question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I am experimenting with a recommendation systems for articles (news, magazines etc). Is there any dataset available for the same which includes the demographic information of users as well? </p> <p>I am actually trying to incorporate demographic information as well in recommending, hence looking for such a dataset. I really don't want to simulate such data as I think real data would give much more interesting insights than simulated one. Anyone aware of such?</p> <p>I found one <a href="http://contest.plista.com/" rel="nofollow">http://contest.plista.com/</a> but unfortunately its has german dataset and demographic information seems to be missing. Would appreciate any information here.</p>
73,626
[ -0.06207353249192238, -0.07370532304048538, -0.003962686285376549, -0.009676418267190456, 0.024345288053154945, 0.0036008234601467848, -0.049940891563892365, -0.03209389001131058, 0.01938287541270256, -0.06330586969852448, 0.03227292373776436, 0.022124750539660454, 0.06211354583501816, 0.028631987050175667, 0.027287164703011513, 0.031216591596603394, -0.014236642979085445, 0.013452143408358097, -0.026324618607759476, 0.019649729132652283, 0.007353236433118582, 0.02012123353779316, 0.011987235397100449, 0.01384212076663971, -0.022596003487706184, 0.021689018234610558, 0.0072937291115522385, -0.024515079334378242, 0.018802965059876442, 0.0245859082788229, -0.028555141761898994, -0.0042661093175411224, 0.0072203753516077995, 0.020084097981452942, 0.04514722898602486, 0.02372880093753338, -0.05138405039906502, -0.002161230193451047, -0.008845237083733082, -0.017107969149947166, -0.0455828420817852, -0.00614136504009366, 0.0023020291700959206, 0.027261730283498764, -0.032739508897066116, 0.024096131324768066, 0.01152687706053257, -0.04398198425769806, 0.013682281598448753, -0.04384081810712814, 0.058575306087732315, -0.003089213976636529, 0.004873314406722784, 0.009817218407988548, -0.014745986089110374, 0.006400909274816513, 0.03723115846514702, 0.05859751999378204, 0.01343705877661705, -0.046170275658369064, -0.004401077516376972, -0.021695176139473915, 0.010889895260334015, -0.03800106421113014, -0.04051312431693077, 0.04517064616084099, -0.015004953369498253, -0.025329040363430977, 0.041866302490234375, 0.0024616126902401447, 0.015223730355501175, 0.03361740708351135, 0.03293844312429428, -0.011714771389961243, 0.006754658184945583, -0.021448783576488495, 0.03150413930416107, 0.00019039494509343058, 0.02825307659804821, 0.010913648642599583, -0.026127170771360397, -0.013944319449365139, 0.009751076810061932, 0.028999263420701027, 0.036892082542181015, -0.024925943464040756, 0.04846755787730217, -0.027548164129257202, -0.022480381652712822, 0.010322446003556252, -0.05051318183541298, -0.009859294630587101, -0.00715653644874692, 0.035389211028814316, -0.04284200444817543, 0.04739830270409584, 0.01745201274752617, 0.04457993432879448, -0.010632726363837719, -0.008034865371882915, 0.00866000447422266, -0.00921605248004198, 0.006990051828324795, 0.07776346802711487, 0.00009825932647800073, -0.02940615825355053, -0.03112930618226528, -0.07295304536819458, -0.0345124714076519, -0.020876159891486168, 0.011103219352662563, -0.02276512421667576, 0.00817055907100439, -0.03330747038125992, 0.003469296731054783, -0.0037245762068778276, 0.0002327690745005384, 0.001461374806240201, 0.03008173778653145, 0.07423427700996399, 0.02341444231569767, 0.007270964793860912, 0.02022639662027359, -0.03501621633768082, -0.03552865982055664, 0.0018887826008722186, 0.04484684392809868, -0.0029882490634918213, -0.03508782759308815, 0.08206845074892044, -0.03581360727548599, -0.016896765679121017, 0.05094117298722267, 0.005035737995058298, 0.037162646651268005, -0.023007569834589958, -0.0766095221042633, -0.038831308484077454, -0.01759883016347885, -0.02695833146572113, 0.01643373817205429, -0.03521448373794556, 0.0050276354886591434, 0.009206095710396767, 0.020828327164053917, 0.023390520364046097, 0.07154779136180878, 0.023642417043447495, 0.022806944325566292, 0.03247770294547081, -0.0345136821269989, 0.021536899730563164, 0.005221886094659567, 0.009771138429641724, -0.003870424348860979, -0.06469493359327316, 0.0471675843000412, 0.013907252810895443, 0.022889206185936928, -0.01555711030960083, 0.014321928843855858, 0.02239687368273735, -0.032900549471378326, -0.00994865968823433, 0.046674977988004684, -0.029545452445745468, 0.05791855975985527, -0.027925802394747734, 0.011097142472863197, -0.0023142918944358826, -0.01119028590619564, 0.025865456089377403, 0.02750413306057453, 0.01692771725356579, 0.04066992923617363, 0.02250736579298973, -0.025136996060609818, -0.005796879529953003, 0.027794335037469864, -0.0020132146310061216, -0.012451186776161194, -0.040549710392951965, -0.02422487549483776, 0.017211750149726868, -0.0032070328015834093, 0.04597491770982742, 0.02450152300298214, -0.003039477625861764, 0.054204877465963364, -0.03413553163409233, -0.003039949107915163, -0.045905787497758865, 0.019361669197678566, 0.002404861617833376, 0.011965564452111721, 0.02970925346016884, 0.02501264028251171, 0.017643604427576065, -0.008655255660414696, -0.052198152989149094, -0.02561350353062153, -0.024815870448946953, 0.02593887224793434, -0.03558686003088951, -0.04506377875804901, 0.031879302114248276, -0.009052268229424953, -0.05939231440424919, 0.045176856219768524, -0.026211006566882133, -0.07070687413215637, -0.0005340664065442979, -0.03546345978975296, 0.03986087441444397, -0.021192999556660652, -0.009637182578444481, 0.0005407639546319842, 0.03968716412782669, -0.004546808078885078, 0.018581606447696686, -0.053001340478658676, 0.0434410534799099, 0.06201867014169693, -0.014049042947590351, 0.004027208779007196, -0.01831398904323578, 0.013281041756272316, 0.009112164378166199, -0.024170106276869774, -0.009442904032766819, -0.056768808513879776, 0.005325264763087034, 0.10359247028827667, 0.0014335459563881159, -0.06619830429553986, -0.01764828898012638, 0.026008566841483116, 0.018354490399360657, 0.043420013040304184, 0.0202711783349514, -0.01688246615231037, -0.04835355654358864, 0.018101241439580917, 0.03419585898518562, 0.0151963597163558, 0.017438067123293877, 0.007445293478667736, -0.009363747201859951, 0.027144156396389008, -0.00594997638836503, -0.00614743260666728, 0.034460172057151794, -0.011644496582448483, -0.015777908265590668, -0.03319273516535759, 0.00039739301428198814, 0.03110908716917038, -0.05387827381491661, -0.013888915069401264, -0.001630347571335733, -0.010615820065140724, 0.010657240636646748, 0.011137084104120731, -0.03813503310084343, 0.0025388547219336033, 0.07227597385644913, -0.020731555297970772, -0.006140980403870344, 0.01465942244976759, -0.05373895540833473, 0.0012373252538964152, 0.008807976730167866, 0.005536011885851622, -0.0263059101998806, 0.06098686158657074, 0.05658663436770439, 0.013000178150832653, -0.023324191570281982, -0.0033188527449965477, -0.04609237611293793, 0.018650852143764496, -0.00420199753716588, -0.01758650131523609, 0.01750269904732704, -0.051402799785137177, -0.016670526936650276, 0.01653054542839527, -0.015449008904397488, 0.037026770412921906, 0.031736213713884354, -0.009780315682291985, 0.03236984461545944, -0.015134735964238644, -0.025620155036449432, -0.022453580051660538, -0.0289967842400074, 0.023512544110417366, -0.034212660044431686, 0.0105112474411726, -0.006506797391921282, 0.03321142494678497, -0.04569856449961662, 0.0024414737708866596, -0.01792573183774948, -0.06395619362592697, -0.032951828092336655, -0.009758456610143185, 0.023651570081710815, 0.000556487706489861, 0.019990233704447746, 0.02322501316666603, 0.015530196949839592, -0.0007307365885935724, -0.0749344602227211, -0.05396321788430214, 0.06942479312419891, -0.00007687273318879306, 0.02785506471991539, 0.03172195702791214, 0.016870815306901932, 0.03858645260334015, 0.013123907148838043, -0.03824896365404129, -0.07578255981206894, -0.027193773537874222, -0.03777426853775978, -0.02919938787817955, 0.020127693191170692, 0.03862714767456055, -0.008931088261306286, 0.018398607149720192, 0.004985047969967127, 0.012486514635384083, 0.034152161329984665, -0.00669123837724328, 0.03840140625834465, 0.01982380449771881, -0.012317740358412266, -0.0007284695166163146, 0.042621809989213943, 0.05232249200344086, -0.05058164522051811, 0.017428554594516754, -0.02198927104473114, 0.05705532431602478, 0.025671664625406265, -0.051813773810863495, 0.007762467954307795, -0.006790183950215578, -0.010752204805612564, -0.006578165106475353, -0.006199037656188011, -0.026070907711982727, -0.036597345024347305, -0.03362777456641197, 0.0526350699365139, 0.010045992210507393, -0.020574159920215607, -0.013292639516294003, 0.06461560726165771, 0.03812970966100693, -0.010357540100812912, 0.006375857628881931, -0.008977124467492104, 0.007330822292715311, -0.014409434981644154, 0.04215151444077492, 0.01028335653245449, 0.01857634447515011, 0.05900290235877037, -0.004629210568964481, 0.03754656761884689, -0.05528737232089043, 0.058077260851860046, -0.09263640642166138, 0.006601258181035519, -0.04342668503522873, 0.07178346067667007, -0.02287926897406578, 0.04365643858909607, -0.009483556263148785, 0.05433345586061478, -0.016545843333005905, 0.004402626305818558, -0.0562606155872345, 0.012681908905506134, -0.030745120719075203, 0.010095751844346523, 0.006485056132078171, -0.0019768481142818928, 0.01891237683594227, 0.011513645760715008, -0.006962964311242104, 0.011575677432119846, 0.04061763733625412, -0.011450018733739853, 0.005657866597175598, 0.02508554980158806, -0.010204512625932693, 0.02043767459690571, -0.003948318772017956, -0.008868396282196045, -0.01739317923784256, 0.009512940421700478, 0.030303452163934708, 0.009503918699920177, -0.052088141441345215, -0.05954715237021446, 0.024784334003925323, -0.019736314192414284, 0.053584855049848557, 0.03146187961101532, 0.0161687433719635, -0.030873456969857216, 0.02300121635198593, -0.05527857318520546, 0.020151223987340927, 0.048024732619524, 0.029566898941993713, 0.004384771920740604, -0.039724577218294144, -0.020492589101195335, -0.0003200283972546458, -0.021012770012021065, -0.030273977667093277, -0.007726159878075123, 0.02310442551970482, 0.012326827272772789, -0.015575727447867393, -0.030921610072255135, 0.06335534900426865, 0.019796544685959816, 0.03905157744884491, -0.015345671214163303, 0.004454696085304022, -0.006197832059115171, 0.01025154534727335, 0.011141502298414707, 0.03689201548695564, 0.0056257955729961395, -0.0054417564533650875, 0.02325376123189926, -0.033698223531246185, -0.06247442215681076, 0.03329113870859146, 0.02888093702495098, 0.08211216330528259, -0.007094584405422211, -0.03790399059653282, 0.0062097832560539246, 0.06278132647275925, 0.05101442709565163, 0.010328278876841068, 0.006711916066706181, -0.10212620347738266, 0.018990302458405495, 0.06504850089550018, 0.05462471768260002, -0.02648310177028179, -0.0216099601238966, -0.045486100018024445, -0.001231774571351707, 0.04914684221148491, 0.03301602974534035, 0.01043915469199419, -0.025630727410316467, 0.035026490688323975, -0.0014698161976411939, -0.028666064143180847, 0.027686279267072678, -0.02420564368367195, -0.011571650393307209, 0.012738201767206192, -0.009550672955811024, -0.0426412969827652, -0.04331769421696663, 0.033762842416763306, 0.019795743748545647, 0.017613643780350685, 0.003717531217262149, 0.0037160676438361406, 0.025819091126322746, 0.019170386716723442, -0.030001655220985413, -0.06868910044431686, 0.007560580037534237, 0.03324245661497116, -0.007910013198852539, 0.05440366268157959, -0.013930605724453926, 0.0031210912857204676, 0.011194722726941109, -0.011493425816297531, -0.02010592631995678, -0.022533919662237167, -0.062104325741529465, 0.029123125597834587, 0.0026085912249982357, -0.022847825661301613, 0.01641330122947693, 0.050174493342638016, 0.012109991163015366, 0.0005236687138676643, -0.026859547942876816, -0.008244147524237633, -0.00854542013257742, -0.03442360460758209, -0.023720145225524902, -0.03845585882663727, -0.03234747052192688, -0.003236932447180152, 0.01347465068101883, 0.03962792456150055, -0.02019527368247509, -0.013502518646419048, -0.03577597811818123, 0.021813232451677322, -0.011437943205237389, -0.025209849700331688, -0.007761747110635042, 0.012975006364285946, -0.018212269991636276, -0.01635453850030899, 0.034073084592819214, -0.03557313606142998, -0.015984343364834785, 0.02567918226122856, -0.03217647224664688, -0.0033511118963360786, -0.02911607176065445, -0.0353967621922493, -0.009049409069120884, 0.00396786630153656, 0.03401348739862442, -0.02068495564162731, 0.030282000079751015, 0.0517178438603878, -0.06018712371587753, 0.030781541019678116, 0.019131889566779137, 0.010722021572291851, 0.03106306865811348, -0.03569810837507248, 0.03337831050157547, -0.002760303672403097, -0.03484988957643509, -0.052915818989276886, -0.0012734757037833333, 0.03689434379339218, -0.0029429595451802015, -0.051561854779720306, -0.05484708398580551, 0.004736163653433323, -0.005166229791939259, -0.028238847851753235, 0.004625593777745962, 0.04028445482254028, -0.01084201317280531, -0.004537253640592098, -0.024989807978272438, -0.023056937381625175, 0.08309967070817947, 0.016438810154795647, -0.010282247327268124, 0.043127574026584625, 0.03077011927962303, -0.0015463823219761252, -0.035574108362197876, 0.028434133157134056, 0.0006383751751855016, 0.005033472087234259, -0.03452233597636223, -0.0010476255556568503, 0.027040105313062668, -0.03124195523560047, 0.015633555129170418, 0.028805935755372047, -0.025235462933778763, -0.00316220847889781, -0.019057905301451683, -0.018723953515291214, -0.020769884809851646, -0.017787663266062737, -0.05595163255929947, 0.018183808773756027, -0.016364391893148422, 0.028059622272849083, 0.030409857630729675, -0.006089939270168543, -0.028607387095689774, -0.00623413547873497, 0.05815334990620613, -0.02023567073047161, 0.009688129648566246, 0.011293938383460045, -0.032280389219522476, 0.058563411235809326, 0.0010637918021529913, 0.001662719645537436, -0.027422210201621056, 0.03143196925520897, -0.03804754838347435, -0.024952847510576248, -0.03801718354225159, -0.01012854091823101, 0.01614631898701191, -0.018951138481497765, 0.04671647772192955, 0.048077426850795746, -0.007490966934710741, 0.007455146871507168, -0.00405725184828043, 0.01751011423766613, 0.03642329201102257, -0.016122931614518166, -0.011997481808066368, 0.006554897408932447, 0.005643380805850029, 0.014995384961366653, 0.02862624078989029, 0.04055864363908768, 0.03591139242053032, 0.013824592344462872, 0.038307856768369675, 0.02067931741476059, -0.03874761238694191, -0.052256274968385696, 0.021334053948521614, -0.03856950253248215, 0.02736249938607216, -0.023039400577545166, -0.03349468111991882, 0.015031132847070694, 0.018445275723934174, 0.02906722202897072, -0.011650427244603634, -0.018748728558421135, -0.013514583930373192, 0.0034648708533495665, 0.004718524403870106, -0.019694238901138306, -0.009996404871344566, 0.02066202275454998, 0.032075073570013046, 0.028425419703125954, 0.03510155901312828, 0.010169461369514465, -0.07094014436006546, 0.0017067586304619908, -0.05312284082174301, -0.0673276036977768, 0.012010077014565468, 0.026318734511733055, -0.002550800098106265, 0.009779542684555054, -0.05284714326262474, -0.008822505362331867, -0.0006214550812728703, 0.048749297857284546, 0.01801239885389805, 0.055055052042007446, -0.01978953368961811, 0.030824266374111176, 0.009942852891981602, 0.014127734117209911, 0.14270427823066711, 0.10549654811620712, 0.04059036821126938, -0.06049998849630356, -0.0038302107714116573, 0.008347484283149242, -0.028133267536759377, -0.014137782156467438, -0.008495901711285114, 0.009558257646858692, -0.010515797883272171, 0.02974710613489151, 0.03869836404919624, 0.044449422508478165, 0.007726367563009262, 0.048815008252859116, -0.058829814195632935, -0.023736899718642235, 0.05213022232055664, 0.013855249620974064, -0.0008078670362010598, -0.049340248107910156, -0.037160832434892654, 0.01623356156051159, 0.025873789563775063, 0.0061175040900707245, -0.01809762232005596, -0.016949491575360298, 0.021448912099003792, -0.042509108781814575, -0.026873787865042686, -0.00719485804438591, -0.006011271383613348, 0.025241386145353317, 0.01611500047147274, 0.0032138419337570667, -0.003520135534927249, -0.00659322552382946, 0.006528052967041731, 0.03456796705722809, -0.0013248644536361098, 0.013034678995609283, -0.013833211734890938, 0.005306898150593042, -0.03242292255163193, -0.01484477985650301, -0.04223380982875824, 0.008919198997318745, -0.059044525027275085, -0.010885017924010754, -0.02151787467300892, 0.030156424269080162, 0.01701437123119831, -0.002530353842303157, -0.026661662384867668, 0.008653078228235245, 0.03434236720204353, 0.03005731850862503, -0.026383323594927788, -0.026381172239780426, 0.018572241067886353, -0.02338859811425209, 0.0197138674557209, 0.030341850593686104, -0.055256303399801254, -0.007721170783042908, -0.03692818060517311, -0.0004910810384899378, 0.00792090967297554, -0.04696941375732422, -0.0030992908868938684, -0.020823778584599495, -0.0265376977622509, -0.009332720190286636, 0.0005971113569103181, 0.012018337845802307, 0.022243574261665344, -0.011973747983574867, 0.0023092308547347784, -0.03282030671834946, -0.0003806383174378425, 0.01859658770263195, -0.014074742794036865, -0.014380000531673431, -0.019940512254834175, 0.026279142126441002, 0.02921755239367485, 0.016690969467163086, -0.024454666301608086, 0.013877499848604202, -0.0013400287134572864, -0.0004628195601981133, 0.01471728552132845, -0.04375322163105011, -0.02215137518942356, 0.01082569919526577, -0.07058393955230713, 0.037838831543922424, 0.008338689804077148, 0.049556948244571686, 0.0006094069103710353, 0.011744029819965363, 0.018189717084169388, 0.0007794550037942827, -0.02006256766617298, -0.0001800642057787627, 0.0008586843614466488, -0.0791812539100647, -0.011077257804572582, 0.0020141282584518194, -0.025081241503357887, -0.029858112335205078, -0.028256531804800034, -0.006024637725204229, 0.006764143239706755, 0.02975538745522499, 0.007113469764590263, -0.016646036878228188, 0.022426540032029152, -0.018298720940947533, 0.01689799129962921, -0.024226117879152298, -0.006332323420792818, -0.0323387086391449, 0.01362679898738861, -0.026798635721206665, 0.01251757238060236, 0.00015235035971272737, -0.022695137187838554, 0.03072664514183998, 0.024625282734632492, 0.017278775572776794, 0.02885739505290985, -0.04019346088171005, -0.006803652737289667, 0.015142221935093403, -0.010968118906021118, 0.043722979724407196, -0.06057614088058472, -0.049471665173769, 0.06927791237831116, -0.03130374476313591, -0.030522912740707397, 0.020006278529763222, -0.006621761247515678, 0.04796283319592476, 0.0003276433562859893, -0.006374943535774946, 0.011017095297574997, 0.10263641923666, 0.00652683898806572, 0.010179072618484497, 0.036863405257463455, 0.054184187203645706, 0.06794567406177521, 0.020707527175545692, -0.03349712863564491, 0.00033840935793705285, -0.017762387171387672, 0.05048224702477455, 0.0540325902402401, 0.010634238831698895, -0.03826417028903961, -0.02178996428847313, -0.0252893827855587, -0.007600976154208183, 0.018239064142107964, -0.0031556098256260157, 0.048674505203962326, 0.03822609782218933, -0.04936622083187103, -0.016712170094251633, 0.016894595697522163, -0.027176033705472946, -0.06616490334272385, -0.014323856681585312, 0.01771421544253826, 0.011940152384340763, 0.021229339763522148, -0.05095018818974495, 0.032581575214862823, -0.0033766773995012045, -0.033109862357378006, 0.023697717115283012, 0.050711046904325485, -0.00485687842592597, -0.019795170053839684, -0.009844665415585041, -0.035152316093444824, 0.019649656489491463, 0.019062276929616928, 0.04341612383723259, 0.06288082897663116, 0.01180557906627655, -0.01870127022266388, -0.07305318117141724, -0.050213806331157684, 0.008414365351200104, -0.005759752821177244, -0.0455317385494709, 0.030577465891838074, -0.041934385895729065, -0.05680076405405998, 0.053571972995996475, 0.0040648807771503925, 0.0006690470036119223, 0.044802114367485046, 0.024337545037269592, 0.014935808256268501, 0.0411158986389637, 0.07687725126743317, 0.028275294229388237, -0.028177451342344284, -0.0013276629615575075, -0.0007424585055559874, 0.0442817285656929, -0.01324477419257164, 0.02472624182701111, 0.013858789578080177, -0.010596700012683868, -0.009098305366933346, 0.020955270156264305, -0.032313112169504166, 0.006519674323499203, -0.022609718143939972, -0.06611821055412292, 0.025201313197612762, -0.044283684343099594, 0.030510313808918, -0.022133655846118927, -0.01501461397856474, 0.007575080264359713, -0.01493594329804182, 0.0345732644200325, 0.017169367522001266, -0.007231887895613909, -0.052070554345846176, 0.024889884516596794, -0.004016390535980463, 0.0032467935234308243, -0.03592897579073906, -0.005657527595758438, 0.004475537221878767, -0.003938581794500351, -0.04248952120542526, -0.004513154737651348, -0.029951125383377075, 0.046061813831329346, -0.027242660522460938, -0.012432510033249855, 0.02068975195288658, -0.012551763094961643, 0.007854366675019264, -0.06494038552045822, 0.024412985891103745, 0.012456177733838558, -0.004686207044869661, -0.023621883243322372, 0.0006513069965876639, -0.06012988090515137, -0.008491216227412224, 0.024774575605988503, -0.05341320484876633, -0.0034643777180463076, -0.030702555552124977, -0.01372021995484829, 0.019308138638734818, -0.058502838015556335, 0.0486171655356884, -0.021753989160060883, -0.021340470761060715, -0.007118492852896452, 0.012183294631540775, -0.011808781884610653, -0.025626014918088913, 0.0024207348469644785, -0.017647575587034225, -0.02515033446252346, 0.056414566934108734, 0.006566434167325497, 0.030050214380025864, 0.08022553473711014, 0.03462451696395874, 0.006272255443036556, 0.0039846887812018394, 0.004367487039417028, 0.0184091255068779, 0.03775712102651596, -0.05319584533572197, 0.037727102637290955, -0.027788957580924034, 0.005582515615969896, -0.023631293326616287, 0.002312334720045328, -0.03980415314435959, -0.01086306944489479, 0.018670208752155304, 0.033894263207912445, -0.012288260273635387, -0.0018928045174106956, 0.019506320357322693, 0.03368484601378441, 0.01556449569761753, -0.011827334761619568, 0.03894525021314621, 0.016315849497914314, -0.018672088161110878, -0.005069562699645758, -0.015612571500241756, 0.015937918797135353, -0.019732901826500893, 0.008963555097579956, 0.043334875255823135, 0.029089076444506645, 0.06749778240919113, -0.006002566311508417, 0.03909970074892044, -0.0031225490383803844, -0.001180335646495223, 0.012734748423099518, 0.020893827080726624, 0.011149514466524124, 0.03494071587920189, -0.012911655940115452, 0.052175991237163544, -0.02139938995242119, 0.023459648713469505, -0.07127398252487183, 0.012164590880274773, -0.05219898372888565, 0.009995236061513424, -0.018839528784155846, -0.014553721994161606, -0.007728462107479572, 0.009683901444077492, 0.023356875404715538, -0.007780476938933134, 0.0466708280146122, -0.030956918373703957, 0.02868942730128765, -0.010862106457352638, 0.001173222903162241, -0.01056274026632309, -0.017079276964068413, 0.005320955533534288, 0.003776824800297618, 0.015367932617664337, 0.024431249126791954, 0.01600775495171547, -0.04153831675648689, -0.001349912490695715, -0.024710683152079582, 0.004238081630319357, -0.04911274462938309, -0.0016427944647148252, -0.05876029655337334, -0.009731816127896309, -0.01804761402308941, 0.008746634237468243 ]
<p>I have a problem that I can't seem to solve:</p> <p>The prior: $\beta_h \sim \mathcal{N}(\bar{\beta},D)$.</p> <p>Somehow the posterior is $\beta_h \sim \mathcal{N}(M, \Omega)$, where $M=(D^{-1}+X'X)^{-1}(D^{-1}\bar{\beta}+X'p)$ and $\Omega=(D^{-1}+X'X')^{-1}$, where $X$ is a data matrix and $p$ is a data vector.</p> <p>How can I prove $M$ and $\Omega$ are as such? What would be the likelihood function? I have 7 similar 'derive' questions that make no sense to me.</p>
73,627
[ -0.02622062712907791, 0.017077479511499405, 0.024423131719231606, -0.016484228894114494, 0.022572455927729607, 0.010252169333398342, -0.03125889226794243, 0.024341432377696037, 0.02695554681122303, -0.054052408784627914, 0.010303192771971226, 0.042009349912405014, 0.09251203387975693, -0.00290334178134799, 0.03153779357671738, 0.023324282839894295, -0.013784549199044704, 0.03183501586318016, 0.00046016849228180945, -0.014751455746591091, 0.03985574096441269, 0.026389257982373238, 0.027951791882514954, -0.007829105481505394, -0.008392768912017345, 0.036263205111026764, 0.01734040677547455, -0.028289703652262688, -0.021092208102345467, 0.08015280961990356, -0.010799364186823368, -0.040607620030641556, 0.02709619700908661, 0.03853648155927658, -0.01998300664126873, -0.005716328509151936, -0.05266881361603737, -0.023853596299886703, -0.007048876490443945, 0.05834994465112686, -0.013296667486429214, -0.04070695489645004, -0.01746232993900776, 0.07648280262947083, -0.04475798085331917, 0.004900013096630573, 0.042490214109420776, -0.01260282564908266, 0.025335805490612984, -0.041310716420412064, 0.0696817934513092, 0.0019018983002752066, 0.041075896471738815, 0.06253956258296967, -0.02127484604716301, -0.01794211007654667, 0.035731878131628036, 0.05999422073364258, 0.034563206136226654, -0.05174098163843155, -0.016535548493266106, -0.06232278421521187, 0.025921355932950974, -0.04007803276181221, -0.021248886361718178, 0.030608171597123146, 0.016149330884218216, 0.0027579818852245808, 0.03502558171749115, -0.035802047699689865, 0.0325559638440609, 0.022401854395866394, 0.009106657467782497, -0.013450062833726406, -0.022753149271011353, -0.019960250705480576, 0.006324038840830326, 0.06591057777404785, 0.04333454743027687, 0.010599536821246147, 0.027653248980641365, -0.009356461465358734, 0.028505677357316017, 0.034089356660842896, -0.015966802835464478, -0.008078359998762608, 0.08492522686719894, -0.001657293876633048, 0.013034824281930923, -0.00896370504051447, -0.016121074557304382, 0.0008485441212542355, 0.030358534306287766, -0.03277105465531349, -0.01651492342352867, 0.04430585354566574, -0.0052908072248101234, 0.05450639873743057, 0.008594129234552383, -0.03477545455098152, -0.03819052875041962, -0.04007181152701378, 0.028254162520170212, 0.014385038986802101, -0.037302758544683456, -0.017163515090942383, -0.028238821774721146, 0.048772722482681274, -0.022048819810152054, -0.015341908670961857, -0.02645762637257576, 0.06787968426942825, -0.016806432977318764, -0.008643683977425098, -0.03269857168197632, -0.04127097874879837, -0.0006894238758832216, -0.019554203376173973, 0.06159185618162155, 0.06477569788694382, 0.01762518472969532, -0.019628779962658882, 0.02319333516061306, -0.02284366264939308, -0.07874862104654312, -0.005941797513514757, 0.0018768733134493232, -0.02423788234591484, -0.008773421868681908, 0.03461938723921776, -0.017542948946356773, -0.025024840608239174, 0.034255657345056534, 0.0487673394382, 0.0030610323883593082, 0.007020754273980856, -0.08839042484760284, -0.04916641116142273, 0.013408000580966473, -0.007715079467743635, -0.007261749356985092, -0.05814775824546814, 0.0010583661496639252, 0.07862884551286697, 0.05892781913280487, -0.016199860721826553, 0.027981890365481377, 0.029564524069428444, 0.01930900476872921, -0.002481143455952406, -0.030383404344320297, -0.06032369285821915, -0.03880159929394722, -0.009687047451734543, -0.03957296535372734, -0.059837114065885544, 0.02147834748029709, -0.009471789933741093, 0.0017211862141266465, -0.02749570459127426, 0.062247615307569504, 0.009822403080761433, -0.024224022403359413, -0.005833572708070278, -0.0029612225480377674, -0.04428737983107567, 0.08293812721967697, 0.002669721143320203, -0.003139141947031021, 0.03373810276389122, -0.020023295655846596, 0.025873789563775063, -0.015632880851626396, 0.056548286229372025, 0.04522348567843437, -0.02050580270588398, -0.04185256361961365, 0.005976962856948376, 0.014070112258195877, 0.0228972639888525, -0.02155759185552597, -0.01481870748102665, -0.011558298952877522, -0.01887623593211174, 0.015645554289221764, 0.026923157274723053, -0.008064829744398594, -0.01432113628834486, 0.009910703636705875, -0.03309909626841545, -0.019916091114282608, -0.06998363882303238, -0.002067923778668046, -0.020309941843152046, -0.014642978087067604, 0.017463363707065582, 0.024046756327152252, 0.009593813680112362, 0.02176704630255699, -0.043482765555381775, -0.013912703841924667, -0.03925936669111252, 0.027690155431628227, -0.04318331554532051, -0.0000623936575721018, 0.06021610274910927, 0.0582304447889328, -0.0007109632133506238, 0.0535183884203434, -0.02159920334815979, -0.03549392521381378, 0.010462136007845402, -0.019028490409255028, -0.00020293000852689147, -0.007104094605892897, -0.03679142892360687, -0.0007224820437841117, -0.030127186328172684, -0.009903197176754475, 0.00871241930872202, -0.032011713832616806, 0.05121713504195213, 0.07409442961215973, 0.007271090522408485, -0.017239516600966454, 0.005693306215107441, 0.03387518972158432, 0.037028584629297256, -0.02144295908510685, -0.001551610417664051, -0.026609331369400024, 0.005089599173516035, 0.0515102781355381, 0.026155313476920128, -0.04622938483953476, 0.028024952858686447, -0.0011912502814084291, 0.02714245207607746, 0.022685755044221878, 0.0022369634825736284, 0.005600367207080126, -0.023987289518117905, -0.006809793878346682, -0.0049810223281383514, -0.007022829260677099, -0.0001789915404515341, 0.03487963229417801, 0.028683630749583244, 0.052513979375362396, -0.00038533355109393597, -0.0005210789386183023, 0.06533195823431015, -0.01766442321240902, 0.003937830682843924, -0.03582284227013588, -0.004512169864028692, 0.035840846598148346, 0.0056497869081795216, 0.015584946610033512, 0.028369320556521416, -0.004980727564543486, 0.024159962311387062, -0.005233705509454012, 0.002609542803838849, 0.020398413762450218, 0.04577142000198364, -0.048281632363796234, -0.001935326959937811, 0.021130641922354698, -0.030753707513213158, 0.03541701287031174, -0.01496095396578312, -0.033562302589416504, 0.003604963654652238, -0.007164435461163521, 0.009355688467621803, 0.027024811133742332, 0.009341983124613762, -0.03425026312470436, -0.04808848723769188, -0.007860162295401096, -0.023289643228054047, 0.021726297214627266, 0.02841883711516857, -0.062090061604976654, -0.009800084866583347, -0.05825570598244667, -0.0048189545050263405, 0.0395544171333313, 0.012541172094643116, -0.04953433573246002, -0.009600138291716576, -0.021070536226034164, -0.07018870860338211, -0.06737133115530014, -0.02979160100221634, 0.025247225537896156, -0.045941632241010666, -0.0013960162177681923, 0.014995919540524483, 0.009792431257665157, 0.030438359826803207, 0.037545181810855865, -0.003748454386368394, -0.04208541661500931, -0.015481867827475071, -0.0027437922544777393, 0.005142959766089916, -0.00064759113593027, 0.04512161388993263, 0.007878742180764675, -0.026762960478663445, -0.001008471823297441, -0.051620375365018845, -0.06807108968496323, 0.03272209316492081, 0.033709511160850525, 0.0017028767615556717, 0.018820587545633316, -0.04401408135890961, 0.07327095419168472, 0.0405515693128109, -0.05952848494052887, -0.03228040039539337, 0.03354339674115181, -0.03739744797348976, -0.07722937315702438, 0.03411094471812248, 0.02950889989733696, -0.008216352201998234, 0.0349256657063961, -0.022326910868287086, 0.005916071590036154, 0.03615493327379227, 0.003179281484335661, -0.011923030950129032, 0.04226035997271538, -0.0066293710842728615, 0.0076009915210306644, 0.027689894661307335, 0.0014893271727487445, -0.002863418310880661, -0.004633557982742786, -0.01350882463157177, 0.04515274986624718, -0.013050612062215805, -0.038130879402160645, 0.007896668277680874, -0.01245369017124176, -0.010186606086790562, -0.06532035768032074, 0.05523998290300369, 0.009729194454848766, -0.024306999519467354, 0.014818109571933746, -0.007642315234988928, 0.018363993614912033, -0.02857198938727379, 0.0030427398160099983, 0.0478547066450119, 0.006997580640017986, -0.03717886656522751, 0.00937984324991703, 0.007115860935300589, -0.027082158252596855, 0.008183237165212631, -0.013125600293278694, -0.01757875457406044, 0.054865457117557526, 0.02281554415822029, -0.012726294808089733, 0.008464108221232891, -0.05640789121389389, -0.0011168747441843152, -0.05247678607702255, 0.04968990013003349, -0.00589336734265089, 0.02952389605343342, -0.0011558333644643426, 0.06554394960403442, 0.025622406974434853, 0.01821613684296608, 0.026453230530023575, -0.012773972935974598, -0.05862950161099434, 0.019046524539589882, -0.006959903985261917, -0.006421267054975033, -0.01762189157307148, -0.0118226557970047, 0.05109550803899765, -0.03797755762934685, 0.00031325320014730096, -0.007820622064173222, -0.00508450111374259, -0.05400073900818825, -0.0013875258155167103, -0.05513961985707283, -0.025638556107878685, 0.0073724426329135895, 0.014784734696149826, 0.03526320680975914, 0.022990891709923744, -0.01648755557835102, 0.05629981309175491, 0.007490832358598709, -0.011075678281486034, -0.030540743842720985, -0.013571392744779587, 0.017132429406046867, 0.024376941844820976, 0.03820319101214409, 0.03161833435297012, -0.014856101013720036, 0.05576042830944061, 0.00635542394593358, 0.07428175210952759, 0.04509697109460831, 0.007713897153735161, 0.010074821300804615, -0.016241854056715965, -0.00707648042589426, 0.0030343004036694765, 0.03599782660603523, 0.016087008640170097, 0.014663714915513992, 0.0679129809141159, 0.014155014418065548, -0.020676247775554657, 0.014032093808054924, 0.0592905730009079, 0.012739635072648525, 0.014076744206249714, -0.051409658044576645, 0.004442407749593258, -0.052100785076618195, 0.007614618167281151, 0.004955998621881008, -0.0039050476625561714, 0.0035163310822099447, -0.019296055659651756, 0.014985168352723122, -0.04276229441165924, 0.05202598124742508, 0.013508575037121773, 0.016646960750222206, 0.03652677685022354, 0.03439484164118767, -0.03667420893907547, 0.020817171782255173, 0.044014595448970795, 0.0672227293252945, 0.021595817059278488, 0.0007546179695054889, -0.1049535945057869, 0.018451662734150887, 0.011329734697937965, 0.03591239079833031, -0.02178868278861046, 0.0017496132059022784, -0.05128849670290947, -0.04592573270201683, 0.0407642163336277, 0.009123465977609158, 0.01966085471212864, 0.006708788685500622, 0.00011064133286708966, 0.03166932240128517, 0.01637459173798561, -0.07191701978445053, 0.006994776427745819, 0.019236160442233086, 0.023503994569182396, -0.025531934574246407, 0.007369179278612137, -0.039687223732471466, 0.01692715846002102, 0.020390324294567108, 0.06917672604322433, -0.0001122168469009921, -0.029947424307465553, -0.006609234027564526, 0.033604737371206284, -0.011057169176638126, -0.062375180423259735, 0.02366897463798523, 0.022644300013780594, -0.05722988769412041, 0.03323137015104294, -0.04020242765545845, -0.014385971240699291, 0.052153296768665314, 0.019738519564270973, -0.024548159912228584, 0.03274519741535187, -0.0045499736443161964, 0.030634364113211632, 0.0277424156665802, 0.037319451570510864, 0.06364095211029053, 0.009228486567735672, 0.0020612035878002644, -0.015962595120072365, -0.02085481956601143, -0.005081680603325367, -0.02835254557430744, -0.018581058830022812, -0.06903906911611557, 0.024722162634134293, -0.007940602488815784, 0.020596036687493324, -0.001451988471671939, 0.01746939681470394, 0.005357585847377777, -0.023609064519405365, 0.0173469390720129, 0.05863426253199577, 0.0034474688582122326, -0.001116003724746406, 0.029647821560502052, 0.022192655131220818, 0.02822241000831127, -0.012690399773418903, 0.03643930330872536, -0.007678966503590345, -0.005016552284359932, -0.01740241050720215, -0.027302181348204613, 0.04229908064007759, -0.02247043140232563, -0.014195391908288002, 0.03497355431318283, -0.029359159991145134, 0.009773063473403454, -0.031466126441955566, 0.013536094687879086, 0.012632890604436398, -0.04809428006410599, -0.02248496748507023, -0.007338294293731451, -0.010496046394109726, 0.030183330178260803, -0.0465809591114521, 0.01161287259310484, -0.009884449653327465, 0.009735650382936, -0.048260949552059174, -0.03549528494477272, 0.0004729895736090839, -0.006666416302323341, -0.05211450532078743, -0.02806890569627285, 0.009297683835029602, -0.04891994595527649, -0.03385954350233078, -0.03602370619773865, 0.049671947956085205, -0.010347913019359112, 0.012554663233458996, 0.0036036805249750614, 0.049852773547172546, 0.05922488123178482, -0.020501788705587387, 0.006533666048198938, 0.04217980429530144, -0.008339431136846542, -0.006946350447833538, -0.0030688282568007708, 0.024994272738695145, -0.03311683610081673, 0.021197738125920296, -0.0397702120244503, 0.003059371607378125, 0.0534009113907814, -0.03543861210346222, -0.012875615619122982, 0.02376459538936615, 0.023603670299053192, -0.006871480960398912, -0.041629549115896225, -0.0002846859279088676, -0.0138495322316885, 0.017079148441553116, -0.0012056503910571337, 0.004737251903861761, -0.006653026212006807, -0.01339744869619608, 0.02979547157883644, -0.022856811061501503, 0.002429177053272724, -0.021146487444639206, 0.08117036521434784, -0.03473278880119324, 0.0162477008998394, 0.02802245505154133, 0.019718274474143982, 0.025001658126711845, 0.04186873510479927, 0.004645001608878374, 0.02140916883945465, 0.026904867962002754, -0.06120697036385536, -0.019762910902500153, -0.06979257613420486, 0.060491811484098434, 0.07139258831739426, -0.00034886127104982734, 0.02508300170302391, 0.018855014815926552, 0.013802234083414078, -0.010457324795424938, -0.004626238718628883, -0.03929742053151131, 0.015091336332261562, 0.009216357953846455, 0.04122030362486839, -0.02438954822719097, -0.031019674614071846, 0.02025681547820568, 0.02741280198097229, -0.009344658814370632, -0.005473876837641001, 0.0025764964520931244, 0.010273197665810585, 0.023869479075074196, 0.005587735213339329, -0.04070177674293518, 0.03780103847384453, -0.05202535539865494, 0.02056870236992836, -0.0344720296561718, -0.031393058598041534, 0.03952321037650108, 0.04249197989702225, 0.016349701210856438, -0.04750211164355278, -0.01019273791462183, -0.03313331678509712, 0.029711764305830002, 0.033788375556468964, 0.0026026731356978416, 0.03892778232693672, -0.005368467886000872, 0.04208217188715935, -0.015290961600840092, 0.038020193576812744, -0.002878258703276515, -0.06913784891366959, -0.020037995651364326, -0.024925697594881058, -0.01975424401462078, -0.012029295787215233, 0.010758910328149796, -0.024322958663105965, 0.005903488490730524, -0.027766522020101547, 0.013528008945286274, 0.000980411539785564, 0.008077060803771019, 0.0042782737873494625, 0.052455831319093704, 0.008284959010779858, 0.02756950445473194, -0.0014167327899485826, -0.010952170006930828, 0.11077413707971573, 0.06168408691883087, 0.032593827694654465, -0.05821843445301056, 0.017781229689717293, -0.007606319151818752, 0.011246363632380962, -0.04691220819950104, 0.017760802060365677, -0.005076499190181494, 0.0015176398446783423, 0.004813666455447674, 0.052003830671310425, 0.00778930401429534, 0.022108009085059166, 0.027731657028198242, -0.050100672990083694, -0.024675097316503525, -0.026805175468325615, -0.01913546398282051, -0.04808090627193451, -0.02331387996673584, -0.02821892313659191, 0.02580983005464077, -0.0005644734483212233, -0.02858334220945835, -0.030655818060040474, 0.0020481508690863848, -0.022957446053624153, 0.01120017096400261, 0.00420162919908762, -0.028556065633893013, -0.014749724417924881, 0.0008867325959727168, -0.015073873102664948, 0.0018513754475861788, 0.009032822214066982, -0.011014299467206001, 0.007109237369149923, 0.048880960792303085, 0.0008228698279708624, 0.002387532964348793, 0.0016081652138382196, -0.0017669640947133303, -0.0207337848842144, -0.015114153735339642, -0.03531748801469803, 0.065519779920578, -0.016784261912107468, 0.01651058904826641, 0.01569756492972374, -0.012592136859893799, -0.040293723344802856, -0.06057437136769295, -0.006194649264216423, 0.013249208219349384, 0.039732880890369415, 0.001223215484060347, 0.011684182099997997, -0.02219461463391781, 0.02732553705573082, 0.005124526564031839, 0.010394753888249397, 0.009359910152852535, -0.02491394802927971, -0.03647978603839874, -0.017862854525446892, 0.025759633630514145, -0.022215548902750015, 0.0058791181072592735, -0.013833073899149895, -0.0002365303080296144, -0.0005692319828085601, -0.015961116179823875, 0.016697484999895096, -0.021843062713742256, 0.016404131427407265, 0.002531678881496191, 0.0005406400887295604, 0.024328257888555527, -0.049467284232378006, -0.010506788268685341, -0.04432129114866257, -0.02355705015361309, -0.05691516026854515, 0.025926996022462845, 0.026797063648700714, 0.04415695741772652, 0.016486357897520065, 0.03190808743238449, 0.009338753297924995, 0.03004802204668522, 0.015702972188591957, -0.07197948545217514, -0.04115721955895424, 0.03297297656536102, -0.005441221408545971, 0.019802015274763107, -0.01888265460729599, 0.023014720529317856, 0.035105977207422256, 0.05260758474469185, -0.01668940857052803, 0.021926436573266983, -0.009001007303595543, 0.01986481063067913, -0.022881509736180305, -0.05758707970380783, 0.028762491419911385, -0.00047065853141248226, -0.0017934993375092745, -0.03692519664764404, -0.027769800275564194, -0.03563808277249336, -0.009543237276375294, 0.00459930207580328, -0.0009955578716471791, -0.032298747450113297, 0.001627823687158525, 0.018613029271364212, 0.010551064275205135, -0.01586991176009178, 0.013686411082744598, 0.004649203270673752, 0.002703681355342269, -0.013891485519707203, -0.0069793215952813625, -0.01031852699816227, 0.0026823270600289106, -0.06526470184326172, -0.01892441138625145, 0.0335560217499733, 0.032167233526706696, 0.021906662732362747, -0.03007272072136402, 0.011568303219974041, 0.004961709026247263, 0.023724667727947235, -0.022453511133790016, -0.03232857957482338, 0.04277822747826576, -0.07734023779630661, -0.037723932415246964, 0.02858423814177513, 0.06498067826032639, 0.04216470196843147, 0.019962484017014503, -0.013255635276436806, -0.009326325729489326, 0.028454001992940903, -0.04971074312925339, -0.01392587460577488, -0.006158544681966305, -0.009401916526257992, -0.019524890929460526, 0.0030907418113201857, -0.006090249866247177, 0.01782403327524662, 0.04502874240279198, 0.025983678176999092, 0.04498259350657463, -0.0147712966427207, 0.0016506596002727747, 0.026054637506604195, 0.019118966534733772, 0.013428413309156895, 0.012247933074831963, 0.021729301661252975, -0.003236711025238037, 0.05421193316578865, -0.03226534649729729, 0.03167348727583885, 0.0023427268024533987, 0.002176545560359955, -0.09981024265289307, 0.023417048156261444, 0.01736920326948166, 0.016676411032676697, 0.04973353445529938, -0.06269030272960663, -0.010688968934118748, 0.02544366382062435, -0.03329189494252205, 0.0208424162119627, -0.004863104782998562, -0.0004467510152608156, -0.030368955805897713, 0.013402724638581276, 0.006678361911326647, 0.05468861386179924, 0.016074039041996002, 0.06461463868618011, 0.041437190026044846, 0.013303153216838837, 0.00031289184698835015, -0.02890993468463421, -0.028440551832318306, 0.037249524146318436, 0.01119414996355772, -0.06877781450748444, 0.023016581311821938, -0.02991377003490925, -0.041842661798000336, 0.03492759168148041, 0.006045466288924217, 0.0018206140957772732, 0.028033332899212837, 0.0352652333676815, 0.019417809322476387, 0.028811082243919373, 0.0266676377505064, -0.007909543812274933, -0.004200605675578117, 0.0146245826035738, 0.021428802981972694, 0.018669238314032555, -0.03642435744404793, 0.015137541107833385, -0.008036788552999496, -0.01667449250817299, -0.03778202459216118, 0.01347876712679863, -0.04770025983452797, -0.016934849321842194, -0.010662556625902653, -0.01886567287147045, -0.016518449410796165, -0.034448809921741486, 0.019728807732462883, -0.029554227367043495, 0.00005107121978653595, 0.06031090393662453, 0.010528401471674442, -0.02949979528784752, 0.0076735010370612144, -0.01670899987220764, -0.055632997304201126, 0.029427068307995796, 0.01772855408489704, 0.0025102028157562017, -0.06795811653137207, -0.023163465782999992, -0.00316857872530818, 0.024953361600637436, -0.01347583532333374, -0.014707829803228378, -0.03597572073340416, 0.046519361436367035, -0.026261501014232635, -0.014510571956634521, -0.017466943711042404, -0.028438037261366844, -0.017484256997704506, -0.07920223474502563, 0.04336267337203026, 0.0014665109338238835, -0.0633491799235344, -0.02637479081749916, -0.010344667360186577, -0.03297016769647598, -0.03637475520372391, 0.061634182929992676, -0.027525173500180244, 0.017493056133389473, -0.006482663564383984, 0.001429581898264587, 0.01828054152429104, -0.03906509652733803, 0.03931773453950882, -0.01188237126916647, -0.03409546613693237, -0.012874896638095379, -0.00792444683611393, 0.055680759251117706, 0.016413135454058647, -0.002507037715986371, -0.025262650102376938, 0.018705105409026146, -0.003649648744612932, -0.009078631177544594, 0.013113053515553474, -0.009198819287121296, 0.0017016974743455648, 0.027511147782206535, -0.016936182975769043, 0.012845711782574654, 0.0358247235417366, -0.01349104568362236, -0.03321370854973793, 0.013440397568047047, -0.02367122657597065, -0.047494519501924515, 0.02793656848371029, 0.0018087744247168303, 0.002781960414722562, -0.029543403536081314, -0.04976711794734001, 0.03354708477854729, -0.031027251854538918, 0.000038890688301762566, 0.019916735589504242, 0.006765221245586872, 0.04080982506275177, 0.008230043575167656, 0.002148481784388423, 0.04154964163899422, -0.0075440858490765095, 0.02752603590488434, 0.04209752380847931, 0.05480317026376724, -0.043601371347904205, -0.009288080967962742, 0.03143647685647011, -0.027099469676613808, 0.012953550554811954, -0.02788158319890499, 0.031940609216690063, -0.020704088732600212, -0.013282517902553082, -0.020798858255147934, -0.023413127288222313, -0.02976658195257187, -0.007252355571836233, -0.005666060373187065, 0.05595327541232109, -0.03241262957453728, 0.0017579084960743785, -0.011865380220115185, 0.018957581371068954, -0.07398097217082977, 0.0151844946667552, -0.015561091713607311, 0.028986172750592232, 0.016628218814730644, -0.003825383260846138, 0.011436598375439644, -0.030074376612901688, 0.025290539488196373, -0.03127539902925491, -0.01680171862244606, -0.006309174932539463, -0.008203905075788498, -0.0004705518367700279, -0.02019524574279785, -0.005020986311137676, -0.01659664697945118, 0.022437158972024918, 0.011936905793845654, 0.03760926425457001, -0.03708239272236824, -0.03338072821497917, -0.02770869806408882, 0.023728659376502037, -0.07263252139091492, -0.011021500453352928, -0.048364728689193726, 0.0067338477820158005, 0.03046385571360588, 0.003759637475013733 ]
<p>From what I understand hot deck imputation involves 2 parts</p> <p>1) Choosing the donor pool: This based on variables related to the missing variable. Maybe using a regression technique to test for association or just ask a subject matter expert.</p> <p>2) Choosing the value to be imputed from the donor pool based on characteristics such as distance or through random sampling techniques.</p> <p>For single stochastic imputation the process is</p> <p>1) Determine the distribution of the dataset after listwise deletion of item nonresponding units</p> <p>2) Use stochastic techniques to choose a value from the distribution.</p> <p>Both these processes seem very similar to me. What exactly is the difference between the two ?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,628
[ -0.025022367015480995, -0.03343748301267624, 0.01606868766248226, -0.016608145087957382, -0.003387571545317769, -0.031207796186208725, 0.018177557736635208, -0.017723046243190765, 0.0345725454390049, -0.0030406832229346037, 0.00990920327603817, -0.004563039634376764, 0.03534388914704323, -0.006450079381465912, 0.014920865185558796, 0.027091102674603462, 0.031034430488944054, 0.02023099735379219, 0.011287654750049114, -0.014296583831310272, -0.03316066786646843, 0.003841451834887266, 0.03809623792767525, -0.04229586571455002, -0.043054137378931046, 0.015263032168149948, 0.01592550240457058, 0.006725302431732416, -0.003406670643016696, 0.04351230338215828, -0.05217825993895531, -0.04092370346188545, -0.030107978731393814, 0.01221701130270958, 0.0008910819888114929, 0.014325428754091263, -0.038795240223407745, -0.022940756753087044, -0.010501234792172909, 0.03500538319349289, -0.02291775494813919, -0.012543546967208385, -0.011668489314615726, 0.03504007309675217, 0.0013101203367114067, 0.012123792432248592, -0.0386698842048645, -0.040680501610040665, 0.026501020416617393, -0.041753821074962616, 0.04300380498170853, -0.015408942475914955, 0.04120740666985512, 0.02768307738006115, -0.01022916566580534, -0.005917227361351252, 0.07382814586162567, 0.06907536834478378, -0.04225923866033554, -0.05972171947360039, 0.03247711807489395, 0.005608363542705774, -0.016043834388256073, -0.013676752336323261, 0.010211418382823467, 0.026018956676125526, -0.0024334616027772427, -0.006598939187824726, 0.05950288102030754, -0.023049747571349144, 0.037754859775304794, 0.03217731788754463, 0.05789415165781975, -0.004800031427294016, 0.04849277809262276, -0.04182799905538559, -0.015787623822689056, 0.049508918076753616, 0.040900763124227524, 0.026466459035873413, 0.019208082929253578, -0.015230454504489899, 0.030041802674531937, 0.028703447431325912, -0.00667223846539855, -0.023659968748688698, 0.031821124255657196, -0.0496496707201004, 0.013779680244624615, -0.0021542564500123262, -0.036889951676130295, -0.0013777515850961208, 0.039528485387563705, -0.015573469921946526, -0.04233060032129288, 0.029771391302347183, -0.01763964258134365, 0.049923188984394073, 0.00814028549939394, 0.015106244012713432, -0.004292127676308155, -0.03213324025273323, 0.0007744307513348758, 0.03807934746146202, -0.03361532837152481, 0.009536036290228367, -0.016055211424827576, 0.03804639354348183, -0.007570070680230856, -0.013631108216941357, -0.05762958154082298, 0.04666312783956528, 0.02886923775076866, 0.006783041637390852, 0.065098337829113, 0.0252128466963768, -0.03523954749107361, -0.00467397877946496, 0.044031884521245956, 0.07222045958042145, 0.017627093940973282, -0.0162658654153347, 0.02330181747674942, -0.029818233102560043, -0.03716332092881203, 0.03505578637123108, 0.01034609042108059, 0.0038106103893369436, -0.03527821600437164, 0.04235415533185005, -0.02701004594564438, -0.02432848885655403, 0.09613360464572906, 0.017267975956201553, 0.006783961318433285, -0.006728842854499817, -0.09306041151285172, -0.029366055503487587, 0.017440691590309143, -0.049247607588768005, 0.006152468733489513, -0.03556166961789131, 0.018622275441884995, 0.02242492511868477, 0.027900096029043198, -0.004472776781767607, 0.058274123817682266, 0.0022629343438893557, 0.03767579793930054, 0.03490016981959343, -0.008269865065813065, -0.04071855917572975, -0.02074921689927578, 0.009778483770787716, -0.017328038811683655, -0.05847788229584694, 0.044937584549188614, 0.02102118544280529, -0.017039407044649124, -0.024152953177690506, 0.01537504605948925, 0.035402216017246246, 0.000004453158453543438, 0.010930863209068775, 0.037663187831640244, 0.005366225726902485, 0.0870291069149971, 0.013997395522892475, 0.02961449697613716, 0.02520432323217392, -0.012963253073394299, 0.05041635408997536, 0.031213779002428055, 0.05103175714612007, 0.04639627784490585, -0.019720321521162987, -0.019632119685411453, 0.013050678186118603, 0.014338670298457146, 0.013940786011517048, -0.05263056606054306, 0.002810976468026638, -0.011211618781089783, -0.013986789621412754, 0.020861636847257614, 0.0562276653945446, 0.00879830215126276, -0.0461575947701931, 0.034842099994421005, -0.06170065701007843, -0.05052381381392479, -0.08980312198400497, -0.0016601304523646832, 0.027498744428157806, 0.0040512182749807835, 0.056983962655067444, 0.0016080947825685143, 0.009875809773802757, -0.009428868070244789, -0.00740225613117218, -0.026333142071962357, -0.03588646650314331, 0.010638667270541191, -0.020390504971146584, -0.009332723915576935, 0.05980651080608368, 0.008428741246461868, -0.023881960660219193, 0.037782859057188034, -0.05102430656552315, -0.06742672622203827, 0.006915124598890543, -0.06527191400527954, 0.048319701105356216, -0.03557990863919258, -0.017402319237589836, -0.005955223925411701, -0.031447213143110275, -0.013529683463275433, 0.013050262816250324, -0.07100345194339752, 0.07569602876901627, 0.0750124529004097, 0.000024359289454878308, -0.002627104287967086, 0.027028124779462814, -0.030557526275515556, -0.006355473771691322, 0.019777853041887283, -0.025296751409769058, -0.07259391248226166, -0.015544847585260868, 0.01690467819571495, -0.010367583483457565, -0.03341594710946083, -0.02424626797437668, 0.049595121294260025, 0.01388323213905096, -0.004699426703155041, 0.014732209965586662, -0.0021284145768731833, 0.010359597392380238, 0.013370294123888016, 0.020987046882510185, 0.009005402214825153, 0.0027916659601032734, 0.001645706477575004, -0.013302297331392765, 0.020379990339279175, -0.006812868639826775, -0.028331436216831207, 0.055258817970752716, 0.04057801142334938, 0.0067059858702123165, -0.027378426864743233, -0.02804785966873169, 0.019411517307162285, -0.03304964676499367, -0.012971313670277596, 0.01936611533164978, -0.014981960877776146, 0.0013718430418521166, -0.021352864801883698, -0.018344886600971222, 0.026480458676815033, 0.007738626096397638, -0.02092703804373741, -0.0032316448632627726, 0.014388712123036385, -0.021117931231856346, -0.0012067490024492145, -0.006841716822236776, -0.037059083580970764, -0.05536198616027832, 0.013158547692000866, 0.052159667015075684, -0.014437931589782238, 0.04320799186825752, -0.005756547674536705, -0.010357355698943138, -0.025437073782086372, 0.006703263148665428, 0.021304558962583542, 0.02395923249423504, -0.06132100895047188, -0.02666287124156952, -0.022332051768898964, -0.012483515776693821, 0.013351062312722206, -0.039315175265073776, -0.03773794695734978, 0.03272096440196037, 0.0131000317633152, -0.07186533510684967, -0.01290289405733347, 0.0012381542474031448, 0.044387225061655045, 0.03382961452007294, -0.004317346028983593, 0.06578729301691055, 0.016540247946977615, -0.020459463819861412, 0.01269864197820425, -0.03320654481649399, -0.03662317618727684, -0.028618138283491135, -0.027698924764990807, 0.024331670254468918, -0.029088128358125687, -0.0020087442826479673, 0.02341313660144806, -0.004062629770487547, 0.02332892455160618, -0.0685805007815361, -0.03119996190071106, 0.046706125140190125, -0.0070082624442875385, 0.014391659758985043, 0.01634322665631771, 0.010887046344578266, 0.07518241554498672, 0.03957730159163475, -0.027488935738801956, 0.005963265895843506, 0.002527536591514945, -0.013183015398681164, 0.010054433718323708, 0.012445221655070782, 0.037403546273708344, 0.030305132269859314, 0.014656208455562592, 0.01562565192580223, 0.04287371039390564, 0.04333614557981491, 0.008752812631428242, 0.0036535528488457203, 0.010607770644128323, -0.021839061751961708, -0.03375564515590668, 0.059141796082258224, -0.02491496130824089, -0.034174878150224686, 0.01204052846878767, -0.05406121537089348, 0.017117412760853767, 0.005633828230202198, -0.0557735301554203, 0.005428379867225885, -0.01746148243546486, 0.0049384115263819695, -0.03547460585832596, 0.00995997991412878, 0.024302266538143158, -0.06554945558309555, 0.008992549031972885, 0.046053797006607056, 0.052586764097213745, -0.019528087228536606, -0.0011120170820504427, 0.06234738975763321, 0.05476989597082138, 0.0013616812648251653, 0.009171858429908752, -0.009248285554349422, 0.0003071449464187026, 0.033528026193380356, -0.005420831963419914, -0.0032961235847324133, 0.02617248333990574, 0.03886088728904724, -0.015255114994943142, -0.04602120816707611, -0.023185351863503456, 0.011834369041025639, -0.08289222419261932, 0.030811941251158714, -0.019763169810175896, 0.07974638044834137, -0.03438345715403557, 0.038388799875974655, 0.041776686906814575, -0.015562018379569054, -0.012749469839036465, 0.015163162723183632, -0.06411077827215195, 0.027071760967373848, -0.014046190306544304, -0.02152862958610058, -0.028541257604956627, -0.026937011629343033, 0.025135548785328865, -0.0019301361171528697, -0.008277756161987782, -0.011250980198383331, 0.020123519003391266, -0.03183399513363838, 0.06473983079195023, -0.020680619403719902, -0.031855832785367966, -0.00992626789957285, -0.014040507376194, 0.005527848843485117, -0.032724201679229736, 0.019862093031406403, 0.04226284846663475, 0.018882909789681435, -0.0024237518664449453, -0.029787851497530937, 0.009381666779518127, 0.016177844256162643, 0.029315462335944176, 0.044746283441782, 0.047563981264829636, -0.0747276246547699, 0.02804349735379219, 0.010892023332417011, 0.035474419593811035, 0.01962364837527275, -0.031229477375745773, -0.0242939256131649, -0.04888619855046272, 0.00973732490092516, -0.024450883269309998, 0.000934746814891696, 0.018284685909748077, 0.0010567347053438425, 0.07047202438116074, 0.008864745497703552, -0.051197778433561325, 0.009467857889831066, 0.048914264887571335, 0.008856969885528088, -0.011397084221243858, -0.04053125157952309, 0.02341403067111969, 0.0005747703835368156, -0.0337662398815155, 0.09189906716346741, 0.03318946808576584, 0.03112373873591423, 0.0018015766981989145, 0.06703625619411469, -0.009188620373606682, -0.04869980737566948, -0.019649572670459747, 0.009673327207565308, 0.007879209704697132, 0.025771120563149452, -0.013357413932681084, 0.03612120822072029, 0.02884812280535698, 0.0187856275588274, 0.033477723598480225, 0.05098091810941696, -0.05056348070502281, 0.008402125909924507, 0.021067528054118156, 0.013334234245121479, -0.06152651458978653, -0.027859918773174286, -0.0926695391535759, 0.023638524115085602, 0.03162238374352455, -0.034858059138059616, 0.02115294709801674, -0.03804401680827141, -0.0034809429198503494, -0.020157048478722572, 0.0009087249636650085, -0.00611097039654851, 0.02625887282192707, -0.019266756251454353, 0.02374422736465931, -0.024587031453847885, -0.014405656605958939, -0.040822435170412064, 0.02159394696354866, 0.02474997192621231, 0.0862833559513092, -0.013235821388661861, 0.012034012004733086, 0.029673080891370773, 0.060040585696697235, -0.01001305878162384, -0.05714113265275955, -0.026174308732151985, -0.019226040691137314, -0.00578652136027813, 0.040931496769189835, 0.011363649740815163, -0.03421206399798393, -0.002799488604068756, 0.014479824341833591, -0.04123614355921745, 0.01970408856868744, -0.01298578456044197, 0.02680668607354164, 0.01509811356663704, 0.025034615769982338, 0.06552325189113617, 0.04752163216471672, -0.018996143713593483, -0.005133378319442272, -0.036929503083229065, 0.008920813910663128, -0.03737794980406761, -0.012743574567139149, -0.08198820054531097, -0.001857818104326725, -0.026036692783236504, -0.017083998769521713, 0.021931296214461327, 0.02406955510377884, -0.012884396128356457, -0.03365688398480415, 0.01172851212322712, 0.02556067891418934, 0.00820730347186327, 0.022179199382662773, -0.048542093485593796, 0.041022252291440964, -0.003387528471648693, -0.00234054122120142, 0.023014305159449577, -0.0037713295314460993, 0.03519199416041374, -0.025794070214033127, -0.0522344708442688, 0.008927612565457821, -0.05529656261205673, -0.030268680304288864, 0.034165531396865845, 0.0017690797103568912, 0.041933950036764145, 0.020388521254062653, 0.047351278364658356, -0.04374979808926582, -0.04626241698861122, -0.021958786994218826, -0.009992112405598164, 0.0010557749774307013, 0.02153868041932583, -0.0367567278444767, 0.06395722925662994, -0.0015204043593257666, -0.006466064136475325, -0.08481575548648834, -0.04366167262196541, -0.003447809023782611, 0.003592677880078554, -0.03765129670500755, -0.06483680009841919, 0.007809789851307869, 0.0017075833166018128, -0.028548523783683777, -0.024275600910186768, 0.056501541286706924, 0.022051028907299042, -0.061614349484443665, -0.032571855932474136, 0.0168364979326725, 0.06826368719339371, 0.003658819478005171, -0.011597344651818275, -0.0034996354952454567, -0.0420556478202343, 0.008248888887465, -0.024795513600111008, 0.0383523665368557, -0.01406788919121027, -0.028771961107850075, -0.022590765729546547, 0.012529582716524601, 0.03617069870233536, 0.012736551463603973, -0.012401935644447803, -0.006838817615061998, 0.000840504711959511, -0.018256420269608498, 0.020089799538254738, 0.005341093055903912, -0.034910649061203, -0.0072806342504918575, -0.003246141830459237, 0.009344625286757946, -0.009410758502781391, 0.017416438087821007, 0.049984175711870193, -0.015833690762519836, -0.01243665162473917, 0.04736798629164696, 0.0020359386689960957, -0.025419196113944054, 0.017607109621167183, 0.028241433203220367, -0.024169305339455605, 0.06919152289628983, 0.003290127729997039, 0.008559522219002247, -0.004805507604032755, 0.015045000240206718, -0.010097870603203773, -0.016666481271386147, -0.03270967677235603, -0.007401362527161837, 0.03699352592229843, -0.0071052671410143375, 0.03415073826909065, 0.02110414206981659, -0.017402611672878265, 0.0031654576305299997, -0.01994062028825283, 0.01686747372150421, -0.02025962434709072, -0.014691830612719059, 0.060672685503959656, -0.00873558409512043, 0.006108082830905914, 0.06656558811664581, 0.0012339476961642504, 0.039026785641908646, 0.008531032130122185, -0.005051760468631983, 0.02495783381164074, 0.03546350449323654, -0.023021379485726357, 0.0029377229511737823, -0.013281871564686298, -0.04521378129720688, 0.006569639313966036, -0.004364788997918367, 0.0009540271130390465, 0.049918804317712784, 0.017810393124818802, -0.021925408393144608, -0.03718912601470947, 0.009469219483435154, -0.055841781198978424, 0.012523608282208443, 0.013659539632499218, 0.023477736860513687, -0.0020640743896365166, 0.004742149263620377, 0.037102825939655304, -0.002879106206819415, 0.03567558526992798, -0.025568943470716476, -0.05742590129375458, -0.02597879245877266, -0.019925542175769806, -0.01850287616252899, 0.013294643722474575, 0.007309311535209417, -0.044486064463853836, 0.020964518189430237, -0.018558550626039505, 0.016457581892609596, 0.00039418379310518503, 0.03469854220747948, -0.055135633796453476, 0.09061199426651001, 0.012359175831079483, 0.04141470417380333, -0.007846643216907978, 0.005733957979828119, 0.10285570472478867, 0.07248923182487488, 0.0603063739836216, -0.07336588203907013, -0.016350965946912766, -0.016183963045477867, 0.021249601617455482, -0.024037588387727737, -0.006290728226304054, 0.02390372008085251, -0.029062341898679733, 0.06450633704662323, 0.02711205556988716, 0.00998958945274353, -0.008431035093963146, 0.0817209780216217, -0.0331355519592762, -0.00544695882126689, 0.029087098315358162, -0.010711345821619034, 0.007831714116036892, -0.020597711205482483, -0.04467478767037392, 0.0022193994373083115, 0.06346005201339722, 0.003910228610038757, -0.021415237337350845, -0.028716793283820152, -0.000018263424863107502, 0.01537377294152975, -0.017796479165554047, 0.022983688861131668, -0.005184996407479048, 0.022381728515028954, 0.025414934381842613, -0.013141750358045101, 0.02281452715396881, -0.06232927367091179, 0.007194074336439371, 0.0728013813495636, 0.013839513063430786, -0.016102023422718048, 0.042816389352083206, 0.01730293408036232, -0.060342997312545776, -0.02429739385843277, -0.02597491629421711, -0.010912208817899227, -0.021740788593888283, -0.02150571532547474, -0.04094395413994789, -0.002999468008056283, 0.02322174422442913, -0.012260345742106438, -0.005056099966168404, 0.04407740384340286, 0.027458354830741882, -0.018274549394845963, -0.03401534631848335, 0.014990141615271568, 0.015186830423772335, -0.013587087392807007, 0.02334095910191536, 0.012966136448085308, 0.006806313060224056, -0.02096698246896267, -0.033164091408252716, 0.02897072397172451, 0.015015002340078354, 0.003679043846204877, 0.007969284430146217, -0.03656364977359772, -0.03466138616204262, -0.014942700043320656, 0.004935345146805048, 0.02478834241628647, 0.022608064115047455, -0.031127747148275375, 0.005423364695161581, 0.0069010755978524685, -0.026583140715956688, 0.00826750136911869, -0.03201350197196007, -0.025528663769364357, -0.04992993548512459, -0.0019325678003951907, -0.020396418869495392, 0.014467350207269192, 0.047505103051662445, 0.0018258464988321066, 0.05867039039731026, 0.050613489001989365, -0.02490025945007801, -0.06536802649497986, -0.003351046936586499, -0.023259801790118217, -0.03828343749046326, -0.01740172877907753, -0.016877079382538795, 0.02156250551342964, 0.031469374895095825, 0.01473728846758604, -0.035958997905254364, -0.007611327804625034, 0.03220897167921066, 0.02999463677406311, 0.02230914495885372, -0.03902282938361168, 0.001978479092940688, 0.0023406792897731066, -0.002289665164425969, -0.04112036153674126, 0.025812694802880287, 0.007544341031461954, -0.008418579585850239, 0.024053309112787247, 0.015864290297031403, -0.06003876030445099, -0.024851739406585693, 0.006249374710023403, 0.032584551721811295, 0.0023050992749631405, 0.0013865436194464564, -0.05518617108464241, 0.022362779825925827, -0.008931919932365417, -0.00703849270939827, -0.021437201648950577, 0.029437659308314323, -0.0057005672715604305, 0.018172452226281166, -0.0118934391066432, -0.03671523183584213, -0.018889622762799263, 0.03998357057571411, 0.009830819442868233, -0.01040059793740511, 0.03165510296821594, -0.016151322051882744, 0.008896841667592525, 0.014855004847049713, -0.04279569536447525, -0.010969111695885658, 0.03276699036359787, 0.003193216398358345, 0.039435964077711105, 0.014559471048414707, -0.020402047783136368, -0.014575213193893433, 0.08452646434307098, -0.035449303686618805, -0.02878289856016636, -0.039590053260326385, -0.021933354437351227, -0.005891371518373489, -0.006719324737787247, -0.012181785888969898, 0.017337212339043617, -0.0058488086797297, 0.01259929034858942, 0.03407415747642517, 0.00951184518635273, 0.011991873383522034, 0.007059500552713871, 0.02342497743666172, 0.01607682555913925, -0.02384267933666706, 0.006444213446229696, 0.01140023022890091, 0.08081871271133423, -0.008914843201637268, 0.016879074275493622, -0.008530731312930584, 0.009884501807391644, -0.07987584918737411, -0.03454823046922684, 0.013183077797293663, -0.014456813223659992, 0.010697620920836926, 0.0009416672983206809, -0.01819794811308384, 0.028614841401576996, -0.01682446151971817, -0.0005708267563022673, 0.009713835082948208, 0.011981640011072159, -0.047193001955747604, 0.05371517688035965, -0.013542940840125084, 0.008797654882073402, 0.040581680834293365, -0.0003178463375661522, 0.0031589085701853037, 0.008244374766945839, 0.00895550474524498, 0.02076362818479538, -0.03181974217295647, -0.0058089932426810265, 0.007820834405720234, -0.057344645261764526, 0.04058723896741867, -0.01015099510550499, -0.050398681312799454, 0.024471411481499672, -0.02748858742415905, 0.017729826271533966, 0.023303411900997162, 0.030952254310250282, 0.002692434936761856, 0.01435583084821701, 0.041647184640169144, 0.011300302110612392, -0.0019669814500957727, 0.028596239164471626, 0.0392194464802742, 0.01219419576227665, -0.020211368799209595, 0.021376539021730423, 0.036724355071783066, -0.01690775156021118, 0.02811933308839798, 0.029433494433760643, -0.021098941564559937, -0.013656353577971458, 0.01011757180094719, -0.011962272226810455, 0.04076789692044258, 0.016032539308071136, 0.014448312111198902, -0.04649366810917854, 0.018869640305638313, 0.046776264905929565, -0.01590854860842228, -0.022569924592971802, 0.00744132325053215, -0.04101047292351723, -0.029801147058606148, -0.00876700971275568, 0.0051249489188194275, -0.033934254199266434, -0.05498276650905609, -0.03897501528263092, -0.025328805670142174, -0.00480686267837882, -0.005256921052932739, -0.021487422287464142, -0.03374104201793671, 0.06208338588476181, 0.0109979547560215, -0.0005352871376089752, 0.028231024742126465, 0.009925187565386295, -0.012005607597529888, -0.032591890543699265, 0.039922457188367844, 0.014351882040500641, -0.06409751623868942, -0.015098354779183865, 0.02002337947487831, -0.027919815853238106, 0.035094957798719406, 0.028210101649165154, -0.01591741107404232, 0.00166278553660959, -0.01933019421994686, 0.0015189689584076405, 0.026071036234498024, -0.05070621892809868, 0.023353561758995056, 0.012363262474536896, -0.017514074221253395, -0.009033050388097763, -0.012016251683235168, -0.005313614849001169, 0.017204580828547478, -0.0023496546782553196, -0.0026956824585795403, 0.043220482766628265, 0.016354169696569443, 0.008755797520279884, -0.010257182642817497, 0.021257834509015083, -0.0010147925931960344, 0.050449956208467484, -0.058785829693078995, 0.01632794737815857, 0.01620788313448429, -0.0003078948357142508, -0.07292550802230835, 0.022449010983109474, -0.04873870313167572, -0.02394804358482361, 0.022725675255060196, -0.011127304285764694, 0.023194298148155212, -0.0647374764084816, -0.014111661352217197, 0.005993060301989317, -0.030382681638002396, 0.014451968483626842, 0.029500149190425873, 0.0125314611941576, 0.008742770180106163, 0.013485012575984001, 0.00029330168035812676, -0.02772199921309948, -0.02220156043767929, 0.009145945310592651, 0.011771752499043941, 0.005832904949784279, 0.02201700210571289, 0.028561335057020187, -0.0011386364931240678, 0.022663963958621025, 0.021553149446845055, 0.0016105847898870707, 0.012090652249753475, -0.030313605442643166, -0.04374244436621666, -0.00467314850538969, 0.017765024676918983, 0.01571289636194706, 0.022412678226828575, 0.01693771593272686, 0.04528115317225456, -0.020035989582538605, 0.010347099974751472, -0.02628283016383648, -0.030095839872956276, -0.0025074980221688747, -0.027528556063771248, 0.005656348541378975, -0.003865564940497279, -0.025459488853812218, -0.0202074833214283, 0.016777457669377327, 0.0031144048552960157, 0.012907980009913445, -0.0332166813313961, 0.023772714659571648, -0.007093274034559727, -0.024532422423362732, -0.045593682676553726, -0.031012151390314102, 0.023013247177004814, -0.005255472846329212, -0.011053628288209438, 0.05207208916544914, 0.0037310095503926277, -0.01796380616724491, -0.040024273097515106, -0.023556789383292198, 0.03617764264345169, -0.08354438096284866, -0.014626576565206051, -0.06393152475357056, -0.0006088717491365969, -0.008760367520153522, -0.04447803646326065 ]
<p>Are there many features in Eviews that R misses? I have heard that especially when dealing with time series R is less extensive than Eviews. Is this true? Which of the two packages contains most statistical tools (or are they comparable?)?</p>
73,629
[ -0.0274698194116354, 0.00040819947025738657, 0.0013077887706458569, 0.001857228111475706, 0.04672812670469284, 0.02247980237007141, -0.053686823695898056, -0.03799004107713699, 0.011877339333295822, -0.03300034627318382, 0.023028256371617317, 0.045833732932806015, 0.06562868505716324, 0.020368484780192375, 0.010536997579038143, -0.025887103751301765, -0.01824781857430935, 0.00823849719017744, -0.007187031675130129, -0.003716860432177782, -0.034192055463790894, 0.0027405337896198034, 0.0758226290345192, -0.00047544119297526777, -0.0003927793586626649, 0.019557956606149673, 0.025776829570531845, 0.015336953103542328, 0.017154214903712273, 0.021730488166213036, -0.038946740329265594, -0.016245221719145775, -0.019399363547563553, 0.056309040635824203, 0.028655335307121277, 0.014026543125510216, -0.03463685140013695, -0.024928322061896324, 0.02821289747953415, 0.0336424820125103, -0.043558161705732346, 0.009095381945371628, -0.007991320453584194, 0.005746045615524054, -0.023795591667294502, 0.01698254980146885, 0.009615404531359673, -0.015645816922187805, 0.048017699271440506, -0.0005153279053047299, 0.02480977214872837, -0.001336780027486384, 0.026142699643969536, 0.00604338338598609, 0.003778491634875536, 0.06519696116447449, 0.05663853883743286, 0.023958491161465645, 0.0018068115459755063, -0.054145682603120804, 0.0034779245033860207, 0.024434467777609825, -0.011978358961641788, -0.03102685883641243, -0.02699647657573223, 0.041545320302248, -0.006494300905615091, -0.017850281670689583, 0.04109228029847145, 0.020166531205177307, -0.002803501905873418, 0.025264715775847435, -0.00710794422775507, 0.01884465478360653, 0.02541518770158291, -0.03886951133608818, -0.004254823084920645, -0.000047672790969954804, 0.02247200347483158, 0.03309068828821182, 0.009590532630681992, -0.006485610269010067, 0.0379132516682148, 0.05283518135547638, 0.05875956639647484, -0.008351529948413372, 0.055080972611904144, -0.027403047308325768, 0.006539514288306236, 0.007822591811418533, -0.022283632308244705, 0.007183825597167015, 0.04605013132095337, 0.0340045727789402, -0.021379614248871803, 0.025442538782954216, -0.018550310283899307, 0.04343803599476814, 0.02360876463353634, -0.016499407589435577, 0.0007138779037632048, -0.009071223437786102, 0.01441883947700262, 0.027245454490184784, 0.005233159754425287, -0.026913102716207504, -0.023094838485121727, -0.05596713349223137, -0.037130095064640045, -0.002028360962867737, -0.05828665941953659, 0.025400059297680855, -0.014790638349950314, 0.00348028470762074, 0.04184155538678169, 0.026270847767591476, 0.006349340546876192, -0.011393261142075062, 0.021359875798225403, 0.11934278160333633, 0.06717488914728165, -0.01121340412646532, -0.006895214319229126, -0.040528554469347, -0.071116603910923, 0.014904018491506577, 0.011390343308448792, -0.039534810930490494, -0.05354365333914757, 0.019201239570975304, -0.0023102525155991316, -0.026136524975299835, 0.04691677168011665, 0.0012383919674903154, 0.0405854657292366, 0.0350821316242218, -0.07284469157457352, -0.04238785803318024, 0.04964372143149376, -0.013644804246723652, -0.0024699303321540356, -0.029455581679940224, 0.03517627343535423, 0.0026799356564879417, 0.016203757375478745, 0.0068022459745407104, 0.05012224614620209, 0.029944218695163727, 0.03591116890311241, 0.006605109665542841, -0.042876362800598145, 0.0028245977591723204, -0.014421941712498665, -0.0259747002273798, 0.015791799873113632, -0.02748236432671547, 0.04754789173603058, 0.006357171572744846, -0.005471482872962952, 0.01530893798917532, 0.024093128740787506, 0.02243613637983799, -0.026832332834601402, -0.029685301706194878, 0.021874018013477325, -0.03623541072010994, 0.04535292461514473, -0.032868292182683945, 0.06604123115539551, -0.004927224945276976, -0.04220692440867424, 0.024639757350087166, 0.0773630440235138, 0.01930578425526619, 0.03804409131407738, 0.0068588885478675365, -0.022051706910133362, 0.011201288551092148, -0.0036701150238513947, 0.03411010652780533, -0.035853516310453415, -0.01613428071141243, 0.004119241144508123, -0.03019927814602852, -0.007117393892258406, 0.08052462339401245, 0.00782324280589819, -0.019370561465620995, 0.03142838552594185, -0.056391868740320206, -0.02032882533967495, -0.030007202178239822, -0.022181324660778046, -0.024319738149642944, -0.021228384226560593, 0.03360506892204285, 0.019662264734506607, 0.01742026023566723, -0.004199051298201084, -0.03451170399785042, -0.00541519233956933, 0.00398204056546092, 0.00562781747430563, -0.021958300843834877, -0.022055858746170998, 0.019566547125577927, 0.06181163713335991, -0.02724587544798851, 0.027782877907156944, -0.030803967267274857, -0.09100289642810822, 0.019554922357201576, -0.031189531087875366, -0.002948242938145995, 0.02227967418730259, -0.02687382884323597, 0.027305753901600838, 0.010334220714867115, -0.002636060118675232, 0.03703052178025246, -0.0038983931299299, 0.005165817681699991, 0.040402527898550034, 0.013376930728554726, 0.018945107236504555, 0.036280933767557144, 0.05081433057785034, 0.010910513810813427, -0.0028484093490988016, 0.023055950179696083, -0.021007992327213287, 0.009460702538490295, 0.054869066923856735, 0.04139917343854904, -0.041429467499256134, 0.022012753412127495, 0.036009471863508224, 0.005108932964503765, 0.023376556113362312, 0.001479809870943427, 0.017398901283740997, -0.03946179896593094, 0.025739196687936783, 0.025905955582857132, 0.02305563911795616, -0.005965712480247021, 0.01955481804907322, -0.021038029342889786, 0.06816443055868149, 0.006235324777662754, -0.04616319760680199, 0.06489217281341553, -0.03980405628681183, -0.011188018135726452, -0.03552040830254555, -0.009140340611338615, 0.02372237853705883, -0.03365207090973854, -0.015285004861652851, 0.020868517458438873, 0.06494694203138351, 0.025343140587210655, 0.009559853933751583, 0.007868587039411068, 0.0032124335411936045, 0.012365133501589298, -0.04460129514336586, -0.02250109799206257, 0.025029072538018227, -0.057877372950315475, 0.011072919704020023, -0.07227178663015366, -0.0000062392664403887466, -0.06950481235980988, 0.02211298979818821, 0.05467742308974266, -0.018977144733071327, 0.012494366616010666, -0.013544268906116486, -0.033903464674949646, 0.031370531767606735, -0.04863326624035835, -0.0020107943564653397, -0.0009617739706300199, -0.030187565833330154, 0.018116913735866547, -0.017605861648917198, 0.004251960199326277, 0.01107026357203722, -0.03488043323159218, -0.008038938976824284, -0.0038882207591086626, -0.02753332071006298, -0.03088962286710739, -0.024295182898640633, -0.0089167645201087, 0.0177756454795599, -0.014070925302803516, -0.03201904520392418, 0.0270175039768219, -0.009410243481397629, -0.02504241093993187, 0.014282540418207645, -0.02912754938006401, -0.005690622143447399, -0.07343754917383194, 0.0010341114830225706, 0.013192917220294476, -0.02141626551747322, -0.02719196118414402, 0.0381242111325264, -0.05976932868361473, -0.007812274154275656, -0.035947415977716446, -0.06520858407020569, 0.014162478037178516, -0.0044523365795612335, 0.031273532658815384, 0.015371167100965977, 0.025222130119800568, 0.018590211868286133, 0.003818199271336198, -0.053061630576848984, -0.06192439794540405, 0.019140589982271194, -0.023288389667868614, 0.005831983871757984, 0.00695854751393199, 0.01579376496374607, 0.053194861859083176, 0.006470984313637018, -0.0296460147947073, 0.030177943408489227, 0.017227591946721077, 0.0012828512117266655, 0.02685552090406418, 0.01375780813395977, 0.032072871923446655, -0.005810324568301439, 0.01535174623131752, 0.007999147288501263, -0.0034089251421391964, -0.004304252099245787, 0.0016828799853101373, 0.029101407155394554, 0.014094927348196507, -0.024953491985797882, 0.03100777231156826, -0.010810909792780876, 0.05515749007463455, -0.015404684469103813, -0.01140633039176464, 0.021637380123138428, 0.00885389931499958, -0.02021423541009426, 0.006329857278615236, 0.045438382774591446, -0.012948310002684593, -0.005090696737170219, 0.04250026121735573, 0.006762421689927578, -0.035126686096191406, 0.007270189933478832, -0.02837301604449749, -0.010051453486084938, 0.03731011226773262, 0.01239512488245964, -0.027710050344467163, 0.08427350223064423, 0.042810674756765366, 0.0034887727815657854, 0.01123103965073824, -0.06844067573547363, 0.00844038836658001, -0.06461602449417114, -0.029828567057847977, -0.024116380140185356, 0.04017694666981697, -0.00381023483350873, 0.04957258701324463, 0.0069888499565422535, 0.026104377582669258, -0.01755317486822605, -0.03599722310900688, -0.06703802943229675, 0.008579692803323269, -0.035580795258283615, -0.000608151953201741, -0.018343398347496986, -0.001089828205294907, 0.02549075521528721, 0.031824588775634766, -0.003596213413402438, -0.042110491544008255, -0.005009606014937162, -0.04684561863541603, 0.027715709060430527, -0.016810301691293716, 0.019005652517080307, 0.002641645958647132, -0.0025434342678636312, 0.025256941094994545, -0.03710772842168808, 0.029865115880966187, 0.03902886435389519, -0.0072562843561172485, -0.017091626301407814, -0.0021527251228690147, 0.02924617938697338, 0.01389483455568552, 0.05672834813594818, 0.042997296899557114, 0.039811089634895325, -0.06358969211578369, 0.004027979914098978, 0.03530218079686165, 0.012534192763268948, 0.038288578391075134, -0.012451091781258583, -0.03839956969022751, -0.023041367530822754, -0.029378363862633705, 0.005723461974412203, 0.029050452634692192, 0.032498907297849655, 0.00039291332359425724, 0.06346525251865387, 0.014003877528011799, -0.035923950374126434, -0.00784301944077015, 0.03873177245259285, 0.009557829238474369, -0.020636383444070816, -0.013544193468987942, 0.005907333921641111, 0.009117195382714272, 0.006883022841066122, 0.0038857341278344393, 0.020488575100898743, -0.005641934461891651, -0.01321568712592125, -0.005571533460170031, -0.054089292883872986, -0.05030839890241623, -0.02600439079105854, 0.05343944951891899, 0.026948437094688416, -0.005272681824862957, -0.04588375613093376, 0.02071053721010685, 0.016299892216920853, 0.041434284299612045, 0.01621128059923649, -0.01263110339641571, -0.06459139287471771, 0.03602474182844162, 0.05450019985437393, 0.00659998320043087, -0.049653731286525726, -0.006486851256340742, -0.025553027167916298, -0.030349183827638626, 0.01681526005268097, -0.02253919094800949, 0.00528683140873909, -0.03887314721941948, 0.0040558092296123505, -0.02760833129286766, -0.06367727369070053, -0.01530961412936449, -0.02903456799685955, -0.028798526152968407, 0.047788746654987335, -0.010278417728841305, -0.02380140870809555, -0.055768899619579315, 0.05065390467643738, 0.012566164135932922, 0.014169864356517792, 0.022333737462759018, -0.009947206825017929, 0.03048449009656906, 0.0055248732678592205, -0.015634382143616676, -0.04858596250414848, -0.03427211567759514, 0.04410816356539726, -0.01999484747648239, 0.030486442148685455, 0.030071133747696877, -0.019420478492975235, 0.00919797457754612, 0.00908635463565588, -0.043878212571144104, -0.03651195019483566, 0.0026760317850857973, 0.014101204462349415, 0.03577619418501854, 0.0005436783540062606, 0.0659775659441948, 0.017808176577091217, 0.01407510507851839, 0.0053199296817183495, -0.02660149335861206, 0.03310641646385193, -0.04492669925093651, -0.02507089264690876, -0.042654622346162796, -0.054661933332681656, -0.019798394292593002, -0.0018565923674032092, 0.023328952491283417, 0.02472720667719841, -0.06100190058350563, 0.022650791332125664, 0.011775421909987926, 0.011453840881586075, 0.010584265924990177, -0.0009613951551727951, -0.011195609346032143, 0.003817073069512844, -0.028991658240556717, -0.0027521648444235325, 0.030741011723876, -0.016466157510876656, -0.030954629182815552, 0.01929496042430401, -0.030555520206689835, 0.008560976013541222, 0.004904233384877443, -0.0020092688500881195, 0.055269982665777206, -0.014131024479866028, 0.00923238880932331, -0.024411767721176147, 0.02124013565480709, -0.010441244579851627, -0.030990388244390488, 0.0016512617003172636, 0.022932283580303192, 0.0018132523400709033, 0.004595446866005659, -0.0498015359044075, 0.042678505182266235, -0.01192210242152214, -0.04066181182861328, -0.07097373157739639, -0.06327827274799347, 0.018007054924964905, 0.014637002721428871, -0.0355609655380249, -0.014242664910852909, -0.005248986650258303, -0.00999748706817627, 0.04766377434134483, -0.037502434104681015, 0.023627780377864838, -0.024186592549085617, 0.012744899839162827, -0.005929509177803993, 0.03412355110049248, 0.06073964759707451, 0.03323058411478996, 0.0397435687482357, 0.039512261748313904, -0.005027887411415577, 0.020812511444091797, -0.00006172956636874005, 0.033423520624637604, -0.012395099736750126, 0.00006236199988052249, -0.018204575404524803, -0.024653790518641472, -0.0038566605653613806, -0.04823455959558487, 0.005868649575859308, 0.06371045112609863, -0.019038202241063118, -0.0013217877130955458, -0.020079659298062325, 0.016617121174931526, -0.0632079541683197, -0.013107015751302242, -0.027844788506627083, 0.0004351483075879514, 0.01206838246434927, -0.03008597157895565, 0.004629035480320454, -0.004422560799866915, 0.001574156922288239, 0.016223473474383354, 0.011861702427268028, 0.009664938785135746, 0.015787405893206596, -0.016524238511919975, -0.005144009366631508, 0.008014523424208164, -0.02210232801735401, 0.019861740991473198, -0.006972342263907194, 0.02990657277405262, 0.004569767974317074, -0.05406785011291504, -0.018994996324181557, -0.00615875655785203, 0.0798107385635376, -0.008768551982939243, 0.05095253884792328, 0.017380688339471817, -0.02164882980287075, -0.032255083322525024, -0.08922921866178513, -0.03006557561457157, 0.017117861658334732, 0.008171110413968563, 0.04942052438855171, 0.021870357915759087, -0.005911913700401783, 0.011758203618228436, 0.018950102850794792, 0.03774837404489517, 0.05846255272626877, 0.007461542263627052, 0.019605595618486404, 0.0139795346185565, -0.010780470445752144, -0.04889903962612152, -0.006161441560834646, -0.0023916473146528006, 0.016689496114850044, -0.03364213928580284, -0.02142053097486496, 0.03025985136628151, 0.030768467113375664, 0.02535119093954563, -0.05636049807071686, -0.012830501422286034, -0.027293676510453224, 0.0030244130175560713, 0.0589337982237339, 0.017120370641350746, -0.011172875761985779, -0.015079621225595474, 0.022048847749829292, -0.006319501902908087, 0.05185537412762642, -0.013615927658975124, -0.0788840502500534, -0.03433176502585411, -0.03529532626271248, -0.04294651001691818, 0.043733950704336166, -0.0029745621141046286, -0.04684244468808174, -0.022068526595830917, -0.012668690644204617, 0.037637677043676376, -0.02024022303521633, 0.06502100825309753, 0.028437459841370583, 0.058651745319366455, -0.01030312292277813, -0.012027074582874775, -0.008678525686264038, -0.019308658316731453, 0.13382135331630707, 0.07125154882669449, 0.056857574731111526, -0.06597325205802917, -0.004605444148182869, 0.0018289170693606138, -0.0003947311488445848, -0.021400436758995056, -0.010045232251286507, 0.017107585445046425, 0.0042218673042953014, 0.07667127996683121, 0.04555531591176987, 0.04998011142015457, -0.0240783654153347, 0.019891628995537758, -0.035310957580804825, 0.003610841231420636, -0.00833487045019865, 0.04627031460404396, 0.05063841864466667, -0.01741281896829605, -0.1019938662648201, -0.012404996901750565, 0.0020680755842477083, -0.04396473616361618, -0.019295454025268555, -0.014152725227177143, -0.0028558310586959124, -0.011145409196615219, -0.055759791284799576, -0.01829240284860134, 0.02300155721604824, 0.01977919228374958, 0.005375806707888842, 0.005603611469268799, 0.0183282271027565, -0.032747868448495865, -0.0013046285603195429, 0.039680447429418564, 0.020323101431131363, -0.02251117303967476, -0.001497175544500351, 0.002388143679127097, -0.0756055936217308, 0.004539188463240862, -0.0047111124731600285, 0.010835468769073486, -0.006538913585245609, 0.021242385730147362, -0.023823987692594528, -0.019432751461863518, 0.005558549426496029, -0.0028735597152262926, -0.02223680354654789, 0.018712248653173447, 0.02943645603954792, -0.011828044429421425, -0.025070348754525185, -0.02719029039144516, 0.0291250329464674, -0.03588533028960228, 0.0378829687833786, 0.0036076910328119993, -0.07782573997974396, -0.009564751759171486, -0.007814079523086548, 0.030083417892456055, -0.03243131935596466, -0.017876027151942253, 0.030917488038539886, 0.0038403079379349947, -0.0208351481705904, -0.0011190592776983976, 0.01852976530790329, 0.02572866715490818, 0.011622999794781208, -0.025705980136990547, -0.009081750176846981, -0.042848892509937286, -0.0416378490626812, 0.019174160435795784, -0.0025175076443701982, -0.02006460167467594, -0.006526948884129524, 0.0009497691644355655, 0.06773543357849121, -0.009279213845729828, 0.0199714507907629, 0.029064470902085304, -0.046339549124240875, 0.09137558937072754, -0.014551714062690735, -0.046761877834796906, 0.014940747059881687, -0.013939659111201763, -0.013210912235081196, 0.009762813337147236, -0.005628405138850212, 0.04205732420086861, 0.044075388461351395, 0.02215602621436119, -0.01635252684354782, 0.026797175407409668, -0.01798836514353752, -0.006814317312091589, 0.031321629881858826, -0.0749126523733139, -0.0009851246140897274, 0.034498050808906555, -0.003937277011573315, -0.056811727583408356, -0.024263810366392136, -0.06811132282018661, -0.021744921803474426, -0.004744342993944883, -0.04520855098962784, -0.04238820821046829, 0.013763770461082458, 0.015131540596485138, 0.045947492122650146, -0.01620849221944809, -0.003890453139320016, -0.04608515277504921, -0.00487724831327796, -0.021218974143266678, -0.03547273576259613, 0.057270076125860214, -0.014729546383023262, -0.032530102878808975, -0.006466906052082777, 0.01510077714920044, 0.016554398462176323, 0.01895119436085224, 0.029773913323879242, -0.014514331705868244, -0.002446932252496481, 0.05125465616583824, -0.03642597422003746, -0.013419630005955696, 0.06213763728737831, -0.0378819964826107, -0.0327005535364151, 0.030020156875252724, -0.02809484861791134, -0.02170545794069767, -0.034788828343153, -0.005964034702628851, -0.032043032348155975, 0.05958637595176697, -0.022755194455385208, 0.03174985200166702, 0.005454898811876774, 0.00906540546566248, 0.009222559630870819, 0.014616191387176514, 0.003563967766240239, 0.002832310274243355, -0.011222340166568756, 0.018135400488972664, 0.07111469656229019, 0.02240198664367199, -0.012380754575133324, -0.019365353509783745, -0.03218802064657211, 0.03397861495614052, 0.03064212203025818, -0.010736578144133091, 0.03903256729245186, 0.01194015983492136, -0.03246976062655449, 0.039491213858127594, 0.014015275053679943, 0.034605447202920914, -0.07429702579975128, 0.012679875828325748, 0.0010168669978156686, 0.009669303894042969, 0.026799382641911507, -0.046870436519384384, 0.012268809601664543, 0.010103380307555199, -0.08263293653726578, 0.007979058660566807, -0.014527564868330956, -0.028223788365721703, -0.04417595639824867, 0.006330639123916626, -0.015775112435221672, -0.005522648338228464, 0.0481090284883976, 0.00827407743781805, 0.0308944471180439, 0.02565723843872547, 0.010488354600965977, -0.019088253378868103, -0.038991529494524, 0.03318376466631889, -0.002359295729547739, -0.027773477137088776, 0.030711589381098747, -0.035269320011138916, -0.050686392933130264, 0.01215055026113987, -0.024974297732114792, 0.08018123358488083, 0.024693790823221207, 0.020672952756285667, 0.019754497334361076, 0.033099375665187836, 0.03518933430314064, -0.04352965205907822, -0.03647880628705025, -0.020495641976594925, -0.013326885178685188, 0.010843790136277676, 0.01756567507982254, 0.024475213140249252, -0.005416272208094597, 0.015977809205651283, -0.01674061454832554, -0.006372765637934208, 0.004439234733581543, -0.02654123678803444, 0.010664817877113819, 0.02114688977599144, 0.011300124228000641, -0.0027900764252990484, 0.017875315621495247, -0.031718067824840546, 0.015091551467776299, 0.04490342363715172, 0.00304660783149302, 0.016430608928203583, 0.01033855602145195, -0.018401289358735085, -0.032505668699741364, -0.01125275157392025, 0.0032603999134153128, 0.011999228969216347, -0.0390906035900116, 0.01563248224556446, 0.01589016616344452, -0.005387827754020691, -0.021998461335897446, 0.022572772577404976, -0.03356160968542099, 0.03838376700878143, 0.0037196269258856773, 0.0041638645343482494, 0.03649232164025307, 0.010344790294766426, 0.01555833499878645, -0.07949907332658768, 0.07131019979715347, -0.00868414156138897, -0.006029824260622263, -0.03270115330815315, 0.003753477241843939, -0.02326282672584057, 0.002559852786362171, 0.05817600339651108, -0.028395265340805054, -0.001702315523289144, -0.010820339433848858, 0.04084557667374611, 0.011113258078694344, -0.01793753169476986, 0.046619173139333725, -0.04549926891922951, -0.03709447756409645, -0.013462606817483902, -0.05293941870331764, 0.01283614058047533, 0.01885867863893509, 0.004390548914670944, -0.05779513716697693, -0.025244811549782753, 0.011209269985556602, 0.005423299968242645, 0.040708523243665695, 0.010288515128195286, -0.019336897879838943, 0.020754633471369743, -0.006815746892243624, 0.0015836365055292845, 0.008758097887039185, 0.029028229415416718, -0.02669426240026951, 0.08249460160732269, -0.0133689995855093, -0.03634915500879288, 0.025929860770702362, -0.013078448362648487, -0.006178553216159344, -0.029613975435495377, -0.04338974505662918, 0.04181494191288948, -0.009317648597061634, -0.0011526006273925304, 0.037886377424001694, 0.020253730937838554, 0.037499792873859406, -0.0032273693941533566, -0.002015496836975217, 0.043012067675590515, -0.02137606404721737, -0.014971187338232994, 0.01601368561387062, 0.025476302951574326, 0.01409389078617096, -0.01663966476917267, 0.01795518398284912, -0.04674933850765228, 0.04594628885388374, 0.015525365248322487, 0.03183978423476219, -0.01248819101601839, -0.031891848891973495, -0.01502205803990364, 0.003023656317964196, 0.01688760705292225, -0.007724505849182606, -0.010405668057501316, 0.04916498437523842, -0.046669721603393555, 0.004806508310139179, -0.06503926217556, -0.032554544508457184, -0.045713067054748535, 0.007613126188516617, -0.022798268124461174, -0.010126729495823383, -0.004333361051976681, 0.033976614475250244, 0.022212574258446693, 0.01477059442549944, 0.025625791400671005, 0.0013574910117313266, 0.023123348131775856, -0.04626545310020447, 0.0037901857867836952, 0.01838754490017891, -0.007386437151581049, -0.04484391584992409, -0.022367019206285477, 0.033300578594207764, 0.02408132515847683, 0.026621181517839432, -0.007188158109784126, -0.031306326389312744, -0.01766756735742092, 0.02443215250968933, -0.07964275032281876, -0.002741435309872031, -0.024665361270308495, 0.01489295531064272, 0.026706086471676826, -0.000966186576988548 ]
<p>I'm afraid that related questions didn't answer mine. We evaluate the performances of >2 classifiers (machine learning). Our Null hypothesis is that performances do not differ. We perform parametric (ANOVA) and non-parametric (Friedman) tests to evaluate this hypothesis. If they're significant, we want to find out which classifiers differ in a post-hoc quest.</p> <p>My question is twofold: </p> <p>1) Is a correction of p-values after multiple comparisons testing necessary at all? The German Wikipedia site on "Alphafehler Kumulierung" says that the problem only occurs if multiple hypotheses are tested on the same data. When comparing classifiers (1,2),(1,3),(2,3), data only partially overlaps. Is it still required to correct the p-values? </p> <p>2) P-value correction is often used after pairwise testing with a t-test. Is it also necessary when doing specialised post-hoc tests, such as Nemenyi's (non-parametric) or Tukey's HSD test? This answer says "no" for Tukey's HSD: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/33357/does-the-tukey-hsd-test-correct-for-multiple-comparisons">Does the Tukey HSD test correct for multiple comparisons?</a>. Is there a rule or do I have to look this up for every potential post-hoc test?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,630
[ -0.055764343589544296, -0.033790744841098785, -0.011636221781373024, -0.00030721729854121804, 0.019120709970593452, 0.027592573314905167, -0.004615191835910082, -0.012309172190725803, 0.024859575554728508, -0.0350683219730854, 0.03278356418013573, 0.0045821634121239185, 0.06464387476444244, 0.02276196889579296, -0.0021151467226445675, 0.0005731067503802478, 0.014578709378838539, 0.01406145840883255, 0.013553042896091938, -0.0009034789982251823, -0.031055442988872528, 0.018086548894643784, 0.001318357652053237, -0.002932370640337467, -0.04349455609917641, 0.025190982967615128, -0.0033833617344498634, 0.000017025351553456858, 0.05859963223338127, 0.0183500237762928, -0.05590004846453667, -0.01439062412828207, 0.036535680294036865, 0.01994978077709675, -0.014817629009485245, -0.009484163485467434, -0.01884111948311329, 0.0002938508114311844, -0.017293576151132584, 0.054140541702508926, -0.01580258458852768, -0.009070726111531258, 0.015852434560656548, 0.053177494555711746, -0.010056284256279469, 0.00373178836889565, -0.012598651461303234, -0.03667347505688667, 0.012440696358680725, -0.04061548039317131, 0.049756914377212524, 0.012959965504705906, 0.020276673138141632, 0.016995321959257126, -0.019879644736647606, -0.024182116612792015, 0.055916544049978256, 0.06771145761013031, 0.0023559695109725, -0.0751533955335617, 0.02575933374464512, -0.03955612704157829, 0.0487176813185215, 0.015867164358496666, -0.062008410692214966, 0.068296879529953, -0.005636165384203196, -0.025806667283177376, 0.048590682446956635, -0.020563330501317978, -0.0038011029828339815, 0.00800982303917408, 0.025440270081162453, -0.013194039463996887, 0.013571349903941154, -0.01504503097385168, -0.00837295688688755, 0.024610843509435654, 0.06308343261480331, 0.04823387786746025, 0.00448780320584774, -0.00021384529827628285, 0.024356838315725327, 0.07717317342758179, 0.0504024401307106, -0.008233370259404182, 0.0778435692191124, -0.006709625944495201, 0.01923060603439808, -0.022473622113466263, 0.002695942297577858, -0.0009050137596204877, 0.03608749061822891, -0.007511207368224859, -0.027992453426122665, 0.020225761458277702, -0.03819972276687622, 0.01922440528869629, 0.012887472286820412, 0.0038418732583522797, 0.0035402891226112843, -0.0500514954328537, 0.023592252284288406, -0.0022312127985060215, -0.03565371036529541, 0.021824412047863007, -0.03522343933582306, -0.009048664011061192, -0.009945730678737164, -0.02489353157579899, -0.03942325338721275, 0.035080812871456146, -0.03192879259586334, 0.005373368039727211, 0.024401595816016197, -0.0160035640001297, -0.0097313541918993, 0.016223127022385597, 0.052383728325366974, 0.06718156486749649, 0.029232077300548553, -0.02513818070292473, 0.03386326879262924, -0.0260463859885931, -0.07162051647901535, 0.019116707146167755, 0.005498574580997229, -0.006408234126865864, -0.04715296998620033, 0.0820930153131485, 0.0002839227672666311, 0.0068088099360466, 0.017828045412898064, 0.012818480841815472, 0.024609459564089775, 0.02401423081755638, -0.08032311499118805, -0.04087189584970474, 0.02423255518078804, -0.012425179593265057, -0.012072550132870674, -0.07231283187866211, 0.009427186101675034, 0.028464259579777718, 0.07141145318746567, 0.02002914808690548, 0.04655023664236069, -0.007339384872466326, 0.02860051766037941, 0.028455840423703194, -0.03868735209107399, -0.018204620108008385, -0.03278511390089989, -0.01651988923549652, -0.02599583938717842, -0.09160630404949188, 0.014608821831643581, 0.004113252740353346, 0.006521731149405241, 0.01197072397917509, 0.0666070282459259, 0.013594008050858974, -0.010116197168827057, -0.007668562699109316, -0.011244644410908222, 0.01200155634433031, 0.06289805471897125, -0.005367540754377842, 0.05688776075839996, -0.03484692424535751, -0.03701392933726311, 0.031411733478307724, -0.023419320583343506, 0.028691189363598824, 0.01927023194730282, -0.011740796267986298, -0.015892434865236282, -0.03303200751543045, 0.0513317845761776, -0.002597071463242173, -0.05779571831226349, 0.009565267711877823, -0.017361517995595932, -0.0043655685149133205, 0.000005420869001682149, 0.023546045646071434, -0.007329735904932022, -0.011525262147188187, 0.04037877544760704, -0.04517746716737747, -0.043586261570453644, -0.057940855622291565, 0.007334126625210047, -0.01720106229186058, -0.011666867882013321, 0.061096563935279846, -0.012139588594436646, 0.015667293220758438, -0.01545847486704588, 0.0019096818286925554, -0.001301590702496469, 0.005534000229090452, 0.04070892184972763, -0.06970548629760742, 0.002818184206262231, 0.05818236991763115, 0.023307040333747864, -0.01860406994819641, 0.050452299416065216, -0.04937790334224701, -0.051974065601825714, 0.025763826444745064, -0.0298240315169096, 0.0177766103297472, -0.029018744826316833, -0.013012305833399296, 0.012639573775231838, -0.010960235260426998, -0.019072309136390686, 0.03384348005056381, -0.054030586034059525, 0.06634555011987686, 0.05398222431540489, -0.01935240626335144, 0.025647535920143127, 0.0019786388147622347, -0.014927295967936516, -0.0004888051189482212, -0.029955536127090454, 0.021245941519737244, -0.039022404700517654, -0.0013676550006493926, 0.057400815188884735, -0.009075329639017582, -0.04501670226454735, 0.044645071029663086, 0.053183894604444504, 0.017984144389629364, -0.013318977318704128, 0.02459832839667797, -0.0065788691863417625, -0.060787275433540344, 0.020904602482914925, 0.05763401463627815, 0.028723014518618584, 0.02578158490359783, 0.023442482575774193, -0.015056988224387169, 0.04619564861059189, 0.04362530633807182, 0.0011415109038352966, 0.032292284071445465, -0.03792690113186836, -0.0011605157051235437, -0.0014074306236580014, -0.014081448316574097, -0.0016098901396617293, 0.008938079699873924, 0.017453333362936974, 0.009190097451210022, 0.01579413004219532, 0.005723456386476755, -0.002725028432905674, -0.005437806714326143, 0.019711308181285858, 0.039138082414865494, -0.00812592450529337, 0.014487474225461483, 0.031481433659791946, -0.0509355291724205, -0.012196316383779049, -0.06134124845266342, -0.03037969022989273, -0.020409343764185905, 0.03478028252720833, -0.0199236162006855, -0.002142311306670308, 0.025351909920573235, -0.04666717350482941, 0.008718275465071201, -0.03083920106291771, -0.0010463492944836617, 0.026573216542601585, -0.03224964067339897, -0.07610932737588882, -0.020413106307387352, -0.04196221008896828, -0.00809300784021616, 0.020545100793242455, -0.011082188226282597, -0.01751641370356083, 0.007696664426475763, 0.014981256797909737, -0.04140607267618179, -0.021588213741779327, -0.029116962105035782, 0.024705536663532257, -0.026888251304626465, -0.03200149163603783, 0.004882078617811203, 0.00855974480509758, -0.0363728329539299, 0.06198254972696304, 0.007789106108248234, -0.009881907142698765, -0.026997923851013184, -0.0058013563975691795, -0.015788940712809563, -0.0019400130258873105, -0.03953026980161667, 0.05645782873034477, -0.019025655463337898, -0.020754169672727585, -0.04186200723052025, -0.04489884898066521, 0.06750562787055969, -0.02399001270532608, 0.033863287419080734, -0.005704445764422417, -0.05417083203792572, 0.04281369596719742, 0.016964901238679886, -0.03376852348446846, -0.022733569145202637, 0.02057618647813797, -0.03932425379753113, 0.0004948758287355304, -0.004395444877445698, 0.025219561532139778, 0.016055593267083168, 0.02699930965900421, -0.01718982122838497, 0.03400842845439911, 0.046231459826231, 0.010587652213871479, -0.017702044919133186, 0.02531450428068638, 0.04305585101246834, 0.00034213793696835637, 0.03994634002447128, 0.023120639845728874, 0.005962856113910675, 0.008298664353787899, -0.010753590613603592, 0.010027926415205002, 0.002117091091349721, -0.017722632735967636, 0.047664888203144073, -0.01685454323887825, -0.0055232662707567215, -0.029040947556495667, 0.011605682782828808, 0.03466227278113365, -0.040859121829271317, -0.0010744532337412238, -0.0014881988754495978, 0.04264567419886589, -0.017274903133511543, 0.014187605120241642, 0.02747812122106552, 0.06856629252433777, -0.02747967094182968, -0.006108286324888468, -0.020448097959160805, -0.012118102051317692, 0.011128702200949192, -0.026504117995500565, -0.013764697127044201, 0.0061254543252289295, 0.054032228887081146, 0.035281386226415634, 0.015643607825040817, -0.06233173981308937, 0.018864650279283524, -0.05984490364789963, 0.039831217378377914, -0.03135162219405174, 0.0555981881916523, -0.013034435920417309, -0.0010024980874732137, 0.014894035644829273, -0.021812036633491516, 0.013193237595260143, 0.004640973173081875, -0.028999578207731247, 0.0038292543031275272, -0.006540845613926649, -0.00861018430441618, 0.01384021621197462, -0.01877759024500847, 0.003978307358920574, -0.05663241446018219, 0.037457242608070374, -0.00191188242752105, -0.003965235780924559, -0.038267605006694794, -0.027797769755125046, -0.041395653039216995, -0.028508789837360382, -0.019289596006274223, 0.02430911548435688, 0.019787650555372238, -0.033319488167762756, 0.026679158210754395, 0.022226227447390556, -0.01229663286358118, -0.0036751204170286655, 0.011135146021842957, 0.03753591328859329, 0.0012237754417583346, 0.042859092354774475, 0.046498846262693405, 0.013447866775095463, -0.06430060416460037, 0.03477798402309418, 0.035029154270887375, 0.05148044228553772, 0.05323994159698486, -0.019686048850417137, -0.011295239441096783, 0.005746305920183659, -0.029682975262403488, -0.015555472113192081, 0.03181667998433113, 0.027491126209497452, -0.00022923726646695286, 0.046827878803014755, 0.04198498651385307, -0.030850889161229134, 0.0058417548425495625, 0.0839257538318634, -0.007837698794901371, 0.02202361449599266, -0.03135800361633301, -0.05124490708112717, -0.02846342697739601, 0.006487058009952307, 0.018207300454378128, 0.019887447357177734, -0.006731885951012373, 0.0025163362734019756, 0.030049845576286316, -0.000008512053682352416, -0.040625907480716705, -0.026768850162625313, 0.05344577506184578, 0.05658339709043503, 0.02914220094680786, -0.010636793449521065, 0.017961742356419563, 0.03918912261724472, 0.05981435999274254, 0.010237609967589378, 0.00424444442614913, -0.07922553271055222, 0.027816863730549812, 0.041168443858623505, 0.078839972615242, -0.04518207535147667, 0.01582168973982334, -0.008402055129408836, 0.029383238404989243, 0.021755894646048546, -0.01132762897759676, 0.027709418907761574, -0.027113037183880806, 0.012096577323973179, -0.04080970212817192, -0.016872208565473557, -0.03203639015555382, 0.015770012512803078, -0.0014895823551341891, 0.03834683075547218, -0.008773069828748703, -0.03134286403656006, -0.03834369406104088, 0.0017092862399294972, 0.0011474279453977942, 0.033149972558021545, -0.014527828432619572, -0.02684364840388298, 0.006514622364193201, -0.004334528464823961, -0.015681445598602295, -0.07077696919441223, 0.011073993518948555, -0.025828741490840912, -0.03211836516857147, 0.04913695901632309, -0.008617871440947056, -0.0075677381828427315, 0.029900943860411644, 0.006789063569158316, -0.0685020461678505, -0.00926144141703844, 0.0075304945930838585, 0.029375238344073296, 0.015798045322299004, 0.0022760764695703983, 0.05221479386091232, 0.001621240982785821, -0.02927962876856327, -0.007734266575425863, -0.023706665262579918, 0.0288679376244545, -0.022923283278942108, -0.004880775697529316, -0.014084857888519764, -0.04193149507045746, -0.03635307773947716, 0.04603138566017151, 0.010937501676380634, 0.02732834964990616, -0.026630058884620667, 0.01761467009782791, 0.0025228119920939207, 0.039490412920713425, -0.012247961945831776, 0.003270782297477126, -0.00714458804577589, 0.026600593701004982, -0.0011542297434061766, 0.02477133274078369, 0.013993152417242527, -0.012012084946036339, -0.011837671510875225, 0.014124357141554356, -0.015511559322476387, 0.02795146033167839, -0.0032523046247661114, -0.016317298635840416, -0.0016530229477211833, 0.009572994895279408, 0.0094352588057518, -0.010641920380294323, 0.00006337133527267724, -0.007572547532618046, -0.028783105313777924, 0.002545790048316121, 0.009172225371003151, -0.006115694530308247, 0.022706516087055206, -0.04571360722184181, 0.059381842613220215, 0.0086132250726223, 0.016418254002928734, -0.05380530655384064, -0.004674839787185192, 0.02805618941783905, 0.020878860726952553, -0.02181691862642765, 0.006834227126091719, -0.025127237662672997, -0.020678259432315826, -0.038285791873931885, -0.024219729006290436, 0.07575403898954391, -0.012648952193558216, -0.04575466364622116, -0.008806160651147366, 0.0043275426141917706, 0.06311570107936859, 0.008184214122593403, 0.00733992038294673, 0.0154956029728055, -0.00421710591763258, -0.015154313296079636, 0.008547186851501465, 0.005892057437449694, -0.02653452567756176, -0.022282177582383156, -0.053034164011478424, -0.01330472156405449, 0.04000197350978851, 0.003213262651115656, -0.030974335968494415, 0.018815143033862114, -0.04887613281607628, -0.004097998607903719, -0.03915439173579216, -0.0020854859612882137, -0.03225310519337654, 0.024157170206308365, -0.00529475649818778, 0.011567767709493637, 0.0004782387404702604, 0.012881397269666195, 0.030292388051748276, -0.0006803717114962637, -0.04277319088578224, 0.017574474215507507, 0.0679100900888443, -0.036991387605667114, 0.04637720063328743, -0.0044669765047729015, -0.07206589728593826, 0.01723259873688221, -0.011919280514121056, -0.00007994676707312465, -0.009886449202895164, 0.038040027022361755, -0.00253285956569016, 0.0030167161021381617, -0.021223891526460648, 0.008264894597232342, 0.06311309337615967, 0.010916007682681084, 0.010451039299368858, 0.024454211816191673, 0.030482742935419083, 0.009219406172633171, -0.030729705467820168, -0.0037819715216755867, -0.001561697805300355, 0.023402009159326553, 0.013163183815777302, 0.01153691578656435, 0.021571794524788857, 0.07075324654579163, 0.059781044721603394, 0.003500739810988307, 0.019849533215165138, 0.00654492387548089, -0.0013180408859625459, 0.03904376178979874, -0.0650012269616127, -0.029256099835038185, 0.053541019558906555, -0.0539558120071888, -0.002896268153563142, -0.04605475068092346, -0.03618422523140907, 0.025914214551448822, 0.06604203581809998, 0.001105657429434359, -0.04045333340764046, -0.022270452231168747, -0.05700239539146423, 0.002786256605759263, -0.028558634221553802, 0.003827077569440007, 0.00993331614881754, -0.04185387119650841, 0.03239491209387779, 0.021134406328201294, 0.0074403067119419575, -0.002033123280853033, -0.07528641074895859, -0.07667656242847443, -0.014258844777941704, -0.002079755999147892, 0.017353126779198647, 0.011040057055652142, -0.05392562970519066, 0.015742741525173187, -0.025499235838651657, 0.0436626560986042, -0.0037308570463210344, 0.05269512161612511, -0.0015841185813769698, 0.053063176572322845, -0.03838108852505684, 0.04478394240140915, 0.013913558796048164, -0.06177588552236557, 0.09898693114519119, 0.05814024433493614, 0.04402798414230347, -0.0686565712094307, 0.05079628527164459, -0.012952388264238834, 0.0007965259719640017, -0.012695176526904106, 0.004826008807867765, 0.0052178120240569115, -0.006905884947627783, 0.011405719444155693, 0.07453476637601852, 0.01459192018955946, -0.03831885755062103, 0.039441972970962524, -0.03231548145413399, -0.011649574153125286, 0.008862246759235859, 0.021230153739452362, 0.02365696243941784, -0.04445752874016762, -0.012297439388930798, -0.03332984820008278, 0.0026703570038080215, 0.02114362083375454, -0.0018148993840441108, -0.002652324503287673, 0.011179731227457523, -0.010106032714247704, -0.005853855982422829, -0.01047399640083313, -0.024281300604343414, -0.0002071232011076063, -0.04064638912677765, -0.008963929489254951, -0.005385248921811581, -0.019116774201393127, 0.017545145004987717, 0.08504445105791092, 0.019262613728642464, -0.003107088152319193, 0.0010796657297760248, 0.011469729244709015, -0.0544193759560585, -0.02709336206316948, -0.012076308950781822, 0.051614392548799515, -0.02917664125561714, -0.03652963042259216, -0.007964348420500755, -0.02305842563509941, -0.010548843070864677, -0.05338841676712036, -0.03927477076649666, -0.008947503753006458, 0.024973899126052856, -0.02022385597229004, -0.03197411820292473, -0.044275976717472076, 0.03409985825419426, 0.010350054129958153, 0.03388996422290802, 0.01881934329867363, -0.02970178797841072, -0.016372228041291237, -0.03078634850680828, 0.03831887245178223, 0.021968862041831017, 0.006236049346625805, -0.010998991318047047, 0.017369961366057396, -0.04400000348687172, -0.011674832552671432, 0.0010256536770612001, 0.02051692269742489, 0.029697773978114128, -0.010259164497256279, -0.038738712668418884, -0.006707881111651659, -0.03172244504094124, 0.015962153673171997, -0.06512665748596191, 0.013578137382864952, -0.061067864298820496, -0.053995970636606216, 0.039558980613946915, 0.010674292221665382, 0.04137769341468811, 0.035748183727264404, -0.029753807932138443, 0.023131676018238068, -0.010287368670105934, -0.07033895701169968, -0.03782271966338158, 0.019176514819264412, -0.034334585070610046, 0.006852411199361086, -0.018074430525302887, 0.027973873540759087, 0.040146566927433014, 0.055311985313892365, 0.015309886075556278, -0.004446299280971289, 0.023556694388389587, 0.009786694310605526, 0.0241017434746027, -0.045317355543375015, -0.03947066143155098, 0.01623578369617462, 0.007726276759058237, -0.01981234736740589, -0.04483545199036598, -0.06921718269586563, -0.012316749431192875, 0.030395813286304474, -0.008618868887424469, -0.04795327037572861, 0.02735908515751362, -0.000856597616802901, 0.02884814143180847, -0.04962630942463875, 0.0034548891708254814, -0.038203515112400055, 0.006167547777295113, 0.0031146788969635963, -0.013452584855258465, -0.014529472216963768, -0.02680891752243042, -0.02492571622133255, 0.009892064146697521, 0.049247246235609055, 0.0029527803417295218, -0.022296832874417305, -0.003579378128051758, 0.005544860381633043, 0.013479601591825485, 0.05218851566314697, -0.02909259684383869, -0.01625397428870201, 0.05166146159172058, -0.029842015355825424, -0.035680972039699554, 0.041562341153621674, 0.010229293256998062, 0.019642099738121033, 0.012551898136734962, 0.007701494265347719, -0.005488332826644182, 0.020819595083594322, -0.009920873679220676, -0.009936045855283737, -0.0019346560584381223, -0.008724854327738285, -0.0012621254427358508, 0.04347941651940346, 0.015401355922222137, -0.01615995354950428, -0.027409838512539864, 0.06966376304626465, 0.08501873910427094, 0.06698782742023468, -0.01077717449516058, 0.00970297772437334, -0.02806011401116848, 0.03255767747759819, 0.03021099604666233, 0.013047238811850548, 0.0155563959851861, 0.06365914642810822, 0.006814946886152029, 0.039447784423828125, 0.0003543994971551001, 0.015979308634996414, -0.09815077483654022, -0.011728128418326378, 0.010301852598786354, 0.04369107633829117, 0.012261164374649525, -0.04351287707686424, 0.005511786323040724, -0.009984583593904972, -0.04891963675618172, 0.05557230859994888, 0.007269751746207476, -0.05424770340323448, -0.023721521720290184, 0.018448155373334885, -0.006720350589603186, 0.033105120062828064, 0.002238309010863304, 0.004232154693454504, 0.01715504378080368, -0.007411452941596508, -0.006518236361443996, -0.029849378392100334, -0.040199387818574905, 0.021103300154209137, 0.0236099511384964, -0.045599862933158875, 0.024452026933431625, -0.01696780137717724, -0.059926703572273254, 0.00958650466054678, -0.0161836426705122, 0.01112801767885685, 0.037444911897182465, 0.01933428831398487, -0.0008950400515459478, 0.011040044948458672, 0.06294635683298111, -0.01587831601500511, -0.027499163523316383, 0.03521939739584923, 0.0027339656371623278, 0.030955780297517776, -0.033750154078006744, -0.007935581728816032, -0.0016814018599689007, -0.006942512467503548, -0.008879116736352444, 0.01652350462973118, -0.019616656005382538, -0.027084728702902794, 0.0017845327965915203, 0.019750477746129036, 0.016263164579868317, -0.005666464567184448, 0.011497809551656246, -0.03355582058429718, -0.019660092890262604, 0.021463343873620033, 0.04935934767127037, -0.026970114558935165, 0.026150962337851524, -0.0031586720142513514, -0.02133942022919655, 0.003759474726393819, -0.02705499902367592, 0.004702611826360226, -0.05078829079866409, 0.0015459585702046752, -0.01967872865498066, -0.006207731086760759, -0.03499092161655426, -0.02246410772204399, -0.02575884759426117, 0.016208956018090248, -0.023311208933591843, 0.029250698164105415, 0.02430068328976631, -0.02025541104376316, 0.005934766959398985, -0.06593602150678635, 0.051430560648441315, -0.024352803826332092, -0.034118495881557465, -0.011578196659684181, 0.025373799726366997, -0.05500773712992668, 0.02107119746506214, 0.05126924812793732, -0.013087650761008263, 0.023311853408813477, -0.013812732882797718, -0.015662139281630516, 0.002791227074339986, -0.10238294303417206, 0.02183401584625244, 0.0023207732010632753, -0.004145616665482521, -0.021390879526734352, -0.03081701323390007, 0.019559768959879875, 0.004382339306175709, 0.028265707194805145, -0.020059669390320778, 0.04775794595479965, 0.0138165932148695, 0.024328356608748436, 0.04477059841156006, 0.021955329924821854, 0.00007248828478623182, 0.0193494763225317, 0.007067765574902296, 0.0470234639942646, 0.03412645682692528, -0.00037543411599472165, -0.05781443789601326, 0.024714834988117218, -0.04181560128927231, -0.02433508262038231, -0.0016656500520184636, 0.007328916806727648, -0.011299342848360538, -0.06395163387060165, 0.007325728423893452, 0.014204422011971474, 0.005621159449219704, -0.010042096488177776, 0.013972850516438484, 0.04490402713418007, 0.024895334616303444, -0.019998813048005104, 0.018971627578139305, -0.002733435481786728, -0.018678726628422737, -0.004958641715347767, 0.013118844479322433, 0.018107431009411812, 0.016579169780015945, -0.0008663347689434886, 0.022535093128681183, -0.023946788161993027, 0.033437784761190414, 0.004190109204500914, 0.036080170422792435, -0.016436081379652023, -0.042447108775377274, -0.005930595565587282, 0.019970059394836426, 0.006246672011911869, -0.018920138478279114, -0.009960141032934189, 0.041431769728660583, -0.04184655472636223, 0.018807491287589073, -0.025380373001098633, -0.004687001928687096, -0.002307093935087323, -0.03823310509324074, 0.010521819815039635, 0.03454900160431862, -0.027889646589756012, 0.015671417117118835, 0.015774160623550415, 0.014692317694425583, 0.022821731865406036, 0.017667416483163834, 0.0229662973433733, -0.017947277054190636, 0.011677526868879795, -0.011549344286322594, -0.032878484576940536, -0.017128344625234604, -0.03231620788574219, -0.009904973208904266, 0.03729882463812828, 0.05498663708567619, -0.054076194763183594, -0.012567554600536823, -0.02680210955440998, 0.046177055686712265, -0.04304612800478935, -0.04250616207718849, -0.04381823167204857, -0.008533850312232971, 0.027582285925745964, -0.0037403784226626158 ]
<p>First off, I know little about statistics, so some of this question may seem naive.</p> <p>I'm trying to perform linear regression to model the relationship between x and y where:</p> <p>-x is a company's daily stock volume on a date</p> <p>-y is variable that is taken from the same date, however is something unrelated to stock volume. It is the volume of activity on that wikipedia for that company.</p> <p>I assume that the variables need normalising. Specifically, x needs to be normalised as overall index volume fluctuates. My first thoughts were to divide the daily volume by the total index volume. I'll do the same with the y variable. </p> <p>I just wondered if this seems sensible? Thanks</p> <p>EDIT:</p> <p>I've just noticed a typo in the question, the Y variable description has changed.</p>
73,631
[ -0.01947508379817009, -0.012360043823719025, -0.007460556458681822, 0.006805372890084982, 0.040927790105342865, 0.0296175517141819, -0.0008289550896733999, -0.0023316845763474703, 0.054857756942510605, -0.03414513170719147, 0.022766346111893654, 0.05867059528827667, 0.06434626877307892, 0.001907232333905995, 0.05440724641084671, 0.023190341889858246, -0.029228102415800095, -0.006276163272559643, 0.015333633869886398, -0.019528135657310486, -0.010520667769014835, 0.016716085374355316, 0.0003328712482471019, 0.006697401404380798, -0.0122938621789217, 0.049823932349681854, 0.022858677431941032, 0.008442828431725502, -0.005702739115804434, 0.05839889869093895, -0.030179418623447418, -0.058905936777591705, 0.02259650267660618, 0.07332313805818558, 0.008733496069908142, 0.010514074936509132, -0.008396393619477749, -0.03130435198545456, -0.04333658143877983, 0.05401599407196045, -0.0012685572728514671, -0.000518480665050447, -0.005156772211194038, 0.05988825112581253, -0.00805714912712574, 0.059397678822278976, 0.0026986540760844946, -0.05091789364814758, 0.026645921170711517, -0.04749181494116783, 0.08438967913389206, -0.009364882484078407, 0.023937465623021126, 0.04848921671509743, -0.008927866816520691, -0.009102226234972477, 0.044310182332992554, 0.05755385756492615, -0.010523666627705097, -0.03408508002758026, -0.03083888255059719, -0.003929273225367069, -0.01964656449854374, 0.011797016486525536, -0.021528897807002068, 0.00862232968211174, 0.003031326225027442, -0.014355889521539211, 0.03495650738477707, -0.059908829629421234, 0.023786496371030807, 0.03163100779056549, 0.04343944415450096, -0.026555713266134262, 0.017354389652609825, -0.029150014743208885, 0.024974757805466652, 0.0461365170776844, 0.025378001853823662, 0.040852759033441544, 0.012449930422008038, 0.011655491776764393, 0.003912182524800301, 0.03749958053231239, 0.01908062770962715, -0.00003483727414277382, 0.08333002775907516, -0.04054812341928482, 0.01116045843809843, 0.0596558153629303, -0.016884921118617058, 0.008380969054996967, 0.07531312853097916, 0.006847790442407131, -0.04356617107987404, 0.05343366041779518, -0.022845933213829994, 0.04243920370936394, 0.04345307499170303, -0.005736558232456446, -0.0008272280101664364, -0.05192556977272034, -0.0017851614393293858, 0.033754441887140274, -0.027588607743382454, -0.012571639381349087, -0.015181371942162514, 0.02253161184489727, -0.0026560586411505938, -0.05028196796774864, -0.03564165160059929, -0.0023913257755339146, 0.013407411053776741, -0.0577327162027359, 0.02897127903997898, -0.024013621732592583, -0.035888124257326126, 0.006949773523956537, 0.06556934863328934, 0.0767623633146286, 0.02661656029522419, -0.01664731092751026, 0.05051236227154732, 0.015921836718916893, -0.0472019761800766, 0.020513534545898438, 0.003723854897543788, -0.013218875043094158, -0.04744427651166916, 0.07079432904720306, -0.006320179905742407, -0.01269188430160284, 0.05189264193177223, -0.0447501614689827, 0.03841773420572281, 0.03355170041322708, -0.06463883072137833, -0.03755800053477287, 0.026138417422771454, 0.002415133873000741, 0.014767911285161972, -0.06490147858858109, -0.01763167977333069, 0.024698859080672264, 0.04371902719140053, 0.03381558507680893, 0.05381821468472481, 0.027320723980665207, 0.014730438590049744, -0.008473995141685009, -0.018410922959446907, -0.017091501504182816, -0.0005154372192919254, -0.054974526166915894, -0.004037796985358, -0.06523540616035461, -0.007658345624804497, 0.022063646465539932, 0.004195614717900753, -0.015604913234710693, 0.032824818044900894, 0.006544005591422319, -0.03953154757618904, 0.03465591371059418, 0.010435889475047588, -0.059997159987688065, 0.0344996303319931, 0.014452326111495495, 0.04908455163240433, 0.026993930339813232, 0.020277999341487885, 0.006164242513477802, -0.009320078417658806, 0.024842403829097748, 0.03767026215791702, -0.016460008919239044, -0.005605428479611874, -0.04331163316965103, 0.03446294739842415, 0.021426528692245483, -0.040845464915037155, -0.045514002442359924, -0.0472077839076519, 0.011115535162389278, 0.0245758555829525, 0.052138444036245346, 0.026064906269311905, 0.011585475876927376, 0.03518599271774292, -0.05415678024291992, -0.0510413832962513, -0.04761486500501633, 0.005037661176174879, -0.05388970300555229, -0.0039061186835169792, -0.00618052389472723, -0.002540099900215864, 0.030832812190055847, -0.020352916792035103, -0.04037849232554436, 0.014683278277516365, -0.02011124975979328, 0.04652945697307587, -0.03743138536810875, 0.008885238319635391, 0.027432959526777267, 0.03832557424902916, -0.027277767658233643, 0.023677844554185867, -0.05967798829078674, -0.026664946228265762, 0.0018734565237537026, -0.047261156141757965, -0.0001452187425456941, -0.009842682629823685, -0.011423328891396523, 0.02888147346675396, 0.004981000907719135, -0.00912412628531456, -0.00395558774471283, -0.035759732127189636, 0.065569207072258, 0.06609001755714417, 0.0008728780085220933, -0.03463968262076378, -0.01576053351163864, 0.030409108847379684, 0.03291567787528038, 0.0077057452872395515, -0.012118177488446236, -0.057153765112161636, 0.01958507113158703, 0.012855304405093193, 0.015430785715579987, -0.016934361308813095, 0.01087096892297268, 0.09956938773393631, 0.0021842778660357, 0.006797250360250473, 0.03278284892439842, -0.007106856442987919, -0.005855495110154152, -0.0025599331129342318, -0.01897820085287094, 0.015123289078474045, -0.010874739848077297, -0.0007198553648777306, -0.015952246263623238, 0.02751222997903824, 0.012365421280264854, -0.00970050785690546, 0.016679096966981888, 0.003830388654023409, 0.01785574108362198, -0.005185605492442846, -0.027872230857610703, 0.047345954924821854, -0.007361149415373802, -0.017603561282157898, 0.026235681027173996, -0.011415306478738785, -0.010333389043807983, -0.013004117645323277, -0.0032002876978367567, -0.008361841551959515, 0.017897795885801315, -0.05887233838438988, 0.012287615798413754, 0.008514683693647385, -0.018282784149050713, 0.0008526250021532178, -0.01733209192752838, -0.03577692434191704, -0.014840405434370041, 0.02655082382261753, 0.014986426569521427, 0.020338522270321846, 0.027698198333382607, -0.03141866624355316, -0.03240366652607918, -0.013180974870920181, -0.013256912119686604, -0.011675393208861351, -0.011392929591238499, -0.06056160107254982, -0.025522608309984207, -0.006549794692546129, -0.03637736290693283, 0.01751377433538437, -0.01926645077764988, 0.01812528446316719, 0.030097633600234985, -0.0008466076687909663, -0.04202254116535187, -0.04139731079339981, -0.028499692678451538, 0.028151830658316612, 0.009832942858338356, -0.006972382310777903, 0.02654997818171978, 0.000461770425317809, -0.048597097396850586, 0.003293465357273817, -0.048122987151145935, -0.01572166197001934, -0.04712217301130295, -0.03118499554693699, -0.014014814980328083, -0.011974724009633064, 0.0076933978125452995, 0.01728709042072296, -0.026840809732675552, 0.0006090195383876562, -0.04808506742119789, -0.06801891326904297, 0.038312382996082306, -0.0008777313632890582, 0.007381793111562729, -0.008952288888394833, -0.026560474187135696, 0.0408918559551239, 0.0062973713502287865, -0.029958728700876236, -0.05258344113826752, 0.008352327160537243, -0.042396556586027145, -0.04234406352043152, 0.02782299742102623, 0.04452237859368324, 0.028788305819034576, 0.024175841361284256, 0.013014502823352814, 0.018388310447335243, 0.05518535152077675, 0.035526759922504425, 0.002845618175342679, 0.011861448176205158, 0.017976175993680954, 0.001911798259243369, 0.03687546029686928, 0.03579511120915413, -0.007457779720425606, -0.000143494937219657, -0.03205987438559532, 0.02870391309261322, 0.02542705461382866, -0.026824764907360077, 0.026745937764644623, -0.017937226220965385, 0.01309544499963522, 0.006868127267807722, 0.023640142753720284, -0.010567424818873405, -0.05075005814433098, -0.0035476593766361475, 0.0033386715222150087, 0.010168691165745258, 0.003044885117560625, 0.005818706471472979, 0.06954548507928848, 0.032289836555719376, 0.0019666855223476887, -0.022863106802105904, -0.02255282737314701, -0.010927170515060425, 0.005556102842092514, -0.061610039323568344, -0.0121035510674119, 0.011767963878810406, 0.03036564216017723, 0.024620281532406807, -0.014618795365095139, -0.04724568501114845, -0.0025223002303391695, -0.07281960546970367, -0.01308212149888277, -0.01751873269677162, 0.026495711877942085, 0.027790291234850883, 0.02783125266432762, 0.033270206302404404, -0.03194163367152214, 0.04702330008149147, -0.02498799003660679, -0.05745849385857582, 0.02809063345193863, -0.02611430361866951, -0.011992355808615685, 0.002427233848720789, 0.009495039470493793, 0.0329468697309494, 0.003793592331930995, 0.0004036536265630275, 0.018633097410202026, -0.010247858241200447, -0.0564325675368309, -0.00462572555989027, -0.024502042680978775, -0.023288147523999214, 0.002501186914741993, -0.002181192161515355, 0.012269792146980762, 0.03435452654957771, 0.014463718049228191, 0.02297300472855568, 0.004296833649277687, -0.022978201508522034, -0.0054510049521923065, 0.012141739949584007, 0.03928384184837341, 0.014602681621909142, -0.011037002317607403, 0.022428136318922043, -0.028775926679372787, 0.038671817630529404, -0.022241070866584778, 0.006347212474793196, 0.06385864317417145, 0.009459822438657284, -0.004061385989189148, -0.020572088658809662, 0.00942292157560587, 0.02849849872291088, 0.0013663184363394976, 0.005308140534907579, 0.02899792417883873, 0.05591275915503502, 0.02998783439397812, -0.017317811027169228, 0.010330009274184704, 0.1107906624674797, -0.016283299773931503, -0.02238825149834156, -0.019251422956585884, 0.018007710576057434, -0.002426294842734933, -0.016129570081830025, 0.03296086564660072, 0.00906280055642128, -0.005216157529503107, 0.00720636174082756, 0.0061706667765975, 0.004054098855704069, -0.03173823282122612, 0.040274448692798615, 0.011628245003521442, 0.04295368492603302, -0.007768426090478897, -0.059668466448783875, 0.037090741097927094, 0.048420317471027374, 0.03821191191673279, 0.002324150176718831, -0.011807458475232124, -0.10638442635536194, 0.018077302724123, 0.03414035588502884, 0.07123226672410965, -0.02965322509407997, -0.01153414323925972, -0.009766863659024239, -0.009265315718948841, 0.033819738775491714, -0.01867353357374668, -0.002295684302225709, -0.031201373785734177, -0.01068594865500927, 0.007207330781966448, -0.008000952191650867, -0.0599115714430809, 0.0007741836016066372, -0.03906315565109253, 0.011743943206965923, -0.016053026542067528, -0.04045502468943596, -0.07733409106731415, 0.013943884521722794, 0.006233479827642441, 0.04916704073548317, -0.012747402302920818, -0.04079563170671463, 0.006174658890813589, 0.048275597393512726, -0.01660722680389881, -0.047379378229379654, 0.02351001463830471, 0.028240399435162544, -0.0001463030930608511, 0.03234795853495598, 0.012295540422201157, -0.014935100451111794, 0.012366663664579391, 0.027181867510080338, -0.0003347751626279205, 0.006913243792951107, 0.020318813621997833, 0.023259805515408516, 0.006948314607143402, 0.013153619132936, 0.05422525852918625, 0.06027849763631821, 0.00672683771699667, -0.01511884294450283, -0.015647251158952713, 0.009421669878065586, -0.007721427828073502, -0.0015568886883556843, -0.04057372733950615, 0.014127408154308796, 0.016246309503912926, 0.019097518175840378, -0.03365149721503258, -0.004188584629446268, -0.05666293203830719, -0.024772604927420616, -0.004634498618543148, -0.009133558720350266, -0.006880898494273424, -0.056626904755830765, 0.017329763621091843, 0.005428215488791466, -0.049236979335546494, -0.03163892403244972, 0.008794036693871021, -0.046751223504543304, 0.011448932811617851, 0.028140276670455933, -0.011481737717986107, -0.0007729661301709712, 0.030510053038597107, -0.031130487099289894, 0.0030475652310997248, 0.013448139652609825, -0.013027899898588657, -0.01567583531141281, 0.025065982714295387, 0.008245151489973068, -0.014298305846750736, 0.0003749545430764556, 0.037774402648210526, 0.010308470577001572, 0.03634314239025116, -0.04788641631603241, 0.04428580775856972, -0.04328082501888275, -0.006722979713231325, -0.060163356363773346, -0.07565979659557343, 0.044582489877939224, 0.005179694388061762, -0.024988053366541862, -0.03726022690534592, -0.0016619270900264382, -0.03231543302536011, -0.01210799440741539, -0.016128981485962868, 0.019465776160359383, -0.041026875376701355, -0.02641587145626545, -0.030398018658161163, 0.013505308888852596, 0.08125369995832443, 0.026336990296840668, -0.017865492030978203, 0.022603003308176994, 0.021508440375328064, -0.011153731495141983, -0.017360929399728775, -0.005624005571007729, -0.047617144882678986, -0.0008992943912744522, -0.024057360365986824, -0.03412650525569916, 0.04899798706173897, -0.047606538981199265, -0.030686495825648308, 0.01808001473546028, 0.031136970967054367, -0.00849668774753809, -0.04651670157909393, 0.024988794699311256, -0.006900300271809101, -0.010583330877125263, -0.01331121101975441, -0.004778136499226093, -0.023540347814559937, 0.01445745024830103, 0.008949109353125095, -0.013851366005837917, -0.011769790202379227, 0.005696019623428583, 0.055092133581638336, 0.0059719085693359375, 0.01892351731657982, -0.029937153682112694, 0.004084686748683453, 0.03483078256249428, 0.013496920466423035, -0.0040385848842561245, -0.017625123262405396, 0.02023230865597725, -0.011201538145542145, -0.045889224857091904, -0.01940826140344143, 0.0031646236311644316, 0.058326493948698044, -0.011944434605538845, 0.044062916189432144, 0.07399170845746994, 0.04209068417549133, -0.02064552903175354, -0.03592977300286293, -0.024917583912611008, -0.01964939944446087, -0.008357631042599678, 0.015438140369951725, -0.008023926056921482, -0.004799460992217064, 0.025318574160337448, 0.011730998754501343, 0.01084089744836092, 0.044802647083997726, 0.04012425243854523, 0.021128596737980843, 0.01783810369670391, 0.010612888261675835, -0.07319028675556183, 0.021543337032198906, -0.02645082026720047, 0.04281923174858093, -0.059275317937135696, -0.033588625490665436, 0.03682866320014, 0.015988510102033615, -0.001477375510148704, -0.0670212134718895, -0.024181855842471123, -0.03220520541071892, -0.00688606221228838, 0.03847947344183922, -0.01623343862593174, 0.02458733320236206, 0.02528475970029831, 0.04258209094405174, 0.009708041325211525, 0.03656396642327309, 0.005190628580749035, -0.08424258232116699, -0.008504251018166542, -0.02921956777572632, -0.011927267536520958, 0.036027032881975174, -0.0002959112171083689, -0.007340271957218647, 0.008118929341435432, -0.04998084902763367, -0.04503335431218147, 0.0007063926896080375, 0.04899865388870239, 0.014548041857779026, 0.05764295160770416, 0.0003443921450525522, -0.04280467331409454, -0.028606120496988297, -0.0067849368788301945, 0.10644689947366714, 0.08233693987131119, 0.020265262573957443, -0.04808633774518967, -0.01493377797305584, -0.001304947305470705, 0.001780664548277855, -0.05109294131398201, -0.005797663703560829, 0.007479946594685316, -0.018960218876600266, 0.061650294810533524, 0.055902402848005295, 0.010284545831382275, 0.005814303178340197, 0.050064463168382645, -0.020130742341279984, -0.014792807400226593, 0.005660886410623789, 0.007209875620901585, 0.0013515186728909612, -0.004957434721291065, -0.06700924783945084, 0.03355461731553078, -0.03470279276371002, -0.021716540679335594, -0.012849775142967701, -0.009969309903681278, -0.019635004922747612, 0.02591189183294773, -0.04883882775902748, 0.033455997705459595, 0.0272678192704916, 0.03039040043950081, -0.006574289407581091, -0.016299275681376457, 0.04001724347472191, -0.02025495655834675, -0.03298972174525261, 0.028950514271855354, 0.011836809106171131, -0.013330199755728245, -0.010786401107907295, 0.0012275828048586845, -0.06299537420272827, -0.0022355299443006516, -0.02058858424425125, 0.05059749633073807, 0.021028712391853333, -0.012541144154965878, -0.006294829770922661, -0.009168988093733788, -0.011398987844586372, -0.03767867386341095, 0.011982369236648083, 0.0404411256313324, 0.04951082170009613, -0.03056374378502369, 0.014495127834379673, -0.008160936646163464, 0.0008963008294813335, -0.003442994551733136, 0.039968084543943405, 0.045542798936367035, -0.018823636695742607, -0.009563306346535683, 0.006107847206294537, 0.051035840064287186, -0.0499175600707531, -0.015502684749662876, 0.003976504784077406, -0.0015568420058116317, -0.05575256422162056, -0.0005320972413755953, -0.009450042620301247, -0.01742691732943058, 0.010241947136819363, -0.018617913126945496, 0.003935766872018576, -0.010750156827270985, -0.03852025046944618, 0.014187882654368877, 0.0059171440079808235, -0.008537372574210167, -0.0689716637134552, 0.024440307170152664, 0.023896725848317146, 0.035907525569200516, -0.007324873935431242, -0.01749541610479355, -0.005325922276824713, 0.07008720934391022, 0.02489122748374939, -0.03235906362533569, -0.04680958390235901, 0.02804909273982048, -0.031167149543762207, -0.0031762048602104187, 0.00811164639890194, 0.04942897707223892, 0.017280003055930138, 0.006695927120745182, -0.010426658205688, 0.01607085019350052, -0.029998790472745895, 0.04452253878116608, 0.014777363277971745, -0.09361027181148529, 0.0031919709872454405, 0.02458646148443222, -0.009059424512088299, -0.022696880623698235, -0.03024696372449398, -0.004921389743685722, 0.005585385486483574, 0.03984491154551506, -0.010031151585280895, -0.020654505118727684, 0.020940061658620834, -0.036518972367048264, 0.045455824583768845, -0.024755842983722687, 0.00047691797954030335, -0.03439730778336525, 0.02052517607808113, 0.0030704920645803213, -0.01574012264609337, -0.008347775787115097, -0.002879550913348794, 0.005746568087488413, 0.01788461022078991, 0.02542705275118351, 0.021729636937379837, 0.028496434912085533, -0.025149347260594368, 0.021612918004393578, -0.005757464095950127, 0.03957203030586243, -0.05610077455639839, -0.029176117852330208, 0.021228915080428123, -0.017362885177135468, -0.04695591330528259, 0.02119961939752102, 0.022621165961027145, 0.035314273089170456, -0.01089832466095686, 0.014540757983922958, -0.009157889522612095, 0.0417296476662159, -0.020627593621611595, 0.026361383497714996, 0.02831016108393669, -0.01135759986937046, 0.003453717101365328, -0.003334370208904147, 0.015091368928551674, 0.060054194182157516, -0.01439824141561985, 0.03231612592935562, 0.06007609888911247, -0.02430252730846405, 0.006808883976191282, 0.008592360652983189, 0.02398536540567875, 0.008030984550714493, 0.005243194289505482, -0.04007026180624962, 0.06566109508275986, 0.01305979024618864, -0.05769987031817436, -0.00963714811950922, -0.0002187464851886034, 0.00519871199503541, -0.044670477509498596, -0.019963402301073074, 0.011341465637087822, -0.01507902517914772, 0.020972417667508125, -0.02986990660429001, -0.02324136160314083, 0.01003204844892025, -0.047345612198114395, -0.003028217703104019, -0.0057153296656906605, -0.02726130373775959, 0.003188604488968849, -0.008041231893002987, 0.017128828912973404, 0.01961781457066536, 0.017798442393541336, 0.021479932591319084, 0.03775712475180626, 0.02486724965274334, 0.02590600587427616, -0.03255154937505722, 0.0034078615717589855, 0.002403208753094077, 0.03440301865339279, -0.04314882308244705, 0.0011125189485028386, -0.03740238770842552, -0.02128221094608307, 0.04318642243742943, -0.01951037161052227, 0.04497835785150528, 0.022169170901179314, 0.028665773570537567, 0.012955420650541782, 0.038639798760414124, 0.02791488729417324, 0.023500794544816017, -0.008320094086229801, 0.0023835531901568174, 0.03370115906000137, 0.04830634221434593, 0.022291837260127068, -0.0019276380771771073, 0.028778614476323128, -0.04549506679177284, 0.02045358158648014, 0.011421676725149155, 0.02153158001601696, 0.029229309409856796, -0.049180202186107635, -0.0282945167273283, 0.0020878238137811422, -0.03453054651618004, 0.01403797697275877, -0.03251924738287926, -0.001971903722733259, 0.05144978314638138, 0.013771937228739262, -0.0324905663728714, -0.017627064138650894, -0.04071855545043945, -0.0734764114022255, 0.015600203536450863, 0.002725053345784545, 0.031224669888615608, -0.05886799097061157, -0.0010286909528076649, -0.008219881914556026, -0.04862767457962036, -0.0016623808769509196, -0.02490551769733429, -0.04130777344107628, 0.060791753232479095, -0.015431220643222332, -0.015752514824271202, 0.01962733268737793, 0.004067449830472469, 0.01358268316835165, -0.07965384423732758, 0.06599362939596176, 0.04125701263546944, -0.0017573314253240824, 0.010175436735153198, 0.0231995340436697, -0.03455372527241707, -0.004400200676172972, 0.056180261075496674, 0.007931840606033802, -0.0037531526759266853, -0.01988339237868786, 0.00713289575651288, -0.023502789437770844, -0.03529885411262512, 0.03432305157184601, -0.03654797002673149, -0.03575361520051956, 0.014879032969474792, -0.01141773909330368, 0.01481915544718504, 0.008829225786030293, 0.01706058718264103, -0.013570567592978477, -0.005703409668058157, 0.004155255854129791, -0.016669007018208504, 0.01413708459585905, 0.005807819310575724, -0.044799450784921646, 0.006454374175518751, 0.055902425199747086, 0.0018849499756470323, 0.0767323225736618, 0.023282552137970924, -0.08171119540929794, 0.00977319199591875, -0.0784861296415329, -0.013488451950252056, -0.0023263171315193176, 0.006160507909953594, 0.005049793981015682, -0.06911604851484299, 0.003693191334605217, 0.035554878413677216, -0.05236335098743439, 0.0025462480261921883, 0.022213157266378403, 0.015759779140353203, 0.04568309336900711, -0.012078346684575081, 0.019504835829138756, 0.019424164667725563, 0.010303756222128868, 0.011396663263440132, -0.013315418735146523, 0.06582599878311157, -0.0075368089601397514, -0.009373985230922699, 0.028751278296113014, -0.002362047554925084, 0.034151483327150345, -0.008876238949596882, 0.007921688258647919, -0.04442114755511284, -0.0010819043964147568, 0.012649196200072765, -0.03200219199061394, 0.008899185806512833, 0.018302228301763535, 0.018171031028032303, 0.03693188726902008, -0.05948943272233009, -0.0008801125804893672, -0.04089377820491791, -0.04080260917544365, -0.024796361103653908, 0.007933308370411396, -0.003604234429076314, 0.01868651993572712, -0.007445337250828743, -0.024978136643767357, 0.009799523279070854, -0.024371424689888954, 0.04094362631440163, -0.014247779734432697, -0.017980752512812614, -0.06755196303129196, -0.01259587612003088, 0.008804861456155777, -0.03991219401359558, -0.07274002581834793, -0.023575132712721825, 0.030321625992655754, 0.051281608641147614, 0.005758625455200672, -0.0130276158452034, -0.011023050174117088, -0.02008606120944023, 0.04315302520990372, -0.05422455444931984, 0.0017514127539470792, -0.02143332175910473, 0.009214011952280998, 0.026696735993027687, -0.01624724268913269 ]
<p>I have data sets of the returns of two indexes in the same market (two different sets of stocks constituting each index), with 496 observations for each. I want to compare if the means are statistically different. I believe the variances are different, so I think I have to check if the variances are statistically different first. How would I do these things?</p>
36,032
[ -0.054974015802145004, 0.00928111094981432, -0.047728799283504486, 0.013917672447860241, 0.027004064992070198, 0.03703801706433296, 0.005446300376206636, -0.028619350865483284, 0.013662279583513737, -0.001637254492379725, 0.052855294197797775, 0.03670811280608177, 0.04344622790813446, 0.054626982659101486, 0.028840478509664536, 0.005030207801610231, -0.0343521386384964, 0.004898422863334417, -0.012367048300802708, -0.036175791174173355, 0.016237718984484673, 0.0110397357493639, 0.013498556800186634, -0.015552637167274952, -0.04313342645764351, 0.029757147654891014, 0.022139400243759155, -0.0019398919539526105, -0.0018904029857367277, 0.048566125333309174, -0.06704071909189224, -0.03679145127534866, 0.01764172501862049, 0.03382240980863571, 0.006864887662231922, 0.01972118578851223, -0.024090146645903587, -0.030711768195033073, -0.02602727897465229, 0.021513184532523155, -0.040309835225343704, 0.008067891001701355, -0.0051358710043132305, 0.022126996889710426, -0.003520186059176922, -0.011619074270129204, 0.008476168848574162, -0.030976668000221252, 0.017774520441889763, -0.04982028901576996, 0.10209093987941742, 0.007634431589394808, 0.05621485784649849, 0.04125748574733734, -0.03775421530008316, 0.019168928265571594, 0.010498464107513428, 0.06127220392227173, 0.004489568993449211, -0.031441714614629745, -0.008419769816100597, -0.011395818553864956, 0.01180038508027792, -0.025575853884220123, -0.03996943682432175, 0.027122076600790024, -0.014960521832108498, -0.02892191894352436, 0.02750581130385399, -0.009658734314143658, 0.03132809326052666, 0.026427289471030235, 0.037452250719070435, -0.005722092464566231, 0.0037497931625694036, -0.031595028936862946, 0.018531344830989838, 0.011099039576947689, 0.05318744480609894, 0.03408150374889374, 0.011085263453423977, 0.01664697751402855, 0.03158266469836235, 0.03914729133248329, 0.03465981408953667, -0.025887275114655495, 0.05507102981209755, -0.011531533673405647, 0.005692275241017342, 0.046392772346735, 0.0046910736709833145, -0.037596575915813446, 0.04849710687994957, 0.002700173994526267, -0.04944385960698128, 0.029409460723400116, -0.027000974863767624, 0.026483653113245964, -0.013909134082496166, 0.0022846912033855915, 0.005861647427082062, -0.04017743840813637, 0.055799465626478195, 0.0375555045902729, 0.003043745644390583, -0.026872823014855385, -0.02561573125422001, 0.009138242341578007, -0.02392347902059555, -0.00497784186154604, 0.025333676487207413, 0.007843940518796444, 0.00818995013833046, -0.011101756244897842, 0.05471343174576759, 0.012626702897250652, -0.018594946712255478, -0.04233419522643089, 0.04874168708920479, 0.06544282287359238, 0.0435723252594471, -0.008149828761816025, -0.0007121136877685785, -0.013588720001280308, -0.02647431567311287, 0.022653916850686073, 0.0012449966743588448, -0.01388902124017477, -0.048236265778541565, 0.05727637931704521, -0.030865972861647606, -0.03317062929272652, 0.011678734794259071, -0.04533069580793381, 0.04079741984605789, 0.019393540918827057, -0.07548056542873383, -0.05654660612344742, 0.05031704530119896, -0.03213746100664139, -0.01627977192401886, -0.06065107509493828, 0.0035307640209794044, 0.018931493163108826, 0.00990613829344511, 0.006802548188716173, 0.04347711801528931, 0.013955693691968918, 0.021913520991802216, 0.028840741142630577, -0.031104935333132744, -0.01891070418059826, -0.02421034500002861, -0.0000360282720066607, 0.013129926286637783, -0.05909491702914238, -0.01993345096707344, -0.030082745477557182, -0.06679006665945053, -0.0010308172786608338, -0.003891524625942111, 0.017986910417675972, -0.01673232391476631, -0.001992511795833707, 0.024207590147852898, -0.00017524797294754535, 0.06816958636045456, 0.009350686334073544, 0.03164385259151459, 0.016873836517333984, -0.021082378923892975, -0.005277570337057114, -0.011313656345009804, 0.031506236642599106, 0.06345145404338837, -0.020177673548460007, 0.0020168577320873737, -0.002178646856918931, 0.02443639747798443, -0.005490560084581375, 0.008985504508018494, -0.0074079399928450584, -0.028402214869856834, -0.03111388348042965, 0.041137199848890305, 0.064409039914608, 0.025363018736243248, -0.013259013183414936, 0.030799662694334984, -0.0662151575088501, -0.02717498131096363, -0.0748409703373909, -0.026175623759627342, -0.04054258391261101, -0.05936282500624657, 0.010334517806768417, 0.01648555137217045, 0.015303876250982285, -0.02839190512895584, -0.034983061254024506, 0.0018502541352063417, -0.03132026270031929, 0.052827462553977966, -0.0376637801527977, -0.012133462354540825, 0.04155203327536583, 0.07013974338769913, -0.00802826602011919, 0.03014123998582363, -0.0472801998257637, -0.047413963824510574, 0.018728522583842278, -0.03756282478570938, -0.019796760752797127, 0.05178435146808624, -0.007192488759756088, 0.03888312727212906, -0.013857544399797916, -0.013042064383625984, 0.012403454631567001, -0.026771055534482002, 0.05228603258728981, 0.05265498906373978, -0.0018714526668190956, 0.010663782246410847, -0.02809004858136177, 0.011660256423056126, 0.01960940845310688, -0.016391711309552193, -0.008869295008480549, -0.03829887509346008, 0.00825477484613657, 0.015948763117194176, 0.026422103866934776, -0.02186015248298645, 0.03192729130387306, 0.07807175070047379, -0.021531453356146812, 0.01904270052909851, 0.03088405914604664, -0.0003014272078871727, -0.025582628324627876, 0.0040258257649838924, 0.0010051311692222953, 0.01781539060175419, 0.008599108085036278, 0.019945455715060234, 0.012702067382633686, 0.03365136310458183, 0.005147616378962994, -0.0032074651680886745, 0.039429038763046265, 0.01884722150862217, 0.010845747776329517, -0.010416380129754543, -0.04337269440293312, 0.018600840121507645, 0.03103342093527317, -0.01388558465987444, 0.04768441990017891, -0.00011061732948292047, -0.014940700493752956, 0.03817681595683098, -0.02864127606153488, 0.02121852897107601, 0.025358490645885468, -0.024056416004896164, -0.011146986857056618, 0.018786687403917313, -0.04731913283467293, 0.03307509049773216, 0.0036223086062818766, -0.016593726351857185, -0.03489639610052109, 0.024866675958037376, 0.010044069960713387, -0.025492558255791664, 0.04300600662827492, -0.02137673832476139, -0.024807743728160858, -0.0010436129523441195, -0.026929223909974098, 0.0021362868137657642, -0.011561853811144829, -0.05710233375430107, 0.026579566299915314, -0.030202988535165787, -0.010479448363184929, 0.01862371899187565, -0.013683602213859558, -0.001582253142260015, 0.06388573348522186, 0.00124089396558702, -0.04349289461970329, 0.006526292767375708, -0.03325021639466286, 0.01702144369482994, 0.018730565905570984, -0.02048809826374054, 0.053458694368600845, -0.00896869134157896, -0.03618817403912544, 0.015451210550963879, -0.030803415924310684, -0.023739216849207878, -0.04612730070948601, -0.00955210905522108, 0.023954924196004868, -0.004574139602482319, 0.003969729878008366, 0.03993776813149452, -0.041384000331163406, 0.002325200941413641, -0.06138426065444946, -0.06755371391773224, -0.01042991504073143, 0.015658529475331306, -0.008213203400373459, -0.006141112186014652, -0.0441826768219471, 0.035785868763923645, 0.04757670685648918, -0.02601378783583641, -0.033960990607738495, -0.006673265714198351, -0.0434269905090332, -0.037995774298906326, 0.027284804731607437, 0.00436444254592061, -0.0189969502389431, 0.012402095831930637, 0.03051612712442875, 0.028208168223500252, 0.04961510747671127, 0.0002505372103769332, -0.013557624071836472, -0.008179695345461369, 0.002267219824716449, -0.00007228242611745372, 0.059356339275836945, 0.009280199185013771, -0.031154874712228775, -0.015283972956240177, 0.04308048263192177, 0.022437196224927902, 0.012289594858884811, -0.021705415099859238, 0.03830024600028992, -0.013200951740145683, 0.013475500978529453, -0.04254598170518875, 0.02347739413380623, 0.024522021412849426, -0.0015874761156737804, -0.011247543618083, 0.009157169610261917, -0.005869152024388313, -0.003918982110917568, 0.00284583936445415, 0.06443852186203003, 0.032973725348711014, -0.024317730218172073, -0.006597788073122501, -0.03409779816865921, -0.015758227556943893, 0.012502096593379974, -0.04638279601931572, -0.03428536653518677, 0.0609675832092762, 0.010764146223664284, 0.037140607833862305, -0.007170624565333128, -0.04525266960263252, 0.006503142882138491, -0.0359848327934742, 0.01947471685707569, -0.005242247600108385, 0.05109572038054466, 0.005873807705938816, 0.06507645547389984, 0.047846123576164246, 0.007009437307715416, -0.0032644011080265045, -0.02052467130124569, -0.03885157033801079, 0.05733807384967804, -0.013872631825506687, -0.024625089019536972, -0.017855368554592133, -0.039342086762189865, 0.013247968629002571, -0.03785523399710655, 0.04518477991223335, -0.001377425855025649, 0.022175638005137444, -0.0504385344684124, 0.01763208582997322, -0.051381077617406845, -0.018292192369699478, 0.026778513565659523, 0.02814365364611149, -0.0023864053655415773, -0.00622128788381815, 0.050871558487415314, 0.014867497608065605, -0.018109938129782677, -0.015013437718153, -0.005587286781519651, 0.03097456321120262, -0.011306168511509895, 0.040901102125644684, 0.008050929754972458, 0.011363831348717213, -0.045490071177482605, 0.04580925032496452, 0.01990324631333351, 0.05151502788066864, 0.049667537212371826, 0.019212035462260246, -0.011325327679514885, -0.026818882673978806, -0.0155678391456604, 0.004159760661423206, 0.02582133561372757, -0.019396627321839333, -0.04572167992591858, 0.04453970864415169, 0.04115351662039757, -0.051262978464365005, 0.019810566678643227, 0.07463642209768295, 0.0456075444817543, 0.01844693161547184, -0.01814701408147812, -0.02951263263821602, -0.010995902121067047, -0.041814032942056656, 0.023638390004634857, 0.026293998584151268, 0.009788095951080322, 0.0112762451171875, 0.040595732629299164, -0.028384175151586533, -0.04731578007340431, 0.026531191542744637, 0.027831943705677986, 0.05744405463337898, -0.006358581129461527, -0.033646196126937866, 0.04455174505710602, 0.0358169749379158, 0.005124041344970465, 0.015380664728581905, 0.037774309515953064, -0.09633845090866089, 0.01693156361579895, 0.05755271390080452, 0.010025772266089916, -0.04570571333169937, -0.01921318657696247, -0.06471925228834152, 0.01620962657034397, 0.052435897290706635, -0.02298761159181595, 0.034743908792734146, -0.013309354893863201, 0.022967977449297905, -0.024062441661953926, -0.0021964837796986103, -0.026817912235856056, 0.03687914088368416, -0.009801584295928478, 0.028488658368587494, -0.012669842690229416, -0.017313335090875626, -0.038506850600242615, -0.01301099918782711, 0.018780911341309547, 0.03749793767929077, -0.02486622892320156, 0.02691403031349182, 0.02757980301976204, 0.029968369752168655, -0.018046032637357712, -0.06465829163789749, 0.01846817322075367, 0.004133790265768766, -0.003017464419826865, 0.04408466815948486, -0.010466963052749634, -0.043814968317747116, 0.0101374052464962, -0.027360685169696808, 0.003583395155146718, 0.013605605810880661, -0.02005063369870186, 0.037253107875585556, 0.04123130440711975, 0.036190297454595566, 0.0692678838968277, 0.006510638166218996, 0.022844607010483742, 0.0036179509479552507, -0.0235378909856081, 0.034680385142564774, -0.035139117389917374, -0.031326986849308014, -0.046136774122714996, -0.009373714216053486, -0.014922619797289371, 0.022408338263630867, -0.014672384597361088, 0.05048500746488571, -0.027376649901270866, 0.004306866321712732, -0.00351196201518178, 0.01751272939145565, 0.030016833916306496, -0.027524810284376144, 0.016460828483104706, 0.018566686660051346, -0.07634121179580688, -0.0252333115786314, 0.04219535365700722, -0.004765802528709173, -0.030794084072113037, -0.010792113840579987, -0.055132314562797546, 0.0013682032003998756, -0.04136333987116814, -0.0077891056425869465, -0.030053511261940002, -0.00865129753947258, 0.048233866691589355, 0.009397227317094803, 0.05674591660499573, 0.04421336203813553, -0.008959945291280746, 0.00328426668420434, 0.034815408289432526, -0.0025912250857800245, 0.005473695695400238, -0.06564067304134369, 0.04999887943267822, -0.019528262317180634, -0.03629143163561821, -0.08498331159353256, -0.03118213079869747, -0.00008129783964250237, 0.04910951107740402, 0.012049466371536255, -0.05052988603711128, 0.005948139354586601, 0.0013188546290621161, 0.004870330449193716, -0.06337092071771622, 0.037757277488708496, 0.008629330433905125, -0.03537106513977051, -0.002121011260896921, 0.01551691722124815, 0.09894032031297684, -0.028709588572382927, 0.005831913556903601, 0.012204005382955074, -0.005044589284807444, -0.004013806581497192, 0.022103911265730858, 0.006708765402436256, -0.007780032232403755, -0.007357672322541475, -0.0363529771566391, 0.012186193838715553, 0.032302189618349075, -0.050582192838191986, 0.02250063046813011, 0.006481627933681011, -0.007562065962702036, 0.013982838951051235, -0.041528500616550446, 0.011860555969178677, -0.024219701066613197, 0.011680874973535538, -0.02858889475464821, 0.003898746334016323, 0.013101507909595966, 0.0023746155202388763, 0.020370222628116608, -0.0019491846906021237, -0.0015068474458530545, 0.006078421603888273, 0.05881907418370247, -0.01765356957912445, -0.0018118992447853088, -0.014650870114564896, -0.004625693429261446, 0.014946877025067806, -0.01652667671442032, 0.0034345185849815607, -0.0038640734273940325, 0.01836371049284935, -0.042909301817417145, -0.029898444190621376, 0.00048021491966210306, -0.023142069578170776, 0.06898317486047745, -0.006116490811109543, 0.056932270526885986, 0.08060289919376373, 0.024001875892281532, 0.02166793681681156, -0.04266851022839546, -0.006488228216767311, 0.006714635528624058, 0.006290656980127096, 0.06279686093330383, 0.016498370096087456, 0.016876449808478355, 0.04214569181203842, 0.02244092896580696, 0.06655992567539215, 0.03876183554530144, 0.024996183812618256, 0.0340879000723362, 0.020748451352119446, -0.016975533217191696, -0.03996783494949341, 0.0073035103268921375, -0.03680948540568352, 0.03458256646990776, -0.07937713712453842, 0.003130310447886586, 0.056611478328704834, 0.06165365129709244, -0.0068183583207428455, 0.002827949821949005, -0.041653845459222794, -0.06171626225113869, 0.021762404590845108, 0.010292462073266506, -0.011537284590303898, 0.02247213013470173, 0.024229995906352997, 0.045581091195344925, -0.04788598418235779, 0.009943298995494843, -0.03992220759391785, -0.05376438796520233, -0.012689647264778614, -0.026511525735259056, -0.01603824645280838, 0.048418741673231125, 0.008779163472354412, -0.014825720340013504, 0.006726549938321114, -0.02901916205883026, -0.012242361903190613, -0.006152569781988859, 0.0005829926230944693, -0.02625630982220173, 0.06817120313644409, 0.02370736375451088, 0.034225866198539734, 0.004003576003015041, -0.010933315381407738, 0.08808733522891998, 0.03458696976304054, 0.047442298382520676, -0.056606318801641464, 0.00763814989477396, -0.0073594930581748486, 0.01641232706606388, -0.031006058678030968, 0.045895326882600784, 0.008869217708706856, 0.03375883400440216, 0.048525694757699966, 0.04633894935250282, 0.016100633889436722, -0.0313570573925972, 0.05950428918004036, -0.027865787968039513, 0.020048251375555992, -0.01382155530154705, 0.015020343475043774, -0.0022347241174429655, -0.028552288189530373, -0.05480724573135376, 0.03722323104739189, -0.020970147103071213, 0.0016107362462207675, -0.006542904302477837, -0.01358624454587698, 0.005076040513813496, 0.02436164580285549, 0.0023593713995069265, 0.01593839004635811, 0.06387606263160706, 0.015056077390909195, -0.015386907383799553, -0.016051391139626503, 0.049771882593631744, -0.03164968267083168, 0.027975348755717278, -0.004105218220502138, -0.012850983068346977, -0.010574630461633205, -0.005727330222725868, 0.012860292568802834, -0.0212558601051569, -0.030081313103437424, -0.026777591556310654, 0.034641560167074203, 0.031926028430461884, -0.03663285821676254, -0.013580510392785072, -0.008261569775640965, -0.03885383903980255, -0.057958729565143585, -0.01779196225106716, -0.008794782683253288, -0.02723628655076027, -0.05156157165765762, 0.010644244030117989, -0.04128206893801689, 0.05655904859304428, -0.027814507484436035, 0.04530256241559982, 0.016364432871341705, -0.040370844304561615, -0.045904505997896194, -0.03142955154180527, 0.055499352514743805, -0.03542302921414375, -0.028731338679790497, -0.007170849945396185, -0.02528541348874569, -0.0003606420650612563, 0.018881648778915405, -0.008929532021284103, 0.0031356276012957096, 0.0026893969625234604, 0.002404969185590744, -0.013951834291219711, 0.008924386464059353, -0.028927305713295937, 0.018033115193247795, -0.006265032570809126, 0.009440800175070763, -0.04166751354932785, 0.001656549284234643, 0.06654950976371765, 0.028738178312778473, 0.03432106971740723, 0.014308908022940159, 0.0003849379427265376, 0.035537030547857285, 0.034192848950624466, -0.03904658183455467, -0.017274752259254456, -0.002472817664965987, -0.037789106369018555, -0.019229641184210777, -0.04629328101873398, 0.06396419554948807, 0.05405677855014801, 0.0054847486317157745, -0.0013548906426876783, 0.008435373194515705, -0.020954541862010956, 0.032203543931245804, -0.01938457041978836, -0.04433156177401543, -0.010208318941295147, 0.025042666122317314, 0.0082742590457201, -0.024274418130517006, -0.033783216029405594, -0.03138900175690651, -0.030218569561839104, 0.00953692477196455, 0.013637909665703773, -0.01795140653848648, -0.0015637953765690327, 0.003981460351496935, 0.020078912377357483, -0.02891497313976288, 0.01010670606046915, -0.04269164055585861, -0.010829197242856026, 0.01845201849937439, -0.00802852213382721, -0.021306615322828293, 0.009640105068683624, -0.0018100226297974586, -0.02108558639883995, 0.04731263220310211, 0.02478632889688015, 0.024426208809018135, 0.00667415140196681, 0.0024812831543385983, -0.010545855388045311, 0.016521696001291275, -0.013827688992023468, -0.01686777174472809, 0.04576399177312851, -0.007408828940242529, -0.024225231260061264, 0.0177096426486969, 0.004124523606151342, 0.039816342294216156, 0.018606077879667282, -0.02073306404054165, -0.04470192268490791, 0.050933144986629486, -0.04871658608317375, -0.025964245200157166, -0.03131970763206482, -0.009483253583312035, 0.011125634424388409, -0.010042551904916763, 0.06405970454216003, -0.0036960591096431017, -0.026580864563584328, 0.012706146575510502, 0.015604931861162186, -0.0194116048514843, 0.005585900042206049, -0.003383395029231906, 0.03631684184074402, 0.003320458112284541, 0.0019343632739037275, -0.03742516040802002, 0.059575267136096954, 0.048906050622463226, -0.02480713091790676, 0.027793090790510178, -0.04020955041050911, 0.025830766186118126, -0.05261480435729027, -0.00694234436377883, 0.012790931388735771, -0.029915379360318184, 0.04325904697179794, -0.04149607941508293, 0.025633886456489563, 0.047022704035043716, -0.029649967327713966, 0.007499417290091515, -0.004812548868358135, -0.0104507552459836, -0.030177786946296692, 0.03343338146805763, -0.005787239875644445, 0.022444551810622215, -0.0019864204805344343, -0.018371740356087685, 0.025228358805179596, 0.028573662042617798, 0.022075600922107697, -0.01303663570433855, -0.022155195474624634, -0.011732837185263634, 0.021175352856516838, -0.0538247786462307, -0.002609601244330406, -0.06588617712259293, -0.04546497017145157, 0.035088904201984406, -0.007873548194766045, 0.01216835156083107, -0.008916109800338745, -0.015298406593501568, 0.008980107493698597, 0.03156038746237755, -0.007617135066539049, 0.03678790107369423, -0.01061153318732977, -0.03340147063136101, -0.0001410358672728762, 0.022920193150639534, -0.019414886832237244, -0.008244780823588371, 0.04942665994167328, -0.019304310902953148, -0.009870177134871483, -0.00032712676329538226, 0.002013103337958455, -0.029222635552287102, -0.013382276520133018, 0.013159663416445255, 0.023380221799016, 0.0021582141052931547, 0.003780895844101906, -0.0124307069927454, 0.019379420205950737, 0.06090564280748367, 0.01713702455163002, -0.04169180244207382, 0.011322886683046818, -0.018112663179636, -0.04902217909693718, 0.023374944925308228, 0.0019164599943906069, -0.016410846263170242, -0.061903562396764755, -0.01817338541150093, 0.0018103059846907854, -0.028095189481973648, -0.028244607150554657, -0.012178437784314156, -0.006180052179843187, 0.032244689762592316, -0.019732879474759102, 0.004522920586168766, 0.0125017324462533, -0.01783294603228569, -0.004344557411968708, -0.08963672816753387, 0.028177540749311447, 0.040371961891651154, -0.024129847064614296, -0.024483343586325645, -0.0010535381734371185, -0.08656005561351776, 0.0017384029924869537, 0.04268063232302666, 0.041347552090883255, 0.005270952824503183, 0.009154344908893108, -0.006345468107610941, 0.0045803003013134, -0.08135423809289932, 0.052226029336452484, -0.008467819541692734, -0.03988735377788544, 0.006578037980943918, -0.039353854954242706, 0.02493119053542614, 0.012458688579499722, -0.025641800835728645, -0.003768478287383914, -0.0256845410913229, 0.034778811037540436, -0.014543352648615837, 0.042718660086393356, 0.003318360075354576, -0.02484053373336792, 0.018656741827726364, -0.01606236770749092, 0.0013415615539997816, 0.020380549132823944, 0.018826434388756752, -0.06594250351190567, 0.073073610663414, -0.040025703608989716, -0.02466907538473606, 0.00126904237549752, 0.010366442613303661, 0.006030835676938295, -0.056370146572589874, -0.011222691275179386, 0.012705134227871895, -0.02760486863553524, 0.019647011533379555, 0.04824031889438629, 0.013724028132855892, 0.0036036018282175064, -0.016306467354297638, 0.014921648427844048, 0.025227723643183708, -0.008142291568219662, -0.001276434282772243, -0.014813940972089767, 0.03992857038974762, -0.0035526894498616457, 0.005170589778572321, 0.04316096007823944, -0.01684039644896984, 0.01386982761323452, -0.009992324747145176, 0.03356232866644859, -0.015878550708293915, -0.006397150922566652, -0.0037593136075884104, -0.026491006836295128, -0.005080329719930887, 0.012802882120013237, -0.023841476067900658, 0.060729797929525375, -0.06611732393503189, 0.008088366128504276, -0.04179501533508301, 0.005467415787279606, -0.008142937906086445, -0.0038601146079599857, 0.0440337173640728, -0.023085013031959534, -0.023128865286707878, 0.005268067121505737, 0.009210904128849506, 0.008097074925899506, 0.02904445305466652, -0.03447239473462105, 0.02606746181845665, -0.02905363403260708, 0.0013633219059556723, -0.024713607504963875, -0.014008326455950737, -0.09107184410095215, -0.013960500247776508, 0.020025039091706276, 0.011188001371920109, 0.010407472960650921, 0.009477329440414906, -0.03712625056505203, -0.010199413634836674, 0.027589743956923485, -0.10056260228157043, -0.02860545553267002, -0.035775940865278244, 0.0029587033204734325, -0.012578972615301609, -0.010975216515362263 ]
<p>I don't really have a motivation for this - but I was thinking about this and couldn't work it out. </p> <p>Suppose I have a random variables $X$ and $Y$ which are correlated. Is it possible that the partial correlation between $X$ and $X\cdot Y$ is zero after taking into account Y? In other words, would a regression of $X$ on $Y$ and $X\cdot Y$ possibly result in a zero coefficient on $X\cdot Y$?</p>
36,033
[ -0.018500614911317825, 0.017969049513339996, 0.00507020577788353, -0.03133563697338104, 0.03310180827975273, 0.0338207446038723, -0.029227817431092262, -0.0023404480889439583, 0.03703926503658295, -0.05471725016832352, -0.009886994026601315, 0.035417165607213974, 0.05827437713742256, 0.03288350626826286, 0.032383400946855545, 0.02435329742729664, -0.02329445257782936, 0.018549039959907532, 0.008576085790991783, -0.009133260697126389, -0.0031766307074576616, 0.062160491943359375, 0.021967776119709015, 0.026128215715289116, -0.00478522339835763, 0.017584577202796936, -0.01642155647277832, -0.04361218214035034, 0.026518885046243668, 0.05554615333676338, -0.061400432139635086, -0.015681395307183266, -0.01924651861190796, 0.06548381596803665, 0.05938218533992767, 0.008736553601920605, -0.011435742489993572, -0.016115378588438034, 0.026035383343696594, 0.04512283578515053, -0.024772901087999344, -0.045939840376377106, 0.018086612224578857, 0.04911305382847786, -0.015399787575006485, 0.019145123660564423, 0.017090927809476852, -0.03875765576958656, 0.053595855832099915, -0.017190979793667793, 0.06620950996875763, -0.00897347740828991, 0.030134225264191628, 0.06891066581010818, 0.011029588989913464, 0.005140712019056082, 0.07547219842672348, 0.03595464676618576, -0.05097903683781624, -0.05467367172241211, -0.005505755078047514, -0.028548967093229294, 0.01873907633125782, 0.0003971072437707335, -0.052292559295892715, -0.0005205321358516812, 0.010739084333181381, -0.04800786077976227, 0.028164681047201157, -0.020999806001782417, -0.016723209992051125, 0.04851451516151428, 0.04652528837323189, -0.022606151178479195, 0.011311056092381477, -0.021556485444307327, 0.04613690823316574, 0.015191982500255108, 0.020259171724319458, 0.03645293042063713, -0.00881888996809721, 0.008381737396121025, 0.03747730329632759, 0.04854742810130119, 0.009326951578259468, 0.014384131878614426, 0.03196575120091438, -0.03446979075670242, 0.05495048686861992, 0.026905391365289688, -0.004594145808368921, -0.01262873224914074, 0.050267934799194336, 0.013843107968568802, -0.05382273718714714, 0.05242208391427994, -0.008733238093554974, 0.05673277750611305, 0.03908839076757431, -0.023590805009007454, -0.0031663791742175817, 0.015128305181860924, -0.015167444944381714, 0.06478135287761688, -0.023416800424456596, -0.018614070490002632, -0.017561689019203186, 0.02903982251882553, 0.0045564486645162106, -0.021013513207435608, -0.026936886832118034, 0.0059004537761211395, 0.009788122959434986, -0.023910075426101685, 0.03146633878350258, -0.006663009058684111, 0.014346206560730934, -0.039807528257369995, 0.06626832485198975, 0.05753900483250618, 0.020620830357074738, -0.03275249898433685, -0.007404503412544727, -0.017919830977916718, -0.04271728917956352, 0.007521620485931635, 0.03834747150540352, -0.008924168534576893, -0.04137903451919556, 0.05537080392241478, 0.000581753789447248, 0.005284078419208527, 0.025028236210346222, -0.005969373043626547, 0.03195293992757797, -0.000030998580768937245, -0.07227374613285065, -0.040085796266794205, 0.04466214030981064, -0.028276842087507248, -0.010017839260399342, -0.015879446640610695, 0.008187792263925076, 0.030496768653392792, 0.07202796638011932, -0.015100967139005661, 0.014970839954912663, -0.00699178921058774, 0.0075346436351537704, 0.029221804812550545, 0.002176685258746147, -0.04106157645583153, -0.004407763015478849, -0.05836839973926544, -0.017710963264107704, -0.049079105257987976, 0.01703079231083393, 0.040003132075071335, -0.027376113459467888, -0.004690008703619242, 0.041487496346235275, 0.01448109745979309, -0.030542239546775818, -0.0015614312142133713, -0.0008790516294538975, -0.05934203788638115, 0.07956738024950027, 0.014607096090912819, 0.018959708511829376, 0.018805304542183876, 0.015579501166939735, 0.04983212798833847, 0.02427477203309536, 0.07321230322122574, 0.05007381737232208, -0.03813029080629349, -0.02839992195367813, -0.005630017723888159, 0.018400320783257484, -0.027342136949300766, -0.07048387825489044, -0.0032360616605728865, -0.03217710927128792, 0.006342864595353603, 0.03225995972752571, 0.047815412282943726, 0.02190195955336094, -0.012357467785477638, 0.03921075165271759, -0.02150638774037361, -0.005853128619492054, -0.05866248533129692, -0.0030922405421733856, 0.016499847173690796, -0.030246393755078316, 0.016620878130197525, 0.03351270779967308, 0.0014483227860182524, -0.01682756282389164, -0.02631732076406479, -0.009046980179846287, 0.01908571645617485, 0.012443128041923046, -0.04875849932432175, 0.03764523193240166, 0.03717198967933655, 0.0440850704908371, -0.0002860436215996742, 0.029620952904224396, -0.03732664883136749, -0.05365941673517227, 0.019974486902356148, -0.003964515868574381, 0.017430447041988373, -0.04503266140818596, -0.00039991631638258696, 0.017142143100500107, -0.03680895268917084, -0.014122876338660717, 0.031673092395067215, -0.04692096263170242, 0.05467015504837036, 0.05965562164783478, -0.008807666599750519, -0.011481005698442459, -0.007248976733535528, 0.056142210960388184, -0.005110856145620346, -0.03550001606345177, -0.04522107169032097, -0.031181709840893745, 0.012677186168730259, 0.02699376828968525, 0.04847986623644829, -0.04629399999976158, 0.0222909078001976, 0.07086418569087982, 0.05212552100419998, -0.024863187223672867, 0.01955443248152733, 0.011571770533919334, 0.0066916425712406635, -0.011695184744894505, 0.000797308050096035, 0.018391333520412445, 0.02133696712553501, 0.000922817678656429, 0.02265220507979393, 0.041929252445697784, 0.010603024624288082, -0.013292167335748672, 0.04442480951547623, 0.019397178664803505, 0.006651651114225388, 0.000687571126036346, -0.003542395308613777, 0.031891100108623505, -0.028522411361336708, 0.03232835605740547, 0.02448684349656105, 0.03075641393661499, -0.005606184247881174, 0.0018822118872776628, -0.022128626704216003, -0.003434449899941683, 0.028394611552357674, -0.04141290858387947, 0.009135985746979713, 0.011821885593235493, -0.01623133383691311, 0.010091091506183147, -0.03145159035921097, -0.015141976065933704, -0.015150231309235096, 0.0029060635715723038, 0.052081674337387085, 0.03128749132156372, 0.027976632118225098, -0.032436471432447433, -0.026834407821297646, -0.0027676685713231564, -0.012376646511256695, 0.01967247761785984, -0.0010003141360357404, -0.051609016954898834, 0.008968601934611797, -0.02684292010962963, -0.0028894287534058094, -0.002811042359098792, -0.025218848139047623, 0.03191783279180527, 0.038493767380714417, -0.043624065816402435, -0.08849550038576126, -0.047237057238817215, -0.03539374843239784, -0.0036403853446245193, -0.05804656818509102, -0.014551701955497265, 0.020883433520793915, -0.0039110262878239155, -0.07108016312122345, -0.012323329225182533, -0.02016366459429264, -0.0159860011190176, -0.043726470321416855, -0.03739186376333237, 0.01746167242527008, -0.023159349337220192, 0.03692753612995148, 0.0286432933062315, -0.03077871911227703, -0.01111855823546648, -0.050321146845817566, -0.0666881799697876, 0.05421358346939087, -0.014306404627859592, 0.024627406150102615, -0.029728664085268974, -0.03500846028327942, 0.04569673910737038, 0.027167975902557373, -0.001474507967941463, -0.022672921419143677, -0.01268012449145317, -0.013447773642838001, -0.02574186958372593, 0.01177247241139412, -0.031041603535413742, 0.016919126734137535, 0.05738029256463051, 0.00035698467399924994, 0.02789052203297615, 0.01486551109701395, 0.024890005588531494, 0.03053947538137436, 0.005852954462170601, 0.01105110440403223, 0.01941700093448162, 0.0146989356726408, 0.02964288368821144, -0.014740949496626854, 0.010768609121441841, -0.004384822212159634, 0.03684939444065094, 0.008836079388856888, -0.042402103543281555, 0.02525043487548828, -0.000687846215441823, 0.03158870339393616, -0.0341770276427269, 0.018427584320306778, 0.02692156657576561, -0.00682026194408536, -0.04943609982728958, 0.005696803331375122, 0.02797679975628853, -0.00594617985188961, 0.0007762253517284989, 0.020944474264979362, 0.001175261684693396, -0.020853307098150253, -0.027145152911543846, 0.007497780490666628, 0.004386139567941427, 0.023471754044294357, -0.001470782794058323, -0.003209412796422839, 0.052848681807518005, 0.01878475956618786, 0.0025427977088838816, -0.04055468738079071, -0.03696165233850479, 0.011214122176170349, -0.04343507066369057, 0.00808201264590025, -0.030289199203252792, 0.03292827680706978, 0.003440077416598797, 0.04912131652235985, -0.010844253934919834, 0.008096300065517426, 0.008854378946125507, 0.02566421590745449, -0.08077152818441391, -0.002051940420642495, -0.03384510055184364, -0.014227167703211308, 0.016808761283755302, -0.001694818027317524, 0.04942641779780388, -0.03891739249229431, -0.018065351992845535, -0.04133422672748566, 0.009092902764678001, -0.01944112218916416, -0.00711107300594449, -0.0006940326420590281, -0.046259935945272446, -0.0012932639801874757, 0.01009890902787447, -0.012835958041250706, -0.01885601133108139, 0.039915066212415695, 0.027151305228471756, 0.013184853829443455, -0.00918313767760992, -0.04331861063838005, 0.009662151336669922, 0.03195880353450775, 0.029946139082312584, 0.026399828493595123, 0.007011687848716974, -0.04277357831597328, 0.030520614236593246, -0.002374321222305298, 0.05318361148238182, 0.028567595407366753, -0.03699866309762001, -0.02516048029065132, -0.013815287500619888, -0.035848211497068405, -0.0026789323892444372, 0.018312541767954826, 0.00019468511163722724, 0.009398393332958221, 0.04376130551099777, 0.038329243659973145, -0.03974536061286926, -0.00394358579069376, 0.028086833655834198, 0.048399582505226135, 0.003633063053712249, 0.012873456813395023, 0.003777171950787306, 0.00466335192322731, 0.01765373721718788, 0.01256350614130497, -0.021545931696891785, -0.02150345779955387, -0.027125611901283264, 0.019100740551948547, 0.046928465366363525, 0.00731114624068141, 0.0013694792287424207, 0.006985045969486237, 0.05359397456049919, -0.005310737993568182, -0.016372298821806908, 0.03146211802959442, 0.05338886380195618, 0.0010661071864888072, 0.048479318618774414, -0.006602719891816378, -0.03864441066980362, 0.008376432582736015, 0.030821798369288445, 0.05531212314963341, -0.039807211607694626, 0.006135743577033281, -0.018887272104620934, -0.02609657309949398, 0.032600805163383484, -0.009403851814568043, 0.008892872370779514, -0.027322320267558098, -0.009332156740128994, 0.019285308197140694, -0.02412298135459423, -0.06827308237552643, 0.012768551707267761, -0.019423415884375572, 0.025061555206775665, -0.00368300499394536, -0.03781311213970184, -0.04435202479362488, -0.013511565513908863, 0.03654550760984421, 0.07443910837173462, 0.005268831271678209, -0.007748181466013193, -0.009584889747202396, 0.05676167458295822, 0.03602347522974014, -0.08468177914619446, 0.0401013046503067, 0.01725374534726143, -0.028083350509405136, 0.055647604167461395, -0.01846185140311718, -0.05121713504195213, 0.05119363218545914, -0.0008846760028973222, -0.02600543387234211, 0.033045876771211624, -0.01328026782721281, 0.040552183985710144, 0.04698134958744049, -0.009285432286560535, 0.04129086062312126, 0.057801298797130585, -0.01205917727202177, -0.045449160039424896, -0.015556859783828259, 0.019743775948882103, -0.05023285001516342, 0.010340710170567036, -0.0317075289785862, -0.0179433673620224, -0.010485622100532055, 0.0002910986077040434, -0.016155174002051353, 0.023661145940423012, -0.021780578419566154, -0.007734524551779032, -0.016271790489554405, 0.036924831569194794, -0.015064402483403683, -0.0006137755699455738, -0.015170414000749588, 0.02096097357571125, -0.017946941778063774, -0.03124803863465786, 0.0017880296800285578, 0.007811331190168858, -0.01893005520105362, 0.022186195477843285, -0.019213588908314705, 0.012596551328897476, -0.02032635733485222, -0.012968230992555618, -0.017547234892845154, -0.006812971085309982, 0.019671084359288216, 0.0025608609430491924, 0.014877017587423325, -0.021892720833420753, -0.017309272661805153, -0.004022487439215183, 0.018552949652075768, -0.008574623614549637, -0.0019536528270691633, -0.04105005040764809, 0.0026029623113572598, -0.02409149892628193, -0.00595263484865427, -0.0667286366224289, -0.05450468882918358, -0.014405547641217709, 0.005656170193105936, 0.016310852020978928, -0.017066463828086853, 0.0005514418589882553, -0.020861277356743813, -0.04040536656975746, -0.029336247593164444, 0.061456259340047836, -0.024505678564310074, -0.021488133817911148, 0.014775625430047512, 0.00037114357110112906, 0.04199732095003128, -0.013645625673234463, -0.05245250463485718, 0.039832230657339096, -0.0429711751639843, -0.022503860294818878, 0.026253528892993927, 0.03267958015203476, -0.029071273282170296, -0.011874728836119175, -0.03333665430545807, -0.0348549485206604, 0.04575777426362038, -0.0202177744358778, -0.02146500162780285, 0.004397514741867781, 0.023655448108911514, -0.003712501609697938, -0.014110731892287731, 0.013870940543711185, -0.00155331299174577, -0.004434897564351559, 0.022245174273848534, -0.03482804819941521, -0.02865392342209816, -0.03326621279120445, 0.03838212043046951, -0.007943411357700825, -0.022730577737092972, -0.008588253520429134, 0.08703913539648056, 0.010688221082091331, -0.010693014599382877, -0.015479974448680878, -0.011598879471421242, 0.027260685339570045, 0.015377877280116081, 0.0006738191586919129, -0.0026678668800741434, 0.020810505375266075, -0.0645240992307663, -0.04184451699256897, -0.04888984188437462, -0.016223756596446037, 0.07568830996751785, -0.05701091140508652, 0.036731358617544174, 0.03220180422067642, -0.01610986329615116, -0.024953346699476242, -0.0414629690349102, -0.010968020185828209, 0.01704379729926586, 0.0008180835284292698, 0.03404366225004196, -0.014187181368470192, 0.005292255897074938, 0.033414699137210846, 0.036917053163051605, 0.00468550156801939, 0.036339521408081055, -0.0016705150483176112, 0.012413929216563702, 0.04146963730454445, -0.02823786810040474, -0.05462827533483505, 0.009625419043004513, -0.022771231830120087, 0.017066042870283127, -0.012161006219685078, -0.04195433855056763, 0.05177133157849312, 0.027429021894931793, 0.021091194823384285, -0.05895787477493286, -0.04287022352218628, -0.03665924072265625, 0.00373307173140347, 0.009499181061983109, 0.013199460692703724, 0.02883523516356945, -0.023382239043712616, 0.004311982076615095, -0.02569296583533287, 0.040182460099458694, -0.008297991938889027, -0.09307911992073059, -0.02065129205584526, -0.0054277339950203896, 0.01808919943869114, 0.02596953511238098, 0.0084843086078763, -0.010957594960927963, 0.018961364403367043, -0.03936897590756416, 0.010693836957216263, -0.007312330417335033, 0.04137156158685684, -0.021644214168190956, 0.049809347838163376, 0.019285187125205994, 0.010080281645059586, -0.00670962268486619, -0.02329923026263714, 0.10176632553339005, 0.04100462794303894, 0.03582506999373436, -0.06200410798192024, -0.00598962651565671, -0.040451254695653915, -0.006571292877197266, -0.04003749042749405, 0.010143882595002651, 0.009513521566987038, 0.0016826394712552428, 0.030873320996761322, 0.06259887665510178, 0.023725004866719246, 0.0010709804482758045, 0.05554095283150673, -0.049357134848833084, -0.015518625266849995, -0.03156580775976181, 0.021022437140345573, 0.020809929817914963, -0.03133706375956535, -0.026129230856895447, -0.008782047778367996, -0.021896464750170708, -0.01628308743238449, -0.04018260911107063, 0.011377225629985332, 0.004203347489237785, -0.010434544645249844, -0.05150898918509483, -0.007124683819711208, 0.05482945218682289, -0.003348671831190586, -0.02532772533595562, -0.012726270593702793, 0.06654918938875198, -0.02472027949988842, -0.01647532358765602, 0.014871619641780853, -0.03699788078665733, 0.0022765598259866238, 0.049777284264564514, -0.02346159890294075, -0.04905557259917259, -0.015896417200565338, -0.008455635979771614, 0.06825623661279678, -0.01602824032306671, -0.009215478785336018, -0.03215428814291954, -0.023978203535079956, 0.0063238488510251045, -0.01816905103623867, -0.046153366565704346, 0.036262474954128265, 0.039841603487730026, -0.02658628672361374, 0.013515702448785305, -0.0016900695627555251, -0.0011093218345195055, -0.017125040292739868, 0.046724263578653336, 0.03288375213742256, -0.05609260872006416, -0.005375434644520283, -0.021627116948366165, 0.06701859831809998, 0.008709455840289593, -0.019496168941259384, 0.025925854220986366, -0.022357264533638954, -0.021534062922000885, -0.02228626422584057, 0.016307996585965157, -0.014606313779950142, 0.05679043009877205, -0.0207462627440691, -0.00460655614733696, -0.013531938195228577, -0.017523789778351784, 0.025388184934854507, -0.04445832595229149, 0.022648485377430916, -0.06438446789979935, 0.006793291307985783, 0.035914357751607895, 0.06282224506139755, 0.031169617548584938, -0.04483230784535408, -0.01444987766444683, 0.057753536850214005, 0.00837485957890749, -0.03007633052766323, -0.03978254646062851, 0.0010303050512447953, -0.02962321788072586, 0.017472390085458755, 0.0040132952854037285, 0.02884630300104618, 0.030731525272130966, 0.05285477265715599, -0.009260253980755806, 0.008149159140884876, -0.014100586995482445, -0.004542182199656963, 0.03532462567090988, -0.042173147201538086, 0.0022544320672750473, 0.01980721205472946, 0.027022266760468483, -0.02674766629934311, -0.02037772722542286, -0.026144301518797874, 0.036743342876434326, -0.010599334724247456, 0.006358603481203318, -0.0262500811368227, -0.0011015015188604593, -0.0031939635518938303, 0.0017572520300745964, -0.04117220640182495, -0.03218409791588783, -0.05407261848449707, -0.012997071258723736, 0.03917670249938965, -0.009963493794202805, 0.009426454082131386, 0.007705786731094122, -0.029358629137277603, 0.010407966561615467, 0.06173093244433403, 0.01730021834373474, -0.0011775125749409199, -0.0320277214050293, 0.029214883223176003, -0.006443479564040899, 0.04229717701673508, -0.027825232595205307, -0.0399167537689209, 0.028751282021403313, -0.023652885109186172, -0.02580972947180271, 0.005738924257457256, 0.0028522172942757607, 0.03437841683626175, -0.0047692167572677135, -0.002175062894821167, -0.056073907762765884, 0.04971323907375336, 0.009561074897646904, 0.026340188458561897, -0.02027035877108574, 0.03639449551701546, -0.011074157431721687, 0.004252506885677576, 0.01295235101133585, -0.004146742168813944, -0.015406050719320774, 0.008984997868537903, 0.0372970812022686, 0.02074180543422699, -0.02231249026954174, 0.03617815673351288, 0.011990844272077084, -0.01025203987956047, -0.007502298802137375, -0.007892499677836895, -0.01659967191517353, 0.03461318090558052, -0.038047295063734055, 0.03815726935863495, 0.04358296096324921, 0.030523495748639107, -0.10364549607038498, -0.03613108769059181, 0.013862377032637596, 0.02774454839527607, 0.013552975840866566, -0.030646473169326782, -0.003462261287495494, 0.0336228609085083, -0.07205855846405029, 0.022278154268860817, 0.05153957009315491, -0.027111830189824104, -0.030126240104436874, 0.015900783240795135, -0.025336604565382004, 0.04551007226109505, 0.04977693408727646, 0.051909081637859344, 0.030046429485082626, 0.031668759882450104, 0.0021853966172784567, -0.010734708979725838, -0.03493287041783333, -0.019664814695715904, -0.001714808284305036, -0.04058827832341194, 0.07327663153409958, -0.05736426264047623, -0.03591543063521385, 0.011430002748966217, -0.021718813106417656, 0.018728695809841156, -0.022307060658931732, 0.027213511988520622, -0.010176380164921284, 0.02094053104519844, 0.029934601858258247, 0.00026357496972195804, 0.002291580894961953, -0.0015244155656546354, -0.007474849931895733, 0.053998567163944244, -0.04152075946331024, 0.021864579990506172, -0.003105153562501073, -0.022092701867222786, -0.029703548178076744, 0.01814144477248192, 0.01016279123723507, -0.020679594948887825, 0.0379604771733284, 0.02079768478870392, -0.012455767951905727, -0.005003379657864571, 0.03772053122520447, -0.056658897548913956, -0.04479604959487915, 0.038382384926080704, 0.04414398595690727, -0.02928312122821808, -0.013551058247685432, -0.0183080043643713, -0.03341129794716835, 0.04052455723285675, -0.013908312655985355, -0.0007940168725326657, -0.08638487011194229, -0.022404979914426804, -0.007769226096570492, -0.023881681263446808, -0.009975926019251347, -0.02152019366621971, -0.052745528519153595, 0.0174410380423069, -0.010673771612346172, 0.014016738161444664, 0.012786339037120342, -0.03866041451692581, -0.013879013247787952, -0.07652676105499268, 0.043966442346572876, -0.010787604376673698, 0.008345010690391064, -0.03131008893251419, -0.014791668392717838, -0.05410014092922211, -0.03088783472776413, 0.03506392240524292, -0.024627983570098877, 0.02042555622756481, -0.007416878826916218, 0.02423013560473919, 0.020625052973628044, -0.0537538044154644, 0.046221476048231125, 0.004436220973730087, -0.02894793078303337, -0.010421051643788815, 0.002051390940323472, -0.018725691363215446, -0.008583459071815014, 0.01926393061876297, -0.023361070081591606, 0.006319465581327677, -0.012872331775724888, 0.0006705786800011992, 0.07289490848779678, 0.01586499810218811, 0.00784271489828825, 0.05483472719788551, 0.018072454258799553, 0.04461817443370819, 0.02707008458673954, 0.0034822935704141855, -0.0884363204240799, -0.007207368966192007, -0.039843399077653885, -0.03036988340318203, -0.00549427792429924, 0.021945515647530556, -0.004221899900585413, -0.0180195402354002, 0.0016442076303064823, 0.0450071282684803, -0.01593680866062641, -0.010855507105588913, 0.014522373676300049, 0.0023484062403440475, 0.037371229380369186, 0.019467463716864586, -0.0021705827675759792, 0.038757141679525375, -0.022761395201086998, 0.040939342230558395, 0.014741269871592522, 0.025715800002217293, 0.0016087840776890516, 0.041368771344423294, 0.02119601145386696, 0.008077988401055336, 0.020356133580207825, -0.029636166989803314, 0.0110064297914505, -0.07805326581001282, -0.0009627952240407467, 0.025693560019135475, -0.004668110050261021, 0.02736964449286461, -0.026145288720726967, -0.003118429332971573, 0.04408882185816765, -0.016580291092395782, -0.0020048555452376604, -0.033159125596284866, 0.020240189507603645, -0.008167429827153683, 0.00025063412613235414, 0.00003607134203775786, 0.017475051805377007, -0.03658168017864227, -0.010497226379811764, 0.009680950082838535, -0.0386822372674942, 0.01923232153058052, -0.010717864148318768, -0.00449545681476593, -0.005281421355903149, -0.024912305176258087, -0.021145695820450783, -0.012899470515549183, -0.0217023603618145, -0.034957729279994965, 0.059546664357185364, 0.05162259191274643, -0.005415625870227814, -0.021657947450876236, -0.005532245151698589, -0.003236250253394246, 0.07108504325151443, -0.07197360694408417, 0.0033730831928551197, -0.018107637763023376, 0.03823642432689667, 0.004760280717164278, -0.029802344739437103 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/298/in-linear-regression-when-is-it-appropriate-to-use-the-log-of-an-independent-va">In linear regression, when is it appropriate to use the log of an independent variable instead of the actual values?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>I am running a series of multiple mediation models. Each model includes one IV, two mediators, and a DV. I’m using a macro created for SPSS (provided by Preacher and Hayes) that uses bootstrapping to examine the indirect effects of the mediators. My DV’s are depression and social anxiety (each run in a separate model) and are both positively skewed. Normally I would perform a log transformation on these variables, however, bootstrapping is a nonparametric resampling procedure that does not hold the assumption of normality of the sampling distribution. Therefore, my question is: Is it necessary to transform positively skewed DV’s even though I am using bootstrapping? </p> <p>Note: I have run my models with the log transformed means vs. untransformed means for the DV’s and the pattern of results are essentially the same. However, I would prefer to use the untransformed means as the unstandardized regression coefficients more strongly support my predictions. </p>
49,325
