024973407387733, -0.011327607557177544, -0.020809518173336983, 0.02010875940322876, -0.042495910078287125, 0.020255306735634804, -0.01738317310810089, 0.008209487423300743, -0.028699900954961777, -0.010580978356301785, 0.05291106551885605, -0.027276983484625816, 0.008153817616403103, 0.01906975358724594, 0.014450964517891407, -0.032606955617666245, -0.02348307892680168, -0.012217883951961994, -0.026359673589468002, 0.0024888203479349613, -0.04479631036520004, -0.010369483381509781, 0.03090583346784115, 0.005720603279769421, -0.011416714638471603, 0.021555131301283836, 0.01614122837781906, -0.04001534730195999, -0.002972432877868414, 0.027490848675370216, -0.02759576588869095, 0.049719471484422684, -0.03679922595620155, -0.03200038522481918, -0.028788859024643898, 0.010431145317852497, -0.00273829884827137, 0.00019983015954494476, -0.09023591130971909, 0.0356840044260025, -0.011881974525749683, -0.05738785117864609, 0.021122779697179794, -0.012727572582662106, 0.00857379101216793, -0.002812393708154559, 0.024976767599582672, -0.008448162116110325, -0.04636939615011215, -0.03975945711135864, 0.011312950402498245, -0.04003353416919708, -0.00870544370263815, 0.08789999037981033, 0.021853459998965263, -0.040630847215652466, 0.02574886754155159, -0.038110289722681046, -0.007461699191480875, -0.04319686442613602, 0.017714668065309525, 0.018787946552038193, -0.03522995859384537, 0.024036817252635956, -0.010095611214637756, -0.02555127441883087, -0.005085046868771315, -0.07100483775138855, -0.07463370263576508, -0.04173444211483002, 0.003702572314068675, 0.009034373797476292, 0.00008068699389696121, -0.012538153678178787, 0.05627253279089928, 0.04895377904176712, -0.02787669003009796, -0.028609175235033035, 0.036493390798568726, 0.019114919006824493, -0.028689712285995483, 0.019275877624750137, 0.03008645586669445, -0.04873114451766014, 0.0241424348205328, 0.030658965930342674, 0.04864557087421417, 0.03321227803826332, -0.013142982497811317, -0.020642641931772232, 0.017263468354940414, -0.002010841155424714, 0.012393767945468426, 0.01828693225979805, 0.026153190061450005, -0.04078734666109085, -0.008539758622646332, -0.0034969360567629337, 0.0015155683504417539, 0.022139593958854675, -0.04361575096845627, 0.048707567155361176, -0.016198813915252686, -0.01923278719186783, -0.04653257876634598, 0.020773377269506454, -0.00938345305621624, -0.023977484554052353, 0.011798860505223274, -0.022464526817202568, 0.05498239025473595, 0.0038644687738269567, -0.0032570515759289265, 0.03272755444049835, 0.0017717292066663504, -0.043365638703107834, -0.042907651513814926, -0.014147602953016758, 0.011258842423558235, -0.015372023917734623, -0.029328124597668648, -0.03281702846288681, 0.05336511507630348, 0.028175612911581993, 0.011982500553131104, -0.016232578083872795, -0.04232163727283478, -0.014903132803738117, -0.06414942443370819, -0.013282299041748047, -0.045003533363342285, 0.02022968791425228, 0.025621648877859116, 0.030092041939496994, -0.03480536863207817, -0.01026824675500393, 0.02433537133038044, 0.003807350294664502, -0.07642219960689545, 0.027113385498523712, -0.011923156678676605, 0.008950063958764076, -0.0321640707552433, -0.004096748773008585, 0.04708287864923477, -0.031742069870233536, -0.03786202520132065, -0.007001177407801151, 0.010698322206735611, -0.05678543820977211, 0.01354155782610178, 0.005693244282156229, -0.04193638637661934, 0.010357988066971302, 0.01432747207581997, 0.06323594599962234, 0.023214232176542282, 0.07035502791404724, 0.02650616131722927, 0.004326440393924713, -0.030458519235253334, -0.020449191331863403, 0.04328658804297447, 0.02526227943599224, 0.05335715040564537, 0.017415111884474754, 0.011261245235800743, -0.039259377866983414, 0.045083217322826385, 0.03436167538166046, 0.047896843403577805, 0.022182948887348175, -0.002339846221730113, -0.015665683895349503, -0.03982130438089371, -0.015040337108075619, 0.003200621111318469, -0.009157715365290642, 0.008567923679947853, 0.005722034256905317, 0.06046580523252487, -0.0023855937179178, -0.03926458582282066, 0.03159654885530472, 0.07424486428499222, -0.009732254780828953, 0.002622373169288039, -0.023988772183656693, -0.012694509699940681, -0.002676108619198203, -0.02758725732564926, -0.008766967803239822, -0.0010408922098577023, -0.005728135816752911, 0.02490410953760147, 0.025350401178002357, 0.00967789813876152, -0.002062420127913356, -0.0026503850240260363, -0.036782559007406235, 0.027919592335820198, 0.021366363391280174, -0.045284535735845566, 0.017024891451001167, 0.012643488124012947, -0.0068825241178274155, 0.032890308648347855, -0.024590246379375458, -0.07031137496232986, 0.02555439993739128, 0.018608007580041885, 0.03319833427667618, -0.027488354593515396, 0.02108623832464218, -0.040804773569107056, -0.013619906269013882, 0.0061837052926421165, -0.04323182255029678, 0.019065557047724724, -0.025154607370495796, 0.012241698801517487, -0.009906225837767124, -0.031055713072419167, -0.03836647793650627, 0.002959963632747531, -0.020857447758316994, 0.012295778840780258, -0.028235681354999542, 0.03049631230533123, -0.040867842733860016, 0.015981435775756836, 0.04540037736296654, 0.026604801416397095, -0.04996255040168762, 0.020934417843818665, -0.031013207510113716, 0.03391386941075325, -0.00023333275748882443, -0.09081900864839554, 0.04053347185254097, -0.002368497895076871, 0.009727539494633675, 0.03768158704042435, -0.01840236596763134, -0.03744084760546684, 0.02512727491557598, -0.001096061198040843, -0.02739619091153145, 0.0020833199378103018, -0.021150728687644005, 0.03233734890818596, 0.026760190725326538, 0.042850226163864136, 0.06934386491775513, 0.013871868140995502, -0.009300513193011284, 0.025763511657714844, 0.022989334538578987, 0.008994873613119125, -0.005055462475866079, 0.041303008794784546, -0.044924356043338776, 0.02081635408103466, -0.009809477254748344, 0.05952784791588783, -0.005810310132801533, 0.011301861144602299, -0.03185461089015007, -0.015497923828661442, -0.04210904240608215, 0.03578292950987816, 0.0031801615841686726, -0.04223009943962097, -0.005619614850729704, -0.004773935303092003, -0.0242399163544178, -0.006929396651685238, 0.021154632791876793, -0.03459283709526062, -0.011286724358797073, -0.029835082590579987, -0.01978086121380329, 0.006606775335967541, 0.0004760359588544816, -0.022198181599378586, -0.004088591318577528, -0.042485397309064865, 0.029610347002744675, -0.01816914603114128, 0.04831310734152794, -0.008929258212447166, -0.042786575853824615, -0.02350340597331524, -0.028508415445685387, 0.026522452011704445, -0.012887188233435154, -0.03437960520386696, 0.006244020536541939, 0.012837912887334824, -0.01037855725735426, -0.0668114572763443, -0.039707377552986145, 0.009333490394055843, 0.026552395895123482, -0.031067432835698128, -0.024394258856773376, 0.020602313801646233, -0.015026450157165527, -0.04904383420944214, -0.01622672751545906, 0.005617405287921429, 0.008984086103737354, 0.0015106027713045478, 0.03801006078720093, -0.001040354953147471, 0.04499569162726402, 0.016089728102087975, -0.05341887101531029, 0.011015675030648708, 0.009768478572368622, -0.01974397897720337, -0.004671473987400532, 0.019667821004986763, -0.042741693556308746, -0.0256898645311594, -0.027600448578596115, 0.0028572489973157644, 0.004788088146597147, -0.03646833449602127, -0.017478080466389656, -0.013815032318234444, -0.004586793016642332, -0.002045618835836649, -0.03893386200070381, -0.02343646064400673, -0.001135568367317319, 0.014236115850508213, 0.0009685768745839596, 0.031566668301820755, -0.003043294418603182, -0.02024090103805065, -0.02276986464858055, -0.006844834890216589, -0.0003884415200445801, 0.025641262531280518, 0.050460085272789, 0.0024053859524428844, -0.008974297903478146, 0.0004122612299397588, -0.039080239832401276, 0.030076265335083008, -0.046705324202775955, -0.008394468575716019, 0.021081356331706047, -0.006426251493394375, -0.030884122475981712, -0.02586567960679531, -0.022644151002168655, 0.013499978929758072, 0.030435310676693916, -0.03870270773768425, 0.03576728701591492, 0.011665411293506622, -0.006031956523656845, -0.010903500020503998, -0.004447664599865675, -0.0029820313211530447, 0.00676006218418479, 0.022387636825442314, 0.05440545082092285, -0.0362490713596344, 0.004114056006073952, 0.04013848677277565, 0.04145462438464165, 0.033806465566158295, 0.010366901755332947, 0.025160090997815132, 0.011207550764083862, 0.044446058571338654, -0.0023812674917280674, -0.04318913444876671, 0.03788505867123604, -0.02706875093281269, 0.05853340029716492, -0.06708924472332001, -0.020192530006170273, 0.06327171623706818, 0.040958888828754425, -0.04854728654026985, -0.012625438161194324, -0.01921648532152176, -0.036351609975099564, -0.006564584095031023, -0.007445550989359617, 0.015440448187291622, 0.03898250311613083, -0.013752997852861881, 0.019922753795981407, -0.014033256098628044, -0.010944750159978867, 0.00013673417561221868, -0.03276523947715759, -0.01940067671239376, -0.057345591485500336, -0.06005707383155823, 0.039081454277038574, 0.006600890774279833, 0.02136128768324852, 0.004412406124174595, -0.0100548779591918, -0.01550174318253994, 0.010072355158627033, 0.04883820563554764, -0.021375982090830803, 0.10456591099500656, 0.0604267492890358, 0.015350841917097569, -0.030564116314053535, -0.01197807490825653, 0.14038747549057007, 0.07723741978406906, 0.003827905049547553, -0.06301578879356384, 0.01319864857941866, -0.006062669213861227, 0.04638848081231117, -0.018897732719779015, 0.04569759964942932, 0.03157670795917511, 0.004380040802061558, 0.027608517557382584, 0.07277239859104156, -0.022832008078694344, -0.02282501757144928, 0.05303991213440895, -0.05337459594011307, -0.03514064848423004, -0.015589293092489243, -0.0060983202420175076, -0.00815244484692812, 0.0073062218725681305, -0.08217252045869827, -0.006687399931252003, -0.011506197974085808, 0.02325119450688362, 0.0020840412471443415, -0.035250406712293625, -0.0027174740098416805, 0.03761742636561394, -0.017870264127850533, -0.014673300087451935, 0.02965386211872101, 0.017018219456076622, -0.011237342841923237, 0.004186590202152729, 0.030905311927199364, -0.03240225091576576, -0.007190852425992489, 0.02779565192759037, 0.049661170691251755, 0.015329459682106972, -0.0069695208221673965, 0.027166180312633514, -0.04705102741718292, 0.0047445097006857395, -0.029220324009656906, -0.002356631448492408, -0.0014174545649439096, 0.028888581320643425, -0.05604454129934311, 0.0158205758780241, 0.011386660858988762, -0.015161709859967232, -0.03606404736638069, 0.0033581629395484924, 0.014288518577814102, -0.0032246625050902367, -0.032077107578516006, -0.037903930991888046, -0.0026623245794326067, -0.039690956473350525, 0.06735879182815552, 0.0567641407251358, -0.04230199381709099, -0.05415894836187363, -0.03406503051519394, 0.05197352170944214, 0.004178533796221018, -0.0024761513341218233, -0.031981442123651505, -0.005434568505734205, -0.07829182595014572, 0.022888511419296265, -0.05568304285407066, -0.004713875241577625, 0.026542240753769875, -0.00807241816073656, -0.015162867493927479, 0.027288850396871567, 0.006198166869580746, 0.02946740761399269, 0.013766026124358177, -0.014383314177393913, -0.0200303103774786, 0.018541527912020683, 0.026193737983703613, 0.01559921819716692, -0.024382149800658226, 0.009291449561715126, -0.016198722645640373, 0.024844080209732056, 0.01432752888649702, -0.03217056766152382, 0.0025175679475069046, -0.004512698855251074, -0.0448397621512413, -0.051469091325998306, 0.005897711031138897, 0.08027181029319763, 0.005450584460049868, -0.009841208346188068, 0.014492257498204708, -0.0016267264727503061, -0.01559612900018692, 0.010669736191630363, -0.003861082950606942, -0.051873140037059784, -0.008411729708313942, 0.03685005009174347, -0.01007197704166174, -0.014543777331709862, 0.0005576013354584575, 0.04467642679810524, 0.005916620139032602, 0.03321322053670883, -0.0011352746514603496, -0.05870692804455757, -0.005149370059370995, -0.01635640487074852, 0.04119431599974632, 0.01443895697593689, -0.01253123302012682, -0.03527767211198807, -0.008849939331412315, 0.003099209861829877, -0.01441357471048832, -0.008981490507721901, 0.005447167903184891, -0.010593033395707607, -0.02189645543694496, 0.0014298243913799524, 0.048762474209070206, 0.010231336578726768, -0.042538903653621674, 0.04054110497236252, -0.012980286031961441, 0.014322042465209961, -0.016260815784335136, -0.029093079268932343, 0.046444203704595566, -0.027482835575938225, -0.022515220567584038, 0.03800637274980545, 0.020908942446112633, 0.08784466981887817, 0.032876163721084595, -0.002164219506084919, -0.020220527425408363, 0.018741482868790627, -0.01937728561460972, -0.02290491946041584, -0.010690061375498772, -0.0021043135784566402, 0.018466681241989136, -0.017568785697221756, 0.007870116271078587, 0.016791291534900665, -0.02085273526608944, -0.0023829166311770678, 0.03198767080903053, -0.03195840120315552, -0.014554574154317379, 0.00909580010920763, -0.000917313271202147, 0.015415886417031288, -0.014107709750533104, -0.02549690380692482, 0.00471897516399622, 0.018798330798745155, -0.01264125481247902, 0.027400873601436615, -0.012266140431165695, 0.029603060334920883, -0.06177210062742233, -0.0055693271569907665, 0.023639464750885963, -0.0023153575602918863, 0.04360535368323326, -0.0658416748046875, 0.006135518662631512, 0.00846836343407631, -0.03387157991528511, -0.0030674166046082973, 0.030579352751374245, 0.022433608770370483, -0.019160673022270203, 0.010409361682832241, -0.026019936427474022, 0.06647468358278275, 0.061688221991062164, 0.03857562690973282, 0.03929063677787781, -0.018390940502285957, -0.009074321947991848, -0.010258940048515797, -0.024193057790398598, 0.0076577370055019855, -0.03368425369262695, -0.022304654121398926, 0.06532799452543259, -0.03770213574171066, -0.030154194682836533, 0.04164543002843857, -0.026746707037091255, 0.00267930724658072, 0.028043773025274277, 0.011346191167831421, 0.012063393369317055, 0.02865917794406414, 0.01314609870314598, 0.01306668296456337, 0.0025340979918837547, 0.024778500199317932, 0.046772588044404984, 0.00834896881133318, -0.021840853616595268, -0.00905201118439436, 0.07028479874134064, -0.034078020602464676, -0.01976139284670353, -0.00792685430496931, -0.0049870009534060955, 0.03480503708124161, -0.0041277543641626835, -0.015635116025805473, 0.02636578492820263, 0.0071366759948432446, 0.024806298315525055, 0.009866578504443169, -0.01328937616199255, 0.011311442591249943, -0.024936065077781677, 0.004962145816534758, 0.0003432914090808481, 0.022507984191179276, -0.03488009050488472, 0.02961379662156105, 0.01059301570057869, 0.0011505542788654566, -0.02243315428495407, 0.02616151235997677, 0.014044474810361862, -0.018041914328932762, 0.03030008263885975, -0.009749258868396282, -0.02927009016275406, -0.002266851020976901, -0.0072847758419811726, 0.0350094810128212, 0.03660067543387413, -0.004114131443202496, 0.009654729627072811, -0.0797099843621254, 0.0768280029296875, 0.016268745064735413, 0.021612774580717087, -0.04004732146859169, 0.0009772446937859058, 0.019053829833865166, 0.004811370745301247, 0.020401762798428535, -0.029800258576869965, -0.004048953298479319, 0.012312382459640503, 0.05017213523387909, 0.05480717495083809, -0.05294241011142731, -0.0056863026693463326, -0.04396219179034233, -0.01778353564441204, -0.01039078924804926, -0.03682028874754906, 0.019651124253869057, -0.003965823445469141, -0.002941335318610072, -0.042828332632780075, -0.0044318935833871365, -0.021351657807826996, -0.004657867830246687, 0.01211480237543583, 0.026883848011493683, -0.032581817358732224, 0.06022235006093979, 0.017987128347158432, -0.015522812493145466, -0.016411669552326202, -0.0011777346953749657, -0.049511123448610306, 0.05314987525343895, -0.03905134275555611, -0.009047864936292171, -0.022300243377685547, -0.010952997952699661, 0.0018509500660002232, -0.013540828600525856, -0.04334154352545738, 0.008665615692734718, -0.03385334461927414, -0.018283981829881668, 0.05653442442417145, -0.004521708469837904, 0.023232631385326385, -0.009636826813220978, 0.00024499319260939956, -0.007876919582486153, -0.006626410875469446, -0.029365092515945435, -0.02648986130952835, 0.05408419296145439, 0.0070623611100018024, 0.012128546833992004, 0.02048618718981743, 0.004722867626696825, 0.010805566795170307, 0.02160206064581871, 0.010246779769659042, -0.02988005429506302, 0.015766683965921402, 0.015387389808893204, -0.005149816628545523, 0.020529713481664658, 0.011275695636868477, -0.027144255116581917, 0.02018854394555092, 0.03584055230021477, 0.007442147005349398, -0.008509179577231407, 0.04864456132054329, 0.0044190105982124805, 0.013860221020877361, 0.02446548454463482, 0.04139517620205879, 0.01718314364552498, 0.0340832844376564, -0.015789015218615532, 0.03783496841788292, 0.07162214070558548, -0.017689477652311325, 0.015819482505321503, -0.012487417086958885, -0.03756987676024437, 0.022009925916790962, 0.026342269033193588, -0.0048074196092784405, -0.016113489866256714, 0.0013167520519345999, 0.005037464667111635, 0.010808420367538929, 0.025309985503554344, -0.020795106887817383, 0.003077462315559387, 0.0747188851237297, -0.024467315524816513, -0.02807803638279438, -0.06257506459951401, 0.005713139660656452, 0.011867656372487545, -0.01720963418483734 ]
<p>I am familiar with meta analysis and meta regression techniques (using the R package <code>metafor</code> from Viechtbauer), but I recently stumbled on a problem I can't easily solve. Say we have a disease that can go from mother to the unborn child, and it has been studied already a number of times. Mother and child were tested for the virus right after birth. As an unborn child can impossibly get the virus other than from the mother, one would expect crosstabulations like :</p> <pre><code> | neg kid | pos kid mother neg | A | C=0 -----------|---------|-------- mother pos | B | D </code></pre> <p>Obviously using odds ratios (OR) gives errors as one would be dividing by 0. Same for relative risks :</p> <p>$\frac{A/(A+B)}{0/(0+D)}$ </p> <p>Now the researchers want to test the (senseless) hypothesis whether infection of the child is related to the infection of the mother (which seems very, very obvious). I'm trying to reformulate the hypothesis and come up with something that makes sense, but I can't really find something. </p> <p>To complicate things, some kids with negative moms actually are positive, probably due to infection in the first week. So I only have a number of studies where C = 0. </p> <p>Anybody an idea on how to statistically summarize the data of different studies following such a pattern. Links to scientific papers are also more than welcome. </p>
74,446
[ -0.02616409957408905, -0.015212413854897022, -0.006166339851915836, 0.006654274649918079, 0.018946588039398193, 0.015107749029994011, 0.011102228425443172, 0.0009088055812753737, 0.04706207290291786, -0.0020154998637735844, 0.029650328680872917, 0.04288821667432785, 0.04423791542649269, 0.005669320467859507, 0.0241719800978899, 0.01739318296313286, -0.0009311934118159115, -0.0105799101293087, -0.010011830367147923, -0.006596897728741169, 0.03737680986523628, 0.008043734356760979, 0.029003003612160683, 0.041799623519182205, 0.0029054172337055206, 0.02561383880674839, 0.02487958036363125, -0.04180297255516052, -0.005645324010401964, 0.02540944702923298, -0.014099192805588245, -0.006706845015287399, 0.0210267324000597, -0.013946897350251675, 0.015840310603380203, 0.023328548297286034, 0.003374565625563264, -0.006698780693113804, 0.002637038938701153, 0.04880189895629883, -0.011378432624042034, -0.020736223086714745, -0.030684543773531914, 0.049752380698919296, -0.029316669330000877, 0.00727303558960557, 0.008164236322045326, -0.013262826949357986, 0.04116424545645714, -0.06640315055847168, 0.0486309714615345, -0.03541761636734009, 0.04750906676054001, 0.009886987507343292, -0.01756741851568222, -0.0009149819961749017, 0.060785431414842606, 0.06989777088165283, 0.0426081120967865, -0.07190898060798645, -0.03196340799331665, -0.021707210689783096, -0.007521447259932756, 0.01157720759510994, -0.024237623438239098, 0.03952816128730774, -0.006443455349653959, -0.06882589310407639, 0.05218921974301338, -0.041607484221458435, 0.023478897288441658, -0.0005996405379846692, 0.025726990774273872, -0.005275125615298748, -0.0068430774845182896, -0.009204371832311153, -0.006366867572069168, 0.043596215546131134, 0.026315292343497276, 0.03269064053893089, -0.03487371280789375, -0.004137667361646891, 0.03309481963515282, 0.07290024310350418, 0.008527109399437904, -0.02173321694135666, 0.03570856153964996, -0.026009494438767433, 0.04257507249712944, 0.03282929211854935, -0.013418165035545826, -0.03200174868106842, 0.04749863222241402, -0.0033642398193478584, -0.06573402881622314, 0.007474022451788187, 0.0012499646982178092, 0.042160265147686005, 0.014408172108232975, -0.010198940522968769, -0.009252499788999557, -0.02438303455710411, 0.0038317053113132715, 0.023783521726727486, 0.002475616754963994, 0.0060526407323777676, -0.0543401837348938, 0.015738151967525482, 0.007483817171305418, -0.01786888763308525, -0.010422354564070702, 0.03092857077717781, -0.0008653693948872387, 0.008886090479791164, 0.014594716019928455, -0.04924644157290459, -0.029114725068211555, 0.0030748213175684214, 0.05509079992771149, 0.03450709953904152, 0.05170509219169617, -0.02951664663851261, 0.051574550569057465, -0.032710686326026917, -0.022200807929039, -0.00764882005751133, -0.0015537114813923836, 0.005500137340277433, -0.025710690766572952, 0.04878867790102959, 0.030559353530406952, -0.008593074046075344, 0.02416042797267437, -0.00637851981446147, 0.04978182911872864, -0.024810388684272766, -0.05157294496893883, -0.07998672127723694, 0.030635373666882515, -0.00120135850738734, -0.01012466475367546, -0.03459084779024124, -0.027361122891306877, 0.026863954961299896, 0.07419581711292267, 0.002730090171098709, 0.050313666462898254, -0.00908955279737711, 0.01898082345724106, 0.03487376123666763, 0.023811383172869682, -0.023821596056222916, -0.011114319786429405, 0.009222477674484253, -0.01888195052742958, -0.06781112402677536, 0.03695196658372879, 0.011461873538792133, 0.005780014209449291, 0.007119117770344019, 0.03780871629714966, -0.019504504278302193, -0.02777484431862831, -0.0008140382706187665, -0.0006923249457031488, -0.016711998730897903, 0.06854233145713806, 0.0009500653250142932, -0.04243113473057747, 0.02776249684393406, 0.004738026764243841, 0.01769336499273777, 0.04020298644900322, 0.021253077313303947, 0.0363437794148922, 0.0007433472201228142, -0.01409105584025383, -0.013969159685075283, 0.02226862497627735, 0.004633765202015638, -0.020687831565737724, -0.016506727784872055, -0.02584826387465, 0.016537532210350037, 0.02010953798890114, 0.007669062819331884, -0.031572554260492325, -0.008705982938408852, 0.04423166438937187, -0.05420304089784622, -0.04506509006023407, -0.0462721586227417, 0.011366622522473335, 0.014962537214159966, -0.019098421558737755, 0.03630809113383293, 0.015230417251586914, 0.04962949454784393, -0.044460125267505646, -0.020931843668222427, -0.03146611526608467, -0.04674898833036423, 0.025157207623124123, -0.0014146269531920552, -0.0078008174896240234, 0.03789478912949562, 0.04215313866734505, -0.04030874744057655, 0.04092750698328018, -0.03485346958041191, -0.004527242388576269, -0.01777712069451809, -0.020754577592015266, 0.014954501762986183, 0.0055371494963765144, 0.012689712457358837, 0.033094704151153564, -0.008148775435984135, 0.012185837142169476, -0.02684110775589943, -0.06261024624109268, 0.02597813494503498, 0.053052641451358795, 0.051074620336294174, -0.004899908322840929, 0.0003689327568281442, 0.05657278373837471, 0.004654898773878813, -0.0038089638110250235, -0.04898109659552574, -0.046523746103048325, 0.006193192210048437, 0.016581250354647636, -0.012327286414802074, -0.027907997369766235, 0.0029356321319937706, 0.05755797028541565, 0.026550782844424248, -0.01863803341984749, 0.05172144994139671, -0.00598242087289691, -0.03136897459626198, 0.014492812566459179, 0.014315729960799217, 0.02298467420041561, 0.0017139228293672204, 0.027632325887680054, -0.009319715201854706, 0.03153516352176666, 0.031143808737397194, -0.03088691271841526, 0.00642232084646821, 0.029204560443758965, 0.026135478168725967, -0.026548074558377266, 0.009315608069300652, 0.03962858393788338, -0.02752905711531639, 0.03328777477145195, 0.025365585461258888, 0.010584242641925812, 0.020670441910624504, -0.01306151319295168, -0.01590435765683651, 0.02576383948326111, 0.0056238858960568905, -0.05635860189795494, 0.05778476223349571, 0.007172503042966127, -0.024466795846819878, -0.006083304528146982, -0.01879783906042576, -0.03275040537118912, -0.03439433127641678, 0.015174602158367634, -0.009115273132920265, 0.002341384766623378, 0.02382492460310459, -0.03134685754776001, -0.037150319665670395, -0.002796294866129756, -0.011083531193435192, -0.011999929323792458, 0.021014072000980377, -0.03812849894165993, 0.015688767656683922, -0.028670622035861015, -0.010798856616020203, 0.03280334919691086, -0.009661581367254257, -0.01931777223944664, 0.014769545756280422, 0.0066696349531412125, -0.03867650404572487, -0.03919049724936485, -0.04093540087342262, 0.014117024838924408, -0.017110217362642288, 0.0033701863139867783, -0.011378624476492405, 0.014550074934959412, -0.043326135724782944, 0.025545485317707062, -0.05462493374943733, -0.006868470460176468, 0.023668376728892326, -0.005512653384357691, 0.026743700727820396, 0.00016544146637897938, 0.034665536135435104, 0.00839303620159626, 0.0032192368526011705, -0.01380082592368126, -0.05122101679444313, -0.0288392324000597, 0.03496040403842926, -0.031071921810507774, 0.013961435295641422, 0.0187689121812582, -0.008977732621133327, 0.06745689362287521, 0.02556796744465828, -0.000970365188550204, -0.06321102380752563, 0.029802588745951653, -0.016515931114554405, -0.030360160395503044, 0.02246858738362789, 0.03986484184861183, 0.0294710211455822, 0.04477778449654579, -0.003378605470061302, 0.0445706881582737, 0.014818902127444744, -0.004614097531884909, -0.01593158394098282, 0.030924540013074875, 0.001908611273393035, -0.02104097232222557, -0.006998883560299873, 0.030031440779566765, 0.035732708871364594, 0.03482400253415108, -0.005686604417860508, 0.03863353654742241, -0.017968259751796722, -0.05446583032608032, 0.013140060938894749, 0.02520104870200157, -0.019766392186284065, -0.027877315878868103, 0.030750863254070282, -0.013180221430957317, 0.012417097575962543, -0.00643717497587204, -0.025888919830322266, 0.03311740607023239, -0.03700587525963783, 0.0421551875770092, 0.05612781271338463, 0.040884654968976974, -0.016072813421487808, -0.010393699631094933, -0.00963425450026989, 0.022029880434274673, -0.010814928449690342, -0.022940343245863914, -0.02486872673034668, 0.03334492817521095, 0.07340389490127563, -0.0025773197412490845, -0.029346689581871033, -0.0669294074177742, -0.0005120372516103089, -0.022261343896389008, -0.02695387601852417, -0.029462821781635284, 0.02174772322177887, 0.008068898692727089, 0.02988995797932148, 0.007463374175131321, -0.024961814284324646, 0.00531024020165205, -0.01563096232712269, -0.07762759178876877, -0.015995517373085022, -0.002245048526674509, 0.01178494468331337, -0.006886467803269625, -0.025615574792027473, 0.02649098075926304, -0.01616138406097889, -0.025637906044721603, -0.02310139499604702, 0.020457163453102112, -0.007112842984497547, -0.012497061863541603, -0.000524298578966409, -0.012024306692183018, -0.03325770050287247, 0.01867070607841015, 0.011259297840297222, -0.0053998795337975025, -0.00725824199616909, 0.04481824114918709, 0.026670759543776512, -0.028484083712100983, -0.0672168955206871, -0.009809543378651142, 0.02094406820833683, 0.05719250440597534, 0.0494232214987278, -0.0031382504384964705, -0.08877544850111008, 0.01213166769593954, -0.015339753590524197, -0.017413601279258728, 0.040618184953927994, -0.025881389155983925, -0.021249691024422646, -0.026354502886533737, -0.014634184539318085, -0.01433684304356575, -0.018432937562465668, 0.0018063844181597233, 0.016377143561840057, 0.09724543243646622, 0.05058639869093895, -0.023717308416962624, 0.015768777579069138, 0.08235762268304825, 0.01945897564291954, 0.019779708236455917, -0.03891916200518608, -0.018382970243692398, -0.020953131839632988, -0.01978595368564129, 0.03492586687207222, 0.006347798742353916, -0.0010031178826466203, -0.03724902868270874, 0.031383804976940155, -0.008805869147181511, -0.04036812484264374, 0.037515006959438324, -0.010191632434725761, 0.04085119068622589, 0.0031644217669963837, -0.05194883793592453, 0.008074352517724037, 0.01764674484729767, 0.044418688863515854, 0.05802391469478607, -0.022314593195915222, -0.04566771164536476, 0.0046464791521430016, 0.059329114854335785, 0.061164140701293945, -0.015296132303774357, 0.00006090890019549988, -0.006135571748018265, 0.007962062023580074, 0.0242520272731781, -0.02618163451552391, 0.004141523037105799, -0.021936362609267235, 0.002019076608121395, -0.0230883676558733, -0.06035783886909485, -0.03865969553589821, 0.027117332443594933, -0.0019358608406037092, 0.021971367299556732, -0.04411497712135315, -0.019850555807352066, -0.047794654965400696, -0.004454169888049364, -0.0013234540820121765, 0.0453747995197773, -0.05351513251662254, -0.034116361290216446, 0.014022232964634895, 0.014539775438606739, -0.04227680712938309, -0.10290045291185379, -0.010304580442607403, 0.014021145179867744, 0.0025883889757096767, 0.05380406975746155, -0.012248098850250244, 0.004194088280200958, 0.0038046424742788076, 0.005326081067323685, -0.02706160955131054, 0.03037758357822895, -0.034007564187049866, 0.016930080950260162, 0.02224806323647499, 0.020668350160121918, 0.03289268538355827, -0.0171518437564373, 0.027781708166003227, -0.0283454991877079, -0.03242062032222748, 0.020326092839241028, 0.002519941655918956, 0.015245245769619942, -0.02214275859296322, -0.02755073644220829, 0.025159796699881554, -0.01051815040409565, 0.009746037423610687, 0.015889616683125496, -0.013201626017689705, 0.01703931950032711, 0.0016866768710315228, -0.013347236439585686, -0.04903789982199669, 0.014890529215335846, -0.015531020238995552, -0.01654759608209133, -0.004439974669367075, -0.006265777163207531, 0.05377696081995964, -0.05607164651155472, -0.002414802322164178, 0.018212631344795227, -0.06982269138097763, 0.0021478936541825533, -0.011068090796470642, -0.0166513342410326, -0.0020040925592184067, -0.04313405603170395, 0.0036040260456502438, -0.028358755633234978, -0.005740946624428034, -0.008891956880688667, -0.025270426645874977, -0.01543594803661108, 0.02267758920788765, 0.022663066163659096, 0.048607829958200455, -0.012362734414637089, 0.03054250217974186, -0.0038207087200134993, -0.006730871740728617, -0.07388876378536224, -0.024649670347571373, 0.0193199310451746, 0.008154371753334999, -0.050383903086185455, -0.04034610837697983, -0.0022475416772067547, -0.004259909503161907, -0.010188174434006214, -0.009139963425695896, 0.08107458055019379, -0.04229344055056572, -0.011205854825675488, 0.019075507298111916, 0.02729940600693226, 0.08107940107584, -0.03579277917742729, -0.0058935899287462234, 0.03411121293902397, -0.010050113312900066, 0.02245549112558365, 0.024931730702519417, -0.01364508830010891, -0.03817889839410782, -0.02173847332596779, -0.030668087303638458, 0.00946993287652731, 0.03846411406993866, -0.019644802436232567, -0.03304238244891167, 0.020943842828273773, -0.0047795651480555534, 0.009599030017852783, -0.029140794649720192, 0.015800176188349724, -0.014419594779610634, 0.01793597638607025, -0.04424142464995384, 0.027992168441414833, -0.02552063763141632, -0.023605817928910255, 0.03451851010322571, -0.003448500530794263, -0.02283017709851265, 0.022616174072027206, 0.06344345211982727, -0.007446237374097109, -0.04539553076028824, 0.007750498130917549, 0.006534511689096689, 0.0159855205565691, 0.03405971825122833, 0.01989704743027687, 0.004827935714274645, 0.021413346752524376, -0.026446515694260597, -0.032971128821372986, -0.05703452229499817, 0.018911443650722504, 0.04716906696557999, 0.004145151935517788, 0.04366975277662277, 0.0350971594452858, 0.032578617334365845, -0.005313587374985218, 0.010195395909249783, -0.01772347278892994, -0.00388082442805171, 0.016494350507855415, 0.03240685537457466, -0.0482940673828125, -0.015986699610948563, 0.01980425789952278, 0.03366825357079506, 0.0017675465205684304, 0.05279964208602905, 0.022054515779018402, -0.002531510777771473, 0.05484253168106079, -0.017255952581763268, -0.019110875204205513, 0.043370671570301056, -0.07895442843437195, 0.03470246121287346, -0.04505518451333046, -0.01764143817126751, 0.08417388796806335, 0.018071724101901054, -0.01421226654201746, -0.05931481346487999, -0.04646670073270798, -0.05747772753238678, 0.006527668330818415, 0.056852515786886215, -0.01919238083064556, 0.04700683802366257, -0.006232590414583683, 0.04662315919995308, -0.032907724380493164, 0.012200052849948406, -0.03756337612867355, -0.09882520884275436, -0.020568959414958954, -0.02809394709765911, -0.03657460957765579, 0.025413990020751953, -0.017013300210237503, -0.0037795756943523884, 0.02041531540453434, -0.03868948668241501, 0.0011946030426770449, 0.025745581835508347, 0.03365086391568184, -0.02133254148066044, 0.08213155716657639, 0.035470105707645416, -0.005280247423797846, 0.006428559776395559, -0.033242709934711456, 0.12889984250068665, 0.03805626183748245, 0.03612707927823067, -0.07945840060710907, 0.05887427181005478, 0.026494277641177177, 0.02120513841509819, -0.021080994978547096, 0.04407172277569771, 0.039025504142045975, -0.014377608895301819, 0.07469119876623154, 0.05758312717080116, 0.04506145045161247, 0.009218442253768444, 0.05956431105732918, -0.04449755698442459, -0.05699923262000084, -0.0250952560454607, 0.0189231988042593, 0.014521442353725433, -0.02549152821302414, 0.00013495761959347874, 0.020600395277142525, 0.022657152265310287, 0.013497467152774334, -0.014144531451165676, 0.008582433685660362, 0.0023465720005333424, -0.01729053258895874, -0.0046145119704306126, 0.0028283800929784775, 0.022323649376630783, 0.019796187058091164, -0.022882122546434402, -0.028407959267497063, 0.05234236642718315, -0.03390895947813988, 0.02629072219133377, 0.003998964559286833, 0.018850969150662422, -0.00758692342787981, 0.020446499809622765, 0.04160366952419281, -0.04933812841773033, 0.002188917016610503, -0.02097550965845585, 0.06409414112567902, -0.008674714714288712, -0.003126844996586442, -0.02602769248187542, 0.006759962532669306, 0.013299339450895786, -0.02033570595085621, -0.01579717919230461, 0.013756893575191498, 0.04911121353507042, -0.04631271958351135, 0.003417727304622531, -0.031723588705062866, 0.04446262866258621, -0.012806261889636517, 0.04949763044714928, 0.052072349935770035, -0.012619029730558395, -0.05503631383180618, -0.05233130604028702, 0.03661017119884491, -0.008935113437473774, -0.005859538912773132, 0.02868899330496788, -0.002572599332779646, -0.021156124770641327, 0.035550545901060104, -0.009144020266830921, -0.04839115962386131, 0.04534471780061722, -0.0071167731657624245, -0.0057957954704761505, 0.024677639827132225, -0.01846492290496826, -0.004693973809480667, -0.04922964796423912, -0.008720619603991508, -0.019589750096201897, 0.005067779682576656, 0.06260844320058823, 0.05320916324853897, -0.04867434874176979, 0.03189020976424217, -0.025476260110735893, 0.08979341387748718, 0.00045414987835101783, -0.03703916445374489, -0.019195761531591415, -0.024738293141126633, -0.015873011201620102, -0.016095411032438278, -0.01606994867324829, 0.028926730155944824, -0.0021667988039553165, -0.002344486303627491, 0.03609020635485649, 0.003141849534586072, -0.011523766443133354, 0.02097175642848015, -0.0009507276699878275, -0.07466984540224075, -0.04156564921140671, 0.0011657896684482694, -0.018950670957565308, 0.02256079949438572, -0.0020613924134522676, 0.008026819676160812, -0.029414497315883636, 0.01705971360206604, -0.016928518190979958, -0.03697160631418228, 0.014579826034605503, -0.03721759468317032, -0.005599678494036198, -0.01153288222849369, -0.0015363203128799796, -0.06404050439596176, -0.03069389797747135, 0.010325540788471699, -0.02941776253283024, -0.005746983457356691, 0.023252714425325394, 0.002346884226426482, 0.002010298427194357, 0.010507196187973022, -0.004599294625222683, 0.002402971964329481, 0.019621681421995163, 0.005423401016741991, 0.009760442189872265, 0.03035968355834484, -0.035095397382974625, -0.023663295432925224, 0.030144933611154556, -0.0462147518992424, -0.027241108939051628, 0.033630866557359695, 0.016177792102098465, 0.00043234991608187556, -0.0338197760283947, 0.02062888815999031, 0.01547557394951582, 0.029828237369656563, -0.04170186072587967, -0.011041669175028801, -0.004542679991573095, 0.0003501625615172088, -0.027132274582982063, 0.0015261207008734345, -0.009576305747032166, 0.03241034969687462, -0.023471461609005928, -0.0008454137714579701, 0.0665392354130745, 0.018009589985013008, 0.010488408617675304, -0.00033758539939299226, -0.01516187097877264, 0.019227707758545876, -0.009235668927431107, -0.013147306628525257, 0.024385252967476845, 0.05544911324977875, -0.039130814373493195, 0.023460526019334793, -0.0052406941540539265, 0.005485271103680134, -0.08830566704273224, -0.021807100623846054, -0.0005587897030636668, 0.006175009999424219, 0.03631485253572464, -0.07355252653360367, 0.001839637872762978, -0.010569814592599869, -0.03253961354494095, 0.004268806427717209, -0.007898096926510334, 0.0028024453204125166, -0.0052353315986692905, -0.012561664916574955, -0.06005916744470596, 0.03281548246741295, 0.0006285564741119742, -0.00006326939910650253, 0.02030092477798462, 0.03226335719227791, -0.030873607844114304, -0.044855181127786636, -0.011350506916642189, 0.026431040838360786, 0.02541693113744259, -0.034369293600320816, 0.03063199482858181, -0.010139831341803074, -0.019183993339538574, 0.019672999158501625, -0.02464022859930992, 0.016824105754494667, 0.007093430496752262, 0.031219853088259697, -0.012578018009662628, 0.0177700687199831, 0.007512379437685013, -0.004425725433975458, 0.028020041063427925, -0.029208116233348846, 0.04347559064626694, 0.014874022454023361, -0.02999258041381836, 0.05450842157006264, 0.08050043880939484, 0.0023211908992379904, -0.0036878676619380713, 0.010961276479065418, -0.017659487202763557, -0.014462990686297417, 0.0040551056154072285, -0.03505813330411911, 0.03130742162466049, -0.021993817761540413, 0.04437698423862457, -0.05105120316147804, 0.03245165944099426, 0.06768503040075302, 0.06308021396398544, -0.03613106161355972, 0.026543553918600082, -0.033650174736976624, -0.016238044947385788, -0.011639995500445366, -0.02618190087378025, 0.013257267884910107, -0.03974524512887001, -0.0019190694438293576, -0.043694864958524704, 0.008067969232797623, -0.045869797468185425, -0.015131809748709202, -0.042102329432964325, 0.01359147485345602, -0.03450293093919754, -0.00850052572786808, 0.01187707856297493, -0.013939705677330494, 0.06323079764842987, -0.07178713381290436, 0.048538368195295334, 0.006852936465293169, 0.013095577247440815, -0.02902362309396267, -0.03266843408346176, -0.03299421817064285, 0.022234885022044182, 0.07257362455129623, -0.015080854296684265, 0.020152125507593155, -0.017160871997475624, 0.04845248535275459, -0.00930465292185545, -0.05518697202205658, 0.01882775127887726, -0.06907231360673904, -0.023236557841300964, -0.001882343553006649, -0.0024344739504158497, 0.04428153112530708, -0.00824181642383337, 0.021181492134928703, 0.0057148318737745285, -0.018832417204976082, -0.007891110144555569, -0.01894875429570675, 0.041845764964818954, 0.013290589675307274, -0.006914258003234863, 0.049762845039367676, 0.008558281697332859, 0.03137359023094177, 0.03618483990430832, -0.004404027480632067, -0.05752257630228996, 0.07312880456447601, -0.02930481918156147, -0.009974687360227108, 0.0025068095419555902, -0.04625757038593292, 0.012189715169370174, -0.022041721269488335, -0.0028816484846174717, 0.013686400838196278, -0.028158709406852722, 0.005586778745055199, 0.026584727689623833, 0.018734997138381004, -0.004448881838470697, 0.0076910099014639854, -0.0010630664182826877, -0.006146817468106747, 0.001283362158574164, -0.04876266047358513, 0.004939815495163202, -0.020771214738488197, -0.020569005981087685, -0.003063519485294819, 0.02496393583714962, -0.01866302825510502, 0.0620143823325634, -0.015034281648695469, 0.0034336308017373085, -0.016712142154574394, 0.008860918693244457, -0.01259202416986227, -0.01596088707447052, -0.023787738755345345, -0.023073559626936913, 0.008724560961127281, 0.04801931977272034, 0.004306862596422434, 0.024472162127494812, -0.01695488952100277, -0.014083619229495525, -0.027436187490820885, 0.03144080191850662, 0.008088871836662292, 0.03929596766829491, 0.010744687169790268, 0.003547856817021966, -0.01395692490041256, -0.009830542840063572, 0.0008087723981589079, -0.017393851652741432, 0.044424690306186676, -0.02798142097890377, -0.032110653817653656, 0.011341416276991367, -0.01921221800148487, -0.01284041628241539, 0.00014247040962800384, 0.029426835477352142, 0.06319165974855423, -0.007820989936590195, -0.030471790581941605, -0.049034591764211655, -0.003158526262268424, 0.04584961757063866, -0.04119018837809563, -0.041518520563840866, -0.042393285781145096, 0.014334344305098057, 0.030073491856455803, -0.029458094388246536 ]
<p>I originally asked this on a machine learning site, but one of the responses made me think that maybe this site is more suitable.</p> <p>Suppose you have two weighted coins, and every day you flip each one a number of times and record the total number of heads. So on the tenth day you might have flipped coin A 106 times, coin B 381 times, and recorded 137 heads. Supposing your goal is to figure out the weights of each coin, is it reasonable to just regress the number of heads on the number of flips for each coin? E.g, something along the lines of:</p> <p>num_heads ~ num_flips_A + num_flips_B + intercept</p> <p>However,it doesn't seem to make sense to have an intercept term in this scenario (it is negative for my data, which is confusing), so I tried subtracting out -1 from the formula, and it seemed to yield reasonable results. My first question is whether this approach is a good one.</p> <p>Now, suppose that you suspect the existence of a third coin, C, that someone else is flipping unbeknownst to you, and the heads for that coin are getting mixed up in your count. The number of flips for this coin are not recorded, but you do not particularly care about its weight - it's more of a confounding factor. Then would it be reasonable to fit a similar regression, but constrain the intercept to be positive?</p> <p>Thanks for any help</p>
37,440
[ -0.05499211698770523, -0.003733803052455187, -0.02667234092950821, -0.030129512771964073, 0.03614763915538788, -0.0030412855558097363, -0.021583998575806618, 0.015480534173548222, 0.01340586319565773, -0.025964364409446716, 0.0509161576628685, 0.03689828887581825, 0.014746058732271194, 0.00015829360927455127, 0.022327402606606483, 0.016410941258072853, 0.0109566580504179, -0.008161764591932297, -0.0038581208791583776, -0.021232089027762413, 0.013885580003261566, 0.031178999692201614, 0.027113523334264755, 0.019743923097848892, -0.02115832269191742, 0.037819184362888336, 0.04691612720489502, -0.04330247640609741, 0.004757915157824755, 0.049498703330755234, -0.02746731974184513, -0.013622607104480267, 0.013636277057230473, 0.034898821264505386, 0.049379199743270874, 0.003254109062254429, -0.003980638924986124, -0.026654193177819252, -0.010237671434879303, 0.056408870965242386, -0.0317680723965168, 0.009284375235438347, -0.010438816621899605, 0.03774651885032654, -0.0041877590119838715, 0.0003511698741931468, 0.001561049954034388, -0.0437316857278347, -0.0057359375059604645, -0.08953963220119476, 0.06583911180496216, -0.018691468983888626, 0.023825330659747124, -0.0013381390599533916, -0.020426101982593536, -0.04255707561969757, 0.05822589248418808, 0.05838555842638016, -0.011370595544576645, -0.021764202043414116, -0.005949514918029308, -0.0029284569900482893, -0.0027094543911516666, -0.0006732744514010847, -0.015633145347237587, 0.021654250100255013, 0.02051195688545704, -0.04282817989587784, 0.027157515287399292, 0.00027848719037137926, 0.026073182001709938, 0.0031258927192538977, 0.04259905591607094, 0.0038798400200903416, 0.00011671421088976786, -0.046230658888816833, 0.009621167555451393, 0.031218338757753372, 0.04041404277086258, 0.020558269694447517, -0.01280647050589323, -0.0012392608914524317, 0.06184319406747818, 0.04331325739622116, 0.031512562185525894, -0.0016375848790630698, 0.051866140216588974, -0.02238224633038044, 0.03697074204683304, 0.04594899341464043, -0.05677247792482376, 0.01655198074877262, 0.03914613649249077, -0.02152896299958229, -0.056997913867235184, 0.017690561711788177, -0.008961236104369164, 0.017315134406089783, 0.030464645475149155, -0.014729397371411324, -0.06525226682424545, -0.027136623859405518, 0.005558024160563946, 0.07084701955318451, -0.03618743270635605, -0.007540990598499775, -0.03430159389972687, 0.025611404329538345, -0.021877866238355637, -0.04289660230278969, 0.011409256607294083, 0.005714267026633024, 0.013694936409592628, -0.03537566587328911, 0.027973249554634094, -0.0027514623943716288, -0.012742241844534874, -0.006420667748898268, 0.03333097696304321, 0.04946024343371391, 0.012022817507386208, -0.01012344565242529, 0.014316437765955925, -0.047372832894325256, -0.020601969212293625, -0.00889156199991703, 0.03965962305665016, 0.008716195821762085, -0.021973444148898125, 0.04791256785392761, 0.030120089650154114, -0.0516357347369194, 0.025305846706032753, -0.014277506619691849, 0.002725458238273859, -0.0008906396687962115, -0.08588749915361404, -0.06431847810745239, 0.010493571870028973, -0.02728978730738163, -0.011820128187537193, -0.031501006335020065, -0.03262855485081673, 0.03367927670478821, 0.08087775111198425, 0.014349793083965778, 0.04060400649905205, 0.008474726229906082, 0.03367515653371811, 0.01518245693296194, -0.00854941364377737, -0.018896253779530525, -0.026572365313768387, -0.026289144530892372, -0.02156059630215168, -0.08723856508731842, 0.03693051263689995, 0.00235136691480875, -0.022624468430876732, -0.0014082276029512286, 0.04253187030553818, 0.017884183675050735, 0.009516182355582714, 0.01912257820367813, 0.00011562476720428094, -0.01039064023643732, 0.07279126346111298, -0.000768556201364845, 0.03652036190032959, 0.007605032529681921, 0.02236104942858219, 0.03876388818025589, 0.006936417426913977, 0.04728568717837334, 0.029661543667316437, -0.03649570420384407, 0.0034440031740814447, -0.047643646597862244, 0.022622905671596527, -0.005645437631756067, -0.02466542273759842, -0.023466667160391808, 0.007425128482282162, -0.009387974627315998, 0.0420379601418972, 0.012391937896609306, 0.011067362502217293, -0.0225251205265522, 0.07011009752750397, -0.024234166368842125, -0.003906113561242819, -0.041360143572092056, -0.01572134904563427, 0.001707018120214343, -0.035392049700021744, 0.028412384912371635, 0.0022862658370286226, 0.011689070612192154, -0.020708328112959862, -0.041394561529159546, 0.003121663350611925, 0.0026472893077880144, 0.07283549010753632, -0.050123460590839386, -0.042690761387348175, 0.06086365506052971, 0.018929528072476387, -0.027800092473626137, 0.04188798367977142, -0.05452333018183708, 0.0009166545933112502, -0.006193534005433321, -0.03736577183008194, 0.0022854211274534464, 0.026187647134065628, 0.023295948281884193, 0.048267967998981476, -0.016110140830278397, -0.010227512568235397, 0.017649618908762932, -0.06151449307799339, 0.064256951212883, 0.059496648609638214, 0.028664221987128258, 0.006306033581495285, 0.019962888211011887, 0.027079114690423012, -0.004397045820951462, -0.028659535571932793, -0.03070273995399475, -0.05006648972630501, -0.0444030687212944, -0.002560637192800641, -0.019662417471408844, -0.015605180524289608, -0.010194750502705574, 0.05312323942780495, 0.024434445425868034, 0.0037985467351973057, 0.009512422606348991, -0.0243183895945549, -0.03776227682828903, -0.016677798703312874, -0.0109172984957695, -0.0028626075945794582, 0.0119839608669281, 0.03701133280992508, 0.0038874929305166006, 0.01760346069931984, 0.011991036124527454, -0.04344630241394043, 0.03722170367836952, 0.024523964151740074, 0.006496538873761892, -0.02168036811053753, -0.027888905256986618, 0.046046990901231766, -0.04413215070962906, 0.021896786987781525, 0.01870138756930828, -0.009478411637246609, -0.015470203012228012, -0.006721206475049257, -0.02939901314675808, 0.009310459718108177, 0.03257434070110321, -0.025230763480067253, -0.012205002829432487, 0.016277365386486053, -0.04288560524582863, -0.01743328757584095, 0.02408183366060257, -0.0155975092202425, -0.018489083275198936, 0.028047269210219383, 0.0034528023097664118, 0.009178869426250458, 0.017772331833839417, -0.031150538474321365, -0.0435020886361599, 0.007147865369915962, -0.009637166745960712, 0.007587327156215906, 0.018700195476412773, -0.0861300602555275, -0.02627623826265335, -0.011419388465583324, -0.00004945155524183065, 0.029753297567367554, -0.008916777558624744, -0.013443880714476109, 0.025513408705592155, 0.0030966554768383503, -0.04111276939511299, -0.03321488946676254, -0.03304290026426315, 0.003305351361632347, -0.043551307171583176, -0.033903200179338455, 0.04546421766281128, 0.04570475220680237, -0.045099951326847076, 0.0017432592576369643, -0.016752028837800026, -0.03856009989976883, -0.02160859853029251, -0.020798366516828537, 0.012903520837426186, 0.01931564323604107, -0.02297336608171463, 0.014721798710525036, -0.005274382885545492, 0.013280601240694523, -0.09567565470933914, -0.0971805676817894, 0.03467898815870285, -0.01989508792757988, -0.010332482866942883, 0.021228531375527382, -0.033137474209070206, 0.07358303666114807, 0.041528552770614624, -0.006956996396183968, -0.02854086458683014, -0.00585521524772048, -0.01810396835207939, -0.021509036421775818, 0.009270732291042805, 0.011183870024979115, 0.02436324581503868, 0.01717163622379303, -0.030866436660289764, 0.006761471275240183, 0.03237336874008179, 0.0331522673368454, -0.0035016487818211317, 0.04185434430837631, -0.03308471292257309, -0.0043235826306045055, 0.03289676830172539, 0.01632382534444332, -0.009613178670406342, 0.013344410806894302, 0.008016099222004414, 0.012053443118929863, 0.0005984588642604649, 0.0034850023221224546, -0.022843413054943085, -0.02472735568881035, 0.07653799653053284, -0.019460484385490417, 0.025608012452721596, -0.03171703964471817, -0.0251764003187418, -0.033955447375774384, 0.019014304503798485, 0.024451494216918945, -0.041129305958747864, 0.031971074640750885, 0.04872738942503929, 0.01962878182530403, 0.01745319366455078, -0.014958123676478863, -0.016978755593299866, -0.015824850648641586, 0.004313962534070015, -0.0416206531226635, 0.020280495285987854, 0.038260117173194885, 0.03766849264502525, 0.02326369285583496, -0.018563097342848778, -0.03590153902769089, -0.009306118823587894, -0.07278294116258621, -0.016459867358207703, 0.005186821334064007, 0.05160807445645332, 0.0045000663958489895, 0.022090338170528412, 0.02755868434906006, -0.013858557678759098, -0.0016265473095700145, 0.01595032401382923, -0.0792887881398201, 0.034498464316129684, 0.00185707351192832, -0.010530811734497547, 0.008898017928004265, -0.022571660578250885, 0.03757327049970627, -0.05235423520207405, 0.03715208172798157, 0.004936052020639181, 0.04152506962418556, -0.027971206232905388, 0.024050040170550346, -0.030512351542711258, -0.010383076034486294, 0.014362635090947151, 0.02236640825867653, 0.0216353852301836, -0.0054959384724497795, 0.04601212218403816, 0.03426429629325867, -0.037634532898664474, -0.027260959148406982, -0.03205292671918869, 0.007831511087715626, 0.01863078959286213, 0.031368188560009, 0.0134809585288167, 0.016260609030723572, -0.07588033378124237, 0.037552718073129654, -0.029955625534057617, -0.002321489853784442, 0.03656504675745964, -0.0019815596751868725, -0.03066522441804409, -0.06284158676862717, -0.03454221785068512, 0.007961955852806568, -0.0013155897613614798, -0.021605636924505234, 0.01924734190106392, 0.054491739720106125, -0.018445078283548355, -0.04102542623877525, -0.027664899826049805, 0.09631945937871933, 0.04741581156849861, 0.022515621036291122, -0.026253607124090195, 0.03973086178302765, -0.013864004984498024, -0.0002814280451275408, 0.011206606402993202, 0.013571269810199738, -0.004213732201606035, -0.010849707759916782, 0.03581194579601288, -0.02247360348701477, 0.00606165686622262, 0.0362037718296051, 0.004622009117156267, 0.037018340080976486, -0.009825155138969421, -0.04361281171441078, 0.022468866780400276, 0.053435806185007095, -0.0017032818868756294, 0.016818514093756676, -0.005451255477964878, -0.09210589528083801, 0.001270715962164104, 0.049840010702610016, 0.05570654198527336, -0.06187928095459938, -0.005934949964284897, -0.029571447521448135, 0.005807546433061361, 0.043148674070835114, -0.03725757077336311, 0.001277725794352591, 0.011414357461035252, 0.010211136192083359, -0.01832110621035099, -0.060025837272405624, -0.08457570523023605, 0.06181282177567482, -0.034111302345991135, 0.044504377990961075, -0.025854727253317833, -0.046712152659893036, -0.007143809460103512, 0.008719244040548801, 0.024558687582612038, 0.010844503529369831, -0.011465281248092651, -0.04329719766974449, 0.005501982755959034, 0.036249298602342606, -0.016343271359801292, -0.06588380038738251, 0.004472621716558933, -0.021124696359038353, 0.0032147171441465616, 0.050304021686315536, 0.0051504699513316154, -0.030093355104327202, -0.024155987426638603, 0.013970410451292992, -0.02501201070845127, 0.0033775458578020334, -0.04099884256720543, 0.09093578159809113, 0.03989067301154137, -0.029263917356729507, 0.021394692361354828, 0.024111444130539894, 0.021125419065356255, 0.015948612242937088, -0.022468743845820427, -0.002177615649998188, -0.0007922817021608353, -0.0050991312600672245, -0.002118780044838786, -0.015137840993702412, -0.026616785675287247, 0.030295928940176964, 0.004682483617216349, 0.053072236478328705, -0.006491856649518013, 0.0009500540909357369, -0.030657852068543434, -0.0018189834663644433, -0.00664746668189764, 0.009748273529112339, 0.045571230351924896, -0.012157576158642769, 0.03254414722323418, -0.034690048545598984, 0.005334286019206047, -0.02313224785029888, -0.009217411279678345, -0.002505775773897767, -0.024098645895719528, 0.011640865355730057, -0.01601160503923893, -0.022807881236076355, 0.005991728510707617, -0.008510067127645016, 0.046278078109025955, -0.009709385223686695, 0.04763032868504524, -0.0207307580858469, -0.03607235103845596, -0.0021927966736257076, -0.012359501793980598, -0.037172574549913406, 0.010318399406969547, -0.04273916035890579, 0.027291314676404, -0.018263552337884903, -0.015468436293303967, -0.056069087237119675, -0.013514582999050617, -0.004872542805969715, -0.035961948335170746, -0.019061775878071785, -0.021123124286532402, 0.017902953550219536, -0.029298532754182816, -0.03160577639937401, 0.003477469552308321, 0.024466993287205696, -0.0620100237429142, -0.019322926178574562, 0.005204431712627411, -0.0028195378836244345, 0.07339842617511749, 0.01138738077133894, -0.0013161069946363568, 0.015094447880983353, -0.043923623859882355, -0.009545410051941872, 0.022976990789175034, 0.011397105641663074, -0.026677895337343216, -0.009876325726509094, -0.012576461769640446, -0.03026430495083332, 0.02446659654378891, -0.004024703521281481, -0.004113474860787392, -0.010455561801791191, -0.008508335798978806, 0.008106732740998268, 0.0008897764491848648, -0.003950629383325577, -0.001262902980670333, 0.009336190298199654, -0.024647299200296402, 0.007003709673881531, 0.016941510140895844, 0.011084947735071182, 0.036561161279678345, 0.03572480008006096, -0.051730312407016754, -0.03335314244031906, 0.05563044175505638, 0.032677777111530304, 0.0017710647080093622, -0.02979028783738613, -0.020119307562708855, 0.020766912028193474, -0.041043635457754135, -0.01017596572637558, 0.03180738911032677, 0.02142820879817009, -0.04298371076583862, -0.035003118216991425, -0.05275921896100044, 0.01610257849097252, 0.026654966175556183, -0.015177550725638866, 0.05111291632056236, 0.02845294587314129, 0.01703801564872265, -0.013693446293473244, -0.028309598565101624, 0.01648583821952343, -0.0013438960304483771, -0.007213572971522808, 0.022525351494550705, 0.005350906401872635, 0.03643679991364479, 0.05112108588218689, -0.010336214676499367, 0.015272960066795349, 0.03322744369506836, 0.02332191728055477, 0.04424609988927841, 0.043840546160936356, -0.023589208722114563, -0.039625510573387146, 0.004630590323358774, -0.042227569967508316, -0.01276969350874424, -0.012769566848874092, -0.0435645692050457, 0.03420440852642059, 0.026945237070322037, 0.017084816470742226, -0.04961366206407547, -0.07080341875553131, -0.034867625683546066, -0.023220926523208618, 0.030198806896805763, -0.055759869515895844, 0.013805338181555271, -0.0026135253719985485, 0.039047740399837494, 0.008849592879414558, 0.014096034690737724, -0.04267171025276184, -0.11709617078304291, -0.04450705274939537, -0.027075152844190598, -0.058376602828502655, -0.005726132076233625, -0.011047814041376114, -0.00997694581747055, 0.03506679832935333, -0.05291617661714554, -0.0017840544460341334, 0.0013270259369164705, 0.0372207872569561, -0.01346910372376442, 0.07516392320394516, 0.0064897239208221436, -0.009252618998289108, -0.027004804462194443, -0.0028911661356687546, 0.12818196415901184, 0.08017534017562866, 0.07225427776575089, -0.06789803504943848, 0.03824927285313606, -0.0017465960700064898, 0.007247856352478266, -0.03833375871181488, -0.011698323301970959, -0.026534341275691986, 0.01263301633298397, 0.012956995517015457, 0.028118884190917015, 0.03373834118247032, -0.0181129053235054, 0.031657036393880844, -0.02612365037202835, -0.007813303731381893, 0.007287304382771254, 0.008110576309263706, -0.007238550577312708, -0.033971868455410004, -0.030302179977297783, 0.03732132539153099, -0.010990195907652378, -0.026069965213537216, 0.0003508743830025196, 0.01209213025867939, -0.018822066485881805, 0.019879302009940147, -0.004978228826075792, 0.01836201176047325, 0.01897628977894783, -0.017573518678545952, -0.023264626041054726, 0.03120117075741291, 0.043253663927316666, -0.042136408388614655, 0.01773686707019806, 0.019717048853635788, -0.02856687270104885, -0.025579556822776794, 0.028100429102778435, 0.013893598690629005, -0.050074610859155655, -0.030645471066236496, -0.0049146986566483974, 0.05766727030277252, -0.024611206725239754, -0.0019299808191135526, 0.01553981564939022, -0.025739047676324844, 0.038010191172361374, -0.0463828481733799, -0.0210970938205719, -0.0009101918549276888, 0.016053585335612297, -0.05739649012684822, -0.024199817329645157, -0.006788043305277824, 0.03270441293716431, 0.021830741316080093, 0.037466153502464294, 0.03282184898853302, -0.02130570076406002, -0.05650320276618004, -0.012550124898552895, 0.058880988508462906, 0.051237016916275024, -0.01997290551662445, 0.0385613739490509, -0.008056041784584522, -0.023957477882504463, -0.015993908047676086, 0.011795774102210999, 0.000541835033800453, 0.0064768302254378796, -0.008458073250949383, 0.01602465845644474, -0.023990679532289505, -0.01248260959982872, 0.045922599732875824, -0.04211584851145744, 0.01185105461627245, -0.051040053367614746, 0.00006401215796358883, 0.005584282334893942, 0.01952408440411091, -0.0007426476804539561, -0.0225378330796957, 0.01066751778125763, 0.07108797132968903, -0.001752772950567305, -0.01183110848069191, -0.01366154570132494, -0.00939899031072855, -0.027128810063004494, 0.008927655406296253, -0.0003729318268597126, 0.06392371654510498, 0.013104761950671673, 0.012876014225184917, 0.00016502614016644657, 0.029904134571552277, -0.010746074840426445, 0.01298816129565239, -0.00833607092499733, -0.0533810555934906, -0.014077946543693542, -0.0020559881813824177, -0.00607440248131752, 0.0011934625217691064, -0.038153886795043945, -0.04248705878853798, 0.010098276659846306, -0.01794918067753315, -0.019858740270137787, -0.0693809986114502, 0.028023511171340942, 0.013023169711232185, 0.020469391718506813, -0.010239837691187859, 0.04724084213376045, -0.0423249788582325, -0.016491306945681572, 0.014136077836155891, -0.02470133826136589, 0.03275251016020775, 0.014066717587411404, 0.01878061331808567, 0.01984890177845955, 0.033171359449625015, -0.004014595877379179, 0.020037395879626274, 0.0008043709676712751, 0.025513198226690292, -0.0004341595049481839, 0.06698998063802719, -0.007439810317009687, -0.035723961889743805, 0.05944700911641121, -0.04611735790967941, 0.005439672619104385, 0.033214256167411804, 0.003061661496758461, 0.0359201654791832, 0.03994292393326759, 0.006845303811132908, -0.0033004870638251305, 0.03252454474568367, -0.030858943238854408, 0.012735419906675816, 0.006272850092500448, 0.004403074737638235, 0.03524881601333618, -0.010198571719229221, 0.02116880938410759, 0.0016033583087846637, 0.01329752430319786, 0.0014620742294937372, 0.06069924682378769, 0.026965565979480743, 0.027950506657361984, 0.007315922994166613, 0.011392883025109768, -0.006724393926560879, -0.018331147730350494, -0.042091913521289825, 0.02909168228507042, 0.009103149175643921, -0.06593315303325653, 0.047005899250507355, -0.011688746511936188, 0.024424714967608452, -0.07586544007062912, -0.021188225597143173, 0.05071914568543434, 0.020991140976548195, 0.04107268527150154, -0.04487461596727371, 0.009078118950128555, 0.02281981334090233, -0.015548110008239746, 0.01622580923140049, -0.00590335251763463, -0.010292468592524529, -0.02333371341228485, 0.029698750004172325, -0.018926214426755905, -0.01882750540971756, -0.009370137937366962, -0.008100062608718872, 0.061245400458574295, 0.03087654709815979, -0.015926020219922066, -0.03777463361620903, 0.015264087356626987, 0.0036297678016126156, 0.0031829923391342163, -0.05129905790090561, 0.05174626037478447, -0.03321833536028862, 0.0009964363416656852, 0.0609138198196888, -0.019564570859074593, 0.038217440247535706, 0.007764429319649935, 0.03984155133366585, 0.010438104160130024, 0.047874804586172104, 0.01012489665299654, 0.017957696691155434, 0.036196235567331314, 0.02229822613298893, 0.01954924501478672, 0.0393214076757431, 0.031022608280181885, 0.026705443859100342, -0.029116487130522728, -0.011525716632604599, -0.003172505646944046, 0.003771998453885317, 0.0028795127291232347, 0.02005394734442234, -0.020602311939001083, -0.013755729421973228, 0.02254984900355339, -0.011872448958456516, -0.00123516411986202, -0.04994519054889679, 0.017228063195943832, 0.026019876822829247, -0.002268306678161025, -0.039036959409713745, -0.008236262015998363, -0.016037678346037865, -0.055155619978904724, 0.026746783405542374, -0.018145594745874405, 0.0015571514377370477, -0.04353861138224602, -0.0032921857200562954, 0.021013163030147552, 0.03830510377883911, -0.010748165659606457, 0.007152294274419546, -0.033440325409173965, 0.026110762730240822, -0.04404232278466225, 0.010336671024560928, 0.043711401522159576, -0.012937545776367188, 0.03099791146814823, -0.09786059707403183, 0.05699944123625755, 0.010796119458973408, 0.011205023154616356, -0.004138026852160692, -0.012728345580399036, -0.04379430413246155, -0.017154335975646973, 0.06735989451408386, 0.010484887287020683, -0.014757542870938778, -0.023019207641482353, 0.01396853942424059, -0.01489699725061655, -0.047250840812921524, 0.054779402911663055, 0.02510995976626873, 0.018440110608935356, 0.004296322353184223, -0.0073178294114768505, 0.03141867369413376, 0.015642186626791954, 0.010026438161730766, 0.001938047120347619, -0.009508436545729637, 0.03445194289088249, -0.015645654872059822, 0.009529966861009598, 0.006930306553840637, 0.03899265080690384, 0.046456627547740936, 0.034853674471378326, 0.02820337750017643, 0.028943903744220734, -0.009289092384278774, -0.03240368515253067, 0.06847106665372849, -0.0059549096040427685, -0.006359035614877939, 0.029923124238848686, -0.00021174382709432393, -0.009339823387563229, -0.04238816350698471, -0.0023885471746325493, -0.0007077964255586267, -0.013677972368896008, -0.03835160657763481, 0.004053340759128332, 0.0034203357063233852, 0.03183760493993759, 0.005591870751231909, 0.03080301731824875, 0.032002042979002, 0.006471613422036171, 0.023232126608490944, 0.015815984457731247, 0.015179106965661049, 0.027981126680970192, 0.010371689684689045, 0.04152455925941467, 0.015278134495019913, 0.0308675654232502, -0.00816513691097498, 0.02706713229417801, -0.007021051831543446, -0.004262594506144524, -0.02167324535548687, 0.0037149605341255665, 0.003303128993138671, -0.0011240261374041438, 0.010771818459033966, 0.05209292843937874, -0.03338786959648132, 0.017687741667032242, -0.03922588750720024, 0.01840047724545002, -0.010880744084715843, -0.0054634613916277885, 0.026904575526714325, 0.01937650889158249, 0.014531012624502182, -0.040241558104753494, 0.01513689011335373, -0.0026941937394440174, 0.00437378603965044, -0.043856240808963776, 0.030169134959578514, -0.009605002589523792, -0.009132705628871918, -0.044006068259477615, -0.053692691028118134, -0.035339634865522385, -0.05985864996910095, -0.003355307737365365, 0.030311303213238716, 0.03151300922036171, -0.02494937926530838, -0.02954391948878765, -0.006179538089782, 0.05953060835599899, -0.07242067903280258, -0.019048258662223816, -0.0319332592189312, 0.03414714336395264, -0.01799139380455017, -0.03043127804994583 ]
<p>In R, the <code>step</code> command is supposedly intended to help you select the input variables to your model, right? </p> <p>The following comes from <code>example(step)#-&gt; swiss</code> &amp; <code>step(lm1)</code></p> <pre><code>&gt; step(lm1) Start: AIC=190.69 Fertility ~ Agriculture + Examination + Education + Catholic + Infant.Mortality Df Sum of Sq RSS AIC - Examination 1 53.03 2158.1 189.86 &lt;none&gt; 2105.0 190.69 - Agriculture 1 307.72 2412.8 195.10 - Infant.Mortality 1 408.75 2513.8 197.03 - Catholic 1 447.71 2552.8 197.75 - Education 1 1162.56 3267.6 209.36 Step: AIC=189.86 Fertility ~ Agriculture + Education + Catholic + Infant.Mortality Df Sum of Sq RSS AIC &lt;none&gt; 2158.1 189.86 - Agriculture 1 264.18 2422.2 193.29 - Infant.Mortality 1 409.81 2567.9 196.03 - Catholic 1 956.57 3114.6 205.10 - Education 1 2249.97 4408.0 221.43 Call: lm(formula = Fertility ~ Agriculture + Education + Catholic + Infant.Mortality, data = swiss) Coefficients: (Intercept) Agriculture Education 62.1013 -0.1546 -0.9803 Catholic Infant.Mortality 0.1247 1.0784 </code></pre> <p>Now, when I look at this, I guess the last Step table is the model which we should use? The last few lines include the "Call" function, which describes the actual model and what input variables it includes, and the "Coefficients" are the actual parameter estimates for these values, right? So this is the model I want, right? I'm trying to extrapolate this to my project, where there are more variables. </p>
37,706
[ -0.015436027199029922, 0.012775889597833157, -0.028149334713816643, 0.00413957703858614, 0.01997043751180172, -0.008075142279267311, -0.008766358718276024, -0.03511321544647217, 0.06078764423727989, -0.022202378138899803, 0.04516783356666565, 0.07189106196165085, 0.08157152682542801, -0.02661735564470291, 0.051594048738479614, 0.01991141214966774, 0.019375991076231003, 0.026714684441685677, -0.009822753258049488, -0.033345311880111694, 0.009115894325077534, 0.04998965188860893, 0.005044898949563503, -0.01117260567843914, 0.016061967238783836, 0.05350366234779358, -0.0028202838730067015, 0.005615612026304007, -0.025449227541685104, 0.023860255256295204, -0.03853227198123932, -0.00005631363455904648, -0.006440395954996347, -0.008688755333423615, 0.023990899324417114, 0.07243886590003967, -0.053801558911800385, -0.04776276275515556, 0.016871465370059013, 0.04589482769370079, 0.001979709602892399, -0.004985688719898462, 0.020221004262566566, 0.036406002938747406, 0.034642916172742844, 0.05095425620675087, 0.009985939599573612, -0.0036694828886538744, 0.0479729026556015, -0.0011341918725520372, 0.018162738531827927, -0.0017759620677679777, 0.012588257901370525, 0.05135916918516159, -0.013294517062604427, 0.01242116466164589, 0.06012172996997833, 0.05275414139032364, -0.0011556710815057158, -0.016064569354057312, -0.030639851465821266, 0.0009261537343263626, 0.004344236571341753, -0.042517807334661484, -0.03163007274270058, -0.021816039457917213, 0.04034212976694107, -0.02432798594236374, 0.0361221544444561, -0.03828255087137222, 0.0020206624176353216, 0.027721676975488663, 0.007370930630713701, -0.007722880225628614, 0.02058590017259121, -0.0021978705190122128, 0.0038907420821487904, -0.004678237251937389, 0.022189661860466003, 0.00611700676381588, -0.017700906842947006, 0.01342189684510231, 0.004623629618436098, 0.04262438416481018, 0.04536176472902298, 0.023577481508255005, 0.05462278798222542, -0.02134411782026291, 0.012769262306392193, -0.00593904685229063, -0.04774772748351097, 0.05196968838572502, 0.03407991677522659, 0.05567571893334389, -0.008852226659655571, 0.04515422508120537, 0.00707713607698679, 0.030047381296753883, 0.021869713440537453, -0.01963983289897442, -0.023980021476745605, -0.05877400189638138, 0.0022754205856472254, 0.01951983943581581, -0.022882571443915367, -0.015404357574880123, -0.028533903881907463, -0.026712913066148758, -0.008949583396315575, -0.08331705629825592, -0.005999018903821707, 0.0250812117010355, 0.004450499080121517, -0.002972581423819065, 0.006005752366036177, -0.040070757269859314, -0.019519563764333725, 0.0225478895008564, 0.027110356837511063, 0.03600609675049782, 0.04833635687828064, -0.004680842626839876, 0.04578043892979622, -0.04382902383804321, -0.05347656458616257, -0.00011131794599350542, -0.015812892466783524, -0.03192295506596565, -0.019604921340942383, 0.0349467471241951, 0.027956845238804817, -0.018160473555326462, 0.033410944044589996, 0.0010999161750078201, 0.041844386607408524, -0.02652488648891449, -0.049649011343717575, -0.04201263561844826, 0.0002908689493779093, -0.007566507905721664, 0.048007987439632416, -0.03346679359674454, 0.021008988842368126, 0.01501426286995411, 0.0780981034040451, 0.0006929495721124113, -0.009920898824930191, 0.027011234313249588, 0.011037898249924183, 0.006989383138716221, -0.0439860075712204, 0.02202393300831318, -0.03626294061541557, -0.0026857343036681414, -0.012039393186569214, -0.06013179197907448, 0.020003072917461395, 0.03437013924121857, -0.012362073175609112, -0.010822444222867489, 0.03185870870947838, 0.03682766854763031, 0.013540015555918217, 0.0011987402103841305, -0.05237695947289467, -0.046060364693403244, 0.08839993923902512, 0.003467530943453312, 0.0012061094166710973, 0.06579134613275528, 0.0068997605703771114, 0.015919866040349007, -0.02152908220887184, 0.045077674090862274, 0.05271215736865997, 0.004494599997997284, 0.035348255187273026, -0.03018932230770588, 0.025027746334671974, 0.039756715297698975, -0.048185598105192184, -0.03691336140036583, 0.022392479702830315, 0.003558994736522436, 0.017093036323785782, 0.011660446412861347, 0.015287309885025024, -0.015380230732262135, 0.05102349445223808, -0.058405306190252304, -0.030775127932429314, -0.020772064104676247, -0.030727967619895935, 0.015374811366200447, 0.003327564336359501, -0.021091600880026817, 0.007787548936903477, 0.016069095581769943, 0.030205177143216133, -0.024574464187026024, -0.0330934040248394, -0.010838741436600685, 0.048329226672649384, 0.004085559863597155, -0.00799789559096098, 0.042431607842445374, 0.05093652755022049, 0.007001238875091076, 0.055553991347551346, -0.025180047377943993, 0.015866750851273537, 0.024955956265330315, -0.018881693482398987, 0.000242211070144549, -0.013538499362766743, -0.020048322156071663, -0.01510393526405096, 0.014305826276540756, 0.0032559174578636885, 0.044412389397621155, -0.032718028873205185, 0.04446954280138016, 0.049513205885887146, 0.0476701445877552, -0.0014148239279165864, -0.003823923645541072, 0.03080316260457039, 0.06841906160116196, -0.027493754401803017, -0.0009660611976869404, 0.004854247439652681, -0.048181429505348206, 0.0188920758664608, -0.04913344234228134, -0.07532064616680145, -0.008832791820168495, 0.051378268748521805, -0.010446724481880665, 0.0065074581652879715, 0.02558174356818199, -0.00676202867180109, 0.026418857276439667, 0.01141230296343565, -0.012993870303034782, 0.004137128591537476, -0.011191724799573421, 0.00729436194524169, 0.014831213280558586, 0.01479453407227993, -0.009332158602774143, -0.02006460167467594, 0.05824501812458038, -0.010141397826373577, -0.011522731743752956, -0.014202316291630268, -0.000917680561542511, 0.04527817666530609, -0.01095100212842226, 0.00019386869098525494, 0.023162472993135452, 0.00664790254086256, -0.04842506721615791, -0.029780853539705276, -0.02577998861670494, 0.022677293047308922, 0.013771533034741879, -0.04362288862466812, 0.015797508880496025, 0.030132979154586792, -0.041016072034835815, 0.03992468863725662, -0.014974125660955906, -0.04364039748907089, -0.06522058695554733, 0.0292644202709198, 0.00036586078931577504, 0.024140475317835808, 0.018364842981100082, -0.041953444480895996, -0.05557993799448013, -0.014817035757005215, -0.025718508288264275, 0.06172109767794609, 0.017131300643086433, -0.05472208186984062, 0.002354634227231145, -0.0063437819480896, -0.02076493762433529, 0.06453907489776611, 0.027168557047843933, -0.0679035410284996, 0.004165403079241514, -0.0031756425742059946, -0.004382335115224123, -0.058244477957487106, -0.041886694729328156, 0.024066532030701637, 0.010271350853145123, 0.00338678527623415, 0.005828654393553734, -0.00035927144926972687, -0.014760023914277554, 0.03188277781009674, -0.0661519318819046, -0.01231392752379179, -0.025800209492444992, -0.02881930023431778, -0.008423428982496262, 0.03717714920639992, -0.006626639049500227, 0.010791707783937454, -0.04648100584745407, 0.004956450778990984, -0.06887079775333405, -0.04588601738214493, -0.005359157454222441, 0.04051068052649498, -0.0014725587097927928, 0.03110080398619175, -0.0006607214454561472, 0.06882183998823166, 0.018028879538178444, -0.0840424969792366, -0.052337486296892166, 0.028328923508524895, -0.011118026450276375, -0.01396115031093359, 0.008334893733263016, 0.02371678315103054, 0.01675662398338318, 0.03706320375204086, -0.03821554780006409, 0.025380488485097885, 0.051507461816072464, -0.03192843496799469, 0.04156752675771713, 0.02359016239643097, -0.03549009561538696, -0.02330276556313038, 0.042832743376493454, 0.010031348094344139, 0.004692235961556435, 0.058577533811330795, -0.03514615073800087, 0.013324527069926262, -0.0009626157116144896, -0.02435206063091755, -0.01036176085472107, 0.0006365601439028978, 0.001134347403421998, -0.05140361934900284, 0.0243103988468647, 0.009940109215676785, -0.05705698952078819, -0.010320259258151054, 0.017613571137189865, 0.03815144672989845, -0.019356394186615944, -0.02309410832822323, 0.02125697396695614, -0.0022376857232302427, -0.01663774438202381, 0.038981612771749496, -0.005810949485749006, -0.013732967898249626, 0.006597661878913641, -0.0022465218789875507, 0.009495284408330917, 0.05153665691614151, 0.039892204105854034, -0.008907857351005077, -0.019965821877121925, -0.060211874544620514, 0.02133427932858467, -0.0537470318377018, -0.03665584325790405, -0.033578045666217804, 0.03732339292764664, 0.015824776142835617, 0.035145103931427, 0.025040874257683754, -0.004476469941437244, 0.026665596291422844, 0.0018598638707771897, -0.038551561534404755, 0.018392346799373627, 0.008535114116966724, -0.03748057037591934, -0.009994684718549252, -0.010360651649534702, 0.05492892861366272, -0.04107004776597023, -0.041769612580537796, 0.004477435722947121, -0.024844922125339508, -0.01729883812367916, 0.036602891981601715, -0.02214008755981922, 0.012693628668785095, -0.015978870913386345, -0.004724572878330946, 0.007598895113915205, 0.00686605554074049, -0.02478736639022827, 0.06952463835477829, -0.004154284950345755, -0.02468659169971943, -0.03615124896168709, 0.011812093667685986, 0.013878521509468555, 0.01674443855881691, 0.052874721586704254, 0.03728702291846275, -0.06609403342008591, 0.045808251947164536, 0.02767043560743332, 0.03582289069890976, 0.07012315094470978, 0.015654753893613815, -0.0356595404446125, -0.013582463376224041, -0.0032606450840830803, 0.026762202382087708, -0.005737270228564739, 0.009594863280653954, -0.005810914561152458, 0.06990838795900345, 0.04382574185729027, -0.016022320836782455, 0.024165816605091095, 0.04969564825296402, -0.015197566710412502, -0.0034834551624953747, -0.004902223125100136, -0.006433011032640934, -0.02030503749847412, -0.0021374754142016172, 0.015941357240080833, 0.029909338802099228, -0.014655889011919498, -0.014856620691716671, 0.022958749905228615, -0.028452537953853607, 0.0010667769238352776, 0.031574275344610214, 0.02970253676176071, 0.029763055965304375, -0.010714019648730755, -0.03863200917840004, -0.0107002267614007, 0.029095251113176346, -0.004465884529054165, 0.01743263565003872, 0.011619635857641697, -0.10228010267019272, -0.018923582509160042, 0.02370956353843212, 0.03824729099869728, -0.0497097410261631, -0.02728474698960781, -0.03805815055966377, -0.026066947728395462, -0.0008019135566428304, -0.01174482423812151, 0.0027665989473462105, -0.03614257276058197, -0.00958852656185627, -0.02055039256811142, -0.023013154044747353, -0.04611668363213539, -0.01900031790137291, -0.04964260384440422, 0.0011933742789551616, -0.0338192954659462, -0.017302380874753, -0.029382502660155296, 0.03134706988930702, -0.009188048541545868, 0.044133223593235016, -0.05671969801187515, -0.06795887649059296, 0.03207576274871826, 0.02816726453602314, -0.008625173941254616, -0.01685892790555954, -0.01922525279223919, -0.00900277215987444, -0.008963149972259998, 0.042765796184539795, 0.005339710041880608, -0.00035296252463012934, 0.023022612556815147, 0.03818085789680481, 0.009166516363620758, 0.01736474595963955, -0.03705405071377754, 0.027591172605752945, 0.02584659866988659, -0.013372059911489487, 0.03495103120803833, 0.03910845145583153, -0.022894026711583138, 0.03708510845899582, -0.05656231567263603, -0.016198523342609406, -0.01332233939319849, -0.02188599854707718, -0.06402771174907684, 0.005687165539711714, -0.012517974711954594, -0.011601717211306095, 0.030153410509228706, 0.011282213032245636, -0.05839534103870392, 0.013978266157209873, 0.030485451221466064, 0.03494991734623909, -0.028070727363228798, -0.02174735628068447, -0.009101243689656258, 0.033021919429302216, -0.019783630967140198, -0.04459429904818535, -0.025955798104405403, -0.03972407430410385, 0.03451409563422203, -0.02637512795627117, 0.01357760839164257, 0.023740433156490326, -0.001747749513015151, -0.03790758177638054, 0.05815286561846733, -0.00908113643527031, -0.015049677342176437, 0.00416472926735878, 0.03399038687348366, -0.03129773959517479, -0.02054620534181595, -0.02525070123374462, 0.02205357700586319, 0.005357752554118633, -0.0030940042342990637, -0.0034362548030912876, 0.019357474520802498, -0.008587858639657497, -0.007910543121397495, -0.03797609359025955, -0.04836621880531311, 0.023316362872719765, -0.0220803190022707, -0.040291927754879, -0.01867399737238884, -0.03266279026865959, -0.019932713359594345, -0.018887413665652275, 0.022189941257238388, 0.030591582879424095, -0.07387425005435944, 0.01497573684900999, -0.016437428072094917, 0.029696056619286537, 0.037061866372823715, 0.01145164854824543, 0.04011565446853638, 0.042760513722896576, -0.024139078333973885, 0.00855081994086504, 0.05280917510390282, -0.008331509307026863, -0.01235335972160101, 0.021332168951630592, -0.003925546072423458, 0.032467905431985855, 0.044634319841861725, -0.016654225066304207, -0.033238764852285385, 0.006549307145178318, -0.022763142362236977, 0.02341402880847454, -0.014322872273623943, 0.008650398813188076, -0.028030233457684517, 0.01803181692957878, -0.04852977767586708, 0.013525101356208324, 0.0032580941915512085, 0.0050037931650877, 0.0069317384622991085, -0.022455500438809395, 0.021809475496411324, 0.02820185013115406, 0.06947336345911026, -0.017169956117868423, 0.009156374260783195, -0.015622789040207863, 0.020843002945184708, 0.06774679571390152, 0.025702232494950294, 0.007250027731060982, 0.0007514170720241964, 0.05809321254491806, -0.0400242805480957, -0.00802623014897108, -0.058432094752788544, -0.008015143685042858, 0.024961022660136223, -0.018809577450156212, 0.026273995637893677, 0.022654488682746887, -0.013231242075562477, 0.01769430749118328, -0.01465562917292118, -0.03843903914093971, 0.021173225715756416, -0.007959472946822643, 0.07705885171890259, 0.009540202096104622, -0.0379045195877552, 0.05517468601465225, -0.0035276899579912424, 0.024193555116653442, 0.006724894512444735, -0.0008514886139892042, 0.01825733669102192, -0.005506896413862705, 0.0018106894567608833, 0.0008660844760015607, -0.004052506759762764, -0.017134439200162888, -0.010477141477167606, -0.026032494381070137, -0.0348910316824913, 0.05248183384537697, 0.06901480257511139, 0.010615527629852295, -0.04680371657013893, 0.006881336215883493, -0.04733303189277649, -0.03127111867070198, 0.0367378368973732, -0.00022783495660405606, 0.05539320781826973, -0.021018831059336662, -0.00343365129083395, 0.007279516663402319, 0.045322440564632416, -0.05895455926656723, -0.071088045835495, -0.039741743355989456, -0.05923568084836006, -0.036311302334070206, 0.06743346154689789, -0.0013512528967112303, 0.0026057574432343245, 0.02637295424938202, -0.02553979493677616, -0.0029042770620435476, 0.007707048673182726, 0.005777717102319002, -0.02001282013952732, 0.04507890343666077, -0.014364168047904968, -0.030209235846996307, -0.021078113466501236, -0.03707036375999451, 0.15161387622356415, 0.06829799711704254, 0.027839096263051033, -0.0745714083313942, 0.02657408080995083, 0.014161283150315285, 0.01028493419289589, -0.0074026999063789845, -0.04500596225261688, 0.01954573206603527, 0.0046583255752921104, 0.0535360723733902, 0.05098233371973038, 0.045436710119247437, 0.06971240788698196, -0.002581670880317688, -0.04207877442240715, -0.02599790319800377, 0.02806919440627098, 0.02015356719493866, 0.000026947216611006297, -0.019520262256264687, -0.021690215915441513, -0.0008957803365774453, 0.03402910754084587, -0.021115338429808617, -0.04026785120368004, 0.007632911205291748, -0.006232124753296375, -0.013777803629636765, -0.03271087631583214, -0.011430323123931885, 0.012831265106797218, 0.020046627148985863, 0.03189849853515625, 0.0149626350030303, 0.0014323669020086527, -0.02066097967326641, -0.0135617945343256, 0.03308757767081261, 0.035666875541210175, -0.0064488560892641544, -0.008389446884393692, 0.005180095322430134, -0.030590897426009178, -0.015335076488554478, -0.012536708265542984, 0.01810920424759388, 0.008259367197751999, -0.026741812005639076, -0.025976747274398804, 0.013873649761080742, 0.02963467873632908, -0.039744142442941666, -0.011819682084023952, 0.02604769542813301, -0.003313762601464987, 0.0005735722370445728, -0.02705739066004753, -0.006160604301840067, 0.02764376997947693, 0.002013836055994034, 0.0018418185645714402, 0.0287698432803154, -0.08194397389888763, -0.014001710340380669, -0.027432402595877647, 0.05008280277252197, -0.0048984927125275135, 0.015801802277565002, 0.054660484194755554, -0.015268996357917786, -0.031162714585661888, -0.018763508647680283, 0.02793380618095398, 0.016648052260279655, 0.007488972041755915, -0.05725054070353508, 0.010134049691259861, -0.06185765936970711, -0.007981601171195507, -0.004588088020682335, -0.03556211292743683, -0.01009374763816595, -0.020910719409585, -0.032907381653785706, -0.011779912747442722, 0.019828515127301216, 0.003329306375235319, -0.007033067289739847, -0.025700781494379044, 0.05726725235581398, -0.023451564833521843, -0.061740562319755554, -0.016548650339245796, 0.03324131667613983, -0.022814327850937843, 0.01934315450489521, -0.005468091927468777, 0.08961082249879837, 0.010349646210670471, 0.03934527188539505, -0.02785603143274784, 0.014319691807031631, -0.008141427300870419, 0.008117889054119587, 0.0003882816236000508, -0.035123322159051895, 0.007880647666752338, -0.006476895418018103, -0.004550337791442871, -0.052757784724235535, 0.007619152311235666, -0.02281157486140728, -0.06874357908964157, -0.005393632687628269, 0.002962749684229493, -0.07251705229282379, 0.06460754573345184, -0.01716793328523636, -0.015471291728317738, -0.011558846570551395, 0.012013418599963188, -0.026703715324401855, -0.0043124184012413025, -0.004220875445753336, -0.07340128719806671, -0.0009574172436259687, 0.0030899245757609606, -0.024607911705970764, -0.01403672806918621, 0.011016464792191982, 0.004572688601911068, -0.001659136381931603, -0.008350794203579426, 0.011238405480980873, -0.008670718409121037, 0.03884853050112724, -0.04284293204545975, -0.0062807234935462475, -0.014089697040617466, -0.001950100064277649, -0.06142372265458107, 0.011685291305184364, -0.017604917287826538, 0.06275659054517746, 0.036560337990522385, 0.01580817997455597, -0.004466760437935591, 0.05280068516731262, -0.01731688156723976, 0.020345047116279602, -0.002666004002094269, 0.009278572164475918, 0.026140566915273666, -0.02921527624130249, -0.022554880008101463, 0.01724405214190483, -0.008603813126683235, 0.0402490608394146, 0.07380644232034683, 0.0026614435482770205, -0.005826241802424192, -0.0011054102797061205, -0.030623024329543114, 0.013200314715504646, 0.009970015846192837, -0.015592719428241253, 0.0157165490090847, 0.016620256006717682, -0.0033215482253581285, 0.02036816067993641, 0.023417534306645393, 0.030616482719779015, -0.06728865206241608, 0.023030804470181465, -0.0387159138917923, 0.012228041887283325, 0.016232289373874664, -0.0579511858522892, -0.006819847971200943, 0.010656938888132572, -0.03641560673713684, -0.014413658529520035, -0.014730546623468399, 0.02222277782857418, -0.02011690102517605, 0.01576935313642025, -0.005382966250181198, -0.01726900413632393, 0.029744304716587067, 0.010208950378000736, 0.047789353877305984, -0.02788459323346615, 0.016700642183423042, -0.030937153846025467, -0.024671250954270363, -0.0040642679668962955, -0.038628123700618744, -0.0315060131251812, 0.015026366338133812, -0.021669510751962662, -0.021916987374424934, 0.007026271428912878, 0.0009139769827015698, 0.02548147365450859, 0.028106098994612694, 0.03284734860062599, 0.03948404639959335, 0.018282802775502205, -0.016833500936627388, -0.0015484055038541555, -0.028128325939178467, 0.01019409392029047, 0.011951652355492115, -0.008874169550836086, -0.029833657667040825, 0.033570706844329834, -0.0004203857097309083, 0.0350804477930069, -0.0036467539612203836, 0.018395962193608284, -0.04327782243490219, 0.012804164551198483, -0.01054619625210762, -0.01106406468898058, -0.018828118219971657, -0.03363648056983948, 0.019534405320882797, -0.031074360013008118, 0.014982606284320354, 0.0052227661944925785, 0.02884344942867756, 0.005608090199530125, -0.004848428536206484, -0.04551021009683609, -0.02903788536787033, -0.00038264624890871346, 0.039999820291996, -0.020288730040192604, -0.006551008205860853, 0.00794532336294651, 0.00831651035696268, -0.030796824023127556, 0.016337856650352478, 0.04291485249996185, -0.06496886909008026, 0.015598363243043423, 0.014956706203520298, 0.006350476760417223, 0.024737495929002762, -0.010446224361658096, 0.050607405602931976, -0.11354879289865494, 0.07124541699886322, -0.003548308741301298, -0.005473300814628601, -0.03244229033589363, 0.008241153322160244, -0.013002178631722927, 0.01744774356484413, 0.045795414596796036, -0.018915897235274315, 0.015931349247694016, -0.017785193398594856, 0.035326823592185974, -0.014301067218184471, 0.009420886635780334, 0.06559684127569199, -0.006748412270098925, -0.0022560041397809982, -0.018202461302280426, -0.001872452674433589, 0.013070700690150261, 0.03604410961270332, -0.00957091711461544, 0.006173665635287762, -0.014131532981991768, 0.016375213861465454, -0.04601708799600601, -0.01134451013058424, -0.02315218187868595, -0.00236023822799325, 0.02048993483185768, 0.014160092920064926, -0.017111780121922493, 0.04645857587456703, 0.023112108930945396, -0.058288149535655975, 0.07954911887645721, 0.0006727674044668674, -0.02812671661376953, -0.006386840250343084, -0.009231510572135448, 0.0308479405939579, -0.050337810069322586, 0.011364279314875603, 0.023074069991707802, -0.009022061713039875, -0.02155851572751999, -0.01113493088632822, 0.01903715170919895, 0.0382344052195549, -0.012312725186347961, 0.03209889307618141, -0.005357655696570873, -0.019657669588923454, 0.012976391240954399, 0.002855096710845828, 0.028786251321434975, -0.0015912679955363274, 0.011831060983240604, 0.04737795144319534, -0.02976522222161293, -0.002043770160526037, -0.027445722371339798, 0.06524404883384705, -0.005402029026299715, -0.040176767855882645, -0.018752573058009148, -0.00543573871254921, 0.01883520744740963, -0.01599092036485672, -0.00677691912278533, 0.029868289828300476, -0.015837514773011208, 0.0418313704431057, -0.043726596981287, 0.011952988803386688, -0.019448110833764076, -0.022163838148117065, -0.004128738306462765, -0.019611092284321785, -0.017455480992794037, -0.014148982241749763, -0.03563228249549866, -0.02555014006793499, 0.008632729761302471, -0.04666363075375557, 0.010801617056131363, -0.012583578005433083, 0.0019321063300594687, 0.003526294371113181, -0.0075984220020473, -0.01582922972738743, -0.003407519543543458, 0.08706746250391006, 0.033078309148550034, 0.02486560493707657, -0.07833193987607956, -0.03684401884675026, 0.0142207071185112, 0.03879270702600479, -0.012751856818795204, -0.0125364875420928, -0.01589024066925049, 0.04460878670215607, 0.023395409807562828, -0.0020490451715886593 ]
<p>I don't have much experience with panel data so I apologize in advance if this sounds ridiculous.</p> <p>Let's say that I am trying to control for individual and temporal fixed effects when running a panel data regression and I have 998 individuals and 29 years of data. In Stata the way to deal with multi-variate fixed effects is to create dummy variables that uniquely identify each combination. In my case this would be (29&times;998) - 1 = 28,941 dummy variables.</p> <p>Will this result in very high multicolinearity? What if I had ~74,000 individuals?</p> <p>My gut tells me that this is ridiculous, but gut feel and statistics don't really go well together. </p>
74,447
[ -0.02112213894724846, 0.019338205456733704, 0.023522989824414253, 0.032820653170347214, 0.03180624544620514, 0.006585931871086359, -0.022287791594862938, -0.02904311567544937, 0.026508113369345665, -0.05124465003609657, -0.00793359987437725, 0.05009659379720688, 0.03724370896816254, -0.0370095893740654, -0.007022050209343433, 0.03960941731929779, -0.009883496910333633, 0.04738118499517441, -0.018832841888070107, 0.014598395675420761, -0.03138624131679535, 0.06518349051475525, 0.006971731316298246, -0.051261138170957565, 0.028300581499934196, 0.05107743665575981, 0.004645728971809149, -0.016292456537485123, 0.011290588416159153, 0.0709695816040039, -0.004356596618890762, -0.06180015578866005, 0.027969786897301674, 0.03634704276919365, -0.0005056015797890723, 0.007185481023043394, -0.018807169049978256, -0.040440917015075684, -0.004314477555453777, 0.029605060815811157, -0.03801460191607475, -0.002708195010200143, -0.0235881470143795, 0.05904832109808922, -0.011059154756367207, 0.0374642051756382, -0.006488263141363859, -0.015691222622990608, 0.048113733530044556, -0.01626492850482464, 0.06375938653945923, 0.033816251903772354, 0.05028652399778366, 0.046125371009111404, -0.04229416325688362, -0.01639881543815136, 0.04671035706996918, 0.03457534685730934, 0.03112533874809742, -0.0401543527841568, 0.008080750703811646, -0.01014502439647913, 0.023500479757785797, 0.0002423733239993453, -0.02051134593784809, 0.04267507418990135, 0.0009355697548016906, 0.006836980581283569, 0.006344523746520281, -0.05473687872290611, 0.03859000653028488, -0.004692445509135723, 0.0329645499587059, -0.0075997766107320786, -0.003925336059182882, -0.023916564881801605, 0.03678462281823158, 0.00015760055975988507, 0.051015421748161316, 0.039572641253471375, -0.02784736454486847, 0.0203268863260746, 0.015343472361564636, 0.03129471093416214, 0.0637199655175209, 0.00474102608859539, 0.049193669110536575, -0.07909557968378067, 0.03588492423295975, 0.010577034205198288, -0.04832099378108978, 0.01003263145685196, 0.053101398050785065, 0.044299907982349396, -0.05471157655119896, 0.03605606034398079, -0.00431837746873498, 0.0028001938480883837, 0.029549971222877502, -0.008374469354748726, -0.018218794837594032, -0.011144796386361122, -0.0057035814970731735, 0.036100834608078, 0.02491556480526924, 0.04955890029668808, -0.042157817631959915, -0.006841251626610756, -0.023959338665008545, -0.01112859882414341, -0.01550301257520914, -0.019066430628299713, -0.009600162506103516, -0.048034653067588806, 0.03750910237431526, -0.01633019745349884, -0.00695768604055047, -0.01566299982368946, 0.046933360397815704, 0.08312524110078812, 0.01255232933908701, -0.05541214346885681, 0.03907915949821472, -0.02809900790452957, -0.06851670145988464, 0.04574422538280487, 0.02682792954146862, 0.01029303576797247, -0.0843420922756195, 0.03877392038702965, 0.03841573745012283, -0.02384467050433159, 0.042582958936691284, 0.0023687337525188923, 0.03597230091691017, -0.016438543796539307, -0.05389350652694702, -0.09323036670684814, 0.032025985419750214, -0.016060972586274147, 0.00500365300104022, -0.04138626530766487, 0.007242363877594471, -0.022156434133648872, 0.06803259253501892, -0.0003649693098850548, 0.04475141316652298, 0.03137800469994545, 0.034425657242536545, 0.022255253046751022, -0.03900653123855591, -0.0043603298254311085, -0.049229368567466736, -0.03265443071722984, -0.011550524272024632, -0.07346221804618835, 0.03877640515565872, 0.0040970672853291035, 0.00882739294320345, 0.035104963928461075, 0.01711583137512207, 0.03255682811141014, -0.0122758774086833, 0.03347228467464447, 0.0036102847661823034, -0.04970773681998253, 0.04755280166864395, -0.009146103635430336, 0.02058759145438671, 0.021741650998592377, -0.02326376922428608, 0.03901953622698784, -0.0024542922619730234, 0.07493516802787781, 0.00739333126693964, -0.015132470987737179, 0.05044286698102951, -0.024288538843393326, 0.025180881842970848, 0.01676861010491848, -0.05317765101790428, -0.01699901930987835, -0.028426554054021835, -0.04323599115014076, 0.031211966648697853, 0.03204959258437157, -0.030478142201900482, -0.019427664577960968, 0.025852283462882042, -0.06088808923959732, -0.03946659713983536, -0.06391032040119171, 0.007047770544886589, 0.02871050499379635, -0.013550246134400368, 0.028198931366205215, -0.030277159065008163, 0.01700625754892826, 0.0024951575323939323, -0.04241322726011276, -0.019582053646445274, -0.009505879133939743, 0.0397268682718277, -0.03625568002462387, 0.02508191205561161, 0.0049598184414207935, 0.06582918763160706, -0.00441506365314126, 0.05228380113840103, -0.030082937330007553, -0.048117101192474365, 0.013174597173929214, -0.042432766407728195, 0.06245271861553192, -0.03280394524335861, -0.0035718739964067936, 0.012490923516452312, -0.02872319519519806, -0.03427543118596077, 0.011168266646564007, -0.046692367643117905, 0.04491796717047691, 0.053051263093948364, -0.03161533549427986, -0.010067888535559177, 0.019533073529601097, 0.023961864411830902, -0.0319918617606163, -0.0133671835064888, -0.014516843482851982, -0.035168278962373734, 0.019742202013731003, -0.01057395152747631, 0.035917773842811584, -0.023034099489450455, 0.024281052872538567, 0.03910096734762192, 0.03689902275800705, 0.011496531777083874, 0.012413508258759975, 0.023810287937521935, -0.001527345972135663, 0.009895754978060722, 0.021989421918988228, 0.010868716053664684, 0.016582423821091652, 0.020709117874503136, -0.030158840119838715, 0.012311938218772411, -0.010569953359663486, 0.015333806164562702, 0.006922416854649782, 0.00010994925105478615, 0.022164447233080864, -0.016007311642169952, -0.00900795217603445, 0.060610026121139526, -0.03331722319126129, 0.044726092368364334, 0.014698527753353119, 0.020316002890467644, -0.0386369414627552, -0.010669464245438576, -0.008083319291472435, 0.01615086756646633, 0.0502961166203022, -0.048963308334350586, 0.026398763060569763, 0.028298648074269295, 0.007541895844042301, 0.031905751675367355, -0.008072194643318653, -0.03040269762277603, 0.007867494598031044, 0.002855794969946146, 0.044511087238788605, -0.028647102415561676, 0.031212856993079185, 0.0018706981791183352, 0.0032190768979489803, 0.009053114801645279, 0.013387885875999928, 0.03468511626124382, 0.029898924753069878, -0.052277784794569016, -0.019118525087833405, -0.02069966308772564, -0.027776340022683144, 0.046464305371046066, -0.0061102877371013165, -0.021019961684942245, 0.048331595957279205, -0.01689537987112999, -0.04953302443027496, -0.008928926661610603, -0.025522414594888687, 0.021116115152835846, -0.02387944981455803, 0.003572572488337755, 0.01957845315337181, -0.008156624622642994, -0.0185635294765234, -0.005864520091563463, -0.050990305840969086, -0.017680225893855095, 0.007010996341705322, 0.0014476978685706854, -0.0035929311998188496, -0.016366302967071533, -0.005471466109156609, 0.01696544699370861, -0.02795254811644554, -0.0030120350420475006, -0.06024456396698952, -0.0700298622250557, -0.015792666003108025, 0.020502863451838493, 0.03574748337268829, -0.004021805245429277, -0.006088719703257084, 0.029329512268304825, -0.0003396641695871949, -0.020252855494618416, -0.02034207247197628, -0.03452650085091591, -0.0013182603288441896, -0.04011620953679085, 0.05163125693798065, 0.008749861270189285, -0.0096290810033679, 0.018556607887148857, -0.0010120987426489592, 0.02000368945300579, 0.08361458778381348, -0.00991070456802845, 0.004730645567178726, 0.014540117233991623, -0.03603917360305786, -0.029408259317278862, 0.011629275046288967, 0.0016948587726801634, -0.02555561065673828, -0.013310408219695091, -0.011258157901465893, 0.01611403562128544, -0.020937999710440636, -0.021419046446681023, 0.025668339803814888, -0.01209202129393816, 0.029013490304350853, -0.05565430596470833, -0.017404230311512947, -0.00504674855619669, -0.04139166325330734, -0.048607684671878815, -0.013598265126347542, 0.019824158400297165, -0.013830435462296009, 0.0362657867372036, 0.01796617917716503, 0.03266093134880066, 0.04238908365368843, 0.01096645463258028, -0.036836981773376465, -0.0177512988448143, 0.015570533461868763, -0.04705183580517769, 0.003097336972132325, 0.0032949221786111593, 0.002283134264871478, 0.018451811745762825, -0.014250105246901512, -0.04303893819451332, -0.015588443726301193, -0.06807416677474976, -0.016489870846271515, -0.037599846720695496, 0.04185095056891441, 0.0038940436206758022, 0.009595850482583046, 0.010157323442399502, -0.01294651161879301, -0.004040151368826628, -0.019530726596713066, -0.05406934395432472, 0.005845064762979746, -0.0156340803951025, -0.022217124700546265, 0.024099761620163918, -0.03702140599489212, 0.02481335774064064, -0.006827344186604023, 0.0012146165827289224, 0.0036080239806324244, -0.003965604584664106, -0.030146459117531776, -0.01706717163324356, 0.002145039616152644, -0.021814020350575447, -0.02987109124660492, 0.007576636504381895, -0.013493659906089306, -0.020391516387462616, 0.00046114521683193743, -0.0044638547115027905, -0.05271902680397034, -0.004588264040648937, -0.04895547404885292, -0.007700861431658268, 0.003384592942893505, 0.027510682120919228, 0.014310612343251705, 0.02590041048824787, -0.036235060542821884, 0.0032455180771648884, 0.015374061651527882, 0.058488477021455765, 0.03075225278735161, 0.0016017807647585869, -0.02600475586950779, -0.003426048904657364, -0.046317730098962784, 0.04688024893403053, 0.018737493082880974, 0.018139181658625603, -0.000024618999304948375, 0.03879701346158981, 0.041742198169231415, -0.049387313425540924, 0.008873159997165203, 0.07783536612987518, 0.02531176619231701, -0.015757737681269646, -0.01960383914411068, 0.010141354985535145, 0.01107704732567072, 0.02923714928328991, 0.004008283838629723, 0.0036648635286837816, -0.011077350936830044, -0.004875800106674433, 0.05089528486132622, -0.02021217532455921, -0.05795950070023537, 0.04579697921872139, 0.0417230986058712, 0.047246385365724564, -0.017425382509827614, -0.002743456745520234, 0.0306918416172266, 0.039492782205343246, 0.030705636367201805, 0.04387418180704117, -0.0029571070335805416, -0.10183767974376678, 0.025228140875697136, 0.015459676273167133, 0.01401051040738821, -0.03504183515906334, -0.035350650548934937, -0.034821946173906326, 0.008558441884815693, 0.02048642560839653, -0.022630145773291588, 0.014037096872925758, -0.01258348859846592, 0.021571718156337738, -0.01559196226298809, -0.052592333406209946, -0.024286454543471336, 0.037689585238695145, 0.010701574385166168, 0.03786816447973251, -0.008457556366920471, -0.0006018415442667902, -0.03206630051136017, 0.07172728329896927, 0.029336392879486084, 0.03461938723921776, 0.008015679195523262, -0.021474454551935196, 0.03211791813373566, 0.010787014849483967, -0.016061194241046906, -0.04694269225001335, 0.03454264998435974, -0.002433388726785779, 0.014817016199231148, 0.042211346328258514, -0.009472898207604885, -0.03985818102955818, -0.0048507931642234325, 0.025431890040636063, 0.048330824822187424, 0.006093927659094334, -0.03941959887742996, 0.03024166263639927, 0.005646829959005117, 0.020294582471251488, 0.02269207313656807, 0.01406104676425457, -0.02199171856045723, 0.07002542912960052, -0.02536412514746189, 0.03918647766113281, -0.03542743995785713, -0.037135377526283264, -0.027993550524115562, -0.028782589361071587, 0.009165825322270393, -0.009066637605428696, 0.023788444697856903, 0.01468328945338726, -0.02585524134337902, -0.022736601531505585, -0.02635803259909153, 0.016021616756916046, 0.007932950742542744, 0.0004652633215300739, -0.006044639740139246, 0.05239451304078102, -0.018499908968806267, -0.04527343064546585, -0.0038531082682311535, -0.023083627223968506, 0.04009507969021797, 0.0014553293585777283, 0.002335321856662631, -0.0005463298293761909, -0.0278254933655262, -0.05487332120537758, 0.0026549287140369415, -0.006090858485549688, 0.03669183328747749, -0.03420286998152733, 0.020423879846930504, -0.03206716850399971, -0.04389442503452301, 0.018639130517840385, 0.04176526144146919, -0.024522431194782257, 0.03516684100031853, -0.011160225607454777, 0.027324695140123367, -0.02521379664540291, -0.023554673418402672, -0.07783263176679611, -0.03910954296588898, -0.011271130293607712, 0.015463252551853657, -0.011213351972401142, -0.023510491475462914, 0.02350681647658348, -0.03640391677618027, -0.032810747623443604, 0.013258222490549088, 0.05121292173862457, -0.004058833234012127, -0.019580917432904243, -0.016368772834539413, 0.031051525846123695, 0.06601624935865402, -0.031614046543836594, -0.007412833161652088, 0.023196646943688393, -0.04836339130997658, -0.006612274795770645, -0.04285261780023575, -0.012495588511228561, -0.017544375732541084, 0.026225801557302475, -0.04486464336514473, -0.009442138485610485, 0.009867535904049873, -0.017829405143857002, 0.02835031785070896, 0.03848981857299805, -0.038163285702466965, 0.016832459717988968, -0.026893040165305138, 0.05091124773025513, -0.06014103442430496, 0.003700125264003873, 0.03375515341758728, 0.03923260048031807, -0.0013843439519405365, -0.008607741445302963, 0.025390347465872765, -0.026606682687997818, -0.06229327991604805, 0.02001655288040638, 0.02713748998939991, -0.0021754817571491003, 0.0153372623026371, -0.012503081001341343, -0.011638198047876358, 0.08942262828350067, -0.000053117633797228336, -0.038257699459791183, 0.0037817922420799732, -0.006572862155735493, -0.013510624878108501, -0.036972109228372574, -0.0322788804769516, 0.01949194259941578, 0.019636988639831543, 0.01569097302854061, 0.028016051277518272, 0.05519499257206917, -0.007831692695617676, -0.020530277863144875, -0.026006244122982025, 0.016277840360999107, 0.03692682832479477, -0.02104155160486698, 0.042208340018987656, 0.024831976741552353, -0.04750755801796913, 0.01561491098254919, 0.015023153275251389, 0.028426077216863632, 0.041883811354637146, 0.000015390902262879536, 0.026047375053167343, 0.027398601174354553, -0.0012802401324734092, -0.033768076449632645, 0.010798639617860317, -0.04485653340816498, -0.006921644788235426, -0.027272965759038925, 0.009722222574055195, 0.013030982576310635, 0.07998735457658768, -0.011434130370616913, -0.006827878300100565, -0.0504036545753479, -0.03707883134484291, 0.023732617497444153, 0.03931286185979843, 0.005464667454361916, 0.037423957139253616, 0.005932615604251623, 0.05868934094905853, 0.030077900737524033, 0.037258122116327286, -0.022517919540405273, -0.05654245615005493, -0.019967207685112953, -0.039144087582826614, -0.004211911465972662, 0.022803205996751785, -0.02155035361647606, -0.02368512749671936, 0.020507248118519783, -0.03578808531165123, -0.029258985072374344, -0.04819389432668686, 0.04878221079707146, -0.016300389543175697, 0.06941603869199753, 0.009210564196109772, 0.02033933438360691, -0.01799205131828785, -0.010625138878822327, 0.11173290014266968, 0.07739658653736115, 0.05790602043271065, -0.06601189076900482, 0.010692412964999676, 0.020364485681056976, -0.03613702952861786, -0.04446035251021385, 0.010525506921112537, 0.0017547516617923975, -0.012425383552908897, 0.04044818878173828, 0.06059608235955238, 0.013571533374488354, 0.004589268937706947, 0.03670461103320122, -0.0031665023416280746, -0.0038902461528778076, 0.005638930015265942, 0.0012299943482503295, 0.024283481761813164, -0.026422645896673203, -0.07373593747615814, -0.0025108610279858112, -0.025305861607193947, -0.007786549162119627, -0.01669415459036827, -0.006485325284302235, -0.012246917933225632, 0.01870492845773697, -0.03103007934987545, -0.009054645895957947, 0.028066033497452736, -0.0018441505962982774, -0.026557333767414093, -0.014805908314883709, 0.02239619381725788, 0.002161548240110278, 0.02024180442094803, 0.04444774240255356, -0.02555425651371479, -0.002349043032154441, 0.01031770370900631, -0.014090842567384243, -0.015731383115053177, -0.022812947630882263, -0.034209657460451126, 0.040446970611810684, -0.006088748574256897, -0.036986250430345535, -0.004073415417224169, -0.0036295391619205475, 0.012645172886550426, -0.018342802301049232, -0.0002759778581093997, 0.004378060810267925, 0.00514948321506381, -0.02558000572025776, 0.002059942577034235, -0.014681265689432621, -0.004012030083686113, 0.00473638903349638, 0.02955463156104088, 0.008037489838898182, -0.024029714986681938, 0.024306656792759895, -0.015010994859039783, 0.06626910716295242, -0.0019683679565787315, -0.029144657775759697, 0.004828526172786951, -0.034813687205314636, -0.02914580889046192, -0.03705477714538574, 0.013080663979053497, 0.06387808918952942, 0.021238386631011963, -0.01575901173055172, 0.016297949478030205, -0.012495934031903744, -0.022550417110323906, 0.006203120574355125, -0.038061510771512985, 0.010738338343799114, -0.03732359781861305, 0.008326626382768154, 0.015038375742733479, 0.024183545261621475, -0.0061168186366558075, 0.035277701914310455, -0.0309271402657032, 0.06981069594621658, -0.00232102838344872, -0.06046879664063454, 0.015607488341629505, -0.03686996549367905, -0.045847322791814804, -0.0031772830989211798, -0.022668933495879173, 0.024802032858133316, -0.0056068915873765945, 0.01934713125228882, 0.004233102314174175, 0.05029350146651268, 0.02348237670958042, 0.03469310700893402, 0.08162649720907211, -0.06581351161003113, -0.005867431405931711, -0.008941606618463993, 0.009699844755232334, -0.007917042821645737, -0.03256317973136902, -0.0316835418343544, -0.017183339223265648, -0.0026454401668161154, -0.038455843925476074, -0.051520347595214844, 0.0034908370580524206, -0.02823825553059578, 0.004831507336348295, -0.01759168691933155, -0.0004629130125977099, -0.05331847071647644, 0.034789539873600006, 0.0026942130643874407, -0.017325984314084053, 0.027873074635863304, 0.047032538801431656, -0.011376038193702698, 0.012610279023647308, 0.02761029452085495, 0.0034069844987243414, 0.025119930505752563, 0.008742897771298885, 0.025964755564928055, 0.0033663809299468994, 0.03233969211578369, -0.02813366800546646, -0.0014323742361739278, -0.0074997395277023315, -0.010193889029324055, -0.04147036373615265, 0.000670103298034519, -0.02521633356809616, 0.038898490369319916, 0.053161777555942535, -0.01781170628964901, -0.035203784704208374, 0.06442191451787949, -0.047055963426828384, -0.04000099375844002, 0.01163465715944767, 0.017980795353651047, 0.006623833440244198, 0.023070456460118294, 0.005582770332694054, 0.027260802686214447, -0.019454382359981537, 0.05286945775151253, 0.05844470486044884, 0.016554785892367363, -0.002878712024539709, 0.008383139967918396, 0.005903622135519981, 0.0329011008143425, -0.005231573712080717, -0.010708541609346867, 0.04039476439356804, 0.039585988968610764, -0.025960000231862068, -0.008405977860093117, -0.01029970683157444, 0.01816082000732422, -0.06927932053804398, -0.027715163305401802, 0.016925562173128128, 0.000660598510876298, 0.03149294853210449, -0.03273196890950203, -0.0043041883036494255, -0.01343289203941822, -0.05164039507508278, -0.012508678250014782, -0.015841076150536537, -0.012989884242415428, -0.047265853732824326, -0.004964577965438366, -0.005371416453272104, 0.0381503701210022, 0.04248567298054695, -0.006675494834780693, -0.0025646244175732136, 0.061745237559080124, -0.010806601494550705, -0.04350251331925392, -0.005549902096390724, -0.006177741102874279, 0.009891221299767494, -0.05996433272957802, 0.018246959894895554, -0.06936924904584885, -0.06758693605661392, 0.03310398757457733, -0.023470722138881683, 0.019318899139761925, -0.011381193064153194, 0.03840291500091553, 0.016038216650485992, 0.026588989421725273, 0.056950055062770844, 0.01243085041642189, 0.008195082657039165, 0.010722031816840172, 0.027506977319717407, 0.01692410558462143, -0.013714276254177094, 0.02690262719988823, -0.0050818040035665035, -0.016224270686507225, -0.01851843297481537, -0.0084148608148098, 0.017842568457126617, 0.03977113217115402, 0.016291441395878792, -0.01247949618846178, 0.004139671102166176, 0.03499507158994675, 0.010462578386068344, -0.014039088040590286, -0.0028076546732336283, 0.03655213117599487, 0.03139488771557808, 0.004728325176984072, -0.004207235295325518, -0.020079897716641426, -0.04411710426211357, 0.007624431978911161, 0.031185969710350037, -0.0040363953448832035, -0.07612992078065872, 0.0003949334204662591, 0.026769831776618958, -0.020674511790275574, -0.059691742062568665, 0.015974147245287895, -0.011423860676586628, 0.03340943157672882, -0.0017072187038138509, -0.010910162702202797, 0.015508076176047325, -0.01575336419045925, -0.00038032399606890976, -0.08653958141803741, 0.043103136122226715, 0.03231286257505417, 0.007291075773537159, -0.022643527016043663, -0.034668177366256714, -0.025320593267679214, 0.006493675522506237, 0.01470276154577732, -0.031186850741505623, -0.0019146994454786181, 0.007548271678388119, 0.020472373813390732, -0.024792619049549103, -0.036077409982681274, 0.0714040994644165, -0.0007505123503506184, -0.019616572186350822, -0.017587173730134964, 0.003431576071307063, 0.024595411494374275, -0.03894517198204994, 0.024713687598705292, -0.042048048228025436, 0.004958903882652521, 0.04435935989022255, -0.02121315896511078, 0.01888713240623474, 0.0022228106390684843, -0.0017391955479979515, 0.036376193165779114, 0.008635475300252438, 0.0001858781324699521, 0.029052376747131348, -0.0407237634062767, -0.04622902721166611, 0.04346219822764397, -0.026758786290884018, -0.010480177588760853, -0.01662602461874485, 0.03756943717598915, -0.02533355914056301, -0.055737078189849854, 0.046140752732753754, 0.013896116055548191, -0.04037783667445183, 0.03350839763879776, 0.04662005230784416, 0.030334563925862312, 0.034807611256837845, 0.022749921306967735, 0.013122979551553726, 0.021921832114458084, -0.017816876992583275, 0.012745415791869164, 0.015070748515427113, 0.0586547888815403, -0.0028314320370554924, 0.01992672309279442, 0.0033582616597414017, -0.00676232622936368, 0.018124207854270935, -0.04150104522705078, 0.04789016395807266, -0.04167098551988602, -0.02096131630241871, -0.006706110201776028, 0.02229873277246952, 0.03355154022574425, -0.0021247058175504208, 0.01069608237594366, 0.07527492940425873, -0.04727073758840561, -0.018572043627500534, -0.010009286925196648, -0.017556287348270416, -0.010575136169791222, -0.0005480848485603929, -0.0027262941002845764, 0.05333785340189934, -0.008536109700798988, -0.017566367983818054, -0.011393094435334206, -0.016841141507029533, -0.0006915268604643643, -0.01636718399822712, 0.010943965055048466, -0.023199794813990593, 0.01742139458656311, -0.015498596243560314, -0.009272187948226929, -0.031234245747327805, -0.054807327687740326, 0.02273738570511341, 0.013426600955426693, -0.007818721234798431, -0.02366708219051361, -0.06959709525108337, -0.0010335956467315555, 0.023134354501962662, -0.057970475405454636, -0.028772452846169472, -0.051634129136800766, 0.033607788383960724, -0.02616814710199833, 0.05788850039243698 ]
<p>I start with a vector of random numbers sampled from a normal distribution:</p> <pre><code>R&lt;-rnorm(100, mean=0, sd=30) </code></pre> <p>I would now like to create 3 variables that are correlated with each other with a pre-specified correlation. In addition I would like to have these three variables correlated with <code>R</code> with a pre-specified correlation.</p> <p>For example <code>A</code>, <code>B</code>, <code>C</code> would have correlation 0.7 with each other, and <code>A</code>, <code>B</code>, <code>C</code> would have correlation 0.6 with <code>R</code>.</p> <p>I.e. I am looking for the following covariance matrix:</p> <pre><code> R A B C R 1 .6 .6 .6 A .6 1 .7 .7 B .6 .7 1 .7 C .6 .7 .7 1 </code></pre> <p>How can this be done in R?</p>
49,933