[ -0.060647495090961456, 0.019377971068024635, -0.02070874348282814, -0.025115717202425003, 0.02652215212583542, 0.010598692111670971, -0.03494706377387047, -0.018424713984131813, 0.02954067476093769, -0.018931878730654716, 0.031942013651132584, 0.015083413571119308, 0.05674751102924347, -0.02892397902905941, 0.029093127697706223, -0.0008935303776524961, -0.009911158122122288, 0.02241806499660015, -0.013489698991179466, 0.02186262421309948, -0.024270588532090187, 0.04430387169122696, 0.0027129733934998512, 0.018687043339014053, -0.016760624945163727, 0.07208216935396194, 0.009322228841483593, 0.004513104446232319, -0.03792189806699753, 0.04797985404729843, -0.0033471728675067425, 0.010753611102700233, -0.00448203831911087, 0.03296934813261032, -0.0031076897867023945, -0.019620731472969055, -0.01692010648548603, 0.01332235336303711, -0.01731453835964203, 0.05132476985454559, -0.019135136157274246, -0.013725530356168747, -0.04821088910102844, 0.05124302953481674, 0.033347729593515396, 0.056076787412166595, -0.007400385104119778, -0.03022473119199276, -0.009190928190946579, -0.02988637611269951, 0.05770578235387802, -0.03334123268723488, 0.007675311993807554, 0.05286860466003418, -0.019794313237071037, -0.024464339017868042, 0.04163793846964836, 0.057708337903022766, -0.0009217769256792963, -0.028621897101402283, 0.02524041198194027, -0.006991115398705006, -0.0203886479139328, -0.011849363334476948, -0.0077180564403533936, 0.02226797305047512, 0.05053985118865967, 0.00017283980560023338, 0.06626825779676437, -0.03687307983636856, 0.027570443227887154, 0.0016814700793474913, 0.04591440036892891, -0.019043341279029846, -0.01874108985066414, -0.04060450196266174, -0.0177881121635437, 0.03963562473654747, 0.05037558451294899, 0.045153796672821045, 0.031731124967336655, 0.022274024784564972, 0.00669687706977129, 0.040023963898420334, 0.021530166268348694, -0.009423024952411652, 0.09859991073608398, -0.01766243949532509, 0.026305120438337326, 0.04814732074737549, -0.029658880084753036, -0.025924209505319595, 0.05552281066775322, -0.0066505614668130875, -0.011366436257958412, 0.012169929221272469, -0.0006122041959315538, 0.0388002023100853, 0.015218974091112614, -0.0016025047516450286, -0.035759419202804565, -0.011396667920053005, 0.006899339146912098, 0.039588507264852524, 0.0076177469454705715, 0.00389823317527771, -0.041089724749326706, 0.03076017275452614, -0.01118285208940506, -0.06639546900987625, -0.02003060281276703, 0.004344834014773369, -0.006992826238274574, 0.02161894366145134, 0.042004216462373734, -0.019988292828202248, -0.01434380654245615, -0.020724868401885033, 0.029107511043548584, 0.026450788602232933, 0.03357775881886482, -0.045890096575021744, -0.00969927478581667, -0.02818039432168007, -0.027549391612410545, 0.05404461920261383, 0.03875516355037689, 0.0144162867218256, -0.030557090416550636, 0.034873489290475845, 0.04894452914595604, -0.016204284504055977, 0.03875866159796715, -0.0007999636000022292, -0.0022959099151194096, 0.003846097970381379, -0.059658922255039215, -0.0870552659034729, 0.04005934298038483, 0.024430228397250175, 0.02994733490049839, -0.055956028401851654, -0.04097560793161392, 0.022306222468614578, 0.03404040262103081, -0.003984219394624233, 0.05154647305607796, 0.02577994391322136, 0.03417222574353218, 0.022412948310375214, -0.02029218152165413, -0.022779468446969986, -0.04703940451145172, -0.03833547979593277, 0.007575121242552996, -0.10257464647293091, -0.0020069791935384274, 0.0225676279515028, -0.01667580008506775, 0.03341606631875038, 0.054581210017204285, -0.009163404814898968, -0.003461643122136593, 0.002506762742996216, 0.011706696823239326, -0.043067678809165955, 0.04617853835225105, -0.04777123034000397, 0.04735182598233223, -0.008456259965896606, -0.033950064331293106, 0.001625984557904303, 0.01710609346628189, 0.06128465756773949, 0.03574520722031593, -0.0232006274163723, -0.005119395907968283, -0.02394893206655979, 0.03692697733640671, -0.008842205628752708, -0.04085071012377739, -0.006879901513457298, -0.044934459030628204, -0.00930737890303135, 0.000873005366884172, 0.0492752306163311, 0.0039998991414904594, -0.005019516218453646, 0.015232359990477562, -0.03020540252327919, -0.06481228023767471, -0.02024981379508972, 0.016431428492069244, 0.017343400046229362, -0.018293660134077072, 0.05554613843560219, -0.009941430762410164, 0.05412236228585243, -0.014672627672553062, -0.005226657725870609, 0.009111329913139343, -0.02625279501080513, 0.060370005667209625, -0.048834845423698425, 0.02750861644744873, 0.04743054881691933, 0.05093546584248543, -0.033528197556734085, 0.014292403124272823, -0.02978801354765892, 0.0104279275983572, 0.019991697743535042, -0.017379041761159897, 0.022870337590575218, -0.034785617142915726, -0.017084568738937378, 0.0147609394043684, -0.005335927940905094, -0.029901962727308273, 0.027546100318431854, -0.05061866343021393, 0.053968511521816254, 0.06465137749910355, -0.019137924537062645, -0.012732015922665596, 0.03181911259889603, 0.008821086026728153, 0.020199133083224297, -0.0582859106361866, -0.008460285142064095, -0.04765576496720314, -0.01094895415008068, 0.036869704723358154, 0.016302673146128654, -0.017200948670506477, 0.020481936633586884, 0.05247817561030388, -0.013421846553683281, 0.014820866286754608, 0.007977591827511787, -0.011492539197206497, -0.047571875154972076, 0.015027710236608982, 0.017297936603426933, 0.03139861300587654, -0.022572685033082962, -0.013230822049081326, -0.0261251088231802, 0.034000009298324585, 0.01590752601623535, 0.01030926313251257, 0.029328716918826103, 0.028540275990962982, 0.01793258637189865, -0.020480243489146233, -0.014136942103505135, 0.03968429192900658, -0.040733519941568375, 0.012906881980597973, 0.06245167925953865, -0.021735424175858498, 0.0032134875655174255, 0.026186002418398857, -0.0014741802588105202, 0.009339225478470325, 0.06694913655519485, -0.03488447517156601, 0.0215580053627491, 0.008878842927515507, -0.03307584300637245, 0.0007819659658707678, -0.024479232728481293, -0.04044327512383461, 0.015519650653004646, -0.00284836208447814, 0.0058072879910469055, 0.021597176790237427, 0.003808087669312954, -0.04838980734348297, 0.020059550181031227, -0.013762010261416435, 0.014141151681542397, -0.0007262314902618527, 0.006452003959566355, -0.028465965762734413, -0.03934849053621292, -0.03849798068404198, -0.014753422699868679, -0.00842378567904234, -0.0010784866753965616, -0.02516270987689495, -0.0054131681099534035, -0.006329726427793503, -0.05576801300048828, -0.05808552727103233, -0.0045991619117558, 0.005406133830547333, 0.008079963736236095, -0.04246882349252701, 0.041814159601926804, 0.023404384031891823, -0.0652850940823555, -0.0058320630341768265, -0.01846115104854107, -0.029522806406021118, -0.01861971616744995, -0.017601607367396355, 0.012372275814414024, -0.012289297766983509, 0.04208934307098389, -0.02284942753612995, -0.04935783892869949, 0.003204729175195098, -0.07123645395040512, -0.05523276701569557, 0.049434032291173935, 0.055202629417181015, 0.05909377709031105, 0.0010537882335484028, -0.05275809392333031, 0.07510048896074295, 0.04677031189203262, -0.031105754896998405, -0.05130309984087944, -0.0221555158495903, -0.0418400876224041, 0.0011210533557459712, 0.017426872625947, 0.009805943816900253, 0.032123416662216187, 0.0466679111123085, -0.04536391794681549, 0.037415701895952225, -0.01250606682151556, 0.017882030457258224, -0.027676895260810852, 0.0013708046171814203, -0.011127516627311707, -0.04025597125291824, 0.02828233502805233, 0.032554592937231064, 0.014292096719145775, -0.016127731651067734, 0.013510193675756454, 0.02284437231719494, -0.004462673794478178, -0.04986982420086861, 0.014723895117640495, 0.005207507871091366, -0.005349508486688137, -0.047255709767341614, 0.03823346272110939, 0.01768258586525917, -0.016629327088594437, -0.02307334914803505, 0.02414690889418125, -0.0110190249979496, -0.022292455658316612, 0.01950829289853573, 0.005788946989923716, 0.03332598879933357, 0.029402513056993484, -0.0028215651400387287, -0.03908344358205795, -0.015700485557317734, 0.03185197338461876, -0.00992615520954132, 0.010609211400151253, 0.010427655652165413, 0.07523234933614731, -0.0015749098965898156, -0.03361652418971062, -0.04436647891998291, -0.0007791034877300262, -0.039079684764146805, 0.03548350930213928, -0.014971273951232433, -0.003407268086448312, 0.0186044629663229, 0.032940611243247986, 0.009857661090791225, -0.023143598809838295, -0.006074359640479088, -0.0023668825160712004, -0.055185165256261826, 0.035319700837135315, -0.010062151588499546, 0.025999540463089943, 0.03596397116780281, -0.03511626273393631, 0.02905598096549511, -0.02518545463681221, 0.022726915776729584, 0.019478268921375275, 0.03702312707901001, -0.016984809190034866, 0.015066538006067276, -0.008837347850203514, -0.02898511476814747, -0.00663753179833293, 0.01061785314232111, -0.011498053558170795, -0.029650770127773285, 0.021725978702306747, 0.02088378369808197, 0.010565612465143204, -0.021848531439900398, -0.03523002192378044, 0.02539019100368023, 0.03183622285723686, 0.06545526534318924, 0.006572010461241007, -0.023772921413183212, -0.03052973747253418, 0.023867372423410416, 0.030202707275748253, 0.017281292006373405, 0.02117403782904148, -0.02385767735540867, -0.027577420696616173, -0.029947491362690926, -0.01992034539580345, 0.000866031157784164, -0.003502708626911044, 0.012047204189002514, 0.041884712874889374, 0.048156872391700745, 0.024492105469107628, -0.057303790003061295, 0.027669787406921387, 0.07853267341852188, 0.01781151071190834, -0.04754825308918953, -0.029976719990372658, 0.012489449232816696, -0.010515681467950344, 0.002043643966317177, 0.04371800646185875, -0.006973990239202976, -0.003254145849496126, 0.013380039483308792, 0.033576902002096176, 0.0032471257727593184, -0.031333424150943756, 0.020359646528959274, -0.002777770860120654, 0.052304740995168686, -0.017765402793884277, -0.03504905477166176, 0.009682586416602135, 0.03316270932555199, 0.016423299908638, 0.024239556863904, -0.0013143349206075072, -0.0696517676115036, 0.03595620021224022, 0.03003012202680111, 0.051438961178064346, -0.03401648998260498, -0.0037353429943323135, 0.020729215815663338, -0.003898859489709139, 0.0016272648936137557, -0.036402828991413116, 0.0252371858805418, -0.0028975217137485743, 0.0050383941270411015, -0.01671222224831581, -0.029959160834550858, -0.0680936723947525, -0.0002944995940197259, 0.034107401967048645, -0.0064519974403083324, -0.009513508528470993, -0.04971998184919357, -0.06843437999486923, 0.023503169417381287, 0.005725837778300047, 0.04551956430077553, -0.044658951461315155, -0.03397025167942047, -0.013490931130945683, 0.027009107172489166, -0.04518381878733635, -0.05890331044793129, 0.006299765780568123, 0.03334122151136398, -0.010446612723171711, 0.04263985902070999, 0.039016347378492355, -0.03188483044505119, 0.006831773091107607, 0.009037208743393421, -0.02583235688507557, -0.021020961925387383, -0.016298964619636536, 0.04326116293668747, 0.018872583284974098, 0.01983734406530857, 0.06414895504713058, 0.044310763478279114, -0.01850966364145279, 0.004370083101093769, -0.04523402079939842, 0.0013399721356108785, -0.0716668963432312, -0.03435947373509407, -0.03911467641592026, -0.0020438062492758036, -0.012250563129782677, 0.036324452608823776, -0.02224179171025753, 0.012633404694497585, -0.006038719788193703, -0.012637821026146412, 0.023569095879793167, 0.03392070159316063, -0.011151918210089207, 0.0101363155990839, -0.014044400304555893, 0.003837482538074255, -0.026138117536902428, -0.018165715038776398, -0.009451254270970821, -0.027357468381524086, 0.022097652778029442, 0.007488958537578583, -0.056674737483263016, -0.015595797449350357, -0.004288631025701761, -0.0018223855877295136, 0.0277559831738472, -0.03874443843960762, -0.0028689743485301733, 0.024672893807291985, 0.020855670794844627, -0.017025640234351158, -0.04377226158976555, 0.015550459735095501, -0.007587526924908161, -0.04085485264658928, 0.031293660402297974, -0.048030536621809006, 0.03818436339497566, -0.03033294342458248, 0.008475272916257381, -0.02376599796116352, -0.03980032354593277, 0.04429544880986214, -0.032968513667583466, -0.009124408476054668, -0.008928420953452587, 0.0005550339701585472, -0.0035689075011759996, -0.012407341040670872, -0.042580340057611465, 0.08597371727228165, -0.01427147164940834, -0.03511042892932892, -0.023732665926218033, 0.017830172553658485, 0.06232066452503204, -0.015975363552570343, 0.020838141441345215, 0.04070786014199257, 0.004511519335210323, -0.029913729056715965, 0.03044208511710167, 0.019134940579533577, -0.02292771264910698, -0.0387079156935215, -0.03667106851935387, -0.011939126066863537, 0.051596712321043015, -0.017516836524009705, -0.006597475614398718, 0.024976138025522232, -0.008200976066291332, -0.0032974735368043184, 0.004832900129258633, -0.03054015338420868, 0.0023861764930188656, 0.003283201949670911, -0.016144994646310806, 0.021963495761156082, -0.04040491208434105, 0.02545192465186119, 0.046117790043354034, -0.010345669463276863, 0.007438881788402796, -0.016012663021683693, 0.06905162334442139, 0.02673957124352455, 0.01010296493768692, -0.014349481090903282, -0.04371935874223709, 0.04698796197772026, -0.014250692911446095, 0.0214153453707695, -0.003628925420343876, 0.011474872007966042, -0.013591625727713108, -0.048413537442684174, -0.02937224693596363, -0.017316659912467003, 0.05081453546881676, 0.0021384828723967075, 0.04065299779176712, 0.03421944007277489, -0.007659644354134798, -0.0036070486530661583, -0.059383999556303024, 0.020756451413035393, -0.018733495846390724, 0.028476528823375702, 0.05644764378666878, -0.018255801871418953, 0.01534905657172203, 0.002851832425221801, -0.031942564994096756, 0.024762270972132683, 0.052270565181970596, 0.03155205398797989, 0.04569942131638527, 0.03362106904387474, -0.033127833157777786, -0.038310494273900986, 0.03380405902862549, -0.05962036922574043, 0.01963179185986519, -0.027102632448077202, -0.025870583951473236, 0.034496769309043884, 0.037707094103097916, 0.005082734394818544, -0.05278533697128296, -0.008495892398059368, -0.03387090936303139, -0.008605523966252804, 0.010448690503835678, -0.008048854768276215, 0.03514167293906212, 0.0010292436927556992, 0.061496324837207794, 0.001393190468661487, -0.017641033977270126, -0.06650961190462112, -0.07993082702159882, -0.0026486534625291824, -0.014003833755850792, -0.05085056275129318, 0.032732732594013214, -0.06205553933978081, -0.006350413896143436, 0.012148530222475529, -0.065716452896595, -0.023295555263757706, -0.0011264608474448323, 0.01749752275645733, -0.02328922040760517, 0.08081425726413727, 0.0036483830772340298, -0.029739977791905403, -0.009316690266132355, -0.025782454758882523, 0.10436736792325974, 0.057694245129823685, 0.03159228339791298, -0.06522438675165176, 0.021675629541277885, 0.0014615923864766955, 0.04783403500914574, -0.017125248908996582, -0.00708662299439311, -0.00026694676489569247, -0.017423352226614952, 0.03641849011182785, 0.06990338116884232, 0.009063809178769588, -0.024929141625761986, 0.039427097886800766, -0.021291663870215416, 0.01941126212477684, 0.026744142174720764, -0.006345133297145367, -0.008601763285696507, 0.0037463936023414135, -0.032514188438653946, 0.014799581840634346, 0.005681358277797699, 0.013745800592005253, -0.009650035761296749, 0.004222795367240906, -0.019418422132730484, -0.03326617553830147, -0.02018766850233078, 0.012615255080163479, 0.04595222324132919, 0.011258259415626526, -0.02601437456905842, 0.006142306607216597, 0.0366714745759964, -0.05207257717847824, 0.04211072251200676, 0.039613112807273865, -0.059418439865112305, 0.032953012734651566, 0.017109211534261703, 0.01210584957152605, -0.044238630682229996, -0.03776160255074501, -0.03626125305891037, 0.04693174362182617, 0.003497669007629156, -0.02601357363164425, -0.014281690120697021, 0.0027451866772025824, 0.00042890236363746226, -0.019789334386587143, -0.010993638075888157, 0.02264268696308136, 0.021385950967669487, -0.022502651438117027, -0.046572402119636536, -0.013236284255981445, -0.017935115844011307, 0.04765748977661133, 0.031417954713106155, 0.028883356600999832, 0.009256484918296337, -0.028263568878173828, -0.015076831914484501, 0.027034703642129898, 0.010425034910440445, -0.001953991362825036, -0.028325378894805908, 0.007473309524357319, -0.037392422556877136, -0.022054273635149002, 0.04965948313474655, -0.015846682712435722, 0.0499865785241127, -0.006079571787267923, 0.02227078564465046, -0.07883282005786896, -0.03154630586504936, 0.008078275248408318, -0.03344372659921646, -0.00802783202379942, -0.04407501220703125, 0.021668730303645134, 0.015397327952086926, 0.023349864408373833, 0.015291167423129082, -0.0007092559244483709, -0.0004243752919137478, 0.05550092086195946, -0.00020550390763673931, -0.050268471240997314, -0.044061776250600815, -0.0034140925854444504, -0.020382937043905258, -0.008470570668578148, -0.036416590213775635, 0.030139977112412453, 0.01661165989935398, 0.015163288451731205, -0.04527529701590538, 0.0399215966463089, 0.00457563903182745, 0.024353807792067528, 0.0334610752761364, -0.04561322182416916, 0.01215932983905077, 0.007346021477133036, -0.0018197769531980157, 0.02484164945781231, 0.025028742849826813, -0.03411003202199936, -0.033025726675987244, 0.0027411682531237602, -0.02820766530930996, -0.036401789635419846, 0.01757056638598442, -0.009247406385838985, 0.03497534990310669, -0.03849015384912491, -0.0496402382850647, -0.0288773775100708, 0.02595602534711361, -0.01251907180994749, -0.02941528521478176, 0.0030193913262337446, 0.019295576959848404, -0.0018765071872621775, 0.030540719628334045, 0.05603979900479317, 0.014965971931815147, 0.008609140291810036, -0.028351619839668274, 0.020150678232312202, -0.00413148570805788, 0.026908954605460167, 0.0016354859108105302, -0.021863488480448723, 0.05897120386362076, -0.010618711821734905, -0.02908678725361824, 0.01541865337640047, 0.007668077480047941, 0.022617673501372337, 0.0025228182785212994, 0.028469355776906013, -0.021148892119526863, 0.055909425020217896, -0.012325034476816654, 0.016539478674530983, -0.03001365438103676, -0.04209940508008003, 0.014064915478229523, 0.012192068621516228, -0.0008396182092837989, 0.03838244825601578, -0.01003276091068983, 0.02992437221109867, 0.029215563088655472, -0.0024276163894683123, 0.022545330226421356, -0.007640470284968615, 0.03439232334494591, 0.024861473590135574, -0.013642460107803345, 0.002893220167607069, 0.027485636994242668, 0.03136242926120758, -0.05101638287305832, 0.010337332263588905, -0.036908648908138275, 0.001199439400807023, -0.08403417468070984, -0.00703017832711339, 0.007451884914189577, 0.02267507091164589, 0.017289692535996437, -0.04853219911456108, -0.01183389127254486, 0.005607034079730511, -0.011876925826072693, -0.012555267661809921, -0.01449416670948267, -0.015939464792609215, -0.024470798671245575, 0.015325271524488926, -0.031745005398988724, 0.034904103726148605, 0.0196077823638916, 0.02850996144115925, -0.03252347931265831, 0.00685129314661026, 0.030612213537096977, -0.0031257844530045986, -0.016653921455144882, 0.025471506640315056, 0.03060479834675789, -0.061211809515953064, 0.050289545208215714, -0.061004433780908585, -0.0019443334313109517, 0.06308741122484207, -0.0014593997038900852, 0.042644061148166656, 0.009248360991477966, 0.014387072995305061, 0.025606701150536537, 0.07276301085948944, 0.005141302011907101, -0.008271331898868084, 0.007694294676184654, 0.021004371345043182, 0.014586398378014565, 0.03478299826383591, 0.012139645405113697, -0.002176637528464198, 0.0028621647506952286, -0.015256796032190323, -0.0031542982906103134, -0.008800456300377846, -0.026459461078047752, -0.018506448715925217, -0.02213895320892334, -0.010556728579103947, -0.0042871152982115746, -0.006468834821134806, 0.0034173496533185244, -0.04836130887269974, 0.001123068737797439, 0.0646505206823349, 0.025436915457248688, -0.018886102363467216, 0.01365732029080391, -0.011034389957785606, -0.0719178318977356, -0.0012661325745284557, -0.02295701578259468, 0.011641978286206722, -0.054837897419929504, -0.0047989473678171635, -0.011678040027618408, 0.0027368059381842613, 0.003233717754483223, 0.026372047141194344, -0.02850242331624031, 0.06402509659528732, -0.06517284363508224, 0.028403988108038902, -0.010793061926960945, -0.0258499588817358, 0.007608345244079828, -0.06705142557621002, 0.0703742653131485, 0.011096647009253502, -0.028621524572372437, -0.05004535987973213, -0.012441148050129414, -0.008717777207493782, 0.014179233461618423, 0.05649011954665184, -0.00015355981304310262, -0.0057301889173686504, 0.013741782866418362, 0.035152554512023926, -0.011994581669569016, -0.039083123207092285, 0.028026631101965904, 0.013416759669780731, 0.019268963485956192, -0.014604601077735424, 0.01247137226164341, -0.019695069640874863, 0.02008650451898575, 0.038592755794525146, -0.04857225716114044, 0.020212560892105103, 0.01837274059653282, 0.014035905711352825, 0.047143708914518356, 0.022850697860121727, -0.01822415180504322, 0.04319066181778908, 0.022674554958939552, -0.004884790629148483, 0.0499301552772522, 0.009059932082891464, -0.051142752170562744, -0.004767332226037979, -0.0000824906092020683, -0.04131985828280449, 0.0027693375013768673, 0.016383156180381775, -0.009177546948194504, -0.054563235491514206, 0.01328688208013773, 0.020307371392846107, -0.0607478953897953, -0.0016091131838038564, 0.03134690970182419, -0.000972662353888154, 0.017422067001461983, 0.00982317328453064, 0.03434411436319351, 0.002851685509085655, -0.013844101689755917, 0.010557188652455807, -0.0033345455303788185, 0.020877236500382423, 0.05455436930060387, -0.03272409364581108, 0.04363285005092621, -0.009991811588406563, 0.07389461249113083, -0.0017083045095205307, 0.05506274476647377, -0.03556804358959198, -0.03843660652637482, 0.027503307908773422, 0.0024744467809796333, 0.016579296439886093, -0.007454549428075552, 0.01933123543858528, 0.016987064853310585, -0.030711717903614044, 0.021826433017849922, -0.010190561413764954, -0.029000449925661087, -0.06862416118383408, 0.028644822537899017, 0.0111275315284729, 0.0036276732571423054, 0.022781824693083763, 0.02245715633034706, 0.016270063817501068, -0.03961595520377159, 0.013033795170485973, -0.026769323274493217, 0.021278709173202515, -0.017757127061486244, -0.01368025690317154, -0.010960678569972515, -0.04525778815150261, -0.03903479874134064, -0.03379061073064804, -0.0033036794047802687, 0.020809810608625412, -0.009066447615623474, -0.024533230811357498, -0.03564413636922836, -0.015999138355255127, 0.07125749439001083, -0.02937980182468891, -0.009307936765253544, -0.01990494318306446, 0.00943784136325121, 0.017279649153351784, -0.03623185679316521 ]
<p>Let's say I have 1 success in 4 bernoulli trials, and I wish to plot the distribution of the parameter $p$ of the corresponding binomial distribution. I'm using R.</p> <p>The probability of seeing 1 sucess and 3 failures in 4 tests for $p=0.25$ is, for these parameters:</p> <pre><code>&gt; n &lt;- 4 &gt; p &lt;- 0.25 &gt; dbinom(1, n, p) [1] 0.421875 </code></pre> <p>To get the distribution for the parameter, I use a beta distribution $Beta(k+1, n-k+1)$. But when I try to calculate the value for $p=0.25$, I get a different result:</p> <pre><code>&gt; k &lt;- 1 &gt; dbeta(p, k+1, n-k+1) &gt; [1] 2.109375 </code></pre> <p>I tried to divide that by the function beta $B(k+1, n-k+1)$, but that did not work either:</p> <pre><code>&gt; dbeta(p, k+1, n-k+1)/beta(k+1, n-k+1) &gt; [1] 42.1875 </code></pre> <p>That's exactly 100 times the result I expected. I am certainly missing something - maybe something basic, I'm no expert.</p> <p>Another thing that intrigues me: <code>dbeta</code> region sums to 1 without dividing by the beta function.</p>
47,532
[ -0.020462077111005783, 0.015109959058463573, 0.004875220824033022, -0.007510315161198378, 0.04866104573011398, -0.0021953252144157887, 0.011860583908855915, -0.003693959442898631, 0.04114248976111412, -0.04436551034450531, 0.06628915667533875, 0.04727112501859665, 0.04012802988290787, -0.005948172416538, 0.016409046947956085, -0.0053777387365698814, -0.042960379272699356, -0.004577706102281809, -0.011412912048399448, -0.03581666201353073, 0.029917141422629356, 0.01331715565174818, 0.03069526143372059, -0.033036548644304276, -0.007513744290918112, 0.0007938360795378685, 0.032943736761808395, -0.006566634867340326, -0.003844853490591049, 0.07481265813112259, -0.041627299040555954, -0.04236928001046181, 0.04825962334871292, 0.04168017953634262, 0.007408844772726297, 0.014101184904575348, -0.02305898256599903, -0.03638225048780441, -0.033493347465991974, 0.017224710434675217, -0.026198476552963257, -0.011084398254752159, -0.0016786630731076002, 0.02296690084040165, -0.027665989473462105, -0.0041543603874742985, 0.0157167986035347, 0.005815047770738602, 0.02749994397163391, -0.047030072659254074, 0.041756488382816315, 0.04196569696068764, 0.014998515136539936, 0.04160679876804352, -0.014134078286588192, -0.033093418926000595, 0.04746958240866661, 0.0857856422662735, 0.02184608019888401, -0.031049629673361778, -0.022051945328712463, -0.044341206550598145, 0.0036971948575228453, -0.013138029724359512, -0.0301218144595623, -0.01797349750995636, 0.003911251202225685, -0.014143573120236397, 0.021561164408922195, -0.01644725166261196, 0.00871601514518261, 0.03649897128343582, 0.037693239748477936, -0.016635527834296227, -0.009013034403324127, 0.024726225063204765, -0.00282849813811481, -0.030805733054876328, 0.06340975314378738, 0.02060425840318203, -0.02060551755130291, 0.02286435104906559, 0.021529005840420723, -0.002537531778216362, 0.01888459548354149, -0.03381602093577385, 0.07022899389266968, -0.011564258486032486, 0.02804368920624256, 0.0010280299466103315, -0.021142059937119484, 0.015898065641522408, 0.043026238679885864, 0.01840030401945114, -0.01985437050461769, 0.0597839280962944, -0.009774130769073963, 0.02235775999724865, 0.022570734843611717, -0.0212014801800251, -0.03818142041563988, -0.04700847715139389, 0.02795698679983616, 0.0651715025305748, -0.03428516909480095, -0.02663627453148365, -0.020729972049593925, 0.005220835562795401, -0.01133648119866848, -0.007586331572383642, -0.02286546677350998, 0.03448722884058952, -0.0008312745485454798, 0.0041167158633470535, 0.031090673059225082, -0.03256090730428696, -0.01616530865430832, 0.000029144135623937473, 0.018822098150849342, 0.0238020196557045, 0.015647724270820618, 0.00011011162860086188, 0.02692159079015255, -0.02559717185795307, -0.03663637116551399, 0.005177871324121952, 0.009110765531659126, -0.014201994054019451, -0.017301904037594795, 0.04026733711361885, -0.016093656420707703, -0.010951782576739788, 0.028881849721074104, 0.009262804873287678, 0.02639910764992237, 0.022879965603351593, -0.03305996581912041, -0.030155900865793228, 0.041265588253736496, 0.006359209772199392, -0.01521371491253376, -0.05562543496489525, 0.03752351924777031, 0.04695664718747139, 0.044874973595142365, -0.0026736310683190823, 0.02501372992992401, -0.017970284447073936, 0.004135079216212034, 0.04398949071764946, -0.050264373421669006, 0.007462276611477137, -0.00917656160891056, -0.014260074123740196, -0.03747190162539482, -0.06424271315336227, 0.0042591639794409275, -0.014784717001020908, 0.010884955525398254, -0.030736353248357773, 0.046634234488010406, -0.005638362839818001, -0.006159378681331873, -0.04318150132894516, 0.009123924188315868, -0.02435818314552307, 0.0869779884815216, 0.033451102674007416, 0.016248345375061035, 0.01372477225959301, -0.009670214727520943, 0.011455856263637543, -0.009665077552199364, 0.021874628961086273, 0.07034245878458023, -0.03598916530609131, 0.02409129962325096, -0.018808364868164062, 0.03760667145252228, 0.005448015872389078, -0.01729465089738369, -0.002049051458016038, -0.00021848019969183952, 0.019154135137796402, -0.0020172882359474897, 0.008839546702802181, 0.012244001030921936, -0.009779360145330429, 0.046608634293079376, -0.034691158682107925, -0.05457744747400284, -0.07628469169139862, -0.03925849869847298, 0.01925235241651535, -0.036988094449043274, 0.03199637308716774, 0.005014821887016296, 0.03187574818730354, -0.008588734082877636, -0.008404507301747799, -0.02489178441464901, 0.0038538675289601088, 0.06656612455844879, -0.0362466461956501, -0.03965654596686363, 0.05358042195439339, 0.061436593532562256, 0.006195735651999712, 0.057226937264204025, -0.026785098016262054, -0.011013242416083813, -0.003420765744522214, -0.04838910698890686, 0.0018387256423011422, -0.01841268502175808, -0.028606323525309563, -0.005149324890226126, 0.019305050373077393, 0.004919264931231737, 0.03269282355904579, -0.08143617957830429, 0.056151777505874634, 0.09791000187397003, 0.037566062062978745, 0.014065892435610294, -0.014298301190137863, 0.029188690707087517, -0.0001549740700284019, -0.042189598083496094, -0.012822848744690418, -0.04165557399392128, 0.020997390151023865, 0.0036302923690527678, -0.035404812544584274, -0.0007494192686863244, 0.05062791332602501, 0.03392729163169861, -0.03295506164431572, 0.004328869748860598, 0.0305836983025074, 0.0231131911277771, 0.03813600912690163, -0.01925843022763729, -0.0003646222467068583, 0.01811324432492256, 0.008514126762747765, 0.004090525675565004, 0.00691121444106102, 0.020421920344233513, -0.02256840281188488, -0.018379950895905495, 0.022737715393304825, -0.046449024230241776, -0.032675642520189285, -0.03736218437552452, 0.015014193020761013, 0.04752204194664955, 0.0017265151254832745, -0.006448258180171251, 0.042861513793468475, 0.031645625829696655, 0.024152321740984917, 0.0014765918022021651, -0.06217804178595543, 0.03771957755088806, 0.05555862560868263, -0.02957778424024582, -0.03989659249782562, 0.019740480929613113, -0.016203010454773903, 0.03230072557926178, -0.028797628358006477, -0.01692323572933674, -0.0027112741954624653, 0.029454166069626808, -0.0019066159147769213, 0.029912184923887253, 0.016940316185355186, -0.036508794873952866, -0.02891412377357483, 0.0008850263548083603, 0.029247116297483444, 0.02441069483757019, 0.02484714612364769, -0.056775081902742386, -0.018478350713849068, -0.031096475198864937, 0.001038084737956524, 0.02772180177271366, 0.006870047189295292, -0.049672357738018036, -0.016211863607168198, 0.013509348966181278, -0.025975795462727547, -0.028478100895881653, -0.041153356432914734, 0.005988729652017355, -0.07808877527713776, -0.024418005719780922, 0.07088659703731537, 0.017299924045801163, 0.018304184079170227, 0.05700041726231575, -0.041209880262613297, -0.010049778036773205, -0.01387864165008068, -0.00867004320025444, 0.014812280423939228, 0.00600806437432766, 0.013888826593756676, 0.02714487910270691, -0.02044595405459404, -0.03542559593915939, -0.047049231827259064, -0.07850420475006104, -0.018543772399425507, -0.004599340260028839, 0.005087544675916433, 0.007994109764695168, -0.01624053344130516, 0.08619161695241928, 0.05043100193142891, 0.029998915269970894, -0.019613943994045258, -0.0023192591033875942, -0.0627889335155487, -0.048660751432180405, -0.0027492560911923647, 0.004315461032092571, -0.01653343066573143, 0.03242332488298416, -0.01567135564982891, 0.017466722056269646, 0.06221932917833328, -0.034244831651449203, -0.006718296092003584, 0.02537793107330799, 0.011228210292756557, -0.01622636802494526, 0.06187450885772705, 0.007111614570021629, 0.002745036967098713, 0.006995628122240305, 0.006849860306829214, 0.010555947199463844, -0.009094789624214172, -0.02495194412767887, 0.009947603568434715, -0.0037411393132060766, 0.010747561231255531, -0.010101698338985443, 0.04625517502427101, 0.008284066803753376, -0.021750928834080696, -0.01552374567836523, 0.0002742959186434746, 0.07484915107488632, -0.024742206558585167, 0.018253562971949577, 0.038307055830955505, 0.018501462414860725, -0.03577111288905144, -0.031205181032419205, 0.014841727912425995, -0.01614370010793209, -0.017413562163710594, -0.013324560597538948, -0.015857581049203873, 0.02452758327126503, 0.013775808736681938, 0.005918571259826422, -0.008104654029011726, -0.03846040740609169, -0.0012717790668830276, -0.034108661115169525, -0.04014910012483597, -0.061343323439359665, 0.03390520438551903, 0.023982679471373558, 0.0028531921561807394, -0.0028156451880931854, -0.02098243311047554, -0.007997236214578152, -0.006291991099715233, -0.04524509236216545, 0.016560036689043045, 0.005664269905537367, -0.03575723245739937, -0.021374816074967384, 0.005896244663745165, 0.051904045045375824, 0.023016462102532387, 0.022536998614668846, 0.04592122137546539, 0.011367524042725563, -0.027198143303394318, -0.018688160926103592, -0.013845673762261868, -0.010043195448815823, -0.02215205691754818, 0.016930680721998215, 0.01825171336531639, -0.015425330959260464, 0.025005899369716644, 0.062476228922605515, 0.014299863018095493, 0.020415576174855232, -0.06302964687347412, 0.027091024443507195, -0.006673778407275677, 0.016111580654978752, 0.060304194688797, 0.013779151253402233, -0.05262255296111107, 0.00487157516181469, 0.012834168039262295, 0.045508965849876404, 0.053385037928819656, 0.004063213709741831, -0.0015709195286035538, -0.03711448609828949, -0.01788044534623623, 0.01766418293118477, -0.041765134781599045, 0.028073061257600784, 0.008768999017775059, 0.062231890857219696, 0.023242484778165817, -0.04058891907334328, 0.0476803183555603, 0.031598933041095734, -0.03791950270533562, 0.00169936113525182, -0.03148967772722244, -0.021830478683114052, -0.018233897164463997, -0.033472172915935516, -0.01471085287630558, 0.02143104001879692, -0.0008626948692835867, 0.027219273149967194, 0.05599359795451164, -0.05720653384923935, 0.02022726833820343, 0.029237845912575722, 0.01613715849816799, 0.01783958077430725, -0.013064146041870117, -0.028741998597979546, 0.020789911970496178, 0.0061486694030463696, 0.020136911422014236, 0.031071804463863373, -0.040962476283311844, -0.032452989369630814, -0.02784648723900318, 0.06240202486515045, 0.022252514958381653, -0.0253155454993248, 0.002160323318094015, -0.05467693880200386, 0.0007498696213588119, 0.009276478551328182, -0.06284022331237793, 0.028618277981877327, 0.001681437366642058, 0.05948506295681, -0.02434980869293213, -0.048922017216682434, -0.05041470751166344, 0.016151461750268936, -0.038387615233659744, 0.03376186639070511, -0.02227211929857731, -0.012659690342843533, -0.038559574633836746, 0.020056413486599922, 0.015046871267259121, 0.09498005360364914, -0.01952609233558178, -0.04971037805080414, 0.000007799058948876336, -0.011171606369316578, -0.02788555435836315, -0.06529583036899567, 0.012806199491024017, -0.015634652227163315, 0.008681939914822578, 0.04132870212197304, -0.007274826057255268, -0.022458091378211975, 0.04072767123579979, -0.00155971001368016, -0.03096853755414486, 0.0021267873235046864, -0.015839435160160065, 0.044145554304122925, 0.04877965897321701, 0.03668710216879845, 0.05118062347173691, 0.0029387380927801132, -0.004674854688346386, 0.010860909707844257, -0.04650326445698738, -0.000914200150873512, 0.012494740076363087, 0.007994158193469048, -0.043474230915308, -0.00006373556971084327, 0.004693556576967239, 0.022533012554049492, 0.007280171848833561, -0.004843457136303186, -0.015772534534335136, -0.03326140344142914, -0.001449862844310701, 0.0251662265509367, 0.023606497794389725, -0.006410237401723862, 0.03586773946881294, 0.004628838039934635, 0.005170229822397232, -0.02599499002099037, 0.03518661856651306, -0.01677330583333969, 0.003509120550006628, 0.04426758363842964, -0.03967367112636566, 0.01780206710100174, -0.04363338649272919, 0.005077030975371599, 0.024005400016903877, -0.026228487491607666, 0.019315529614686966, -0.003926230128854513, 0.030630959197878838, -0.010212564840912819, -0.029845429584383965, -0.030113063752651215, 0.009164620190858841, -0.02772955782711506, -0.017618518322706223, -0.049776721745729446, 0.013955286704003811, -0.013798674568533897, 0.030873220413923264, -0.07623139768838882, -0.04229617863893509, 0.034782081842422485, 0.00007501793879782781, 0.008095096796751022, -0.01697889342904091, -0.03226878494024277, 0.0037188061978667974, -0.020304223522543907, 0.033881932497024536, 0.045103996992111206, -0.02613111585378647, -0.023410873487591743, -0.018534725531935692, 0.03623811900615692, 0.08750168234109879, -0.008223259821534157, 0.008521693758666515, 0.005092211998999119, -0.005389055702835321, -0.029633168131113052, 0.01924336701631546, 0.015302254818379879, -0.04670627787709236, 0.009085687808692455, 0.017249472439289093, 0.006367606110870838, 0.053896788507699966, -0.04422757402062416, -0.028012437745928764, 0.005692663136869669, 0.0023759519681334496, 0.025306005030870438, -0.03951733931899071, -0.004232007544487715, 0.04092204198241234, 0.005687312688678503, -0.019711816683411598, 0.006339275278151035, -0.020173707976937294, -0.0016165523556992412, 0.019207177683711052, 0.002042921492829919, -0.023899896070361137, 0.006994897499680519, 0.1011621281504631, -0.005304727237671614, 0.014911001548171043, -0.02185923047363758, -0.01834479160606861, 0.06300557404756546, 0.04206007346510887, -0.03173630312085152, 0.009939929470419884, 0.025495029985904694, -0.016681740060448647, -0.01512416172772646, -0.04061015322804451, 0.000012372801393212285, 0.02818661741912365, -0.03270312398672104, 0.03752199932932854, 0.007346408441662788, -0.0035073217004537582, 0.019586745649576187, 0.000839347077999264, 0.0011280508479103446, -0.00159778306260705, 0.009865679778158665, 0.029283776879310608, 0.0023748758248984814, -0.006722576916217804, 0.029768221080303192, 0.011896703392267227, -0.002333715558052063, 0.017594384029507637, 0.007990904152393341, -0.011750451289117336, 0.027934502810239792, -0.037557829171419144, -0.02011902630329132, 0.04918743669986725, -0.031190281733870506, 0.021475721150636673, -0.049680568277835846, -0.05312655121088028, 0.07128271460533142, -0.0009422159637324512, -0.02851189114153385, -0.05622052401304245, -0.016788063570857048, -0.025222521275281906, -0.03492077440023422, 0.045951563864946365, -0.023130418732762337, 0.04579736664891243, -0.012576638720929623, 0.04767291620373726, 0.016877133399248123, 0.058612462133169174, 0.003820552257820964, -0.04246800020337105, -0.06459163129329681, -0.02376638911664486, -0.03023635782301426, 0.041524920612573624, 0.0004785518685821444, -0.009875484742224216, 0.01745470054447651, -0.028969233855605125, 0.058292269706726074, 0.0356786772608757, 0.007961282506585121, 0.009677151218056679, 0.06070173904299736, 0.02892901934683323, 0.022629274055361748, 0.00043311621993780136, -0.007223563268780708, 0.1399756669998169, 0.07714533060789108, 0.03911910951137543, -0.06481147557497025, -0.012169498018920422, 0.020647959783673286, 0.012857037596404552, 0.006706748623400927, 0.015697265043854713, 0.026938248425722122, -0.013352146372199059, 0.04472028464078903, 0.0446588397026062, -0.00766817107796669, 0.029186414554715157, 0.003007297869771719, -0.04554029554128647, -0.02310287393629551, 0.016667254269123077, 0.0252402164041996, -0.019417747855186462, -0.03362926468253136, -0.031156985089182854, 0.00971008837223053, 0.0024440744891762733, -0.0006792875938117504, -0.03834890201687813, -0.0121318893507123, -0.022835038602352142, 0.006894905585795641, 0.011961287818849087, -0.01896243542432785, 0.006696542724967003, -0.01159721426665783, 0.027739712968468666, -0.006365353707224131, 0.01305510476231575, -0.023622946813702583, 0.014867053367197514, 0.029093630611896515, -0.003997480031102896, -0.0020169373601675034, 0.001722052227705717, 0.045143336057662964, -0.037993233650922775, -0.021071668714284897, -0.0009870713111013174, 0.0123817827552557, -0.03826077654957771, -0.012055901810526848, -0.023132916539907455, -0.023384863510727882, 0.001396617037244141, -0.04489552602171898, -0.013294455595314503, 0.04583648964762688, -0.007486601360142231, -0.018532084301114082, -0.014139482751488686, 0.01889270916581154, 0.020861247554421425, -0.00466383108869195, 0.009555228054523468, 0.0005031591281294823, -0.017824765294790268, 0.002945426618680358, -0.005941927898675203, 0.04434280842542648, 0.0007467695977538824, -0.002685011364519596, 0.013867707923054695, -0.01480814442038536, -0.049788471311330795, 0.04714734107255936, -0.030552536249160767, -0.01052598562091589, 0.006263199727982283, -0.016448212787508965, -0.024577636271715164, 0.00850877445191145, -0.024464979767799377, 0.0043799988925457, -0.02970215119421482, -0.005168430507183075, -0.03333072364330292, 0.004189203958958387, 0.02335260808467865, 0.03308805823326111, 0.008199241943657398, -0.004823458380997181, -0.01665654219686985, 0.06201166659593582, 0.010246007703244686, -0.07356596738100052, -0.006953525356948376, 0.02091330476105213, -0.044922180473804474, 0.012288603000342846, -0.05077008157968521, 0.05916769430041313, 0.02975122258067131, 0.03845281898975372, 0.01854756288230419, 0.04144749790430069, -0.019063105806708336, 0.003276666160672903, -0.0074849301017820835, -0.0666811540722847, 0.020748892799019814, -0.006841825786978006, 0.01882220432162285, -0.027269108220934868, -0.009686814621090889, -0.037475135177373886, -0.010285750031471252, 0.02008272148668766, -0.032804109156131744, -0.0413922481238842, -0.02609565481543541, -0.008404805324971676, -0.027231942862272263, -0.017792807891964912, 0.00941153522580862, 0.005982364993542433, -0.00867814477533102, -0.02185504324734211, 0.009163131937384605, -0.02615666203200817, 0.010659432969987392, -0.031106216832995415, -0.007598318159580231, 0.023523515090346336, 0.04324928671121597, 0.031916867941617966, -0.010904990136623383, 0.012396452017128468, 0.009857308119535446, 0.014726920984685421, -0.0014727642992511392, -0.03196127712726593, 0.03590225800871849, -0.03363828733563423, -0.06882420182228088, -0.011770476587116718, 0.03564890846610069, 0.011816469021141529, 0.007885201834142208, 0.006078754551708698, -0.050039805471897125, 0.03357269987463951, -0.05436824634671211, -0.008179866708815098, 0.03283035755157471, -0.017460638657212257, 0.02859845571219921, 0.023812301456928253, 0.002930331276729703, 0.011140144430100918, 0.010561192408204079, -0.015281024388968945, 0.02739453874528408, 0.009304696694016457, -0.009481110610067844, 0.013900135643780231, -0.026097556576132774, 0.017408443614840508, 0.016804756596684456, 0.004019596613943577, 0.010724554769694805, 0.07238952815532684, -0.043497346341609955, 0.014925267547369003, -0.06168649345636368, 0.034673020243644714, -0.12295754253864288, -0.02668212354183197, 0.004096748307347298, 0.011264716275036335, 0.05555635318160057, -0.05553470551967621, 0.0295279398560524, 0.008604592643678188, -0.017125742509961128, 0.04710877314209938, -0.02114698477089405, -0.0020924913696944714, -0.08040803670883179, 0.001579266507178545, -0.00986796710640192, 0.04306255653500557, 0.049852095544338226, 0.016745945438742638, 0.05478563904762268, 0.000521015259437263, 0.03629842400550842, -0.021977098658680916, -0.003930995240807533, 0.010584412142634392, -0.0016918241744861007, -0.06909512728452682, 0.032088082283735275, -0.015287629328668118, -0.04559634253382683, 0.0034384073223918676, -0.014787925407290459, -0.011829040013253689, 0.004471538122743368, 0.020408278331160545, 0.010316039435565472, 0.09350725263357162, 0.03803781047463417, -0.023470042273402214, 0.02173670195043087, -0.010500227101147175, 0.01988966576755047, -0.007370354142040014, -0.05076444521546364, 0.013978573493659496, 0.04429016262292862, 0.017500150948762894, -0.06157083809375763, 0.0012735642958432436, -0.010418425314128399, -0.05722764506936073, -0.035302553325891495, -0.014660967513918877, 0.021388540044426918, -0.07365783303976059, 0.03630504757165909, -0.026609793305397034, 0.014608907513320446, 0.047026004642248154, 0.018788328394293785, 0.0063398671336472034, 0.0038595611695200205, -0.02554684691131115, -0.04215593636035919, -0.04264974594116211, -0.0001478401682106778, -0.011786996386945248, -0.007418992463499308, 0.004799908492714167, 0.0018429122865200043, 0.03481391444802284, -0.017403407022356987, -0.0383448526263237, 0.0016846639337018132, 0.011959572322666645, -0.01890421472489834, 0.014253995381295681, 0.0027552908286452293, 0.0008274530991911888, 0.011140655726194382, -0.10805198550224304, 0.06679399311542511, -0.022174907848238945, -0.0408179946243763, -0.029221784323453903, 0.004189616534858942, -0.062016379088163376, 0.0018461095169186592, 0.045488063246011734, 0.011301141232252121, -0.012181743048131466, 0.00800086185336113, 0.030377129092812538, -0.012358240783214569, -0.06564565747976303, 0.025420883670449257, -0.0341581255197525, -0.05009235069155693, -0.04513714462518692, 0.006842940580099821, 0.01097955834120512, 0.029768669977784157, 0.0005639261798933148, 0.005804469343274832, 0.011272519826889038, -0.0272290650755167, 0.020845776423811913, 0.024297842755913734, -0.003305949503555894, -0.013600725680589676, 0.03267056122422218, 0.017229285091161728, 0.06095816567540169, 0.02334457077085972, 0.02661420963704586, -0.05232467129826546, 0.034498512744903564, -0.021567899733781815, -0.023104092106223106, -0.02287304401397705, -0.027049848809838295, -0.030601760372519493, -0.053899407386779785, 0.002819591434672475, -0.009159045293927193, -0.037604860961437225, 0.0029153793584555387, 0.016762156039476395, -0.0008177041308954358, 0.07069481909275055, -0.015211081132292747, -0.005467513110488653, 0.023441458120942116, 0.007415670435875654, -0.00505405105650425, 0.02585792914032936, 0.004952788818627596, -0.015914857387542725, 0.02253970317542553, 0.014919454231858253, 0.01213648822158575, 0.00651177205145359, -0.0024933312088251114, 0.06698311120271683, -0.0007700538262724876, -0.00983057077974081, 0.0402013398706913, -0.03089040517807007, -0.016826460137963295, 0.002381392987444997, 0.006789069622755051, 0.05171562731266022, -0.005059448536485434, 0.054906804114580154, -0.01598384603857994, -0.044663846492767334, -0.0018903115997090936, -0.017239157110452652, -0.007000940851867199, 0.018566491082310677, -0.012478887103497982, 0.007702407892793417, -0.0034680403769016266, 0.01670878566801548, 0.014594217762351036, -0.014186377637088299, -0.007445438299328089, -0.028093654662370682, 0.033510930836200714, -0.00839131698012352, -0.03990060091018677, -0.025675272569060326, -0.03214544430375099, 0.03347409889101982, 0.013976164162158966, 0.006211364176124334, -0.005998664069920778, -0.030751042068004608, -0.005988430231809616, 0.06255131214857101, -0.014692207798361778, -0.03632486239075661, -0.043848030269145966, 0.02849831059575081, 0.03435936197638512, 0.0011792982695624232 ]
<p>Is it possible to do discriminant analysis with random effects? Is there an R package for this?</p> <p>Context: </p> <p>I have habitat use data for two species of frogs from radio telemetry, but nested within 'species' the data is for individuals with highly autocorrelated data. </p> <p>For example, I have ~280 relocations for species 1, with a mean of 20 relocations per individual, and ~ 210 relocations for species 2, with a mean of 13 relocations per animal. Relocations per animal are highly autocorrelated. At each relocation I collected structural habitat data, and I would like to identify which parameters are most strongly identified with each species.</p> <p>My preference is to have this autocorrelation accounted for in the analysis, but my alternatives with DA, I think, are to:</p> <ol> <li>Use mean values for each individual, however then I would be breaking assumptions of sample size as I would have fewer samples than variables (therefore not a viable alternative); or</li> <li>Cut relocations from individuals with lots of data points. </li> </ol> <p>I've done some searching through CranR, docs, etc, but haven't had much success. The MASS package does discriminant analysis and random effects, but RE in DA? I'd be grateful to be pointed in the right direction (or told that I'm completely out to lunch!) </p>
29,245
[ -0.0449584499001503, -0.006747365463525057, -0.004426751751452684, 0.010136757045984268, 0.019033282995224, 0.006144569721072912, -0.04833642393350601, -0.004970885347574949, -0.00979166105389595, -0.05583463981747627, 0.03559811785817146, 0.04250584915280342, 0.07200130820274353, 0.03783620893955231, 0.016243774443864822, -0.008319232612848282, -0.01751624047756195, -0.0036344232503324747, -0.0027104606851935387, -0.045866530388593674, -0.013193131424486637, 0.01785246469080448, 0.04784771054983139, -0.0226786807179451, 0.002231078688055277, 0.04674328491091728, 0.011724483221769333, -0.019906185567378998, -0.04483490064740181, 0.026370827108621597, -0.05218314379453659, -0.012172267772257328, 0.006663206964731216, 0.025185851380228996, 0.024304555729031563, -0.006769537925720215, 0.0035524663981050253, -0.02402447909116745, 0.00616227462887764, 0.06487443298101425, -0.044088058173656464, -0.026545174419879913, -0.0056966980919241905, 0.03542039543390274, -0.003569573862478137, 0.013667023740708828, 0.019572455435991287, -0.020718026906251907, 0.06306115537881851, -0.004007138777524233, 0.09568605571985245, 0.005170488264411688, 0.006154413800686598, 0.02586768940091133, -0.006040936801582575, 0.013805516995489597, 0.038516025990247726, 0.03304736688733101, -0.02107228897511959, -0.02229928970336914, -0.002380256773903966, -0.04010229930281639, 0.013882331550121307, 0.023717384785413742, 0.01491292379796505, 0.004662942141294479, 0.03863847628235817, -0.010773291811347008, 0.027427054941654205, 0.006772492080926895, 0.024263771250844002, -0.017580274492502213, 0.0614318884909153, 0.004828940611332655, 0.031224222853779793, -0.01958497427403927, 0.013674669899046421, 0.0030467992182821035, 0.06214272603392601, 0.020910251885652542, -0.023760851472616196, 0.02004321478307247, -0.0033006095327436924, 0.0026749714743345976, 0.02658337913453579, -0.030279358848929405, 0.03199760243296623, -0.01892000436782837, -0.009046472609043121, 0.015221736393868923, 0.01747945509850979, 0.008154334500432014, 0.05766310170292854, 0.016295380890369415, -0.04178581386804581, 0.020580576732754707, 0.027450621128082275, 0.04912082850933075, -0.014972226694226265, 0.00562651501968503, -0.059630315750837326, -0.021310297772288322, 0.025862907990813255, 0.03847123682498932, -0.024421868845820427, 0.010679402388632298, -0.03254295513033867, -0.005749601870775223, -0.04307642579078674, -0.02306416817009449, -0.022113515064120293, 0.017417626455426216, -0.018612872809171677, 0.0046714963391423225, 0.039805762469768524, 0.018157705664634705, -0.017172230407595634, -0.0026031113229691982, 0.07017939537763596, 0.10244153439998627, 0.02971586026251316, -0.04315531253814697, 0.023872479796409607, -0.0420408770442009, -0.0449884794652462, 0.007548698224127293, 0.018924854695796967, 0.0006654668832197785, -0.03451749309897423, 0.05353325605392456, 0.011334339156746864, -0.012020102702081203, 0.05046946182847023, -0.039073243737220764, 0.012656813487410545, -0.004266743548214436, -0.07655325531959534, -0.05659829080104828, 0.020361116155982018, -0.03647136688232422, 0.0193755142390728, -0.06726374477148056, -0.013157120905816555, -0.008415398187935352, 0.03134521469473839, 0.030543234199285507, 0.02941974066197872, -0.0028024327475577593, 0.009534508921205997, -0.002854431513696909, -0.035185202956199646, -0.017879489809274673, -0.010987247340381145, -0.007338010240346193, -0.05512889474630356, -0.0770081952214241, 0.027953319251537323, 0.005800807382911444, -0.007885401137173176, 0.03439422696828842, 0.05714389681816101, -0.012917795218527317, -0.022206654772162437, -0.008335722610354424, 0.01737489178776741, 0.009827344678342342, 0.04797466844320297, -0.01933407038450241, 0.01716429926455021, 0.0025260925758630037, -0.015304768458008766, 0.027900639921426773, 0.01351592130959034, 0.05300217121839523, 0.05582347884774208, -0.03719150647521019, -0.0005257995799183846, 0.00021380455291364342, 0.008621885441243649, 0.01587880775332451, -0.0010641299886628985, -0.014677785336971283, -0.02701473981142044, -0.05934072285890579, 0.020523225888609886, 0.03436917066574097, -0.009718269109725952, 0.0029811777640134096, 0.07752405852079391, -0.014004307799041271, -0.028168078511953354, -0.056782472878694534, 0.024781467393040657, -0.0031545590609312057, 0.006285530049353838, 0.016125435009598732, 0.029152555391192436, 0.03848534822463989, -0.0023426201660186052, -0.021285034716129303, -0.007738297339528799, -0.024842139333486557, 0.06818122416734695, -0.017603158950805664, 0.019112933427095413, 0.02900473028421402, 0.010009716264903545, -0.037885550409555435, 0.039050377905368805, -0.016311319544911385, -0.03197338059544563, 0.005002841353416443, -0.03185278922319412, 0.017460042610764503, -0.015168514102697372, 0.003993773367255926, 0.0308014377951622, -0.00604286091402173, -0.0688358023762703, 0.02532160095870495, -0.05031038448214531, 0.06115099787712097, 0.05359470099210739, 0.004841850139200687, 0.01280486024916172, 0.04412200301885605, 0.019616324454545975, 0.01715434528887272, -0.03507158160209656, -0.004584731068462133, -0.03749789297580719, -0.0013191034086048603, 0.05651185289025307, 0.019059814512729645, -0.020742468535900116, 0.05602314695715904, 0.030244313180446625, 0.041290514171123505, 0.03404311090707779, 0.034064747393131256, 0.02072744630277157, -0.01268074382096529, 0.017484236508607864, 0.02665623463690281, -0.003926220815628767, -0.013627481646835804, 0.021157177165150642, -0.04160400107502937, 0.06045997142791748, -0.03127756714820862, 0.010629678145051003, 0.03254329785704613, 0.008366468362510204, -0.0009600874036550522, -0.034854624420404434, -0.03135471045970917, 0.055913783609867096, -0.015190944075584412, 0.022381311282515526, 0.05545875430107117, 0.028096001595258713, -0.01147481519728899, 0.005030123516917229, -0.013714009895920753, 0.050839148461818695, 0.00976897869259119, -0.04530706629157066, 0.027044430375099182, 0.020658522844314575, -0.051023539155721664, 0.05901109427213669, -0.02752610854804516, -0.020963216200470924, -0.03136138990521431, 0.017633898183703423, 0.062400516122579575, -0.005160822067409754, 0.032682932913303375, -0.004572148434817791, 0.01759093813598156, 0.006544206757098436, 0.017718186601996422, 0.003743702545762062, 0.035414308309555054, -0.0502939447760582, 0.004671917296946049, -0.01956406980752945, -0.03359966352581978, -0.003944973461329937, -0.0014131558127701283, -0.05121653154492378, 0.039832551032304764, 0.012326397933065891, -0.09497571736574173, -0.039269059896469116, -0.001500413753092289, -0.012102729640901089, -0.05790248513221741, -0.012912595644593239, 0.035123929381370544, 0.02520126849412918, 0.008763137273490429, -0.005723931360989809, -0.028220245614647865, 0.017606107518076897, 0.007750122342258692, -0.00636451318860054, 0.023192990571260452, 0.0038987663574516773, -0.015537743456661701, 0.026424666866660118, -0.007326311431825161, 0.004980947822332382, -0.07315436005592346, -0.06289751082658768, 0.006825756747275591, 0.025708163157105446, 0.02784016542136669, 0.024328919127583504, 0.007116391323506832, 0.05066249147057533, 0.03635643422603607, -0.03346782550215721, -0.02541274204850197, -0.005062964744865894, -0.028817886486649513, -0.036650557070970535, 0.0072991205379366875, 0.014118917286396027, -0.01671864651143551, 0.012764443643391132, 0.011568537913262844, 0.020417097955942154, -0.0016838769661262631, -0.01034132856875658, -0.01751582697033882, 0.05908624827861786, 0.004148704465478659, -0.013909988105297089, 0.027092665433883667, 0.005590967368334532, -0.030851304531097412, 0.01597283035516739, -0.014985754154622555, -0.011835365556180477, -0.026391809806227684, -0.06607796251773834, -0.013815647922456264, 0.0010243832366541028, 0.01173692848533392, -0.016002219170331955, -0.0025767413899302483, 0.02416839823126793, -0.04170721769332886, -0.014196404255926609, -0.02218952775001526, 0.010163274593651295, -0.020039504393935204, 0.0012708409922197461, 0.0796949565410614, 0.03958754241466522, 0.01762760430574417, 0.020419884473085403, -0.023072363808751106, -0.0003834438684862107, -0.002516398672014475, -0.022047709673643112, -0.006033776793628931, 0.030671553686261177, -0.004317350219935179, 0.016725219786167145, -0.012969093397259712, -0.022609319537878036, 0.008626417256891727, -0.08961157500743866, 0.0263754203915596, -0.045705873519182205, 0.04062027111649513, -0.004346055909991264, 0.015274296514689922, 0.010908660478889942, -0.022788366302847862, -0.0077264378778636456, 0.006079060956835747, -0.05441996082663536, 0.007755137048661709, -0.030829504132270813, 0.00764111615717411, 0.03367475047707558, -0.04895642772316933, 0.0275704525411129, -0.0391569584608078, 0.0006886075134389102, 0.0018491989467293024, 0.036684080958366394, -0.03040725737810135, -0.009088710881769657, -0.014698093757033348, -0.05263049155473709, -0.018573520705103874, 0.0008871156605891883, 0.010650936514139175, -0.02918504737317562, 0.03799496963620186, 0.040535494685173035, -0.013065440580248833, -0.023826809599995613, -0.04315133020281792, 0.03361470252275467, -0.009555399417877197, 0.00859146285802126, 0.021192818880081177, -0.00997109618037939, -0.0636390671133995, 0.012818681076169014, 0.0012941386085003614, 0.05971493199467659, 0.007367854937911034, 0.023094777017831802, -0.019977636635303497, -0.042312685400247574, -0.021608715876936913, 0.04258229210972786, 0.019542740657925606, -0.0009526032372377813, -0.019574297592043877, 0.044350896030664444, 0.027172431349754333, -0.06417994201183319, 0.02128422074019909, 0.006152425426989794, 0.038655687123537064, -0.014342619106173515, -0.012009823694825172, 0.013155119493603706, 0.007507918868213892, -0.02179020643234253, 0.05576011911034584, -0.002189338207244873, 0.018169252201914787, 0.013277063146233559, 0.0162060409784317, -0.005926748737692833, -0.019768372178077698, -0.0009035051916725934, 0.030029769986867905, 0.04071013256907463, -0.013335238210856915, -0.01857067458331585, -0.017359325662255287, 0.0021377636585384607, 0.026414865627884865, 0.04181991145014763, 0.0479159839451313, -0.09241117537021637, 0.006881941109895706, 0.041463062167167664, 0.029336683452129364, -0.04398484155535698, 0.022054119035601616, -0.0475764237344265, -0.04317976534366608, 0.0030023050494492054, -0.02468760870397091, 0.00016244457219727337, -0.012896126136183739, 0.023184724152088165, -0.017571257427334785, -0.02446366660296917, -0.045173998922109604, -0.015465931035578251, 0.016620617359876633, -0.00027790074818767607, 0.004397836048156023, -0.04590142145752907, -0.02067338302731514, 0.027163337916135788, 0.030906187370419502, 0.039250560104846954, 0.02854052558541298, -0.01852775551378727, 0.041214339435100555, 0.018778979778289795, 0.00973894540220499, -0.044453319162130356, 0.031129799783229828, 0.012874293141067028, 0.00788967963308096, 0.062119260430336, -0.004175208043307066, 0.0015411247732117772, 0.02299204282462597, 0.015023279935121536, -0.033283594995737076, -0.02013920247554779, -0.004598867613822222, 0.048885732889175415, 0.04015674814581871, -0.00973124336451292, 0.07263819128274918, 0.03206293284893036, 0.018367910757660866, -0.007624790538102388, -0.001251799869351089, 0.03729155659675598, -0.04888591915369034, -0.0207170732319355, -0.07534396648406982, -0.012884235009551048, -0.011993545107543468, 0.020840249955654144, 0.02859133668243885, 0.0546455904841423, -0.04051477834582329, -0.014909567311406136, -0.011800814419984818, 0.044957052916288376, -0.04354463890194893, 0.0007336152484640479, 0.006542157847434282, 0.02356307953596115, -0.0019036330049857497, -0.0012787465238943696, -0.003760053776204586, -0.0008191500091925263, -0.0192148145288229, 0.019479811191558838, -0.04834465682506561, 0.018686488270759583, -0.03914054110646248, -0.0327376164495945, 0.009478210471570492, -0.028428062796592712, 0.041178494691848755, 0.005446704104542732, 0.045464031398296356, 0.019454285502433777, -0.0380822978913784, -0.004487739410251379, 0.07060016691684723, 0.014297550544142723, 0.002137789037078619, -0.02615473046898842, 0.03895852714776993, -0.05070001259446144, 0.005712833721190691, -0.057892393320798874, -0.034883201122283936, -0.04011370614171028, 0.0020742735359817743, -0.001374092767946422, -0.05126144737005234, -0.013770049437880516, -0.0170279573649168, -0.011138269677758217, -0.010317275300621986, 0.04427793622016907, -0.04102352261543274, 0.05952323228120804, -0.014684179797768593, 0.02039194479584694, 0.07997911423444748, -0.02367892675101757, 0.008826881647109985, -0.004330058116465807, -0.00833964068442583, -0.026420563459396362, -0.011775622144341469, 0.0016832288820296526, -0.037559472024440765, -0.0021322104148566723, -0.025567855685949326, 0.029958412051200867, 0.045089513063430786, -0.024792643263936043, -0.012588637880980968, 0.012987971305847168, -0.0402129702270031, 0.03205525875091553, -0.06855859607458115, -0.011386713944375515, -0.020728470757603645, -0.012257669121026993, -0.002731334650889039, 0.057917140424251556, -0.03784659132361412, -0.000515984371304512, -0.0007872006390243769, 0.004351193550974131, -0.01800074800848961, 0.03691492974758148, 0.024519741535186768, -0.03449327126145363, 0.023932669311761856, 0.0017215849366039038, -0.02886218950152397, 0.07299961894750595, -0.017355913296341896, 0.009567426517605782, 0.016745710745453835, -0.003666751319542527, -0.060237087309360504, -0.03752756491303444, -0.044837284833192825, -0.02727673202753067, 0.0307262372225523, 0.03457333892583847, 0.042654700577259064, 0.07948857545852661, -0.011445853859186172, 0.005828512832522392, -0.04200531914830208, -0.014081092551350594, -0.022950151935219765, -0.013469938188791275, 0.07688914239406586, -0.030898135155439377, -0.008996968157589436, 0.0007509274873882532, 0.027595002204179764, 0.028851795941591263, 0.07553654164075851, 0.012112938798964024, 0.0180097296833992, 0.019490143284201622, -0.024848151952028275, -0.04273248836398125, -0.005412279162555933, -0.04285408928990364, -0.0001928026758832857, -0.03941037133336067, -0.022648317739367485, 0.044218532741069794, 0.06681119650602341, 0.0029574884101748466, -0.04606092348694801, -0.04338682442903519, -0.09490234404802322, 0.06979775428771973, 0.0318162627518177, 0.015071198344230652, 0.02319321408867836, 0.009405532851815224, 0.06430436670780182, -0.035700179636478424, 0.03585662692785263, 0.00017334058065898716, -0.029289769008755684, 0.006345624104142189, -0.005000982899218798, -0.02677582949399948, 0.046511080116033554, -0.054877955466508865, -0.05791439861059189, 0.013041535392403603, -0.06397612392902374, -0.0034705917350947857, 0.008671407587826252, 0.013209155760705471, -0.006603870075196028, 0.07352247089147568, -0.02414802648127079, 0.000024806386136333458, 0.022967979311943054, -0.010221626609563828, 0.13409064710140228, 0.040558263659477234, 0.05227518454194069, -0.015334044583141804, 0.011147765442728996, 0.02148989774286747, 0.012570207938551903, -0.007407860364764929, -0.0320403166115284, 0.010964520275592804, 0.012862405739724636, 0.040233902633190155, 0.014656787738204002, 0.022435685619711876, -0.029565399512648582, 0.042854271829128265, 0.013861552812159061, 0.0029276881832629442, 0.03425152972340584, -0.010013265535235405, -0.002701799850910902, -0.011776689440011978, -0.015337268821895123, 0.009781738743185997, 0.008249245584011078, -0.017346149310469627, -0.05260227993130684, -0.021644115447998047, -0.03791375458240509, 0.019657626748085022, -0.015237266197800636, 0.00017932636546902359, -0.0029335657600313425, 0.024981997907161713, 0.02410784550011158, -0.0162739809602499, -0.02400839887559414, -0.057925086468458176, 0.005022966302931309, 0.0442960187792778, 0.008746610023081303, -0.013925946317613125, -0.01671728678047657, 0.01686682552099228, -0.02204914391040802, -0.025076836347579956, -0.02617786079645157, 0.05708488076925278, -0.037929046899080276, -0.05176614224910736, 0.004846631549298763, 0.000040838040149537846, 0.012959987856447697, -0.0565316379070282, -0.027081472799181938, 0.008036769926548004, 0.013180779293179512, -0.03269778564572334, 0.004823246970772743, -0.03545001894235611, 0.010996817611157894, -0.014302089810371399, 0.013547808863222599, -0.0018239774508401752, -0.0036439308896660805, -0.04924101009964943, -0.042938705533742905, 0.0557648167014122, 0.018911579623818398, -0.004617903381586075, -0.04229850694537163, -0.004479418974369764, -0.03185504302382469, -0.015031209215521812, -0.021272677928209305, 0.006765489932149649, 0.01798681914806366, -0.004042385146021843, -0.017334939911961555, 0.0029785609804093838, -0.026914997026324272, 0.005940277595072985, -0.04742518439888954, -0.029490604996681213, -0.01097455620765686, -0.002298519480973482, -0.003918165806680918, 0.03735208511352539, 0.019962886348366737, 0.036564864218235016, -0.023738086223602295, 0.04804518073797226, -0.014191645197570324, -0.04467933997511864, 0.021161340177059174, -0.02049505151808262, -0.0006993009592406452, 0.002785790478810668, 0.021750081330537796, 0.05246591195464134, 0.01391964964568615, -0.017062747851014137, -0.024803699925541878, 0.04000726342201233, -0.01121771614998579, 0.026614928618073463, 0.014630092307925224, -0.03770732879638672, 0.02863365411758423, -0.016094502061605453, -0.018562812358140945, -0.02748204953968525, -0.019284283742308617, -0.05930640175938606, -0.008950443007051945, -0.016624867916107178, -0.011255879886448383, -0.03649744391441345, -0.015976369380950928, -0.027051998302340508, 0.013112525455653667, -0.012632962316274643, -0.003302379511296749, -0.04106641933321953, -0.029467681422829628, -0.027140803635120392, 0.019753631204366684, 0.01327879261225462, -0.002379206009209156, 0.01150717306882143, 0.008356872014701366, 0.03229445219039917, -0.029169470071792603, -0.013326404616236687, 0.014282941818237305, -0.012300086207687855, -0.02997344359755516, 0.07966341823339462, 0.002976943738758564, 0.003355222987011075, 0.002065216889604926, -0.06040208786725998, 0.012752988375723362, -0.008000900968909264, -0.01863022893667221, 0.022038422524929047, 0.021818865090608597, 0.016712704673409462, -0.010958191007375717, 0.045410312712192535, -0.015398865565657616, -0.020454177632927895, -0.03281017020344734, 0.024735774844884872, -0.02174578420817852, -0.00813854020088911, -0.0034560218919068575, 0.006812298204749823, -0.03488052636384964, 0.05508463457226753, 0.03281495347619057, 0.0115592610090971, -0.007937430404126644, 0.0035463697277009487, -0.04823035001754761, -0.014238260686397552, -0.007895390503108501, 0.020111439749598503, 0.0049245706759393215, 0.07544522732496262, -0.022433258593082428, 0.013368098065257072, 0.01823868788778782, 0.014654792845249176, -0.08398973196744919, 0.005716399289667606, 0.012688824906945229, 0.02658994495868683, 0.01929544471204281, -0.04937376454472542, 0.0008675316348671913, 0.004224381409585476, -0.04181881621479988, 0.011437715962529182, -0.0019564349204301834, 0.021403584629297256, -0.032285284250974655, 0.00291850115172565, -0.02403949573636055, 0.013465060852468014, 0.00551891652867198, 0.005349722690880299, 0.020089736208319664, 0.04421941936016083, -0.002713974332436919, -0.041962213814258575, -0.01394843403249979, -0.006321720313280821, 0.038623664528131485, -0.058695241808891296, 0.05257105082273483, -0.04515703767538071, -0.01867283321917057, 0.046500783413648605, -0.01967489719390869, 0.03787815570831299, 0.05239257588982582, -0.0031494314316660166, 0.017184820026159286, 0.05539149418473244, 0.04660637676715851, 0.014567525126039982, 0.006939059589058161, -0.006237097084522247, -0.003006858518347144, 0.01700097694993019, -0.022263314574956894, 0.01483752578496933, -0.001367553137242794, -0.010500834323465824, -0.009558391757309437, 0.004612151999026537, -0.03836159408092499, -0.04805652052164078, -0.0022276181261986494, -0.022037016227841377, 0.002226052572950721, 0.027741532772779465, 0.00753397261723876, -0.0370045080780983, 0.020985199138522148, 0.046225655823946, 0.006912467535585165, -0.00688186613842845, 0.029223553836345673, 0.01806437037885189, -0.03517816588282585, -0.017992209643125534, 0.022541573271155357, -0.016909731552004814, -0.05026692524552345, -0.02626979537308216, -0.02204762026667595, -0.02081700973212719, -0.034172724932432175, 0.03374490514397621, -0.04414437338709831, 0.03127698972821236, -0.033159445971250534, 0.02074589766561985, -0.007197106257081032, 0.019319023936986923, 0.03578777238726616, -0.08079664409160614, 0.05916662514209747, 0.029210541397333145, -0.01222502626478672, -0.041496142745018005, 0.011480395682156086, -0.01731278747320175, 0.011869668960571289, 0.04417061433196068, 0.005238844081759453, 0.022767972201108932, 0.016434412449598312, 0.053871702402830124, 0.0033428326714783907, -0.022180473431944847, 0.07071609050035477, -0.0020165143068879843, -0.010075015015900135, 0.016243426129221916, -0.03678932785987854, -0.01384480856359005, 0.02622741460800171, -0.02377323806285858, 0.0037193219177424908, 0.015082682482898235, 0.0145829813554883, 0.00927459541708231, 0.04656887426972389, -0.030636923387646675, -0.003919712733477354, 0.011751323007047176, 0.022135434672236443, 0.015249957330524921, 0.012063296511769295, -0.032285239547491074, -0.028801700100302696, 0.0608459897339344, -0.04066998139023781, -0.06674956530332565, 0.023344753310084343, 0.04750601574778557, -0.025018619373440742, -0.04854467138648033, 0.06203966960310936, -0.01161062903702259, -0.026154357939958572, -0.040854740887880325, 0.04790637269616127, -0.004270171280950308, 0.04828619956970215, -0.007895907387137413, 0.046105705201625824, -0.008409963920712471, -0.0004597747465595603, 0.0184431541711092, 0.015257705934345722, 0.001281851902604103, -0.01861588843166828, -0.03744763508439064, 0.007708798162639141, -0.024427201598882675, 0.013983394019305706, -0.02369924820959568, 0.03137284889817238, -0.010471712797880173, 0.004571887198835611, 0.018538884818553925, -0.011310400441288948, 0.022599870339035988, -0.0014337857719510794, -0.01168858353048563, 0.05612897872924805, -0.035559553653001785, -0.0191959235817194, -0.016571907326579094, -0.04539195075631142, -0.008343849331140518, 0.015066081658005714, -0.006274387240409851, 0.01881277933716774, -0.003697925014421344, 0.07174807041883469, -0.011807744391262531, -0.012907428666949272, 0.015443740412592888, -0.02363092638552189, 0.019268184900283813, -0.0009471976081840694, -0.011347632855176926, -0.023889444768428802, 0.017585139721632004, 0.005944599397480488, -0.04065798223018646, 0.029265189543366432, 0.03733580559492111, 0.012505861930549145, -0.03084491193294525, -0.030862584710121155, 0.034911300987005234, 0.03731175512075424, -0.03836836665868759, -0.06019127368927002, -0.04408836364746094, -0.01197761856019497, 0.009719287976622581, -0.010469960980117321 ]
<p>I have a time series data set of photon arrival times from a detector and need to know whether the arrival time is uniform.It is a continuous distribution?</p> <p>I have calculated the maximum $D$ between the normalized CDF of the photon arrival times. Then what should I do? There is a "$Pr(k\le x)$" in the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov%E2%80%93Smirnov_test" rel="nofollow">Wiki link</a>. What does it stand for in my question? Could somebody tell me the basic definition of ks-test?</p> <p>In fact, I can calculate ks-test probability via <a href="http://docs.scipy.org/doc/scipy/reference/generated/scipy.stats.kstest.html" rel="nofollow">scipy.stats.kstest</a>. Does anybody know the meaning of <code>args</code> for a uniform distribution? And the two output values?</p> <pre><code>&gt;&gt;&gt; stats.kstest(sample, 'uniform',args=(1,2,3,4,5,6)) (1.0, 0.0) &gt;&gt;&gt; stats.kstest(sample, 'uniform',args=(0.1,0.2,0.3,0.4,0.5,0.6)) (1.0, 0.0) &gt;&gt;&gt; stats.kstest(sample, 'uniform',args=(0.1,0.2)) (1.0, 0.0) &gt;&gt;&gt; stats.kstest(sample, 'uniform',args=(1,2)) (0.98999999999999999, 0.0) &gt;&gt;&gt; stats.kstest(sample, 'uniform',args=(1.1,2.1)) (0.98499999999999999, 0.0) </code></pre> <p><strong>about uniform</strong> I think I should compare two cdf:the normalised real data and the cdf of a uniform distribution that the photons arrive uniformly.<br/></p> <p>Please take a look at my plot.The green points are from real data.There are hundreds of green points.Every green point means an arrival of a new photon.x-axis is time and y-axis is normalised,in fact,it is the percent(cumulative arrival photons/total photon number).The red straight line stands for the cdf of uniform distribution. stats.uniform picks random values every time.Is stats.uniform appropriate? <br/> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/yvUBz.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p><strong>about ks-test</strong> I took an image of the 2rd version Numerical Recipes in C.<br/> What is the relation between 14.3.9 and wikipedia's Pr(k&lt;=x)?Just an approximation,right?<br/> The significance should be decided only by two values max(D) and sample size,right? Pr(k&lt;=x) is the cdf of D?How to define x?<br/> I can not get a consistent result with stats.kstest().<br/> You mean if I use the real time data which is not normalised,I should use two-sample ks-test,right?<br/> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/hGMz5.jpg" alt="NumerialRecipes2rdCh14"></p>
73,632
[ 0.0006014875834807754, -0.04783496633172035, 0.009203968569636345, -0.025207344442605972, 0.02582516334950924, 0.029398737475275993, -0.0031386499758809805, -0.034883927553892136, -0.007994012907147408, -0.0447457917034626, 0.09243349730968475, 0.03207702934741974, 0.0338188000023365, 0.029188409447669983, 0.05347764492034912, 0.016340188682079315, 0.023597221821546555, 0.01918054185807705, -0.003674756269901991, -0.05085292086005211, 0.03680099919438362, 0.005374938249588013, 0.0266493521630764, -0.001638157875277102, -0.03192149102687836, 0.010862158611416817, -0.00008651969983475283, -0.01689290441572666, 0.01479517761617899, 0.060659073293209076, -0.06738121062517166, -0.03647737205028534, -0.0077874427661299706, 0.0020196218974888325, -0.018522266298532486, 0.031323064118623734, 0.002592042088508606, -0.05944594740867615, -0.015079909935593605, 0.046787623316049576, -0.021946726366877556, -0.00373464566655457, 0.03111451305449009, 0.008261292241513729, 0.010144556872546673, 0.04881269484758377, 0.013483819551765919, -0.020053809508681297, 0.02116956003010273, -0.02571302279829979, 0.0903606042265892, -0.023221662268042564, 0.03512069955468178, -0.018772203475236893, -0.05932341888546944, -0.0061805094592273235, 0.05456563085317612, 0.03997248783707619, -0.027545269578695297, -0.05890776962041855, -0.017722677439451218, -0.06322286278009415, -0.011070984415709972, 0.013394219800829887, 0.02287302538752556, 0.024231698364019394, -0.016421763226389885, -0.006232406944036484, 0.013701381161808968, 0.004761956166476011, 0.03149166330695152, 0.013441917486488819, 0.038317251950502396, -0.024761071428656578, 0.01567540131509304, 0.01856367103755474, -0.010754360817372799, 0.0030721048824489117, 0.014090552926063538, 0.03231000527739525, -0.0036882194690406322, 0.03125821053981781, -0.0003278654767200351, -0.004066984169185162, 0.03175721317529678, -0.004005607217550278, 0.06954149901866913, 0.0037158613558858633, 0.019999448210000992, 0.015934718772768974, -0.04207134246826172, 0.04563506692647934, 0.03466646373271942, 0.018717914819717407, -0.02620992809534073, 0.03820864111185074, 0.006084693595767021, 0.03107757307589054, -0.03847213089466095, -0.02572343684732914, -0.0009566490189172328, -0.060226913541555405, 0.043920744210481644, 0.06692002713680267, -0.018090970814228058, -0.01732400618493557, -0.027894338592886925, -0.0210548285394907, -0.046520475298166275, -0.03806522116065025, -0.015441691502928734, 0.02031547576189041, -0.010414082556962967, 0.01566079445183277, 0.003988275770097971, 0.015962282195687294, -0.013533227145671844, 0.00710199074819684, 0.06205049529671669, 0.047040026634931564, 0.046143095940351486, 0.02208355814218521, 0.003148317337036133, -0.024840710684657097, -0.05619576573371887, 0.03326977416872978, 0.021339237689971924, 0.04978647828102112, -0.014437353238463402, 0.054455045610666275, -0.008426941931247711, 0.0026300381869077682, 0.021646510809659958, 0.020814908668398857, -0.012818855233490467, -0.018362870439887047, -0.08998878300189972, -0.061413347721099854, 0.025110749527812004, 0.017774388194084167, 0.010179263539612293, -0.05713178589940071, 0.015023775398731232, 0.015273882076144218, 0.024564560502767563, 0.020572368055582047, 0.055342428386211395, -0.03648623079061508, -0.02270798198878765, 0.010590960271656513, -0.05780500918626785, -0.007085914257913828, -0.015468097291886806, -0.0018412333447486162, -0.000053387393563752994, -0.06286487728357315, 0.0009244075044989586, 0.005571641027927399, 0.0074606905691325665, -0.017209213227033615, 0.020976856350898743, -0.014269882813096046, 0.020248685032129288, -0.005641588941216469, -0.014010817743837833, -0.014421558938920498, 0.0748806968331337, 0.06658517569303513, 0.0422908179461956, 0.009057093411684036, -0.015437420457601547, -0.029065335169434547, -0.020907573401927948, 0.05388383939862251, 0.014303690753877163, -0.020624669268727303, 0.0016282284632325172, -0.0371735580265522, 0.066780224442482, -0.014883373863995075, -0.04536374658346176, 0.020013542845845222, 0.007084989920258522, 0.011808096431195736, 0.008376382291316986, 0.02184321917593479, 0.028633907437324524, -0.005049530882388353, -0.007225750479847193, -0.07649368047714233, -0.05463356524705887, -0.03259596228599548, 0.001282880431972444, -0.024183763191103935, -0.059417981654405594, 0.023602576926350594, 0.008373077027499676, 0.0218534916639328, 0.013703523203730583, -0.023128267377614975, -0.05048835650086403, -0.05483172833919525, 0.04642527550458908, -0.010895530693233013, 0.0069817653857171535, 0.05859898030757904, 0.04612968862056732, 0.002767167054116726, 0.025499120354652405, -0.010233292356133461, -0.009024509228765965, -0.019519491121172905, -0.0472697988152504, -0.019934847950935364, 0.014621010981500149, -0.011715495958924294, 0.02809765562415123, 0.018314344808459282, 0.00825242418795824, -0.0122384587302804, -0.09158298373222351, 0.047227583825588226, 0.05427579954266548, 0.005629579070955515, -0.0070816343650221825, -0.035521768033504486, -0.021218301728367805, 0.01841413602232933, 0.005059645976871252, -0.017047246918082237, -0.043336350470781326, 0.0020583660807460546, 0.0500146746635437, 0.025542644783854485, -0.015621405094861984, -0.003387733595445752, 0.06121905520558357, -0.00930275209248066, 0.023336261510849, 0.025730589404702187, -0.011939420364797115, -0.025827795267105103, 0.004728623665869236, 0.004657222423702478, 0.0013655651127919555, 0.0003827827167697251, 0.028019091114401817, -0.0031212572939693928, 0.05167271941900253, -0.022596070542931557, -0.02185283787548542, -0.004549284931272268, -0.029386335983872414, 0.01555640809237957, -0.01378895528614521, -0.009102926589548588, 0.012840854935348034, 0.008778873831033707, 0.004382267128676176, 0.039254263043403625, 0.02770266681909561, 0.016423840075731277, -0.045871928334236145, -0.063653364777565, 0.012789487838745117, 0.040386397391557693, -0.03743983432650566, -0.05492629483342171, -0.0018300499068573117, -0.03430222347378731, 0.0008875717176124454, -0.019929545000195503, -0.029663536697626114, -0.06320820748806, -0.021837016567587852, 0.028621269389986992, 0.012688972987234592, -0.014190313406288624, -0.015624850988388062, -0.008122689090669155, -0.006286411080509424, 0.017584485933184624, 0.03631328418850899, 0.0018868851475417614, -0.02895323373377323, -0.027851933613419533, 0.02033945918083191, -0.019763562828302383, 0.03502621129155159, -0.017870303243398666, -0.012536240741610527, 0.01819247007369995, -0.03561563044786453, -0.02698484994471073, -0.012426325120031834, -0.0199215617030859, 0.05230619013309479, -0.03429413586854935, 0.0014942192938178778, 0.07023227214813232, 0.016672886908054352, -0.06583200395107269, 0.018761783838272095, -0.052467893809080124, -0.01774163730442524, -0.07364516705274582, -0.03768259286880493, -0.004185175988823175, -0.0271140169352293, 0.03395551070570946, 0.020068956539034843, -0.03742336109280586, 0.006659868638962507, -0.04836307838559151, -0.06395934522151947, 0.02184971794486046, -0.025194410234689713, 0.008258880116045475, -0.0000752421619836241, -0.026110094040632248, 0.09427428245544434, 0.03619380667805672, 0.0019672976341098547, -0.005424878094345331, -0.0025074633304029703, -0.04678504168987274, -0.008738750591874123, -0.014244736172258854, 0.013762484304606915, 0.00148971623275429, 0.047727953642606735, 0.009882020764052868, 0.06850618869066238, 0.047103848308324814, -0.047400664538145065, 0.029798012226819992, 0.0010031415149569511, -0.008405610918998718, -0.011949612759053707, 0.01955435238778591, 0.048853013664484024, -0.04649277403950691, 0.010915648192167282, -0.016357282176613808, -0.009574762545526028, 0.005588719621300697, -0.0038567937444895506, 0.02684636227786541, -0.000009188742296828423, 0.02665383368730545, -0.03772047907114029, 0.027940528467297554, 0.0091793118044734, -0.07866619527339935, -0.015370871871709824, 0.027475198730826378, 0.019599618390202522, -0.03464417904615402, 0.0025196832139045, 0.0256321020424366, 0.07695335894823074, -0.022190986201167107, 0.004746405873447657, 0.00041779453749768436, -0.04036835953593254, 0.002841745037585497, -0.04815732315182686, -0.025558581575751305, 0.04176580533385277, 0.020338961854577065, 0.041723255068063736, 0.012528621591627598, -0.04365333542227745, -0.029303504154086113, -0.02671709470450878, 0.007878316566348076, -0.005850135814398527, 0.01880861446261406, 0.04344424232840538, 0.05257387459278107, 0.04701303690671921, -0.02450946532189846, -0.0256026703864336, -0.006853932049125433, -0.07003527134656906, 0.04110728204250336, 0.01606370136141777, -0.04601232334971428, 0.01859227381646633, -0.0387403704226017, -0.001376382657326758, -0.019907427951693535, 0.01001174096018076, 0.035272371023893356, 0.017957204952836037, -0.04730643704533577, 0.025091160088777542, -0.017932720482349396, -0.029872952029109, -0.025293326005339622, -0.02239546738564968, 0.0497586689889431, -0.002329497830942273, 0.04545013606548309, 0.003711639204993844, -0.044535111635923386, 0.003010154003277421, -0.0007314805407077074, 0.027303189039230347, 0.032093364745378494, 0.04234728962182999, 0.029160941019654274, 0.008534104563295841, -0.044251807034015656, 0.040705036371946335, 0.026311513036489487, 0.07836710661649704, 0.07114246487617493, -0.08378452807664871, -0.014165911823511124, -0.030933205038309097, 0.018349209800362587, 0.004184906370937824, 0.011150036938488483, 0.029357867315411568, 0.02429877780377865, 0.03697766736149788, -0.0025022821500897408, -0.016804715618491173, 0.016642579808831215, 0.04373885318636894, -0.03516663238406181, 0.022723359987139702, -0.0072599127888679504, -0.02825816161930561, 0.020212447270751, 0.0016379047883674502, 0.03727738559246063, 0.02905251644551754, -0.012457786127924919, 0.032062824815511703, 0.029606280848383904, 0.00439853360876441, -0.02822035364806652, -0.010770943947136402, 0.05187889561057091, 0.027055490761995316, -0.014366500079631805, -0.04684794694185257, 0.017119737342000008, 0.019623786211013794, 0.030491067096590996, 0.013441956602036953, 0.013524471782147884, -0.056312114000320435, 0.009436627849936485, 0.037597063928842545, 0.044107500463724136, -0.01709206961095333, -0.028973493725061417, -0.024397078901529312, -0.0015366093721240759, 0.03232675790786743, -0.02602425217628479, 0.033419761806726456, -0.0035625500604510307, 0.03369535505771637, -0.029229922220110893, -0.006496600341051817, -0.04434457793831825, 0.04615560919046402, 0.003229358233511448, 0.030288737267255783, -0.03742690756917, -0.04511187970638275, -0.014982098713517189, 0.01687764935195446, -0.0046926867216825485, 0.051453907042741776, -0.018677257001399994, -0.016829010099172592, 0.013260379433631897, 0.004006515257060528, 0.03470730036497116, -0.05969363823533058, 0.029222847893834114, -0.008947246707975864, 0.02845301665365696, 0.0411611832678318, 0.0028536736499518156, -0.005959383677691221, 0.045578841120004654, -0.0024508468341082335, -0.034542907029390335, 0.023288384079933167, -0.029757127165794373, 0.05601499602198601, 0.05165873095393181, -0.008529109880328178, 0.03939308226108551, -0.007259037345647812, -0.0123741514980793, 0.004054803866893053, -0.042216863483190536, 0.029087228700518608, -0.03627036139369011, -0.0013233923818916082, -0.045526035130023956, -0.014266368933022022, -0.023348839953541756, 0.02912653051316738, 0.026651538908481598, 0.03920908272266388, -0.018763672560453415, -0.0006618543993681669, -0.006484643556177616, 0.0564383789896965, -0.0004944298416376114, -0.008663125336170197, -0.03991788625717163, -0.003809322603046894, 0.013744482770562172, -0.0017930454341694713, 0.013537765480577946, -0.040644723922014236, 0.032291095703840256, 0.006146137602627277, -0.009614766575396061, -0.0008096388773992658, -0.027609627693891525, -0.020969215780496597, 0.01752154529094696, 0.001052396954037249, 0.015823256224393845, 0.0317888967692852, 0.01455774623900652, -0.005794524680823088, -0.02921513468027115, -0.0077377972193062305, 0.006594880484044552, -0.02590038627386093, 0.046513743698596954, -0.027543844655156136, 0.04952913895249367, -0.00902912113815546, 0.009940464049577713, -0.06986396759748459, 0.00826591718941927, 0.03948551416397095, 0.002066015964373946, -0.047844067215919495, -0.02757137455046177, -0.0015303257387131453, 0.0011200106237083673, -0.0015920926816761494, -0.011888098903000355, 0.03917919471859932, -0.046406179666519165, -0.03511780872941017, -0.0219583623111248, 0.02509080059826374, 0.04637708142399788, 0.03506329655647278, -0.006683051586151123, 0.021107617765665054, 0.010013464838266373, -0.0202513188123703, 0.0029227840714156628, 0.010331728495657444, -0.010037504136562347, -0.010532718151807785, -0.028445551171898842, 0.024594120681285858, 0.039295535534620285, -0.014610650017857552, -0.04212528094649315, -0.022370295599102974, -0.004761340096592903, 0.028820021077990532, -0.03455257788300514, -0.02462068200111389, -0.037734515964984894, 0.013891306705772877, 0.0019177556969225407, -0.03191453590989113, -0.02091151289641857, -0.013090797699987888, 0.04561980441212654, -0.014102374203503132, 0.012634538114070892, 0.032245926558971405, 0.0738072320818901, 0.002366833621636033, -0.014446421526372433, -0.015091518871486187, -0.023268859833478928, -0.03717264533042908, -0.031801220029592514, 0.0008151312358677387, 0.030579699203372, -0.016088243573904037, -0.006842545699328184, 0.022695520892739296, -0.06718455255031586, -0.05165312439203262, 0.06998825818300247, -0.013394917361438274, 0.06682116538286209, 0.0250377394258976, 0.011293244548141956, 0.015371180139482021, -0.061788562685251236, -0.008215706795454025, -0.013405174016952515, 0.013652960769832134, 0.015548628754913807, -0.015481577254831791, 0.019353682175278664, 0.021232854574918747, 0.038687463849782944, 0.02430136129260063, 0.025823038071393967, -0.015140477567911148, 0.02644624374806881, 0.008796459063887596, -0.03664305806159973, -0.03597758710384369, 0.03960800915956497, -0.04873144254088402, 0.01614726521074772, -0.005729303695261478, 0.022971414029598236, -0.004966327454894781, 0.053029704838991165, -0.017318930476903915, -0.036073870956897736, 0.00781880784779787, -0.06289365142583847, 0.024728652089834213, 0.022385668009519577, -0.04386286810040474, 0.0478116013109684, -0.007050126325339079, 0.04138130322098732, 0.009497938677668571, 0.041715193539857864, -0.035152193158864975, -0.032900840044021606, -0.03915013372898102, -0.042176537215709686, -0.020049618557095528, 0.04835053160786629, 0.00003914470289601013, -0.024743082001805305, -0.002327973721548915, -0.04700007289648056, 0.05161100625991821, 0.043198395520448685, 0.017374897375702858, -0.0068664876744151115, 0.08892296999692917, -0.01969403401017189, 0.03583616390824318, -0.0405411496758461, -0.01739497482776642, 0.13266023993492126, 0.062131188809871674, 0.03432771936058998, -0.03670680522918701, -0.04241737350821495, 0.010509204119443893, 0.008090617135167122, -0.028113843873143196, -0.019907480105757713, 0.0014598937705159187, -0.027777835726737976, 0.056635838001966476, 0.0023654114920645952, 0.009160877205431461, 0.007638984359800816, 0.018214112147688866, -0.0397658497095108, -0.002721428172662854, 0.00031452832627110183, 0.048689424991607666, -0.001025065896101296, -0.009362133219838142, -0.060139674693346024, 0.0173355620354414, 0.023772507905960083, -0.0008829921716824174, -0.01449691690504551, -0.01806187443435192, 0.022326378151774406, -0.010505905374884605, 0.021264316514134407, 0.012826859951019287, 0.011675655841827393, -0.037025295197963715, -0.023716626688838005, -0.006288465112447739, 0.013070514425635338, -0.030888009816408157, 0.023824598640203476, 0.01940915919840336, 0.023344993591308594, -0.03250842168927193, -0.0041240518912673, 0.06433501094579697, -0.027402110397815704, -0.023631568998098373, -0.015251521952450275, 0.031094608828425407, -0.018052099272608757, 0.0030304323881864548, -0.019315319135785103, 0.06314033269882202, -0.022569110617041588, -0.05201112478971481, 0.008865585550665855, -0.02024470455944538, 0.04558607563376427, -0.058211080729961395, -0.0037815277464687824, -0.019829969853162766, -0.00144722661934793, -0.0010630086762830615, 0.0423872135579586, 0.027665529400110245, -0.018315162509679794, 0.0014921632828190923, -0.05188388004899025, 0.002315359888598323, -0.013440691865980625, 0.008540026843547821, 0.020709440112113953, -0.005700720474123955, -0.03234264254570007, 0.007966929115355015, 0.024020537734031677, -0.02860400266945362, -0.005368377082049847, 0.00018108532822225243, -0.00980799924582243, -0.02734636329114437, -0.013856187462806702, 0.027258342131972313, -0.03627259284257889, -0.01882139779627323, 0.005301984492689371, -0.005000458564609289, 0.007836614735424519, 0.02438044175505638, 0.06071503832936287, 0.03452333062887192, -0.00483306311070919, 0.05646839737892151, 0.018212955445051193, -0.059165649116039276, -0.0007213039789348841, 0.022773664444684982, 0.0006595450104214251, -0.020136157050728798, -0.02291061356663704, 0.05808034539222717, 0.013285529799759388, -0.013903823681175709, -0.005528004374355078, 0.0012581556802615523, -0.04765951260924339, -0.001380469650030136, -0.025769434869289398, -0.009196850471198559, -0.004125989507883787, -0.00048304497613571584, -0.0020118686370551586, -0.02877017669379711, -0.009660880081355572, -0.003783599939197302, -0.04750344529747963, 0.040170818567276, -0.015276474878191948, -0.031118256971240044, -0.014781937934458256, 0.001320391776971519, -0.0003629271814133972, 0.007507497910410166, -0.03715440258383751, 0.017802515998482704, 0.030490174889564514, -0.05163086578249931, -0.009764493443071842, -0.0027845522854477167, -0.003567499341443181, 0.0394531711935997, -0.024976879358291626, 0.017731942236423492, 0.04743735119700432, 0.03481604531407356, -0.026777073740959167, 0.013710670173168182, -0.031110404059290886, 0.02717890590429306, 0.02006612904369831, -0.0115900207310915, 0.029078563675284386, -0.041989948600530624, -0.06874781847000122, 0.06112028658390045, 0.02764098346233368, 0.004757493268698454, 0.008207582868635654, 0.01864156499505043, -0.0024576031137257814, 0.03607596829533577, -0.03287498652935028, -0.01277158223092556, -0.04507188871502876, -0.016513632610440254, 0.005893408786505461, -0.021838974207639694, -0.0206903088837862, 0.007023457437753677, 0.0003710150776896626, 0.04290793836116791, 0.011337991803884506, -0.05146939679980278, 0.020338384434580803, 0.02524908259510994, -0.030752193182706833, -0.019450364634394646, 0.010678851045668125, 0.010502993129193783, 0.028526226058602333, 0.0298826452344656, -0.021317997947335243, 0.006976165808737278, -0.02787891961634159, 0.005243527702987194, -0.08660553395748138, -0.025149190798401833, 0.004317082464694977, 0.008231857791543007, 0.05439943075180054, -0.059444114565849304, 0.0015080553712323308, 0.008250988088548183, -0.012841825373470783, 0.029185200110077858, -0.02130475826561451, -0.014625316485762596, -0.043750278651714325, 0.0230240635573864, -0.012231034226715565, 0.029076382517814636, 0.03767963871359825, 0.013816915452480316, 0.030397552996873856, 0.03009648621082306, 0.03521426394581795, -0.017268063500523567, -0.011922883801162243, 0.008889544755220413, -0.01055081281810999, -0.04458310455083847, 0.07475756108760834, 0.0017028829315677285, 0.02402656339108944, 0.02796470932662487, 0.012950550764799118, 0.014303777366876602, 0.014845496043562889, 0.026261044666171074, 0.033004771918058395, 0.023420875892043114, 0.012417691759765148, 0.013256066478788853, -0.047489479184150696, -0.07440585643053055, 0.03233092650771141, 0.0293597225099802, -0.012119149789214134, 0.023790299892425537, 0.00421594874933362, -0.01562635414302349, -0.05962897464632988, 0.06162504106760025, 0.006810189224779606, -0.02703578770160675, 0.02858782559633255, 0.0014104383299127221, -0.0002043597341980785, -0.01446568313986063, 0.026764987036585808, -0.04957270622253418, -0.006547362543642521, 0.017464805394411087, 0.01810619607567787, -0.015881681814789772, -0.005870847497135401, -0.03328688070178032, -0.04334443435072899, 0.03133029118180275, 0.003979881294071674, -0.017551971599459648, -0.011295866221189499, -0.03585902601480484, -0.03174601495265961, 0.015611328184604645, 0.01753154583275318, -0.0029248984064906836, -0.05104745179414749, 0.02071751095354557, 0.00042615990969352424, -0.0029012381564825773, 0.02553842030465603, 0.0058440291322767735, -0.009320678189396858, -0.08117757737636566, 0.04148903861641884, -0.001624585478566587, -0.030275460332632065, -0.04444623738527298, 0.008142487145960331, -0.012094149366021156, 0.034158192574977875, 0.03644172474741936, 0.04471225291490555, -0.008781463839113712, -0.031349822878837585, 0.025912676006555557, 0.018323034048080444, -0.07746991515159607, -0.0006234326283447444, -0.036429230123758316, -0.027998248115181923, -0.01734679378569126, -0.014657682739198208, -0.0072781797498464584, 0.018579816445708275, 0.04073406010866165, 0.00045998237328603864, 0.04471080005168915, -0.017351003363728523, -0.005995742045342922, 0.033916328102350235, 0.022033534944057465, 0.002456049667671323, 0.011160186491906643, 0.002655798103660345, -0.015551239252090454, 0.032352786511182785, -0.01044607162475586, -0.03733976557850838, 0.029737260192632675, -0.0012964714551344514, -0.031728021800518036, 0.016160475090146065, 0.011814597062766552, 0.02703445591032505, -0.03828473761677742, -0.05274680629372597, 0.04539871960878372, -0.06898661702871323, -0.018461231142282486, 0.027618763968348503, 0.006923660170286894, 0.06640151888132095, 0.0020876957569271326, 0.0028747273609042168, 0.025547074154019356, -0.015596472658216953, 0.022219497710466385, 0.009463133290410042, 0.05328647419810295, -0.026716601103544235, -0.019931579008698463, -0.02261689305305481, -0.011908330023288727, 0.013395363464951515, -0.04137839376926422, 0.07077120244503021, -0.037158478051424026, 0.004802949260920286, -0.013721044175326824, 0.019513338804244995, 0.004597440827637911, 0.02922014333307743, -0.0010822010226547718, 0.042754460126161575, -0.02568245120346546, -0.012623495422303677, -0.010979045182466507, -0.05722764506936073, -0.015333346091210842, 0.0015832203207537532, 0.05564025789499283, 0.016771461814641953, -0.010585500858724117, 0.014235277660191059, 0.011524978093802929, -0.006726948078721762, 0.04805363342165947, -0.016352765262126923, 0.019435226917266846, -0.001531809801235795, -0.020748455077409744, 0.005448479671031237, -0.005823148414492607, 0.03749691694974899, -0.0007552187307737768, -0.021158508956432343, 0.0018245604587718844, -0.002463318407535553, -0.021083487197756767, -0.009299008175730705, 0.023471776396036148, 0.006270889658480883, -0.049024637788534164, -0.012478373013436794, -0.00858450960367918, 0.03258124738931656, -0.0056525361724197865, -0.03139417991042137 ]
<p>I have conducted a survey which asks respondents to indicate the informational sources regarding a product. There are 8 information sources (e.g., internet, newspaper, brochure and so on) and people can choose more than one source.</p> <p>I want to use information source a predictor variable in a multiple regression. However, because people can choose more than one information source, it does not seem possible to to treat it as a single categorical variable. </p> <p><strong>How can a categorical variable where respondents can choose more than one response be used as a predictor in multiple regression?</strong></p>
73,633
[ -0.06626966595649719, -0.012587658129632473, 0.044705405831336975, 0.0012874039821326733, 0.032442331314086914, -0.0019382779719308019, 0.01104856189340353, 0.005466422997415066, 0.035663120448589325, -0.045950546860694885, 0.011774975806474686, 0.02512803114950657, 0.05392767861485481, 0.0030965409241616726, -0.004280311055481434, 0.051618363708257675, 0.0015236999606713653, 0.06852573156356812, 0.005726047791540623, 0.0005660357419401407, -0.006341051775962114, 0.03053525649011135, -0.007583539001643658, 0.004310495685786009, -0.007137089502066374, 0.05962841585278511, 0.030046291649341583, 0.000773312000092119, 0.023778898641467094, 0.009929328225553036, 0.017754461616277695, -0.03876878321170807, -0.014432219788432121, 0.06179964169859886, 0.005166466347873211, -0.030719488859176636, -0.022442305460572243, -0.023638015612959862, 0.008393875323235989, 0.024318939074873924, -0.042999427765607834, -0.011764071881771088, -0.010597322136163712, 0.013059353455901146, -0.03589058667421341, 0.007491115480661392, -0.012862828560173512, -0.06945943832397461, -0.0011385779362171888, -0.01935250125825405, 0.08173338323831558, -0.01232574786990881, -0.0047648390755057335, 0.038580965250730515, -0.07770191133022308, 0.018290111795067787, 0.03388962894678116, 0.07070206105709076, -0.03592485561966896, -0.018025202676653862, -0.02486424520611763, -0.010757221840322018, 0.021881168708205223, -0.03452613204717636, -0.02311747521162033, 0.03521476686000824, 0.018746010959148407, 0.012496107257902622, 0.06136176362633705, -0.020861446857452393, 0.02730829268693924, -0.023281510919332504, 0.02273302525281906, 0.011192837730050087, -0.009288354776799679, -0.048588186502456665, 0.0253983736038208, 0.041020724922418594, 0.0537460558116436, 0.03876953199505806, 0.017866041511297226, -0.006901986431330442, 0.011664149351418018, 0.02922934480011463, 0.035464536398649216, -0.0115865059196949, 0.054932836443185806, -0.03275144845247269, 0.002984776860103011, -0.005799680948257446, -0.05278180167078972, -0.02898375503718853, 0.03951425105333328, 0.007577488198876381, -0.04093252122402191, 0.0580933652818203, -0.021165385842323303, 0.014102333225309849, 0.018532341346144676, -0.015665436163544655, 0.024753324687480927, -0.013893424533307552, 0.022687796503305435, 0.050985414534807205, -0.023967230692505836, 0.009744697250425816, -0.04743889719247818, -0.015836942940950394, -0.014955705963075161, -0.05011371150612831, 0.008677779696881771, 0.01413815002888441, 0.011609000153839588, -0.012513251975178719, 0.00020427163690328598, -0.020315183326601982, -0.02569388411939144, -0.014179935678839684, 0.04227723181247711, 0.06664470583200455, 0.011939159594476223, -0.07479703426361084, 0.020372284576296806, -0.010889437049627304, -0.030530059710144997, -0.0071776555851101875, 0.013620059937238693, 0.00833495520055294, -0.03148936852812767, 0.04040829464793205, -0.023111075162887573, 0.013026244938373566, 0.03668384626507759, 0.0379166379570961, -0.003252895548939705, 0.04609658569097519, -0.12647083401679993, -0.08037673681974411, 0.025801990181207657, -0.015855569392442703, -0.021670589223504066, -0.05919517204165459, 0.007738157641142607, 0.0356232151389122, 0.05727830529212952, -0.006303857080638409, 0.05359083414077759, 0.04301771521568298, 0.03419572860002518, 0.03377887234091759, -0.04914455488324165, 0.002901453757658601, -0.04113098606467247, 0.005543002393096685, -0.001009650412015617, -0.09768731892108917, 0.025054026395082474, 0.0403701476752758, -0.020774811506271362, 0.0008503968128934503, 0.018113579601049423, 0.020977480337023735, -0.03117922693490982, 0.018834058195352554, 0.03218066319823265, 0.00014465120329987258, 0.034693557769060135, -0.01914677396416664, 0.004371265415102243, 0.009042068384587765, 0.03324247524142265, 0.009321801364421844, 0.000365835236152634, 0.04524939879775047, 0.0074969627894461155, -0.02251407690346241, 0.0033668202813714743, 0.026202073320746422, 0.03037848137319088, -0.00635692710056901, -0.05311577767133713, -0.02971157245337963, -0.009005452506244183, -0.00747925927862525, 0.0520656481385231, 0.057963039726018906, -0.004366235341876745, -0.015135963447391987, 0.04564668983221054, -0.04002503305673599, -0.02135767601430416, -0.026621868833899498, 0.03262367099523544, -0.010915307328104973, -0.0036733446177095175, 0.025561541318893433, 0.017432017251849174, -0.01439877413213253, 0.005602376069873571, -0.009248101152479649, -0.037728581577539444, -0.018330318853259087, 0.03043295070528984, -0.013402765616774559, -0.035974644124507904, 0.035402026027441025, 0.010644630528986454, -0.041861433535814285, -0.009047938510775566, -0.014766157604753971, -0.06801420450210571, 0.013114213943481445, -0.04048944637179375, 0.04522000253200531, -0.021243439987301826, -0.00850545335561037, 0.004254450090229511, 0.039158955216407776, -0.03626401349902153, 0.06435811519622803, -0.08471657335758209, 0.04641832038760185, 0.03339914605021477, -0.015678610652685165, -0.030081860721111298, 0.01566077023744583, 0.003381495364010334, 0.014843438751995564, -0.04561590403318405, -0.02076943777501583, -0.08081848919391632, -0.015528791584074497, 0.020972002297639847, -0.0029559063259512186, -0.07418708503246307, 0.03690801560878754, 0.03312031924724579, 0.01785394363105297, 0.015841839835047722, 0.024373484775424004, 0.00009290347225032747, -0.00718176132068038, 0.025154486298561096, 0.0012741744285449386, 0.004242636263370514, 0.015514404512941837, 0.03180987015366554, 0.020651554688811302, 0.017967216670513153, -0.005593603011220694, 0.03298154100775719, 0.07063747942447662, -0.014132628217339516, 0.0012536803260445595, 0.01974261924624443, -0.013767500407993793, 0.02689017355442047, -0.047137774527072906, 0.018927916884422302, 0.03567216917872429, 0.031184280291199684, -0.03238779306411743, 0.023250769823789597, -0.011910878121852875, 0.004015249665826559, 0.035434965044260025, -0.05064413323998451, 0.012624859809875488, 0.016666755080223083, -0.04728994891047478, 0.014857366681098938, -0.026199445128440857, 0.0003291188913863152, -0.002589223440736532, 0.011700024828314781, 0.033476684242486954, 0.0034633909817785025, 0.01038918923586607, -0.013668380677700043, -0.03325268626213074, -0.010979664511978626, -0.02972961589694023, -0.0019499841146171093, 0.0009036311530508101, -0.05195295438170433, -0.039964720606803894, -0.041915398091077805, -0.021341102197766304, 0.03882402554154396, 0.0020692364778369665, -0.0706285908818245, 0.04797077178955078, 0.001126555958762765, -0.08901932835578918, -0.0064665786921978, -0.015032641589641571, 0.00938420370221138, -0.034161992371082306, -0.04312029480934143, -0.0022878737654536963, -0.011741126887500286, -0.021956929937005043, -0.012441329658031464, -0.05000476539134979, -0.04966709017753601, 0.013034798204898834, -0.03499699756503105, 0.023586787283420563, -0.018679115921258926, 0.021928198635578156, 0.03362567722797394, 0.011920706368982792, -0.0023726732470095158, -0.1038055494427681, -0.09077193588018417, 0.01784447394311428, -0.005795472767204046, 0.047751106321811676, -0.0007969191065058112, 0.012650935910642147, 0.09218085557222366, 0.02970602735877037, -0.03537348285317421, -0.033883802592754364, -0.018563346937298775, -0.006783465854823589, -0.05009297654032707, 0.03312698379158974, 0.01022579800337553, 0.016739772632718086, 0.028642235323786736, -0.0013231427874416113, 0.020979851484298706, 0.025271007791161537, -0.02739902026951313, 0.009956720285117626, 0.01319620106369257, -0.00439073983579874, -0.025611761957406998, 0.022276978939771652, 0.02473125234246254, -0.02997700870037079, 0.014597868546843529, -0.01770736835896969, 0.03378542885184288, -0.01538976188749075, -0.014215387403964996, 0.009413579478859901, -0.018456807360053062, -0.010910767130553722, -0.04840587452054024, 0.027878545224666595, 0.029518624767661095, -0.0385877899825573, -0.020303623750805855, 0.01783991977572441, 0.03828710690140724, -0.02042219415307045, -0.014617222361266613, 0.08829616010189056, 0.028845548629760742, -0.012841916643083096, -0.006468906532973051, -0.024925358593463898, 0.001895311987027526, 0.02706247754395008, -0.012568967416882515, 0.013367421925067902, 0.009909957647323608, 0.013828806579113007, 0.018139367923140526, -0.005711328703910112, -0.04996633902192116, 0.042870089411735535, -0.03507537022233009, 0.016778940334916115, -0.008437152951955795, 0.045547742396593094, -0.01815180666744709, 0.0533471517264843, 0.02128143049776554, -0.02110876329243183, 0.007889202795922756, 0.02338341251015663, -0.056428905576467514, -0.003401079447939992, -0.023943116888403893, 0.03905411809682846, 0.03196599707007408, -0.0362052246928215, 0.023972133174538612, -0.029093530029058456, 0.00816518533974886, -0.006978908553719521, 0.037813641130924225, -0.02284642681479454, 0.00824639294296503, -0.008188330568373203, -0.010932646691799164, 0.00043248399742878973, 0.012284497730433941, 0.008243965916335583, 0.00698489835485816, 0.033423326909542084, 0.0550350658595562, -0.014790513552725315, 0.012311712838709354, -0.04215531051158905, -0.0476653166115284, 0.0049995072185993195, 0.026277810335159302, 0.026992972940206528, 0.023665308952331543, -0.014096208848059177, 0.03813062608242035, -0.0010980413062497973, 0.021838290616869926, 0.015481208451092243, -0.02212604321539402, -0.01825765334069729, -0.04158839210867882, -0.005738076753914356, -0.033901769667863846, 0.002220682566985488, -0.021815424785017967, 0.005799392703920603, 0.07345376908779144, 0.027204077690839767, -0.036597367376089096, 0.019173547625541687, 0.027028869837522507, 0.04676511138677597, 0.008103461936116219, -0.00017473897605668753, 0.028223970904946327, 0.012796192429959774, -0.004283787216991186, 0.006718794349581003, 0.011741048656404018, -0.008002129383385181, 0.004212444648146629, 0.03352769464254379, -0.0003367036406416446, -0.04453153908252716, -0.01350390538573265, 0.021636128425598145, 0.023204755038022995, 0.0019448123639449477, -0.05163634940981865, -0.007029098458588123, 0.05041484534740448, 0.02764069102704525, 0.005439062137156725, -0.0067070769146084785, -0.11381997913122177, -0.0035648923367261887, 0.03719049319624901, 0.0425988994538784, -0.0427047498524189, 0.010656495578587055, -0.026595572009682655, -0.008795646019279957, 0.026015980169177055, -0.005300939083099365, 0.02478884533047676, -0.013735711574554443, 0.041264619678258896, -0.012511307373642921, -0.04042736440896988, -0.017772577702999115, 0.014920282177627087, -0.04047263786196709, 0.018689272925257683, -0.002799856709316373, -0.0035984122660011053, -0.02105598896741867, 0.02735019102692604, 0.04704669490456581, 0.0347016341984272, 0.002150982618331909, -0.0013972833985462785, 0.02139260806143284, 0.04218766838312149, -0.024610571563243866, -0.04043681174516678, 0.014947093091905117, 0.01667221449315548, -0.0271796565502882, 0.04202910140156746, -0.011315961368381977, -0.03243226185441017, -0.001273622619919479, 0.021907446905970573, -0.018755240365862846, -0.0041231028735637665, -0.048945412039756775, 0.0036378060467541218, 0.01110986340790987, 0.008280794136226177, 0.04736915975809097, 0.020430544391274452, -0.00013775243132840842, 0.012915684841573238, -0.015483167953789234, -0.015267468057572842, -0.024517659097909927, -0.07095349580049515, 0.013393864035606384, 0.007662328891456127, -0.010500012896955013, 0.0005310301785357296, 0.023416679352521896, -0.010667162947356701, -0.03856031969189644, -0.03322073072195053, -0.013617094606161118, 0.03186139464378357, -0.00231951498426497, 0.028043797239661217, -0.012506257742643356, 0.022480521351099014, -0.017736459150910378, -0.010858885943889618, 0.008658818900585175, -0.028766311705112457, 0.031535521149635315, 0.029200825840234756, -0.02653726190328598, 0.011883977800607681, -0.025654267519712448, -0.05159289017319679, 0.017912080511450768, -0.03969654440879822, 0.0656735897064209, 0.00638591730967164, 0.03336698189377785, -0.02665163017809391, -0.06158791109919548, -0.013913464732468128, 0.04039700701832771, -0.006481238640844822, 0.039832036942243576, -0.01713341847062111, 0.04726925119757652, -0.020589035004377365, -0.00907201785594225, -0.049530692398548126, -0.02266405150294304, -0.009260578081011772, 0.03246311470866203, -0.03132089227437973, -0.021615376695990562, 0.024687068536877632, -0.05335784703493118, -0.03256847336888313, -0.023624617606401443, 0.0305610541254282, -0.00009803708962863311, -0.025090452283620834, 0.006585802882909775, 0.04319607466459274, 0.05231250077486038, 0.007584680803120136, -0.042275670915842056, 0.028854789212346077, -0.02443142980337143, 0.023323524743318558, -0.013017795979976654, -0.020226821303367615, -0.0070111858658492565, -0.009712032042443752, 0.0003864500322379172, 0.0174093060195446, 0.040296267718076706, 0.0005836942582391202, 0.03600668907165527, 0.01124761626124382, -0.0008724636281840503, -0.03996653109788895, -0.013516969978809357, 0.01605539210140705, -0.005155059974640608, -0.005824688822031021, -0.005207862239331007, 0.028847388923168182, -0.06389928609132767, 0.03850007802248001, 0.042350828647613525, -0.02640128880739212, -0.044054754078388214, 0.013224913738667965, 0.0991358682513237, 0.04341462627053261, 0.03513332083821297, -0.0284026637673378, -0.01578543335199356, 0.03393033891916275, -0.0023869602009654045, 0.004792443942278624, 0.009747927077114582, 0.032574236392974854, 0.0013398794690147042, -0.030153164640069008, 0.004861061926931143, -0.0011439163936302066, 0.05703432857990265, -0.042622294276952744, 0.011974251829087734, 0.06436751037836075, 0.011805258691310883, -0.002007564762607217, -0.026245564222335815, 0.016490519046783447, 0.00040667387656867504, 0.018117574974894524, 0.059620726853609085, -0.002050690818578005, -0.024590855464339256, 0.036517929285764694, 0.020279889926314354, 0.007491409312933683, 0.011215634644031525, 0.03150767832994461, 0.038184650242328644, 0.007622409611940384, -0.04062649607658386, -0.05304209515452385, 0.0015117611037567258, -0.06621433049440384, 0.03609153628349304, -0.012742292135953903, -0.030916523188352585, 0.04276605695486069, 0.0030690378043800592, 0.02625538781285286, -0.05550537258386612, -0.002519527217373252, -0.033507052809000015, 0.01608891785144806, -0.00062567024724558, 0.030802296474575996, 0.038613442331552505, -0.009103508666157722, 0.018771134316921234, -0.015143590047955513, 0.014202096499502659, -0.005214645527303219, -0.0802488774061203, -0.03192461282014847, -0.027473796159029007, -0.01963069476187229, 0.019371433183550835, -0.009160289540886879, -0.012281420640647411, 0.020733492448925972, -0.05492653697729111, 0.015500042587518692, 0.012990977615118027, 0.02508830465376377, -0.005023609846830368, 0.07514696568250656, -0.02648574486374855, 0.022084349766373634, 0.027258021757006645, -0.011548085138201714, 0.12597808241844177, 0.10587750375270844, 0.013167181052267551, -0.09096840769052505, -0.03277138993144035, 0.02256850153207779, 0.007990239188075066, -0.008964660577476025, -0.0038714308757334948, -0.013185075484216213, 0.042178697884082794, 0.06374708563089371, 0.03858736529946327, -0.00021790788741782308, 0.038155101239681244, 0.07760704308748245, -0.051473941653966904, 0.0073159257881343365, 0.01969226263463497, -0.006923752836883068, 0.011868445202708244, -0.010297678411006927, -0.01953764446079731, 0.014413157477974892, 0.011080118827521801, -0.006133983377367258, 0.01761028729379177, -0.02181132324039936, 0.014765404164791107, 0.00563181983307004, -0.018441684544086456, -0.008908257819712162, 0.020852502435445786, 0.04225502163171768, -0.03407004103064537, 0.002534821629524231, 0.024973157793283463, -0.027147743850946426, 0.00729279313236475, 0.016413362696766853, -0.018159661442041397, -0.024738140404224396, 0.014746559783816338, 0.03625563532114029, -0.04085773229598999, -0.014696527272462845, -0.0409277006983757, -0.0023543555289506912, -0.005630637984722853, -0.011015800759196281, -0.03429420292377472, 0.01396993175148964, 0.013454056344926357, -0.01584971696138382, -0.02576657012104988, 0.04491090029478073, 0.01637081801891327, -0.034949008375406265, -0.050119467079639435, -0.015720892697572708, -0.0013389831874519587, -0.013348943553864956, 0.014864464290440083, 0.012893804349005222, -0.04540962353348732, -0.018522538244724274, -0.013600177131593227, 0.006416311487555504, 0.035290371626615524, -0.031551096588373184, 0.01251510251313448, -0.006154775619506836, -0.02739076130092144, -0.006494514178484678, 0.007869020104408264, -0.019635887816548347, 0.01792311668395996, -0.006915468722581863, 0.01990807242691517, -0.023514579981565475, -0.02353152632713318, -0.0076475380919873714, -0.002451268257573247, 0.0051686568185687065, -0.028942547738552094, 0.04357977584004402, 0.001948877819813788, 0.02434029057621956, 0.026518236845731735, 0.005603186320513487, 0.01773589290678501, 0.0506851002573967, 0.030390771105885506, -0.05684932321310043, -0.011818640865385532, 0.009926720522344112, -0.04607982188463211, 0.006787801161408424, -0.03314555808901787, 0.06692984700202942, -0.00822987500578165, 0.014914062805473804, 0.026022791862487793, -0.00762807484716177, -0.002802235772833228, 0.02543500065803528, 0.010178210213780403, -0.027921712026000023, -0.005098680034279823, 0.03175869956612587, -0.007929257117211819, -0.00593072734773159, -0.01527418289333582, -0.019264699891209602, -0.04212786629796028, 0.039062824100255966, -0.03327587619423866, -0.025553885847330093, 0.03749557584524155, -0.0239529050886631, 0.012597521767020226, 0.003954712301492691, 0.006996977608650923, -0.06112862750887871, 0.011362388730049133, -0.0036796038039028645, -0.028147058561444283, -0.026316454634070396, 0.03789666295051575, -0.021790385246276855, 0.017083557322621346, 0.027108533307909966, 0.03402591124176979, 0.02457018941640854, 0.004179274197667837, 0.021297607570886612, 0.003960308153182268, 0.04984677955508232, -0.012503852136433125, -0.010553254745900631, 0.019096314907073975, -0.024815287441015244, -0.013639052398502827, -0.00948050245642662, -0.006790908053517342, 0.0572049543261528, 0.0321853831410408, 0.002935622585937381, 0.017584361135959625, 0.050651442259550095, -0.010405262000858784, 0.011183253489434719, 0.004777329508215189, 0.02564949542284012, 0.012054317630827427, -0.031932562589645386, -0.01155928336083889, 0.038891855627298355, -0.012798471376299858, 0.028020810335874557, 0.05697507783770561, 0.0223799217492342, -0.013897160068154335, 0.0020484833512455225, -0.01784004643559456, 0.022254662588238716, 0.019453004002571106, 0.011285549029707909, 0.04271990805864334, 0.01710163615643978, -0.01723533682525158, 0.024661850184202194, 0.013401108793914318, 0.009310274384915829, -0.09717617183923721, -0.03132623806595802, 0.020169315859675407, 0.00023084343411028385, 0.04108632355928421, -0.013227410614490509, -0.014679458923637867, 0.028206441551446915, -0.04459354281425476, -0.01584102027118206, 0.005841512698680162, -0.01168767735362053, -0.022711513563990593, -0.013463841751217842, -0.06127390265464783, 0.020227065309882164, 0.06216886639595032, 0.018829800188541412, 0.02177589014172554, 0.02010776661336422, -0.020497893914580345, -0.044836245477199554, -0.004820171743631363, 0.0036691545974463224, -0.006331578362733126, -0.0782017931342125, 0.04685242101550102, -0.03141653910279274, -0.039495278149843216, 0.041003160178661346, -0.00005791061630588956, 0.03316594660282135, 0.03659219667315483, -0.00963897816836834, 0.010399811901152134, 0.04486635699868202, 0.012166626751422882, -0.019454635679721832, -0.0323336087167263, 0.02070763148367405, 0.005133586935698986, 0.030439425259828568, 0.007571042515337467, 0.006278918590396643, 0.012177505530416965, -0.037958092987537384, -0.010584712959825993, -0.01082561258226633, -0.018677690997719765, -0.020987605676054955, 0.012395159341394901, 0.005531940143555403, 0.002667695749551058, -0.02675728313624859, 0.0021747159771621227, -0.07535584270954132, -0.04303129017353058, 0.06363783776760101, -0.0086743775755167, -0.02050846628844738, -0.03155047446489334, -0.030852867290377617, -0.05609513819217682, 0.04438381269574165, -0.010464142076671124, -0.014164038002490997, -0.057121675461530685, 0.0036988977808505297, 0.010111615993082523, 0.008857845328748226, -0.0646476224064827, 0.0043763224966824055, -0.016329152509570122, 0.03564636781811714, -0.028222447261214256, -0.02253391034901142, -0.006036176811903715, -0.04372984170913696, 0.012212278321385384, -0.06492968648672104, 0.05174962058663368, 0.043608009815216064, -0.0018646306125447154, -0.02513734996318817, -0.03202174976468086, -0.041116226464509964, -0.0031216663774102926, 0.05259518325328827, -0.01574084348976612, -0.010624549351632595, 0.010306525975465775, 0.031050540506839752, -0.0052283164113759995, -0.020900776609778404, 0.03167093172669411, 0.01093435101211071, -0.03839185833930969, -0.026318319141864777, 0.019113417714834213, 0.005917247850447893, -0.008410897105932236, -0.00006338409730233252, 0.0008812373853288591, 0.01109529472887516, 0.019510459154844284, 0.0033833314664661884, 0.0029411192517727613, -0.005695426370948553, -0.03635355085134506, 0.023598425090312958, -0.001159526058472693, -0.004846659023314714, 0.009872829541563988, 0.01095738634467125, -0.05819988250732422, 0.02616824023425579, 0.03520684316754341, -0.029942218214273453, -0.024990178644657135, 0.01973569765686989, -0.004957196302711964, -0.0548875592648983, -0.03277396410703659, 0.03085177205502987, -0.04392239823937416, 0.015180165879428387, 0.023678377270698547, 0.03600931167602539, 0.019308174028992653, 0.023980235680937767, 0.013515351340174675, 0.005047122947871685, -0.0499112606048584, 0.0012149258982390165, 0.006340124644339085, 0.023221781477332115, 0.010676371864974499, -0.018870757892727852, 0.05147536098957062, 0.03117167204618454, 0.009283626452088356, -0.016954489052295685, 0.02685357816517353, -0.05942402780056, -0.016079433262348175, 0.005025842227041721, 0.023090785369277, 0.013553707860410213, 0.020444653928279877, 0.002349297981709242, 0.043387699872255325, -0.009500447660684586, 0.006167486775666475, -0.03982311114668846, 0.019462894648313522, -0.028798678889870644, -0.014699961990118027, 0.0028027119114995003, 0.05104415491223335, 0.05051092430949211, 0.012245587073266506, 0.021676326170563698, -0.03403174877166748, 0.023656116798520088, -0.027008218690752983, 0.002419551834464073, -0.011058961041271687, -0.0451231449842453, -0.050849344581365585, -0.02565070241689682, -0.0009470733930356801, -0.011767683550715446, 0.04835844784975052, 0.04928644746541977, 0.029979802668094635, -0.03517110273241997, -0.045580968260765076, -0.02251402474939823, 0.05186796560883522, -0.05088897421956062, 0.00491817994043231, -0.027624454349279404, -0.004855685401707888, 0.021450763568282127, -0.023923374712467194 ]
<p>I am developing a physiological test using R that requires some parameters optimised. In comparing the new method against the existing method, the values of individual readings correlate in a linear way but are very heteroscedastic - the variance approximately proportional to the mean. </p> <p>I would like to compare the effects of various parameter changes by examining the goodness-of-fit of the linear models compared with each other. Confidence intervals around the linear model parameters are not needed. Comparing R squareds does not seem appropriate given the heteroscedasticity. Would distance correlation or R squared after HCCM correction be appropriate ways to test if one method is superior to another ?</p>
39,335
[ -0.02432958222925663, 0.007320839446038008, 0.001319221337325871, -0.025028282776474953, 0.0058989315293729305, 0.0136988814920187, -0.00920888688415289, -0.026482054963707924, 0.029397837817668915, 0.0032628995832055807, 0.039732012897729874, 0.021473802626132965, 0.04897069185972214, 0.02359304204583168, 0.025443032383918762, -0.00953814759850502, -0.03038002923130989, 0.0005128096090629697, -0.021383026614785194, -0.03537604212760925, -0.03184697777032852, 0.012794486247003078, 0.026744626462459564, -0.025774115696549416, -0.04423530399799347, 0.0672728419303894, 0.02791791781783104, -0.01979132741689682, -0.014433998614549637, 0.05992914363741875, -0.08077619224786758, -0.029352223500609398, 0.011029236949980259, 0.007236993871629238, 0.024849507957696915, -0.00970158539712429, -0.017462341114878654, -0.062273863703012466, -0.027963826432824135, 0.06903903931379318, -0.02641749382019043, -0.018770363181829453, 0.022881072014570236, 0.040546562522649765, 0.010304809547960758, 0.03714386373758316, -0.04669605568051338, -0.02311966009438038, 0.03014962561428547, -0.041304875165224075, 0.07248632609844208, 0.003317125141620636, 0.05622778460383415, 0.00893309898674488, -0.012784253805875778, -0.022770095616579056, 0.03862619772553444, 0.05144732818007469, -0.019591081887483597, -0.04548783227801323, 0.012836698442697525, -0.034961577504873276, 0.00981882307678461, -0.01298394426703453, -0.01537014078348875, 0.009038061834871769, 0.006908298935741186, -0.019523024559020996, 0.05255470797419548, -0.006978476420044899, 0.011021207086741924, 0.023794209584593773, 0.048035550862550735, -0.020647084340453148, 0.04652366787195206, -0.038262926042079926, -0.02660963498055935, 0.005757469683885574, 0.04875323176383972, 0.05044998228549957, -0.00925272423774004, -0.009133120998740196, 0.025441957637667656, 0.0032041447702795267, 0.03239330276846886, -0.04012810066342354, 0.03601019084453583, -0.009118492715060711, -0.01048839557915926, 0.03256237879395485, 0.003216652199625969, 0.027220962569117546, 0.03491167724132538, 0.05505022034049034, -0.029695408418774605, 0.009820928797125816, -0.019690576940774918, 0.06584524363279343, 0.0067703500390052795, -0.0006887510535307229, -0.019541965797543526, -0.039324525743722916, 0.01599971577525139, 0.029427874833345413, -0.010057076811790466, -0.011204132810235023, -0.013352250680327415, -0.014871603809297085, -0.023639870807528496, 0.0016884217038750648, -0.035666730254888535, 0.008299576118588448, -0.01975947804749012, 0.037786953151226044, 0.04502004012465477, -0.026744164526462555, -0.022641051560640335, -0.0355944000184536, 0.08879534900188446, 0.054650094360113144, 0.03513166308403015, 0.01641443371772766, -0.02240186370909214, -0.010015247389674187, 0.028395622968673706, 0.013175384141504765, -0.010997848585247993, -0.019850172102451324, -0.03496857360005379, 0.06742995232343674, 0.009812641888856888, -0.017030533403158188, -0.004642812069505453, -0.020031610503792763, 0.03429993987083435, -0.0010786015773192048, -0.09129900485277176, -0.04607803747057915, 0.008095121942460537, -0.004093240946531296, 0.003204832086339593, -0.028792446479201317, -0.028078509494662285, -0.0021550108212977648, 0.05161358043551445, 0.007740591652691364, 0.0217707771807909, 0.002907505724579096, 0.027605963870882988, 0.0073559097945690155, 0.01469767652451992, -0.003438792657107115, -0.02614450827240944, -0.03032364323735237, -0.03230820968747139, -0.09283320605754852, -0.010575423017144203, 0.023624684661626816, -0.012967034243047237, 0.027100324630737305, 0.03310564160346985, 0.03249206766486168, -0.012998376972973347, 0.007358940783888102, -0.00922227930277586, 0.015351406298577785, 0.08663097023963928, -0.03769288957118988, 0.01608116179704666, -0.006941552273929119, -0.012617796659469604, 0.01589476503431797, 0.023917637765407562, 0.01664435677230358, 0.04538965970277786, -0.004652457777410746, 0.018376678228378296, -0.010460086166858673, 0.017764786258339882, 0.049984268844127655, -0.02007172629237175, -0.018125230446457863, -0.016310757026076317, -0.007524630054831505, 0.015843380242586136, 0.059608444571495056, -0.023232217878103256, -0.031534601002931595, 0.07694805413484573, -0.03133713826537132, -0.040994856506586075, -0.041924040764570236, -0.018006861209869385, 0.014805060811340809, -0.02901891991496086, 0.05183407664299011, -0.004961921367794275, 0.054790619760751724, 0.005716796964406967, 0.005336706060916185, -0.02579325996339321, 0.013849089853465557, 0.06406521797180176, -0.0116290133446455, 0.01363436970859766, 0.03626522049307823, 0.04317368566989899, -0.005020633339881897, 0.038764432072639465, -0.01583394967019558, -0.058701712638139725, 0.029877470806241035, -0.04498036578297615, 0.03528924658894539, 0.00808786228299141, -0.012768308632075787, -0.024354074150323868, 0.019883492961525917, -0.03190129995346069, 0.04350258782505989, -0.0391661711037159, 0.072001151740551, 0.04045229032635689, 0.012958268634974957, 0.03088349662721157, 0.022487225010991096, -0.012107261456549168, 0.022192176431417465, -0.029947854578495026, -0.038239985704422, -0.051375217735767365, 0.005791922565549612, 0.03400227054953575, 0.003726519178599119, -0.03051222488284111, -0.009582874365150928, 0.05529114231467247, 0.013453803025186062, 0.013295776210725307, 0.03469906374812126, 0.00632582837715745, -0.04232108220458031, 0.007617420982569456, -0.00647319620475173, 0.00037111996789462864, -0.016011612489819527, 0.035042326897382736, -0.02812126651406288, 0.053303420543670654, -0.01587013714015484, 0.011093067936599255, 0.03208056464791298, 0.008418560028076172, 0.003291598754003644, -0.04422803595662117, -0.029211290180683136, 0.0024414898362010717, -0.002263883361592889, -0.016282541677355766, 0.04454982653260231, -0.002886488102376461, 0.003153708763420582, -0.0008625024929642677, 0.0010338581632822752, 0.039093274623155594, 0.030550777912139893, -0.007227977272123098, -0.02666902169585228, 0.03124118223786354, -0.055375780910253525, -0.004640073981136084, -0.0655846819281578, -0.01385621726512909, -0.033606115728616714, -0.027640340849757195, 0.02070571854710579, 0.030321132391691208, 0.03776226565241814, -0.0095371687784791, 0.0340307392179966, 0.007364972494542599, 0.003107470693066716, 0.01233209390193224, -0.004984981846064329, -0.014698939397931099, -0.012275154702365398, -0.03838049992918968, 0.010968568734824657, -0.0023190162610262632, -0.0014963994035497308, -0.012903845869004726, 0.02583191730082035, 0.0024231707211583853, -0.041378069669008255, -0.01523538213223219, -0.0200649481266737, 0.002233936218544841, 0.031128186732530594, -0.02019847184419632, 0.0688164234161377, -0.00480425963178277, -0.028014156967401505, 0.03386896103620529, -0.048257406800985336, 0.008469103835523129, -0.013788914307951927, 0.0046471799723804, 0.0028673957567662, 0.011465435847640038, 0.004037234466522932, -0.006040838081389666, -0.05199873074889183, -0.010023478418588638, -0.07265691459178925, -0.055127862840890884, 0.04762771725654602, -0.011864268220961094, 0.06114150211215019, -0.00873782578855753, -0.03320933133363724, 0.05011017620563507, 0.06105717644095421, -0.026398004963994026, -0.02847668156027794, 0.02673090621829033, -0.06280718743801117, 0.009465747512876987, 0.028292609378695488, 0.04399879276752472, -0.007676036562770605, 0.033761803060770035, 0.004833531565964222, 0.013727984391152859, 0.052413210272789, 0.010777292773127556, -0.013767333701252937, 0.025284865871071815, 0.0008625441114418209, -0.015421995893120766, 0.04975098744034767, 0.003350242506712675, -0.01409249659627676, -0.009200616739690304, -0.0002817611675709486, -0.03358049318194389, 0.02914675511419773, -0.05164444074034691, 0.0028735417872667313, 0.009818753227591515, 0.015106241218745708, -0.003984419628977776, -0.0005237445002421737, 0.013836640864610672, -0.03461390361189842, -0.015363500453531742, 0.04170772433280945, 0.012847473844885826, -0.007155840750783682, -0.007646853569895029, 0.02329804003238678, 0.04401865974068642, -0.012028216384351254, 0.006847923155874014, 0.04220425337553024, 0.009709661826491356, 0.05411404371261597, -0.05172199755907059, -0.0402158722281456, 0.048639945685863495, 0.011189408600330353, 0.019872218370437622, 0.014594786800444126, -0.041970640420913696, -0.012573732063174248, -0.055892374366521835, -0.039608851075172424, -0.04433804377913475, 0.03741688281297684, -0.008729362860321999, -0.008202031254768372, 0.0453629307448864, -0.033269673585891724, 0.023512814193964005, -0.02423294447362423, -0.055702030658721924, 0.04709533229470253, -0.003569207154214382, -0.019607488065958023, 0.046792395412921906, -0.03155159205198288, 0.01899460144340992, -0.01894758827984333, 0.024327663704752922, -0.0043823025189340115, 0.010007099248468876, -0.02066158875823021, 0.04472532123327255, -0.0036632996052503586, -0.029696473851799965, 0.0038363258354365826, 0.009067108854651451, -0.035175956785678864, -0.018940679728984833, 0.01125758420675993, -0.0008488661842420697, 0.0007287704502232373, 0.005116772837936878, 0.004809313919395208, 0.03540409356355667, 0.044595181941986084, 0.037494413554668427, 0.01753636822104454, -0.008448908105492592, -0.032576415687799454, 0.04031631723046303, 0.027479086071252823, 0.020682724192738533, 0.021281126886606216, -0.011875612661242485, -0.04774019122123718, -0.03631734475493431, -0.04971824586391449, -0.023531800135970116, 0.011283224448561668, 0.008251309394836426, -0.018091678619384766, 0.039507340639829636, 0.02610229142010212, -0.006878308951854706, -0.01409187726676464, 0.03547143563628197, 0.00750426622107625, -0.010035359300673008, -0.01894312910735607, -0.033602792769670486, 0.023784348741173744, -0.022531751543283463, 0.029126320034265518, 0.017085792496800423, 0.000754305743612349, 0.0013936175964772701, 0.08815622329711914, -0.006386798340827227, -0.058160968124866486, -0.005476347170770168, 0.04847238212823868, 0.037711985409259796, 0.00435147387906909, 0.007410508580505848, 0.02393961139023304, 0.024983810260891914, 0.03120333142578602, -0.00037673115730285645, 0.005162528250366449, -0.04847929626703262, 0.007263151928782463, 0.028828328475356102, 0.024308031424880028, -0.04968814551830292, -0.015764161944389343, -0.038626182824373245, 0.01093699224293232, 0.03284280747175217, -0.027444100007414818, 0.012689592316746712, 0.0069013419561088085, -0.01888112910091877, -0.017481913790106773, -0.03340687230229378, -0.08204255998134613, -0.013191907666623592, 0.0025445593055337667, 0.015723280608654022, -0.06836094707250595, -0.031410474330186844, -0.019978463649749756, -0.005049064289778471, -0.005415238440036774, 0.05139726400375366, -0.046829912811517715, -0.012793227098882198, 0.0286751426756382, 0.004670104011893272, -0.006845887750387192, -0.05393245071172714, 0.006826308555901051, 0.01616797037422657, 0.0001644939766265452, 0.03472699597477913, 0.0072307707741856575, 0.002090772148221731, -0.005965149030089378, -0.03613917902112007, -0.04228140041232109, -0.02513127401471138, -0.014287710189819336, 0.05185844749212265, 0.04520491510629654, 0.017249172553420067, 0.05430728569626808, 0.020388728007674217, -0.030489744618535042, -0.007965249009430408, -0.02293821983039379, 0.002722798613831401, -0.00694387499243021, -0.04816126823425293, -0.06268240511417389, -0.01600467786192894, -0.003181279171258211, 0.0456283837556839, -0.02125759795308113, 0.04260699078440666, -0.03990614041686058, 0.012835782021284103, 0.026091627776622772, 0.04529011622071266, -0.017728883773088455, 0.025948775932192802, 0.013722900301218033, 0.047215092927217484, -0.02718357928097248, -0.00437012268230319, 0.02544793300330639, -0.007197536528110504, 0.023931588977575302, 0.03007671795785427, -0.05817583575844765, 0.008975581265985966, -0.021553754806518555, 0.022830529138445854, -0.001559042721055448, -0.008153891190886497, 0.014845399186015129, 0.0017691885586827993, 0.039058201014995575, -0.0016321636503562331, -0.03155263513326645, -0.0006899541476741433, 0.010908922180533409, -0.044328805059194565, 0.042047999799251556, -0.01895979419350624, -0.008882777765393257, -0.015501205809414387, 0.0014413135359063745, -0.06453313678503036, -0.022524802014231682, 0.012806788086891174, 0.011133041232824326, -0.0012911155354231596, -0.04167467728257179, -0.000027040990971727297, -0.006327780894935131, -0.003338407026603818, -0.0199084784835577, 0.06588484346866608, 0.01050563808530569, -0.007613063789904118, -0.031221872195601463, 0.017207546159625053, 0.0777263268828392, 0.0027957262936979532, 0.020701993256807327, 0.031182097271084785, 0.009957058355212212, -0.021698622032999992, -0.0070034172385931015, 0.007429399061948061, -0.04374980181455612, -0.012204647995531559, -0.02430066280066967, -0.013074042275547981, 0.060614798218011856, 0.0019207816803827882, -0.053041618317365646, 0.018498210236430168, -0.047994643449783325, -0.011973457410931587, -0.04569242522120476, 0.019195444881916046, -0.05166006088256836, 0.008276179432868958, -0.02283380925655365, 0.02726089023053646, 0.009585702791810036, -0.04452450945973396, 0.01713709905743599, 0.0004585506394505501, -0.028258822858333588, -0.01094658114016056, 0.06009622663259506, 0.003546827007085085, 0.022051218897104263, 0.021920736879110336, -0.029403185471892357, 0.025949642062187195, 0.002084610518068075, 0.010749556124210358, -0.006664428859949112, 0.03212931752204895, -0.0200919508934021, -0.05383867025375366, -0.011857922188937664, -0.013186846859753132, 0.058671630918979645, 0.01862298510968685, 0.06238268315792084, 0.060760390013456345, 0.010223772376775742, 0.013372329995036125, 0.0010727460030466318, 0.004552611615508795, -0.00624896539375186, 0.013166907243430614, 0.053033702075481415, -0.018959425389766693, -0.02224765159189701, 0.04636926203966141, 0.019033724442124367, 0.017017662525177002, 0.027341634035110474, -0.006979643367230892, 0.025814663618803024, 0.030035050585865974, 0.007158447988331318, -0.04860556498169899, 0.03184434026479721, -0.057609427720308304, 0.007127688266336918, -0.05002822354435921, -0.004177275113761425, 0.019943606108427048, 0.03251945972442627, -0.02126019075512886, -0.018699079751968384, -0.025979867205023766, -0.04552491381764412, -0.009306707419455051, 0.03473898768424988, -0.035055968910455704, -0.013300370424985886, 0.013988328166306019, 0.07149846106767654, -0.0026548118330538273, 0.02697339467704296, -0.04415885731577873, -0.07036222517490387, -0.013657764531672001, 0.03559163957834244, -0.030884644016623497, 0.07214301079511642, 0.009197277948260307, -0.015980277210474014, -0.015315377153456211, -0.028909768909215927, 0.011661962606012821, 0.013524465262889862, 0.01938055455684662, -0.03960498049855232, 0.053633589297533035, -0.029686246067285538, -0.03131333366036415, 0.0011644134065136313, -0.00841987319290638, 0.08818879723548889, 0.05234227329492569, 0.04399031773209572, -0.0446946918964386, 0.03620735555887222, 0.00411645695567131, 0.020069170743227005, 0.0027209660038352013, 0.01744319312274456, 0.0009181767236441374, 0.015354184433817863, 0.06714042276144028, 0.027823105454444885, 0.009691698476672173, -0.022953055799007416, 0.062472160905599594, 0.014410668052732944, -0.0029549759346991777, 0.01534106582403183, 0.009470652788877487, -0.012174534611403942, -0.00010660962288966402, 0.005226034205406904, 0.04140602797269821, -0.0070261540822684765, -0.002918471582233906, -0.056862931698560715, -0.02773815393447876, -0.018784338608384132, 0.012838161550462246, -0.07291455566883087, 0.0128632215783, -0.00780456094071269, 0.04162265732884407, -0.009091859683394432, 0.015123180113732815, 0.015832725912332535, -0.00257179606705904, 0.019796403124928474, 0.04579697549343109, 0.003040806856006384, -0.013540184125304222, 0.025708185508847237, -0.0023977092932909727, -0.06712924689054489, -0.02554219402372837, -0.05479812249541283, 0.014979316852986813, -0.004658976569771767, -0.02932366542518139, 0.017796576023101807, -0.005263171158730984, -0.045788154006004333, -0.059852417558431625, -0.03465249761939049, 0.03444115072488785, 0.01940002664923668, 0.011707336641848087, -0.00917104259133339, -0.05221407487988472, 0.0602218396961689, 0.0021954565308988094, 0.02017131634056568, 0.057820286601781845, -0.036073606461286545, -0.0020945407450199127, -0.0061299740336835384, 0.06087319552898407, -0.028502019122242928, -0.0026358761824667454, -0.005316193215548992, 0.011768752709031105, -0.033260442316532135, 0.0035763217601925135, 0.022219767794013023, -0.004033122677356005, 0.04674747586250305, 0.015347536653280258, -0.032760970294475555, -0.008596478030085564, -0.0708911120891571, -0.028058113530278206, 0.014888983219861984, 0.04628729447722435, -0.049107737839221954, -0.03632739186286926, 0.04284194856882095, 0.002928365720435977, 0.04481342062354088, 0.0038374573923647404, 0.018517492339015007, 0.011465966701507568, 0.007360960356891155, -0.06290164589881897, -0.03249906003475189, 0.007982801645994186, -0.05709833279252052, 0.014024462550878525, -0.02187112346291542, 0.05237541347742081, 0.03544869273900986, 0.05465172603726387, -0.02988908626139164, 0.011288951151072979, 0.018604328855872154, 0.020160062238574028, 0.00850935373455286, -0.04416555166244507, -0.03662282973527908, -0.03319919481873512, 0.029584772884845734, -0.02596685290336609, 0.00729602575302124, -0.04246259853243828, -0.04478819668292999, 0.006441897712647915, -0.02722960337996483, -0.027535628527402878, -0.0076986695639789104, -0.03011702001094818, -0.008399143815040588, -0.033523138612508774, 0.037585701793432236, -0.022215934470295906, -0.02332528680562973, -0.002224999014288187, -0.027219368144869804, 0.03512914851307869, 0.00414425041526556, -0.03475434333086014, 0.00021637194731738418, 0.07193844765424728, -0.019687751308083534, 0.019021952524781227, -0.009513315744698048, 0.013289153575897217, 0.034886639565229416, 0.03530467301607132, -0.03606199845671654, -0.00670961569994688, 0.02640918456017971, -0.03254677727818489, -0.007999802008271217, 0.015919625759124756, 0.006085909903049469, 0.008570869453251362, 0.030706709250807762, -0.0017324859509244561, -0.00295220036059618, 0.025196272879838943, -0.022323807701468468, 0.009238006547093391, -0.029321830719709396, -0.009532312862575054, 0.011048778891563416, 0.02995322085916996, -0.010891429148614407, -0.009973101317882538, -0.01736484281718731, 0.017698947340250015, 0.05326969176530838, -0.015366137027740479, 0.04758463054895401, -0.0158537644892931, -0.041602231562137604, 0.0010848274687305093, 0.0007697568507865071, -0.035227660089731216, 0.025863977149128914, 0.061520449817180634, -0.010508785024285316, 0.04913722351193428, 0.017520179972052574, 0.01029130443930626, -0.08969556540250778, -0.032844383269548416, 0.004510727245360613, 0.025378206744790077, 0.0003934162377845496, -0.051244329661130905, 0.0011084883008152246, 0.01598530262708664, -0.0676131471991539, 0.011533844284713268, 0.007822566665709019, -0.006683558691293001, -0.01169534120708704, 0.006613795645534992, -0.02316018007695675, -0.0031662413384765387, 0.022257478907704353, 0.02662798762321472, 0.004394391551613808, 0.0015808801399543881, 0.031798649579286575, -0.0005257715820334852, -0.00867345929145813, 0.017071349546313286, 0.020210588350892067, -0.06057455390691757, -0.0034898538142442703, -0.02563340589404106, -0.057940367609262466, 0.01711558736860752, -0.037726081907749176, 0.031535904854536057, 0.006957095582038164, 0.03851602226495743, 0.03780185803771019, 0.05683426558971405, 0.005641395691782236, -0.017017368227243423, -0.03990842029452324, -0.04280246049165726, -0.01765286922454834, 0.05583253875374794, -0.03737274929881096, -0.019752761349081993, 0.010676803067326546, -0.02797752618789673, -0.019056372344493866, -0.0065076290629804134, -0.029752124100923538, -0.002098195254802704, 0.016287745907902718, 0.005547635722905397, -0.006615974474698305, -0.01120020356029272, 0.004809245467185974, -0.023316655308008194, -0.0006594461156055331, 0.05950064957141876, 0.07023202627897263, -0.053112760186195374, 0.004284978378564119, -0.02230599895119667, -0.006561021786183119, -0.012959216721355915, 0.011082989163696766, 0.00022822046594228595, -0.05168793722987175, -0.020945854485034943, -0.02416585385799408, 0.013941040262579918, -0.0000963041529757902, -0.005042987875640392, 0.008534896187484264, 0.05110407620668411, -0.0017712742555886507, 0.00720056751742959, 0.010206878185272217, -0.011977240443229675, -0.010160909965634346, -0.0721960961818695, 0.0736747682094574, 0.015426580794155598, -0.013488895259797573, -0.01819564402103424, -0.017424730584025383, -0.10409260541200638, 0.03611445799469948, 0.08298361301422119, 0.036192066967487335, -0.006773033645004034, -0.011298081837594509, 0.03241715952754021, -0.013999337330460548, -0.06294214725494385, 0.06651769578456879, 0.00046941774780862033, -0.0055632987059652805, 0.005323325749486685, -0.021873904392123222, 0.0054567125625908375, 0.016165107488632202, 0.007466735318303108, -0.06603679805994034, 0.05502806603908539, -0.012974275276064873, -0.003113361308351159, 0.034993767738342285, 0.02251514606177807, -0.027860814705491066, 0.03319885954260826, -0.017821818590164185, 0.025073925033211708, 0.01979769580066204, -0.008241193369030952, -0.028605110943317413, 0.024115022271871567, -0.013327601365745068, -0.02158334106206894, 0.02459952048957348, 0.01591094210743904, -0.013454655185341835, -0.03598657250404358, 0.017400581389665604, 0.016981590539216995, -0.040650200098752975, 0.0003047892823815346, 0.04964554309844971, 0.015931034460663795, 0.03179320693016052, -0.01117141917347908, 0.02015615813434124, 0.025395531207323074, -0.0033715686295181513, -0.028711996972560883, 0.008226266130805016, 0.04347890615463257, 0.003648639190942049, -0.042878955602645874, 0.026065589860081673, -0.050575368106365204, 0.05510867387056351, 0.004291146993637085, 0.00021821149857714772, -0.03290741890668869, -0.02584635093808174, 0.012169920839369297, -0.006238461937755346, 0.0012437660479918122, -0.022566111758351326, -0.0038615483790636063, 0.07274524122476578, -0.04919186234474182, 0.012355729006230831, -0.058784183114767075, -0.03571506217122078, 0.008656611666083336, 0.0034916894510388374, 0.033018819987773895, 0.03563249111175537, 0.0007888000691309571, 0.03783538192510605, 0.006479160860180855, -0.01806926168501377, 0.011007307097315788, -0.04433877766132355, 0.009692673571407795, -0.030185097828507423, -0.00014808165724389255, -0.008249885402619839, -0.02151848003268242, -0.03281537815928459, -0.009967946447432041, 0.011774474754929543, 0.024765782058238983, 0.021229736506938934, 0.0037210858426988125, -0.03674044832587242, 0.0008667322690598667, 0.058269668370485306, -0.06988053023815155, -0.045132964849472046, -0.03869563341140747, 0.01011706329882145, -0.012241749092936516, -0.034726832062006 ]
<p>Given a hierarchical model $p(x|\phi,\theta)$, I want a two stage process to fit the model. First, fix a handful of hyperparameters $\theta$, and then do Bayesian inference on the rest of the parameters $\phi$. For fixing the hyperparameters I am considering two options.</p> <ol> <li>Use <strong>Empirical Bayes (EB)</strong> and maximize the marginal likelihood $p(\mbox{all data}|\theta)$ (integrating out the rest of the model which contains high dimensional parameters).</li> <li>Use <strong>Cross Validation (CV)</strong> techniques such as $k$-fold cross validation to choose $\theta$ that maximizes the likelihood $p(\mbox{test data}|\mbox{training data}, \theta)$.</li> </ol> <p>The advantage of EB is that I can use all data at once, while for CV I need to (potentially) compute the model likelihood multiple times and search for $\theta$. The performance of EB and CV are comparable in many cases, and often EB is faster to estimate.</p> <p>Question: Is there a theoretical foundation that links the two (say, EB and CV are the same in the limit of large data)? Or links EB to some generalizability criterion such as empirical risk? Can someone point to a good reference material?</p>
73,634
[ -0.0649595707654953, 0.01904875785112381, 0.02336650900542736, -0.023160601034760475, 0.02099786140024662, -0.014965257607400417, -0.010422877967357635, -0.012351338751614094, 0.06596575677394867, -0.027096351608633995, 0.04372153431177139, 0.05301859229803085, 0.09240704774856567, 0.02160593308508396, 0.01281841192394495, 0.02748045139014721, -0.005128367803990841, -0.005440948531031609, -0.01069802138954401, 0.013577294535934925, -0.01301723625510931, -0.0034982094075530767, 0.04056708142161369, -0.0438845157623291, -0.028108352795243263, 0.033739108592271805, 0.046479612588882446, -0.018421387299895287, -0.027359891682863235, 0.051324352622032166, 0.007775760255753994, -0.03637688606977463, -0.01070010382682085, 0.059857092797756195, -0.015300238505005836, -0.008915113285183907, 0.00012180796329630539, -0.045658908784389496, -0.014199309051036835, 0.04167517274618149, -0.02258225902915001, -0.043295666575431824, 0.00975017435848713, 0.019109273329377174, 0.00921360682696104, 0.010817917995154858, -0.04213907569646835, -0.022194501012563705, 0.0243462473154068, -0.04500843584537506, 0.05080609396100044, 0.0034718301612883806, 0.021041009575128555, 0.04899588227272034, -0.030913008376955986, -0.05418940633535385, 0.05534248799085617, 0.07567805796861649, -0.029712380841374397, -0.053703371435403824, -0.04456295445561409, -0.030440062284469604, -0.013511820696294308, -0.014799123629927635, -0.043401625007390976, 0.036796968430280685, -0.00020283513003960252, -0.019934147596359253, 0.025141799822449684, -0.007078572176396847, 0.03311176598072052, 0.008788537234067917, 0.03462660685181618, 0.0008419161313213408, 0.025223946198821068, 0.0015442267758771777, 0.015342095866799355, 0.0379183255136013, 0.0340317077934742, 0.02343728393316269, -0.009813042357563972, -0.008247671648859978, 0.020119955763220787, 0.037560731172561646, 0.0026748571544885635, 0.026363646611571312, 0.07388076931238174, 0.009662323631346226, -0.016138361766934395, 0.000108257845568005, -0.03613637387752533, 0.017140254378318787, 0.04464470222592354, -0.03981632739305496, -0.03699299320578575, 0.04630317538976669, -0.018469879403710365, 0.01600700058043003, 0.014366872608661652, 0.003370768390595913, -0.0018601438496261835, -0.043951164931058884, 0.01456520427018404, 0.04115135595202446, -0.026859713718295097, -0.005060391500592232, 0.006531359627842903, -0.01754537597298622, -0.03560706600546837, -0.01616337150335312, -0.044700123369693756, 0.04075055941939354, -0.028138289228081703, 0.026387305930256844, 0.034891277551651, 0.006995855364948511, 0.010094532743096352, -0.05219876021146774, 0.06390292197465897, 0.038899101316928864, 0.06479069590568542, -0.016462670639157295, 0.03707462549209595, -0.015641698613762856, -0.04988620802760124, -0.0018653532024472952, 0.005699596367776394, -0.012548656202852726, -0.047947779297828674, 0.02324327640235424, -0.010259518399834633, -0.014659224078059196, 0.027113016694784164, 0.013031460344791412, 0.014563457109034061, 0.014753911644220352, -0.054466355592012405, -0.0714169517159462, 0.011942338198423386, 0.017274845391511917, -0.005470693577080965, -0.0683673769235611, -0.007948833517730236, 0.03177522495388985, 0.041832976043224335, 0.011401725932955742, 0.058101896196603775, 0.015862874686717987, 0.032312896102666855, -0.003674327628687024, -0.028886524960398674, -0.044580865651369095, 0.005259470548480749, 0.04428195580840111, -0.03169335052371025, -0.1014568954706192, 0.019926203414797783, 0.020262954756617546, -0.017099499702453613, 0.030242040753364563, 0.05407541245222092, -0.016209283843636513, -0.031056707724928856, -0.03881506249308586, 0.043167661875486374, -0.007943321950733662, 0.07407844066619873, 0.008070845156908035, 0.049383774399757385, 0.02762100286781788, -0.01222380343824625, 0.011275761760771275, 0.04360831156373024, 0.021892771124839783, 0.007921510376036167, 0.002871806500479579, 0.012910746969282627, -0.0180637426674366, 0.04138357564806938, 0.01116831973195076, -0.005389063153415918, -0.031248075887560844, -0.01621704176068306, -0.029704030603170395, -0.001212421921081841, 0.045824404805898666, -0.0077452389523386955, -0.06400199234485626, 0.017285406589508057, -0.061824340373277664, -0.0709589496254921, -0.06586911529302597, 0.009529570117592812, -0.019647132605314255, -0.008025307208299637, 0.11667695641517639, -0.03024732880294323, 0.00031353867962025106, -0.03827209398150444, 0.008502919226884842, -0.023023247718811035, -0.012459072284400463, 0.03491118922829628, -0.04702727496623993, 0.00889371708035469, 0.037408266216516495, 0.026194579899311066, -0.02086084708571434, 0.04814356938004494, -0.019240500405430794, -0.08182083070278168, -0.0013323994353413582, -0.06821652501821518, 0.009383339434862137, -0.0019564705435186625, -0.0019125206163153052, -0.009481309913098812, 0.007175654172897339, -0.0016781905433163047, 0.0036740165669471025, -0.0593026801943779, 0.07748420536518097, 0.05550297349691391, 0.025685759261250496, 0.029119519516825676, 0.026782430708408356, 0.017478130757808685, 0.018298687413334846, 0.0012061387533321977, -0.03220211714506149, -0.04879385605454445, 0.01579831726849079, 0.04593146964907646, -0.019097143784165382, -0.017885131761431694, 0.03103489987552166, 0.021616248413920403, 0.01611725427210331, -0.004072272684425116, 0.029541824012994766, -0.019557397812604904, -0.010754699818789959, 0.03328722342848778, 0.018376188352704048, -0.0411018468439579, 0.03402525931596756, 0.010677104815840721, -0.006557706743478775, 0.02944132126867771, -0.020123951137065887, 0.010726559907197952, 0.040242381393909454, -0.0010133659234270453, -0.038674257695674896, -0.027294958010315895, -0.04285784810781479, 0.053079575300216675, -0.028280790895223618, 0.013925069943070412, 0.0029434463940560818, -0.0007979503134265542, 0.0056073106825351715, -0.024129269644618034, 0.0035953123588114977, 0.04111136496067047, 0.018739765509963036, -0.012499120086431503, 0.020989276468753815, 0.032147251069545746, -0.012831096537411213, 0.011655104346573353, -0.037295278161764145, -0.040979836136102676, -0.03378579765558243, 0.025456532835960388, 0.025320978835225105, -0.005152207333594561, 0.037228550761938095, -0.019925566390156746, -0.06363677978515625, -0.00881050806492567, -0.036628544330596924, 0.020867377519607544, -0.013080388307571411, -0.020368922501802444, 0.01110265776515007, -0.05447037145495415, 0.01408857200294733, 0.04081716388463974, 0.0029094049241393805, -0.010560544207692146, -0.02029242180287838, 0.01975739561021328, -0.042328786104917526, -0.026636211201548576, 0.003207105677574873, -0.015712959691882133, -0.0020310007967054844, -0.04399915412068367, 0.037820376455783844, 0.03302713483572006, -0.0164871234446764, 0.02829124964773655, 0.005126007832586765, -0.03462471440434456, -0.004170425236225128, 0.0023718001320958138, -0.023511027917265892, -0.002171659143641591, 0.03712107613682747, 0.05848315358161926, -0.016927430406212807, -0.005950822029262781, -0.10487990826368332, -0.06113334000110626, 0.027014685794711113, -0.001420211629010737, 0.02315978892147541, 0.014200255274772644, -0.0034844696056097746, 0.042761825025081635, 0.019158462062478065, -0.024452539160847664, -0.06422749906778336, 0.04264878109097481, -0.03492468595504761, -0.008841205388307571, -0.01914287358522415, 0.031533364206552505, 0.005889791063964367, 0.008436421863734722, 0.00014218097203411162, -0.012354717589914799, 0.028165170922875404, 0.014131943695247173, 0.026141509413719177, 0.025829659774899483, 0.019552480429410934, -0.024615421891212463, -0.03687841817736626, 0.007005950901657343, -0.0056680189445614815, 0.008502557873725891, -0.004877880215644836, 0.031070154160261154, 0.011623536236584187, -0.008468421176075935, 0.015400799922645092, -0.018423661589622498, -0.018455971032381058, -0.023903265595436096, 0.01750553399324417, 0.01882007345557213, -0.03213083744049072, -0.009366556070744991, 0.03098389133810997, -0.0007495498866774142, -0.032746683806180954, 0.0028920182958245277, 0.03553510457277298, 0.06050333380699158, -0.04425680264830589, -0.024878304451704025, -0.03570300713181496, 0.029202260076999664, 0.013487037271261215, 0.016913821920752525, -0.02118758298456669, 0.026184652000665665, 0.046117011457681656, 0.00807806383818388, -0.02101108431816101, -0.05068783462047577, 0.00018721542437560856, -0.046725668013095856, 0.012991922907531261, -0.017580056563019753, 0.027315208688378334, 0.0022267696913331747, 0.023036137223243713, 0.014480973593890667, -0.007857215590775013, 0.03271377086639404, 0.034025777131319046, -0.10187172889709473, -0.00929277203977108, 0.0034938144963234663, 0.013689517043530941, -0.004987054038792849, 0.004646638873964548, 0.06426975131034851, 0.003515471937134862, 0.000011829652066808194, -0.0006756567745469511, 0.05652797222137451, -0.013753529638051987, 0.026214824989438057, -0.04159647971391678, -0.023838050663471222, 0.004505685064941645, -0.007531668525189161, 0.03632873669266701, -0.009692548774182796, 0.003961702808737755, 0.06017008423805237, -0.01926386170089245, 0.011486797593533993, -0.017897892743349075, 0.03501434624195099, -0.002323567634448409, 0.017664114013314247, 0.011635991744697094, 0.04013403505086899, -0.028267988935112953, 0.04167021065950394, -0.009317925199866295, 0.03839036822319031, 0.05503600463271141, -0.019775941967964172, -0.019076459109783173, -0.04341265931725502, -0.05177600309252739, -0.014456446282565594, 0.030863497406244278, 0.00886609684675932, -0.022035794332623482, 0.05337483435869217, 0.023840131238102913, -0.02345370128750801, 0.017710868269205093, 0.053994469344615936, 0.0035640248097479343, 0.004108957480639219, 0.005527178291231394, -0.03502725064754486, -0.01881377585232258, 0.0011720225447788835, 0.027604244649410248, -0.0012743647675961256, -0.031013185158371925, -0.029757795855402946, 0.021777847781777382, -0.036896903067827225, -0.030885696411132812, -0.007698048371821642, 0.022368798032402992, 0.00658787926658988, 0.0054681203328073025, -0.02894781529903412, 0.021584324538707733, 0.03015892207622528, 0.06615258753299713, 0.020661139860749245, -0.004999246448278427, -0.06131564825773239, 0.018286550417542458, 0.055089809000492096, 0.004983172751963139, -0.04212355241179466, -0.026477644219994545, -0.034558866173028946, -0.024472955614328384, 0.0390680730342865, 0.004005972295999527, -0.012699740007519722, -0.010841341689229012, -0.018291087821125984, -0.02890479750931263, -0.0394008569419384, -0.028393875807523727, -0.007825201377272606, 0.012482762336730957, 0.02858898974955082, -0.006267075892537832, -0.004106990061700344, -0.002465648576617241, 0.028916222974658012, -0.0035869739949703217, 0.05067318677902222, -0.0023273597471415997, -0.06122564151883125, 0.013396567665040493, -0.0013792156241834164, -0.01846657134592533, -0.07141119241714478, -0.003371461294591427, -0.0070771146565675735, -0.035699810832738876, 0.011343258433043957, -0.009928438812494278, -0.06807858496904373, 0.02936498261988163, -0.00857976172119379, -0.055160894989967346, 0.02903258427977562, 0.025950757786631584, 0.048928648233413696, 0.021945076063275337, 0.049169693142175674, 0.05961763113737106, -0.022237207740545273, 0.00959553848952055, -0.020442942157387733, -0.03714534267783165, -0.0026058549992740154, -0.0357808843255043, -0.013560863211750984, -0.046066220849752426, -0.012991202995181084, -0.03360055759549141, 0.05863785743713379, 0.021410470828413963, 0.04434722289443016, -0.06754544377326965, -0.036715876311063766, -0.0005610423977486789, 0.019826797768473625, -0.00418064696714282, -0.02315530553460121, 0.001575532485730946, 0.04487970843911171, 0.016883285716176033, -0.0017953268252313137, 0.021578270941972733, -0.021758927032351494, 0.04338165745139122, -0.013894973322749138, -0.05531862750649452, -0.003248281078413129, -0.030498582869768143, 0.007389983162283897, 0.05619868263602257, -0.023144928738474846, 0.04149291291832924, -0.017006855458021164, 0.05798102542757988, -0.013144660741090775, -0.03421062231063843, -0.003771749557927251, 0.03358343243598938, 0.009869738481938839, 0.04871666058897972, -0.04163746535778046, 0.015314300544559956, -0.025297552347183228, -0.012133816257119179, -0.052621982991695404, -0.020929429680109024, 0.028313137590885162, -0.0032370327971875668, -0.005802490282803774, -0.04904177784919739, 0.03055516816675663, -0.02778332680463791, -0.03962467983365059, 0.008485223166644573, 0.07296869158744812, 0.0030001907143741846, 0.008897150866687298, 0.007401228882372379, 0.05423158407211304, 0.048844967037439346, 0.03464256972074509, 0.03490849956870079, 0.010867106728255749, 0.0023119887337088585, 0.040651820600032806, 0.02096743695437908, -0.005378264933824539, -0.02073969505727291, 0.018095852807164192, -0.032936450093984604, 0.022323651239275932, 0.02464461885392666, 0.001109360484406352, -0.028006328269839287, 0.03957291319966316, -0.02439303509891033, 0.02205318585038185, -0.003858832409605384, -0.0053043365478515625, -0.009173717349767685, 0.01424003392457962, -0.02807256206870079, -0.0065470002591609955, -0.007273986469954252, -0.037573330104351044, 0.03146584704518318, -0.0011595028918236494, -0.027416616678237915, 0.03214295953512192, 0.029638083651661873, -0.03707899898290634, 0.017746441066265106, 0.0030746678821742535, 0.011502835899591446, 0.022990955039858818, -0.005835790652781725, 0.009379936382174492, 0.0429287888109684, 0.017857085913419724, -0.03493214026093483, -0.03582419455051422, -0.026660677045583725, -0.026730211451649666, 0.040625277906656265, -0.027873490005731583, 0.06860828399658203, 0.016624346375465393, -0.004653859883546829, -0.016421232372522354, -0.027210379019379616, -0.009343721903860569, -0.0313376858830452, -0.003605189034715295, 0.04212284833192825, -0.01038685254752636, -0.0013860971666872501, 0.045657142996788025, 0.0038057507481426, 0.031172996386885643, 0.009179695509374142, 0.0048782555386424065, 0.009803415276110172, 0.023562809452414513, -0.07382611185312271, -0.014951806515455246, 0.05807013437151909, -0.07459157705307007, 0.008919679559767246, -0.03818868473172188, -0.024299681186676025, 0.023260071873664856, 0.061865776777267456, -0.01409468799829483, -0.019677303731441498, -0.03762168437242508, -0.07680905610322952, 0.023011088371276855, 0.03666452690958977, 0.006354558281600475, 0.010698492638766766, -0.00980439968407154, 0.03358892723917961, 0.033495549112558365, 0.019051240757107735, -0.041244685649871826, -0.07517436146736145, -0.05671091005206108, -0.0049345907755196095, -0.023934371769428253, 0.030379055067896843, 0.02549065463244915, -0.011222724802792072, 0.027567094191908836, -0.0315919853746891, 0.02383779175579548, 0.011702521704137325, 0.02379261702299118, -0.024737829342484474, 0.033980101346969604, 0.005778937600553036, -0.0014546564780175686, 0.005044459830969572, -0.0020312853157520294, 0.10959040373563766, 0.09495680779218674, 0.04513837769627571, -0.060359206050634384, 0.032911401242017746, -0.0059575280174613, -0.0006930774543434381, -0.02399282716214657, -0.004083395004272461, 0.014687912538647652, -0.02816886268556118, -0.00029243816970847547, 0.07291190326213837, 0.01743330806493759, -0.01442159153521061, 0.05141911655664444, -0.03854221850633621, -0.001657365239225328, 0.01146409660577774, 0.001962454291060567, -0.02029150351881981, -0.0008483285782858729, 0.006769353989511728, -0.009467353112995625, -0.010886052623391151, -0.013936182484030724, -0.03202233836054802, -0.031153954565525055, -0.013324758037924767, 0.0025636975187808275, -0.016262290999293327, -0.016307352110743523, -0.002143871271982789, 0.004915426019579172, 0.04271962121129036, 0.001162711181677878, -0.01276237890124321, -0.0038470514118671417, 0.0358671136200428, 0.03174140676856041, 0.028346724808216095, -0.016739092767238617, 0.029206670820713043, -0.008877058513462543, -0.02509106881916523, -0.03436833620071411, -0.0294930599629879, 0.05261841043829918, -0.005629671271890402, 0.01058074738830328, -0.01475229300558567, -0.013156415894627571, 0.000029113034543115646, 0.005738248582929373, -0.019579123705625534, 0.0018059767317026854, 0.019480112940073013, -0.01784415915608406, 0.009482286870479584, -0.03992379829287529, 0.03839396312832832, 0.012647462077438831, 0.049653537571430206, 0.009741551242768764, -0.029080107808113098, -0.02319711074233055, -0.03153272718191147, 0.05259829759597778, -0.002739126095548272, -0.02438787743449211, 0.015217669308185577, -0.011753898113965988, -0.043950404971838, -0.03347393497824669, 0.016108401119709015, -0.01886586844921112, 0.023327095434069633, 0.013973832130432129, -0.04446299001574516, -0.013949377462267876, -0.051279839128255844, 0.000760634895414114, -0.002356131561100483, -0.0054631708189845085, -0.05143197998404503, 0.00863730814307928, -0.016955118626356125, -0.0018198373727500439, 0.02854793891310692, -0.004513069521635771, 0.0016691889613866806, 0.053054358810186386, 0.013015578500926495, -0.06512005627155304, -0.042599644511938095, -0.03923879936337471, -0.010164427570998669, -0.00027242014766670763, -0.0015791069017723203, 0.04700753092765808, -0.012333433143794537, 0.04683474823832512, -0.008160370402038097, 0.02111394889652729, -0.0021320597734302282, 0.00981737021356821, -0.011714993976056576, -0.03891559690237045, -0.021936459466814995, 0.020219625905156136, 0.008344773203134537, -0.010464577935636044, -0.004155813716351986, -0.04416149854660034, -0.0033145591150969267, 0.04023260623216629, -0.04348202422261238, -0.020978840067982674, 0.014873023144900799, -0.025770554319024086, 0.037526004016399384, -0.0387088917195797, 0.03588438034057617, 0.006510562263429165, 0.014967388473451138, -0.014451250433921814, -0.02532680332660675, 0.036907561123371124, 0.029195671901106834, -0.034168317914009094, -0.05123676732182503, 0.006465555168688297, 0.015124145895242691, 0.028234517201781273, 0.01836620643734932, -0.013764441013336182, -0.009360436350107193, 0.03665979951620102, -0.03217453137040138, -0.023618359118700027, 0.04231959581375122, -0.06302664428949356, -0.020893320441246033, 0.007727323565632105, -0.003473574761301279, 0.02747223898768425, 0.0337686613202095, -0.0035848391707986593, -0.006921264808624983, -0.005769661162048578, -0.041676584631204605, -0.015383194200694561, 0.013937409035861492, -0.00464704679325223, -0.034662291407585144, -0.0038747494108974934, 0.03763683885335922, 0.028181860223412514, -0.010227980092167854, 0.05096250772476196, -0.0025956786703318357, 0.017952531576156616, -0.008594121783971786, 0.016938069835305214, -0.014268030412495136, 0.040166035294532776, 0.005007140804082155, -0.023185767233371735, 0.03987337648868561, 0.055976126343011856, -0.024236898869276047, 0.03865046426653862, 0.0021227954421192408, 0.009820162318646908, -0.09353449195623398, -0.024666452780365944, 0.009730637073516846, 0.015005088411271572, 0.009277761913836002, -0.038642339408397675, -0.003526928834617138, 0.02713078260421753, -0.044601161032915115, 0.031927675008773804, 0.0165879987180233, 0.014200594276189804, -0.03318371996283531, 0.006648344453424215, -0.02347656339406967, -0.01709994301199913, 0.009256964549422264, 0.022100631147623062, 0.03612397611141205, 0.0007805443601682782, 0.028896845877170563, -0.03639402240514755, -0.014092499390244484, 0.020220553502440453, 0.010563074611127377, -0.0568106584250927, 0.025800464674830437, -0.010782438330352306, -0.017523011192679405, 0.03235776349902153, 0.026831556111574173, 0.04258827120065689, 0.01603214628994465, 0.017040150240063667, 0.01804087683558464, 0.0398714616894722, 0.029012633487582207, -0.002333172829821706, -0.001190579729154706, 0.01699214056134224, 0.000981294782832265, 0.031864069402217865, -0.02931676246225834, 0.003593211993575096, 0.023419782519340515, -0.013201167806982994, 0.0014758063480257988, 0.023316780105233192, 0.015262841247022152, -0.029952453449368477, 0.030464861541986465, -0.03977157548069954, 0.0046429880894720554, 0.016668768599629402, -0.016039662063121796, -0.04808342829346657, 0.006757807917892933, 0.00909984577447176, 0.0024505590554326773, 0.008118667639791965, 0.019479112699627876, -0.01765042543411255, -0.03824056684970856, 0.0009026890038512647, 0.027500685304403305, -0.01283746212720871, -0.023834511637687683, -0.013984311372041702, -0.00154977070633322, -0.007808003108948469, -0.04374450817704201, -0.015578582882881165, -0.03766239807009697, 0.047803979367017746, -0.04162485525012016, 0.04968814179301262, 0.014007057063281536, -0.009007088840007782, -0.01274261623620987, -0.0430864617228508, 0.06035831943154335, -0.010150291956961155, -0.03485039249062538, -0.00602720957249403, 0.007104760035872459, -0.003302234224975109, 0.0032958309166133404, 0.0889010950922966, 0.004058909602463245, 0.029674263671040535, -0.009858053177595139, 0.026704924181103706, -0.012063110247254372, -0.07873573899269104, 0.02366947941482067, -0.03128411993384361, -0.03672610595822334, 0.002219589427113533, 0.01835539937019348, 0.03007088229060173, 0.020763607695698738, 0.022511381655931473, -0.018380269408226013, 0.00135058315936476, 0.01869053952395916, 0.014266140758991241, 0.010265389457345009, -0.010456543415784836, -0.0034385505132377148, 0.045590221881866455, -0.0029626330360770226, 0.009234225377440453, -0.0044257729314267635, -0.018474996089935303, -0.039994414895772934, 0.03938625752925873, -0.043645694851875305, -0.043922897428274155, -0.003049643710255623, 0.03161497786641121, -0.04189935699105263, -0.04065052792429924, -0.01363478135317564, 0.040887799113988876, -0.05119470879435539, -0.006666061468422413, 0.062070246785879135, 0.03091728314757347, 0.052814334630966187, -0.00915595330297947, 0.004034634213894606, 0.037762731313705444, 0.010272457264363766, 0.029612021520733833, 0.016952956095337868, 0.09419368207454681, 0.004933886229991913, 0.0321790874004364, 0.023993398994207382, -0.0009804220171645284, 0.028194278478622437, -0.03226882591843605, 0.03402943164110184, -0.03159359097480774, -0.04804535582661629, 0.01642569527029991, -0.012126046232879162, -0.021791517734527588, -0.029942678287625313, -0.029468543827533722, 0.07411040365695953, -0.03527572378516197, -0.0372045524418354, -0.013463174924254417, 0.014039043337106705, 0.006924683693796396, 0.015690023079514503, 0.018731018528342247, 0.001955508254468441, 0.014113054610788822, -0.012766447849571705, -0.011789499782025814, -0.004784742835909128, -0.002515785163268447, -0.005829549860209227, 0.020872635766863823, -0.0005819144425913692, -0.025577371940016747, -0.03643447905778885, -0.03627372160553932, -0.021824607625603676, -0.041295554488897324, 0.00390453590080142, 0.05246715992689133, 0.02551797404885292, 0.019423915073275566, -0.02150595933198929, 0.010281017050147057, 0.028727278113365173, -0.09909551590681076, 0.0015739441150799394, -0.025538014248013496, -0.027800336480140686, -0.0027820540126413107, 0.0014994984958320856 ]
<p>I am developing a method to do something with permutation testing. I have two permutation / randomization schemes and do not know which one is better than the other. Can I find the confidence interval for each permutation scheme? If so, is the one with the narrower confidence region better?</p>
29,254
[ -0.015522943809628487, -0.04439004883170128, -0.04537276178598404, -0.014632821083068848, 0.013880176469683647, 0.017132483422756195, 0.018954932689666748, -0.026579475030303, 0.01669483259320259, -0.009805988520383835, 0.03322109952569008, 0.04561480134725571, -0.001532641937956214, 0.016393572092056274, 0.008662233129143715, 0.021861623972654343, -0.02299916371703148, 0.00850436557084322, 0.009100835770368576, 0.001554923364892602, 0.0010989727452397346, -0.009548233821988106, 0.021332086995244026, -0.023303093388676643, -0.04200921580195427, 0.003499644808471203, 0.03547244518995285, -0.03581489250063896, 0.01803361251950264, 0.0702110081911087, -0.06261111050844193, 0.0002419453376205638, 0.009930100291967392, 0.06907229870557785, 0.005442815367132425, -0.017916996031999588, -0.0105736730620265, -0.032481759786605835, -0.02816622704267502, 0.019999762997031212, -0.062225256115198135, 0.0018735304474830627, -0.02891567535698414, 0.015533232130110264, 0.0272380281239748, 0.04124781861901283, -0.02055749110877514, -0.029471972957253456, 0.014330627396702766, -0.05922771617770195, 0.06822384148836136, -0.018937190994620323, 0.006380394101142883, 0.044099703431129456, 0.004446328151971102, 0.016258293762803078, 0.02402327209711075, 0.07162972539663315, -0.02876194566488266, -0.03165736049413681, -0.014070683158934116, -0.06654560565948486, 0.01436951570212841, -0.026825739070773125, -0.04961629956960678, 0.024030283093452454, -0.022396406158804893, -0.004529386293143034, 0.019869742915034294, -0.007347726728767157, -0.005803790409117937, 0.03522573411464691, 0.07138243317604065, -0.010980372317135334, 0.023873820900917053, -0.03459318354725838, 0.02774970605969429, 0.0052470862865448, 0.039291366934776306, 0.03091593086719513, -0.0051609124056994915, 0.04201636463403702, 0.03248527646064758, 0.053108468651771545, 0.003563817124813795, -0.03229023516178131, 0.05181048810482025, -0.00955407414585352, -0.0021248655393719673, 0.07219388335943222, -0.03442353010177612, -0.017092883586883545, 0.033896107226610184, 0.009821231476962566, -0.014132555574178696, 0.01937260664999485, -0.03199642896652222, 0.023377906531095505, -0.0014680555323138833, -0.014934445731341839, -0.011574511416256428, -0.018755922093987465, 0.016145991161465645, 0.06378298252820969, 0.00846839975565672, 0.00680034514516592, -0.031169632449746132, 0.019458089023828506, -0.014293341897428036, 0.004402854014188051, 0.003663128474727273, 0.040111418813467026, -0.012215416878461838, 0.025772100314497948, 0.020025484263896942, -0.004910071846097708, -0.00450033089146018, -0.022032219916582108, 0.0694296658039093, 0.06356978416442871, 0.042509645223617554, -0.01744450069963932, 0.016565771773457527, -0.046652652323246, -0.01768859662115574, 0.013113748282194138, -0.01411040686070919, 0.0035734062548726797, -0.038468603044748306, 0.05886153131723404, -0.016625111922621727, -0.03075435198843479, 0.03252500295639038, -0.002691636560484767, 0.02095109038054943, -0.025843361392617226, -0.0760500580072403, -0.060303620994091034, 0.027823979035019875, -0.0228781308978796, -0.010573295876383781, -0.04637885466217995, 0.003653110470622778, 0.040600232779979706, 0.03216155618429184, 0.005860442761331797, 0.05335978418588638, -0.03277203068137169, 0.03281864523887634, 0.021507468074560165, -0.02954666130244732, 0.022413909435272217, -0.02403699979186058, -0.010764019563794136, 0.009440260007977486, -0.07630442827939987, 0.02312287874519825, 0.021821025758981705, 0.00850171223282814, -0.03673451021313667, 0.015315381810069084, -0.010851128958165646, -0.01665983349084854, -0.031158432364463806, 0.0314461924135685, 0.005383182782679796, 0.08727411180734634, 0.0033475090749561787, 0.03428894653916359, 0.012099400162696838, -0.011295542120933533, 0.0037595280446112156, 0.028757667168974876, 0.0003104516363237053, 0.05575646087527275, -0.05045558139681816, 0.002156716538593173, -0.018499301746487617, 0.051088713109493256, 0.007044774014502764, -0.00895324070006609, 0.010248356498777866, 0.0012095508864149451, -0.0043376050889492035, 0.011072344146668911, 0.031454164534807205, 0.03084651008248329, -0.013772694393992424, 0.026063302531838417, -0.06358727067708969, -0.013575566001236439, -0.05881889909505844, -0.046472836285829544, 0.03554926812648773, -0.053277820348739624, 0.04902656003832817, 0.00845283828675747, 0.03365455940365791, -0.00201690592803061, -0.0468788668513298, -0.03082076460123062, -0.0030369325540959835, 0.003344284137710929, -0.03928645700216293, 0.003769628005102277, 0.05188824608922005, 0.03129909560084343, -0.05727902799844742, 0.05569618195295334, -0.04155457019805908, -0.048879094421863556, -0.0020592231303453445, -0.026758769527077675, 0.029224013909697533, 0.010849501937627792, -0.03792132809758186, 0.002644113963469863, 0.0175578985363245, -0.0033041771966964006, 0.05499713867902756, -0.06614404171705246, 0.06961514055728912, 0.04810115322470665, 0.02621358446776867, 0.015069015324115753, -0.016006626188755035, 0.038120683282613754, -0.001167106325738132, -0.007051329594105482, -0.021816985681653023, -0.04459865391254425, 0.0019105933606624603, 0.060835834592580795, -0.02126961387693882, -0.04786860942840576, 0.00887968298047781, 0.07078061997890472, -0.01359150093048811, -0.006317634601145983, 0.04192829504609108, 0.009089025668799877, -0.012631542980670929, -0.013242318294942379, 0.06591904908418655, 0.0327887237071991, 0.05271267518401146, 0.003523176768794656, -0.01955408975481987, 0.018506640568375587, 0.03519553318619728, -0.032712243497371674, 0.03879852220416069, 0.0051478976383805275, -0.008380901999771595, -0.005893168970942497, -0.06420779973268509, -0.0008052248740568757, -0.028821196407079697, -0.002059210790321231, 0.02011488936841488, -0.013297638855874538, 0.016514534130692482, 0.03114122711122036, -0.020671533420681953, 0.016647176817059517, 0.02609197236597538, -0.012991225346922874, -0.0006631361320614815, 0.036403026431798935, -0.021770263090729713, 0.0029237226117402315, -0.023063234984874725, 0.026192286983132362, -0.02072751522064209, 0.00835387222468853, 0.027377396821975708, -0.03427910432219505, 0.029761962592601776, -0.03261509910225868, -0.0012141942279413342, 0.0013534750323742628, -0.013432720676064491, 0.01729092188179493, -0.012776806019246578, -0.07860883325338364, -0.0029122026171535254, -0.023613866418600082, -0.042146142572164536, 0.02847553789615631, -0.04423004016280174, -0.035551656037569046, 0.03198164701461792, -0.0002719017502386123, -0.02901562862098217, -0.02253967709839344, -0.008505529724061489, 0.06640695780515671, -0.01744084618985653, -0.02665766142308712, 0.045790836215019226, 0.027468981221318245, -0.047146644443273544, 0.033522166311740875, -0.01295726653188467, -0.006654712837189436, -0.04404573515057564, 0.007083482574671507, -0.00205794395878911, -0.010404008440673351, -0.016052626073360443, 0.052919212728738785, 0.01297062262892723, -0.017863653600215912, -0.03704048693180084, -0.042601779103279114, 0.032188959419727325, -0.02660788968205452, 0.03328957036137581, -0.007970591075718403, -0.02266738750040531, 0.0733555406332016, 0.02764762192964554, -0.010522165335714817, -0.016121385619044304, -0.02606656216084957, -0.024432672187685966, 0.02616731822490692, 0.021104389801621437, 0.02784973569214344, -0.006796748377382755, 0.028949065133929253, 0.02939801849424839, 0.01313832588493824, 0.04432059824466705, -0.028914904221892357, 0.006509304512292147, 0.01178060658276081, 0.02956605702638626, -0.06090863421559334, 0.04431910440325737, -0.005774982273578644, -0.030837582424283028, -0.030536245554685593, 0.005722742062062025, 0.01920660212635994, 0.029544182121753693, -0.046749673783779144, 0.03569528087973595, -0.04724884778261185, -0.012716532684862614, -0.027007488533854485, 0.04736751690506935, 0.01294376514852047, -0.0060297464951872826, 0.017684035003185272, 0.02948111854493618, 0.01189698837697506, -0.010596701875329018, -0.004213904961943626, 0.00982606690376997, 0.06112617999315262, -0.03502940759062767, 0.01661563292145729, -0.022493548691272736, -0.02391663007438183, 0.030960921198129654, -0.02121775783598423, -0.027872234582901, 0.02530653215944767, 0.05187800154089928, 0.021898608654737473, -0.0002139770076610148, -0.04202800616621971, 0.020378412678837776, -0.07081450521945953, 0.027853703126311302, -0.02727854810655117, 0.03554520756006241, 0.003474217839539051, 0.032933756709098816, -0.011668350547552109, -0.029662303626537323, -0.017881065607070923, 0.011052725836634636, -0.04035201668739319, 0.034971725195646286, -0.031458865851163864, -0.03456661477684975, 0.00418933667242527, -0.028042715042829514, 0.020763695240020752, 0.003463543253019452, 0.00464803259819746, 0.015522639267146587, 0.017594454810023308, -0.05217950418591499, 0.05207281559705734, -0.04828681796789169, 0.00014990323688834906, 0.030608784407377243, 0.04685846343636513, -0.024217087775468826, 0.0009958682348951697, 0.06034416705369949, 0.007150635588914156, -0.009135568514466286, 0.022631939500570297, 0.04146846756339073, 0.045354731380939484, 0.02146337553858757, 0.01330738514661789, 0.02806449681520462, 0.03538164496421814, -0.03428204730153084, 0.01787896640598774, -0.03093606047332287, 0.060804106295108795, 0.000523048103787005, -0.037297070026397705, 0.011192482896149158, -0.020672457292675972, -0.019286934286355972, -0.01506285835057497, 0.0005021162796765566, -0.030898498371243477, 0.01224631629884243, 0.028897086158394814, 0.015796491876244545, -0.0536537691950798, -0.023267079144716263, 0.07167547196149826, -0.002207760000601411, -0.0005538810510188341, -0.04388369247317314, -0.004330750554800034, -0.0006967534427531064, -0.010068139992654324, -0.005445402581244707, 0.016120024025440216, 0.0070814634673297405, 0.011735575273633003, 0.05846406891942024, -0.025694245472550392, -0.06511176377534866, 0.02228494919836521, -0.013718980364501476, 0.043859172612428665, 0.022678416222333908, -0.013821952976286411, 0.04874071851372719, -0.015910223126411438, -0.007907452993094921, 0.030168797820806503, -0.01657925918698311, -0.05124838650226593, 0.0027694806922227144, 0.06304075568914413, 0.03328971192240715, -0.04812835901975632, 0.004421765450388193, -0.028999600559473038, -0.011444907635450363, 0.04529011249542236, -0.02567572332918644, 0.033182207494974136, -0.023447396233677864, 0.0029689401853829622, -0.08084512501955032, -0.0060822381637990475, -0.04093673825263977, 0.022060703486204147, 0.009417751803994179, 0.005270183552056551, -0.031711921095848083, 0.007528064772486687, -0.035770971328020096, -0.0184340737760067, 0.07655651122331619, 0.07809256762266159, -0.035858627408742905, 0.001999149564653635, 0.01943151094019413, 0.028987741097807884, -0.045875098556280136, -0.06634390354156494, -0.006048695184290409, 0.0032071389723569155, 0.007968460209667683, 0.04600100219249725, -0.040449947118759155, -0.0176568441092968, 0.0032878813799470663, -0.04259330406785011, -0.03562312573194504, 0.013899359852075577, 0.004756095353513956, 0.03778659179806709, 0.030198875814676285, 0.004379295744001865, 0.03390266373753548, 0.0006616654573008418, 0.007682362105697393, 0.0003266199491918087, -0.038051385432481766, 0.03219829127192497, -0.029554184526205063, 0.0335085354745388, -0.022659683600068092, -0.004394873045384884, -0.04225971922278404, 0.012875217944383621, -0.006331032142043114, 0.034620389342308044, -0.0029645271133631468, -0.02020694874227047, -0.011324848979711533, 0.008450913242995739, 0.030797921121120453, 0.015137641690671444, 0.00608573155477643, 0.003176320344209671, 0.000894471537321806, -0.0210662130266428, 0.005702243186533451, -0.009910221211612225, 0.024688664823770523, 0.03212069347500801, -0.046677108854055405, 0.020351100713014603, -0.06905033439397812, -0.0392671562731266, -0.003193443873897195, -0.03129901736974716, 0.05123941972851753, 0.020943772047758102, -0.0022397085558623075, -0.0054396456107497215, -0.06195468828082085, -0.02844720333814621, 0.028164144605398178, -0.02958972193300724, 0.050622619688510895, -0.017566313967108727, 0.05484051629900932, -0.023734627291560173, -0.009802332147955894, -0.08736767619848251, -0.06651975214481354, 0.010769973509013653, 0.05783924460411072, -0.016737565398216248, -0.04470546916127205, -0.0054646143689751625, 0.0012336809886619449, -0.015371754765510559, -0.05132070183753967, 0.03575553372502327, 0.009111396968364716, -0.0006272959290072322, -0.026225365698337555, -0.012357625178992748, 0.087302565574646, 0.030150290578603745, 0.02230498194694519, 0.014237248338758945, -0.0065011391416192055, 0.002390325767919421, 0.010308983735740185, 0.007961491122841835, -0.02178139239549637, -0.004350121133029461, -0.018237415701150894, 0.05488630011677742, 0.061544761061668396, 0.004026851151138544, -0.026141738519072533, 0.04081329330801964, 0.013993528671562672, 0.008631994016468525, -0.021366119384765625, -0.03265170007944107, -0.02072540484368801, 0.01988300494849682, -0.021544793620705605, 0.023853668943047523, 0.003981334622949362, 0.007129888515919447, 0.025241458788514137, 0.002541497815400362, -0.03925829380750656, -0.004932655021548271, 0.08278071135282516, -0.024805985391139984, -0.0033963825553655624, -0.0026491419412195683, -0.023598328232765198, 0.006743940524756908, 0.011890464462339878, 0.011075906455516815, 0.02099166437983513, 0.013814842328429222, -0.01307603344321251, -0.019009562209248543, -0.02735162526369095, 0.008398407138884068, 0.02573239430785179, 0.007481940556317568, 0.05153552442789078, 0.047269634902477264, 0.011415458284318447, -0.013650142587721348, 0.00004710381472250447, -0.038408391177654266, -0.002616950310766697, -0.009668136015534401, 0.05227148160338402, -0.015005344524979591, -0.00845978781580925, 0.05152978375554085, 0.023443197831511497, 0.01250550989061594, 0.04696774482727051, 0.020450040698051453, 0.00573061965405941, 0.013131853193044662, -0.0019432520493865013, -0.01818503811955452, 0.03452111780643463, -0.07270705699920654, 0.020420016720891, -0.05578045919537544, 0.003653279971331358, 0.06460200995206833, 0.020011266693472862, -0.02531886100769043, -0.008142128586769104, -0.0276310034096241, -0.05743946135044098, 0.022876901552081108, -0.0025328604970127344, 0.010511797852814198, 0.00965583510696888, 0.002726393286138773, 0.02418443374335766, -0.008818701840937138, 0.009639800526201725, -0.02974373660981655, -0.07977403700351715, -0.017269158735871315, -0.003147526178508997, -0.061805155128240585, 0.0027709200512617826, 0.016282523050904274, -0.02355238050222397, -0.0020097012165933847, -0.008258472196757793, 0.009853482246398926, -0.002928730333223939, 0.057238511741161346, -0.013806120492517948, 0.06582795828580856, -0.004838848486542702, 0.03141557797789574, 0.014480500482022762, -0.03229726850986481, 0.11869502067565918, 0.09683658182621002, 0.0279022715985775, -0.09139954298734665, 0.03413543850183487, -0.014243819750845432, -0.00220770132727921, -0.023159312084317207, 0.03566618636250496, 0.03469409421086311, -0.014492266811430454, 0.04308700188994408, 0.05919411778450012, -0.038630664348602295, -0.04359555244445801, 0.05452580377459526, -0.02139076590538025, -0.027219921350479126, 0.01606474630534649, 0.024599531665444374, -0.00809525791555643, -0.005633036606013775, -0.05889679491519928, -0.004938760306686163, 0.018827853724360466, 0.04241852089762688, -0.008508182130753994, -0.05713033676147461, 0.0039111957885324955, 0.006470885593444109, 0.01662401854991913, 0.009695112705230713, 0.02620125189423561, -0.01758435182273388, -0.03132995218038559, -0.0269620381295681, 0.016317959874868393, -0.028750859200954437, 0.0168966893106699, 0.059072524309158325, 0.003222084604203701, 0.0013851318508386612, -0.00009098550799535587, 0.020906079560518265, -0.05792445316910744, -0.020598506554961205, -0.03472096472978592, 0.0013774106046184897, 0.0008075523073785007, 0.013733499683439732, -0.0028097289614379406, -0.034166693687438965, -0.009670192375779152, -0.038007356226444244, -0.009891116991639137, 0.010195286013185978, 0.02432679571211338, -0.0445178747177124, -0.019675850868225098, -0.05745643749833107, 0.04827657341957092, -0.0123539874330163, 0.028677286580204964, 0.01894473470747471, -0.015451805666089058, 0.023726092651486397, 0.0013034094590693712, 0.02837947942316532, 0.03121025860309601, -0.006784522440284491, 0.002157873008400202, -0.01600710302591324, -0.047174129635095596, 0.005708725191652775, 0.008193452842533588, -0.0014003036776557565, 0.058121729642152786, -0.011598045937716961, -0.013207630254328251, 0.048694901168346405, -0.02928735688328743, -0.008382672443985939, -0.027345681563019753, -0.022370727732777596, -0.026056796312332153, 0.015177802182734013, 0.04309652000665665, 0.019570937380194664, 0.008443271741271019, 0.05828285217285156, 0.019319608807563782, 0.043068405240774155, 0.01365362573415041, -0.056864164769649506, 0.013851650059223175, -0.01994737982749939, -0.05660698562860489, -0.008060785010457039, -0.062471743673086166, 0.058887068182229996, 0.01855781115591526, 0.0048600672744214535, 0.0025336621329188347, -0.023291664198040962, 0.0005032297922298312, 0.008628719486296177, -0.009019773453474045, -0.04992740601301193, -0.0538126602768898, 0.022030498832464218, -0.01050631608814001, -0.04122709855437279, -0.010414610616862774, -0.046094171702861786, -0.030478565022349358, 0.02490600012242794, -0.018089592456817627, -0.021713126450777054, -0.01895803213119507, -0.008273310028016567, -0.024316884577274323, -0.00936355534940958, -0.011389484629034996, -0.018555909395217896, -0.002911023795604706, -0.008607754483819008, 0.028507184237241745, 0.005658331327140331, 0.008102448657155037, -0.02389776147902012, -0.0004955405602231622, 0.060755133628845215, 0.029710469767451286, 0.0025792208034545183, -0.017856061458587646, 0.01762199029326439, 0.014946894720196724, 0.0513712614774704, -0.013766380026936531, -0.0067964838817715645, 0.007799050305038691, -0.036146678030490875, -0.015272913500666618, 0.011307401582598686, 0.006568544078618288, 0.020242886617779732, 0.009175756946206093, -0.018028035759925842, -0.024786481633782387, 0.03809838369488716, -0.029069693759083748, -0.025752361863851547, -0.00038104329723864794, 0.010277350433170795, 0.01642051339149475, -0.019909033551812172, -0.011531727388501167, -0.008140054531395435, -0.00998984556645155, 0.02376599796116352, 0.011469806544482708, 0.0009228331036865711, -0.0173224825412035, -0.0028200154192745686, 0.004966177046298981, 0.04223421961069107, 0.0018646916141733527, -0.030015725642442703, 0.01025240495800972, 0.05891362577676773, -0.0264743585139513, 0.05018579214811325, -0.005862104240804911, -0.00041819424950517714, -0.06706146895885468, -0.02201174944639206, 0.02004530467092991, 0.014647174626588821, 0.02951921708881855, -0.016735929995775223, 0.013796218670904636, 0.05287248641252518, -0.04269223287701607, 0.02404879778623581, -0.005917553789913654, 0.019249767065048218, -0.07850594818592072, -0.009668845683336258, 0.008001081645488739, 0.011825907975435257, 0.016681058332324028, -0.002211730694398284, 0.01839229092001915, 0.022895388305187225, -0.03127305209636688, -0.013287162408232689, 0.008067449554800987, 0.01436890009790659, 0.00278703891672194, -0.07622303813695908, 0.01668592169880867, -0.021650945767760277, -0.044205356389284134, 0.03586999326944351, 0.00342030031606555, 0.00434538722038269, 0.007593202870339155, 0.036128729581832886, -0.007558990735560656, 0.030168328434228897, 0.04829346016049385, -0.002588265808299184, -0.030084721744060516, -0.0049194651655852795, 0.002873989986255765, 0.01440070103853941, -0.04062645137310028, -0.0028780652210116386, 0.02665359154343605, 0.0008270675898529589, -0.010224483907222748, 0.04564405977725983, -0.016178954392671585, -0.025951096788048744, -0.01740178093314171, -0.028258979320526123, 0.006476316601037979, 0.011927282437682152, 0.03451782464981079, -0.03835674375295639, 0.0076294573955237865, 0.03398188576102257, 0.02101089619100094, -0.02673029899597168, 0.01594088226556778, -0.016171231865882874, -0.034942299127578735, -0.012092848308384418, 0.006594110745936632, -0.002151366788893938, -0.06133686378598213, 0.008524182252585888, -0.009811964817345142, -0.01715053990483284, 0.011873215436935425, -0.04676581546664238, -0.012344231829047203, 0.04482979327440262, -0.014844659715890884, -0.008388616144657135, 0.019626088440418243, 0.016009872779250145, -0.001679748180322349, -0.05586694926023483, 0.03938727080821991, -0.03391566872596741, -0.034327663481235504, -0.05644715204834938, 0.011474987491965294, -0.027691056951880455, 0.018521975725889206, 0.027915846556425095, 0.02788892574608326, -0.005089035723358393, -0.03904091194272041, 0.03984013572335243, 0.04972337931394577, -0.061938896775245667, 0.03120422549545765, -0.05487256869673729, -0.0024668187834322453, -0.011285270564258099, -0.017614515498280525, 0.03201649710536003, 0.008768502622842789, -0.014344112016260624, -0.01730949804186821, 0.005269180051982403, -0.009724315255880356, 0.02631039172410965, 0.02358515001833439, 0.006616602651774883, 0.008466873317956924, 0.04292260482907295, -0.005258849356323481, 0.0108296237885952, 0.002266514115035534, 0.015230482444167137, -0.040666431188583374, 0.046039581298828125, -0.04424414783716202, -0.011917613446712494, 0.02612294815480709, 0.005981973372399807, 0.00986640527844429, -0.04687768965959549, 0.011774574406445026, 0.019899697974324226, -0.07370354980230331, -0.008448789827525616, 0.007204869762063026, 0.012736851349473, 0.03378039598464966, -0.03714049607515335, 0.049903351813554764, 0.0346808023750782, -0.024463191628456116, -0.027072792872786522, 0.014765932224690914, -0.025677138939499855, 0.01899201050400734, 0.024135611951351166, 0.016877219080924988, -0.028676478192210197, 0.05960756912827492, 0.02156359888613224, 0.009276067838072777, -0.003690456273034215, -0.020796749740839005, 0.03867027536034584, -0.023216499015688896, 0.017207298427820206, 0.007963599637150764, -0.015841934829950333, 0.03673732653260231, -0.03962109610438347, 0.025025464594364166, -0.04390239343047142, -0.03288693726062775, -0.019665086641907692, -0.04311220347881317, 0.01897616870701313, 0.00985813234001398, 0.01248337235301733, 0.0005577109986916184, -0.02373119816184044, 0.022598817944526672, 0.0489380918443203, -0.04840454086661339, 0.04086865484714508, -0.0339898020029068, -0.006456227973103523, -0.04731329157948494, -0.01712789013981819, -0.051731884479522705, 0.0003108226228505373, 0.015292583964765072, 0.03410643711686134, 0.04572119191288948, 0.013857844285666943, -0.03918003663420677, 0.01600778102874756, 0.02595282718539238, -0.021700460463762283, -0.01551145687699318, -0.04509858414530754, 0.015755603089928627, 0.04357745498418808, 0.008596445433795452 ]
<p>I need to calculate the sample size required for an observational study in which incidence of disease is 19-29%. Population affected is 600,000 people.</p> <p>The study has two samples similar on baseline characteristics treated with two different drugs.</p> <p>Statistical analysis will be chi-square and Fisher's test. I have to demonstrate non-inferiority of one drugs with respect of the other one. I don't have any other info.</p> <p>Can anyone help me to calculate the sample sizes required in order to obtain power of 0.80 with an alpha 0.05?</p> <p>Thanks a lot in advance</p>
47,538
[ -0.05434158444404602, -0.018390271812677383, -0.01306779682636261, 0.04195364564657211, 0.03905385732650757, 0.03868579864501953, -0.027654528617858887, -0.04799032211303711, 0.019762732088565826, -0.006560235284268856, 0.04145338758826256, 0.005682745017111301, 0.05991316959261894, 0.010850786231458187, -0.004020232707262039, -0.00951584056019783, -0.044918645173311234, 0.03671322017908096, 0.010840557515621185, -0.02281034179031849, 0.031730085611343384, -0.016317564994096756, 0.038611747324466705, 0.015527143143117428, -0.042666979134082794, 0.08023064583539963, 0.02555089071393013, -0.003372755367308855, -0.014157840050756931, 0.06723106652498245, -0.02642400935292244, -0.04056684300303459, 0.034367721527814865, 0.043518077582120895, 0.0187011007219553, 0.006760539021342993, -0.04962072893977165, -0.040210526436567307, -0.0030920282006263733, 0.01997850462794304, -0.02310028485953808, -0.023612484335899353, 0.04812600463628769, -0.03067842498421669, -0.03055875562131405, 0.0405103825032711, -0.012546896003186703, -0.0847867950797081, 0.015190411359071732, -0.03489892557263374, 0.08343116194009781, 0.011800959706306458, 0.08962328732013702, 0.022125063464045525, -0.014467623084783554, -0.03456512466073036, 0.004957012832164764, 0.05805300176143646, -0.0000978833413682878, -0.02975226193666458, -0.018512029200792313, -0.01222508866339922, -0.015654899179935455, -0.023340092971920967, -0.04912707582116127, 0.03044094145298004, -0.02478417381644249, -0.020075025036931038, 0.02984589897096157, 0.009250547736883163, 0.03406323865056038, 0.02425183542072773, 0.038397662341594696, -0.02417062781751156, -0.003909920807927847, -0.04027802497148514, 0.0011335245799273252, 0.04154675453901291, 0.019399261102080345, 0.0247659794986248, -0.017411179840564728, 0.03298252448439598, 0.03755631297826767, 0.016881631687283516, 0.0215597040951252, -0.026645539328455925, 0.046331070363521576, -0.021671762689948082, 0.009603312239050865, 0.024584291502833366, -0.0346183218061924, -0.0036428060848265886, 0.08373723179101944, -0.0006927651120349765, -0.0364200659096241, -0.026183195412158966, -0.01957392506301403, 0.06094236671924591, -0.019829781726002693, 0.026597391813993454, 0.0010869682300835848, -0.039583753794431686, 0.03641658276319504, 0.04381819814443588, 0.016225693747401237, -0.02447371929883957, -0.0341772735118866, 0.0025611056480556726, 0.020555583760142326, -0.025207478553056717, 0.01550840213894844, 0.019747259095311165, 0.01749170757830143, -0.0006294556078501046, 0.000036573059333022684, -0.009249914437532425, -0.028875291347503662, -0.009154616855084896, 0.07191884517669678, 0.051870737224817276, 0.053294189274311066, -0.0034847860224545, 0.0013590945163741708, -0.006244579330086708, -0.025293489918112755, 0.011365605518221855, -0.0019517418695613742, -0.018876753747463226, -0.05494216829538345, 0.04558417946100235, 0.010959128849208355, -0.014252622611820698, 0.02270178310573101, -0.03287811577320099, 0.024161819368600845, 0.0022149274591356516, -0.0769929438829422, -0.0308938417583704, 0.033201977610588074, 0.002078102668747306, 0.005873593036085367, -0.04772916063666344, 0.04013213887810707, 0.05163845419883728, 0.033875588327646255, 0.015544327907264233, 0.03716249391436577, 0.03274998813867569, 0.04437091201543808, 0.022780660539865494, -0.02998071350157261, 0.019114190712571144, -0.035003334283828735, 0.00954743754118681, -0.03873820602893829, -0.09696140885353088, -0.0015740512171760201, 0.016457313671708107, -0.01187879592180252, -0.0396280363202095, 0.026806723326444626, 0.01381415780633688, 0.012462286278605461, -0.01982763223350048, 0.011447478085756302, -0.04849394038319588, 0.06346538662910461, 0.01317159179598093, 0.019104251638054848, 0.026258209720253944, -0.006061711814254522, 0.017773278057575226, 0.029138842597603798, 0.010898924432694912, 0.03282257542014122, 0.009892161004245281, 0.01924426108598709, -0.037041887640953064, 0.02784718945622444, 0.05792532488703728, -0.07041238248348236, 0.0010445605730637908, -0.006921981927007437, -0.006971712689846754, 0.03679920732975006, 0.019460314884781837, 0.022171322256326675, -0.007931080646812916, 0.04279578477144241, -0.036908429116010666, -0.05676225572824478, -0.064130038022995, 0.010569343343377113, -0.0003528510278556496, -0.05407867953181267, -0.01895035430788994, 0.023055240511894226, -0.006050726864486933, -0.015052982605993748, -0.019584020599722862, 0.012476029805839062, -0.01020432636141777, 0.036551542580127716, -0.019103173166513443, 0.008501303382217884, 0.07270219922065735, 0.07771626859903336, -0.04209354147315025, 0.04398585483431816, -0.03335384279489517, -0.021619392558932304, -0.0060396320186555386, -0.03616800531744957, -0.011484313756227493, -0.038278285413980484, -0.014614847488701344, 0.011281515471637249, 0.01548665389418602, 0.026927514001727104, 0.06056734547019005, -0.03398754075169563, 0.10226166248321533, 0.056352175772190094, 0.014703089371323586, 0.017265966162085533, 0.007027831859886646, -0.00660115759819746, 0.007489186245948076, -0.029523134231567383, -0.019324976950883865, -0.06766798347234726, -0.006998555269092321, 0.031497519463300705, -0.004176597576588392, -0.03372976928949356, -0.012447449378669262, 0.048959292471408844, -0.011904753744602203, 0.04529827833175659, 0.04275871440768242, -0.0024504177272319794, -0.018902968615293503, -0.006435604300349951, 0.03776119649410248, 0.01895730011165142, 0.004080344922840595, -0.0006858904962427914, -0.0032754968851804733, 0.03814401477575302, -0.00027921359287574887, -0.021773116663098335, 0.04569408297538757, -0.005575726740062237, 0.045984700322151184, -0.035390667617321014, -0.014561439864337444, 0.04614696651697159, -0.008960947394371033, -0.0019472632557153702, 0.02674541249871254, -0.01871492527425289, 0.026396024972200394, -0.004232687875628471, -0.010066652670502663, 0.0060526835732162, 0.03503722697496414, -0.036201778799295425, 0.04255719855427742, 0.01277075707912445, -0.053354207426309586, -0.018927212804555893, -0.000574342324398458, -0.03200773149728775, -0.027386879548430443, -0.009009541012346745, 0.04533819854259491, -0.013131547719240189, 0.04392184317111969, 0.003613849636167288, -0.014812625013291836, -0.00959180761128664, -0.007664600852876902, -0.0179402157664299, 0.021609198302030563, -0.05505821853876114, 0.01763032376766205, -0.01489685196429491, -0.014019273221492767, 0.020016124472022057, 0.010975271463394165, 0.016058551147580147, 0.027495233342051506, 0.018263768404722214, -0.058200132101774216, -0.005816122982650995, -0.0015253578312695026, 0.003545242128893733, -0.010480538941919804, -0.01958790421485901, 0.01755375601351261, 0.017349975183606148, -0.020672209560871124, 0.024103226140141487, -0.014545303769409657, -0.014018510468304157, -0.014086454175412655, 0.005352003965526819, 0.009447166696190834, -0.025979984551668167, 0.0045101032592356205, 0.004648341331630945, -0.037367645651102066, -0.010798626579344273, -0.05227549374103546, -0.04820164665579796, -0.0018754840129986405, 0.011465516872704029, 0.029552314430475235, -0.012858825735747814, -0.025703469291329384, 0.06118512898683548, 0.029922448098659515, -0.004609767813235521, -0.02414786070585251, -0.023094411939382553, -0.047063156962394714, -0.009946121834218502, 0.043822627514600754, 0.03496516868472099, -0.021966252475976944, -0.011718072928488255, -0.009200314991176128, 0.01146238949149847, 0.053613562136888504, 0.010939951054751873, 0.014077010564506054, 0.006423857528716326, 0.03523750975728035, 0.005345593672245741, 0.051422376185655594, 0.0007506032125093043, -0.05308983102440834, 0.025086592882871628, 0.007725786883383989, 0.010153505951166153, 0.0037059986498206854, -0.029994826763868332, -0.006103354040533304, 0.011721388436853886, 0.011507725343108177, -0.03447256609797478, 0.02071119099855423, 0.011093491688370705, -0.029253751039505005, -0.006122625432908535, 0.0340033695101738, 0.012549517676234245, -0.05109958350658417, -0.003170401556417346, 0.055677685886621475, 0.044288404285907745, -0.0015266152331605554, -0.020748192444443703, -0.027081452310085297, 0.0013167259749025106, -0.0042534987442195415, -0.025403756648302078, -0.018214698880910873, 0.003786677261814475, 0.046511005610227585, 0.032428301870822906, -0.02026483230292797, 0.009200484491884708, 0.0008798256167210639, -0.05199480429291725, -0.01794177107512951, -0.04153786227107048, 0.05060198903083801, -0.01906808279454708, 0.042031869292259216, -0.013670275919139385, -0.018272262066602707, 0.011057060211896896, -0.013406062498688698, -0.045480672270059586, 0.07258562743663788, -0.029591359198093414, -0.04176501929759979, 0.029554463922977448, 0.016993718221783638, 0.015618349425494671, 0.017562860623002052, 0.007128881756216288, 0.010354339145123959, 0.02139311283826828, -0.01688544824719429, 0.04014195501804352, -0.01810302771627903, 0.013925977982580662, 0.009957762435078621, 0.057898253202438354, -0.017570629715919495, 0.003920226823538542, 0.020387927070260048, 0.011363589204847813, -0.02704416960477829, -0.01429903693497181, -0.021003413945436478, 0.045496050268411636, 0.004374988377094269, 0.017757652327418327, 0.028620140627026558, 0.021924028173089027, -0.04006218537688255, -0.010849431157112122, -0.005377630703151226, 0.02729390747845173, 0.023906173184514046, 0.011008433997631073, 0.008989276364445686, -0.04103662446141243, -0.022895662114024162, -0.0028480319306254387, 0.021305419504642487, -0.0009436555556021631, -0.004797846078872681, 0.016188105568289757, -0.014956450089812279, -0.03887420892715454, 0.02482978254556656, 0.07414999604225159, 0.02663280814886093, -0.0016797804273664951, -0.05400465056300163, -0.0033760732039809227, -0.01986670307815075, -0.005348084960132837, 0.012073719874024391, 0.018821237608790398, -0.0036533568054437637, -0.024501100182533264, 0.025188518688082695, -0.023550478741526604, -0.03800123929977417, 0.016041113063693047, 0.022355565801262856, 0.035084959119558334, 0.004407907370477915, -0.04984536021947861, 0.01829342171549797, 0.04102575033903122, 0.04042647033929825, 0.000623321917373687, 0.01862342283129692, -0.0738460049033165, 0.017617568373680115, 0.006480788812041283, 0.045698996633291245, -0.02028261497616768, -0.012295764870941639, -0.049747105687856674, -0.004819412250071764, 0.015154247172176838, -0.06936626136302948, 0.018638882786035538, -0.024536484852433205, 0.015161968767642975, -0.03481335937976837, 0.003472565207630396, -0.04925094172358513, -0.007680634967982769, -0.020346205681562424, 0.007461552042514086, 0.0007933680317364633, -0.004194945562630892, -0.05327509343624115, 0.011450725607573986, 0.022574031725525856, 0.07940150052309036, -0.04193390905857086, -0.04862212762236595, 0.007702961564064026, 0.0292392298579216, -0.03930934891104698, -0.04528625309467316, 0.03622426092624664, -0.007360934745520353, 0.014512661844491959, 0.0224166102707386, -0.036259282380342484, -0.024317476898431778, 0.00928935781121254, 0.024753399193286896, -0.052496809512376785, -0.012243534438312054, -0.0561426505446434, 0.03334817290306091, 0.026868946850299835, 0.020113850012421608, 0.09322865307331085, 0.006677553523331881, -0.006076090969145298, 0.0028351638466119766, -0.04486992955207825, -0.0051115103997290134, -0.014041216112673283, -0.01571357436478138, -0.05500657111406326, 0.00738692469894886, -0.00969098974019289, 0.02915860153734684, -0.011105972342193127, 0.057753223925828934, -0.008169572800397873, -0.004975650925189257, 0.027179934084415436, 0.005100959446281195, 0.02308572642505169, -0.009953535161912441, -0.001524835592135787, 0.05582749843597412, 0.004065449349582195, -0.0020467592403292656, 0.05888574942946434, -0.03381029888987541, -0.01258251816034317, -0.0009755554492585361, -0.07104828953742981, -0.009055165573954582, -0.034771136939525604, -0.03802519291639328, 0.009669509716331959, -0.03824678435921669, 0.018288416787981987, -0.052896272391080856, 0.03828124329447746, 0.013476620428264141, -0.036881498992443085, -0.02264699526131153, 0.03510981798171997, 0.004967423155903816, 0.04975002259016037, -0.04050813615322113, 0.037414390593767166, 0.007597086951136589, -0.021285226568579674, -0.08172108978033066, -0.0300158504396677, 0.05811681970953941, 0.008692990988492966, -0.004837024956941605, -0.005931783467531204, 0.011242656968533993, 0.016523707658052444, -0.011385126039385796, -0.03592836484313011, 0.004808897152543068, 0.007771482225507498, -0.009166710078716278, -0.015255938284099102, -0.00009116251021623611, 0.0661262571811676, -0.00946072768419981, -0.017248421907424927, 0.034728486090898514, -0.04738689586520195, -0.030463794246315956, -0.02267295867204666, -0.010351362638175488, -0.025771813467144966, -0.035100556910037994, -0.07200895994901657, -0.003862903453409672, 0.007186194881796837, 0.02033466473221779, -0.032695382833480835, -0.003233672119677067, 0.03676986321806908, 0.01073114387691021, -0.04057403281331062, -0.017760446295142174, -0.0022764489986002445, 0.018197357654571533, -0.04290614649653435, 0.037469733506441116, -0.03097655437886715, 0.00898684561252594, 0.008046642877161503, 0.009916063398122787, 0.003902829485014081, -0.015672359615564346, 0.060393232852220535, 0.014230668544769287, 0.04258355125784874, -0.006056369282305241, -0.01614738628268242, 0.009783600457012653, 0.0419977568089962, -0.03069467842578888, 0.004941938910633326, 0.02365272492170334, -0.049423206597566605, -0.03223564848303795, -0.030025942251086235, 0.05123097822070122, 0.06195761635899544, 0.02070644125342369, 0.040202200412750244, 0.06668978929519653, 0.03389380872249603, 0.0028801558073610067, -0.0028858918230980635, -0.002298095030710101, -0.012117763981223106, 0.015020305290818214, 0.04642379656434059, -0.000046181525249267, -0.03281712159514427, 0.06785838305950165, 0.01351511012762785, 0.029508568346500397, 0.050509292632341385, 0.03839607164263725, 0.023976199328899384, -0.002408684464171529, -0.03191306069493294, -0.0229213684797287, -0.0011216482380405068, -0.03128623217344284, 0.038098063319921494, -0.03740951418876648, -0.022175811231136322, 0.07474663108587265, 0.030500268563628197, 0.02785807102918625, -0.02805267833173275, -0.03349653631448746, -0.02908402867615223, -0.030835866928100586, -0.0017543556168675423, -0.003479845356196165, 0.011223074980080128, 0.03370026499032974, 0.016344189643859863, -0.026427462697029114, 0.06618696451187134, -0.028524480760097504, -0.06927736103534698, -0.016722995787858963, 0.0038014082238078117, -0.07041355222463608, 0.046843595802783966, -0.009444016963243484, -0.02286989986896515, 0.03979033976793289, -0.03589929640293121, 0.003438109066337347, 0.000962868973147124, 0.031295813620090485, -0.0011009537847712636, 0.05818156525492668, 0.0222608782351017, -0.0010604807175695896, 0.013808120042085648, 0.01361989974975586, 0.10562338680028915, 0.057756125926971436, -0.020810360088944435, -0.0533268041908741, 0.05429932475090027, -0.011942789889872074, -0.021647829562425613, -0.007935724221169949, 0.0018046876648440957, -0.007719781715422869, -0.03669598698616028, 0.072569340467453, 0.028459053486585617, 0.030582129955291748, -0.0203938540071249, 0.05502885580062866, -0.03417490795254707, -0.037434905767440796, 0.017643384635448456, 0.0006872944068163633, -0.00030569088994525373, -0.03262638300657272, -0.013086391612887383, 0.051705606281757355, -0.018910979852080345, -0.030430234968662262, -0.030147681012749672, 0.0049624377861619, 0.017420649528503418, -0.00021635329176206142, -0.03250930458307266, 0.009761400520801544, 0.006743286270648241, -0.012858713045716286, -0.045782484114170074, -0.026532748714089394, 0.032147184014320374, -0.042409397661685944, -0.013974014669656754, 0.05307213217020035, -0.024199873208999634, 0.02712101675570011, 0.0030342573300004005, 0.033427584916353226, -0.03804117068648338, -0.008958793245255947, -0.024484675377607346, 0.05189096927642822, 0.0022875976283103228, 0.01032351329922676, -0.024566980078816414, 0.013010638765990734, -0.03028883785009384, -0.05523563548922539, 0.005992121994495392, 0.00675478158518672, 0.005646184086799622, -0.04351574927568436, -0.024903440847992897, -0.03483283147215843, 0.02152886986732483, -0.013031012378633022, 0.037714045494794846, 0.013793881982564926, 0.011483762413263321, -0.03210073709487915, -0.02664586342871189, 0.021620674058794975, -0.004659451078623533, -0.00036328547867015004, 0.010833976790308952, -0.01954522915184498, -0.036148764193058014, 0.034303683787584305, -0.02309371531009674, -0.005196332931518555, 0.041844405233860016, -0.01545306108891964, 0.0008708774112164974, -0.04313080012798309, -0.027790777385234833, 0.013307998888194561, -0.02402116172015667, 0.0016852588159963489, -0.016591636463999748, -0.018184475600719452, 0.04179662466049194, 0.016081100329756737, -0.00697751110419631, 0.0030055188108235598, 0.008536376990377903, 0.0005353576852940023, 0.017033129930496216, -0.07168607413768768, -0.01651308871805668, 0.007808229885995388, -0.054487939924001694, -0.003390381345525384, -0.027313776314258575, 0.06107078120112419, 0.01847488060593605, -0.011617275886237621, 0.018408872187137604, 0.02660997398197651, -0.012474802322685719, -0.01897408813238144, -0.012453881092369556, -0.06455857306718826, -0.006465268321335316, 0.0035708846990019083, 0.005254708230495453, -0.01662948727607727, 0.005971311591565609, -0.058526452630758286, -0.020218372344970703, 0.0038840735796839, -0.04198910668492317, 0.0163455531001091, -0.016288524493575096, -0.01636841520667076, 0.021804168820381165, -0.019228683784604073, -0.0017964184517040849, -0.03340703621506691, 0.003920300398021936, 0.026100048795342445, 0.026281803846359253, -0.04366453364491463, 0.029077844694256783, -0.019560432061553, -0.01750711351633072, 0.004063769709318876, 0.021726977080106735, 0.03272407129406929, 0.004626933019608259, -0.03200900927186012, 0.013085843995213509, 0.05186007544398308, -0.02923009730875492, 0.01439108420163393, 0.05198637396097183, -0.08265082538127899, -0.02613557130098343, 0.022125791758298874, -0.035459183156490326, 0.03117469884455204, 0.02400369569659233, 0.007985243573784828, -0.012645277194678783, 0.049646418541669846, -0.030817773193120956, -0.055086519569158554, -0.03353491425514221, 0.012232374399900436, -0.01744365692138672, 0.0028891765978187323, -0.02111150696873665, 0.017427947372198105, 0.010305955074727535, 0.03690943494439125, 0.04792018607258797, 0.013397948816418648, -0.0023168479092419147, -0.010820905677974224, 0.055516280233860016, 0.009734347462654114, -0.005406501702964306, -0.04575423523783684, 0.050927720963954926, 0.05783412978053093, -0.027410559356212616, 0.009913300164043903, -0.03321113809943199, 0.01793011836707592, -0.08635611832141876, -0.00383738218806684, -0.02618776634335518, 0.02509881928563118, 0.042069438844919205, -0.05544278025627136, 0.015725772827863693, 0.011502215638756752, -0.038352612406015396, -0.013012820854783058, -0.020198814570903778, -0.00975349172949791, -0.026806965470314026, 0.03399062529206276, 0.007595281582325697, 0.044311873614788055, 0.012119706720113754, 0.005511883646249771, 0.02616715617477894, 0.030788706615567207, 0.0031255928333848715, -0.005526845809072256, -0.023067815229296684, 0.01643800176680088, 0.008358679711818695, -0.0699266567826271, -0.007867620326578617, -0.03482950106263161, -0.029851166531443596, 0.024963943287730217, -0.025669382885098457, 0.03594653308391571, 0.04096653312444687, 0.0039304448291659355, -0.007839069701731205, 0.04684608057141304, 0.03262008726596832, -0.0029738787561655045, -0.02917628549039364, -0.02612197771668434, 0.019542282447218895, 0.020892459899187088, 0.012081144377589226, 0.02438146248459816, 0.07490306347608566, 0.002988678403198719, 0.0017852707533165812, 0.010883187875151634, 0.006939489394426346, -0.02491212636232376, -0.0027534961700439453, -0.00257658283226192, -0.008854937739670277, -0.005559184588491917, -0.00006345121073536575, -0.024383390322327614, 0.009927406907081604, 0.046195149421691895, 0.009223362430930138, -0.015019300393760204, 0.03601235896348953, -0.0046629649586975574, -0.011881127953529358, 0.004044522996991873, -0.005486395210027695, 0.00281063886359334, -0.048872001469135284, 0.02186235971748829, -0.02199886552989483, -0.021195121109485626, 0.013861401006579399, -0.02101106569170952, -0.054488230496644974, 0.027532249689102173, -0.030996186658740044, -0.002836452564224601, 0.021715335547924042, 0.03240049257874489, 0.02456780895590782, -0.06503208726644516, 0.06693063676357269, 0.003249699715524912, -0.006162518169730902, -0.032532013952732086, -0.043427083641290665, -0.03743106871843338, 0.028500385582447052, 0.04448779672384262, 0.019302647560834885, -0.042155634611845016, -0.02034916914999485, 0.035858336836099625, -0.01047136913985014, -0.07452598959207535, 0.04980486258864403, -0.022745858877897263, -0.03314464911818504, 0.011747543700039387, 0.025842221453785896, 0.059814952313899994, 0.013182801194489002, 0.012151542119681835, -0.04405616968870163, 0.01948932744562626, 0.025572145357728004, -0.044092629104852676, 0.021272799000144005, 0.01087790448218584, -0.010394183918833733, 0.03151392191648483, -0.0065197027288377285, 0.013868245296180248, 0.027419669553637505, 0.00886453129351139, -0.053371280431747437, 0.024074716493487358, -0.024624938145279884, -0.003111151047050953, 0.017082227393984795, -0.013605313375592232, -0.007402931805700064, -0.06402936577796936, 0.01045087818056345, 0.01303078606724739, -0.03556162863969803, 0.028188122436404228, 0.04031474143266678, 0.04655538871884346, 0.025890477001667023, -0.03191249817609787, 0.0026140031404793262, -0.01279107853770256, -0.015441377647221088, -0.029809394851326942, -0.016289493069052696, 0.0051706270314753056, 0.03278840333223343, 0.012202741578221321, 0.043208103626966476, 0.008915640413761139, 0.0061631593853235245, -0.0037579757627099752, 0.040684301406145096, 0.011305684223771095, -0.0401434563100338, -0.0043870145455002785, -0.005040219984948635, 0.046341050416231155, 0.0081376563757658, 0.012182787992060184, 0.0672203078866005, -0.027428803965449333, 0.01962086744606495, -0.007447769399732351, -0.03574827313423157, -0.06622027605772018, -0.003089773701503873, 0.0157198216766119, 0.027513863518834114, -0.007497845217585564, 0.0040712058544158936, 0.0032643508166074753, -0.028214288875460625, 0.01677815243601799, -0.04173464700579643, 0.023837776854634285, -0.024115581065416336, -0.02494373917579651, -0.0419156514108181, -0.0010640739928930998, -0.00531674874946475, -0.03140587732195854, 0.017404794692993164, 0.03372931107878685, 0.016414400190114975, -0.03515421226620674, -0.029492409899830818, 0.0022019892930984497, 0.042957570403814316, -0.0499882809817791, -0.02673851139843464, -0.030864905565977097, 0.011293327435851097, -0.022006845101714134, 0.012762637808918953 ]