[ -0.034635029733181, 0.014049897901713848, 0.0012511960230767727, -0.009637271985411644, 0.006808818783611059, -0.013060560449957848, -0.03037489578127861, -0.031722214072942734, 0.05451493710279465, -0.038430631160736084, 0.01634499989449978, 0.04678870365023613, 0.04976296052336693, 0.037271615117788315, 0.0651271641254425, -0.010116641409695148, 0.023832419887185097, -0.017092736437916756, -0.011481823399662971, -0.03761138767004013, -0.007088782731443644, 0.007368789985775948, 0.043207649141550064, 0.0011834964388981462, 0.00727720046415925, 0.052825551480054855, 0.02352166175842285, -0.011736320331692696, 0.021306663751602173, 0.044323600828647614, -0.0702609196305275, -0.034291185438632965, 0.008885247632861137, 0.05636299028992653, 0.020705070346593857, 0.0000653614551993087, -0.022176183760166168, -0.0033703504595905542, 0.00942592415958643, 0.006747909355908632, -0.04004393890500069, -0.02842157892882824, 0.017613399773836136, 0.035549525171518326, 0.0021011526696383953, 0.0028770200442522764, -0.006145672872662544, -0.030129384249448776, 0.03481112793087959, -0.02025889977812767, 0.12009948492050171, 0.005307558923959732, 0.04492303356528282, 0.04351687431335449, -0.0186313446611166, -0.008305073715746403, 0.06938932836055756, 0.08068308234214783, 0.02534545212984085, -0.02460276521742344, 0.005405183881521225, -0.03687189146876335, -0.003471738426014781, -0.0020815690513700247, -0.06112886220216751, 0.004422491881996393, -0.020085487514734268, -0.007571721449494362, 0.04549814388155937, -0.043507061898708344, 0.019358616322278976, 0.027040230110287666, 0.02733592689037323, -0.01672220788896084, 0.017653530463576317, -0.042374808341264725, 0.0010270094498991966, -0.027913708239793777, 0.0317794568836689, 0.02237866073846817, 0.018979031592607498, 0.031313009560108185, -0.005893418099731207, 0.029216229915618896, 0.038072071969509125, 0.005312245339155197, 0.053367920219898224, -0.04099397361278534, 0.03525552153587341, 0.04038872569799423, -0.015011796727776527, 0.017540309578180313, 0.0479205921292305, 0.06255721300840378, -0.07070465385913849, 0.05732608214020729, -0.01181118469685316, 0.057193513959646225, 0.0059564425610005856, -0.011088300496339798, -0.034715209156274796, -0.036796510219573975, 0.0023841112852096558, 0.04832061007618904, -0.02610616385936737, -0.014995619654655457, -0.024764182046055794, 0.017994137480854988, -0.003475285368040204, -0.01994367316365242, -0.01383809931576252, -0.000551630393601954, -0.00579800782725215, -0.01625688187777996, 0.05653534457087517, -0.03321366757154465, -0.025898141786456108, -0.006395396776497364, 0.055490557104349136, 0.08041392266750336, 0.038398317992687225, 0.00899845827370882, 0.018225161358714104, -0.027153098955750465, -0.05935258790850639, 0.005568164400756359, 0.007135588210076094, 0.011751092970371246, -0.02795599400997162, 0.038848768919706345, -0.023457998409867287, -0.04902906343340874, 0.009075229987502098, -0.010925499722361565, 0.024384943768382072, 0.0019483042415231466, -0.1090928167104721, -0.03674059733748436, 0.029160261154174805, -0.04587358608841896, 0.004741494078189135, -0.06334579735994339, 0.017708465456962585, 0.014278971590101719, 0.05670193210244179, 0.012302727438509464, 0.024197902530431747, 0.005613543558865786, 0.025866180658340454, 0.008420049212872982, -0.030035216361284256, -0.012047357857227325, -0.021844152361154556, -0.031360726803541183, -0.008956070058047771, -0.05557120963931084, 0.011225585825741291, -0.00906979851424694, 0.004471551161259413, 0.003222488798201084, 0.010099508799612522, -0.024298982694745064, -0.002485011238604784, -0.01743963360786438, -0.011879795230925083, -0.005331729538738728, 0.030234601348638535, 0.015973465517163277, -0.00993554200977087, 0.015055445022881031, -0.04267607256770134, 0.004331876523792744, -0.004617579281330109, 0.05448838695883751, 0.0594467893242836, -0.02095804549753666, 0.0173779483884573, 0.025353146716952324, 0.037818584591150284, 0.01305922120809555, -0.028314705938100815, -0.019832605496048927, 0.029739050194621086, -0.025392308831214905, 0.036413054913282394, 0.024889077991247177, 0.017132481560111046, -0.010855133645236492, 0.009487642906606197, -0.023955119773745537, 0.003098635235801339, -0.08146686851978302, -0.00874463189393282, -0.01755804382264614, -0.0664624348282814, 0.018872622400522232, 0.04664160683751106, 0.04812142997980118, 0.02184118703007698, -0.056872643530368805, -0.039598409086465836, 0.003609796054661274, 0.05031109228730202, -0.019507693126797676, 0.008031905628740788, 0.05235113203525543, 0.06272845715284348, -0.017577052116394043, 0.041745319962501526, 0.008412952534854412, -0.019411936402320862, 0.010711316019296646, -0.021969342604279518, 0.0006943657645024359, -0.016645407304167747, 0.014508947730064392, 0.031161518767476082, 0.010622675530612469, -0.006459305994212627, 0.03615303337574005, -0.03057757206261158, 0.015495319850742817, 0.036855299025774, 0.03811895474791527, -0.00810393039137125, -0.0036201151087880135, 0.023044543340802193, 0.030231401324272156, -0.04493311420083046, 0.0004038706829305738, -0.05117293819785118, -0.008148103021085262, 0.03090144880115986, 0.04158683866262436, -0.0478765107691288, 0.015684545040130615, 0.0549282543361187, 0.026568148285150528, -0.0002162310411222279, 0.07303678244352341, -0.008547919802367687, -0.0019896593876183033, 0.00012459023855626583, -0.0068922145292162895, 0.04179566726088524, -0.00376080977730453, -0.02060241997241974, 0.022956842556595802, 0.035243287682533264, -0.00592389702796936, -0.02609180100262165, 0.0457521490752697, -0.020971179008483887, 0.00046430964721366763, -0.020214134827256203, -0.01237555406987667, 0.018917541950941086, -0.002125820377841592, -0.004593755584210157, 0.03312712535262108, 0.01638687774538994, -0.02869095653295517, 0.03772829845547676, -0.03103460930287838, -0.004268711432814598, 0.057425349950790405, -0.014770868234336376, -0.003361299866810441, 0.010774033144116402, -0.019887976348400116, -0.0037909364327788353, 0.0022731509525328875, 0.010118242353200912, -0.03566775843501091, 0.018023904412984848, 0.04561843350529671, 0.0038149759639054537, 0.040125902742147446, -0.028262581676244736, -0.048150695860385895, 0.011241784319281578, -0.006777709349989891, 0.024054503068327904, -0.016836045309901237, -0.057880155742168427, 0.023982705548405647, -0.020460495725274086, -0.024524938315153122, 0.0031727657187730074, -0.01214667595922947, -0.02570747584104538, 0.034956734627485275, -0.012585223652422428, -0.07674595713615417, 0.001429186319001019, 0.004414616152644157, 0.034742165356874466, -0.011402199976146221, -0.011998589150607586, 0.03375055268406868, 0.0014826057013124228, -0.07232727855443954, -0.010814350098371506, -0.06103198975324631, -0.0033027976751327515, -0.02275393344461918, -0.026233496144413948, 0.017610488459467888, -0.00821815524250269, 0.031414639204740524, 0.03253113105893135, -0.028308479115366936, -0.0020484619308263063, -0.05690810829401016, -0.03914756327867508, 0.012946325354278088, 0.01588992215692997, 0.002266951370984316, 0.0018511124653741717, 0.008618971332907677, 0.05305780842900276, 0.017513561993837357, -0.04639706760644913, -0.05365214869379997, -0.00594731979072094, -0.026878898963332176, -0.048058051615953445, 0.038238462060689926, 0.0055854469537734985, 0.012427783571183681, 0.009835243225097656, 0.015160628594458103, 0.006306258030235767, 0.052044935524463654, -0.01727347820997238, 0.010823586955666542, 0.016927074640989304, -0.016494624316692352, -0.02276388555765152, 0.04303404316306114, 0.0015973156550899148, -0.022251006215810776, 0.0015513611724600196, -0.010950334370136261, -0.019288195297122, -0.014023048803210258, -0.038670629262924194, -0.008560582995414734, -0.009324177168309689, 0.05147535353899002, -0.05031317472457886, -0.001491545350290835, 0.022335011512041092, -0.031333062797784805, -0.01006912812590599, 0.03516025468707085, 0.030701838433742523, -0.024061083793640137, -0.0007682049181312323, 0.0473858118057251, 0.012668485753238201, -0.02134367823600769, 0.008906292729079723, 0.011531096883118153, -0.02759742923080921, 0.014343935064971447, -0.036827266216278076, -0.027640584856271744, 0.05616125464439392, 0.009715954773128033, 0.010416016913950443, -0.0008227400248870254, -0.03203337639570236, 0.042266082018613815, -0.05861593410372734, 0.012097597122192383, -0.04161635413765907, 0.058112747967243195, 0.008818268775939941, 0.08621570467948914, 0.024001656100153923, -0.027748772874474525, 0.024297138676047325, -0.0005744653171859682, -0.05053737014532089, 0.04278351366519928, 0.007489528972655535, 0.018334494903683662, 0.009747556410729885, -0.030330274254083633, 0.031323980540037155, 0.005760516040027142, 0.013407830148935318, 0.010461789555847645, -0.012684057466685772, -0.018169797956943512, -0.0038026985712349415, -0.016820313408970833, -0.02293023094534874, -0.011595127172768116, 0.005659759510308504, 0.03508323058485985, -0.009337454102933407, 0.04908554628491402, 0.047605961561203, -0.0038971956819295883, -0.007329332642257214, -0.010534479282796383, -0.007553201634436846, 0.0013522054068744183, 0.04029106721282005, 0.05715996399521828, 0.029960233718156815, 0.005297315306961536, 0.005247220862656832, -0.02903599664568901, 0.04202725365757942, 0.06934748589992523, -0.0029205165337771177, 0.006533856503665447, -0.03364161029458046, 0.007650106213986874, 0.02152908407151699, -0.00040528608951717615, -0.01099967397749424, -0.019099337980151176, 0.05325940251350403, 0.044053494930267334, -0.05364839732646942, 0.02602090872824192, 0.08538053929805756, 0.04241972044110298, -0.020122181624174118, -0.0177382230758667, -0.008429699577391148, 0.00127079535741359, -0.009601574391126633, 0.025692168623209, 0.013953507877886295, -0.02167888917028904, 0.019698917865753174, 0.026238664984703064, -0.03527144715189934, 0.008237004280090332, -0.0013435406144708395, 0.02414996176958084, 0.06514978408813477, -0.009723186492919922, -0.03701299801468849, -0.04612991586327553, 0.045566756278276443, 0.015208788216114044, 0.01878497190773487, -0.018783291801810265, -0.07104519754648209, 0.04488927870988846, 0.031255993992090225, 0.0474027544260025, -0.04216499999165535, -0.02649681642651558, -0.021440694108605385, -0.03232696279883385, 0.06229298189282417, -0.06270558387041092, 0.01086331531405449, -0.02669268287718296, -0.013256378471851349, -0.005931456107646227, -0.02504371665418148, -0.06515480577945709, 0.014896384440362453, -0.04485316947102547, 0.010710201226174831, -0.020424887537956238, -0.0563693605363369, -0.0188139695674181, -0.009943008422851562, 0.048679325729608536, 0.08525054901838303, -0.02128511108458042, -0.0059230513870716095, -0.0061917975544929504, 0.031507398933172226, 0.015676964074373245, -0.03108382783830166, 0.03268237039446831, 0.0017626896733418107, -0.02270524762570858, 0.06715722382068634, -0.03361622616648674, -0.010330223478376865, -0.012583032250404358, 0.017757002264261246, -0.002642077626660466, 0.024508550763130188, 0.01562122069299221, 0.051378604024648666, 0.027366312220692635, 0.0012401604326441884, 0.0392615981400013, 0.011764289811253548, -0.01035346370190382, -0.018197661265730858, -0.05074824020266533, 0.014220519922673702, -0.008475275710225105, -0.014092735946178436, -0.05251814424991608, -0.018124770373106003, -0.008942007087171078, 0.015820007771253586, 0.012279454618692398, 0.019971583038568497, -0.05978555977344513, 0.0066591426730155945, 0.017924083396792412, 0.039542537182569504, -0.05097595602273941, -0.022077476605772972, 0.02404569275677204, -0.017383426427841187, -0.0003828243352472782, -0.030790964141488075, 0.010108551010489464, -0.012036089785397053, -0.005582268349826336, 0.015949947759509087, -0.05919220298528671, 0.0011353703448548913, -0.015294003300368786, -0.006001047324389219, -0.0025772899389266968, -0.039218831807374954, 0.020497474819421768, 0.022392136976122856, 0.08045549690723419, 0.007295181509107351, -0.06412491202354431, 0.004487837199121714, 0.05364543944597244, -0.022305242717266083, 0.003958956804126501, -0.028126129880547523, 0.04616425558924675, -0.019175512716174126, 0.014994848519563675, -0.045202478766441345, -0.045578524470329285, -0.000224911913392134, -0.004326659720391035, 0.008195766247808933, -0.05167551711201668, -0.00343082076869905, -0.036507055163383484, 0.011363004334270954, -0.05372446030378342, 0.04134698584675789, -0.011051257140934467, 0.00154744868632406, -0.010784098878502846, 0.015793118625879288, 0.059278737753629684, -0.009407349862158298, -0.011252318508923054, 0.0514342226088047, 0.0013581044040620327, -0.020227031782269478, 0.012919465079903603, -0.0057023377157747746, -0.031091684475541115, -0.006769805680960417, -0.028653297573328018, 0.008944189175963402, 0.06531134992837906, -0.005046286154538393, -0.021983595564961433, -0.017975760623812675, 0.002819840796291828, -0.005232095718383789, -0.07067959010601044, 0.007862200029194355, -0.007261493243277073, -0.010979874059557915, -0.027315502986311913, 0.009238753467798233, -0.04533323273062706, -0.010778413154184818, 0.03900459036231041, 0.001201567705720663, -0.005408447235822678, 0.013229689560830593, 0.0725926086306572, -0.0030946042388677597, 0.018828781321644783, -0.026854362338781357, 0.00850224681198597, 0.012376422062516212, 0.005264764651656151, 0.015057695098221302, 0.020123817026615143, 0.00035275230766274035, -0.03690780699253082, -0.04694380611181259, -0.03168470785021782, -0.006362139713019133, 0.056179966777563095, -0.04357708990573883, 0.04987037181854248, 0.07455209642648697, -0.013761743903160095, -0.008486789651215076, 0.01621866039931774, -0.02950173243880272, -0.0013020072365179658, 0.026943953707814217, 0.07155664265155792, -0.02072286792099476, -0.01897166483104229, 0.01104210689663887, 0.013623105362057686, 0.0323588028550148, 0.05609290674328804, -0.013826091773808002, 0.009767355397343636, 0.019898412749171257, 0.0026497223880141973, -0.027210302650928497, 0.04229496419429779, -0.011117886751890182, 0.020903147757053375, -0.0023764779325574636, -0.04902704060077667, 0.018671277910470963, 0.005758142098784447, -0.05646771937608719, -0.03036237135529518, -0.03757856786251068, -0.034761037677526474, 0.004930928815156221, 0.03946089372038841, -0.047295305877923965, -0.004003212787210941, 0.01668698340654373, 0.03375421091914177, -0.023014036938548088, 0.0517357736825943, -0.038505472242832184, -0.10044685751199722, -0.047666795551776886, -0.03700204938650131, -0.0018175584264099598, 0.058848343789577484, 0.03514134883880615, -0.02238965779542923, 0.01454531867057085, -0.017336981371045113, 0.01157741155475378, 0.0015995922731235623, 0.028698738664388657, -0.0073306625708937645, 0.0795779749751091, 0.020755203440785408, 0.017093470320105553, 0.02090161293745041, -0.016357403248548508, 0.10083884745836258, 0.0656622052192688, 0.038170550018548965, -0.09227079898118973, 0.008923452347517014, 0.018490685150027275, -0.020495852455496788, -0.023570731282234192, 0.026480332016944885, -0.018146390095353127, 0.011828471906483173, 0.03896987438201904, 0.020327121019363403, 0.025234604254364967, 0.03795648366212845, 0.038727935403585434, -0.023709705099463463, -0.028593143448233604, -0.020677397027611732, 0.008637353777885437, 0.015977663919329643, -0.028289752081036568, -0.06635433435440063, -0.004846194759011269, -0.004721206147223711, -0.03201495110988617, -0.03537861630320549, 0.0034901141189038754, 0.010029559955000877, 0.017977502197027206, -0.0019383638864383101, 0.021280182525515556, 0.010842358693480492, 0.03162742033600807, 0.0022377867717295885, -0.0024743208196014166, 0.04500728100538254, -0.019873393699526787, 0.018062181770801544, -0.0033261124044656754, -0.0010483328951522708, 0.00637719314545393, -0.02241561934351921, -0.007987681776285172, -0.03696008771657944, -0.021379588171839714, -0.011238054372370243, 0.04682503640651703, -0.02726966142654419, -0.023412197828292847, -0.031348224729299545, 0.011358474381268024, 0.017354020848870277, -0.013927945867180824, -0.01027230080217123, 0.03085886500775814, 0.018118856474757195, -0.051341988146305084, 0.03372945263981819, -0.033589668571949005, 0.004884567577391863, -0.025274865329265594, 0.04521654173731804, -0.0038738115690648556, -0.038624342530965805, 0.01959742233157158, -0.09489382058382034, 0.07905104011297226, -0.015491138212382793, 0.00439018290489912, 0.017908578738570213, -0.01062845904380083, -0.037261202931404114, -0.011976133100688457, 0.01761164702475071, 0.00950171984732151, 0.030086208134889603, -0.0007701783906668425, 0.011426576413214207, -0.0025506422389298677, -0.0190032459795475, 0.0007749315700493753, -0.03138802573084831, -0.012730589136481285, -0.027106892317533493, 0.010753665119409561, 0.052178286015987396, 0.045953843742609024, 0.014079783111810684, -0.017401237040758133, -0.012026747688651085, 0.039837002754211426, 0.01310392003506422, -0.039733462035655975, -0.0034371172077953815, -0.006361567880958319, -0.026458458974957466, 0.014446581713855267, -0.00953386165201664, 0.03570852801203728, 0.022614438086748123, 0.011241843923926353, -0.025270191952586174, 0.034396942704916, -0.023751920089125633, -0.01573808118700981, 0.04021379351615906, -0.02227635681629181, 0.020952722057700157, 0.010159213095903397, 0.009993601590394974, -0.016971474513411522, -0.006220262497663498, -0.01960056647658348, -0.04002843052148819, 0.016720427200198174, -0.02834984101355076, -0.04516606405377388, -0.010737750679254532, 0.002596817445009947, -0.007847877219319344, -0.04162140190601349, 0.0002957960241474211, -0.0526646226644516, -0.0043836552649736404, -0.008480533957481384, -0.017222244292497635, -0.02635735645890236, 0.0599224790930748, -0.025935115292668343, 0.00946937594562769, 0.023273587226867676, 0.02029069885611534, 0.02511017769575119, -0.007069580256938934, -0.014608426950871944, -0.0001836403098423034, 0.04630110785365105, -0.01881398819386959, -0.03705309331417084, 0.0027535450644791126, -0.053002987056970596, -0.0026203838642686605, -0.014430963434278965, 0.0002957504475489259, 0.03690570592880249, 0.014724585227668285, -0.011417108587920666, -0.014025479555130005, 0.05233875289559364, -0.003188924863934517, -0.000650332251098007, -0.025322478264570236, 0.0383501872420311, 0.015917902812361717, 0.003159811021760106, 0.0208906177431345, -0.02126806229352951, -0.006544969044625759, 0.01253130566328764, 0.055410418659448624, 0.0024275947362184525, 0.01809144951403141, 0.02473224699497223, 0.03573436290025711, 0.009851713664829731, -0.013881820254027843, -0.01807614229619503, 0.03144039958715439, 0.040782950818538666, -0.030914099887013435, 0.04342764616012573, 0.02440202236175537, 0.015615686774253845, -0.10065465420484543, -0.007659544236958027, 0.008692740462720394, -0.03969216346740723, 0.05533280223608017, -0.04230308532714844, -0.00628880737349391, 0.03677035868167877, -0.04405399411916733, 0.01827348954975605, -0.0069132642820477486, -0.019353670999407768, -0.0010456988820806146, 0.05174734443426132, -0.024682654067873955, 0.01848730258643627, 0.019645094871520996, 0.012031965889036655, 0.050634849816560745, 0.028280727565288544, 0.00578768877312541, -0.01746048778295517, -0.052392635494470596, -0.00951196439564228, 0.02252149023115635, -0.05860447138547897, -0.005363547243177891, -0.026716813445091248, -0.03777657076716423, 0.018210209906101227, -0.014343854039907455, 0.020201845094561577, 0.007507907692342997, 0.028714122250676155, -0.012087740935385227, 0.044276315718889236, 0.029554856941103935, -0.004245202522724867, -0.007273695431649685, -0.022445950657129288, 0.037666186690330505, 0.013911079615354538, -0.006311935372650623, -0.002548449207097292, 0.0033778699580579996, -0.0012521097669377923, -0.026422137394547462, 0.047230299562215805, -0.028998490422964096, -0.016338519752025604, -0.022487245500087738, -0.007623343262821436, 0.004162529483437538, -0.05829304829239845, -0.007345529273152351, -0.04680107906460762, -0.020728880539536476, 0.028911134228110313, 0.027316417545080185, -0.025674598291516304, 0.015967821702361107, -0.03746119514107704, -0.009087109938263893, 0.004518765490502119, 0.0140349380671978, 0.008731158450245857, -0.06094157695770264, -0.010698258876800537, 0.020512128248810768, -0.016530051827430725, -0.013867026194930077, -0.01611652597784996, -0.02664346992969513, 0.048848673701286316, -0.02053133025765419, 0.02314380556344986, 0.02756556123495102, 0.0033679003827273846, 0.017295531928539276, -0.060614075511693954, 0.04987441003322601, 0.0038835906889289618, -0.023041442036628723, -0.047311197966337204, 0.0004496028705034405, -0.04701516032218933, 0.03414271026849747, 0.043078288435935974, -0.0022462306078523397, 0.02703082747757435, -0.017214961349964142, 0.05843510851264, 0.015532039105892181, -0.0717504695057869, 0.04782870039343834, 0.0031712958589196205, -0.01859733648598194, -0.003914515487849712, -0.01075375359505415, 0.027368295937776566, -0.0212410818785429, -0.05159195885062218, -0.02496383525431156, -0.0038570864126086235, 0.013134684413671494, -0.03757549449801445, 0.004717558156698942, -0.021129531785845757, -0.025874312967061996, 0.025959182530641556, -0.00371941109187901, 0.01839531399309635, 0.048288244754076004, 0.01604296639561653, -0.0205119326710701, 0.023228690028190613, -0.060005076229572296, -0.04982655867934227, -0.006254245061427355, 0.018493065610527992, -0.026691898703575134, -0.08129480481147766, 0.015499146655201912, 0.004237313289195299, -0.04540199786424637, 0.004847743548452854, 0.04139002785086632, -0.0010582557879388332, 0.062096018344163895, -0.007437048014253378, -0.00796402245759964, -0.009849249385297298, -0.04426135495305061, -0.007790515199303627, 0.00636800192296505, 0.023873982951045036, -0.034108005464076996, -0.011533684097230434, 0.014995921403169632, -0.02757270634174347, 0.01780969649553299, -0.03894083946943283, 0.014566121622920036, -0.0053166672587394714, -0.005034024361521006, 0.024111270904541016, -0.007230762857943773, 0.042292531579732895, 0.0023381332866847515, -0.003062773495912552, 0.017659204080700874, -0.05125213786959648, 0.006558993365615606, -0.021547071635723114, 0.013420251198112965, -0.03587112948298454, 0.018540270626544952, -0.010722173377871513, 0.015824005007743835, 0.0011203852482140064, 0.012986941263079643, 0.010603836737573147, -0.017153209075331688, -0.002770510734990239, -0.03455625846982002, 0.02919667586684227, -0.02669861726462841, 0.01624603569507599, 0.002306159818544984, 0.009709310717880726, -0.020746402442455292, -0.03413495793938637, 0.0351250097155571, 0.02851109951734543, 0.024151155725121498, -0.059570327401161194, -0.0004830828111153096, 0.009544072672724724, 0.041712455451488495, -0.050496309995651245, -0.019195856526494026, -0.045186273753643036, 0.004037741106003523, -0.003161342116072774, 0.03378932923078537 ]
<p>Suppose you have a set of numbers $\{1,2,...,m\}$ where $m \ge 5$ . Now you randomly choose five of those elements with replacement, $\text{a}_1$ ... $\text{a}_5$.</p> <p>What is the distribution of max($\text{a}_1$,$\text{a}_2$,$\text{a}_3$,$\text{a}_4$,$\text{a}_5$)?</p>
37,325
[ -0.05798545479774475, -0.05205952003598213, -0.0012775026261806488, -0.006306622643023729, 0.050046488642692566, 0.03886405751109123, -0.0024001216515898705, -0.04085090011358261, 0.013370011933147907, -0.03429190814495087, 0.025085100904107094, -0.0009216222097165883, 0.026324976235628128, 0.027000317350029945, 0.02143295668065548, 0.010152679868042469, -0.017639292404055595, -0.018412696197628975, -0.0007027207757346332, 0.004475139081478119, 0.009847027249634266, 0.035813771188259125, 0.019757632166147232, -0.06844261288642883, -0.07038231939077377, 0.014251455664634705, 0.019846733659505844, -0.025892924517393112, 0.017061954364180565, 0.07608000189065933, -0.05529256910085678, -0.021025782451033592, 0.02442002482712269, 0.05192329362034798, 0.024838576093316078, 0.01667501963675022, -0.01431098859757185, -0.050209417939186096, 0.007613633293658495, 0.0040713646449148655, -0.029362883418798447, -0.039728861302137375, -0.00618748227134347, -0.03266587108373642, -0.013063670136034489, -0.003199630184099078, -0.027627240866422653, -0.04690449684858322, -0.005422006826847792, -0.03985337167978287, 0.09882327169179916, 0.02972784824669361, 0.0018277809722349048, -0.008760825730860233, -0.02115391567349434, -0.013955975882709026, 0.021582787856459618, 0.07565537840127945, 0.017420588061213493, -0.06887339800596237, 0.013167086988687515, -0.016690537333488464, 0.005029469728469849, -0.01819453574717045, -0.04361505061388016, 0.06689783185720444, -0.012603343464434147, 0.008968668058514595, 0.018161749467253685, 0.011017542332410812, 0.0008352903532795608, 0.05301332101225853, 0.06055315583944321, -0.009568561799824238, 0.01668730191886425, 0.015399587340652943, 0.06641647219657898, -0.02222275547683239, 0.03129474073648453, 0.044566698372364044, 0.029839519411325455, 0.0526789128780365, 0.034772999584674835, -0.0015422117430716753, 0.0013923137448728085, -0.03521144390106201, 0.07892687618732452, -0.005439576227217913, 0.02878653071820736, 0.020624004304409027, -0.04258091747760773, -0.029351765289902687, 0.03849954903125763, -0.022052491083741188, -0.08042949438095093, 0.029080741107463837, -0.04121267423033714, 0.022320318967103958, -0.01575060747563839, 0.006028099916875362, -0.00825958140194416, -0.049641840159893036, 0.019609874114394188, 0.053537387400865555, -0.021962661296129227, -0.020482884719967842, -0.02267291210591793, -0.024150395765900612, -0.024249622598290443, 0.00015311400056816638, -0.0000010385142559243832, 0.045790642499923706, -0.00830379594117403, 0.020312130451202393, 0.02141926810145378, 0.011129587888717651, 0.017981382086873055, -0.04627615213394165, 0.04744505137205124, 0.048054322600364685, 0.0014338367618620396, -0.030122822150588036, 0.012668486684560776, -0.0045678699389100075, 0.012169262394309044, 0.017193716019392014, 0.015167188830673695, 0.021603597328066826, -0.051828380674123764, 0.04789453372359276, -0.04324299842119217, 0.002158194314688444, 0.03377018868923187, 0.011329523287713528, 0.010921187698841095, -0.0440346896648407, -0.08089001476764679, -0.04382729157805443, 0.05719340220093727, -0.05775101110339165, -0.020247183740139008, -0.04982183873653412, 0.04388897493481636, 0.027503041550517082, 0.00439037848263979, 0.011675573885440826, 0.04877028614282608, -0.010176454670727253, 0.010516694746911526, 0.02968059852719307, -0.003636597655713558, 0.0006072241230867803, -0.019745534285902977, -0.0029412650037556887, 0.02010079100728035, -0.08952388167381287, 0.0013049995759502053, 0.028967713937163353, 0.011550858616828918, -0.021978996694087982, 0.0029345338698476553, 0.0007370355888269842, -0.014098710380494595, -0.023575441911816597, 0.034321293234825134, 0.005987114738672972, 0.07371141016483307, 0.04928482323884964, 0.021992653608322144, 0.028561437502503395, 0.012946633622050285, 0.03380541875958443, -0.02003764547407627, 0.0573207326233387, 0.02239460125565529, -0.0016985845286399126, 0.024626385420560837, -0.03952246904373169, 0.027631238102912903, 0.03609764948487282, -0.02235984615981579, 0.011113776825368404, -0.021294737234711647, 0.0047947559505701065, 0.02026493288576603, 0.02875545620918274, 0.004223098512738943, -0.0034287075977772474, 0.007635374553501606, -0.05750681087374687, -0.024230431765317917, -0.05218465253710747, 0.02639503963291645, -0.014927701093256474, 0.0011229380033910275, 0.006728946231305599, -0.001317842397838831, 0.013956556096673012, -0.008973225019872189, 0.013264956884086132, 0.0032592101488262415, -0.02125358395278454, -0.00105469417758286, -0.024722309783101082, -0.012927714735269547, 0.0882377177476883, 0.048026636242866516, -0.00906699150800705, 0.043450403958559036, -0.031624000519514084, -0.04280335456132889, -0.005048695020377636, -0.0052928440272808075, 0.033131927251815796, -0.0014109911862760782, -0.020850781351327896, 0.0030141379684209824, 0.010986711829900742, -0.015135002322494984, 0.03354978561401367, -0.05058677867054939, 0.03544479236006737, 0.06567514687776566, -0.012813514098525047, 0.013645317405462265, -0.018873611465096474, -0.0153999924659729, 0.0191024262458086, -0.010631183162331581, -0.003693603677675128, -0.06820954382419586, -0.013953587971627712, 0.038552455604076385, 0.025328615680336952, -0.0507570318877697, 0.03282587602734566, 0.0471370667219162, 0.032502610236406326, 0.020336506888270378, 0.006214132998138666, 0.0028675803914666176, -0.002201015828177333, 0.018642371520400047, 0.03203689306974411, 0.017176833003759384, -0.004052432253956795, 0.011852474883198738, -0.004351818934082985, 0.029714129865169525, 0.016215210780501366, 0.018575116991996765, 0.02060895599424839, -0.015128067694604397, 0.028893614187836647, -0.02886728011071682, -0.03987398371100426, 0.027299566194415092, -0.024484580382704735, -0.029107386246323586, 0.049798812717199326, 0.006295341998338699, 0.006548681296408176, 0.008298372849822044, -0.0462777242064476, 0.026416100561618805, 0.044565241783857346, -0.003745557041838765, -0.023269813507795334, 0.012430643662810326, 0.0024293134920299053, 0.008194508962333202, -0.02490389533340931, -0.021646184846758842, -0.013332763686776161, 0.011793815530836582, 0.016320938244462013, -0.026257842779159546, 0.03183353692293167, 0.00033573713153600693, -0.030329396948218346, -0.0017447305144742131, -0.006783727556467056, 0.024118462577462196, 0.011037060990929604, -0.059635285288095474, -0.012053784914314747, -0.03306824713945389, -0.0470285564661026, 0.032313622534275055, -0.012589247897267342, -0.004446810577064753, 0.02267664484679699, -0.019116001203656197, -0.04142646864056587, 0.0012036520056426525, -0.004800012335181236, 0.03685373812913895, -0.04093987122178078, 0.0023892091121524572, 0.07152965664863586, 0.003529441077262163, -0.04258786141872406, 0.00022939265181776136, -0.06765609234571457, -0.045995671302080154, -0.04430720955133438, 0.008676393888890743, 0.015170927159488201, -0.011150120757520199, 0.028523826971650124, 0.034043457359075546, 0.01944269798696041, 0.00509253516793251, -0.06727434694766998, -0.029906336218118668, -0.006011665798723698, -0.044726621359586716, 0.007923572324216366, -0.013149835169315338, -0.040402382612228394, 0.05451492592692375, 0.06508976221084595, -0.009584578685462475, 0.025829121470451355, 0.0008460772805847228, 0.022952858358621597, -0.03667374327778816, 0.04901322349905968, 0.037627190351486206, -0.017049139365553856, 0.04335153475403786, 0.036768294870853424, 0.03287981078028679, 0.04446514695882797, -0.03407370299100876, -0.011523238383233547, 0.018499936908483505, 0.006699147168546915, 0.009608590044081211, 0.026452751830220222, -0.023935463279485703, -0.019287830218672752, 0.008552653715014458, 0.0037046538200229406, 0.018321923911571503, -0.002192937070503831, -0.02527736686170101, 0.04558880999684334, -0.0435381717979908, 0.004152531735599041, -0.02482311986386776, 0.06934435665607452, 0.012790059670805931, -0.06421834975481033, 0.00481447484344244, 0.02058350294828415, 0.0181229617446661, -0.042716026306152344, -0.01397482305765152, 0.024149559438228607, 0.047550003975629807, -0.06533727794885635, -0.04613905027508736, -0.03736554831266403, -0.018521487712860107, -0.006649049464613199, 0.004248384851962328, -0.03287501633167267, 0.0012291815364733338, 0.013694324530661106, 0.031148109585046768, -0.0012592519633471966, -0.05708501115441322, 0.002010722178965807, -0.08342613279819489, 0.006701670121401548, -0.014187335968017578, 0.05291846767067909, 0.005432699806988239, 0.05474065989255905, 0.019236082211136818, 0.01829405315220356, 0.011676601134240627, 0.016704121604561806, -0.08888028562068939, 0.02494443580508232, -0.010548730380833149, 0.015463176183402538, -0.03554053232073784, -0.02677593007683754, 0.07371688634157181, -0.0036726901307702065, 0.0005587487830780447, -0.019222136586904526, 0.009560969658195972, -0.05432211607694626, -0.018306303769350052, -0.026258546859025955, -0.01742076687514782, 0.026883849874138832, 0.0003045538906008005, 0.0033951636869460344, -0.020223867148160934, 0.07000620663166046, 0.010372135788202286, -0.0023282566107809544, -0.009836551733314991, -0.011588730849325657, 0.02076403982937336, 0.02293427661061287, 0.014622191898524761, 0.04249665141105652, 0.05876179784536362, -0.0112012829631567, 0.017850246280431747, -0.008163252845406532, 0.0641721859574318, 0.04778248071670532, 0.02592029608786106, -0.003287964267656207, -0.04337478429079056, -0.005892819259315729, 0.025638164952397346, -0.007090404164046049, -0.00238807057030499, -0.029497232288122177, 0.055597808212041855, 0.011715471744537354, -0.045318495482206345, 0.01463751308619976, 0.020331723615527153, -0.006240630988031626, 0.005163236986845732, -0.03774671629071236, 0.01064001489430666, -0.019518624991178513, -0.003526541870087385, 0.010478758253157139, -0.0040033599361777306, -0.010815870948135853, 0.010290496051311493, 0.02789933979511261, 0.015655778348445892, -0.049552179872989655, -0.003021035809069872, 0.001043794909492135, 0.020280227065086365, 0.008379056118428707, -0.006641272455453873, 0.027628999203443527, -0.023358622565865517, 0.03121432475745678, -0.0027115431148558855, 0.0012404685840010643, -0.042244620621204376, 0.02389405481517315, 0.06109258905053139, 0.04214936122298241, -0.05102043226361275, 0.04712992534041405, -0.04125210642814636, 0.006404230836778879, 0.00647415965795517, -0.02931976318359375, 0.04501853510737419, -0.0012164252111688256, -0.0009637518087401986, -0.001695406623184681, -0.01144277025014162, -0.051934339106082916, 0.023490794003009796, 0.0006807397585362196, 0.04918377473950386, -0.03416683152318001, 0.017823077738285065, -0.050278205424547195, -0.011164894327521324, 0.015662027522921562, 0.07300805300474167, 0.003456271253526211, 0.005016292445361614, -0.001555388793349266, 0.024706562981009483, 0.003810109803453088, -0.04860445857048035, 0.018233664333820343, 0.010843179188668728, -0.025875287130475044, 0.04411096125841141, -0.05119897052645683, -0.06449083983898163, 0.026103390380740166, 0.01806686446070671, 0.011135821230709553, 0.023380914703011513, -0.02205413579940796, 0.03189922496676445, 0.05054361745715141, -0.011460051871836185, 0.0574183315038681, 0.009693917818367481, 0.011283406056463718, -0.0196066927164793, -0.007699188776314259, 0.030294407159090042, -0.0315885990858078, -0.023155109956860542, 0.002478234935551882, -0.015094341710209846, -0.037533123046159744, 0.006043712608516216, 0.0009653187007643282, 0.037534166127443314, -0.022472288459539413, -0.030829839408397675, -0.031643468886613846, 0.004146295599639416, 0.00697366101667285, 0.008715079165995121, -0.01317590195685625, 0.027983926236629486, 0.015251190401613712, 0.006913398392498493, 0.02219470404088497, 0.0025021976325660944, 0.020921608433127403, -0.001682862639427185, -0.012036759406328201, -0.0038912491872906685, -0.048200298100709915, -0.013478884473443031, -0.002910576993599534, -0.019108906388282776, 0.0356561578810215, -0.01249393355101347, 0.022979935631155968, 0.04777613654732704, -0.051295842975378036, -0.045231372117996216, 0.03939134255051613, -0.025952544063329697, 0.005897859111428261, -0.029272902756929398, 0.06606826931238174, -0.028276219964027405, 0.029716048389673233, -0.08640511333942413, -0.02958683855831623, 0.014160632155835629, 0.023358484730124474, -0.021009361371397972, -0.0035451832227408886, -0.005961365066468716, -0.001606564735993743, -0.05600947141647339, -0.011101261712610722, 0.04961031302809715, -0.01587298884987831, -0.01910972036421299, -0.0017172970110550523, -0.00411565974354744, 0.0893455296754837, 0.00829729437828064, 0.005740206688642502, 0.009599076583981514, -0.028016621246933937, -0.022921673953533173, -0.007252429146319628, 0.0173246618360281, -0.02254960872232914, -0.014192230999469757, 0.02998754009604454, 0.029503032565116882, 0.03212380409240723, -0.008152001537382603, -0.0193336084485054, 0.008902745321393013, 0.0004669295740313828, -0.013315437361598015, -0.02759644202888012, -0.017511475831270218, -0.01867189072072506, -0.012119568884372711, -0.006494942586869001, -0.0004218895919620991, 0.025184545665979385, -0.019584333524107933, 0.052445802837610245, -0.0009942426113411784, 0.012998648919165134, 0.027037888765335083, 0.09336598962545395, -0.03589855879545212, 0.0215116236358881, -0.0006127046071924269, -0.043948881328105927, 0.038632240146398544, -0.010190051048994064, -0.012795696035027504, 0.005781043320894241, 0.006989317946135998, -0.031377777457237244, 0.0013644678983837366, -0.046365801244974136, 0.01890510693192482, 0.02370397001504898, -0.026645999401807785, -0.010597776621580124, 0.03928426653146744, 0.005254494957625866, 0.007120923604816198, -0.03729802370071411, 0.004478661343455315, 0.00280050584115088, -0.0030922377482056618, 0.045774586498737335, -0.029987923800945282, 0.04203253611922264, 0.0261082723736763, 0.012956980615854263, -0.019547853618860245, 0.019832737743854523, 0.012824484147131443, -0.022418642416596413, 0.029313720762729645, -0.03096655197441578, -0.04505215212702751, 0.009074120782315731, -0.04368458315730095, 0.005948448553681374, -0.026160268113017082, -0.02904300019145012, 0.039636969566345215, 0.009531415067613125, 0.03818065673112869, -0.02739483118057251, -0.026525408029556274, -0.0355062335729599, 0.0022153102327138186, 0.037318527698516846, 0.010482799261808395, 0.05959034711122513, 0.0027355917263776064, 0.03189488872885704, -0.027253583073616028, 0.04682687669992447, -0.02383578009903431, -0.06560366600751877, -0.0024841860868036747, -0.0011720075272023678, -0.0990716964006424, 0.009782480075955391, -0.03456017002463341, -0.003043769160285592, -0.017953457310795784, -0.04269604757428169, 0.003818575758486986, -0.0013732652878388762, 0.030033940449357033, 0.012463955208659172, 0.09519961476325989, 0.047031059861183167, 0.03348516300320625, 0.021733349189162254, -0.011669212952256203, 0.11878548562526703, 0.032475296407938004, 0.017184117808938026, -0.05774357542395592, -0.00018561015895102173, -0.017878346145153046, -0.01881704106926918, -0.023617198690772057, 0.00959870871156454, -0.009293073788285255, 0.008323051035404205, 0.028595102950930595, 0.026210777461528778, -0.04405650869011879, 0.0034698152448982, 0.039846546947956085, -0.043516580015420914, -0.023670412600040436, 0.03163784369826317, 0.01203596405684948, -0.009648479521274567, -0.007761493790894747, -0.07666518539190292, 0.017871396616101265, -0.0016860929317772388, -0.0212872251868248, -0.04246919974684715, -0.026138219982385635, 0.005847873631864786, -0.021966202184557915, 0.017030861228704453, 0.00006803351425332949, 0.030438518151640892, 0.0038555131759494543, -0.002379158977419138, -0.0005440698587335646, -0.0019525919342413545, -0.022164463996887207, 0.03434640169143677, 0.07819516211748123, 0.008231151849031448, 0.009827814064919949, 0.027621621266007423, 0.03230667486786842, -0.04210119694471359, -0.051971014589071274, -0.042746610939502716, 0.008423021994531155, -0.0418986901640892, 0.00392942177131772, -0.016816236078739166, -0.0022286446765065193, -0.02278910204768181, -0.02512073889374733, 0.003037576097995043, 0.03528124466538429, 0.02718835510313511, -0.01576671004295349, -0.010905739851295948, -0.018105827271938324, 0.01667308248579502, 0.0029381492640823126, 0.041696157306432724, 0.00852299202233553, -0.022970398887991905, -0.018351219594478607, -0.02243342623114586, -0.01263838168233633, 0.0031498700845986605, -0.005059351213276386, -0.03522653877735138, 0.004958854056894779, -0.00723852775990963, -0.010309119708836079, 0.0012824430596083403, -0.021104563027620316, 0.05095645785331726, 0.0029273589607328176, -0.0172465480864048, 0.020328344777226448, -0.03613004460930824, 0.01662539876997471, -0.0424160473048687, -0.008207573555409908, -0.0336792953312397, 0.012919298373162746, -0.017641296610236168, 0.05008905753493309, 0.024932125583291054, -0.017090938985347748, -0.010963247157633305, 0.04622257873415947, 0.008825433440506458, -0.047459665685892105, 0.05750768259167671, -0.00329801719635725, -0.030468272045254707, -0.027514774352312088, -0.01991371624171734, 0.06614772230386734, 0.02027641236782074, 0.006123873870819807, 0.029956767335534096, -0.007420856971293688, -0.004653319250792265, 0.009296786040067673, 0.021066028624773026, -0.040078528225421906, -0.010559278540313244, 0.04355066642165184, -0.0396597795188427, -0.03145955130457878, -0.030964406207203865, 0.00769804185256362, -0.01817345805466175, 0.03384201601147652, -0.006818145513534546, -0.014404753223061562, 0.00520870229229331, -0.013205320574343204, 0.012973449192941189, -0.0014458411606028676, -0.02997133694589138, -0.005628006998449564, 0.009242678992450237, 0.006466689053922892, -0.008227360434830189, -0.019795166328549385, 0.005995891522616148, -0.0061986735090613365, -0.023291589692234993, 0.011884468607604504, 0.007860048674046993, 0.015750689432024956, -0.025268595665693283, 0.005920864641666412, -0.021079737693071365, 0.06553906202316284, -0.02936265617609024, 0.0028249784372746944, 0.0791742205619812, -0.0711795762181282, -0.0024468109477311373, 0.022992609068751335, -0.022617965936660767, 0.06719095259904861, 0.002061235485598445, 0.006637683138251305, -0.01885966584086418, 0.048082947731018066, -0.03573227301239967, -0.012471816502511501, -0.034922171384096146, 0.029179908335208893, 0.04300869256258011, 0.0022243885323405266, -0.03805277869105339, 0.015839708968997, -0.005328253842890263, 0.00814033392816782, 0.028418051078915596, -0.0009397026151418686, 0.002748247468844056, 0.05957012623548508, -0.008130069822072983, 0.05099594220519066, -0.0011280676117166877, 0.007663342170417309, 0.015050242654979229, 0.04753202944993973, -0.0006730894092470407, 0.029171094298362732, -0.0327245332300663, -0.030219094827771187, -0.10626833885908127, -0.051565032452344894, 0.01317065954208374, -0.02905760519206524, 0.04768626019358635, -0.0456274151802063, -0.0019132536835968494, 0.06122525781393051, -0.052019618451595306, 0.03730359673500061, 0.0088677192106843, -0.019710110500454903, -0.04911556467413902, 0.01846335269510746, -0.022794215008616447, 0.04292917251586914, 0.007285286672413349, 0.01139891892671585, 0.04140479862689972, 0.033319514244794846, -0.023876719176769257, -0.04234654828906059, 0.005174093414098024, 0.048433609306812286, -0.01782805472612381, -0.03489173576235771, 0.09162203222513199, -0.006365695036947727, -0.03386015444993973, 0.041404858231544495, 0.021297721192240715, 0.011495436541736126, 0.012153520248830318, 0.0034610258881002665, 0.0072153047658503056, 0.0401005744934082, 0.049881063401699066, -0.0022084983065724373, -0.003890282940119505, 0.017757613211870193, 0.014815175905823708, 0.013292800635099411, -0.05906820297241211, 0.0003487668582238257, 0.04007650166749954, -0.02449752204120159, -0.03717707470059395, -0.005432319827377796, 0.014675717800855637, -0.04548795148730278, 0.016538525000214577, -0.004026961512863636, 0.006396692246198654, -0.011514462530612946, -0.00031735317315906286, -0.02384350821375847, -0.008473429828882217, 0.030829202383756638, 0.007765451446175575, -0.012188407592475414, -0.0202316977083683, 0.007711258716881275, 0.000990686472505331, -0.005400025751441717, 0.005070690531283617, -0.03627284988760948, -0.06948937475681305, 0.011792209930717945, -0.010251183994114399, 0.017997274175286293, -0.025844644755125046, -0.03930216655135155, -0.024260928854346275, -0.0034671188332140446, 0.014477762393653393, 0.008495235815644264, -0.013355902396142483, -0.002337819430977106, -0.0011446939315646887, -0.0707642138004303, 0.04716028645634651, 0.014268148690462112, -0.0196189247071743, -0.047501593828201294, -0.013873014599084854, -0.016377748921513557, 0.007398601155728102, 0.03697240352630615, 0.041180357336997986, 0.004555980674922466, -0.00821775384247303, 0.0483534038066864, 0.04211606830358505, -0.05792856588959694, 0.031317032873630524, -0.0008510040934197605, -0.03649192675948143, -0.036240626126527786, 0.02932017669081688, 0.044825490564107895, 0.021494317799806595, -0.007365809753537178, -0.02612331137061119, -0.00009751738980412483, -0.003679949091747403, 0.013906103558838367, 0.03162030875682831, 0.006117038894444704, 0.004726903513073921, 0.041369982063770294, -0.030033577233552933, 0.01454625092446804, -0.01950126141309738, 0.017844434827566147, -0.07544165104627609, -0.007109742145985365, -0.06365546584129333, 0.006804171949625015, -0.03250487893819809, 0.022276442497968674, 0.0038042780943214893, -0.030703574419021606, -0.006023508496582508, 0.03492061793804169, -0.06759796291589737, -0.027496451511979103, 0.005280838347971439, 0.02922753617167473, 0.05995245277881622, -0.006021700333803892, 0.006904296111315489, -0.025461461395025253, -0.026881607249379158, -0.00944378413259983, 0.020749293267726898, -0.005537606310099363, -0.02749374508857727, 0.01612534560263157, 0.013965478166937828, -0.014874664135277271, 0.014412056654691696, -0.000784761446993798, 0.028096690773963928, -0.02032395452260971, -0.02078828029334545, 0.03175560012459755, -0.022839395329356194, 0.010933463461697102, -0.004760583862662315, -0.022586798295378685, 0.06276629865169525, 0.007255037315189838, 0.003806621301919222, -0.04512370377779007, -0.008504439145326614, -0.02840423211455345, -0.014408267103135586, -0.019301045686006546, -0.010623794980347157, -0.0005568413180299103, 0.025032825767993927, 0.005386369302868843, 0.048701874911785126, 0.04509778693318367, -0.028780359774827957, 0.03964032232761383, 0.016986634582281113, 0.00942848902195692, -0.02940243110060692, -0.026154650375247, -0.026681186631321907, -0.03407767042517662, 0.009459064342081547, 0.044484999030828476, 0.04153715446591377, -0.0006676623015664518, -0.028021976351737976, -0.015284517779946327, 0.038719553500413895, 0.006784126628190279, -0.022465286776423454, -0.07203879952430725, -0.004084643442183733, -0.007814345881342888, 0.006247492041438818 ]
<p>I have an independent sequence of random variables such that P($X_n = \pm1) = \frac{1-2^{-n}} {2} $<br> and P($X_n = 2^ k)=2^{-k}$ for k = n+1,n+2,... Define a new sequence of random variables by $Y_n = X_n$ if $X_n = \pm1$<br> $Y_n = 0$ otherwise. Find P($Y_n = y)$</p> <p>How to do this? I have so far proven $X_n$ and $Y_n$ to be tail equivalent. I have to prove Lyapunov's condition for sum of $Y_n$ which I will be able to if I can find E($Y_n)$ but that is where I am stuck.</p>
74,448
[ -0.026481468230485916, -0.01831989362835884, 0.026152869686484337, -0.006685738451778889, 0.02014000527560711, -0.0017264900961890817, -0.011934802867472172, -0.008791472762823105, 0.011183781549334526, -0.04534473642706871, 0.04663822799921036, 0.06673890352249146, 0.01959521323442459, 0.023039838299155235, 0.046307098120450974, 0.03602844849228859, -0.058037903159856796, -0.006383141502737999, -0.01171885896474123, -0.00042367930291220546, -0.02456025220453739, 0.021841274574398994, 0.07158482074737549, -0.0031033875420689583, -0.07597135752439499, 0.026806853711605072, 0.035447753965854645, 0.006439110264182091, 0.03465447202324867, 0.0796300396323204, -0.025508809834718704, -0.028531236574053764, 0.01302188728004694, 0.03557005152106285, 0.014794612303376198, 0.036598771810531616, -0.023214733228087425, 0.00043807996553368866, 0.023835092782974243, -0.0013787117786705494, -0.008890013210475445, -0.025903699919581413, -0.015390620566904545, -0.025773489847779274, -0.013295809738337994, 0.028505653142929077, -0.0034655292984098196, -0.025438671931624413, 0.03394874185323715, -0.04374929517507553, 0.07441255450248718, -0.01796541176736355, 0.029461897909641266, 0.015535633079707623, 0.04791795834898949, -0.032578930258750916, 0.03338649868965149, 0.07218282669782639, -0.0061525325290858746, -0.011045184917747974, -0.015517810359597206, -0.055323220789432526, 0.0039812177419662476, -0.0377688929438591, -0.06007124483585358, 0.011663563549518585, 0.02488044649362564, -0.006845520809292793, -0.01702161319553852, -0.012473857961595058, 0.027313750237226486, 0.004965139552950859, 0.021012723445892334, -0.013200664892792702, 0.01011120155453682, -0.016949132084846497, 0.018319204449653625, 0.01991627924144268, -0.006772929336875677, 0.04828371852636337, 0.016087211668491364, 0.041378311812877655, 0.015279124490916729, 0.029208708554506302, -0.009949136525392532, -0.007575003895908594, 0.07635314017534256, 0.025661081075668335, 0.012359343469142914, 0.016575800254940987, 0.019409162923693657, -0.020458320155739784, 0.06577873229980469, -0.03391486778855324, -0.025754984468221664, 0.006378522142767906, -0.04505017772316933, 0.032736364752054214, 0.01010025106370449, 0.0025811889208853245, 0.008196928538382053, -0.06229231506586075, 0.04108858108520508, 0.03158184513449669, -0.04174857586622238, -0.009743096306920052, -0.006976121570914984, 0.02744673565030098, -0.013556770980358124, -0.019901003688573837, 0.0013625406427308917, 0.05484263598918915, 0.008311133831739426, -0.010428676381707191, 0.0014201264129951596, 0.003169020637869835, -0.03163867071270943, 0.003510496113449335, 0.004805233329534531, 0.08070898801088333, 0.05308843404054642, -0.006044488865882158, 0.010442257858812809, -0.02828594483435154, -0.04529695212841034, -0.005334313493221998, 0.017637036740779877, 0.0011176986154168844, -0.04016558825969696, 0.03875809535384178, 0.017979271709918976, -0.006718257907778025, 0.04122251272201538, 0.04666056111454964, 0.0720328837633133, 0.013702725991606712, -0.07577547430992126, -0.04464239254593849, 0.0429496243596077, -0.0216340571641922, 0.011524660512804985, -0.07688015699386597, 0.0418381430208683, 0.05509700998663902, 0.05642149597406387, -0.0118607422336936, 0.02540517784655094, 0.007913165725767612, 0.004404808860272169, 0.0014116695383563638, -0.033925045281648636, -0.029428012669086456, -0.009736819192767143, -0.026660725474357605, 0.019115973263978958, -0.07716697454452515, 0.02872421033680439, 0.0318901464343071, -0.014671007171273232, -0.03612019866704941, 0.05620881915092468, -0.011821340769529343, -0.009249626658856869, -0.026592684909701347, -0.007614791858941317, -0.04392456263303757, 0.10116857290267944, 0.017916163429617882, -0.008383601903915405, 0.004954768344759941, 0.0033846059814095497, 0.050299253314733505, 0.001742411172017455, 0.05618293955922127, 0.0508381724357605, -0.050670091062784195, -0.014627818018198013, -0.03008057363331318, 0.011816628277301788, 0.033388055860996246, -0.0418570339679718, 0.0011262311600148678, -0.02915334329009056, -0.006080568302422762, 0.01253674365580082, 0.014688018709421158, 0.022675635293126106, -0.0009331522160209715, 0.011669697239995003, -0.03008604235947132, -0.004706272389739752, -0.050240468233823776, -0.03658831864595413, 0.011026176624000072, -0.030151907354593277, 0.016913626343011856, 0.029464298859238625, 0.044309135526418686, -0.04652852937579155, -0.002352862386032939, -0.01038332749158144, 0.03456472232937813, 0.03469587117433548, -0.039100002497434616, 0.012524348683655262, 0.05872640758752823, 0.03269653394818306, -0.007717051077634096, 0.018324114382267, -0.049796897917985916, -0.017575548961758614, -0.027097811922430992, -0.0300142765045166, -0.014009485952556133, -0.002284014830365777, 0.01125883124768734, 0.01960139535367489, -0.006505937781184912, -0.002278682542964816, -0.004231035243719816, -0.058704644441604614, 0.07180910557508469, 0.07519616186618805, 0.02629893273115158, 0.019594326615333557, -0.046264518052339554, 0.06788706034421921, 0.004949148278683424, -0.04189362749457359, -0.010491377674043179, -0.010868433862924576, 0.011346790008246899, 0.03984667733311653, 0.04624985158443451, -0.05473266914486885, 0.024608202278614044, 0.05122173950076103, -0.01508865412324667, -0.008052341639995575, 0.057357169687747955, -0.01619482785463333, 0.0048702252097427845, -0.013792078010737896, 0.04155595600605011, 0.004534929990768433, 0.004335265140980482, 0.00534712104126811, 0.018019355833530426, -0.022978680208325386, -0.016877086833119392, -0.044503215700387955, 0.024318302050232887, -0.012067840434610844, -0.018704891204833984, -0.0027438688557595015, -0.032237373292446136, 0.03571774438023567, 0.014272810891270638, -0.021872511133551598, 0.021361323073506355, -0.0027838891837745905, 0.009304200299084187, -0.028489943593740463, -0.017584651708602905, 0.027401817962527275, -0.009887021034955978, -0.040649738162755966, -0.045174531638622284, 0.03396836295723915, 0.0011862731771543622, 0.010970821604132652, 0.0371159128844738, -0.07409097999334335, 0.004239033907651901, -0.00896574929356575, 0.03379732370376587, 0.02073436975479126, 0.0008649915689602494, -0.008115909993648529, -0.021878017112612724, -0.004191990941762924, -0.005897141061723232, 0.006318593397736549, -0.008971882984042168, -0.057790905237197876, 0.0015591081464663148, 0.015972338616847992, 0.013160021975636482, 0.04647534340620041, 0.017435315996408463, 0.02252105064690113, 0.0027053661178797483, 0.005409889854490757, -0.06197727471590042, -0.0362723134458065, -0.043776437640190125, 0.015426051802933216, -0.056859564036130905, -0.03765221685171127, 0.0645681768655777, 0.02920263633131981, -0.010107869282364845, 0.03900836408138275, -0.054613083600997925, -0.013040361925959587, -0.04756512492895126, -0.01760939508676529, 0.030729258432984352, 0.002409239299595356, 0.021776748821139336, 0.010015160776674747, -0.002424143720418215, -0.0019619918894022703, -0.06940843164920807, -0.07867633551359177, 0.004887389950454235, -0.01404280960559845, 0.04442664980888367, 0.016114922240376472, -0.05639621987938881, 0.06665174663066864, 0.05332765728235245, -0.008571166545152664, -0.01732703670859337, -0.0026395951863378286, -0.01873965747654438, -0.04868617653846741, -0.009143575094640255, 0.0004986620042473078, -0.004315018653869629, 0.040684666484594345, 0.05084352195262909, -0.015387045219540596, 0.046453140676021576, -0.019080650061368942, 0.0022510839626193047, 0.01712357997894287, 0.005247717257589102, 0.024606389924883842, 0.051905788481235504, 0.016649754717946053, -0.024308770895004272, -0.002210453385487199, 0.0400548130273819, 0.03836532682180405, -0.009049830958247185, -0.02415953204035759, 0.017833691090345383, -0.03976782411336899, 0.01852761022746563, 0.0026869704015552998, 0.11460774391889572, 0.0025979839265346527, -0.012606633827090263, 0.019785098731517792, -0.010096298530697823, 0.030475996434688568, -0.02206151932477951, 0.02546793408691883, 0.04926241561770439, 0.026658575981855392, -0.009750056080520153, -0.025058379396796227, 0.004822032060474157, -0.045182690024375916, 0.04672630503773689, -0.005743515212088823, -0.012886544689536095, 0.015524903312325478, 0.016260240226984024, 0.013927308842539787, 0.002368901390582323, 0.012124184519052505, -0.016239067539572716, -0.04967131465673447, 0.017907872796058655, -0.023813331499695778, 0.04708404839038849, -0.0011309522669762373, 0.056287262588739395, 0.003319923998787999, 0.0018989231903105974, 0.013657048344612122, 0.012830829247832298, -0.07815802097320557, -0.006665646098554134, -0.04726516455411911, -0.03036835975944996, -0.02853463403880596, 0.025954479351639748, 0.04246974363923073, -0.03014892153441906, 0.03951616957783699, -0.0035590899642556906, -0.009902517311275005, -0.033804770559072495, -0.017949555069208145, -0.053960639983415604, -0.023965004831552505, 0.009878287091851234, 0.03943377360701561, 0.041737545281648636, -0.01060983631759882, 0.023300651460886, 0.036853425204753876, -0.03356219828128815, -0.011221855878829956, -0.015910131856799126, 0.006448232103139162, 0.0013925902312621474, 0.014306582510471344, 0.02870681695640087, 0.04025919735431671, -0.00665586581453681, 0.026941590011119843, 0.0071816700510680676, 0.03480374813079834, 0.030492305755615234, 0.00225243391469121, 0.008940232917666435, -0.022886862978339195, -0.017346035689115524, -0.0013046138919889927, 0.017346881330013275, 0.02370416186749935, 0.011940588243305683, 0.04356468468904495, 0.0026914826594293118, -0.06144590675830841, 0.0448153093457222, 0.056571394205093384, -0.02236267738044262, -0.0028802542947232723, -0.04123111069202423, -0.011249165050685406, -0.024799562990665436, 0.029125381261110306, 0.016239752992987633, -0.03405630961060524, -0.02172456495463848, 0.0010143364779651165, 0.04366471618413925, -0.00410828460007906, 0.011617396958172321, 0.0002560837019700557, 0.015561113134026527, 0.06521081179380417, 0.006161076482385397, -0.035528991371393204, 0.04671679437160492, 0.023967256769537926, -0.019525200128555298, 0.005006303079426289, -0.02217988669872284, -0.01584564335644245, 0.001112518017180264, 0.009086048230528831, 0.04391956701874733, -0.017135027796030045, -0.006132537964731455, -0.032766591757535934, -0.02508445829153061, 0.046979982405900955, -0.025331934913992882, 0.043427154421806335, 0.024891557171940804, -0.03728766739368439, 0.014203852042555809, -0.01815057173371315, -0.06884650141000748, 0.028849555179476738, -0.0045862952247262, 0.018578406423330307, -0.036683280020952225, -0.06514568626880646, -0.06817030906677246, -0.011139260604977608, 0.03176667541265488, 0.07781852781772614, -0.04247717559337616, 0.009833560325205326, -0.06411349028348923, 0.02646700292825699, -0.011514037847518921, -0.05905706807971001, 0.044057562947273254, -0.014901654794812202, -0.006984744220972061, 0.007127401418983936, -0.03731329366564751, -0.08766692131757736, 0.023227866739034653, -0.03383907303214073, -0.024746980518102646, 0.007187586277723312, 0.005539634730666876, 0.004922024440020323, 0.06165052950382233, -0.019935566931962967, 0.05147968977689743, 0.033713631331920624, 0.014128757640719414, 0.015581496991217136, -0.007190469186753035, 0.016606828197836876, -0.040258534252643585, -0.007826338522136211, -0.024386916309595108, 0.00013307375775184482, -0.070638008415699, 0.027340497821569443, -0.0006093241390772164, 0.009399154223501682, -0.010659431107342243, 0.004574754741042852, 0.008474559523165226, 0.004110546782612801, 0.04617935046553612, -0.0183796975761652, 0.005144813563674688, 0.0031649875454604626, 0.01517284195870161, -0.02000097557902336, 0.03775591030716896, 0.0009923813631758094, -0.026615822687745094, -0.0005716391024179757, -0.004128007218241692, 0.0001860337215475738, -0.04914143308997154, -0.010210205800831318, -0.020352071151137352, -0.011553382501006126, 0.03626224026083946, -0.0036976984702050686, 0.025513822212815285, 0.018221838399767876, -0.021756291389465332, -0.012808826752007008, 0.014962810091674328, 0.03943656012415886, 0.02195741795003414, -0.04339227080345154, 0.009419715963304043, 0.039346419274806976, -0.04100777581334114, -0.0740342065691948, -0.04290064051747322, 0.0083202188834548, -0.02610839530825615, -0.013884510844945908, -0.05818556249141693, 0.006718567106872797, -0.013773681595921516, -0.025544453412294388, -0.001316716312430799, 0.02722143568098545, 0.004578241612762213, -0.028668109327554703, 0.03254394605755806, 0.009310852736234665, 0.06641292572021484, 0.020726878196001053, -0.038207847625017166, 0.035574425011873245, -0.020687349140644073, -0.04916806146502495, -0.012856410816311836, 0.044605910778045654, -0.03080032207071781, 0.017210980877280235, 0.0018102314788848162, -0.0350494384765625, 0.020581193268299103, -0.04340682551264763, -0.0465795174241066, 0.03336202725768089, 0.028177211061120033, 0.017903413623571396, -0.036172542721033096, -0.03242021054029465, 0.018760306760668755, 0.01852576620876789, -0.0033095888793468475, -0.02674235589802265, 0.009491837583482265, -0.05261973664164543, -0.013372242450714111, 0.02992662414908409, 0.025816895067691803, 0.013560596853494644, 0.05392901971936226, 0.0031152814626693726, -0.04311114922165871, 0.0003547288943082094, -0.0044800713658332825, 0.010425399988889694, 0.005682071205228567, -0.03423147648572922, 0.0028044942300766706, 0.011290173046290874, -0.046356648206710815, -0.017607849091291428, -0.03880798816680908, 0.012933199293911457, 0.08187521249055862, -0.006042224820703268, 0.03224708512425423, 0.02261558547616005, 0.0583050511777401, 0.022925138473510742, 0.008230638690292835, -0.0031161196529865265, -0.033287033438682556, 0.004199731629341841, 0.03747418895363808, -0.047846220433712006, 0.04181413725018501, 0.010730891488492489, 0.008534478023648262, 0.01959278993308544, 0.005294156260788441, 0.008046161383390427, 0.01646288111805916, 0.020808491855859756, -0.026615362614393234, -0.028095437213778496, 0.0456576906144619, -0.03107502870261669, 0.011695520021021366, -0.0068768528290092945, -0.015494244173169136, 0.05016622692346573, 0.009346194565296173, -0.03983351215720177, -0.028265779837965965, -0.04350486770272255, -0.04020905867218971, -0.005367035046219826, -0.008030346594750881, 0.012785103172063828, 0.03435420244932175, 0.01501413993537426, 0.028257764875888824, 0.004969975911080837, 0.03138510882854462, -0.019808584824204445, -0.06064695864915848, -0.010044227354228497, -0.009160976856946945, -0.03659899905323982, 0.00704977847635746, 0.018785813823342323, -0.018255211412906647, 0.02126576378941536, -0.0031677347142249346, -0.013826161623001099, 0.046605080366134644, 0.02583036571741104, 0.0086819501593709, 0.07145439833402634, 0.0281369648873806, 0.03018103539943695, -0.03292272984981537, 0.016391688957810402, 0.09245235472917557, 0.047568827867507935, 0.04955027997493744, -0.06584475189447403, 0.01861615665256977, -0.0036435830406844616, 0.011018999852240086, -0.06626195460557938, 0.040249429643154144, 0.037780117243528366, -0.005927924066781998, 0.02188538946211338, 0.05556882172822952, -0.01382990088313818, -0.02710653841495514, 0.05738728865981102, -0.0026182003784924746, -0.031191756948828697, -0.019070936366915703, -0.012214252725243568, -0.020312150940299034, -0.006409329362213612, -0.030882030725479126, 0.02935897372663021, -0.0024513935204595327, -0.019925886765122414, -0.02785240113735199, -0.005476159509271383, 0.026848498731851578, 0.009581990540027618, -0.01929793693125248, -0.023554930463433266, 0.05015096440911293, 0.0062493314035236835, -0.009765350259840488, 0.022395459935069084, -0.012540730647742748, -0.024375734850764275, 0.01198079064488411, 0.035672131925821304, 0.05439714714884758, -0.019317248836159706, 0.030895613133907318, -0.007176559884101152, -0.04999390244483948, -0.0354820191860199, -0.03026394359767437, 0.024853698909282684, 0.012289307080209255, 0.025722038000822067, 0.015223446302115917, 0.0015890648355707526, -0.030243314802646637, -0.04940396919846535, -0.018334174528717995, 0.006686203181743622, 0.02665971964597702, -0.05126359313726425, -0.010894021950662136, -0.0448593869805336, -0.0026854611933231354, 0.011592932045459747, 0.014097834937274456, 0.07038402557373047, -0.015460040420293808, -0.0210662130266428, 0.0012078996514901519, 0.027194924652576447, 0.004274272825568914, -0.017901768907904625, -0.03676872327923775, 0.01150066964328289, -0.010651478543877602, -0.00991093460470438, 0.01419213879853487, -0.050884079188108444, 0.008111659437417984, 0.03864157944917679, -0.02612481825053692, 0.011341274715960026, -0.031845495104789734, 0.0048746694810688496, -0.02683175541460514, -0.012499340809881687, -0.027356192469596863, -0.018438670784235, 0.02608185075223446, -0.005228921305388212, 0.00017852560267783701, -0.03191927820444107, -0.0031578196212649345, 0.04093348607420921, 0.0076295603066682816, -0.0460878349840641, -0.023792792111635208, -0.014307239092886448, -0.03390789404511452, 0.00005680454705725424, -0.0032775814179331064, 0.06809486448764801, 0.04995154216885567, 0.01717555895447731, 0.006300984416157007, -0.02048099786043167, -0.05383307859301567, 0.021387336775660515, -0.0048447828739881516, -0.02606874704360962, -0.0009485455811955035, 0.018877100199460983, 0.02283092588186264, 0.009421129710972309, -0.027370110154151917, 0.002104214858263731, 0.010924456641077995, 0.02141599729657173, -0.009720002301037312, -0.037398599088191986, -0.03125882148742676, -0.05272534489631653, 0.006656987592577934, -0.04543763026595116, 0.01516866497695446, -0.019475862383842468, -0.02750002034008503, -0.005037109833210707, 0.008111720904707909, -0.0382002554833889, 0.02051691524684429, -0.0189413633197546, -0.008556542918086052, 0.0625116378068924, 0.03021109290421009, 0.010268316604197025, -0.016250336542725563, 0.032452672719955444, -0.026621276512742043, 0.06686579436063766, -0.022770918905735016, -0.014852277003228664, 0.07490862160921097, -0.026133671402931213, 0.0022709660697728395, -0.007925942540168762, 0.016856590285897255, 0.0651218444108963, 0.023036904633045197, -0.031883057206869125, -0.0532669872045517, 0.010429386980831623, -0.02483569271862507, -0.0035312746185809374, 0.011273263022303581, 0.004750610329210758, 0.012788130901753902, 0.007027875166386366, 0.01357812900096178, -0.009211735799908638, -0.009670129045844078, -0.006636869162321091, 0.03890334069728851, -0.007813237607479095, -0.033201221376657486, 0.020800156518816948, 0.028331108391284943, 0.0209021158516407, -0.02747654914855957, -0.006898806430399418, 0.04728439450263977, -0.005555569659918547, -0.007094952277839184, -0.016038382425904274, -0.10523715615272522, -0.01748102344572544, -0.052027393132448196, -0.016657309606671333, 0.014208517968654633, 0.014907707460224628, 0.056500546634197235, -0.02963012084364891, -0.02635224722325802, 0.03213934227824211, -0.013334046117961407, -0.013516743667423725, 0.006611890159547329, 0.0027129475492984056, -0.04143548756837845, -0.0014427397400140762, -0.018730932846665382, 0.022006269544363022, 0.032118167728185654, 0.04931819811463356, 0.05829785019159317, 0.008250604383647442, -0.014230155386030674, -0.0024473145604133606, 0.015656650066375732, -0.0020774665754288435, 0.00749643798917532, -0.06100231409072876, 0.018492277711629868, -0.010458959266543388, 0.009551065973937511, 0.042540401220321655, -0.022766804322600365, -0.005139784887433052, -0.005706076975911856, 0.011159961111843586, 0.006097913254052401, 0.04271213337779045, -0.0018936279229819775, 0.01028034184128046, 0.011871019378304482, -0.01968649961054325, 0.015707753598690033, -0.000023294747734325938, -0.054187797009944916, -0.027327772229909897, 0.04117942228913307, -0.0021793548949062824, -0.03723210096359253, 0.02007087878882885, 0.011378473602235317, -0.020254896953701973, -0.0018392354249954224, -0.013136936351656914, -0.005514996126294136, -0.0238539706915617, 0.04567665979266167, -0.018045462667942047, -0.04708173871040344, 0.0015521794557571411, 0.021530888974666595, -0.014160536229610443, -0.009546228684484959, 0.03622150048613548, -0.046302102506160736, 0.0344083309173584, 0.04943608492612839, -0.0008501432603225112, -0.04630453512072563, 0.016418904066085815, 0.017559753730893135, 0.026042243465781212, -0.010901501402258873, -0.07653117179870605, -0.03001595102250576, 0.03669040650129318, -0.005728491116315126, 0.002207376528531313, -0.004557181615382433, 0.012809290550649166, -0.003169517032802105, -0.05144520848989487, 0.0443708673119545, 0.014327013865113258, 0.010373475030064583, -0.0426020622253418, 0.0007938863709568977, -0.028564272448420525, 0.002345668850466609, 0.05714729055762291, 0.013881886377930641, 0.03575269877910614, -0.003183807246387005, 0.02109236642718315, 0.03562641888856888, -0.03886546194553375, 0.02279835008084774, -0.03921906277537346, -0.010433800518512726, -0.009990356862545013, -0.006050207652151585, 0.026851825416088104, 0.00629332335665822, 0.04588914290070534, 0.01840650849044323, -0.01360017154365778, -0.0016420641914010048, -0.010111408308148384, 0.010347530245780945, -0.019523678347468376, 0.0054677329026162624, 0.046411097049713135, -0.0329686775803566, 0.01330446358770132, -0.01824500411748886, -0.011135932058095932, -0.03933103382587433, 0.021610310301184654, -0.07684104144573212, -0.011567014269530773, -0.04408452287316322, -0.01142051164060831, -0.010491465218365192, -0.03439689055085182, -0.03894353657960892, 0.011846590787172318, -0.018001481890678406, -0.021069638431072235, 0.044364895671606064, 0.017655735835433006, 0.05240856111049652, 0.006644680164754391, 0.02735467068850994, -0.012741172686219215, 0.021622639149427414, 0.04119247570633888, 0.008834939450025558, 0.0477551706135273, -0.02512168511748314, 0.016031015664339066, 0.0049942536279559135, 0.004780095536261797, 0.027476167306303978, 0.001693564117886126, 0.015584869310259819, -0.005222190637141466, -0.014227062463760376, 0.047728512436151505, -0.04443034157156944, -0.01279930118471384, 0.0021015603560954332, -0.02128063142299652, 0.05431663617491722, -0.022071875631809235, 0.02806028351187706, -0.0018081220332533121, -0.026016175746917725, -0.015360400080680847, -0.008564888499677181, -0.037441663444042206, -0.03061884641647339, -0.008283933624625206, 0.011447444558143616, 0.014895105734467506, -0.026215216144919395, 0.007780625484883785, -0.01017106231302023, 0.004746986553072929, 0.00102026027161628, -0.023054050281643867, -0.03821286931633949, -0.04765835776925087, -0.03867937996983528, -0.027746550738811493, 0.00669195456430316, 0.036130789667367935, 0.01731402426958084, 0.0021203195210546255, -0.040124207735061646, -0.010259069502353668, 0.0746791809797287, -0.07719038426876068, -0.007589238695800304, -0.03511716052889824, 0.010804107412695885, 0.029232900589704514, -0.02653961069881916 ]
<p>I am doing a project on low birth weight cohort and normal birth weight tested at 3 different age groups on one cognitive test. Is this considered a 2x3 ANOVA if I want to know birth group differences? Do I need to do t-tests or one-way anova first to test if there is an actual birth group different with age collapsed before I do the 2x3 ANOVA? </p>
74,449
[ -0.034562092274427414, -0.011697237379848957, -0.04541667550802231, -0.014694330282509327, 0.05913125351071358, -0.018527714535593987, -0.012096601538360119, -0.027988959103822708, 0.04795322194695473, -0.03529912605881691, 0.04731043800711632, 0.0009345068247057498, 0.051094330847263336, 0.005611991044133902, 0.025870824232697487, 0.05254387483000755, -0.01584986224770546, -0.009647684171795845, -0.015327110886573792, -0.007061312440782785, -0.012767278589308262, -0.00044778973096981645, 0.012062201276421547, 0.028216583654284477, -0.008201918564736843, 0.025821885094046593, 0.014198189601302147, -0.05876832455396652, 0.005734147969633341, 0.04265368729829788, -0.03985024243593216, -0.017447324469685555, -0.03536762669682503, 0.027154747396707535, 0.032804783433675766, 0.007546606473624706, -0.018137214705348015, -0.009093265980482101, -0.02241288311779499, 0.025854678824543953, -0.06048367917537689, -0.0018720774678513408, -0.02446352317929268, 0.04150647297501564, -0.026381922885775566, 0.02016570046544075, -0.02624075673520565, -0.030160926282405853, 0.010908709838986397, -0.05806863680481911, 0.05150582641363144, -0.006092175841331482, 0.02120964229106903, 0.06473476439714432, -0.023060472682118416, -0.022700268775224686, 0.08014357089996338, 0.052517250180244446, 0.0002615327830426395, -0.04247615486383438, -0.02620525099337101, -0.038606081157922745, 0.018378697335720062, 0.005052117630839348, -0.04914488270878792, 0.018790684640407562, -0.004231331869959831, -0.05227423831820488, 0.029387664049863815, -0.04684531316161156, 0.024083301424980164, 0.005647101439535618, 0.03486352786421776, -0.015327392145991325, 0.014693842269480228, -0.005615762434899807, 0.013880942016839981, 0.013578935526311398, 0.051924943923950195, 0.04827142879366875, -0.002660096390172839, 0.04141464829444885, 0.000658192322589457, 0.05442192405462265, 0.01223878562450409, -0.025240834802389145, 0.07440256327390671, -0.04090626910328865, 0.005960467271506786, 0.02255397103726864, -0.03992640599608421, -0.018771018832921982, 0.059123676270246506, -0.003744483459740877, 0.005738025065511465, 0.05017790570855141, -0.014599998481571674, 0.03229222074151039, -0.0016353490063920617, -0.02413261868059635, -0.021466253325343132, -0.004932904615998268, 0.032288189977407455, 0.054871223866939545, -0.0077709476463496685, 0.023368462920188904, -0.03962132707238197, 0.044684797525405884, -0.028918273746967316, 0.005161124747246504, 0.003808768466114998, 0.023855408653616905, -0.006942008156329393, 0.004966276697814465, 0.04869399964809418, -0.005171770695596933, -0.005914321634918451, -0.011112264357507229, 0.06701947003602982, 0.036900825798511505, 0.05610025301575661, -0.005940757226198912, 0.03576704487204552, 0.015926184132695198, -0.043845199048519135, 0.05189314857125282, 0.01473603118211031, 0.0089797368273139, -0.030820174142718315, 0.09117640554904938, 0.0010457226308062673, -0.015140973031520844, 0.04003724083304405, -0.03624459356069565, 0.01524438802152872, -0.017871275544166565, -0.09977388381958008, -0.06495554000139236, 0.0002668991219252348, 0.002256072126328945, -0.004427370615303516, -0.03848372399806976, -0.015000825747847557, 0.015044492669403553, 0.05570700019598007, -0.007406042423099279, 0.04610081762075424, -0.0014571192441508174, 0.015792079269886017, 0.029049919918179512, -0.008821237832307816, -0.010565921664237976, -0.03707760199904442, -0.02205437235534191, 0.024208327755331993, -0.06871522217988968, 0.028870997950434685, 0.009271602146327496, 0.01982448808848858, -0.00027036952087655663, 0.021557701751589775, -0.015527998097240925, -0.01763004995882511, 0.013184497132897377, 0.03188696503639221, 0.012327127158641815, 0.05267835780978203, -0.047684527933597565, -0.004288605414330959, -0.001953581813722849, -0.016512971371412277, 0.054876942187547684, -0.011522826738655567, 0.05981595441699028, 0.03187799081206322, -0.0041044061072170734, -0.03083249367773533, -0.011168260127305984, 0.035944048315286636, 0.029241696000099182, 0.002100548939779401, -0.0058444286696612835, -0.0413927286863327, -0.01681359112262726, 0.04103630408644676, 0.030309146270155907, -0.007791056297719479, 0.007876227609813213, 0.059930264949798584, -0.01779790222644806, -0.02437751740217209, -0.059694234281778336, -0.013866180554032326, -0.006406706757843494, -0.007935007102787495, 0.02872071973979473, 0.012508952058851719, 0.037910472601652145, -0.025706030428409576, -0.03360430523753166, -0.030650166794657707, 0.025382712483406067, 0.024221239611506462, 0.004879305604845285, 0.043321024626493454, 0.026976075023412704, 0.01635769009590149, -0.051716431975364685, 0.03538566082715988, -0.05543423816561699, -0.009552530944347382, 0.00810197927057743, 0.0032921344973146915, 0.033373814076185226, -0.006234499625861645, 0.020866118371486664, -0.020305085927248, 0.04417590796947479, -0.032280292361974716, 0.08187562972307205, -0.0788586288690567, 0.09713072329759598, 0.053240884095430374, -0.04244571551680565, -0.02080787532031536, -0.008854188956320286, 0.040449514985084534, 0.030126243829727173, 0.003953578881919384, 0.02539631724357605, -0.05670834332704544, -0.04478367045521736, 0.04203052818775177, 0.016760878264904022, -0.02898435667157173, -0.01087020430713892, 0.0218090508133173, -0.00699023250490427, 0.0010535749606788158, 0.00588430929929018, 0.00942398514598608, -0.0575287900865078, -0.009979060851037502, 0.048522356897592545, 0.021392617374658585, 0.021301457658410072, 0.048210639506578445, 0.015821123495697975, 0.04644457995891571, 0.016262691468000412, -0.029044870287179947, 0.052246466279029846, 0.02441249042749405, -0.010228137485682964, -0.026323573663830757, -0.014293954707682133, 0.023310068994760513, -0.02288437820971012, 0.026368938386440277, 0.053283076733350754, -0.0017607923364266753, -0.034680310636758804, 0.01678350940346718, -0.048464953899383545, 0.04748952016234398, 0.04325953498482704, -0.008415655232965946, -0.00023842741211410612, 0.013170492835342884, -0.021145343780517578, -0.006590391509234905, -0.0042180027812719345, -0.016050253063440323, -0.025309721007943153, 0.025684399530291557, 0.013011048547923565, -0.03773551434278488, 0.010151117108762264, -0.06688770651817322, -0.038226041942834854, -0.012000145390629768, 0.0031785510946065187, 0.05038554221391678, 0.009946114383637905, -0.04648582264780998, 0.02658834494650364, -0.043816886842250824, 0.01598130725324154, 0.02212996408343315, -0.024146560579538345, 0.019861437380313873, 0.047573674470186234, -0.02314021624624729, -0.06295847147703171, -0.04052587226033211, 0.003082276089116931, 0.04044456407427788, -0.016783982515335083, -0.008541246876120567, 0.030327001586556435, 0.053269222378730774, -0.023997312411665916, -0.008289524354040623, -0.019823763519525528, -0.015666691586375237, 0.027264587581157684, -0.008662240579724312, -0.009345771744847298, -0.006262657232582569, 0.011388767510652542, 0.0436832420527935, -0.05877111852169037, 0.008816303685307503, -0.02965623326599598, -0.07726148515939713, 0.041495367884635925, -0.0039803218096494675, 0.03579418361186981, -0.027254100888967514, -0.019547011703252792, 0.05319764092564583, 0.02502729371190071, -0.018714016303420067, -0.037786953151226044, 0.007856344804167747, -0.018339399248361588, -0.02115677297115326, 0.0675920769572258, -0.009717189706861973, -0.007984752766788006, -0.004346578847616911, -0.006834005005657673, 0.046803031116724014, 0.06527354568243027, 0.011838438920676708, -0.0028650800231844187, 0.06023893132805824, 0.013501441106200218, -0.02250988595187664, 0.02995792217552662, 0.02984897792339325, -0.01602153107523918, 0.0072386255487799644, -0.027785111218690872, 0.03321712091565132, -0.012826486490666866, -0.043438635766506195, 0.03976954147219658, -0.03484295308589935, 0.012990511953830719, -0.0219253059476614, 0.005976465530693531, 0.021814415231347084, 0.004095534328371286, -0.017834914848208427, 0.007613977883011103, 0.023075098171830177, -0.006981052923947573, -0.0062849088571965694, 0.060756392776966095, 0.03741053491830826, 0.010774637572467327, -0.017941487953066826, 0.027451414614915848, -0.014736860059201717, 0.04164591431617737, -0.02136666513979435, 0.001006331411190331, 0.006437106989324093, 0.05470551177859306, 0.012929465621709824, -0.01812523975968361, -0.03769945353269577, 0.010903346352279186, -0.055337004363536835, 0.03684135526418686, -0.03718316927552223, 0.027018075808882713, 0.008138040080666542, 0.048279616981744766, 0.009311888366937637, 0.004172106273472309, 0.001405194285325706, -0.020711449906229973, -0.04377586022019386, -0.030805952847003937, -0.043393827974796295, -0.012776350602507591, 0.0394786074757576, 0.012311394326388836, 0.03001612424850464, -0.005665128119289875, 0.026519929990172386, -0.028003014624118805, 0.033781133592128754, -0.009855546057224274, -0.008206890895962715, 0.0005461100954562426, 0.0011057620868086815, -0.0049954187124967575, 0.015477108769118786, -0.014367930591106415, 0.011369911953806877, 0.03255219757556915, 0.031658995896577835, 0.023142850026488304, -0.013266712427139282, -0.0051393355242908, -0.005749225150793791, 0.014033018611371517, 0.042084887623786926, 0.024214355275034904, 0.023647446185350418, -0.04967432841658592, 0.020954113453626633, 0.00197884370572865, 0.008866164833307266, -0.012296012602746487, 0.006904285401105881, -0.018240898847579956, -0.00825090054422617, -0.04956003278493881, -0.005281380843371153, 0.03166971355676651, -0.005228232592344284, 0.0002638983423821628, 0.016647903248667717, 0.06348709762096405, -0.013854142278432846, 0.025986483320593834, 0.08818920701742172, -0.014195825904607773, -0.03145959973335266, -0.03800090402364731, -0.01656305231153965, -0.042727164924144745, -0.016047360375523567, 0.020240262150764465, 0.0204833522439003, -0.016223546117544174, 0.012435482814908028, 0.06657066196203232, -0.016562944278120995, -0.027600731700658798, 0.027066122740507126, 0.027680449187755585, -0.0028998302295804024, 0.011597958393394947, -0.04350600764155388, 0.03540761023759842, 0.011255606077611446, 0.015293960459530354, 0.014828489162027836, -0.020938774570822716, -0.05974395573139191, 0.0019321896834298968, 0.01551111601293087, 0.05468202009797096, -0.03254029527306557, -0.007705694530159235, 0.0018745145061984658, -0.019160974770784378, 0.05854383111000061, -0.025673922151327133, 0.0007077594636939466, 0.005606009624898434, -0.007537003140896559, -0.0662233754992485, 0.006696645170450211, -0.016578515991568565, -0.009423106908798218, -0.010035309009253979, -0.008347954601049423, 0.00910498108714819, -0.001834515598602593, -0.004265335854142904, -0.014213995076715946, 0.009644526056945324, 0.036853764206171036, -0.03579943999648094, -0.009221043437719345, 0.03140989691019058, 0.022736407816410065, -0.055983345955610275, -0.04201215133070946, 0.029414715245366096, 0.02370673045516014, -0.016035113483667374, 0.05574222654104233, 0.008459577336907387, -0.029149644076824188, 0.018428096547722816, -0.023858141154050827, 0.002216703025624156, -0.0023386545944958925, -0.02035524882376194, 0.05628814548254013, 0.0074240160174667835, -0.003329397179186344, 0.03710229694843292, 0.03126373142004013, 0.009996423497796059, 0.0021431823261082172, -0.044773321598768234, 0.01216532289981842, -0.06916617602109909, -0.00884580984711647, -0.02844913676381111, -0.046019699424505234, 0.001504679792560637, 0.013865463435649872, 0.005726272705942392, 0.029066376388072968, -0.015036550350487232, -0.0292079858481884, 0.03186002001166344, 0.031218137592077255, 0.03573882207274437, 0.012989966198801994, 0.017188869416713715, -0.008480140008032322, -0.012118039652705193, -0.04534466564655304, 0.021746894344687462, -0.018259244039654732, 0.019268564879894257, -0.0038145638536661863, -0.043167516589164734, 0.013227156363427639, -0.019980788230895996, -0.026369990780949593, 0.04070279002189636, -0.016687948256731033, 0.03007117100059986, -0.004796672612428665, 0.0233454667031765, -0.015046139247715473, -0.05059471353888512, -0.020262153819203377, 0.049809426069259644, -0.01143435575067997, 0.033675603568553925, -0.03199363872408867, 0.04176782816648483, 0.0017780930502340198, -0.004746538586914539, -0.06759456545114517, -0.008885231800377369, -0.0017066188156604767, 0.013520876877009869, 0.045115288347005844, -0.006191832944750786, 0.010136540047824383, -0.0025640048552304506, 0.016008371487259865, -0.03838396072387695, 0.09388736635446548, 0.010581252165138721, 0.004272389225661755, -0.0038673048838973045, 0.0013914002338424325, 0.061205096542835236, 0.018708758056163788, 0.004143914673477411, -0.028383715078234673, -0.032547786831855774, -0.007976417429745197, -0.0006303625414147973, 0.011288425885140896, -0.022256135940551758, -0.0059466916136443615, -0.019700979813933372, 0.01646106131374836, 0.027205299586057663, -0.06211331859230995, -0.043104853481054306, 0.01995844393968582, -0.01992216892540455, -0.01877858117222786, -0.07713053375482559, 0.01721779815852642, -0.04338642582297325, 0.0009231838048435748, -0.047924235463142395, -0.012176615186035633, -0.01154952123761177, -0.01610851101577282, 0.05074606090784073, -0.01586199924349785, -0.026836933568120003, 0.02943282388150692, 0.051410011947155, -0.004344158805906773, -0.0010219371179118752, 0.021452482789754868, -0.05275411158800125, 0.015367268584668636, 0.0003138455795124173, -0.011251700110733509, 0.022923264652490616, 0.03674578294157982, -0.038926735520362854, -0.009484305046498775, -0.03184957057237625, 0.01144771184772253, 0.0650816410779953, -0.02823774702847004, 0.046227794140577316, 0.04061581566929817, 0.007703689392656088, -0.02245422452688217, -0.01483491063117981, 0.010898799635469913, 0.0005142073496244848, -0.005867327563464642, 0.05402825400233269, -0.04400176554918289, -0.0009181014029309154, -0.001903904601931572, 0.01891513168811798, -0.0020399969071149826, 0.053841907531023026, 0.02587989903986454, 0.005489544477313757, 0.02369685098528862, -0.0022923194337636232, -0.056380994617938995, 0.036440975964069366, -0.03068930096924305, -0.005363245494663715, -0.057951297610998154, -0.035023558884859085, 0.05472530797123909, 0.031176738440990448, 0.03130440041422844, -0.05693315342068672, -0.03888139873743057, -0.04632435739040375, 0.019838150590658188, 0.05724797770380974, -0.025472266599535942, 0.01268317736685276, -0.0025385378394275904, 0.03740815818309784, -0.02019636705517769, -0.00700022466480732, -0.03993412107229233, -0.0966811403632164, -0.046600453555583954, -0.022106356918811798, -0.022259235382080078, 0.022474071010947227, -0.028605524450540543, -0.015759319067001343, 0.008319852873682976, -0.008651561103761196, 0.012231199070811272, 0.008846824988722801, 0.023938998579978943, -0.03427210450172424, 0.04404040426015854, 0.0042226314544677734, 0.012989426963031292, 0.0036471739877015352, 0.004323906265199184, 0.10194598883390427, 0.07746905088424683, 0.028474822640419006, -0.06688660383224487, 0.04096011817455292, -0.011779699474573135, 0.01889173686504364, 0.004003587644547224, 0.010844944044947624, -0.010607833042740822, -0.03104095719754696, 0.0357169434428215, 0.05565827339887619, -0.002286731032654643, -0.0082481624558568, 0.02464592643082142, -0.008259224705398083, -0.06628522276878357, 0.016418766230344772, 0.017039330676198006, 0.0270565003156662, -0.026884468272328377, 0.007630419451743364, 0.029387539252638817, 0.004529435187578201, 0.0006093680858612061, -0.0008379666833207011, -0.026713643223047256, 0.034911513328552246, -0.024712946265935898, -0.021121110767126083, 0.02657357044517994, 0.013815621845424175, 0.000693038571625948, -0.05946122109889984, -0.007615697104483843, -0.007343140430748463, -0.06799644976854324, 0.010281350463628769, 0.017611002549529076, 0.024873381480574608, -0.017555370926856995, -0.003495024051517248, 0.031205225735902786, -0.06159426271915436, -0.012928297743201256, 0.03085956536233425, 0.049749407917261124, -0.013657990843057632, -0.03261723741889, -0.021053938195109367, -0.007418953813612461, 0.017887452617287636, -0.02428525499999523, -0.04628444090485573, 0.029721802100539207, 0.023099442943930626, -0.016778109595179558, -0.04311394691467285, -0.021408649161458015, -0.023233681917190552, -0.001328650047071278, 0.03783341497182846, 0.0027577991131693125, 0.010609935037791729, 0.020169630646705627, -0.04480232298374176, 0.023498360067605972, 0.007409432902932167, -0.01165091898292303, 0.03589043766260147, 0.004690782632678747, -0.011998109519481659, -0.014952725730836391, -0.007361036259680986, 0.01103547215461731, 0.04037090018391609, 0.006829998921602964, -0.03340493142604828, -0.003174574114382267, -0.04266791790723801, -0.0015436811372637749, -0.033354029059410095, 0.0173124261200428, -0.03009946085512638, 0.026072485372424126, 0.03549295291304588, 0.04097093641757965, -0.0010747582418844104, 0.03727729991078377, -0.014826244674623013, 0.05286196991801262, 0.02270040102303028, -0.054001156240701675, 0.00839860737323761, 0.023947255685925484, -0.03387932479381561, -0.02959028258919716, -0.05873268470168114, 0.05970306694507599, -0.012128840200603008, 0.03261341154575348, -0.01676476188004017, 0.01457087229937315, -0.009788654744625092, -0.011987145990133286, -0.020687516778707504, -0.05679137632250786, 0.016199948266148567, -0.010084891691803932, 0.036073144525289536, 0.025761963799595833, -0.03428557887673378, -0.03385785222053528, -0.026510871946811676, -0.0037153030280023813, -0.028422117233276367, -0.015567616559565067, 0.01588895544409752, -0.02296757698059082, 0.009268083609640598, -0.023355450481176376, 0.0032221884466707706, -0.010331664234399796, 0.014306175522506237, -0.01710372231900692, -0.02586403861641884, 0.0119849294424057, -0.006501084193587303, -0.013926252722740173, 0.01229933649301529, 0.015400168485939503, -0.014047864824533463, -0.01144719310104847, 0.017080724239349365, -0.001298562390729785, 0.004791757091879845, 0.05045543983578682, 0.020200511440634727, -0.010300409980118275, 0.04536529630422592, -0.04018811509013176, -0.015436134301126003, 0.01820480264723301, -0.013939173892140388, 0.03458883613348007, 0.013795383274555206, -0.011000317521393299, -0.030660618096590042, 0.04362262040376663, -0.021253835409879684, -0.045418497174978256, -0.00572508480399847, -0.011117319576442242, -0.001968841999769211, 0.000607732858043164, 0.005661275703459978, 0.00427662068977952, -0.05586527660489082, 0.05746975541114807, 0.02478756196796894, 0.023465648293495178, -0.0246430691331625, -0.020845331251621246, -0.0011568275513127446, 0.03426065668463707, -0.001203055726364255, -0.005357088055461645, 0.010828778147697449, 0.06892061978578568, -0.009329807944595814, 0.01788392849266529, -0.02337786927819252, -0.012826019898056984, -0.0784790888428688, -0.016933904960751534, -0.018427541479468346, 0.014445425942540169, 0.013302461244165897, -0.06822463124990463, 0.012506303377449512, 0.044499851763248444, -0.03014921210706234, 0.04643169417977333, -0.012457458302378654, -0.03189447894692421, -0.0240522138774395, -0.008104680106043816, -0.031551849097013474, 0.010203579440712929, -0.04598746448755264, 0.012425967492163181, -0.02846156619489193, 0.03482833504676819, -0.04023236781358719, -0.03936486691236496, 0.02968505024909973, 0.01832478865981102, 0.0015587207162752748, -0.05349448695778847, 0.008370223455131054, -0.0013559316284954548, -0.04098670929670334, 0.027708223089575768, -0.035555753856897354, 0.009908693842589855, 0.01158825121819973, 0.014630919322371483, 0.021276166662573814, 0.011091501452028751, 0.04276624321937561, -0.0009113170090131462, 0.019742131233215332, 0.020830227062106133, 0.01706072688102722, 0.02724493481218815, -0.008427671156823635, 0.02349068596959114, 0.0424780547618866, 0.0016349341021850705, -0.0013200390385463834, 0.02756192721426487, -0.023394005373120308, 0.008723349310457706, 0.011385113932192326, -0.04537258669734001, 0.00905284658074379, -0.000566916074603796, -0.0019538213964551687, -0.023602621629834175, -0.016759678721427917, 0.027769148349761963, 0.03580273687839508, -0.06232712045311928, 0.025540897622704506, -0.031742773950099945, -0.021401647478342056, 0.014222904108464718, -0.018910855054855347, -0.004663318395614624, -0.05017251893877983, -0.010022507980465889, -0.004626598209142685, -0.00011209701915504411, -0.040374260395765305, -0.009921255521476269, -0.04121481999754906, 0.040768563747406006, -0.0454031340777874, -0.018202144652605057, 0.032920192927122116, 0.0045537943951785564, 0.009062345139682293, -0.09204448014497757, 0.0627463236451149, 0.0073510343208909035, -0.00411676662042737, -0.03606829419732094, 0.0062101068906486034, -0.06226537749171257, 0.039931997656822205, 0.08816743642091751, 0.029752817004919052, 0.028840821236371994, -0.005872844718396664, 0.017705200240015984, 0.007748216390609741, -0.04962659254670143, 0.01794218271970749, -0.023174451664090157, 0.01189352385699749, -0.005960484035313129, -0.018623733893036842, 0.006499384995549917, -0.008008585311472416, 0.03273770213127136, -0.017746882513165474, 0.027377484366297722, -0.007840132340788841, 0.004804766271263361, -0.0020638296846300364, 0.013905324041843414, -0.015411129221320152, 0.05265459790825844, -0.026395505294203758, -0.013212419115006924, 0.04042607918381691, 0.023320911452174187, -0.06193164363503456, 0.019673790782690048, 0.00464361859485507, 0.004321159794926643, 0.0047446684911847115, -0.007232631091028452, 0.01459693256765604, -0.05326098948717117, -0.019408294931054115, 0.02317194826900959, -0.01344973873347044, -0.015802424401044846, 0.05773501098155975, 0.05074619501829147, 0.011084887199103832, -0.033554524183273315, 0.003219635458663106, 0.025542819872498512, -0.034476637840270996, 0.045330874621868134, 0.025735795497894287, 0.003228092798963189, -0.004588153678923845, -0.007845387794077396, 0.021302707493305206, -0.013038049452006817, 0.005674236454069614, -0.01665790006518364, 0.032714538276195526, -0.034161243587732315, -0.028621947392821312, 0.0018066252814605832, -0.0075511145405471325, 0.027540504932403564, -0.02848672866821289, 0.005544488318264484, 0.060912907123565674, -0.04348210245370865, -0.0009312732727266848, 0.008753961883485317, 0.0029772731941193342, -0.061191361397504807, 0.012608231976628304, 0.04659617319703102, 0.033378615975379944, 0.0030505782924592495, -0.018743321299552917, -0.03987221047282219, -0.043418996036052704, 0.006979391444474459, -0.02982126548886299, 0.058077648282051086, -0.050013087689876556, 0.0025216874200850725, -0.015351430512964725, 0.015149732120335102, -0.08396023511886597, -0.03819565102458, 0.010728812776505947, 0.017169486731290817, 0.04371195659041405, -0.04609343782067299, -0.02381874807178974, 0.010771447792649269, 0.02489570528268814, -0.08358462154865265, -0.0394720695912838, -0.029904456809163094, 0.008771158754825592, 0.022199096158146858, -0.0043788813054561615 ]
<p>I understand that it's instead correct to cross-validate using new data. Why is it so? It is just that a model will tend to fit the data set that was used to created it better than another randomly sampled set of data?</p> <p>Could it ever be justified to use the same data for EFA and CFA?</p>
74,450
[ -0.001034830929711461, 0.008946526795625687, -0.020919492468237877, -0.0030073572415858507, 0.0494995191693306, 0.002465406898409128, -0.013287383131682873, -0.026360489428043365, 0.0448889434337616, -0.014855235815048218, 0.0014479574747383595, 0.006197414826601744, 0.03300407901406288, 0.010941511951386929, 0.007872562855482101, 0.031018732115626335, 0.009036165662109852, -0.006053900346159935, 0.007010630331933498, -0.0022535594180226326, 0.023672904819250107, 0.013205025345087051, 0.013343247584998608, -0.046847980469465256, -0.03767707943916321, 0.023628264665603638, 0.02549798972904682, -0.05024949461221695, 0.04775891825556755, 0.03436516597867012, -0.025787556543946266, -0.025897065177559853, 0.002727158134803176, 0.06416216492652893, 0.00914281141012907, 0.0004810771788470447, -0.04243141785264015, -0.045496318489313126, 0.01551435049623251, 0.04487476125359535, -0.020382164046168327, -0.012427273206412792, 0.005080631468445063, 0.06247277185320854, 0.015491573140025139, 0.012472427450120449, -0.02473827823996544, -0.03479670360684395, 0.0024937386624515057, -0.04295601695775986, 0.061850786209106445, -0.04280693456530571, 0.029790297150611877, 0.06990475952625275, -0.004081552382558584, -0.009594463743269444, 0.09323404729366302, 0.047536369413137436, -0.00035859787021763623, -0.027608757838606834, -0.051617223769426346, -0.0019587420392781496, -0.002136985072866082, -0.02144647389650345, -0.010680485516786575, 0.022188052535057068, 0.003746827132999897, -0.02656731568276882, 0.0027083540335297585, -0.022703129798173904, 0.029506081715226173, 0.04324798658490181, 0.037385910749435425, -0.03466501086950302, 0.04187389835715294, 0.0006640958017669618, 0.025329558178782463, 0.028874557465314865, 0.045959584414958954, 0.03166207671165466, -0.01427414920181036, -0.004373057279735804, 0.028996530920267105, 0.029797464609146118, 0.02449462190270424, -0.008131075650453568, 0.057684700936079025, 0.0046893395483493805, -0.0008498758543282747, -0.009182660840451717, 0.01702313870191574, 0.02160005457699299, 0.04481491073966026, -0.017666714265942574, -0.017331579700112343, 0.02591422013938427, 0.010632769204676151, 0.031743839383125305, 0.026651203632354736, -0.0023873704485595226, 0.012356018647551537, -0.03949781134724617, 0.04090022295713425, 0.040254145860672, -0.03811826556921005, -0.002534186700358987, -0.010043174028396606, -0.021496528759598732, -0.010468361899256706, -0.03104560635983944, -0.031198017299175262, 0.024243315681815147, 0.032906681299209595, 0.033250533044338226, 0.04786823317408562, 0.028459414839744568, 0.01336795836687088, -0.007033403031527996, 0.06816863268613815, 0.07077062129974365, 0.043878231197595596, -0.010219579562544823, 0.035345785319805145, -0.0004797196888830513, -0.02880626544356346, -0.0038834563456475735, -0.012037668377161026, -0.01263920497149229, -0.05939269810914993, 0.04276951774954796, -0.030777523294091225, -0.033645231276750565, 0.023691080510616302, -0.01351203303784132, 0.007928255945444107, 0.013384091667830944, -0.12218014895915985, -0.03699362277984619, 0.02651185356080532, -0.014917511492967606, 0.00932674203068018, -0.06899193674325943, 0.017953719943761826, 0.001141820801422, 0.03506109118461609, -0.008735994808375835, 0.03312743082642555, -0.006471928209066391, 0.02915218099951744, -0.02929561212658882, -0.010186469182372093, -0.043075498193502426, -0.013470055535435677, 0.011229646392166615, -0.04679842293262482, -0.07421691715717316, 0.00640163104981184, 0.0014189834473654628, -0.01862962730228901, -0.01687871664762497, 0.03772006183862686, 0.0016111572040244937, -0.0035642150323837996, -0.035058047622442245, 0.019015314057469368, -0.04225650057196617, 0.05318903177976608, 0.011940899305045605, 0.02852514758706093, 0.03984524682164192, -0.04051719978451729, 0.00990980863571167, 0.01799459010362625, 0.022388188168406487, 0.03782100975513458, -0.010347128845751286, 0.028007855638861656, -0.026361363008618355, 0.04245686158537865, 0.01071899477392435, -0.012098454870283604, 0.018108928576111794, -0.007431951351463795, 0.00007241730781970546, 0.017822906374931335, 0.028260208666324615, 0.007268209010362625, -0.026618530973792076, 0.029702026396989822, -0.06722024828195572, -0.057967495173215866, -0.06942594051361084, 0.037735555320978165, -0.019202860072255135, -0.006859038025140762, 0.0411142073571682, -0.0003269971639383584, 0.02035781741142273, -0.03132238984107971, -0.03525017201900482, -0.03054012916982174, -0.017770055681467056, -0.007002735044807196, -0.05178842321038246, 0.020444102585315704, 0.07594563066959381, -0.018820881843566895, -0.012822225689888, 0.06949999928474426, -0.025014253333210945, -0.06756354868412018, -0.0006231646984815598, -0.06361294537782669, 0.008510032668709755, -0.029534319415688515, -0.006890269927680492, 0.012534445151686668, 0.0010405086213722825, -0.05265120789408684, 0.014969528652727604, -0.05494968593120575, 0.05502195283770561, 0.05381060019135475, -0.004144131671637297, -0.0035453049931675196, 0.03089107573032379, 0.04124998301267624, 0.024879781529307365, -0.005011109635233879, -0.0347546711564064, -0.06854579597711563, -0.011882496997714043, 0.030139347538352013, -0.0013138302601873875, -0.011348380707204342, 0.004922982305288315, 0.07376770675182343, -0.0037238451186567545, 0.02403147704899311, 0.00804905965924263, 0.032609112560749054, -0.028371436521410942, 0.004316273145377636, 0.04721008986234665, 0.01450820080935955, -0.018611585721373558, -0.03138519078493118, -0.0283567626029253, 0.0023426893167197704, 0.014717940241098404, 0.01595323532819748, 0.04840940982103348, 0.012180943973362446, -0.01797698251903057, -0.005433053243905306, -0.007997418753802776, 0.023414447903633118, -0.036066751927137375, 0.040546149015426636, -0.006641128100454807, 0.009842787869274616, -0.03172680735588074, 0.004873175639659166, -0.019822658970952034, 0.028027912601828575, 0.0186334066092968, -0.010366285219788551, 0.02975037321448326, 0.029075531288981438, -0.042590975761413574, -0.006214605178683996, -0.04642198979854584, -0.03553114831447601, -0.02526291459798813, 0.013340389356017113, 0.01318291760981083, 0.005056057590991259, 0.03674006834626198, -0.024165049195289612, -0.027191203087568283, -0.014251124113798141, -0.004860935732722282, 0.0065972330048680305, -0.025258801877498627, -0.04432007670402527, 0.006653284188359976, -0.011827845126390457, -0.019793257117271423, 0.02619018591940403, -0.013812251389026642, 0.013500159606337547, 0.006435999646782875, 0.012730437330901623, -0.004678281489759684, 0.0008129099733196199, -0.0429157018661499, -0.011965537443757057, 0.030294010415673256, -0.04382782429456711, 0.042791422456502914, 0.008448461070656776, -0.05985521897673607, 0.005601729732006788, -0.00460462411865592, -0.008418561890721321, -0.007695413194596767, -0.0056194039061665535, 0.011006027460098267, -0.02650230936706066, 0.02042475715279579, 0.044147081673145294, -0.00901994202286005, -0.001289951498620212, -0.05872942507266998, -0.05458405986428261, 0.040928915143013, -0.032994724810123444, 0.01657859981060028, 0.0012176348827779293, 0.0045233783312141895, 0.06188606843352318, 0.0410337969660759, -0.031008385121822357, -0.020642725750803947, 0.009597654454410076, -0.04394363611936569, -0.0666847825050354, -0.013102032244205475, 0.019924921914935112, -0.009371905587613583, 0.04909693822264671, -0.0192616768181324, 0.0004402350459713489, 0.047299351543188095, -0.0015401290729641914, -0.009283044375479221, -0.021762128919363022, 0.02753838710486889, -0.009436742402613163, 0.040955137461423874, 0.014600124210119247, 0.003587052458897233, 0.011043639853596687, 0.03728354722261429, 0.053974684327840805, 0.033768363296985626, -0.019081294536590576, 0.014478609897196293, -0.050208523869514465, 0.03594183921813965, -0.054491739720106125, 0.04621265083551407, -0.010197793133556843, -0.027874814346432686, -0.02224843017756939, 0.016788164153695107, 0.03133947029709816, -0.025152351707220078, -0.008071346208453178, 0.037340350449085236, 0.010967575944960117, -0.008398618549108505, -0.004623508546501398, -0.03541680797934532, 0.015829091891646385, 0.017659220844507217, 0.021986844018101692, -0.02780419960618019, 0.045219745486974716, 0.0538133904337883, 0.03180309757590294, 0.01137563120573759, -0.04848908632993698, -0.03341098129749298, -0.0735374465584755, 0.003479916136711836, -0.021954284980893135, 0.03766695410013199, 0.010183108039200306, 0.049872610718011856, 0.0052630286663770676, -0.046137735247612, -0.016337530687451363, 0.011301158927381039, -0.0746714249253273, 0.00917481817305088, 0.009771124459803104, -0.009918788447976112, -0.016095157712697983, -0.03528265282511711, 0.01760503090918064, -0.011873000301420689, -0.016661768779158592, -0.021394744515419006, 0.016674969345331192, -0.019836848601698875, -0.008661000058054924, -0.049703843891620636, -0.00531039759516716, 0.004263941198587418, 0.030944745987653732, 0.023091640323400497, -0.013879353180527687, 0.017051847651600838, 0.036007169634103775, -0.019522758200764656, -0.044063277542591095, -0.03542192280292511, 0.030503589659929276, 0.012828170321881771, 0.018068881705403328, 0.007417744025588036, 0.053150251507759094, -0.06435736268758774, 0.030461527407169342, 0.020035775378346443, 0.018704542890191078, 0.05206260085105896, 0.009339699521660805, -0.033367957919836044, -0.06944788992404938, -0.042075302451848984, 0.011175683699548244, 0.028620975092053413, 0.005748508498072624, -0.021574588492512703, 0.017337162047624588, 0.05465947091579437, -0.0523407943546772, 0.0029957653023302555, 0.054735563695430756, 0.025193968787789345, 0.021133577451109886, -0.023627998307347298, -0.014485885389149189, -0.00598886888474226, -0.050832245498895645, 0.026065178215503693, 0.020126087591052055, -0.012950152158737183, 0.011563950218260288, 0.04505243897438049, -0.04992755874991417, -0.02114829048514366, 0.019408825784921646, 0.00740370899438858, 0.008737826719880104, 0.006421194411814213, -0.017299527302384377, 0.0043617188930511475, 0.03161843121051788, 0.08032765984535217, 0.027216987684369087, 0.0017202168237417936, -0.0796697810292244, 0.026611337438225746, 0.07089502364397049, 0.004421411547809839, -0.051985371857881546, -0.018451524898409843, -0.06700266152620316, -0.03115004301071167, 0.008395032957196236, -0.022935574874281883, 0.01492272224277258, 0.0007287028711289167, 0.013997253030538559, -0.03559347987174988, -0.014982538297772408, -0.004234816879034042, 0.009187514893710613, -0.004968228284269571, 0.032416075468063354, -0.005321499425917864, -0.011084252968430519, -0.008148638531565666, 0.007608192507177591, 0.015078023076057434, 0.05353042110800743, -0.01500626653432846, -0.0434013269841671, -0.0001862380449892953, 0.013847146183252335, -0.00045232908450998366, -0.07059682160615921, -0.01871059089899063, -0.020728547126054764, 0.011379999108612537, 0.003642836818471551, -0.0005041869590058923, -0.025245029479265213, 0.010782613418996334, 0.030943848192691803, -0.028380228206515312, -0.0298781618475914, -0.005799964070320129, 0.05347222462296486, 0.02724481374025345, 0.05133618041872978, 0.07364729046821594, 0.012602048926055431, 0.026294225826859474, -0.027904903516173363, -0.01760835573077202, 0.008387347683310509, -0.059671517461538315, -0.015038064680993557, -0.05923580750823021, 0.00575538445264101, -0.03302684426307678, -0.002864455571398139, 0.0072260149754583836, 0.05417275428771973, -0.014579779468476772, -0.0408087819814682, -0.006697005592286587, 0.01671365648508072, -0.011216356419026852, 0.0030065434984862804, -0.015338322147727013, 0.014512976631522179, -0.025859089568257332, -0.011374399997293949, 0.00337834469974041, 0.020519882440567017, -0.021137375384569168, 0.008479658514261246, -0.007765945512801409, 0.021988561376929283, -0.05636078119277954, -0.03277125954627991, 0.02660677768290043, -0.01810581237077713, 0.031784240156412125, 0.009055343456566334, 0.060388222336769104, -0.003353100037202239, -0.055568479001522064, 0.02296634390950203, 0.049771834164857864, -0.009212855249643326, 0.034406594932079315, -0.03146165609359741, 0.03555178642272949, -0.022616369649767876, -0.02429821901023388, -0.08258099853992462, -0.0448007695376873, 0.015476989559829235, -0.0215456560254097, -0.010396735742688179, -0.022140493616461754, -0.021791942417621613, -0.009854859672486782, -0.011900383979082108, -0.015910854563117027, 0.0595625638961792, -0.00885099545121193, -0.006621660199016333, 0.029843708500266075, -0.005433660466223955, 0.07592429965734482, 0.0014348597032949328, 0.02731349505484104, -0.00966553296893835, -0.03293579816818237, -0.0005057430826127529, -0.007848055101931095, 0.0066473945043981075, -0.031265124678611755, 0.01170776691287756, -0.056500475853681564, 0.02050996571779251, 0.022748462855815887, -0.03141433000564575, -0.0006476606940850616, -0.003999107517302036, 0.0023902920074760914, 0.013111492618918419, -0.016897570341825485, 0.005627689883112907, -0.007744422648102045, -0.009266017936170101, -0.028826186433434486, 0.010554519481956959, -0.02832287736237049, -0.0003298077208455652, 0.03426105156540871, -0.005223352927714586, 0.012129432521760464, 0.030111538246273994, 0.08544541150331497, -0.05794668197631836, -0.030702190473675728, -0.013111206702888012, -0.011307242326438427, 0.050828512758016586, -0.0012928261421620846, 0.006122790277004242, -0.007703184615820646, 0.019688637927174568, -0.038889527320861816, -0.020564742386341095, 0.005816066637635231, -0.010140184313058853, 0.033784233033657074, 0.01462162472307682, 0.06507778912782669, 0.021847955882549286, 0.04124916344881058, -0.029563529416918755, -0.023404289036989212, -0.014841257594525814, -0.009090369567275047, -0.02099734917283058, 0.03888856619596481, 0.010095318779349327, -0.021117566153407097, -0.0005331022548489273, -0.01208337303251028, 0.06121265888214111, 0.01386722270399332, 0.025777719914913177, 0.05956806614995003, 0.004825775511562824, -0.01186874695122242, -0.040192633867263794, 0.045649461448192596, -0.054494891315698624, -0.0034152832813560963, 0.03221027925610542, -0.00951332412660122, 0.0501079335808754, 0.03480086848139763, -0.0071183014661073685, -0.027244849130511284, -0.022463783621788025, -0.03744463622570038, 0.04190589115023613, 0.03232193365693092, 0.003869306528940797, 0.049044009298086166, -0.022737417370080948, 0.03138139843940735, -0.011920559220016003, 0.0110753383487463, -0.01043436024338007, -0.10207866132259369, -0.04897705093026161, -0.024461083114147186, 0.01961103267967701, 0.03448495641350746, -0.010626031085848808, -0.04447588697075844, 0.01769997738301754, -0.016524694859981537, 0.025492485612630844, -0.04423930123448372, 0.03810347616672516, -0.03416144847869873, 0.03779124468564987, 0.0006193166482262313, 0.03544801473617554, 0.0033706894610077143, 0.011564069427549839, 0.11963579803705215, 0.06540434807538986, 0.02662227302789688, -0.053561195731163025, 0.05057195946574211, -0.008604632690548897, 0.00659589609131217, -0.03892848268151283, 0.003574876580387354, 0.039551980793476105, 0.026304909959435463, 0.027411628514528275, 0.03996412083506584, 0.027734043076634407, -0.0034713365603238344, 0.06396498531103134, -0.00865244586020708, 0.004984489642083645, 0.022871173918247223, 0.04770340397953987, -0.0010742158629000187, -0.029812602326273918, 0.006188902072608471, -0.019298404455184937, -0.014008022844791412, -0.030042607337236404, 0.0219299104064703, -0.031277742236852646, 0.005106472875922918, 0.022628366947174072, 0.0026919448282569647, -0.010227360762655735, 0.004015489015728235, 0.005284725222736597, -0.022588316351175308, -0.0008153327507898211, -0.03694583848118782, 0.00434033153578639, 0.0021327054128050804, 0.04848167672753334, 0.018910720944404602, -0.026961440220475197, -0.01549181155860424, 0.009996341541409492, -0.02274617925286293, -0.027598125860095024, -0.0785394161939621, 0.005292439367622137, -0.03150000795722008, -0.012873878702521324, -0.0009867454646155238, -0.0123462975025177, 0.006787982303649187, -0.05353514850139618, -0.05760505050420761, 0.030748113989830017, 0.0006061849999241531, -0.024126963689923286, -0.01794162206351757, -0.05376041308045387, 0.012926061637699604, 0.008064099587500095, -0.0019881869666278362, 0.010050277225673199, -0.020771367475390434, -0.013667894527316093, -0.03181777149438858, 0.049957454204559326, -0.0027138818986713886, -0.0176559928804636, -0.014565441757440567, -0.015518572181463242, -0.04211714491248131, -0.031853482127189636, 0.03195512294769287, 0.02896188758313656, 0.07077569514513016, -0.021413782611489296, 0.02237413264811039, -0.020304543897509575, -0.02625633217394352, -0.007666618563234806, 0.002122159581631422, 0.015351489186286926, -0.025733597576618195, -0.0067963553592562675, 0.005413373000919819, 0.03265053406357765, 0.019515611231327057, 0.0030761254020035267, -0.004521983675658703, 0.03410132974386215, 0.012212655507028103, -0.05577865242958069, -0.022022387012839317, -0.03143606334924698, -0.05085964500904083, 0.009335885755717754, -0.0060171098448336124, 0.020519260317087173, 0.02796534076333046, 0.05687694624066353, -0.02912849932909012, 0.07080516219139099, 0.019891267642378807, 0.02205212414264679, 0.0030709775164723396, -0.05659221112728119, 0.01557899173349142, 0.009713156148791313, 0.002384328516200185, -0.009681791067123413, -0.03392431139945984, -0.022874081507325172, -0.03613215312361717, 0.030441656708717346, -0.001492749317549169, -0.0425121895968914, 0.013884512707591057, -0.027564680203795433, 0.03382699936628342, -0.038290057331323624, 0.002275108592584729, -0.05224628746509552, 0.0023133268114179373, -0.027302192524075508, -0.08720758557319641, -0.007563451770693064, -0.009366909973323345, -0.011028268374502659, 0.00878632627427578, 0.06016550958156586, 0.005769290961325169, -0.007094844710081816, -0.01860862784087658, 0.0022298533003777266, 0.010764743201434612, 0.030587365850806236, -0.04149634391069412, 0.00003872889283229597, 0.02815171517431736, -0.028225809335708618, -0.03397916257381439, 0.015668032690882683, -0.009883437305688858, 0.029899194836616516, -0.00655386783182621, -0.010567963123321533, 0.01604529097676277, 0.05539778992533684, -0.037356313318014145, -0.014538940973579884, 0.018831491470336914, 0.037464439868927, 0.03320755064487457, 0.0059779915027320385, 0.040531452745199203, 0.020211242139339447, 0.003439872292801738, 0.03761103376746178, 0.03549658879637718, 0.04740539565682411, -0.03610512986779213, 0.02765335515141487, -0.02917643077671528, 0.022869927808642387, 0.033995628356933594, 0.0365162156522274, 0.0005839378573000431, 0.0553600899875164, 0.009475428611040115, -0.013476114720106125, -0.003066878067329526, 0.01574869453907013, -0.09121225029230118, -0.019091134890913963, 0.047355763614177704, -0.005741602275520563, 0.010240519419312477, -0.011346697807312012, 0.028133375570178032, 0.021757394075393677, -0.07442159950733185, 0.025145145133137703, -0.007464971859008074, 0.0019025789806619287, -0.031023642048239708, 0.021889399737119675, -0.01918499544262886, 0.008448166772723198, 0.05556090921163559, -0.009353309869766235, 0.009971527382731438, 0.002466001082211733, 0.002927433466538787, 0.008475682698190212, -0.02297690138220787, 0.03094951994717121, 0.006562711670994759, -0.0256934966892004, 0.024871453642845154, -0.017882084473967552, -0.045211974531412125, -0.011488457210361958, 0.012419907376170158, 0.011353366076946259, 0.00031538240727968514, 0.019423870369791985, 0.0476849302649498, -0.021926628425717354, 0.03899136558175087, 0.0009229504503309727, -0.0035107412841171026, -0.006360809784382582, 0.012938888743519783, 0.039829254150390625, -0.014117838814854622, 0.0205101128667593, 0.008473634719848633, 0.0038297518622130156, -0.05261271819472313, 0.026649199426174164, -0.009999571368098259, -0.014455487951636314, -0.00638936972245574, 0.02607044391334057, -0.01034920010715723, -0.03589572757482529, 0.002848181640729308, 0.0004279977292753756, 0.0008509840117767453, 0.03779517859220505, 0.040744177997112274, -0.02268795669078827, 0.005649433005601168, -0.029884250834584236, -0.034374237060546875, 0.014422881416976452, 0.01399065088480711, 0.00018046319019049406, -0.08136964589357376, -0.009610309265553951, 0.0011306089581921697, -0.034944504499435425, -0.04721212759613991, 0.0005696790176443756, -0.03724557161331177, 0.06347288191318512, -0.02059027925133705, -0.009482019580900669, 0.032191257923841476, -0.037135448306798935, -0.006899045314639807, -0.08303231745958328, 0.054700739681720734, -0.017422305420041084, -0.05407208576798439, -0.026607530191540718, -0.003981574438512325, -0.014152186922729015, 0.0018887808546423912, 0.040925879031419754, 0.004711132496595383, 0.025680039077997208, -0.01790729910135269, 0.04080602526664734, -0.03664501756429672, -0.05376092717051506, 0.05475771427154541, -0.0141829252243042, -0.008723307400941849, -0.017428649589419365, -0.008321734145283699, 0.0018586068181321025, 0.013436955399811268, -0.01447267271578312, -0.016685260459780693, 0.05692235007882118, 0.02860245481133461, -0.015473880805075169, 0.04354053735733032, 0.015084199607372284, 0.0003740453103091568, 0.03714591637253761, 0.00021967635257169604, 0.011267968453466892, -0.0024772025644779205, 0.00011061836266890168, -0.05901334062218666, 0.03635021671652794, -0.04615305736660957, -0.017265861853957176, -0.029007162898778915, 0.051427211612463, -0.009612910449504852, -0.02471770904958248, -0.00787101499736309, 0.06455117464065552, -0.0542655773460865, 0.003935924731194973, 0.03118838369846344, 0.043927982449531555, 0.019780199974775314, -0.028815099969506264, 0.01502835750579834, 0.015358869917690754, -0.0027317628264427185, 0.004916807170957327, 0.004377275705337524, 0.03755559027194977, -0.015209535136818886, 0.008520903997123241, 0.060411952435970306, -0.010781491175293922, 0.0032046325504779816, 0.014368368312716484, 0.08096447587013245, -0.032897088676691055, -0.016479624435305595, 0.01984192244708538, 0.036811258643865585, 0.017460670322179794, 0.009993508458137512, -0.03766816109418869, 0.07099422812461853, -0.02567479759454727, -0.001298480317927897, -0.012405816465616226, -0.009845299646258354, -0.0019920077174901962, 0.018013421446084976, 0.028337886556982994, 0.03722637519240379, 0.029814397916197777, 0.014411812648177147, -0.028830301016569138, 0.019241107627749443, 0.0041072554886341095, -0.01031401101499796, -0.0032219162676483393, 0.0036074332892894745, 0.012556045316159725, -0.0400184690952301, -0.02548999898135662, -0.014450880698859692, -0.011912339366972446, 0.026767900213599205, 0.046670470386743546, -0.007631284184753895, -0.004676928278058767, -0.0633130595088005, -0.005872670561075211, 0.03844904154539108, -0.06519389152526855, -0.024061309173703194, -0.009758795611560345, 0.010644094087183475, -0.006069676484912634, -0.0007050827844068408 ]
<p>I am an actuary working on a Bayesian loss reserve model using incremental average severity data. Exploratory analysis of the response seems to suggest a skew normal distribution of some sort would be appropriate, as there are some negative values in the left tail, and the log transformed positive values fit a normal distribution fairly well. I was inspired by <a href="http://www.casact.org/newsletter/index.cfm?fa=viewart&amp;id=6544" rel="nofollow">this posting</a> by Glenn Meyers and feel like the latter parameterization should be easy to implement in JAGS. However, since I am not used to JAGS, I am struggling to set the model up. Here is a example of what I am trying to do.</p> <pre><code>#Likelihood (training set) for (i in 1:n){ y[i] ~ dnorm(z[i], tau) z[i] ~ dlnorm(mu[i], tauln) mu[i] &lt;- beta1*Dev[i] + ... } </code></pre> <p>I am not sure how to handle the negative $\mu_i$s in the absence of control structures (<code>if</code>, <code>else</code>, etc...) I am used to. I need to pass the zero valued or negative $\mu_i$s directly to the mean parameter for my response <em>y</em><sub>i</sub>. Is there a clever way to do this with the step function? Should I consider specifying the normal-log-normal mixture another way? FYI – I also posted this question <a href="https://sourceforge.net/p/mcmc-jags/discussion/610036/thread/9061a96e/" rel="nofollow">here</a>.</p>
74,451