<p>Lets say for example a class of students and their grades are the data set. Lets say there are around 35 students.</p> <p>Here is what you know:</p> <pre><code>Your mark The class average The median mark The standard deviation </code></pre> <p>Are there any other conclusions about this data that can be made given this information?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
996
[ -0.039752665907144547, -0.028419001027941704, -0.03913261368870735, 0.01851782202720642, 0.029689323157072067, 0.05441765859723091, -0.017431503161787987, -0.03669421747326851, 0.008554276078939438, -0.030368177220225334, 0.020030463114380836, 0.00404469994828105, 0.03617580607533455, 0.037393007427453995, 0.04305577278137207, 0.00023616172256879508, -0.035561397671699524, -0.006558154243975878, 0.027070848271250725, -0.001051377854309976, -0.03227255493402481, 0.019688071683049202, 0.014490703120827675, 0.0025798201095312834, -0.04444354400038719, 0.02248305268585682, 0.031178249046206474, 0.0051668263040483, 0.029452862218022346, 0.034052230417728424, 0.01441927533596754, -0.0013762625167146325, 0.007661748677492142, 0.03897402435541153, 0.03857877478003502, -0.009632907807826996, -0.02194291166961193, -0.033192362636327744, 0.00571289099752903, -0.0035297430586069822, 0.005197996273636818, 0.005473605822771788, 0.02069510519504547, 0.04126081243157387, -0.0017496391665190458, 0.01959940232336521, -0.020441830158233643, -0.02932698279619217, 0.025910483673214912, -0.029339149594306946, 0.08196555078029633, -0.016269298270344734, 0.03916419669985771, 0.034082893282175064, -0.024478744715452194, -0.003700505243614316, 0.04580695554614067, 0.0732441172003746, -0.02145458571612835, -0.06814966350793839, -0.00010590317833703011, -0.03420446440577507, -0.025976797565817833, -0.019181665033102036, -0.05382942780852318, 0.016115371137857437, -0.062127865850925446, -0.01640794612467289, 0.0673176497220993, -0.0015962232137098908, 0.01170178223401308, 0.05890060216188431, 0.04355176165699959, 0.03404531255364418, 0.02757500670850277, -0.03560224175453186, 0.03388631343841553, -0.0036678239703178406, 0.013103689067065716, 0.03967339172959328, 0.003782516811043024, 0.015069217421114445, 0.03436817601323128, 0.04110264405608177, 0.046655576676130295, -0.00501603726297617, 0.0484500452876091, -0.020574213936924934, 0.016479386016726494, 0.009907393716275692, 0.020026911050081253, -0.04587690532207489, 0.033638861030340195, 0.00335360923781991, -0.012909477576613426, 0.02174203097820282, -0.021297309547662735, 0.023700380697846413, 0.023931458592414856, -0.028834717348217964, 0.023218274116516113, -0.020059822127223015, 0.003658055095002055, 0.02789248339831829, -0.013207116164267063, -0.03068862110376358, -0.03509977087378502, -0.010633973404765129, 0.007239117287099361, -0.014244269579648972, 0.005848661530762911, 0.006760279182344675, 0.03702068701386452, -0.029644181951880455, 0.013392070308327675, -0.0268101803958416, -0.01174318976700306, -0.009868945926427841, 0.015972819179296494, 0.025345178321003914, 0.03400293365120888, -0.041253458708524704, 0.02516135945916176, -0.0038072061724960804, -0.02236795425415039, 0.004222801886498928, 0.01512135285884142, -0.02239208109676838, -0.03487243130803108, 0.048471685498952866, -0.06632502377033234, 0.030224906280636787, 0.03576676920056343, -0.014694126322865486, 0.02701335959136486, 0.009765286929905415, -0.09394378960132599, -0.0378425307571888, 0.050460971891880035, -0.02663588337600231, -0.00034454165142960846, -0.04738295078277588, -0.011089799925684929, 0.02168307825922966, 0.02599859982728958, 0.022422175854444504, 0.035373881459236145, -0.005698188673704863, 0.02742169052362442, 0.024400509893894196, -0.00064891017973423, -0.006597744766622782, 0.020094361156225204, -0.0662754625082016, -0.017382439225912094, -0.06594255566596985, -0.03237183019518852, 0.01812051050364971, -0.022147590294480324, -0.028495050966739655, 0.0010887644020840526, -0.03444258123636246, 0.005077944602817297, -0.0024830906186252832, 0.004761919844895601, -0.019427163526415825, 0.07770980149507523, 0.009928174316883087, 0.02975190244615078, 0.0005003560218028724, -0.00415395200252533, 0.04317990317940712, 0.01493371743708849, 0.04230713099241257, 0.05414621904492378, -0.001974400132894516, -0.01639246940612793, -0.00463777594268322, 0.021736998111009598, -0.044725801795721054, -0.050551846623420715, -0.04208697751164436, -0.005005449056625366, 0.049233678728342056, 0.009778639301657677, 0.05995345115661621, -0.0029685853514820337, -0.022660357877612114, 0.024509459733963013, -0.039389435201883316, -0.007895695976912975, -0.09592701494693756, 0.013628422282636166, -0.025638364255428314, -0.044554535299539566, 0.00010693549847928807, 0.039931923151016235, 0.019696669653058052, -0.020621955394744873, 0.002213534899055958, -0.03829622268676758, -0.04267868772149086, 0.037427276372909546, -0.03213110566139221, 0.00010834659042302519, 0.015279499813914299, 0.04564252495765686, -0.02746407501399517, 0.036407943814992905, -0.059039995074272156, -0.024875324219465256, 0.015549658797681332, -0.03996599465608597, 0.011537797749042511, -0.02539617009460926, -0.006247148849070072, 0.02784358151257038, -0.005612362641841173, -0.02361026033759117, 0.018593210726976395, -0.03482191637158394, 0.08610843122005463, 0.037027254700660706, 0.009154686704277992, 0.02143000438809395, -0.00744626484811306, -0.002936100587248802, 0.051958080381155014, -0.024441074579954147, -0.016621652990579605, -0.03158620372414589, 0.0023876188788563013, 0.016360759735107422, 0.02811918966472149, -0.03780253976583481, 0.0344865508377552, 0.04916909709572792, -0.008549685589969158, 0.01888568326830864, 0.017565740272402763, -0.008963994681835175, -0.005746392533183098, -0.005543334875255823, 0.020719440653920174, 0.01739952340722084, -0.01691002957522869, 0.019085261970758438, 0.054342228919267654, 0.005100877955555916, 0.04547338932752609, 0.03965640068054199, 0.05252262204885483, -0.012184555642306805, 0.001287380000576377, 0.008387286216020584, -0.030731039121747017, 0.039472948759794235, -0.026794133707880974, 0.029319772496819496, 0.04713893309235573, 0.00513561861589551, -0.011230187490582466, 0.009688588790595531, -0.01721961796283722, 0.003939197398722172, 0.037260062992572784, -0.025533346459269524, -0.0027300266083329916, 0.03162841498851776, -0.053054239600896835, 0.010575031861662865, 0.02117355726659298, -0.03496239706873894, -0.03885599598288536, 0.01997475139796734, 0.0466679185628891, -0.016296066343784332, 0.05335470661520958, -0.016405751928687096, -0.027328096330165863, -0.005960782989859581, -0.02225464954972267, -0.017367811873555183, -0.027542635798454285, -0.07074666768312454, -0.008552128449082375, 0.023473501205444336, -0.038843847811222076, 0.02602989412844181, -0.03817402198910713, -0.03780853748321533, 0.045592352747917175, -0.0438542477786541, 0.006353490054607391, 0.0019022554624825716, -0.03502649813890457, 0.019653232768177986, -0.008673980832099915, -0.0003300689859315753, 0.014590582810342312, -0.010035308077931404, -0.007299717050045729, 0.06680919229984283, -0.045450884848833084, -0.04221785441040993, -0.04253756254911423, 0.016181284561753273, 0.022455323487520218, -0.005921760108321905, 0.021809283643960953, 0.02226242423057556, -0.004732007160782814, -0.02419857494533062, -0.060817692428827286, -0.058141861110925674, 0.03161226585507393, 0.003936486784368753, 0.026285924017429352, 0.0025200997479259968, -0.0562964528799057, 0.06313983350992203, 0.0018283178796991706, -0.08812904357910156, -0.04638013616204262, -0.005163642577826977, -0.00704026548191905, 0.010062324814498425, 0.029658550396561623, 0.027513140812516212, -0.007899107411503792, -0.006366963963955641, 0.0267060287296772, 0.017548589035868645, 0.03914187103509903, 0.0028883954510092735, -0.01055733859539032, -0.000855489110108465, -0.007528791204094887, -0.020893506705760956, 0.043398480862379074, 0.041905730962753296, -0.04210552200675011, -0.0035304459743201733, 0.025444794446229935, 0.05377680063247681, 0.022445829585194588, -0.03455605357885361, 0.030350392684340477, -0.00256921024993062, 0.013031897135078907, -0.033341821283102036, 0.02146231196820736, 0.025256529450416565, -0.013022647239267826, -0.00610280642285943, -0.0062788911163806915, 0.004891263321042061, -0.015487252734601498, 0.023678500205278397, 0.08021991699934006, 0.029069416224956512, -0.016775570809841156, -0.014458241872489452, -0.0025872071273624897, -0.004346933215856552, 0.0016653601778671145, -0.0242058876901865, -0.04243645817041397, 0.07218186557292938, 0.05987176671624184, -0.007406388409435749, -0.0008765169768594205, -0.0476016029715538, 0.017201051115989685, -0.07446620613336563, -0.028849976137280464, -0.028627591207623482, 0.05974476411938667, -0.010260934941470623, 0.0345291905105114, 0.002237184438854456, -0.006245740689337254, 0.03916209191083908, 0.0033685166854411364, -0.028350243344902992, 0.018009290099143982, -0.006556246429681778, -0.01641346700489521, 0.012811367399990559, -0.02413334883749485, 0.00656064972281456, -0.0532042421400547, 0.03610071912407875, -0.00321538676507771, 0.00637321500107646, -0.02204873599112034, -0.011271637864410877, 0.0010071699507534504, 0.00888806488364935, -0.008490840904414654, 0.015883492305874825, 0.007228425703942776, -0.001593854045495391, 0.028389539569616318, 0.04794124886393547, -0.03414708003401756, -0.0304157342761755, -0.04155184328556061, -0.0032777213491499424, 0.028436170890927315, 0.0698615312576294, 0.03134051710367203, 0.008311616256833076, -0.04955515265464783, 0.03732408210635185, -0.03979695215821266, 0.04536724463105202, 0.030103780329227448, -0.004007746931165457, -0.007792378775775433, -0.02031533233821392, -0.012337219901382923, 0.009810750372707844, 0.005520232021808624, -0.011239273473620415, -0.0029746859800070524, 0.0327635258436203, 0.019160570576786995, -0.06673301756381989, 0.03526615351438522, 0.07234440743923187, 0.021205784752964973, 0.020320959389209747, -0.05939222872257233, -0.008427929133176804, -0.01349327340722084, -0.03624292463064194, 0.0005353779997676611, 0.004508370999246836, 0.01698078028857708, 0.01773643307387829, 0.01666070707142353, 0.015088076703250408, -0.059058982878923416, -0.009894157759845257, -0.03532502055168152, 0.04439413547515869, -0.006532040424644947, -0.041589751839637756, 0.030116006731987, 0.054207999259233475, 0.03301556780934334, 0.00173245242331177, 0.0018420980777591467, -0.14032286405563354, 0.009156612679362297, 0.03053283505141735, 0.05587521940469742, -0.06023996323347092, 0.010311393067240715, -0.015782808884978294, -0.0033410436008125544, 0.04832891747355461, -0.04499880224466324, 0.036152005195617676, -0.035626061260700226, 0.005434785969555378, -0.03411341831088066, -0.013033118098974228, -0.04859807714819908, 0.007109359372407198, -0.014027060009539127, 0.026960281655192375, -0.015288706868886948, -0.01951141655445099, -0.04578705504536629, 0.02204502560198307, 0.01664491556584835, 0.0532812774181366, -0.023824024945497513, -0.012201513163745403, -0.011165045201778412, 0.025659453123807907, -0.015461557544767857, -0.06963391602039337, 0.030432917177677155, -0.011938699521124363, -0.023398905992507935, 0.035652581602334976, 0.007954088971018791, -0.03553955256938934, -0.004239234142005444, 0.0008848588331602514, -0.03418503329157829, -0.0018906507175415754, -0.042830806225538254, 0.02317025326192379, 0.021572301164269447, 0.01613365299999714, -0.006883715745061636, 0.005577060393989086, 0.009967670775949955, 0.001410433673299849, -0.031727708876132965, 0.0076062846928834915, -0.008003056049346924, -0.0084657222032547, -0.02109435945749283, -0.019149141386151314, -0.013038243167102337, 0.023686598986387253, -0.008189101703464985, 0.024410666897892952, -0.02564479224383831, -0.005547677632421255, -0.022294972091913223, -0.012845920398831367, 0.004977821838110685, 0.006634993944317102, -0.002599409781396389, -0.010401786305010319, 0.013179318979382515, -0.03298364207148552, 0.03987971320748329, -0.011210795491933823, -0.007101243827491999, -0.002660169964656234, -0.022364679723978043, 0.0004476973263081163, -0.021883327513933182, -0.029286906123161316, 0.015497781336307526, -0.04701682925224304, -0.0010796599090099335, -0.008355929516255856, 0.015383523888885975, 0.0394577793776989, -0.03411606326699257, -0.04140044376254082, 0.038890767842531204, -0.03249349817633629, 0.023411180824041367, -0.010474969632923603, 0.06936594843864441, -0.007925169542431831, 0.006679091136902571, -0.0622466504573822, -0.06769368052482605, 0.02747735008597374, 0.0140974260866642, -0.022318458184599876, -0.014765815809369087, 0.0033898367546498775, -0.019830763339996338, -0.00430583069100976, 0.023301362991333008, 0.024443315342068672, -0.03004833124577999, -0.025468425825238228, -0.0018481024308130145, -0.025018395856022835, 0.15414674580097198, 0.012668158859014511, -0.004059233237057924, 0.0421413816511631, 0.0061501567251980305, -0.03519942983984947, -0.003703564638271928, 0.045899081975221634, -0.021851124241948128, -0.027718110010027885, -0.024586113169789314, 0.013420598581433296, 0.061447855085134506, -0.02524043247103691, 0.007942503318190575, -0.03201634809374809, 0.017559699714183807, 0.01930432952940464, -0.03185494616627693, 0.028482351452112198, -0.010413486510515213, -0.011800320819020271, 0.0015717772766947746, 0.029210321605205536, -0.04019145295023918, -0.003320632502436638, 0.037347517907619476, 0.03314614295959473, -0.0331796333193779, 0.010956035926938057, 0.06368407607078552, -0.007261455524712801, -0.027772577479481697, -0.001994370948523283, -0.05842234194278717, 0.01265425980091095, 0.02995661273598671, 0.028107794001698494, 0.000501281872857362, 0.050066884607076645, -0.0266492310911417, -0.009286751039326191, -0.042330581694841385, -0.03320474922657013, 0.06778125464916229, 0.008071567863225937, 0.05670987442135811, 0.05118522420525551, 0.007237956393510103, 0.010601705871522427, 0.022599125280976295, 0.007347813341766596, 0.00043952270061708987, 0.017104879021644592, 0.06375075876712799, -0.018951131030917168, -0.003119695233181119, 0.014584718272089958, -0.00959811545908451, 0.0015969750238582492, 0.0039055824745446444, 0.015592951327562332, -0.026070117950439453, 0.02137397974729538, -0.026473991572856903, -0.04459194466471672, 0.021948715671896935, -0.02844024822115898, 0.0037903664633631706, -0.05582534521818161, -0.002157757757231593, 0.03346266224980354, -0.004961440339684486, 0.019702494144439697, -0.05062681436538696, -0.02028852142393589, -0.03134866803884506, -0.019519446417689323, 0.006518213078379631, -0.009789313189685345, 0.019430482760071754, -0.0016695488011464477, 0.05203135311603546, -0.0076697273179888725, 0.049595415592193604, -0.03266041725873947, -0.09559789299964905, -0.03961336240172386, -0.017730940133333206, -0.051824431866407394, 0.019229203462600708, 0.025741824880242348, -0.021202562376856804, -0.014315733686089516, -0.04098760709166527, 0.04700516164302826, 0.009022459387779236, 0.04952669143676758, -0.0294854324311018, 0.052637774497270584, 0.010618230327963829, 0.008527346886694431, 0.034772638231515884, -0.022340284660458565, 0.10509277880191803, 0.09173276275396347, 0.03591187670826912, -0.022318247705698013, 0.03701062127947807, 0.022935573011636734, -0.0015339796664193273, -0.0069124833680689335, 0.007019634358584881, 0.00956315454095602, 0.014686825685203075, 0.042565133422613144, 0.04387791454792023, 0.006507370620965958, -0.012039567343890667, 0.03581894561648369, -0.05270100384950638, -0.0319429375231266, 0.027084965258836746, 0.004421198274940252, 0.01187452394515276, 0.006765294354408979, -0.07250173389911652, 0.0009316939394921064, 0.007489066105335951, 0.013765981420874596, -0.0068395002745091915, -0.006988036446273327, -0.008585342206060886, -0.025729378685355186, -0.03220260515809059, -0.006608833093196154, -0.008265744894742966, 0.025542235001921654, -0.05410657450556755, -0.007155759260058403, 0.012442205101251602, 0.002124161459505558, -0.01745654083788395, 0.04088298976421356, -0.01766739971935749, -0.005104397889226675, 0.0028750505298376083, 0.04898955672979355, -0.029945245012640953, -0.006423870101571083, -0.02652120590209961, 0.01589784026145935, -0.017840487882494926, -0.020814668387174606, -0.008326424285769463, 0.023173773661255836, -0.03488032892346382, -0.023815643042325974, -0.04696936160326004, 0.01651870273053646, -0.007312946021556854, -0.03644513711333275, -0.014668909832835197, -0.01576840877532959, 0.015927668660879135, -0.011570156551897526, -0.007529436610639095, 0.014963921159505844, -0.02053072676062584, -0.027676401659846306, -0.02070087566971779, 0.056646525859832764, 0.0011942294659093022, -0.0023340682964771986, -0.0057626753114163876, -0.04060203954577446, -0.03423670679330826, 0.0022349078208208084, 0.025200361385941505, 0.028547843918204308, -0.017149141058325768, 0.02384074218571186, -0.00596500001847744, -0.007110742852091789, 0.009069833904504776, 0.03048713505268097, -0.011517309583723545, 0.0036103094462305307, -0.04680294543504715, 0.023879919201135635, 0.025925273075699806, 0.06615058332681656, 0.015828829258680344, 0.014825617894530296, 0.024861391633749008, 0.047187067568302155, -0.02541266568005085, -0.04469975456595421, 0.004037380684167147, 0.023693472146987915, -0.04399866610765457, 0.03111484833061695, -0.0008447847212664783, 0.11188853532075882, 0.023867713287472725, 0.0139173474162817, 0.008066495880484581, 0.05158952623605728, -0.013144723139703274, 0.026236506178975105, 0.0035913402680307627, -0.059046611189842224, 0.0033162403851747513, 0.009138839319348335, 0.022968731820583344, -0.03886168450117111, 0.020339472219347954, 0.00895540602505207, -0.03855320066213608, 0.013341180048882961, -0.01514454372227192, -0.02703000418841839, 0.017262548208236694, -0.016676437109708786, 0.012208414264023304, -0.03922172263264656, 0.02472309209406376, -0.035662777721881866, -0.03888406231999397, -0.01961573399603367, -0.029734384268522263, -0.010091256350278854, -0.011751299723982811, -0.0005155386170372367, 0.006209761369973421, 0.0456744022667408, 0.015556924976408482, 0.012443458661437035, -0.04879404604434967, 0.009634784422814846, -0.015468894504010677, 0.022467106580734253, -0.032875653356313705, -0.023182392120361328, 0.04247480258345604, -0.0719027891755104, -0.04392655938863754, 0.015259262174367905, -0.013008548878133297, 0.0355706587433815, -0.0016116795595735312, 0.017453189939260483, -0.00958093162626028, 0.07749998569488525, -0.02303038351237774, -0.03155738487839699, -0.0249651912599802, -0.020638220012187958, 0.02735942415893078, 0.025879688560962677, -0.004735543858259916, -0.0009655460016801953, -0.038704827427864075, 0.001453654607757926, 0.035537801682949066, 0.004048724193125963, -0.024021051824092865, 0.03243096545338631, 0.013102955184876919, -0.0018350202590227127, 0.030967969447374344, -0.005028780084103346, 0.03179001435637474, 0.009397069923579693, -0.06063896045088768, 0.022650117054581642, -0.025092579424381256, 0.013061489909887314, -0.0553879477083683, -0.03565608337521553, 0.020657852292060852, 0.009638036601245403, 0.045122671872377396, -0.052097223699092865, -0.009585537947714329, 0.041993483901023865, -0.02186587266623974, 0.07197479903697968, 0.0012539324816316366, -0.023478588089346886, -0.016265947371721268, 0.02338862419128418, -0.012456153519451618, 0.04290541633963585, 0.03715599700808525, 0.06493399292230606, 0.047040145844221115, -0.0002881440450437367, 0.04140092805027962, 0.002733478555455804, -0.043372880667448044, 0.015805959701538086, -0.00919316615909338, -0.0560823529958725, 0.027927692979574203, -0.038461774587631226, -0.01449412852525711, 0.024491092190146446, -0.005344413220882416, 0.029062222689390182, 0.039851799607276917, -0.00879834033548832, 0.00841134786605835, 0.06093611940741539, 0.005006580613553524, -0.010581242851912975, -0.03619411587715149, 0.019724460318684578, 0.012518252246081829, 0.020436957478523254, -0.012962428852915764, 0.02640889771282673, 0.025985097512602806, -0.005557383876293898, -0.01363531593233347, 0.01698269322514534, -0.02476138435304165, -0.032199349254369736, -0.02604478970170021, 0.0023258146829903126, -0.017646407708525658, -0.04982181265950203, 0.013586013577878475, -0.050563935190439224, 0.027111267670989037, 0.014844723045825958, 0.03962348774075508, -0.041366785764694214, 0.030773108825087547, 0.01720665954053402, -0.03517226129770279, -0.026858076453208923, -0.0004090197617188096, -0.000009861274520517327, -0.024623461067676544, 0.017138613387942314, -0.008492332883179188, -0.017953578382730484, -0.001426398055627942, -0.035107050091028214, -0.03519129380583763, 0.04369521141052246, -0.009324928745627403, 0.012610805220901966, 0.030646303668618202, -0.02431178279221058, -0.005785879213362932, -0.08948887139558792, 0.04684248939156532, 0.01322740875184536, -0.0016599259106442332, -0.03402804210782051, 0.007083666976541281, -0.04695919156074524, 0.006593282800167799, 0.06554918736219406, -0.00811768602579832, 0.009561512619256973, -0.02798343263566494, -0.007857629097998142, -0.006597073283046484, -0.0444343164563179, 0.03037930838763714, 0.003769371658563614, -0.0200689435005188, -0.035841651260852814, -0.011337603442370892, 0.019515935331583023, 0.025004679337143898, 0.040698595345020294, 0.01072351261973381, -0.01786402240395546, -0.026781896129250526, -0.01985761523246765, 0.03134922683238983, 0.009828121401369572, -0.014542274177074432, 0.06843285262584686, -0.0003180711355526, 0.015705402940511703, 0.011103826574981213, -0.010841435752809048, -0.05219174921512604, 0.0169272068887949, -0.015459720976650715, -0.01873026043176651, -0.01718449592590332, 0.003042895346879959, -0.012320208363234997, -0.03649887815117836, 0.005648252088576555, 0.022763481363654137, -0.02805786393582821, -0.030603887513279915, 0.016518348827958107, 0.03142339363694191, 0.0034716620575636625, -0.03369717299938202, 0.01850462704896927, -0.001699374639429152, -0.05067351087927818, 0.02121623605489731, 0.054585326462984085, 0.03785960003733635, 0.011486461386084557, 0.04144304245710373, 0.03628021478652954, 0.014157000929117203, 0.006081570405513048, 0.023389918729662895, 0.04206343740224838, -0.034026116132736206, -0.004273839294910431, 0.006560719572007656, -0.00508153485134244, 0.0245234165340662, 0.013284439221024513, -0.002619917271658778, 0.034866608679294586, -0.037124574184417725, 0.003763047279790044, -0.05188878998160362, -0.02001608908176422, -0.037508636713027954, -0.004284752067178488, 0.022051269188523293, 0.0278200451284647, 0.007602923549711704, -0.003032954642549157, 0.02329792082309723, 0.011724731884896755, 0.0026485936250537634, 0.01524089090526104, 0.03265314921736717, -0.021274277940392494, -0.039353467524051666, 0.01259865052998066, 0.0029053078033030033, -0.03788676857948303, 0.007057617884129286, 0.037502992898225784, 0.06041889265179634, 0.02642291598021984, 0.009928005747497082, -0.015453801490366459, -0.019599564373493195, 0.04301048815250397, -0.01431820448487997, -0.018923822790384293, -0.04398634284734726, 0.011782943271100521, -0.032387349754571915, -0.04619091749191284 ]
<p>I have some data which works nicely with JMP's canned linear discriminant analysis (LDA), but after <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_discriminant_analysis" rel="nofollow">reading about LDA</a> I'm not sure if the analysis is valid. The Wiki article notes a fundamental assumption of LDA is that independent variables are normally distributed. Does this also mean that I cannot use LDA if my variables have any correlation whatsoever? Also, supposing I have or transform to independent variables-- then I must also test if they are normally distributed (say, Shapiro-Wilk test) and only use those that pass in the LDA? </p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,635
[ -0.04004397615790367, -0.02047223038971424, 0.029258793219923973, -0.017115922644734383, 0.06473561376333237, -0.023150501772761345, -0.04698023945093155, -0.01625206507742405, 0.04183438792824745, -0.03079185262322426, 0.044005874544382095, 0.0003447711351327598, 0.048803042620420456, 0.038987286388874054, 0.026733001694083214, 0.025751275941729546, -0.021971488371491432, 0.018257198855280876, -0.004297683481127024, 0.015799079090356827, -0.02640187181532383, 0.030430663377046585, 0.038265664130449295, -0.019029831513762474, -0.01944923959672451, 0.04588319733738899, -0.0436706505715847, -0.027637798339128494, 0.017371874302625656, 0.04083077237010002, -0.01705618016421795, -0.016998792067170143, 0.0025276814121752977, 0.060400109738111496, -0.013963584788143635, 0.0001762846513884142, -0.02013866975903511, -0.02712291106581688, 0.026894094422459602, 0.04040028154850006, -0.022558048367500305, -0.04282275587320328, 0.031527481973171234, 0.059588585048913956, -0.011200735345482826, 0.033803198486566544, 0.01825902797281742, -0.033525362610816956, 0.04544803500175476, -0.029069501906633377, 0.08394845575094223, 0.011723854579031467, 0.03917931392788887, 0.03231848403811455, -0.014195678755640984, 0.00315299304202199, 0.04173589497804642, 0.06194679066538811, -0.02054549567401409, -0.04729429632425308, -0.01625872403383255, -0.03826535865664482, 0.009549184702336788, 0.0030109661165624857, -0.022712627425789833, 0.03748522698879242, 0.004872288089245558, -0.02664470672607422, 0.04491208866238594, -0.008477753028273582, 0.02711276151239872, 0.019279636442661285, 0.046387117356061935, -0.016709601506590843, 0.004372662398964167, -0.019345490261912346, 0.01779979094862938, -0.0010408293455839157, 0.017835868522524834, 0.018737811595201492, 0.007108656223863363, 0.025510571897029877, -0.020259525626897812, 0.051095232367515564, 0.039227426052093506, -0.02205222100019455, 0.06944787502288818, -0.02980540506541729, 0.013927062042057514, 0.030971163883805275, 0.009882437996566296, -0.008828244172036648, 0.03437032923102379, 0.0255905594676733, -0.04216274246573448, 0.032387446612119675, -0.0037690172903239727, 0.036386992782354355, -0.00673292251303792, -0.02796860784292221, -0.01357609685510397, -0.02325046993792057, -0.015835385769605637, 0.03284821659326553, -0.019729088991880417, -0.012429115362465382, -0.05180009827017784, 0.03851009160280228, -0.006302429363131523, -0.027386920526623726, -0.02459603361785412, 0.02820477820932865, 0.02485670894384384, -0.019719671458005905, 0.02284318581223488, 0.012308265082538128, -0.023882417008280754, 0.005872031208127737, 0.029984120279550552, 0.04381740093231201, 0.024129336699843407, -0.03311249241232872, 0.02501905895769596, -0.011665324680507183, -0.029727699235081673, 0.01768646016716957, -0.0048708561807870865, 0.01496769767254591, -0.0511603057384491, 0.07044369727373123, -0.001125770970247686, -0.03636716306209564, 0.030015237629413605, 0.004892502445727587, 0.02127685956656933, -0.005017607007175684, -0.05476812645792961, -0.053947143256664276, 0.0144901592284441, -0.029787620529532433, 0.029986603185534477, -0.07091962546110153, -0.033780235797166824, 0.013831119984388351, 0.04260306432843208, -0.025756344199180603, 0.03618441894650459, 0.010971409268677235, 0.015288174152374268, -0.0036508566699922085, -0.05395878106355667, -0.03030882216989994, -0.024399640038609505, -0.04836089164018631, -0.0035626746248453856, -0.06718555092811584, 0.0033209994435310364, 0.013092520646750927, -0.021520240232348442, -0.031180741265416145, 0.038327816873788834, 0.03797965869307518, 0.002775588072836399, -0.005293669179081917, 0.010344507172703743, -0.026458842679858208, 0.05128859728574753, -0.017078068107366562, 0.028160594403743744, 0.005559882614761591, 0.002269469201564789, 0.020665781572461128, 0.012970288284122944, 0.05994904413819313, 0.05781106650829315, -0.022896839305758476, -0.004835036583244801, -0.04056985676288605, 0.055593859404325485, -0.012284906581044197, -0.0709858387708664, 0.006872898433357477, -0.03718222677707672, 0.005305807571858168, -0.022653840482234955, 0.03295840695500374, 0.00925576314330101, 0.003371433587744832, 0.008108709938824177, -0.03757761791348457, -0.01947808265686035, -0.02535891719162464, -0.006158157717436552, -0.02660403586924076, -0.04361090064048767, 0.042919889092445374, 0.03889153525233269, 0.07122590392827988, 0.0027688690461218357, -0.027559077367186546, -0.036329809576272964, -0.03274308890104294, 0.04900950938463211, -0.018678318709135056, 0.0037336626555770636, 0.02579118311405182, 0.019662247970700264, -0.02623552829027176, 0.02240591123700142, -0.028988653793931007, -0.05302411690354347, 0.01642613112926483, -0.030661175027489662, 0.030160794034600258, 0.04269177094101906, 0.011594776064157486, 0.010305473580956459, 0.018770277500152588, -0.0184430293738842, 0.031056784093379974, -0.037224382162094116, 0.03844428062438965, 0.003476602490991354, 0.0010735911782830954, -0.001093884464353323, 0.01317486073821783, 0.01678769290447235, 0.022255009040236473, -0.012897582724690437, -0.018496770411729813, -0.05401957035064697, -0.017926588654518127, 0.03425101190805435, 0.006696394644677639, -0.06843680143356323, 0.04756233096122742, 0.09354560077190399, 0.015308096073567867, -0.0064591532573103905, 0.028817206621170044, 0.0034394448157399893, -0.016004890203475952, -0.022772809490561485, 0.034963127225637436, -0.0010337918065488338, 0.013384364545345306, -0.03901655226945877, 0.0024308471474796534, 0.07611564546823502, 0.01203857734799385, -0.022193552926182747, 0.039854809641838074, -0.00014510631444863975, -0.0014499388635158539, 0.020077724009752274, -0.0015773006016388535, 0.05785100534558296, -0.006508233956992626, 0.028227882459759712, 0.07297097891569138, 0.012221076525747776, -0.016448793932795525, -0.004247222561389208, 0.0030010014306753874, 0.028836047276854515, 0.03601112589240074, -0.02762819267809391, 0.027022793889045715, 0.01697671227157116, -0.04837919771671295, 0.0016567824641242623, -0.008756201714277267, -0.017402885481715202, -0.034678488969802856, -0.00212329369969666, 0.02213335409760475, 0.006371593102812767, 0.055716004222631454, -0.005370666738599539, -0.02832372859120369, -0.007031200919300318, -0.020715955644845963, 0.023757396265864372, -0.007547459099441767, -0.07004915177822113, -0.029522694647312164, -0.000495235959533602, -0.026335114613175392, 0.02658616378903389, -0.013187183998525143, 0.001693997299298644, 0.03385985270142555, -0.008099864237010479, -0.055727194994688034, -0.05481624975800514, -0.0002843238180503249, 0.060289911925792694, -0.04060307517647743, -0.03584440425038338, 0.03913697227835655, 0.02281167544424534, -0.029377195984125137, -0.022673826664686203, -0.03138665109872818, -0.0499265231192112, -0.03944021835923195, -0.007803738117218018, 0.02532179281115532, -0.009361984208226204, -0.006215437315404415, 0.0252867192029953, -0.06580618023872375, 0.00928308255970478, -0.07213333249092102, -0.09164538234472275, 0.04326673969626427, 0.050322890281677246, 0.03921160474419594, 0.02424965426325798, -0.027875259518623352, 0.07488149404525757, 0.031081877648830414, -0.05455256998538971, -0.05084807053208351, 0.008319847285747528, -0.07765460014343262, -0.036772459745407104, -0.0015948842046782374, -0.0021383892744779587, 0.020359141752123833, 0.04823130741715431, -0.01679026335477829, 0.004205043893307447, 0.03856579214334488, -0.03429428115487099, -0.0208438690751791, 0.025247039273381233, 0.010412884876132011, -0.03182259574532509, 0.007529971189796925, 0.03369984030723572, -0.03899338096380234, -0.006755227223038673, 0.015562101267278194, 0.025254402309656143, 0.019256966188549995, -0.03595903515815735, 0.013975952751934528, -0.025463681668043137, 0.02796177566051483, -0.037919219583272934, -0.028128406032919884, 0.03672150894999504, -0.000942701066378504, 0.0182916559278965, -0.00895219761878252, 0.034563783556222916, -0.017747336998581886, 0.02553343027830124, 0.05862767994403839, 0.0012377831153571606, 0.0028262450359761715, -0.003422085428610444, -0.003928812686353922, -0.023017650470137596, 0.010693090036511421, 0.006528273690491915, 0.017938660457730293, 0.046895723789930344, 0.02934717945754528, 0.0038056850899010897, -0.01080531720072031, -0.027495557442307472, 0.021634787321090698, -0.06862851977348328, 0.040197111666202545, -0.02958652563393116, 0.007905710488557816, 0.007797269616276026, 0.042641300708055496, 0.05057581886649132, 0.0060095167718827724, -0.0005007577710784972, 0.018046094104647636, -0.07048692554235458, 0.013747802935540676, -0.03588974103331566, -0.019054044038057327, 0.015033593401312828, -0.03692197799682617, -0.0029382111970335245, -0.006189713720232248, -0.0098615363240242, 0.016099251806735992, 0.044527746737003326, -0.034083813428878784, 0.007444216404110193, -0.01443617232143879, -0.02677267976105213, -0.012509462423622608, 0.005496339872479439, -0.01168848667293787, -0.003886258229613304, 0.0292076226323843, 0.045932117849588394, -0.0019225309370085597, -0.021144697442650795, -0.03917858749628067, 0.015574472025036812, 0.02228197269141674, 0.07565788924694061, -0.0012031042715534568, 0.024384113028645515, -0.014964943751692772, 0.025068357586860657, -0.014650355093181133, 0.04395267367362976, 0.008376569487154484, -0.010197436437010765, -0.020691437646746635, -0.05825214087963104, -0.022762175649404526, -0.0053971135057508945, 0.008653318509459496, 0.01751292496919632, 0.004107718821614981, 0.04585082083940506, 0.02643710933625698, -0.027006108313798904, 0.009970289655029774, 0.055338870733976364, 0.022608060389757156, 0.009637936018407345, -0.012833422981202602, 0.007337945979088545, 0.006197491195052862, -0.01741241104900837, 0.02789432555437088, 0.013551547192037106, 0.00448064599186182, -0.021574584767222404, 0.04729161411523819, -0.01942945271730423, -0.015427024103701115, 0.001699663931503892, 0.02537955343723297, 0.04875630885362625, -0.01870420016348362, -0.032015591859817505, 0.04972612485289574, 0.04414777830243111, -0.0024053039960563183, 0.015905248001217842, 0.009040563367307186, -0.07313332706689835, 0.017812754958868027, 0.019075848162174225, 0.04058275371789932, -0.03718460351228714, 0.005810552276670933, -0.04254616051912308, -0.021103784441947937, 0.033227674663066864, -0.005884950514882803, 0.01448268536478281, 0.022848205640912056, 0.026840252801775932, -0.008549666963517666, 0.0026825270615518093, -0.06174546480178833, 0.0020401296205818653, -0.00964877475053072, 0.013282384723424911, -0.03673378750681877, -0.06785435974597931, -0.05828181654214859, 0.028947535902261734, -0.004290489014238119, 0.03580321744084358, -0.016432853415608406, 0.005484435241669416, 0.008486811071634293, 0.03978267312049866, -0.03453455865383148, -0.06098026782274246, 0.003533951472491026, 0.028312217444181442, -0.023609941825270653, 0.042941126972436905, -0.012898012064397335, -0.02975153923034668, 0.002986048348248005, 0.00854475237429142, -0.021282151341438293, 0.01376380492001772, 0.02580690197646618, 0.03831744194030762, -0.009856888093054295, 0.009778843261301517, 0.04232152923941612, 0.03283178433775902, -0.020119035616517067, -0.03254963457584381, -0.006438021548092365, 0.03444818779826164, -0.048498719930648804, 0.0062120468355715275, -0.03834542632102966, -0.02155197784304619, -0.013734855689108372, 0.006640927866101265, -0.03391018882393837, 0.036771051585674286, -0.02712724544107914, 0.023148467764258385, -0.005497022066265345, 0.005480197258293629, -0.042990002781152725, -0.041395723819732666, -0.05305119976401329, 0.025273218750953674, -0.014875492081046104, -0.013880443759262562, 0.02567179873585701, -0.04352457448840141, -0.0038723652251064777, 0.00955921970307827, -0.039409954100847244, -0.0024312608875334263, 0.0015284866094589233, -0.023189768195152283, 0.031125038862228394, -0.016145244240760803, 0.043497566133737564, 0.03132389858365059, 0.058567583560943604, 0.023407474160194397, -0.04396490752696991, 0.03669963404536247, 0.013748377561569214, 0.0006876690895296633, 0.0371251106262207, -0.0213590320199728, 0.02075999602675438, -0.04825986921787262, -0.010423718951642513, -0.035184361040592194, -0.04157787188887596, -0.02040376141667366, 0.00776436273008585, 0.00015796045772731304, -0.028566157445311546, -0.017950385808944702, 0.014577695168554783, -0.010645553469657898, -0.00987838301807642, 0.057127695530653, -0.02149597741663456, -0.023764431476593018, 0.026316635310649872, 0.010920082218945026, 0.08796707540750504, -0.007522542029619217, 0.002230219077318907, 0.0017346972599625587, -0.013042272068560123, -0.011466067284345627, 0.008563353680074215, 0.013678930699825287, -0.02659379132091999, 0.013528185896575451, -0.016260923817753792, 0.0034574028104543686, 0.05103810131549835, -0.02944173850119114, -0.028309736400842667, -0.021264392882585526, -0.03528382256627083, 0.002339201746508479, -0.016867635771632195, -0.005003333557397127, -0.02968219481408596, -0.009888894855976105, -0.005436364561319351, -0.018943630158901215, -0.026651645079255104, 0.00022095284657552838, 0.017234284430742264, -0.017028914764523506, 0.026379266753792763, 0.037670351564884186, 0.05318162217736244, 0.0035685596521943808, 0.03910345584154129, -0.012354125268757343, -0.03398410975933075, 0.024643035605549812, -0.00729366997256875, 0.025599302724003792, -0.010280969552695751, 0.015575923025608063, -0.017474215477705002, -0.07873932272195816, -0.034310534596443176, 0.005823880899697542, 0.03757039085030556, 0.025052402168512344, 0.029392264783382416, 0.07913298159837723, 0.015086928382515907, -0.001837259391322732, -0.06039508804678917, -0.004200303461402655, 0.009631109423935413, -0.010912480764091015, 0.06575991958379745, 0.028072664514183998, -0.02930575981736183, 0.0565713606774807, 0.03279649838805199, 0.03393707051873207, 0.044128820300102234, 0.01173133123666048, -0.01853788085281849, 0.03578373044729233, 0.03824756294488907, -0.06453732401132584, 0.013759952038526535, -0.05392298102378845, 0.020966382697224617, -0.020229976624250412, -0.015298128128051758, 0.01787203550338745, 0.0570681206882, -0.005034881643950939, -0.05436423420906067, -0.03397481516003609, -0.034797050058841705, 0.03869855776429176, 0.03361302241683006, 0.00500180060043931, 0.04147704318165779, -0.001973632723093033, 0.05273584648966789, -0.018569517880678177, 0.025154761970043182, 0.011791639029979706, -0.06608379632234573, -0.0334351621568203, -0.042826853692531586, -0.009615808725357056, 0.04298744723200798, -0.009922652505338192, -0.012231566943228245, 0.003880350850522518, -0.029827876016497612, 0.018211625516414642, -0.001672039390541613, 0.03334940969944, 0.014502701349556446, 0.05838024243712425, -0.009949839673936367, 0.015493253245949745, -0.005662593990564346, -0.01664843037724495, 0.1132102683186531, 0.03453335165977478, 0.03400687500834465, -0.04807034507393837, 0.02632198855280876, 0.0020849367137998343, 0.002314817626029253, -0.026608018204569817, 0.029735172167420387, -0.014692519791424274, 0.005565138999372721, 0.035547710955142975, 0.01494507398456335, -0.011003347113728523, 0.00013846209913026541, 0.065442755818367, -0.03127848356962204, -0.028006330132484436, 0.052819520235061646, 0.010065545327961445, -0.04076002538204193, -0.02489505149424076, -0.01332893781363964, 0.0268977340310812, -0.005715859122574329, -0.03202518820762634, -0.01348179392516613, -0.014156714081764221, 0.02394704893231392, -0.014742651954293251, -0.041064485907554626, 0.021085068583488464, 0.05054757744073868, 0.048963841050863266, -0.033751148730516434, -0.02107357606291771, 0.03570215404033661, -0.02140793576836586, 0.01482662558555603, -0.0026816565077751875, -0.007387490011751652, -0.014308614656329155, 0.038275379687547684, -0.02434822916984558, -0.028136925771832466, -0.034885384142398834, -0.0420374721288681, 0.02537679858505726, 0.013812491670250893, -0.01349713746458292, -0.01645503006875515, -0.009722734801471233, -0.020183654502034187, -0.08643460273742676, -0.00726281525567174, 0.012837870046496391, 0.030357157811522484, -0.009892174042761326, -0.0306641086935997, -0.059870120137929916, 0.000757589063141495, -0.005784174893051386, 0.018498670309782028, -0.004775017965584993, 0.01877247728407383, 0.04033920541405678, -0.01835811324417591, 0.05270273610949516, 0.0077617294155061245, -0.014500705525279045, -0.0874587893486023, -0.00838503148406744, -0.0363377146422863, -0.018592873588204384, 0.0196531992405653, 0.02684250846505165, 0.040517352521419525, 0.016084671020507812, -0.022174257785081863, -0.02780253440141678, -0.06828749924898148, 0.03977590799331665, -0.01866847462952137, -0.04344556853175163, -0.024691175669431686, 0.030707981437444687, 0.06162193417549133, 0.05039668455719948, 0.022364027798175812, -0.012099014595150948, -0.023983679711818695, 0.05924005061388016, 0.0034597215708345175, -0.04581169784069061, -0.012323768809437752, -0.004178589675575495, -0.01676069013774395, 0.01899247244000435, 0.004187998361885548, 0.03995509073138237, 0.03705446794629097, -0.006519501097500324, -0.02841590717434883, 0.02853725664317608, -0.023014575242996216, -0.00494152819737792, 0.018533911556005478, -0.026891950517892838, 0.012965778820216656, 0.0089876102283597, 0.014910656027495861, -0.020593099296092987, -0.01968158408999443, -0.05835271254181862, -0.027534684166312218, 0.017903069034218788, 0.008322888985276222, -0.02290273644030094, -0.04580716788768768, -0.01385016180574894, 0.01021945383399725, -0.014963873662054539, 0.007198923733085394, -0.03467782586812973, 0.02906208485364914, -0.033859603106975555, 0.0071879662573337555, 0.013064421713352203, 0.0006500590825453401, -0.017259368672966957, 0.0210682712495327, 0.07240460813045502, 0.0341193825006485, -0.0035825578961521387, -0.014943706803023815, 0.014388130977749825, -0.017850415781140327, 0.07379098981618881, -0.02305193990468979, 0.02096743695437908, 0.0348287932574749, -0.036419063806533813, -0.011655163019895554, 0.025049502030014992, 0.01475575566291809, 0.00650073541328311, 0.005731185898184776, 0.021641919389367104, -0.028376024216413498, 0.04624543711543083, -0.0052009280771017075, 0.0011174080427736044, -0.007648138329386711, -0.013087970204651356, 0.009908990003168583, 0.009925499558448792, 0.01443425938487053, 0.007650441490113735, -0.02046504057943821, 0.06757329404354095, 0.028459103778004646, 0.016656557098031044, 0.0002589587529655546, 0.015591745264828205, -0.0049966746009886265, 0.018999464809894562, -0.019145015627145767, -0.012966526672244072, 0.04641061648726463, 0.05429761856794357, 0.00669877091422677, 0.04286768659949303, 0.016923094168305397, 0.02777649462223053, -0.09788274765014648, 0.0012104357592761517, -0.03971077501773834, 0.020482907071709633, 0.02805001474916935, -0.038006652146577835, -0.0028000527527183294, 0.0314909890294075, -0.023671794682741165, -0.021308913826942444, -0.00332429027184844, -0.03425198793411255, -0.030391819775104523, 0.017559129744768143, 0.01296267006546259, 0.005098888650536537, 0.013368978165090084, -0.010178869590163231, 0.016539182513952255, 0.041238121688365936, 0.015406398102641106, 0.032309409230947495, -0.03239823877811432, -0.01965506561100483, 0.010591939091682434, -0.06694512069225311, 0.011127815581858158, -0.03989652544260025, -0.06050732359290123, 0.02648509107530117, -0.017046064138412476, 0.030819522216916084, 0.016689153388142586, 0.030695542693138123, 0.03230716660618782, 0.02720319665968418, 0.0636005625128746, -0.0027451757341623306, -0.008398124948143959, 0.005781619809567928, 0.03183935210108757, 0.031367238610982895, -0.02429133467376232, -0.010955785401165485, -0.009838176891207695, -0.05186081305146217, -0.04196222499012947, 0.014189680106937885, -0.01684601418673992, 0.008072216995060444, 0.001399922533892095, -0.0183298010379076, 0.005044207908213139, -0.010012103244662285, 0.04642396420240402, -0.03965841606259346, -0.003967594355344772, 0.03317522257566452, 0.039488356560468674, -0.046937886625528336, 0.03241673856973648, 0.002524986630305648, -0.05104551836848259, 0.015011812560260296, 0.0275290347635746, -0.02464403584599495, -0.03847750648856163, 0.008785453625023365, -0.02103339694440365, -0.03159767761826515, -0.06377667188644409, -0.001816373085603118, -0.04913434013724327, 0.06087503209710121, -0.027839919552206993, 0.02492966316640377, 0.032990433275699615, -0.05466870591044426, 0.005578446667641401, -0.07648979872465134, 0.08085133880376816, 0.01253859605640173, -0.020315194502472878, -0.03233174979686737, 0.006708772387355566, -0.03203951194882393, -0.009087560698390007, 0.03189085051417351, -0.004794400651007891, 0.05490889772772789, -0.006169058382511139, 0.004836409352719784, -0.017835162580013275, -0.03530365601181984, 0.029924292117357254, 0.003469511168077588, -0.007009906694293022, -0.013405922800302505, -0.0144555838778615, -0.03280935063958168, -0.01446828804910183, 0.026732977479696274, -0.027943871915340424, 0.034850701689720154, 0.010316764935851097, -0.023249829187989235, 0.02745998091995716, -0.005227274261415005, -0.032787024974823, 0.04523847624659538, -0.010677454993128777, 0.040927570313215256, 0.04305582121014595, -0.033205099403858185, -0.059945713728666306, 0.0374334491789341, -0.032616183161735535, -0.03501587361097336, -0.004927793517708778, 0.057349078357219696, -0.01934875175356865, -0.036041129380464554, 0.016833433881402016, 0.03636418655514717, -0.023978451266884804, -0.030362777411937714, 0.016715871170163155, 0.017035644501447678, 0.0037375425454229116, -0.0008432093309238553, -0.0042486474849283695, 0.01868375390768051, -0.03923024609684944, 0.028050826862454414, -0.0019868877716362476, 0.020165039226412773, -0.023386100307106972, -0.024089187383651733, 0.014768484979867935, 0.012148396112024784, 0.01891571655869484, -0.030995724722743034, 0.05827612429857254, -0.056460388004779816, 0.0001742665481287986, 0.013618922792375088, 0.022429142147302628, 0.042470041662454605, 0.017627373337745667, -0.014661429449915886, 0.038570210337638855, -0.02930091880261898, 0.0028658085502684116, -0.04831145703792572, -0.03509800136089325, -0.016273099929094315, 0.0012154971482232213, -0.007249504327774048, 0.016649674624204636, -0.002351967617869377, 0.0045656743459403515, -0.00721810944378376, -0.04601573944091797, 0.03455892205238342, -0.005119943525642157, -0.00911937840282917, -0.004428789485245943, -0.0018100375309586525, -0.021860666573047638, -0.016499560326337814, -0.008838779293000698, -0.010450142435729504, -0.013199284672737122, 0.038724444806575775, -0.0015190140111371875, -0.06430530548095703, -0.009319862350821495, -0.010244443081319332, 0.036198925226926804, -0.04145406559109688, -0.033279936760663986, -0.04746063053607941, 0.023161746561527252, 0.011596869677305222, 0.013392666354775429 ]
<p>I apologize in advance if the question is rather simple, but I have been having a difficult time figuring it out. </p> <p>I am an experimental scientist interested in modeling human disease with induced pluripotent stem cells. The disease is fairly common, but doesn't have a common genetic basis. It is mainly driven by rare genetic variants of high penetrance but in a small number of individuals. </p> <p>For (let's say) 5 patients out of 1000 screened affected cases, we are able to strongly associate mutations in one gene with the condition. These mutations are completely absent from a control population of 5000 individuals. </p> <p>We have made stem cells from 2 of those individuals to determine whether these mutations result in cellular dysfunction (let's call this phenotype A) when compared to controls. We have several stem cell lines per individual. In this situation, phenotype A is an 'intermediate phenotype'.</p> <p>The big conceptual question for me is this: Am I modeling the disease or am I only modeling the effect of the disease-associated mutations on cellular function? How can I determine the sample size to test the former claim with, say, 80% power?</p>
73,636
[ -0.03371989727020264, -0.017651813104748726, 0.005765869282186031, -0.034466784447431564, 0.02480904757976532, 0.012259730137884617, -0.021406173706054688, -0.024783596396446228, 0.016341183334589005, 0.00568151380866766, 0.0806426852941513, 0.01579173654317856, 0.04502066224813461, -0.029086489230394363, -0.013749675825238228, 0.014760874211788177, -0.0418606773018837, -0.0038778739981353283, -0.022130252793431282, 0.0024326536804437637, 0.02239881083369255, -0.003434775397181511, 0.019855922088027, -0.0075603146106004715, -0.0416286364197731, 0.02325287088751793, 0.007195900660008192, -0.019785134121775627, 0.00527547812089324, 0.0707775428891182, -0.020135223865509033, -0.022255847230553627, 0.022538553923368454, 0.06518564373254776, 0.005390328820794821, 0.01982332393527031, -0.045427508652210236, -0.02165152132511139, -0.009335880167782307, 0.0387108251452446, -0.01493909489363432, -0.0031338215339928865, -0.01636158861219883, 0.015899263322353363, 0.0062177907675504684, -0.008158700540661812, 0.0002957390679512173, -0.03167710453271866, 0.029065560549497604, -0.05850045382976532, 0.06108362600207329, 0.012286391109228134, 0.06754070520401001, 0.023328283801674843, 0.01777803711593151, -0.014076333492994308, 0.038582608103752136, 0.08902905881404877, -0.0038482770323753357, -0.05165531486272812, -0.040755998343229294, -0.01431515533477068, -0.009637527167797089, -0.03302096202969551, -0.060268584638834, 0.05832739174365997, -0.019843395799398422, -0.02468089945614338, 0.03779608756303787, -0.016258077695965767, 0.05214809998869896, 0.011275846511125565, 0.03286733478307724, 0.000060193331592017785, 0.012926673516631126, -0.01666197180747986, 0.019907517358660698, 0.03155839815735817, 0.01675425097346306, 0.035748325288295746, -0.06432200223207474, 0.006652019917964935, 0.020690953359007835, 0.03977265581488609, 0.0008604009635746479, -0.030878981575369835, 0.02477346919476986, -0.058522097766399384, 0.01783168502151966, 0.007222713436931372, -0.061482034623622894, -0.03090190701186657, 0.0768030658364296, -0.012950094416737556, -0.03633886203169823, 0.020674044266343117, -0.022208930924534798, 0.03939957916736603, 0.00477581424638629, 0.007671610452234745, -0.0467253178358078, -0.04433437064290047, 0.013558674603700638, 0.061466678977012634, -0.01793384552001953, -0.016831060871481895, 0.007972288876771927, -0.031331680715084076, -0.0014062343398109078, -0.0233930516988039, -0.017207155004143715, 0.015429328195750713, 0.021844737231731415, 0.030292252078652382, 0.02851295657455921, 0.010528532788157463, -0.023953933268785477, -0.020487098023295403, 0.08446846157312393, 0.06102781370282173, 0.0470169261097908, -0.04589724913239479, 0.021908670663833618, -0.01148573774844408, -0.000028588316126842983, 0.024066774174571037, 0.002808584365993738, -0.021037526428699493, -0.04623381793498993, 0.03505636751651764, 0.02819022163748741, 0.0014410745352506638, 0.025854235514998436, -0.024198129773139954, 0.07671525329351425, -0.008899793960154057, -0.07027582079172134, -0.04724579676985741, 0.03769563511013985, 0.004632557742297649, -0.0167482178658247, -0.06011012941598892, -0.015427005477249622, 0.05239579826593399, 0.07181089371442795, -0.002386518055573106, 0.038607049733400345, -0.006595941726118326, 0.03382519632577896, 0.019601989537477493, -0.023885076865553856, 0.00041868671542033553, -0.037674665451049805, 0.022220399230718613, -0.022709572687745094, -0.07697279006242752, 0.009123250842094421, 0.03379753604531288, -0.01259742584079504, -0.011124830693006516, 0.025397224351763725, -0.013810914009809494, 0.014612686820328236, -0.008350362069904804, -0.019304214045405388, -0.0001981089444598183, 0.056004203855991364, -0.03564473241567612, 0.0354132354259491, 0.056871991604566574, 0.009258539415895939, 0.020132476463913918, 0.07053198665380478, 0.05608585476875305, 0.03018827736377716, 0.0026381290517747402, 0.01370356697589159, -0.029384737834334373, 0.004641598556190729, 0.04074881970882416, -0.03471933305263519, 0.019713953137397766, -0.009270799346268177, 0.01644863374531269, 0.04470536485314369, 0.013423647731542587, -0.014096163213253021, -0.04213952645659447, 0.029975302517414093, -0.051003459841012955, -0.06219349801540375, -0.07472216337919235, -0.017477618530392647, -0.00807142909616232, -0.016054900363087654, 0.02118110843002796, -0.03117562271654606, 0.026879632845520973, -0.05647701397538185, -0.0076575372368097305, -0.05138497054576874, -0.017392650246620178, 0.035166338086128235, -0.010200046002864838, 0.023146282881498337, 0.0329374261200428, 0.0344822034239769, -0.03465697169303894, 0.046944793313741684, -0.00585669931024313, -0.0434296578168869, -0.0022561231162399054, -0.05144830048084259, 0.051457859575748444, -0.001623906777240336, -0.009497341699898243, -0.016677187755703926, -0.026168715208768845, 0.007256444543600082, 0.058656398206949234, -0.022142348811030388, 0.08672019094228745, 0.02004205621778965, 0.01548337284475565, 0.021527158096432686, -0.009678351692855358, 0.009472986683249474, -0.00947057269513607, -0.021732067689299583, 0.001685066963545978, -0.04733213409781456, -0.0017284535570070148, 0.05088398978114128, 0.00490175886079669, -0.021795861423015594, -0.006897582206875086, 0.026712026447057724, -0.010416410863399506, 0.016039617359638214, 0.018248826265335083, -0.014100629836320877, 0.01738390512764454, 0.019725028425455093, 0.01534915342926979, 0.03580934926867485, 0.025102881714701653, 0.029516248032450676, -0.02843610942363739, 0.00665134796872735, -0.022561965510249138, -0.010806120932102203, 0.02791813388466835, 0.009078988805413246, 0.003401755355298519, -0.04061552509665489, -0.010414465330541134, 0.021146394312381744, 0.0015971570974215865, 0.005963605362921953, 0.021610267460346222, -0.02329634502530098, -0.0010410778922960162, -0.03006155416369438, -0.004935869947075844, 0.020981725305318832, 0.0165527556091547, -0.032597143203020096, 0.026031922549009323, 0.009796717204153538, -0.02859634719789028, 0.0012321241665631533, -0.00709141930565238, -0.013414673507213593, -0.031159844249486923, 0.005316803697496653, 0.03602433577179909, 0.00861282180994749, 0.07820157706737518, -0.024189379066228867, -0.03587166965007782, 0.01453318540006876, -0.02414139360189438, 0.050842784345149994, 0.05782518908381462, -0.07776015251874924, -0.0010555285261943936, -0.019261160865426064, -0.02603037841618061, 0.04362698644399643, -0.018350781872868538, -0.03147368133068085, 0.003426118055358529, 0.012995384633541107, -0.05382654443383217, -0.01950443722307682, -0.02786034345626831, 0.01707339473068714, -0.006953672505915165, -0.009161184541881084, 0.026196500286459923, 0.01785348728299141, -0.030476680025458336, 0.060727138072252274, 0.0037274037022143602, 0.00691897002980113, 0.03242968022823334, 0.008771849796175957, -0.005499935708940029, -0.024689285084605217, 0.020385602489113808, 0.03948249667882919, -0.031628064811229706, -0.013024200685322285, -0.043394461274147034, -0.09431222081184387, 0.021750016137957573, -0.029421430081129074, 0.04217483475804329, -0.01376807689666748, -0.035520005971193314, 0.07148099690675735, 0.03852514177560806, -0.011602639220654964, -0.01587386056780815, -0.020009877160191536, -0.022197557613253593, -0.033971212804317474, 0.025315463542938232, 0.0429510623216629, -0.027376355603337288, -0.00943387858569622, 0.0002061040431726724, 0.0276752058416605, 0.028354398906230927, 0.01116310153156519, -0.0011066285660490394, 0.039748985320329666, 0.009468954056501389, 0.011883789673447609, 0.006953693460673094, 0.03650607913732529, -0.01595402881503105, 0.0232695322483778, -0.04083933308720589, 0.018283287063241005, 0.010749886743724346, -0.04329574480652809, -0.017263472080230713, 0.018109094351530075, 0.003306191647425294, -0.0005733106518164277, -0.010504561476409435, -0.022420944646000862, -0.016937844455242157, 0.029254799708724022, 0.04835861921310425, 0.030161332339048386, -0.013807343319058418, -0.0208296962082386, 0.03702929988503456, 0.02659703977406025, -0.013515523634850979, -0.000056955988839035854, -0.041153278201818466, -0.009009853936731815, -0.002677139127627015, 0.005662691779434681, -0.045073941349983215, 0.03799786791205406, 0.026359479874372482, 0.05289677903056145, -0.061267606914043427, -0.012752573937177658, -0.014384644106030464, -0.049711212515830994, -0.02533825859427452, -0.0336153581738472, 0.03891923278570175, -0.010316390544176102, -0.006728653330355883, 0.0037618293426930904, -0.013624708168208599, -0.03294936195015907, 0.0034178518690168858, -0.05305569991469383, 0.02727804146707058, -0.001348643796518445, -0.03735264018177986, -0.030778151005506516, -0.020590554922819138, 0.07805541157722473, -0.014668656513094902, -0.007313963957130909, -0.01637362688779831, 0.022668080404400826, -0.020626647397875786, 0.03643864393234253, -0.026829779148101807, 0.01865420490503311, -0.0028939887415617704, 0.04870370402932167, -0.016770139336586, 0.019146909937262535, -0.011794162914156914, 0.028716836124658585, -0.025895318016409874, -0.009957423433661461, -0.02775696851313114, 0.0295699592679739, 0.0015134094282984734, 0.03443525359034538, 0.07339214533567429, 0.05732778459787369, -0.06778516620397568, 0.017026536166667938, -0.029096772894263268, 0.03219051659107208, 0.02338966354727745, 0.019884459674358368, -0.005802277475595474, -0.05412128195166588, -0.03827691450715065, 0.006930229254066944, 0.03148077800869942, -0.006495288573205471, 0.004093946423381567, 0.04647926986217499, 0.022744912654161453, -0.045045964419841766, 0.015508802607655525, 0.02577812783420086, -0.002976180985569954, -0.043761469423770905, -0.050864629447460175, -0.012548292055726051, -0.01407188642770052, 0.012935011647641659, 0.054426729679107666, 0.009051475673913956, -0.013522862456738949, -0.016967883333563805, 0.009215590544044971, -0.0343918539583683, -0.0393562875688076, 0.016592958942055702, -0.01282164640724659, 0.059499021619558334, 0.014618516899645329, -0.020751362666487694, 0.04184899851679802, 0.018081732094287872, -0.0095228785648942, 0.04568829759955406, 0.003580662189051509, -0.10997842252254486, -0.0047895158641040325, 0.03680673614144325, 0.01865685172379017, -0.018750524148344994, -0.0026810145936906338, -0.009496299549937248, -0.00937570445239544, 0.009332077577710152, -0.03735915198922157, 0.012315437197685242, 0.02539985254406929, -0.016783567145466805, -0.043050553649663925, -0.014135720208287239, -0.02846282348036766, 0.002295633777976036, -0.03249635174870491, 0.014704417437314987, -0.05196283757686615, -0.005364398006349802, -0.06160622462630272, 0.01703103817999363, 0.022570094093680382, 0.06779516488313675, -0.036059603095054626, -0.01897015981376171, 0.02337392419576645, 0.0315449982881546, -0.042046815156936646, -0.0786624550819397, 0.030676957219839096, -0.015067783184349537, -0.005192008800804615, 0.02064061351120472, -0.0224736537784338, -0.05209227278828621, 0.04620936140418053, 0.029418807476758957, -0.02392851747572422, 0.012695001438260078, -0.00839338731020689, 0.056049250066280365, 0.01359579712152481, 0.0103595657274127, 0.025555580854415894, 0.00006717487121932209, -0.009952528402209282, 0.0051816049963235855, -0.03013511560857296, 0.015419065952301025, -0.02523442544043064, -0.015614734962582588, -0.01837344840168953, -0.018096106126904488, -0.004169538617134094, 0.05700147524476051, 0.029996002092957497, 0.060283247381448746, -0.008406277745962143, -0.03880617022514343, 0.0030063067097216845, -0.017118515446782112, 0.012821312993764877, -0.025736937299370766, -0.011931806802749634, 0.03631120175123215, -0.0009879569988697767, -0.009218276478350163, 0.028945742174983025, -0.013954655267298222, 0.0042663156054914, 0.002780064707621932, -0.04414049908518791, -0.01798860915005207, -0.034497011452913284, -0.02221531793475151, 0.0205516554415226, -0.016747353598475456, 0.04176168143749237, -0.019486937671899796, 0.038861632347106934, -0.0211178045719862, -0.05804655700922012, -0.01720571331679821, 0.016284877434372902, 0.010406676679849625, 0.03411078825592995, -0.014281567186117172, 0.018786370754241943, -0.02921302616596222, 0.0024598788004368544, -0.07449730485677719, -0.05783778056502342, 0.02464628964662552, 0.002383993472903967, -0.005652796011418104, -0.04328056424856186, -0.013547378592193127, -0.005326211452484131, -0.030739568173885345, 0.00317585002630949, 0.04998326674103737, -0.027909236028790474, 0.01736384630203247, -0.015104484744369984, -0.014882395975291729, 0.07487618178129196, -0.005445046816021204, -0.028812706470489502, 0.027074139565229416, -0.03475014865398407, 0.03641704469919205, 0.004456500522792339, 0.010658073239028454, -0.026645760983228683, 0.006927718408405781, -0.024390382692217827, 0.0020845222752541304, 0.024374322965741158, -0.02785213477909565, -0.032728783786296844, 0.032522544264793396, -0.013735104352235794, 0.030728217214345932, -0.0641026720404625, -0.009386335499584675, -0.024462558329105377, 0.026336148381233215, 0.012232797220349312, 0.024651313200592995, 0.016741199418902397, -0.0026284903287887573, 0.029707705602049828, 0.031950704753398895, -0.012617327272891998, 0.008470949716866016, 0.05135822296142578, -0.027986925095319748, -0.00012690133007708937, -0.0025537190958857536, -0.016279971227049828, 0.07275178283452988, -0.0035472395829856396, 0.02978212758898735, 0.0020400865469127893, 0.023326195776462555, -0.04364427179098129, -0.01225701067596674, -0.08410084247589111, 0.023583928123116493, 0.043940335512161255, -0.008399967104196548, 0.03628615662455559, 0.05548638105392456, 0.02926105633378029, -0.001315032597631216, -0.030776631087064743, 0.01673148386180401, 0.003139669308438897, 0.04083321988582611, 0.032214660197496414, 0.012851336039602757, -0.026204969733953476, 0.06119241937994957, 0.0024669149424880743, -0.0163874588906765, 0.03336673974990845, 0.037680402398109436, -0.0015978566370904446, -0.00360105955041945, -0.02380705066025257, -0.02201845496892929, 0.006743921432644129, -0.04817092418670654, 0.03999973088502884, -0.027484357357025146, 0.00027366072754375637, 0.07945366948843002, 0.042315080761909485, 0.024440953508019447, -0.03129304200410843, -0.046664100140333176, -0.03166062757372856, 0.0007950665312819183, 0.021439960226416588, 0.0267411470413208, 0.03934844210743904, -0.020975662395358086, 0.035183437168598175, -0.008625701069831848, 0.012155722826719284, -0.036202795803546906, -0.07154878973960876, -0.02522335760295391, -0.0034493030980229378, -0.028217429295182228, 0.007962718605995178, 0.02665526606142521, -0.005771520081907511, 0.0005251559778116643, -0.022282367572188377, 0.002346619265154004, -0.02225976251065731, 0.061968475580215454, -0.054412420839071274, 0.06877102702856064, 0.022820787504315376, 0.005899390671402216, -0.027747467160224915, 0.022155577316880226, 0.08809217810630798, 0.06520964205265045, 0.003996318206191063, -0.054787296801805496, 0.024520376697182655, -0.020224804058670998, 0.004591166973114014, 0.016439266502857208, 0.02950960025191307, 0.028199506923556328, -0.02242169715464115, 0.013583643361926079, 0.022163627669215202, 0.011296814307570457, 0.017368754372000694, 0.07475490123033524, -0.04121142998337746, -0.012107044458389282, 0.04286203533411026, -0.0379217192530632, 0.01782625913619995, -0.010141068138182163, -0.008970043621957302, 0.02102433517575264, 0.009298853576183319, -0.0070924414321780205, -0.005632542539387941, 0.01801336742937565, -0.02208496257662773, 0.016070153564214706, -0.029931984841823578, 0.011182769201695919, 0.004565104376524687, 0.014608209021389484, -0.05199125036597252, -0.007211950141936541, -0.03618615120649338, -0.024839898571372032, -0.02217143028974533, 0.028010757640004158, -0.011382234282791615, 0.01944747008383274, 0.0035881842486560345, 0.045586131513118744, -0.0034826609771698713, -0.03401193767786026, -0.020875969901680946, 0.05048683285713196, 0.017727989703416824, 0.003041954943910241, -0.011530343443155289, -0.00665185647085309, -0.023786937817931175, -0.053493380546569824, -0.031891386955976486, 0.02482144720852375, 0.01758563704788685, -0.023662932217121124, -0.002883106702938676, -0.0024202673230320215, 0.06253265589475632, -0.01882673241198063, 0.02207079716026783, 0.023017562925815582, -0.01904725655913353, -0.024764372035861015, -0.005530873313546181, 0.023115580901503563, 0.012413845397531986, 0.012935485690832138, -0.03390452638268471, -0.01229657232761383, -0.03728223219513893, 0.003483316395431757, 0.015279483050107956, 0.009411493316292763, 0.02666631154716015, -0.0021171928383409977, -0.022055361419916153, -0.006237574387341738, -0.0126468725502491, 0.001620391383767128, 0.029919611290097237, -0.01971266232430935, -0.039589256048202515, 0.017443973571062088, 0.00009966599463950843, 0.06651479750871658, -0.0016899150796234608, 0.022473463788628578, -0.020639879629015923, 0.03778863325715065, -0.013057188130915165, -0.07676039636135101, -0.008550012484192848, 0.026013728231191635, -0.016423003748059273, 0.022816451266407967, -0.008917170576751232, 0.06970903277397156, -0.0018656791653484106, -0.00872043427079916, 0.009992810897529125, 0.037046391516923904, -0.013914285227656364, 0.03943800926208496, -0.00552354846149683, -0.07226667553186417, 0.0038260857108980417, -0.026416614651679993, 0.01575363427400589, -0.02851112000644207, -0.01946137845516205, -0.03844577074050903, -0.016048211604356766, 0.05031107738614082, -0.03673209622502327, 0.009952782653272152, 0.013973414897918701, 0.014393448829650879, -0.0004141444223932922, -0.009143281728029251, -0.002661975333467126, -0.05434555560350418, -0.013096041977405548, 0.01712043210864067, 0.00031618334469385445, 0.02464008517563343, 0.0001383305643685162, -0.0076333400793373585, -0.02022756263613701, 0.01724315620958805, -0.009203320369124413, -0.021244652569293976, -0.001593459048308432, -0.001978362677618861, 0.017154529690742493, 0.03471297770738602, -0.03073709085583687, -0.011709862388670444, 0.03208078816533089, -0.0590965636074543, 0.001901392126455903, 0.020191198214888573, -0.035101208835840225, 0.05551153048872948, 0.009919518604874611, -0.02189907245337963, -0.0042280578054487705, 0.03622056171298027, 0.006298891734331846, -0.041587624698877335, -0.00027247227262705564, 0.03953311964869499, -0.03492548689246178, -0.008704784326255322, 0.015195824205875397, 0.0029440131038427353, 0.012611867859959602, 0.03491605073213577, 0.02534387819468975, -0.013905549421906471, -0.04337036609649658, 0.004236677661538124, 0.00980406440794468, 0.002697655465453863, -0.031977321952581406, 0.00330157857388258, 0.044095687568187714, 0.05628719553351402, -0.03689051792025566, 0.03712962567806244, -0.027918491512537003, 0.04651796817779541, -0.09131120890378952, -0.037306662648916245, -0.008478895761072636, 0.0515117384493351, -0.0048942845314741135, -0.02443249523639679, -0.0020034739281982183, 0.006137983873486519, -0.07789169251918793, -0.0031957668252289295, -0.008059176616370678, -0.007286784704774618, -0.06783297657966614, -0.0031480477191507816, -0.05570199713110924, -0.00205765082500875, 0.013852188363671303, 0.03436579182744026, 0.01135572325438261, 0.017621489241719246, 0.0005400751251727343, -0.007608005777001381, -0.0006743951234966516, 0.023140832781791687, 0.005599446129053831, -0.06410639733076096, 0.002484050579369068, -0.017833663150668144, -0.04965838044881821, 0.022491460666060448, -0.008516374975442886, 0.023689551278948784, 0.03222968429327011, 0.004521084949374199, 0.0370950885117054, 0.046055953949689865, 0.019114119932055473, -0.05580691248178482, 0.0132924048230052, -0.011181199923157692, 0.00798042118549347, 0.05225706845521927, 0.010808251798152924, 0.04703943058848381, 0.059223953634500504, -0.004926119465380907, -0.0027459037955850363, 0.008138285018503666, 0.010842970572412014, -0.01230682898312807, 0.004403935745358467, 0.001320090377703309, 0.019949177280068398, -0.002132953843101859, -0.012121249921619892, -0.05352882668375969, 0.010788231156766415, 0.035311706364154816, 0.03816988319158554, -0.002565635135397315, 0.017163293436169624, -0.04803638905286789, 0.01134129986166954, -0.011494924314320087, 0.004368883557617664, -0.03894923999905586, -0.03256366029381752, 0.02994333766400814, -0.0066546108573675156, -0.005790440831333399, -0.006326831877231598, -0.04182667285203934, -0.05790753662586212, 0.03577185794711113, 0.0014005067059770226, 0.018052222207188606, 0.008627689443528652, -0.03613296151161194, 0.016158346086740494, -0.07272492349147797, 0.07505238801240921, -0.010591737926006317, 0.02870858646929264, -0.019952764734625816, -0.014338855631649494, 0.008545520715415478, 0.025049172341823578, 0.02192029170691967, -0.005179381929337978, -0.005578535608947277, -0.036494288593530655, 0.01421967800706625, -0.009349824860692024, -0.03206721320748329, 0.02243158593773842, -0.03432188183069229, -0.008492989465594292, -0.010726862587034702, -0.005512484814971685, 0.046136919409036636, 0.018746348097920418, 0.04613349586725235, 0.00937719363719225, 0.031966760754585266, -0.011556411162018776, -0.04118265211582184, 0.039597705006599426, -0.00023465484264306724, -0.019139669835567474, 0.06647088378667831, 0.008936559781432152, 0.009700579568743706, 0.04795942083001137, -0.007049494422972202, -0.020336400717496872, 0.04099193587899208, -0.03935197740793228, -0.019192993640899658, 0.041648007929325104, -0.002013690769672394, 0.009088962338864803, -0.02620892971754074, 0.00910512451082468, 0.016445040702819824, -0.041429921984672546, -0.009244472719728947, 0.014652096666395664, 0.025717219337821007, -0.004166231956332922, -0.03450772911310196, -0.0152346296235919, -0.029153887182474136, 0.0000049230106924369466, -0.05581604689359665, -0.03195060044527054, 0.012283409014344215, 0.024725768715143204, 0.03435692936182022, 0.027494171634316444, -0.040355756878852844, -0.004628418944776058, -0.00799773819744587, 0.026907531544566154, -0.05189986154437065, -0.024929456412792206, -0.003057233989238739, -0.02910146303474903, 0.05242428183555603, 0.00022719032131135464, 0.03300153836607933, 0.08922329545021057, -0.015269296243786812, -0.013226384297013283, -0.028121300041675568, -0.013071226887404919, -0.014057482592761517, 0.032237328588962555, 0.04174697399139404, 0.034244947135448456, 0.02548077702522278, -0.009953059256076813, -0.026515601202845573, 0.01721041090786457, 0.029665857553482056, -0.03873647004365921, 0.05696862190961838, -0.014944777823984623, -0.0077799223363399506, 0.008390399627387524, 0.0020267327781766653, -0.009118468500673771, -0.01970316842198372, 0.01718101277947426, 0.05261221155524254, 0.027931777760386467, -0.04194389283657074, -0.034696824848651886, -0.008688482455909252, 0.019671481102705002, -0.0504603274166584, -0.03002227656543255, -0.02835802547633648, 0.02915276773273945, -0.013684449717402458, -0.01576010137796402 ]
<p>I am new to R and I have run the <code>lmer</code> in lme4. In the model summary, there is no any warning message, but when I ask for <code>confint(lmer)</code>, R gives me this message at the bottom of the output:</p> <pre><code>Warning messages: 1: In profile.merMod(object, signames = oldNames, ...) : non-monotonic profile 2: In profile.merMod(object, signames = oldNames, ...) : non-monotonic profile 3: In profile.merMod(object, signames = oldNames, ...) : non-monotonic profile </code></pre> <p>What does it mean? and what should I do?</p>
73,637
[ -0.011243080720305443, -0.0007106809644028544, 0.015243440866470337, -0.01892969012260437, 0.013116911053657532, 0.008304981514811516, -0.005076022353023291, 0.005834485869854689, 0.04868844896554947, -0.023181453347206116, 0.03006359376013279, 0.04301348701119423, 0.07469500601291656, 0.03234439715743065, 0.035121604800224304, -0.03826851770281792, 0.011384871788322926, -0.0010733584640547633, 0.015698187053203583, -0.015607316978275776, 0.0027233450673520565, 0.00041936818161047995, 0.004136017523705959, -0.009200490079820156, 0.002473530825227499, 0.03501970320940018, -0.008069434203207493, -0.01927630417048931, 0.006068411748856306, 0.010403163731098175, -0.028582539409399033, -0.015399972908198833, -0.00038880613283254206, -0.01213791687041521, 0.00483763637021184, 0.0018631432903930545, -0.026380905881524086, -0.01617777906358242, -0.03983589634299278, 0.03662047162652016, -0.005305075086653233, -0.020867373794317245, 0.01163746789097786, 0.01919259876012802, -0.01305882167071104, 0.010810998268425465, 0.0406358502805233, 0.03180796280503273, 0.0642416700720787, 0.007081472314894199, 0.07845655828714371, -0.04286296293139458, 0.0043703000992536545, 0.023587604984641075, -0.020478174090385437, 0.023480119183659554, 0.04314730688929558, 0.05342555046081543, 0.010070101357996464, -0.06775111705064774, -0.053691454231739044, -0.060221947729587555, 0.0013237323146313429, 0.016564901918172836, -0.038027580827474594, 0.036642011255025864, 0.0024557991418987513, -0.047350313514471054, 0.03585706278681755, -0.014988066628575325, -0.006753773894160986, 0.0271836556494236, 0.04263181984424591, -0.04012884572148323, 0.05905643850564957, 0.005717766936868429, 0.00515307392925024, -0.04174631088972092, 0.01926874928176403, 0.020411118865013123, 0.010371848940849304, 0.018345436081290245, 0.007725741248577833, 0.05306781083345413, 0.00850965827703476, -0.009999542497098446, 0.0190049447119236, -0.017381148412823677, 0.025831148028373718, 0.03238674998283386, -0.0016188973095268011, 0.004245441406965256, 0.028659047558903694, -0.005289377644658089, -0.03899558261036873, 0.042898841202259064, -0.027267547324299812, -0.005223546642810106, -0.01838730461895466, -0.02529945783317089, -0.038500115275382996, -0.06260054558515549, 0.011784794740378857, 0.0018891363870352507, -0.009138203226029873, 0.004419984295964241, -0.0375298336148262, -0.025012267753481865, 0.005939308553934097, -0.007594701834022999, -0.01124617364257574, 0.006091575603932142, 0.03577309101819992, -0.005018169526010752, 0.004461536183953285, -0.06403666734695435, -0.03235827758908272, 0.016734901815652847, 0.03646128624677658, 0.040832992643117905, 0.04703809693455696, -0.018859485164284706, 0.032434359192848206, 0.025973573327064514, -0.04466564953327179, 0.02291676588356495, 0.028579380363225937, -0.012237870134413242, -0.04906156286597252, 0.060474783182144165, 0.05229838937520981, -0.0007777842693030834, 0.027706574648618698, 0.003992659505456686, 0.058372728526592255, 0.014343095943331718, -0.07073817402124405, -0.05755387246608734, 0.03198745474219322, 0.020682919770479202, 0.046402085572481155, -0.04363343119621277, 0.0008095621014945209, 0.01906299963593483, 0.08767063170671463, 0.0166533961892128, 0.01692747138440609, 0.04320381209254265, 0.028560971841216087, 0.020016631111502647, -0.04085339978337288, 0.008865118958055973, -0.044037073850631714, -0.003141116350889206, -0.022807521745562553, -0.09241913259029388, 0.004986929707229137, 0.01743358187377453, -0.03273941949009895, -0.005293297115713358, 0.07208408415317535, 0.004475561436265707, 0.004184001591056585, -0.012265251949429512, -0.031321942806243896, -0.05173207446932793, 0.09316232800483704, 0.0036259458865970373, 0.04271950200200081, 0.0041427300311625, -0.005909256171435118, 0.05307414382696152, -0.026128489524126053, 0.038163814693689346, 0.04813757538795471, -0.002488048281520605, 0.0031601397786289454, -0.07169127464294434, 0.007877735421061516, 0.06274550408124924, -0.05142256245017052, -0.03254568576812744, 0.01897565834224224, -0.012833102606236935, 0.009720760397613049, 0.017098810523748398, -0.010384410619735718, -0.014337290078401566, 0.028250014409422874, -0.0481344573199749, -0.023944076150655746, -0.06267295777797699, -0.009464656934142113, -0.016728704795241356, -0.026993824169039726, 0.0011215654667466879, -0.01197006180882454, 0.014395765960216522, 0.0017597987316548824, 0.0035111848264932632, -0.03411102667450905, -0.004795286804437637, 0.065102219581604, -0.03635084256529808, 0.017391609027981758, -0.02389531396329403, 0.006463258992880583, -0.04757528379559517, 0.03038238361477852, -0.03766255080699921, -0.040024612098932266, 0.030291065573692322, -0.0110420947894454, 0.008564291521906853, -0.01976269669830799, -0.030778026208281517, -0.0036876739468425512, -0.005332143045961857, -0.02601279318332672, 0.047290343791246414, -0.02511201798915863, 0.0313602089881897, 0.04672883078455925, 0.03599923849105835, 0.009164699353277683, -0.02374224178493023, 0.0022866828367114067, 0.018527531996369362, -0.06323957443237305, -0.0011118367547169328, 0.004975931718945503, -0.03615147992968559, 0.04971473664045334, -0.012746624648571014, -0.05063195899128914, -0.007666597608476877, 0.04411686211824417, -0.021588874980807304, 0.03902926295995712, 0.01780184544622898, -0.008560248650610447, -0.012928161770105362, 0.04356212913990021, 0.0718781128525734, 0.040429987013339996, 0.02022801712155342, 0.03989797830581665, -0.02204636111855507, 0.053295183926820755, -0.019966721534729004, -0.009281984530389309, 0.04003212973475456, -0.00561333354562521, -0.004213500302284956, -0.03585491701960564, -0.015332234092056751, 0.0485355518758297, -0.03208332881331444, 0.03654458373785019, 0.03385433554649353, -0.00716036232188344, 0.004485576879233122, -0.01764827035367489, 0.027184151113033295, -0.03386203944683075, 0.07757894694805145, -0.018119262531399727, -0.026269175112247467, 0.02832796983420849, -0.08078692108392715, 0.014471260830760002, -0.012943037785589695, -0.0801980122923851, -0.05776822939515114, 0.007745199836790562, 0.018244562670588493, -0.004092899616807699, 0.044348444789648056, -0.059669043868780136, 0.0006386284367181361, -0.006972921546548605, -0.019471481442451477, 0.026224598288536072, -0.02485484816133976, -0.05006730556488037, -0.02575649693608284, 0.022268055006861687, -0.024028820917010307, 0.03607973828911781, 0.005815570242702961, -0.00726835522800684, 0.011256103403866291, 0.00010802577889990062, -0.010514005087316036, -0.06371791660785675, -0.02219509705901146, -0.007509704679250717, 0.015199224464595318, 0.01681910641491413, 0.0418752059340477, 0.007246700581163168, -0.02483486197888851, 0.009956817142665386, -0.09059211611747742, 0.004341302439570427, -0.04576297104358673, -0.040055785328149796, 0.013463780283927917, 0.02456497773528099, 0.009953085333108902, 0.01638038270175457, -0.02370903454720974, -0.010891137644648552, -0.0710144191980362, -0.06149362027645111, 0.007848946377635002, -0.020918790251016617, 0.03722222521901131, 0.03729761391878128, -0.01767999678850174, 0.06791991740465164, 0.02013998106122017, -0.015019713900983334, -0.08066171407699585, -0.03420114517211914, -0.04314105957746506, -0.028435762971639633, 0.010629650205373764, -0.01566685177385807, 0.05049589276313782, 0.003690562676638365, -0.006836296990513802, 0.03960610181093216, 0.030135631561279297, -0.04422787204384804, 0.00008366600377485156, 0.02461341954767704, -0.021908720955252647, -0.04176923632621765, 0.04840731620788574, 0.032637570053339005, 0.003962303977459669, 0.06951935589313507, -0.016674473881721497, 0.03026518039405346, -0.018813975155353546, -0.05525133013725281, -0.018977202475070953, -0.034408118575811386, 0.031911205500364304, 0.0013529519783332944, 0.009357474744319916, -0.009908265434205532, -0.06056956946849823, 0.021497799083590508, 0.012199200689792633, 0.05254331976175308, -0.035497989505529404, -0.0010230730986222625, 0.004077331628650427, 0.02662772685289383, -0.05045872554183006, 0.04535966366529465, 0.019158625975251198, -0.02975170500576496, 0.004644301254302263, -0.0065905312076210976, -0.025304526090621948, 0.0331069715321064, -0.004758065100759268, 0.0011533938813954592, 0.014866100624203682, -0.028509482741355896, 0.009201663546264172, -0.05707818269729614, 0.005566063802689314, -0.033311061561107635, 0.03300027176737785, 0.00044594774954020977, -0.007740443106740713, 0.060094237327575684, 0.00934574194252491, 0.007126146927475929, 0.009731082245707512, -0.05608194321393967, 0.05121423676609993, 0.007490876130759716, -0.004468637518584728, 0.015211454592645168, -0.009153258055448532, -0.01655740477144718, 0.013064495287835598, -0.0032806817907840014, -0.0033394915517419577, 0.016548417508602142, -0.02426910027861595, 0.002075557829812169, -0.03816928341984749, -0.008458451367914677, -0.030991235747933388, 0.03209654986858368, 0.03137200325727463, -0.003661980153992772, 0.06875040382146835, 0.037839725613594055, 0.005756874568760395, -0.015742888674139977, -0.024430228397250175, -0.009041015058755875, 0.00897983368486166, 0.03168832138180733, -0.008517307229340076, 0.012432442978024483, -0.042738113552331924, 0.04204154387116432, 0.03476063907146454, 0.027805576100945473, 0.01718219928443432, 0.03469923511147499, -0.01784500852227211, 0.014243275858461857, -0.013386381790041924, -0.009814556688070297, -0.01003726851195097, 0.03382815048098564, 0.009492989629507065, 0.047627490013837814, 0.025640616193413734, 0.013566020876169205, 0.011132104322314262, 0.05621882155537605, 0.046252623200416565, 0.005740192718803883, -0.017699353396892548, -0.020686618983745575, 0.005992543417960405, 0.039781536906957626, 0.007037909235805273, 0.008272519335150719, -0.006392554379999638, 0.002538386732339859, -0.016566889360547066, -0.025575309991836548, -0.03298799321055412, 0.019616737961769104, 0.007788578048348427, 0.0047811102122068405, -0.05077806115150452, -0.04818471893668175, 0.03341272100806236, 0.010941914282739162, 0.021048638969659805, -0.01181959081441164, -0.0012344486312940717, -0.11707542836666107, -0.013225450180470943, 0.012205326929688454, 0.04928094893693924, -0.009335558861494064, -0.03836739435791969, -0.039005693048238754, -0.002293019788339734, 0.020216533914208412, -0.021791065111756325, 0.02108350582420826, -0.025658706203103065, 0.03819350525736809, -0.02924824133515358, 0.016256166622042656, -0.05284282565116882, -0.008279477246105671, -0.046144645661115646, 0.030639545992016792, 0.014264562167227268, -0.01548191998153925, -0.06059388816356659, 0.02042386680841446, -0.06638958305120468, 0.015940383076667786, -0.06446842849254608, -0.020286623388528824, 0.04654975235462189, -0.012323431670665741, -0.0017890826566144824, 0.007528021931648254, 0.0379573330283165, -0.04167880862951279, 0.01932050846517086, 0.032417818903923035, -0.025192229077219963, 0.01343605201691389, 0.01951458677649498, 0.005427648313343525, 0.005010321736335754, 0.002170379040762782, -0.03497384116053581, 0.02390628308057785, 0.015288288705050945, -0.0014296716544777155, 0.025797106325626373, 0.025780409574508667, -0.02428562380373478, -0.00046825187746435404, -0.06852666288614273, 0.0238368920981884, -0.018107859417796135, -0.0028955598827451468, -0.055591464042663574, -0.026671618223190308, -0.03601719066500664, 0.01749250292778015, -0.0007066819816827774, 0.027158640325069427, -0.01207529753446579, 0.012111219577491283, 0.03772999718785286, 0.004000196699053049, -0.026106728240847588, -0.04738738387823105, 0.037705689668655396, -0.0029257063288241625, -0.026055995374917984, 0.0006658114143647254, 0.028441721573472023, -0.05295335873961449, -0.0056298235431313515, -0.006699855905026197, -0.01684943027794361, 0.016176728531718254, 0.04535238817334175, 0.00165052420925349, 0.003341818228363991, -0.012465741485357285, 0.006190930027514696, 0.043783124536275864, 0.008928763680160046, -0.00498609896749258, -0.061916451901197433, 0.017319224774837494, 0.021025966852903366, -0.08746557682752609, -0.00853196531534195, -0.03988447040319443, 0.061162758618593216, 0.004775886423885822, 0.004438844975084066, -0.021775122731924057, -0.056429121643304825, 0.03850987181067467, -0.04006641358137131, -0.027742518112063408, -0.027498388662934303, -0.061164166778326035, 0.006713654845952988, -0.04248342290520668, 0.003807446686550975, 0.06616523861885071, -0.04245065897703171, 0.008418556302785873, 0.012089419178664684, 0.014537225477397442, 0.05565657839179039, 0.04160243272781372, 0.01958291046321392, 0.00941284466534853, 0.003949068486690521, -0.01781606487929821, -0.016335396096110344, -0.042723190039396286, -0.046785954385995865, -0.015095395967364311, -0.02175258845090866, -0.0007613011985085905, 0.07268020510673523, -0.003736393991857767, -0.02551204152405262, 0.004592156037688255, -0.016362469643354416, 0.012881506234407425, -0.03317590802907944, -0.02888782136142254, -0.0760439783334732, 0.014967221766710281, -0.05192459374666214, 0.012925234623253345, 0.013572820462286472, -0.037981484085321426, 0.03798365592956543, -0.005226572975516319, 0.02486317791044712, 0.037605054676532745, 0.05364939197897911, -0.0005872641922906041, -0.0010338289430364966, -0.001116157160140574, -0.006386399269104004, 0.0012840309645980597, 0.03352881222963333, -0.001669352757744491, -0.021229881793260574, 0.04999515414237976, -0.02646363154053688, -0.02051307074725628, -0.016161363571882248, 0.03055407665669918, 0.014412143267691135, -0.006739955395460129, 0.06463780999183655, 0.04671068489551544, -0.035581350326538086, -0.0069927251897752285, -0.010648556053638458, -0.05378979817032814, 0.03262321650981903, 0.035232070833444595, 0.09039448946714401, -0.018420841544866562, 0.007763670291751623, 0.04076124355196953, 0.016816316172480583, 0.00724737299606204, 0.014427334070205688, -0.0036566746421158314, 0.017931528389453888, 0.009308058768510818, -0.017826639115810394, -0.017433317378163338, 0.04937078058719635, -0.01685108058154583, 0.030019255355000496, -0.034554194658994675, -0.006712727714329958, -0.007979357615113258, 0.024319512769579887, 0.02009706385433674, -0.0552736297249794, -0.024909112602472305, -0.008609366603195667, 0.00680070836097002, 0.024050496518611908, -0.049624986946582794, 0.03509809449315071, 0.01041841134428978, 0.04407119378447533, 0.03781571239233017, 0.024445772171020508, -0.04766765609383583, -0.05322816222906113, -0.03277470916509628, -0.03869226947426796, -0.012615379877388477, 0.0161285363137722, 0.016355235129594803, -0.018142811954021454, 0.012842501513659954, -0.016423417255282402, 0.017844948917627335, 0.01803058199584484, 0.009870813228189945, -0.011624643579125404, 0.04169036075472832, 0.02983914315700531, 0.022961625829339027, -0.03058478608727455, -0.02213936112821102, 0.15253934264183044, 0.08975804597139359, 0.03727472573518753, -0.0471474751830101, 0.021676458418369293, 0.028096478432416916, 0.006031616125255823, 0.0066617694683372974, -0.019725413993000984, 0.029089970514178276, -0.012783931568264961, 0.033261340111494064, 0.02509847655892372, -0.008877430111169815, 0.04501810297369957, 0.03059382364153862, -0.027490347623825073, -0.004092621151357889, 0.021695783361792564, 0.0006713950424455106, 0.021923931315541267, -0.019846158102154732, -0.04632427170872688, 0.028117304667830467, 0.055739253759384155, 0.022580120712518692, -0.04196801409125328, -0.020486969500780106, 0.0063961525447666645, 0.017653461545705795, -0.012738300487399101, 0.030253667384386063, -0.0025012039113789797, -0.014041983522474766, 0.032475948333740234, 0.005472119897603989, 0.027418993413448334, -0.0015230533899739385, 0.027549291029572487, 0.0948566198348999, -0.023543117567896843, 0.018041592091321945, -0.03309720754623413, 0.028006169945001602, -0.01292215846478939, -0.028273943811655045, -0.0010080289794132113, 0.0019382549216970801, 0.015902141109108925, 0.01848798803985119, 0.005288188345730305, 0.06109144166111946, 0.0035908177960664034, -0.03451951965689659, -0.028799591585993767, 0.0023777049500495195, 0.006288147531449795, -0.012369132600724697, -0.01674235798418522, -0.033789992332458496, -0.023645786568522453, -0.0052129593677818775, 0.02300507016479969, 0.014934586361050606, -0.03334568813443184, 0.023375652730464935, -0.06293439120054245, 0.04072616249322891, -0.022634537890553474, 0.024500850588083267, -0.013661663979291916, -0.009898005053400993, -0.032848507165908813, -0.014015239663422108, 0.011640973389148712, 0.018898094072937965, 0.021794268861413002, -0.010611976496875286, -0.01122510340064764, -0.004388823639601469, -0.028755728155374527, -0.0008554654195904732, -0.01788182556629181, -0.016876019537448883, -0.0076404353603720665, 0.0055084796622395515, 0.02672514133155346, 0.024356167763471603, -0.013951258733868599, 0.0029506846331059933, 0.0000909856244106777, 0.03356018662452698, -0.010225636884570122, -0.04152313992381096, -0.024823401123285294, 0.028428422287106514, -0.011233808472752571, 0.020427536219358444, -0.024275222793221474, 0.06547302007675171, 0.029017329216003418, 0.02249573916196823, 0.0059294747188687325, 0.003638356924057007, -0.010523121803998947, -0.029267534613609314, 0.04526551440358162, -0.0033554292749613523, 0.01685277745127678, -0.03308602422475815, -0.03168673440814018, -0.04421113431453705, 0.010416830889880657, -0.06678090244531631, -0.04870546981692314, 0.012715354561805725, -0.027447175234556198, -0.013076068833470345, 0.025212595239281654, 0.01579921878874302, 0.006527754478156567, 0.012958215549588203, 0.006596369668841362, -0.031382184475660324, -0.008188003674149513, 0.0026584092993289232, 0.015844009816646576, -0.012567000463604927, 0.032982081174850464, -0.03933192044496536, -0.00936349667608738, -0.025387808680534363, 0.01358829252421856, -0.001477914280258119, -0.019826361909508705, 0.023782145231962204, 0.024108966812491417, 0.0333951935172081, -0.0032271079253405333, -0.0068533215671777725, -0.009457035921514034, -0.03343193605542183, -0.012081347405910492, -0.005464534740895033, 0.0053819315508008, 0.002080473117530346, -0.005437432788312435, 0.029578283429145813, -0.011137142777442932, 0.06971970200538635, -0.042275648564100266, 0.03436554595828056, -0.008122420869767666, -0.021298525854945183, 0.010756378062069416, 0.015964964404702187, -0.0006425417959690094, 0.018474668264389038, 0.001352233113721013, 0.0033573638647794724, 0.06899517774581909, -0.011926023289561272, -0.02284989133477211, 0.006973646581172943, -0.03788314014673233, -0.011264682747423649, 0.01517164334654808, 0.01869874820113182, 0.03823142126202583, 0.05453043803572655, -0.022979993373155594, 0.046916935592889786, -0.011527782306075096, 0.0159883014857769, -0.08239854127168655, 0.010731032118201256, -0.011255468241870403, -0.02609856054186821, 0.022925520315766335, -0.044059868901968, 0.03113582171499729, 0.02737381123006344, -0.03173253685235977, -0.01819443516433239, -0.0050658718682825565, -0.018264014273881912, -0.0775347650051117, -0.010657965205609798, -0.01502196490764618, 0.03169108182191849, 0.029809683561325073, -0.005276983138173819, 0.02001289464533329, -0.01751718856394291, 0.008283901028335094, -0.025949627161026, -0.029270581901073456, 0.026804905384778976, 0.0048707337118685246, -0.03570199012756348, 0.04530211165547371, -0.021028658375144005, -0.03509997949004173, 0.013969732448458672, -0.029841957613825798, 0.005615775007754564, 0.026186762377619743, 0.04588019475340843, 0.051447734236717224, 0.007317128591239452, 0.019363820552825928, -0.00791109912097454, -0.02050802856683731, 0.008147007785737514, 0.03242591768503189, 0.0058571393601596355, -0.03331492096185684, 0.030710497871041298, 0.00972948968410492, 0.005239951889961958, -0.000503232644405216, 0.04270022734999657, -0.041230443865060806, 0.027683643624186516, -0.05432438105344772, -0.03997369855642319, -0.011369003914296627, -0.05743512883782387, 0.018825087696313858, 0.014024488627910614, 0.01713922806084156, 0.017778905108571053, 0.0431988388299942, 0.0011571870418265462, 0.016589581966400146, -0.023491621017456055, -0.027204720303416252, -0.006251629441976547, -0.0055044409818947315, -0.012438959442079067, -0.009249568916857243, 0.03282663971185684, 0.006137264426797628, -0.015355054289102554, -0.03154360502958298, 0.0143981808796525, -0.01242720428854227, 0.05763426423072815, -0.008105055429041386, -0.018199194222688675, 0.023865938186645508, -0.02451108582317829, 0.026450058445334435, -0.0874447450041771, 0.06960304826498032, 0.0007317943382076919, 0.02134423889219761, -0.05329376459121704, -0.002965295920148492, -0.03829709440469742, 0.02988891303539276, 0.03555846959352493, 0.021117761731147766, 0.026960939168930054, -0.010357530787587166, 0.05561906844377518, -0.04273732006549835, -0.04481339827179909, 0.011183403432369232, 0.05206693336367607, -0.007853740826249123, 0.018045617267489433, -0.00016224219871219248, -0.00001026620975608239, -0.012116220779716969, -0.01847025193274021, 0.014074232429265976, -0.006766885984688997, 0.008446414023637772, -0.044456832110881805, -0.012756179086863995, -0.015804139897227287, -0.013692737556993961, 0.03487291559576988, 0.006084160413593054, 0.012137608602643013, 0.045507192611694336, 0.005964370910078287, -0.03119548037648201, 0.014156504534184933, 0.004994826857000589, 0.024929573759436607, 0.010140947066247463, 0.0042980145663022995, 0.016301805153489113, -0.015322069637477398, -0.0034902766346931458, 0.031592465937137604, -0.013066556304693222, -0.021761102601885796, 0.04113665595650673, 0.04223007708787918, 0.04916752129793167, -0.047430962324142456, -0.03308199718594551, -0.03268076851963997, -0.027254899963736534, -0.00701818335801363, 0.03513360768556595, 0.024098731577396393, 0.0012272363528609276, -0.005218192934989929, 0.019896959885954857, -0.0381748303771019, 0.017949650064110756, -0.02121235430240631, 0.05562340468168259, -0.003639829810708761, -0.03264596313238144, 0.008388676680624485, 0.007165540009737015, 0.016211548820137978, 0.0014521817211061716, -0.012314608320593834, 0.02766522951424122, -0.040881238877773285, 0.008338306099176407, 0.00019528645498212427, -0.02228715270757675, 0.006856698542833328, -0.013230567798018456, -0.01189877837896347, 0.02702026069164276, 0.04562228173017502, 0.001756019308231771, 0.009319016709923744, -0.029747657477855682, 0.03696523234248161, -0.010050933808088303, 0.014294959604740143, -0.013838310725986958, 0.020231321454048157, 0.013424864038825035, -0.04061617702245712, -0.0060037486255168915, -0.02456297166645527, 0.019970590248703957, 0.010596593841910362, 0.037307851016521454, -0.07936271280050278, -0.015146519057452679, 0.025809627026319504, 0.004737432114779949, 0.006572308484464884, -0.02704719454050064, -0.02117939665913582, -0.01080104149878025, 0.017803087830543518, -0.024196360260248184 ]
<p>I recently read a <a href="http://blog.echen.me/2012/03/20/infinite-mixture-models-with-nonparametric-bayes-and-the-dirichlet-process/" rel="nofollow">fascinating article</a> describing methods for clustering data without assuming a fixed number of clusters.</p> <p>The article even includes some sample code, in a mix of Ruby, Python, and R. However, the meat of the analysis is performed using <a href="http://scikit-learn.sourceforge.net/dev/index.html" rel="nofollow">scikit-learn</a>'s <a href="http://scikit-learn.sourceforge.net/dev/modules/mixture.html" rel="nofollow">Dirichlet Process Gaussian Mixture Model</a> to actually find clusters in some sample data taken from McDonald's menu.</p> <p>Obviously, this a a great excuse to learn some more python, but I'm lazy and would like to find a ready-made R package that can take a dataframe and return clusters, in a manner similar to the <a href="http://stat.ethz.ch/R-manual/R-devel/library/stats/html/kmeans.html" rel="nofollow">kmeans</a> function. <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/views/Cluster.html" rel="nofollow">A quick search on CRAN</a> reveals the packages <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/dpmixsim/index.html" rel="nofollow">dpmixsim</a> and <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/profdpm/index.html" rel="nofollow">profdpm</a>. Any suggestions for the best place to start?</p>
25,062
[ -0.053401123732328415, 0.0022253592032939196, 0.01201856043189764, -0.02749812789261341, 0.02427457459270954, 0.00285050249658525, -0.030940566211938858, -0.025727445259690285, -0.01013107318431139, -0.029100485146045685, 0.015801433473825455, 0.030852021649479866, 0.0336444191634655, 0.04522322863340378, 0.0030421267729252577, 0.02267085574567318, 0.02351478487253189, -0.022413987666368484, -0.030862566083669662, -0.0029434722382575274, 0.00312670785933733, -0.017316969111561775, 0.027930179610848427, -0.03661191090941429, -0.04764008894562721, 0.006448647938668728, 0.01996275968849659, -0.03339996188879013, -0.032242756336927414, 0.03654984384775162, -0.07304884493350983, -0.009910954162478447, 0.011986727826297283, -0.001710610929876566, 0.0167889092117548, 0.01703258976340294, -0.03825785219669342, -0.01799372397363186, -0.01637718454003334, 0.012308339588344097, -0.019134989008307457, -0.03229305520653725, 0.01662510447204113, 0.03330988809466362, -0.01906144805252552, 0.03564206883311272, 0.024045124650001526, -0.015858758240938187, 0.005414991639554501, -0.03311328962445259, 0.06828626990318298, 0.009801357984542847, 0.01573432981967926, 0.02912345714867115, -0.011489056050777435, 0.007735505700111389, 0.030414680019021034, 0.0367891788482666, 0.003815838834270835, -0.045486047863960266, -0.028862548992037773, -0.017670411616563797, 0.023003095760941505, -0.03880082070827484, -0.026445725932717323, 0.052644986659288406, -0.0013312380760908127, 0.023710109293460846, 0.050957757979631424, 0.008838864974677563, 0.02513953670859337, 0.024072619155049324, 0.06425584852695465, -0.03868310898542404, 0.006113682873547077, -0.004943960811942816, -0.018729837611317635, 0.008244096301496029, 0.018940582871437073, 0.044762272387742996, 0.041123244911432266, 0.00324742472730577, -0.008155280724167824, -0.02668987214565277, 0.04453451558947563, -0.016421537846326828, 0.05348403751850128, -0.030150428414344788, 0.008726793341338634, 0.06609240919351578, -0.03890376165509224, -0.0010596992215141654, 0.032892704010009766, 0.02391340211033821, -0.021900128573179245, 0.01527472771704197, -0.017396021634340286, 0.04319753125309944, -0.02531084604561329, -0.014001380652189255, -0.027965642511844635, -0.013625805266201496, -0.02311510592699051, 0.09248355776071548, -0.03272471949458122, -0.02536635473370552, -0.04304535314440727, -0.018565332517027855, -0.045249104499816895, -0.01119107473641634, -0.036021888256073, 0.031989119946956635, 0.02819264493882656, -0.014940707944333553, 0.026749849319458008, -0.02375103160738945, -0.01049971766769886, -0.026688210666179657, 0.01083165779709816, 0.10379356145858765, 0.009784008376300335, -0.01593927852809429, 0.0037883685436099768, -0.0577692948281765, -0.07735215127468109, 0.013609137386083603, 0.014190594665706158, -0.015515536069869995, 0.005231945775449276, 0.013434701599180698, -0.0030073849484324455, -0.01578686572611332, 0.06410032510757446, 0.005007031373679638, -0.001626182347536087, -0.010514401830732822, -0.05595214292407036, -0.019246071577072144, 0.024758147075772285, -0.015238682739436626, 0.03031008690595627, -0.029968075454235077, -0.02489149384200573, -0.002651334274560213, 0.021797629073262215, 0.008014848455786705, 0.027853526175022125, 0.011666751466691494, 0.030818328261375427, -0.033235736191272736, -0.031752534210681915, 0.004589612130075693, -0.010799800977110863, 0.016080420464277267, -0.015614152885973454, -0.07343511283397675, 0.04052426666021347, 0.009437937289476395, 0.011473171412944794, 0.030442014336586, -0.013488566502928734, 0.012821461074054241, 0.00013364815094973892, -0.04436342418193817, 0.020217344164848328, 0.018634706735610962, 0.0687708854675293, 0.0011890074238181114, 0.06776849925518036, -0.009025072678923607, -0.04627539590001106, 0.0013275396777316928, 0.005674884654581547, 0.02484361082315445, 0.015680044889450073, -0.018113797530531883, 0.005247196182608604, -0.001858205534517765, 0.06537339091300964, 0.007160992361605167, -0.015033138915896416, -0.013102845288813114, 0.006385456304997206, -0.03236355260014534, 0.012176772579550743, 0.042814578860998154, 0.031699638813734055, -0.03532346710562706, 0.049132708460092545, -0.060811519622802734, -0.04041982814669609, -0.05694510042667389, 0.003970269579440355, -0.053549330681562424, 0.002225844655185938, 0.031194711104035378, 0.004186546895653009, -0.009964064694941044, 0.0063468473963439465, -0.036000415682792664, -0.026311762630939484, -0.023482898250222206, 0.039515480399131775, -0.03281259536743164, -0.04102923721075058, 0.048723526298999786, 0.03654728829860687, -0.009189140051603317, 0.024100525304675102, -0.04327663034200668, -0.07126986980438232, -0.014872947707772255, -0.037184812128543854, -0.015726689249277115, -0.03671668469905853, -0.015091336332261562, 0.04346466064453125, 0.035097636282444, -0.056385986506938934, -0.0006422269507311285, -0.04841494560241699, 0.04951124265789986, 0.04274635761976242, 0.006896852981299162, -0.006821103859692812, -0.027370410040020943, -0.010702774859964848, 0.0464814268052578, -0.01866830699145794, -0.0017309190006926656, -0.05674219876527786, 0.008382088504731655, 0.0633438229560852, 0.03661162406206131, -0.025460414588451385, -0.022386079654097557, 0.024140721186995506, 0.0037792869843542576, 0.0024048122577369213, 0.0071347542107105255, -0.025501638650894165, -0.0355757400393486, 0.04016706719994545, 0.0031260016839951277, -0.005548426415771246, -0.002731845248490572, 0.03226673975586891, -0.013347783125936985, 0.0468815341591835, -0.034785278141498566, -0.041278235614299774, 0.017632808536291122, 0.02161366492509842, -0.015854541212320328, -0.0001936807093443349, -0.021141469478607178, 0.04814255237579346, -0.02930675633251667, 0.025101497769355774, 0.019243724644184113, 0.03127404302358627, -0.016969742253422737, 0.013789620250463486, -0.03823333978652954, 0.021269388496875763, 0.05980613827705383, -0.030872369185090065, 0.013126113452017307, 0.011669786646962166, -0.053661562502384186, 0.008642363362014294, -0.004706888925284147, -0.05104668438434601, -0.05552402511239052, 0.005702497437596321, -0.0032886206172406673, 0.0005774913006462157, -0.00291995657607913, -0.03440643474459648, 0.03573223575949669, 0.02791806310415268, 0.011750902980566025, 0.011022103019058704, 0.022871846333146095, -0.026418009772896767, 0.009002052247524261, 0.03827207535505295, -0.006439270917326212, 0.02965407446026802, 0.035624075680971146, -0.030882608145475388, -0.000028227033908478916, 0.004401735495775938, -0.045781515538692474, 0.006891893222928047, 0.007319918833673, -0.013646679930388927, -0.019623463973402977, 0.01662830263376236, 0.010884977877140045, 0.005690878257155418, -0.04811088368296623, 0.03256973624229431, -0.0502963662147522, -0.03850448504090309, -0.027585500851273537, -0.0003930918173864484, 0.007888895459473133, 0.018037496134638786, -0.014667253941297531, 0.03605235740542412, -0.01999274455010891, 0.03512945398688316, -0.061039578169584274, -0.0602572076022625, 0.012153672985732555, -0.0006995078292675316, 0.01362073328346014, 0.007416926324367523, -0.007196913007646799, 0.05062609165906906, 0.010659348219633102, -0.0399613119661808, -0.047601766884326935, -0.0033164487686008215, -0.03941519930958748, 0.028094222769141197, 0.023603584617376328, 0.006562194786965847, -0.028790807351469994, -0.036753229796886444, -0.014849197119474411, 0.04174860939383507, 0.06199607625603676, -0.019863292574882507, 0.0011440146481618285, 0.017394278198480606, -0.017059840261936188, 0.009957360103726387, 0.00549578620120883, 0.02903045527637005, -0.0454278327524662, -0.0004730616637971252, -0.053287263959646225, 0.005979723297059536, 0.010744338855147362, -0.04808034375309944, 0.0072346958331763744, -0.0025808503851294518, -0.01358862780034542, -0.07500547915697098, -0.005909099709242582, 0.0025535058230161667, -0.06598400324583054, 0.02596849761903286, 0.02980908751487732, 0.03606727719306946, -0.002768199425190687, -0.01981108821928501, 0.06678450852632523, 0.03405855968594551, -0.003449045354500413, 0.0014848588034510612, 0.005767923779785633, -0.02278376743197441, 0.0007109632715582848, -0.012400605715811253, -0.0018164378125220537, 0.026692118495702744, 0.05382194370031357, 0.002900010207667947, -0.007380061782896519, -0.029776237905025482, 0.015669113025069237, -0.06269920617341995, -0.0008043377310968935, -0.05435335636138916, 0.008796892128884792, -0.006362535059452057, 0.04095270857214928, 0.013218694366514683, -0.01732487790286541, -0.015490646474063396, 0.014873038046061993, -0.07528285682201385, 0.010408836416900158, -0.013354284688830376, -0.004506497643887997, -0.008313416503369808, -0.022612953558564186, 0.031028056517243385, 0.02048920840024948, 0.05872853100299835, -0.003108320292085409, 0.04514385759830475, -0.029681548476219177, 0.03807586431503296, -0.015609229914844036, -0.03809770196676254, 0.02939009852707386, 0.01359705999493599, 0.05362702161073685, 0.01511162705719471, 0.03166285902261734, -0.012857847847044468, -0.00878354161977768, -0.03867219388484955, 0.00009127553494181484, 0.005838323850184679, -0.005081042647361755, -0.013447580859065056, -0.004709695000201464, 0.06300608068704605, -0.04694168642163277, 0.024040181189775467, -0.0020741852931678295, 0.045598290860652924, -0.005474622827023268, -0.04460296407341957, 0.02036929875612259, -0.012223020195960999, -0.014128781855106354, 0.012329107150435448, 0.017470769584178925, -0.025145767256617546, 0.019269362092018127, 0.005003755446523428, 0.017900429666042328, -0.04389971122145653, -0.011277536861598492, 0.07137125730514526, 0.008622761815786362, -0.023110326379537582, -0.026470422744750977, -0.006496813613921404, 0.0026384613011032343, 0.0018699347274377942, 0.022765377536416054, 0.029855873435735703, 0.0034480567555874586, 0.02530202828347683, 0.045604318380355835, -0.01625164970755577, -0.007497911807149649, 0.0005988692864775658, 0.021734774112701416, 0.05757220834493637, -0.039266180247068405, -0.03548792004585266, 0.017603415995836258, 0.04464733973145485, 0.033701300621032715, 0.018884534016251564, 0.012765161693096161, -0.10324934124946594, -0.002223613206297159, 0.03916863352060318, 0.03969951719045639, -0.023458480834960938, 0.019788745790719986, -0.06182636320590973, -0.022585557773709297, 0.02991567738354206, -0.045409973710775375, 0.011320140212774277, -0.007203719113022089, -0.013857553713023663, -0.009644536301493645, 0.006613190285861492, -0.03140699118375778, 0.01023225486278534, -0.029097802937030792, 0.0164216049015522, -0.024137157946825027, -0.012655009515583515, -0.04069247096776962, 0.01261205691844225, 0.00027753185713663697, 0.04213233292102814, -0.03511069715023041, -0.01721034198999405, 0.03392534330487251, 0.0008837698260322213, -0.002222837880253792, -0.017003364861011505, 0.01668400503695011, 0.022468212991952896, 0.025219811126589775, 0.07476522028446198, -0.03233257681131363, -0.048302192240953445, 0.032519347965717316, 0.009639352560043335, -0.033937204629182816, 0.03161991760134697, -0.013475378975272179, 0.031931035220623016, 0.026477940380573273, -0.0012993470299988985, 0.025045718997716904, 0.012217722833156586, -0.013225102797150612, 0.02782101184129715, -0.04341458901762962, 0.023623725399374962, -0.05838519334793091, -0.01059461198747158, -0.04107961803674698, -0.02612806111574173, -0.020008129999041557, -0.013443727977573872, 0.00785782840102911, 0.054684657603502274, -0.015744710341095924, -0.015306253917515278, 0.016147077083587646, 0.0006302971742115915, 0.007700232323259115, 0.024308176711201668, -0.014786682091653347, 0.015103895217180252, 0.02120327763259411, 0.0029649322386831045, 0.03601407632231712, 0.010824069380760193, 0.022587455809116364, -0.002571000251919031, -0.0760485902428627, 0.004734263755381107, -0.038911253213882446, -0.03280802071094513, 0.053550850600004196, -0.00150098477024585, 0.017998969182372093, 0.0151929697021842, 0.052312109619379044, 0.003933962434530258, -0.04780084267258644, -0.028121506795287132, 0.005679002497345209, 0.0009055181872099638, 0.03287855535745621, -0.018628036603331566, 0.02887849695980549, 0.004281971137970686, -0.022881023585796356, -0.04699296876788139, -0.02628505602478981, 0.03443978354334831, -0.05418878793716431, -0.04312088340520859, -0.10293801128864288, 0.023260653018951416, 0.03911447525024414, -0.010448860935866833, -0.011473018676042557, 0.05213114619255066, -0.016120951622724533, 0.01532124262303114, -0.017749417573213577, 0.018103836104273796, 0.06292614340782166, 0.02845943719148636, -0.019617805257439613, 0.036942433565855026, 0.03182462602853775, 0.003810636466369033, -0.0031402541790157557, 0.018410541117191315, 0.0003850506036542356, 0.02270057052373886, -0.029171280562877655, 0.010884299874305725, 0.06564178317785263, -0.05401065945625305, -0.0249163880944252, -0.0038300754968076944, 0.02916657365858555, 0.012447003275156021, -0.0697551742196083, -0.0014684040797874331, -0.0026555643416941166, -0.01462955866008997, -0.06058265641331673, 0.024625074118375778, 0.0023096080403774977, -0.0030680890195071697, 0.03789624944329262, -0.019430916756391525, -0.0024648746475577354, 0.031032010912895203, 0.040322307497262955, 0.030313508585095406, -0.008857442066073418, 0.010087982751429081, -0.00802274513989687, 0.007122112438082695, -0.019191112369298935, 0.006218052469193935, -0.0007823760970495641, 0.010789179243147373, -0.026899516582489014, -0.018477315083146095, -0.048938337713479996, -0.004605521913617849, 0.05039815232157707, 0.045900363475084305, 0.04199817404150963, 0.05318833515048027, -0.008154005743563175, -0.003979675006121397, -0.056044645607471466, -0.014863064512610435, -0.027682896703481674, 0.03798918426036835, 0.045506544411182404, -0.007388606667518616, -0.0026683651376515627, 0.06540539115667343, 0.011999224312603474, 0.031129032373428345, 0.04774145036935806, 0.01752087101340294, 0.01294171903282404, 0.013564977794885635, -0.04941529408097267, -0.057847630232572556, 0.025508452206850052, -0.034789420664310455, 0.02441234700381756, -0.051063138991594315, -0.056177932769060135, 0.03218585252761841, 0.07418917864561081, 0.039052434265613556, -0.032374173402786255, -0.007244734093546867, -0.06495129317045212, 0.060896486043930054, 0.04360124096274376, -0.008225719444453716, 0.008494541980326176, 0.017955072224140167, 0.031676724553108215, -0.003808851120993495, 0.011015770956873894, -0.009452630765736103, -0.0312088280916214, -0.027168989181518555, -0.03860758990049362, -0.01878504641354084, 0.027660002931952477, 0.016846662387251854, -0.04679058864712715, 0.002516155131161213, -0.01471100002527237, 0.01941443420946598, 0.032044295221567154, 0.01593576930463314, -0.016594460234045982, 0.0401461198925972, -0.010192046873271465, 0.004017999861389399, -0.037019260227680206, -0.009055922739207745, 0.1595427691936493, 0.0480172224342823, 0.06791921705007553, -0.051318105310201645, -0.007254777476191521, 0.0369681715965271, -0.005970545578747988, -0.02584032714366913, 0.010827908292412758, -0.005310263019055128, -0.020075460895895958, 0.006167078856378794, 0.028265319764614105, 0.04353822395205498, 0.01926322840154171, 0.06373459100723267, -0.002624035580083728, -0.012810454703867435, -0.021679284051060677, -0.01895591989159584, -0.0035269230138510466, -0.03490620478987694, -0.10367550700902939, 0.05680908262729645, 0.030961349606513977, -0.03335949406027794, -0.022992949932813644, -0.009651685133576393, -0.023380976170301437, 0.021581314504146576, -0.01462443359196186, -0.03823680430650711, -0.003556642448529601, -0.005125727038830519, 0.03436024859547615, -0.009536121040582657, 0.03420229256153107, -0.05636797472834587, 0.028480805456638336, 0.024051059037446976, 0.02931460179388523, -0.02654753439128399, -0.01903616264462471, -0.0018459886778146029, -0.027351349592208862, -0.021070873364806175, -0.02957288734614849, 0.05884639173746109, -0.03522630035877228, 0.018858306109905243, 0.02256295271217823, -0.0018951008096337318, 0.002858369145542383, -0.00743250735104084, 0.015359500423073769, 0.007463023532181978, 0.05509837344288826, 0.013512363657355309, -0.0015675188042223454, -0.03444938361644745, 0.022871626541018486, -0.018571509048342705, 0.02662060782313347, 0.020943092182278633, -0.00817738939076662, -0.06981469690799713, -0.020357439294457436, 0.040630899369716644, 0.0015024638269096613, 0.014555379748344421, -0.0003311682667117566, -0.010945581831037998, -0.0005820649676024914, 0.008536921814084053, 0.0037845021579414606, 0.01347379107028246, 0.02070002630352974, 0.001465218490920961, -0.0016278235707432032, -0.004242738708853722, -0.008624874986708164, 0.0035424218513071537, -0.04043615609407425, -0.016278769820928574, 0.005354685243219137, 0.012508431449532509, 0.030354883521795273, 0.04660646617412567, -0.006319896318018436, 0.04498247429728508, 0.0010375321144238114, 0.006744963116943836, 0.011347620747983456, -0.031286854296922684, -0.00561544019728899, -0.02271980233490467, -0.03774723410606384, -0.0057173012755811214, -0.009306436404585838, 0.03715311735868454, 0.017941247671842575, -0.010999892838299274, 0.005149475764483213, 0.02991875819861889, -0.022958213463425636, 0.04254026710987091, 0.013341128826141357, -0.04334203898906708, 0.005231100134551525, -0.020633304491639137, -0.01300327479839325, -0.06936253607273102, -0.021417396143078804, 0.006912292446941137, -0.03577287122607231, 0.008161535486578941, -0.02788105048239231, -0.053623903542757034, -0.014507005922496319, 0.009086895734071732, 0.006132143083959818, -0.03616443648934364, 0.009755147621035576, -0.014029869809746742, -0.00614831643179059, -0.04559975862503052, -0.0027278957422822714, -0.006249775644391775, 0.01183345727622509, -0.0013501622015610337, 0.022892143577337265, 0.04462462663650513, 0.023368466645479202, 0.022027907893061638, 0.0034896410070359707, 0.032898664474487305, -0.019643716514110565, -0.0008354762685485184, -0.011894338764250278, -0.019811850041151047, 0.027972614392638206, -0.04362478852272034, -0.07467085123062134, -0.016754599288105965, 0.026343312114477158, 0.047618553042411804, 0.00818190909922123, 0.007879803888499737, -0.021720971912145615, 0.03234652057290077, -0.017921745777130127, -0.01397015806287527, 0.014557916671037674, 0.046408217400312424, 0.03804757446050644, 0.0025779325515031815, -0.042198166251182556, -0.004887519869953394, -0.028324436396360397, 0.03171582147479057, 0.026291722431778908, 0.009053939953446388, 0.01608385145664215, 0.04899368807673454, -0.046020884066820145, -0.0018031098879873753, -0.051425009965896606, -0.003174268640577793, 0.05401064455509186, 0.055950842797756195, -0.06945370882749557, 0.03703626990318298, -0.019917573779821396, 0.016976404935121536, -0.08624200522899628, -0.030775917693972588, 0.011949833482503891, 0.038372207432985306, 0.0483977347612381, -0.0373147651553154, 0.007309900131076574, 0.023733828216791153, -0.0774315595626831, 0.009280238300561905, 0.03771766647696495, 0.018028732389211655, -0.026573121547698975, 0.02555740810930729, -0.03998710215091705, 0.030998162925243378, 0.015437668189406395, 0.06663975119590759, 0.05477181077003479, 0.04133809357881546, 0.005754544865339994, 0.002987914951518178, 0.008373256772756577, 0.0033259443007409573, -0.00016998131468426436, -0.0399356372654438, 0.031007708981633186, -0.03564845770597458, -0.007985611446201801, 0.020729273557662964, 0.02337583154439926, 0.044568438082933426, 0.07004761695861816, 0.04864023998379707, -0.0076420544646680355, 0.06320399791002274, 0.010037995874881744, 0.005018375813961029, 0.00894182175397873, -0.017068540677428246, 0.011825760826468468, 0.010927014984190464, -0.02156676910817623, 0.013821050524711609, 0.03336642310023308, -0.032472897320985794, -0.013118188828229904, 0.010527060367166996, -0.038936108350753784, -0.014332321472465992, -0.00829777680337429, -0.0012648768024519086, -0.0069731720723211765, -0.0003793816140387207, 0.002052175346761942, -0.05159381031990051, 0.01845499873161316, 0.012381366454064846, 0.01293265912681818, -0.01671862229704857, 0.05292342230677605, -0.01722695678472519, -0.022558903321623802, 0.007559024728834629, -0.01702062226831913, -0.005715504754334688, -0.017266158014535904, 0.024740101769566536, 0.013624893501400948, 0.018662085756659508, -0.014735331758856773, 0.017525650560855865, -0.020638078451156616, 0.06304776668548584, -0.03214466571807861, 0.029563909396529198, 0.03729284182190895, -0.0035960599780082703, 0.05494585633277893, -0.07951417565345764, 0.058834996074438095, -0.0046226573176681995, -0.02123076096177101, -0.02975592017173767, -0.016002612188458443, -0.03124820441007614, -0.009579240344464779, 0.06068667396903038, -0.018456455320119858, 0.034962039440870285, -0.02828291989862919, 0.036931347101926804, 0.05253646522760391, -0.02135205827653408, 0.045301735401153564, -0.0466168150305748, -0.023397395387291908, 0.02043306827545166, -0.005169982556253672, 0.0250631682574749, -0.014537363313138485, 0.03870414197444916, -0.01717539131641388, -0.019289836287498474, 0.0040025608614087105, -0.017041273415088654, 0.021812546998262405, -0.01510343886911869, -0.008901664055883884, 0.01793341524899006, -0.017826495692133904, -0.019459474831819534, 0.034514475613832474, -0.002431458793580532, -0.04442516341805458, 0.026205355301499367, 0.004804699681699276, -0.037219248712062836, -0.004136063624173403, -0.005989393685013056, 0.0022495617158710957, -0.0374377965927124, -0.00995421502739191, 0.015608021058142185, 0.0010814054403454065, -0.007746577262878418, 0.030115757137537003, 0.011526205576956272, 0.0771898701786995, 0.03256477043032646, 0.011972693726420403, -0.010591560043394566, 0.00008525616431143135, 0.06175091117620468, -0.014717557467520237, 0.018330184742808342, 0.004641578532755375, -0.030595475807785988, 0.019677095115184784, -0.03443358466029167, 0.015479459427297115, -0.023471307009458542, 0.008818531408905983, -0.01693161204457283, -0.009754541330039501, -0.00940762273967266, -0.0196035448461771, 0.012824250385165215, 0.02291380986571312, -0.004940875340253115, 0.07429800182580948, -0.011297018267214298, -0.01725980080664158, -0.03989691287279129, -0.024095114320516586, -0.02812834456562996, 0.021634196862578392, -0.017379874363541603, 0.026863889768719673, 0.00553757743909955, 0.0413757860660553, -0.0017310379771515727, -0.011934560723602772, 0.04887551814317703, -0.03527591750025749, 0.012622743844985962, -0.03311183303594589, 0.02071036957204342, 0.015554181300103664, -0.0038344431668519974, 0.004715796560049057, -0.023684801533818245, 0.03031001053750515, 0.019681930541992188, 0.011975017376244068, -0.05849412828683853, 0.016818532720208168, -0.0046860952861607075, 0.03064076416194439, -0.05255834758281708, -0.01336662471294403, -0.04854454845190048, 0.0037776553072035313, -0.03216606378555298, -0.011522457003593445 ]
<p>I have some trouble with score functions in likelihood calculation. I'm not good at statistics or probability, so I'm still confused on formalism and mathematical-probabilistic language.</p> <p><strong>Some background:</strong> I'm on particle filter, so inferring a pdf that is analytically intractable by a Monte Carlo sampling: put some random particles, evaluate them with a likelihood function, and the normalised-weighted set of particles can be an approximation of the pdf.</p> <p>I have to give a weight to each particle and compute the likelihood with a likelihood function or score function.</p> <p>If my hidden state described by this difficult pdf that I have to infer is denoted as $X$, and I have some observation $z$, the likelihood can be formalised by:</p> <p>$$ p( X | z ) = \text{likelihood} $$</p> <p><strong>What I have now:</strong> a nice distance function that give me the distance between the particle and the target. It works. It is the Bhattacharyya distance (I'm working with images, and colour histogram is a relevant feature). So that:</p> <p>$$ d = \text{Bhattacharyya(particle, target)} $$</p> <p>This $d$ is a distance, and for a likelihood function I need a probability, so I'm putting it into a <a href="http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=e%5E%28-%28d-0%29%5E2/%282%200.4%5E2%29%29/%28sqrt%282%20pi%29%200.4%29" rel="nofollow">Gaussian with zero means and variance = 0.4</a>:</p> <p>$$ \text{likelihood} = \frac{e^{-\frac{(d-\mu)^2}{2 \sigma^2}}}{\sqrt[2]{ \pi \sigma}} $$</p> <p><strong>What I want:</strong> Now I'd like to improve my experiments, adding similarly another score function so that the total likelihood is calculated with two score functions (let's say a shape-distance or something else) $s_1$ and $s_2$.</p> <p>I remember from school (but don't remember exactly why) that if you want to combine 2 probabilities, you have only to multiply, not sum. So I know that:</p> <p>$$ \text{likelihood} \propto s_1 s_2 $$</p> <p>where $s_1$ is the Gaussian with the Bhattacharyya with the colour histogram, and $s_2$ is the shape distance.</p> <p>The two score functions are Gaussian, and they are not independent (they depend on the same hidden state).</p> <p><strong>Question 1</strong>: Is it true I have to multiply them? Why? So that my final formula will be:</p> <p>$$ \text{likelihood} = \frac{e^{-\frac{(d_1-\mu)^2}{2 \sigma^2}}}{\sqrt[2]{ \pi \sigma}} \frac{e^{-\frac{(d_2-\mu)^2}{2 \sigma^2}}}{\sqrt[2]{ \pi \sigma}} $$</p> <p><strong>Question 2:</strong> What if I want to empirically add some more importance to one of the two scores because I think it is more descriptive of my data? Like:</p> <p>$$ \text{likelihood} = \alpha s_1 (1-\alpha)s_2 $$</p>
36,045
[ 0.00255236541852355, -0.03849320486187935, 0.033917538821697235, -0.040818952023983, 0.025157742202281952, -0.001411288627423346, -0.0297105610370636, -0.011881777085363865, -0.014980737119913101, -0.023655470460653305, 0.04004883021116257, 0.043217338621616364, 0.0622689388692379, 0.014097385108470917, 0.004178506322205067, 0.004385539796203375, -0.016684163361787796, 0.012491937726736069, -0.028331153094768524, -0.028321940451860428, 0.08167469501495361, 0.03173702955245972, 0.024232367053627968, -0.03945942595601082, -0.012781892903149128, 0.023636654019355774, 0.008758713491261005, -0.03094085305929184, -0.010684107430279255, 0.06941314786672592, -0.03777812048792839, -0.03443652018904686, 0.012417064979672432, 0.02050650306046009, 0.007013530004769564, 0.017655884847044945, -0.0029947904404252768, -0.008953172713518143, -0.01773078925907612, 0.02654978260397911, -0.03507610782980919, -0.020555566996335983, 0.008979004807770252, 0.06867428123950958, -0.004179283976554871, -0.0037210467271506786, -0.0037601080257445574, -0.008101477287709713, 0.026562241837382317, -0.057420480996370316, 0.06909094005823135, 0.026337573304772377, 0.012306004762649536, 0.012664937414228916, -0.009461484849452972, -0.05639009550213814, 0.03860074281692505, 0.08463490754365921, -0.03790755942463875, -0.06599652767181396, -0.03784099593758583, -0.021825099363923073, 0.011373819783329964, -0.03600334748625755, 0.005973455496132374, 0.0030791223980486393, 0.028802331537008286, -0.0193234384059906, 0.05125365033745766, -0.004075680859386921, 0.002809548983350396, 0.01852729357779026, -0.006129753310233355, 0.0004800402675755322, 0.02511279471218586, -0.020748548209667206, 0.011676731519401073, 0.05909609794616699, 0.034020476043224335, 0.014617061242461205, 0.0035104677081108093, 0.004927400965243578, -0.01981637440621853, 0.005546088330447674, 0.0036614073906093836, 0.003489540424197912, 0.08313076198101044, -0.03877483680844307, 0.02007201686501503, 0.030094707384705544, -0.04230527579784393, 0.011067931540310383, 0.05114169418811798, -0.031710218638181686, -0.01805705577135086, 0.06593107432126999, -0.003701192559674382, 0.018541788682341576, 0.01738017611205578, -0.02278410829603672, -0.034572783857584, -0.055928681045770645, 0.029358353465795517, 0.06265325844287872, -0.017099494114518166, -0.008205180056393147, 0.025179613381624222, 0.0032804396469146013, -0.03719279542565346, -0.012563472613692284, -0.03117161989212036, 0.049095191061496735, 0.010168672539293766, 0.004489661660045385, -0.0070401765406131744, -0.024158671498298645, -0.02133787050843239, -0.020929619669914246, 0.06769336014986038, 0.00138227385468781, 0.013458664529025555, -0.026640456169843674, -0.004708885680884123, -0.04992757365107536, -0.04828968271613121, 0.012144599109888077, 0.05123652145266533, -0.012656152248382568, -0.011800137348473072, 0.027378687635064125, 0.005091846454888582, -0.00019259918190073222, 0.04188455268740654, 0.029309043660759926, 0.000660307181533426, 0.010584574192762375, -0.0839875265955925, -0.04673803225159645, 0.06833887100219727, 0.014909214340150356, 0.021833321079611778, -0.06438879668712616, -0.04342431575059891, 0.06605228036642075, 0.026447979733347893, -0.006442926358431578, 0.024642834439873695, -0.007056082598865032, 0.03540975973010063, -0.01661461964249611, -0.02724846638739109, -0.007380583789199591, -0.04279109090566635, 0.010602300055325031, -0.02704755589365959, -0.04456633701920509, 0.023519448935985565, 0.01419049222022295, -0.0145946079865098, -0.016232164576649666, 0.05896618217229843, -0.02142387442290783, -0.027073118835687637, 0.0029164478182792664, 0.01728929579257965, -0.03360394015908241, 0.05974745377898216, 0.009416832588613033, 0.02273036539554596, 0.009614991955459118, -0.04524604231119156, 0.007406381890177727, 0.0002581004227977246, -0.008805685676634312, 0.07474009692668915, -0.026465609669685364, -0.04740769788622856, -0.04191579297184944, 0.007026418577879667, 0.006157573312520981, -0.0143539784476161, -0.031217874959111214, -0.029514921829104424, 0.010848380625247955, 0.00026851415168493986, -0.0070200227200984955, 0.04399603232741356, -0.01172611489892006, 0.00791239459067583, -0.030727537348866463, -0.033693116158246994, -0.044900644570589066, -0.01673492230474949, -0.024922607466578484, 0.008984644897282124, 0.04311947152018547, -0.026525383815169334, -0.02200651355087757, 0.039864011108875275, -0.019205816090106964, -0.02805917337536812, -0.008374790661036968, 0.00805603340268135, 0.0020844177342951298, -0.007796135731041431, 0.06770408153533936, 0.02977742999792099, 0.014259075745940208, 0.03405039757490158, -0.01928587444126606, -0.009496470913290977, -0.0336623452603817, -0.0066269622184336185, 0.04861057922244072, 0.0005818441859446466, -0.00622256426140666, 0.009562699124217033, -0.05547921359539032, -0.027279851958155632, -0.016888679936528206, -0.025105318054556847, 0.04259825125336647, 0.08096255362033844, -0.001550609478726983, -0.030858438462018967, 0.029482005164027214, 0.015983914956450462, 0.020596370100975037, 0.005342317745089531, -0.02201797254383564, -0.03775801509618759, -0.026800742372870445, 0.006448663771152496, 0.030965199694037437, -0.028695983812212944, -0.0006274563493207097, 0.05493394285440445, 0.023624097928404808, 0.008288518525660038, -0.0031015463173389435, -0.008045484311878681, -0.03274695947766304, 0.042358558624982834, -0.009852509014308453, -0.028675923123955727, -0.01008826307952404, 0.015656396746635437, -0.015315873548388481, 0.03034464828670025, -0.004477981477975845, -0.03051433525979519, -0.006829466205090284, 0.021348413079977036, -0.002507322235032916, -0.05102178081870079, -0.012161762453615665, 0.016520068049430847, -0.003101506968960166, 0.03192998096346855, 0.05763569101691246, -0.054226912558078766, -0.019792884588241577, -0.01063332986086607, -0.04902141913771629, 0.004748714156448841, 0.04373641684651375, -0.024281149730086327, -0.010988873429596424, 0.024929028004407883, -0.04113681986927986, 0.04152475297451019, 0.03887036442756653, -0.013986158184707165, 0.01398527156561613, 0.005974746309220791, 0.00028816951089538634, 0.030035583302378654, -0.024237697944045067, -0.037376657128334045, -0.03080509789288044, 0.012143087573349476, 0.014257189817726612, 0.045058391988277435, 0.05782657116651535, -0.04939514398574829, 0.005003118421882391, -0.05921906977891922, -0.044674430042505264, 0.006114004645496607, -0.0159778892993927, -0.018287820741534233, 0.010695787146687508, -0.01930205710232258, 0.004964002408087254, -0.018741639330983162, 0.031023859977722168, 0.0008287138771265745, -0.062432631850242615, -0.027875050902366638, 0.017303921282291412, 0.031043581664562225, -0.024593304842710495, 0.02821442298591137, -0.03960980102419853, -0.05011576786637306, -0.040773533284664154, 0.03422579914331436, -0.02583163045346737, -0.02126944437623024, 0.04617976397275925, 0.03003976307809353, -0.02622082456946373, 0.04809221252799034, -0.05146467313170433, -0.03594139590859413, 0.029197897762060165, -0.007738109678030014, 0.010203112848103046, 0.010853935033082962, -0.013302373699843884, 0.08256920427083969, 0.04139740392565727, -0.03695158660411835, -0.033150844275951385, 0.008170760236680508, -0.043080929666757584, -0.006526559125632048, 0.007001979276537895, 0.008496355265378952, 0.011799640022218227, 0.004529780708253384, 0.005013827234506607, 0.0003815969976130873, 0.04454466328024864, -0.010264362208545208, -0.00033676603925414383, 0.04958522692322731, -0.009096315130591393, -0.04188092052936554, 0.05568741261959076, 0.013440798968076706, 0.01647741161286831, 0.047261402010917664, -0.01046112459152937, 0.012161445803940296, 0.052036117762327194, -0.028243981301784515, 0.017329568043351173, 0.010116825811564922, 0.004257548600435257, -0.06244266405701637, 0.0752943903207779, 0.024295296519994736, -0.054238416254520416, -0.006100155878812075, -0.040030039846897125, 0.04494038224220276, -0.006868273951113224, 0.0005866489955224097, 0.03886198624968529, 0.03427381440997124, 0.0021182107739150524, -0.020252764225006104, -0.026501992717385292, -0.0005043693236075342, -0.0015819065738469362, -0.004997181240469217, -0.03697420656681061, 0.024372871965169907, 0.041276250034570694, 0.0006480010342784226, -0.01110400352627039, 0.0022692298516631126, -0.04019487276673317, -0.04808085784316063, 0.010603050701320171, -0.019375959411263466, 0.0424785241484642, 0.028818123042583466, 0.04129302129149437, 0.03233679011464119, -0.0171195175498724, -0.015326952561736107, -0.03491543233394623, -0.08340653032064438, 0.0308744665235281, 0.007583226077258587, -0.00125149788800627, -0.02255399338901043, -0.0450991727411747, 0.01195297297090292, -0.042064931243658066, -0.014769652858376503, -0.02868722938001156, 0.052690692245960236, -0.012225208804011345, -0.004163916222751141, -0.018466465175151825, -0.04496437683701515, -0.011509856209158897, 0.0547441802918911, 0.04801653325557709, -0.017645999789237976, 0.032006192952394485, 0.048589516431093216, -0.01931159198284149, -0.009869987145066261, -0.021991299465298653, -0.0019982107914984226, 0.02888387069106102, 0.02249164693057537, 0.025767125189304352, 0.028961865231394768, -0.020617058500647545, 0.01751319319009781, 0.0039903828874230385, 0.044026970863342285, 0.0043903072364628315, -0.03687424585223198, 0.016470568254590034, -0.03239022195339203, -0.028371399268507957, -0.00011443818220868707, 0.02138584852218628, -0.04040248692035675, 0.026606572791934013, 0.03078456036746502, -0.029064185917377472, -0.02694331482052803, 0.0005249780369922519, 0.01595708727836609, 0.0026371378917247057, -0.021055098623037338, -0.03784758225083351, -0.016230372712016106, -0.007767091505229473, 0.010986275970935822, 0.015078033320605755, 0.02366534061729908, 0.01428233552724123, -0.009033549576997757, 0.024825984612107277, 0.00945712998509407, -0.02219502627849579, -0.017452269792556763, 0.009130588732659817, 0.006756168324500322, 0.002969405148178339, 0.015005253255367279, 0.029160771518945694, 0.03529413416981697, 0.017476530745625496, -0.00018464184540789574, 0.0287761352956295, -0.07917124032974243, -0.015631649643182755, 0.04386290907859802, 0.04756125435233116, -0.01993766985833645, 0.003897406393662095, -0.05350333824753761, -0.013930375687777996, 0.022458819672465324, -0.02014843001961708, 0.021137313917279243, -0.017534567043185234, 0.003259099554270506, 0.008472916670143604, -0.03382768854498863, -0.043205611407756805, 0.014079217799007893, 0.001611927174963057, -0.011684032157063484, -0.024199603125452995, -0.050812479108572006, -0.02712649665772915, -0.0008465041755698621, 0.017828796058893204, 0.05530768260359764, -0.023465143516659737, 0.0026640978176146746, 0.007930011488497257, -0.04767929017543793, -0.0064869108609855175, -0.06171223893761635, 0.0005470440373755991, -0.02471407689154148, -0.0028374535031616688, 0.036326177418231964, -0.029002336785197258, -0.027997268363833427, 0.011820782907307148, -0.005259913858026266, -0.010393877513706684, 0.0293105635792017, -0.031674228608608246, 0.03339987248182297, 0.045221958309412, 0.02195034921169281, 0.021517518907785416, 0.00925416685640812, -0.028105972334742546, 0.02009006217122078, -0.05228303372859955, 0.022223763167858124, -0.02420114353299141, -0.024298740550875664, -0.06251690536737442, 0.005294532049447298, -0.04117538034915924, 0.023023033514618874, 0.019724030047655106, 0.03978312388062477, -0.013920355588197708, -0.04468464106321335, -0.030111487954854965, 0.024102546274662018, -0.030975913628935814, 0.02489924617111683, -0.014474472962319851, 0.01911264844238758, 0.029804622754454613, 0.003890280146151781, 0.0019534295424818993, -0.008715528063476086, 0.02278786711394787, -0.01913195289671421, -0.05427093431353569, 0.007101293653249741, -0.033351413905620575, -0.011222144588828087, 0.03699522092938423, -0.05606304109096527, 0.03284768760204315, -0.027201363816857338, -0.008527600206434727, -0.006439972203224897, -0.044725146144628525, -0.034320954233407974, 0.009343903511762619, -0.00241245049983263, 0.030772225931286812, -0.028236549347639084, -0.0006377655081450939, -0.03650910034775734, 0.011327414773404598, -0.02656557410955429, 0.013989709317684174, -0.010201127268373966, 0.0000579350526095368, -0.025208186358213425, -0.035964615643024445, 0.02697644755244255, 0.006909720133990049, -0.021573232486844063, -0.042215075343847275, 0.02214316464960575, 0.02775128185749054, 0.0393851213157177, -0.012874237261712551, 0.007038906682282686, 0.03045082837343216, -0.003754404839128256, 0.014116686768829823, 0.02103489451110363, 0.016196317970752716, 0.009672354906797409, 0.03536873310804367, 0.007307844236493111, -0.03874947130680084, -0.005484320688992739, 0.013168159872293472, 0.006612573284655809, 0.002175339963287115, -0.05162382125854492, -0.0024163478519767523, -0.016582392156124115, 0.047957226634025574, -0.016322225332260132, 0.003030432155355811, -0.044516369700431824, -0.01881541684269905, -0.007834047079086304, -0.040806323289871216, 0.00446091266348958, 0.0001930244907271117, 0.0076632206328213215, 0.04262925684452057, -0.02088545821607113, -0.007453895173966885, 0.013439611531794071, 0.05212801694869995, -0.006705601699650288, -0.015972081571817398, 0.01445797923952341, 0.019529664888978004, 0.05252191424369812, -0.022967681288719177, 0.013708606362342834, 0.04895884543657303, 0.010888886637985706, -0.03320571780204773, -0.004294541664421558, -0.08466958999633789, -0.02034236490726471, 0.05447668209671974, 0.002566527109593153, 0.03598298132419586, -0.024739211425185204, -0.009156579151749611, 0.01099665928632021, -0.04156201705336571, -0.029290711507201195, -0.004719938617199659, 0.002178431022912264, 0.027583518996834755, -0.023295922204852104, 0.00009645211684983224, 0.01691054366528988, -0.004939042963087559, 0.016998600214719772, 0.00817977823317051, 0.015333338640630245, 0.020386477932333946, 0.03772793710231781, -0.05230455845594406, -0.008480677381157875, 0.03995689004659653, -0.01971263438463211, 0.0037717465311288834, -0.013877849094569683, -0.03205803781747818, 0.04734334722161293, 0.04938136413693428, 0.006123803555965424, -0.024064628407359123, -0.002363960025832057, -0.059903357177972794, 0.03864159435033798, 0.04742995277047157, -0.03797018527984619, 0.0299887303262949, -0.011120691895484924, 0.02750512957572937, -0.001319478265941143, -0.000719123927410692, -0.03199170157313347, -0.049779102206230164, -0.028865288943052292, -0.04289492219686508, -0.06208212301135063, 0.001359382877126336, -0.023276157677173615, -0.02029486931860447, 0.018257368355989456, -0.00012072645768057555, 0.05492372810840607, -0.016315272077918053, -0.009083658456802368, -0.018287910148501396, 0.029028920456767082, -0.0009688314748927951, 0.005403309594839811, -0.014049624092876911, -0.00823953840881586, 0.1300574243068695, 0.04656941071152687, 0.04654098302125931, -0.03574184700846672, -0.0012267444981262088, -0.02929561585187912, 0.0150876110419631, -0.03459015488624573, 0.043291814625263214, 0.044089674949645996, -0.014221344143152237, -0.018499406054615974, 0.01895769312977791, 0.02067853882908821, 0.0002781805524136871, 0.04179436340928078, -0.040752191096544266, -0.04720199853181839, -0.009340591728687286, -0.0063810269348323345, -0.02777397818863392, 0.0029201218858361244, -0.02806016430258751, -0.008364985696971416, -0.021295133978128433, -0.007370063569396734, -0.02150149829685688, -0.060580018907785416, -0.01726098172366619, -0.014038706198334694, -0.0010405887151136994, -0.017986703664064407, 0.017955338582396507, -0.01897609978914261, 0.04540421813726425, 0.0004883765941485763, 0.033581797033548355, -0.027787087485194206, 0.012581199407577515, 0.04041724652051926, 0.004027822520583868, 0.018857095390558243, 0.016325252130627632, -0.009114561602473259, -0.0013416644651442766, -0.039132747799158096, -0.05047567933797836, 0.06757093966007233, -0.02465648390352726, -0.0008766372338868678, 0.004947120323777199, 0.02217871882021427, -0.0016198542434722185, -0.0448230542242527, 0.03335482254624367, 0.005028760991990566, 0.04396310821175575, -0.005300421733409166, -0.019939566031098366, -0.007785938214510679, 0.05348556488752365, 0.01936469040811062, 0.025713160634040833, 0.04041872173547745, 0.021632103249430656, -0.03999108076095581, -0.0284530371427536, 0.06958230584859848, 0.001884459052234888, -0.017509903758764267, -0.0076332129538059235, 0.0012019566493108869, -0.03399590030312538, -0.026019008830189705, 0.030618170276284218, -0.0035071682650595903, 0.04105548933148384, -0.0033833510242402554, 0.012382566928863525, -0.021379828453063965, -0.061631690710783005, -0.0071446592919528484, -0.03349601477384567, -0.030026841908693314, -0.011906139552593231, 0.007170947268605232, 0.010072572156786919, 0.08106712996959686, 0.01846114732325077, 0.0038922596722841263, 0.020226314663887024, 0.04927688464522362, 0.015281015075743198, -0.07754842191934586, -0.030465003103017807, 0.017087481915950775, -0.007541042286902666, -0.0028870091773569584, -0.005177747458219528, 0.036817312240600586, 0.030779201537370682, 0.01003997027873993, 0.013510321266949177, 0.02160475216805935, -0.034506507217884064, 0.013724138960242271, -0.008061625063419342, -0.05050060153007507, 0.003958478104323149, 0.001520386547781527, -0.006987931672483683, -0.015908338129520416, -0.005857266020029783, -0.015913384035229683, -0.04114704951643944, 0.001992258010432124, -0.02918039821088314, -0.028297772631049156, -0.028268614783883095, 0.010058306157588959, 0.00160910002887249, -0.010867646895349026, 0.01904723048210144, 0.024224968627095222, 0.02606130577623844, -0.06420449167490005, 0.001533772679977119, -0.009124883450567722, 0.0016959751956164837, -0.00037789728958159685, -0.0003910518134944141, 0.05184066295623779, 0.0032653717789798975, 0.025120757520198822, -0.03149871900677681, 0.028475597500801086, -0.00391866359859705, 0.04963548108935356, 0.017441030591726303, 0.001770737231709063, 0.013041667640209198, -0.032085832208395004, -0.06934738159179688, 0.05087468773126602, 0.05041224882006645, 0.047297220677137375, 0.04321387782692909, 0.014563044533133507, -0.009517286904156208, 0.029375415295362473, 0.005812376271933317, -0.027894310653209686, -0.030188025906682014, -0.02756795659661293, -0.013710295781493187, -0.009761541150510311, 0.01778065226972103, 0.018661120906472206, -0.006093389820307493, 0.0552205964922905, 0.019563201814889908, 0.014912297017872334, 0.013602349907159805, 0.016451364383101463, -0.01585058867931366, 0.02245502918958664, -0.025450320914387703, -0.006567171774804592, 0.04133162647485733, 0.06288120150566101, 0.003464462235569954, 0.0060195582918822765, 0.012542341835796833, -0.01030000764876604, -0.1007164865732193, 0.005870196968317032, 0.04152250289916992, 0.0053743585012853146, 0.09132224321365356, -0.09248344600200653, 0.043597687035799026, 0.027995390817523003, -0.06665009260177612, -0.005226822569966316, -0.022578323259949684, 0.02244112454354763, 0.002229960635304451, 0.02572939358651638, -0.0311181228607893, 0.05639456585049629, 0.018629562109708786, 0.06065494194626808, 0.033510733395814896, 0.021607780829072, -0.012173905968666077, -0.04511387273669243, 0.0007120132213458419, 0.05173233896493912, 0.026376038789749146, -0.06684872508049011, 0.06704653054475784, -0.04918307065963745, -0.016619108617305756, 0.01756424270570278, 0.03561833128333092, 0.025185851380228996, -0.02320466749370098, 0.07416611909866333, 0.05473504588007927, 0.05222798138856888, 0.03333045542240143, 0.011917631141841412, 0.011775568127632141, -0.029942592605948448, 0.025538824498653412, 0.0021286753471940756, -0.04437527060508728, -0.013725434429943562, 0.00605670316144824, 0.020464284345507622, -0.04147391766309738, 0.05247121676802635, -0.0032998467795550823, -0.03900919854640961, 0.0046659489162266254, 0.0039847902953624725, 0.024620767682790756, -0.048547446727752686, 0.014283793047070503, -0.03334946930408478, 0.06912209838628769, 0.008687449619174004, 0.03084169141948223, -0.02404928393661976, 0.025896063074469566, -0.02353396825492382, -0.047688696533441544, 0.02033272199332714, -0.01698242500424385, -0.00871360395103693, -0.003281019162386656, 0.0028948746621608734, 0.01193284709006548, 0.03579949587583542, -0.015181265771389008, -0.000931972754187882, -0.025657257065176964, 0.013353658840060234, -0.016724176704883575, 0.0357004813849926, 0.016743600368499756, -0.01705559529364109, -0.007355303969234228, -0.08312909305095673, 0.04839238151907921, 0.017065580934286118, -0.015341675840318203, -0.05616000294685364, -0.011751143261790276, 0.019684599712491035, 0.009250647388398647, 0.049257539212703705, -0.008658288978040218, 0.018006209284067154, -0.004478109069168568, 0.01762142777442932, 0.02842596545815468, -0.004279825370758772, 0.01661444827914238, -0.015113117173314095, 0.015274829231202602, -0.020671993494033813, 0.03231867030262947, -0.0038407074753195047, 0.05374645069241524, 0.04493214562535286, -0.0005851797177456319, 0.010783460922539234, -0.013950279913842678, -0.03106730990111828, 0.057890623807907104, 0.005779672414064407, -0.016391444951295853, 0.02269873395562172, 0.0041969516314566135, 0.01264858990907669, 0.02575753629207611, -0.03901184722781181, -0.024265645071864128, -0.007691820152103901, -0.02229277603328228, -0.09087561815977097, 0.0321258120238781, -0.014602312818169594, 0.017946990206837654, -0.07589665055274963, -0.011323553510010242, 0.04518026486039162, 0.005369134247303009, -0.021446693688631058, 0.04531177505850792, 0.03644512966275215, 0.08317331969738007, 0.03467421233654022, 0.03652789816260338, -0.015462796203792095, 0.006607727613300085, 0.03173316270112991, -0.008187537081539631, 0.01670663245022297, -0.010446417145431042, 0.044443413615226746, -0.00046894734259694815, -0.016505219042301178, -0.006153741851449013, -0.004400762263685465, 0.026850879192352295, 0.020907249301671982, 0.0005360362702049315, 0.034059975296258926, 0.00360026559792459, -0.008413867093622684, -0.0004847213567700237, -0.036156922578811646, 0.11635302007198334, -0.03828451782464981, -0.011724918149411678, -0.050276752561330795, 0.02954472415149212, -0.04250841587781906, 0.033874694257974625, 0.007543411571532488, 0.025014912709593773, 0.02853384055197239, 0.007660181261599064, -0.008200830779969692, 0.009152649901807308, 0.00731334974989295, -0.047449544072151184, -0.012065984308719635, 0.006636762525886297, -0.01185376476496458, 0.027212049812078476, -0.01908840425312519, 0.004464660305529833, 0.008853831328451633, -0.009600250981748104, 0.013173156417906284, 0.028255702927708626, -0.01192888617515564, -0.0010360103333368897, -0.017288286238908768, 0.038040872663259506, -0.05029071494936943, -0.00005080417395220138, -0.04425560683012009, -0.01144613977521658, -0.019938938319683075, -0.03165459632873535 ]
<p>I'm trying to wrap my head around mixture modelling, and I've come across a small matlab script that seems relevant. In order to familiarize myself with pymix, I've decided to try rewriting the matlab script in python. I appear to have successfully fitted/decomposed the data with the expectation maximization algorithm, but I'm not sure I understand the nature of the method's output.</p> <p>My question is as follows:</p> <ol> <li>How can I replicate the second figure from the matlab code (below) with the output of <code>pymix.MixtureModel.EM</code>?</li> <li>Can someone explain the output of the above method?</li> </ol> <p>I should mention that I'm horribly under-educated in statistics and mathematics in general (I'm working on it!), so please assume I know nothing =)</p> <p>In any case, here's the matlab script:</p> <pre><code>% Generate some data drawn from two Gaussians data = [0.4+randn(100,1).*0.15; 1+ randn(200,1).*0.25]'; data(data &lt; 0.05) = 0.05; [n,x] = hist(data); bar(x,n); % Make the mixture model pdf mixtureGauss = ... @(x,m1,s1,m2,s2,theta) (theta*normpdf(x,m1,s1) + (1-theta)*normpdf(x,m2,s2)); % Set up parameters for the MLE function options = statset('mlecustom'); options.MaxIter = 20000; options.MaxFunEvals = 20000; % Get max likilihood parameters for our mixture model (start with some % reasonable guesses about the parameters) p = mle(data, 'pdf', mixtureGauss, 'start', [0.5 0.1 0.5 0.1 0.5], ... 'lowerbound', [-Inf 0 -Inf 0 0], 'upperbound', [Inf Inf Inf Inf 1], ... 'options', options); % Plot and print information hold on; x = linspace(min(data),max(data),100); plot(x, mixtureGauss(x,p(1),p(2),p(3),p(4),p(5))*max(n), 'r', 'LineWidth', 2); fprintf('Gauss 1: %0.2f (+/- %0.2f)\n', p(1), p(2)); fprintf('Gauss 2: %0.2f (+/- %0.2f)\n', p(3), p(4)); fprintf('Mix: %0.2f proportion first gaussian\n', p(5)); </code></pre> <p>And here's what I've done in python so far. Note that I'm running this code in iPython with the <code>--pylab=inline</code> option, thereby importing pyplot into my main workspace:</p> <pre><code>import numpy as np import mixture # Generate some data drawn from two Gaussians data = np.concatenate((0.4 + np.random.randn(100) * 0.15, 1 + np.random.randn(200) * 0.25)) data[np.nonzero(data &lt; .05)] = .05 print type(data), len(data) plt = Figure() hist(data, bins=50) show() # Create DataSet object mixdat = mixture.DataSet() mixdat.fromArray(data) # reasonable-guess mixture, akin to random starting point in K-Means n1 = mixture.NormalDistribution(-2, 0.4) n2 = mixture.NormalDistribution(2, 0.6) # Mixture model and EM clustering mix = mixture.MixtureModel(2, [.5, .5], [n1, n2]) postmat, _ = mix.EM(mixdat, 40, 0.1) fig = Figure() hist(data, bins=50) x = np.linspace(np.min(data), np.max(data), 100) # Now what? show() </code></pre> <p>Any other comments, criticisms, or explanations are more than welcome. Thanks for putting up with my ignorance ;-)</p>
36,046
[ -0.0607476569712162, -0.03166024014353752, -0.011010388843715191, -0.02286665514111519, 0.020014572888612747, 0.050964150577783585, -0.016620930284261703, -0.03554197773337364, 0.01717325672507286, -0.024770967662334442, 0.04089779034256935, 0.05093863978981972, 0.08624275773763657, 0.04459863156080246, 0.0389396995306015, 0.007395779713988304, 0.013149545527994633, 0.029631221666932106, -0.006322832778096199, -0.019733741879463196, -0.021735062822699547, 0.025288453325629234, 0.009010140784084797, -0.03177497535943985, -0.04309282451868057, 0.03528350591659546, 0.046204108744859695, -0.02504550665616989, -0.005557291675359011, 0.08245763927698135, -0.048150043934583664, -0.048470329493284225, 0.001030090032145381, -0.03241567686200142, 0.013029462657868862, 0.01251616794615984, -0.004079725127667189, -0.018951958045363426, -0.015433373861014843, 0.012488298118114471, -0.03255254402756691, -0.011077539063990116, 0.020238108932971954, 0.04214522987604141, -0.00582545530050993, 0.037144359201192856, 0.020356325432658195, -0.028702983632683754, 0.05674465373158455, -0.03919349983334541, 0.07725218683481216, 0.027458947151899338, 0.027999095618724823, -0.012266561388969421, 0.00025314625236205757, 0.002896218793466687, 0.036964744329452515, 0.06047472730278969, 0.028323715552687645, -0.0752255991101265, 0.029389364644885063, -0.0045444355346262455, 0.002225359668955207, 0.004046169109642506, 0.01499102171510458, 0.003313288325443864, 0.003652904648333788, -0.010989958420395851, 0.047989144921302795, 0.012079454958438873, 0.029683729633688927, 0.0529613271355629, 0.06002647429704666, -0.04035528376698494, 0.05744536966085434, 0.0060957046225667, -0.028181832283735275, -0.006302174646407366, 0.026450462639331818, 0.0066858078353106976, -0.0037177137564867735, 0.0073633622378110886, -0.023342391476035118, 0.025007089599967003, -0.002666901098564267, 0.01030668243765831, 0.06597104668617249, -0.001914486289024353, 0.029857853427529335, 0.01593276672065258, -0.053050339221954346, 0.03851860761642456, 0.010614704340696335, 0.005722749046981335, -0.00795031152665615, 0.039337970316410065, -0.009072801098227501, 0.05316317453980446, 0.009100665338337421, -0.0079813152551651, 0.012155378237366676, -0.021896762773394585, -0.039230696856975555, 0.042312633246183395, 0.0011744487565010786, 0.0038504493422806263, -0.00008534056541975588, -0.011044715531170368, 0.00843124557286501, -0.011701534502208233, -0.005627881735563278, 0.017944879829883575, 0.029997168108820915, -0.018598074093461037, -0.005814540199935436, -0.03513298183679581, 0.014138246886432171, 0.015113959088921547, 0.013233723118901253, 0.0692499503493309, -0.022874286398291588, 0.007815518416464329, -0.0031224731355905533, -0.022903066128492355, -0.0792464166879654, -0.024541785940527916, -0.004407028201967478, 0.004570308607071638, -0.019701534882187843, 0.03694614768028259, -0.035442497581243515, 0.004772897809743881, 0.07060641050338745, 0.035997118800878525, 0.017311397939920425, -0.015342351980507374, -0.095354363322258, -0.030144259333610535, 0.023965636268258095, -0.037196703255176544, 0.06082747131586075, -0.05167761817574501, -0.007372804451733828, 0.010784685611724854, 0.014458541758358479, 0.026275813579559326, 0.06179649010300636, 0.0030730264261364937, 0.019441599026322365, -0.022432541474699974, -0.006309966091066599, -0.003419693326577544, -0.0636129155755043, -0.00748072424903512, 0.003881483804434538, -0.05726734176278114, 0.008327357470989227, -0.0010831765830516815, -0.013049555011093616, 0.02145869843661785, 0.013663466088473797, 0.013787595555186272, -0.01631087251007557, 0.007213384844362736, -0.011299176141619682, 0.008512974716722965, 0.10703293979167938, 0.018132774159312248, 0.06248364970088005, 0.009044529870152473, -0.03794710338115692, -0.007579355966299772, -0.026562524959445, 0.010806526988744736, 0.024492846801877022, -0.005831056274473667, 0.0020987738389521837, -0.034953970462083817, 0.04843522608280182, 0.03917413949966431, -0.03672847896814346, -0.02418748289346695, -0.022681644186377525, -0.014763097278773785, 0.04944058507680893, 0.05959169939160347, 0.0318591482937336, -0.03491813689470291, 0.0614180751144886, -0.07532215863466263, -0.05134287849068642, -0.06420677900314331, 0.016468646004796028, -0.013202434405684471, -0.03932762145996094, 0.0045053488574922085, -0.013237412087619305, 0.03382285311818123, 0.01701205037534237, -0.022991541773080826, -0.05280033499002457, -0.02595669776201248, 0.02055584080517292, -0.0098981112241745, -0.0022329778876155615, 0.04190028831362724, 0.05148327723145485, -0.01602650247514248, 0.032622359693050385, -0.04499337822198868, -0.02573632076382637, 0.012441778555512428, -0.0244051031768322, 0.009432264603674412, 0.05565568059682846, -0.06446050107479095, 0.000356234930222854, 0.015143649652600288, -0.024093184620141983, -0.02452981285750866, -0.03813939169049263, 0.03514130786061287, 0.06149260699748993, -0.015272584743797779, 0.009745889343321323, 0.042854320257902145, -0.00920544657856226, 0.0211448073387146, -0.0024349333252757788, -0.00304048671387136, -0.023904450237751007, -0.01664852723479271, 0.07244545221328735, 0.0587209053337574, -0.040140263736248016, -0.008531689643859863, 0.05020353943109512, -0.03029726818203926, 0.027234304696321487, 0.026118600741028786, -0.015582681633532047, -0.01417719479650259, 0.0004925414104945958, 0.05789078772068024, -0.018042927607893944, -0.00197411235421896, 0.0357494056224823, -0.018066395074129105, 0.04089667275547981, -0.017261050641536713, -0.03231114521622658, 0.034693483263254166, -0.0011183104943484068, -0.003694717539474368, -0.03496042266488075, -0.00034172020968981087, 0.005425581242889166, -0.007379966322332621, -0.00577025068923831, 0.03548242151737213, 0.007715611718595028, 0.02614692971110344, -0.01274498738348484, -0.028520969673991203, 0.04661170393228531, 0.04413877800107002, -0.01025617029517889, 0.00613299710676074, 0.006632484029978514, -0.04680316522717476, 0.02887634001672268, -0.009930320084095001, -0.061772800981998444, -0.06570503115653992, 0.013648314401507378, 0.023593882098793983, 0.004661446437239647, -0.014565767720341682, -0.009774262085556984, -0.05054094269871712, -0.029520779848098755, 0.02688339352607727, 0.03633686155080795, -0.0006151571869850159, -0.028924481943249702, -0.021032653748989105, -0.0025071941781789064, -0.010036256164312363, 0.013027489185333252, 0.04718838259577751, -0.01751496084034443, 0.021753787994384766, -0.036609385162591934, -0.035492926836013794, -0.024197641760110855, -0.019489753991365433, -0.02382345125079155, 0.006352342199534178, 0.010945421643555164, 0.03370757773518562, -0.013034389354288578, -0.01289526466280222, 0.025681963190436363, -0.03570253401994705, -0.03649154677987099, -0.05242478847503662, 0.025085309520363808, -0.0020721035543829203, 0.04493559151887894, 0.008690706454217434, 0.025365501642227173, -0.0042188470251858234, -0.00861747283488512, -0.04879651218652725, -0.006002491805702448, -0.013129456900060177, -0.01458516251295805, 0.022959817200899124, -0.007035327609628439, 0.006959850899875164, 0.09764385223388672, 0.020712824538350105, -0.04288218170404434, -0.026249658316373825, 0.014566903933882713, -0.02150380052626133, 0.012215382419526577, 0.04746835306286812, 0.041482798755168915, 0.02132824808359146, 0.03250667825341225, -0.001658945926465094, 0.007447625044733286, 0.07212813943624496, -0.007971788756549358, 0.031446248292922974, 0.01995045319199562, -0.013501385226845741, -0.04735000431537628, 0.04809420928359032, 0.06076345592737198, 0.000167179896379821, 0.019010283052921295, -0.012855368666350842, 0.028326192870736122, 0.03272699937224388, -0.040038496255874634, 0.0018838710384443402, -0.020344415679574013, 0.004188438877463341, -0.048697520047426224, 0.014265602454543114, 0.00047126816934905946, -0.08063400536775589, 0.002032987307757139, 0.0026586323510855436, 0.013810939155519009, 0.010405701585114002, -0.057894784957170486, 0.02995571307837963, 0.032338839024305344, -0.045367881655693054, -0.009082334116101265, -0.012224804610013962, -0.01278416346758604, 0.007941430434584618, -0.02121364139020443, -0.007894797250628471, 0.05141199007630348, 0.0009638200281187892, 0.0024415203370153904, 0.0030766762793064117, -0.03528051823377609, -0.021892542019486427, -0.05144072696566582, 0.026449192315340042, -0.007383829914033413, 0.02456480823457241, 0.013142676092684269, 0.05828516557812691, -0.00791825633496046, -0.0032199914567172527, -0.0009043356403708458, -0.016027376055717468, -0.09945101290941238, 0.04486364498734474, 0.006396778859198093, -0.010744062252342701, 0.025573458522558212, -0.030912889167666435, 0.0482158400118351, -0.04386819526553154, 0.021079327911138535, 0.005139308515936136, 0.012847992591559887, -0.05983986705541611, 0.004911406897008419, -0.026518674567341805, -0.020458124577999115, -0.010725724510848522, 0.02983168140053749, 0.013760997913777828, 0.014824260026216507, 0.03461308777332306, 0.0038222605362534523, -0.011452310718595982, -0.03660391643643379, -0.021302243694663048, 0.014398537576198578, 0.018217885866761208, 0.03211547061800957, 0.0023367535322904587, 0.024332037195563316, -0.025391090661287308, 0.020964164286851883, 0.013189611956477165, 0.09314941614866257, 0.06389908492565155, 0.0065936739556491375, 0.007473813835531473, 0.0059977504424750805, -0.02118643932044506, -0.0020643456373363733, 0.007288724184036255, -0.0039387475699186325, 0.012690055184066296, -0.0083335405215621, 0.011551644653081894, -0.023192301392555237, -0.004911706782877445, 0.08074697852134705, 0.019639423117041588, 0.005938062909990549, -0.05720189958810806, -0.028440061956644058, -0.028284642845392227, 0.0344991497695446, 0.010661713778972626, 0.028926929458975792, -0.0007077866466715932, -0.01997629925608635, 0.06441794335842133, -0.023591110482811928, -0.008386894129216671, -0.02064395137131214, 0.04861126095056534, 0.04287448525428772, -0.013064478524029255, -0.024172618985176086, 0.0012363671557977796, 0.016239982098340988, 0.038691964000463486, 0.014734799973666668, 0.0032002131920307875, -0.0661698654294014, -0.01103953830897808, 0.02861570380628109, 0.04701226204633713, -0.002474949462339282, 0.023811059072613716, -0.03161165118217468, 0.004754526074975729, 0.0013217818923294544, -0.026750151067972183, 0.016708368435502052, -0.04812004417181015, -0.0009715651394799352, -0.0493093878030777, 0.005637031048536301, -0.0502241849899292, 0.019107602536678314, -0.015249517746269703, -0.012338186614215374, -0.016953928396105766, -0.020510133355855942, -0.03078482858836651, 0.05481013283133507, 0.010301698930561543, 0.020445680245757103, -0.05326935648918152, -0.02004736103117466, 0.025803009048104286, 0.006243559066206217, 0.01649397984147072, -0.055060382932424545, 0.03216557949781418, 0.005244150757789612, 0.017489641904830933, 0.05809501186013222, -0.023613102734088898, -0.048068076372146606, 0.01592782512307167, 0.012802163138985634, 0.005956158507615328, 0.014261668547987938, 0.002661326201632619, 0.014334888197481632, 0.01484874077141285, -0.038408584892749786, 0.021272113546729088, 0.018121449276804924, 0.025095336139202118, 0.005163873080164194, -0.07337330281734467, 0.009208062663674355, -0.0020199851132929325, -0.03013092838227749, -0.0696457102894783, -0.0019407985964789987, -0.012668154202401638, 0.0020584205631166697, 0.014560029841959476, 0.06166694313287735, -0.046485308557748795, -0.005579586606472731, 0.020673828199505806, 0.020209316164255142, 0.021074283868074417, -0.01691947877407074, -0.023236313834786415, 0.017815254628658295, 0.02851703390479088, 0.009398557245731354, 0.019105246290564537, -0.007434455677866936, 0.010835479013621807, 0.003923498094081879, -0.04636583849787712, -0.02763536013662815, -0.01756555773317814, -0.03711704537272453, 0.018842490389943123, -0.024499956518411636, 0.011714168824255466, -0.024190019816160202, 0.018899211660027504, 0.045171190053224564, -0.01522592268884182, -0.0058967117220163345, 0.014664556831121445, -0.020992416888475418, 0.04190970957279205, -0.038722265511751175, 0.028847679495811462, -0.02180447429418564, -0.036427706480026245, -0.06445172429084778, -0.03329717367887497, 0.027246279641985893, -0.04100300744175911, -0.02433427795767784, -0.06390831619501114, -0.06453680992126465, 0.003053555265069008, -0.0008794027962721884, 0.031530916690826416, 0.03639833256602287, -0.032793886959552765, -0.003871397813782096, -0.026122061535716057, 0.01065811887383461, 0.07649683952331543, 0.0029307673685252666, -0.008976073004305363, 0.051049213856458664, 0.008768384344875813, 0.004376672208309174, 0.02384987100958824, -0.0013938765041530132, -0.0051437565125525, 0.013346962630748749, -0.03220063075423241, 0.01800871267914772, 0.026105690747499466, -0.007027372717857361, 0.016230247914791107, -0.010112669318914413, 0.026280159130692482, 0.033688489347696304, -0.03801291808485985, -0.03981638327240944, -0.02785571478307247, 0.026867065578699112, -0.026598168537020683, -0.04047933593392372, -0.026523955166339874, 0.010358675383031368, 0.0676262155175209, 0.01673400215804577, 0.0018471814692020416, -0.01323317363858223, 0.06650756299495697, -0.012551854364573956, 0.0026180034037679434, 0.010986775159835815, -0.024010948836803436, 0.02509135566651821, 0.02007528953254223, 0.02727656252682209, 0.03457341715693474, 0.033884331583976746, 0.004832781385630369, 0.01556268148124218, -0.1002027690410614, -0.011801701970398426, 0.024483676999807358, -0.007152824196964502, 0.030498281121253967, 0.04598569497466087, -0.028316950425505638, 0.01615157537162304, -0.07644256949424744, -0.037884462624788284, -0.0021090873051434755, -0.024419669061899185, 0.060099780559539795, 0.012918471358716488, -0.008055951446294785, 0.05375084653496742, 0.015389056876301765, 0.012967935763299465, 0.011648319661617279, 0.014408223330974579, 0.0013714295346289873, 0.009103731252253056, -0.038168542087078094, -0.05316973850131035, 0.05041009932756424, -0.023646479472517967, 0.03303320333361626, -0.0592888779938221, -0.021868983283638954, -0.01449219323694706, 0.05904484540224075, 0.006697244476526976, -0.04752473533153534, 0.03907852619886398, -0.058037035167217255, 0.009158366359770298, 0.03022957220673561, -0.008781486190855503, 0.04563676938414574, 0.004356828518211842, 0.003625664161518216, 0.033354051411151886, 0.025235923007130623, -0.022146206349134445, -0.01675255410373211, -0.04958465322852135, 0.0009791738120839, -0.056420955806970596, 0.023014822974801064, -0.010540737770497799, -0.02319919876754284, 0.016440439969301224, -0.045944616198539734, 0.016821369528770447, -0.016598060727119446, 0.017874468117952347, 0.0029547037556767464, 0.07002763450145721, 0.014856581576168537, 0.0393294133245945, -0.020176012068986893, -0.004500596784055233, 0.14220181107521057, 0.05084942281246185, 0.06069061532616615, -0.06271950155496597, 0.007269308436661959, -0.005802573636174202, -0.01396543625742197, -0.040420230478048325, 0.008051053620874882, 0.015729226171970367, -0.021915916353464127, 0.01962210424244404, 0.028939872980117798, 0.04300231486558914, 0.0039215353317558765, 0.04730743542313576, -0.031083323061466217, -0.02333972230553627, -0.029961680993437767, 0.03589259460568428, -0.03450580686330795, -0.030357493087649345, -0.08806939423084259, 0.005170237272977829, -0.031376730650663376, -0.02397250384092331, -0.010122491046786308, -0.01606128178536892, 0.006243210285902023, -0.004119236953556538, -0.007115463726222515, 0.009498737752437592, -0.010366338305175304, -0.0306144617497921, 0.028436046093702316, -0.001609593047760427, 0.02876259945333004, 0.007054105866700411, -0.003453310579061508, 0.026146985590457916, 0.015041841194033623, -0.01696508564054966, 0.001911832601763308, 0.00232788291759789, -0.04012944549322128, -0.004685522057116032, -0.023173050954937935, 0.061820827424526215, 0.006479558069258928, -0.05141644552350044, 0.005388856399804354, 0.02255667746067047, 0.00592985562980175, -0.023179877549409866, -0.0006763969431631267, -0.03664909675717354, 0.01885194331407547, 0.009410862810909748, 0.006221376825124025, -0.031055966392159462, 0.010668634437024593, 0.00981002114713192, 0.032302435487508774, 0.022852115333080292, -0.009976224973797798, -0.006392087321728468, -0.04411701858043671, 0.027390874922275543, 0.003976736217737198, -0.002770444145426154, 0.010378014296293259, -0.016270214691758156, 0.012616054154932499, -0.06482914835214615, 0.030006667599081993, -0.01562119834125042, -0.0027181748300790787, -0.027012700214982033, -0.0018868673359975219, -0.05048110708594322, -0.02073153480887413, -0.007715724874287844, -0.021256180480122566, -0.020261885598301888, -0.02751850336790085, -0.018061768263578415, -0.005513091571629047, 0.03819746896624565, -0.005494784563779831, 0.0435294434428215, -0.023848064243793488, 0.05623111501336098, 0.007654610089957714, -0.04433155432343483, -0.032416995614767075, 0.024578412994742393, -0.025027049705386162, -0.009044994600117207, -0.009981004521250725, 0.043386053293943405, 0.008379059843719006, 0.005097583401948214, -0.015157581306993961, 0.038201235234737396, -0.03830662742257118, 0.01021935697644949, -0.011848416179418564, -0.03946981206536293, -0.011928722262382507, -0.002911193063482642, 0.0007899898919276893, 0.007951367646455765, 0.011328546330332756, -0.007920652627944946, -0.057509712874889374, 0.0037831254303455353, 0.029672442004084587, -0.02790777198970318, -0.0034017066936939955, 0.025019198656082153, 0.015260252170264721, -0.011729699559509754, -0.007213624659925699, 0.009534180164337158, -0.0077364323660731316, -0.025288168340921402, -0.008638201281428337, -0.012093900702893734, -0.005397483240813017, 0.0028231181204319, -0.005021377000957727, 0.01175218727439642, 0.02363530360162258, 0.03970807045698166, -0.026139600202441216, 0.019228611141443253, 0.004792697262018919, 0.03382868319749832, -0.0013468462275341153, -0.008729489520192146, 0.029365163296461105, -0.06243005394935608, -0.05989007279276848, 0.014080780558288097, 0.02542388066649437, 0.05683448910713196, 0.020861148834228516, 0.003381404560059309, -0.025822199881076813, 0.05702509358525276, -0.014294006861746311, -0.016406172886490822, -0.02925839275121689, 0.00615958496928215, 0.032859571278095245, -0.015185920521616936, 0.01211212296038866, -0.00924863200634718, -0.021487178280949593, 0.03747370466589928, 0.015378942713141441, -0.008165759965777397, -0.026434337720274925, 0.04199361428618431, -0.052504248917102814, 0.003722997847944498, 0.011834532953798771, -0.018328167498111725, 0.05491429567337036, 0.050483766943216324, -0.00006626586400670931, 0.0013544849352911115, -0.045834966003894806, 0.04415559023618698, -0.09020642936229706, -0.025636428967118263, 0.016144288703799248, 0.003045059973374009, 0.03791910037398338, -0.062149327248334885, 0.02185782976448536, 0.024752842262387276, -0.03395102173089981, -0.028691332787275314, 0.01621118374168873, 0.01420412678271532, -0.04418053850531578, 0.023223185911774635, -0.04190973564982414, 0.017495671287178993, 0.011320109479129314, 0.028444906696677208, 0.03091009519994259, 0.017287395894527435, -0.020344914868474007, -0.031226202845573425, -0.008780679665505886, -0.012489152140915394, 0.012059703469276428, -0.03943997621536255, 0.0423673577606678, -0.04504508897662163, -0.04001995921134949, 0.016964593902230263, 0.0032451855950057507, 0.020795263350009918, 0.03877389430999756, 0.02037329412996769, 0.0025166114792227745, 0.03277071192860603, 0.01790689490735531, 0.03630123659968376, 0.031636033207178116, -0.025211751461029053, 0.05284145101904869, 0.012437374331057072, -0.023425037041306496, 0.0024466754402965307, 0.01652730070054531, 0.012925849296152592, -0.04383821040391922, 0.014202834106981754, -0.020167754963040352, -0.012412053532898426, -0.020374720916152, 0.005370090249925852, 0.012257574126124382, -0.021579956635832787, 0.0002503746945876628, -0.03597056120634079, -0.045777034014463425, 0.04394451528787613, 0.021572699770331383, 0.005269255954772234, 0.013854358345270157, -0.030427394434809685, -0.019658701494336128, 0.0021348234731703997, -0.004738503135740757, -0.010038203559815884, -0.0012684472603723407, 0.008996622636914253, -0.0045816050842404366, -0.014874953776597977, 0.020654408261179924, -0.00009070753731066361, -0.04817751795053482, 0.0048851692117750645, -0.02179829776287079, 0.011948523111641407, 0.01048552617430687, -0.027959538623690605, 0.034787554293870926, -0.1177220493555069, 0.02871038392186165, -0.049023449420928955, -0.02786715142428875, -0.036803968250751495, -0.0127444202080369, 0.0008367837290279567, 0.01309921033680439, 0.03691984340548515, 0.026232488453388214, 0.02200167253613472, -0.018763508647680283, 0.011554064229130745, 0.056351032108068466, -0.0393364317715168, 0.031027263030409813, -0.032314516603946686, -0.004876584745943546, -0.0010861401678994298, -0.010108907707035542, -0.007785171736031771, 0.007902344688773155, 0.009307672269642353, 0.01586439460515976, -0.008030107244849205, -0.031859319657087326, -0.01255547534674406, 0.030995098873972893, 0.0012056377017870545, -0.0489078015089035, 0.035524338483810425, -0.0132255544885993, 0.004534272477030754, 0.024298086762428284, 0.005556860007345676, -0.07817340642213821, 0.017755672335624695, 0.0015617192257195711, -0.0036860923282802105, -0.026223793625831604, 0.01002474408596754, 0.0375606045126915, -0.058065637946128845, 0.0021694207098335028, 0.020525868982076645, -0.010811801068484783, -0.03731558099389076, 0.03598719462752342, 0.015655681490898132, 0.02414053864777088, -0.02141350321471691, 0.0208396315574646, -0.010497636161744595, -0.026722872629761696, 0.023493994027376175, -0.010777861811220646, 0.04066021367907524, -0.025193460285663605, -0.027737999334931374, 0.04894428700208664, -0.008329999633133411, 0.02231236733496189, 0.00597132695838809, 0.03293360397219658, -0.006477979477494955, -0.01657853089272976, 0.028461135923862457, 0.002548560267314315, 0.019901756197214127, 0.014383714646100998, -0.0011144708842039108, 0.0804767981171608, -0.055062104016542435, -0.010162735357880592, -0.020445939153432846, -0.00743592344224453, -0.04540785029530525, -0.007183379027992487, 0.01147652231156826, 0.012399550527334213, 0.02816673554480076, 0.01651671528816223, -0.03377982974052429, -0.010194215923547745, 0.053926821798086166, -0.011289192363619804, 0.018100209534168243, 0.005050909239798784, 0.021231086924672127, 0.028510628268122673, -0.02755853720009327, -0.026675796136260033, -0.01785103604197502, 0.02661844715476036, 0.006492977030575275, -0.0042729745618999004, -0.04118115454912186, -0.012666896916925907, 0.02250009961426258, 0.03724030777812004, -0.020863553509116173, -0.035743895918130875, -0.014235041104257107, 0.006831286009401083, -0.00028385932091623545, -0.030321842059493065 ]
<p>I would like to compare the data of a community of species between two years. I used to compare communities based on different levels of a factor (for example, a treatment). The case of a treatment is easy because each site has a corresponding level of the treatment. </p> <p>However, if the factor is a year, we face a paired design with each site sampled twice. In this case I cannot just assign a year to a site and, therefore, I do not know which method I should apply to analyse community differences between two years. </p>
47,551
[ -0.019300878047943115, -0.0013326057232916355, -0.025385607033967972, 0.004652229603379965, -0.005343170370906591, 0.015691552311182022, 0.006507531739771366, 0.0035636944230645895, 0.030241338536143303, -0.013174626976251602, 0.03165609389543533, 0.05486432462930679, 0.035644594579935074, 0.030476275831460953, 0.017546575516462326, 0.024576278403401375, -0.02720053680241108, 0.0018157792510464787, -0.022880755364894867, 0.011445580050349236, -0.004347067791968584, -0.022804806008934975, 0.013132358901202679, -0.0069025191478431225, -0.053018130362033844, 0.06107810512185097, 0.0067421202547848225, -0.041272588074207306, 0.008633960969746113, 0.0054017771035432816, -0.059506628662347794, -0.05428948253393173, 0.012665952555835247, 0.022056596353650093, 0.04772517830133438, -0.013083436526358128, -0.056845467537641525, -0.04185163602232933, -0.0002128085179720074, 0.046826060861349106, -0.0360557995736599, -0.03904658183455467, 0.011167879216372967, 0.005203432869166136, -0.03498809412121773, 0.014098750427365303, 0.00514915119856596, 0.00068399723386392, 0.0450722761452198, -0.026173653081059456, 0.055927637964487076, 0.017686033621430397, 0.026942944154143333, 0.04530526325106621, -0.019041597843170166, -0.0015964555786922574, 0.020164305344223976, 0.03466926887631416, 0.003362735966220498, -0.032101020216941833, -0.04930194839835167, -0.04429979249835014, 0.024461397901177406, 0.00922897644340992, -0.036963582038879395, -0.010113396681845188, 0.006244148593395948, -0.01347668468952179, 0.014041539281606674, 0.0015961123863235116, -0.025721034035086632, -0.02456536330282688, 0.050494711846113205, -0.0031082520727068186, 0.007378564216196537, -0.04805167764425278, 0.021287178620696068, 0.020760977640748024, 0.02582378126680851, 0.019246837124228477, -0.020920390263199806, 0.03656648471951485, -0.013822803273797035, -0.005371237639337778, 0.03959772363305092, -0.04908815026283264, 0.031244473531842232, -0.030115576460957527, -0.02008913829922676, 0.03693374618887901, 0.038227908313274384, 0.018294719979166985, 0.07917925715446472, -0.00855206698179245, -0.03163788840174675, 0.0050011915154755116, -0.014123291708528996, 0.012567808851599693, -0.001966878306120634, 0.020095951855182648, -0.004692623857408762, -0.06627307832241058, 0.01238641981035471, 0.004152467008680105, 0.01618615724146366, 0.015953335911035538, -0.05631932243704796, -0.013144695200026035, -0.023748889565467834, -0.008823561482131481, -0.01656907983124256, 0.02198476903140545, 0.02065885066986084, 0.012916491366922855, 0.05378712713718414, -0.02420234866440296, -0.01994067057967186, -0.010533059947192669, 0.11001627147197723, 0.02572077512741089, 0.048419732600450516, -0.022067120298743248, 0.028759175911545753, -0.02420826070010662, -0.07213806360960007, 0.002773423446342349, 0.00378991081379354, 0.01293153129518032, -0.009381469339132309, 0.051932767033576965, 0.007054075598716736, -0.005763302557170391, 0.02224620245397091, -0.034410569816827774, 0.02167605049908161, 0.04548446461558342, -0.07217223942279816, -0.06094365194439888, 0.006531009450554848, -0.009279811754822731, 0.029291320592164993, -0.04037582129240036, 0.009772606194019318, 0.0032603959552943707, 0.05065317079424858, 0.004701357334852219, 0.01284230500459671, 0.02458835020661354, 0.044241804629564285, 0.0013766116462647915, 0.03529919311404228, -0.008375647477805614, -0.025325927883386612, -0.025261152535676956, -0.0175661388784647, -0.0495048426091671, 0.04244830831885338, 0.015499747358262539, 0.024023512378335, 0.04084121808409691, 0.08846048265695572, 0.0013267394388094544, -0.03500627353787422, 0.03544445335865021, 0.03220092132687569, -0.012845894321799278, 0.051751185208559036, -0.014821559190750122, 0.013852146454155445, 0.030024772509932518, -0.017976989969611168, 0.01675925776362419, 0.005016404669731855, 0.023836839944124222, 0.03551135212182999, -0.014928493648767471, 0.011977051384747028, 0.004457684233784676, -0.01890757493674755, 0.031279999762773514, -0.036866962909698486, -0.0007718155975453556, -0.03880372270941734, -0.02310299687087536, 0.046263664960861206, 0.0473974384367466, -0.010129165835678577, 0.009577184915542603, 0.06707505136728287, -0.04054414480924606, -0.05692066252231598, -0.10133183002471924, 0.015213259495794773, 0.019732238724827766, -0.03930563107132912, 0.0071333423256874084, 0.0172906294465065, -0.007258205208927393, -0.020612699910998344, -0.01686944253742695, -0.01754295639693737, 0.016143715009093285, 0.04807848855853081, -0.03878983110189438, -0.021060355007648468, 0.0463651642203331, 0.07042580842971802, 0.005017680581659079, 0.06480732560157776, -0.03492369130253792, -0.053429316729307175, 0.015754057094454765, -0.03206678852438927, 0.026159729808568954, 0.019241012632846832, -0.025314345955848694, -0.009111789055168629, 0.007464855443686247, -0.03527890518307686, 0.05864308029413223, -0.03679230064153671, 0.04245249927043915, 0.09379953145980835, -0.02153724990785122, 0.013560325838625431, 0.0017997999675571918, 0.001568212523125112, 0.03375472500920296, -0.0336291678249836, -0.010710369795560837, -0.05261481553316116, -0.026456430554389954, 0.03624501824378967, 0.03426731005311012, -0.013719597831368446, 0.02335985377430916, 0.040407538414001465, -0.011494242586195469, -0.005302716512233019, 0.027573194354772568, 0.016642745584249496, -0.007360835559666157, 0.04806186258792877, 0.03513285145163536, 0.016854820773005486, -0.004235788714140654, 0.06138874590396881, -0.018897641450166702, 0.024686936289072037, -0.012662441469728947, 0.01715787686407566, 0.05512857809662819, -0.00703633576631546, -0.012149371206760406, -0.016150394454598427, -0.015200600028038025, 0.03405272588133812, -0.025642257183790207, 0.013103538192808628, 0.03315811976790428, 0.01122810784727335, -0.02366362325847149, 0.012829745188355446, -0.0033912162762135267, 0.015350884757936, 0.0366152822971344, -0.04782887175679207, -0.014295155182480812, 0.02862546779215336, -0.01222058292478323, 0.03420691937208176, 0.0017008573049679399, -0.06402656435966492, -0.0030506846960633993, -0.004651256836950779, 0.03894055634737015, -0.006136574316769838, 0.023964880034327507, 0.016566243022680283, 0.010369089432060719, 0.0020807799883186817, -0.02582528628408909, 0.023318717256188393, 0.005408396478742361, -0.031247638165950775, 0.004892976954579353, 0.004886188544332981, 0.012045687064528465, 0.011297098360955715, 0.016610773280262947, -0.029762135818600655, 0.035461001098155975, 0.019291676580905914, -0.026131952181458473, -0.0221874937415123, -0.01566394977271557, 0.0020027398131787777, 0.017368296161293983, -0.006411060690879822, 0.028766212984919548, 0.003104129107668996, -0.026496725156903267, -0.01957458071410656, -0.06874906271696091, 0.02325582504272461, -0.013460678048431873, -0.022997993975877762, 0.003184444969519973, -0.013460095040500164, -0.035006072372198105, 0.04516158252954483, -0.0029565191362053156, -0.01872849091887474, -0.06850925832986832, -0.08730704337358475, 0.007528495974838734, -0.008733182214200497, 0.04907016083598137, -0.011469824239611626, 0.002442693104967475, 0.08574062585830688, 0.03331935778260231, 0.0188833549618721, -0.04077647253870964, -0.01296164933592081, -0.05592873692512512, -0.018225213512778282, 0.03603063523769379, -0.008983815088868141, -0.015364198945462704, 0.018469655886292458, 0.019065283238887787, 0.0021782901603728533, 0.06611340492963791, 0.0019147630082443357, -0.012732177041471004, -0.0020447340793907642, 0.049494996666908264, -0.0026242046151310205, 0.03432231768965721, -0.008886274881660938, -0.03657499700784683, -0.019516367465257645, -0.007848498411476612, -0.020469823852181435, 0.005458533763885498, -0.04131166636943817, -0.007425579242408276, -0.04462473839521408, 0.014138179831206799, -0.010604866780340672, 0.013214876875281334, 0.040851891040802, -0.024086404591798782, 0.006166324485093355, 0.028696181252598763, 0.021784398704767227, -0.04017970710992813, -0.007510832976549864, 0.04251042380928993, 0.034986644983291626, -0.03272762522101402, -0.02293461747467518, 0.002831976395100355, -0.0018958615837618709, 0.007790815085172653, -0.028176017105579376, 0.0034656208008527756, 0.023453067988157272, -0.013770727440714836, 0.021472575142979622, 0.004509554244577885, -0.018522443249821663, -0.002570761600509286, -0.0552729070186615, 0.027358757331967354, -0.011441676877439022, 0.06878086924552917, -0.031183432787656784, -0.01124657317996025, -0.028899673372507095, -0.007426270749419928, -0.012483627535402775, -0.022578062489628792, -0.04921792820096016, -0.008317472413182259, 0.009226609952747822, 0.018001185730099678, 0.01698732003569603, -0.005469304043799639, 0.03284962475299835, -0.009148851968348026, 0.011873126961290836, -0.016799435019493103, 0.03548017516732216, -0.005176708102226257, -0.00015829339099582285, -0.04986008256673813, -0.03697879984974861, -0.013854450546205044, 0.0002951541682705283, 0.04150102660059929, -0.047589853405952454, 0.023975882679224014, 0.007762339431792498, 0.025850525125861168, 0.00945314858108759, -0.01886548288166523, 0.012320597656071186, 0.04729296267032623, 0.04033239930868149, 0.0005693304119631648, 0.06635042279958725, -0.043134842067956924, 0.012439290061593056, -0.009151991456747055, 0.03938661143183708, 0.020474236458539963, -0.006892362143844366, -0.01785987988114357, -0.03092118166387081, -0.04501976817846298, 0.01899230293929577, 0.05019724369049072, 0.00637050298973918, -0.014802570454776287, -0.009616640396416187, 0.030720338225364685, -0.0618419274687767, 0.01856086403131485, 0.04968791827559471, 0.018092062324285507, 0.0017288142116740346, -0.0003974599239882082, -0.03588413447141647, 0.026914620772004128, 0.02894512191414833, 0.032985880970954895, 0.028773587197065353, 0.006966793909668922, -0.013340740464627743, 0.05536644533276558, 0.02488962560892105, -0.03965495526790619, 0.011823579668998718, -0.0025271328631788492, 0.026488691568374634, 0.013837205246090889, -0.009821668267250061, -0.003016677452251315, 0.03867443650960922, 0.049263183027505875, 0.005057892296463251, 0.0005415678606368601, -0.08176691085100174, -0.04260532930493355, 0.04559853672981262, 0.034694138914346695, -0.04494195431470871, -0.024276822805404663, -0.036391157656908035, -0.014897709712386131, -0.0018091105157509446, -0.04153312370181084, 0.03051747754216194, -0.0023344627115875483, 0.013899460434913635, -0.02316676266491413, -0.029409557580947876, -0.047759439796209335, 0.047440242022275925, -0.00798232201486826, 0.022662177681922913, 0.03901993855834007, -0.028674911707639694, -0.017083898186683655, 0.0029942654073238373, 0.044543273746967316, 0.05751599743962288, -0.03324805200099945, 0.0011452857870608568, 0.04558800905942917, -0.007681909948587418, -0.0015107359504327178, -0.015194756910204887, 0.06115387752652168, 0.04374037683010101, -0.003677923232316971, 0.03341307491064072, -0.02692260779440403, -0.016424160450696945, -0.004467083141207695, -0.012524592690169811, -0.02712967060506344, -0.009271352551877499, 0.029976075515151024, 0.02631552889943123, 0.03276345506310463, 0.0072687421925365925, 0.11768074333667755, 0.07429558783769608, -0.020977646112442017, 0.01484180148690939, -0.060837723314762115, 0.01998113840818405, -0.02894894778728485, -0.01426512561738491, -0.03935697674751282, -0.019190572202205658, -0.03780262917280197, 0.01633390411734581, 0.0010857146698981524, 0.04802275449037552, -0.0046018073335289955, -0.012580414302647114, 0.00496996846050024, -0.0315089151263237, -0.012883182615041733, -0.0004894912126474082, 0.01657859794795513, 0.006028442177921534, -0.01855284906923771, -0.014487594366073608, 0.013071564957499504, -0.032816313207149506, -0.009735330007970333, -0.032659322023391724, -0.05520138517022133, 0.023336730897426605, -0.03962685540318489, -0.06582190841436386, -0.013031099922955036, -0.0337497740983963, 0.050502341240644455, -0.04263119027018547, 0.03358255699276924, 0.019580766558647156, -0.03943086415529251, -0.007243964355438948, 0.026037368923425674, 0.013392794877290726, -0.018671279773116112, -0.010413342155516148, 0.04075568914413452, 0.009263322688639164, -0.021002212539315224, -0.06151193380355835, -0.05267205834388733, 0.0012176980962976813, 0.020745890215039253, -0.011897671967744827, -0.027463292703032494, -0.0027189957909286022, 0.02342905104160309, 0.020508846268057823, -0.01161206141114235, 0.07935392111539841, -0.012204841710627079, -0.02670098841190338, -0.019357867538928986, 0.026633040979504585, 0.03576064854860306, -0.004574750084429979, 0.008032605983316898, 0.0026753658894449472, 0.009775610640645027, -0.010501307435333729, -0.025249751284718513, -0.023459497839212418, -0.017197588458657265, 0.0045875548385083675, -0.050342053174972534, 0.005587354302406311, 0.050872936844825745, -0.03350275009870529, -0.01765403337776661, 0.011448165401816368, -0.032966841012239456, -0.02202535979449749, -0.037006642669439316, 0.0007993351900950074, -0.022098949179053307, 0.02449660189449787, -0.07698073238134384, -0.0017305513611063361, 0.019940750673413277, -0.03545175865292549, -0.01854194514453411, 0.011301728896796703, -0.03362947702407837, 0.012274162843823433, 0.06078440696001053, -0.03840275853872299, 0.0029316050931811333, 0.03597761690616608, -0.02067279815673828, -0.007919996045529842, -0.0049693388864398, -0.019174007698893547, 0.027703724801540375, 0.012313442304730415, -0.03710570186376572, -0.02972935326397419, -0.001737835817039013, -0.018598493188619614, 0.06676097214221954, 0.010368745774030685, 0.045351240783929825, 0.11739572882652283, -0.031979408115148544, 0.03674039989709854, -0.04494423046708107, -0.013259386643767357, -0.006877959705889225, 0.009342869743704796, 0.0889451876282692, -0.03860898315906525, -0.02339961752295494, 0.06705668568611145, 0.019184034317731857, 0.019365431740880013, 0.08233155310153961, -0.007876813411712646, 0.020908452570438385, 0.047431010752916336, -0.053985096514225006, -0.0591379851102829, -0.004603952169418335, -0.05050281435251236, -0.0027869322802871466, -0.03990315645933151, -0.017421923577785492, 0.05384337529540062, 0.061143796890974045, 0.01589108258485794, -0.05771788954734802, -0.02996779792010784, -0.05687643960118294, 0.00452083395794034, 0.007002569269388914, 0.0014669534284621477, -0.0005115707754157484, 0.03966160863637924, 0.0690106451511383, -0.006874856073409319, 0.005042125936597586, 0.00848689116537571, -0.021379657089710236, -0.025285057723522186, -0.005891855340451002, -0.02065908908843994, -0.010869100689888, -0.011615312658250332, -0.031689077615737915, 0.006918089929968119, -0.012872429564595222, -0.03989027813076973, -0.018072020262479782, 0.03245965763926506, -0.004357137251645327, 0.04076532647013664, 0.02587929554283619, 0.007445143535733223, 0.00707946065813303, -0.029092276468873024, 0.13742882013320923, 0.05959535762667656, 0.03533056005835533, -0.07438574731349945, 0.0556483119726181, 0.014920162037014961, 0.014615866355597973, -0.00199340982362628, -0.02159365639090538, 0.018477005884051323, -0.006345510017126799, 0.047247227281332016, -0.005809491034597158, 0.003320276038721204, -0.029159730300307274, 0.07365572452545166, -0.021208999678492546, 0.0002518214168958366, 0.006983552593737841, -0.026811471208930016, 0.006402583792805672, 0.017422430217266083, -0.01389098446816206, 0.0026764473877847195, 0.04520439729094505, 0.0024585314095020294, -0.012837078422307968, -0.020533276721835136, -0.013662535697221756, 0.014570416882634163, -0.005713087972253561, 0.030688801780343056, 0.001254908973351121, -0.008310271427035332, -0.04667707532644272, 0.013666662387549877, -0.0018101647729054093, -0.02101878449320793, 0.00990865658968687, 0.023821232840418816, -0.004596668295562267, -0.007891125045716763, 0.03702571988105774, 0.0011910948669537902, -0.021216144785284996, -0.028248971328139305, -0.015133838169276714, 0.05673285573720932, -0.017569711431860924, -0.007434365339577198, -0.023093227297067642, -0.014542863704264164, 0.022523878142237663, -0.026287255808711052, -0.049382563680410385, 0.024874405935406685, 0.01561298593878746, -0.0032540252432227135, -0.0052505312487483025, -0.04524918645620346, -0.007111771032214165, -0.02493865229189396, 0.013543485663831234, 0.04301504045724869, -0.025395948439836502, -0.017978500574827194, -0.029936011880636215, 0.03866894543170929, 0.010138338431715965, -0.01275629922747612, 0.0008588556665927172, 0.008579354733228683, -0.020756011828780174, -0.01874670386314392, -0.0031494488939642906, 0.041090819984674454, 0.028012987226247787, -0.005703609902411699, -0.05219491571187973, -0.014352749101817608, -0.04866444692015648, 0.005894958041608334, -0.0010184833081439137, 0.004075553268194199, -0.008766548708081245, -0.0015083721373230219, 0.02380651980638504, 0.033550869673490524, -0.011749526485800743, 0.039052173495292664, -0.00074690644396469, 0.017756350338459015, 0.00956565048545599, -0.05770730972290039, -0.015431419014930725, -0.015177087858319283, -0.02927001193165779, -0.03901098296046257, -0.019666528329253197, 0.047313470393419266, 0.025042343884706497, -0.04071715846657753, 0.013626758940517902, 0.03781210258603096, -0.023927684873342514, 0.028762418776750565, 0.025782421231269836, -0.043260205537080765, 0.013924013823270798, 0.012590507045388222, 0.015498511493206024, -0.021060289815068245, -0.02469584159553051, -0.0353768914937973, -0.06489839404821396, 0.0011963618453592062, -0.014751522801816463, -0.013948403298854828, -0.029627371579408646, -0.034831106662750244, -0.00032774079591035843, -0.023845655843615532, -0.010750523768365383, -0.0667397752404213, -0.014760177582502365, -0.001310576917603612, 0.01998768001794815, -0.017907733097672462, 0.01310720294713974, -0.017759347334504128, 0.007205564994364977, 0.03160225227475166, 0.0003995703300461173, 0.0062956796027719975, 0.00731216324493289, -0.007262136321514845, 0.019906550645828247, 0.0698016881942749, -0.0063651190139353275, -0.03879225626587868, 0.0042395442724227905, -0.050211239606142044, -0.02128567546606064, 0.00018993661797139794, 0.028919512405991554, 0.04588758200407028, -0.016060730442404747, 0.018443185836076736, -0.00831273477524519, 0.02527102269232273, -0.030713384971022606, -0.027673499658703804, -0.030306987464427948, 0.01998066157102585, -0.00890912115573883, -0.01671462692320347, -0.026783619076013565, 0.0028388933278620243, -0.02874351665377617, 0.021696006879210472, 0.031632907688617706, 0.0051737516187131405, -0.02894153632223606, -0.024855297058820724, -0.032987143844366074, 0.013588792644441128, 0.0101573271676898, -0.01720459572970867, 0.037778113037347794, 0.07321285456418991, -0.02358975261449814, 0.013520615175366402, -0.014758069068193436, -0.01516297459602356, -0.05198633670806885, -0.00493670254945755, 0.022069862112402916, 0.01689213328063488, 0.03023802861571312, -0.07596533745527267, 0.04492389038205147, 0.018200332298874855, -0.016388148069381714, 0.00830182433128357, 0.018550649285316467, -0.008293156512081623, -0.046186380088329315, 0.02611314132809639, -0.03257318213582039, 0.002217243891209364, 0.020946340635418892, 0.04224332422018051, 0.0046691917814314365, 0.02671300619840622, 0.03829294815659523, -0.052831705659627914, -0.00789548084139824, -0.028269492089748383, 0.031730543822050095, -0.056942347437143326, 0.03350882604718208, -0.036889541894197464, -0.00570570956915617, 0.03155592083930969, -0.05156371742486954, 0.022192778065800667, 0.046189047396183014, 0.021490901708602905, -0.021854138001799583, 0.046412304043769836, 0.034613143652677536, -0.030765729025006294, -0.02092665061354637, -0.03733308985829353, -0.013692871667444706, 0.035969559103250504, 0.006259258836507797, 0.03541909530758858, 0.010488079860806465, -0.01264904160052538, 0.016164252534508705, 0.019278163090348244, 0.0005737156025134027, -0.026685260236263275, 0.008755093440413475, -0.011837601661682129, 0.02500919997692108, 0.03325049951672554, -0.03370135650038719, -0.044733237475156784, 0.007800318766385317, 0.061121825128793716, -0.05245690420269966, -0.02599850855767727, 0.048508260399103165, -0.03739207610487938, -0.025094419717788696, 0.01726033352315426, 0.007059362716972828, -0.0030168360099196434, -0.07015965133905411, -0.02389426715672016, -0.00732438825070858, -0.028665658086538315, -0.035935331135988235, 0.0018952530808746815, -0.06630752235651016, 0.05108511075377464, -0.027008958160877228, -0.02265048213303089, 0.010033993981778622, 0.013210631906986237, 0.03573319688439369, -0.052817054092884064, 0.07179409265518188, 0.027671337127685547, -0.0314696840941906, -0.018368445336818695, -0.0182632002979517, -0.02161761187016964, 0.015869082883000374, 0.03386814519762993, 0.025199469178915024, -0.007976287975907326, -0.02028781920671463, 0.03389428183436394, 0.017259538173675537, -0.03831448405981064, 0.08455196022987366, -0.020287441089749336, -0.040961287915706635, 0.023393964394927025, -0.01150825060904026, -0.01867421343922615, -0.0017103513237088919, 0.01753150299191475, -0.025784626603126526, 0.03286319226026535, 0.0003660502261482179, -0.0011481893016025424, 0.034225668758153915, -0.021128587424755096, -0.00005856103598489426, 0.014811379835009575, 0.02305505983531475, 0.049989428371191025, 0.012782417237758636, -0.007752768695354462, -0.037562206387519836, -0.0020801438950002193, -0.0733901858329773, -0.0017339615151286125, 0.012739252299070358, 0.00923245120793581, -0.0131307914853096, -0.05844759941101074, 0.015750151127576828, 0.027543319389224052, -0.017547588795423508, -0.0010957906488329172, 0.018052928149700165, 0.022807365283370018, 0.024347718805074692, -0.02886311709880829, 0.03007112443447113, -0.012061040848493576, 0.007276917342096567, 0.005735157057642937, -0.0018517142161726952, -0.010760176926851273, -0.0006025742623023689, 0.0001772749819792807, 0.010014071129262447, 0.01412091962993145, 0.00891596544533968, 0.007435543462634087, 0.024889202788472176, 0.0013811734970659018, 0.023673955351114273, 0.0294613316655159, 0.024131057783961296, 0.025703471153974533, 0.008338768035173416, 0.012390917167067528, 0.027662605047225952, -0.031424809247255325, -0.019220510497689247, -0.03687122091650963, 0.0037449817173182964, -0.04165692254900932, 0.03150453045964241, 0.027743114158511162, 0.027795899659395218, -0.0011241012252867222, -0.0012764058774337173, -0.013430091552436352, -0.013836666010320187, 0.009463867172598839, -0.009926551952958107, 0.051725950092077255, 0.018408074975013733, 0.008539524860680103, -0.00799692515283823, 0.014204955659806728, -0.01811095140874386, -0.04750765487551689, 0.052354734390974045, 0.026309499517083168, 0.0183272622525692, -0.014385197311639786, -0.009226957336068153, 0.0023688743822276592, 0.013362444005906582, -0.05429941043257713, -0.043702125549316406, -0.05214075371623039, -0.00808112882077694, 0.02629794552922249, -0.004503894131630659 ]
<p>I have a time series dataset that reports the hourly page views and social media shares of online news stories. What I hope to obtain is the relationship between the two variables. I would imagine that the more shares a story gets, the more page views it will attract, and vice versa. That means the two variables would demonstrate a similar fast/slow growth curve. </p> <p>In terms of a single story, I can use VAR (vector autoregressive) model to estimate the coefficients. However, how could I make use of hundreds of stories to build a more generalized model? What I've thought of so far is to fit each story with the same model and then observe the distribution of the coefficients. Would it be an appropriate method? </p> <p>That would be great if you could kindly cite some papers and/or R packages that would inspire potential solutions. Thank you!</p>
73,638
[ -0.037640281021595, -0.011941809207201004, 0.009635061025619507, 0.011699198745191097, 0.03893716633319855, 0.019958453252911568, 0.004149890970438719, -0.004085528198629618, 0.021056367084383965, -0.04703294113278389, 0.004075549077242613, 0.047917842864990234, 0.03326885774731636, 0.019180523231625557, 0.03041975200176239, -0.00046729479799978435, -0.009809152223169804, 0.02035408467054367, 0.0005443917470984161, -0.01833157055079937, -0.0434146374464035, 0.014190326444804668, 0.02922455593943596, 0.01115526631474495, -0.02842717617750168, 0.04050225391983986, 0.022454263642430305, -0.013918635435402393, -0.023662107065320015, 0.027499381452798843, 0.014756674878299236, -0.022086109966039658, 0.0018421598942950368, 0.0524965263903141, 0.018970899283885956, -0.00786014273762703, -0.020796913653612137, -0.03682108595967293, 0.003127087140455842, 0.010758485645055771, -0.04495230317115784, -0.0013488426338881254, -0.021454310044646263, 0.023282170295715332, -0.0380098931491375, -0.020246608182787895, -0.006025693379342556, -0.0291300006210804, 0.033484265208244324, -0.05010000616312027, 0.08880235999822617, 0.02974657528102398, 0.030434640124440193, 0.05016005039215088, -0.01795031875371933, -0.0014219041913747787, 0.02747347578406334, 0.04460790753364563, 0.0056190635077655315, -0.0225216094404459, -0.02522074244916439, 0.0037911476101726294, -0.041466545313596725, -0.041748274117708206, -0.039784956723451614, 0.041028380393981934, -0.013140518218278885, -0.002836585510522127, 0.01908150687813759, -0.029024161398410797, 0.02446998842060566, 0.042772140353918076, 0.08114100247621536, 0.03393632546067238, -0.020724793896079063, -0.014545910991728306, -0.014395243488252163, 0.019990423694252968, 0.04151670262217522, 0.017492646351456642, 0.0040489486418664455, 0.03471909463405609, -0.0006220666691660881, 0.02428281679749489, 0.03374333679676056, -0.006926071830093861, 0.0908743366599083, -0.02700524404644966, 0.002525456715375185, 0.03699710592627525, -0.04746890813112259, -0.015666751191020012, 0.0440826490521431, 0.0049355956725776196, -0.05558484047651291, 0.023208027705550194, -0.025329263880848885, 0.01752343401312828, 0.06386648863554001, 0.01500723510980606, -0.044334106147289276, -0.050953458994627, -0.009002428501844406, 0.04549340158700943, -0.0224533099681139, -0.024166952818632126, -0.019509144127368927, -0.030818704515695572, -0.034058332443237305, -0.004810614511370659, -0.03372131288051605, -0.00470763212069869, 0.03296694532036781, 0.0020810989663004875, 0.011909953318536282, 0.004636154510080814, 0.005488597322255373, -0.044946420937776566, 0.08806100487709045, 0.08565053343772888, 0.019576115533709526, -0.020538289099931717, 0.02231135033071041, -0.014311118982732296, 0.00048688938841223717, 0.006695012096315622, 0.006203766446560621, -0.036003559827804565, -0.03270450606942177, 0.06555629521608353, -0.014666903764009476, -0.0022429367527365685, -0.009818102233111858, -0.05496903508901596, 0.02336229756474495, 0.044530726969242096, -0.08992288261651993, -0.03694895654916763, 0.02901790849864483, -0.025603629648685455, 0.013005886226892471, -0.05099370330572128, -0.008235925808548927, 0.008638741448521614, 0.07364069670438766, 0.014569367282092571, 0.05893047899007797, 0.019969787448644638, 0.04193694517016411, -0.004112639930099249, -0.025606734678149223, -0.009437988512217999, 0.011541971005499363, 0.011674884706735611, -0.02343066781759262, -0.07063911855220795, 0.005127616226673126, 0.005590932443737984, -0.006054822821170092, 0.016177695244550705, 0.014521468430757523, 0.029437802731990814, -0.02803397923707962, -0.02212531864643097, 0.045532673597335815, -0.03911299630999565, 0.01811172626912594, -0.022173147648572922, 0.014761797152459621, 0.021666228771209717, -0.014660422690212727, 0.010588295757770538, 0.04230694845318794, 0.03864765167236328, 0.026122132316231728, 0.025738153606653214, 0.032546788454055786, 0.005267355125397444, 0.011694728396832943, 0.04734054207801819, -0.01993044838309288, -0.04537403583526611, -0.028455276042222977, 0.004237161483615637, 0.034400299191474915, 0.0459354966878891, 0.0073454114608466625, 0.017572414129972458, 0.00826240610331297, -0.03978839889168739, -0.03729681670665741, -0.05452825874090195, -0.013654653914272785, -0.03284936025738716, -0.011816728860139847, 0.039913713932037354, -0.003868429223075509, 0.008493916131556034, -0.034839462488889694, -0.0033417153172194958, -0.011928592808544636, -0.0068719652481377125, 0.04148237034678459, -0.0266121719032526, 0.00015320643433369696, 0.021309062838554382, 0.019957832992076874, -0.01157841831445694, 0.03395141661167145, -0.052489787340164185, -0.06727363914251328, 0.009049364365637302, -0.028145423159003258, 0.037128254771232605, -0.01446018647402525, 0.0045408145524561405, 0.029427139088511467, 0.02093229442834854, -0.01820434257388115, 0.01770639978349209, -0.053863849490880966, 0.03405515104532242, 0.059294622391462326, 0.01791825331747532, -0.031641311943531036, 0.024163788184523582, 0.04421446472406387, -0.003821137361228466, -0.047571390867233276, -0.015588129870593548, -0.07931480556726456, 0.015053643845021725, 0.04000741243362427, 0.030995287001132965, -0.041997987776994705, -0.020014451816678047, 0.03895401209592819, 0.0473521389067173, -0.013520357199013233, 0.010549327358603477, -0.03380904719233513, -0.01249959971755743, 0.02366746962070465, -0.006552786100655794, 0.01564284972846508, -0.0009176222956739366, 0.013547079637646675, -0.007596408482640982, 0.030539464205503464, 0.004312473349273205, 0.0018139333697035909, 0.01620633155107498, 0.017956426367163658, 0.016841698437929153, -0.029205288738012314, 0.010108903050422668, 0.05344998463988304, -0.007811902090907097, -0.033148687332868576, 0.004391734953969717, 0.0006850124918855727, 0.007618470583111048, 0.019026972353458405, -0.02916858159005642, 0.02605353854596615, 0.0030713893938809633, -0.02110767550766468, -0.030396966263651848, 0.014932975172996521, -0.02448645792901516, 0.016380401328206062, 0.008230991661548615, -0.049738671630620956, -0.0216346625238657, 0.007263358682394028, 0.018411526456475258, -0.006152248941361904, 0.007662913762032986, -0.01768670231103897, -0.047930311411619186, 0.06342942267656326, 0.011999783106148243, -0.01066894643008709, -0.00888162199407816, -0.05526955798268318, 0.027526943013072014, -0.0019955800380557775, -0.007970137521624565, 0.013678330928087234, 0.0011167500633746386, 0.016944315284490585, 0.011948908679187298, -0.0032099292147904634, -0.06275448948144913, 0.006715133786201477, -0.019926035776734352, 0.02893429435789585, -0.038887232542037964, -0.02526257187128067, 0.022662542760372162, -0.015603011474013329, -0.0533485934138298, 0.013484853319823742, -0.03180595114827156, -0.015407975763082504, -0.03203699737787247, 0.011009731329977512, 0.0029063124675303698, -0.02688000723719597, 0.0400521419942379, 0.024259109050035477, -0.006023000925779343, -0.02660706453025341, -0.08498784899711609, -0.05592853203415871, 0.03284670412540436, -0.011155991815030575, 0.04706878587603569, 0.027911407873034477, -0.025439029559493065, 0.06257154047489166, 0.03971458971500397, -0.0036586786154657602, -0.019178340211510658, 0.0034736497327685356, -0.04465603083372116, -0.035656511783599854, 0.050477173179388046, 0.040548887103796005, 0.009659766219556332, 0.016707587987184525, 0.03051804192364216, 0.0284417737275362, 0.0486135259270668, 0.019792666658759117, 0.00694305170327425, -0.007066119462251663, 0.014423486776649952, 0.03726809844374657, 0.019191350787878036, 0.03889162838459015, -0.051687825471162796, 0.02719775401055813, 0.03217991068959236, 0.02554776892066002, 0.004003068897873163, -0.03068106807768345, -0.006654607597738504, -0.006376722361892462, -0.023879991844296455, -0.04661205783486366, 0.01998205855488777, -0.015257167629897594, -0.020535971969366074, -0.005031133536249399, 0.010230512358248234, 0.03169456869363785, -0.0029597666580229998, 0.002765306271612644, 0.04118214547634125, 0.03173542395234108, -0.030569085851311684, -0.029631759971380234, -0.08406352996826172, -0.006722842808812857, -0.004964881110936403, -0.0358414389193058, 0.027473976835608482, 0.021378468722105026, 0.014134778641164303, 0.004924379289150238, -0.0030462918803095818, -0.03491292893886566, 0.014918961562216282, -0.05368055775761604, 0.008430372923612595, -0.04233531281352043, 0.03406578302383423, -0.001704648369923234, 0.07040898501873016, 0.020940395072102547, 0.044786546379327774, 0.05440240725874901, -0.012784218415617943, -0.048950158059597015, 0.02678222954273224, -0.05373453348875046, 0.009819820523262024, -0.013505497016012669, -0.008420993573963642, 0.05188773199915886, -0.0011587482877075672, -0.014537504874169827, -0.01390367653220892, 0.014674652367830276, -0.0008411069866269827, 0.01726912148296833, -0.033225029706954956, -0.049786534160375595, 0.0003164523805025965, -0.01813475973904133, 0.016974659636616707, -0.01747075654566288, 0.039826650172472, 0.05500638484954834, 0.008852732367813587, -0.013028426095843315, -0.027449054643511772, 0.022173525765538216, 0.023307716473937035, 0.018608804792165756, 0.038200199604034424, 0.01658976823091507, -0.05970112234354019, 0.04922574386000633, -0.027074644342064857, 0.018283715471625328, 0.04811945557594299, 0.002261585323140025, -0.0300825834274292, -0.06155601143836975, -0.01818222738802433, -0.0004750917141791433, 0.004130654036998749, -0.0012000927235931158, -0.013633212074637413, 0.04606669768691063, 0.004762181546539068, -0.04793180152773857, 0.0011895342031493783, 0.06353174895048141, 0.021970273926854134, -0.008928018622100353, 0.00629230123013258, 0.01463274285197258, 0.019308777526021004, 0.008308970369398594, 0.010195464827120304, -0.009075410664081573, -0.009179515764117241, -0.020595014095306396, 0.040154628455638885, -0.032215435057878494, -0.046557582914829254, 0.028760671615600586, 0.010570866987109184, 0.04738587141036987, 0.009050083346664906, -0.08108225464820862, -0.007886151783168316, 0.0673639103770256, 0.05607205629348755, 0.02669477090239525, -0.006562558002769947, -0.09282767027616501, 0.025226393714547157, 0.04502463713288307, 0.0070402733981609344, -0.03781060129404068, -0.014531749300658703, -0.04241757094860077, -0.009028177708387375, 0.02434024214744568, -0.024724606424570084, 0.018295198678970337, 0.023790638893842697, -0.0017943301936611533, -0.016991473734378815, -0.0135364830493927, -0.040824439376592636, 0.029215285554528236, -0.07597251981496811, 0.037080101668834686, -0.04878026247024536, -0.046854134649038315, -0.08003269135951996, 0.047935932874679565, 0.030941663309931755, 0.03950690105557442, 0.0020538729149848223, -0.008386985398828983, -0.016417179256677628, 0.017035936936736107, -0.025801442563533783, -0.06455706059932709, 0.031380586326122284, -0.006610237993299961, -0.0321052223443985, 0.03986837714910507, 0.0007714118692092597, -0.019955428317189217, 0.012822220101952553, -0.004735539201647043, -0.023606838658452034, 0.014089212752878666, -0.03820342943072319, 0.035337843000888824, 0.02415897324681282, 0.01244012638926506, 0.05166976526379585, 0.05989306792616844, 0.022132035344839096, 0.010846485383808613, 0.011295209638774395, 0.027048252522945404, -0.036402203142642975, -0.008932504802942276, 0.00673050619661808, 0.012194328010082245, -0.014759567566215992, 0.008589494973421097, -0.009858794510364532, 0.017694642767310143, -0.06687983870506287, -0.024139320477843285, -0.0035430514253675938, 0.019581517204642296, -0.004540041089057922, -0.039367832243442535, 0.033738017082214355, 0.029265645891427994, 0.02384628728032112, -0.005271079484373331, 0.007297635078430176, -0.027588263154029846, -0.030083876103162766, -0.007335585542023182, -0.018670229241251945, 0.006641417276114225, -0.026396598666906357, -0.002039343351498246, 0.0024371296167373657, -0.012510462664067745, 0.05817760154604912, -0.0057960632257163525, 0.021148180589079857, 0.0024658890906721354, -0.039066385477781296, 0.009725244715809822, 0.011722009629011154, 0.020534150302410126, 0.05638965219259262, -0.0296272411942482, 0.018674908205866814, -0.04198853299021721, -0.04075416177511215, -0.07572485506534576, -0.05117451772093773, 0.03828561678528786, -0.010514798574149609, -0.014204475097358227, -0.05443408340215683, 0.017889801412820816, -0.02773188427090645, -0.009416305460035801, -0.021606069058179855, 0.03966080769896507, -0.030119821429252625, -0.023156363517045975, -0.008946758694946766, 0.03224431723356247, 0.06805238872766495, -0.006849702913314104, 0.004205700941383839, 0.029739361256361008, -0.003367009339854121, -0.004108414985239506, -0.0373530276119709, 0.04066791385412216, -0.040351759642362595, -0.008959700353443623, -0.04297777637839317, -0.014743979088962078, 0.05663390830159187, -0.038759175688028336, 0.022252822294831276, 0.012429988011717796, 0.015401449054479599, 0.036338984966278076, -0.030052606016397476, 0.017994582653045654, 0.009716005995869637, -0.020050732418894768, -0.021981380879878998, 0.00012366054579615593, -0.027631675824522972, 0.005214361939579248, 0.02579505182802677, 0.0163198821246624, -0.0217323936522007, 0.024510685354471207, 0.07986854761838913, -0.002465803176164627, -0.024399761110544205, 0.024740055203437805, -0.002432853914797306, 0.047200608998537064, -0.03538152575492859, 0.013462440110743046, -0.007838664576411247, 0.01589077338576317, -0.02887587621808052, -0.029376346617937088, -0.016009248793125153, -0.04527031257748604, 0.07355251908302307, -0.02326064556837082, 0.07913932204246521, 0.06218407303094864, -0.0012200141791254282, 0.0009654069435782731, -0.028652021661400795, -0.02706040069460869, -0.019627060741186142, 0.018424486741423607, 0.018523123115301132, -0.04766835272312164, -0.010893884114921093, 0.020772786810994148, 0.001941318972967565, 0.028742533177137375, 0.0632765144109726, 0.013130782172083855, 0.014303998090326786, 0.034785035997629166, -0.029373617842793465, -0.027025602757930756, 0.030604878440499306, -0.04515843465924263, 0.022051379084587097, -0.07215773314237595, -0.007063774392008781, 0.044184643775224686, 0.045215677469968796, -0.002958707744255662, -0.033145733177661896, -0.07793571799993515, -0.03583824634552002, -0.015915924683213234, 0.05756283923983574, -0.008752427063882351, 0.013290893286466599, 0.03489088639616966, 0.02777097560465336, 0.016520315781235695, 0.05459241941571236, -0.03899124637246132, -0.07612844556570053, -0.008552697487175465, -0.008991911076009274, -0.049238014966249466, 0.04706493020057678, 0.008258992806077003, -0.019738437607884407, 0.03372599929571152, -0.03505701199173927, -0.03026297688484192, 0.0056409998796880245, 0.023071492090821266, -0.018389394506812096, 0.06089472398161888, -0.02067440003156662, 0.015725377947092056, 0.012713064439594746, -0.015874452888965607, 0.10490482300519943, 0.10319432616233826, 0.03405768796801567, -0.05587124079465866, 0.023635711520910263, 0.016409169882535934, 0.0038282128516584635, -0.05460764467716217, 0.001566000166349113, 0.0008794920868240297, 0.010525144636631012, 0.05670086666941643, 0.04691498726606369, 0.007260091137140989, -0.0031672674231231213, 0.062172677367925644, -0.03942897915840149, -0.0016994167817756534, -0.006515784189105034, -0.010825217701494694, -0.002006679540500045, 0.0016197036020457745, -0.043080031871795654, 0.013399722054600716, 0.0019748464692384005, -0.019192516803741455, -0.01139325462281704, -0.016762955114245415, -0.00828724168241024, -0.009759129025042057, -0.02784181758761406, 0.015034271404147148, 0.028400855138897896, 0.010308029130101204, 0.02739807963371277, -0.017220675945281982, 0.02501755952835083, -0.010533995926380157, 0.010516298934817314, 0.04230660945177078, 0.003645157441496849, -0.010959820821881294, 0.0012666078982874751, 0.016992121934890747, -0.04069899022579193, -0.050315167754888535, -0.04020904377102852, 0.013760706409811974, -0.003553746733814478, 0.026363441720604897, -0.016199685633182526, 0.00899691041558981, -0.0007382610347121954, 0.0046039242297410965, -0.03657812252640724, 0.03644087165594101, 0.02543872594833374, -0.04077373817563057, 0.008521493524312973, -0.02670804038643837, 0.011289998888969421, 0.013141385279595852, 0.03602440282702446, 0.06461243331432343, -0.017012856900691986, 0.004533466417342424, -0.03184004873037338, 0.05745513364672661, -0.03218141198158264, -0.011949037201702595, 0.004564027301967144, -0.032670386135578156, -0.0236873310059309, 0.0011269300011917949, 0.025766432285308838, -0.004325447604060173, -0.030961528420448303, -0.00022452855773735791, 0.0005546166212297976, -0.03908773511648178, 0.02165899984538555, 0.016356002539396286, 0.011029909364879131, -0.013404288329184055, -0.048803940415382385, -0.005020692013204098, 0.05748148262500763, 0.03894113376736641, -0.001737174461595714, 0.008138169534504414, -0.0164813119918108, 0.039714038372039795, 0.01593749411404133, -0.057447899132966995, -0.007362727541476488, -0.01345507986843586, -0.0418727807700634, -0.029869573190808296, -0.0013147684512659907, 0.04325844347476959, 0.021466808393597603, -0.01750444807112217, 0.015256175771355629, 0.013718491420149803, -0.0397198460996151, 0.032831888645887375, 0.026874257251620293, -0.05737234652042389, 0.0032498082146048546, 0.0003239444922655821, -0.021438991650938988, -0.001553764333948493, -0.015481076203286648, -0.008164557628333569, -0.004075424745678902, 0.02742411009967327, -0.010603111237287521, -0.020440729334950447, 0.01862308941781521, -0.02847580797970295, 0.08510125428438187, -0.012030800804495811, -0.009008064866065979, -0.05451714247465134, -0.006303443107753992, -0.019984591752290726, -0.011391201056540012, 0.012433321215212345, 0.04413057118654251, -0.016348619014024734, -0.0027710418216884136, -0.009574462659657001, -0.0026928060688078403, -0.01455279253423214, -0.030073771253228188, 0.023391926661133766, -0.04889095574617386, 0.025605039671063423, -0.02332889474928379, -0.08980747312307358, 0.04064520075917244, -0.021536583080887794, -0.004049036186188459, 0.021684084087610245, -0.008558820001780987, 0.04746559262275696, -0.016201144084334373, -0.020043617114424706, 0.016271742060780525, 0.026303766295313835, 0.0027844193391501904, 0.006491374224424362, -0.002987752202898264, 0.011828849092125893, 0.029292555525898933, 0.014067595824599266, 0.016673674806952477, 0.02572689950466156, -0.011047071777284145, -0.004749296698719263, 0.041519712656736374, -0.032415952533483505, 0.013265312649309635, 0.010334725491702557, -0.022989027202129364, 0.012754684314131737, 0.020705631002783775, -0.0028493045829236507, 0.06372570246458054, 0.04310828447341919, -0.05611933395266533, 0.00013383048644755036, -0.014004822820425034, -0.0009824769804254174, -0.06835366040468216, -0.003831683425232768, 0.012542272917926311, -0.0359388031065464, 0.027441395446658134, -0.03586868196725845, -0.04171402007341385, 0.006305486895143986, -0.05012296140193939, 0.018733855336904526, 0.020660731941461563, 0.016587242484092712, -0.04561283439397812, -0.017553599551320076, -0.005048215854912996, 0.05172312632203102, 0.05959140509366989, 0.0623888336122036, 0.023670531809329987, 0.039858777076005936, 0.001519284094683826, -0.0268329456448555, -0.03624359518289566, 0.00297555117867887, 0.03264330327510834, -0.027342472225427628, 0.04952321574091911, -0.06571762263774872, -0.029026975855231285, 0.026607580482959747, -0.03194405883550644, 0.026349971070885658, 0.0411849208176136, 0.000027216980015509762, 0.0031120898202061653, 0.03380816429853439, -0.003702128306031227, 0.005932422820478678, 0.004848036449402571, 0.006421939469873905, -0.0015807313611730933, 0.046964146196842194, -0.0218867938965559, 0.009893209673464298, 0.012809429317712784, -0.005223222076892853, 0.006272036116570234, 0.007112884894013405, -0.01387306023389101, -0.03229953721165657, -0.00801688339561224, -0.02611669711768627, 0.04052020236849785, -0.017056560143828392, 0.050109922885894775, -0.05697791278362274, -0.0097555723041296, 0.0014126284513622522, 0.017439264804124832, -0.016448646783828735, 0.03584799915552139, -0.02140437811613083, -0.012567107565701008, 0.028687817975878716, 0.010439182631671429, 0.010965768247842789, -0.04252315312623978, -0.01729774661362171, 0.02057492360472679, 0.009762500412762165, -0.03247170150279999, -0.007651259656995535, -0.01816498301923275, 0.018538959324359894, -0.007335775997489691, 0.015852807089686394, 0.025546863675117493, -0.023507660254836082, 0.008363553322851658, -0.08280223608016968, 0.05486278980970383, 0.021470801904797554, 0.015078848227858543, -0.031527139246463776, -0.039746690541505814, -0.011959129944443703, 0.01142735593020916, 0.0557359978556633, -0.03663413226604462, 0.0174404364079237, 0.0021239365451037884, 0.027429018169641495, -0.0018450206844136119, -0.05478077009320259, 0.029863566160202026, -0.013930698856711388, -0.027422137558460236, -0.0007638094830326736, 0.01734386943280697, 0.010624345391988754, -0.027665531262755394, -0.007037056609988213, -0.017279203981161118, -0.025000372901558876, 0.008867945522069931, -0.023972103372216225, 0.018695488572120667, 0.04055459052324295, 0.006896607112139463, 0.03781824931502342, 0.01429785043001175, 0.007215236313641071, 0.013933920301496983, 0.0006313087651506066, -0.04602489620447159, 0.049092840403318405, -0.043328821659088135, -0.012194477021694183, -0.003912493586540222, -0.01439851988106966, -0.019143549725413322, -0.05502966046333313, -0.017189491540193558, -0.004487745929509401, -0.017097024247050285, 0.04079275205731392, 0.003354596206918359, 0.014795415103435516, 0.02832059934735298, -0.017273984849452972, -0.008709368295967579, -0.0018815866205841303, 0.007022663950920105, -0.008453717455267906, 0.006470276974141598, 0.03674570098519325, 0.016245029866695404, 0.018036875873804092, 0.026562288403511047, 0.006729335058480501, 0.05693628638982773, -0.03698211908340454, -0.019780848175287247, -0.026560841128230095, -0.02869192324578762, 0.022997664287686348, 0.01262273732572794, -0.00045850322931073606, 0.05164838954806328, -0.015150724910199642, 0.07079533487558365, -0.03814610466361046, 0.011142861098051071, -0.019032003358006477, 0.006710559595376253, -0.013276549056172371, 0.020743900910019875, -0.006537316367030144, 0.007311214692890644, 0.014020693488419056, -0.02698671631515026, 0.018907330930233, -0.022590629756450653, -0.024347474798560143, -0.004887223243713379, 0.019257891923189163, -0.015167348086833954, -0.0005281999474391341, -0.02102300338447094, -0.047169603407382965, -0.013533366844058037, -0.016541961580514908, 0.0649624690413475, 0.025495395064353943, -0.021096719428896904, -0.01845587231218815, -0.015675930306315422, -0.01952863484621048, 0.039605896919965744, -0.08370496332645416, -0.018993878737092018, -0.037307556718587875, 0.03938736394047737, 0.003862619400024414, -0.004000108223408461 ]
<p>I am trying to build sparse coefficient time series models but couldn't find a good resource/book to learn from. Can anyone share with me a good resource/book? It will be great if it comes with R codes.Can anyone use this kind model? Thanks.</p>
36,048
[ -0.0009161197813227773, -0.02917470410466194, 0.009694818407297134, -0.004826088435947895, 0.03459242358803749, -0.004419765435159206, -0.01380444597452879, -0.018065905198454857, 0.055866941809654236, -0.04504195973277092, 0.018194742500782013, 0.01815042272210121, 0.043339911848306656, -0.007498061750084162, 0.029540864750742912, -0.03646674007177353, -0.022459357976913452, 0.005141997244209051, -0.013401727192103863, -0.0012293285690248013, -0.006828762590885162, -0.009453765116631985, 0.0005239403690211475, 0.008145416155457497, -0.0038609665352851152, 0.0422138050198555, 0.002586201997473836, 0.015069616958498955, -0.04726344347000122, 0.05035238713026047, -0.04935380443930626, -0.0017042473191395402, -0.052767444401979446, 0.03983451426029205, 0.011572932824492455, -0.016876747831702232, -0.022886352613568306, -0.04706064984202385, -0.012895170599222183, 0.039507098495960236, -0.014119583182036877, -0.03776510804891586, 0.010043126530945301, 0.016308024525642395, -0.01174688246101141, 0.006547537166625261, 0.021500838920474052, -0.03097357600927353, 0.02526620775461197, -0.059108950197696686, 0.056586362421512604, 0.0034600484650582075, 0.06903408467769623, 0.03559763357043266, 0.013979578390717506, 0.040854811668395996, 0.044539663940668106, 0.06978924572467804, -0.019711492583155632, -0.03957141935825348, -0.022758862003684044, -0.022500667721033096, 0.0172582920640707, -0.05835176631808281, -0.07706843316555023, 0.03592534363269806, -0.0010593101615086198, -0.017463648691773415, 0.038331903517246246, -0.020888475701212883, 0.011687477119266987, 0.005168958101421595, 0.03434349223971367, -0.0026229042559862137, -0.01831696182489395, -0.02223169431090355, 0.007145005743950605, 0.011022851802408695, 0.04138294234871864, 0.03413856774568558, -0.011173776350915432, 0.02581305429339409, 0.006468680687248707, 0.002729661064222455, 0.0045027704909443855, 0.015581965446472168, 0.06368371844291687, -0.02417558804154396, 0.002933208364993334, -0.004986216314136982, -0.04145288094878197, 0.016576126217842102, 0.02073686011135578, 0.009662497788667679, -0.03541403263807297, 0.029385287314653397, 0.02363528124988079, 0.03069997765123844, 0.02725684456527233, -0.02208833396434784, -0.01367333997040987, -0.0170671995729208, -0.027089370414614677, 0.05696010962128639, -0.04167911037802696, -0.009098662063479424, -0.022784879431128502, -0.00004136582720093429, -0.02567380666732788, -0.035059791058301926, -0.04548104107379913, 0.0028067503590136766, -0.0011234635021537542, -0.017212696373462677, 0.03803431987762451, -0.008288722485303879, 0.0033802110701799393, -0.006379534024745226, 0.06047838181257248, 0.10560864210128784, 0.03532367944717407, -0.037031084299087524, 0.04845812916755676, -0.038879815489053726, -0.039065588265657425, -0.012592119164764881, 0.0064135463908314705, -0.024825304746627808, -0.03186130151152611, 0.08221463114023209, -0.011794032528996468, -0.04986761882901192, 0.06088532134890556, -0.009260030463337898, 0.02044535055756569, -0.024471940472722054, -0.04103102162480354, -0.01637425646185875, 0.03315967693924904, -0.05163059011101723, 0.026626087725162506, -0.03248263895511627, -0.0017193901585415006, -0.009386423975229263, 0.049765635281801224, 0.03262404724955559, 0.040551766753196716, 0.024426711723208427, 0.02524385042488575, 0.008785243146121502, -0.03273659944534302, -0.024351544678211212, 0.005032922141253948, 0.009917539544403553, 0.00022469159739557654, -0.06641121208667755, -0.006556013133376837, 0.04788524657487869, -0.016724707558751106, 0.006341618951410055, 0.045654069632291794, 0.03477473929524422, -0.036445990204811096, 0.027727017179131508, 0.009184779599308968, -0.02863004244863987, 0.05709891766309738, -0.004825877491384745, 0.01599988341331482, 0.014662920497357845, 0.020426196977496147, -0.02569793350994587, 0.04340934753417969, 0.057349178940057755, 0.0393107607960701, -0.0009451626101508737, -0.0077911303378641605, 0.018873505294322968, 0.0057581569999456406, 0.018012240529060364, -0.03553226217627525, -0.036239273846149445, -0.03189851716160774, -0.02553713694214821, 0.011817472986876965, 0.04022707790136337, -0.0008525852463208139, -0.0330158956348896, 0.04070277884602547, -0.010743319988250732, -0.03766809031367302, -0.019638750702142715, -0.009851757436990738, -0.01580829918384552, 0.016542453318834305, 0.04018405079841614, 0.0021402225829660892, 0.04710276424884796, 0.008637108840048313, -0.05911315977573395, -0.03091517649590969, -0.02758440002799034, 0.014665588736534119, -0.020532744005322456, -0.004081675782799721, 0.005075172055512667, 0.035082947462797165, -0.03053327277302742, 0.05060684308409691, -0.022801654413342476, -0.030087901279330254, 0.008535540662705898, -0.06729421019554138, 0.025307947769761086, -0.054828498512506485, -0.0025879719760268927, 0.035742659121751785, -0.030408773571252823, 0.013437293469905853, 0.0047799767926335335, -0.03646513819694519, 0.026264941319823265, 0.06613220274448395, 0.052073609083890915, 0.007934498600661755, -0.01653105765581131, 0.013432571664452553, 0.010901160538196564, -0.04237999767065048, 0.0035004233941435814, -0.015329290181398392, 0.0021441495046019554, 0.0685739666223526, 0.0433308444917202, -0.031813234090805054, 0.011587411165237427, 0.06214156746864319, 0.04191521555185318, 0.04305896535515785, 0.02406376600265503, -0.017223915085196495, 0.003979871515184641, 0.008628591895103455, 0.012904247269034386, -0.008713340386748314, 0.006984436418861151, 0.0035031915176659822, 0.0137063879519701, 0.035548992455005646, -0.009620259515941143, -0.016691643744707108, 0.040244124829769135, 0.00862094946205616, -0.018185347318649292, -0.029166748747229576, -0.03771562501788139, 0.029461167752742767, -0.02759227342903614, -0.00493083568289876, 0.015135531313717365, 0.006741601508110762, 0.0369434654712677, 0.011561695486307144, -0.02171454206109047, 0.018853597342967987, -0.003182261949405074, -0.007884552702307701, -0.014243599958717823, 0.023503020405769348, -0.044664692133665085, 0.03389733284711838, -0.017314720898866653, -0.024216677993535995, -0.07262041419744492, -0.026501908898353577, 0.057059239596128464, 0.00945187360048294, 0.018884046003222466, -0.005169851705431938, -0.020994389429688454, 0.034215960651636124, -0.009136294014751911, 0.05695955827832222, 0.007823717780411243, -0.050951842218637466, 0.009460614062845707, -0.02356855385005474, -0.003224182641133666, 0.03578956797719002, 0.01095660962164402, -0.009812681004405022, 0.014707432128489017, -0.014443241991102695, -0.05217780917882919, -0.020270681008696556, -0.020147599279880524, 0.015175464563071728, -0.015716321766376495, -0.01070135086774826, 0.01183027308434248, -0.03160848841071129, -0.04680586978793144, 0.0007464471273124218, -0.044370900839567184, 0.004047746304422617, -0.07066924124956131, 0.0012226374819874763, 0.017681311815977097, -0.03723130747675896, 0.004633078817278147, 0.04180372133851051, -0.03826889768242836, 0.0015859509585425258, -0.05239429324865341, -0.013845046050846577, -0.009023074060678482, -0.0018641520291566849, 0.02574561908841133, 0.026301156729459763, -0.01661035604774952, 0.04465102776885033, 0.011071338318288326, 0.0024632469285279512, -0.03652803227305412, -0.011966116726398468, -0.04375271499156952, -0.04056809842586517, 0.024771859869360924, 0.004425675608217716, 0.008942604064941406, -0.010570187121629715, -0.036078665405511856, -0.007612297777086496, 0.0627996176481247, 0.020860280841588974, 0.024934599176049232, 0.04574805870652199, -0.0211088377982378, 0.0030102061573415995, 0.008145565167069435, 0.023761769756674767, -0.018878329545259476, 0.015269187279045582, -0.012853536754846573, 0.028663698583841324, 0.009784572757780552, -0.02165200747549534, -0.0459027923643589, -0.016590110957622528, 0.0035712900571525097, -0.05172865465283394, -0.009687058627605438, -0.021542925387620926, -0.030618876218795776, -0.007269902154803276, 0.036964304745197296, -0.012382159940898418, -0.0026889685541391373, 0.018191376700997353, 0.01712016388773918, -0.0056002940982580185, -0.024154452607035637, -0.009961562231183052, -0.026367660611867905, -0.006350289098918438, 0.012815788388252258, -0.02074720337986946, 0.023196669295430183, 0.06551025062799454, -0.003343392862007022, 0.03389310836791992, -0.011670086532831192, -0.06590735167264938, 0.03729695454239845, -0.0734376385807991, -0.0032095618080347776, -0.009274514392018318, 0.056763071566820145, -0.0008564964518882334, 0.015037978067994118, 0.01768084056675434, -0.010398698039352894, 0.0399659089744091, -0.01471279188990593, -0.05608932673931122, 0.02657890133559704, -0.032484978437423706, 0.005656799301505089, 0.017391564324498177, 0.03766835853457451, 0.033782266080379486, -0.008853660896420479, 0.0023937958758324385, -0.011764022521674633, 0.026071367785334587, -0.0320947989821434, 0.016326460987329483, -0.015540900640189648, 0.006574312690645456, -0.02890370972454548, 0.0006509938393719494, 0.021968167275190353, -0.014475167728960514, 0.029980802908539772, 0.042214978486299515, 0.012325415387749672, 0.008017204701900482, -0.016909006983041763, 0.012674582190811634, 0.03922617435455322, -0.0012073558755218983, 0.060902196913957596, 0.017131498083472252, -0.03540966287255287, 0.030760997906327248, 0.010958120226860046, 0.013446700759232044, 0.022810718044638634, 0.005464394111186266, -0.017116829752922058, -0.01923321560025215, -0.039059847593307495, 0.046667393296957016, -0.01187360379844904, 0.021279921755194664, 0.015186203643679619, 0.05033471807837486, 0.0349123440682888, -0.07457621395587921, 0.015441056340932846, 0.05200173705816269, -0.003875833237543702, 0.016086379066109657, -0.006067271810024977, 0.005837130360305309, -0.005671032704412937, 0.017344828695058823, 0.027490675449371338, 0.016454387456178665, -0.001238566474057734, 0.014918196015059948, 0.04020311310887337, -0.020314453169703484, -0.012146028690040112, -0.007527023088186979, 0.0664953887462616, 0.05644999071955681, -0.010808452032506466, -0.040128838270902634, 0.008571630343794823, 0.032929517328739166, 0.030813096091151237, 0.052620623260736465, -0.010406137444078922, -0.08638732880353928, 0.00028054366703145206, 0.010811993852257729, 0.0035740151070058346, -0.012005772441625595, 0.008088874630630016, -0.048278696835041046, -0.043719906359910965, 0.03920086845755577, -0.03760790079832077, 0.0303327739238739, 0.004708683118224144, -0.032675713300704956, -0.013433153741061687, -0.003465464571490884, -0.01977112889289856, 0.034234628081321716, -0.034781213849782944, 0.07291638106107712, -0.01011018268764019, -0.030529003590345383, -0.061581626534461975, 0.039006441831588745, 0.004639885388314724, 0.0459933765232563, -0.015031750313937664, -0.023636527359485626, 0.025183001533150673, 0.024889951571822166, -0.020526062697172165, -0.042596008628606796, 0.0013215426588431, -0.019615773111581802, -0.003915575798600912, 0.048016030341386795, 0.0007018932374194264, -0.026664575561881065, -0.016947193071246147, 0.03742143139243126, -0.03362401947379112, -0.00014057877706363797, -0.03895721212029457, 0.007184456568211317, -0.0057017202489078045, 0.007973563857376575, 0.07964091002941132, 0.03180432692170143, 0.002643891144543886, 0.018411649391055107, -0.02284768596291542, 0.03818213567137718, -0.04675891622900963, -0.013989881612360477, -0.047675058245658875, -0.012050282210111618, -0.035448361188173294, 0.028923776000738144, -0.017634455114603043, 0.043784577399492264, -0.03130670636892319, 0.004600231535732746, -0.005408113822340965, 0.058411430567502975, -0.0044831084087491035, -0.020480966195464134, 0.028864040970802307, 0.03141822665929794, -0.01791570708155632, -0.01460064947605133, 0.011597540229558945, -0.017344597727060318, -0.01390189677476883, -0.025308573618531227, -0.002448730170726776, 0.01792834885418415, -0.04368627071380615, -0.04893355071544647, 0.03506091982126236, 0.020067524164915085, 0.04825188219547272, -0.00946584902703762, 0.03979415073990822, -0.01196316909044981, -0.07104519754648209, -0.010259686969220638, 0.003218923695385456, -0.005941714625805616, 0.03861292451620102, -0.07851371169090271, 0.013319647870957851, -0.03499210253357887, -0.025165677070617676, -0.051759976893663406, -0.07095262408256531, 0.04127248376607895, -0.010554482229053974, -0.02094411663711071, -0.0495988093316555, 0.04465450718998909, -0.02218022570014, -0.006291883997619152, -0.01011454313993454, 0.04907840117812157, -0.03399025648832321, 0.0004053686570841819, -0.008158066309988499, 0.0016376262065023184, 0.0426323302090168, 0.037347786128520966, 0.009347300976514816, 0.018371710553765297, 0.0019004663918167353, -0.03623991832137108, -0.023512685671448708, 0.030499311164021492, -0.03500644862651825, -0.002518768422305584, -0.04786735400557518, 0.017853200435638428, 0.0571199469268322, -0.039067454636096954, 0.026658613234758377, 0.03581424057483673, 0.006132001057267189, 0.016924967989325523, -0.06884858757257462, 0.0009272776078432798, -0.033778414130210876, -0.004605866968631744, -0.030807014554739, -0.03604460507631302, -0.02303398586809635, -0.010380016639828682, 0.008183460682630539, -0.014331987127661705, -0.008146170526742935, 0.013855982571840286, 0.034555092453956604, 0.015365892089903355, 0.0069003175012767315, -0.012833556160330772, -0.004826435353606939, 0.020939646288752556, 0.021818794310092926, 0.027952343225479126, 0.01880568638443947, 0.011255521327257156, -0.04873592033982277, -0.03592253848910332, -0.03278077766299248, 0.029523273929953575, 0.06213286891579628, -0.01569291576743126, 0.04382433369755745, 0.06596565991640091, -0.028548823669552803, -0.003053846536204219, -0.04323706775903702, -0.037685200572013855, 0.022027859464287758, 0.015791743993759155, 0.05484301224350929, -0.020441647619009018, -0.0069897472858428955, 0.03289555385708809, -0.01740451529622078, 0.038601625710725784, 0.057412274181842804, -0.0071717300452291965, 0.019084330648183823, 0.01591118983924389, -0.016493801027536392, -0.04168003052473068, 0.003174758283421397, -0.013888913206756115, 0.007192513905465603, -0.014715011231601238, 0.005308068357408047, 0.03882361575961113, 0.05584067106246948, 0.029084958136081696, -0.024082059040665627, -0.018156355246901512, -0.031220832839608192, 0.01980101689696312, 0.054110024124383926, -0.041447713971138, 0.027555106207728386, 0.044952522963285446, 0.023703761398792267, 0.003839339828118682, 0.05845210328698158, 0.024521270766854286, -0.08276955783367157, -0.016646184027194977, -0.012852529063820839, -0.006126731168478727, 0.0367390438914299, 0.031790513545274734, -0.029661597684025764, 0.015380360186100006, -0.032469313591718674, 0.006983817555010319, 0.038020242005586624, 0.022428302094340324, 0.008317697793245316, 0.07384849339723587, -0.01879764348268509, -0.004839726723730564, -0.019538825377821922, -0.022834444418549538, 0.1158137246966362, 0.08729694038629532, 0.03928935155272484, -0.06982950866222382, 0.016178017482161522, 0.0284738689661026, -0.002641981700435281, -0.04203427582979202, 0.02591591887176037, 0.028583165258169174, 0.0015566789079457521, 0.04437432810664177, 0.06494467705488205, 0.012757767923176289, 0.006757722701877356, 0.04012603685259819, -0.012513290159404278, -0.014639733359217644, -0.011705701239407063, 0.005611109547317028, 0.01268576830625534, -0.006507357582449913, -0.07860905677080154, 0.00315658375620842, -0.012021370232105255, -0.053766801953315735, -0.023616766557097435, 0.006044632289558649, 0.019777148962020874, -0.022064125165343285, -0.011096596717834473, -0.002973667811602354, 0.013499327935278416, 0.02280016988515854, 0.020852837711572647, 0.016132814809679985, 0.016613712534308434, -0.004032987169921398, -0.000055592456192243844, -0.013916358351707458, 0.004494687542319298, -0.001899841008707881, 0.019326921552419662, -0.021843817085027695, -0.0484667606651783, -0.03372259438037872, -0.041001319885253906, 0.044454023241996765, 0.00869767740368843, 0.035377491265535355, 0.0019785556942224503, 0.046812694519758224, 0.014840272255241871, -0.026314832270145416, -0.021992387250065804, 0.04418603703379631, 0.05925162509083748, -0.08097965270280838, -0.0018154160352423787, -0.028779800981283188, -0.00944756343960762, -0.01544905174523592, 0.02176186814904213, 0.009679200127720833, -0.05726960673928261, 0.012735330499708652, -0.03944747522473335, 0.052047695964574814, -0.006544304545968771, 0.0045104133896529675, 0.02308528870344162, 0.005962754134088755, -0.019153933972120285, -0.051214270293712616, 0.04379742220044136, 0.01984066143631935, -0.011525041423738003, -0.04193279519677162, -0.019071945920586586, 0.0006230860017240047, -0.02226915955543518, 0.009293991141021252, -0.025931909680366516, -0.02600875496864319, -0.02070118486881256, -0.021380530670285225, 0.04883522912859917, 0.03008381649851799, 0.008229897357523441, 0.014050296507775784, -0.05367279052734375, 0.03226340562105179, 0.040612153708934784, -0.057474564760923386, 0.013043290935456753, -0.013582238927483559, -0.029981788247823715, 0.01563364267349243, 0.004750363528728485, 0.0798189789056778, 0.051584865897893906, 0.004514235537499189, -0.022261986508965492, 0.01347280852496624, -0.03141416981816292, -0.0026248192880302668, -0.007825542241334915, -0.11082372069358826, 0.013598100282251835, -0.0007548339781351388, 0.018681056797504425, -0.040528833866119385, -0.026726502925157547, -0.002381947124376893, 0.01153535209596157, -0.01576494798064232, 0.024682460352778435, -0.07694634795188904, 0.016631485894322395, -0.012781837023794651, 0.029714930802583694, -0.040849797427654266, 0.014078422449529171, -0.010928376577794552, -0.004554583225399256, -0.024614309892058372, -0.030869223177433014, -0.002005429472774267, -0.011565656401216984, -0.03367169573903084, 0.03153713420033455, 0.004411145579069853, -0.017310721799731255, 0.0339796356856823, 0.005543372128158808, 0.010096335783600807, -0.03386785462498665, 0.06093313917517662, -0.015901347622275352, -0.03579581156373024, 0.046460192650556564, -0.03820646554231644, -0.07589025795459747, -0.009959119372069836, -0.011017385870218277, 0.03636234626173973, 0.015898901969194412, 0.0043188962154090405, -0.03221737965941429, 0.032434944063425064, -0.006916004233062267, -0.008916152641177177, 0.003332628170028329, 0.048206575214862823, 0.018194064497947693, -0.003187319030985236, 0.0069579496048390865, 0.005858167540282011, -0.03126979246735573, 0.015804044902324677, 0.06393906474113464, 0.03182860091328621, -0.019628945738077164, 0.01856083981692791, -0.010754548013210297, 0.02822941541671753, 0.015478474088013172, -0.019079390913248062, 0.04086657240986824, 0.021577931940555573, -0.019975529983639717, 0.013082919642329216, -0.020500101149082184, 0.02454463765025139, -0.0720890536904335, -0.003300833748653531, -0.025986256077885628, 0.022885100916028023, 0.05244279280304909, -0.05883108824491501, -0.01799677312374115, 0.05188056826591492, -0.03689897805452347, 0.052516382187604904, -0.006445175502449274, -0.01663440279662609, -0.02093292959034443, -0.02881029061973095, -0.008242152631282806, 0.026826726272702217, 0.03128805011510849, 0.01901899091899395, 0.04096220061182976, 0.022897373884916306, 0.041314758360385895, 0.00872422568500042, -0.004688204266130924, -0.004068660084158182, 0.01731793023645878, -0.02499488927423954, 0.0252518467605114, -0.030400682240724564, -0.021799320355057716, -0.004331246949732304, -0.02555537037551403, -0.0073143672198057175, -0.0010911732679232955, 0.02339800074696541, -0.013654205948114395, 0.051977403461933136, 0.012290317565202713, -0.023208964616060257, 0.020530780777335167, -0.033483318984508514, -0.004147930070757866, 0.035001806914806366, 0.010485567152500153, 0.034310232847929, 0.02506130188703537, -0.047945186495780945, -0.014947433955967426, 0.014424936845898628, -0.005725917872041464, -0.006305064540356398, 0.003288575913757086, -0.014796048402786255, 0.014147348701953888, -0.03458390757441521, 0.04466165974736214, -0.04791295528411865, -0.007641770876944065, 0.02167702466249466, -0.002107621170580387, 0.00024045142345130444, 0.03381367400288582, -0.011810845695436, -0.04303666576743126, 0.021363098174333572, 0.0006307580624707043, 0.005593561101704836, -0.02828507125377655, -0.019275978207588196, 0.032402973622083664, -0.006030421704053879, -0.0595964640378952, -0.001748622627928853, -0.020617308095097542, 0.03031964786350727, 0.006373145151883364, -0.045120324939489365, 0.04095375910401344, -0.035918042063713074, 0.01009433064609766, -0.08403796702623367, 0.07819865643978119, 0.013389511033892632, -0.01491774432361126, -0.008894948288798332, -0.010674153454601765, -0.024371998384594917, -0.0009622302604839206, 0.03941508010029793, -0.026321785524487495, 0.009960624389350414, -0.012505772523581982, 0.029008369892835617, 0.031418416649103165, -0.0144475307315588, 0.05984808877110481, 0.02130139246582985, -0.03660053387284279, -0.0020684185437858105, -0.016226237639784813, 0.01457615289837122, -0.017069002613425255, 0.0112219899892807, 0.016211112961173058, 0.011076770722866058, -0.006977519486099482, -0.03657398745417595, 0.03815789148211479, 0.013354950584471226, 0.0026463570538908243, 0.038880325853824615, -0.0321846678853035, 0.018278829753398895, 0.02186216600239277, 0.0034117267932742834, -0.07686393707990646, 0.021778777241706848, -0.046716246753931046, -0.013445922173559666, 0.03509753569960594, -0.0023345237132161856, 0.016241086646914482, -0.05006524920463562, 0.007627806626260281, 0.012183397077023983, -0.04040699824690819, 0.011879035271704197, 0.022897791117429733, -0.0037590188439935446, 0.032749537378549576, 0.0006928773364052176, 0.0007481771754100919, 0.0512535534799099, 0.031446706503629684, 0.010514872148633003, 0.015354037284851074, 0.03264138102531433, 0.003857608884572983, 0.012187667191028595, 0.007903171703219414, -0.03296694904565811, 0.027452386915683746, -0.021047523245215416, 0.02005072869360447, -0.022964434698224068, -0.03345891088247299, 0.019088130444288254, -0.019243091344833374, -0.007001396268606186, 0.011101508513092995, -0.019441086798906326, 0.06418798863887787, -0.04181143641471863, -0.014217270538210869, -0.04427304491400719, -0.010544216260313988, -0.04392813518643379, 0.022192278876900673, -0.010365325957536697, 0.010124343447387218, -0.024168094620108604, 0.0116780586540699, 0.0048658219166100025, -0.011225628666579723, 0.028487810865044594, -0.04765232279896736, 0.02652861922979355, 0.013256042264401913, 0.000981528195552528, -0.03032391332089901, -0.031085627153515816, 0.0001746683701639995, -0.06802375614643097, 0.01944872923195362, 0.05154712125658989, 0.01067017950117588, -0.05336790531873703, -0.027478931471705437, -0.03412601724267006, 0.039190273731946945, -0.08102551847696304, 0.021226029843091965, -0.0270900409668684, 0.018807947635650635, -0.02566390298306942, 0.023882338777184486 ]
<p>I am using <code>R</code> and <code>e1071</code> package to tune a C-classification SVM.</p> <p>My question is: regardless of the kernel type (linear, polynomial, radial basis or sigmoidal), is there any good criterion to choose the range in which cost and $\gamma$ parameters should range over and/or to choose what the granularity should be (that is, as an example, <code>gamma = 10 ^ (1:2)</code> or <code>gamma = 1:2</code> or <code>gamma = 100 ^ (1:2)</code>)?</p> <p>I add a second question: can <code>tune.svm()</code> return the best kernel type, too?</p> <p>Thanks,</p>
73,639
[ -0.01040873397141695, -0.018450889736413956, 0.012796739116311073, 0.013230802491307259, 0.006963405292481184, 0.022846074774861336, -0.024125251919031143, -0.025371519848704338, 0.031640298664569855, -0.04333508387207985, 0.022831253707408905, 0.05720558762550354, 0.053612664341926575, 0.04202021285891533, 0.03599242866039276, -0.01971985585987568, -0.042679186910390854, -0.0171088557690382, 0.007599144708365202, -0.009288623929023743, 0.006556947715580463, 0.006689783185720444, -0.009445290081202984, -0.02016441337764263, -0.022732699289917946, 0.03622332215309143, 0.0023811915889382362, 0.0014551979256793857, 0.023614175617694855, 0.03190847858786583, -0.04119531065225601, -0.013055667281150818, 0.040463827550411224, 0.026252327486872673, 0.0348578542470932, 0.009885508567094803, -0.02601213939487934, -0.018021350726485252, -0.04559649899601936, 0.027627458795905113, -0.023765236139297485, -0.014300411567091942, -0.005975351203233004, 0.030731581151485443, 0.016671329736709595, 0.01988927088677883, 0.014953916892409325, -0.0038765822537243366, 0.03688805550336838, -0.03004131093621254, 0.07520643621683121, 0.0074658384546637535, -0.002236369764432311, 0.02574084885418415, -0.016968104988336563, -0.026608899235725403, 0.06604466587305069, 0.08606031537055969, 0.019454319030046463, -0.04519416764378548, -0.001368595869280398, -0.0387515164911747, 0.016605600714683533, -0.008144740015268326, -0.007587130181491375, 0.03591592609882355, 0.03296023979783058, 0.0065389066003263, 0.008544038981199265, -0.03402404487133026, 0.0025744102895259857, -0.017682373523712158, 0.0050862920470535755, 0.01406667660921812, 0.044012103229761124, -0.017634106799960136, 0.005101023707538843, 0.03962891176342964, 0.043557342141866684, 0.011025887914001942, 0.006832782179117203, 0.04133930057287216, 0.010280381888151169, 0.014089959673583508, -0.02194622904062271, 0.019205372780561447, 0.060887254774570465, 0.0091735003516078, 0.03274449706077576, 0.04431787505745888, 0.0034091840498149395, 0.032060589641332626, 0.021513696759939194, 0.006373841315507889, -0.02745349332690239, 0.022460393607616425, -0.01463758572936058, 0.001830584486015141, 0.0029928735457360744, -0.049167126417160034, -0.011644011363387108, -0.024714026600122452, -0.0008632789831608534, 0.04939171299338341, -0.04610282927751541, 0.024019725620746613, -0.03112632781267166, -0.011129829101264477, -0.032778412103652954, -0.02237849123775959, 0.008665001019835472, 0.010580429807305336, -0.018298443406820297, 0.007426490541547537, 0.02842879667878151, -0.01955103501677513, -0.03403817117214203, -0.038786694407463074, 0.024100156500935555, 0.0211179256439209, 0.08653924614191055, -0.025967823341488838, 0.02371406927704811, -0.009097224101424217, -0.036057792603969574, 0.044030215591192245, 0.055867694318294525, -0.010127048939466476, -0.07098063081502914, 0.02195647731423378, 0.02510705217719078, -0.02850365824997425, 0.014396240934729576, -0.02168479934334755, 0.007665228098630905, -0.020278573036193848, -0.08597421646118164, -0.056434646248817444, 0.029238862916827202, -0.016835786402225494, 0.014631222002208233, -0.08385013788938522, -0.0005546710453927517, 0.012352277524769306, 0.027134770527482033, 0.0034517322201281786, 0.029862411320209503, 0.03278348594903946, 0.03222839534282684, -0.003024511272087693, -0.0328432098031044, -0.013132819905877113, -0.03877729922533035, -0.0033758871722966433, -0.03841247782111168, -0.015249965712428093, 0.03084886632859707, 0.024131080135703087, 0.01628195308148861, 0.025451771914958954, 0.03858171030879021, -0.03756440803408623, 0.007251101080328226, -0.019473347812891006, -0.005523477680981159, -0.020939113572239876, 0.043514396995306015, 0.033466387540102005, 0.05715140327811241, -0.0008923148852773011, -0.025481216609477997, 0.028840074315667152, 0.04493764787912369, 0.004275599494576454, 0.05809921398758888, -0.0002644328342285007, 0.008186271414160728, -0.06394416093826294, 0.029486479237675667, 0.03733642399311066, -0.05005404353141785, -0.03182109817862511, 0.007404679898172617, 0.015514175407588482, 0.0009513177210465074, 0.028284018859267235, -0.0012160937767475843, 0.00302832736633718, 0.05912487581372261, -0.01830432191491127, -0.04757296293973923, -0.033996306359767914, -0.020240919664502144, -0.0034488753881305456, -0.035513103008270264, 0.040598105639219284, -0.017106471583247185, 0.014097461476922035, 0.031046781688928604, -0.0008615166880190372, -0.012671173550188541, 0.005134090315550566, 0.0763520747423172, -0.03844350576400757, -0.0049780369736254215, 0.03230250999331474, 0.029219770804047585, -0.045020926743745804, 0.06492684036493301, -0.010965264402329922, -0.0780530497431755, 0.010936075821518898, -0.002955144504085183, -0.00274406629614532, -0.01642252691090107, -0.010778221301734447, 0.005096070934087038, 0.020845787599682808, -0.010898088105022907, 0.032938189804553986, -0.046872373670339584, 0.03437161445617676, 0.08463217318058014, 0.0037439465522766113, -0.0025768019258975983, 0.01057829987257719, -0.02046077884733677, 0.04679475352168083, -0.05374133214354515, -0.008708066307008266, -0.031413398683071136, 0.005932848434895277, 0.04946073517203331, 0.038659825921058655, -0.03627391904592514, 0.01019845250993967, 0.025368744507431984, 0.02278921939432621, 0.013223649933934212, 0.030886337161064148, -0.008466806262731552, -0.004123486112803221, 0.035615839064121246, 0.03437419235706329, -0.016111453995108604, 0.005623345263302326, 0.02640353888273239, -0.013658162206411362, 0.01583847962319851, 0.010512279346585274, 0.008537400513887405, 0.02062084712088108, -0.032635122537612915, -0.012028943747282028, 0.00018748300499282777, 0.004669458605349064, 0.04574812576174736, -0.03323904424905777, 0.0021189323160797358, 0.04447146877646446, -0.00895206443965435, -0.0012026976328343153, -0.00899142399430275, -0.00027595425490289927, 0.041768260300159454, 0.026710145175457, -0.010015160776674747, -0.006342075765132904, 0.016079196706414223, -0.032579898834228516, 0.0005206692148931324, -0.02540857158601284, 0.0033952519297599792, -0.04661446437239647, 0.02621123567223549, 0.04586172103881836, -0.01279431115835905, 0.0335196852684021, -0.007731267251074314, -0.037534892559051514, 0.010958794504404068, -0.04500141739845276, 0.012169744819402695, 0.0043581342324614525, -0.04135163873434067, -0.011165879666805267, -0.02353334054350853, 0.007760863751173019, 0.046352215111255646, -0.026000941172242165, 0.006789481267333031, 0.031239988282322884, 0.013899932615458965, -0.027591535821557045, -0.001422098372131586, -0.045781463384628296, 0.025049855932593346, -0.02059391513466835, -0.041161224246025085, 0.04735772684216499, 0.023802412673830986, -0.053109925240278244, 0.021340860053896904, -0.04959579557180405, -0.0316280834376812, 0.001486552064307034, -0.025219090282917023, 0.025708910077810287, -0.009981663897633553, -0.013721947558224201, 0.04327217862010002, -0.024296769872307777, 0.029341382905840874, -0.060789644718170166, -0.04123877361416817, 0.042000219225883484, -0.029841957613825798, 0.0387972816824913, 0.032343171536922455, -0.004021316301077604, 0.08949055522680283, 0.06170153617858887, -0.02172374352812767, -0.051611050963401794, 0.0016987464623525739, -0.02455267868936062, -0.005221718456596136, 0.016528315842151642, 0.031071286648511887, 0.013473495841026306, 0.01747475564479828, -0.0023970173206180334, 0.020223166793584824, 0.04459945112466812, -0.008731288835406303, -0.026138145476579666, 0.045625023543834686, 0.0010766738560050726, -0.02912147343158722, 0.03781585395336151, 0.028030095621943474, 0.0003574544098228216, 0.01470889151096344, -0.009914995171129704, -0.004192599095404148, -0.02262028120458126, -0.007075243163853884, 0.00020903456606902182, -0.031499236822128296, 0.03369196876883507, -0.010634580627083778, 0.0005630480009131134, 0.024904584512114525, -0.052821580320596695, -0.0023672005627304316, 0.006112839560955763, 0.028171157464385033, -0.05157749354839325, -0.0017125688027590513, 0.03521418944001198, 0.05603969842195511, 0.00628478592261672, -0.004383212421089411, 0.019986990839242935, -0.018248049542307854, 0.023191658779978752, -0.02170824073255062, -0.01630564220249653, 0.05229541286826134, 0.02523794211447239, 0.01856190524995327, 0.008093741722404957, -0.040692463517189026, 0.03341496363282204, -0.07406316697597504, -0.03352808952331543, -0.05478166788816452, 0.07003360986709595, 0.022890109568834305, 0.011783820576965809, 0.02858571894466877, -0.0450851134955883, 0.008127140812575817, 0.008954615332186222, -0.025725575163960457, 0.019317250698804855, 0.0072541143745183945, 0.010561447590589523, 0.028689226135611534, -0.042076196521520615, 0.0021119387820363045, -0.027354471385478973, 0.028841499239206314, 0.012693092226982117, 0.016193201765418053, -0.029498610645532608, 0.010137838311493397, -0.014878612011671066, -0.023695938289165497, -0.020837653428316116, 0.009598132222890854, 0.003712058998644352, -0.02240624465048313, -0.013474545441567898, 0.004398760851472616, -0.028612203896045685, 0.006961714010685682, -0.024490339681506157, 0.007283821702003479, -0.022713255137205124, 0.05195192992687225, 0.0009000213467516005, 0.023603351786732674, -0.03562374413013458, 0.0017789362464100122, 0.006490720435976982, 0.04761834815144539, 0.046152494847774506, -0.01545550487935543, -0.017194945365190506, -0.05371248722076416, -0.03325992822647095, 0.01985921896994114, 0.022532813251018524, 0.0005606182385236025, -0.02574191242456436, 0.07241686433553696, 0.009116929955780506, -0.07338527590036392, 0.0020154023077338934, 0.07779375463724136, 0.012266654521226883, -0.023982131853699684, -0.055604394525289536, -0.00801373366266489, 0.005051266402006149, -0.003430437296628952, 0.0015187995741143823, 0.01712789572775364, -0.03809736296534538, 0.01473346259444952, 0.029614970088005066, -0.043685898184776306, -0.030656518414616585, -0.016656020656228065, 0.049233149737119675, 0.06549712270498276, -0.015999488532543182, -0.008402715437114239, -0.003321354277431965, 0.01899995654821396, 0.050080034881830215, 0.016793103888630867, -0.018873408436775208, -0.07179687172174454, 0.0012908331118524075, 0.08753159642219543, 0.059987783432006836, -0.052684854716062546, -0.031446266919374466, -0.04088124260306358, -0.02763283997774124, 0.023799149319529533, -0.042639318853616714, 0.022406620904803276, -0.031164070591330528, -0.00758525263518095, -0.042497918009757996, -0.01818990521132946, -0.030373794957995415, 0.040088050067424774, -0.023021673783659935, 0.013874636963009834, -0.06470027565956116, -0.010602511465549469, -0.04390254616737366, 0.008700214326381683, 0.004356111865490675, 0.06010349094867706, -0.01546646561473608, -0.055777810513973236, 0.012960853055119514, -0.006141175981611013, -0.004022897686809301, -0.0792955607175827, 0.00284210336394608, 0.005646408535540104, 0.01897391676902771, 0.011797814629971981, -0.002660120604559779, -0.0208777766674757, -0.0007981604430824518, 0.038671329617500305, -0.004028309136629105, -0.002221441362053156, -0.00012653082376345992, 0.039168164134025574, 0.030995193868875504, 0.01553289219737053, 0.03470848873257637, 0.03790474683046341, -0.012384457513689995, -0.014676285907626152, -0.04757288470864296, 0.007066878955811262, -0.01392476074397564, -0.03577049821615219, -0.039635058492422104, -0.026449039578437805, -0.0012419138802215457, 0.021973052993416786, 0.02724289707839489, 0.06503847986459732, -0.03465592488646507, -0.016057245433330536, -0.009668667800724506, 0.05840146169066429, -0.012140451930463314, -0.02849285490810871, 0.02407999336719513, 0.0704575628042221, -0.020256420597434044, 0.00732620432972908, -0.026848802343010902, 0.0027282703667879105, 0.0014344752999022603, 0.05837095528841019, -0.06519541889429092, 0.02961353026330471, -0.042102351784706116, 0.020288944244384766, -0.028141047805547714, -0.03875346854329109, 0.06412532925605774, 0.023247871547937393, 0.0004908789996989071, -0.00994829460978508, -0.04555626958608627, 0.012111467309296131, 0.003396576503291726, -0.019060857594013214, 0.03775664418935776, -0.022124364972114563, 0.023196497932076454, -0.004488628823310137, -0.021792830899357796, -0.06689703464508057, -0.02893752045929432, -0.003568467451259494, -0.00142702367156744, -0.025888536125421524, -0.03614575415849686, 0.02753327041864395, -0.02219516597688198, -0.04059980437159538, 0.005747979506850243, 0.06386199593544006, 0.026248885318636894, -0.0006535690044984221, -0.008162787184119225, -0.0025800722651183605, 0.07439330220222473, -0.0006774001521989703, 0.015545087866485119, 0.015123930759727955, -0.018795592710375786, -0.010009151883423328, 0.021004756912589073, 0.012898856773972511, -0.01385174784809351, -0.004632570315152407, -0.050000663846731186, 0.012111371383070946, 0.033602338284254074, 0.006219841539859772, -0.03660079091787338, 0.040938254445791245, -0.034721627831459045, 0.044939007610082626, -0.012328371405601501, -0.0042501455172896385, -0.019956765696406364, -0.0010725754546001554, -0.005339726805686951, -0.020446276292204857, -0.03272523358464241, -0.025056829676032066, 0.0010124865220859647, 0.023574812337756157, 0.01611231453716755, 0.01168750412762165, 0.04824109748005867, -0.011727675795555115, 0.01763336732983589, -0.018736885860562325, -0.04108232632279396, 0.02246229164302349, -0.016578922048211098, 0.025830766186118126, -0.0011595735559239984, 0.001605782425031066, -0.015644459053874016, 0.0017131069907918572, -0.03922448307275772, -0.018964624032378197, 0.04104652255773544, 0.018649766221642494, 0.05873379483819008, 0.03211928904056549, 0.017283635213971138, 0.01362876407802105, -0.036424435675144196, -0.036779798567295074, -0.0330439954996109, 0.03493097424507141, 0.04867484048008919, -0.019883323460817337, -0.010915715247392654, 0.04462582245469093, 0.0166071318089962, 0.03383178263902664, 0.032460905611515045, -0.004496787209063768, 0.0357540026307106, 0.007816451601684093, -0.05339973792433739, -0.043419234454631805, 0.04594551771879196, -0.017823537811636925, 0.014311548322439194, 0.006481741555035114, -0.04524683207273483, 0.0277954563498497, 0.023736342787742615, 0.035585012286901474, -0.02160950005054474, -0.017039988189935684, -0.03875841200351715, 0.008449234999716282, 0.0659363865852356, -0.03263390064239502, 0.029540754854679108, 0.041865840554237366, 0.023919302970170975, 0.0006719689699821174, 0.017713138833642006, -0.02745014987885952, -0.08045569062232971, -0.046007562428712845, -0.0209671538323164, -0.049269869923591614, -0.0009523839689791203, 0.034605808556079865, -0.05004231259226799, 0.00595320388674736, -0.016517149284482002, 0.03303113207221031, -0.0054480284452438354, 0.05291368439793587, 0.004120791330933571, 0.03878259286284447, -0.0010909572010859847, -0.027280310168862343, 0.03377614542841911, -0.019288161769509315, 0.1208314299583435, 0.07416322827339172, -0.006642014253884554, -0.06886623054742813, -0.0019415357382968068, -0.02149175852537155, -0.012415224686264992, -0.01790532097220421, 0.02893851511180401, 0.0031068918760865927, -0.019361501559615135, 0.033810313791036606, 0.020618602633476257, 0.011549470946192741, 0.036666691303253174, 0.07710204273462296, 0.00291078700684011, -0.0037552881985902786, 0.02638206258416176, 0.011565802618861198, 0.011927814222872257, -0.01795968785881996, -0.018354644998908043, 0.023670725524425507, 0.000848678289912641, -0.03178185224533081, -0.038109321147203445, -0.03908243030309677, 0.02366873063147068, 0.0024366159923374653, -0.002660839818418026, -0.026289131492376328, 0.010610511526465416, 0.0248839370906353, 0.0013222083216533065, -0.017562486231327057, -0.03648912161588669, -0.03191305324435234, -0.00834500789642334, 0.05542156100273132, 0.013085751794278622, 0.006705951411277056, -0.008248232305049896, 0.016767818480730057, -0.014860719442367554, -0.01511575561016798, -0.024814698845148087, 0.04755711182951927, -0.000866939255502075, 0.007352976128458977, 0.0021371759939938784, 0.041802529245615005, -0.005696827080100775, -0.051458146423101425, -0.009629307314753532, -0.00035616307286545634, 0.03391150385141373, -0.011340978555381298, -0.014413191005587578, -0.041541699320077896, 0.03547438606619835, -0.03671982139348984, 0.03359801322221756, 0.023337259888648987, -0.0989631861448288, -0.023779839277267456, -0.030603352934122086, 0.037121858447790146, -0.010502271354198456, -0.012522836215794086, 0.03851540386676788, -0.028015879914164543, -0.005341497249901295, -0.01679077185690403, 0.02666211500763893, 0.014623431488871574, 0.012973243370652199, -0.016562173143029213, -0.01584385521709919, -0.03653126209974289, -0.03028315119445324, -0.022580111399292946, -0.010548543184995651, 0.0252239853143692, -0.03337117284536362, 0.0116453031077981, 0.01232203934341669, 0.02679717168211937, 0.040348004549741745, -0.0007126429700292647, 0.007002345751971006, 0.00036028469912707806, 0.019549554213881493, -0.054765962064266205, -0.015539583750069141, 0.002305251080542803, -0.03295810520648956, 0.028836913406848907, 0.004277093801647425, 0.0740349069237709, -0.014245674014091492, 0.028711022809147835, 0.00830682273954153, 0.007230590563267469, -0.009212429635226727, -0.013054432347416878, 0.01592574082314968, -0.04377056658267975, 0.01622915081679821, -0.04522358253598213, -0.012292057275772095, -0.04469287395477295, -0.04529149457812309, -0.05215086042881012, -0.007837047800421715, -0.02999996580183506, -0.00488493125885725, -0.034501370042562485, 0.0018703066743910313, -0.022878235206007957, -0.02133338712155819, -0.03318654000759125, -0.0071060978807508945, 0.011212789453566074, 0.008347357623279095, -0.026504237204790115, -0.027493759989738464, 0.03367002680897713, -0.02676466479897499, -0.02040831372141838, -0.019632523879408836, 0.03332144767045975, -0.0014856362249702215, 0.04087207466363907, -0.005925256293267012, -0.004956436343491077, -0.004448994528502226, 0.07101696729660034, -0.03756552189588547, 0.020404275506734848, 0.040045056492090225, -0.060904502868652344, -0.022371530532836914, 0.014047213830053806, -0.027997761964797974, -0.006434044800698757, 0.0002281978086102754, -0.026060180738568306, 0.014760656282305717, 0.050758831202983856, -0.001717526582069695, 0.016251277178525925, -0.015374655835330486, 0.029847608879208565, 0.008152179419994354, 0.004657263867557049, 0.016768431290984154, -0.015298048034310341, -0.002727931598201394, 0.00207860697992146, 0.013618680648505688, -0.019786719232797623, -0.019579516723752022, -0.010372649878263474, -0.014833838678896427, -0.003961896523833275, 0.0007596195209771395, 0.02320042811334133, 0.06078627333045006, 0.010174746625125408, -0.01642090082168579, 0.03967289254069328, 0.004247987177222967, 0.0048188320361077785, -0.09845056384801865, -0.03671561926603317, -0.007289641536772251, 0.029746145009994507, 0.022049857303500175, -0.0479080006480217, 0.034571323543787, -0.002565154107287526, -0.04288036376237869, 0.02430265210568905, -0.013431469909846783, 0.0007655764347873628, -0.05473609268665314, -0.0029985264409333467, -0.024549363180994987, -0.029146363958716393, 0.027873653918504715, -0.006657601799815893, 0.04137735441327095, -0.015083764679729939, -0.038821373134851456, -0.0068095070309937, -0.0014382803346961737, 0.035981107503175735, -0.025775963440537453, -0.045473143458366394, 0.017395779490470886, -0.0102235097438097, -0.04935736581683159, -0.0014517693780362606, -0.00323879299685359, 0.01597600430250168, 0.040380362421274185, 0.04903292655944824, 0.032765842974185944, 0.06537844240665436, 0.06326918303966522, -0.007340553682297468, -0.03154386952519417, -0.007682170253247023, 0.003309815190732479, 0.010636623948812485, -0.01990630477666855, 0.0180031880736351, 0.012846463359892368, -0.0036996675189584494, -0.03353118523955345, -0.006316663697361946, -0.050428010523319244, -0.04458417370915413, -0.0073768668808043, 0.019635971635580063, -0.017457390204072, -0.0469755083322525, 0.05270567163825035, -0.0037425763439387083, -0.027600346133112907, -0.0010907109826803207, 0.0502292700111866, 0.005525817628949881, -0.02467864379286766, -0.002639112528413534, -0.05050361901521683, -0.01536235585808754, 0.037780389189720154, -0.043558716773986816, -0.0467098169028759, -0.0034162732772529125, 0.010347146540880203, -0.03148827329277992, -0.030394751578569412, -0.008082699030637741, -0.019275682047009468, 0.06818746775388718, -0.026532050222158432, 0.04038359969854355, 0.03119412623345852, 0.014354418031871319, 0.031071819365024567, -0.06274345517158508, 0.041111093014478683, 0.01865117996931076, 0.019763236865401268, -0.026860862970352173, 0.0010545115219429135, -0.012760295532643795, 0.002622817875817418, 0.07287674397230148, -0.020101921632885933, -0.03199189901351929, -0.023872794583439827, -0.008234632201492786, 0.02234647609293461, -0.023848313838243484, 0.0544414147734642, -0.023450084030628204, -0.06870318949222565, -0.027918491512537003, 0.006832098122686148, 0.026950016617774963, 0.021622145548462868, 0.004703592974692583, 0.015577747486531734, -0.025882704183459282, -0.004163403995335102, -0.033997707068920135, 0.026501620188355446, 0.00943569652736187, 0.03779717534780502, 0.06390656530857086, -0.0016198097728192806, -0.0019530965946614742, 0.0006493969704024494, 0.0018169224495068192, -0.025928644463419914, 0.037077002227306366, -0.009153825230896473, -0.03943297266960144, -0.01699405163526535, 0.012921832501888275, 0.010663144290447235, -0.006704169791191816, -0.012031606398522854, 0.07315417379140854, -0.03931679576635361, -0.0033526758197695017, 0.03222557157278061, 0.022490644827485085, 0.06262423098087311, -0.005253845825791359, 0.020441940054297447, 0.015940792858600616, -0.022707752883434296, -0.016969971358776093, 0.006004909984767437, 0.00669510243460536, 0.007136138621717691, 0.015384792350232601, 0.015989383682608604, -0.035882335156202316, 0.0018451010109856725, -0.02691194787621498, 0.06779128313064575, -0.06405661255121231, -0.02187751606106758, -0.010746807791292667, 0.005012966226786375, -0.00292764394544065, -0.03164238482713699, -0.048858895897865295, 0.051452770829200745, -0.045234404504299164, -0.010548548772931099, -0.05509933829307556, -0.025545494630932808, 0.001441112020984292, 0.03224606066942215, -0.00025010723038576543, 0.04795048013329506, 0.019294796511530876, 0.028734829276800156, 0.0037644230760633945, 0.016837505623698235, 0.07119481265544891, -0.02200659178197384, 0.05186251178383827, -0.02408832684159279, 0.013030881062150002, 0.011454528197646141, 0.03421411290764809, -0.03254273906350136, -0.03315984830260277, 0.016102690249681473, 0.040398430079221725, 0.031155766919255257, -0.022927377372980118, -0.04921029508113861, 0.031493112444877625, 0.02431163750588894, -0.06335659325122833, -0.030948903411626816, -0.039829790592193604, 0.009280595928430557, -0.02079791948199272, 0.012286681681871414 ]
<p>Suppose I am doing random forest classification of labels $A$,$B$,$C$,$D$. There is some theoretical ordering to this output such that when $A$ is more likely than $B$, $B$ is also more likely than $C$, etc. Also, if $P(D) &gt; P(C)$, we also have that $P(C) &gt; P(B) &gt; P(A)$. There are other such conditions that need to be met.</p> <p>The issue is that a real random forest may give something silly that completely violates the above constraints, <em>even if</em> it is able to predict the most likely outcome successfully. For my use case the ordering is important since decisions are made not only on the most likely outcome.</p> <p>It also seems intuitive that I should be able to improve generalization if I can somehow enforce this prior knowledge into the model. </p> <p>How do I account for this in a decision forest? Despite this structure to the output I do not think it is possible to construct a real-valued response variable since they are <em>still class labels</em> with no natural real value, even if there is some type of ordering to them.</p>
73,640
[ -0.020025942474603653, -0.028360482305288315, 0.0012947206851094961, -0.010963279753923416, 0.017133979126811028, 0.049705587327480316, -0.024307401850819588, 0.013145332224667072, 0.033047866076231, -0.03367840126156807, 0.03275280445814133, 0.003756687743589282, 0.028998687863349915, 0.02354719489812851, 0.00874374806880951, 0.01289057731628418, 0.00015531029202975333, -0.004205287899821997, -0.009132946841418743, -0.004754979163408279, -0.023938221856951714, 0.05621066316962242, 0.040310997515916824, -0.00810130126774311, -0.0017359963385388255, 0.033430084586143494, 0.02607305534183979, 0.043390579521656036, 0.002512350445613265, 0.05689710006117821, -0.023971281945705414, 0.0006319071399047971, -0.005194030236452818, 0.05935081094503403, 0.02944166399538517, 0.007686627563089132, -0.019291866570711136, 0.0024005030281841755, -0.024502353742718697, -0.009285788983106613, -0.016684826463460922, -0.005370707251131535, 0.011220416985452175, 0.07386129349470139, -0.0023081882391124964, 0.039608437567949295, -0.017244694754481316, -0.030463965609669685, 0.031407132744789124, -0.06650948524475098, 0.07582887262105942, -0.020690400153398514, 0.04746659845113754, 0.07502619177103043, -0.023286664858460426, -0.04207200929522514, 0.07063745707273483, 0.09630715847015381, -0.011066505685448647, -0.04903985187411308, -0.0367230586707592, -0.043390221893787384, 0.022793106734752655, 0.004585611168295145, -0.0418674498796463, 0.03564869984984398, 0.011464249342679977, 0.014441551640629768, -0.0017205055337399244, -0.006937647238373756, 0.018778977915644646, 0.0025869635865092278, 0.022631565108895302, 0.03105643391609192, 0.03591719642281532, 0.0019854335114359856, 0.012143137864768505, 0.027901358902454376, 0.05549243092536926, 0.0005599710857495666, -0.0021982681937515736, 0.010077271610498428, -0.007919327355921268, 0.03935515880584717, -0.005447786301374435, -0.008648647926747799, 0.04327366501092911, -0.015243728645145893, 0.03845524787902832, -0.005798943806439638, -0.016927536576986313, -0.006475575268268585, 0.0642133504152298, -0.04214351251721382, -0.05417410656809807, 0.00021884232410229743, -0.011529709212481976, 0.01655283197760582, -0.00908032339066267, -0.013455215841531754, -0.01304507814347744, -0.03346572816371918, 0.0038132984191179276, 0.03774842992424965, -0.04653619974851608, -0.026529083028435707, -0.05397326871752739, 0.01531955599784851, 0.0036093760281801224, -0.02056477591395378, -0.013533973135054111, 0.04233464226126671, 0.005352121312171221, 0.009472707286477089, 0.032410115003585815, -0.05401601269841194, -0.027806224301457405, -0.03242924436926842, 0.03080781176686287, 0.0460498109459877, 0.06824379414319992, -0.027634644880890846, 0.044378552585840225, 0.008448350243270397, -0.057697851210832596, -0.012527490966022015, 0.03547481447458267, 0.00807022862136364, -0.04084737226366997, 0.0056128064170479774, -0.0030765063129365444, -0.021606871858239174, 0.051730927079916, -0.021328497678041458, 0.003304390935227275, -0.018389275297522545, -0.10416468977928162, -0.02858664095401764, 0.02096704952418804, 0.0025321636348962784, 0.010512104257941246, -0.07091046124696732, 0.003084035124629736, 0.039065368473529816, 0.043025385588407516, -0.005971948616206646, 0.024278588593006134, 0.03069811500608921, 0.036973048001527786, 0.012670802883803844, -0.007416789885610342, 0.0038356862496584654, -0.0002629228984005749, -0.0100346514955163, -0.05616425350308418, -0.0417054183781147, 0.01592572033405304, 0.015305833891034126, 0.005451871082186699, -0.006820421200245619, 0.04834688827395439, -0.04277614504098892, -0.007520084269344807, 0.014119327999651432, -0.00016939615306910127, 0.018817748874425888, 0.0568835623562336, 0.011679229326546192, 0.05334004387259483, 0.0189230777323246, 0.015085731633007526, 0.018611544743180275, 0.048131830990314484, 0.0525750033557415, 0.04788210615515709, -0.024238955229520798, -0.03862562030553818, -0.02748708985745907, 0.04075213149189949, -0.020522063598036766, -0.009743421338498592, -0.017403563484549522, -0.04171718284487724, 0.003926409408450127, -0.006603737827390432, -0.0006217165500856936, -0.028813686221837997, -0.0077616679482162, 0.06411214917898178, -0.06521410495042801, -0.0475582592189312, -0.0656997486948967, 0.011235900223255157, 0.0107831209897995, -0.010693798772990704, 0.040584441274404526, -0.0038753910921514034, 0.012816025875508785, 0.004646124318242073, -0.0017449241131544113, -0.042483340948820114, 0.003491893643513322, 0.04076780006289482, -0.02898900955915451, 0.009336218237876892, 0.03543046861886978, 0.010709754191339016, -0.00013056001625955105, 0.0350356288254261, -0.01566273532807827, -0.08943171799182892, 0.01168888434767723, -0.03819430246949196, 0.0017927733715623617, -0.04233222454786301, -0.008020933717489243, 0.013744506053626537, -0.023855824023485184, -0.020634692162275314, 0.017043644562363625, -0.038053207099437714, 0.0624522902071476, 0.09310327470302582, 0.011797362938523293, 0.0019871334079653025, 0.043421242386102676, -0.006409334484487772, -0.019951872527599335, -0.02297797240316868, -0.027700992301106453, -0.0441911481320858, -0.03593006357550621, 0.03892866522073746, 0.052279699593782425, -0.03402526676654816, 0.030766138806939125, 0.01974824257194996, 0.04757102578878403, 0.04565651714801788, 0.06541194766759872, -0.011788898147642612, 0.0070609888061881065, 0.026953713968396187, 0.02500852383673191, 0.010737285949289799, -0.007334443740546703, 0.020781926810741425, -0.01946546509861946, 0.015844887122511864, -0.019615206867456436, -0.011239025741815567, 0.01154264621436596, -0.00029230964719317853, 0.008860597386956215, 0.008003845810890198, -0.022359199821949005, 0.0059219603426754475, -0.03755558282136917, 0.024870160967111588, 0.04332786425948143, 0.024972086772322655, -0.030088551342487335, -0.007156850770115852, -0.018152043223381042, 0.041181374341249466, 0.03908639773726463, -0.05808883532881737, -0.00047124928096309304, 0.027697276324033737, -0.03355708718299866, 0.021603042259812355, -0.012458872981369495, -0.05370653048157692, -0.048036497086286545, 0.03806323558092117, 0.036794476211071014, 0.0036961380392313004, 0.03360562399029732, 0.009128986857831478, -0.008632645010948181, -0.002119444077834487, -0.040375806391239166, 0.017335854470729828, 0.0345953032374382, -0.022077925503253937, 0.003113481216132641, -0.013220567256212234, -0.038609109818935394, 0.021955538541078568, 0.003444288158789277, -0.04403053596615791, -0.005642515141516924, -0.021885288879275322, -0.04451337829232216, -0.01397752109915018, -0.04935446381568909, 0.031291063874959946, -0.011203396134078503, -0.016948159784078598, 0.013500620611011982, -0.01632341742515564, -0.04604382812976837, 0.012701455503702164, 0.011343703605234623, -0.003972948528826237, 0.004185143392533064, -0.034649983048439026, -0.012178248725831509, -0.005680385045707226, 0.03260209038853645, 0.017981352284550667, -0.04784959554672241, 0.0005863909027539194, -0.06099969148635864, -0.07356579601764679, 0.0333518423140049, -0.0039075142703950405, 0.02791335992515087, 0.012456092052161694, 0.0022056696470826864, 0.08092736452817917, 0.030747920274734497, -0.025696123018860817, -0.012556787580251694, -0.01807154342532158, 0.007209464907646179, -0.01386774517595768, -0.029773052781820297, 0.027660250663757324, 0.0051548173651099205, 0.058914750814437866, 0.026842428371310234, 0.04649791121482849, -0.00030232282006181777, -0.028315233066678047, -0.044189974665641785, 0.05115596950054169, 0.034086354076862335, 0.009819895960390568, -0.0008264532661996782, 0.01987910270690918, 0.013940155506134033, 0.04556134715676308, 0.0009044150356203318, -0.00983585137873888, 0.010474912822246552, -0.04311732202768326, 0.005138054955750704, -0.03380607068538666, 0.05743558332324028, -0.03452903777360916, 0.02311139926314354, 0.004562790971249342, -0.04921276122331619, -0.02136288769543171, 0.011980225332081318, 0.050328683108091354, -0.04226922616362572, 0.013972831889986992, 0.06717909127473831, 0.03432920202612877, 0.010620036162436008, 0.0073458910919725895, -0.019262967631220818, -0.011897359974682331, 0.03937570005655289, 0.005863595753908157, 0.015117370523512363, 0.034045055508613586, 0.025795092806220055, 0.012983264401555061, -0.0120009146630764, -0.03581729158759117, 0.013320120051503181, -0.019265199080109596, -0.01562393270432949, -0.03399743139743805, 0.04339231923222542, 0.03081292286515236, 0.02732342854142189, 0.005395233165472746, -0.024579182267189026, 0.0024093736428767443, 0.02699252963066101, -0.054545264691114426, 0.004430606961250305, -0.007376810070127249, 0.008181773126125336, -0.013606819324195385, -0.029971808195114136, 0.022939326241612434, -0.05694908648729324, 0.005122171714901924, -0.01270628534257412, 0.016565006226301193, -0.024096161127090454, -0.024828406050801277, -0.00897577591240406, -0.02356116846203804, -0.007317308336496353, -0.010887755081057549, 0.011627830564975739, -0.0346829779446125, 0.037082646042108536, 0.038641542196273804, -0.03791380301117897, -0.0018044313183054328, -0.03796769306063652, 0.003980591893196106, 0.023257557302713394, 0.04796598479151726, 0.024339668452739716, -0.010953591205179691, -0.01977185159921646, 0.0036890418268740177, -0.01502100471407175, 0.05856841802597046, 0.03109792061150074, -0.011215760372579098, -0.017241736873984337, -0.028527824208140373, -0.02270255610346794, 0.0029182005673646927, 0.035348232835531235, 0.009962938725948334, 0.006694670766592026, 0.04146374389529228, 0.00046744872815907, -0.05549175664782524, 0.001980290748178959, 0.047375090420246124, -0.02689962089061737, -0.020428644493222237, -0.013336608186364174, 0.003177263308316469, -0.007840900681912899, -0.008208828046917915, 0.037269651889801025, 0.004963332321494818, -0.0062936278991401196, -0.009595246985554695, 0.04713967815041542, -0.03285997733473778, -0.03962985426187515, -0.015989532694220543, -0.0015415647067129612, 0.038770537823438644, 0.029971932992339134, -0.02112453244626522, 0.0182618610560894, 0.02902371622622013, 0.020027566701173782, 0.028118975460529327, 0.02303859405219555, -0.08096789568662643, -0.003517253091558814, 0.040575284510850906, 0.027070924639701843, -0.031149297952651978, -0.014057439751923084, -0.056304026395082474, -0.02017311193048954, 0.024945370852947235, -0.02446603588759899, 0.007561876438558102, -0.0343007817864418, 0.013432431034743786, -0.012697882950305939, -0.0419640950858593, -0.03400246053934097, 0.01829114556312561, -0.017653806135058403, 0.04278646409511566, 0.010417484678328037, -0.02263817749917507, -0.06807053089141846, -0.003378107910975814, 0.016842849552631378, 0.03639135882258415, -0.025128472596406937, -0.02441677264869213, 0.005137940403074026, -0.0024130528327077627, -0.0036443048156797886, -0.07513826340436935, 0.040564484894275665, 0.020043011754751205, 0.023001467809081078, 0.05160663649439812, -0.0006399204139597714, -0.03535361960530281, -0.0037682033143937588, 0.0007793559925630689, -0.03570900484919548, 0.005769762676209211, 0.043849583715200424, 0.06574973464012146, 0.024836253374814987, 0.0228255707770586, 0.011968369595706463, 0.040225379168987274, 0.04992799088358879, -0.0032764135394245386, -0.002759256400167942, 0.03242332860827446, -0.05005822703242302, 0.007312292233109474, -0.06397957354784012, -0.010496838949620724, -0.012120385654270649, 0.017716575413942337, -0.010151985101401806, 0.041253797709941864, -0.0023231056984514, -0.015673577785491943, -0.040656596422195435, 0.02808772213757038, -0.02076534926891327, -0.02120748534798622, -0.05507924407720566, 0.040652018040418625, -0.03489310294389725, 0.0207106601446867, 0.017861559987068176, -0.00031582004157826304, 0.015017406083643436, 0.009776162914931774, -0.04536660760641098, 0.0434388630092144, -0.026914795860648155, -0.02381938509643078, -0.004366863053292036, -0.041770655661821365, 0.03376573696732521, 0.016736209392547607, -0.002770210150629282, -0.03529371693730354, -0.03374217450618744, -0.015923719853162766, 0.02282106876373291, -0.011610823683440685, 0.02441084012389183, -0.055856335908174515, -0.01272539235651493, -0.013357637450098991, -0.00012299018271733075, -0.0703885480761528, -0.02339373342692852, 0.0029907228890806437, -0.007622191682457924, -0.02835199050605297, -0.04212222248315811, 0.023444315418601036, 0.0015097267460078, -0.015164719894528389, -0.011666321195662022, 0.06374838203191757, -0.021450938656926155, -0.021991698071360588, -0.027270253747701645, 0.003657375695183873, 0.06960781663656235, -0.027427658438682556, 0.006410299334675074, 0.038022685796022415, -0.022446809336543083, -0.002606135793030262, 0.011323909275233746, 0.01029765885323286, -0.03373681381344795, 0.017978044226765633, -0.039612285792827606, 0.03896136209368706, 0.03850299492478371, 0.03136756271123886, 0.013940217904746532, -0.003929422702640295, -0.004739741329103708, 0.0062528811395168304, -0.03990863636136055, -0.010244306176900864, -0.006810714025050402, -0.007803972810506821, -0.02183498628437519, 0.02289162017405033, -0.001412792014889419, -0.029625598341226578, 0.012197091244161129, -0.014088855125010014, 0.013078417629003525, 0.012606006115674973, 0.04977119714021683, -0.025360535830259323, 0.03280017897486687, -0.007261289749294519, -0.049096424132585526, 0.029856234788894653, 0.02534271590411663, 0.02577505074441433, 0.005967851262539625, 0.019407937303185463, -0.06383281201124191, -0.009782623499631882, -0.043773118406534195, -0.02596043050289154, 0.07776482403278351, 0.0021255440078675747, 0.08190809935331345, 0.013495628722012043, -0.00031198534998111427, -0.0010232768254354596, -0.014293254353106022, 0.015407956205308437, 0.005522291641682386, 0.011562640778720379, 0.05052805691957474, 0.004264472518116236, 0.04563423991203308, 0.030480435118079185, 0.00914582796394825, 0.03769124671816826, 0.03396812453866005, 0.020481310784816742, 0.02561105787754059, 0.04468131437897682, -0.0443495474755764, -0.04105525463819504, 0.029464920982718468, -0.05494863539934158, -0.0093587851151824, 0.008417047560214996, -0.030010990798473358, 0.052095524966716766, 0.004286052193492651, -0.02612997591495514, -0.03830442577600479, -0.04253460839390755, -0.06196855008602142, 0.02595302276313305, -0.0021946679335087538, -0.008332922123372555, 0.03849927335977554, -0.04523427411913872, -0.008416580967605114, -0.014052746817469597, 0.02696172706782818, -0.016890205442905426, -0.07215415686368942, -0.06451442837715149, -0.027078334242105484, -0.01932109147310257, 0.019461896270513535, 0.022175876423716545, -0.02713882178068161, 0.014058910310268402, -0.029827574267983437, 0.026136614382267, 0.021541567519307137, 0.034445952624082565, -0.013993432745337486, 0.04141273349523544, 0.03630051761865616, 0.010890594683587551, 0.016871459782123566, -0.03631756827235222, 0.11635428667068481, 0.07502720504999161, 0.05133331939578056, -0.06380417197942734, 0.030858783051371574, 0.008578363806009293, 0.0026606146711856127, -0.03189042955636978, 0.02182253822684288, 0.014025149866938591, 0.001310884254053235, 0.02015618234872818, -0.00545149203389883, 0.02171844244003296, -0.0119478739798069, 0.06600207090377808, -0.05348984897136688, -0.024324551224708557, 0.014927185140550137, 0.03232380747795105, 0.03470286354422569, -0.01904074102640152, -0.039392925798892975, -0.0032685555052012205, 0.012401876971125603, -0.007738510146737099, -0.011578268371522427, 0.0012258903589099646, 0.011302679777145386, -0.0048606786876916885, 0.013254650868475437, -0.017069736495614052, 0.028471246361732483, 0.03549356386065483, 0.0004291958757676184, 0.005919232033193111, 0.0006977865705266595, -0.006007429212331772, -0.0032293780241161585, -0.0033285743556916714, 0.005095342174172401, 0.003106881631538272, 0.0010035205632448196, 0.009740864858031273, -0.07757752388715744, -0.01888265646994114, -0.016093216836452484, 0.014608511701226234, -0.010494895279407501, -0.02842574380338192, -0.024983977898955345, -0.010570847429335117, 0.0028815174009650946, -0.0404064767062664, -0.021527737379074097, 0.03425198793411255, 0.043524786829948425, 0.0009917241986840963, -0.04440397769212723, 0.02096419222652912, 0.04179276525974274, -0.02589563839137554, 0.014759436249732971, -0.007072940934449434, -0.047081150114536285, -0.020362861454486847, -0.03638127073645592, 0.048423659056425095, 0.023569708690047264, -0.011371282860636711, 0.009136469103395939, -0.0019559229258447886, -0.01322751771658659, -0.015033664181828499, 0.015764892101287842, 0.0032044253312051296, 0.04171164333820343, -0.020901354029774666, 0.009682096540927887, -0.05254174768924713, -0.010995803400874138, -0.010981528088450432, -0.060997482389211655, -0.0007675089873373508, -0.06736064702272415, -0.014267586171627045, 0.017279088497161865, 0.060131825506687164, 0.03539355471730232, 0.021204397082328796, -0.007522189524024725, 0.02177749201655388, -0.003703107824549079, -0.034445587545633316, -0.0104856938123703, -0.01326495036482811, -0.05475585162639618, 0.0143518578261137, 0.04524810239672661, 0.0641738772392273, 0.052300889045000076, 0.037189025431871414, -0.02404600940644741, 0.03619438782334328, -0.01843404397368431, 0.03577766567468643, 0.04159034416079521, -0.04943542927503586, 0.01035456731915474, -0.003252487163990736, 0.014472411945462227, -0.032199401408433914, -0.045452434569597244, 0.00012519244046416134, -0.0331340953707695, -0.006355449557304382, -0.011466996744275093, 0.01140088401734829, -0.03418970853090286, 0.0036620665341615677, 0.01569535955786705, -0.027988789603114128, -0.028837570920586586, -0.04595344886183739, 0.01158940326422453, -0.028406398370862007, -0.0731167122721672, -0.03459257632493973, 0.0033461961429566145, 0.02098078839480877, -0.014028884470462799, 0.009369593113660812, 0.004725376609712839, -0.0013016975717619061, 0.012213981710374355, -0.013343509286642075, -0.004207535646855831, 0.047105249017477036, -0.03747096285223961, -0.03697754442691803, 0.005369482096284628, -0.049769703298807144, -0.014175477437675, 0.026697440072894096, -0.00123875611461699, 0.04250643029808998, 0.007068677805364132, 0.011399876326322556, -0.029527859762310982, 0.05215047672390938, 0.014625770039856434, -0.017492763698101044, 0.015847453847527504, 0.014531764201819897, 0.0035412616562098265, -0.005706252995878458, -0.007666199933737516, -0.034080129116773605, 0.006607980001717806, 0.011419730260968208, 0.03011235035955906, 0.04490970820188522, -0.012506772764027119, 0.04484393447637558, -0.013510686345398426, 0.03491568937897682, 0.009558972902595997, 0.011884979903697968, 0.018766462802886963, 0.010794325731694698, -0.015291606076061726, 0.04575682058930397, 0.010500285774469376, 0.02526846155524254, -0.0820518359541893, -0.004924017935991287, 0.035137027502059937, 0.007539134472608566, 0.024433283135294914, -0.05002524331212044, 0.02039581723511219, -0.0066138096153736115, -0.04208142310380936, 0.015155943110585213, -0.013138430193066597, -0.0271310918033123, -0.044120904058218, 0.001994926715269685, -0.0521625280380249, 0.014163644053041935, 0.03707364946603775, 0.043664220720529556, 0.02736591175198555, -0.011335602961480618, -0.012260984629392624, -0.032207608222961426, 0.011749232187867165, 0.029554473236203194, -0.005141908302903175, -0.07181417942047119, 0.056537337601184845, -0.028465569019317627, -0.0358850434422493, 0.01988592930138111, 0.012110495008528233, 0.009465903043746948, 0.05574336275458336, 0.057288460433483124, 0.021722013130784035, 0.04166177660226822, 0.03429079428315163, -0.029034819453954697, -0.042882684618234634, -0.0013307406334206462, 0.01262835692614317, -0.005570847075432539, -0.0006080347229726613, 0.027302458882331848, 0.01115381345152855, -0.012753605842590332, -0.012139244005084038, 0.0257734265178442, -0.01731107383966446, -0.04849410802125931, -0.024644188582897186, -0.0033707248512655497, -0.0033643473871052265, -0.021474745124578476, -0.009163831360638142, -0.04061543196439743, 0.018050990998744965, 0.06232083961367607, 0.01113063469529152, -0.006687505636364222, 0.005896123591810465, -0.03598994016647339, -0.06418100744485855, -0.0022870630491524935, 0.004634791519492865, 0.008085796609520912, -0.0834222286939621, 0.0067908582277596, -0.006315668113529682, -0.044205911457538605, -0.027428915724158287, -0.008801952004432678, -0.022058112546801567, 0.039477959275245667, 0.001250550034455955, 0.015028277412056923, 0.019868865609169006, -0.036128077656030655, -0.005762543063610792, -0.09515664726495743, 0.07851056754589081, 0.032648973166942596, -0.0038729803636670113, -0.0038693579845130444, 0.035014186054468155, -0.025410551577806473, 0.018684834241867065, 0.04400833323597908, 0.019984757527709007, -0.014522767625749111, -0.01788964681327343, 0.04168005287647247, 0.019445108249783516, -0.05432695522904396, 0.01944831572473049, -0.009243900887668133, -0.005112123675644398, -0.04921453073620796, -0.027700893580913544, 0.01641928032040596, 0.011568871326744556, -0.004989955108612776, 0.015298069454729557, -0.0218679029494524, 0.015346862375736237, 0.009387527592480183, 0.049648985266685486, -0.027650795876979828, 0.029417434707283974, 0.04026900604367256, -0.017299160361289978, -0.000571900571230799, -0.0028874522540718317, -0.008135303854942322, -0.025686340406537056, 0.047156982123851776, -0.013038444332778454, -0.05324341729283333, 0.003285920713096857, 0.033818043768405914, 0.006261182948946953, -0.07134107500314713, -0.016645051538944244, 0.037908632308244705, -0.04162677004933357, 0.012740403413772583, 0.03526127338409424, 0.0146930618211627, 0.05888361483812332, 0.022309185937047005, 0.005802744068205357, 0.00028168721473775804, -0.029222816228866577, 0.0267062745988369, 0.006022443063557148, 0.020839998498558998, -0.0017672597896307707, 0.03770304098725319, 0.013983533717691898, -0.05147485062479973, 0.0151309659704566, -0.019945986568927765, 0.04606557637453079, -0.026849405840039253, -0.0021660970523953438, 0.027283282950520515, 0.0014273878186941147, 0.04162997379899025, -0.0027254093438386917, 0.03150973841547966, 0.03759435936808586, -0.014668691903352737, 0.0028535337187349796, -0.05865499749779701, -0.013043529354035854, -0.009224683046340942, -0.007942100055515766, 0.0026549575850367546, 0.019358262419700623, -0.0024441678542643785, 0.022518450394272804, 0.0030754695180803537, -0.010176076553761959, 0.024779407307505608, -0.01939578354358673, 0.02012205682694912, 0.002567184390500188, -0.04043550416827202, 0.02084360085427761, -0.05055497959256172, -0.03606817498803139, -0.02834855578839779, 0.036817505955696106, 0.042442720383405685, 0.04413425922393799, 0.0032375971786677837, -0.03014957718551159, -0.009880364872515202, 0.0038987977895885706, -0.07351745665073395, -0.0028012406546622515, -0.05604963377118111, -0.0017405132530257106, -0.014265265315771103, -0.01821144111454487 ]
<p>I have two <em>finite</em> samples $s_1$ and $s_2$ and two distributions $p_1(s_1)$ and $p_2(s_2)$ that are associated to these samples. I'm essentially interested to measure the distance or similarity between these two distributions. I'm currently using the Jensen-Shannon (JS) distance, which involves in calculating the entropies of the two distributions separately and jointly. I need to bin the data for calculating the basic entropy functions and it looks like the resulted JS distance is also a function of the data binning strategy that I use. It sounds quite arbitrary and I don't know how much I can trust the results. Is there any way around this? How can I measure the distance between $p_1(s_1)$ and $p_2(s_2)$ in a more rigorous way that needs no data binning or any other sort of arbitrariness?</p>
73,641
[ -0.025328107178211212, -0.0004606872971635312, -0.06101153418421745, 0.01776108890771866, -0.001734913676045835, 0.033700671046972275, 0.009578647091984749, 0.01337403990328312, 0.02712390013039112, -0.02180524542927742, 0.05043431743979454, 0.034168895334005356, 0.03879304602742195, -0.01721907965838909, 0.009747655130922794, -0.019325044006109238, -0.03848281502723694, 0.01774923875927925, 0.02655220776796341, -0.033572129905223846, 0.0351225808262825, 0.028283046558499336, 0.031500767916440964, -0.011054394766688347, -0.055289529263973236, 0.05286238715052605, 0.004617587197571993, -0.030328940600156784, 0.010183660313487053, 0.08104004710912704, -0.04364170506596565, -0.04144713282585144, 0.015972577035427094, 0.05578552186489105, -0.015358401462435722, -0.05308801680803299, -0.07383131980895996, -0.02719915099442005, -0.007126084994524717, 0.028729131445288658, -0.11819099634885788, -0.0181380994617939, -0.023828834295272827, 0.018442191183567047, -0.022554736584424973, 0.004503997042775154, 0.013816284015774727, -0.0397179052233696, -0.01617005467414856, -0.024145042523741722, 0.05398920550942421, -0.0022690347395837307, 0.024480067193508148, 0.026650981977581978, -0.017909536138176918, 0.026406671851873398, 0.04739520698785782, 0.07169502228498459, -0.015024014748632908, -0.05359865725040436, -0.02847074531018734, -0.04555201530456543, -0.00220473762601614, -0.02796635776758194, -0.013332948088645935, 0.04230879247188568, -0.03327607735991478, -0.02498450316488743, -0.010373006574809551, -0.009639393538236618, 0.004839729517698288, 0.026588106527924538, 0.040716178715229034, -0.022220833227038383, 0.0310590248554945, -0.010908029973506927, 0.0376276932656765, 0.03253602236509323, 0.05846676602959633, 0.04330584779381752, -0.006524986587464809, 0.02731105498969555, 0.026698652654886246, 0.04585321247577667, 0.04102305695414543, -0.05281396582722664, 0.04365784674882889, -0.030379656702280045, -0.00027456157840788364, 0.048174843192100525, -0.002987299580127001, -0.024387001991271973, 0.04781002551317215, 0.00041847789543680847, -0.014662936329841614, 0.03691941499710083, -0.022575873881578445, 0.02763640321791172, -0.003804966574534774, -0.05529125779867172, -0.011641464196145535, -0.04343061521649361, 0.02254224754869938, 0.06706070154905319, -0.013600637204945087, -0.023681970313191414, -0.021790046244859695, 0.012335625477135181, 0.02027250826358795, 0.013186609372496605, -0.002458596369251609, 0.013346176594495773, 0.008157245814800262, -0.007253510411828756, 0.03495161980390549, -0.00591660663485527, 0.019040679559111595, -0.007714718580245972, 0.04891953244805336, 0.06495901942253113, 0.05758451670408249, -0.01487267017364502, -0.0027908312622457743, -0.020125670358538628, -0.0452093705534935, 0.01789073832333088, 0.026617562398314476, -0.03469514101743698, -0.03775584697723389, 0.047208528965711594, -0.037827856838703156, -0.019144287332892418, 0.02300221286714077, -0.03764254227280617, 0.008268941193819046, 0.0007248923648148775, -0.08731658011674881, -0.041209619492292404, 0.020766867324709892, -0.023030050098896027, 0.006813439074903727, -0.05680366978049278, 0.0042657372541725636, 0.024541130289435387, 0.04415683075785637, 0.02612374722957611, 0.05995927006006241, -0.024544956162571907, 0.0518542118370533, 0.041605520993471146, -0.013662143610417843, -0.008300929330289364, -0.030217742547392845, 0.0033159488812088966, -0.01236025895923376, -0.06127171590924263, 0.0443544015288353, 0.012927215546369553, -0.01670907437801361, -0.02753494679927826, 0.03420067951083183, 0.014490828849375248, -0.018969571217894554, -0.040602244436740875, 0.03274139016866684, -0.013917362317442894, 0.05577004328370094, -0.005141069181263447, 0.013454729691147804, 0.009159747511148453, -0.02717522718012333, -0.0002721600467339158, 0.049712371081113815, 0.03551548346877098, 0.021902726963162422, -0.012960557825863361, -0.0253393966704607, -0.015042450278997421, 0.002591947326436639, -0.0021998065058141947, 0.00974322110414505, -0.01150437816977501, -0.03251543641090393, -0.00171521061565727, 0.01978198252618313, 0.02763456106185913, 0.0091645997017622, -0.012537436559796333, 0.03644462302327156, -0.03342057019472122, -0.005164477974176407, -0.06324172019958496, -0.0024153583217412233, -0.01465566921979189, -0.021810272708535194, 0.0543704628944397, 0.019990934059023857, 0.021081972867250443, -0.0019729246851056814, -0.05864478275179863, -0.035904258489608765, -0.009297258220613003, 0.04291030019521713, -0.029490122571587563, -0.00981852039694786, 0.051382482051849365, 0.04931991547346115, -0.007514333352446556, 0.052521783858537674, -0.006691918708384037, -0.09395953267812729, 0.010222268290817738, -0.01614348776638508, 0.001193060539662838, -0.010577063076198101, 0.01638510264456272, 0.027209779247641563, 0.01035990659147501, -0.004532633814960718, -0.017414268106222153, -0.02840496599674225, 0.06787016242742538, 0.04027523845434189, 0.03716695308685303, -0.009035395458340645, 0.0033968554344028234, 0.026835670694708824, -0.017370032146573067, -0.008433985523879528, -0.0176077950745821, -0.05208531767129898, 0.007506305817514658, 0.055920280516147614, 0.05187124013900757, -0.04254801198840141, -0.007799036800861359, 0.03566572070121765, 0.01923796534538269, 0.0027926259208470583, -0.0025084547232836485, -0.01254410482943058, -0.027889946475625038, 0.022153515368700027, 0.020763447508215904, 0.015027763321995735, 0.02261522226035595, 0.015348435379564762, -0.007811605464667082, 0.048080943524837494, 0.0029743004124611616, -0.0168873630464077, 0.04247654601931572, 0.008178041316568851, -0.022808048874139786, -0.01071842759847641, -0.01167148258537054, 0.02268880233168602, -0.01635732315480709, -0.021581467241048813, 0.07076770067214966, -0.008748520165681839, 0.0022630109451711178, 0.01436961255967617, -0.026993868872523308, 0.026688789948821068, 0.019007956609129906, -0.027997367084026337, 0.040603820234537125, 0.0021939228754490614, -0.07343204319477081, 0.01087383832782507, -0.018794767558574677, -0.020609969273209572, -0.021865561604499817, 0.017962390556931496, 0.015060174278914928, -0.004585255868732929, -0.011861019767820835, 0.004892605356872082, -0.038181331008672714, 0.023632043972611427, -0.002439814852550626, 0.012622229754924774, -0.011998658068478107, -0.07198791205883026, 0.001312878681346774, -0.010875018313527107, 0.0024326862767338753, 0.00244433362968266, -0.004672563634812832, -0.0043717436492443085, -0.003472892800346017, -0.030157169327139854, -0.01695331744849682, 0.004930179566144943, 0.0038360932376235723, 0.03615010529756546, -0.03966956213116646, 0.0005897894152440131, 0.037769418209791183, -0.021020781248807907, -0.07209207117557526, 0.003351796418428421, -0.02716641314327717, -0.038114190101623535, -0.047341033816337585, -0.007964559830725193, -0.0052474308758974075, -0.024060871452093124, -0.0024039587005972862, 0.049455318599939346, 0.004262831527739763, -0.03298665210604668, -0.04085982218384743, -0.058607712388038635, 0.034444499760866165, 0.015587220899760723, 0.022685136646032333, 0.012376371771097183, -0.00592772476375103, 0.07697184383869171, 0.03603480011224747, 0.004320688080042601, -0.03304555267095566, -0.00583695899695158, -0.022098464891314507, 0.03242187201976776, -0.029697062447667122, -0.003919313661754131, 0.03215218707919121, 0.01031466480344534, 0.009857544675469398, 0.006227556150406599, 0.07153650373220444, -0.040379948914051056, -0.014329895377159119, 0.02749379724264145, 0.01865982450544834, -0.022926658391952515, 0.04871488735079765, 0.019983375445008278, -0.03311450034379959, 0.009751205332577229, 0.04672997444868088, 0.0017865293193608522, 0.01831662654876709, -0.029044058173894882, 0.021707503125071526, -0.007420232519507408, 0.009943274781107903, -0.03313923254609108, 0.024557407945394516, 0.006657736375927925, -0.036002740263938904, 0.020932184532284737, 0.037016693502664566, 0.01201662141829729, -0.017235083505511284, 0.02510521374642849, 0.034365832805633545, 0.018064551055431366, -0.023165402933955193, -0.029176680371165276, -0.029891449958086014, -0.008561159484088421, 0.0288600604981184, -0.011553147807717323, -0.039344895631074905, 0.0069952295161783695, 0.019365714862942696, 0.04626500979065895, -0.018597543239593506, -0.04447606950998306, -0.005405779927968979, -0.059007883071899414, -0.03494219854474068, -0.015385771170258522, 0.04958229139447212, -0.005153256934136152, 0.06341635435819626, 0.02144114300608635, -0.0008148049819283187, -0.005075201857835054, 0.005234129261225462, -0.051037706434726715, 0.03972604498267174, -0.021881354972720146, -0.02475951611995697, -0.012461281381547451, -0.005676648113876581, 0.020586613565683365, -0.027823077514767647, 0.02462678775191307, -0.020135587081313133, 0.01722080446779728, -0.0263814777135849, -0.010708755813539028, -0.022385291755199432, -0.018208662047982216, 0.02481718920171261, 0.039574526250362396, -0.010937472805380821, -0.025046303868293762, 0.024078482761979103, 0.030330142006278038, -0.006892133504152298, 0.010347389616072178, -0.03405698388814926, 0.035397469997406006, 0.01960955373942852, 0.019446993246674538, 0.03022250346839428, 0.040750134736299515, -0.002755153924226761, 0.007233756128698587, -0.0033437483943998814, 0.045658938586711884, 0.030529731884598732, -0.012247123755514622, -0.023924415931105614, -0.025642694905400276, -0.03751515969634056, -0.011169827543199062, 0.045048799365758896, -0.030895063653588295, 0.024100961163640022, 0.03960978612303734, 0.058465659618377686, -0.04771578311920166, -0.023322153836488724, 0.0672932118177414, 0.020063672214746475, -0.012814563699066639, -0.0077123637311160564, -0.026372892782092094, -0.012952575460076332, -0.017587997019290924, 0.014410545118153095, 0.01917317323386669, 0.01506958156824112, -0.01571187563240528, 0.01929875649511814, -0.015529417432844639, -0.02515311911702156, -0.018716802820563316, 0.016802100464701653, 0.029330819845199585, -0.005372356623411179, 0.0039095524698495865, 0.021085383370518684, 0.04307293891906738, 0.04916873201727867, 0.014355763792991638, 0.0036125420592725277, -0.06705284863710403, 0.011125986464321613, 0.03717714548110962, 0.035109784454107285, -0.04437590390443802, 0.0014357402687892318, -0.012065603397786617, -0.025807667523622513, 0.03952965512871742, -0.01567232981324196, 0.054032545536756516, -0.01422804594039917, -0.01990405283868313, -0.005140891298651695, 0.0015912370290607214, -0.05014937371015549, 0.0301665011793375, 0.0152220968157053, -0.0010325360344722867, -0.021738646551966667, -0.03619986027479172, -0.05957725644111633, -0.008672002702951431, 0.008056011982262135, 0.06753519177436829, -0.04539846256375313, -0.008836387656629086, 0.024279210716485977, 0.013055507093667984, 0.024994472041726112, -0.08191588521003723, 0.03090795874595642, -0.0020877833012491465, -0.06425993144512177, 0.023489700630307198, -0.005580856930464506, -0.04084273800253868, 0.016312740743160248, -0.028973152860999107, -0.00965783093124628, 0.022917041555047035, 0.02458609640598297, 0.0450754277408123, 0.042901813983917236, 0.007609755732119083, 0.02074180170893669, 0.02539275772869587, 0.010924180038273335, -0.0035297400318086147, -0.026027649641036987, 0.047885000705718994, -0.05023706704378128, -0.020259100943803787, -0.030152559280395508, -0.006388940382748842, -0.03979767486453056, 0.03773975372314453, 0.004667746368795633, 0.02724381722509861, -0.014595639891922474, -0.02372615598142147, -0.02146274968981743, 0.04030735418200493, -0.01810007356107235, 0.007548854220658541, -0.008725235238671303, 0.02350277453660965, -0.006792375817894936, -0.006120753008872271, 0.014705436304211617, -0.011866671964526176, 0.005066717974841595, 0.0009086651261895895, -0.06564661860466003, 0.03108629398047924, -0.07487225532531738, -0.02101890742778778, 0.010508505627512932, -0.0013317834818735719, 0.04970287159085274, -0.007486545015126467, 0.02157224528491497, 0.018361354246735573, -0.043115537613630295, -0.0046310508623719215, 0.012587526813149452, 0.01767953857779503, 0.034111056476831436, -0.03713501989841461, 0.014227369800209999, -0.003261951031163335, -0.022831831127405167, -0.09660825878381729, -0.03215096890926361, 0.01656155474483967, 0.03894011303782463, -0.018809668719768524, -0.0927402526140213, 0.009101158007979393, 0.013704720884561539, -0.015603280626237392, -0.027188731357455254, 0.029975615441799164, -0.004898272454738617, -0.026113390922546387, -0.003640990937128663, -0.017060764133930206, 0.08751548081636429, -0.01715625263750553, 0.012094397097826004, 0.0010632519843056798, 0.013766909018158913, -0.005639318376779556, 0.03394307196140289, 0.004592240322381258, -0.01250289287418127, 0.0022806692868471146, -0.02602980099618435, 0.0043312436901032925, 0.035321541130542755, -0.0667802095413208, -0.025776246562600136, -0.01640968583524227, -0.012535370886325836, 0.024013720452785492, 0.0013450052356347442, -0.01934410072863102, -0.01041586697101593, 0.009094689972698689, -0.09103532880544662, -0.011453875340521336, 0.019595688208937645, -0.03120231442153454, 0.022805601358413696, -0.001589223393239081, -0.0034047430381178856, 0.0015318228397518396, 0.056454166769981384, -0.02046443521976471, -0.008565268479287624, 0.012426801957190037, -0.005297617521136999, 0.030662918463349342, 0.0005781172658316791, -0.0009540364844724536, 0.0361337810754776, 0.029500799253582954, -0.013234976679086685, -0.00343916448764503, -0.04632939025759697, -0.024291833862662315, 0.06960123032331467, -0.01704992912709713, 0.057976942509412766, 0.0377916619181633, -0.009063218720257282, 0.008701683953404427, -0.017665784806013107, 0.0009119148016907275, 0.04444801062345505, 0.01525136735290289, 0.051380325108766556, 0.01753014512360096, -0.02144322544336319, 0.01747800223529339, 0.009743732400238514, -0.02211667411029339, 0.03224429860711098, -0.010754181072115898, 0.028206689283251762, 0.06293713301420212, -0.030850738286972046, -0.023507539182901382, 0.04125494882464409, -0.04788077995181084, 0.011079401709139347, -0.028028417378664017, -0.016140667721629143, 0.05420568212866783, 0.016731008887290955, 0.004094341769814491, -0.03414652496576309, -0.05873952433466911, -0.03702278435230255, 0.0321434810757637, 0.04720549285411835, 0.006406046915799379, 0.06271155178546906, 0.0009625693201087415, -0.0026818537153303623, -0.017839010804891586, 0.004621459636837244, 0.013588772155344486, -0.03700163587927818, -0.01629169099032879, -0.056533169001340866, -0.06726272404193878, 0.03356073051691055, -0.0036661310587078333, -0.038438934832811356, 0.0200228001922369, -0.01567184552550316, 0.044194869697093964, 0.004042027052491903, 0.021316612139344215, -0.023916836827993393, 0.10324357450008392, -0.008303063921630383, 0.03343934938311577, -0.009173191152513027, -0.03967278450727463, 0.09524790197610855, 0.023461468517780304, 0.04727520793676376, -0.07315115630626678, 0.024989081546664238, 0.009615857154130936, -0.018991272896528244, -0.026276368647813797, 0.04981120675802231, 0.02955232933163643, 0.007953804917633533, 0.025607755407691002, 0.04164143651723862, 0.0008636109414510429, -0.02910597063601017, 0.055813632905483246, -0.009179689921438694, 0.02976592257618904, 0.025025643408298492, 0.027449216693639755, 0.001122285146266222, -0.03641146048903465, -0.04178030043840408, 0.011107983067631721, 0.031002763658761978, 0.002089760033413768, -0.04153081402182579, -0.04753939062356949, 0.010384145192801952, 0.0010366988135501742, -0.02416842058300972, -0.0009260797523893416, 0.042196616530418396, 0.018773062154650688, 0.018656712025403976, -0.02118522673845291, 0.018570180982351303, -0.013864215463399887, 0.0015984545461833477, 0.014452992007136345, 0.018630051985383034, 0.004706159234046936, 0.012844807468354702, -0.0008952048956416547, -0.04320288822054863, -0.04339258372783661, -0.04921006038784981, 0.02681889571249485, -0.01817557029426098, -0.0078001441434025764, 0.005673043429851532, 0.010081600397825241, 0.00341207068413496, -0.043632082641124725, -0.02979329042136669, 0.010422442108392715, 0.021557658910751343, -0.02373037114739418, -0.014950870536267757, -0.02897946536540985, 0.034832071512937546, -0.007520782295614481, 0.03368586301803589, -0.0010373502736911178, -0.014307823963463306, -0.011399127542972565, 0.032013967633247375, 0.03291953355073929, 0.02388780191540718, -0.022548792883753777, -0.02012239582836628, -0.02642165683209896, -0.020401116460561752, -0.01587178185582161, -0.00827629305422306, 0.003604944096878171, 0.022263212129473686, 0.043304771184921265, -0.04133259877562523, 0.014116644859313965, -0.049603354185819626, 0.02576320804655552, -0.02761940285563469, -0.009771894663572311, -0.024993209168314934, -0.01825602911412716, 0.07760537415742874, 0.04098684340715408, 0.03750922530889511, 0.005518027115613222, 0.022619051858782768, 0.04827142506837845, 0.027488168329000473, -0.0552704744040966, 0.007444031536579132, -0.0023259599693119526, -0.028694460168480873, 0.006219989620149136, -0.0171295665204525, 0.03778814896941185, 0.019577881321310997, 0.035422977060079575, -0.009387320838868618, -0.01805933378636837, -0.0007630483014509082, 0.04399077594280243, -0.027247080579400063, -0.02871496044099331, -0.009818310849368572, 0.020426826551556587, -0.002619439736008644, -0.029251661151647568, -0.022061128169298172, -0.022668734192848206, 0.0034604689572006464, 0.0018377559026703238, -0.03616446629166603, -0.028314031660556793, -0.06640703976154327, -0.01848829910159111, -0.02695867232978344, -0.028779085725545883, -0.01787729375064373, -0.003220117185264826, -0.016474293544888496, -0.027406807988882065, 0.03145432099699974, 0.00408127112314105, -0.006938447244465351, -0.0013572809984907508, -0.017540667206048965, 0.06802455335855484, 0.028895655646920204, 0.013851475901901722, 0.013422324322164059, 0.019276389852166176, -0.005820797756314278, 0.04438655450940132, -0.04317536950111389, -0.012530815787613392, 0.05971943587064743, -0.04988682270050049, -0.049430277198553085, 0.03503547981381416, -0.010154382325708866, 0.026777422055602074, 0.008328313007950783, -0.012249942868947983, -0.023192787542939186, 0.027379827573895454, -0.0041412836872041225, -0.026229489594697952, -0.007385652046650648, 0.004115755669772625, 0.00131509592756629, 0.011914639733731747, -0.004300076514482498, -0.014945351518690586, -0.031714290380477905, 0.051395948976278305, 0.012062525376677513, 0.012851712293922901, 0.005709345452487469, 0.02178945764899254, 0.025965584442019463, 0.021509138867259026, 0.005067063961178064, -0.00299189449287951, 0.06051906198263168, 0.07964113354682922, -0.024348905310034752, 0.03433661535382271, 0.012589688412845135, 0.013907055370509624, -0.07428663969039917, 0.023079900071024895, 0.030208704993128777, 0.0021837165113538504, 0.034870460629463196, -0.07903166115283966, 0.029292022809386253, 0.01864992268383503, -0.030827105045318604, 0.019768226891756058, -0.012897848151624203, -0.03765653073787689, -0.02136203832924366, 0.003142448840662837, -0.034857358783483505, 0.027166979387402534, 0.02913184091448784, 0.026981262490153313, 0.028383156284689903, 0.034500639885663986, -0.009841784834861755, 0.01631087064743042, -0.0459427610039711, -0.0033441355917602777, -0.0008371170260943472, -0.04909384995698929, 0.032842714339494705, -0.038555808365345, -0.032948970794677734, 0.038571398705244064, -0.03140217438340187, -0.011736937798559666, 0.03072725236415863, 0.03346638381481171, 0.020761383697390556, 0.01199092622846365, 0.016870621591806412, -0.014313479885458946, -0.0015228844713419676, -0.008702114224433899, 0.03158189728856087, 0.011734296567738056, -0.048298969864845276, -0.025842780247330666, 0.04303164407610893, -0.00285861873999238, -0.0007926716934889555, 0.04319460317492485, -0.019398758187890053, -0.05127272754907608, -0.003907246049493551, -0.013127916492521763, 0.024617306888103485, -0.003830858040601015, 0.0363532230257988, -0.07086335122585297, -0.014078199863433838, 0.050368744879961014, 0.006899985019117594, -0.03845691308379173, 0.03611296787858009, -0.024069253355264664, -0.058266740292310715, 0.02520735189318657, 0.04005080834031105, -0.02206273190677166, -0.04747241735458374, -0.026614045724272728, 0.00380399520508945, 0.0191046129912138, -0.0010968070710077882, -0.03738197684288025, -0.03912824019789696, 0.04012381657958031, -0.039529167115688324, 0.013733789324760437, 0.05368157476186752, 0.020348047837615013, -0.004505257587879896, -0.06933596730232239, 0.024225028231739998, 0.020742105320096016, 0.003588976338505745, -0.04748998209834099, 0.007359637878835201, -0.056330204010009766, 0.017061244696378708, 0.08522413671016693, 0.016170285642147064, 0.007651444524526596, -0.025570882484316826, 0.01596824638545513, 0.03178280591964722, -0.038050420582294464, 0.010724508203566074, -0.048878200352191925, -0.014299217611551285, 0.014870647341012955, -0.015538839623332024, -0.0197954960167408, 0.031369101256132126, -0.021492987871170044, -0.03353246673941612, -0.02001035213470459, 0.01784859225153923, 0.01348883006721735, 0.0388675220310688, -0.04361443221569061, -0.02632533200085163, 0.018636586144566536, 0.007167319767177105, 0.01260025892406702, 0.013985163532197475, 0.002390064764767885, -0.04104165732860565, 0.05182627961039543, -0.01488463394343853, -0.066684789955616, 0.02378290332853794, 0.026484161615371704, -0.003304938320070505, -0.08001287281513214, -0.020702248439192772, 0.00886182114481926, -0.06992258131504059, 0.0035089626908302307, 0.03644467890262604, 0.030387001112103462, 0.01635782979428768, 0.002370961010456085, 0.03446749970316887, 0.016558658331632614, 0.013952494598925114, 0.01997438073158264, 0.037357453256845474, 0.047354549169540405, -0.0159455556422472, 0.018090516328811646, 0.018416138365864754, -0.01639840006828308, 0.03631385788321495, 0.009041920304298401, 0.046647801995277405, -0.010295704007148743, -0.01656492054462433, 0.01336083747446537, -0.00559065630659461, 0.019739821553230286, -0.03183361515402794, -0.023280292749404907, 0.056913092732429504, -0.018795490264892578, 0.016615724191069603, -0.04021568223834038, -0.023032205179333687, -0.003686118172481656, -0.005983447190374136, 0.016289031133055687, 0.01703421212732792, 0.023222170770168304, 0.00002145112921425607, -0.012999243102967739, -0.02226399816572666, 0.03239661455154419, -0.019462279975414276, 0.023870743811130524, -0.02737969160079956, 0.014829808846116066, -0.030176056548953056, -0.016153503209352493, 0.0031455198768526316, -0.01585080474615097, 0.022474631667137146, 0.02022777870297432, 0.03341500461101532, 0.008062001317739487, -0.019042672589421272, 0.01591995544731617, 0.0470413975417614, -0.07322660088539124, -0.017612852156162262, -0.0371534563601017, -0.00143886124715209, 0.007787484675645828, -0.02949952520430088 ]
<p>I was wondering if you could share your experience in reporting chi-square tests for complex survey data in journal publications. Normally Chi-square tests are reported as $\chi^2_1(2,\text{ N} = 90)= 0.89, \text{ p} = .35$. (for example, although I guess there can be some variations). However the concept of N becomes rather tricky with complex survey design, and I'm not sure whether I should report the probability weighted sample size or just the sample size.I'm also interested in whether people would report different Ns if the sample was just subject to probability weighting (e.g. for example if strata or cluster information was unfortunately missing) or probability weighting with clustering and stratification. And if the sample size was reported in the format above should this be reported as n rather than N?</p> <p>Just to give an example: Lumley's R package returns the following:</p> <pre><code>data(api) dclus1&lt;-svydesign(id=~dnum, weights=~pw, data=apiclus1, fpc=~fpc) svychisq(~sch.wide+stype,dclus1, statistic="Chisq") Pearson's X^2: Rao &amp; Scott adjustment data: svychisq(~sch.wide + stype, dclus1, statistic = "Chisq") X-squared = 11.94, df = 2, p-value = 0.005553 </code></pre> <p>Would you report as N </p> <pre><code>sum(xtabs(~sch.wide+stype, data=apiclus1)) #or sum(svytable(~sch.wide+stype, dclus1)) </code></pre> <p>See <a href="http://faculty.washington.edu/tlumley/survey/html/svychisq.html" rel="nofollow">this</a> page for details on computation and Rao-Scott corrections to the Pearson chisquared test.</p> <p>Very interested in your opinion. Many thanks</p>
73,642
[ -0.029206421226263046, -0.008875543251633644, 0.001454658224247396, -0.008203184232115746, 0.06836368143558502, 0.03196566179394722, -0.02321983315050602, -0.030880175530910492, -0.01626557484269142, -0.05711311846971512, 0.027160365134477615, 0.05141656473278999, 0.00020759923791047186, 0.0432923287153244, -0.011501329950988293, -0.004208593163639307, -0.0054239546880126, 0.012598601169884205, -0.007955498062074184, 0.006145132705569267, 0.010769006796181202, -0.011154104955494404, -0.018178017809987068, -0.02448153868317604, -0.04364040121436119, 0.07184334844350815, -0.0014686381909996271, -0.06710130721330643, -0.0031426160130649805, 0.04372864589095116, -0.05246391147375107, 0.004325569607317448, -0.005451986566185951, -0.044491615146398544, 0.022580673918128014, 0.011326342821121216, 0.002503476571291685, -0.04108840599656105, 0.0175319891422987, 0.059485506266355515, -0.016784869134426117, 0.0300282072275877, -0.0012223842786625028, 0.007001807447522879, -0.03520512580871582, 0.04663960635662079, 0.003226621076464653, -0.020285863429307938, -0.0023945665452629328, -0.03470352664589882, 0.03956136107444763, 0.026175111532211304, 0.03030093014240265, 0.020427430048584938, -0.04137417674064636, 0.005161675158888102, 0.03467082604765892, 0.016008086502552032, 0.03865860402584076, -0.05020778626203537, -0.003842174308374524, -0.031754303723573685, -0.009942853823304176, -0.024721313267946243, -0.038972124457359314, 0.024665838107466698, -0.00398805970326066, -0.04181563854217529, 0.012003404088318348, -0.03348119184374809, 0.04030216112732887, 0.023063862696290016, 0.003646360943093896, -0.009592423215508461, 0.016578897833824158, -0.06845438480377197, 0.003008118364959955, 0.02052130550146103, 0.03292037546634674, 0.017119476571679115, -0.01076187752187252, 0.014916304498910904, 0.022274455055594444, 0.012081674300134182, 0.028958721086382866, -0.0011500080581754446, 0.03250566124916077, 0.00015722998068667948, -0.004870899952948093, 0.029362844303250313, 0.012559243477880955, 0.017637435346841812, 0.06603828072547913, 0.016438845545053482, -0.026391567662358284, -0.00002806048360071145, -0.02706005796790123, 0.06667394191026688, -0.022250447422266006, -0.029933137819170952, -0.044376030564308167, -0.04603101685643196, 0.029657315462827682, 0.04199278727173805, -0.0502447634935379, -0.026344064623117447, -0.0063046352006495, 0.010675584897398949, -0.0332162044942379, -0.03498690575361252, -0.008178752847015858, 0.007722076028585434, -0.010246282443404198, -0.014662384055554867, 0.024572046473622322, -0.017860859632492065, 0.0008118568221107125, 0.01060074009001255, 0.05185858905315399, 0.08515815436840057, 0.04161446914076805, -0.02428639493882656, 0.02189893089234829, -0.04312431067228317, -0.05926542356610298, 0.01851404458284378, 0.027243612334132195, -0.02903900481760502, -0.06600825488567352, 0.019396819174289703, -0.0015380217228084803, -0.008738777600228786, 0.05435668304562569, -0.002040548250079155, -0.006346149370074272, 0.024963432922959328, -0.07843828201293945, -0.08642180263996124, 0.024257676675915718, 0.017620980739593506, -0.03119969740509987, -0.053855814039707184, 0.01684666983783245, 0.05242268368601799, 0.03192766010761261, -0.003185850800946355, 0.05266744643449783, 0.0023457363713532686, 0.02200506441295147, 0.007913450710475445, -0.022736266255378723, -0.00914361234754324, -0.026580510661005974, -0.03267037868499756, -0.03850667178630829, -0.027763348072767258, 0.06497041881084442, 0.034801654517650604, 0.01196496281772852, 0.006395709700882435, 0.007228183560073376, 0.015518882311880589, -0.0012540617026388645, -0.022156711667776108, 0.012436223216354847, -0.020211385563015938, 0.081596240401268, 0.016880162060260773, 0.0373736135661602, 0.00013893577852286398, -0.022586820647120476, 0.002774738008156419, 0.01977933757007122, 0.02963169477880001, 0.027702439576387405, -0.01223133597522974, -0.0028364763129502535, -0.006014641374349594, 0.0023686799686402082, 0.03056955523788929, -0.0657956451177597, -0.041926734149456024, -0.0012441418366506696, -0.01653200574219227, 0.05784071981906891, 0.06359801441431046, 0.022823141887784004, -0.04508521407842636, 0.08144595474004745, -0.06341533362865448, -0.02999126724898815, -0.024979243054986, 0.011941453441977501, -0.019817214459180832, -0.04726630449295044, 0.012048568576574326, -0.026140062138438225, -0.022058231756091118, 0.02298145741224289, 0.0022019348107278347, -0.008323067799210548, 0.039826370775699615, 0.06774429976940155, -0.03497178480029106, -0.046547602862119675, 0.029488172382116318, 0.04898654296994209, -0.014956829138100147, 0.019860608503222466, 0.003947055898606777, -0.043867167085409164, -0.003795758355408907, 0.0015707365237176418, 0.03683933988213539, 0.0011506256414577365, -0.0015467487974092364, 0.012608875520527363, 0.035086341202259064, -0.016561785712838173, 0.05555061623454094, -0.0625949576497078, 0.06401797384023666, 0.07403934001922607, -0.02695547789335251, 0.013878131285309792, 0.02708512730896473, -0.0010088123381137848, 0.0027185294311493635, -0.009358770214021206, 0.021526377648115158, -0.04645829275250435, 0.013806701637804508, 0.059422124177217484, 0.016348015516996384, -0.03538591414690018, -0.021549122408032417, 0.05666595697402954, -0.004739647731184959, -0.014066319912672043, 0.022310277447104454, -0.01053952518850565, -0.050289273262023926, 0.018433094024658203, 0.009817134588956833, 0.006562584079802036, -0.007717476692050695, 0.030473535880446434, -0.019215287640690804, 0.029449252411723137, 0.030618663877248764, -0.005716584622859955, 0.0291142500936985, -0.00580186489969492, -0.00791107676923275, -0.02482026070356369, -0.0035726549103856087, 0.044632043689489365, -0.005254169460386038, 0.0036925170570611954, 0.02875644527375698, -0.031060364097356796, -0.010589653626084328, -0.014224467799067497, 0.001671763020567596, 0.030486861243844032, -0.0018743198597803712, -0.038409169763326645, -0.015813443809747696, 0.008498088456690311, -0.028545957058668137, 0.006758847739547491, -0.02438340149819851, -0.007196539547294378, -0.05880238488316536, 0.03114187903702259, 0.019230958074331284, 0.008034426718950272, 0.016511406749486923, -0.01083969697356224, -0.03787199780344963, -0.024991868063807487, -0.001114040263928473, 0.03899695351719856, 0.02544454112648964, -0.060895878821611404, 0.03335224464535713, -0.0186090636998415, -0.021195024251937866, -0.0019259268883615732, -0.029040277004241943, -0.028488779440522194, 0.04567506164312363, 0.004917459562420845, -0.04716847836971283, 0.009190885350108147, -0.0027089654467999935, -0.0232751052826643, -0.03047509305179119, -0.0064905667677521706, 0.02174590341746807, 0.010457508265972137, -0.014906872995197773, 0.03147618845105171, -0.03749469667673111, -0.012621687725186348, -0.013236800208687782, 0.004847265779972076, -0.007575124967843294, -0.024122802540659904, -0.0020271362736821175, 0.008856374770402908, -0.019261999055743217, -0.02316168136894703, -0.05938133969902992, -0.038340914994478226, 0.00005447911098599434, -0.00595457898452878, 0.06668255478143692, -0.002990195294842124, -0.003082090523093939, 0.06351520866155624, 0.036816131323575974, -0.010676341131329536, -0.022406063973903656, 0.040375009179115295, -0.02697804756462574, -0.010230342857539654, 0.011605864390730858, 0.03263796120882034, 0.019784318283200264, 0.007720206864178181, -0.021997962146997452, -0.007142751943320036, 0.045730799436569214, 0.05525144934654236, 0.013821524567902088, 0.03340878337621689, -0.033066555857658386, -0.009124339558184147, 0.05526517331600189, 0.036897338926792145, -0.02307255007326603, -0.01846805028617382, -0.006017149891704321, 0.01274611335247755, 0.006852305959910154, -0.017407692968845367, -0.017709748819470406, -0.009354779496788979, 0.01658950373530388, -0.03858056291937828, 0.02619236148893833, 0.030387818813323975, -0.028081266209483147, -0.011566722765564919, 0.016561949625611305, 0.04061637446284294, -0.013026162050664425, -0.019218891859054565, 0.05729520320892334, 0.04762953147292137, -0.021073922514915466, 0.009384057484567165, 0.027550892904400826, 0.02087099850177765, 0.046948615461587906, -0.05215343460440636, -0.035705577582120895, 0.023602936416864395, 0.06754056364297867, 0.032202720642089844, -0.005356543231755495, -0.029291372746229172, 0.03625275194644928, -0.05115765705704689, -0.0042677829042077065, -0.06621336936950684, 0.029273999854922295, 0.035014037042856216, 0.028760049492120743, 0.01562923565506935, -0.04101646691560745, -0.004030060488730669, -0.042179130017757416, -0.07417621463537216, 0.00565407844260335, -0.01411451492458582, -0.012794608250260353, 0.004347002599388361, -0.022543756291270256, 0.026198189705610275, -0.013983162119984627, 0.05082619935274124, -0.005925563629716635, 0.03773537650704384, -0.0171075277030468, 0.04190457984805107, 0.0344494953751564, 0.009363381192088127, 0.010878725908696651, 0.03254975751042366, 0.030479200184345245, 0.014135952107608318, 0.017701776698231697, 0.00982296746224165, -0.01296100951731205, 0.025283867493271828, 0.008612031117081642, 0.022493978962302208, -0.016013875603675842, 0.027722077444195747, -0.012499983422458172, 0.0090354448184371, -0.052849359810352325, 0.009316428564488888, 0.015893155708909035, 0.01090051420032978, 0.055599063634872437, -0.025127211585640907, 0.018357859924435616, -0.01092296652495861, -0.014575655572116375, -0.007246340159326792, 0.033000167459249496, -0.005217230878770351, -0.004331669770181179, 0.049655310809612274, 0.005405918229371309, -0.030531715601682663, -0.011561203747987747, 0.04036314785480499, -0.004813724663108587, 0.02235899120569229, -0.005235294811427593, 0.02388632670044899, 0.016344737261533737, 0.00094823376275599, 0.006859105080366135, 0.027117449790239334, 0.010158777236938477, -0.00594881409779191, 0.02514869160950184, -0.03666101023554802, -0.03318459540605545, -0.008122311905026436, 0.0038619735278189182, 0.029851825907826424, 0.0034419712610542774, -0.03144809231162071, 0.03074096329510212, 0.06660497188568115, 0.05548623949289322, 0.009652428328990936, -0.03255897015333176, -0.07870905846357346, -0.035649798810482025, 0.040124088525772095, 0.032292161136865616, -0.035933997482061386, -0.002238710643723607, -0.030024591833353043, 0.005434366874396801, 0.009667795151472092, -0.0316118523478508, 0.008723639883100986, -0.03973529115319252, 0.02665688842535019, -0.028553498908877373, -0.03557061403989792, -0.035486046224832535, 0.024769678711891174, -0.02643880806863308, 0.04803420975804329, 0.0034431086387485266, -0.029496269300580025, -0.05066957697272301, -0.0016118476632982492, 0.04574849084019661, 0.006257311906665564, -0.03925599157810211, -0.036259960383176804, 0.0026820397470146418, 0.03712180256843567, -0.00770975649356842, -0.055078163743019104, 0.01115349680185318, 0.005928732920438051, 0.0280988197773695, 0.05401625111699104, -0.005207196343690157, -0.039651453495025635, 0.03344385325908661, 0.019548220559954643, -0.02147853747010231, -0.0050165001302957535, -0.003933560103178024, 0.06348638981580734, 0.007710486650466919, 0.01943984627723694, 0.03711089491844177, 0.0277162566781044, 0.012229460291564465, 0.021597152575850487, -0.07275009900331497, -0.05664563551545143, -0.023194115608930588, -0.028716538101434708, -0.052465587854385376, -0.0016604235861450434, -0.049468230456113815, 0.0011732029961422086, 0.0022000574972480536, 0.0537206269800663, -0.033751100301742554, 0.0053985100239515305, 0.010224130935966969, 0.021950656548142433, 0.014385754242539406, 0.03131091222167015, 0.0211253073066473, 0.035741835832595825, 0.04731840267777443, -0.010176340118050575, 0.0012406480964273214, -0.0387757383286953, -0.020714085549116135, 0.012681541964411736, -0.048648249357938766, -0.0008401450468227267, -0.026234282180666924, 0.0042550768703222275, 0.005657467059791088, -0.01258180569857359, 0.01943826675415039, -0.011468585580587387, 0.052373044192790985, -0.027840595692396164, -0.0038637020625174046, -0.010809753090143204, 0.036597784608602524, -0.017973728477954865, 0.011249951086938381, -0.025485284626483917, 0.028498247265815735, 0.007489843759685755, -0.02634013257920742, -0.04025563970208168, -0.009909145534038544, 0.02483432926237583, -0.01621696539223194, -0.023439351469278336, -0.012377841398119926, -0.02652408927679062, -0.01206476241350174, -0.012602430768311024, 0.014663856476545334, 0.03434637561440468, -0.03964471444487572, 0.003144236048683524, -0.048882417380809784, 0.012419371865689754, 0.09224086254835129, -0.04733376204967499, -0.027268238365650177, 0.004211496561765671, 0.008340309374034405, -0.02137753739953041, 0.026457404717803, -0.013589211739599705, -0.05120877921581268, -0.03373830392956734, -0.02312784641981125, -0.01509777270257473, 0.03599093109369278, 0.0003655226028058678, -0.03735196962952614, -0.025082001462578773, -0.06374938040971756, -0.004152022767812014, -0.004506358876824379, 0.02271372079849243, -0.030324244871735573, 0.01811292953789234, -0.04395458102226257, -0.004886927083134651, -0.02779393084347248, 0.0029246427584439516, -0.02193201333284378, -0.0025085601955652237, -0.0328691191971302, 0.0006478898576460779, 0.044014181941747665, 0.02128499560058117, 0.010142272338271141, 0.0041523161344230175, -0.006478033494204283, 0.05019521340727806, 0.021807225421071053, 0.016756964847445488, 0.029264042153954506, 0.03402427211403847, 0.033921074122190475, -0.019741294905543327, -0.05314904451370239, -0.007415980566293001, 0.053533732891082764, 0.03212470933794975, 0.027739888057112694, 0.044375229626894, 0.023410683497786522, 0.005422546528279781, -0.042261917144060135, -0.022638149559497833, -0.0564936026930809, 0.010889565572142601, 0.06183436140418053, 0.009994583204388618, 0.0017088238382712007, 0.048288557678461075, 0.023017918691039085, -0.012031981721520424, 0.024953747168183327, 0.02749556303024292, -0.01991588994860649, 0.0026223466265946627, -0.06745445728302002, -0.03911011666059494, 0.0592736080288887, -0.01979040540754795, 0.011118698865175247, -0.01961250975728035, -0.02933649905025959, 0.044318970292806625, 0.014454491436481476, 0.013897142373025417, -0.04208255559206009, -0.027514681220054626, -0.053724516183137894, -0.02018415927886963, 0.024997713044285774, -0.043174389749765396, -0.023996921256184578, -0.03179541230201721, 0.017202181741595268, -0.01420059148222208, 0.023687511682510376, -0.012203225865960121, -0.0686441957950592, -0.04123301804065704, -0.012451289221644402, -0.022337425500154495, 0.035275161266326904, 0.0048412661999464035, -0.019511369988322258, -0.015099572949111462, -0.050648801028728485, 0.06824608892202377, 0.018461382016539574, 0.001410971861332655, 0.03075760416686535, 0.02878517098724842, -0.04873482882976532, -0.0012293453328311443, -0.012522955425083637, -0.04216108098626137, 0.14930281043052673, 0.05824356526136398, 0.05151250213384628, -0.042712971568107605, 0.030909201130270958, 0.02250942401587963, 0.027272559702396393, 0.0026237184647470713, -0.021044079214334488, -0.012905895709991455, -0.041037555783987045, 0.06145348772406578, 0.03452416881918907, 0.026020720601081848, -0.013293353840708733, 0.03434130549430847, -0.0008290500845760107, -0.03231177106499672, 0.01704433001577854, 0.013910479843616486, 0.010500967502593994, -0.02383231185376644, -0.03373459354043007, 0.009325536899268627, 0.0665031373500824, -0.02028772607445717, -0.05206732451915741, -0.0007196874357759953, -0.011930480599403381, 0.04104194790124893, -0.03538263961672783, -0.01915588043630123, 0.010338753461837769, 0.0334145650267601, 0.015930604189634323, -0.01210381742566824, 0.022165102884173393, -0.04885381832718849, 0.021692052483558655, 0.06197138503193855, -0.00437265494838357, -0.022449897602200508, 0.005899698939174414, 0.05165162310004234, -0.05019596591591835, -0.011001990176737309, -0.02020673267543316, 0.032124113291502, -0.008650427684187889, -0.03717886656522751, 0.0014997196849435568, 0.0038865008391439915, 0.0021583714988082647, -0.041807010769844055, -0.004833381623029709, 0.019721243530511856, 0.03738575428724289, -0.030384648591279984, -0.010494415648281574, -0.006752639077603817, -0.010201052762567997, 0.014243008568882942, 0.03454187884926796, 0.08041118085384369, -0.028502391651272774, -0.03485311567783356, -0.03042476251721382, 0.03008362464606762, -0.02746560610830784, 0.032962676137685776, 0.03325711190700531, 0.040020398795604706, -0.025298794731497765, -0.02523760125041008, -0.00578329898416996, 0.024352693930268288, 0.0420285202562809, -0.04000314697623253, -0.0030412476044148207, -0.02458212524652481, -0.053597819060087204, 0.011997465044260025, 0.0018846736056730151, -0.028040548786520958, -0.04459245130419731, 0.016159145161509514, 0.002977804746478796, -0.018692733719944954, 0.0074032992124557495, 0.02363949827849865, -0.0022048025857657194, 0.07196667045354843, 0.0020214493852108717, -0.04408125951886177, 0.012175662443041801, 0.0023432672023773193, -0.01616727001965046, 0.004108613356947899, -0.002624836517497897, 0.028562495484948158, 0.04813278466463089, -0.002980919787660241, -0.0022923797369003296, 0.04122152552008629, 0.001680809073150158, -0.012388796545565128, 0.030583826825022697, -0.05930817872285843, 0.013702434487640858, -0.027038786560297012, 0.019890327006578445, -0.011468488723039627, -0.002061316976323724, -0.05654902011156082, -0.054342418909072876, -0.0320914089679718, -0.011345800012350082, -0.0733693540096283, 0.00766904978081584, -0.04380277916789055, 0.0022004791535437107, 0.016493957489728928, -0.028824415057897568, -0.004748906474560499, -0.009012045338749886, -0.032322440296411514, -0.023167602717876434, 0.010212215594947338, -0.004288144875317812, -0.039665188640356064, 0.0046562072820961475, 0.02131352201104164, -0.023832015693187714, -0.0013821200700476766, 0.003942343406379223, -0.011261887848377228, 0.029161281883716583, 0.024028142914175987, 0.00845035258680582, -0.008935768157243729, 0.01769011653959751, -0.0318945087492466, -0.04923394322395325, 0.017532506957650185, 0.004532839637249708, 0.028559671714901924, -0.004924483131617308, -0.023192644119262695, -0.03832096979022026, 0.054576337337493896, -0.05229828506708145, -0.04099879041314125, -0.013506618328392506, 0.014165547676384449, 0.01988951675593853, 0.012346201576292515, -0.012553819455206394, -0.0004865917726419866, 0.007689645513892174, 0.0444265715777874, 0.0241768229752779, 0.01715768501162529, -0.02453536167740822, 0.002782668685540557, -0.028905082494020462, 0.044943079352378845, 0.011630906723439693, -0.036635469645261765, 0.017183657735586166, 0.037832099944353104, -0.05212624743580818, 0.018171317875385284, -0.027351347729563713, 0.01339472085237503, -0.09300387650728226, -0.022832367569208145, 0.01049093808978796, 0.019841190427541733, -0.01783696375787258, -0.06610465049743652, 0.03109326772391796, 0.02289094217121601, -0.06412141025066376, 0.020414019003510475, -0.023699626326560974, -0.025055114179849625, -0.058864984661340714, 0.050988491624593735, -0.03450934588909149, 0.006428327411413193, 0.019484642893075943, -0.021944602951407433, -0.0004454395384527743, -0.00015676069597247988, 0.006786128040403128, -0.023964593186974525, -0.018416400998830795, -0.0036981026642024517, -0.0057636406272649765, -0.06964914500713348, 0.023503873497247696, 0.007075036410242319, -0.027678683400154114, 0.02850935235619545, 0.025206858292222023, 0.0252419151365757, 0.05784459784626961, 0.05046486482024193, 0.01978972740471363, 0.05527563765645027, 0.0424320362508297, 0.01592942699790001, -0.030078791081905365, 0.0016299780691042542, 0.01591094397008419, 0.018545961007475853, -0.037743549793958664, 0.03315303474664688, 0.005063699092715979, 0.01799764111638069, 0.008666825480759144, 0.03813330829143524, -0.031220417469739914, 0.006405507680028677, -0.04550674185156822, -0.039691854268312454, 0.023529691621661186, -0.023369228467345238, 0.05499140918254852, -0.04329373314976692, 0.011515322141349316, 0.025441275909543037, 0.04236699640750885, -0.008117090910673141, 0.0358697809278965, 0.005936064757406712, 0.0007973580504767597, 0.009695542976260185, -0.0027180579490959644, -0.0037120527122169733, -0.01950308494269848, -0.06041775271296501, -0.0018058387795463204, 0.017771419137716293, 0.003378253895789385, 0.010552692227065563, -0.038728777319192886, 0.034495625644922256, -0.035831622779369354, 0.016678649932146072, 0.019627418369054794, 0.004951547831296921, 0.04027910158038139, -0.09765969961881638, 0.02318301424384117, 0.0033370747696608305, 0.018005434423685074, -0.02886859141290188, -0.006727427709847689, -0.045055046677589417, 0.02130095846951008, 0.05707902833819389, 0.01423693262040615, -0.004407654982060194, -0.0033637313172221184, 0.000740185147151351, 0.015463746152818203, -0.04989122226834297, 0.04390706121921539, -0.022871294990181923, -0.0034770516213029623, -0.01551807951182127, -0.0023819159250706434, 0.02819140814244747, 0.012220021337270737, 0.016943998634815216, 0.014609715901315212, 0.005212244112044573, -0.012061899527907372, -0.03484482318162918, 0.010850973427295685, 0.02923257276415825, -0.00914432480931282, 0.024912314489483833, -0.00038476608460769057, 0.017432093620300293, 0.04077300801873207, 0.0004981676465831697, -0.025538746267557144, 0.020424719899892807, -0.03278994560241699, -0.040942516177892685, 0.03337804228067398, 0.021546466276049614, 0.022427774965763092, -0.0480685792863369, -0.026570135727524757, 0.017347585409879684, -0.039862606674432755, -0.03468773141503334, 0.03753150627017021, 0.0590364933013916, 0.03892960399389267, -0.0004008778487332165, 0.0190411563962698, 0.03979465365409851, -0.0326152965426445, -0.0016723510343581438, -0.017577333375811577, 0.044594865292310715, 0.009799828752875328, -0.02501409314572811, 0.04123339429497719, -0.005005672108381987, 0.012792903929948807, -0.018356677144765854, 0.04730197414755821, -0.016063351184129715, -0.02438044361770153, 0.023317717015743256, -0.0054528433829545975, -0.0016058726469054818, -0.0006495778798125684, -0.022055156528949738, 0.04231039062142372, -0.0078980578109622, 0.022643860429525375, -0.047527581453323364, -0.05337226763367653, -0.03354987874627113, -0.01879425346851349, -0.0061713517643511295, 0.09293284267187119, -0.005818973295390606, 0.02752678655087948, 0.01910184882581234, -0.025991471484303474, 0.03407464176416397, -0.018390130251646042, 0.03931671008467674, -0.014351047575473785, 0.03013615868985653, 0.013541074469685555, 0.042151886969804764, 0.0032393173314630985, -0.024027550593018532, 0.04603422060608864, 0.019643694162368774, 0.031105536967515945, -0.022666361182928085, 0.009854712523519993, 0.03463894501328468, 0.0231403186917305, -0.001649491023272276, -0.008026981726288795, -0.014858182519674301, 0.0074576218612492085, 0.01254729088395834, -0.0157760176807642 ]
<p>I'm looking to use a multivariate regression for prediction, but making use of (possibly) superior estimates of variance for both the independent and extraneous variables.</p> <p>My approach is to standardize the dependent and extraneous variables (by dividing their respective standard deviations derived from the full data history). Once I have the standardized regression coefficients, I use these, together with my separately sourced variance estimates, to get back to an equation that will be used for generating the predictions. Do I simply multiply each coefficient by my separately sourced variance estimate? But what about the dependent variable variance estimate?</p> <p>As background info, my separate sourcing of variances estimates is because I believe I have better (more up-to-date) estimates than available from the full data history (let's say, because the variances aren't stable through time, I can estimate a more timely measure of variance using higher frequency data over a shorter, recent period).</p> <ul> <li>Is this approach a sensible standard practice?</li> <li>How to go from the standardized betas, to un-standardized ones using the high frequency variance estimates?</li> </ul> <p>I read here (http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/29781/when-should-you-center-your-data-when-should-you-standardize) about WHEN to standardize, but not clear to me if this covers the case of standardizing both dependent and extraneous variables. </p> <p>Thank you!</p>
39,441
[ -0.034924838691949844, 0.02240149676799774, -0.02342243678867817, -0.009181792847812176, 0.04422031715512276, -0.001959322253242135, -0.002956092357635498, -0.010589214973151684, 0.04362126812338829, -0.05088930204510689, 0.00012605728989001364, 0.03411387652158737, 0.06121164932847023, -0.00789872370660305, 0.02392757497727871, -0.011845115572214127, -0.0004456190508790314, 0.00033599528251215816, -0.0008299936889670789, -0.0023669085931032896, 0.015039119869470596, 0.007631103508174419, -0.015497270040214062, 0.002459173323586583, -0.04047622159123421, 0.055489394813776016, 0.03575604781508446, -0.0009419445996172726, -0.001655561150982976, 0.0499492846429348, -0.008713622577488422, -0.01733626239001751, 0.024739576503634453, 0.045067377388477325, -0.004044695757329464, 0.01619916409254074, -0.012713979929685593, -0.005656123161315918, -0.006881371606141329, 0.05036984384059906, -0.00744154118001461, -0.004657379351556301, -0.03924560546875, 0.03619099035859108, -0.003764893626794219, 0.016915705054998398, -0.020975153893232346, -0.01653163880109787, 0.028432196006178856, -0.05207033455371857, 0.07624871283769608, -0.00608950387686491, 0.020758019760251045, 0.0385671928524971, -0.04436785355210304, -0.010112850926816463, 0.05542955547571182, 0.034787409007549286, 0.02309940755367279, -0.05562460049986839, -0.004874020349234343, 0.008975592441856861, 0.006267733871936798, -0.03382745012640953, -0.020943354815244675, 0.008756721392273903, -0.001381573616527021, -0.0008973851799964905, 0.04783013463020325, -0.057438820600509644, 0.02483237534761429, 0.03331605717539787, 0.03534715622663498, 0.015166292898356915, 0.0014797616750001907, -0.017121845856308937, 0.01996728405356407, 0.014150740578770638, 0.05763714015483856, 0.021546797826886177, 0.021799622103571892, 0.0010315559338778257, 0.04417414218187332, 0.01961369812488556, 0.02148662507534027, 0.018368089571595192, 0.08239998668432236, -0.018911955878138542, 0.0023786493111401796, 0.009990699589252472, -0.005221950355917215, 0.0007216986850835383, 0.08031157404184341, 0.0046519688330590725, -0.029533496126532555, 0.028368283063173294, -0.026746202260255814, 0.018030550330877304, 0.005712313577532768, -0.002884277142584324, -0.01101640984416008, -0.019128751009702682, -0.008357386104762554, 0.036619242280721664, 0.0021545528434216976, -0.024438023567199707, -0.015201971866190434, 0.007010653614997864, -0.01656886376440525, -0.06405056267976761, -0.028795693069696426, 0.0009997222805395722, -0.031029392033815384, 0.00717081967741251, 0.007113322149962187, -0.010294444859027863, 0.012433914467692375, -0.0029842176008969545, 0.06426668912172318, 0.058336272835731506, 0.01955176703631878, -0.034542348235845566, 0.009130630642175674, -0.02145202085375786, -0.015105053782463074, 0.038620416074991226, 0.01329396665096283, -0.027550164610147476, -0.07144878804683685, 0.043600939214229584, -0.0037350375205278397, -0.0346454419195652, 0.019205130636692047, -0.011816352605819702, -0.02867305278778076, 0.03272604942321777, -0.06969398260116577, -0.07536260783672333, 0.033008407801389694, -0.031574130058288574, 0.016423098742961884, -0.0581047385931015, -0.0116159338504076, -0.005501643288880587, 0.044187091290950775, 0.003231455571949482, 0.030244849622249603, 0.028055930510163307, 0.03303085267543793, 0.023236172273755074, -0.03708409518003464, -0.028771866112947464, -0.011453848332166672, -0.000020879342628177255, -0.03818698599934578, -0.07187100499868393, -0.0021365168504416943, 0.015022511593997478, -0.017671113833785057, 0.019762031733989716, 0.03474752604961395, 0.02892027422785759, -0.02486593835055828, -0.0072795916348695755, 0.033064305782318115, -0.04865729436278343, 0.061730608344078064, 0.0033929089549928904, 0.021080058068037033, 0.016008643433451653, 0.005325246602296829, -0.017410844564437866, -0.025249015539884567, 0.03618631884455681, 0.023169731721282005, 0.003914196975529194, 0.047774504870176315, -0.009298325516283512, -0.007358447182923555, -0.003607288235798478, -0.0653732419013977, -0.01948711834847927, -0.02487178146839142, -0.01557256281375885, 0.007844924926757812, 0.06342198699712753, -0.020774301141500473, -0.012466773390769958, 0.03296222910284996, -0.06335269659757614, -0.061772771179676056, -0.06567303836345673, -0.000628575449809432, -0.013620738871395588, -0.039688508957624435, 0.023516815155744553, -0.021816644817590714, 0.060249682515859604, -0.0005923325661569834, -0.017407340928912163, -0.005769453477114439, 0.041000109165906906, 0.06379056721925735, -0.030500371009111404, 0.03393365442752838, 0.060170240700244904, 0.061703577637672424, -0.010187188163399696, 0.027102338150143623, -0.007464502472430468, -0.051705170422792435, 0.004979465156793594, -0.0746985375881195, 0.028848256915807724, -0.01936427317559719, -0.03328927978873253, 0.027487095445394516, -0.03325818106532097, -0.011111545376479626, 0.008705969899892807, -0.04505462199449539, 0.05846000462770462, 0.057417090982198715, -0.03474198654294014, -0.01274755410850048, 0.04448780044913292, 0.045505624264478683, 0.013552522286772728, -0.043332554399967194, -0.004418699070811272, -0.048984628170728683, -0.023343531414866447, 0.03582008183002472, 0.01622701622545719, -0.033021703362464905, 0.004829166457056999, 0.027079347521066666, 0.02008194848895073, 0.015024477615952492, 0.018303902819752693, -0.01431967131793499, -0.03728020563721657, -0.0012059143045917153, 0.004662577528506517, 0.02377445623278618, 0.01510046049952507, -0.010754497721791267, 0.0052266595885157585, 0.02912338450551033, 0.0046606059186160564, 0.02942558005452156, 0.022963672876358032, 0.02099481411278248, -0.027315838262438774, -0.009439230896532536, -0.007128526456654072, 0.04141109809279442, -0.007085001096129417, 0.02586035244166851, 0.016787758097052574, 0.026257526129484177, 0.0003314400091767311, 0.030999567359685898, -0.019649803638458252, 0.030729537829756737, 0.026541784405708313, -0.036775220185518265, 0.0628988966345787, 0.014559861272573471, -0.01685565710067749, 0.03227730840444565, -0.039781417697668076, -0.03552115708589554, -0.009058009833097458, -0.036273714154958725, 0.009420817717909813, 0.029018310829997063, 0.026313669979572296, -0.011839146725833416, -0.014084406197071075, -0.02458100952208042, 0.018929436802864075, 0.02086877077817917, 0.023061765357851982, -0.018008209764957428, -0.004358674865216017, -0.031823016703128815, -0.008635555393993855, 0.03085603564977646, -0.0032377364113926888, -0.008867315948009491, 0.059023477137088776, 0.030877485871315002, -0.07872630655765533, -0.028127891942858696, 0.003579392796382308, 0.0071153477765619755, -0.0017079258104786277, -0.038419123739004135, 0.028139900416135788, -0.000958291522692889, -0.03914005309343338, 0.044232822954654694, -0.01626942865550518, -0.024082763120532036, -0.033701639622449875, -0.014778831973671913, -0.020588096231222153, -0.01939227245748043, 0.026005445048213005, 0.006292660720646381, -0.03899053856730461, -0.03784354776144028, -0.04610275477170944, -0.05012708902359009, 0.007357771508395672, 0.01962253265082836, 0.06909691542387009, 0.011561138555407524, -0.032864514738321304, 0.06853603571653366, 0.02881147712469101, 0.0047993408516049385, -0.03894476592540741, 0.007369074039161205, -0.012564022094011307, -0.06253322213888168, 0.015971586108207703, -0.0013291032519191504, -0.009268520399928093, 0.003447715425863862, -0.018251996487379074, 0.018668461591005325, 0.03882605582475662, 0.013361427001655102, 0.025739450007677078, -0.02473963238298893, -0.011297271586954594, 0.006483742035925388, 0.02704731933772564, 0.005125833209604025, 0.011378019116818905, -0.04538142308592796, 0.0032882282976061106, 0.029988160356879234, 0.012917546555399895, -0.06013218313455582, 0.010633462108671665, -0.007366458885371685, -0.0037494024727493525, -0.06061629578471184, 0.016834605485200882, 0.020026735961437225, -0.03461780026555061, -0.02809750847518444, -0.008115257136523724, 0.020280616357922554, -0.00041473403689451516, 0.00466202525421977, 0.03800337761640549, 0.043144043534994125, 0.036413535475730896, -0.007065269164741039, -0.052574265748262405, -0.021533450111746788, 0.05314081534743309, -0.03238457441329956, -0.015495372004806995, 0.0300811305642128, 0.048070136457681656, -0.004059848375618458, 0.0041403938084840775, -0.08990586549043655, 0.017696712166070938, -0.06951643526554108, 0.022910892963409424, -0.048490431159734726, 0.02482954040169716, 0.009399736300110817, 0.043929312378168106, -0.017333459109067917, -0.04468153417110443, 0.0216392632573843, -0.006884294096380472, -0.06046205013990402, 0.007348764222115278, -0.023405125364661217, 0.015240570530295372, -0.0004548214783426374, -0.009515557438135147, 0.03690069168806076, 0.010701828636229038, 0.023493468761444092, -0.027320202440023422, 0.030768292024731636, -0.03105958364903927, 0.018645253032445908, -0.03455032780766487, -0.022387024015188217, -0.0037807580083608627, 0.024542683735489845, -0.019607972353696823, -0.016095563769340515, 0.03628716245293617, 0.03378751873970032, -0.01900988072156906, 0.006110562011599541, -0.024876536801457405, 0.023462515324354172, -0.006693668197840452, 0.03320030868053436, 0.0286910030990839, 0.017551610246300697, -0.046250369399785995, -0.0060866279527544975, 0.0318644754588604, 0.024579618126153946, 0.04361243173480034, -0.007065704092383385, -0.02288082428276539, -0.02503322809934616, -0.03665642812848091, 0.014456733129918575, 0.01969236321747303, 0.03476930782198906, 0.009744434617459774, 0.06712750345468521, 0.018322160467505455, -0.04282364621758461, 0.016827639192342758, 0.06887441873550415, 0.021490849554538727, 0.002519184025004506, -0.013049529865384102, 0.0005483733839355409, 0.03546422719955444, -0.02400348149240017, 0.00796967837959528, 0.01026114635169506, -0.013512400910258293, 0.00012608213000930846, -0.004866751842200756, -0.04076013341546059, 0.023402169346809387, 0.031324755400419235, 0.02964957430958748, 0.06606154143810272, 0.0073786284774541855, -0.041230883449316025, 0.015519396401941776, 0.03174986690282822, 0.06442605704069138, 0.07130572199821472, -0.007733318023383617, -0.07382303476333618, -0.007125425152480602, 0.008111762814223766, 0.0325743593275547, -0.034812334924936295, -0.01613553613424301, -0.0014331556158140302, -0.03849564865231514, 0.018356747925281525, -0.036687880754470825, -0.001432867837138474, -0.024358874186873436, 0.0029965932480990887, -0.021446270868182182, -0.0304532703012228, -0.02936837635934353, 0.018123291432857513, -0.015387286432087421, 0.08812636882066727, -0.0037769179325550795, -0.03939666971564293, -0.03639679402112961, 0.03267167508602142, 0.004334659315645695, 0.07665883749723434, -0.007553224917501211, -0.03903637453913689, 0.0005787179106846452, 0.03648637980222702, -0.010442315600812435, -0.06263226270675659, -0.015790339559316635, 0.016937728971242905, -0.014913654886186123, 0.05571703985333443, 0.017735464498400688, -0.05783133581280708, 0.0016242084093391895, 0.026427630335092545, -0.00848462712019682, 0.02888650819659233, 0.012911507859826088, 0.05375320836901665, 0.02699393592774868, 0.030837396159768105, 0.07742564380168915, 0.02008146606385708, 0.004487169440835714, 0.008105304092168808, -0.013900970108807087, 0.012023473158478737, -0.045436955988407135, -0.053562864661216736, -0.03828379511833191, -0.026960954070091248, -0.0034302975982427597, 0.01178500335663557, -0.02767047844827175, 0.047380659729242325, 0.0030174909625202417, -0.023478928953409195, 0.02663469687104225, 0.030994819477200508, 0.004698678385466337, -0.014379487372934818, 0.03441152349114418, 0.02625506930053234, -0.007273233029991388, 0.0023546621669083834, 0.008581439964473248, 0.0017349357949569821, 0.02480209432542324, 0.01797417923808098, -0.04305751249194145, -0.023789027705788612, -0.046817317605018616, -0.040748417377471924, 0.008181010372936726, -0.014244040474295616, 0.04198448732495308, 0.016449326649308205, 0.05203139781951904, 0.003317910246551037, -0.03371146693825722, -0.011938975192606449, 0.023091144859790802, -0.02976069040596485, 0.022769177332520485, -0.04121574014425278, 0.024602646008133888, -0.021547894924879074, 0.008474054746329784, -0.026472371071577072, -0.02906833402812481, 0.029479674994945526, 0.020438985899090767, 0.001309889368712902, -0.021673332899808884, 0.007880442775785923, -0.037797797471284866, -0.035732027143239975, -0.05007888004183769, 0.02497529238462448, -0.030599890276789665, -0.020724045112729073, -0.031515758484601974, 0.019429439678788185, 0.0689680352807045, -0.030916646122932434, -0.0046335672959685326, 0.03123858943581581, -0.012499102391302586, -0.0025321231223642826, -0.00952343363314867, 0.020374711602926254, -0.021855110302567482, -0.01154625229537487, -0.03812558576464653, 0.01893654279410839, 0.03570905700325966, -0.014813203364610672, -0.026618413627147675, 0.03627835959196091, -0.02711857482790947, 0.012858327478170395, -0.011056194081902504, -0.001697355997748673, 0.002830080222338438, 0.031345270574092865, -0.028912534937262535, 0.014141647145152092, -0.00308936252258718, -0.003936950117349625, 0.01214328221976757, -0.004652287811040878, -0.0058390675112605095, -0.01266117487102747, 0.03737242892384529, 0.01326675619930029, 0.02132878266274929, -0.023915620520710945, -0.01420916710048914, 0.05605104938149452, 0.030872127041220665, 0.029350021854043007, 0.013879206962883472, 0.03270867094397545, -0.03744366765022278, -0.043991364538669586, -0.03141161426901817, -0.004910897929221392, 0.0711728110909462, -0.04339494928717613, 0.0163371991366148, 0.061923060566186905, -0.004553941078484058, -0.021748080849647522, -0.09057971090078354, -0.03304079920053482, 0.011382756754755974, 0.013563168235123158, 0.03739594668149948, -0.003735582111403346, -0.0012833238579332829, 0.01531624048948288, 0.018452368676662445, -0.0007570651359856129, 0.038561515510082245, 0.01819589175283909, 0.03440587967634201, 0.00002172040694858879, -0.05387561023235321, -0.03475271165370941, 0.024821385741233826, -0.056096725165843964, 0.007897509261965752, -0.03902628645300865, -0.010853694751858711, 0.04720326513051987, 0.06154230982065201, 0.00023979779507499188, -0.06672675907611847, -0.006218752823770046, -0.05156460031867027, -0.003353796899318695, 0.016922196373343468, -0.039265021681785583, 0.01462955866008997, -0.0236310176551342, 0.05399124696850777, -0.0017994518857449293, 0.019075701013207436, -0.05617975443601608, -0.08405639231204987, -0.006869161035865545, -0.006022516172379255, -0.009606806561350822, 0.021022316068410873, -0.002823659684509039, -0.0372222363948822, 0.0007110070437192917, -0.039879269897937775, 0.006323263980448246, -0.04276863485574722, 0.004337340127676725, -0.012125293724238873, 0.0798955038189888, -0.0073700533248484135, -0.029962707310914993, -0.015286704525351524, -0.008596336469054222, 0.11547878384590149, 0.06221029534935951, 0.06961341947317123, -0.045173659920692444, 0.004857445601373911, 0.0017727422527968884, 0.0018397478852421045, -0.0032895610202103853, -0.005104987882077694, -0.049273740500211716, -0.008036185055971146, 0.05352621152997017, 0.06660804152488708, 0.013216874562203884, -0.003017963143065572, 0.04297412931919098, -0.012853536754846573, 0.018116485327482224, -0.005852419883012772, 0.0516967736184597, 0.0009914891561493278, -0.008506265468895435, -0.020706603303551674, 0.010997026227414608, -0.011351116001605988, 0.006426755804568529, -0.04452035203576088, 0.04409269988536835, -0.0188377033919096, -0.010548661462962627, -0.007188817486166954, -0.0051013510674238205, 0.013972343876957893, 0.02096935361623764, -0.022740354761481285, -0.017827682197093964, 0.052015408873558044, -0.031833089888095856, 0.02663220465183258, 0.0040992614813148975, -0.06717735528945923, 0.012591279111802578, 0.015781372785568237, -0.020909497514367104, -0.07910455763339996, -0.02090608887374401, -0.05034512281417847, 0.04522908106446266, -0.018520422279834747, -0.04069991037249565, -0.012731824070215225, -0.021223798394203186, 0.04745623469352722, -0.02388647384941578, 0.005229003261774778, 0.04873428866267204, 0.012411758303642273, -0.05058318376541138, -0.00829855166375637, -0.032411716878414154, 0.0005155851831659675, 0.02592173032462597, 0.026698937639594078, -0.011225789785385132, -0.03844531625509262, -0.04218289628624916, -0.01389121264219284, 0.03771337866783142, 0.005017548333853483, 0.014572218991816044, 0.006247011944651604, -0.012424729764461517, -0.025576598942279816, 0.0015664859674870968, 0.050822239369153976, -0.0009165911469608545, 0.023329639807343483, -0.021015118807554245, 0.01764621026813984, -0.062351927161216736, -0.008381516672670841, 0.020460480824112892, -0.022984743118286133, -0.011008196510374546, -0.06462029367685318, 0.05036381632089615, -0.005478709936141968, 0.031664054840803146, 0.022860398516058922, 0.028390666469931602, -0.02676442824304104, 0.06609748303890228, 0.007297656964510679, -0.051158446818590164, -0.000021798134184791707, -0.0038576596416532993, -0.034477684646844864, -0.005500794854015112, -0.015992550179362297, 0.04677692800760269, 0.04827655106782913, 0.0422237403690815, -0.013310686685144901, 0.06731735169887543, 0.04187311977148056, 0.014152949675917625, 0.010237918235361576, -0.06794135272502899, 0.0031650422606617212, 0.01523050107061863, 0.017675790935754776, -0.015121146105229855, 0.008341660723090172, -0.054797422140836716, -0.041424818336963654, -0.004215174354612827, -0.008675752207636833, -0.04890553653240204, 0.05336330458521843, -0.017355075106024742, 0.056305836886167526, -0.04711371287703514, -0.006282308138906956, 0.001146811875514686, -0.003347268793731928, -0.0031638138461858034, -0.018975069746375084, 0.0131489597260952, 0.03207523748278618, -0.014031227678060532, 0.007443128619343042, 0.0493013970553875, -0.0005980315618216991, 0.02190546877682209, -0.008930391632020473, -0.012829413637518883, 0.01143934577703476, 0.028615541756153107, -0.011722451075911522, -0.005356810055673122, -0.01961577869951725, 0.011187415570020676, -0.04215832054615021, 0.023592347279191017, 0.020788028836250305, 0.03312285244464874, 0.013026410713791847, 0.019148489460349083, -0.030642440542578697, 0.013623571023344994, -0.03182511776685715, -0.005261991638690233, -0.010230067186057568, 0.04212135449051857, 0.02868054434657097, 0.01050748024135828, 0.06210190802812576, 0.013996755704283714, 0.01898799277842045, 0.03364860638976097, 0.009071516804397106, 0.017904629930853844, -0.01739795133471489, 0.022823423147201538, -0.0036334446631371975, -0.012980320490896702, 0.01295139268040657, 0.0032874871976673603, -0.004827219061553478, 0.03860800340771675, -0.041706524789333344, 0.028277505189180374, 0.004560123197734356, 0.00919206254184246, -0.08633720129728317, -0.037398360669612885, 0.002507584635168314, 0.007212421391159296, 0.025981610640883446, -0.03120177797973156, 0.011448445729911327, 0.0313604362308979, -0.05614851787686348, -0.0010092773009091616, -0.01620457135140896, -0.013297287747263908, -0.0039054197259247303, -0.023671364411711693, -0.007962058298289776, 0.019328707829117775, 0.008923906832933426, 0.0014236102579161525, -0.00624440424144268, 0.049316730350255966, 0.019871631637215614, -0.06615134328603745, -0.022200629115104675, -0.014766891486942768, 0.033298444002866745, -0.06516129523515701, 0.014710524119436741, -0.04652891680598259, -0.017344586551189423, 0.03314229100942612, 0.009684122167527676, 0.03108176402747631, -0.027157749980688095, 0.015903491526842117, 0.0026656726840883493, 0.05051220580935478, 0.02923397719860077, -0.00880054384469986, 0.018640050664544106, 0.003768223337829113, 0.026780052110552788, 0.024961916729807854, -0.028157472610473633, 0.022805742919445038, 0.016917137429118156, -0.006185104139149189, -0.025748424232006073, 0.017378749325871468, -0.03214216232299805, -0.030994033440947533, -0.016149695962667465, -0.011138474568724632, 0.0005658015143126249, -0.003924922086298466, 0.016143279150128365, -0.0368778370320797, -0.03890429437160492, 0.08036718517541885, 0.024398529902100563, -0.019959505647420883, 0.02242271415889263, 0.0012584829237312078, -0.05917051061987877, 0.010940187610685825, 0.012465006671845913, -0.00022863302729092538, -0.08313760906457901, -0.033508382737636566, 0.018851380795240402, -0.003096971893683076, -0.012823916971683502, -0.017352161929011345, -0.041257258504629135, 0.036875586956739426, 0.017146388068795204, 0.019349902868270874, -0.004750821273773909, -0.036092065274715424, 0.0016236158553510904, -0.052419379353523254, 0.045260678976774216, 0.0037269769236445427, -0.030168261379003525, -0.03413223847746849, -0.008135330863296986, -0.045745134353637695, -0.009265901520848274, 0.05741233378648758, 0.012465368025004864, 0.00590708339586854, 0.008860000409185886, 0.04295248165726662, -0.00842629186809063, -0.07983733713626862, 0.030549172312021255, 0.007833448238670826, -0.0229827631264925, -0.012927231378853321, -0.00477255042642355, 0.010944481939077377, 0.013956773094832897, 0.013599492609500885, -0.009006458334624767, 0.019124416634440422, 0.035176221281290054, 0.024837518110871315, 0.010846715420484543, 0.018247058615088463, -0.02012406848371029, 0.028912534937262535, 0.008925529196858406, 0.009299238212406635, 0.03063104674220085, -0.014109422452747822, -0.03777294605970383, 0.01538907177746296, -0.03423060104250908, -0.014009821228682995, 0.00274920416995883, 0.03348202630877495, -0.0073091755621135235, -0.06811844557523727, 0.029118303209543228, 0.050695937126874924, -0.03914805129170418, 0.019505131989717484, 0.02558170072734356, 0.011054019443690777, 0.021109428256750107, 0.007149704732000828, -0.008709337562322617, 0.051799219101667404, -0.03155085816979408, 0.004595310427248478, 0.007290765643119812, 0.05816325545310974, 0.02210172638297081, 0.0007895022281445563, 0.00260317325592041, -0.0026268484070897102, 0.031518179923295975, -0.021722843870520592, 0.04356662556529045, -0.05593583732843399, -0.029048753902316093, 0.04075955972075462, 0.018883682787418365, 0.043730754405260086, -0.00001644875192141626, -0.010625496506690979, 0.035394445061683655, -0.04266243800520897, -0.027615228667855263, -0.029780877754092216, -0.011091664433479309, -0.021316679194569588, -0.014373310841619968, -0.031146740540862083, 0.014123721979558468, -0.00669143907725811, 0.02204826846718788, -0.01757882721722126, -0.008055614307522774, 0.028455769643187523, -0.00664615910500288, 0.012452160939574242, -0.024217242375016212, 0.008930064737796783, -0.01709582656621933, -0.05129115656018257, -0.06049921363592148, -0.001983882626518607, 0.01259892899543047, 0.034992557018995285, 0.029828108847141266, -0.025043629109859467, -0.03945334255695343, 0.02263939566910267, 0.02642323262989521, -0.046204786747694016, 0.01227422896772623, -0.03173644840717316, 0.0012867009500041604, -0.021068774163722992, 0.010317067615687847 ]
<blockquote> <p>Let $X$ be a random varaible from a distribution with pdf $$ f(x) = \theta x^{\theta-1}, \quad 0&lt; x &lt; 1. $$</p> <p>a) Name the distribution of $U=-\ln(X)$ by first finding its density </p> <p>b) Let $X_1, X_2, \ldots,X_n$ be independent and identically distributed random variables with pdf given by earlier with $\theta$= 3. Using the result from a) and by the central limit theorem (CLT)</p> <p>i) find an approximation to $P(X_1 \cdot X_2 \cdot \ldots\cdot X_{30} \leq 1.85 \cdot 10^{-5})$</p> </blockquote> <p>i.e. for the probability of the product of the r.v's.</p> <p><strong>My attempt</strong></p> <p>I found part a) by doing the transformation, and got an exponential with parameter $\theta$ where my pdf is: $$ f(x)=\theta e^{-u\theta} . $$ Now where I am struggling is with part i) where I am supposed to find an approximation using the CLT and together with the mean equal to $1/3$ and variance equal to $1/9$. I am able to show that with 30 observation we just take the product of every mean and variance from each individual observation giving us: </p> <p>mean = $(\frac{1}{3})^{30}$<br> variance = $(\frac{1}{9})^{30}$</p> <p>and then we can just substitute these into the z score by using central limit theorem $$ P(X_1 \cdot X_2 \cdot \ldots \cdot X_{30} \leq 1.85 \cdot 10^{-5}) = P\left(\frac{X -\mu }{\sigma}\leq \frac {1.85 \cdot 10^{-5} - (\frac{1}{3})^{30}}{(\frac{1}{9})^{15}} \right) $$ Hence giving me an answer of $ P(Z \leq 3,808,985,943)$ which definitely cannot be correct. Would appreciate it if somebody could point out my mistake.</p> <p><strong>Reattempt:</strong> </p> <p>Using the hint i got i managed to deduce the following </p> <p>$P(X_1 \cdot X_2 \cdot \ldots \cdot X_{30} \leq 1.85 \cdot 10^{-5})$</p> <p>$P(log X_1 \cdot log X_2 \cdot \ldots \cdot log X_{30} \leq log 1.85 \cdot 10^{-5})$</p> <p>P($\sum_{k=1}^{30} log X_i \leq log 1.85 \cdot 10^{-5})$</p> <p>And since X random variable can be normally distributed X~ N( $\frac{1}{3}$ , $\frac{1}{9}$)</p> <p>Substitute into the Z score </p> <p>$ P(\frac{ log X -\mu }{\frac{\sigma}{\sqrt(n)}})\leq \frac { \frac{log1.85 \cdot 10^{-5}}{30} - (\frac{1}{3})}{(\frac{\frac{1}{3}}{\sqrt(n)})} $</p> <p>$P(Z \leq 11.45)$</p> <p>Am I on the right track? Is it correct to use $\mu$ = $\frac{1}{3}$ and $\sigma$ = $\frac{1}{3}$ in the z score?</p>
16,625
[ -0.05117523670196533, -0.0032615254167467356, 0.02298177033662796, -0.014207342639565468, 0.056637395173311234, -0.01690492033958435, -0.036994706839323044, -0.0043296790681779385, 0.04019369184970856, -0.008898553438484669, 0.0070028482005000114, 0.018302397802472115, 0.0637301430106163, 0.030753973871469498, 0.03762693703174591, 0.01859043911099434, -0.029670201241970062, 0.0062242611311376095, 0.010750173591077328, -0.019367435947060585, 0.026071803644299507, 0.018783478066325188, 0.007999393157660961, -0.02533280849456787, -0.043962378054857254, 0.018784023821353912, 0.012668050825595856, -0.017305569723248482, -0.03253435716032982, 0.09187234193086624, 0.001879413495771587, -0.021890100091695786, 0.007481219246983528, 0.034983258694410324, 0.012474507093429565, 0.030027691274881363, -0.03207665681838989, -0.032247379422187805, 0.024364326149225235, 0.02743634395301342, -0.03439902141690254, -0.008337526582181454, -0.011119209229946136, -0.000619996921159327, 0.0033596737775951624, 0.01204374898225069, -0.021769000217318535, -0.009543263353407383, 0.03955058753490448, -0.03660367801785469, 0.05375486612319946, 0.014572441577911377, 0.030101725831627846, 0.015376310795545578, -0.02595256082713604, -0.0590091235935688, 0.03415001928806305, 0.07517287135124207, 0.026552211493253708, -0.0361957922577858, -0.00012601300841197371, -0.016885001212358475, -0.019732344895601273, -0.004094547592103481, -0.03510246425867081, -0.011413966305553913, 0.013729925267398357, -0.015726005658507347, 0.036566585302352905, -0.027946248650550842, 0.06760566681623459, 0.01676219329237938, 0.024820629507303238, 0.02470308169722557, 0.015398040413856506, -0.00756868114694953, 0.020236533135175705, -0.0038602249696850777, 0.03845618665218353, 0.007949923165142536, -0.004344924818724394, 0.029794443398714066, 0.048813626170158386, 0.03532716631889343, 0.021781519055366516, 0.000919072946999222, 0.09739838540554047, 0.010726950131356716, 0.004368756432086229, 0.03937097638845444, 0.006858233828097582, -0.004526408854871988, 0.03407623991370201, -0.047378476709127426, -0.051758553832769394, 0.07068023830652237, -0.030097324401140213, -0.0031383440364152193, 0.02082660049200058, 0.015736503526568413, -0.005692455917596817, -0.04442925378680229, 0.011308874934911728, 0.05798714980483055, 0.004768907092511654, -0.021805819123983383, 0.012976361438632011, -0.023631626740098, 0.014674709178507328, -0.01875300332903862, 0.001226251944899559, 0.03258349001407623, -0.001241787918843329, -0.011284705251455307, 0.0037703923881053925, 0.04118283838033676, -0.00963086262345314, 0.0013491977006196976, 0.04310356825590134, 0.034411270171403885, 0.06231556832790375, -0.009533565491437912, -0.02774464339017868, -0.030651574954390526, -0.043858643621206284, 0.024959472939372063, 0.013931951485574245, 0.008340809494256973, -0.044523946940898895, 0.05145912617444992, 0.013532320037484169, 0.007304062135517597, 0.04992751032114029, 0.05406186729669571, 0.01269268523901701, 0.019147003069519997, -0.10680872946977615, -0.055741820484399796, 0.053038354963064194, -0.0007387223304249346, 0.021512296050786972, -0.04766875505447388, -0.008023408241569996, 0.032564427703619, 0.040359072387218475, 0.031150199472904205, 0.04437609761953354, -0.018189284950494766, 0.029628047719597816, 0.03129017725586891, 0.011000830680131912, -0.0032082414254546165, -0.0112209627404809, -0.02678212709724903, 0.011780998669564724, -0.03092661127448082, 0.009694084525108337, -0.0019435768481343985, -0.04923737794160843, -0.030458485707640648, 0.03750111907720566, -0.005345870275050402, 0.010552830062806606, -0.02891409769654274, 0.006996127776801586, -0.03473940119147301, 0.05719967931509018, -0.011448545381426811, 0.025198301300406456, -0.008503841236233711, -0.037242528051137924, -0.0022356139961630106, -0.011838995851576328, 0.04282104969024658, 0.05721425637602806, -0.03945523127913475, -0.024990174919366837, -0.05798434093594551, -0.003964853007346392, 0.030369047075510025, -0.04981718584895134, 0.014465969987213612, -0.03853364661335945, -0.008682101964950562, 0.011959710158407688, 0.025886453688144684, -0.003680804744362831, -0.0006361877312883735, 0.05408911406993866, -0.05963766947388649, -0.0350784957408905, -0.02946193888783455, 0.0042752912268042564, 0.017910365015268326, -0.02787325717508793, 0.05022020265460014, -0.019073348492383957, 0.027115000411868095, 0.014650334604084492, -0.02891298569738865, -0.009980271570384502, -0.004904729314148426, 0.026921603828668594, -0.022823967039585114, 0.027631180360913277, 0.039691679179668427, 0.05599556863307953, -0.03236541897058487, 0.043720830231904984, -0.03903307393193245, -0.016711276024580002, -0.000013436455446935724, -0.016084181144833565, 0.04293617978692055, 0.0037777975667268038, -0.017275521531701088, 0.04545288905501366, 0.0010490985587239265, -0.011531454510986805, 0.025499645620584488, -0.06450352817773819, 0.037115976214408875, 0.0738714411854744, -0.013125309720635414, -0.009917001239955425, 0.0323849692940712, -0.013404917903244495, 0.047472015023231506, 0.011958844028413296, -0.03197826072573662, -0.044345512986183167, -0.029956480488181114, 0.02522728219628334, 0.011930756270885468, -0.02033342607319355, 0.011798608116805553, 0.08384007215499878, 0.003977749962359667, 0.03589855507016182, 0.029826072975993156, -0.0006667838315479457, -0.013701444491744041, -0.009658691473305225, 0.007326951250433922, 0.001371480873785913, 0.010244867764413357, 0.014412610791623592, -0.027942821383476257, 0.04286080226302147, -0.009968213737010956, -0.030647534877061844, 0.007486940827220678, 0.047985516488552094, 0.016902917996048927, -0.03014567494392395, -0.0075594596564769745, 0.03579041734337807, -0.02968486212193966, -0.0013811456738039851, 0.00661889323964715, 0.010366912931203842, 0.050367213785648346, -0.03440064191818237, -0.013814265839755535, -0.005071273539215326, 0.04987229034304619, -0.019526438787579536, 0.0015268524875864387, 0.01455661654472351, 0.0027032445650547743, -0.012972901575267315, -0.005022399593144655, -0.02141364850103855, -0.017915088683366776, 0.005646273959428072, 0.04265478998422623, 0.010151025839149952, -0.02656024880707264, -0.016469288617372513, -0.02455310896039009, 0.0059504383243620396, 0.04468555375933647, 0.018633466213941574, 0.026311909779906273, -0.06178034096956253, 0.0004981213132850826, 0.004602538421750069, -0.028590379282832146, 0.0013606451684609056, 0.029904982075095177, -0.02047465741634369, 0.017562149092555046, -0.01134047843515873, -0.0780487209558487, -0.020975299179553986, 0.005663587246090174, -0.018076829612255096, -0.010015113279223442, -0.04019966721534729, 0.055991314351558685, 0.050143156200647354, -0.020360233262181282, 0.029748687520623207, -0.041980113834142685, -0.029313452541828156, -0.03846754506230354, 0.006771780084818602, -0.01690000109374523, -0.023136567324399948, 0.02966262772679329, 0.02272411622107029, 0.01305206585675478, -0.025234661996364594, -0.052976589649915695, -0.02295776642858982, -0.012974090874195099, 0.008438699878752232, 0.029336154460906982, 0.0045169200748205185, -0.019851407036185265, 0.0500660240650177, 0.04431718960404396, -0.03973916918039322, -0.029160887002944946, 0.05110445246100426, -0.004692634101957083, -0.04532639682292938, 0.029861796647310257, 0.024073878303170204, -0.03598532825708389, -0.02368292771279812, 0.0028609319124370813, 0.00351213151589036, 0.03409106284379959, 0.00974014401435852, 0.035943660885095596, 0.023018280044198036, 0.006848777178674936, -0.007871545851230621, 0.05057455599308014, 0.0005879378877580166, -0.02581709437072277, 0.0020389968995004892, 0.02258349023759365, 0.023301396518945694, 0.04495684430003166, -0.06069165840744972, 0.030589167028665543, -0.007351325824856758, 0.045105744153261185, -0.04054132476449013, 0.0497998483479023, 0.03657539188861847, -0.07908475399017334, -0.021358193829655647, 0.020167643204331398, 0.03663566708564758, -0.019756481051445007, -0.02265174500644207, 0.04664419963955879, 0.041103165596723557, 0.0038095437921583652, -0.03944866731762886, -0.034770261496305466, -0.0063582672737538815, 0.0326121561229229, -0.03265122324228287, 0.02100304886698723, 0.03179849684238434, 0.073112353682518, -0.01880848966538906, -0.06229480355978012, -0.009287233464419842, -0.022256117314100266, -0.022131819278001785, 0.018574312329292297, -0.014432082884013653, 0.03652751445770264, 0.03232552856206894, 0.05209536850452423, -0.0019553815945982933, -0.017298782244324684, 0.007124427706003189, -0.0038708029314875603, -0.06185571476817131, 0.054028455168008804, 0.03350229188799858, -0.02409318834543228, -0.005483821500092745, -0.010013963095843792, 0.006948563270270824, 0.01918567158281803, 0.03749152645468712, -0.02517005056142807, 0.019489392638206482, -0.015231866389513016, -0.0019517750479280949, -0.012663586996495724, -0.019732914865016937, 0.000737431226298213, 0.0672217458486557, 0.004559043329209089, -0.04127410054206848, 0.042665839195251465, 0.012641021981835365, -0.03067949041724205, -0.03985045850276947, -0.023841435089707375, 0.02288752608001232, 0.006218055263161659, 0.027090733870863914, -0.0052831219509243965, 0.009295477531850338, 0.01652120240032673, 0.046683747321367264, 0.0251898393034935, 0.04436326399445534, 0.03909825533628464, 0.005707321222871542, -0.022388717159628868, 0.0016789924120530486, -0.03760471194982529, 0.017830325290560722, 0.006888494826853275, 0.008750790730118752, -0.00500503508374095, 0.05789252743124962, -0.0013405820354819298, -0.03533833101391792, -0.03690224140882492, 0.024598954245448112, -0.019023284316062927, 0.0001516215706942603, -0.035277899354696274, 0.004332020878791809, 0.005266802851110697, 0.01140551082789898, 0.02725943922996521, 0.01650792360305786, 0.0028942679055035114, -0.003860673401504755, 0.07920010387897491, 0.027775077149271965, -0.053745049983263016, 0.006911810953170061, 0.015500197187066078, 0.0156454648822546, 0.00863647647202015, -0.06388931721448898, 0.020518722012639046, 0.018543709069490433, 0.0376741960644722, -0.02274147979915142, -0.0026202222798019648, -0.015370318666100502, 0.022706985473632812, 0.023814121261239052, 0.04107700288295746, -0.03863854333758354, 0.001357679138891399, -0.054986219853162766, -0.027142832055687904, -0.00547326635569334, -0.014271991327404976, 0.0015121897449716926, -0.012423408217728138, -0.03595978766679764, 0.012322144582867622, -0.05432390794157982, -0.04125208035111427, -0.053125523030757904, -0.02296651527285576, 0.03791721537709236, -0.02547670714557171, -0.026260603219270706, -0.029832307249307632, 0.04356139153242111, 0.0450262613594532, 0.07214461266994476, -0.01937595196068287, -0.04066380485892296, -0.01116187870502472, 0.03461235389113426, 0.018561512231826782, -0.05833584815263748, 0.023338966071605682, -0.02718218043446541, 0.015826962888240814, 0.02140001207590103, -0.007937588728964329, -0.06451989710330963, 0.029812337830662727, -0.01964014209806919, -0.010867360047996044, 0.011151425540447235, -0.020522398874163628, 0.04636805132031441, 0.03784187510609627, -0.003072646213695407, 0.05705995857715607, 0.016504067927598953, 0.006633332464843988, -0.0074646309949457645, -0.044397685676813126, 0.0010913352016359568, -0.007254414726048708, 0.017375903204083443, -0.03392859175801277, -0.0043794852681458, -0.009379319846630096, 0.01845204457640648, -0.017242735251784325, 0.038316674530506134, -0.04499109461903572, -0.0037416694685816765, 0.0006598192267119884, -0.013592992909252644, -0.01074785552918911, 0.06053606793284416, 0.0036083045415580273, 0.022129742428660393, 0.018656158819794655, 0.005407536868005991, 0.020259039476513863, -0.014917494729161263, -0.001393455546349287, -0.0036049867048859596, -0.03227749466896057, -0.03288479894399643, -0.0461512990295887, -0.016931729391217232, 0.003040024545043707, -0.04956960678100586, 0.051185183227062225, -0.01220710575580597, 0.03675740957260132, 0.015185565687716007, 0.00301896664313972, -0.04486570879817009, 0.024343496188521385, -0.0011061376426368952, 0.04033113270998001, -0.024574216455221176, -0.00579317519441247, -0.02524084784090519, -0.007667643018066883, -0.05705002322793007, 0.013852342963218689, 0.0027725386898964643, -0.008400590158998966, -0.025033390149474144, -0.025082560256123543, 0.008609832264482975, 0.022137649357318878, -0.054631344974040985, -0.014626349322497845, 0.02094288356602192, -0.002013707999140024, -0.00925946980714798, -0.05422432720661163, 0.034607019275426865, 0.10264895111322403, -0.0030494844540953636, -0.005679691210389137, 0.008168123662471771, -0.019168976694345474, -0.027035832405090332, 0.023759203031659126, 0.0029718095902353525, 0.0030341199599206448, 0.02669067122042179, 0.006166371516883373, 0.007454400882124901, -0.0007221749401651323, -0.010618064552545547, -0.01742200180888176, -0.0031473860144615173, -0.0007135855266824365, -0.014935094863176346, -0.025344243273139, -0.011025793850421906, -0.001965767005458474, -0.0013206074945628643, -0.03528342396020889, 0.013673648238182068, -0.02904270775616169, 0.004261440131813288, 0.009078613482415676, 0.00645722821354866, -0.006488076411187649, 0.03047078289091587, 0.07814795523881912, -0.004186881706118584, -0.04884197190403938, -0.0037543210200965405, 0.0031205634586513042, 0.041467126458883286, -0.026842013001441956, -0.0009511618409305811, 0.029917297884821892, 0.022315815091133118, -0.02931460179388523, -0.0042128493078053, -0.08443048596382141, 0.03302590176463127, 0.04813212901353836, 0.021627342328429222, 0.05424438416957855, 0.03475877270102501, 0.0024053698871284723, -0.014416350051760674, -0.04267006367444992, -0.020853964611887932, -0.01588745415210724, -0.0012803804129362106, 0.03100186213850975, 0.007564594503492117, -0.017851797863841057, -0.009428214281797409, -0.007631388958543539, 0.018203863874077797, 0.029931215569376945, 0.02337709069252014, -0.05340483784675598, 0.012983319349586964, -0.005431012716144323, -0.009424115531146526, 0.027053644880652428, -0.05071346089243889, -0.0026116170920431614, -0.018416112288832664, 0.001202512881718576, -0.003303840756416321, 0.04123136028647423, -0.015497282147407532, -0.032812803983688354, -0.04794823378324509, -0.0686420202255249, 0.0038854675367474556, 0.004389943089336157, -0.02008897252380848, 0.05138116329908371, -0.002952203620225191, 0.03871975094079971, 0.007172405254095793, 0.025550302118062973, -0.01738530583679676, -0.046455249190330505, -0.015496636740863323, -0.016729233786463737, -0.06252890080213547, 0.042062077671289444, -0.017588147893548012, -0.023869065567851067, -0.0013549876166507602, -0.022573821246623993, 0.061309006065130234, -0.01997522823512554, 0.020203256979584694, -0.015279054641723633, 0.07331933826208115, 0.030109547078609467, 0.05492927134037018, -0.001404494047164917, -0.03061656281352043, 0.13782775402069092, 0.007336692418903112, 0.021529875695705414, 0.00044385847286321223, 0.018520774319767952, -0.01703769527375698, 0.01516492385417223, -0.021752430126070976, 0.014648002572357655, 0.023754913359880447, -0.034712452441453934, 0.013845156878232956, 0.01848028227686882, 0.021477334201335907, -0.04310339316725731, 0.03247826173901558, -0.03716486319899559, -0.029343614354729652, -0.021432217210531235, -0.01689344085752964, -0.028742656111717224, -0.033268533647060394, -0.009239893406629562, 0.02902429923415184, -0.03821626678109169, -0.01978963613510132, -0.05752449482679367, -0.019080480560660362, 0.026854034513235092, -0.047536756843328476, -0.0203132014721632, 0.0037564574740827084, 0.007095105946063995, -0.01136768888682127, -0.0035065277479588985, -0.0023231718223541975, 0.018459118902683258, -0.01593429408967495, 0.03642618656158447, 0.06069941446185112, -0.01599939912557602, 0.009421179071068764, -0.001475680386647582, 0.012973825447261333, -0.048615749925374985, -0.056626949459314346, -0.05041954293847084, 0.04891647771000862, -0.003881591372191906, -0.01928223855793476, -0.00836019404232502, 0.028991878032684326, -0.025536712259054184, -0.040503572672605515, 0.013036118820309639, 0.003579432610422373, 0.030905432999134064, -0.05740074813365936, -0.009610413573682308, -0.01829267106950283, 0.020997894927859306, 0.036209505051374435, 0.03833331912755966, 0.05566704645752907, -0.013525309972465038, -0.009585707448422909, -0.04057804495096207, 0.041230782866477966, -0.008357477374374866, -0.00037192244781181216, -0.016990523785352707, 0.016558170318603516, 0.02329413592815399, 0.0009332126355729997, 0.015136247500777245, -0.023676788434386253, 0.030257869511842728, 0.026555970311164856, 0.023358231410384178, -0.026913685724139214, -0.0626225546002388, 0.004520581569522619, -0.01778891310095787, 0.02283693477511406, -0.05181947723031044, -0.004944743122905493, -0.04741654917597771, 0.04750005155801773, 0.0237885769456625, -0.016025271266698837, 0.02251647226512432, 0.08457783609628677, 0.010661162436008453, -0.03825221210718155, -0.014794399030506611, -0.01777913048863411, -0.03860053792595863, -0.003923094365745783, -0.010494538582861423, 0.090882807970047, 0.05974240601062775, 0.025483248755335808, -0.0271050613373518, 0.022992810234427452, -0.02058425173163414, -0.004996851086616516, 0.007980193011462688, -0.03102920763194561, 0.008460675366222858, 0.033308979123830795, 0.013830493204295635, -0.008023740723729134, -0.02530352957546711, -0.04029811546206474, -0.03931056335568428, -0.02807433344423771, -0.051536183804273605, -0.006817930843681097, -0.029126711189746857, -0.032835952937603, 0.025976326316595078, -0.01569448411464691, 0.01956545189023018, 0.018522808328270912, 0.005434818100184202, -0.003558758646249771, -0.008581647649407387, -0.05072462558746338, 0.005442645400762558, 0.023865168914198875, -0.021532082930207253, 0.05348270386457443, 0.005068199709057808, 0.04083694890141487, -0.07182444632053375, 0.004208830650895834, -0.0041124350391328335, 0.03706277906894684, -0.0022187524009495974, -0.02546498365700245, 0.06579955667257309, -0.06769880652427673, -0.053345102816820145, 0.07259558886289597, 0.023910703137516975, 0.04563121497631073, 0.003705812618136406, -0.004624773282557726, -0.029391948133707047, 0.006123026832938194, -0.013446424156427383, -0.04518174007534981, -0.026118289679288864, -0.013202707283198833, 0.01434376835823059, -0.02076372504234314, 0.026328252628445625, -0.015986625105142593, 0.027973495423793793, 0.01257418841123581, 0.028942130506038666, -0.0030395418871194124, 0.022193297743797302, 0.03195895999670029, -0.005084190517663956, -0.014896306209266186, -0.018177948892116547, -0.004753092769533396, 0.03216005861759186, 0.03634651377797127, -0.03596122935414314, 0.007200056686997414, -0.022577358409762383, -0.009936762973666191, -0.08889017254114151, -0.053077101707458496, 0.02644296921789646, -0.01608910597860813, 0.045223820954561234, -0.05251190811395645, -0.02099696360528469, 0.009764761663973331, -0.039033737033605576, 0.01497911661863327, -0.003194166347384453, -0.012001585215330124, -0.028781268745660782, 0.039619557559490204, -0.03076043352484703, -0.0017570983618497849, -0.019486643373966217, 0.021345850080251694, 0.04180083051323891, 0.06863798201084137, 0.008557689376175404, -0.041498370468616486, -0.025766022503376007, 0.008652521297335625, 0.020262185484170914, -0.040311507880687714, 0.04786643385887146, -0.0558767206966877, -0.04136937856674194, 0.04436049610376358, -0.00484840851277113, 0.010662791319191456, -0.019546616822481155, 0.011922862380743027, 0.026740284636616707, 0.07756052911281586, 0.0767417699098587, 0.03684694319963455, 0.00453934958204627, 0.013697311282157898, 0.05705195292830467, -0.019962890073657036, -0.009181808680295944, -0.008027295581996441, 0.0613626092672348, 0.02567387744784355, -0.03570603206753731, -0.01675812341272831, 0.011607811786234379, -0.041622865945100784, -0.012766165658831596, -0.016952700912952423, -0.019554823637008667, -0.013092237524688244, -0.010567082092165947, -0.043228600174188614, -0.017162173986434937, 0.01994471438229084, 0.037249185144901276, -0.02868322841823101, -0.008567235432565212, -0.025500578805804253, -0.019104870036244392, -0.002420842181891203, -0.011135145090520382, 0.01086018793284893, -0.02288021892309189, -0.04790087416768074, 0.0030490923672914505, 0.0031207846477627754, -0.031241854652762413, 0.02062087133526802, -0.03840712830424309, -0.00289337569847703, -0.03038889169692993, -0.001882346230559051, -0.01170373149216175, -0.008922863751649857, 0.006256025284528732, -0.08532349020242691, 0.04341481998562813, -0.0005618311697617173, -0.02596445381641388, -0.03481588885188103, -0.0004985220730304718, -0.01776617206633091, -0.005584572441875935, 0.05237308144569397, -0.002735626418143511, -0.0023779855109751225, -0.01337059773504734, 0.06127162277698517, 0.016635926440358162, -0.09523377567529678, 0.03155827522277832, -0.01268510427325964, 0.000712953507900238, -0.00817215908318758, 0.001414470374584198, 0.014571252278983593, 0.01141083613038063, 0.034479741007089615, 0.003081279108300805, -0.03636426851153374, -0.018269749358296394, 0.005534812808036804, 0.029644768685102463, -0.021070081740617752, -0.014340739697217941, 0.015912631526589394, 0.006882613990455866, 0.013036678545176983, 0.021537866443395615, -0.02447277493774891, -0.04792347922921181, -0.008325965143740177, -0.020666679367423058, -0.021076638251543045, -0.023509949445724487, 0.006432405672967434, -0.023035600781440735, -0.07920543849468231, -0.02016170136630535, 0.042076367884874344, -0.028892241418361664, -0.00325043429620564, 0.05120391026139259, 0.009805086068809032, 0.04471815377473831, 0.007603084668517113, 0.015295830555260181, -0.01838911883533001, -0.000816380197647959, -0.020845597609877586, -0.005390090402215719, 0.040944963693618774, -0.036606866866350174, 0.005485501140356064, 0.01365996990352869, -0.02034660056233406, 0.018437141552567482, -0.0003708485164679587, 0.0455426461994648, 0.012970592826604843, 0.01236716564744711, 0.005012352019548416, -0.02469738759100437, -0.009538477286696434, 0.021773673593997955, -0.013752221129834652, 0.0880296379327774, -0.021247457712888718, 0.0005523516447283328, -0.0385747104883194, 0.031693439930677414, -0.045714959502220154, 0.04269087314605713, 0.03442392498254776, 0.02369825169444084, 0.0037964859511703253, 0.02083260752260685, 0.01562872901558876, 0.006877589039504528, -0.006177012342959642, -0.022921858355402946, -0.016789510846138, 0.022013183683156967, -0.001722992048598826, -0.024711525067687035, -0.030325623229146004, -0.02283143438398838, -0.042641688138246536, 0.010072428733110428, 0.0015366673469543457, 0.01997772417962551, 0.006773143075406551, -0.04957529902458191, -0.009717284701764584, 0.03890872374176979, -0.01259218156337738, 0.007645735517144203, -0.008525523357093334, -0.007322036195546389, -0.0008384601096622646, -0.01712845265865326 ]
<p>If I'm not wrong, likelihood functions are sensitive to the size of the sample, i.e. the larger the sample, the lower the likelihood value. Given a sample $x$ of a random variable $X \sim f(\theta)$, and a parameter estimate $\hat\theta$, suppose I want to test the hypothesis that the likelihoods of different subsamples of $x$, let's call them $x_a$ and $x_b$ are equal.</p> <p>The problem is $x_a$ and $x_b$ have a different number of elements, say $n_a$ and $n_b$ respectively, and $n_a \neq n_b$, so I assume the likelihoods must be normalized in some way. Is it enough to divide by the sample size? For instance, can I use a test statistic such as</p> <p>$T = \frac{\ell(\hat\theta|x_a)}{n_a} - \frac{\ell(\hat\theta|x_b)}{n_b}$</p> <p>and then test the hypothesis that $T = 0$. A related question would be how do I find the probability distribution of the above statistic, but that is another story.</p>
36,056