[ -0.0003556555020622909, -0.030882148072123528, -0.005184991750866175, 0.010240278206765652, 0.048350028693675995, 0.011902100406587124, -0.014231937006115913, -0.02760131284594536, 0.023690471425652504, -0.06715945899486542, 0.05484865978360176, 0.01861838437616825, 0.05322258546948433, 0.006635317113250494, 0.028057917952537537, 0.0088155223056674, -0.017769329249858856, -0.002059078076854348, -0.053549014031887054, 0.006112325936555862, -0.007213632110506296, -0.010151050984859467, 0.010917246341705322, 0.01359853520989418, -0.027225647121667862, 0.02503952570259571, 0.01335051842033863, -0.01759283058345318, -0.05955228954553604, 0.04120275750756264, -0.03072332963347435, -0.000013489354387274943, -0.02359323762357235, 0.016671868041157722, -0.013381795957684517, 0.024410653859376907, -0.0357317291200161, -0.02918758988380432, 0.0016968469135463238, 0.015444976277649403, 0.004696510266512632, -0.00647627841681242, -0.022128403186798096, 0.0040343934670090675, 0.0010227822931483388, 0.014864844270050526, -0.012356381863355637, -0.026514926925301552, 0.0047999219968914986, -0.027198074385523796, 0.05256282165646553, -0.015601367689669132, 0.022291943430900574, 0.037896960973739624, 0.0325130894780159, -0.04014425352215767, 0.04465033486485481, 0.04759645834565163, 0.037082940340042114, -0.04999709874391556, -0.010201667435467243, -0.010448627173900604, -0.015608403831720352, -0.011760144494473934, 0.017116567119956017, -0.021476203575730324, 0.017410852015018463, -0.035743921995162964, 0.04210022836923599, -0.019696803763508797, 0.019365016371011734, 0.024332262575626373, -0.001316745183430612, 0.016635438427329063, 0.05330090969800949, -0.03128228709101677, -0.010607070289552212, 0.03956840559840202, 0.023788820952177048, 0.03490465506911278, 0.011349344626069069, 0.009418550878763199, 0.021639784798026085, 0.029309604316949844, 0.01871529407799244, -0.004363044165074825, 0.08019840717315674, -0.04944775998592377, 0.06240271404385567, 0.034510836005210876, -0.05438914895057678, 0.002258512657135725, 0.03348459675908089, -0.0052270954474806786, -0.047735996544361115, 0.04022068530321121, -0.03199959173798561, 0.07052599638700485, 0.008561542257666588, 0.0018507898785173893, -0.03705385699868202, -0.07419520616531372, 0.019386831670999527, 0.01905786618590355, -0.016962414607405663, 0.022838298231363297, -0.008882079273462296, -0.006973509676754475, 0.0025768245104700327, -0.0690096989274025, -0.06297416985034943, 0.035567060112953186, -0.005625023972243071, -0.0018281525699421763, 0.020249202847480774, -0.030091507360339165, -0.01064705103635788, -0.024551641196012497, 0.024989765137434006, 0.026626138016581535, 0.05986180156469345, 0.003350814338773489, 0.04313116893172264, -0.018850354477763176, -0.05070727691054344, 0.010936680249869823, 0.04188209027051926, -0.01943509466946125, -0.05151817575097084, 0.016850655898451805, -0.0014605224132537842, 0.003096628235653043, 0.07842382788658142, -0.001064329408109188, 0.029985083267092705, -0.008033446036279202, -0.020815778523683548, -0.07914925366640091, 0.026319269090890884, -0.020325463265180588, 0.012614069506525993, -0.058341603726148605, -0.05506299436092377, 0.03779548406600952, 0.006781827192753553, -0.0035052939783781767, 0.03332124650478363, 0.016735661774873734, -0.0017292638076469302, 0.013315873220562935, -0.008194188587367535, -0.001983077498152852, -0.049031272530555725, -0.009352565743029118, -0.044017400592565536, -0.08737022429704666, 0.06772378087043762, 0.006147426087409258, -0.013876899145543575, -0.002549605444073677, 0.027327463030815125, 0.0012173298746347427, 0.013088632375001907, -0.018589656800031662, -0.0197076927870512, -0.045714158564805984, 0.08798600733280182, 0.00017366318206768483, 0.03510775789618492, -0.0019390098750591278, 0.0349762924015522, -0.01463282946497202, -0.0013883643550798297, 0.05011753365397453, 0.05936431884765625, -0.0387745201587677, -0.006542033050209284, -0.02231290005147457, 0.008931421674787998, 0.03202235698699951, -0.0076394095085561275, 0.026631619781255722, -0.057903584092855453, 0.007437774445861578, -0.02172718569636345, -0.007445051800459623, 0.005672068800777197, 0.008553404361009598, 0.049202945083379745, -0.04406585544347763, -0.029290925711393356, -0.05737444385886192, -0.0018877180991694331, 0.009489556774497032, 0.012371462769806385, 0.0013824187917634845, -0.03938496485352516, 0.049373697489500046, 0.027524560689926147, 0.0007856191950850189, 0.024989614263176918, 0.012766576372087002, 0.04839790239930153, -0.043674178421497345, 0.002342973370105028, 0.03644413873553276, 0.044806528836488724, -0.04642189294099808, 0.028804056346416473, -0.05303841456770897, -0.011812048964202404, -0.022693926468491554, -0.028967292979359627, 0.03108130767941475, 0.019514480605721474, 0.00492235878482461, 0.0046374183148145676, -0.028810802847146988, 0.011027166619896889, 0.0026971662882715464, -0.0659160315990448, 0.0703701302409172, 0.14144162833690643, 0.006031899247318506, 0.017543939873576164, 0.01976042427122593, 0.004671770613640547, 0.02408422902226448, -0.013694140128791332, -0.00010346654016757384, -0.054307665675878525, -0.017928529530763626, 0.04258662089705467, -0.0049528321251273155, -0.0217902772128582, -0.00014346794341690838, 0.06009216979146004, -0.041544701904058456, 0.02080434188246727, 0.030846012756228447, -0.008905528113245964, 0.007400228176265955, -0.009597185999155045, 0.007038569077849388, 0.018186943605542183, -0.009285320527851582, 0.02477715164422989, -0.023675499483942986, 0.044144321233034134, -0.047885019332170486, 0.014531266875565052, 0.00464888010174036, 0.022120749577879906, 0.028120992705225945, -0.028200551867485046, -0.014123436994850636, 0.04243917018175125, -0.015218176878988743, -0.010342185385525227, 0.04627013951539993, -0.018743623048067093, -0.03568010777235031, 0.016595987603068352, -0.014241241849958897, 0.026733282953500748, 0.048512957990169525, 0.006697268225252628, 0.0368228480219841, 0.016131116077303886, -0.023284990340471268, 0.04899561405181885, -0.021828951314091682, -0.010813500732183456, 0.004470283165574074, 0.029264502227306366, 0.009115660563111305, 0.04339606314897537, 0.005978603381663561, -0.05366784706711769, -0.03240993618965149, -0.010064464993774891, 0.02325638011097908, 0.052218105643987656, 0.03555247187614441, -0.04833623394370079, -0.01130065880715847, -0.01186638604849577, 0.006397082936018705, 0.014489926397800446, 0.020393047481775284, -0.02479666844010353, -0.006413107737898827, -0.014494821429252625, -0.066956527531147, -0.045605894178152084, 0.012110093608498573, -0.021099718287587166, 0.003455368336290121, -0.03331049904227257, 0.06463208794593811, 0.04350210353732109, -0.04805900156497955, 0.04023822769522667, -0.03675080090761185, -0.021406300365924835, -0.05029050633311272, -0.03858647122979164, 0.02103431150317192, -0.006600131746381521, 0.01683732494711876, 0.003755398327484727, -0.041715171188116074, 0.03731703385710716, -0.06406094133853912, -0.04433021321892738, -0.0031020171009004116, 0.02503543719649315, 0.01832239143550396, -0.003490458708256483, 0.022926028817892075, 0.06520618498325348, 0.007148518692702055, 0.010941552929580212, -0.03729226440191269, 0.005886965896934271, -0.006122244521975517, -0.05530642718076706, -0.008448215201497078, 0.017652513459324837, 0.02609162963926792, 0.018100330606102943, -0.04298921301960945, 0.05042833834886551, 0.020946545526385307, 0.01831357181072235, -0.01970982924103737, 0.023260705173015594, -0.02427969127893448, 0.016252795234322548, 0.038021016865968704, 0.05447760969400406, 0.03336169198155403, 0.04285738989710808, -0.013047736138105392, 0.00287352642044425, 0.012546297162771225, -0.03809018433094025, 0.019935226067900658, 0.04560697451233864, -0.012636344879865646, -0.023511655628681183, 0.023631075397133827, 0.02149401605129242, -0.06686311960220337, -0.04137789458036423, 0.0248459093272686, 0.060894135385751724, -0.0276621263474226, -0.03457063436508179, 0.02917991578578949, 0.027759838849306107, -0.0030396580696105957, -0.010850541293621063, -0.026915019378066063, 0.0018082914175465703, 0.008240248076617718, -0.034506067633628845, 0.03607914596796036, 0.006578925997018814, 0.03346676751971245, 0.015578159131109715, -0.03424756973981857, -0.019123932346701622, -0.011670044623315334, -0.05540471896529198, -0.014484629966318607, -0.032074183225631714, 0.029400955885648727, 0.022380806505680084, 0.0016869684914126992, 0.0302383154630661, -0.02565789967775345, 0.020376618951559067, 0.002707836916670203, -0.08020958304405212, 0.02843763865530491, -0.01825578883290291, 0.009796562604606152, -0.01586822420358658, -0.019941626116633415, 0.05603467673063278, -0.0067908428609371185, 0.006286709103733301, -0.007825326174497604, 0.03796939551830292, -0.010345305316150188, 0.012049359269440174, -0.03543303534388542, -0.0312809981405735, -0.012224383652210236, 0.013053568080067635, 0.0072630769573152065, -0.002968017477542162, -0.00607390096411109, 0.004090756177902222, 0.029292196035385132, -0.0013844582717865705, -0.027833059430122375, 0.012345606461167336, 0.005430079996585846, 0.025178449228405952, 0.03850769251585007, 0.06792806833982468, -0.05177020654082298, -0.0016762522282078862, -0.007546840235590935, 0.030692126601934433, 0.060925815254449844, -0.008359340019524097, -0.03324952349066734, -0.052712246775627136, -0.04374552518129349, 0.026164907962083817, 0.0024935801047831774, 0.01936217211186886, 0.026996828615665436, 0.04194675758481026, 0.035320959985256195, -0.05741051584482193, 0.014256862923502922, 0.04059312492609024, 0.022546157240867615, 0.0003513396077323705, -0.005934772547334433, 0.02778126671910286, -0.006698703859001398, -0.0019773230887949467, 0.010522644966840744, 0.02402796410024166, 0.00604701554402709, -0.004695795010775328, 0.019724499434232712, -0.015658235177397728, -0.0026150562334805727, 0.030171329155564308, 0.024116063490509987, 0.027736471965909004, 0.014138824306428432, -0.004416566342115402, 0.05621645599603653, 0.021862264722585678, 0.03930022194981575, 0.0048302472569048405, 0.010066579096019268, -0.06491634249687195, -0.01582004874944687, 0.03912465274333954, 0.05500518158078194, -0.033159613609313965, -0.019531041383743286, -0.05667268484830856, -0.04741440340876579, -0.0018939959118142724, -0.024967914447188377, 0.018121298402547836, -0.00398366991430521, 0.016395991668105125, 0.02801530435681343, -0.028147421777248383, -0.07087650150060654, 0.024362200871109962, -0.01521294005215168, 0.02384149841964245, 0.01022353395819664, -0.012913205660879612, -0.01959376223385334, 0.016779562458395958, -0.02143900841474533, 0.04721790924668312, -0.054085273295640945, -0.036333538591861725, 0.004809207748621702, 0.0059972223825752735, 0.022159244865179062, -0.04878149554133415, 0.017839893698692322, -0.004101666156202555, -0.013797665014863014, 0.029963521286845207, 0.027444465085864067, -0.02555168606340885, 0.02761196531355381, 0.05085696280002594, -0.014909212477505207, 0.006268537137657404, -0.008738423697650433, 0.04954024776816368, 0.02455386333167553, -0.012250256724655628, 0.061147015541791916, 0.01942448318004608, -0.01574660651385784, -0.015084470622241497, -0.029597830027341843, 0.01728028804063797, -0.03500447794795036, -0.009818010032176971, -0.08178900927305222, 0.010977477766573429, -0.006796509027481079, 0.029973788186907768, -0.004347811918705702, 0.011911078356206417, -0.03138180077075958, -0.030574416741728783, 0.040918074548244476, -0.008006096817553043, -0.028846414759755135, -0.036608316004276276, 0.004537131637334824, 0.006839079782366753, -0.02521892637014389, 0.012027623131871223, 0.032084010541439056, -0.07761535793542862, 0.017105789855122566, 0.03505181521177292, -0.07461118698120117, -0.005187429022043943, -0.024834174662828445, -0.02299235761165619, -0.000004999851171305636, -0.0217282697558403, 0.027711350470781326, 0.021362416446208954, 0.018356425687670708, -0.006359879858791828, -0.0038010631687939167, 0.04310805723071098, -0.005195187870413065, -0.01806740276515484, -0.02804851345717907, -0.03976814076304436, 0.03208816796541214, 0.0006983726052567363, 0.00008685606007929891, -0.0760025605559349, -0.016364065930247307, 0.022397223860025406, -0.02365480363368988, 0.008717703633010387, -0.04677717760205269, -0.04404021054506302, 0.0114202369004488, -0.029204312711954117, -0.02729947678744793, 0.04576900973916054, -0.048162855207920074, -0.004695025738328695, -0.0369548425078392, 0.01737567037343979, 0.06832004338502884, -0.001738163409754634, 0.02013646438717842, 0.048037100583314896, -0.007848495617508888, -0.010953833349049091, -0.008164770901203156, 0.02777322567999363, -0.023897359147667885, -0.0049504730850458145, 0.01183171197772026, -0.021584220230579376, 0.04673052579164505, -0.019330136477947235, -0.038843829184770584, 0.015206625685095787, 0.03959059715270996, 0.011196867562830448, -0.028387753292918205, -0.02174256555736065, 0.002171378117054701, -0.01799153722822666, -0.03639989346265793, 0.0074065132066607475, -0.007388740312308073, 0.005661324597895145, 0.03847774490714073, 0.004645451437681913, 0.041678398847579956, 0.037744466215372086, 0.042224954813718796, 0.012214405462145805, -0.005953282117843628, 0.015328243374824524, -0.0017215658444911242, 0.034563031047582626, 0.02096560411155224, -0.006109486799687147, 0.006284578703343868, -0.005716503597795963, -0.03176246955990791, -0.023479999974370003, -0.048627521842718124, -0.0035380783956497908, 0.01516523864120245, 0.01812773570418358, 0.030942576006054878, -0.02780752070248127, 0.00934174470603466, -0.005923863500356674, -0.03448404371738434, 0.003500356338918209, -0.030517786741256714, 0.012768317945301533, 0.041196852922439575, -0.020244330167770386, 0.05635563284158707, -0.004122014157474041, 0.0007281231810338795, 0.029922671616077423, 0.03168994188308716, 0.022348983213305473, 0.033439915627241135, 0.01788279227912426, -0.037032678723335266, -0.029213877394795418, -0.00047755445120856166, -0.04039823263883591, 0.03166522458195686, -0.028232844546437263, -0.03882346302270889, 0.027093054726719856, 0.026673732325434685, 0.007174438796937466, -0.0708758756518364, -0.0026934361085295677, -0.0789511501789093, 0.036853231489658356, 0.05231519043445587, -0.02909150905907154, 0.026912905275821686, 0.003036500420421362, 0.06906783580780029, -0.05012636259198189, 0.01160658709704876, -0.03913148120045662, -0.06873557716608047, -0.0054106456227600574, -0.038850221782922745, -0.04973004013299942, 0.042769502848386765, -0.013800526037812233, 0.014980504289269447, 0.004529618192464113, -0.037719424813985825, 0.0341813750565052, -0.019706234335899353, 0.0013402177719399333, -0.0006766344886273146, 0.060787636786699295, -0.005817129276692867, -0.01873166672885418, -0.03364544361829758, -0.02186262048780918, 0.14001603424549103, 0.07044786959886551, 0.030893774703145027, -0.04862106591463089, -0.027963634580373764, -0.016018636524677277, 0.003790538525208831, -0.004856619983911514, -0.014917909167706966, 0.0376400500535965, -0.024882132187485695, 0.034794796258211136, 0.04435436427593231, 0.007887701503932476, 0.011265910230576992, 0.01694597490131855, -0.020151635631918907, 0.011975500732660294, -0.0036321687512099743, 0.005340173374861479, 0.012336787767708302, -0.010895011946558952, -0.03735782951116562, 0.040588703006505966, 0.03334121033549309, -0.0239358302205801, -0.01941140741109848, -0.022097617387771606, -0.009035867638885975, 0.01534517016261816, 0.0030761598609387875, -0.0033401953987777233, 0.02342809922993183, 0.027111245319247246, 0.05861052870750427, -0.008542635478079319, 0.024374689906835556, -0.032245706766843796, 0.01619139313697815, 0.039511553943157196, -0.02018510363996029, 0.0023745731450617313, 0.00911621656268835, -0.005557517521083355, -0.05594010278582573, -0.05455496907234192, -0.02335941046476364, 0.02859712392091751, -0.016139330342411995, -0.028519561514258385, -0.031100988388061523, -0.03410983830690384, 0.014404673129320145, -0.02241867408156395, -0.007527521345764399, 0.051838621497154236, 0.05109315738081932, -0.041070468723773956, 0.002284818096086383, 0.03892599418759346, 0.010898979380726814, 0.02367839403450489, 0.02830950915813446, 0.036714665591716766, -0.019188133999705315, -0.05292510986328125, -0.016330329701304436, 0.03238709270954132, 0.0026859038043767214, -0.004354606382548809, 0.011933586560189724, 0.026695111766457558, -0.03387722000479698, 0.030676178634166718, -0.005881038960069418, 0.0034036843571811914, 0.02096845768392086, 0.023335134610533714, 0.014149420894682407, -0.02585727348923683, -0.026508266106247902, 0.011455606669187546, -0.04209413006901741, 0.008617524057626724, -0.030116843059659004, -0.025198455899953842, 0.005638010334223509, 0.042929552495479584, -0.0155193991959095, 0.01291639544069767, 0.015498182736337185, 0.10351496934890747, 0.014838465489447117, -0.025801347568631172, -0.029240962117910385, 0.04411329701542854, -0.04707656055688858, 0.03687891736626625, 0.01650078594684601, 0.05400591343641281, -0.0029969566967338324, 0.034400034695863724, -0.04172034189105034, 0.022223232313990593, -0.009852837771177292, -0.001311986823566258, 0.03825880587100983, -0.04927203804254532, 0.024700960144400597, -0.015769625082612038, 0.022114310413599014, 0.0009927459759637713, 0.017685169354081154, -0.015527429059147835, -0.04711108282208443, 0.002408636501058936, 0.01073547638952732, 0.005267011933028698, 0.015319811180233955, -0.014400956220924854, 0.005095317959785461, 0.001600699033588171, 0.013535939157009125, -0.0017915068892762065, 0.0008525675511918962, -0.02112511917948723, 0.006498332135379314, -0.017476433888077736, -0.0012877992121502757, -0.03707007318735123, -0.006904671899974346, 0.019671162590384483, 0.020168466493487358, 0.04468576982617378, 0.01626194454729557, -0.017080465331673622, 0.004578748252242804, 0.04314308986067772, -0.014384930022060871, -0.000404589984100312, 0.005667061544954777, -0.022984718903899193, -0.027844835072755814, 0.011786135844886303, 0.0535716786980629, 0.014992471784353256, -0.035145103931427, -0.0021733969915658236, -0.04830646142363548, 0.02383500337600708, -0.004037147853523493, 0.01017395406961441, 0.003407180542126298, 0.009442082606256008, -0.016696108505129814, -0.009850163012742996, -0.015289463102817535, 0.029985960572957993, 0.033244308084249496, 0.022094452753663063, -0.004872093442827463, 0.009053520858287811, -0.0019600605592131615, 0.009252544492483139, 0.007054225541651249, 0.00022625693236477673, -0.03657490387558937, 0.01354964915663004, 0.001676680170930922, 0.03896411880850792, -0.00812602136284113, 0.02276773937046528, -0.04905983433127403, -0.007297579664736986, -0.07054702192544937, -0.039802201092243195, 0.03462204709649086, -0.002042848151177168, 0.02691829390823841, -0.043645020574331284, 0.003911375999450684, -0.01070220023393631, 0.00011732127313734964, -0.01714021898806095, -0.04122557491064072, 0.003796227741986513, -0.015164417214691639, -0.019413769245147705, -0.02408304065465927, 0.006172709167003632, 0.014997475780546665, 0.03041950799524784, 0.04210013523697853, 0.02155601605772972, 0.024098562076687813, -0.03390803188085556, -0.011760215274989605, 0.004821921698749065, 0.04190690442919731, -0.06841260939836502, 0.05040429159998894, -0.04470376670360565, -0.000017890923118102364, 0.007557818200439215, 0.016984937712550163, 0.024892831221222878, -0.0159009899944067, 0.02373058721423149, 0.04422355815768242, 0.08318813890218735, 0.06160120293498039, 0.008480108343064785, -0.00019417515431996435, 0.007943239994347095, 0.012849879451096058, -0.0013726245379075408, -0.02540970779955387, 0.02622140198945999, 0.0469808503985405, 0.00628823833540082, 0.00043378330883570015, 0.003568968502804637, -0.023447925224900246, -0.04808945208787918, -0.015699831768870354, -0.0039652930572628975, -0.0004692140209954232, -0.02630024403333664, -0.0010004632640630007, -0.03560197353363037, 0.0145022664219141, 0.06466256082057953, 0.006944167893379927, -0.01733950898051262, -0.02692955918610096, -0.05301172286272049, -0.05560719966888428, -0.024700123816728592, 0.00007965384429553524, -0.044060997664928436, -0.062353938817977905, -0.020820697769522667, -0.04013022035360336, 0.00839703157544136, -0.03600040078163147, 0.03672844171524048, -0.04622339829802513, 0.04697239771485329, -0.02590274065732956, 0.056839119642972946, 0.026253653690218925, -0.013492676429450512, 0.031756967306137085, -0.07016691565513611, 0.06512721627950668, 0.02180752530694008, -0.019868796691298485, 0.002742502838373184, -0.023237071931362152, -0.022344538941979408, 0.0137209203094244, 0.064073346555233, -0.031110307201743126, -0.03255342319607735, 0.009348294697701931, 0.04019862040877342, 0.035108886659145355, -0.012438700534403324, 0.030318576842546463, -0.017342133447527885, -0.02316262014210224, -0.016588808968663216, 0.03154514357447624, 0.0194114837795496, 0.037215299904346466, -0.020659003406763077, -0.00238001043908298, -0.016606228426098824, -0.0008100159466266632, 0.0038837457541376352, 0.008523997850716114, -0.016442008316516876, -0.022982463240623474, 0.04016557335853577, 0.027558479458093643, 0.02011539787054062, 0.0072952331975102425, 0.024726374074816704, -0.04163272678852081, 0.020523618906736374, -0.044879503548145294, -0.04426632076501846, -0.012806045822799206, -0.019502602517604828, 0.033568333834409714, -0.04970952495932579, 0.02413959428668022, 0.030104080215096474, -0.021222006529569626, 0.0001453905424568802, 0.011997677385807037, 0.004971196409314871, 0.06412611156702042, 0.01119525358080864, 0.009477474726736546, 0.007515503093600273, -0.03617936372756958, 0.002531368052586913, -0.002306893700733781, 0.0023659802973270416, -0.028727151453495026, -0.006760663818567991, 0.023159148171544075, -0.025589654222130775, 0.043021008372306824, 0.0066885314881801605, 0.0129570746794343, -0.0021484610624611378, -0.030146265402436256, 0.036915071308612823, -0.009780650958418846, -0.020073097199201584, -0.04412170872092247, 0.002828404074534774, 0.014711698517203331, -0.018962521106004715, -0.00488439854234457, -0.010439958423376083, -0.019213924184441566, -0.038859814405441284, -0.008667887188494205, -0.03055148385465145, 0.004920023027807474, 0.03103623352944851, 0.0019036574522033334, 0.028966542333364487, -0.033672936260700226, 0.02955004759132862, -0.06867512315511703, 0.020937010645866394, 0.0023367423564195633, 0.016418669372797012, 0.053820837289094925, -0.06446750462055206, -0.05241147801280022, -0.015619226731359959, 0.004710485693067312, 0.002922960091382265, -0.003301168791949749, -0.04599810019135475, -0.026774005964398384, 0.01630213111639023, 0.0450468435883522, -0.05050050839781761, 0.01920151896774769, -0.04168430715799332, 0.0012537201400846243, -0.019151682034134865, -0.01354492362588644 ]
<p>My question is: is it possible to pool observations when it is the same countries that are observed through the years. I have observations on 37 countries in 2010, 47 countries in 2011 and 60 countries in 2012. However, it is the same countries that have been observed (more countries are though added). </p> <p>Which pitfalls might exist if i pool the countries and years, so i get 144 observations and use pooled ols? Should i use this command: reg y x (with time dummies), cluster(id)</p> <p>furthermore, would you say it is balanced or unbalanced dataset? And it is panel data I have, right? </p>
74,452
[ -0.04370006173849106, 0.019758854061365128, -0.020694920793175697, 0.009314429014921188, 0.04435902088880539, 0.0068524619564414024, -0.012239711359143257, -0.028386961668729782, 0.04260021448135376, -0.04070056602358818, 0.042196281254291534, 0.04006743058562279, 0.03606121614575386, 0.005634026601910591, 0.03043489344418049, 0.003287155646830797, 0.02331247366964817, 0.033066827803850174, 0.0031204468104988337, -0.000013945053069619462, -0.013490872457623482, 0.03465305268764496, -0.00962711963802576, -0.009180933237075806, -0.02151884324848652, 0.05109286308288574, -0.014829307794570923, -0.00017393009329680353, 0.02914300374686718, 0.06551680713891983, -0.014421354979276657, -0.023335931822657585, 0.02153698168694973, 0.006346111185848713, -0.008779716677963734, -0.024158932268619537, 0.009834354743361473, -0.031014487147331238, -0.010750134475529194, -0.002751080086454749, -0.05661725252866745, 0.006558843422681093, -0.021476004272699356, 0.044781483709812164, 0.004686207510530949, 0.036425650119781494, 0.0019225900759920478, -0.007607289124280214, 0.034535013139247894, -0.039981257170438766, 0.07092338800430298, -0.004674847703427076, 0.048411060124635696, 0.0740424171090126, -0.023158017545938492, 0.005338467191904783, 0.05821080133318901, 0.05046930909156799, 0.008235872723162174, 0.018110089004039764, -0.014071100391447544, -0.0018811009358614683, 0.04859263822436333, -0.02848586067557335, -0.02153359167277813, 0.015017557889223099, 0.01726032793521881, -0.00735203642398119, 0.025270668789744377, -0.01211925595998764, 0.01659334823489189, 0.025936929509043694, 0.028237169608473778, -0.02171359956264496, 0.004272927064448595, -0.06726913899183273, 0.031243151053786278, 0.0020870291627943516, 0.03583399951457977, 0.014433280564844608, 0.018737468868494034, 0.052101828157901764, 0.05254422128200531, -0.007177688181400299, 0.058264683932065964, -0.02352924644947052, 0.05614132806658745, -0.04697925224900246, 0.008785868063569069, 0.022165590897202492, -0.012055234983563423, 0.013788560405373573, 0.03141337260603905, 0.036315154284238815, -0.04253725707530975, 0.03355879709124565, -0.016183415427803993, 0.05710207298398018, -0.01747164875268936, 0.009925132617354393, 0.006508549675345421, -0.03597618266940117, -0.02210899069905281, 0.039272792637348175, 0.019215218722820282, 0.003316811751574278, -0.03642487898468971, -0.022231699898838997, 0.01999705657362938, -0.01475322525948286, -0.03883728012442589, 0.0007212645723484457, -0.012752610258758068, -0.04491123557090759, 0.03701598942279816, -0.01632838137447834, -0.007694966159760952, 0.009387618862092495, 0.02603829652070999, 0.0609317384660244, 0.022998424246907234, -0.05471642315387726, 0.058203548192977905, -0.018014704808592796, -0.09002409130334854, 0.04744027927517891, 0.005658957175910473, -0.009705527685582638, -0.08655037730932236, 0.044409677386283875, 0.03869284316897392, -0.048408087342977524, 0.009972551837563515, -0.024108195677399635, 0.04302950203418732, 0.019233999773859978, -0.08504588156938553, -0.0792301744222641, 0.007886117324233055, -0.06298598647117615, 0.005445694550871849, -0.06556015461683273, 0.004181731026619673, -0.028033914044499397, 0.07809028029441833, 0.0027164623606950045, 0.05366881564259529, 0.04789746552705765, 0.043225690722465515, 0.024402746930718422, 0.0022191402968019247, -0.016588516533374786, 0.0075974129140377045, -0.05142708495259285, 0.016584187746047974, -0.08699207007884979, 0.008756275288760662, -0.0021073229145258665, 0.018587594851851463, 0.011814054101705551, 0.018654929473996162, 0.022928033024072647, -0.007103422190994024, -0.02287095971405506, 0.024503257125616074, -0.033672552555799484, 0.06349297612905502, -0.01799049600958824, 0.05067663639783859, 0.012491426430642605, -0.016268957406282425, 0.03256097808480263, 0.03190046548843384, 0.04510838910937309, 0.03194756060838699, -0.0028998437337577343, 0.013481652364134789, -0.03306584432721138, 0.005498072598129511, -0.009261446073651314, -0.06597176939249039, -0.0304866936057806, -0.014985162764787674, -0.005087943747639656, 0.0027344003319740295, 0.02867458388209343, 0.006373371463268995, 0.010771169327199459, 0.0023891055025160313, -0.06058703362941742, -0.0593562126159668, -0.07158616930246353, -0.002663885010406375, -0.021364934742450714, 0.024798646569252014, -0.0003321392578072846, -0.0177531149238348, 0.031920693814754486, -0.0048303850926458836, -0.04385429993271828, -0.01768314652144909, 0.01591281220316887, 0.024397261440753937, -0.04751170799136162, -0.01681479625403881, 0.015564688481390476, 0.059638045728206635, 0.007487672846764326, 0.06690517067909241, -0.053948935121297836, -0.021085742861032486, 0.012114436365664005, -0.033743686974048615, 0.009301681071519852, 0.0004715264367405325, -0.011740176007151604, -0.0012836003443226218, -0.00015332354814745486, -0.03966464474797249, 0.03936809301376343, -0.04303470626473427, 0.06030908226966858, 0.05123543739318848, -0.008161064237356186, 0.013631192035973072, 0.030911948531866074, 0.00038553171907551587, 0.006533286068588495, -0.0235558170825243, -0.03176926448941231, -0.07427023351192474, -0.004068182781338692, 0.006775035057216883, 0.025236614048480988, 0.004177604801952839, 0.036987368017435074, 0.027485230937600136, 0.002640175400301814, -0.0018347710138186812, -0.009815461933612823, 0.006601846311241388, -0.025015519931912422, 0.02332603931427002, 0.021809889003634453, 0.010528973303735256, 0.028842473402619362, 0.027180161327123642, -0.005241102539002895, 0.02444102242588997, 0.004444883670657873, -0.010256902314722538, 0.04125676304101944, -0.001652624225243926, 0.015813689678907394, 0.0032931696623563766, -0.029980218037962914, 0.012612038291990757, -0.025697872042655945, 0.021772827953100204, 0.008432382717728615, 0.03601202368736267, -0.009513878263533115, -0.02617936208844185, -0.023380659520626068, 0.00276432977989316, 0.02031232789158821, -0.03593694418668747, -0.00884947832673788, 0.010126681067049503, -0.015818871557712555, 0.019860820844769478, -0.005501861218363047, -0.008032683283090591, -0.01941353641450405, 0.03601439297199249, 0.031895168125629425, -0.027782777324318886, 0.018908562138676643, -0.017020247876644135, -0.01283306535333395, -0.02348420023918152, 0.016534913331270218, 0.007069316226989031, 0.0008658876176923513, -0.025881970301270485, 0.011601592414081097, -0.01342166867107153, -0.016574067994952202, 0.04017621651291847, -0.001605197205208242, -0.011988130398094654, 0.05727279186248779, 0.007553061004728079, -0.030672335997223854, -0.023007867857813835, -0.005984664894640446, 0.02789749763906002, -0.028655391186475754, -0.034087762236595154, 0.018235616385936737, 0.017544450238347054, -0.03394549340009689, -0.016894208267331123, -0.05871663615107536, -0.028542138636112213, -0.008043114095926285, 0.0001715782273095101, 0.03363553807139397, -0.031102711334824562, 0.02359730191528797, 0.02598428726196289, -0.020732708275318146, -0.003317962633445859, -0.023469019681215286, -0.06162406876683235, 0.0269930399954319, -0.007307059597223997, 0.0016903351061046124, -0.0015526835341006517, -0.023634757846593857, 0.05169408768415451, 0.0004462299693841487, -0.002545885043218732, -0.029265448451042175, -0.005241837818175554, 0.01705433614552021, -0.023784847930073738, 0.05043121427297592, 0.010293738916516304, 0.015189360827207565, 0.0010713636875152588, -0.013081375509500504, -0.0008812107844278216, 0.06667156517505646, -0.03256664797663689, 0.004335671663284302, 0.012219710275530815, -0.0019138576462864876, -0.0055489689111709595, 0.04250728711485863, 0.020288975909352303, -0.033780790865421295, -0.00440537603572011, 0.019689414650201797, 0.023742500692605972, 0.005855836905539036, -0.036664437502622604, 0.042481500655412674, -0.0069027673453092575, 0.02590285614132881, -0.028737880289554596, 0.03183548152446747, 0.021640142425894737, -0.036072101444005966, -0.04003667086362839, 0.0007807661313563585, 0.012180752120912075, 0.005970836617052555, -0.007206907495856285, 0.06623932719230652, 0.018486708402633667, 0.008172840811312199, -0.01295136846601963, -0.016138136386871338, -0.011118543334305286, 0.04437332972884178, -0.016031133010983467, -0.02610875479876995, 0.026043502613902092, 0.019673338159918785, -0.0010605639545246959, -0.012634755112230778, -0.032928623259067535, -0.002487462479621172, -0.0906318947672844, -0.0028359501156955957, -0.015846701338887215, 0.04536356404423714, -0.007127510849386454, 0.007730694487690926, 0.026505788788199425, -0.004720355849713087, 0.0013291958021000028, -0.012965994887053967, -0.03172151371836662, 0.001246695057488978, -0.0064734648913145065, -0.008607112802565098, -0.0010298332199454308, -0.02540368214249611, 0.014931104145944118, 0.00003941912291338667, 0.005752451252192259, -0.008957000449299812, 0.01019778847694397, -0.02367677167057991, -0.020646199584007263, 0.004270053468644619, 0.004702919628471136, 0.01758694462478161, 0.00328281638212502, 0.017727764323353767, -0.0033353085163980722, 0.04448598250746727, 0.014968359842896461, 0.01394068542867899, -0.02176286280155182, -0.030410585924983025, -0.020249586552381516, 0.011152820661664009, 0.04340174049139023, 0.011012513190507889, 0.04008379206061363, -0.034356776624917984, 0.0060327802784740925, 0.008396386168897152, 0.03904701769351959, 0.019162889569997787, 0.002669819165021181, -0.03323230519890785, -0.026131533086299896, -0.01839691586792469, 0.03424051031470299, 0.004529624246060848, 0.02625260502099991, 0.01597684435546398, 0.03433755785226822, 0.024524502456188202, -0.040928784757852554, 0.02282997965812683, 0.07887136191129684, 0.02967730537056923, 0.002169886603951454, -0.020049143582582474, -0.0006248342688195407, 0.006904365960508585, -0.0009312586626037955, 0.03980567678809166, 0.010254988446831703, -0.006102446466684341, -0.0018906110199168324, 0.04436585679650307, -0.008818818256258965, -0.05821092426776886, 0.015984810888767242, 0.0298443716019392, 0.044576603919267654, -0.018845733255147934, -0.05275655910372734, 0.028941666707396507, 0.053951624780893326, 0.05347175896167755, 0.0691756084561348, -0.0038069940637797117, -0.08828579634428024, 0.0020067363511770964, 0.04387776553630829, 0.02913670241832733, -0.04299881309270859, 0.025053968653082848, -0.016342265531420708, 0.006681791972368956, 0.005480766296386719, -0.042412012815475464, 0.03227786347270012, -0.0557723231613636, 0.0039276317693293095, -0.013667244464159012, -0.02602430060505867, -0.004325283225625753, 0.017115114256739616, 0.020250089466571808, 0.058262601494789124, -0.0036453905049711466, -0.019395658746361732, -0.01936863362789154, 0.018656639382243156, 0.014964914880692959, -0.000008378889106097631, -0.027605123817920685, -0.004578768275678158, 0.016316596418619156, 0.0598352886736393, -0.04203968495130539, -0.0792480856180191, 0.007948610000312328, -0.008897820487618446, -0.009483658708631992, 0.037327785044908524, 0.02604757249355316, -0.021286945790052414, -0.007880035787820816, 0.024868564680218697, 0.018726453185081482, -0.00749322772026062, -0.003461403539404273, 0.033850837498903275, 0.007624500896781683, 0.008794302120804787, 0.03596610575914383, 0.029096461832523346, 0.03926082327961922, 0.02134791761636734, -0.021666809916496277, 0.014620105735957623, -0.0698109120130539, -0.02145342156291008, -0.0038427605759352446, -0.023074917495250702, -0.01874374970793724, -0.0014114086516201496, -0.04125424474477768, 0.03728318214416504, -0.044576093554496765, -0.016653114929795265, 0.0175333134829998, 0.003464462934061885, 0.006876129191368818, 0.00005080741902929731, -0.0009518839069642127, 0.013948250561952591, -0.015544900670647621, -0.023356260731816292, -0.018377160653471947, -0.016270428895950317, 0.004574859049171209, -0.006576248910278082, -0.025115204975008965, 0.02574504166841507, -0.03007109835743904, 0.01864723116159439, -0.002071307273581624, -0.0024318895302712917, 0.04190058261156082, 0.008718900382518768, 0.0073484089225530624, 0.003732002805918455, -0.04595102369785309, -0.0014465928543359041, 0.011078095063567162, -0.01754727214574814, 0.01736522652208805, -0.06947934627532959, 0.04312626272439957, 0.025646662339568138, -0.04704703018069267, -0.0943652093410492, -0.04657910019159317, 0.030394360423088074, 0.00023817138571757823, -0.007845310494303703, -0.046811506152153015, -0.0008672255207784474, 0.00015454133972525597, -0.03992197662591934, -0.057739488780498505, 0.07423814386129379, -0.01815464161336422, -0.008557523600757122, -0.03569178655743599, 0.011742828413844109, 0.09203622490167618, -0.041413769125938416, 0.03730440512299538, -0.007946277037262917, -0.061136841773986816, -0.012317318469285965, -0.05892593041062355, -0.0019462198251858354, -0.025791391730308533, 0.02371833845973015, -0.01018032431602478, 0.0065629743039608, 0.04480811581015587, -0.057118870317935944, -0.04875629022717476, 0.036059506237506866, -0.02448555827140808, 0.016499407589435577, -0.011344158090651035, 0.022642292082309723, -0.0555109977722168, -0.00427526980638504, -0.03208233416080475, 0.013668056577444077, 0.00641290657222271, -0.032979708164930344, 0.026519689708948135, -0.04074784740805626, -0.01988632045686245, 0.04618652164936066, 0.08038751035928726, -0.0066009447909891605, -0.00379231502301991, -0.005669413600116968, -0.052726272493600845, 0.05104620382189751, 0.005086199846118689, -0.035378649830818176, -0.006862633861601353, 0.028931330889463425, -0.019741307944059372, -0.0625099465250969, 0.020446788519620895, 0.03563462570309639, 0.07265905290842056, 0.000451250234618783, 0.01838422194123268, 0.09443941712379456, 0.03087328001856804, 0.03444235026836395, -0.018961962312459946, -0.00042973982635885477, 0.00038644560845568776, -0.005471442360430956, 0.06808313727378845, 0.018725518137216568, -0.008652380667626858, 0.011205400340259075, 0.011819692328572273, 0.041028063744306564, 0.04255852848291397, 0.007694792468100786, 0.040920112282037735, 0.0010314047103747725, -0.016167763620615005, -0.05743812397122383, 0.004320365842431784, -0.023235252127051353, -0.015208371914923191, -0.061517275869846344, -0.057756438851356506, 0.029083965346217155, 0.027048692107200623, 0.013318429701030254, -0.048313919454813004, -0.043885983526706696, -0.07245122641324997, 0.0034896605648100376, 0.03168531879782677, 0.006312985438853502, 0.02032097615301609, 0.04244406148791313, 0.05880581960082054, 0.04455578327178955, -0.01941816136240959, -0.02388850413262844, -0.09555962681770325, -0.04525919258594513, -0.03613820672035217, -0.006474270019680262, 0.015646250918507576, 0.00385429710149765, -0.01795983500778675, 0.0007920583593659103, -0.0014048831071704626, -0.017332226037979126, -0.010210397653281689, 0.06302335113286972, -0.03282445669174194, 0.05619341507554054, 0.0009423944866284728, 0.044481612741947174, -0.010241934098303318, 0.020133286714553833, 0.11736193299293518, 0.06492028385400772, 0.01840279996395111, -0.046711407601833344, 0.013333657756447792, 0.04843448847532272, -0.05765749141573906, -0.017838332802057266, -0.02158767729997635, -0.011927440762519836, 0.0006081429892219603, 0.01858288235962391, 0.06683677434921265, 0.047684039920568466, -0.022982198745012283, 0.04485941305756569, 0.003990468103438616, -0.016158094629645348, 0.0003853838425129652, 0.039068758487701416, -0.014762704260647297, -0.01068059355020523, -0.08146943897008896, 0.009643996134400368, 0.046893078833818436, 0.007608156185597181, -0.007221406791359186, -0.010547610931098461, 0.012092026881873608, 0.016896992921829224, -0.021723324432969093, 0.001303540077060461, 0.012264552526175976, 0.017366206273436546, -0.0450458750128746, 0.012713942676782608, 0.025178581476211548, -0.0357111431658268, 0.030456624925136566, 0.030990632250905037, -0.010523851960897446, -0.015717538073658943, -0.00929173082113266, -0.011953800916671753, -0.03231542557477951, -0.0005376030458137393, -0.004930066876113415, 0.02688600681722164, -0.03509058803319931, -0.02386939525604248, -0.003974132239818573, -0.020778752863407135, 0.017757806926965714, -0.015321959741413593, -0.02279718592762947, 0.0155143141746521, 0.032014988362789154, -0.02746056579053402, -0.01371101476252079, -0.037413980811834335, -0.023191997781395912, -0.04330270364880562, 0.03348433971405029, 0.012713846750557423, -0.04593752324581146, -0.008142261765897274, -0.062114764004945755, 0.03457910194993019, -0.005839343182742596, 0.005754556972533464, -0.018328947946429253, -0.006134412717074156, -0.027777234092354774, -0.02930503524839878, 0.025039568543434143, 0.03321782127022743, 0.021406562998890877, 0.011286933906376362, 0.003889569314196706, -0.034133028239011765, -0.03447731211781502, -0.021674444898962975, -0.03229968622326851, -0.0054816980846226215, -0.0536140501499176, 0.031068094074726105, 0.03660205751657486, 0.023180300369858742, -0.04805121198296547, 0.03393760323524475, 0.0093952976167202, 0.03175327181816101, 0.007826866582036018, -0.025582749396562576, 0.0025765218306332827, -0.008425833657383919, -0.05276278033852577, -0.01908031851053238, -0.04306425899267197, 0.055779870599508286, 0.008379776030778885, 0.01728539727628231, -0.012641340494155884, 0.05204656720161438, -0.015678882598876953, 0.018372315913438797, 0.043839674443006516, -0.04856244847178459, -0.013505670242011547, -0.004843998700380325, 0.023541247472167015, -0.04777929186820984, -0.029467370361089706, -0.010303488932549953, -0.011741592548787594, 0.024453869089484215, -0.028319712728261948, -0.057824015617370605, 0.024021923542022705, -0.01573118381202221, 0.016292070969939232, -0.017032565549016, 0.010700466111302376, -0.07679053395986557, -0.03420353680849075, -0.02264498732984066, -0.006937156431376934, -0.01616538316011429, 0.0006911807577125728, -0.0014807097613811493, -0.002562135923653841, 0.04611750319600105, 0.010073955170810223, -0.002672633621841669, 0.02750818245112896, 0.012606395408511162, -0.029488220810890198, 0.04434295743703842, -0.01855441741645336, -0.03283238038420677, 0.07292424142360687, -0.031896255910396576, 0.008725974708795547, 0.02145831100642681, -0.004709620960056782, 0.05120665952563286, 0.036240287125110626, 0.003186108311638236, -0.005811395589262247, 0.06521936506032944, -0.03646865487098694, 0.028511932119727135, -0.0028672143816947937, -0.0023030750453472137, 0.02220386639237404, 0.025402620434761047, -0.0014797626063227654, 0.03614138066768646, -0.04507498815655708, 0.04444371908903122, 0.027031229808926582, 0.0018616396700963378, -0.013586800545454025, -0.004772978834807873, 0.02659173682332039, 0.04485388845205307, -0.03757127746939659, -0.02318383939564228, 0.0014859925722703338, 0.04671354964375496, -0.07963595539331436, 0.018509991466999054, -0.0348258875310421, -0.015884364023804665, -0.021030280739068985, 0.009035938419401646, 0.012429015710949898, 0.0054418835788965225, 0.0215549748390913, -0.029291454702615738, -0.01599361002445221, 0.011308388784527779, -0.027081388980150223, -0.012040965259075165, -0.014954841695725918, -0.02169445902109146, -0.024693945422768593, 0.03150753304362297, -0.005649346858263016, 0.012839899398386478, 0.027206847444176674, 0.03395981341600418, 0.0020050425082445145, 0.026894133538007736, 0.03686467930674553, -0.04485393315553665, -0.02932691015303135, -0.018296552821993828, 0.011218199506402016, -0.04683053120970726, 0.050796255469322205, -0.03885747119784355, -0.026080423966050148, 0.028506893664598465, -0.048279039561748505, 0.024650901556015015, 0.02115057222545147, 0.009036342613399029, -0.01771966926753521, 0.029122555628418922, 0.006801130715757608, -0.027301901951432228, 0.01081639900803566, 0.014872325584292412, 0.02393876016139984, -0.007631714455783367, -0.00437880540266633, 0.035301968455314636, -0.008994526229798794, 0.013716964982450008, -0.006749395746737719, -0.02829584851861, -0.008203435689210892, -0.03349288925528526, 0.023553021252155304, -0.025472348555922508, 0.010408180765807629, 0.017197487875819206, 0.005608377978205681, 0.0077840113081038, 0.024562204256653786, 0.05624311417341232, 0.025060830637812614, -0.02507735602557659, 0.025316063314676285, -0.04452136158943176, -0.058564238250255585, 0.009973433800041676, -0.00805348064750433, -0.003973912447690964, -0.03310968726873398, -0.013239786028862, 0.05208718404173851, -0.023528456687927246, -0.02810601145029068, 0.006716970354318619, -0.016924038529396057, 0.0512646920979023, -0.01512302178889513, -0.000605946232099086, 0.050988566130399704, -0.023677363991737366, 0.02452867478132248, -0.0348144993185997, 0.029483726248145103, 0.02520720288157463, -0.022828811779618263, -0.017673131078481674, -0.03660758584737778, -0.057962674647569656, 0.020683595910668373, 0.02790522389113903, 0.0008497526869177818, 0.028025129809975624, 0.014056075364351273, 0.009668282233178616, 0.0050905728712677956, -0.00382405798882246, 0.04619332775473595, -0.01791321486234665, -0.027951518073678017, -0.0023136695381253958, -0.012404805049300194, 0.011271673254668713, -0.03474760800600052, -0.009248633868992329, -0.02952338382601738, -0.015822580084204674, 0.05846789851784706, 0.005466097965836525, 0.04689663276076317, -0.011572000570595264, -0.00006331776239676401, 0.02845786325633526, -0.003797742072492838, -0.014483095146715641, 0.01832818239927292, 0.023831067606806755, -0.05472051724791527, 0.01891617849469185, -0.062460027635097504, -0.01227040495723486, -0.01252802461385727, 0.0024475662503391504, -0.0023504600394517183, -0.05392460525035858, 0.01871398836374283, 0.03959735855460167, 0.0081572774797678, 0.004305613227188587, 0.052856191992759705, 0.019776908680796623, 0.016989095136523247, 0.01795857399702072, 0.02808569185435772, -0.01784578710794449, -0.013865704648196697, 0.003752897959202528, 0.03438510000705719, 0.02872077003121376, 0.017784735187888145, 0.02197674661874771, 0.006654978264123201, 0.0051193153485655785, 0.04351995512843132, -0.017150012776255608, 0.04856247827410698, -0.024454597383737564, -0.014763918705284595, 0.001034785294905305, 0.0007048324914649129, 0.03462735563516617, 0.032349806278944016, 0.005292627960443497, 0.034136366099119186, -0.05802200734615326, 0.01600344106554985, -0.0026340133044868708, -0.048034004867076874, -0.019579092040657997, -0.021312052384018898, 0.0036788613069802523, 0.0328434593975544, 0.008886151015758514, -0.008752427063882351, -0.06414101272821426, -0.045597415417432785, 0.032606057822704315, -0.00754365511238575, 0.040909599512815475, -0.06524944305419922, -0.007315569091588259, 0.018400751054286957, -0.015386642888188362, -0.053705718368291855, -0.014594919048249722, 0.038479775190353394, 0.032270751893520355, 0.020696502178907394, -0.01476798765361309, -0.025243442505598068, -0.008139824494719505, 0.013553867116570473, -0.053912196308374405, -0.03909755125641823, -0.05382208153605461, -0.010189587250351906, -0.006240827031433582, -0.005705258809030056 ]
<p>I have a data set of around 5000 features. For that data I first used Chi Square test for feature selection; after that, I got around 1500 variables which showed significance relationship with the response variable. </p> <p>Now I need to fit logistic regression on that. I am using glmulti package for R (glmulti package provides efficient subset selection for vlm) but it can use only 30 features at a time, else its performance goes down as the number of rows in my dataset is around 20000.</p> <p>Is there any other approach or techniques to solve the above problems? If I go by the above method it will take too much time to fit the model.</p>
74,453
[ -0.03542525693774223, 0.024928458034992218, 0.017874296754598618, 0.014566229656338692, 0.04355155676603317, -0.014299934729933739, -0.014976218342781067, -0.04802606254816055, 0.04937530681490898, -0.01953410729765892, 0.02248954586684704, 0.043276626616716385, 0.0031382236629724503, 0.01991892419755459, 0.016493577510118484, -0.015385880134999752, -0.003210120601579547, -0.018575144931674004, 0.0027921178843826056, -0.019231092184782028, -0.009216980077326298, -0.003516495693475008, 0.017087697982788086, 0.0062610371969640255, -0.04340701922774315, 0.05664585530757904, 0.013947876170277596, -0.009199907071888447, -0.004314054269343615, 0.05964519828557968, -0.03096321038901806, -0.016441907733678818, -0.0025252248160541058, 0.048574768006801605, 0.03294139355421066, -0.0010918424231931567, -0.005235667340457439, -0.03653212636709213, 0.0028002378530800343, 0.012299206107854843, 0.0021428591571748257, -0.017796674743294716, 0.027711983770132065, 0.030327897518873215, 0.00122857338283211, 0.027108557522296906, -0.016563743352890015, -0.03841353952884674, 0.028313763439655304, -0.050465263426303864, 0.089047871530056, 0.002459223847836256, 0.05490608885884285, 0.01300431601703167, -0.006810986436903477, -0.014810299500823021, 0.04067560285329819, 0.07799183577299118, -0.04206381365656853, -0.03092467412352562, 0.001798317302018404, -0.07205021381378174, 0.00601399689912796, -0.018100881949067116, -0.0369834266602993, 0.039585549384355545, -0.01741473749279976, 0.02088698372244835, 0.04942347854375839, -0.002752777887508273, 0.001648430130444467, -0.01304328441619873, 0.03761039301753044, -0.02229863964021206, -0.0014930256875231862, -0.051393188536167145, -0.007462941575795412, 0.006351441610604525, 0.03513561934232712, 0.031291309744119644, 0.006000767461955547, 0.009382007643580437, 0.013545623980462551, 0.03418485447764397, 0.03221050277352333, -0.04661361873149872, 0.05105550214648247, -0.011480662040412426, 0.0035677484702318907, 0.038569577038288116, -0.030268095433712006, 0.010712270624935627, 0.06153236702084541, 0.032398100942373276, -0.041706208139657974, 0.0058176531456410885, -0.02837505377829075, 0.02815108373761177, 0.05831249803304672, -0.0010428116656839848, -0.005322599783539772, -0.04350651428103447, -0.01246135588735342, 0.07340200245380402, -0.030117886140942574, 0.02796301804482937, -0.032355573028326035, -0.011484930291771889, 0.011180209927260876, -0.03433411940932274, 0.004694532137364149, 0.011083398945629597, 0.00038575625512748957, -0.0054911295883357525, 0.012333942577242851, -0.012478416785597801, -0.034482695162296295, -0.0578249953687191, 0.06534391641616821, 0.06352774798870087, 0.02255050279200077, -0.040888711810112, 0.009723091498017311, -0.023829197511076927, -0.01819833554327488, 0.01231654454022646, 0.0024945256300270557, -0.027699073776602745, -0.02596954256296158, 0.043331079185009, 0.011858339421451092, -0.052525684237480164, 0.03186235576868057, 0.022356294095516205, 0.0378204882144928, 0.015471744351089, -0.07745038717985153, -0.05531148985028267, 0.040261946618556976, -0.025633344426751137, 0.04846500605344772, -0.042208001017570496, 0.009869924746453762, 0.004850791767239571, 0.05149063840508461, 0.025552580133080482, 0.019612573087215424, 0.017322976142168045, 0.013835817575454712, -0.009158194065093994, -0.016862234100699425, -0.027052147313952446, -0.03173263370990753, 0.010445293970406055, 0.003714365419000387, -0.08056477457284927, 0.03371061012148857, 0.026289289817214012, -0.020124636590480804, -0.0031297672539949417, -0.015180645510554314, 0.016427261754870415, -0.015112382359802723, 0.005187840200960636, 0.002741194562986493, -0.0010929679265245795, 0.04851016774773598, -0.026168731972575188, 0.047280579805374146, 0.02565617859363556, -0.012407371774315834, 0.007693111430853605, 0.03343478962779045, 0.04496758058667183, 0.03337062522768974, -0.011326718144118786, 0.02485816180706024, -0.012946372851729393, 0.027214081957936287, 0.03650238364934921, 0.0037426804192364216, -0.060899075120687485, -0.011169139295816422, 0.00010600742825772613, 0.019924776628613472, 0.04613318666815758, 0.0010972972959280014, -0.02324223332107067, 0.06496117264032364, -0.0662102922797203, -0.054368406534194946, -0.043420374393463135, 0.0032915568444877863, -0.013979961164295673, -0.02120627835392952, -0.006554821506142616, 0.01853080652654171, 0.03374168649315834, 0.004199116490781307, -0.015272448770701885, -0.030190933495759964, -0.03915904462337494, 0.03320170193910599, -0.018982352688908577, -0.02886253222823143, 0.033303722739219666, 0.012541549280285835, -0.06519347429275513, 0.07360577583312988, -0.05178455263376236, -0.05033852905035019, 0.028223276138305664, 0.002657422563061118, -0.014317934401333332, -0.03849639743566513, -0.022638780996203423, 0.017314134165644646, 0.018970001488924026, -0.04198962450027466, 0.04688968136906624, -0.053577959537506104, 0.07029744237661362, 0.06020983308553696, 0.017491891980171204, 0.03293324634432793, -0.007951514795422554, -0.03296108543872833, 0.0011817468330264091, -0.012342594563961029, -0.03021654300391674, -0.06318465620279312, -0.009523911401629448, 0.029801644384860992, -0.01300844643265009, -0.025227000936865807, -0.006672909017652273, 0.04294099658727646, 0.003072589635848999, 0.04486757516860962, 0.02306382544338703, -0.03168768063187599, -0.005379750393331051, 0.003918316215276718, 0.031119033694267273, -0.007293674163520336, -0.00985149946063757, 0.020752668380737305, 0.0064805494621396065, 0.026741480454802513, -0.0059212748892605305, -0.02808699570596218, 0.05009877309203148, 0.011067947372794151, -0.03790861368179321, -0.014794762246310711, -0.025536181405186653, 0.019518893212080002, -0.027050327509641647, 0.00690444465726614, 0.052715469151735306, 0.035656072199344635, 0.02346399798989296, -0.0016681811539456248, -0.00985327921807766, 0.05203291028738022, 0.057373303920030594, -0.06176605820655823, -0.010469583794474602, 0.026592744514346123, -0.07598107308149338, 0.019077740609645844, -0.014563487842679024, -0.04056278616189957, -0.05425875261425972, 0.04363396018743515, 0.009367872029542923, -0.00965888798236847, 0.030251409858465195, -0.004315484315156937, -0.030852215364575386, 0.012300202623009682, -0.04588361829519272, 0.010667966678738594, -0.009359662421047688, -0.03936661407351494, -0.021001307293772697, -0.01089800801128149, -0.02607826143503189, -0.003747070673853159, -0.025778885930776596, -0.008677138015627861, 0.01655077002942562, -0.018083250150084496, -0.05469168722629547, -0.01160987839102745, -0.01872200518846512, 0.017484204843640327, 0.0206161979585886, -0.018592966720461845, 0.0004136165662202984, 0.024841107428073883, -0.04588644951581955, 0.005552622489631176, -0.042929936200380325, -0.027294134721159935, -0.04178236797451973, -0.02314404398202896, 0.008598570711910725, -0.02317941002547741, -0.01064886711537838, 0.03422389551997185, -0.024967297911643982, 0.04062549024820328, -0.0723739042878151, -0.051553476601839066, 0.009717999957501888, 0.009711389429867268, 0.05155342072248459, 0.00911295972764492, -0.009698388166725636, 0.032093144953250885, 0.060103077441453934, -0.03059527836740017, -0.05132952332496643, 0.0008747975807636976, -0.03957861661911011, -0.04913312569260597, 0.0358862541615963, 0.014974535442888737, 0.04396267235279083, 0.03805024176836014, -0.008340288884937763, -0.024495642632246017, 0.0315123088657856, 0.03606315329670906, -0.02210676483809948, 0.020746970549225807, 0.006362454034388065, 0.012609065510332584, -0.0020875975023955107, 0.011393112130463123, -0.050820425152778625, 0.026156041771173477, 0.005871042609214783, 0.01248855609446764, -0.0013300587888807058, -0.04976757615804672, -0.01689954847097397, -0.01790347881615162, 0.03198857232928276, -0.009860975667834282, -0.013108938001096249, 0.013199031352996826, -0.04857967793941498, 0.021903399378061295, 0.04338327795267105, 0.037812985479831696, -0.005277683027088642, 0.0009114897693507373, -0.0014831862645223737, 0.0187823623418808, -0.021666940301656723, 0.014638803899288177, -0.006582363974303007, -0.015132005326449871, 0.019922083243727684, -0.029666967689990997, -0.011441846378147602, 0.03999418020248413, 0.0511782243847847, 0.030218174681067467, -0.027722958475351334, -0.04219444841146469, 0.03133498877286911, -0.05199349299073219, -0.0019805694464594126, 0.011060497723519802, 0.0739409327507019, 0.044896457344293594, 0.0224554855376482, 0.046427369117736816, -0.024259885773062706, 0.021199453622102737, -0.010287967510521412, -0.07106742262840271, 0.05610630661249161, -0.025028284639120102, 0.006779911462217569, 0.020087096840143204, -0.03718787804245949, 0.0295717790722847, -0.03896581009030342, 0.0004988007131032646, -0.010238035582005978, 0.05417189002037048, -0.018441956490278244, 0.012811138294637203, 0.0017370327841490507, -0.013792683370411396, -0.03617051988840103, 0.004723525606095791, -0.026322094723582268, 0.010370775125920773, 0.029822612181305885, 0.056665994226932526, -0.0001373004779452458, -0.007782044820487499, 0.013289051130414009, 0.030427971854805946, 0.017771076411008835, 0.04945843666791916, -0.017993487417697906, 0.02004074491560459, -0.06489603221416473, 0.02187967114150524, -0.02876393496990204, 0.01479239109903574, 0.05336318910121918, 0.0006129218963906169, 0.004616486374288797, -0.030971627682447433, -0.01748349703848362, -0.00029540061950683594, 0.03100622445344925, 0.023210952058434486, -0.03413504734635353, 0.07454106956720352, 0.016352880746126175, -0.051428064703941345, -0.01084403321146965, 0.057805683463811874, 0.022766197100281715, -0.016970008611679077, -0.01818300224840641, -0.012958317995071411, 0.00021431449567899108, 0.035373639315366745, 0.014248711988329887, 0.013991828076541424, -0.005810531787574291, -0.012667386792600155, 0.03280945494771004, -0.037660278379917145, -0.02751680463552475, -0.007939941249787807, 0.04690919071435928, 0.052246201783418655, -0.009850415401160717, -0.03543443605303764, 0.012434978038072586, 0.05747920647263527, 0.006836858112365007, 0.02677830494940281, 0.006419097539037466, -0.08983995020389557, 0.010259205475449562, 0.042930494993925095, 0.03189645707607269, -0.05030864104628563, -0.03140508383512497, -0.02884659916162491, 0.006836526561528444, 0.02559245191514492, -0.043742597103118896, 0.0252386461943388, -0.012927665375173092, 0.008245998062193394, -0.02578054368495941, -0.03337832912802696, -0.050134290009737015, 0.027238739654421806, -0.05469218268990517, 0.023434540256857872, -0.035320404917001724, -0.038771193474531174, -0.04178271070122719, 0.021715832874178886, -0.01721622794866562, 0.04965528845787048, 0.025469468906521797, -0.0032162179704755545, 0.032034337520599365, 0.014945820905268192, -0.006640471052378416, -0.04665573313832283, -0.007047869265079498, 0.006258189678192139, -0.010518047958612442, 0.00912751816213131, -0.0012141598854213953, -0.04544781148433685, 0.0006541575421579182, 0.03142107278108597, -0.007686208002269268, -0.04148067533969879, -0.0405123271048069, -0.0041095903143286705, 0.010054667480289936, 0.002809426048770547, 0.05689302086830139, 0.03537214174866676, -0.025251423940062523, 0.009464486502110958, -0.02679705061018467, -0.0036306309048086405, -0.030554158613085747, -0.06805288791656494, -0.006312169600278139, 0.00957980751991272, -0.018954169005155563, 0.012804619036614895, -0.005406188778579235, 0.022764094173908234, -0.008410193026065826, 0.004965969827026129, -0.02306460402905941, 0.022674856707453728, -0.016122328117489815, 0.007884953171014786, 0.025753313675522804, 0.035768602043390274, 0.01669016107916832, 0.010169592685997486, 0.040261007845401764, 0.009883395396173, 0.010918832384049892, 0.016277920454740524, -0.016188237816095352, 0.0014880459057167172, -0.02958286553621292, -0.028264902532100677, -0.015536096878349781, -0.038343388587236404, 0.036635734140872955, -0.004470977000892162, 0.011764525435864925, 0.004766717087477446, -0.05315506458282471, -0.002506255405023694, 0.007733458653092384, 0.0014142327709123492, 0.0369717963039875, -0.04216116666793823, 0.053273361176252365, -0.043141815811395645, 0.004465017002075911, -0.06279124319553375, -0.024432580918073654, -0.007632949389517307, -0.01583443023264408, -0.005618324037641287, -0.05864737555384636, 0.01204780675470829, -0.034798089414834976, 0.013823541812598705, -0.010644941590726376, 0.045158956199884415, -0.0033315331675112247, 0.021631263196468353, -0.019932907074689865, 0.02831071801483631, 0.04395891726016998, 0.001031695632264018, -0.017605409026145935, 0.007008342072367668, 0.0011437099892646074, 0.007957633584737778, 0.022520393133163452, 0.013550875708460808, -0.026055315509438515, -0.0033772902097553015, -0.016582436859607697, 0.012265211902558804, 0.013846134766936302, 0.01564507931470871, -0.0009251685696654022, -0.012987107038497925, -0.02922513335943222, -0.01816629432141781, -0.01927337236702442, 0.007884584367275238, 0.04095234349370003, -0.0029444233514368534, -0.014684724621474743, 0.0058448780328035355, -0.004913700744509697, -0.008906995877623558, 0.030926933512091637, 0.00809818971902132, 0.022677602246403694, 0.005357745103538036, 0.05273246020078659, -0.0013037205208092928, 0.005495456047356129, -0.02524164505302906, -0.02389695681631565, 0.06558393687009811, 0.007118545938283205, -0.027226122096180916, -0.000003803402705671033, 0.06264124810695648, -0.018824879080057144, -0.013397137634456158, -0.020869113504886627, -0.02283971570432186, 0.04936817288398743, -0.010765479877591133, 0.05923346430063248, 0.04460069537162781, 0.011225562542676926, 0.02150554396212101, -0.027847208082675934, -0.014254284091293812, 0.012395539321005344, 0.023474542424082756, 0.05788307264447212, 0.017719320952892303, 0.005174106918275356, 0.031809981912374496, -0.000992105226032436, 0.021464776247739792, 0.05442238226532936, -0.014262286946177483, 0.015943650156259537, 0.00851208996027708, -0.039824895560741425, -0.045827869325876236, 0.014645654708147049, -0.03722865507006645, 0.023179657757282257, -0.0033536741975694895, 0.0008433415205217898, 0.05172445997595787, 0.02966345101594925, 0.03641907870769501, -0.030929291620850563, -0.02007279358804226, -0.04907383397221565, -0.0004868475953117013, 0.037569619715213776, -0.029398910701274872, 0.03644886240363121, 0.027127742767333984, 0.0024421517737209797, 0.006143245846033096, -0.002007455565035343, -0.02663259394466877, -0.07866036146879196, -0.005311601795256138, -0.00033985768095590174, -0.02149912156164646, 0.011466153897345066, -0.002324189292266965, -0.025785567238926888, -0.008977534249424934, -0.02464032731950283, -0.012250842526555061, -0.02345111593604088, 0.025944335386157036, 0.026289839297533035, 0.06248214468359947, 0.0011952425120398402, -0.0006241113878786564, 0.013638831675052643, 0.011803243309259415, 0.10934168845415115, 0.08716247975826263, 0.0189040619879961, -0.07533540576696396, -0.002716274932026863, -0.0015619166661053896, -0.03696191683411598, -0.035999495536088943, -0.01602935418486595, 0.009473683312535286, -0.025047026574611664, 0.0614599846303463, 0.03505399078130722, 0.02921469695866108, 0.012780709192156792, 0.06743760406970978, -0.04712602496147156, -0.015376740135252476, 0.017039872705936432, 0.020915694534778595, -0.010710570961236954, -0.0030068515334278345, -0.03602684289216995, 0.04315339773893356, -0.03289133310317993, -0.039689742028713226, -0.01659229025244713, 0.010929648764431477, 0.002917865291237831, -0.02385481633245945, -0.0038193860091269016, -0.017496954649686813, 0.02965536154806614, 0.021471364423632622, 0.018220003694295883, 0.02457098849117756, 0.0012423120206221938, -0.016050705686211586, 0.009410864673554897, 0.042641907930374146, -0.01297044288367033, 0.014098440296947956, -0.019408300518989563, 0.004216440487653017, -0.0006511345272883773, -0.03475586697459221, -0.044707272201776505, 0.05166131258010864, -0.000732890737708658, -0.012936059385538101, 0.003957334440201521, 0.020680021494627, -0.0012049967190250754, -0.029498964548110962, -0.01625795289874077, 0.05799567699432373, 0.024182695895433426, -0.03260045871138573, -0.019262146204710007, -0.034847792237997055, 0.04740244150161743, 0.010697022080421448, 0.05004437267780304, 0.03524307534098625, -0.018264347687363625, 0.005484193097800016, -0.03484172374010086, 0.062180452048778534, -0.01020415686070919, 0.007324957754462957, 0.020581642165780067, -0.02780919149518013, -0.003457346698269248, -0.010736608877778053, 0.03005058318376541, -0.012988061644136906, -0.00020312289416324347, -0.0342426598072052, -0.021599555388092995, -0.06373458355665207, -0.05252356454730034, 0.013409178704023361, 0.005299649201333523, -0.011480982415378094, -0.05033835396170616, -0.004406956024467945, -0.00025262884446419775, 0.055353276431560516, 0.051094334572553635, 0.025934414938092232, -0.009810966439545155, 0.030258357524871826, -0.003876960836350918, -0.06873627007007599, -0.03911271318793297, -0.03148500248789787, -0.053553227335214615, -0.0005071869818493724, 0.0033152299001812935, 0.06974436342716217, 0.008571543730795383, 0.005660782568156719, -0.000693576643243432, 0.04675447568297386, -0.029479855671525, -0.0006875726976431906, 0.011226831935346127, -0.01141724456101656, -0.0055870432406663895, -0.018389947712421417, 0.012700321152806282, -0.01341176126152277, -0.02694755792617798, -0.052490297704935074, -0.08580463379621506, 0.018830731511116028, -0.0277303084731102, -0.03545911982655525, 0.03568127378821373, -0.015127741731703281, 0.03311847150325775, -0.03403889387845993, 0.009122570045292377, -0.0559607595205307, -0.0007246990571729839, -0.0031152060255408287, -0.03515861555933952, 0.010803446173667908, 0.009941003285348415, -0.032461073249578476, 0.022991206496953964, 0.0516536571085453, 0.030307525768876076, 0.010530787520110607, 0.005630691070109606, 0.009625495411455631, 0.0031853695400059223, 0.03499159589409828, -0.04394999146461487, 0.0005577484262175858, 0.03035549260675907, -0.04315504804253578, -0.028144419193267822, 0.03471212089061737, -0.04395633190870285, 0.04864639788866043, 0.012601410038769245, 0.02098451554775238, -0.00809265486896038, 0.02299509383738041, 0.02858026884496212, -0.0018508570501580834, -0.020450152456760406, 0.03360937908291817, 0.01301528513431549, 0.0047950237058103085, -0.00690819276496768, -0.0053864349611103535, -0.016032760962843895, 0.0077002448961138725, 0.06974858045578003, 0.03388019651174545, 0.003002421697601676, 0.006193630397319794, -0.008665618486702442, 0.05469561368227005, 0.0486302524805069, -0.04271554946899414, 0.03495234251022339, 0.060333795845508575, -0.01508712861686945, 0.03163791820406914, -0.0022744284942746162, 0.046594277024269104, -0.09167429059743881, -0.04302090406417847, -0.004187858663499355, -0.0003151963755954057, 0.023029128089547157, -0.06230558454990387, 0.00901214312762022, 0.04041002318263054, -0.027438288554549217, 0.0252023097127676, 0.0007100194343365729, -0.013611718080937862, -0.01923728920519352, 0.01071936171501875, 0.026673540472984314, -0.005367456469684839, 0.032097820192575455, -0.0035119603853672743, 0.027608703821897507, 0.023736609145998955, -0.011926164850592613, -0.05496241897344589, -0.011035396717488766, 0.027730140835046768, -0.01897173933684826, -0.06617345660924911, 0.05249321088194847, -0.04037036746740341, -0.032129544764757156, 0.015244287438690662, 0.01415977068245411, 0.04860091209411621, 0.06178375333547592, 0.0366937518119812, 0.029781276360154152, 0.0718759074807167, 0.058476466685533524, 0.007696736138314009, 0.012641781941056252, 0.0032115946523845196, 0.0218354482203722, 0.027376903221011162, -0.026158884167671204, 0.02031116560101509, -0.005643521435558796, -0.0002000044914893806, -0.008896040730178356, 0.00269895326346159, -0.005813397467136383, -0.008711199276149273, -0.025289781391620636, -0.024888331070542336, -0.021500322967767715, -0.02440779097378254, 0.0015976137947291136, -0.0455111525952816, 0.007940133102238178, 0.01847456395626068, 0.01650111936032772, -0.04641253128647804, 0.002746684942394495, -0.010187110863626003, -0.020180951803922653, -0.02418101578950882, -0.019862908869981766, 0.01890447549521923, -0.050773728638887405, 0.0033777772914618254, 0.00047051571891643107, -0.037794336676597595, -0.04416097700595856, 0.019672684371471405, -0.057214945554733276, 0.058386657387018204, -0.028919359669089317, 0.01624678261578083, 0.04358949139714241, -0.010422008112072945, 0.031240904703736305, -0.09312164783477783, 0.03894982859492302, 0.02304893173277378, -0.010377418249845505, -0.018866704776883125, -0.031199058517813683, -0.028750792145729065, -0.006393338553607464, 0.04823135957121849, -0.010882126167416573, 0.038092199712991714, -0.021021993830800056, 0.04540349170565605, 0.03133513778448105, -0.023870522156357765, 0.014090500771999359, -0.00949072279036045, -0.05164744704961777, -0.016468899324536324, -0.01991584710776806, 0.04247891902923584, -0.01358497329056263, 0.030547432601451874, -0.00647807028144598, -0.022285006940364838, 0.011303604580461979, -0.028478970751166344, 0.02429926209151745, -0.007415486499667168, 0.020825253799557686, 0.023415202274918556, -0.008893213234841824, 0.03500382974743843, 0.019977649673819542, 0.017957931384444237, -0.0738263726234436, 0.03209864720702171, -0.05811779573559761, -0.025373950600624084, 0.02475239895284176, 0.01521789375692606, 0.0018260867800563574, -0.048721376806497574, 0.0513048954308033, 0.016611656174063683, -0.01735379546880722, 0.0017259949818253517, 0.011979620903730392, -0.01296938769519329, 0.02357148379087448, -0.0267474465072155, 0.042844243347644806, 0.006528864149004221, -0.019729753956198692, -0.0057133776135742664, -0.002991506364196539, -0.008019986562430859, -0.023292647674679756, 0.03231377899646759, 0.035383451730012894, 0.009738351218402386, 0.037007030099630356, -0.0002580485597718507, 0.01927269622683525, -0.007112552877515554, -0.0015881183790042996, -0.021096091717481613, -0.014784213155508041, 0.010871210135519505, -0.016355283558368683, -0.01549332495778799, 0.07034002244472504, -0.06085710972547531, -0.016251059249043465, -0.03163738548755646, -0.045937977731227875, -0.04064248502254486, 0.006414293777197599, 0.008999657817184925, 0.04123072326183319, -0.008650029078125954, 0.04846334457397461, 0.029536640271544456, -0.014594204723834991, 0.018817724660038948, -0.007891280576586723, 0.02605552226305008, -0.012947709299623966, 0.002320310100913048, 0.008382963947951794, -0.01387257594615221, -0.0033979222644120455, -0.030143102630972862, 0.032254915684461594, 0.04655015841126442, -0.0075476220808923244, -0.02777457796037197, -0.008314031176269054, -0.014262245036661625, 0.030535969883203506, -0.0541551373898983, 0.013771647587418556, -0.059325240552425385, -0.0012524023186415434, -0.03895645961165428, -0.04095310717821121 ]
<p>The height for 1000 students is approximately normal with a mean 174.5cm and a standard deviation of 6.9cm. If 200 random samples of size 25 are chosen from this population and the values of the mean are recorded to the nearest integer, determine the probability that the mean height for the students is more than 176cm.</p> <p>Since the samples were rounded to the nearest integer, I should find $P(X&gt;176.5)$ instead of $P(X&gt;176)$. Is this how we account for the effect of rounding the observations?</p> <p>EDIT: In light of whuber's answer:</p> <p>The answer given by my module (no workings were provided):</p> <p>$\hspace{1cm} n=25; Normal$ </p> <p>$\hspace{1cm} \mu_{\overline{x}}=174.5cm$ </p> <p>$\hspace{1cm} \sigma_{\overline{x}}=6.9/5=1.38$ </p> <p>The answer is 0.1379. Which I'm pretty sure was found using $1-\phi(\dfrac{176-174.5}{1.38})$ </p> <p>So,</p> <ol> <li>Is this an acceptable answer?</li> <li>Since $n$ was less than 30, would it be ok to find the probability using a t-distribution?</li> </ol> <p>Thank you.</p>
74,454
[ -0.00938404444605112, -0.05784105136990547, 0.02973453514277935, -0.021363262087106705, 0.04118611663579941, 0.009885190986096859, 0.006676292046904564, -0.019406428560614586, -0.0065580750815570354, -0.03148624300956726, 0.0441858135163784, 0.051645852625370026, 0.03707915171980858, 0.01007166039198637, 0.028839111328125, -0.01792079582810402, -0.04016341641545296, 0.011666783131659031, -0.00489621888846159, -0.06665649265050888, 0.03394553065299988, 0.052173249423503876, -0.03480551391839981, -0.027455458417534828, -0.045854486525058746, 0.0015010720817372203, 0.0398661345243454, -0.02368513122200966, -0.00894746370613575, 0.05165933445096016, -0.05263001471757889, -0.007580645382404327, 0.04066476970911026, 0.008144192397594452, 0.018122471868991852, -0.01319658849388361, -0.005017932504415512, -0.023818230256438255, -0.004010349977761507, 0.005120841786265373, -0.04137019068002701, 0.010719159618020058, 0.018386632204055786, 0.02181251160800457, -0.03999880328774452, 0.024877753108739853, -0.009517359547317028, -0.03946082293987274, 0.022838210687041283, -0.0362003892660141, 0.0394609197974205, 0.009576109237968922, 0.019528673961758614, 0.04502140358090401, 0.012006798759102821, -0.007593617774546146, 0.026717660948634148, 0.06695698946714401, 0.007569028530269861, -0.03677491843700409, 0.01086424384266138, -0.07550767064094543, -0.01650169864296913, 0.01815168187022209, -0.008362996391952038, -0.03672108054161072, 0.0004973909235559404, -0.009528555907309055, 0.0337863564491272, -0.018086591735482216, 0.05211878567934036, 0.044368498027324677, 0.04550664871931076, -0.006225909572094679, 0.04979595169425011, -0.04381898418068886, 0.035878680646419525, 0.01616331748664379, 0.06541107594966888, 0.02845013327896595, 0.006299921311438084, -0.01986885629594326, 0.020337259396910667, 0.03404591977596283, 0.018805088475346565, -0.03729073330760002, 0.08051741868257523, -0.019780591130256653, 0.01919284649193287, 0.02620120346546173, -0.02133338898420334, -0.011554011143743992, 0.042562924325466156, 0.009862185455858707, -0.028877366334199905, 0.06541544944047928, -0.013068052008748055, 0.02764729969203472, 0.0062233149074018, 0.0059794154949486256, 0.0021938884165138006, -0.023824959993362427, 0.04774210974574089, 0.05498138815164566, -0.039505671709775925, -0.012280774302780628, -0.024588560685515404, -0.011887271888554096, -0.007602437864989042, -0.03097248636186123, -0.041128747165203094, 0.02090250700712204, -0.0013106747064739466, -0.015438000671565533, 0.026814209297299385, -0.005687484983354807, 0.019871752709150314, -0.03239784389734268, 0.05485894903540611, 0.0438777431845665, 0.03897882252931595, 0.0064792633056640625, 0.05170448496937752, -0.008382974192500114, -0.04434945806860924, 0.044072434306144714, 0.02247435972094536, -0.0008961009443737566, -0.05753983557224274, 0.04226599261164665, 0.0048277536407113075, 0.028467120602726936, 0.04123067855834961, -0.032181527465581894, 0.05204594135284424, 0.006542423274368048, -0.07635007798671722, -0.056783437728881836, 0.054737191647291183, 0.005262505728751421, -0.033572252839803696, -0.06074415147304535, -0.008349432609975338, 0.020368365570902824, 0.020195359364151955, 0.0072870743460953236, 0.04177737236022949, -0.009058336727321148, 0.0348757766187191, 0.0008441334357485175, -0.04687436297535896, -0.0037886970676481724, -0.012670492753386497, -0.03864575922489166, -0.0018696174956858158, -0.10237038880586624, 0.030236009508371353, 0.0007160822278819978, 0.022625206038355827, -0.04155662655830383, 0.029842698946595192, -0.03225609287619591, 0.015662671998143196, -0.017994044348597527, -0.0010157246142625809, -0.026038384065032005, 0.08835618942975998, 0.02609674073755741, 0.020852550864219666, 0.01786291040480137, 0.0006977299926802516, 0.013555366545915604, -0.01719711907207966, 0.016054833307862282, 0.059331126511096954, -0.019006455317139626, 0.01736539602279663, -0.029717661440372467, 0.04282889515161514, 0.035053011029958725, -0.025102784857153893, 0.00628716591745615, 0.006680524442344904, 0.034665849059820175, 0.011950687505304813, 0.0495920367538929, 0.004985508508980274, -0.007936878129839897, 0.03583691641688347, -0.03847099468111992, -0.06601502746343613, -0.057343848049640656, 0.00532915024086833, 0.019684026017785072, -0.011076058261096478, 0.013468810357153416, -0.015130853280425072, -0.003364392090588808, -0.024115556851029396, 0.00356661225669086, 0.020065156742930412, -0.02581925503909588, 0.03953275457024574, -0.0633048489689827, 0.009292482398450375, 0.05701960250735283, 0.03908003121614456, -0.00158957508392632, 0.046985283493995667, -0.039003677666187286, -0.006784997880458832, -0.06218511611223221, -0.04472870007157326, 0.005701610818505287, -0.02371356263756752, -0.006623738445341587, 0.02001376263797283, -0.011947866529226303, -0.007339693605899811, 0.03504395857453346, -0.035494815558195114, 0.053139038383960724, 0.043990358710289, 0.0018126892391592264, -0.017464710399508476, 0.001824759179726243, 0.015539669431746006, -0.014109982177615166, 0.01937761902809143, -0.025993207469582558, -0.04350947216153145, -0.019531359896063805, 0.0019064070656895638, -0.014684395864605904, -0.03764549642801285, -0.00038181550917215645, 0.04158642515540123, 0.011661847122013569, 0.03501034155488014, 0.017551178112626076, 0.01656082086265087, -0.02982703223824501, 0.01039128191769123, 0.007964804768562317, 0.014853136613965034, -0.03242231160402298, -0.024446167051792145, 0.04053904488682747, 0.008777926675975323, 0.035518284887075424, 0.01845012605190277, 0.01793161779642105, -0.015020661987364292, 0.03834424167871475, -0.012079671956598759, -0.005133252125233412, 0.04291754588484764, -0.009445187635719776, -0.038441017270088196, 0.033459533005952835, -0.03395869955420494, -0.0021148985251784325, -0.06762295961380005, -0.02141265943646431, 0.029482966288924217, 0.037731073796749115, -0.02226857841014862, -0.01418674923479557, 0.004103680606931448, -0.036213330924510956, -0.0225606057792902, -0.0006562845082953572, -0.036421846598386765, -0.006767185404896736, 0.05094753950834274, 0.04054449871182442, -0.004858668427914381, 0.05107751488685608, -0.03903583437204361, -0.036389511078596115, -0.02682223729789257, 0.011099346913397312, 0.01437198556959629, 0.009458538144826889, -0.08128372579813004, -0.012035205028951168, 0.015398474410176277, -0.012221582233905792, 0.012587059289216995, -0.043688394129276276, -0.017590131610631943, 0.00875775795429945, -0.0038432579021900892, -0.005267283879220486, -0.014702890999615192, -0.04489348456263542, -0.03585730865597725, -0.019917529076337814, 0.004578245338052511, 0.03898118436336517, 0.004691709764301777, -0.01849455200135708, 0.06132589280605316, -0.0348028801381588, -0.05372389033436775, -0.03698723018169403, 0.046128541231155396, -0.011669197119772434, 0.016276588663458824, -0.005087761208415031, 0.0018069170182570815, 0.017810694873332977, -0.005068777594715357, -0.06955234706401825, -0.048559337854385376, 0.011513425037264824, 0.006003635935485363, 0.057393595576286316, 0.03237459808588028, -0.001567730912938714, 0.08897184580564499, 0.004743772558867931, -0.05647611990571022, 0.014369705691933632, -0.006246546283364296, -0.00270849303342402, -0.04838330298662186, 0.025272870436310768, 0.029156068339943886, -0.041487883776426315, 0.046510566025972366, 0.012398207560181618, 0.016987115144729614, 0.05422881990671158, 0.028335846960544586, 0.040011994540691376, -0.029539354145526886, -0.02752455696463585, -0.04050534591078758, 0.030184920877218246, -0.01688254624605179, -0.026905884966254234, 0.011387580074369907, -0.029673203825950623, 0.00030489140772260725, -0.00161642674356699, -0.061239004135131836, 0.03531857207417488, -0.011097259819507599, 0.011685562320053577, -0.04041222110390663, 0.018995191901922226, 0.013656566850841045, -0.05202293023467064, 0.02223358303308487, 0.024822335690259933, -0.0005805420223623514, -0.03132498264312744, 0.020445095375180244, 0.04640871286392212, 0.07267539203166962, 0.00833992287516594, -0.011976535432040691, 0.00970988254994154, 0.012780739925801754, 0.015586291439831257, -0.0327603854238987, -0.027220478281378746, 0.031927432864904404, 0.06758437305688858, -0.0007956471526995301, -0.017180562019348145, -0.03381328284740448, 0.0068417564034461975, -0.07715119421482086, 0.0026594484224915504, -0.09270136058330536, 0.047773756086826324, -0.002531601581722498, 0.01613747328519821, 0.002889832016080618, 0.007689925841987133, 0.032236725091934204, 0.045242536813020706, -0.018124358728528023, 0.016145233064889908, -0.018929529935121536, 0.0030450394842773676, -0.009065136313438416, 0.015610236674547195, 0.027098700404167175, 0.009304921142756939, 0.01907452940940857, -0.006412038579583168, 0.018795328214764595, -0.016602015122771263, -0.00560660008341074, -0.05957424268126488, -0.03107970580458641, -0.01022587064653635, 0.009074564091861248, -0.028758209198713303, -0.05164533481001854, 0.029838018119335175, 0.03967756778001785, 0.000356115197064355, -0.029294654726982117, -0.02676992304623127, 0.005185290239751339, -0.01834818348288536, 0.07356679439544678, 0.024603325873613358, 0.015897242352366447, -0.053248170763254166, 0.041451435536146164, 0.0007682931027375162, 0.05378253757953644, 0.05008435621857643, 0.0036970844957977533, -0.02340521477162838, 0.015370740555226803, 0.0032675170805305243, -0.013581587933003902, -0.0016057606553658843, -0.026172766461968422, -0.01234053447842598, 0.06047798693180084, 0.003223367501050234, -0.047963861376047134, 0.05614728853106499, 0.05338231846690178, -0.003971177618950605, 0.011596018448472023, -0.01863427646458149, -0.003679821500554681, -0.038696326315402985, -0.024594873189926147, 0.0387331023812294, 0.011083320714533329, 0.015090092085301876, 0.008551359176635742, 0.0410592146217823, 0.020041905343532562, -0.05254688486456871, 0.028816821053624153, 0.009659749455749989, 0.0385318398475647, 0.006103989202529192, -0.032500218600034714, 0.02272968366742134, 0.02887125313282013, 0.03654906526207924, -0.0009563292260281742, 0.004385150037705898, -0.05859467014670372, -0.011267680674791336, 0.03365271911025047, 0.041994258761405945, -0.05678589269518852, 0.020509324967861176, -0.04054446518421173, 0.02696574479341507, 0.04611331969499588, -0.033301129937171936, -0.017535129562020302, -0.028112687170505524, 0.026053577661514282, -0.0019939749035984278, -0.010735987685620785, -0.05415528267621994, -0.03259451687335968, -0.0202277023345232, 0.015691397711634636, -0.016318263486027718, -0.01077853050082922, -0.02706426940858364, -0.003967917058616877, 0.024874549359083176, 0.09174039214849472, -0.01133829727768898, -0.05268704891204834, 0.02754443883895874, -0.0052806297317147255, 0.015043763443827629, -0.05317306891083717, 0.00747263478115201, -0.034593287855386734, 0.0004755798727273941, 0.02413790486752987, -0.022757794708013535, -0.055186688899993896, 0.039966288954019547, 0.0323503278195858, -0.03618534654378891, -0.003049794351682067, -0.04854290559887886, 0.029066991060972214, 0.027239695191383362, 0.0047721583396196365, 0.022398535162210464, 0.033528562635183334, 0.04783837869763374, -0.013251097872853279, -0.04634517431259155, 0.013320693746209145, -0.013159967958927155, -0.01055135577917099, -0.06520605832338333, 0.009800934232771397, 0.00545513117685914, 0.039958205074071884, 0.01636551506817341, 0.009900087490677834, -0.030067700892686844, -0.04056485369801521, 0.004531900864094496, 0.010861600749194622, 0.0023463163524866104, 0.042211566120386124, 0.004397359676659107, 0.0014232831308618188, 0.028988005593419075, -0.023820899426937103, 0.0005168797797523439, -0.014292408712208271, 0.03386562690138817, 0.008314978331327438, -0.03580304607748985, 0.015300036408007145, -0.035275448113679886, -0.014102855697274208, 0.027784869074821472, -0.03853503242135048, 0.0038673197850584984, 0.009399078786373138, 0.05516759678721428, 0.02032359130680561, 0.020318424329161644, -0.02782825194299221, 0.027498193085193634, 0.02318587154150009, 0.03452741727232933, -0.03104870207607746, 0.041838567703962326, 0.015186427161097527, 0.027831992134451866, -0.06523150205612183, -0.023718778043985367, -0.04150610417127609, 0.020346203818917274, 0.005839894525706768, -0.023996476083993912, 0.0080586988478899, -0.004565082956105471, -0.02624020166695118, -0.0014882268151268363, 0.05900520458817482, -0.002113867551088333, -0.004373118281364441, -0.01877576857805252, 0.033605337142944336, 0.0779213085770607, -0.019750647246837616, 0.014322713948786259, 0.02928106114268303, 0.0020759685430675745, -0.05217112600803375, 0.020336132496595383, 0.05623193830251694, -0.05320344865322113, -0.018323423340916634, -0.01883297599852085, -0.01342754252254963, 0.024517809972167015, -0.024217696860432625, -0.022645020857453346, 0.012812958098948002, -0.01563328504562378, 0.0006073347758501768, -0.015825018286705017, 0.01175087969750166, -0.02331552840769291, 0.017170334234833717, -0.032860539853572845, 0.01582675240933895, 0.010232849977910519, 0.012467609718441963, 0.03977074474096298, 0.023458188399672508, -0.032723575830459595, 0.02696007303893566, 0.06612030416727066, -0.019196562469005585, -0.015042638406157494, 0.006652666721493006, -0.03507012873888016, 0.023038266226649284, 0.019829589873552322, -0.04064277186989784, 0.018225040286779404, 0.010539224371314049, 0.0011225392809137702, -0.023007189854979515, -0.029159072786569595, -0.003196474863216281, 0.05076367035508156, 0.026783356443047523, 0.03709779307246208, -0.005678560584783554, -0.0060137915425002575, 0.009340965189039707, 0.006716773379594088, -0.013613387010991573, -0.002781730145215988, -0.008503047749400139, 0.05614805966615677, -0.03027956746518612, 0.019291657954454422, 0.00848934892565012, -0.02372080460190773, 0.018337011337280273, 0.030211323872208595, 0.030985433608293533, 0.004688508342951536, 0.01644294150173664, -0.026807095855474472, -0.03131326287984848, 0.036053963005542755, -0.04889599606394768, 0.02565823495388031, -0.019498230889439583, -0.01668456755578518, 0.02239583432674408, 0.030733132734894753, 0.0032839179039001465, -0.040386274456977844, 0.003370853140950203, -0.0313744880259037, -0.031263552606105804, 0.01751747913658619, 0.00048784390673972666, 0.011431661434471607, -0.008848357014358044, 0.005312281660735607, 0.002368329791352153, 0.018484747037291527, -0.06742271780967712, -0.0582575723528862, -0.06139032915234566, -0.016022497788071632, -0.06733747571706772, 0.01775369793176651, -0.01535917166620493, -0.02475685067474842, 0.0713723748922348, -0.03824553266167641, 0.05169426649808884, -0.023575572296977043, 0.02347845584154129, -0.013937965035438538, 0.05642330273985863, 0.018640419468283653, 0.010365215130150318, -0.0020604378078132868, -0.004506261553615332, 0.12233780324459076, 0.07194260507822037, 0.03109588474035263, -0.041239090263843536, 0.004635073710232973, 0.001228873967193067, -0.010243318974971771, -0.010060478001832962, 0.001852621790021658, -0.007601694203913212, -0.010630634613335133, 0.03352043777704239, 0.07617634534835815, 0.03701977804303169, -0.02277642861008644, 0.04313461109995842, -0.023159315809607506, -0.03283810615539551, 0.018694637343287468, -0.05413650721311569, 0.03412288799881935, -0.024226851761341095, -0.029442548751831055, 0.04360610991716385, -0.016338728368282318, 0.0005418117507360876, -0.06646163016557693, -0.034610457718372345, -0.0310653205960989, 0.005077700596302748, -0.02607782557606697, 0.010700764134526253, 0.01733154058456421, -0.020472727715969086, -0.003652455285191536, -0.015345483087003231, -0.012016117572784424, -0.02221280336380005, 0.03727302700281143, 0.08351173251867294, 0.001803231192752719, 0.04234353080391884, 0.007790484931319952, 0.03234826773405075, -0.057203926146030426, -0.05558284372091293, -0.0054800561629235744, 0.03037688322365284, 0.017976827919483185, -0.013918471522629261, -0.016048509627580643, 0.002550128847360611, -0.013659205287694931, -0.011237611062824726, -0.023786654695868492, 0.008309559896588326, 0.016312241554260254, -0.01863686554133892, -0.013002840802073479, 0.005808445159345865, 0.009612294845283031, -0.02524014189839363, 0.02077837474644184, 0.02931446023285389, -0.010595615021884441, -0.012144225649535656, 0.028819162398576736, 0.043060775846242905, -0.017368203029036522, -0.01480898167937994, -0.01717284880578518, -0.0268070288002491, -0.0171003807336092, 0.00027965460321865976, 0.007536448538303375, -0.02122471109032631, 0.026995031163096428, 0.0021377461962401867, 0.000953220238443464, -0.024121737107634544, -0.024756507948040962, 0.023192942142486572, -0.017419889569282532, 0.00907959509640932, -0.04995618015527725, -0.049941536039114, -0.024516329169273376, 0.03045690804719925, 0.03580256551504135, -0.021803371608257294, 0.009924001060426235, 0.06908925622701645, 0.016252387315034866, -0.017831621691584587, 0.011875709518790245, -0.02371273934841156, -0.027608349919319153, 0.010687308385968208, -0.0018004144076257944, 0.05144059285521507, 0.02257384918630123, 0.054214656352996826, 0.013570369221270084, 0.015743475407361984, 0.016759350895881653, -0.008846782147884369, -0.00515640527009964, -0.06475331634283066, 0.01318679191172123, 0.030495379120111465, 0.0020217306446284056, -0.05099499598145485, -0.0005336966132745147, 0.005206697154790163, -0.01477805431932211, 0.006080453284084797, -0.011831574141979218, -0.06835608184337616, -0.0033224793151021004, -0.01669093407690525, -0.00815232191234827, -0.004584061913192272, -0.0020093636121600866, 0.02722342312335968, -0.020604917779564857, -0.003956296015530825, 0.029100656509399414, -0.00810458604246378, 0.02762860804796219, -0.0002733440196607262, -0.006811835337430239, 0.03454316779971123, -0.01609603501856327, 0.014463836327195168, 0.002520556328818202, 0.006277663167566061, 0.009654716588556767, 0.009894758462905884, -0.036617379635572433, -0.01168861798942089, 0.05390103906393051, -0.018860405310988426, -0.035542815923690796, 0.04236292839050293, -0.00030229147523641586, 0.02432149089872837, 0.022328278049826622, -0.011006077751517296, -0.0008817396010272205, 0.04582161083817482, -0.05407820641994476, 0.018124116584658623, -0.03375298157334328, -0.0063726771622896194, 0.03227383270859718, -0.020398827269673347, -0.006749462336301804, 0.017835725098848343, -0.0050539374351501465, 0.054601144045591354, 0.038151226937770844, -0.02388174459338188, 0.02003934606909752, 0.008078566752374172, 0.004720218013972044, -0.01883937418460846, -0.017984408885240555, 0.040423374623060226, -0.015677042305469513, 0.051064565777778625, 0.0036807020660489798, 0.04582715779542923, -0.020723404362797737, 0.007697912398725748, -0.08695505559444427, -0.032538097351789474, 0.05335182696580887, -0.01614491082727909, 0.018171507865190506, -0.04205373302102089, -0.02837858721613884, 0.047196242958307266, -0.06563396006822586, 0.019890068098902702, -0.019411567598581314, -0.005003741942346096, -0.017893338575959206, 0.03177992254495621, 0.004417349584400654, 0.021272554993629456, -0.000657167169265449, 0.01337819080799818, 0.009723887778818607, 0.035703934729099274, -0.004355250857770443, -0.03825189545750618, -0.01116279885172844, 0.026430383324623108, 0.0021111194510012865, -0.09886957705020905, 0.026043027639389038, -0.016276299953460693, -0.034163862466812134, 0.02214568853378296, 0.00537073565647006, 0.00486680818721652, -0.018632473424077034, -0.0039792791940271854, 0.010969707742333412, 0.03592011332511902, 0.01980544440448284, 0.023759661242365837, -0.028092816472053528, 0.019052034243941307, 0.04650373011827469, 0.026043979451060295, -0.030245978385210037, -0.013632124289870262, 0.05648023635149002, 0.016783472150564194, -0.023448947817087173, 0.03148285299539566, 0.00023523707932326943, -0.03165297210216522, 0.014499473385512829, 0.006779167335480452, -0.04836954548954964, -0.015426227822899818, 0.02017967216670513, -0.04269381985068321, -0.0010313594248145819, 0.00491998391225934, 0.059475768357515335, -0.013218863867223263, 0.01700390875339508, -0.027373995631933212, -0.03447900712490082, -0.02157289907336235, 0.004028708674013615, -0.03423028439283371, -0.02702396549284458, 0.0014798197662457824, -0.007617113646119833, -0.008652344346046448, 0.028183195739984512, -0.02996043860912323, -0.05753036215901375, 0.004581380169838667, 0.004224712960422039, 0.0398864708840847, 0.021710650995373726, -0.013866089284420013, 0.0002493556239642203, -0.07454121112823486, 0.05018031597137451, 0.005761296954005957, 0.016708925366401672, -0.036432959139347076, -0.011146432720124722, -0.03494199737906456, 0.02743595279753208, 0.041852980852127075, 0.06636670976877213, 0.016054389998316765, -0.010146642103791237, 0.0249194148927927, -0.016505902633070946, -0.08232995122671127, 0.028265168890357018, -0.01023579016327858, -0.003965441603213549, 0.0023395989555865526, -0.020549887791275978, 0.007273642811924219, 0.00512315146625042, 0.012857855297625065, -0.007086079567670822, 0.002409199718385935, 0.00618315115571022, 0.00877370499074459, 0.032080136239528656, -0.015360868535935879, -0.0025072689168155193, 0.05631585046648979, 0.0015515574486926198, -0.007133339997380972, 0.018796538934111595, -0.0020947828888893127, -0.051185887306928635, 0.038859348744153976, -0.032570384442806244, -0.022513940930366516, -0.008508249185979366, 0.03484277427196503, -0.020870082080364227, -0.0736222043633461, -0.011188698001205921, 0.01285534631460905, -0.03563977777957916, -0.03269028291106224, 0.03648357465863228, 0.007186823058873415, 0.006069219671189785, -0.047424331307411194, 0.011259844526648521, 0.014654026366770267, -0.02103412337601185, -0.005718257278203964, -0.006247012875974178, 0.030766580253839493, -0.024179324507713318, 0.007237824611365795, 0.01689404807984829, -0.011113404296338558, 0.035214535892009735, -0.002320090541616082, 0.04423470422625542, -0.02259221114218235, -0.04882374405860901, 0.017576783895492554, 0.018013985827565193, 0.030452243983745575, -0.0018769977614283562, 0.0016057929024100304, 0.07771367579698563, 0.030744479969143867, -0.007969992235302925, -0.03532646968960762, -0.014862438663840294, -0.04487373307347298, 0.006645923480391502, 0.019307328388094902, 0.033506814390420914, -0.0032222832087427378, -0.013277892023324966, 0.0036570820957422256, 0.0255779717117548, 0.018362289294600487, -0.02834557369351387, -0.005073299165815115, -0.01834193244576454, -0.023875711485743523, 0.002372978487983346, -0.015348237939178944, -0.0209632720798254, -0.0038137983065098524, 0.029542507603764534, 0.008736790157854557, 0.04503820091485977, 0.01192900724709034, -0.04764505848288536, -0.0019004859495908022, 0.04770861193537712, -0.05795598775148392, -0.027290765196084976, -0.030778435990214348, -0.025593025609850883, -0.022273950278759003, -0.05445672571659088 ]
<p>I understand that when sampling from a finite population and our sample size is more than 5% of the population, we need to a correction on the sample's mean and standard error using this formula:</p> <p>$\hspace{10mm} FPC=\sqrt{\frac{N-n}{N-1}}$ </p> <p>Where N is the population size and n is the sample size.</p> <p>I have 3 questions about this formula:</p> <ol> <li>Why is the threshold set at 5%?</li> <li>How was the formula derived?</li> <li>Are there other online resources that comprehensively explain this formula besides <a href="http://www.jstor.org/pss/2340569">this</a> paper?</li> </ol> <p>Thank you,</p>
37,333
[ 0.004321707412600517, -0.04370422661304474, 0.033995773643255234, 0.011771759949624538, 0.026618707925081253, 0.004321135580539703, -0.022834744304418564, -0.025131458416581154, 0.0007912564906291664, -0.019062090665102005, 0.059096988290548325, 0.05039707571268082, 0.03942255303263664, 0.014587203972041607, 0.010918003506958485, 0.01525014266371727, -0.01942237839102745, 0.019660206511616707, -0.007453285623341799, -0.05647481232881546, -0.008010097779333591, 0.06142309308052063, 0.0008476172224618495, -0.01525389775633812, -0.03892792388796806, 0.018234679475426674, 0.05335782468318939, 0.01015456672757864, 0.035895250737667084, 0.05436991527676582, -0.03682471066713333, 0.015483256429433823, 0.0482117161154747, 0.02283259481191635, 0.016752775758504868, 0.018439577892422676, -0.020792057737708092, -0.029737671837210655, 0.03015999123454094, 0.00839489046484232, -0.0562959648668766, 0.006197846028953791, 0.028653312474489212, -0.010585540905594826, -0.00872205663472414, 0.01972546987235546, -0.0026120911352336407, -0.059514325112104416, 0.04628376290202141, -0.05475136637687683, 0.06159665063023567, 0.027191128581762314, 0.0406939797103405, -0.009547458030283451, 0.020144332200288773, 0.013963300734758377, 0.06252496689558029, 0.06612064689397812, -0.011758233420550823, -0.058819662779569626, -0.02519005537033081, -0.040891192853450775, -0.005645327735692263, -0.019191637635231018, -0.04196963459253311, 0.016628706827759743, -0.061084527522325516, -0.0034586265683174133, -0.000220278074266389, -0.0038884978275746107, 0.02855542115867138, 0.014121931046247482, 0.005754784215241671, 0.028532717376947403, 0.006948759313672781, -0.03919258341193199, -0.005818456877022982, 0.008908030577003956, 0.025303484871983528, 0.03409188240766525, -0.004100207705050707, 0.018412955105304718, 0.057372353971004486, 0.028657473623752594, 0.03042234107851982, -0.035444844514131546, 0.06441204249858856, -0.050014711916446686, 0.05603122338652611, 0.01076189149171114, -0.019591983407735825, 0.0222456157207489, 0.060386497527360916, -0.026246385648846626, -0.030566275119781494, 0.04510052502155304, -0.02751820534467697, 0.023352844640612602, -0.02417595684528351, 0.009713319130241871, -0.002647645305842161, -0.051039040088653564, 0.010823948308825493, 0.06960175186395645, -0.03482716158032417, -0.018154621124267578, -0.022543562576174736, -0.023392587900161743, 0.01883651129901409, -0.0070219687186181545, -0.010029464960098267, 0.018131067976355553, 0.006910237018018961, 0.01929432712495327, 0.014571494422852993, 0.01814498007297516, 0.01419359166175127, -0.015443437732756138, 0.06911712884902954, -0.0019484763033688068, 0.04891344532370567, 0.007124459836632013, 0.03910703957080841, -0.03550232946872711, -0.06315169483423233, 0.010626775212585926, -0.007944650948047638, -0.02787693776190281, -0.0276984591037035, 0.04688979685306549, 0.0226424653083086, -0.038995664566755295, 0.027838747948408127, 0.04139326140284538, 0.020204711705446243, 0.005350241903215647, -0.05728154629468918, -0.043501827865839005, 0.06712141633033752, 0.0098510030657053, 0.012408040463924408, -0.06628776341676712, 0.021984189748764038, 0.033734019845724106, 0.03850407525897026, 0.02386648952960968, 0.017056763172149658, -0.014226946979761124, -0.0022268486209213734, 0.018526799976825714, -0.05958818644285202, -0.02057878114283085, -0.005164169240742922, -0.005017860792577267, -0.02557683363556862, -0.09028851240873337, 0.047210294753313065, 0.026532210409641266, -0.006967291235923767, -0.02565724402666092, 0.016396518796682358, 0.005701342131942511, -0.03439957648515701, -0.023003853857517242, 0.01507672481238842, -0.029117587953805923, 0.07517094165086746, -0.010199581272900105, 0.02326199598610401, 0.013139823451638222, -0.010807519778609276, 0.025176849216222763, 0.02188113145530224, 0.04197206720709801, 0.045101188123226166, -0.049778684973716736, 0.006901722867041826, -0.03840581327676773, -0.007209545932710171, 0.02799161523580551, -0.055861394852399826, 0.032940950244665146, -0.008236788213253021, 0.033427540212869644, 0.03744877129793167, 0.013472718186676502, -0.010083724744617939, -0.02389952354133129, -0.02188108302652836, -0.06365097314119339, -0.04342769831418991, -0.08145081996917725, -0.017523817718029022, -0.018755298107862473, -0.015152813866734505, 0.004236497450619936, -0.01763395592570305, 0.03293202072381973, 0.010610579513013363, -0.009487387724220753, -0.01847880519926548, 0.014988469891250134, 0.035982172936201096, -0.053112614899873734, 0.01755799911916256, 0.04067718982696533, 0.05108434334397316, 0.010421005077660084, 0.030493274331092834, -0.027404500171542168, -0.04197501763701439, -0.0046990099363029, -0.00614763330668211, 0.037261731922626495, -0.01649935357272625, -0.022007353603839874, 0.004064049571752548, -0.011879968456923962, -0.006598083768039942, 0.057591065764427185, -0.05575196444988251, 0.07495911419391632, 0.05233282223343849, 0.00895790383219719, 0.011971813626587391, -0.0015769719611853361, 0.011550260707736015, -0.019330793991684914, -0.018243320286273956, -0.013476808555424213, -0.06919708102941513, -0.02803686074912548, 0.025686342269182205, 0.003017284907400608, -0.00014160448336042464, -0.03466353565454483, 0.08061571419239044, 0.0004985168343409896, 0.018629150465130806, 0.023435385897755623, -0.015713060274720192, -0.02594160847365856, -0.006721509620547295, 0.03297559544444084, 0.011818633414804935, 0.03802179917693138, -0.0037282854318618774, 0.0037029108498245478, 0.038256753236055374, 0.01430995762348175, 0.0007951054139994085, 0.035338129848241806, -0.015721427276730537, 0.029804762452840805, -0.002098462777212262, 0.004572944715619087, 0.03457549959421158, -0.03828463330864906, -0.027968214824795723, 0.05357810854911804, -0.01654909923672676, -0.007648152764886618, -0.03845623880624771, -0.008352109231054783, 0.026741227135062218, 0.005429029930382967, -0.02470274642109871, 0.03562964126467705, -0.004025084897875786, -0.03947622328996658, -0.0012557461159303784, -0.053494296967983246, -0.027804257348179817, -0.023651206865906715, -0.02930176816880703, 0.012210826389491558, -0.009601118043065071, 0.03159790858626366, -0.022894123569130898, 0.008318156935274601, -0.016865121200680733, -0.01178821176290512, 0.023333441466093063, 0.028289051726460457, -0.06401123851537704, -0.013627464883029461, -0.0024578270968049765, -0.03430567681789398, 0.030806714668869972, -0.011996890418231487, 0.028218990191817284, 0.013827493414282799, 0.009426943026483059, -0.020506592467427254, 0.013847877271473408, 0.023215729743242264, -0.004309691954404116, -0.02194482833147049, -0.01857060194015503, 0.02948475070297718, 0.022770509123802185, -0.0010178397642448545, 0.04738529771566391, -0.023275185376405716, -0.04143129289150238, -0.08863651752471924, 0.014632867649197578, 0.00017933179333340377, -0.03003445453941822, -0.011226415634155273, 0.008289334364235401, 0.026125621050596237, -0.006456281989812851, -0.04530606046319008, -0.05273882672190666, -0.018351560458540916, -0.0006609917618334293, 0.03572142496705055, 0.02607985958456993, -0.026081550866365433, 0.07297481596469879, 0.025184182450175285, 0.004957569297403097, 0.00378991081379354, 0.010436647571623325, 0.02396038919687271, -0.041050784289836884, 0.0001483983069192618, 0.048596080392599106, -0.008755868300795555, -0.00029661267763003707, -0.019086718559265137, 0.01957382820546627, 0.03916879743337631, 0.008839981630444527, -0.011098921298980713, -0.007616384886205196, -0.029113996773958206, -0.011808257550001144, 0.027569182217121124, -0.003281437326222658, -0.0386815182864666, 0.007276732940226793, 0.01057502906769514, 0.032532576471567154, 0.036602433770895004, -0.015667788684368134, 0.018745262175798416, -0.011881524696946144, -0.030853312462568283, -0.05173574015498161, 0.02151479572057724, -0.009885220788419247, -0.031043244525790215, 0.02373380959033966, 0.014982800930738449, 0.01746778003871441, -0.039182402193546295, -0.01590866781771183, 0.03399892896413803, 0.02913636527955532, -0.03235812857747078, -0.007439691573381424, -0.022305119782686234, -0.016011377796530724, -0.01565178856253624, 0.00017994357040151954, -0.013430957682430744, 0.007998055778443813, 0.05592966079711914, 0.026160098612308502, -0.023184793069958687, -0.0011254516430199146, 0.0035714954137802124, -0.06115282326936722, -0.015432293526828289, -0.01054294966161251, 0.05252739042043686, -0.01570829376578331, 0.006753452587872744, 0.0033856502268463373, -0.00842656847089529, 0.02903161384165287, 0.013100842013955116, -0.07989676296710968, 0.013137814588844776, -0.028179869055747986, -0.03941004350781441, -0.049061477184295654, -0.007763782516121864, 0.015494676306843758, 0.022302765399217606, -0.004247908014804125, -0.006696658208966255, 0.02279943972826004, -0.00021399187971837819, 0.0104148481041193, 0.01691228337585926, 0.032975517213344574, -0.0051361857913434505, 0.03397881239652634, 0.015015056356787682, -0.026153329759836197, -0.00037081033224239945, 0.006588528398424387, -0.004925802815705538, -0.0649837851524353, -0.027592092752456665, 0.018810227513313293, 0.037836704403162, 0.0674949437379837, 0.039662957191467285, 0.027111371979117393, -0.05410804599523544, 0.04096611216664314, -0.026346631348133087, 0.05412566289305687, 0.018014686182141304, -0.005367574281990528, -0.04069991037249565, -0.04658535495400429, -0.0011382949305698276, 0.01363583467900753, -0.00021979387383908033, -0.011118564754724503, 0.01949467696249485, 0.06449637562036514, -0.011479819193482399, -0.08766045421361923, 0.0008901104447431862, 0.03565683215856552, -0.01800697110593319, 0.02467087097465992, -0.04160973057150841, 0.02239827811717987, -0.0377349890768528, 0.021219486370682716, 0.013255191966891289, 0.018131976947188377, -0.017260611057281494, 0.0070627364329993725, 0.05780982971191406, -0.001156939659267664, -0.020075056701898575, -0.005006743595004082, 0.012774080969393253, 0.04410180076956749, 0.0012682577362284064, -0.015301693230867386, 0.03560749068856239, 0.018742186948657036, 0.036336492747068405, -0.0167315024882555, -0.009031800553202629, -0.05983348935842514, 0.011062962003052235, -0.009622659534215927, 0.042483117431402206, -0.04429156333208084, 0.04097515717148781, -0.08813879638910294, 0.012590454891324043, 0.016390332952141762, -0.028306446969509125, 0.009927414357662201, -0.03263644501566887, 0.026256849989295006, -0.01828092150390148, -0.015246783383190632, -0.06941039115190506, -0.0036868976894766092, 0.005688489880412817, 0.021011756733059883, -0.012107998132705688, -0.016941046342253685, -0.043847206979990005, 0.0019677055533975363, 0.015139655210077763, 0.11356166750192642, -0.03941597044467926, -0.04151231795549393, 0.00982268713414669, 0.020956719294190407, -0.005922755226492882, -0.054615020751953125, -0.005063333082944155, -0.02453060820698738, 0.008418801240622997, 0.009536998346447945, -0.01931047812104225, -0.05874988064169884, 0.0283451396971941, 0.061010006815195084, -0.0264222864061594, -0.021439576521515846, -0.014713400043547153, 0.03781253099441528, 0.03587186709046364, -0.03573676943778992, 0.06832123547792435, -0.008909723721444607, -0.014033871702849865, 0.012133972719311714, -0.03325432538986206, 0.013539021834731102, -0.03477005288004875, -0.008453821763396263, -0.02063833363354206, 0.015085345134139061, -0.04766502603888512, 0.02306644804775715, 0.0005576003459282219, 0.057283300906419754, -0.017559489235281944, -0.009501207619905472, 0.006700810045003891, -0.00544506311416626, 0.0268851425498724, 0.03910105302929878, 0.021148748695850372, 0.019047725945711136, 0.03984050080180168, -0.02227865159511566, 0.02944815158843994, -0.012997116893529892, -0.003726862370967865, 0.026662630960345268, 0.0018805509898811579, -0.020693201571702957, -0.07224948704242706, -0.03597551956772804, 0.05597492307424545, -0.007945618592202663, 0.04037148132920265, -0.04608019068837166, 0.03325669839978218, -0.007471598219126463, -0.040444180369377136, -0.004732840228825808, 0.03778655454516411, -0.0069118766114115715, 0.005565766245126724, -0.03554368391633034, 0.04138512909412384, 0.03650286793708801, 0.022541256621479988, -0.0468805655837059, -0.03711627423763275, 0.023163804784417152, -0.00706851901486516, -0.023254169151186943, -0.04484311863780022, -0.017529431730508804, -0.023968661203980446, -0.05284157022833824, 0.015880374237895012, 0.08115016669034958, -0.014292185194790363, -0.055033985525369644, -0.030497847124934196, 0.009100689552724361, 0.08221442997455597, -0.040188904851675034, -0.02537589520215988, 0.03799612447619438, -0.02483236789703369, -0.010083016939461231, -0.011979908682405949, 0.03824235498905182, -0.04907555133104324, -0.027900807559490204, -0.030309932306408882, 0.0004350724339019507, 0.014418854378163815, -0.0029543177224695683, -0.02583017572760582, 0.02186885103583336, 0.0009259548969566822, 0.04392096400260925, -0.02479381486773491, -0.023556366562843323, 0.017519937828183174, 0.02079688385128975, -0.015576640143990517, 0.001339812995865941, -0.022740812972187996, 0.0009779310785233974, 0.061074331402778625, 0.005429019685834646, -0.005071056541055441, 0.003211582312360406, 0.0802110806107521, -0.03175058960914612, 0.027018679305911064, 0.02644551359117031, -0.05946407839655876, 0.04458204284310341, 0.0432610921561718, -0.0175765510648489, 0.029963141307234764, -0.00030870907357893884, -0.05693274363875389, -0.04055425152182579, -0.040437109768390656, 0.056037455797195435, 0.025587452575564384, 0.0006817776011303067, 0.011499508284032345, 0.022784974426031113, -0.007614857517182827, 0.000014938029380573425, -0.0076316655613482, -0.023120976984500885, 0.013205992989242077, -0.016479186713695526, 0.02886108122766018, -0.00030985221383161843, 0.013206087052822113, 0.008806347846984863, 0.016242025420069695, -0.002015529666095972, 0.03583583980798721, 0.030271433293819427, 0.01852872036397457, -0.005641178227961063, -0.03241008520126343, -0.029376499354839325, 0.05534052848815918, -0.04529230669140816, 0.01558409258723259, -0.011211417615413666, -0.022928209975361824, 0.049249473959207535, 0.02801825851202011, 0.011250685900449753, -0.020307565107941628, 0.004280957393348217, 0.0020235690753906965, -0.015451113693416119, -0.00689543504267931, -0.005394025705754757, 0.042343419045209885, 0.00031186483101919293, 0.008178018033504486, -0.012489860877394676, 0.03062427043914795, -0.014309126883745193, -0.06929075717926025, -0.037385281175374985, -0.04132891446352005, -0.06538441777229309, 0.00576219754293561, -0.01694321259856224, -0.026018382981419563, 0.0487208254635334, -0.06362284719944, 0.02397042140364647, 0.01838456280529499, 0.03896304965019226, -0.02378748543560505, 0.05965648964047432, 0.0063866362906992435, 0.023825753480196, -0.020616240799427032, -0.013919786550104618, 0.11346523463726044, 0.07325860112905502, -0.0036534746177494526, -0.04262855276465416, 0.04801610857248306, -0.03510656952857971, -0.009997067041695118, 0.010813185013830662, -0.0048096696846187115, -0.01711728796362877, -0.008551056496798992, 0.02660555951297283, 0.0663192868232727, 0.0214814692735672, 0.01426528301090002, 0.007379765622317791, -0.01998712681233883, -0.04710962623357773, 0.05760154873132706, -0.013754812069237232, 0.01066779438406229, 0.01095154881477356, -0.04249787703156471, 0.009929629042744637, -0.0034829340875148773, -0.023764047771692276, -0.02462385594844818, 0.01317495945841074, -0.026970556005835533, -0.006366151850670576, -0.011686793528497219, 0.016668321564793587, -0.00041660110582597554, -0.012210341170430183, 0.0031375871039927006, -0.015361933968961239, -0.016066189855337143, -0.045399803668260574, 0.007860979996621609, 0.023542702198028564, -0.02180297113955021, 0.0018373499624431133, 0.005922806914895773, 0.03478287160396576, -0.022333795204758644, -0.04547005519270897, -0.04277394711971283, 0.0416271798312664, -0.004076561890542507, -0.005996936932206154, 0.002210536738857627, -0.005701971240341663, -0.009338394738733768, -0.036943528801202774, -0.0032106745056807995, 0.037624750286340714, 0.04633873328566551, -0.02412968873977661, -0.033758632838726044, -0.030367886647582054, 0.02321314811706543, 0.0015019498532637954, -0.015668293461203575, 0.051703035831451416, -0.008590543642640114, -0.00605546310544014, 0.012429251335561275, -0.00568802934139967, -0.02079317905008793, 0.0002157485141651705, 0.019890060648322105, 0.029334556311368942, -0.06200674548745155, -0.016623569652438164, 0.001018179696984589, 0.008190149441361427, 0.0666811540722847, -0.009083456359803677, 0.018684471026062965, 0.012332051061093807, -0.08096476644277573, 0.0514313243329525, -0.0452284999191761, -0.021345077082514763, -0.0487440750002861, -0.03906264528632164, 0.002925183391198516, 0.01617421954870224, 0.005054457113146782, 0.01030744332820177, -0.00539650022983551, 0.03691841661930084, 0.013127648271620274, -0.028963396325707436, 0.011204461567103863, 0.009497217833995819, -0.0017531486228108406, 0.02473800629377365, -0.0037553661968559027, 0.0800117626786232, 0.044150661677122116, 0.0200590118765831, 0.0361194871366024, 0.026503950357437134, -0.004444665741175413, -0.004312305711209774, -0.006740219425410032, -0.038599636405706406, 0.01899266242980957, 0.00404396140947938, -0.01217603124678135, -0.04424675181508064, -0.013413580134510994, -0.051210880279541016, -0.014561024494469166, 0.014287194237112999, -0.005711634177714586, -0.019178146496415138, 0.019548630341887474, -0.033586159348487854, -0.008646512404084206, -0.011226181872189045, -0.041474804282188416, 0.014390288852155209, -0.010506870225071907, -0.029514070600271225, 0.003819928038865328, -0.03131233528256416, 0.008437618613243103, -0.011100192554295063, 0.011382043361663818, 0.045423708856105804, -0.012539509683847427, 0.0040419199503958225, -0.005923225544393063, -0.010944278910756111, 0.0028892389964312315, 0.044850803911685944, -0.04323539137840271, 0.009782264940440655, 0.05060717836022377, -0.07010223716497421, -0.05139009654521942, 0.013047316111624241, 0.0356469489634037, 0.028161631897091866, 0.01883886195719242, 0.010911407880485058, -0.00606849230825901, 0.04341574385762215, -0.050077129155397415, -0.03490765765309334, -0.026108387857675552, 0.025383416563272476, 0.012322179041802883, -0.024349885061383247, -0.002646168926730752, -0.0053075277246534824, -0.0009235440520569682, 0.03902455046772957, 0.02881188690662384, -0.00781304482370615, -0.004712464287877083, 0.06009252369403839, -0.019805576652288437, 0.00479328166693449, 0.00898899044841528, 0.02870182693004608, -0.01639961265027523, 0.04551927372813225, -0.017980771139264107, 0.026523465290665627, -0.04381769895553589, -0.015319252386689186, -0.09268111735582352, -0.034418392926454544, -0.00568834925070405, 0.024932870641350746, 0.019302453845739365, -0.08215842396020889, -0.010217295028269291, 0.03351883217692375, -0.046774715185165405, 0.0038151927292346954, -0.0026417295448482037, -0.0463758148252964, -0.03620968014001846, 0.013131292536854744, -0.014302467927336693, 0.032840628176927567, 0.018980296328663826, -0.016387049108743668, 0.03990444540977478, 0.024054672569036484, -0.017794912680983543, -0.056385550647974014, 0.01098676212131977, 0.026141993701457977, -0.011452867649495602, -0.05711672082543373, 0.002609374700114131, 0.003915545996278524, -0.009104033000767231, 0.047474708408117294, 0.00031099861371330917, 0.00581592321395874, 0.03096538595855236, 0.05308486148715019, -0.011794674210250378, 0.04064076766371727, 0.0198851078748703, 0.005312202963978052, 0.009953991509974003, 0.02534179762005806, 0.03347590193152428, 0.04340657964348793, 0.013855024240911007, -0.002985024591907859, 0.03316716477274895, -0.0008056635269895196, -0.01999320462346077, 0.015885112807154655, -0.01635846495628357, -0.012583719566464424, 0.03054378367960453, 0.003774072276428342, -0.012802453711628914, -0.05973917245864868, 0.04601683095097542, -0.025180382654070854, -0.01043475978076458, 0.032747089862823486, 0.04757475107908249, 0.006365679204463959, 0.004043076653033495, 0.003136467421427369, -0.0034795301035046577, 0.045012082904577255, 0.02698689140379429, -0.015421505086123943, -0.03138530254364014, -0.018688181415200233, 0.04224314168095589, -0.010665586218237877, -0.015716837719082832, 0.0036588378716260195, -0.022662628442049026, 0.03289705887436867, -0.012447239831089973, 0.013824913650751114, -0.002428156090900302, -0.005668905563652515, -0.00007868721877457574, -0.06716499477624893, 0.08071097731590271, -0.011917506344616413, 0.013830810785293579, -0.03217329457402229, -0.019134266301989555, -0.016283616423606873, 0.000447814934886992, 0.04326027259230614, 0.008876315318048, -0.017144618555903435, 0.013605457730591297, 0.03374381363391876, 0.023117225617170334, -0.04126591607928276, 0.036512549966573715, -0.025844478979706764, -0.025810953229665756, -0.040085338056087494, -0.009086732752621174, 0.01242841687053442, 0.012978635728359222, -0.03695480525493622, -0.0009745454299263656, 0.034095123410224915, 0.011504662223160267, 0.015272300690412521, 0.031250931322574615, 0.033216413110494614, 0.0157794039696455, 0.03537435084581375, -0.06631627678871155, 0.031030140817165375, 0.029529990628361702, 0.010728912428021431, -0.0469396710395813, 0.0013040017802268267, -0.0419904850423336, -0.04206232354044914, -0.020756138488650322, 0.007907602936029434, 0.005092403385788202, -0.0444662980735302, -0.0005329496343620121, 0.02144882082939148, -0.02757316455245018, 0.019706573337316513, 0.05324914678931236, 0.010951809585094452, 0.035995714366436005, -0.03102106973528862, 0.0184851735830307, 0.0028871309477835894, -0.026862720027565956, -0.011310084722936153, -0.012824771925807, -0.0019503537332639098, -0.004037186037749052, 0.035039063543081284, 0.042501162737607956, -0.001316446578130126, 0.04837610572576523, 0.008334591053426266, 0.035707876086235046, -0.02193787321448326, -0.02322571724653244, 0.019300533458590508, -0.018872467800974846, 0.02618711069226265, 0.014012394472956657, -0.02252037264406681, 0.05608475208282471, -0.0033398433588445187, 0.007414616644382477, 0.003893238725140691, 0.0019149676663801074, -0.01978500373661518, -0.03946831077337265, -0.029997462406754494, 0.03531383350491524, 0.003143895883113146, 0.025149140506982803, 0.02084084413945675, 0.021757375448942184, 0.03413711115717888, -0.031014569103717804, 0.062374718487262726, 0.0020932909101247787, -0.002132542198523879, -0.04803427681326866, -0.013360320590436459, -0.0044201333075761795, -0.006088383961468935, 0.028723739087581635, 0.03760229051113129, 2.902439746321761e-7, 0.00008672579133417457, -0.02138735167682171, 0.019985102117061615, 0.050180379301309586, -0.049035318195819855, -0.012301217764616013, -0.043473340570926666, -0.0038786791265010834, -0.009361647069454193, -0.03456060215830803 ]
<p>I've called my question "clustering" but I am not sure if that's the right term. Imagine my matrix looks like this:</p> <pre><code>[ 0. , 0.92, 0. , 0.85, 0. ] [ 0.92, 0. , 0. , 0.89, 0. ] [ 0.85, 0. , 0. , 0.89, 0. ] [ 0. , 0. , 0. , 0. , 0. ] [ 0. , 0.89, 0. , 0.89, 0. ] </code></pre> <p>What I am after is not a single clustering/dendrogram of indices, I am after extracting largest possible rectangles from the matrix (by re-arranging X/Y indices).</p> <p>For example, from the above I am expecting to get:</p> <pre><code>[ 0.92, 0.89, 0. , 0. , 0. ] [ 0.85, 0.89, 0. , 0. , 0. ] [ 0. , 0.85, 0.92, 0. , 0. ] [ 0. , 0.89, 0.89, 0. , 0. ] [ 0. , 0. , 0. , 0. , 0. ] </code></pre> <p>However, I expect each cluster to be identified, even if it is not possible to show them all in a single matrix.</p> <p>What would be an algorithm I should be after? I've tried various clustering algorithms and they give me best single clustering, not focusing on the best individuals (which are mutually incompatible).</p>
23,909
[ -0.04743260517716408, 0.0017703654011711478, 0.0044801728799939156, -0.022492768242955208, 0.018661003559827805, 0.02456522360444069, -0.0057456353679299355, -0.00800261739641428, -0.005191555246710777, -0.06208104267716408, 0.027608191594481468, 0.05445355549454689, 0.05240596830844879, 0.05067051574587822, 0.024809036403894424, -0.02523922361433506, -0.03859977051615715, 0.00044630683260038495, -0.013482766225934029, -0.03423308581113815, -0.018032725900411606, -0.031973645091056824, 0.017505235970020294, 0.0017527026357129216, -0.02811736986041069, 0.04769549518823624, 0.016460375860333443, 0.024711856618523598, 0.020394837483763695, 0.03844805434346199, -0.0507655069231987, -0.031195439398288727, 0.006415392272174358, -0.00905819796025753, 0.037583865225315094, -0.018386799842119217, -0.014481849037110806, 0.015146218240261078, -0.034629371017217636, 0.01003373134881258, -0.04045352339744568, -0.044793084263801575, -0.017248190939426422, 0.04444621503353119, -0.001966926036402583, 0.03267182409763336, 0.007734749931842089, -0.03401006758213043, 0.030071550980210304, -0.040881481021642685, 0.11604537069797516, 0.031387027353048325, 0.053630389273166656, 0.024715986102819443, -0.04876473918557167, -0.0029603363946080208, 0.035323772579431534, 0.04211711511015892, -0.00071953289443627, -0.028132978826761246, -0.010021119378507137, -0.00660718372091651, 0.018050700426101685, -0.02366812527179718, -0.05150322616100311, 0.01680082455277443, -0.0452483668923378, -0.02370896376669407, 0.059013430029153824, -0.0036040174309164286, -0.03413086757063866, 0.020914243534207344, 0.07813505828380585, -0.04430701956152916, 0.016549034044146538, -0.01998266577720642, -0.0030376415234059095, 0.05229289084672928, 0.02170160412788391, -0.015852665528655052, -0.011103032156825066, 0.03824343532323837, 0.006678055040538311, -0.006502303760498762, 0.06483086943626404, -0.022274289280176163, 0.07029016315937042, -0.062319185584783554, 0.007067906204611063, 0.03546911105513573, -0.015673121437430382, -0.007167378440499306, 0.05410374328494072, 0.04349258542060852, -0.040667593479156494, 0.03772691264748573, 0.010272628627717495, 0.01664079539477825, -0.008034172467887402, -0.018983636051416397, -0.01644013822078705, -0.022910092025995255, -0.03894423693418503, 0.020104369148612022, -0.012609009630978107, 0.014119476079940796, -0.0751398354768753, 0.009795193560421467, -0.009891416877508163, 0.01919436827301979, -0.0034109591506421566, 0.005066591780632734, 0.005001379642635584, -0.0019243955612182617, 0.03540819138288498, -0.019905151799321175, -0.005299837328493595, 0.02308836206793785, -0.002171561121940613, 0.07361945509910583, 0.017001226544380188, -0.006832517217844725, 0.049749597907066345, -0.047766394913196564, -0.09415541589260101, 0.010965724475681782, -0.0051003252156078815, -0.0010676009114831686, -0.03198680654168129, 0.03105844371020794, 0.019002219662070274, -0.011677891947329044, 0.058036256581544876, -0.058096349239349365, 0.02883031778037548, -0.004903706721961498, -0.058905698359012604, -0.05666066333651543, 0.024889230728149414, -0.012563670985400677, 0.028650378808379173, -0.04022456705570221, 0.0018414685036987066, 0.036008015275001526, 0.06987880915403366, -0.008677504025399685, 0.031181098893284798, 0.03255483880639076, 0.010462954640388489, 0.02989104762673378, -0.042078860104084015, -0.003410683711990714, -0.0027404658030718565, -0.05574740469455719, 0.03291771933436394, -0.018132133409380913, -0.010690685361623764, 0.012457387521862984, -0.019397374242544174, 0.005698788445442915, 0.02416292205452919, -0.0038883048109710217, 0.012952794320881367, -0.010725715197622776, -0.010798768140375614, 0.0016707141185179353, 0.07411234080791473, -0.005821506027132273, 0.06236133351922035, 0.03866937756538391, -0.04342637211084366, 0.05105986446142197, 0.035975467413663864, 0.0320168174803257, 0.04987721145153046, -0.0010675342055037618, -0.004250519908964634, 0.002596866572275758, 0.010990303009748459, 0.009550032205879688, -0.04122820124030113, -0.07124801725149155, 0.04769669100642204, 0.0032156738452613354, 0.025566134601831436, 0.048253852874040604, 0.003081169445067644, -0.04752497375011444, 0.037245746701955795, -0.024028826504945755, -0.0038994282949715853, -0.0518256351351738, -0.010973645374178886, 0.005299743264913559, -0.002845974639058113, 0.03649064898490906, -0.0216546468436718, -0.009678211063146591, 0.034197255969047546, -0.02742544189095497, -0.0659276470541954, 0.028434768319129944, 0.04245303198695183, -0.02774907648563385, 0.006395131349563599, 0.027094542980194092, 0.04253428429365158, -0.008388049900531769, 0.07423216104507446, -0.02203432098031044, -0.014889789745211601, 0.014007664285600185, -0.03295028954744339, -0.00952834077179432, -0.008988704532384872, 0.00014161253056954592, 0.00411318801343441, 0.03796803206205368, -0.03496948629617691, 0.005231549963355064, -0.0252816341817379, 0.060718029737472534, 0.03544619306921959, 0.0008345548994839191, -0.00848073698580265, -0.017066139727830887, -0.017686352133750916, 0.019048471003770828, -0.020573195070028305, 0.003746830625459552, -0.05497162789106369, 0.002319865394383669, 0.04654749855399132, 0.02428855374455452, -0.07274656742811203, 0.015657344833016396, 0.025480257347226143, 0.015301228500902653, -0.010363209992647171, 0.06137501820921898, -0.03573077917098999, 0.015200587920844555, 0.02469007484614849, 0.02733851969242096, 0.022526543587446213, 0.0003537505108397454, 0.03764580562710762, 0.004887410439550877, 0.014095769263803959, -0.032191790640354156, -0.0038785107899457216, 0.04677850753068924, -0.032109081745147705, -0.009172115474939346, 0.011181654408574104, -0.03700367361307144, 0.0010902839712798595, 0.011649716645479202, 0.004576605744659901, -0.0009800202678889036, -0.001263934071175754, -0.034262094646692276, -0.01703091524541378, -0.01991753838956356, -0.0038355218712240458, 0.0653599426150322, -0.04818084463477135, 0.001394010498188436, 0.016721129417419434, -0.04165317118167877, 0.054975371807813644, -0.008584335446357727, -0.014325196854770184, -0.016877375543117523, 0.039660580456256866, 0.06661064922809601, 0.031319450587034225, 0.0227680504322052, -0.00599056389182806, -0.022112935781478882, -0.021384213119745255, -0.03387264162302017, 0.03465540334582329, 0.03034411557018757, -0.06108685955405235, -0.01904752105474472, -0.027211952954530716, -0.007805560249835253, 0.013314739800989628, 0.03229333087801933, -0.034084662795066833, 0.03088102675974369, -0.02299603819847107, -0.03748688846826553, -0.002397149568423629, -0.042777787894010544, 0.03204285725951195, -0.0069079468958079815, 0.01817329041659832, 0.049430426210165024, -0.009537113830447197, -0.06969856470823288, 0.013438870199024677, -0.045592762529850006, -0.017421463504433632, -0.017989972606301308, -0.03536000847816467, 0.024645797908306122, 0.014406207017600536, -0.018559526652097702, 0.040713150054216385, 0.005966545082628727, 0.017849581316113472, -0.04688389226794243, -0.08062547445297241, -0.02873801253736019, -0.014876564964652061, 0.026135491207242012, 0.025022543966770172, -0.018931493163108826, 0.06620226800441742, 0.012779776006937027, -0.03455395624041557, -0.029880233108997345, 0.02458362840116024, -0.01199775468558073, -0.0011928007006645203, 0.002045807894319296, -0.005574370734393597, 0.0038464167155325413, -0.006918467581272125, 0.017164448276162148, 0.04741945117712021, 0.07286427170038223, -0.01332564651966095, 0.003710994031280279, 0.005973044317215681, -0.006472596898674965, -0.051090918481349945, 0.0008991887443698943, 0.016123531386256218, -0.019193582236766815, 0.05770578607916832, -0.02287663333117962, -0.023726848885416985, 0.030691450461745262, -0.01237670611590147, -0.004703844897449017, -0.0398654043674469, 0.03004615195095539, -0.013335979543626308, -0.03172100707888603, -0.003971891477704048, -0.01394675299525261, -0.019470511004328728, 0.03319490700960159, 0.03236132487654686, -0.015415060333907604, -0.022227812558412552, 0.060655660927295685, 0.038278862833976746, -0.0208748709410429, 0.018848348408937454, 0.013438518159091473, -0.012252511456608772, -0.011227444745600224, -0.003279648954048753, 0.009258207865059376, 0.026092158630490303, 0.024076266214251518, 0.025991661474108696, 0.014432348310947418, -0.018661150708794594, 0.03685268759727478, -0.05195553973317146, 0.019497258588671684, -0.05734671652317047, 0.042343735694885254, -0.03742010518908501, 0.022294960916042328, 0.056204963475465775, 0.009551380760967731, 0.02584885247051716, 0.02928013540804386, -0.06675562262535095, -0.003986573312431574, 0.011208679527044296, 0.008956745266914368, -0.04301472008228302, -0.03408874198794365, -0.002140125958248973, -0.01197005994617939, 0.018163546919822693, 0.04659460112452507, 0.0038363563362509012, -0.05344584584236145, 0.04433826357126236, -0.01625821739435196, 0.012993652373552322, -0.006366810295730829, 0.021941769868135452, 0.010678979568183422, 0.018033014610409737, 0.057993825525045395, 0.021907173097133636, -0.02519313246011734, 0.04063224792480469, 0.012735475786030293, 0.02297264337539673, 0.015911299735307693, 0.01684214547276497, -0.021287834271788597, 0.0472809299826622, -0.006766425911337137, -0.04195566475391388, -0.0012388451723381877, 0.052793219685554504, -0.008742482401430607, -0.012807751074433327, -0.041142016649246216, -0.025204496458172798, -0.016775766387581825, -0.009737801738083363, 0.017082927748560905, -0.024413790553808212, 0.013200481422245502, 0.0015294903423637152, 0.06133357435464859, -0.071104034781456, 0.02344924584031105, 0.0972343310713768, 0.015535552054643631, -0.029825253412127495, -0.0257131177932024, -0.029879987239837646, 0.003274669172242284, -0.00938809011131525, -0.01472286693751812, 0.025162193924188614, 0.008146645501255989, 0.015964828431606293, 0.05018091946840286, -0.01724821701645851, -0.043593984097242355, 0.019278613850474358, -0.009859512560069561, 0.041222501546144485, -0.04442501813173294, -0.01659686677157879, -0.009474232792854309, 0.008106604218482971, 0.0025690605398267508, 0.036490704864263535, -0.04097549617290497, -0.10002274066209793, 0.010971036739647388, 0.03775624930858612, 0.047324683517217636, -0.007810734212398529, -0.010943219996988773, -0.04430758208036423, 0.011968661099672318, 0.018535995855927467, -0.03701401874423027, 0.04206192120909691, 0.0018424221780151129, 0.015898145735263824, -0.0013811758253723383, 0.026932768523693085, -0.019089743494987488, 0.00445987144485116, -0.0181028600782156, 0.0357915461063385, -0.030802248045802116, -0.029677635058760643, -0.06304463744163513, 0.013987218961119652, 0.0011942964047193527, 0.04139320179820061, -0.03038722462952137, -0.01521908026188612, 0.0009182885987684131, 0.034540124237537384, -0.028717268258333206, -0.0369936004281044, 0.027785545215010643, 0.0632816031575203, -0.008088653907179832, 0.07081640511751175, -0.022847462445497513, -0.04854719713330269, 0.02074580453336239, 0.0005610308726318181, 0.022526875138282776, 0.010164778679609299, 0.014210755005478859, 0.08626071363687515, 0.03351932764053345, -0.007585836108773947, 0.01888623833656311, 0.01569964550435543, 0.002186222467571497, 0.040517475455999374, -0.045844703912734985, 0.0029532010667026043, -0.011341840028762817, 0.015458834357559681, -0.0384349562227726, 0.04933718964457512, -0.015608993358910084, 0.031157134100794792, -0.02331221103668213, 0.04325738176703453, -0.022043734788894653, -0.025416607037186623, -0.010560132563114166, 0.031030500307679176, -0.0069156247191131115, -0.006920973304659128, 0.01220121793448925, 0.018121447414159775, -0.024958090856671333, -0.027638915926218033, 0.018793610855937004, -0.021633083000779152, 0.010720204561948776, 0.028515474870800972, -0.011631937697529793, -0.013121730647981167, -0.03729032725095749, 0.0008998838602565229, -0.000811543723102659, 0.0035171592608094215, 0.039037153124809265, -0.016075482591986656, 0.041750673204660416, 0.02517169527709484, -0.04330429062247276, -0.02462110109627247, 0.02362702414393425, -0.01966130919754505, 0.03671279549598694, -0.017621885985136032, -0.001736843609251082, -0.0014747733948752284, -0.0055651054717600346, -0.05720328912138939, -0.04695311561226845, 0.004353951197117567, 0.03700265288352966, -0.015696125105023384, -0.06705932319164276, -0.028353678062558174, -0.0002928157337009907, -0.019078128039836884, -0.0064171478152275085, 0.034519437700510025, -0.023040596395730972, -0.053175006061792374, -0.006440921686589718, 0.008673151955008507, 0.07499778270721436, 0.0008604727336205542, 0.014883176423609257, 0.00929331686347723, -0.007281502243131399, 0.02173525281250477, 0.006756484508514404, -0.01057407259941101, -0.028124717995524406, -0.014435294084250927, -0.03557974845170975, 0.004885938949882984, 0.07438691705465317, -0.03534100949764252, -0.012942078523337841, -0.01776762679219246, 0.025245707482099533, -0.00397499930113554, -0.03718021884560585, 0.013119228184223175, -0.03601717948913574, -0.04481191188097, -0.002641311613842845, 0.019397197291254997, 0.006405555177479982, -0.0084989657625556, 0.03883414342999458, 0.00516663771122694, -0.03498652204871178, 0.0037627655547112226, 0.06817548722028732, -0.02249312773346901, 0.00022192717005964369, 0.00811311136931181, -0.01987115480005741, 0.06319277733564377, 0.010037971660494804, -0.012066657654941082, -0.010496874339878559, 0.009501207619905472, 0.02089107595384121, -0.03200641646981239, -0.04238855838775635, 0.02038322389125824, 0.03778963163495064, 0.014534941874444485, 0.03781628608703613, 0.07470054924488068, 0.010163483209908009, 0.019736526533961296, -0.010253011249005795, -0.013423766009509563, 0.0052394019439816475, 0.0084723811596632, 0.042988039553165436, 0.015021691098809242, -0.017325475811958313, 0.058268383145332336, 0.01656482368707657, 0.024519426748156548, 0.03516780212521553, -0.00484301894903183, 0.012250755913555622, -0.007264850661158562, -0.04282330721616745, -0.05214020982384682, 0.025180328637361526, -0.042308539152145386, 0.03002551570534706, -0.05610166862607002, -0.05217494070529938, 0.026537157595157623, 0.006295198109000921, -0.012985517270863056, -0.010072440840303898, -0.021033216267824173, -0.03231236711144447, 0.007024252321571112, 0.013201860710978508, -0.01915702596306801, 0.009528120048344135, 0.006907474249601364, 0.002855549333617091, 0.03321170061826706, 0.014692283235490322, -0.04153882712125778, -0.07712848484516144, -0.057412806898355484, -0.028767310082912445, -0.027164718136191368, 0.03605707734823227, 0.030241437256336212, -0.042780451476573944, 0.03453032299876213, -0.03512852266430855, 0.005101135466247797, 0.02209167554974556, 0.03697307035326958, -0.0012680422514677048, 0.03927810862660408, 0.0300615131855011, 0.06472296267747879, -0.005155500955879688, -0.026825033128261566, 0.08931272476911545, 0.07585611194372177, 0.011848492547869682, -0.02516929805278778, 0.030577758327126503, 0.03506331145763397, -0.0488811656832695, -0.024183209985494614, 0.019061533734202385, 0.011274585500359535, 0.014688573777675629, 0.0366801880300045, 0.007017665077000856, 0.021213127300143242, 0.022020049393177032, -0.004070356488227844, -0.020882364362478256, -0.053345926105976105, 0.025460783392190933, 0.010854623280465603, -0.014021324925124645, -0.015163092873990536, -0.0634988322854042, 0.02552211470901966, 0.02578861638903618, 0.0036217321176081896, -0.029016759246587753, -0.014979648403823376, 0.01168928574770689, 0.02481098845601082, 0.0010771829402074218, 0.02099524438381195, -0.0008685805951245129, -0.0058333659544587135, -0.02595416083931923, 0.0052304877899587154, 0.011577185243368149, -0.0021401201374828815, 0.03358794003725052, -0.005614534020423889, 0.029477663338184357, -0.004534601233899593, -0.01854788325726986, 0.013917657546699047, -0.012095647864043713, -0.024517493322491646, -0.014586498960852623, 0.04135395213961601, -0.007651308551430702, -0.006787351332604885, 0.017957795411348343, 0.010254439897835255, 0.0004998610238544643, -0.0570777989923954, -0.013554442673921585, 0.024055108428001404, 0.05869205668568611, 0.015155959874391556, -0.005521198268979788, -0.02455037459731102, 0.04846876859664917, -0.017009347677230835, -0.0007274241652339697, -0.025295615196228027, -0.017336755990982056, -0.016166094690561295, -0.04273895174264908, 0.05982454866170883, -0.022650109604001045, -0.00807676650583744, -0.017389880493283272, -0.026746287941932678, -0.0061770351603627205, -0.036394745111465454, -0.015443773940205574, -0.0006855261162854731, 0.025683000683784485, 0.008600710891187191, -0.025624066591262817, -0.010945192538201809, -0.014245877973735332, -0.0011612999951466918, -0.029212014749646187, -0.02248779498040676, -0.028103070333600044, -0.0015269553987309337, 0.06739158928394318, 0.06029922515153885, -0.01905333623290062, 0.020321721211075783, -0.010623528622090816, 0.009055120870471, -0.003073388244956732, -0.02179022692143917, -0.04731442779302597, -0.005466353613883257, -0.037136197090148926, 0.05793081969022751, -0.03617183119058609, 0.06406289339065552, 0.014321462251245975, -0.022771669551730156, 0.00584745267406106, 0.04615906625986099, 0.012971633113920689, 0.006607521325349808, 0.004437074530869722, -0.029627544805407524, -0.04086776822805405, 0.003144921036437154, -0.045730821788311005, -0.027049891650676727, 0.008653665892779827, -0.015217295847833157, -0.037454839795827866, -0.003521164646372199, 0.005733557045459747, -0.03118634782731533, -0.011489873751997948, -0.03257348760962486, -0.030389145016670227, -0.03322141617536545, -0.03390848636627197, -0.025923652574419975, -0.0068860724568367004, -0.023134905844926834, -0.03095427341759205, -0.012111499905586243, 0.01371079869568348, 0.0019729111809283495, 0.010051851160824299, 0.027023309841752052, 0.011478410102427006, -0.0069677275605499744, 0.000753010914195329, -0.009077063761651516, -0.007085899822413921, 0.041118014603853226, -0.030796879902482033, -0.00001560130658617709, 0.031107038259506226, -0.04089751094579697, -0.046194929629564285, -0.027534954249858856, -0.007766497787088156, 0.051185719668865204, 0.01443379744887352, -0.010522020980715752, -0.02707165665924549, 0.056796275079250336, -0.03096383437514305, -0.026772091165184975, 0.017592253163456917, 0.015516151674091816, -0.012756203301250935, -0.019065789878368378, -0.004540319088846445, -0.005242920480668545, -0.028071489185094833, 0.020966632291674614, 0.020618075504899025, 0.019850825890898705, -0.032640986144542694, 0.023204851895570755, 0.027623789384961128, 0.02572662942111492, -0.00047845288645476103, -0.029353152960538864, 0.039846837520599365, 0.05213872715830803, -0.05342073366045952, -0.00943346694111824, -0.025939766317605972, 0.03319894149899483, -0.0593559555709362, 0.0006482786848209798, 0.0024328306317329407, -0.009426765143871307, 0.02967592515051365, -0.0314587838947773, 0.01154788862913847, 0.05139293521642685, -0.05115047097206116, 0.026359975337982178, 0.005451701581478119, 0.027467573061585426, -0.03457297757267952, 0.04343713819980621, -0.05006382614374161, 0.014062211848795414, 0.033808715641498566, 0.038462452590465546, 0.05844397842884064, 0.006224747281521559, -0.01283634826540947, -0.00658183079212904, 0.002615908160805702, -0.001751469331793487, 0.016034256666898727, -0.01888071931898594, 0.019940942525863647, -0.022791489958763123, -0.028728924691677094, 0.026436304673552513, -0.006821285467594862, -0.04427936673164368, 0.05792933329939842, 0.05445718392729759, 0.012819821015000343, 0.06053823605179787, 0.012679116800427437, -0.03317127004265785, -0.024090513586997986, 0.0027233194559812546, -0.005258453544229269, 0.021902570500969887, -0.0041250488720834255, 0.027271589264273643, -0.015113962814211845, 0.00769153842702508, -0.028229158371686935, 0.013083333149552345, -0.04919233173131943, -0.0095587819814682, -0.044501565396785736, -0.007886513136327267, 0.03527268022298813, -0.019495191052556038, 0.0004324939218349755, -0.020341703668236732, 0.028530007228255272, -0.012417510151863098, 0.028636250644922256, -0.009697617031633854, 0.015563939698040485, 0.002027441980317235, -0.03785819187760353, -0.010022892616689205, 0.006528629455715418, 0.005158206447958946, -0.03196188807487488, -0.017557796090841293, 0.0087206419557333, -0.021017074584960938, 0.005216152407228947, -0.02035704255104065, -0.021109363064169884, 0.06102484092116356, -0.03358384221792221, 0.001703263376839459, 0.06197849288582802, -0.03326689824461937, 0.0486052967607975, -0.08654756844043732, 0.0376114696264267, 0.024913378059864044, -0.007919280789792538, -0.020513197407126427, -0.025650974363088608, -0.036127347499132156, 0.04121412709355354, 0.030449196696281433, 0.0043472652323544025, -0.00467721140012145, 0.0023307320661842823, 0.008562404662370682, 0.0423477441072464, -0.041521668434143066, 0.05496534705162048, -0.031296007335186005, 0.004050289746373892, -0.014909574761986732, -0.0026280235033482313, 0.02581002563238144, -0.03218007832765579, 0.017817312851548195, 0.005037541966885328, -0.0605180449783802, 0.009690896607935429, -0.04307477921247482, 0.02451464533805847, -0.020888546481728554, -0.017097119241952896, 0.06703954190015793, -0.022192873060703278, 0.0005041585536673665, 0.0786421000957489, 0.00006386831228155643, -0.02962241880595684, -0.01713833585381508, -0.04809774458408356, -0.030956877395510674, 0.014727223664522171, 0.011861603707075119, 0.0410778746008873, -0.06601640582084656, -0.009236082434654236, -0.018758511170744896, -0.06551823019981384, -0.026356086134910583, 0.011471361853182316, 0.016705965623259544, 0.03379574790596962, 0.018154935911297798, 0.03733912855386734, 0.020713165402412415, 0.0024818340316414833, 0.004770570434629917, 0.032826244831085205, -0.0007851289701648057, 0.025321045890450478, 0.016628865152597427, -0.02188485860824585, 0.001748660928569734, 0.03811974823474884, -0.04354773089289665, 0.015283073298633099, -0.017687875777482986, 0.010325312614440918, 0.015925664454698563, -0.06537854671478271, -0.0004331326053943485, 0.00586159760132432, -0.001974729588255286, 0.020886322483420372, -0.02722434140741825, 0.014552359469234943, -0.03203889727592468, -0.024738425388932228, -0.013775015249848366, 0.009168211370706558, 0.01622810773551464, 0.029660489410161972, -0.04772752895951271, 0.022745246067643166, -0.0002165549958590418, 0.007552185095846653, 0.052378106862306595, -0.004277182277292013, 0.04411989077925682, -0.031767744570970535, -0.0025669150054454803, 0.028435764834284782, -0.004946214146912098, -0.04375382140278816, -0.006277722772210836, 0.03742346540093422, 0.033494316041469574, 0.022045210003852844, -0.033819958567619324, -0.02604869194328785, -0.06149579584598541, 0.011253079399466515, -0.043816566467285156, -0.002358575351536274, -0.05995893105864525, 0.01925848051905632, 0.003947217483073473, 0.022423366084694862 ]