[ -0.03190493956208229, -0.0014832831220701337, 0.010716489516198635, -0.013882637955248356, 0.007689963094890118, 0.015276563353836536, -0.01337712537497282, -0.00657676300033927, 0.017305679619312286, -0.01806592009961605, 0.023761974647641182, 0.050308093428611755, 0.06580136716365814, 0.0063954610377550125, 0.027809342369437218, 0.011475293897092342, -0.043169744312763214, 0.026017991825938225, 0.004637543577700853, -0.010898331180214882, 0.014357980340719223, 0.013230676762759686, 0.03797854110598564, -0.042443517595529556, -0.00420432398095727, 0.03018546849489212, 0.03506717085838318, -0.049858737736940384, -0.0212151650339365, 0.10726598650217056, -0.03710739687085152, -0.02589084580540657, 0.010701283812522888, 0.05804206430912018, -0.006579900160431862, 0.0023926659487187862, -0.03514018654823303, -0.0497300960123539, -0.010994295589625835, 0.0461832620203495, -0.05658763274550438, -0.014219106175005436, 0.017606286332011223, 0.059212032705545425, -0.01764467917382717, 0.029482526704669, 0.004762853495776653, -0.03057464025914669, 0.012011387385427952, -0.0737428218126297, 0.10129694640636444, 0.03476934880018234, 0.03412304073572159, 0.03621276468038559, -0.016463616862893105, -0.02983822673559189, 0.02139449305832386, 0.07107909768819809, -0.030001148581504822, -0.03353950008749962, -0.038576263934373856, -0.05408626049757004, -0.0027050005737692118, -0.00945927482098341, -0.05203677713871002, 0.018627604469656944, -0.014195652678608894, -0.007747983559966087, 0.028747662901878357, -0.004464431665837765, 0.00022192239703144878, 0.018481779843568802, 0.046106595546007156, -0.014189787209033966, -0.010695048607885838, -0.03504430502653122, 0.015848170965909958, 0.03866610303521156, 0.059869103133678436, 0.07361224293708801, 0.013559076003730297, 0.01612897776067257, 0.013525398448109627, 0.028633398935198784, 0.024471906945109367, 0.00011423896648921072, 0.07859861105680466, -0.023248929530382156, 0.0029281422030180693, -0.007609778083860874, -0.035742200911045074, 0.010631095618009567, 0.04598885774612427, -0.04446738213300705, -0.04959123954176903, 0.05023385211825371, -0.027035638689994812, 0.031097203493118286, 0.00926952250301838, -0.024369675666093826, 0.0016085903625935316, -0.049981068819761276, 0.011241530068218708, 0.04505588486790657, -0.03594641387462616, 0.014223874546587467, -0.004513710271567106, 0.0033544411417096853, -0.027233561500906944, -0.006559946108609438, -0.012482182122766972, 0.02286345139145851, 0.025483151897788048, 0.0054664104245603085, -0.007495360914617777, -0.01418281253427267, -0.0171626266092062, -0.011771196499466896, 0.05610135570168495, 0.044417984783649445, 0.0763232409954071, 0.002735767513513565, 0.03985171392560005, -0.02718259021639824, -0.04798543080687523, 0.003733016550540924, -0.02160659059882164, -0.011193682439625263, -0.03228992596268654, 0.03391638025641441, -0.014816254377365112, -0.04765387997031212, 0.04809775575995445, -0.000704803504049778, 0.02846999652683735, -0.009336957708001137, -0.0666595920920372, -0.05977214127779007, 0.04587431997060776, -0.0034471333492547274, -0.007561144419014454, -0.032671548426151276, -0.018064934760332108, 0.040270667523145676, 0.01918412744998932, 0.0011788355186581612, 0.06538660824298859, -0.029848800972104073, 0.02542913146317005, 0.02233160100877285, -0.03366122394800186, 0.01105230301618576, -0.029854323714971542, 0.008449788205325603, 0.006096672732383013, -0.07645858824253082, 0.007699642330408096, 0.015477641485631466, -0.008370904251933098, -0.024898702278733253, 0.047273557633161545, 0.024549957364797592, -0.02131493389606476, -0.01208414789289236, 0.05277156084775925, -0.02258909121155739, 0.07974756509065628, -0.008887382224202156, -0.01277764793485403, 0.0027812046464532614, -0.000342148618074134, 0.00029180001001805067, 0.018891682848334312, 0.03029530495405197, 0.052685946226119995, -0.044861000031232834, -0.013139620423316956, -0.037594981491565704, 0.054891012609004974, 0.020473837852478027, -0.05203630030155182, -0.006193569395691156, 0.0012634271988645196, 0.008016933687031269, 0.016779374331235886, 0.03809953108429909, 0.024268321692943573, -0.03451138734817505, 0.036034099757671356, -0.06209905445575714, -0.018283365294337273, -0.08237139880657196, -0.00016150787996593863, -0.019932622089982033, -0.023236915469169617, 0.09308364242315292, 0.008017188869416714, 0.018226616084575653, -0.007581810001283884, -0.014476253651082516, -0.025247283279895782, -0.018776100128889084, 0.0067418236285448074, -0.03885798528790474, 0.015766439959406853, 0.030573692172765732, 0.06517469882965088, 0.003107371972873807, 0.0459013432264328, -0.037793371826410294, -0.0434214323759079, 0.00466374633833766, -0.04020334407687187, 0.03215539827942848, -0.0013138599460944533, -0.005663658492267132, -0.027370471507310867, -0.003275355789810419, -0.0008129525231197476, 0.0690145343542099, -0.04706649109721184, 0.04982554912567139, 0.06359230726957321, 0.02741318568587303, -0.003613156732171774, -0.018022118136286736, 0.03326279670000076, 0.0005684907082468271, 0.011063236743211746, -0.015025231055915356, -0.06205606088042259, -0.0051451316103339195, 0.05806460604071617, -0.009118437767028809, -0.01510664727538824, 0.0013986381236463785, 0.08016622811555862, 0.007044452242553234, -0.005193682853132486, 0.04061751812696457, -0.012733925133943558, -0.036768943071365356, -0.0004098089411854744, 0.010712547227740288, 0.010208300314843655, 0.01853308640420437, 0.030534029006958008, 0.008059405721724033, 0.04201424494385719, 0.03451153263449669, -0.008649454452097416, 0.045389220118522644, 0.0060926624573767185, -0.005521728657186031, -0.012687789276242256, 0.00423791166394949, 0.009976114146411419, -0.017424434423446655, 0.027686171233654022, 0.007379740476608276, 0.012691519223153591, -0.0011078553507104516, 0.01702129654586315, 0.0008098392281681299, 0.06638596951961517, -0.0015372505877166986, 0.0011899246601387858, 0.02277298830449581, 0.018584877252578735, -0.021660741418600082, 0.003595187794417143, -0.026085030287504196, -0.04049817845225334, -0.03003416396677494, -0.010857068933546543, 0.006110090296715498, 0.0004918075283057988, 0.04356565698981285, -0.027730414643883705, -0.04360298067331314, -0.01807330548763275, -0.02589758299291134, 0.03099636361002922, -0.0021322257816791534, -0.05182914808392525, 0.004453329369425774, -0.015628328546881676, -0.05121806263923645, 0.019352400675415993, 0.000019508912373567, 0.0001508178247604519, 0.007766903843730688, -0.026327887549996376, -0.03578556329011917, -0.0069204336032271385, -0.0094553017988801, -0.01205437071621418, -0.05755019560456276, 0.0022532937582582235, 0.020505864173173904, 0.010917874984443188, -0.031495600938797, 0.006622432265430689, -0.03832177817821503, -0.0333990678191185, -0.014168900437653065, -0.004453249741345644, 0.0031984541565179825, -0.011211282573640347, 0.0345023050904274, 0.02090880274772644, -0.05517420172691345, -0.001745508867315948, -0.04756839945912361, -0.042622629553079605, -0.002940436126664281, 0.010753820650279522, 0.026802754029631615, -0.0026134520303457975, -0.05808297172188759, 0.04772231727838516, 0.027732286602258682, -0.0034094953443855047, -0.02104046568274498, 0.0014390558935701847, -0.034922536462545395, -0.013554811477661133, 0.00982128456234932, 0.013185663148760796, 0.0024405652657151222, 0.037705861032009125, 0.019300444051623344, 0.0022405977360904217, 0.04908187314867973, 0.01820218935608864, 0.009273920208215714, 0.03733862563967705, 0.03530559316277504, -0.03686581552028656, 0.04357677325606346, 0.0370725579559803, -0.004803625866770744, 0.016727639362215996, -0.006597581785172224, 0.021026451140642166, 0.013793468475341797, -0.01522450614720583, -0.0010857457527890801, -0.013065900653600693, -0.00573038961738348, -0.052514612674713135, 0.032325271517038345, 0.010210764594376087, -0.02243933640420437, 0.0006483869510702789, 0.03875467926263809, 0.020094212144613266, -0.021017294377088547, -0.005143107380717993, 0.03124142624437809, 0.014333785511553288, -0.056202106177806854, -0.02439405396580696, -0.034005992114543915, 0.016081901267170906, -0.0026366515085101128, -0.026922855526208878, -0.05115918442606926, 0.06817574799060822, 0.05054209753870964, 0.03381897881627083, -0.017524685710668564, -0.02419576235115528, 0.011807604692876339, -0.04154147580265999, 0.012496769428253174, -0.029698660597205162, 0.039117977023124695, 0.03803244233131409, 0.050051022320985794, 0.03972969949245453, -0.0004568482981994748, 0.020741820335388184, 0.004600768443197012, -0.08951178193092346, 0.04163524508476257, -0.03880224749445915, -0.011487656272947788, 0.012448688969016075, -0.007002427242696285, 0.04384109005331993, -0.03505470231175423, 0.029609456658363342, 0.012421625666320324, 0.041983332484960556, -0.015519283711910248, 0.010489397682249546, -0.012008746154606342, -0.041604410856962204, 0.004736451432108879, 0.008294026367366314, 0.006355775520205498, 0.019811881706118584, 0.017037605866789818, 0.07166875153779984, -0.027014510706067085, -0.004177130293101072, -0.05271091312170029, 0.02486247383058071, -0.01444578729569912, 0.006740859244018793, 0.0287360567599535, 0.020065275952219963, -0.0333455353975296, 0.027845362201333046, -0.0030709875281900167, 0.0766376256942749, 0.052946750074625015, 0.001726029790006578, -0.017762502655386925, -0.03522464260458946, -0.03640064224600792, -0.012329303659498692, 0.030690109357237816, 0.027241181582212448, -0.0195170845836401, 0.05383682623505592, 0.027221623808145523, -0.011256234720349312, -0.0034638657234609127, 0.04542158171534538, -0.0009695821790955961, 0.01063568890094757, -0.01187966763973236, 0.009330600500106812, -0.004457105416804552, 0.02643594890832901, 0.004618374165147543, 0.005103291943669319, 0.0125063331797719, -0.025167271494865417, 0.04656727984547615, -0.015939032658934593, -0.024882160127162933, -0.0002152442466467619, -0.018590839579701424, 0.011523501947522163, -0.006954196374863386, -0.04561803862452507, 0.046566035598516464, 0.020014159381389618, 0.025605885311961174, 0.03136499971151352, -0.009354210458695889, -0.07100726664066315, 0.037293966859579086, 0.04126341640949249, 0.006123578641563654, -0.04064992070198059, 0.010501670651137829, -0.03426685184240341, -0.007330984342843294, 0.043079864233732224, -0.010865425691008568, 0.01757112890481949, 0.02068392187356949, 0.02632327564060688, -0.05689142271876335, 0.00928539875894785, -0.03400631994009018, 0.01035632286220789, -0.03383474797010422, -0.008079322054982185, -0.03952998295426369, -0.015498350374400616, -0.016567956656217575, 0.016129055991768837, 0.01825781911611557, 0.06267889589071274, -0.021832482889294624, -0.05344004184007645, -0.0013020348269492388, 0.03367869183421135, -0.009193615056574345, -0.059035878628492355, -0.003979027271270752, 0.00974730122834444, -0.011708037927746773, 0.004494753200560808, -0.019610924646258354, -0.06478222459554672, 0.05335484817624092, -0.015803145244717598, -0.014952382072806358, 0.008861380629241467, 0.006181854754686356, 0.04099791496992111, 0.014156678691506386, 0.05553030967712402, 0.06668511033058167, 0.020862624049186707, 0.041835520416498184, -0.02047855779528618, -0.030188804492354393, 0.00948728621006012, -0.02205977775156498, -0.008771302178502083, -0.05255039036273956, 0.008609295822679996, -0.015371978282928467, 0.041525863111019135, -0.0036215598229318857, 0.04001616686582565, -0.014003046788275242, -0.021567512303590775, -0.012953627854585648, 0.04725702852010727, 0.02749539166688919, 0.000012909366887470242, 0.03702116385102272, 0.03140556067228317, 0.006420609541237354, -0.0016604592092335224, 0.015700705349445343, -0.04522383213043213, 0.00493933679535985, 0.0003821292775683105, -0.03530564904212952, 0.04453423619270325, -0.04404362291097641, 0.004202551208436489, 0.022595133632421494, -0.007032536901533604, 0.030428238213062286, -0.00622984953224659, 0.023733843117952347, -0.002987376879900694, -0.01637570746243, -0.015132186003029346, 0.032801393419504166, 0.0037210832815617323, 0.05491785705089569, -0.06706458330154419, 0.016570651903748512, -0.00856069941073656, -0.003902623662725091, -0.07569852471351624, 0.003411984071135521, -0.024904729798436165, 0.028436897322535515, 0.01556321606040001, -0.047416895627975464, -0.021011127158999443, 0.016080442816019058, -0.03938274085521698, -0.008114537224173546, 0.07611774653196335, -0.0012465035542845726, -0.013279329054057598, -0.04150979593396187, 0.0020511557813733816, 0.10182975232601166, 0.01199420914053917, -0.027036985382437706, 0.004599374253302813, -0.0008197234710678458, 0.000664923049043864, 0.027995232492685318, -0.004862124565988779, -0.03230561688542366, -0.00888890027999878, -0.013770141638815403, -0.0023865927942097187, 0.02320794202387333, -0.031085247173905373, -0.03590267524123192, -0.009966260753571987, 0.012395423837006092, 0.013253600336611271, -0.005366043653339148, -0.029149265959858894, -0.008580773137509823, 0.020101316273212433, -0.013418585993349552, -0.006807106547057629, -0.004138491116464138, -0.00042886260780505836, 0.006936029531061649, -0.0023590796627104282, -0.01764577440917492, -0.0052007948979735374, 0.1060367077589035, -0.01777701824903488, 0.019528502598404884, 0.025483284145593643, 0.00060315674636513, 0.05354122817516327, 0.01108104083687067, -0.008833076804876328, 0.010834136046469212, 0.025043228641152382, -0.03070211410522461, -0.010619068518280983, -0.01628388836979866, -0.03064637817442417, 0.05212756246328354, -0.005038288421928883, 0.03921132907271385, 0.026898551732301712, -0.03031253069639206, -0.01607494242489338, -0.03902819752693176, -0.015250250697135925, -0.05904944986104965, 0.00420865323394537, 0.02210497111082077, -0.022797223180532455, -0.016448594629764557, 0.06122741848230362, 0.004731975495815277, 0.019497718662023544, 0.04000767692923546, 0.03749113902449608, 0.005346584599465132, 0.02064640261232853, -0.018718773499131203, -0.04327452555298805, 0.07342448830604553, -0.06126122549176216, 0.013768874108791351, -0.04186676815152168, 0.0006598627078346908, 0.043147191405296326, 0.01920066773891449, 0.03671206906437874, -0.026478851214051247, -0.01686965674161911, -0.04774941876530647, 0.0487305112183094, 0.03114817664027214, -0.014477365650236607, 0.023780979216098785, 0.027747809886932373, 0.017853865399956703, -0.001849076827056706, 0.0054956055246293545, -0.024135056883096695, -0.0758800283074379, -0.04478877782821655, -0.0402413047850132, -0.02861807309091091, 0.011508682742714882, -0.015445498749613762, -0.0012578453170135617, 0.04591350257396698, -0.04015282168984413, 0.0292066540569067, -0.024119118228554726, 0.028248704969882965, -0.04577513411641121, 0.06491192430257797, -0.010845291428267956, 0.02403002418577671, -0.01584894023835659, 0.0007984572439454496, 0.11027728021144867, 0.051358602941036224, 0.043812643736600876, -0.03532245010137558, -0.004622061736881733, -0.0018236112082377076, -0.01518832053989172, -0.04804060980677605, 0.010690041817724705, 0.0032711587846279144, -0.0294119194149971, 0.004781214985996485, 0.04026469588279724, 0.0007557415519841015, -0.02133161760866642, 0.05993536859750748, 0.0008840096998028457, -0.060493577271699905, 0.00039448353345505893, -0.009482556022703648, -0.025993838906288147, -0.028314003720879555, -0.05574793368577957, 0.0034995018504559994, -0.0166330486536026, -0.00866813026368618, -0.02355620078742504, -0.004200942814350128, -0.0062962062656879425, -0.002404441125690937, -0.035287778824567795, -0.03100847452878952, 0.035436008125543594, 0.02693670615553856, -0.020890608429908752, 0.001111876219511032, 0.007525022141635418, -0.010248547419905663, 0.022968968376517296, 0.08290106058120728, 0.0126021234318614, 0.007380166091024876, -0.0156366266310215, 0.009421242401003838, -0.04064737632870674, -0.010966411791741848, -0.03221416100859642, 0.050882212817668915, -0.02176758274435997, 0.013406197540462017, -0.002244514413177967, -0.0038201347924768925, -0.022471170872449875, -0.025006983429193497, 0.01343803945928812, -0.002692922716960311, 0.009482072666287422, -0.011256096884608269, 0.008494595997035503, -0.02277505025267601, 0.04650215432047844, 0.01807430014014244, 0.02426893822848797, 0.023481523618102074, -0.009443091228604317, 0.008302455767989159, -0.005617637652903795, 0.05650824308395386, -0.015620764344930649, -0.01207625214010477, 0.00840709451586008, -0.035519134253263474, -0.02470550872385502, -0.012573594227433205, 0.03013676591217518, -0.009809249080717564, 0.057730015367269516, -0.009451455436646938, 0.0032248152419924736, -0.03376865014433861, -0.06159916892647743, -0.0010707919718697667, -0.038990385830402374, -0.015162351541221142, -0.018699226900935173, 0.021028820425271988, 0.046857062727212906, 0.0360606424510479, 0.012419658713042736, 0.008244091644883156, 0.03159865364432335, 0.0488767996430397, 0.03325119614601135, -0.0716833770275116, -0.04596762731671333, 0.010202274657785892, 0.029696758836507797, 0.003602219047024846, -0.022413797676563263, 0.051829833537340164, 0.02038738876581192, 0.02967333234846592, -0.025916432961821556, 0.004267298616468906, -0.015563951805233955, 0.003464973531663418, -0.006192407570779324, -0.018065784126520157, 0.005426608957350254, 0.043188754469156265, 0.004332337062805891, 0.00870514940470457, -0.02731863036751747, -0.04946776106953621, -0.0009147698292508721, 0.04575256630778313, -0.024271564558148384, -0.03850717097520828, -0.021753869950771332, -0.005665036849677563, -0.021334512159228325, -0.019052397459745407, 0.010649113915860653, 0.007806085981428623, -0.02801940031349659, -0.004395117983222008, -0.010527241975069046, 0.015036503784358501, 0.0018308964790776372, -0.050140734761953354, -0.019707607105374336, 0.03184918314218521, 0.001604394055902958, 0.015376872383058071, -0.0018604389624670148, 0.007959406822919846, -0.01090047974139452, 0.06816941499710083, -0.02760671079158783, 0.00168763124383986, 0.05636962875723839, -0.05898511782288551, -0.04737154766917229, 0.038342755287885666, 0.011938299983739853, 0.040934596210718155, 0.004819474183022976, -0.004909771028906107, -0.008992377668619156, 0.0193954948335886, -0.0357835628092289, -0.000957001349888742, -0.01328642014414072, 0.0013386763166636229, 0.009210772812366486, 0.0002898532839026302, -0.000791966391261667, 0.008394252508878708, -0.002524865325540304, 0.06297972053289413, 0.0557086244225502, 0.0057660238817334175, -0.010274226777255535, 0.028889376670122147, 0.028170166537165642, 0.00858213473111391, -0.0033418547827750444, -0.019260309636592865, 0.041406624019145966, 0.07176102697849274, -0.023450493812561035, 0.027591966092586517, -0.012042451649904251, 0.031099367886781693, -0.10050449520349503, -0.03224463388323784, 0.014756813645362854, -0.0019528619013726711, 0.01602877490222454, -0.08152133226394653, -0.037754710763692856, 0.010919955559074879, -0.03843362256884575, 0.017943887040019035, -0.0032477006316184998, -0.03448282182216644, -0.04157751053571701, 0.012744779698550701, -0.04425549879670143, 0.022327037528157234, 0.00972757488489151, 0.028176508843898773, 0.03123214654624462, 0.03170676529407501, 0.009113864041864872, -0.029513124376535416, -0.007420614827424288, -0.008685166016221046, 0.020519353449344635, -0.07684700936079025, 0.025939885526895523, -0.03254729509353638, -0.04616694524884224, 0.0509326308965683, -0.001651747734285891, 0.002100639510899782, -0.0013975563924759626, 0.030822275206446648, 0.006078529637306929, 0.03005976974964142, 0.05281638726592064, 0.0074486820958554745, -0.033772051334381104, 0.033667486160993576, 0.01941739395260811, 0.04750388488173485, -0.04522205889225006, -0.025748543441295624, 0.023121044039726257, -0.014270332641899586, -0.012613918632268906, 0.010402284562587738, -0.015134546905755997, -0.0238944124430418, -0.027673019096255302, -0.04252362996339798, -0.01134199183434248, -0.039135318249464035, 0.0237763449549675, -0.030080053955316544, 0.002579079009592533, 0.021700508892536163, 0.017978545278310776, -0.01975982077419758, 0.015401726588606834, -0.02815959043800831, -0.029757658019661903, 0.013333193026483059, 0.006939834449440241, -0.009087720885872841, -0.04446623846888542, -0.025676513090729713, -0.01911167800426483, 0.0018849675543606281, -0.025878265500068665, -0.012246299535036087, -0.02701006643474102, 0.03693503513932228, -0.030114762485027313, 0.018596386536955833, 0.014569178223609924, 0.0017502171685919166, 0.0003713667974807322, -0.09295041114091873, 0.051066551357507706, -0.012929561547935009, 0.0037442788016051054, -0.04115304350852966, -0.020493431016802788, -0.012892872095108032, -0.010420571081340313, 0.020452991127967834, -0.0020968292374163866, 0.027803316712379456, 0.01617530919611454, 0.02171449549496174, 0.0009544187341816723, -0.06954968720674515, 0.026860257610678673, -0.021957101300358772, -0.040972210466861725, -0.014141116291284561, -0.02150598354637623, 0.03324112296104431, 0.008773011155426502, 0.013913731090724468, 0.0042604259215295315, -0.011468455195426941, -0.021379021927714348, -0.008150790818035603, 0.03816206380724907, 0.00035946627031080425, -0.008373169228434563, 0.06106023117899895, 0.011081664822995663, 0.015413638204336166, -0.020858358591794968, -0.004516432993113995, -0.05711498484015465, 0.019377179443836212, -0.04441739246249199, -0.053660690784454346, -0.0021328344009816647, 0.014393786899745464, 0.036490559577941895, -0.04847795143723488, -0.01924617402255535, 0.003689873730763793, -0.04544981196522713, 0.013249563984572887, 0.005408426281064749, 0.05085501819849014, 0.05356501415371895, -0.005767206195741892, -0.009688318707048893, 0.031088709831237793, 0.01192640420049429, 0.013993731699883938, 0.004985069390386343, -0.0024417077656835318, -0.0150254862383008, -0.003428764408454299, 0.004244418349117041, -0.024487841874361038, 0.011172746308147907, -0.03236781060695648, 0.04033653810620308, -0.006426034960895777, -0.04190221056342125, 0.02983585186302662, -0.008944027125835419, 0.02212921716272831, -0.017986372113227844, -0.0035972557961940765, 0.07497876137495041, -0.022022824734449387, -0.021015217527747154, -0.02555936574935913, 0.03706062212586403, -0.00863646063953638, 0.006970181129872799, 0.01088652852922678, -0.01916213519871235, -0.0007108396966941655, -0.007344338111579418, 0.009607142768800259, -0.03919072076678276, 0.04062582924962044, -0.02200951799750328, -0.009749549441039562, 0.002083009807392955, -0.02570975571870804, -0.019332485273480415, -0.004333618097007275, -0.018168823793530464, -0.032860904932022095, -0.012981931678950787, 0.014923885464668274, 0.04011809825897217, -0.03399094566702843, -0.01204111147671938, 0.014472929760813713, 0.041485048830509186, -0.04102228954434395, -0.03659695386886597, -0.03017294779419899, -0.0010798039147630334, 0.014746231026947498, -0.038926996290683746 ]
<p>In a panel regression using fixed effects, is it correct to use an instrument that does not vary by year? To use an old but simple example, Angrist and Kruger 1991 use quarter of birth as an instrument for education. If one had access to similar data that was in panel form, is it still correct (and I don't mean specifically quarter of birth, I know there are problems with the validity of this IV) to use quarter of birth (same for each respondent regardless of panel wave) as an instrument in the panel IV regression? Why or why not?</p>
36,057
[ 0.003322020871564746, -0.013268410228192806, 0.00913223996758461, -0.0021900017745792866, 0.04537449777126312, 0.023018941283226013, -0.008163650520145893, -0.02367865853011608, 0.032609086483716965, -0.02534898929297924, 0.005932539235800505, 0.0015186334494501352, 0.0706053301692009, -0.03542336821556091, 0.030530381947755814, 0.025017093867063522, -0.004910748451948166, 0.013012618757784367, -0.024244388565421104, 0.013825307600200176, -0.038026805967092514, 0.04783393815159798, -0.03833926096558571, -0.022825926542282104, -0.014924649149179459, 0.04313385486602783, -0.0019226687727496028, -0.004800194408744574, 0.007355289999395609, 0.04237297177314758, -0.024185936897993088, -0.03898962214589119, 0.006828639656305313, 0.012149778194725513, 0.011769687756896019, -0.015882957726716995, 0.00005024843630963005, -0.03764183819293976, 0.001162407803349197, 0.04360898956656456, -0.040416181087493896, 0.011531700380146503, 0.005876741372048855, 0.056014787405729294, -0.009472141973674297, 0.04555709287524223, -0.00009675098408479244, -0.028771642595529556, 0.042267102748155594, -0.03232376277446747, 0.07268117368221283, -0.0009352959459647536, 0.031289488077163696, 0.07965584844350815, -0.02738184854388237, -0.015347111038863659, 0.06034009903669357, 0.06864770501852036, 0.0008257041336037219, -0.0035786230582743883, -0.033861804753541946, -0.05075355991721153, 0.01100875809788704, 0.010456064715981483, -0.029321473091840744, -0.015260498970746994, 0.005194202996790409, -0.017001178115606308, 0.020587537437677383, -0.06480048596858978, 0.01199852954596281, 0.0014562677824869752, 0.03392263501882553, -0.02008950151503086, 0.002776866080239415, -0.047032251954078674, 0.0219337809830904, 0.024956120178103447, 0.04544550180435181, 0.0465739481151104, -0.021154828369617462, 0.0020115491934120655, 0.031047973781824112, 0.039640817791223526, 0.021517043933272362, -0.0016922075301408768, 0.04286801069974899, -0.03458721190690994, 0.030236920341849327, 0.0044511593878269196, -0.04027826339006424, -0.0012581555638462305, 0.06504456698894501, -0.007463433779776096, -0.06096792221069336, 0.041335608810186386, -0.01384689100086689, 0.01759430766105652, 0.01981746219098568, -0.0013054620940238237, -0.0005850745947100222, -0.04791663959622383, -0.008775566704571247, 0.03799103945493698, 0.030703619122505188, -0.002549361903220415, -0.025315921753644943, 0.03827149420976639, -0.012416873127222061, -0.02469470538198948, 0.015958033502101898, 0.01997850462794304, -0.022967131808400154, 0.009661498479545116, 0.08101292699575424, -0.002933402545750141, -0.020026642829179764, 0.0005983203300274909, 0.09491399675607681, 0.05681847035884857, 0.028172023594379425, -0.05466371029615402, 0.02220212109386921, -0.01381535455584526, -0.0536111518740654, 0.0346502959728241, -0.011087585240602493, 0.0009975074790418148, -0.03416726738214493, 0.032103486359119415, 0.01371969748288393, -0.03178507834672928, 0.04737585037946701, -0.04889560490846634, 0.04852423816919327, 0.03690388798713684, -0.046979304403066635, -0.065422922372818, 0.015128730796277523, 0.004406734835356474, 0.00769822159782052, -0.07837142795324326, 0.019210901111364365, -0.02854302152991295, 0.0434948205947876, -0.0118842339143157, 0.02964700013399124, 0.0368739552795887, 0.058999013155698776, 0.0077733262442052364, -0.027335232123732567, -0.02695048786699772, -0.006897210143506527, -0.07275719940662384, -0.014369281008839607, -0.07723342627286911, 0.011414234526455402, 0.019217155873775482, 0.011735775507986546, 0.00785557646304369, 0.06743413209915161, 0.01873638667166233, -0.011940478347241879, 0.0837208703160286, 0.02872462011873722, -0.0447397381067276, 0.06518633663654327, -0.022233253344893456, 0.027521846815943718, 0.027318919077515602, 0.02865401655435562, 0.04070449620485306, 0.023655343800783157, 0.029270756989717484, 0.018781045451760292, -0.031249837949872017, 0.012260118499398232, -0.029012974351644516, 0.026518365368247032, 0.020101042464375496, -0.06241361051797867, -0.0034771424252539873, -0.037631213665008545, -0.01803051307797432, 0.014778613112866879, 0.031629715114831924, -0.007500129751861095, -0.006078141741454601, 0.02028338983654976, -0.056754130870103836, -0.05333976820111275, -0.05511816218495369, 0.01933271810412407, 0.028308186680078506, -0.01971517503261566, 0.027728673070669174, -0.023895150050520897, 0.0350705087184906, -0.01215263269841671, -0.01755126751959324, -0.021874839439988136, 0.006531905382871628, -0.00793544203042984, -0.06733054667711258, 0.02272820845246315, 0.007850084453821182, 0.06464233994483948, 0.020149530842900276, 0.05894845724105835, -0.04607594758272171, -0.02706172503530979, 0.015612699091434479, -0.028852812945842743, 0.04234350100159645, -0.03382521867752075, -0.021134573966264725, -0.009382781572639942, -0.019780447706580162, -0.024233274161815643, 0.06288859248161316, -0.04350385069847107, 0.049236807972192764, 0.05621793866157532, -0.0120301004499197, -0.011964925564825535, 0.008979752659797668, 0.036376696079969406, 0.01128777302801609, -0.008020895533263683, -0.02980463020503521, -0.04931246489286423, 0.019454967230558395, 0.0018052890663966537, 0.004475932102650404, -0.004066831897944212, 0.027952877804636955, 0.0710807740688324, 0.005517048295587301, -0.003383062779903412, 0.022355733439326286, 0.0275629423558712, -0.006975619122385979, 0.018328070640563965, 0.005964298266917467, -0.0026916589122265577, 0.004096909426152706, 0.025945933535695076, -0.01764129288494587, 0.025078527629375458, 0.02184404246509075, 0.03304680064320564, 0.030373748391866684, 0.01214875839650631, 0.012227739207446575, -0.01565318927168846, 0.0023286298383027315, 0.02193336933851242, -0.042596153914928436, 0.03940144181251526, 0.04474082961678505, 0.014396445825695992, -0.02126568742096424, 0.009630628861486912, -0.03169117867946625, 0.019325079396367073, 0.02522147260606289, -0.048791516572237015, 0.010673662647604942, 0.01421173196285963, 0.024982383474707603, 0.012212460860610008, -0.04980917647480965, -0.03644198551774025, 0.018110238015651703, -0.011829757131636143, 0.02606819197535515, 0.002901929896324873, -0.00931544415652752, -0.018692631274461746, 0.0035377659369260073, -0.015541356056928635, -0.0013134557520970702, 0.02386438101530075, 0.021324943751096725, -0.04498676210641861, 0.01556155551224947, -0.02342662587761879, -0.03537522256374359, 0.021507062017917633, -0.004464399069547653, 0.0014318161411210895, 0.05402467027306557, 0.0021250597201287746, -0.023203322663903236, -0.023142151534557343, -0.029760189354419708, -0.013696286827325821, -0.005322860553860664, -0.029474474489688873, 0.013843431137502193, 0.005860562901943922, 0.009821431711316109, -0.010685205459594727, -0.03169737011194229, -0.041550930589437485, 0.044066090136766434, -0.011763312853872776, 0.04295387491583824, -0.00029037659987807274, 0.025877468287944794, 0.02675313502550125, -0.023605136200785637, 0.00339674879796803, -0.030681079253554344, -0.0828699916601181, 0.02946070395410061, -0.021437397226691246, 0.015144146978855133, -0.011406411416828632, -0.016380395740270615, 0.05024079233407974, 0.0276465006172657, -0.0013916997704654932, -0.023801298812031746, -0.0009971914114430547, 0.004888206720352173, -0.03674513101577759, 0.03079189732670784, -0.0032781646586954594, 0.018413636833429337, 0.007202340289950371, -0.02022634819149971, 0.01651611179113388, 0.05524514243006706, 0.01194426603615284, 0.01176389865577221, 0.008083313703536987, 0.04106936231255531, -0.020687216892838478, 0.013971509411931038, 0.02083669975399971, -0.02711815945804119, -0.006776229478418827, -0.02576024830341339, 0.028883161023259163, 0.01122682448476553, -0.02537061646580696, 0.03272360563278198, -0.03711206838488579, -0.009188356809318066, -0.012620856054127216, 0.03630073741078377, 0.03055797889828682, 0.012911783531308174, -0.06615705788135529, -0.012729177251458168, -0.021055355668067932, -0.023043815046548843, 0.015860818326473236, 0.021230751648545265, 0.0012423195876181126, 0.0207357294857502, 0.004057832527905703, -0.0034648615401238203, 0.0042946855537593365, 0.03374478965997696, -0.011006937362253666, -0.019112873822450638, 0.02588774263858795, 0.026191290467977524, 0.008839276619255543, -0.024576179683208466, -0.04670717567205429, 0.018765611574053764, -0.06018112599849701, -0.022432580590248108, -0.023424267768859863, 0.022104745730757713, -0.005741122644394636, 0.024877440184354782, -0.006911850068718195, 0.013576329685747623, 0.013670428656041622, 0.007925970479846, -0.029805244877934456, -0.004116642288863659, -0.03847381845116615, 0.004847812466323376, -0.006418915465474129, -0.003126914380118251, 0.03952212631702423, -0.010320122353732586, -0.012382627464830875, -0.015163878910243511, 0.01296392921358347, -0.027180498465895653, -0.014873141422867775, -0.00954993162304163, -0.007691120263189077, -0.0039337701164186, -0.020138967782258987, -0.039007071405649185, -0.023843633010983467, 0.0017413332825526595, 0.02023729868233204, 0.047896720468997955, -0.002018861472606659, -0.03196209669113159, -0.04177258908748627, -0.004237911198288202, 0.045907750725746155, 0.029969029128551483, -0.010793491266667843, -0.06467688083648682, 0.02853456698358059, 0.023618891835212708, 0.026426563039422035, 0.0304613895714283, -0.0012073845136910677, -0.025281433016061783, -0.0005781390354968607, -0.02632511965930462, 0.013259350322186947, 0.023300161585211754, 0.031017575412988663, -0.0035446498077362776, 0.05839311331510544, 0.027351059019565582, -0.029176335781812668, 0.011905956082046032, 0.08962076157331467, -0.004444709047675133, -0.0042813001200556755, -0.05912454053759575, 0.023027636110782623, -0.015842249616980553, -0.010099592618644238, 0.01668645441532135, 0.01169329509139061, 0.01549518946558237, 0.006754215341061354, 0.04335101321339607, 0.020708031952381134, -0.05655963346362114, 0.05688435584306717, 0.012903074733912945, 0.030009834095835686, -0.00020470011804718524, -0.03337503969669342, 0.030990811064839363, 0.04325799271464348, 0.0371767096221447, 0.02344527095556259, 0.010576847940683365, -0.06971755623817444, -0.000846926704980433, 0.014974680729210377, 0.013024085201323032, -0.047301605343818665, -0.006284210365265608, -0.029651107266545296, -0.017334749922156334, 0.01384541392326355, -0.024249089881777763, -0.009355670772492886, -0.04749999940395355, -0.012781621888279915, -0.05442549288272858, -0.00849625188857317, -0.021018441766500473, 0.021027466282248497, 0.008544539101421833, 0.018099680542945862, 0.004258710891008377, -0.014049175195395947, -0.008044193498790264, 0.0023923786357045174, 0.015314478427171707, 0.042116399854421616, -0.011958186514675617, -0.023878706619143486, 0.03389250114560127, 0.016418585553765297, -0.041343264281749725, -0.03302450850605965, 0.03692338243126869, 0.01525296550244093, 0.0030475144740194082, -0.0010068215196952224, 0.012019823305308819, -0.027331458404660225, -0.005125097464770079, 0.0006546630756929517, 0.028763720765709877, 0.02696317620575428, -0.02525663934648037, 0.04602592810988426, -0.02703404799103737, 0.024762051180005074, 0.056591641157865524, 0.07134630531072617, 0.03353423997759819, 0.033237941563129425, -0.03480326756834984, 0.006690220441669226, -0.07516654580831528, -0.03564612194895744, -0.02862694300711155, -0.013040293008089066, 0.005866240710020065, 0.01095438003540039, -0.0054018800146877766, 0.02320685237646103, -0.047224801033735275, -0.02973013184964657, 0.0023467489518225193, 0.01763322949409485, 0.0047686235047876835, -0.023579038679599762, -0.023288019001483917, -0.0112369479611516, -0.022229716181755066, -0.024235734716057777, 0.027272243052721024, -0.02256167307496071, 0.0022204092238098383, 0.0013789873337373137, -0.02578539028763771, 0.02670530416071415, 0.009676719084382057, -0.027687789872288704, 0.03367070108652115, -0.014120315201580524, 0.01299070194363594, -0.034295037388801575, -0.02534041926264763, -0.015363116748631, -0.06937725096940994, 0.000734472181648016, 0.012434296309947968, -0.005986124277114868, 0.06104438379406929, -0.04770215228199959, 0.021313199773430824, 0.025980016216635704, -0.01053208950906992, -0.10338298231363297, -0.02306288108229637, -0.003388599958270788, -0.022975005209445953, -0.008813479915261269, 0.028835121542215347, 0.02599727362394333, -0.03039087913930416, -0.01611037738621235, -0.017707476392388344, 0.08852964639663696, -0.01686464436352253, -0.016298983246088028, -0.03762756288051605, 0.02586703933775425, 0.0713978111743927, -0.017238490283489227, -0.00359366531483829, -0.005191822070628405, -0.06484559923410416, 0.02509581670165062, -0.029421595856547356, 0.01525392197072506, -0.009634444490075111, 0.038191504776477814, -0.015553358942270279, -0.02453700825572014, 0.01794528402388096, -0.023543715476989746, -0.021754184737801552, 0.06729001551866531, -0.03131335973739624, 0.01901058852672577, -0.02801208756864071, 0.0247581135481596, -0.0711025819182396, -0.01342327706515789, -0.014600935392081738, 0.03224904090166092, -0.0029049753211438656, -0.020297305658459663, 0.021747028455138206, -0.06032898649573326, -0.026623668149113655, 0.012480287812650204, 0.07090100646018982, -0.03216058760881424, -0.012978626415133476, 0.007219279184937477, -0.03245828300714493, 0.040851738303899765, 0.00279989349655807, -0.015942346304655075, 0.012536726891994476, 0.019655907526612282, -0.01632777974009514, -0.023357681930065155, -0.022684408351778984, -0.004773383028805256, 0.07148025184869766, 0.008737431839108467, 0.014567716047167778, 0.07118082046508789, -0.006342811975628138, -0.006760856136679649, -0.013788850978016853, 0.022441072389483452, 0.014679732732474804, -0.060151662677526474, 0.06060468405485153, -0.040090885013341904, -0.04326128959655762, 0.01637633703649044, 0.016360606998205185, 0.008160260505974293, 0.03158548101782799, 0.013552493415772915, 0.06575115770101547, 0.01845415309071541, 0.021423378959298134, -0.07368756085634232, 0.005896560847759247, -0.029781173914670944, -0.0011277837911620736, -0.0357421413064003, -0.034944720566272736, 0.018675025552511215, 0.023323113098740578, 0.015467572957277298, -0.06199699267745018, -0.030933860689401627, -0.016256703063845634, 0.018297892063856125, 0.06798664480447769, 0.0038695321418344975, 0.02210957743227482, -0.008825715631246567, 0.0376824252307415, 0.035685595124959946, 0.010849475860595703, -0.03955727443099022, -0.06181459501385689, -0.05088373273611069, -0.046808287501335144, -0.0011206937488168478, -0.0022690389305353165, -0.0064964257180690765, -0.00878528319299221, 0.005836977157741785, -0.03290845826268196, -0.02134879305958748, -0.0025194711051881313, 0.022033963352441788, 0.00435481546446681, 0.04299077391624451, -0.009295870549976826, -0.001498222234658897, 0.0033585235942155123, 0.02015095390379429, 0.13107800483703613, 0.06466708332300186, 0.010405794717371464, -0.07284268736839294, 0.05132583528757095, -0.001901789684779942, -0.005509182810783386, -0.03115108422935009, 0.021382862702012062, 0.021222729235887527, -0.07120460271835327, 0.029048772528767586, 0.08565618842840195, 0.00772651843726635, 0.035420700907707214, 0.04656483605504036, -0.005830403883010149, -0.024571619927883148, -0.003459610277786851, 0.02220878005027771, 0.03167456015944481, 0.009071050211787224, -0.00939872581511736, -0.034174755215644836, -0.02234332077205181, 0.0002258564200019464, 0.010133160278201103, -0.0019511834252625704, 0.00447781290858984, 0.009078055620193481, -0.027073465287685394, 0.0010373125551268458, 0.012468175031244755, 0.0028940036427229643, -0.05608135834336281, -0.042904339730739594, -0.00737341120839119, -0.022972704842686653, 0.025305358693003654, 0.014163008891046047, -0.007941004820168018, -0.015687987208366394, 0.03444570302963257, 0.012886682525277138, -0.027059709653258324, 0.0034906710498034954, -0.01773066446185112, 0.020136477425694466, 0.009976939298212528, -0.01934506557881832, -0.03716941922903061, -0.008740444667637348, -0.018334683030843735, -0.044536788016557693, -0.04401804134249687, 0.01309452299028635, 0.03689003363251686, -0.023565901443362236, 0.002084155334159732, -0.007315864320844412, -0.014394043944776058, -0.02383960597217083, 0.052161309868097305, 0.02432982809841633, -0.05890631303191185, -0.01749204844236374, 0.008255059830844402, 0.009262076579034328, -0.008578998036682606, -0.0546521320939064, 0.040041569620370865, -0.011817592196166515, -0.07314550876617432, -0.00953192450106144, 0.02487015910446644, 0.02581917494535446, 0.051511500030756, -0.02673519030213356, 0.015552332624793053, -0.03008100390434265, -0.029395394027233124, 0.0016402130713686347, -0.011125675402581692, -0.002901231637224555, -0.07458900660276413, 0.04277750104665756, 0.021109797060489655, 0.03840582072734833, -0.06054357811808586, 0.029317747801542282, -0.005204538814723492, 0.06711673736572266, 0.016625965014100075, -0.06532680988311768, 0.009346275590360165, 0.003984686452895403, -0.028397023677825928, -0.01568557880818844, -0.03919174522161484, 0.030886733904480934, 0.016713498160243034, -0.002588871633633971, -0.011382846161723137, 0.03803176432847977, -0.0203365758061409, 0.05049104616045952, 0.031223604455590248, -0.07362721115350723, -0.000805009389296174, 0.01666332595050335, 0.021800806745886803, -0.03163844347000122, -0.04242126643657684, -0.03516369313001633, -0.017161861062049866, -0.016785118728876114, -0.02927860990166664, -0.03209448233246803, 0.007799447048455477, -0.03229919448494911, -0.0066569531336426735, -0.019281834363937378, -0.005738389678299427, -0.0586090087890625, 0.0074915336444973946, 0.029849722981452942, -0.030450861901044846, 0.005968691781163216, 0.037014190107584, -0.0033158764708787203, -0.028978144749999046, 0.040731701999902725, 0.020679084584116936, 0.008470368571579456, 0.0031565213575959206, -0.008327657356858253, -0.0003769589529838413, 0.052943985909223557, -0.044765230268239975, -0.02075597271323204, 0.008655487559735775, -0.04364429786801338, -0.059943199157714844, 0.04209224879741669, 0.0054931179620325565, 0.023366261273622513, 0.015820302069187164, 0.03764874488115311, 0.007817113772034645, 0.06192004680633545, -0.023590078577399254, 0.032377470284700394, 0.0045918007381260395, -0.01197243295609951, -0.015227774158120155, -0.021396629512310028, -0.035947803407907486, 0.07104900479316711, -0.03291837126016617, 0.054770927876234055, 0.024258406832814217, 0.027028322219848633, -0.0237819105386734, -0.004380970727652311, -0.023448506370186806, -0.00791457761079073, 0.021438466385006905, 0.012154615484178066, 0.0391768254339695, 0.048545364290475845, -0.006467120721936226, 0.0038155121728777885, -0.008498694747686386, 0.008009111508727074, -0.04575832188129425, -0.00958299357444048, 0.02952425740659237, 0.06966080516576767, 0.02494552545249462, -0.010964756831526756, 0.00491669587790966, -0.003211987903341651, -0.035360630601644516, -0.005173464771360159, -0.03337548300623894, -0.005339376162737608, -0.04632067680358887, 0.0014485664432868361, 0.006315135397017002, 0.012337806634604931, 0.03754115849733353, 0.0034184004180133343, -0.000490419624838978, 0.03549078106880188, 0.03215837851166725, -0.05155107006430626, -0.006381866056472063, 0.01764257624745369, 0.023088278248906136, -0.07357959449291229, 0.011485927738249302, -0.05077635496854782, -0.039553381502628326, 0.0419144481420517, 0.005175792146474123, 0.04163224250078201, -0.0034912775736302137, 0.016831086948513985, 0.012439394369721413, 0.02579028718173504, 0.04578351229429245, 0.0013982203090563416, -0.008714862167835236, -0.00996829941868782, 0.021909566596150398, 0.01408536359667778, -0.01135735958814621, 0.006784139666706324, 0.018899641931056976, -0.013560988008975983, -0.024360783398151398, -0.024881524965167046, 0.004767454229295254, 0.02358616143465042, 0.007771551609039307, -0.02567310817539692, -0.00017793013830669224, 0.05001628398895264, 0.03275815024971962, -0.019423821941018105, 0.00010101862426381558, 0.02654426172375679, 0.008618381805717945, -0.010580400936305523, -0.008129305206239223, -0.013398648239672184, -0.04591348394751549, 0.01163187064230442, -0.010631379671394825, -0.005902441684156656, -0.04871935024857521, 0.014750315807759762, -0.006129458546638489, -0.014327027834951878, -0.017701463773846626, 0.003666909411549568, -0.02311066910624504, 0.03659101948142052, -0.03234430402517319, -0.027835508808493614, -0.009455238468945026, -0.022258367389440536, -0.0037344025913625956, -0.06502719223499298, 0.09749173372983932, 0.02596782147884369, -0.016511475667357445, -0.015376906841993332, 0.0014743831707164645, -0.05480004847049713, 0.04173906892538071, 0.033166658133268356, -0.010228434577584267, -0.00006814045627834275, 0.01027691550552845, 0.007215291261672974, 0.008886896073818207, -0.04568219184875488, 0.06482856720685959, -0.012464627623558044, -0.026965809985995293, -0.006854792591184378, 0.02689707651734352, -0.052205462008714676, 0.010383070446550846, 0.005918463692069054, 0.011566318571567535, 0.052363310009241104, 0.03308795392513275, -0.005153602454811335, 0.016665857285261154, 0.025566106662154198, -0.011573851108551025, 0.06244386360049248, -0.01740356720983982, 0.03144645690917969, 0.05022048205137253, 0.015567565336823463, -0.07891502976417542, -0.0065595004707574844, -0.03887541964650154, -0.026402145624160767, -0.009522225707769394, 0.02788265235722065, -0.00711715966463089, -0.048320211470127106, 0.014629448764026165, 0.03633415699005127, -0.03159324824810028, -0.01533468160778284, 0.05103791132569313, 0.02928379736840725, 0.015517760999500751, -0.008827781304717064, 0.011720269918441772, 0.006269541569054127, -0.009910414926707745, 0.011313199065625668, -0.017999162897467613, 0.04290803149342537, 0.028656162321567535, 0.01236998476088047, 0.022600410506129265, 0.004050595685839653, -0.0013276324607431889, -0.007532324176281691, 0.05009417608380318, -0.026891890913248062, -0.05321628227829933, 0.014045504853129387, 0.0035687971394509077, 0.00923430360853672, 0.041864484548568726, 0.0027948743663728237, 0.020933467894792557, -0.03588807210326195, 0.0030503023881465197, -0.006914236582815647, 0.0000338692007062491, -0.027686968445777893, 0.020192978903651237, 0.001647107070311904, 0.026248671114444733, -0.02550409361720085, -0.007996203377842903, -0.008128679357469082, -0.050947416573762894, 0.01380823738873005, -0.03969482332468033, 0.00029712505056522787, -0.0076934099197387695, -0.030776740983128548, -0.03667294606566429, 0.02596232295036316, -0.07243755459785461, -0.006648121401667595, 0.026247045025229454, 0.014040391892194748, 0.02902226708829403, -0.024536054581403732, -0.02401432953774929, 0.0027648985851556063, 0.03771228715777397, -0.05329607054591179, 0.007872364483773708, -0.0269427802413702, 0.01754961535334587, 0.007463655900210142, 0.0003037420683540404 ]
<p>I am currently working on biomass estimates using satellite imagery. I'll quickly define the background of my question, and then explain the statistical question I am working on.</p> <p><strong>Background</strong></p> <p><em>Problem</em> </p> <p>I am trying to estimate biomass over an area in France. My response is the steamwood volume density (in $m^3/ha$), which is more or less proportional to biomass (depending on the wood densities...).</p> <p>The independent variables that I have are vegetation indices derived from measured reflectances over this area (the satellite used in the study is MODIS for those who know it). These indices are for example NDVI, EVI, etc. I have maps of the indices, and the resolution of the maps are 250m.</p> <p>There are strong correlations between these indices and the volume in a same forest type (biome and climate). So I am trying to regress the volume density against these indicators (actually their time series) on inventory plots where I know the volume.</p> <p><em>Forest inventories</em></p> <p>The volume on these plots is estimated with the following sampling method:</p> <ol> <li>Inventory nodes are placed on a regular grid covering the area.</li> <li>A plot is attached to each node, and the inventory process (tree types, volumes, canopy height, etc.) occurs on this plot. Of course I am interested only in the inventory plot and the values of my vegetation indices is the value of the pixel containing the plot.</li> <li><p>The inventory process on a plot is the following: </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/qcHtu.png" alt="http://i.stack.imgur.com/DeHdC.png"></p> <ul> <li>Measure of the trees that have a diameter > 37.5cm in the 15m radius circle</li> <li>Measure of the trees that have a diameter > 22.5cm in the 9m radius circle</li> <li>Measure of the trees that have a diameter > 7.5cm in the 6m radius circle</li> </ul></li> </ol> <p>The volume density is then calculated using expansion factors.</p> <p>For each plot I have access to the data for all the measured trees. </p> <p>Moreover, for each single tree, I have an uncertainty on the volume due to the use of allometric equations (let us say 10%).</p> <p><strong>Where statistics are important...</strong></p> <p>For my regressions to be more accurate, I need for each estimate of volume the variance/CI of this measure. This depends, IMO, on the number of trees sampled and the volume density found.</p> <p>So I have two problems:</p> <ol> <li><p>How to account for the fact that my vegetation indices are measured over a pixel of 250m ?</p> <blockquote> <p>I can assume that the volume density is constant over one pixel, and that I sample this pixel with one inventory plot.</p> </blockquote></li> <li><p>How to estimate the variability of my volume density? </p> <blockquote> <p>I think I could use bootstrapping on the tree population. But my total number of trees measured can be pretty small (from 7 to 20...). Moreover, how can I take into account the fact that I am measuring the trees on different circles depending on their sizes ? And how should the variability change if I am looking on an entire pixel ?</p> </blockquote></li> </ol> <blockquote> <p>I was also thinking that I could use a Monte Carlo Simulation to simulate a forest, and then randomly sample this forest with plots to see what is going on...</p> </blockquote> <p>I do not have a strong statistical background, so I am a little bit lost!</p>
36,058
[ -0.038177795708179474, 0.00018526142230257392, 0.029295150190591812, 0.021478168666362762, 0.055279314517974854, -0.008758033625781536, -0.043450307101011276, -0.03668735548853874, 0.03756306692957878, -0.041445598006248474, 0.04387025535106659, 0.02276242896914482, 0.07997020334005356, 0.04851698502898216, -0.016348665580153465, 0.006766166538000107, -0.0052732182666659355, 0.0134740537032485, -0.01651345007121563, -0.026733359321951866, -0.008902331814169884, 0.04421515390276909, 0.011667383834719658, -0.022664235904812813, -0.03273550420999527, 0.0685126855969429, 0.011877063661813736, -0.014596084132790565, -0.017421865835785866, 0.06957408040761948, -0.05982569605112076, -0.01817234419286251, -0.01703215204179287, 0.04336442053318024, 0.04334336146712303, 0.011850602924823761, -0.02587289921939373, -0.04007519781589508, 0.04619427025318146, 0.05218951404094696, -0.02144674025475979, -0.01533733494579792, -0.00653788261115551, -0.000352828879840672, -0.011842784471809864, 0.051951814442873, -0.013518057763576508, -0.02853461354970932, 0.06702818721532822, -0.03566361963748932, 0.09254404157400131, 0.02398734726011753, 0.04778086766600609, 0.064478799700737, -0.01863747090101242, -0.024432186037302017, 0.06463290005922318, 0.06859515607357025, -0.016293132677674294, -0.015616079792380333, -0.017372185364365578, 0.021071838214993477, 0.011264702305197716, 0.003803899744525552, -0.01273935567587614, -0.013315699994564056, 0.012328063137829304, 0.0021427408792078495, 0.04647959768772125, 0.0050392160192132, 0.006712139584124088, 0.020390888676047325, 0.013207081705331802, -0.01910470984876156, 0.009331452660262585, -0.026034578680992126, 0.0257332194596529, 0.022654008120298386, 0.05151249095797539, 0.0003831543726846576, 0.013739659450948238, 0.018963783979415894, 0.005565951578319073, -0.014573187567293644, 0.031916484236717224, 0.027747998014092445, 0.07062181830406189, -0.028530221432447433, 0.00794422347098589, 0.008999899961054325, 0.01810433715581894, 0.019872983917593956, 0.0406423844397068, -0.026060905307531357, -0.008639042265713215, 0.03408827260136604, -0.0455247163772583, 0.03370809927582741, -0.01635238341987133, 0.01631137914955616, -0.03175067529082298, -0.027212804183363914, 0.02996703051030636, 0.045832812786102295, -0.02350796014070511, -0.01694701425731182, -0.01884785108268261, 0.004985703621059656, 0.001708658179268241, -0.03438057377934456, -0.03621194139122963, 0.04673014208674431, -0.0024881199933588505, -0.030677564442157745, 0.03666781634092331, -0.008196323178708553, 0.010112069547176361, -0.0007717600674368441, 0.04412923753261566, 0.06685896217823029, 0.04874290153384209, -0.022323764860630035, 0.004346386529505253, -0.03993774950504303, -0.07239505648612976, 0.037953197956085205, 0.024998990818858147, -0.00874374806880951, -0.029110562056303024, 0.03761250525712967, 0.003342547919601202, 0.0019647430162876844, 0.0757729709148407, -0.028589412569999695, 0.018648331984877586, 0.04823572561144829, -0.08707644790410995, -0.05506317690014839, 0.030395038425922394, 0.007466986775398254, 0.022665975615382195, -0.04973555728793144, 0.0013259509578347206, 0.03410932049155235, 0.05085877701640129, -0.014447178691625595, 0.02008686773478985, 0.02484375238418579, 0.029071437194943428, -0.01960626244544983, -0.011764997616410255, -0.03627936169505119, 0.0017530983313918114, -0.02787059172987938, -0.0034574426244944334, -0.08858330547809601, 0.030291549861431122, 0.02025078423321247, -0.014476284384727478, -0.02272704243659973, 0.04109310358762741, 0.029814423993229866, 0.015174683183431625, 0.02261347882449627, 0.013036957941949368, -0.05667707324028015, 0.04899624362587929, 0.011412940919399261, 0.010156773962080479, -0.010803615674376488, 0.007665527984499931, -0.013297759927809238, 0.013688977807760239, 0.011405058205127716, 0.07065433263778687, -0.007328805513679981, 0.00737946480512619, -0.01779554784297943, -0.008903281763195992, 0.04876306653022766, -0.026431001722812653, -0.07203464210033417, -0.020126812160015106, -0.0026200904976576567, 0.07439400255680084, -0.021138478070497513, -0.0015867174370214343, -0.07710978388786316, 0.04275546967983246, -0.06543122977018356, -0.04887736961245537, -0.06891021132469177, -0.018071303144097328, -0.018068203702569008, -0.012205312959849834, -0.002824438037350774, -0.02521752379834652, -0.010731219314038754, 0.006942740175873041, -0.023706350475549698, 0.00421646423637867, 0.005927312653511763, 0.036810338497161865, -0.03672272711992264, -0.023134863004088402, 0.02554943971335888, 0.05987568199634552, -0.004914084915071726, 0.012999940663576126, -0.03737363591790199, -0.05237041041254997, -0.04129987955093384, -0.03193582221865654, 0.01967117376625538, -0.0239156074821949, -0.033737849444150925, 0.006516678724437952, 0.027395689859986305, -0.02657453715801239, -0.0038475431501865387, -0.03462110087275505, 0.07316000014543533, 0.0799577459692955, -0.010121087543666363, -0.016472388058900833, 0.023466993123292923, 0.010492987930774689, 0.03260542452335358, -0.02405243180692196, -0.03547278046607971, -0.07779393345117569, 0.00395214045420289, 0.023335644975304604, 0.02859940379858017, 0.00332178664393723, 0.039694078266620636, 0.06354359537363052, 0.027721146121621132, 0.0028738677501678467, 0.016508208587765694, 0.0009557817247696221, 0.0013909096596762538, -0.0011879965895786881, -0.013740282505750656, 0.0154569735750556, -0.016078006476163864, -0.04010845348238945, -0.01393070723861456, 0.050814613699913025, -0.016040856018662453, 0.025666411966085434, 0.016130076721310616, -0.025751154869794846, -0.01526477187871933, 0.03014129213988781, -0.0017122755525633693, 0.022779516875743866, 0.011485678143799305, -0.013305162079632282, 0.04043789207935333, 0.017574099823832512, 0.030833063647150993, -0.0012374912621453404, -0.016030658036470413, 0.014035400934517384, 0.028210315853357315, -0.047925323247909546, -0.015241828747093678, 0.01825077272951603, -0.016396645456552505, 0.025938451290130615, -0.016462303698062897, -0.011117745190858841, -0.024894990026950836, -0.0045331004075706005, 0.023176981136202812, 0.0015316350618377328, 0.016229327768087387, -0.014614671468734741, -0.026308495551347733, -0.02464034967124462, -0.003971914295107126, 0.02249710075557232, 0.02655457891523838, -0.028672613203525543, 0.015307950787246227, 0.00038656152901239693, 0.030444784089922905, -0.0021032916847616434, 0.014721039682626724, -0.029734546318650246, 0.036597009748220444, 0.008171145804226398, -0.0670110210776329, -0.054232705384492874, -0.024126369506120682, 0.029017021879553795, 0.006036027334630489, 0.000021493016902240925, 0.046808961778879166, 0.014688504859805107, -0.03526442125439644, -0.006564320530742407, -0.07233880460262299, -0.01206789631396532, -0.05006898567080498, 0.018168896436691284, -0.03252024203538895, -0.006624620873481035, 0.0002775339817162603, 0.029874341562390327, 0.0013590870657935739, 0.0106336185708642, -0.06858544796705246, -0.05626519396901131, 0.014488558284938335, 0.04225993901491165, 0.041404906660318375, -0.025830401107668877, -0.014156325720250607, 0.07516586780548096, -0.0031139024067670107, -0.034265752881765366, -0.036846358329057693, -0.023368483409285545, -0.022001167759299278, 0.00048727099783718586, 0.016665397211909294, -0.0070615424774587154, 0.019566409289836884, 0.021541384980082512, -0.0017761343624442816, 0.026566853746771812, 0.03166836127638817, 0.003827515058219433, -0.008936814032495022, 0.04844926670193672, -0.007394419051706791, -0.011111319065093994, 0.0704926922917366, 0.02253454551100731, -0.0009859446436166763, 0.006521044299006462, -0.05332915112376213, -0.001442654407583177, -0.013144104741513729, -0.09107055515050888, -0.00945255160331726, -0.0205784123390913, 0.03072335384786129, -0.053343500941991806, 0.04310127720236778, 0.022104965522885323, -0.033151183277368546, -0.020281055942177773, 0.010967401787638664, 0.05799955502152443, 0.010559086687862873, -0.03859075531363487, 0.06415897607803345, 0.03260384127497673, 0.006628750823438168, 0.01962035708129406, -0.0194379985332489, -0.002848608186468482, -0.011117978021502495, -0.055010389536619186, 0.01857069693505764, 0.043298088014125824, 0.05873876437544823, 0.005219246260821819, -0.01652185618877411, -0.02757946401834488, 0.005326585378497839, -0.05334774777293205, -0.003415593644604087, -0.022994836792349815, 0.05067264661192894, 0.022576602175831795, 0.058707017451524734, 0.00011909941531484947, 0.010427065193653107, 0.00801766850054264, 0.023120347410440445, -0.03349548205733299, -0.01079102698713541, 0.017137747257947922, -0.01266112457960844, 0.0003989136894233525, -0.008991336449980736, 0.016291746869683266, -0.015491479076445103, 0.01669803075492382, -0.03043362684547901, 0.04078098386526108, -0.05971303582191467, -0.03071950189769268, -0.0029834574088454247, -0.002510729944333434, -0.02881244756281376, 0.022151611745357513, 0.04702386632561684, -0.04793909937143326, 0.0634850338101387, 0.04215136915445328, 0.031072081997990608, -0.034633178263902664, -0.02405376359820366, -0.0034978182520717382, 0.04504657909274101, 0.012906868010759354, -0.015818996354937553, 0.009205356240272522, -0.044341739267110825, 0.023181553930044174, 0.04301723465323448, 0.05516476929187775, 0.052091967314481735, 0.00035398773616179824, 0.018056334927678108, 0.01356346346437931, -0.006520095746964216, 0.015024924650788307, 0.0038147575687617064, -0.030758406966924667, -0.053610797971487045, 0.04675344005227089, 0.022913392633199692, -0.04635137692093849, 0.026722606271505356, 0.022462232038378716, 0.012603993527591228, 0.01673351228237152, -0.024142764508724213, -0.006448487751185894, -0.008612880483269691, 0.005811743438243866, 0.06497278064489365, 0.02824396640062332, -0.004470705054700375, -0.007824800908565521, 0.013162102550268173, -0.02248506247997284, -0.0480777733027935, 0.01408431213349104, 0.003013953333720565, 0.022880807518959045, -0.02576783299446106, -0.03035501390695572, 0.021110955625772476, 0.02563902549445629, 0.015860039740800858, -0.0013434730935841799, 0.018178187310695648, -0.09402192384004593, -0.04435354843735695, 0.03978539630770683, -0.008268768899142742, -0.018643368035554886, -0.008805893361568451, -0.09635726362466812, -0.018590128049254417, -0.008496841415762901, -0.03096943534910679, 0.013084501028060913, -0.04405873641371727, 0.012417151592671871, 0.016733694821596146, -0.06908918917179108, -0.014079040847718716, -0.026437008753418922, -0.002922288840636611, 0.006399382837116718, -0.023776795715093613, -0.028970427811145782, -0.04833850637078285, 0.04116172343492508, 0.015660570934414864, 0.03912137821316719, -0.009770979173481464, -0.015114362351596355, 0.0004885541857220232, -0.015199446119368076, -0.013231800869107246, -0.042654283344745636, 0.04501921311020851, 0.00465804897248745, 0.027334896847605705, 0.05558943375945091, -0.015446257777512074, -0.04509266838431358, 0.026557188481092453, 0.018716687336564064, -0.0372970886528492, -0.013974112458527088, -0.015953196212649345, 0.030430356040596962, 0.04913506284356117, -0.0007027791580185294, 0.061063893139362335, 0.06045815721154213, 0.0114959217607975, 0.034824129194021225, -0.06022605299949646, 0.051554907113313675, -0.047046151012182236, -0.043470598757267, -0.044803645461797714, -0.02597685530781746, -0.010465710423886776, -0.005575474817305803, 0.009201521053910255, 0.04695603623986244, -0.03713231906294823, -0.041348498314619064, 0.02884519286453724, 0.027416154742240906, 0.018744125962257385, 0.022111808881163597, 0.012546958401799202, 0.013695052824914455, 0.014925445429980755, -0.021084560081362724, 0.018855726346373558, 0.007103887852281332, -0.008035763166844845, 0.009515846148133278, -0.021525954827666283, -0.0034462129697203636, -0.03607314079999924, -0.025180013850331306, -0.00759092066437006, -0.017645323649048805, 0.05441214144229889, -0.02142323926091194, 0.07323062419891357, 0.008327178657054901, -0.031202485784888268, -0.016154617071151733, 0.005702030844986439, -0.015706771984696388, -0.006047721486538649, -0.02767329104244709, 0.024085083976387978, -0.008679292164742947, 0.03716721758246422, -0.0330345444381237, -0.017611263319849968, -0.001481726998463273, 0.022459419444203377, -0.029483865946531296, -0.06268229335546494, -0.008392326533794403, 0.024684665724635124, -0.03423704206943512, -0.013686302118003368, 0.021445760503411293, -0.032655443996191025, -0.021138733252882957, -0.03085876628756523, 0.013094027526676655, 0.06121335178613663, -0.05787455663084984, 0.01814504712820053, 0.03262471780180931, -0.024181358516216278, -0.005451729521155357, -0.01316101849079132, -0.005136137828230858, -0.030460629612207413, -0.014076916500926018, -0.05348929390311241, 0.03620509058237076, 0.019561320543289185, 0.024155745282769203, -0.04404433071613312, 0.015765873715281487, 0.010753436014056206, -0.008875575847923756, -0.023014558479189873, -0.003217278979718685, -0.008943109773099422, -0.017022551968693733, -0.049986787140369415, 0.004661566112190485, -0.01491465698927641, -0.012327232398092747, 0.026073960587382317, -0.02893640100955963, 0.015521612018346786, 0.0506046786904335, 0.056922439485788345, -0.007204605266451836, 0.024955809116363525, 0.03294435888528824, 0.002256903564557433, 0.010656424798071384, -0.015492185950279236, -0.017082177102565765, 0.03962017968297005, 0.02829037979245186, -0.03806779533624649, -0.0172277819365263, -0.03261907398700714, -0.008503727614879608, 0.03758123889565468, -0.0010474546579644084, 0.03250283747911453, 0.01398983784019947, -0.007371844258159399, 0.044990044087171555, -0.0479174442589283, -0.011961196549236774, -0.02322457544505596, -0.02726713940501213, 0.06753451377153397, -0.002547631738707423, 0.019743436947464943, 0.04590730369091034, -0.0017778073670342565, -0.005343627650290728, 0.009963765740394592, -0.000536205421667546, 0.014580466784536839, 0.027494683861732483, -0.04434597119688988, -0.04556141048669815, 0.00034379487624391913, -0.013866975903511047, 0.025843055918812752, -0.0120159350335598, -0.023634912446141243, 0.03580218181014061, 0.05512712523341179, -0.038068003952503204, -0.055929820984601974, -0.015085699036717415, -0.05037054792046547, 0.00695818942040205, 0.03144669532775879, -0.02346731908619404, 0.011492814868688583, -0.0019379443256184459, 0.008812197484076023, -0.019577698782086372, -0.005130464676767588, -0.03312715142965317, -0.0598999559879303, -0.042560942471027374, -0.010783745907247066, -0.04001274332404137, 0.05994551256299019, -0.0225520022213459, -0.00829002633690834, 0.033525604754686356, -0.03204433247447014, 0.014502251520752907, 0.026420556008815765, 0.046407509595155716, -0.0022737043909728527, 0.037512507289648056, 0.018287353217601776, -0.004097473341971636, -0.04581790789961815, 0.0027852989733219147, 0.12086424976587296, 0.056767787784338, 0.011250227689743042, -0.03152267262339592, 0.01765209063887596, 0.0574762262403965, -0.009899660013616085, -0.0215474683791399, -0.015034507028758526, 0.012336594052612782, -0.04610208794474602, 0.01908104307949543, 0.0010022020433098078, -0.005575241055339575, 0.025646599009633064, 0.02446160838007927, 0.010307595133781433, 0.0015708304708823562, 0.017075667157769203, 0.015103158541023731, -0.014178890734910965, 0.03150835633277893, -0.05729876831173897, 0.020853441208600998, -0.018567804247140884, -0.03244612738490105, -0.032277803868055344, -0.03308066353201866, 0.03516007214784622, 0.009271658025681973, -0.039741598069667816, 0.024290073662996292, 0.044026825577020645, -0.0030354559421539307, 0.01190287433564663, 0.0017110652988776565, -0.0015276242047548294, -0.009873928502202034, 0.01600026711821556, 0.012436099350452423, -0.03900850936770439, -0.011263985186815262, -0.011361435987055302, -0.0020450667943805456, -0.04783106595277786, -0.027251536026597023, -0.03155865520238876, 0.032215796411037445, 0.017061037942767143, -0.03221719339489937, -0.029177291318774223, 0.026093721389770508, 0.009396011009812355, -0.04036974161863327, 0.039558377116918564, 0.0005886902217753232, 0.016165202483534813, -0.042720235884189606, -0.049923963844776154, 0.019979381933808327, 0.010650844313204288, -0.0083925174549222, 0.041198283433914185, 0.013727736659348011, -0.006147308275103569, -0.020066995173692703, -0.03748558089137077, 0.022871868684887886, 0.0028270480688661337, 0.008701561950147152, 0.03041556105017662, -0.017861858010292053, -0.005398108623921871, -0.04520310461521149, -0.0031458227895200253, -0.010744373314082623, 0.02934633195400238, -0.016888035461306572, -0.025645708665251732, -0.023265691474080086, -0.0881156325340271, 0.014887288212776184, -0.05088099092245102, -0.021722521632909775, -0.07228796929121017, 0.026412835344672203, 0.01648252084851265, 0.03443165495991707, 0.03272885084152222, 0.007198502775281668, -0.01289405021816492, 0.06018655002117157, 0.026457326486706734, -0.03435836732387543, -0.056468017399311066, 0.02939227782189846, -0.023893428966403008, -0.01962619088590145, 0.01224518846720457, 0.045162927359342575, 0.03981538861989975, 0.015951871871948242, -0.0033010568004101515, 0.03648127615451813, 0.008534771390259266, 0.015338672325015068, -0.007225774694234133, -0.048868149518966675, 0.03776528313755989, -0.008763118647038937, 0.014412561431527138, -0.023652203381061554, 0.0016671641496941447, -0.0004337785649113357, -0.02969825640320778, 0.004347039386630058, -0.01516181044280529, -0.026791298761963844, 0.012302245944738388, -0.03635668754577637, 0.03486401215195656, -0.023989545181393623, -0.01464791689068079, -0.032938018441200256, 0.011273122392594814, 0.006026012357324362, -0.0009542427724227309, -0.026391850784420967, -0.0013906069798395038, -0.0318218395113945, -0.014172966592013836, 0.06554307043552399, -0.011997733265161514, 0.029194584116339684, -0.007103864103555679, 0.019687233492732048, 0.02488226816058159, 0.044991232454776764, 0.0012944499030709267, -0.002645027358084917, 0.03306964412331581, -0.017280273139476776, -0.015960510820150375, 0.005752720404416323, -0.015479038469493389, 0.05023960396647453, 0.034834202378988266, 0.010044998489320278, -0.021290285512804985, 0.028698917478322983, -0.002277564723044634, 0.0023309739772230387, -0.004902940709143877, -0.002188325161114335, 0.04869293048977852, -0.017879821360111237, 0.025647586211562157, 0.01564684323966503, -0.008268330246210098, 0.024041781201958656, 0.02257695235311985, -0.010038706474006176, -0.007095587905496359, 0.029920833185315132, -0.01710425689816475, 0.003002335550263524, -0.026344604790210724, -0.020395193248987198, 0.041516706347465515, 0.020197266712784767, -0.03937136009335518, 0.004942113067954779, 0.014013552106916904, -0.016930008307099342, -0.03636958822607994, -0.011772902682423592, 0.003249897388741374, 0.00016018110909499228, 0.036757875233888626, -0.03679315000772476, -0.025577984750270844, 0.0687166377902031, -0.02737211063504219, 0.007439856417477131, 0.026730908080935478, 0.015138066373765469, -0.05528305470943451, 0.010158909484744072, -0.01371691096574068, -0.007742323912680149, 0.043763335794210434, 0.0319117046892643, 0.02714337594807148, 0.05698132514953613, 0.0160747729241848, -0.019847450777888298, -0.00946110300719738, 0.01962711103260517, 0.020275238901376724, -0.060252632945775986, 0.010857880115509033, -0.04125193506479263, 0.011376045644283295, -0.009294717572629452, 0.01038410048931837, 0.027315249666571617, 0.025799619033932686, 0.01293562725186348, -0.017578057944774628, 0.04943472146987915, 0.045848820358514786, 0.011478465050458908, 0.001669267425313592, -0.015441065654158592, -0.006174239795655012, 0.013712627813220024, -0.018435977399349213, -0.0014391150325536728, 0.029143761843442917, -0.018763752654194832, 0.013447782956063747, 0.031079091131687164, 0.01800495758652687, -0.029453031718730927, 0.02987656369805336, -0.02155371382832527, -0.01257522776722908, -0.014729284681379795, 0.005452325101941824, -0.05195590481162071, 0.005593268666416407, 0.0431072935461998, -0.032187942415475845, -0.020162900909781456, -0.0014242676552385092, 0.011938485316932201, -0.05739111453294754, 0.03183722868561745, 0.0026895932387560606, -0.04438730701804161, -0.038244497030973434, -0.0074620298109948635, -0.0030736387707293034, -0.01026216708123684, -0.015740877017378807, 0.027151431888341904, -0.04665578529238701, 0.0734928548336029, 0.022024303674697876, -0.026549428701400757, -0.045542530715465546, -0.01824912615120411, 0.010869271121919155, -0.08092523366212845, 0.05658893287181854, 0.00889590010046959, -0.019620293751358986, -0.027484456077218056, 0.008911210112273693, -0.004870134871453047, 0.01646851934492588, -0.00836879201233387, 0.027275625616312027, 0.0010347346542403102, 0.01948748156428337, 0.022551482543349266, 0.01567891426384449, -0.050053391605615616, 0.04125237092375755, 0.010581671260297298, -0.012568271718919277, 0.029018426313996315, -0.013613192364573479, -0.012208759784698486, -0.020597998052835464, 0.02198307029902935, -0.020471369847655296, -0.007145065348595381, -0.007744302973151207, 0.008673036471009254, 0.03073936514556408, -0.04242212325334549, 0.005429538432508707, 0.057541798800230026, -0.01528222020715475, -0.004308934789150953, 0.023082073777914047, 0.012264354154467583, -0.07688657939434052, -0.012774021364748478, -0.05329320207238197, -0.05716430023312569, -0.022553937509655952, -0.011805683374404907, 0.0487947091460228, -0.07620905339717865, 0.0083604846149683, 0.03073835000395775, -0.011406231671571732, -0.00007414281571982428, 0.07078258693218231, -0.013477794826030731, 0.03839035704731941, 0.0174382496625185, 0.05008020997047424, 0.012666022405028343, -0.017723320052027702, -0.005508822854608297, 0.006648910231888294, 0.028196606785058975, -0.004839062225073576, 0.03138156235218048, 0.02169971913099289, 0.03395261615514755, 0.0005111887003295124, -0.04429363086819649, 0.017320191487669945, -0.028642917051911354, -0.0016948414267972112, 0.012592144310474396, -0.036523040384054184, 0.006454906426370144, 0.021022628992795944, 0.0012117343721911311, 0.06796970963478088, -0.020190440118312836, -0.02235078439116478, -0.014061452820897102, -0.032392848283052444, -0.024906549602746964, 0.025838885456323624, 0.0025285647716373205, 0.011588530614972115, 0.020945202559232712, 0.031178893521428108, 0.0070067537017166615, -0.020521255210042, 0.007713517639786005, -0.03230961039662361, 0.02455664426088333, 0.025710662826895714, -0.024562237784266472, 0.017482677474617958, -0.02099905163049698, 0.006109650246798992, -0.01702057756483555, 0.030049843713641167, -0.0017715594731271267, 0.0014046513242647052, 0.009492297656834126, -0.04074811562895775, 0.008408492431044579, 0.041330914944410324, -0.045210812240839005, -0.0035877879709005356, -0.007694608066231012, -0.014249161817133427, 0.018368840217590332, -0.018108146265149117 ]
<p>I am aware that the "prediction interval", as defined in most textbooks on linear models, is focused on the uncertainty in the model being fit and is used to estimate an output prediction range for exact inputs. However, as is normally the case, what about situations where the input isn't exact? How do you calculate a "prediction interval" that accounts for both the uncertainty in the model and the uncertainty in the input data?</p> <p>For example,</p> <p>Assume the model is: <code>y = a0 + (a1 * x1) + (a2 * x2)</code></p> <p>Where <code>y</code>, <code>x1</code>, and <code>x2</code> are time series vectors. </p> <p>I only have one observation of the <code>y</code> time series with its associated <code>x1</code> and <code>x2</code> time series. That data is used to fit the model. However, I also have 1000 additional observations for <code>x1</code> and <code>x2</code>. I can easily calculate individual "prediction intervals", using the model and each <code>x1</code> <code>x2</code> pair, however I want to estimate a "prediction interval" that allows for all <code>x1</code> and <code>x2</code> observations. To be more specific, I generated the example below. The questionable code is below the <code>#======</code> comment line.</p> <p>Basically, I used <code>lm(..)</code> to fit the <code>y</code> vector to its associated <code>x1</code> and <code>x2</code> vectors. Next, I used <code>predict.lm(...interval="prediction", level=alpha)</code> to generate its typical <code>fit</code>, <code>lwr</code>, and <code>upr</code> vectors for each additional <code>x1</code> <code>x2</code> pair (see Graph 1, <code>fit</code> is the solid line, <code>upr</code> and <code>lwr</code> are the dashed lines for two observations). I then collected these vectors for all <code>x1</code> <code>x2</code> pairs and used <code>alpha</code> to extract the upper and lower tails of all of the <code>lwr</code> and <code>upr</code> vectors (see Graph 2).</p> <p>Is this scheme valid? Does the <code>alpha</code> that was used in <code>predict.lm(... level=alpha)</code> apply directly to counting-up/sorting the results to generate a "prediction interval" that allows for all <code>x1</code> <code>x2</code> pairs? Can a 5% range from a competing model (for example an ARIMA model) be compared to this 5% "prediction interval"?</p> <p>I'm fairly sure that the following scheme isn't right, but so far, I haven't figured out what I need to fix.</p> <pre><code>set.seed(1) numpoi &lt;- 10 #Number of data points in a time series vector #First independent variable "x1", first observation x1mea &lt;- 0.03 x1sta &lt;- 0.05 x1 &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x1mea, sd=x1sta)) #Second independent variable "x2", first observation x2mea &lt;- -0.01 x2sta &lt;- 0.1 x2 &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x2mea, sd=x2sta)) #Dependent variable "y", first observation a0 &lt;- 3 a1 &lt;- 2 a2 &lt;- 1 noimea &lt;- 0.0 noista &lt;- 0.1 y &lt;- a0 + (a1 * x1) + (a2 * x2) + rnorm(numpoi, mean=noimea, sd=noista) #Build a data frame of the "first observation" data datfra &lt;- data.frame(y=y, x1=x1, x2=x2) #Fit the model for the "first observation" mod &lt;- lm(y ~ x1 + x2, data=datfra) summary(mod) #Set up desired alpha value alpha &lt;- 0.95 onetai &lt;- (1 - alpha)/2 #Convert the two tail "alpha" to a one tail value for use later #Generate some new data "a" for a second observation of "x1" and "x2". x1a &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x1mea, sd=x1sta)) x2a &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x2mea, sd=x2sta)) datfraa &lt;- data.frame(y=rep(NA, numpoi), x1=x1a, x2=x2a) modprea &lt;- predict(mod, newdata=datfraa, interval="prediction", level=alpha) #Generate some new data "b" for a third observation of "x1" and "x2". x1b &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x1mea, sd=x1sta)) x2b &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x2mea, sd=x2sta)) datfrab &lt;- data.frame(y=rep(NA, numpoi), x1=x1b, x2=x2b) modpreb &lt;- predict(mod, newdata=datfrab, interval="prediction", level=alpha) #Plot the results for both new data "a" and "b" plot(modprea[, 1], type="l", ylim=c(min(modprea, modpreb), max(modprea, modpreb)), main="Graph 1 - Second and Third Observations for x1 and x2", lwd=2, col="red") lines(modprea[, 2], lwd=2, lty=2, col="red") lines(modprea[, 3], lwd=2, lty=2, col="red") lines(modpreb[, 1], lwd=2, col="green") lines(modpreb[, 2], lwd=2, lty=2, col="green") lines(modpreb[, 3], lwd=2, lty=2, col="green") #=========================================================================== #The code below is where my question lies. Is this the appropriate method #to account for all observations? #Run the above calculation scheme on "all" observations. numtri &lt;- 1000 #All observations modprecfit &lt;- matrix(0, nrow=numpoi, ncol = numtri) #Matrix to hold all "fit" vectors modpreclwr &lt;- matrix(0, nrow=numpoi, ncol = numtri) #Matrix to hold all "lwr" vectors modprecupr &lt;- matrix(0, nrow=numpoi, ncol = numtri) #Matrix to hold all "upr" vectors #Fill up the modprecfit, modpreclwr, and modprecupr matricies. for (i in 1:numtri) { #Generate the new data and put it in a dataframe x1c &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x1mea, sd=x1sta)) x2c &lt;- cumsum(rnorm(numpoi, mean=x2mea, sd=x2sta)) datfrac &lt;- data.frame(y=rep(NA, numpoi), x1=x1c, x2=x2c) #Predict the new "y" for new input data modprec &lt;- predict(mod, newdata=datfrac, interval="prediction", level=alpha) #Store the "ft", "lwr", and "upr" vectors so they can be processed later modprecfit[, i] &lt;- modprec[, 1] modpreclwr[, i] &lt;- modprec[, 2] modprecupr[, i] &lt;- modprec[, 3] } #Extract the average "fit", the lower quantile "lwr", and the upper quantile "upr" modprecfitfin &lt;- apply(modprecfit, 1, quantile, 0.5) modpreclwrfin &lt;- apply(modpreclwr, 1, quantile, onetai) modprecuprfin &lt;- apply(modprecupr, 1, quantile, (1 - onetai)) plot(modprecfitfin, type="l", ylim=c(min(modpreclwrfin), max(modprecuprfin)), main="Graph 2 - All Observations for x1 and x2", lwd=2, col="red") lines(modpreclwrfin, lwd=2, lty=2, col="red") lines(modprecuprfin, lwd=2, lty=2, col="red") </code></pre> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/dHaNa.png" alt="enter image description here"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/oMcGL.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
47,564
[ -0.010577568784356117, -0.010632900521159172, -0.023200623691082, 0.013449136167764664, 0.008350442163646221, 0.0018869464984163642, -0.0162745863199234, -0.04210684075951576, 0.038357924669981, 0.0039975144900381565, 0.019240383058786392, 0.05444170534610748, 0.0544966422021389, 0.010197624564170837, 0.007910305634140968, 0.0028411108069121838, 0.022390706464648247, -0.024108806625008583, -0.010009379126131535, -0.05361972749233246, -0.0019060838967561722, 0.03312729299068451, 0.0024940010625869036, -0.03337181359529495, 0.02258014678955078, 0.06898148357868195, 0.07650526612997055, -0.014682766981422901, 0.008393503725528717, 0.04859710484743118, -0.03513416275382042, -0.050988901406526566, 0.017701013013720512, 0.03892631083726883, 0.025945667177438736, 0.016452042385935783, 0.02084772102534771, -0.018085667863488197, 0.0028415201231837273, 0.047192152589559555, -0.054755933582782745, 0.0397186353802681, 0.00853768177330494, 0.05055300518870354, 0.013270178809762001, -0.003064597025513649, 0.012056437321007252, 0.005524883046746254, 0.024784913286566734, 0.0059889983385801315, 0.06709332019090652, -0.015046559274196625, 0.03496764227747917, 0.0014183205785229802, -0.008980744518339634, 0.006199046038091183, 0.07445560395717621, 0.07068353146314621, 0.009824522770941257, -0.05564574524760246, -0.01778618060052395, -0.004985235631465912, -0.024629630148410797, -0.014052492566406727, -0.006874433718621731, 0.011325583793222904, 0.007522188127040863, -0.003205886110663414, 0.005267732311040163, -0.03802439942955971, 0.0000646027983748354, 0.00568728381767869, 0.017411602661013603, -0.036974433809518814, 0.04835620895028114, -0.022753845900297165, 0.012670119293034077, 0.014347605407238007, 0.04176933318376541, 0.028759155422449112, -0.02187253348529339, 0.04170743748545647, 0.041748348623514175, 0.02698907069861889, 0.025823557749390602, -0.0010438007302582264, 0.0455331951379776, 0.01778435707092285, 0.013600502163171768, 0.03041834384202957, -0.04201505333185196, 0.0506606251001358, 0.03491435572504997, 0.014440144412219524, -0.0003923139302060008, 0.026260456070303917, -0.012348232790827751, 0.03483056649565697, -0.0092746177688241, -0.024457769468426704, 0.01933801919221878, -0.010900561697781086, 0.0027469461783766747, 0.061123039573431015, 0.00480587687343359, -0.03920686990022659, -0.01328909583389759, -0.028253478929400444, -0.016085484996438026, -0.04530652239918709, 0.01914219558238983, 0.03715251386165619, -0.018246842548251152, 0.007331234868615866, -0.012176737189292908, -0.02225922979414463, 0.009009993635118008, 0.0014224812621250749, 0.02417108416557312, 0.05725250393152237, 0.031132901087403297, -0.03427518159151077, 0.009799015708267689, 0.007979301735758781, -0.03163451328873634, -0.0015419479459524155, 0.0036763751413673162, -0.03914587199687958, -0.06499423831701279, 0.0374726839363575, 0.0013221742119640112, -0.05137499421834946, 0.039178621023893356, 0.011848852038383484, 0.007837554439902306, -0.01888885535299778, -0.042836468666791916, -0.08300745487213135, -0.00016224721912294626, 0.0031569642014801502, -0.009807657450437546, -0.04781030863523483, 0.019623568281531334, 0.025304369628429413, 0.04790632426738739, 0.05321819707751274, 0.019260777160525322, 0.04626565799117088, -0.022271499037742615, 0.012235775589942932, -0.051274340599775314, 0.0006629780982621014, -0.03005952760577202, -0.03445341810584068, -0.02739507518708706, -0.07367336004972458, 0.02309223636984825, 0.030677402392029762, -0.0204198956489563, 0.035439230501651764, 0.022487711161375046, 0.048800989985466, -0.015297670848667622, -0.006188175641000271, -0.018089786171913147, -0.06074129417538643, 0.05138971284031868, -0.004547840915620327, 0.035300008952617645, 0.01030114758759737, -0.029974641278386116, -0.0037493284326046705, 0.025045126676559448, 0.020254366099834442, 0.0636354386806488, 0.020170854404568672, -0.028503891080617905, -0.0379171147942543, 0.0152155552059412, 0.030244825407862663, -0.049101367592811584, -0.02689562551677227, -0.014669357798993587, -0.01761876791715622, 0.03914417326450348, 0.023677783086895943, 0.0027882009744644165, -0.020964020863175392, 0.03522465005517006, -0.026634464040398598, -0.02223731391131878, -0.03153521940112114, -0.0028278077952563763, 0.02032666653394699, 0.00026047759456560016, -0.03888505697250366, -0.034623946994543076, 0.020231597125530243, 0.010173712857067585, -0.02011118456721306, -0.03364754468202591, -0.02186695672571659, 0.06931337714195251, -0.03130465745925903, 0.00731787271797657, 0.057167235761880875, 0.07508690655231476, -0.018711475655436516, 0.03229006379842758, -0.04816249758005142, -0.03781663998961449, 0.011288570240139961, -0.055015143007040024, 0.020548630505800247, -0.012358568608760834, 0.007892650552093983, 0.027921287342905998, 0.004216233268380165, 0.022406190633773804, 0.023545529693365097, -0.03625991567969322, 0.045401621609926224, 0.056261129677295685, -0.004048056434839964, -0.001496551325544715, 0.0001322542957495898, 0.022030828520655632, 0.012217040173709393, -0.05609025061130524, -0.008014021441340446, -0.04990600794553757, -0.024249255657196045, 0.024451224133372307, 0.02332070842385292, -0.01457800529897213, -0.015271322801709175, 0.057996392250061035, -0.026341751217842102, 0.012496141716837883, 0.047388408333063126, 0.027685442939400673, -0.02272302843630314, 0.015231668017804623, -0.015044922940433025, 0.027313923463225365, -0.02592209167778492, 0.03046836145222187, 0.03491100296378136, 0.03950626030564308, 0.0005215717246755958, -0.009579958394169807, 0.04766484349966049, 0.008862601593136787, 0.00983892660588026, -0.023266306146979332, -0.03185494989156723, 0.034130364656448364, -0.015841662883758545, 0.007541123777627945, 0.048286378383636475, 0.00350349023938179, -0.011414390057325363, 0.02483835443854332, 0.0007030274718999863, -0.0002884186978917569, 0.05693410709500313, -0.050282254815101624, 0.003938661888241768, 0.011025270447134972, -0.05143392086029053, 0.026935698464512825, -0.0255007054656744, -0.04398151487112045, -0.021596860140562057, 0.017776621505618095, 0.045396529138088226, 0.04525824636220932, 0.01476128026843071, -0.03119821846485138, -0.015727480873465538, 0.0361020565032959, -0.018967777490615845, 0.042222876101732254, -0.0064428504556417465, -0.012629524804651737, 0.0012957868166267872, -0.015152757987380028, -0.03325968235731125, 0.024840079247951508, 0.008282691240310669, -0.025122620165348053, 0.03846801817417145, -0.03963450342416763, -0.06836802512407303, -0.024125277996063232, -0.05448529124259949, -0.002999247284606099, -0.004201782867312431, -0.03568403795361519, 0.05196851119399071, 0.043897099792957306, -0.10231687128543854, 0.017150234431028366, -0.019838538020849228, 0.0317235067486763, -0.06691409647464752, 0.02493830770254135, 0.005254875868558884, -0.008985549211502075, 0.036011140793561935, 0.045909494161605835, 0.021671712398529053, -0.015903200954198837, -0.05010463669896126, -0.052920375019311905, -0.006049981340765953, 0.031417809426784515, 0.02861587516963482, 0.0030964354518800974, 0.031192045658826828, 0.09331996738910675, -0.0026994755025953054, 0.010854123160243034, -0.04544798284769058, 0.0014505446888506413, 0.012937851250171661, -0.022911440581083298, 0.02592271938920021, 0.010598466731607914, 0.03126235678792, 0.005009798798710108, -0.015223122201859951, 0.002317103324458003, 0.04444606974720955, 0.012038163840770721, 0.05691811814904213, 0.007926334626972675, 0.017647717148065567, -0.025653859600424767, 0.024268409237265587, 0.009929477237164974, 0.005579647142440081, 0.023660851642489433, -0.0054460810497403145, 0.02966686524450779, 0.020008230581879616, -0.044243745505809784, -0.002101451624184847, -0.05007237195968628, 0.009123818948864937, -0.029445409774780273, 0.02137356624007225, 0.017355574294924736, -0.040119562298059464, -0.03083897940814495, 0.027183663100004196, 0.034792326390743256, -0.009298993274569511, -0.014153573662042618, 0.04299227148294449, 0.03484226390719414, -0.015080743469297886, -0.0008126141037791967, -0.01918000914156437, -0.01114865392446518, 0.005464243236929178, -0.05137837678194046, -0.010921327397227287, 0.0341973751783371, 0.029048128053545952, -0.007872511632740498, -0.004487643018364906, -0.0038395971059799194, 0.027605626732110977, -0.06866760551929474, 0.011654755100607872, -0.054587289690971375, 0.04066205024719238, 0.02214948646724224, 0.06662840396165848, 0.032275889068841934, -0.0227986928075552, 0.025338198989629745, 0.0021739760413765907, -0.06035313010215759, 0.04296492785215378, 0.023133529350161552, -0.044397007673978806, -0.0006612851284444332, 0.01171874813735485, 0.022934027016162872, -0.03722637891769409, -0.009759909473359585, -0.022808270528912544, 0.020253874361515045, -0.05273476243019104, 0.021800076588988304, 0.010659861378371716, -0.02850567176938057, -0.028688067570328712, 0.031775377690792084, 0.03207654133439064, -0.022235620766878128, 0.024415047839283943, 0.028157049790024757, -0.025896629318594933, 0.004951808601617813, -0.008338027633726597, 0.0003060000017285347, 0.022229056805372238, 0.04119184613227844, 0.02819565311074257, 0.014626879245042801, -0.04454699903726578, 0.015912773087620735, 0.012606226839125156, 0.029934844002127647, 0.0589301697909832, -0.018383683636784554, -0.020643653348088264, 0.020290624350309372, 0.01618056744337082, 0.03047838807106018, -0.016836175695061684, -0.0014449162408709526, 0.008470186963677406, 0.040084417909383774, 0.0203035157173872, -0.028343304991722107, 0.01662059873342514, 0.08200665563344955, 0.01996263489127159, 0.00744885066524148, -0.03326188027858734, 0.012126523070037365, 0.0037645557895302773, -0.0010624985443428159, -0.005121211986988783, -0.024293795228004456, 0.015033685602247715, 0.005661351606249809, -0.005398198962211609, -0.009304704144597054, -0.01935538277029991, -0.015604994259774685, 0.04621207341551781, 0.07494964450597763, 0.008427395485341549, -0.04581637308001518, -0.016377419233322144, 0.031769540160894394, 0.04627012461423874, 0.023492952808737755, 0.009300166741013527, -0.10848191380500793, 0.00045353034511208534, 0.03710321709513664, 0.06293907761573792, -0.021003449335694313, -0.03630475327372551, 0.010823313146829605, -0.012222844175994396, 0.04319867119193077, -0.01959495060145855, 0.03367011994123459, 0.005871420260518789, -0.014687412418425083, -0.03655103221535683, -0.026247408241033554, -0.053783610463142395, 0.02022642083466053, -0.036548811942338943, 0.048665523529052734, -0.03901166841387749, -0.023083170875906944, -0.020400388166308403, 0.015460368245840073, 0.04362880066037178, 0.04403749108314514, -0.018160300329327583, -0.03417739272117615, 0.013300738297402859, 0.00043930712854489684, -0.008234485052525997, -0.05092894285917282, 0.006721509620547295, 0.024106919765472412, -0.016483312472701073, 0.03362687677145004, -0.015246303752064705, -0.023209137842059135, 0.034670744091272354, 0.037069082260131836, 0.002714201807975769, -0.02462906390428543, -0.014256497845053673, 0.029163822531700134, 0.02625352144241333, -0.015328573063015938, 0.06128339841961861, 0.059014394879341125, 0.006826459430158138, -0.0012966740177944303, -0.036254651844501495, -0.02438744716346264, -0.01137419044971466, -0.037843238562345505, -0.037920162081718445, -0.027077533304691315, -0.04794817417860031, 0.026722321286797523, -0.02620042860507965, 0.02566012553870678, -0.004391277674585581, 0.006411588750779629, -0.004373766947537661, 0.04960418492555618, -0.03520727902650833, -0.01618254743516445, -0.054533571004867554, 0.013822919689118862, -0.01357237994670868, 0.026886574923992157, -0.007640412077307701, -0.013093642890453339, 0.000709683052264154, 0.0021578019950538874, -0.018683966249227524, 0.013515410013496876, -0.001648574136197567, -0.0032570387702435255, 0.011959001421928406, 0.00106862373650074, 0.039286620914936066, -0.025244221091270447, 0.01665336824953556, -0.04171743616461754, -0.001034171786159277, -0.006901782937347889, 0.053266461938619614, -0.002279274631291628, 0.051521480083465576, 0.0009861089056357741, 0.010805086232721806, -0.017340030521154404, -0.019070424139499664, -0.051491789519786835, -0.02330290526151657, 0.04358871281147003, 0.013215931132435799, -0.034462299197912216, -0.03375040739774704, -0.012599528767168522, -0.02771318517625332, 0.025976574048399925, -0.02175433188676834, 0.013289831578731537, -0.028291627764701843, -0.03304740786552429, -0.04609363526105881, -0.009429302997887135, 0.02100488357245922, 0.018769294023513794, 0.022333309054374695, 0.05783744901418686, -0.005525198765099049, -0.03575035557150841, 0.00385214458219707, -0.012005717493593693, -0.039014045149087906, 0.0009388530161231756, -0.013569358736276627, 0.026966048404574394, 0.06723887473344803, -0.006097895093262196, -0.023374704644083977, 0.021677087992429733, 0.015150037594139576, 0.009987191297113895, -0.024624669924378395, -0.010486857034265995, -0.02085503563284874, -0.006244432646781206, -0.02567794732749462, -0.009155303239822388, 0.0024685233365744352, 0.017629848793148994, -0.020456010475754738, -0.025929445400834084, -0.008682848885655403, 0.006742734927684069, 0.060116562992334366, 0.03564569726586342, 0.00719969067722559, -0.0430525504052639, -0.023901740089058876, 0.020899083465337753, 0.01549742091447115, 0.007965396158397198, 0.021748853847384453, 0.052000902593135834, -0.02130007930099964, -0.02858682908117771, -0.03416477143764496, -0.025103483349084854, 0.047232575714588165, -0.0213790126144886, 0.03622928634285927, 0.030577830970287323, 0.03968586027622223, -0.010682624764740467, -0.055533263832330704, -0.03817887231707573, -0.004480836447328329, 0.00552416080608964, 0.0515192449092865, -0.0008029232849366963, -0.06822527945041656, 0.024599460884928703, -0.048373252153396606, 0.03358886018395424, 0.01788647100329399, -0.02310962975025177, 0.0413811020553112, 0.004360525403171778, -0.010655500926077366, -0.031972236931324005, 0.007864710874855518, -0.02390557900071144, -0.025341812521219254, -0.006647933274507523, -0.01537600252777338, 0.023032402619719505, 0.054835595190525055, -0.011531022377312183, -0.021793236956000328, 0.004565614741295576, -0.06704889237880707, 0.0026625210884958506, -0.00040862231981009245, -0.006561057176440954, 0.03281382843852043, 0.010286012664437294, 0.025844553485512733, -0.02036004140973091, -0.0010529933497309685, -0.03283240646123886, -0.08028057217597961, -0.023416010662913322, -0.03896784037351608, -0.03951461240649223, 0.04875076562166214, 0.005631658248603344, -0.017179347574710846, 0.0017306235386058688, -0.02291949652135372, 0.01158392895013094, -0.025578893721103668, 0.04095080867409706, -0.0017480633687227964, 0.04729709401726723, -0.009132607840001583, 0.002603394677862525, -0.049664247781038284, -0.028160057961940765, 0.13922646641731262, 0.0714443176984787, 0.034893184900283813, -0.08278130739927292, -0.00938002672046423, -0.011244269087910652, -0.01976565457880497, -0.02483244612812996, -0.028823411092162132, 0.05283713713288307, -0.03438914194703102, 0.0234606321901083, 0.039073701947927475, 0.0001277092524105683, -0.008013897575438023, 0.05433027073740959, -0.023533688858151436, 0.04655061289668083, -0.013831154443323612, 0.014829888939857483, 0.01670743152499199, -0.026530854403972626, -0.020238282158970833, 0.004707231651991606, -0.01869032345712185, 0.031135158613324165, -0.023927291855216026, 0.004380415193736553, 0.010544959455728531, -0.011599322780966759, -0.01870887540280819, 0.00346360239200294, 0.011157428845763206, 0.012347006238996983, 0.05218665674328804, 0.02744673192501068, -0.015811314806342125, 0.0025074458681046963, -0.002337564015761018, 0.005885069724172354, -0.006273139268159866, 0.011400382965803146, -0.007439722772687674, 0.01718936860561371, -0.04524708539247513, -0.05699750408530235, -0.05309479311108589, 0.030202550813555717, 0.016602836549282074, -0.0507872998714447, 0.0028078893665224314, 0.004915434867143631, 0.015849346294999123, -0.008829519152641296, 0.006491145584732294, 0.05881752818822861, 0.039560556411743164, -0.03602231293916702, 0.0002104845189023763, -0.012660834938287735, -0.011417742818593979, -0.022229377180337906, 0.03169116750359535, 0.03248682990670204, -0.049098096787929535, -0.02477271668612957, -0.01507062092423439, 0.05692561715841293, -0.009974726475775242, 0.012030394747853279, 0.034261684864759445, -0.019218098372220993, -0.02639264240860939, -0.043943628668785095, 0.05469686910510063, -0.005883669480681419, 0.004290613811463118, -0.00016522097575943917, 0.009193583391606808, -0.01907181367278099, -0.0445559099316597, -0.004411401227116585, -0.009343612939119339, -0.007928997278213501, -0.04056954011321068, 0.01852584257721901, 0.009440982714295387, 0.022280531004071236, 0.009437083266675472, 0.0030949157662689686, -0.026688117533922195, 0.035198796540498734, 0.022132886573672295, -0.02867872081696987, -0.04832720011472702, 0.01725640706717968, -0.020740555599331856, 0.025247665122151375, 0.0074816481210291386, 0.09393993020057678, 0.01934713125228882, 0.04276386648416519, -0.017656566575169563, 0.014298288151621819, -0.012692855671048164, 0.014901540242135525, 0.0074846078641712666, -0.027378804981708527, -0.0041177161037921906, 0.023826617747545242, 0.030430719256401062, -0.03363896533846855, -0.00425227964296937, -0.01746569760143757, -0.06369813531637192, 0.00008365518442587927, -0.03363112732768059, -0.0555216483771801, 0.023953506723046303, -0.014343352057039738, -0.003604061435908079, -0.005455933045595884, 0.002393431728705764, -0.0397774912416935, -0.02081981860101223, -0.04343283548951149, -0.07101736217737198, -0.016537707298994064, -0.00248278328217566, -0.0322127528488636, 0.00497418362647295, 0.03020525723695755, -0.002555089071393013, 0.009569796733558178, -0.003509142203256488, -0.00792081281542778, -0.022753959521651268, 0.01936045102775097, -0.014488866552710533, -0.060883570462465286, 0.006739764474332333, -0.008020604960620403, -0.03895212709903717, 0.03081134520471096, 0.0010763166937977076, 0.07138489186763763, 0.0401943176984787, -0.0037014982663094997, -0.040559571236371994, 0.054728806018829346, 0.0011353251757100224, -0.016912516206502914, -0.013357014395296574, 0.03244413435459137, -0.009705432690680027, 0.015618395060300827, 0.024765916168689728, 0.021531717851758003, 0.0056225392036139965, 0.015303724445402622, 0.04010970517992973, -0.005576402880251408, -0.0477045513689518, -0.009257611818611622, -0.01696152426302433, 0.054454028606414795, -0.018704766407608986, -0.014257708564400673, 0.030853426083922386, 0.022958984598517418, 0.024629080668091774, 0.03297995775938034, -0.0025696950033307076, -0.004355196375399828, -0.08101479709148407, -0.01046108640730381, -0.018171941861510277, 0.020647728815674782, 0.023095879703760147, -0.024840418249368668, 0.016230598092079163, 0.037589140236377716, -0.029788412153720856, 0.00953191053122282, -0.003990276250988245, 0.03457076847553253, -0.02241397649049759, -0.0044709681533277035, -0.02503187209367752, -0.022656699642539024, 0.06554600596427917, -0.025086794048547745, 0.024314219132065773, 0.022190295159816742, 0.006333757191896439, -0.06433538347482681, -0.011189826764166355, 0.009485574439167976, 0.021330451592803, -0.04956778138875961, 0.007206039037555456, -0.025731146335601807, 0.004110132809728384, 0.003385836724191904, -0.033228207379579544, 0.012684782035648823, 0.01207544282078743, 0.055378906428813934, 0.000306259433273226, 0.07183399796485901, 0.015728965401649475, 0.0029352849815040827, 0.0159466415643692, -0.011247094720602036, 0.009181706234812737, -0.013384966179728508, -0.03456292301416397, 0.009493769146502018, 0.00017905984714161605, -0.013813893310725689, -0.03719780966639519, 0.027113059535622597, 0.009868285618722439, -0.001969810575246811, 0.006630797404795885, 0.029540792107582092, -0.04181583598256111, -0.07903221994638443, 0.020774362608790398, -0.02002675086259842, -0.015035443939268589, 0.03190496563911438, 0.04424191638827324, -0.031094469130039215, -0.00876667071133852, -0.039377640932798386, -0.032616037875413895, 0.03565099462866783, -0.009508183225989342, -0.030196262523531914, -0.096482053399086, -0.029651198536157608, -0.0004049698472954333, 0.0056835985742509365, -0.030787425115704536, -0.00004786317367688753, -0.05099347606301308, 0.03570416197180748, -0.03995174542069435, -0.014023835770785809, 0.025333672761917114, -0.010975760407745838, 0.004825717769563198, -0.08920593559741974, 0.07862851768732071, -0.003936310764402151, -0.03034954145550728, -0.014283938333392143, -0.02375204861164093, -0.0012192215071991086, 0.004608296323567629, 0.056649498641490936, 0.05915799364447594, -0.010096500627696514, -0.0005527329631149769, 0.02002766542136669, 0.014089198783040047, -0.006927896291017532, 0.041134174913167953, -0.005115539766848087, -0.019695967435836792, 0.004599143285304308, -0.01962568424642086, -0.002677643671631813, 0.004816785920411348, 0.028204375877976418, -0.030485181137919426, 0.01572060026228428, 0.018463194370269775, 0.003800363512709737, 0.014122067019343376, 0.008453739807009697, -0.005717252381145954, 0.03010677359998226, 0.01191418431699276, 0.009602922014892101, 0.018605608493089676, 0.009352987632155418, -0.07549683004617691, 0.024961035698652267, -0.027182862162590027, -0.014123705215752125, 0.01409408450126648, 0.02075069025158882, 0.0207575261592865, -0.06284928321838379, 0.019776683300733566, 0.03523583710193634, -0.023037277162075043, 0.010799511335790157, 0.041169025003910065, 0.0029064533300697803, 0.04555744677782059, 0.008284591138362885, 0.03988160192966461, -0.006044511217623949, -0.018115578219294548, 0.007946985773742199, -0.02328256331384182, 0.0556260384619236, -0.015199276618659496, 0.0015884076710790396, 0.04776304215192795, -0.02230839803814888, -0.006710296031087637, -0.02057655155658722, 0.022304441779851913, -0.004800891503691673, -0.022478748112916946, 0.007668533828109503, -0.046709172427654266, -0.009316944517195225, 0.03867259994149208, -0.02020762301981449, -0.008771294727921486, -0.059060756117105484, 0.008645804598927498, -0.07053519040346146, -0.011914588510990143, -0.010001680813729763, 0.035900820046663284, -0.011213192716240883, 0.005723142065107822, 0.004887586459517479, 0.01790844462811947, 0.012270450592041016, -0.021225186064839363, 0.002630806528031826, -0.004346749279648066, 0.014097919687628746, -0.017293529585003853, 0.030972525477409363, -0.02919182740151882, -0.02939780429005623, -0.021560147404670715, -0.03767337277531624, 0.040675580501556396, 0.051330678164958954, 0.03254912048578262, -0.01625353842973709, -0.05751805379986763, -0.028985174372792244, 0.02653612568974495, -0.06985793262720108, 0.0018784449202939868, -0.05096590518951416, 0.043033018708229065, -0.0031831900123506784, -0.0510869175195694 ]
<p>I'm trying to assess the difference between two algorithms. They are stochastic, so I've run them multiple times against the same input files and noted their results. I want to determine whether my algorithm offers a statistically significant improvement over a previous approach. From my (potentially flawed) understanding this sort of situation is where I should (or rather could) use the Wilcoxon Sign Rank test. </p> <p>The data is naturally paired, so I can join together outputs of both algorithms by the particular input problem they used. Since I want to test that my algorithm is not just different, but actually better (in this case returning lower values) than the other algorithm this appears to be a one-tailed assumption. </p> <p>I'm using the R <code>wilcox.test</code> function to perform the test and I'm slightly confused about how I should interpret the results. I have read the help page for <code>wilcox.test</code> and it doesn't seem to offer much information about the results, more focus is made to the function's arguments. I've made a minimal working example with a small subset of my data:</p> <pre><code>x &lt;- structure(list(instance = structure(c(1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L), .Label = c("competition01", "competition02", "competition03", "competition04", "competition05", "competition06", "competition07", "competition08", "competition09", "competition10", "competition11", "competition12", "competition13", "competition14", "competition15", "competition16", "competition17", "competition18", "competition19", "competition20"), class = "factor"), nhoods = structure(c(1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L), .Label = c("nhoods1", "nhoods2", "nhoods3", "nhoods4", "nhoods5"), class = "factor"), run.no = structure(c(1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 3L, 3L, 4L, 4L, 5L, 5L), .Label = c("1", "2", "3", "4", "5"), class = "factor"), partition = structure(c(1L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 2L), .Label = c("Hard-Soft", "Full" ), class = "factor"), VNS = c(984L, 1445L, 1033L, 1445L, 1035L, 1318L, 1058L, 1445L, 913L, 1445L), `VNS-Skip` = c(1083L, 1425L, 1099L, 1230L, 1077L, 1363L, 1102L, 1442L, 1093L, 1252L)), .Names = c("instance", "nhoods", "run.no", "partition", "VNS", "VNS-Skip"), row.names = c(NA, 10L), class = "data.frame") wilcox.test(x[,5], x[,6], paired = TRUE, conf.int = TRUE, alternative = "greater") </code></pre> <p>My algorithm's results are in the 6th column and the original ones are in the 5th column. Since I want to assess whether my algorithm is better I've used the alternative = "greater" option which should mean that the test is checking for 1st arg > 2nd arg. </p> <p>This results in the output:</p> <pre><code> Wilcoxon signed rank test data: x[, 5] and x[, 6] V = 22, p-value = 0.7217 alternative hypothesis: true location shift is greater than 0 95 percent confidence interval: -72 Inf sample estimates: (pseudo)median -21 </code></pre> <p>In this case the p-value is not less than 0.05 so there is not enough evidence to discard the null hypothesis.</p> <p>What does having infinity as the upper bound of a confidence interval mean? Is this because I'm using the one-tailed version of the test? All the tests I've run on my data always have the upper confidence interval as Inf. If the p-value were less than 0.05 would that mean I would be justified in saying "with a 95% confidence x[,5]'s mean will be within -72 of x[,6]'s?" </p> <p>What does the V value mean with regard to my data? From what I can see it is the difference between <code>median(x[,5])</code> and <code>median(x[,6]</code> but how would describe that in prose? Does anyone actually use the V value is the discussion of their data analyses? </p>
47,566
[ -0.028840867802500725, 0.00919053703546524, -0.02088124118745327, -0.032017022371292114, -0.02586190775036812, 0.03116387128829956, -0.015691818669438362, -0.023507749661803246, 0.021210290491580963, -0.018777329474687576, 0.035850703716278076, 0.047529786825180054, 0.046888403594493866, 0.05417582020163536, 0.015256344340741634, 0.009067489765584469, -0.015382979065179825, 0.0004747764905914664, 0.008290720172226429, 0.016440456733107567, -0.0179641954600811, 0.004251046106219292, 0.01382576022297144, -0.005560542456805706, -0.011261875741183758, 0.04632527381181717, -0.020541490986943245, -0.013157210312783718, 0.020272772759199142, 0.020510373637080193, -0.06163725256919861, -0.026980692520737648, -0.0015750060556456447, 0.00785389170050621, 0.051419731229543686, 0.02933271788060665, 0.014236798509955406, -0.017613610252738, -0.021993262693285942, 0.033365339040756226, 0.009633254259824753, -0.025473525747656822, 0.01095606293529272, 0.017451658844947815, 0.0033000640105456114, 0.04758863523602486, -0.013817895203828812, -0.01583603210747242, 0.028164753690361977, -0.02419021539390087, 0.04733124375343323, 0.021281981840729713, 0.00004020482083433308, 0.042864903807640076, -0.032171543687582016, 0.010862785391509533, 0.01351767685264349, 0.049096912145614624, -0.025285713374614716, -0.05080662667751312, -0.033077217638492584, -0.0646139532327652, -0.027396991848945618, 0.016610126942396164, -0.020799046382308006, 0.005978450179100037, 0.018870407715439796, -0.02470516972243786, 0.0444759726524353, -0.015733785927295685, 0.01063510961830616, 0.02571558952331543, 0.015326792374253273, -0.02986113913357258, 0.028939418494701385, 0.0023265534546226263, 0.01363434549421072, 0.019033748656511307, 0.026413027197122574, 0.03172486647963524, -0.010470847599208355, 0.013036775402724743, -0.015446595847606659, 0.049781326204538345, 0.008960815146565437, 0.017886832356452942, 0.0473320335149765, -0.05132364109158516, 0.002977583324536681, 0.028051378205418587, -0.01955479010939598, 0.007279576268047094, 0.07146740704774857, 0.03206077218055725, -0.011684547178447247, -0.016209345310926437, -0.0037738389801234007, -0.02454211935400963, -0.012677453458309174, -0.029627518728375435, -0.05078071728348732, -0.06471724063158035, 0.0002670683024916798, 0.03242747113108635, -0.04131893068552017, 0.0016286686295643449, -0.008233286440372467, -0.0007722952286712825, -0.06813813000917435, -0.019888490438461304, -0.0047132233157753944, 0.03363964334130287, -0.01860891468822956, 0.01644575223326683, 0.020974162966012955, -0.014780200086534023, -0.03389665111899376, 0.012915115803480148, 0.05904971808195114, 0.07416237145662308, 0.08535589277744293, 0.003532487666234374, -0.00013601104728877544, -0.024706386029720306, -0.015136326663196087, 0.004250520374625921, 0.002400049241259694, 0.0006655064644291997, -0.0037740482948720455, 0.05200079083442688, -0.011188667267560959, -0.023990321904420853, 0.045866481959819794, -0.005436966195702553, 0.02880812995135784, 0.008263364434242249, -0.09855352342128754, -0.023839788511395454, 0.04390691965818405, -0.016363773494958878, -0.00120635237544775, -0.045557666569948196, -0.003385623451322317, -0.0015259553911164403, 0.03715137019753456, -0.0046754563227295876, 0.017518790438771248, 0.0259452722966671, 0.040453746914863586, 0.021441999822854996, -0.019188109785318375, -0.01883566379547119, -0.04888175055384636, -0.03206038475036621, -0.02852346934378147, -0.060537900775671005, 0.008641977794468403, 0.012093751691281796, -0.01734975539147854, 0.018728258088231087, 0.02277836948633194, 0.006848313380032778, 0.0044206902384757996, -0.046728696674108505, -0.014099680818617344, 0.01950675994157791, 0.056775741279125214, 0.0055250125005841255, 0.019497143104672432, 0.007281338330358267, -0.07429482787847519, -0.032633986324071884, 0.004423500504344702, 0.024965956807136536, 0.028327777981758118, -0.03268970549106598, 0.04229581356048584, -0.04015214741230011, -0.004844715818762779, -0.00719495490193367, -0.005214989650994539, -0.020182061940431595, -0.023040132597088814, -0.022964879870414734, -0.005521758459508419, 0.052735835313797, -0.0006478752475231886, 0.016824986785650253, 0.10991740971803665, -0.05011549964547157, -0.09093467146158218, -0.07318839430809021, -0.036776840686798096, 0.0170064028352499, -0.056060127913951874, 0.015692807734012604, 0.030833475291728973, 0.01182122714817524, -0.006488904356956482, 0.017785638570785522, -0.03468916192650795, 0.014474269933998585, -0.003358460497111082, -0.0037201978266239166, 0.01249789074063301, 0.036623645573854446, 0.04965484142303467, -0.028569258749485016, 0.0351593904197216, -0.07897438108921051, -0.04183809086680412, 0.028862779960036278, -0.04726022481918335, -0.01058289222419262, 0.04524178430438042, -0.002993225585669279, 0.03740823268890381, 0.005092529579997063, 0.027125073596835136, 0.04715551808476448, -0.048009976744651794, 0.03257519006729126, 0.05226453021168709, 0.0015699362847954035, 0.007422194350510836, -0.03778683766722679, 0.006286898162215948, -0.006314159370958805, -0.03971273452043533, 0.021127428859472275, -0.04059172421693802, -0.026614880189299583, 0.05796454846858978, 0.017770223319530487, -0.02248804271221161, -0.03195474296808243, 0.04437606781721115, -0.022033389657735825, 0.02027725614607334, 0.03949231281876564, 0.019665438681840897, -0.015765314921736717, 0.03826505318284035, 0.05435609444975853, -0.0008420899393968284, 0.03552904352545738, 0.04880518838763237, -0.00861803162842989, 0.040148407220840454, 0.014103884808719158, -0.004451839718967676, 0.03340659290552139, 0.011489581316709518, -0.03308975324034691, -0.044147640466690063, -0.036096516996622086, 0.05205100402235985, -0.011936607770621777, 0.017684953287243843, 0.06283261626958847, -0.003629548940807581, 0.005474785342812538, -0.03342059999704361, -0.0007448046235367656, 0.03763524815440178, 0.031836338341236115, -0.03234585002064705, 0.0059266542084515095, 0.020421890541911125, -0.01968725211918354, 0.007264332380145788, -0.031625259667634964, 0.007284056395292282, -0.06948219984769821, 0.0006298680673353374, 0.0189418476074934, 0.02675638161599636, 0.015601471066474915, -0.0429786778986454, 0.00716715632006526, -0.003732509445399046, -0.03297911584377289, 0.0447184219956398, 0.01015655416995287, -0.032669682055711746, -0.012009299360215664, -0.02662714384496212, 0.0068167815916240215, 0.030702438205480576, 0.005327014718204737, -0.07018584758043289, 0.025544730946421623, -0.003296286566182971, -0.021125219762325287, -0.006478205788880587, -0.07586032897233963, 0.008307401090860367, -0.02299230359494686, -0.02038395218551159, 0.05673617497086525, -0.005759336054325104, -0.0960363894701004, 0.029568549245595932, -0.008557864464819431, -0.009347100742161274, -0.009822905994951725, -0.0048631420359015465, -0.05101188272237778, 0.019558168947696686, -0.004073697607964277, 0.01674717664718628, -0.005902958568185568, -0.006083047017455101, -0.06605227291584015, -0.02108636125922203, 0.012952161952853203, -0.02174459584057331, 0.004179452080279589, 0.0011895282659679651, -0.022954827174544334, 0.049933914095163345, 0.03584136813879013, -0.009570327587425709, -0.056860145181417465, 0.01515208464115858, -0.05327241122722626, 0.033322401344776154, 0.02151191048324108, 0.050419215112924576, 0.033056970685720444, 0.004822645336389542, -0.02751130796968937, 0.05994090065360069, 0.024151289835572243, -0.012713102623820305, -0.018429365009069443, 0.03212650492787361, 0.01232204120606184, -0.05768323317170143, 0.05569307878613472, -0.0014495843788608909, 0.0000924689884413965, 0.003250585403293371, 0.008771397173404694, -0.014578381553292274, 0.007601337507367134, -0.019338088110089302, 0.006902427412569523, -0.0004695215029641986, 0.014846566133201122, -0.034455083310604095, 0.02335740253329277, -0.0014707701047882438, -0.021923739463090897, -0.0014857933856546879, -0.0059871491976082325, 0.0263949166983366, -0.007092193700373173, 0.009771062061190605, 0.03471158444881439, 0.03691920265555382, 0.0014120712876319885, -0.0023731654509902, -0.013299340382218361, -0.05460397154092789, -0.004529064986854792, -0.03816240280866623, -0.02597988210618496, 0.01801854372024536, 0.015442149713635445, 0.006426501553505659, 0.02759486809372902, -0.0380203053355217, 0.0091194286942482, -0.014866595156490803, 0.03325764089822769, -0.03746190667152405, 0.05481734126806259, 0.020214807242155075, 0.04825935885310173, -0.0026630086358636618, -0.027813581749796867, -0.03468582406640053, -0.04311385750770569, -0.06357090175151825, 0.057540491223335266, 0.027556585147976875, -0.011436574161052704, -0.003676491556689143, -0.0076111252419650555, 0.020590709522366524, 0.0031022580806165934, 0.028095990419387817, 0.03396123647689819, 0.042336348444223404, -0.05308834835886955, 0.03400023281574249, -0.03257647156715393, -0.008863172493875027, -0.004078148398548365, 0.006004040595144033, 0.04555365443229675, -0.013269245624542236, 0.021830560639500618, 0.006333204451948404, -0.007767868228256702, 0.01667788065969944, -0.010037839412689209, 0.023671912029385567, 0.0781463235616684, 0.023910248652100563, 0.03440109267830849, 0.02827472798526287, -0.05669012665748596, 0.04015382006764412, 0.012147501111030579, 0.036844853311777115, 0.037370987236499786, -0.02787058614194393, -0.003880743868649006, 0.010257826186716557, -0.043786030262708664, -0.024042127653956413, -0.001485802698880434, 0.003986485302448273, -0.023575982078909874, 0.004076877608895302, 0.039112553000450134, 0.0047463309019804, 0.012953666038811207, 0.08045973628759384, 0.006421122699975967, 0.014453786425292492, -0.010743089020252228, -0.00523682264611125, 0.00817901361733675, -0.023353954777121544, 0.03589751943945885, 0.02412443608045578, 0.017787829041481018, 0.01682756282389164, 0.04220087081193924, -0.052011989057064056, -0.04189254716038704, 0.01351996324956417, -0.003497302532196045, 0.03951222077012062, -0.031775109469890594, -0.020354142412543297, 0.011746421456336975, 0.03146122768521309, 0.00936825666576624, 0.002523874631151557, -0.012586764059960842, -0.07738376408815384, -0.02013317495584488, 0.06868179142475128, 0.052110008895397186, -0.033691368997097015, -0.011091628111898899, -0.04486629739403725, -0.028897598385810852, 0.01946943625807762, -0.051305752247571945, 0.04248080030083656, 0.008554727770388126, 0.01857088692486286, -0.06143532320857048, -0.010972906835377216, -0.021323187276721, 0.012116646394133568, -0.028052708134055138, 0.045735497027635574, -0.057259973138570786, -0.061501890420913696, -0.0058274175971746445, 0.030377978459000587, -0.009042131714522839, 0.0012374934740364552, -0.06635044515132904, -0.01412802841514349, 0.01640954241156578, 0.004816941451281309, -0.02990526147186756, -0.05927291139960289, 0.04652394726872444, 0.005530073307454586, 0.021717166528105736, 0.052725329995155334, 0.01813722774386406, -0.03782527893781662, 0.019845543429255486, -0.012829450890421867, -0.03220733255147934, -0.01580270379781723, 0.01720782369375229, 0.027838602662086487, 0.043336521834135056, 0.01999046839773655, 0.03260698914527893, 0.0016798258293420076, 0.01505852211266756, -0.01879921928048134, -0.03659744933247566, -0.009772458113729954, -0.01235935464501381, -0.061699189245700836, -0.05621059983968735, -0.007251111324876547, -0.028863564133644104, 0.014235825277864933, -0.016689974814653397, 0.07748140394687653, -0.047239068895578384, 0.03765682131052017, 0.0018514554249122739, 0.022568408399820328, -0.02476074919104576, -0.011927613988518715, -0.018285304307937622, 0.0039023684803396463, -0.005025955848395824, 0.013445252552628517, 0.022860584780573845, -0.04113975167274475, 0.007466085255146027, -0.02444024570286274, -0.0229504257440567, 0.0009773287456482649, -0.007642656564712524, -0.013501001521945, 0.018148886039853096, -0.03572963550686836, 0.022850558161735535, 0.00285918521694839, 0.017012836411595345, -0.0016359217697754502, -0.0015168441459536552, -0.02195528894662857, 0.036838509142398834, 0.015108219347894192, -0.0010320028522983193, -0.02922886423766613, 0.023897474631667137, -0.002489016391336918, -0.04774386063218117, -0.04155923053622246, -0.010854963213205338, -0.024509770795702934, 0.026633955538272858, -0.039982836693525314, -0.04745495319366455, -0.039290446788072586, 0.023895343765616417, -0.00657563004642725, -0.026574190706014633, 0.010633462108671665, -0.03291346877813339, -0.01988830231130123, 0.023766329512000084, -0.01711069606244564, 0.066886305809021, -0.0019242683192715049, -0.017780713737010956, -0.007393325213342905, -0.02283090353012085, -0.006404549814760685, 0.002333221025764942, -0.009874962270259857, -0.018813496455550194, -0.03977957367897034, -0.04718319699168205, 0.03668784722685814, 0.03243720903992653, -0.005917336326092482, -0.03369057551026344, -0.003329624654725194, -0.03770040348172188, 0.03722267597913742, -0.05045425891876221, -0.04860816150903702, -0.014356967993080616, 0.02499876543879509, 0.030825341120362282, 0.01626165583729744, 0.006950828246772289, -0.04294489324092865, -0.00595838064327836, -0.015522368252277374, -0.020216558128595352, 0.012701790779829025, 0.07617394626140594, 0.0023506705183535814, 0.009053733199834824, 0.0013680803822353482, -0.050582148134708405, 0.02793050929903984, 0.0045733703300356865, 0.016919413581490517, -0.017824644222855568, 0.04794880747795105, -0.02776091918349266, -0.012874414213001728, -0.047892846167087555, -0.0027409507893025875, 0.06805847585201263, 0.00244351988658309, 0.026871873065829277, 0.062278036028146744, -0.01910383626818657, 0.006464350502938032, -0.0369320847094059, -0.022683266550302505, 0.005269317887723446, -0.004559674300253391, 0.07183735072612762, 0.0022741889115422964, -0.02519521862268448, 0.09594155848026276, -0.0064173233695328236, 0.05651837959885597, 0.02443224936723709, 0.015815818682312965, -0.004194180481135845, 0.02881128154695034, -0.014784376136958599, -0.030791113153100014, 0.028340380638837814, -0.03404559567570686, 0.03607623279094696, -0.045408524572849274, 0.01408303901553154, 0.01169512327760458, 0.06904076784849167, -0.019139239564538002, -0.05480056256055832, -0.01756807416677475, -0.08924605697393417, -0.006603471003472805, 0.027894331142306328, -0.029045308008790016, 0.05153512582182884, 0.018613312393426895, 0.012532826513051987, 0.030093636363744736, 0.055106401443481445, -0.0344434455037117, -0.048120804131031036, -0.029227204620838165, 0.03418208658695221, -0.023084191605448723, 0.02808307856321335, -0.0008119694539345801, 0.010075882077217102, 0.033742837607860565, -0.014775987714529037, 0.03364063426852226, -0.004644690081477165, 0.014869656413793564, 0.0010383381741121411, 0.0336303748190403, -0.02917947806417942, 0.026325181126594543, 0.0027239485643804073, -0.01914089173078537, 0.16651758551597595, 0.056264813989400864, 0.049229107797145844, -0.031399406492710114, 0.0064454879611730576, 0.02304159104824066, 0.013397131115198135, -0.03832130506634712, -0.01556763332337141, 0.03287519887089729, 0.0028353407979011536, 0.06539922952651978, 0.027258725836873055, 0.029873741790652275, -0.03277821093797684, 0.03474193438887596, -0.05639899894595146, 0.008864130824804306, -0.006942302454262972, 0.0269343089312315, 0.0012935558333992958, -0.00487197982147336, -0.04188486933708191, 0.006873173173516989, 0.06104997172951698, -0.003259949618950486, 0.014885908924043179, -0.005272216163575649, 0.006531392224133015, 0.032793622463941574, 0.031045502051711082, 0.01524942647665739, 0.0014001999516040087, -0.022191394120454788, 0.016295049339532852, 0.012894649058580399, -0.01233251765370369, -0.04740699380636215, 0.03305720165371895, 0.035706475377082825, 0.021552221849560738, 0.007734762504696846, 0.00014529710460919887, 0.016698425635695457, -0.052398473024368286, 0.008796990849077702, -0.05579470470547676, 0.006407894194126129, -0.02253987267613411, 0.017333539202809334, -0.020078124478459358, -0.014574731700122356, 0.028465811163187027, -0.05065452307462692, -0.014561195857822895, 0.03415753319859505, 0.04133113473653793, -0.03348115459084511, -0.01064983382821083, -0.030059294775128365, 0.02842976525425911, -0.04062138870358467, 0.029149388894438744, 0.026297900825738907, -0.04574643820524216, -0.041040461510419846, -0.05027903616428375, 0.023074612021446228, 0.01647247187793255, 0.031049221754074097, -0.02218620479106903, 0.017911763861775398, 0.008677594363689423, -0.012360011227428913, -0.0035181802231818438, -0.0027573909610509872, 0.03361609950661659, 0.0011322618229314685, -0.039333097636699677, -0.02940853126347065, -0.03186589479446411, 0.00958256609737873, -0.0008338410989381373, -0.017992159351706505, -0.035304341465234756, -0.03959226235747337, 0.018679173663258553, 0.015704670920968056, 0.0697900801897049, 0.017145520076155663, 0.029640983790159225, 0.046401187777519226, 0.037400271743535995, -0.04779746010899544, -0.05719481036067009, 0.014448238536715508, -0.00950283370912075, -0.03741483762860298, -0.025597181171178818, 0.051901377737522125, 0.04429280385375023, -0.037945620715618134, -0.022351538762450218, -0.0002470550825819373, 0.003659326583147049, 0.006319176405668259, 0.028604667633771896, -0.041985295712947845, 0.008388086222112179, 0.028027981519699097, -0.01894935965538025, -0.03243730217218399, -0.03503810986876488, -0.04094612970948219, -0.04311864450573921, 0.023519674316048622, -0.015113349072635174, -0.01891314424574375, 0.002158402930945158, -0.006605725735425949, 0.024260442703962326, -0.000651721260510385, -0.013346956111490726, -0.020020604133605957, -0.022420577704906464, -0.008860796689987183, -0.015405557118356228, 0.01929016225039959, 0.011353125795722008, -0.03388234227895737, 0.010350147262215614, 0.03899554908275604, 0.022175101563334465, 0.032251182943582535, -0.004065635148435831, -0.021289367228746414, 0.016470618546009064, 0.03265942260622978, 0.007670284248888493, 0.034720830619335175, 0.05602256953716278, -0.06088157370686531, -0.056176863610744476, -0.010044713504612446, -0.029721511527895927, 0.04269960895180702, 0.023101210594177246, -0.029216455295681953, -0.023083489388227463, 0.04102868214249611, -0.04625437781214714, 0.007116201799362898, 0.015680832788348198, -0.005097611807286739, 0.05104387551546097, -0.009248943068087101, -0.0022691490594297647, 0.02731921337544918, -0.020631497725844383, -0.0005876446375623345, 0.010307099670171738, 0.0019944594241678715, 0.0036555209662765265, -0.014088530093431473, -0.059717997908592224, -0.002459930023178458, -0.0003318378294352442, -0.03658110275864601, 0.020306039601564407, 0.054756660014390945, -0.011755729094147682, 0.0448979027569294, -0.04393928498029709, 0.013919126242399216, -0.06002499908208847, -0.01113994512706995, 0.018907442688941956, 0.012810982763767242, 0.034723345190286636, -0.052915457636117935, 0.04142996296286583, 0.003544503590092063, -0.021799009293317795, 0.046459175646305084, 0.0036677939351648092, 0.007970673963427544, -0.05345577746629715, 0.010435652919113636, -0.011910198256373405, 0.021107308566570282, 0.018375981599092484, 0.0009208089904859662, 0.03684310242533684, 0.00048702798085287213, 0.027713671326637268, -0.005587471649050713, 0.00014795621973462403, -0.0006999645265750587, 0.005814921576529741, -0.07903673499822617, 0.014722657389938831, -0.03545498847961426, -0.018666138872504234, 0.023304373025894165, -0.000972216366790235, 0.03329982981085777, 0.01158337015658617, 0.010944321751594543, 0.018772786483168602, 0.04143702611327171, -0.004348197486251593, -0.0472717247903347, -0.008412014693021774, 0.002756757428869605, 0.005906517617404461, -0.014716164208948612, -0.06619568914175034, -0.0028555335011333227, 0.020566528663039207, -0.021542705595493317, -0.042876292020082474, 0.025332417339086533, -0.008534525521099567, -0.016769742593169212, -0.03529492765665054, -0.0036788578145205975, 0.025776997208595276, 0.0124788424000144, -0.029873451218008995, 0.014202866703271866, 0.02144317515194416, 0.03433813899755478, 0.03545404225587845, -0.02913585491478443, 0.02080494537949562, -0.03472530096769333, -0.02574310451745987, 0.0012373740319162607, 0.009925002232193947, 0.008166150189936161, -0.025144722312688828, -0.02755608782172203, -0.019420120865106583, 0.010518474504351616, -0.009661121293902397, -0.006776407826691866, 0.010820307768881321, 0.016115523874759674, -0.02885337918996811, -0.0005662734620273113, -0.00770654296502471, -0.02719433605670929, 0.01902836561203003, -0.09721481800079346, 0.026908772066235542, 0.03742709383368492, -0.01701471023261547, -0.015400683507323265, 0.002414749236777425, -0.056700292974710464, 0.05928239971399307, 0.011996516957879066, 0.038038548082113266, -0.00732095493003726, -0.024745509028434753, 0.001674787956289947, -0.01755264401435852, -0.07544753700494766, 0.05065460875630379, -0.0006116817821748555, 0.0117548992857337, -0.004896660801023245, -0.00131035887170583, 0.03246792405843735, 0.014879952184855938, -0.018012158572673798, -0.0129996407777071, -0.017752639949321747, 0.009617365896701813, -0.007412808481603861, 0.023216914385557175, -0.003737943945452571, 0.014393895864486694, 0.04455282911658287, 0.01065467856824398, 0.03811391443014145, 0.025651732459664345, -0.006777135655283928, -0.025602540001273155, 0.04726295545697212, -0.02911148965358734, 0.026922015473246574, 0.028707079589366913, -0.008099492639303207, 0.035134509205818176, -0.02400311455130577, -0.003814468625932932, -0.009492621757090092, -0.0064919488504529, 0.012495419941842556, 0.008807634003460407, 0.006972964853048325, 0.03425060957670212, -0.0442071296274662, 0.027822472155094147, -0.0028028206434100866, -0.03675021603703499, 0.026191851124167442, 0.03718796372413635, 0.014036785811185837, 0.022374600172042847, 0.0056027197279036045, 0.05125420540571213, -0.017989618703722954, 0.018799228593707085, -0.01743202656507492, 0.03671594709157944, 0.003701229812577367, 0.0017973302165046334, 0.01886092871427536, -0.007030856795608997, -0.035447124391794205, -0.01537990290671587, 0.013447362929582596, 0.009708790108561516, -0.00846248958259821, 0.026972394436597824, -0.01767769269645214, 0.0013425571378320456, 0.03154855966567993, -0.01701236702501774, -0.008926786482334137, 0.029088957235217094, -0.02862292155623436, 0.00831108633428812, 0.030680103227496147, -0.004741313401609659, 0.01077608298510313, -0.006839052774012089, 0.040876083076000214, -0.0027711791917681694, 0.026243936270475388, -0.027869246900081635, 0.01776938885450363, -0.05386073514819145, -0.01184061635285616, 0.019789617508649826, 0.027460606768727303, 0.0074880244210362434, -0.021957777440547943, -0.02990555390715599, 0.023284902796149254, 0.0514647550880909, -0.007234623655676842, -0.012406247667968273, -0.022883204743266106, 0.01302200835198164, 0.05638626590371132, -0.02196677401661873 ]
<p>I'm familiar with using tools like SVMs and decision trees for discrete classification problems. But one detail that I have not encountered in that domain is: what do you do if your classifier must conserve some quantity when it is predicting outcomes for new input data?</p> <p>For example, suppose that you took all teams in the NFL and broke them into quintiles (20% buckets) based on their rushing yards per game (or say you took teams from the EPL and broke them down into quintiles based on their time-of-possession or some other statistic). Further let's say you are doing this on a weekly basis, so every week you collect your stats and then rank the teams 1 to N, chop them into quintiles, and each team's "class label" is its quintile.</p> <p>Now let's say you build a bunch of features for each team that you think will predict the team's quintile for next week. It could be the team's historical quintile, coaching changes, injuries to key players, whatever. But the point is you can make a feature vector for each team and you want to train a classifier that will predict which class label (1 to 5) to assign based on the features.</p> <p>What are some common or empirically effective ways to constrain the classifier so that the output makes sense? That is to say, it should only be possible to classify 20% of the teams in any particular quintile, and the classifier should not be able to logically contradict itself by putting more teams in a quintile than 20% of the total. (That is, the theory behind the classifier ought to demonstrate how we can <em>know in advance</em> that the classifier won't make contradictions).</p> <p>I'm not looking for post-hoc hacky ways to do rounding or anything, and I am also specifically trying to avoid the situation where you build a regression model of the underlying continuous quantity and then just predict the quantity and manually assign quintiles yourself. I want the classifier to discretely choose quintiles for each feature vector while respecting external constraints on the class labels.</p> <p>More generically you could wonder, how do you train an SVM-like classifier such that it has internal rules like "Only M of the N objects can receive label L, and I need to take that into account all the time for <em>every other</em> label that I assign too..."</p> <p><strong>Some thoughts:</strong></p> <p>(1) Use something like simulated annealing to shuffle the boundary points for the quintile after prediction. That is, use the trained classifier to classify every team's quintile. Use the distance from the margin as the "energy function" to be minimized, and then start randomly shuffling members of over-populated quintiles to nearby under-populated quintiles. You either accept or reject such a shuffling based on the extent to which it worsens the overall distance from the margin.</p> <p>I don't like this solution because it probably would be computationally inefficient after you already solve the SVM optimization problem. Also, it feels like you're actually just using the margin distance as a continuous quantity to determine the classification, at which point you might as well try to derive a more model-driven or physically plausible continuous quantity and just do regression or something and chop the predicted output into quintiles at the end, which is something I wanted to avoid.</p>
73,643
[ -0.01989729516208172, -0.0331803634762764, -0.03983302786946297, -0.016596002504229546, 0.05552435293793678, 0.003263777354732156, -0.007111688610166311, -0.009847343899309635, 0.008693310432136059, -0.001222125836648047, 0.016155552119016647, 0.028809821233153343, 0.019423285499215126, 0.009972193278372288, -0.012077335268259048, -0.008710970170795918, 0.013591397553682327, -0.022648004814982414, 0.021829115226864815, 0.01070913951843977, -0.01700683683156967, 0.03845465928316116, 0.009260491468012333, -0.00568633247166872, -0.021018827334046364, 0.054518815129995346, 0.029552891850471497, 0.025844475254416466, 0.015671461820602417, 0.046810541301965714, -0.03325554355978966, -0.027288516983389854, 0.016072170808911324, 0.06613138318061829, 0.04216607287526131, -0.007671751547604799, 0.01065873447805643, -0.0426952950656414, -0.030054733157157898, 0.0006037637358531356, -0.06827031821012497, 0.0017130326014012098, -0.0027017462998628616, 0.021166430786252022, 0.02095578797161579, 0.04976492375135422, 0.013741026632487774, 0.001859593321569264, 0.046211034059524536, -0.021096589043736458, 0.08043117076158524, 0.04424421861767769, 0.03251248970627785, 0.04564923793077469, -0.01580703631043434, -0.014921501278877258, 0.0443350188434124, 0.08381588011980057, -0.016712773591279984, -0.029581308364868164, -0.005389070138335228, -0.002385150408372283, -0.003740545827895403, -0.02156904898583889, -0.0030118024442344904, 0.049894314259290695, 0.000707602477632463, 0.0053423563949763775, 0.007321151439100504, -0.05390535295009613, 0.010053373873233795, -0.0162003505975008, 0.04708672687411308, -0.005579635966569185, -0.005550941452383995, -0.005828107241541147, 0.02509392984211445, 0.010234793648123741, 0.05289542302489281, -0.00583168538287282, 0.014323215931653976, 0.0069645908661186695, 0.00592685816809535, 0.04286808893084526, 0.028698911890387535, 0.0026190876960754395, 0.006687287241220474, -0.035670552402734756, 0.03534811735153198, 0.032161518931388855, -0.0337538942694664, 0.008826221339404583, 0.041247252374887466, -0.0064446148462593555, -0.0483231395483017, 0.032054316252470016, -0.024233059957623482, 0.0012487657368183136, -0.005141068249940872, -0.026124905794858932, -0.013773457147181034, -0.027878032997250557, -0.014803978614509106, -0.003034976776689291, -0.04175591468811035, -0.018755843862891197, -0.06813916563987732, -0.032687943428754807, -0.005853260867297649, 0.011853490956127644, -0.0034841124434024096, 0.03869747743010521, -0.006379039958119392, 0.01155221089720726, 0.0002162132877856493, 0.013578626327216625, 0.006775181274861097, -0.01385954674333334, 0.05257703736424446, 0.08145119994878769, 0.001073869876563549, -0.04337034374475479, 0.041662149131298065, -0.015912340953946114, -0.030833398923277855, 0.03540055826306343, -0.0016895754961296916, -0.04630076885223389, 0.016816262155771255, 0.03186339884996414, -0.002250082790851593, -0.02830694243311882, 0.01951128989458084, -0.021970408037304878, 0.027369538322091103, -0.030821602791547775, -0.06420315057039261, -0.028512824326753616, 0.03515439108014107, 0.0036094440147280693, 0.008966288529336452, -0.040043845772743225, -0.01958700641989708, 0.026096714660525322, 0.034613534808158875, 0.0296771377325058, 0.04402485862374306, 0.030551688745617867, 0.013970774598419666, 0.020874127745628357, 0.01159176230430603, -0.009346915408968925, -0.06967001408338547, -0.00968510378152132, -0.0409402996301651, -0.03639472275972366, 0.02441733330488205, 0.023930836468935013, 0.00023198570124804974, -0.0037529892288148403, -0.012545492500066757, 0.00391057413071394, -0.03944655507802963, 0.004622248932719231, -0.02330070175230503, -0.018389826640486717, 0.03742639347910881, 0.032514140009880066, 0.041912999004125595, -0.008163521997630596, -0.005253645591437817, -0.0043737986125051975, 0.05322068929672241, 0.05330599844455719, 0.05819135531783104, -0.013762285001575947, -0.0010432981653138995, -0.06632543355226517, 0.005667481571435928, -0.03716352581977844, -0.034835126250982285, -0.03635841980576515, -0.05187195539474487, 0.005823547951877117, 0.012962850742042065, 0.021934526041150093, 0.019303923472762108, 0.017973722890019417, 0.028404638171195984, -0.06566384434700012, -0.0548010915517807, -0.06435371190309525, 0.029817726463079453, -0.0006912976386956871, -0.018875589594244957, 0.016523217782378197, 0.012231363914906979, 0.035268548876047134, -0.05156230181455612, 0.006616885308176279, -0.019366567954421043, 0.015722641721367836, 0.04578549414873123, -0.04902641475200653, 0.004516568500548601, 0.04585782065987587, 0.0515904575586319, -0.004065458197146654, 0.04654304310679436, -0.04249417409300804, -0.0841616541147232, -0.0031099861953407526, -0.01623734086751938, 0.04493406042456627, -0.07302416115999222, 0.014796607196331024, 0.03736913949251175, -0.017157478258013725, -0.03510072082281113, 0.012782924808561802, -0.04274263605475426, 0.04997282475233078, 0.06302563101053238, -0.032470859587192535, -0.0011475818464532495, -0.0061693559400737286, -0.04413137957453728, 0.037928786128759384, -0.034462615847587585, -0.03417396545410156, -0.040106069296598434, 0.0028715035878121853, 0.03352236747741699, 0.042126335203647614, -0.0005488772876560688, -0.005368045996874571, 0.03340890258550644, 0.036869246512651443, -0.028228892013430595, 0.015692779794335365, -0.0567212849855423, 0.035183168947696686, 0.011602416634559631, -0.050382185727357864, 0.03952872008085251, -0.035987358540296555, 0.019788196310400963, 0.01201162301003933, 0.03073800355195999, -0.00027961519663222134, -0.020786743611097336, 0.041085317730903625, 0.01890968345105648, 0.005277707707136869, 0.022492775693535805, -0.04987634718418121, 0.03665627911686897, -0.014866017736494541, -0.016596002504229546, 0.013403230346739292, 0.008503353223204613, 0.010040178894996643, -0.0011871266178786755, -0.019544078037142754, 0.0027892841026186943, 0.048259176313877106, -0.016020717099308968, 0.02790183760225773, 0.025145890191197395, -0.03680688515305519, 0.016359498724341393, -0.017604734748601913, -0.021033305674791336, -0.03432110324501991, 0.011562585830688477, 0.0571078397333622, 0.0017759319161996245, 0.024511443451046944, -0.026012538000941277, 0.004491979721933603, 0.008062968030571938, 0.007564096711575985, 0.025342941284179688, 0.022704478353261948, -0.0453365221619606, 0.005210219882428646, -0.02438107691705227, -0.020059878006577492, 0.024802258238196373, 0.000495560874696821, -0.042157284915447235, 0.024665305390954018, -0.02131839282810688, -0.0646013543009758, -0.02643599919974804, -0.02463691122829914, 0.01702740788459778, -0.028595488518476486, -0.014540850184857845, 0.03999485820531845, 0.027582718059420586, -0.09567539393901825, -0.009320700541138649, -0.0328247956931591, 0.01580197364091873, -0.042046912014484406, -0.012594683095812798, 0.014292242005467415, 0.009156717918813229, 0.021691955626010895, 0.036811765283346176, 0.00821883324533701, -0.017641950398683548, -0.03240351751446724, -0.03371218219399452, 0.019719094038009644, -0.021170904859900475, 0.022518735378980637, -0.0009286567219533026, 0.002121877623721957, 0.06602286547422409, 0.05027846246957779, -0.018722902983427048, -0.0514167882502079, 0.006704261992126703, 0.0023254749830812216, -0.012923738919198513, -0.0027701964136213064, 0.003532858332619071, 0.002880216808989644, 0.008658822625875473, -0.03468259796500206, 0.0065167853608727455, 0.038986265659332275, -0.022700754925608635, -0.03442754969000816, 0.057604558765888214, -0.005382586736232042, 0.017300186678767204, -0.011451234109699726, 0.02250349335372448, -0.040666837245225906, 0.02409873716533184, -0.00315878726541996, -0.005402145907282829, 0.005759365390986204, -0.031301967799663544, 0.011412474326789379, -0.02416582964360714, -0.029632380232214928, -0.013877743855118752, 0.021435650065541267, 0.015202831476926804, -0.05023431405425072, -0.006110436748713255, 0.04161835089325905, 0.03916875645518303, -0.013739418238401413, -0.0019008888630196452, 0.05293487384915352, 0.018963705748319626, -0.0066519007086753845, -0.0048294332809746265, -0.014508405700325966, 0.0023324829526245594, 0.005022797733545303, -0.04967043176293373, -0.0017915398348122835, 0.038822855800390244, 0.004321911372244358, 0.01514701172709465, 0.011670134961605072, -0.015007911249995232, -0.020441977307200432, -0.03322944790124893, -0.00088921730639413, -0.008310394361615181, 0.05327500402927399, 0.023181315511465073, 0.03324158489704132, -0.024523021653294563, 0.01583431102335453, -0.013900707475841045, 0.003442225744947791, -0.06427925825119019, 0.025660715997219086, -0.01733715645968914, 0.01289530098438263, -0.0180756114423275, -0.013938261196017265, 0.05570448562502861, -0.02402692660689354, -0.003796172793954611, -0.03141546994447708, 0.011400778777897358, -0.011179191060364246, 0.025815041735768318, -0.006840300280600786, -0.015388482250273228, 0.0008808429702185094, -0.01112732570618391, 0.04088183492422104, -0.029629789292812347, 0.058292701840400696, -0.015289726667106152, -0.0027181010227650404, -0.018870195373892784, -0.020766040310263634, 0.02478654496371746, 0.022555066272616386, 0.030418751761317253, 0.011034061200916767, 0.04661427438259125, -0.053584806621074677, 0.004101384896785021, -0.01522817648947239, 0.06049805507063866, 0.03101464733481407, 0.00042219815077260137, -0.00806086789816618, -0.04189836233854294, -0.028937172144651413, 0.0014152885414659977, 0.016946839168667793, -0.010697639547288418, -0.003860119264572859, 0.049317363649606705, 0.004433406051248312, -0.059700578451156616, -0.025810297578573227, 0.061570435762405396, 0.023546939715743065, -0.02400677651166916, -0.028974691405892372, 0.00676878122612834, -0.005062995012849569, 0.044908568263053894, 0.008830626495182514, 0.03371439874172211, 0.05511290580034256, 0.0021335571072995663, 0.041540417820215225, -0.02661050111055374, -0.03234929218888283, 0.028217952698469162, 0.020749613642692566, 0.03310227394104004, -0.013081928715109825, -0.009697170928120613, 0.009305544197559357, 0.060408953577280045, 0.03291217237710953, 0.06064916402101517, 0.04116629436612129, -0.0981559157371521, -0.04052463918924332, 0.032037653028964996, 0.040288046002388, 0.000490807113237679, -0.04766267165541649, -0.05552296340465546, -0.018488271161913872, 0.03868284821510315, -0.03661361336708069, 0.03006327524781227, 0.01682627573609352, 0.022004829719662666, -0.03616095334291458, -0.037181247025728226, -0.013341526500880718, 0.03246159106492996, -0.052525609731674194, 0.08538829535245895, -0.009052453562617302, -0.011893080547451973, -0.03590729087591171, 0.0035804465878754854, 0.026625849306583405, 0.036818020045757294, -0.05141494795680046, -0.030850885435938835, 0.005703105591237545, 0.021086236461997032, 0.02024274691939354, -0.06358025223016739, 0.007501835934817791, 0.03057720698416233, 0.02552417665719986, 0.04671662673354149, -0.013308215886354446, -0.050672125071287155, -0.015937447547912598, 0.029559049755334854, -0.058540403842926025, 0.0000793661383795552, -0.02601843886077404, 0.03868738189339638, 0.025286776944994926, -0.0039055231027305126, 0.018528444692492485, 0.001888959319330752, 0.025564221665263176, -0.00028886785730719566, -0.051388632506132126, 0.005356304347515106, -0.002528444631025195, -0.02011350356042385, -0.04379387944936752, -0.024665074422955513, -0.011265051551163197, 0.002152916742488742, -0.018581794574856758, 0.03987206146121025, 0.014981352724134922, -0.03272990137338638, -0.028150122612714767, 0.030932024121284485, -0.024488968774676323, -0.02454281598329544, -0.010629447177052498, 0.030491827055811882, -0.012393692508339882, 0.04100180044770241, 0.011374806985259056, 0.04043668136000633, 0.027933474630117416, 0.003961910959333181, -0.033378783613443375, -0.003663410199806094, -0.016538377851247787, 0.002910204930230975, -0.03822741284966469, -0.011461209505796432, 0.04239776358008385, -0.014622334390878677, 0.031142722815275192, -0.036823902279138565, -0.04538750648498535, -0.01881994679570198, 0.004553386941552162, -0.0021205225493758917, 0.045127984136343, -0.0043203262612223625, -0.005693893413990736, -0.01724313013255596, 0.001294681685976684, -0.050505660474300385, 0.0011255135759711266, -0.011387391947209835, -0.016163505613803864, -0.05460400506854057, -0.020050305873155594, 0.022699454799294472, -0.0009259458747692406, -0.06042104959487915, 0.029004164040088654, 0.05306071788072586, -0.05263951048254967, -0.010887537151575089, 0.03257618471980095, 0.00584461260586977, 0.06485471874475479, -0.03424949571490288, 0.006131867412477732, 0.03161901235580444, -0.007095079869031906, 0.0036294402088969946, 0.03201130032539368, -0.031152060255408287, -0.043904513120651245, -0.026382824406027794, -0.022018011659383774, 0.02972671017050743, 0.03656066209077835, 0.0022243375424295664, -0.007941032759845257, 0.0020670141093432903, -0.031247247010469437, 0.007643499877303839, -0.03653321415185928, 0.030278949066996574, 0.023595625534653664, -0.03349895402789116, -0.02612137421965599, 0.013193645514547825, -0.004120820201933384, -0.01805865205824375, 0.015001417137682438, 0.013042185455560684, 0.041035909205675125, 0.0009732305188663304, 0.04781477153301239, -0.01479751244187355, -0.008710222318768501, 0.01314699836075306, -0.03716514632105827, 0.05646900832653046, 0.011808924376964569, 0.008544608019292355, -0.012576951645314693, 0.0425962395966053, -0.03174479305744171, -0.011080819182097912, -0.037434376776218414, -0.01671808958053589, 0.04655992239713669, 0.016113031655550003, 0.05322188884019852, 0.04759129136800766, 0.01653863862156868, -0.033039528876543045, -0.042981360107660294, 0.004695351701229811, -0.021713869646191597, 0.0005733335856348276, 0.036381542682647705, -0.0036140354350209236, -0.012257007881999016, 0.026570923626422882, 0.004379664082080126, 0.03999944031238556, 0.030584320425987244, 0.013458210974931717, 0.028681116178631783, 0.029288241639733315, -0.03281731158494949, -0.03452953323721886, 0.014242466539144516, -0.03236901015043259, -0.005846208892762661, -0.009448217228055, -0.01600702293217182, 0.05479837581515312, 0.008807789534330368, 0.0001937944907695055, -0.05327178165316582, -0.03005734272301197, -0.05849973484873772, 0.041585762053728104, 0.016281800344586372, -0.04893575236201286, 0.014033266343176365, 0.004178994335234165, -0.0013089670101180673, -0.023296300321817398, 0.04360442981123924, -0.01256840955466032, -0.054376088082790375, -0.045353565365076065, -0.05386177822947502, -0.06203160062432289, 0.013349426910281181, -0.005335584748536348, -0.033294811844825745, 0.006470013875514269, -0.01486994232982397, 0.015972532331943512, -0.015427815727889538, 0.005355902016162872, 0.0071627916768193245, 0.022757267579436302, -0.010097959078848362, 0.0026750194374471903, -0.013574222102761269, 0.004137389361858368, 0.1359720230102539, 0.08299504965543747, 0.05502919852733612, -0.0226499792188406, -0.013050351291894913, 0.025832820683717728, -0.011186976917088032, -0.03227199614048004, 0.029769057407975197, 0.013672408647835255, -0.0419057235121727, -0.000048985522880684584, 0.021143946796655655, 0.02767764776945114, -0.024071747437119484, 0.051483627408742905, -0.03976605087518692, 0.021218515932559967, -0.016033221036195755, 0.03269641846418381, 0.02988402731716633, 0.016444718465209007, -0.06189259514212608, 0.013315447606146336, 0.009914585389196873, -0.0007233409560285509, -0.03491784259676933, -0.014660865068435669, -0.014447693713009357, -0.00010388986265752465, -0.026100678369402885, -0.006493993103504181, 0.016751954331994057, 0.018510280176997185, 0.00927624013274908, -0.0033951299265027046, -0.010527797043323517, -0.05130656063556671, -0.03045724332332611, -0.010688848793506622, 0.04899321123957634, -0.005547464359551668, -0.027856657281517982, 0.01359554659575224, -0.046319298446178436, -0.026792732998728752, -0.07140424102544785, 0.026020435616374016, -0.01213960349559784, -0.01467063371092081, 0.006209414917975664, 0.00010753477545222268, 0.013573470525443554, -0.025882171466946602, -0.002944495528936386, 0.020062515512108803, 0.011123789474368095, 0.020214250311255455, -0.03351755440235138, -0.0085857342928648, 0.050421781837940216, -0.00904074776917696, 0.0257539264857769, -0.0014280538307502866, -0.04197227209806442, -0.03496285527944565, 0.014200578443706036, 0.027209913358092308, 0.023272132501006126, 0.0007239593542180955, -0.003417759668081999, 0.005142440553754568, -0.045612189918756485, -0.000718776835128665, -0.016668137162923813, 0.0022487447131425142, 0.02026534453034401, 0.010440089739859104, -0.012891780585050583, -0.045718003064394, -0.017797023057937622, 0.003019642550498247, -0.03974423184990883, 0.01154189184308052, -0.0316641628742218, 0.017166875302791595, -0.019320722669363022, 0.08844563364982605, -0.015275582671165466, 0.03417148441076279, 0.017267080023884773, 0.029081258922815323, 0.023938767611980438, -0.01811373233795166, -0.020988235250115395, -0.026846272870898247, -0.057213105261325836, 0.06285781413316727, 0.01207047700881958, 0.07850418239831924, 0.0641246810555458, 0.019453125074505806, 0.017830269411206245, 0.062262143939733505, -0.005716720130294561, 0.031003190204501152, -0.010806846432387829, -0.06468753516674042, -0.006261283066123724, -0.006854691077023745, -0.026935869827866554, -0.07452621310949326, -0.021675800904631615, -0.04556577652692795, -0.032981932163238525, 0.0005315686576068401, -0.03356952965259552, -0.03753426671028137, 0.015891456976532936, -0.028978470712900162, 0.045732058584690094, 0.0240981075912714, -0.05098085105419159, -0.023304838687181473, -0.015053687617182732, -0.010121989995241165, -0.024600163102149963, -0.027024418115615845, -0.024666376411914825, -0.0028520002961158752, -0.008634191006422043, 0.04039274901151657, -0.02806241437792778, 0.03070845827460289, -0.008457084186375141, 0.020356815308332443, -0.0025505833327770233, 0.03052213415503502, -0.016122261062264442, 0.021866751834750175, 0.0061865560710430145, -0.003079039044678211, -0.046330153942108154, 0.021782031282782555, -0.011105526238679886, 0.049718137830495834, 0.010199743323028088, -0.01476659532636404, -0.024455668404698372, 0.0168776772916317, 0.002309710718691349, -0.013869989663362503, 0.005787627771496773, 0.04457973688840866, 0.005003824830055237, -0.02471511997282505, 0.039645783603191376, 0.014314086176455021, -0.010471506975591183, -0.003325602039694786, 0.02756163664162159, 0.04902280867099762, -0.048228368163108826, 0.014640877023339272, -0.023946715518832207, 0.027331003919243813, 0.014610743150115013, 0.03383117541670799, 0.056320082396268845, 0.0031076990999281406, -0.02957315742969513, 0.04965803027153015, 0.03476626053452492, 0.012309680692851543, -0.08391508460044861, -0.028263501822948456, 0.019772805273532867, 0.016686487942934036, 0.04717490077018738, -0.03241991251707077, 0.005973313003778458, 0.02672119438648224, -0.0860452726483345, 0.04034667834639549, -0.00303853303194046, -0.009533482603728771, -0.04990674555301666, -0.016534218564629555, -0.04423084855079651, -0.009278550744056702, 0.02029917575418949, 0.00876131746917963, 0.02773730643093586, 0.039135124534368515, -0.012816510163247585, -0.02184869907796383, -0.032388847321271896, 0.004765533842146397, -0.0007439127657562494, -0.024141788482666016, 0.05623869225382805, -0.05270839482545853, -0.028960438445210457, 0.010864145122468472, -0.02414858713746071, -0.0029078489169478416, 0.051018066704273224, 0.023575644940137863, 0.0035858533810824156, 0.05305827409029007, 0.040932804346084595, -0.021593382582068443, 0.04877923056483269, 0.02347538247704506, -0.009909412823617458, 0.022674746811389923, 0.005379365757107735, 0.0035286361817270517, 0.05325694382190704, -0.03047284297645092, -0.00832908321171999, 0.005159527529031038, 0.0017675968119874597, -0.0009842060972005129, 0.022670214995741844, -0.006152112502604723, -0.011281332932412624, 0.008418616838753223, 0.023553309962153435, -0.04685043916106224, -0.005548682063817978, 0.004485560581088066, 0.04438374191522598, -0.0035295088309794664, 0.010199003852903843, -0.026621492579579353, -0.048103947192430496, 0.007996578700840473, 0.030713390558958054, -0.022426210343837738, -0.07170747965574265, 0.03418845310807228, 0.02761431224644184, -0.04013693332672119, -0.015718521550297737, -0.014089447446167469, -0.03130604699254036, 0.03753374516963959, 0.0112847238779068, 0.029352014884352684, 0.03147483617067337, 0.011866929940879345, 0.0290946327149868, -0.09206891059875488, 0.060119956731796265, 0.010906519368290901, 0.011621217243373394, -0.0005488504539243877, -0.015275269746780396, -0.03500235453248024, -0.008527044206857681, 0.07222487032413483, 0.004067912232130766, 0.04079050570726395, -0.02207976020872593, 0.018404370173811913, 0.008859104476869106, -0.05398337170481682, 0.008680627681314945, -0.00796497706323862, -0.0022157069761306047, -0.026025643572211266, -0.014716831035912037, 0.0025843228213489056, -0.0312565341591835, 0.018708307296037674, 0.01868920959532261, -0.033052340149879456, 0.02086913213133812, 0.008379270322620869, 0.020593345165252686, 0.009997921995818615, 0.010654131881892681, 0.036524102091789246, 0.03715543448925018, 0.004310612101107836, 0.035764481872320175, -0.02366035059094429, -0.06144195422530174, 0.03593020886182785, -0.04096537455916405, -0.01357570942491293, -0.027315279468894005, 0.015960082411766052, 0.004447325598448515, -0.06798917800188065, -0.0029866378754377365, 0.04976832866668701, 0.0035795660223811865, 0.034264467656612396, 0.016400963068008423, 0.02244744449853897, 0.05729295313358307, -0.011385262943804264, 0.031783442944288254, -0.02027841843664646, -0.003008473664522171, 0.009191282093524933, -0.03619784861803055, 0.06591908633708954, 0.018277522176504135, 0.018808487802743912, 0.021926717832684517, -0.028905389830470085, 0.03770569711923599, -0.0276501402258873, 0.01406853087246418, -0.03612075001001358, 0.006924204528331757, -0.015425733290612698, -0.02861657366156578, 0.01553476881235838, 0.0026616184040904045, -0.0086617236956954, 0.06240636482834816, -0.04176239296793938, 0.006547532510012388, -0.05439426377415657, -0.013530991971492767, 0.014482210390269756, 0.01603495329618454, 0.017584294080734253, 0.03705807775259018, 0.011632351204752922, 0.012491392903029919, 0.019753417000174522, -0.001390078105032444, 0.017697209492325783, 0.0036530583165585995, 0.028192227706313133, 0.024314068257808685, 0.029707511886954308, 0.02081712894141674, -0.013411405496299267, 0.00004402352715260349, -0.01754051446914673, 0.012375794351100922, 0.07131455838680267, 0.016934726387262344, 0.009432320483028889, -0.05904607102274895, -0.003145841648802161, -0.004913902375847101, -0.075321264564991, -0.011256030760705471, -0.08335268497467041, 0.014454607851803303, 0.01885880157351494, -0.04114660620689392 ]
<p>I am doing multiple imputation on a database of observations on hospital patients. There is one observation of many covariates per patient. There are 2 binary outcome variables:</p> <ol> <li><p>Alive/Dead after 30 days</p></li> <li><p>Died in hospital, or survived/discharged</p></li> </ol> <p>Two seperate analysis models (logistic regression), with identical covariates, are to be run, each with one of these outcomes as the response. There are 7 covariates in the analysis models.</p> <p>There is missing data of between 3 and 11% in the covariates and the outcomes. </p> <p>In addition there are 7 further covariates that are to be used in the imputation model to predict the missingness in the covariates and outcomes.</p> <p>My questions concerns the imputation of the two outcome variables. They are to be used as predictors for missingness in the covariates, as per standard practice, but they are highly collinear with each other. Is this a concern for the imputation model ? Is it valid/recommended to impute them both in the same model (to generate several complete datasets all containing both outcomes) or should seperate imputations be performed for each of the outcomes (to generate two distinct sets of complete datasets, each distinct set having one of the outcomes) ? Any other suggestions for how to proceed would be welcome.</p>
47,568
[ -0.06108243018388748, -0.0031808498315513134, -0.05487678200006485, 0.0017272582044824958, 0.04249739646911621, 0.0007193178753368556, -0.004733747337013483, -0.020500488579273224, 0.05483604222536087, -0.01592591591179371, 0.025073496624827385, 0.0199094507843256, 0.015361720696091652, -0.037961870431900024, -0.002771251369267702, 0.013397334143519402, -0.005182922352105379, 0.03069731779396534, 0.015433874912559986, 0.0030932528898119926, -0.015466728247702122, 0.015797071158885956, 0.051029372960329056, 0.0051730843260884285, -0.014721136540174484, 0.030642375349998474, 0.032386064529418945, -0.02867717668414116, -0.011670062318444252, 0.01584795117378235, -0.03409687802195549, -0.054931607097387314, -0.006621109321713448, 0.06393954157829285, 0.002087762113660574, 0.006272878963500261, -0.037805911153554916, -0.015685206279158592, -0.0039022432174533606, 0.04645445570349693, -0.02706518955528736, -0.04355756193399429, -0.014702043496072292, 0.027475161477923393, 0.00785005372017622, -0.0017665791092440486, -0.03210751712322235, -0.04243752732872963, 0.012193028815090656, -0.028496017679572105, 0.04412783309817314, -0.04788755625486374, 0.08171207457780838, 0.04303785413503647, -0.002268382580950856, 0.010918494313955307, 0.05305953696370125, 0.09727580100297928, 0.01835288293659687, -0.05077608674764633, -0.016124170273542404, -0.006114716175943613, -0.0027636506129056215, 0.02502554841339588, -0.02994951233267784, 0.03016974963247776, -0.0060226269997656345, -0.015919148921966553, 0.03564835712313652, -0.005297056399285793, 0.03803116828203201, 0.014391927048563957, 0.04883938655257225, -0.011818713508546352, 0.06318282335996628, -0.036005403846502304, -0.008766992948949337, 0.021008122712373734, 0.015480361878871918, -0.004129576031118631, 0.0038191897328943014, -0.013988621532917023, 0.029424045234918594, 0.0601484440267086, -0.002786940662190318, 0.013968406245112419, 0.06386060267686844, -0.03489350527524948, 0.0282965749502182, -0.03937404602766037, -0.008448142558336258, 0.003557033371180296, 0.038701076060533524, 0.017185306176543236, -0.02989143319427967, 0.023601539433002472, -0.03626386448740959, 0.06694144755601883, -0.0017169468337669969, 0.02127072960138321, -0.00008484096906613559, -0.0109445471316576, 0.021046584472060204, 0.06254573911428452, -0.03187818080186844, 0.00013975032197777182, -0.034228451550006866, -0.006999866105616093, 0.024352969601750374, -0.049847330898046494, -0.026793379336595535, 0.02904135175049305, 0.008470694534480572, -0.0014015173073858023, -0.013719534501433372, -0.020358100533485413, -0.013593205250799656, -0.022435251623392105, 0.03401140496134758, 0.08277514576911926, 0.06248375400900841, -0.032362453639507294, 0.003445556852966547, -0.03822283074259758, -0.057667940855026245, -0.018789714202284813, 0.0032306737266480923, -0.012546793557703495, -0.057455774396657944, 0.05505872890353203, 0.012856480665504932, -0.0041981288231909275, 0.05860361084342003, 0.005465826950967312, 0.0587921105325222, 0.010674791410565376, -0.10023481398820877, -0.041856471449136734, -0.03693423047661781, -0.006133197341114283, 0.03009900078177452, -0.02723904699087143, -0.004506976343691349, -0.0028968004044145346, 0.05865465849637985, -0.0034333716612309217, 0.010580877773463726, 0.02712712064385414, 0.028747450560331345, 0.02111932821571827, 0.01978899911046028, 0.018900172784924507, -0.038448765873909, -0.00508232694119215, -0.024590272456407547, -0.0837089791893959, 0.011733563616871834, 0.03532690182328224, -0.007165935356169939, -0.03783271461725235, 0.02246745117008686, 0.02321484498679638, 0.015521733090281487, 0.009726385585963726, -0.0049812085926532745, -0.019888317212462425, 0.05359571799635887, -0.02144387736916542, 0.017122337594628334, 0.04819658398628235, 0.026264866814017296, 0.05053909868001938, 0.020561886951327324, 0.03682463616132736, 0.016192113980650902, 0.0025275968946516514, -0.005705307237803936, -0.007302292622625828, -0.001426656381227076, 0.037718113511800766, -0.03446042910218239, -0.051806431263685226, -0.012369295582175255, -0.02705477550625801, 0.044360239058732986, 0.018887173384428024, 0.019724275916814804, -0.02840215340256691, 0.04586013779044151, -0.021003970876336098, -0.026954973116517067, -0.06410795450210571, 0.03437028452754021, 0.0075431945733726025, -0.014150021597743034, 0.03477988392114639, -0.001461188541725278, 0.010651107877492905, -0.013573718257248402, -0.0005878596566617489, -0.020549727603793144, -0.029366303235292435, 0.05689985305070877, -0.02548796869814396, 0.027878882363438606, 0.051342252641916275, 0.025269895792007446, -0.016397155821323395, 0.03203533962368965, -0.01061244960874319, -0.04392365366220474, -0.01021366473287344, -0.015486359596252441, 0.022607626393437386, -0.041251443326473236, -0.024703683331608772, -0.005524089559912682, 0.0016691108467057347, -0.02465282380580902, 0.033927641808986664, -0.04784568399190903, 0.09857629239559174, 0.0738891139626503, -0.020081650465726852, -0.01899120584130287, -0.003559298347681761, -0.006058004219084978, 0.0430443100631237, -0.023449713364243507, -0.0384240597486496, -0.07250401377677917, -0.002892198972404003, 0.02157880924642086, -0.016564784571528435, -0.0337354838848114, 0.019939854741096497, 0.047796010971069336, 0.0038077349308878183, 0.014380041509866714, 0.010773573070764542, -0.024716021493077278, -0.008856041356921196, 0.014153403230011463, 0.015085576102137566, 0.0012235401663929224, -0.0011227669892832637, -0.0016546528786420822, -0.027067242190241814, 0.0366545207798481, -0.022205878049135208, 0.024822046980261803, 0.07847989350557327, 0.00621789088472724, 0.013942277990281582, -0.03193141520023346, -0.053606778383255005, 0.028497761115431786, -0.01485191285610199, 0.012559429742395878, 0.04272252693772316, 0.008448273874819279, -0.014758719131350517, 0.030682221055030823, 0.00543872220441699, 0.029151638969779015, 0.045164112001657486, -0.05813872441649437, 0.034335073083639145, -0.013742701150476933, -0.053072489798069, 0.01438908465206623, -0.01429759431630373, -0.03019733540713787, -0.044254403561353683, -0.011165664531290531, 0.024418426677584648, -0.004609381314367056, 0.053805481642484665, -0.026506541296839714, -0.020010018721222878, -0.004446750041097403, -0.04544045031070709, 0.025538403540849686, 0.05136622115969658, -0.028960656374692917, -0.0035327638033777475, -0.030107686296105385, 0.015479703433811665, 0.025500984862446785, -0.024644186720252037, -0.008497362025082111, 0.004698420874774456, 0.006266951095312834, -0.056920625269412994, -0.03504525497555733, 0.008622794412076473, 0.05221842974424362, 0.009807360358536243, -0.034544553607702255, 0.04693017527461052, 0.0296770166605711, -0.04566335305571556, -0.003233525436371565, -0.02402016520500183, -0.009026582352817059, 0.0024248759727925062, -0.007287909742444754, 0.03008977323770523, 0.014777186326682568, 0.007608682382851839, 0.014038982801139355, -0.012150955386459827, -0.005770339164882898, -0.0728338435292244, -0.07555168122053146, 0.04525185748934746, -0.010801895521581173, 0.040870025753974915, -0.002780874725431204, 0.0141904940828681, 0.06808202713727951, 0.034642286598682404, 0.005511455703526735, -0.044975340366363525, 0.0012954623671248555, -0.040739286690950394, 0.034493520855903625, 0.007575423456728458, 0.014586659148335457, 0.018404683098196983, 0.008236312307417393, -0.010768485255539417, 0.03748968616127968, 0.043762627989053726, 0.0006544822826981544, 0.0026581769343465567, 0.021026190370321274, 0.050129517912864685, -0.039561957120895386, 0.024977944791316986, 0.021199127659201622, -0.01728830672800541, 0.005462625529617071, -0.033237770199775696, 0.012293021194636822, 0.008021888323128223, -0.06293532252311707, -0.017904946580529213, -0.023565389215946198, 0.022747844457626343, -0.037276491522789, -0.0257266853004694, 0.038944873958826065, -0.0367327556014061, -0.0011549406917765737, 0.03421288728713989, 0.052325401455163956, -0.04876353591680527, -0.002667491789907217, 0.0749734565615654, 0.015082113444805145, -0.0000865695474203676, -0.002070225775241852, -0.017734969034790993, 0.0027080345898866653, 0.03451283276081085, -0.03656845912337303, 0.012985719367861748, 0.04431852698326111, 0.02404375560581684, 0.013823962770402431, -0.047940343618392944, -0.029674900695681572, 0.02095482498407364, -0.07859084010124207, 0.016236916184425354, 0.011715156026184559, 0.060720622539520264, -0.0011915756622329354, 0.025355881080031395, 0.02182234264910221, -0.02913368120789528, -0.0009957478614524007, 0.03718758746981621, -0.03833294287323952, 0.013285045512020588, -0.01223414484411478, 0.024423405528068542, 0.012545612640678883, -0.005311915650963783, 0.004352362360805273, -0.00032746419310569763, -0.026026984676718712, -0.02220836654305458, 0.01801306940615177, -0.017044132575392723, 0.018379611894488335, -0.04237084090709686, 0.007439261302351952, 0.012954344972968102, 0.012889326550066471, -0.00720989890396595, 0.0064306799322366714, 0.02115522138774395, 0.031906381249427795, 0.01296796090900898, -0.031077463179826736, -0.022959763184189796, -0.029412860050797462, 0.008179496973752975, 0.03951341286301613, 0.005793631076812744, 0.03908495232462883, -0.03488413617014885, 0.00341224018484354, 0.002580928849056363, 0.008262556046247482, 0.02296287566423416, -0.013635851442813873, -0.007133395876735449, -0.023882966488599777, -0.0007159425294958055, -0.001390645862556994, 0.022143488749861717, 0.03607327118515968, -0.02218441106379032, 0.0584554448723793, 0.0476641021668911, -0.06861792504787445, -0.013217883184552193, 0.06864515691995621, 0.029200613498687744, 0.006390681490302086, -0.01982639729976654, 0.0036437492817640305, -0.006530160084366798, -0.016010180115699768, 0.043350692838430405, 0.03883291035890579, -0.004323280416429043, -0.01524503156542778, 0.04448319971561432, -0.011311310343444347, -0.011164840310811996, -0.008854033425450325, 0.04323536157608032, 0.04744252562522888, 0.039291851222515106, -0.016757188364863396, 0.0124739371240139, 0.06264501065015793, 0.025370707735419273, 0.037330470979213715, 0.03614291176199913, -0.08354932069778442, 0.015760159119963646, 0.02331680618226528, 0.02153444103896618, -0.0033191319089382887, -0.02355625480413437, -0.028703555464744568, 0.018978998064994812, 0.03031822293996811, -0.03584781661629677, -0.013208724558353424, 0.0032194715458899736, 0.011916757561266422, 0.027344170957803726, -0.04209801182150841, -0.021163085475564003, -0.011042562313377857, -0.022545184940099716, 0.01147715374827385, 0.01526730414479971, -0.01715712808072567, 0.005924215540289879, 0.01650344580411911, 0.007200631313025951, 0.10324478149414062, -0.005715520586818457, -0.02024916745722294, 0.005950553808361292, 0.015420603565871716, -0.008389790542423725, -0.027237987145781517, -0.029447847977280617, -0.022366534918546677, -0.030262287706136703, 0.04650825262069702, -0.03705325350165367, -0.04803038015961647, 0.008247911930084229, 0.011279534548521042, -0.043462060391902924, 0.00433512544259429, -0.0520767867565155, 0.021809665486216545, -0.012598480097949505, -0.01863752491772175, 0.06161995977163315, 0.020449167117476463, -0.010782966390252113, 0.0016812740359455347, -0.05815945565700531, 0.011716454289853573, -0.0036305927205830812, -0.015538371168076992, -0.04018282890319824, -0.010887456126511097, -0.019503720104694366, -0.005601257085800171, -0.0022757542319595814, 0.03983200713992119, -0.01080700010061264, 0.011417267844080925, 0.03466111794114113, 0.029599500820040703, 0.0015456731198355556, 0.028303051367402077, -0.03627277910709381, 0.0172713715583086, -0.013100292533636093, -0.011715981177985668, 0.036842938512563705, -0.011910013854503632, 0.0011735877487808466, 0.01940816454589367, -0.07197481393814087, 0.02311176434159279, -0.01581968180835247, -0.05057968199253082, 0.020977938547730446, 0.0010924841044470668, 0.0020731675904244184, 0.010554218664765358, 0.06333886831998825, -0.020601460710167885, -0.062239520251750946, 0.005001449026167393, 0.02379506267607212, 0.01683500036597252, 0.012385111302137375, -0.020288068801164627, 0.04724527522921562, -0.0025963459629565477, -0.008870194666087627, -0.06123155727982521, -0.04829757288098335, 0.035286836326122284, -0.01333347987383604, -0.03671368211507797, -0.016965318471193314, 0.022192884236574173, -0.028043469414114952, -0.03630923107266426, -0.04346059635281563, 0.056702520698308945, -0.025464283302426338, -0.032151203602552414, -0.02889317460358143, 0.03454163670539856, 0.060954079031944275, 0.00518613588064909, 0.0036966963671147823, 0.006183736026287079, -0.05572574958205223, -0.0024390171747654676, 0.013974575325846672, 0.006989756133407354, -0.010806538164615631, -0.033239878714084625, -0.05031927302479744, 0.01738894358277321, 0.03759630769491196, -0.003281158395111561, -0.0023813974112272263, -0.007244754582643509, -0.004096577875316143, -0.01637166365981102, -0.0030716010369360447, 0.010854098945856094, -0.016643023118376732, 0.002618260681629181, -0.02421535551548004, 0.020514005795121193, 0.0012836954556405544, -0.0030953153036534786, 0.0021127210929989815, -0.006043041590601206, -0.03307002782821655, 0.02542276307940483, 0.038831666111946106, 0.003870302578434348, 0.034021880477666855, 0.020648613572120667, -0.022340266034007072, 0.050006091594696045, -0.0232247281819582, -0.008536129258573055, 0.0009436330292373896, 0.026125721633434296, -0.05138308182358742, -0.036086417734622955, -0.016014207154512405, -0.002464243210852146, 0.04929677024483681, -0.0013409091625362635, 0.026222169399261475, 0.033708732575178146, -0.00889747403562069, -0.019738875329494476, -0.033961694687604904, -0.00042100914288312197, 0.010041432455182076, 0.01958729512989521, 0.0672144889831543, 0.0014463945990428329, -0.054494865238666534, 0.048177655786275864, -0.0017675290582701564, 0.02815544605255127, 0.030420344322919846, -0.007864877581596375, 0.002823233837261796, -0.00845970306545496, 0.0061776041984558105, -0.02930350787937641, -0.007121377624571323, -0.0516088642179966, -0.014699351042509079, -0.04131652042269707, -0.06142564117908478, 0.0386730320751667, 0.04814305156469345, 0.017636535689234734, -0.02231699973344803, -0.021844755858182907, -0.04353315383195877, 0.009362271055579185, -0.0064455848187208176, 0.0023255206178873777, 0.02846321277320385, -0.008875187486410141, 0.042829837650060654, 0.009220059029757977, 0.028446581214666367, -0.048800744116306305, -0.09476634860038757, -0.05438755452632904, -0.014704947359859943, -0.013017123565077782, 0.014899123460054398, -0.0006889915093779564, -0.008975254371762276, 0.0018284323159605265, 0.004051967989653349, 0.012957819737493992, -0.04816872999072075, 0.05587127059698105, -0.020840635523200035, 0.08259414881467819, 0.016006886959075928, -0.004867917392402887, 0.016876399517059326, -0.005040740594267845, 0.10550130158662796, 0.10578198730945587, 0.05249488726258278, -0.08251925557851791, 0.01469202246516943, 0.05838783457875252, 0.030848344787955284, -0.010024077259004116, 0.01743955910205841, 0.0034493356943130493, -0.052628301084041595, 0.081931471824646, 0.008126105181872845, -0.006190471351146698, -0.024130843579769135, 0.06533752381801605, -0.024057496339082718, -0.023758355528116226, 0.0009760971297509968, 0.0035336860455572605, -0.008690305054187775, -0.03562453016638756, -0.030159922316670418, 0.032358840107917786, 0.015281450934708118, -0.01777440682053566, -0.0055983783677220345, 0.007952890358865261, -0.00815420038998127, -0.0030264602974057198, -0.003532024333253503, 0.008734220638871193, 0.0011135201202705503, 0.03434260934591293, -0.01406762097030878, -0.005376582499593496, 0.008845113217830658, -0.041175004094839096, -0.009114154614508152, 0.03908194601535797, 0.008542188443243504, 0.018946751952171326, 0.007126982323825359, 0.009474028833210468, -0.05586668848991394, -0.022753223776817322, -0.008231889456510544, 0.0336507149040699, 0.00279328809119761, -0.008855991065502167, -0.06259990483522415, 0.005180904641747475, 0.022544095292687416, -0.031142212450504303, -0.02969188056886196, 0.002707158215343952, 0.02732853963971138, -0.034638117998838425, -0.03783569112420082, 0.0005062965210527182, -0.009871846064925194, -0.006139169447124004, 0.03997413441538811, 0.004976017866283655, -0.025702232494950294, -0.021727876737713814, -0.03516436740756035, 0.04905932396650314, 0.011371519416570663, 0.059270165860652924, 0.0026095532812178135, -0.026016835123300552, -0.0014603529125452042, -0.01917392946779728, 0.04534081742167473, 0.013270338997244835, 0.030848301947116852, -0.016815805807709694, 0.0031326222233474255, -0.026401134207844734, -0.06343107670545578, 0.013156525790691376, 0.013914784416556358, -0.013443240895867348, -0.03876655921339989, 0.017514148727059364, 0.023979444056749344, 0.057075466960668564, 0.003333896631374955, 0.026227347552776337, -0.005085483659058809, 0.04575806111097336, -0.0285550095140934, -0.04962599277496338, -0.003997229039669037, -0.024762414395809174, -0.04908410832285881, -0.009593382477760315, -0.026764636859297752, 0.05145774781703949, -0.002678079530596733, 0.05028253048658371, 0.024215953424572945, 0.03490564599633217, 0.015602141618728638, 0.03484291583299637, -0.002052486874163151, -0.05077604949474335, -0.003980634268373251, -0.009677738882601261, 0.046142466366291046, -0.0011298909084871411, 0.00023373137810267508, -0.02346798963844776, -0.04041869938373566, 0.011446751654148102, -0.046315934509038925, -0.04057063162326813, 0.002878657542169094, 0.0018790668109431863, 0.0022600956726819277, -0.04399943724274635, -0.011323029175400734, -0.04077053442597389, 0.003549718763679266, -0.004888684023171663, -0.05126113072037697, 0.009509814903140068, 0.020300768315792084, -0.0010638086823746562, 0.012369287200272083, 0.021193813532590866, -0.011528236791491508, -0.011889536865055561, 0.017848340794444084, 0.03724005073308945, -0.014128364622592926, 0.05026380345225334, -0.027623826637864113, 0.005126968026161194, 0.013238630257546902, -0.021481851115822792, -0.03652072325348854, 0.036490026861429214, 0.0044610886834561825, 0.023884333670139313, 0.007293920964002609, 0.006376827135682106, -0.06361740082502365, 0.06135031208395958, -0.0317533016204834, -0.04080769419670105, -0.024223916232585907, 0.020113050937652588, -0.031325411051511765, 0.0042084865272045135, -0.0056730289943516254, 0.033668939024209976, -0.026195280253887177, 0.02147223986685276, 0.04505031183362007, 0.02689996361732483, -0.01217508316040039, 0.0003986144729424268, 0.027562810108065605, 0.036803096532821655, -0.014183638617396355, 0.017659619450569153, 0.051001571118831635, 0.05407649651169777, 0.010617438703775406, 0.06000600382685661, 0.018420521169900894, 0.03978334739804268, -0.07300763577222824, -0.022261852398514748, 0.007962767966091633, 0.03457416966557503, 0.02040480636060238, -0.0008694326970726252, -0.02523021586239338, 0.0486641563475132, -0.01933087408542633, 0.006275865249335766, -0.012144135311245918, 0.0006521877949126065, -0.02325918711721897, 0.03989395499229431, -0.016956891864538193, -0.0018041707808151841, 0.01819068007171154, 0.02748698741197586, 0.016592713072896004, 0.028508685529232025, 0.009274370037019253, -0.020896725356578827, -0.05259411036968231, 0.014086099341511726, 0.006862814538180828, -0.039039138704538345, 0.029948322102427483, -0.02869819849729538, -0.08005325496196747, 0.02241438440978527, -0.009848833084106445, 0.022208811715245247, 0.034293126314878464, 0.00446926848962903, -0.0071642640978097916, 0.03195629641413689, 0.014580938965082169, 0.009721974842250347, 0.010403722524642944, 0.0031348986085504293, 0.01241608988493681, 0.02354881912469864, -0.03423616662621498, 0.025640808045864105, 0.03170710429549217, -0.02801697701215744, -0.007230841554701328, 0.016963331028819084, 0.011149086058139801, -0.010013054125010967, -0.055083032697439194, 0.017383508384227753, 0.03152317926287651, -0.022978251799941063, 0.0011291846167296171, -0.05020627751946449, -0.00331183266825974, 0.08605936914682388, 0.018604107201099396, -0.0013674459187313914, 0.020442098379135132, -0.00958466436713934, 0.00024072729866020381, -0.006317296996712685, 0.003200366860255599, 0.0041289073415100574, -0.04442330822348595, 0.010009379126131535, -0.019183125346899033, -0.006782026495784521, -0.05865370109677315, 0.007387637160718441, -0.0504172258079052, 0.03900140896439552, -0.035178471356630325, 0.010935216210782528, 0.0314975269138813, -0.015626776963472366, -0.008400808088481426, -0.03862186521291733, 0.03041488490998745, -0.01053999736905098, -0.043981362134218216, -0.04354735463857651, -0.007632098626345396, -0.009831137023866177, 0.01787494495511055, 0.07480733841657639, -0.01835506036877632, -0.010357847437262535, -0.01331635843962431, 0.020383751019835472, -0.00499701825901866, -0.04693940654397011, 0.01706543378531933, -0.04770541191101074, -0.027382763102650642, -0.02617262676358223, 0.0012952557299286127, -0.007624891586601734, 0.009002428501844406, 0.009635554626584053, -0.06800266355276108, 0.03732982650399208, 0.009344606660306454, -0.0010836351430043578, -0.0017412672750651836, -0.020976873114705086, -0.03274678438901901, 0.03458119556307793, -0.014641964808106422, 0.018680108711123466, 0.025650419294834137, -0.010646119713783264, -0.06717033684253693, 0.03339576721191406, -0.02295062504708767, -0.03371220827102661, 0.010166971944272518, -0.0020414553582668304, -0.01600492373108864, -0.07029889523983002, 0.008076520636677742, 0.026774175465106964, -0.039036255329847336, 0.04309886693954468, 0.05084202438592911, 0.0021020539570599794, 0.029925260692834854, -0.0026895536575466394, -0.007060558535158634, 0.008786279708147049, -0.016996731981635094, 0.008031376637518406, -0.01380277331918478, 0.006862028036266565, 0.008492174558341503, -0.005416328553110361, 0.013995693996548653, 0.001181456376798451, 0.031638581305742264, -0.01187401358038187, 0.022651543840765953, -0.037406038492918015, -0.0017347360262647271, -0.03244137763977051, 0.016736941412091255, 0.015343784354627132, -0.002367194974794984, -0.01597936823964119, 0.03967895358800888, -0.023822259157896042, 0.02238805592060089, -0.05181826278567314, -0.028324194252490997, -0.03121303580701351, 0.021877150982618332, 0.008332986384630203, 0.03999838978052139, 0.0005585239268839359, -0.01248668972402811, 0.011662006378173828, -0.024273037910461426, 0.0016961549408733845, -0.049371711909770966, 0.019381966441869736, -0.01139185018837452, -0.014606843702495098, -0.015229874290525913, -0.04692579060792923, -0.04149191081523895, -0.026570402085781097, 0.010656751692295074, 0.03502315282821655, 0.01882408745586872, -0.05495045334100723, -0.042384304106235504, -0.010527887381613255, 0.04766232892870903, -0.05754726752638817, -0.025973603129386902, -0.023817528039216995, 0.0003072542604058981, 0.008131218142807484, 0.0037516108714044094 ]
<p>Suppose, the data below shows the mean response time on a task for respondents among four different groups:</p> <pre><code>A B C D 1.2 2.3 4.5 6.7 </code></pre> <p>In order to assess which one of the means are different from one another I do a multiple comparisons test (after an omnibus ANOVA test is cleared) and the multiple comparisons test tells me that the mean for group D is significantly different from the ones for groups A and B and no other pair of differences is significantly different.</p> <p>What is the best way to present this information visually? </p>
6,799
[ -0.05178322270512581, 0.0037563343066722155, -0.013162755407392979, -0.007842529565095901, 0.030992193147540092, 0.03312128409743309, 0.02966688573360443, -0.007639333140105009, 0.007330731023102999, 0.02094024047255516, 0.057768914848566055, 0.015045195817947388, 0.05119972303509712, -0.01807653345167637, 0.03416023403406143, -0.0027569634839892387, 0.005855245515704155, -0.04080197960138321, -0.017835592851042747, -0.019457850605249405, -0.00860173162072897, -0.029138032346963882, 0.011312217451632023, -0.0026400508359074593, -0.008158429525792599, 0.045014750212430954, 0.04325878620147705, 0.011283721774816513, 0.005006030667573214, 0.04084250330924988, -0.061909813433885574, -0.03202184662222862, 0.010126499459147453, 0.014517733827233315, 0.01238621212542057, 0.009862896054983139, -0.013168448582291603, 0.0005160559667274356, 0.019670726731419563, 0.029500385746359825, -0.020552154630422592, 0.030107202008366585, 0.008610541000962257, 0.03470464423298836, -0.003034111810848117, 0.01655193790793419, -0.015016749501228333, -0.010940502397716045, 0.0029857016634196043, -0.034709613770246506, 0.06345818191766739, 0.01180567778646946, 0.05529717728495598, 0.018781324848532677, -0.04001718387007713, -0.014967150054872036, 0.021712342277169228, 0.08576253801584244, 0.010252611711621284, -0.08182787895202637, 0.012500135228037834, -0.012797802686691284, 0.0033928186167031527, -0.00020352230058051646, -0.03095795214176178, 0.04374521225690842, -0.00673605315387249, -0.005859047640115023, 0.027814948931336403, -0.010241251438856125, -0.003312251530587673, 0.029904717579483986, 0.06153196841478348, -0.020466068759560585, 0.02158844657242298, -0.04182208329439163, 0.05483810603618622, 0.007848876528441906, 0.04714841768145561, 0.03459488973021507, -0.023824583739042282, 0.003340192139148712, -0.027884511277079582, 0.041732240468263626, 0.022374650463461876, -0.017084559425711632, 0.061149198561906815, -0.02031470090150833, -0.009006897918879986, 0.04062388092279434, -0.036053843796253204, -0.009566100314259529, 0.03116370365023613, 0.03294846788048744, -0.0341731421649456, 0.024804387241601944, -0.020178452134132385, 0.05315035209059715, 0.013470727019011974, -0.04206031933426857, -0.029511405155062675, -0.023679500445723534, 0.0398198701441288, 0.02917618118226528, 0.01147264614701271, 0.031615085899829865, -0.04261038079857826, 0.017439013347029686, -0.010041864588856697, -0.013595965690910816, -0.022838929668068886, 0.01800086908042431, 0.021791815757751465, 0.04322929307818413, 0.021812425926327705, -0.01013523805886507, -0.019955985248088837, 0.013280997052788734, 0.057250168174505234, 0.055169690400362015, 0.04095129296183586, -0.05936635658144951, 0.016779182478785515, -0.026040581986308098, -0.06794664263725281, -0.00407585222274065, 0.001582994475029409, -0.0297774039208889, -0.017904317006468773, 0.05714745819568634, -0.019254831597208977, 0.02391321025788784, 0.03804752230644226, -0.019492289051413536, 0.011900292709469795, 0.040109194815158844, -0.06935039907693863, -0.06166889891028404, 0.01693904399871826, -0.02926262468099594, -0.013676467351615429, -0.0743551030755043, -0.012946066446602345, 0.03426026552915573, 0.004218440968543291, 0.016491390764713287, 0.014923139475286007, -0.01821911893785, 0.0016355622792616487, 0.010509316809475422, 0.0035122029948979616, 0.0009980297181755304, 0.006499637383967638, -0.0345618762075901, 0.017405321821570396, -0.05734966695308685, -0.01382124051451683, 0.012077996507287025, -0.004441539756953716, -0.003575780661776662, 0.04553529620170593, -0.0024355200584977865, -0.023284900933504105, -0.008002225309610367, 0.015058673918247223, 0.019532520323991776, 0.0681455209851265, -0.00837188120931387, 0.04262099787592888, -0.0017733302665874362, 0.00824441947042942, 0.011567165143787861, -0.022871362045407295, 0.039287421852350235, 0.04365025833249092, -0.012008343823254108, 0.009693266823887825, 0.06189723685383797, -0.014229869470000267, -0.014208798296749592, -0.015937453135848045, -0.041032951325178146, -0.026010187342762947, 0.03187887370586395, 0.008575435727834702, 0.03431070223450661, -0.014071492478251457, 0.004543504677712917, 0.02917480282485485, -0.023455452173948288, -0.05609328672289848, -0.06918332725763321, 0.006993627175688744, 0.016225319355726242, -0.06003708392381668, 0.013421912677586079, -0.017086774110794067, 0.0069904332049191, 0.0059338705614209175, -0.013388462364673615, -0.026429539546370506, -0.01285338681191206, 0.057706285268068314, -0.030310524627566338, -0.024043655022978783, 0.048490867018699646, 0.048071473836898804, -0.03585539385676384, 0.03293934836983681, -0.006634088698774576, -0.0011576686520129442, 0.0026656207628548145, -0.020995337516069412, 0.016915524378418922, 0.011087460443377495, 0.016749918460845947, -0.015959693118929863, 0.03644637018442154, -0.02676738239824772, 0.024891817942261696, -0.02288430742919445, 0.0690612718462944, 0.07401158660650253, -0.041045572608709335, 0.014796840026974678, -0.02428590878844261, -0.006559802684932947, 0.017779942601919174, -0.007249512244015932, 0.0014775885501876473, -0.05470125377178192, -0.0028811083175241947, 0.03214595466852188, -0.02688201144337654, -0.0330456867814064, 0.041914183646440506, 0.046691447496414185, 0.0072556608356535435, 0.007346448488533497, 0.010920267552137375, -0.003635810222476721, -0.003872697940096259, -0.006290477700531483, 0.019047312438488007, 0.02415911853313446, -0.009019473567605019, 0.014202315360307693, 0.030868694186210632, 0.038581859320402145, 0.022499531507492065, 0.05426879599690437, 0.034149155020713806, -0.009593797847628593, 0.014425771310925484, -0.019584670662879944, -0.0000708215738995932, 0.03407811373472214, 0.0015571421245113015, -0.002162231132388115, 0.06571640819311142, -0.009559408761560917, 0.0007317839190363884, 0.024781428277492523, -0.04160378500819206, 0.03511526435613632, 0.02969563938677311, -0.015018973499536514, -0.0018828317988663912, 0.01275312714278698, -0.011393328197300434, 0.047916244715452194, -0.05015706270933151, -0.024608897045254707, -0.045260876417160034, 0.0025881400797516108, 0.02836696058511734, -0.012804814614355564, 0.015244903042912483, -0.027760474011301994, -0.01453961431980133, -0.02387685328722, 0.008605347014963627, 0.03055742383003235, 0.008083024062216282, -0.045195963233709335, -0.006666451692581177, -0.05537346005439758, -0.05312345549464226, 0.019147388637065887, -0.008890497498214245, -0.03684842959046364, 0.04605051875114441, 0.016666021198034286, -0.05092098191380501, -0.01693040318787098, -0.0017459883820265532, 0.036493610590696335, -0.01422184705734253, -0.025560302659869194, 0.06426794081926346, -0.0114249587059021, -0.036579541862010956, 0.02889910340309143, -0.05711248889565468, -0.02655135467648506, 0.0022260101977735758, -0.000017893711628858, 0.011440843343734741, 0.01634342223405838, -0.01859058439731598, -0.0003664989781100303, -0.012768171727657318, -0.0051822480745613575, -0.051110535860061646, -0.07351484149694443, -0.004611090756952763, 0.025119435042142868, 0.05516219884157181, -0.02452143095433712, -0.03293841332197189, 0.04274260252714157, 0.0458596833050251, -0.029780875891447067, -0.03133213147521019, -0.0044905622489750385, -0.03718717396259308, -0.02780965529382229, 0.03455108404159546, 0.03204113990068436, -0.00941991526633501, -0.009285146370530128, 0.0036254413425922394, 0.026382841169834137, 0.05047333985567093, -0.0010387580841779709, -0.03748210892081261, 0.0026779293548315763, -0.004351092968136072, -0.02842790074646473, 0.022202175110578537, 0.036599475890398026, -0.05690794065594673, 0.031529948115348816, -0.027868399396538734, 0.016034238040447235, -0.013785645365715027, -0.024720782414078712, 0.020998310297727585, -0.024923445656895638, -0.008118262514472008, -0.041274238377809525, 0.02641172893345356, 0.032778557389974594, 0.007577433250844479, -0.01912412792444229, 0.016162725165486336, 0.03250303119421005, -0.021790744736790657, -0.03085310570895672, 0.06848609447479248, 0.030454980209469795, -0.022144600749015808, -0.001171426847577095, -0.006853004451841116, -0.012000690214335918, 0.02201867662370205, -0.03299183025956154, -0.015148606151342392, 0.043023835867643356, 0.024077657610177994, 0.023163510486483574, 0.026428312063217163, -0.031737882643938065, -0.003397213527932763, -0.0827740952372551, 0.02190162055194378, -0.016895931214094162, 0.06347688287496567, 0.014820339158177376, 0.03978319466114044, 0.06556086242198944, -0.018328672274947166, -0.030412714928388596, -0.021774079650640488, -0.06835342198610306, 0.03123478777706623, -0.008401697501540184, 0.0008593641687184572, 0.014747094362974167, -0.02673570066690445, 0.03672705590724945, -0.030776290223002434, 0.047091301530599594, 0.01957046613097191, 0.038354236632585526, -0.023241790011525154, -0.022571969777345657, 0.032899029552936554, 0.02401404082775116, -0.01396933849900961, 0.026522044092416763, 0.016867807134985924, 0.015566044487059116, 0.04753703251481056, 0.03937976062297821, -0.018568843603134155, 0.003604432102292776, -0.01899966038763523, -0.029535256326198578, 0.00588546646758914, 0.017878027632832527, 0.020662756636738777, 0.03220004960894585, -0.06991614401340485, 0.03263477608561516, 0.02437131293118, 0.03631511330604553, 0.03443603217601776, -0.016057198867201805, 0.0021363776177167892, -0.03528944030404091, -0.001297017210163176, -0.008610555902123451, 0.0363597609102726, -0.006581081077456474, 0.0020812228322029114, 0.017085915431380272, 0.03927985951304436, -0.021051110699772835, 0.0419355072081089, 0.02057909406721592, 0.006141775753349066, -0.01666058413684368, -0.0491861030459404, -0.029699960723519325, -0.020857857540249825, -0.015275516547262669, 0.02998310700058937, 0.0626896396279335, 0.03448769450187683, 0.03168357536196709, 0.026101471856236458, 0.0062492587603628635, -0.027547156438231468, 0.010548897087574005, -0.012462399899959564, -0.005354295484721661, 0.03988157585263252, -0.0020882387179881334, 0.025068337097764015, 0.054555442184209824, 0.009450563229620457, -0.006011033430695534, -0.022614678367972374, -0.09166525304317474, -0.01871936023235321, 0.04093702882528305, 0.04934634268283844, -0.02556677721440792, 0.0009764088899828494, 0.0018766336143016815, 0.01723531447350979, 0.044111136347055435, -0.05590143799781799, 0.03982781246304512, -0.03448616713285446, 0.0010547470301389694, -0.036226026713848114, 0.013569480739533901, -0.04418164864182472, 0.04207289591431618, -0.010296638123691082, 0.0023154502268880606, 0.024812905117869377, -0.012963442131876945, -0.03655385971069336, -0.002557376865297556, 0.026346955448389053, 0.02417316846549511, -0.018631586804986, -0.015253080986440182, 0.035785648971796036, -0.009479938074946404, -0.046488646417856216, -0.018700333312153816, 0.043443452566862106, 0.0025291340425610542, -0.015597185119986534, 0.05333241820335388, -0.02825944684445858, -0.03945770859718323, 0.02688135951757431, -0.003797615645453334, 0.010306005366146564, -0.018568938598036766, -0.0292833112180233, 0.05235789343714714, 0.05232075974345207, 0.01406608335673809, 0.021708941087126732, 0.020201487466692924, 0.0005860995152033865, 0.0017094191862270236, -0.017845600843429565, -0.011319974437355995, -0.02624519355595112, -0.005639028735458851, 0.002372165210545063, -0.009914140217006207, -0.03711977228522301, 0.03517789766192436, -0.026289429515600204, 0.027871817350387573, -0.0378207229077816, -0.017927713692188263, 0.016206657513976097, 0.005488900002092123, 0.02168130874633789, -0.016397302970290184, 0.024846885353326797, -0.047528259456157684, -0.017476992681622505, -0.006727221421897411, 0.03606336563825607, -0.04019826650619507, -0.01401431392878294, 0.03204881399869919, -0.05200333520770073, -0.012047612108290195, -0.04512053728103638, -0.03133520483970642, 0.0015451882500201464, -0.03994680568575859, 0.008497895672917366, -0.009218853898346424, 0.04290984943509102, 0.036795396357774734, -0.054612379521131516, -0.025765925645828247, 0.04602197930216789, -0.003299752017483115, -0.005266064777970314, -0.04990222677588463, 0.06146230548620224, -0.022739453241229057, 0.012967929244041443, -0.05652700737118721, -0.02769041433930397, 0.018880465999245644, 0.013510501012206078, -0.012105179950594902, -0.02446700818836689, -0.023338552564382553, 0.0065842499025166035, -0.00605136901140213, -0.005220871418714523, 0.045241232961416245, 0.02323145419359207, -0.03120301477611065, -0.03704497590661049, 0.03636428713798523, 0.10705044120550156, 0.0020481240935623646, 0.004282635170966387, 0.000051561964937718585, -0.01928521692752838, -0.03058060072362423, -0.0037714121863245964, 0.00426694517955184, -0.04231417924165726, -0.011496210470795631, -0.030835378915071487, 0.04556970298290253, 0.06444458663463593, -0.01597847416996956, 0.007420440670102835, -0.016271276399493217, -0.02651635929942131, -0.024711210280656815, -0.08634743094444275, -0.012104528956115246, -0.04076327383518219, 0.024304557591676712, -0.018980612978339195, 0.026214798912405968, -0.04220781475305557, 0.0017063467530533671, 0.006701435893774033, 0.02278042584657669, -0.04595610871911049, -0.011862346902489662, 0.05224756896495819, -0.015484500676393509, 0.02700020931661129, -0.020064683631062508, -0.01565360464155674, 0.01615401916205883, -0.0023427223786711693, 0.005228913854807615, 0.005896645598113537, 0.01788940839469433, -0.04221854358911514, 0.01792723499238491, -0.009206857532262802, -0.05164046213030815, 0.028313344344496727, -0.025311999022960663, 0.07768955081701279, 0.07203319668769836, -0.009505250491201878, 0.03167859837412834, -0.028709925711154938, 0.009198996238410473, -0.022346194833517075, 0.03895307332277298, 0.06619960814714432, 0.002459337469190359, -0.015328711830079556, 0.038090821355581284, 0.03115958347916603, 0.010204127989709377, 0.031758155673742294, 0.0348847471177578, 0.0007915344322100282, 0.02613208442926407, -0.04229568690061569, -0.03247016295790672, 0.03488176316022873, -0.06143806502223015, 0.045606113970279694, -0.02573849819600582, -0.007198734674602747, 0.013741139322519302, 0.016322480514645576, -0.030860139057040215, -0.05146750062704086, -0.02007707767188549, -0.06774482876062393, 0.01658482663333416, 0.019538499414920807, -0.005854831542819738, 0.008729392662644386, -0.05468427389860153, 0.06450922042131424, -0.04137422516942024, 0.030716517940163612, -0.017334919422864914, -0.05781508609652519, -0.02799089066684246, -0.01500800158828497, -0.009018142707645893, 0.04992297291755676, -0.031722549349069595, -0.03938433527946472, -0.009019510820508003, -0.042385127395391464, 0.008322241716086864, -0.0226181298494339, -0.012927109375596046, -0.030028345063328743, 0.06591662019491196, -0.005106271244585514, 0.029955293983221054, 0.026009034365415573, -0.013913135975599289, 0.10918794572353363, 0.032622989267110825, 0.007801107130944729, -0.05002303048968315, 0.036616139113903046, 0.038660261780023575, 0.019752878695726395, -0.021327251568436623, 0.03370556980371475, 0.01686379313468933, 0.018577484413981438, 0.03840998187661171, 0.04200210049748421, 0.0014876455534249544, 0.024523302912712097, 0.03506454452872276, -0.016822248697280884, -0.0018942063907161355, 0.007257936056703329, 0.039308883249759674, 0.010968524031341076, -0.005147994030267, -0.07851572334766388, -0.007964816875755787, 0.037305258214473724, -0.004513067658990622, -0.0075774723663926125, -0.015022730454802513, -0.0009499305160716176, 0.031890809535980225, -0.009281935170292854, 0.035256411880254745, 0.03345616161823273, -0.0003359905385877937, -0.01696045882999897, -0.03393470123410225, 0.010877122171223164, -0.03942311555147171, 0.023159412667155266, 0.030243929475545883, -0.007564049679785967, -0.013425768353044987, -0.008005400188267231, 0.025848083198070526, -0.025946054607629776, -0.030633848160505295, -0.0060125780291855335, 0.03457513451576233, 0.004350841045379639, -0.024363143369555473, -0.0077805304899811745, 0.0347723513841629, -0.042924121022224426, -0.05744648352265358, -0.04379476606845856, 0.021215520799160004, -0.00205204077064991, -0.03404819220304489, -0.005413718521595001, -0.009749351069331169, 0.018363727256655693, -0.02184447832405567, 0.006883406545966864, -0.00406293012201786, -0.0009705909760668874, -0.004033038392663002, -0.068344846367836, 0.02699521742761135, -0.010262824594974518, -0.003368099918588996, 0.007185032125562429, 0.004903475288301706, -0.01767566241323948, 0.01274406909942627, 0.01770109497010708, 0.016369443386793137, -0.005164663773030043, 0.03244826942682266, -0.0004362559411674738, -0.020597223192453384, -0.017137248069047928, -0.013653500936925411, 0.009681463241577148, -0.00854350347071886, -0.035619959235191345, -0.01452843938022852, 0.060657382011413574, 0.022632043808698654, 0.0056055886670947075, 0.008851537480950356, 0.026271527633070946, 0.06667845696210861, 0.02541741356253624, -0.07319816946983337, -0.0006675184122286737, 0.021504675969481468, -0.01892903819680214, -0.02734449878334999, -0.029819738119840622, 0.07646249234676361, 0.021270979195833206, -0.02385440468788147, 0.007303278427571058, 0.03700300678610802, -0.005629071965813637, 0.0022483132779598236, 0.02671932242810726, -0.06406794488430023, -0.03549599274992943, 0.0019623618572950363, -0.010765081271529198, -0.03191829100251198, -0.010616209357976913, -0.04074492305517197, -0.03985441103577614, 0.014992606826126575, -0.016994062811136246, -0.0018146219663321972, 0.020112788304686546, -0.026913689449429512, 0.001638537971302867, -0.05019206926226616, 0.0025254306383430958, -0.06488300859928131, -0.029486557468771935, -0.030470261350274086, -0.002103418344631791, -0.02202889323234558, 0.029031720012426376, -0.011027595959603786, 0.00916584674268961, 0.01991298235952854, 0.010362966917455196, 0.06623299419879913, 0.031905997544527054, -0.011690504848957062, 0.008496255613863468, 0.038980238139629364, 0.03194974735379219, -0.029686925932765007, 0.019597474485635757, -0.03541405498981476, -0.03676224499940872, 0.00015765575517434627, 0.014411961659789085, 0.030857400968670845, -0.00563177652657032, 0.00795169360935688, -0.008108098059892654, 0.044097863137722015, -0.050874341279268265, -0.04390350356698036, -0.010275947861373425, -0.02525908313691616, 0.013892616145312786, -0.02073262818157673, 0.019532183185219765, -0.009985758922994137, -0.007237354293465614, -0.0023980233818292618, 0.03242027014493942, 0.013441278599202633, -0.053967420011758804, -0.0202017929404974, 0.014072620309889317, 0.06618327647447586, 0.00963689386844635, 0.0009326678118668497, 0.03385872021317482, 0.02641765959560871, -0.04022230952978134, 0.020583804696798325, -0.05134810134768486, -0.00758403493091464, -0.07154633104801178, -0.01720152609050274, 0.0194515660405159, -0.016905035823583603, 0.04008328914642334, -0.03676578029990196, 0.007139972411096096, 0.028883419930934906, -0.036394983530044556, 0.040399834513664246, -0.03493328019976616, -0.05642407387495041, -0.0467647910118103, 0.025445567443966866, -0.015703201293945312, 0.05574836581945419, 0.004054470453411341, 0.016835901886224747, 0.03851696848869324, -0.002225576899945736, 0.007878700271248817, -0.012934609316289425, 0.01104920543730259, 0.04359292611479759, 0.03818855807185173, -0.0863557979464531, 0.020459504798054695, -0.005645492114126682, -0.034334249794483185, 0.04707016423344612, -0.020057430490851402, 0.03591572493314743, 0.014807765372097492, -0.015495071187615395, 0.02285655029118061, 0.048189427703619, 0.04263235628604889, -0.004076949320733547, -0.03794250637292862, -0.007954668253660202, 0.012788099236786366, 0.01494587678462267, -0.00588530208915472, 0.04644590616226196, 0.020129306241869926, 0.030747748911380768, -0.036959465593099594, 0.0037448022048920393, -0.007804568856954575, -0.05847309157252312, -0.014570591039955616, -0.0201838631182909, 0.04324782267212868, -0.029722796753048897, -0.016720902174711227, -0.047541916370391846, 0.0002255940344184637, 0.03762534260749817, 0.0010905867675319314, -0.02487107925117016, 0.029012713581323624, -0.02243751287460327, -0.01028561219573021, -0.03581136465072632, 0.008724302984774113, 0.003105185693129897, -0.012556281872093678, -0.026288850232958794, -0.006728649139404297, 0.019161289557814598, -0.02409149892628193, -0.01893952488899231, -0.003744891146197915, 0.018528208136558533, -0.012683059088885784, -0.018421761691570282, -0.000553736521396786, -0.029830969870090485, -0.007497313432395458, -0.08517781645059586, 0.023433076217770576, 0.023600848391652107, -0.03278173878788948, -0.010274511761963367, 0.020195065066218376, -0.06122082844376564, 0.05893237888813019, 0.07659199833869934, 0.036082711070775986, -0.027500882744789124, -0.000446347170509398, -0.0039739408530294895, 0.013675074093043804, -0.06076955422759056, 0.039252378046512604, 0.002350155496969819, 0.0021084193140268326, 0.006402900908142328, -0.011410987935960293, 0.01801486313343048, -0.01547165960073471, 0.013164008967578411, 0.033609792590141296, 0.024815473705530167, 0.0004369659873191267, -0.01585501804947853, 0.01802162081003189, -0.008685418404638767, -0.06496712565422058, 0.015280717052519321, -0.018523583188652992, 0.012911212630569935, 0.020710457116365433, 0.025758692994713783, -0.04369819909334183, 0.016625341027975082, -0.048290327191352844, -0.016417482867836952, 0.006436964962631464, -0.007845122367143631, -0.01087391097098589, -0.09447743743658066, 0.006923247594386339, -0.008157996460795403, -0.016345471143722534, -0.024241898208856583, 0.01988411508500576, 0.05784954875707626, 0.04182477295398712, -0.012612600810825825, 0.03529591113328934, -0.038809675723314285, -0.0165614765137434, 0.0054575372487306595, -0.011414176784455776, 0.011906794272363186, 0.019067388027906418, 0.007318626623600721, 0.03793617710471153, -0.03189981356263161, 0.04929392412304878, -0.012980056926608086, 0.0435563400387764, 0.018088815733790398, 0.00905558094382286, 0.02338011935353279, -0.019281592220067978, -0.009248347021639347, 0.023434700444340706, 0.0485554002225399, 0.03094603307545185, -0.026821643114089966, 0.006768370512872934, -0.04872575402259827, -0.019844690337777138, -0.07172960788011551, -0.0002976538671646267, 0.06307327747344971, 0.01593269407749176, -0.01680596172809601, 0.014674128033220768, 0.006372024770826101, -0.013365429826080799, 0.012837762013077736, 0.011958049610257149, 0.04160057753324509, -0.026056012138724327, -0.03277921676635742, 0.00902941357344389, 0.0007527812267653644, -0.06733299046754837, -0.0007829358801245689, 0.04207184165716171, 0.019730141386389732, 0.0386354885995388, -0.022995229810476303, -0.023514648899435997, 0.020724046975374222, 0.030293401330709457, -0.0537659227848053, -0.037253160029649734, -0.04955959692597389, -0.0063636708073318005, 0.010328325442969799, -0.016768353059887886 ]
<p>I am trying to implement a test as described in a paper in R. The aim is to calculate enrichment for a particular type of mutation that occurs in a given base in a given sequence context.</p> <p>I quote</p> <blockquote> <p>Statistical evaluation of the over-representation of APOBEC signature mutations in each sample was performed using a one-sided Fisher's exact test comparing the ratio of the number of cytosine-to-thymine or cytosine-to-guanine substitutions and guanine-to-adenine or guanine-to-cytosine substitutions that occurred in and out of the APOBEC target motif (TCW or WGA) to an analogous ratio for all cytosines and guanines that reside inside and outside of the TCW or WGA motif within a sample fraction of the genome.</p> </blockquote> <p>Reference - <a href="http://www.nature.com/ng/journal/v45/n9/full/ng.2702.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.nature.com/ng/journal/v45/n9/full/ng.2702.html</a></p> <p>This means they calculate enrichment by comparing CtoT or CtoG mutations in the base context TCW to those outside that context to the number of Cytosines found in and out of the TCW context in the genome.</p> <p>So we've got the following values.</p> <pre><code>TCW.mutations = the number of C to T or G mutations in the context TCW non.TCW.CtoTG.mutations = the number of C to T or G mutations outside the context TCW TCW.cytosines = the number of cytosines in the base context TCW in the human exome nonTCW.cytosines = the number of cytosines outside the base context TCW. </code></pre> <p>I need to do a one-tailed fisher's exact test comparing the following using the fisher.test function in R</p> <pre><code>TCW.mutations/non.TCW.CtoTG.mutations to TCW.cytosines/nonTCW.cytosines </code></pre> <p>How is my input matrix supposed to look?</p>
36,060