<p>I have a biometric authentication system that is using a person's gait to authenticate them. I extract features from gait, run it through a comparison versus a template and produce a similarity score (where if this similarity score is below a certain threshold, then the user is authenticated). So, I have 72 trials total (36 trials containing a positive case and 36 that contain a negative case). What I want to do is graph the ability of this system to authenticate people by illustrating it with a ROC graph. </p> <p>Unfortunately, I don't quite understand how to choose a threshold. Is there some mathematical procedure involved for choosing a threshold for the similarity scores? Do I just choose a bunch of different thresholds, and graph the corresponding ROC curves for all these different threshold values? The resulting similarity scores vary from [0.6,1.2] where the positive cases tend to lie around 0.6. All my coding is being done in Matlab. </p>
51
[ -0.025457993149757385, -0.037425342947244644, 0.015200045891106129, 0.001366278505884111, 0.00780623871833086, 0.019345249980688095, -0.02446667291224003, -0.009182519279420376, 0.0069872974418103695, 0.015906834974884987, 0.04366371035575867, 0.01807093806564808, 0.06424606591463089, 0.04164251312613487, 0.01959792897105217, -0.023137468844652176, -0.0026056868955492973, -0.038340769708156586, -0.017052823677659035, -0.04532313346862793, 0.016374466940760612, 0.01169635821133852, 0.04364633187651634, -0.00691455602645874, -0.024628063663840294, 0.022630814462900162, 0.06146930903196335, -0.0167988371104002, 0.0003993340942543, 0.039770618081092834, -0.09548255801200867, 0.01781139150261879, 0.026368282735347748, 0.002940206555649638, 0.010219547897577286, 0.0341033898293972, -0.03249465301632881, -0.00029635627288371325, -0.027663541957736015, 0.0077638472430408, -0.013850129209458828, 0.020451197400689125, 0.023251520469784737, 0.055067453533411026, -0.030781976878643036, -0.0030522900633513927, 0.018404196947813034, -0.04056816175580025, 0.0256793349981308, -0.03995542228221893, 0.07846323400735855, -0.015155530534684658, 0.05135544762015343, 0.03427479416131973, 0.04759814590215683, -0.006462986581027508, 0.060883987694978714, 0.08679477870464325, 0.014431227929890156, -0.05106812343001366, -0.013181954622268677, -0.040551621466875076, -0.005991622805595398, -0.019331440329551697, 0.003711885306984186, 0.041169121861457825, -0.025143837556242943, -0.01351550966501236, 0.043773047626018524, -0.03039366565644741, -0.013383084908127785, 0.038465745747089386, 0.04464445263147354, -0.03536033257842064, 0.04282769933342934, -0.024180591106414795, 0.013977093622088432, 0.02943994477391243, 0.05071169137954712, -0.0062634809873998165, -0.00169105245731771, 0.017547430470585823, -0.008535529486835003, 0.02989896945655346, 0.014065125957131386, -0.03149136155843735, 0.05648307129740715, -0.06468715518712997, 0.019981132820248604, 0.022196605801582336, -0.007881302386522293, 0.009596548974514008, 0.03217014670372009, 0.02993655949831009, -0.030815163627266884, 0.026506928727030754, 0.02028685435652733, 0.01836235448718071, 0.0050805676728487015, 0.03494623303413391, -0.03136685863137245, -0.04658323526382446, -0.009761592373251915, 0.04711590334773064, -0.003737320192158222, 0.04762914031744003, -0.018059875816106796, -0.018557609990239143, 0.00769785838201642, -0.011926260776817799, -0.055781178176403046, 0.005164340604096651, 0.023577410727739334, 0.01448771357536316, 0.003073283238336444, -0.007085245102643967, -0.03679858148097992, -0.04688114672899246, 0.032315321266651154, 0.016241971403360367, 0.000202572628040798, -0.014572478830814362, 0.03064347244799137, -0.030333971604704857, -0.05176375061273575, 0.0207597054541111, -0.01806817017495632, -0.012235617265105247, -0.051583703607320786, 0.046292196959257126, 0.0003366445889696479, -0.03919414430856705, 0.01579638198018074, 0.0021022192668169737, 0.02723100408911705, -0.024907274171710014, -0.05943485349416733, -0.03513208404183388, 0.029177282005548477, -0.033736638724803925, 0.014251995831727982, -0.06629207730293274, -0.0023094795178622007, 0.07507176697254181, 0.05557055398821831, 0.04082857817411423, 0.03890807554125786, 0.004198422189801931, 0.00217107473872602, 0.006159331649541855, -0.026522565633058548, -0.014653244987130165, -0.03523312509059906, -0.025060003623366356, -0.015428708866238594, -0.07786035537719727, -0.006331280805170536, 0.01114631537348032, -0.025215251371264458, -0.0483996719121933, 0.016673780977725983, -0.017923053354024887, 0.009869962930679321, -0.039983395487070084, -0.015409799292683601, 0.012561461888253689, 0.0878520980477333, -0.0034935553558170795, 0.010969656519591808, 0.014887715689837933, 0.0016654562205076218, -0.030913781374692917, 0.0022192501928657293, 0.0488877110183239, 0.06989508867263794, -0.0001048275371431373, -0.005528403911739588, -0.019850676879286766, 0.014909129589796066, 0.014474140480160713, -0.029290756210684776, -0.04745717719197273, -0.015081343241035938, 0.0049604554660618305, 0.029314139857888222, 0.022301048040390015, -0.006183433812111616, -0.025514181703329086, 0.034538038074970245, -0.014107641763985157, -0.03576035425066948, -0.08051539212465286, 0.009830445982515812, 0.010323099792003632, -0.03684944286942482, -0.0023436842020601034, 0.0013735542306676507, 0.005752730183303356, -0.023119309917092323, -0.019184157252311707, -0.02598506584763527, -0.04301900789141655, 0.016616670414805412, -0.058087386190891266, -0.008621829561889172, 0.05643601343035698, 0.04377114400267601, -0.009800073690712452, 0.0827908143401146, -0.041639652103185654, -0.02452429197728634, 0.006352018099278212, -0.024637408554553986, 0.012532648630440235, 0.023299964144825935, -0.012593197636306286, 0.0013812882825732231, -0.01927364245057106, -0.0339706689119339, 0.020849494263529778, -0.0376104936003685, 0.07845599949359894, 0.07413674890995026, 0.011726087890565395, -0.005844491999596357, -0.0022380242589861155, 0.006754097994416952, 0.0016667639138177037, 0.003732766257598996, -0.02797805331647396, -0.026370106264948845, -0.04390349239110947, 0.043248433619737625, 0.030807869508862495, -0.03816967457532883, 0.009163704700767994, 0.030216911807656288, 0.00897354818880558, 0.026500945910811424, 0.030315905809402466, 0.03834080696105957, -0.004347164183855057, 0.011265391483902931, 0.02660740539431572, -0.006342662498354912, -0.02693682722747326, 0.023700939491391182, 0.0145155293866992, 0.023425424471497536, -0.0031705324072390795, -0.013735159300267696, 0.03418314829468727, -0.014080091379582882, 0.03640155494213104, -0.04058869555592537, -0.011241649277508259, 0.036495890468358994, 0.006869491655379534, -0.024536864832043648, 0.05274306237697601, -0.004294286482036114, 0.017598900943994522, 0.029050342738628387, -0.012878729030489922, 0.03240756317973137, 0.04011116921901703, -0.010724961757659912, 0.00436780322343111, 0.022331630811095238, -0.06036991626024246, 0.026124751195311546, -0.017102809622883797, -0.029693497344851494, -0.025075359269976616, 0.045064326375722885, 0.0443229041993618, -0.02504122257232666, 0.045422766357660294, -0.012601644732058048, -0.058639101684093475, -0.0018049186328426003, 0.016730934381484985, 0.044549934566020966, 0.031809043139219284, -0.056046437472105026, -0.012839126400649548, -0.009898791089653969, -0.02804037183523178, 0.018209757283329964, -0.043836791068315506, 0.0003227009146939963, 0.0026915380731225014, 0.003405656898394227, -0.02253774181008339, -0.018818337470293045, -0.05268726125359535, 0.0012777599040418863, 0.012010205537080765, -0.010981573723256588, 0.03037492372095585, 0.006846943404525518, -0.05759628862142563, 0.034026455134153366, -0.009256166405975819, -0.008279833942651749, -0.007822697050869465, 0.016104266047477722, 0.025352902710437775, -0.0020756181329488754, 0.016017284244298935, 0.01620570756494999, 0.007904811762273312, -0.023941777646541595, -0.055871423333883286, -0.04836955666542053, 0.014602789655327797, -0.034242209047079086, 0.01959955506026745, 0.03795899450778961, 0.005232709925621748, 0.07596232742071152, 0.03785780444741249, -0.0015045020263642073, -0.03776427358388901, -0.02782553620636463, -0.02812393568456173, -0.030055634677410126, 0.02461608313024044, 0.0585944801568985, -0.024623041972517967, 0.034325011074543, -0.022614894434809685, 0.011194249615073204, 0.05783481523394585, -0.0008888988522812724, -0.01779201067984104, -0.0038775946013629436, -0.03741345554590225, -0.0354766845703125, 0.012361221015453339, 0.03122006542980671, -0.02643347904086113, 0.04750152677297592, 0.015083312056958675, -0.014845934696495533, 0.014990279451012611, -0.00578973488882184, 0.02702411077916622, -0.007002025842666626, 0.028389140963554382, -0.0473824180662632, -0.026711968705058098, -0.006568810902535915, -0.01786426082253456, -0.0047219982370734215, 0.01707570254802704, 0.02432701177895069, -0.042344480752944946, -0.015316307544708252, 0.059086959809064865, 0.03998452425003052, 0.00768055347725749, 0.014544415287673473, -0.014599182642996311, -0.020363271236419678, -0.0006494980771094561, -0.014148188754916191, -0.008462184108793736, 0.02777578867971897, 0.001923075644299388, 0.020410271361470222, 0.048197001218795776, -0.02308664470911026, -0.016033940017223358, -0.05368002876639366, -0.027801470831036568, -0.027343912050127983, 0.07940974831581116, 0.007899312302470207, -0.004211890045553446, 0.052523545920848846, -0.003745396388694644, -0.017283985391259193, 0.0124898636713624, -0.058910224586725235, 0.03990582004189491, -0.020013421773910522, -0.013379339128732681, 0.024785419926047325, 0.0009435529937036335, -0.003052874468266964, -0.02973671443760395, -0.014184733852744102, 0.01575506292283535, 0.03433452919125557, -0.02387112006545067, 0.0017727226950228214, -0.01978990249335766, -0.0008869182784110308, -0.034136366099119186, 0.02984905056655407, 0.003839282551780343, -0.0027655651792883873, -0.002847198396921158, -0.0039620050229132175, -0.01945720985531807, -0.033111877739429474, 0.000025953149815904908, 0.01871975138783455, 0.024116480723023415, 0.04022587835788727, 0.03188285231590271, 0.022887175902724266, -0.03331270068883896, 0.000829515338409692, -0.013312806375324726, 0.059214767068624496, 0.03037211298942566, -0.019749674946069717, 0.004422785248607397, -0.08649547398090363, -0.01832479238510132, 0.006371169816702604, 0.045906856656074524, -0.05737360939383507, -0.003926697187125683, 0.01100326981395483, -0.002032242249697447, -0.08594408631324768, -0.0038603488355875015, 0.07504019886255264, 0.009436636231839657, -0.013036124408245087, -0.023004842922091484, -0.04889649897813797, -0.03874872624874115, -0.012876274064183235, 0.010331980884075165, 0.011012244038283825, -0.03944414481520653, 0.001103788847103715, 0.03635130450129509, -0.011844941414892673, -0.030469153076410294, -0.03093067742884159, 0.04869965836405754, 0.09064948558807373, -0.011035515926778316, -0.041762761771678925, -0.005362548399716616, 0.004496107809245586, 0.04608969762921333, 0.033240966498851776, 0.01213756762444973, -0.07017674297094345, -0.011300588957965374, 0.04292425140738487, 0.058061033487319946, -0.023067664355039597, -0.03753427043557167, -0.03773583099246025, 0.006175565533339977, 0.04051103815436363, -0.017036907374858856, 0.007734294515103102, -0.007367721758782864, 0.04132656008005142, -0.027702391147613525, 0.012186208739876747, -0.0297422893345356, 0.016253041103482246, 0.022858591750264168, 0.003223401727154851, -0.03813004493713379, -0.001621754840016365, -0.05140131339430809, 0.005198680330067873, -0.004357232712209225, 0.07801572978496552, 0.007796130143105984, -0.01753462292253971, 0.0182723980396986, -0.0026049597654491663, -0.03161061555147171, -0.0413903072476387, -0.0071531324647367, 0.014237071387469769, -0.004632715601474047, 0.05481402575969696, -0.006727728061378002, 0.015360462479293346, 0.001320938696153462, 0.02850537747144699, -0.015691285952925682, 0.020684245973825455, -0.014730103313922882, 0.05718943476676941, 0.04395836219191551, 0.004886803217232227, 0.03745521232485771, 0.023238331079483032, -0.013322358019649982, -0.00040849941433407366, -0.0036768196150660515, -0.0018296082271263003, -0.01528011541813612, -0.0220072902739048, -0.03113533928990364, 0.007942534051835537, -0.026675524190068245, 0.02255229279398918, -0.009939238429069519, 0.07113327831029892, -0.013653662987053394, -0.0018734992481768131, -0.017647746950387955, 0.021128717809915543, 0.02177315019071102, -0.017391139641404152, 0.04497487470507622, 0.03691541403532028, -0.0007883064681664109, -0.003051923820748925, -0.02197413332760334, 0.004363874904811382, 0.0031523562502115965, 0.018610071390867233, -0.01773480325937271, 0.00511179119348526, -0.05626267194747925, -0.001006124191917479, 0.007868929766118526, -0.053876008838415146, 0.041086018085479736, -0.01033969409763813, 0.02146674320101738, 0.01423010602593422, -0.00926996860653162, 0.005049508064985275, 0.02175953797996044, 0.0053375656716525555, 0.0202664602547884, -0.0517040379345417, 0.04616614803671837, -0.02619212493300438, 0.0021450493950396776, -0.054906535893678665, -0.03795313835144043, 0.01717204786837101, -0.006849612109363079, -0.01893869787454605, -0.03641018271446228, 0.005701404996216297, -0.009714770130813122, -0.007945943623781204, -0.007976921275258064, 0.05047402158379555, -0.0029563524294644594, -0.019900228828191757, -0.019016239792108536, -0.004886278882622719, 0.05719050392508507, -0.010782752186059952, -0.002762241056188941, 0.019223187118768692, 0.01825963705778122, -0.05159709230065346, -0.014675595797598362, 0.03361387550830841, -0.04907677322626114, -0.008762880228459835, -0.040610380470752716, 0.01256970688700676, 0.03452768176794052, -0.002508259378373623, -0.02280539833009243, 0.0012811175547540188, 0.016993120312690735, 0.017451008781790733, -0.03381161019206047, -0.009860965423285961, 0.017302677035331726, 0.003484351560473442, -0.0011008239816874266, -0.007714660372585058, -0.030425043776631355, -0.0016452432610094547, 0.029575422406196594, 0.03174993395805359, -0.008031387813389301, -0.022392045706510544, 0.04065129905939102, -0.021214377135038376, 0.00562170660123229, -0.008693893440067768, -0.02383352816104889, 0.03472340479493141, -0.002946750959381461, 0.01737663336098194, 0.02872318960726261, 0.01962258107960224, -0.041741978377103806, 0.02452097088098526, -0.05899297446012497, -0.017019327729940414, 0.026872342452406883, 0.0025608318392187357, 0.052518971264362335, 0.045936692506074905, 0.020560121163725853, 0.03571643307805061, -0.012517538852989674, -0.033562418073415756, -0.012302476912736893, 0.009417198598384857, 0.041667480021715164, -0.01619512028992176, 0.008899052627384663, 0.02180277369916439, -0.009885898791253567, 0.01474681030958891, 0.06578179448843002, -0.013902132399380207, 0.016607921570539474, 0.033949144184589386, -0.0332615040242672, -0.0019334161188453436, 0.04236128181219101, -0.04003337770700455, 0.05429800599813461, 0.010170520283281803, -0.01519972737878561, 0.0459870845079422, 0.03737562149763107, -0.0037592146545648575, -0.03296082094311714, 0.002518296940252185, -0.034170880913734436, 0.03169788792729378, 0.03837834298610687, -0.03892737627029419, 0.021050414070487022, 0.025322452187538147, 0.017775211483240128, 0.01289519015699625, 0.027878258377313614, -0.06886319071054459, -0.05019447207450867, -0.015413583256304264, -0.06265424937009811, -0.05724550783634186, 0.026459593325853348, 0.019184710457921028, -0.03592972084879875, 0.04090036451816559, -0.03813895583152771, 0.004805142991244793, -0.002933626528829336, 0.045762334018945694, -0.0005764837842434645, 0.076321080327034, -0.004145900718867779, 0.03255157545208931, 0.034118372946977615, 0.018700283020734787, 0.14420248568058014, 0.08260384202003479, 0.005451158620417118, -0.09381851553916931, 0.04905416816473007, 0.02692604809999466, -0.014009928330779076, -0.024578308686614037, 0.03102470375597477, 0.004982138518244028, -0.023186063393950462, 0.0586438812315464, 0.009953124448657036, -0.012483809143304825, -0.027397625148296356, 0.06783895194530487, -0.018195785582065582, -0.010911088436841965, 0.016880281269550323, 0.02533818781375885, -0.030318276956677437, -0.028635522350668907, -0.02793242409825325, 0.01879020780324936, -0.014759679324924946, -0.002711212495341897, 0.014557977207005024, -0.03081451542675495, 0.021224480122327805, -0.026937326416373253, 0.02474580891430378, 0.030557731166481972, 0.003383107017725706, 0.0010838634334504604, 0.028188804164528847, -0.012437288649380207, -0.007100406102836132, -0.039107874035835266, 0.022398769855499268, 0.041056305170059204, 0.010990289971232414, -0.0028494892176240683, -0.024407396093010902, -0.016077347099781036, -0.02660711109638214, -0.06143684685230255, -0.0784744843840599, 0.051228929311037064, 0.021032273769378662, -0.0027458840049803257, 0.01926523447036743, 0.015807198360562325, 0.02699713408946991, -0.06026661768555641, -0.044764645397663116, -0.01540143322199583, 0.04629772529006004, 0.007311234250664711, -0.0018314823973923922, -0.05246219038963318, 0.047665055841207504, 0.02879219502210617, -0.015307595022022724, 0.01832152158021927, -0.02617216669023037, 0.025655291974544525, -0.052565474063158035, 0.02219025418162346, -0.039059221744537354, -0.022057872265577316, 0.026188310235738754, -0.005566208157688379, -0.026003394275903702, -0.01619996875524521, -0.017880532890558243, -0.007532814983278513, 0.006859480869024992, 0.016301678493618965, -0.02553456649184227, 0.0029918437357991934, -0.006547003984451294, 0.008186767809092999, -0.033517152070999146, 0.0016701496206223965, -0.011737952008843422, -0.03389995917677879, 0.04443352669477463, 0.011821885593235493, 0.0034695349168032408, 0.017442675307393074, 0.011882501654326916, 0.013341075740754604, 0.016857847571372986, -0.0258265919983387, -0.005559808108955622, -0.005088298115879297, -0.030710507184267044, 0.05599575862288475, -0.02618773840367794, 0.061854079365730286, 0.023879138752818108, 0.026498984545469284, -0.008050805889070034, 0.05974617227911949, -0.027012823149561882, -0.02146749198436737, 0.0011089053004980087, -0.03919585794210434, -0.01964934729039669, -0.019526636227965355, -0.01970008574426174, -0.057449836283922195, -0.034248318523168564, -0.024671392515301704, -0.02225548028945923, 0.016175614669919014, -0.0012030282523483038, -0.030898703262209892, 0.018398435786366463, 0.0060829599387943745, -0.005891479551792145, -0.02087906189262867, -0.0033155058044940233, -0.01950225420296192, 0.0032553181517869234, -0.016581948846578598, -0.010183018632233143, -0.0072097452357411385, 0.022594323381781578, 0.015964608639478683, 0.02463826909661293, 0.013030897825956345, 0.026601511985063553, 0.009726554155349731, 0.0006649648421443999, 0.00046209071297198534, -0.018252506852149963, 0.05241267755627632, -0.008261419832706451, 0.009584642946720123, 0.049698881804943085, -0.05953998118638992, -0.017250919714570045, 0.023499013856053352, -0.003338511800393462, -0.010251401923596859, 0.003999446984380484, -0.008996699005365372, -0.001872790278866887, 0.04292844235897064, -0.0008430949528701603, -0.03514079749584198, -0.013519342988729477, 0.060689348727464676, -0.014536137692630291, -0.011015931144356728, 0.0303637757897377, 0.007155802100896835, 0.007408443372696638, -0.004220791161060333, 0.013517162762582302, -0.026323463767766953, -0.03108152188360691, -0.0031615563202649355, -0.00738091254606843, 0.005867305677384138, 0.012542414478957653, -0.0030829214956611395, 0.07631499320268631, 0.0379924401640892, 0.007314061280339956, 0.014755700714886189, -0.02512316405773163, 0.027901623398065567, -0.0684397965669632, 0.003968255128711462, -0.013673249632120132, -0.003082609735429287, 0.016017567366361618, -0.08558389544487, -0.000559199252165854, 0.04885095730423927, -0.02714397758245468, 0.00727311335504055, 0.0017739703180268407, -0.019097644835710526, -0.027531398460268974, 0.030696041882038116, -0.010772258043289185, 0.027564875781536102, 0.022297747433185577, 0.028641479089856148, 0.048403944820165634, 0.000754553999286145, -0.027683136984705925, -0.03307478129863739, 0.015206280164420605, 0.04445062205195427, -0.033829379826784134, -0.09530281275510788, 0.046264663338661194, -0.0402786023914814, -0.05019545182585716, 0.03422485291957855, -0.03673433139920235, -0.021232565864920616, 0.046302877366542816, 0.01892254315316677, 0.012963913381099701, 0.02735423482954502, 0.017486294731497765, -0.012099293060600758, 0.018160682171583176, -0.02903514914214611, 0.02466493658721447, 0.012637351639568806, -0.02346767671406269, 0.010703841224312782, 0.02213403955101967, -0.0027510232757776976, -0.049079444259405136, 0.026363646611571312, -0.04164690896868706, -0.013398943468928337, -0.03741113469004631, 0.022369403392076492, 0.004969453439116478, -0.07301054149866104, 0.016950270161032677, -0.044345609843730927, 0.0064973109401762486, 0.0014911876060068607, 0.006354309152811766, 0.011570833623409271, -0.016633572056889534, -0.047698117792606354, -0.04291125386953354, 0.005299693904817104, 0.02911926992237568, -0.03570928797125816, -0.051559679210186005, 0.004856990650296211, -0.03181402385234833, -0.037199243903160095, -0.0058664013631641865, -0.0117789376527071, -0.013374531641602516, 0.021361203864216805, -0.015631522983312607, 0.0672215074300766, 0.04843607544898987, -0.000498421723023057, 0.01535105798393488, -0.112110935151577, 0.036349158734083176, 0.0028696099761873484, -0.03816354274749756, -0.038958270102739334, -0.006848130375146866, -0.028712794184684753, 0.009533511474728584, 0.022317936643958092, 0.015339581295847893, -0.0026086748111993074, -0.015708278864622116, 0.010265759192407131, 0.01085616834461689, -0.007525628432631493, 0.02005968987941742, -0.039685364812612534, 0.005291389767080545, -0.010792339220643044, -0.01668262481689453, 0.01729372888803482, 0.024614674970507622, 0.00023113287170417607, -0.013639742508530617, -0.012048273347318172, -0.0023285781498998404, -0.019345667213201523, 0.02587270922958851, 0.016335174441337585, -0.027570359408855438, 0.04233512282371521, -0.028355242684483528, 0.020063595846295357, 0.04298419877886772, -0.005265243351459503, -0.03339184820652008, 0.038415927439928055, -0.016410570591688156, -0.05322973430156708, 0.02170196920633316, 0.007001976016908884, -0.00023548983153887093, -0.08326411992311478, 0.010194027796387672, 0.024721341207623482, -0.006075705401599407, 0.012638871558010578, 0.025280771777033806, 0.0409105159342289, 0.028076887130737305, -0.03392256051301956, 0.042635202407836914, -0.011118842288851738, -0.021027937531471252, 0.0074090310372412205, -0.025425756350159645, 0.0141926109790802, -0.010897360742092133, -0.004996236879378557, 0.029599985107779503, -0.027728207409381866, 0.052879590541124344, 0.01500349398702383, 0.011299069039523602, 0.0027346541173756123, 0.011876491829752922, -0.0023134637158364058, -0.010534374974668026, 0.03928196802735329, -0.010508491657674313, -0.008342433720827103, 0.049483440816402435, -0.011773432604968548, -0.0266535896807909, -0.010622628033161163, 0.007731767371296883, -0.0537215881049633, 0.021332593634724617, 0.05890042707324028, 0.04361166059970856, -0.0003462235035840422, 0.025551442056894302, -0.013147867284715176, 0.02474275417625904, 0.03509478643536568, -0.031772222369909286, 0.067904993891716, -0.005915233865380287, -0.029000893235206604, 0.012940161861479282, 0.0018321137176826596, -0.01620233803987503, 0.014347599819302559, 0.014250397682189941, 0.03191569820046425, -0.008558276109397411, -0.0007316751289181411, -0.031586408615112305, -0.015627525746822357, 0.010483095422387123, -0.08137326687574387, -0.04625525325536728, -0.05957138165831566, 0.01726388931274414, 0.000343134073773399, 0.013414756394922733 ]
<p>I am conducting a study on a cohort of people with a follow-up period of 7 years. I wish to use Cox Proportional Hazard model to estimate HR between an exposure and the length of time of an event. One missing information is the date of birth for the all subjects, but month and year are available.This prevents the calculation of exact age at the time of the study.</p> <p>Any suggestions will be much appreciated? Any sensitivity analysis should be conducted?</p> <p>Thanks </p>
49,162
[ -0.0014055349165573716, -0.05393526703119278, 0.04292774945497513, -0.0208699069917202, 0.0043548946268856525, -0.006979805883020163, -0.023159917443990707, -0.018366407603025436, 0.047367244958877563, -0.052223559468984604, 0.01950640045106411, 0.03339853882789612, 0.03535296395421028, 0.0004456809547264129, -0.015369130298495293, 0.028383005410432816, -0.0074386452324688435, -0.019974755123257637, -0.029084866866469383, 0.001983679598197341, 0.009510940872132778, 0.02575036883354187, -0.011171811260282993, -0.004086639732122421, -0.0030587681103497744, 0.029956530779600143, 0.03506482392549515, -0.03757813945412636, -0.0055844588205218315, 0.07355022430419922, -0.04571818932890892, -0.02723325788974762, 0.03715715929865837, 0.022138966247439384, 0.012959903106093407, 0.0036727124825119972, -0.03265879675745964, -0.02756854146718979, -0.01496643852442503, 0.020908601582050323, -0.03317788243293762, -0.009465454146265984, 0.023996485397219658, 0.09227273613214493, -0.02468074858188629, 0.04991278052330017, -0.021161001175642014, 0.0011293799616396427, 0.04048185423016548, -0.01648309826850891, 0.018728576600551605, -0.04107111692428589, 0.05871718004345894, 0.011334341950714588, -0.022117730230093002, -0.030005544424057007, 0.016087552532553673, 0.09592194110155106, 0.03447183966636658, -0.034908417612314224, -0.02680463157594204, -0.031544528901576996, -0.009492000564932823, -0.02101769857108593, -0.02089318074285984, -0.029102327302098274, -0.005155929829925299, -0.029603200033307076, 0.014030028134584427, -0.019585760310292244, 0.0303422212600708, -0.0295883622020483, 0.018641551956534386, 0.042051441967487335, 0.04193335771560669, -0.06110021099448204, -0.004594494588673115, 0.01895841211080551, 0.020394954830408096, 0.0010281407739967108, -0.025329746305942535, -0.032323937863111496, 0.05448878929018974, 0.011901781894266605, -0.016603950411081314, -0.0004174780915491283, 0.03252703696489334, -0.03138650208711624, 0.0004896956961601973, 0.026641858741641045, -0.0534127876162529, 0.016927406191825867, 0.04475568234920502, 0.010011290200054646, -0.027837831526994705, 0.046086955815553665, -0.00654374435544014, 0.05459700897336006, 0.004899465478956699, 0.024199850857257843, 0.019780050963163376, -0.03382651507854462, 0.033895764499902725, 0.016905855387449265, -0.004488809499889612, -0.02293834649026394, 0.01620103046298027, -0.049531903117895126, 0.007745123002678156, -0.042831771075725555, -0.032842982560396194, 0.0051387520506978035, -0.017392685636878014, -0.01997145637869835, 0.0089499456807971, -0.0023096802178770304, -0.03156143054366112, -0.03719695284962654, 0.07844418287277222, 0.0326739102602005, 0.032110657542943954, -0.02499758079648018, -0.0029095595236867666, -0.04524198919534683, -0.03541099652647972, 0.0048665679059922695, 0.008120046928524971, -0.03430623933672905, -0.022949697449803352, 0.061034802347421646, 0.024885520339012146, -0.03483723849058151, 0.1073613166809082, -0.023160018026828766, 0.05745565891265869, 0.02288711443543434, -0.0832676962018013, -0.017330486327409744, -0.004311648663133383, 0.006251084618270397, -0.03088318184018135, -0.058323025703430176, -0.004144730046391487, -0.017121829092502594, 0.014432400465011597, -0.0018652969738468528, 0.06817183643579483, 0.02866610325872898, 0.0397479273378849, 0.019428471103310585, 0.004983608610928059, -0.01944947987794876, 0.021276870742440224, 0.00983809120953083, -0.009023365564644337, -0.08324751257896423, -0.013348991051316261, 0.01820758916437626, 0.0032938290387392044, -0.0028654697816818953, 0.07171674817800522, -0.0033611245453357697, -0.051216237246990204, 0.044146578758955, 0.03246890753507614, -0.0634961798787117, 0.06834273785352707, -0.00009788088209461421, 0.01626800373196602, 0.01532714907079935, 0.023169195279479027, 0.05698160454630852, 0.03355662152171135, 0.039164479821920395, 0.005177317652851343, -0.019912073388695717, 0.015971338376402855, 0.05098401755094528, 0.0009536538273096085, 0.014796331524848938, -0.040517665445804596, 0.0016191692557185888, -0.018149632960557938, -0.03043229505419731, 0.04612506926059723, 0.004512859974056482, 0.014859819784760475, -0.030341556295752525, 0.043270643800497055, -0.005316100083291531, -0.03692389279603958, -0.08368406444787979, 0.013371235691010952, -0.008660510182380676, -0.007567537482827902, 0.01810920238494873, -0.027756696566939354, -0.009385032579302788, -0.011088964529335499, -0.0043140253983438015, -0.015187913551926613, -0.03389642387628555, 0.033283017575740814, -0.044583726674318314, -0.01914113759994507, 0.02613980695605278, 0.05697373300790787, 0.023876957595348358, 0.03125591576099396, -0.052814096212387085, -0.015157810412347317, -0.016944102942943573, -0.0586446076631546, 0.03156992793083191, -0.037846364080905914, -0.008904894813895226, -0.02850673720240593, -0.036362819373607635, 0.00861342903226614, 0.023847484961152077, -0.007325907237827778, 0.057134076952934265, 0.05090424418449402, -0.027747418731451035, -0.002963197184726596, -0.003767463145777583, 0.05887817218899727, 0.011967528611421585, -0.0030859855469316244, -0.006063384469598532, -0.01641305536031723, 0.005030924454331398, 0.038294751197099686, -0.021653544157743454, -0.016538109630346298, 0.027789805084466934, 0.02651408687233925, 0.04720798134803772, 0.005101796239614487, 0.021045848727226257, 0.019740073010325432, -0.017413128167390823, 0.03744357451796532, -0.007380935829132795, -0.031337007880210876, 0.0008620087755843997, 0.00947628729045391, -0.012603160925209522, 0.05047549307346344, -0.042281344532966614, 0.024640846997499466, 0.042238570749759674, -0.003095917636528611, -0.007452305871993303, -0.015433523803949356, -0.028958389535546303, 0.02614484168589115, -0.04152243211865425, 0.03940518572926521, 0.019442008808255196, -0.030616309493780136, -0.010996801778674126, 0.021086782217025757, -0.05198651924729347, 0.02988378331065178, 0.04969773069024086, -0.06031837314367294, 0.011473366990685463, 0.01656513661146164, -0.017580045387148857, -0.017085783183574677, -0.027258137241005898, -0.04057159647345543, 0.005091097671538591, -0.0016132830642163754, 0.039479050785303116, 0.017482997849583626, 0.03928375616669655, 0.012383806519210339, 0.0024653971195220947, 0.020751597359776497, -0.02805042639374733, 0.0036053210496902466, 0.037384919822216034, -0.03756965696811676, -0.014299945905804634, 0.018071984872221947, -0.008247742429375648, 0.04623665660619736, 0.008678226731717587, -0.006419914308935404, 0.02787020243704319, 0.00946806650608778, -0.03910712152719498, -0.053255513310432434, -0.012325480580329895, -0.013066482730209827, -0.012336422689259052, 0.001673205872066319, 0.0189121775329113, 0.019820496439933777, -0.013195296749472618, 0.015401339158415794, -0.03485489264130592, 0.009541081264615059, -0.009786967188119888, 0.005989674013108015, 0.007609474938362837, -0.0049646408297121525, -0.0020750367548316717, 0.014500911347568035, -0.0018561829347163439, -0.0007336793350987136, -0.06867185980081558, -0.08820737153291702, 0.06362150609493256, 0.0044389828108251095, 0.003070112783461809, 0.014105062931776047, 0.02389814518392086, 0.056336965411901474, 0.01341535709798336, 0.003987578675150871, -0.057893384248018265, -0.006222547497600317, 0.0014765110099688172, -0.0225860383361578, 0.016402868553996086, -0.004526887089014053, 0.026162320747971535, 0.01622954197227955, -0.032275449484586716, -0.0033452054485678673, 0.05579065904021263, 0.003459179075434804, 0.0224591176956892, 0.008790703490376472, -0.001991043798625469, -0.001398666063323617, 0.020705698058009148, 0.012267880141735077, -0.0318223237991333, 0.018178990110754967, -0.05122492089867592, 0.04353190213441849, 0.0021221297793090343, -0.08648400753736496, -0.032743874937295914, -0.028973929584026337, -0.015194635838270187, -0.01374230906367302, 0.009005107916891575, -0.0014123915461823344, -0.031280968338251114, -0.03816494718194008, 0.010981600731611252, 0.011240334250032902, -0.026025597006082535, -0.01885596476495266, 0.03673569858074188, 0.025451742112636566, 0.008045641705393791, 0.0035612056963145733, -0.022807061672210693, 0.0004397238080855459, 0.015120694413781166, -0.014455541968345642, -0.0037104773800820112, 0.04356532543897629, 0.03162142261862755, 0.03891148045659065, 0.012724240310490131, -0.07106233388185501, -0.015665126964449883, -0.04571487382054329, 0.0006166737875901163, -0.019317280501127243, 0.05494672805070877, -0.013593032956123352, 0.017463287338614464, 0.01690693199634552, -0.026040557771921158, -0.003034770954400301, 0.031496305018663406, -0.04916662350296974, -0.0065435306169092655, -0.02423303946852684, 0.004158468451350927, 0.0031224298290908337, -0.0019358944846317172, 0.04510577768087387, 0.0009872708469629288, 0.004241675604134798, 0.006699217949062586, 0.004534834995865822, -0.04733242839574814, 0.00008614988473709673, -0.0038681775331497192, 0.03287480026483536, -0.013178710825741291, 0.02110174112021923, 0.031919363886117935, 0.011078900657594204, 0.002737975213676691, 0.04888071492314339, 0.03094339743256569, -0.014104758389294147, -0.02508590929210186, 0.0025095127057284117, 0.008117473684251308, 0.046327799558639526, 0.01884397119283676, 0.01696396991610527, -0.04518495872616768, 0.034079086035490036, -0.038669370114803314, 0.0011409706203266978, 0.047670770436525345, 0.027080237865447998, -0.04971962794661522, -0.016290882602334023, -0.004583551082760096, 0.023850537836551666, 0.016465218737721443, -0.003786189015954733, 0.03776421397924423, 0.03873852267861366, 0.004182227421551943, -0.055252332240343094, -0.031787529587745667, 0.0800163522362709, 0.024385832250118256, -0.0024993938859552145, 0.0018540589371696115, 0.007971886545419693, -0.03457857295870781, -0.011577064171433449, -0.012237695045769215, 0.04825852811336517, 0.004942204803228378, -0.0059715756215155125, 0.036041684448719025, -0.008547431789338589, -0.023464448750019073, 0.051191169768571854, 0.07011891156435013, 0.03934048116207123, 0.05711071193218231, -0.013415341265499592, 0.04525316506624222, 0.05425773188471794, 0.04057551920413971, 0.005730973556637764, 0.0394117534160614, -0.0934491828083992, -0.01603875122964382, 0.032429035753011703, 0.07261563837528229, -0.03392014652490616, -0.05387488752603531, -0.029711680486798286, -0.015268390066921711, 0.056554339826107025, -0.025495557114481926, -0.010284201242029667, -0.018279409036040306, -0.010679821483790874, 0.011311450973153114, -0.057218972593545914, -0.028863251209259033, 0.02135147713124752, -0.015854928642511368, -0.004063801374286413, 0.0016968847485259175, 0.008251224644482136, 0.002141656819730997, -0.005500188563019037, 0.01171021442860365, 0.03568604588508606, -0.003287161700427532, -0.009666560217738152, 0.0018821506528183818, -0.004348971880972385, -0.029024891555309296, -0.039860621094703674, -0.010192024521529675, -0.016885953024029732, -0.007786404341459274, 0.07154448330402374, -0.030309120193123817, -0.005071654450148344, 0.028852516785264015, 0.010420801118016243, -0.0042513045482337475, -0.021805712953209877, -0.030743282288312912, 0.03416189178824425, 0.021474570035934448, -0.049646783620119095, 0.055928535759449005, 0.04566657543182373, 0.008837198838591576, 0.021754542365670204, -0.020078718662261963, 0.016162943094968796, -0.018466448411345482, -0.017836470156908035, -0.03582403063774109, -0.018319446593523026, 0.012941543012857437, -0.0031063868664205074, -0.040296804159879684, 0.025232188403606415, -0.011191188357770443, 0.011400256305932999, 0.03918285667896271, 0.03265385702252388, -0.002108965301886201, 0.018306914716959, 0.0071103619411587715, -0.011411342769861221, 0.0031189853325486183, -0.01098794024437666, 0.02059759944677353, 0.009055252186954021, 0.020953524857759476, 0.017854642122983932, -0.04747343435883522, 0.010734215378761292, -0.009926271624863148, -0.04043028503656387, -0.004382219165563583, -0.0019304719753563404, 0.026174576953053474, -0.02227908745408058, 0.022514427080750465, 0.013495366089046001, -0.053160469979047775, 0.02881782315671444, 0.027488237246870995, -0.02096383646130562, 0.06359975039958954, -0.015759006142616272, 0.04528559371829033, 0.0010695948731154203, 0.008744785562157631, -0.042984459549188614, -0.04192423075437546, 0.030483966693282127, 0.007913426496088505, -0.0593390129506588, -0.0029984302818775177, 0.013354431837797165, -0.010397126898169518, 0.0031151953153312206, -0.0033549517393112183, 0.06334423273801804, -0.006351235788315535, -0.0031013863626867533, -0.01921387016773224, 0.03481662645936012, 0.03474988788366318, 0.0007832145784050226, 0.024589145556092262, 0.04804213345050812, -0.004111131653189659, -0.0019752192310988903, -0.041268639266490936, 0.0006233144085854292, -0.014321603812277317, -0.03037162683904171, -0.01565917395055294, -0.008940066210925579, 0.0517193004488945, -0.024193361401557922, -0.04484705254435539, 0.023962127044796944, -0.0018154119607061148, -0.004912682808935642, -0.06380780786275864, 0.00393869262188673, -0.03133087605237961, 0.011495491489768028, -0.029094191268086433, 0.013849231414496899, 0.006136324722319841, 0.008821755647659302, 0.010331705212593079, -0.028464114293456078, -0.03410685807466507, 0.006611112970858812, 0.028570594266057014, -0.02276807837188244, 0.01214867178350687, 0.025515669956803322, -0.04109533876180649, 0.0211481936275959, 0.02065865881741047, 0.0013454955769702792, 0.016601670533418655, -0.036546315997838974, -0.09389949589967728, -0.039980437606573105, -0.026235582306981087, -0.00718644866719842, 0.055819835513830185, -0.03548482432961464, 0.03788169100880623, -0.006258683279156685, 0.0006588721298612654, -0.015923701226711273, 0.017922991886734962, -0.00570855475962162, 0.010916362516582012, -0.0030615166760981083, 0.055805377662181854, -0.0026163829024881124, -0.016531668603420258, 0.0420319102704525, 0.04432171583175659, -0.02537420764565468, 0.040553852915763855, 0.008842771872878075, 0.010589675046503544, 0.01700838841497898, 0.005398094654083252, -0.03774300217628479, -0.011307514272630215, -0.02835848368704319, 0.013395672664046288, -0.02493293397128582, -0.017721934244036674, 0.031799204647541046, 0.008385860361158848, -0.01859770342707634, -0.021478615701198578, -0.02500743791460991, -0.034843217581510544, 0.008984368294477463, 0.04400412738323212, -0.011372479610145092, 0.0031382364686578512, 0.014156072400510311, 0.08116766065359116, -0.021422253921628, -0.0015706880949437618, -0.03141610324382782, -0.06308919936418533, -0.02403600886464119, -0.02532893791794777, -0.059382498264312744, 0.022662635892629623, 0.016361141577363014, -0.010401868261396885, -0.012437734752893448, 0.01574515737593174, 0.003750966163352132, -0.02177339233458042, 0.06704413145780563, -0.006209918763488531, 0.10156579315662384, 0.02120664156973362, -0.023181336000561714, -0.00885043479502201, 0.048214878886938095, 0.1187848299741745, 0.07868759334087372, 0.0295711699873209, -0.024392466992139816, -0.012222222052514553, 0.03020186722278595, -0.002577509032562375, -0.020562153309583664, 0.061021771281957626, 0.02167135663330555, -0.07188598066568375, 0.06631524860858917, 0.015143285505473614, -0.009084471501410007, 0.014638510532677174, 0.04189981147646904, -0.025886574760079384, -0.026047810912132263, -0.042704902589321136, -0.00483303377404809, 0.030691536143422127, -0.022180549800395966, -0.033187102526426315, 0.007742852438241243, 0.026006095111370087, -0.02070225402712822, -0.0209934264421463, -0.016728706657886505, -0.03223941847681999, 0.028916778042912483, -0.04981570318341255, 0.01985001564025879, 0.02008068934082985, 0.040482472628355026, -0.03405515477061272, -0.016902228817343712, -0.021708613261580467, -0.006318442057818174, -0.0034375404939055443, 0.024718571454286575, 0.020226292312145233, -0.012705979868769646, 0.012104691937565804, 0.016504555940628052, -0.03502528741955757, -0.014168729074299335, -0.016376234591007233, 0.03060038574039936, -0.03828659653663635, -0.0035763296764343977, -0.0408327579498291, -0.015469853766262531, -0.02877250500023365, -0.053813595324754715, -0.03500564396381378, 0.029078703373670578, 0.04362856596708298, 0.006551178637892008, -0.011851571500301361, -0.017137272283434868, 0.02992885373532772, -0.03206491470336914, 0.04786302521824837, 0.03384621441364288, -0.05870211124420166, 0.01627803035080433, -0.0635923370718956, 0.030149944126605988, 0.0003017605922650546, 0.006468027364462614, 0.03292424604296684, -0.0017051943577826023, -0.02372048981487751, -0.005467508919537067, 0.02334417589008808, 0.0011784436646848917, 0.01944282278418541, -0.024326937273144722, -0.014165720902383327, -0.022859280928969383, -0.03849389776587486, 0.020954977720975876, 0.02702498249709606, -0.021798664703965187, -0.07634677737951279, 0.019489068537950516, 0.03220762312412262, 0.055516935884952545, -0.03528931736946106, 0.029168881475925446, -0.02817322313785553, 0.06728438287973404, 0.02561197057366371, -0.06570784747600555, 0.015755798667669296, 0.02216208726167679, -0.014781739562749863, 0.009794548153877258, -0.007342744152992964, 0.058660510927438736, -0.001714592450298369, 0.028923936188220978, 0.0130851985886693, 0.03833404928445816, 0.014182664453983307, 0.01962955668568611, 0.0061751860193908215, -0.04690182954072952, -0.008728155866265297, -0.0567341074347496, 0.036095838993787766, -0.028381681069731712, -0.04633667692542076, -0.021150365471839905, -0.028207091614603996, 0.005080297123640776, -0.047719862312078476, -0.009776129387319088, 0.0021973014809191227, -0.052980970591306686, 0.0006970447720959783, -0.0030633893329650164, 0.06395238637924194, -0.03161884844303131, 0.013279227539896965, -0.012371825985610485, -0.01404191367328167, 0.007723240647464991, 0.04734369367361069, -0.0009343976271338761, 0.0026013401802629232, 0.014997283928096294, -0.0005878993542864919, -0.00006834429950686172, 0.028816210106015205, -0.020841127261519432, 0.0005258636665530503, 0.04179700091481209, -0.008685416541993618, -0.04266715794801712, 0.0036040828563272953, -0.0736861303448677, -0.02834276482462883, 0.061978958547115326, 0.0217659380286932, 0.030276382341980934, 0.014658253639936447, -0.00756694795563817, 0.018057746812701225, 0.0759410709142685, -0.052088089287281036, -0.0284598208963871, -0.020133186131715775, 0.03935188427567482, 0.02941913716495037, -0.005218212958425283, -0.030871229246258736, 0.004475812893360853, -0.012410396710038185, 0.0390024408698082, 0.0361984558403492, 0.022145336493849754, 0.005316475406289101, 0.018032245337963104, 0.0012720953673124313, -0.021977024152874947, 0.007534828502684832, 0.0060488879680633545, 0.043477389961481094, 0.04722440615296364, -0.043305955827236176, 0.05450069159269333, 0.017559858039021492, -0.03347233682870865, -0.0656822919845581, -0.02419881522655487, 0.007756535895168781, 0.02154412306845188, 0.011163027957081795, -0.015623173676431179, 0.01584499515593052, 0.0270213820040226, -0.060186564922332764, 0.024688713252544403, 0.018981849774718285, -0.012186515145003796, -0.018229320645332336, 0.013638022355735302, 0.024276360869407654, 0.014505448751151562, 0.04819898307323456, 0.03406192734837532, 0.026089942082762718, 0.03732422739267349, -0.0030445975717157125, -0.08223878592252731, -0.010593457147479057, -0.0009382003336213529, 0.01175004057586193, -0.07015082240104675, 0.027356501668691635, -0.01931712031364441, -0.011529901996254921, -0.005095395725220442, -0.03811640292406082, 0.039369769394397736, 0.02424205094575882, 0.0034634126350283623, -0.003926093690097332, 0.012727075256407261, 0.052654482424259186, -0.027144381776452065, -0.0024550165981054306, -0.01510484330356121, -0.016752850264310837, 0.0505542978644371, -0.03316191956400871, 0.03600751608610153, -0.00864497572183609, -0.010502624325454235, -0.014310479164123535, 0.026667295023798943, 0.025227772071957588, -0.015456922352313995, 0.013685150071978569, -0.003915868699550629, -0.0023395803291350603, -0.03492613509297371, -0.011918933130800724, -0.02132526971399784, -0.011865077540278435, 0.06553604453802109, 0.0027880186680704355, -0.01565275713801384, 0.019438648596405983, -0.07668148726224899, -0.032230179756879807, 0.024820759892463684, 0.020935416221618652, -0.02519061043858528, -0.014869350008666515, -0.014577457681298256, 0.0043735262006521225, 0.024610010907053947, -0.02093750610947609, -0.017510635778307915, -0.02540728822350502, 0.03597217798233032, -0.02440827526152134, -0.02355593629181385, 0.04564148932695389, 0.02160247601568699, 0.020995216444134712, -0.04221351817250252, 0.03219657763838768, 0.023311998695135117, -0.0236229095607996, -0.01687345653772354, -0.037386901676654816, 0.018166912719607353, -0.008460205048322678, 0.05421359837055206, 0.001212339149788022, -0.015449297614395618, -0.007780923508107662, 0.04073168709874153, -0.008296939544379711, -0.02105155773460865, 0.04865599423646927, -0.008300925604999065, 0.005926888901740313, -0.018934685736894608, -0.006968839094042778, -0.016483493149280548, 0.008172007277607918, -0.02355109713971615, -0.024730807170271873, 0.056753937155008316, 0.06492799520492554, 0.02116694487631321, -0.0026367390528321266, 0.017308950424194336, -0.02798478677868843, 0.015439171344041824, -0.016588697209954262, 0.009999716654419899, 0.05030414089560509, -0.01312075462192297, -0.06386049091815948, 0.031489983201026917, -0.0442618690431118, -0.039654068648815155, 0.021363310515880585, -0.004835193045437336, -0.03017142228782177, -0.039862003177404404, -0.01572607457637787, 0.03389573469758034, -0.02287370339035988, 0.01006946712732315, 0.03208893910050392, 0.014998196624219418, 0.026810074225068092, -0.027027109637856483, 0.014766808599233627, 0.057401642203330994, -0.03461506590247154, 0.01813141442835331, -0.007001684978604317, -0.0004626106529030949, -0.02363373152911663, 0.00247631361708045, 0.02185674197971821, 0.016250133514404297, 0.005172931123524904, 0.006006842479109764, 0.03306994214653969, -0.016757331788539886, -0.023059360682964325, -0.006239402107894421, -0.010324864648282528, -0.0024212889838963747, 0.01835501752793789, -0.009744369424879551, 0.03458458185195923, 0.008092633448541164, 0.002863482804968953, -0.022956743836402893, -0.021748781204223633, -0.06494419276714325, 0.018947763368487358, 0.034224383533000946, 0.0017158006085082889, -0.032662853598594666, -0.00756208086386323, 0.021046416833996773, -0.00766263622790575, 0.014265605248510838, -0.053110696375370026, 0.02464178204536438, 0.005214272532612085, -0.028862981125712395, -0.02233624830842018, -0.026496410369873047, -0.032532840967178345, -0.009296245872974396, 0.019298722967505455, 0.03506573662161827, 0.024738416075706482, -0.024778956547379494, -0.02288518100976944, -0.008973376825451851, -0.005897924769669771, -0.07887881994247437, 0.0029644363094121218, -0.06152663007378578, -0.008010242134332657, -0.04538169130682945, -0.0029509281739592552 ]
<p>What statistical research blogs would you recommend, and why?</p>
74,455
[ -0.0395452044904232, -0.057153552770614624, -0.015152125619351864, -0.053469933569431305, 0.037987563759088516, 0.015042931772768497, 0.018381884321570396, -0.01930779032409191, -0.010745253413915634, -0.03017229214310646, 0.021109310910105705, 0.018924107775092125, 0.013400690630078316, 0.022996429353952408, -0.03111300989985466, -0.002226457465440035, -0.011414207518100739, 0.0010230706539005041, -0.04100443050265312, 0.026199499145150185, -0.0036422444973140955, 0.003573598572984338, -0.014059602282941341, 0.004193839617073536, -0.03827840834856033, 0.012497303076088428, 0.045099347829818726, 0.005438673309981823, -0.015339072793722153, 0.05530448630452156, -0.03630666062235832, 0.00026294877170585096, -0.011369723826646805, 0.02328576147556305, -0.011607730761170387, -0.021916737779974937, 0.02076033502817154, 0.007424418348819017, 0.004908826667815447, 0.0376068614423275, -0.026234053075313568, 0.008851451799273491, -0.0027905539609491825, -0.04365593194961548, -0.035392019897699356, 0.03890186920762062, -0.013705694116652012, -0.02542305178940296, 0.04793176054954529, -0.01238175854086876, 0.026206595823168755, 0.01611434295773506, 0.011201929301023483, 0.030514800921082497, 0.004521211143583059, 0.026370082050561905, 0.03931054100394249, 0.03705940768122673, -0.00032521362300030887, -0.0515361987054348, -0.0015131147811189294, -0.0008329384727403522, 0.01657010242342949, -0.006428565364331007, -0.03628486767411232, 0.06481453031301498, 0.02917441911995411, -0.0010203697020187974, 0.03760381042957306, -0.006978179328143597, -0.0022707676980644464, 0.022649776190519333, 0.03076082281768322, 0.0004859926411882043, -0.008493232540786266, -0.012895866297185421, -0.012353434227406979, -0.003982631955295801, 0.062196169048547745, 0.06429494917392731, 0.0371604859828949, 0.016247574239969254, 0.02266867645084858, 0.027108069509267807, 0.014043312519788742, -0.018508736044168472, 0.06178366765379906, 0.007493386976420879, -0.0333402082324028, 0.05339427292346954, -0.019114648923277855, -0.022540507838129997, 0.021709736436605453, 0.010348975658416748, -0.055862993001937866, 0.0037033220287412405, -0.010049929842352867, 0.0351126603782177, 0.01592967100441456, -0.005816908553242683, -0.0346049964427948, -0.0299586970359087, 0.0012162438360974193, 0.022089706733822823, -0.03145919367671013, -0.009194105863571167, -0.02234448865056038, 0.00806333962827921, -0.041739583015441895, -0.028572091832756996, -0.038010306656360626, -0.001076365471817553, 0.010091722011566162, -0.02017894573509693, 0.050572775304317474, -0.014464521780610085, 0.03450523689389229, -0.049307867884635925, 0.03608618304133415, 0.09270226955413818, 0.011806105263531208, -0.030547695234417915, 0.021092748269438744, -0.0393773689866066, -0.03369074687361717, 0.010926109738647938, 0.03858840465545654, -0.06653735041618347, -0.056367259472608566, 0.06488857418298721, -0.020987430587410927, -0.0027658373583108187, 0.013540496118366718, 0.001834040624089539, 0.0012821514392271638, 0.018971793353557587, -0.08543115854263306, -0.05872712284326553, 0.06834528595209122, -0.013767157681286335, -0.007453147787600756, -0.023965466767549515, -0.0220100786536932, 0.02203483134508133, 0.04145243391394615, 0.031981997191905975, 0.048779021948575974, -0.010503622703254223, 0.018552882596850395, -0.005727944429963827, -0.014428769238293171, -0.006390702445060015, 0.00019944377709180117, -0.012962273322045803, 0.012714829295873642, -0.06801846623420715, 0.01689881458878517, 0.007210400886833668, -0.006398340687155724, -0.023749150335788727, 0.016864914447069168, -0.003226503962650895, -0.0009489455260336399, 0.015990540385246277, 0.004741393495351076, -0.0173362884670496, 0.07726473361253738, -0.0025264439173042774, 0.000941657752264291, 0.025356972590088844, -0.03435448184609413, 0.0419422872364521, 0.04291338101029396, 0.025967350229620934, 0.007615543436259031, 0.004306724760681391, -0.00942483451217413, 0.028198644518852234, 0.007533414289355278, 0.005384358577430248, -0.033478524535894394, 0.020817657932639122, 0.02624848671257496, -0.004335758276283741, -0.0001877898321254179, 0.050252366811037064, 0.015974795445799828, -0.0022416168358176947, 0.04110373929142952, -0.05314645916223526, -0.04575524479150772, -0.03269200772047043, 0.022074032574892044, -0.02200663462281227, -0.008946390822529793, 0.030025986954569817, 0.01419922523200512, 0.009790163487195969, -0.03129836544394493, -0.0159502811729908, -0.01950863003730774, 0.014694303274154663, 0.037787552922964096, -0.013764589093625546, -0.022549647837877274, 0.021984297782182693, 0.02266942895948887, -0.01677648536860943, 0.007833374664187431, -0.0343964658677578, -0.0539688766002655, -0.019640423357486725, -0.02503887377679348, 0.04028516635298729, -0.027101298794150352, -0.032200273126363754, 0.015958290547132492, 0.011269099079072475, -0.023299062624573708, 0.020643390715122223, -0.051906928420066833, 0.036082763224840164, -0.0070218476466834545, 0.005234158597886562, -0.02279735542833805, -0.023867810145020485, 0.02791670151054859, -0.030059045180678368, -0.0035837304312735796, 0.007404634263366461, -0.044777750968933105, 0.024702537804841995, 0.08217164874076843, 0.04768268018960953, -0.024659032002091408, 0.005127526354044676, 0.019884346053004265, 0.03442658111453056, -0.03443652018904686, 0.022128773853182793, -0.010291419923305511, -0.05089152604341507, -0.00018258034833706915, 0.01345393992960453, -0.0010226151207461953, -0.007790623232722282, 0.011770594865083694, 0.005324820056557655, 0.038076333701610565, 0.033190496265888214, -0.04513343796133995, 0.03329490125179291, 0.002039500745013356, -0.019581330940127373, 0.02056049183011055, -0.00789049081504345, 0.022974342107772827, -0.034818172454833984, -0.0019597825594246387, 0.01480106171220541, 0.02038147673010826, 0.02770099602639675, 0.003129338612779975, -0.03913533315062523, 0.005015428178012371, 0.011359436437487602, -0.01871156133711338, 0.01282824669033289, 0.03794991970062256, -0.009440942667424679, 0.038260769098997116, -0.024716004729270935, -0.00010101429506903514, -0.06749042123556137, 0.003262201091274619, 0.003348357044160366, 0.012739431113004684, 0.0019886004738509655, 0.017278950661420822, -0.04466754570603371, 0.02217210829257965, -0.020460383966565132, 0.031960874795913696, -0.012812744826078415, -0.02013547345995903, 0.01913152076303959, -0.008243618533015251, 0.021987322717905045, 0.03026437945663929, 0.0029073620680719614, 0.00851642806082964, -0.006558182183653116, 0.004020389169454575, -0.07228538393974304, -0.03135073557496071, -0.005422806367278099, 0.002402435289695859, -0.021166915073990822, -0.015454782173037529, 0.006632258649915457, -0.0494399257004261, -0.0465427003800869, 0.0226560290902853, -0.0340297631919384, -0.006144889164716005, -0.022291049361228943, -0.0011267035733908415, 0.01563861221075058, 0.01090382132679224, -0.01205164473503828, 0.012831134721636772, -0.06278578191995621, -0.006569933611899614, -0.06186765804886818, -0.015134320594370365, 0.033737942576408386, -0.004483893979340792, 0.019572338089346886, -0.019204020500183105, 0.01751064322888851, 0.04465227946639061, 0.02861570008099079, -0.03984321653842926, -0.0397748202085495, -0.015775753185153008, -0.056799206882715225, -0.04846438392996788, 0.04989258944988251, 0.004832874052226543, 0.013609412126243114, 0.0032805129885673523, -0.02798190712928772, 0.028105085715651512, 0.025012705475091934, 0.048748213797807693, 0.02248489111661911, 0.01582156866788864, -0.020889919251203537, -0.006951558869332075, 0.011014280840754509, 0.02739374339580536, -0.059336937963962555, -0.01147814467549324, 0.015150264836847782, 0.020561201497912407, -0.007540382910519838, -0.03805380314588547, 0.010921107605099678, -0.0006481613963842392, -0.0005124625167809427, -0.061849337071180344, -0.005621254909783602, 0.016356253996491432, -0.02517312951385975, -0.0011746224481612444, 0.028507810086011887, 0.002308940514922142, -0.008763376623392105, -0.02437617816030979, 0.028482189401984215, 0.05590297281742096, -0.03764686360955238, -0.011460639536380768, -0.013967706821858883, -0.013866199180483818, 0.031650591641664505, -0.0039829229936003685, -0.002134887268766761, 0.07199139893054962, 0.02582704834640026, -0.010008096694946289, 0.006236243527382612, -0.07538923621177673, 0.0042083668522536755, -0.06805901229381561, 0.03741252049803734, -0.012652499601244926, 0.049539048224687576, 0.014146778732538223, 0.026843100786209106, -0.023317966610193253, 0.014850369654595852, -0.03423589468002319, 0.01911526545882225, -0.056099310517311096, 0.019262058660387993, -0.05354071781039238, 0.0009686506236903369, 0.005648482125252485, 0.02086365409195423, 0.02629448100924492, 0.01724277436733246, 0.01532411202788353, -0.03276169300079346, 0.06382826715707779, -0.022333532571792603, -0.008935099467635155, -0.024910634383559227, -0.030842160806059837, 0.001038921531289816, -0.020259272307157516, 0.01365650910884142, -0.020374998450279236, 0.04440845921635628, 0.030451862141489983, 0.0005782598746009171, -0.03137869015336037, 0.013604696840047836, 0.02396906167268753, 0.0186355859041214, 0.04465986788272858, 0.024206645786762238, 0.0294596366584301, -0.03454084321856499, 0.04453553259372711, -0.00226455251686275, 0.014751583337783813, 0.033691905438899994, -0.020203903317451477, -0.021245473995804787, -0.02793353982269764, -0.020764406770467758, -0.01089291088283062, 0.023588234558701515, -0.0005657832371070981, 0.013320199213922024, 0.03754981979727745, -0.004064009990543127, -0.05384253337979317, -0.0025677625089883804, 0.056605223566293716, 0.032138802111148834, 0.016444258391857147, -0.012824575416743755, -0.018920041620731354, 0.013452211394906044, 0.01915016956627369, 0.0021171357948333025, 0.016788803040981293, 0.037699371576309204, -0.026638563722372055, 0.0014948650496080518, -0.0205715112388134, -0.02992314100265503, -0.028737518936395645, 0.020375294610857964, 0.04493867605924606, -0.00720618711784482, -0.008006745018064976, 0.03439083322882652, 0.0499609149992466, 0.08216054737567902, 0.06660135835409164, -0.007979708723723888, -0.07157199084758759, 0.002798181725665927, 0.08281289786100388, 0.015016090124845505, -0.04794652760028839, -0.0034653060138225555, -0.030526146292686462, 0.005758791696280241, 0.0445992611348629, -0.02094852365553379, 0.023555375635623932, -0.01619204320013523, -0.001473836600780487, -0.019027426838874817, -0.0031804535537958145, -0.03279411420226097, 0.035446640104055405, 0.024036699905991554, 0.045261673629283905, -0.01641051471233368, -0.010268875397741795, -0.07629681378602982, 0.002446525264531374, 0.044921230524778366, 0.0302821546792984, -0.013320119120180607, 0.0077607580460608006, 0.02296549640595913, 0.045487601310014725, -0.049875881522893906, -0.046991825103759766, -0.003497977741062641, 0.027103552594780922, -0.008581901900470257, 0.06133482605218887, 0.01152704656124115, -0.06526096910238266, 0.011590047739446163, -0.030990712344646454, -0.07712925970554352, -0.002765432232990861, -0.032975710928440094, 0.006457294337451458, 0.026171701028943062, 0.008585379458963871, 0.04763149097561836, 0.05433700233697891, -0.0015722871758043766, -0.006525340490043163, -0.06094725802540779, 0.029609156772494316, -0.025824284180998802, -0.027355464175343513, -0.037183355540037155, -0.018824992701411247, -0.06262613832950592, -0.010955256409943104, -0.002936288481578231, 0.03757474943995476, -0.007192620541900396, -0.014518707059323788, 0.025303032249212265, 0.03262895718216896, 0.029958920553326607, 0.0025862290058285, 0.0018359663663432002, -0.004794017411768436, 0.013323712162673473, -0.011886377818882465, 0.058066919445991516, -0.016982853412628174, 0.00034419933217577636, 0.033692263066768646, -0.0482708178460598, -0.006113946903496981, -0.04661143571138382, -0.02039431966841221, -0.00625862181186676, -0.04377942159771919, 0.05858934670686722, -0.013334298506379128, 0.03307614475488663, -0.011801829561591148, -0.027733586728572845, -0.020822448655962944, 0.014383609406650066, -0.02886177971959114, 0.02686435915529728, -0.048081524670124054, 0.06342267990112305, -0.03840891271829605, -0.05300971493124962, -0.06774232536554337, -0.019712448120117188, 0.03669062629342079, -0.03981912508606911, -0.046603135764598846, -0.06177578866481781, 0.06474889069795609, -0.028996795415878296, -0.009005571715533733, 0.0037553273141384125, 0.07681918889284134, -0.04281569644808769, -0.01831025443971157, -0.00174336030613631, -0.0022530974820256233, 0.07734938710927963, 0.007038541603833437, 0.0005453090416267514, 0.019354043528437614, 0.003142507979646325, -0.020793583244085312, -0.004142195452004671, 0.023881999775767326, -0.042981237173080444, 0.00036055524833500385, -0.034251607954502106, -0.016717758029699326, 0.0032095317728817463, -0.05723363533616066, 0.017211470752954483, 0.01801898330450058, -0.002392629161477089, -0.021126531064510345, -0.04649505391716957, 0.036117713898420334, -0.03239936754107475, 0.033595114946365356, -0.04533850774168968, 0.0014580885181203485, -0.0014035511994734406, -0.004553306847810745, 0.0222861897200346, 0.02947905659675598, 0.0023683025501668453, 0.028867745772004128, 0.048638083040714264, 0.019142210483551025, 0.019675055518746376, 0.025240115821361542, -0.032311420887708664, 0.011875213123857975, -0.014168629422783852, 0.027611857280135155, 0.011293767020106316, 0.003255534451454878, -0.0526198074221611, -0.054234329611063004, -0.011084289290010929, -0.04094698280096054, 0.02792956493794918, 0.022979483008384705, 0.03389885649085045, 0.03513167053461075, -0.02540348470211029, -0.00942947342991829, -0.03557111695408821, -0.002449438441544771, -0.02467438578605652, -0.01161426492035389, 0.017898453399538994, -0.006591317243874073, 0.03269890323281288, 0.010373497381806374, -0.005554027855396271, 0.04047129675745964, 0.04530544951558113, 0.028752563521265984, 0.043703705072402954, 0.05122951790690422, -0.03972456976771355, -0.05800916999578476, 0.036643270403146744, -0.05267781764268875, 0.038484614342451096, -0.0337955467402935, -0.021023260429501534, 0.03429005667567253, 0.006792083848267794, -0.006322311703115702, -0.029287440702319145, -0.019025541841983795, -0.05993737652897835, -0.005028306040912867, 0.0061698551289737225, -0.027662495151162148, 0.026744915172457695, -0.005308822263032198, 0.01982724666595459, -0.02296029031276703, 0.04444232955574989, -0.04022885113954544, -0.08533925563097, -0.02199641615152359, 0.03217822313308716, -0.05307583883404732, 0.026106737554073334, 0.014468503184616566, -0.0533502958714962, 0.01091618463397026, -0.0337776318192482, 0.0287905503064394, 0.00805253442376852, 0.01794963702559471, -0.023883968591690063, 0.045474208891391754, -0.012210823595523834, -0.0225153136998415, 0.003665193449705839, -0.014141971245408058, 0.12883058190345764, 0.08222194761037827, 0.08379354327917099, -0.09646452963352203, 0.052354052662849426, 0.01647999882698059, 0.032836221158504486, -0.03215596079826355, 0.030121872201561928, -0.011463596485555172, 0.034712307155132294, 0.0667034462094307, 0.03506182134151459, 0.00891098566353321, 0.024629825726151466, 0.069970041513443, -0.030477551743388176, -0.022386062890291214, -0.012874561361968517, 0.000506149954162538, 0.033754970878362656, -0.02100907824933529, -0.030657634139060974, 0.008784199133515358, 0.02737421728670597, -0.02317526936531067, -0.049224380403757095, -0.04494349658489227, -0.0012245603138580918, 0.002212837105616927, -0.016042761504650116, -0.029024802148342133, 0.031542036682367325, 0.02154461294412613, -0.022896096110343933, -0.007876364514231682, 0.0018440375570207834, -0.025300491601228714, 0.0007068790728226304, 0.00031274056527763605, -0.026499992236495018, -0.01243626419454813, 0.03155568242073059, 0.00048411826719529927, -0.05119317024946213, -0.012709842063486576, -0.04662710428237915, 0.0089108319953084, -0.03707580640912056, 0.005624667275696993, -0.04025396332144737, -0.013040327467024326, 0.015480228699743748, 0.005938431713730097, -0.014663241803646088, 0.03662104904651642, 0.04916054382920265, -0.029606753960251808, -0.0044928244315087795, -0.021013464778661728, 0.010453124530613422, -0.017027441412210464, 0.02354176715016365, 0.04546165093779564, -0.03493494167923927, -0.049732755869627, -0.009019061923027039, 0.0027626734226942062, 0.007417429704219103, 0.007816102355718613, 0.04169077426195145, 0.05725926160812378, -0.03692254796624184, 0.013202195055782795, 0.014898993074893951, -0.015027275308966637, 0.030612066388130188, 0.008218629285693169, 0.012603161856532097, -0.005459185689687729, -0.05180390551686287, 0.011975686997175217, -0.008637317456305027, -0.028379598632454872, -0.02812686376273632, 0.019120285287499428, 0.022864025086164474, 0.02530008740723133, 0.05699433386325836, 0.02145950123667717, -0.008518844842910767, 0.027970856055617332, 0.01638699509203434, -0.0317247211933136, 0.039302997291088104, -0.017358437180519104, -0.02593819983303547, -0.03451535105705261, -0.0144950645044446, 0.029677623882889748, 0.012670688331127167, 0.007119331508874893, 0.01668727956712246, -0.008896841667592525, -0.023681309074163437, 0.010664710775017738, -0.00019158108625561, -0.05276136472821236, -0.006003082729876041, 0.025882096961140633, 0.016392162069678307, -0.01890159584581852, -0.0342290885746479, -0.02907794527709484, -0.037537042051553726, -0.0002510054619051516, -0.012225502170622349, -0.04188971966505051, 0.018866879865527153, 0.03712303563952446, 0.02671283297240734, -0.0390910841524601, -0.026217693462967873, -0.050532709807157516, -0.03753435239195824, -0.004699926823377609, -0.01621398888528347, 0.011678406037390232, 0.00871924590319395, 0.02852136641740799, 0.024471670389175415, 0.039589688181877136, 0.012283930554986, 0.015942709520459175, 0.01516415923833847, 0.012749943882226944, -0.004905419889837503, 0.04999207705259323, -0.02259203791618347, -0.04259336367249489, 0.03315933048725128, -0.020676838234066963, -0.03922519460320473, 0.016896361485123634, -0.023997988551855087, 0.003443224588409066, -0.012774335220456123, -0.015125159174203873, 0.01315164752304554, 0.03011084534227848, -0.027519339695572853, -0.027198540046811104, -0.02605533041059971, 0.00419514300301671, 0.041102148592472076, -0.01899850182235241, 0.006275967229157686, -0.027329981327056885, -0.022984543815255165, -0.0008184437174350023, 0.04294300451874733, 0.018416177481412888, 0.012138153426349163, 0.01308244839310646, 0.002448556013405323, 0.020641053095459938, -0.031373776495456696, -0.01928681507706642, 0.037510402500629425, 0.04939164221286774, -0.04726283624768257, 0.034149736166000366, -0.010382425971329212, 0.012630589306354523, -0.07579647749662399, 0.004098084289580584, 0.015245432034134865, -0.020309656858444214, 0.044640038162469864, -0.04128219559788704, 0.04839804396033287, 0.07371602952480316, -0.0656113401055336, -0.001726641901768744, 0.011612242087721825, -0.010560796596109867, -0.02881721593439579, -0.00785896461457014, -0.0220535546541214, 0.04648350551724434, 0.005410024430602789, 0.011953406035900116, 0.009174039587378502, 0.02349909394979477, 0.005380991846323013, -0.025895586237311363, -0.03552927076816559, -0.0038778651505708694, -0.01939726062119007, -0.04030721262097359, 0.043245553970336914, -0.02565910294651985, 0.002265600487589836, 0.030861247330904007, 0.023259498178958893, 0.022281954064965248, 0.035518184304237366, 0.005738846492022276, -0.035892825573682785, 0.05494645982980728, 0.023388318717479706, 0.00016251653141807765, -0.03307165578007698, -0.03163112699985504, -0.011053487658500671, 0.04947110638022423, 0.004614061675965786, 0.04268636927008629, 0.02419743314385414, -0.035400811582803726, -0.024348841980099678, 0.03990105167031288, -0.002413536189123988, -0.026776401326060295, 0.017939046025276184, -0.001694331644102931, 0.020414620637893677, -0.01587880216538906, 0.041107021272182465, -0.058954477310180664, 0.03187085688114166, 0.05507214367389679, 0.030894624069333076, -0.004013288300484419, 0.01215160172432661, 0.008472022600471973, -0.03717035427689552, -0.01147776935249567, -0.030486444011330605, -0.0034017073921859264, -0.03562268242239952, -0.025524279102683067, 0.018145522102713585, 0.020246360450983047, -0.02430036850273609, 0.00369568751193583, -0.022676248103380203, 0.036984510719776154, 0.004362284671515226, 0.0022428191732615232, 0.022927869111299515, -0.02999475970864296, 0.04157097637653351, -0.05994268134236336, 0.09298362582921982, 0.017806025221943855, -0.0015410606283694506, -0.0168946273624897, -0.00277671474032104, -0.015316053293645382, 0.0073629263788461685, 0.06455829739570618, -0.01545680407434702, 0.03738071769475937, -0.025507284328341484, 0.019507326185703278, 0.027105072513222694, -0.0520135872066021, 0.07452832162380219, 0.013887247070670128, -0.008994359523057938, -0.029614616185426712, -0.00866869930177927, 0.0018830009503290057, -0.019032560288906097, 0.006619921885430813, 0.004485452082008123, 0.04290667548775673, 0.02889874204993248, -0.008245831355452538, 0.04123213142156601, 0.01468088198453188, 0.011555653065443039, 0.01757776364684105, -0.013930531218647957, 0.026875080540776253, -0.004246153403073549, -0.013308233581483364, -0.024646500125527382, 0.05751379579305649, -0.02984454669058323, 0.005263345781713724, -0.03422818332910538, -0.00844552181661129, -0.027664145454764366, -0.03549867868423462, 0.0030855070799589157, 0.014944400638341904, -0.015308302827179432, 0.02076488360762596, 0.014888061210513115, 0.03813380002975464, 0.03543933480978012, -0.005184694658964872, 0.05881032347679138, 0.03655672445893288, -0.01411762461066246, -0.027950214222073555, 0.004428753163665533, 0.05420306324958801, 0.0059114075265824795, -0.00055858981795609, 0.02006375789642334, -0.012394297868013382, 0.08845286071300507, -0.002648981288075447, 0.015303594060242176, -0.056402720510959625, -0.030608506873250008, 0.023521531373262405, -0.03538360074162483, 0.01312738936394453, 0.04792207106947899, 0.012074392288923264, 0.06925404816865921, -0.04549155384302139, -0.010670626536011696, -0.062310438603162766, -0.008907469920814037, -0.030982907861471176, -0.022280486300587654, -0.043201521039009094, 0.06005237251520157, 0.01493027899414301, 0.014047174714505672, 0.002377256751060486, 0.027126414701342583, 0.011319362558424473, -0.024294624105095863, 0.06072229892015457, -0.023186951875686646, -0.01557286735624075, -0.02391378954052925, -0.021798769012093544, 0.0035946802236139774, 0.012539904564619064, 0.04446907714009285, 0.04355882853269577, 0.00004535878179012798, 0.005283527076244354, -0.010214223526418209, -0.031831998378038406, 0.022084325551986694, -0.0563531257212162, -0.036489732563495636, -0.03916651010513306, 0.03321271762251854, -0.007445535156875849, 0.005423364229500294 ]
<p>I have been looking into theoretical frameworks for method selection (note: not model selection) and have found very little systematic, mathematically-motivated work. By 'method selection', I mean a framework for distinguishing the appropriate (or better, optimal) method with respect to a problem, or problem type.</p> <p>What I have found is substantial, if piecemeal, work on particular methods and their tuning (i.e. prior selection in Bayesian methods), and method selection via bias selection (e.g. <a href="http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=218546">Inductive Policy: The Pragmatics of Bias Selection</a>). I may be unrealistic at this early stage of machine learning's development, but I was hoping to find something like what <a href="ftp://ftp.sas.com/pub/neural/measurement.html">measurement theory</a> does in prescribing admissible transformations and tests by scale type, only writ large in the arena of learning problems.</p> <p>Any suggestions?</p>
49,167
[ -0.047421008348464966, -0.018836021423339844, -0.022690456360578537, -0.04138040170073509, 0.01321763452142477, 0.015128746628761292, -0.041129522025585175, -0.020032420754432678, 0.026557283475995064, -0.011534811928868294, 0.013334434479475021, 0.04259658232331276, 0.05886297672986984, 0.029596300795674324, 0.02361179143190384, -0.004702266305685043, -0.04124050214886665, 0.039358194917440414, -0.028385471552610397, -0.011465025134384632, 0.012832621112465858, 0.01820794865489006, 0.042166028171777725, -0.013297440484166145, -0.01649765484035015, 0.0013127046404406428, -0.02077479660511017, -0.016135910525918007, -0.02388784848153591, 0.04741353914141655, -0.00880042091012001, -0.002772604115307331, -0.010745123028755188, 0.01965806633234024, -0.015367944724857807, -0.015078294090926647, 0.004984752740710974, 0.019712207838892937, -0.019767170771956444, 0.027993682771921158, -0.014814690686762333, -0.02079734578728676, 0.004160392098128796, 0.0033642598427832127, -0.01822844333946705, 0.02076222375035286, -0.05350311100482941, -0.019673755392432213, 0.019529160112142563, -0.05463970825076103, 0.06415450572967529, 0.022704752162098885, -0.015130525454878807, 0.053419869393110275, -0.018397917971014977, -0.020508747547864914, 0.05660851299762726, 0.04327701777219772, -0.04120246693491936, -0.016727523878216743, -0.03286565840244293, -0.04229935258626938, 0.01868484541773796, -0.009231683798134327, -0.022373372688889503, 0.0645134299993515, 0.028402825817465782, -0.016475822776556015, 0.030784551054239273, -0.01784527860581875, 0.003738664323464036, -0.0015743052354082465, -0.006504144985228777, 0.004423241131007671, -0.0009739248198457062, -0.013821848668158054, 0.0023655458353459835, 0.044637639075517654, 0.04521745443344116, 0.04688497260212898, 0.017750108614563942, 0.0000888724607648328, 0.010023240000009537, 0.041813332587480545, 0.002995128044858575, 0.007823034189641476, 0.09716837853193283, -0.011578129604458809, 0.015071465633809566, 0.012545526027679443, 0.000414666865253821, -0.028111429885029793, 0.023403063416481018, -0.03436372056603432, -0.030858062207698822, 0.04723186790943146, 0.004504584241658449, 0.026200104504823685, -0.011117910034954548, -0.025720909237861633, -0.0425100103020668, -0.033903639763593674, -0.01824040710926056, 0.03253871574997902, -0.03887419402599335, 0.007763249333947897, -0.008668765425682068, 0.029853416606783867, -0.018922792747616768, -0.032611362636089325, -0.009431660175323486, 0.02336098998785019, 0.02278217487037182, 0.014560624957084656, 0.05839082971215248, -0.012135758996009827, -0.022670358419418335, -0.040238168090581894, 0.07003949582576752, 0.0767744705080986, 0.032169122248888016, -0.05956854671239853, 0.01159810833632946, -0.0205390565097332, -0.05432302504777908, 0.01972941681742668, 0.0049102227203547955, -0.008284850046038628, -0.009370597079396248, 0.01357000321149826, -0.010737687349319458, -0.030721083283424377, 0.031233644112944603, 0.003134452737867832, -0.005144856870174408, -0.011774464510381222, -0.06441065669059753, -0.05211074277758598, 0.016005493700504303, 0.0018412892241030931, 0.01115687470883131, -0.04320197179913521, -0.010795444250106812, 0.044319964945316315, 0.06830641627311707, 0.02110624872148037, 0.043223291635513306, -0.0009523321059532464, 0.021651001647114754, -0.01181069202721119, -0.01219954900443554, -0.03721032291650772, -0.02048058807849884, 0.0023253015242516994, -0.02454359270632267, -0.035440631210803986, 0.0488068051636219, 0.01867830753326416, -0.008684715256094933, 0.02501099742949009, 0.044314026832580566, -0.007579730823636055, -0.0549812987446785, -0.004200349561870098, 0.04920206591486931, 0.036805447190999985, 0.049621619284152985, 0.01820613443851471, 0.03362497687339783, 0.03951508551836014, 0.015834515914320946, 0.017223792150616646, 0.03460494801402092, 0.015763839706778526, 0.05648747831583023, -0.03678301349282265, -0.023747649043798447, 0.006600758992135525, 0.030809925869107246, -0.0271893460303545, 0.0059823873452842236, -0.020495444536209106, -0.029551221057772636, -0.02663504146039486, 0.05211961269378662, 0.05801162123680115, -0.02029769867658615, -0.002629891037940979, 0.05064230412244797, -0.05099964886903763, -0.026603780686855316, -0.043931253254413605, -0.004910980351269245, -0.03178100287914276, -0.02740401029586792, 0.058138374239206314, -0.01490477193146944, 0.02125268243253231, -0.026054251939058304, -0.05799856781959534, -0.014941966161131859, -0.0019356523407623172, 0.04385196417570114, 0.008539333008229733, 0.005929422564804554, 0.03721402958035469, -0.014447868801653385, -0.037077851593494415, 0.040433190762996674, -0.037686243653297424, -0.05099702626466751, -0.0033402189146727324, -0.03276992589235306, -0.007273197174072266, 0.002252669306471944, -0.033407244831323624, 0.019826188683509827, -0.02980981580913067, -0.03951886296272278, 0.04429370164871216, -0.07639230787754059, 0.09648632258176804, 0.03651720657944679, -0.0008859509835019708, 0.021319378167390823, 0.06432196497917175, 0.013825233094394207, 0.01134293619543314, -0.02894134819507599, 0.008485183119773865, -0.05140732601284981, -0.048151858150959015, 0.03580727055668831, 0.037061385810375214, -0.04155711457133293, 0.02084239572286606, 0.013319985941052437, 0.04779398441314697, 0.0066434526816010475, 0.0374734029173851, -0.02072255127131939, -0.0220459196716547, -0.0035476088523864746, 0.04200790449976921, -0.0073978048749268055, 0.005219305865466595, -0.0034375623799860477, 0.00901124533265829, 0.028170397505164146, 0.024964094161987305, -0.017724057659506798, 0.039215054363012314, 0.018308749422430992, 0.017579922452569008, 0.0007920463103801012, -0.014796674251556396, -0.0006190824788063765, -0.037289079278707504, -0.006577721331268549, 0.020543085411190987, -0.004875136539340019, 0.020555054768919945, -0.0012882964219897985, -0.004781602881848812, 0.061315156519412994, 0.011467539705336094, -0.007018455304205418, 0.005384649615734816, 0.03993329033255577, -0.019374478608369827, 0.006753913126885891, -0.0036139856092631817, -0.0022342028096318245, -0.047229502350091934, 0.012366444803774357, -0.024906473234295845, -0.005439399741590023, -0.0019328230991959572, -0.024702509865164757, -0.006953326053917408, 0.0066017829813063145, -0.023343930020928383, 0.03214649483561516, -0.024483324959874153, -0.047782909125089645, -0.014028269797563553, -0.06373810023069382, -0.005840560887008905, 0.042293090373277664, 0.0027327744755893946, -0.02124227024614811, 0.013297418132424355, 0.050028908997774124, -0.06900814175605774, -0.018802452832460403, -0.029462719336152077, 0.028352713212370872, 0.018609294667840004, -0.01693134382367134, 0.034752268344163895, 0.016076194122433662, -0.06294385343790054, 0.032645873725414276, 0.0022221810650080442, -0.041538115590810776, -0.02154722809791565, -0.022797998040914536, -0.009653558023273945, 0.0033553605899214745, 0.0003244978142902255, 0.040625009685754776, -0.060293249785900116, -0.0076534682884812355, -0.03441876918077469, -0.03335335850715637, 0.011206178925931454, 0.007578799966722727, 0.046738822013139725, 0.038829464465379715, -0.0019195781787857413, 0.06633973866701126, 0.06148865446448326, -0.04094080626964569, -0.03510267660021782, 0.03261665627360344, -0.005467582494020462, -0.004415116738528013, 0.025552114471793175, 0.04574306681752205, -0.003195124212652445, 0.014654950238764286, -0.013772332109510899, 0.02893586829304695, 0.03527284786105156, 0.015044860541820526, 0.03268805891275406, 0.034931480884552, 0.01443701982498169, -0.01273268647491932, -0.0023121347185224295, 0.05642849579453468, -0.03523885831236839, 0.0062296208925545216, -0.01343075092881918, 0.003399613779038191, 0.02502419985830784, -0.029871566221117973, 0.008481821976602077, -0.03437313809990883, -0.0022566653788089752, -0.019108792766928673, 0.0072620464488863945, 0.007833551615476608, -0.021721919998526573, 0.003407725365832448, 0.020540228113532066, 0.015816569328308105, -0.0348537303507328, -0.013568908907473087, 0.0372108556330204, 0.03627913445234299, -0.0017391940345987678, -0.021307621151208878, -0.009356370195746422, -0.03416430577635765, 0.030110683292150497, -0.0171895120292902, -0.00421148631721735, 0.05262992903590202, 0.02756957896053791, 0.04357869550585747, -0.01600302755832672, -0.04010504111647606, 0.02764720842242241, -0.05852938070893288, -0.006574984639883041, -0.038819320499897, 0.09215746074914932, 0.0036271167919039726, 0.005216954741626978, 0.021437201648950577, -0.02474646084010601, -0.008600163273513317, 0.01816062442958355, -0.072066530585289, 0.022053036838769913, -0.026172148063778877, 0.01836448907852173, 0.006433727685362101, -0.029010284692049026, 0.03338285908102989, -0.0365045927464962, -0.0034380564466118813, -0.016878092661499977, 0.05472030118107796, -0.018561799079179764, 0.002857041312381625, -0.048220518976449966, -0.04556363821029663, -0.008375203236937523, 0.030874013900756836, 0.030841602012515068, -0.028495632112026215, 0.010795896872878075, 0.008867492899298668, -0.007829544134438038, -0.03631322458386421, -0.023358933627605438, 0.022075919434428215, -0.005505927838385105, 0.06434328109025955, 0.0022712950594723225, 0.03416050225496292, -0.051512476056814194, 0.06774485111236572, 0.018239933997392654, 0.019934536889195442, 0.028101610019803047, -0.05346614494919777, -0.036244675517082214, -0.06844747066497803, -0.023670651018619537, 0.01979103684425354, 0.03474873676896095, 0.03361614793539047, -0.03603130206465721, 0.061328161507844925, 0.013243181630969048, -0.025251194834709167, 0.004267107229679823, 0.07187594473361969, 0.012170186266303062, -0.005643573589622974, -0.013388080522418022, -0.016271021217107773, 0.01781785488128662, 0.0012363566784188151, 0.012318942695856094, 0.02435256540775299, 0.02865407057106495, -0.005252047907561064, 0.03648487105965614, -0.01692061871290207, -0.023338546976447105, -0.02247772552073002, 0.03004828654229641, 0.03408985584974289, 0.03207223489880562, -0.02327927201986313, 0.0007536861230619252, 0.06292597204446793, 0.08062392473220825, 0.023392485454678535, 0.019400306046009064, -0.07740166783332825, 0.024569297209382057, 0.06011013686656952, 0.020578637719154358, -0.04766587167978287, 0.022537412121891975, -0.016952570527791977, -0.029858423396945, 0.05089002102613449, -0.012569628655910492, 0.06018228828907013, -0.04113965481519699, -0.0021235754247754812, -0.04693559929728508, -0.016854548826813698, -0.02344033308327198, 0.005153559148311615, -0.019618229940533638, 0.06366480141878128, -0.023870909586548805, 0.0018033530795946717, -0.020317628979682922, -0.031814172863960266, -0.017355551943182945, 0.03465104475617409, 0.004140895325690508, -0.03126434609293938, 0.011807804927229881, 0.0304117351770401, -0.016892854124307632, -0.06678663939237595, -0.026235293596982956, 0.013293080031871796, 0.00005977131149847992, 0.007948697544634342, 0.018596936017274857, -0.06888023018836975, 0.020679369568824768, -0.02097713015973568, -0.04496852308511734, 0.021268397569656372, -0.020877931267023087, 0.04934597760438919, 0.009703850373625755, 0.02647898718714714, 0.04404546692967415, 0.030366621911525726, -0.00011367699335096404, 0.000651144830044359, -0.021456126123666763, 0.0009060525917448103, -0.014664392918348312, -0.014779673889279366, -0.03244693949818611, 0.006905199959874153, -0.015975428745150566, 0.03819073364138603, 0.0221095010638237, 0.05619918182492256, -0.05027385056018829, -0.011882060207426548, 0.0007832992123439908, 0.021821903064846992, -0.0164637491106987, -0.025596382096409798, 0.02414598874747753, 0.043094731867313385, -0.012640335597097874, -0.003218557685613632, 0.006569626275449991, -0.00999861117452383, 0.02340957708656788, 0.0184117890894413, -0.05543878301978111, 0.02196776680648327, -0.01334811095148325, -0.009533720090985298, 0.04429014027118683, -0.025708338245749474, 0.039608780294656754, -0.010831732302904129, 0.01457776315510273, -0.004920365288853645, -0.03747512027621269, -0.02398526482284069, 0.00636290293186903, 0.01800016686320305, 0.02966933138668537, -0.044265348464250565, -0.01882110722362995, -0.02215050719678402, -0.014170906506478786, -0.05249251797795296, -0.032786205410957336, 0.017842840403318405, 0.008475411683321, 0.005728243850171566, -0.030573276802897453, 0.05489139258861542, -0.03739038482308388, -0.034333307296037674, -0.007247181609272957, 0.08819661289453506, -0.022361598908901215, -0.04607376828789711, -0.0007295482791960239, 0.047528985887765884, 0.035591695457696915, -0.014947276562452316, 0.018988290801644325, -0.00822224747389555, 0.0020399915520101786, 0.008030412718653679, 0.054243896156549454, 0.006260946858674288, -0.03391045704483986, -0.017498677596449852, -0.0466269925236702, 0.004081552382558584, 0.02702149748802185, -0.036200106143951416, 0.004407878499478102, 0.027063831686973572, -0.037781670689582825, -0.053571917116642, -0.0271296389400959, 0.021307045593857765, -0.006647584028542042, -0.0200192928314209, 0.002742084674537182, -0.0034387658815830946, 0.0036883759312331676, -0.021837130188941956, 0.02106080949306488, 0.011203614063560963, -0.01676315814256668, 0.022341879084706306, 0.02000550366938114, -0.009990353137254715, 0.0063942596316337585, 0.008610649034380913, -0.03209179267287254, 0.050938770174980164, -0.01874573715031147, 0.02322310209274292, 0.016200896352529526, 0.004509990103542805, -0.028656741604208946, -0.02477220818400383, -0.03770599514245987, -0.003302237018942833, 0.06028756499290466, 0.01018408965319395, 0.06330951303243637, 0.0632854476571083, -0.025008805096149445, -0.023170335218310356, -0.03261801600456238, 0.014398830942809582, -0.01710011437535286, -0.006484779994934797, 0.06043613329529762, -0.026040179654955864, -0.011541730724275112, 0.017509711906313896, -0.0004668302717618644, 0.0023207436315715313, 0.009475069120526314, -0.005689101759344339, 0.03495478630065918, 0.031804926693439484, -0.09286029636859894, -0.02556016854941845, 0.019090939313173294, -0.057051561772823334, -0.02027384750545025, -0.012171710841357708, -0.04757774993777275, 0.03415505215525627, 0.026965564116835594, 0.0043756403028965, -0.02883320301771164, -0.013279218226671219, -0.08071667701005936, -0.011360974051058292, 0.016506841406226158, -0.008944517001509666, 0.04291883483529091, 0.03247138857841492, 0.004867601208388805, -0.009588943794369698, 0.02803008072078228, -0.009732392616569996, -0.052676841616630554, -0.0632767602801323, -0.03610372915863991, -0.03268543258309364, 0.01956796459853649, 0.025269877165555954, -0.01686731167137623, -0.005231981631368399, -0.03376190736889839, 0.015891728922724724, 0.06925684958696365, 0.034221842885017395, -0.03798459470272064, 0.04642883688211441, -0.022478673607110977, 0.014130668714642525, -0.005855628289282322, -0.0024882322177290916, 0.13404718041419983, 0.11292387545108795, 0.043169088661670685, -0.08154694736003876, 0.024315956979990005, -0.021535193547606468, 0.0009911397937685251, -0.00743428198620677, 0.00965526606887579, 0.009419968351721764, 0.00014628768258262426, -0.015437662601470947, 0.053359486162662506, 0.05984966456890106, -0.016749480739235878, 0.061282068490982056, -0.03157518804073334, -0.009265003725886345, 0.041734158992767334, 0.0018784772837534547, 0.0059364065527915955, -0.005117369350045919, -0.016186030581593513, -0.004722090438008308, 0.029434405267238617, -0.03449712693691254, 0.009348250925540924, 0.0021182491909712553, -0.008101549930870533, -0.012632692232728004, 0.0014184493338689208, -0.016738904640078545, 0.005103947129100561, -0.0011925066355615854, -0.005383883137255907, -0.00039681894122622907, 0.0023934575729072094, -0.04542739689350128, 0.010843358002603054, 0.03019711747765541, 0.020181600004434586, -0.02138342894613743, -0.012062174268066883, 0.010034924373030663, -0.03693248704075813, -0.01269469317048788, -0.051815565675497055, 0.0507851243019104, 0.00012262421660125256, -0.017950991168618202, 0.01642821729183197, -0.025079580023884773, 0.03257595747709274, -0.039914123713970184, 0.011020557954907417, 0.03288108855485916, 0.04857179895043373, -0.030419684946537018, -0.03535240516066551, 0.031537629663944244, 0.012084992602467537, -0.018382932990789413, 0.019503893330693245, 0.006270757410675287, -0.04153988137841225, -0.037921249866485596, -0.022209178656339645, 0.028014076873660088, 0.03828703239560127, -0.015249359421432018, 0.022321809083223343, -0.0010457687312737107, -0.03691529110074043, 0.0060604470781981945, 0.00954886432737112, 0.013043304905295372, 0.04136427864432335, -0.01666949689388275, -0.0006834727828390896, -0.02802380360662937, -0.0101848179474473, 0.025513365864753723, -0.026211204007267952, -0.0013752984814345837, -0.04765694588422775, 0.011431023478507996, -0.019990799948573112, 0.015976866707205772, 0.05251273885369301, -0.02329925075173378, 0.004357416648417711, -0.009004133753478527, 0.016953380778431892, -0.03824450820684433, -0.0030909162014722824, -0.012058911845088005, -0.037579961121082306, -0.001564223668538034, 0.0017336662858724594, 0.06180239096283913, 0.021125569939613342, -0.005540149286389351, -0.010133717209100723, 0.008465401828289032, -0.0150761092081666, 0.008546542376279831, -0.014288637787103653, -0.029625145718455315, -0.0063765645027160645, -0.03979913145303726, -0.0027923681773245335, -0.03827124461531639, -0.01569339819252491, -0.08177964389324188, 0.0036457194946706295, 0.0023627527989447117, 0.0014000043738633394, -0.04282733425498009, 0.039251700043678284, 0.014929895289242268, 0.02719378098845482, -0.006066802889108658, 0.0013195544015616179, -0.01551753655076027, -0.03178144618868828, -0.033047378063201904, -0.007847695611417294, 0.022762233391404152, 0.008637617342174053, -0.03432596102356911, -0.019154058769345284, 0.018155962228775024, 0.009152689017355442, -0.012723783031105995, -0.00026351920678280294, 0.001434871694073081, -0.009957855567336082, 0.04033109173178673, -0.023182006552815437, 0.012255922891199589, 0.005875223781913519, -0.038432519882917404, -0.035834234207868576, 0.0055497800931334496, -0.03453772887587547, 0.010101876221597195, 0.03183720260858536, -0.0015037056291475892, -0.03136594220995903, 0.011741421185433865, -0.010413698852062225, -0.019876539707183838, -0.040164507925510406, 0.008070173673331738, -0.02873326651751995, -0.030165817588567734, 0.036759667098522186, -0.003457289421930909, -0.02772623486816883, 0.015511207282543182, 0.012800944037735462, 0.01081116683781147, 0.0016224433202296495, 0.005365161225199699, -0.018371127545833588, 0.015568405389785767, 0.03883480280637741, 0.010959263890981674, 0.02511654794216156, 0.0386163704097271, -0.03012796677649021, 0.021123992279171944, 0.021916525438427925, 0.013501091860234737, -0.10095874965190887, 0.00024174051941372454, 0.02109452523291111, 0.02569540962576866, 0.057083964347839355, -0.08302270621061325, 0.005458677187561989, 0.004787988029420376, -0.048687245696783066, 0.025543896481394768, -0.03961304575204849, -0.00149258179590106, 0.0073301587253808975, -0.014408254995942116, -0.0343736857175827, 0.00602918304502964, 0.0034896056167781353, -0.000947758904658258, 0.02252763882279396, -0.007513248827308416, 0.0035741091705858707, -0.011732887476682663, -0.011504103429615498, 0.011537979356944561, -0.010687889531254768, -0.05261621251702309, 0.022663060575723648, -0.016947517171502113, -0.05065833032131195, 0.04555851221084595, 0.01828383095562458, 0.058177314698696136, 0.009132005274295807, 0.020868025720119476, -0.003818816039711237, 0.027690770104527473, 0.0011841931845992804, -0.02442537248134613, -0.016802286729216576, 0.0048006754368543625, 0.0075907944701612, 0.035963792353868484, 0.015032431110739708, -0.009113378822803497, 0.009164885617792606, -0.004161238670349121, -0.029772372916340828, -0.004639481659978628, -0.023873472586274147, -0.0384746752679348, 0.017364654690027237, 0.0032751159742474556, 0.002282081637531519, 0.013455655425786972, 0.04562302306294441, -0.034916844218969345, -0.005006180144846439, 0.03288727253675461, 0.004475663416087627, -0.0010383551707491279, 0.0012509135995060205, 0.011451923288404942, -0.017437178641557693, 0.01017630472779274, -0.012520947493612766, 0.005925266072154045, -0.06134252995252609, 0.013404819183051586, 0.02116004005074501, -0.03953564912080765, -0.014780735597014427, 0.03434113413095474, -0.010108095593750477, 0.037736814469099045, -0.030180158093571663, 0.012472052127122879, -0.03881858289241791, -0.025151321664452553, 0.013546420261263847, -0.11396072059869766, 0.07006485015153885, -0.004612752702087164, 0.002833741484209895, -0.0074439886957407, -0.014951844699680805, -0.013678341172635555, 0.002606762805953622, 0.08012788742780685, -0.023386551067233086, -0.013734675943851471, -0.05060392618179321, 0.004699889104813337, 0.015711430460214615, -0.05526181682944298, 0.036099329590797424, 0.008806230500340462, 0.003525710664689541, -0.011583301238715649, -0.025346381589770317, 0.020548604428768158, 0.024133600294589996, 0.02070200815796852, 0.04266103357076645, 0.013250740244984627, 0.005670875310897827, -0.025866277515888214, 0.041594985872507095, 0.03278781846165657, 0.02048768289387226, 0.008254447020590305, 0.02710738033056259, -0.009056095033884048, -0.012176546268165112, 0.01649523340165615, -0.07982724159955978, 0.023438796401023865, -0.037291284650564194, -0.033220384269952774, -0.002683572471141815, 0.03898266330361366, 0.047208938747644424, -0.025399981066584587, -0.008089160546660423, 0.019717330113053322, -0.036175984889268875, -0.02171790599822998, 0.0118727907538414, -0.008753912523388863, 0.03698866441845894, 0.012161687016487122, 0.034582361578941345, 0.04309278726577759, 0.02721286006271839, -0.013345981948077679, 0.019097942858934402, 0.0631355568766594, -0.011747462674975395, 0.014698026701807976, 0.04270756244659424, -0.025165710598230362, 0.02329733781516552, -0.018150070682168007, 0.03966093435883522, -0.052608851343393326, 0.019162671640515327, 0.020596913993358612, -0.010052601806819439, -0.00940641574561596, 0.018120327964425087, -0.024388562887907028, 0.0745987668633461, 0.01783905364573002, -0.003829896915704012, -0.04393976554274559, -0.028659164905548096, 0.01867954432964325, 0.027014411985874176, -0.03544052690267563, 0.04026048257946968, 0.006475883536040783, 0.03656145930290222, 0.008557510562241077, -0.0011326431995257735, 0.0197785384953022, -0.029657509177923203, 0.04886045679450035, -0.001634347252547741, -0.02778744325041771, -0.003614167682826519, -0.02225787378847599, -0.05503300204873085, -0.021857215091586113, -0.0017725145444273949, 0.056978918612003326, 0.05751887336373329, -0.021385973319411278, -0.018775083124637604, -0.021508609876036644, 0.06372059136629105, -0.07174170762300491, -0.01035576593130827, -0.025713838636875153, 0.020607924088835716, -0.010238921269774437, 0.009709838777780533 ]
<p>We want to compare two distributions of ages (birth years) of individuals. Given a set of individuals (<em>all</em>) and a subset of that set (<em>subset</em>), we want to find out:</p> <ol> <li>Is it valid to compare the age distribution of <em>all</em> with that of <em>subset</em> (when |<em>subset</em>| is much smaller than |<em>all</em>|) or can we only compare <em>all</em> minus <em>subset</em>? </li> <li>We did a Shapiro-Wilk test on both distributions and got W = 0.7456 (p-value = 7.499e-08) for <em>all</em> and W = 0.7467 (p-value = 7.865e-08) for <em>subset</em>. This confirms that both distributions are not normal distributions, rather exponential or power-law. Therefore, we can not use Pearson correlation to compare them but should rather use Spearman?</li> <li><p>Comparing both distributions with Spearman, R says</p> <pre><code>t = 93.9151, df = 47, p-value &lt; 2.2e-16 alternative hypothesis: true correlation is not equal to 0 95 percent confidence interval: 0.9952748 0.9985103 sample estimates: cor 0.9973462 </code></pre> <p>which shows a high correlation. How meaningful is this result, given the large amount of young people?</p></li> <li>Can we infer from the correlation test that both distributions are (very) similar?</li> <li>If so, does this allow us to conclude that <em>subset</em> is not more biased towards younger people than <em>all</em> is?</li> <li>Finally, if our assumption was that <em>subset</em> contains more younger people than one would expect, can we now infer that this assumption is wrong?</li> </ol> <p>Since I can not upload images, yet: <a href="https://plus.google.com/106609077152064677019/posts/RWvnXLMVosT" rel="nofollow">here is a plot of both distributions</a> and here the raw data:</p> <pre><code># year age(all) age(subset) 1938 368 1 1939 360 1 1941 394 1 1942 809 3 1943 964 1 1944 686 1 1945 701 1 1946 1301 1 1947 1228 5 1948 1565 2 1949 2019 1 1950 2146 3 1951 2202 6 1952 2343 5 1953 2061 7 1954 2313 3 1955 2963 11 1956 3157 8 1957 3676 16 1958 4051 12 1959 5024 18 1960 5282 19 1961 6849 29 1962 7376 21 1963 8951 38 1964 10314 29 1965 13052 60 1966 13601 65 1967 14606 68 1968 18571 97 1969 19796 101 1970 21248 101 1971 20997 101 1972 24852 135 1973 26648 145 1974 30310 170 1975 34124 190 1976 39344 232 1977 45367 240 1978 54883 303 1979 63037 302 1980 73844 390 1981 77437 377 1982 83985 428 1983 90484 482 1984 100153 500 1985 100139 526 1986 106011 529 1987 101197 472 </code></pre>
74,456
[ -0.043641235679388046, -0.043588701635599136, -0.009256234392523766, -0.028073545545339584, 0.027291644364595413, -0.023349814116954803, -0.007867489941418171, -0.032657526433467865, 0.036010511219501495, -0.052978627383708954, 0.034987494349479675, 0.04643759876489639, 0.025323238223791122, 0.039611686021089554, 0.04391936957836151, 0.0300617516040802, -0.0033607804216444492, 0.008710641413927078, 0.01854291558265686, 0.0057205441407859325, -0.0059917219914495945, 0.009397531859576702, -0.00040783974691294134, -0.043058253824710846, -0.0392698273062706, 0.040552299469709396, 0.008576923981308937, -0.07344148308038712, 0.007627654820680618, 0.04246914014220238, -0.07398952543735504, -0.021658767014741898, 0.011140956543385983, 0.037143584340810776, 0.03876999020576477, -0.003921753726899624, -0.010789602063596249, 0.002228176686912775, 0.022696830332279205, 0.025148116052150726, -0.0549652986228466, -0.010210752487182617, 0.01667233370244503, 0.01897290349006653, 0.012914142571389675, 0.04676627367734909, -0.01840645633637905, -0.030213909223675728, 0.014197367243468761, -0.00809011422097683, 0.011222267523407936, 0.0073246704414486885, 0.026521772146224976, 0.01839420758187771, -0.007245184853672981, -0.021112190559506416, 0.03804725408554077, 0.06687412410974503, -0.005438440013676882, -0.06656210124492645, -0.0038203459698706865, -0.04107506573200226, 0.014159755781292915, 0.027696000412106514, -0.009803335182368755, 0.007461508270353079, 0.014637894928455353, -0.03709558770060539, 0.018188949674367905, -0.030558357015252113, 0.039915524423122406, 0.04076042398810387, 0.019142301753163338, -0.0057701291516423225, 0.008096114732325077, 0.002869531512260437, 0.0255369134247303, 0.015135410241782665, 0.02338530868291855, 0.0231411661952734, 0.0041966610588133335, 0.017207344993948936, 0.04033855348825455, 0.05370260775089264, 0.05358997359871864, -0.009419147856533527, 0.0756966695189476, -0.04191065579652786, -0.007589289918541908, 0.02425369806587696, -0.003116402542218566, -0.02199241891503334, 0.05557568743824959, 0.02061392366886139, -0.02450190857052803, 0.03160390257835388, -0.030256075784564018, 0.022682584822177887, 0.0020929749589413404, 0.021522974595427513, -0.0069760228507220745, -0.05174998193979263, 0.019051849842071533, 0.0485680066049099, -0.00303927855566144, -0.03678738698363304, -0.039905935525894165, -0.0189681313931942, -0.04647452384233475, -0.03942324221134186, -0.011189778335392475, 0.029015084728598595, 0.011683483608067036, 0.011370335705578327, 0.0551796481013298, 0.021946925669908524, -0.0025770666543394327, -0.03211604803800583, 0.07644417136907578, 0.04544374719262123, 0.03466557338833809, 0.0032191418576985598, -0.021807799115777016, -0.011684577912092209, -0.009191282093524933, -0.002466434147208929, 0.02525624819099903, -0.010327368043363094, -0.015588902868330479, 0.009236999787390232, 0.02233840711414814, -0.01793174259364605, 0.047257158905267715, 0.011425296775996685, 0.04428525269031525, 0.007038197945803404, -0.08405905961990356, -0.024103360250592232, 0.0298633873462677, 0.027911219745874405, -0.006227144040167332, -0.044639017432928085, -0.003936236724257469, 0.015329219400882721, 0.03111501783132553, -0.004314228892326355, 0.06267095357179642, -0.021128196269273758, 0.0632411316037178, 0.03668326139450073, -0.021774010732769966, 0.023683061823248863, -0.031925998628139496, -0.007772008888423443, -0.013106074184179306, -0.09897881001234055, 0.01617177575826645, 0.018969256430864334, 0.01598334312438965, -0.027863746508955956, 0.01984092965722084, -0.036930374801158905, -0.03420250862836838, -0.03895431384444237, 0.020161954686045647, 0.00035105334245599806, 0.04033452644944191, 0.008069412782788277, 0.02689284272491932, 0.014311113394796848, -0.023677485063672066, 0.0410148911178112, 0.024096069857478142, 0.029028598219156265, 0.029548661783337593, -0.0344671905040741, 0.0208311565220356, -0.019982118159532547, -0.006256621330976486, 0.00281829503364861, -0.05010848119854927, 0.005959372501820326, -0.06404043734073639, -0.023096170276403427, 0.028102215379476547, 0.035047564655542374, 0.022227736189961433, 0.0009028787608258426, 0.046256810426712036, -0.04293489828705788, -0.0797591581940651, -0.07842595875263214, -0.025030195713043213, -0.0003538520250003785, -0.057292915880680084, 0.0364946573972702, 0.007964466698467731, 0.04218288138508797, -0.01555643230676651, 0.0019867527298629284, -0.03847465291619301, 0.028130818158388138, 0.04273407533764839, -0.037767212837934494, 0.039648886770009995, -0.011407998390495777, 0.05990704894065857, -0.01617218181490898, 0.030772767961025238, -0.03446556255221367, -0.08814087510108948, 0.033578623086214066, -0.023901963606476784, 0.029491808265447617, 0.0033357434440404177, -0.014816895127296448, 0.015428153797984123, 0.01594538986682892, -0.01044909656047821, 0.04215364158153534, -0.022758612409234047, 0.051412906497716904, 0.05341653898358345, -0.019843673333525658, -0.027636945247650146, -0.004745482932776213, 0.010141797363758087, 0.004428504500538111, -0.015496514737606049, 0.013681769371032715, -0.03426994010806084, -0.03859751671552658, 0.01831948012113571, 0.02471322752535343, -0.051870524883270264, -0.004668190144002438, 0.039388883858919144, 0.008496148511767387, -0.05112519487738609, 0.010029000230133533, 0.017108500003814697, -0.04694017395377159, 0.005067890509963036, 0.04190577566623688, 0.0416749082505703, 0.037526071071624756, 0.01814292185008526, 0.012621957808732986, 0.03981948271393776, 0.005241085309535265, -0.0075966292060911655, 0.023708174005150795, -0.014680015854537487, -0.007945483550429344, -0.01553500909358263, -0.031105289235711098, 0.02208712138235569, -0.013237018138170242, 0.012842882424592972, 0.010372553952038288, -0.025642652064561844, -0.02531377039849758, 0.008913095109164715, -0.04334290325641632, 0.02592495270073414, 0.044866204261779785, -0.010669365525245667, -0.024685963988304138, 0.013671253807842731, -0.029264846816658974, -0.013239847496151924, -0.0025547698605805635, -0.03889124467968941, -0.041486192494630814, 0.013588429428637028, 0.035121455788612366, 0.003961298149079084, 0.010236088186502457, -0.048230890184640884, 0.0024150791577994823, -0.03617670759558678, 0.012489669024944305, 0.020427532494068146, -0.004086218308657408, -0.09079914540052414, -0.005980274640023708, 0.008482437580823898, -0.016774054616689682, 0.020087219774723053, -0.010647567920386791, -0.002985080936923623, 0.024768086150288582, 0.00564176868647337, -0.04030735790729523, -0.007499236147850752, -0.001688075135461986, 0.009122730232775211, -0.049843378365039825, -0.030607877299189568, 0.04309498146176338, -0.00438710767775774, -0.06324570626020432, 0.0046259015798568726, -0.01841863803565502, -0.03453477844595909, 0.010900463908910751, -0.022094974294304848, -0.025465482845902443, 0.02141672559082508, 0.0019001811742782593, 0.023978669196367264, 0.018001414835453033, -0.018229534849524498, -0.0862036943435669, -0.0680617168545723, 0.058571189641952515, -0.0020343994256109, 0.02562367357313633, 0.006331206765025854, -0.02552059292793274, 0.0069768535904586315, 0.01943792775273323, -0.004026726353913546, -0.04384636506438255, 0.022601764649152756, -0.045561060309410095, -0.012154456228017807, 0.0173477865755558, 0.041206955909729004, 0.0341985747218132, 0.009978988207876682, 0.006900751031935215, 0.013376947492361069, 0.014044125564396381, -0.022415701299905777, 0.040905337780714035, 0.022433850914239883, 0.004180877469480038, -0.0026070503517985344, 0.04125424101948738, 0.0024328595027327538, -0.0545780174434185, 0.03753937408328056, -0.003370692254975438, 0.03635284677147865, 0.02986263856291771, -0.06552248448133469, 0.03868230804800987, -0.01721261255443096, 0.026430940255522728, -0.0467141792178154, 0.03035760670900345, 0.012884321622550488, -0.0434444397687912, 0.009852422401309013, 0.018880100920796394, 0.00670596631243825, 0.015481457114219666, 0.013835767284035683, 0.07087565958499908, 0.039559319615364075, 0.0003716829523909837, -0.00020438428327906877, -0.007957624271512032, -0.03127000853419304, 0.028075741603970528, -0.02639862708747387, -0.022169407457113266, 0.05353200435638428, 0.06509064137935638, -0.018080035224556923, -0.00006476420821854845, -0.009632699191570282, 0.002045051194727421, -0.04383973032236099, 0.02961748279631138, -0.04602997377514839, 0.0335918627679348, 0.01702885329723358, 0.04117079824209213, 0.018104350194334984, 0.00430868798866868, -0.018802551552653313, -0.02044973336160183, -0.03886735066771507, 0.03926834836602211, -0.006917561870068312, -0.0034824346657842398, -0.026336034759879112, -0.05775127187371254, 0.021017402410507202, -0.01827642321586609, 0.022976843640208244, -0.003061871277168393, 0.03563915565609932, 0.004770198836922646, -0.010014007799327374, -0.018656527623534203, 0.014149358496069908, 0.025912046432495117, -0.0001862111676018685, -0.017097003757953644, -0.005968297831714153, 0.055422913283109665, 0.042537566274404526, 0.012027231976389885, -0.01424463838338852, -0.053269095718860626, 0.04564454406499863, 0.03922967240214348, 0.03629176691174507, 0.02940884418785572, 0.009182307869195938, -0.04603562504053116, -0.008580400608479977, 0.003411076730117202, 0.023312097415328026, 0.056931592524051666, -0.038965966552495956, -0.018117625266313553, 0.017805960029363632, -0.022923287004232407, -0.01033209078013897, 0.009240034967660904, -0.000750073348172009, -0.0013532188022509217, 0.03744344413280487, 0.04274183139204979, -0.027172327041625977, 0.02188989520072937, 0.06064307317137718, -0.0011937899980694056, 0.02190210297703743, -0.043080177158117294, -0.00859025027602911, -0.005293365102261305, 0.02167475037276745, 0.01674238033592701, 0.04224301129579544, -0.00007574624032713473, -0.0012695090845227242, 0.04369457811117172, -0.011166905052959919, -0.07060929387807846, 0.036365631967782974, 0.01534254103899002, 0.046943631023168564, -0.024494241923093796, -0.019890574738383293, 0.017602920532226562, 0.030379928648471832, -0.0015706720296293497, 0.019156325608491898, 0.00942020770162344, -0.07159199565649033, -0.007543874438852072, 0.044075291603803635, 0.056501369923353195, -0.033824268728494644, 0.004923985339701176, -0.0578828789293766, 0.003026772988960147, 0.06150877848267555, 0.0004189829633105546, -0.004578562919050455, 0.011810682713985443, -0.011850152164697647, -0.02775351144373417, -0.06002523750066757, -0.05468665063381195, -0.010065613314509392, -0.028936324641108513, -0.0003088314551860094, -0.040760062634944916, -0.0442776121199131, -0.028666896745562553, -0.027164950966835022, 0.03834345564246178, 0.05367322266101837, -0.023287108168005943, -0.008967144414782524, -0.028406502678990364, 0.002837040228769183, 0.008406530134379864, -0.05778365209698677, 0.02019420638680458, -0.011821424588561058, -0.04093771427869797, 0.040450889617204666, -0.03627539426088333, -0.029202304780483246, 0.028118547052145004, -0.03191075474023819, -0.00048364215763285756, 0.013172647915780544, -0.024877378717064857, 0.09449846297502518, 0.028241442516446114, 0.012307338416576385, 0.027489379048347473, 0.027123073115944862, -0.03820259869098663, 0.02395985834300518, -0.0953914001584053, -0.02552061155438423, -0.0024064299650490284, -0.0017733024433255196, -0.06316106766462326, -0.04573940485715866, 0.003284923266619444, 0.012881002388894558, -0.016020391136407852, -0.0029526595026254654, 0.0022647669538855553, 0.02748088166117668, 0.016963955014944077, 0.030442532151937485, -0.03582742065191269, 0.022482775151729584, -0.005660722963511944, 0.018698418512940407, 0.03291753679513931, -0.022299598902463913, 0.03113708831369877, -0.0153727475553751, 0.013209747150540352, 0.007491980213671923, -0.04026207700371742, -0.012377684935927391, -0.024826083332300186, -0.020290080457925797, -0.016915593296289444, -0.00005440953464130871, 0.030153971165418625, 0.008702771738171577, 0.035908084362745285, 0.033435795456171036, -0.020646221935749054, 0.001798697398044169, 0.040362559258937836, -0.02811344340443611, 0.047650083899497986, 0.01113494299352169, 0.033806052058935165, 0.002990884007886052, -0.03819254785776138, -0.04693340137600899, -0.014431163668632507, 0.008965387009084225, 0.016044070944190025, -0.01647612825036049, -0.016452772542834282, -0.031138911843299866, 0.004325005691498518, 0.005969173274934292, -0.014959112741053104, 0.0738362967967987, -0.005615888629108667, -0.008486619219183922, -0.020508112385869026, 0.003605043748393655, 0.07927379757165909, -0.03560996428132057, 0.0010728134075179696, 0.012640053406357765, -0.039301156997680664, -0.007005984429270029, -0.0038295909762382507, 0.0019641402177512646, -0.031837183982133865, -0.007107814308255911, -0.0314701646566391, 0.0195485670119524, 0.04815460368990898, -0.0133062107488513, -0.08238670974969864, -0.02855588123202324, -0.04339754208922386, 0.006916229147464037, 0.00958906952291727, -0.002191575476899743, -0.009466773830354214, 0.01988121308386326, -0.021494185552001, 0.019103556871414185, -0.029423819854855537, -0.043929215520620346, 0.02291126549243927, 0.02938671223819256, -0.0515303872525692, 0.03672623261809349, 0.05577218905091286, -0.05729858577251434, 0.01349659264087677, -0.028427956625819206, -0.036074914038181305, 0.03237096965312958, 0.016828017309308052, -0.0031586582772433758, -0.005309479311108589, 0.03314870223402977, -0.054989688098430634, -0.011984051205217838, -0.04124646261334419, 0.001975859282538295, 0.055464159697294235, 0.01745809055864811, 0.04325210303068161, 0.062028925865888596, -0.005743473768234253, 0.013331362046301365, -0.015355329029262066, -0.018228523433208466, 0.008350235410034657, -0.02863103523850441, 0.02303759567439556, -0.021297870203852654, 0.004648452624678612, 0.06733100861310959, 0.007011261768639088, 0.01626969873905182, 0.04364258795976639, -0.007961420342326164, -0.003543715924024582, 0.0215819850564003, 0.009580872021615505, -0.02016618102788925, 0.028185179457068443, -0.027022235095500946, -0.004490443971008062, -0.056545209139585495, -0.019680850207805634, 0.020555829629302025, 0.03444869816303253, 0.003034966764971614, -0.05917693302035332, -0.029552310705184937, -0.029735617339611053, -0.004385668784379959, 0.02659507654607296, -0.03709280863404274, 0.012047204189002514, -0.012545864097774029, 0.04060491919517517, -0.01602400839328766, 0.0456557534635067, -0.014409179799258709, -0.06314637511968613, -0.044100530445575714, -0.011429860256612301, -0.02686425670981407, 0.02766408957540989, -0.004232971463352442, -0.01854979246854782, -0.003925771452486515, -0.033957093954086304, -0.007936210371553898, 0.01868142932653427, 0.014953731559216976, -0.028389232233166695, 0.028046371415257454, 0.012575006112456322, 0.006935933604836464, -0.01618753932416439, -0.018030131235718727, 0.1398458182811737, 0.045189451426267624, 0.02073669247329235, -0.04797295853495598, 0.035623300820589066, 0.011209131218492985, -0.030893266201019287, -0.01209379080682993, -0.005560058634728193, 0.0016979544889181852, -0.01473539974540472, 0.06489718705415726, 0.03432527929544449, 0.03461822494864464, -0.035911738872528076, 0.044246867299079895, -0.02680114470422268, -0.0177441593259573, -0.03148389235138893, 0.015024165622889996, -0.0016739889979362488, -0.011949117295444012, -0.04536664858460426, -0.013806162402033806, 0.038448549807071686, -0.012038418091833591, -0.03979504853487015, -0.012765079736709595, -0.005790143273770809, -0.03142591565847397, -0.043967921286821365, 0.004942485596984625, 0.022737450897693634, -0.008165109902620316, -0.001511088921688497, -0.0015236816834658384, 0.021130435168743134, -0.06329022347927094, 0.02797560766339302, 0.016398528590798378, -0.0038207743782550097, 0.005049477331340313, 0.002861884655430913, 0.05702756717801094, -0.012188917957246304, -0.02012939192354679, -0.04109862074255943, 0.028091609477996826, -0.02050156332552433, -0.013034299947321415, 0.018766622990369797, -0.02257002517580986, -0.025699205696582794, -0.036469656974077225, -0.009892736561596394, 0.021320216357707977, -0.004177237395197153, 0.005089651793241501, 0.00484291510656476, -0.030979730188846588, -0.004807435441762209, -0.01988730952143669, 0.05286898463964462, 0.023969300091266632, -0.00519842142239213, -0.001728529343381524, -0.05559292808175087, 0.029081881046295166, 0.016708845272660255, -0.0010433288989588618, -0.027988405898213387, 0.01177249476313591, -0.044252168387174606, 0.002639868063852191, 0.00965575035661459, -0.008576459251344204, 0.07846817374229431, 0.014263167977333069, -0.024338478222489357, -0.06012812629342079, -0.030767235904932022, 0.028361951932311058, -0.026736842468380928, -0.017332889139652252, -0.0010636084480211139, -0.025757338851690292, 0.008709482848644257, 0.025547361001372337, 0.03148483857512474, 0.022885778918862343, -0.022699682042002678, 0.07478388398885727, 0.017055103555321693, -0.047404833137989044, -0.01222804095596075, -0.01257046777755022, -0.032185789197683334, -0.013179768808186054, 0.0313560776412487, 0.02367638424038887, -0.005787404719740152, 0.004370667971670628, 0.004378973972052336, -0.03163343295454979, -0.007030217442661524, 0.0021494682878255844, 0.013686328195035458, -0.026937032118439674, -0.028785835951566696, 0.028097212314605713, 0.007339194882661104, -0.03114277683198452, -0.005586476530879736, -0.056289587169885635, -0.04388813301920891, 0.03249821066856384, -0.036844491958618164, 0.013456330634653568, -0.018861431628465652, -0.019801262766122818, -0.02311602793633938, -0.002919323742389679, -0.009021756239235401, -0.02473004162311554, -0.011171744205057621, -0.018649376928806305, 0.02163822390139103, 0.032615140080451965, 0.04503096640110016, -0.006176230497658253, 0.03859294205904007, 0.03872237727046013, 0.021233059465885162, -0.03809136524796486, 0.015264486894011497, 0.023574404418468475, 0.006366575136780739, 0.00666586821898818, 0.020944735035300255, -0.012564988806843758, 0.052855268120765686, -0.03369537740945816, -0.05247458815574646, 0.020129460841417313, -0.01872333511710167, 0.026422826573252678, -0.012759367004036903, 0.011752927675843239, 0.009488733485341072, 0.029704289510846138, -0.03330027312040329, -0.02945849671959877, -0.014369496144354343, 0.01973172463476658, 0.02376437559723854, -0.011709538288414478, -0.0025824308395385742, 0.008370665833353996, -0.018921107053756714, 0.046759627759456635, 0.03329048305749893, -0.029393235221505165, -0.011184885166585445, -0.021642709150910378, -0.03645062819123268, -0.005899719428271055, 0.010494048707187176, -0.026574531570076942, 0.04279995337128639, 0.0657663345336914, -0.035740796476602554, 0.06995362043380737, -0.01002651546150446, -0.027506081387400627, -0.10195109993219376, -0.03540072217583656, 0.030165713280439377, -0.00465176859870553, 0.03812137618660927, -0.041582077741622925, -0.03172034025192261, 0.03652356192469597, -0.06009519100189209, 0.06003548949956894, -0.0011508753523230553, 0.02338666282594204, -0.04436399042606354, 0.04741501808166504, -0.02491779439151287, 0.025027355179190636, 0.0035046639386564493, 0.05124342814087868, 0.030172355473041534, 0.035359323024749756, 0.008195726200938225, -0.01319496426731348, -0.05484866723418236, -0.01569461077451706, 0.010270033031702042, -0.03699541836977005, 0.007100113667547703, -0.03381839022040367, -0.00040676104254089296, 0.03325032815337181, 0.0015183489304035902, 0.037732742726802826, 0.015948446467518806, 0.04230903089046478, 0.0184926837682724, 0.011954886838793755, 0.049077268689870834, -0.016322284936904907, -0.007097327150404453, 0.018606802448630333, 0.01875404827296734, 0.040377501398324966, -0.04732850193977356, 0.007946359924972057, -0.0023292051628232002, -0.020618630573153496, 0.034313783049583435, 0.02709946408867836, 0.01840754970908165, 0.004633104428648949, 0.014619695022702217, -0.005426378920674324, -0.010933727957308292, 0.02459915727376938, 0.024103591218590736, -0.042885322123765945, -0.0014345962554216385, 0.01227858942002058, 0.05850781127810478, -0.017030375078320503, 0.019976874813437462, -0.05520176514983177, 0.007055027410387993, -0.001122716348618269, 0.008179938420653343, 0.035529766231775284, -0.03377203270792961, -0.007271402981132269, -0.034583233296871185, 0.030866490676999092, -0.022239502519369125, -0.008603285066783428, -0.04641219228506088, 0.04977373406291008, -0.02428545616567135, 0.008590495213866234, 0.025561051443219185, 0.012164135463535786, 0.010572661645710468, -0.06209709867835045, 0.06350746005773544, 0.010648651979863644, 0.006142356898635626, -0.05626069754362106, 0.004054615274071693, -0.03079831413924694, 0.02581954188644886, 0.055024612694978714, 0.04107443615794182, 0.04155169054865837, 0.01465004961937666, -0.007429440040141344, -0.009660500101745129, -0.08061961829662323, 0.06106414273381233, -0.007323648314923048, 0.0218238215893507, 0.014975061640143394, 0.008843306452035904, 0.010084453970193863, -0.01147435698658228, -0.004287890624254942, -0.023434197530150414, 0.01389345247298479, 0.021307818591594696, -0.02680128812789917, 0.04472130909562111, 0.005211945157498121, -0.002694434951990843, 0.019712138921022415, -0.004948656540364027, 0.03080795891582966, 0.036367934197187424, -0.0003755119105335325, -0.054585736244916916, 0.030380183830857277, -0.03311976417899132, -0.03440240025520325, 0.013674306683242321, 0.04861007258296013, -0.029506493359804153, -0.030066106468439102, -0.0015648725675418973, 0.06052326038479805, -0.03518059104681015, -0.018643837422132492, 0.03292039409279823, 0.03921331837773323, 0.023970916867256165, -0.0011453876504674554, 0.007533578667789698, 0.0023475917987525463, -0.042942363768815994, 0.006936406251043081, -0.000014755886695638765, 0.033630289137363434, -0.0252156313508749, 0.00012481384328566492, 0.026337143033742905, 0.023456642404198647, 0.002597661456093192, -0.012538992799818516, 0.05774219334125519, -0.03973735123872757, -0.027083538472652435, 0.016528138890862465, 0.00298627489246428, 0.04946419596672058, 0.006615299731492996, 0.015399268828332424, 0.04615534469485283, -0.04380074515938759, -0.007778801955282688, 0.007572879549115896, -0.03707383945584297, -0.03224851191043854, 0.022993095219135284, 0.027457697317004204, -0.009275239892303944, -0.006920515093952417, -0.014180614612996578, -0.018559778109192848, -0.005251054652035236, 0.022480595856904984, 0.01408354565501213, 0.0373801663517952, 0.0029532238841056824, 0.004100337158888578, -0.015027259476482868, 0.008109659887850285, -0.028660019859671593, -0.03630785271525383, 0.005091278348118067, 0.020431365817785263, 0.0009285751730203629, -0.019956601783633232, 0.005500953644514084, -0.005927897058427334, 0.06049776077270508, -0.057369742542505264, -0.008710386231541634, -0.027217136695981026, 0.03903672471642494, 0.01614650897681713, -0.03213198482990265 ]
<p>In the definition of standard deviation, why do we have to <strong>square</strong> the difference from the mean to get the mean (E) and take the <strong>square root back</strong> at the end? Can't we just simply take <strong>the absolute value</strong> of the difference instead and get the expected value (mean) of those, and wouldn't that also show the variation of the data? The number is going to be different from square method (the absolute-value method will be smaller), but it should still show the spread of data. Anybody know why we take this square approach as a standard?</p> <p>The definition of standard deviation:</p> <p>$\sigma = \sqrt{E\left[\left(X - \mu\right)^2\right]}.$ </p> <p>Can't we just take the absolute value instead and still be a good measurement?</p> <p>$\sigma = E\left[|X - \mu|\right]$ </p>
49,295
[ -0.038418639451265335, 0.009849997237324715, 0.015305943787097931, -0.026426218450069427, 0.03057800605893135, 0.02539854869246483, -0.006005730479955673, -0.05588702857494354, -0.010230920277535915, -0.009715133346617222, 0.04653411731123924, 0.02268531359732151, 0.07348014414310455, 0.0007342987228184938, 0.0428345613181591, -0.001316729700192809, 0.0009281293605454266, -0.024959469214081764, -0.03653295338153839, -0.006595571991056204, -0.008024453185498714, 0.023336898535490036, -0.006237952969968319, 0.009097502566874027, -0.046878863126039505, 0.03785078227519989, 0.03070862405002117, 0.022922126576304436, 0.03749282285571098, 0.07624644041061401, -0.056968361139297485, -0.024372894316911697, 0.020803486928343773, 0.026485316455364227, 0.018222590908408165, -0.00963054969906807, -0.0011910086032003164, 0.013838758692145348, -0.011498909443616867, 0.044100768864154816, -0.024778589606285095, -0.01000174880027771, 0.001851312001235783, 0.01364952977746725, -0.023222049698233604, 0.031179072335362434, 0.004388783592730761, -0.06493087112903595, 0.030477577820420265, -0.036464616656303406, 0.05884282663464546, -0.025949643924832344, 0.044642988592386246, 0.04144342243671417, -0.01459276583045721, 0.029262010008096695, 0.07467722147703171, 0.024477969855070114, -0.024423759430646896, -0.0533519871532917, 0.024308886379003525, -0.0074045914225280285, 0.02676432393491268, -0.005139525514096022, -0.013498838059604168, 0.012503158301115036, 0.0034680748358368874, -0.015105929225683212, 0.04159216955304146, -0.02056080289185047, 0.008724860846996307, 0.04251258447766304, 0.004311802797019482, -0.02954312227666378, 0.016535265371203423, -0.02297891676425934, 0.002214160980656743, 0.009025086648762226, 0.03651893138885498, 0.046245306730270386, 0.02901838906109333, 0.0011020712554454803, 0.059332817792892456, 0.01558398362249136, -0.001352500868961215, -0.026615774258971214, 0.05971638113260269, -0.0064760237000882626, 0.00917618628591299, 0.021148085594177246, 0.028245609253644943, 0.004167098086327314, 0.04886319860816002, -0.029497098177671432, -0.015083791688084602, 0.04215779900550842, 0.00008706973312655464, 0.026181306689977646, 0.004904800094664097, -0.015881694853305817, 0.009298298507928848, -0.036292970180511475, 0.04095190390944481, 0.015742016956210136, -0.03671517223119736, -0.02945980243384838, -0.003589243395254016, 0.02730744704604149, 0.025110138580203056, -0.027747776359319687, -0.0012729829177260399, 0.006455731112509966, -0.004583704750984907, -0.006831700447946787, 0.027442501857876778, 0.008626018650829792, -0.0026678515132516623, -0.014675376005470753, 0.028423933312296867, 0.06685572117567062, 0.03282604739069939, -0.042287323623895645, 0.005132464691996574, -0.03365570679306984, -0.07661928236484528, 0.025221455842256546, 0.01864597387611866, -0.006816253997385502, -0.06945589184761047, 0.030255503952503204, -0.0005850103916600347, -0.0007262253202497959, 0.0339389331638813, -0.002169939922168851, 0.012698412872850895, 0.008668811991810799, -0.10723881423473358, -0.0740852952003479, 0.047346677631139755, -0.02561700902879238, -0.025144733488559723, -0.06494695693254471, 0.003873406909406185, 0.023506848141551018, 0.02833392843604088, 0.020321330055594444, 0.018093815073370934, -0.00568646052852273, 0.008995892480015755, 0.03159128502011299, -0.012812575325369835, -0.002386674517765641, -0.005840727128088474, -0.030298199504613876, 0.021772125735878944, -0.038243379443883896, 0.010831770487129688, 0.027610519900918007, -0.022073788568377495, -0.0328669399023056, 0.021930087357759476, 0.0067617157474160194, -0.007791964802891016, 0.019053267315030098, 0.01854783482849598, -0.00887017697095871, 0.06692091375589371, 0.030015114694833755, 0.007494915276765823, 0.021832169964909554, 0.0020479026716202497, 0.020970545709133148, 0.004817172419279814, 0.02888563647866249, 0.04247575253248215, -0.021221887320280075, -0.01978003978729248, -0.028634095564484596, 0.0063498783856630325, 0.03618945926427841, -0.07642775028944016, -0.003479975974187255, -0.015322577208280563, 0.019024254754185677, -0.010390147566795349, 0.0749187096953392, 0.0009110061218962073, 0.006180028431117535, 0.02819070965051651, -0.07469065487384796, -0.04174609109759331, -0.09962096065282822, 0.032098881900310516, 0.0028723233845084906, -0.03791496902704239, -0.001160946092568338, 0.01149776577949524, 0.027500780299305916, -0.04183831065893173, -0.01581001468002796, 0.019684942439198494, 0.026232261210680008, 0.03657927364110947, -0.04100016877055168, 0.02075216732919216, 0.07338269799947739, 0.04666272550821304, 0.014797179959714413, 0.022817349061369896, -0.01576591096818447, -0.061812739819288254, -0.0033056088723242283, -0.05609704181551933, 0.0008928939932957292, 0.002308270428329706, -0.051859237253665924, -0.020090246573090553, -0.016946125775575638, -0.018647130578756332, 0.03480919823050499, -0.03541881591081619, 0.06353339552879333, 0.03737543150782585, 0.0021311966702342033, 0.009812243282794952, 0.03254206106066704, 0.014085414819419384, 0.012276478111743927, -0.024926280602812767, -0.018211405724287033, -0.03386274352669716, 0.01400455366820097, 0.01734260469675064, 0.026632605120539665, -0.03907801955938339, 0.001905389130115509, 0.05911576375365257, 0.008051049895584583, 0.006714951246976852, 0.014903191477060318, 0.0008041649125516415, -0.048668939620256424, -0.019496534019708633, 0.007169518619775772, 0.0008588089258410037, 0.02846740372478962, -0.023229338228702545, 0.025506379082798958, 0.011284179985523224, 0.03087170235812664, 0.015444333665072918, 0.03196631744503975, -0.011731681413948536, 0.002369592897593975, 0.01819472573697567, -0.0026950028259307146, 0.016146771609783173, -0.023630395531654358, 0.0015896896366029978, 0.022046392783522606, -0.024533456191420555, 0.005778038874268532, -0.015585806220769882, -0.022605903446674347, -0.0034647707361727953, 0.014062360860407352, -0.003460775827988982, 0.017585642635822296, 0.01819276437163353, -0.03149066120386124, -0.002625838853418827, -0.044824279844760895, -0.015215757302939892, -0.026993244886398315, -0.010610053315758705, 0.025683842599391937, -0.0023243986070156097, 0.02738102339208126, -0.012481283396482468, -0.01895967870950699, -0.02172977663576603, -0.02346844971179962, 0.009017718024551868, -0.01321648433804512, -0.03124372661113739, -0.008699649944901466, -0.04482048749923706, -0.02953740954399109, 0.022090421989560127, -0.02244384214282036, -0.005133572965860367, 0.04133721441030502, 0.02655259147286415, -0.02186659723520279, -0.012431368231773376, -0.019516780972480774, 0.006151871755719185, 0.02211393602192402, -0.024643976241350174, 0.030692294239997864, -0.040485478937625885, -0.0049172937870025635, 0.05664212629199028, -0.07017664611339569, -0.05052541568875313, -0.06790272146463394, -0.0037305729929357767, 0.03284967690706253, -0.02067319117486477, 0.0020801641512662172, 0.04284203425049782, -0.04268566146492958, -0.006039164960384369, -0.04610299691557884, -0.020975865423679352, 0.00006649524584645405, -0.014055977575480938, 0.04167816787958145, 0.007860987447202206, -0.019304493442177773, 0.10369873046875, 0.04178817197680473, -0.027812521904706955, -0.0287809856235981, 0.015938812866806984, -0.03421541675925255, -0.04519731178879738, 0.0024558857548981905, 0.038232285529375076, -0.0015804595313966274, 0.014257892034947872, 0.014700526371598244, 0.026888052001595497, 0.01519103441387415, 0.0006042059394530952, -0.033995121717453, -0.02481928840279579, -0.020162248983979225, -0.017018500715494156, 0.03570711612701416, 0.0003863316378556192, -0.019152488559484482, 0.0043106828816235065, 0.02136680856347084, 0.04683396965265274, 0.008831886574625969, -0.02577842026948929, 0.05005247890949249, -0.019680848345160484, 0.009448052383959293, -0.05119059607386589, 0.049640312790870667, 0.02298244647681713, -0.02439410239458084, -0.004041727632284164, -0.02352103963494301, -0.0056889657862484455, -0.011506201699376106, -0.023870380595326424, 0.05493345111608505, 0.054214801639318466, -0.030645865947008133, -0.04313497990369797, 0.0013243915745988488, 0.0012471374357119203, 0.013172303326427937, -0.021497217938303947, -0.04692131653428078, 0.032019324600696564, 0.07569151371717453, 0.00035967829171568155, -0.03026307374238968, -0.03340528532862663, -0.02116432599723339, -0.06542432308197021, -0.011411386542022228, 0.0034736194647848606, 0.051148053258657455, -0.001506699831224978, 0.07562952488660812, 0.024723099544644356, -0.01372784934937954, 0.01237013190984726, -0.007350801955908537, -0.05792661011219025, 0.010897856205701828, -0.038058310747146606, -0.051542311906814575, -0.01423706952482462, -0.011818336322903633, 0.01844204217195511, -0.010506238788366318, 0.028381647542119026, -0.027405673637986183, 0.007574679329991341, -0.013290537521243095, -0.015176109969615936, 0.0033261089120060205, 0.0074936640448868275, -0.03359531983733177, 0.025597909465432167, 0.03138956055045128, -0.049291834235191345, 0.031192997470498085, 0.033802930265665054, -0.02860453352332115, -0.003710072720423341, -0.0329924076795578, 0.003936466295272112, 0.028580868616700172, 0.02867964282631874, 0.0336250476539135, 0.009794727899134159, -0.020920267328619957, 0.024800701066851616, 0.030194871127605438, 0.05989409238100052, 0.04014291986823082, -0.012252390384674072, -0.017684437334537506, -0.0337148979306221, -0.013158982619643211, -0.003753725439310074, 0.012555958703160286, -0.012528421357274055, 0.018918592482805252, 0.05262158811092377, 0.009376064874231815, -0.05634666979312897, 0.02448386885225773, 0.05519077181816101, -0.011694388464093208, 0.021159106865525246, -0.054039206355810165, -0.014057635329663754, -0.02169986441731453, -0.04390011727809906, 0.03401878848671913, 0.005725970957428217, -0.0011964539298787713, -0.030271679162979126, 0.0480772964656353, -0.015156696550548077, -0.04016822203993797, -0.011283953674137592, 0.030976032838225365, 0.01159198023378849, -0.015877513214945793, -0.008040414191782475, -0.006694943644106388, 0.04134238138794899, 0.040487032383680344, 0.005321177188307047, -0.002628232119604945, -0.0641838014125824, -0.005888347048312426, 0.01422737818211317, 0.039151377975940704, 0.007107319310307503, -0.0015031384536996484, -0.03536844253540039, -0.019365154206752777, 0.031721390783786774, -0.029054803773760796, 0.0255059152841568, -0.057620592415332794, 0.008589197881519794, -0.045505549758672714, -0.03959856182336807, -0.03929740935564041, 0.004185445141047239, 0.0032815237063914537, 0.03397028148174286, -0.009010153822600842, -0.01159705687314272, -0.04571502283215523, -0.019506102427840233, 0.0022602889221161604, 0.08527668565511703, -0.040925756096839905, -0.013815590180456638, 0.0011565377935767174, 0.0525963231921196, -0.01485136616975069, -0.09756118059158325, -0.017635753378272057, 0.0016288092592731118, -0.008872868493199348, 0.0309583880007267, 0.007745074108242989, -0.06280138343572617, 0.016245832666754723, 0.015203440561890602, -0.024986442178487778, 0.02256074734032154, -0.027091095224022865, 0.042570821940898895, 0.05747779458761215, 0.026836231350898743, 0.08719684183597565, 0.013883216306567192, -0.012557074427604675, 0.01878717914223671, -0.04329240694642067, 0.025787312537431717, -0.023865655064582825, -0.056926243007183075, -0.06170908734202385, -0.004144733306020498, -0.042115893214941025, 0.027369098737835884, 0.0054199350997805595, 0.038343846797943115, -0.03156657889485359, -0.010255776345729828, 0.01781800575554371, 0.028966013342142105, 0.017304174602031708, 0.007798632141202688, 0.010339216329157352, 0.016054237261414528, -0.0051274080760777, -0.021416526287794113, 0.016194123774766922, 0.003859699936583638, 0.0022800015285611153, 0.013831637799739838, -0.031223271042108536, 0.002653921954333782, -0.021305209025740623, -0.04820672795176506, 0.02475721947848797, -0.027731524780392647, 0.04132366552948952, -0.01561783254146576, 0.005213618744164705, 0.0024580173194408417, -0.052814628928899765, -0.0490274578332901, 0.007836735807359219, -0.013097618706524372, 0.01740015484392643, -0.06927558779716492, 0.0488768108189106, 0.0237736739218235, 0.004727305844426155, -0.11321740597486496, -0.04139586538076401, 0.008657081983983517, -0.020505134016275406, -0.013394107110798359, 0.0036604588385671377, -0.0008222082396969199, -0.01528257504105568, -0.03931302949786186, -0.049075476825237274, 0.02789798565208912, 0.013575172983109951, -0.017126059159636497, -0.013563059270381927, 0.03149145096540451, 0.06571149080991745, -0.020852526649832726, 0.004779616836458445, 0.0009954117704182863, -0.002150100888684392, -0.029699373990297318, 0.03178626671433449, 0.04669331759214401, -0.03768524155020714, -0.01320645771920681, -0.010746147483587265, -0.01924971304833889, 0.008027473464608192, -0.010754904709756374, -0.04955560714006424, 0.019381944090127945, 0.021466678008437157, 0.0007024843362160027, -0.00152549147605896, 0.03467701002955437, -0.0017608206253498793, 0.021923933178186417, 0.005862623918801546, -0.004896110855042934, -0.029518617317080498, -0.018118590116500854, 0.034935902804136276, 0.02851867862045765, -0.0008290726109407842, 0.029750121757388115, 0.05128037929534912, -0.021937383338809013, -0.005884182173758745, 0.0033254395239055157, 0.010439105331897736, 0.042866744101047516, 0.008469615131616592, -0.004889385774731636, 0.017762737348675728, 0.026988688856363297, -0.021749047562479973, -0.0031193061731755733, -0.011091186664998531, -0.0008883147384040058, 0.07552029192447662, 0.01091020368039608, 0.05166124179959297, 0.05102236941456795, -0.019419098272919655, 0.0006049751536920667, -0.040837809443473816, -0.020402580499649048, -0.024509437382221222, -0.015673082321882248, 0.05665815994143486, 0.00011408050340833142, 0.017625199630856514, 0.03836410120129585, 0.03740042448043823, 0.0035856999456882477, 0.02631109021604061, 0.0063019548542797565, 0.024141980335116386, -0.0027688653208315372, -0.014230063185095787, -0.06395438313484192, 0.02441483736038208, -0.042214445769786835, 0.03157765418291092, -0.02989412471652031, 0.00007255103992065415, 0.053477998822927475, -0.021347543224692345, -0.012411062605679035, -0.04226284474134445, -0.0031010243110358715, -0.07076326757669449, -0.03987784683704376, 0.029216060414910316, -0.013631407171487808, 0.012820727191865444, -0.0056482236832380295, 0.029764430597424507, -0.02981809340417385, 0.021782973781228065, -0.030459271743893623, -0.08249624073505402, -0.05430760607123375, -0.028694847598671913, -0.03573869913816452, 0.050744373351335526, -0.03918689861893654, -0.03487568348646164, 0.010245922021567822, -0.03893706202507019, 0.033282749354839325, 0.023488536477088928, 0.015018241479992867, -0.05423569679260254, 0.04801555722951889, -0.0017831233562901616, 0.0123926792293787, -0.007118079345673323, -0.00833289884030819, 0.09334640949964523, 0.07248710840940475, 0.03323143720626831, -0.02754504419863224, 0.025606799870729446, -0.025527717545628548, -0.002349532674998045, -0.003236835589632392, 0.01900300569832325, -0.014095951803028584, 0.04810149967670441, 0.03246873989701271, 0.06084733083844185, 0.05833059549331665, -0.039179302752017975, 0.023262329399585724, -0.026728706434369087, -0.04172968119382858, 0.008971503004431725, 0.025021729990839958, -0.023162715137004852, 0.041333552449941635, -0.016637742519378662, 0.01777384988963604, -0.012788195163011551, -0.01280044112354517, -0.006113175768405199, 0.007910550571978092, -0.006575168576091528, -0.011739041656255722, -0.03044869191944599, -0.0020137231331318617, 0.03129436448216438, -0.015661124140024185, -0.04237494617700577, -0.0029937406070530415, 0.013404306024312973, -0.04224104434251785, -0.011072258464992046, 0.0264267697930336, -0.00864142645150423, -0.029195377603173256, 0.002412780188024044, 0.024547366425395012, -0.051786184310913086, -0.031991537660360336, -0.04650304093956947, 0.05293824523687363, 0.0020555169321596622, -0.0027830402832478285, 0.019067371264100075, 0.010482866317033768, -0.03157578408718109, -0.05375698208808899, -0.0036086183972656727, 0.013082776218652725, 0.04444959759712219, -0.03313940018415451, -0.015881367027759552, -0.007326342165470123, 0.019358940422534943, -0.012824746780097485, -0.006418182514607906, 0.032934315502643585, -0.030094236135482788, -0.04564318060874939, -0.002082102233543992, -0.0007483361987397075, -0.022092048078775406, 0.0009727042634040117, -0.00386950490064919, 0.01343476865440607, -0.048081766813993454, 0.026733051985502243, 0.0238798838108778, 0.0179454255849123, 0.03897856920957565, -0.01735270954668522, 0.05027191713452339, -0.017961690202355385, -0.054288867861032486, 0.044824156910181046, -0.03764616325497627, 0.008206200785934925, -0.05230510234832764, 0.021911269053816795, 0.023707315325737, 0.026628030464053154, 0.017584821209311485, -0.0021913242526352406, 0.006209016777575016, 0.04732817783951759, 0.019901985302567482, -0.05302782356739044, -0.005429346114397049, 0.033073242753744125, -0.015657292678952217, -0.005562037695199251, 0.022271813824772835, 0.04453758895397186, 0.05221235379576683, 0.03508209064602852, -0.029436210170388222, 0.03388260304927826, 0.006816996727138758, -0.005108384881168604, 0.032481931149959564, -0.026831651106476784, -0.008453386835753918, 0.043819546699523926, 0.010583730414509773, -0.010109051130712032, -0.003688760567456484, -0.03249616548418999, -0.027748022228479385, -0.004095340147614479, 0.029727282002568245, -0.014723652973771095, 0.01702580600976944, -0.01332235150039196, 0.026514967903494835, -0.01970694400370121, -0.008312550373375416, -0.04176190868020058, 0.000871682190336287, -0.016929054632782936, -0.03465796634554863, -0.0051436941139400005, 0.01433225255459547, 0.008861000649631023, 0.002826529322192073, 0.03701453655958176, 0.028983624652028084, 0.036049190908670425, 0.001785445841960609, 0.002274624537676573, -0.010966412723064423, 0.0398755706846714, -0.014719108119606972, -0.010017517022788525, 0.05023975670337677, -0.055087123066186905, -0.03805847093462944, 0.031440455466508865, 0.016021057963371277, 0.01464929897338152, -0.0021428330801427364, 0.003162047127261758, 0.0037708370946347713, 0.010943803004920483, -0.03160274028778076, -0.021187078207731247, -0.024033905938267708, -0.026750003919005394, -0.023083483800292015, -0.040353111922740936, 0.04534449428319931, -0.0038013590965420008, -0.008779832161962986, 0.045924145728349686, 0.04832232743501663, -0.013280217535793781, 0.01068221963942051, 0.006211122497916222, -0.023513732478022575, 0.03067213110625744, 0.026403646916151047, 0.03181147575378418, 0.04750410094857216, 0.030758658424019814, -0.03763885423541069, 0.05786074325442314, -0.009640056639909744, -0.010366189293563366, -0.07883056253194809, -0.010952875018119812, 0.021903149783611298, 0.026490306481719017, 0.03618379682302475, -0.0661303773522377, 0.006020684726536274, 0.06384243816137314, -0.06091422960162163, -0.0055365064181387424, -0.03155761957168579, -0.015208020806312561, 0.013148829340934753, -0.0015417274553328753, -0.011473988182842731, 0.04327025264501572, 0.022534264251589775, 0.02517618052661419, 0.03632127866148949, 0.019575119018554688, 0.017704956233501434, -0.017939161509275436, -0.03561630845069885, 0.027668209746479988, 0.016159001737833023, -0.04412197321653366, 0.012979242950677872, -0.022147351875901222, 0.003644615411758423, 0.044868748635053635, 0.009022899903357029, 0.025954602286219597, 0.009646827355027199, 0.010717982426285744, 0.0136379050090909, 0.018399745225906372, 0.007280271966010332, -0.014825385063886642, -0.019964812323451042, -0.013571811839938164, 0.02081964537501335, 0.03244643285870552, 0.03786366805434227, 0.0003417759435251355, 0.017871111631393433, -0.0226927287876606, -0.030566755682229996, 0.00023588453768752515, -0.012405474670231342, -0.034058794379234314, 0.015932854264974594, 0.02008013240993023, 0.01798137091100216, -0.06377283483743668, 0.039322249591350555, -0.0130242258310318, 0.01057508960366249, 0.04047216847538948, 0.01749933697283268, -0.028524506837129593, 0.013734245672821999, 0.011916662566363811, -0.04060071334242821, 0.02208639495074749, 0.022024005651474, -0.008292192593216896, -0.05704181268811226, -0.023062817752361298, 0.0034787096083164215, -0.03220652416348457, 0.015784870833158493, 0.003967392258346081, -0.034300900995731354, 0.013276271522045135, -0.0190811175853014, 0.015863990411162376, -0.01946963742375374, -0.01731918565928936, -0.007590280380100012, -0.10284914076328278, 0.054994452744722366, 0.02223077602684498, 0.005073679145425558, -0.036857377737760544, 0.019123101606965065, -0.05105261132121086, 0.013645071536302567, 0.06212713196873665, 0.043704744428396225, 0.0021299307700246572, 0.006416367832571268, 0.048558276146650314, 0.020667975768446922, -0.04442936182022095, 0.029634058475494385, -0.021479947492480278, -0.017544018104672432, -0.01802726276218891, -0.011295652016997337, 0.0192327331751585, 0.011501502245664597, 0.016580769792199135, -0.04267390817403793, 0.028487572446465492, 0.008302782662212849, 0.015296603552997112, 0.0400410033762455, 0.027075795456767082, -0.0742182582616806, 0.045633114874362946, -0.024533679708838463, 0.01791290193796158, 0.050309062004089355, -0.006741210352629423, -0.02817624621093273, 0.00308198481798172, -0.017973169684410095, -0.03089270368218422, -0.005388821009546518, 0.02078050747513771, 0.02429414913058281, -0.06410060822963715, -0.02995554730296135, 0.04999076947569847, -0.07526874542236328, -0.0027003467548638582, 0.05602031201124191, 0.05094661936163902, 0.019354337826371193, 0.01512555405497551, -0.016191143542528152, -0.006269446574151516, -0.02286163717508316, 0.014823954552412033, 0.01023553591221571, 0.025798970833420753, -0.002201232360675931, 0.026365233585238457, 0.023506084457039833, -0.01561625674366951, 0.019617874175310135, -0.008919247426092625, 0.07467355579137802, -0.014917171560227871, -0.009340241551399231, -0.006103935651481152, 0.003663151292130351, 0.023214558139443398, -0.00014126351743470877, -0.04045022279024124, 0.07971803098917007, -0.02186465635895729, -0.009411169216036797, -0.0019404609920457006, -0.03018902987241745, -0.026745526120066643, -0.016832765191793442, 0.025868050754070282, 0.05538325011730194, 0.015398593619465828, -0.009419502690434456, -0.011211073957383633, 0.026429492980241776, 0.028012733906507492, -0.025298867374658585, 0.020063355565071106, 0.0025223155971616507, -0.021628886461257935, -0.05903737619519234, -0.008889678865671158, -0.007221982814371586, 0.0018571354448795319, 0.02521994337439537, 0.044517699629068375, 0.0574558824300766, 0.012865237891674042, -0.0391518771648407, 0.0023557632230222225, 0.03804345056414604, -0.05363049358129501, -0.015918010845780373, -0.046070948243141174, -0.0028657803777605295, -0.01192641444504261, -0.019668813794851303 ]
<p>In logistic regression, if we considered residuals, could they only take on the values $0$ or $1$? The data points themselves take on only $1$ or $0$. The logistic curve can take on any value between $0$ and $1$. What would the distribution of the residuals look like?</p>
74,457
[ -0.009764311835169792, 0.023779647424817085, -0.011900878511369228, 0.0008834874024614692, 0.035811301320791245, -0.0022907734382897615, -0.04315827041864395, 0.01996791921555996, 0.008300415240228176, -0.04291238263249397, 0.025938494130969048, 0.015798019245266914, 0.039995718747377396, 0.007379703223705292, 0.04056968912482262, 0.006287934258580208, -0.004405048210173845, 0.006767135113477707, 0.0015382549026980996, 0.015339329838752747, 0.02064627595245838, 0.008577719330787659, 0.057416707277297974, 0.016104085370898247, -0.0409940704703331, 0.02924453839659691, 0.04454111307859421, 0.013908805325627327, 0.010198451578617096, 0.07457758486270905, -0.02124929428100586, -0.0068681929260492325, -0.005643363576382399, 0.053329095244407654, 0.009276927448809147, -0.006706639192998409, -0.03613615781068802, -0.012839125469326973, -0.00009748263255460188, 0.028136374428868294, -0.017479535192251205, -0.038205262273550034, 0.014258299022912979, 0.01991293951869011, -0.006769994739443064, -0.01857481338083744, 0.003580660093575716, -0.055670056492090225, 0.043696824461221695, -0.034452345222234726, 0.04866999387741089, -0.0035487764980643988, 0.02940378151834011, 0.04312771558761597, 0.005581161007285118, -0.001221514423377812, 0.048185184597969055, 0.04856094345450401, -0.019211359322071075, -0.0735563412308693, -0.0321095772087574, -0.0018784034764394164, 0.0033903492148965597, -0.013143069110810757, -0.02961803786456585, 0.03427385538816452, -0.016173070296645164, -0.04548489302396774, 0.03789466619491577, 0.00994613952934742, 0.0060768150724470615, 0.040513020008802414, 0.016653213649988174, -0.002750920131802559, 0.01843903958797455, -0.0058733695186674595, 0.019256990402936935, -0.026211148127913475, 0.03381730988621712, 0.05209852010011673, 0.010895539075136185, -0.007425581105053425, 0.05640639737248421, 0.03208720311522484, -0.010386546142399311, -0.004651830997318029, 0.05942048504948616, -0.011054612696170807, 0.05555328354239464, 0.02112232893705368, -0.009653124026954174, -0.002671446418389678, 0.0153220659121871, -0.007834671065211296, -0.03861958906054497, 0.02282014861702919, -0.023095574229955673, 0.024251990020275116, 0.041711241006851196, 0.002672264352440834, 0.014933070167899132, -0.03196084499359131, 0.025174494832754135, 0.051412180066108704, -0.032442979514598846, -0.008685407228767872, -0.0022167060524225235, 0.012751942500472069, -0.0021359105594456196, -0.04362406209111214, -0.01625266671180725, 0.008151466958224773, 0.04156407713890076, -0.0021821295376867056, 0.054489828646183014, 0.0037168217822909355, 0.0032007864210754633, -0.0641179233789444, 0.0534677654504776, 0.028287814930081367, 0.044034793972969055, -0.03228721767663956, 0.016525080427527428, 0.021310308948159218, -0.04080914705991745, -0.00188853545114398, 0.008898360654711723, 0.008043291047215462, -0.03854803740978241, 0.027694182470440865, -0.03358839079737663, -0.041646890342235565, 0.054418716579675674, 0.021645253524184227, 0.04389440640807152, 0.012834377586841583, -0.04651395604014397, -0.04090356081724167, -0.006587682291865349, -0.023686449974775314, 0.024598801508545876, -0.020949598401784897, -0.04292714223265648, 0.033170901238918304, 0.009966220706701279, 0.0016137143829837441, 0.0146492263302207, -0.007864844053983688, 0.01749270223081112, 0.008001674897968769, 0.006620520260185003, 0.019107503816485405, -0.018323859199881554, -0.06266368180513382, -0.027003150433301926, -0.08467984944581985, 0.027003029361367226, 0.04094032198190689, -0.0033293007872998714, -0.04306793212890625, -0.007782512344419956, -0.03240685909986496, 0.03304888680577278, 0.009576315060257912, -0.014698468148708344, 0.0018665126990526915, 0.0794827938079834, -0.0030446555465459824, 0.03281417489051819, 0.05286303907632828, 0.01348051056265831, 0.014218772761523724, 0.025568215176463127, 0.06688046455383301, 0.04713492840528488, -0.02805963344871998, -0.020541992038488388, -0.023397957906126976, 0.05049167945981026, 0.025590552017092705, -0.0574311800301075, 0.005116740707308054, -0.0006418456323444843, -0.009586532600224018, -0.0028995785396546125, 0.04847388342022896, -0.025567149743437767, -0.024850036948919296, 0.0073464964516460896, -0.03399646654725075, -0.013505935668945312, -0.026143798604607582, 0.037920236587524414, -0.00014669472875539213, 0.003294619731605053, 0.017820464447140694, 0.0373007170855999, 0.007442548405379057, -0.03105171211063862, 0.004784190561622381, -0.029012832790613174, -0.027952296659350395, 0.010555445216596127, -0.06032879650592804, -0.006083156447857618, 0.036944277584552765, 0.03899267688393593, 0.017361335456371307, 0.0585797093808651, -0.042951371520757675, -0.05402171239256859, 0.012620012275874615, -0.0214881282299757, 0.02495444379746914, -0.03777501732110977, -0.010973255150020123, 0.012054337188601494, 0.007125969510525465, -0.01732856035232544, 0.023900672793388367, -0.06246408075094223, 0.04803105443716049, 0.07581546157598495, 0.0036288760602474213, -0.030253814533352852, -0.03830660879611969, -0.009739351458847523, -0.011406626552343369, -0.015792399644851685, -0.030546799302101135, -0.04801945760846138, -0.0026341844350099564, 0.02894667722284794, 0.03207099437713623, -0.021152501925826073, 0.0033634030260145664, 0.06555323302745819, 0.017424795776605606, 0.029566356912255287, -0.011137346737086773, -0.018923528492450714, -0.0019591841846704483, 0.005526550114154816, 0.031844545155763626, 0.025282898917794228, -0.011201130226254463, 0.036458879709243774, -0.0024518659338355064, 0.03520704805850983, 0.035233642905950546, -0.008192211389541626, 0.02582613192498684, -0.021810131147503853, -0.02768031880259514, -0.030483076348900795, 0.002422966994345188, 0.041893914341926575, -0.009477713145315647, 0.010621787048876286, 0.027845390141010284, 0.03800472989678383, -0.036678947508335114, 0.00820939615368843, 0.00044298978173173964, 0.031120169907808304, 0.05229461193084717, -0.02992272563278675, -0.03183148428797722, 0.024838630110025406, -0.033939823508262634, 0.01588006317615509, -0.057459283620119095, -0.03984633833169937, -0.031176965683698654, 0.020191000774502754, 0.024437304586172104, 0.020063970237970352, 0.005695037543773651, -0.03577163442969322, -0.04526252672076225, 0.003367822151631117, -0.017903786152601242, 0.026372529566287994, 0.029949121177196503, -0.06945370137691498, -0.013935081660747528, -0.0378766804933548, -0.03433799743652344, 0.044491879642009735, -0.01969084143638611, 0.00857565924525261, 0.013532701879739761, -0.057011671364307404, -0.058863379061222076, -0.02202102355659008, -0.05243462324142456, 0.0007633372442796826, -0.035550475120544434, -0.014070309698581696, 0.011977896094322205, -0.0056722830049693584, -0.027067266404628754, 0.01688239723443985, -0.047049038112163544, -0.035357505083084106, -0.03262942656874657, -0.005031029228121042, 0.03066170960664749, -0.009431709535419941, 0.03275744244456291, 0.0189460888504982, -0.043715186417102814, -0.005221970845013857, -0.07749560475349426, -0.07237508893013, 0.03159352019429207, -0.03738846257328987, 0.0016023835632950068, -0.01989687979221344, -0.03401399776339531, 0.076846644282341, 0.040919139981269836, 0.009124328382313251, -0.0020909435115754604, 0.004649719689041376, -0.013494506478309631, -0.020003240555524826, -0.012585383839905262, -0.018587563186883926, 0.03940150514245033, 0.05544856935739517, -0.033571600914001465, 0.04421118274331093, 0.043217528611421585, 0.03643209487199783, -0.020566783845424652, 0.031803056597709656, -0.0003750924370251596, -0.005646167788654566, 0.005536632612347603, 0.047736480832099915, -0.024206461384892464, 0.04468872398138046, 0.0250258706510067, 0.07816839218139648, -0.008866921067237854, -0.04907761141657829, 0.044046591967344284, -0.004352967254817486, 0.0112296799197793, 0.008235747925937176, 0.011094841174781322, 0.02026556432247162, 0.008512292988598347, -0.010524527169764042, 0.007912076078355312, 0.02792549878358841, -0.025755353271961212, 0.02428746223449707, 0.016303280368447304, 0.04185899719595909, -0.025499768555164337, -0.029267894104123116, 0.015271522104740143, 0.014727184548974037, 0.035960182547569275, -0.0010633068159222603, -0.015433124266564846, 0.04349726438522339, 0.0067261019721627235, 0.0035947246942669153, -0.023469559848308563, -0.03426660597324371, 0.026800433173775673, -0.043865934014320374, -0.022049354389309883, 0.03823292255401611, 0.03928637132048607, -0.009398331865668297, 0.014534457586705685, 0.0038337355945259333, 0.0029985408764332533, -0.022792037576436996, 0.05221274867653847, -0.07820820808410645, 0.013646615669131279, -0.042778000235557556, -0.02338646724820137, -0.016156485304236412, -0.03268984332680702, 0.038318898528814316, -0.05412852764129639, 0.01691977120935917, -0.009958743117749691, -0.004391889087855816, -0.01969577930867672, -0.012580920942127705, 0.0016758051933720708, -0.02242751605808735, -0.024875186383724213, 0.00592521158978343, -0.02321188896894455, -0.008432636968791485, 0.020920436829328537, 0.056726936250925064, 0.021007897332310677, 0.00533082103356719, -0.030320540070533752, 0.025890909135341644, 0.02421022392809391, 0.046171486377716064, 0.06847278773784637, 0.014752445742487907, -0.0412755012512207, 0.024782991036772728, -0.01674490235745907, 0.07990280538797379, 0.03827352449297905, -0.00963098369538784, -0.003982746507972479, -0.023625710979104042, -0.03673471882939339, 0.0016339337453246117, 0.018160896375775337, -0.027610309422016144, -0.028574440628290176, 0.037550486624240875, 0.028988540172576904, -0.045640572905540466, 0.01457675639539957, 0.07305464893579483, 0.016167499125003815, -0.0343528687953949, -0.017255667597055435, -0.0011309884721413255, 0.006801609881222248, 0.007978996261954308, 0.006699581164866686, 0.011804917827248573, -0.013526437804102898, -0.005329594016075134, 0.03319517895579338, 0.014252048917114735, -0.036188092082738876, -0.02807663381099701, 0.01738981157541275, 0.055913519114255905, 0.021629713475704193, -0.053739868104457855, 0.03206770122051239, 0.03441416472196579, 0.013348092325031757, 0.0368623360991478, 0.005184591747820377, -0.08476077020168304, 0.01411497313529253, 0.009898878633975983, 0.004182326141744852, -0.027485808357596397, 0.021993957459926605, -0.02278893254697323, -0.0012345965951681137, 0.05929851531982422, -0.02531459368765354, -0.016203109174966812, -0.003024943172931671, 0.033421117812395096, 0.012272315099835396, -0.01898256316781044, -0.06726109236478806, 0.026599520817399025, -0.019989294931292534, -0.003932285122573376, -0.02397184818983078, -0.0037623022217303514, -0.047887738794088364, 0.029462937265634537, -0.00001333497857558541, 0.061633072793483734, -0.010248205624520779, 0.015500172972679138, -0.015562973916530609, 0.042841050773859024, 0.031401704996824265, -0.07676421850919724, 0.015127113088965416, 0.021860843524336815, 0.0024336762726306915, 0.0628298819065094, 0.012520132586359978, -0.06199784204363823, 0.03934851288795471, 0.013446692377328873, 0.002751047955825925, 0.030500145629048347, -0.04804028570652008, 0.003029953222721815, 0.0002948030305560678, 0.00258140848018229, 0.03842074051499367, 0.05541367828845978, 0.012982097454369068, -0.046535674482584, -0.044006917625665665, 0.036786552518606186, -0.0199847761541605, -0.03946483135223389, -0.006810345686972141, -0.00043505290523171425, -0.0048283119685947895, 0.011083544231951237, 0.01927516795694828, 0.008078599348664284, 0.006235617678612471, -0.05063004046678543, -0.019812796264886856, 0.008977917954325676, 0.02573896013200283, 0.04078894108533859, -0.010961953550577164, 0.0185315553098917, -0.04049111157655716, -0.013206294737756252, 0.021443452686071396, -0.014805958606302738, 0.021869534626603127, 0.0215307530015707, -0.03859016299247742, 0.0017392795998603106, -0.0383201502263546, -0.0033214492723345757, -0.0024812922347337008, -0.03367947041988373, 0.041561972349882126, 0.003334467066451907, 0.018456991761922836, -0.018176017329096794, -0.05332985520362854, -0.002005324000492692, -0.00024676090106368065, 0.005638406611979008, 0.06120864674448967, -0.044083695858716965, 0.01929365284740925, -0.003580329939723015, -0.013097668066620827, -0.1018318384885788, -0.023234898224473, 0.006204098928719759, 0.020441368222236633, -0.024681128561496735, 0.0007516637560911477, -0.006275302730500698, -0.011419768445193768, -0.03040078841149807, -0.0037831957451999187, 0.09312175959348679, -0.02327629365026951, -0.02050914615392685, -0.018109120428562164, 0.00018734253535512835, 0.05746541917324066, -0.004416649229824543, -0.04046258702874184, 0.007039711810648441, -0.054144542664289474, 0.005498779471963644, 0.003359589958563447, 0.04678064212203026, -0.01750830002129078, -0.018762867897748947, -0.04300358146429062, -0.027532517910003662, 0.03953179717063904, -0.027380432933568954, -0.025151195004582405, 0.0003785514272749424, -0.0006555092986673117, 0.015225965529680252, 0.0005745549569837749, -0.01156536489725113, -0.008394293487071991, -0.011207100935280323, 0.009398392401635647, -0.025318745523691177, -0.011642402037978172, 0.012169887311756611, 0.03221232816576958, 0.014865434728562832, -0.012880193069577217, 0.02803579531610012, 0.08049538731575012, 0.017128409817814827, -0.046855803579092026, -0.03872878476977348, -0.010654646903276443, 0.058144036680459976, 0.01662430912256241, -0.01729673333466053, 0.021463854238390923, 0.032634712755680084, -0.02042209543287754, -0.004597566090524197, -0.054098498076200485, -0.02131354995071888, 0.05793393775820732, -0.015589268878102303, 0.019266808405518532, 0.03759872168302536, 0.01757301203906536, 0.018940452486276627, -0.039421677589416504, -0.0007263607112690806, 0.0026691800449043512, -0.00962111260741949, 0.04952703416347504, -0.02667994610965252, -0.004477370530366898, 0.019014902412891388, 0.008256328292191029, 0.005327163264155388, 0.027390077710151672, -0.00948699563741684, -0.0009029266075231135, 0.043241459876298904, 0.01490255631506443, -0.033725250512361526, 0.010880050249397755, -0.046844206750392914, 0.009884532541036606, -0.0013852014672011137, -0.02595195174217224, 0.05905238911509514, -0.0032961415126919746, 0.03275589644908905, -0.03667772561311722, -0.0500054731965065, -0.04780105873942375, 0.03015303984284401, 0.0022962037473917007, 0.025058912113308907, 0.023157767951488495, -0.02998526766896248, -0.00302331056445837, -0.0255222637206316, 0.012068181298673153, -0.002020364161580801, -0.07210961729288101, -0.04115079343318939, 0.004478998016566038, -0.01170728262513876, 0.023866815492510796, 0.0223130751401186, -0.025891980156302452, 0.01815364509820938, -0.06068184971809387, 0.0382392480969429, 0.05286899581551552, 0.0419083796441555, 0.015352481044828892, 0.0873013362288475, 0.017462054267525673, 0.01878599263727665, -0.021427789703011513, -0.011564134620130062, 0.12352191656827927, 0.08776181936264038, 0.021730512380599976, -0.0873299092054367, 0.007009576540440321, 0.0026505030691623688, -0.022402862086892128, -0.009726932272315025, -0.0004545772389974445, 0.021414995193481445, 0.007525619585067034, 0.04526850953698158, 0.04353553056716919, -0.009861861355602741, -0.002496554981917143, 0.06236598640680313, -0.036005668342113495, -0.01586560532450676, -0.034602828323841095, 0.0328228697180748, 0.011804375797510147, 0.01900271326303482, -0.05386970192193985, 0.006018832325935364, 0.02418026328086853, -0.01568763144314289, -0.023912249132990837, -0.0186935942620039, -0.0021687813568860292, -0.028050774708390236, -0.04045853018760681, -0.038603074848651886, 0.035469189286231995, -0.0020833625458180904, -0.03434043750166893, -0.03026830404996872, 0.007727465126663446, -0.035859741270542145, -0.0014802186051383615, 0.050595417618751526, 0.00760418176651001, 0.018395304679870605, 0.032401032745838165, -0.020290590822696686, -0.028918882831931114, -0.02796306647360325, -0.044505175203084946, 0.04751336947083473, -0.020025238394737244, 0.012243795208632946, -0.026327069848775864, -0.019869385287165642, -0.01286123413592577, -0.05377328023314476, -0.01207043044269085, 0.03325812518596649, 0.007504789158701897, -0.000010989189831889234, -0.005956409964710474, -0.025847358629107475, 0.028997447341680527, 0.00902774278074503, 0.02578962966799736, 0.021463939920067787, -0.06276848912239075, -0.013629253953695297, -0.02600957453250885, 0.06915899366140366, -0.01910495199263096, 0.0032738621812313795, 0.027048110961914062, -0.017893312498927116, -0.02425137534737587, 0.029993759468197823, 0.0054663666523993015, -0.0060676150023937225, 0.04169858992099762, -0.006204495206475258, -0.006892629899084568, -0.014720484614372253, -0.05799175426363945, 0.036208149045705795, -0.037126731127500534, 0.01647796295583248, -0.02348601073026657, -0.0308783371001482, 0.029064176604151726, 0.039827004075050354, 0.004575422033667564, -0.011158697307109833, -0.016701260581612587, 0.04806768521666527, -0.030926315113902092, -0.047646503895521164, -0.018467843532562256, 0.02454845979809761, -0.04600206017494202, 0.002367866924032569, -0.01825767196714878, 0.06256809830665588, 0.0241569634526968, 0.027396181598305702, -0.025354091078042984, 0.03697334975004196, 0.0072331964038312435, -0.0029838411137461662, 0.01325174979865551, -0.06148011237382889, -0.004370768088847399, 0.032821349799633026, -0.008319875225424767, -0.0058033703826367855, -0.04349619895219803, -0.02683844417333603, -0.035770196467638016, -0.0017609181813895702, 0.023943105712532997, 0.004640440922230482, -0.0014660208253189921, -0.015495508909225464, -0.007968218997120857, -0.021589061245322227, -0.017707467079162598, -0.03561780974268913, -0.008887505158782005, 0.023856977000832558, -0.03126554563641548, -0.00471772626042366, 0.009679007343947887, 0.014937406405806541, -0.00671803392469883, 0.04927007108926773, 0.030875489115715027, 0.036961618810892105, -0.00476369634270668, 0.015779461711645126, 0.011474698781967163, 0.018464345484972, -0.04066287353634834, -0.00505734421312809, 0.0373295322060585, -0.013415632769465446, -0.014863005839288235, 0.040374159812927246, 0.0040308027528226376, 0.026392461732029915, 0.022308005020022392, 0.036960408091545105, -0.04019659385085106, 0.041952744126319885, -0.002006703522056341, 0.011529969051480293, 0.00029072538018226624, 0.020427482202649117, -0.024749238044023514, 0.007373352535068989, 0.004401629325002432, 0.012464502826333046, -0.026610534638166428, -0.02139013446867466, 0.04806304723024368, -0.004885056987404823, -0.01482277549803257, 0.037176959216594696, -0.007698918227106333, 0.029867613688111305, 0.025762496516108513, -0.015588662587106228, -0.0003590000269468874, 0.06255646795034409, -0.03528505191206932, 0.053192950785160065, 0.013201268389821053, 0.023465067148208618, -0.11006204038858414, -0.0398741140961647, 0.029478317126631737, 0.010058586485683918, 0.00854563619941473, -0.01419115625321865, -0.01947161555290222, 0.047580622136592865, -0.046623971313238144, -0.006218388210982084, -0.0027359467931091785, -0.041554756462574005, -0.03622163459658623, -0.012112804688513279, -0.02568037435412407, 0.044329334050416946, 0.036580123007297516, 0.03714922070503235, 0.018693452700972557, 0.007084688637405634, -0.02111889235675335, -0.012565076351165771, -0.00015748426085337996, 0.025300119072198868, -0.013742885552346706, -0.03873017430305481, 0.03229254484176636, -0.06583858281373978, -0.0063752890564501286, 0.01293205190449953, 0.010687840171158314, -0.007581237703561783, 0.03214164078235626, 0.007866724394261837, 0.011279516853392124, 0.031157061457633972, 0.03253069147467613, 0.006093994248658419, -0.02023572102189064, 0.028600327670574188, 0.0191778764128685, 0.011024247854948044, -0.05552221089601517, 0.027825450524687767, 0.023848600685596466, -0.028485512360930443, -0.05561865493655205, 0.02232302539050579, -0.0007049234700389206, -0.05027346312999725, -0.002431797329336405, -0.005113527178764343, -0.00883354339748621, -0.04761480540037155, 0.026662161573767662, -0.08469639718532562, 0.016769981011748314, 0.03848345950245857, 0.016137467697262764, -0.036943595856428146, 0.015288055874407291, -0.029574338346719742, -0.021402422338724136, -0.008709901943802834, -0.006834548898041248, -0.025786271318793297, -0.06847713142633438, 0.028843455016613007, -0.0187673456966877, -0.02625669352710247, -0.030186887830495834, -0.01706153154373169, -0.023133618757128716, 0.016588399186730385, -0.0208674818277359, 0.001876122667454183, 0.057192251086235046, -0.04331629350781441, -0.010587227530777454, -0.10755553841590881, 0.07441791892051697, 0.013193953782320023, -0.014926071278750896, -0.03821149840950966, -0.008955593220889568, -0.04825714975595474, 0.00011496579099912196, 0.03168939799070358, 0.01609548181295395, 0.006153172347694635, -0.001629057340323925, 0.03765767812728882, 0.005727133713662624, -0.02164279669523239, 0.027655422687530518, -0.01049495954066515, -0.03943267837166786, -0.042875707149505615, 0.02679561637341976, -0.009823010303080082, 0.007822640240192413, 0.023608744144439697, -0.011253908276557922, -0.0161924846470356, -0.04302844777703285, -0.013303084298968315, 0.04769246652722359, -0.00830890517681837, 0.002338977064937353, 0.042073141783475876, -0.010066129267215729, 0.018513847142457962, 0.03300689533352852, 0.003956598229706287, -0.08494949340820312, 0.011820944957435131, -0.017990950495004654, -0.02682790346443653, -0.01094675250351429, 0.02555239386856556, -0.002339676022529602, -0.031209878623485565, 0.013496944680809975, 0.012635023333132267, 0.009489013813436031, 0.016714589670300484, -0.015873568132519722, 0.01718497835099697, 0.038598235696554184, -0.0021288718562573195, -0.027704307809472084, 0.019032055512070656, -0.019434738904237747, 0.025289511308073997, 0.03945581987500191, 0.007373911794275045, -0.012566085904836655, 0.008362093940377235, -0.010644284076988697, 0.014250241219997406, 0.022403212264180183, 0.019275538623332977, 0.042931005358695984, -0.02908853441476822, -0.0006757953087799251, 0.004748865962028503, -0.002250187797471881, 0.007955197244882584, -0.021720413118600845, 0.02448876202106476, 0.03627593815326691, -0.017763027921319008, 0.023119553923606873, -0.05464000627398491, -0.031234117224812508, -0.004851208999752998, 0.004009794443845749, 0.04224547743797302, 0.03662031516432762, -0.02337106317281723, -0.02457680180668831, 0.019284751266241074, 0.020450102165341377, 0.018327288329601288, -0.033025432378053665, 0.025758694857358932, 0.016467386856675148, -0.002774252323433757, -0.02682405710220337, -0.021708760410547256, -0.02554870769381523, -0.042999379336833954, 0.020534249022603035, 0.04042334109544754, 0.029000669717788696, -0.009655185975134373, -0.00920808408409357, -0.02649741992354393, 0.05493558198213577, -0.035031311213970184, -0.02410569041967392, -0.022243378683924675, 0.029473252594470978, 0.012066374532878399, -0.04720272496342659 ]
<p>I hope that this is a right place and way to ask this question. I am trying to understand how to derive the probability density function of x(t) in an AR model of order K given (t-k) past observations.<br> I am primarily referring to this <a href="http://reference.kfupm.edu.sa/content/u/n/a_unifying_framework_for_detecting_outli_70701.pdf" rel="nofollow">paper</a> (Section 2.2) but it cites a Japanese book for this derivation. I could not find similar derivation in the other time series books(Shumway and stoffer, Pourahmadi). Can someone please provide me appropriate references or explain it. </p> <p>Thanks for your time. iinception</p>
74,458
[ 0.002818673849105835, -0.047092076390981674, 0.057840678840875626, -0.02078753523528576, 0.03279067203402519, -0.02690795436501503, -0.013648462481796741, 0.035947952419519424, 0.030158784240484238, -0.05554192513227463, 0.010863098315894604, 0.030115481466054916, 0.06570037454366684, 0.02755912020802498, 0.031495142728090286, 0.00558897852897644, -0.04049227386713028, 0.01126244105398655, 0.003198978491127491, -0.057803601026535034, 0.024414002895355225, 0.016261445358395576, -0.006404954474419355, -0.024236418306827545, -0.0430845208466053, 0.029658449813723564, 0.004063927568495274, 0.020556053146719933, 0.04419955611228943, 0.07703589648008347, -0.04319026693701744, -0.009263360872864723, -0.018107308074831963, 0.036672722548246384, 0.027804264798760414, 0.0272526778280735, -0.022551650181412697, -0.02053694613277912, 0.004144427832216024, 0.04874490574002266, -0.022359035909175873, -0.025942198932170868, 0.013460652902722359, 0.044222380965948105, -0.03313999995589256, 0.006702672690153122, 0.007912683300673962, -0.026069387793540955, 0.05376491695642471, -0.0450887605547905, 0.08098290860652924, -0.03717583790421486, 0.02839643880724907, 0.0194875355809927, -0.013959567993879318, 0.024791382253170013, 0.047676071524620056, 0.06638627499341965, 0.015473597683012486, -0.05213138461112976, -0.007057021372020245, -0.040838003158569336, -0.04012482240796089, -0.03533758968114853, -0.01390556525439024, -0.028148913756012917, -0.03271506354212761, -0.0493454709649086, 0.020036397501826286, -0.016995033249258995, 0.039222899824380875, -0.013359279371798038, 0.01649843342602253, 0.007289612200111151, 0.016487253829836845, 0.0010716720717027783, -0.03485614061355591, -0.032587721943855286, 0.03822331130504608, -0.00766645697876811, 0.01564033329486847, 0.03182416409254074, 0.03830455616116524, 0.025730811059474945, -0.0049439393915236, 0.00221684155985713, 0.08729518949985504, 0.002057523000985384, -0.007936338894069195, 0.0277622789144516, -0.03187258541584015, 0.01845390722155571, 0.033479318022727966, -0.0034611108712852, -0.05826106294989586, 0.039019860327243805, -0.011483338661491871, 0.05985284224152565, -0.03437405824661255, 0.013267924077808857, 0.0007418781169690192, -0.03549284487962723, 0.02852773107588291, 0.06543198227882385, -0.013966361992061138, -0.013947650790214539, -0.0005351972649805248, -0.0013749435311183333, -0.031041672453284264, -0.02218601107597351, -0.0582234226167202, 0.010603201575577259, -0.00853262934833765, -0.021822119131684303, 0.005732807330787182, 0.027445537969470024, -0.008561923168599606, 0.004728852771222591, 0.03134385496377945, 0.07864164561033249, 0.02695145271718502, 0.00695871701464057, 0.028382334858179092, -0.042004525661468506, -0.08319176733493805, 0.01919974759221077, 0.0016901958733797073, -0.00780616607517004, -0.011573679745197296, 0.07829159498214722, 0.000676025403663516, -0.03151869773864746, 0.05499501898884773, 0.024401240050792694, 0.06172508746385574, -0.027050413191318512, -0.08793831616640091, -0.0301364716142416, 0.030157065019011497, 0.013729818165302277, 0.05385385453701019, -0.05811123177409172, 0.021610230207443237, 0.05047350004315376, 0.04518347233533859, 0.013520903885364532, 0.038216739892959595, 0.010588167235255241, 0.034410279244184494, 0.0007499249768443406, -0.04965634271502495, -0.05198594927787781, -0.01716521382331848, -0.03357229754328728, -0.024430325254797935, -0.07686838507652283, 0.0315694585442543, 0.028016824275255203, 0.003998694941401482, -0.026969807222485542, 0.07540501654148102, 0.049204498529434204, -0.06281307339668274, 0.004626912996172905, -0.021033599972724915, -0.025675270706415176, 0.06708895415067673, 0.010153856128454208, -0.010636167600750923, -0.009310455061495304, 0.020382564514875412, 0.0355258584022522, 0.010235625319182873, 0.06036309152841568, 0.01295062992721796, -0.00815034843981266, 0.006543467286974192, -0.007438472472131252, -0.014499356970191002, 0.013435392640531063, -0.03450717404484749, 0.0001850747357821092, -0.005646454636007547, -0.009604621678590775, 0.006067698821425438, -0.0016998396022245288, -0.015343939885497093, -0.022015610709786415, 0.016259392723441124, -0.04382093623280525, -0.027870409190654755, -0.02711154706776142, -0.008614810183644295, -0.014309710822999477, -0.011423607356846333, 0.02337769977748394, 0.007049503270536661, 0.038976967334747314, 0.00034448085352778435, -0.0354682132601738, -0.014401651918888092, -0.044961828738451004, 0.016033466905355453, -0.04903239384293556, 0.013186013326048851, 0.0126466304063797, 0.036820027977228165, 0.02951895259320736, 0.02470960095524788, -0.0379379577934742, -0.01526402123272419, 0.010225408710539341, -0.04272131621837616, -0.009069859981536865, -0.01269992534071207, -0.01567954011261463, 0.021047253161668777, -0.02278454601764679, 0.049834609031677246, 0.010421336628496647, -0.017419155687093735, 0.029172182083129883, 0.07362978160381317, 0.04787059500813484, 0.004598176572471857, 0.00661433394998312, 0.006581283174455166, -0.012313137762248516, -0.018452109768986702, 0.0018241330981254578, -0.02005695179104805, -0.05048222839832306, 0.051614709198474884, 0.009381283074617386, -0.0005430766032077372, 0.019836261868476868, 0.07522156089544296, -0.011408471502363682, -0.001747457659803331, 0.049376096576452255, 0.0021136051509529352, 0.010399715043604374, -0.002650477224960923, -0.0011310306144878268, -0.0077703543938696384, -0.029359998181462288, 0.011145097203552723, -0.007787353824824095, 0.024369977414608, -0.015634901821613312, -0.028778143227100372, 0.013497157022356987, -0.010719108395278454, 0.06007630005478859, -0.02600359357893467, -0.03208230808377266, 0.01870681159198284, -0.012854705564677715, 0.0010214849608018994, 0.005642930045723915, -0.004391348455101252, 0.029099395498633385, -0.0005321820499375463, -0.04152621701359749, 0.031284939497709274, -0.018246261402964592, -0.03361264988780022, -0.04055590555071831, 0.01166316494345665, -0.03979762643575668, 0.0035984006244689226, 0.00559941865503788, -0.041633110493421555, -0.021516088396310806, 0.010858933441340923, 0.04620559886097908, 0.041880350559949875, 0.0097108855843544, 0.005813289899379015, -0.019957467913627625, -0.022077400237321854, 0.013722861185669899, 0.0235274825245142, 0.01850629784166813, -0.03543084114789963, 0.027507733553647995, 0.006388174835592508, -0.038061801344156265, 0.049194592982530594, -0.015540571883320808, -0.006837467662990093, 0.011604823172092438, 0.01643023081123829, -0.03325694426894188, -0.027687110006809235, -0.013931679539382458, -0.008113637566566467, -0.025647522881627083, -0.002050587208941579, 0.03955627232789993, 0.007927652448415756, -0.015169070102274418, 0.02785070799291134, -0.060398656874895096, -0.030323149636387825, -0.061661653220653534, -0.024918215349316597, 0.02022232674062252, -0.03144068643450737, 0.043270234018564224, 0.001958269625902176, -0.027982836589217186, 0.010107740759849548, -0.03537820652127266, -0.0842466726899147, 0.0053459214977920055, 0.03481904789805412, 0.04287878796458244, 0.0358855202794075, -0.05151097849011421, 0.07341717183589935, 0.017054155468940735, -0.04173153638839722, -0.03195958957076073, -0.014606318436563015, 0.0029491991735994816, -0.03211018443107605, 0.01075266394764185, 0.009486540220677853, -0.00014763165381737053, 0.041018180549144745, -0.008876470848917961, -0.006617669947445393, 0.07501861453056335, -0.012431123293936253, 0.010045703500509262, 0.02891923114657402, 0.0048297615721821785, 0.006875868421047926, 0.055380772799253464, 0.009018738754093647, -0.02650327980518341, 0.0034522174391895533, -0.007262968458235264, 0.010157042182981968, 0.026959845796227455, -0.01752910204231739, 0.014591149985790253, 0.000981672084890306, -0.05229657515883446, -0.03811351954936981, 0.042342234402894974, -0.011445771902799606, -0.020428339019417763, -0.00413676118478179, 0.02319497801363468, 0.026267966255545616, -0.01143042091280222, 0.00414041243493557, 0.044494207948446274, 0.013238699175417423, -0.007985832169651985, -0.02768026478588581, -0.03463911637663841, -0.029013264924287796, 0.016703810542821884, -0.012640857137739658, -0.0135049382224679, 0.04463013634085655, -0.002361500170081854, 0.015326281078159809, -0.017405202612280846, -0.03767035901546478, -0.0003974759019911289, -0.05674155801534653, -0.014198223128914833, -0.041117388755083084, 0.0752721056342125, 0.027660008519887924, 0.0705668181180954, -0.0024987596552819014, -0.008265351876616478, 0.0345810130238533, -0.008547707460820675, -0.03677625581622124, 0.02199827879667282, -0.0012087615905329585, -0.033748429268598557, -0.005045659374445677, -0.015092294663190842, 0.033915530890226364, -0.008195293135941029, -0.005205714609473944, 0.0049195182509720325, -0.022618811577558517, -0.05402776971459389, 0.009799917228519917, -0.04892602935433388, -0.017666926607489586, -0.03537459671497345, 0.007545654661953449, 0.0774775817990303, -0.0024818789679557085, 0.039125483483076096, 0.050460394471883774, -0.007534428965300322, -0.03459406644105911, -0.02515842206776142, 0.015740644186735153, 0.024932513013482094, 0.00027536210836842656, 0.05917639285326004, -0.0009167196694761515, -0.04782919958233833, 0.034308817237615585, 0.03791961446404457, 0.05397459492087364, 0.023221444338560104, -0.0101171238347888, 0.011089705862104893, 0.0007444638758897781, 0.004252873361110687, 0.033462561666965485, 0.014032689854502678, 0.0271535012871027, 0.03215427324175835, 0.03348176181316376, 0.028145447373390198, -0.0401371568441391, 0.0202939510345459, 0.022222183644771576, -0.012400154024362564, 0.029224790632724762, -0.016885869204998016, 0.03058738261461258, 0.011489481665194035, 0.02782011777162552, -0.0003987317031715065, 0.007945302873849869, 0.020650217309594154, 0.01597391441464424, 0.018484318628907204, -0.016014760360121727, -0.003018032293766737, -0.029509374871850014, 0.011240963824093342, 0.018677346408367157, -0.024033065885305405, -0.05587484687566757, 0.052317455410957336, 0.0420648492872715, 0.046516209840774536, 0.07811093330383301, 0.021130330860614777, -0.08085960149765015, 0.0010984215186908841, 0.03669994696974754, 0.0032802412752062082, -0.002600455889478326, 0.009064748883247375, -0.10331818461418152, -0.02129744365811348, 0.03035343997180462, 0.008298257365822792, 0.02857125736773014, -0.01056427601724863, -0.0035633498337119818, 0.005715407896786928, -0.048187047243118286, -0.010383060202002525, 0.006970577873289585, 0.0044523486867547035, 0.04030919075012207, -0.0045677474699914455, -0.02403213270008564, -0.026028085500001907, -0.014578147791326046, 0.00653462577611208, 0.037214431911706924, -0.0008971557836048305, -0.013240895234048367, -0.02252034656703472, 0.04162897914648056, -0.012347511015832424, -0.06049365550279617, 0.01744309812784195, -0.05350587144494057, 0.015015761367976665, 0.06864684075117111, -0.025149982422590256, -0.01588614098727703, -0.004845418035984039, 0.021856509149074554, -0.009604748338460922, -0.006842814385890961, -0.02069157175719738, 0.04429979994893074, 0.012186022475361824, -0.0173544529825449, 0.0594925694167614, -0.007215385790914297, 0.05188397318124771, 0.018601324409246445, 0.0006679749931208789, 0.02331596240401268, -0.03178984671831131, 0.03841301053762436, -0.055360157042741776, 0.0020032853353768587, -0.054746340960264206, 0.02104916423559189, -0.008967026136815548, 0.03267989680171013, 0.004041905514895916, -0.025569431483745575, -0.01695789024233818, 0.0312524251639843, -0.02513711526989937, 0.01440693624317646, -0.0010008210083469748, 0.005583988036960363, 0.008036562241613865, 0.0026959278620779514, 0.022602159529924393, -0.04771384596824646, -0.006168385501950979, 0.007141603156924248, 0.0029826785903424025, 0.03992825001478195, -0.039583563804626465, -0.03381970897316933, 0.03422603756189346, 0.015423945151269436, 0.013903537765145302, -0.015253337100148201, 0.05085443705320358, -0.004029735457152128, -0.006279165390878916, -0.024247610941529274, -0.020678389817476273, -0.004702174570411444, 0.07689616829156876, -0.04654332995414734, 0.028652209788560867, -0.0012009786441922188, -0.01600351370871067, -0.10114006698131561, -0.03766149282455444, 0.05236247554421425, -0.02451462484896183, -0.06767264753580093, -0.029327768832445145, 0.017677538096904755, -0.032799895852804184, -0.020772479474544525, 0.01571863889694214, 0.05573359131813049, 0.00044508534483611584, -0.015165833756327629, 0.00001082767266780138, 0.006445969920605421, 0.05888182297348976, 0.00906539335846901, 0.017568955197930336, 0.032616861164569855, -0.03739870339632034, -0.03346855565905571, -0.006511525716632605, 0.03138070926070213, -0.02927851490676403, 0.03924979642033577, -0.01314846333116293, 0.005755250807851553, 0.024630315601825714, -0.058889247477054596, -0.028157856315374374, 0.0061993044801056385, -0.0032087836880236864, 0.02893894352018833, -0.027621230110526085, -0.012435700744390488, -0.03614154830574989, 0.0040143076330423355, -0.0038652599323540926, -0.04740624874830246, -0.016940638422966003, -0.010407342575490475, 0.020797474309802055, -0.029797522351145744, -0.0144809540361166, 0.015336720272898674, 0.05857130140066147, 0.0029529330786317587, 0.009704463183879852, 0.004390974063426256, -0.0063049267046153545, 0.0346376858651638, -0.012999490834772587, -0.005848909728229046, 0.022947827354073524, -0.006297118030488491, -0.03518917039036751, -0.0044651697389781475, -0.05968042090535164, 0.03267696872353554, 0.04427056014537811, -0.007073208224028349, 0.049988310784101486, 0.01056252047419548, 0.009677601046860218, 0.0033904891461133957, -0.0024482773151248693, -0.010247849859297276, -0.00180747639387846, -0.028404485434293747, 0.032651081681251526, -0.050679609179496765, 0.022353794425725937, 0.03451267629861832, 0.007393523119390011, 0.014598057605326176, 0.02828674577176571, 0.00988277979195118, 0.01991184800863266, 0.014231031760573387, -0.015404028818011284, -0.01205491553992033, 0.06461061537265778, -0.015422428958117962, 0.005847310647368431, -0.01843566633760929, -0.01941801980137825, 0.01110111828893423, 0.02070457488298416, 0.012869005091488361, -0.04000303894281387, -0.02074599266052246, -0.058099765330553055, -0.007235434837639332, 0.026084955781698227, -0.010947092436254025, 0.019686881452798843, 0.04419797658920288, 0.008007796481251717, 0.008909625001251698, 0.014935838058590889, -0.0062346914783120155, -0.046711940318346024, -0.024784455075860023, -0.031880129128694534, -0.05033106729388237, -0.01898772455751896, -0.010785825550556183, -0.059136174619197845, 0.01017188560217619, -0.009053276851773262, 0.022772405296564102, 0.034186623990535736, 0.02747264690697193, 0.023293597623705864, 0.140028715133667, 0.016656776890158653, 0.048778463155031204, -0.017058594152331352, 0.023647453635931015, 0.11612053960561752, 0.0430656298995018, 0.03577046096324921, -0.055929455906152725, -0.01826813817024231, -0.0023319933097809553, 0.038361549377441406, -0.06423896551132202, 0.030695509165525436, 0.02022612653672695, -0.01849139854311943, 0.02412717416882515, 0.027414493262767792, -0.017208656296133995, -0.05231396108865738, 0.036405932158231735, -0.012738442048430443, -0.021458420902490616, -0.007953203283250332, -0.004144903272390366, -0.023686982691287994, -0.03520355373620987, -0.04733012989163399, 0.002193884924054146, -0.005579320713877678, -0.01612623780965805, -0.011473502032458782, -0.0180596262216568, -0.015760142356157303, 0.006446436047554016, 0.0047105154953897, -0.014514409936964512, 0.01394674088805914, 0.0402195043861866, -0.002258569933474064, -0.025304028764367104, -0.0012549631064757705, -0.03690605238080025, 0.060552019625902176, 0.02298876643180847, 0.0708702877163887, -0.016551492735743523, 0.036368776112794876, 0.017100023105740547, -0.016284456476569176, -0.03407629206776619, -0.014417706988751888, 0.04209110885858536, -0.019278528168797493, -0.010161962360143661, -0.02613210864365101, 0.008141690865159035, -0.00154524901881814, -0.03290614113211632, -0.011518976651132107, 0.03851758688688278, 0.026303302496671677, -0.06923173367977142, -0.02090669795870781, -0.017981067299842834, -0.04194927215576172, 0.0007317454437725246, 0.031247815117239952, 0.01156302634626627, -0.028645813465118408, -0.007761695422232151, -0.015612996183335781, 0.01966118812561035, -0.03684308007359505, -0.020459292456507683, -0.013871463015675545, -0.018298311159014702, -0.04278955236077309, -0.017105355858802795, 0.02926899679005146, -0.01920080929994583, 0.03212588652968407, 0.008573130704462528, -0.009168625809252262, 0.002790244063362479, -0.03814513608813286, -0.00678500859066844, -0.04407745972275734, -0.028389476239681244, -0.005151829682290554, 0.021530291065573692, -0.011274539865553379, 0.01047893613576889, -0.0014951616758480668, 0.013230790384113789, -0.0340295284986496, 0.015685725957155228, 0.015034972690045834, -0.04918050393462181, 0.007252410985529423, -0.006038274150341749, -0.00478756707161665, -0.013634361326694489, -0.011996270157396793, 0.04502284526824951, 0.06299946457147598, 0.021806370466947556, -0.017875373363494873, 0.041564665734767914, -0.02123032510280609, -0.008700674399733543, -0.0019298583501949906, -0.042223818600177765, 0.007571772206574678, 0.012754072435200214, 0.027123035863041878, -0.028318537399172783, -0.030484963208436966, -0.008069463074207306, 0.007003120146691799, 0.008747771382331848, 0.0008358334889635444, -0.04474557936191559, -0.03007807582616806, -0.0024520540609955788, -0.025399070233106613, 0.007557920180261135, 0.032634422183036804, 0.01074952818453312, 0.0023528868332505226, -0.046604469418525696, 0.016712311655282974, -0.01906229741871357, 0.033564306795597076, -0.005986591335386038, -0.019707554951310158, -0.00829620473086834, -0.00888711865991354, -0.012821504846215248, -0.0016824168851599097, 0.017605746164917946, -0.013111067935824394, 0.017101094126701355, -0.003025765996426344, -0.006045288871973753, -0.00016619704547338188, -0.04236897826194763, -0.019082466140389442, 0.0006112642004154623, 0.03412516787648201, 0.033034246414899826, -0.0025932216085493565, 0.01787165179848671, -0.019256437197327614, 0.024134667590260506, -0.017607862129807472, -0.004525120835751295, 0.013355407863855362, 0.0149064427241683, 0.014352326281368732, -0.00996895506978035, -0.009612216614186764, 0.027719154953956604, -0.011875498108565807, 0.027966685593128204, 0.05173240229487419, 0.008825521916151047, 0.007263719569891691, 0.03301973640918732, -0.005751049146056175, -0.0016959068598225713, -0.013792145065963268, 0.0025621862150728703, 0.05797654762864113, 0.04757635295391083, 0.00939208921045065, 0.0031323498114943504, -0.04308357462286949, 0.03620123863220215, -0.06187067925930023, -0.0026371320709586143, -0.0019728965125977993, 0.021692657843232155, 0.06078251078724861, -0.0852980762720108, -0.023300044238567352, 0.033089615404605865, -0.02691664732992649, 0.049124594777822495, 0.011658302508294582, 0.01887911558151245, -0.052635397762060165, 0.005939353257417679, -0.019891658797860146, 0.06906624883413315, 0.0481405071914196, 0.013452078215777874, 0.03236735984683037, 0.026122039183974266, 0.004178826697170734, -0.02625797875225544, -0.025755757465958595, 0.02068835310637951, 0.017760267481207848, -0.03587447479367256, 0.06165984272956848, -0.03385797515511513, -0.027558451518416405, 0.058768853545188904, -0.030838554725050926, -0.0028912872076034546, -0.013479968532919884, 0.02567206881940365, 0.025409046560525894, 0.019556600600481033, 0.02137240208685398, -0.039002370089292526, 0.023611854761838913, 0.02016555517911911, 0.037016090005636215, -0.025892894715070724, -0.03414437919855118, 0.014783213846385479, -0.013064924627542496, -0.03972868248820305, -0.04115385562181473, 0.021848592907190323, 0.0086184311658144, 0.013261411339044571, 0.013653142377734184, -0.026383697986602783, -0.004631037823855877, -0.0266508050262928, 0.02711659111082554, -0.020417777821421623, 0.010969454422593117, 0.028173789381980896, 0.023892370983958244, -0.027082569897174835, 0.017455415800213814, -0.05395495519042015, -0.07372714579105377, 0.029936110600829124, -0.010011130012571812, -0.009851673617959023, -0.047022879123687744, -0.006911095231771469, -0.013466197066009045, 0.002351162489503622, -0.036674246191978455, -0.027062084525823593, -0.045026570558547974, 0.002151267835870385, -0.015184166841208935, -0.021311722695827484, 0.04005658999085426, -0.06290341168642044, -0.012531491927802563, -0.054820965975522995, 0.057764116674661636, 0.019490763545036316, -0.022755231708288193, -0.028065327554941177, -0.05380859598517418, -0.004159011412411928, -0.0032644220627844334, 0.03130226582288742, 0.002524137031286955, -0.01462781336158514, -0.020116614177823067, 0.006490768399089575, -0.008714995346963406, -0.023328835144639015, 0.0475572869181633, -0.0045775482431054115, -0.013538743369281292, -0.019186951220035553, -0.012293658219277859, 0.01208734605461359, 0.007622725795954466, 0.007627528160810471, -0.010794121772050858, 0.005337460432201624, 0.012128141708672047, -0.025690468028187752, 0.012738069519400597, 0.048807401210069656, 0.003558544209226966, 0.056698497384786606, -0.028273852542042732, 0.03778529167175293, 0.03955690190196037, 0.009228668175637722, -0.060788869857788086, -0.0021445376332849264, -0.04636312648653984, -0.025990450754761696, 0.02585607022047043, -0.006812501698732376, 0.010750211775302887, -0.02671423926949501, -0.04750041291117668, 0.03918235003948212, -0.03586355224251747, -0.031174631789326668, 0.037472646683454514, 0.013169582933187485, 0.07995331287384033, -0.015171278268098831, -0.0032642444130033255, 0.010592788457870483, 0.017344139516353607, -0.011525215581059456, 0.03000369854271412, 0.029955370351672173, 0.03795377537608147, 0.013446024619042873, -0.03348194807767868, -0.001963901799172163, 0.029606997966766357, -0.04251882806420326, 0.025225041434168816, -0.028218237683176994, -0.005780234467238188, 0.023711003363132477, -0.018646730110049248, 0.013711314648389816, 0.042146798223257065, -0.04100769758224487, 0.07745060324668884, -0.0366673618555069, 0.01434327196329832, -0.0029259631410241127, 0.013513016514480114, -0.04143301397562027, 0.021878227591514587, 0.03975525498390198, 0.002690468914806843, -0.03379996120929718, 0.022286754101514816, 0.006727990228682756, 0.005878644995391369, 0.028791645541787148, -0.05172118544578552, -0.007404792588204145, -0.027238156646490097, -0.010410333052277565, -0.010907897725701332, -0.058911196887493134, -0.03743540123105049, -0.012796086259186268, 0.030569739639759064, 0.016448628157377243, 0.019543036818504333, -0.015521193854510784, 0.015656625851988792, -0.011944365687668324, 0.062321100383996964, -0.05541645735502243, 0.024188324809074402, -0.02650177851319313, -0.0050659868866205215, -0.00948971975594759, -0.017355602234601974 ]
<p>I have a data set with 24 predictor variables, all continuous, but with different scales and potential collinearity. I’m trying to decide whether to use <code>randomForest</code> or <code>cforest</code> in <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/party/index.html" rel="nofollow">party</a> with conditional importance permutation. </p> <p>I recognize that I should probably use <code>cforest</code> if I want to overcome variable selection bias, but I find the ability to get partial dependence plots and percent variance explained from the <code>randomForest</code> package to be quite appealing. </p> <p>I was wondering if anyone knew if it were possible to get partial dependence plots and percent variance explained from <code>cforest</code>?</p> <p>Also, it appears that <code>ctree</code> uses a significance test to select variables; is this the same for <code>cforest</code>? And how might I get these significance values for each variable in cforest?</p>
74,459
[ -0.017121486365795135, 0.005296874791383743, -0.02372416853904724, 0.0118495998904109, 0.04398559406399727, 0.003245173953473568, -0.03792953118681908, -0.008553508669137955, 0.04120953008532524, -0.05536134913563728, 0.009305541403591633, 0.05042338743805885, 0.043663281947374344, 0.023452525958418846, 0.03738825395703316, 0.006954049225896597, 0.004343950189650059, 0.014319334179162979, -0.003909350372850895, -0.017934216186404228, -0.04594938084483147, 0.02152123674750328, 0.002203754149377346, 0.009064538404345512, -0.016011444851756096, 0.06242653355002403, -0.0015978016890585423, -0.019202860072255135, 0.021564628928899765, 0.027058005332946777, -0.05123378708958626, 0.006849929224699736, -0.010070204734802246, 0.05510547384619713, 0.004205132834613323, -0.020831609144806862, 0.017880115658044815, 0.002975375158712268, 0.014663521200418472, 0.009123027324676514, -0.043864574283361435, -0.014624613337218761, -0.04565926641225815, 0.039667509496212006, 0.020283201709389687, 0.025139374658465385, -0.022714613005518913, -0.02900136634707451, 0.0663532093167305, -0.03977212682366371, 0.06491817533969879, -0.005976691376417875, 0.02973751537501812, 0.025188913568854332, 0.01229347288608551, 0.012275438755750656, 0.03646426647901535, 0.04770108684897423, -0.022235915064811707, -0.02406209334731102, -0.014886414632201195, -0.0227960292249918, 0.013894893229007721, -0.015560955740511417, -0.03275051340460777, 0.003810181515291333, 0.008812536485493183, 0.003949178382754326, 0.05467534437775612, 0.005710842553526163, -0.007154714781790972, 0.02335514687001705, 0.019104251638054848, -0.0064660171046853065, -0.011603281833231449, 0.004416038282215595, 0.0015754005871713161, 0.007925450801849365, 0.010219897143542767, 0.042973365634679794, 0.0003615469904616475, 0.004205876495689154, 0.007962026633322239, 0.035902608186006546, 0.022313393652439117, 0.012319395318627357, 0.041833776980638504, 0.01021391898393631, 0.03901323303580284, 0.030423492193222046, 0.012827866710722446, -0.02857748046517372, 0.04332144185900688, 0.053849585354328156, -0.05911045894026756, 0.04233478382229805, -0.029566988348960876, 0.012772339396178722, 0.007449367083609104, 0.027303040027618408, -0.04548046737909317, -0.037161920219659805, -0.010981682687997818, 0.06818262487649918, -0.026716172695159912, 0.05378266051411629, -0.05080737546086311, -0.006181338336318731, -0.006335013546049595, 0.019382916390895844, -0.005330762825906277, 0.0490398034453392, -0.02302083931863308, -0.04778504744172096, 0.024702079594135284, -0.02100801281630993, -0.008275915868580341, -0.002834165934473276, 0.10046755522489548, 0.07298550754785538, 0.05377006158232689, -0.008166544139385223, 0.008422840386629105, -0.04207077994942665, -0.0427827350795269, 0.019504664465785027, 0.002825069474056363, -0.011470463126897812, -0.024175142869353294, 0.048710405826568604, 0.004595485515892506, -0.008289163932204247, 0.025886036455631256, -0.0021365501452237368, 0.00485620740801096, 0.01718829944729805, -0.10118631273508072, -0.05228307470679283, 0.027956848964095116, -0.06235002726316452, 0.03487201780080795, -0.04050951451063156, -0.03405648097395897, -0.008921486325562, 0.035719793289899826, -0.06972145289182663, 0.04389548301696777, -0.0014649308286607265, 0.03228023648262024, -0.003127734875306487, -0.03717786446213722, -0.021681101992726326, 0.013088660314679146, -0.036161869764328, -0.020208023488521576, -0.069680355489254, -0.0016307500191032887, 0.025929922237992287, -0.005074752029031515, 0.04022256284952164, 0.02435452491044998, -0.017668284475803375, -0.0209637638181448, -0.030597584322094917, -0.005247627384960651, -0.04179726913571358, 0.07428979128599167, 0.01022118330001831, 0.06845121085643768, 0.022075897082686424, 0.009211396798491478, 0.019941294565796852, 0.03959337994456291, 0.031838417053222656, 0.03458854556083679, -0.018015181645751, 0.003216321114450693, 0.016811594367027283, -0.004511969164013863, -0.022506820037961006, -0.03593463823199272, -0.012139817699790001, -0.020626183599233627, -0.0008675234857946634, 0.03100714273750782, 0.03301530331373215, -0.017301687970757484, -0.017404815182089806, 0.05416330695152283, -0.06439138948917389, -0.01773441955447197, -0.05195663869380951, -0.02625880017876625, -0.0340241864323616, -0.05631272867321968, 0.040337033569812775, 0.024384809657931328, 0.027789749205112457, 0.04365874081850052, -0.012675049714744091, -0.04800087958574295, 0.033419057726860046, 0.02527875453233719, -0.009313554503023624, 0.0020017584320157766, 0.02543291077017784, 0.030515985563397408, -0.034835465252399445, 0.044109851121902466, -0.055521924048662186, -0.0879596620798111, 0.006622500251978636, -0.030022619292140007, 0.0043909624218940735, -0.022589366883039474, -0.03261777386069298, 0.033142365515232086, 0.013852562755346298, 0.00012270553270354867, 0.0634535551071167, -0.023001383990049362, 0.06428250670433044, 0.034005653113126755, 0.03890698775649071, -0.00919410865753889, 0.002351023955270648, 0.021420130506157875, 0.013418495655059814, -0.011221542954444885, 0.0448349192738533, -0.05577860772609711, -0.015741905197501183, 0.028341524302959442, 0.006520222872495651, -0.02981044352054596, -0.0026753852143883705, 0.05347452685236931, 0.00705148559063673, 0.023593975231051445, 0.023086650297045708, -0.014578895643353462, -0.0508187934756279, 0.016755659133195877, 0.01733562909066677, 0.008104553446173668, -0.00776972621679306, 0.04898635298013687, -0.0072309416718780994, 0.055903609842061996, -0.003938679117709398, 0.00005374560350901447, 0.0647062435746193, 0.0009731445461511612, -0.019676432013511658, -0.001679694396443665, -0.05209101736545563, 0.038036443293094635, -0.019413528963923454, -0.0015460109570994973, 0.032692112028598785, 0.023327238857746124, -0.00641109561547637, 0.023144429549574852, -0.023081257939338684, 0.011968923732638359, 0.030068818479776382, -0.0616634264588356, 0.012083343230187893, 0.0001940472866408527, -0.034397970885038376, 0.04391098767518997, -0.010447660461068153, -0.03391687572002411, -0.04669477418065071, 0.044159337878227234, 0.0038867767434567213, 0.011741976253688335, 0.04386287182569504, -0.012125596404075623, -0.007598049473017454, -0.011336798779666424, -0.03651849925518036, 0.023355640470981598, -0.009281648322939873, -0.011012387461960316, 0.023173434659838676, -0.024961665272712708, -0.003760166931897402, -0.0017214702675119042, -0.012565376237034798, -0.019145920872688293, 0.024079138413071632, -0.0009207208058796823, -0.0545986145734787, -0.03276831656694412, -0.01072611566632986, 0.05154382437467575, -0.013689140789210796, -0.0316971018910408, 0.0019594719633460045, -0.015893325209617615, -0.003658525412902236, 0.026695167645812035, -0.05539128929376602, 0.010886948555707932, 0.02292761392891407, -0.01073263306170702, -0.012533484026789665, 0.021076979115605354, -0.002878960920497775, 0.04377212002873421, -0.03766374662518501, -0.032777946442365646, -0.06312873959541321, -0.07928293198347092, 0.036304671317338943, 0.027817171066999435, 0.045143984258174896, -0.020474646240472794, 0.01531795784831047, 0.04748758673667908, 0.0351417139172554, -0.025532191619277, -0.034963831305503845, -0.018315525725483894, -0.03455906733870506, -0.007982006296515465, -0.0210486501455307, 0.034448377788066864, 0.008118781261146069, 0.024842867627739906, -0.014760786667466164, 0.02316027693450451, 0.023444924503564835, -0.016297105699777603, -0.014441553503274918, 0.006823629606515169, -0.0073446249589324, -0.02140190452337265, 0.03432346507906914, -0.00540606863796711, -0.00021321760141290724, 0.006655667908489704, -0.01678234338760376, -0.012914279475808144, -0.006574097089469433, -0.057232875376939774, 0.025326641276478767, -0.01981802098453045, 0.020145880058407784, -0.030718298628926277, -0.0007062705117277801, 0.026763012632727623, -0.04691537469625473, -0.01813957653939724, -0.010533670894801617, 0.08224467188119888, -0.004930302035063505, -0.01838749460875988, 0.03760327026247978, 0.03587494418025017, 0.0003732183249667287, -0.026801953092217445, -0.025808045640587807, -0.010658390820026398, 0.006692796479910612, -0.03533098101615906, -0.014369992539286613, 0.051207561045885086, 0.018619071692228317, 0.030398089438676834, -0.008200770244002342, -0.06023355945944786, 0.04963952302932739, -0.0566776804625988, 0.03604571893811226, -0.0637945607304573, 0.0393855944275856, 0.023579049855470657, 0.0513581782579422, -0.004310681018978357, -0.02882721833884716, -0.0203781109303236, 0.0251295268535614, -0.035983797162771225, 0.05009280517697334, 0.02056509628891945, 0.02090027928352356, -0.021091429516673088, -0.017945850268006325, 0.0181123036891222, 0.0180400088429451, 0.0008111911010928452, -0.004957543686032295, -0.0033995951525866985, 0.01302952878177166, 0.024333681911230087, -0.03557509928941727, -0.04505493864417076, -0.0010289906058460474, 0.06173692271113396, 0.019031686708331108, -0.031884096562862396, 0.02092100866138935, 0.028989877551794052, -0.033224474638700485, -0.013229952193796635, -0.0008089056937023997, -0.0247967429459095, 0.03352581709623337, 0.06955043226480484, 0.020567798987030983, -0.0022977569606155157, -0.015647700056433678, -0.0030545624904334545, -0.01810048148036003, 0.07457184791564941, 0.009154246188700199, 0.002349096816033125, 0.021492265164852142, -0.040103696286678314, -0.007429463788866997, 0.004915208555757999, -0.000027330022930982523, -0.013013309799134731, -0.003001731587573886, 0.04217889904975891, 0.037957239896059036, -0.05669792741537094, 0.008096992038190365, 0.02092624641954899, 0.008641275577247143, -0.02812250889837742, -0.03697395324707031, 0.02152549847960472, 0.03378108888864517, -0.0269764456897974, 0.019179049879312515, 0.026578733697533607, 0.00401684595271945, -0.01588742807507515, 0.009272291325032711, -0.005834995768964291, -0.011860135942697525, 0.01811480149626732, 0.01497216708958149, 0.04084424301981926, -0.014868722297251225, -0.025794751942157745, 0.01929043047130108, 0.027691544964909554, -0.017705567181110382, 0.027434753254055977, 0.012602167204022408, -0.05819056183099747, -0.0002278024039696902, 0.05284753814339638, 0.0827351063489914, -0.05240756273269653, -0.015216131694614887, -0.029303060844540596, -0.01590660959482193, 0.053474005311727524, -0.03953941911458969, 0.029867645353078842, -0.013754847459495068, 0.024082491174340248, -0.0310911126434803, -0.048768606036901474, -0.04337864741683006, -0.0010433620773255825, -0.038573555648326874, 0.020905036479234695, -0.03806229680776596, -0.04264819994568825, -0.021277645602822304, 0.035233188420534134, 0.007094741798937321, 0.06152147799730301, -0.009348774328827858, -0.021757861599326134, 0.007576451636850834, 0.04070701450109482, 0.03522786870598793, -0.052370816469192505, 0.008080177940428257, -0.004480822943150997, 0.004591601435095072, 0.049372654408216476, -0.01773124560713768, -0.029066001996397972, -0.004843488801270723, 0.0036697369068861008, -0.03167645260691643, -0.016822224482893944, 0.019396746531128883, 0.06689244508743286, 0.02206616848707199, -0.007133132312446833, 0.046792227774858475, 0.05515312775969505, -0.0056028906255960464, 0.004391440190374851, 0.0095391059294343, 0.01570279151201248, -0.046919915825128555, 0.011419392190873623, -0.050333812832832336, -0.038467273116111755, -0.05762758105993271, 0.013164352625608444, -0.006660064682364464, 0.04473569244146347, -0.05702028051018715, 0.004036568105220795, -0.004086161032319069, 0.007335572503507137, 0.006065952125936747, 0.023899180814623833, 0.011036106385290623, -0.047431327402591705, -0.032289162278175354, -0.00801785383373499, 0.036572519689798355, -0.023680254817008972, 0.008453932590782642, 0.00006596457387786359, -0.028898373246192932, 0.00490052392706275, -0.043331392109394073, 0.004558658227324486, 0.0045562139712274075, -0.014404797926545143, 0.030285300686955452, 0.037032194435596466, 0.0475635752081871, -0.02282118797302246, -0.044311489909887314, -0.014531721360981464, 0.021859601140022278, -0.018451372161507607, 0.019045483320951462, -0.03227586671710014, 0.03102666512131691, -0.039736557751894, 0.012008413672447205, -0.05693772807717323, 0.00221016863361001, 0.004026566632091999, 0.03874748945236206, 0.008821672759950161, -0.051477547734975815, -0.0058060395531356335, -0.019468773156404495, 0.017077509313821793, -0.032308537513017654, 0.029059262946248055, 0.0077015189453959465, 0.012977865524590015, -0.005083728116005659, 0.030141519382596016, 0.08480307459831238, -0.01873219944536686, 0.001119081862270832, 0.01667526178061962, -0.0096511822193861, -0.028673475608229637, 0.005057329777628183, 0.03940466046333313, -0.031654104590415955, 0.02215193770825863, -0.0015712127787992358, 0.016656724736094475, 0.028023922815918922, -0.016497816890478134, -0.007074372377246618, 0.004044521600008011, 0.009254707023501396, 0.02283143252134323, -0.044125985354185104, -0.013911327347159386, -0.019555166363716125, 0.0030265047680586576, 0.001379737164825201, 0.018439335748553276, -0.01333299558609724, -0.008964433334767818, -0.011674127541482449, -0.01753087341785431, -0.043946411460638046, 0.05047617107629776, 0.06474223732948303, -0.011051995679736137, 0.012892063707113266, -0.005187526810914278, -0.00730694318190217, 0.021596385166049004, 0.007519400212913752, 0.016978641971945763, 0.011235453188419342, 0.019947800785303116, -0.02658761478960514, -0.03350573033094406, -0.021332530304789543, 0.005335613153874874, 0.03128528967499733, -0.013098510913550854, 0.037164751440286636, 0.06791990995407104, -0.03909005969762802, -0.016364162787795067, -0.038449227809906006, -0.023315304890275, -0.014032223261892796, 0.0328073687851429, 0.06092369556427002, -0.003392044687643647, 0.017302380874753, 0.03988859802484512, 0.01001629326492548, 0.028948498889803886, 0.06469637900590897, 0.018800847232341766, 0.02074570022523403, 0.01926068402826786, -0.03901682049036026, -0.044485174119472504, 0.01693957857787609, -0.04216610640287399, 0.02300315722823143, -0.023809265345335007, -0.027469603344798088, 0.047900326550006866, 0.031641557812690735, -0.015269061550498009, -0.01495801005512476, -0.01812002994120121, -0.028873806819319725, -0.0017560524865984917, 0.00250302255153656, -0.019702523946762085, 0.008055872283875942, -0.0027605954091995955, 0.02247978374361992, 0.006050080060958862, 0.04887128621339798, -0.04705647751688957, -0.106120765209198, -0.020751191303133965, -0.007986461743712425, -0.02194436639547348, 0.013191747479140759, 0.0017018966609612107, -0.039220985025167465, 0.030956920236349106, -0.021193088963627815, -0.007406760938465595, 0.0037003590259701014, 0.030442014336586, 0.02442564070224762, 0.03278274089097977, -0.006173976697027683, -0.01413855142891407, 0.016556302085518837, -0.045419562608003616, 0.1382542848587036, 0.0755247101187706, 0.03915628790855408, -0.06781506538391113, 0.026347296312451363, 0.009139230474829674, 0.008286279626190662, -0.012843091040849686, -0.011402929201722145, 0.0061082858592271805, -0.010766737163066864, 0.06623167544603348, 0.025923365727066994, 0.04812430962920189, -0.0012840207200497389, 0.03678207844495773, -0.016528166830539703, -0.04591783508658409, 0.005461200140416622, 0.014251824468374252, -0.012277122586965561, -0.052433498203754425, -0.06138850376009941, -0.038599204272031784, 0.03585683926939964, 0.002481071511283517, -0.010131248272955418, -0.005469552706927061, -0.01394083071500063, -0.005860528443008661, -0.01657194271683693, 0.0009101943578571081, 0.021742062643170357, 0.02419930323958397, -0.017252124845981598, 0.006771129556000233, 0.025355149060487747, -0.03357455134391785, 0.02513238973915577, 0.011369195766746998, -0.031594499945640564, -0.022695448249578476, -0.01777174510061741, 0.019016005098819733, -0.04330940172076225, -0.0358966663479805, -0.05427960306406021, 0.03129546344280243, -0.010946974158287048, -0.02121533825993538, -0.0018576392903923988, -0.038475725799798965, 0.03858047351241112, 0.009737185202538967, 0.007114758249372244, 0.004902712069451809, 0.04284680634737015, -0.04280126467347145, 0.0015214030863717198, -0.04768983647227287, 0.013396317139267921, -0.030785519629716873, 0.014622598886489868, 0.033703699707984924, -0.05287930741906166, -0.028401844203472137, -0.06277213990688324, 0.06259392946958542, 0.018401747569441795, -0.008504035882651806, 0.018089301884174347, -0.0014008193975314498, -0.0276147723197937, 0.00010950054274871945, 0.0014325741212815046, -0.006441413890570402, 0.063201904296875, -0.04006834700703621, 0.024422312155365944, -0.017017804086208344, -0.002092443872243166, 0.007812119089066982, -0.0486057810485363, -0.006232222076505423, -0.03429673612117767, 0.02840997278690338, 0.032829176634550095, 0.04296880587935448, 0.04586203768849373, -0.004802818410098553, -0.033879559487104416, 0.046083882451057434, 0.00918789952993393, -0.021382443606853485, -0.043543241918087006, -0.021029073745012283, 0.0017305039800703526, -0.02341986633837223, -0.029329145327210426, 0.055590998381376266, 0.005129854194819927, -0.0046716476790606976, -0.034777574241161346, 0.039853535592556, -0.00519159622490406, 0.02960033528506756, 0.0299195758998394, -0.06066250056028366, -0.013104382902383804, -0.004002854228019714, 0.007593697402626276, -0.051694244146347046, -0.02357855625450611, -0.03927607089281082, -0.036484088748693466, 0.0019030568655580282, -0.019092267379164696, -0.045584097504615784, -0.02259010635316372, -0.007089567836374044, 0.056633077561855316, -0.005725292023271322, -0.04425670951604843, -0.03665296733379364, -0.031775668263435364, 0.01727365516126156, -0.003687008749693632, 0.002022296190261841, 0.027989588677883148, -0.022951459512114525, -0.0005695169093087316, 0.02142326906323433, 0.016018951311707497, 0.009824471548199654, -0.03597237542271614, 0.004159100353717804, 0.0025853943079710007, 0.030318377539515495, -0.023129437118768692, -0.01109487283974886, 0.05131940916180611, -0.05026125907897949, -0.031715311110019684, 0.0037404377944767475, -0.02787543646991253, 0.04738977551460266, -0.0170354712754488, -0.004823233932256699, -0.022309783846139908, 0.026546377688646317, 0.0012794083449989557, -0.001096548163332045, -0.016609912738204002, 0.026912285014986992, 0.042736031115055084, -0.015999510884284973, 0.012789296917617321, -0.005063025746494532, 0.005026236176490784, 0.01162398885935545, 0.01692606508731842, 0.02502131648361683, 0.012401711195707321, 0.007628761697560549, 0.0038568100426346064, 0.014373501762747765, -0.00071397126885131, -0.022649794816970825, 0.03549664840102196, 0.04273303598165512, -0.04717191681265831, 0.07481376826763153, 0.01763145439326763, 0.026600591838359833, -0.07311856746673584, -0.020223209634423256, -0.001829493441618979, 0.014982404187321663, 0.005255947355180979, -0.04434902220964432, 0.03038397617638111, 0.0271682757884264, -0.05381631478667259, 0.018132926896214485, -0.00839466042816639, -0.00363252405077219, -0.020878106355667114, 0.0036303873639553785, -0.02749394252896309, 0.03903362900018692, 0.03347683325409889, 0.009668740443885326, 0.06399448961019516, 0.024399533867836, 0.03605741634964943, -0.02938520535826683, 0.016124429181218147, -0.014157760888338089, -0.00013858667807653546, -0.08456671237945557, 0.0327874980866909, -0.027279110625386238, -0.057057008147239685, 0.021452326327562332, -0.031331706792116165, 0.03437338396906853, -0.009200705215334892, 0.02619439922273159, 0.027710212394595146, 0.05408782511949539, 0.03259747847914696, 0.00825312826782465, -0.02949119545519352, -0.020626980811357498, -0.00015364206046797335, 0.01155767310410738, -0.013514136895537376, 0.010804184712469578, 0.02419981360435486, 0.030606649816036224, 0.00015132082626223564, 0.022732239216566086, -0.03019367903470993, -0.02402077242732048, -0.04140060022473335, -0.04069232940673828, 0.0012829747283831239, 0.0057910410687327385, 0.013000463135540485, -0.05172179266810417, -0.02667010948061943, 0.05697125568985939, 0.004279117565602064, 0.020094793289899826, 0.028191829100251198, -0.02916211076080799, -0.037980008870363235, -0.013585382141172886, -0.008178469724953175, -0.006344124209135771, -0.018810506910085678, -0.020239058881998062, 0.007169723976403475, -0.004051992204040289, -0.018326427787542343, -0.0023654755204916, -0.01685107685625553, 0.053553566336631775, -0.018261456862092018, 0.0011737375753000379, -0.0021286748815327883, -0.027856355533003807, 0.06440649926662445, -0.07507123053073883, 0.0279155895113945, 0.03925143927335739, -0.018475353717803955, -0.03285592421889305, -0.00942039955407381, -0.036441870033741, 0.00533010670915246, 0.022882701829075813, -0.006928256247192621, 0.04548689350485802, -0.026349086314439774, 0.027873139828443527, 0.02540247142314911, -0.08748619258403778, 0.03581428900361061, -0.002663387916982174, -0.02842497080564499, -0.038757093250751495, -0.03130064532160759, 0.034488316625356674, 0.02756313420832157, 0.012170861475169659, 0.01334432139992714, -0.008860890753567219, -0.020422186702489853, -0.017540978267788887, 0.052335843443870544, -0.03862769901752472, -0.012140895240008831, 0.027411002665758133, -0.01240549236536026, 0.038425836712121964, 0.015297322534024715, 0.020149189978837967, 0.002590919379144907, 0.03962653875350952, -0.0491146519780159, -0.03682351112365723, 0.032528940588235855, 0.0038820260670036077, 0.010831720195710659, -0.0819820910692215, 0.01697934791445732, 0.022493692114949226, -0.023696647956967354, 0.01904408074915409, 0.041917335242033005, 0.008375502191483974, 0.03767406567931175, 0.04276363179087639, -0.007719623390585184, 0.014776444062590599, -0.05016859620809555, -0.025420261546969414, 0.010819274000823498, -0.0024459646083414555, 0.01280330028384924, -0.004690001253038645, 0.02992939203977585, -0.04846232011914253, 0.039319805800914764, -0.02302870899438858, 0.030829833820462227, 0.014448992908000946, -0.005201630759984255, -0.0003063670883420855, 0.0087727140635252, 0.03209355100989342, 0.007773927878588438, -0.004630728159099817, -0.006149793043732643, -0.03034541942179203, 0.0075172497890889645, -0.020600974559783936, -0.013548724353313446, -0.0106655303388834, -0.007320079021155834, -0.009106273762881756, 0.014363536611199379, 0.011506062000989914, 0.05782576650381088, -0.02308846078813076, -0.02433083951473236, 0.029090160503983498, -0.02089228294789791, 0.028721148148179054, -0.038833387196063995, -0.008046282455325127, 0.02371727116405964, -0.0027125331107527018, -0.031753916293382645, -0.04312337934970856, 0.03371969237923622, 0.04370331019163132, 0.01269704382866621, -0.03580770269036293, -0.009980915114283562, 0.03197050839662552, 0.05067390576004982, -0.037647414952516556, 0.00367492507211864, -0.03294658660888672, -0.026945043355226517, -0.006271669641137123, 0.006366840563714504 ]
<p>I did multinomial logistic regression using SPSS chi-square is .000 , df is 0 and significance =. </p> <p>So what does it mean significance = .? </p>
37,344
[ -0.03270113840699196, -0.05384758114814758, -0.011824910528957844, 0.023446593433618546, 0.05326251685619354, 0.014245090074837208, -0.001266423612833023, -0.02528507448732853, 0.003990523517131805, -0.035036101937294006, 0.04839088395237923, 0.01210726797580719, -0.01822063699364662, 0.013999992050230503, 0.02592405490577221, 0.02781667374074459, -0.009861540049314499, 0.048851270228624344, -0.006725819781422615, 0.04511309787631035, -0.0000816680330899544, 0.029595058411359787, 0.023396415635943413, 0.013101761229336262, -0.015910573303699493, 0.05459567904472351, 0.033436357975006104, -0.025063861161470413, 0.014275779016315937, 0.041860926896333694, -0.040745049715042114, -0.015349084511399269, 0.01678197644650936, 0.0064375922083854675, 0.028747644275426865, -0.017099130898714066, -0.02510775811970234, -0.02198295295238495, 0.006815208122134209, 0.01153866108506918, 0.013142028823494911, -0.013285514898598194, 0.0400230772793293, 0.03206530958414078, -0.032624829560518265, -0.008623347617685795, -0.002021402819082141, -0.02834637090563774, 0.01723039336502552, -0.016602879390120506, 0.0503348708152771, -0.02049391157925129, 0.0401020348072052, 0.014507798478007317, 0.008844614028930664, -0.0067899818532168865, 0.0269484780728817, 0.029930833727121353, -0.019383825361728668, -0.04929071664810181, -0.003943226300179958, -0.02169550210237503, 0.030592480674386024, -0.059742193669080734, -0.010703742504119873, -0.00976868811994791, -0.000043907126382691786, -0.02066091261804104, 0.08980772644281387, 0.03212777152657509, 0.01740076206624508, 0.027064088732004166, 0.03643842041492462, -0.043766897171735764, 0.03458516672253609, -0.051546841859817505, 0.013545352965593338, -0.021331654861569405, 0.010719651356339455, 0.04951229318976402, 0.02690693363547325, 0.0052199531346559525, -0.010520890355110168, -0.002587420865893364, 0.02054508775472641, -0.005629547871649265, 0.031034843996167183, 0.013698472641408443, 0.01925184391438961, 0.025297194719314575, -0.023135662078857422, -0.0035079852677881718, 0.03153771162033081, -0.00570429302752018, -0.019479626789689064, -0.01715046539902687, -0.04523748159408569, 0.04333038255572319, 0.04099889099597931, -0.008560103364288807, 0.0024202552158385515, -0.036345336586236954, 0.03701966255903244, 0.04241661727428436, -0.041486579924821854, 0.05504590645432472, -0.03895265981554985, 0.014666911214590073, 0.010778920724987984, -0.04766275733709335, -0.03531724587082863, 0.012611902318894863, 0.040561094880104065, -0.005744015797972679, -0.003990353085100651, 0.0012225693790242076, -0.023499269038438797, -0.008755524642765522, 0.012846271507441998, 0.031424760818481445, 0.028833691030740738, -0.03721078112721443, 0.008628123439848423, -0.00624596793204546, -0.029192622750997543, 0.0029414843302220106, 0.00030095287365838885, 0.0018578874878585339, -0.027079952880740166, 0.04416296258568764, -0.015577641315758228, -0.010772384703159332, 0.0035529464948922396, 0.03126366436481476, -0.015155863016843796, -0.013470527715981007, -0.06900175660848618, -0.07155902683734894, 0.021547334268689156, -0.007137190084904432, 0.03121056966483593, -0.031101752072572708, -0.03987589851021767, 0.014407319948077202, 0.05040092021226883, 0.002884152578189969, 0.021880192682147026, 0.013612326234579086, 0.008409797213971615, 0.008590352721512318, -0.009179123677313328, 0.015364449471235275, -0.06309611350297928, -0.033432379364967346, 0.008283459581434727, -0.07945761829614639, 0.04354514554142952, 0.036947380751371384, 0.00229062931612134, -0.03580378741025925, -0.03022182732820511, -0.014547356404364109, 0.0019837329164147377, -0.003241524565964937, -0.04052427411079407, 0.010758415795862675, 0.043868228793144226, -0.004903895780444145, 0.04275967553257942, 0.02612152136862278, 0.009843039326369762, 0.02543984167277813, 0.006377287674695253, 0.0956677719950676, 0.027476539835333824, 0.02306685969233513, -0.0033176890574395657, -0.041504405438899994, 0.030882161110639572, 0.009482488967478275, -0.06574642658233643, -0.030156224966049194, -0.015318457037210464, -0.008633567951619625, 0.0024625875521451235, 0.05125100910663605, 0.008241572417318821, -0.0008375417091883719, 0.03165438026189804, -0.03941885754466057, -0.06022895872592926, -0.06869379431009293, 0.01801229454576969, -0.03679829090833664, -0.0340120866894722, -0.008079508319497108, 0.018287433311343193, 0.020549191161990166, -0.03244025260210037, 0.016970299184322357, -0.03070211224257946, -0.003891622880473733, 0.031568512320518494, -0.04032548516988754, 0.010720782913267612, 0.06495954096317291, 0.03157029300928116, -0.03395063057541847, 0.01959717459976673, -0.05386563390493393, 0.0009551178081892431, 0.023488184437155724, -0.001259476412087679, -0.016100233420729637, -0.009163928218185902, -0.01903434656560421, 0.031639549881219864, -0.0153121966868639, -0.04090756177902222, 0.05313319340348244, -0.06040837988257408, 0.08931400626897812, 0.04705933481454849, -0.01045592874288559, 0.026932116597890854, 0.0011976014357060194, -0.02468046545982361, -0.019237175583839417, -0.030738452449440956, -0.024735061451792717, -0.062305692583322525, -0.012676357291638851, 0.04977387189865112, -0.004087740555405617, -0.02892906777560711, -0.01229914091527462, 0.024670960381627083, 0.016482694074511528, 0.03849680349230766, 0.01426389254629612, -0.04888107627630234, -0.00854596495628357, 0.013836313970386982, 0.022640470415353775, 0.010599362663924694, 0.051942378282547, 0.04228002578020096, 0.019166860729455948, 0.05670073255896568, -0.0027919996064156294, -0.02502651885151863, 0.06234467029571533, -0.027605462819337845, 0.019974716007709503, -0.015990780666470528, -0.00811716541647911, 0.012198526412248611, -0.04339531436562538, 0.006643138360232115, 0.03345442935824394, 0.01984318718314171, -0.008368119597434998, 0.01800307258963585, -0.01225625816732645, 0.04798860102891922, 0.06996004283428192, -0.014810092747211456, -0.017994964495301247, 0.02312181331217289, -0.04145459085702896, 0.027095044031739235, -0.0012411093339323997, -0.04831564053893089, -0.03264053910970688, -0.014814112335443497, 0.022259313613176346, 0.005404998082667589, 0.03276105970144272, -0.00371422222815454, -0.035147666931152344, 0.00012484889884945005, -0.047368038445711136, 0.034137360751628876, -0.03562002629041672, -0.0753355324268341, -0.059106141328811646, 0.0026670824736356735, -0.02335207536816597, 0.017643596976995468, -0.01074324082583189, -0.014919692650437355, 0.017765527591109276, -0.04597051069140434, -0.025416230782866478, -0.0036741129588335752, -0.02037138305604458, -0.006279517896473408, -0.025160279124975204, -0.010701297782361507, 0.02131744846701622, -0.01094436552375555, -0.024469707161188126, 0.028731590136885643, -0.06669556349515915, 0.003240069607272744, -0.02282875031232834, -0.026429710909724236, 0.007268859539180994, -0.023102523759007454, 0.020483560860157013, -0.042794134467840195, -0.0056475927121937275, 0.012698143720626831, -0.07025354355573654, -0.03456917777657509, 0.008833345957100391, -0.011253755539655685, 0.04711747542023659, -0.028514359146356583, -0.020038310438394547, 0.07575467973947525, 0.03413734212517738, 0.007114239502698183, -0.04639421030879021, -0.009734665974974632, -0.043394651263952255, -0.04329025745391846, 0.02779284678399563, 0.035577915608882904, 0.01711117848753929, 0.03430759906768799, -0.024892112240195274, 0.01773093082010746, 0.03071332722902298, 0.014519806019961834, -0.00018022819131147116, 0.018602099269628525, -0.03141487017273903, -0.02098170295357704, 0.06359896808862686, 0.013264166191220284, -0.03522216156125069, 0.03510722517967224, -0.006006814539432526, 0.018419386819005013, 0.007419705390930176, -0.017469333484768867, 0.02002192661166191, 0.000819014327134937, -0.008059488609433174, -0.014237355440855026, 0.013142178766429424, 0.02946476638317108, -0.030693287029862404, -0.01584576442837715, -0.026048630475997925, 0.02476123534142971, -0.019644025713205338, -0.0020417063497006893, -0.0005163466557860374, 0.023068111389875412, -0.013855256140232086, -0.013540796004235744, -0.04734396934509277, -0.009892704896628857, 0.026511363685131073, -0.00884241797029972, -0.02425161376595497, 0.03930385038256645, 0.054991625249385834, 0.011164676398038864, 0.011159418150782585, -0.05110703781247139, -0.006830619648098946, -0.026220737025141716, 0.0013148934813216329, -0.0012243749806657434, 0.0461425743997097, -0.004104137420654297, 0.031084667891263962, 0.02848491445183754, -0.027828486636281013, -0.01797322928905487, 0.02470829151570797, -0.05149224400520325, 0.03171095997095108, -0.028362132608890533, -0.004798910580575466, 0.03860204666852951, -0.05187332257628441, 0.010262652300298214, -0.04417252540588379, 0.039933186024427414, 0.028320245444774628, 0.028805486857891083, -0.020060840994119644, 0.014439092017710209, 0.014792081899940968, 0.008803823962807655, 0.007128708530217409, 0.015496857464313507, 0.0025263444986194372, 0.04310380667448044, 0.015723109245300293, 0.027413710951805115, -0.010058492422103882, -0.0034726785961538553, -0.023159287869930267, 0.006999791134148836, 0.040613118559122086, 0.04674718528985977, 0.03337137773633003, 0.010953000746667385, -0.04861748591065407, 0.026920925825834274, 0.004641932435333729, 0.02881762571632862, 0.021260561421513557, -0.005076973233371973, -0.04562568664550781, -0.043807294219732285, -0.029434368014335632, -0.013261345215141773, 0.02737303264439106, 0.0010985259432345629, 0.0003862505836877972, 0.05480599403381348, 0.014862270094454288, -0.052891094237565994, 0.035479750484228134, 0.06397325545549393, 0.023572005331516266, -0.02930932305753231, -0.04457778483629227, 0.03046567551791668, -0.03400947153568268, 0.0007135260384529829, -0.01787397265434265, 0.021830569952726364, 0.016595853492617607, -0.005254875402897596, 0.010849113576114178, -0.03799433633685112, -0.04315876588225365, -0.0032983075361698866, 0.010575676336884499, 0.046895235776901245, 0.02203543670475483, -0.027590136975049973, -0.0031574848107993603, 0.047408659011125565, -0.003134495811536908, 0.037124305963516235, 0.003612840548157692, -0.07697238028049469, 0.00646381126716733, 0.0410163588821888, 0.03571433201432228, -0.04635470360517502, -0.0038753380067646503, 0.000232875463552773, 0.030948296189308167, 0.029889032244682312, -0.041623156517744064, 0.027556423097848892, -0.013444211333990097, 0.05499934032559395, -0.007347618695348501, -0.008097684942185879, -0.07552679628133774, 0.04995853081345558, -0.04364173486828804, 0.049304552376270294, -0.030112795531749725, -0.01043664664030075, -0.08738145977258682, 0.010838578455150127, -0.006288560573011637, 0.04328268766403198, -0.02441219985485077, -0.019274774938821793, 0.015949750319123268, 0.0056838118471205235, 0.013643520884215832, -0.058987654745578766, 0.028005536645650864, -0.004007088020443916, 0.01648148149251938, 0.029364585876464844, -0.0006554311839863658, -0.05462177097797394, -0.001041344366967678, 0.015838781371712685, -0.024373076856136322, -0.005785338114947081, -0.06600925326347351, 0.01650591939687729, 0.021366151049733162, 0.0017796289175748825, 0.056792549788951874, 0.003817549906671047, -0.033029310405254364, 0.01040253508836031, -0.06425489485263824, 0.0497283935546875, -0.0046987636014819145, -0.0215301476418972, -0.03860058635473251, 0.02645866759121418, -0.02288622222840786, 0.016303157433867455, -0.004872479941695929, 0.009994493797421455, -0.009307906031608582, -0.016602421179413795, -0.00703252712264657, 0.003304970683529973, 0.02960493043065071, -0.0037005599588155746, 0.013335179537534714, 0.0071480488404631615, 0.011514801532030106, -0.021471034735441208, 0.030501922592520714, -0.01259199995547533, 0.015589863993227482, 0.04676620662212372, 0.0006918975850567222, 0.0008076675585471094, -0.022870169952511787, -0.06009403243660927, 0.022630468010902405, -0.05308603122830391, 0.00730421906337142, -0.01931348256766796, 0.02419988065958023, 0.0035349498502910137, -0.07113414257764816, -0.04332543909549713, 0.01366177387535572, 0.003797208657488227, 0.049576181918382645, -0.06161857768893242, 0.011366200633347034, 0.013197085820138454, 0.0025181316304951906, -0.0456233024597168, -0.04173777997493744, 0.02129169926047325, 0.005863819736987352, -0.011045324616134167, -0.006984000094234943, -0.005861160811036825, -0.005013544112443924, -0.030895406380295753, 0.003821857040748, 0.042976170778274536, -0.03213826194405556, 0.003661849768832326, -0.019322380423545837, -0.010118566453456879, 0.06610942631959915, 0.004342698957771063, -0.02103681117296219, -0.0017157214460894465, 0.008094074204564095, -0.030195284634828568, 0.01775677502155304, 0.03183422237634659, -0.029902692884206772, -0.01876094937324524, -0.012600169517099857, -0.025952192023396492, 0.020105067640542984, -0.019644077867269516, -0.001617646892555058, -0.007918803952634335, -0.019417157396674156, 0.020335514098405838, -0.006252029445022345, 0.013576401397585869, -0.015124826692044735, 0.007009616121649742, -0.00007296272087842226, -0.008737821131944656, -0.03252623230218887, 0.031719181686639786, 0.027801044285297394, -0.010241761803627014, 0.03232741355895996, 0.024671463295817375, 0.06657327711582184, 0.02414342388510704, 0.011408627964556217, -0.042542465031147, 0.012725086882710457, 0.032635483890771866, 0.04163159802556038, -0.045306701213121414, -0.003962954506278038, 0.03915693610906601, -0.013402560725808144, 0.03652404248714447, -0.04219692945480347, -0.0033125984482467175, 0.055661581456661224, 0.006439334247261286, 0.04655841365456581, 0.032668597996234894, -0.008378440514206886, 0.027345260605216026, -0.047255270183086395, -0.006967846304178238, 0.007319957949221134, 0.0421367846429348, 0.017863059416413307, -0.010403713211417198, 0.0028336471877992153, 0.05239433795213699, 0.010015384294092655, 0.019995255395770073, 0.043937232345342636, 0.05015147477388382, -0.003069882979616523, 0.01713208481669426, -0.036544736474752426, -0.04981016367673874, 0.05447547510266304, -0.028477845713496208, 0.021078262478113174, -0.019557001069188118, 0.0060508172027766705, 0.08233299851417542, 0.05759693682193756, 0.017137521877884865, -0.04732507839798927, -0.021160058677196503, -0.056086257100105286, -0.01793539524078369, 0.021540282294154167, -0.04482986405491829, 0.008490708656609058, 0.01447459775954485, 0.02396124042570591, -0.015784520655870438, 0.009287238121032715, 0.013505998998880386, -0.07498136162757874, -0.019765077158808708, 0.010813991539180279, -0.04054979979991913, -0.024183977395296097, -0.02076050639152527, -0.041652604937553406, -0.035540871322155, -0.04346942901611328, 0.0106637142598629, 0.016002804040908813, 0.0009142980561591685, 0.00942861009389162, 0.05072983354330063, 0.018732311204075813, 0.006415585987269878, 0.016436701640486717, -0.009922797791659832, 0.11314128339290619, 0.07452205568552017, -0.00027405109722167253, -0.06690174341201782, -0.006919499021023512, -0.01439108606427908, 0.022658897563815117, -0.01440618745982647, -0.02276715077459812, 0.011530404910445213, -0.013744511641561985, 0.052568722516298294, 0.04706527292728424, 0.043916553258895874, -0.0024981964379549026, 0.06815410405397415, -0.014066719450056553, -0.06834425032138824, 0.0006231688312254846, 0.006928292568773031, -0.018222279846668243, -0.034841325134038925, -0.04154413193464279, 0.020146699622273445, 0.0061685931868851185, -0.026935603469610214, -0.02330053597688675, -0.002192514715716243, 0.0069544450379908085, 0.0019787608180195093, -0.013647649437189102, -0.014958435669541359, 0.02688434347510338, 0.02044634334743023, -0.06078561022877693, -0.011397343128919601, 0.029100285843014717, -0.0277267936617136, 0.005262945778667927, 0.04791866987943649, -0.02076561003923416, 0.008934637531638145, 0.007323198486119509, -0.01805541105568409, -0.05287127196788788, -0.030943704769015312, -0.036152344197034836, 0.05212000384926796, 0.018653936684131622, -0.03767940774559975, -0.008196643553674221, 0.018301742151379585, -0.009632367640733719, -0.04910067096352577, 0.0025134016759693623, 0.03808220848441124, -0.0017873060423880816, -0.027614597231149673, -0.029039619490504265, -0.04559112340211868, 0.0008366447291336954, 0.0063786134123802185, 0.03849869221448898, 0.04010874032974243, -0.007413838058710098, -0.005923022516071796, -0.054214585572481155, 0.04462553560733795, -0.052337270230054855, -0.006729850545525551, 0.01627206802368164, -0.019777586683630943, -0.02909395657479763, 0.023963283747434616, 0.0025946057867258787, -0.005192229058593512, 0.010627765208482742, -0.019297512248158455, -0.016654105857014656, -0.039464738219976425, -0.03663548827171326, 0.04280894622206688, -0.02408876270055771, -0.0009762734407559037, -0.03958014398813248, -0.007333184126764536, 0.021129203960299492, 0.04422488436102867, 0.02638544887304306, 0.03904992341995239, 0.00888292770832777, 0.045724283903837204, 0.012747683562338352, -0.03802722319960594, -0.018761368468403816, 0.021948980167508125, -0.0433444008231163, 0.004375047516077757, -0.03982481732964516, 0.05323266237974167, 0.02244717627763748, 0.007988667115569115, 0.008897129446268082, 0.04008573293685913, -0.026692233979701996, 0.010880043730139732, 0.0004309945506975055, -0.06157203018665314, 0.027060434222221375, 0.005008825566619635, 0.00347153446637094, -0.015876401215791702, -0.03449385613203049, -0.052040573209524155, -0.02995496243238449, 0.021824177354574203, -0.01832546666264534, -0.026450837031006813, -0.006943240761756897, -0.0074362982995808125, 0.047295019030570984, -0.003243468701839447, -0.025000745430588722, -0.061668433248996735, 0.017561066895723343, 0.026447121053934097, -0.026086894795298576, 0.005287256557494402, 0.00037560288910754025, -0.007783672772347927, 0.03278125822544098, 0.019326088950037956, -0.007565129082649946, 0.02186998911201954, -0.004700405057519674, 0.006336720194667578, 0.017532477155327797, 0.030910909175872803, -0.023267561569809914, 0.02041390910744667, 0.03254631906747818, -0.03106680139899254, -0.017841650173068047, 0.04160064458847046, 0.0032532494515180588, 0.04162999987602234, 0.0192139632999897, 0.02937062457203865, -0.01399069931358099, 0.012434198521077633, -0.01252842042595148, -0.005405924748629332, -0.038733139634132385, -0.026428526267409325, 0.02657294273376465, 0.019687656313180923, -0.04622223228216171, -0.0009431192884221673, -0.01276823878288269, 0.003976622596383095, 0.05954624339938164, 0.03658721223473549, -0.01831265538930893, 0.007011743728071451, -0.0002539326378609985, 0.018243912607431412, 0.03278733417391777, -0.023067541420459747, 0.022998806089162827, 0.06869373470544815, -0.008145221509039402, 0.026200754567980766, -0.02750256285071373, 0.017108675092458725, -0.07006340473890305, -0.0680077075958252, -0.010787039995193481, -0.00007008644024608657, 0.046866487711668015, -0.0361897274851799, 0.04888865351676941, 0.037924956530332565, -0.031655725091695786, 0.007396923843771219, -0.004902512766420841, -0.03406619653105736, 0.0033016668166965246, 0.014846988022327423, 0.0203270111232996, 0.059726741164922714, 0.03345854952931404, 0.02011229656636715, 0.03600041940808296, -0.0007938516791909933, 0.022862106561660767, -0.034955963492393494, -0.014157620258629322, 0.03182824328541756, -0.014164668507874012, -0.05982410907745361, 0.034160226583480835, -0.031642161309719086, -0.027209969237446785, 0.02614729478955269, 0.001705068163573742, 0.034698907285928726, 0.08406122773885727, 0.04325880855321884, 0.04349745810031891, 0.0612434521317482, 0.011910351924598217, -0.0042407759465277195, -0.03756670281291008, 0.010570308193564415, 0.0405600368976593, 0.05324758216738701, -0.05011417344212532, -0.00457809679210186, 0.016004543751478195, -0.04135563224554062, -0.027200719341635704, 0.005986561067402363, -0.03508765995502472, -0.01402850728482008, 0.00862194038927555, -0.02529500238597393, 0.0004027918039355427, -0.02057194896042347, 0.028239760547876358, -0.05782078951597214, 0.014096221886575222, 0.03277265653014183, 0.0683913379907608, -0.041821662336587906, 0.022353721782565117, -0.0005005209241062403, -0.031855013221502304, 0.006151901558041573, -0.01815064251422882, -0.04438597708940506, -0.03757559508085251, 0.00788477249443531, -0.011508557945489883, -0.01535656675696373, -0.015246504917740822, 0.012151156552135944, -0.0787484422326088, 0.018738649785518646, -0.024052539840340614, 0.007148368284106255, 0.04411061108112335, -0.019761519506573677, 0.011852344498038292, -0.09828543663024902, 0.05370493233203888, 0.048724956810474396, -0.0412493571639061, -0.05151776969432831, -0.030007455497980118, -0.04724886640906334, 0.0034254896454513073, 0.04688185080885887, -0.002727842889726162, 0.0027770926244556904, -0.029430465772747993, 0.03948540985584259, 0.01870306208729744, -0.024709029123187065, 0.0351187102496624, 0.006182533223181963, -0.06007802113890648, -0.04788651689887047, 0.014886870980262756, 0.02500014565885067, -0.00717830890789628, 0.03511691465973854, -0.010995253920555115, 0.03448839858174324, -0.014946753159165382, -0.011179680936038494, 0.02634466253221035, 0.009904833510518074, -0.01010524295270443, 0.032953228801488876, -0.0014483836712315679, -0.008528449572622776, 0.03903757035732269, 0.02276468276977539, -0.05539195239543915, 0.05384206771850586, -0.02231631614267826, 0.0003164636727888137, 0.013196002691984177, 0.01623956486582756, 0.01935083419084549, -0.045421868562698364, 0.016590574756264687, 0.020005622878670692, -0.010060537606477737, 0.004682279657572508, 0.020810918882489204, 0.03888027369976044, 0.0473887175321579, 0.023102546110749245, 0.004776290617883205, -0.02617328241467476, -0.05182668939232826, 0.0477377325296402, 0.015427671372890472, -0.006413055583834648, -0.019005371257662773, 0.0399865098297596, 0.03925497457385063, -0.021908044815063477, 0.021814437583088875, 0.022823164239525795, 0.016651896759867668, 0.000757447793148458, -0.0020470519084483385, -0.012288830243051052, -0.018748290836811066, 0.03791460394859314, 0.026605065912008286, -0.006782678421586752, 0.0821726992726326, -0.03113945946097374, 0.003211462404578924, -0.008563938550651073, -0.004436112940311432, -0.047301582992076874, -0.02316618151962757, 0.03500241041183472, 0.03978307917714119, 0.006576751358807087, 0.014421586878597736, 0.03611810505390167, 0.006983765866607428, 0.029412245377898216, -0.0035040744114667177, 0.003400371875613928, -0.027670104056596756, -0.011981409974396229, -0.01756630651652813, -0.03754137083888054, -0.006221844349056482, -0.028487490490078926, 0.033338457345962524, 0.0054704281501472, 0.010107782669365406, -0.0025364276953041553, -0.02828814461827278, 0.045538000762462616, 0.05221618339419365, -0.05744094029068947, -0.02041419968008995, -0.040320299565792084, 0.01624939776957035, -0.021710442379117012, -0.0174636859446764 ]