[ 0.007706992793828249, -0.02400299161672592, 0.010371250100433826, -0.012205816805362701, -0.007226091343909502, -0.003683942137286067, -0.0269708801060915, -0.015320644713938236, -0.019193753600120544, -0.04713370278477669, 0.05855405330657959, 0.02365095727145672, 0.029153477400541306, -0.03473542258143425, -0.004995446652173996, -0.004725171253085136, -0.027409764006733894, -0.005161300767213106, -0.015108564868569374, -0.024481043219566345, 0.023906970396637917, -0.007063796278089285, -0.03703901916742325, 0.03817564249038696, 0.0147468326613307, 0.001473860233090818, 0.025150682777166367, -0.02439947985112667, 0.01319163478910923, 0.05420523136854172, -0.03627834469079971, -0.03131565824151039, 0.04343762248754501, 0.012727295979857445, -0.0009794386569410563, 0.03580344840884209, -0.014998084865510464, -0.03911053016781807, -0.003125665942206979, 0.01308546494692564, -0.01664414256811142, -0.02504817396402359, 0.010018676519393921, 0.05237211659550667, 0.011262974701821804, 0.0493645966053009, -0.027791745960712433, 0.014062312431633472, 0.006647871341556311, -0.010408520698547363, 0.07872374355792999, 0.0007267766050063074, 0.04833926633000374, -0.0021438540425151587, 0.017152253538370132, 0.061859503388404846, 0.04293365404009819, 0.023037748411297798, 0.008761173114180565, -0.05744875222444534, -0.03433438390493393, -0.03730597347021103, 0.0220494344830513, -0.03840971738100052, -0.05643250048160553, 0.029740072786808014, 0.002028663409873843, -0.020713750272989273, 0.043165139853954315, -0.005398472771048546, 0.03917073458433151, -0.00041786371730268, 0.009198182262480259, -0.010322936810553074, 0.012221054174005985, -0.02790074050426483, -0.01010192558169365, 0.0018499132711440325, 0.002230457030236721, 0.04173501580953598, 0.01105429232120514, -0.007246361579746008, 0.018611105158925056, 0.029477214440703392, 0.009746893309056759, 0.004446502309292555, 0.05280637741088867, -0.05618439242243767, 0.013913638889789581, 0.04419849440455437, 0.013724819757044315, -0.013339405879378319, 0.08161672949790955, 0.015198295935988426, -0.028597205877304077, 0.027537882328033447, -0.010775278322398663, 0.02505536936223507, -0.0345473438501358, -0.002987355226650834, -0.03167349100112915, -0.057385653257369995, 0.04944559186697006, 0.054188042879104614, -0.04421714320778847, 0.01888389326632023, -0.03234467655420303, -0.017104556784033775, -0.009758360683918, 0.011811917647719383, -0.00841659214347601, 0.041596297174692154, -0.0252764280885458, 0.00019266337039880455, -0.0009902429301291704, -0.009764444082975388, 0.021282987669110298, -0.009819378145039082, 0.07011423259973526, 0.05672267824411392, 0.05377241596579552, -0.0230746828019619, 0.008954486809670925, -0.014611977152526379, 0.00014102543354965746, -0.00191188242752105, -0.005653712898492813, 0.02297334372997284, -0.02111426182091236, 0.016038833186030388, -0.0202668234705925, -0.036635082215070724, 0.01872631348669529, 0.03368280082941055, 0.0065575046464800835, -0.017541687935590744, -0.07341081649065018, -0.09346488863229752, 0.05024304240942001, -0.004000862129032612, 0.009286152198910713, -0.07169515639543533, 0.044334776699543, 0.02521488256752491, 0.04003551974892616, -0.0034187750425189734, 0.04243411123752594, 0.05761510506272316, -0.02131868153810501, 0.002661473583430052, -0.04194347560405731, -0.005387290380895138, -0.03516700491309166, 0.009958875365555286, -0.030188631266355515, -0.0760326161980629, 0.030543377622961998, 0.007304910104721785, -0.027842966839671135, 0.004038396757096052, 0.027321593835949898, -0.017075005918741226, -0.0269024558365345, -0.035951703786849976, -0.0012566831428557634, -0.03580474853515625, 0.06029674783349037, 0.008173069916665554, -0.00011621372686931863, 0.07929619401693344, -0.0025540825445204973, 0.02547825314104557, 0.013161316514015198, 0.0025507279206067324, 0.0445108525454998, -0.057721097022295, -0.0019442324992269278, -0.026592690497636795, 0.00271845911629498, 0.013054830022156239, -0.009312945418059826, 0.0006112352712079883, 0.01681969128549099, 0.006999011617153883, 0.06187313422560692, 0.0018638999899849296, -0.016408463940024376, 0.0072815860621631145, 0.035693585872650146, -0.04237952455878258, 0.0005031827604398131, -0.020899012684822083, -0.00743419723585248, 0.01853175088763237, -0.03008083999156952, -0.01679053343832493, 0.004416628275066614, 0.03132697939872742, -0.001513429800979793, -0.016909154132008553, -0.040993817150592804, 0.018756426870822906, 0.04945533350110054, -0.0202739667147398, -0.04483772814273834, 0.03630617633461952, 0.047983039170503616, 0.0025310534983873367, 0.03480806201696396, -0.022307150065898895, -0.01631477102637291, 0.017303861677646637, -0.03200067952275276, 0.011793745681643486, 0.01719864085316658, 0.011651653796434402, 0.024011634290218353, 0.005712959449738264, -0.014121376909315586, 0.046556878834962845, -0.022696610540151596, 0.02737073041498661, 0.04340366646647453, 0.054845504462718964, -0.003657025983557105, -0.032176487147808075, 0.002476074732840061, 0.01109157782047987, -0.04492257162928581, 0.003912842366844416, -0.048280857503414154, -0.03509977087378502, 0.03895134478807449, 0.009658423252403736, -0.017278099432587624, -0.04211283102631569, 0.04025246575474739, -0.03015207126736641, 0.016856711357831955, 0.041757263243198395, -0.0007293837843462825, -0.02373994141817093, 0.019249537959694862, 0.02288074418902397, 0.020507456734776497, -0.007554642856121063, 0.06413660943508148, -0.025227665901184082, 0.046556465327739716, -0.005635387264192104, -0.02226095460355282, 0.05013743042945862, 0.05265147238969803, -0.004805202130228281, -0.00040621787775307894, 0.013217775151133537, 0.004202233627438545, 0.018693631514906883, 0.008583148941397667, 0.03798997402191162, -0.028102083131670952, -0.015171161852777004, -0.0027807417791336775, 0.007711706217378378, -0.007171206176280975, 0.03883552551269531, -0.00715924147516489, -0.00769220432266593, -0.018117446452379227, -0.0746726393699646, 0.01303845550864935, -0.0026046852581202984, -0.014754521660506725, -0.021319029852747917, 0.022834857925772667, 0.04792843014001846, 0.026428593322634697, 0.04359638690948486, -0.03705881908535957, -0.026223961263895035, -0.004380107391625643, -0.021931348368525505, -0.004811717197299004, -0.004520686808973551, -0.03429851308465004, -0.0025056865997612476, -0.03626576066017151, -0.010273219086229801, 0.02156161516904831, -0.017364876344799995, -0.03332730010151863, 0.023524226620793343, 0.006210435647517443, -0.027470624074339867, 0.009471552446484566, -0.022720644250512123, 0.0031890852842479944, -0.0018870787462219596, -0.03184132277965546, 0.044675830751657486, 0.0033613992854952812, -0.042478933930397034, 0.06567475199699402, -0.014414381235837936, -0.009371550753712654, 0.0177837535738945, -0.0018117919098585844, -0.025250867009162903, -0.0128810228779912, 0.044221777468919754, 0.007459414657205343, -0.03615826740860939, -0.030491722747683525, -0.0623890645802021, -0.030535627156496048, 0.031847383826971054, 0.01741269789636135, 0.05083290860056877, -0.011632933281362057, -0.019286008551716805, 0.062276437878608704, 0.0401383638381958, -0.005453136283904314, -0.04688943549990654, -0.015221581794321537, -0.027147531509399414, -0.02458660677075386, 0.0006816500681452453, -0.0065955715253949165, -0.01965603232383728, -0.018656721338629723, 0.024017343297600746, 0.029878707602620125, 0.07183060795068741, -0.0217522531747818, 0.03009500727057457, 0.047186508774757385, -0.0000730918109184131, 0.013698392547667027, 0.06604599952697754, 0.013366474770009518, 0.020958881825208664, 0.007787842769175768, -0.0030925117898732424, -0.0021758463699370623, -0.010811101645231247, -0.07814493030309677, 0.025893963873386383, 0.03201555460691452, 0.026564372703433037, -0.02906954288482666, 0.04724248871207237, 0.03019089810550213, -0.03255527466535568, -0.014889837242662907, 0.029846185818314552, 0.0578172542154789, -0.03425213694572449, -0.014635720290243626, 0.052172355353832245, 0.058300938457250595, 0.0033097390551120043, 0.027978023514151573, 0.01745467819273472, -0.023118766024708748, 0.028462884947657585, -0.05377921462059021, -0.03782337158918381, 0.027795955538749695, 0.05717617645859718, 0.0038813299033790827, 0.005344546865671873, -0.027385344728827477, 0.02751828357577324, -0.0060236952267587185, 0.002246750984340906, -0.031446292996406555, 0.04385540634393692, 0.020845966413617134, 0.03567200154066086, 0.004302990157157183, -0.011787116527557373, -0.03477315232157707, 0.0036793870385736227, -0.05296051502227783, -0.0012364431750029325, 0.02668720856308937, -0.03510555624961853, -0.0015159102622419596, -0.06011828035116196, 0.036451973021030426, 0.027242327108979225, -0.00892908126115799, -0.01700717955827713, 0.02507892996072769, -0.005824177525937557, 0.08356636017560959, 0.00746849924325943, 0.008283913135528564, -0.016290023922920227, 0.06382528692483902, 0.03347614035010338, 0.03091614693403244, 0.003749087220057845, 0.056904442608356476, -0.01574079878628254, 0.01995271071791649, 0.003817759221419692, 0.010006125085055828, 0.029445258900523186, 0.04651335999369621, 0.051519688218832016, 0.06699474900960922, -0.029997723177075386, -0.021308043971657753, -0.01025681383907795, 0.0054292501881718636, 0.07568228244781494, -0.009685182943940163, 0.004841564688831568, -0.03806771710515022, -0.00935660395771265, 0.006675937213003635, 0.026860162615776062, -0.005646556615829468, 0.005254150368273258, 0.07479923218488693, 0.013684241101145744, -0.03022540733218193, 0.0362992025911808, 0.005453134421259165, 0.028216296806931496, -0.02731887809932232, -0.026647567749023438, -0.0054727778770029545, 0.015738116577267647, -0.04009811952710152, 0.009589905850589275, 0.02663513273000717, -0.006605885457247496, -0.03269438073039055, -0.01243212167173624, -0.013753124512732029, -0.04740380123257637, 0.016666200011968613, -0.023754237219691277, 0.045877762138843536, -0.04458670690655708, -0.02380511164665222, 0.027314435690641403, 0.006542880088090897, 0.016602367162704468, 0.02874053083360195, 0.028377821668982506, -0.07330945134162903, 0.009699308313429356, 0.05301789566874504, 0.07877001911401749, 0.010654495097696781, -0.01111165713518858, -0.014896211214363575, -0.000033167281799251214, -0.04177922010421753, -0.03418264165520668, 0.04235590994358063, -0.02419905737042427, 0.02649993635714054, -0.03788602352142334, -0.034306369721889496, -0.04491209611296654, -0.03114979714155197, -0.06143679842352867, -0.008700304664671421, -0.06422322243452072, 0.006537105888128281, -0.040630802512168884, -0.00032025965629145503, 0.018420783802866936, 0.026973620057106018, -0.06120549514889717, -0.02471275068819523, 0.04538345709443092, 0.0312470942735672, -0.01493895798921585, -0.02337053045630455, 0.009532606229186058, 0.023899048566818237, -0.009580503217875957, 0.06784472614526749, -0.011837330646812916, -0.033546026796102524, 0.02502802200615406, 0.006837655324488878, -0.03966439515352249, 0.008592363446950912, 0.0001743234315654263, 0.05206161364912987, 0.05900612473487854, -0.011789062060415745, 0.08678842335939407, 0.052790649235248566, -0.05150660499930382, 0.022054946050047874, -0.06698333472013474, -0.012890112586319447, -0.020167579874396324, -0.019302349537611008, -0.041533682495355606, -0.052226513624191284, -0.01772153005003929, -0.005436934996396303, -0.006316911429166794, 0.034856367856264114, -0.026418693363666534, -0.026492729783058167, 0.044949810951948166, -0.008828911930322647, -0.02647354081273079, -0.005068439524620771, -0.008449520915746689, 0.013806033879518509, -0.010136589407920837, 0.021035434678196907, 0.0591585710644722, -0.056931640952825546, 0.002847031457349658, -0.0026473405305296183, -0.04326155409216881, -0.013477245345711708, -0.033104654401540756, -0.02460291050374508, 0.006431405432522297, -0.007817361503839493, 0.01912766322493553, -0.0025130619760602713, 0.013848337344825268, -0.029314646497368813, -0.029553987085819244, -0.035936176776885986, 0.010019822977483273, -0.0000736350120860152, 0.017450248822569847, -0.007470723241567612, 0.037733376026153564, -0.0022490103729069233, -0.00865471363067627, -0.04280852898955345, 0.01690024882555008, -0.004831378348171711, 0.01464078202843666, -0.04462847858667374, -0.027640774846076965, -0.03975604102015495, -0.00023432998568750918, 0.012435449287295341, -0.044245533645153046, 0.0330488346517086, -0.01421475037932396, 0.002692738315090537, -0.02137875370681286, 0.02654089592397213, 0.061579104512929916, -0.001408450654707849, -0.005575463175773621, 0.009959130547940731, -0.006388598121702671, -0.020151088014245033, -0.003971354104578495, -0.017021499574184418, -0.026962272822856903, -0.010387673042714596, 0.003926929552108049, 0.028846053406596184, 0.02431182749569416, -0.005029261577874422, -0.06606684625148773, -0.0074740080162882805, 0.011975990608334541, 0.040822017937898636, -0.049845222383737564, -0.006294331047683954, -0.009584027342498302, 0.03318867087364197, -0.03143887221813202, 0.06995980441570282, 0.002266561845317483, -0.026457322761416435, -0.026318175718188286, -0.05336694046854973, 0.002359407488256693, -0.004850451834499836, 0.11380220204591751, 0.0003642348456196487, 0.027684766799211502, -0.01808895915746689, -0.027319297194480896, 0.024559002369642258, 0.01424842607229948, 0.010356553830206394, 0.0002587796770967543, 0.007164692971855402, -0.019725460559129715, 0.0017012987518683076, -0.053761258721351624, 0.018475163727998734, 0.0624944344162941, 0.031086087226867676, 0.05754312872886658, 0.04551003873348236, -0.0010163915576413274, 0.0032253076788038015, -0.0674489438533783, -0.009348634630441666, 0.0010826876387000084, 0.026319745928049088, 0.04164949059486389, -0.00020653365936595947, -0.0005313103902153671, 0.06376875936985016, 0.015301921404898167, 0.0024632266722619534, 0.03621940314769745, 0.015407649800181389, -0.038357045501470566, 0.0064485156908631325, -0.029509665444493294, -0.018379760906100273, 0.02177208848297596, -0.04581468924880028, 0.04246010631322861, -0.007244125008583069, -0.006738701369613409, 0.044477466493844986, 0.02402649261057377, -0.028769878670573235, -0.02781800739467144, -0.023125717416405678, -0.056416768580675125, 0.023099681362509727, -0.005031192675232887, -0.024915261194109917, 0.025893112644553185, -0.014997423626482487, 0.03615064546465874, -0.008301632478833199, 0.03296530246734619, -0.026344332844018936, -0.04909855127334595, 0.014640542678534985, -0.018704509362578392, -0.05351874232292175, 0.029388729482889175, -0.01594851352274418, -0.036055903881788254, 0.002606056397780776, -0.009669030085206032, 0.07091083377599716, -0.033610351383686066, 0.03784755617380142, -0.04019303247332573, 0.0969136655330658, 0.00880028959363699, 0.029673663899302483, -0.02433355338871479, -0.018020104616880417, 0.13975435495376587, 0.07735271006822586, 0.0022965683601796627, -0.0810222402215004, -0.008260812610387802, -0.0016694329679012299, 0.03680415451526642, -0.007872551679611206, -0.037052467465400696, -0.003341802628710866, 0.007740776054561138, 0.050228752195835114, 0.032531797885894775, -0.0021585619542747736, -0.007426443975418806, 0.021309344097971916, -0.04541819542646408, -0.03284508362412453, 0.0022490599658340216, -0.0006996166193857789, 0.0022049846593290567, -0.05930056422948837, -0.02592799812555313, -0.008221757598221302, 0.021043801680207253, -0.00858887005597353, -0.056194860488176346, -0.03817316144704819, 0.014826585538685322, -0.00009312839392805472, -0.047701071947813034, 0.03418956696987152, -0.026090633124113083, 0.0018679683562368155, -0.003556382842361927, -0.010259636677801609, 0.011086038313806057, -0.020753223448991776, -0.0044476608745753765, 0.04971284791827202, 0.007548866327852011, 0.0001811865804484114, 0.0002999676507897675, 0.037846390157938004, -0.0605984628200531, -0.006832609418779612, -0.03666778281331062, 0.023554323241114616, -0.020750656723976135, -0.01620468497276306, -0.014484293758869171, -0.0005013686022721231, 0.047747038304805756, -0.00809222087264061, -0.012194594368338585, 0.019257839769124985, 0.03573572635650635, -0.01622583158314228, -0.00532458396628499, -0.010686016641557217, 0.010962553322315216, 0.002712518908083439, 0.05423997715115547, 0.014510495588183403, 0.0036461474373936653, -0.01029022317379713, -0.015073644928634167, 0.057360611855983734, -0.04094674438238144, 0.023897742852568626, -0.016070228070020676, 0.015149634331464767, -0.045875102281570435, -0.024558046832680702, 0.002690287074074149, -0.03418074920773506, 0.04691094905138016, 0.0012234924361109734, 0.004084045998752117, -0.014683227054774761, -0.03966021165251732, 0.009146795608103275, -0.025561071932315826, -0.04417828097939491, -0.02894723415374756, 0.02154448628425598, 0.022287633270025253, 0.02248954214155674, 0.003070228500291705, 0.019656198099255562, -0.008419448509812355, 0.060148127377033234, -0.0005919176037423313, 0.0009220617939718068, -0.05696115642786026, 0.03356392681598663, -0.001608925056643784, -0.05902650207281113, 0.0038740907330065966, 0.025514092296361923, 0.03105694241821766, 0.0238453671336174, 0.02459290251135826, 0.009501457214355469, -0.0065204910933971405, -0.01588331162929535, 0.006044270936399698, -0.04888627305626869, -0.0036614108830690384, 0.005110569763928652, -0.014493360184133053, -0.03626842051744461, 0.020840173587203026, -0.043918874114751816, -0.030806489288806915, 0.06707596033811569, 0.01161247119307518, -0.035066667944192886, -0.020215023308992386, -0.03275072202086449, -0.016718151047825813, -0.02737959660589695, -0.03656386211514473, -0.014322982169687748, -0.005092019215226173, -0.017957083880901337, -0.016828591004014015, 0.01590496487915516, 0.014086124487221241, -0.02325546368956566, 0.007308139931410551, 0.05075005069375038, 0.030462315306067467, -0.005627188365906477, 0.0049904389306902885, 0.0019140380900353193, -0.006348160095512867, 0.03066958673298359, 0.0039966292679309845, 0.03061244823038578, 0.014174070209264755, -0.0661260187625885, -0.03539847955107689, 0.03696966916322708, -0.010962551459670067, 0.009634927846491337, -0.03369956091046333, -0.0002124133170582354, -0.009456433355808258, 0.027372309938073158, 0.011173521168529987, -0.02373127080500126, 0.01556194107979536, 0.01129490789026022, -0.008217640221118927, -0.0067993956618011, 0.01160170417279005, 0.022996775805950165, 0.0006519870948977768, -0.0004815459542442113, 0.028986582532525063, -0.0032239172141999006, -0.02927602455019951, 0.010955716483294964, -0.03403143584728241, 0.014168547466397285, -0.009950357489287853, -0.02725076489150524, -0.00612005265429616, 0.06282992660999298, 0.0028105564415454865, 0.02384689636528492, -0.044180698692798615, -0.0020898913498967886, -0.08245429396629333, -0.00013498467160388827, 0.014813972637057304, 0.03549986705183983, 0.028060995042324066, -0.0232490636408329, 0.01461032871156931, 0.022915147244930267, -0.033111993223428726, 0.00476206885650754, -0.003736824030056596, 0.013800899498164654, -0.042322784662246704, 0.005028252024203539, -0.015579664148390293, 0.017910318449139595, -0.001042976975440979, 0.005278267897665501, 0.042816899716854095, 0.0014967723982408643, -0.023613886907696724, -0.03688978776335716, -0.00953585933893919, 0.004174904432147741, 0.00210823817178607, -0.07801303267478943, 0.017510179430246353, 0.013162811286747456, 0.008687890134751797, -0.030007699504494667, -0.039352864027023315, 0.014204984530806541, 0.0037316163070499897, 0.052893318235874176, 0.046607062220573425, 0.04423268884420395, 0.035334423184394836, 0.0032922804821282625, -0.005694334860891104, -0.014082281850278378, -0.016955118626356125, 0.0004383617779240012, -0.028379278257489204, 0.0025104081723839045, 0.017672942951321602, -0.0288250632584095, -0.009865705855190754, 0.040466584265232086, -0.00638375710695982, 0.007689196150749922, -0.019252760335803032, -0.015811078250408173, -0.0007227507303468883, -0.014689753763377666, 0.0068075573071837425, -0.028262309730052948, 0.03238851949572563, 0.03510323539376259, 0.03162437304854393, -0.00030134557164274156, 0.005200069397687912, -0.02338661439716816, -0.021226808428764343, -0.009587829001247883, 0.015680605545639992, -0.015094509348273277, -0.04502302035689354, -0.01728459820151329, -0.03291117399930954, 0.01287223119288683, 0.001953797647729516, -0.005703468341380358, -0.05740758404135704, 0.0533466637134552, -0.030988240614533424, -0.00027011128258891404, -0.003401099005714059, 0.01209617592394352, 0.019345125183463097, -0.08075404167175293, 0.06192007660865784, 0.010363953188061714, -0.030152224004268646, -0.017741376534104347, -0.008685152977705002, -0.0027955572586506605, 0.027687853202223778, 0.03404007479548454, -0.021082160994410515, -0.015461686067283154, -0.0399530790746212, 0.02415614202618599, -0.015934975817799568, -0.0874721109867096, 0.05215252563357353, -0.015907227993011475, -0.0027621567714959383, 0.004330701194703579, -0.0162494033575058, -0.0044687301851809025, 0.05793937295675278, 0.04261412471532822, -0.04108013957738876, -0.02341376058757305, 0.0033899727277457714, -0.016857953742146492, 0.05986672639846802, -0.02073490060865879, -0.01240430399775505, 0.049540579319000244, 0.007085246033966541, 0.02039944939315319, 0.03847814351320267, 0.023047752678394318, -0.052629582583904266, 0.03668718412518501, -0.029920106753706932, 0.0028009386733174324, 0.025298742577433586, -0.0005246629007160664, 0.02589426375925541, -0.025503896176815033, 0.0007403268828056753, 0.026730598881840706, -0.0362575463950634, 0.015507876873016357, 0.02462884783744812, 0.011252141557633877, 0.05257081240415573, -0.0356268547475338, 0.035018205642700195, -0.034740202128887177, -0.05992327630519867, -0.010472046211361885, -0.013338997028768063, -0.008099574595689774, -0.015467082150280476, 0.016762524843215942, -0.00458678649738431, -0.03470706567168236, 0.02464357763528824, 0.01829381473362446, 0.05243683606386185, -0.022932257503271103, -0.016796840354800224, -0.009098834358155727, -0.0390770360827446, 0.031426992267370224, 0.019720379263162613, -0.03127651661634445, 0.08501841872930527, -0.039643630385398865, 0.007354431785643101, 0.0035853427834808826, -0.030571935698390007, -0.010929453186690807, -0.004907368216663599, -0.012233668938279152, 0.02319551445543766, -0.0003504761843942106, -0.007766393944621086, 0.04805537685751915, -0.012361973524093628, 0.013626170344650745, -0.04804171621799469, 0.06689024716615677, -0.023993078619241714, -0.010139093734323978, 0.006454684305936098, -0.003472688375040889, -0.04560629650950432, -0.007650003302842379, 0.021980974823236465, -0.003686959156766534, 0.030394479632377625, -0.03821573778986931, -0.0029023385141044855, 0.0016379387816414237, 0.03116985782980919, -0.02348516695201397, -0.013253550976514816, -0.01666611060500145, 0.021311316639184952, -0.018567170947790146, -0.03392171114683151 ]
<p>I have 6,000 points for which I have all pairwise distances in a distance matrix. I want to get an idea whether these data were generated by a mixture of Gaussian distributions so I'm trying to get a visualization. I am trying to apply multidimensional scaling in 2 dimensions using sklearn in Python. </p> <p>I have four questions: </p> <ol> <li>In all the examples I found, the number of points were very limited (around 20). Is it possible to apply MDS with 6,000 points?</li> <li>If not, is there any way I can get a better idea whether my data were generated by a mixture of Gaussians? (I want to cluster this data using GMM.)</li> <li>sklearn uses the function <a href="http://scikit-learn.org/stable/modules/generated/sklearn.manifold.MDS.html" rel="nofollow">manifold.MDS</a>. One of the parameters of this function is 'random state'. What does it represent?</li> <li>In <a href="http://scikit-learn.org/stable/auto_examples/manifold/plot_mds.html" rel="nofollow">this example</a>, the matrix used (X_true) has dimension 20x2. Shouldn't MDS take a distance matrix (i.e., a square matrix)?</li> </ol>
73,644
[ -0.05886407941579819, 0.01347476989030838, 0.02804877981543541, -0.029762152582406998, 0.06198413297533989, -0.0012512251269072294, -0.07100524753332138, -0.05169197916984558, 0.007698624860495329, -0.0323450081050396, 0.04445784166455269, 0.01893923059105873, 0.05743201822042465, 0.040045127272605896, 0.0031780374702066183, 0.006868474651128054, 0.02563655748963356, 0.007329861167818308, 0.00038630134076811373, -0.00171952648088336, 0.01634480431675911, 0.03684978559613228, 0.044526975601911545, -0.02278643660247326, -0.04077764227986336, 0.06168784946203232, 0.015780514106154442, -0.03417765721678734, 0.004384071100503206, 0.027267256751656532, -0.04617318511009216, -0.029043495655059814, 0.03773370385169983, -0.031482815742492676, 0.001704126363620162, -0.020188316702842712, -0.029574258252978325, -0.014242052100598812, 0.004054107703268528, 0.012975656427443027, -0.00945995096117258, -0.007296576164662838, 0.0038793026469647884, 0.05958147719502449, -0.006431243382394314, 0.050405655056238174, 0.029370734468102455, -0.021946243941783905, 0.014452331699430943, -0.012332247570157051, 0.10338137298822403, 0.007879907265305519, 0.01911742053925991, 0.008813031949102879, -0.008872135542333126, 0.009039446711540222, 0.03921637311577797, 0.057913124561309814, 0.008972123265266418, -0.052181366831064224, 0.008893041871488094, -0.016700822860002518, -0.006435875315219164, -0.060220230370759964, 0.023775851354002953, 0.04133450612425804, -0.01209510862827301, 0.02314189448952675, 0.04100031778216362, -0.0011690015671774745, -0.004163708072155714, 0.038343772292137146, 0.017464835196733475, -0.031026549637317657, 0.006263395771384239, 0.008755753748118877, 0.027661073952913284, -0.00995864812284708, 0.04800575599074364, 0.007430771831423044, 0.03602762892842293, -0.0055288090370595455, -0.03463297337293625, -0.024705344811081886, 0.021911246702075005, 0.0057975915260612965, 0.038927752524614334, -0.021040543913841248, 0.0164419524371624, 0.03378072381019592, -0.02244512550532818, 0.02942919358611107, 0.029045669361948967, 0.04554741457104683, -0.04217091202735901, 0.027157407253980637, -0.00252464204095304, 0.036867499351501465, -0.018566090613603592, 0.0050863535143435, -0.07486647367477417, -0.01907036080956459, 0.013098062016069889, 0.013764272443950176, -0.04848995804786682, 0.01515259500592947, -0.016141828149557114, -0.019109569489955902, -0.05264006182551384, -0.022309597581624985, -0.0339248962700367, 0.02835088036954403, 0.02672121673822403, -0.0023574167862534523, 0.021324608474969864, -0.0144030237570405, -0.02713288739323616, -0.005523785017430782, 0.009610123932361603, 0.09816070646047592, 0.008851747959852219, 0.0001146733557106927, 0.003099034773185849, -0.045228246599435806, -0.06119379773736, 0.039498791098594666, -0.010783682577311993, -0.0037385981995612383, -0.028993720188736916, 0.016079818829894066, -0.02105158008635044, 0.01907574199140072, 0.01590895466506481, 0.007150640711188316, 0.012738864868879318, 0.0038141938857734203, -0.10063757002353668, -0.0537688285112381, 0.06067189201712608, -0.023937704041600227, 0.04063248261809349, -0.012371016666293144, -0.005630595609545708, 0.027733324095606804, 0.021940262988209724, 0.006828879006206989, 0.04884400591254234, 0.017600076273083687, 0.053391844034194946, -0.026780279353260994, -0.025986280292272568, -0.02833571657538414, -0.05794617533683777, -0.04360426217317581, 0.010303213261067867, -0.098094642162323, 0.021264130249619484, 0.01913999207317829, 0.009998896159231663, -0.0019722350407391787, -0.0018111609388142824, -0.001270190579816699, 0.002315942430868745, 0.000831310695502907, -0.012279667891561985, -0.014846762642264366, 0.07086073607206345, 0.01271781511604786, 0.09022810310125351, 0.02606508508324623, -0.03997531160712242, 0.00936719961464405, 0.0002449427265673876, 0.04526090994477272, 0.010457271710038185, 0.04251794517040253, -0.01605801284313202, 0.027924036607146263, 0.033104803413152695, 0.045022785663604736, -0.05616168677806854, -0.019171293824911118, -0.025913376361131668, -0.004392003640532494, 0.011162381619215012, 0.009335453622043133, 0.0041041006334125996, -0.00784357264637947, 0.014482468366622925, -0.053573474287986755, -0.0334613211452961, -0.03937166556715965, 0.05453759804368019, -0.03382749482989311, -0.003911768086254597, -0.005765982437878847, -0.006002120207995176, 0.015316130593419075, 0.010634413920342922, -0.03826962411403656, -0.019486166536808014, -0.025405000895261765, 0.02387738600373268, -0.0052389889024198055, -0.01906595379114151, 0.03873694688081741, 0.037455592304468155, -0.021394426003098488, 0.03871212527155876, -0.03060164861381054, -0.048563554883003235, -0.01842035911977291, -0.01583845354616642, 0.009727288037538528, -0.015469145961105824, -0.011512662284076214, 0.01338133029639721, 0.02842787466943264, -0.06643079221248627, 0.009226584807038307, -0.05315364897251129, 0.06973189115524292, 0.08422094583511353, -0.00487289484590292, -0.003853475907817483, -0.011456732638180256, -0.001767208450473845, -0.0003559416509233415, 0.04045955464243889, -0.001714865560643375, -0.06604921817779541, -0.020396998152136803, 0.03006569668650627, 0.05308151617646217, -0.03369947150349617, 0.01611322909593582, 0.04453888162970543, 0.013988076709210873, -0.01435609720647335, -0.011426355689764023, -0.0031606571283191442, -0.018248196691274643, 0.03695416450500488, 0.02192452922463417, 0.019669117406010628, -0.021792905405163765, 0.021981917321681976, -0.016125783324241638, 0.0377868115901947, -0.022633537650108337, -0.013044140301644802, 0.04074423760175705, -0.049523647874593735, -0.0019854935817420483, 0.0012624099617823958, -0.02479304000735283, 0.01598714105784893, -0.0022467412054538727, 0.01136044692248106, 0.05530322715640068, 0.022673621773719788, 0.003021382726728916, -0.030033178627490997, -0.012330690398812294, 0.003285737708210945, 0.05342670902609825, -0.009230528958141804, -0.022561920806765556, 0.012222672812640667, -0.060977693647146225, 0.016907094046473503, -0.022423481568694115, -0.030619261786341667, -0.028355905786156654, 0.00842234492301941, 0.06061851233243942, 0.00280869216658175, 0.03170129656791687, -0.017377372831106186, 0.0000072107768573914655, 0.02105133794248104, 0.014502555131912231, 0.025124231353402138, 0.004046175628900528, -0.032388098537921906, 0.04290853813290596, -0.03689642623066902, 0.0036879247054457664, 0.002680589444935322, -0.011152703315019608, -0.03286820650100708, -0.011330186389386654, -0.035092949867248535, -0.02491925098001957, -0.038769107311964035, -0.017244920134544373, 0.03276566416025162, -0.002434568013995886, -0.0031961346976459026, 0.020149942487478256, -0.024948639795184135, -0.017818709835410118, 0.013865410350263119, -0.0026613648515194654, -0.005606753285974264, -0.009458166547119617, 0.0038505150005221367, -0.002690412336960435, 0.002031765878200531, 0.005307494197040796, 0.06352908909320831, -0.014623495750129223, -0.009118195623159409, -0.042679451406002045, -0.049494802951812744, 0.020193543285131454, -0.004605971276760101, 0.041673772037029266, -0.0038641232531517744, 0.008083702996373177, 0.08031564950942993, 0.02925986237823963, -0.046482205390930176, -0.033546652644872665, -0.005833879113197327, -0.0616416372358799, -0.02156790718436241, 0.013109820894896984, 0.03691905736923218, -0.014827640727162361, -0.0039520785212516785, -0.008138499222695827, 0.029145358130335808, 0.07980599999427795, -0.0615990050137043, -0.013258423656225204, -0.007000365294516087, -0.020109349861741066, -0.042024485766887665, 0.05768129602074623, 0.02709910273551941, -0.028165724128484726, 0.004907896742224693, -0.012233061715960503, 0.007339345756918192, 0.003410287667065859, -0.038993656635284424, 0.005302958190441132, -0.03284269943833351, 0.05398043245077133, -0.04792041331529617, 0.008203703910112381, 0.015116672031581402, -0.07053909450769424, 0.01870073191821575, 0.037967752665281296, 0.0364210307598114, -0.01766633242368698, -0.02462763525545597, 0.05213678255677223, 0.04651442915201187, 0.002605595625936985, 0.0174570232629776, 0.0020036480855196714, 0.00933558028191328, -0.027905384078621864, -0.027764415368437767, -0.03264386206865311, 0.05049404874444008, 0.007704850286245346, 0.03558516874909401, 0.02086263708770275, -0.039034079760313034, 0.01914522796869278, -0.07492005825042725, 0.008762017823755741, -0.03217541053891182, 0.01039055548608303, 0.013440309092402458, 0.004742179531604052, 0.003018902149051428, -0.03634496033191681, -0.0355432890355587, -0.02642127312719822, -0.029722511768341064, 0.01207819301635027, -0.01721801981329918, -0.01237544696778059, 0.03418808802962303, -0.06602204591035843, -0.009094491600990295, -0.02597593516111374, 0.031320467591285706, 0.028581267222762108, 0.06051256135106087, -0.06933955103158951, -0.01649496704339981, -0.02463887445628643, -0.04196995124220848, -0.014080378226935863, 0.010274011641740799, 0.025939254090189934, 0.00492789875715971, 0.014693873934447765, 0.027569107711315155, -0.004058009944856167, -0.015168651007115841, -0.006142907310277224, 0.016953714191913605, -0.002029701368883252, 0.009968485683202744, 0.004366432782262564, 0.033037446439266205, -0.039796363562345505, 0.03611379489302635, 0.014187091030180454, 0.07035225629806519, 0.02208247222006321, -0.05250577628612518, 0.01242133416235447, -0.014420082792639732, -0.03247634693980217, 0.03895769268274307, -0.0011356351897120476, -0.00603253161534667, 0.010813036002218723, -0.01611154153943062, 0.020829876884818077, -0.06487361341714859, -0.002860485576093197, 0.0883588045835495, -0.007114769425243139, -0.005261067301034927, -0.04006694629788399, -0.058048371225595474, 0.0038255208637565374, -0.012256518937647343, 0.06783346086740494, 0.0024806142318993807, 0.004651717841625214, 0.025080401450395584, -0.008253353647887707, -0.015047382563352585, -0.05142224207520485, 0.0009346111910417676, 0.004279354587197304, 0.0466763935983181, -0.000007779010957165156, -0.0003573699214030057, -0.008907661773264408, 0.027513012290000916, 0.04597325995564461, 0.020751671865582466, -0.022492870688438416, -0.09506676346063614, 0.02739436738193035, 0.021784165874123573, 0.02851553075015545, 0.011167703196406364, -0.000987416598945856, -0.0478922463953495, -0.00960717536509037, 0.019431589171290398, -0.03512491285800934, 0.03735719621181488, -0.0055488222278654575, 0.01660747639834881, -0.043468307703733444, 0.012198294512927532, -0.046541281044483185, -0.0031258082017302513, -0.005069563630968332, 0.03262143209576607, -0.009004342369735241, -0.035908617079257965, -0.027456197887659073, 0.04627780616283417, 0.00446996558457613, 0.05667989328503609, -0.019110623747110367, -0.007516736164689064, 0.004611678421497345, 0.011825543828308582, -0.011910508386790752, -0.05758117139339447, 0.010601641610264778, 0.031566306948661804, -0.03273775428533554, 0.03175478056073189, -0.011053936555981636, -0.013391467742621899, 0.0212225541472435, -0.008046218194067478, -0.0006709381123073399, 0.010871111415326595, -0.006497475318610668, 0.04435713589191437, 0.05164027959108353, -0.03398071229457855, 0.025897985324263573, 0.015451112762093544, 0.0036718242336064577, 0.0006600882625207305, -0.053839217871427536, 0.04613671451807022, -0.03348555043339729, 0.006813832093030214, -0.04771575331687927, 0.006962511222809553, -0.034959692507982254, 0.028821300715208054, 0.027120577171444893, 0.049793243408203125, -0.03124048374593258, -0.013395333662629128, 0.027164185419678688, 0.036314334720373154, 0.005739681422710419, -0.0354490801692009, -0.0077405571937561035, 0.04993779957294464, 0.028508208692073822, 0.019352344796061516, 0.022442765533924103, -0.014445509761571884, 0.036253880709409714, 0.002605140209197998, -0.023355746641755104, 0.00008581181464251131, -0.05563781037926674, -0.005068942438811064, 0.0056673819199204445, -0.07830336689949036, 0.015246416442096233, -0.010919373482465744, -0.021766023710370064, 0.0286579392850399, -0.03138772398233414, 0.01840505562722683, -0.010941381566226482, 0.026592589914798737, 0.03248400613665581, -0.019763341173529625, 0.033799637109041214, -0.015406782738864422, -0.001703800866380334, -0.05685228854417801, -0.00416906364262104, 0.025465017184615135, 0.0006641061627306044, -0.017181701958179474, -0.08297629654407501, 0.005739583168178797, -0.0022987443953752518, 0.007164997048676014, 0.005289279390126467, 0.042845647782087326, -0.00844690203666687, -0.013982363045215607, 0.0067908368073403835, 0.02453869767487049, 0.03573639690876007, -0.005629519000649452, -0.03803928941488266, 0.04576684907078743, 0.029105357825756073, 0.006744400132447481, 0.0009119915193878114, 0.05059468001127243, -0.01985141634941101, -0.01862787827849388, -0.04704330116510391, 0.03235930576920509, 0.06306273490190506, -0.05356016382575035, -0.018350860103964806, -0.0033019769471138716, 0.038541633635759354, 0.019785840064287186, -0.027883285656571388, -0.011926406063139439, -0.021627891808748245, -0.027180703356862068, -0.003513739909976721, 0.017772216349840164, 0.017554327845573425, -0.015816468745470047, 0.03709743916988373, 0.0010164370760321617, -0.010359011590480804, 0.028997361660003662, 0.06843585520982742, -0.00805896520614624, -0.01692887209355831, 0.005554536357522011, -0.0028487863019108772, 0.020076455548405647, -0.012842590920627117, -0.0002298516483278945, 0.02283255197107792, 0.0026866993866860867, 0.0007080200593918562, 0.000303039385471493, -0.0447106771171093, 0.02638147957623005, 0.07520146667957306, 0.0021085136104375124, 0.014120666310191154, 0.04262756556272507, -0.008068207651376724, -0.005815613083541393, -0.04744274169206619, -0.015945469960570335, -0.02856389246881008, 0.01042601466178894, 0.025309711694717407, -0.01476340927183628, -0.005576910451054573, 0.03359108045697212, 0.025122011080384254, 0.011749744415283203, 0.011943068355321884, 0.03403301164507866, 0.00623956136405468, 0.039613690227270126, -0.03552905470132828, -0.030808070674538612, 0.045781027525663376, -0.0018851294880732894, 0.030477534979581833, -0.03281261771917343, 0.013433938845992088, 0.03151248022913933, 0.06614798307418823, 0.010731833986938, -0.02055199444293976, -0.011646163649857044, -0.056490056216716766, 0.03142119199037552, 0.03836481273174286, -0.008760922588407993, 0.04895130544900894, 0.034690264612436295, 0.03615639731287956, 0.007575265597552061, 0.02120269276201725, -0.003458669176325202, -0.05008978769183159, -0.053282469511032104, -0.006834781263023615, -0.023303762078285217, 0.0030672301072627306, 0.00523607712239027, -0.04801594465970993, -0.026201218366622925, -0.014464002102613449, 0.015724482014775276, -0.02142235077917576, 0.011001074686646461, -0.027046220377087593, 0.043170265853405, -0.004402779042720795, 0.006725465878844261, -0.006772073917090893, 0.0057523129507899284, 0.12240289151668549, 0.024901729077100754, 0.0491001233458519, -0.07112773507833481, -0.011311322450637817, -0.0049307579174637794, -0.04785633459687233, -0.020011648535728455, 0.0085104675963521, 0.013906163163483143, 0.003080114722251892, 0.0175401009619236, 0.017454080283641815, 0.027461793273687363, 0.000023674667318118736, 0.059471484273672104, 0.0028695547953248024, -0.03372832387685776, -0.013976815156638622, -0.022047456353902817, -0.009705725125968456, 0.010537628084421158, -0.05300034210085869, 0.03796390816569328, 0.020371677353978157, -0.004624239634722471, -0.026855649426579475, -0.025838760659098625, -0.03122520074248314, 0.017406798899173737, -0.017422063276171684, 0.016402296721935272, 0.029071182012557983, 0.015523304231464863, -0.005107632838189602, 0.027906816452741623, 0.027507483959197998, -0.003701786044985056, 0.014883821830153465, 0.0582246370613575, -0.0021388581953942776, 0.01830170676112175, -0.005934545304626226, -0.005923866759985685, -0.02325824834406376, -0.061247505247592926, -0.040378276258707047, 0.06705228984355927, 0.0027970450464636087, -0.0047530545853078365, 0.010944725945591927, 0.016659090295433998, -0.009614710696041584, -0.058106739073991776, 0.031508076936006546, -0.014518903568387032, 0.07184380292892456, 0.004287722520530224, -0.028569970279932022, -0.02686549723148346, 0.02279556542634964, -0.012889718636870384, 0.01656721532344818, 0.03641270101070404, 0.01713859848678112, -0.016032980754971504, 0.0017385251121595502, 0.06659111380577087, 0.003572711255401373, 0.03037942387163639, -0.05546265095472336, -0.017518188804388046, -0.006636875215917826, -0.04461107403039932, 0.01736224815249443, 0.005629186052829027, 0.01701604761183262, 0.02597872167825699, -0.017112314701080322, -0.00886176060885191, -0.013267554342746735, 0.014912317506968975, -0.012936754152178764, -0.014557401649653912, 0.004575998522341251, 0.012688706628978252, 0.01880321092903614, 0.03355306386947632, 0.029802987352013588, 0.02818942815065384, 0.012698453851044178, 0.01042614784091711, -0.01416628435254097, -0.033528294414281845, -0.015319254249334335, 0.020239517092704773, -0.03664793074131012, -0.014356251806020737, 0.010376984253525734, 0.04907100275158882, 0.019964909180998802, 0.003650546772405505, -0.02352479286491871, 0.02807445637881756, -0.003101977752521634, 0.011526932939887047, 0.013190868310630322, -0.08578546345233917, 0.02050061710178852, 0.001755410572513938, -0.033630456775426865, -0.05343573912978172, -0.01447416190057993, -0.009476411156356335, -0.04312039166688919, -0.004832146689295769, 0.03262142837047577, -0.032834116369485855, -0.01442679949104786, 0.0044104005210101604, -0.0063447547145187855, -0.018765434622764587, 0.003453716868534684, 0.005952911917120218, -0.0069803656078875065, -0.0067494651302695274, -0.03197599947452545, -0.013135982677340508, -0.0035152649506926537, -0.028249533846974373, 0.03233211115002632, 0.031157253310084343, 0.03180704265832901, 0.030089637264609337, -0.028160635381937027, 0.014836493879556656, -0.016159726306796074, 0.03416796773672104, -0.04172523692250252, -0.013713319785892963, 0.007808689959347248, -0.05152317136526108, -0.04247049614787102, 0.009092488326132298, -0.0003598337643779814, 0.06918610632419586, -0.001838008756749332, 0.019962256774306297, -0.03679796680808067, 0.044117964804172516, -0.027382349595427513, -0.006336595397442579, -0.0009391407365910709, -0.006565719842910767, 0.015474565327167511, -0.002626194851472974, -0.013506468385457993, 0.01768762245774269, 0.007320297881960869, 0.041983917355537415, 0.007083594333380461, -0.021143512800335884, -0.009371970780193806, -0.0010296533582732081, -0.05500572919845581, -0.010341886430978775, 0.010650074109435081, -0.004017231520265341, 0.05954621359705925, 0.03683794289827347, 0.0018128182273358107, 0.003392391838133335, -0.009361550211906433, 0.04793606698513031, -0.09545697271823883, -0.013524641282856464, 0.03282307833433151, -0.006987519562244415, 0.04867248237133026, -0.06617759168148041, 0.0027743361424654722, 0.00964321754872799, -0.07086361944675446, 0.02423885092139244, -0.013990468345582485, -0.015047485940158367, -0.017230743542313576, 0.03410780429840088, -0.002789876190945506, 0.05859331414103508, 0.02800619602203369, 0.06208944320678711, 0.028270641341805458, 0.026174921542406082, -0.005016437731683254, -0.017161868512630463, 0.0004773577384185046, 0.03205875679850578, 0.00281622726470232, -0.058860376477241516, 0.02230810560286045, -0.011370688676834106, -0.01989937014877796, 0.034432150423526764, -0.047486502677202225, 0.03206201270222664, 0.050494786351919174, 0.02650362066924572, -0.005095089785754681, 0.010131489485502243, 0.03857608512043953, 0.011389974504709244, 0.02432779222726822, -0.01456495001912117, -0.01599465124309063, 0.004412329755723476, -0.02384193055331707, 0.009648304432630539, 0.013700931333005428, 0.005493038333952427, -0.023406539112329483, 0.007266223430633545, -0.0327480286359787, -0.04911855235695839, -0.023698050528764725, 0.022261325269937515, 0.01496981456875801, -0.030459268018603325, 0.020760152488946915, -0.03352149575948715, 0.0015256762271746993, 0.046907052397727966, 0.01715874671936035, -0.027666393667459488, 0.02681637369096279, -0.043393805623054504, -0.029729019850492477, -0.02273174375295639, -0.04017387703061104, -0.035700444132089615, -0.021106405183672905, -0.013566031120717525, -0.004355229903012514, 0.017573464661836624, -0.010860768146812916, 0.009090675041079521, -0.04382332041859627, 0.07684779912233353, 0.006577922962605953, 0.03269564360380173, 0.029424652457237244, -0.056405723094940186, 0.0007181914988905191, -0.11229147017002106, 0.034680355340242386, -0.020475227385759354, -0.06607063859701157, -0.030120734125375748, 0.01241034921258688, -0.006830038968473673, -0.012621138244867325, 0.024107521399855614, 0.02990906685590744, 0.06493554264307022, -0.015311162918806076, 0.059949252754449844, 0.04756256937980652, -0.023557385429739952, 0.00643707811832428, -0.03540808707475662, -0.008165191859006882, -0.031763456761837006, -0.028748875483870506, -0.010954935103654861, -0.0065058255568146706, 0.031134765595197678, -0.010156114585697651, 0.017903639003634453, -0.0012715435586869717, -0.01806456968188286, 0.013173731043934822, -0.0005117252003401518, -0.002791046164929867, 0.016682790592312813, -0.008810214698314667, -0.012829075567424297, -0.004778400529175997, 0.008403540588915348, -0.016449270769953728, 0.024175463244318962, -0.011789776384830475, -0.056812405586242676, 0.02061661146581173, -0.017886657267808914, 0.021800819784402847, -0.0744841992855072, -0.018447935581207275, 0.021838583052158356, -0.007499318569898605, 0.01380986999720335, 0.045254919677972794, 0.03541751205921173, 0.03032682090997696, 0.0303731057792902, 0.005347076337784529, 0.0010385068599134684, 0.009443064220249653, -0.00011303528299322352, 0.022276496514678, 0.021494602784514427, -0.0013666815357282758, -0.04768243059515953, 0.013795067556202412, -0.04694494232535362, 0.010697049088776112, -0.01007069367915392, 0.06381519138813019, -0.009210021235048771, -0.0019472817657515407, 0.0034225787967443466, 0.0014256134163588285, -0.0014212459791451693, -0.006116536911576986, -0.010993906296789646, 0.07461049407720566, -0.026533739641308784, -0.02525242790579796, -0.060100194066762924, -0.036755505949258804, -0.032851651310920715, 0.002894927281886339, 0.0201836246997118, 0.0120155718177557, 0.022998971864581108, 0.02768370322883129, -0.02151329256594181, 0.0014480663230642676, 0.04446016997098923, -0.031838081777095795, 0.00971840787678957, -0.010341770015656948, 0.02388797514140606, 0.04722646623849869, 0.02680879458785057, 0.007402355317026377, -0.008110014721751213, 0.05269084870815277, 0.02127016708254814, -0.017005911096930504, -0.05424493923783302, -0.021860813722014427, -0.03815743327140808, 0.016404591500759125, -0.06573240458965302, -0.011946281418204308, -0.04098057001829147, 0.008405211381614208, -0.03609027713537216, -0.014421726576983929 ]
<p>This question regards the basic statistics of a normal distribution, but I can't figure it out. I have been given the mean and 95% confidence intervals for a distribution, but would like to know the standard deviation. In my example:</p> <p>$$ \mu=53.4\quad 95\%\ c.i.=(52.3, 54.3) $$</p> <p>I had thought that the solution for $\sigma$ would be something like:</p> <p>$$54.3=53.4+(SE*1.96)$$ $$SE=(54.3-53.4)/1.96=0.46$$ and then, $$SE=\frac{\sigma}{\sqrt{n}}$$ $$\sigma=0.46*\sqrt{n}$$</p> <p>So, if I don't know the $n$, is this possible?</p>
49,618
[ -0.015623250976204872, -0.02796556055545807, -0.022378241643309593, -0.012053188867866993, 0.000738960225135088, 0.02579565718770027, -0.04032205045223236, -0.03485633432865143, 0.020265819504857063, -0.04252331703901291, 0.07303991913795471, 0.03541490435600281, 0.03644591197371483, 0.03345246985554695, 0.0405280739068985, 0.022975627332925797, -0.04591966047883034, 0.020529262721538544, -0.025690125301480293, -0.03970486670732498, -0.003971660044044256, 0.017961304634809494, -0.03201253339648247, -0.034210145473480225, -0.031400881707668304, 0.030608201399445534, 0.016025390475988388, -0.0007768285577185452, 0.004338534083217382, 0.06809411942958832, -0.023493878543376923, -0.009338310919702053, 0.033415742218494415, 0.05581608787178993, 0.012349634431302547, 0.0035227451007813215, 0.005206465721130371, -0.009554513730108738, -0.003368197940289974, 0.012346047908067703, -0.037562720477581024, 0.017601240426301956, 0.008850716054439545, 0.009646445512771606, -0.01815003901720047, 0.0526236928999424, -0.041992440819740295, -0.05390588566660881, 0.008060275577008724, -0.03918693959712982, 0.07143707573413849, 0.01024302002042532, 0.05870715528726578, 0.03644989803433418, 0.004789287690073252, 0.010971699841320515, 0.04444842413067818, 0.03858543187379837, -0.00434914929792285, -0.05012385919690132, 0.010752932168543339, -0.013299848884344101, -0.017550863325595856, -0.04463953524827957, -0.0053026615642011166, -0.006184973753988743, -0.019258717074990273, -0.000014790128261665814, 0.06595981866121292, 0.010917243547737598, 0.0130924042314291, 0.0675322562456131, 0.02629886008799076, -0.011896376498043537, -0.0033721886575222015, -0.03897067531943321, 0.04182816296815872, -0.005059345625340939, 0.03837554529309273, 0.015287830494344234, 0.0223977193236351, 0.005232885479927063, 0.04953165352344513, 0.038054436445236206, 0.03468513861298561, -0.02247362770140171, 0.07750741392374039, -0.02025802806019783, 0.02409631758928299, 0.04392658919095993, -0.0027884754817932844, 0.02998943440616131, 0.06114321947097778, -0.054130591452121735, -0.03628288581967354, 0.07125803828239441, -0.023397110402584076, 0.03680090233683586, 0.006637430749833584, -0.013718808069825172, 0.009798883460462093, -0.03955927491188049, 0.014900381676852703, 0.031688276678323746, -0.032607004046440125, -0.005461601540446281, -0.018739763647317886, 0.019808998331427574, 0.024941736832261086, -0.020893851295113564, 0.009245731867849827, 0.022896109148859978, -0.004773544147610664, 0.004912602715194225, 0.05763505771756172, 0.014023613184690475, -0.028115099295973778, -0.039840687066316605, 0.04689580202102661, 0.052937403321266174, 0.002957945456728339, -0.01739325374364853, 0.01563659869134426, -0.022554701194167137, -0.028369594365358353, 0.004091577138751745, 0.02578842081129551, 0.024433966726064682, -0.061525195837020874, 0.050976842641830444, -0.013234876096248627, -0.006911644246429205, 0.017071019858121872, 0.018475539982318878, 0.017368540167808533, -0.0009807597380131483, -0.07709354162216187, -0.061336077749729156, 0.012763258069753647, -0.03410511836409569, -0.017979908734560013, -0.06940329074859619, -0.006273449398577213, 0.03654057905077934, 0.012013246305286884, 0.004005477763712406, 0.03843789920210838, -0.026331182569265366, 0.024441687390208244, 0.03241203725337982, -0.014133683405816555, -0.004026493057608604, -0.011435138061642647, -0.028443654999136925, 0.0066273813135921955, -0.04793400317430496, 0.03570319339632988, 0.0028734123334288597, 0.023949764668941498, -0.030327947810292244, -0.007818756625056267, 0.014829592779278755, -0.008107172325253487, -0.012444356456398964, 0.030624428763985634, -0.04781414940953255, 0.1070452630519867, 0.007291185203939676, 0.011020306497812271, 0.004823509603738785, -0.008443444967269897, -0.012944310903549194, 0.0035370634868741035, 0.011729910969734192, 0.0807204321026802, -0.05145018547773361, -0.03323299437761307, -0.03018946759402752, 0.03402934968471527, 0.016148902475833893, -0.042060721665620804, 0.022485647350549698, 0.006292504258453846, 0.029464878141880035, 0.008436627686023712, 0.07039844989776611, 0.03626467287540436, -0.031130613759160042, 0.00570977758616209, -0.0456402413547039, -0.006502413656562567, -0.059496715664863586, -0.012880967929959297, -0.019045135006308556, -0.04274095967411995, 0.006230051629245281, 0.027995681390166283, 0.07134091854095459, -0.0012168240500614047, -0.029372410848736763, 0.01717165857553482, 0.013414221815764904, 0.023362474516034126, -0.0678030252456665, 0.03184599429368973, 0.04645852372050285, 0.060043398290872574, 0.0007318311254493892, 0.03627872094511986, -0.021380016580224037, -0.04496723413467407, -0.018105128780007362, -0.056361567229032516, -0.008662453852593899, 0.03151492401957512, -0.025647925212979317, -0.011055391281843185, -0.013863340951502323, 0.0036526599433273077, 0.016002051532268524, -0.02141193486750126, 0.031390462070703506, 0.04507202282547951, 0.0088095273822546, -0.008580015040934086, 0.0008786034886725247, 0.044008441269397736, -0.005866227205842733, -0.02025481127202511, -0.016093775629997253, -0.030260607600212097, -0.024580033496022224, 0.025759348645806313, 0.011445524170994759, -0.03451778367161751, -0.006389525718986988, 0.06077783927321434, 0.01204119622707367, 0.028426330536603928, 0.04475192725658417, -0.016428161412477493, -0.026274554431438446, -0.036274492740631104, 0.010351672768592834, -0.00019130154396407306, 0.029013579711318016, -0.003521515754982829, 0.04130290448665619, 0.013405933044850826, 0.014890884049236774, 0.010810581967234612, 0.029761865735054016, -0.003096975851804018, 0.003183799097314477, 0.016966326162219048, -0.001993191195651889, 0.040685608983039856, -0.02972640097141266, -0.00009437914559384808, 0.03100791573524475, -0.013257351703941822, -0.018008500337600708, -0.0005790661089122295, -0.019033636897802353, -0.0034899963065981865, 0.047021884471178055, -0.002499023452401161, 0.015045738779008389, 0.00043425217154435813, -0.009858966805040836, 0.005811925977468491, -0.02979028783738613, 0.026843128725886345, 0.0067183757200837135, 0.008396838791668415, -0.0014730230905115604, 0.018479781225323677, 0.04516798257827759, -0.020145289599895477, -0.059031907469034195, -0.007003478705883026, -0.014039422385394573, -0.005185957998037338, 0.0179308969527483, -0.054430585354566574, -0.009239066392183304, 0.010441696271300316, -0.04874499514698982, -0.015022153034806252, -0.014977697283029556, 0.007604378275573254, 0.0607428103685379, -0.03546706587076187, -0.028481299057602882, -0.018614497035741806, -0.026957564055919647, 0.013334198854863644, -0.023169683292508125, -0.010170291177928448, 0.021690446883440018, 0.0048621525056660175, -0.01134263351559639, 0.03113551437854767, -0.06342203915119171, -0.07647241652011871, -0.06276620924472809, 0.013556262478232384, 0.025692380964756012, -0.009353761561214924, 0.004499584436416626, 0.02345321886241436, -0.006577887572348118, 0.018737182021141052, -0.0621003620326519, -0.05188678577542305, 0.007709603291004896, -0.008883961476385593, 0.030087513849139214, 0.017579663544893265, -0.015913162380456924, 0.09015540033578873, 0.006384651642292738, -0.034276481717824936, 0.011738438159227371, 0.011984958313405514, -0.0050759389996528625, -0.030153028666973114, -0.02192069962620735, 0.006350000388920307, -0.03237592801451683, 0.027160638943314552, 0.044780485332012177, 0.026538696140050888, 0.038818202912807465, 0.01915249414741993, -0.004424211569130421, -0.03508983924984932, -0.04452484846115112, -0.0038135305512696505, 0.06610217690467834, 0.001198135782033205, -0.013044842518866062, 0.004638927523046732, -0.004728415515273809, 0.058453723788261414, 0.036640994250774384, -0.04068287834525108, 0.045306939631700516, -0.01982206478714943, -0.014177517965435982, -0.07633048295974731, 0.04479573294520378, 0.034548088908195496, -0.030474238097667694, 0.0014131427742540836, 0.02182839624583721, 0.017335494980216026, -0.02050270512700081, -0.001586581813171506, 0.06796831637620926, 0.030107351019978523, -0.017978260293602943, -0.040834348648786545, -0.010082362219691277, -0.0150147695094347, -0.00842883251607418, 0.011394277215003967, -0.017763396725058556, 0.04260886460542679, 0.07755499333143234, 0.04292561113834381, -0.008519161492586136, -0.03734709694981575, 0.021921252831816673, -0.04727572575211525, -0.013192379847168922, 0.006012023892253637, 0.012683330103754997, -0.0058194724842906, 0.06686737388372421, 0.019075613468885422, -0.03388511762022972, 0.018805570900440216, 0.0013822235632687807, -0.058650076389312744, 0.039698146283626556, -0.02153659425675869, -0.06216380000114441, -0.01036936603486538, -0.04292484000325203, 0.0010331361554563046, -0.00888847652822733, 0.045472320169210434, 0.01930295117199421, 0.029396042227745056, -0.011871382594108582, 0.009187739342451096, -0.033386193215847015, 0.0036567337810993195, -0.023536430671811104, 0.037740834057331085, -0.011832009069621563, -0.03496399521827698, -0.0022624703124165535, 0.02462552674114704, 0.02025623433291912, -0.024776358157396317, -0.04798372834920883, -0.016431720927357674, -0.023097749799489975, 0.05049820989370346, 0.03472255542874336, 0.02209174633026123, -0.009907596744596958, 0.0014202052261680365, -0.0028930294793099165, 0.047955796122550964, 0.036665432155132294, -0.004916535224765539, -0.008352164179086685, -0.04207511618733406, -0.008522577583789825, -0.013007733970880508, 0.02580312266945839, -0.01026085577905178, 0.03484296053647995, 0.052813101559877396, -0.0059225973673164845, -0.07685201615095139, 0.01202752161771059, 0.07733321934938431, -0.010410620830953121, -0.018256230279803276, -0.050656795501708984, 0.007710193283855915, -0.06608027219772339, -0.008982561528682709, -0.007777118124067783, 0.037873756140470505, -0.003928607329726219, -0.021831896156072617, 0.049784645438194275, -0.0009543151827529073, -0.0023076648358255625, -0.0054873512126505375, 0.013743279501795769, 0.055065762251615524, 0.007199379615485668, -0.021935492753982544, 0.02772638015449047, 0.0263096671551466, 0.02881346084177494, -0.03061610274016857, 0.02998438850045204, -0.06301148235797882, -0.00611975509673357, 0.019549192860722542, 0.033519621938467026, -0.02067575603723526, -0.007767249830067158, -0.032317984849214554, 0.016403302550315857, 0.04516373202204704, -0.0231223925948143, 0.0022283957805484533, -0.005457411054521799, 0.030568581074476242, -0.0032674004323780537, -0.021954460069537163, -0.07416225969791412, 0.006470126565545797, -0.020894968882203102, 0.013648252002894878, -0.06325013190507889, -0.01995987445116043, -0.054165083914995193, -0.0053020864725112915, 0.023993926122784615, 0.07900065183639526, -0.01795276813209057, -0.008869188837707043, -0.00725695863366127, 0.05065673589706421, -0.012732933275401592, -0.05665894225239754, -0.0080635454505682, 0.007320648059248924, -0.011486398056149483, 0.030102020129561424, -0.0030223196372389793, -0.043114107102155685, 0.04859048128128052, 0.020751234143972397, -0.04386811703443527, -0.013771121390163898, 0.008341916836798191, 0.03339555114507675, 0.05399588868021965, 0.03901910409331322, 0.062105078250169754, -0.01630547270178795, -0.00012076841812813655, -0.012450829148292542, -0.058484263718128204, 0.02856326475739479, -0.010049079544842243, -0.025765378028154373, -0.02662595547735691, 0.008888762444257736, -0.0016370491357520223, 0.029582126066088676, -0.007134172599762678, 0.05781317502260208, 0.004427235573530197, 0.012097426690161228, -0.006226153112947941, 0.00311051937751472, 0.017534414306282997, 0.02578350529074669, 0.017782097682356834, 0.014566861093044281, -0.01715993694961071, -0.022226504981517792, 0.0005155902472324669, -0.009752982296049595, -0.0028952190186828375, 0.015707744285464287, -0.02558928169310093, 0.014686446636915207, -0.019753150641918182, -0.07987160980701447, 0.010595737025141716, -0.03686758875846863, 0.022366361692547798, -0.0353146456182003, 0.04389535263180733, -0.006035221740603447, -0.0582612082362175, -0.028928251937031746, 0.00017545404261909425, 0.0024237323086708784, 0.008844869211316109, -0.03469107672572136, 0.04544054716825485, 0.012651768513023853, 0.007614955306053162, -0.06466028094291687, -0.0013154818443581462, -0.01033998467028141, 0.022641004994511604, -0.02789244055747986, -0.030713235959410667, -0.013144929893314838, -0.011911846697330475, -0.06524785608053207, -0.024486960843205452, 0.0045340582728385925, 0.0007667173049412668, -0.024501604959368706, -0.007657354697585106, 0.03332304209470749, 0.0672205314040184, -0.012233555316925049, 0.006845730822533369, 0.016967924311757088, -0.004453086294233799, -0.02770415134727955, 0.018273575231432915, 0.0217918548732996, -0.005812621675431728, -0.01008090190589428, -0.010565588250756264, -0.0024676863104104996, 0.04310208186507225, -0.026911800727248192, -0.018260324373841286, 0.02484801411628723, 0.03222157433629036, 0.005469145253300667, -0.005202697589993477, 0.01427293661981821, -0.00009244659304386005, 0.03828897699713707, -0.029937976971268654, 0.01738578826189041, -0.02609553560614586, 0.029616856947541237, 0.054039765149354935, -0.0035464290995150805, 0.02309051901102066, -0.00696985749527812, 0.07135006785392761, -0.047970015555620193, -0.01389286294579506, 0.00931018590927124, 0.028080802410840988, 0.012674597091972828, 0.045864805579185486, -0.008999031968414783, 0.014958973042666912, -0.029458384960889816, -0.037001848220825195, -0.01200349535793066, -0.03185166046023369, 0.021433444693684578, 0.04785735532641411, -0.0023725142236799, 0.04738776758313179, 0.030687475576996803, 0.032150957733392715, -0.004126536659896374, -0.020143233239650726, -0.019495291635394096, -0.01599929668009281, 0.004457767121493816, 0.04230554774403572, 0.010806129314005375, 0.0047133369371294975, 0.03443232178688049, 0.027051551267504692, -0.007317396812140942, 0.05693169683218002, 0.002156559145078063, 0.007073769345879555, 0.008001269772648811, -0.011769551783800125, -0.023023368790745735, 0.03574153035879135, -0.03477500379085541, 0.013368656858801842, 0.0021555114071816206, -0.014494749717414379, 0.0326632596552372, -0.0019465616205707192, 0.0018305688863620162, -0.003995858132839203, -0.008867121301591396, -0.0004626878653652966, -0.005569728557020426, 0.009321347810328007, -0.013558304868638515, -0.014087941497564316, -0.006829231046140194, 0.006164143793284893, -0.03316729515790939, 0.06852874159812927, -0.027627931907773018, -0.0929325744509697, -0.04613649472594261, -0.016588343307375908, -0.02894054725766182, 0.05280156061053276, -0.013595730066299438, -0.0188426673412323, 0.031036296859383583, -0.056741707026958466, 0.06085830181837082, 0.00412285840138793, 0.010657749138772488, -0.018462292850017548, 0.09501459449529648, 0.010587614960968494, 0.033855587244033813, 0.008053546771407127, 0.00772428885102272, 0.1139468252658844, 0.05092901736497879, -0.002816985361278057, -0.0259419996291399, -0.014420052990317345, -0.02214500494301319, -0.007358902599662542, 0.004183137323707342, 0.021412385627627373, -0.007614050060510635, 0.018396323546767235, 0.032126761972904205, 0.0441746860742569, 0.016723066568374634, -0.030171262100338936, 0.03692296892404556, -0.000584763998631388, -0.05594000592827797, 0.007295515853911638, -0.0015650928253307939, -0.023826058954000473, -0.0029661001171916723, -0.025147929787635803, 0.044384147971868515, -0.0054114749655127525, -0.009145242162048817, -0.02476387470960617, -0.009708509780466557, -0.0092990817502141, -0.006955030374228954, -0.044174905866384506, 0.0011952928034588695, 0.024325132369995117, -0.02217656373977661, -0.029048925265669823, -0.009136712178587914, 0.048371005803346634, -0.02890765108168125, 0.005122930742800236, 0.015815790742635727, -0.007788375951349735, 0.0048065087758004665, 0.020502189174294472, 0.016809731721878052, -0.04442094638943672, -0.05509151145815849, -0.047033436596393585, 0.03307545185089111, -0.0005339666386134923, 0.004726383835077286, 0.002360983518883586, -0.004830933175981045, 0.0022607119753956795, -0.048837486654520035, 0.0018153076525777578, -0.010443579405546188, 0.028975946828722954, -0.0391683466732502, -0.006014578510075808, -0.020375093445181847, 0.030111461877822876, -0.004256079904735088, 0.024342061951756477, 0.018853357061743736, -0.011689798906445503, -0.034258369356393814, -0.019694868475198746, 0.007968921214342117, -0.030960287898778915, -0.029791967943310738, 0.005338476039469242, -0.014805750921368599, -0.014380859211087227, -0.00676159281283617, 0.0337601937353611, -0.013906545005738735, 0.039238255470991135, -0.007839305326342583, 0.011993257328867912, -0.0008849543519318104, -0.03430056571960449, 0.023370986804366112, -0.030001817271113396, 0.031205972656607628, -0.04338172823190689, -0.013268526643514633, 0.015328423120081425, 0.0480220653116703, -0.005207659211009741, 0.019346652552485466, 0.01652689464390278, 0.08038943260908127, 0.044250041246414185, -0.05083199590444565, -0.013768642209470272, 0.01320913527160883, -0.04974241554737091, 0.038210976868867874, -0.01347721554338932, 0.03606611117720604, 0.03012768365442753, 0.05304449796676636, 0.015871334820985794, 0.030339011922478676, -0.02106906846165657, -0.009294580668210983, 0.008671548217535019, -0.05024486035108566, -0.010443156585097313, 0.03664093464612961, 0.019260454922914505, -0.010350476950407028, -0.011502204462885857, 0.0010823301272466779, -0.039241015911102295, 0.004984639119356871, 0.030716203153133392, -0.036888476461172104, 0.00805289950221777, -0.023319341242313385, -0.03263146057724953, 0.0050611356273293495, -0.008048687130212784, -0.02076629176735878, -0.011228568851947784, -0.024863766506314278, -0.006308309733867645, -0.03673059865832329, 0.027606947347521782, 0.0024335316848009825, 0.00022828878718428314, 0.021544428542256355, 0.0262753926217556, 0.02787207067012787, -0.01913178712129593, 0.014762298204004765, -0.023457350209355354, 0.04879206791520119, -0.03378036618232727, 0.01056399941444397, 0.056268688291311264, -0.04557136446237564, -0.027890991419553757, -0.014823872596025467, 0.0248026791960001, 0.044819705188274384, 0.012904967181384563, -0.01955946534872055, -0.01776825450360775, 0.03733569011092186, -0.04470352455973625, 0.025437522679567337, -0.03620521351695061, -0.002707458334043622, -0.009061080403625965, -0.0033345711417496204, -0.0032462964300066233, -0.008792680688202381, -0.008439182303845882, 0.03746367618441582, 0.013949728570878506, -0.01950746215879917, 0.017939135432243347, 0.02603134885430336, 0.015100857242941856, 0.015647374093532562, 0.022870207205414772, 0.01210460439324379, 0.0010466664098203182, 0.035240255296230316, -0.020652273669838905, 0.04301859810948372, -0.014188732020556927, -0.00854929257184267, -0.10406729578971863, -0.013985262252390385, 0.007380403578281403, 0.012167956680059433, 0.038066934794187546, -0.05323725566267967, -0.0060551888309419155, 0.04537069424986839, -0.05413014814257622, -0.02866661176085472, -0.025493726134300232, -0.04191846027970314, -0.020077737048268318, 0.02320086769759655, -0.00839526578783989, 0.01659543626010418, 0.03392506018280983, 0.01660514995455742, 0.013490185141563416, 0.043936196714639664, 0.04719788208603859, 0.0015815483639016747, -0.01037895493209362, 0.0007491034921258688, 0.043517258018255234, -0.06685589253902435, -0.012996328063309193, -0.05577213317155838, -0.028988100588321686, 0.025864306837320328, -0.004245250020176172, 0.038686465471982956, 0.007555705960839987, 0.015461824834346771, 0.01600015163421631, 0.06150577962398529, 0.007385519333183765, -0.022794965654611588, -0.03214767575263977, 0.0012760285753756762, 0.020518235862255096, 0.032565630972385406, -0.005561051424592733, -0.030964231118559837, 0.0469701774418354, -0.005980959627777338, -0.08452887088060379, 0.011159454472362995, -0.03318234533071518, -0.011548353359103203, 0.014860711060464382, -0.031237149611115456, 0.01829250529408455, -0.03886265307664871, 0.041671257466077805, -0.06396535038948059, 0.030337370932102203, 0.017496129497885704, 0.04077576473355293, 0.0028023715130984783, -0.016049541532993317, -0.0358625091612339, -0.046792469918727875, 0.027127208188176155, 0.009179944172501564, -0.010450394824147224, -0.0504160113632679, -0.0226067416369915, 0.00038439876516349614, -0.015087922103703022, 0.02596227079629898, -0.023008929565548897, -0.05947287008166313, 0.06538204848766327, 0.023959161713719368, 0.008297186344861984, 0.024757051840424538, -0.03569181635975838, 0.012491953559219837, -0.0716327503323555, 0.03705878183245659, 0.02671658806502819, -0.0014158269623294473, -0.04632739722728729, 0.021056676283478737, -0.036532528698444366, -0.02722395397722721, 0.040905989706516266, 0.01235906034708023, 0.013839486986398697, 0.006359643302857876, 0.0364871621131897, 0.036782607436180115, -0.06027132645249367, 0.027653148397803307, -0.03510027378797531, -0.01964629255235195, -0.0458233505487442, -0.02452438324689865, 0.006732284557074308, 0.0052336337976157665, -0.024881508201360703, 0.0009696932975202799, 0.016002792865037918, -0.012839226983487606, -0.007296919822692871, 0.03020695224404335, 0.02190394140779972, -0.03335699811577797, 0.04377800226211548, -0.026293518021702766, -0.01939602755010128, 0.07869894802570343, -0.018597714602947235, -0.03339060768485069, 0.009691772982478142, -0.02868320420384407, -0.03546367958188057, -0.028225217014551163, 0.013275670818984509, -0.0015662629157304764, -0.056086327880620956, -0.0030681861098855734, 0.04260408505797386, -0.03935474157333374, -0.029688425362110138, 0.021668586879968643, 0.019476601853966713, 0.03695480152964592, 0.010616827756166458, -0.01252399105578661, 0.003128813114017248, -0.031548067927360535, 0.011283216066658497, -0.011898787692189217, 0.0015423963777720928, -0.006513393949717283, 0.00016551846056245267, 0.015333548188209534, -0.009745598770678043, 0.02014913037419319, -0.0076833791099488735, 0.03722589090466499, -0.008616991341114044, -0.01664247177541256, -0.00863998755812645, -0.005476458463817835, 0.06035346910357475, -0.012603898532688618, -0.03618345037102699, 0.05868857353925705, 0.00048073456855490804, 0.030186733230948448, -0.03146615996956825, -0.009722738526761532, -0.02803438901901245, -0.027472849935293198, -0.0023005439434200525, -0.007297829259186983, 0.014331065118312836, -0.026791419833898544, -0.006368446163833141, 0.03843548148870468, 0.05587859824299812, -0.008479961194097996, 0.015061466954648495, -0.0006174563895910978, -0.010962672531604767, -0.05045624077320099, -0.023401565849781036, -0.04141832888126373, -0.015623577870428562, 0.01705212891101837, 0.025951197370886803, 0.025669187307357788, 0.011283348314464092, -0.03212444856762886, 0.0005365481483750045, 0.09369178861379623, -0.03966302424669266, -0.016118407249450684, -0.06340742856264114, 0.008494541980326176, -0.02243170142173767, -0.0653839111328125 ]
<p>I was able to reproduce table 3.1 from ESL. However, when I tried to reproduce table 3.2, my estimated coefficients were way off (shown below):</p> <pre><code> [,1] [1,] 0.4292 [2,] 0.5765 [3,] 0.6140 [4,] -0.0190 [5,] 0.1448 [6,] 0.7372 [7,] -0.2063 [8,] -0.0295 [9,] 0.0095 </code></pre> <p>The results from table 3.2 in ESL are as follow: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/epSz4.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I have attached my code here: </p> <pre><code>res &lt;- read.table("prostate.data", sep = "") fix(res) XTraining = subset(res, train) XTesting = subset(res, train == FALSE) nrow = dim( XTraining )[1] p = dim( XTraining )[2] - 1 # the last column is the response D = XTraining[,1:p-1] # get the predictor data # This gives the raw data for Table 3.1 from the book: # print(cor(D),digts=3) library(xtable) xtable( cor(D), caption="Duplication of the values from Table 3.1 from the book", digits=3 ) # # Duplicate Table 3.2 from the book # # Append a column of ones: # Dp = cbind( matrix(1,nrow,1), as.matrix( D ) ) lpsa = XTraining[,p] library(MASS) betaHat = ginv( t(Dp) %*% Dp ) %*% t(Dp) %*% as.matrix(lpsa) # this is basically the first column in Table 3.2: # print('first column: beta estimates') print(betaHat,digits=2) </code></pre> <p>Does anyone have similar issues ? I would like to know what went wrong with my output. </p>
73,645
[ -0.013267681002616882, 0.007466907612979412, 0.007231271825730801, -0.008574520237743855, 0.026792699471116066, 0.0198509618639946, -0.029559358954429626, -0.033560220152139664, 0.019211016595363617, -0.007833032868802547, 0.046035438776016235, 0.020875755697488785, 0.058972664177417755, 0.029785342514514923, 0.030111098662018776, 0.024976888671517372, -0.012879212386906147, 0.03263724595308304, -0.005914101842790842, -0.03487929329276085, 0.03924569487571716, 0.01548840757459402, -0.019807014614343643, 0.0024737089406698942, -0.002571918535977602, 0.045930858701467514, 0.019713912159204483, -0.029510149732232094, -0.02240639366209507, 0.04486854374408722, -0.04021259397268295, -0.02610138989984989, -0.02077377960085869, -0.015791259706020355, 0.024887870997190475, 0.031051669269800186, -0.011328420601785183, -0.0687340721487999, 0.013984340243041515, 0.040541376918554306, -0.0009096125140786171, -0.0019731055945158005, 0.007107513956725597, 0.031277626752853394, 0.0015203686198219657, 0.033596452325582504, 0.008979929611086845, 0.021488172933459282, 0.035000286996364594, 0.0032947822473943233, 0.050738316029310226, 0.0012301087845116854, 0.02509141154587269, 0.06621788442134857, -0.018666837364435196, -0.015720929950475693, 0.024695731699466705, 0.07240048050880432, 0.014049623161554337, -0.049827516078948975, -0.0016209633322432637, 0.004616097547113895, 0.009359616786241531, -0.0069085173308849335, -0.03070441447198391, 0.01471868809312582, 0.025387806817889214, -0.01538774836808443, 0.03050510585308075, -0.026390492916107178, 0.04742218181490898, 0.0335816890001297, -0.0020260605961084366, -0.04493308067321777, 0.012029622681438923, -0.004286766517907381, 0.01583901233971119, 0.01854829490184784, 0.02548188716173172, 0.00605734484270215, 0.032198965549468994, 0.001611148240044713, 0.014728164300322533, 0.04350550100207329, -0.012612764723598957, 0.012724189087748528, 0.04290783777832985, -0.020137520506978035, 0.009908784180879593, 0.031340137124061584, -0.022387078031897545, 0.013817663304507732, 0.032120686024427414, -0.01522673387080431, -0.012267962098121643, 0.05562509596347809, -0.003975106403231621, 0.07118148356676102, -0.02197415567934513, 0.010554959997534752, 0.004529477097094059, -0.04341048747301102, 0.012601739726960659, 0.015611270442605019, -0.019457440823316574, -0.07359840720891953, -0.042729511857032776, 0.004480627365410328, -0.017878379672765732, -0.029071997851133347, -0.0463852733373642, 0.017341379076242447, 0.005489044357091188, -0.008469490334391594, 0.004474444314837456, -0.032870370894670486, 0.02578968182206154, 0.03623322769999504, 0.02822580561041832, 0.05229414254426956, 0.025440460070967674, -0.024494633078575134, 0.023675009608268738, -0.03776745870709419, -0.05437716096639633, 0.028589647263288498, 0.022366756573319435, -0.026576371863484383, 0.013320271857082844, 0.014958896674215794, -0.008036991581320763, -0.0075001767836511135, 0.05174212530255318, 0.04043806716799736, 0.006478129420429468, 0.006890296470373869, -0.08248616009950638, -0.040467020124197006, 0.02212962694466114, -0.012444037944078445, 0.010353350080549717, -0.06571368128061295, -0.012546522542834282, 0.04851391166448593, 0.04264507442712784, 0.0026647746562957764, 0.03938990458846092, 0.013108895160257816, 0.01136292889714241, 0.024860970675945282, -0.01730404421687126, 0.026058673858642578, -0.06115669384598732, -0.016785386949777603, -0.0490458607673645, -0.07940739393234253, 0.006475165951997042, -0.007556478027254343, 0.013324677012860775, -0.010613208636641502, 0.03401947021484375, -0.03028997592628002, -0.021869901567697525, -0.03528701514005661, -0.021153349429368973, -0.03590951859951019, 0.06609780341386795, -0.0070431530475616455, -0.00019258058455307037, 0.009185327216982841, -0.01849723979830742, 0.018901702016592026, -0.004079906735569239, 0.024080976843833923, 0.04226261377334595, -0.018702944740653038, -0.023797590285539627, 0.006863190792500973, 0.0036169898230582476, -0.004302761517465115, -0.0187473576515913, -0.03512956202030182, 0.013757438398897648, -0.012774898670613766, 0.008212413638830185, 0.0018359237583354115, 0.007022657431662083, -0.02178657241165638, 0.045112621039152145, -0.03839699923992157, -0.04294950142502785, -0.04336841031908989, -0.0006538652232848108, -0.009438850916922092, -0.011514129117131233, 0.00038188055623322725, 0.001003583543933928, 0.010150758549571037, 0.025836249813437462, -0.016667399555444717, -0.012257758527994156, 0.013193870894610882, 0.06517046689987183, -0.05266888812184334, -0.0020636124536395073, 0.04292196407914162, 0.043232131749391556, -0.04011810943484306, 0.03223037347197533, -0.035002194344997406, -0.002178940922021866, 0.03412158787250519, -0.031363826245069504, -0.006207076366990805, -0.03598574921488762, -0.006513102911412716, 0.014105054549872875, 0.03101026453077793, -0.032503336668014526, 0.028302917256951332, -0.04796219617128372, 0.03444056585431099, 0.057646337896585464, -0.020147766917943954, -0.009054100140929222, -0.03315630927681923, -0.013691403903067112, 0.057017359882593155, -0.008820174261927605, -0.0017781674396246672, -0.026919854804873466, -0.0165049210190773, -0.00432055676355958, 0.020015275105834007, 0.02924717403948307, 0.03606027364730835, 0.042067062109708786, -0.01950935460627079, -0.001232190988957882, 0.04807041585445404, 0.010297849774360657, -0.01636013574898243, 0.03492617607116699, 0.0020712455734610558, 0.018691975623369217, 0.02121298760175705, -0.018369564786553383, -0.005053726490586996, 0.037652768194675446, -0.014193951152265072, 0.01841931976377964, 0.01638740487396717, -0.0297223050147295, 0.011278861202299595, -0.040009189397096634, -0.018525244668126106, 0.04432063549757004, -0.0009434343664906919, 0.037246301770210266, -0.011711142025887966, -0.01302372943609953, -0.021860146895051003, 0.00020058282825630158, -0.02575063705444336, 0.014136641286313534, 0.039780233055353165, -0.044474538415670395, -0.016771841794252396, 0.011176533065736294, -0.07610597461462021, 0.0418081171810627, -0.023371756076812744, -0.02631664276123047, -0.03150629252195358, -0.0059892479330301285, 0.028688838705420494, 0.021709831431508064, 0.017687363550066948, -0.029970018193125725, 0.010904497466981411, -0.007051133085042238, -0.01858544908463955, 0.04127376526594162, -0.020337658002972603, -0.05842464044690132, -0.014767132699489594, -0.03259091451764107, -0.011874806135892868, 0.004525754135102034, 0.006967559922486544, -0.05988001450896263, 0.004056456498801708, -0.012770280241966248, -0.043258581310510635, -0.0302622988820076, -0.03451351076364517, -0.012615594081580639, -0.008034640923142433, -0.02092154137790203, 0.027359552681446075, 0.031229620799422264, -0.055076561868190765, 0.03098296746611595, -0.017247315496206284, -0.000797142565716058, 0.016089919954538345, -0.0009638399933464825, -0.0054958113469183445, 0.012066409923136234, -0.0036944325547665358, 0.03072616457939148, 0.012337050400674343, -0.0027057435363531113, -0.08535049110651016, -0.014861779287457466, -0.0036998409777879715, 0.025941738858819008, -0.013438841328024864, 0.0020421419758349657, 0.004714296665042639, 0.07359940558671951, 0.010868137702345848, -0.022824903950095177, -0.0168501827865839, 0.02470346912741661, -0.008837957866489887, -0.0690683126449585, 0.03987191617488861, 0.027112938463687897, 0.032533857971429825, 0.01992015540599823, -0.0587778240442276, 0.053740933537483215, 0.05598004162311554, -0.01413370855152607, 0.01595107652246952, 0.023486295714974403, -0.020111069083213806, -0.0051728105172514915, 0.05221809446811676, -0.009595316834747791, 0.024530896916985512, 0.040300484746694565, -0.0014599775895476341, 0.011476291343569756, -0.038693495094776154, -0.030672304332256317, -0.0030677912291139364, 0.0024484398309141397, 0.04238398000597954, -0.0335613451898098, 0.03732633963227272, 0.01495693065226078, -0.053357213735580444, -0.018651101738214493, 0.02077031135559082, 0.05735970288515091, -0.02041490748524666, 0.01293216459453106, 0.054347019642591476, 0.002247283700853586, 0.0021296273916959763, 0.04779873415827751, -0.026337528601288795, -0.023828081786632538, -0.005517483688890934, -0.04222213849425316, -0.013164367526769638, 0.06207897886633873, 0.0250407624989748, 0.009114165790379047, 0.0032376761082559824, 0.0042794798500835896, 0.0014306086814031005, -0.021740498021245003, 0.013848365284502506, -0.03258838132023811, 0.04193984717130661, 0.022085899487137794, 0.05714637413620949, -0.0024542922619730234, -0.012803850695490837, 0.012805846519768238, -0.004364208783954382, -0.06297075748443604, 0.0011404517572373152, 0.030793311074376106, -0.02655063383281231, 0.004668856039643288, -0.046673670411109924, 0.03826078027486801, -0.0086953304708004, -0.049697186797857285, 0.052125487476587296, -0.03513651341199875, -0.047518473118543625, -0.00174111092928797, -0.003385955933481455, 0.006922105792909861, -0.02185535617172718, 0.020813187584280968, 0.06343744695186615, -0.0015886486507952213, -0.041048090904951096, 0.03060087002813816, -0.016782760620117188, 0.006822730414569378, -0.029420753940939903, 0.04859134554862976, 0.03357596695423126, 0.05286423861980438, 0.02506454661488533, 0.023432809859514236, -0.03917093202471733, 0.018289998173713684, 0.0002331426803721115, 0.0018941129092127085, 0.1048891618847847, -0.034065958112478256, -0.012391640804708004, -0.004556645639240742, 0.015317577868700027, 0.05289200693368912, -0.0029930672608315945, -0.00875000935047865, 0.008926418609917164, 0.04764251410961151, 0.054818231612443924, -0.017793796956539154, 0.023984270170331, 0.05921761319041252, -0.011972956359386444, -0.025749802589416504, -0.04655594378709793, -0.009206745773553848, -0.017924968153238297, -0.03541046380996704, 0.05270101875066757, 0.0123139014467597, 0.011567631736397743, 0.0014657473657280207, 0.01509078312665224, 0.045639768242836, -0.03198029100894928, -0.002632374409586191, 0.02646271139383316, 0.023282019421458244, 0.0035383293870836496, -0.040185898542404175, -0.0027708769775927067, 0.02185123972594738, 0.05005394294857979, 0.02585531771183014, 0.0255608931183815, -0.08223346620798111, -0.04815543442964554, 0.027271699160337448, 0.061759594827890396, -0.06074056029319763, -0.01626400649547577, -0.04967780038714409, 0.006757644936442375, 0.00519955949857831, -0.03237789869308472, 0.02409380115568638, -0.03374578058719635, 0.0005886032013222575, -0.007549882400780916, -0.03183947131037712, -0.05048602819442749, -0.002331007272005081, -0.05233732983469963, 0.03604409098625183, 0.006213326007127762, -0.0070006363093853, -0.006409745197743177, -0.0015944859478622675, 0.012608082965016365, 0.04012260586023331, -0.048356421291828156, -0.02789294347167015, 0.014973287470638752, 0.03781920298933983, -0.03629221022129059, -0.06416644901037216, 0.02839459665119648, -0.008266115561127663, 0.015104779973626137, 0.02254057675600052, -0.0138388117775321, -0.031000064685940742, 0.04835119843482971, 0.03209919109940529, -0.008631008677184582, -0.03229992091655731, -0.04671319201588631, -0.0035547204315662384, 0.033381178975105286, -0.007653598207980394, 0.09305576235055923, 0.014777502045035362, -0.01843808963894844, -0.004706286825239658, -0.048287417739629745, -0.007584909908473492, -0.026197917759418488, -0.024279631674289703, -0.04657867178320885, 0.008400822058320045, -0.003904221812263131, 0.020907975733280182, -0.004337117075920105, 0.02408435568213463, 0.011349000968039036, 0.007777207065373659, 0.038720738142728806, 0.05556076020002365, -0.07865642011165619, 0.0017255587736144662, -0.0036276911851018667, 0.021798280999064445, 0.0023613334633409977, -0.019857054576277733, 0.040185004472732544, -0.017664389684796333, 0.008680007420480251, 0.01651088148355484, -0.044839344918727875, 0.03232711926102638, 0.001635227119550109, -0.007911032065749168, -0.00028699220274575055, 0.00108055560849607, 0.012126704677939415, -0.03976051136851311, 0.04593999311327934, 0.008724394254386425, -0.00895704235881567, -0.05711730197072029, 0.028967151418328285, -0.004516888875514269, -0.004616947844624519, -0.03211342543363571, -0.005261056590825319, -0.014938614331185818, 0.0061532254330813885, -0.05427985638380051, -0.010155713185667992, 0.033730339258909225, -0.007098800502717495, -0.04216047376394272, -0.02215217798948288, -0.055557981133461, 0.004446468781679869, -0.023388709872961044, -0.007176203653216362, 0.03302464261651039, -0.058960143476724625, 0.031237196177244186, 0.010694612748920918, 0.008914920501410961, 0.04666096344590187, -0.007052984554320574, 0.0036141513846814632, 0.007967391051352024, 0.016983242705464363, -0.057893507182598114, -0.011608125641942024, -0.005463917274028063, -0.020599624142050743, 0.009255997836589813, -0.0007184677524492145, 0.015933645889163017, 0.05671026185154915, -0.04323023930191994, -0.039166729897260666, 0.0055315219797194, 0.002475221175700426, 0.015459907241165638, -0.07027608901262283, -0.02617308869957924, -0.012381547130644321, 0.019719338044524193, -0.005803932435810566, -0.005865551996976137, 0.01115608774125576, 0.013405418023467064, 0.014085482805967331, -0.022695103660225868, -0.030227024108171463, 0.009179957211017609, 0.07743673771619797, 0.030365368351340294, 0.025723274797201157, -0.012316777370870113, -0.03545866906642914, 0.08421541005373001, 0.031202033162117004, 0.06077031046152115, -0.0009478009887970984, 0.010484296828508377, -0.019119182601571083, 0.003222717670723796, -0.06383518874645233, 0.03457847982645035, 0.07488399744033813, 0.023405715823173523, 0.03316506743431091, 0.03856354206800461, 0.0018621280323714018, 0.027328360825777054, -0.03941382095217705, 0.006634209770709276, -0.024462059140205383, 0.0033110748045146465, 0.03588319942355156, -0.015249923802912235, -0.05151381343603134, 0.01582341268658638, -0.013596178032457829, 0.004916591104120016, 0.05046228691935539, 0.013115701265633106, -0.03297370672225952, -0.028761234134435654, -0.044987596571445465, -0.03774606063961983, 0.019977755844593048, -0.007321717217564583, 0.05025458335876465, -0.0234067440032959, -0.025664743036031723, 0.028597000986337662, 0.0628473088145256, 0.01243495661765337, -0.061561569571495056, -0.05484376847743988, -0.0812997967004776, -0.016462968662381172, 0.004424338694661856, -0.019741397351026535, 0.031322985887527466, 0.03208430856466293, 0.004559169057756662, -0.039405256509780884, 0.056404437869787216, -0.021979475393891335, -0.061612166464328766, -0.003014687681570649, -0.031466733664274216, 0.006263599265366793, 0.058321982622146606, -0.017231188714504242, -0.0614367239177227, 0.0037885624915361404, -0.07514936476945877, 0.0528113916516304, 0.003837087657302618, 0.032730087637901306, 0.004178307484835386, 0.0226618479937315, -0.02157425321638584, 0.0007790725212544203, -0.033292658627033234, 0.0015973264817148447, 0.14186786115169525, 0.08560198545455933, 0.06782663613557816, -0.04699910804629326, 0.00410322193056345, 0.011920121498405933, 0.01861647702753544, 0.0119738494977355, -0.027004960924386978, 0.008143221028149128, -0.027407081797719002, -0.004979326855391264, 0.043409936130046844, 0.015368783846497536, -0.0028448556549847126, -0.014360406436026096, -0.02268950641155243, -0.0064436085522174835, 0.02159055881202221, 0.004132844507694244, 0.00037640921073034406, -0.04526292160153389, -0.02385081723332405, 0.013424504548311234, 0.05277382582426071, -0.02607995830476284, -0.06575746834278107, -0.00573523947969079, -0.0014480164973065257, -0.004317035898566246, -0.010731884278357029, -0.014533469453454018, -0.03580641746520996, -0.00957820750772953, 0.020455598831176758, 0.01499925646930933, 0.0021834957879036665, -0.023678360506892204, -0.00817700196057558, 0.03001416102051735, 0.05012202635407448, 0.023266704753041267, -0.028317632153630257, 0.03988976031541824, -0.024895556271076202, -0.026990747079253197, -0.0344482846558094, 0.0435221865773201, -0.01784648187458515, -0.06908508390188217, 0.027293190360069275, 0.0184002835303545, -0.01131262257695198, -0.057794053107500076, -0.004275831859558821, 0.033739060163497925, -0.010272122919559479, -0.034878119826316833, -0.01362493634223938, 0.003955945372581482, 0.0016637666849419475, -0.02644096128642559, 0.0219125859439373, 0.005658366251736879, -0.03090059757232666, -0.011285576969385147, -0.06246325001120567, 0.015911445021629333, -0.016302447766065598, 0.056525830179452896, 0.008814356289803982, -0.022188611328601837, -0.018907414749264717, -0.04506566748023033, 0.0031089801341295242, 0.018400097265839577, 0.025519084185361862, -0.005123160779476166, -0.01257253997027874, -0.05370165780186653, -0.0586356446146965, 0.027423987165093422, 0.007069149054586887, 0.027245579287409782, -0.03995563089847565, -0.03294023871421814, 0.02943260781466961, 0.037219155579805374, 0.004343671258538961, 0.0038228435441851616, -0.018397236242890358, 0.02286642976105213, 0.015019205398857594, -0.048656415194272995, -0.010442845523357391, 0.006896483711898327, -0.05293808877468109, -0.009122813120484352, -0.02398843690752983, 0.05792376026511192, 0.03542732447385788, 0.05032758414745331, -0.01737663336098194, 0.02557697519659996, 0.028033673763275146, 0.004551341291517019, -0.008075575344264507, -0.01545912679284811, 0.06093570217490196, 0.02646741084754467, -0.01213223859667778, -0.042876407504081726, 0.010948768816888332, -0.0533117838203907, -0.06891870498657227, -0.024364689365029335, -0.03158114105463028, -0.05198919400572777, 0.010871079750359058, 0.004409288056194782, 0.007210134528577328, -0.016123225912451744, -0.015493561513721943, -0.03863067179918289, 0.009638709016144276, -0.013649933971464634, -0.005729189142584801, -0.014824657700955868, 0.026341840624809265, -0.04666341468691826, -0.01647130772471428, 0.008924276567995548, -0.020340656861662865, 0.006505242548882961, -0.01395321637392044, 0.008802050724625587, 0.023570138961076736, 0.01220019068568945, 0.008996169082820415, 0.007980846799910069, 0.004170823376625776, -0.06152739375829697, -0.010616565123200417, 0.010799746960401535, 0.016598723828792572, 0.022660929709672928, -0.0006737622315995395, -0.009756027720868587, -0.03769158571958542, 0.08009988814592361, -0.034899432212114334, -0.021396948024630547, -0.013413576409220695, 0.0057138665579259396, 0.03897008299827576, 0.040410153567790985, -0.0000419208372477442, 0.026797477155923843, 0.006949809845536947, 0.00978718139231205, 0.040573686361312866, -0.01412195060402155, -0.009472541511058807, -0.03062095120549202, -0.033566296100616455, 0.004878222942352295, -0.0032421292271465063, -0.015402987599372864, 0.0007843942730687559, 0.03791540488600731, 0.005332493223249912, 0.05533728748559952, -0.00038692817906849086, 0.016767891123890877, -0.13063016533851624, -0.03307833522558212, -0.012633107602596283, 0.04110985994338989, 0.010091840289533138, -0.05630071833729744, -0.01186009868979454, -0.0012557153822854161, -0.04325477033853531, 0.038809504359960556, 0.00491552846506238, 0.0007981710368767381, -0.014133411459624767, 0.017334209755063057, -0.0170066449791193, 0.014635657891631126, 0.06044498458504677, -0.017779890447854996, 0.016462385654449463, 0.013477586209774017, 0.016633503139019012, -0.007995645515620708, -0.03845119848847389, 0.027148349210619926, 0.007390595972537994, -0.010641773231327534, -0.019288666546344757, -0.04171375930309296, -0.010864410549402237, -0.011176316067576408, -0.015377926640212536, -0.006529965903609991, 0.04721640422940254, 0.023958995938301086, 0.021283267065882683, 0.039135295897722244, 0.029412461444735527, -0.013537279330193996, 0.0064376350492239, -0.023300986737012863, -0.0178702250123024, -0.007703691720962524, -0.02197299152612686, 0.044259555637836456, 0.021451542153954506, 0.00708976574242115, -0.0007019958575256169, -0.0016693193465471268, -0.027609817683696747, 0.003760780906304717, -0.01900453492999077, 0.018730437383055687, 0.027569426223635674, -0.02485354244709015, 0.019455894827842712, -0.0330154187977314, 0.026256762444972992, 0.02707044593989849, 0.054563429206609726, 0.00823418889194727, 0.04732338711619377, -0.01585768721997738, -0.03623168542981148, -0.0009420716087333858, 0.01704617217183113, 0.015290866605937481, -0.0657380148768425, -0.01562333945184946, 0.036398325115442276, -0.004134476650506258, -0.02090199664235115, 0.009791569784283638, -0.0508909672498703, 0.016113482415676117, -0.004075947217643261, -0.00369031960144639, 0.0419171005487442, 0.018714599311351776, 0.04072614759206772, -0.11374294012784958, 0.05368703231215477, 0.007499340455979109, -0.06132285296916962, -0.025837816298007965, 0.019916918128728867, -0.03801456093788147, 0.03783963993191719, 0.010951765812933445, 0.014193158596754074, 0.005345242563635111, -0.01735403575003147, 0.03469989821314812, -0.016903992742300034, -0.011488540098071098, 0.05436893552541733, 0.028940634801983833, 0.006591127719730139, -0.02241705358028412, 0.036062613129615784, 0.024262262508273125, 0.04014662653207779, 0.0011372007429599762, -0.011755458079278469, 0.0168549083173275, 0.017799746245145798, 0.0006228289566934109, 0.02728436142206192, -0.006112981121987104, -0.00127387885004282, 0.02159877121448517, 0.014220433309674263, -0.011931048706173897, 0.03231274336576462, 0.008965878747403622, -0.05867018178105354, 0.017025914043188095, -0.036780524998903275, -0.008276007138192654, 0.016370726749300957, -0.009044437669217587, -0.03350852057337761, -0.03286810219287872, 0.018311573192477226, -0.022683976218104362, 0.02421225793659687, -0.01468597911298275, 0.006852225866168737, 0.021454360336065292, 0.048023518174886703, 0.022760577499866486, 0.025706473737955093, -0.005631004925817251, -0.02433265745639801, 0.041550587862730026, 0.0008087138412520289, 0.015726208686828613, 0.018363473936915398, -0.025838578119874, 0.05415552854537964, -0.04219238832592964, 0.0006599933840334415, 0.004635507706552744, 0.07559444010257721, -0.027475519105792046, 0.014585799537599087, 0.004155803471803665, -0.049391619861125946, -0.018910661339759827, -0.015052419155836105, 0.009764804504811764, 0.043062109500169754, -0.035713907331228256, 0.0016068347031250596, -0.010197005234658718, 0.000661458121612668, -0.01084775011986494, 0.015551951713860035, 0.019763078540563583, 0.024966392666101456, 0.004962779115885496, -0.0010557821951806545, -0.002857827814295888, -0.0006283174152486026, -0.0008024632697924972, -0.01665458083152771, -0.018661580979824066, 0.005784609355032444, 0.007615022361278534, 0.013192151673138142, 0.00151166133582592, 0.001724022557027638, -0.007998301647603512, 0.05378201603889465, 0.031012680381536484, -0.006611182354390621, -0.025467565283179283, 0.009750345721840858, 0.025996778160333633, 0.06664237380027771, -0.03501154109835625, -0.03582701459527016, -0.004159005358815193, 0.03883714973926544, -0.0173500906676054, -0.0037269622553139925 ]
<p>I am currently reviewing some work and have come across the following, which seems wrong to me. Two mixed models are fitted (in R) using lmer. The models are non-nested and are compared by likelihood-ratio tests. In short, here is a reproducible example of what I have:</p> <pre><code>set.seed(105) Resp = rnorm(100) A = factor(rep(1:5,each=20)) B = factor(rep(1:2,times=50)) C = rep(1:4, times=25) m1 = lmer(Resp ~ A + (1|C), REML = TRUE) m2 = lmer(Resp ~ B + (1|C), REML = TRUE) anova(m1,m2) </code></pre> <p>As far as I can see, <code>lmer</code> is used to compute the log-likelihood and the <code>anova</code> statement tests the difference between the models using a chi-square with the usual degrees of freedom. This does not seem correct to me. If it is correct, does anyone know of any reference justifying this? I am aware of methods relying on simulations (Paper by Lewis et al., 2011) and the approach developed by Vuong (1989) but I do not think that this is what is produced here. I do not think that the use of the <code>anova</code> statement is correct.</p>
73,646
[ -0.023222917690873146, -0.014339214190840721, -0.018833303824067116, 0.0018594085704535246, 0.03268895670771599, 0.021608924493193626, 0.022880282253026962, -0.0012497601564973593, 0.04338030144572258, -0.020298069342970848, 0.017973734065890312, 0.06338126212358475, 0.07055217772722244, 0.011919820681214333, 0.04274102300405502, -0.01562616601586342, 0.00815166998654604, 0.000024097789719235152, 0.025101786479353905, -0.036647140979766846, -0.00905634369701147, 0.003169858595356345, 0.0004149627056904137, -0.023656286299228668, -0.024570472538471222, 0.026909109205007553, 0.012621374800801277, -0.06635487824678421, -0.014111618511378765, 0.035552702844142914, -0.01890719123184681, -0.0373939573764801, -0.021557874977588654, 0.0018480679718777537, -0.010316392406821251, -0.028313981369137764, -0.010762046091258526, -0.040810003876686096, 0.005774121265858412, 0.05096321180462837, -0.007076130714267492, -0.010858471505343914, -0.018913963809609413, 0.02335350774228573, 0.011914311908185482, 0.013856191188097, -0.0077562169171869755, 0.0011426345445215702, 0.05624109506607056, -0.039446037262678146, 0.059568140655756, 0.0076248482801020145, 0.02000243216753006, 0.03946138173341751, -0.031652919948101044, 0.005968458950519562, 0.04789223521947861, 0.06406602263450623, -0.008920940570533276, -0.08680729568004608, -0.014392037875950336, -0.039980802685022354, 0.0063506304286420345, 0.017224567010998726, -0.04682169854640961, -0.012489634566009045, 0.010223048739135265, -0.03200281411409378, 0.05622925981879234, 0.005586283281445503, 0.028747964650392532, 0.014204070903360844, 0.06690371781587601, -0.028034530580043793, 0.030627654865384102, -0.009428323246538639, 0.018208380788564682, -0.003225175430998206, -0.006917660124599934, 0.033411163836717606, -0.026468314230442047, 0.02255556546151638, 0.00762405339628458, 0.047197844833135605, 0.006907519418746233, -0.028467386960983276, 0.07439399510622025, -0.034303583204746246, -0.010632338933646679, 0.002498040208593011, -0.019445065408945084, 0.0055871158838272095, 0.043472472578287125, 0.022364582866430283, -0.06009920313954353, 0.05783212557435036, -0.014095584861934185, 0.028925927355885506, 0.0005548811750486493, -0.0235475804656744, -0.03696822375059128, -0.029750052839517593, 0.04747533053159714, 0.05341105908155441, -0.0036453320644795895, 0.014308846555650234, -0.015257157385349274, 0.017702605575323105, 0.017130829393863678, -0.01607789658010006, -0.027881184592843056, 0.03750748187303543, -0.023514535278081894, 0.011517709121108055, -0.0058576613664627075, -0.03898201510310173, -0.02683282643556595, -0.012077044695615768, 0.05590764805674553, 0.02653411217033863, 0.029874417930841446, -0.04522347450256348, 0.02886716090142727, -0.03351115062832832, -0.047916144132614136, -0.01073185633867979, -0.013796506449580193, 0.007793692406266928, -0.07119068503379822, 0.08087695389986038, -0.02890019863843918, 0.0011025660205632448, 0.020006274804472923, 0.03825856000185013, 0.010154622606933117, -0.027957214042544365, -0.0926235169172287, -0.07938068360090256, 0.029574284330010414, -0.008878846652805805, 0.04366360604763031, -0.09393245726823807, -0.017265016213059425, 0.014784852042794228, 0.08247749507427216, 0.02386466972529888, 0.021604804322123528, -0.011657404713332653, 0.05088835954666138, 0.018244856968522072, -0.0330268070101738, -0.009826377965509892, -0.043840717524290085, -0.018069595098495483, -0.016447721049189568, -0.10084955394268036, 0.014942923560738564, 0.010558810085058212, -0.0357213132083416, 0.012888146564364433, 0.022978167980909348, -0.012091082520782948, -0.00606074882671237, 0.0028238343074917793, 0.009529594331979752, -0.01224303338676691, 0.05512913316488266, -0.023785395547747612, 0.05308390036225319, 0.04404531419277191, -0.013126885518431664, -0.006387272849678993, 0.01514364406466484, 0.03566298261284828, 0.053977902978658676, -0.025707270950078964, 0.024424705654382706, -0.0010715043172240257, 0.05568477511405945, 0.016269057989120483, -0.05105164647102356, 0.010013681836426258, -0.02761302888393402, -0.00196441519074142, 0.007541003171354532, 0.03167785704135895, 0.006835631560534239, -0.028807617723941803, 0.0617360882461071, -0.044954653829336166, -0.027105918154120445, -0.05853860452771187, -0.019428305327892303, 0.01923329010605812, 0.0072164386510849, 0.01833474449813366, -0.01634114794433117, 0.03260939568281174, -0.0025060984771698713, -0.0245852991938591, -0.05372697860002518, -0.030612997710704803, 0.006433494389057159, -0.015272507444024086, 0.013342225924134254, 0.005287099629640579, 0.027358490973711014, -0.02009444311261177, 0.06520690768957138, -0.00397371593862772, -0.034520186483860016, 0.012443818151950836, -0.011852768249809742, -0.016078393906354904, 0.027372678741812706, -0.029849419370293617, -0.009820728562772274, 0.025103358551859856, -0.006147150415927172, 0.03948003798723221, -0.047781482338905334, 0.035715389996767044, 0.03606095537543297, 0.03792082890868187, -0.009452012367546558, 0.005347488448023796, 0.007213996257632971, 0.02126542292535305, -0.03377493470907211, 0.0019653807394206524, -0.05244915187358856, -0.008535505272448063, 0.0662267804145813, -0.010182991623878479, -0.039456598460674286, 0.01599668152630329, 0.02415894903242588, -0.004507869947701693, -0.008597247302532196, 0.030454644933342934, -0.02439301647245884, -0.03870672732591629, 0.0182099137455225, 0.06500083953142166, 0.018526436761021614, 0.03146352991461754, 0.006903801113367081, -0.009034174494445324, 0.01179477944970131, 0.002555151004344225, 0.001742885448038578, 0.04546240344643593, -0.03497583419084549, 0.012351141311228275, -0.034060265868902206, -0.017960170283913612, 0.03333393856883049, -0.0422358512878418, 0.006271683145314455, 0.03639497980475426, 0.01417718268930912, -0.002342105843126774, -0.01708046905696392, 0.012998727150261402, 0.035107534378767014, 0.02812846750020981, -0.02695290371775627, -0.0014133857330307364, 0.014053317718207836, 0.0016180594684556127, 0.0012623491929844022, -0.03685450553894043, -0.023622112348675728, -0.03854495659470558, 0.011943931691348553, -0.019503824412822723, -0.01832578331232071, 0.02505183033645153, -0.03308860585093498, -0.04121727868914604, 0.008507812395691872, -0.016895219683647156, 0.04095141962170601, -0.021817153319716454, -0.03437855839729309, 0.01039767637848854, -0.027521982789039612, 0.005019490607082844, -0.0016032379353418946, 0.0001390656252624467, -0.017868291586637497, 0.0035120691172778606, -0.012435957789421082, -0.03420323505997658, -0.02420639805495739, 0.017524683848023415, 0.0046636988408863544, 0.016008904203772545, 0.012997444719076157, 0.0325520820915699, 0.023598117753863335, -0.0014917480293661356, 0.03943707048892975, -0.03548283502459526, -0.03082181140780449, 0.003109324723482132, -0.005979299545288086, -0.014126836322247982, 0.008568602614104748, 0.036386098712682724, 0.0480213426053524, -0.013936563394963741, -0.013557004742324352, -0.06294290721416473, -0.0510060079395771, 0.0032830792479217052, -0.004597005434334278, 0.01879620924592018, 0.023558687418699265, -0.010737747885286808, 0.08022479712963104, 0.0005351363797672093, -0.006447839550673962, -0.04483276233077049, 0.00498358765617013, -0.008614876307547092, 0.006214607506990433, 0.0006720451056025922, 0.021034330129623413, -0.006916677579283714, 0.04139741510152817, -0.0031186994165182114, 0.011310608126223087, 0.04884837940335274, 0.01018825639039278, 0.013790293596684933, 0.0434071309864521, 0.025702347978949547, -0.04604945704340935, -0.0002915109507739544, -0.011492704041302204, -0.002028071554377675, 0.014214691706001759, 0.020253300666809082, 0.02055763453245163, 0.00594462500885129, -0.05386214703321457, 0.02578825131058693, -0.036641113460063934, -0.012497060932219028, -0.01709025353193283, 0.02263561263680458, 0.013624249957501888, -0.01978066749870777, 0.003994337283074856, 0.046832285821437836, 0.022207416594028473, -0.0028136170003563166, -0.02236592024564743, 0.030800001695752144, 0.03343404084444046, -0.014566381461918354, -0.0033321762457489967, 0.019419947639107704, -0.017482198774814606, 0.045670974999666214, -0.01959826610982418, 0.0023767759557813406, 0.0593443363904953, 0.01809384860098362, 0.015111641027033329, -0.008467169478535652, -0.05165118724107742, 0.019819946959614754, -0.06257347017526627, 0.037528473883867264, -0.04988839849829674, 0.03919880464673042, 0.0015314329648390412, 0.016987599432468414, 0.013477799482643604, -0.046216629445552826, -0.012265465222299099, -0.004778185859322548, -0.03957941010594368, 0.01718611642718315, -0.01845123991370201, -0.009014148265123367, -0.0024801664985716343, -0.011028658598661423, 0.019795667380094528, -0.01504940539598465, 0.00938069075345993, -0.019667746499180794, 0.011218118481338024, -0.0037723814602941275, 0.014684638008475304, -0.023044725880026817, -0.020507726818323135, -0.01869332790374756, 0.0002298197359777987, 0.0008976195240393281, 0.002085493877530098, 0.021987546235322952, 0.04176436364650726, 0.0033602069597691298, 0.0000906281202333048, -0.003982021007686853, 0.005550174042582512, 0.0227279681712389, 0.00914501678198576, 0.023615626618266106, 0.014536491595208645, -0.060479775071144104, 0.03021468222141266, 0.01330532506108284, 0.02998538129031658, 0.04784413054585457, -0.020909305661916733, -0.009800945408642292, -0.0007700223359279335, -0.046066705137491226, 0.033976152539253235, -0.006183634512126446, 0.0202944278717041, 0.02114890329539776, 0.057507727295160294, 0.059309594333171844, 0.003805924206972122, 0.01706141233444214, 0.08285941183567047, -0.016467319801449776, -0.008413943462073803, -0.02474256046116352, 0.007003188133239746, -0.02956024557352066, 0.004621358122676611, 0.021207613870501518, -0.02862662263214588, 0.032592855393886566, -0.01805984601378441, 0.05936233699321747, 0.004923541564494371, -0.018845615908503532, -0.007797330152243376, 0.018033530563116074, 0.014323145151138306, 0.0005833558971062303, -0.030362119898200035, 0.011597638949751854, 0.032261330634355545, 0.03578609228134155, 0.04579321667551994, -0.021693162620067596, -0.10227413475513458, 0.010329746641218662, 0.0557914674282074, 0.014951827935874462, -0.039803486317396164, 0.0010875455336645246, 0.0005303717334754765, 0.007350202649831772, -0.00873201247304678, -0.021206850185990334, 0.04980330169200897, -0.011430102400481701, 0.02255074493587017, -0.027503617107868195, -0.017571058124303818, -0.020859377458691597, 0.02107396349310875, -0.02645447850227356, -0.008340195752680302, 0.006530379876494408, -0.03865089267492294, -0.03523075580596924, 0.01848568022251129, 0.022746821865439415, 0.007086784578859806, -0.04311302304267883, -0.03598574921488762, 0.005624134559184313, 0.012005968950688839, -0.030929600819945335, -0.030736323446035385, 0.052241116762161255, -0.013743970543146133, -0.0005586378974840045, 0.06633640825748444, -0.007500331848859787, -0.033492185175418854, 0.032860200852155685, 0.02543705143034458, -0.0026030470617115498, -0.014064304530620575, -0.005373308435082436, 0.044834960252046585, 0.02584683895111084, 0.007174754049628973, 0.05680268257856369, 0.015913695096969604, -0.03297329321503639, 0.002909078262746334, -0.03769843280315399, 0.02443847246468067, -0.03823016956448555, -0.016271770000457764, -0.07019317150115967, 0.0055874488316476345, -0.02227611653506756, 0.04759969189763069, 0.03190751001238823, 0.04424470290541649, -0.05524356663227081, -0.022069860249757767, -0.005216437857598066, 0.005947405938059092, -0.03416314721107483, -0.017349891364574432, 0.03081723302602768, 0.02061953954398632, 0.007585807703435421, -0.00524316867813468, 0.04170414060354233, -0.046902380883693695, -0.01766250468790531, 0.003367263823747635, -0.0381181500852108, 0.00459359772503376, -0.01160760410130024, -0.038023144006729126, 0.018462728708982468, -0.008345769718289375, 0.029555438086390495, 0.028622431680560112, 0.005708263721317053, -0.038002777844667435, -0.06553618609905243, -0.006987927481532097, 0.026072360575199127, -0.023243479430675507, 0.04870683699846268, -0.03972070291638374, 0.010406509973108768, -0.00768221914768219, -0.01048959419131279, -0.055560242384672165, -0.028297901153564453, 0.0061667910777032375, -0.0032024276442825794, -0.006191308610141277, -0.035517092794179916, -0.06061156094074249, -0.01540452055633068, -0.007290687412023544, -0.01097466703504324, 0.07090546935796738, -0.046360861510038376, 0.019709957763552666, 0.0005694965948350728, 0.03500630706548691, 0.06858090311288834, 0.021758414804935455, -0.004033839330077171, 0.0018240796634927392, -0.0064159478060901165, 0.006579341366887093, 0.02057943493127823, 0.01213068887591362, -0.05894161015748978, 0.015023313462734222, -0.01996244676411152, 0.051465604454278946, 0.07952367514371872, -0.0002471855259500444, -0.04776891693472862, 0.055587973445653915, -0.006327423732727766, 0.037019047886133194, -0.047976210713386536, -0.009365807287395, -0.03494051843881607, 0.010774826630949974, -0.022143907845020294, 0.023057779297232628, 0.001018039183691144, 0.00741212721914053, 0.05376351624727249, -0.034991323947906494, -0.01629297435283661, 0.011603312566876411, 0.08312458544969559, -0.022876257076859474, 0.0015201802598312497, -0.02227165922522545, 0.002806915668770671, 0.02414940483868122, 0.008417445234954357, 0.03899136558175087, 0.045819930732250214, 0.04870050400495529, -0.01375526562333107, -0.01434436347335577, -0.021320657804608345, -0.011713823303580284, 0.06268870830535889, 0.0007905907114036381, 0.036900460720062256, 0.03155188262462616, -0.025135956704616547, 0.02090294472873211, -0.024745957925915718, -0.0464777834713459, 0.02086438611149788, 0.01737487129867077, 0.06496500968933105, -0.03838228061795235, -0.013222998939454556, 0.04667221009731293, -0.009771669283509254, 0.008496096357703209, 0.02923717349767685, 0.007171222940087318, 0.024521976709365845, 0.0009864364983513951, 0.03243403881788254, -0.028207354247570038, 0.06861592829227448, -0.037484340369701385, 0.03965262323617935, -0.06145235896110535, -0.002994194393977523, 0.04429090395569801, 0.04369564354419708, 0.0024620569311082363, -0.055665772408246994, -0.01969914697110653, -0.07076580077409744, 0.014395098201930523, 0.003710208460688591, 0.0020365219097584486, 0.032201722264289856, -0.03635508567094803, 0.022571232169866562, 0.02842865139245987, 0.005024397745728493, -0.029521394520998, -0.06713341921567917, -0.034191299229860306, -0.008243299089372158, 0.008581281639635563, 0.022921379655599594, -0.025439631193876266, -0.018604770302772522, 0.032308828085660934, -0.027897868305444717, 0.017916033044457436, -0.017749110236763954, 0.029424790292978287, -0.00495013827458024, 0.05899553373456001, 0.005725367460399866, 0.0334153026342392, -0.039509281516075134, -0.027865132316946983, 0.0935790166258812, 0.07344318181276321, 0.023872068151831627, -0.07015296071767807, 0.08200923353433609, -0.008788743987679482, 7.117415066204558e-7, 0.0052930559031665325, -0.007702734787017107, 0.01120824832469225, -0.017924640327692032, 0.016945596784353256, 0.07705125957727432, 0.012407879345119, -0.009087647311389446, 0.04601939395070076, -0.01836136169731617, -0.039968203753232956, 0.006007886957377195, -0.006122715305536985, -0.012865972705185413, -0.04512728378176689, -0.020900219678878784, -0.03355497121810913, 0.015329983085393906, -0.010920124128460884, -0.0052698771469295025, -0.007965545170009136, -0.012015029788017273, -0.0006558545283041894, -0.027595454826951027, 0.028041286394000053, -0.002840996254235506, -0.008437702432274818, 0.0016285519814118743, -0.0057599362917244434, 0.018301980569958687, -0.006658651866018772, 0.017571376636624336, 0.06210711970925331, 0.005218883510679007, -0.022918013855814934, 0.01130448468029499, 0.006532555446028709, -0.05105210095643997, -0.02004576474428177, -0.032541826367378235, 0.026124009862542152, -0.022832559421658516, -0.004462623968720436, -0.005521724000573158, -0.019880525767803192, -0.010890662670135498, 0.0033890684135258198, -0.000017783637304091826, 0.030252277851104736, 0.0076782312244176865, -0.010153311304748058, 0.010184327140450478, -0.049411606043577194, 0.026797110214829445, 0.015524346381425858, 0.03556361049413681, 0.024524686858057976, -0.009205183945596218, 0.014974996447563171, -0.03609053045511246, 0.04299348592758179, -0.03527721390128136, 0.034628964960575104, 0.000011350449312885758, 0.008184840902686119, -0.03824488818645477, -0.03774295002222061, 0.008826684206724167, 0.029209010303020477, 0.046538010239601135, -0.019316017627716064, -0.020760975778102875, -0.017634926363825798, -0.09307081997394562, 0.019671235233545303, -0.006529549136757851, -0.015736928209662437, -0.04577302187681198, -0.003664559219032526, 0.04417422041296959, 0.026379331946372986, -0.013628771528601646, 0.01404044684022665, -0.01684906892478466, 0.06590200960636139, -0.01493520475924015, -0.09487669169902802, -0.027341125532984734, 0.0030888463370501995, -0.026219772174954414, -0.03484306484460831, -0.021046290174126625, 0.0322684645652771, 0.012116525322198868, 0.048086702823638916, -0.0064927139319479465, 0.045196570456027985, -0.01675860770046711, -0.0003717124927788973, 0.015135814435780048, -0.019000524654984474, -0.026340631768107414, 0.0023702566977590322, -0.0000500036112498492, 0.005631501320749521, -0.026721863076090813, -0.062354207038879395, -0.0661713033914566, 0.03562544658780098, -0.020271608605980873, -0.033379048109054565, -0.02621183730661869, -0.011552843265235424, -0.03542118892073631, -0.015252549201250076, -0.00656959367915988, -0.02203616313636303, -0.025317221879959106, 0.020847119390964508, -0.012306971475481987, -0.013628912158310413, 0.03061784990131855, -0.023231934756040573, 0.012843998149037361, 0.040204353630542755, 0.002183736301958561, 0.027976850047707558, -0.01774667575955391, -0.007646144833415747, 0.008889921009540558, 0.03660978004336357, -0.030715305358171463, -0.03659321740269661, 0.02031012997031212, -0.027986913919448853, -0.04544545337557793, -0.007259013596922159, -0.011852337047457695, 0.008127621375024319, 0.00007380292663583532, 0.009157252497971058, -0.030261212959885597, 0.03656608983874321, -0.011509811505675316, -0.019722886383533478, -0.034725286066532135, -0.01876048371195793, 0.0456872433423996, -0.02557832933962345, -0.007974902167916298, 0.003358494257554412, -0.0006222797674126923, 0.06910263746976852, 0.05699934810400009, 0.01825130172073841, -0.009260168299078941, -0.013939199037849903, -0.012447105720639229, 0.08690846711397171, 0.004718033596873283, 0.008647005073726177, 0.042469702661037445, 0.044204771518707275, -0.008085045032203197, 0.01680922694504261, -0.03540249168872833, 0.01421179436147213, -0.08703973144292831, -0.03458276391029358, -0.017868539318442345, 0.011667313985526562, -0.0031680548563599586, -0.052737683057785034, 0.011045129969716072, 0.015056905336678028, -0.03867729380726814, -0.03671320155262947, -0.0014519502874463797, -0.024729778990149498, -0.045590512454509735, -0.0257598627358675, -0.038711998611688614, 0.004765491001307964, 0.003687936346977949, -0.0054369415156543255, 0.028346367180347443, -0.03118593990802765, 0.010197888128459454, -0.01996232569217682, -0.000056587457947898656, 0.018001588061451912, 0.0409562885761261, -0.060915492475032806, 0.04297342523932457, -0.0197269506752491, -0.04991905391216278, 0.030221082270145416, -0.008276725187897682, 0.03325384855270386, 0.0157338697463274, 0.0419803224503994, 0.04545798897743225, 0.03826439380645752, 0.037656720727682114, 0.02822166681289673, 0.003424466820433736, 0.0013905769446864724, 0.004724017344415188, 0.022523723542690277, -0.05065549165010452, 0.013150032609701157, 0.019877323880791664, -0.012827708385884762, -0.042965177446603775, 0.0032395501621067524, -0.04200620949268341, -0.00010957947233691812, -0.036734215915203094, -0.03257839009165764, 0.011793770827353, -0.00630355067551136, 0.00019337964477017522, -0.0552753247320652, 0.020241836085915565, 0.03954483941197395, 0.046186767518520355, -0.024241989478468895, 0.024837350472807884, -0.027171296998858452, -0.006005062256008387, -0.019168680533766747, 0.01372698973864317, -0.008604024536907673, -0.026337523013353348, -0.018596073612570763, 0.010050565004348755, -0.016407035291194916, -0.026083411648869514, -0.006383334286510944, -0.013144347816705704, -0.0011581482831388712, -0.019267801195383072, 0.02524821273982525, 0.001360392663627863, 0.009609050117433071, 0.035247962921857834, -0.08831878006458282, 0.08929812163114548, 0.0027607043739408255, -0.01799333095550537, -0.05215765908360481, -0.022198500111699104, -0.00047848717076703906, 0.01103898510336876, 0.055708564817905426, 0.03516112640500069, 0.019577035680413246, 0.0016970235155895352, 0.04857085272669792, -0.004707838408648968, -0.03677669167518616, 0.02306329272687435, -0.0007118909270502627, 0.009994766674935818, -0.0028102139476686716, -0.0368773378431797, -0.01937960460782051, -0.01254795491695404, 0.017328867688775063, -0.009324108250439167, -0.02098771743476391, -0.0148673290386796, -0.012545890174806118, 0.03010619804263115, -0.00580236129462719, -0.04569366201758385, 0.06513261049985886, 0.00441108550876379, 0.026196319609880447, 0.02980036661028862, 0.03573917970061302, -0.054070670157670975, 0.03863188251852989, -0.03435913845896721, 0.003416571067646146, 0.007019522599875927, -0.0003290145832579583, 0.0032146263401955366, -0.03528900071978569, 0.01682891510426998, 0.014778963290154934, -0.04211472347378731, -0.024936586618423462, 0.03183427080512047, 0.054850827902555466, 0.038898784667253494, 0.016870569437742233, 0.02033320441842079, 0.018928611651062965, -0.022801870480179787, -0.019874947145581245, 0.03274546191096306, 0.05492251366376877, -0.01273905485868454, -0.021690428256988525, 0.01905163750052452, -0.02427067421376705, 0.017907947301864624, -0.02418002113699913, 0.06539329141378403, 0.022732924669981003, -0.008771768771111965, 0.026825595647096634, -0.02434813790023327, 0.021704062819480896, 0.0022329422645270824, -0.03631086274981499, 0.057566527277231216, -0.04200194776058197, 0.023159209638834, -0.001561925164423883, -0.009537670761346817, 0.01194799318909645, 0.013045815750956535, 0.055956654250621796, 0.016607636585831642, 0.03276624530553818, 0.0009626710671000183, 0.0001878031180240214, -0.05289459601044655, 0.012519474141299725, 0.0007502043736167252, 0.012294112704694271, -0.014781582169234753, -0.0055105481296777725, -0.011119077913463116, -0.03578633815050125, -0.009404376149177551, -0.04327283054590225, 0.03983724117279053, -0.007520369254052639, 0.0451868437230587, -0.06403763592243195, -0.0462440550327301, 0.02011844702064991, 0.04672030732035637, -0.03161117434501648, -0.003604792756959796, -0.043175093829631805, 0.025044679641723633, 0.03791124001145363, -0.04477864131331444 ]
<p>I am trying to learn some statistics using the book, Biometry by Sokal and Rohlf (3e). This is an exercise in the 5th chapter which covers probability, the binomial distribution, and Poisson distribution. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/T0Tth.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I realize there is a formula to produce an answer to this question: $$ n = \frac 4 {( \sqrt{p} - \sqrt{q} )^2} $$ However, this equation is not in this text. I'd like to know how to calculate sample size knowing only the probability, the desired level of confidence, and the binomial distribution. Are there any resources covering this topic that I can be pointed to? I've tried Google, but what I've seen so far requires information I don't have access to in this problem.</p>
73,647
[ -0.019964125007390976, -0.061192624270915985, 0.02153594419360161, 0.009296062402427197, 0.025792423635721207, -0.003847312880679965, 0.00727153941988945, -0.03007061779499054, 0.009846106171607971, -0.006754325237125158, 0.02432606928050518, 0.06393694877624512, 0.055234264582395554, 0.015549161471426487, -0.00953096617013216, 0.026059841737151146, -0.027966488152742386, -0.0003841939615085721, -0.016408387571573257, -0.033520523458719254, 0.011979135684669018, 0.028355231508612633, 0.029119472950696945, -0.017950918525457382, -0.030369911342859268, 0.04496811330318451, 0.04487209394574165, -0.015146030113101006, 0.0021228052210062742, 0.06753972917795181, -0.041104111820459366, -0.008143844082951546, 0.044911060482263565, 0.047679975628852844, -0.015494746156036854, -0.018661927431821823, -0.028690287843346596, -0.05684123933315277, 0.008658649399876595, 0.019438080489635468, -0.05799044296145439, 0.0072108786553144455, 0.010826858691871166, -0.008654025383293629, -0.0037497475277632475, 0.027206728234887123, 0.011892353184521198, -0.0758357122540474, 0.014812561683356762, -0.07798577845096588, 0.07346393913030624, 0.045714545994997025, 0.036926429718732834, 0.01609828695654869, 0.01041355635970831, -0.0025362845044583082, 0.02386557310819626, 0.06638635694980621, -0.014088811352849007, -0.053571220487356186, -0.032991454005241394, -0.05313283950090408, 0.0019632012117654085, -0.05676228553056717, -0.058748506009578705, -0.02156984992325306, -0.035823605954647064, -0.029829194769263268, 0.03584188595414162, -0.022893566638231277, 0.03588659688830376, 0.03973977640271187, 0.07479268312454224, 0.004970226902514696, -0.032964836806058884, -0.011033128947019577, 0.008649807423353195, 0.016785185784101486, 0.04156631976366043, -0.00446012569591403, -0.008976658806204796, 0.018341446295380592, 0.009799103252589703, 0.027721542865037918, 0.003733058925718069, -0.02932792343199253, 0.06720969080924988, -0.014019294641911983, 0.01672460325062275, 0.006185936741530895, -0.029275083914399147, -0.0076983533799648285, 0.048248130828142166, -0.015234576538205147, -0.005812298506498337, 0.018069108948111534, -0.03880158066749573, 0.04579756036400795, -0.0163405891507864, -0.03753548488020897, 0.01404144149273634, -0.04929226636886597, 0.002670006128028035, 0.07188762724399567, -0.030863158404827118, -0.01753067597746849, 0.0030093363020569086, -0.0042996713891625404, 0.012031005695462227, 0.00009902017336571589, 0.01771419681608677, 0.027146870270371437, 0.024656586349010468, 0.005000663455575705, -0.008930135518312454, -0.019371287897229195, -0.00333219300955534, -0.0009655270841903985, 0.06522568315267563, 0.05001039803028107, 0.018011530861258507, 0.0018033816013485193, 0.0412922203540802, -0.03214361518621445, -0.02617374248802662, 0.029052870348095894, -0.014037198387086391, -0.009690707549452782, -0.05784153938293457, 0.04069065302610397, 0.0231828261166811, 0.0009107827791012824, 0.03197776898741722, 0.022664308547973633, 0.02607625536620617, 0.008840509690344334, -0.0739557072520256, -0.01641712710261345, 0.041131243109703064, -0.03425616770982742, 0.028962355107069016, -0.08003804087638855, 0.04831400513648987, 0.046336643397808075, 0.03162884712219238, -0.0015593930147588253, 0.03797146677970886, -0.010321052744984627, 0.023974943906068802, 0.04180475324392319, -0.03191861882805824, 0.038114238530397415, -0.06497668474912643, 0.0037756990641355515, 0.0156810712069273, -0.0736861601471901, 0.048504915088415146, 0.0017745370278134942, 0.03361601382493973, -0.0538201630115509, 0.04654427245259285, -0.004371929913759232, -0.02782745473086834, -0.01438449788838625, -0.001555177615955472, -0.024035638198256493, 0.08430885523557663, 0.005489574279636145, -0.03803400695323944, -0.022729648277163506, 0.01943943090736866, 0.006389559246599674, 0.03921237960457802, 0.027713214978575706, 0.04217163100838661, -0.02509712427854538, -0.0036188242956995964, -0.01670643873512745, 0.0003582496428862214, 0.027181224897503853, -0.0009257462806999683, -0.0058406502939760685, 0.02589799091219902, 0.013699990697205067, 0.021653752774000168, 0.03896065801382065, 0.01753896474838257, -0.01118435338139534, 0.016569355502724648, 0.003415868617594242, -0.031295180320739746, -0.048965319991111755, 0.020401179790496826, 0.033663827925920486, -0.0158829465508461, 0.0027383265551179647, 0.03141418844461441, 0.011217993684113026, -0.014081692323088646, -0.036467842757701874, -0.022430740296840668, -0.0005678263260051608, 0.020629441365599632, -0.053157202899456024, 0.01733449287712574, 0.05640929564833641, 0.03675622493028641, -0.007855566218495369, 0.048263195902109146, -0.027675680816173553, -0.03201043978333473, -0.013867502100765705, -0.048172011971473694, 0.018396446481347084, -0.023827534168958664, -0.03171840310096741, 0.014672421850264072, -0.004486916586756706, 0.0016710470663383603, 0.04029107093811035, -0.03241771459579468, 0.07529722154140472, 0.013378862291574478, 0.024666309356689453, 0.012167193926870823, -0.011138352565467358, 0.018947016447782516, -0.0025861752219498158, -0.03349002078175545, -0.009281829930841923, -0.04818018153309822, 0.02427891455590725, 0.04058351740241051, -0.020342642441391945, -0.028791518881917, -0.00003665865006041713, 0.04494009166955948, 0.009081072174012661, 0.02380990795791149, 0.005015342961996794, -0.01009493600577116, -0.027378933504223824, -0.0101759759709239, 0.04376588389277458, -0.017489811405539513, 0.017810486257076263, -0.020701711997389793, 0.007347702980041504, 0.0441521592438221, 0.00727062625810504, -0.020502163097262383, 0.045053720474243164, -0.0010918808402493596, 0.02649153210222721, -0.032673828303813934, -0.01413324661552906, 0.04057862237095833, -0.021284544840455055, -0.008429603651165962, 0.043218906968832016, 0.005014599766582251, -0.00015767739387229085, 0.00952838733792305, -0.03693137317895889, 0.03292735666036606, 0.038399070501327515, -0.053851693868637085, 0.0039681000635027885, -0.004989699926227331, -0.04730267450213432, -0.012076243758201599, -0.00405129324644804, -0.04534723982214928, -0.023814402520656586, -0.013778463006019592, 0.001123748137615621, 0.003221070859581232, 0.019439654424786568, 0.00704147620126605, -0.032495494931936264, 0.001579263829626143, 0.01381723303347826, 0.006142744328826666, -0.018142756074666977, -0.07202450931072235, -0.031599659472703934, -0.02555907890200615, -0.04401816055178642, 0.009748618118464947, -0.019283514469861984, -0.0025308753829449415, 0.01930535025894642, -0.014078170992434025, -0.0008182763122022152, 0.007692522834986448, -0.020665399730205536, -0.02916705794632435, -0.02841491624712944, 0.009139860980212688, 0.021566323935985565, 0.022131700068712234, -0.007054448127746582, 0.03622981160879135, -0.031315792351961136, -0.04146404564380646, -0.03381973132491112, 0.025954458862543106, 0.02938785031437874, -0.02532275952398777, -0.004172292537987232, 0.02213432267308235, 0.001463558990508318, -0.012956899590790272, -0.051559388637542725, -0.07948121428489685, -0.0012360218679532409, 0.022390954196453094, 0.04495660960674286, 0.005311259999871254, -0.025165019556879997, 0.07101614773273468, 0.00709972670301795, -0.019768530502915382, 0.0074495188891887665, 0.020552983507514, -0.03336898609995842, 0.0020399370696395636, 0.006482166703790426, 0.0186528991907835, -0.010529634542763233, 0.02718459442257881, -0.019782012328505516, 0.0097196651622653, 0.04647834599018097, -0.0028041379991918802, -0.004256910178810358, 0.028585540130734444, -0.00010330740769859403, -0.004500558599829674, 0.01550004817545414, 0.01885431818664074, -0.05428013578057289, 0.0229315385222435, -0.009515294805169106, 0.005765135399997234, -0.0016160659724846482, -0.04268261045217514, 0.017033953219652176, -0.023066408932209015, -0.021004680544137955, -0.0588085763156414, 0.03759700804948807, -0.007282230071723461, -0.020150773227214813, 0.032216381281614304, 0.02653600089251995, 0.026246750727295876, -0.03135199472308159, -0.0033313296735286713, 0.04963366687297821, 0.04266238212585449, -0.014221219345927238, -0.01618017442524433, -0.009136701934039593, -0.030708884820342064, 0.010596475563943386, -0.012000134214758873, -0.02957810088992119, 0.012069162912666798, 0.04837499186396599, 0.03181782364845276, 0.00464991107583046, 0.011961323209106922, -0.00560643058270216, -0.05374288558959961, -0.0319414846599102, -0.0064347488805651665, 0.02923022024333477, -0.005977022461593151, 0.0359795056283474, 0.011921849101781845, -0.01596374623477459, 0.01146981492638588, 0.034109704196453094, -0.05229166895151138, 0.045130934566259384, -0.049194782972335815, -0.03568533435463905, 0.00938041228801012, 0.012334520928561687, 0.03030860424041748, 0.00805964320898056, 0.012076709419488907, -0.0019006391521543264, 0.02266395092010498, -0.0249775480479002, 0.020891398191452026, -0.021580789238214493, 0.013436839915812016, 0.011358499526977539, 0.051579076796770096, -0.01729804463684559, -0.014021938666701317, 0.022910384461283684, 0.051656294614076614, 0.0012491742381826043, -0.0210324227809906, -0.008961746469140053, 0.014297135174274445, -0.0005981656722724438, 0.03491568937897682, 0.033397283405065536, 0.014268498867750168, -0.038686152547597885, -0.005151867400854826, -0.03210556134581566, 0.04566437005996704, 0.028440967202186584, 0.008322479203343391, 0.015352364629507065, -0.023279860615730286, 0.010585798881947994, -0.007709791883826256, -0.021162163466215134, 0.003034267108887434, 0.006646520458161831, 0.055633168667554855, -0.011690552346408367, -0.06545108556747437, 0.013569786213338375, 0.08197212964296341, -0.007764177396893501, 0.012666921131312847, -0.06109647825360298, 0.027172794565558434, -0.02687838301062584, 0.000846651557367295, 0.012654837220907211, 0.04529302939772606, 0.012062054127454758, 0.003550878958776593, 0.06592554599046707, -0.00533366808667779, -0.03817795589566231, -0.0017476854845881462, -0.004352532792836428, 0.04300186410546303, -0.01962856389582157, -0.03785896301269531, 0.019598746672272682, 0.008872587233781815, 0.0324355848133564, -0.011047987267374992, -0.019649816676974297, -0.06844346970319748, -0.012784277088940144, 0.010674085468053818, 0.04957187548279762, -0.039750486612319946, 0.01293321792036295, -0.05845979228615761, -0.0060957069508731365, 0.03318193182349205, -0.04714301601052284, 0.013037392869591713, -0.02092927135527134, 0.025540176779031754, -0.02552834153175354, -0.005386746022850275, -0.04174919053912163, -0.012566708028316498, -0.018877549096941948, 0.008885597810149193, -0.020696451887488365, -0.010290764272212982, -0.014281315729022026, 0.03694029897451401, 0.02255401387810707, 0.08941718190908432, -0.043236903846263885, -0.023402400314807892, 0.012959258630871773, 0.012463358230888844, -0.0460556335747242, -0.03477872535586357, 0.011560134589672089, -0.036039501428604126, 0.017251621931791306, 0.03156028315424919, -0.020900502800941467, -0.07173551619052887, 0.026403626427054405, -0.002782014198601246, -0.031599611043930054, -0.008048294112086296, -0.04398256540298462, 0.030829766765236855, 0.001185581204481423, 0.02216445468366146, 0.11250592023134232, -0.000480152724776417, 0.011111744679510593, 0.0016288455808535218, -0.058163825422525406, 0.03311367705464363, -0.025566956028342247, -0.05243266001343727, -0.049591779708862305, 0.03078410029411316, -0.019671253859996796, 0.03171519562602043, -0.031790535897016525, 0.0168303195387125, -0.03149186447262764, -0.021564211696386337, 0.008510671555995941, -0.01154608465731144, 0.053567469120025635, 0.03478582948446274, -0.013982340693473816, 0.0012840144336223602, 0.005884935148060322, -0.007038789801299572, 0.01978193037211895, -0.008190217427909374, -0.0047073932364583015, -0.007307648658752441, -0.022143667563796043, -0.0032401413191109896, -0.030092447996139526, -0.059825338423252106, 0.012707472778856754, -0.04193512722849846, 0.06305450201034546, -0.028758561238646507, 0.015742290765047073, -0.003828546265140176, -0.07476240396499634, -0.04666552320122719, -0.006096457131206989, 0.0008190622320398688, 0.05062658712267876, -0.07445544749498367, -0.0003727461735252291, 0.00450265733525157, 0.018704818561673164, -0.0555851086974144, -0.042024023830890656, 0.028582274913787842, 0.0009484727634117007, -0.002394275041297078, -0.0419522300362587, -0.03224094957113266, 0.026728272438049316, -0.03334387019276619, -0.008100727573037148, 0.00841287150979042, 0.004418238531798124, -0.02081627957522869, -0.039622992277145386, 0.04269875958561897, 0.039317965507507324, 0.015687385573983192, -0.011057880707085133, -0.004387045279145241, -0.026126094162464142, -0.02364645153284073, 0.01997363567352295, 0.01086180005222559, -0.02129252627491951, -0.02448292449116707, -0.03876291215419769, 0.011674875393509865, 0.03580664098262787, -0.057707734405994415, -0.03995773196220398, -0.027851486578583717, 0.044534727931022644, 0.01135511789470911, -0.04282115772366524, -0.018752219155430794, 0.022192690521478653, 0.04742114618420601, -0.024088414385914803, 0.009311043657362461, 0.008492021821439266, -0.0004189169849269092, 0.030913880094885826, 0.005090325605124235, -0.00639227544888854, 0.025803446769714355, 0.07846258580684662, -0.016458621248602867, -0.009178604930639267, 0.0013994687469676137, -0.028896639123558998, 0.03434110805392265, 0.0492534302175045, -0.018534129485487938, 0.04134615510702133, 0.03109024651348591, -0.026907870545983315, -0.0307136420160532, -0.0773509293794632, 0.017681999132037163, 0.056984104216098785, -0.002445872640237212, 0.05194094777107239, 0.05881723016500473, 0.011963803321123123, 0.018607473000884056, 0.031835369765758514, -0.023106785491108894, -0.006180428899824619, 0.0168934166431427, 0.06219187006354332, 0.002711648354306817, -0.006632382981479168, 0.03602946549654007, 0.01497978437691927, 0.008546543307602406, 0.04422837868332863, 0.020332682877779007, 0.043376218527555466, 0.0013483983930200338, -0.025087740272283554, -0.024352703243494034, 0.024370742961764336, -0.04753531888127327, 0.025063570588827133, -0.04239945858716965, -0.014661135151982307, 0.052784137427806854, 0.029700931161642075, 0.0057494863867759705, -0.04064201936125755, -0.03597043827176094, 0.0012436292599886656, 0.0011696511646732688, 0.033737294375896454, 0.002666781423613429, 0.015428620390594006, 0.02076921984553337, 0.001363188261166215, -0.006413182243704796, 0.0500616617500782, 0.009583949111402035, -0.051597822457551956, -0.03774035722017288, -0.017257818952202797, -0.048001546412706375, 0.01853184401988983, -0.011059759184718132, -0.01899511180818081, 0.04271255061030388, -0.018867580220103264, 0.03834505379199982, 0.0014243461191654205, 0.02663392201066017, -0.026723116636276245, 0.07972002029418945, 0.02073136903345585, -0.011117092333734035, 0.018233686685562134, 0.04130314290523529, 0.11227267235517502, 0.0957004502415657, 0.01870686002075672, -0.047171175479888916, 0.025942547246813774, -0.00485329469665885, 0.007783327717334032, -0.017240101471543312, 0.0056162611581385136, -0.022375114262104034, -0.015607548877596855, 0.0533536858856678, 0.028826192021369934, 0.011674467474222183, -0.023847121745347977, 0.06006646156311035, 0.0024914832320064306, -0.05812033638358116, 0.007179416250437498, 0.0020362292416393757, -0.01867193728685379, 0.005265760235488415, -0.013497773557901382, 0.003251143265515566, 0.028208108618855476, -0.021543949842453003, -0.047158148139715195, -0.002260735258460045, -0.03507304936647415, -0.006382238119840622, -0.016651738435029984, -0.0048972791992127895, 0.01703818328678608, -0.01100711990147829, -0.01747802086174488, -0.020272785797715187, 0.002391830552369356, -0.035065364092588425, -0.005552059505134821, 0.037352848798036575, -0.002037340309470892, 0.026921506971120834, 0.006716452073305845, 0.022456353530287743, -0.03857610374689102, -0.03343738615512848, -0.024683278053998947, 0.020716650411486626, 0.010329116135835648, 0.03478722274303436, -0.012190715409815311, 0.00847367662936449, -0.003975325264036655, -0.045305363833904266, -0.004086506552994251, 0.0019012894481420517, 0.04607481509447098, -0.053974490612745285, -0.02475905232131481, -0.005077631678432226, 0.017173252999782562, 0.01397194154560566, 0.017333336174488068, 0.055415332317352295, -0.01219102181494236, -0.020894337445497513, -0.01980983279645443, -0.004665617365390062, -0.015768298879265785, 0.004523771349340677, -0.019062308594584465, -0.015740228816866875, -0.027299227192997932, 0.0038747808430343866, 0.024018609896302223, 0.011760471388697624, 0.0594816617667675, -0.01644347608089447, -0.04603169485926628, 0.004579569678753614, -0.03085543029010296, 0.023355742916464806, -0.022205287590622902, -0.015510909259319305, -0.018995631486177444, -0.0018691591685637832, 0.004660437814891338, 0.03482184186577797, -0.044130876660346985, 0.03371819481253624, -0.0072402553632855415, 0.020988812670111656, 0.035284966230392456, -0.028827976435422897, 0.03307371586561203, 0.03631601855158806, -0.015606250613927841, -0.012750769034028053, -0.013442475348711014, 0.024430282413959503, 0.029342826455831528, 0.035406872630119324, 0.024558698758482933, 0.009312668815255165, -0.006140288896858692, 0.02761182188987732, -0.01909138634800911, -0.06441866606473923, -0.008343874476850033, 0.01974005624651909, -0.010383198037743568, -0.046839695423841476, -0.04720618575811386, -0.02650359459221363, -0.0253938939422369, 0.014448901638388634, -0.012792651541531086, -0.04357212036848068, -0.010679525323212147, -0.014673310332000256, -0.03365405648946762, 0.00047366597573272884, 0.0054187593050301075, -0.022094231098890305, 0.01331161055713892, 0.017827704548835754, 0.02220332622528076, -0.0066058216616511345, 0.016122007742524147, 0.007379007060080767, -0.016405319795012474, 0.05078950151801109, -0.010728482156991959, 0.015411943197250366, -0.004400487523525953, -0.017425287514925003, 0.020164158195257187, 0.02202867716550827, -0.0344797745347023, 0.01739218644797802, 0.06352356821298599, -0.08540370315313339, -0.037337642163038254, 0.049014728516340256, -0.008067390881478786, 0.03800143301486969, 0.056528933346271515, 0.0035143066197633743, -0.010954692028462887, 0.018983857706189156, -0.04552055895328522, -0.020771769806742668, -0.014781516045331955, -0.0019146653357893229, -0.008583137765526772, -0.0024489888455718756, -0.04705552011728287, 0.017687831073999405, 0.004552228841930628, 0.036381471902132034, 0.060986317694187164, -0.011646480299532413, 0.018660258501768112, 0.01603033021092415, 0.0009394895751029253, 0.013261447660624981, 0.02254105545580387, -0.012179500423371792, 0.01136034820228815, 0.05984633043408394, 0.0067727696150541306, 0.04632899910211563, -0.03526536747813225, -0.009622353129088879, -0.10895319283008575, -0.028291713446378708, -0.014605917036533356, 0.03520895168185234, 0.05795377865433693, -0.08511345833539963, 0.02484811283648014, 0.03472205251455307, -0.050836969166994095, 0.001525222440250218, -0.02510976605117321, 0.0009059834992513061, -0.030639199540019035, -0.0003005813341587782, -0.00425161886960268, 0.0017307063098996878, 0.017994200810790062, 0.0015782898990437388, 0.05384201183915138, 0.020488187670707703, -0.008304202929139137, -0.020157260820269585, 0.02539295144379139, 0.022802846506237984, 0.010415266267955303, -0.06778717786073685, -0.0007430462865158916, -0.026866119354963303, -0.019634410738945007, 0.054341256618499756, -0.0267410296946764, 0.027701392769813538, 0.028881860896945, 0.04639589414000511, -0.020758554339408875, 0.03304700180888176, 0.020626772195100784, -0.009285734966397285, -0.001174664357677102, -0.008058764040470123, 0.03522991016507149, 0.02844129502773285, -0.02551823854446411, -0.006660476326942444, 0.04373981058597565, 0.0041055153124034405, -0.034444309771060944, 0.038868967443704605, -0.028574712574481964, 0.007470456417649984, 0.008226935751736164, -0.0013497230829671025, -0.01777947135269642, -0.03608313947916031, 0.04555796831846237, -0.052468523383140564, 0.006233332213014364, 0.0051613482646644115, 0.016241393983364105, 0.009395524859428406, 0.020194977521896362, -0.015204024501144886, -0.03680882230401039, -0.0004053891752846539, 0.0016890647821128368, -0.04196535795927048, -0.044789671897888184, 0.022503234446048737, -0.016231494024395943, 0.018861202523112297, 0.00367751601152122, -0.03491026163101196, -0.06719181686639786, 0.02501431107521057, -0.012878087349236012, -0.012352087534964085, -0.016547968611121178, 0.020909324288368225, 0.004250514321029186, -0.08629810810089111, 0.06486845761537552, 0.004918597638607025, -0.029140563681721687, -0.05788920447230339, 0.006121288053691387, -0.04020525515079498, 0.026169553399086, 0.041029155254364014, 0.008763753809034824, -0.006560410372912884, -0.0023168630432337523, 0.03307381644845009, 0.0032179029658436775, -0.04888022318482399, 0.006801649462431669, -0.03952848166227341, -0.008514288812875748, -0.03299632668495178, -0.0030033118091523647, 0.043593090027570724, -0.01066968310624361, -0.023052535951137543, 0.0025621927343308926, 0.03591223433613777, 0.0042723435908555984, -0.01013769768178463, 0.03474925458431244, -0.004348902963101864, 0.0020158225670456886, 0.03662470728158951, -0.025056827813386917, -0.0019553869497030973, 0.05346163734793663, 0.02443225122988224, -0.06875768303871155, 0.03201526030898094, -0.020059607923030853, -0.03516948223114014, 0.004478127229958773, 0.007068742532283068, 0.01806993968784809, -0.054389648139476776, 0.015403944998979568, 0.02111045829951763, -0.02957826294004917, 0.017682313919067383, 0.03631576895713806, 0.03261789306998253, 0.03222145140171051, -0.03400003910064697, -0.02308179996907711, 0.013348608277738094, -0.019262172281742096, -0.018665166571736336, 0.0029974959325045347, -0.017346400767564774, -0.01818188652396202, 0.035431500524282455, 0.05358521640300751, 0.016656111925840378, 0.01800212822854519, 0.042486924678087234, 0.037686221301555634, -0.020006904378533363, -0.04252218082547188, 0.01309209130704403, -0.005529625806957483, 0.03983135148882866, 0.020208068192005157, -0.010435746051371098, 0.0837404876947403, -0.0019284292357042432, 0.027569817379117012, -0.008706089109182358, -0.01385106984525919, -0.045333173125982285, -0.028401019051671028, -0.0024888424668461084, 0.031164778396487236, -0.015770532190799713, -0.0049191913567483425, -0.012440883554518223, -0.005260800942778587, 0.055414676666259766, -0.029153641313314438, 0.03659895434975624, 0.02296275645494461, 0.00259744212962687, -0.0528179407119751, -0.025859152898192406, -0.007223840802907944, -0.008322257548570633, 0.032283127307891846, 0.006458979099988937, 0.0379246361553669, 0.03768949583172798, 0.0019482818897813559, 0.0074215964414179325, 0.062444645911455154, -0.03848404809832573, -0.05032195523381233, -0.03075711615383625, 0.0019091384019702673, 0.016869984567165375, -0.022891052067279816 ]
<p>Here is an example case:</p> <ul> <li>I have a population of 10,000 items. Each item has an unique id. </li> <li>I randomly pick 100 items and record down the ids </li> <li>I put the 100 items back into the population </li> <li>I randomly pick 100 items again, record down the ids and replace. </li> <li>In total, I repeat this random sampling 5 times</li> </ul> <p>What is the probability that $X$ number of items appear in all 5 random samplings?</p> <p>I am not very well versed in statistics. Would this be correct for $X = 10$?</p> <ul> <li>For each sampling, the number of possible combinations of 100 items from 10,000 is ${\rm binom}(10000, 100)$</li> <li>Out of all possible combinations of 100 items, ${\rm binom}(9990, 90) * {\rm binom}(100, 10)$ combinations contain 10 specific items</li> <li>The probability of having 10 specific items is $({\rm binom}(9990, 90) * {\rm binom}(100, 10)) / {\rm binom}(10000, 100)$</li> <li>The calculated probability to the power of 5 would represent 5 indepenent samplings. </li> </ul> <p>So essentially we are just calculating 5 independent hypergeometric probabilities and then multiplying them together? I feel like I am missing a step somewhere.</p>
73,648
[ -0.030763085931539536, -0.058078471571207047, 0.0395243763923645, 0.003822979284450412, 0.055702388286590576, -0.01423177495598793, -0.01743074506521225, -0.023330558091402054, 0.028516676276922226, -0.022982237860560417, 0.05682019144296646, 0.030961016193032265, 0.03946200758218765, 0.01610703207552433, 0.003306333441287279, 0.039559900760650635, -0.002680197125300765, 0.02660594880580902, 0.02981819584965706, 0.009740482084453106, -0.017555586993694305, 0.03415295109152794, 0.025915851816534996, -0.00969080999493599, -0.05004686862230301, 0.03057900443673134, 0.02843349054455757, -0.02095695212483406, 0.04814264550805092, 0.06502783298492432, -0.04966617748141289, -0.0033771609887480736, 0.035190120339393616, 0.0731823667883873, -0.0044242460280656815, -0.014079911634325981, -0.004847449716180563, -0.029620317742228508, -0.004875536076724529, 0.0214295145124197, -0.027518905699253082, -0.016582904383540154, -0.025376413017511368, 0.0166129432618618, -0.0022114492021501064, 0.010669725015759468, -0.02010047249495983, -0.05448317900300026, 0.02292543649673462, -0.0435059554874897, 0.0448150597512722, 0.014470287598669529, 0.04655098915100098, 0.02016793005168438, -0.04450681805610657, -0.00794769823551178, 0.017133748158812523, 0.04395269230008125, -0.012444557622075081, -0.029208052903413773, -0.03736959025263786, -0.05734474956989288, -0.0069004204124212265, 0.009991555474698544, -0.03663093224167824, 0.010371211916208267, -0.006454096641391516, -0.004401785787194967, 0.015159301459789276, -0.038121774792671204, 0.05392291396856308, 0.026940468698740005, 0.046390507370233536, -0.034038010984659195, 0.0023138627875596285, -0.019007179886102676, 0.03165556490421295, -0.011338312178850174, 0.08407706767320633, 0.03513011708855629, -0.010988403111696243, 0.00876718107610941, 0.023991327732801437, 0.030973147600889206, 0.03292066231369972, -0.057033658027648926, 0.04613078758120537, 0.005194871686398983, -0.008007790893316269, -0.018837517127394676, -0.00742906890809536, 0.013757296837866306, 0.07442707568407059, 0.003658752888441086, -0.03330552950501442, 0.060464005917310715, -0.03689620643854141, 0.04500737413764, -0.010494576767086983, -0.0119850505143404, 0.008675136603415012, -0.05542543902993202, 0.019057784229516983, 0.09831217676401138, -0.03010391630232334, -0.014129839837551117, -0.006282784976065159, -0.0088753467425704, -0.0160613302141428, -0.025580953806638718, 0.004965434316545725, 0.030094385147094727, 0.034628719091415405, -0.029454173520207405, 0.007070060819387436, 0.02558916248381138, 0.009153778664767742, -0.005596514791250229, 0.03366962447762489, 0.05156714469194412, 0.050657715648412704, -0.022164911031723022, 0.04760182648897171, -0.03430671617388725, -0.031199606135487556, 0.020215371623635292, 0.00972327496856451, 0.00030196981970220804, -0.042779188603162766, 0.06910914927721024, 0.016348857432603836, -0.021585240960121155, 0.04363561049103737, 0.016891030594706535, 0.010999025776982307, -0.008184908889234066, -0.05245968699455261, -0.04684063419699669, 0.010282231494784355, -0.014770356938242912, -0.0205682422965765, -0.040740132331848145, 0.03677181154489517, 0.05573803186416626, 0.06807591021060944, -0.015334446914494038, 0.0399257056415081, -0.011143037118017673, 0.0183268915861845, 0.04386982321739197, -0.025095263496041298, 0.0011029865127056837, -0.025390151888132095, -0.03742624819278717, -0.013347510248422623, -0.08904895186424255, 0.056268151849508286, 0.029319893568754196, -0.02225937880575657, -0.025336693972349167, 0.008910431526601315, 0.028990738093852997, -0.00983397290110588, -0.027776513248682022, 0.030467413365840912, -0.004689907655119896, 0.07708994299173355, 0.01235626358538866, 0.0209046583622694, 0.016880787909030914, -0.006209483370184898, 0.05673389136791229, 0.0204832274466753, 0.036959558725357056, 0.025960350409150124, -0.0185787845402956, 0.026501687243580818, -0.030319862067699432, 0.03191803768277168, 0.020306110382080078, -0.019181817770004272, -0.008315269835293293, -0.00948887225240469, -0.027335770428180695, 0.06065010651946068, -0.01324465498328209, 0.014467882923781872, -0.03220183774828911, 0.019130747765302658, -0.033125944435596466, -0.050038669258356094, -0.08355904370546341, 0.011765972711145878, -0.020294010639190674, 0.0019478390458971262, 0.044865917414426804, -0.017518315464258194, 0.03067309781908989, 0.03102358803153038, -0.012650959193706512, -0.06354418396949768, 0.008014325052499771, 0.03499874472618103, -0.07417305558919907, -0.021457631140947342, 0.06377971917390823, 0.03121820278465748, -0.01702897436916828, 0.047115571796894073, -0.034893423318862915, -0.03844563663005829, -0.009851103648543358, -0.021087752655148506, 0.003329017199575901, 0.009719766676425934, -0.03701527789235115, 0.02476278506219387, 0.009264213964343071, 0.0008638260769657791, 0.07403495907783508, -0.050174083560705185, 0.06514343619346619, 0.07720910757780075, 0.008348689414560795, 0.010978016071021557, 0.025960804894566536, -0.004272352438420057, -0.007607833947986364, 0.033565063029527664, -0.05171901732683182, -0.08470891416072845, 0.0173164252191782, 0.02839437499642372, 0.014963867142796516, -0.02820863574743271, 0.024819504469633102, 0.056376684457063675, 0.005662478972226381, -0.012896712869405746, 0.028281161561608315, 0.0033539822325110435, -0.0032144475262612104, -0.010926301591098309, 0.030567102134227753, 0.03629938140511513, 0.015095501206815243, 0.004020515363663435, -0.025597939267754555, 0.013407345861196518, -0.008225144818425179, 0.0036553095560520887, 0.009336649440228939, -0.0018086701165884733, 0.03195521980524063, -0.021157797425985336, -0.02910825051367283, 0.024390902370214462, 0.01415540836751461, -0.01758754439651966, 0.019594905897974968, 0.021632632240653038, 0.026590263471007347, -0.017072664573788643, -0.015814436599612236, -0.010708561167120934, 0.01043503824621439, -0.05113748461008072, -0.008109191432595253, 0.012759460136294365, -0.029307756572961807, 0.012223017401993275, -0.026804743334650993, -0.013086155988276005, -0.05461854115128517, 0.006494125351309776, 0.006248614750802517, 0.0031986834947019815, 0.016343526542186737, -0.0423051156103611, -0.029070299118757248, 0.012809259817004204, -0.011376974172890186, -0.022661754861474037, -0.02799857407808304, -0.09063465148210526, -0.011641060002148151, -0.04720469191670418, -0.029161345213651657, 0.03141063451766968, -0.00504784332588315, -0.0230034738779068, 0.006970094051212072, -0.020283639430999756, -0.03824897110462189, -0.0016534533351659775, -0.024521516636013985, 0.006789783481508493, -0.060899414122104645, -0.04307861626148224, 0.06410178542137146, -0.007374689914286137, -0.04397495090961456, 0.03288017213344574, -0.021991398185491562, -0.03874962404370308, -0.0342983603477478, 0.02584277093410492, 0.01700112223625183, -0.039741452783346176, -0.0030915255192667246, 0.015773823484778404, 0.0339629128575325, 0.002930152928456664, -0.08159636706113815, -0.07168933004140854, -0.03631740063428879, -0.0065314993262290955, 0.03518841788172722, 0.012661177664995193, -0.0249800868332386, 0.058298259973526, 0.053911346942186356, -0.02880353480577469, 0.0031636524945497513, -0.00021187176753301173, 0.008836821652948856, -0.013869923539459705, -0.004131895024329424, 0.03507781773805618, -0.039040278643369675, 0.012612218037247658, 0.029080836102366447, -0.005150407552719116, 0.05314265936613083, -0.003521419595927, -0.00608424236997962, 0.04507436975836754, 0.01810232363641262, -0.02145407162606716, 0.038608696311712265, -0.004307069815695286, -0.03874976560473442, 0.026755210012197495, -0.020241737365722656, -0.004040903877466917, 0.015326733700931072, -0.020248711109161377, 0.03452563285827637, -0.01003505103290081, 0.03817754238843918, -0.03437577560544014, 0.04329018294811249, 0.0008700512698851526, -0.050612859427928925, 0.022108616307377815, 0.02989991381764412, 0.04436928778886795, -0.05618467181921005, 0.00028141768416389823, 0.007976203225553036, 0.06936841458082199, -0.023093320429325104, -0.03992890939116478, -0.03285863995552063, -0.013663368299603462, 0.01365989912301302, -0.024736834689974785, -0.0003637099580373615, -0.0017373878508806229, 0.06834746897220612, 0.00808725506067276, -0.04285543039441109, -0.032888758927583694, 0.00867446418851614, -0.07540778815746307, -0.005631200969219208, -0.034717459231615067, 0.03039068914949894, -0.01098662056028843, 0.06164926290512085, 0.003301996039226651, -0.021691767498850822, -0.015921978279948235, 0.021791594102978706, -0.06347358226776123, 0.051367297768592834, 0.008241760544478893, 0.00867767445743084, -0.009310407564043999, -0.03190689906477928, 0.033126842230558395, 0.011018848977982998, 0.01909014582633972, -0.01185070350766182, 0.0045078773982822895, -0.04177020117640495, 0.009712046012282372, -0.0031842433381825686, -0.007093135733157396, 0.026591064408421516, 0.041069239377975464, 0.00062360311858356, 0.01357528381049633, 0.05058533698320389, 0.011755957268178463, -0.00872887670993805, 0.006349273957312107, -0.042416978627443314, 0.009402472525835037, -0.007425593677908182, 0.055031538009643555, 0.01716955564916134, 0.03713279962539673, -0.0014816373586654663, 0.014403163455426693, 0.0031373407691717148, 0.07624639570713043, 0.025620434433221817, -0.022123977541923523, -0.005889195948839188, -0.025315970182418823, -0.014023350551724434, -0.01416897401213646, -0.01091600302606821, 0.0012351475888863206, 0.0053155082277953625, 0.082830049097538, 0.02848261594772339, -0.03824182227253914, 0.024289287626743317, 0.02853243239223957, -0.008758800104260445, -0.008361631073057652, -0.00945456512272358, 0.0032533658668398857, -0.02443346567451954, -0.004316344391554594, -0.016973182559013367, 0.01243461761623621, 0.02296305261552334, 0.011027064174413681, 0.04437066987156868, -0.003384785493835807, -0.042016997933387756, 0.035211145877838135, -0.012576770968735218, 0.05311775952577591, -0.04108774662017822, -0.017427681013941765, 0.05191219225525856, 0.006421325262635946, 0.0034604184329509735, 0.00037985044764354825, -0.02636118233203888, -0.06350123882293701, 0.02858804352581501, 0.029088618233799934, 0.05978738144040108, -0.06100860610604286, 0.04477177560329437, -0.05426981300115585, -0.004875136073678732, 0.019793974235653877, -0.01936701312661171, 0.03281955048441887, -0.02044384926557541, -0.019991641864180565, 0.0179888978600502, -0.006452797446399927, -0.029254291206598282, 0.022413738071918488, -0.02034117467701435, 0.03639592230319977, -0.018978705629706383, 0.015137068927288055, -0.008253097534179688, 0.04572070389986038, 0.02623293176293373, 0.07022260874509811, -0.011975409463047981, -0.008205702528357506, 0.011775952763855457, 0.030311603099107742, 0.004816907458007336, -0.051240064203739166, 0.04736154526472092, -0.028734102845191956, -0.004694447387009859, 0.02656707912683487, -0.026753298938274384, -0.05837893486022949, -0.005405067000538111, 0.008495562709867954, 0.014826077967882156, -0.011291640810668468, -0.007652949541807175, 0.008715097792446613, 0.040309712290763855, -0.0012078233994543552, 0.0667680874466896, 0.012990052811801434, -0.018275346606969833, 0.016053713858127594, -0.01262382697314024, 0.06704941391944885, -0.025629136711359024, 0.020990051329135895, -0.055047061294317245, 0.01637069322168827, -0.06298280507326126, 0.043177198618650436, -0.017351418733596802, 0.013954550959169865, -0.02582339011132717, -0.03300117328763008, 0.008553577587008476, 0.007999233901500702, 0.010667713358998299, 0.03591203689575195, -0.047478411346673965, 0.02318006381392479, 0.008927901275455952, 0.010865610092878342, 0.029077524319291115, -0.007737724110484123, 0.025984397158026695, -0.021359354257583618, -0.017239917069673538, -0.002352411625906825, -0.06799934059381485, -0.02051621489226818, 0.034374237060546875, -0.0036624777130782604, 0.056500017642974854, -0.0007558685028925538, 0.03460638225078583, 0.0022889394313097, -0.04870335012674332, -0.019638923928141594, 0.0012642295332625508, -0.007991588674485683, 0.020264239981770515, -0.00986402202397585, 0.022676371037960052, -0.01677105762064457, -0.01784396916627884, -0.07588378340005875, -0.030036186799407005, 0.000937441480346024, 0.007565769366919994, 0.0012340577086433768, -0.029637690633535385, -0.006887937430292368, -0.02244432643055916, -0.06450964510440826, -0.0615423321723938, 0.055217765271663666, -0.025217611342668533, -0.009846058674156666, -0.03225252404808998, 0.00531530287116766, 0.08631247282028198, 0.002230121986940503, -0.022956542670726776, 0.027103366330266, -0.0215363260358572, 0.04737570881843567, 0.006187764462083578, -0.006954581011086702, -0.029477328062057495, -0.011872527189552784, 0.002219788497313857, 0.009932579472661018, 0.060155026614665985, -0.05753858759999275, -0.030201593413949013, -0.012902379967272282, -0.0030689348932355642, 0.009045328013598919, -0.008523511700332165, 0.009378512389957905, -0.006615663878619671, 0.018621109426021576, -0.007178400177508593, 0.03783295676112175, -0.015049156732857227, -0.025786228477954865, 0.06605217605829239, -0.0038971693720668554, 0.014747879467904568, 0.034154780209064484, 0.08665814995765686, -0.01438214536756277, 0.026947420090436935, -0.014254876412451267, -0.028124097734689713, 0.046071603894233704, -0.011414824053645134, -0.02533283457159996, 0.026477478444576263, -0.007506790105253458, -0.023923562839627266, -0.011423376388847828, -0.04316125437617302, 0.01630905643105507, 0.03554414212703705, -0.035484977066516876, 0.010742190293967724, 0.04081925377249718, -0.009771972894668579, 0.018496526405215263, 0.00385861424729228, -0.005137760192155838, -0.013766016811132431, 0.04015056788921356, 0.025807704776525497, -0.0040729474276304245, -0.009864063933491707, 0.021274853497743607, 0.019521154463291168, 0.04356032609939575, 0.007388850208371878, 0.017242619767785072, -0.002875488717108965, 0.0037169908173382282, -0.05333397909998894, -0.010853594169020653, -0.0018634155858308077, -0.03905297815799713, -0.0008212079992517829, -0.01888604275882244, -0.03342132270336151, 0.03174908831715584, 0.015468288213014603, -0.021349340677261353, -0.036567650735378265, -0.024637727066874504, -0.024916712194681168, -0.019931532442569733, 0.03259033337235451, 0.03191199526190758, 0.030039288103580475, 0.0015530367381870747, 0.01777479611337185, 0.009317601099610329, 0.00824721623212099, -0.00890019629150629, -0.046421997249126434, -0.06429480761289597, 0.0033389502204954624, -0.06265384703874588, -0.003559058764949441, 0.006467756349593401, -0.0023150413762778044, -0.0007624751888215542, -0.019613320007920265, 0.025554275140166283, 0.014557218179106712, 0.03585496172308922, 0.00177779421210289, 0.09742680191993713, 0.01419510692358017, 0.047912660986185074, -0.01078126672655344, -0.008134125731885433, 0.12093894928693771, 0.02789085917174816, 0.01693671941757202, -0.05138305574655533, -0.011727807112038136, -0.020859936252236366, -0.026969682425260544, 0.004595795180648565, 0.022083332762122154, -0.005950131919234991, -0.007902583107352257, 0.03332848101854324, 0.05758543312549591, -0.011883649043738842, 0.026405423879623413, 0.030776208266615868, -0.031571414321660995, -0.0009153250721283257, 0.006161448545753956, -0.012807797640562057, -0.011402054689824581, -0.024628711864352226, -0.05972687900066376, 0.004553908947855234, 0.0017470814054831862, -0.006427618209272623, -0.05661902576684952, -0.019142068922519684, -0.01545789372175932, 0.0313330702483654, 0.01492656022310257, -0.01042510848492384, 0.038591526448726654, -0.03406279534101486, 0.016316862776875496, 0.01722443662583828, 0.018712781369686127, -0.02826119028031826, 0.020944343879818916, 0.0532209537923336, -0.01321423053741455, 0.004710782784968615, 0.006833137944340706, 0.04217963293194771, -0.0542464554309845, -0.022496912628412247, -0.04039110988378525, 0.03630218282341957, -0.02443823590874672, -0.018559539690613747, -0.03555121645331383, -0.0055345394648611546, -0.022071996703743935, -0.044924911111593246, -0.0017231750534847379, 0.029396409168839455, 0.010499992407858372, -0.04914085194468498, -0.026239339262247086, -0.020472055301070213, 0.01099458895623684, -0.019229624420404434, 0.038433339446783066, 0.01072425302118063, -0.029990028589963913, -0.016061680391430855, -0.0025369420181959867, 0.012070959433913231, 0.028127295896410942, -0.020401015877723694, -0.05509822443127632, 0.005060871597379446, -0.03487677872180939, 0.009515655227005482, -0.010679489001631737, 0.0025085778906941414, 0.034444164484739304, -0.027229994535446167, -0.01566137745976448, 0.009251189418137074, -0.01083995122462511, 0.011809062212705612, 0.009285938926041126, 0.006189889740198851, -0.026830509305000305, 0.010620971210300922, -0.021208681166172028, 0.01893394999206066, 0.009870634414255619, 0.00998819712549448, 0.006678434554487467, 0.027499303221702576, 0.0071919444017112255, -0.033327821642160416, 0.027507970109581947, 0.01005293894559145, -0.010460411198437214, 0.004297022707760334, 0.0074849375523626804, 0.052766501903533936, 0.020070737227797508, 0.008894078433513641, 0.013299334794282913, 0.017583684995770454, 0.02088308148086071, 0.0322539396584034, -0.0062808748334646225, -0.037979014217853546, -0.0022845289204269648, 0.005423518363386393, -0.003662774106487632, -0.046890322118997574, -0.04140041396021843, -0.04471278563141823, -0.006560335401445627, 0.03735928237438202, -0.015758786350488663, -0.02815558947622776, -0.02048407681286335, -0.02432837337255478, 0.024778127670288086, 0.014986707828938961, -0.018475614488124847, 0.015691503882408142, 0.03206997737288475, 0.009971240535378456, -0.007472471799701452, 0.015055558644235134, -0.0030578153673559427, 0.006132312119007111, 0.0010431824484840035, 0.04219991713762283, 0.013806978240609169, 0.019702395424246788, -0.008097891695797443, 0.02712894044816494, -0.013341116718947887, 0.03309004008769989, -0.07746690511703491, -0.007441018708050251, 0.06817017495632172, -0.019686391577124596, -0.02022414468228817, 0.03383087366819382, -0.006172511726617813, 0.022944381460547447, 0.023962493985891342, 0.0011405806289985776, -0.023388462141156197, -0.0034322477877140045, -0.051831696182489395, -0.02097250707447529, 0.02156062051653862, 0.012818963266909122, 0.04094712436199188, -0.012491043657064438, -0.037181317806243896, 0.03722468391060829, 0.008074129931628704, 0.03279176726937294, 0.025307800620794296, 0.02051224187016487, 0.011055666022002697, 0.050677381455898285, 0.02828884869813919, 0.043951865285634995, 0.0026268232613801956, -0.02423781156539917, 0.002068229950964451, 0.022936448454856873, -0.03309546038508415, 0.048260901123285294, -0.02891073003411293, -0.017355868592858315, -0.07425407320261002, -0.027142325416207314, -0.017238669097423553, 0.002535613253712654, 0.03281914070248604, -0.04466192424297333, -0.03333118557929993, 0.027457524091005325, -0.043574120849370956, 0.024141497910022736, -0.023920685052871704, 0.00754572032019496, -0.028019530698657036, 0.04373082518577576, -0.03882485628128052, 0.016626795753836632, 0.03120463527739048, 0.03143364563584328, 0.016762563958764076, 0.024798087775707245, -0.0008565302123315632, -0.016740700230002403, -0.005227894056588411, -0.014020668342709541, -0.00491388700902462, -0.038957804441452026, 0.07616488635540009, -0.009292363189160824, -0.05571309104561806, 0.028431253507733345, -0.00038465033867396414, -0.009234759025275707, 0.01500769704580307, 0.005120602436363697, -0.00386936217546463, 0.037430476397275925, 0.022941624745726585, -0.0031562703661620617, -0.024059785529971123, 0.012417992576956749, 0.045600734651088715, 0.02279500663280487, -0.019305987283587456, -0.012076269835233688, 0.0552964024245739, 0.013229829259216785, -0.035105954855680466, 0.05164232477545738, 0.0184450875967741, -0.025508157908916473, -0.005031019914895296, -0.03481259196996689, -0.01714821718633175, 0.008786058984696865, 0.03149544075131416, -0.04419877007603645, -0.003976133652031422, 0.044623963534832, -0.014154612086713314, 0.0012944744667038321, 0.004993903916329145, -0.043993815779685974, -0.03828988969326019, 0.022220024839043617, 0.016214916482567787, -0.029826411977410316, -0.07538866251707077, -0.020159704610705376, -0.0062978873029351234, 0.019402559846639633, 0.01195554994046688, 0.009902694262564182, -0.06678134202957153, 0.03372658044099808, -0.0013189312303438783, 0.034638382494449615, 0.011011146940290928, -0.011988604441285133, -0.02079147659242153, -0.051279280334711075, 0.04841318726539612, 0.005348460283130407, -0.02651023678481579, -0.05509084090590477, -0.03264139965176582, -0.028029175475239754, 0.024373626336455345, 0.030357636511325836, -0.0035048252902925014, -0.008930747397243977, -0.026908114552497864, 0.006441210862249136, 0.025591600686311722, -0.06164752319455147, 0.016788214445114136, -0.020019207149744034, -0.017300881445407867, -0.027104247361421585, -0.023291312158107758, 0.02126595377922058, -0.02270490489900112, 0.004001689609140158, -0.04269201308488846, 0.01309849601238966, 0.001221401966176927, 0.004175695590674877, 0.012415369972586632, 0.013073524460196495, -0.0005506934830918908, 0.03247986361384392, -0.010447250679135323, 0.01827237568795681, 0.01628733240067959, 0.02617676556110382, -0.03879998251795769, 0.01583285443484783, -0.0666734129190445, -0.057281170040369034, 0.0009857641998678446, 0.0019627967849373817, 0.02092043310403824, -0.04940544068813324, 0.03563062846660614, 0.015196064487099648, -0.06744491308927536, 0.0032431718427687883, 0.03358948603272438, -0.002318931743502617, 0.04142998903989792, 0.02573547139763832, 0.013150493614375591, 0.0105120949447155, -0.004147006198763847, -0.0390922836959362, 0.004089425317943096, 0.014504206366837025, -0.034051332622766495, 0.000828188203740865, 0.03489288315176964, 0.037576381117105484, 0.02461186982691288, 0.0022983017843216658, 0.05717943608760834, -0.034918759018182755, -0.03490927815437317, -0.017752204090356827, -0.046073924750089645, 0.015953857451677322, 0.0226157046854496, -0.02481396496295929, 0.07310320436954498, -0.0003781375417020172, 0.022525686770677567, -0.0317874550819397, -0.01771111972630024, -0.014956962317228317, -0.007902010343968868, 0.007207108661532402, 0.02187070995569229, -0.007951473817229271, 0.0011878375662490726, -0.01709877885878086, 0.014534899033606052, 0.055394332855939865, -0.04003576561808586, 0.0024337368085980415, -0.014709807932376862, -0.02261219546198845, -0.03298928216099739, -0.04715627804398537, 0.008879229426383972, -0.0404449962079525, 0.011628436855971813, 0.0038920254446566105, 0.018999740481376648, 0.006940274965018034, -0.03740109130740166, -0.0011506081791594625, 0.04820943996310234, -0.0269949808716774, -0.004243946168571711, -0.0761970579624176, 0.01282646507024765, 0.021662408486008644, -0.021646443754434586 ]
<p>This is a homework question and I need suggestion how to approach it. We have given the transitions </p> <ol> <li>$\ i\rightarrow i+1$ with rate $\lambda(i)$ where $\ i \ge 1$ </li> <li>$\ i\rightarrow i-1$ with rate $\mu(i)(i-1)$ where $\ i \ge 2$</li> </ol> <p>I am starting the forward equation like this:</p> <p>$$\ p_j(t) = [1-(\lambda_jh+\mu_jh +o(h))p(t)]+ \lambda(j-1)p(j-1)(t)h + ...$$</p> <p>and I cannot really continue from here. I need to get to the point where I can show that </p> <p>$$\ G(z, t) = \sum P(N(t)= j|N(0) = a) z^j $$</p> <p>satisfies</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial G}{\partial t} = z \left( z-1\right) \left(\lambda\frac{\partial G}{\partial z}- \mu\frac{\partial^2 G}{\partial z^2}\right)$$</p>
36,067
[ -0.015319455415010452, -0.03371354565024376, 0.034359343349933624, -0.023936131969094276, 0.026402391493320465, -0.0012727293651551008, -0.01063393335789442, -0.03941575437784195, -0.00021332297183107585, -0.03244491294026375, 0.07296708971261978, 0.00968876015394926, 0.07770620286464691, 0.011786893010139465, 0.04665007069706917, 0.023958412930369377, -0.004244115203619003, -0.026246240362524986, -0.038351140916347504, 0.013388323597609997, -0.011984698474407196, 0.00559292221441865, 0.002026753267273307, -0.02422419749200344, -0.03377032279968262, 0.014571664854884148, 0.0014012381434440613, 0.005026767496019602, -0.015613465569913387, 0.07839612662792206, -0.022616537287831306, -0.04012181982398033, -0.002845720387995243, 0.017226293683052063, -0.007449024822562933, 0.04300209507346153, -0.06370380520820618, -0.042899586260318756, -0.03175272420048714, 0.0011621371377259493, -0.02884627692401409, -0.024258339777588844, 0.001624130760319531, 0.03315245732665062, -0.010191272012889385, 0.0491359569132328, -0.006492559798061848, 0.012157412245869637, 0.052702516317367554, -0.030798494815826416, 0.037780117243528366, 0.003309740452095866, 0.026381008327007294, 0.027686918154358864, -0.035582348704338074, -0.012513630092144012, 0.056749377399683, 0.0911703035235405, 0.02110815979540348, -0.041748739778995514, 0.006749305408447981, -0.03795900568366051, 0.007593874353915453, -0.008823047392070293, -0.004503924399614334, -0.01008390262722969, 0.000021923222448094748, -0.07485786825418472, 0.020209575071930885, -0.02513304352760315, -0.01425920706242323, -0.01222399715334177, 0.02280491217970848, -0.00698403175920248, -0.010904766619205475, 0.002154058311134577, 0.014266355894505978, 0.061282090842723846, 0.03065565600991249, -0.010641525499522686, -0.012071315199136734, -0.006118122022598982, 0.02205781452357769, 0.051991842687129974, -0.03980766981840134, -0.020434865728020668, 0.08981641381978989, 0.00295552727766335, 0.033997174352407455, 0.012265580706298351, -0.0003461415763013065, -0.0072469767183065414, 0.030697185546159744, 0.004270792007446289, -0.01909361593425274, 0.05496320500969887, -0.012388083152472973, 0.044221434742212296, 0.007079028524458408, 0.019261488690972328, -0.04064522683620453, -0.05952345207333565, -0.002830483950674534, 0.05170440673828125, -0.008659053593873978, 0.02449542097747326, -0.06147090345621109, -0.03737145662307739, 0.002524122828617692, -0.030613170936703682, -0.056630853563547134, 0.02416045591235161, 0.005953833926469088, -0.012776137329638004, -0.04740934073925018, -0.021715672686696053, -0.030276086181402206, -0.018531089648604393, 0.025891387835144997, 0.03851804509758949, 0.04623468220233917, -0.01562735065817833, 0.026316659525036812, -0.005540643818676472, -0.08657839894294739, -0.007929821498692036, 0.06156693771481514, -0.020335523411631584, -0.06616631895303726, 0.04780910909175873, 0.024564381688833237, -0.0038088648580014706, 0.021608909592032433, -0.0063416664488613605, 0.027376776561141014, -0.016512393951416016, -0.03500184044241905, -0.04361763596534729, 0.04454335197806358, -0.07065476477146149, 0.016474217176437378, -0.055986978113651276, -0.010217067785561085, 0.04496009275317192, 0.0938674733042717, -0.03327139839529991, 0.0266537144780159, -0.005949679296463728, 0.04309289529919624, 0.018121790140867233, -0.023238277062773705, -0.005801485385745764, -0.009661662392318249, -0.01568448729813099, 0.032075464725494385, -0.04126560315489769, 0.014833107590675354, 0.007020110264420509, 0.039252445101737976, -0.023323625326156616, 0.10518792271614075, 0.0047500417567789555, -0.01027502678334713, -0.0034223992843180895, 0.003010045737028122, -0.014815567061305046, 0.06596961617469788, 0.04200761020183563, 0.013341125100851059, 0.0039731888100504875, 0.029329240322113037, -0.008565908297896385, -0.048010069876909256, 0.02493220381438732, 0.022744467481970787, -0.05086515471339226, -0.011008336208760738, 0.013735838234424591, -0.027356063947081566, 0.016935350373387337, 0.02460983768105507, -0.005730756558477879, -0.007726788520812988, 0.0026461039669811726, -0.000807343574706465, -0.006942894775420427, -0.016606871038675308, 0.03138883039355278, -0.016746925190091133, -0.05862274393439293, -0.004990333691239357, -0.03476405143737793, 0.04401795566082001, -0.006990145891904831, -0.006563452072441578, 0.02695409394800663, -0.02859160304069519, 0.016693037003278732, 0.03228304535150528, -0.03401202708482742, -0.008727598004043102, -0.014630787074565887, -0.013125759549438953, -0.0027780926320701838, -0.01197768934071064, 0.07093749195337296, 0.01659812591969967, -0.006453261245042086, 0.06348409503698349, 0.008113511838018894, 0.04162224754691124, 0.003228880697861314, 0.009002367965877056, 0.001112998346798122, 0.009952264837920666, -0.02853587083518505, -0.041775546967983246, -0.024686524644494057, 0.025795677676796913, 0.028413649648427963, -0.07879062741994858, 0.025426795706152916, 0.07359982281923294, 0.035060327500104904, 0.016157781705260277, 0.024178938940167427, -0.012853795662522316, 0.03008594736456871, -0.03922846540808678, -0.009012069553136826, -0.014064781367778778, 0.0026494115591049194, 0.03401333466172218, 0.017643017694354057, -0.0412435345351696, -0.026136543601751328, 0.061634164303541183, 0.013740173541009426, 0.044438622891902924, 0.042385660111904144, -0.036967597901821136, -0.05046525225043297, 0.033690497279167175, 0.04674564674496651, 0.004904091823846102, 0.01253918930888176, 0.0020659882575273514, -0.018378665670752525, 0.014892175793647766, -0.01837298646569252, -0.04528044909238815, 0.04912981390953064, 0.008516794070601463, 0.01952880434691906, -0.026572957634925842, -0.0005630298983305693, 0.050243135541677475, 0.00784929096698761, -0.021842077374458313, 0.03842267766594887, 0.030568309128284454, 0.0008867541328072548, -0.054382335394620895, -0.014555422589182854, 0.005770261865109205, -0.0014489160384982824, -0.03706991672515869, 0.025335868820548058, 0.015036403201520443, 0.011241212487220764, -0.005411878693848848, -0.015078467316925526, 0.015065199695527554, -0.03753741458058357, -0.003352646017447114, -0.014678641222417355, 0.00613154424354434, -0.013172580860555172, -0.04707637056708336, -0.07332887500524521, 0.013499283231794834, 0.01293831504881382, 0.06401491910219193, 0.04053374007344246, -0.02651885524392128, -0.006194720044732094, -0.03020523488521576, -0.04448818042874336, 0.07018502801656723, 0.03894992545247078, 0.009842847473919392, 0.00209931586869061, 0.025120170786976814, -0.013033522292971611, -0.025657780468463898, -0.005469777621328831, 0.007773373741656542, -0.03884139284491539, 0.018898312002420425, 0.06192057579755783, 0.0014580633724108338, -0.02870718203485012, 0.007308014668524265, 0.00541530828922987, -0.036962516605854034, -0.02564452588558197, 0.005413384176790714, 0.0267476886510849, 0.009106778539717197, 0.04266154766082764, 0.00948149710893631, -0.005220295395702124, 0.018962645903229713, -0.060950592160224915, -0.02584993466734886, -0.0007589629967696965, 0.012932373210787773, 0.014380192384123802, -0.007991078309714794, -0.018702618777751923, 0.04780393838882446, 0.029071414843201637, -0.02196172997355461, -0.01087477058172226, 0.018240563571453094, -0.014840779826045036, -0.0804896205663681, 0.007772212382405996, 0.020483804866671562, -0.04969701170921326, 0.01982867531478405, 0.012434808537364006, 0.03564944863319397, 0.07738778740167618, -0.006231619976460934, -0.02152152918279171, 0.03062821924686432, 0.015537738800048828, 0.00027382795815356076, 0.05412689968943596, 0.004871423821896315, -0.022439539432525635, 0.03489555045962334, -0.019578708335757256, -0.014196621254086494, 0.014603461138904095, -0.0903668999671936, 0.03940671682357788, 0.034837398678064346, 0.00006579218461411074, -0.028286471962928772, 0.06633786857128143, 0.03405890613794327, -0.01907462254166603, 0.03135561943054199, 0.010721626691520214, 0.07915794104337692, -0.010711576789617538, 0.00747645040974021, 0.015179059468209743, 0.017416607588529587, -0.018727006390690804, -0.03263530507683754, -0.03450460359454155, -0.015416264533996582, 0.003395249368622899, -0.012870043516159058, -0.023744402453303337, -0.00304727116599679, 0.0022638633381575346, 0.015945345163345337, -0.037070028483867645, -0.03718181326985359, 0.012497049756348133, -0.0704125165939331, -0.0027633679565042257, -0.003552542068064213, 0.059871748089790344, -0.019289880990982056, 0.06931652128696442, 0.00756011251360178, 0.012737049721181393, 0.055482085794210434, 0.014221671968698502, -0.12349008023738861, 0.027070747688412666, 0.04454444348812103, -0.012398822233080864, -0.00958030391484499, -0.02441203035414219, 0.019904159009456635, -0.04652257636189461, -0.004476167727261782, 0.028933897614479065, 0.0011741865891963243, -0.049193061888217926, 0.030859865248203278, -0.07931291311979294, -0.009071427397429943, -0.033405452966690063, 0.007227741181850433, 0.013950127176940441, -0.014518906362354755, 0.040263306349515915, 0.03793090954422951, -0.00742759183049202, 0.01789921708405018, -0.031755153089761734, 0.006204234901815653, 0.018411114811897278, 0.03380099684000015, 0.03387315943837166, 0.029373176395893097, -0.010747497901320457, 0.048626627773046494, -0.009420759975910187, 0.03149363771080971, 0.04369334131479263, 0.0027078536804765463, -0.0009425106691196561, -0.05214901268482208, -0.0331498421728611, 0.03027266263961792, 0.05001676082611084, 0.04267032817006111, -0.014666445553302765, 0.016297513619065285, -0.008453675545752048, -0.013041697442531586, 0.02926783077418804, 0.03244403749704361, -0.04099502041935921, -0.020703399553894997, -0.03713863715529442, -0.047319479286670685, -0.02342735044658184, 0.022550728172063828, 0.006313230376690626, 0.015483330003917217, 0.020594626665115356, 0.006731677800416946, 0.04185481742024422, 0.06195652484893799, 0.014199617318809032, 0.007025109604001045, 0.03192400932312012, 0.05593269690871239, 0.045636653900146484, -0.027037153020501137, 0.024461060762405396, 0.03302495926618576, 0.017298301681876183, -0.03665817901492119, -0.017273223027586937, -0.07341045886278152, -0.02742132917046547, 0.00035123061388731003, 0.029834389686584473, -0.022958744317293167, 0.01073870062828064, -0.02768186666071415, -0.005030299071222544, 0.059954673051834106, -0.006998488213866949, 0.0700288861989975, 0.004514832515269518, -0.006027122028172016, 0.006405831780284643, -0.055532872676849365, -0.033029694110155106, 0.009943348355591297, -0.017655951902270317, 0.005600585136562586, -0.06202651187777519, 0.028919043019413948, -0.018976232036948204, 0.010677053593099117, 0.0007015467272140086, 0.045196328312158585, -0.020226821303367615, -0.012272444553673267, 0.028704259544610977, 0.04130857437849045, -0.03441565856337547, -0.051213301718235016, 0.018142756074666977, -0.016652826219797134, -0.01148762833327055, 0.0287737175822258, -0.05963488668203354, -0.023892531171441078, 0.02121553011238575, 0.02145555429160595, -0.03198591247200966, 0.0022453709971159697, -0.008683523163199425, 0.03506975620985031, 0.019724629819393158, 0.006724227219820023, 0.049737993627786636, 0.053016044199466705, -0.00008415312913712114, 0.000585001427680254, 0.0029945725109428167, -0.00513881491497159, -0.00018130824901163578, 0.018207699060440063, -0.01739799976348877, 0.023280221968889236, -0.02388806827366352, 0.05475221201777458, 0.031962402164936066, -0.008430988527834415, -0.0434240959584713, -0.04920436814427376, 0.030129650607705116, 0.026222683489322662, -0.057756077498197556, -0.0055793519131839275, 0.01678476855158806, 0.00029545024153776467, 0.022470735013484955, -0.011922819539904594, 0.012720683589577675, -0.05324273556470871, 0.005273990798741579, 0.029308311641216278, -0.021346718072891235, 0.034483421593904495, -0.05577804893255234, -0.02534131333231926, 0.04680953919887543, -0.048358701169490814, 0.027322258800268173, 0.015914706513285637, 0.014526240527629852, 0.013722608797252178, -0.013873056508600712, -0.02566879615187645, 0.006253672763705254, 0.011521613225340843, -0.013844489119946957, -0.019547291100025177, -0.004637289326637983, 0.04420416057109833, -0.0002511297643650323, -0.10363070666790009, -0.002740038326010108, 0.034009695053100586, -0.017928894609212875, -0.04514797776937485, -0.013682243414223194, -0.0026990510523319244, -0.06293685734272003, -0.032095614820718765, -0.0255866851657629, 0.005043623503297567, -0.0024215683806687593, -0.004616022575646639, 0.023647388443350792, 0.04966622591018677, 0.04341534525156021, 0.006539839319884777, -0.002784052398055792, -0.0019450924592092633, -0.03517474979162216, -0.01468572486191988, -0.0075629884377121925, 0.014331133104860783, -0.0026231498923152685, 0.012432446703314781, 0.0548614040017128, 0.010969110764563084, 0.031152352690696716, -0.026272553950548172, -0.008493565954267979, 0.03180357441306114, 0.013675947673618793, 0.015675418078899384, -0.055321045219898224, -0.032723862677812576, -0.01834377646446228, 0.020538169890642166, 0.011696092784404755, 0.02973451279103756, -0.022729136049747467, -0.006770736072212458, 0.03236045688390732, -0.00393172912299633, 0.013637591153383255, -0.0034112166613340378, 0.09481934458017349, -0.011251178570091724, -0.005896208807826042, -0.014730380848050117, -0.015578986145555973, 0.04691228270530701, 0.00216907961294055, 0.009564126841723919, 0.040628109127283096, -0.024110756814479828, -0.040296316146850586, -0.01630493998527527, -0.035837627947330475, 0.03555117920041084, 0.04277795925736427, -0.021711604669690132, 0.021380716934800148, -0.026659421622753143, 0.03339250385761261, -0.021730659529566765, -0.013274336233735085, 0.005043133161962032, 0.017379188910126686, -0.003168207360431552, 0.020188486203551292, -0.02137117274105549, 0.022358357906341553, 0.05550607293844223, 0.003726179478690028, -0.011885448358952999, 0.03551125153899193, -0.0015187455574050546, 0.013181567192077637, 0.0038006838876754045, -0.0156576968729496, -0.02090464159846306, -0.0016537716146558523, -0.021559318527579308, 0.04296192154288292, -0.07101624459028244, 0.011578282341361046, 0.04178974777460098, 0.06178537383675575, -0.008301784284412861, -0.04428375884890556, 0.01117230486124754, -0.054421618580818176, 0.01800321787595749, 0.03198741748929024, 0.002956619020551443, 0.03799418732523918, 0.007257294841110706, 0.036482568830251694, -0.025108585134148598, 0.022362196817994118, -0.019183801487088203, -0.019233791157603264, 0.02823275327682495, -0.04192916676402092, -0.08785612136125565, 0.024691851809620857, -0.020983057096600533, -0.02947951853275299, 0.006922825239598751, 0.01676975004374981, -0.02031545527279377, 0.006799761205911636, 0.012176314368844032, -0.003478244412690401, 0.09809259325265884, 0.004707448650151491, 0.031705498695373535, 0.03102961741387844, -0.004014199133962393, 0.11071962118148804, 0.050524674355983734, -0.014657238498330116, -0.02567397430539131, 0.018803130835294724, -0.002696892013773322, -0.0013952970039099455, -0.035463280975818634, 0.03568752110004425, 0.01490734051913023, -0.005774555262178183, 0.004121033474802971, 0.03400418534874916, -0.01005489844828844, 0.024933485314249992, 0.003850409761071205, -0.05309832841157913, -0.02047266997396946, -0.010055935010313988, -0.023261521011590958, -0.0036969457287341356, 0.021805239841341972, -0.02895788662135601, 0.009010856039822102, -0.025348801165819168, -0.01869816519320011, -0.038655370473861694, -0.021997643634676933, -0.006800555158406496, -0.01370517909526825, -0.05185898393392563, 0.025944579392671585, 0.021693455055356026, -0.02078690379858017, -0.0013706600293517113, 0.014198675751686096, 0.016707507893443108, -0.0190862026065588, 0.04526538401842117, 0.04936632513999939, -0.006029897835105658, 0.004899172578006983, 0.025397229939699173, 0.010682551190257072, -0.022882193326950073, 0.006823048926889896, -0.02136562205851078, 0.04598341882228851, -0.010252312757074833, 0.020381387323141098, 0.046731945127248764, -0.018525119870901108, 0.005682323593646288, -0.025570591911673546, -0.007094832602888346, -0.0071906354278326035, 0.020658468827605247, -0.03851737827062607, -0.005009389948099852, -0.01584153063595295, -0.043303243815898895, 0.015566719695925713, -0.01682034134864807, 0.014371422119438648, -0.017687272280454636, -0.01744197867810726, -0.04804385453462601, 0.031930141150951385, -0.047243405133485794, -0.019491543993353844, -0.008437549695372581, -0.003883213270455599, -0.010806807316839695, -0.018664918839931488, -0.022680746391415596, -0.03443654254078865, 0.020587528124451637, 0.02327870950102806, -0.01723838970065117, 0.01172491256147623, -0.066067636013031, -0.005672507919371128, -0.0022542232181876898, 0.018003828823566437, -0.024459395557641983, -0.038350339978933334, 0.011346569284796715, 0.005698465742170811, -0.0318649522960186, 0.014299677684903145, -0.009852681308984756, 0.06848102807998657, 0.022791670635342598, -0.0364348441362381, -0.027824988588690758, -0.01690857857465744, 0.021151592954993248, 0.03850553184747696, -0.025669900700449944, 0.05053873732686043, 0.00496445270255208, 0.032610878348350525, 0.0093472208827734, 0.022567136213183403, 0.003370734630152583, 0.005413688253611326, 0.03246353939175606, -0.02455560863018036, 0.0204982440918684, 0.028042977675795555, 0.0269630029797554, 0.0006295755738392472, 0.0059797740541398525, -0.0013568596914410591, -0.012441277503967285, 0.03444478288292885, -0.03416214883327484, -0.01383439265191555, -0.004587812349200249, -0.04192885011434555, -0.009884347207844257, -0.02648714743554592, -0.009612697176635265, -0.02769756130874157, 0.016262011602520943, 0.012757002376019955, 0.02061379700899124, 0.003057705005630851, 0.03233940526843071, 0.010797967202961445, -0.028210846707224846, 0.0284437108784914, 0.04217477887868881, -0.0006419693818315864, 0.012302166782319546, 0.048272453248500824, -0.014652659185230732, 0.036714427173137665, 0.034730035811662674, -0.022500421851873398, 0.019034797325730324, -0.04708356410264969, -0.0029368926770985126, 0.02346995286643505, -0.005467651877552271, 0.019093437120318413, -0.00399459432810545, -0.04374212026596069, 0.007071604952216148, 0.022114858031272888, 0.005131421610713005, -0.017997968941926956, 0.01781337521970272, -0.05949932709336281, -0.036465249955654144, -0.013816970400512218, 0.0051472242921590805, 0.0043983059003949165, 0.006033208221197128, -0.021857082843780518, 0.05442354828119278, -0.03583681955933571, -0.00007500237552449107, -0.01675049029290676, -0.04290289431810379, 0.015746058896183968, -0.019134918227791786, -0.0028240170795470476, 0.021588020026683807, 0.058127615600824356, -0.010261481627821922, -0.025685084983706474, -0.038645386695861816, -0.0076964301988482475, -0.05673295632004738, 0.032435059547424316, 0.018870245665311813, -0.008840048685669899, 0.0621415339410305, -0.05756957828998566, 0.02480974793434143, 0.004465910606086254, -0.01568031497299671, 0.00110067508649081, -0.0051118554547429085, -0.011110176332294941, -0.0393909215927124, -0.02660457044839859, -0.04718348756432533, 0.03205607831478119, 0.024378277361392975, 0.046650633215904236, 0.04994948208332062, 0.025638526305556297, -0.037399861961603165, -0.06219009310007095, 0.02315448224544525, 0.029378952458500862, -0.018229831010103226, -0.025123991072177887, 0.059706367552280426, 0.0016179633093997836, -0.01351455133408308, 0.00865657813847065, -0.024443909525871277, -0.0057088760659098625, -0.035359181463718414, 0.012385474517941475, 0.0006465433980338275, 0.025610599666833878, 0.012017841450870037, 0.036117661744356155, 0.03403400629758835, -0.0022328607738018036, 0.00998329184949398, -0.017688948661088943, -0.035292934626340866, 0.03195350989699364, 0.038019463419914246, -0.016596732661128044, -0.04825248196721077, 0.02659606747329235, -0.022211434319615364, 0.004935885779559612, 0.018758324906229973, -0.027546077966690063, -0.00015199952758848667, -0.037377871572971344, -0.0267152339220047, -0.024282969534397125, 0.0022453926503658295, 0.05995895341038704, 0.008495965041220188, -0.013926569372415543, -0.027626458555459976, -0.013952956534922123, -0.03824125975370407, 0.011778034269809723, -0.025520751252770424, 0.008073179982602596, -0.02205006591975689, -0.014265709556639194, -0.031353700906038284, -0.016279272735118866, -0.01550426334142685, -0.03414159640669823, -0.03801005333662033, 0.0354897640645504, -0.022824469953775406, -0.004159132484346628, -0.025803932920098305, 0.013813023455440998, 0.02290968783199787, -0.07729434967041016, -0.0004879507760051638, -0.02360386587679386, -0.00670959148555994, -0.00023618596605956554, -0.03469286486506462, -0.00906310137361288, 0.016033051535487175, 0.08401679992675781, -0.012910004705190659, -0.0039397659711539745, 0.022592749446630478, 0.020604003220796585, 0.038684070110321045, -0.025549180805683136, 0.027382927015423775, -0.04460388422012329, -0.009279162622988224, -0.035709355026483536, 0.004371032118797302, -0.01155890617519617, 0.020807035267353058, 0.0054313973523676395, 0.026107672601938248, 0.011177457869052887, 0.01218047272413969, -0.014436648227274418, 0.003219656413421035, -0.016818078234791756, -0.026801299303770065, 0.04825203865766525, -0.006834261119365692, 0.0293260607868433, 0.04257631674408913, -0.020833447575569153, -0.0839753970503807, 0.016956916078925133, -0.05139372870326042, -0.010684805922210217, -0.007883823476731777, -0.006880927365273237, 0.007156001403927803, -0.03288649767637253, 0.007745497860014439, -0.010017300955951214, -0.09342299401760101, -0.03278724104166031, 0.05855095386505127, 0.02489607222378254, 0.004682257305830717, -0.03304019942879677, -0.010739093646407127, 0.028010133653879166, -0.022533835843205452, -0.027966322377324104, 0.06846281886100769, -0.02211567386984825, -0.028090715408325195, 0.006010189652442932, -0.013559271581470966, -0.020815417170524597, 0.009521156549453735, 0.03156345337629318, -0.002816106891259551, -0.04210161045193672, 0.020397035405039787, 0.035433270037174225, 0.0023943514097481966, -0.02657385915517807, 0.016268184408545494, -0.009282764978706837, 0.021224727854132652, -0.0013773577520623803, 0.02892213873565197, -0.03924058750271797, -0.0007960028597153723, -0.03527408093214035, 0.009188042022287846, 0.014611957594752312, 0.03739263489842415, 0.018270699307322502, 0.03933482989668846, -0.004838747438043356, -0.0031915027648210526, 0.01314459927380085, -0.03031979314982891, 0.009469219483435154, 0.025324925780296326, -0.04739511385560036, 0.006315029226243496, -0.021653302013874054, -0.0014430321753025055, -0.031692929565906525, 0.032190240919589996, 0.02162501960992813, 0.002493589650839567, -0.03635810688138008, -0.00008591828373027965, -0.019948894158005714, 0.03751302510499954, -0.001860894146375358, -0.0030789992306381464, -0.009156027808785439, -0.024887025356292725, 0.009802483953535557, -0.015538137406110764 ]
<p>I've used rjags to run MCMC on a model, specified in the JAGS language. Is there a good way to extract that model and perform predictions with it (using the posterior distributions of my parameters)? I can re-specify the model in R and plug in the modes of my parameter posteriors; I'm just wondering if there's a less redundant way of doing this.</p> <p>I believe <a href="http://sourceforge.net/p/mcmc-jags/discussion/610037/thread/0ecab41c" rel="nofollow">http://sourceforge.net/p/mcmc-jags/discussion/610037/thread/0ecab41c</a> is asking the same question.</p>
47,486
[ -0.016305621713399887, 0.010289816185832024, 0.01848621666431427, -0.0252855122089386, 0.02934466488659382, 0.017416467890143394, -0.006931571755558252, -0.023031258955597878, 0.021185526624321938, -0.06183662638068199, 0.03204861655831337, 0.0398094579577446, 0.04938652366399765, 0.019109414890408516, 0.01232669223099947, 0.009837142191827297, -0.000486346340039745, -0.03529444709420204, -0.013478860259056091, 0.013057786971330643, -0.011400419287383556, 0.009574311785399914, 0.0005759766791015863, -0.019106922671198845, -0.005967186763882637, 0.009817352518439293, 0.049637068063020706, 0.0017775127198547125, -0.008162486366927624, 0.04943472892045975, -0.016650812700390816, -0.007945584133267403, 0.04155033454298973, 0.05223881080746651, -0.013532213866710663, 0.002511183964088559, -0.0009431598009541631, -0.06155640631914139, -0.02172308787703514, 0.02639932744204998, -0.03973907604813576, -0.016111241653561592, 0.019538361579179764, 0.04167154058814049, -0.00542207108810544, 0.037968654185533524, -0.00009148760727839544, 0.012567966245114803, 0.024882003664970398, -0.033432502299547195, 0.057928383350372314, 0.02530703879892826, -0.005284326151013374, 0.03558662533760071, -0.011967381462454796, -0.004292408004403114, 0.07655107975006104, 0.06808391213417053, 0.044553495943546295, -0.08685844391584396, -0.011040564626455307, -0.012867937795817852, 0.0057672117836773396, -0.014986079186201096, -0.02716766856610775, 0.033732153475284576, 0.011168076656758785, -0.05198248103260994, 0.049054402858018875, 0.00923693273216486, 0.013827135786414146, 0.012571691535413265, 0.034719374030828476, -0.0009505464695394039, 0.041994836181402206, -0.019438249990344048, -0.001156408223323524, 0.07833926379680634, 0.029467372223734856, 0.009882086887955666, 0.037407711148262024, 0.027562087401747704, 0.0006918379222042859, 0.04708920791745186, -0.005194599740207195, -0.011521054431796074, 0.048630766570568085, -0.034733641892671585, 0.01167674083262682, 0.030905861407518387, -0.0730380266904831, 0.015816135331988335, 0.0545276440680027, 0.000021064073735033162, -0.015423531644046307, 0.038373325020074844, -0.010203658603131771, 0.07124236226081848, -0.010817637667059898, -0.009886600077152252, -0.03162482753396034, -0.0298912413418293, -0.003980046603828669, 0.0348980613052845, -0.025190088897943497, -0.01342111174017191, -0.026874640956521034, -0.029497742652893066, -0.03432990610599518, -0.045882537961006165, -0.05012376233935356, 0.006402445491403341, -0.0413697175681591, -0.03001505695283413, -0.0024172114208340645, -0.017356663942337036, -0.007430415600538254, -0.047106366604566574, 0.039923809468746185, 0.09677375853061676, 0.037166811525821686, 0.0006157435709610581, 0.02947540208697319, -0.03919162601232529, -0.0912257581949234, -0.004478722810745239, 0.004247535485774279, -0.02483399026095867, -0.045880816876888275, 0.05095730721950531, -0.03333701193332672, -0.04708331823348999, 0.04718431830406189, 0.007854645140469074, 0.02416912093758583, -0.04151330515742302, -0.06126682087779045, -0.05863924324512482, 0.020951347425580025, -0.03426026925444603, 0.021783864125609398, -0.06225929036736488, 0.04198135435581207, 0.019044602289795876, 0.002296276856213808, 0.010123339481651783, 0.05056852847337723, -0.0008456141222268343, 0.026720108464360237, -0.042180135846138, -0.01187688484787941, -0.042744774371385574, -0.03576855733990669, -0.00709251593798399, -0.042213503271341324, -0.10333598405122757, 0.01372434664517641, 0.024951791390776634, -0.02703286148607731, 0.010782028548419476, 0.04606461152434349, 0.027196649461984634, 0.005449612159281969, -0.041299689561128616, 0.000293366436380893, -0.05004294961690903, 0.07086148113012314, -0.009017429314553738, 0.0028751108329743147, -0.01748107373714447, -0.0013642472913488746, 0.013263764791190624, -0.008482730016112328, 0.03940681368112564, 0.027331652119755745, -0.032660484313964844, 0.0016937947366386652, 0.0016098589403554797, 0.02090417593717575, -0.019658122211694717, -0.022741084918379784, 0.017293449491262436, -0.009688238613307476, -0.025589052587747574, 0.008630810305476189, 0.021238699555397034, 0.002540190704166889, -0.024015985429286957, 0.042034681886434555, -0.04004598781466484, -0.017330169677734375, -0.04116256162524223, -0.00994054228067398, -0.02493012510240078, -0.00455965381115675, 0.02080988511443138, -0.00823768600821495, 0.05020877346396446, 0.02033114992082119, -0.040632087737321854, -0.026293398812413216, -0.0024354003835469484, 0.03521750494837761, -0.015793686732649803, 0.011807195842266083, 0.05548597127199173, 0.05054266005754471, -0.024783648550510406, 0.04814434424042702, -0.0163120049983263, -0.06102943420410156, -0.004822238348424435, -0.049018897116184235, -0.011596781201660633, -0.0032227355986833572, -0.0023129344917833805, -0.016364768147468567, -0.03407038375735283, -0.0007081343792378902, -0.015869902446866035, -0.03490623086690903, 0.06592021137475967, 0.08541472256183624, -0.0061996919102966785, -0.007175277918577194, 0.030110957100987434, -0.0046560438349843025, 0.029425792396068573, -0.011985073797404766, 0.03402510657906532, -0.07363083213567734, 0.003739064559340477, 0.04870826005935669, -0.01134468987584114, -0.048958733677864075, 0.0033043003641068935, 0.046062320470809937, 0.012491484172642231, 0.01193141844123602, 0.029729686677455902, 0.00574894854798913, 0.017676888033747673, 0.005839931778609753, -0.006478255148977041, 0.01476971060037613, -0.02687361277639866, 0.026346271857619286, 0.008255411870777607, 0.040655773133039474, -0.04376878961920738, -0.01808018609881401, 0.04958907514810562, 0.03079933300614357, -0.03302597627043724, -0.03177870064973831, -0.045923586934804916, 0.031713422387838364, -0.016917208209633827, 0.019505301490426064, 0.015606135129928589, 0.0195565577596426, -0.0024301449302583933, 0.01404500100761652, -0.03564370423555374, 0.0005572602967731655, 0.027359861880540848, -0.019905555993318558, 0.0188568364828825, 0.004712631460279226, -0.04303848370909691, -0.003415601560845971, -0.0326419435441494, 0.03074163943529129, -0.05237024277448654, 0.045782409608364105, -0.012216766364872456, 0.0009131045662797987, -0.013929449021816254, -0.017491359263658524, -0.04070832207798958, 0.04511449113488197, 0.018383055925369263, 0.003955373540520668, 0.025456886738538742, -0.0314076729118824, 0.026707880198955536, -0.010660121217370033, -0.003722395980730653, 0.00237097661010921, -0.0030407726299017668, -0.033268142491579056, 0.012799253687262535, -0.024753835052251816, -0.053348902612924576, -0.028093485161662102, -0.0004225988523103297, -0.01343370322138071, -0.02059996873140335, -0.04039236530661583, 0.03429699316620827, 0.03913115710020065, -0.05042903497815132, -0.006242937408387661, -0.03403652459383011, -0.028201274573802948, -0.039330706000328064, -0.008304030634462833, 0.03950885683298111, -0.0011090670013800263, 0.03143244981765747, 0.010987753979861736, -0.04528483375906944, 0.0282904002815485, -0.04218418896198273, -0.024460842832922935, 0.05564667657017708, 0.028726277872920036, 0.0053322347812354565, 0.01901492476463318, 0.005845597945153713, 0.08289406448602676, 0.021115019917488098, -0.062248218804597855, -0.03562851995229721, 0.017539789900183678, -0.009675183333456516, -0.03227843716740608, -0.016169624403119087, -0.0060033793561160564, 0.030998865142464638, -0.0053055547177791595, -0.022267723456025124, 0.03257357329130173, 0.042324863374233246, 0.009033290669322014, 0.019691752269864082, -0.004769281484186649, -0.0410270132124424, 0.014209587126970291, 0.04035772755742073, 0.01748473383486271, -0.007962802425026894, 0.006533351261168718, -0.020050957798957825, 0.04548799619078636, -0.03212738037109375, -0.06230577081441879, -0.0018825798761099577, 0.04167003184556961, 0.013567060232162476, -0.035181924700737, 0.022079480811953545, 0.026668766513466835, -0.03601188212633133, 0.004168785642832518, 0.0046472265385091305, 0.04453763738274574, -0.007225972134619951, 0.007187617477029562, 0.016927029937505722, -0.0044519915245473385, -0.032656919211149216, 0.008066522888839245, -0.017368270084261894, -0.013271007686853409, 0.010347863659262657, -0.007196910213679075, 0.003998769912868738, 0.058848682790994644, -0.009027070365846157, 0.02068847045302391, 0.0056533971801400185, -0.03177017346024513, 0.02774830162525177, -0.0667787715792656, 0.01305963471531868, -0.023352915421128273, 0.02962837740778923, -0.003805682063102722, 0.0635014995932579, 0.01685911789536476, -0.007952610030770302, 0.00838629249483347, -0.023266790434718132, -0.057689111679792404, 0.034791551530361176, -0.0026786290109157562, -0.02499326318502426, 0.007414813619107008, -0.03841624781489372, 0.03829298913478851, -0.03321344032883644, 0.024429311975836754, -0.016369644552469254, 0.010629331693053246, -0.021314462646842003, 0.04030236974358559, -0.04392675682902336, -0.022348834201693535, -0.004924827720969915, 0.02479984238743782, 0.06615209579467773, -0.027255462482571602, 0.0022078962065279484, 0.02539888210594654, -0.022876029834151268, -0.004308740608394146, 0.0024090001825243235, 0.01191843580454588, 0.011446190997958183, 0.031271301209926605, 0.06576208770275116, 0.06305602192878723, -0.032606564462184906, 0.02027714252471924, 0.015502119436860085, 0.02182581275701523, 0.03833296149969101, -0.02909523993730545, 0.003743585431948304, -0.03790263086557388, -0.009100249968469143, 0.039825133979320526, 0.026850011199712753, -0.012522963806986809, 0.024236874654889107, 0.059378378093242645, 0.0048627774231135845, -0.013177145272493362, 0.014057786203920841, 0.05418403074145317, 0.014706672169268131, -0.014580872841179371, -0.013812617398798466, 0.008629326708614826, -0.01856522262096405, -0.014961663633584976, 0.03799692168831825, 0.0258974339812994, 0.0008315127925015986, 0.022561734542250633, -0.009029323235154152, -0.018281783908605576, -0.012363246642053127, -0.003334951354190707, 0.03465092554688454, 0.035697851330041885, 0.016328414902091026, -0.01057348120957613, 0.014033684507012367, 0.04639183729887009, 0.015528758056461811, -0.015190626494586468, -0.000896835932508111, -0.09521761536598206, -0.00425333809107542, 0.05954110622406006, 0.048198360949754715, -0.02837338112294674, 0.0020914399065077305, -0.0446130633354187, -0.025870369747281075, 0.03471074253320694, -0.016053445637226105, 0.028022609651088715, 0.017232120037078857, -0.002708133775740862, 0.042334508150815964, -0.002173489658161998, -0.031424421817064285, 0.01914474368095398, -0.048348795622587204, 0.011721556074917316, -0.022432705387473106, 0.004081703722476959, -0.0522572360932827, 0.03872453793883324, -0.007529141381382942, 0.03563709929585457, -0.033032748848199844, 0.002416429575532675, -0.019136536866426468, 0.002889626193791628, 0.004487895406782627, -0.035668011754751205, 0.01051913108676672, 0.027238432317972183, -0.04798397794365883, 0.0520554780960083, -0.010711349546909332, 0.009306327439844608, 0.02403147518634796, 0.0036057860124856234, -0.00841817818582058, -0.014258977957069874, -0.020784517750144005, 0.014525864273309708, -0.0031693633645772934, -0.01068584993481636, 0.038460735231637955, 0.019862541928887367, 0.008806131780147552, -0.009315211325883865, -0.022361204028129578, 0.03092597983777523, -0.03727196156978607, -0.0058161234483122826, -0.04201975092291832, 0.0187456626445055, -0.011297542601823807, 0.015292888507246971, -0.010743285529315472, 0.043960634618997574, -0.016538208350539207, 0.0069037978537380695, 0.0273816529661417, 0.024546120315790176, -0.018952693790197372, -0.0119610745459795, -0.018812350928783417, 0.01596684753894806, -0.01800086908042431, -0.026206331327557564, 0.05089592933654785, -0.02373388595879078, 0.009124403819441795, 0.02218574471771717, -0.08275295048952103, 0.014800126664340496, -0.008266778662800789, -0.009072585962712765, 0.03568313643336296, -0.027343129739165306, 0.015340905636548996, -0.030850565060973167, 0.05920683592557907, -0.0002965675084851682, -0.05368255078792572, -0.013042640872299671, -0.0155305415391922, 0.0034193838946521282, 0.0015096866991370916, -0.023814242333173752, 0.03159758821129799, -0.04970737546682358, -0.0003078272275160998, -0.05256155505776405, -0.05582951381802559, 0.007358296308666468, -0.012552392669022083, -0.037295639514923096, -0.023224778473377228, 0.024492746219038963, -0.008044514805078506, 0.01623392663896084, -0.019211655482649803, 0.038548171520233154, -0.06586052477359772, 0.01275822427123785, -0.012961456552147865, 0.008597029373049736, 0.0574968159198761, 0.009266180917620659, 0.0023095239885151386, 0.032347410917282104, 0.009914166294038296, -0.021979674696922302, -0.023639608174562454, -0.004825315438210964, -0.007164690177887678, 0.048174239695072174, -0.015844358131289482, 0.0014494337374344468, 0.04764633998274803, -0.027423156425356865, 0.011719445697963238, 0.029320137575268745, -0.00464967917650938, -0.006842060014605522, -0.04971051588654518, -0.017770562320947647, -0.042248278856277466, -0.02991039864718914, -0.050064727663993835, 0.019291264936327934, 0.0488605760037899, 0.015677982941269875, 0.02862304262816906, -0.03734375908970833, -0.00955288391560316, 0.030919471755623817, 0.05165088549256325, 0.012929246760904789, 0.020467502996325493, 0.021020419895648956, -0.021272918209433556, 0.006955487187951803, -0.014388578943908215, 0.04314879700541496, 0.00027209840482100844, 0.01428897213190794, -0.02539905533194542, -0.0224844291806221, -0.05575137212872505, -0.021944493055343628, 0.06564169377088547, -0.024541761726140976, 0.03948862478137016, 0.020067855715751648, 0.027945484966039658, 0.009672165848314762, -0.031160151585936546, -0.014925913885235786, -0.005440525244921446, 0.0007731737568974495, 0.06567491590976715, 0.02526707760989666, 0.013142351061105728, 0.004759021569043398, -0.00036430530599318445, 0.007918291725218296, 0.046603601425886154, 0.019585587084293365, 0.03066035732626915, 0.011523491702973843, -0.026450013741850853, -0.0332370363175869, 0.00651133107021451, -0.06361741572618484, -0.01945279724895954, -0.027372872456908226, -0.04642799496650696, 0.03186962381005287, 0.040923964232206345, -0.0011116797104477882, -0.05115577206015587, 0.020404690876603127, -0.033429309725761414, 0.04898529127240181, 0.038441285490989685, 0.017900045961141586, 0.008559691719710827, 0.020970914512872696, 0.035506464540958405, -0.023571975529193878, 0.048751410096883774, -0.02074907347559929, -0.07508562505245209, -0.01593732461333275, -0.03794191777706146, -0.035051021724939346, 0.05369482561945915, 0.03018135577440262, -0.00040539356996305287, -0.004044259898364544, -0.033273130655288696, 0.02510076016187668, -0.040282510221004486, 0.04523928835988045, 0.0023973973002284765, 0.10852174460887909, 0.008545177057385445, 0.01154307834804058, 0.014401258900761604, 0.0017857730854302645, 0.12422709912061691, 0.026176657527685165, 0.0659041702747345, -0.06629078835248947, 0.011319943703711033, -0.014933953061699867, -0.013966146856546402, 0.01155038084834814, -0.015112092718482018, 0.009611883200705051, -0.004517369903624058, 0.033578526228666306, 0.04189983755350113, -0.01976531371474266, 0.034184589982032776, 0.03270452842116356, -0.023731796070933342, 0.0173418540507555, -0.00025610424927435815, 0.016950789839029312, 0.003063999116420746, -0.024199772626161575, -0.042533908039331436, 0.013994204811751842, -0.006269817240536213, -0.046173498034477234, -0.03189579024910927, -0.020807383581995964, 0.00015434810484293848, 0.03075648657977581, 0.02054518647491932, -0.014579379931092262, 0.009470611810684204, 0.038604676723480225, 0.025296244770288467, -0.01932542398571968, 0.041058603674173355, -0.03143463656306267, -0.006494882516562939, 0.042378704994916916, 0.026396607980132103, 0.013721698895096779, -0.018533850088715553, 0.0020995240192860365, -0.03767906129360199, -0.028298471122980118, -0.019821688532829285, 0.03637249395251274, -0.009117860347032547, -0.02464526705443859, -0.032315537333488464, 0.01902233064174652, 0.028733056038618088, -0.04629778861999512, -0.056144434958696365, 0.033529628068208694, 0.03234987333416939, -0.002194359665736556, -0.019275691360235214, -0.0212224293500185, -0.0018917142879217863, 0.0025321487337350845, 0.03488325700163841, -0.015135744586586952, -0.04512427747249603, -0.06046565622091293, -0.009592365473508835, 0.020543096587061882, -0.02283022180199623, -0.021628938615322113, 0.0030851128976792097, -0.043125852942466736, -0.03004818595945835, 0.009926669299602509, 0.011606469750404358, 0.03834247589111328, 0.02243243344128132, -0.01346275582909584, -0.009428922086954117, -0.030288198962807655, -0.04358765482902527, -0.017962079495191574, -0.059760913252830505, 0.015844011679291725, -0.048299092799425125, 0.0040727099403738976, 0.04604280740022659, 0.048981696367263794, 0.0011905189603567123, 0.021783625707030296, -0.012635606341063976, 0.022435255348682404, 0.014851009473204613, -0.053151242434978485, -0.013510245829820633, 0.00344279408454895, -0.049557335674762726, 0.016744818538427353, -0.006672790739685297, 0.0403134822845459, 0.04890936240553856, 0.016690315678715706, -0.04694213718175888, 0.03625961393117905, -0.004527117591351271, 0.03680937737226486, 0.0018369377357885242, -0.02639944665133953, -0.010686982423067093, -0.037742458283901215, 0.013631404377520084, -0.03601609915494919, 0.019716721028089523, 0.00046308684977702796, 0.0067454250529408455, -0.007879901677370071, -0.034411557018756866, -0.05241161584854126, 0.01573674939572811, -0.006093093194067478, 0.02196916937828064, -0.026888635009527206, 0.052630577236413956, -0.010624855756759644, -0.009306549094617367, 0.0014397513587027788, -0.01242949441075325, 0.004120507277548313, 0.007833544164896011, -0.05147462710738182, -0.001442063134163618, 0.053255703300237656, 0.029949361458420753, 0.03887316212058067, 0.008873521350324154, 0.02743563801050186, 0.009756460785865784, 0.0586174912750721, 0.0011489074677228928, 0.004496375564485788, -0.006625244859606028, -0.0602332204580307, -0.03070867620408535, 0.001561117940582335, 0.020235637202858925, 0.029177190735936165, 0.017219869419932365, -0.022583382204174995, -0.0349007323384285, 0.040886152535676956, -0.018610822036862373, 0.011132027953863144, -0.0036068870685994625, 0.006465258542448282, 0.003979660104960203, 0.02785372920334339, 0.00021084806940052658, 0.0005611512460745871, 0.02004479430615902, 0.0413687527179718, -0.003661691676825285, 0.016490673646330833, -0.03863134980201721, 0.005229211412370205, -0.006090208422392607, -0.00026200508000329137, -0.017884286120533943, -0.0006672628805972636, -0.0007137996726669371, 0.020491065457463264, -0.017816992476582527, 0.06148235499858856, 0.02453363500535488, 0.03435332328081131, -0.09666357934474945, -0.02094900794327259, -0.02354450151324272, 0.01133718155324459, 0.05329218879342079, -0.05650712549686432, 0.05099008232355118, 0.012426238507032394, -0.02780502289533615, -0.008173748850822449, 0.007968644611537457, -0.00800186675041914, -0.0257746409624815, 0.009262734092772007, -0.025292804464697838, 0.025402046740055084, 0.0019318793201819062, 0.026782648637890816, 0.034227706491947174, 0.012063708156347275, 0.011910372413694859, -0.017649255692958832, -0.009231342002749443, -0.0018007353646680713, 0.030208880081772804, -0.008829894475638866, 0.05185515061020851, -0.03317123278975487, -0.0580451563000679, 0.007679772097617388, 0.021176928654313087, 0.05100051313638687, -0.011221049353480339, 0.036220382899045944, 0.04686702787876129, 0.04409407824277878, 0.0311586856842041, 0.0037529959809035063, 0.05213988572359085, -0.006438454147428274, -0.03277839347720146, 0.0031182444654405117, -0.02360762655735016, 0.028621498495340347, 0.009388549253344536, -0.03024008311331272, -0.009156334213912487, 0.02477622963488102, -0.034926027059555054, -0.022192345932126045, -0.028209293261170387, 0.013815408572554588, -0.019218213856220245, -0.013489183969795704, 0.011883337050676346, -0.08653996139764786, 0.013999269343912601, 0.06401625275611877, 0.019485102966427803, -0.06050723046064377, 0.008696514181792736, -0.027826977893710136, -0.0329994335770607, 0.01951345056295395, -0.0018230765126645565, -0.02477382682263851, -0.07534334063529968, 0.0072202375158667564, 0.01485710684210062, 0.008546030148863792, -0.048282723873853683, 0.005037569906562567, -0.040851399302482605, 0.03551876172423363, -0.00908298883587122, 0.02727370522916317, 0.03653476759791374, 0.004126050043851137, 0.06180842965841293, -0.07325674593448639, 0.059064917266368866, 0.007531151175498962, -0.042762380093336105, 0.0009158161701634526, -0.02267506718635559, -0.0035033461172133684, 0.009935515001416206, 0.06757528334856033, -0.04415454715490341, 0.018440615385770798, -0.020967785269021988, 0.03718380630016327, 0.026169391348958015, -0.019273703917860985, 0.03154672682285309, 0.015459827147424221, 0.010160070843994617, 0.000583711254876107, -0.02017012983560562, -0.006444932892918587, 0.07405562698841095, 0.0289299413561821, 0.0011923363199457526, -0.00622797105461359, -0.0012026519980281591, -0.029672497883439064, 0.015236965380609035, -0.031084123998880386, 0.0029620917048305273, 0.043601252138614655, 0.017986485734581947, 0.011689834296703339, 0.017442887648940086, 0.0369894914329052, -0.008988832123577595, 0.035358402878046036, -0.05052850767970085, -0.022866275161504745, 0.02741062454879284, -0.00225542183034122, 0.01097569428384304, -0.019688941538333893, 0.020783690735697746, 0.01254325732588768, -0.03467603400349617, 0.018255237489938736, 0.023861300200223923, -0.01942320540547371, 0.055520571768283844, -0.005009448621422052, 0.005522269289940596, 0.03425842896103859, -0.04071294888854027, 0.008755458518862724, -0.00738811818882823, 0.048853661864995956, -0.02047106623649597, 0.036739639937877655, 0.03614158555865288, -0.024250946938991547, 0.028469031676650047, -0.017515696585178375, 0.03556566312909126, -0.043693624436855316, -0.03721769526600838, 0.014919133856892586, -0.0358487032353878, -0.018653441220521927, -0.043885648250579834, -0.04585354030132294, 0.04858452081680298, -0.012966729700565338, -0.02012387290596962, -0.05252261087298393, 0.002867531031370163, -0.021541766822338104, 0.007218192331492901, -0.04951808601617813, -0.019881296902894974, 0.005114375147968531, 0.028039678931236267, 0.008980724960565567, -0.034972336143255234, 0.032167673110961914, -0.04816052317619324, -0.004876694642007351, 0.0030114997643977404, 0.02183198370039463, -0.0032734868582338095, -0.01919938623905182, -0.012775836512446404, -0.0043588182888925076, 0.01851823553442955, 0.01624278724193573, -0.0049192593432962894, -0.05286955460906029, -0.0043273791670799255, 0.006441599223762751, 0.037453919649124146, -0.047224532812833786, 0.002510715276002884, -0.03394812345504761, 0.009538556449115276, -0.040986016392707825, -0.01124914363026619 ]