<p>My book outlines a procedure but a preliminary part of it is unclear to me. </p> <p>Let X be the number of occurences of an event over a unit of time and assume that it has a Poisson distribution with mean $m=\lambda $. Let $T_1, T_2 , T_3, \ldots $ be the interarrival times of the occurences and they are iid with an exponential $\lambda $ distribution. Note that $ X=k $ iff $$ \sum_{j=1}^k T_j \leq 1 \quad \text{and} \quad \sum_{j=1}^{k+1} T_j &gt;1. $$</p> <p>This is precisely what I do not understand. Why does the total waiting tme until $k$ occurences have to be less than or equal to 1? Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you.</p>
74,460
[ 0.003967277240008116, -0.06729979068040848, 0.02003045566380024, -0.0003639749775175005, 0.014114340767264366, 0.0007639164687134326, 0.008115109987556934, 0.007769345305860043, 0.03159235045313835, 0.012007957324385643, 0.0270835030823946, 0.05274966359138489, 0.05566702038049698, -0.0007309971260838211, 0.050827641040086746, -0.005703425034880638, -0.028849277645349503, -0.0040613277815282345, 0.0062324595637619495, -0.034027766436338425, 0.011557829566299915, 0.009959330782294273, 0.005659064743667841, -0.037895239889621735, -0.01951712556183338, 0.009401083923876286, -0.016635099425911903, -0.009132102131843567, 0.025069503113627434, 0.045371461659669876, -0.05714385211467743, -0.022972898557782173, 0.029009873047471046, 0.048989780247211456, 0.007512764539569616, 0.019249415025115013, -0.048524994403123856, -0.04619763046503067, -0.0021807090379297733, 0.024367880076169968, -0.04253162443637848, -0.04406340792775154, -0.0050669764168560505, -0.0005733342259190977, -0.016181936487555504, 0.03801437467336655, 0.004953252151608467, -0.05141003057360649, 0.01797710731625557, -0.03446947783231735, 0.043045658618211746, 0.022106021642684937, 0.0532841719686985, -0.0008195122936740518, 0.020244242623448372, 0.0004140081873629242, 0.05331270769238472, 0.04288671165704727, 0.018323108553886414, -0.009943822398781776, -0.02674689143896103, -0.038565099239349365, 0.0011052601039409637, -0.006185921840369701, -0.007884579710662365, -0.0010265865130349994, -0.01683775894343853, 0.002836991101503372, 0.06436633318662643, -0.05233096331357956, 0.02856922522187233, 0.012082666158676147, 0.03916988521814346, -0.007134521845728159, -0.018277129158377647, 0.014730674214661121, 0.03633100539445877, 0.012884783558547497, 0.051605548709630966, 0.025964533910155296, 0.03277735039591789, 0.03622793033719063, 0.039999887347221375, 0.06544015556573868, -0.024018049240112305, -0.01672329381108284, 0.10155940800905228, 0.012553094886243343, 0.0011760410852730274, -0.0002514648949727416, -0.013797592371702194, 0.02479306422173977, 0.01632843352854252, -0.024820107966661453, -0.03738545998930931, 0.02849447727203369, -0.033126384019851685, 0.009176502004265785, -0.008367654867470264, 0.022916380316019058, -0.015399028547108173, -0.05062258243560791, 0.027048656716942787, 0.03531869128346443, -0.0032752081751823425, 0.000778873567469418, -0.04033427685499191, 0.025300895795226097, -0.012607457116246223, -0.00437889201566577, -0.03357610106468201, 0.03104797750711441, 0.022993681952357292, -0.008458912372589111, -0.027910199016332626, 0.0028377643320709467, 0.004531089682132006, -0.007435432635247707, 0.021678123623132706, 0.0746476873755455, 0.046686429530382156, -0.014748437330126762, 0.015001026913523674, -0.006388354580849409, -0.06063959375023842, 0.0009609130793251097, 0.03692510724067688, -0.023205434903502464, -0.04745336249470711, 0.0712573453783989, 0.008003461174666882, -0.0012267400743439794, 0.04248591512441635, 0.030809365212917328, 0.043648481369018555, -0.03570743650197983, -0.07319820672273636, -0.036869775503873825, 0.028372788801789284, -0.009644268080592155, -0.01160909328609705, -0.07945969700813293, 0.001124552683904767, 0.06516402959823608, 0.052529364824295044, -0.004277619533240795, 0.02891700156033039, -0.013652958907186985, -0.0367429181933403, 0.040693674236536026, -0.048974767327308655, -0.030674118548631668, 0.015940016135573387, -0.030932297930121422, 0.034398868680000305, -0.06720530986785889, -0.005516610108315945, 0.03850628063082695, 0.018725182861089706, -0.0002020042884396389, 0.051858462393283844, 0.013594318181276321, -0.04125369340181351, -0.008447814732789993, 0.02673099748790264, -0.031290072947740555, 0.03223478049039841, 0.009092246182262897, 0.03592604026198387, -0.0031656301580369473, 0.03277899697422981, 0.010100018233060837, 0.0021658707410097122, 0.05893704295158386, 0.015857473015785217, -0.04140558838844299, -0.0024348616134375334, -0.025537963956594467, -0.0033821118995547295, 0.031302258372306824, 0.005331673659384251, 0.0101366201415658, -0.006560983136296272, 0.0068613444454967976, 0.011841246858239174, 0.0035997647792100906, 0.013682406395673752, 0.03683512657880783, -0.009184037335216999, -0.002179794479161501, -0.05776083841919899, -0.04568848758935928, 0.003111871425062418, 0.042529016733169556, -0.03912946581840515, 0.04829826578497887, -0.019316067919135094, 0.004646093584597111, -0.02459154836833477, -0.002172409323975444, -0.012601836584508419, -0.016302630305290222, 0.00044451048597693443, -0.07182993739843369, 0.02328784205019474, 0.06427714228630066, 0.058660510927438736, -0.008364510722458363, 0.026952946558594704, -0.03438498452305794, -0.025354988873004913, -0.012585089541971684, -0.025794057175517082, 0.02055923268198967, -0.018590088933706284, -0.01827041432261467, 0.00414797430858016, -0.007707871962338686, 0.006186026614159346, 0.03772832453250885, -0.052429139614105225, 0.026296058669686317, 0.04305325075984001, 0.04737222194671631, -0.008804380893707275, 0.026824671775102615, 0.019209016114473343, 0.017427124083042145, -0.022374920547008514, -0.04235103353857994, -0.041568055748939514, -0.027591070160269737, 0.038018375635147095, 0.030573012307286263, -0.00332388817332685, 0.013889007270336151, 0.06468962877988815, 0.011597719043493271, 0.047088637948036194, 0.04209114983677864, 0.0009111795807257295, -0.010788694024085999, 0.020400725305080414, 0.04454430192708969, 0.007104654796421528, 0.004973906092345715, 0.003881890792399645, -0.019089866429567337, 0.03594481572508812, -0.014847119338810444, 0.005813281983137131, 0.023290902376174927, -0.00006629241397604346, 0.027149828150868416, -0.039396338164806366, 0.0020301700569689274, 0.04194668307900429, -0.00917951762676239, 0.0057616764679551125, 0.009099905379116535, 0.03001471981406212, 0.03973495215177536, 0.00281891250051558, -0.018929272890090942, 0.02252003364264965, -0.012850656174123287, -0.05136488378047943, -0.025523334741592407, 0.005474549252539873, -0.047360558062791824, 0.051576271653175354, -0.01670238934457302, -0.06314101070165634, -0.031998325139284134, 0.018334785476326942, 0.03641948848962784, 0.005022040102630854, 0.014183628372848034, -0.03372381627559662, -0.021295921877026558, -0.025563523173332214, 0.0013632747577503324, 0.03715146705508232, -0.0034663844853639603, -0.05974898114800453, -0.012501792050898075, -0.01849615015089512, -0.06721576303243637, 0.05493559315800667, -0.016574006527662277, 0.019118657335639, 0.0032332041300833225, -0.00641976110637188, -0.033835891634225845, -0.03433247283101082, -0.024495074525475502, 0.0023572477512061596, -0.03448672220110893, -0.010248364880681038, 0.06253264099359512, 0.01747179962694645, -0.04197201132774353, 0.03139597922563553, -0.05164491757750511, -0.03155549243092537, -0.060068484395742416, 0.0028900261968374252, -0.002046937122941017, -0.05159533768892288, 0.020102359354496002, 0.027773749083280563, -0.009876689873635769, 0.0015764838317409158, -0.06025030463933945, -0.08141326904296875, -0.010275068692862988, -0.03050028532743454, 0.07795820385217667, 0.003976199775934219, -0.04300825297832489, 0.05650079622864723, 0.0344964861869812, 0.0008817092166282237, -0.0005323457880876958, 0.019588198512792587, -0.02116543799638748, -0.03811270743608475, 0.04626515880227089, -0.007369840983301401, -0.01585841178894043, 0.0353676900267601, 0.011735868640244007, 0.05290306359529495, 0.0700293779373169, -0.022537555545568466, -0.013307968154549599, 0.02222583256661892, 0.017979323863983154, -0.002708549378439784, 0.04181920364499092, 0.023478670045733452, -0.012379651889204979, -0.0024505078326910734, -0.023347914218902588, 0.009070788510143757, -0.00044521145173348486, -0.048558227717876434, -0.0005942481220699847, 0.007270128466188908, 0.0215433482080698, -0.032789234071969986, 0.0245442483574152, 0.00219916645437479, -0.053017571568489075, 0.029454022645950317, 0.02514140121638775, 0.022298427298665047, -0.0522916242480278, 0.013608802109956741, 0.03177948296070099, 0.06375765055418015, -0.03296357020735741, -0.024998923763632774, -0.01412403304129839, -0.019213249906897545, 0.014279168099164963, -0.025596091523766518, -0.010718419216573238, 0.026832537725567818, 0.011556098237633705, -0.005119169596582651, -0.025837630033493042, -0.022209828719496727, -0.019416775554418564, -0.011777132749557495, -0.017656613141298294, 0.02242576703429222, 0.056362591683864594, -0.0008532500360161066, 0.05526801943778992, 0.008986582979559898, 0.006173925939947367, 0.022332284599542618, 0.004744573496282101, -0.055929578840732574, 0.01712392270565033, -0.023065704852342606, -0.01113109104335308, -0.0009955207351595163, 0.028365986421704292, 0.018846968188881874, -0.019442128017544746, 0.011200102046132088, -0.006433908827602863, 0.0025151653680950403, -0.04081372916698456, 0.013361969031393528, -0.022710323333740234, -0.015047607012093067, -0.027359122410416603, 0.005988375749439001, 0.027775831520557404, -0.0053197708912193775, 0.04335561767220497, 0.008789366111159325, -0.011146909557282925, -0.020183971151709557, 0.005720752757042646, -0.03531275689601898, 0.017652422189712524, 0.02844954840838909, 0.038778726011514664, 0.0011502978159114718, -0.04549235850572586, -0.001418932108208537, 0.0368959978222847, 0.05124146118760109, 0.038950737565755844, 0.004152845125645399, 0.014159416779875755, -0.0379478745162487, -0.03184936195611954, 0.023751480504870415, 0.02899617701768875, 0.03273206204175949, -0.005223679356276989, 0.021008463576436043, 0.03549092635512352, -0.046587586402893066, 0.02825595811009407, 0.04323345422744751, 0.007209846284240484, 0.007475084159523249, -0.031248221173882484, -0.012107690796256065, -0.02665560320019722, 0.026548177003860474, -0.004968041088432074, 0.019153445959091187, 0.022053824737668037, 0.01202765479683876, 0.030619638040661812, -0.03266940638422966, -0.0010075696045532823, -0.017556890845298767, 0.013559825718402863, 0.017982082441449165, 0.009826427325606346, -0.03198015317320824, 0.057173728942871094, 0.00904997531324625, 0.018894555047154427, 0.02803138829767704, 0.005204073153436184, -0.06310150772333145, -0.05013158172369003, 0.03396901860833168, 0.05628306418657303, -0.014313340187072754, -0.007336762268096209, -0.06384233385324478, 0.0022078908514231443, 0.02570164203643799, -0.02560356818139553, 0.04580089822411537, -0.012102514505386353, -0.024905607104301453, 0.00274327932856977, -0.03131181746721268, -0.03623715788125992, 0.019151005893945694, 0.009773807600140572, 0.04338686168193817, -0.012152445502579212, 0.011618024669587612, -0.035455022007226944, -0.012480790726840496, 0.0365825779736042, 0.061982885003089905, -0.018060142174363136, -0.015271228738129139, 0.005339979659765959, 0.00005170055010239594, -0.014243780635297298, -0.06421486288309097, 0.03421303629875183, -0.038180697709321976, 0.026891188696026802, 0.05488695576786995, -0.03750627860426903, -0.02252914011478424, 0.026012873277068138, 0.05043170601129532, -0.018970152363181114, -0.02411782741546631, -0.02308238111436367, 0.05667152255773544, 0.022216401994228363, -0.0314595103263855, 0.06028546765446663, 0.031006617471575737, 0.021556999534368515, 0.037847284227609634, 0.015481648966670036, -0.017801102250814438, -0.01778499409556389, -0.009419995360076427, -0.04128493368625641, 0.01941550523042679, -0.02497221529483795, 0.025524724274873734, -0.01773468777537346, -0.01088325958698988, -0.0018638548208400607, -0.003286885330453515, 0.04024883359670639, 0.03508384898304939, 0.017811093479394913, 0.026312343776226044, -0.02280483953654766, 0.02143602818250656, 0.0018527406500652432, -0.01660902425646782, 0.0451657809317112, -0.034523334354162216, -0.0001797611766960472, 0.025690512731671333, 0.0002688171516638249, 0.013086166232824326, -0.0455843023955822, 0.019959131255745888, 0.02660435065627098, 0.003307337872684002, 0.028594527393579483, -0.016905121505260468, 0.028629539534449577, 0.0034320096019655466, -0.034813590347766876, -0.008275162428617477, -0.006533331237733364, -0.03866896033287048, 0.051365453749895096, -0.024088043719530106, 0.030504152178764343, -0.0048930528573691845, -0.007985192351043224, -0.10963016003370285, -0.039651304483413696, 0.03601580858230591, -0.022431407123804092, -0.05866903439164162, -0.009627830237150192, -0.003401790978386998, -0.04221551492810249, -0.03759784251451492, -0.012499633245170116, 0.05039997771382332, -0.016026191413402557, -0.027486033737659454, 0.013019569218158722, 0.03919300436973572, 0.050613969564437866, 0.015738898888230324, -0.019362550228834152, 0.022123051807284355, -0.012430434115231037, -0.03466916084289551, -0.006560231558978558, 0.039182793349027634, -0.03290058672428131, -0.013208579272031784, -0.013415731489658356, 0.0074156285263597965, -0.01177743636071682, -0.05619318410754204, -0.0713629350066185, 0.008846436627209187, 0.010160650126636028, 0.015988629311323166, -0.048241447657346725, 0.004311640281230211, 0.017534106969833374, 0.005080883856862783, -0.003115070518106222, 0.007697966881096363, -0.016545524820685387, -0.016163749620318413, 0.040824439376592636, -0.007237339857965708, 0.04043450951576233, 0.0316082201898098, 0.05529577657580376, -0.0064393822103738785, 0.010678131133317947, -0.009329363703727722, -0.0008235340937972069, 0.046409156173467636, -0.026193274185061455, -0.021173793822526932, 0.02166617289185524, 0.005000641103833914, -0.021667160093784332, -0.006294147577136755, -0.05843793973326683, 0.04147319495677948, 0.05284535884857178, -0.03776083141565323, 0.03575045242905617, 0.024812761694192886, 0.013628805987536907, -0.002286795061081648, 0.007218918297439814, -0.013402705080807209, 0.016653016209602356, 0.009574230760335922, 0.023685786873102188, -0.018345041200518608, 0.017883379012346268, 0.053010936826467514, 0.016223423182964325, 0.022914230823516846, 0.016427982598543167, -0.023128630593419075, -0.010699978098273277, 0.001891752821393311, -0.0033982263412326574, -0.016685856506228447, 0.013095153495669365, -0.010576820001006126, 0.013720929622650146, -0.0288540106266737, -0.037043213844299316, 0.03857516869902611, 0.01604991778731346, -0.002085631713271141, -0.054037049412727356, -0.014080489985644817, -0.04064260050654411, 0.024308403953909874, 0.03699575364589691, 0.020846907049417496, 0.04128505289554596, 0.022397328168153763, 0.043688707053661346, 0.0015339752426370978, 0.00403295224532485, 0.014025656506419182, -0.03828980028629303, -0.03428783640265465, -0.038632892072200775, -0.047131747007369995, 0.006440884433686733, -0.0030873434152454138, -0.03965387120842934, -0.005953543353825808, -0.0029917536303400993, 0.020272156223654747, 0.007647702004760504, 0.03575873002409935, -0.006175583694130182, 0.10674840956926346, 0.046539612114429474, 0.04764305427670479, -0.0004027897957712412, 0.03570064529776573, 0.10775604844093323, 0.05303368344902992, 0.021457156166434288, -0.052773404866456985, 0.02166692540049553, 0.007814071141183376, -0.0009502880275249481, -0.03915989026427269, 0.022319577634334564, -0.0066963802091777325, -0.005705559626221657, 0.029542868956923485, 0.044428177177906036, -0.011600448749959469, -0.02122132107615471, 0.05437358468770981, -0.035798173397779465, -0.0411297008395195, -0.007153598591685295, -0.01335796620696783, 0.04060014709830284, -0.008525016717612743, -0.08145911246538162, 0.023355809971690178, -0.017320338636636734, -0.00429387716576457, -0.0029692600946873426, -0.010951419360935688, -0.03612694516777992, -0.02185591123998165, -0.021636804565787315, -0.010619322769343853, 0.05530818551778793, -0.034928321838378906, -0.019369827583432198, 0.020547596737742424, -0.019343476742506027, -0.05708989500999451, 0.05023860186338425, 0.05384032055735588, 0.009330418892204762, 0.0013731117360293865, 0.03896081820130348, 0.008987629786133766, -0.040269456803798676, -0.022439880296587944, -0.025183944031596184, 0.042844418436288834, -0.02816084772348404, 0.013318627141416073, -0.017552951350808144, -0.023302029818296432, -0.009387819096446037, -0.044552452862262726, -0.01662149280309677, -0.022717630490660667, 0.014795723371207714, -0.025307100266218185, 0.003501665545627475, -0.07389401644468307, -0.012870105914771557, 0.007369666360318661, 0.011627891100943089, 0.0439792275428772, -0.04516937956213951, 0.019846772775053978, -0.06076200306415558, 0.04105537384748459, -0.0062210517935454845, 0.011725794523954391, -0.03895963728427887, -0.036182552576065063, -0.0026806837413460016, 0.016990812495350838, -0.016516737639904022, -0.021976588293910027, 0.029096219688653946, -0.008584822528064251, -0.03039209358394146, 0.011475751176476479, -0.03766526281833649, -0.026011167094111443, -0.03379099816083908, -0.027869854122400284, -0.04919801652431488, -0.026836859062314034, 0.01293190848082304, 0.0309099480509758, 0.015683811157941818, 0.01879548653960228, 0.019736239686608315, 0.046412888914346695, 0.018912626430392265, -0.03995968773961067, 0.015021730214357376, -0.024100156500935555, 0.0036085171159356833, 0.004711370915174484, -0.018258335068821907, 0.04326169937849045, 0.03779831528663635, 0.013368992134928703, 0.028712401166558266, -0.01185335498303175, -0.013074956834316254, 0.022455519065260887, -0.003919034730643034, -0.019369876012206078, -0.0021367063745856285, 0.029351815581321716, 0.02356952428817749, -0.028570132330060005, -0.02456379495561123, -0.005205524619668722, 0.007451786659657955, 0.024806853383779526, -0.06311823427677155, -0.03877022862434387, -0.027125179767608643, -0.02293744869530201, 0.03871484845876694, 0.0003887514758389443, -0.003245868720114231, -0.01239087339490652, 0.01851666159927845, -0.012583083473145962, -0.0003958537126891315, -0.022914128378033638, 0.004665538668632507, -0.022375592961907387, 0.004025359638035297, 0.011960224248468876, 0.0000702540492056869, 0.008827722631394863, 0.007683095522224903, 0.01675717905163765, -0.0216764397919178, 0.031818974763154984, -0.033065926283597946, -0.036922626197338104, 0.06352183222770691, -0.04472140595316887, -0.01894739456474781, 0.0317143090069294, 0.016036437824368477, 0.026628531515598297, 0.005544949322938919, -0.015445603057742119, -0.06491173058748245, 0.00435926066711545, -0.044390249997377396, 0.0025087175890803337, 0.011842376552522182, -0.0009871022775769234, 0.03332241252064705, -0.022206038236618042, -0.03954245522618294, 0.017610959708690643, -0.005499460734426975, -0.019121086224913597, 0.049057573080062866, -0.022576451301574707, -0.03288887068629265, -0.0029994570650160313, 0.02610035613179207, 0.04046586528420448, 0.0019360171863809228, 0.006744331680238247, 0.03697264567017555, 0.06141527369618416, -0.02926560491323471, 0.035053178668022156, -0.04173470288515091, -0.0192926824092865, -0.06318085640668869, -0.006470364984124899, -0.03142967447638512, -0.004013030789792538, 0.029406143352389336, -0.004635173361748457, -0.043044865131378174, 0.024283241480588913, -0.02164262719452381, 0.05149096995592117, 0.005832344759255648, -0.02313384599983692, -0.05099998041987419, 0.011340046301484108, 0.0027483091689646244, 0.009890923276543617, 0.028353417292237282, 0.005718032363802195, 0.028686443343758583, 0.042027950286865234, -0.009103753603994846, -0.017345990985631943, -0.008710495196282864, 0.03159738704562187, 0.012154811061918736, -0.059647638350725174, 0.03531485050916672, -0.042121388018131256, -0.028248192742466927, 0.03019712120294571, -0.007434910628944635, -0.0434984527528286, 0.010326548479497433, 0.017015554010868073, -0.03772631660103798, 0.03251846134662628, 0.0424799844622612, -0.016866350546479225, 0.07517078518867493, 0.008083486929535866, 0.018390782177448273, 0.005421668291091919, -0.018584422767162323, -0.006656724959611893, 0.08762966841459274, -0.03290240839123726, -0.046590618789196014, 0.017405642196536064, 0.0196396391838789, -0.023938152939081192, 0.00946106482297182, 0.022546449676156044, 0.016232497990131378, -0.04386671259999275, 0.02448895014822483, -0.0031880729366093874, -0.014422823674976826, 0.05377606675028801, 0.04322835057973862, -0.030386898666620255, -0.008726436644792557, -0.039149556308984756, -0.033411718904972076, 0.024041078984737396, 0.030947599560022354, -0.03711891174316406, -0.06727012246847153, 0.015601630322635174, -0.005019283387809992, 0.01852208375930786, -0.030286945402622223, -0.02226291596889496, -0.056384116411209106, 0.014469899237155914, -0.023752758279442787, -0.015972955152392387, 0.009825840592384338, 0.0015465094475075603, 0.026270687580108643, -0.069327712059021, 0.04994136095046997, -0.00560038024559617, -0.01022975705564022, -0.041737597435712814, -0.056348346173763275, -0.029751619324088097, -0.019102413207292557, 0.06877314299345016, 0.024858392775058746, -0.0450524277985096, 0.032727040350437164, 0.03306741267442703, 0.02290693111717701, -0.05050233379006386, 0.03532001003623009, -0.03407515585422516, -0.014630397781729698, -0.015592326410114765, -0.008239839226007462, 0.022750884294509888, -0.01762722246348858, -0.0026522637344896793, -0.011634673923254013, 0.010832998901605606, -0.028700754046440125, -0.011316102929413319, -0.011396070010960102, 0.01315287221223116, -0.02805091254413128, 0.051544517278671265, 0.013815095648169518, 0.027249690145254135, 0.0029452417511492968, -0.0060745058581233025, -0.08259007334709167, 0.0022300465498119593, -0.05062907561659813, 0.031043346971273422, 0.008903424255549908, -0.0025611303281039, -0.0065200007520616055, -0.08641721308231354, -0.017878297716379166, 0.02089712768793106, -0.006072985008358955, -0.021511418744921684, 0.057347748428583145, 0.0515463724732399, 0.02832218073308468, -0.030837085098028183, 0.008218332193791866, -0.01611875183880329, -0.009907248429954052, 0.04407817870378494, 0.05431048199534416, 0.015936333686113358, -0.022158252075314522, 0.0026662868913263083, -0.007594638969749212, -0.027790937572717667, 0.0533578097820282, 0.001859763404354453, 0.03507547080516815, 0.016143884509801865, -0.026359640061855316, 0.027217069640755653, -0.0159929096698761, -0.011014026589691639, 0.015997126698493958, 0.007046337705105543, 0.06092408671975136, -0.02085937187075615, 0.05265146121382713, -0.004776413086801767, -0.02006824128329754, -0.028305020183324814, -0.01908651925623417, 0.019051294773817062, 0.018940594047307968, -0.05019013211131096, 0.010103721171617508, -0.0025119874626398087, 0.011964980512857437, -0.0023826914839446545, -0.05605557933449745, 0.015313317067921162, 0.028841685503721237, -0.013536989688873291, -0.013165125623345375, -0.05497632920742035, 0.012894255109131336, -0.019758274778723717, 0.017335571348667145, 0.04304911196231842, 0.014517600648105145, 0.007945900782942772, -0.02413100190460682, -0.005620977375656366, 0.024868611246347427, -0.05874989926815033, -0.04060383141040802, -0.09177939593791962, 0.018726030364632607, 0.01779869571328163, 0.006657756399363279 ]
<p>I have obtained optimally scaled variables from a highly mixed nature of data containing binary, nominal, ordinal and scale type variables. The optimal scaling was obtained in SPSS through a CATPCA procedure. Now I want to use these variables in a Factor Analysis and want to use a rotation to obtain meaningful loads. What I think is that I should avoid any normality assumption for these optimally scaled variables. So, maximum likelihood method of factor extraction is probably not applicable here (although I am not so good at FA, so not exactly sure). Should I use principal components method of factor extraction instead? </p> <p>What else method can be useful that avoids distributional assumption?</p> <p>If I want the factor scores in a further regression as IVs, will it be at all a good idea to use oblique rotation? I think I should try to keep the factors as uncorrelated as possible if I want them as IVs in a further regression. Is this concept right?</p> <p>Thanks for any kind of suggestion. :)</p>
37,345
[ -0.03559161722660065, 0.013941608369350433, -0.009413226507604122, -0.01028405874967575, 0.04766353219747543, 0.0017738931346684694, -0.01074099913239479, 0.011824918910861015, 0.03442570939660072, -0.038254514336586, 0.015175013802945614, 0.0030429624021053314, 0.024937326088547707, 0.01213838066905737, -0.01506741438060999, -0.003751300973817706, -0.026961205527186394, 0.033584024757146835, -0.03362899273633957, 0.02525191567838192, -0.01358780451118946, 0.022554142400622368, -0.010349380783736706, -0.00019378142314963043, -0.0009050932130776346, 0.03441775590181351, 0.02365218475461006, -0.026240823790431023, 0.006018442567437887, 0.029717886820435524, -0.0038229606579989195, -0.014645062386989594, 0.0050386046059429646, 0.021505707874894142, 0.01680154539644718, 0.026713652536273003, -0.00005613895336864516, 0.022062717005610466, -0.004789758939296007, 0.04985234886407852, -0.020656535401940346, -0.013580258935689926, -0.016514135524630547, 0.014897599816322327, 0.012249085120856762, 0.03425145894289017, -0.022950362414121628, 0.008009388111531734, 0.02508588135242462, -0.04489029943943024, 0.08724154531955719, 0.011163832619786263, -0.010452713817358017, 0.013001101091504097, 0.013507680967450142, -0.04592518135905266, 0.043049681931734085, 0.04200590029358864, -0.012237673625349998, -0.051357220858335495, -0.0017638852586969733, -0.043626878410577774, -0.013251498341560364, -0.029875438660383224, -0.01298019103705883, 0.013906801119446754, 0.026308732107281685, -0.005556183401495218, 0.08721967041492462, -0.016681000590324402, 0.032942257821559906, 0.012108497321605682, 0.03916124626994133, -0.021640190854668617, -0.02851802483201027, -0.05193698778748512, 0.023840127512812614, -0.000842725916299969, 0.013196628540754318, 0.024505484849214554, 0.014817317016422749, 0.02801325172185898, -0.0022343455348163843, 0.006470357533544302, 0.0010396342258900404, 0.014752778224647045, 0.0642065703868866, -0.03981199860572815, -0.002265780931338668, 0.03361242637038231, 0.008079812861979008, -0.004169192630797625, 0.03344365209341049, -0.005807971581816673, -0.030087793245911598, 0.03889869898557663, 0.001389198936522007, 0.006550718564540148, -0.022924071177840233, -0.0003833462833426893, -0.039277564734220505, -0.013416903093457222, -0.029830509796738625, 0.0737316831946373, -0.018395422026515007, 0.022266343235969543, -0.0328642912209034, 0.016555823385715485, -0.00745338574051857, -0.016701534390449524, 0.006391800008714199, -0.032473549246788025, 0.021973852068185806, 0.004525366704910994, 0.020231083035469055, -0.015010105445981026, -0.009280472062528133, -0.03820113465189934, 0.05778153985738754, 0.08130694180727005, 0.012156454846262932, -0.041358090937137604, 0.021892882883548737, -0.01803436502814293, -0.035771578550338745, 0.01669156551361084, 0.01105665136128664, 0.024362491443753242, -0.03499052673578262, 0.034653786569833755, 0.0017057133372873068, -0.010097983293235302, 0.05386030301451683, -0.00008311605779454112, -0.005106418859213591, -0.01060887984931469, -0.0932527408003807, -0.04407668113708496, 0.032184772193431854, -0.043979741632938385, 0.030440006405115128, -0.0766378864645958, -0.015679923817515373, 0.03086518496274948, 0.06597188860177994, 0.014854693785309792, 0.020294396206736565, 0.010530021041631699, 0.06409726291894913, -0.006733250338584185, -0.031807806342840195, -0.04051394760608673, -0.04048004373908043, -0.06404668092727661, -0.02599259279668331, -0.08117549121379852, 0.010821552947163582, 0.010548071004450321, -0.002705832477658987, -0.019561661407351494, 0.04137318208813667, -0.0007936661713756621, -0.02344515547156334, -0.004076648969203234, -0.0038547676522284746, 0.008222456090152264, 0.009967147372663021, -0.045148082077503204, 0.044103145599365234, 0.024961061775684357, -0.01862083189189434, 0.0292225182056427, 0.01030349638313055, 0.06009915843605995, 0.03282792121171951, -0.020718252286314964, 0.020875943824648857, -0.02912916988134384, 0.03251273185014725, 0.00378630543127656, -0.036817487329244614, -0.04749862849712372, -0.04530453309416771, -0.012205449864268303, 0.016601866111159325, 0.06772594898939133, -0.006362278945744038, -0.03779382258653641, 0.02995247021317482, -0.07035117596387863, -0.012613863684237003, -0.023796727880835533, 0.014535631984472275, -0.003330696141347289, -0.021084964275360107, 0.04303590953350067, -0.007278584875166416, 0.018515851348638535, 0.027948938310146332, 0.005028510931879282, -0.0174770038574934, -0.016773609444499016, 0.034398071467876434, -0.01782950572669506, 0.008167988620698452, 0.055981650948524475, 0.008196892216801643, -0.026276428252458572, 0.015874620527029037, -0.01738853007555008, -0.04817038029432297, 0.01923145167529583, -0.04079657420516014, 0.03284065052866936, -0.01655006967484951, 0.0024938066489994526, 0.025740431621670723, 0.023962760344147682, -0.04601511359214783, 0.0012253631139174104, -0.013786832801997662, 0.08078917860984802, 0.04884859547019005, -0.029901066794991493, -0.006944615393877029, 0.0550135038793087, 0.034292761236429214, 0.015333572402596474, -0.01596147008240223, 0.010862624272704124, -0.06577782332897186, -0.0109555097296834, 0.04923130199313164, 0.019326534122228622, -0.08124937117099762, 0.01670580729842186, 0.03211048245429993, 0.02196541801095009, 0.029882093891501427, 0.045268576592206955, -0.021022476255893707, -0.03983570635318756, 0.022450467571616173, 0.02910032868385315, 0.002689663553610444, -0.011689244769513607, 0.004680588375777006, 0.011740367859601974, 0.06521743535995483, 0.010636393912136555, -0.00978364422917366, 0.027701163664460182, 0.03488057106733322, 0.023204078897833824, 0.024516085162758827, -0.00998286996036768, 0.0652080774307251, -0.01730494014918804, 0.023210672661662102, 0.052827343344688416, -0.03169725090265274, 0.007447435054928064, 0.006550954654812813, 0.028068507090210915, 0.014544451609253883, 0.03695501759648323, -0.029230758547782898, 0.011577604338526726, 0.022557316347956657, -0.01965857855975628, -0.003222088562324643, -0.02325008437037468, -0.02200617454946041, -0.03873865678906441, -0.032131750136613846, 0.03189888596534729, 0.007049339357763529, 0.024759355932474136, 0.01604355499148369, 0.03290336951613426, -0.00044425157830119133, -0.016218360513448715, -0.012145559303462505, 0.015009002760052681, -0.044736962765455246, 0.00118057185318321, -0.03794621676206589, -0.02538599818944931, 0.010913199745118618, -0.024459345266222954, -0.0040614972822368145, 0.03569275513291359, 0.005279206205159426, -0.03149992227554321, -0.007247816305607557, 0.00023078024969436228, -0.0041126892901957035, -0.030070079490542412, -0.04858476668596268, 0.05210084095597267, 0.021223101764917374, -0.04208098724484444, 0.00005376642002374865, -0.034144025295972824, -0.030513018369674683, 0.003098470624536276, -0.0007490357966162264, -0.0011368145933374763, 0.0061929672956466675, -0.001845765975303948, -0.028630543500185013, -0.038567330688238144, -0.015242201276123524, -0.054863154888153076, -0.04911841079592705, -0.017256977036595345, 0.005917699076235294, 0.03843462094664574, 0.020293813198804855, 0.0009158902685157955, 0.07530353218317032, 0.0433303527534008, -0.06042909249663353, -0.06675223261117935, -0.02056005783379078, -0.016783565282821655, -0.02406829409301281, 0.028469227254390717, 0.016468217596411705, 0.013952747918665409, 0.025092514231801033, -0.04237730801105499, 0.011723365634679794, 0.030994754284620285, 0.02868298441171646, -0.01482380460947752, 0.04030200093984604, 0.019899677485227585, -0.06579560041427612, -0.002845803741365671, 0.012967715971171856, -0.028973229229450226, 0.0028217106591910124, 0.030391350388526917, 0.007957047782838345, 0.022192660719156265, -0.06448331475257874, 0.014459105208516121, -0.02484286203980446, 0.00033953177626244724, -0.04178408533334732, -0.0038325570058077574, -0.0062157344073057175, -0.024333829060196877, 0.0037674750201404095, 0.03532518073916435, 0.01721346192061901, -0.01091073639690876, -0.013641160912811756, 0.04997836798429489, 0.07294446974992752, 0.021784326061606407, -0.006328036542981863, -0.039149779826402664, -0.0077964914962649345, 0.07545488327741623, -0.027790892869234085, -0.002533212536945939, 0.052727535367012024, 0.05271812528371811, 0.03320197016000748, 0.013176732696592808, -0.07221198081970215, 0.03415180370211601, -0.046399835497140884, 0.04184648022055626, -0.03859693557024002, 0.03991095349192619, -0.010140872560441494, 0.03081331215798855, 0.04880920425057411, -0.015299676917493343, -0.01892913691699505, 0.026229240000247955, -0.09310620278120041, -0.004622636828571558, 0.00337779289111495, 0.03957485407590866, 0.0018011170905083418, -0.0012256529880687594, 0.009023109450936317, -0.014058016240596771, 0.020790815353393555, 0.0022766084875911474, 0.034458063542842865, 0.003434040118008852, -0.013652726076543331, -0.026900500059127808, -0.05194733291864395, 0.018905704841017723, 0.01730029657483101, 0.018218377605080605, -0.04771168529987335, 0.0403023436665535, 0.03941396251320839, -0.00652681477367878, -0.011587973684072495, -0.007737310137599707, 0.04368017986416817, 0.0013747368939220905, 0.04741213098168373, 0.022294241935014725, 0.010458164848387241, -0.02036520093679428, 0.006031001452356577, -0.05312012508511543, 0.0411800779402256, 0.028525197878479958, -0.03104930929839611, -0.03082120604813099, -0.010042738169431686, -0.017457403242588043, -0.0244330745190382, 0.027127303183078766, -0.00007540505612269044, -0.005917102564126253, 0.07008224725723267, 0.020448951050639153, -0.05732014402747154, 0.03907203674316406, 0.08282936364412308, 0.046358782798051834, -0.028079934418201447, -0.03641518950462341, -0.02440347522497177, 0.01895931549370289, 0.0007155604544095695, 0.019375644624233246, -0.019578441977500916, -0.014292481355369091, -0.030189914628863335, 0.03041207231581211, -0.012072655372321606, -0.046166859567165375, 0.04193226620554924, 0.022808266803622246, 0.051284950226545334, -0.0018092170357704163, -0.03005913645029068, -0.004933686926960945, 0.03308885172009468, 0.04333053156733513, 0.02864539436995983, 0.003055120352655649, -0.09255699813365936, 0.015262242406606674, 0.027079859748482704, 0.03994491696357727, -0.027676712721586227, -0.006762629374861717, 0.0038689407519996166, -0.017209572717547417, 0.023863252252340317, -0.02688068337738514, 0.04102236032485962, 0.003377106972038746, 0.027497226372361183, -0.04370493441820145, -0.025663232430815697, -0.07978901267051697, 0.0213069636374712, -0.012981361709535122, 0.0027447494212538004, -0.0039120144210755825, -0.024745838716626167, -0.07084418833255768, 0.012127107940614223, -0.013781329616904259, 0.009430551901459694, -0.015656566247344017, -0.03166915848851204, 0.03513804078102112, 0.03208758309483528, -0.021316353231668472, -0.048728860914707184, 0.0007801424362696707, 0.04462422803044319, -0.02035653218626976, 0.030274560675024986, 0.009531249292194843, -0.05040464177727699, -0.006322825793176889, -0.018010171130299568, 0.00790647603571415, 0.030121244490146637, -0.025366192683577538, 0.047007638961076736, 0.0015752434264868498, -0.019784007221460342, 0.03373018279671669, 0.04159026965498924, 0.0008914408390410244, -0.005772720091044903, -0.011766954325139523, 0.026226434856653214, -0.022111808881163597, -0.03381624072790146, -0.04400293156504631, 0.02970568649470806, 0.0025370928924530745, 0.004195617511868477, -0.017816614359617233, 0.033598195761442184, -0.019881905987858772, -0.0435531884431839, 0.0028472610283643007, 0.04755888506770134, 0.0010970832081511617, -0.027457183226943016, 0.020953193306922913, -0.005177538376301527, -0.0016324528260156512, -0.026805516332387924, -0.015353881753981113, 0.007498137652873993, 0.0218063872307539, 0.0015431230422109365, -0.017656728625297546, -0.018534403294324875, -0.031209353357553482, -0.0027981088496744633, -0.008335716091096401, -0.04029069468379021, 0.02933507226407528, -0.02122257836163044, 0.046105094254016876, 0.03768714517354965, -0.03766844421625137, 0.014131794683635235, 0.056140925735235214, -0.0015075182309374213, 0.020072193816304207, -0.03285122290253639, 0.010363808833062649, -0.018621809780597687, 0.012927110306918621, -0.0652502030134201, -0.03683282807469368, -0.020722318440675735, -0.015851907432079315, -0.031294796615839005, -0.005287048406898975, 0.008828451856970787, -0.014039450325071812, -0.011478153057396412, -0.007528589107096195, 0.045700110495090485, -0.021970538422465324, -0.00798520352691412, -0.015017337165772915, 0.04536072909832001, 0.0716981366276741, -0.013909378089010715, -0.02823977917432785, 0.0316179096698761, 0.012151849456131458, 0.017853524535894394, 0.024881308898329735, 0.012051976285874844, -0.029601911082863808, 0.008352989330887794, -0.03375677019357681, -0.0019185668788850307, 0.044176556169986725, 0.005122702568769455, 0.000851071032229811, -0.009276919066905975, -0.034021709114313126, -0.006243428681045771, -0.007168931886553764, 0.008735833689570427, -0.004112481139600277, 0.0009987758239731193, -0.006843687035143375, 0.009893085807561874, -0.024864966049790382, -0.007079760544002056, 0.0011657474096864462, 0.004786218050867319, -0.015829356387257576, 0.009237019345164299, 0.049997907131910324, 0.007570868823677301, 0.013201728463172913, -0.02749624289572239, -0.01018515881150961, 0.02576819807291031, 0.03144000843167305, 0.003105729352682829, 0.015735525637865067, 0.013898470439016819, -0.0117515092715621, -0.033374857157468796, -0.059616681188344955, -0.0060110255144536495, 0.05816575884819031, 0.011076469905674458, 0.039281610399484634, 0.04606693610548973, 0.00835378561168909, -0.049809861928224564, -0.04295689985156059, 0.014340373687446117, 0.015615591779351234, 0.011382639408111572, 0.0788244754076004, -0.0012588843237608671, -0.012968897819519043, -0.00997935701161623, 0.043079640716314316, -0.006096931640058756, 0.03729989379644394, 0.04684196785092354, 0.02349156327545643, 0.028050338849425316, -0.017949184402823448, -0.06879089772701263, 0.01303217001259327, -0.055838119238615036, 0.008050646632909775, -0.009399013593792915, -0.05160447955131531, 0.029726272448897362, 0.022212687879800797, 0.011791104450821877, -0.09087307006120682, -0.03149442747235298, -0.032474592328071594, -0.005695220548659563, 0.029084591194987297, -0.036068692803382874, 0.024908484891057014, -0.009718007408082485, 0.038374435156583786, 0.0158840324729681, 0.05225353688001633, -0.014031034894287586, -0.07180194556713104, -0.0384039543569088, 0.0008250218816101551, -0.06262500584125519, 0.009398641996085644, -0.01530173234641552, -0.007659315597265959, 0.005907013081014156, -0.06010941416025162, -0.011863975785672665, 0.017133112996816635, 0.020119206979870796, 0.03994489088654518, 0.07149884104728699, -0.011600758880376816, -0.019350478425621986, 0.0039304462261497974, -0.021323127672076225, 0.1331256777048111, 0.07856570929288864, 0.04573323205113411, -0.07043266296386719, 0.02114805579185486, 0.0018881127471104264, 0.017946626991033554, -0.0007931774016469717, 0.009604296647012234, -0.00965660810470581, 0.010375220328569412, 0.02823113463819027, 0.05058181285858154, 0.017907503992319107, -0.009253276512026787, 0.05431749299168587, -0.02276197075843811, -0.01902722753584385, 0.004338238853961229, 0.01624923199415207, -0.025230377912521362, -0.0060396939516067505, -0.05338688939809799, 0.02556806057691574, -0.025635594502091408, -0.03156883269548416, 0.005671165883541107, -0.009774266742169857, -0.024876754730939865, -0.03206289932131767, -0.020982395857572556, 0.03672611713409424, 0.0338076576590538, 0.0017489406745880842, -0.03350258618593216, -0.003401638939976692, 0.01717662625014782, -0.03176119923591614, 0.014804758131504059, 0.011124234646558762, -0.005474655423313379, -0.016809076070785522, 0.05944686383008957, 0.004366888664662838, -0.056495606899261475, -0.03345842659473419, -0.04099687561392784, 0.03790516033768654, -0.0194663405418396, -0.00461116898804903, -0.027428651228547096, -0.02915292978286743, 0.02971491776406765, -0.017371701076626778, 0.006333960685878992, 0.01161531638354063, 0.03270065039396286, -0.000016562895325478166, -0.006971113383769989, -0.020116666331887245, -0.004838129505515099, 0.0284871943295002, 0.03998890146613121, -0.009037364274263382, -0.003755700308829546, -0.01288547832518816, -0.0020417936611920595, 0.08491633832454681, 0.02125602215528488, 0.0007517760386690497, 0.009112364612519741, 0.0019865508656948805, -0.043122075498104095, -0.010318540036678314, 0.006817718502134085, -0.01578540727496147, 0.015299315564334393, -0.002277598949149251, -0.007867546752095222, -0.08251241594552994, -0.019448639824986458, -0.024147192016243935, -0.02429416961967945, -0.022433849051594734, -0.05475256219506264, 0.032218921929597855, -0.018731409683823586, 0.01923961006104946, 0.03810659423470497, -0.024070173501968384, -0.015246267430484295, 0.03942842409014702, 0.010765673592686653, -0.015245635993778706, -0.040509652346372604, -0.003848076332360506, -0.005336440168321133, -0.007864036597311497, -0.004166120197623968, 0.05109347030520439, 0.020886672660708427, -0.03419015184044838, -0.027673209086060524, 0.02968668006360531, 0.021026456728577614, 0.012214758433401585, 0.022350521758198738, -0.057235900312662125, 0.006092288065701723, 0.013016815297305584, -0.011321418918669224, -0.029864316806197166, -0.004696009214967489, -0.025990307331085205, -0.05341455712914467, 0.01548219658434391, -0.018620837479829788, -0.02550312504172325, 0.008795712143182755, -0.026284651830792427, 0.0709293931722641, -0.04968743026256561, -0.032523542642593384, -0.003179153660312295, 0.00008496636291965842, -0.004754708148539066, 0.022456567734479904, -0.01090047787874937, 0.0528736412525177, -0.0039000550750643015, 0.01619100384414196, 0.017893310636281967, 0.028390206396579742, 0.030208924785256386, -0.03260159492492676, -0.0013661094708368182, -0.021004199981689453, 0.06442387402057648, -0.02515643835067749, 0.0007632744964212179, -0.0032655883114784956, -0.01562795788049698, -0.02902813069522381, 0.0282345749437809, -0.016913263127207756, 0.04539167135953903, 0.030169609934091568, 0.009173502214252949, -0.031967662274837494, 0.04554665461182594, -0.009874173440039158, -0.023980971425771713, -0.042494036257267, -0.004413135349750519, -0.0034818013664335012, 0.002292556455358863, -0.004324567504227161, 0.0032647543121129274, -0.021270129829645157, 0.0368175245821476, 0.02328093722462654, 0.0004729989741463214, 0.009433320723474026, 0.03607967123389244, 0.014360347762703896, -0.005684665869921446, 0.01267559826374054, -0.036734018474817276, 0.03548058122396469, 0.0384230874478817, -0.0190911702811718, 0.05009125918149948, -0.011808538809418678, 0.04417801275849342, -0.03470940887928009, -0.02527180127799511, 0.013875450938940048, 0.019571468234062195, 0.03624675050377846, -0.04933927580714226, -0.00927684921771288, 0.02650265023112297, -0.040269870311021805, 0.008971128612756729, -0.005497903563082218, -0.015290183015167713, 0.009318464435636997, 0.003495829412713647, -0.008875438943505287, 0.00869726575911045, 0.023265976458787918, 0.004290918353945017, 0.014653966762125492, 0.04384537413716316, 0.022223714739084244, -0.031012829393148422, 0.04146004840731621, 0.0034848754294216633, 0.017535192891955376, -0.0679316520690918, 0.04766947403550148, -0.018505707383155823, -0.03801167011260986, 0.042693812400102615, 0.013956716284155846, 0.04165655001997948, 0.034708913415670395, 0.03373340889811516, -0.015443419106304646, 0.05300991237163544, -0.009452703408896923, -0.0055173421278595924, 0.00562462629750371, -0.002714065369218588, 0.006385757587850094, 0.058627162128686905, -0.017810698598623276, 0.03807590529322624, 0.009737007319927216, -0.030178604647517204, -0.01838812418282032, -0.013944084756076336, -0.047731317579746246, -0.023791443556547165, -0.002195600885897875, -0.00042579887667670846, -0.02173926867544651, -0.01199797261506319, 0.03897396847605705, -0.03805386275053024, -0.024137260392308235, 0.018496856093406677, 0.0021890285424888134, 0.00770572479814291, 0.018169838935136795, 0.007602241821587086, -0.037009306252002716, -0.001978067448362708, 0.005363319534808397, -0.011520206928253174, -0.049691032618284225, -0.0007113997708074749, 0.012825384736061096, -0.02545732818543911, -0.05940212309360504, -0.014167280867695808, -0.03757574409246445, 0.035075943917036057, -0.05564175546169281, 0.010680273175239563, 0.014425288885831833, -0.06281891465187073, 0.015480299480259418, -0.08286947011947632, 0.0470903106033802, -0.01579994149506092, -0.035655427724123, -0.021143397316336632, -0.006687507499009371, -0.021826254203915596, 0.015458203852176666, 0.03189486265182495, 0.0145777752622962, 0.00796258170157671, -0.020450683310627937, 0.035659294575452805, 0.023420317098498344, -0.04185657575726509, 0.04480346292257309, 0.015522594563663006, -0.03716971352696419, 0.020098887383937836, -0.012751640751957893, -0.012407628819346428, -0.017515508458018303, 0.026924313977360725, -0.024945933371782303, 0.02707122266292572, 0.00233573280274868, -0.009054775349795818, 0.035393085330724716, -0.01877542957663536, -0.010399925522506237, 0.046473629772663116, -0.0070398771204054356, 0.020044876262545586, 0.03631012886762619, 0.0022361662704497576, -0.04045512527227402, 0.04903967306017876, -0.003857373958453536, -0.00602324353531003, -0.03115692175924778, 0.04341104254126549, 0.004176810849457979, -0.054727938026189804, 0.017329268157482147, 0.06380393356084824, -0.06089642271399498, 0.017143094912171364, 0.025920676067471504, 0.0075850654393434525, 0.004814762622117996, -0.0022526218090206385, 0.040298689156770706, 0.03694678097963333, -0.05502014607191086, 0.048487864434719086, 0.023456452414393425, 0.04016387462615967, 0.003115870524197817, -0.007372796535491943, 0.01990741863846779, -0.014596037566661835, 0.020331665873527527, -0.03554971516132355, 0.05092161148786545, -0.06414569169282913, -0.015685690566897392, 0.04926367476582527, 0.02618556283414364, 0.06272606551647186, 0.01305638812482357, 0.0024036886170506477, 0.04569897800683975, -0.029475480318069458, -0.005547619424760342, -0.06790010631084442, -0.019714172929525375, -0.04527835175395012, -0.015839586034417152, -0.031651921570301056, 0.028900019824504852, 0.013787944801151752, 0.0236359890550375, -0.019030610099434853, -0.05232546478509903, 0.025985293090343475, -0.007930301129817963, 0.021396758034825325, 0.0010870042024180293, 0.02758261375129223, -0.0006066071218810976, -0.02477591671049595, -0.07053177058696747, -0.040352966636419296, -0.002575409132987261, 0.03565790504217148, 0.016396457329392433, -0.028638530522584915, -0.012154378928244114, -0.006582795642316341, 0.04671501740813255, -0.06081761419773102, -0.01587637886404991, -0.042110804468393326, -0.006854746490716934, 0.011180169880390167, 0.016203293576836586 ]
<p>I have a data set containing a daily sensor data measurements recorded from 20 participants for 60 days (baseline data).</p> <p>I am trying to develop methods for predicting/estimating decline in long-term monitoring studies, i.e. can measurement of a parameter on a daily basis be used to detect/predict decline (i.e. significant change) by identification of negative trends or abberant measurements. I hope to be able to generate statistical thresholds to allow identification of decline by examining the trends (using some combination of sensor derived parameters and referencing these to baseline clinical data.</p> <p>What is the most appropriate method to define a threshold for a significant change or decline for each participant and how do I best predict/detect negative trending or aberrant behaviour in unseen data? </p> <p>I wondered if I could get some opinions on a good approach? (note I have been using ICC, ANOVA as well as examining std. dev. of the baseline but have not found any of these approaches particularly useful)</p>
74,461
[ -0.025841347873210907, -0.006606813985854387, -0.0013547433773055673, -0.00021061947336420417, 0.03206908330321312, 0.027928562834858894, -0.022314421832561493, -0.03425225988030434, 0.02227911725640297, -0.035455670207738876, 0.0037808087654411793, 0.009468146599829197, 0.029772916808724403, -0.0028252534102648497, 0.021835077553987503, -0.020457496866583824, -0.04580894485116005, -0.038428306579589844, -0.03908512368798256, -0.025895696133375168, 0.006643517408519983, -0.015605174005031586, 0.02054746076464653, 0.0022614472545683384, -0.05860672891139984, 0.029114646837115288, 0.04456658661365509, -0.03960432857275009, -0.029661215841770172, 0.05742555111646652, -0.06935981661081314, -0.0259857140481472, -0.02884000726044178, -0.00873913336545229, 0.042868293821811676, -0.011257356032729149, -0.030312128365039825, -0.029200870543718338, -0.0017977420939132571, 0.06151934340596199, -0.014106404967606068, 5.956367772341764e-7, -0.005399332847446203, 0.028454160317778587, 0.004795553162693977, -0.027096470817923546, 0.015052465721964836, -0.016541924327611923, 0.025319544598460197, -0.08184243738651276, 0.04636305943131447, -0.04034049063920975, 0.05187121406197548, 0.004461175762116909, 0.009645177982747555, -0.022848859429359436, 0.04383919760584831, 0.048872210085392, 0.010716130957007408, -0.05272684246301651, -0.003754085162654519, -0.0002649500092957169, -0.012105937115848064, 0.0011598904384300113, -0.005993850063532591, 0.025313232094049454, -0.015729278326034546, -0.024068551138043404, 0.047398459166288376, 0.020836131647229195, 0.01920570246875286, 0.025433363392949104, 0.033281873911619186, -0.002721125725656748, 0.030607786029577255, -0.007452570833265781, -0.01273033581674099, 0.015775693580508232, 0.022778386250138283, 0.04522528871893883, 0.003951949533075094, -0.003914265427738428, 0.03159487247467041, 0.03306520730257034, -0.0040030996315181255, -0.01936657354235649, 0.04785282164812088, -0.05436484515666962, 0.008599595166742802, 0.026612596586346626, -0.002831520978361368, 0.004758971743285656, 0.024782763794064522, -0.012397035956382751, -0.05400918051600456, 0.010595470666885376, -0.019556652754545212, 0.04207288846373558, -0.03951461613178253, -0.002371112583205104, 0.0092409523203969, -0.03293765336275101, 0.023859988898038864, 0.007406163029372692, -0.048805490136146545, 0.005860461853444576, -0.034349340945482254, -0.02453007362782955, 0.00254909903742373, -0.017665455117821693, -0.044958677142858505, -0.021299131214618683, 0.03286465257406235, -0.02133932150900364, 0.010037940926849842, -0.014894491992890835, -0.053977709263563156, -0.04645448178052902, 0.054677899926900864, 0.0352761410176754, 0.0533919557929039, -0.00173795351292938, 0.01005362905561924, -0.016898583620786667, -0.06186410039663315, 0.017304444685578346, -0.0008819223730824888, -0.007267339155077934, -0.03574191778898239, 0.06325352936983109, 0.017524128779768944, -0.019366735592484474, 0.059701502323150635, -0.0360233336687088, 0.0398087203502655, 0.012455846183001995, -0.06725192815065384, -0.0488242469727993, 0.04211436212062836, -0.01688678003847599, 0.019694747403264046, -0.048666805028915405, -0.029281988739967346, 0.026355769485235214, 0.05013219639658928, 0.05087117850780487, -0.006306254304945469, 0.0160860326141119, 0.03535216674208641, 0.006215984467417002, -0.005475223064422607, -0.0008731318521313369, -0.012901184149086475, -0.00035661013680510223, -0.037798430770635605, -0.0935571938753128, 0.0020944923162460327, 0.023676447570323944, -0.0009818151593208313, -0.015313489362597466, 0.03345237672328949, 0.007685858756303787, -0.016432981938123703, -0.008787349797785282, 0.0037886379286646843, -0.00865606777369976, 0.07350290566682816, -0.025359896942973137, 0.009379209950566292, 0.023922232910990715, 0.035945672541856766, 0.019842015579342842, 0.026660721749067307, 0.04280783608555794, 0.05945590138435364, 0.02447848580777645, 0.003490335773676634, -0.039531197398900986, 0.006398117169737816, 0.01757432334125042, -0.05528315529227257, -0.00657174875959754, -0.062381234019994736, -0.0030603520572185516, 0.02674967423081398, 0.014086628332734108, -0.03440838307142258, -0.013075144961476326, 0.05914836749434471, -0.07321929931640625, -0.013583292253315449, -0.07870461046695709, -0.013028087094426155, -0.014648313634097576, -0.021926553919911385, 0.02936055138707161, -0.012941833585500717, 0.010080438107252121, -0.016689639538526535, -0.005391424987465143, -0.004223247058689594, -0.0019981744699180126, 0.047147028148174286, -0.06780842691659927, -0.0044684759341180325, 0.03161204233765602, 0.03757655248045921, -0.018603580072522163, 0.04621414840221405, -0.04110155254602432, -0.0377805233001709, -0.0015972218243405223, -0.04109775274991989, 0.016868192702531815, 0.025780869647860527, -0.02956644631922245, 0.009128283709287643, -0.022693248465657234, -0.03817290812730789, 0.004641941748559475, -0.051678068935871124, 0.08552782237529755, 0.033051203936338425, -0.027502143755555153, 0.0010264657903462648, 0.019857551902532578, 0.01628960110247135, 0.0017687921645119786, -0.05693095549941063, -0.0030759628862142563, -0.048772238194942474, -0.009846463799476624, 0.0595548115670681, 0.038539182394742966, -0.012832824140787125, 0.01844070665538311, 0.04703008383512497, -0.010471805930137634, 0.010482401587069035, 0.0096929632127285, 0.02626792900264263, -0.011862175539135933, 0.021156756207346916, 0.044476017355918884, 0.016855163499712944, 0.013015816919505596, 0.008360405452549458, -0.006221803370863199, 0.050209205597639084, 0.005303545854985714, 0.028328709304332733, 0.016832975670695305, 0.029770856723189354, 0.03258480131626129, -0.02057926170527935, -0.01903645135462284, 0.030264897271990776, -0.01314604002982378, 0.009118719026446342, -0.0019196374341845512, -0.010866338387131691, 0.0028644981794059277, 0.03669966384768486, -0.012118577025830746, 0.04093179479241371, 0.01731986552476883, -0.03325054422020912, 0.02530103549361229, 0.0019765738397836685, -0.04128633439540863, 0.01814444735646248, -0.03053838014602661, -0.032981790602207184, -0.01763780042529106, -0.014157716184854507, 0.02904433198273182, 0.005370857194066048, 0.04115211218595505, -0.030938655138015747, -0.004070809576660395, -0.00801701657474041, -0.02927578240633011, 0.024562940001487732, 0.06400549411773682, -0.018088331446051598, -0.016571294516324997, 0.014702137559652328, -0.04095681011676788, 0.04183080792427063, -0.040069207549095154, 0.03607337921857834, 0.04924967139959335, 0.005913788452744484, -0.06897000968456268, -0.03594587370753288, -0.022252226248383522, -0.000530377437826246, 0.0014666023198515177, -0.029937397688627243, 0.05760268494486809, -0.0034195021726191044, -0.034910108894109726, 0.012323621660470963, -0.03264240548014641, -0.003558216616511345, -0.038589101284742355, -0.009389207698404789, 0.03125644475221634, -0.007762391120195389, 0.002304262714460492, 0.0037333082873374224, -0.041971299797296524, -0.02327069453895092, -0.06626822799444199, -0.06683889776468277, 0.04137196019291878, -0.0317167192697525, 0.058016855269670486, -0.009222072549164295, 0.013348488137125969, 0.08268745988607407, 0.04073382541537285, -0.01415489986538887, -0.025711748749017715, -0.0007800617604516447, -0.024539336562156677, -0.02603510580956936, 0.00005780181891168468, 0.03855938836932182, 0.013471614569425583, 0.005074597429484129, -0.021511340513825417, 0.012199725024402142, 0.031306810677051544, 0.03024964965879917, -0.040211670100688934, 0.003346917685121298, 0.026351947337388992, 0.009220745414495468, 0.009252006188035011, -0.002621046034619212, -0.007637226488441229, -0.007246877998113632, -0.02551000565290451, 0.027373427525162697, 0.03339746966958046, -0.044064052402973175, 0.01981421932578087, -0.02426331862807274, 0.002359910635277629, -0.00036924038431607187, -0.021897338330745697, 0.012554733082652092, -0.02848842740058899, -0.05357120931148529, 0.042664021253585815, 0.006916665472090244, -0.019058823585510254, -0.02156270295381546, 0.05189066752791405, 0.018913723528385162, 0.010555358603596687, 0.0062710377387702465, -0.012311341241002083, -0.01521287951618433, 0.0037227889988571405, -0.03847331181168556, -0.03176679462194443, 0.026165831834077835, 0.015428919345140457, 0.032607551664114, 0.005315385293215513, -0.04938235878944397, 0.002951294183731079, -0.05110614001750946, -0.03113752044737339, -0.019953811541199684, 0.060782626271247864, 0.009416849352419376, -0.01463267020881176, 0.041112270206213, -0.018177414312958717, 0.023434728384017944, -0.00870111770927906, -0.054909978061914444, 0.042330529540777206, -0.014375238679349422, 0.004859365522861481, 0.037922684103250504, 0.00527605414390564, 0.0024438046384602785, -0.02063644677400589, -0.007772715762257576, -0.03224962577223778, 0.09359309822320938, -0.024853628128767014, -0.017736921086907387, -0.016073469072580338, -0.015605631284415722, -0.038828786462545395, 0.0009368727332912385, 0.03712722286581993, -0.0028956825844943523, 0.000837958708871156, 0.01915895752608776, -0.0016657159430906177, -0.02159346453845501, -0.030487146228551865, 0.012025907635688782, 0.012725637294352055, 0.030325762927532196, 0.009674926288425922, 0.02697666920721531, -0.05514511093497276, 0.03926949203014374, 0.01087274681776762, 0.04349494352936745, 0.014506234787404537, 0.03105965256690979, 0.012534825131297112, -0.031004799529910088, -0.028043262660503387, 0.030947772786021233, 0.020074512809515, 0.02967514470219612, 0.003203683765605092, 0.04337010160088539, -0.018292434513568878, -0.06260373443365097, 0.008313407190144062, 0.053503286093473434, 0.033293649554252625, -0.0032560317777097225, -0.0333653949201107, -0.017137112095952034, 0.029528789222240448, 0.003380913520231843, 0.05050728842616081, 0.021045751869678497, 0.025845665484666824, -0.004867700859904289, 0.027305632829666138, 0.02306228131055832, -0.024528615176677704, -0.0204984862357378, 0.01784142293035984, 0.0646810382604599, 0.02175033837556839, -0.010308537632226944, 0.04896446317434311, 0.018072515726089478, 0.05491137504577637, 0.03487348556518555, 0.04715937748551369, -0.13910707831382751, 0.009317214600741863, 0.05416914448142052, 0.05054008960723877, -0.011478723958134651, -0.013973093591630459, -0.02543383277952671, -0.007880869321525097, 0.040830276906490326, -0.025667687878012657, 0.012651433236896992, 0.001176381716504693, 0.026044564321637154, -0.029932251200079918, -0.029641514644026756, -0.03444384038448334, -0.0010405781213194132, -0.0035433638840913773, 0.017290428280830383, 0.0008840038790367544, -0.001357409404590726, -0.0437118299305439, 0.006743001751601696, -0.027658570557832718, 0.07597795128822327, -0.022252898663282394, 0.0069165159948170185, 0.018889257684350014, -0.01536471676081419, 0.0028495131991803646, -0.048447366803884506, 0.01691650040447712, 0.018937641754746437, 0.023489302024245262, 0.03691047057509422, 0.02040589600801468, -0.018661590293049812, -0.02668461762368679, 0.01707730069756508, -0.0341305248439312, 0.00802233349531889, -0.05303305387496948, 0.07860610634088516, 0.009321064688265324, -0.04333268478512764, 0.05420210212469101, 0.012641924433410168, 0.015000252053141594, 0.003920816816389561, -0.0013069096021354198, -0.005965314339846373, -0.024099161848425865, -0.0059258658438920975, -0.006781222298741341, -0.0027022112626582384, -0.018995234742760658, 0.05127488821744919, 0.009033957496285439, 0.02877483144402504, -0.011791819706559181, -0.0064613837748765945, 0.049257151782512665, 0.023049484938383102, 0.019446076825261116, -0.00564773753285408, 0.02603224664926529, 0.01621195301413536, -0.01913883350789547, -0.0350271500647068, 0.0011188070056959987, -0.03588554635643959, -0.01680605672299862, 0.027586428448557854, -0.059325218200683594, -0.009162763133645058, -0.06040642410516739, -0.0230812169611454, -0.0007388083031401038, -0.021547140553593636, 0.03256165608763695, -0.004775086883455515, 0.014666774310171604, 0.016615616157650948, -0.01687055267393589, 0.0007125611882656813, 0.012018353678286076, -0.007985017262399197, 0.032143451273441315, -0.03586312755942345, 0.026609789580106735, -0.02905503287911415, 0.022695396095514297, -0.05762216076254845, -0.03650714084506035, 0.04656318947672844, -0.00047951482702046633, -0.011319934390485287, -0.009424089454114437, 0.0218194629997015, -0.039628926664590836, -0.038951825350522995, 0.011950721964240074, 0.038898203521966934, -0.02294573001563549, 0.010627467185258865, 0.013799521140754223, 0.021915096789598465, 0.0911511480808258, -0.025797251611948013, 0.023045729845762253, 0.02793898992240429, 0.009458675980567932, -0.022106442600488663, -0.0389070101082325, 0.013863922096788883, -0.041798338294029236, 0.015201965346932411, -0.038397371768951416, -0.012430034577846527, 0.07254341244697571, -0.028820980340242386, -0.05995902791619301, 0.01266474835574627, -0.024698566645383835, 0.03593285754323006, -0.03215226158499718, 0.011582483537495136, -0.03831123560667038, 0.004559934139251709, -0.0010491805151104927, -0.012265893630683422, -0.0017036031931638718, -0.04512351006269455, 0.03914884850382805, 0.029940010979771614, -0.029196875169873238, 0.005459321662783623, 0.002678744960576296, -0.015024954453110695, -0.018654467537999153, 0.012978735379874706, -0.030089523643255234, 0.015479070134460926, -0.0007321930606849492, 0.0049080573953688145, -0.007962298579514027, -0.007720803376287222, -0.05175357311964035, -0.04298475757241249, -0.04688411206007004, -0.056434210389852524, 0.06908024847507477, 0.04424043372273445, 0.032565888017416, 0.04472034052014351, -0.013367394916713238, -0.012251841835677624, -0.03743210434913635, 0.007894442416727543, 0.0135270981118083, -0.011430609971284866, 0.026891954243183136, -0.03786870464682579, -0.0010616680374369025, -0.00886046327650547, -0.003892435459420085, 0.012323706410825253, 0.05417454242706299, 0.0027209180407226086, 0.028840964660048485, 0.029858097434043884, -0.04863268509507179, -0.04312457889318466, 0.03057452104985714, -0.04496338218450546, 0.033438123762607574, -0.035876303911209106, -0.0026634002570062876, 0.008389611728489399, 0.04331635311245918, 0.005700728856027126, -0.03137193247675896, -0.013449701480567455, -0.049115728586912155, 0.0013722649309784174, 0.027987325564026833, -0.05813303962349892, 0.01675279811024666, 0.030394447967410088, 0.03892816603183746, -0.00928976945579052, -0.005440928507596254, -0.03487019240856171, -0.0641966238617897, -0.010153035633265972, -0.009347868151962757, -0.06037028506398201, 0.017263688147068024, 0.00007256074604811147, -0.002001416403800249, -0.03263043984770775, -0.02882460318505764, 0.005561168771237135, 0.019314229488372803, 0.04987289011478424, -0.0030662091448903084, 0.058118559420108795, -0.006148453336209059, 0.01684403233230114, 0.03875495865941048, 0.004935565870255232, 0.1341210901737213, 0.08275587856769562, -0.0029244213365018368, -0.05899781733751297, 0.036729373037815094, 0.008666669018566608, 0.03079092502593994, -0.01063781138509512, 0.027437789365649223, 0.0032947941217571497, -0.01203727163374424, 0.06335481256246567, 0.04193313419818878, 0.006812830455601215, -0.023949159309267998, 0.10481517761945724, 0.025934463366866112, -0.0031646762508898973, 0.034648455679416656, 0.015089633874595165, -0.026706114411354065, 0.008506650105118752, -0.00993126817047596, 0.07873649150133133, -0.018003661185503006, -0.06369847804307938, 0.0013759165303781629, 0.021762428805232048, -0.016544144600629807, -0.00014853355241939425, -0.032711975276470184, -0.02566542476415634, -0.006500940304249525, 0.030500592663884163, -0.012597078457474709, -0.01866900734603405, -0.014406269416213036, -0.012643972411751747, 0.011354233138263226, 0.036528579890728, -0.0007042092038318515, -0.021522289142012596, -0.0015316397184506059, 0.019084960222244263, -0.011444855481386185, -0.050137415528297424, -0.044189710170030594, 0.04904112219810486, -0.003247210057452321, -0.033740267157554626, 0.001743236556649208, -0.009876434691250324, -0.017779774963855743, -0.03334670886397362, -0.0413447767496109, -0.006167296320199966, 0.04327505826950073, -0.03712774068117142, 0.010634774342179298, -0.016741806641221046, -0.008705511689186096, 0.0038080690428614616, -0.0009421426220797002, 0.0206094142049551, -0.036170557141304016, -0.03344057500362396, -0.0059268176555633545, 0.03181027993559837, 0.006357175298035145, 0.04441948980093002, 0.025439560413360596, -0.012001406401395798, -0.02422507107257843, 0.015675781294703484, 0.03499671816825867, -0.0028414831031113863, 0.003926876466721296, 0.004503922536969185, -0.011189891956746578, -0.020874686539173126, -0.06209966540336609, 0.0219487976282835, -0.016974739730358124, 0.011387379840016365, -0.051150236278772354, -0.004665030632168055, 0.042214203625917435, 0.0468418225646019, 0.006014192942529917, -0.020792141556739807, -0.00009386566671309993, 0.0611870102584362, 0.017726052552461624, -0.033789072185754776, -0.014521544799208641, 0.007088321261107922, -0.029540786519646645, 0.02368795871734619, -0.03170829266309738, 0.07412981241941452, 0.021720383316278458, 0.009096764959394932, 0.0012198089389130473, 0.022406985983252525, -0.002296631457284093, 0.012884562835097313, 0.0017302603228017688, -0.03713199496269226, -0.005604160949587822, -0.02914433367550373, 0.02417028695344925, 0.009101306088268757, -0.0518469400703907, -0.029612019658088684, -0.009368007071316242, -0.0045424560084939, -0.019954325631260872, 0.024727677926421165, 0.0241737961769104, -0.0164056234061718, -0.001416509854607284, -0.020784027874469757, 0.010551705956459045, -0.05097530782222748, -0.03938204050064087, 0.004570051562041044, -0.006141225807368755, 0.011168920435011387, 0.005821332335472107, -0.013495109975337982, -0.004312957637012005, 0.03688747063279152, 0.014248661696910858, 0.03389935567975044, 0.011253070086240768, -0.0006788495811633766, -0.016984574496746063, 0.019951941445469856, 0.011321009136736393, -0.0377807691693306, 0.029500707983970642, -0.021216867491602898, -0.02293410152196884, 0.029719529673457146, 0.018046533688902855, -0.018984459340572357, 0.009890317916870117, -0.012108278460800648, -0.0031742656137794256, 0.020766153931617737, -0.024162786081433296, -0.0396999754011631, -0.012876760214567184, 0.016987651586532593, -0.04349900782108307, 0.017344417050480843, 0.043897178024053574, 0.01783396676182747, -0.014907967299222946, 0.011368854902684689, 0.027045026421546936, 0.027789810672402382, -0.0037729181349277496, 0.0033515519462525845, -0.007907369174063206, -0.0065043093636631966, -0.005851117894053459, 0.0005773660959675908, 0.05825810879468918, 0.056040823459625244, -0.036491770297288895, 0.0014296307926997542, -0.03591148927807808, -0.006638415157794952, -0.07189682871103287, 0.007407316472381353, -0.013691689819097519, 0.022335972636938095, 0.0050415657460689545, -0.07076529413461685, 0.003637596732005477, 0.018784351646900177, -0.03210783377289772, 0.009786374866962433, 0.002558333333581686, 0.0078002759255468845, -0.01438644714653492, 0.0024047400802373886, -0.009751537814736366, 0.011248261667788029, 0.004843208473175764, 0.025608882308006287, 0.022869985550642014, 0.04195254668593407, 0.018244752660393715, -0.032516345381736755, -0.013911914080381393, 0.03612203150987625, 0.027338115498423576, -0.06365901231765747, 0.004787474870681763, -0.05552194267511368, -0.02088620327413082, 0.011486692354083061, -0.03614625707268715, 0.05956457182765007, 0.027428245171904564, 0.003215778386220336, 0.02136518992483616, 0.07555150985717773, -0.007363907992839813, -0.028908682987093925, 0.00509548420086503, -0.027200430631637573, -0.014786304906010628, 0.03948632627725601, -0.029704764485359192, 0.03716173395514488, 0.033649176359176636, -0.023075584322214127, -0.015561764128506184, 0.012342240661382675, -0.030699685215950012, -0.02312927320599556, -0.003315876005217433, 0.006336941849440336, 0.022222330793738365, -0.03707544133067131, 0.01627734676003456, -0.01861509308218956, -0.018190305680036545, 0.01221286691725254, 0.02363310195505619, -0.029666589573025703, 0.00801581609994173, -0.022685956209897995, -0.01741315796971321, 0.03990434110164642, 0.003891735803335905, 0.0005850260495208204, -0.07050443440675735, -0.02811475284397602, -0.04752017930150032, -0.00039113254752010107, -0.027461344376206398, 0.03927117958664894, -0.0254053995013237, 0.039313435554504395, -0.014624660834670067, 0.023063570261001587, 0.03141416981816292, -0.03172367438673973, -0.014271309599280357, -0.0825982317328453, 0.04830138012766838, 0.02311253733932972, 0.007647144142538309, -0.027553046122193336, -0.04466569796204567, -0.04077069088816643, 0.01701953262090683, 0.06498713791370392, -0.001255764625966549, -0.0021820832043886185, -0.03182472661137581, 0.02710864506661892, 0.004504289478063583, -0.044244322925806046, 0.07463813573122025, -0.017160484567284584, 0.004581713117659092, -0.006874998100101948, -0.014387696050107479, 0.03424123302102089, 0.01168001163750887, 0.026493532583117485, -0.02746487408876419, 0.02746051549911499, 0.028325742110610008, -0.0025202941615134478, 0.027295170351862907, 0.02363533154129982, -0.021389568224549294, 0.04007667303085327, -0.020747225731611252, 0.018611349165439606, 0.0309920534491539, 0.008619395084679127, -0.031536586582660675, 0.04611756280064583, -0.01979108527302742, -0.0232112817466259, 0.014390974305570126, 0.017503229901194572, -0.019088098779320717, -0.05633031576871872, -0.05255217105150223, 0.0012926372000947595, 0.0062651666812598705, 0.040960077196359634, 0.06513889878988266, -0.007941385731101036, 0.02508663572371006, -0.019018912687897682, 0.04002136364579201, 0.026184052228927612, 0.04632062837481499, 0.020153990015387535, 0.02791197970509529, 0.006706458982080221, -0.01587303727865219, 0.01816674880683422, 0.030326878651976585, -0.029237745329737663, 0.0557958260178566, -0.007521625608205795, -0.012235009111464024, -0.01993512362241745, 0.02211291342973709, -0.011209800839424133, 0.007535739801824093, 0.004203168209642172, 0.05256105959415436, 0.012619175016880035, 0.06368977576494217, -0.04660547524690628, -0.03972044214606285, -0.03117816522717476, -0.030294904485344887, -0.009839698672294617, 0.03376085311174393, 0.029942408204078674, 0.05428669601678848, 0.020442340523004532, 0.03139185905456543, -0.000399499578634277, 0.032241541892290115, -0.01951274648308754, -0.023326754570007324, 0.062407586723566055, -0.0034987223334610462, -0.0036345343105494976, -0.0032376653980463743, -0.013410070911049843, -0.032685671001672745, -0.006176862400025129, -0.015730828046798706, 0.027697870507836342, 0.06160919740796089, 0.011146713979542255, -0.009471883065998554, -0.005917492788285017, 0.016557535156607628, -0.052580997347831726, 0.01679646037518978, -0.0370112881064415, -0.010687796398997307, -0.02902226522564888, -0.020467348396778107 ]
<p>I am working on a problem where we are interested in finding the MLE for a function of two parameters.</p> <p>I am having problems with going about finding this. Intuitively, the idea makes sense. I am just wondering about the definition of the MLE of a function of two parameters (Google isn't turning up much). The question is as follows:</p> <p><strong>Question:</strong> Suppose that $X_1,\ldots,\,X_n$ are iid $N(\mu, \sigma^2)$ with unknown $\mu,\sigma^2$. Find the MLE for $\frac{\mu}{\sigma}$. </p> <p>Note that this is not just a homework problem, but part of a take home final. I really am not looking for much of an answer, but more or less the idea for such problems. </p> <p><strong>Edit</strong></p> <p>Apparently MLE's are invariant under function. TY</p>
27,621
[ -0.03354043886065483, 0.009135455824434757, -0.024418078362941742, -0.008541819639503956, 0.0007776210550218821, 0.02438407577574253, -0.0013348482316359878, -0.02859647013247013, 0.02063104137778282, -0.03766685724258423, 0.062200773507356644, 0.03669913858175278, 0.1017954871058464, -0.016255635768175125, 0.05076226219534874, 0.02450704202055931, -0.03469209745526314, 0.056905172765254974, -0.01954791136085987, -0.013447600416839123, 0.002757558599114418, 0.03226439282298088, 0.03312712162733078, -0.03203247860074043, -0.03669556975364685, 0.02400383912026882, 0.015001990832388401, -0.0028264354914426804, 0.008758033625781536, 0.08167628943920135, -0.03338805213570595, -0.04398888722062111, 0.028997909277677536, 0.03873112052679062, -0.047896794974803925, 0.008928054943680763, -0.023685216903686523, 0.012157972902059555, -0.0032830096315592527, 0.03266832232475281, -0.039283912628889084, -0.027886060997843742, 0.014587770216166973, 0.033138010650873184, -0.016742631793022156, 0.00665454613044858, -0.011162146925926208, -0.05571082606911659, 0.017397603020071983, -0.03225075453519821, 0.12533481419086456, -0.003980797249823809, 0.07306718081235886, 0.03293345123529434, -0.015585361048579216, -0.014358079992234707, 0.05358780920505524, 0.07630083709955215, -0.0058113704435527325, -0.0595271959900856, -0.01894996128976345, -0.031581927090883255, 0.042241234332323074, 0.008632120676338673, -0.0495930090546608, 0.0033443430438637733, -0.0011439207009971142, -0.01658092439174652, 0.03025706298649311, 0.006277127657085657, 0.03436356037855148, 0.02518736757338047, 0.06546144932508469, -0.013395179063081741, -0.007558002136647701, -0.012724154628813267, 0.04465346410870552, 0.015895361080765724, 0.031054897233843803, 0.009310458786785603, 0.01167984027415514, 0.028399648144841194, 0.0442538820207119, 0.00411613006144762, -0.0029213076923042536, 0.012218602001667023, 0.09512604773044586, 0.006958177778869867, 0.033673010766506195, 0.0034409186337143183, -0.023269172757864, 0.02851438894867897, 0.052296120673418045, -0.012773020192980766, -0.03685075417160988, 0.04828168451786041, -0.0073656197637319565, 0.03452714905142784, 0.01773066073656082, -0.02929653972387314, -0.0006308738375082612, -0.031014634296298027, 0.0066724251955747604, 0.044906336814165115, -0.027026602998375893, 0.010974995791912079, -0.011038681492209435, 0.004163562320172787, -0.017262762412428856, -0.035160768777132034, 0.000952820002567023, 0.04555022343993187, -0.021624887362122536, 0.010953577235341072, 0.030695250257849693, 0.007917243987321854, -0.015269375406205654, 0.011497273109853268, 0.043076902627944946, 0.06689896434545517, 0.038391124457120895, -0.019527992233633995, -0.0010362876346334815, 0.012287560850381851, -0.05877915769815445, 0.030185747891664505, 0.02562909759581089, 0.009081878699362278, -0.0582440048456192, 0.07960864901542664, -0.0017482003895565867, -0.021492986008524895, 0.025824138894677162, 0.026812348514795303, 0.027735956013202667, -0.0049590603448450565, -0.042695432901382446, -0.054228901863098145, 0.0377018041908741, -0.02928002178668976, 0.01555485650897026, -0.08706365525722504, -0.008411864750087261, 0.05986328423023224, 0.07744278013706207, 0.00047796970466151834, 0.05077280104160309, 0.0046088662929832935, 0.01700594648718834, 0.0049514202401041985, -0.016563454642891884, -0.05534614250063896, -0.013345806859433651, 0.010071477852761745, -0.006370211951434612, -0.020130442455410957, -0.0015363057609647512, 0.014853489585220814, -0.022176342085003853, -0.02028922736644745, 0.03314507380127907, 0.009311186149716377, -0.023340607061982155, -0.015502102673053741, 0.06643888354301453, -0.019550571218132973, 0.06502516567707062, 0.018948819488286972, 0.02542918361723423, 0.020590441301465034, -0.002907663583755493, 0.04600517451763153, 0.008480427786707878, 0.04157865792512894, 0.05834151804447174, -0.024618953466415405, -0.0426543690264225, -0.004016377031803131, 0.026158617809414864, 0.045021262019872665, -0.04993169382214546, 0.020596403628587723, -0.01685696467757225, 0.0002589594223536551, 0.006520633585751057, 0.020097261294722557, 0.018330968916416168, -0.02123045176267624, 0.008183937519788742, -0.0576937310397625, -0.01619475893676281, -0.08385883271694183, -0.018248459324240685, -0.01922878436744213, -0.032272517681121826, 0.017892591655254364, 0.0022258595563471317, -0.006057529244571924, -0.0225860383361578, -0.03572479635477066, -0.02059176005423069, -0.016261188313364983, 0.024692945182323456, -0.0157757718116045, 0.023951837792992592, 0.010785105638206005, 0.047700896859169006, 0.0034121698699891567, 0.04176625981926918, -0.03249024972319603, -0.021665744483470917, 0.019851883873343468, -0.02945753000676632, 0.012596146203577518, 0.004986884072422981, -0.019565781578421593, 0.0013499795459210873, -0.010048029944300652, -0.002347624395042658, 0.03375335782766342, -0.062344782054424286, 0.035983916372060776, 0.04552643001079559, 0.03502281382679939, -0.006825183052569628, 0.008562509901821613, 0.04712284728884697, 0.003938004840165377, -0.04444799944758415, -0.01978304795920849, -0.025219375267624855, -0.042675040662288666, 0.015978073701262474, 0.04999557510018349, -0.042549148201942444, 0.01870020665228367, 0.04747508093714714, 0.027398597449064255, 0.04237068071961403, 0.038767892867326736, 0.018071820959448814, -0.009373607113957405, -0.02097969315946102, -0.0015019115526229143, -0.007480754051357508, 0.04649772122502327, 0.024547196924686432, -0.0077670058235526085, 0.013813428580760956, 0.009397108107805252, -0.009167429059743881, 0.06908074021339417, -0.004036900121718645, 0.008072992786765099, -0.025669824331998825, -0.0017671287059783936, 0.03458225727081299, -0.006120009813457727, -0.018991047516465187, 0.008094134740531445, 0.022375870496034622, -0.025733336806297302, -0.01654965430498123, 0.02110007405281067, 0.03306528180837631, 0.007775037549436092, -0.021919410675764084, -0.0067478991113603115, 0.01813487522304058, -0.020725252106785774, 0.010175246745347977, -0.006689959671348333, -0.016279488801956177, -0.008830617181956768, -0.014761040918529034, 0.0007080886280164123, 0.016796914860606194, 0.004622787702828646, -0.016180312260985374, -0.06097133085131645, -0.009352561086416245, -0.018890030682086945, 0.04077673703432083, -0.0056939697824418545, -0.01835036836564541, 0.014540228992700577, -0.021136026829481125, -0.018302349373698235, 0.042499370872974396, -0.002653781557455659, -0.0014361561043187976, 0.011091054417192936, -0.009124299511313438, -0.0659455955028534, 0.007293656002730131, -0.047908537089824677, 0.024877097457647324, -0.015391015447676182, 0.012762418948113918, 0.04583016410470009, -0.00870111957192421, -0.008511670865118504, 0.014725214801728725, 0.006762996781617403, -0.03542788699269295, -0.04498227685689926, 0.003424079390242696, 0.01972353085875511, 0.012752870097756386, 0.03294314444065094, 0.05780685320496559, -0.03288829326629639, -0.005966319236904383, -0.04938805475831032, -0.06661195307970047, -0.0016848139930516481, -0.004513903055340052, 0.013241738080978394, 0.0023665265180170536, -0.019855277612805367, 0.08538752794265747, 0.005147221032530069, -0.025871342048048973, -0.013789525255560875, -0.010555295273661613, 0.014882010407745838, -0.037403181195259094, 0.021222399547696114, 0.017399299889802933, -0.007217965554445982, 0.06778278201818466, 0.027404146268963814, 0.0043908883817493916, 0.0511682964861393, -0.013211281038820744, 0.004168535117059946, 0.008181353099644184, 0.00629105931147933, -0.02691054157912731, 0.051651179790496826, 0.029905816540122032, -0.012850509025156498, 0.0480005107820034, 0.02542172744870186, 0.015280312858521938, 0.003946621902287006, 0.00007839391764719039, 0.033745259046554565, -0.020541872829198837, -0.018954826518893242, -0.05648426339030266, 0.048956237733364105, 0.03872619569301605, -0.04130009561777115, -0.010245049372315407, -0.00884961523115635, 0.013988019898533821, -0.04270104691386223, 0.009246138855814934, 0.05260024219751358, 0.004109493922442198, -0.013988083228468895, -0.02586325816810131, -0.04180997610092163, 0.0001887581020127982, -0.0014871181920170784, -0.014607013203203678, -0.03366934508085251, 0.051114991307258606, -0.005630133673548698, 0.027721744030714035, -0.02689404971897602, -0.022785473614931107, -0.008631843142211437, -0.051662031561136246, 0.030564870685338974, 0.00859370268881321, 0.039042599499225616, 0.007980688475072384, 0.03696918115019798, 0.018313515931367874, -0.00789105799049139, 0.0037487875670194626, 0.005806673783808947, -0.053013019263744354, 0.02168135717511177, -0.03131253272294998, -0.010094000957906246, -0.0034524835646152496, -0.02788423001766205, 0.03448774293065071, -0.042834509164094925, 0.0035877018235623837, 0.01940850354731083, -0.0024094837717711926, -0.02695089764893055, -0.013744405470788479, -0.07652723789215088, -0.019520653411746025, -0.015537481755018234, 0.058354590088129044, -0.0008598662097938359, -0.02694503217935562, 0.008931058458983898, 0.04019199684262276, 0.0039188372902572155, -0.029030581936240196, -0.04407402127981186, -0.0175089742988348, 0.0013405551435425878, 0.030246606096625328, 0.010774334892630577, 0.014748265035450459, -0.022823497653007507, 0.03765178471803665, 0.005154043436050415, 0.07881011813879013, 0.03798266127705574, 0.01867000199854374, -0.030870147049427032, -0.009562637656927109, -0.01810072734951973, -0.01344255730509758, 0.039821818470954895, 0.037796299904584885, 0.006280082743614912, 0.058478355407714844, 0.01566706784069538, -0.04997461289167404, 0.03178997337818146, 0.07028397917747498, 0.0222573634237051, 0.01395347435027361, -0.0037356417160481215, -0.007094943895936012, -0.01348027028143406, -0.011498489417135715, 0.0069958423264324665, 0.0033044787123799324, 0.004417696502059698, -0.014685406349599361, 0.039258960634469986, -0.03500259667634964, -0.038432203233242035, -0.01756880432367325, 0.03860805556178093, 0.024944636970758438, 0.019840914756059647, -0.04060577601194382, -0.003663143375888467, 0.06464540213346481, 0.042631760239601135, 0.01669679954648018, 0.010536814108490944, -0.041211944073438644, 0.020161353051662445, 0.022601395845413208, 0.02229132130742073, -0.02603927254676819, -0.009375400841236115, -0.019588900730013847, 0.02297353558242321, 0.021673154085874557, -0.02635999210178852, 0.01704985648393631, -0.004530849400907755, -0.02081417106091976, -0.010127659887075424, 0.0063916281796991825, -0.04291294887661934, -0.0051699066534638405, 0.009901688434183598, 0.017051395028829575, -0.03466857969760895, -0.02154868096113205, -0.05584845691919327, -0.01796271838247776, 0.025897447019815445, 0.0694688931107521, -0.014181499369442463, -0.010623670183122158, 0.015273972414433956, 0.05981777608394623, -0.02217674069106579, -0.05198829248547554, 0.01969926990568638, -0.007628375664353371, 0.009731230325996876, 0.044096946716308594, -0.05157596245408058, -0.04588437080383301, 0.029498180374503136, -0.006492071319371462, -0.02346125617623329, -0.00029580292175523937, -0.02644222415983677, 0.014722124673426151, 0.04082607105374336, 0.0355050303041935, 0.073337122797966, -0.000575912359636277, 0.009229159913957119, -0.013527147471904755, -0.05627106502652168, 0.012935331091284752, -0.05758818984031677, -0.033588606864213943, -0.061081286519765854, -0.025308696553111076, -0.03997504711151123, 0.039291862398386, -0.007643230725079775, 0.048443011939525604, -0.046921104192733765, -0.010435204021632671, 0.0012730991002172232, 0.03563448786735535, -0.0051760319620370865, 0.015979845076799393, 0.02991764433681965, 0.03484678640961647, -0.013024330139160156, -0.028846662491559982, 0.01912979781627655, -0.02674645557999611, 0.007194779813289642, 0.01956244371831417, -0.04989640414714813, 0.0349532850086689, -0.031666677445173264, -0.04775942489504814, -0.014084924943745136, -0.006446537561714649, 0.022129524499177933, -0.01807624287903309, 0.015667593106627464, 0.002442835131660104, -0.04754440486431122, -0.01522165909409523, 0.03478584066033363, 0.03422411531209946, 0.04463737830519676, -0.03416399657726288, 0.03193620964884758, 0.014309091493487358, 0.005077522713690996, -0.08208278566598892, -0.03422105312347412, -0.0018439562991261482, -0.020314717665314674, -0.007680574432015419, -0.033261287957429886, 0.013495301827788353, -0.036752570420503616, -0.045147605240345, -0.005145403556525707, 0.0589972585439682, 0.015788419172167778, -0.026855986565351486, 0.0061349691823124886, 0.01602957583963871, 0.06308773159980774, 0.006525314413011074, 0.007111300248652697, -0.0057603707537055016, -0.034690797328948975, 0.005260661710053682, 0.03883751854300499, 0.04231613501906395, -0.02667318657040596, 0.019705913960933685, -0.022988369688391685, -0.034626733511686325, 0.01860932819545269, -0.04754093289375305, -0.01243626233190298, 0.015808289870619774, 0.019122716039419174, 0.0020466495770961046, -0.009185356087982655, -0.021312102675437927, -0.04549308493733406, 0.020258760079741478, -0.006045476999133825, -0.015932906419038773, -0.004519797395914793, -0.0029189325869083405, 0.0481894426047802, 0.019419780001044273, -0.0038275117985904217, 0.023265719413757324, 0.07639504969120026, -0.002941923914477229, -0.015442336909472942, 0.010054491460323334, 0.015499903820455074, 0.031926460564136505, 0.006781318690627813, 0.013281635008752346, -0.02033698372542858, 0.027108972892165184, -0.04605383053421974, -0.025915827602148056, -0.027766263112425804, 0.0062662456184625626, 0.05175437405705452, -0.0252616535872221, 0.03240719437599182, 0.02127891033887863, 0.007272751536220312, -0.01818741485476494, -0.05044766515493393, -0.006234104745090008, -0.017913611605763435, -0.007258181925863028, 0.03346685320138931, -0.012794438749551773, -0.01464394573122263, 0.040916990488767624, -0.0012778514064848423, 0.005599204450845718, 0.030018894001841545, -0.043775808066129684, 0.028910282999277115, -0.011495048180222511, -0.002916729776188731, -0.03057161346077919, 0.028429286554455757, -0.03388741984963417, -0.0014896069187670946, -0.054268695414066315, 0.0009283863473683596, 0.007373979780822992, 0.027112392708659172, -0.010911816731095314, -0.018162546679377556, -0.017462993040680885, -0.0688868910074234, 0.0023903960827738047, 0.02986576408147812, -0.0014713233103975654, 0.05926337093114853, 0.04176950454711914, 0.026102101430296898, -0.02490234188735485, 0.024159878492355347, -0.04528547078371048, -0.053239960223436356, -0.00038442976074293256, -0.013486921787261963, -0.022358965128660202, 0.03293054550886154, -0.010625826194882393, -0.03559604287147522, 0.03589041903614998, -0.02901562675833702, 0.01617666892707348, -0.002561790170148015, 0.024890590459108353, -0.06285098195075989, 0.09338840842247009, 0.010387854650616646, 0.03690071031451225, -0.006406173575669527, 0.030054960399866104, 0.08571438491344452, 0.05526778846979141, 0.00883269403129816, -0.06044691056013107, -0.007267648819833994, -0.0465116947889328, -0.02164812758564949, -0.019059831276535988, 0.029253968968987465, 0.02218855358660221, 0.010577987879514694, 0.02419573999941349, 0.03728969022631645, 0.04392996430397034, -0.02091255970299244, 0.049254871904850006, -0.009357095696032047, -0.05011492967605591, 0.008514082059264183, -0.00900947954505682, -0.008533062413334846, -0.007273526396602392, -0.020498737692832947, 0.030591556802392006, -0.008589248172938824, -0.012471918016672134, -0.028507784008979797, -0.01971549354493618, -0.007327014580368996, -0.0337626188993454, -0.0065432386472821236, -0.002675597555935383, 0.006410145200788975, -0.008021226152777672, -0.03497082367539406, 0.016204118728637695, -0.0011811204021796584, -0.02687043882906437, 0.022793326526880264, 0.05507168173789978, 0.013872979208827019, 0.003922469448298216, 0.03573665767908096, -0.021640287712216377, -0.03910287842154503, -0.03907224163413048, -0.0502091683447361, 0.03544499725103378, -0.002016147132962942, -0.01621561124920845, 0.00971346627920866, 0.019786467775702477, -0.0015550103271380067, -0.05846681445837021, -0.009644642472267151, 0.00586487352848053, 0.011501587927341461, -0.03587030991911888, 0.0009889727225527167, -0.020928381010890007, 0.04536290839314461, 0.0012487125350162387, 0.03621293231844902, -0.006525529082864523, -0.028953684493899345, -0.021149421110749245, -0.010125258937478065, 0.02324197068810463, 0.009797382168471813, -0.04328559339046478, 0.003836903488263488, -0.0359087698161602, -0.0042740595526993275, 0.007852977141737938, 0.021221451461315155, -0.00003202086008968763, 0.03053962253034115, -0.005772378761321306, -0.010359914042055607, 0.001141600776463747, -0.08167112618684769, 0.014997848309576511, -0.03247784823179245, 0.009545021690428257, -0.03584766760468483, -0.023504700511693954, 0.030311543494462967, 0.0360775962471962, 0.006799565628170967, 0.00604038592427969, -0.004023997578769922, 0.0471658930182457, 0.05369522050023079, -0.07753680646419525, -0.03038741648197174, 0.009393556974828243, -0.009351355955004692, 0.009912136942148209, -0.04835718870162964, 0.06393236666917801, 0.02034514769911766, 0.039241973310709, -0.022332750260829926, 0.0165899395942688, -0.05818330869078636, 0.02725227363407612, 0.011985167860984802, -0.024461278691887856, 0.0022288623731583357, 0.0025692556519061327, 0.006562529597431421, 0.003088004421442747, -0.015021308325231075, -0.021607819944620132, -0.006132431793957949, 0.001256133895367384, -0.030182374641299248, -0.060607269406318665, 0.0013055462623015046, -0.011660171672701836, 0.00017017318168655038, -0.014914629980921745, -0.0027218107134103775, -0.0009360891417600214, -0.0026030486915260553, 0.0025935068260878325, -0.029585113748908043, -0.027510253712534904, 0.0320686474442482, -0.03439883887767792, -0.061267606914043427, 0.02669709362089634, 0.0132832583039999, 0.01146417111158371, -0.021210238337516785, 0.00794913712888956, -0.02784615382552147, 0.0616561658680439, -0.030073100700974464, 0.00942214671522379, 0.04355056956410408, -0.06840135902166367, -0.018455354496836662, 0.014006363227963448, 0.003713175654411316, 0.043024659156799316, 0.017802076414227486, -0.016888178884983063, -0.042588040232658386, 0.03388282656669617, -0.04295311123132706, 0.011785868555307388, -0.023691929876804352, -0.02070077694952488, -0.013012510724365711, -0.03327477350831032, 0.015803128480911255, 0.0008634683908894658, -0.0046358476392924786, 0.015473581850528717, 0.06599973142147064, -0.01694469526410103, -0.012294993735849857, 0.032678376883268356, 0.014508410356938839, 0.03910665214061737, -0.00951790064573288, 0.04179143160581589, 0.03450953587889671, 0.056203387677669525, -0.028309684246778488, 0.018600227311253548, -0.044750019907951355, 0.027644634246826172, -0.11379452794790268, 0.010500122793018818, 0.048936810344457626, 0.026683975011110306, 0.05094487965106964, -0.0480586513876915, -0.01679295115172863, 0.02243565022945404, -0.036668017506599426, -0.02614707686007023, -0.042556241154670715, -0.013968730345368385, -0.020315032452344894, 0.004080202430486679, -0.020405935123562813, 0.0046014972031116486, 0.015828542411327362, 0.037613093852996826, 0.03223297372460365, 0.03316260874271393, -0.024456877261400223, 0.006673603318631649, -0.01908441074192524, -0.019544413313269615, 0.016259033232927322, -0.06416858732700348, 0.02051636204123497, -0.03173481300473213, -0.038191117346286774, 0.04264841973781586, -0.014531456865370274, 0.014421585015952587, 0.012899374589323997, 0.017870545387268066, 0.04227471724152565, 0.02124866098165512, 0.010305754840373993, -0.016499940305948257, 0.016009772196412086, 0.015179542824625969, 0.02093776874244213, 0.02384994737803936, -0.024940652772784233, -0.041434016078710556, 0.024093760177493095, -0.017127996310591698, -0.032433800399303436, -0.0012559137539938092, -0.006885652896016836, -0.04001884162425995, 0.010922517627477646, -0.005506861489266157, 0.0020595176611095667, -0.05349220335483551, 0.062173355370759964, -0.02667059749364853, -0.03021049126982689, 0.03698677569627762, 0.035429224371910095, -0.007322273217141628, -0.007645412348210812, 0.01034256536513567, -0.0462738461792469, 0.02782037854194641, 0.008131936192512512, -0.03649500012397766, -0.07794471085071564, -0.017167123034596443, 0.00872771069407463, 0.0022387977223843336, -0.012774207629263401, -0.03128109127283096, -0.02343393862247467, 0.01478181779384613, 0.001422654720954597, 0.025802280753850937, -0.007707567419856787, -0.0064055887050926685, -0.0180580485612154, -0.07067084312438965, 0.04257398843765259, 0.029350807890295982, -0.01686345599591732, -0.05823583900928497, -0.015357413329184055, -0.018739452585577965, -0.03813333436846733, 0.04624072089791298, 0.005112344864755869, 0.013473883271217346, 0.0035731694661080837, 0.0703144371509552, 0.009125045500695705, -0.03286486864089966, 0.015211979858577251, -0.0335766039788723, -0.023399222642183304, -0.027390750125050545, -0.002460196614265442, 0.013721393421292305, 0.008074695244431496, 0.0036778757348656654, -0.011739702895283699, 0.00267411838285625, 0.01835213415324688, -0.04639647528529167, 0.0034003688488155603, 0.022991793230175972, -0.016753999516367912, 0.039960891008377075, 0.0033374044578522444, 0.021983077749609947, 0.018766628578305244, 0.027485154569149017, -0.06334534287452698, 0.020590614527463913, -0.01045999489724636, -0.027076179161667824, -0.01120288111269474, 0.02538130432367325, -0.01518365740776062, -0.050146665424108505, -0.025950774550437927, 0.028412654995918274, -0.04412074014544487, -0.034549299627542496, 0.03472987934947014, 0.02374742366373539, 0.027811823412775993, 0.013908903114497662, 0.010167598724365234, -0.0022940158378332853, -0.0185585618019104, 0.023133384063839912, 0.015226531773805618, 0.03240314498543739, -0.004948010668158531, 0.01416518073529005, 0.05557160824537277, -0.004264300689101219, 0.003281824290752411, -0.02796940505504608, 0.04437690228223801, -0.014940131455659866, -0.03975547105073929, 0.001858461182564497, -0.026984190568327904, 0.023056602105498314, -0.026734720915555954, -0.03651027753949165, 0.05947766825556755, -0.016334176063537598, 0.0077277906239032745, -0.04278726130723953, 0.028634823858737946, -0.015889884904026985, -0.0031779317650943995, 0.038106776773929596, -0.015808258205652237, 0.006050977855920792, 0.015791887417435646, 0.008614948019385338, -0.011982261203229427, 0.020922759547829628, -0.031323231756687164, 0.027560338377952576, -0.0022970049176365137, -0.0015836528036743402, -0.06838265061378479, -0.01500279176980257, -0.019826408475637436, -0.03008602187037468, 0.04718627780675888, 0.04241172969341278, 0.01200846116989851, -0.040177151560783386, -0.02471926063299179, -0.002090314170345664, 0.07076527178287506, -0.07089009881019592, -0.013356322422623634, -0.04126032814383507, 0.011367760598659515, -0.0034190358128398657, -0.039593011140823364 ]
<p>I am currently trying to better understand probabilistic skill ranking systems for games, but I find that I have trouble properly understanding the basic concept of how skill as a pairwise comparison can be generalized.</p> <p>For instance, if all you know is that player C wins player B 80% of the time, while that same player B wins player A 80% of the time, would this be enough data to determine how often C would win against A? How would those calculations work?</p> <p>Of course it might even be possible for a game to have different styles of play where A might win specifically against C, which would completely confuse the issue, but I am talking about general ranking systems such as <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elo_rating_system" rel="nofollow">ELO</a> or <a href="http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/trueskill/faq.aspx" rel="nofollow">Trueskill</a> that only take winning into account.</p>
74,462
[ -0.029190149158239365, -0.05874306708574295, -0.021209806203842163, -0.011972051113843918, 0.019173962995409966, 0.012770082801580429, 0.025731263682246208, -0.020627697929739952, 0.021890221163630486, -0.00652304757386446, 0.017454130575060844, -0.0010298695415258408, 0.05424017086625099, 0.03404879570007324, -0.02686365321278572, -0.01883949339389801, -0.04863601177930832, -0.007571318186819553, -0.015968995168805122, 0.023545391857624054, -0.021295718848705292, -0.0009076188434846699, 0.031329695135354996, -0.024345112964510918, -0.017766417935490608, 0.04108486697077751, 0.03302676975727081, -0.020859552547335625, 0.05788009986281395, 0.040731608867645264, 0.01573539711534977, -0.03215000778436661, 0.018085340037941933, 0.014874177984893322, 0.04065084084868431, 0.008192076347768307, -0.03884720429778099, -0.002285546390339732, -0.006668257527053356, 0.012034987099468708, -0.03278823569417, -0.021431010216474533, -0.020382551476359367, 0.055035460740327835, -0.018796976655721664, 0.011725610122084618, -0.044741395860910416, -0.026939498260617256, 0.022917235270142555, -0.06468384712934494, 0.07895147055387497, 0.006440659053623676, 0.04446477070450783, 0.034542277455329895, -0.028596343472599983, 0.01586230657994747, 0.042058344930410385, 0.0833115354180336, 0.009069432504475117, -0.06114114448428154, -0.04248572140932083, -0.03031284734606743, -0.017611922696232796, -0.0064445724710822105, -0.010378861799836159, 0.03211042284965515, 0.012947977520525455, -0.043657105416059494, 0.010822594165802002, -0.005518258083611727, -0.029149886220693588, 0.05344471335411072, 0.05279487743973732, 0.00005457242878037505, 0.03896553814411163, -0.0235456433147192, 0.03436211124062538, 0.03582705184817314, 0.04040936008095741, 0.025954708456993103, -0.03348935768008232, 0.031056679785251617, -0.016903430223464966, 0.05544731393456459, 0.05622458830475807, -0.00422939145937562, 0.01625971682369709, -0.054291412234306335, 0.029402462765574455, 0.01692919433116913, -0.002964374143630266, 0.008640076965093613, 0.0050619435496628284, -0.02818203717470169, -0.0593235157430172, 0.020759321749210358, -0.011923307552933693, 0.03144826740026474, 0.013742173090577126, 0.022328391671180725, 0.010055160149931908, -0.05812613293528557, -0.011921880766749382, 0.044451262801885605, 0.008885898627340794, -0.03592740744352341, -0.010119474492967129, 0.003137399675324559, -0.000309847469907254, 0.015252132900059223, -0.002424828941002488, 0.02303655631840229, 0.0030958664137870073, 0.03303007036447525, 0.0038558661472052336, -0.01596890762448311, 0.020613208413124084, -0.00559280626475811, 0.04489264264702797, 0.04086841642856598, 0.010838888585567474, -0.00444908207282424, 0.03360333293676376, -0.022388771176338196, -0.03236202523112297, 0.015349002555012703, 0.03228595852851868, -0.01777900941669941, -0.05733887478709221, 0.029209153726696968, -0.021145455539226532, -0.012211640365421772, 0.0004442342324182391, 0.011059288866817951, 0.01660030707716942, -0.01718454249203205, -0.09430240839719772, -0.030953148379921913, 0.02210448868572712, -0.003901380579918623, -0.001246933126822114, -0.06345174461603165, -0.024724069982767105, 0.015620715916156769, 0.05298368260264397, 0.011696768924593925, 0.05817122384905815, 0.020876821130514145, 0.03489242121577263, 0.03475368767976761, -0.013871257193386555, -0.033322885632514954, -0.027973297983407974, -0.023452267050743103, 0.005246963817626238, -0.09256967157125473, 0.03658311441540718, 0.0006758669042028487, -0.00784370768815279, -0.007746644783765078, 0.033749502152204514, 0.024309096857905388, -0.009500043466687202, 0.005586997140198946, 0.004229819867759943, 0.0038350799586623907, 0.090699702501297, 0.021577011793851852, 0.04026956483721733, 0.01450551301240921, -0.02270479127764702, -0.015595820732414722, 0.0558648556470871, 0.05252472311258316, 0.09252887219190598, 0.009727537631988525, -0.0017350917914882302, -0.039462652057409286, -0.020985852926969528, -0.020154885947704315, -0.05772915855050087, -0.0269940085709095, -0.0025592122692614794, 0.005357172340154648, 0.03291669487953186, 0.030073700472712517, -0.009333426132798195, 0.035712722688913345, 0.017556406557559967, -0.014933819882571697, -0.06407657265663147, -0.09445709735155106, 0.02169601246714592, -0.011678747832775116, 0.012027854099869728, 0.04307512938976288, -0.006526289042085409, 0.017486680299043655, -0.04365622624754906, -0.029313666746020317, -0.026471739634871483, 0.01302188541740179, 0.03750244900584221, -0.055685658007860184, 0.008010797202587128, 0.04556518420577049, 0.03169966861605644, -0.011183924041688442, 0.0667424350976944, -0.054219212383031845, -0.11142027378082275, 0.014697574079036713, -0.029369598254561424, 0.009972947649657726, 0.01021159254014492, 0.00460728770121932, 0.012591805309057236, 0.011780505068600178, -0.01905762404203415, -0.014793820679187775, -0.05379544571042061, 0.04428672045469284, 0.0552033856511116, -0.020201442763209343, 0.0035700625739991665, 0.018449153751134872, -0.008984302170574665, -0.031976163387298584, 0.011170578189194202, -0.027642449364066124, -0.03634759411215782, -0.01806630566716194, 0.0037685208953917027, 0.027224276214838028, -0.04127442091703415, 0.014247938990592957, 0.06787724047899246, 0.03235030174255371, -0.005923028104007244, 0.04472732171416283, -0.019254252314567566, 0.015331617556512356, 0.006223226431757212, 0.03225749731063843, 0.02541292831301689, 0.02839042618870735, 0.030906083062291145, 0.024500364437699318, -0.004568444564938545, 0.01075825933367014, -0.03316370025277138, 0.049037933349609375, 0.056468818336725235, 0.04354492947459221, 0.01495076809078455, -0.023724086582660675, 0.036564312875270844, -0.000415776448789984, 0.016665376722812653, 0.014833132736384869, -0.005766251124441624, -0.020915457978844643, -0.0033792946487665176, -0.030455565080046654, 0.02545686438679695, 0.04260074347257614, -0.039214760065078735, 0.0030707840342074633, 0.01728358305990696, -0.005016266368329525, 0.029101956635713577, -0.008075878955423832, -0.003917862195521593, -0.03624741733074188, -0.001685622613877058, 0.019026074558496475, -0.0029979951214045286, 0.021610144525766373, -0.023117829114198685, -0.035750195384025574, -0.02866525761783123, -0.04595177620649338, 0.007271566893905401, 0.0035260366275906563, -0.06974879652261734, 0.013201257213950157, -0.027605783194303513, -0.010725622996687889, 0.017567114904522896, 0.011295679025352001, -0.00030202820198610425, 0.028547421097755432, -0.019243478775024414, -0.01650913432240486, -0.019670750945806503, -0.04338923469185829, 0.013789896853268147, -0.037160616368055344, 0.005685367621481419, 0.034665968269109726, 0.004975212272256613, -0.05354924872517586, 0.03823787346482277, -0.0023156895767897367, -0.027054090052843094, -0.018506333231925964, -0.004308236297219992, 0.005888968240469694, -0.010604474693536758, 0.023174887523055077, 0.028054554015398026, -0.03393734619021416, -0.036030229181051254, -0.053783051669597626, -0.06318190693855286, 0.03650933504104614, -0.009904091246426105, 0.022459592670202255, 0.018413182348012924, -0.0395551472902298, 0.07028422504663467, 0.005671232473105192, 0.0041831922717392445, -0.03582150116562843, 0.0034411342348903418, -0.017759479582309723, -0.007073499727994204, 0.006144909653812647, 0.002101222751662135, -0.02877378836274147, 0.03119247779250145, -0.005913682747632265, 0.026483574882149696, 0.06091766804456711, -0.020034924149513245, -0.009066549129784107, -0.0045453826896846294, 0.025033582001924515, -0.03588608279824257, 0.0037754052318632603, 0.017118850722908974, -0.052258849143981934, 0.0280805341899395, 0.013227257877588272, 0.024805791676044464, -0.0022701288107782602, -0.025982115417718887, 0.01456527505069971, -0.0006821994902566075, -0.026701947674155235, -0.03649592399597168, 0.015169373713433743, -0.002198129426687956, -0.017514798790216446, 0.0071454416029155254, 0.010982848703861237, 0.035755742341279984, -0.022189689800143242, 0.017659340053796768, 0.051236171275377274, 0.047936633229255676, -0.032017000019550323, -0.04370252788066864, -0.013179360888898373, -0.00019374096882529557, 0.004252768121659756, -0.049225084483623505, -0.029411884024739265, 0.020383786410093307, -0.0124795688316226, 0.010172149166464806, 0.016687145456671715, -0.04171254485845566, -0.011570874601602554, -0.054906558245420456, -0.021924098953604698, -0.05012238025665283, 0.06632400304079056, -0.020935187116265297, 0.0472349114716053, 0.0037178192287683487, -0.026813464239239693, -0.015190096572041512, 0.009414661675691605, -0.06436571478843689, 0.04200500622391701, -0.02608010359108448, -0.028246065601706505, 0.0032634632661938667, -0.02379993535578251, 0.02826067805290222, -0.027206284925341606, -0.024774592369794846, -0.007035250775516033, 0.018347889184951782, -0.029010096564888954, 0.0014034475898370147, -0.05079861357808113, -0.06994586437940598, 0.02626972645521164, -0.016473906114697456, -0.007045671809464693, -0.032562874257564545, 0.056192684918642044, 0.03426840528845787, -0.050262048840522766, -0.007611753419041634, -0.02503313682973385, 0.04788738861680031, 0.05375763028860092, 0.005436969920992851, 0.01178930327296257, 0.07612645626068115, -0.032989174127578735, 0.004767983686178923, 0.008745594881474972, 0.07239525020122528, 0.06298915296792984, -0.02842821180820465, 0.000006392337581928587, -0.052734848111867905, -0.046692512929439545, 0.04360446333885193, 0.018110333010554314, -0.018054986372590065, 0.01957049034535885, 0.02105601131916046, 0.04894031956791878, -0.05626438930630684, 0.006460786331444979, 0.05116184800863266, 0.03399382159113884, 0.010432682000100613, -0.04049422964453697, 0.018406422808766365, 0.025727488100528717, -0.004452669061720371, 0.013381227850914001, 0.018205296248197556, 0.008764171041548252, 0.009896454401314259, 0.053594473749399185, -0.020546000450849533, -0.05799732357263565, 0.014983116649091244, 0.012222263030707836, 0.03277819603681564, -0.013636595569550991, -0.015703726559877396, 0.03155539557337761, 0.04153632000088692, 0.060749102383852005, -0.011007131077349186, 0.024250317364931107, -0.03747846558690071, -0.00804971344769001, 0.04520903155207634, 0.02368481084704399, -0.01610158570110798, -0.00963541865348816, -0.006813462357968092, 0.0008037464576773345, -0.004389427602291107, -0.01644263230264187, 0.05710601434111595, 0.0226857028901577, 0.014681597240269184, -0.06615167111158371, -0.010999076999723911, -0.0182296521961689, 0.055036235600709915, -0.03556859865784645, 0.04637158662080765, -0.0086258789524436, -0.025211310014128685, -0.04336962476372719, 0.020701715722680092, 0.020915981382131577, 0.026307273656129837, -0.05828085169196129, -0.006066792644560337, -0.018363911658525467, 0.008528864942491055, -0.017593003809452057, -0.06059630960226059, 0.018720196560025215, 0.016163498163223267, -0.019103627651929855, 0.03414163738489151, 0.01402908843010664, -0.02480577491223812, 0.009827901609241962, 0.004865813069045544, -0.00009149827383225784, -0.004475192632526159, 0.011218452826142311, 0.05871143192052841, 0.05769600719213486, -0.00860174186527729, 0.049254510551691055, -0.014825542457401752, -0.0017214067047461867, -0.02346089854836464, 0.02520596794784069, 0.01287283655256033, -0.024685217067599297, 0.034657612442970276, -0.00407522963359952, -0.023171238601207733, -0.042728863656520844, -0.015449711121618748, 0.008587632328271866, 0.0556354783475399, -0.022516900673508644, -0.006974429823458195, -0.054918061941862106, -0.010570862330496311, 0.011215843260288239, -0.04540045186877251, 0.016115503385663033, 0.03305359557271004, -0.011539250612258911, 0.0008615987026132643, 0.026401670649647713, 0.01930980756878853, 0.016525017097592354, -0.018248822540044785, -0.02809383161365986, 0.03155147656798363, -0.026097552850842476, -0.011045074090361595, -0.023246876895427704, -0.014732304029166698, 0.0423649325966835, -0.000121910976304207, 0.020678995177149773, 0.007654634770005941, -0.031975217163562775, -0.05863206833600998, 0.020790833979845047, 0.01520230621099472, -0.013317259028553963, -0.03447344899177551, 0.007380195427685976, 0.004742778837680817, -0.03811236098408699, -0.06189970672130585, 0.021142875775694847, 0.009737201035022736, -0.0010562033858150244, -0.007544300053268671, -0.03686828911304474, -0.003547379747033119, 0.012421442195773125, -0.015087168663740158, 0.016096822917461395, 0.03937874361872673, -0.0037836874835193157, -0.038143057376146317, -0.005911179818212986, -0.03747012838721275, 0.04619961231946945, 0.026675356552004814, -0.029538748785853386, -0.0014274895656853914, -0.002185520250350237, 0.02334604412317276, -0.009055061265826225, 0.028964271768927574, -0.03488440811634064, 0.01220626663416624, -0.028401633724570274, 0.03264176473021507, 0.040080465376377106, 0.0032190147321671247, 0.012657441198825836, -0.03355027362704277, 0.01168906968086958, 0.018963433802127838, -0.00025276915403082967, -0.005702759604901075, 0.0014173643430694938, 0.019009023904800415, -0.02886156365275383, -0.010131859220564365, 0.00039180013118311763, -0.0023243376053869724, 0.022354142740368843, 0.02642679400742054, 0.02066432498395443, -0.0002816082560457289, 0.030630329623818398, -0.03018476441502571, -0.005256629548966885, 0.008638770319521427, -0.018287206068634987, 0.0677587017416954, 0.004576301667839289, -0.0206125620752573, 0.03278196230530739, 0.019250385463237762, 0.01822507567703724, -0.009643472731113434, -0.06384514272212982, -0.00745701277628541, 0.048241712152957916, -0.04587560519576073, 0.042392466217279434, 0.07849596440792084, 0.012987694703042507, 0.0032915472984313965, -0.008868043310940266, 0.0013593054609373212, -0.03522943705320358, 0.010400738567113876, 0.01683417148888111, -0.037965185940265656, -0.025508012622594833, 0.05766262859106064, 0.029362045228481293, 0.019586311653256416, 0.026045601814985275, 0.039566658437252045, 0.010832328349351883, 0.04758863151073456, -0.041442420333623886, -0.05514315888285637, 0.09937194734811783, -0.07502643764019012, 0.009905499406158924, 0.018775826320052147, -0.028844092041254044, 0.07778044790029526, 0.03125479072332382, -0.004566116724163294, -0.03649356588721275, -0.046292997896671295, -0.03996976092457771, 0.04113341495394707, -0.0023761193733662367, -0.01466394029557705, 0.03672483190894127, -0.010533084161579609, 0.0241436418145895, 0.01004419382661581, -0.0004175974754616618, -0.023771677166223526, -0.0554131381213665, -0.0037338805850595236, -0.005192957818508148, -0.05802605673670769, -0.028060248121619225, 0.013870193623006344, -0.026798006147146225, 0.008909491822123528, -0.028289536014199257, -0.003440030850470066, -0.01590866968035698, 0.04321639984846115, -0.061802253127098083, 0.07636868208646774, 0.011874761432409286, 0.04546298831701279, 0.013981307856738567, -0.01507216040045023, 0.11757971346378326, 0.046924054622650146, 0.017344068735837936, -0.052740711718797684, 0.0001358559966320172, -0.017236458137631416, 0.013156754896044731, -0.023585420101881027, 0.010387047193944454, 0.02353587932884693, 0.016431385651230812, 0.040139805525541306, 0.0008511919295415282, 0.03657180815935135, -0.043027881532907486, 0.06861767917871475, -0.06171274557709694, -0.000553084013517946, 0.021865710616111755, 0.014733481220901012, 0.012291844002902508, -0.015162051655352116, 0.012656019069254398, 0.00945905689150095, 0.008288896642625332, 0.014294586144387722, 0.0022535051684826612, -0.04749183729290962, -0.03763842582702637, 0.042625848203897476, -0.004160027485340834, 0.004672063980251551, 0.02514519728720188, 0.020994018763303757, -0.032963745296001434, 0.0062599037773907185, 0.03939700871706009, -0.02296016365289688, 0.021350791677832603, 0.0009781774133443832, 0.005008521489799023, -0.015368283726274967, 0.014094333164393902, -0.008105309680104256, -0.04150601848959923, -0.017871005460619926, -0.06570268422365189, 0.015223858878016472, -0.01585114188492298, 0.014551703818142414, -0.002670449437573552, -0.02943095937371254, 0.004062880761921406, -0.028760604560375214, -0.012529131956398487, 0.03806069865822792, 0.04323586821556091, -0.030356453731656075, -0.027305608615279198, -0.021547731012105942, 0.003409767057746649, -0.02392362244427204, 0.02854805812239647, -0.0021352663170546293, -0.026530073955655098, -0.036827798932790756, -0.06493221968412399, 0.015642335638403893, -0.00507840421050787, -0.0098356232047081, 0.013571853749454021, -0.01195648591965437, -0.03696049377322197, -0.02382189780473709, 0.014886724762618542, 0.010676209814846516, 0.029145842418074608, 0.023365123197436333, -0.017865221947431564, -0.012051044031977654, -0.043605025857686996, 0.006352379452437162, -0.051509156823158264, -0.002632151124998927, -0.035827506333589554, -0.009461241774260998, 0.05778704956173897, 0.034901753067970276, -0.005640686023980379, -0.002471002284437418, -0.006597063969820738, -0.013044650666415691, 0.033984292298555374, -0.05370575934648514, -0.03933727368712425, 0.01266313623636961, -0.04676910862326622, 0.001473102020099759, 0.011430024169385433, 0.06155375391244888, 0.03202637657523155, 0.004801224917173386, -0.00813840702176094, -0.006960421800613403, -0.012287653051316738, 0.04932638257741928, 0.020089169964194298, -0.07549900561571121, -0.025328997522592545, 0.019695693626999855, 0.0030656380113214254, -0.010038133710622787, -0.049235641956329346, -0.03700082749128342, -0.020931117236614227, 0.01874532923102379, -0.016698937863111496, -0.009529484435915947, -0.043619051575660706, -0.01635240577161312, 0.012228280305862427, -0.003583038691431284, -0.0023725186474621296, -0.016254732385277748, 0.0015497178537771106, 0.011500487104058266, 0.008219781331717968, 0.00313667138107121, 0.014017991721630096, 0.00043761380948126316, 0.0030139016453176737, -0.005002281628549099, 0.007936201058328152, -0.0022593759931623936, -0.028948131948709488, -0.020197013393044472, -0.03613223880529404, 0.04138534516096115, -0.017601698637008667, -0.03937273100018501, 0.04720434918999672, -0.047107305377721786, -0.0031215492635965347, 0.044378407299518585, 0.017053041607141495, 0.07173305749893188, -0.005796812009066343, -0.003959523513913155, -0.030698293820023537, 0.03835299611091614, -0.00733569823205471, -0.012971416115760803, 0.017372051253914833, 0.02105509676039219, 0.03945263475179672, 0.03107411041855812, -0.004421444144099951, -0.019751742482185364, -0.010102590546011925, 0.004845676477998495, 0.044836971908807755, 0.007936968468129635, -0.0023067721631377935, -0.018138008192181587, 0.027017436921596527, 0.00570790795609355, 0.003947773948311806, 0.004614972043782473, 0.03577357158064842, 0.036448221653699875, 0.004382445476949215, 0.031933318823575974, 0.009969779290258884, -0.0027727074921131134, -0.08309987187385559, -0.011033103801310062, 0.019675176590681076, 0.004958722274750471, 0.04234775900840759, -0.03988337144255638, 0.01687926985323429, -0.006596067454665899, -0.059372805058956146, 0.018463270738720894, 0.016349071636795998, 0.00941799022257328, -0.032757628709077835, 0.003393682651221752, -0.0284135602414608, 0.023474998772144318, 0.011882826685905457, -0.01845800131559372, 0.01615888997912407, -0.002985829021781683, -0.002910915296524763, -0.0009090607054531574, -0.016557609662413597, 0.03231381997466087, -0.01701481267809868, -0.048297785222530365, -0.003988893702626228, -0.050838079303503036, -0.024975603446364403, 0.034407202154397964, -0.011037404648959637, 0.015918143093585968, 0.008478720672428608, 0.023030199110507965, 0.01594940759241581, 0.021766027435660362, 0.005174603313207626, 0.004764737095683813, -0.019073791801929474, -0.0002487913297954947, 0.018182290717959404, 0.031045924872159958, -0.008541448973119259, 0.022653788328170776, 0.035265736281871796, -0.052976518869400024, -0.033935461193323135, 0.03810190036892891, -0.016750795766711235, -0.010846336372196674, 0.045447565615177155, 0.013313696719706059, 0.046525657176971436, 0.0036877093371003866, 0.04116593301296234, -0.023520801216363907, 0.015570943243801594, 0.01262657344341278, -0.006174965295940638, 0.003931246232241392, 0.016059815883636475, -0.01605723798274994, -0.04203559085726738, 0.03980578854680061, -0.0040161097422242165, -0.02744848094880581, -0.052344098687171936, 0.0018154517747461796, 0.021661045029759407, -0.009542521089315414, 0.0014423897955566645, -0.03518415614962578, -0.014703351072967052, 0.007947096601128578, -0.007079887669533491, 0.048908546566963196, 0.013741068542003632, -0.03697938099503517, 0.004172337241470814, -0.092814140021801, 0.08756449818611145, 0.017273517325520515, -0.018481403589248657, -0.033128734678030014, -0.017962845042347908, -0.017425714060664177, -0.03237840160727501, 0.015848929062485695, -0.0043186345137655735, -0.016764985397458076, -0.016950106248259544, 0.01863524131476879, 0.009163383394479752, -0.04908454418182373, 0.016720330342650414, -0.018930679187178612, -0.013318093493580818, -0.029271796345710754, -0.0221856702119112, -0.023232603445649147, -0.0015650572022423148, 0.0456450991332531, -0.03301694989204407, -0.021247820928692818, -0.0033854669891297817, -0.02393113262951374, 0.07913690060377121, 0.04553169384598732, -0.002485217060893774, 0.02637724205851555, -0.00995456799864769, 0.007740133907645941, 0.04738514497876167, -0.017375046387314796, -0.03444105014204979, 0.03703723102807999, -0.04960554093122482, -0.01070905290544033, 0.02895193360745907, -0.008035257458686829, 0.003022142220288515, -0.0812731459736824, -0.01580905169248581, 0.03630496934056282, -0.0002079254772979766, -0.009505347348749638, 0.0637081190943718, 0.04454499110579491, 0.0403856597840786, -0.03066246770322323, 0.0026627706829458475, -0.012241257354617119, -0.01615261472761631, -0.010319032706320286, 0.001669013174250722, 0.044567789882421494, 0.02451290190219879, 0.007518821861594915, 0.0069799041375517845, 0.023721730336546898, 0.03795933350920677, -0.010720337741076946, 0.057544268667697906, -0.031664226204156876, 0.009317098185420036, 0.02364368736743927, 0.0012642706278711557, 0.012133128941059113, -0.010153989307582378, -0.030714087188243866, 0.06160450726747513, -0.007347005419433117, -0.022876763716340065, -0.0425073616206646, 0.01051477063447237, -0.009614499285817146, -0.03454599529504776, 0.01820266619324684, 0.022476356476545334, -0.0012362003326416016, 0.030674980953335762, -0.008501000702381134, 0.042465463280677795, 0.03860633075237274, -0.01392688974738121, 0.025694921612739563, 0.012707424350082874, -0.00804279837757349, -0.013338861055672169, -0.025575384497642517, -0.013406927697360516, -0.033624067902565, 0.03726770728826523, 0.002928786678239703, 0.02876233123242855, -0.019302424043416977, -0.033751074224710464, -0.004731462802737951, 0.02901117503643036, -0.06687896698713303, 0.0172890592366457, -0.06924819946289062, 0.05451924726366997, 0.0064785112626850605, -0.026009008288383484 ]