<p>I've been looking at numerous questions on this site regarding bootstrapping and confidence intervals, but I'm still confused. Part of the reason for my confusion is probably that I'm not advanced enough in my statistics knowledge to understand a lot of the answers. I'm about half-way through an introductory statistics course and my math level is only about mid-Algebra II, so anything past that level just confuses me. If one of the knowledgeable people on this site could explain this issue at my level it would be extremely helpful.</p> <p>We were learning in class how to take resamples using the bootstrap method and use those to build up a confidence interval for some statistic we'd like to measure. So for example, say we take a sample from a large population and find that 40% say they'll vote for Candidate A. We assume that this sample is a pretty accurate reflection of the original population, in which case we can take resamples from it to discover something about the population. So we take resamples and find (using a 95% confidence level) that the resulting confidence interval ranges from 35% to 45%.</p> <p>My question is, what does this confidence interval actually <em>mean</em>?</p> <p>I keep reading that there's a difference between (Frequentist) Confidence Intervals and (Bayesian) Credible Intervals. If I understood correctly, a credible interval would say that there's a 95% chance that in <em>our situation</em> the true parameter is within the given interval (35%-45%), while a confidence interval would say that there's a 95% that in <em>this type of situation</em> (but not necessarily in our situation specifically) the method we're using would accurately report that the true parameter is within the given interval.</p> <p>Assuming this definition is correct, my question is: What's the "true parameter" that we're talking about when using confidence intervals built up using the bootstrap method? Are we referring to (a) the true parameter of the <em>original population</em>, or (b) the true parameter of the <em>sample</em>? If (a), then we'd be saying that 95% of the time the bootstrap method will accurately report true statements about the original population. But how could we possibly know that? Doesn't the whole bootstrap method rest on the <em>assumption</em> that the original sample is an accurate reflection of the population it was taken from? If (b) then I don't understand the meaning of the confidence interval at all. Don't we already know the true parameter of the sample? It's a straightforward measurement!</p> <p>I discussed this with my teacher and she was quite helpful. But I'm still confused.</p>
73,649
[ -0.016521988436579704, -0.00887215044349432, 0.017659500241279602, -0.026799192652106285, 0.03817662224173546, 0.01503528468310833, -0.009807052090764046, -0.03687234967947006, 0.0029087041039019823, 0.00019538278866093606, 0.02798387221992016, 0.026310095563530922, 0.032464683055877686, 0.013481169007718563, -0.008533187210559845, 0.01225230935961008, -0.009891781024634838, 0.008210656233131886, -0.0030990561936050653, -0.005520311184227467, 0.02167077362537384, 0.03493758663535118, 0.0075830621644854546, -0.06202953681349754, 0.010070380754768848, 0.03128882125020027, 0.015322200953960419, -0.009510807693004608, -0.009710644371807575, 0.10008364170789719, -0.034437019377946854, -0.040090471506118774, 0.03964536264538765, 0.03023361787199974, -0.0027049663476645947, 0.001754974597133696, -0.01249605230987072, -0.019850533455610275, -0.019871192052960396, 0.04914503172039986, -0.0729154646396637, 0.0026098224334418774, 0.009728561155498028, 0.01515724416822195, 0.00429535424336791, -0.006026402115821838, -0.007051275577396154, -0.0485667809844017, -0.003561338409781456, -0.013378598727285862, 0.04037366062402725, -0.018518373370170593, 0.030507519841194153, 0.05753994733095169, 0.011770415119826794, -0.02300332300364971, 0.0593075230717659, 0.039847325533628464, -0.021856993436813354, -0.06672071665525436, -0.023238645866513252, -0.03466661646962166, -0.012454713694751263, -0.006016659550368786, 0.0011880918173119426, 0.026061851531267166, -0.013427539728581905, -0.007718588691204786, 0.03356165811419487, -0.005699236411601305, -0.01854216307401657, 0.022483380511403084, 0.06152884289622307, -0.007246922701597214, 0.05467374622821808, -0.05579013004899025, 0.014202835038304329, 0.037354033440351486, 0.04370229318737984, 0.046232596039772034, -0.029727989807724953, 0.018285103142261505, 0.02150127850472927, 0.03224232420325279, 0.02245371788740158, -0.03435269370675087, 0.05228168144822121, -0.036408357322216034, 0.03479413315653801, 0.013368899002671242, -0.03588787838816643, 0.012099278159439564, 0.03264741599559784, -0.0330146886408329, -0.013952763751149178, 0.05892794206738472, -0.0140038738027215, 0.04956372454762459, -0.01930866949260235, 0.004950129892677069, 0.0025001487229019403, -0.008506148122251034, 0.05079410597681999, 0.06585501879453659, 0.020683296024799347, -0.012296291999518871, -0.03376086428761482, -0.026675879955291748, -0.031213494017720222, -0.04640103131532669, -0.0032215588726103306, 0.044041313230991364, -0.009921938180923462, 0.05064071714878082, 0.018769407644867897, 0.023393455892801285, 0.04055175930261612, -0.04678676277399063, 0.06718912720680237, 0.0010776858543977141, 0.031144073233008385, 0.009745527058839798, 0.00182405486702919, -0.02623601444065571, -0.01990232616662979, 0.026438483968377113, 0.015050613321363926, -0.005386750679463148, -0.02300761640071869, 0.03670721501111984, 0.009367547929286957, -0.023643789812922478, 0.028265053406357765, 0.034673839807510376, 0.015307286754250526, -0.004061450716108084, -0.09783054143190384, -0.07509687542915344, 0.048801861703395844, 0.023559821769595146, -0.04351836442947388, -0.06445842236280441, 0.014955583959817886, 0.01708313636481762, 0.037395380437374115, 0.005022549536079168, 0.03895408660173416, -0.017289694398641586, 0.039026111364364624, 0.021842483431100845, -0.04431955888867378, 0.0007828415255062282, -0.03918379545211792, 0.01367812417447567, -0.013011567294597626, -0.05780753120779991, 0.02158292941749096, -0.000883251428604126, -0.022545810788869858, -0.034300535917282104, 0.028884315863251686, -0.033698827028274536, -0.013971948996186256, -0.01349667925387621, 0.01248309575021267, 0.00042859348468482494, 0.07175807654857635, -0.019384874030947685, 0.0007304301834665239, 0.012845909222960472, -0.0063481018878519535, -0.00010845639917533845, 0.05994289368391037, 0.029295632615685463, 0.05701349303126335, -0.035256508737802505, -0.02817530184984207, -0.058852724730968475, 0.019299816340208054, -0.021449102088809013, -0.01406879536807537, 0.0019986885599792004, 0.019758453592658043, 0.011343546211719513, -0.0038713531102985144, 0.0072821457870304585, 0.031369056552648544, -0.040251921862363815, 0.03110843524336815, -0.03358263149857521, -0.027574099600315094, -0.06377193331718445, -0.015593711286783218, -0.009689838625490665, -0.010469465516507626, 0.02909405156970024, -0.00647966330870986, -0.0057418448850512505, -0.033354517072439194, 0.00039047017344273627, -0.01896311715245247, 0.003303789533674717, 0.06123432517051697, -0.03330590948462486, 0.04471577703952789, 0.039180297404527664, 0.04343516752123833, -0.03284042328596115, 0.038406502455472946, -0.02738070674240589, -0.06664928793907166, -0.026656370609998703, -0.034408070147037506, 0.0168460626155138, 0.01036701537668705, -0.05236857756972313, -0.014174753800034523, -0.03335794433951378, -0.03328517824411392, 0.029771290719509125, -0.06780648231506348, 0.05278805270791054, 0.03194383159279823, 0.001194998505525291, -0.010797933675348759, 0.04180832952260971, 0.0026836241595447063, 0.004733235575258732, -0.023017268627882004, 0.006814701948314905, -0.0641833171248436, -0.01894955337047577, 0.0449710376560688, -0.0012150994734838605, -0.009084993973374367, 0.02461536042392254, 0.05321656912565231, 0.028267450630664825, 0.004198783542960882, 0.04260781407356262, 0.013662626035511494, -0.014421616680920124, -0.005427208263427019, -0.002912035444751382, 0.02094767801463604, 0.033947817981243134, 0.010746984742581844, 0.008325720205903053, 0.035925768315792084, 0.037372615188360214, 0.024841194972395897, 0.0197402685880661, 0.021670201793313026, 0.0038498693611472845, -0.004786699544638395, -0.02218472771346569, 0.030508851632475853, -0.03524080663919449, -0.009898770600557327, 0.0075079044327139854, -0.01620103232562542, 0.0009565001237206161, -0.006960301660001278, -0.00014444038970395923, 0.035631489008665085, 0.06105219945311546, -0.04595157876610756, 0.009314500726759434, 0.0192314051091671, 0.007981416769325733, -0.0091530941426754, -0.03435720503330231, -0.030324039980769157, 0.004527610260993242, -0.0026943269185721874, -0.006508980877697468, -0.00803243089467287, 0.04521586745977402, -0.01785537786781788, -0.04095476493239403, -0.007703469134867191, 0.018734797835350037, 0.0280026663094759, -0.012454602867364883, -0.07444558292627335, 0.01174518745392561, -0.0012001321883872151, -0.013522421009838581, -0.014622402377426624, 0.0022971804719418287, -0.016798879951238632, -0.012912913225591183, -0.01287221908569336, -0.010919534601271152, 0.0022073083091527224, -0.004510893486440182, -0.014388558454811573, -0.010573962703347206, -0.021967340260744095, 0.06052892282605171, 0.01524408720433712, -0.014392812736332417, 0.06491163372993469, 0.005297754891216755, -0.037900280207395554, -0.041504353284835815, -0.008746335282921791, 0.0033150657545775175, 0.019661827012896538, 0.01775137148797512, -0.00658726179972291, -0.009965643286705017, -0.0018445864552631974, -0.0636444017291069, -0.07138965278863907, 0.021443258970975876, 0.005843640770763159, 0.02611071802675724, -0.015880268067121506, 0.001556804054416716, 0.1075054407119751, 0.025730494409799576, 0.0004345749330241233, 0.009806756861507893, -0.005769039504230022, -0.00779724633321166, 0.04086356237530708, 0.009103188291192055, 0.02151883952319622, -0.011181962676346302, 0.0142653314396739, -0.017363768070936203, 0.021959837526082993, 0.05368223413825035, 0.010095612145960331, 0.023273691534996033, 0.009133642539381981, 0.008608042262494564, -0.004887654446065426, 0.03785187751054764, 0.007135420106351376, -0.040242280811071396, 0.022677449509501457, -0.025184035301208496, 0.047119054943323135, 0.029114509001374245, -0.06485632807016373, 0.0149292116984725, -0.021137163043022156, 0.006394098047167063, -0.053445860743522644, 0.0548064298927784, 0.017334584146738052, -0.019459325820207596, -0.001573458081111312, -0.024119067937135696, 0.014250724576413631, -0.033938612788915634, 0.002158919582143426, 0.02413194812834263, 0.042126044631004333, -0.034755587577819824, 0.0005225622444413602, 0.001301915617659688, -0.04060990735888481, 0.005524099338799715, -0.02182205766439438, -0.007635184098035097, 0.0222484078258276, 0.05047490820288658, 0.01792646385729313, -0.02554156817495823, -0.04878740385174751, -0.029436439275741577, -0.05724790319800377, 0.025948084890842438, -0.01393423043191433, 0.022469114512205124, -0.017600495368242264, 0.04111890122294426, 0.014537336304783821, 0.021207476034760475, -0.023643547669053078, 0.01902531459927559, -0.03349634259939194, 0.010923382826149464, -0.03870447352528572, -0.045241136103868484, 0.011108764447271824, -0.0502190887928009, 0.06391249597072601, -0.008371598087251186, -0.0405350998044014, -0.03537745028734207, 0.03971752151846886, -0.006556658074259758, 0.052889708429574966, -0.040340177714824677, -0.019972868263721466, 0.026106426492333412, -0.015034083276987076, 0.020837320014834404, -0.010509745217859745, 0.07007895410060883, 0.02520637959241867, 0.01695922017097473, -0.018688460811972618, 0.010967436246573925, -0.005850886460393667, 0.053384535014629364, 0.02302725426852703, 0.04470183327794075, 0.019323233515024185, -0.04679595306515694, 0.04989556968212128, 0.0337526910007, 0.0979265570640564, 0.04342707619071007, -0.07045413553714752, -0.012344516813755035, -0.02505495958030224, -0.0368519127368927, -0.006390207912772894, 0.003478630678728223, -0.03651594743132591, 0.001274503068998456, 0.053323667496442795, 0.009345605038106441, -0.05831090733408928, 0.03846531733870506, 0.02029481716454029, -0.0059584397822618484, -0.0027512330561876297, -0.03824426233768463, 0.017261050641536713, -0.014838182367384434, -0.0242556594312191, 0.005681310780346394, 0.00765820499509573, -0.0007425423827953637, -0.007689754478633404, 0.049247659742832184, 0.00448930449783802, -0.031438443809747696, 0.012812669388949871, 0.03339994326233864, 0.008588101714849472, 0.0070131397806108, -0.03324802592396736, 0.0014479372184723616, -0.00973941758275032, 0.022236526012420654, 0.0012363307178020477, 0.026227667927742004, -0.06408488005399704, 0.005881196819245815, 0.04482234641909599, 0.052356794476509094, -0.06440244615077972, 0.01318378746509552, -0.02288261242210865, -0.008812942542135715, 0.01795170269906521, -0.023240862414240837, 0.015611106529831886, -0.03984740749001503, -0.009610192850232124, -0.04167017340660095, 0.0012032652739435434, -0.04414204880595207, -0.038184817880392075, -0.015951797366142273, 0.018166786059737206, -0.019645018503069878, -0.012469377368688583, -0.05443335697054863, 0.0017218642169609666, 0.023131102323532104, 0.09144389629364014, -0.014611135236918926, -0.0283052921295166, 0.01573742926120758, -0.0008038870291784406, -0.020081432536244392, -0.06672460585832596, 0.01406199112534523, -0.0024678714107722044, -0.018652908504009247, 0.028189105913043022, 0.010038288310170174, -0.05654243379831314, 0.05036143213510513, -0.01994418539106846, 0.0014256522990763187, -0.007810181938111782, -0.03164226561784744, 0.015880784019827843, 0.02620420604944229, 0.008941217325627804, 0.061825692653656006, -0.016462169587612152, -0.031265370547771454, 0.006937447469681501, -0.09176619350910187, 0.007023566402494907, -0.04942556843161583, 0.009882704354822636, -0.05291122943162918, -0.03048909641802311, -0.03622320666909218, 0.020328501239418983, 0.036834634840488434, 0.007435941603034735, 0.000510888930875808, -0.018005479127168655, -0.000535353843588382, 0.027048295363783836, -0.013861537910997868, 0.02602543868124485, -0.03319903090596199, 0.016248537227511406, 0.0074083530344069, 0.016550753265619278, 0.024934779852628708, -0.03242840617895126, 0.006194658111780882, 0.012006386183202267, -0.022093243896961212, 0.0020514889620244503, -0.03453638404607773, -0.030789382755756378, 0.04392421990633011, -0.05150940641760826, 0.0461311973631382, 0.012811827473342419, 0.012183679267764091, -0.01578635536134243, -0.03949742391705513, -0.05044831335544586, 0.01588890701532364, -0.005090280901640654, 0.04695022478699684, -0.01200255099684, 0.0067540607415139675, 0.0016896144952625036, -0.0015586462104693055, -0.05823809653520584, -0.019355254247784615, 0.046775754541158676, 0.020126499235630035, -0.029675519093871117, -0.010375185869634151, 0.021103806793689728, 0.0030551371164619923, -0.02073577605187893, 0.012334841303527355, 0.061745475977659225, -0.017309635877609253, -0.014253418892621994, -0.014273558743298054, 0.013049056753516197, 0.09198091924190521, -0.00477293785661459, 0.016645753756165504, -0.024287449195981026, -0.012933597899973392, -0.03187340125441551, 0.039766404777765274, 0.020340805873274803, -0.03985163941979408, -0.03250684589147568, -0.01584753952920437, 0.010989129543304443, 0.03199152275919914, -0.00964810699224472, -0.008630766533315182, 0.022257035598158836, -0.0013493777951225638, 0.021500565111637115, -0.007772208657115698, -0.020508944988250732, -0.022272607311606407, 0.01342532504349947, -0.017036650329828262, 0.0048844716511666775, 0.016324808821082115, -0.024913914501667023, 0.054348140954971313, -0.005014160647988319, -0.013014954514801502, -0.006457965355366468, 0.08243347704410553, -0.05492444336414337, 0.009535783901810646, -0.003559897420927882, -0.029101191088557243, 0.03401331230998039, 0.017550574615597725, -0.01192564982920885, 0.021004941314458847, -0.018334995955228806, -0.020620038732886314, -0.013798529282212257, -0.0521748811006546, -0.029671115800738335, 0.04886836186051369, 0.02093648724257946, 0.06721048057079315, 0.02764916606247425, 0.005411110352724791, 0.010952850803732872, -0.0018548561492934823, -0.002049458911642432, -0.009838738478720188, 0.0011539574479684234, 0.008511071093380451, -0.027372034266591072, -0.01440473087131977, 0.021551454439759254, -0.013489137403666973, -0.0020310559775680304, 0.03250966593623161, 0.02582499012351036, 0.024342110380530357, 0.0322992280125618, 0.00914844498038292, -0.039392586797475815, 0.042279381304979324, -0.04063790291547775, -0.01132624875754118, -0.017615552991628647, -0.0373258963227272, 0.029586443677544594, 0.03344199061393738, -0.027072176337242126, 0.005503321997821331, 0.01265387050807476, -0.03839896619319916, 0.00918447133153677, -0.014760347083210945, 0.026052001863718033, 0.03691625967621803, -0.015892477706074715, 0.009568585082888603, -0.01904088631272316, 0.03776397183537483, -0.0346360057592392, -0.07118064165115356, -0.028763793408870697, -0.014647646807134151, -0.07625842839479446, 0.033244721591472626, -0.028132228180766106, -0.007642876356840134, -0.0015355147188529372, -0.04748526215553284, 0.008029819466173649, 0.010900424793362617, 0.022277818992733955, -0.04877009615302086, 0.04940364509820938, 0.012958718463778496, 0.03807208687067032, 0.0014128965558484197, 0.018096113577485085, 0.11420852690935135, 0.07798634469509125, 0.021945040673017502, -0.030027445405721664, 0.027619637548923492, -0.011396296322345734, 0.021741991862654686, -0.012083140201866627, 0.0188030656427145, 0.03052215650677681, -0.005163287278264761, 0.020794520154595375, 0.009172358550131321, 0.011397079564630985, -0.02025868371129036, 0.052160296589136124, 0.0012537525035440922, -0.012281595729291439, 0.015222382731735706, 0.02132020704448223, -0.049825847148895264, -0.001483576837927103, 0.0024896517861634493, 0.01825394108891487, -0.018716098740696907, -0.009379942901432514, 0.0064309886656701565, -0.06031329557299614, -0.004376373719424009, -0.0037614027969539165, -0.02387803979218006, -0.02319859340786934, 0.007496742997318506, -0.020106779411435127, -0.01967242732644081, 0.007888143882155418, -0.027642978355288506, -0.009806714951992035, -0.022582724690437317, 0.06433199346065521, -0.023944716900587082, 0.009376274421811104, 0.002792702754959464, 0.05432974919676781, -0.012317411601543427, -0.038421664386987686, -0.07571817189455032, 0.014719436876475811, -0.017367195338010788, 0.0061304341070353985, -0.02218090556561947, -0.026231778785586357, -0.01241945568472147, -0.04905248433351517, 0.034975212067365646, 0.025630632415413857, -0.010815981775522232, -0.020695066079497337, -0.033587496727705, -0.022857939824461937, 0.01713734306395054, -0.006515477318316698, 0.010459130629897118, 0.033873993903398514, -0.019820595160126686, -0.024882439523935318, -0.023768074810504913, 0.0048521049320697784, 0.0019881902262568474, -0.015666130930185318, -0.007157830987125635, -0.021190984174609184, -0.07470894604921341, -0.006794871296733618, 0.015381221659481525, -0.012399557046592236, 0.027203068137168884, -0.02677837759256363, 0.0031537904869765043, -0.0333993062376976, -0.023442862555384636, 0.02355426736176014, -0.013144615106284618, 0.006524623837321997, -0.02787165343761444, -0.005039782263338566, 0.008831871673464775, 0.025148604065179825, 0.01615949347615242, 0.026416050270199776, -0.011211754754185677, 0.003924285992980003, 0.012790041044354439, -0.057269155979156494, -0.03842822089791298, 0.000897067366167903, -0.05799417942762375, -0.02412896789610386, 0.011143557727336884, 0.0764002650976181, 0.02320043556392193, 0.04356847703456879, 0.021515078842639923, 0.007219130173325539, 0.028814032673835754, 0.031051326543092728, 0.00830011535435915, -0.03724955767393112, -0.01931161619722843, 0.028929034247994423, 0.004022516310214996, -0.011344623751938343, -0.032133106142282486, -0.026815133169293404, -0.027027860283851624, -0.007507865317165852, -0.01043007243424654, -0.03252089396119118, -0.005444251000881195, 0.021402888000011444, -0.019013984128832817, -0.021075032651424408, -0.013145104050636292, -0.047601960599422455, 0.015981359407305717, -0.009445659816265106, 0.0025796308182179928, 0.014575761742889881, -0.006707998923957348, 0.002009118441492319, 0.002987039741128683, 0.04805797338485718, -0.00704104732722044, 0.004584182053804398, -0.03040873259305954, 0.060734473168849945, 0.023887451738119125, 0.04714992269873619, -0.018763089552521706, 0.021105432882905006, 0.06611142307519913, -0.05444849282503128, -0.04671993851661682, -0.002576118800789118, 0.01601080782711506, 0.025788575410842896, 0.015302884392440319, -0.014822670258581638, 0.0037617115303874016, 0.035271577537059784, -0.03870844468474388, -0.03424535319209099, -0.009967111982405186, 0.005586083512753248, -0.015288999304175377, 0.008062287233769894, -0.0050512393936514854, 0.013962519355118275, -0.01371458638459444, 0.03761202469468117, 0.04229510948061943, -0.024319080635905266, -0.0024338432122021914, 0.03170260414481163, 0.0024555108975619078, 0.013523575849831104, -0.030544212087988853, -0.005730119999498129, -0.00976052787154913, 0.059864092618227005, 0.0018425016896799207, 0.053436942398548126, -0.012514745816588402, 0.009672006592154503, -0.07110924273729324, -0.020649820566177368, 0.0003269920125603676, 0.03784135356545448, 0.03491748496890068, -0.03036660887300968, -0.002392987720668316, 0.057135652750730515, -0.01815621182322502, 0.009655546396970749, -0.02357606776058674, 0.005957263056188822, -0.018592361360788345, -0.002524404553696513, -0.03217136114835739, 0.022751010954380035, 0.02741437405347824, -0.0015986838843673468, -0.007277253083884716, 0.0013487469404935837, 0.0020051265601068735, -0.020099926739931107, -0.005744848400354385, 0.05633394420146942, -0.007993129082024097, -0.07437588274478912, 0.018221912905573845, -0.002052475232630968, -0.013509332202374935, 0.06412650644779205, 0.056812968105077744, 0.07201781123876572, -0.0006557511514984071, 0.02308773063123226, 0.036215890198946, 0.06590639054775238, 0.020092694088816643, 0.010260705836117268, -0.02677978202700615, -0.007973705418407917, 0.010338288731873035, 0.04492110386490822, -0.000862802320625633, 0.005535222124308348, 0.02065137028694153, -0.04450185224413872, -0.03650519624352455, 0.01962033100426197, -0.02192542515695095, -0.02250281721353531, 0.04814337566494942, -0.024934155866503716, -0.04245954751968384, 0.0006458817515522242, 0.03425181657075882, -0.044579796493053436, -0.0013130427105352283, 0.04200097173452377, 0.014407815411686897, -0.025213168933987617, 0.004417224787175655, -0.003884705947712064, -0.026165589690208435, 0.03311995044350624, -0.010372213087975979, -0.035811468958854675, -0.0218880083411932, -0.015001073479652405, -0.015956377610564232, 0.03551217168569565, 0.026812007650732994, 0.005706503987312317, -0.020171131938695908, 0.05753684043884277, -0.022838300094008446, 0.0011395623441785574, 0.006590425502508879, -0.002614376600831747, -0.008238573558628559, -0.08491957932710648, 0.11049461364746094, 0.003563952399417758, -0.026087427511811256, -0.06519786268472672, -0.005930519197136164, 0.00781975407153368, -0.031172938644886017, 0.024173084646463394, 0.05125853046774864, -0.006346738897264004, 0.013348360545933247, -0.0010826633078977466, 0.01077644620090723, -0.041752152144908905, 0.01603744737803936, 0.00005669803431374021, 0.005295315757393837, -0.032015834003686905, -0.006270327605307102, -0.009614584036171436, 0.05316565930843353, 0.021348560228943825, -0.018946196883916855, 0.03692038729786873, 0.021464016288518906, 0.014966844581067562, 0.05370422080159187, 0.031631868332624435, -0.0065357680432498455, 0.05469045788049698, -0.0001787578221410513, -0.006294611841440201, 0.03838898241519928, -0.016633478924632072, -0.05672232061624527, 0.002709712367504835, 0.009867794811725616, -0.07649310678243637, 0.011932028457522392, -0.02246806025505066, -0.016619961708784103, -0.05964115634560585, -0.04185333102941513, 0.05225839465856552, -0.044903334230184555, 0.049425769597291946, 0.042756587266922, 0.016105836257338524, 0.028579208999872208, -0.008598473854362965, 0.02848072536289692, -0.007937446236610413, -0.07161643356084824, -0.016895899549126625, -0.009624178521335125, 0.04712965339422226, -0.02465643920004368, 0.028334762901067734, 0.048594340682029724, -0.0025723183061927557, 0.011468586511909962, -0.00887264497578144, 0.049011968076229095, -0.05562082305550575, -0.01869811862707138, 0.030074644833803177, -0.018526997417211533, 0.014268185012042522, 0.022004852071404457, -0.0008019350352697074, 0.05751395970582962, -0.0072371624410152435, 0.022582801058888435, -0.027542654424905777, 0.01611674576997757, -0.03963155299425125, 0.0013795363483950496, 0.017463697120547295, -0.01993170939385891, 0.04189314693212509, -0.008191809989511967, -0.005646134726703167, 0.018669191747903824, 0.031211989000439644, -0.02081652358174324, 0.005367591977119446, -0.001070820027962327, -0.005921913776546717, -0.04241619631648064, -0.004116854630410671, -0.04272495582699776, -0.015266877599060535, 0.008986249566078186, 0.004297980573028326, 0.021314876154065132, 0.027441665530204773, -0.0621187724173069, -0.00561456847935915, 0.05001429095864296, -0.023023787885904312, 0.007394550368189812, -0.028590722009539604, 0.0533340722322464, 0.012032792903482914, -0.043796371668577194 ]
<p>I computed a feature <code>x</code> that I use to predict <code>y</code> which is a <strong>probability</strong> of being a certain class.</p> <p><strong>Raw data in R format for (x,y) is pasted here:</strong> <a href="http://tny.cz/a97b3fd0" rel="nofollow">http://tny.cz/a97b3fd0</a> (500 samples)</p> <p>plot(x,y) looks like this:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/sKoJo.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>It seems similar to a <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/83554/linear-regression-not-fitting-well">previous question</a> I asked, so I am tempted to try <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/83613/21720">this advice</a>, which I understand is the "Least Squared Fit"on log(y) (because y is a probability).</p> <p>Am I correct?</p> <p>(My objective is to minimize the MSE.)</p>
49,921
[ -0.023045672103762627, 0.006875103339552879, 0.006083265878260136, -0.010552202351391315, -0.0017149664927273989, 0.019353069365024567, 0.019183166325092316, -0.05219344422221184, 0.04399459809064865, 0.0024899221025407314, 0.04698245972394943, 0.07351349294185638, 0.075913205742836, 0.020113924518227577, 0.02256522886455059, 0.018779562786221504, -0.007304471917450428, 0.004776821006089449, 0.01207814458757639, -0.0016469476977363229, -0.044762954115867615, 0.0011705131037160754, 0.008587946183979511, -0.011827153153717518, -0.019059045240283012, 0.04987328127026558, 0.025865841656923294, 0.00944333802908659, -0.006701224017888308, 0.05566634237766266, -0.06071481853723526, -0.011850032024085522, -0.005876261740922928, 0.030165422707796097, 0.02687568962574005, 0.033293988555669785, -0.013841292820870876, -0.026406634598970413, -0.015881875529885292, 0.029007501900196075, 0.021101074293255806, 0.0013516813050955534, 0.03006422519683838, 0.05167251452803612, 0.019870541989803314, 0.03558601811528206, -0.016272656619548798, -0.021083662286400795, 0.06242385879158974, -0.016750702634453773, 0.06062614172697067, -0.014554398134350777, 0.019622480496764183, 0.02453875169157982, -0.04429839923977852, -0.033443719148635864, 0.07589329034090042, 0.05952293425798416, -0.04088447615504265, -0.05577940493822098, -0.008536427281796932, -0.032337434589862823, 0.016190992668271065, 0.00014261451724451035, -0.033052001148462296, 0.0023576931562274694, -0.012639735825359821, -0.010112252086400986, 0.05226119980216026, 0.020278200507164, 0.02840396761894226, 0.04598825424909592, 0.05373821035027504, -0.010006570257246494, 0.039753157645463943, -0.008815871551632881, 0.01100132241845131, 0.04611526429653168, 0.019365644082427025, 0.01750737801194191, -0.02263660356402397, -0.002903202548623085, 0.013531587086617947, 0.02632889151573181, 0.023119507357478142, 0.005607327912002802, 0.06377303600311279, -0.020477743819355965, 0.0019324980676174164, 0.011822580359876156, 0.00948367454111576, -0.0032020877115428448, 0.05260856822133064, 0.005425599403679371, -0.010474061593413353, 0.0594245083630085, -0.002615866018459201, 0.01393205113708973, 0.039000511169433594, -0.015499857254326344, -0.014220118522644043, -0.04582926258444786, -0.0035437815822660923, 0.026347380131483078, -0.0174330435693264, 0.0008691158727742732, -0.0247003473341465, -0.004832996986806393, 0.023328997194767, -0.03347324579954147, -0.016624990850687027, 0.010603041388094425, 0.002286123111844063, -0.014454735442996025, 0.009963907301425934, -0.025354834273457527, -0.007540627382695675, 0.01681087352335453, 0.04105621576309204, 0.015388960018754005, 0.02473370172083378, -0.016517793759703636, 0.015179232694208622, -0.03135793283581734, -0.014615671709179878, 0.0004839493485633284, 0.022246165201067924, -0.011935788206756115, -0.014432781375944614, 0.0543256476521492, -0.043249551206827164, -0.004631831776350737, 0.03344181180000305, 0.014853891916573048, 0.02664046548306942, -0.042956992983818054, -0.07443929463624954, -0.05016540735960007, 0.04055851325392723, 0.0022476064041256905, 0.013038440607488155, -0.0563204362988472, -0.04705788195133209, 0.017900846898555756, 0.05490921065211296, 0.0036351652815937996, 0.0403234139084816, 0.004020019434392452, 0.0276520736515522, -0.0036420170217752457, -0.037591155618429184, 0.0029723483603447676, -0.04398510977625847, -0.030012862756848335, -0.011907890439033508, -0.07195689529180527, -0.0003877791459672153, 0.012834818102419376, -0.028421279042959213, -0.022147081792354584, 0.035857319831848145, -0.029363762587308884, -0.013631080277264118, -0.020623015239834785, -0.021748822182416916, -0.052763815969228745, 0.09730231016874313, 0.016757357865571976, 0.01749356836080551, 0.026146767660975456, -0.06715553998947144, 0.00968998298048973, -0.005603793542832136, 0.04220603033900261, 0.03049272857606411, -0.01561999972909689, -0.006961812265217304, -0.028243975713849068, 0.055956508964300156, 0.0033480823040008545, -0.044933997094631195, -0.05336278676986694, -0.02228902466595173, -0.0214913971722126, -0.013660096563398838, 0.041600678116083145, -0.010332446545362473, -0.035550471395254135, 0.05909505859017372, -0.045476850122213364, -0.06712090969085693, -0.055161211639642715, -0.009975045919418335, -0.0056081730872392654, -0.01920897327363491, 0.002092083916068077, -0.0035516575444489717, 0.00419484032317996, -0.031846482306718826, -0.00708871940150857, -0.0299693513661623, -0.026653015986084938, 0.03788945823907852, -0.01817251555621624, -0.008256925269961357, 0.022233370691537857, 0.008902695961296558, -0.027926798909902573, 0.024880778044462204, -0.049643624573946, -0.031199194490909576, 0.01561607513576746, -0.0016233617207035422, 0.006613397970795631, 0.008541204035282135, -0.012235123664140701, 0.0089105274528265, 0.0029381581116467714, -0.0028783914167433977, 0.01743064448237419, -0.04292129725217819, 0.02247900515794754, 0.03009060025215149, 0.02357078716158867, -0.03779734671115875, -0.012237798422574997, -0.021694457158446312, 0.03363402560353279, -0.030054738745093346, 0.009424333460628986, -0.037744052708148956, -0.0157717727124691, 0.032277852296829224, -0.0029161819256842136, -0.03747081756591797, -0.01016896404325962, 0.04196639358997345, 0.000230737728998065, 0.017445707693696022, 0.04320256784558296, -0.024415910243988037, -0.023014556616544724, 0.022613557055592537, 0.01134695764631033, -0.00746145099401474, 0.005121387541294098, 0.012849701568484306, 0.04146317020058632, 0.01865527033805847, 0.005041012540459633, 0.019711975008249283, 0.058918099850416183, -0.011417052708566189, -0.025322621688246727, -0.013824516907334328, 0.0051941461861133575, 0.07844104617834091, -0.02246137149631977, 0.021083340048789978, 0.056403618305921555, 0.004464790225028992, -0.012537127360701561, -0.021812818944454193, -0.010807991959154606, 0.00856083631515503, 0.026373013854026794, -0.03943615406751633, 0.009304249659180641, 0.020630264654755592, -0.03957492113113403, -0.006145074963569641, -0.008700259029865265, -0.05328773707151413, -0.039182763546705246, 0.05163038522005081, 0.05983748286962509, -0.0002331620780751109, 0.01009443774819374, -0.03284503519535065, -0.054914556443691254, 0.016486696898937225, -0.0141811054199934, 0.04132135584950447, -0.015403689816594124, -0.048059944063425064, -0.029397690668702126, -0.03525839373469353, -0.010767919011414051, 0.021628616377711296, -0.013976816087961197, -0.02253737673163414, 0.011618752032518387, -0.03816243261098862, -0.031049322336912155, -0.027527207508683205, -0.013382024131715298, 0.04512261971831322, 0.01758725568652153, -0.021454492583870888, 0.03558607026934624, -0.020423855632543564, -0.0472632497549057, 0.001529910252429545, -0.03680641949176788, -0.027906863018870354, -0.0394817553460598, 0.004614353179931641, -0.009768353775143623, 0.028887653723359108, 0.007163177710026503, 0.05731462687253952, 0.005493501201272011, -0.00018543715123087168, -0.0653381198644638, -0.05101422965526581, 0.009011239744722843, 0.007038697134703398, 0.01725064031779766, 0.0014145022723823786, -0.005072609055787325, 0.060288574546575546, 0.06097613647580147, -0.04039992764592171, -0.05275372415781021, -0.021723462268710136, -0.021233312785625458, -0.020088456571102142, 0.006513649597764015, 0.005230704788118601, 0.021920114755630493, 0.0189718846231699, -0.008801613934338093, 0.01830422878265381, 0.01617017574608326, -0.01378194522112608, 0.01541850809007883, 0.022606410086154938, -0.02390803024172783, -0.03358545899391174, 0.035206135362386703, 0.022925209254026413, -0.031202727928757668, 0.04125325754284859, 0.01144737470895052, 0.01932612806558609, 0.00819751899689436, -0.06855787336826324, 0.019605347886681557, -0.011987288482487202, 0.011798462830483913, -0.009782941080629826, 0.018649721518158913, 0.01583029516041279, -0.034893475472927094, 0.01811201497912407, 0.0025708326138556004, -0.0022967520635575056, 0.0059332167729735374, -0.02197301760315895, 0.05227971449494362, 0.04382576420903206, 0.01219747494906187, -0.016692250967025757, -0.02288156934082508, -0.014974286779761314, -0.007909245789051056, -0.009745072573423386, -0.02108372375369072, 0.02625090815126896, 0.04119301959872246, 0.027930419892072678, 0.00047672033542767167, -0.05916150286793709, 0.018531329929828644, -0.051488347351551056, 0.0037810197100043297, -0.013680657371878624, 0.057402804493904114, 0.03687886893749237, 0.023148581385612488, 0.014793825335800648, -0.011924316175282001, 0.016613254323601723, 0.012140446342527866, -0.07856269925832748, 0.06506958603858948, 0.00718695716932416, -0.004811124410480261, 0.004058369901031256, -0.023396650329232216, 0.04925542324781418, -0.04040055721998215, 0.026594720780849457, 0.03921324014663696, 0.026743989437818527, -0.0287728700786829, -0.012644920498132706, -0.0005412566242739558, -0.0027026343159377575, -0.033398039638996124, -0.01699163019657135, 0.0059652929194271564, 0.02049117349088192, 0.04793853685259819, 0.05149679258465767, -0.004193056840449572, 0.003796935547143221, -0.010231687687337399, 0.03973488509654999, 0.006707586348056793, 0.06649384647607803, 0.005021197721362114, 0.014277709648013115, -0.04250470548868179, 0.028892433270812035, -0.004967715125530958, 0.04861690476536751, 0.05143658444285393, 0.002286777598783374, -0.02054578624665737, -0.004962162114679813, -0.015319465659558773, 0.028894169256091118, -0.002497531473636627, -0.008151456713676453, 0.015585426241159439, 0.05814270302653313, 0.031209370121359825, -0.07899990677833557, 0.007882077246904373, 0.09250404685735703, 0.00026986125158146024, -0.03210217133164406, -0.008614170365035534, -0.004927437752485275, -0.004881835542619228, 0.036533355712890625, 0.01950220763683319, -0.000959722907282412, -0.015404452569782734, -0.052620332688093185, 0.04265608265995979, 0.008287138305604458, -0.015187344513833523, 0.0019114839378744364, 0.011885394342243671, 0.03494412451982498, -0.018040340393781662, -0.05237279087305069, 0.006509547121822834, 0.05796926096081734, 0.01566569320857525, 0.03440004214644432, 0.013891604728996754, -0.077077217400074, -0.023849595338106155, 0.030981365591287613, 0.05171168968081474, -0.05005712807178497, -0.028952544555068016, -0.04674529284238815, -0.015794895589351654, 0.013310909271240234, -0.04509781673550606, 0.02328936569392681, -0.024691268801689148, 0.04276305437088013, -0.011506571434438229, -0.022136837244033813, -0.07570476830005646, 0.018282964825630188, 0.0117532042786479, 0.03025679849088192, -0.030225886031985283, -0.03828071802854538, -0.04508855938911438, 0.007214331068098545, -0.0007975085754878819, 0.02511664293706417, -0.07298456877470016, -0.032070767134428024, 0.004866133444011211, 0.018578149378299713, -0.017715437337756157, -0.06222514808177948, 0.012808390893042088, -0.0035370266996324062, -0.01353382971137762, 0.02691216953098774, -0.003874704474583268, -0.04610229283571243, 0.042150676250457764, 0.041990336030721664, -0.017496010288596153, 0.008870315738022327, -0.02177175134420395, 0.02239539846777916, 0.033644113689661026, 0.03333767130970955, 0.0338125117123127, 0.05017842724919319, -0.0028115275781601667, -0.011840094812214375, -0.05884847417473793, 0.012180115096271038, 0.0033661394845694304, -0.01811092719435692, -0.04195627570152283, -0.0056993491016328335, -0.024923648685216904, 0.017251551151275635, -0.0023001909721642733, 0.015546346083283424, -0.03867227956652641, -0.019381122663617134, -0.015864182263612747, 0.0004559907247312367, -0.0188986137509346, 0.0006784592405892909, 0.013974960893392563, 0.008245555683970451, -0.01000603474676609, -0.011698716320097446, 0.008001571521162987, -0.003795912954956293, 0.010342285968363285, 0.04411033168435097, -0.03481101989746094, 0.0043517351150512695, -0.018334295600652695, -0.05017048865556717, 0.002088607754558325, -0.03364688903093338, 0.022772690281271935, 0.0029219812713563442, 0.01642177440226078, 0.014073929749429226, -0.03377765044569969, 0.008948729373514652, 0.01656767912209034, 0.021811887621879578, 0.017710477113723755, -0.053115349262952805, 0.06403311342000961, -0.03744359686970711, -0.02411630190908909, -0.05753997340798378, -0.03597567602992058, 0.01474368292838335, 0.0075821224600076675, -0.05672613903880119, -0.06452954560518265, -0.029288727790117264, -0.01996142603456974, 0.004589525982737541, -0.018724264577031136, 0.020313825458288193, -0.04808007553219795, -0.04249998927116394, -0.002845869865268469, 0.016877353191375732, 0.08184179663658142, 0.017278224229812622, -0.006529116537421942, 0.04424487426877022, 0.012585763819515705, -0.0006166819948703051, -0.0002941060229204595, 0.029997242614626884, -0.058903858065605164, -0.006151720881462097, -0.03118642419576645, 0.006665848195552826, 0.05740397050976753, -0.012843942269682884, 0.0026376210153102875, 0.020477689802646637, 0.0026850819122046232, 0.024633187800645828, -0.03228181228041649, 0.010800131596624851, -0.012823827564716339, 0.011176861822605133, 0.0006130135152488947, 0.01122438907623291, -0.01753840781748295, 0.01532694697380066, 0.03219958022236824, 0.010445219464600086, 0.009657719172537327, 0.04109586775302887, 0.0693703442811966, 0.021803809329867363, 0.011302131228148937, -0.030618485063314438, -0.016219984740018845, 0.051392070949077606, 0.03536951541900635, 0.015287660993635654, 0.022434750571846962, 0.06960797309875488, -0.023280467838048935, -0.020840628072619438, -0.054896075278520584, -0.0013806630158796906, 0.04589342698454857, -0.024836033582687378, 0.03217025101184845, 0.052758779376745224, -0.026853002607822418, -0.010698094964027405, -0.011110953986644745, -0.021338097751140594, -0.030260425060987473, 0.03770880401134491, 0.032280970364809036, 0.0011566780740395188, -0.012607269920408726, 0.02919555827975273, -0.0373457595705986, 0.04165537282824516, 0.030295725911855698, 0.007665522862225771, -0.0017284075729548931, 0.04153959080576897, -0.010443671606481075, -0.05698075145483017, 0.02088097296655178, -0.017347030341625214, 0.019344210624694824, -0.02396717667579651, -0.03467288985848427, 0.01895708218216896, 0.026435120031237602, 0.015379373915493488, -0.026022084057331085, -0.01203108485788107, -0.031623393297195435, -0.03678251430392265, 0.031615544110536575, -0.010041821748018265, 0.029458409175276756, 0.0014455638593062758, -0.0005569910863414407, 0.021596604958176613, 0.03414275869727135, -0.027613557875156403, -0.06622975319623947, -0.011007961817085743, 0.001479250960983336, -0.029641736298799515, 0.04065368324518204, 0.014134306460618973, -0.025259627029299736, 0.04595515877008438, -0.05127420648932457, 0.023699332028627396, 0.011896505951881409, 0.037306416779756546, 0.023088272660970688, 0.06596639752388, 0.0076095350086688995, -0.007226934190839529, -0.04236501455307007, -0.01242201030254364, 0.11776904761791229, 0.0948791652917862, 0.05044730380177498, -0.07284083217382431, 0.024688618257641792, -0.03255506604909897, -0.0062319557182490826, 0.011585256084799767, -0.027743013575673103, 0.004295207094401121, -0.007305763196200132, 0.04816339164972305, 0.04160667955875397, 0.006240242160856724, 0.0061726816929876804, 0.03380335494875908, -0.048352353274822235, -0.020198505371809006, 0.020639676600694656, -0.003684958443045616, 0.019190264865756035, -0.04633462429046631, -0.050750359892845154, -0.005689877085387707, 0.0023642960004508495, -0.02800685353577137, 0.0032639855053275824, -0.02009173110127449, 0.001357998582534492, -0.021955184638500214, -0.0158601813018322, 0.006166001781821251, 0.030890757218003273, 0.004354243166744709, 0.01558392308652401, 0.004104762338101864, 0.0358954519033432, -0.022198930382728577, 0.019819656386971474, 0.04106364771723747, 0.0024357540532946587, 0.0052688405849039555, 0.02673753909766674, -0.01720593310892582, -0.03191373869776726, -0.03579716756939888, -0.05037537217140198, 0.029186049476265907, 0.006914389785379171, -0.013275553472340107, 0.005340146832168102, 0.015340378507971764, 0.006863879039883614, -0.02292768657207489, -0.001750853843986988, 0.009181060828268528, 0.03360159695148468, -0.009774569422006607, -0.03573981299996376, -0.010808898136019707, 0.020101699978113174, -0.021536480635404587, 0.013589795678853989, 0.03860969468951225, -0.017715902999043465, -0.009365761652588844, -0.017572058364748955, 0.043240319937467575, 0.01969732716679573, 0.02419186383485794, -0.009466699324548244, -0.03403646871447563, -0.02712855488061905, -0.05899491906166077, 0.03670908510684967, 0.013385588303208351, 0.010608343407511711, -0.006979368627071381, -0.012555715627968311, -0.018308458849787712, -0.07579024136066437, 0.038243889808654785, -0.01858511194586754, 0.008830768056213856, -0.06199363246560097, 0.01680278219282627, 0.007342004682868719, 0.059758082032203674, 0.04075761139392853, 0.013008734211325645, 0.008658521808683872, 0.04875785484910011, 0.012271763756871223, -0.04345913976430893, -0.04207513853907585, 0.03766420856118202, -0.03361024335026741, 0.017375260591506958, 0.028816010802984238, 0.05971723049879074, 0.012768079526722431, 0.037827156484127045, 0.00572391040623188, -0.010855094529688358, -0.027801917865872383, -0.0055221449583768845, -0.018162259832024574, -0.04995033144950867, -0.001496724085882306, 0.005274693947285414, -0.006071774289011955, -0.03905384615063667, -0.018151091411709785, -0.038324516266584396, -0.0498729944229126, 0.009356952272355556, -0.0034349681809544563, -0.03819059580564499, 0.04623381048440933, 0.007329441141337156, -0.004097010474652052, -0.04418965056538582, -0.02757703699171543, -0.010552492924034595, -0.012859433889389038, -0.009289352223277092, -0.026040371507406235, -0.038106050342321396, 0.020843379199504852, 0.007086009252816439, 0.007037979084998369, 0.0057006170973181725, 0.009432204999029636, 0.03763098642230034, -0.0012215188471600413, 0.008284836076200008, -0.03235184773802757, 0.041495177894830704, -0.04692447930574417, -0.007826832123100758, 0.01611703261733055, -0.0532035157084465, -0.0448475182056427, 0.02402852475643158, -0.049073319882154465, 0.03246933966875076, 0.023087048903107643, 0.008326145820319653, -0.017453348264098167, 0.06154986098408699, 0.011940510012209415, -0.0025198624935001135, 0.0014652041718363762, 0.020510759204626083, 0.03754279762506485, 0.011951148509979248, 0.000781134411226958, 0.012688866816461086, -0.018381016328930855, 0.01191760040819645, 0.06344249844551086, -0.01106600183993578, -0.03974965214729309, 0.003656302811577916, -0.0034558710176497698, 0.01996573433279991, 0.004770386964082718, 0.0028420083690434694, 0.04668290540575981, 0.031297098845243454, -0.030176812782883644, 0.01574934460222721, -0.016431577503681183, 0.014171578921377659, -0.0963326096534729, -0.030448347330093384, 0.02853442169725895, 0.018362656235694885, 0.049151014536619186, -0.06684932112693787, -0.013813728466629982, 0.02860666997730732, -0.05092408508062363, -0.012914453633129597, 0.011110411956906319, 0.025534827262163162, -0.06277874857187271, 0.04172070324420929, -0.02547249011695385, 0.010227947495877743, 0.0218821968883276, 0.02648763731122017, 0.03861192241311073, 0.031118344515562057, 0.0055859885178506374, -0.024141797795891762, -0.010547712445259094, 0.03572526574134827, 0.026481881737709045, -0.07400345802307129, 0.040265925228595734, -0.04854891821742058, -0.0393371656537056, 0.05860718712210655, 0.0018228620756417513, 0.05606549605727196, 0.0364278182387352, 0.015241116285324097, -0.010614631697535515, 0.026380639523267746, 0.03275414556264877, -0.037480100989341736, 0.013823119923472404, 0.012939122505486012, 0.021810615435242653, 0.02890082821249962, -0.008537614718079567, 0.016281886026263237, 0.0010960291838273406, -0.028667734935879707, -0.036694929003715515, 0.02736223302781582, 0.0022198765072971582, 0.002398301148787141, -0.02190498448908329, 0.011604990810155869, 0.004754002671688795, -0.041450951248407364, 0.004206117242574692, -0.057828012853860855, 0.034716907888650894, 0.06939355283975601, 0.01880226843059063, 0.01194828376173973, 0.010613281279802322, -0.02093491517007351, -0.06708157062530518, 0.004085317719727755, -0.01365493331104517, -0.009810962714254856, -0.03216390684247017, 0.02178928069770336, -0.0020880987867712975, -0.041596900671720505, 0.0012254834873601794, -0.03097439557313919, -0.041175276041030884, 0.027465712279081345, -0.013892041519284248, 0.025577841326594353, 0.03299420699477196, -0.004302464425563812, 0.0215210672467947, -0.0838262289762497, 0.06792329251766205, -0.00047127099242061377, -0.01719733327627182, -0.03881856054067612, -0.004524044692516327, -0.026079731062054634, 0.030009571462869644, 0.03120463341474533, -0.004887061659246683, 0.020719118416309357, -0.00014877408102620393, 0.042956795543432236, -0.001547423074953258, -0.010772992856800556, 0.04258143901824951, -0.0002927504538092762, -0.022762667387723923, -0.02038673311471939, -0.029512036591768265, -0.009805228561162949, -0.013675357215106487, 0.04079402610659599, -0.027276592329144478, 0.0031589404679834843, -0.008376608602702618, -0.009351305663585663, 0.009013557806611061, -0.013561325147747993, -0.009212908335030079, 0.0685841292142868, 0.03826871141791344, -0.016725124791264534, 0.03739162161946297, -0.0039940811693668365, -0.041532933712005615, 0.01714060828089714, -0.020502643659710884, -0.025453252717852592, 0.04255414381623268, 0.01494876854121685, 0.010414350777864456, -0.055164434015750885, 0.0003022071032319218, 0.04626477509737015, 0.008042851462960243, -0.027857581153512, 0.043874405324459076, 0.02947331964969635, 0.062443025410175323, 0.0011121620191261172, 0.01831049658358097, 0.0025063245557248592, -0.03832527622580528, -0.007350943051278591, -0.028102463111281395, 0.025586361065506935, -0.025230400264263153, 0.004881940316408873, 0.02966449409723282, -0.0007445505470968783, 0.01830737665295601, -0.012863239273428917, 0.0625738874077797, -0.024654487147927284, -0.009993238374590874, 0.03759787231683731, -0.03601916506886482, 0.010295954532921314, -0.0002942007267847657, -0.029769690707325935, 0.04127436503767967, -0.04915090650320053, 0.006380267441272736, -0.040761660784482956, -0.040456097573041916, -0.027234915643930435, 0.012511304579675198, 0.020619802176952362, 0.007360882591456175, -0.0007204686407931149, 0.014181913807988167, 0.006800808943808079, -0.017905469983816147, 0.03397510573267937, -0.010327238589525223, 0.01145974826067686, -0.02480195090174675, -0.012892365455627441, -0.006089752074331045, -0.007255464792251587, 0.015266885980963707, -0.019548308104276657, 0.02040651999413967, 0.06713729351758957, -0.0156941469758749, -0.0522034727036953, -0.026987427845597267, -0.0027684858068823814, 0.06568337976932526, -0.054074883460998535, 0.010787242092192173, -0.03642668575048447, -0.0029587543103843927, 0.020426254719495773, -0.08508700132369995 ]
<p>I'm working on my final project, and it's a QUEST algorithm, and it uses the chi-square test. I have a problem where the expected value = 0. </p> <ol> <li>What should I do? </li> <li>What does it imply to the chi-square test or to the QUEST algorithm?</li> </ol>
73,650
[ -0.004696977324783802, -0.07111957669258118, 0.003092139260843396, -0.017400208860635757, 0.04208403453230858, 0.03536124899983406, -0.006809405982494354, -0.003705156035721302, 0.0033710056450217962, -0.0005983210867270827, 0.05095866695046425, 0.05194145068526268, 0.010686811991035938, 0.03800549730658531, -0.006498572416603565, 0.020253919064998627, -0.021817296743392944, -0.014851746149361134, -0.04038139805197716, 0.009683406911790371, -0.027614282444119453, 0.03581186756491661, 0.0076300641521811485, -0.006632375530898571, -0.0795658603310585, 0.022704994305968285, 0.05287237465381622, -0.05552031099796295, -0.00937193538993597, 0.06970584392547607, -0.058198072016239166, -0.014627769589424133, -0.0011472931364551187, 0.020022761076688766, 0.031436797231435776, -0.0005943416617810726, -0.015145925804972649, 0.001246563158929348, -0.02138972282409668, 0.026681141927838326, -0.008193539455533028, 0.013882528990507126, 0.018481438979506493, 0.045628052204847336, -0.028956213966012, 0.05170046165585518, 0.008947915397584438, -0.029911043122410774, 0.019035179167985916, -0.03634365275502205, 0.05648740381002426, 0.007701955735683441, 0.014492850750684738, 0.009594853036105633, 0.01673438772559166, -0.027018871158361435, 0.01582060568034649, 0.04605667293071747, 0.0002770923310890794, -0.07258126139640808, -0.007016032002866268, -0.029673755168914795, 0.008083083666861057, 0.00032026038388721645, -0.03401622176170349, 0.027522390708327293, 0.008891631849110126, -0.02468753792345524, 0.017330190166831017, -0.009907681494951248, -0.0024944383185356855, 0.06596468389034271, 0.026796065270900726, -0.026924949139356613, 0.01616819202899933, -0.02549027092754841, 0.014802047982811928, 0.04531316086649895, 0.016998231410980225, 0.006956071127206087, 0.03206156566739082, 0.01745864935219288, 0.03308313712477684, 0.029027162119746208, 0.012626390904188156, -0.019822677597403526, 0.04903305321931839, -0.04059647023677826, -0.01453898474574089, 0.031754955649375916, -0.004908958915621042, 0.009248253889381886, 0.056578975170850754, -0.006648718379437923, -0.04954370856285095, 0.046513088047504425, -0.010806447826325893, 0.06269940733909607, -0.01796453818678856, -0.03378945589065552, -0.00926862470805645, -0.037309430539608, 0.016315752640366554, 0.048280760645866394, -0.04771203547716141, 0.01727430894970894, -0.023659110069274902, 0.02638235129415989, -0.00020270772802177817, -0.03620515763759613, 0.0005536445532925427, 0.050979260355234146, 0.02117321640253067, 0.03315747529268265, 0.01778740994632244, -0.03141505643725395, -0.02706761844456196, -0.04312009736895561, 0.04607772082090378, 0.043386951088905334, 0.03495778515934944, -0.03319405019283295, 0.030180925503373146, -0.010919881984591484, -0.02758391574025154, 0.0019677134696394205, -0.013102501630783081, -0.010766034945845604, -0.04533134400844574, 0.05048973858356476, -0.010590576566755772, -0.009951544925570488, 0.009216454811394215, 0.009246442466974258, 0.012732661329209805, 0.007519887760281563, -0.07769744098186493, -0.0685790479183197, 0.029088379815220833, -0.018216541036963463, -0.020450998097658157, -0.07762078940868378, -0.01690385490655899, 0.03260637819766998, 0.0906466469168663, -0.013978097587823868, 0.036969441920518875, -0.005631269421428442, 0.03073134273290634, 0.012583575211465359, -0.02995871752500534, -0.005251430440694094, -0.056816473603248596, -0.050555676221847534, 0.03677581995725632, -0.05097608268260956, 0.0022838471923023462, 0.006814568769186735, 0.00006373794167302549, -0.030994510278105736, -0.009386638179421425, -0.008711391128599644, -0.004138775169849396, 0.006052831653505564, 0.004186294507235289, -0.013104734010994434, 0.11352726817131042, 0.040950875729322433, -0.02832011505961418, 0.036246173083782196, 0.015687335282564163, 0.041200071573257446, 0.011751582846045494, 0.0344357006251812, 0.08994577825069427, -0.021629195660352707, 0.005458031315356493, -0.040005866438150406, 0.02932273969054222, 0.009081358090043068, -0.041326940059661865, -0.0307117011398077, 0.008087790571153164, 0.02596154622733593, 0.010056624189019203, 0.03638729453086853, -0.010253164917230606, -0.005552374292165041, 0.0487375371158123, -0.026921477168798447, -0.0782722532749176, -0.08526598662137985, 0.021422671154141426, 0.044803909957408905, -0.020109230652451515, -0.04183335229754448, 0.04164888709783554, 0.00601787306368351, -0.020771624520421028, -0.010609247721731663, -0.010175306349992752, -0.011964443139731884, -0.007815681397914886, -0.042448289692401886, -0.018374871462583542, 0.07269544154405594, 0.014325383119285107, -0.05465726554393768, 0.02841937728226185, -0.02234683185815811, -0.03976630046963692, -0.005070656072348356, -0.002432376379147172, 0.012635373510420322, -0.013308797962963581, 0.029152926057577133, -0.0019456582376733422, 0.009380935691297054, -0.0026291864924132824, 0.0445866696536541, -0.049046095460653305, 0.07169017940759659, 0.028963083401322365, 0.0062965648248791695, 0.027312781661748886, -0.009206426329910755, 0.004282306879758835, 0.012851465493440628, -0.010057087056338787, -0.000446203543106094, -0.046347130089998245, -0.004022195935249329, 0.03217170387506485, -0.0268190186470747, -0.04955277219414711, 0.003932020161300898, 0.06629058718681335, -0.0012946638744324446, -0.01433627400547266, 0.042211271822452545, -0.00024752566241659224, 0.03784197196364403, 0.009589281864464283, 0.018564408645033836, 0.011131304316222668, 0.04262232407927513, 0.0195459071546793, 0.008190040476620197, -0.02018114924430847, 0.000017345500964438543, -0.031910452991724014, 0.05380530282855034, -0.022343168035149574, 0.03419557213783264, -0.016382373869419098, -0.010806094855070114, 0.02228870987892151, -0.011604594066739082, -0.005192846059799194, 0.02250955067574978, -0.00860881432890892, 0.006865162402391434, -0.01451086811721325, -0.018602922558784485, 0.03185158222913742, 0.0276026614010334, -0.03394871577620506, 0.0007287365733645856, 0.04965106397867203, -0.018724510446190834, 0.01452606450766325, -0.012823217548429966, -0.03286737948656082, -0.044407472014427185, 0.023641861975193024, 0.03208491578698158, -0.0030698978807777166, 0.015695534646511078, -0.038587018847465515, -0.0693984404206276, -0.014337546192109585, -0.04767261818051338, 0.013082017190754414, 0.03971876576542854, -0.02092333510518074, 0.0008873007609508932, -0.04045970365405083, -0.04859812557697296, 0.0336160883307457, 0.028035303577780724, 0.00304502435028553, 0.06344472616910934, -0.011743548326194286, -0.013235317543148994, 0.006139496807008982, -0.05942264571785927, 0.0018349408637732267, -0.0409955270588398, -0.005088464356958866, 0.04425959661602974, 0.004181165713816881, -0.04771459847688675, 0.06610430777072906, -0.040160030126571655, -0.007350192870944738, -0.033313192427158356, -0.011326366104185581, 0.007508574519306421, -0.025151284411549568, 0.024095585569739342, -0.0020895875059068203, 0.019185971468687057, 0.018857864663004875, -0.06391067057847977, -0.057448700070381165, 0.001750229625031352, -0.014492275193333626, -0.004365132190287113, 0.01662248931825161, -0.010538781061768532, 0.07810048013925552, 0.01856105774641037, -0.011253411881625652, -0.025383591651916504, -0.011081895790994167, -0.03757002204656601, -0.015163719654083252, 0.025939589366316795, 0.014878042973577976, -0.0193330030888319, 0.018978968262672424, -0.038777757436037064, 0.03387950733304024, 0.042761385440826416, 0.028540335595607758, -0.011002885177731514, 0.0036911917850375175, -0.0027335435152053833, -0.002656160620972514, 0.024699855595827103, 0.02125518210232258, -0.012889748439192772, 0.0073495060205459595, 0.03051145188510418, 0.013528996147215366, 0.01030049379914999, -0.018424075096845627, 0.005050095729529858, -0.0489925742149353, 0.025089886039495468, -0.027177076786756516, 0.06608035415410995, 0.006189313251525164, -0.004057750105857849, 0.009122553281486034, -0.006842292379587889, 0.023227456957101822, -0.012950348667800426, -0.022507216781377792, 0.034665435552597046, -0.003849472850561142, -0.0013329406501725316, -0.030507534742355347, -0.04664111137390137, -0.013450047932565212, 0.0010780100710690022, -0.021206850185990334, -0.02838173136115074, 0.024799341335892677, 0.08016525208950043, 0.0064514740370213985, -0.0005023482954129577, -0.019929204136133194, -0.006349803879857063, -0.06020073592662811, -0.016752449795603752, -0.0031661016400903463, 0.06904280930757523, 0.031369373202323914, 0.05522998794913292, 0.041648704558610916, -0.024046290665864944, -0.0012609537225216627, 0.024388793855905533, -0.09392977505922318, 0.011743094772100449, -0.019106421619653702, -0.02082652971148491, -0.016341673210263252, -0.03005085699260235, 0.013712571002542973, -0.0201062373816967, 0.011776200495660305, 0.03211431950330734, 0.03418746963143349, -0.026070622727274895, 0.026089273393154144, -0.0005477043450810015, 0.03505818173289299, -0.021175596863031387, 0.0071262395940721035, 0.01237150002270937, 0.022685149684548378, 0.022754603996872902, 0.020209548994898796, -0.0033134883269667625, -0.03827865049242973, 0.02225598134100437, 0.0012155055301263928, 0.024195289239287376, 0.037630628794431686, -0.0009290617890655994, 0.03277852386236191, -0.032058678567409515, 0.01684369333088398, -0.01150564569979906, 0.046136196702718735, 0.005933946929872036, -0.005793574266135693, 0.005978592671453953, -0.022173888981342316, -0.016316337510943413, -0.00793958269059658, 0.015104447491466999, 0.020297158509492874, 0.004790639039129019, 0.04206804931163788, 0.005271731410175562, -0.011171986348927021, 0.0005333271692506969, 0.07021185010671616, 0.03366904705762863, -0.006229355465620756, 0.01156037300825119, -0.020282374694943428, -0.04885869100689888, -0.016237430274486542, -0.0061104451306164265, -0.011875055730342865, 0.011293826624751091, 0.00019707328465301543, 0.019342314451932907, -0.014132499694824219, -0.022164344787597656, -0.026585329324007034, 0.003663612063974142, 0.04681669548153877, -0.023289864882826805, -0.02359243668615818, 0.01339921448379755, 0.05152030661702156, 0.023227283731102943, 0.009061586111783981, 0.01398032158613205, -0.07231873273849487, -0.015031733550131321, 0.053192559629678726, 0.05613624304533005, -0.034888334572315216, -0.005233244504779577, -0.06386565417051315, 0.030633244663476944, 0.011977524496614933, -0.06537719815969467, -0.006293569225817919, 0.0025073906872421503, 0.0003573146532289684, -0.021941199898719788, 0.011688705533742905, -0.0368623360991478, 0.0064001139253377914, -0.019579675048589706, 0.047497961670160294, -0.02603866346180439, -0.029974132776260376, -0.03948219493031502, 0.0007394443964585662, 0.03977470472455025, 0.044467538595199585, -0.03217101842164993, -0.0005294079310260713, 0.011787011288106441, 0.04675590619444847, -0.026189949363470078, -0.04393675923347473, 0.01982143521308899, -0.023220565170049667, 0.04116971045732498, 0.06655904650688171, -0.04960690438747406, -0.05068734660744667, -0.009112817235291004, -0.021631615236401558, -0.046411920338869095, -0.0009050139924511313, -0.018193282186985016, 0.0038448460400104523, 0.018718505278229713, 0.023191936314105988, 0.05713079497218132, 0.006894410587847233, -0.015031560324132442, -0.019804399460554123, -0.03535415977239609, 0.008331865072250366, -0.04089393466711044, 0.02713717333972454, -0.04605937376618385, -0.001743778120726347, -0.02791908197104931, 0.0225977785885334, -0.007136491592973471, 0.054861295968294144, -0.04238709434866905, 0.02040964923799038, -0.0011670015519484878, 0.005825645290315151, 0.0048218355514109135, 0.013667900115251541, 0.009725532494485378, -0.0027935204561799765, 0.003504222258925438, -0.005239726509898901, 0.01740894466638565, -0.014150440692901611, 0.0220052320510149, 0.019404402002692223, -0.02760317735373974, 0.03509184345602989, -0.029422949999570847, -0.041296474635601044, 0.00959671288728714, -0.03269410878419876, 0.039262790232896805, -0.020340457558631897, 0.023102017119526863, 0.003921492490917444, 0.026662534102797508, -0.03196454048156738, -0.01156333927065134, -0.022867506369948387, 0.04899244382977486, -0.04589957371354103, 0.029332315549254417, 0.02539311908185482, 0.023040592670440674, -0.05612486973404884, -0.039576027542352676, -0.01726684160530567, 0.012862617149949074, 0.004142208490520716, -0.01630154810845852, -0.03628389909863472, -0.003774517448619008, -0.0497896783053875, -0.034685567021369934, 0.07644300907850266, 0.021746331825852394, -0.007514318451285362, 0.020634010434150696, 0.012949032709002495, 0.08258901536464691, 0.03016529232263565, -0.0039017789531499147, 0.028712885454297066, -0.012181269936263561, -0.02913700044155121, -0.0023273734841495752, 0.01896100677549839, -0.05057693272829056, -0.05252420902252197, -0.0026180301792919636, 0.026486560702323914, 0.047318704426288605, -0.006594853475689888, -0.006540342234075069, -0.008603746071457863, -0.00031750660855323076, -0.03725103288888931, -0.029497168958187103, -0.003575375769287348, -0.005863330326974392, -0.005497386213392019, 0.010518661700189114, -0.019208284094929695, -0.012465483509004116, -0.02345055155456066, 0.011361824348568916, -0.01041635125875473, -0.011736034415662289, -0.02550802007317543, 0.055915772914886475, -0.005025989376008511, -0.05217951908707619, -0.020308438688516617, -0.02516753599047661, -0.01964525505900383, 0.010504781268537045, 0.000394438742659986, 0.004536265041679144, 0.030971452593803406, -0.025734828785061836, -0.009484395384788513, -0.010611874982714653, 0.008708517998456955, 0.03916283696889877, 0.029247859492897987, 0.03563275188207626, 0.041788019239902496, 0.023620352149009705, -0.019255397841334343, -0.0006552683189511299, 0.0007398585439659655, -0.005024544429033995, 0.028002209961414337, 0.008016207255423069, 0.007602967321872711, 0.008934919722378254, 0.05482715368270874, 0.0077399020083248615, 0.020983384922146797, 0.033009592443704605, 0.0549689456820488, 0.011378433555364609, 0.01431297603994608, -0.033596158027648926, -0.036048613488674164, 0.03832220286130905, -0.030442185699939728, 0.021166978403925896, -0.009967266581952572, 0.045021217316389084, 0.07170014083385468, 0.05045018345117569, -0.009738333523273468, -0.029480105265975, -0.0046401238068938255, -0.05095715448260307, -0.013955448754131794, 0.017653923481702805, -0.025374887511134148, 0.022878624498844147, 0.005017595831304789, 0.013353297486901283, 0.013869091868400574, 0.04558512568473816, -0.02858920209109783, -0.0826026052236557, 0.01229283306747675, 0.0039031715132296085, -0.023380868136882782, 0.015453078784048557, 0.021712644025683403, -0.017582222819328308, -0.007572310045361519, -0.031114574521780014, 0.01631998084485531, 0.03514627367258072, 0.044428858906030655, -0.05071115121245384, 0.025592954829335213, 0.04000374674797058, 0.03013002872467041, -0.026930665597319603, 0.021360857412219048, 0.1303255707025528, 0.055851105600595474, 0.03643878549337387, -0.06823460757732391, 0.018857011571526527, -0.04873242601752281, 0.01757900044322014, -0.000010889672012126539, 0.010052782483398914, -0.01565958373248577, 0.018823105841875076, 0.052474770694971085, 0.010912562720477581, 0.019335279241204262, -0.006954540032893419, 0.06670746952295303, -0.02671072818338871, -0.027831999585032463, -0.005718192085623741, 0.023588290438055992, 0.01629747822880745, -0.01369466632604599, -0.03268136829137802, 0.022606974467635155, 0.016667570918798447, -0.010862864553928375, -0.01594098098576069, -0.037255726754665375, -0.006251729559153318, -0.013168223202228546, -0.047584764659404755, 0.018068751320242882, 0.05680272355675697, -0.01371794193983078, -0.02136041410267353, 0.02214263379573822, -0.01579893007874489, -0.01639135740697384, 0.02653452567756176, 0.06373465061187744, 0.004731704946607351, -0.002054275246337056, 0.042013589292764664, 0.04011025279760361, -0.04297920688986778, -0.022010723128914833, -0.023108385503292084, 0.05996625870466232, 0.005288171581923962, -0.03388633579015732, -0.03361167758703232, -0.0028149515856057405, -0.025107525289058685, -0.1004677414894104, 0.0009747550939209759, 0.0009159533656202257, 0.014632133767008781, -0.026459326967597008, -0.027756724506616592, -0.031155554577708244, 0.029010599479079247, -0.013943436555564404, 0.004752925597131252, 0.044747862964868546, -0.026282405480742455, -0.014242847450077534, -0.031303178519010544, 0.018492726609110832, -0.03480953350663185, -0.026702402159571648, 0.009597333148121834, -0.018138587474822998, -0.04055668041110039, 0.0065935030579566956, -0.03965268284082413, -0.011608520522713661, 0.05342194065451622, -0.02208164520561695, -0.0037843009922653437, -0.008710633032023907, -0.07456272095441818, 0.01765858568251133, -0.038456518203020096, -0.010144645348191261, -0.045398443937301636, -0.008454225026071072, 0.035911403596401215, 0.038860104978084564, -0.014608503319323063, 0.031287550926208496, 0.027292780578136444, 0.054249633103609085, -0.010108476504683495, 0.034370843321084976, -0.025892026722431183, -0.02792230248451233, -0.03848409652709961, 0.024666987359523773, -0.031266313046216965, 0.07364009320735931, 0.026647081598639488, 0.014416003599762917, -0.022311901673674583, 0.0025934604927897453, -0.01301442738622427, -0.005450243595987558, 0.004130702931433916, -0.055828094482421875, -0.02226889878511429, 0.01499052532017231, 0.0440189391374588, -0.04828794300556183, -0.03117658942937851, -0.02829505130648613, -0.03936303034424782, 0.02111896127462387, 0.004717698786407709, -0.046576231718063354, 0.02876012586057186, -0.04262515529990196, 0.01620808243751526, -0.01108319777995348, 0.007877801544964314, -0.027057915925979614, 0.01612151600420475, 0.02740076743066311, -0.04266204684972763, -0.03675445169210434, -0.01165096927434206, 0.0008796783513389528, -0.0085078664124012, 0.006977338809520006, -0.007958928123116493, 0.013565362431108952, 0.017482731491327286, -0.004187395330518484, 0.0005594852846115828, 0.019734984263777733, -0.020114753395318985, -0.016513260081410408, 0.03680472448468208, -0.04409583657979965, -0.01265959907323122, 0.0017647658241912723, 0.007253057323396206, 0.03330857306718826, 0.0320332869887352, -0.02950020506978035, 0.020563852041959763, -0.003179142251610756, -0.017369909211993217, -0.020751751959323883, -0.02687261439859867, -0.023364799097180367, -0.020254263654351234, 0.006647078320384026, -0.039487823843955994, -0.006240176502615213, -0.01717444136738777, -0.011601170524954796, 0.040475960820913315, 0.011722312308847904, -0.008936240337789059, 0.010027279146015644, 0.005349613260477781, 0.011038335971534252, 0.021908683702349663, 0.0057428982108831406, -0.024465814232826233, 0.050515975803136826, -0.008705049753189087, 0.018723024055361748, -0.04070240259170532, 0.0060813892632722855, -0.09347979724407196, -0.0014658832224085927, 0.022355593740940094, 0.0066613140515983105, 0.02772771567106247, -0.02578180655837059, 0.009044415317475796, 0.04787905141711235, -0.03494039550423622, 0.045262519270181656, 0.021592648699879646, -0.01710338518023491, -0.054071106016635895, 0.002142889890819788, -0.009743707254529, 0.013775784522294998, 0.0470087006688118, 0.010666201822459698, 0.047814369201660156, 0.005243686959147453, -0.030389757826924324, -0.007783339824527502, 0.04224678874015808, 0.03377896547317505, -0.01436049584299326, -0.02412695810198784, 0.027260690927505493, -0.024157509207725525, -0.05181768536567688, 0.03347001224756241, -0.0032460519578307867, 0.04090219736099243, 0.029362373054027557, 0.0028704642318189144, 0.04113807529211044, 0.0738023966550827, 0.04644094407558441, -0.017767194658517838, -0.033341675996780396, 0.015568147413432598, 0.0035455035977065563, 0.030836958438158035, -0.03714197874069214, 0.02044903114438057, 0.020656121894717216, -0.050057634711265564, -0.01641467772424221, 0.03759751468896866, 0.005027121398597956, -0.024199480190873146, 0.010538809932768345, -0.04651818051934242, -0.0011146123288199306, -0.011658204719424248, 0.02087388187646866, -0.034875206649303436, 0.003176696365699172, 0.005731089040637016, 0.05023781210184097, -0.02797229401767254, -0.02723054774105549, -0.007050409447401762, -0.025260547176003456, 0.04533367231488228, 0.0010741704609245062, -0.01721789874136448, -0.07101558893918991, -0.020720385015010834, -0.05493763089179993, 0.022947784513235092, 0.036092277616262436, -0.03766495734453201, -0.02629232220351696, 0.00396325159817934, 0.020209291949868202, 0.009333090856671333, -0.029742861166596413, -0.0028104542288929224, 0.0002908033493440598, -0.08588413149118423, 0.06855614483356476, -0.017701406031847, -0.003943237010389566, -0.0184699147939682, 0.0017198029672726989, -0.058070749044418335, -0.0043255239725112915, 0.03911082446575165, 0.016933292150497437, -0.012270407751202583, 0.004227443598210812, 0.01427652407437563, -0.00025303501752205193, -0.04995090514421463, 0.029931899160146713, -0.014873758889734745, 0.003937881905585527, -0.0446641780436039, 0.006914771161973476, 0.015624959021806717, -0.0017045941203832626, 0.015481849201023579, -0.015917399898171425, 0.0015076115960255265, -0.007108621299266815, 0.0011450635502114892, 0.05304403603076935, 0.02863221988081932, 0.006882088258862495, 0.05792217329144478, -0.0011803900124505162, 0.03166629374027252, -0.005506876856088638, -0.034793198108673096, -0.031901199370622635, 0.07095533609390259, -0.06283094733953476, -0.0056738038547337055, 0.010849823243916035, 0.03180880844593048, 0.009599432349205017, -0.03446114435791969, -0.041834838688373566, 0.04314807802438736, -0.03649524226784706, -0.017578033730387688, 0.033208735287189484, 0.017500141635537148, 0.04950041323900223, -0.008315891027450562, 0.011977799236774445, -0.017423324286937714, -0.00191621039994061, 0.01655489392578602, 0.007891809567809105, 0.006984895560890436, -0.006269518285989761, 0.03627501428127289, 0.06510158628225327, -0.024886704981327057, 0.007674641907215118, -0.007495279423892498, -0.011710711754858494, -0.03788161277770996, 0.003716276492923498, 0.014723335392773151, -0.0038193599320948124, 0.003691367106512189, -0.016278725117444992, -0.04078272730112076, 0.04969920963048935, -0.011550978757441044, 0.04625238850712776, -0.02457452565431595, -0.012146553955972195, -0.02847585640847683, 0.002269099233672023, -0.014764003455638885, 0.023351147770881653, -0.004520295187830925, 0.02644834853708744, -0.01447480358183384, 0.019521785899996758, 0.056133393198251724, -0.02957349270582199, 0.0022178972139954567, -0.003365471726283431, -0.029298782348632812, 0.0014453870244324207, -0.010346392169594765, 0.024674147367477417, 0.0002770131395664066, 0.053678520023822784, 0.05693180486559868, 0.01822354830801487, -0.03365223854780197, -0.0006446049665100873, 0.02887333370745182, 0.05516008287668228, -0.04401281848549843, -0.00973245408385992, -0.03924204409122467, 0.016559215262532234, -0.016797373071312904, -0.041702743619680405 ]
<p>I am interested in the following sampling problem, which I will try to describe by a motivating example. </p> <p>Suppose we want to estimate how many people in a certain area, has blue eyes, how many have them has brown eyes etc.(think of a color scale) We do have an estimate on total number eye colors that the population contains (let's say 100 colors). </p> <p>We then sequentially observe samples - in a motivating context let's say a cruise arrives from that region each month. We disrupt those passengers and examine the eye color of each of them. The cruise does not always contain same number of passengers, and we don't know the decision rule on putting those people on that cruise. A reasonable assumption is that each person has an equal chance (p) of being in that cruise and reasonably we tend to see more the people with common eye colors. </p> <p>The problem is</p> <ol> <li><p>Can we estimate total number of people living on the area?</p></li> <li><p>Can we estimate the proportion or chance "p" ?</p></li> </ol>
36,070
[ -0.02720974013209343, -0.04708625748753548, 0.030736397951841354, -0.011353027075529099, 0.019551921635866165, 0.02831166423857212, -0.0017270242096856236, -0.01466464251279831, 0.025728141888976097, -0.02305227518081665, 0.061908185482025146, 0.07290902733802795, 0.040385980159044266, 0.01186593621969223, -0.0011382009834051132, 0.021193651482462883, -0.02210339531302452, 0.0373007170855999, -0.014449222944676876, 0.006409734021872282, -0.002813560189679265, 0.04299058020114899, 0.037288598716259, -0.06985855102539062, -0.06130947917699814, 0.005173000041395426, 0.024913255125284195, -0.05719247832894325, 0.007874296978116035, 0.06568595767021179, -0.04392401874065399, -0.012153190560638905, 0.03618331998586655, 0.069593645632267, 0.05294698104262352, -0.003875316819176078, -0.029162537306547165, -0.0016622563125565648, -0.0021406530868262053, 0.012262915261089802, -0.04266118258237839, -0.02362513542175293, 0.004488025326281786, 0.02339579164981842, 0.007453061640262604, 0.01848924532532692, 0.0025667715817689896, -0.05779751017689705, 0.027995655313134193, -0.04887227714061737, 0.07027630507946014, -0.024072935804724693, 0.02169535867869854, 0.031692709773778915, -0.007880445569753647, -0.03211620822548866, 0.0401860773563385, 0.08664048463106155, -0.005692224483937025, -0.0070487880147993565, 0.011300073936581612, -0.0046092066913843155, -0.0068175713531672955, 0.006377131678164005, -0.02868097648024559, 0.00395097304135561, -0.030520737171173096, -0.031287096440792084, 0.01256825216114521, -0.0454227440059185, 0.01458531990647316, 0.0029913114849478006, 0.021327467635273933, -0.010431347414851189, -0.02905605174601078, -0.05228576436638832, 0.013471920043230057, 0.05251370370388031, 0.05435876175761223, -0.00211357488296926, 0.030167847871780396, -0.028024883940815926, 0.011120827868580818, 0.03128649294376373, 0.02377992682158947, -0.0525079146027565, 0.08559360355138779, -0.06526323407888412, 0.018150299787521362, -0.018285365775227547, 0.000013165579730411991, -0.02157524973154068, 0.030124863609671593, -0.019711339846253395, -0.03060036338865757, 0.021195106208324432, -0.017257194966077805, 0.034773554652929306, 0.007118333596736193, 0.010168835520744324, -0.0026607897598296404, -0.06042845919728279, -0.012067181058228016, 0.032579727470874786, -0.03102685697376728, -0.029181186109781265, -0.026679430156946182, 0.017490318045020103, 0.02915024571120739, 0.027689943090081215, -0.014785608276724815, 0.015592850744724274, 0.05146917700767517, 0.0179972555488348, 0.007265281863510609, 0.03130030632019043, -0.015729324892163277, -0.019779566675424576, 0.0681181401014328, 0.06956356763839722, 0.036971427500247955, -0.0027504884637892246, 0.005296740215271711, -0.026933301240205765, -0.04155179113149643, 0.02372771129012108, 0.003812245326116681, -0.0088804354891181, -0.012858010828495026, 0.028673360124230385, -0.013498823158442974, -0.005302682518959045, 0.060824740678071976, -0.00322774238884449, -0.0009046531631611288, -0.01715211197733879, -0.07668253779411316, -0.023632220923900604, 0.04084153100848198, -0.012122089974582195, 0.009313062764704227, -0.03365577757358551, 0.01722680777311325, 0.04437658563256264, 0.03760434687137604, 0.002230317797511816, 0.05223330110311508, 0.0010472681606188416, 0.029142053797841072, 0.008201679214835167, -0.036254629492759705, -0.012227506376802921, -0.006185158155858517, 0.02206464484333992, -0.006302596069872379, -0.08554653078317642, 0.04069971665740013, 0.03488430380821228, -0.0019384948536753654, -0.03244895488023758, 0.04335223138332367, -0.0022071455605328083, -0.005604112520813942, 0.015023791231215, 0.04156864807009697, -0.022495843470096588, 0.08773516863584518, -0.013579502701759338, 0.029754886403679848, 0.004531385842710733, 0.020570270717144012, 0.006552389822900295, -0.0009510316886007786, 0.002543498994782567, 0.03894485533237457, -0.05682738870382309, 0.01095491461455822, -0.01454485859721899, 0.0028725918382406235, 0.010572090744972229, -0.009835709817707539, -0.010851975530385971, -0.0010325468610972166, -0.00046828491031192243, 0.07011885941028595, -0.0017290743999183178, 0.022117888554930687, -0.025305135175585747, 0.06365719437599182, -0.059015922248363495, -0.04335494711995125, -0.07095082849264145, -0.0021787267178297043, 0.011763215065002441, -0.024116430431604385, 0.03334258869290352, -0.021810710430145264, 0.0025707134045660496, -0.00013704824959859252, -0.039529602974653244, -0.017915988340973854, -0.027729423716664314, 0.04766759276390076, -0.055408135056495667, 0.007997413165867329, 0.04482342302799225, 0.037065938115119934, -0.0030732261948287487, 0.03751553222537041, -0.04633443057537079, -0.056412190198898315, -0.03963012993335724, -0.023927444592118263, 0.015243428759276867, -0.010524556040763855, 0.010285764932632446, 0.009198928251862526, 0.03227784484624863, -0.031305309385061264, 0.03580329939723015, -0.04232266917824745, 0.08144686371088028, 0.0778055340051651, -0.03150726109743118, 0.022053992375731468, 0.021274685859680176, 0.025803811848163605, -0.01671142689883709, 0.02317780815064907, -0.036694202572107315, -0.04918975755572319, 0.001487148110754788, 0.020522676408290863, 0.0077012586407363415, -0.037465304136276245, 0.008837551809847355, 0.05237015336751938, 0.042918313294649124, 0.024618836119771004, 0.008940736763179302, 0.023878050968050957, 0.006888152100145817, 0.019891904667019844, 0.0031275483779609203, 0.03589065745472908, 0.007511071860790253, 0.02511773817241192, -0.02305739000439644, 0.026650313287973404, -0.01914193667471409, 0.0010384108172729611, 0.00801877025514841, 0.01565319299697876, 0.028108734637498856, -0.031610552221536636, 0.04076762869954109, 0.04715592414140701, -0.07154561579227448, 0.005005822982639074, 0.042672403156757355, 0.025272274389863014, -0.00644098874181509, -0.009514003992080688, -0.03295782580971718, 0.003205939196050167, 0.026303131133317947, -0.06268267333507538, 0.031524404883384705, 0.032324180006980896, -0.015869490802288055, 0.011656566523015499, -0.014340068213641644, -0.018252842128276825, -0.0515715517103672, 0.02585947886109352, 0.030572615563869476, 0.012372905388474464, 0.038716696202754974, -0.011594239622354507, -0.005396622698754072, 0.017179273068904877, 0.023490864783525467, -0.006396119017153978, 0.019205838441848755, -0.09715133160352707, 0.03859309107065201, 0.024898312985897064, -0.020260917022824287, -0.008649113588035107, 0.009656716138124466, -0.033004675060510635, 0.03225696086883545, 0.035495877265930176, -0.04998522996902466, -0.005068614613264799, -0.017940107733011246, 0.007663865108042955, -0.041127752512693405, -0.032922014594078064, 0.05213771387934685, 0.02028804086148739, -0.03624438866972923, 0.029983213171362877, -0.04628714919090271, -0.02025107480585575, -0.040487054735422134, 0.009200948290526867, 0.007734951097518206, -0.015295060351490974, -0.011115672998130322, 0.01359888818114996, 0.022480765357613564, 0.003708761418238282, -0.06695500761270523, -0.06883680075407028, -0.004029391333460808, 0.024298397824168205, 0.061109911650419235, -0.0021530441008508205, 0.012454761192202568, 0.05483447015285492, 0.05275974050164223, -0.005630142521113157, -0.011033555492758751, -0.025754451751708984, -0.02376045286655426, -0.019344666972756386, -0.006290125194936991, -0.0021790650207549334, -0.022889958694577217, 0.018868621438741684, 0.01985185407102108, 0.04354057088494301, 0.030246393755078316, 0.022695263847708702, 0.008863365277647972, 0.005880170501768589, -0.014856506139039993, 0.012686703354120255, 0.05136420950293541, 0.03691457211971283, -0.034588612616062164, 0.0077789416536688805, -0.032890498638153076, 0.0017624425236135721, 0.04243963211774826, -0.06525664031505585, 0.017217859625816345, -0.02556769549846649, -0.005474105942994356, -0.003769423346966505, 0.04033386707305908, 0.038080278784036636, -0.02693597972393036, 0.0038901674561202526, 0.011490730568766594, 0.05594408139586449, -0.049112480133771896, -0.03478327766060829, 0.061503052711486816, 0.021767551079392433, 0.005912697408348322, 0.013635750859975815, -0.02520940825343132, -0.006954447831958532, 0.030787313356995583, -0.00735894963145256, -0.007415975444018841, -0.0130472956225276, 0.04754180833697319, 0.018481988459825516, -0.03192222863435745, -0.01712142489850521, -0.009977832436561584, -0.050456106662750244, -0.030811242759227753, -0.03222082927823067, 0.056455377489328384, -0.015955321490764618, 0.046038661152124405, 0.02533525787293911, -0.01397203654050827, -0.008392158895730972, 0.027217838913202286, -0.08319408446550369, -0.02198641560971737, 0.007334171794354916, 0.004828073550015688, -0.048054181039333344, -0.047393474727869034, 0.06547053903341293, -0.018414057791233063, 0.0023003409150987864, -0.02886422723531723, 0.036980755627155304, -0.03000079281628132, 0.0159795843064785, -0.03125721588730812, -0.01674365997314453, 0.010817423462867737, -0.00934122409671545, 0.014876946806907654, -0.025614697486162186, 0.008117305114865303, 0.003796952310949564, -0.004932268522679806, -0.01779070496559143, -0.03655498847365379, 0.03373561054468155, 0.012330272234976292, 0.047786612063646317, 0.004435661714524031, 0.048204220831394196, -0.05839904397726059, -0.01857745088636875, -0.022283075377345085, 0.033603210002183914, 0.022718986496329308, -0.0011483808048069477, -0.026279425248503685, -0.010286525823175907, -0.02275633066892624, 0.044481515884399414, 0.017107445746660233, -0.030758459120988846, -0.00864489283412695, 0.05895574763417244, 0.0017076346557587385, -0.022007755935192108, 0.0172960814088583, 0.03078005276620388, -0.006130809895694256, 0.0013198647648096085, -0.0157921239733696, 0.04715612903237343, 0.005500549916177988, 0.0032278152648359537, 0.02913615107536316, 0.030944889411330223, 0.022225238382816315, 0.0009643638040870428, 0.02024785242974758, 0.05172710493206978, -0.042698394507169724, 0.025989487767219543, 0.0016780068399384618, 0.046429187059402466, 0.016574202105402946, 0.007378821726888418, 0.024448277428746223, 0.007349579129368067, 0.031821247190237045, 0.0010246539022773504, -0.020501790568232536, -0.07074243575334549, -0.0048022144474089146, 0.02425023727118969, 0.01773553341627121, -0.034311577677726746, 0.03692249208688736, -0.056917693465948105, 0.0005618517170660198, 0.012866398319602013, -0.011364763602614403, -0.009883349761366844, -0.022984685376286507, 0.0017805128591135144, -0.018503187224268913, -0.04327777400612831, -0.00894758477807045, 0.0319371335208416, -0.039664193987846375, 0.011817540973424911, -0.03906669467687607, 0.006436164956539869, -0.05960170552134514, 0.04570021480321884, 0.0595361664891243, 0.07675444334745407, -0.03964550420641899, -0.0628882423043251, -0.034187283366918564, -0.006071839015930891, -0.04860251396894455, -0.06328599154949188, 0.026818696409463882, -0.005526110529899597, -0.014363951981067657, 0.03642991557717323, -0.013644593767821789, -0.01944994553923607, 0.03689076751470566, 0.0020861877128481865, -0.019364643841981888, 0.01374776754528284, -0.033527255058288574, 0.04810599237680435, 0.028821362182497978, 0.058740731328725815, 0.028851281851530075, 0.01602610945701599, 0.004736039321869612, 0.030249519273638725, 0.013921364210546017, 0.013417132198810577, -0.03288443386554718, -0.046806178987026215, 0.005039413925260305, -0.03295909985899925, -0.029143763706088066, 0.008620734326541424, 0.014691054821014404, 0.005963250994682312, -0.006431786809116602, -0.036009155213832855, 0.0046663242392241955, 0.021011047065258026, 0.023878442123532295, 0.023053698241710663, -0.0514073520898819, 0.017516275867819786, 0.00007184034620877355, -0.015229668468236923, 0.05043382942676544, -0.02108311839401722, 0.030982257798314095, -0.0008942013373598456, -0.03437365964055061, -0.017884261906147003, -0.08590349555015564, -0.026786213740706444, 0.03372276574373245, 0.0023086501751095057, 0.04175260290503502, -0.04530087485909462, 0.050407227128744125, 0.036897193640470505, -0.048792991787195206, -0.02724127285182476, 0.019768716767430305, -0.00999737624078989, 0.02439400739967823, -0.015549121424555779, 0.0628599300980568, 0.0014150227652862668, -0.011882461607456207, -0.06445057690143585, -0.038042206317186356, 0.0066374484449625015, 0.02207953855395317, -0.02043825574219227, -0.05099223554134369, -0.0019044745713472366, -0.021526362746953964, -0.01641322672367096, -0.03790317475795746, 0.018457451835274696, 0.004803871735930443, -0.012527157552540302, -0.03232625871896744, 0.030307719483971596, 0.05779917165637016, -0.0210230965167284, -0.011400552466511726, 0.013124804943799973, -0.025609154254198074, 0.015359451062977314, -0.05219803377985954, 0.00016495442832820117, -0.04162655770778656, -0.027818646281957626, -0.00645829364657402, -0.0032206124160438776, 0.010380104184150696, -0.00202200748026371, -0.05280411243438721, 0.03209412470459938, 0.00957958959043026, -0.01303299143910408, -0.027987809851765633, -0.047492846846580505, 0.006008303724229336, -0.005437989253550768, -0.030308635905385017, 0.01673787645995617, 0.014252882450819016, -0.006864939350634813, 0.02912045083940029, 0.01156486663967371, -0.027796650305390358, 0.008948205970227718, 0.05741308256983757, -0.02324685826897621, -0.007092752959579229, 0.011133878491818905, 0.009052403271198273, 0.024221021682024002, 0.0041306521743535995, -0.012809527106583118, -0.0006819689879193902, 0.009363224729895592, -0.016185808926820755, -0.00938668567687273, -0.02099558524787426, 0.014973546378314495, 0.055296383798122406, -0.003070354927331209, 0.057513270527124405, 0.03074794076383114, -0.004873894155025482, 0.026655839756131172, -0.0033767723944038153, 0.0009531491668894887, -0.035913847386837006, 0.009439557790756226, 0.0530083067715168, 0.013916375115513802, -0.047107964754104614, 0.018795892596244812, 0.04627141356468201, 0.0077525475062429905, 0.03621997311711311, -0.006533307023346424, 0.022844236344099045, 0.04712510481476784, -0.045027442276477814, -0.02170693688094616, 0.005298697389662266, -0.02833324298262596, -0.0018372118938714266, -0.03834778070449829, -0.0001760760642355308, 0.08224812150001526, 0.03818099573254585, -0.014410756528377533, -0.050531983375549316, -0.023260993883013725, -0.0181740652769804, -0.007651437073945999, -0.0002915333607234061, 0.027276651933789253, 0.03783022612333298, -0.03665921092033386, -0.00861725490540266, -0.01585681550204754, 0.01059320755302906, -0.03379927575588226, -0.06607972830533981, -0.03013603202998638, -0.03260982036590576, -0.0719713345170021, 0.02593487687408924, -0.007531006820499897, 0.01074693538248539, -0.0022240830585360527, -0.030424581840634346, 0.003764733439311385, 0.01401514746248722, 0.026602722704410553, -0.02090858481824398, 0.0671992227435112, 0.03105432540178299, 0.05051803961396217, -0.031141195446252823, -0.003268437460064888, 0.12216982245445251, 0.044372640550136566, 0.030976777896285057, -0.05958996340632439, 0.023040199652314186, -0.01389157585799694, -0.03060014732182026, -0.011076528578996658, -0.0048651485703885555, 0.03856300190091133, -0.00985738541930914, -0.0014577459078282118, 0.03326313942670822, 0.009310849010944366, -0.005011933855712414, 0.042758576571941376, -0.04595335200428963, -0.028036046773195267, 0.0028431599494069815, -0.03236304223537445, -0.03080926276743412, 0.03767378255724907, -0.04493691772222519, 0.005459887441247702, -0.011647322215139866, -0.026136254891753197, -0.016457553952932358, -0.03357915207743645, 0.006849793251603842, 0.023548731580376625, -0.0062118046917021275, 0.025381149724125862, 0.02157766930758953, -0.022776039317250252, -0.035393211990594864, -0.02758859097957611, 0.005969207268208265, -0.025236744433641434, 0.02432810142636299, 0.043738409876823425, 0.006821302231401205, 0.016697943210601807, -0.022465955466032028, 0.046752117574214935, -0.03918937221169472, -0.016638563945889473, -0.05499299243092537, 0.03126712515950203, 0.00012432882795110345, -0.013343422673642635, -0.0011435404885560274, -0.025360526517033577, 0.00135635060723871, -0.05109760910272598, -0.010698799975216389, 0.02210880257189274, 0.03219194337725639, -0.0014626902993768454, -0.031188486143946648, -0.007863694801926613, 0.009987290017306805, -0.005061883479356766, -0.016137151047587395, 0.042535506188869476, -0.020985616371035576, -0.06683452427387238, 0.008097698912024498, -0.0010432726703584194, 0.039015159010887146, -0.02956763282418251, -0.02910095453262329, -0.0341937392950058, -0.04175081476569176, 0.0033468592446297407, -0.02151678316295147, 0.013839174062013626, 0.018095960840582848, 0.013624877668917179, -0.011402454227209091, 0.005486630368977785, -0.012209469452500343, -0.004831294994801283, -0.01159460749477148, -0.015786297619342804, -0.0292158555239439, 0.01925637759268284, 0.008500760421156883, 0.03848830983042717, 0.027191344648599625, -0.023593183606863022, 0.024349400773644447, 0.07407211512327194, 0.006738175638020039, -0.02074681594967842, -0.007072703912854195, -0.04421084001660347, -0.020715435966849327, 0.050608567893505096, 0.006490885745733976, 0.05939057841897011, 0.01936757005751133, 0.0029431337025016546, 0.0067166611552238464, -0.004487775731831789, -0.012955281883478165, 0.029069671407341957, 0.02077741175889969, -0.07702018320560455, 0.0008539962000213563, -0.0038110148161649704, 0.003791432362049818, -0.03348761796951294, -0.028697865083813667, -0.0039993091486394405, -0.006216911133378744, -0.0019511135760694742, -0.05985341966152191, -0.026979735121130943, 0.001891658059321344, 0.012470043264329433, 0.03779326751828194, -0.01418781466782093, -0.01790260523557663, -0.015858106315135956, -0.008470553904771805, -0.04534439742565155, -0.004708664957433939, -0.018722303211688995, -0.003916580695658922, 0.02009219117462635, -0.015201966278254986, 0.045456547290086746, 0.015818603336811066, 0.03250855579972267, 0.007947706617414951, 0.018260883167386055, -0.015492399223148823, 0.01044300477951765, -0.032375555485486984, -0.010009171441197395, 0.07832251489162445, -0.05005963519215584, -0.02232254482805729, 0.04424889013171196, -0.012651701457798481, 0.05972274765372276, 0.01183390710502863, 0.00878893118351698, 0.022048132494091988, 0.04515725374221802, -0.025868738070130348, -0.015083697624504566, -0.026610255241394043, 0.039742711931467056, -0.01336708478629589, -0.026871344074606895, 0.017652412876486778, -0.007244647014886141, -0.0032821521162986755, 0.017148848623037338, 0.03927087038755417, -0.01052852999418974, -0.004241262562572956, -0.023243725299835205, -0.003200146136805415, 0.012664233334362507, 0.010912736877799034, 0.016171196475625038, 0.024193355813622475, -0.006621159613132477, -0.02026968263089657, 0.04222135245800018, -0.024306446313858032, -0.02605961076915264, -0.06507984548807144, -0.03143779933452606, 0.025413336232304573, -0.0011801121290773153, 0.04706350713968277, -0.025760522112250328, 0.007946311496198177, 0.034527212381362915, -0.06098121032118797, 0.03230602294206619, -0.015109932981431484, 0.00789991021156311, -0.07535059005022049, 0.0376761369407177, -0.03554099425673485, -0.023901071399450302, 0.024296173825860023, -0.018047502264380455, 0.04877357557415962, 0.05427136272192001, 0.013922199606895447, -0.031591229140758514, 0.01565784029662609, 0.0078200688585639, 0.002387129468843341, -0.03881906345486641, 0.05142703279852867, -0.03172098100185394, -0.01838134042918682, 0.018432704731822014, 0.006401136517524719, 0.030801989138126373, 0.024613358080387115, 0.008589326404035091, -0.025096794590353966, 0.04929455742239952, 0.022697845473885536, 0.04643549770116806, -0.0007638068054802716, -0.009513217024505138, 0.016955353319644928, 0.022507674992084503, -0.017195966094732285, -0.017771748825907707, 0.07332924753427505, -0.03020012006163597, -0.035261739045381546, 0.013085714541375637, 0.02227631025016308, 0.006834998726844788, 0.029923591762781143, 0.013559898361563683, -0.00015327284927479923, 0.010947407223284245, 0.043438028544187546, -0.03129320964217186, 0.021186944097280502, -0.014068568125367165, -0.0021806745789945126, -0.013213937170803547, -0.011348848231136799, -0.02588246576488018, -0.06215107440948486, -0.007692358922213316, -0.017466289922595024, 0.0025092042051255703, -0.037730056792497635, 0.021448930725455284, 0.011946549639105797, -0.0008395558688789606, -0.0033220306504517794, -0.0044350638054311275, -0.017521733418107033, 0.017103252932429314, -0.018264802172780037, -0.0268863495439291, 0.03432237356901169, 0.01920444890856743, 0.020973261445760727, -0.07396829128265381, 0.1014682725071907, -0.0025302586145699024, 0.029453197494149208, -0.02628214843571186, 0.002336494391784072, -0.015024997293949127, 0.01626529172062874, 0.024166129529476166, -0.004263513255864382, -0.009389686398208141, 0.0041725970804691315, 0.0212334543466568, 0.01098208874464035, -0.011684851720929146, 0.03863834962248802, -0.05062628537416458, -0.014967713505029678, -0.02113932929933071, -0.03729081526398659, 0.0005636164569295943, -0.012869074940681458, -0.001373501610942185, 0.03409252688288689, 0.019563693553209305, 0.039490070194005966, 0.011937358416616917, 0.029532166197896004, 0.007522226311266422, 0.006429321598261595, -0.009016325697302818, -0.008024947717785835, 0.014296124689280987, 0.02956656739115715, -0.02330840937793255, -0.0887911319732666, 0.015664294362068176, -0.06751713156700134, -0.053263094276189804, 0.005131879821419716, 0.013307926245033741, -0.0017499730456620455, 0.0027515022084116936, 0.0070743076503276825, 0.001916277687996626, -0.025035757571458817, 0.001245725667104125, 0.01830492913722992, -0.01406976580619812, 0.01506402250379324, -0.019882339984178543, -0.009403783828020096, -0.013358546420931816, -0.016819968819618225, -0.021709350869059563, 0.004558483138680458, 0.012312413193285465, -0.038785580545663834, 0.010057354345917702, 0.01740916259586811, 0.03717629611492157, 0.012349573895335197, 0.0056753926910459995, 0.011926354840397835, -0.025514638051390648, -0.01819772459566593, 0.02561263181269169, 0.02922484092414379, 0.028120404109358788, -0.009303833357989788, 0.009886037558317184, 0.05023161694407463, 0.02271750196814537, 0.011252349242568016, -0.02223767340183258, 0.004800041206181049, -0.05646488070487976, -0.006640365347266197, 0.02057129330933094, 0.002987171523272991, -0.01090921275317669, 0.013898703269660473, 0.005252799019217491, 0.024586625397205353, 0.06301672756671906, -0.035789474844932556, 0.044058699160814285, -0.0017273708945140243, -0.024210302159190178, -0.006336909253150225, -0.03478957340121269, -0.010683218948543072, -0.0016426059883087873, 0.015814078971743584, 0.01572367362678051, 0.03237258270382881, 0.02941219136118889, -0.030369902029633522, -0.051745470613241196, 0.046764153987169266, -0.03888082876801491, 0.008470356464385986, -0.04379846900701523, 0.0073521193116903305, -0.036954160779714584, -0.05993874743580818 ]
<p>I am attempting to build a model to forecast attendance in a given week in the current year based on this year's attendance values up until the present, and data from two previous years. My data looks like this:</p> <pre><code> Week 11-12 Cumulative ADA 12-13 Cumulative ADA 13-14 Cumulative ADA 1 0.9941 0.9941 0.9914 2 0.9907 0.991 0.989 3 0.9888 0.9888 0.9879 4 0.9877 0.987 0.9869 5 0.9869 0.9865 0.9867 6 0.9862 0.985 0.9859 7 0.9856 0.9842 0.9857 8 0.9856 0.984 NA 9 0.9852 0.9839 NA 10 0.9848 0.9834 NA </code></pre> <p>Any guidance on how to predict the three NAs based on the past two years data and this year's values would be much appreciated.</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
36,071
[ -0.014194014482200146, -0.029962366446852684, -0.010515916161239147, 0.02297648973762989, 0.0801064744591713, -0.01712440699338913, -0.0015736958011984825, -0.02470978908240795, 0.037819355726242065, -0.0058820839039981365, 0.041042838245630264, 0.046548470854759216, 0.010245004668831825, 0.004468729253858328, 0.03292783349752426, 0.019316287711262703, -0.003022171324118972, -0.00014813346206210554, 0.020232925191521645, -0.011515125632286072, 0.0019742853473871946, 0.008316351100802422, -0.028658198192715645, -0.01958080753684044, -0.037276748567819595, 0.04803470894694328, 0.019609322771430016, 0.0028702944982796907, -0.012470467016100883, 0.040397875010967255, -0.043613288551568985, -0.030957143753767014, 0.01790388859808445, 0.0656224861741066, 0.016010526567697525, 0.0004197820380795747, -0.002217133529484272, -0.0154711389914155, -0.020098328590393066, 0.030369168147444725, -0.04806344211101532, -0.02511056885123253, -0.004381251987069845, 0.0531340166926384, 0.003343757474794984, 0.014974091202020645, -0.03838040679693222, 0.036650292575359344, 0.03883782774209976, -0.041992492973804474, 0.08403341472148895, -0.019812464714050293, 0.062293436378240585, 0.023371664807200432, -0.049627676606178284, -0.0020613744854927063, 0.0435168482363224, 0.041287705302238464, 0.03864573314785957, -0.033442169427871704, 0.0051206136122345924, -0.023881157860159874, -0.016225798055529594, -0.030541058629751205, -0.02334134466946125, 0.005166183691471815, -0.03347465395927429, -0.0023486483842134476, 0.03789910674095154, -0.04820634052157402, 0.012579216621816158, -0.0037723579443991184, 0.04130052402615547, -0.04703532159328461, 0.010593663901090622, -0.03247479349374771, -0.0015106870559975505, -0.020288649946451187, 0.04392847418785095, 0.024121074005961418, -0.00022922593052498996, 0.016118085011839867, 0.021643824875354767, 0.033809076994657516, 0.05101204290986061, -0.019573858007788658, 0.07557830959558487, -0.03379341959953308, 0.015630165114998817, 0.014222074300050735, -0.02697072923183441, 0.006310776807367802, 0.052692729979753494, 0.027284743264317513, -0.008653766475617886, 0.008495030924677849, 0.010445895604789257, 0.03634139522910118, 0.013997519388794899, -0.02530050277709961, 0.017591044306755066, -0.0065060630440711975, 0.003802327672019601, 0.016835568472743034, -0.021781617775559425, -0.05026177316904068, -0.07241456210613251, -0.041138362139463425, -0.019081247970461845, -0.032793961465358734, -0.009923916310071945, 0.014090364798903465, 0.005149992182850838, -0.04404713958501816, 0.02011403627693653, -0.016061149537563324, -0.014832916669547558, -0.008781502023339272, -0.010865106247365475, 0.07321939617395401, 0.04354752227663994, -0.02340015582740307, 0.03432473540306091, -0.051808737218379974, -0.044600531458854675, -0.02364262193441391, -0.01275190431624651, -0.025088662281632423, -0.007592002395540476, 0.06110277771949768, -0.03631947562098503, -0.042848311364650726, 0.046875204890966415, -0.0077310348860919476, 0.030357982963323593, 0.023814048618078232, -0.07651396095752716, -0.04454996809363365, 0.0002970350906252861, -0.02448642998933792, 0.02041713148355484, -0.026129065081477165, 0.02827843651175499, 0.01112417969852686, 0.06542977690696716, 0.03646526858210564, -0.001965736271813512, 0.014876017346978188, 0.011787256225943565, 0.010608230717480183, -0.03380594402551651, -0.007723570801317692, -0.02824799157679081, -0.0018962799804285169, -0.039596136659383774, -0.07902541011571884, 0.04479673504829407, 0.02636129967868328, 0.0024635344743728638, -0.021624738350510597, 0.06114375218749046, 0.019010011106729507, 0.005303587298840284, -0.004090918228030205, 0.00935455597937107, -0.05631382018327713, 0.08113342523574829, -0.008105109445750713, 0.00870804488658905, 0.06380163133144379, -0.012423820793628693, 0.04484871029853821, -0.009079968556761742, 0.04042300954461098, 0.046440720558166504, -0.0019659216050058603, -0.00273162336088717, -0.0185324028134346, 0.0005855350173078477, 0.02510073035955429, -0.011873812414705753, -0.05509180575609207, -0.008429327048361301, -0.01657853275537491, 0.0065005067735910416, 0.010422726161777973, 0.019691884517669678, -0.012142938561737537, 0.03640883415937424, -0.03943353891372681, -0.018338516354560852, -0.07921309024095535, 0.027708593755960464, -0.02844969928264618, -0.00916061270982027, 0.002245199168100953, 0.0008404171676374972, 0.024941643700003624, 0.02937585674226284, -0.0027297313790768385, -0.027607133612036705, -0.00442842673510313, 0.04918145015835762, -0.026545142754912376, -0.008292058482766151, 0.03931942582130432, 0.08084157109260559, -0.02183527499437332, 0.057622674852609634, -0.05731436610221863, -0.007196492049843073, -0.003305799327790737, -0.05984210595488548, 0.007570740766823292, -0.03301943838596344, -0.017644565552473068, 0.019655728712677956, 0.023280318826436996, -0.021662503480911255, 0.05831447243690491, -0.06093717738986015, 0.0248512402176857, 0.02140866219997406, 0.020127801224589348, 0.01975821889936924, -0.01891118474304676, 0.007122527342289686, 0.017848588526248932, -0.03126678615808487, -0.03348418325185776, -0.04297895357012749, -0.00037907459773123264, 0.023702597245573997, 0.013409544713795185, 0.0005892272456549108, 0.04267754778265953, 0.061542052775621414, -0.025727348402142525, 0.003150779753923416, 0.07134930789470673, -0.004133052658289671, 0.03720170259475708, -0.004801121540367603, -0.0020597076509147882, 0.0073219602927565575, -0.024541206657886505, 0.05061021074652672, 0.04388631880283356, 0.03143945336341858, 0.03124704770743847, -0.023018764331936836, 0.04710967838764191, -0.01724059320986271, 0.0021030805073678493, -0.024799518287181854, -0.04773269221186638, 0.06654737144708633, -0.03539218008518219, -0.0005698022432625294, 0.02568785473704338, -0.0050727603957057, -0.013602481223642826, 0.017728788778185844, -0.017846588045358658, -0.004437016788870096, 0.05454640090465546, -0.03265955671668053, 0.019061429426074028, 0.008478688076138496, -0.017443975433707237, 0.04332730919122696, -0.01624026708304882, -0.032291337847709656, -0.05504142865538597, 0.00533315958455205, 0.048135098069906235, 0.023636935278773308, 0.01798436790704727, 0.0060887886211276054, 0.0045130280777812, 0.02067464031279087, -0.02179824747145176, -0.002315542893484235, 0.02795657515525818, -0.025321608409285545, -0.028451865538954735, 0.021866708993911743, -0.030385920777916908, 0.04561370983719826, -0.009515107609331608, -0.04631733149290085, 0.03286535665392876, -0.046340301632881165, -0.05508238822221756, -0.04604093357920647, -0.001720731845125556, 0.03557613119482994, -0.008063269779086113, -0.015426109544932842, 0.02832943946123123, 0.0030167056247591972, -0.040855128318071365, -0.019180016592144966, -0.047503501176834106, -0.00014094488869886845, -0.007217084523290396, -0.019848806783556938, 0.004607073962688446, -0.027660729363560677, 0.0011513513745740056, 0.02913323976099491, -0.0025528804399073124, 0.04963110387325287, -0.07948742806911469, -0.032228343188762665, 0.009352640248835087, -0.008854098618030548, 0.006946352310478687, 0.0097004109993577, -0.00022142087982501835, 0.04884522035717964, 0.008618460968136787, -0.008349243551492691, -0.01727163977921009, -0.019197965040802956, -0.04518001154065132, -0.04789569601416588, 0.029819702729582787, 0.013533414341509342, 0.01798108033835888, 0.02939021587371826, -0.036531079560518265, 0.012459932826459408, 0.057156745344400406, 0.024134943261742592, -0.010245739482343197, -0.003693604376167059, -0.02096242643892765, -0.004469053819775581, 0.029911331832408905, -0.0271159578114748, -0.024894017726182938, -0.008102132007479668, -0.03137679398059845, -0.00010873946303036064, -0.019504938274621964, -0.025693997740745544, -0.019994881004095078, -0.036227308213710785, 0.03248574957251549, -0.014658310450613499, 0.019922083243727684, -0.003968201577663422, -0.03043287806212902, -0.03170289099216461, 0.010684597305953503, 0.025530748069286346, -0.01008867658674717, 0.008866514079272747, 0.04829297214746475, 0.0018026643665507436, -0.02251943200826645, 0.016486503183841705, -0.0007134355255402625, -0.026078499853610992, -0.010898939333856106, -0.04012404382228851, 0.029870882630348206, 0.03374015539884567, 0.04059671610593796, 0.02636357583105564, 0.01567607745528221, -0.018798792734742165, 0.004016260150820017, -0.06268057972192764, 0.022336294874548912, -0.031681355088949203, 0.05922629311680794, 0.019051386043429375, 0.0027695323806256056, 0.01953975111246109, -0.005810294300317764, 0.06350086629390717, -0.01769925467669964, -0.07108581811189651, 0.03855738788843155, 0.01899169385433197, 0.008746616542339325, 0.01493181474506855, -0.023033516481518745, 0.023372707888484, -0.02677343040704727, -0.0003115743456874043, 0.029899027198553085, 0.016623208299279213, -0.03885120898485184, 0.003987678326666355, -0.05776989087462425, 0.026195287704467773, -0.057083480060100555, -0.01153354812413454, 0.026737522333860397, -0.013535400852560997, 0.04536682367324829, 0.004218096379190683, -0.008335666730999947, -0.04325217753648758, -0.02909230627119541, 0.015504185110330582, 0.02709176018834114, 0.02830485627055168, 0.06948526203632355, 0.013820549473166466, -0.04709989205002785, 0.007616495247930288, 0.0015597459860146046, 0.010588948614895344, 0.02625102922320366, 0.015621769241988659, -0.03474906086921692, -0.04490010067820549, -0.009413312189280987, 0.032926321029663086, 0.017073197290301323, 0.046719107776880264, 0.021475354209542274, 0.053372375667095184, -0.010942192748188972, -0.07258042693138123, 0.004086789675056934, 0.05976804718375206, 0.02226446568965912, 0.005855825264006853, -0.014409398660063744, 0.015500297769904137, 0.01942768692970276, -0.0022479163017123938, 0.033115025609731674, -0.0033206199295818806, 0.02111995778977871, -0.00714730704203248, 0.027587078511714935, -0.01835784874856472, -0.03188030421733856, 0.0021191483829170465, 0.002778984373435378, 0.05460837483406067, 0.002752403961494565, -0.04343030974268913, -0.0101409200578928, 0.04307091236114502, 0.04938967898488045, 0.01136088464409113, 0.0063803414814174175, -0.11993952840566635, -0.029100509360432625, 0.057763513177633286, 0.05263446271419525, -0.04576576128602028, -0.048340775072574615, -0.05382627248764038, -0.010284067131578922, 0.01811107248067856, -0.04846009984612465, 0.03182203695178032, 0.017630061134696007, 0.006693514063954353, -0.003403001930564642, -0.027499383315443993, -0.06061243265867233, 0.04244862124323845, -0.024293484166264534, 0.05286634340882301, -0.026809461414813995, -0.025314968079328537, -0.018097352236509323, 0.003249900881201029, 0.045499254018068314, 0.025494594126939774, 0.011558042839169502, -0.03435366973280907, 0.012826909311115742, 0.003148020012304187, -0.017242413014173508, -0.03348157927393913, 0.019273484125733376, 0.005977090913802385, 0.0069975475780665874, 0.032292693853378296, 0.009645003825426102, -0.007018799427896738, -0.01140348706394434, 0.03526405617594719, 0.01159538235515356, -0.024016190320253372, -0.029761934652924538, 0.005365213379263878, -0.0091811278834939, 0.0022569072898477316, 0.04711916670203209, 0.020896343514323235, -0.010187945328652859, 0.01093690749257803, -0.05135690048336983, 0.01761060394346714, 0.036488648504018784, -0.018810035660862923, -0.019401103258132935, -0.035782340914011, -0.006181192118674517, 0.04814503714442253, -0.028174446895718575, 0.029009327292442322, -0.02254939079284668, -0.029459860175848007, 0.00499121006578207, 0.03977787867188454, -0.013455264270305634, 0.0028328506741672754, -0.014767486602067947, -0.00837667565792799, -0.008030585013329983, -0.009250625967979431, 0.02993970736861229, -0.03908207640051842, 0.0071549746207892895, 0.0279585849493742, -0.03720613941550255, 0.05415290966629982, 0.0076913246884942055, -0.032561179250478745, 0.003355769207701087, -0.0036549665965139866, 0.022234544157981873, -0.04306856542825699, 0.027385210618376732, 0.007417252752929926, -0.02986789681017399, -0.005311158020049334, 0.030218621715903282, -0.005621006246656179, 0.04745163768529892, 0.02560267224907875, 0.06390440464019775, -0.005791552364826202, -0.028795858845114708, -0.04210877791047096, -0.04664440453052521, 0.026071365922689438, 0.04875796288251877, -0.054279569536447525, -0.02708207070827484, 0.020036621019244194, -0.06567677110433578, -0.01612478867173195, -0.01651644892990589, 0.03819917514920235, -0.07982293516397476, -0.01474553719162941, 0.03920677676796913, 0.019237397238612175, 0.07388979196548462, 0.037307243794202805, -0.0011414543259888887, 0.021848591044545174, -0.0053841667249798775, -0.027351856231689453, -0.01333481166511774, 0.003495063167065382, -0.02716514840722084, -0.012720233760774136, -0.040114209055900574, -0.012834668159484863, 0.10161697119474411, -0.02873826213181019, -0.011803499422967434, -0.021597551181912422, -0.0019444110803306103, 0.006636910140514374, -0.03202541917562485, 0.007293109782040119, -0.011293378658592701, -0.00937223806977272, -0.04898039996623993, 0.020145757123827934, -0.003040661569684744, 0.0019204659620299935, 0.013962270691990852, 0.002539403270930052, 0.012527910061180592, 0.026946797966957092, 0.044107552617788315, 0.0034490711987018585, -0.006073476746678352, 0.0039076837711036205, 0.02333064004778862, 0.04847598448395729, 0.013422859832644463, 0.03245392441749573, -0.0060096620582044125, 0.016646064817905426, -0.03651177138090134, -0.029826493933796883, -0.029556527733802795, -0.005345555022358894, 0.015976814553141594, -0.0025822059251368046, 0.03213156387209892, 0.016113990917801857, 0.03352418169379234, -0.029165560379624367, 0.00021063054737169296, -0.010594812221825123, 0.00628031836822629, -0.012974364683032036, 0.04216977208852768, 0.013219816610217094, -0.025339631363749504, 0.01883227564394474, -0.007912864908576012, 0.04275631532073021, 0.07885801047086716, 0.013369678519666195, -0.03477122262120247, 0.004010183271020651, -0.012242651544511318, -0.022777095437049866, 0.009351331740617752, -0.021472178399562836, 0.0018169393297284842, -0.017127251252532005, -0.03579667955636978, 0.02751798927783966, 0.03135357052087784, 0.01015342678874731, -0.028637779876589775, -0.028407622128725052, -0.05522630363702774, -0.04171758517622948, 0.033541757613420486, -0.009806028567254543, -0.005208922084420919, 0.05184156075119972, 0.025122815743088722, 0.02043304406106472, 0.03559479862451553, -0.02995450235903263, -0.07456932216882706, -0.011410312727093697, -0.030742982402443886, -0.009377934969961643, 0.01621280051767826, 0.02696477435529232, -0.031013663858175278, -0.007161619607359171, -0.011603674851357937, 0.00812512543052435, 0.028324007987976074, 0.04361727088689804, 0.06297697871923447, 0.06845206767320633, 0.027274737134575844, -0.00016967629198916256, 0.005132055841386318, 0.019419962540268898, 0.12754151225090027, 0.0923612117767334, 0.03784962370991707, -0.05681374669075012, 0.03019128181040287, 0.02357780933380127, -0.031180687248706818, -0.041416604071855545, -0.004138682968914509, 0.0076225316151976585, -0.018205974251031876, 0.06589425355195999, 0.05389690399169922, -0.002269207499921322, 0.02018752694129944, 0.017531009390950203, -0.012141945771872997, -0.015885766595602036, -0.012538062408566475, 0.012549607083201408, 0.006552529986947775, -0.00230481312610209, -0.05028432235121727, 0.01245271135121584, 0.03191787749528885, -0.014293753542006016, -0.012820161879062653, 0.002730519976466894, -0.014474218711256981, -0.019305163994431496, 0.01202111691236496, -0.023327598348259926, -0.007693994324654341, 0.02890624664723873, -0.008122053928673267, 0.017851756885647774, 0.010215487331151962, -0.04736289754509926, 0.02760469727218151, 0.030415713787078857, 0.030185561627149582, -0.024430474266409874, -0.008484226651489735, 0.023645099252462387, -0.0299783106893301, -0.0036967580672353506, -0.02896316722035408, 0.036371614784002304, -0.005948887672275305, 0.0005292054847814143, -0.020829904824495316, -0.028787320479750633, -0.00435460451990366, -0.038120511919260025, -0.005805778317153454, 0.024435129016637802, -0.0044638714753091335, -0.06800851225852966, -0.0007952735759317875, -0.04342874139547348, -0.035746533423662186, -0.008554233238101006, 0.02695288136601448, 0.026219304651021957, -0.025292985141277313, -0.007889674045145512, -0.059000737965106964, 0.053067710250616074, -0.017229480668902397, 0.0026886677369475365, 0.02895851619541645, -0.011044406332075596, -0.042719483375549316, -0.006536419503390789, 0.01892109028995037, -0.00802940595895052, -0.027723398059606552, -0.002527431817725301, 0.006258415058255196, 0.001781092956662178, -0.03289336711168289, 0.01529424823820591, -0.04257039725780487, -0.010333361104130745, -0.0408019982278347, 0.028804676607251167, 0.008593786507844925, 0.01771741732954979, 0.029151124879717827, 0.03214501962065697, -0.004510094411671162, 0.06752483546733856, 0.03220363333821297, -0.07004380226135254, -0.016027823090553284, -0.05675407871603966, -0.04299035295844078, -0.0036014218349009752, -0.034458644688129425, 0.05109817162156105, 0.010844694450497627, -0.027537593618035316, -0.015498543158173561, 0.05088907852768898, -0.008802262134850025, 0.011150266975164413, -0.0140021787956357, -0.05320547893643379, 0.004886006470769644, -0.017954956740140915, -0.008474206551909447, -0.060757413506507874, -0.004725713282823563, -0.008829747326672077, -0.03188849613070488, 0.006113214418292046, -0.023829171434044838, -0.024640101939439774, 0.050922222435474396, 0.013925484381616116, 0.0101188188418746, -0.04240959882736206, -0.008518652059137821, -0.028434565290808678, -0.03749166429042816, -0.02438642457127571, -0.04147811979055405, -0.025514423847198486, 0.02018612250685692, -0.032613158226013184, -0.01755903847515583, 0.0554390586912632, -0.005579851102083921, 0.0011611409718170762, -0.026786059141159058, 0.004639558494091034, -0.03845786675810814, 0.046616919338703156, -0.007160847075283527, -0.03616774082183838, 0.01738015003502369, -0.04131310433149338, -0.02801457606256008, -0.015910189598798752, -0.020046329125761986, 0.05766045302152634, 0.02162863500416279, -0.002166540129110217, -0.0012004624586552382, 0.036212775856256485, -0.03896621987223625, 0.00024678476620465517, -0.033304035663604736, 0.028207877650856972, 0.019711768254637718, 0.0014997763792052865, -0.005443774629384279, 0.044701915234327316, -0.04637875407934189, -0.001464346656575799, 0.0669747069478035, 0.0002990378125105053, -0.02000264637172222, -0.004268463235348463, -0.0030537983402609825, -0.028119491413235664, 0.027668654918670654, 0.017686625942587852, 0.04929496720433235, 0.02029070258140564, -0.024481840431690216, 0.03504354506731033, -0.0027420350816100836, 0.0047014132142066956, -0.05545533448457718, -0.018782170489430428, 0.015162693336606026, 0.012135676108300686, 0.02136225998401642, -0.03702222928404808, 0.014844506047666073, -0.007662918418645859, 0.014623071998357773, 0.013452397659420967, 0.01137563493102789, -0.010110362432897091, 0.0041951402090489864, 0.02546299621462822, 0.0088508864864707, -0.006411556154489517, 0.0005108455079607666, 0.01270369440317154, -0.010920614004135132, -0.005920640658587217, 0.02112617902457714, -0.06148558109998703, -0.04101339727640152, -0.026637522503733635, 0.029030540958046913, -0.03811207413673401, 0.028290873393416405, -0.04311581701040268, -0.006960213650017977, 0.03737926855683327, -0.03770431876182556, 0.02060757577419281, 0.05091939866542816, -0.003801662242040038, -0.016488851979374886, 0.0736536979675293, 0.02839958481490612, 0.01239796169102192, 0.020469220355153084, -0.003991152159869671, -0.010398183949291706, 0.0013738478301092982, -0.007974375039339066, 0.03945918008685112, 0.02662966586649418, -0.020360587164759636, 0.003431564662605524, -0.018291205167770386, -0.014176527038216591, 0.023319697007536888, -0.01096139382570982, 0.0011883961269631982, -0.0038817867171019316, -0.03670216724276543, 0.011961109936237335, 0.0011566148605197668, 0.0003144998336210847, 0.030788345262408257, 0.04075650870800018, -0.018037738278508186, -0.0021865784656256437, -0.0001069790669134818, -0.019625846296548843, 0.017547545954585075, -0.008246837183833122, 0.009731368161737919, -0.03145204856991768, -0.01911112479865551, 0.015559889376163483, -0.012022118084132671, -0.00896582379937172, -0.010288801044225693, -0.052948545664548874, 0.06658855825662613, -0.018917258828878403, -0.004781794268637896, 0.06618871539831161, -0.011715525761246681, 0.055461227893829346, -0.08757440745830536, 0.0321321003139019, 0.008891837671399117, -0.01769745536148548, -0.014322536066174507, -0.025935417041182518, -0.05514402687549591, 0.001454224344342947, 0.0530490018427372, 0.012807515449821949, 0.00020769138063769788, -0.016974804922938347, 0.020789915695786476, -0.0028790852520614862, -0.032642435282468796, 0.04718252643942833, -0.039304737001657486, -0.029151305556297302, -0.034484077244997025, -0.005334991496056318, 0.028560958802700043, -0.026535065844655037, -0.010617246851325035, -0.010932477191090584, 0.014757613651454449, 0.029987169429659843, -0.0463099405169487, -0.0052955979481339455, 0.011159414425492287, 0.012060814537107944, 0.027645016089081764, 0.004531378857791424, 0.026384027674794197, 0.06221359223127365, 0.009273290634155273, -0.06843236088752747, 0.025895416736602783, -0.04020305722951889, -0.023412223905324936, 0.002614896511659026, -0.008104264736175537, -0.0024889283813536167, -0.05122695118188858, -0.013296359218657017, 0.022692617028951645, -0.01416316069662571, 0.02990775927901268, 0.0372551754117012, 0.028679706156253815, 0.044653452932834625, -0.020342431962490082, 0.037175215780735016, 0.02436733804643154, 0.027866987511515617, -0.02839822694659233, 0.003718316787853837, 0.03249140456318855, -0.005711486097425222, 0.012359173968434334, 0.045756638050079346, 0.02114749141037464, 0.005330264568328857, -0.04245244339108467, 0.05127087980508804, -0.023276453837752342, -0.01760551519691944, 0.01695823110640049, 0.026803672313690186, 0.024766694754362106, 0.03566419333219528, 0.012526367790997028, 0.02709384076297283, -0.056788139045238495, 0.05360846966505051, -0.012763907201588154, -0.06944555044174194, -0.014270980842411518, 0.012517538852989674, -0.0019229634199291468, 0.02252315543591976, -0.00538592366501689, 0.022555669769644737, 0.044720571488142014, -0.008183197118341923, 0.007221335545182228, -0.0031311498023569584, 0.0022014251444488764, 0.00006932150427019224, -0.013412585482001305, -0.012668666429817677, 0.014091267250478268, -0.0022825535852462053, -0.029708951711654663, 0.014196988195180893, 0.050886575132608414, 0.037778567522764206, -0.01812257431447506, -0.005748046562075615, -0.008176899515092373, 0.041377123445272446, -0.029114210978150368, -0.05962997302412987, -0.06216542422771454, 0.029678914695978165, -0.0025015848223119974, -0.044334776699543 ]
<p><strong>Study Design:</strong><br> Below is a clinical trial in a longitudinal dataset. All subjects (n=34) attended <code>V1</code> (baseline) and then they were assigned to either a <code>Placebo</code> (n=15) or a <code>Drug</code> (n=19), both then were investigated at visit <code>V2</code>. Based on an investigation's result at <code>V2</code> called <code>grpVar1</code> they were grouped into two groups: <code>grpVar1=P</code> (n=16) and <code>grpVar1=N</code> (n=18).<br> Those <code>N</code> were routed for visit <code>V3</code>, whereas those <code>P</code> were routed for visit <code>V4</code> and later visit <code>V5</code>.<br> <code>Par1</code> was measured in all of the visits for all subjects at two anatomical sites: <code>site1</code> and <code>site2</code>. So each subject has two measurements at the two sites in all of the visits. Additionally, <code>Days</code> variable is the number of days of subsequent visits based on the baseline. Even though the visit is the same, different subjects attended the visit at different days and that was recorded. </p> <p><strong>It looks like this:</strong> </p> <pre><code>&gt; head(df,12) id id_site Gender Visit Days grpVar1 Therapy Par1 1 1 site1 F V1 0 P Placebo 0.61030187 2 1 site2 F V1 0 P Placebo 0.43833820 3 1 site1 F V2 244 P Placebo 7.45492517 4 1 site2 F V2 244 P Placebo 0.63105623 5 1 site1 F V3 322 P Placebo 0.22600916 6 1 site2 F V3 322 P Placebo 0.23180883 7 2 site1 M V1 0 P Drug 0.18130448 8 2 site2 M V1 0 P Drug 0.14165622 9 2 site1 M V2 223 P Drug 1.02354748 10 2 site2 M V2 223 P Drug 2.05987466 11 2 site1 M V3 314 P Drug 0.10194901 12 2 site2 M V3 314 P Drug 0.22315864 </code></pre> <p><strong>Class of variables</strong></p> <pre><code>&gt; sapply(df, class) id id_site Gender Visit Days grpVar1 Therapy Par1 "factor" "factor" "factor" "factor" "numeric" "factor" "factor" "numeric" </code></pre> <p><strong>Conception:</strong><br> So as you can see, repeated measures design with a twist; there is some kind of routing of subjects based on <code>V2</code> results, I call it "bifurcation of subjects" into two different routes of visits after <code>V2</code>.<br> Clearly there should be some individual variations that need to be accounted for by allowing both intercept and slope to change. Another source of variation I believe is the anatomical site that need to be accounted for alike. So <code>Par1</code> is measured in a hierarchy of site and subjects. Both <code>id_site</code> and <code>id</code> can be looked at as contextual variables; therefore, they can be treated as the random effects in a mixed model.<br> Although there were 5 visits as shown in <code>Visit</code> variable, but can we make use of the related <code>Days</code> variable to account for variation in the time as days after the baseline. I wonder how one can let the model account for this also? </p> <p><strong>My trial in R</strong> </p> <pre><code>library(nlme) lm_form_1 &lt;- formula (Par1 ~ Visit + Gender + Therapy + id_site + grpVar1) mod1 &lt;- lme(lm_form_1, random = ~ 1|id , data = df) </code></pre> <p><strong>Question:</strong><br> How to account for variation of <code>id</code>, <code>id_site</code>, and <code>Days</code> as random effects. How to set the var-covar structure of <code>pdMat</code> class based on this study design. Is the layout of the dataset fit for modeling with <code>lme()</code> function or should be modified, what would be suitable? I would be very grateful to suggestions by the statistics community. Please limit your answer to the <code>nlme</code> R package and not <code>lme4</code>. </p>
73,651
[ -0.03525987267494202, 0.02395414188504219, -0.029193295165896416, 0.011989390477538109, 0.03157857432961464, 0.03813383728265762, -0.003192746313288808, -0.020608913153409958, 0.020656919106841087, 0.02267966978251934, 0.052478689700365067, 0.03260943666100502, 0.05172102153301239, -0.01749359257519245, -0.009392932988703251, 0.02804303541779518, 0.0016989095602184534, 0.01035519689321518, 0.027083395048975945, -0.03775754198431969, -0.012264852412045002, 0.0004241583519615233, 0.0027282102964818478, 0.005648954305797815, -0.0004840947513002902, 0.07152947038412094, -0.005836122669279575, -0.0485733225941658, -0.025231411680579185, 0.04069649800658226, -0.047369685024023056, -0.03346607834100723, -0.009585793130099773, -0.012205500155687332, -0.007003293838351965, 0.015400559641420841, -0.01949036680161953, 0.01679198257625103, 0.025611773133277893, 0.018256446346640587, -0.016190318390727043, 0.0133926160633564, -0.026362711563706398, 0.04662119969725609, -0.005873100366443396, 0.03404363989830017, 0.024228600785136223, 0.011938527226448059, 0.04406053200364113, -0.038856081664562225, 0.011767663061618805, -0.029925499111413956, 0.05528782680630684, 0.0017829309217631817, -0.06540858745574951, -0.028402652591466904, 0.03371912240982056, 0.04278077557682991, 0.03867346793413162, -0.06330440938472748, -0.03470280393958092, -0.03435457497835159, 0.011108780279755592, 0.004091913811862469, -0.013463499955832958, 0.016168083995580673, 0.019016139209270477, 0.00015701133816037327, -0.005547109991312027, -0.03957857936620712, 0.01422982756048441, -0.0035319924354553223, 0.0014670935925096273, -0.017235402017831802, 0.007098165340721607, 0.03655271232128143, -0.020888471975922585, 0.010728856548666954, 0.027000587433576584, 0.00868154689669609, -0.028759554028511047, 0.0008013244951143861, 0.02940310351550579, 0.021316710859537125, 0.02079140767455101, 0.0019820230081677437, 0.03910352289676666, -0.05860956385731697, 0.008248565718531609, 0.031164418905973434, -0.013466879725456238, 0.0023937185760587454, 0.013074572198092937, 0.04015975072979927, -0.03678223863244057, 0.013275361619889736, 0.01024780422449112, 0.013120784424245358, -0.04052090272307396, 0.0036554860416799784, -0.020697107538580894, -0.07608357816934586, 0.013118946924805641, 0.001892458531074226, 0.002676940057426691, -0.04013318568468094, -0.025149522349238396, -0.02795412950217724, -0.01969188265502453, -0.00055524124763906, -0.015846505761146545, 0.012843392789363861, -0.0030861806590110064, 0.00023606521426700056, 0.015184223651885986, -0.07168077677488327, -0.0429408885538578, 0.004525152500718832, 0.05543484911322594, 0.038377244025468826, 0.07974158227443695, -0.013183243572711945, -0.010700354352593422, -0.031768593937158585, -0.04376393184065819, -0.015233559533953667, 0.013050271198153496, -0.011645747348666191, 0.007288955617696047, 0.05512852594256401, 0.024911638349294662, 0.001817893935367465, 0.03940055891871452, -0.009801185689866543, 0.03230336308479309, 0.0068629733286798, -0.06652796268463135, -0.03962159901857376, 0.05926893651485443, 0.041802067309617996, 0.016972064971923828, -0.017319347709417343, 0.014209511689841747, 0.04535738006234169, 0.07609439641237259, 0.00435950793325901, 0.0029726766515523195, 0.031314387917518616, -0.0075116707012057304, 0.0005469254101626575, -0.00559944286942482, 0.004222704563289881, -0.027604900300502777, 0.006476454436779022, -0.03775728493928909, -0.09658889472484589, 0.052847668528556824, 0.010447179898619652, -0.009714438579976559, 0.017772335559129715, 0.062433261424303055, -0.018601754680275917, 0.02469313144683838, -0.008842776529490948, -0.027646733447909355, 0.014471948146820068, 0.036208730190992355, 0.014295981265604496, 0.0035731138195842505, 0.04467156529426575, -0.007894478738307953, 0.0008398304344154894, -0.013087441213428974, 0.03278603032231331, 0.01632007211446762, 0.0026140387635678053, 0.012568974867463112, 0.018581507727503777, -0.009446665644645691, 0.02229793556034565, -0.02460589073598385, -0.08518228679895401, -0.055033326148986816, -0.00046994563308544457, 0.024565378203988075, 0.010699263773858547, -0.01791343279182911, 0.015694523230195045, 0.02583695761859417, -0.025386763736605644, -0.03691430762410164, -0.05176033824682236, 0.006993181072175503, 0.004820144269615412, -0.055085841566324234, 0.003573757130652666, -0.0009638128103688359, 0.02085317112505436, 0.017269400879740715, -0.04027578979730606, -0.006773271597921848, 0.002366061555221677, 0.04570407792925835, -0.01593153364956379, -0.04313352331519127, 0.06891479343175888, 0.06077061593532562, -0.011954274959862232, 0.027098698541522026, -0.010888852179050446, -0.0163444634526968, -0.005686061456799507, -0.04028388857841492, 0.01048709824681282, -0.01685386337339878, -0.03104523941874504, -0.02558075822889805, 0.018083736300468445, -0.026310225948691368, 0.018346711993217468, -0.0752505213022232, 0.05240675061941147, 0.09306620806455612, -0.035998545587062836, -0.007275463547557592, -0.022736039012670517, -0.01637822948396206, 0.02685573324561119, -0.04146956279873848, -0.024435225874185562, -0.05942092835903168, -0.054418694227933884, 0.0032932288013398647, -0.012996425852179527, 0.015885991975665092, -0.007479359395802021, 0.02737218514084816, 0.020679665729403496, 0.022955656051635742, 0.04948779568076134, 0.04094187170267105, -0.0274769626557827, 0.04792730137705803, 0.01163489930331707, 0.02988692931830883, -0.017893366515636444, 0.029088301584124565, -0.0061052278615534306, 0.013360238634049892, 0.03609224408864975, 0.03998788818717003, 0.043862175196409225, -0.0019273067591711879, -0.03447972983121872, -0.01898839883506298, -0.02915695495903492, 0.026328086853027344, -0.005582783836871386, 0.024955593049526215, 0.04662640020251274, 0.020437519997358322, -0.026510970667004585, -0.012285740114748478, -0.011091794818639755, 0.0027060993015766144, 0.03388901427388191, -0.023628687486052513, 0.03161831945180893, 0.027071695774793625, -0.014028992503881454, 0.034307606518268585, -0.03842084854841232, -0.04249505698680878, 0.0006355998339131474, 0.003967955708503723, 0.030842849984765053, -0.008723300881683826, 0.013167018070816994, -0.024921508505940437, 0.03438365086913109, 0.007838095538318157, -0.031195079907774925, -0.003366666380316019, 0.01532300841063261, -0.0530504547059536, -0.003391880076378584, -0.02445184625685215, 0.011150166392326355, 0.00286526745185256, 0.02043909579515457, -0.07189314067363739, 0.06281404197216034, 0.01840694062411785, -0.05118689313530922, -0.063796266913414, -0.02736992947757244, 0.03468018397688866, -0.0317743644118309, 0.008275255560874939, 0.04542391002178192, 0.035056162625551224, -0.0372958779335022, 0.005079819820821285, -0.0032687659841030836, 0.017114127054810524, 0.02112753875553608, -0.022491659969091415, -0.024389129132032394, 0.020041337236762047, -0.015747325494885445, 0.04028969630599022, -0.04786870628595352, -0.04004545882344246, -0.058860406279563904, -0.030671505257487297, 0.025267019867897034, 0.023990463465452194, 0.035458192229270935, -0.008142614737153053, 0.0006083669140934944, 0.04852095991373062, 0.06062665209174156, -0.007758965715765953, -0.05800718441605568, 0.01823407970368862, -0.012622305192053318, -0.028870975598692894, 0.024120813235640526, 0.007080791983753443, 0.018521156162023544, 0.001624668249860406, -0.007859489880502224, 0.033428508788347244, 0.06596170365810394, 0.03946347534656525, 0.0032532899640500546, -0.001233612303622067, 0.03189042955636978, -0.011633451096713543, 0.008154717274010181, 0.026021791622042656, -0.033947259187698364, -0.03735394403338432, 0.013119502924382687, 0.031749460846185684, -0.04022200033068657, -0.05602839216589928, 0.03174412623047829, -0.0135448407381773, 0.019720038399100304, -0.02623085118830204, 0.01866350695490837, 0.024126317352056503, -0.03421478345990181, -0.052963390946388245, 0.057799048721790314, 0.05640849843621254, -0.05231362581253052, -0.018475646153092384, 0.04959465190768242, 0.0152783477678895, -0.03892631083726883, 0.0025398717261850834, -0.046135351061820984, -0.0012404288863763213, 0.01408001035451889, -0.04624149575829506, -0.015770485624670982, -0.014754860661923885, 0.06364209204912186, -0.00018200509657617658, 0.019398197531700134, -0.028565539047122, -0.0022401371970772743, -0.04104114696383476, 0.03647672012448311, -0.012738577090203762, 0.011073797009885311, 0.0005985056632198393, 0.05051250383257866, 0.022611932829022408, -0.012066833674907684, -0.02612108364701271, -0.03136591240763664, -0.07316043227910995, 0.0040872846730053425, 0.012607249431312084, -0.03206441551446915, 0.039293184876441956, -0.04413599148392677, -0.002558966865763068, -0.006124415900558233, 0.003511440707370639, 0.01397337019443512, 0.00904405303299427, -0.0003096482250839472, 0.01692739874124527, 0.009892469272017479, 0.02019115909934044, -0.023421362042427063, 0.008445652201771736, 0.06045251712203026, 0.004361383151262999, 0.0150351757183671, 0.010972375981509686, 0.013651242479681969, -0.006679935846477747, -0.02250474877655506, -0.006929142400622368, 0.053347136825323105, 0.06213097646832466, -0.006310368422418833, 0.026181263849139214, -0.04516535997390747, 0.0009424993768334389, -0.009532658383250237, 0.019828371703624725, 0.0735480785369873, -0.028406742960214615, 0.0014558451948687434, 0.0035636229440569878, 0.00862889550626278, -0.00042577111162245274, 0.02684742771089077, 0.024428682401776314, -0.027538498863577843, 0.03316464647650719, 0.04184381663799286, -0.029266975820064545, -0.0033225903753191233, 0.0402086041867733, 0.018480010330677032, -0.0048120287247002125, -0.0337439626455307, -0.02280818484723568, 0.0145778339356184, -0.004044636618345976, 0.025124404579401016, 0.010712437331676483, 0.006991837173700333, 0.008444812148809433, -0.006915170233696699, -0.03392156586050987, -0.0638309046626091, -0.0006435828981921077, -0.01341757457703352, -0.006614630110561848, 0.025473589077591896, -0.011273248121142387, -0.004748031962662935, 0.0423923023045063, 0.01796933077275753, 0.01885806955397129, 0.0036007126327604055, -0.0987502783536911, 0.008632089011371136, 0.02626473642885685, 0.04447316750884056, -0.007189975585788488, -0.021430708467960358, -0.016717251390218735, -0.008627128787338734, 0.009036814793944359, -0.02051660418510437, -0.017129836603999138, 0.004270755685865879, 0.019578712061047554, -0.02144632488489151, -0.06947444379329681, -0.06056712940335274, 0.0003940569586120546, -0.05711418017745018, -0.003183669177815318, -0.00011886238644365221, -0.01932619698345661, -0.009749321267008781, -0.003629568964242935, -0.01543138176202774, 0.008774293586611748, -0.07732301950454712, 0.020348720252513885, 0.006322549190372229, 0.004203121643513441, -0.011277110315859318, -0.04326864331960678, 0.017275892198085785, 0.011292352341115475, 0.006984162610024214, 0.060605406761169434, 0.009160335175693035, 0.007940569892525673, 0.028208082541823387, 0.02063489705324173, 0.03148443251848221, 0.015791919082403183, -0.04051048681139946, 0.07380637526512146, 0.04823848232626915, -0.014419035986065865, 0.0786452442407608, -0.007713600527495146, 0.019506653770804405, 0.026354430243372917, -0.05313366651535034, -0.000795501924585551, 0.011514260433614254, -0.015287329442799091, -0.04275486618280411, -0.019939472898840904, -0.004134784452617168, 0.037570834159851074, -0.009009074419736862, -0.011139060370624065, -0.01658167876303196, 0.0012739280937239528, 0.0037931224796921015, 0.03650358319282532, 0.01216906402260065, 0.007274824660271406, -0.007303422782570124, -0.018175316974520683, -0.010849489830434322, -0.014226513914763927, 0.028486328199505806, -0.04414817690849304, 0.015263587236404419, -0.03610961139202118, -0.03950021415948868, -0.02455272153019905, -0.013203976675868034, -0.012977058067917824, 0.018647607415914536, -0.02160145714879036, 0.00923791155219078, -0.019754664972424507, 0.03411761298775673, 0.006012150086462498, -0.04125075414776802, -0.022444777190685272, 0.056228335946798325, 0.009057036601006985, -0.03156191110610962, 0.01615848019719124, 0.04367784410715103, -0.0021620593033730984, 0.013261510990560055, -0.019061343744397163, 0.010662844404578209, 0.03529956564307213, 0.014295333065092564, -0.044941939413547516, 0.01800471730530262, -0.026813708245754242, -0.015887247398495674, -0.0070021627470850945, -0.025601826608181, 0.031147271394729614, -0.035121381282806396, -0.023568028584122658, -0.005141737870872021, 0.016664324328303337, 0.06109345704317093, -0.031657006591558456, 0.01055485662072897, -0.0032305275090038776, -0.011441686190664768, -0.006747547537088394, -0.03505237400531769, -0.02667422406375408, -0.03910074383020401, -0.009343667887151241, -0.04563044011592865, 0.007676833774894476, 0.04580327495932579, 0.02978796511888504, -0.03844773396849632, -0.021637240424752235, -0.05199754238128662, -0.030161939561367035, -0.04764648899435997, -0.043101195245981216, 0.011579073034226894, 0.04071543738245964, -0.04932539910078049, 0.03811619430780411, 0.01821579411625862, 0.023051682859659195, -0.000059470021369634196, 0.011154216714203358, -0.037869226187467575, 0.023756861686706543, 0.03994838893413544, -0.02844691090285778, 0.02044244483113289, -0.03169824182987213, 0.03137322887778282, 0.018664874136447906, 0.002414563437923789, -0.0015753530897200108, -0.02797013521194458, 0.01166967861354351, -0.04149017855525017, -0.0023130839690566063, -0.05996095389127731, 0.019983312115073204, 0.045373763889074326, 0.009444157592952251, 0.02615063637495041, 0.057379350066185, -0.029351910576224327, 0.0062074195593595505, -0.018914220854640007, 0.017138658091425896, 0.009222433902323246, 0.014680835418403149, 0.0428093746304512, -0.002205193741247058, -0.0363013856112957, 0.046080440282821655, 0.026722751557826996, 0.025731854140758514, 0.022748295217752457, -0.00037006870843470097, -0.014177062548696995, 0.008352206088602543, -0.04714374616742134, -0.019322747364640236, 0.03700599819421768, -0.029356062412261963, -0.02011999674141407, -0.041341714560985565, 0.02512696385383606, 0.0616840198636055, 0.05450126901268959, -0.003979919478297234, -0.02957049012184143, -0.03400660678744316, -0.06101817265152931, -0.023976149037480354, 0.028893161565065384, -0.01613350585103035, 0.04038570821285248, 0.025510398671030998, 0.05022045597434044, -0.02651955746114254, -0.01554824784398079, -0.04972166568040848, -0.04965973272919655, -0.046319831162691116, 0.01436274778097868, -0.006237585563212633, 0.0929892510175705, -0.012442261911928654, -0.02142927423119545, 0.021947642788290977, -0.04577644169330597, 0.030172724276781082, 0.008188636973500252, 0.029619507491588593, 0.008703263476490974, 0.05459565296769142, 0.008561600930988789, 0.028612790629267693, -0.020532766357064247, -0.019713953137397766, 0.1777205616235733, 0.08972423523664474, 0.03405285254120827, -0.05143207311630249, 0.0537821501493454, 0.04103067144751549, -0.008218763396143913, -0.021721379831433296, 0.004259622190147638, 0.044525083154439926, -0.032370224595069885, 0.07699541747570038, 0.024725569412112236, 0.03567738085985184, -0.021846000105142593, 0.049356523901224136, -0.0452369824051857, -0.022914785891771317, 0.01566307432949543, -0.001538549899123609, -0.028973400592803955, -0.007349136285483837, -0.030016308650374413, 0.013885535299777985, 0.029585180804133415, -0.03818656504154205, -0.004144673701375723, -0.0017649749061092734, 0.014864286407828331, 0.0053498889319598675, 0.0005085297743789852, 0.01030026562511921, -0.012011750601232052, 0.006981349550187588, -0.0007625478901900351, 0.017727574333548546, 0.04457001015543938, -0.007880829274654388, 0.01179046742618084, 0.04610341042280197, -0.022600999101996422, 0.02947191335260868, -0.02913685329258442, 0.056890178471803665, -0.02019287832081318, -0.020696690306067467, -0.00997119676321745, 0.04663778096437454, -0.01702244207262993, -0.018838711082935333, -0.012282933108508587, 0.01273819338530302, 0.01912197470664978, -0.039777401834726334, -0.007416094653308392, 0.04674554616212845, 0.01419965922832489, -0.016948644071817398, 0.04229440167546272, -0.03382096067070961, 0.01454141829162836, 0.00804284866899252, -0.032005567103624344, 0.05639492720365524, -0.016096971929073334, -0.008839182555675507, -0.046601977199316025, 0.019622022286057472, 0.0295624528080225, 0.023295320570468903, 0.015993470326066017, -0.019905289635062218, 0.005500932224094868, -0.012223131023347378, 0.028996692970395088, 0.016101649031043053, 0.004668337292969227, 0.008828741498291492, -0.028036069124937057, -0.03686223551630974, -0.012255100533366203, 0.017392875626683235, -0.03682032600045204, -0.0242051649838686, -0.041460901498794556, 0.015713339671492577, 0.01615067943930626, 0.016017170622944832, 0.03887274116277695, 0.008235621266067028, -0.025868134573101997, 0.039064910262823105, 0.0291054155677557, -0.03744516521692276, -0.0666811540722847, -0.001140994718298316, 0.0062730503268539906, -0.028363363817334175, 0.006602419540286064, 0.048414330929517746, 0.023503173142671585, -0.004636061377823353, 0.00959867238998413, 0.03978818282485008, -0.0018117422005161643, -0.024681391194462776, 0.027961695566773415, -0.05548872798681259, 0.0044505298137664795, 0.014301098883152008, -0.02405335009098053, -0.030308812856674194, -0.011906567960977554, -0.024752994999289513, -0.0439688004553318, 0.025172827765345573, -0.044282227754592896, -0.03400396183133125, 0.02182057499885559, -0.01473625935614109, 0.03190029412508011, -0.024990515783429146, -0.013067713007330894, -0.06044561043381691, -0.047560352832078934, -0.00018978779553435743, -0.037446942180395126, 0.020981989800930023, 0.015591672621667385, -0.0253604669123888, 0.0300906952470541, 0.03008183464407921, 0.021308816969394684, 0.04098871350288391, 0.019830308854579926, 0.018120963126420975, 0.007591368164867163, 0.009017014876008034, 0.02105049043893814, -0.05819004029035568, -0.003250665497034788, -0.052545495331287384, -0.026656972244381905, 0.024348275735974312, 0.023401523008942604, 0.0381588414311409, 0.013521767221391201, 0.02133667841553688, 0.01294719334691763, 0.05015721917152405, -0.04695207253098488, -0.033632319420576096, 0.0002481815463397652, -0.02793121710419655, 0.02749377116560936, -0.03624751791357994, 0.028234735131263733, 0.028591446578502655, -0.009071807377040386, 0.016429506242275238, 0.04530317336320877, 0.0170581117272377, -0.007147606462240219, 0.0016318807611241937, 0.008921596221625805, 0.003411548677831888, 0.03151286393404007, -0.02285798452794552, 0.04406367987394333, 0.05272259563207626, -0.010627458803355694, 0.011250142939388752, -0.010867808014154434, 0.012746824882924557, -0.0776766985654831, -0.015309656038880348, -0.02031872607767582, 0.007065058685839176, 0.02368623949587345, -0.05280010402202606, 0.0013075933093205094, 0.013968381099402905, -0.04174898564815521, 0.032297275960445404, 0.005726849194616079, 0.026477960869669914, -0.047048673033714294, 0.018115991726517677, -0.02030235528945923, 0.004599304404109716, 0.02602301724255085, 0.006765653379261494, -0.0005521715502254665, 0.015660617500543594, 0.021421214565634727, -0.0549979992210865, -0.03938204422593117, 0.03805828467011452, 0.01677657477557659, -0.08892406523227692, 0.009111505001783371, -0.025284554809331894, -0.02432876080274582, -0.013773270882666111, -0.019871067255735397, 0.010108675807714462, 0.03838984668254852, 0.013167060911655426, 0.004097788129001856, 0.05267065018415451, -0.010679127648472786, 0.009126250632107258, 0.01810585893690586, -0.0531209297478199, -0.011817394755780697, 0.021909985691308975, -0.02746926061809063, 0.03432931378483772, 0.046088285744190216, 0.016034984961152077, 0.0031068671960383654, 0.0008601418230682611, -0.02138551138341427, -0.019353002309799194, -0.053209010511636734, -0.022298702970147133, 0.010210529901087284, -0.013270139694213867, -0.03595053777098656, -0.05867541953921318, 0.060471173375844955, 0.04705353453755379, -0.006812624633312225, -0.022968297824263573, 0.031153714284300804, -0.011567717418074608, 0.0016946039395406842, 0.0009619356133043766, 0.01105516403913498, 0.01874224841594696, -0.05217348411679268, -0.008338404819369316, -0.032493770122528076, -0.025310557335615158, -0.023829562589526176, 0.04261978343129158, 0.011539689265191555, 0.010561618022620678, -0.021562987938523293, -0.004685120191425085, -0.007101015187799931, -0.00933096930384636, 0.06759155541658401, -0.09255845099687576, 0.0458880178630352, 0.017959915101528168, -0.054188601672649384, -0.053780537098646164, -0.015309757553040981, -0.044827286154031754, 0.027592716738581657, 0.020426983013749123, 0.020593738183379173, -0.022100817412137985, -0.00590893579646945, 0.038955848664045334, -0.0006574478466063738, -0.05350520834326744, 0.08025706559419632, -0.027922973036766052, 0.006025718059390783, -0.021557895466685295, 0.019176768139004707, -0.006078355945646763, 0.04416414722800255, 0.025950036942958832, -0.034880660474300385, -0.004936804994940758, -0.010638412088155746, 0.011046892032027245, 0.002907203510403633, 0.023825306445360184, -0.004297893028706312, 0.004722082521766424, 0.009819994680583477, 0.0065255798399448395, 0.06353006511926651, 0.008997238241136074, -0.02252900041639805, 0.003995517268776894, -0.06385889649391174, -0.012832870706915855, 0.03138117864727974, -0.0007294166716746986, -0.005261536687612534, -0.06894639134407043, -0.005841846112161875, 0.018129877746105194, -0.04247024282813072, -0.014464939013123512, 0.037273287773132324, 0.024174682796001434, -0.004669051617383957, -0.0024571651592850685, 0.030053431168198586, 0.00045567398774437606, 0.004165110178291798, 0.029865868389606476, 0.030936172232031822, 0.010721069760620594, -0.005364421755075455, 0.0047011710703372955, 0.01802138425409794, -0.021461080759763718, 0.018454566597938538, 0.007435389328747988, 0.060849111527204514, -0.007571400608867407, 0.003826887346804142, 0.005103618837893009, 0.003289381042122841, 0.007581585086882114, -0.011277052573859692, 0.011178236454725266, 0.026582732796669006, -0.06319267302751541, 0.003639325499534607, -0.018817899748682976, 0.014260428957641125, -0.00936182588338852, 0.023066215217113495, 0.03702297806739807, 0.006503249518573284, 0.0026937779039144516, 0.011951846070587635, -0.0010916005121544003, -0.011727939359843731, -0.033753760159015656, -0.04733588173985481, 0.038015834987163544, 0.02060934342443943, -0.050982166081666946, 0.004621131811290979, -0.009855180978775024, -0.010254506953060627, -0.042634278535842896, 0.015401273965835571, 0.0051061916165053844, 0.02397191897034645, -0.03734207525849342, 0.0004141604295000434, -0.007970341481268406, 0.028702493757009506, -0.04745956510305405, -0.027921434491872787, -0.026349611580371857, 0.011310488916933537, 0.024255577474832535, 0.028161946684122086 ]
<p>I have set of time series data tuples: {$(1,22), (2, 25), (3, 18), (4, 26), ...$ so on}</p> <p>I want to estimate $Y_{t+1}$ using support vector machine regression technique. I have found numerous publications that mostly refer to <a href="http://alex.smola.org/papers/2003/SmoSch03b.pdf" rel="nofollow">Smola's paper</a>. I want to understand the technique to implement it in my programming. </p> <p>There are numerous examples available for simple regression techniques, but is there any simple example available that solves the problem of finding regression with support vector machine on a given data set using the equations and also shows the steps? </p>
47,585
[ 0.010232016444206238, -0.05588465929031372, -0.0037132457364350557, -0.008738528937101364, -0.0012826925376430154, -0.0005409881705418229, -0.019135192036628723, 0.00935597438365221, 0.03637563809752464, -0.029726166278123856, 0.05400250852108002, 0.0317852683365345, 0.029444517567753792, 0.003049182239919901, 0.03195755183696747, -0.007188727147877216, -0.014424140565097332, -0.004128915723413229, -0.008210699073970318, 0.009949012659490108, 0.0037249720189720392, 0.02533591538667679, -0.004476632922887802, -0.005472199991345406, -0.00044168709428049624, 0.025026148185133934, 0.00974375382065773, 0.017179856076836586, 0.008465471677482128, 0.048189032822847366, -0.04290788993239403, -0.042397383600473404, -0.013427695259451866, 0.04260871559381485, 0.02288808673620224, -0.025385018438100815, -0.029031794518232346, -0.038689665496349335, 0.03012027218937874, 0.05287833511829376, -0.0158385057002306, -0.011151266284286976, -0.003390790894627571, 0.05936163663864136, -0.00835137814283371, 0.036123719066381454, 0.0006770493346266448, -0.02518744021654129, 0.027834106236696243, -0.05233938619494438, 0.09859107434749603, -0.006220211274921894, 0.030757112428545952, 0.017421752214431763, -0.0014853790635243058, 0.024194272235035896, 0.042636796832084656, 0.06786283850669861, -0.0009252239833585918, -0.05030465126037598, -0.009652586653828621, -0.01509279478341341, -0.016318943351507187, -0.039224058389663696, -0.034818582236766815, 0.027715463191270828, -0.006166465114802122, -0.021810822188854218, 0.008253758773207664, -0.029124915599822998, 0.002359105506911874, -0.01935127191245556, 0.05440835654735565, -0.012256115674972534, -0.009043573401868343, -0.031695835292339325, 0.0012656915932893753, 0.024446450173854828, 0.02557089366018772, 0.024623529985547066, 0.03151860460639, 0.02537909336388111, 0.043984562158584595, 0.005134324077516794, -0.024706507101655006, -0.020674901083111763, 0.06794959306716919, 0.005507633090019226, 0.03481137007474899, 0.03146772086620331, -0.00528649752959609, 0.03407585993409157, 0.020805425941944122, 0.011842531152069569, -0.05518548563122749, 0.014695258811116219, -0.0030071723740547895, 0.020966611802577972, 0.00891333632171154, -0.03407109156250954, 0.0065645878203213215, -0.018761439248919487, 0.0029961976688355207, 0.04998694732785225, -0.0703662857413292, 0.0008053521742112935, -0.021116621792316437, -0.001530282897874713, -0.010838952846825123, -0.012845017947256565, -0.03583159297704697, -0.00048122977023012936, 0.018039988353848457, -0.012240598909556866, 0.02401036210358143, 0.004457078408449888, -0.025643106549978256, -0.029890218749642372, 0.022585595026612282, 0.0730823203921318, 0.02781970053911209, -0.051304012537002563, 0.03634729981422424, 0.002780293580144644, -0.055873844772577286, 0.03502996638417244, -0.008522190153598785, -0.04165332764387131, -0.03592795133590698, 0.058842942118644714, -0.008863640017807484, -0.04797340929508209, 0.02541510760784149, -0.011196167208254337, 0.04729168117046356, -0.004758311435580254, -0.07635332643985748, -0.054426006972789764, 0.027526624500751495, -0.017240919172763824, 0.012036824598908424, -0.04558653011918068, 0.02948431856930256, 0.00038041206425987184, 0.05938873067498207, 0.027699071913957596, 0.031215738505125046, 0.05087100714445114, 0.05680247023701668, 0.0006083380430936813, -0.03892930969595909, -0.013593652285635471, -0.015026627108454704, -0.044516343623399734, -0.015920406207442284, -0.06569023430347443, 0.0014197923010215163, 0.007491611875593662, -0.013616007752716541, 0.009409626945853233, 0.029574129730463028, 0.02737242728471756, 0.0004176136280875653, 0.02707034721970558, 0.01615091785788536, -0.030326958745718002, 0.0498327910900116, 0.02777038887143135, 0.013633187860250473, 0.020258832722902298, -0.005311848595738411, -0.007113907020539045, 0.054021429270505905, 0.032337214797735214, 0.05464843660593033, -0.010766481049358845, -0.021195678040385246, 0.03092234767973423, -0.002613550052046776, 0.006295497063547373, -0.053692370653152466, -0.04410933330655098, 0.021119114011526108, 0.0388106107711792, 0.0395018570125103, 0.06896796077489853, -0.008306220173835754, -0.015789585188031197, 0.026029353961348534, -0.07042647898197174, -0.02020200341939926, -0.04488328471779823, -0.0065443613566458225, -0.010799766518175602, -0.0005090355407446623, 0.024729792028665543, 0.010936051607131958, 0.011526111513376236, -0.02573462948203087, -0.030184905976057053, -0.028320807963609695, -0.004915452096611261, 0.04412616416811943, -0.02201613038778305, -0.0172849390655756, 0.031872812658548355, 0.023414362221956253, -0.018334239721298218, 0.04337271675467491, -0.03608836606144905, -0.04088447988033295, 0.007915153168141842, -0.04763985425233841, 0.022072765976190567, -0.029453905299305916, -0.011888065375387669, 0.018832875415682793, -0.038327813148498535, -0.010183217003941536, 0.03687744587659836, -0.04866425693035126, 0.04480263590812683, 0.06440497189760208, 0.06129802390933037, 0.014589456841349602, -0.017818305641412735, 0.005600116215646267, 0.028169037774205208, 0.0006650838768109679, -0.01266328152269125, -0.05947348102927208, -0.01484355702996254, 0.018987879157066345, 0.05811237916350365, -0.06070470064878464, -0.00420747883617878, 0.07891063392162323, 0.023531196638941765, -0.01607835851609707, 0.0026390496641397476, -0.036936886608600616, 0.012870320118963718, -0.004036290105432272, 0.011317404918372631, -0.009066181257367134, -0.0005899777170270681, -0.008607092313468456, 0.038182564079761505, 0.02018970623612404, 0.03204667940735817, 0.0008278263849206269, 0.07187999784946442, -0.009686428122222424, -0.008412846364080906, -0.022440874949097633, -0.04595227167010307, 0.035790447145700455, -0.03012963943183422, -0.014076067134737968, 0.0174233540892601, -0.0029450354631990194, 0.021340027451515198, 0.019813036546111107, 0.012586656026542187, 0.005292570684105158, 0.045668866485357285, -0.025314169004559517, 0.017237622290849686, 0.03410441055893898, -0.06492728739976883, 0.017345471307635307, -0.01810161955654621, -0.05793450027704239, -0.06640941649675369, 0.019397184252738953, 0.028456052765250206, -0.013499695807695389, 0.006924813147634268, -0.018586335703730583, -0.008855478838086128, 0.017611298710107803, -0.01256556622684002, 0.021526409313082695, -0.007981439121067524, -0.04935791343450546, 0.017687533050775528, -0.03092646412551403, -0.02167603187263012, 0.03523053228855133, -0.0013242674758657813, 0.00017189948994200677, 0.0280090793967247, -0.006160149350762367, -0.08491860330104828, -0.036968279629945755, -0.04429610073566437, 0.02830038033425808, -0.008255306631326675, 0.004130166955292225, 0.057883989065885544, 0.001961320172995329, -0.05538627505302429, 0.016056813299655914, -0.03937153145670891, -0.02346661686897278, -0.05451364815235138, -0.004961396101862192, -0.00023640964354854077, -0.010067431256175041, -0.0011291072005406022, 0.029773224145174026, -0.010444638319313526, 0.008734985254704952, -0.07482069730758667, -0.058778099715709686, 0.03254438936710358, 0.02374645136296749, 0.03699644282460213, 0.031865477561950684, -0.03839673846960068, 0.08557574450969696, 0.021819809451699257, -0.025902651250362396, -0.04464045539498329, 0.01594345085322857, -0.011847540736198425, -0.024600457400083542, 0.030339160934090614, 0.022489439696073532, 0.022207075729966164, 0.02255929447710514, -0.004149261862039566, 0.016309386119246483, 0.08963947743177414, 0.013730754144489765, -0.01847982034087181, -0.0003257437492720783, -0.03111051581799984, 0.017087962478399277, 0.042477913200855255, -0.018601996824145317, -0.01076939795166254, -0.021344268694519997, -0.004006090108305216, 0.00005815607437398285, 0.00403205631300807, -0.04356486350297928, 0.011786429211497307, -0.01909247785806656, -0.02219834178686142, -0.032822757959365845, -0.012427300214767456, 0.005261521320790052, -0.005723949056118727, -0.011703968048095703, 0.031107721850275993, 0.014512518420815468, -0.024505620822310448, 0.012849888764321804, 0.03133625164628029, 0.022300798445940018, -0.016377272084355354, -0.02413281425833702, -0.01966547779738903, -0.042386073619127274, 0.029580283910036087, -0.01678491197526455, 0.00038911664159968495, 0.04095188528299332, 0.047776177525520325, 0.012555979192256927, 0.00327454530633986, -0.026515675708651543, 0.014975038357079029, -0.09000011533498764, -0.020683126524090767, -0.024079103022813797, 0.07436900585889816, 0.02182672545313835, 0.023438679054379463, -0.0025461544282734394, -0.016036709770560265, 0.05274937301874161, -0.0039282613433897495, -0.06932559609413147, 0.008653470315039158, -0.028577255085110664, 0.003958940040320158, -0.0024706365074962378, -0.003223692998290062, 0.06629212945699692, -0.02092859148979187, 0.017808424308896065, -0.03959579020738602, 0.01851588301360607, -0.027529172599315643, 0.010017892345786095, -0.006894630845636129, -0.008639317937195301, -0.02765873819589615, 0.005134084727615118, 0.0405244454741478, -0.06123786047101021, 0.008417511358857155, 0.034706972539424896, -0.01990656927227974, -0.014351013116538525, -0.026104707270860672, 0.024569829925894737, 0.0234435573220253, 0.029668796807527542, 0.037469375878572464, 0.01872464269399643, -0.0718841478228569, -0.011719550006091595, -0.009772335179150105, 0.027260534465312958, 0.0631261095404625, -0.005668715573847294, -0.016322406008839607, -0.0032056840136647224, -0.0021022348664700985, 0.04205896332859993, 0.0036380549427121878, 0.03893743455410004, 0.03292334824800491, 0.04866749048233032, -0.0017185840988531709, -0.0896320641040802, 0.01573220267891884, 0.05011041834950447, 0.007628981955349445, 0.026772139593958855, -0.028355149552226067, -0.001393580692820251, -0.008027777075767517, -0.0013391721295192838, 0.013124165125191212, -0.009408347308635712, -0.022253351286053658, 0.005783111788332462, 0.03719203919172287, -0.006860216613858938, -0.032638926059007645, 0.014912835322320461, 0.06128031015396118, 0.06040706858038902, -0.007429024670273066, -0.0426982082426548, 0.020839957520365715, 0.07587464898824692, 0.024851825088262558, 0.016297712922096252, 0.012512567453086376, -0.09728917479515076, 0.010300916619598866, 0.033493977040052414, 0.0361444428563118, -0.03371034562587738, 0.0006085943314246833, -0.032427530735731125, 0.016388369724154472, 0.04158471152186394, -0.00047950385487638414, 0.045305587351322174, 0.019665900617837906, -0.008140438236296177, -0.045014332979917526, -0.02068965509533882, -0.03980458527803421, 0.0492967814207077, -0.04856797680258751, 0.04064108058810234, -0.024659547954797745, -0.028854258358478546, -0.04818587005138397, -0.018134865909814835, 0.011012870818376541, 0.07144026458263397, -0.00777427526190877, -0.018185105174779892, 0.00371343269944191, 0.043677110224962234, -0.0013704721350222826, -0.02930276282131672, 0.005559922195971012, 0.015061737038195133, -0.009022216312587261, 0.03166382759809494, -0.014265371486544609, -0.033204421401023865, 0.01988714188337326, 0.03516165912151337, 0.0009631455177441239, -0.0075678033754229546, -0.024756601080298424, 0.03240786865353584, 0.02416957914829254, 0.018424544483423233, 0.0553988441824913, 0.051301270723342896, 0.015250441618263721, -0.007472379133105278, -0.002945408457890153, -0.03611065819859505, -0.037548162043094635, -0.03960149362683296, -0.029835116118192673, -0.008885592222213745, -0.02474118582904339, 0.03220558166503906, 0.018050340935587883, 0.023375777527689934, -0.041515547782182693, 0.004002345260232687, -0.0249356459826231, 0.05737437680363655, 0.004556433763355017, -0.018093431368470192, 0.024463556706905365, 0.015130751766264439, -0.03244515135884285, -0.02750253491103649, 0.018252363428473473, -0.028690999373793602, -0.011926504783332348, 0.011648718267679214, -0.044862281531095505, 0.022192398086190224, -0.022230729460716248, -0.013235868886113167, 0.01557577308267355, -0.04110994189977646, 0.04154336452484131, -0.01886828802525997, 0.03149065747857094, 0.0030351122841238976, -0.043703194707632065, -0.009025679901242256, -0.007219507824629545, -0.01584906317293644, 0.010600694455206394, -0.025553779676556587, 0.00597080122679472, 0.03003772534430027, -0.013652107678353786, -0.062233198434114456, -0.039687927812337875, 0.032735783606767654, -0.014258376322686672, -0.036759477108716965, -0.03193879872560501, 0.013518705032765865, -0.017961794510483742, -0.0366949625313282, -0.007694673258811235, 0.042511213570833206, -0.0179604385048151, -0.02235393412411213, -0.011478699743747711, 0.0007727686315774918, 0.07749637216329575, 0.017595097422599792, 0.01748056896030903, 0.012016473338007927, -0.011097986251115799, -0.04868298023939133, 0.017637303099036217, 0.023330697789788246, -0.025014737620949745, 0.01360193733125925, -0.05218823626637459, 0.0022630030289292336, 0.010862360708415508, -0.010565057396888733, 0.006080904044210911, 0.019260412082076073, 0.008090957067906857, 0.011291684582829475, -0.04554741084575653, 0.018654098734259605, 0.007078534923493862, -0.05282296985387802, 0.010157942771911621, -0.016594568267464638, 0.011363213881850243, 0.006345967296510935, 0.019738221541047096, -0.006064478773623705, -0.03120163269340992, 0.008618894033133984, 0.04931708052754402, 0.002947807079181075, 0.01877530850470066, 0.009853719733655453, -0.021164031699299812, 0.002865889109671116, 0.00015204984811134636, 0.015473713167011738, 0.0046443939208984375, 0.03305208683013916, -0.031077690422534943, -0.024904681369662285, -0.023571446537971497, 0.020356448367238045, 0.08278439939022064, -0.025196747854351997, 0.05840662121772766, 0.04483687877655029, 0.015001022256910801, 0.02756519243121147, -0.012967465445399284, -0.018841613084077835, -0.03156501054763794, -0.038344208151102066, 0.023777617141604424, -0.006519968155771494, 0.042723190039396286, 0.017090898007154465, 0.02084304764866829, -0.010741555131971836, 0.04529600962996483, -0.01108190044760704, 0.0023913858458399773, 0.038261279463768005, -0.015488248318433762, -0.035963501781225204, 0.013238511048257351, 0.013682118616998196, 0.03551888093352318, -0.025023290887475014, -0.003051499603316188, 0.023725099861621857, 0.008803680539131165, 0.026723945513367653, -0.057563431560993195, -0.015150144696235657, -0.03323011472821236, 0.01985238865017891, 0.052864570170640945, -0.04001394659280777, 0.03826865181326866, 0.07828716188669205, -0.012556463479995728, 0.010945487767457962, 0.05240970849990845, -0.029328783974051476, -0.06543976813554764, -0.038814909756183624, -0.054518550634384155, -0.027939340099692345, 0.04086707904934883, 0.034077174961566925, -0.06073551997542381, -0.024933358654379845, -0.006614196114242077, 0.03502810746431351, 0.01624070294201374, 0.03263882175087929, 0.010821433737874031, 0.06868228316307068, -0.006166336126625538, -0.0019778364803642035, -0.011043415404856205, 0.0037589496932923794, 0.09783877432346344, 0.11369691044092178, 0.033379893749952316, -0.07072868198156357, -0.005285636521875858, -0.0005430802120827138, -0.02959499880671501, -0.017340047284960747, 0.023345671594142914, 0.0040690661408007145, -0.007795906160026789, 0.013288378715515137, 0.03013923577964306, -0.01099933311343193, 0.013699978590011597, 0.061578936874866486, -0.055140383541584015, 0.020857149735093117, -0.008233281783759594, -0.021638289093971252, 0.014637695625424385, -0.003998842556029558, -0.06257614493370056, 0.009043030440807343, -0.006517323665320873, -0.042207248508930206, -0.014092336408793926, -0.04680837690830231, -0.002859884174540639, -0.012295180931687355, -0.04169716313481331, -0.007524521090090275, 0.013470281846821308, 0.005142361856997013, -0.03842197358608246, 0.007874296978116035, -0.015554928220808506, -0.017554596066474915, 0.031089384108781815, 0.03098195418715477, 0.032540470361709595, -0.023822395130991936, -0.0023163899313658476, 0.005960685200989246, -0.03431690111756325, -0.01875198818743229, -0.0405796654522419, 0.05013001710176468, -0.014474897645413876, -0.02986179292201996, -0.018215669319033623, 0.006204699631780386, 0.0015972359105944633, -0.03555189445614815, 0.015938308089971542, 0.02577700838446617, 0.055577926337718964, -0.04738422855734825, -0.007571039255708456, -0.019398579373955727, -0.011985923163592815, -0.030499624088406563, 0.03851330652832985, 0.045043837279081345, -0.0538797453045845, -0.015010833740234375, -0.023572631180286407, -0.003169621340930462, 0.0000831736033433117, -0.03955639898777008, -0.010905805043876171, -0.0452720932662487, 0.003152785124257207, -0.007116351742297411, 0.03642790764570236, -0.001290993532165885, 0.003557539777830243, -0.014162822626531124, -0.027140116319060326, -0.007047567050904036, -0.05339256674051285, 0.03119981847703457, -0.03977125883102417, 0.000489002326503396, -0.03387193754315376, 0.001040977076627314, 0.022135591134428978, 0.026520317420363426, -0.004041493870317936, -0.0065810889936983585, -0.0015904203755781054, 0.008961046114563942, 0.01673126593232155, -0.05747248977422714, -0.0353999026119709, -0.028899425640702248, -0.02630418911576271, 0.0014996143290773034, -0.014880664646625519, 0.061011552810668945, 0.05596642941236496, 0.019558001309633255, 0.000806474476121366, 0.03206543251872063, -0.004258198197931051, 0.01998274400830269, -0.016511565074324608, -0.0397912971675396, 0.015266375616192818, -0.009970984421670437, -0.003612943459302187, -0.01293058693408966, 0.00982896238565445, -0.02540181763470173, -0.014502683654427528, 0.012422184459865093, -0.01155795343220234, -0.06452113389968872, 0.04528774693608284, -0.02275969460606575, 0.015102624893188477, 0.004436202347278595, -0.007442637346684933, -0.015166051685810089, -0.001473217154853046, -0.004908434115350246, -0.02236413210630417, 0.0020346087403595448, -0.004896270576864481, -0.02645272947847843, 0.00109994993545115, 0.03891634941101074, 0.011789308860898018, 0.029818180948495865, 0.018548056483268738, 0.028640147298574448, -0.016995569691061974, 0.04891218617558479, -0.037020232528448105, -0.038003452122211456, 0.01073072012513876, -0.034952592104673386, 0.0022203580010682344, 0.03175996616482735, -0.0057083978317677975, 0.02871481515467167, 0.024796796962618828, 0.013306975364685059, -0.03909378498792648, 0.04899708554148674, -0.011678720824420452, 0.016702190041542053, -0.005752165801823139, 0.02503095008432865, 0.018875235691666603, 0.008755394257605076, -0.0016083379741758108, 0.018502309918403625, -0.0014161239378154278, -0.02462935261428356, 0.033802952617406845, 0.03128528222441673, -0.028374187648296356, 0.007717594504356384, 0.026211852207779884, 0.01075083576142788, 0.00967707484960556, -0.024824099615216255, 0.07203318923711777, 0.02885146252810955, -0.004773907829076052, 0.03641260415315628, 0.011267179623246193, 0.002743964549154043, -0.0779557079076767, 0.012987751513719559, 0.010065617971122265, 0.03527011722326279, 0.00014043085684534162, -0.058048367500305176, 0.008125106804072857, 0.053024012595415115, 0.004406377673149109, 0.018615446984767914, 0.0042874449864029884, -0.01641259156167507, -0.0009185270173475146, -0.007506572641432285, -0.00916068535298109, 0.05710384249687195, 0.05137769132852554, 0.041572455316782, 0.047109637409448624, 0.03317519649863243, 0.0014511074405163527, -0.027060654014348984, -0.021574612706899643, 0.03292438015341759, 0.009801266714930534, -0.04356026276946068, 0.062026455998420715, -0.026428330689668655, -0.011664219200611115, -0.011307455599308014, 0.01393097173422575, 0.009126963093876839, 0.024259857833385468, 0.010499210096895695, -0.028702465817332268, 0.06663189083337784, 0.04199368134140968, -0.000775142980273813, -0.0021719923242926598, -0.011670790612697601, 0.023014113306999207, 0.021665265783667564, -0.01601833663880825, -0.0022865701466798782, 0.008231891319155693, -0.0049036829732358456, -0.024818165227770805, -0.00792159978300333, 0.012898907996714115, -0.020153280347585678, 0.034608393907547, -0.03008234314620495, -0.014491977170109749, -0.03463849052786827, 0.018269676715135574, -0.03930418938398361, -0.01469612866640091, 0.003546549007296562, 0.004301785957068205, -0.04194248095154762, 0.011431409977376461, 0.013685858808457851, -0.041993092745542526, 0.02599695324897766, 0.012281686998903751, -0.025904517620801926, -0.06293676048517227, 0.015425913035869598, 0.027576932683587074, -0.03036457672715187, -0.07867319881916046, -0.0015344201819971204, -0.03474961221218109, 0.0483681820333004, -0.007599662058055401, -0.005569929257035255, 0.04647037386894226, -0.014706402085721493, -0.00020723204943351448, -0.05305693298578262, 0.06609685719013214, 0.013718370348215103, -0.026637980714440346, 0.00025852079852484167, -0.019501321017742157, -0.019555529579520226, -0.0038759030867367983, 0.03326030448079109, -0.033649615943431854, 0.007093423046171665, -0.020972732454538345, 0.024226630106568336, -0.0016578873619437218, -0.04414813593029976, 0.03350185602903366, 0.014428134076297283, -0.037619564682245255, 0.016666023060679436, -0.03442944586277008, -0.0021361778490245342, -0.006916923448443413, 0.03947647660970688, 0.012542260810732841, -0.01958446018397808, 0.030964914709329605, -0.021495237946510315, -0.0037466390058398247, 0.04841289669275284, 0.011643932200968266, 0.10497866570949554, 0.012893562205135822, 0.020072124898433685, 0.012859740294516087, 0.014878125861287117, -0.06001714617013931, 0.010867167264223099, -0.058137424290180206, -0.021325767040252686, -0.017385374754667282, -0.024041425436735153, -0.019941572099924088, -0.07009100914001465, -0.04006774351000786, 0.04723556712269783, -0.003018618794158101, -0.002986692823469639, 0.02668691799044609, -0.01679486408829689, 0.024886025115847588, -0.007258550729602575, 0.027650954201817513, 0.018936343491077423, -0.0003699564840644598, 0.02005350962281227, 0.02287759631872177, 0.020537905395030975, -0.028859242796897888, 0.004882594104856253, 0.026681378483772278, 0.004837806802242994, 0.025596983730793, 0.010878336615860462, 0.020642047747969627, -0.021625077351927757, 0.0020631542429327965, -0.01709824800491333, -0.007491289172321558, -0.0221176128834486, 0.0013883017236366868, -0.04401497170329094, 0.06012021377682686, -0.05054328218102455, 0.0021283491514623165, -0.031010977923870087, -0.00023575988598167896, -0.017626628279685974, -0.013934973627328873, 0.0034091235138475895, 0.015958858653903008, -0.002701273187994957, 0.03853652998805046, 0.05131380632519722, 0.007110767997801304, 0.03524157404899597, 0.00684382626786828, -0.007085468154400587, 0.021004319190979004, 0.009216496720910072, -0.019162887707352638, -0.0204399935901165, 0.0009218288469128311, -0.05578182637691498, 0.02246500737965107, 0.04477118328213692, -0.0014846777776256204, -0.02252260595560074, -0.01712692156434059, -0.03577271103858948, 0.04099361598491669, -0.0922258198261261, -0.019253378733992577, -0.02943134866654873, -0.02152778021991253, -0.020771993324160576, -0.04223604500293732 ]
<p>I have accuracy vectors of two classifiers. How can I make a t-test for them on Matlab and is there a good plot type to show it?</p>
36,075
[ -0.045457739382982254, -0.019985217601060867, -0.0201224684715271, 0.020665721967816353, 0.03000458888709545, 0.03191894665360451, -0.0211466234177351, 0.011681108735501766, 0.009155324660241604, -0.013165139593183994, 0.06356769055128098, 0.029295634478330612, 0.03397798165678978, 0.047453127801418304, 0.00406081136316061, -0.014128083363175392, -0.04914713278412819, -0.0146042350679636, 0.0044527817517519, -0.002237120410427451, -0.0018988966476172209, -0.0037311152555048466, 0.010688669048249722, 0.0009834998054429889, 0.008462686091661453, 0.03365294262766838, 0.0267694890499115, -0.012954402714967728, 0.006765885278582573, 0.06366366893053055, -0.05405522510409355, -0.04753468185663223, 0.04825230687856674, -0.0003020667063537985, 0.009556787088513374, -0.010534670203924179, -0.012998120859265327, -0.015403224155306816, -0.02952727861702442, 0.012502118945121765, -0.03612779453396797, -0.007433561608195305, 0.017225807532668114, 0.04931120574474335, -0.01800389215350151, 0.012429670430719852, 0.009093785658478737, -0.031086325645446777, 0.038010478019714355, -0.045773979276418686, 0.0784752294421196, 0.005472807679325342, 0.049085505306720734, 0.01003709901124239, -0.0032671864610165358, 0.0012145019136369228, 0.023935595527291298, 0.055927880108356476, 0.0030089011415839195, -0.022922825068235397, 0.027848485857248306, -0.019268572330474854, 0.004961267579346895, -0.04201715812087059, -0.028261404484510422, 0.02190198190510273, -0.024571850895881653, 0.004336229059845209, 0.0012675654143095016, -0.042564306408166885, -0.012989499606192112, 0.025103570893406868, 0.0060139247216284275, -0.027937276288866997, 0.013689476065337658, -0.03904044255614281, 0.024901337921619415, 0.047731753438711166, 0.06602299213409424, 0.012226435355842113, 0.018739450722932816, 0.04555896669626236, 0.026504455134272575, 0.044195376336574554, 0.025889644399285316, -0.013311060145497322, 0.04790123179554939, 0.022717026993632317, 0.004721078556030989, 0.02311289682984352, -0.0417855866253376, -0.004296761006116867, 0.06340471655130386, 0.03195449709892273, -0.03441018983721733, -0.0008088742615655065, -0.007328380830585957, 0.033462777733802795, 0.012672639451920986, -0.017612729221582413, 0.005926261190325022, -0.029235344380140305, -0.006000248249620199, 0.04678421467542648, -0.002725724596530199, -0.014276701956987381, -0.017103392630815506, -0.034636687487363815, -0.014804605394601822, -0.002142484998330474, 0.004258220549672842, 0.03739670291543007, 0.0002932503412012011, 0.014099407009780407, 0.032290633767843246, -0.01076817698776722, -0.00758858909830451, -0.00821868609637022, 0.04294925183057785, 0.059480566531419754, 0.050108060240745544, -0.01470826007425785, 0.036848846822977066, 0.0023820616770535707, -0.04724011570215225, 0.012603122740983963, 0.016950706019997597, -0.015724454075098038, -0.03312790021300316, 0.06560586392879486, -0.04810625687241554, -0.020978424698114395, 0.028541598469018936, -0.026894189417362213, 0.011280403472483158, -0.04448733478784561, -0.04366481304168701, -0.0684342086315155, 0.008605658076703548, -0.009905388578772545, -0.002132791094481945, -0.0755777657032013, 0.008536041714251041, 0.047312188893556595, 0.04068300873041153, 0.0626894012093544, 0.03928249329328537, 0.02039838396012783, 0.024836521595716476, 0.005605452693998814, -0.02439188025891781, 0.001313073793426156, -0.028476569801568985, -0.0030400597024708986, -0.02562088891863823, -0.05105869099497795, -0.03427589684724808, 0.014541221782565117, -0.040967971086502075, 0.007677578367292881, 0.01374849397689104, -0.011890994384884834, 0.0016017308225855231, -0.013438401743769646, 0.00412767892703414, -0.015625402331352234, 0.08093714714050293, -0.015964610502123833, 0.03936754912137985, -0.01691114343702793, -0.02784857340157032, -0.0016546824481338263, 0.036810196936130524, 0.016990721225738525, 0.05094849690794945, 0.003327669808641076, -0.02147059515118599, -0.03217972069978714, 0.022357359528541565, 0.02868882566690445, -0.028788750991225243, -0.0574151948094368, -0.045317210257053375, 0.002363015664741397, -0.005721242167055607, 0.04239020124077797, -0.010224795900285244, -0.002405356615781784, 0.046315427869558334, -0.02486070990562439, -0.03470970690250397, -0.042513877153396606, 0.00928279384970665, -0.001205007778480649, -0.031793009489774704, 0.011545426212251186, 0.01934240199625492, -0.004738898482173681, 0.011569567956030369, -0.021139565855264664, -0.0576968714594841, -0.007312558591365814, 0.03007970191538334, -0.04577196389436722, 0.017394132912158966, 0.0391567163169384, 0.06045069545507431, -0.0377783477306366, 0.05397620052099228, -0.029645318165421486, -0.027697762474417686, 0.018256988376379013, -0.037084441632032394, 0.014385401271283627, -0.011549786664545536, -0.03337185084819794, -0.004530637059360743, 0.002338845981284976, -0.0049108220264315605, 0.028936762362718582, -0.041275590658187866, 0.05765455961227417, 0.05915387347340584, 0.014969879761338234, -0.0006000624853186309, -0.020277462899684906, -0.01173487864434719, 0.028412917628884315, -0.0387704074382782, 0.010248086415231228, -0.029178781434893608, 0.0027644240763038397, 0.06055450439453125, 0.034462686628103256, -0.051389820873737335, 0.02317429892718792, 0.03820788115262985, -0.003018805757164955, 0.011990902945399284, 0.06347044557332993, 0.01329098828136921, -0.026913456618785858, -0.0038588200695812702, 0.05150505527853966, -0.007664504460990429, -0.023103537037968636, 0.04605504870414734, 0.006155986338853836, 0.03745432570576668, 0.02582910656929016, -0.019685152918100357, 0.025581466034054756, -0.04186379909515381, 0.001969264354556799, 0.014691604301333427, -0.03232361376285553, 0.010951888747513294, 0.007126015145331621, -0.0390746034681797, 0.02281801402568817, 0.0004588414740283042, 0.0012817821698263288, 0.0641152635216713, -0.02240440435707569, 0.052450161427259445, 0.04169204458594322, 0.011879721656441689, -0.023058732971549034, 0.054329171776771545, -0.04453644901514053, 0.011141893453896046, 0.0007554525509476662, -0.015666432678699493, -0.025930024683475494, 0.05267682671546936, 0.013324483297765255, -0.008399908430874348, 0.006309118587523699, -0.00774386478587985, -0.03894690051674843, 0.024044664576649666, -0.00597458565607667, 0.0580773800611496, -0.012617485597729683, -0.04271625727415085, 0.012930504977703094, -0.013554173521697521, -0.05362347885966301, 0.036456670612096786, 0.03359738737344742, -0.028130153194069862, 0.025157112628221512, -0.019613195210695267, -0.0467197559773922, -0.04493081569671631, -0.03331688418984413, -0.002797473920509219, -0.007101861294358969, 0.005067239981144667, -0.01181414257735014, -0.023020416498184204, -0.04973475635051727, 0.053500376641750336, -0.030842619016766548, -0.012441634200513363, -0.0370837040245533, -0.016592664644122124, -0.0011919740354642272, -0.005054089706391096, -0.008170725777745247, 0.039294496178627014, -0.037325985729694366, -0.023729659616947174, -0.06961231678724289, -0.043637365102767944, 0.0371568538248539, -0.0044106715358793736, 0.008883736096322536, 0.0015285625122487545, -0.017278708517551422, 0.06297201663255692, 0.0011155016254633665, -0.008693716488778591, -0.05982227995991707, -0.006455376744270325, -0.054320260882377625, 0.007699096575379372, 0.022288596257567406, -0.0009461404988542199, 0.024184007197618484, 0.013529985211789608, -0.0299809742718935, -0.0017495955107733607, 0.08113180845975876, -0.015131943859159946, 0.007634387817233801, 0.03596603497862816, 0.000034931174013763666, -0.016626589000225067, 0.05094682797789574, 0.017914654687047005, -0.023641204461455345, 0.02967478148639202, 0.022855427116155624, 0.03384726494550705, 0.02223867177963257, -0.023518631234765053, -0.01051871944218874, -0.03249591961503029, 0.007597236894071102, -0.01489933393895626, -0.006084042135626078, 0.020499764010310173, -0.0206275824457407, -0.013313318602740765, 0.05556285008788109, 0.04278833419084549, -0.024179551750421524, 0.004665785934776068, 0.04186001047492027, 0.0433143712580204, -0.023531457409262657, 0.0017651030793786049, 0.016940416768193245, 0.002917846431955695, 0.020488636568188667, -0.036286406219005585, -0.01233950536698103, 0.0630313903093338, 0.008535238914191723, 0.013332084752619267, 0.03852478787302971, -0.025680340826511383, 0.026786064729094505, -0.03017139993607998, -0.029967110604047775, -0.017616286873817444, 0.044752638787031174, 0.030852315947413445, 0.004662567283958197, 0.014850012958049774, 0.020002951845526695, 0.030912378802895546, -0.01809418387711048, -0.018848475068807602, 0.02930482104420662, -0.017131486907601357, -0.023315757513046265, 0.021403174847364426, 0.009301984682679176, 0.006587750744074583, -0.04915696009993553, 0.03267558291554451, 0.0067007956095039845, 0.004693515133112669, -0.05810302868485451, -0.008780152536928654, -0.009118673391640186, -0.024380594491958618, -0.027994194999337196, 0.017153600230813026, -0.007151953410357237, -0.01713568903505802, 0.037577833980321884, 0.016997897997498512, -0.019402598962187767, -0.016923828050494194, 0.012551097199320793, -0.017658714205026627, -0.0005176829290576279, 0.019327692687511444, 0.0712328776717186, 0.059646084904670715, -0.04717359319329262, 0.009662915952503681, -0.012775459326803684, 0.0870150625705719, 0.046946972608566284, 0.012002320028841496, -0.010170834138989449, -0.053380273282527924, -0.027661023661494255, -0.018247872591018677, 0.04248085245490074, -0.024322813376784325, -0.026044607162475586, 0.0008973982185125351, 0.018639136105775833, -0.0604148767888546, 0.00540875643491745, 0.05842038616538048, 0.011866745539009571, 0.01792769506573677, -0.018873972818255424, -0.022813482210040092, -0.02199202962219715, -0.018522905185818672, 0.049244605004787445, 0.03507455810904503, -0.011844751425087452, -0.019698819145560265, 0.06987310945987701, -0.019188454374670982, -0.03687342256307602, -0.02552676573395729, 0.052791643887758255, 0.029862068593502045, 0.027541831135749817, -0.033480044454336166, -0.0067657968029379845, 0.02943265810608864, 0.055303629487752914, 0.007229781709611416, 0.010314959101378918, -0.08107172697782516, 0.012560786679387093, 0.05585707724094391, 0.021607181057333946, -0.027688169851899147, -0.05612720549106598, -0.0155092254281044, -0.0038934731855988503, 0.02544424682855606, -0.03100070171058178, 0.011596407741308212, -0.014146561734378338, 0.03524349629878998, -0.08887902647256851, 0.030250297859311104, -0.03466080129146576, 0.00682956725358963, -0.0298396497964859, 0.027561597526073456, -0.024570126086473465, -0.036310918629169464, -0.013774611055850983, -0.0025153113529086113, 0.04524758830666542, 0.05137135460972786, -0.008811778388917446, -0.045243989676237106, 0.01635161228477955, -0.008992984890937805, -0.031593285501003265, -0.05963987857103348, 0.0023552817292511463, 0.013776934705674648, -0.01742030493915081, 0.0829877108335495, 0.0021015587262809277, 0.0005226484499871731, 0.029621098190546036, -0.00459271389991045, -0.027487846091389656, -0.002785503165796399, -0.02431377023458481, 0.0007281843572854996, 0.025384627282619476, 0.019015854224562645, 0.029684601351618767, 0.03043692745268345, 0.05152895301580429, -0.01185571774840355, -0.021633382886648178, 0.02194729819893837, -0.02878452092409134, -0.026970796287059784, -0.026341130957007408, -0.023734256625175476, -0.04727322980761528, -0.011110045947134495, 0.00010405342618469149, 0.015067653730511665, -0.04536626115441322, 0.008754809387028217, 0.008897463791072369, 0.04063611850142479, 0.012631893157958984, -0.01224913913756609, -0.011524864472448826, 0.02515430562198162, -0.020503895357251167, 0.005760864354670048, 0.007290135603398085, -0.00641958462074399, -0.01777719520032406, 0.035768765956163406, -0.010001057758927345, 0.029514918103814125, -0.025506198406219482, -0.015570835210382938, -0.025331441313028336, -0.022781968116760254, 0.03786244988441467, -0.008097592741250992, 0.029472116380929947, 0.012916830368340015, -0.022808672860264778, -0.0189796332269907, 0.03469172492623329, 0.025823114439845085, 0.06618227064609528, -0.08645128458738327, 0.05533289164304733, 0.012901773676276207, -0.015088864602148533, -0.0762946829199791, -0.01577238366007805, 0.012012439779937267, 0.005058482754975557, -0.03128908947110176, -0.028457915410399437, 0.01900140754878521, -0.02303493767976761, 0.013056175783276558, -0.018142538145184517, 0.039899736642837524, 0.0042200046591460705, -0.031257711350917816, -0.01850082539021969, -0.02774546854197979, 0.043762724846601486, 0.014596102759242058, 0.05514393001794815, -0.020845884457230568, -0.0010582352988421917, -0.027641644701361656, 0.012100196443498135, -0.022113684564828873, -0.028487080708146095, 0.009441514499485493, -0.04331110417842865, 0.018716435879468918, 0.00886613316833973, -0.008050952106714249, 0.016946252435445786, 0.015671905130147934, -0.01777460053563118, -0.00908121932297945, -0.053795140236616135, -0.00834924727678299, -0.027658546343445778, -0.010792529210448265, -0.04610398784279823, -0.020944109186530113, 0.0007009737309999764, 0.0039565060287714005, 0.014525555074214935, 0.002800028072670102, -0.03741457313299179, 0.010267885401844978, 0.10044234991073608, 0.0013639648677781224, 0.03349611163139343, 0.0013431957922875881, -0.0020797427278012037, 0.009059570729732513, -0.011490624397993088, -0.013686331920325756, -0.0003615641326177865, 0.03974858671426773, -0.01697377860546112, 0.017945202067494392, -0.038648687303066254, 0.011791388504207134, 0.05605893209576607, 0.009654855355620384, 0.061823371797800064, 0.03334939107298851, 0.06204758584499359, -0.008506381884217262, -0.007805628702044487, -0.032948292791843414, 0.00010453527647769079, -0.015763917937874794, 0.04120811074972153, 0.002304786117747426, 0.021370097994804382, 0.03666219860315323, 0.03585260361433029, 0.015597454272210598, 0.06926237791776657, -0.004778359550982714, 0.008781841956079006, 0.03727168217301369, -0.005190082360059023, -0.02947922982275486, 0.017249086871743202, -0.04689783602952957, 0.025186507031321526, -0.028992310166358948, -0.003168385475873947, -0.0006031077355146408, 0.02721889689564705, -0.011798177845776081, -0.03427594527602196, -0.012058493681252003, -0.06385022401809692, 0.018637485802173615, 0.005245001520961523, -0.0029127891175448895, 0.02232508547604084, 0.023194462060928345, 0.02829698473215103, 0.014318263158202171, 0.019912218675017357, -0.04041919857263565, -0.04685043543577194, -0.03516624867916107, -0.06648311018943787, -0.04255017265677452, 0.02461540885269642, -0.003693068167194724, -0.047709833830595016, 0.021337760612368584, -0.022798998281359673, 0.029605908319354057, -0.010680727660655975, 0.027251217514276505, 0.0142462607473135, 0.04285740852355957, -0.02644430100917816, 0.04591101035475731, 0.04450865089893341, -0.013776642270386219, 0.1203024834394455, 0.06000771000981331, 0.032556500285863876, -0.0821690708398819, 0.016877641901373863, 0.012795578688383102, 0.005676939617842436, -0.028103256598114967, 0.03222580626606941, 0.038701869547367096, -0.009448805823922157, 0.022681118920445442, 0.013175170868635178, 0.023086898028850555, -0.005789744667708874, 0.04977891221642494, -0.005824398249387741, 0.01715320721268654, 0.006934992037713528, 0.03518844023346901, -0.002784755313768983, -0.04807252809405327, -0.03292536363005638, 0.007847069762647152, -0.026561100035905838, -0.006143020931631327, -0.011475986801087856, -0.029270056635141373, 0.04418681934475899, -0.01010923832654953, -0.029141966253519058, 0.010050138458609581, 0.005295290146023035, 0.04022825136780739, -0.03707607090473175, 0.0017790846759453416, -0.0035352283157408237, -0.010950764641165733, 0.004488177131861448, 0.051491670310497284, 0.014816530048847198, -0.02785894088447094, -0.0085822818800807, -0.002810525009408593, -0.05016421899199486, -0.02668561041355133, -0.057701412588357925, 0.05314623564481735, 0.0031114122830331326, -0.008299257606267929, 0.006448514759540558, 0.029319865629076958, 0.013551893644034863, -0.04465275630354881, -0.03123083896934986, -0.013617628253996372, -0.017848433926701546, -0.014717351645231247, 0.01258431002497673, -0.0320080891251564, 0.04416409879922867, -0.0016998420469462872, 0.01863938570022583, 0.03311988338828087, -0.029501965269446373, 0.036386385560035706, -0.01831316575407982, 0.050143659114837646, -0.020759809762239456, -0.03475436940789223, 0.0175730399787426, -0.017710456624627113, 0.0133975176140666, -0.020024903118610382, -0.00798990298062563, 0.027737384662032127, -0.012003391049802303, 0.027100464329123497, -0.023644838482141495, 0.03297814354300499, -0.04602695256471634, -0.0013230664189904928, -0.05472097545862198, 0.0015480417059734464, -0.050353989005088806, -0.002345093758776784, 0.05390771105885506, 0.018726810812950134, 0.01692778430879116, 0.0391991101205349, 0.004636007826775312, -0.002405725885182619, 0.03329355642199516, -0.0483863428235054, 0.013437649235129356, 0.011217407882213593, -0.03138066083192825, -0.0007572263129986823, -0.00827802438288927, 0.04736413434147835, 0.04338691383600235, 0.03035818040370941, 0.013649113476276398, -0.03440198674798012, -0.016290957108139992, -0.0022228052839636803, -0.027128873392939568, -0.036987099796533585, -0.026686467230319977, -0.019719691947102547, -0.003824349492788315, -0.043485842645168304, 0.004023819696158171, -0.0756339430809021, -0.04869667813181877, 0.021390996873378754, 0.009465089999139309, -0.04680947586894035, 0.005375941749662161, 0.006094249896705151, 0.045976992696523666, -0.03931264951825142, 0.01287921704351902, -0.00840617623180151, -0.012181997299194336, -0.02341432496905327, 0.008907023817300797, -0.04523691162467003, 0.0021210394334048033, -0.021544702351093292, 0.0009720544330775738, 0.05447861924767494, 0.02549368143081665, 0.006356955971568823, 0.013414282351732254, 0.009037882089614868, -0.02013782598078251, 0.026054495945572853, -0.01803886890411377, 0.00470507750287652, 0.04691891372203827, -0.06814073771238327, -0.005669347941875458, 0.02073376253247261, -0.012420273385941982, 0.01893618144094944, 0.0027032075449824333, 0.00033060292480513453, -0.01329759880900383, 0.03164585679769516, 0.007540922611951828, -0.015921425074338913, 0.015182461589574814, -0.01316033024340868, -0.02448790706694126, 0.034286148846149445, 0.025840220972895622, 0.011018636636435986, -0.004141227342188358, 0.02425520308315754, 0.04252147302031517, 0.03331821784377098, -0.00793626718223095, 0.017334135249257088, -0.006387774832546711, 0.02576344832777977, 0.016620034351944923, -0.04023949056863785, 0.05563472583889961, 0.061274219304323196, 0.004555608611553907, 0.004814264364540577, -0.025807922706007957, 0.013993842527270317, -0.0828637182712555, -0.0011431415332481265, 0.018351202830672264, 0.009703705087304115, 0.03963787853717804, -0.058187246322631836, 0.013450151309370995, 0.04135468974709511, -0.07080049812793732, 0.018764548003673553, -0.012770204804837704, -0.03127063065767288, -0.03198343887925148, -0.005294967908412218, -0.02143719606101513, 0.02660215273499489, -0.0015390956541523337, 0.029122058302164078, 0.045877523720264435, 0.03764043003320694, -0.06474684178829193, -0.01817132905125618, -0.02544012852013111, -0.007572672795504332, 0.001750353490933776, -0.08484629541635513, 0.01211225800216198, -0.027682609856128693, -0.050239447504282, 0.030732402577996254, 0.0034444162156432867, 0.020969344303011894, 0.043512217700481415, 0.028041690587997437, 0.01925787143409252, 0.03323812782764435, 0.035589855164289474, -0.04172303155064583, -0.009631603956222534, 0.014165938831865788, 0.00043226356501691043, 0.008233409374952316, 0.004177404567599297, 0.022830111905932426, 0.02754746749997139, -0.016782121732831, -0.036790631711483, 0.0021514135878533125, -0.0038962482940405607, -0.036904122680425644, -0.03577818349003792, -0.008369219489395618, 0.0080213388428092, -0.020276740193367004, 0.004742709454149008, -0.03248680755496025, -0.030514882877469063, 0.022769587114453316, -0.012908988632261753, -0.012509903870522976, -0.013147464953362942, -0.04337936267256737, -0.051364533603191376, 0.005977015011012554, 0.002512733917683363, 0.0006588867399841547, -0.03021029196679592, 0.0221396554261446, -0.00970128271728754, 0.010701920837163925, -0.024942779913544655, -0.028320835903286934, -0.027211207896471024, 0.04141068458557129, -0.015933755785226822, 0.013419401831924915, 0.02321794629096985, 0.013310888782143593, 0.036876045167446136, -0.056041277945041656, 0.05895005539059639, -0.018099570646882057, -0.014338628388941288, -0.02438904345035553, 0.022859960794448853, -0.056958556175231934, 0.0061936574056744576, 0.03578018397092819, 0.023130670189857483, -0.009110172279179096, -0.01205161027610302, -0.0028629067819565535, 0.018746014684438705, -0.10147909820079803, 0.04100964218378067, -0.021696489304304123, -0.046061012893915176, -0.001783641055226326, 0.00013602609396912158, 0.021332204341888428, 0.026724623516201973, 0.03429809585213661, -0.001283513382077217, -0.004935889970511198, 0.0036511614453047514, -0.03154793381690979, 0.011147675104439259, -0.021039143204689026, -0.00230330228805542, 0.07230070233345032, -0.008730996400117874, 0.03148406744003296, -0.009777451865375042, 0.002513366751372814, -0.0365481935441494, 0.024452151730656624, -0.01798682101070881, 0.013877298682928085, -0.021718623116612434, -0.0015997776063159108, -0.007448432967066765, -0.100752092897892, -0.01428636722266674, -0.021412920206785202, -0.027081402018666267, 0.0014090233016759157, 0.02854083478450775, 0.045137614011764526, 0.047320861369371414, -0.042141154408454895, 0.08602384477853775, -0.02673640102148056, -0.01305851899087429, 0.013186659663915634, 0.01342710666358471, 0.013662508688867092, 0.0029704817570745945, 0.016615120694041252, 0.022511836141347885, -0.06165517866611481, 0.020016802474856377, -0.02631979063153267, 0.05088498443365097, 0.0018760185921564698, -0.017785223200917244, 0.01330719143152237, -0.003243593266233802, 0.02749897539615631, 0.04690767824649811, -0.0087288748472929, 0.05386584624648094, -0.05836234241724014, -0.006420798134058714, -0.04320656135678291, -0.026266438886523247, -0.0300828255712986, -0.000005840133781020995, 0.027669621631503105, 0.02538483217358589, -0.003961979877203703, 0.03464573621749878, 0.002409011358395219, -0.009143596515059471, 0.04328690469264984, -0.00849009957164526, 0.005710583180189133, -0.0069296215660870075, -0.0009954097913578153, -0.012459730729460716, 0.007835134863853455, -0.03547656908631325, -0.034118764102458954, 0.009790921583771706, 0.02892969362437725, 0.03177617862820625, -0.05643519386649132, -0.04440934956073761, -0.01187572255730629, -0.015709642320871353, -0.08817265927791595, -0.016405418515205383, -0.05805628001689911, 0.009950664825737476, 0.04747515544295311, 0.005054191220551729 ]