<p>I have a question regarding how to evaluate agreement between an individual's rating, and that of a group of people (of which the individual was a part). The group score was achieved through consensus (i.e. they agreed on one score as a group). I was originally planning to use kappa to look at agreement between the two scores, but I am now questioning this approach. Any ideas on how I can evaluate either the difference or the agreement between the two scores? My main worry is independence.</p> <p>The data looks something like this:<br> ID IndividualScore GroupScore<br> 1 5 3<br> 2 4 2<br> etc</p>
74,463
[ -0.038467392325401306, -0.0005262030172161758, -0.008481192402541637, -0.008074105717241764, 0.027752505615353584, -0.017138371244072914, -0.034414809197187424, -0.0040644994005560875, 0.03058243729174137, -0.013965767808258533, 0.04308169335126877, -0.011114969849586487, 0.05622270703315735, 0.04039613530039787, -0.02577178180217743, -0.00045213085832074285, -0.02699945494532585, -0.02437244914472103, -0.003472624346613884, 0.007359825074672699, -0.02979494072496891, 0.006936951074749231, -0.006653112825006247, -0.03194575384259224, -0.016655048355460167, 0.059975188225507736, 0.04485936090350151, -0.025540057569742203, 0.03429146111011505, 0.03588762506842613, -0.07170649617910385, -0.011740129441022873, -0.009686329402029514, -0.0019241297850385308, -0.007774113677442074, -0.0012119364691898227, -0.018554724752902985, 0.014740902930498123, -0.06292808055877686, 0.012838013470172882, -0.020565154030919075, -0.015290395356714725, -0.003775609191507101, 0.010854121297597885, -0.021849853917956352, -0.007698046509176493, -0.01933775469660759, -0.029544373974204063, -0.02247614599764347, -0.010078591294586658, 0.05637894570827484, 0.000815892475657165, 0.034283652901649475, 0.0317097008228302, -0.017910320311784744, 0.009791708551347256, 0.02843923680484295, 0.0699165016412735, 0.008027859963476658, -0.031896594911813736, -0.03935430943965912, -0.05142325162887573, 0.02320897951722145, -0.006877277512103319, -0.021730739623308182, 0.03792626038193703, -0.016180751845240593, -0.010238990187644958, 0.033755671232938766, 0.02198515087366104, 0.01712196320295334, 0.05646505206823349, 0.05033860728144646, -0.04207228496670723, 0.008550920523703098, -0.03810737282037735, 0.027943873777985573, 0.023043664172291756, 0.044412434101104736, 0.05315854772925377, -0.006719993893057108, 0.032743021845817566, 0.0587252639234066, 0.02140408381819725, 0.02030097506940365, -0.03420789912343025, 0.05606596916913986, -0.015918705612421036, -0.012859159149229527, 0.008594070561230183, -0.014526433311402798, 0.019504329189658165, 0.014239467680454254, 0.0235927514731884, -0.04053715243935585, 0.021768813952803612, -0.031891487538814545, 0.03922181949019432, -0.009146076627075672, -0.0015596604207530618, 0.024901889264583588, -0.01512323971837759, 0.02248198725283146, 0.04198372736573219, 0.0007533338502980769, -0.020530926063656807, -0.035404324531555176, -0.027574997395277023, 0.009121452458202839, -0.03435777127742767, -0.003368486650288105, -0.017469434067606926, -0.013718766160309315, 0.002800559625029564, 0.042463142424821854, 0.01976330205798149, -0.016772435978055, -0.02543770521879196, 0.06160319969058037, 0.0559314489364624, 0.059275347739458084, -0.028091927990317345, 0.016529737040400505, -0.02229471132159233, -0.033966124057769775, 0.017976215109229088, 0.028429271653294563, -0.028628796339035034, -0.05522961542010307, 0.0654708668589592, -0.021868132054805756, -0.007903922349214554, 0.019588399678468704, 0.007998441345989704, 0.0006651960429735482, -0.015153397805988789, -0.07999701052904129, -0.048867709934711456, 0.01866994984447956, -0.0002565339091233909, 0.021456481888890266, -0.05766500160098076, 0.010297970846295357, 0.037215445190668106, 0.040696848183870316, 0.011348322033882141, 0.04021564871072769, -0.0009791433112695813, 0.0255068838596344, -0.015003888867795467, -0.011716277338564396, -0.0339527428150177, -0.041517287492752075, -0.041555486619472504, -0.010606665164232254, -0.07682853192090988, 0.009714039042592049, 0.016070453450083733, 0.01336092222481966, -0.012453647330403328, 0.03585627302527428, -0.0007452057907357812, -0.005041138734668493, -0.019763967022299767, 0.024722866714000702, 0.04098333418369293, 0.03528380021452904, -0.011761292815208435, 0.012705122120678425, -0.01497610192745924, 0.01970762014389038, 0.0032436642795801163, 0.032525621354579926, 0.05523967370390892, 0.05406182259321213, 0.01084931567311287, -0.030801640823483467, -0.042582422494888306, 0.009102662093937397, -0.032200902700424194, -0.04769046977162361, -0.03985220193862915, -0.029950495809316635, -0.004501843824982643, 0.02360411360859871, 0.027558544650673866, -0.021546412259340286, -0.014063156209886074, 0.016687236726284027, -0.00765191437676549, -0.05561352148652077, -0.06750313937664032, 0.009386313147842884, -0.00028172117890790105, -0.022520259022712708, 0.016915302723646164, 0.01585455611348152, 0.04173796996474266, -0.015541509725153446, -0.0032495837658643723, -0.06671413779258728, -0.019561173394322395, 0.031796813011169434, -0.028443023562431335, 0.024374403059482574, 0.03603692352771759, 0.03998022526502609, -0.023335203528404236, 0.026310747489333153, -0.024260079488158226, -0.059527523815631866, 0.019724814221262932, -0.023678256198763847, 0.00305329542607069, 0.00011112404172308743, -0.018595488741993904, 0.00661421986296773, 0.009695648215711117, -0.04292546957731247, -0.005652986001223326, -0.04891984909772873, 0.07541251182556152, 0.02974572777748108, 0.007881810888648033, 0.0011290840338915586, 0.0127307940274477, -0.0060503422282636166, -0.03258617967367172, -0.03154602274298668, -0.020364712923765182, -0.07897871732711792, -0.02378174290060997, 0.03377397730946541, 0.015963302925229073, -0.023496882990002632, 0.010683717206120491, 0.044241439551115036, 0.037142083048820496, 0.003689651843160391, 0.0019655616488307714, 0.017974691465497017, -0.010133023373782635, 0.0018633907893672585, 0.01667892374098301, 0.024575095623731613, -0.003525350010022521, -0.006495553068816662, 0.025184135884046555, 0.053502023220062256, -0.007734136655926704, 0.009877704083919525, 0.03701327368617058, 0.0093713803216815, 0.015074712224304676, -0.0036081389989703894, -0.03370371460914612, 0.030850466340780258, -0.015208366326987743, 0.017322706058621407, 0.03507106378674507, 0.010812615975737572, 0.00374040100723505, -0.009224463254213333, -0.017429275438189507, 0.007141789887100458, 0.05649695545434952, -0.05348643288016319, -0.018560457974672318, 0.004049253184348345, -0.023793864995241165, 0.027881618589162827, -0.026848535984754562, -0.03896007314324379, -0.038307175040245056, 0.0038502647075802088, 0.051623906940221786, 0.003173045814037323, 0.02515295520424843, -0.012416762299835682, -0.024518541991710663, 0.012415366247296333, -0.03977641835808754, 0.011888221837580204, 0.006021139211952686, -0.05919114500284195, -0.03619176149368286, 0.008733800612390041, 0.009080632589757442, 0.023442208766937256, 0.005936872214078903, -0.043349750339984894, 0.023516427725553513, 0.0234703216701746, -0.0796894058585167, 0.005341507960110903, -0.03289474546909332, 0.018468588590621948, -0.025401996448636055, -0.020391467958688736, 0.02232590690255165, -0.013166607357561588, -0.023639971390366554, 0.062325362116098404, -0.04549992084503174, -0.028011685237288475, 0.025116223841905594, 0.026306862011551857, 0.025351975113153458, 0.018616216257214546, 0.010200495831668377, 0.03657572343945503, -0.018383130431175232, -0.04888645187020302, -0.06824173778295517, -0.08105379343032837, 0.06386815756559372, -0.019204353913664818, 0.00530753331258893, 0.0005243908963166177, -0.03073168732225895, 0.0711779072880745, 0.012031624093651772, -0.029159098863601685, -0.027641935274004936, -0.03221147879958153, -0.0395023450255394, 0.0031464395578950644, -0.003504162421450019, 0.00478491373360157, 0.01297353208065033, 0.012732203118503094, 0.007089712657034397, 0.019051652401685715, 0.0765213891863823, -0.03189367800951004, 0.010033145546913147, 0.013854598626494408, 0.034381382167339325, -0.025852857157588005, 0.01839260384440422, 0.017897533252835274, -0.03761584311723709, 0.00042209975072182715, 0.027707858011126518, 0.015070108696818352, 0.006386420223861933, -0.033030349761247635, 0.012078169733285904, 0.013801337219774723, 0.020830858498811722, -0.0681099072098732, 0.02518044225871563, 0.02027934603393078, -0.008256081491708755, 0.032939355820417404, 0.04729641601443291, 0.040731385350227356, -0.00886161532253027, 0.012697206810116768, 0.09183938801288605, 0.02171955071389675, 0.008370502851903439, -0.0646267756819725, 0.015412749722599983, -0.01566619984805584, 0.021263541653752327, -0.001192442956380546, -0.013493428006768227, 0.022035401314496994, 0.0024081594310700893, 0.025145379826426506, -0.0016766671324148774, -0.06319089233875275, 0.020811624825000763, -0.07265355437994003, 0.02054392732679844, -0.01559078972786665, 0.03241535276174545, 0.0066654616966843605, 0.06437546014785767, 0.040100522339344025, -0.0018416100647300482, 0.012406487949192524, 0.003945483826100826, -0.034180738031864166, 0.03691590949892998, -0.016408855095505714, -0.02101059816777706, 0.03225299343466759, -0.00763282272964716, 0.025154970586299896, -0.004571018740534782, 0.00015896675176918507, 0.00035518573713488877, 0.04695425555109978, 0.009230776689946651, 0.005267742555588484, -0.01601128838956356, 0.019967995584011078, 0.046956174075603485, 0.013370310887694359, -0.010023967362940311, -0.020957911387085915, 0.037902772426605225, 0.050380561500787735, 0.026854394003748894, 0.0208401158452034, -0.02236780896782875, -0.023955998942255974, 0.007729632314294577, 0.04985055327415466, 0.026041219010949135, 0.03328976035118103, 0.00420288136228919, 0.04204067215323448, -0.002849309239536524, 0.033488254994153976, 0.024938371032476425, -0.04145079851150513, -0.0076288883574306965, -0.037318434566259384, -0.021097982302308083, -0.006257836241275072, 0.024146363139152527, -0.01546908263117075, 0.00010988821304636076, 0.014288430102169514, 0.02671774849295616, -0.05756206065416336, 0.01572444662451744, 0.058314286172389984, 0.028978509828448296, -0.028684677556157112, -0.022925138473510742, -0.02806801162660122, 0.013475981540977955, -0.027146730571985245, 0.05508898198604584, 0.030265962705016136, -0.0123209273442626, -0.004557608161121607, 0.04851522296667099, -0.04727168753743172, -0.04290953278541565, -0.02806287445127964, -0.01791134662926197, 0.018308717757463455, -0.014614379964768887, -0.0376850850880146, 0.007497280836105347, 0.05695222318172455, 0.06302784383296967, 0.05124171823263168, -0.009750798344612122, -0.08624128997325897, 0.0001321876043220982, 0.02829260565340519, 0.023278873413801193, -0.047962773591279984, -0.018604008480906487, -0.010503716766834259, -0.023156026378273964, 0.06594723463058472, -0.029038527980446815, 0.04875374957919121, 0.018208079040050507, 0.019056765362620354, -0.0045111640356481075, 0.011715259402990341, -0.008743641898036003, 0.031928449869155884, 0.013467498123645782, 0.03299728408455849, -0.01892676390707493, -0.018446095287799835, -0.032211411744356155, -0.02177736535668373, 0.008531318046152592, 0.04862862080335617, 0.008408631198108196, 0.003349690232425928, -0.010035334154963493, 0.008142697624862194, -0.02450878731906414, -0.036360032856464386, 0.027097126469016075, -0.001284589758142829, -0.007412981241941452, 0.0648232102394104, 0.006674924865365028, -0.04199047386646271, -0.00797987263649702, 0.003821376711130142, -0.011879068799316883, 0.0038340287283062935, 0.011483405716717243, 0.046350039541721344, 0.04648618772625923, 0.015425596386194229, 0.05107443407177925, 0.016455847769975662, -0.01357900258153677, 0.00843764841556549, -0.04609854146838188, 0.007806232199072838, -0.04582899436354637, -0.01339713018387556, 0.007235087454319, -0.009915974922478199, -0.0395631343126297, 0.024335917085409164, -0.0036954956594854593, 0.061741359531879425, -0.03471513092517853, 0.008376344107091427, 0.007518108934164047, -0.014647215604782104, 0.0006543155759572983, 0.014700978063046932, 0.00020962339476682246, 0.022418459877371788, -0.0016416554572060704, -0.0243544839322567, 0.043569911271333694, -0.04472878947854042, 0.0031831732485443354, -0.009663091041147709, -0.08638419210910797, 0.007126068230718374, -0.03258741274476051, -0.03768626227974892, 0.0037384999450296164, -0.04245758801698685, 0.05205586180090904, -0.021649369969964027, 0.04373905062675476, -0.003430319717153907, -0.051013000309467316, -0.025672582909464836, -0.0017918959492817521, -0.0028259812388569117, 0.06703520566225052, -0.02122896909713745, 0.06696159392595291, 0.006382396910339594, -0.03253975138068199, -0.09044985473155975, -0.02921394258737564, 0.039763081818819046, 0.006941196508705616, -0.027663975954055786, -0.052849240601062775, 0.03487107530236244, -0.00474349083378911, 0.008940916508436203, -0.002533828606829047, 0.04467536136507988, 0.004318785388022661, -0.03450706601142883, -0.02084219828248024, -0.0004492641019169241, 0.10183601826429367, 0.011103188619017601, 0.017501678317785263, -0.0023488926235586405, -0.03694092109799385, -0.0025632171891629696, 0.016832636669278145, 0.027751499786973, -0.01626705937087536, 0.0042616454884409904, -0.055694352835416794, 0.024305297061800957, 0.049764830619096756, 0.01067257858812809, -0.008727752603590488, 0.01385659258812666, -0.006897761020809412, 0.0006503984332084656, -0.0004923511878587306, 0.02110299840569496, -0.006520208436995745, -0.011536688543856144, -0.03958550840616226, -0.011361870914697647, -0.024885835126042366, -0.003254169598221779, 0.037907134741544724, 0.009064282290637493, -0.04618312790989876, 0.005659517832100391, 0.0824192613363266, 0.010520169511437416, 0.016939029097557068, 0.004839702509343624, -0.036835744976997375, 0.025335097685456276, -0.024656539782881737, -0.01069622952491045, 0.004041324369609356, 0.035715632140636444, -0.04253186658024788, -0.004868223797529936, -0.015374613925814629, -0.031086515635252, 0.07913703471422195, -0.03705905005335808, 0.06346659362316132, 0.07681942731142044, 0.012682054191827774, 0.005236351862549782, -0.039213165640830994, 0.019793903455138206, -0.0065272897481918335, 0.01750333607196808, 0.02163725718855858, -0.05577355995774269, 0.014631847850978374, 0.012117600068449974, 0.029516998678445816, -0.010996783152222633, 0.03136850520968437, 0.0314691923558712, 0.006877153180539608, 0.014516900293529034, -0.004992329981178045, -0.06215183064341545, 0.02571684867143631, -0.04413866624236107, -0.018935684114694595, -0.03607584908604622, -0.02253331057727337, 0.02654053084552288, 0.05285409092903137, -0.009625623933970928, -0.01748349703848362, -0.0031696108635514975, -0.04245457425713539, 0.03469187766313553, 0.015050371177494526, -0.0073268418200314045, 0.027639329433441162, -0.006053156219422817, 0.035171642899513245, 0.00028981882496736944, 0.021875550970435143, -0.027338402345776558, -0.1047854945063591, -0.03151840344071388, -0.00396968936547637, -0.04541027173399925, 0.01045510359108448, 0.01391333993524313, -0.026734009385108948, 0.01810174435377121, -0.024663660675287247, 0.01433581206947565, 0.011262116022408009, 0.030104095116257668, -0.022843580693006516, 0.04968263581395149, -0.012816117145121098, 0.03932729363441467, 0.03933187574148178, 0.02453162707388401, 0.10615275055170059, 0.04924437403678894, 0.035723522305488586, -0.033889174461364746, 0.04345874860882759, 0.011679730378091335, -0.03967392072081566, -0.012412656098604202, 0.024204032495617867, 0.002274523489177227, -0.014553961344063282, 0.05008387938141823, 0.06763757765293121, 0.060217730700969696, -0.02980065532028675, 0.08246049284934998, -0.012376002036035061, -0.028971858322620392, 0.022478902712464333, 0.018710149452090263, 0.005118361208587885, -0.050007689744234085, -0.005089151207357645, 0.02162747085094452, 0.014745390973985195, -0.020070776343345642, -0.028891611844301224, -0.001125532086007297, 0.028768036514520645, 0.01380995288491249, 0.0025183449033647776, -0.00011533298675203696, 0.009004976600408554, 0.007829793728888035, -0.03878426551818848, 0.012293498031795025, -0.002595500787720084, -0.033712781965732574, 0.029307914897799492, 0.021853603422641754, 0.0018207208486273885, -0.02770169824361801, 0.028120562434196472, 0.005265673156827688, -0.048175908625125885, -0.07129926979541779, -0.03342099115252495, 0.03768099471926689, 0.007196502294391394, 0.012011293321847916, -0.039339181035757065, 0.007669022306799889, -0.024784354493021965, -0.06075315177440643, -0.0213649682700634, 0.014093981124460697, 0.03829855099320412, -0.0268754530698061, -0.04738397151231766, -0.050535377115011215, 0.025505857542157173, -0.029686802998185158, 0.0077536944299936295, 0.036776307970285416, -0.005651447456330061, -0.031086528673768044, -0.05430062487721443, 0.015413875691592693, 0.015976063907146454, 0.007411278784275055, -0.0017636335687711835, 0.0005816986667923629, -0.029295610263943672, 0.018377486616373062, -0.02495451085269451, 0.03411797061562538, 0.03680407255887985, 0.005158805288374424, 0.021525930613279343, -0.053140316158533096, -0.018786560744047165, 0.030927157029509544, -0.03126199543476105, -0.0009049989166669548, -0.024587951600551605, 0.007755766157060862, 0.04890143498778343, 0.005226027220487595, 0.006873783189803362, 0.018839547410607338, 0.004468487109988928, 0.023977909237146378, 0.0023028086870908737, -0.02801050804555416, -0.0080375662073493, 0.0032343240454792976, -0.06238270550966263, 0.006500277668237686, -0.02391563542187214, 0.07208094000816345, 0.01160645391792059, 0.0025041017215698957, -0.0037909443490207195, 0.021598631516098976, 0.005159337073564529, 0.02511884644627571, 0.009924999438226223, -0.04545268416404724, -0.005943912081420422, -0.0020269150845706463, 0.014189907349646091, -0.005230408627539873, 0.006565437186509371, -0.054000869393348694, -0.01872178539633751, 0.02972494810819626, -0.02743993140757084, -0.031568266451358795, -0.014426170848309994, -0.0034227604046463966, 0.03367728739976883, -0.013034675270318985, -0.0022522364743053913, -0.011310892179608345, -0.014223873615264893, -0.009720050729811192, 0.011769425123929977, -0.016251200810074806, 0.0066132619976997375, 0.01632634736597538, 0.007897702045738697, 0.05542146414518356, -0.0019419825403019786, 0.025627290830016136, -0.013682506047189236, 0.003813030431047082, -0.028524916619062424, 0.07053670287132263, 0.005459656938910484, -0.009546359069645405, 0.04199691116809845, -0.06388173252344131, -0.01889229193329811, 0.0034549464471638203, 0.007867606356739998, 0.032359346747398376, 0.018133871257305145, -0.04234691709280014, -0.01911214180290699, 0.038834571838378906, -0.04385596141219139, -0.04741843789815903, -0.016355736181139946, 0.004335469100624323, -0.025668689981102943, 0.014428900554776192, -0.011490310542285442, 0.02027853950858116, -0.022596530616283417, 0.010518912225961685, 0.0285428948700428, -0.0026677909772843122, -0.02743392251431942, 0.008439257740974426, 0.009660513140261173, -0.014183945022523403, 0.007996903732419014, -0.004866479896008968, 0.024517452344298363, 0.0595456026494503, -0.050533831119537354, 0.014808000065386295, 0.0066114021465182304, 0.021731669083237648, -0.07797695696353912, -0.015194776467978954, -0.017781555652618408, 0.0189745482057333, 0.04635334387421608, -0.07090968638658524, -0.010383947752416134, 0.03781379759311676, -0.048502013087272644, 0.018368622288107872, -0.035466745495796204, 0.0023115293588489294, -0.02889171428978443, 0.009351896122097969, -0.03654852509498596, 0.025991622358560562, 0.009460661560297012, 0.039751362055540085, 0.031242942437529564, 0.030318526551127434, 0.012706827372312546, -0.0004419199249241501, -0.035533737391233444, 0.024567147716879845, 0.032341595739126205, -0.08290642499923706, 0.021833499893546104, -0.06342291086912155, -0.05835079774260521, 0.03169241175055504, -0.05828973650932312, 0.02858145348727703, 0.05362909287214279, 0.021441074088215828, 0.015915537253022194, 0.025822175666689873, 0.0026633150409907103, -0.035334762185811996, -0.043011374771595, 0.00023148606123868376, 0.015764066949486732, 0.011907070875167847, 0.005355234257876873, 0.0017445702105760574, 0.0355987548828125, -0.027422267943620682, -0.016627375036478043, 0.0362125001847744, -0.026506299152970314, -0.026479654014110565, -0.04063178226351738, -0.015016303397715092, 0.015810083597898483, -0.02634674496948719, -0.007182774133980274, -0.045578233897686005, 0.002040651859715581, 0.039983589202165604, -0.00466549675911665, 0.003639721078798175, -0.018682818859815598, 0.019220363348722458, -0.02634170465171337, 0.010882904753088951, -0.024828551337122917, -0.002027250127866864, -0.054326415061950684, -0.019536251202225685, -0.02630305103957653, 0.005176789127290249, -0.0012294702464714646, -0.0016236379742622375, 0.008997821249067783, 0.050434257835149765, -0.03975711762905121, 0.013766654767096043, 0.020637882873415947, -0.04215645417571068, -0.009424617514014244, -0.031705498695373535, 0.04727364331483841, 0.03304097801446915, -0.04279250279068947, -0.025195037946105003, -0.013251997530460358, -0.033730193972587585, -0.0069123199209570885, 0.06372102349996567, 0.005336021073162556, 0.011584850959479809, -0.04726819321513176, -0.00964205153286457, 0.015374483540654182, -0.01706267148256302, 0.014905485324561596, -0.007521575782448053, -0.019394444301724434, -0.02697264589369297, 0.005281282123178244, -0.018683699890971184, 0.0026293243281543255, 0.06602628529071808, -0.04787351191043854, 0.011295482516288757, -0.014384569600224495, 0.01333281397819519, 0.03433842211961746, -0.02241450548171997, -0.010352999903261662, 0.04829422011971474, -0.013470706529915333, 0.003182510379701853, 0.049244023859500885, 0.008695160038769245, -0.0224367156624794, 0.046099595725536346, -0.034792739897966385, -0.02509361132979393, 0.018668338656425476, 0.03424471989274025, -0.04546184837818146, -0.05990955978631973, -0.004015463404357433, 0.025357885286211967, -0.05212390050292015, 0.023252736777067184, 0.0395004041492939, 0.021580444648861885, 0.020686455070972443, 0.004179146606475115, 0.00009608755499357358, 0.02734140120446682, -0.024703167378902435, 0.03661125525832176, 0.013986905105412006, 0.06836201995611191, 0.024284664541482925, 0.01688678376376629, 0.0011044495040550828, -0.016234254464507103, 0.022506287321448326, -0.008206341415643692, 0.026179013773798943, -0.041003838181495667, -0.018892066553235054, 0.0027798183728009462, -0.0017117931274697185, 0.04758600518107414, 0.017329232767224312, -0.012687202543020248, 0.03885679692029953, -0.033148378133773804, -0.016041431576013565, -0.04928242415189743, -0.028465209528803825, -0.04443531855940819, 0.005869087763130665, 0.03749844431877136, 0.04502600058913231, 0.0017727387603372335, 0.00572940893471241, -0.005802701693028212, -0.023247208446264267, 0.008368183858692646, -0.02390030026435852, 0.04139869287610054, -0.024287542328238487, 0.03420497849583626, -0.021594518795609474, 0.003386328462511301, -0.028165055438876152, -0.016031211242079735, 0.026316942647099495, 0.03323433920741081, 0.04005682095885277, -0.002040470251813531, -0.03172745183110237, -0.011829928494989872, 0.041841503232717514, -0.04296844080090523, -0.033509511500597, -0.047465816140174866, 0.026764938607811928, 0.028028393164277077, -0.0008006501011550426 ]
<p>I'm looking at the concentration of an event occurrences in a given interval of time. For example, we suppose that an event occurred 4 times in an interval of length 10. I can represent this as a string where <code>X</code> means <em>the event occurred</em> whereas <code>o</code> means <em>the event didn't occur</em>.</p> <p>The distribution of events could be rather "uniform" in time :</p> <pre><code>X o o X o o X o o X </code></pre> <p>Or it can be "concentrated" like this :</p> <pre><code>X X X o o o o o o X </code></pre> <p>Or like this :</p> <pre><code>X o o o X X o o o X </code></pre> <p>I'm looking for an index or a distance that would allow me to measure and compare the concentration of event occurrence in my interval. Ideally it would allow to compare interval of different lengths, for example it would distinguish between : </p> <pre><code>X o X o X o X o X o X </code></pre> <p>And :</p> <pre><code>X o o o X X o X </code></pre> <p>Do you know of any index or measure that would allow such a thing ?</p> <p>Many thanks in advance.</p>
74,464
[ -0.020587697625160217, -0.03947379067540169, -0.008293415419757366, -0.019547665491700172, 0.01988471858203411, 0.021908165886998177, -0.0012639862252399325, -0.007139642257243395, 0.03581813722848892, -0.008277912624180317, 0.04954441264271736, 0.047988347709178925, 0.05802561715245247, 0.021885747089982033, 0.028627000749111176, -0.03110637702047825, -0.012966075912117958, 0.02282101847231388, 0.0018889651400968432, -0.06376948207616806, -0.00010668845061445609, -0.02024064213037491, 0.00861163716763258, -0.00363288726657629, -0.029501913115382195, 0.011114145629107952, -0.007180607412010431, -0.011598693206906319, -0.017620882019400597, 0.04588298872113228, -0.04945572465658188, -0.04632432013750076, 0.02794720232486725, 0.035390857607126236, 0.034506186842918396, 0.005329981911927462, -0.027751274406909943, -0.03068321943283081, -0.026889506727457047, 0.03487455099821091, -0.01631838269531727, -0.011683864519000053, -0.029397372156381607, 0.023277264088392258, 0.011935295537114143, 0.027214664965867996, 0.020625943318009377, -0.04627016931772232, 0.010631853714585304, -0.058372773230075836, 0.07642247527837753, -0.03036557510495186, 0.07813990116119385, 0.013728643767535686, -0.020652446895837784, -0.015472956001758575, 0.03366532549262047, 0.07703076303005219, -0.026364091783761978, -0.04376743361353874, -0.027378853410482407, -0.020568644627928734, 0.0034838635474443436, -0.015680592507123947, -0.02236289530992508, 0.002040330320596695, -0.016901895403862, -0.032240334898233414, 0.03948274999856949, -0.032081183046102524, -0.03825925290584564, 0.04075067117810249, 0.04393516853451729, 0.010496871545910835, 0.011004691012203693, -0.03444541245698929, 0.017313232645392418, -0.008266463875770569, 0.05787697806954384, 0.011499102227389812, -0.017909197136759758, -0.011830789037048817, -0.0047888560220599174, 0.008775817230343819, 0.01155159529298544, -0.022402726113796234, 0.048479314893484116, -0.07464641332626343, -0.001938444678671658, 0.030428050085902214, -0.00543258897960186, 0.00375303509645164, 0.017067376524209976, 0.04586396738886833, -0.03996540978550911, 0.02705426700413227, -0.000501851667650044, 0.024842308834195137, 0.02946390211582184, 0.01711851730942726, -0.00949129182845354, -0.08373109996318817, -0.0033172147814184427, 0.06708461791276932, -0.009490915574133396, -0.019389033317565918, -0.044260356575250626, -0.009963644668459892, -0.029225671663880348, 0.03264300525188446, -0.02883184142410755, -0.023250721395015717, 0.028910009190440178, 0.011542735621333122, 0.04059566929936409, -0.0037472399417310953, 0.010020116344094276, 0.010950982570648193, 0.03493296355009079, 0.08364126831293106, 0.031069951131939888, 0.005914526525884867, 0.025583993643522263, -0.005608855746686459, -0.040979523211717606, 0.016815682873129845, 0.011412068270146847, -0.002854678314179182, -0.014321009628474712, 0.048463571816682816, -0.037977807223796844, 0.022153280675411224, 0.04660402238368988, -0.013492586091160774, 0.04895186424255371, 0.024051357060670853, -0.05870719254016876, -0.008664936758577824, 0.047752007842063904, 0.02942688763141632, -0.04024505615234375, -0.06074192002415657, 0.0016796120908111334, 0.022637777030467987, 0.026912465691566467, 0.0351702943444252, 0.04044660925865173, -0.017702564597129822, -0.0045332033187150955, 0.030884042382240295, -0.017327167093753815, -0.004766348283737898, 0.0028122931253165007, 0.00864281877875328, 0.025618286803364754, -0.03808959946036339, -0.004027307964861393, 0.021138682961463928, -0.018764305859804153, 0.014488022774457932, 0.026491500437259674, 0.007495489437133074, -0.017041228711605072, 0.027818582952022552, 0.04502422362565994, -0.053593069314956665, 0.0710209384560585, 0.009349116124212742, 0.009456047788262367, -0.009389596059918404, 0.022171657532453537, 0.030881645157933235, 0.016841905191540718, -0.005070697516202927, 0.05528421700000763, -0.030439596623182297, -0.011100362055003643, 0.02569671906530857, -0.02149430848658085, 0.03781815618276596, -0.00007273859228007495, -0.04621082544326782, -0.004150399938225746, 0.013287383131682873, 0.043885331600904465, -0.0013042812934145331, 0.0021636246237903833, -0.030380580574274063, 0.026668809354305267, -0.04334032163023949, -0.01422072947025299, -0.05197924003005028, -0.006041937507688999, 0.01996970921754837, -0.04583102837204933, 0.022143252193927765, -0.007057678885757923, 0.00923129078000784, -0.03931283578276634, -0.04089861363172531, -0.06614983826875687, -0.006052451673895121, 0.044896163046360016, -0.04334060475230217, -0.024460334330797195, 0.046169545501470566, 0.029056424275040627, -0.009913919493556023, 0.05552251636981964, -0.0022029741667211056, -0.05468176305294037, -0.03404736891388893, -0.02802429534494877, 0.024011829867959023, -0.03210186958312988, 0.003949711099267006, 0.03147844225168228, -0.020250892266631126, -0.009904728271067142, 0.018319090828299522, -0.023806830868124962, 0.058263614773750305, 0.07235191017389297, 0.04559047520160675, 0.027315640822052956, -0.0353945791721344, 0.022611699998378754, 0.0015612151473760605, -0.009176005609333515, -0.0477869026362896, -0.009898288175463676, 0.006900301203131676, 0.015415078960359097, 0.025635069236159325, -0.03836061432957649, 0.021862559020519257, 0.07651200890541077, 0.026400292292237282, 0.021370278671383858, 0.0411638505756855, 0.01555628702044487, -0.02033177949488163, 0.005585378501564264, 0.020773794502019882, 0.05349588021636009, 0.022865956649184227, 0.035326071083545685, 0.03222203627228737, 0.020360099151730537, -0.034766633063554764, 0.003823834005743265, 0.0017133683431893587, 0.010976912453770638, 0.015648121014237404, -0.029120847582817078, -0.018655557185411453, 0.04201105609536171, -0.007872307673096657, 0.014459585770964622, 0.06816558539867401, -0.0007993884501047432, 0.008283436298370361, -0.002147008664906025, -0.04511672630906105, -0.013538005761802197, 0.018857182934880257, -0.04333946108818054, -0.02055085264146328, 0.01216910220682621, 0.005429847165942192, -0.0039015423972159624, -0.0033715690951794386, 0.011628521606326103, -0.06057654693722725, 0.02408728376030922, 0.05714040249586105, 0.021622326225042343, 0.006580130197107792, 0.011567601002752781, -0.00022774908575229347, 0.0038074832409620285, 0.004569984972476959, 0.0010839139577001333, -0.016091348603367805, -0.05439009889960289, -0.007910058833658695, 0.02453543245792389, -0.050056587904691696, 0.02127249911427498, -0.013957135379314423, -0.061337221413850784, 0.013765036128461361, -0.01103569008409977, -0.03227843716740608, -0.013241169974207878, 0.025326458737254143, -0.008060301654040813, -0.0021390130277723074, -0.0033485889434814453, 0.047393813729286194, -0.013182959519326687, -0.08325901627540588, 0.04744403436779976, -0.04509582743048668, -0.05738129839301109, -0.06373141705989838, 0.024086641147732735, 0.009213605895638466, -0.024244343861937523, -0.002779280999675393, 0.04714631289243698, 0.028461843729019165, -0.0026261969469487667, -0.061483029276132584, -0.053690724074840546, -0.011515268124639988, -0.02512197569012642, 0.04812276363372803, 0.01435011625289917, -0.04205142334103584, 0.024364622309803963, 0.015439444221556187, -0.029713444411754608, -0.06168980896472931, 0.004027478862553835, -0.04194546118378639, 0.0040296707302331924, -0.006101657636463642, -0.005891290493309498, -0.005487809423357248, -0.056818149983882904, 0.040279097855091095, 0.031065432354807854, 0.04246844723820686, 0.004471237305551767, -0.001217497861944139, 0.04626309871673584, 0.018809733912348747, -0.023861801251769066, 0.04409880191087723, 0.04922516644001007, -0.04077926650643349, 0.00355492252856493, -0.014298820868134499, -0.0011392926098778844, 0.022518133744597435, -0.0696360245347023, -0.0007631595944985747, 0.017071515321731567, 0.002460665535181761, 0.014110960066318512, 0.010714486241340637, -0.0042783888056874275, -0.025143422186374664, -0.030402248725295067, 0.04209913685917854, 0.03578662872314453, -0.001026887446641922, -0.02721010148525238, 0.041590366512537, 0.06431592255830765, -0.01829734444618225, -0.0009544582571834326, -0.011621568351984024, 0.0004755693080369383, -0.0009403684525750577, -0.05382698401808739, -0.044590678066015244, 0.022920919582247734, 0.023089108988642693, 0.010556008666753769, -0.0010719025740399957, -0.04928939789533615, -0.0022354272659868, -0.055528368800878525, -0.013759795576334, -0.008400815539062023, 0.059808604419231415, 0.021946165710687637, 0.05498496815562248, 0.024537596851587296, -0.05660519376397133, 0.040521278977394104, 0.003101710695773363, -0.08573785424232483, 0.0192769356071949, -0.04230610653758049, -0.03157687932252884, -0.008227410726249218, -0.013160422444343567, -0.004614993929862976, 0.003070329548791051, 0.008933808654546738, 0.004215425346046686, 0.03125207498669624, -0.0621744729578495, 0.023194650188088417, 0.00643962062895298, 0.008808442391455173, -0.034884192049503326, 0.0032772135455161333, 0.004610800184309483, 0.02863459289073944, 0.0641583725810051, 0.020852738991379738, 0.001800793339498341, 0.03168847784399986, -0.006158487871289253, -0.009737607091665268, 0.009332328103482723, -0.0187423974275589, -0.010778523050248623, 0.011517923325300217, -0.039216406643390656, 0.022921035066246986, -0.003964515402913094, 0.04610934481024742, 0.020287033170461655, -0.006177216302603483, -0.0001954396429937333, -0.02026243321597576, -0.005309001076966524, 0.034440599381923676, 0.016123581677675247, 0.027171732857823372, 0.007301659323275089, -0.016807878389954567, 0.037959255278110504, -0.06634670495986938, 0.01934213750064373, 0.08732495456933975, 0.004648405127227306, -0.01592300646007061, -0.022305017337203026, -0.005416020285338163, 0.03160371258854866, 0.01216245535761118, -0.02718810737133026, 0.035121869295835495, 0.012292907573282719, 0.003717925865203142, 0.014396092854440212, 0.010701884515583515, -0.05115209147334099, 0.011370539665222168, -0.024398326873779297, 0.000310042523778975, -0.01738058216869831, -0.010644043795764446, 0.016300931572914124, -0.0027816523797810078, 0.05268967151641846, 0.05733319744467735, -0.0018194365547969937, -0.11556504666805267, 0.023631054908037186, 0.044455721974372864, 0.04214875027537346, 0.01407498400658369, -0.01724180206656456, -0.0017985085723921657, -0.01741340011358261, 0.04125402122735977, -0.05309530720114708, 0.028871800750494003, -0.0397966168820858, 0.0000619308339082636, -0.012845760211348534, -0.03279634937644005, -0.020574195310473442, 0.05018407851457596, -0.02377546764910221, 0.030552510172128677, -0.019023800268769264, -0.01295558176934719, -0.020558524876832962, 0.034484732896089554, 0.00712171895429492, 0.0462799072265625, -0.03970591351389885, -0.04722992703318596, -0.007346865721046925, 0.018440285697579384, -0.05692063644528389, -0.053184784948825836, -0.0021775660570710897, 0.02516293153166771, 0.0028625517152249813, 0.02430569939315319, 0.006108719855546951, 0.0017845920519903302, 0.01385605800896883, -0.007024054881185293, 0.007706605829298496, 0.032528750598430634, -0.02162870392203331, 0.05344221368432045, 0.05289405584335327, 0.008633232675492764, 0.027460796758532524, 0.05119714140892029, -0.0026484662666916847, 0.02347099408507347, -0.013064080849289894, 0.05503816157579422, -0.011583923362195492, 0.0440969318151474, -0.009784654714167118, 0.0253679808229208, -0.048331692814826965, 0.039181310683488846, -0.03640130162239075, 0.01886782795190811, 0.011056262068450451, -0.004920789040625095, 0.00015150308900047094, 0.005190501920878887, 0.024005310609936714, -0.039970893412828445, 0.006481761112809181, 0.02085760608315468, -0.02077140286564827, 0.019989734515547752, 0.019881555810570717, -0.04745132476091385, -0.011125457473099232, -0.0010960394283756614, -0.017328990623354912, 0.026924163103103638, -0.04830488935112953, -0.017768999561667442, 0.0098950220271945, -0.011991120874881744, 0.04994913190603256, -0.020472563803195953, 0.010948842391371727, 0.020326649770140648, -0.01999642699956894, -0.02430056221783161, 0.02824869565665722, 0.015367604792118073, 0.0597696527838707, -0.05351576581597328, 0.05738362669944763, -0.016376949846744537, -0.011224248446524143, -0.0868636891245842, -0.039044227451086044, 0.05559515953063965, 0.014693302102386951, -0.017258528620004654, -0.05934644863009453, -0.021800572052598, 0.019115902483463287, -0.01953265257179737, -0.02459808997809887, 0.020759468898177147, 0.005387479439377785, -0.02723752334713936, -0.011990967206656933, 0.02256844751536846, 0.05764496326446533, 0.030215101316571236, -0.00987854041159153, -0.0015898799756541848, 0.037947192788124084, -0.004537395667284727, -0.019427407532930374, -0.007218230050057173, -0.04713454097509384, -0.028980175033211708, -0.04748919606208801, 0.013523544184863567, 0.05198833346366882, -0.02531486563384533, -0.02633126638829708, -0.008134382776916027, -0.0013087496627122164, 0.0045023588463664055, -0.04745467007160187, -0.020441560074687004, -0.02761095203459263, -0.008699794299900532, -0.03967557102441788, 0.01615091972053051, -0.02815363183617592, -0.001618559705093503, -0.010754596441984177, 0.004667825531214476, -0.017024917528033257, 0.002556338906288147, 0.043039701879024506, -0.009691188111901283, -0.006086231209337711, 0.006721951998770237, 0.03818904235959053, 0.037895750254392624, -0.02188827097415924, -0.04285315424203873, 0.04614683985710144, 0.02366151660680771, -0.03172420710325241, 0.007775431964546442, -0.004246595315635204, -0.0007801949395798147, 0.04542037099599838, -0.024710921570658684, 0.06808033585548401, 0.06736115366220474, -0.004477307666093111, -0.009996028617024422, 0.03515290096402168, 0.011545686051249504, 0.0020083009731024504, 0.022876134142279625, 0.05124157294631004, -0.022754494100809097, -0.016065165400505066, 0.045498721301555634, 0.037354860454797745, -0.0025698132812976837, 0.04844557121396065, 0.004984614439308643, 0.011066910810768604, 0.023876570165157318, -0.045429032295942307, -0.015081060118973255, 0.017403336241841316, -0.052503131330013275, -0.008881866000592709, -0.036299895495176315, -0.03900472819805145, 0.011450656689703465, 0.0074111116118729115, -0.028537271544337273, -0.024912498891353607, -0.033480748534202576, -0.051179490983486176, 0.015585195273160934, 0.023486044257879257, -0.014878558926284313, 0.019052622839808464, -0.014375667087733746, 0.04157760366797447, 0.045555755496025085, -0.005841377656906843, -0.0019351908704265952, -0.054860737174749374, -0.010360311716794968, -0.022035464644432068, -0.0782310739159584, 0.02542991004884243, -0.007723725400865078, -0.04445985332131386, 0.009406865574419498, -0.01033742818981409, 0.01598762907087803, 0.033115826547145844, 0.02918468788266182, -0.024955257773399353, 0.06684630364179611, 0.03935432434082031, 0.0318307988345623, -0.009855415672063828, -0.002751522231847048, 0.1140633374452591, 0.0903145894408226, 0.0119762709364295, -0.0063597965054214, -0.0021158731542527676, 0.04954664409160614, 0.01181176956743002, -0.04063820466399193, 0.017176026478409767, 0.04396606236696243, -0.03630702197551727, 0.03408797085285187, 0.04035375267267227, 0.030317872762680054, -0.009231535717844963, 0.04436735063791275, -0.015794066712260246, -0.02371448650956154, 0.0017414867179468274, 0.0015195177402347326, -0.005421911366283894, -0.0056756241247057915, -0.10526302456855774, 0.0057544284500181675, 0.04567639157176018, 0.002553085330873728, -0.03971229866147041, -0.0320810005068779, -0.019850490614771843, -0.001431180164217949, 0.005734845995903015, -0.004577672109007835, 0.01766146533191204, 0.00020458053040783852, 0.0020477962680161, -0.0365711972117424, 0.01968720741569996, 0.004241976886987686, -0.006277879234403372, 0.014909001998603344, 0.03229091316461563, -0.012578236870467663, 0.00019103668455500156, 0.03760845586657524, -0.009703770279884338, -0.033825330436229706, -0.03189007565379143, 0.019732732325792313, -0.009039665572345257, 0.015014268457889557, 0.00661838473752141, -0.011077800765633583, -0.009343324229121208, -0.04893781989812851, -0.07098528742790222, -0.008790725842118263, 0.03864346444606781, -0.011296211741864681, 0.026553595438599586, 0.012483294121921062, 0.02006365917623043, -0.014146284200251102, -0.012118877843022346, 0.001973437611013651, 0.0036809418816119432, -0.0076825120486319065, -0.01488505769520998, 0.017023831605911255, -0.024532780051231384, -0.0062257107347249985, -0.001033720443956554, -0.024707777425646782, -0.018231917172670364, -0.004279386252164841, -0.009388870559632778, -0.00669100321829319, -0.0008044450078159571, 0.009932930581271648, -0.013032566756010056, 0.020361684262752533, 0.04079439118504524, 0.008425388485193253, -0.014327031560242176, -0.019728219136595726, -0.037946753203868866, 0.0020046059507876635, -0.0007489257841371, 0.027927659451961517, -0.013692039065063, 0.04514633119106293, -0.023801978677511215, 0.04446505010128021, 0.006685243919491768, -0.02529708854854107, -0.03941595181822777, 0.0037437945138663054, 0.019164828583598137, 0.02123834937810898, 0.013536794111132622, 0.07592840492725372, 0.012106552720069885, -0.013837282545864582, 0.05281980708241463, 0.03462718054652214, -0.037565477192401886, -0.004382794257253408, -0.0016086985124275088, -0.07251409441232681, -0.04718625172972679, 0.0217132531106472, -0.019521987065672874, -0.04231369122862816, -0.024834327399730682, -0.04270505532622337, -0.001065332442522049, 0.009678700938820839, 0.011280623264610767, -0.045357510447502136, -0.00708784582093358, -0.017692353576421738, -0.00613397778943181, 0.007674325257539749, 0.018806148320436478, -0.03594924136996269, -0.021057309582829475, -0.040570903569459915, -0.0017120849806815386, 0.0026466890703886747, 0.01306556724011898, -0.003968719393014908, 0.007535248063504696, -0.008551905862987041, 0.017358973622322083, 0.014029978774487972, 0.010380102321505547, 0.007136456668376923, 0.0032941182143986225, 0.04261872172355652, -0.010143297724425793, -0.04221737012267113, 0.019785890355706215, -0.0628935694694519, -0.02969684824347496, 0.06138006970286369, -0.028456084430217743, 0.026628820225596428, 0.026673581451177597, 0.04285069927573204, 0.03432140871882439, 0.04249487444758415, -0.016049707308411598, -0.014798030257225037, 0.013033723458647728, -0.019508007913827896, 0.00998165737837553, 0.009600103832781315, -0.007955986075103283, 0.00901063997298479, -0.057757437229156494, -0.03327474743127823, 0.04810908064246178, 0.0220817718654871, -0.008841229602694511, 0.007204073015600443, 0.0059700021520257, -0.0291361752897501, -0.012062683701515198, -0.023488417267799377, 0.022546138614416122, 0.020144665613770485, -0.05766592174768448, 0.030039001256227493, -0.011431114748120308, 0.024757636711001396, -0.04554356634616852, -0.0055366624146699905, 0.022078491747379303, 0.031902238726615906, 0.05933186039328575, -0.02301805280148983, -0.002059164922684431, 0.004228328354656696, -0.05989019572734833, 0.03082982636988163, 0.0020590410567820072, 0.00638588098809123, -0.0289197638630867, 0.020694473758339882, -0.019772015511989594, 0.01899290829896927, 0.029421700164675713, 0.029442116618156433, 0.04102158918976784, 0.04542161524295807, 0.017331508919596672, -0.0417933464050293, -0.01221571397036314, -0.0012322843540459871, 0.009248183108866215, -0.014399157837033272, 0.025153737515211105, -0.05589062720537186, -0.0038137200754135847, 0.07059264928102493, -0.02947435900568962, 0.009103544056415558, 0.010270503349602222, 0.035835087299346924, -0.018456239253282547, 0.052866674959659576, 0.005704890005290508, 0.015003458596765995, 0.022548196837306023, 0.009133443236351013, -0.008353304117918015, -0.01996893808245659, -0.012936098501086235, 0.020644238218665123, 0.0409209206700325, -0.01645706221461296, -0.0396411269903183, 0.024479761719703674, 0.02038945071399212, -0.009924441576004028, -0.00006876285624457523, -0.021376952528953552, 0.0538548082113266, -0.016591200605034828, 0.0034725971054285765, -0.009382447227835655, 0.024983851239085197, 0.017557820305228233, -0.018461979925632477, -0.01614437811076641, 0.0016503670485690236, -0.02655795030295849, -0.020512722432613373, -0.004761068616062403, 0.004922026768326759, -0.008615478873252869, -0.04152362421154976, 0.0003704334085341543, -0.0418965108692646, 0.004339895211160183, 0.012967049144208431, -0.007680211681872606, -0.006940070539712906, 0.03356385976076126, -0.044509951025247574, -0.07754650712013245, 0.06397853046655655, 0.0363437794148922, 0.021449370309710503, -0.12486429512500763, 0.0356852263212204, -0.0013802245957776904, 0.031334489583969116, -0.05682211369276047, 0.0017177668632939458, -0.051757365465164185, 0.04603295028209686, 0.04878712072968483, 0.03652491420507431, -0.028640618547797203, -0.008572462946176529, 0.017070405185222626, 0.023896802216768265, -0.037821222096681595, 0.025400273501873016, -0.013642862439155579, -0.03418220952153206, -0.031855836510658264, -0.028422819450497627, -0.016072073951363564, -0.03315998241305351, 0.012371699325740337, 0.00862337090075016, -0.05542819947004318, -0.02746274508535862, -0.019096508622169495, 0.009716101922094822, 0.019258586689829826, -0.0034740441478788853, 0.004824349191039801, -0.0021120251622051, 0.023828689008951187, 0.02188156731426716, 0.02899753861129284, -0.06283129006624222, 0.023885775357484818, -0.03913542255759239, -0.06872010976076126, 0.024693859741091728, 0.010910267010331154, 0.01316207367926836, -0.06269603222608566, -0.02851862832903862, -0.0133822588250041, -0.020772859454154968, -0.031171435490250587, 0.018847890198230743, 0.02274983562529087, 0.046378523111343384, 0.003205107059329748, 0.02105260081589222, -0.02708989381790161, -0.016701318323612213, -0.008548612706363201, 0.008565779775381088, 0.024981675669550896, -0.0048640030436217785, 0.013961656019091606, -0.0070645771920681, -0.0035949975717812777, 0.023456009104847908, 0.026572149246931076, 0.013132079504430294, 0.001997728832066059, -0.01432862225919962, 0.0312209315598011, -0.01653236895799637, 0.004888354334980249, 0.048874832689762115, -0.0010189975146204233, 0.011516558937728405, -0.017971089109778404, 0.03651411831378937, -0.07065656036138535, -0.00026529139722697437, -0.04133095592260361, 0.010778420604765415, 0.03572666272521019, -0.008022695779800415, -0.03285038843750954, -0.0015867362963035703, -0.000766970100812614, -0.013783627189695835, 0.032616496086120605, -0.046265266835689545, 0.050134774297475815, -0.013629849068820477, -0.003504239721223712, 0.029280997812747955, 0.009574134834110737, -0.03721559792757034, -0.011871096678078175, 0.02954987622797489, 0.015594922937452793, 0.06122595816850662, 0.006249722559005022, -0.02999827452003956, -0.013427399098873138, 0.030201110988855362, -0.023589443415403366, 0.0019811636302620173, -0.045817241072654724, 0.0195611584931612, -0.005857230629771948, -0.011175337247550488 ]
<p>I would be very grateful for some advice on how to model mixture distributions with R.</p> <p>Given a problem to create a ranking of graduate students by their yearly income after completing their education, what are some suited models for this task?</p> <p>Specifically, my data has a distribution with a point mass at 0 (the majority of graduates doesn't find, or start, a full-time job right away). The rest of the data is sort of nicely distributed. The data $x$ was transformed $\log(x+1)$. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/4lUnO.png" alt="histogram"></p> <ul> <li>My first approach was a simple regression model </li> <li>My second approach were two models (one for classifying whether they get a job - is very weak, and second to predict the income) Simply chaining these two models works much worse than the simple model.</li> </ul> <p>My next step would be a Bayesian mixture model to predict income. I was thinking about fitting a mixture with 2 Gaussians, where I would set the mean for one of them to be known as equal to 0. Would that make sense? Has anyone a good experience with some package?</p> <p>Another problem might be that I am always predicting the income using a regression and building a ranking from that, rather than running an ordinal regression. What is the best way handle this situation - if the target variable (income) that the ranking is based on is itself available for training data?</p> <p>Full disclosure: This is a fictitious scenario, as I cannot discuss the exact details of the real case.</p>
74,465
[ -0.023661578074097633, -0.012905733659863472, -0.017991995438933372, -0.007291396614164114, 0.017852498218417168, -0.005540559533983469, -0.022892020642757416, -0.012291638180613518, 0.03575673699378967, -0.04669557139277458, 0.011445370502769947, 0.0432441383600235, 0.052568063139915466, 0.03688471391797066, 0.02411051094532013, -0.008699004538357258, -0.00205931905657053, -0.009874551557004452, -0.013759968802332878, 0.02678825333714485, -0.021301891654729843, 0.04644680395722389, 0.0177704356610775, -0.03161884844303131, -0.025955645367503166, 0.007385447155684233, 0.0009137369925156236, -0.010443730279803276, -0.024401379749178886, 0.03393770381808281, -0.05017632991075516, -0.005496754311025143, -0.0007855738513171673, 0.02919107675552368, 0.0202048160135746, 0.0010138683719560504, -0.039258863776922226, -0.03661733865737915, -0.023293979465961456, 0.015112101100385189, -0.05200740694999695, -0.03602008894085884, 0.000651391688734293, 0.028637563809752464, 0.027075089514255524, -0.013414992950856686, -0.0049743494018912315, -0.03840687870979309, 0.06147328019142151, -0.04244808107614517, 0.05596992373466492, 0.013540848158299923, 0.004520210903137922, 0.03318718075752258, -0.0060118925757706165, -0.01011509820818901, 0.04329930245876312, 0.09948450326919556, -0.008061329834163189, -0.04555218294262886, -0.021469704806804657, -0.022289199754595757, -0.02154580131173134, -0.0013728138292208314, -0.03351451829075813, 0.0057234568521380424, -0.013426726683974266, -0.009284308180212975, 0.04166540130972862, -0.02066163532435894, 0.028697486966848373, 0.036922723054885864, 0.04089569300413132, -0.015118269249796867, 0.06590617448091507, -0.023611903190612793, 0.007271734997630119, 0.027499251067638397, 0.0487494058907032, 0.016714731231331825, -0.007938706316053867, -0.01569540798664093, -0.00012262669042684138, 0.05896985903382301, -0.01822839304804802, -0.008000757545232773, 0.04832535609602928, -0.028628218919038773, 0.03703131899237633, 0.03443174809217453, -0.02210678718984127, 0.004368700552731752, 0.03449956327676773, 0.009555580094456673, -0.014907949604094028, 0.0472414530813694, -0.030724119395017624, 0.02077026665210724, -0.0038428357802331448, 0.010585485026240349, 0.006888143252581358, -0.020757878199219704, 0.006164321675896645, 0.06999935209751129, -0.01806717924773693, -0.02200254425406456, -0.011563834734261036, -0.028294192627072334, -0.01752864569425583, -0.06287971884012222, -0.04330185428261757, 0.0432538203895092, 0.002818560693413019, 0.02823341265320778, 0.016939576715230942, -0.03441597893834114, 0.029625870287418365, -0.03619988635182381, 0.03545156493782997, 0.06737886369228363, 0.049034327268600464, -0.043942712247371674, 0.04255497828125954, -0.05657544732093811, -0.05304079130291939, -0.009374716319143772, 0.016962671652436256, -0.043194789439439774, -0.055270493030548096, 0.03880806267261505, -0.022016989067196846, -0.0076381973922252655, 0.08264138549566269, -0.0017894785851240158, 0.027995456010103226, 0.0008139043929986656, -0.0819505900144577, -0.04126417636871338, 0.010804166086018085, 0.006974988617002964, 0.03325343877077103, -0.061822593212127686, -0.042556118220090866, 0.00763568514958024, 0.011347267776727676, -0.007588747888803482, 0.020063603296875954, 0.0032249432988464832, 0.06971145421266556, -0.01588566042482853, -0.006430044770240784, -0.017957577481865883, -0.015032037161290646, -0.014233614318072796, 0.007692346349358559, -0.07559870183467865, 0.015307213179767132, 0.02694656327366829, -0.03644207864999771, -0.00030941629665903747, 0.06970935314893723, 0.03868735954165459, -0.003994247876107693, -0.02829330414533615, 0.028627431020140648, -0.005070977378636599, 0.0768832340836525, 0.017939738929271698, 0.07513292878866196, -0.014303663745522499, 0.01045290008187294, 0.005328996106982231, 0.02285340055823326, 0.050279345363378525, 0.03527354076504707, -0.011935022659599781, 0.009243940934538841, -0.041241198778152466, 0.008242661133408546, 0.0013732119696214795, -0.003184575354680419, -0.01988823525607586, -0.018470892682671547, -0.06306421011686325, 0.011774432845413685, 0.005962245631963015, 0.0245432760566473, -0.020807906985282898, 0.0510401576757431, -0.04674585536122322, -0.036395348608493805, -0.06776361912488937, 0.01655506156384945, 0.007972940802574158, -0.009731837548315525, 0.027186235412955284, 0.0005116621614433825, 0.022336633875966072, -0.043282896280288696, -0.000929584784898907, -0.013619017787277699, -0.031027808785438538, 0.020601259544491768, -0.007662195712327957, 0.0018486896296963096, 0.06252293288707733, 0.05928007513284683, -0.026764195412397385, 0.03195422515273094, -0.06028088927268982, -0.0461186058819294, 0.0006990086985751987, 0.004294844809919596, 0.0353950560092926, -0.05221252888441086, 0.0016314333770424128, 0.011757607571780682, -0.007660635281354189, -0.038539089262485504, 0.04179904982447624, -0.06489230692386627, 0.07269520312547684, 0.10145704448223114, 0.0007368078804574907, 0.0036487081088125706, -0.003183264285326004, 0.00426348065957427, 0.03024076297879219, -0.03827613592147827, 0.0021909417118877172, -0.037737417966127396, -0.020450178533792496, 0.023868702352046967, 0.018769148737192154, -0.018964404240250587, 0.05082053691148758, 0.04357912018895149, 0.02430717647075653, 0.024690337479114532, 0.007481471635401249, -0.026519719511270523, -0.006349654868245125, 0.023830626159906387, 0.020047634840011597, 0.012440633028745651, -0.011191138066351414, 0.022914154455065727, -0.0013506466057151556, 0.046997979283332825, -0.009377118200063705, 0.015573003329336643, 0.047463417053222656, 0.009037505835294724, 0.0064491271041333675, -0.029898012056946754, -0.011471891775727272, 0.04820019751787186, -0.058503393083810806, -0.011295503936707973, 0.03655004873871803, -0.002266390947625041, -0.027436040341854095, 0.03819509595632553, -0.04188387095928192, -0.004882981535047293, 0.05272282287478447, -0.05609118193387985, 0.04385331645607948, 0.027454739436507225, -0.04036931321024895, 0.006153217051178217, -0.0007531454903073609, -0.052317358553409576, -0.06676847487688065, 0.039175037294626236, 0.03177495673298836, 0.00482122041285038, 0.007935273461043835, -0.03278256207704544, -0.04268953204154968, 0.05841536819934845, 0.009163160808384418, 0.05431489646434784, 0.004641400184482336, -0.035907674580812454, 0.03571956232190132, -0.01575889252126217, -0.027285803109407425, 0.02620149590075016, 0.009596666321158409, -0.019017864018678665, -0.0005972418584860861, -0.006569343153387308, -0.010893589816987514, -0.04371831566095352, -0.005515884142369032, -0.02490159310400486, -0.037992388010025024, -0.003409260418266058, 0.019260620698332787, -0.00947767123579979, -0.007813130505383015, 0.013913888484239578, -0.03550196811556816, -0.03064459189772606, -0.01790720783174038, 0.00958666205406189, 0.007006975822150707, 0.05299828201532364, 0.016829708591103554, 0.03557734563946724, 0.032717522233724594, -0.022956691682338715, -0.08815933763980865, -0.04387037828564644, 0.040533583611249924, -0.015052620321512222, 0.03725461661815643, 0.024201886728405952, 0.004017258994281292, 0.0604991652071476, 0.030030574649572372, -0.014743220061063766, -0.03324957937002182, -0.02050301432609558, 0.00003765614019357599, 0.01394219696521759, 0.004050921648740768, 0.015329611487686634, 0.001885628211311996, 0.009612716734409332, -0.010028327815234661, 0.003740747692063451, 0.046448398381471634, -0.022725997492671013, 0.006143059581518173, 0.021804777905344963, -0.018996017053723335, -0.020066455006599426, 0.01108455378562212, 0.016152136027812958, -0.009108051657676697, 0.03795980289578438, -0.012409650720655918, -0.0027060946449637413, -0.012462502345442772, -0.030430829152464867, -0.007414459716528654, 0.000023448546926374547, -0.0002793908934108913, -0.041993796825408936, 0.01099434494972229, 0.019184734672307968, -0.05830084905028343, 0.010672004893422127, -0.008521528914570808, 0.010681853629648685, -0.019927529618144035, 0.03675897791981697, 0.046818479895591736, 0.01947847753763199, -0.009207308292388916, 0.011085174046456814, -0.03788740932941437, -0.024160394445061684, 0.011376413516700268, -0.04182438179850578, -0.006464293226599693, 0.02703395113348961, 0.030886122956871986, 0.006521225441247225, -0.004028939642012119, -0.04764693230390549, 0.02182484231889248, -0.057815708220005035, 0.029776137322187424, -0.01381094940006733, 0.07255137711763382, -0.004178890027105808, 0.002946586348116398, -0.013648588210344315, 0.02302723377943039, 0.009552069939672947, 0.033180464059114456, -0.04873098060488701, 0.014554773457348347, -0.03282219171524048, 0.02768518403172493, 0.004895410500466824, 0.010010183788836002, 0.03526359051465988, -0.025983044877648354, 0.012044891715049744, -0.034094639122486115, 0.039370715618133545, -0.013855873607099056, -0.01101007778197527, -0.05223811790347099, -0.0358615405857563, 0.0035962406545877457, -0.04163925349712372, -0.0016642056871205568, -0.0034384906757622957, 0.04984886944293976, 0.04273447021842003, -0.01910601556301117, -0.019104892387986183, -0.021869037300348282, 0.02457304485142231, -0.011993758380413055, 0.03612682968378067, 0.018984157592058182, 0.011421323753893375, -0.04889022931456566, 0.05140846222639084, -0.028089230880141258, 0.0437161810696125, 0.034281063824892044, -0.04251454770565033, 0.005447463598102331, -0.016247225925326347, -0.052948348224163055, -0.00015428834012709558, 0.00024894511443562806, -0.005677274893969297, -0.025899391621351242, 0.03599357604980469, 0.02838972397148609, -0.05581453815102577, 0.011145283468067646, 0.09056162089109421, 0.044466450810432434, 0.012780102901160717, 0.01907983608543873, -0.006736813113093376, -0.011789917014539242, -0.007082372438162565, 0.025072652846574783, 0.016294581815600395, 0.0070003848522901535, 0.004645856563001871, -0.0017414474859833717, 0.0007400688482448459, 0.007959244772791862, -0.01942247524857521, 0.02662372961640358, 0.07699162513017654, 0.007736057974398136, -0.040613941848278046, -0.014270084910094738, 0.07090882956981659, 0.02417164482176304, -0.01001575868576765, 0.027166251093149185, -0.0978948101401329, -0.0050385454669594765, 0.036352887749671936, 0.046713490039110184, -0.03709188103675842, -0.010114564560353756, -0.06837685406208038, -0.009136290289461613, 0.03739636391401291, -0.0442308709025383, 0.0363638810813427, -0.002175515051931143, 0.004127027466893196, -0.00481787184253335, -0.020096587017178535, -0.04870932549238205, 0.028672397136688232, -0.023108549416065216, 0.030423974618315697, 0.01003314834088087, -0.02208113484084606, -0.041877102106809616, 0.03350571170449257, 0.015336433425545692, 0.024851972237229347, -0.025575822219252586, -0.0317888967692852, 0.0174113716930151, 0.0022293629590421915, 0.0052155498415231705, -0.04823891445994377, 0.012216520495712757, 0.0022805642802268267, -0.003939454443752766, 0.039840299636125565, -0.016669725999236107, -0.06752088665962219, 0.019033171236515045, 0.015465975739061832, -0.04024520516395569, -0.012857439927756786, 0.006592949852347374, 0.022570161148905754, 0.021922627463936806, -0.008322731591761112, 0.03876433148980141, 0.051773469895124435, 0.015499185770750046, 0.010812517255544662, -0.03811894729733467, 0.02085837721824646, -0.020198741927742958, -0.03835194930434227, -0.0434873066842556, -0.030522998422384262, -0.03035803884267807, -0.005289827473461628, -0.013801894150674343, 0.06498241424560547, -0.02317081391811371, -0.008716324344277382, 0.02160101942718029, 0.01612291857600212, -0.008393456228077412, 0.0002454748610034585, 0.001869991305284202, 0.005328928120434284, -0.010083816945552826, 0.0027343423571437597, 0.026450401172041893, 0.019357185810804367, 0.00930385198444128, -0.002900589955970645, -0.04945654422044754, 0.045820873230695724, -0.041486237198114395, -0.01104308944195509, 0.004879045765846968, -0.025396890938282013, 0.0288828257471323, 0.004982331767678261, 0.03500016778707504, 0.02825777418911457, -0.03187503293156624, -0.016796741634607315, -0.0038923609536141157, 0.03269331529736519, -0.0049712746404111385, -0.03258109837770462, 0.021154094487428665, 0.004973463714122772, -0.0032272846437990665, -0.04790966585278511, -0.039371050894260406, -0.006639967206865549, 0.0042058429680764675, 0.004583755042403936, -0.056445810943841934, 0.04160558059811592, 0.007757760118693113, -0.006265576463192701, -0.002874873811379075, 0.05628223344683647, -0.02965390495955944, -0.02488444373011589, -0.021046487614512444, 0.021148448809981346, 0.055877458304166794, 0.003972216509282589, -0.031977102160453796, 0.031225016340613365, -0.0012438908452168107, -0.005862078629434109, 0.02599477581679821, 0.046155136078596115, -0.04160197079181671, -0.018897878006100655, -0.023798277601599693, 0.008210662752389908, 0.07630472630262375, 0.004756230860948563, -0.01799619011580944, 0.007996934466063976, 0.007663871627300978, 0.03234174847602844, -0.011464908719062805, 0.01172239612787962, -0.012388300150632858, -0.02401617355644703, -0.04004652053117752, 0.02382594533264637, -0.000545161310583353, -0.031059466302394867, 0.03336323797702789, -0.0010513196466490626, -0.0045151193626224995, 0.00025308883050456643, 0.05154160037636757, 0.012739215046167374, 0.013201032765209675, 0.008622793480753899, -0.02861863002181053, 0.02707280032336712, 0.0210733525454998, -0.008061280474066734, 0.014489704743027687, 0.006282865535467863, -0.05342143401503563, -0.05983529984951019, -0.05171176791191101, -0.04847470298409462, 0.035572975873947144, -0.010569330304861069, 0.0550236850976944, 0.04401377961039543, -0.016893109306693077, 0.016598809510469437, -0.01676030270755291, -0.03515538573265076, -0.043131306767463684, -0.0034962238278239965, 0.053655657917261124, 0.002746686339378357, -0.003780545201152563, 0.03122032806277275, 0.013980299234390259, 0.021780550479888916, 0.03878406807780266, 0.03778347373008728, 0.008062712848186493, 0.04126845300197601, -0.0371236726641655, -0.038085758686065674, 0.0576302669942379, -0.029104802757501602, 0.03258098289370537, -0.04454565420746803, -0.07794415205717087, 0.037349309772253036, 0.03541162237524986, 0.029153946787118912, -0.05025629326701164, -0.012404894456267357, -0.06371715664863586, 0.018970215693116188, 0.04272601753473282, -0.044510457664728165, 0.05115238204598427, -0.001758632599376142, 0.025713752955198288, 0.020415781065821648, 0.03454679623246193, -0.03852171450853348, -0.08043923228979111, 0.003477185731753707, -0.018772734329104424, -0.0565810427069664, 0.01735236868262291, -0.015080251730978489, 0.012408294714987278, 0.05126345902681351, -0.01220875047147274, 0.006521033588796854, -0.011293615214526653, 0.02514152228832245, 0.01685643382370472, 0.08484519273042679, 0.012472345493733883, 0.00410817563533783, 0.01473518181592226, -0.01168043166399002, 0.14061439037322998, 0.07201597839593887, 0.07364656776189804, -0.03425081819295883, 0.013552053831517696, 0.009779548272490501, 0.013014177791774273, -0.031271230429410934, 0.006680635269731283, -0.0009024696773849428, -0.014453211799263954, 0.033403586596250534, 0.051209840923547745, 0.018179520964622498, 0.024334190413355827, 0.03472278639674187, -0.04328382760286331, -0.01196686178445816, 0.003351232036948204, -0.008083083666861057, -0.0005090344347991049, -0.011769414879381657, -0.03056529350578785, 0.04949852079153061, -0.007173158694058657, 0.0012821056880056858, -0.01641726680099964, -0.03914301097393036, 0.014395619742572308, -0.007530864793807268, -0.028658589348196983, -0.013942962512373924, 0.008895128965377808, 0.001618474954739213, 0.02317098155617714, 0.010747420601546764, 0.0026349001564085484, -0.036616213619709015, 0.004907138179987669, 0.03028729185461998, -0.011860804632306099, 0.016166487708687782, 0.02926711179316044, -0.02089451253414154, -0.05285625904798508, -0.02340501919388771, -0.0329589769244194, 0.009351542219519615, -0.027095695957541466, -0.01017061248421669, -0.04200134798884392, 0.00027270623832009733, 0.0033302369993180037, -0.045875441282987595, -0.03739316761493683, 0.019424207508563995, 0.04964674636721611, -0.02857157774269581, -0.0013594122137874365, 0.00031332223443314433, 0.015173115767538548, 0.0017976189265027642, 0.03531915321946144, 0.015226421877741814, -0.04033923149108887, -0.0362737700343132, -0.0354715958237648, 0.05211648344993591, 0.023015523329377174, 0.005579217802733183, -0.004716599825769663, -0.04171634092926979, -0.04133550077676773, -0.015169191174209118, 0.016947884112596512, -0.013824139721691608, 0.037204403430223465, -0.0352572463452816, -0.0055169472470879555, -0.03649706393480301, -0.012997607700526714, -0.009093435481190681, -0.011207460425794125, 0.033103957772254944, -0.03417416661977768, -0.00925393309444189, 0.006106679793447256, 0.012144636362791061, 0.03752082586288452, 0.016565389931201935, 0.004546403884887695, 0.029363730922341347, 0.016766726970672607, -0.044966842979192734, 0.009937210939824581, -0.013518652878701687, -0.05855097621679306, 0.012207292951643467, -0.009676696732640266, 0.050759848207235336, 0.0020340965129435062, 0.020984023809432983, -0.020706497132778168, 0.019764717668294907, -0.016176756471395493, 0.0557507686316967, -0.0002527920587453991, -0.051494989544153214, 0.011199153028428555, 0.007867866195738316, -0.000751752348151058, -0.011707882396876812, -0.021610047668218613, -0.017403997480869293, -0.020638566464185715, 0.014084781520068645, -0.026547186076641083, -0.009796488098800182, 0.021036066114902496, -0.008202599361538887, 0.006741066463291645, -0.028966780751943588, 0.014971975237131119, -0.014058291912078857, 0.012182800099253654, -0.016433456912636757, 0.004136111121624708, 0.002736646682024002, 0.009963980875909328, 0.01218913309276104, 0.005812472198158503, 0.02018871158361435, -0.02397967129945755, 0.01798900216817856, -0.0006448617787100375, 0.019347157329320908, -0.021229369565844536, 0.04407628998160362, -0.014474076218903065, -0.009045111946761608, 0.03813139721751213, 0.0033319739159196615, -0.040884751826524734, -0.0030496602412313223, -0.008342559449374676, 0.04854768514633179, -0.022135760635137558, -0.02777719683945179, -0.05331802740693092, 0.030533965677022934, -0.027397336438298225, -0.006984901614487171, -0.030575888231396675, 0.000338202400598675, 0.010759097523987293, -0.0046717338263988495, -0.018121691420674324, 0.007901513017714024, -0.020900418981909752, 0.011252768337726593, 0.044301487505435944, 0.021382130682468414, -0.0009232366573996842, 0.000051688555686268955, -0.010463579557836056, 0.000535756757017225, 0.007729205768555403, 0.017945723608136177, 0.05705300346016884, 0.04534180462360382, -0.033290795981884, 0.06391190737485886, -0.02137947455048561, 0.03145250305533409, -0.08918832242488861, -0.052842140197753906, 0.036210477352142334, -0.005443674977868795, 0.022651182487607002, -0.06268609315156937, -0.012837272137403488, 0.0391707643866539, -0.03604025021195412, 0.031629450619220734, 0.007298989221453667, 0.013495033606886864, -0.00939533207565546, 0.011974337510764599, -0.03693123534321785, -0.00545344827696681, -0.00070322270039469, 0.04494665935635567, 0.04008468985557556, 0.027019498869776726, 0.009317401796579361, -0.00008964039443526417, -0.03317581117153168, 0.0224860031157732, -0.005604182835668325, -0.06369172781705856, 0.03748207166790962, -0.04573899134993553, -0.01038001012057066, 0.04216916859149933, 0.021029774099588394, 0.01800546422600746, 0.04247079789638519, 0.030059153214097023, 0.012511875480413437, 0.0615096241235733, 0.03907153755426407, 0.01110375951975584, -0.02137005515396595, 0.028220893815159798, 0.023932229727506638, 0.026272574439644814, -0.05225316062569618, 0.008599596098065376, 0.012820293195545673, -0.02437073178589344, -0.005829673260450363, 0.010009831748902798, -0.027719413861632347, 0.018878277391195297, 0.007164702285081148, -0.00490441732108593, -0.019045624881982803, -0.010029088705778122, 0.0271171685308218, -0.06755127757787704, -0.0240195132791996, 0.01418113149702549, 0.01856771670281887, 0.007966560311615467, 0.036063916981220245, -0.01578487642109394, -0.035898417234420776, -0.009144873358309269, -0.0094616012647748, -0.023580890148878098, -0.016570091247558594, 0.0010275522945448756, 0.00398431858047843, -0.00814148597419262, -0.015819231048226357, -0.018791668117046356, -0.03264981880784035, 0.046037472784519196, -0.056407444179058075, 0.031078901141881943, 0.039361968636512756, -0.004782801494002342, 0.00014637087588198483, -0.09262420982122421, 0.09005796164274216, 0.035395748913288116, -0.012305080890655518, -0.0029098426457494497, -0.015940343961119652, -0.020024647936224937, -0.00995612796396017, 0.07330621033906937, 0.007884800434112549, 0.008750967681407928, -0.005940708797425032, 0.0015999411698430777, 0.025412268936634064, -0.04692000150680542, 0.02540922723710537, 0.01977081410586834, -0.04280966520309448, -0.042367491871118546, 0.0006798136746510863, -0.013756697066128254, -0.00039511825889348984, 0.004442413803189993, 0.0022367516066879034, 0.009020193479955196, 0.028367623686790466, 0.007083701901137829, 0.02904525399208069, 0.010432039387524128, 0.0023861555382609367, 0.04346473887562752, 0.007170558907091618, 0.010124941356480122, 0.01655217632651329, 0.003912013024091721, -0.07100445032119751, 0.026594754308462143, -0.028571216389536858, -0.04530272260308266, -0.02799222432076931, 0.016278671100735664, -0.04086252674460411, -0.06265512853860855, -0.0069519211538136005, 0.014895407482981682, -0.004459043964743614, 0.011659621261060238, 0.02803218364715576, -0.01964169554412365, 0.04706091061234474, 0.0048957024700939655, 0.013154130429029465, 0.011093583889305592, -0.019953623414039612, 0.01010931096971035, -0.00571676529943943, 0.026907775551080704, -0.002305042464286089, 0.01629389449954033, 0.04745917022228241, -0.023068971931934357, 0.018776768818497658, 0.0021166871301829815, 0.023294812068343163, -0.02654394321143627, -0.047769784927368164, 0.019123591482639313, -0.013920623809099197, -0.019772330299019814, -0.007601640652865171, -0.017067663371562958, 0.03137674927711487, 0.003686320735141635, 0.019690273329615593, -0.027007319033145905, -0.03698601573705673, -0.033899158239364624, -0.010332666337490082, -0.024584908038377762, 0.005524700973182917, -0.007142737042158842, 0.015627127140760422, 0.008695157244801521, -0.021487301215529442, 0.020164456218481064, 0.0030276624020189047, 0.008647654205560684, 0.009700704365968704, -0.019159216433763504, 0.015561079606413841, -0.029556255787611008, 0.006396619137376547, -0.049217067658901215, 0.01979953981935978, 0.025827959179878235, 0.03436390310525894, -0.03518465906381607, -0.017117815092206, 0.009262572973966599, 0.0686839297413826, -0.05881213769316673, -0.001176789402961731, -0.054242417216300964, -0.022849084809422493, -0.010479421354830265, -0.05886077508330345 ]
<p>Based on estimated classification accuracy, I want to test whether one classifier is statistically better on a base set than another classifier . For each classifier, I select a training and testing sample randomly from the base set, train the model, and test the model. I do this ten times for each classifier. I therefore have ten estimate classification accuracy measurements for each classifier. How do I statistically test whether the $classifier 1$ is a better classifier than the $classifier 2$ on the base dataset. What t-test is appropriate to use? </p>
37,346
[ -0.01761927269399166, -0.025486808270215988, -0.040076784789562225, 0.029072171077132225, 0.005565893370658159, 0.004818094428628683, 0.0018680059583857656, 0.013730178587138653, 0.03634649142622948, -0.006024698726832867, 0.06131917983293533, 0.0487636961042881, 0.057780761271715164, 0.022419894114136696, 0.0011535135563462973, 0.0000772065541241318, -0.060051146894693375, -0.004133529495447874, 0.011840387247502804, -0.008698619902133942, 0.01563115604221821, 0.001302489428780973, 0.014175950549542904, 0.009947908110916615, -0.02929036132991314, 0.031134625896811485, 0.02302653156220913, -0.0032892709132283926, 0.005209125112742186, 0.03322016820311546, -0.026145881041884422, -0.029954560101032257, 0.011441279202699661, 0.05336315929889679, 0.004509390331804752, -0.027034055441617966, -0.02261384204030037, -0.015181688591837883, -0.03909200802445412, 0.030566923320293427, -0.02224017307162285, -0.050920091569423676, 0.008146215230226517, 0.04031277447938919, -0.004022830631583929, -0.005180831532925367, -0.02462136559188366, -0.009000399149954319, 0.021862121298909187, -0.05492481589317322, 0.06290128827095032, 0.014797459356486797, 0.038455333560705185, 0.038957566022872925, -0.0008933384669944644, -0.02703535556793213, 0.02146097831428051, 0.0797262042760849, -0.018384767696261406, -0.030056145042181015, -0.022930564358830452, -0.0562160350382328, 0.009428869932889938, -0.011735940352082253, -0.049661800265312195, 0.04774520918726921, -0.0010810168460011482, 0.0016751710791140795, -0.007727543357759714, -0.025633756071329117, -0.006939908489584923, 0.008654450066387653, 0.02272755093872547, -0.024196846410632133, 0.011411872692406178, -0.030408797785639763, 0.009409694001078606, 0.07432860881090164, 0.054142605513334274, 0.028699442744255066, 0.019332323223352432, 0.012950779870152473, 0.008441084064543247, 0.07335806638002396, 0.02860230952501297, -0.009436966851353645, 0.06663519144058228, 0.024403465911746025, 0.0026310209650546312, 0.015069333836436272, -0.010007256641983986, -0.01317032240331173, 0.06115306168794632, 0.008005077950656414, -0.03354473039507866, 0.023805730044841766, -0.017343856394290924, 0.031030837446451187, 0.014352791011333466, -0.013944395817816257, 0.02773808315396309, -0.05476338416337967, 0.021271925419569016, 0.056118421256542206, -0.023843415081501007, -0.009617217816412449, -0.03707636520266533, -0.023893343284726143, -0.034622494131326675, 0.013933073729276657, -0.013272748328745365, 0.05323223024606705, -0.010248308070003986, 0.005378242582082748, 0.021557331085205078, -0.007780174259096384, -0.008492529392242432, -0.03308158367872238, 0.02122013084590435, 0.03673695772886276, 0.06642904877662659, -0.041592374444007874, 0.012918797321617603, -0.01803066022694111, -0.023462921380996704, 0.01760481856763363, -0.003354648593813181, -0.03335845097899437, -0.03859077766537666, 0.05568942055106163, -0.02554764784872532, -0.033178187906742096, 0.034081507474184036, -0.014886761084198952, 0.009351696819067001, 0.00481760548427701, -0.07340152561664581, -0.060625672340393066, 0.02505239099264145, -0.02069769985973835, 0.03801898658275604, -0.059502068907022476, -0.0033762906678020954, 0.036791738122701645, 0.02553459256887436, 0.027856288477778435, 0.03523138165473938, 0.03141571953892708, 0.014514613896608353, -0.0212801955640316, -0.01938898302614689, -0.02767139859497547, -0.04374007508158684, 0.00001095842890208587, -0.05602708458900452, -0.07640740275382996, -0.023512039333581924, 0.0024622827768325806, -0.053286824375391006, -0.0063827452249825, 0.014597257599234581, 0.010753724724054337, 0.0069141690619289875, -0.014790630899369717, 0.037183091044425964, -0.0012764167040586472, 0.04266022890806198, 0.015830112621188164, 0.03488403186202049, 0.0029042402748018503, -0.017945410683751106, 0.006572409067302942, 0.032417021691799164, 0.03155216947197914, 0.056572362780570984, -0.021661462262272835, -0.020076293498277664, -0.038219548761844635, 0.02587241865694523, 0.007914656773209572, -0.00931000616401434, -0.04168308153748512, -0.03881043568253517, -0.005942026153206825, -0.012443172745406628, 0.03184036910533905, -0.019427364692091942, -0.0165917556732893, 0.0418897308409214, -0.03819159045815468, -0.06058439239859581, -0.06281103193759918, 0.012420537881553173, 0.006061607506126165, -0.026997510343790054, 0.025426406413316727, 0.008186385966837406, 0.04652545601129532, 0.01285638939589262, 0.008715484291315079, -0.04870068281888962, -0.010916648432612419, 0.03243766725063324, -0.01821736991405487, 0.012951903976500034, 0.054183658212423325, 0.062490083277225494, -0.024453971534967422, 0.05591588839888573, -0.026100918650627136, -0.044994231313467026, 0.012463591061532497, -0.026817258447408676, 0.009190713055431843, 0.0003598595503717661, -0.05380425974726677, 0.03655342012643814, -0.0032842964865267277, -0.01980249397456646, 0.03322593867778778, -0.0335448756814003, 0.08619192987680435, 0.031028104946017265, 0.016713764518499374, -0.0005588168860413134, -0.027714747935533524, -0.018298491835594177, 0.026757916435599327, -0.022082002833485603, 0.005945893470197916, -0.0513477586209774, -0.019045405089855194, 0.04233277216553688, 0.019069835543632507, -0.03151888772845268, 0.026498183608055115, 0.05569718778133392, -0.0019109711283817887, -0.002504501258954406, 0.023586181923747063, -0.006436861585825682, -0.037637993693351746, 0.012591453269124031, 0.04108966141939163, 0.00762360030785203, -0.013440186157822609, 0.06722116470336914, 0.003794161370024085, 0.03074773959815502, 0.03800523653626442, 0.0034595655743032694, 0.03210458531975746, 0.002650009235367179, 0.002289630938321352, -0.0046715689823031425, -0.05923818424344063, 0.013565484434366226, -0.014723310247063637, -0.011642052792012691, 0.030256344005465508, -0.009415405802428722, -0.0017370779532939196, 0.015941977500915527, -0.009457992389798164, 0.07159880548715591, 0.030414355918765068, -0.022096317261457443, -0.008706668391823769, 0.032563745975494385, -0.046967003494501114, 0.01635568216443062, 0.00673174811527133, -0.02324424870312214, -0.035111479461193085, 0.03713654726743698, 0.02918146923184395, -0.024694139137864113, 0.03608052805066109, -0.007043648976832628, -0.0038028815761208534, 0.006253414321690798, -0.03573741763830185, 0.04183846339583397, -0.015905875712633133, -0.05766702815890312, -0.013746754266321659, -0.03033697046339512, -0.04000985249876976, 0.02830382250249386, 0.01723545230925083, -0.04666811600327492, 0.022400053218007088, 0.016461091116070747, -0.02840333990752697, -0.013503885827958584, -0.036507558077573776, 0.026069525629281998, -0.011898419819772243, -0.026710892096161842, 0.009960068389773369, 0.000516250729560852, -0.03911764174699783, 0.04531083628535271, -0.03888821601867676, -0.014363131485879421, 0.005702279973775148, -0.009773843921720982, 0.0026985500007867813, -0.032418686896562576, 0.014852706342935562, 0.03359363228082657, -0.013337408192455769, -0.02687547542154789, -0.05716560408473015, -0.07018906623125076, 0.046673085540533066, -0.00838418398052454, 0.03518935292959213, 0.005635153967887163, -0.01702231913805008, 0.07850402593612671, 0.03836199641227722, -0.016914745792746544, -0.011411844752728939, 0.006124760489910841, -0.022279435768723488, -0.017563512548804283, 0.0006645758985541761, -0.003279461758211255, 0.01592370681464672, 0.003942269366234541, -0.003886318998411298, 0.00912751816213131, 0.07951091229915619, -0.034027229994535446, -0.009594344533979893, 0.014691009186208248, 0.039998266845941544, -0.0169659536331892, 0.020002594217658043, 0.00027045709430240095, -0.03137946501374245, 0.026660578325390816, 0.007088633254170418, 0.005050129257142544, 0.009412712417542934, -0.028921468183398247, 0.02955329231917858, -0.021461637690663338, -0.006616423837840557, -0.020330185070633888, 0.019891561940312386, 0.021969862282276154, -0.022835632786154747, 0.003813218791037798, 0.06238018721342087, 0.016623394563794136, -0.031087927520275116, -0.0009681456140242517, 0.036727678030729294, 0.035863086581230164, 0.0026193123776465654, -0.016715383157134056, -0.03537002578377724, -0.03833432123064995, 0.03837335854768753, -0.005647473037242889, -0.011202673427760601, 0.031100215390324593, 0.04347376152873039, 0.027600707486271858, 0.01691287010908127, -0.04988573119044304, 0.03865765780210495, -0.048396602272987366, 0.006179467309266329, -0.012289734557271004, 0.06432867795228958, 0.013018481433391571, 0.002489279955625534, 0.012183940038084984, -0.016481148079037666, 0.04578308016061783, 0.0075448439456522465, -0.03130608797073364, 0.05195282772183418, -0.008676933124661446, -0.03234133496880531, 0.01856733113527298, -0.014250384643673897, 0.030324408784508705, -0.02259700559079647, 0.0288092028349638, -0.024970578029751778, 0.03172919154167175, -0.042041316628456116, 0.019758624956011772, -0.02605516090989113, -0.004983536899089813, 0.012822831980884075, 0.052528176456689835, -0.011686652898788452, -0.017829595133662224, 0.03184153139591217, 0.017997225746512413, 0.006018320098519325, 0.0014326799428090453, -0.007548847235739231, 0.0009219786734320223, -0.016403352841734886, 0.03598877042531967, 0.05021226033568382, 0.04906840994954109, -0.04846792668104172, 0.041459448635578156, -0.03778565675020218, 0.06248301640152931, 0.035357844084501266, -0.005150102078914642, -0.017600785940885544, -0.04396311938762665, -0.013386652804911137, -0.0004223063588142395, 0.045877210795879364, -0.005895507521927357, -0.04400850459933281, 0.049661360681056976, 0.03154197335243225, -0.04352589324116707, 0.009775673970580101, 0.06945221871137619, -0.007401672657579184, -0.0007802305044606328, -0.0291864275932312, -0.007881290279328823, -0.0083015076816082, -0.022813590243458748, 0.03891972079873085, 0.026190562173724174, -0.011497371830046177, -0.007918307557702065, 0.04023352265357971, -0.03512299805879593, -0.049741387367248535, -0.0028601072262972593, 0.026430204510688782, 0.034874312579631805, 0.024778911843895912, -0.03932780399918556, -0.02375059761106968, 0.03336910903453827, 0.04535014554858208, 0.013695224188268185, 0.027987806126475334, -0.10266970843076706, 0.00926212314516306, 0.0679970234632492, 0.013531185686588287, -0.05952087789773941, -0.03576992079615593, -0.031021608039736748, -0.0014784130034968257, 0.0319315604865551, -0.015834691002964973, 0.023391949012875557, 0.003298654919490218, 0.00038339823368005455, -0.05518617853522301, 0.029757898300886154, -0.04633640497922897, -0.004012709949165583, -0.02195749618113041, 0.035416845232248306, -0.019715916365385056, -0.013184528797864914, -0.021073007956147194, -0.010517527349293232, 0.024701688438653946, 0.06541111320257187, -0.024774163961410522, -0.008590360172092915, -0.0020098481327295303, -0.0017936259973794222, 0.004006995353847742, -0.023485936224460602, 0.0014733177376911044, -0.006544481962919235, -0.0226840078830719, 0.010948890820145607, -0.010948950424790382, -0.01816493272781372, 0.02498193271458149, -0.023195143789052963, -0.06013912335038185, -0.026021862402558327, 0.0011349220294505358, 0.015005996450781822, 0.048689402639865875, 0.012330769561231136, 0.04529396817088127, 0.017935719341039658, 0.04524925723671913, 0.019723260775208473, -0.012494017370045185, 0.027319755405187607, -0.058608949184417725, -0.0329960435628891, -0.00431085517629981, -0.010086582973599434, -0.044694267213344574, 0.05046708509325981, -0.0096935098990798, 0.040375545620918274, -0.022579515352845192, -0.014713682234287262, -0.00235216086730361, 0.04056836664676666, -0.014178217388689518, 0.006666648667305708, -0.003016286063939333, 0.02373133786022663, -0.021296678110957146, 0.022887716069817543, 0.014290759339928627, -0.00665419502183795, -0.003138635540381074, 0.0016231817426159978, -0.04748321697115898, 0.06592120230197906, -0.030783476307988167, -0.0147588811814785, -0.00367985712364316, -0.014690600335597992, 0.04573613405227661, 0.002457177033647895, 0.035810425877571106, -0.01593797467648983, -0.027489755302667618, -0.03810013830661774, 0.018356725573539734, 0.01194344274699688, 0.06942103803157806, -0.0739613026380539, 0.033596962690353394, -0.0025385133922100067, -0.00022261615958996117, -0.06200406700372696, 0.00036982164601795375, 0.011221284978091717, 0.049461815506219864, -0.02975916862487793, -0.026531919836997986, 0.02689276449382305, -0.005858320277184248, 0.0052115130238235, -0.04405828192830086, 0.059218693524599075, 0.013504414819180965, -0.0341959185898304, 0.0010459383483976126, -0.015814246609807014, 0.05650672689080238, 0.0037114436272531748, 0.0349675714969635, -0.002035354496911168, -0.006238514091819525, -0.036288175731897354, 0.010806865058839321, 0.015813279896974564, -0.035055555403232574, -0.004726633429527283, -0.03768625110387802, 0.04317840188741684, 0.03983202204108238, -0.027065511792898178, -0.006994438823312521, 0.017620453611016273, -0.019265539944171906, 0.00764833390712738, -0.031484540551900864, -0.0003711319877766073, -0.03436331823468208, -0.017407245934009552, -0.04658609256148338, 0.020000796765089035, 0.02955201454460621, -0.009245818480849266, 0.004851006902754307, 0.007266127970069647, -0.02473161369562149, -0.012671105563640594, 0.11346696317195892, 0.0018128004157915711, 0.019972197711467743, -0.006600048393011093, -0.04568849876523018, 0.03636927530169487, -0.0019384277984499931, 0.020695088431239128, 0.020139683037996292, 0.037674929946660995, -0.04918421059846878, 0.04185276851058006, -0.026864206418395042, -0.0068143997341394424, 0.08239134401082993, -0.006620423402637243, 0.0634630024433136, 0.059545986354351044, 0.036790769547224045, 0.03624655678868294, -0.03953118994832039, -0.004631122574210167, -0.003865176346153021, 0.013792692683637142, 0.051268789917230606, 0.02017683908343315, 0.014047008939087391, 0.04767985641956329, -0.0023894000332802534, 0.05216750130057335, 0.04740297421813011, -0.0031692064367234707, 0.03483859822154045, 0.022791996598243713, -0.03725550323724747, -0.05972719192504883, 0.026721259579062462, -0.056699756532907486, -0.01241834182292223, -0.012336473912000656, -0.009451682679355145, 0.024830592796206474, 0.03400219976902008, 0.0044565508142113686, -0.013556025922298431, -0.024357320740818977, -0.07614526152610779, 0.027246836572885513, 0.0017074912320822477, 0.014571774750947952, 0.03549746051430702, 0.011579767800867558, -0.004933304153382778, 0.000827546464279294, 0.012133784592151642, -0.05274038389325142, -0.08217039704322815, -0.046247825026512146, -0.01904638111591339, -0.04179565608501434, -0.00995827279984951, 0.01986909657716751, -0.056219086050987244, 0.01928820088505745, -0.010194037109613419, 0.046069785952568054, -0.0023826544638723135, 0.017847208306193352, -0.007714678533375263, 0.04625440761446953, 0.011981933377683163, 0.03536539524793625, 0.026941847056150436, -0.017554713413119316, 0.10748733580112457, 0.06634698808193207, 0.030943820253014565, -0.06383910775184631, 0.01690332591533661, 0.0012354672653600574, -0.014999974519014359, -0.03234919533133507, 0.018110578879714012, 0.040106311440467834, -0.0061771017499268055, 0.025874165818095207, 0.030246255919337273, 0.015205892734229565, -0.027005542069673538, 0.0657496228814125, -0.027426306158304214, 0.01101821567863226, 0.0317048542201519, -0.005636606365442276, -0.0019858754239976406, -0.045656830072402954, -0.027390284463763237, 0.009198550134897232, -0.0008980318089015782, 0.003072821768000722, -0.00757567910477519, 0.0017749426187947392, 0.002495062304660678, 0.011827763170003891, 0.00793698150664568, 0.010206716135144234, -0.012052602134644985, 0.02078034169971943, -0.043857641518116, -0.01421407237648964, -0.02918604388833046, -0.011437702924013138, 0.011490912176668644, 0.03914836421608925, 0.018540402874350548, -0.01902143657207489, 0.005157310049980879, 0.025338687002658844, -0.060473598539829254, -0.02270652912557125, -0.05238167941570282, 0.04917304590344429, -0.005076685454696417, -0.02071913331747055, -0.02409842424094677, -0.0018878376577049494, -0.01983853057026863, -0.04680360481142998, -0.02734013833105564, 0.006061706691980362, 0.0030622335616499186, -0.025453336536884308, -0.016964033246040344, -0.055538032203912735, 0.0510200560092926, -0.028572631999850273, 0.016949903219938278, 0.0036881754640489817, -0.020935852080583572, -0.021944763138890266, 0.006866716779768467, 0.01642855443060398, 0.014502154663205147, 0.0041838139295578, 0.0022315967362374067, -0.021359343081712723, -0.01248306967318058, 0.0014989327173680067, 0.019672244787216187, 0.012702657841145992, 0.009974176995456219, 0.03141464293003082, -0.014673005789518356, -0.004002932459115982, -0.018494660034775734, -0.02094230428338051, -0.04252335801720619, 0.027271244674921036, -0.06107836961746216, -0.03202221915125847, 0.030254127457737923, 0.004454783163964748, 0.046200625598430634, 0.03320855647325516, 0.019995782524347305, 0.011902829632163048, 0.013292321003973484, -0.037394456565380096, 0.005283372476696968, -0.019283372908830643, -0.04229303449392319, 0.0014656721614301205, -0.006836084648966789, 0.052467454224824905, 0.03859040513634682, 0.0224442221224308, -0.003193568205460906, -0.018749527633190155, 0.001749956514686346, 0.025789953768253326, -0.02370840311050415, -0.039196308702230453, -0.03148462250828743, -0.009944218210875988, -0.012212702073156834, -0.05232247710227966, -0.02167203091084957, -0.05120011791586876, -0.047696325927972794, 0.04980824142694473, 0.015176543034613132, -0.039125896990299225, 0.022241385653614998, -0.003294094232842326, 0.026735354214906693, -0.0317864753305912, 0.0015174831496551633, -0.01997700147330761, -0.01730029471218586, -0.0080600306391716, 0.009435711428523064, -0.010552790947258472, 0.0012362644774839282, -0.022794920951128006, -0.013997862115502357, 0.09145364910364151, -0.012624888680875301, 0.00911529827862978, 0.017389480024576187, -0.019078096374869347, -0.007828890345990658, 0.07518123090267181, -0.055808477103710175, 0.01459402684122324, 0.04932040348649025, -0.05494052916765213, -0.0015564016066491604, 0.04631516709923744, -0.00409273337572813, 0.030302202329039574, 0.021182775497436523, -0.01359529048204422, -0.013995835557579994, 0.009331190958619118, -0.005144522059708834, -0.03027322329580784, -0.010718468576669693, 0.0060003758408129215, -0.009628583677113056, 0.025674568489193916, -0.003679372137412429, 0.0033385229762643576, 0.0017542786663398147, 0.012323902919888496, 0.025943171232938766, 0.008352861739695072, -0.03243062645196915, 0.002213536761701107, 0.011838870123028755, 0.013599591329693794, -0.005084962584078312, -0.003902146592736244, 0.0019781619776040316, 0.03473223000764847, -0.012181846424937248, 0.05345650762319565, -0.012449544854462147, -0.021257247775793076, -0.08543815463781357, -0.01696467399597168, 0.004944659303873777, 0.025412999093532562, 0.0065633272752165794, -0.052918288856744766, 0.022378673776984215, 0.043964799493551254, -0.025835245847702026, 0.015540867112576962, -0.011930769309401512, -0.0033825712744146585, -0.037476006895303726, 0.0035551085602492094, -0.00982510857284069, -0.011452734470367432, 0.026845499873161316, 0.02045581303536892, 0.02056952565908432, 0.03367381915450096, -0.028973396867513657, -0.009910032153129578, -0.04474715515971184, 0.024773815646767616, 0.012672511860728264, -0.07985846698284149, 0.008135822601616383, -0.04217134788632393, -0.0474521778523922, 0.04451996833086014, 0.015328195877373219, 0.01349695399403572, 0.0260146614164114, 0.010277695953845978, 0.006157823372632265, 0.03728453814983368, 0.031465765088796616, -0.018140947446227074, -0.02066146582365036, 0.016150588169693947, -0.0024587970692664385, 0.0011026798747479916, -0.015054401941597462, -0.011180057190358639, 0.04208268225193024, 0.005493329372256994, -0.030363410711288452, 0.02786998637020588, 0.002126599894836545, -0.04579624906182289, -0.008375455625355244, 0.008322187699377537, 0.019395701587200165, -0.015677539631724358, -0.01054783258587122, -0.017747703939676285, -0.01276601105928421, 0.028837082907557487, 0.012502881698310375, -0.04669647663831711, 0.00895766168832779, -0.025204498320817947, -0.030026812106370926, -0.015852903947234154, 0.02964283525943756, 0.0036480226553976536, -0.047295428812503815, 0.003342751180753112, -0.006316966377198696, -0.0100849075242877, -0.00964189413934946, -0.034929245710372925, -0.03257439285516739, 0.04469101130962372, -0.03727317973971367, 0.025570007041096687, 0.036451395601034164, 0.0008403725805692375, -0.010942237451672554, -0.06514065712690353, 0.05463920906186104, 0.010760086588561535, -0.03672990947961807, -0.005832192953675985, 0.03021601028740406, -0.04989613592624664, -0.011006069369614124, 0.060358695685863495, 0.030846431851387024, -0.011993068270385265, -0.034529395401477814, 0.015353315509855747, 0.010156447067856789, -0.08376950025558472, 0.035188060253858566, -0.023418907076120377, -0.052791472524404526, -0.03566950932145119, -0.02937513217329979, 0.01560103241354227, 0.02475810796022415, 0.014361056499183178, -0.002561612520366907, -0.0032012457959353924, 0.005934031680226326, -0.0004396748263388872, 0.04677287116646767, -0.018890660256147385, 0.04445063695311546, 0.06298607587814331, 0.00380040449090302, 0.012906588613986969, -0.002382757142186165, -0.0070071350783109665, -0.0253941360861063, 0.02358916401863098, -0.033917710185050964, -0.007102294359356165, -0.02045954018831253, 0.04211382567882538, -0.005087182391434908, -0.0761646032333374, 0.003910752013325691, 0.01967833749949932, -0.011255823075771332, 0.011037170886993408, 0.03733934834599495, 0.03162344545125961, 0.02403951995074749, -0.02463064156472683, 0.05864913761615753, -0.023181721568107605, -0.0029873887542635202, 0.007636632304638624, 0.013405968435108662, 0.024688348174095154, -0.015487701632082462, 0.03806624561548233, 0.012081426568329334, -0.040758393704891205, 0.029566744342446327, -0.029756078496575356, 0.06133414804935455, -0.004431155510246754, -0.04673915356397629, 0.014279728755354881, 0.005427577067166567, 0.015851860865950584, -0.0077514504082500935, -0.0305174570530653, 0.05667828395962715, -0.06901963800191879, -0.010652320459485054, -0.049675531685352325, -0.03740322217345238, -0.007054738234728575, -0.000565239111892879, 0.006627048831433058, 0.01568141020834446, 0.006072908639907837, 0.039484769105911255, 0.00602161418646574, 0.0005699907778762281, 0.032706864178180695, -0.0167282335460186, 0.013806880451738834, -0.01981896534562111, -0.017773717641830444, -0.022125529125332832, -0.0032653608359396458, -0.028588492423295975, -0.01059890165925026, -0.024163823574781418, 0.06279110908508301, 0.057720694690942764, -0.018692102283239365, -0.05039782449603081, 0.0063014947809278965, 0.006577670574188232, -0.06998129189014435, -0.010435876436531544, -0.06016668304800987, -0.0018676454201340675, 0.01298722717911005, -0.05725066363811493 ]
<p>A random sample of <strong>388</strong> married couples found that <strong>292</strong> had two or more personality preferences in common. In another random sample of <strong>552</strong> married couples, it was found that only <strong>24</strong> had no preferences in common. Let p1 be the population proportion of all married couples who have two or more personality preferences in common. Let p2 be the population proportion of all married couples who have no personality preferences in common.</p> <p>Find a 99% confidence interval for p1 – p2. Lower Limit: Upper Limit:</p>
74,466
[ -0.025978608056902885, -0.06413321942090988, 0.011241772212088108, 0.03271857649087906, 0.013656368479132652, 0.007907981984317303, -0.013373344205319881, -0.06095770001411438, 0.007557335309684277, -0.028898727148771286, 0.050552986562252045, 0.04709703102707863, 0.009951703250408173, 0.021675430238246918, -0.0018727562855929136, 0.017199622467160225, 0.024001726880669594, 0.02969060279428959, 0.02229483611881733, 0.012219668366014957, -0.055024415254592896, -0.0023087947629392147, 0.028935447335243225, 0.005091524682939053, -0.021121017634868622, 0.05309857055544853, 0.018752675503492355, -0.05238864943385124, -0.017265664413571358, 0.05443744733929634, -0.04633389040827751, -0.021175174042582512, 0.003317074151709676, 0.043061260133981705, 0.008222886361181736, 0.001174626057036221, -0.034675780683755875, -0.0017728995298966765, 0.014042935334146023, 0.020705102011561394, -0.019404733553528786, -0.022045517340302467, 0.003960606642067432, 0.003005165373906493, -0.022228460758924484, -0.03814423829317093, 0.04352647066116333, -0.052548475563526154, -0.008118700236082077, -0.028848422691226006, 0.06915534287691116, 0.011752275750041008, 0.058248214423656464, 0.0045767053961753845, 0.007928360253572464, -0.012353360652923584, 0.03208116069436073, 0.07192359119653702, -0.023118440061807632, -0.07767514884471893, -0.02420045994222164, -0.03441498056054115, 0.011195973493158817, -0.01736520789563656, -0.03836983069777489, 0.04308445006608963, -0.04439964145421982, -0.005868860520422459, 0.012419593520462513, -0.02782181277871132, 0.04500012844800949, 0.05659130960702896, 0.036562420427799225, -0.0145474998280406, 0.010574821382761002, -0.02422226406633854, 0.020436692982912064, 0.013706964440643787, 0.04763410612940788, 0.050412483513355255, 0.010819397866725922, 0.01960800029337406, 0.024510135874152184, 0.018584774807095528, 0.04755090922117233, -0.031388673931360245, 0.07294277846813202, -0.02862315997481346, 0.000017882095562526956, 0.024935079738497734, -0.0070485263131558895, -0.009592968039214611, 0.023674285039305687, 0.024821514263749123, -0.01951233670115471, 0.044313427060842514, -0.018333446234464645, 0.06274116039276123, -0.031913839280605316, -0.012620797380805016, -0.01654333434998989, -0.01895454153418541, 0.03935627266764641, 0.05169569328427315, 0.033049602061510086, -0.0050504026003181934, -0.045788880437612534, 0.0052182734943926334, 0.047725871205329895, 0.004523188341408968, 0.037499088793992996, 0.04676225408911705, 0.002714752685278654, 0.006910105235874653, 0.026988038793206215, 0.0060930512845516205, -0.006324199493974447, -0.03940754383802414, 0.06480488926172256, 0.02692241594195366, 0.01990073174238205, 0.024100983515381813, -0.012001299299299717, -0.012581788934767246, -0.06733232736587524, -0.0010785654885694385, -0.006221071816980839, 0.016831059008836746, -0.05387701094150543, 0.07148321717977524, -0.05030664801597595, -0.004630547948181629, 0.00036074192030355334, 0.052806973457336426, 0.001173284137621522, 0.020506316795945168, -0.09081843495368958, -0.03593902289867401, 0.021929491311311722, -0.009870141744613647, 0.018453579396009445, -0.07434400171041489, 0.019419154152274132, 0.0427432544529438, 0.07863074541091919, -0.03537321835756302, 0.047310568392276764, 0.009463355876505375, 0.017984015867114067, 0.05053246021270752, -0.03975684195756912, -0.0012594925938174129, -0.03049827180802822, -0.01297132857143879, 0.0012925926130264997, -0.0961097776889801, 0.032981421798467636, -0.017043503001332283, -0.02675100415945053, 0.005040590185672045, -0.02018488384783268, -0.006097637582570314, -0.013153532519936562, -0.03194424882531166, 0.022186553105711937, 0.008230019360780716, 0.06958617269992828, 0.010107106529176235, 0.0029731388203799725, 0.001986514311283827, -0.02173001319169998, 0.02516147680580616, -0.005498738493770361, 0.025594187900424004, 0.0647304356098175, -0.005872230511158705, 0.0038276617415249348, 0.02128566987812519, 0.011351661756634712, 0.007071179337799549, -0.009516728110611439, 0.012095095589756966, -0.021642716601490974, 0.04963257163763046, -0.0042343661189079285, 0.04569479823112488, -0.02193318121135235, -0.03343955799937248, -0.009438901208341122, -0.038165219128131866, -0.010682549327611923, -0.07323682308197021, 0.0012228760169818997, 0.052060067653656006, -0.05291033536195755, 0.005653895437717438, 0.0017378315096721053, 0.0018452118383720517, -0.0015110697131603956, -0.028183819726109505, -0.025592289865016937, 0.020322833210229874, 0.07877441495656967, -0.053576767444610596, 0.019331390038132668, 0.06020955741405487, 0.06240775063633919, -0.061627089977264404, 0.03904508054256439, -0.040524713695049286, -0.02336798794567585, 0.02723967656493187, -0.03147876635193825, 0.025907002389431, -0.0025855014100670815, -0.015175452455878258, 0.029092740267515182, 0.038957394659519196, -0.01163451373577118, 0.008002161979675293, -0.062144555151462555, 0.022910961881279945, 0.049343500286340714, 0.007889257743954659, 0.016945909708738327, -0.008265187032520771, -0.0007231462514027953, -0.022699803113937378, -0.0014468950685113668, -0.012527672573924065, -0.04333712160587311, -0.005555126816034317, 0.021419448778033257, 0.04298747330904007, -0.04284688085317612, 0.007271225098520517, 0.0549691878259182, 0.0311996191740036, -0.015844151377677917, 0.023646418005228043, 0.0029591156635433435, -0.02983301691710949, -0.015004856511950493, 0.03877194598317146, 0.02301289699971676, 0.04221423715353012, -0.02129754237830639, 0.030342387035489082, 0.03164686635136604, -0.007164529990404844, -0.0435827299952507, 0.05955494940280914, 0.025861505419015884, -0.010730407200753689, 0.01203086506575346, 0.0036435388028621674, 0.06300446391105652, -0.011825809255242348, -0.024668149650096893, 0.006844908930361271, 0.02775127813220024, -0.00017159573326352984, 0.02632717415690422, -0.028949065133929253, -0.003790966235101223, 0.06873821467161179, 0.00971115380525589, -0.003844170132651925, -0.0005503440625034273, -0.022193673998117447, -0.017385579645633698, -0.0021959447767585516, -0.024908654391765594, -0.036285221576690674, 0.010606068186461926, 0.007582519669085741, 0.01899663172662258, 0.020038966089487076, -0.012069359421730042, -0.021216612309217453, -0.02745651826262474, -0.009263376705348492, -0.006665016058832407, -0.019885851070284843, -0.09983346611261368, -0.019825348630547523, -0.008733471855521202, -0.0009444326860830188, -0.02197057008743286, -0.009776939637959003, -0.01424709614366293, 0.040476758033037186, -0.021077817305922508, -0.05572916194796562, -0.003988103941082954, 0.0014231924433261156, 0.014967437833547592, 0.020468901842832565, -0.020754635334014893, 0.023576674982905388, 0.02870534360408783, -0.03981246054172516, 0.010516395792365074, 0.008205480873584747, -0.043312206864356995, -0.03155403211712837, -0.010822962038218975, -0.007306349463760853, 0.006065964698791504, -0.0020447494462132454, 0.04998737946152687, 0.014908356592059135, -0.02981214039027691, -0.09203562885522842, -0.059429317712783813, 0.01145072653889656, 0.04117521271109581, 0.03464808315038681, 0.027215775102376938, -0.010975231416523457, 0.06507667899131775, 0.029304033145308495, -0.02748177759349346, -0.028915494680404663, -0.021044518798589706, -0.0010908886324614286, -0.002079309429973364, 0.029156023636460304, 0.021480845287442207, -0.002242752118036151, 0.02974899858236313, 0.05150578171014786, 0.03586789220571518, 0.02948061004281044, -0.015398094430565834, -0.0033287706319242716, 0.009535879828035831, 0.0018742064712569118, -0.02911282144486904, 0.054108839482069016, 0.02567339316010475, -0.04276416450738907, 0.024968840181827545, -0.013577998615801334, 0.020018862560391426, 0.013325922191143036, -0.0445072241127491, 0.03284042328596115, -0.028221527114510536, 0.007989290170371532, -0.030742203816771507, 0.031930841505527496, 0.00014101453416515142, -0.016313573345541954, 0.000287678005406633, -0.009853756055235863, 0.04447537288069725, -0.04439173638820648, 0.014261316508054733, 0.016197074204683304, 0.0208114106208086, 0.004196628462523222, -0.017205718904733658, -0.004849110264331102, -0.01315712183713913, 0.025751832872629166, -0.01035283226519823, -0.04620528593659401, 0.020511670038104057, 0.060617830604314804, 0.022292733192443848, -0.0012054357212036848, -0.04484447091817856, 0.04895830899477005, -0.031253881752491, 0.02038722299039364, -0.036347486078739166, 0.039850469678640366, -0.020582225173711777, 0.05788658931851387, 0.037504639476537704, -0.0023514186032116413, -0.0017526813317090273, 0.02128065563738346, -0.05041131749749184, 0.04392023757100105, -0.005948218982666731, 0.006004731170833111, -0.01574736461043358, -0.022548560053110123, 0.029331838712096214, -0.011950303800404072, -0.0028367373161017895, -0.012783647514879704, 0.02541998028755188, -0.03758913651108742, 0.019643506035208702, -0.05641820281744003, -0.026408594101667404, -0.017531367018818855, 0.03358114883303642, 0.006330360658466816, -0.048250555992126465, 0.07618936896324158, 0.01901651732623577, -0.018392207100987434, -0.01411969494074583, -0.05012533441185951, -0.008577583357691765, 0.022785184904932976, 0.05306799337267876, 0.021257629618048668, -0.0001683796290308237, 0.009593856520950794, -0.012743361294269562, -0.007535656448453665, 0.04672597348690033, 0.050925809890031815, -0.015578598715364933, -0.011239055544137955, 0.00451608607545495, -0.014361525885760784, -0.05222121626138687, 0.017254337668418884, -0.004934151656925678, 0.010912223719060421, 0.021383697167038918, 0.041920434683561325, -0.04350684583187103, 0.003993935417383909, 0.05842911824584007, 0.03494495898485184, -0.011231203563511372, -0.02811126969754696, -0.012174920178949833, -0.027344655245542526, -0.013214723207056522, 0.004574958235025406, 0.011977516114711761, -0.026128314435482025, -0.033983297646045685, 0.047474540770053864, 0.031164860352873802, -0.062019363045692444, 0.03565952554345131, -0.0066253445111215115, 0.04933037608861923, -0.010314015671610832, -0.025440767407417297, 0.00587258068844676, -0.008268780075013638, 0.020180199295282364, 0.002280615735799074, -0.01577172614634037, -0.0398932509124279, 0.020249856635928154, 0.007188880350440741, 0.061615485697984695, -0.0652083307504654, -0.012205032631754875, -0.020206991583108902, 0.027830492705106735, 0.028489256277680397, -0.03788463771343231, 0.005882072262465954, -0.016775578260421753, 0.00829693116247654, -0.03542507067322731, -0.05763182416558266, -0.06418398767709732, 0.014946556650102139, -0.026609735563397408, 0.01369469240307808, -0.031658537685871124, -0.006413331720978022, -0.009294011630117893, 0.0317889042198658, 0.06946992874145508, 0.08619239181280136, -0.02556990273296833, 0.017664393410086632, 0.01878388598561287, 0.007910268381237984, -0.017836635932326317, -0.05155270919203758, 0.000572559772990644, -0.005081719718873501, -0.020210636779665947, 0.06251251697540283, -0.06233695521950722, -0.02267978899180889, -0.017063383013010025, -0.007434376049786806, -0.018236735835671425, 0.0024751625023782253, -0.017802752554416656, 0.023807337507605553, 0.008562359027564526, -0.02870994061231613, 0.04772956669330597, 0.02193034626543522, -0.03563910722732544, -0.010231120511889458, -0.051081109791994095, -0.007307068444788456, -0.03202661871910095, 0.017162326723337173, -0.031420376151800156, -0.031621236354112625, -0.026489365845918655, 0.008104788139462471, -0.007048352621495724, -0.004401792772114277, -0.017661428079009056, 0.003941101022064686, -0.03001047670841217, 0.005179271101951599, 0.00611048424616456, 0.04176071286201477, -0.011593561619520187, 0.011947687715291977, 0.00004837564847548492, 0.0005802973173558712, 0.008738976903259754, -0.07903142273426056, -0.015051954425871372, 0.004642198793590069, -0.026065075770020485, 0.024460189044475555, -0.02332448959350586, -0.04220069572329521, -0.033284515142440796, -0.053598832339048386, 0.014840646646916866, -0.01856548711657524, 0.033244602382183075, 0.010551314800977707, -0.013403046876192093, -0.006286520976573229, 0.02447049506008625, 0.024715904146432877, 0.03735024854540825, 0.0012488524662330747, 0.07613951712846756, 0.02005940116941929, -0.010281497612595558, -0.06176404282450676, -0.030188485980033875, 0.03088359348475933, 0.0343080572783947, -0.03057830035686493, -0.02288910560309887, -0.025882598012685776, -0.017574820667505264, 0.0068123131059110165, -0.030918868258595467, 0.06412729620933533, 0.00916614942252636, -0.048596881330013275, -0.0396307036280632, 0.041139502078294754, 0.05668932944536209, 0.023585405200719833, 0.0039916071109473705, 0.013805638998746872, -0.01940319314599037, -0.018435992300510406, -0.0008771039429120719, 0.007575607858598232, -0.018662046641111374, -0.04507242888212204, -0.000982617144472897, 0.006994060706347227, 0.037362102419137955, 0.0049889348447322845, -0.01571808196604252, 0.005355634726583958, 0.024216562509536743, -0.017962174490094185, -0.019869215786457062, -0.028925087302923203, -0.0312701091170311, -0.0024531767703592777, 0.004531506448984146, 0.006870473735034466, -0.007471779827028513, -0.014717224054038525, 0.023574858903884888, 0.03983791172504425, -0.062306661158800125, -0.022852087393403053, 0.08931642770767212, 0.016072386875748634, 0.007696352433413267, -0.0018487005727365613, 0.0016262250719591975, 0.008668314665555954, 0.008921760134398937, -0.009779484942555428, 0.007230513263493776, 0.020507551729679108, 0.00005782607331639156, 0.026960518211126328, -0.026366038247942924, 0.011471918784081936, 0.04163205623626709, -0.007965653203427792, 0.04731341451406479, 0.05804546922445297, 0.0068548438139259815, -0.017368094995617867, -0.029036927968263626, -0.00884176604449749, -0.017081934958696365, 0.005558647681027651, 0.031841836869716644, 0.007058979477733374, -0.013185307383537292, 0.06770335137844086, 0.028189199045300484, 0.027826320379972458, 0.038658350706100464, -0.009831132367253304, 0.04329124093055725, 0.015429707244038582, -0.03088601864874363, -0.017994971945881844, 0.014712372794747353, -0.039581406861543655, 0.009230059571564198, -0.02365412563085556, -0.011391562409698963, 0.011719961650669575, 0.024987109005451202, 0.0075561790727078915, 0.0209931880235672, -0.05039377138018608, 0.003618332790210843, 0.02895071730017662, -0.018611660227179527, 0.02252175286412239, 0.0008328231051564217, -0.007312532514333725, 0.023703837767243385, 0.0003052417596336454, 0.0362476147711277, -0.03304140269756317, -0.0522138737142086, -0.015620836056768894, -0.0151367811486125, -0.03864520788192749, 0.038554489612579346, 0.005361716728657484, -0.0085831917822361, 0.044250622391700745, -0.03105824813246727, -0.018342815339565277, 0.0028868091758340597, 0.00022680476831737906, -0.013699321076273918, 0.06433214992284775, 0.0313732735812664, 0.06315936893224716, -0.010012521408498287, -0.00611764844506979, 0.1289321482181549, 0.04463948681950569, 0.0350559800863266, -0.06853076815605164, 0.04374656453728676, -0.01703662797808647, -0.02645205333828926, -0.045066241174936295, 0.02777179703116417, 0.00019568263087421656, 0.03974967077374458, 0.056621577590703964, 0.031843554228544235, 0.030798621475696564, 0.02065245248377323, 0.05865953490138054, -0.004065025597810745, -0.03189300745725632, 0.0005904490244574845, 0.00017849457799457014, -0.02260472998023033, -0.038511909544467926, -0.0005942019633948803, -0.019543122500181198, 0.00003244454273954034, 0.018369292840361595, -0.008230866864323616, -0.031166329979896545, 0.020771881565451622, -0.03422745689749718, -0.01215323619544506, -0.0008157829288393259, 0.03740262985229492, -0.004562736488878727, -0.005306662525981665, -0.02376907877624035, 0.03308936581015587, -0.04857971891760826, -0.01380232349038124, 0.012554703280329704, -0.025588570162653923, -0.010655638761818409, 0.045446429401636124, 0.033800046890974045, -0.047039665281772614, -0.029506105929613113, -0.04077152907848358, 0.01715654321014881, -0.004349644295871258, -0.03817947208881378, 0.010490091517567635, -0.013846888206899166, -0.012672971934080124, -0.026135150343179703, -0.025129370391368866, 0.02806035429239273, 0.0070662773214280605, -0.02315739169716835, -0.025050094351172447, -0.032556116580963135, 0.0008204845362342894, -0.008109092712402344, 0.005962693598121405, 0.01749388314783573, -0.03665078431367874, -0.06467767804861069, 0.015078479424118996, 0.00852218084037304, 0.0023457577917724848, -0.0038330534007400274, -0.03648850694298744, -0.01752300374209881, -0.043503448367118835, -0.018076667562127113, 0.007100667338818312, 0.011036859825253487, 0.02171473391354084, -0.004669001325964928, -0.015409808605909348, 0.021757742390036583, 0.010329842567443848, 0.003782654879614711, -0.028367718681693077, -0.03320227563381195, -0.015782438218593597, 0.004881251137703657, 0.010440311394631863, 0.021302638575434685, -0.030917005613446236, -0.009943308308720589, 0.028778599575161934, 0.04326064512133598, 0.05152813345193863, -0.025117812678217888, -0.005818914156407118, -0.019862256944179535, -0.08057771623134613, 0.0003648437559604645, -0.00024232230498455465, 0.05954960733652115, 0.015332872048020363, 0.02576492913067341, 0.016297614201903343, -0.01515672542154789, -0.01226605474948883, 0.026799213141202927, 0.05790488049387932, -0.035531990230083466, -0.051216717809438705, 0.05117339640855789, 0.012211693450808525, -0.05431349575519562, -0.006462969817221165, -0.04083453118801117, -0.015301583334803581, 0.0554007962346077, -0.020670250058174133, -0.04905490204691887, -0.02731809951364994, -0.008820232935249805, 0.014730784110724926, -0.02504357509315014, 0.004254571162164211, -0.01975049264729023, -0.01576337032020092, -0.0019253510981798172, 0.019724326208233833, 0.0007037372561171651, 0.008200551383197308, 0.00569256441667676, 0.026641087606549263, 0.05360512062907219, -0.004372698254883289, 0.017395948991179466, 0.011724092997610569, 0.023220911622047424, 0.000789088022429496, 0.009213521145284176, -0.06889111548662186, -0.04249906912446022, 0.06427310407161713, -0.05045706033706665, -0.03809819370508194, -0.00246027740649879, 0.010788371786475182, 0.031613025814294815, 0.015877723693847656, -0.009810048155486584, -0.0054533896036446095, 0.0251450352370739, -0.014572658576071262, -0.020604347810149193, -0.00020649137150030583, 0.03407176584005356, 0.007870974950492382, -0.011086639016866684, -0.030759606510400772, 0.022909583523869514, -0.005733597092330456, 0.029657214879989624, 0.050976261496543884, -0.024913307279348373, 0.011109228245913982, -0.01728777028620243, 0.017851321026682854, 0.035797882825136185, 0.028528891503810883, -0.0037408543284982443, 0.010956487618386745, 0.03700285032391548, -0.03144317492842674, -0.004659868776798248, -0.023390239104628563, -0.002072828821837902, -0.047829993069171906, -0.017951447516679764, 0.001550141372717917, 0.02433418482542038, 0.022932395339012146, -0.025104539468884468, 0.016244398429989815, 0.05708698183298111, -0.016378508880734444, 0.01463264599442482, 0.012421181425452232, 0.025742182508111, -0.022763816639780998, 0.02975945733487606, -0.053021930158138275, 0.01396487932652235, 0.004305560141801834, 0.00723695894703269, 0.017371822148561478, 0.038485560566186905, 0.051393959671258926, -0.012721475213766098, -0.005530728958547115, -0.015976911410689354, -0.017738036811351776, -0.05216965824365616, 0.014632186852395535, -0.04727482423186302, -0.03379698097705841, 0.06316342949867249, -0.0020434875041246414, 0.008703570812940598, 0.04048497974872589, 0.04877408593893051, -0.007932674139738083, 0.016799412667751312, 0.027259547263383865, 0.04121313616633415, -0.051385678350925446, 0.005384561140090227, 0.006082276348024607, 0.048025842756032944, -0.009013465605676174, -0.01587977446615696, 0.042360011488199234, -0.02373442053794861, -0.029998984187841415, 0.055031709372997284, -0.022211328148841858, -0.00005776492253062315, 0.004437002819031477, -0.02748616598546505, -0.0037133186124265194, -0.0197598859667778, 0.03297121077775955, -0.040126290172338486, -0.019032945856451988, 0.04136364161968231, -0.00385151244699955, 0.01185973733663559, 0.009886049665510654, 0.0041402666829526424, -0.02540465071797371, 0.014289513230323792, 0.007957697845995426, -0.02110818587243557, -0.06094813719391823, 0.00006767958984710276, -0.025579124689102173, 0.008208558894693851, 0.025024304166436195, -0.02634483389556408, -0.05562440678477287, 0.04768422245979309, -0.00913339201360941, 0.007143621798604727, -0.01999334618449211, 0.026581712067127228, -0.011786592192947865, -0.08474264293909073, 0.05927719548344612, -0.012032979167997837, -0.037390824407339096, -0.051164548844099045, 0.011525503359735012, -0.05313389375805855, -0.0051215277053415775, 0.03340696543455124, 0.020710131153464317, -0.0032394404988735914, -0.017865560948848724, 0.005079136695712805, 0.022058390080928802, -0.05551222339272499, 0.019176872447133064, -0.037080999463796616, -0.01349747832864523, -0.009769576601684093, -0.01975114643573761, 0.0049838838167488575, -0.008512170054018497, 0.014329694211483002, -0.0064115263521671295, 0.02169625088572502, 0.012923795729875565, -0.020158711820840836, 0.003139310982078314, -0.007158570922911167, -0.016562405973672867, 0.06519687175750732, -0.03617006167769432, 0.026947716251015663, -0.010387235321104527, -0.006219938397407532, -0.0669841319322586, 0.03520398586988449, -0.022766470909118652, -0.02261464297771454, -0.020111946389079094, 0.020703202113509178, 0.005385014694184065, -0.07993059605360031, 0.04141882061958313, 0.014952684752643108, -0.048006851226091385, 0.00015401355631183833, 0.020480364561080933, 0.02473946288228035, 0.01779809035360813, -0.0068037984892725945, 0.020370298996567726, -0.00816011056303978, -0.053310368210077286, 0.012386583723127842, 0.021649029105901718, 0.005725158844143152, -0.013670699670910835, 0.02576059103012085, 0.03838857263326645, 0.0026105798315256834, 0.030832383781671524, 0.01097432803362608, -0.010982743464410305, 0.006498435046523809, -0.004528928082436323, 0.05450936779379845, 0.0056570409797132015, 0.057583097368478775, -0.02008245326578617, -0.0018884700257331133, 0.03556916490197182, -0.05427737161517143, -0.003183216555044055, -0.05242719128727913, -0.022587165236473083, -0.060735657811164856, -0.006515687331557274, 0.044885020703077316, 0.006377015262842178, 0.024421406909823418, 0.008151695132255554, 0.037738606333732605, -0.027844905853271484, 0.007295326795428991, 0.022578883916139603, -0.005699994508177042, -0.0005478900275193155, -0.028143147006630898, -0.03936633840203285, -0.007054983172565699, 0.019672973081469536, 0.002189679304137826, -0.011628254316747189, 0.039088569581508636, 0.046055153012275696, -0.03235972300171852, -0.045819323509931564, 0.002695240778848529, 0.05410108342766762, 0.0013120119692757726, -0.002790899947285652, -0.05735671520233154, 0.013702263124287128, -0.006488045211881399, -0.04400085657835007 ]
<p>I am fairly new to data analysis and visualization, and I'm trying to figure out the best model to show some data regarding page load time (in seconds).</p> <p>The current view is a line graph where the x-axis is the page, and the y-axis is the load time. This graph is visually misleading though, because in my mind, the psychological expectation of a line graph is to convey something over time. Because there are a couple of outliers in the data where the page load time is much longer than the average, someone looking at the graph might be turned off because their eyes jump to the outliers, so it looks like our pages take forever to load. In actuality, about 95% of the pages take fewer than two seconds to load, and 5% of the pages take longer.</p> <p>So what's the best method to display this data? I want people to understand that on average, our page load time is <em>great</em>, and there are very few exceptions. I feel like depicting a bell curve might help to show that the majority of the pages fall within x-standard deviations of the mean, but A) I'm not sure how to do that in Excel, and B) I'm not sure that's the best option.</p>
37,349
[ -0.03013579174876213, -0.008459622040390968, 0.02350975014269352, -0.005265108309686184, 0.029016299173235893, -0.006301739253103733, 0.012853399850428104, -0.004824846051633358, 0.008022424764931202, 0.010204588994383812, 0.03887564316391945, 0.05711207166314125, 0.04890260100364685, 0.033651202917099, 0.013047361746430397, -0.003508634166792035, -0.022021789103746414, 0.008983083069324493, -0.03576217219233513, -0.03352420777082443, -0.0206257663667202, -0.02767745777964592, 0.0074455225840210915, 0.011968789622187614, -0.020743198692798615, 0.05483117327094078, 0.048330411314964294, -0.014559747651219368, -0.015631329268217087, 0.04939473792910576, -0.03461355343461037, 0.027232127264142036, 0.03287510201334953, 0.019500553607940674, 0.04912126064300537, 0.022302184253931046, -0.006580005865544081, -0.01971333473920822, 0.026866314932703972, 0.003961482085287571, -0.013980984687805176, 0.027003200724720955, 0.03991776704788208, 0.003315448760986328, -0.04175177216529846, 0.027697326615452766, 0.0073286304250359535, -0.06367901712656021, 0.018157944083213806, -0.04813927039504051, 0.08074093610048294, -0.001038077985867858, 0.030444910749793053, 0.01051070261746645, -0.02967808023095131, -0.008950709365308285, 0.002921645063906908, 0.055533166974782944, 0.006492224521934986, -0.07035214453935623, 0.0029899016954004765, 0.009346956387162209, -0.04026160016655922, -0.044469479471445084, 0.0015401674900203943, 0.04015393182635307, -0.02438921295106411, -0.00682323332875967, 0.04079751670360565, -0.05461030453443527, -0.01914072409272194, 0.007935022935271263, 0.051662594079971313, 0.0019272132776677608, 0.01720818690955639, -0.057993333786726, 0.03492142632603645, 0.009865610860288143, 0.0326044037938118, 0.03366374224424362, -0.013768916949629784, 0.00032837234903126955, 0.008205883204936981, 0.0403708852827549, -0.020290488377213478, -0.0009633597219362855, 0.09285075217485428, -0.02692571096122265, -0.0005127146723680198, 0.05418684333562851, -0.029163995757699013, 0.011244475841522217, 0.04183199256658554, 0.020263295620679855, -0.03386626020073891, 0.00522991456091404, -0.020434588193893433, 0.024838887155056, 0.017775211483240128, -0.0019379111472517252, -0.014827284030616283, -0.03982676565647125, -0.009600660763680935, 0.04130363464355469, -0.018248751759529114, 0.01660880818963051, -0.012124179862439632, -0.015930309891700745, 0.009408687241375446, -0.03534119203686714, -0.048871882259845734, -0.004471135791391134, 0.021924199536442757, 0.0628834217786789, 0.008164572529494762, -0.0029931620229035616, 0.024310190230607986, 0.0017009450821205974, 0.038403261452913284, 0.05489642918109894, 0.011352615430951118, -0.023447228595614433, 0.03025609441101551, -0.012931715697050095, -0.027964485809206963, 0.03160490095615387, -0.001667057746089995, -0.03625348582863808, -0.05582397058606148, 0.02751503698527813, -0.017296910285949707, 0.007285012863576412, 0.04292815551161766, -0.024524081498384476, 0.05033992603421211, 0.002446345519274473, -0.08053883910179138, -0.06537783145904541, 0.018545793369412422, 0.02591300755739212, 0.01924094371497631, -0.053884636610746384, -0.03259938582777977, 0.05774254351854324, 0.004741470795124769, 0.0190747007727623, 0.012362745590507984, -0.006864835973829031, -0.00004266248652129434, -0.003610412823036313, -0.04773552343249321, 0.028600335121154785, 0.011458025313913822, -0.031827740371227264, 0.0111150611191988, -0.05980436131358147, 0.00812686700373888, 0.05002857744693756, 0.026807302609086037, -0.03186680004000664, 0.01178658101707697, -0.019515495747327805, -0.015797041356563568, -0.035534169524908066, -0.019119122996926308, -0.026904365047812462, 0.09139696508646011, -0.0016515067545697093, 0.0414888821542263, 0.0023641777224838734, 0.00044379348400980234, 0.05275711044669151, 0.024657756090164185, 0.025178013369441032, 0.024353573098778725, 0.008131587877869606, 0.020791294053196907, 0.035935476422309875, -0.06119976565241814, 0.004204798024147749, -0.040551625192165375, -0.06641937047243118, -0.024612907320261, 0.013653302565217018, -0.0008162396843545139, 0.039669740945100784, -0.03152977302670479, -0.023439066484570503, 0.045706477016210556, -0.014255886897444725, -0.051449596881866455, -0.06048724427819252, 0.029587192460894585, 0.012593124993145466, -0.011162009090185165, 0.023557303473353386, -0.008046094328165054, -0.0083474637940526, -0.007169433403760195, -0.010121718980371952, -0.016917245462536812, 0.017574789002537727, 0.04796630144119263, -0.0431840606033802, -0.01567814312875271, 0.0570756234228611, 0.0036206806544214487, -0.02895008772611618, -0.021724771708250046, -0.06018953397870064, -0.0329168401658535, -0.019789092242717743, -0.05377742648124695, 0.05407607927918434, -0.009028042666614056, 0.032853443175554276, -0.02239968813955784, 0.039670951664447784, -0.007376130670309067, 0.0032248820643872023, -0.021491829305887222, 0.043888721615076065, 0.039055146276950836, 0.0072495415806770325, -0.03848415985703468, -0.017230773344635963, 0.02455366589128971, 0.010483382269740105, 0.01857616938650608, 0.007452161516994238, -0.0359346978366375, 0.014261161908507347, 0.04112422093749046, -0.01533687487244606, 0.007527256850153208, -0.02019093558192253, 0.0743928924202919, 0.023791689425706863, 0.012589375488460064, 0.01930188573896885, -0.03871265426278114, -0.011327303014695644, -0.030106786638498306, 0.00890444591641426, 0.036291468888521194, -0.0010506472317501903, 0.01571553200483322, -0.016301022842526436, -0.0010082860244438052, 0.02821768820285797, 0.04073594883084297, -0.00265730288811028, 0.0011215235572308302, 0.01209492888301611, -0.02141730859875679, 0.025077879428863525, 0.08278394490480423, -0.010185039602220058, -0.01373413484543562, 0.0617063045501709, -0.029591619968414307, -0.0024513776879757643, 0.015489652752876282, -0.02293623425066471, 0.00248044659383595, 0.03425019979476929, -0.031113017350435257, -0.0184208694845438, 0.020478911697864532, -0.009762503206729889, 0.03835843876004219, -0.005718202795833349, -0.05518563836812973, -0.04028832167387009, 0.013167425990104675, 0.03394285961985588, 0.010872963815927505, -0.0009195966413244605, -0.02670258842408657, -0.04531538486480713, 0.028469212353229523, -0.006771654821932316, 0.021021805703639984, -0.0533146895468235, -0.03997482731938362, -0.009392316453158855, -0.024067480117082596, -0.040590617805719376, 0.0396316722035408, -0.002591491676867008, 0.007419290486723185, 0.018045883625745773, -0.02147963084280491, -0.03072297014296055, -0.005164641421288252, -0.02241593785583973, 0.014540161937475204, -0.018738141283392906, -0.033746905624866486, 0.04214810952544212, -0.02810128778219223, -0.01610564813017845, 0.04129886254668236, -0.039568185806274414, -0.03910144791007042, -0.031644534319639206, 0.037674449384212494, -0.01557095069438219, 0.03904029354453087, 0.012753448449075222, -0.03080023266375065, 0.01753602921962738, -0.01315015647560358, -0.041188858449459076, -0.05343246087431908, -0.01848493702709675, 0.0004026112437713891, 0.035988736897706985, 0.002737566363066435, -0.017606498673558235, 0.07191484421491623, 0.037851523607969284, -0.036531053483486176, -0.07900670915842056, -0.01961127668619156, -0.002227185294032097, -0.038288455456495285, 0.043140362948179245, 0.055904094129800797, 0.0030970582738518715, -0.009202434681355953, -0.047436684370040894, 0.028115440160036087, 0.041490014642477036, 0.02155059576034546, -0.012644278816878796, 0.030834663659334183, -0.06349840760231018, 0.0007150893798097968, -0.0005980705027468503, 0.06604298204183578, -0.05234810709953308, 0.009569472633302212, -0.02090189978480339, 0.05654000863432884, 0.001704637543298304, -0.03159908205270767, -0.0005538337281905115, -0.012427247129380703, 0.01736588589847088, -0.01995743438601494, -0.006419405806809664, 0.0029943541157990694, 0.004703068174421787, -0.009337171912193298, 0.00429929094389081, 0.028354058042168617, 0.012181433849036694, 0.03161037713289261, 0.06874605268239975, 0.03154439106583595, -0.014701266773045063, -0.007779273670166731, -0.04077797010540962, -0.011872077360749245, 0.005046900361776352, -0.018573924899101257, -0.02741919830441475, 0.009367176331579685, 0.01343350950628519, -0.007812617346644402, -0.0012438371777534485, -0.03093229979276657, 0.015095962211489677, -0.09205988794565201, -0.024390896782279015, -0.04210321232676506, 0.04706549271941185, 0.02762850560247898, 0.03801841288805008, 0.000435131456470117, -0.010766294784843922, -0.008463971316814423, -0.011873374693095684, -0.07079096138477325, 0.021658880636096, -0.020001323893666267, 0.028213003650307655, -0.019442077726125717, -0.018735241144895554, 0.02047177404165268, -0.06540016829967499, 0.031717292964458466, 0.03443950042128563, 0.027623353525996208, -0.021842310205101967, -0.024889115244150162, 0.026726316660642624, 0.02976636402308941, -0.019828593358397484, -0.0015775648644194007, -0.0027745882980525494, 0.014438746497035027, 0.060995232313871384, 0.038563232868909836, 0.022536369040608406, -0.03891921788454056, -0.011443494819104671, -0.026306122541427612, 0.01211242750287056, 0.02972056344151497, -0.023853927850723267, 0.0041695404797792435, -0.05059780925512314, 0.04200243949890137, -0.04388822242617607, 0.02283105067908764, 0.03215299919247627, 0.018146667629480362, 0.020151332020759583, -0.05260324478149414, -0.001893053064122796, 0.0027593178674578667, 0.0014461408136412501, 0.00041613823850639164, 0.011177277192473412, 0.008209913037717342, 0.028313595801591873, -0.023288456723093987, 0.03885728120803833, 0.06154133751988411, 0.011830476112663746, 0.02157857082784176, -0.019025195389986038, -0.029925480484962463, -0.013161461800336838, -0.007348502054810524, 0.004976486321538687, 0.020776795223355293, 0.03957894444465637, 0.0031253681518137455, 0.006921891588717699, -0.013828415423631668, -0.02634880132973194, 0.025520198047161102, -0.023641323670744896, -0.0021734959445893764, 0.011787347495555878, -0.02141234092414379, 0.05338885635137558, 0.03569972515106201, 0.04363584890961647, 0.03364483639597893, -0.01024107076227665, -0.08240234106779099, -0.027549268677830696, 0.03963227570056915, 0.021488074213266373, -0.01084468699991703, -0.0069353519938886166, -0.016063682734966278, -0.0010272758081555367, 0.0409759059548378, 0.0028688223101198673, 0.017679445445537567, -0.007383042946457863, 0.03234097734093666, -0.0464809387922287, -0.03692804276943207, -0.01679217256605625, 0.02637176215648651, 0.004225271753966808, 0.03824407607316971, -0.0261897724121809, -0.024228444322943687, -0.048940934240818024, -0.0017313605640083551, 0.0016401936300098896, 0.038480304181575775, 0.0173382256180048, -0.020170127972960472, 0.002448015846312046, 0.014514908194541931, -0.055914249271154404, -0.06935529410839081, 0.00806351751089096, -0.006979574915021658, -0.025722937658429146, 0.05945149064064026, 0.017296431586146355, -0.05276390537619591, 0.03401421755552292, 0.030348626896739006, 0.02850254438817501, 0.013704528100788593, -0.026426631957292557, 0.04253636673092842, 0.03763130307197571, -0.00017691077664494514, 0.02530343271791935, 0.03548644855618477, 0.009072099812328815, -0.003387422999367118, 0.003583387238904834, 0.03758809715509415, -0.028150714933872223, -0.006935655605047941, -0.0357070229947567, -0.03276865929365158, -0.04528886824846268, -0.0019478416070342064, -0.007786752190440893, 0.0404570996761322, -0.057740699499845505, -0.04244040697813034, 0.003794398857280612, 0.019732851535081863, 0.03318236768245697, 0.008650385774672031, 0.01444197352975607, -0.020301453769207, -0.023750459775328636, -0.007496966980397701, 0.001313136308453977, -0.027760056778788567, -0.0017653164686635137, 0.040636096149683, -0.009147400967776775, 0.011363961733877659, -0.042276427149772644, -0.004842856433242559, -0.022820159792900085, -0.029616931453347206, 0.05014307051897049, -0.027130126953125, 0.027524862438440323, 0.007567285094410181, -0.0025202680844813585, 0.0009930136147886515, 0.04323280602693558, 0.020157156512141228, 0.04664274677634239, -0.022805429995059967, 0.004958343226462603, -0.02800530381500721, -0.020071113482117653, -0.05925624445080757, -0.052217036485672, 0.03522128984332085, 0.00363140064291656, -0.0701863244175911, -0.017580512911081314, -0.010863404721021652, -0.016842428594827652, -0.026203829795122147, 0.011653316207230091, 0.018856728449463844, -0.003571233944967389, -0.019981471821665764, -0.024629365652799606, 0.02099790796637535, 0.09259230643510818, 0.0002419728261884302, -0.03473333269357681, 0.00022420677123591304, 0.018329350277781487, -0.040535975247621536, -0.03357084468007088, 0.03710723668336868, -0.03523458167910576, 0.020763561129570007, -0.022021090611815453, -0.01270758081227541, 0.015760717913508415, -0.034355100244283676, 0.029434334486722946, 0.023382119834423065, -0.006026952061802149, -0.000034725413570413366, -0.025060422718524933, 0.04289981722831726, -0.01638779230415821, 0.017328346148133278, -0.005720543675124645, -0.010571399703621864, 0.0019794583786278963, 0.006404377054423094, 0.013380642049014568, 0.014980039559304714, -0.022402947768568993, 0.004624456632882357, 0.063397116959095, -0.007569530047476292, 0.0018596522277221084, -0.026572704315185547, -0.027144018560647964, 0.03825861215591431, -0.00022004611673764884, 0.009429224766790867, 0.010579652152955532, 0.009219780564308167, -0.044516775757074356, -0.016152799129486084, -0.028257275000214577, -0.02619028277695179, 0.042439110577106476, -0.018732650205492973, 0.03083764761686325, 0.03159332275390625, 0.03212282434105873, 0.008753607980906963, -0.03161049261689186, -0.030012013390660286, -0.06152228266000748, 0.010056108236312866, 0.014384418725967407, -0.009126879274845123, 0.01860196515917778, 0.032810650765895844, 0.002000348176807165, 0.004884423688054085, 0.06818502396345139, 0.045776668936014175, -0.0020235206466168165, 0.050520990043878555, -0.001448395662009716, -0.04509064927697182, 0.00363710755482316, -0.02829485945403576, 0.04667846858501434, -0.024032047018408775, -0.02349851466715336, 0.01748935505747795, 0.02620931714773178, -0.016416704282164574, -0.026313599199056625, 0.006962798070162535, -0.06552272289991379, -0.016966285184025764, -0.007670363411307335, -0.03215872496366501, -0.0032810987904667854, 0.00015398391406051815, 0.04424956440925598, -0.022182559594511986, 0.028947049751877785, -0.017445281147956848, -0.0751417875289917, -0.010823726654052734, -0.000853575358632952, -0.030770668759942055, 0.05519229173660278, -0.017436983063817024, -0.04764200374484062, 0.01796553283929825, -0.03325970470905304, -0.02483236789703369, -0.017995867878198624, 0.038616735488176346, 0.023455211892724037, 0.06363112479448318, -0.01350845955312252, -0.015365835279226303, -0.03524674475193024, -0.0021850590128451586, 0.10966696590185165, 0.06568518280982971, 0.030539847910404205, -0.06313317269086838, 0.026348499581217766, 0.006381979212164879, 0.008146927691996098, -0.038150522857904434, 0.011311075650155544, 0.0024718744680285454, 0.007181150373071432, 0.057817377150058746, 0.03527745604515076, 0.005612906999886036, 0.0043488130904734135, 0.036661818623542786, -0.052377909421920776, -0.0010192792396992445, -0.01449820026755333, 0.030860761180520058, -0.001529886620119214, 0.009316140785813332, -0.09754002839326859, 0.032198112457990646, 0.011657819151878357, -0.03286270052194595, 0.020310822874307632, -0.03491837531328201, 0.004455635789781809, -0.009758733212947845, -0.022494977340102196, 0.0350082665681839, 0.06751444935798645, -0.014797805808484554, 0.023806661367416382, -0.023826416581869125, -0.01614098623394966, -0.03163840249180794, 0.03570757433772087, 0.060448866337537766, -0.015571747906506062, -0.01477082073688507, -0.013061375357210636, 0.02292952500283718, -0.0037029189988970757, -0.024430857971310616, -0.02804373949766159, 0.027707170695066452, -0.02000507526099682, 0.008027790114283562, 0.0045411596074700356, 0.010124688036739826, -0.011781342327594757, -0.02744838036596775, -0.010598618537187576, 0.009243443608283997, 0.02739722654223442, 0.011137655936181545, 0.017851321026682854, -0.017460962757468224, 0.01080020610243082, -0.02498297579586506, 0.013918467797338963, 0.06744500994682312, -0.004740870092064142, -0.01756923273205757, -0.03794918209314346, 0.04653997719287872, -0.031802210956811905, 0.00023806252283975482, -0.019842127338051796, -0.0006405172171071172, -0.03150681033730507, -0.01184830628335476, 0.017403926700353622, -0.003807754023000598, -0.02242274582386017, 0.015049710869789124, -0.010719259269535542, -0.049107473343610764, -0.01198643445968628, 0.04496511444449425, 0.021980371326208115, -0.023947039619088173, -0.04554419592022896, -0.003957412671297789, 0.05195092037320137, 0.04627053812146187, 0.032682932913303375, 0.026286836713552475, -0.02312258817255497, 0.06899842619895935, 0.04524341970682144, -0.06532227993011475, -0.012465191073715687, 0.01446753740310669, -0.008481677621603012, -0.014482836239039898, 0.04159427806735039, 0.06616084277629852, 0.0019086063839495182, -0.022054284811019897, -0.005056547466665506, 0.026086201891303062, 0.032849233597517014, -0.0046311793848872185, 0.019085394218564034, -0.07177827507257462, 0.022976970300078392, 0.012114021927118301, 0.004019153770059347, -0.027020176872611046, -0.05770740285515785, -0.04487457871437073, -0.015595214441418648, -0.020688291639089584, 0.004810574930161238, 0.02841200679540634, 0.033281110227108, 0.012622926384210587, 0.04345939680933952, -0.03323955833911896, 0.0030674084555357695, -0.0332406722009182, -0.01622621715068817, -0.014385862275958061, -0.008139874786138535, 0.0011888593435287476, 0.04608422890305519, 0.038932498544454575, 0.006068440154194832, 0.010562434792518616, 0.01992294378578663, 0.04196495935320854, -0.006741533521562815, -0.006015680264681578, -0.016606653109192848, 0.047423481941223145, -0.034450266510248184, -0.019179947674274445, 0.05627395212650299, -0.03816371411085129, -0.029095783829689026, 0.01686926931142807, -0.018250465393066406, -0.005288183689117432, -0.030748087912797928, -0.01356362272053957, -0.005498320795595646, 0.02834528498351574, -0.025445781648159027, -0.04771435633301735, 0.0029507430735975504, -0.016483966261148453, -0.0010712038492783904, 0.007607666309922934, 0.004895877093076706, -0.010995078831911087, 0.00856577605009079, 0.014111033640801907, 0.05239159241318703, -0.02110026776790619, -0.0033572842366993427, -0.014828573912382126, 0.005195245612412691, 0.06425251066684723, -0.0369102917611599, -0.008563723415136337, 0.08203837275505066, 0.009430873207747936, -0.06388865411281586, 0.0309922955930233, -0.03457847610116005, -0.023900426924228668, -0.04000924900174141, -0.02365105040371418, 0.004439163953065872, -0.02575879916548729, 0.039467573165893555, -0.04763009026646614, -0.010799129493534565, 0.0487946979701519, -0.0586823970079422, 0.04384012520313263, 0.0018594703869894147, -0.02068716287612915, -0.03318999335169792, -0.014189604669809341, -0.013242313638329506, 0.021864518523216248, 0.01760570891201496, 0.03866233676671982, 0.03704812377691269, 0.03468191623687744, -0.004905369132757187, -0.032508812844753265, 0.01283933687955141, 0.042633023113012314, 0.01219024509191513, -0.04885619506239891, 0.0034294123761355877, -0.05157503858208656, 0.015565110370516777, 0.07602286338806152, 0.004328712821006775, 0.06305298209190369, -0.007147669326514006, 0.007259016390889883, -0.01943388395011425, 0.044012121856212616, 0.060627661645412445, -0.03048122674226761, -0.012289818376302719, -0.006323548965156078, 0.02127889171242714, 0.04862720146775246, -0.00860193558037281, 0.023333707824349403, 0.009576496668159962, -0.0054206447675824165, -0.04706130549311638, 0.02063392847776413, 0.025556910783052444, -0.01785905472934246, 0.00866688508540392, -0.0202056672424078, 0.06952826678752899, -0.01791119948029518, 0.03995377570390701, -0.040201615542173386, 0.01298438385128975, 0.0441037155687809, -0.0071550155989825726, -0.02225801721215248, 0.02951090782880783, -0.03953788802027702, -0.05193902179598808, -0.008056950755417347, 0.0007393095875158906, -0.019793633371591568, -0.03254149481654167, -0.03968530893325806, -0.027919819578528404, 0.009881339967250824, -0.022936591878533363, 0.003918080125004053, -0.01873163692653179, 0.03176797181367874, -0.003272391390055418, 0.006559372879564762, 0.009680119343101978, -0.022885914891958237, 0.00319229019805789, -0.059732452034950256, 0.06827684491872787, 0.05207595229148865, 0.012844681739807129, -0.02162451297044754, -0.0324467197060585, -0.015415612608194351, 0.029926687479019165, 0.07633636891841888, 0.00792032852768898, 0.00816298183053732, -0.027834028005599976, 0.02905651554465294, 0.004382707178592682, -0.04616378992795944, 0.021011721342802048, -0.013789912685751915, -0.007774857338517904, 0.003293692134320736, 0.010068398900330067, 0.035278767347335815, -0.021556252613663673, 0.003260861849412322, 0.0228103119879961, -0.006529971957206726, 0.01637592539191246, -0.044370487332344055, 0.012976415455341339, 0.016035087406635284, -0.0477236770093441, 0.02597157284617424, -0.00017381177167408168, -0.005045222584158182, 0.02144394814968109, 0.00937584973871708, -0.05358143150806427, 0.04878907650709152, -0.048764195293188095, -0.028646131977438927, 0.006579912733286619, -0.001658615772612393, -0.03623164817690849, -0.10122683644294739, 0.02864471636712551, -0.01379593089222908, -0.0014178063720464706, -0.0008719448815099895, 0.0019162792013958097, 0.014705930836498737, 0.06412595510482788, -0.024095138534903526, 0.019854305312037468, -0.05016523599624634, -0.001635533757507801, 0.013597456738352776, -0.02333284169435501, 0.014745136722922325, 0.03202397748827934, 0.036704692989587784, 0.051488131284713745, -0.021418629214167595, 0.04381332919001579, -0.03407224640250206, 0.04094645380973816, -0.01877014897763729, -0.01640985533595085, 0.033811334520578384, -0.013382482342422009, -0.015234794467687607, 0.024682318791747093, 0.004816720262169838, 0.03472907096147537, -0.016047198325395584, 0.0171348936855793, -0.06043724715709686, -0.017469050362706184, -0.04327947273850441, 0.01832571253180504, 0.019530031830072403, 0.03350311145186424, -0.02300349809229374, -0.01287142001092434, 0.01566718891263008, 0.020663674920797348, -0.009043794125318527, 0.007892154157161713, 0.021428439766168594, -0.006160596385598183, -0.02000722661614418, 0.00433197058737278, -0.057772260159254074, -0.005568989552557468, 0.012962671928107738, 0.030326394364237785, 0.0281806830316782, -0.008650590665638447, -0.003813853021711111, 0.0038524961564689875, -0.006715854164212942, 0.027117004618048668, -0.04667495936155319, -0.009675086475908756, -0.01155123021453619, 0.02716883271932602, 0.02848474122583866, -0.009717444889247417 ]
<p>what is the pdf of the product of two independent random variables X and Y, if X and Y are independent? X is normal distributed and Y is chi-square distributed.</p> <p>Z = XY</p> <p>if $X$ has normal distribution $$X\sim N(\mu_x,\sigma_x^2)$$ $$f_X(x)={1\over\sigma_x\sqrt{2\pi}}e^{-{1\over2}({x-\mu_x\over\sigma_x})^2}$$ and $Y$ has Chi-square distribution with $k$ degree of freedom $$Y\sim \chi_k^2$$ $$f_Y(y)={y^{(k/2)-1}e^{-y/2}\over{2^{k/2}\Gamma({k\over2})}}u(y)$$ whre $u(y)$ is unit step function.</p> <p>Now, what is the pdf of $Z$ if $X$ and $Y$ are independent?</p> <p>One way to find the solution is to use Rohatgi's well known result (1976,p.141) if $f_{XY}(x,y)$ be the joint pdf of continuous RV's $X$ and $Y$, the pdf of $Z$ is $$f_Z(z) = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty}{{1\over|y|}f_{XY}({z\over y},y)dy} $$</p> <p>since, $X$ and $Y$ are independent $f_{XY}(x,y)=f_X(x)f_Y(y)$ $$f_Z(z) = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty}{{1\over|y|}f_{X}({z\over y})f_{Y}(y)dy} $$ $$f_Z(z) = {1\over\sigma_x\sqrt{2\pi}}{1\over{2^{k/2}\Gamma({k\over2})}}\int_{0}^{\infty}{{1\over|y|}e^{-{1\over2}({{z\over y}-\mu_x\over\sigma_x})^2} {y^{(k/2)-1}e^{-y/2}}dy} $$ Where we face the problem of solving the integral $\int_{0}^{\infty}{{1\over|y|}e^{-{1\over2}({{z\over y}-\mu_x\over\sigma_x})^2} {y^{(k/2)-1}e^{-y/2}}dy}$. Can anyone help me with this problem. </p> <p>is there any alternative way to solve this?</p>
47,393
[ 0.021967891603708267, -0.003920277580618858, 0.07099708914756775, -0.009902711026370525, 0.027408836409449577, 0.007119625341147184, -0.04882395640015602, -0.05414918065071106, 0.03557523712515831, -0.03281755745410919, 0.060930948704481125, 0.016718057915568352, 0.04160405322909355, 0.03304288163781166, -0.000694036774802953, 0.012211157009005547, -0.043214067816734314, 0.023336423560976982, -0.026851346716284752, 0.003886160673573613, -0.009107106365263462, 0.020440982654690742, 0.02580256387591362, -0.023854639381170273, -0.049917738884687424, 0.02175210788846016, 0.011934117414057255, -0.023319151252508163, 0.0071562486700713634, 0.08343122154474258, -0.06096058711409569, -0.01344092283397913, 0.002318714978173375, 0.051602303981781006, -0.009503928013145924, 0.025028955191373825, -0.03388819843530655, -0.03174622356891632, 0.007309897802770138, 0.031067324802279472, -0.05182797834277153, -0.006624335423111916, -0.0017339851474389434, 0.00614283187314868, -0.027829160913825035, 0.03396674990653992, 0.009801440872251987, -0.053407520055770874, 0.031567446887493134, -0.019336789846420288, 0.07206451147794724, -0.007211638614535332, 0.015967832878232002, 0.017897600308060646, 0.0011850758455693722, -0.023100847378373146, 0.039744265377521515, 0.06362687796354294, 0.027855269610881805, -0.027601279318332672, -0.031168697401881218, -0.07799514383077621, -0.026264002546668053, -0.006769416853785515, 0.004354238510131836, -0.024895839393138885, 0.001828058622777462, -0.04391748085618019, -0.030374212190508842, -0.015979845076799393, 0.026847271248698235, 0.015244382433593273, 0.013421280309557915, -0.03126455843448639, 0.012552340514957905, -0.01593007519841194, 0.0017651369562372565, 0.022861145436763763, 0.009355871006846428, 0.019931934773921967, 0.0008564661256968975, 0.03179030865430832, 0.024806011468172073, -0.001778563135303557, 0.02750525437295437, 0.006116771604865789, 0.11768537014722824, 0.005189087707549334, 0.008039206266403198, 0.01097075454890728, 0.015041006729006767, 0.0208862517029047, 0.06660282611846924, 0.007649964652955532, -0.05811276286840439, 0.08021074533462524, -0.028153643012046814, 0.022205373272299767, 0.012327722273766994, -0.018948575481772423, -0.0023027800489217043, -0.05225338041782379, 0.033757686614990234, 0.07723105698823929, -0.024645105004310608, 0.0012222395744174719, -0.0278643649071455, -0.01142827793955803, -0.05706899240612984, -0.03958415240049362, -0.03571765124797821, 0.02148134633898735, -0.029112011194229126, -0.0068795946426689625, 0.00899464450776577, 0.03408113494515419, -0.02749018184840679, -0.019688455387949944, 0.05222466588020325, 0.052369214594364166, 0.05783971771597862, -0.0051421825774014, -0.032596737146377563, -0.037380654364824295, -0.038972046226263046, 0.02999149076640606, 0.03790653496980667, 0.01773686520755291, -0.0627305880188942, 0.048529352992773056, 0.013594411313533783, 0.0408574678003788, 0.02442934177815914, 0.014360999688506126, -0.008481604978442192, 0.01916140504181385, -0.03999749571084976, -0.022524379193782806, 0.0706041231751442, -0.018494172021746635, 0.03365589678287506, -0.07518956810235977, -0.005064749158918858, 0.02835630066692829, 0.0510946549475193, -0.02468808926641941, 0.049666643142700195, -0.01118532381951809, 0.018376249819993973, -0.018148966133594513, -0.028676938265562057, -0.017654452472925186, 0.015199389308691025, -0.03770268335938454, 0.006298006512224674, -0.040855564177036285, 0.04763282462954521, 0.01899081841111183, 0.00045978339039720595, -0.03390718996524811, 0.03303341194987297, 0.011694983579218388, -0.02426704578101635, -0.017479190602898598, 0.023739757016301155, -0.040483687072992325, 0.059467386454343796, 0.019608652219176292, 0.0367288663983345, -0.006921837572008371, -0.033488426357507706, 0.011784649454057217, -0.003703715279698372, 0.054220736026763916, 0.0061596836894750595, -0.010487602092325687, -0.035630274564027786, -0.02773990109562874, -0.00975013803690672, -0.014415743760764599, -0.05024879053235054, -0.022227661684155464, -0.06567508727312088, -0.012003538198769093, 0.02274465560913086, 0.018686743453145027, 0.02752971090376377, -0.01443797443062067, 0.014792948961257935, -0.08515012264251709, -0.023880664259195328, -0.054801344871520996, -0.000538944557774812, 0.04212816059589386, -0.05132351070642471, 0.021573178470134735, 0.02512141317129135, -0.00646907277405262, -0.003994725178927183, -0.023995738476514816, -0.04652249813079834, -0.026607507839798927, -0.004629878792911768, 0.0027403300628066063, 0.011547591537237167, 0.05710277333855629, 0.04974036291241646, -0.0018111466197296977, 0.026882445439696312, -0.03264117240905762, -0.03471552953124046, -0.010826241225004196, -0.03119596093893051, 0.02039778046309948, 0.001801344333216548, -0.004444791004061699, 0.030571050941944122, -0.00924366433173418, -0.031853724271059036, -0.014203103259205818, -0.051677580922842026, -0.0022807682398706675, 0.07879755645990372, 0.005500133149325848, -0.003607673803344369, 0.02499186433851719, 0.011634765192866325, 0.007286584470421076, -0.0026611369103193283, -0.01488624606281519, -0.034101665019989014, -0.019377920776605606, 0.03384275361895561, 0.04148630052804947, -0.024335641413927078, 0.018330400809645653, 0.017443472519516945, 0.005087780300527811, 0.03521440923213959, 0.010823576711118221, 0.014478306286036968, -0.061886824667453766, -0.0006025948678143322, 0.019025927409529686, 0.0015616363380104303, 0.0027337318751960993, -0.003365803509950638, -0.0027089903596788645, 0.014582003466784954, -0.01931181736290455, -0.0377080999314785, 0.035410430282354355, -0.012016035616397858, 0.03604540601372719, 0.017456907778978348, -0.004184416029602289, 0.0035157629754394293, 0.002680861623957753, -0.01298929750919342, 0.011043025180697441, 0.01080820057541132, 0.013466047123074532, -0.010502232238650322, -0.043134696781635284, 0.026020651683211327, 0.013625886291265488, -0.02478151209652424, -0.00572971859946847, 0.03310439735651016, -0.014065100811421871, 0.002660793485119939, 0.018440071493387222, -0.05618399754166603, 0.0017273117555305362, -0.009539307095110416, 0.01795961894094944, 0.010877829045057297, 0.0046048653312027454, 0.019718177616596222, -0.03098726086318493, 0.02675068937242031, 0.007801166269928217, 0.02641085349023342, -0.017980679869651794, -0.031166281551122665, 0.007251085247844458, -0.018426133319735527, 0.004768294282257557, -0.0010762150632217526, 0.005504091735929251, -0.0012211749562993646, 0.017314614728093147, 0.002508854493498802, -0.06323761492967606, 0.008169740438461304, -0.01114029623568058, 0.04131602123379707, -0.05158952251076698, -0.027231868356466293, 0.045444782823324203, 0.0001885140809463337, -0.06258208304643631, 0.022805798798799515, -0.04271495342254639, -0.01991991139948368, 0.0008506426238454878, 0.0008898427477106452, 0.03696418181061745, -0.01864255778491497, 0.03385178744792938, 0.021899370476603508, -0.00422496534883976, -0.023296339437365532, -0.06751829385757446, -0.04238196089863777, -0.009670017287135124, -0.015946373343467712, 0.028533386066555977, -0.01009979099035263, -0.04251658916473389, 0.06270113587379456, 0.03412478417158127, -0.005656794644892216, 0.004551812540739775, 0.02823069505393505, -0.017888231202960014, -0.046287328004837036, 0.029567206278443336, 0.02277960814535618, -0.019689489156007767, 0.056377943605184555, -0.020484672859311104, -0.018397020176053047, 0.042469944804906845, -0.0034876728896051645, 0.00846234243363142, 0.009694453328847885, 0.02035484090447426, -0.0242343507707119, 0.029988784343004227, 0.02107030339539051, -0.0017120162956416607, -0.00607528630644083, 0.023926667869091034, 0.02435385249555111, 0.0397612489759922, -0.04116130247712135, 0.008336902596056461, -0.030289452522993088, 0.011020753532648087, -0.05251554399728775, 0.054719824343919754, 0.019223148003220558, -0.06623951345682144, -0.026034342125058174, -0.014726193621754646, 0.014212360605597496, -0.020173311233520508, 0.03175259754061699, 0.024298537522554398, 0.01945503056049347, 0.013770638965070248, -0.0234017726033926, -0.03699299693107605, -0.03490736335515976, 0.035481322556734085, -0.037888556718826294, -0.014796847477555275, 0.008231346495449543, 0.03382924199104309, -0.0351051390171051, -0.0641266405582428, -0.017505677416920662, -0.0074309236370027065, -0.031671129167079926, -0.02489975467324257, -0.06289197504520416, 0.04169515520334244, 0.03886254504323006, 0.06566277146339417, -0.029300585389137268, -0.02346056140959263, 0.004822450689971447, -0.041741300374269485, -0.06786547601222992, -0.00019908713875338435, -0.012399471364915371, -0.009296736679971218, -0.021872535347938538, -0.02174477092921734, 0.047137532383203506, 0.018813716247677803, -0.005291332956403494, -0.014331373386085033, -0.007721611298620701, -0.00983407348394394, -0.0009060230804607272, -0.00816400907933712, -0.06247525289654732, 0.002371430629864335, 0.03789626806974411, 0.026280073449015617, -0.011636262759566307, 0.03777562454342842, 0.00871807336807251, -0.012732288800179958, 0.008284015581011772, -0.030293334275484085, 0.0022714054211974144, 0.002438285620883107, 0.02560877427458763, -0.01902417466044426, 0.014213735237717628, 0.009309708140790462, 0.04051307588815689, -0.009334108792245388, 0.06431810557842255, 0.0509454570710659, -0.016629336401820183, -0.013265041634440422, -0.030562106519937515, -0.014271990396082401, -0.0005229141679592431, 0.04316474124789238, -0.012776728719472885, -0.02520168386399746, 0.039236873388290405, 0.005776347126811743, 0.015125278383493423, 0.016536293551325798, 0.043888334184885025, -0.008580927737057209, -0.021365132182836533, 0.010218944400548935, -0.014821456745266914, -0.0055267480202019215, -0.016482409089803696, -0.008857721462845802, 0.005776477511972189, -0.0177902914583683, -0.00864429958164692, 0.03608435392379761, 0.05952899530529976, 0.007450223434716463, -0.009566365741193295, 0.015905611217021942, 0.0033538115676492453, 0.011592049151659012, -0.049262840300798416, 0.028384525328874588, 0.05505695939064026, 0.019162790849804878, -0.0016890810802578926, -0.0049118041060864925, -0.021241145208477974, 0.029741382226347923, 0.05306258052587509, 0.03603234142065048, -0.02394603006541729, 0.00697233434766531, -0.0550970695912838, 0.008068804629147053, 0.03646647557616234, 0.002732558874413371, 0.0169729832559824, -0.011749244295060635, 0.020533105358481407, 0.01232590340077877, -0.028325825929641724, -0.0432450994849205, 0.02342924289405346, 0.02979670837521553, -0.023732148110866547, -0.020953290164470673, -0.025946376845240593, -0.05104745179414749, 0.012790397740900517, 0.0149392019957304, 0.05801129341125488, 0.0021823884453624487, 0.012914717197418213, 0.01894410140812397, 0.03761093690991402, 0.013456162065267563, -0.047582659870386124, 0.054408926516771317, -0.00271398201584816, 0.009151576086878777, 0.058102842420339584, -0.0036399245727807283, -0.04030458629131317, 0.032691050320863724, -0.006564962677657604, -0.013375075533986092, 0.05998688191175461, 0.019102750346064568, 0.04113513231277466, 0.04322277754545212, 0.02310863323509693, 0.05907832458615303, -0.0072664725594222546, -0.016364101320505142, 0.004275336395949125, -0.015864213928580284, 0.0179021954536438, -0.029013032093644142, -0.0029946414288133383, -0.06386665999889374, -0.00914356205612421, 0.003962747752666473, 0.02216069959104061, -0.004552607424557209, 0.04576627537608147, -0.034551844000816345, -0.017621008679270744, -0.0071419356390833855, -0.00124939379747957, -0.026231763884425163, 0.03342919424176216, 0.00602933531627059, 0.04880437254905701, 0.031071001663804054, -0.014304363168776035, -0.0052899862639606, 0.010006134398281574, 0.010637649334967136, 0.0026976107619702816, -0.034301046282052994, 0.014612674713134766, -0.044214747846126556, 0.0003018421703018248, 0.026901429519057274, 0.03940422460436821, 0.030471956357359886, -0.004676997661590576, 0.033314287662506104, 0.024442404508590698, -0.02104782499372959, -0.035441089421510696, 0.019463978707790375, 0.02447466179728508, 0.028034962713718414, -0.00619999086484313, 0.012075956910848618, 0.008549208752810955, -0.011373324319720268, -0.05234638601541519, -0.012034107930958271, 0.007412247825413942, -0.030211767181754112, 0.007659703027456999, -0.058714259415864944, 0.04599081724882126, -0.030370019376277924, -0.05755488947033882, -0.024457380175590515, 0.016604023054242134, 0.00037793206865899265, -0.013150773011147976, -0.011616325005888939, 0.011571688577532768, 0.0397479310631752, -0.0023113987408578396, -0.032940007746219635, 0.03672140836715698, -0.014964447356760502, -0.02860497497022152, 0.02132122963666916, 0.010125680826604366, -0.006508162710815668, 0.013284516520798206, 0.032448749989271164, -0.06082118675112724, 0.033933304250240326, -0.03490912914276123, -0.024821337312459946, 0.03795658424496651, 0.009563827887177467, 0.01518345158547163, 0.010073212906718254, 0.009704699739813805, 0.015010434202849865, 0.03940467908978462, -0.02721760980784893, -0.03225002437829971, -0.029400603845715523, -0.011536688543856144, 0.008479691110551357, -0.011413780972361565, -0.023914793506264687, 0.004175508860498667, 0.060732003301382065, 0.004545513540506363, -0.026999816298484802, -0.025493282824754715, 0.030081328004598618, 0.030198343098163605, -0.022910691797733307, -0.0029336398001760244, 0.03846094012260437, -0.011514933779835701, -0.017241140827536583, -0.01968332566320896, -0.04411754012107849, -0.008840379305183887, 0.03966989740729332, -0.014669260941445827, 0.03673778474330902, 0.02947068400681019, -0.01018394436687231, -0.002551798475906253, -0.02138425223529339, -0.007700525224208832, 0.004221449606120586, -0.026776660233736038, 0.018584541976451874, -0.012371583841741085, -0.011629324406385422, 0.032739926129579544, -0.010635794140398502, 0.016422299668192863, 0.020539885386824608, 0.0050792996771633625, 0.015759265050292015, 0.010841963812708855, -0.04025696590542793, -0.03710165619850159, 0.036707803606987, -0.045550763607025146, 0.008940311148762703, -0.03510349243879318, 0.01682901568710804, 0.04494659975171089, 0.05838041752576828, -0.013369271531701088, -0.03594813495874405, 0.020519476383924484, -0.018582826480269432, -0.0014054843923076987, 0.018817568197846413, -0.023213721811771393, 0.011938301846385002, 0.003483944106847048, 0.032862983644008636, -0.01929161325097084, 0.044292986392974854, -0.05602256581187248, -0.04500899463891983, -0.005934250075370073, -0.0019165806006640196, -0.05516073852777481, 0.020135408267378807, -0.01885439269244671, -0.055842332541942596, 0.010166679508984089, -0.03157947584986687, 0.004293850623071194, 0.0012970131356269121, 0.004468197003006935, 0.018805311992764473, 0.06376375257968903, 0.02852664515376091, 0.05260506272315979, -0.01882541924715042, -0.0023785196244716644, 0.1526450663805008, 0.03237973526120186, 0.028809046372771263, -0.016729503870010376, -0.00466564716771245, -0.03871050477027893, -0.0045303720980882645, -0.04666927084326744, 0.0037766247987747192, 0.005355473607778549, -0.0233601126819849, 0.06425042450428009, 0.027517588809132576, 0.01887023262679577, -0.04853912815451622, 0.010442868806421757, -0.015537875704467297, -0.03185630217194557, -0.0223104115575552, 0.024240706115961075, -0.061709217727184296, -0.012348945252597332, -0.010478944517672062, -0.004753534682095051, -0.041442278772592545, -0.025214748457074165, -0.04208569601178169, -0.03212449327111244, -0.0019285280723124743, -0.016756651923060417, -0.04576735571026802, -0.00450139120221138, 0.04561733826994896, -0.014626303687691689, 0.056680236011743546, 0.004040127154439688, 0.03684563189744949, -0.05608520656824112, -0.006965807639062405, 0.04825276508927345, 0.012902902439236641, -0.013425991870462894, 0.032354872673749924, -0.0050484719686210155, -0.026986103504896164, -0.01524098590016365, -0.0247309859842062, 0.058163244277238846, -0.01004429068416357, -0.01587984524667263, -0.031761541962623596, 0.0011440070811659098, -0.016443783417344093, -0.02114882506430149, -0.002970781410112977, 0.023441698402166367, 0.024690749123692513, -0.04161687195301056, -0.008833589032292366, -0.014790100045502186, 0.039154764264822006, 0.02521846443414688, 0.027927542105317116, 0.0008783573866821826, -0.08292851597070694, -0.007681258022785187, 0.03148061782121658, 0.04553263261914253, 0.00011532768257893622, 0.005215311888605356, -0.02458282932639122, 0.015258949249982834, -0.002145513892173767, -0.012570853345096111, -0.002430037595331669, -0.033084895461797714, 0.04229642450809479, 0.020501311868429184, 0.002993082394823432, -0.030725296586751938, -0.06632236391305923, 0.022056831046938896, -0.012234811671078205, 0.03150048106908798, -0.029620924964547157, -0.029100479558110237, 0.007341787219047546, 0.016932720318436623, 0.004094389732927084, -0.03131834417581558, -0.016424061730504036, 0.06830079108476639, 0.023023642599582672, -0.03246181085705757, -0.01601855270564556, -0.004036240745335817, -0.019734080880880356, -0.0225289985537529, -0.03286740928888321, 0.025768354535102844, 0.03450010344386101, 0.07534521073102951, 0.002696193987503648, 0.030555035918951035, -0.0452539436519146, -0.01685432530939579, 0.03843921795487404, -0.04794267192482948, -0.009180422872304916, 0.013397589325904846, 0.02660016342997551, -0.007173387799412012, 0.02080218866467476, 0.016833290457725525, -0.004723409656435251, -0.04199851676821709, -0.01553351990878582, -0.012317738495767117, -0.03800015524029732, -0.029658008366823196, 0.01303845178335905, -0.00048146132030524313, 0.007134196814149618, 0.04298429191112518, 0.030292024835944176, 0.009294341318309307, 0.01072225533425808, -0.006343729328364134, 0.005567475222051144, 0.03526217117905617, -0.0159648135304451, 0.01276969350874424, 0.014694754034280777, 0.02883637137711048, -0.005207122303545475, 0.01983684115111828, 0.0018186630913987756, 0.028516855090856552, -0.02903914824128151, 0.00402175122871995, 0.027129070833325386, -0.014760931953787804, -0.021376194432377815, 0.01401700172573328, 0.02177150920033455, 0.041563477367162704, 0.013762393966317177, -0.0026326170191168785, -0.05332806706428528, 0.019616443663835526, 0.016791215166449547, 0.0014045650605112314, -0.028109833598136902, 0.012866239063441753, 0.03142965957522392, -0.015976782888174057, 0.0034987174440175295, -0.023067237809300423, 0.0016376563580706716, 0.027996711432933807, -0.007912722416222095, -0.02346975915133953, 0.019263911992311478, 0.04032948613166809, -0.013793745078146458, 0.017742836847901344, -0.042147714644670486, -0.004479126539081335, 0.09193452447652817, 0.04587869718670845, 0.002680381527170539, -0.014336849562823772, -0.049210574477910995, -0.0041095297783613205, -0.08826789259910583, -0.04098032787442207, 0.06736860424280167, 0.033389072865247726, 0.045888904482126236, -0.08082731813192368, -0.03753305971622467, 0.006811561528593302, -0.09955240041017532, -0.011509538628160954, 0.011995214968919754, 0.00732229370623827, -0.041183337569236755, 0.003240967635065317, -0.007633531931787729, 0.04784699156880379, 0.02301843650639057, 0.01594596914947033, 0.015683019533753395, 0.05337616056203842, 0.002925095148384571, -0.004309970419853926, -0.0005465801805257797, -0.03425050154328346, 0.003484145039692521, -0.052779775112867355, 0.06590984016656876, -0.037797242403030396, 0.000005480163508764235, -0.01747754029929638, 0.004826410673558712, 0.02672179415822029, -0.02235081046819687, 0.01838809810578823, 0.03286079689860344, 0.04932907596230507, -0.0023695232812315226, 0.039728712290525436, 0.01699892245233059, -0.014525922946631908, 0.0439215749502182, 0.00026215301477350295, -0.05419467017054558, -0.05701884627342224, 0.04356570541858673, -0.007990876212716103, -0.0279415063560009, 0.06690565496683121, -0.015863988548517227, -0.035509295761585236, 0.026482466608285904, -0.017934001982212067, -0.010152474045753479, -0.007282839622348547, 0.04623604938387871, -0.05607980862259865, -0.03812624141573906, -0.015099669806659222, 0.01484160777181387, -0.0017362014623358846, 0.011033738031983376, 0.0014974832301959395, -0.05669347569346428, 0.0658353641629219, -0.009620550088584423, -0.014910722151398659, -0.023575469851493835, -0.025352180004119873, -0.0053373356349766254, -0.012541699223220348, 0.037849120795726776, -0.004286294337362051, -0.05807507038116455, -0.007657154928892851, 0.034631237387657166, 0.04585053026676178, -0.03337272256612778, 0.007375179789960384, -0.021422259509563446, -0.04452245309948921, 0.017858322709798813, 0.021245155483484268, -0.036581795662641525, -0.02198909781873226, -0.029398953542113304, -0.03509526699781418, -0.023250335827469826, 0.06547506898641586, 0.02844577096402645, -0.008000722154974937, -0.007274989504367113, 0.03504028543829918, 0.024548791348934174, -0.08162607997655869, 0.0103575075045228, -0.028245287016034126, -0.022311126813292503, -0.019996928051114082, -0.00038886014954186976, -0.007421914488077164, 0.0006571480771526694, -0.0007811381365172565, -0.0316384881734848, 0.004867596551775932, 0.022897619754076004, -0.002795932814478874, 0.03680013120174408, -0.0038107805885374546, -0.03141295537352562, 0.05450386181473732, -0.0028712956700474024, 0.008290826342999935, 0.0005041323602199554, -0.020228732377290726, -0.056592170149087906, 0.016502223908901215, -0.0362575389444828, -0.030802253633737564, -0.041793808341026306, 0.010696827434003353, -0.011008691973984241, -0.045502521097660065, -0.016400085762143135, 0.06341685354709625, -0.040335364639759064, -0.004992748610675335, 0.06716645509004593, 0.05971576273441315, 0.03571420907974243, 0.018928002566099167, 0.00651027075946331, 0.02121395245194435, 0.007540262304246426, 0.03678274154663086, -0.010031710378825665, -0.005279571283608675, -0.0010182883124798536, -0.019562646746635437, -0.004063946660608053, -0.018047571182250977, 0.04559790715575218, -0.026118556037545204, 0.030924955382943153, -0.00700957840308547, 0.030811067670583725, 0.03118397295475006, -0.030725421383976936, 0.014036556705832481, 0.037274859845638275, -0.02954796887934208, 0.08158545941114426, -0.01839999482035637, 0.04607752710580826, -0.05382116511464119, 0.050538208335638046, -0.04642324894666672, -0.018194638192653656, 0.07112595438957214, 0.0502515472471714, -0.004271373618394136, 0.019355859607458115, -0.012910562567412853, -0.01842290535569191, 0.017106251791119576, -0.040459368377923965, -0.011895308271050453, -0.0013340386794880033, 0.005119137931615114, 0.019048446789383888, -0.03201977536082268, 0.008912697434425354, -0.02712283469736576, 0.03533872216939926, 0.03357705473899841, 0.015556790865957737, 0.015996403992176056, -0.020579403266310692, 0.027619387954473495, 0.07588525116443634, -0.043096140027046204, -0.011849073693156242, 0.0009344149730168283, 0.02076076902449131, -0.0024783932603895664, -0.008129719644784927 ]
<p>A probability distribution is a member of the two-parameter exponential family if the distribution can be expresses in the following form:</p> <p>$$ h(\theta, \phi) \text{exp}\left[\sum t(x_{i})\psi(\theta, \phi) + \sum u(x_{i})\chi(\theta, \phi)\right] $$ </p> <p>for parameters: $\theta$ and $\phi$, data: $x_{1}, x_{2}, \ldots, x_{n}$ and functions: $h$, $t$, $u$, $\psi$ and $\chi$.</p> <p>Furthermore, the conjugate prior for the two-exponential family takes the following form:</p> <p>$$ p(\theta, \phi) \propto h(\theta, \phi)^{v}\text{exp}\left[\tau\psi(\theta, \phi) + \omega\chi(\theta, \phi)\right] $$</p> <p>Whilst looking at some members of the two-parameter exponential family, I observed the following example:</p> <p>The gamma distribution ($\text{Ga}(\alpha, \beta)$) can be expressed in the above form, where $h = \frac{\phi^{\theta}}{\Gamma(\theta)}$, $\sum t = \sum \text{log}x_{i}$, $\sum u = \sum x_{i}, \psi = \theta, \chi = -\phi$.</p> <p>The example also states, following from the above, that the conjugate prior form for this gamma distribution is given by:</p> <p>$$ \left[\frac{\phi^{\theta}}{\Gamma(\theta)}\right]^{v} \text{exp}[\tau\theta - \omega\phi] $$</p> <p>Could somebody explain how this gamma conjugate prior can be expressed in this form?</p>
37,351
[ -0.011278698220849037, -0.0184921957552433, 0.07884800434112549, -0.026509316638112068, 0.03606545180082321, 0.003885968355461955, -0.010421928018331528, -0.012232610955834389, 0.018087495118379593, -0.031196273863315582, 0.03036595694720745, 0.015416426584124565, 0.04918938875198364, 0.0253546591848135, 0.05566281080245972, 0.014516724273562431, -0.037485986948013306, 0.014200116507709026, -0.028643546625971794, -0.009585070423781872, 0.031798746436834335, 0.0035932979080826044, -0.001978085609152913, -0.026916133239865303, -0.022770749405026436, 0.06386104226112366, 0.022262347862124443, -0.031129350885748863, -0.0163918137550354, 0.08635351061820984, -0.02704019472002983, -0.007823706604540348, -0.007587337400764227, 0.02344529703259468, -0.0003025813202839345, -0.019149988889694214, -0.013837424106895924, -0.04584260284900665, 0.0026744978968054056, 0.04168921336531639, -0.04961961507797241, -0.050517234951257706, -0.007589926011860371, -0.0018852499779313803, -0.03452654927968979, 0.012925468385219574, -0.0015938078286126256, -0.04320031777024269, 0.015761282294988632, -0.051812514662742615, 0.0487888865172863, -0.032837603241205215, 0.007813352160155773, 0.01644185744225979, -0.00268707238137722, -0.012080680578947067, 0.018459316343069077, 0.04351441562175751, 0.012911591678857803, -0.08874773234128952, 0.034367624670267105, 0.01729516126215458, -0.003306014696136117, -0.052951425313949585, -0.024395963177084923, 0.01597101241350174, 0.02981010265648365, -0.034995563328266144, 0.001921169925481081, 0.003913687076419592, 0.05333716422319412, -0.0071732643991708755, 0.022765876725316048, -0.0010439170291647315, 0.017154892906546593, 0.02246326021850109, 0.008112761192023754, 0.025949854403734207, 0.03608502075076103, 0.012617885135114193, -0.0030235580634325743, 0.02116544172167778, 0.04672481119632721, 0.011516907252371311, -0.016202246770262718, 0.023116793483495712, 0.09279248118400574, -0.002318879822269082, 0.0015447624027729034, -0.003860101569443941, -0.02565760910511017, 0.05261727049946785, 0.030918831005692482, -0.04190540686249733, -0.015057380311191082, 0.06635437905788422, -0.030199378728866577, 0.03338104113936424, 0.011339830234646797, 0.006139393430203199, -0.013600104488432407, -0.017106082290410995, 0.01643863320350647, 0.04963776841759682, -0.025083929300308228, -0.019157955422997475, -0.006974572781473398, 0.006379579193890095, -0.044926803559064865, -0.04096053168177605, -0.03867676481604576, 0.0545276403427124, -0.03473735973238945, 0.029630715027451515, -0.0003722556575667113, 0.005056224763393402, 0.01147408876568079, 0.019626319408416748, 0.06110208481550217, 0.037327688187360764, 0.023885367438197136, -0.028921235352754593, -0.014065676368772984, -0.0013213908532634377, -0.052881427109241486, -0.026964524760842323, 0.035892631858587265, -0.008622967638075352, -0.05127691850066185, 0.03632240742444992, -0.004283216316252947, -0.009890463203191757, 0.044043414294719696, 0.040186259895563126, -0.003954688087105751, 0.018462875857949257, -0.07627677172422409, -0.05416978895664215, 0.04338392987847328, 0.007201760075986385, 0.028541961684823036, -0.056528784334659576, -0.017364004626870155, 0.06287071108818054, 0.05833576247096062, -0.03316309675574303, 0.010548590682446957, 0.007405580021440983, 0.01706472411751747, 0.021248336881399155, 0.0053375097922980785, -0.01893417350947857, -0.005236877128481865, -0.004904589150100946, -0.010185996070504189, -0.06715749949216843, 0.05188791826367378, 0.011725003831088543, -0.013723011128604412, -0.001341846538707614, 0.050333283841609955, -0.0027793690096586943, -0.010382481850683689, -0.009062997996807098, 0.0062840720638632774, -0.05839331075549126, 0.08334770798683167, -0.006881248205900192, -0.014284060336649418, 0.05110617354512215, -0.027988174930214882, -0.011178793385624886, -0.0030015637166798115, 0.029934275895357132, 0.014671806246042252, -0.0009883733000606298, -0.04322762042284012, -0.03985266387462616, 0.004739413037896156, -0.002901497296988964, -0.006964245345443487, -0.03455435484647751, -0.03997950628399849, 0.025192154571413994, 0.05953503027558327, 0.016822025179862976, 0.029391778632998466, -0.049188245087862015, 0.031177636235952377, -0.047175366431474686, -0.03819607198238373, -0.03875790536403656, -0.009739423170685768, -0.03340510278940201, -0.02622373029589653, 0.03921712934970856, -0.008562580682337284, -0.015574794262647629, 0.027414612472057343, -0.02531946636736393, -0.000880007806699723, -0.006880274973809719, 0.04770214483141899, -0.028243862092494965, 0.009551962837576866, 0.03569197282195091, 0.05204441025853157, -0.005742992740124464, 0.040511783212423325, -0.006577180232852697, -0.058050163090229034, 0.014504747465252876, -0.02038932964205742, 0.05427291616797447, 0.00686077494174242, 0.004234651103615761, -0.018712889403104782, 0.027705758810043335, -0.019030477851629257, 0.023563144728541374, -0.09446654468774796, 0.004654358606785536, 0.06270883977413177, 0.009305030107498169, 0.004188833758234978, 0.023230819031596184, -0.024685662239789963, 0.03239523246884346, -0.011280938051640987, 0.010821783915162086, -0.0177572350949049, -0.03240783512592316, 0.04375963658094406, 0.03004135750234127, -0.019736994057893753, -0.0028450600802898407, 0.011428461410105228, 0.050397999584674835, 0.0300691369920969, 0.021012956276535988, 0.0071741691790521145, -0.028802329674363136, 0.01741882786154747, 0.009168971329927444, -0.00827170629054308, -0.016542602330446243, 0.0360410213470459, -0.020181993022561073, 0.01242902223020792, -0.04739561676979065, 0.005281636491417885, 0.042055632919073105, -0.009069052524864674, -0.017413582652807236, -0.05341661348938942, 0.009449515491724014, 0.06484130024909973, -0.021820999681949615, 0.029486173763871193, 0.022066578269004822, -0.012135488912463188, -0.01909819059073925, -0.03510833904147148, 0.003986789844930172, 0.012613335624337196, 0.010606631636619568, -0.030122188851237297, -0.008687424473464489, 0.006681082304567099, -0.05592254176735878, -0.014663314446806908, -0.04662144184112549, -0.017596563324332237, 0.0034609853755682707, 0.021654775366187096, 0.02968556620180607, -0.007654409855604172, 0.006188875995576382, -0.017403027042746544, -0.09680952876806259, -0.015772543847560883, 0.001836573937907815, 0.04113341122865677, 0.01593138463795185, -0.0446137897670269, -0.0021554974373430014, -0.03067866899073124, 0.014061332680284977, 0.03611823543906212, -0.031140072271227837, -0.030717458575963974, -0.02798200398683548, -0.0018685890827327967, -0.03644731268286705, -0.04317592456936836, -0.02209436520934105, -0.008537410758435726, -0.036909691989421844, -0.028529563918709755, 0.033230010420084, 0.005855008494108915, -0.00019818787404801697, 0.01806023344397545, -0.023548521101474762, -0.04498452693223953, -0.02664465829730034, -0.011866076849400997, 0.0008944973815232515, -0.010970493778586388, 0.022321585565805435, 0.03679433837532997, -0.03102477639913559, 0.006840856280177832, -0.08640968054533005, -0.039907462894916534, 0.005610999185591936, 0.021183839067816734, 0.03631463274359703, -0.0073120687156915665, -0.03225502744317055, 0.0625787079334259, -0.007183614186942577, -0.006517324130982161, 0.010352572426199913, 0.07535185664892197, -0.012993036769330502, -0.03339298814535141, 0.035664647817611694, 0.04102711006999016, -0.01855389028787613, 0.027797287330031395, 0.006242050789296627, -0.00009679030335973948, 0.05687567591667175, 0.00861816480755806, 0.028400758281350136, 0.049279455095529556, 0.03156760707497597, -0.014208165928721428, 0.029844747856259346, 0.02866365946829319, 0.0010167767759412527, 0.008606752380728722, -0.00018564367201179266, 0.024811606854200363, -0.009727547876536846, -0.046805594116449356, 0.014494109898805618, 0.012497557327151299, -0.025725195184350014, -0.051671404391527176, 0.03667639195919037, 0.05477389693260193, -0.04035563766956329, -0.02066570334136486, 0.01359461434185505, 0.031322985887527466, -0.05278842896223068, 0.020635228604078293, 0.042567767202854156, 0.06001634895801544, -0.06131347641348839, -0.02823294885456562, -0.0007262635626830161, -0.023388512432575226, 0.023395469412207603, -0.019117750227451324, -0.001040875562466681, 0.016025574877858162, 0.03548462316393852, -0.002479830989614129, -0.010602854192256927, 0.005622530821710825, -0.03779551014304161, -0.08040801435709, 0.012610799632966518, -0.031457189470529556, 0.04566546529531479, 0.05118807777762413, 0.055986832827329636, -0.0110927177593112, 0.007293026428669691, 0.007762663997709751, -0.009621618315577507, -0.09392546862363815, -0.0059976535849273205, -0.0012524843914434314, 0.02752011828124523, 0.019691720604896545, -0.03100624680519104, 0.04266420751810074, -0.015999434515833855, -0.006487178150564432, -0.010950744152069092, 0.017528798431158066, -0.06643953174352646, 0.022765370085835457, -0.08226819336414337, -0.009317071177065372, 0.003698986256495118, 0.030981143936514854, -0.026847530156373978, 0.0055620851926505566, 0.000688198721036315, 0.041106466203927994, -0.006802892778068781, 0.016301864758133888, -0.011637300252914429, 0.036977075040340424, 0.00962836854159832, 0.019460000097751617, -0.013235228136181831, 0.05862148478627205, 0.03464650362730026, 0.030490046367049217, 0.016114264726638794, 0.04459487274289131, 0.07133224606513977, -0.0016018901951611042, 0.016441652551293373, -0.019313765689730644, -0.02793543040752411, 0.015088380314409733, 0.03960553556680679, 0.030999833717942238, 0.00446924427524209, 0.029612233862280846, 0.024242941290140152, 0.01993456296622753, 0.027763083577156067, 0.05775212496519089, -0.01914137601852417, 0.013772135600447655, -0.031139418482780457, 0.000922003120649606, -0.011222225613892078, -0.009516429156064987, -0.01489974744617939, 0.028774501755833626, -0.03834151476621628, -0.009577520191669464, 0.015576056204736233, -0.024622922763228416, -0.02149798721075058, -0.037144917994737625, 0.023545926436781883, 0.009831064380705357, 0.02234259806573391, -0.05387229844927788, 0.005364695563912392, 0.0390530489385128, 0.010249818675220013, 0.02275726944208145, -0.008049039170145988, -0.031746912747621536, -0.02352455072104931, 0.04078971967101097, 0.00428155530244112, 0.004398475866764784, 0.0037502464838325977, -0.0524296797811985, -0.032179102301597595, -0.005760406143963337, 0.0017148578772321343, 0.06439696252346039, -0.055432047694921494, -0.014656602405011654, 0.034915730357170105, -0.046534325927495956, -0.03145426884293556, 0.01850423589348793, -0.006653676740825176, 0.003054229775443673, -0.03812304884195328, 0.022272199392318726, -0.010240410454571247, -0.0069907610304653645, -0.012467313557863235, 0.04832861199975014, 0.003351436695083976, -0.06228923797607422, -0.00586744537577033, 0.018361037597060204, 0.010984617285430431, -0.061540208756923676, 0.019390691071748734, -0.020970791578292847, 0.002802696544677019, 0.026459699496626854, -0.03204143047332764, -0.05122292414307594, 0.028220638632774353, 0.04397941753268242, -0.032995954155921936, 0.03999898210167885, -0.008132346905767918, 0.04364529997110367, 0.036546170711517334, 0.0032014944590628147, 0.06604915857315063, 0.02411063015460968, -0.032884739339351654, 0.008980188518762589, -0.07420599460601807, -0.022329451516270638, -0.026711761951446533, 0.003456799080595374, -0.04787576571106911, 0.030670076608657837, -0.03595678135752678, 0.026048172265291214, -0.019484978169202805, 0.037638381123542786, 0.010374631732702255, -0.026194384321570396, -0.014105333015322685, -0.005441361106932163, -0.029022671282291412, 0.006449185311794281, -0.017316902056336403, 0.043084654957056046, 0.021738247945904732, -0.012617378495633602, 0.023943079635500908, -0.031311117112636566, 0.022379428148269653, 0.02024582214653492, -0.015244183130562305, 0.007104192860424519, -0.0343194454908371, 0.007489058654755354, 0.041912563145160675, -0.03269622474908829, 0.03356979042291641, 0.0026589687913656235, 0.024204961955547333, 0.03198913112282753, -0.012877305038273335, -0.03792840987443924, 0.014528676867485046, -0.018066415563225746, 0.024782421067357063, -0.041958052664995193, -0.00795696210116148, 0.010117942467331886, -0.014456558972597122, -0.05436282604932785, 0.005434630438685417, 0.0352192148566246, -0.031340692192316055, -0.015904506668448448, -0.021348413079977036, 0.04588824883103371, -0.031133176758885384, -0.06374557316303253, 0.006220484618097544, 0.04817385599017143, 0.021200185641646385, -0.009871799498796463, -0.016190258786082268, 0.06554119288921356, 0.05067911371588707, 0.043726734817028046, -0.029346436262130737, 0.06991424411535263, -0.02327190525829792, -0.016537325456738472, 0.026923134922981262, 0.020173558965325356, -0.021819990128278732, -0.009022947400808334, 0.017135433852672577, 0.011695950292050838, -0.003202611580491066, -0.002788736019283533, -0.07176783680915833, 0.026562204584479332, 0.0012191594578325748, 0.015712907537817955, -0.01712225005030632, -0.041003674268722534, -0.0021327536087483168, 0.015850551426410675, -0.04199380800127983, -0.056916989386081696, -0.025104254484176636, -0.022217752411961555, 0.04899964481592178, -0.036152806133031845, -0.01817196048796177, 0.043098319321870804, 0.03973555937409401, -0.011546921916306019, -0.0161113478243351, 0.0005801614024676383, 0.0283578522503376, 0.018027639016509056, 0.002309064846485853, 0.015181816183030605, 0.04384416341781616, 0.0028674525674432516, -0.03612110763788223, 0.059615619480609894, -0.0516153909265995, 0.017368312925100327, 0.08245301991701126, -0.01287163607776165, 0.07097012549638748, 0.007132702507078648, 0.018854547291994095, -0.009516687132418156, -0.07090999186038971, -0.01759772002696991, -0.007615962531417608, -0.015210278332233429, 0.04338114336133003, -0.04283098131418228, -0.011301252990961075, 0.05244790017604828, -0.023811548948287964, -0.034008707851171494, 0.008790378458797932, -0.027931276708841324, 0.015892917290329933, -0.01617022417485714, -0.035426292568445206, -0.036485012620687485, 0.036230359226465225, -0.03231678158044815, 0.011752807535231113, -0.0275445394217968, -0.0271461121737957, 0.0012941554887220263, 0.03801695629954338, -0.025367209687829018, -0.055053796619176865, 0.0003041613381356001, -0.03590721637010574, 0.03302479907870293, 0.031192513182759285, -0.019307732582092285, 0.0266730897128582, -0.015029434114694595, 0.049383215606212616, -0.014366894029080868, 0.01513973344117403, -0.025823945179581642, -0.038380105048418045, -0.001326096709817648, 0.0014241683529689908, -0.0497601181268692, 0.0043457020074129105, -0.0006539987516589463, -0.002731362823396921, -0.01049437653273344, -0.0072009568102657795, 0.0072715990245342255, 0.020641086623072624, 0.01597556471824646, -0.04417296499013901, 0.10398223251104355, 0.005510599352419376, -0.005546411033719778, -0.007775967475026846, -0.010903174988925457, 0.13083207607269287, 0.059355221688747406, 0.03575633093714714, -0.017725609242916107, 0.006306375842541456, 0.0022535775788128376, 0.008548158220946789, -0.031121911481022835, -0.014446928165853024, 0.024764569476246834, -0.007356081623584032, 0.03658437356352806, 0.06622543931007385, 0.008296945132315159, -0.02420695312321186, 0.05034365504980087, -0.027112573385238647, -0.029185108840465546, 0.012835193425416946, 0.011727593839168549, -0.016497105360031128, 0.0024796349462121725, -0.01051289215683937, -0.013767632655799389, 0.0006042259628884494, 0.02785232663154602, -0.01751350238919258, -0.01789398118853569, 0.009067848324775696, -0.0013440325856208801, -0.00494029326364398, -0.03596680611371994, 0.01886766590178013, 0.02511421963572502, 0.04364737495779991, -0.013278926722705364, -0.021808817982673645, -0.04869573190808296, 0.008311501704156399, 0.041481297463178635, -0.007276247255504131, 0.016571512445807457, 0.029057547450065613, 0.019394122064113617, -0.03957805410027504, 0.0034704324789345264, -0.021378429606556892, 0.03396468982100487, -0.021923908963799477, -0.0058677950873970985, -0.025705184787511826, -0.009108754806220531, -0.027419164776802063, 0.008524700999259949, -0.009821025654673576, 0.00198817765340209, 0.0017548236064612865, -0.022968458011746407, -0.007536767050623894, 0.00792485661804676, 0.031162183731794357, 0.014286664314568043, 0.07687216997146606, 0.014009475708007812, -0.0644952580332756, -0.015259617008268833, -0.030240770429372787, 0.035649824887514114, 0.01684410870075226, -0.011240807361900806, -0.007195449899882078, -0.015363977290689945, -0.025962727144360542, -0.04850517585873604, 0.012117570266127586, -0.009142679162323475, 0.006683796178549528, 0.01160380057990551, 0.015300430357456207, -0.014995953068137169, -0.04395803436636925, 0.005526039749383926, -0.015544440597295761, -0.017254160717129707, -0.043585408478975296, -0.011549551971256733, 0.0038141380064189434, 0.03209355100989342, -0.01005896832793951, 0.015566437505185604, -0.017275357618927956, 0.054128192365169525, 0.037391990423202515, -0.02083238773047924, -0.06617471575737, 0.010844280011951923, -0.020762404426932335, -0.014179559424519539, 0.0071303811855614185, 0.054570287466049194, 0.04443814605474472, 0.051472220569849014, -0.011378445662558079, 0.010104266926646233, -0.0010201227851212025, -0.010524554178118706, -0.014889058656990528, -0.04923221841454506, -0.016139063984155655, 0.0030045113526284695, 0.03258224576711655, -0.015373633243143559, 0.0077111804857850075, 0.016442812979221344, -0.018350861966609955, -0.008702200837433338, 0.008836810477077961, -0.038520462810993195, -0.012341714464128017, 0.002407426480203867, 0.061171434819698334, 0.028419245034456253, 0.037195876240730286, 0.017744675278663635, -0.0007442935020662844, -0.059858277440071106, -0.030379563570022583, -0.004337809514254332, 0.03403845801949501, -0.03822906315326691, -0.0276174359023571, 0.034816235303878784, 0.034307874739170074, 0.0361555814743042, -0.0025092335417866707, 0.0061577605083584785, -0.0022359229624271393, 0.045473553240299225, 0.02971847541630268, -0.008890524506568909, 0.026045119389891624, -0.02235274575650692, -0.011329595930874348, 0.015340403653681278, 0.025924112647771835, 0.03417722135782242, 0.02818971872329712, 0.01052703708410263, -0.007131014950573444, 0.023980095982551575, -0.029848940670490265, -0.012925689108669758, 0.013291336596012115, -0.006382033694535494, -0.012157977558672428, -0.020617181435227394, 0.00791807472705841, 0.002958314958959818, 0.027558188885450363, 0.0027021856512874365, -0.00765615701675415, -0.00787417870014906, -0.028653893619775772, -0.003881867276504636, -0.0002884323475882411, 0.001570754568092525, -0.00995596032589674, -0.011098611168563366, 0.026939503848552704, 0.011430260725319386, -0.0116896266117692, 0.018220925703644753, -0.01322485227137804, -0.010507538914680481, -0.06734901666641235, -0.03905422240495682, 0.038797225803136826, 0.025266099721193314, 0.048962198197841644, -0.027793508023023605, 0.03680337592959404, 0.019742418080568314, -0.042426370084285736, 0.03335655853152275, 0.01966520957648754, 0.005377952940762043, -0.03865533694624901, 0.007905812934041023, -0.021759983152151108, 0.039313387125730515, 0.014363225549459457, 0.017194703221321106, 0.02361723594367504, 0.011647924780845642, -0.022814102470874786, -0.035024698823690414, -0.008134241215884686, 0.026815887540578842, 0.0008294192375615239, -0.04663657397031784, 0.04071833938360214, -0.04215358570218086, 0.010268024168908596, 0.043127115815877914, 0.026556016877293587, 0.03065226972103119, -0.03987464681267738, 0.017903652042150497, 0.04530032351613045, 0.02108442597091198, 0.03782770410180092, 0.00538560701534152, 0.0007939324714243412, 0.011186618357896805, 0.03214510530233383, 0.0056966873817145824, -0.0005627524224109948, -0.0073621077463030815, 0.027128243818879128, 0.013012085109949112, -0.012523655779659748, 0.00901072658598423, -0.005640119779855013, -0.033404942601919174, 0.018261078745126724, -0.008905606344342232, 0.0036666092928498983, 0.01644975319504738, 0.01940450631082058, -0.08395560830831528, -0.057539455592632294, 0.025110986083745956, 0.027779968455433846, 0.008122405037283897, -0.023587718605995178, -0.022621531039476395, -0.04943674057722092, 0.015628604218363762, -0.0002773126179818064, 0.027049776166677475, -0.0375300869345665, 0.0032197434920817614, 0.0012338418746367097, 0.0018493524985387921, -0.002121669240295887, -0.022366683930158615, -0.048448655754327774, 0.026041850447654724, -0.042280398309230804, 0.022243214771151543, -0.02616981789469719, 0.04272254556417465, -0.008559074252843857, -0.08714602887630463, 0.04080621898174286, 0.0005411797319538891, -0.04827041178941727, -0.010543436743319035, 0.0009107462828978896, -0.02737795189023018, -0.0014482637634500861, 0.07364737242460251, 0.009883570484817028, -0.01690196618437767, -0.005807525012642145, 0.05964269861578941, 0.010309217497706413, -0.04780128598213196, 0.016218023374676704, 0.00038503107498399913, -0.040817949920892715, -0.00686644809320569, 0.0324079766869545, 0.022189373150467873, 0.014177379198372364, 0.014597805216908455, -0.05028141289949417, 0.013065551407635212, -0.010735142976045609, -0.042236000299453735, -0.009388883598148823, 0.011073539033532143, -0.0394880510866642, 0.03081873618066311, -0.03399111330509186, 0.021420804783701897, 0.018152602016925812, 0.019344771280884743, -0.07182739675045013, 0.02074538916349411, 0.01156932208687067, -0.013607058674097061, -0.021100834012031555, -0.012203611433506012, 0.0045802709646523, -0.035603392869234085, -0.03649701923131943, 0.024656668305397034, -0.05408410355448723, -0.0205064807087183, 0.0370977483689785, 0.027904383838176727, 0.06326340138912201, 0.043333545327186584, 0.03794713690876961, -0.018463220447301865, -0.047447461634874344, 0.030657868832349777, 0.027712194249033928, 0.036377545446157455, -0.01825556345283985, 0.012698259204626083, 0.03171762079000473, -0.03203420341014862, 0.009696357883512974, -0.025165798142552376, 0.03278500959277153, -0.02035081386566162, 0.011844920925796032, 0.026708662509918213, -0.004568707197904587, 0.0007208879687823355, 0.008070291951298714, -0.04781172052025795, 0.06983634829521179, -0.03142757713794708, 0.007413195446133614, -0.025693684816360474, 0.020775698125362396, -0.023731591179966927, 0.005043268669396639, 0.03033517301082611, 0.029333023354411125, 0.05683480575680733, 0.008233852684497833, -0.02289578877389431, -0.02259986288845539, 0.00441698357462883, -0.04793725535273552, 0.011230542324483395, 0.027224799618124962, -0.018182609230279922, 0.030747683718800545, -0.05763593316078186, -0.025090839713811874, -0.03037066012620926, -0.014355331659317017, 0.02307208813726902, 0.0007599596865475178, -0.006510807666927576, -0.06719327718019485, 0.016519742086529732, 0.03554202616214752, -0.026804126799106598, 0.031212281435728073, -0.030458763241767883, -0.0032029482536017895, 0.008248581551015377, -0.03883396461606026 ]
<p>I’m using Stata 12.0, and I’ve downloaded the <code>polychoricpca</code> command written by Stas Kolenikov, which I wanted to use with data that includes a mix of categorical and continuous variables. Given the number of variables (around 25), my hunch is that I will need to generate more than 3 components. Ultimately, I would like to generate a handful of meaningful components (rather than dozens of variables) and use the components as independent variables in logistic regression.</p> <p>Using <code>polychoricpca</code>, I am able to generate a table showing the eigenvalues and the eigenvectors (loadings) for each variable for the first three (3) components only. <code>polychoricpca</code> appears to call these loadings “scoring coefficients” and produces these for every level of the variable, such that if a variable has three categories you’ll see three scoring coefficients (“loadings”) for that variable. Never having worked with polychoric PCA before, I’m used to only seeing one loading per variable/item. I want to examine these coefficients (“loadings”) to try to understand what the components are and how they might be labelled. </p> <p>My questions:</p> <p>(1) What if it looks as if I should generate 4 components? It seems as if I wouldn’t be able to examine and understand what that 4th component is because I can’t see how each of the items load on that 4th component, only the first 3. Is there a way to see how each item loads on more than the first three components?</p> <p>(2) Can I simply use the polychoric correlation matrix combined with Stata’s <code>pcamat</code> command to examine how each item loads on each component (the eigenvector table). I thought this might be a way of being able to examine loadings if I have more than 3 components. The idea came from <a href="http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/stata/faq/efa_categorical.htm" rel="nofollow">this UCLA stats help post</a> on using <code>factormat</code> with a polychoric correlation matrix. <code>pcamat</code> in Stata, however, produces only 1 loading (coefficient) per variable, not 1 loading for every level of the variable. Any thoughts on whether it would be appropriate just to report the single loading from <code>pcamat</code>? </p>
37,352
[ -0.02813294716179371, 0.032437220215797424, 0.012671135365962982, 0.005915955640375614, 0.07396668940782547, -0.013028493151068687, -0.005809687543660402, -0.01892247051000595, 0.051901545375585556, -0.03797135874629021, 0.031237421557307243, 0.013438762165606022, 0.05853788182139397, 0.02144652046263218, 0.005684528965502977, 0.015737216919660568, 0.0029301156755536795, 0.0013110422296449542, -0.012547451071441174, -0.00042206989019177854, 0.01465627085417509, -0.003249098313972354, -0.02711351402103901, -0.021244319155812263, 0.013567092828452587, 0.06381364166736603, 0.013541228137910366, -0.028299199417233467, -0.0008268593810498714, 0.025407699868083, -0.017802942544221878, -0.021571079269051552, 0.017665019258856773, 0.004714398179203272, 0.012612600810825825, -0.0063099036924541, -0.020968353375792503, -0.00804972741752863, -0.007405065931379795, 0.048414889723062515, -0.043034233152866364, 0.01168312132358551, -0.005670348647981882, 0.007614501751959324, 0.023048600181937218, 0.02105162851512432, -0.016233831644058228, 0.012801220640540123, 0.03079884499311447, -0.03806210681796074, 0.05687054246664047, 0.014569040387868881, -0.0032276506535708904, 0.03178175538778305, -0.03532789275050163, 0.0012776717776432633, 0.044851724058389664, 0.05668243020772934, 0.005205896217375994, -0.06204932555556297, -0.015154358930885792, 0.005105126649141312, -0.010910024866461754, -0.041290219873189926, -0.030065953731536865, 0.03616391122341156, 0.04460326209664345, 0.022501248866319656, 0.061638157814741135, -0.02252119779586792, -0.009457327425479889, 0.00047290403745137155, 0.02818431705236435, -0.014107893221080303, 0.014623476192355156, -0.011952362023293972, 0.02714790217578411, 0.010688849724829197, 0.0193390604108572, -0.008653278462588787, 0.015231913886964321, 0.013116957619786263, -0.014563623815774918, 0.006911441218107939, 0.020641092211008072, 0.0024399254471063614, 0.059488289058208466, -0.049863655120134354, 0.020524419844150543, 0.011612195521593094, -0.004043226130306721, 0.025894375517964363, 0.0031795285176485777, 0.00997172947973013, -0.015813501551747322, 0.07078199088573456, -0.029292210936546326, 0.02637060545384884, 0.0015462946612387896, 0.011709841899573803, -0.01722714863717556, -0.010025141760706902, 0.013765410520136356, 0.03315494582056999, -0.0001804301282390952, 0.018997102975845337, -0.0173657163977623, 0.0019609956070780754, -0.013936972245573997, -0.054468318819999695, -0.048154622316360474, 0.02356141433119774, 0.020442401990294456, -0.0017389894928783178, -0.008781792595982552, -0.0060239145532250404, -0.013394230045378208, 0.016158631071448326, 0.015521110035479069, 0.04045948386192322, 0.02392413094639778, -0.05635210499167442, 0.011524424888193607, -0.03284814953804016, -0.10153469443321228, 0.011744407936930656, -0.01614728569984436, -0.022284913808107376, -0.019920315593481064, 0.040427885949611664, -0.025585733354091644, -0.016693616285920143, 0.04847445338964462, 0.025381820276379585, -0.019598396494984627, 0.015540072694420815, -0.10874862968921661, -0.04759247601032257, 0.02334621176123619, -0.018720293417572975, -0.002828152384608984, -0.04437299817800522, 0.0015601345803588629, 0.006442213896661997, 0.04532670974731445, -0.022207273170351982, 0.026060763746500015, 0.007039626594632864, 0.05049014836549759, 0.0006309133023023605, -0.02724088728427887, 0.023822378367185593, -0.07358361035585403, -0.004808592610061169, -0.03266424313187599, -0.07689370959997177, 0.0122655825689435, 0.033867426216602325, 0.015014014206826687, 0.001935659791342914, 0.05469655245542526, 0.011175568215548992, -0.022617030888795853, -0.002809630474075675, 0.004367024637758732, -0.016922930255532265, 0.008241942152380943, -0.013726795092225075, 0.014758313074707985, -0.019568808376789093, -0.03211113065481186, -0.020527875050902367, -0.004724652506411076, 0.059327490627765656, 0.031791795045137405, -0.012715362943708897, -0.02734312042593956, 0.0011887532891705632, 0.002420867793262005, -0.020290706306695938, -0.020497644320130348, -0.057982783764600754, 0.013791960664093494, -0.009202077053487301, 0.019069060683250427, 0.04330945014953613, 0.02275889553129673, -0.008781928569078445, 0.03039153665304184, -0.03551551327109337, -0.07058902084827423, -0.018484454602003098, 0.0030000503174960613, -0.020348669961094856, -0.04983444884419441, 0.06363940984010696, 0.014706400223076344, 0.01698148250579834, 0.0383802093565464, 0.021574469283223152, -0.025547266006469727, 0.029692592099308968, 0.03457960858941078, -0.03081606701016426, -0.004080177750438452, 0.03342009708285332, 0.030981598421931267, -0.01235923171043396, 0.042109452188014984, -0.03507661446928978, -0.03715610131621361, 0.028437679633498192, -0.03792136162519455, 0.04668786749243736, -0.01726720854640007, 0.010568566620349884, -0.038989972323179245, 0.032737549394369125, -0.05472428351640701, 0.016275137662887573, -0.050814446061849594, 0.04949592053890228, 0.09616745263338089, 0.012670749798417091, -0.021456534042954445, 0.004393900278955698, -0.018667323514819145, 0.012474981136620045, -0.039737995713949203, 0.04843612015247345, -0.01760144904255867, -0.026690665632486343, 0.043857648968696594, 0.042969901114702225, -0.03656652942299843, 0.017213303595781326, 0.052581679075956345, -0.00436518806964159, 0.03663252666592598, 0.03261963650584221, 0.010285829193890095, -0.02146967314183712, 0.0019640580285340548, 0.020124029368162155, 0.00593388918787241, -0.009317363612353802, 0.007822035811841488, 0.00792862381786108, 0.034640051424503326, 0.03302835300564766, -0.0040644570253789425, 0.06750024855136871, -0.032768163830041885, -0.004206244368106127, -0.008951779454946518, -0.01884640008211136, 0.06657236069440842, 0.023011917248368263, 0.05437355116009712, 0.025038406252861023, 0.014429757371544838, -0.014557876624166965, -0.008315198123455048, -0.008860554546117783, 0.011574548669159412, 0.050846949219703674, -0.010134459473192692, -0.03043678030371666, 0.002373799914494157, -0.022637035697698593, 0.05639311298727989, -0.022064324468374252, -0.01550699770450592, -0.04585374891757965, -0.0010596150532364845, 0.03763237223029137, 0.009347867220640182, 0.03889038413763046, -0.06476660072803497, -0.00450380751863122, 0.03736743703484535, 0.013738973066210747, 0.0031680085230618715, -0.00451737130060792, -0.08249949663877487, -0.04815445467829704, -0.03861071914434433, -0.009000945836305618, 0.02056163176894188, -0.01947287656366825, -0.04321752116084099, 0.06991113722324371, -0.045065924525260925, -0.020379025489091873, -0.04409778118133545, 0.04609110578894615, -0.001162497908808291, -0.06353794038295746, -0.04666963964700699, 0.017630353569984436, 0.0029465050902217627, -0.056606244295835495, 0.005492259282618761, -0.033985838294029236, -0.0021376577205955982, 0.015570288524031639, -0.03277980163693428, 0.002814363921061158, -0.008434250950813293, 0.0010463546495884657, 0.02667011320590973, 0.0051069557666778564, 0.011851293034851551, -0.053306944668293, -0.04526802524924278, 0.008760392665863037, 0.021705441176891327, 0.040151070803403854, 0.01902708038687706, -0.026664596050977707, 0.05932227149605751, 0.03088352456688881, -0.04700790345668793, -0.04380595311522484, -0.001434219884686172, -0.048982247710227966, -0.016493793576955795, 0.024753866717219353, 0.004694718401879072, 0.009289068169891834, -0.0028838582802563906, -0.036608848720788956, 0.02442012168467045, 0.06983453780412674, -0.008839817717671394, 0.02201920934021473, 0.0406840555369854, -0.03081102855503559, -0.03945773094892502, 0.025859542191028595, 0.011987700127065182, -0.013381396420300007, 0.02406580187380314, -0.03332073241472244, 0.041793592274188995, 0.017208613455295563, -0.01833842135965824, 0.00300419214181602, -0.003332380438223481, -0.009149042889475822, -0.08085459470748901, -0.016006166115403175, 0.029354598373174667, -0.04292968660593033, -0.030189933255314827, 0.016515569761395454, 0.042816583067178726, -0.01880587637424469, -0.021284818649291992, 0.04517355188727379, 0.016491077840328217, -0.02696993388235569, 0.016893580555915833, 0.02049063704907894, -0.006174780428409576, 0.039839863777160645, 0.01282510906457901, -0.0016230627661570907, 0.044988129287958145, 0.02079438418149948, 0.01390907634049654, 0.024751488119363785, -0.02555593103170395, 0.04624510556459427, -0.044062960892915726, -0.0011083950521424413, -0.04673708975315094, 0.04808313399553299, 0.008217311464250088, 0.05387173965573311, 0.00010711727372836322, -0.023486407473683357, -0.00260146870277822, -0.008935365825891495, -0.08363669365644455, -0.009467228315770626, 0.018190918490290642, 0.0006188204861246049, 0.034775927662849426, -0.015393788926303387, 0.028067590668797493, -0.013015387579798698, -0.02494264952838421, 0.026485729962587357, 0.015168704092502594, -0.023985182866454124, 0.041846029460430145, -0.00306943547911942, 0.021495437249541283, -0.022658614441752434, 0.008148115128278732, 0.005838562734425068, 0.00594340218231082, 0.03474218025803566, 0.05916035547852516, -0.009593181312084198, 0.017074743285775185, -0.021608203649520874, -0.014431473799049854, 0.019149761646986008, 0.031192125752568245, -0.009542375802993774, 0.04083464667201042, -0.011086645536124706, 0.01098930649459362, -0.030255209654569626, 0.05698602646589279, 0.04134561866521835, -0.0013124034740030766, 0.014713219366967678, -0.038028717041015625, -0.01479574665427208, -0.012016242370009422, 0.008050218224525452, -0.00902178417891264, 0.03779149428009987, 0.02944369427859783, 0.029573842883110046, -0.056246526539325714, 0.04325981065630913, 0.06565165519714355, 0.02509441412985325, -0.020417727530002594, -0.04607628285884857, -0.007595369126647711, 0.002251650672405958, 0.011969280429184437, -0.013199320994317532, 0.029164044186472893, 0.021605513989925385, 0.01105616707354784, 0.042922493070364, -0.07307754456996918, -0.017473820596933365, 0.0397150032222271, 0.005456720013171434, 0.010601784102618694, -0.019594665616750717, -0.031491927802562714, 0.027360152453184128, 0.02102048322558403, 0.06757405400276184, 0.009898255579173565, 0.013957524672150612, -0.07593018561601639, -0.026953430846333504, 0.0509769432246685, 0.026738077402114868, -0.06726682931184769, -0.021303653717041016, -0.021583186462521553, -0.040630582720041275, 0.014774360693991184, -0.033305563032627106, 0.03608403354883194, -0.0016002707416191697, 0.040815625339746475, -0.047854047268629074, -0.02358110249042511, -0.03779715672135353, 0.01391688734292984, -0.01902640052139759, 0.015325834043323994, 0.008061946369707584, -0.01808989606797695, -0.024511974304914474, 0.04620056226849556, -0.005466646980494261, 0.03284433111548424, -0.039647866040468216, -0.013417365960776806, 0.006419450975954533, -0.0026852297596633434, -0.03672259673476219, -0.04280206188559532, -0.009151330217719078, -0.016017382964491844, -0.012839347124099731, 0.04041595757007599, -0.005556805524975061, -0.007807184010744095, -0.037995241582393646, 0.0037770255003124475, 0.011558490805327892, 0.013179361820220947, -0.03809741511940956, 0.07126162201166153, -0.018876994028687477, -0.017648115754127502, 0.06225897744297981, 0.027456939220428467, -0.04031718522310257, -0.0002466621808707714, -0.06462828069925308, 0.02432522550225258, -0.01898970454931259, -0.010961370542645454, -0.02639453299343586, 0.0052970279939472675, -0.011428708210587502, 0.0035758386366069317, -0.0016756403492763638, 0.01297523733228445, 0.006148501764982939, -0.0025648309383541346, -0.02053127996623516, 0.02933385781943798, -0.005020070821046829, 0.01576182246208191, -0.00611887825652957, 0.021277233958244324, -0.009932925924658775, -0.05424097180366516, 0.044765714555978775, -0.012299521826207638, 0.020148402079939842, 0.016832932829856873, -0.019482571631669998, -0.02315462753176689, -0.032015156000852585, 0.026419270783662796, -0.018606826663017273, -0.03429242596030235, 0.05274948477745056, -0.0024231825955212116, 0.07060620933771133, 0.0039597321301698685, -0.026271536946296692, -0.02487446367740631, 0.023266389966011047, -0.03163750842213631, 0.011402915231883526, -0.010128808207809925, 0.03863496705889702, -0.04380437731742859, -0.0073216804303228855, -0.02151629328727722, -0.06524794548749924, 0.04769804701209068, 0.010696613229811192, -0.017572572454810143, -0.04101846367120743, -0.01878018118441105, 0.011797448620200157, 0.007344410289078951, -0.0023589185439050198, 0.026764921844005585, -0.06249692663550377, 0.010717847384512424, -0.014519614167511463, 0.03272981196641922, 0.07149519771337509, 0.004320655018091202, 0.013396006077528, 0.018526475876569748, -0.00993276759982109, -0.02101789601147175, -0.011923259124159813, -0.03389672935009003, -0.005744090769439936, 0.01546623557806015, -0.02753237821161747, 0.012480203993618488, 0.06413544714450836, -0.024681486189365387, -0.034238994121551514, -0.03396428003907204, -0.04043375328183174, -0.00041563782724551857, -0.05031298100948334, -0.0057313572615385056, 0.006777462549507618, -0.01902148872613907, -0.02390420250594616, 0.018190592527389526, -0.04040779173374176, -0.029381038621068, 0.020108958706259727, -0.004009817261248827, -0.03068920224905014, 0.03495359048247337, 0.07642016559839249, 0.012920625507831573, 0.008980974555015564, -0.012260893359780312, -0.010550964623689651, 0.033497460186481476, 0.04958655685186386, -0.022202663123607635, 0.0191427543759346, -0.004889659583568573, -0.0309402234852314, -0.0027532740496098995, -0.06698960810899734, 0.004308952484279871, 0.027314357459545135, 0.00042697362368926406, 0.0313686840236187, 0.07538479566574097, -0.011804829351603985, 0.008780253119766712, -0.02242978662252426, 0.02267950028181076, 0.013145623728632927, 0.006364411674439907, 0.06862439215183258, 0.0009158881730400026, -0.024323442950844765, 0.03207498416304588, 0.0278813187032938, -0.02030434086918831, 0.03870009630918503, 0.02005254104733467, 0.001827739179134369, 0.011079979129135609, -0.01828582212328911, -0.02237892709672451, 0.008125574328005314, -0.019834838807582855, -0.006184787955135107, -0.019528046250343323, -0.04752553999423981, 0.04294535890221596, 0.07763779908418655, 0.02626052312552929, -0.060124412178993225, -0.027278296649456024, -0.04066220298409462, 0.018117690458893776, 0.012542828917503357, -0.03346708416938782, 0.03201732411980629, -0.04643887281417847, 0.09087320417165756, 0.013505445793271065, 0.04238121211528778, -0.02082245796918869, -0.06745319068431854, -0.050297901034355164, -0.0006018299027346075, -0.025944575667381287, 0.023447798565030098, -0.014149132184684277, -0.046015284955501556, 0.04448726028203964, -0.051190610975027084, 0.05349557846784592, 0.014688593335449696, 0.037076689302921295, -0.012380042113363743, 0.04411754384636879, -0.02751639112830162, -0.016490522772073746, 0.0216615479439497, -0.02834513410925865, 0.15932314097881317, 0.08469495922327042, 0.042864445596933365, -0.041190627962350845, 0.005337866954505444, 0.04571182653307915, 0.003969196230173111, -0.028486045077443123, -0.005895308684557676, 0.020939908921718597, -0.0336889773607254, 0.010478868149220943, 0.0724136233329773, 0.0035884857643395662, 0.03444581478834152, 0.03856714069843292, -0.01732858084142208, -0.005081582814455032, -0.014907054603099823, 0.006717553827911615, -0.01193555910140276, -0.026226691901683807, -0.0439394935965538, -0.023582229390740395, -0.0056761931627988815, -0.025148287415504456, -0.03381238132715225, -0.03136062249541283, -0.006556412670761347, -0.028340883553028107, -0.023394618183374405, -0.011355657130479813, 0.05532063916325569, 0.008319951593875885, 0.021738551557064056, 0.008770487271249294, 0.03678298741579056, -0.02259332314133644, -0.007867234759032726, 0.0354996956884861, -0.04528982564806938, -0.018664143979549408, 0.015203922055661678, 0.018594563007354736, 0.009618641808629036, -0.021722368896007538, -0.026816977187991142, 0.030309364199638367, -0.02242525853216648, -0.009562633000314236, -0.0308072566986084, 0.01864667795598507, -0.00003254523471696302, -0.04582299292087555, -0.020334774628281593, 0.013895891606807709, 0.009540395811200142, -0.01697354018688202, -0.02162616141140461, -0.02232174389064312, -0.02089649625122547, -0.02290194481611252, 0.04655306041240692, 0.005854654125869274, -0.011540441773831844, 0.009315971285104752, -0.07793284207582474, 0.046853385865688324, 0.009325042366981506, 0.010458079166710377, 0.024594390764832497, -0.009569228626787663, -0.01361910905689001, -0.02474859543144703, 0.0017651485977694392, 0.00805835984647274, -0.005059137474745512, -0.008208290673792362, -0.027706531807780266, -0.051032695919275284, -0.002182362601161003, -0.04361434653401375, -0.024963106960058212, -0.015239277854561806, -0.03548267111182213, 0.008422176353633404, 0.03036040998995304, 0.04365423694252968, 0.017014030367136, 0.038967035710811615, 0.03242510184645653, 0.051630619913339615, 0.011773867532610893, -0.049393072724342346, -0.011890108697116375, 0.01586131565272808, -0.0200570710003376, 0.006388879381120205, -0.006173991598188877, 0.059179309755563736, 0.019704042002558708, 0.009164734743535519, -0.0486893430352211, 0.03965500742197037, 0.00772444624453783, 0.005388977471739054, 0.05739213526248932, -0.012112992815673351, 0.027574118226766586, 0.01249607466161251, 0.014374657534062862, -0.04615463688969612, -0.02942519076168537, -0.025024855509400368, -0.07692590355873108, 0.0012494040420278907, -0.008171726018190384, -0.04149438068270683, 0.009907933883368969, -0.023427221924066544, 0.014645990915596485, -0.028892265632748604, 0.002456854097545147, -0.032713454216718674, 0.021472476422786713, -0.013304042629897594, -0.021327080205082893, -0.02764764428138733, 0.04235697165131569, -0.025638477876782417, 0.010971310548484325, 0.03546791896224022, 0.03534123674035072, 0.012535016052424908, -0.04561500996351242, 0.03805415332317352, 0.01072322390973568, 0.03170258551836014, 0.020000360906124115, -0.018147563561797142, 0.012553871609270573, -0.027165275067090988, -0.007766937371343374, -0.015193721279501915, -0.009558680467307568, 0.05363782122731209, -0.010442680679261684, 0.005297665484249592, -0.016461439430713654, 0.03128337487578392, -0.028404323384165764, 0.0035120032262057066, -0.01218965370208025, 0.01424093171954155, -0.0005704081850126386, 0.020310182124376297, 0.014546914026141167, 0.0223329309374094, -0.03091169148683548, 0.03286401927471161, 0.06519517302513123, -0.01397163886576891, -0.038746483623981476, 0.01723693683743477, -0.04732150211930275, 0.011648140847682953, 0.010720528662204742, -0.017823347821831703, 0.03221524506807327, 0.027874192222952843, -0.0016697935061529279, 0.039957888424396515, 0.023500800132751465, 0.010743235237896442, -0.06956366449594498, -0.059834420680999756, -0.03579383343458176, -0.015564891509711742, 0.025250745937228203, -0.030489597469568253, 0.003339545102789998, 0.026798194274306297, -0.03550830855965614, 0.01915682479739189, 0.031951021403074265, 0.026022201403975487, -0.05358313396573067, 0.03493022173643112, 0.0008273997809737921, 0.015066128224134445, 0.01611742191016674, 0.01624956913292408, 0.004703409504145384, 0.04003506526350975, -0.007578308694064617, -0.04917073994874954, 0.012334048748016357, -0.0002694048744160682, 0.020320720970630646, -0.03095616213977337, 0.05027865990996361, -0.030254175886511803, -0.020640408620238304, 0.03418225422501564, -0.007384998723864555, 0.04072008281946182, 0.03542497381567955, 0.00013828523515257984, 0.01359596848487854, 0.035641271620988846, 0.008442484773695469, 0.011220665648579597, 0.019872235134243965, -0.0011174879036843777, 0.030875971540808678, 0.023438936099410057, -0.02862313948571682, 0.029229719191789627, 0.01680421456694603, -0.015755165368318558, 0.003708879230543971, 0.003233043011277914, -0.061599668115377426, 0.013324564322829247, -0.037054404616355896, -0.017163554206490517, 0.00468836072832346, -0.03465406224131584, 0.03840959072113037, -0.008556131273508072, 0.01225190982222557, -0.0054710316471755505, 0.02118573896586895, -0.0032030229922384024, -0.005869330372661352, -0.02047789841890335, -0.00494049210101366, 0.008989602327346802, 0.020006848499178886, -0.026752430945634842, -0.05028356611728668, -0.017199860885739326, 0.009262783452868462, -0.020826306194067, -0.029182057827711105, 0.04702622815966606, -0.0483560711145401, 0.05079236626625061, -0.01563115045428276, -0.014722539111971855, 0.04880646988749504, -0.03265010938048363, 0.05886400490999222, -0.06205200031399727, 0.016020171344280243, 0.03561453893780708, -0.04057732969522476, -0.05330786481499672, 0.008649788796901703, -0.040815483778715134, 0.016049973666667938, 0.0412956178188324, -0.04063686355948448, 0.00904825609177351, -0.0328742079436779, 0.02665272168815136, 0.02212712913751602, 0.0034092324785888195, 0.050389863550662994, -0.002632622607052326, -0.0000941208636504598, -0.03564324602484703, -0.021853802725672722, 0.01951594091951847, -0.0096116429194808, 0.018758069723844528, -0.01407624315470457, -0.016297785565257072, -0.01476162951439619, -0.02544143982231617, 0.025416728109121323, -0.0034938545431941748, -0.037215374410152435, 0.025464609265327454, 0.009181137196719646, -0.004988610744476318, 0.042002152651548386, 0.0114342225715518, -0.014730910770595074, 0.01020878553390503, -0.032169777899980545, -0.041118964552879333, 0.004193910397589207, -0.0022549910936504602, 0.006399603094905615, -0.04663221538066864, 0.01885777898132801, 0.02028932236135006, -0.004559612832963467, 0.0006511769606731832, 0.04961223527789116, 0.014359857887029648, 0.03282422572374344, -0.020182818174362183, 0.009148845449090004, 0.010677721351385117, -0.07190372049808502, 0.02099604904651642, 0.04541131854057312, 0.02004261314868927, -0.0043302723206579685, -0.02497481368482113, 0.045656368136405945, -0.028949158266186714, -0.004761809948831797, -0.0030167282093316317, 0.043678101152181625, -0.019868474453687668, -0.010325911454856396, 0.050182368606328964, 0.010835313238203526, 0.041243284940719604, 0.018398448824882507, -0.006135494448244572, 0.03100736252963543, -0.03969293460249901, -0.007905799895524979, -0.017352838069200516, 0.02186235599219799, -0.031210700049996376, -0.03573131933808327, 0.006575980689376593, 0.011734801344573498, -0.009354943409562111, -0.0026443686801940203, -0.03741125017404556, -0.02464381419122219, 0.023814035579562187, -0.05438068136572838, 0.00010315988038200885, 0.015531538054347038, 0.059428807348012924, 0.014543709345161915, -0.038305774331092834, -0.014264305122196674, -0.029193606227636337, 0.06808274984359741, 0.021452583372592926, 0.005836941301822662, -0.04667830839753151, -0.010815844871103764, -0.03089318610727787, 0.04030522704124451, -0.008671318180859089, -0.029174525290727615, -0.021243128925561905, 0.017250068485736847, 0.005870348308235407, -0.004420593846589327 ]
<p>I am building a cox survival analysis model with a retailer's transaction data. Almost all the variables have failed the proportionality test. Can I continue with the Cox model? Should I build a LIFEREG model instead of the Cox model?</p>
74,467
[ -0.007590469904243946, -0.024516001343727112, 0.025805825367569923, -0.028312958776950836, 0.036256883293390274, 0.008572356775403023, -0.03578066825866699, 0.0037174250464886427, 0.066106878221035, -0.004249714780598879, 0.044439710676670074, 0.027267178520560265, 0.025862498208880424, 0.014896150678396225, -0.004148404113948345, 0.017155179753899574, -0.006057404447346926, -0.007041141390800476, -0.006530341692268848, 0.024010036140680313, 0.004701864905655384, -0.009622865356504917, 0.013820931315422058, -0.005485477391630411, -0.013085319660604, 0.0543450303375721, 0.05105648189783096, -0.036981988698244095, -0.03562101349234581, 0.03914981335401535, -0.023715516552329063, -0.02317129075527191, 0.0071598538197577, 0.04473070800304413, 0.030093180015683174, 0.05557612329721451, -0.0026353278663009405, -0.039620038121938705, -0.013517593964934349, 0.04750704765319824, -0.007291056681424379, -0.029259037226438522, 0.016463328152894974, 0.062075238674879074, 0.006852902937680483, 0.0181011613458395, -0.012672093696892262, -0.0167087372392416, 0.028178047388792038, -0.020113438367843628, 0.05637834221124649, -0.013196451589465141, 0.039810243993997574, 0.009833655320107937, -0.01802920550107956, -0.020833343267440796, 0.06692183017730713, 0.1099386066198349, -0.013184242881834507, -0.028839847072958946, -0.027565117925405502, -0.03781917691230774, -0.006487867794930935, -0.03935245797038078, -0.01789620891213417, -0.0053494274616241455, 0.028354007750749588, -0.043987587094306946, 0.06421710550785065, 0.02315988950431347, 0.014497239142656326, -0.0034527818206697702, 0.024903370067477226, 0.025845633819699287, -0.029016319662332535, -0.0030695225577801466, 0.0014467221917584538, 0.013794916681945324, 0.03304040804505348, 0.015524654649198055, -0.012684673070907593, 0.004531444516032934, 0.009172601625323296, 0.05233174189925194, -0.013249333947896957, -0.022311324253678322, 0.039681412279605865, -0.00948978029191494, -0.01907169073820114, 0.03601235896348953, -0.015112508088350296, -0.0012700591469183564, 0.04802832379937172, 0.022900333628058434, -0.017958395183086395, 0.048314888030290604, -0.009893118403851986, 0.02870992012321949, 0.008461442776024342, 0.014383498579263687, 0.008859019726514816, -0.0389748141169548, 0.011377428658306599, 0.029630916193127632, 0.018309272825717926, -0.01555747352540493, -0.031506992876529694, -0.01835285872220993, -0.0072804903611540794, -0.028153622522950172, -0.03901008144021034, 0.015372734516859055, -0.015993468463420868, 0.03676757961511612, -0.019549738615751266, -0.00876906979829073, -0.057365406304597855, -0.07329487055540085, 0.10444183647632599, 0.052322205156087875, 0.05318854749202728, -0.0005451705073937774, 0.011285923421382904, -0.025453999638557434, -0.035346198827028275, 0.010637260973453522, 0.022681530565023422, -0.02389354817569256, -0.0594111867249012, 0.07361621409654617, 0.01012496929615736, -0.035151924937963486, 0.04130372405052185, -0.01833825372159481, 0.044262222945690155, 0.016072720289230347, -0.07506569474935532, -0.020971830934286118, 0.013795202597975731, -0.0032096062786877155, -0.03192112594842911, -0.031119203194975853, -0.009041620418429375, 0.04862785339355469, 0.04342828318476677, -0.00447874516248703, 0.06454867124557495, 0.00964418612420559, 0.0192437581717968, 0.006067225243896246, 0.016281617805361748, -0.007690953090786934, -0.029159829020500183, -0.02607121132314205, -0.006206008139997721, -0.09059133380651474, -0.005704117473214865, 0.022755658254027367, 0.01266686711460352, -0.0192123856395483, 0.026998097077012062, 0.00008622893074061722, -0.03402873873710632, 0.0057245842181146145, -0.018822161480784416, -0.023663466796278954, 0.052764277905225754, -0.01788858324289322, 0.04971570894122124, -0.009088292717933655, 0.011723754927515984, 0.03510159254074097, 0.0275216493755579, 0.04500364512205124, 0.0647696703672409, 0.032803744077682495, 0.018714452162384987, 0.011366561986505985, 0.01004770491272211, 0.03757398948073387, -0.06879258900880814, 0.0033603732008486986, -0.02394966594874859, -0.02860427275300026, 0.015244618058204651, -0.016558105126023293, -0.0007460427586920559, -0.023932715877890587, 0.04732972010970116, -0.006287264171987772, -0.04424503818154335, -0.05338280647993088, -0.010211104527115822, -0.008310523815453053, -0.015112463384866714, -0.009775294922292233, 0.013412075117230415, -0.03383566439151764, -0.023454736918210983, -0.01695946231484413, -0.03264206275343895, -0.024074658751487732, 0.02074533700942993, -0.03969204053282738, -0.0012302094837650657, 0.008610165677964687, 0.06714221090078354, -0.03128216788172722, 0.0034790681675076485, -0.03830096498131752, -0.027236610651016235, -0.0012800623662769794, 0.018782127648591995, 0.03449709340929985, -0.006343049928545952, -0.014102641493082047, 0.0053878105245530605, 0.009536867029964924, -0.021827487275004387, 0.05800550431013107, -0.03927577659487724, 0.023938296362757683, 0.06177467107772827, -0.0013666792074218392, 0.0025110600981861353, -0.011333431117236614, 0.016377035528421402, 0.024569232016801834, 0.014442573301494122, -0.0016351960366591811, -0.023184001445770264, 0.03196769952774048, -0.007056105881929398, -0.013730546459555626, 0.004375565331429243, 0.04602201282978058, 0.06983133405447006, 0.025644024834036827, 0.0007596955401822925, 0.005691996775567532, 0.05466669052839279, -0.020645365118980408, 0.029894869774580002, -0.0034178534988313913, -0.0119923772290349, -0.008078387007117271, 0.012976986356079578, 0.009774980135262012, 0.016672316938638687, -0.026255521923303604, 0.011443647556006908, 0.04425729811191559, 0.024581285193562508, 0.0028871644753962755, 0.0004674641531892121, -0.03514578565955162, 0.028047868981957436, -0.007363333832472563, 0.012577169574797153, 0.04648051783442497, 0.004497982095927, 0.007436560001224279, 0.016761956736445427, -0.024677850306034088, -0.0184019785374403, 0.035669777542352676, -0.04437733814120293, 0.00855193380266428, 0.030914712697267532, -0.04214523360133171, 0.011128837242722511, -0.03917814418673515, -0.046319108456373215, -0.03457364812493324, -0.03164384886622429, 0.050919435918331146, 0.003615010529756546, 0.05632437765598297, -0.014603336341679096, -0.013342088088393211, 0.024044450372457504, -0.027663270011544228, -0.010890625417232513, 0.03183922544121742, -0.042997825890779495, -0.03329688310623169, -0.021793421357870102, -0.029555417597293854, 0.0002573974779807031, 0.005142921581864357, 0.05675302445888519, 0.0378970131278038, -0.01076072733849287, -0.01854930818080902, -0.03660609945654869, -0.014987113885581493, 0.002193761058151722, -0.026524093002080917, -0.024423668161034584, 0.03165822848677635, 0.02354087308049202, -0.05801604315638542, 0.0010414349380880594, -0.05127891153097153, -0.0028000741731375456, 0.0208647008985281, 0.0034193142782896757, 0.02724801003932953, -0.00756202032789588, 0.04478370025753975, 0.018403682857751846, -0.044272515922784805, 0.024673612788319588, -0.10167984664440155, -0.06878504157066345, 0.0360516794025898, -0.016726626083254814, 0.028464600443840027, 0.010907027870416641, 0.017811819911003113, 0.04386775195598602, 0.038049936294555664, -0.0023309432435780764, -0.017909791320562363, -0.023200692608952522, -0.07256016880273819, -0.041654687374830246, -0.009622018784284592, -0.0024825814180076122, 0.03508931025862694, 0.028304671868681908, -0.00040220210212282836, 0.03654187172651291, 0.049153149127960205, 0.010332641191780567, -0.022369159385561943, 0.014997079037129879, 0.019691102206707, -0.005412732716649771, 0.021851196885108948, 0.0384911485016346, -0.014294929802417755, 0.028455112129449844, 0.017221741378307343, 0.018271848559379578, 0.02071346528828144, -0.05434463545680046, -0.0191960372030735, -0.03696518391370773, 0.008515559136867523, 0.009287037886679173, 0.00423720758408308, 0.015342514030635357, -0.04892904311418533, -0.030066339299082756, 0.02213934436440468, 0.06404922902584076, -0.02219942770898342, -0.00009152128041023389, 0.01853032410144806, 0.005736041348427534, 0.00251639261841774, -0.004478348419070244, -0.018134888261556625, -0.020723892375826836, 0.005901352036744356, -0.0127512626349926, -0.024180524051189423, 0.008830390870571136, 0.016389669850468636, 0.06152515485882759, 0.00723032932728529, -0.07906574010848999, -0.0018740068189799786, -0.054385099560022354, -0.0024495769757777452, -0.016212360933423042, 0.03321368619799614, 0.010950885713100433, 0.0021418468095362186, 0.015569598414003849, -0.028024425730109215, -0.01927429623901844, -0.004415924660861492, -0.03266899287700653, 0.027545753866434097, -0.0257028266787529, 0.005372197832912207, 0.024878161028027534, -0.025029685348272324, 0.024229085072875023, -0.0349968820810318, -0.00020973071514163166, -0.015561104752123356, 0.022032354027032852, 0.023180030286312103, 0.024780934676527977, -0.02595311403274536, -0.027396632358431816, 0.020722253248095512, -0.018980929628014565, 0.0371042862534523, 0.028386130928993225, 0.00795922614634037, 0.05828297883272171, 0.035206861793994904, -0.009514729492366314, 0.009145899675786495, -0.006494247820228338, 0.04795927554368973, 0.05037461593747139, 0.013274585828185081, 0.01779082976281643, -0.05453958734869957, 0.010351022705435753, 0.012456034310162067, 0.030511170625686646, 0.0482277050614357, -0.011249697767198086, -0.0426311194896698, -0.02973966673016548, -0.027319397777318954, 0.0025001277681440115, 0.0024283593520522118, 0.03981265053153038, -0.03327608481049538, 0.061614740639925, 0.011485974304378033, -0.04868630692362785, -0.010846054181456566, 0.03420448675751686, 0.045844271779060364, -0.05188946798443794, 0.011048724874854088, -0.015165196731686592, 0.011205342598259449, -0.048649806529283524, 0.038851190358400345, 0.029264921322464943, -0.016946742311120033, -0.00016244118160102516, 0.01675061322748661, 0.010259078815579414, -0.015546473674476147, -0.0017294493736699224, 0.036430343985557556, 0.027925176545977592, 0.015898525714874268, -0.03407172113656998, 0.02829725295305252, 0.01925150491297245, 0.01594015769660473, 0.04916558787226677, 0.029312655329704285, -0.10876750200986862, 0.04685095697641373, 0.038683101534843445, 0.04733141511678696, -0.009778433479368687, -0.05196986719965935, -0.03478454053401947, -0.039120152592659, 0.02589401602745056, -0.05938766524195671, 0.0217886995524168, 0.014519592747092247, -0.010821115225553513, -0.041795141994953156, -0.06007221341133118, -0.03171190619468689, 0.036174334585666656, -0.006211904808878899, -0.0228368379175663, -0.0006343636778183281, -0.021482784301042557, 0.014863396994769573, 0.01252933219075203, 0.015774862840771675, 0.019988637417554855, -0.02558845840394497, 0.0006054277764633298, 0.012973894365131855, 0.034469544887542725, -0.036020975559949875, -0.031021492555737495, 0.03785151615738869, -0.0004596445942297578, -0.019485188648104668, 0.05518826097249985, 0.009729410521686077, -0.018499474972486496, 0.036097846925258636, 0.009481500834226608, -0.014937853440642357, 0.0009086665231734514, -0.015169941820204258, 0.033457767218351364, -0.003134598955512047, -0.010913623496890068, 0.05802025645971298, 0.025615517050027847, -0.015026620589196682, -0.006287105847150087, -0.03700483962893486, -0.008336897008121014, -0.03650740161538124, -0.005143383517861366, -0.03943479433655739, 0.002322013257071376, 0.00560603104531765, -0.010390017181634903, -0.0089141009375453, 0.04971933737397194, -0.024755271151661873, 0.02775505743920803, 0.05795075744390488, 0.004065531771630049, 0.014130945317447186, 0.0009578587487339973, 0.02124175615608692, 0.011264761909842491, -0.037451960146427155, -0.019138116389513016, 0.00910337083041668, -0.04257379099726677, -0.006790634244680405, 0.012425451539456844, -0.029506776481866837, 0.0239070113748312, -0.023242702707648277, -0.0288741122931242, -0.013316436670720577, 0.009924919344484806, 0.04798012599349022, 0.014919949695467949, 0.009766598232090473, 0.012471643276512623, -0.007820184342563152, 0.01711835339665413, 0.028058558702468872, -0.017474312335252762, 0.04272501915693283, -0.014741424471139908, 0.10329309105873108, -0.01162885595113039, -0.0003419458807911724, -0.09013275802135468, -0.03605714067816734, 0.017569804564118385, 0.017278192564845085, -0.03685246407985687, -0.006134165916591883, 0.03189733251929283, -0.033335089683532715, -0.025115083903074265, -0.02276141382753849, 0.030516598373651505, -0.027462759986519814, 0.0027499785646796227, -0.032859642058610916, 0.03890247270464897, 0.0833892896771431, -0.009755604900419712, 0.0022460194304585457, 0.040254946798086166, -0.01849532313644886, -0.02225336618721485, -0.00313512678258121, -0.016389217227697372, -0.023059815168380737, -0.03397975489497185, -0.04093187302350998, 0.018909910693764687, 0.046067576855421066, -0.00904836691915989, -0.008318059146404266, -0.00893139187246561, -0.014700745232403278, 0.02833932265639305, -0.02297387644648552, -0.002070990391075611, 0.0295841284096241, -0.021578384563326836, -0.027483420446515083, 0.008946284651756287, 0.023896200582385063, 0.0031773876398801804, 0.016369018703699112, -0.01707017794251442, 0.01140099298208952, 0.03585108742117882, 0.04175689071416855, -0.016003021970391273, 0.024090318009257317, 0.012896479107439518, -0.04688381403684616, 0.01384626142680645, -0.01239591185003519, -0.023458518087863922, 0.0008267082157544792, 0.039901942014694214, -0.05915169045329094, -0.06328244507312775, -0.028249623253941536, 0.005393330939114094, 0.037073586136102676, -0.02316088229417801, 0.0297706201672554, -0.004009007941931486, -0.00877691712230444, -0.032013487070798874, -0.007450138218700886, -0.03257753327488899, 0.005077768582850695, -0.0026415151078253984, 0.0640932247042656, -0.019115328788757324, -0.009377820417284966, 0.043436240404844284, 0.031844452023506165, -0.00588528485968709, 0.04975178465247154, 0.020549649372696877, -0.03136579319834709, 0.03617009148001671, -0.002879531355574727, -0.0527874156832695, -0.0012052091769874096, -0.05874314904212952, 0.033978186547756195, -0.05558225139975548, -0.04237935319542885, 0.027153143659234047, 0.04557948186993599, -0.032528895884752274, -0.029479486867785454, -0.014704082161188126, -0.04769858717918396, -0.008383175358176231, -0.0012712664902210236, 0.01232591550797224, 0.045706551522016525, 0.017331616953015327, 0.04270486906170845, 0.018558021634817123, 0.03382942080497742, -0.01857917383313179, -0.07453496009111404, -0.021236184984445572, 0.003479447215795517, -0.02771151065826416, 0.0428265705704689, -0.00016896722081582993, 0.020623940974473953, -0.0263165682554245, -0.02974516712129116, -0.020012708380818367, -0.04388514906167984, 0.0499359555542469, -0.019547725096344948, 0.04286039620637894, 0.026689304038882256, 0.01795840635895729, 0.023359838873147964, 0.013473971746861935, 0.13696537911891937, 0.05573106184601784, 0.037157755345106125, -0.028950227424502373, 0.02822236716747284, -0.0006924016051925719, 0.011575824581086636, -0.02412993088364601, 0.014798065647482872, 0.02268679253757, -0.034061480313539505, 0.07392387092113495, 0.032513327896595, -0.054225075989961624, 0.028750179335474968, 0.0668897032737732, -0.00918940082192421, -0.037305865436792374, 0.016109524294734, 0.010533095337450504, 0.01174090150743723, -0.03059549257159233, -0.009025704115629196, 0.006190549582242966, 0.010474747978150845, -0.043142326176166534, 0.01349648367613554, -0.008625341579318047, -0.0012073635589331388, 0.020827528089284897, -0.010230554267764091, -0.00947317574173212, 0.006286475341767073, 0.03458022326231003, -0.022681474685668945, -0.012469438835978508, 0.0068831066600978374, -0.023125970736145973, -0.007595670875161886, 0.0546271987259388, -0.010532703250646591, 0.011638343334197998, 0.01293135154992342, 0.0044198473915457726, -0.07103754580020905, -0.013325290754437447, -0.03589949756860733, 0.0028542291838675737, -0.005929007660597563, 0.04261964559555054, -0.03884298726916313, -0.025590049102902412, -0.0206848606467247, -0.03576584905385971, -0.014180542901158333, 0.024156952276825905, 0.040114548057317734, -0.007874221540987492, -0.04114995151758194, -0.03275161236524582, -0.033586882054805756, -0.0019471130799502134, 0.04293154180049896, 0.029428811743855476, -0.03911695256829262, 0.016868354752659798, -0.052848272025585175, 0.029368368908762932, -0.025699522346258163, 0.015494599007070065, 0.02207411453127861, 0.000521923357155174, 0.0018089116783812642, -0.009709016419947147, 0.023620296269655228, 0.029079731553792953, 0.027918539941310883, -0.04633975028991699, 0.00787594635039568, -0.04947870597243309, -0.06615924835205078, 0.023861177265644073, -0.033688295632600784, -0.028946906328201294, -0.06130976229906082, 0.026245148852467537, 0.012782503850758076, 0.06324153393507004, -0.01550365425646305, 0.031595587730407715, -0.020452503114938736, 0.046020008623600006, 0.0025530876591801643, -0.05164194852113724, -0.00034615598269738257, -0.03735274448990822, -0.030249537900090218, 0.011592894792556763, -0.03488278388977051, 0.09681408852338791, 0.007563997991383076, 0.030593710020184517, -0.015280632302165031, 0.002869789255782962, 0.004067220725119114, 0.026008063927292824, 0.023806387558579445, -0.04887852445244789, -0.011300178244709969, 0.035151563584804535, 0.044581055641174316, -0.010401359759271145, -0.06482713669538498, -0.018165992572903633, -0.044095512479543686, 0.03607626631855965, -0.018074864521622658, -0.008225065656006336, -0.014248727820813656, -0.045777302235364914, 0.04582856595516205, -0.03183712810277939, 0.006632108706980944, -0.034933872520923615, -0.000007453481430275133, -0.007353567518293858, -0.045244306325912476, 0.002973935566842556, -0.007847439497709274, 0.0014258937444537878, 0.037269867956638336, 0.016763731837272644, 0.04891825094819069, -0.009327160194516182, -0.035139765590429306, -0.0030614440329372883, 0.014240715652704239, 0.06352432072162628, -0.02535356394946575, 0.0050630513578653336, 0.04514806717634201, -0.025111176073551178, -0.02825632318854332, 0.00485537713393569, 0.01269217487424612, 0.03152903914451599, -0.01633455604314804, 0.006767190061509609, -0.02285708673298359, 0.0077066970989108086, -0.03624618425965309, -0.016686510294675827, -0.02391219697892666, 0.012718908488750458, 0.01816043071448803, 0.015711946412920952, 0.013155067339539528, 0.019086424261331558, -0.035561129450798035, 0.022339683026075363, 0.040225349366664886, 0.019818011671304703, -0.011764938943088055, -0.016350582242012024, 0.008818176575005054, 0.014256403781473637, 0.015546968206763268, -0.006823578849434853, 0.029246900230646133, 0.018680473789572716, -0.015675432980060577, 0.022640572860836983, -0.004506699275225401, -0.017798559740185738, -0.07683756947517395, -0.00917042326182127, 0.024788975715637207, 0.017147134989500046, 0.029146509245038033, -0.007951267063617706, -0.006863626651465893, 0.0004303283058106899, -0.06557642668485641, 0.02339429035782814, -0.008561077527701855, -0.022214055061340332, -0.052242301404476166, 0.00033132772659882903, 0.00878570694476366, 0.017302580177783966, 0.037288762629032135, 0.04405326396226883, 0.01622987538576126, 0.031096473336219788, 0.015560092404484749, -0.02197391167283058, -0.016675766557455063, 0.01432984322309494, -0.04051161929965019, -0.056722965091466904, 0.052801765501499176, -0.06884374469518661, -0.04921499267220497, -0.0047237626276910305, -0.031829409301280975, 0.046403512358665466, 0.02061551809310913, 0.001168516231700778, 0.01343238539993763, 0.00442596385255456, 0.0758969858288765, 0.007994206622242928, 0.0013520973734557629, -0.03532866761088371, 0.010077630169689655, 0.03581549599766731, -0.03014512173831463, 0.0438494049012661, 0.029380276799201965, -0.01780318096280098, -0.019372455775737762, 0.008916378952562809, 0.019645022228360176, -0.0292950626462698, 0.0001461051288060844, 0.038147952407598495, 0.01213429681956768, -0.014865911565721035, 0.017810294404625893, -0.047638848423957825, -0.01482568308711052, 0.052281592041254044, 0.026327025145292282, 0.002661625389009714, 0.01787097565829754, -0.012401150539517403, -0.006801540497690439, 0.01692488230764866, 0.013034971430897713, -0.019188635051250458, -0.05826464295387268, 0.004286804236471653, -0.03881055489182472, -0.001994692487642169, -0.05073104798793793, -0.018291562795639038, -0.03496679291129112, 0.06847058981657028, -0.009457732550799847, 0.038551099598407745, 0.05968538299202919, 0.015044276602566242, 0.018226806074380875, -0.09284450858831406, 0.0473003052175045, -0.002728826832026243, 0.0034814004320651293, -0.0331956222653389, -0.03860115259885788, -0.021291302517056465, -0.015137818641960621, 0.08940432220697403, -0.013783874921500683, 0.03008756972849369, 0.004591392353177071, -0.00022954121232032776, -0.024137936532497406, -0.03609327971935272, 0.018113858997821808, -0.042307622730731964, -0.018954867497086525, -0.03731723874807358, 0.030583782121539116, -0.013607370667159557, -0.027067821472883224, -0.027884040027856827, -0.02742408961057663, 0.002881200285628438, 0.019399534910917282, -0.0032910106237977743, 0.016895702108740807, -0.017844494432210922, -0.028992297127842903, 0.024764133617281914, 0.013897780328989029, 0.02977553941309452, 0.022721493616700172, -0.03196163475513458, -0.05919180437922478, 0.0634215697646141, -0.04921520873904228, -0.012794542126357555, 0.006281836424022913, 0.0075987172313034534, -0.012433376163244247, -0.034332524985075, -0.037807151675224304, 0.06828200817108154, -0.015274525620043278, 0.03699211776256561, 0.0064567504450678825, -0.004676363430917263, 0.025123508647084236, -0.01537171471863985, -0.0064588431268930435, 0.011031003668904305, -0.03648148849606514, 0.009348444640636444, -0.01482167188078165, 0.023946814239025116, -0.013726003468036652, -0.015138463117182255, 0.020225128158926964, -0.01475186925381422, -0.012303410097956657, -0.019376391544938087, 0.005714469589293003, -0.028616173192858696, 0.007051671855151653, -0.010718848556280136, -0.006193619221448898, -0.003983015194535255, 0.008183193393051624, -0.01929294317960739, 0.03492440655827522, -0.004868841264396906, 0.0029431923758238554, -0.0407540388405323, -0.025408225134015083, 0.00011328351683914661, 0.03734675049781799, 0.0433390811085701, 0.033229727298021317, -0.03507581725716591, 0.027587028220295906, -0.01256607472896576, 0.018947172909975052, 0.033986251801252365, -0.011897957883775234, -0.01778283156454563, -0.023089634254574776, -0.010515628382563591, -0.027648936957120895, -0.004175872076302767, -0.02784302644431591, -0.019784269854426384, 0.00986204482614994, 0.025234760716557503, -0.004413748160004616, -0.03856020048260689, -0.036214571446180344, 0.020378660410642624, 0.013315323740243912, -0.022987335920333862, -0.056701887398958206, -0.04137851670384407, -0.0198023933917284, 0.008560992777347565, 0.01683771423995495 ]