<p>I am using Wilcoxon test to compare two paired sets of data for whether their means differ. Besides the p-value, I would also like to know the power of this test. How to compute it in R? Thank you in advance.</p>
36,078
[ -0.030872076749801636, -0.005215105600655079, -0.013206668198108673, -0.011296414770185947, -0.011625248938798904, 0.011973063461482525, -0.007765892427414656, -0.03345223888754845, 0.016979167237877846, -0.0026237675920128822, 0.05374176427721977, 0.04027444124221802, 0.035945575684309006, -0.013061175122857094, -0.0012248496059328318, 0.007966862991452217, -0.020974183455109596, -0.0013041882775723934, 0.01893443986773491, -0.0003916032728739083, 0.024811651557683945, 0.0387427844107151, 0.02718801237642765, -0.004172138404101133, -0.023521047085523605, 0.07082066684961319, 0.032477132976055145, 0.0014218228170648217, -0.001624553231522441, 0.06783492863178253, -0.05074675753712654, -0.042125407606363297, 0.03011554665863514, 0.03866160288453102, 0.011992702260613441, -0.000026941650503431447, -0.029450049623847008, -0.04739374667406082, 0.0019412597175687551, 0.046897679567337036, -0.01653781719505787, -0.04549497738480568, 0.016945624724030495, 0.03563695773482323, -0.007431037724018097, 0.022718148306012154, -0.008068186230957508, -0.04518355429172516, 0.007071314379572868, -0.0360526517033577, 0.07301362603902817, 0.033924318850040436, 0.05095783248543739, 0.012742996215820312, -0.004807984922081232, 0.0110298041254282, 0.047603458166122437, 0.046169381588697433, -0.041879355907440186, -0.06626974791288376, -0.03891574218869209, -0.04381140321493149, -0.005579706747084856, -0.0003953798150178045, -0.05444229021668434, 0.007702603470534086, -0.015053939074277878, -0.04119472578167915, 0.00962370540946722, -0.004587078932672739, 0.0022357492707669735, 0.02278890088200569, 0.04342666640877724, -0.016415460035204887, -0.00027620859327726066, 0.006155374459922314, 0.008159773424267769, 0.010584245435893536, 0.02150520123541355, 0.06451515108346939, -0.012921315617859364, 0.01828262023627758, 0.012544514611363411, 0.055458858609199524, 0.00759687926620245, -0.00040783314034342766, 0.05165771767497063, -0.006829747464507818, -0.006042920518666506, 0.034469034522771835, -0.021318528801202774, -0.02755611389875412, 0.05180343985557556, 0.007374949287623167, -0.020997287705540657, 0.01945844665169716, -0.04062441363930702, 0.02337997406721115, -0.0021970488596707582, -0.022402126342058182, 0.0025063157081604004, -0.04238240420818329, 0.03783145546913147, 0.01703592576086521, -0.0154806487262249, -0.017690377309918404, -0.0262221097946167, 0.0029647471383213997, -0.007290333043783903, 0.018953552469611168, 0.022417249158024788, 0.03866655379533768, -0.003953078296035528, -0.005757073871791363, 0.03703545778989792, -0.035075843334198, -0.022554118186235428, -0.01918301172554493, 0.07185554504394531, 0.06161010265350342, 0.059648752212524414, 0.004534727428108454, 0.03257378935813904, -0.045217666774988174, -0.02113400399684906, 0.00571500463411212, -0.013661650009453297, -0.016553716734051704, -0.03148652985692024, 0.054677654057741165, -0.013100533746182919, -0.028314078226685524, 0.025300271809101105, -0.004893834237009287, 0.045794032514095306, 0.022416485473513603, -0.09674503654241562, -0.023835593834519386, 0.024764349684119225, -0.01190078817307949, 0.0016983802197501063, -0.06345707178115845, 0.0243162102997303, 0.004882132168859243, 0.02949264831840992, 0.004306098446249962, 0.0334426686167717, -0.003938117530196905, 0.021185634657740593, 0.01803741790354252, -0.04111248999834061, -0.016795888543128967, -0.03332027047872543, -0.03866102918982506, 0.0003914171829819679, -0.05429405719041824, 0.011627946980297565, 0.018349608406424522, -0.031741585582494736, -0.02134787291288376, 0.03466145694255829, -0.007444568909704685, 0.0033740492071956396, -0.024808485060930252, 0.0038122013211250305, -0.0021326809655874968, 0.07821749150753021, -0.013503901660442352, 0.004800107795745134, 0.0047770533710718155, -0.02968761697411537, 0.01708916574716568, 0.04660509154200554, 0.042320020496845245, 0.023942256346344948, -0.02298755571246147, 0.010104074142873287, -0.07146447896957397, 0.020451663061976433, 0.010907857678830624, -0.0361626036465168, 0.030065013095736504, -0.02132025547325611, -0.022987600415945053, 0.00036042698775418103, 0.03193477541208267, -0.018687158823013306, -0.014356415718793869, 0.04022274911403656, -0.03563112020492554, -0.056741081178188324, -0.0720994770526886, 0.014800840057432652, 0.006466647144407034, -0.040394701063632965, 0.011158258654177189, 0.03734971210360527, 0.0372871495783329, -0.03642136976122856, 0.010316708125174046, -0.02786979451775551, 0.015223639085888863, 0.016151778399944305, -0.04885300621390343, -0.010213319212198257, 0.03422686830163002, 0.07939533144235611, -0.03313463553786278, 0.04172751307487488, -0.04964083805680275, -0.04502490535378456, 0.03148786723613739, -0.045590996742248535, -0.004694369155913591, 0.0006399198318831623, -0.007867466658353806, 0.012960339896380901, 0.016725914552807808, 0.014568899758160114, 0.05169728398323059, -0.02561071701347828, 0.07085635513067245, 0.0465039387345314, 0.04804347828030586, 0.020519915968179703, -0.04348568618297577, 0.011814571917057037, -0.025653595104813576, -0.04500914737582207, -0.01901739276945591, -0.040963683277368546, -0.0012749091256409883, 0.014512848109006882, 0.015825839713215828, -0.022454136982560158, 0.01835869997739792, 0.04488186910748482, -0.02510090172290802, 0.02920902706682682, 0.039970651268959045, 0.04243036359548569, -0.005411246791481972, -0.008322893641889095, 0.013991892337799072, -0.008651329204440117, 0.019052932038903236, 0.03968661278486252, 0.027951354160904884, 0.06746502220630646, 0.026771077886223793, -0.02850591577589512, 0.049734342843294144, 0.012462739832699299, -0.007219805847853422, -0.014638949185609818, -0.024814769625663757, 0.0320211760699749, -0.030553266406059265, -0.0028643161058425903, 0.059650011360645294, 0.02159905433654785, 0.011443519033491611, -0.01992383599281311, -0.020717056468129158, 0.03714539483189583, 0.014838667586445808, -0.04417349770665169, 0.013371679000556469, 0.006088545545935631, -0.04620593413710594, 0.011990140192210674, -0.020068898797035217, 0.00005915609290241264, -0.02773619256913662, -0.004630977753549814, 0.021586202085018158, 0.005039823241531849, 0.03604967147111893, -0.02977280505001545, -0.04034615680575371, -0.018488328903913498, -0.052622366696596146, -0.004523788578808308, -0.034794289618730545, -0.04561717435717583, -0.008508232422173023, -0.0018217623000964522, -0.02651192806661129, 0.017207417637109756, -0.020807864144444466, -0.0298769474029541, 0.061291955411434174, -0.0010199097450822592, -0.038751646876335144, 0.015549815259873867, -0.0565401054918766, 0.015923259779810905, -0.046891260892152786, -0.02631375566124916, 0.03405067324638367, -0.03413672372698784, -0.044341906905174255, 0.026906797662377357, -0.015482490882277489, -0.006726972293108702, -0.010734646581113338, 0.019886093214154243, 0.01429799199104309, 0.003180110827088356, 0.0011240617604926229, 0.01101765874773264, -0.044840361922979355, -0.025617968291044235, -0.07298644632101059, -0.05200617015361786, 0.04648556932806969, 0.001832220470532775, 0.02212408185005188, -0.03209874778985977, -0.08280005306005478, 0.04754411056637764, 0.0395614430308342, -0.015786247327923775, -0.0481584407389164, -0.0003923012118320912, -0.041309405118227005, 0.02513314224779606, 0.028279930353164673, 0.024894988164305687, 0.017727190628647804, 0.04617660492658615, 0.009646998718380928, 0.010707445442676544, 0.04937218874692917, -0.0018289979780092835, -0.03730437904596329, 0.025906236842274666, 0.006882491055876017, -0.007513588760048151, 0.0443839393556118, -0.00876616034656763, -0.021175889298319817, 0.027565782889723778, 0.015117533504962921, 0.0009971220279112458, -0.031307872384786606, -0.01709214225411415, -0.023383991792798042, 0.013251562602818012, 0.029869865626096725, -0.0238331351429224, 0.0674576386809349, -0.014332137070596218, 0.0005959619884379208, 0.0039606583304703236, 0.04925406724214554, 0.029424890875816345, -0.01861570030450821, 0.008617589250206947, 0.027290044352412224, 0.03534221649169922, -0.02127115987241268, -0.017104733735322952, -0.004467830061912537, -0.02310444600880146, -0.0012510359520092607, -0.03637503460049629, -0.04501236602663994, 0.04714713245630264, 0.02517446130514145, 0.009900620207190514, -0.0013553152093663812, -0.016211239621043205, 0.01962396502494812, -0.025689205154776573, 0.01781316287815571, -0.021864766255021095, 0.047908980399370193, -0.003934263251721859, 0.06448433548212051, 0.043149661272764206, -0.00346011808142066, -0.01937309093773365, -0.041482530534267426, -0.030267924070358276, 0.0255111251026392, -0.005888551939278841, -0.015866819769144058, -0.007052361499518156, -0.027791207656264305, 0.005407859571278095, 0.02149033732712269, 0.019948597997426987, 0.01829565316438675, 0.030779413878917694, -0.04833478480577469, 0.00784641969949007, -0.02148611843585968, 0.010353513062000275, 0.004869324155151844, 0.042088985443115234, 0.031627681106328964, -0.013691998086869717, 0.005685021635144949, 0.056167058646678925, -0.009570544585585594, 0.0005498735699802637, -0.00853592436760664, 0.007457709405571222, 0.023934809491038322, 0.05379859730601311, 0.054575365036726, 0.020792685449123383, -0.049629002809524536, 0.026553524658083916, -0.024261847138404846, 0.03973166644573212, 0.058223623782396317, -0.0182631928473711, -0.016992485150694847, -0.023005420342087746, -0.028842711821198463, -0.04107891768217087, 0.011723564006388187, -0.009215827099978924, -0.01179499365389347, 0.03962116315960884, 0.03518027812242508, -0.046135786920785904, 0.01297532208263874, 0.09562800079584122, 0.031853001564741135, -0.013333962298929691, -0.0318961963057518, -0.006365924142301083, -0.007568698842078447, -0.03459807112812996, 0.01796211116015911, 0.0059654382057487965, 0.008065775036811829, -0.005896122194826603, 0.013272331096231937, -0.03100740723311901, -0.030625266954302788, -0.012017817236483097, 0.00035063325776718557, 0.030796309933066368, -0.02647465467453003, -0.016025163233280182, -0.010198273696005344, 0.04061000794172287, 0.008687310852110386, 0.000799106783233583, 0.013173118233680725, -0.07255604863166809, 0.01916729286313057, 0.06315601617097855, 0.05186057463288307, -0.018832892179489136, -0.032885242253541946, -0.008692923001945019, 0.027405094355344772, 0.05869680270552635, -0.050083138048648834, 0.04059264063835144, -0.0048868898302316666, 0.010479883290827274, -0.05186634138226509, 0.00912435818463564, -0.04013001173734665, 0.012445037253201008, -0.041596248745918274, 0.023264506831765175, -0.01023817341774702, -0.04119657725095749, -0.020542601123452187, 0.01067497581243515, 0.003328245598822832, 0.03406594321131706, -0.03073621727526188, -0.010540954768657684, 0.023203827440738678, 0.024551019072532654, -0.013283791020512581, -0.040772806853055954, 0.02499968931078911, -0.01296177413314581, -0.000719173694960773, 0.05517216771841049, -0.008199515752494335, -0.023955682292580605, 0.009582127444446087, 0.007752399891614914, -0.012492802925407887, -0.02265782468020916, -0.0071281869895756245, 0.015261651948094368, 0.022282613441348076, -0.0044985562562942505, 0.06681251525878906, -0.002913333475589752, 0.0011670112144201994, -0.008767087012529373, -0.04151961952447891, 0.04660557210445404, -0.006444082595407963, -0.04393318295478821, -0.05637180432677269, -0.016466589644551277, -0.0429292656481266, 0.02562403306365013, -0.025347746908664703, 0.015578916296362877, -0.032079339027404785, 0.028220782056450844, 0.012024051509797573, 0.021384036168456078, 0.027855614200234413, 0.02246861718595028, -0.013728470541536808, 0.010834510438144207, 0.008548884652554989, -0.007985854521393776, 0.02734372578561306, -0.037462808191776276, 0.0005572238005697727, -0.01299560721963644, -0.03248123452067375, 0.01998555287718773, 0.01507677510380745, -0.01319477241486311, 0.002558862790465355, -0.014359969645738602, 0.04238063842058182, -0.0269086305052042, -0.010610842145979404, 0.0033883382566273212, -0.07139352709054947, -0.0013593893963843584, 0.04963134601712227, -0.02596564032137394, 0.037106748670339584, -0.02768918126821518, 0.010288374498486519, -0.006554941181093454, 0.01397135853767395, -0.06851249188184738, -0.0642344132065773, -0.0014944463036954403, 0.010318437591195107, -0.010811470448970795, -0.034487392753362656, -0.003895697882398963, -0.008314186707139015, -0.0057512749917805195, -0.0463360995054245, 0.05750993639230728, -0.009073245339095592, 0.0018459210405126214, -0.03505663573741913, -0.008884139358997345, 0.07077693939208984, 0.010647762566804886, -0.013815261423587799, 0.0015730791492387652, -0.012006768956780434, -0.011873839423060417, 0.0076584885828197, -0.0005218774313107133, -0.03250857815146446, -0.031566452234983444, -0.04579736664891243, -0.016832930967211723, 0.04754260554909706, -0.05806243419647217, -0.019086064770817757, -0.02201896905899048, -0.006854172330349684, 0.028574254363775253, -0.0035026127006858587, -0.006567580625414848, -0.030790014192461967, 0.04132310673594475, -0.02656478062272072, -0.005958543159067631, -0.020519698038697243, -0.03534051775932312, -0.01119780633598566, 0.03880268707871437, -0.021962128579616547, 0.0010254709050059319, 0.09344923496246338, 0.0033536243718117476, 0.025153590366244316, -0.024439100176095963, -0.04566393047571182, 0.018497509881854057, 0.031736332923173904, -0.01500752754509449, 0.015497771091759205, 0.026898758485913277, -0.04274692013859749, -0.009497128427028656, -0.02969156950712204, -0.008922991342842579, 0.0519288145005703, 0.008634491823613644, 0.0527949221432209, 0.06761912256479263, 0.00406168308109045, -0.000972329406067729, 0.003001516917720437, -0.018408119678497314, 0.005386976059526205, 0.01304234005510807, 0.045717913657426834, 0.024191133677959442, -0.00851163174957037, 0.06437795609235764, 0.02711275964975357, 0.029685188084840775, 0.037699051201343536, 0.04006841033697128, 0.01771826297044754, 0.05155370011925697, -0.008478714153170586, -0.05268733203411102, -0.01179598644375801, -0.04734194651246071, 0.0006697718054056168, -0.04775521904230118, 0.00914305541664362, 0.027350040152668953, 0.032169539481401443, -0.0249300729483366, -0.04369540512561798, -0.038044434040784836, -0.04342902451753616, -0.011614440940320492, 0.028246548026800156, -0.0030128564685583115, 0.0281814094632864, 0.02811785228550434, 0.011038274504244328, -0.023050887510180473, 0.04720069840550423, -0.004713726695626974, -0.05900915712118149, -0.0276421457529068, 0.005507622845470905, -0.029091961681842804, 0.011086302809417248, 0.003850627923384309, -0.02067197673022747, 0.019423894584178925, -0.027273593470454216, -0.008879804983735085, -0.016180383041501045, 0.0250663161277771, -0.012914549559354782, 0.08725245296955109, -0.01633967086672783, 0.01559160090982914, 0.03261083737015724, -0.02358594909310341, 0.10104922950267792, 0.05735064297914505, 0.028062986209988594, -0.07961003482341766, 0.02100260555744171, 0.0004134179325774312, -0.009623934514820576, -0.049886830151081085, 0.007111002691090107, 0.017541902139782906, 0.015735995024442673, 0.05524412542581558, 0.06843569129705429, 0.034097619354724884, 0.0042182826437056065, 0.07579691708087921, -0.03376302123069763, -0.006315486505627632, 0.03536149859428406, 0.022587047889828682, -0.028261205181479454, -0.035765260457992554, -0.03151717036962509, 0.028835861012339592, -0.0007731387158855796, -0.027961289510130882, -0.004596279002726078, 0.020475339144468307, 0.017928477376699448, -0.001044629723764956, -0.006583969574421644, -0.0029083765111863613, 0.006410521455109119, 0.018402166664600372, -0.025864310562610626, 0.005911011248826981, 0.037127140909433365, -0.015651140362024307, 0.0002474854118190706, 0.041441723704338074, -0.005159963387995958, -0.0074066235683858395, 0.003184984903782606, 0.013470075093209743, -0.041421663016080856, -0.01867854595184326, -0.033962178975343704, 0.025623073801398277, 0.00694633461534977, 0.034849025309085846, 0.013075166381895542, 0.02492714487016201, -0.03177635744214058, -0.05428379029035568, -0.028864430263638496, 0.0007101529045030475, 0.031686753034591675, -0.029903767630457878, -0.04679016396403313, -0.05945345014333725, 0.03872228041291237, -0.039931632578372955, 0.06452954560518265, -0.0016305588651448488, -0.03917871043086052, -0.02821439318358898, -0.015470602549612522, 0.026600027456879616, 0.00638852221891284, -0.014280528761446476, -0.009966219775378704, -0.018893901258707047, 0.0014767226530238986, 0.009120392613112926, 0.014101764187216759, -0.001784694497473538, 0.01990061067044735, -0.023223338648676872, -0.01228659600019455, -0.016732972115278244, -0.05274977907538414, 0.015649501234292984, -0.03445538133382797, -0.016839150339365005, -0.0355856753885746, -0.033965278416872025, 0.07307149469852448, 0.014830260537564754, 0.03954722359776497, 0.02714812010526657, -0.01952274702489376, 0.05273183062672615, 0.03664277121424675, -0.07370451092720032, -0.018631884828209877, 0.011473341844975948, -0.031104443594813347, -0.03385050967335701, -0.01628781296312809, 0.031828876584768295, 0.03948149457573891, 0.008056295104324818, -0.009270457550883293, -0.020201703533530235, -0.03595656529068947, 0.010256513021886349, 0.006111758761107922, -0.05504348501563072, -0.010008291341364384, 0.024514691904187202, -0.03299090266227722, -0.010384139604866505, -0.01514181587845087, -0.055266886949539185, -0.044878702610731125, 0.03190643712878227, -0.04516516625881195, -0.009157643653452396, -0.016387939453125, 0.0035702926106750965, 0.019435212016105652, -0.02493908628821373, 0.0009384352015331388, -0.023585349321365356, -0.00889377947896719, 0.028910230845212936, 0.0076580471359193325, -0.016179153695702553, -0.001453653909265995, -0.013860023580491543, 0.008407136425375938, 0.04609055817127228, 0.007743517868220806, 0.023211531341075897, 0.017842991277575493, 0.0005337698967196047, 0.0216787401586771, 0.08063042908906937, -0.018450647592544556, -0.018650220707058907, 0.07446098327636719, -0.08646157383918762, -0.02972293458878994, 0.030855972319841385, -0.0031269355677068233, 0.044582054018974304, 0.016486939042806625, -0.015644505620002747, -0.03311622887849808, 0.04437774047255516, -0.02451133541762829, -0.019351696595549583, -0.009039219468832016, -0.001542573794722557, -0.025791626423597336, 0.04491991177201271, -0.021615419536828995, 0.005220035556703806, -0.0025691594928503036, 0.01156871858984232, 0.061331164091825485, 0.009221967309713364, 0.0161032322794199, -0.004521406255662441, -0.019151311367750168, -0.0058700935915112495, 0.017447981983423233, -0.03446643799543381, 0.03615005686879158, 0.054494280368089676, -0.01658383384346962, 0.023631274700164795, -0.047015491873025894, 0.029287287965416908, -0.08915649354457855, 0.00903269648551941, -0.0023530409671366215, -0.0024065226316452026, 0.05804286152124405, -0.06453345715999603, 0.0068428730592131615, 0.028772739693522453, -0.0309191532433033, 0.040014516562223434, -0.009842283092439175, -0.02583402954041958, -0.048839446157217026, 0.019139140844345093, 0.008252670988440514, 0.033430103212594986, 0.03746739402413368, 0.03799446299672127, 0.04485245794057846, 0.02408953756093979, 0.016091328114271164, -0.00365241221152246, 0.009785412810742855, 0.017564373090863228, 0.012580173090100288, -0.07821643352508545, 0.013666096143424511, -0.021768050268292427, -0.04308006167411804, 0.022151820361614227, -0.041071854531764984, 0.013480587862432003, -0.014857427217066288, 0.057666853070259094, 0.0015755955828353763, 0.055697403848171234, 0.017554186284542084, -0.033610016107559204, -0.01898883283138275, 0.0019415784627199173, 0.0004969313740730286, 0.0280329380184412, -0.0458475798368454, -0.011022382415831089, 0.04086332395672798, -0.022728439420461655, -0.02667262591421604, 0.025762900710105896, 0.009139529429376125, -0.028127217665314674, -0.020978938788175583, -0.021956339478492737, 0.002122550504282117, -0.014965773560106754, 0.0152035653591156, -0.04545559734106064, -0.0032907789573073387, 0.060324907302856445, 0.03248632699251175, -0.01329893060028553, 0.032087698578834534, -0.012947022914886475, -0.04063820838928223, 0.011018512770533562, 0.013325480744242668, 0.022763101384043694, -0.06166920065879822, -0.002536989049986005, -0.0020889961160719395, 0.021652132272720337, -0.019494350999593735, -0.00436168210580945, -0.024962441995739937, 0.027052519842982292, -0.009223994798958302, 0.01791338436305523, 0.02892915904521942, -0.012022326700389385, 0.024866051971912384, -0.080851249396801, 0.06666315346956253, 0.01511478889733553, 0.006850598379969597, -0.04420677572488785, -0.003808028297498822, -0.03581122308969498, -0.004860448185354471, 0.04974554851651192, 0.007958686910569668, -0.02078680880367756, -0.023688852787017822, 0.02062041126191616, -0.030818257480859756, -0.07698088139295578, 0.01635087840259075, -0.027417125180363655, -0.029290692880749702, -0.036200448870658875, -0.0004185414290986955, 0.03626769781112671, 0.01984800584614277, -0.024895919486880302, -0.020097432658076286, 0.0033975644037127495, 0.008071517571806908, 0.0010481232311576605, 0.04220641404390335, 0.003315331181511283, 0.008216902613639832, 0.055020809173583984, 0.005781133659183979, 0.022155869752168655, 0.01364910788834095, -0.0001251451176358387, -0.02631370909512043, 0.05872177332639694, -0.02083749510347843, -0.011519812047481537, 0.02673879824578762, 0.011542744003236294, 0.0012809542240574956, -0.028726834803819656, -0.018206585198640823, 0.02997411973774433, -0.03770972415804863, 0.028480220586061478, 0.026915457099676132, 0.024047035723924637, 0.04305722936987877, -0.03480326011776924, 0.02368440292775631, -0.010757781565189362, -0.001016101916320622, 0.005980344023555517, 0.009711426682770252, 0.006899232044816017, 0.009509135968983173, 0.013982027769088745, 0.02092921920120716, -0.04720830172300339, 0.029389383271336555, -0.006148417014628649, 0.05857490003108978, -0.0006498481961898506, -0.030467219650745392, -0.009734428487718105, -0.015548801980912685, 0.0383298322558403, -0.011068366467952728, 0.004760085605084896, 0.05777556821703911, -0.014704802073538303, 0.018673919141292572, -0.03745974972844124, -0.03648604452610016, -0.02147710509598255, -0.015936851501464844, 0.025980141013860703, -0.002640767255797982, -0.03160475939512253, 0.02054300718009472, 0.03774891048669815, -0.04067358374595642, 0.006734499707818031, -0.0017837812192738056, 0.018386276438832283, -0.009752083569765091, 0.016317453235387802, -0.030799126252532005, 0.008556275628507137, -0.03926277533173561, 0.0031663153786212206, 0.018552197143435478, 0.01531495526432991, 0.03439318388700485, 0.01366182416677475, -0.0014257519505918026, 0.046466000378131866, 0.0441875085234642, -0.0806843638420105, -0.015551851131021976, -0.027474727481603622, -0.0017763193463906646, 0.022171910852193832, -0.019839635118842125 ]
<p>I am trying to ascertain if a relationship exists between <strong>hours of play</strong> and <strong>number of friends</strong>. I have two contexts for the study: "at school" and "at a place other than the school".</p> <p>My data set relates to the "at school" context and the correlation r=0.8766 (significant). </p> <p>Now the difficult part....</p> <p>As I want to focus on the <strong>same group of students</strong> for the "at a place other than the school" context, I have asked a question that filters my respondents and puts them in the "at a place other than the school context".</p> <p>The question is: Did you make any friends in the last three weeks? The answer can be either "yes" or "no". If it is yes, then I have asked them to indicate whether they made the friends "at the school", "at a place other than the school" or "at both places". </p> <p>So I have four data sets as follows: </p> <ol> <li>Those who did not make any friends</li> <li>Those who made one or more friends at the school</li> <li>Those who made one or more friends at a place other than the school</li> <li>Those who made one or more friends at both places (i.e. school and a place other than the school)</li> </ol> <p>I have ignored data set 1 because there is obviously no relationship between hours of play and number of friends because no new friends are made.</p> <p>I have also ignored data set 2 because I already have this finding (in the correlation above, which was at the school)</p> <p>I have also ignored data set 4 because it does not distinguish between "at school" and "at a place other than the school".</p> <p>I have used data set 3 and worked out the correlation, which is 0.7687 (significant). My interpretation of this finding is the relationship between hours of play and number of friends exists at the school and also outside the school.</p> <p>Does this make sense? </p>
73,652
[ -0.024500872939825058, 0.023953722789883614, 0.03573179617524147, 0.013750368729233742, 0.03661889582872391, 0.04626835510134697, 0.02965933084487915, -0.02142403833568096, 0.03198302164673805, -0.02535037137567997, 0.031019872054457664, 0.04802069067955017, 0.03811929374933243, 0.04112711176276207, -0.01052357628941536, 0.019960343837738037, 0.012813515029847622, 0.031000947579741478, -0.019613204523921013, -0.0046830931678414345, -0.029735691845417023, 0.0014448367292061448, -0.023992976173758507, -0.0074942829087376595, -0.006615620106458664, 0.04474067687988281, 0.029619911685585976, -0.06086807698011398, -0.026049204170703888, 0.05276108160614967, -0.025676464661955833, -0.043773550540208817, 0.015043089166283607, -0.020647043362259865, 0.04123564064502716, 0.03022235818207264, -0.017005344852805138, -0.00008627822535345331, 0.017676346004009247, 0.04452864080667496, -0.03978713974356651, -0.008772126398980618, 0.0027587173972278833, 0.04618850722908974, -0.03620406985282898, 0.033327214419841766, 0.020011454820632935, -0.01113108079880476, 0.01110774651169777, -0.02291368693113327, 0.0438968762755394, -0.016534866765141487, 0.016216043382883072, 0.02741158753633499, -0.04725099727511406, -0.007630523294210434, 0.01829441450536251, 0.016608692705631256, 0.001261839410290122, -0.04754031449556351, -0.059743817895650864, -0.0009149821125902236, -0.03463880345225334, 0.007208894472569227, -0.03038118965923786, -0.020648779347538948, 0.033699795603752136, -0.01688758097589016, 0.04175669699907303, -0.0038266710471361876, 0.00273076887242496, 0.03498520702123642, 0.05613095685839653, -0.0033917457330971956, -0.003415868617594242, -0.05085747689008713, 0.0006123709608800709, 0.009176761843264103, 0.04661347717046738, 0.03809050843119621, 0.0017951418412849307, 0.00850089080631733, 0.04093354195356369, -0.01742551475763321, 0.03369975835084915, -0.031790390610694885, 0.06156092509627342, -0.03603258728981018, -0.0002524003793951124, 0.00977971963584423, -0.004336428828537464, -0.0015817750245332718, 0.04147324711084366, 0.024881385266780853, -0.019100584089756012, 0.04308253899216652, -0.04942530021071434, -0.00003270653178333305, -0.016235794872045517, 0.02667519636452198, -0.04627973958849907, -0.05586395040154457, 0.04684237763285637, 0.04550908878445625, -0.009400716982781887, -0.011820485815405846, -0.02844894491136074, -0.012103214859962463, -0.020926114171743393, -0.00726300897076726, 0.009072109125554562, 0.01458744890987873, 0.04137878119945526, 0.0114002525806427, 0.017539577558636665, -0.037403035908937454, -0.01894519291818142, -0.008332177996635437, 0.08230593800544739, 0.07204137742519379, 0.014867160469293594, -0.01812683418393135, -0.01695382222533226, -0.016774127259850502, -0.06335568428039551, 0.024679385125637054, 0.005265370476990938, 0.027529388666152954, -0.03179268166422844, 0.05035385116934776, 0.0008702850318513811, 0.039122436195611954, 0.010214547626674175, -0.03424131125211716, 0.037682708352804184, 0.0178896002471447, -0.08834347128868103, -0.03712349012494087, 0.05222791060805321, 0.033961351960897446, -0.02077680267393589, -0.028525302186608315, -0.0020753212738782167, 0.025212213397026062, 0.04384371638298035, -0.007437185384333134, 0.018665391951799393, 0.03664189204573631, 0.011350144632160664, 0.037284884601831436, -0.019713057205080986, -0.010153323411941528, -0.03818988427519798, -0.02460157684981823, -0.01223263330757618, -0.04970636963844299, 0.054795291274785995, 0.02722538821399212, 0.0074557592160999775, -0.005990050733089447, 0.050825051963329315, -0.003945650067180395, -0.03548802062869072, 0.015403100289404392, 0.03803271800279617, -0.0026585960295051336, 0.0420316718518734, -0.0027980890590697527, -0.0004828742239624262, -0.0048764594830572605, -0.011728748679161072, 0.01448151096701622, 0.010910186916589737, 0.019430475309491158, 0.012671834789216518, 0.00014698031009174883, -0.016748709604144096, -0.017825908958911896, 0.023875027894973755, -0.006492102984338999, -0.030622374266386032, 0.006924047600477934, -0.032044120132923126, -0.002356010489165783, 0.0213178601115942, 0.05589152127504349, 0.03218677267432213, -0.012679231353104115, 0.020165549591183662, -0.019004449248313904, -0.042726822197437286, -0.07398734986782074, -0.004228520672768354, -0.006624870002269745, -0.06595607846975327, 0.0015324725536629558, 0.009281862527132034, -0.004219807684421539, 0.005437218118458986, -0.013914918527007103, -0.009905558079481125, -0.013207864947617054, 0.050746090710163116, -0.04546351358294487, 0.013653021305799484, 0.05392196401953697, 0.04219656065106392, 0.011741221882402897, 0.039613574743270874, -0.03628912940621376, 0.017848778516054153, 0.037024252116680145, -0.01967170089483261, 0.013316137716174126, 0.005260925740003586, -0.005368080921471119, 0.02810071036219597, -0.0061657424084842205, -0.05167680233716965, 0.020743483677506447, -0.06591217964887619, 0.06377113610506058, 0.07212543487548828, -0.019081730395555496, 0.03281480073928833, 0.01839260756969452, 0.004235046915709972, 0.0015625745290890336, -0.021129567176103592, -0.009966029785573483, -0.06445039808750153, -0.04372601583600044, 0.013485746458172798, -0.01972896419465542, -0.02622765675187111, 0.025952711701393127, 0.074048712849617, -0.007438509725034237, -0.03264739736914635, 0.04515121132135391, -0.007549641188234091, -0.005526482593268156, 0.025021441280841827, 0.028456779196858406, 0.0302278995513916, -0.006944853812456131, -0.0191892609000206, 0.010954444296658039, 0.02317844144999981, 0.012325565330684185, 0.024994004517793655, 0.04973352700471878, 0.05395737662911415, 0.03962242603302002, 0.005490883719176054, 0.01851394958794117, 0.052912596613168716, -0.01382801216095686, 0.005048289429396391, 0.01832209713757038, 0.001643264782615006, -0.014441205188632011, 0.02447091042995453, -0.024588456377387047, 0.014035646803677082, -0.001079207519069314, -0.012623310089111328, 0.018064966425299644, 0.02118898369371891, -0.03033112734556198, 0.00048087580944411457, -0.013079957105219364, -0.02962297387421131, 0.0032448002602905035, -0.012545594945549965, 0.060906749218702316, 0.019757471978664398, 0.029691025614738464, -0.02906484715640545, -0.000879140745382756, -0.06029548868536949, -0.00986487977206707, -0.0014545520534738898, 0.03166693076491356, -0.04618873447179794, -0.010774660855531693, -0.0057608503848314285, -0.006445818580687046, -0.01851840503513813, -0.02426237240433693, -0.031709589064121246, 0.036948930472135544, 0.042504873126745224, -0.035471800714731216, -0.027867987751960754, -0.05115336924791336, -0.010689149610698223, -0.05583493411540985, -0.013767864555120468, 0.06916388124227524, 0.026547491550445557, -0.06119436398148537, -0.011882119812071323, -0.01612100377678871, -0.012993652373552322, -0.014820692129433155, -0.030562624335289, 0.001333452295511961, -0.007933150976896286, -0.013421723619103432, -0.016301440075039864, -0.011124332435429096, -0.0030712138395756483, -0.08179348707199097, -0.06284499913454056, 0.026494214311242104, 0.030553733929991722, 0.03803444281220436, -0.01716398447751999, -0.0006111734546720982, 0.0543932281434536, 0.03534799441695213, -0.016807423904538155, -0.06093120574951172, 0.004825111944228411, -0.0509086512029171, -0.02422218583524227, 0.02540857344865799, 0.01735197752714157, -0.00807451643049717, -0.02542065642774105, 0.01873164251446724, 0.0330277681350708, 0.021484050899744034, 0.01344587653875351, 0.01358241867274046, -0.019171228632330894, 0.0025625969283282757, -0.01809220016002655, 0.07299395650625229, 0.027340251952409744, -0.049658581614494324, -0.007389184553176165, -0.019675690680742264, 0.010748924687504768, 0.016327926889061928, -0.052861567586660385, -0.024501964449882507, 0.002834869083017111, 0.025363054126501083, -0.03817012533545494, 0.017892401665449142, 0.039368581026792526, -0.025984250009059906, -0.012501979246735573, 0.002969953464344144, 0.04405495151877403, -0.007861120626330376, -0.0087388651445508, 0.0463133342564106, 0.03330178186297417, -0.029354063794016838, 0.004035063087940216, -0.012433037161827087, 0.01050500851124525, 0.019054127857089043, -0.019025718793272972, -0.04565751925110817, 0.024465639144182205, 0.03988872841000557, -0.01792076602578163, -0.013639064505696297, -0.04375343769788742, -0.004959717392921448, -0.05842195823788643, 0.019921930506825447, -0.014335385523736477, 0.05689167231321335, -0.015214365907013416, 0.012399842962622643, 0.031529948115348816, -0.02003428339958191, -0.024244965985417366, 0.01879921555519104, -0.06133268401026726, 0.0278333593159914, 0.007591116242110729, -0.006173409521579742, 0.027133917436003685, -0.038171153515577316, 0.005332643166184425, -0.02591770887374878, 0.006535472813993692, -0.00975561048835516, -0.007453534286469221, -0.012083202600479126, -0.02105000428855419, -0.026543742045760155, -0.013050200417637825, -0.01876191794872284, 0.0026428373530507088, 0.04847639426589012, -0.02100358158349991, 0.04125766456127167, 0.035186417400836945, -0.01455818023532629, 0.03576882556080818, -0.02011285349726677, -0.012992633506655693, 0.06539582461118698, 0.06979502737522125, -0.029777325689792633, 0.0244616512209177, -0.015163257718086243, 0.011715763248503208, 0.013269864954054356, 0.0005801629740744829, 0.0641796886920929, -0.03143763542175293, -0.004647404421120882, -0.004458802752196789, 0.011049439199268818, -0.03141498565673828, 0.04630788043141365, -0.03093995340168476, -0.01478443294763565, 0.0521768257021904, 0.005118918605148792, -0.0683402270078659, 0.044978078454732895, 0.06606996804475784, 0.04430433735251427, -0.0000773277715779841, -0.02017912082374096, 0.006445051170885563, 0.01154575776308775, -0.024418342858552933, 0.031286537647247314, -0.002214760985225439, 0.024369973689317703, -0.027355585247278214, 0.02397620677947998, 0.011020523495972157, -0.05429753661155701, 0.0506945438683033, -0.029252009466290474, -0.004583549685776234, -0.005461895372718573, -0.06503795832395554, 0.02327338047325611, 0.0504148006439209, 0.024547992274165154, -0.011471317149698734, 0.037651848047971725, -0.09053487330675125, -0.0034827294293791056, 0.06775692850351334, 0.06004911661148071, 0.038962773978710175, 0.001132011297158897, -0.038871437311172485, -0.013285322114825249, -0.004778233356773853, -0.0163397379219532, 0.03879975154995918, -0.02560415118932724, 0.04057569056749344, -0.04542262852191925, -0.04684918001294136, -0.047456320375204086, -0.006661000195890665, -0.060432445257902145, 0.03642001003026962, 0.020375121384859085, -0.03977886959910393, -0.040960583835840225, -0.0037974680308252573, 0.005177846644073725, 0.02790210023522377, -0.00682733254507184, -0.03578302264213562, -0.0014435786288231611, -0.015163379721343517, -0.04059893265366554, -0.041021090000867844, 0.04384435713291168, 0.01356742437928915, 0.019693627953529358, 0.10610843449831009, -0.023004891350865364, -0.03847762197256088, -0.020971626043319702, -0.003735110629349947, 0.003989589400589466, 0.02765006199479103, -0.02390735037624836, 0.08409395068883896, 0.030338240787386894, 0.014840567484498024, 0.053801149129867554, 0.022802243009209633, 0.006695007439702749, -0.021080268546938896, -0.01099819503724575, -0.044980090111494064, -0.04185669124126434, 0.007681972347199917, -0.030078263953328133, -0.010703069157898426, -0.04120835289359093, -0.008471881039440632, -0.0321182943880558, 0.027193274348974228, -0.006064423359930515, -0.0049524432979524136, -0.0031239690724760294, 0.029510317370295525, -0.01716993935406208, 0.012092174030840397, -0.010103564709424973, 0.028898419812321663, -0.008987187407910824, -0.012793215923011303, 0.012409551069140434, -0.05238209664821625, 0.0037358186673372984, -0.008757646195590496, -0.0147986626252532, 0.007890104316174984, -0.011482157744467258, -0.011242982931435108, -0.006549397017806768, -0.015850594267249107, 0.01570974476635456, -0.0011916373623535037, 0.03368575498461723, -0.0033899880945682526, -0.013455312699079514, -0.03688763082027435, 0.01840210147202015, -0.01246139407157898, 0.001273311791010201, -0.0017033552285283804, 0.04807187244296074, 0.00032009740243665874, -0.023381998762488365, -0.07167315483093262, -0.01576031558215618, -0.022059589624404907, 0.030247310176491737, -0.011190707795321941, -0.022250503301620483, -0.024157000705599785, 0.010081315413117409, 0.004818366840481758, -0.006103863939642906, 0.04063546285033226, -0.00737298047170043, -0.010194515809416771, 0.019614312797784805, 0.051372889429330826, 0.05268368124961853, -0.007078549358993769, 0.00389659870415926, 0.021827107295393944, -0.0017112873028963804, -0.00117479485925287, -0.011492644436657429, -0.019006788730621338, -0.035440295934677124, -0.016876447945833206, -0.060197990387678146, 0.0353425070643425, 0.0439169704914093, -0.028926530852913857, -0.024761725217103958, -0.028171535581350327, -0.03770123049616814, -0.011034020222723484, -0.03494813293218613, 0.005674733314663172, -0.017490671947598457, 0.006223574280738831, -0.010700245387852192, 0.04402540996670723, -0.0410994254052639, 0.002818652894347906, 0.014070977456867695, -0.02472577802836895, -0.013736525550484657, -0.010598810389637947, 0.037930626422166824, -0.005245060659945011, 0.014544001780450344, -0.005377489607781172, 0.0015472306404262781, 0.0432732030749321, -0.04522807151079178, -0.03443242982029915, -0.012920346111059189, 0.025170352309942245, -0.03984864056110382, -0.02096899412572384, -0.020958133041858673, -0.026226859539747238, 0.037322357296943665, 0.010343531146645546, 0.04058034345507622, 0.04617048799991608, -0.02124425396323204, 0.01670786365866661, -0.024195749312639236, 0.009507760405540466, -0.006707835476845503, -0.026489602401852608, 0.05609194561839104, -0.030942359939217567, 0.001014474779367447, 0.07174728810787201, -0.003324533812701702, 0.021096013486385345, 0.011644968762993813, 0.06690048426389694, 0.007986878044903278, 0.024757275357842445, -0.0166437029838562, -0.030765144154429436, -0.02055276930332184, -0.04154127463698387, -0.013917067088186741, -0.015113120898604393, -0.03661331161856651, 0.014801730401813984, 0.042667288333177567, -0.018447700887918472, -0.0530783049762249, -0.028758127242326736, -0.07622528076171875, 0.015745701268315315, 0.019909176975488663, -0.02738315984606743, 0.016026195138692856, 0.007301474921405315, 0.041268207132816315, -0.014389324001967907, 0.009234090335667133, -0.020442523062229156, -0.043257664889097214, -0.015278601087629795, -0.019286023452878, -0.015318230725824833, 0.012429640628397465, -0.04192858561873436, -0.04676461219787598, 0.06107483431696892, -0.05236149951815605, 0.01029200293123722, 0.0388200543820858, 0.06901313364505768, -0.04948575422167778, 0.04301120340824127, 0.033122092485427856, 0.025573410093784332, 0.01695864647626877, -0.045410577207803726, 0.139561265707016, 0.07947158813476562, 0.0013941599754616618, -0.06770376861095428, 0.016957834362983704, 0.030644355341792107, 0.0008042724803090096, -0.012416547164320946, -0.013291104696691036, -0.006694192532449961, -0.006436996161937714, 0.02311026118695736, 0.06273509562015533, 0.02605484612286091, -0.031162697821855545, 0.04250257462263107, -0.037403929978609085, -0.012053290382027626, -0.013569656759500504, 0.013976027257740498, 0.004334396217018366, -0.030794667080044746, -0.027941517531871796, 0.0022720792330801487, 0.025769498199224472, -0.02386568672955036, -0.015616564080119133, -0.01973017491400242, 0.014564924873411655, 0.0023469736333936453, -0.02826991118490696, 0.031147073954343796, 0.022292692214250565, -0.01321291271597147, -0.014275624416768551, -0.00574217364192009, 0.05458691716194153, -0.060376428067684174, 0.024350853636860847, 0.04173827916383743, -0.018371913582086563, -0.020751899108290672, -0.0007163853151723742, 0.02385120838880539, -0.05757060647010803, -0.045299604535102844, -0.028514372184872627, 0.058976911008358, 0.027719495818018913, -0.06076803430914879, -0.0030347388237714767, 0.007546824403107166, 0.036583904176950455, -0.0042691659182310104, -0.014076950959861279, 0.012160215526819229, 0.0016727535985410213, -0.06578847765922546, -0.02670644223690033, 0.0031955153681337833, -0.009594880044460297, 0.001773643190972507, 0.003309317398816347, 0.039748311042785645, -0.0011708472156897187, -0.029681626707315445, -0.024320410564541817, 0.01858917996287346, 0.0034179342910647392, 0.011161540634930134, 0.002799845766276121, -0.028553424403071404, -0.024176856502890587, 0.017445877194404602, 0.020285731181502342, 0.02294698916375637, 0.03449910879135132, -0.001394340069964528, -0.00839884951710701, -0.051174346357584, 0.02447211742401123, -0.04078592360019684, -0.027841124683618546, -0.03589292988181114, -0.020690198987722397, -0.0025851577520370483, -0.006653202697634697, 0.013945690356194973, 0.03913719579577446, -0.030458349734544754, 0.00414141034707427, 0.048278991132974625, 0.032371047884225845, -0.04304756969213486, -0.059415072202682495, -0.012397045269608498, -0.013645968399941921, 0.00022163281391840428, 0.025352833792567253, 0.06156504154205322, -0.00025905718212015927, -0.005571701098233461, 0.028646495193243027, 0.028892286121845245, -0.022078415378928185, -0.0031918862368911505, 0.03141039237380028, -0.0211124736815691, -0.019882993772625923, 0.023943964391946793, -0.025852566584944725, -0.0027531106024980545, 0.01200299896299839, -0.0324043445289135, 0.0024457848630845547, 0.035250499844551086, -0.03098645620048046, -0.04271399974822998, -0.003238084726035595, -0.007593986578285694, 0.026208333671092987, -0.02449442259967327, 0.004556427244096994, -0.05220704525709152, -0.03232969343662262, 0.02334723435342312, -0.016771206632256508, 0.004412747919559479, 0.033323291689157486, 0.007597643416374922, 0.02668183296918869, 0.02203967608511448, -0.009730054996907711, 0.03014063648879528, 0.0010663141729310155, 0.02742369845509529, -0.012899692170321941, 0.048082634806632996, 0.014094911515712738, -0.022872762754559517, 0.0232844315469265, -0.03220530226826668, -0.0017469673184677958, 0.03503996506333351, 0.015317155048251152, 0.027856172993779182, 0.009455257095396519, 0.040161486715078354, 0.008171656168997288, 0.049380287528038025, -0.018621759489178658, -0.02640581503510475, -0.01501421257853508, 0.029161568731069565, 0.03716658428311348, -0.034572843462228775, -0.010564548894762993, 0.008826403878629208, -0.03981612250208855, 0.01406900305300951, 0.018462542444467545, 0.025560282170772552, -0.022727642208337784, -0.03758246451616287, -0.0005182291497476399, 0.0367126427590847, -0.008055858314037323, -0.0014403705717995763, 0.003539356868714094, 0.04719478264451027, -0.00460914196446538, 0.024319984018802643, 0.03179807588458061, 0.01584484986960888, -0.09387501329183578, -0.003679427783936262, 0.01717611402273178, 0.021647784858942032, 0.052052609622478485, -0.052400410175323486, 0.011778054758906364, 0.03379751369357109, -0.05766679346561432, 0.005890029948204756, -0.005021376069635153, 0.04523314908146858, -0.04315202683210373, 0.038210704922676086, -0.051307957619428635, 0.0142265809699893, 0.02405731752514839, 0.03154463320970535, -0.014056344516575336, 0.027136588469147682, 0.004145354963839054, -0.03595488518476486, -0.021165473386645317, 0.00496794143691659, -0.007415353320538998, -0.046415530145168304, 0.02415918931365013, -0.04032374918460846, 0.025427350774407387, 0.02500568889081478, -0.050377290695905685, -0.0010696991812437773, 0.013707476668059826, 0.007380631752312183, -0.005944161210209131, 0.023744644597172737, 0.005149477627128363, -0.035460881888866425, 0.005117409862577915, -0.020650088787078857, -0.02831246703863144, 0.04833514988422394, 0.004640172701328993, -0.0007304463651962578, 0.01894534006714821, -0.021212510764598846, -0.015877878293395042, 0.027378620579838753, 0.004286147188395262, 0.03874586895108223, 0.023080026730895042, -0.013253191486001015, 0.0024505124893039465, -0.036860886961221695, -0.017352981492877007, -0.011473353952169418, 0.009326756931841373, 0.03088802844285965, 0.03978288546204567, -0.03829685598611832, 0.0015414718072861433, -0.042601387947797775, -0.05828419700264931, -0.01514135580509901, -0.01835593953728676, -0.023787733167409897, -0.03393659368157387, 0.007386874407529831, -0.0031851008534431458, -0.012802103534340858, -0.0007045746897347271, 0.04422781616449356, -0.018501846119761467, 0.03968951106071472, -0.004163592122495174, 0.0158903356641531, -0.015584489330649376, -0.02053762599825859, 0.011822108179330826, -0.08789531886577606, 0.05962510034441948, 0.06762560456991196, -0.011999610811471939, -0.061586637049913406, -0.007263380568474531, -0.031084049493074417, 0.025162121281027794, 0.049739688634872437, -0.001631795079447329, -0.010550701059401035, -0.012598053552210331, 0.028025466948747635, -0.012749208137392998, -0.04192463681101799, 0.07116445899009705, 0.014027687720954418, 0.01860874705016613, 0.015287887305021286, -0.009296768344938755, -0.015632042661309242, 0.006928050424903631, 0.006582571193575859, -0.009213636629283428, 0.0015906660119071603, 0.025734305381774902, -0.011663835495710373, 0.03357492759823799, 0.027845457196235657, -0.02719181962311268, 0.019099870696663857, 0.018972966820001602, 0.016213824972510338, 0.03798389062285423, 0.0008728199754841626, -0.050116509199142456, 0.041303664445877075, -0.0505874939262867, -0.05252693220973015, 0.03105335868895054, 0.01265142671763897, -0.016015227884054184, -0.041508983820676804, -0.00990330521017313, 0.026532519608736038, 0.003683940740302205, -0.04192637279629707, 0.027940871194005013, 0.011714911088347435, 0.0502321682870388, 0.018064070492982864, 0.01380077376961708, -0.01174209825694561, -0.06431955844163895, 0.02850491926074028, 0.0015078431461006403, -0.0032027512788772583, 0.0629720464348793, -0.010672435164451599, 0.061841193586587906, 0.030212804675102234, 0.004845675081014633, -0.026809709146618843, 0.04555994272232056, -0.03829708695411682, 0.021131716668605804, 0.022600291296839714, 0.020008131861686707, 0.017605135217308998, 0.03459755331277847, 0.014527563937008381, 0.040920440107584, -0.045433904975652695, -0.0023940696846693754, -0.011295880191028118, 0.005712449084967375, -0.03184090927243233, 0.03063385561108589, 0.05720313638448715, -0.02826874516904354, -0.007068037521094084, 0.014296305365860462, -0.0015786744188517332, -0.04658201336860657, -0.0029028395656496286, -0.026331769302487373, 0.02717634104192257, 0.018574420362710953, -0.018638145178556442, 0.0005616856506094337, -0.0065615177154541016, -0.02417646534740925, -0.000949244829826057, 0.010008500888943672, 0.025182537734508514, -0.013258453458547592, -0.04747135192155838, 0.01173046138137579, 0.02222510613501072, 0.0624128133058548, -0.08684050291776657, -0.015531227923929691, -0.06308943778276443, -0.011571470648050308, -0.011641218326985836, -0.013142487965524197 ]
<p>This may be too simple a question for this forum - it is possibly a very basic statistics question as commonly found in biomedical research. But since scientists often lack good understanding of statistics, I would appreciate a lot if I could hear the thoughts from expert statisticians on this forum and be educated a little bit.</p> <p>I want to test if the treatment X affects the parameter P in a sample group of subjects. The design is paired: each subject is tested with no treatment (negative control) and with treatment X (order is randomized). To analyze such data, a paired t-test is obvious. However, I also have a positive control group - which is a separate independent group of subjects with sort of intrinsically different level of P, the one we would expect if treatment X works. So now I have three groups of measurements - two are paired, and one is un-paired. For three groups, I would need to use 1-way ANOVA. However, this will treat three groups as independent. How can I test if there is a difference in means between these three groups. Which test to use? Is it always appropriate to treat paired samples as un-paired? I understand that this leads to lower power, however - is this the only problem with this approach and is it still correct? Thank you!</p>
73,653
[ -0.035660624504089355, 0.01331323105841875, -0.033043019473552704, -0.004292667843401432, 0.02555496245622635, 0.025173647329211235, -0.003748553805053234, -0.003020358504727483, -0.0073733641766011715, 0.008638272061944008, 0.04462335631251335, 0.04211091995239258, 0.030158929526805878, -0.01454545371234417, 0.01731214113533497, -0.0028496887534856796, -0.03848540410399437, -0.02419639378786087, 0.00651159742847085, -0.0268658809363842, -0.012950592674314976, 0.003186032408848405, 0.00879825558513403, 0.01024116575717926, -0.029877319931983948, 0.04177108034491539, 0.007895849645137787, -0.03797166422009468, 0.022420920431613922, 0.04686787724494934, -0.027784138917922974, -0.03431420773267746, -0.0046699573285877705, 0.005750959273427725, 0.018181897699832916, 0.006753143388777971, -0.021025585010647774, 0.002750898478552699, 0.0029629403725266457, 0.0560966357588768, -0.02415676973760128, -0.015858951956033707, 0.005885391961783171, 0.003664433490484953, -0.013784346170723438, 0.04144982993602753, 0.004556591156870127, -0.028713565319776535, 0.033937301486730576, -0.05589437112212181, 0.06245656684041023, -0.0026470848824828863, 0.04838012158870697, 0.025157462805509567, -0.01603294350206852, -0.02344082109630108, 0.04601125791668892, 0.03295546770095825, 0.00026992938364855945, -0.06554176658391953, -0.03407616913318634, -0.01732208952307701, 0.012933081015944481, 0.0009214015444740653, -0.05193208530545235, 0.02513461373746395, -0.010567238554358482, -0.010309433564543724, 0.026325931772589684, -0.005226864945143461, 0.02026030234992504, 0.01964627392590046, 0.041030675172805786, 0.019915182143449783, -0.03337454795837402, 0.012768740765750408, 0.025294413790106773, 0.01940503716468811, 0.06626786291599274, 0.029985928907990456, -0.023300375789403915, 0.02126641385257244, 0.026951070874929428, 0.08928364515304565, 0.010785643011331558, -0.032408859580755234, 0.05063309147953987, -0.028361696749925613, 0.0076046534813940525, 0.011294419877231121, -0.040655896067619324, -0.028693707659840584, 0.05386019125580788, -0.00016332895029336214, -0.014397405087947845, 0.008910850621759892, -0.04012562334537506, 0.03736786171793938, -0.0074464804492890835, 0.006275929510593414, -0.0045154038816690445, -0.054137151688337326, 0.026213927194476128, 0.02867494523525238, -0.0150105906650424, -0.015752648934721947, -0.027792958542704582, 0.03118973597884178, -0.00978611409664154, -0.019237836822867393, -0.018623558804392815, 0.017152562737464905, -0.0170160923153162, -0.005872387904673815, 0.04445742815732956, -0.028936104848980904, -0.02532332018017769, -0.02812822163105011, 0.07914936542510986, 0.060007885098457336, 0.06240462139248848, -0.034787122160196304, 0.022696761414408684, -0.014886732213199139, -0.03161487355828285, 0.008302904665470123, 0.006520981900393963, -0.009637669660151005, -0.014659822918474674, 0.06165369972586632, 0.028992438688874245, 0.010488085448741913, 0.03573291748762131, -0.007786925882101059, 0.023215845227241516, 0.018306639045476913, -0.08211592584848404, -0.04046805575489998, 0.027460865676403046, -0.011127514764666557, -0.024647563695907593, -0.043193571269512177, -0.0154106505215168, 0.02668100968003273, 0.06038375571370125, -0.024399707093834877, 0.01723180152475834, -0.03054516762495041, 0.035829491913318634, 0.034876272082328796, 0.0016759749269112945, -0.011881213635206223, -0.059264227747917175, -0.04392384737730026, -0.0037187947891652584, -0.07939283549785614, 0.020553812384605408, -0.006701334845274687, -0.0016538079362362623, 0.012295825406908989, 0.03875885158777237, -0.00009055400732904673, 0.0036721061915159225, 0.019799649715423584, 0.0017991990316659212, 0.027584103867411613, 0.060525037348270416, -0.026234636083245277, 0.04488023370504379, -0.008334832265973091, 0.013432979583740234, 0.042777761816978455, 0.009701547212898731, 0.03324998915195465, 0.03049374371767044, -0.03189357742667198, -0.03909725323319435, -0.014000099152326584, 0.028435558080673218, 0.012868073768913746, -0.030993904918432236, -0.0001079671856132336, -0.026690198108553886, -0.015837132930755615, 0.016446553170681, 0.04850544035434723, 0.019397586584091187, 0.0017601283034309745, 0.07324708253145218, -0.024177908897399902, -0.04946570470929146, -0.08803971111774445, 0.0007929247221909463, 0.02193400077521801, -0.03001452051103115, 0.0460876040160656, -0.025695346295833588, 0.03334460407495499, -0.028343211859464645, -0.01446904893964529, -0.010422952473163605, 0.016723399981856346, 0.049579497426748276, -0.06575462967157364, 0.03769714757800102, 0.04751785099506378, 0.05472659319639206, -0.02512330375611782, 0.030258966609835625, -0.0438675619661808, -0.03402410447597504, 0.006609432864934206, -0.03219917044043541, 0.0070738038048148155, 0.011162838898599148, -0.04377299174666405, -0.014975355938076973, 0.014797478914260864, -0.04604849964380264, 0.06188478693366051, -0.07702842354774475, 0.09524235874414444, 0.05064307525753975, -0.02064419537782669, 0.0015085118357092142, 0.007163517642766237, 0.0074187531135976315, 0.006417938973754644, -0.03455008938908577, -0.014665398746728897, -0.03491482511162758, -0.011714422143995762, 0.03296676650643349, 0.005645275115966797, -0.02733226679265499, 0.026182403787970543, 0.05092577636241913, -0.01858014054596424, 0.007688259705901146, 0.04370145872235298, 0.03394564986228943, -0.025889188051223755, 0.0075701517052948475, 0.04346980154514313, 0.00939201284199953, 0.016603490337729454, 0.035496849566698074, -0.015313620679080486, 0.04677233472466469, 0.026294345036149025, -0.017074527218937874, 0.014703023247420788, 0.009131381288170815, 0.029300156980752945, -0.01503301877528429, -0.02629234828054905, 0.016984732821583748, -0.01483753602951765, 0.022310597822070122, 0.002126104896888137, 0.024779677391052246, -0.024693641811609268, 0.0027483401354402304, -0.009988665580749512, 0.019714178517460823, 0.013570664450526237, -0.038911961019039154, 0.01649419032037258, 0.0038358771707862616, -0.023427417501807213, 0.01766964979469776, -0.020192133262753487, -0.03530712053179741, -0.02602088451385498, 0.010056975297629833, 0.012903922237455845, -0.0020113762002438307, 0.03343883901834488, -0.018530597910284996, -0.006856904830783606, 0.0006489897496066988, -0.016436481848359108, 0.010405640117824078, 0.030990738421678543, -0.055701326578855515, -0.009390388615429401, -0.06147226691246033, -0.01610497571527958, 0.018600808456540108, -0.01545996405184269, -0.002112138317897916, 0.029838332906365395, -0.0029160259291529655, -0.05716930702328682, -0.04248783737421036, -0.060504134744405746, 0.002225277479737997, 0.00408668490126729, -0.02008700557053089, 0.0509454682469368, 0.026906169950962067, -0.02207130566239357, 0.035592056810855865, -0.03307011350989342, -0.010494934394955635, 0.026386814191937447, 0.011342545971274376, 0.0241005327552557, 0.013716288842260838, -0.005210780538618565, 0.039644114673137665, -0.04342079907655716, -0.02201726846396923, -0.06948763877153397, -0.060651276260614395, 0.04305192828178406, -0.0021090798545628786, 0.0285127405077219, -0.008012848906219006, -0.048652660101652145, 0.06820975244045258, 0.031715042889118195, -0.01145450584590435, -0.012716188095510006, -0.03236863389611244, -0.05232135206460953, -0.007642135489732027, 0.053361229598522186, 0.008354531601071358, 0.006353812757879496, 0.023811649531126022, -0.0004372143012005836, 0.024940984323620796, 0.021758990362286568, 0.03682379052042961, -0.01341783907264471, 0.005726912058889866, 0.05430055782198906, -0.013583202846348286, 0.01801569201052189, 0.030494624748826027, -0.01437855139374733, -0.009087299928069115, 0.018395554274320602, 0.018137769773602486, -0.02260437235236168, -0.031147131696343422, 0.02372533455491066, 0.002053734613582492, 0.03894443064928055, -0.003101016627624631, 0.02044239640235901, 0.019180959090590477, 0.019379545003175735, 0.013554491102695465, 0.03639614209532738, 0.009071791544556618, -0.032011356204748154, 0.014659887179732323, 0.06431762129068375, 0.03635468706488609, -0.016007041558623314, -0.02673996426165104, 0.011227072216570377, -0.02217053808271885, 0.012787682004272938, 0.0021715615876019, -0.04028556868433952, 0.023906853049993515, 0.036854103207588196, 0.03897315636277199, 0.009955178946256638, -0.019939392805099487, 0.010739779099822044, -0.052898574620485306, 0.045901134610176086, -0.0321868360042572, 0.031092233955860138, -0.0065599288791418076, 0.04934491217136383, 0.00363082904368639, -0.009775998070836067, -0.04188026487827301, -0.019129225984215736, -0.031086964532732964, 0.02947680465877056, -0.01489301584661007, -0.0325285866856575, 0.012298437766730785, 0.0038252926897257566, 0.021901810541749, -0.020268075168132782, 0.03439803421497345, -0.017156869173049927, 0.035546571016311646, -0.02850647084414959, -0.021589122712612152, -0.023023847490549088, -0.008593222126364708, -0.007569742389023304, 0.02939765341579914, 0.0024674548767507076, -0.027953892946243286, 0.02505919709801674, 0.017894776538014412, -0.0355951301753521, -0.004636088851839304, -0.026038695126771927, 0.02591700106859207, 0.04187224060297012, 0.041988398879766464, 0.03499045595526695, 0.040522802621126175, -0.05786456912755966, 0.04751718044281006, 0.00956921186298132, 0.03569681942462921, 0.0026694454718381166, -0.02489624172449112, -0.0013282872969284654, -0.04615183547139168, -0.04529595002532005, -0.0007289394270628691, 0.04176594689488411, 0.03650869429111481, 0.007164343260228634, 0.04558920860290527, 0.008712876588106155, -0.044930268079042435, 0.0004247005272191018, 0.05977857857942581, 0.016773102805018425, -0.017339447513222694, -0.05708214268088341, 0.0032869819551706314, -0.021804198622703552, 0.012000671587884426, 0.036175403743982315, 0.03918294981122017, 0.02136123925447464, -0.009854975156486034, 0.04355518892407417, 0.02935168705880642, -0.03164323791861534, -0.005332230124622583, -0.0005663365591317415, 0.017839808017015457, 0.0103793079033494, -0.024514198303222656, 0.04986660182476044, 0.02647808939218521, -0.01161129865795374, 0.009956141002476215, -0.013757207430899143, -0.05062809959053993, 0.019167236983776093, 0.06337835639715195, 0.050679612904787064, -0.04985787346959114, -0.02162441983819008, 0.02518371120095253, 0.00907896552234888, -0.0010480069322511554, -0.043863989412784576, 0.013369354419410229, -0.013040559366345406, 0.005377571098506451, -0.03609735891222954, -0.011637079529464245, -0.05541423708200455, 0.010879925452172756, -0.02215507999062538, -0.0009332192130386829, 0.0183749757707119, -0.05345597118139267, -0.02001197077333927, 0.006778921466320753, 0.04042297229170799, 0.061144936829805374, -0.04129691421985626, -0.035719793289899826, 0.05348118022084236, 0.028607849031686783, -0.016854852437973022, -0.07456523925065994, 0.018513279035687447, -0.011861499398946762, -0.009250852279365063, 0.05981436371803284, -0.020029067993164062, -0.048197295516729355, 0.003632085397839546, -0.020594768226146698, -0.03724658116698265, 0.0020562626887112856, 0.006898030173033476, 0.02613358199596405, 0.01969997212290764, -0.006369899958372116, 0.07795549184083939, 0.04368993267416954, -0.0016434133285656571, -0.013393459841609001, -0.040772050619125366, 0.01594807207584381, -0.018338436260819435, 0.004575174767524004, -0.0558382086455822, -0.0057265679351985455, -0.014932073652744293, 0.040941569954156876, -0.0038884440436959267, 0.03773946315050125, -0.005596712697297335, 0.0041236975230276585, 0.01954127661883831, -0.01404796727001667, 0.017318841069936752, 0.014633534476161003, -0.008836123161017895, -0.010600450448691845, -0.00974210910499096, -0.026073236018419266, -0.0005237167933955789, -0.02654898166656494, -0.0028295116499066353, -0.00027411748305894434, -0.05985487997531891, 0.00614134082570672, -0.015454799868166447, -0.06588611751794815, -0.025803271681070328, -0.03300973027944565, 0.01202100794762373, -0.00948361586779356, 0.027276987209916115, -0.018906379118561745, -0.033178143203258514, -0.024469370022416115, 0.040096428245306015, 0.012487861327826977, 0.0462922528386116, -0.05062844231724739, 0.044842999428510666, -0.03263391926884651, -0.010476802475750446, -0.0526994913816452, -0.03800451010465622, 0.012534928508102894, 0.01269262284040451, 0.004966989625245333, -0.0012478727148845792, 0.019913200289011, -0.024099864065647125, 0.008543678559362888, -0.02973492257297039, 0.07182765007019043, -0.0195561945438385, -0.0416586697101593, -0.010216251015663147, 0.0050651938654482365, 0.06063324585556984, -0.01867673173546791, -0.011022606864571571, -0.008215650916099548, -0.011595361866056919, -0.007994226180016994, -0.0009860097197815776, -0.020846663042902946, -0.02749737910926342, -0.023808207362890244, -0.023125382140278816, 0.00682381447404623, 0.03546765446662903, -0.026179281994700432, -0.04250055178999901, 0.023898009210824966, 0.0010834400309249759, -0.029982784762978554, -0.04509248211979866, 0.0008598610293120146, -0.01360161229968071, 0.0010688251350075006, -0.0256512351334095, 0.02182534895837307, 0.00270653422921896, -0.012375949881970882, 0.04528653621673584, 0.025937212631106377, -0.07791859656572342, -0.03013814240694046, 0.04558680206537247, 0.049047719687223434, 0.005773595999926329, -0.010201348923146725, -0.02804619073867798, 0.019770491868257523, -0.004209603648632765, -0.0077367243357002735, -0.0016765816835686564, 0.03912452608346939, -0.037500813603401184, 0.0005131483194418252, -0.017885880544781685, -0.006286530755460262, 0.07403291016817093, 0.0009707664139568806, 0.06856334954500198, 0.07603069394826889, 0.014601798728108406, -0.015141979791224003, -0.02375890128314495, 0.00605451175943017, -0.03765273094177246, 0.005866316147148609, 0.04417719319462776, -0.014043958857655525, 0.001525943516753614, 0.04616273567080498, -0.012543785385787487, 0.0010199823882430792, 0.043854620307683945, 0.014280704781413078, 0.008736524730920792, 0.045606035739183426, -0.027526186779141426, -0.04328777268528938, 0.03350858762860298, -0.08373227715492249, -0.00035814224975183606, -0.0575992614030838, -0.015737636014819145, 0.036167602986097336, 0.04158402979373932, 0.00460087601095438, -0.06180145591497421, -0.02422238141298294, -0.07526702433824539, -0.01403560396283865, 0.006285578943789005, 0.002100608544424176, 0.033667732030153275, -0.017445925623178482, 0.051656223833560944, -0.007278846576809883, 0.013703637756407261, -0.028350472450256348, -0.07266684621572495, -0.04962627589702606, 0.015044905245304108, 0.0011939674150198698, 0.02123223803937435, -0.007184979971498251, -0.03684883937239647, 0.004105023108422756, -0.03519047796726227, 0.021696845069527626, -0.027218850329518318, 0.03616069257259369, -0.04860476776957512, 0.04642831161618233, -0.01024802215397358, 0.018554264679551125, 0.05138388276100159, -0.00608840910717845, 0.09572672098875046, 0.0339864119887352, 0.050076745450496674, -0.09174337238073349, 0.056212328374385834, -0.021744631230831146, -0.01173290703445673, -0.03344283998012543, 0.028495831415057182, 0.022654982283711433, -0.009116304107010365, 0.03762180730700493, 0.06046547740697861, 0.05290892347693443, -0.03212599456310272, 0.0880696102976799, -0.036644067615270615, -0.03245827555656433, 0.03143951669335365, -0.0038038636557757854, 0.003959607798606157, -0.030344290658831596, -0.01481667347252369, 0.01748957484960556, -0.0037100124172866344, 0.0059960633516311646, 0.0014091269113123417, 0.009845825843513012, 0.007472188677638769, 0.027774488553404808, 0.02268877625465393, -0.0018451525829732418, -0.00992904044687748, 0.0029638116247951984, -0.06953811645507812, -0.007763706147670746, -0.00004299831562093459, -0.07085509598255157, 0.020613471046090126, 0.02405027113854885, -0.013357050716876984, -0.008992401883006096, 0.02084895595908165, 0.004186652600765228, -0.055765021592378616, -0.04707349091768265, -0.0011106283636763692, 0.05116068944334984, 0.028814610093832016, 0.006064942106604576, -0.017348894849419594, 0.015479647554457188, 0.001789349364116788, -0.04098714143037796, -0.03171137720346451, 0.020582588389515877, 0.04213729128241539, -0.03692945837974548, -0.012597073800861835, -0.014256182126700878, 0.018749387934803963, -0.005091993138194084, 0.03709125146269798, 0.04494078457355499, -0.0021275607869029045, 0.003864648751914501, 0.0050612254999578, 0.023211758583784103, 0.03964049369096756, -0.005859119351953268, 0.011229799129068851, -0.011118817143142223, -0.012232093140482903, 0.012834489345550537, 0.028963172808289528, 0.02397676557302475, 0.020561372861266136, -0.005079912021756172, 0.0031037128064781427, -0.0040161809884011745, -0.036024633795022964, 0.022716043516993523, -0.04607769846916199, 0.015490085817873478, -0.029465442523360252, -0.015005655586719513, 0.03719484433531761, 0.03638456016778946, 0.016306884586811066, -0.0016313310479745269, 0.037095677107572556, 0.03732818737626076, 0.01338656060397625, -0.07517457753419876, -0.0109480619430542, -0.004926486872136593, -0.029847584664821625, -0.017332755029201508, -0.026679664850234985, 0.03610869124531746, 0.030675655230879784, 0.00962316244840622, -0.03613469749689102, -0.0004203913558740169, -0.014319652691483498, -0.00317209935747087, 0.020416736602783203, -0.0553123876452446, -0.009056765586137772, 0.023958686739206314, -0.009518414735794067, -0.005813767667859793, -0.04567531496286392, -0.025123251602053642, -0.05280736833810806, 0.024262268096208572, -0.02453555352985859, -0.003219571430236101, -0.021974261850118637, -0.008853473700582981, 0.0296932365745306, -0.030202090740203857, -0.004865788388997316, -0.052883800119161606, -0.014421830885112286, 0.01918967254459858, -0.0012516157003119588, -0.010618671774864197, 0.014171522110700607, -0.0024851239286363125, 0.011070792563259602, 0.035442229360342026, -0.0235050730407238, 0.02739758789539337, 0.008827059529721737, 0.006616366561502218, 0.006563518662005663, 0.05685494467616081, 0.033166319131851196, -0.004294241312891245, 0.049806009978055954, -0.06338180601596832, -0.02119075320661068, -0.00973204243928194, 0.02146223373711109, 0.03868001326918602, 0.0001409310061717406, -0.028359893709421158, -0.034471794962882996, 0.02981727384030819, -0.030129434540867805, -0.034186363220214844, -0.0041980803944170475, -0.013509214855730534, -0.010198657400906086, -0.006300564855337143, -0.003732789773494005, -0.00949719175696373, -0.002983459737151861, 0.04579640552401543, 0.05172942951321602, 0.03026438318192959, 0.001507533248513937, -0.004495255649089813, 0.02365165948867798, 0.020318230614066124, -0.002011035569012165, -0.017342451959848404, 0.016137419268488884, 0.06678923964500427, -0.005709606688469648, 0.030588600784540176, -0.02943071722984314, 0.01622014306485653, -0.09183357656002045, -0.01706097461283207, -0.005555587355047464, 0.00804981030523777, 0.029326140880584717, -0.08566298335790634, 0.00030207843519747257, -0.00746753066778183, -0.024389099329710007, 0.01825854554772377, -0.023445168510079384, -0.0459732823073864, -0.03631104156374931, 0.011094486340880394, -0.006854132283478975, -0.007066661491990089, -0.011990929022431374, 0.024696193635463715, -0.007253216113895178, 0.029791850596666336, 0.012644319795072079, 0.006202237214893103, -0.0019512694561854005, 0.006930997129529715, 0.02137896604835987, -0.06984146684408188, 0.012771788984537125, -0.023033030331134796, -0.03566325455904007, 0.03355465456843376, -0.006924518384039402, 0.007418022956699133, 0.008234317414462566, 0.05172370746731758, -0.0172831192612648, 0.05323794484138489, 0.03857114166021347, -0.042747728526592255, -0.014842627570033073, 0.002163344295695424, -0.015697745606303215, 0.046644993126392365, -0.002573575358837843, 0.02229445055127144, 0.02959115244448185, 0.01733006164431572, 0.0029535454232245684, 0.014837362803518772, -0.003963815979659557, -0.015532832592725754, -0.02566717565059662, -0.0002759111230261624, 0.015797775238752365, -0.011448659002780914, -0.010581162758171558, -0.050109922885894775, 0.010552500374615192, 0.02570556476712227, 0.006072090473026037, -0.01866844855248928, 0.015957769006490707, -0.03260503336787224, -0.03635990992188454, 0.015569728799164295, -0.025620033964514732, 0.06171092018485069, -0.07087395340204239, -0.0008079928229562938, -0.01305138785392046, 0.011241670697927475, -0.03912263363599777, -0.027615219354629517, -0.016958849504590034, 0.03188537061214447, -0.02348947338759899, 0.0035664234310388565, 0.0009303383412770927, 0.006097411271184683, 0.0023593001533299685, -0.08152148127555847, 0.06689005345106125, 0.0012508619111031294, 0.006482172291725874, -0.04684676229953766, 0.007880477234721184, -0.046459488570690155, 0.0185383353382349, 0.06410783529281616, 0.027560049667954445, -0.00245890230871737, -0.009882095269858837, 0.02253001742064953, -0.016698580235242844, -0.03915069252252579, 0.05385831370949745, -0.01032812986522913, 0.012137494049966335, -0.031958259642124176, -0.03077920526266098, 0.008898899890482426, 0.02651801146566868, 0.017053328454494476, -0.024720868095755577, 0.03456238657236099, 0.011275844648480415, 0.02180165983736515, 0.03802966699004173, 0.01363912969827652, -0.0007692629005759954, 0.04540833458304405, 0.0119856595993042, 0.014441286213696003, 0.01295129768550396, -0.02439410798251629, -0.028633035719394684, 0.022135069593787193, -0.05576406046748161, -0.0335458368062973, 0.00982451532036066, 0.01931259222328663, -0.013195502571761608, -0.06304320693016052, 0.002531892852857709, 0.014638856053352356, -0.05564837157726288, 0.012099395506083965, 0.009976373985409737, 0.03978235647082329, -0.008312457241117954, -0.05544126406311989, 0.01911531388759613, 0.0034366075415164232, 0.014299873262643814, 0.013933098874986172, 0.022184962406754494, 0.013838089071214199, 0.0483633428812027, -0.004750075284391642, 0.002919598016887903, -0.04522567614912987, 0.03088401071727276, 0.009664401412010193, 0.034683555364608765, 0.012126580812036991, -0.01140241976827383, 0.013229284435510635, -0.0020187783520668745, 0.0315781831741333, -0.010927284136414528, 0.008158647455275059, 0.05284538120031357, -0.039710041135549545, -0.010436403565108776, -0.03226501867175102, -0.00008246549259638414, -0.0041884141974151134, -0.007009071297943592, 0.06251952797174454, 0.023697935044765472, -0.02705949917435646, -0.004716645926237106, 0.021363485604524612, -0.036557458341121674, 0.00003254945477237925, -0.013690142892301083, 0.05465763807296753, -0.0324413925409317, -0.009080296382308006, -0.03145137429237366, -0.0509079247713089, -0.05082536116242409, -0.025792622938752174, 0.035489272326231, 0.031117184087634087, 0.05372467637062073, -0.023397138342261314, -0.012150345370173454, 0.011957893148064613, 0.06201818957924843, -0.0740334689617157, -0.03522955998778343, -0.04531574249267578, 0.029246153309941292, 0.03869757801294327, -0.004853503312915564 ]
<p>I have a waveform, for which most people will measure either a peak amplitude or a slope. I have included the area under the curve and several other measures involving the same original waveform. I now have 10 measures on such waveforms (and I have measured these waveforms in 500 patients). Is it legitimate to put all these measures side by side in one big principal component analysis (PCA) to distil a smaller set of principal components. My worry is about the fact that some of the measures are inherently interdependent (for example, peak amplitude will be inherently correlated with area under the curve), so I was afraid it might fail to meet some of the assumptions behind PCA, such as independence of measures. Is there another analysis method I should use instead of PCA? Independent Component Analysis? Another multi-dimensional scaling method? Cluster analysis? Thanks very much!</p> <p>A bit more detail: In my case, I have made 9 raw measures, <em>x1</em> .. <em>x9</em>, in each patient. I already know that <em>x2</em> and <em>x4</em> are highly correlated, but their difference has important prognostic implications. On one hand, I am afraid PCA would fail to note this difference (because <em>x2</em> and <em>x4</em> are so correlated), so I would like to include <em>x2-x4</em> as a 10th measure. However, I am bothered by the fact that I am thus introducing trivial correlation, which will inflate the importance of <em>x2</em> and <em>x4</em> and any noise in them. Thanks again.</p>
73,654
[ -0.00915501918643713, 0.022271085530519485, -0.0052985395304858685, -0.0015267400303855538, 0.056660544127225876, 0.029028208926320076, -0.007077758200466633, -0.014559634029865265, 0.031270407140254974, -0.03260359168052673, 0.04726682975888252, -0.007167457602918148, 0.053874291479587555, 0.013816740363836288, 0.010120397433638573, -0.011899040080606937, -0.023379763588309288, 0.011804535053670406, 0.0006994269788265228, -0.038250524550676346, -0.0006795627414248884, 0.0029595782980322838, 0.012256240472197533, -0.016874734312295914, 0.0004611907934304327, 0.07601656764745712, 0.018793677911162376, 0.0005474900244735181, 0.008191335014998913, 0.03470084071159363, -0.038500260561704636, -0.029386939480900764, 0.002696302952244878, 0.0618889220058918, 0.01902664080262184, -0.021540271118283272, -0.0130237378180027, 0.0005516777164302766, 0.013831946067512035, 0.04582786560058594, -0.012929461896419525, -0.025887465104460716, -0.020605584606528282, 0.026377584785223007, -0.0281696617603302, 0.010910537093877792, 0.009027346037328243, -0.03031276725232601, 0.02996494621038437, -0.03703925386071205, 0.0843053087592125, -0.01031745970249176, 0.044028379023075104, 0.03362401947379112, -0.0047048646956682205, 0.00905195064842701, 0.036589473485946655, 0.08705316483974457, 0.0026533789932727814, -0.0780506357550621, -0.04502430185675621, 0.003766529494896531, 0.007565507665276527, -0.01544223167002201, -0.028856812044978142, 0.044109612703323364, 0.006227327510714531, -0.01731196604669094, 0.02465745620429516, -0.021970471367239952, 0.011333792470395565, 0.006321793422102928, 0.022598059847950935, -0.040113963186740875, 0.003678266191855073, -0.0029557249508798122, 0.025286054238677025, 0.026173060759902, 0.031782057136297226, 0.0016734026139602065, 0.0061327312141656876, -0.01457631029188633, 0.026693103834986687, 0.004431404639035463, 0.01840122416615486, 0.02887967973947525, 0.047845784574747086, -0.03642236813902855, 0.03956644982099533, 0.008774451911449432, 0.020074693486094475, 0.042801838368177414, 0.032495129853487015, 0.036934591829776764, -0.033724095672369, 0.0073552001267671585, -0.005725149996578693, 0.05716722458600998, 0.0024148039519786835, 0.020761018618941307, -0.0012947657378390431, -0.04667945206165314, 0.0069872657768428326, 0.05637441948056221, -0.010798056609928608, 0.0022087935358285904, -0.06463101506233215, -0.013316366821527481, -0.01772359199821949, -0.019745761528611183, -0.013823683373630047, -0.007080522365868092, 0.023523759096860886, -0.019168710336089134, 0.011275489814579487, -0.008079512976109982, 0.001357872155494988, 0.004206330515444279, 0.04056394472718239, 0.07330765575170517, 0.03757449612021446, -0.030742192640900612, 0.009806331247091293, -0.021601621061563492, -0.0563511997461319, -0.00970438402146101, 0.01199534721672535, -0.02404385805130005, -0.04891400784254074, 0.07203831523656845, 0.020244525745511055, -0.018852194771170616, 0.061122674494981766, -0.021549951285123825, 0.032786671072244644, 0.022622710093855858, -0.06194134056568146, -0.023433439433574677, 0.043379176408052444, -0.05421224609017372, 0.018604444339871407, -0.03656988963484764, -0.01957840286195278, 0.02925020270049572, 0.08242955803871155, -0.02066202089190483, 0.022857576608657837, 0.012189460918307304, 0.04695437476038933, 0.005304344929754734, -0.016967808827757835, -0.007190840318799019, -0.021928580477833748, -0.024945544078946114, -0.06487652659416199, -0.08000919222831726, -0.00030806445283815265, 0.043865952640771866, 0.0033027806784957647, 0.0016181515529751778, 0.014607301913201809, 0.01968631148338318, -0.0035023512318730354, -0.01878114975988865, -0.00046803909935988486, 0.007431334350258112, 0.04911644011735916, -0.027249999344348907, 0.008021645247936249, 0.01070336438715458, 0.01867670938372612, -0.0045575303956866264, 0.019032087177038193, 0.0363595113158226, 0.036241885274648666, 0.02806020714342594, -0.0029707446228712797, 0.0005361790535971522, -0.00963115319609642, 0.03079361841082573, -0.04150919243693352, -0.07374397665262222, -0.043763596564531326, 0.025364767760038376, 0.024556372314691544, 0.05694112926721573, -0.00428651412948966, -0.061978016048669815, 0.04011083021759987, -0.01287620235234499, -0.03554887697100639, -0.0443904809653759, 0.06704716384410858, -0.027177631855010986, -0.030136480927467346, 0.03217243403196335, -0.00434861471876502, 0.001661652815528214, -0.007079046219587326, -0.028697147965431213, -0.025302203372120857, 0.002085624961182475, 0.03648962825536728, -0.027612803503870964, 0.008207323029637337, 0.022212954238057137, 0.022804636508226395, -0.032874707132577896, 0.03857450932264328, -0.036946963518857956, -0.04161136969923973, 0.025273405015468597, -0.033047713339328766, 0.015506245195865631, -0.011737581342458725, -0.03686065971851349, -0.026022544130682945, -0.006656758487224579, -0.05605630576610565, 0.04444441571831703, -0.06294535845518112, 0.11547219008207321, 0.042899880558252335, -0.0033586490899324417, -0.005522063001990318, 0.006352458614856005, 0.0191044844686985, 0.023488324135541916, -0.02684149332344532, -0.01726357452571392, -0.043301839381456375, -0.018564485013484955, 0.05872174724936485, 0.022986464202404022, -0.040757086127996445, 0.028447473421692848, 0.0879545658826828, 0.030316319316625595, 0.030021721497178078, 0.03111555613577366, 0.00670341681689024, -0.024220796301960945, -0.00018301393720321357, 0.045665644109249115, -0.024050729349255562, -0.028115149587392807, 0.009704018011689186, -0.013232178054749966, 0.03800826892256737, 0.006163685116916895, -0.0032678551506251097, 0.050806924700737, -0.0036637180019170046, 0.033296339213848114, -0.01654394157230854, -0.024110086262226105, 0.05841297656297684, 0.0016499068588018417, 0.04316973313689232, 0.018957993015646935, 0.0009198935586027801, -0.014215678907930851, 0.012158566154539585, -0.047876812517642975, 0.024039098992943764, 0.032091833651065826, -0.07643746584653854, 0.01354336366057396, 0.001406339812092483, -0.044737912714481354, -0.0006778542301617563, -0.059247009456157684, -0.03777448087930679, -0.04377347230911255, 0.023880956694483757, 0.07646923512220383, 0.0070617604069411755, 0.049753930419683456, -0.04882384091615677, -0.042861778289079666, 0.01929355226457119, -0.020259633660316467, 0.014663223177194595, -0.0006237871712073684, -0.054203081876039505, -0.013659029267728329, -0.01924736797809601, -0.003929722588509321, 0.0331626795232296, -0.023336758837103844, 0.015095958486199379, -0.014929055236279964, -0.026408541947603226, -0.05490178242325783, -0.02059580199420452, -0.02107982337474823, 0.011784517206251621, -0.0102579016238451, -0.0662345364689827, 0.07154983282089233, -0.017225593328475952, -0.05305752903223038, -0.010379211977124214, 0.011181148700416088, 0.00502008805051446, 0.01840100809931755, 0.00014505695435218513, 0.05826014652848244, -0.02102673053741455, -0.018985282629728317, 0.020093318074941635, -0.024840231984853745, -0.021759672090411186, -0.027325842529535294, -0.06742992997169495, 0.023988110944628716, -0.005536369048058987, 0.037448663264513016, 0.006430178880691528, -0.021424943581223488, 0.04941997304558754, 0.02300938405096531, -0.04538164287805557, -0.03277617320418358, 0.0450281985104084, -0.05399861931800842, -0.009507187642157078, -0.012284891679883003, 0.02138552814722061, 0.036442551761865616, 0.03104274347424507, 0.00367080164141953, 0.011162979528307915, 0.052738290280103683, 0.027212392538785934, -0.026248440146446228, 0.046278730034828186, 0.03602268174290657, -0.0008522121352143586, 0.00253379438072443, 0.020391233265399933, -0.029995329678058624, 0.010525312274694443, 0.013922753743827343, -0.012358221225440502, 0.004789880011230707, -0.021962815895676613, 0.023970521986484528, -0.004712928086519241, 0.0181400366127491, -0.05497260019183159, -0.0342373326420784, 0.004127003252506256, 0.009718205779790878, -0.011695983819663525, 0.05741701275110245, 0.03301123157143593, -0.01884470507502556, 0.011702579446136951, 0.04102364182472229, 0.0036463330034166574, -0.0023824512027204037, -0.009263850748538971, -0.011729096062481403, 0.01554888766258955, 0.025365103036165237, 0.010784044861793518, -0.021535055711865425, 0.04621265456080437, 0.014989180490374565, 0.02419775351881981, 0.006368633359670639, -0.05236583948135376, 0.039229851216077805, -0.08355805277824402, -0.021843519061803818, -0.029401959851384163, 0.04071981832385063, 0.017144635319709778, 0.04260934889316559, 0.04277123138308525, -0.057605039328336716, 0.007716849911957979, 0.017691615968942642, -0.08781305700540543, -0.006407163571566343, -0.02034500613808632, 0.018672116100788116, 0.00893730390816927, -0.007641676347702742, -0.00440718000754714, -0.0034522085916250944, -0.029819829389452934, 0.009142599999904633, 0.021240822970867157, -0.04549034684896469, -0.0010437360033392906, -0.022665584459900856, -0.0005665296921506524, -0.02809266932308674, 0.008466443978250027, 0.013767391443252563, 0.007345863617956638, 0.024800987914204597, 0.03641483560204506, 0.02718329429626465, -0.014499176293611526, -0.016276737675070763, 0.01962997205555439, -0.0001345257187495008, 0.04037974029779434, -0.02200317569077015, 0.024505212903022766, -0.03260631859302521, 0.023203061893582344, 0.01097352895885706, 0.033841170370578766, 0.04067622870206833, -0.0071794334799051285, -0.00004906905087409541, -0.0248558446764946, -0.007994700223207474, -0.009243120439350605, 0.01682642474770546, 0.023611513897776604, -0.030808957293629646, 0.015879599377512932, 0.0168454609811306, -0.06187138706445694, 0.011570495553314686, 0.04882138967514038, 0.018748629838228226, -0.016344085335731506, -0.059891119599342346, -0.025967558845877647, 0.0014967425959184766, -0.026407068595290184, -0.004122911486774683, 0.018862852826714516, 0.0034024438355118036, -0.019139258190989494, 0.01867467164993286, -0.03611380606889725, -0.004791950341314077, -0.02239135280251503, 0.026427017524838448, 0.03629356622695923, -0.016240553930401802, -0.02814980410039425, 0.023927630856633186, 0.025769997388124466, 0.045786626636981964, 0.03204303979873657, 0.004750951658934355, -0.09455438703298569, 0.0007634423091076314, 0.02784121409058571, 0.06553035229444504, -0.02148827351629734, -0.02429775334894657, -0.03819521144032478, -0.02665327489376068, 0.06321361660957336, -0.022807130590081215, 0.021132471039891243, -0.029092444106936455, -0.00824134610593319, -0.029279464855790138, -0.04119226709008217, -0.05027462914586067, 0.011783534660935402, 0.010637647472321987, 0.039368897676467896, -0.0297082606703043, -0.04485718905925751, -0.0273917093873024, -0.00633017485961318, -0.011623590253293514, 0.07820165157318115, -0.0010080229258164763, -0.012217925861477852, -0.007095173932611942, 0.02871612273156643, 0.00032660880242474377, -0.060267336666584015, 0.016296133399009705, 0.0021554084960371256, -0.02899223566055298, 0.05158405378460884, -0.006802019197493792, -0.030196765437722206, -0.019981898367404938, 0.0031982145737856627, 0.004380716476589441, 0.0020903677213937044, 0.0023657376877963543, 0.09980680793523788, 0.03372126817703247, 0.01120792143046856, 0.08698748052120209, -0.0035825015511363745, -0.011106796562671661, -0.015232005156576633, -0.01777162402868271, 0.006785494275391102, -0.046255696564912796, -0.0011698059970512986, -0.04027598723769188, 0.01902405545115471, -0.03659839183092117, 0.0534997321665287, -0.02535267360508442, 0.02936193160712719, 0.010258583351969719, 0.01845105178654194, -0.00971527025103569, 0.02095361240208149, -0.015577675774693489, -0.0005800854996778071, 0.009993233717978, 0.011944579891860485, -0.006552881095558405, -0.012239508330821991, -0.001959121786057949, -0.018807070329785347, -0.0077235824428498745, 0.049308620393276215, -0.01582089252769947, -0.010635199956595898, -0.03905375674366951, -0.004175350535660982, 0.007751159835606813, -0.04360881447792053, 0.0005822828970849514, -0.008133764378726482, 0.05066794902086258, 0.017397582530975342, -0.03395475819706917, 0.007886533625423908, -0.002649707021191716, 0.022140832617878914, 0.048874568194150925, -0.06416583806276321, 0.021397000178694725, -0.030017059296369553, -0.01400506030768156, -0.06155644729733467, -0.057725146412849426, 0.04540418088436127, 0.037187688052654266, -0.0007706086034886539, -0.04425758868455887, 0.00997384637594223, -0.009916734881699085, -0.017592504620552063, -0.018667293712496758, 0.02530832402408123, -0.01483228337019682, -0.015362869948148727, 0.0005135293467901647, 0.018041960895061493, 0.10643438249826431, -0.009777696803212166, -0.024138711392879486, 0.023985452950000763, -0.01986667700111866, -0.011921169236302376, -0.04288822412490845, 0.007874686270952225, -0.05124218389391899, 0.012894710525870323, -0.0489809587597847, -0.012988744303584099, 0.045753393322229385, -0.02812354266643524, -0.03321092575788498, -0.011169962584972382, -0.004449316766113043, 0.008202996104955673, -0.00749167799949646, -0.01416510995477438, -0.04282562434673309, -0.017551444470882416, 0.002581315115094185, -0.00043668682337738574, -0.027941294014453888, -0.024877188727259636, -0.007876000367105007, 0.019954010844230652, -0.03940368816256523, 0.021854229271411896, 0.04312710836529732, 0.02209119126200676, 0.01062315795570612, -0.01888272352516651, -0.030017828568816185, 0.030017521232366562, -0.014280524104833603, 0.011259668506681919, -0.005803333595395088, 0.02288787253201008, -0.03497921675443649, -0.03262549638748169, -0.003462968859821558, -0.01602949947118759, 0.05351677164435387, 0.03414393588900566, 0.05423831194639206, 0.0891866609454155, -0.0031746248714625835, 0.003661306807771325, -0.027420159429311752, 0.014923826791346073, -0.0027203261852264404, 0.006561197806149721, 0.04443064332008362, -0.01942666806280613, -0.03748375549912453, 0.02110162563621998, -0.00008779839845374227, 0.009449340403079987, 0.003343501826748252, -0.005273026414215565, 0.048835430294275284, 0.011791439726948738, 0.021807869896292686, -0.03850702568888664, 0.04191657155752182, -0.02434225007891655, -0.01923978514969349, -0.021701550111174583, -0.008501977659761906, 0.026035990566015244, 0.056530073285102844, -0.010895115323364735, -0.02111062780022621, -0.011146409437060356, -0.04097362607717514, 0.003313855966553092, -0.0015915504191070795, -0.003677505999803543, 0.03564158082008362, 0.003164110239595175, 0.0358920618891716, 0.025721153244376183, 0.023210959509015083, -0.052229348570108414, -0.08185230195522308, -0.05197659507393837, -0.010219811461865902, -0.033622823655605316, 0.06335968524217606, 0.004903891589492559, -0.0424126498401165, 0.01993134804069996, -0.03358152508735657, 0.023902324959635735, -0.017079586163163185, 0.028604652732610703, -0.017992399632930756, 0.044866982847452164, 0.010550426319241524, 0.005631025414913893, 0.014998300932347775, -0.017865486443042755, 0.11308478564023972, 0.11186712980270386, 0.045079026371240616, -0.04191772639751434, 0.051848333328962326, -0.006522639188915491, 0.017425773665308952, -0.03132810443639755, 0.032509997487068176, 0.03532173112034798, -0.0507262721657753, 0.04793431982398033, 0.05343049392104149, 0.03138679638504982, -0.034509796649217606, 0.0880507305264473, -0.004821786191314459, -0.010852064937353134, 0.02116698957979679, 0.026118364185094833, -0.003928593825548887, -0.02305428497493267, -0.024050412699580193, 0.02146102301776409, -0.00329324952326715, -0.04759586602449417, -0.03216571733355522, -0.019101906567811966, 0.021202271804213524, -0.0019619266968220472, -0.013666925951838493, -0.0013505559181794524, 0.02261931262910366, 0.028350893408060074, -0.019173430278897285, -0.003212998155504465, -0.013817242346704006, -0.025181470438838005, 0.0025178212672472, -0.011514480225741863, -0.0048569063656032085, -0.020610125735402107, -0.00431606313213706, 0.01874677836894989, -0.034918446093797684, -0.05145591124892235, -0.041006073355674744, 0.05762971192598343, 0.00553051196038723, -0.012108306400477886, -0.0022055385634303093, 0.0090234549716115, 0.011930344626307487, -0.07279527187347412, -0.019710956141352654, 0.0066620586439967155, 0.06283140927553177, -0.0011326776584610343, 0.00907339807599783, -0.03207717463374138, -0.000040741910197539255, -0.002852543955668807, 0.03669911250472069, 0.03405691683292389, -0.024776654317975044, -0.008842702955007553, -0.03201437368988991, 0.03903079032897949, 0.025204338133335114, 0.015825508162379265, -0.015337614342570305, -0.003272215835750103, -0.03346697613596916, -0.0024679312482476234, -0.0015045140171423554, -0.002342450898140669, 0.02603057399392128, 0.019323790445923805, -0.03646799549460411, 0.006528697442263365, -0.00678566237911582, 0.030942726880311966, 0.01593952067196369, 0.00756087014451623, -0.005727204028517008, -0.018115025013685226, 0.023022938519716263, 0.04785183444619179, 0.005044490098953247, 0.00677336985245347, -0.025145135819911957, 0.03642291948199272, 0.015060488134622574, -0.042755745351314545, -0.02377685159444809, 0.005665662232786417, -0.01753268390893936, 0.009519442915916443, 0.018552757799625397, 0.051308535039424896, -0.006138553377240896, -0.007884162478148937, -0.02294139750301838, 0.06662020832300186, -0.019733930006623268, -0.028782714158296585, -0.0022372258827090263, -0.03947173058986664, -0.0006063812761567533, -0.0018320456147193909, 0.0015375845832750201, -0.01791834458708763, -0.015857510268688202, -0.02975556254386902, -0.0019516699248924851, 0.013903783634305, -0.005698800552636385, -0.02628486603498459, -0.002791747683659196, -0.009955492801964283, 0.010517971590161324, -0.03366827964782715, -0.0173699501901865, -0.04752214252948761, 0.01982021890580654, -0.00030915610841475427, -0.03385278955101967, -0.01442366000264883, -0.007057846058160067, -0.007841696962714195, -0.026600483804941177, 0.02953888662159443, 0.01922639273107052, -0.022664494812488556, 0.006082417909055948, -0.012893810868263245, 0.015963325276970863, 0.03996846452355385, -0.044955335557460785, -0.013932624831795692, 0.02512294426560402, -0.06196016073226929, -0.025609776377677917, 0.022940855473279953, -0.0074652982875704765, 0.004534161649644375, 0.03471437841653824, 0.0023774737492203712, -0.009695088490843773, 0.02530936524271965, -0.007579662837088108, -0.02909051440656185, -0.004877542611211538, 0.019478943198919296, -0.03783782944083214, 0.01985623687505722, 0.012204568833112717, 0.027538616210222244, -0.012350017204880714, 0.034976210445165634, 0.041842956095933914, 0.013552720658481121, -0.029822269454598427, 0.02505367062985897, -0.009399276226758957, 0.036499228328466415, -0.005674839019775391, -0.0006431326037272811, 0.07094905525445938, 0.032864686101675034, -0.038634952157735825, 0.04602028802037239, -0.01919795572757721, 0.0240386463701725, -0.07545474171638489, -0.009139501489698887, -0.03788265585899353, 0.006578956265002489, 0.017154840752482414, -0.044995132833719254, -0.012940716929733753, -0.01219453476369381, -0.043903425335884094, 0.044844407588243484, -0.012882809154689312, -0.007075846195220947, -0.016883695498108864, 0.007019041571766138, -0.03409530594944954, 0.015209753066301346, 0.03860102966427803, 0.0450265035033226, 0.016461605206131935, 0.013060418888926506, 0.026275720447301865, -0.003395011415705085, -0.018844226375222206, 0.020025771111249924, 0.009011738002300262, -0.05562126263976097, 0.02549884095788002, -0.04016677662730217, -0.08375110477209091, 0.0160566084086895, -0.03602323308587074, 0.016682107001543045, 0.04606984928250313, 0.03336057811975479, -0.010792096145451069, 0.04557572305202484, 0.010384800843894482, -0.0278005413711071, 0.0025702447164803743, -0.016225283965468407, 0.030923835933208466, -0.002255055820569396, -0.020624123513698578, 0.0512612909078598, 0.03580848500132561, -0.0014532931381836534, -0.007661362644284964, -0.0044336640276014805, -0.04202304780483246, -0.02707194909453392, -0.02355312369763851, 0.010739701800048351, 0.005410948768258095, -0.011587667278945446, 0.013721215538680553, -0.016013534739613533, -0.0028846871573477983, 0.02876267395913601, 0.013614216819405556, 0.00028216082137078047, -0.0032356164883822203, -0.0001120052911574021, -0.029380353167653084, 0.013632169924676418, 0.011191685684025288, -0.0105159692466259, -0.061281319707632065, -0.016460787504911423, -0.004520696122199297, -0.02754596807062626, -0.014080027118325233, 0.0024151832330971956, -0.02527204528450966, 0.02400825545191765, -0.018432551994919777, 0.04032658413052559, 0.01447058655321598, -0.012510833330452442, 0.0000018770191445582896, -0.07559245824813843, 0.03429729864001274, 0.016982490196824074, -0.022371875122189522, -0.03140512481331825, 0.0009694312466308475, -0.02230432815849781, 0.034850116819143295, 0.035658158361911774, -0.007649920880794525, 0.007805145811289549, -0.02828303351998329, 0.013933363370597363, 0.00012059444998158142, -0.0345279723405838, 0.05577104911208153, -0.005322618875652552, -0.0005439841770567, -0.02406034618616104, -0.007888147607445717, 0.0008908899617381394, 0.0008561140857636929, 0.028041135519742966, -0.03786753863096237, 0.004573604092001915, 0.0067096250131726265, 0.0152428662404418, 0.056021589785814285, -0.006845001596957445, -0.05599536374211311, 0.03171207010746002, 0.011206702329218388, 0.014105673879384995, 0.04440050199627876, -0.02825748547911644, -0.03893265500664711, 0.021830977872014046, -0.010282650589942932, -0.03453557938337326, 0.014487951062619686, 0.037430644035339355, 0.011212848126888275, -0.06549828499555588, -0.014436808414757252, 0.026548119261860847, -0.03667137771844864, -0.008574296720325947, 0.07163385301828384, 0.032974280416965485, -0.0033530788496136665, 0.023800192400813103, 0.03845619782805443, 0.0035781015176326036, -0.016655515879392624, -0.02396453358232975, -0.012847907841205597, 0.04933708533644676, 0.0268864706158638, 0.008582967333495617, 0.04269499331712723, -0.0326806977391243, 0.005731741897761822, 0.002848608186468482, 0.03714039549231529, -0.03348727151751518, -0.01108064316213131, -0.004534001462161541, -0.013025285676121712, 0.042630087584257126, -0.01952606439590454, -0.014241174794733524, 0.03698307275772095, -0.047475095838308334, -0.03678770735859871, -0.053481560200452805, -0.02685045264661312, -0.013071049004793167, 0.0030213352292776108, 0.03904144838452339, 0.04110666736960411, 0.01156981848180294, 0.01934109255671501, -0.02724834345281124, -0.028612881898880005, 0.01834464818239212, -0.019777970388531685, 0.012856299057602882, -0.05218689516186714, -0.006646763067692518, 0.024564510211348534, -0.006642590276896954, -0.028591323643922806, -0.039201244711875916, 0.005526601802557707, 0.05675259977579117, 0.02877635695040226, -0.011482921428978443, -0.005913360044360161, -0.015496371313929558, 0.04643947631120682, -0.05642864480614662, -0.011701486073434353, -0.020787790417671204, 0.020587129518389702, 0.03692841902375221, -0.0031404553446918726 ]
<p>I've known that, in orthogonal rotation, if the rotation matrix has determinant of -1 then reflection is present. Otherwise the determinant is +1 and we have pure rotation. May I extend this "sign-of-determinant" rule for non-orthogonal rotations? Such as orthogonal-into-oblique axes or oblique-into-orthogonal axes rotations? For example, this matrix</p> <pre><code> .9427 .2544 .1665 .1377 -.0451 -.0902 -.9940 -.0421 .3325 .3900 .1600 .8437 .4052 .8702 .2269 .1644 </code></pre> <p>is an oblique-to-orthogonal rotation (I think, because sums of squares in rows, not in columns, are 1). Its determinant is -0.524. May I state that the rotation contains a reflection? Thanks in advance.</p>
73,655
[ -0.03247947245836258, -0.017035819590091705, -0.047665707767009735, 0.0002552469668444246, 0.047864772379398346, 0.03364818915724754, -0.0374395027756691, -0.019010473042726517, 0.0023309187963604927, -0.07519111782312393, -0.005019537638872862, 0.0382610559463501, 0.04357697814702988, 0.052261609584093094, 0.012813582085072994, -0.024440474808216095, -0.033790472894907, -0.000056729935749899596, -0.01859944686293602, -0.02926218882203102, 0.041086990386247635, 0.008681817911565304, 0.0243731290102005, -0.005325804930180311, -0.020884286612272263, 0.032619722187519073, 0.023089097812771797, -0.021474137902259827, 0.03397729620337486, 0.05210301652550697, -0.014280435629189014, -0.0008182055898942053, 0.051190540194511414, 0.045598968863487244, -0.0005141747533343732, 0.0129530169069767, 0.0010454555740579963, 0.020609214901924133, -0.016781404614448547, -0.003017870942130685, -0.004747278522700071, -0.0018526558997109532, -0.04327622428536415, 0.05267932638525963, 0.02573598362505436, 0.01879347488284111, -0.03439721837639809, 0.018918709829449654, 0.02526627853512764, -0.064534492790699, 0.09662377834320068, -0.008905185386538506, 0.02714282087981701, -0.0034993321169167757, 0.010051757097244263, -0.013313429430127144, 0.06695326417684555, 0.04852912575006485, -0.007942542433738708, 0.002437232295051217, -0.03736015036702156, -0.04592956230044365, 0.010479510761797428, -0.014274012297391891, -0.03290601074695587, -0.012983880937099457, -0.0009461906156502664, -0.035833895206451416, 0.04948815703392029, -0.02244478277862072, 0.0023188511840999126, 0.03633194789290428, 0.005624114535748959, -0.07941211014986038, -0.0055454266257584095, -0.02216777577996254, 0.034164976328611374, -0.00555829331278801, 0.005502046551555395, 0.0051445732824504375, 0.008653374388813972, 0.005797161255031824, 0.04722379520535469, 0.013385839760303497, 0.02466379478573799, -0.005651314742863178, 0.06703049689531326, -0.019085321575403214, 0.030219348147511482, 0.025541141629219055, 0.025060784071683884, -0.014098962768912315, 0.007509232498705387, 0.00577078852802515, -0.04018295928835869, 0.0021568527445197105, -0.005988797172904015, 0.05243690311908722, -0.003825910622254014, -0.03142074868083, -0.052552204579114914, -0.034855496138334274, 0.030365122482180595, 0.04244352504611015, -0.02713203802704811, 0.01786113902926445, -0.024563508108258247, 0.04117220640182495, -0.02574768289923668, -0.03678120672702789, 0.024365950375795364, 0.02993919514119625, -0.01700543239712715, -0.013047337532043457, 0.0009024444152601063, -0.03144143521785736, -0.009229947812855244, 0.020812755450606346, 0.021590914577245712, 0.08453214168548584, 0.05181926116347313, -0.00857642013579607, 0.012233446352183819, -0.04622519761323929, -0.09566375613212585, 0.0017555399099364877, 0.025343578308820724, -0.0060805692337453365, -0.04142914339900017, 0.03689233586192131, 0.02432745136320591, -0.0483277402818203, 0.003071283921599388, -0.004910834599286318, 0.056142158806324005, -0.033172763884067535, -0.08481898903846741, -0.04572990536689758, 0.0647953525185585, -0.004970251116901636, -0.02071588672697544, -0.07133344560861588, -0.0056953453458845615, 0.05093013122677803, 0.08335836231708527, 0.003752708900719881, 0.00336537160910666, 0.011881230399012566, 0.022295020520687103, -0.0037719516549259424, -0.03941752761602402, -0.008779640309512615, -0.0210773553699255, -0.07175136357545853, -0.011703670024871826, -0.04987090826034546, 0.0390615276992321, 0.04603036493062973, -0.022708259522914886, -0.02326817251741886, 0.040187474340200424, -0.0376993827521801, 0.012052538804709911, 0.03315816819667816, -0.04103781655430794, -0.04583362862467766, 0.07705246657133102, -0.008822975680232048, 0.03379088640213013, 0.026080558076500893, -0.012873206287622452, 0.008306695148348808, -0.028444115072488785, 0.0636158362030983, 0.09282255172729492, -0.027344325557351112, -0.0028291172347962856, 0.007636736612766981, 0.03899350389838219, -0.014017227105796337, 0.0008678340818732977, -0.027045026421546936, 0.001712501049041748, -0.010152704082429409, 0.017580721527338028, 0.03976454958319664, -0.014859609305858612, -0.02674434520304203, 0.049141477793455124, -0.05980949476361275, -0.011760774068534374, -0.031151385977864265, 0.03778800740838051, 0.030565224587917328, -0.03753436356782913, 0.023256774991750717, 0.0408371239900589, 0.02945537678897381, -0.010126419365406036, -0.03396441042423248, -0.032699134200811386, 0.013635950163006783, 0.026852132752537727, -0.05264950171113014, -0.011129742488265038, 0.036798980087041855, 0.06507077068090439, -0.008656254969537258, 0.050175391137599945, -0.0316535085439682, -0.0017288870876654983, -0.006137650925666094, -0.004045452922582626, -0.006771586369723082, -0.010081448592245579, 0.007189644500613213, 0.04730953648686409, 0.020955564454197884, -0.009039033204317093, 0.01744169555604458, -0.031698863953351974, 0.0631662979722023, 0.06566690653562546, 0.02612408436834812, 0.015092934481799603, 0.010138722136616707, 0.041555631905794144, 0.01844485104084015, -0.02376936562359333, -0.013364036567509174, -0.01334777195006609, -0.0030468576587736607, 0.05351001396775246, 0.018437478691339493, -0.10881759971380234, 0.015203125774860382, 0.05502473935484886, 0.018192443996667862, 0.013067643158137798, 0.03865434229373932, -0.023356668651103973, -0.026986006647348404, -0.029486946761608124, 0.016979416832327843, 0.014228833839297295, 0.017314517870545387, 0.007452062796801329, 0.008572683669626713, 0.0037916842848062515, 0.02460997924208641, -0.05300944671034813, 0.020328480750322342, -0.004186715930700302, 0.039258915930986404, -0.002895059296861291, -0.010343457572162151, 0.04726676642894745, 0.021304473280906677, 0.009307950735092163, 0.007707182317972183, -0.024383053183555603, 0.008988184854388237, -0.011512274853885174, -0.00045679276809096336, -0.016378378495573997, 0.007395945023745298, -0.029600057750940323, -0.017894597724080086, 0.0271215308457613, -0.03368254750967026, 0.01905135251581669, -0.0414617620408535, -0.02261902205646038, -0.008547552861273289, 0.01924634911119938, 0.020922064781188965, 0.017450138926506042, 0.0063086035661399364, -0.031244460493326187, -0.021229488775134087, -0.027637707069516182, -0.024565517902374268, 0.004690301138907671, 0.008352925069630146, -0.05195995420217514, 0.0064580366015434265, -0.0631282702088356, -0.025653144344687462, 0.05147847533226013, 0.010056555271148682, -0.006529882550239563, 0.0005350567516870797, 0.015071272850036621, -0.04409159719944, -0.03788403049111366, -0.04610243812203407, 0.003964897710829973, -0.04495451971888542, -0.020738163962960243, 0.034484077244997025, -0.0007351557142101228, -0.045872822403907776, 0.0027439340483397245, -0.02673407830297947, -0.05418523773550987, -0.003754015313461423, -0.008251179940998554, 0.06720448285341263, -0.0249312836676836, 0.026589129120111465, 0.0030399304814636707, -0.023906923830509186, 0.021109063178300858, -0.024709057062864304, -0.04468201473355293, 0.010769776068627834, 0.006668430287390947, 0.03930801898241043, 0.049097996205091476, -0.04078109189867973, 0.050390906631946564, 0.027076683938503265, -0.0335518904030323, -0.0456523522734642, -0.025676164776086807, -0.014247325249016285, -0.042467307299375534, -0.0038144278805702925, 0.01016352791339159, 0.0006405931198969483, 0.06620174646377563, -0.006111667491495609, 0.009107866324484348, 0.03607946261763573, -0.0029243614990264177, -0.019889168441295624, 0.04058995842933655, -0.004065508488565683, -0.015110459178686142, 0.009134406223893166, -0.0050522987730801105, -0.04306110739707947, 0.006738011259585619, 0.02572374790906906, 0.008953869342803955, 0.011069157160818577, -0.05209832265973091, 0.02570212446153164, -0.003112086793407798, 0.033599771559238434, 0.0044925943948328495, 0.05397181957960129, -0.014762911014258862, 0.015991171821951866, 0.0092959338799119, 0.04308788478374481, 0.01695573516190052, -0.012995606288313866, -0.00022666141740046442, 0.029684819281101227, 0.0013538862112909555, 0.005811986047774553, 0.019108541309833527, -0.0019158862996846437, -0.025989187881350517, 0.052252158522605896, -0.04751577600836754, -0.02775927260518074, 0.050022851675748825, 0.021544504910707474, 0.02506764605641365, 0.03806041553616524, -0.02848934382200241, 0.04196234792470932, -0.01574489288032055, -0.004746511112898588, 0.0008711458649486303, 0.030449485406279564, -0.02382570318877697, 0.009516405873000622, 0.030970318242907524, -0.010991507209837437, -0.020750531926751137, 0.013377798721194267, -0.06528862565755844, 0.03791190683841705, 0.005374391097575426, -0.020673107355833054, 0.0024258489720523357, 0.019877620041370392, 0.012916686944663525, -0.03828513249754906, -0.01369762048125267, 0.007253736723214388, -0.032629892230033875, -0.06283103674650192, 0.03997160866856575, -0.018717430531978607, 0.006649424321949482, -0.044969458132982254, 0.023282703012228012, 0.05084008350968361, -0.01209627091884613, 0.026364365592598915, 0.027603674679994583, -0.051111336797475815, -0.003957569133490324, -0.00633027171716094, 0.053714241832494736, 0.005122098606079817, 0.02628157287836075, 0.04368819296360016, -0.004747719503939152, -0.00005256406439002603, 0.022859852761030197, -0.023449379950761795, 0.04463478922843933, -0.007699079345911741, -0.03528622165322304, -0.016468262299895287, -0.034146711230278015, -0.018166903406381607, -0.032300159335136414, 0.05500064045190811, -0.04164217785000801, 0.00018596512381918728, 0.027410952374339104, 0.015498629771173, -0.028827322646975517, 0.04902995005249977, 0.111033134162426, 0.06350938975811005, -0.014261003583669662, -0.02905719354748726, -0.004400201607495546, 0.011638789437711239, 0.007088097278028727, -0.009725866839289665, 0.00004847268428420648, 0.0045613134279847145, -0.012602891772985458, -0.004615917336195707, -0.0043173315934836864, 0.007769445423036814, 0.024142807349562645, -0.003317787777632475, 0.035404521971940994, -0.01303897239267826, 0.019222227856516838, 0.02179744467139244, 0.032705582678318024, 0.049986373633146286, 0.020880788564682007, -0.017087357118725777, -0.06516508013010025, 0.0015938050346449018, 0.04674268141388893, 0.07104749977588654, 0.02685205638408661, 0.0034677947405725718, -0.02954159863293171, -0.02967074140906334, 0.051896993070840836, -0.030597766861319542, 0.044132497161626816, -0.00546357873827219, 0.011090044863522053, -0.022178342565894127, -0.009240806102752686, -0.03406907990574837, 0.03949357569217682, -0.010450439527630806, 0.028140326961874962, -0.035950638353824615, -0.001551200868561864, -0.047135114669799805, -0.004937540274113417, 0.004101113881915808, 0.011736382730305195, 0.003542977152392268, -0.01797047071158886, -0.0300610214471817, 0.05296652764081955, -0.04268265515565872, -0.06563283503055573, 0.022170303389430046, 0.03370086848735809, -0.011039447970688343, 0.048023730516433716, -0.03471548482775688, -0.009786040522158146, -0.006574188359081745, -0.020059816539287567, 0.019206129014492035, 0.00992413517087698, -0.03914632275700569, 0.036174558103084564, 0.01255717035382986, -0.03891841694712639, 0.022249562665820122, 0.03904501721262932, 0.00879646372050047, -0.025044208392500877, -0.019565848633646965, 0.03660186007618904, -0.027224615216255188, -0.028517913073301315, -0.0430586040019989, 0.024654801934957504, -0.01951494999229908, 0.046494148671627045, -0.0014193713432177901, 0.013838865794241428, 0.010282948613166809, -0.005181675776839256, -0.033386509865522385, 0.04884917661547661, -0.011762467212975025, -0.015716364607214928, 0.012942635454237461, 0.028709258884191513, -0.0026017571799457073, -0.04843449220061302, 0.008466499857604504, -0.03932316601276398, -0.000635674805380404, 0.021794861182570457, 0.02407950907945633, 0.021707724779844284, -0.017897609621286392, 0.012159435078501701, -0.010282895527780056, -0.029157716780900955, 0.017209699377417564, -0.013773292303085327, 0.032727379351854324, 0.04306710511445999, -0.05076926201581955, 0.05393889546394348, 0.043106142431497574, -0.0019278210820630193, 0.02699876017868519, -0.05576523393392563, 0.015200672671198845, -0.015340559184551239, 0.017697032541036606, -0.042193375527858734, -0.06935436278581619, -0.02391018532216549, 0.027662744745612144, -0.021815717220306396, -0.028387829661369324, -0.04348847270011902, -0.02017507143318653, -0.05585580691695213, 0.011954572051763535, 0.03550325334072113, -0.034018516540527344, 0.011179761029779911, 0.06135297939181328, 0.005090934224426746, 0.07984784245491028, -0.03662779554724693, -0.020797522738575935, 0.035406891256570816, -0.0339985229074955, -0.0027889872435480356, 0.028101181611418724, 0.07525014132261276, -0.027208421379327774, -0.035803213715553284, -0.041411373764276505, -0.006558863911777735, 0.030876506119966507, -0.027964141219854355, -0.004421581048518419, -0.01168900728225708, -0.029231956228613853, 0.027348725125193596, -0.030909288674592972, 0.02297566644847393, -0.017185529693961143, 0.04313473030924797, 0.014326867647469044, 0.014191312715411186, -0.014780467376112938, -0.032156385481357574, -0.013147439807653427, 0.022397328168153763, 0.03222394362092018, 0.014848948456346989, 0.0376514308154583, -0.03131559118628502, -0.006515216547995806, 0.002811332466080785, -0.00429798336699605, 0.028860487043857574, 0.017491372302174568, 0.0168593842536211, 0.00015249547141138464, 0.021392492577433586, -0.02164888009428978, -0.05746781826019287, -0.014113352634012699, 0.005491780117154121, 0.0761822983622551, 0.0011001995299011469, 0.04281039535999298, 0.029450280591845512, 0.00612800195813179, -0.033699728548526764, 0.01678725704550743, 0.018360931426286697, -0.0020348241087049246, 0.004219852853566408, 0.03762008249759674, -0.035103484988212585, 0.01596582494676113, -0.00033045175950974226, 0.032779864966869354, 0.0018599584000185132, 0.002819312736392021, 0.012854991480708122, 0.013071110472083092, 0.013343705795705318, 0.043505117297172546, -0.04561164230108261, 0.01601340062916279, -0.04645757004618645, 0.03644382208585739, -0.007848890498280525, -0.027446208521723747, 0.033109307289123535, 0.038575056940317154, 0.012308952398598194, -0.022529806941747665, -0.016117310151457787, -0.06717546284198761, 0.0030861126724630594, -0.014891067519783974, 0.011231614276766777, -0.026900090277194977, -0.02103034406900406, 0.05414219945669174, -0.002501352457329631, 0.012086845003068447, -0.034494638442993164, -0.05199423059821129, -0.03912167623639107, -0.037835221737623215, -0.035335078835487366, 0.03353020176291466, -0.006070109084248543, -0.001717647654004395, 0.003396078711375594, -0.013968298211693764, 0.009538982063531876, 0.03274451568722725, 0.06987107545137405, -0.007255800999701023, 0.03835497424006462, 0.02183128148317337, 0.03568790853023529, -0.008397947996854782, -0.032227080315351486, 0.12382268905639648, 0.07821911573410034, 0.00746600516140461, -0.06805328279733658, 0.04384420067071915, -0.015960710123181343, -0.005946027580648661, -0.03391653299331665, 0.004046777728945017, 0.01037132553756237, 0.0051851412281394005, -0.005397091619670391, 0.05835575610399246, 0.006478139199316502, -0.027924329042434692, 0.020722417160868645, -0.04588877782225609, -0.043247949331998825, -0.0074272798374295235, 0.04003911465406418, -0.03143958002328873, 0.022021019831299782, -0.05926879122853279, 0.005679645575582981, -0.00790804997086525, -0.030025774613022804, -0.030785037204623222, -0.03860320523381233, -0.0067488327622413635, 0.015510983765125275, 0.013117455877363682, 0.0188058502972126, 0.03466028347611427, -0.015471383929252625, -0.03649650886654854, 0.02726195566356182, -0.0018048126948997378, -0.02500905841588974, 0.04403393715620041, 0.03404897823929787, 0.03081989288330078, -0.016320200636982918, 0.014470656402409077, -0.015104171819984913, -0.044145647436380386, 0.023124748840928078, -0.0020761683117598295, 0.012420625425875187, -0.009581485763192177, 0.0036134100519120693, -0.00039838405791670084, -0.001019362243823707, 0.02562282606959343, -0.09061452746391296, -0.017258893698453903, -0.019986677914857864, 0.03369396924972534, -0.007739810273051262, -0.039147403091192245, -0.0033098843414336443, 0.025588087737560272, 0.00048690641415305436, 0.006468651816248894, -0.002045496366918087, -0.043780356645584106, 0.0013762968592345715, 0.008669689297676086, 0.0434417761862278, -0.013986424542963505, -0.003858498763293028, -0.018387215211987495, 0.010570956394076347, -0.03641228750348091, -0.011540614068508148, 0.002888299524784088, -0.011531130410730839, 0.04323430359363556, -0.0010303589515388012, -0.019001811742782593, 0.027875350788235664, -0.062336161732673645, 0.01083808671683073, -0.06046789884567261, -0.033832699060440063, -0.02713777683675289, 0.012710101902484894, 0.058654576539993286, 0.009355931542813778, -0.042121246457099915, -0.015693461522459984, 0.006781699135899544, 0.04487663879990578, -0.0012051088269799948, 0.007347673177719116, -0.050046056509017944, 0.008021578192710876, -0.01082021277397871, 0.004716589581221342, -0.03763243556022644, 0.04351523518562317, 0.05227568745613098, 0.04658941924571991, -0.012681392021477222, 0.02045447938144207, -0.010802709497511387, -0.018888145685195923, -0.02537868358194828, -0.04293465241789818, -0.0160279031842947, 0.001224205712787807, -0.03656438738107681, -0.03230525180697441, -0.022093771025538445, -0.031708791851997375, -0.010716371238231659, 0.013473073951900005, 0.02846635691821575, -0.06670749932527542, -0.01795116253197193, -0.0632053017616272, 0.015205439180135727, -0.026653984561562538, -0.03812330588698387, 0.01036140974611044, 0.009843815118074417, 0.02401464246213436, -0.008197207003831863, -0.007047878112643957, 0.019167305901646614, 0.004061378538608551, -0.008543306961655617, 0.04721502959728241, 0.04919099435210228, 0.007823081687092781, -0.021030228585004807, 0.021022407338023186, -0.03745928406715393, 0.053893763571977615, -0.014603168703615665, -0.014737107791006565, 0.0597572885453701, -0.03552908077836037, -0.02457617223262787, 0.04122469574213028, -0.05054236948490143, 0.019579391926527023, 0.02740965224802494, 0.0008636616403236985, -0.002320685423910618, 0.0268032718449831, -0.002114352770149708, -0.014335287734866142, 0.018192080780863762, -0.019114410504698753, -0.0022574400063604116, -0.013009295798838139, 0.027275286614894867, -0.032040804624557495, -0.017373742535710335, 0.009211257100105286, 0.03332557529211044, -0.047094400972127914, -0.00969617161899805, -0.004732340108603239, 0.009633607231080532, -0.016339058056473732, 0.025269607082009315, -0.026742208749055862, 0.014512719586491585, 0.04318904131650925, -0.013040394522249699, 0.02917070873081684, -0.002884513698518276, 0.001269761472940445, -0.038421668112277985, -0.0022418934386223555, 0.025952793657779694, 0.013559577986598015, 0.03583228960633278, -0.06094770133495331, 0.007490831892937422, 0.013000214472413063, -0.07143532484769821, 0.003973149694502354, -0.034584950655698776, -0.024394484236836433, -0.02602129802107811, -0.020981308072805405, 0.021837010979652405, 0.025132132694125175, 0.009614694863557816, 0.026592236012220383, 0.05531720444560051, 0.0009768784511834383, -0.01548135094344616, -0.023615222424268723, -0.019310111179947853, -0.003843914717435837, -0.03411517292261124, -0.0334286168217659, 0.031116630882024765, -0.013401120901107788, -0.03729478269815445, 0.017250964418053627, -0.042329274117946625, -0.011124193668365479, 0.012470889836549759, 0.01024378277361393, 0.011842108331620693, 0.0221260916441679, -0.0032355531584471464, -0.009761546738445759, -0.03253761678934097, 0.0043725320138037205, 0.01277491170912981, 0.026200372725725174, -0.04988087713718414, 0.02758537232875824, -0.03783496096730232, -0.05510925129055977, -0.031582243740558624, -0.010875294916331768, -0.020408067852258682, -0.0049580722115933895, -0.02075357362627983, -0.008417248725891113, 0.0046847970224916935, -0.0003205081738997251, 0.043480176478624344, -0.02734498679637909, 0.020276816561818123, 0.03192734718322754, -0.0059815747663378716, 0.020642496645450592, 0.02284560725092888, 0.001314168912358582, -0.06195460259914398, 0.03405417501926422, -0.0023376434110105038, -0.021080370992422104, -0.04650156572461128, -0.018307264894247055, 0.00752078415825963, -0.033532992005348206, -0.014604700729250908, -0.006508645135909319, -0.005371033679693937, 0.04660908505320549, -0.004726557992398739, 0.005942828953266144, 0.0036264790687710047, -0.021040745079517365, -0.0411648154258728, -0.05020296201109886, 0.020000681281089783, 0.019985556602478027, -0.018701501190662384, -0.03874959051609039, -0.009079137817025185, -0.03246248885989189, 0.03153938800096512, 0.05455956980586052, 0.01945711113512516, 0.005882989149540663, -0.023763684555888176, 0.01757284626364708, 0.016360783949494362, -0.017974907532334328, 0.026397667825222015, -0.02867896668612957, -0.028962841257452965, 0.008452330715954304, -0.030718788504600525, -0.019444983452558517, -0.0007941226358525455, -0.004699204117059708, -0.012420718558132648, -0.036778539419174194, -0.015964623540639877, -0.0301981084048748, 0.057791873812675476, 0.0020374429877847433, -0.0035559278912842274, 0.04023414105176926, 0.0036752631422132254, -0.006192215718328953, 0.06217456981539726, -0.018962973728775978, -0.02235916443169117, 0.02004408650100231, -0.058868978172540665, -0.03282435983419418, 0.006486165337264538, 0.000010950178875646088, 0.0615929514169693, -0.02912549488246441, 0.012307497672736645, 0.04021283984184265, -0.024086754769086838, -0.001861158525571227, 0.040621913969516754, 0.011540751904249191, 0.03067622520029545, -0.00401290412992239, 0.051059599965810776, 0.03182647004723549, -0.02338828705251217, 0.03369736671447754, 0.0450592078268528, 0.009110353887081146, -0.024095438420772552, -0.0007711764192208648, 0.002451125532388687, 0.01237676665186882, 0.0458533838391304, 0.01634909212589264, 0.053284186869859695, -0.0028841542080044746, 0.018352720886468887, 0.027040094137191772, -0.040787696838378906, 0.013750276528298855, 0.001364136696793139, -0.0362057201564312, 0.04879814013838768, -0.010639184154570103, 0.03677694872021675, -0.027438150718808174, -0.005470508709549904, -0.030322005972266197, -0.032312266528606415, 0.029198896139860153, 0.03969043865799904, -0.034972548484802246, -0.021327044814825058, 0.010670188814401627, -0.023055758327245712, -0.003441272070631385, -0.026857638731598854, 0.0664047822356224, -0.018537068739533424, 0.029552234336733818, 0.014920766465365887, -0.007054426241666079, -0.0046395193785429, 0.0018163600470870733, 0.003953369800001383, 0.017197666689753532, 0.06417674571275711, -0.015638550743460655, -0.012635069899260998, 0.011668264865875244, 0.01125405915081501, -0.03172646090388298, -0.029598375782370567, -0.010248425416648388, 0.055794551968574524, 0.01577400416135788, 0.010383465327322483 ]
<p>Suppose I have a random symmetric matrix W of size $n\times n$, with i.i.d. coefficients uniformly distributed in [0,1], and I set $W_{ii} = 0$.</p> <p>Then I apply a Multidimensional Scaling of dimension $k$, which I define as minimizing the quantity: $H=n^{-2}\sum_{i,j} (W_{ij} - ||x_i-x_j||^2)^2$ with respect to the $n$ points $x_i \in R^k$. Say I denote $H^*$ the minimum.</p> <p>The question is : what is the behavior of $\mathbb{E}[H^*]$ as a function of $k$ and $n$ ?</p> <p>Is there a mathematical article out there dealing with this question ? or is it an open question ?</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
73,656
[ -0.02950255386531353, -0.028840186074376106, 0.017558827996253967, -0.04395749792456627, 0.024815894663333893, 0.009892440401017666, -0.034357208758592606, -0.047158803790807724, 0.01119457557797432, -0.07068701833486557, 0.0156326275318861, 0.010184383019804955, 0.05990438163280487, 0.0028618292417377234, 0.025278573855757713, -0.00838223285973072, -0.07650595158338547, -0.018704932183027267, -0.025694871321320534, 0.011970564723014832, 0.0050866734236478806, 0.040782712399959564, 0.017275510355830193, -0.048900213092565536, -0.05520523339509964, -0.009725749492645264, 0.02355632372200489, -0.01529100351035595, 0.0031053374987095594, 0.07535844296216965, -0.061898138374090195, -0.006190810352563858, 0.019022449851036072, 0.04117867723107338, 0.007671512197703123, 0.012887346558272839, -0.05621584877371788, -0.02039000391960144, 0.008892023004591465, 0.002834182232618332, -0.02823738381266594, -0.03264431655406952, 0.0018488448113203049, 0.012183204293251038, 0.007356454152613878, 0.05179007351398468, -0.001495466334745288, -0.06354997307062149, 0.02956152707338333, -0.047514043748378754, 0.0995686799287796, 0.02297712303698063, -0.01471392996609211, -0.012937730178236961, -0.024296946823596954, 0.02322862297296524, 0.016579067334532738, 0.04437077417969704, 0.04512353613972664, -0.016673970967531204, 0.00769759388640523, -0.007456130813807249, 0.004749653395265341, -0.01055107731372118, -0.029214968904852867, 0.03182566538453102, 0.00035750516690313816, -0.009281267412006855, 0.024086367338895798, 0.0030080426950007677, -0.04872245341539383, 0.027769818902015686, 0.027922019362449646, -0.01758270151913166, 0.025606069713830948, 0.017499186098575592, 0.026657527312636375, 0.04264436289668083, 0.026527591049671173, -0.004657346289604902, 0.031734880059957504, 0.007377067115157843, 0.0035139708779752254, 0.05169204995036125, -0.007286169100552797, 0.014575036242604256, 0.058997057378292084, -0.038285333663225174, 0.02938534878194332, 0.03417953848838806, 0.00020109544857405126, -0.003272821195423603, 0.037974219769239426, -0.015082396566867828, -0.028680894523859024, 0.029418425634503365, -0.009220157749950886, 0.013505283743143082, 0.021739916875958443, -0.030933599919080734, 0.0033733658492565155, -0.03231289982795715, -0.013918805867433548, 0.0377940833568573, -0.014827278442680836, -0.008220693096518517, -0.034397441893815994, 0.0024503422901034355, -0.052023012191057205, -0.0005888852174393833, -0.006220647599548101, -0.004231493454426527, 0.013809707947075367, -0.0186538677662611, 0.05321679264307022, 0.0069632986560463905, 0.0035734691191464663, 0.013677907176315784, 0.023920360952615738, 0.056598350405693054, 0.002342202700674534, -0.0003605461970437318, 0.025569042190909386, -0.060926277190446854, -0.05460386723279953, 0.028727229684591293, 0.01107052993029356, -0.017233366146683693, -0.05024639889597893, 0.014914898201823235, 0.014420965686440468, 0.021129628643393517, 0.04384865611791611, 0.002194063737988472, 0.009447762742638588, -0.011072385124862194, -0.0832834541797638, -0.05426768958568573, 0.03146839514374733, -0.016617391258478165, 0.03673264756798744, -0.043839551508426666, -0.04285121336579323, 0.03050798922777176, 0.05742416903376579, 0.004889613017439842, 0.04487728700041771, 0.015039005316793919, 0.05586284399032593, -0.003513137809932232, -0.027091842144727707, -0.0371130146086216, -0.024956850335001945, -0.015183262526988983, 0.02718990668654442, -0.07720012962818146, 0.0006146538653410971, 0.050318438559770584, -0.002591873984783888, 0.01742849312722683, 0.040927473455667496, 0.02125733718276024, -0.009734787978231907, 0.015748923644423485, -0.004184997174888849, -0.020909132435917854, 0.03413425013422966, 0.020064612850546837, 0.04030562937259674, -0.020534193143248558, -0.02036522515118122, 0.011249254457652569, -0.01499997079372406, 0.06776189804077148, 0.0637163370847702, -0.01917610876262188, 0.006827566772699356, -0.0009321586112491786, 0.041381921619176865, 0.022054044529795647, -0.03966566175222397, -0.025225063785910606, -0.006978803779929876, 0.021360186859965324, 0.01696251891553402, 0.020195288583636284, -0.012829414568841457, -0.019820397719740868, 0.0007759146974422038, -0.02581830322742462, -0.0026144536677747965, -0.029894554987549782, -0.00622388394549489, 0.05987901985645294, -0.0467001348733902, 0.09222143888473511, -0.011996963992714882, -0.013046768493950367, -0.007371959276497364, -0.009077475406229496, 0.008742011152207851, -0.010324819013476372, 0.028094641864299774, -0.0031865614000707865, 0.023109665140509605, 0.044361744076013565, 0.06670980155467987, 0.0152930011972785, 0.07326573878526688, -0.027988426387310028, -0.06446979939937592, -0.03019723668694496, -0.009228752925992012, 0.014600723050534725, 0.018163664266467094, 0.015901392325758934, 0.006588640622794628, -0.031489297747612, 0.018090462312102318, -0.017555663362145424, -0.054578013718128204, 0.016309458762407303, 0.04776201769709587, -0.0006834574742242694, -0.006810350343585014, 0.02784007415175438, 0.025721417739987373, 0.006764460355043411, 0.0073286499828100204, -0.040954459458589554, -0.04427746683359146, 0.03574375808238983, 0.023442139849066734, 0.08407995849847794, -0.07144836336374283, -0.018141569569706917, 0.040780212730169296, 0.023107970133423805, 0.02213078737258911, 0.011372500099241734, -0.01889943890273571, -0.014431074261665344, 0.02510034292936325, -0.011029841378331184, 0.0030684128869324923, 0.006404582876712084, -0.019428692758083344, 0.003464343259111047, 0.03103002719581127, -0.023261239752173424, -0.017663534730672836, 0.051786601543426514, -0.0003253846662119031, 0.0022415334824472666, -0.014217237010598183, -0.0051085855811834335, 0.027698632329702377, -0.022498086094856262, -0.006163561716675758, 0.05161725729703903, -0.0025757967960089445, 0.011549759656190872, -0.029553759843111038, -0.012137672863900661, 0.039585504680871964, 0.0004208032914903015, -0.00813317857682705, -0.00657701538875699, 0.028427837416529655, -0.02681341953575611, 0.02614510990679264, -0.03979382663965225, -0.0349401980638504, -0.023567218333482742, -0.00500428956001997, 0.05212577059864998, -0.013856394216418266, -0.031949568539857864, -0.029215507209300995, 0.005966337863355875, -0.01666947640478611, -0.02192997746169567, 0.019046980887651443, 0.01799258589744568, -0.001473372452892363, -0.019143326207995415, -0.055184587836265564, 0.042740944772958755, 0.026590541005134583, -0.027704138308763504, -8.287113359983778e-7, 0.01868543028831482, -0.003723606001585722, -0.02523202821612358, 0.0023180809803307056, -0.014293283224105835, 0.017092429101467133, -0.058679476380348206, -0.0015159378526732326, 0.05773923173546791, 0.004040455911308527, -0.03192565217614174, 0.03345306217670441, -0.0035483178216964006, -0.03982296586036682, -0.06714468449354172, -0.024604959413409233, 0.03954809904098511, -0.034100811928510666, -0.007090530823916197, 0.04760756716132164, -0.003320590825751424, 0.002464188262820244, -0.07059616595506668, -0.05234353616833687, 0.02952612191438675, -0.06592438369989395, 0.06352294981479645, -0.007375871296972036, -0.03994591534137726, 0.08738943934440613, 0.0411314032971859, 0.003447915194556117, -0.01916038617491722, 0.0038367307279258966, -0.045704204589128494, -0.026812629774212837, 0.0201728418469429, 0.03121226094663143, 0.013363240286707878, 0.04749714210629463, -0.011116758920252323, 0.013622177764773369, 0.03932221233844757, -0.01847410947084427, -0.048469506204128265, 0.01321092527359724, 0.0020691175013780594, -0.019693823531270027, 0.016082284972071648, 0.02323814667761326, -0.022563695907592773, 0.006046845577657223, 0.03436417132616043, 0.03664574772119522, 0.03707718104124069, -0.03371333330869675, 0.0005147521151229739, -0.04196719452738762, 0.004077771212905645, -0.024624260142445564, 0.0362907312810421, 0.005344537552446127, -0.007439735345542431, -0.037466518580913544, 0.00480804406106472, -0.0020869546569883823, -0.004876652732491493, 0.020959237590432167, 0.02894464321434498, 0.03892773762345314, -0.005667159333825111, 0.0022022705525159836, -0.02452288195490837, 0.01399267092347145, 0.00889078713953495, -0.0280623659491539, -0.05159931629896164, 0.034831464290618896, 0.009188155643641949, 0.004250307567417622, 0.009679767303168774, -0.06026681140065193, 0.01709936372935772, -0.048254966735839844, -0.012610935606062412, -0.018412169069051743, 0.05080571398139, -0.02010495774447918, 0.007016235496848822, 0.015125477686524391, 0.0027399652171880007, -0.002325706882402301, -0.0012731251772493124, -0.06715045869350433, -0.004997358191758394, -0.056423369795084, 0.02008015289902687, -0.001185157336294651, -0.024722851812839508, 0.03687817230820656, -0.008568397723138332, -0.0025798152200877666, 0.015388889238238335, 0.06254664808511734, -0.02583310939371586, 0.00016734201926738024, -0.009245996363461018, -0.0459681935608387, -0.015509739518165588, 0.020125336945056915, 0.07619450986385345, -0.02458754926919937, 0.024991462007164955, 0.017062978819012642, -0.01515137404203415, 0.01281261071562767, 0.000651416543405503, 0.04622442647814751, -0.0036287284456193447, 0.031507708132267, -0.023033099249005318, 0.021987229585647583, 0.0102327736094594, 0.04032402113080025, -0.0026880961377173662, 0.030350739136338234, 0.012025081552565098, 0.0008005661657080054, 0.04763590171933174, -0.046768032014369965, -0.0378972664475441, -0.01274117361754179, 0.021308738738298416, -0.008219161070883274, 0.000018921660739579238, 0.01805572770535946, 0.04016942158341408, -0.05836044251918793, -0.008927670307457447, 0.05903337895870209, 0.023644568398594856, 0.0008133508963510394, -0.04515624791383743, -0.025112783536314964, 0.010982029139995575, 0.03306431323289871, 0.005305141676217318, -0.04040275886654854, -0.01955694705247879, -0.006562508177012205, 0.04125143215060234, 0.0009779112879186869, -0.014107012189924717, -0.0030783875845372677, 0.012743355706334114, 0.017688989639282227, -0.02517104521393776, 0.010929098352789879, 0.022147096693515778, 0.007546708919107914, 0.03889939561486244, 0.026908811181783676, 0.008202442899346352, -0.0361332930624485, -0.018598178401589394, 0.025056660175323486, 0.017956567928195, -0.0005732115241698921, 0.005914431530982256, -0.04807081073522568, -0.008019956760108471, 0.05203371122479439, -0.008773138746619225, 0.036306437104940414, 0.02816847711801529, -0.016175299882888794, -0.009786797687411308, 0.024106115102767944, -0.03702997416257858, 0.003721710294485092, -0.0009912257082760334, 0.04956604167819023, -0.03104683756828308, -0.018946785479784012, -0.04678940400481224, 0.007397334091365337, 0.049182549118995667, 0.058072902262210846, 0.02313964255154133, -0.00816090777516365, -0.0026021923404186964, 0.01637418568134308, -0.0073590329848229885, -0.06220242753624916, 0.004107562359422445, 0.04028576239943504, -0.024938082322478294, 0.014627346768975258, -0.024637315422296524, -0.009233016520738602, 0.026927879080176353, 0.007498865947127342, -0.020401407033205032, 0.026272054761648178, 0.01230169553309679, 0.057793740183115005, 0.06526853144168854, -0.021540528163313866, 0.054399266839027405, 0.029825981706380844, -0.008463707752525806, 0.010448603890836239, -0.020085975527763367, 0.049685779958963394, -0.017801344394683838, 0.008163859136402607, -0.049431782215833664, -0.007938576862215996, 0.016986535862088203, 0.04355238005518913, -0.006184029392898083, 0.05771336331963539, -0.02504217065870762, -0.0208070557564497, -0.0046551949344575405, 0.025473657995462418, 0.014650309458374977, -0.03386615589261055, 0.035823822021484375, 0.04788539558649063, 0.018959376960992813, -0.03804999589920044, 0.04318350926041603, 0.019363217055797577, -0.016383137553930283, 0.03761046752333641, -0.008328132331371307, 0.006789710372686386, -0.053748223930597305, -0.01751060225069523, -0.008403035812079906, -0.011617655865848064, 0.014375125989317894, -0.035806864500045776, -0.007150895427912474, 0.023859478533267975, -0.029387665912508965, 0.01515375729650259, -0.013011466711759567, -0.011979598551988602, -0.0009337983792647719, -0.017058810219168663, -0.0014963735593482852, 0.026205847039818764, -0.0014584210002794862, -0.06943417340517044, -0.019243286922574043, 0.004135009367018938, 0.009489825926721096, 0.015896398574113846, -0.05481557175517082, -0.0032475311309099197, -0.04192255809903145, -0.03320380672812462, -0.021693997085094452, 0.056690383702516556, -0.020394137129187584, -0.01677422598004341, 0.019210360944271088, 0.013109719380736351, 0.04364139586687088, -0.014923205599188805, -0.01470637135207653, 0.07479020208120346, -0.02546028606593609, 0.006963392253965139, -0.02242363803088665, 0.0699443370103836, -0.029250899329781532, 0.003677194006741047, -0.032562583684921265, -0.02262260764837265, 0.021408511325716972, -0.011144815012812614, -0.015971152111887932, 0.0423283725976944, 0.019172437489032745, 0.03703150525689125, -0.028368806466460228, -0.03934212028980255, -0.016708791255950928, 0.0153864910826087, -0.01080659031867981, -0.04525039345026016, -0.021258339285850525, -0.024298984557390213, 0.0043755387887358665, 0.019273756071925163, -0.009396708570420742, -0.002413112437352538, 0.04294620826840401, -0.04766959324479103, -0.035356368869543076, 0.003986265044659376, -0.0326978825032711, 0.034229714423418045, 0.013829994946718216, -0.028574470430612564, 0.023370996117591858, 0.03736024722456932, -0.03281707316637039, -0.06509274244308472, -0.07583649456501007, 0.05491046607494354, 0.04829082265496254, -0.02980576641857624, 0.03128163889050484, 0.06266216188669205, -0.022534076124429703, -0.02460569329559803, -0.05914323776960373, -0.016373291611671448, -0.02173815481364727, 0.014385868795216084, 0.023937391117215157, -0.015778090804815292, -0.0054611749947071075, 0.055397503077983856, 0.021547336131334305, -0.023203950375318527, 0.025693167001008987, 0.02126067690551281, -0.0006036641425453126, 0.02459418773651123, -0.06733442097902298, -0.06417470425367355, 0.03920763358473778, -0.0524444617331028, -0.01321479957550764, -0.011410110630095005, -0.02292144112288952, 0.022045444697141647, 0.019578425213694572, 0.020335566252470016, -0.012517426162958145, -0.030928632244467735, 0.004454864654690027, 0.016146838665008545, -0.03158079460263252, -0.010661440901458263, 0.011656819842755795, 0.022967906668782234, 0.014385796152055264, 0.002498141722753644, 0.020001405850052834, -0.018437160179018974, -0.04196082800626755, 0.016540629789233208, -0.023578520864248276, -0.050457440316677094, -0.026249945163726807, 0.05089959502220154, -0.01496400311589241, 0.0072046988643705845, -0.04039362818002701, -0.008589132688939571, 0.013569707050919533, 0.03379923850297928, 0.006080238614231348, 0.049456872045993805, 0.04570701718330383, 0.005116750951856375, -0.012128105387091637, -0.00450870580971241, 0.12348983436822891, 0.061353497207164764, 0.015371703542768955, -0.06005161255598068, 0.025591449812054634, 0.009203149005770683, -0.024671006947755814, -0.031117763370275497, 0.0025644670240581036, -0.007498502731323242, -0.02844778262078762, 0.0043053352274000645, 0.04996669664978981, 0.028901482000947, -0.018887445330619812, 0.046803101897239685, -0.039422452449798584, -0.034637026488780975, 0.003013274632394314, -0.036487702280282974, -0.026366833597421646, 0.0156049570068717, -0.050282515585422516, 0.0650179460644722, -0.00349997216835618, -0.025721058249473572, -0.009373904205858707, -0.012590997852385044, -0.033825621008872986, 0.0014232981484383345, -0.03647356852889061, 0.019508754834532738, 0.03757492080330849, -0.005908916238695383, -0.034195274114608765, 0.0093404371291399, 0.03982075676321983, -0.010220046155154705, -0.007770492695271969, 0.0008930635522119701, 0.013401570729911327, 0.01988200470805168, 0.014539077877998352, 0.0009194921585731208, -0.02914094366133213, -0.021920597180724144, -0.04908101633191109, 0.04303595423698425, 0.011244182474911213, -0.0046798414550721645, 0.011777926236391068, -0.028762316331267357, -0.02432980015873909, -0.054840680211782455, 0.009838824160397053, 0.012974603101611137, 0.039467278867959976, -0.010366932488977909, 0.011431100778281689, 0.006592729594558477, 0.050025712698698044, 0.007663078140467405, -0.008384130895137787, 0.04708318039774895, -0.02286376804113388, -0.047902677208185196, -0.011413481086492538, 0.05245637521147728, -0.008925044909119606, -0.012851035222411156, -0.014884615316987038, -0.022543663159012794, 0.015896517783403397, -0.0544823594391346, -0.003287453902885318, -0.01816103234887123, 0.022209057584404945, -0.00754692405462265, -0.04382744058966637, -0.02159610204398632, -0.06469903886318207, 0.008393273688852787, -0.025634417310357094, -0.022131899371743202, -0.03096126578748226, -0.005724056623876095, 0.024154530838131905, 0.012057767249643803, -0.000019135775801260024, -0.044743429869413376, -0.008694717660546303, 0.04520426318049431, 0.017807120457291603, -0.030690550804138184, -0.0296611450612545, -0.004020698368549347, -0.021857736632227898, 0.0015385155566036701, 0.0025732305366545916, 0.01005236990749836, 0.011892256326973438, 0.011967649683356285, 0.008542501367628574, 0.021188298240303993, -0.03565312922000885, -0.010237906128168106, 0.02265651896595955, -0.07016096264123917, 0.040212251245975494, 0.0299592986702919, -0.009172018617391586, -0.011381425894796848, 0.0053492034785449505, -0.01521336194127798, -0.0168855432420969, -0.005279684439301491, 0.03260640799999237, 0.0021888227201998234, 0.013995721936225891, -0.03751302510499954, 0.027459705248475075, -0.03380628675222397, -0.02807886339724064, -0.008029631339013577, 0.0310987439006567, 0.008865932002663612, 0.011788614094257355, 0.02169274352490902, -0.013089518062770367, -0.012862569652497768, 0.024757204577326775, 0.027869973331689835, 0.033295027911663055, 0.0214899480342865, 0.0039988174103200436, -0.011525101959705353, -0.01716296747326851, 0.07129177451133728, -0.003992600366473198, -0.040118321776390076, 0.05478258803486824, -0.0524936243891716, -0.03221515566110611, 0.018580237403512, -0.027446411550045013, 0.023015571758151054, -0.002394304843619466, -0.023478321731090546, -0.05100048705935478, 0.0450250580906868, -0.009414400905370712, -0.003923508338630199, 0.0373462438583374, -0.016950543969869614, -0.012372847646474838, -0.0068247332237660885, 0.021703289821743965, -0.018847888335585594, 0.0072853234596550465, 0.027436792850494385, 0.038104891777038574, -0.034744322299957275, -0.02915950119495392, 0.026763182133436203, -0.02051294781267643, 0.01683839224278927, 0.03203331679105759, -0.006519625894725323, 0.039715614169836044, 0.0662979930639267, -0.04274682328104973, 0.04452415555715561, -0.039493247866630554, 0.008963637053966522, -0.10949616879224777, -0.028379231691360474, 0.03258895128965378, -0.0057469024322927, 0.05372587963938713, -0.034670136868953705, -0.0033069769851863384, 0.009421141818165779, -0.07579082995653152, 0.05025187507271767, -0.005570683628320694, -0.024336514994502068, -0.046844448894262314, 0.011023067869246006, -0.04282218962907791, 0.022621214389801025, 0.010391045361757278, 0.06943913549184799, 0.013828964903950691, 0.06368035078048706, -0.03225870430469513, -0.04272745922207832, 0.003694345476105809, 0.05545797199010849, 0.02392197586596012, -0.02794671058654785, 0.0231863372027874, -0.017184583470225334, -0.019529681652784348, -0.005557599477469921, -0.017211688682436943, 0.00822388008236885, -0.039394620805978775, 0.005884217564016581, 0.01784886047244072, 0.0779251977801323, 0.012621501460671425, -0.007585085462778807, 0.04521222412586212, -0.011779557913541794, 0.004303927067667246, -0.0029289661906659603, -0.01521663460880518, 0.03300846368074417, 0.00629214383661747, -0.045825693756341934, -0.0147884925827384, 0.03577089682221413, 0.0010374868288636208, -0.03857453539967537, -0.013875597156584263, 0.012618758715689182, 0.048962194472551346, -0.03185731917619705, 0.059185247868299484, -0.007851017639040947, -0.028332047164440155, 0.004636260215193033, 0.05033201351761818, -0.012793128378689289, 0.019444024190306664, 0.01671985350549221, -0.02372679114341736, 0.02038685232400894, -0.0016034900909289718, -0.004272351041436195, -0.0657072439789772, -0.06419825553894043, -0.006167812272906303, 0.03247629851102829, -0.023214057087898254, -0.018933236598968506, -0.03728821501135826, 0.004012024961411953, -0.006343450862914324, 0.01940055750310421, -0.003006793325766921, -0.04726564884185791, -0.00941498763859272, -0.08950330317020416, 0.05209669470787048, -0.015770841389894485, 0.020378025248646736, 0.024199556559324265, -0.0173383466899395, -0.009709764271974564, 0.014798164367675781, 0.057371463626623154, 0.020157888531684875, -0.006497859954833984, -0.014405922032892704, 0.017769301310181618, 0.05187270790338516, -0.03612834960222244, 0.03715423122048378, -0.02597898244857788, 0.0002300528431078419, -0.026944970712065697, -0.057770729064941406, 0.03643009066581726, -0.01992080733180046, -0.010270917788147926, -0.005295639391988516, -0.019469844177365303, -0.020072273910045624, -0.015236135572195053, 0.065388023853302, 0.01251925714313984, -0.018886186182498932, 0.08005624264478683, -0.010947488248348236, 0.011436180211603642, 0.008253188803792, 0.002087274333462119, -0.016282230615615845, 0.03517579287290573, -0.035760216414928436, -0.035418618470430374, 0.003021267708390951, 0.037844497710466385, 0.03803915157914162, -0.0112175727263093, -0.02264147251844406, 0.05398769676685333, -0.027000516653060913, -0.03496032953262329, 0.048347920179367065, 0.03828716650605202, 0.018527021631598473, 0.02273760922253132, -0.0013957710471004248, 0.03400436043739319, 0.02775084227323532, 0.02042848989367485, 0.025070887058973312, 0.0191312525421381, 0.006080220453441143, 0.0001115809500333853, -0.016933998093008995, -0.05095586180686951, 0.04527408257126808, -0.0012069153599441051, -0.007218507584184408, -0.03763827309012413, -0.03794321045279503, 0.042465757578611374, 0.006145208142697811, -0.011949964798986912, -0.028049705550074577, -0.013785144314169884, 0.07494520395994186, 0.008468477055430412, -0.006607647519558668, -0.06422404944896698, 0.002164277480915189, 0.012442352250218391, 0.011772519908845425, -0.004694635979831219, 0.02789866365492344, -0.017610063776373863, 0.022816604003310204, -0.018442416563630104, 0.021696757525205612, 0.0022983828093856573, -0.025327689945697784, 0.052754417061805725, -0.012816842645406723, -0.003705444047227502, -0.020800970494747162, -0.018795225769281387, -0.009891565889120102, -0.015310059301555157, 0.001150027266703546, 0.06458748877048492, 0.00989292748272419, 0.011213750578463078, 0.005897433031350374, -0.01492378395050764, 0.023594960570335388, -0.05189599096775055, 0.007966393604874611, -0.030834008008241653, -0.005401836708188057, 0.005134969018399715, -0.00631391117349267 ]
<p>I have a data which contains several columns which I later reduced using a PCA algorithms to two different components. I then applied the k-means algorithms to the data.<br> Now, how can I verify that my data clustered well into each group? Or how do I determine misclassification rate?</p> <p>For instance, using R, if I check the cluster vector say k$cluster against the labels of the data I had previously before clustering can I just draw a confusion matrix from that and assume that 1 in the clustered vector is equivalent to 1 in my labels?</p> <pre><code>col3 col2 Col1 lables 123 2.32 2.50 0 124 2.81 3.10 1 125 2.72 3.09 2 126 2.92 3.03 3 127 2.32 2.95 4 </code></pre> <p>Please note this is a hypothetical data; my data is way bigger than this.</p>
73,657
[ -0.07041070610284805, -0.005491345655173063, -0.02141653001308441, -0.021870417520403862, 0.03725356608629227, 0.0055184257216751575, -0.01356266438961029, 0.005119072739034891, 0.0180667657405138, -0.007707236334681511, 0.032634224742650986, 0.03815425559878349, 0.037011098116636276, 0.02908186800777912, 0.024703744798898697, 0.02954828180372715, -0.018309038132429123, -0.00803086906671524, 0.0118940444663167, 0.019932633265852928, 0.012595104984939098, -0.009328496642410755, 0.007806821260601282, -0.022864997386932373, -0.014309684745967388, 0.02742159552872181, 0.027950270101428032, -0.007433063350617886, 0.024240827187895775, 0.022530166432261467, -0.029433805495500565, -0.004288936499506235, 0.03707177937030792, 0.030893729999661446, -0.0002546536270529032, 0.003188425675034523, 0.0019409817177802324, -0.013607199303805828, -0.03395303711295128, 0.025250624865293503, -0.04595636576414108, -0.03974581137299538, 0.019196011126041412, 0.046133335679769516, 0.014958979561924934, 0.025123439729213715, -0.0022708806209266186, -0.01051284372806549, 0.0308010745793581, -0.057400938123464584, 0.08820127695798874, 0.02816046215593815, 0.042500294744968414, 0.037946246564388275, -0.03417948633432388, -0.0029673618264496326, 0.052579790353775024, 0.07071518152952194, -0.032332077622413635, -0.048543088138103485, -0.013628694228827953, -0.03287520259618759, 0.012094340287148952, -0.04562794789671898, -0.03424542769789696, 0.05763031169772148, -0.025214366614818573, -0.0023912270553410053, 0.03069496341049671, -0.016104571521282196, -0.013848942704498768, -0.0128922238945961, 0.03454984724521637, -0.011533587239682674, 0.028615115210413933, -0.0352085642516613, -0.011068211868405342, 0.04143809527158737, 0.03994045779109001, 0.009879092685878277, 0.025768477469682693, 0.036921560764312744, 0.0282592736184597, 0.008904083631932735, 0.04203762859106064, -0.0016107234405353665, 0.05857332795858383, -0.028346579521894455, 0.033760424703359604, 0.02300078049302101, -0.027944199740886688, 0.026449406519532204, 0.01591612957417965, 0.02221972495317459, -0.0006349734612740576, 0.03839012607932091, 0.003040076931938529, 0.01827782206237316, -0.002778728259727359, -0.025570709258317947, 0.014764997176826, -0.015768064185976982, 0.006310551427304745, 0.034054309129714966, -0.04159555584192276, -0.011653176508843899, -0.060016531497240067, -0.017929397523403168, -0.020513981580734253, -0.02595539018511772, 0.0012023256858810782, 0.015201842412352562, 0.03543167933821678, -0.0059692710638046265, 0.0336759127676487, -0.023031504824757576, 0.0041449121199548244, -0.018501052632927895, 0.04765466973185539, 0.06016699969768524, 0.06017594411969185, -0.015729116275906563, 0.03442689776420593, -0.029406290501356125, -0.049650728702545166, -0.0025314129889011383, 0.0003116539737675339, -0.031051596626639366, -0.03677423298358917, 0.038022834807634354, -0.019449003040790558, -0.0330585353076458, 0.01679747924208641, -0.034210458397865295, 0.01949578896164894, -0.00866685714572668, -0.0902852863073349, -0.02381802536547184, 0.0018429968040436506, -0.015963668003678322, 0.006026959978044033, -0.07222537696361542, -0.009988789446651936, 0.005510633811354637, 0.053209371864795685, 0.02299664169549942, 0.024764511734247208, -0.004744342993944883, 0.01126760896295309, 0.013874289579689503, -0.030448319390416145, 0.0002554966777097434, -0.0047040460631251335, -0.017422785982489586, 0.003588029881939292, -0.0734163373708725, -0.01623300462961197, 0.025887804105877876, 0.008929870091378689, -0.012995285913348198, -0.00011089701729360968, 0.0007844276260584593, -0.013667762279510498, -0.015453265979886055, -0.008727431297302246, 0.010028867982327938, 0.0668521523475647, -0.0010820627212524414, 0.0424148365855217, 0.0216353926807642, -0.0027375277131795883, 0.035986073315143585, 0.01986214704811573, 0.0409119576215744, 0.061658408492803574, 0.009222975000739098, 0.006277880631387234, -0.025138510391116142, 0.044905032962560654, -0.02201228030025959, -0.04106975719332695, -0.018343521282076836, -0.011564236134290695, -0.0054963077418506145, 0.023152166977524757, 0.03658755496144295, 0.004055774305015802, -0.017613261938095093, 0.021212004125118256, -0.005464579444378614, -0.041613753885030746, -0.04833175614476204, 0.027582870796322823, -0.04126247763633728, -0.054064806550741196, 0.027143258601427078, 0.0252840556204319, -0.005959257483482361, -0.025447126477956772, -0.03982606157660484, -0.06521008908748627, -0.0092089818790555, 0.02429974265396595, -0.0436837412416935, -0.031207188963890076, 0.029400361701846123, 0.029302099719643593, -0.020228641107678413, 0.08389472961425781, -0.024408500641584396, -0.04892155900597572, 0.006961919832974672, -0.019115760922431946, -0.02626209147274494, -0.019740957766771317, 0.01907101646065712, 0.04345640167593956, 0.018053963780403137, -0.02957523614168167, 0.02807553857564926, -0.053922537714242935, 0.06342673301696777, 0.05077621713280678, 0.011384913697838783, 0.01467000413686037, -0.026470491662621498, -0.018366480246186256, -0.0031578605994582176, -0.013437923975288868, -0.016823120415210724, -0.0671926736831665, -0.03303995728492737, 0.05384445562958717, 0.016713488847017288, -0.01680731028318405, 0.004865969531238079, 0.041480984538793564, 0.0012082202592864633, -0.005290703382343054, 0.0067149982787668705, -0.01850617118179798, -0.02488761581480503, 0.025647912174463272, 0.012563456781208515, -0.033483367413282394, -0.006968043278902769, 0.024731535464525223, 0.009410052560269833, 0.04889333248138428, -0.004318388178944588, -0.006556652020663023, 0.05067582428455353, -0.040268123149871826, -0.004742792341858149, 0.014511557295918465, -0.024502452462911606, 0.03800056129693985, -0.005607519298791885, -0.0061561595648527145, 0.014607266522943974, 0.01295267790555954, -0.015629149973392487, 0.017312144860625267, -0.016602400690317154, 0.018101396039128304, 0.061473604291677475, -0.05767695978283882, 0.00787259265780449, 0.01616300269961357, -0.04655789956450462, 0.013892004266381264, -0.016391072422266006, -0.03889385983347893, -0.012359341606497765, 0.06554171442985535, 0.05509210377931595, 0.008661298081278801, 0.02894679643213749, -0.010041093453764915, 0.0029955788049846888, 0.0004773855034727603, -0.035509541630744934, 0.023684263229370117, 0.03385666012763977, -0.027003832161426544, 0.027615336701273918, -0.03532940149307251, 0.0011470649624243379, 0.009046782739460468, -0.027656419202685356, -0.032754216343164444, 0.011330923065543175, -0.006788736209273338, -0.01230674609541893, -0.013621050864458084, -0.03554937615990639, 0.018619354814291, -0.009718681685626507, -0.015236776322126389, -0.028144508600234985, 0.011594763025641441, -0.04170318320393562, -0.020954053848981857, -0.033092059195041656, -0.018463769927620888, -0.003532306058332324, -0.014840777963399887, 0.00033347023418173194, -0.020524969324469566, -0.008389683440327644, 0.029310978949069977, -0.022771669551730156, -0.010536378249526024, -0.025409508496522903, -0.06701026856899261, 0.011384524405002594, 0.009939420036971569, 0.02553694322705269, 0.0058564976789057255, -0.04479808360338211, 0.06457594037055969, 0.010892296209931374, -0.05812963843345642, -0.024573152884840965, -0.003561672056093812, -0.07542062550783157, 0.004473640117794275, 0.01653718389570713, 0.016458921134471893, 0.03675243258476257, 0.010967216454446316, 0.017353471368551254, 0.0005458363448269665, 0.045020099729299545, -0.005830646492540836, -0.015944642946124077, 0.017876237630844116, -0.0014404383255168796, -0.007510586176067591, 0.015689104795455933, 0.004734530579298735, -0.051456693559885025, 0.0005409031291492283, 0.031944531947374344, 0.009412628598511219, 0.0290916096419096, -0.025654833763837814, 0.0003132994461338967, -0.03239528462290764, 0.06996320188045502, -0.03352869302034378, 0.017823440954089165, 0.022321805357933044, -0.016045929864048958, 0.043621212244033813, 0.036604143679142, 0.028460487723350525, -0.021824104711413383, 0.0018287639832124114, 0.08145372569561005, 0.0358453243970871, -0.027849478647112846, -0.011491305194795132, -0.021388601511716843, -0.022498495876789093, 0.032369956374168396, -0.037938106805086136, -0.013601073063910007, 0.03287599980831146, 0.03273135423660278, 0.007550349459052086, 0.0072591546922922134, -0.020129628479480743, 0.033281657844781876, -0.07617910206317902, -0.008787326514720917, -0.02640567719936371, 0.028651854023337364, -0.013697884976863861, 0.03895294666290283, 0.042924296110868454, -0.035223282873630524, 0.011783265508711338, -0.0004111596499569714, -0.07126284390687943, 0.01058579608798027, 0.0030366983264684677, 0.0026880986988544464, 0.0045102909207344055, -0.04633302241563797, -0.0017828999552875757, -0.013989315368235111, 0.040736932307481766, 0.01921202428638935, 0.0331881083548069, -0.035121120512485504, 0.005758040118962526, 0.01804373227059841, 0.013669745996594429, -0.008781146258115768, 0.011657378636300564, 0.038060691207647324, 0.024891594424843788, 0.05294502153992653, 0.04086880013346672, -0.006753891706466675, -0.004834442399442196, -0.0034473626874387264, 0.02124519646167755, 0.03176381066441536, 0.022957105189561844, 0.014804219827055931, 0.02378864772617817, -0.015123681165277958, 0.015127693302929401, -0.012707204557955265, 0.06206801161170006, 0.011362719349563122, 0.01279713399708271, -0.013291808776557446, -0.039437271654605865, -0.01322480570524931, -0.02969866245985031, 0.02901008352637291, 0.005287019070237875, -0.024162212386727333, 0.011608727276325226, 0.045692406594753265, -0.08772803843021393, -0.0000762800409574993, 0.11209320276975632, 0.049677666276693344, -0.035171154886484146, -0.027890628203749657, -0.03136276453733444, -0.0004850423720199615, -0.021140392869710922, 0.03168421983718872, 0.0007584721897728741, 0.02718382142484188, 0.018203331157565117, 0.05352690815925598, -0.05072576925158501, -0.04131964594125748, 0.013151106424629688, -0.016314709559082985, 0.017299063503742218, 0.002590648829936981, -0.017573999240994453, 0.0098834577947855, 0.04710446670651436, 0.05325198546051979, -0.0058780633844435215, -0.023739060387015343, -0.09987277537584305, -0.0028897211886942387, 0.048864755779504776, 0.048195093870162964, -0.035066619515419006, -0.003938897978514433, -0.04836088791489601, -0.016640564426779747, 0.05772431567311287, -0.05165091156959534, 0.0648583471775055, -0.016562655568122864, 0.013693561777472496, -0.04957350715994835, 0.013999073766171932, -0.04167332872748375, 0.006244325079023838, -0.007920130155980587, 0.04648725315928459, -0.013071486726403236, -0.019685834646224976, -0.0603555329144001, 0.010318726301193237, 0.024253031238913536, 0.03592991456389427, -0.036943353712558746, -0.014607495628297329, -0.008452584967017174, 0.015676509588956833, -0.014993799850344658, -0.035661015659570694, 0.015687227249145508, 0.015857039019465446, -0.023552728816866875, 0.07849546521902084, 0.00385006470605731, -0.025338314473628998, 0.02007799595594406, 0.023656778037548065, 0.014456910081207752, -0.01983611285686493, 0.0026472355239093304, 0.042807046324014664, 0.013295209035277367, 0.031027136370539665, 0.033148862421512604, -0.03690201789140701, 0.028438463807106018, 0.025637907907366753, -0.05737069994211197, 0.02044849283993244, -0.04164167866110802, -0.019371716305613518, -0.0041519771330058575, 0.009454051963984966, -0.027854537591338158, 0.04143768921494484, -0.038384515792131424, 0.03367917984724045, -0.006771857850253582, -0.01229057926684618, 0.0049707465805113316, 0.022056931629776955, -0.015143620781600475, 0.008745891973376274, -0.0038930911105126143, 0.0279733557254076, -0.019583869725465775, 0.019023500382900238, 0.032049670815467834, -0.0032563742715865374, -0.007220271043479443, 0.01849512569606304, -0.04325510561466217, 0.023712359368801117, -0.038100361824035645, -0.0006173563888296485, 0.008295823819935322, -0.04382887855172157, 0.03438567742705345, -0.01826195977628231, 0.03110385313630104, -0.007638492155820131, -0.04136503115296364, -0.013068496249616146, -0.011337051168084145, -0.006651426665484905, 0.05198753997683525, -0.012169881723821163, 0.040702544152736664, 0.026126142591238022, 0.01053900457918644, -0.07773618400096893, -0.030938664451241493, 0.003663643728941679, 0.02122436836361885, -0.011392652057111263, -0.06256686896085739, 0.006486122962087393, -0.0005339081399142742, -0.028862902894616127, -0.0020212982781231403, 0.06167759373784065, -0.024459930136799812, -0.03693511709570885, 0.023614194244146347, -0.00145615020301193, 0.09239944070577621, 0.005624842364341021, -0.00967253465205431, 0.009280230849981308, -0.03907027468085289, -0.014137566089630127, 0.011240788735449314, 0.0025269724428653717, -0.031980279833078384, -0.012763838283717632, -0.05887949466705322, 0.016202712431550026, 0.050109315663576126, -0.019343586638569832, -0.024391448125243187, -0.017275454476475716, -0.012147395871579647, 0.014688137918710709, -0.033466637134552, 0.004972934257239103, -0.035590045154094696, 0.01572650857269764, -0.036375030875205994, -0.024368196725845337, -0.026800453662872314, -0.008672448806464672, 0.024693936109542847, -0.003618274349719286, -0.004187690559774637, 0.010915118269622326, 0.09946738928556442, -0.008796854875981808, 0.0229390487074852, 0.0028059864416718483, -0.050651565194129944, 0.028711440041661263, -0.012412778101861477, -0.01581588387489319, -0.01231432519853115, 0.04918342083692551, -0.015024349093437195, -0.022116640582680702, -0.022628048434853554, -0.0006801411509513855, 0.0700397863984108, 0.03814227506518364, 0.012172048911452293, 0.06266894191503525, 0.018473558127880096, -0.01766226626932621, 0.0021441697608679533, 0.005824713502079248, -0.024725453928112984, 0.0005546387401409447, 0.03210344910621643, 0.013515325263142586, -0.00032228956115432084, -0.0025307824835181236, 0.008408463560044765, 0.017143920063972473, 0.03702786564826965, 0.03540928289294243, 0.022427085787057877, -0.0003735950158443302, -0.023839347064495087, -0.05633080005645752, 0.04137921333312988, -0.03769256919622421, 0.011705460026860237, -0.05343026667833328, -0.06644658744335175, 0.015421053394675255, 0.03411492705345154, 0.011653747409582138, 0.001709261443465948, -0.038629770278930664, -0.05636657401919365, 0.015282434411346912, 0.0064897360280156136, -0.03312959522008896, 0.017142334952950478, -0.013467181473970413, 0.03260153532028198, 0.02335628867149353, 0.025726301595568657, -0.024984871968626976, -0.07412316650152206, -0.03782681003212929, -0.04053707793354988, -0.021765535697340965, 0.029841376468539238, 0.03263946995139122, -0.045234162360429764, 0.02926526591181755, -0.02975901961326599, 0.04142841696739197, 0.012634224258363247, 0.045840803533792496, -0.002991659101098776, 0.02775968238711357, -0.011371745727956295, 0.06785600632429123, 0.008060724474489689, -0.005569047294557095, 0.11114414036273956, 0.0884927436709404, 0.023190608248114586, -0.023529890924692154, 0.047654520720243454, 0.04730767384171486, 0.016869407147169113, -0.04482528939843178, 0.0315433107316494, -0.022904861718416214, 0.028486665338277817, 0.020477930083870888, 0.052584704011678696, -0.008505296893417835, 0.010619075037539005, 0.06245948001742363, 0.004313373938202858, -0.03597049415111542, 0.001395195024088025, 0.007310022599995136, -0.007002146448940039, -0.02749256230890751, -0.06337027996778488, 0.03519343584775925, 0.05298217013478279, -0.00786419678479433, -0.018388433381915092, 0.041312605142593384, 0.019968876615166664, -0.011833441443741322, -0.010009403340518475, 0.008303449489176273, 0.006320580840110779, 0.012357112020254135, -0.026360178366303444, 0.0019552502781152725, 0.005380462389439344, -0.024019526317715645, 0.01761307194828987, 0.010790841653943062, 0.0063396356999874115, -0.01869862712919712, -0.008241627365350723, 0.02006503753364086, -0.0530838780105114, -0.022022005170583725, -0.06068031117320061, 0.05632855370640755, -0.018822386860847473, 0.018641315400600433, 0.015901995822787285, -0.010316839441657066, -0.019674701616168022, -0.06027579307556152, -0.02981983684003353, 0.02685336396098137, 0.015340006910264492, -0.0155692333355546, -0.010829796083271503, -0.05505029857158661, 0.009052682667970657, -0.026217659935355186, -0.008099393919110298, 0.018780654296278954, -0.0037270840257406235, 0.0006251789745874703, -0.01852884143590927, 0.05912802368402481, -0.020709821954369545, 0.01791710965335369, -0.03934198245406151, -0.019556868821382523, -0.0021392193157225847, -0.03058774210512638, -0.0011781821958720684, 0.012723860330879688, 0.017017867416143417, 0.02393243834376335, -0.017105598002672195, -0.011179632507264614, -0.0560583770275116, -0.0030052957590669394, -0.01970585063099861, -0.017379919067025185, -0.03592899069190025, 0.009529788047075272, 0.04660285264253616, 0.004895188845694065, 0.031778883188962936, 0.03395574912428856, -0.0037848528008908033, 0.02977186068892479, -0.014785530976951122, -0.024518931284546852, -0.00828471314162016, -0.0028286047745496035, -0.02598983608186245, 0.038854677230119705, -0.028242716565728188, 0.062019508332014084, 0.03301987051963806, -0.014250455424189568, -0.010798368602991104, 0.033137038350105286, 0.008541938848793507, 0.01571599580347538, 0.012104575522243977, -0.027408231049776077, 0.015644501894712448, -0.007674156688153744, 0.020615383982658386, -0.03550763428211212, -0.026631133630871773, -0.045975081622600555, -0.04241371527314186, 0.003993374761193991, -0.022105487063527107, -0.03815920650959015, -0.0127287982031703, 0.003706870600581169, -0.008203823119401932, -0.055500373244285583, -0.010317318141460419, -0.026285288855433464, -0.0017775519518181682, -0.04716218262910843, -0.014337572269141674, -0.022868018597364426, 0.019526872783899307, -0.003652711631730199, 0.03212949261069298, 0.053360145539045334, 0.007472142577171326, 0.02822801284492016, 0.030301837250590324, 0.0022031674161553383, -0.021308226510882378, 0.04315035417675972, -0.02120073512196541, 0.0016534564783796668, 0.04613511636853218, -0.05190235748887062, -0.0335518941283226, -0.005929163657128811, -0.01344007346779108, 0.04152791202068329, 0.020933089777827263, -0.006365966517478228, 0.010638284496963024, 0.057065609842538834, -0.02988339215517044, -0.012863807380199432, 0.006712248548865318, 0.00992221012711525, -0.007720216177403927, 0.005279154516756535, 0.014586028642952442, 0.00607217475771904, -0.051251016557216644, 0.03463912755250931, 0.04802990332245827, 0.014992187730967999, -0.02610609494149685, 0.019808415323495865, 0.014190005138516426, 0.017830319702625275, 0.005989013239741325, -0.017334967851638794, 0.040797967463731766, 0.06224586069583893, -0.04208673536777496, 0.04227377474308014, -0.02559622749686241, 0.014239100739359856, -0.07769954949617386, -0.03915093094110489, 0.01037466898560524, 0.017998643219470978, 0.032457854598760605, -0.06252121925354004, 0.0239508505910635, 0.0539955273270607, -0.044381797313690186, 0.020244425162672997, -0.0017868191935122013, -0.007215224672108889, -0.02491885796189308, 0.039170898497104645, -0.03204164281487465, 0.021605124697089195, 0.02325989305973053, 0.01472950167953968, 0.010205020196735859, 0.025719458237290382, 0.02643718011677265, -0.0035499667283147573, -0.008196784183382988, 0.02182747609913349, -0.0026256421115249395, -0.0666196420788765, 0.037535395473241806, -0.0407596118748188, -0.039683420211076736, 0.01964789256453514, -0.025199536234140396, 0.022275373339653015, 0.07421612739562988, 0.003917204216122627, -0.02624247781932354, 0.03889328986406326, -0.0033126752823591232, -0.025526149198412895, -0.014666534028947353, 0.022836636751890182, 0.009669393301010132, 0.023688849061727524, 0.016812991350889206, 0.01548696868121624, 0.019382430240511894, -0.029077468439936638, 0.0013163159601390362, -0.016711382195353508, -0.0274374857544899, -0.0054083410650491714, -0.028884965926408768, -0.02284861169755459, -0.0036453385837376118, -0.021837515756487846, 0.02073640376329422, -0.04267338663339615, -0.021359587088227272, 0.021926118060946465, 0.07541580498218536, -0.004280197434127331, 0.044584065675735474, -0.024588415399193764, -0.04851089417934418, 0.010785761289298534, 0.013805054128170013, -0.013840153813362122, -0.06774424761533737, -0.008316694758832455, 0.029746100306510925, 0.007885864935815334, -0.006924058776348829, -0.04511317238211632, 0.004307475872337818, 0.08663289248943329, -0.040387265384197235, -0.009480329230427742, 0.037191037088632584, -0.029640529304742813, 0.021461650729179382, -0.07630866765975952, 0.042447175830602646, 0.006860798224806786, -0.02575678750872612, -0.03331265226006508, -0.015854550525546074, -0.05731133744120598, 0.01823735050857067, 0.05313082039356232, 0.048272084444761276, 0.017943857237696648, -0.0317780002951622, -0.0023640738800168037, 0.004664211999624968, -0.09172085672616959, 0.03660879656672478, -0.023962704464793205, -0.02972964383661747, -0.015258388593792915, -0.0007540065562352538, 0.03914886713027954, -0.01807643659412861, 0.029097244143486023, -0.006027575582265854, -0.027669351547956467, 0.012394089251756668, -0.0233882088214159, 0.023561326786875725, -0.02358323521912098, 0.022726478055119514, 0.0366642139852047, -0.005692476872354746, -0.003630782710388303, 0.06087971851229668, 0.0023381763603538275, -0.02850513719022274, 0.04739726707339287, -0.07207091897726059, 0.004267231561243534, 0.018162013962864876, 0.003177095204591751, 0.004774949047714472, -0.0851825475692749, -0.0032880937214940786, 0.004233955405652523, -0.019676875323057175, 0.01922541670501232, 0.01751399226486683, 0.015553602017462254, 0.030560171231627464, 0.010326126590371132, 0.03491491451859474, 0.017113901674747467, -0.014694718644022942, 0.030922062695026398, 0.02797526866197586, 0.0039734928868710995, 0.003004437778145075, 0.006217745132744312, 0.021092357113957405, -0.012752123177051544, 0.00710814306512475, 0.009463118389248848, 0.03352723643183708, -0.0409751795232296, 0.00494740717113018, 0.01810993067920208, -0.00651064608246088, 0.02072720043361187, 0.006845069117844105, 0.0016498336335644126, 0.01944284699857235, -0.0471181720495224, -0.011363462544977665, -0.03641374409198761, -0.03603293374180794, -0.004548073746263981, -0.0038715326227247715, 0.00015436008106917143, 0.033597182482481, -0.0018443140434101224, 0.017484772950410843, -0.022542184218764305, -0.03928113728761673, 0.017654109746217728, -0.0055894022807478905, 0.035180751234292984, -0.032781440764665604, -0.0044249133206903934, 0.0011601268779486418, 0.007471680175513029, -0.048615556210279465, -0.014300480484962463, 0.029266357421875, 0.037123117595911026, 0.030670544132590294, -0.017797838896512985, -0.020521199330687523, -0.01868249475955963, 0.022771237418055534, -0.058912284672260284, -0.036928411573171616, -0.06022106856107712, -0.008233238011598587, 0.015884244814515114, -0.010115468874573708 ]
<p>I'd like to test how well my data can be modeled by an <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponentially_modified_Gaussian_distribution" rel="nofollow">Exponentially modified Gaussian distribution (Wikipedia)</a> or <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normal-exponential-gamma_distribution" rel="nofollow">Normal-exponential-gamma (NEG) Distribution</a>. However, the parameter estimation (which involves Skewness) is not very robust when there are outliers in the data set.</p> <p>I've good experiences with Median based parameter estimation on this data set (see the related question <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/48864/estimating-parameters-of-a-normal-distribution-median-instead-of-mean">Estimating parameters of a normal distribution: median instead of mean?</a> ).</p> <p>Do you know a Median-based or similarly robust parameter estimation for the ExGaussian / NEG distributions? I've already tried trimming my data set, the results were clearly better afterwards. Yet, this obviously introduces a bias, that I would need to correct somehow.</p>
73,658
[ -0.012828104197978973, -0.0018927576020359993, -0.0001836444716900587, 0.010070079937577248, 0.02247597835958004, 0.006755699869245291, -0.01278394740074873, -0.026325782760977745, 0.005712499842047691, -0.04731499403715134, 0.03320074826478958, 0.04766591638326645, 0.039390679448843, 0.003816850483417511, 0.01704108901321888, -0.026925791054964066, -0.03921316936612129, 0.008297188207507133, -0.011311512440443039, -0.019350502640008926, -0.0067236218601465225, 0.0029594649095088243, -0.012210930697619915, -0.0009173074504360557, -0.035632211714982986, 0.04325796663761139, 0.044520288705825806, -0.02156442031264305, 0.011120393872261047, 0.08101274818181992, -0.04261165112257004, -0.015891071408987045, 0.010843668133020401, 0.03205690160393715, 0.018261507153511047, 0.0008763124933466315, -0.008695795200765133, -0.021712591871619225, -0.009899073280394077, 0.031943343579769135, -0.04570474848151207, -0.009305613115429878, -0.006298080086708069, -0.00011979066039202735, 0.00500436220318079, 0.006959863472729921, 0.008622771129012108, -0.06357233971357346, 0.029478099197149277, -0.02716132067143917, 0.09201323986053467, -0.005038590636104345, 0.02631158009171486, 0.023463033139705658, 0.01087546069175005, -0.011068630032241344, 0.05820101499557495, 0.08636803179979324, -0.007551421411335468, -0.05561148747801781, 0.01265604980289936, -0.011931358836591244, -0.021185247227549553, -0.017885368317365646, -0.04076533019542694, 0.020321212708950043, 0.0007575303316116333, -0.03198816999793053, 0.015804536640644073, 0.026295872405171394, 0.004992786794900894, 0.023452166467905045, 0.02543870359659195, 0.009377451613545418, 0.0166454017162323, -0.0378534160554409, -0.009674474596977234, 0.025097040459513664, 0.02852432057261467, 0.023578640073537827, 0.02199673280119896, -0.023106016218662262, 0.014644240029156208, 0.05101880431175232, 0.004864854738116264, 0.0036051201168447733, 0.09011650830507278, -0.043238550424575806, 0.024260301142930984, 0.03614301607012749, -0.054556459188461304, -0.024669675156474113, 0.04647992551326752, -0.003830254776403308, -0.02984163537621498, 0.023454058915376663, -0.017337284982204437, 0.040080726146698, -0.013085625134408474, -0.0003146605158690363, -0.007216857746243477, -0.024776307865977287, -0.006176348775625229, 0.03751891851425171, -0.028432143852114677, 0.016882233321666718, -0.0006554362480528653, 0.0024956001434475183, -0.035019081085920334, -0.028714317828416824, -0.031331468373537064, 0.025176553055644035, -0.022785287350416183, -0.01257314719259739, 0.047972217202186584, 0.008933675475418568, -0.002696200041100383, -0.06197108328342438, 0.03401244804263115, 0.061277735978364944, 0.024158580228686333, -0.030674684792757034, 0.015719367191195488, -0.0370224192738533, -0.01714974269270897, -0.017503438517451286, 0.04746817797422409, -0.007353371009230614, -0.03858319669961929, 0.03008265420794487, 0.00664654141291976, -0.014233054593205452, 0.08720201998949051, -0.023820748552680016, 0.06362320482730865, 0.004212445113807917, -0.06766069680452347, -0.07036226987838745, 0.035911109298467636, 0.01368830818682909, 0.015499679371714592, -0.08124589920043945, -0.04660370945930481, 0.014035260304808617, -0.015144368633627892, 0.02422887459397316, 0.018533747643232346, 0.006014467682689428, 0.023604368790984154, 0.008617188781499863, 0.0016769025241956115, 0.0026923015248030424, 0.002933410694822669, -0.02676428109407425, -0.023665834218263626, -0.09233219176530838, 0.022353295236825943, 0.03128336742520332, -0.013128983788192272, 0.0063048480078577995, 0.02137736976146698, 0.024059493094682693, -0.01087175216525793, -0.014816067181527615, 0.033046457916498184, -0.024800153449177742, 0.10589903593063354, 0.0022336761467158794, 0.050505299121141434, 0.020390763878822327, -0.027250833809375763, 0.0344490222632885, 0.02701687440276146, -0.0008817871566861868, 0.03462827578186989, -0.015000558458268642, 0.000734176835976541, -0.04425690695643425, 0.03359008952975273, 0.0283367857336998, -0.039597805589437485, -0.03125900775194168, 0.013260852545499802, -0.0027000599075108767, 0.03611937165260315, 0.01970658265054226, -0.00505207059904933, 0.000030514902391587384, 0.045298151671886444, -0.06162223964929581, -0.013130232691764832, -0.04342718422412872, 0.00370845478028059, -0.000026162633730564266, -0.02444429136812687, 0.04380124434828758, -0.02296033874154091, 0.014543014578521252, -0.005450749304145575, 0.004915733356028795, 0.021749325096607208, 0.01116176601499319, 0.07262969762086868, -0.03588920459151268, -0.010719308629631996, 0.0590587817132473, 0.04849306121468544, -0.027428528293967247, 0.029256030917167664, -0.032006505876779556, -0.07718466967344284, -0.012869822792708874, -0.0505426824092865, 0.014070876874029636, -0.013568345457315445, 0.017545349895954132, 0.0034885499626398087, 0.03760934993624687, -0.000753744097892195, 0.0031354431994259357, -0.031243229284882545, 0.07345505803823471, 0.042917400598526, 0.00023610933567397296, 0.028355959802865982, 0.005141817964613438, -0.01615794003009796, 0.03175323083996773, -0.027476906776428223, -0.0067544663324952126, -0.03486734628677368, -0.015073303133249283, 0.02264292538166046, -0.027782348915934563, -0.04068922996520996, 0.010404844768345356, 0.05252823233604431, 0.004070560913532972, 0.0314469113945961, -0.00235435226932168, -0.01246696338057518, -0.04336528852581978, 0.026630686596035957, -0.026531144976615906, 0.012356423772871494, 0.011591177433729172, 0.02878938987851143, -0.010255778208374977, 0.018573276698589325, -0.008480171672999859, 0.06101998686790466, 0.04138372093439102, 0.027560720220208168, 0.004140511620789766, -0.018876824527978897, 0.004795906599611044, 0.048653945326805115, -0.006902485154569149, -0.00017820134235080332, 0.03519541397690773, -0.01682938076555729, -0.0028379024006426334, -0.019071143120527267, -0.01018834300339222, 0.006447430234402418, 0.012343626469373703, -0.023006116971373558, 0.0077506364323198795, 0.008772225119173527, -0.002824270399287343, 0.0211366917937994, -0.03354734554886818, 0.0020987074822187424, 0.0031437831930816174, 0.025837929919362068, 0.03308023512363434, 0.05272615700960159, 0.014512363821268082, -0.007832517847418785, -0.04235710948705673, -0.0007497030892409384, 0.01684989593923092, 0.013180081732571125, 0.01859107054769993, -0.03539929911494255, -0.010355237871408463, -0.027637246996164322, -0.004319596569985151, 0.014087727293372154, 0.0007093885214999318, 0.024842238053679466, 0.007852472364902496, 0.010432983748614788, -0.026169300079345703, 0.00554698845371604, -0.027065519243478775, -0.006248416844755411, -0.03331037983298302, -0.06682199984788895, 0.06113430857658386, 0.011259079910814762, -0.02368239127099514, 0.08259369432926178, -0.035347625613212585, -0.023391425609588623, -0.028428776189684868, 0.02023168094456196, 0.025128476321697235, 0.0026128843892365694, 0.014476965181529522, 0.01793215423822403, 0.006044633220881224, -0.009684648364782333, -0.09088541567325592, -0.05927746742963791, 0.009422754868865013, 0.02445310726761818, 0.04560108855366707, 0.0010498734191060066, -0.04217115044593811, 0.049847815185785294, 0.03562761843204498, -0.03990834206342697, -0.017949894070625305, -0.013140702620148659, -0.015174232423305511, -0.05908792465925217, 0.004163622390478849, 0.00978930201381445, 0.023992391303181648, -0.013621444813907146, 0.027295108884572983, 0.024054257199168205, 0.007961323484778404, 0.01844925247132778, -0.02894040010869503, 0.007341661956161261, 0.009547175839543343, -0.006584629416465759, 0.06817243248224258, 0.059895727783441544, -0.007706210482865572, 0.008648506365716457, 0.014630718156695366, 0.0385323166847229, 0.017251014709472656, -0.052946366369724274, -0.0017524906434118748, -0.029697012156248093, -0.0076459539122879505, -0.024372290819883347, 0.01910843700170517, 0.009523117914795876, -0.03567429631948471, -0.01938369683921337, 0.017861900851130486, 0.026774348691105843, -0.01612907461822033, 0.02751808427274227, 0.06268957257270813, 0.04652935639023781, -0.006409159861505032, 0.005171672906726599, 0.015611493028700352, -0.024235378950834274, -0.0025174650363624096, -0.007302623242139816, 0.004345775581896305, 0.047708962112665176, 0.03639819473028183, 0.002738777780905366, -0.03707347437739372, -0.0388532392680645, 0.0008176007540896535, -0.08974854648113251, 0.02137010172009468, -0.012543966993689537, 0.027758970856666565, 0.02771078236401081, 0.007911155000329018, 0.021643320098519325, -0.022117506712675095, -0.017325416207313538, 0.0018461368745192885, -0.06423284113407135, 0.04430793970823288, -0.008272304199635983, -0.015861179679632187, -0.012686418369412422, -0.0458514578640461, 0.013866519555449486, -0.020071422681212425, 0.035455286502838135, 0.013284730724990368, 0.03981301560997963, -0.017980916425585747, -0.012622540816664696, -0.03602823615074158, -0.0022349338978528976, 0.008141948841512203, -0.0003043033357243985, -0.018641097471117973, -0.01884862221777439, -0.007956729270517826, 0.05122465267777443, -0.003513905918225646, -0.03790720924735069, -0.038083694875240326, -0.010359600186347961, 0.018188470974564552, 0.05770586431026459, 0.015617577359080315, 0.03261993080377579, -0.022889072075486183, 0.006167849525809288, -0.011551942676305771, 0.04027523100376129, 0.0533081591129303, 0.017890343442559242, -0.021378979086875916, -0.04826867952942848, -0.03222949802875519, -0.001440876629203558, 0.02141098864376545, 0.004327030852437019, 0.014259357936680317, 0.038477033376693726, 0.012133190408349037, -0.047991033643484116, -0.030146565288305283, 0.0355047732591629, 0.019633902236819267, 0.020301463082432747, -0.0343589223921299, -0.0011367398547008634, 0.012676543556153774, -0.032891955226659775, 0.001570450491271913, 0.021515674889087677, 0.014714366756379604, -0.00809546746313572, 0.008589131757616997, -0.002233140869066119, -0.016422754153609276, -0.029881028458476067, 0.01761554554104805, 0.062081851065158844, -0.016256803646683693, 0.0015972935361787677, 0.02879679948091507, 0.03687568008899689, 0.018653886392712593, 0.018459660932421684, 0.0009092696127481759, -0.06894086301326752, 0.027284199371933937, 0.06489016115665436, 0.04803629592061043, -0.003139093518257141, -0.01633334718644619, -0.035387784242630005, -0.0070101735182106495, -0.006069152615964413, -0.00223307847045362, 0.01801137812435627, -0.015062429010868073, -0.016274631023406982, -0.005495338700711727, -0.017156431451439857, -0.030027056112885475, 0.017112748697400093, -0.011126217432320118, 0.007008942309767008, -0.03136947378516197, -0.007774212397634983, -0.0377829410135746, 0.021029222756624222, -0.003684264374896884, 0.055346712470054626, -0.005184447392821312, -0.04201804846525192, 0.02505541406571865, 0.017493274062871933, -0.006116531323641539, -0.0865536704659462, -0.025899361819028854, -0.0053351265378296375, -0.011156451888382435, 0.03669588267803192, -0.004170888569205999, -0.03260475769639015, 0.025068586692214012, 0.021158261224627495, -0.034174781292676926, -0.013469896279275417, -0.03266202285885811, 0.04435427114367485, 0.02129042148590088, -0.009826840832829475, 0.07047131657600403, 0.0843055322766304, -0.022150417789816856, -0.0037143859080970287, -0.04952717944979668, -0.0036058062687516212, -0.04594040662050247, -0.03479006886482239, -0.027779487892985344, -0.019613003358244896, -0.03131892904639244, 0.014364550821483135, -0.006845808122307062, 0.055762335658073425, 0.00766335241496563, -0.0007606270373798907, 0.0244627445936203, 0.01893741264939308, -0.0018404625589028, 0.014419534243643284, -0.014730705879628658, 0.01938164047896862, -0.025514839217066765, -0.011724264360964298, 0.00019392457033973187, -0.016580985859036446, 0.0077447001822292805, 0.007843784056603909, -0.07641041278839111, -0.0038582056295126677, -0.05564461275935173, -0.02755655348300934, 0.0350281223654747, 0.020807096734642982, 0.030465656891465187, -0.0004784606280736625, 0.00659533403813839, 0.020948592573404312, -0.0259767584502697, -0.006281057372689247, 0.02485169842839241, -0.017744408920407295, 0.022312307730317116, -0.039161551743745804, 0.018798239529132843, -0.0180155448615551, 0.007651480380445719, -0.07387886196374893, -0.02474251203238964, 0.023946193978190422, -0.03711030259728432, -0.012959555722773075, -0.043131519109010696, 0.0020944627467542887, -0.004503235686570406, -0.024978190660476685, -0.01760888658463955, 0.05504785478115082, 0.027362270280718803, -0.020263589918613434, -0.02848481945693493, 0.016063177958130836, 0.07749371975660324, -0.024252967908978462, -0.0153876394033432, 0.0392475463449955, -0.025141796097159386, -0.025124812498688698, -0.0032002474181354046, 0.03405546769499779, -0.017095617949962616, -0.00031566162942908704, -0.01476861909031868, 0.020742855966091156, 0.030672812834382057, -0.03641601651906967, -0.055697619915008545, -0.013440566137433052, 0.01211093831807375, 0.06602484732866287, -0.01894119195640087, -0.014669847674667835, -0.02786581963300705, -0.00688677653670311, -0.01294388622045517, 0.017921343445777893, 0.00402088463306427, -0.008100487291812897, 0.04885188862681389, 0.014788060449063778, -0.02516758255660534, 0.01719794236123562, 0.08525843918323517, -0.0023560712579637766, -0.009218364022672176, -0.016413802281022072, -0.0503721721470356, 0.066485196352005, -0.01451865490525961, -0.026490092277526855, -0.0012386065209284425, 0.025573117658495903, -0.04479151591658592, -0.00209885579533875, -0.041509900242090225, -0.014847897924482822, 0.04708300158381462, -0.0006019797874614596, 0.052938830107450485, 0.021165527403354645, 0.032388608902692795, -0.013699333183467388, -0.039153046905994415, -0.017734413966536522, 0.014758257195353508, -0.015473967418074608, 0.00638120761141181, 0.012800754979252815, 0.0485168993473053, -0.0013655773364007473, 0.004518143367022276, 0.01892881840467453, 0.032494090497493744, 0.016020379960536957, 0.03941364213824272, 0.016450494527816772, -0.04236431047320366, -0.025945017114281654, 0.04841034486889839, -0.046501826494932175, 0.05062856525182724, -0.016737155616283417, -0.022879038006067276, 0.024072159081697464, 0.019048742949962616, -0.0023471324238926172, -0.017817910760641098, -0.013066346757113934, -0.04795723408460617, 0.009211666882038116, 0.03052417002618313, -0.030197521671652794, 0.024767009541392326, 0.016473496332764626, 0.05509398505091667, -0.047881074249744415, 0.019252363592386246, -0.04006863757967949, -0.06986939907073975, 0.005465964321047068, 0.006666692905128002, -0.04616188630461693, 0.02338459901511669, 0.011596850119531155, -0.028668148443102837, 0.02723085880279541, -0.04200899973511696, 0.00910188164561987, 0.005053121596574783, 0.030498728156089783, -0.030551275238394737, 0.09697027504444122, -0.01274818368256092, -0.0216587632894516, -0.017986923456192017, -0.012240157462656498, 0.10991236567497253, 0.07195433229207993, 0.06480952352285385, -0.04548348858952522, 0.009097198955714703, -0.007269301451742649, 0.002560489112511277, -0.021976806223392487, -0.006087011191993952, 0.002241052221506834, -0.0025382002349942923, 0.04135524854063988, 0.04840967804193497, 0.01068343035876751, -0.009025270119309425, 0.060567766427993774, 0.008950554765760899, -0.031336717307567596, 0.013023821637034416, 0.004089281894266605, 0.024401867762207985, -0.015255754813551903, -0.051176972687244415, 0.04713375121355057, 0.0005600703880190849, -0.026562239974737167, -0.0451137013733387, -0.024796346202492714, 0.016037579625844955, 0.004092494957149029, -0.016523772850632668, -0.009227617643773556, 0.019236041232943535, 0.025504691526293755, 0.014751335605978966, -0.013903417624533176, -0.021275246515870094, -0.02733582817018032, 0.0023050999734550714, 0.02704557403922081, 0.019351324066519737, 0.007950062863528728, 0.044774141162633896, 0.0045383344404399395, -0.031035052612423897, -0.03718433156609535, -0.05103573948144913, 0.03849978372454643, -0.01696203649044037, 0.022599710151553154, 0.007614013738930225, 0.000890726747456938, -0.02188003621995449, -0.0441792793571949, -0.04224591329693794, 0.014929722063243389, 0.045478180050849915, -0.017095647752285004, -0.03140609338879585, 0.002386639127507806, 0.015078042633831501, 0.0031969191040843725, 0.05011206865310669, 0.037067096680402756, -0.060383494943380356, -0.012330630794167519, -0.03827746585011482, 0.06494047492742538, 0.046388477087020874, -0.035639576613903046, 0.008858965709805489, -0.0636390745639801, -0.023665379732847214, 0.00415923772379756, 0.04110243171453476, -0.0033296470064669847, 0.03954155743122101, 0.005196371115744114, 0.029747003689408302, -0.02902694046497345, -0.007930189371109009, 0.009473745711147785, -0.019204044714570045, 0.014686821028590202, -0.06096121668815613, -0.028900161385536194, 0.014616737142205238, 0.02767486684024334, 0.02886761911213398, 0.034010838717222214, -0.0007316712290048599, 0.04493352398276329, 0.002023249864578247, -0.05763213336467743, -0.013513489626348019, -0.006539276801049709, -0.05087536200881004, 0.026158373802900314, -0.018662074580788612, 0.08191238343715668, -0.013955008238554, 0.033956535160541534, -0.004646369256079197, 0.02084866538643837, -0.008130714297294617, -0.01176777109503746, 0.0235936027020216, -0.0765487477183342, -0.0048127672635018826, -0.009708377532660961, 0.01133208442479372, -0.026195017620921135, -0.024357439950108528, -0.00723270745947957, -0.046359311789274216, 0.012878299690783024, 0.0017548262840136886, -0.01868131384253502, 0.0032451367005705833, -0.04507535323500633, 0.0038463559467345476, -0.021726498380303383, 0.003072501393035054, -0.008191734552383423, -0.03906960412859917, -0.0579133965075016, -0.025024626404047012, 0.03249673545360565, -0.028003470972180367, 0.014083372429013252, 0.01155130472034216, 0.051606301218271255, 0.015549630858004093, 0.046259161084890366, 0.009905178099870682, -0.0018120347522199154, 0.011743813753128052, 0.03063439205288887, -0.013657760806381702, 0.0018044711323454976, 0.0853835865855217, -0.021465901285409927, -0.054512955248355865, 0.018408838659524918, 0.013636017218232155, 0.018677808344364166, -0.0024819793179631233, -0.01996779814362526, -0.027371997013688087, 0.04363435506820679, -0.02239709161221981, -0.019243460148572922, -0.017863525077700615, 0.004482892341911793, -0.015336990356445312, 0.002575858263298869, 0.005417129024863243, -0.02044370397925377, -0.017061952501535416, 0.03949182108044624, 0.025715112686157227, 0.0014992880169302225, -0.021274175494909286, 0.027324331924319267, 0.030872073024511337, 0.0075133563950657845, -0.019918717443943024, 0.014475132338702679, -0.004180288407951593, 0.01658816449344158, -0.01467388030141592, 0.04227805137634277, -0.04147593677043915, 0.013747721910476685, -0.0781158059835434, -0.02035185508430004, 0.04659828543663025, -0.0000031838726499699987, 0.03920278698205948, -0.04765189439058304, -0.012108169496059418, 0.05098916217684746, -0.035455506294965744, 0.05177253857254982, -0.0075430418364703655, -0.005450747907161713, -0.0414167158305645, -0.024061156436800957, -0.01859808713197708, 0.01531919278204441, 0.016329951584339142, 0.038374271243810654, 0.025985587388277054, 0.03173603489995003, -0.0002107446634909138, -0.0112716443836689, 0.007821033708751202, 0.041819874197244644, 0.06375043094158173, -0.06118834391236305, 0.01086405199021101, -0.016734279692173004, 0.014681988395750523, 0.04137048497796059, -0.003011018270626664, 0.0348476767539978, -0.010705962777137756, 0.01034613698720932, 0.01136312447488308, 0.05400959402322769, 0.07603677362203598, 0.03856924548745155, -0.030481496825814247, -0.019854122772812843, 0.027099009603261948, 0.05573444813489914, -0.021299313753843307, 0.00038921929080970585, 0.025135423988103867, -0.01604359783232212, -0.03078456036746502, 0.006974955555051565, -0.011132893152534962, 0.0014536541420966387, -0.018062328919768333, 0.005541738588362932, 0.005439205095171928, -0.05572895333170891, 0.04218897223472595, -0.047085437923669815, 0.004618318751454353, 0.04741822928190231, 0.015941310673952103, -0.012853010557591915, 0.03409565985202789, 0.009367205202579498, -0.020173396915197372, -0.01703794300556183, -0.016604172065854073, 0.014582103118300438, -0.078246109187603, 0.012469383887946606, -0.0140073886141181, -0.026981288567185402, -0.03210424259305, 0.003168548457324505, -0.014332412742078304, 0.08420237898826599, -0.015915824100375175, 0.014168660156428814, 0.020815039053559303, -0.0193544402718544, 0.016889821738004684, -0.08573076874017715, 0.059921786189079285, 0.02079055830836296, -0.008744827471673489, -0.017483919858932495, 0.0049243103712797165, -0.02225913107395172, -0.01604497618973255, 0.06179213896393776, -0.00694762310013175, -0.013563163578510284, 0.011053756810724735, 0.042427003383636475, -0.022245552390813828, -0.058899715542793274, 0.033252518624067307, -0.0033828557934612036, -0.03420032560825348, -0.017214199528098106, 0.0025041771586984396, 0.008702507242560387, 0.019766652956604958, 0.01374100986868143, -0.025280196219682693, 0.022895241156220436, 0.041075143963098526, -0.03401203453540802, 0.02716033346951008, 0.001126771909184754, -0.033674247562885284, 0.017446329817175865, -0.015350336208939552, 0.003750741947442293, -0.0006387195317074656, 0.012015006504952908, -0.05855664610862732, 0.024980520829558372, -0.01775871217250824, -0.037768635898828506, -0.019217904657125473, -0.012127898633480072, -0.01027292013168335, -0.058299630880355835, -0.013788469135761261, 0.01857169158756733, -0.06191183626651764, 0.00961815845221281, -0.005550242029130459, -0.013650715351104736, 0.041887812316417694, 0.0013311738148331642, 0.020009756088256836, -0.0008610242512077093, -0.026200473308563232, -0.007373612839728594, -0.002183612436056137, 0.0047469534911215305, 0.006561362650245428, -0.016026271507143974, 0.029364578425884247, -0.04817856103181839, 0.0628485307097435, -0.004457654897123575, 0.04330720379948616, -0.016411619260907173, -0.03887271508574486, 0.017183074727654457, 0.018544642254710197, 0.004643719643354416, -0.04062724858522415, -0.006385777611285448, 0.03971487656235695, -0.005001899786293507, -0.023310676217079163, -0.047439463436603546, -0.01947983354330063, -0.016826897859573364, -0.001886070822365582, 0.006775221787393093, -0.008826088160276413, -0.0004784782649949193, 0.01239261869341135, 0.00656366441398859, 0.011703201569616795, 0.03302152454853058, -0.034108493477106094, 0.05352359265089035, -0.019734470173716545, -0.005087354686111212, -0.017412588000297546, -0.012186509557068348, -0.05219624564051628, -0.01941172033548355, 0.006146573927253485, 0.01895195245742798, 0.015188702382147312, -0.006980557925999165, -0.028978528454899788, -0.0033596286084502935, 0.06365768611431122, -0.08239434659481049, 0.009121597744524479, -0.007656515575945377, -0.017869731411337852, -0.04426756128668785, -0.043522223830223083 ]
<p>I have $n$ dice with $m$ sides. The $i^{th}$ dice will show value $0 \leq x_i \leq m-1$ with probability $0 \leq D_i(x_i) \leq 1$. What is the probability that the sum of the dice equals $\alpha$</p> <p>Is there some approximation for $P(\alpha)$</p>
73,659
[ -0.031044475734233856, -0.030830426141619682, -0.0009358235402032733, -0.0182436965405941, 0.05334625020623207, 0.03587805852293968, -0.04651813581585884, -0.0248080063611269, 0.012988593429327011, -0.06952127814292908, 0.03158177435398102, 0.046897806227207184, 0.018937507644295692, 0.024323677644133568, 0.03098810836672783, -0.00803872849792242, -0.007340208161622286, -0.03337964415550232, 0.04141024872660637, -0.017004432156682014, 0.03230293467640877, 0.061153676360845566, 0.03775574639439583, -0.0205414816737175, -0.036258719861507416, 0.04694028198719025, 0.00824020430445671, -0.03212304413318634, 0.03337192162871361, 0.09133598953485489, -0.027287662029266357, -0.009676002897322178, 0.05587553605437279, 0.07206307351589203, 0.010891360230743885, 0.005281420890241861, 0.0065274606458842754, -0.03418038785457611, -0.021439379081130028, 0.019237995147705078, -0.04220286011695862, -0.04507739841938019, 0.04217345640063286, 0.02152148447930813, -0.02274489589035511, 0.004201781004667282, 0.012807545252144337, -0.07539106160402298, 0.0003729813906829804, -0.05746481195092201, 0.07591436058282852, -0.025444768369197845, 0.05783204361796379, 0.03135726973414421, 0.011220121756196022, -0.017617477104067802, 0.03981788828969002, 0.06394865363836288, 0.027077222242951393, -0.023002304136753082, -0.002999483374878764, -0.03454821556806564, 0.02871553972363472, -0.02504529058933258, -0.01435703132301569, 0.04342878237366676, 0.005450468976050615, -0.005079952999949455, -0.01692870445549488, -0.03084181807935238, -0.008725781925022602, 0.033180058002471924, 0.039452943950891495, -0.01958722434937954, 0.0018522432073950768, -0.015698200091719627, 0.053117070347070694, 0.047947775572538376, 0.03641620650887489, 0.04542117193341255, 0.01328237820416689, 0.019457777962088585, 0.08459600061178207, 0.00922848004847765, 0.01675781048834324, -0.03962424397468567, 0.042437635362148285, 0.0034590642899274826, -0.004612687975168228, 0.006099566351622343, -0.014825544320046902, -0.007666066754609346, 0.03914535045623779, -0.02616088278591633, -0.053047727793455124, 0.01333300769329071, -0.026679951697587967, 0.0470510795712471, -0.0057940129190683365, -0.02157471887767315, -0.003591087879613042, -0.02066793665289879, 0.0292857363820076, 0.0722714215517044, 0.010239788331091404, 0.0071794260293245316, -0.042414672672748566, 0.010818418115377426, -0.012122822925448418, -0.01599222794175148, -0.01090516708791256, 0.04226692393422127, 0.008599837310612202, -0.013378968462347984, 0.00613844208419323, -0.02229832485318184, -0.023272722959518433, -0.0022414305713027716, 0.011048157699406147, 0.07422521710395813, 0.013757259584963322, -0.005747176706790924, 0.040341299027204514, -0.020625712350010872, -0.061775900423526764, 0.016764087602496147, 0.03424074873328209, -0.024148836731910706, -0.05865640938282013, 0.038739319890737534, -0.004021705128252506, -0.03891560807824135, 0.0016021160408854485, 0.02282983995974064, 0.02814609557390213, 0.0007659895927645266, -0.0640556812286377, -0.06138674169778824, 0.024174967780709267, -0.06516125053167343, -0.025641342625021935, -0.02441718429327011, 0.041851889342069626, 0.0420871265232563, 0.038437530398368835, 0.029856819659471512, 0.05132751539349556, 0.0001631385530345142, 0.02646034024655819, 0.017447197809815407, -0.014836706221103668, -0.02652328833937645, -0.021779216825962067, -0.006769817788153887, -0.010092751123011112, -0.07393515855073929, 0.04783286526799202, 0.012993082404136658, -0.014161703176796436, -0.04375898465514183, 0.07039537280797958, 0.013947991654276848, 0.007059882394969463, -0.014185409992933273, 0.02245001681149006, -0.0443299226462841, 0.07799874991178513, 0.03665096312761307, 0.0549931637942791, 0.0316871702671051, -0.027843547984957695, 0.028142493218183517, 0.008342938497662544, 0.05149796977639198, 0.06172614544630051, -0.03807460516691208, -0.02011224627494812, -0.01814570464193821, 0.01867491379380226, 0.04090961441397667, -0.016063299030065536, 0.009824256412684917, -0.014414430595934391, 0.026794299483299255, 0.030706241726875305, 0.0292693842202425, 0.02345002442598343, -0.022148562595248222, -0.026686672121286392, -0.024744143709540367, -0.03282725065946579, -0.08116722851991653, 0.004883354064077139, 0.007499401457607746, -0.01653803139925003, 0.029512370005249977, 0.008548344485461712, 0.011852498166263103, -0.004382328130304813, -0.009161773137748241, -0.023365365341305733, -0.027301916852593422, 0.0476459264755249, -0.06490374356508255, -0.0018903124146163464, 0.06340789794921875, 0.048201654106378555, -0.0008986926986835897, 0.03469632938504219, -0.018076593056321144, -0.006838170345872641, -0.0020143373403698206, -0.02417048066854477, 0.007169913966208696, -0.017199300229549408, 0.029583778232336044, 0.005734318867325783, -0.0012842484284192324, 0.04327692836523056, 0.014768232591450214, -0.033102188259363174, 0.04023024067282677, 0.05053294822573662, 0.04551943019032478, 0.008933481760323048, -0.0027565935160964727, 0.01010118704289198, -0.010164122097194195, -0.0141222532838583, -0.028632638975977898, -0.028925735503435135, 0.0256664901971817, 0.025067508220672607, 0.023395314812660217, -0.0564737431704998, 0.009660061448812485, 0.07082744687795639, 0.015115281566977501, 0.015105025842785835, 0.03284287452697754, -0.016107244417071342, 0.003755246289074421, -0.009042616933584213, -0.007677879184484482, 0.01526743732392788, 0.029374513775110245, -0.01547410897910595, -0.020070841535925865, 0.03504504635930061, -0.010624448768794537, -0.04536296799778938, 0.02529299445450306, -0.022591497749090195, 0.007858570665121078, -0.03232203796505928, -0.05304618552327156, 0.04278261587023735, 0.0014259633608162403, -0.022871794179081917, 0.05620254948735237, 0.008534613996744156, 0.004498129710555077, -0.039460502564907074, -0.05550329387187958, 0.03545175492763519, 0.008887545205652714, -0.017850268632173538, -0.03516068309545517, 0.012698942795395851, -0.0032825579401105642, -0.00044632566277869046, -0.014742208644747734, -0.029360881075263023, 0.016702713444828987, 0.0036245465744286776, 0.008844932541251183, -0.01544303260743618, -0.010604393668472767, -0.051344312727451324, -0.00758688198402524, -0.003888877108693123, -0.027306457981467247, 0.02677919901907444, 0.011259171180427074, -0.06853397935628891, -0.0005393303581513464, -0.022377151995897293, -0.03600943833589554, 0.06853713095188141, 0.010820438154041767, -0.02109151892364025, 0.012551133520901203, -0.012127886526286602, -0.023414460942149162, -0.006718988995999098, -0.0029741977341473103, -0.017874235287308693, -0.0666809007525444, -0.013174457475543022, -0.009922347031533718, -0.0030113314278423786, -0.009003890678286552, 0.016890782862901688, -0.03331855311989784, -0.0168607197701931, -0.03323234245181084, -0.01958070695400238, 0.0218299999833107, -0.0391070693731308, -0.011382382363080978, 0.03186621889472008, 0.015533366240561008, 0.002615850418806076, -0.08497235178947449, -0.046697504818439484, 0.005059511866420507, -0.01869981363415718, 0.00791340321302414, 0.021836383268237114, -0.056973956525325775, 0.07489235699176788, 0.03790649399161339, 0.009570509195327759, 0.003544716164469719, 0.0022247331216931343, 0.012733056209981441, -0.01576116867363453, 0.023359673097729683, 0.007359715178608894, -0.02136220969259739, 0.028278181329369545, -0.0032081902027130127, 0.01116134412586689, 0.05455581098794937, -0.020841438323259354, -0.006258279085159302, 0.04000793769955635, -0.001164291868917644, 0.022389868274331093, 0.0523826964199543, 0.014915532432496548, -0.005335216410458088, 0.0005498818354681134, 0.00744248740375042, 0.019173508509993553, -0.02618253417313099, -0.03689504787325859, 0.020969325676560402, 0.007628205232322216, 0.024898216128349304, 0.012454239651560783, 0.05879119783639908, 0.023842232301831245, -0.035098373889923096, 0.023295298218727112, 0.018467538058757782, 0.056518830358982086, -0.04352163150906563, 0.027114663273096085, 0.053362470120191574, -0.005490921437740326, -0.007652660831809044, -0.026362134143710136, -0.016052361577749252, -0.00412828428670764, 0.006699194200336933, -0.030954409390687943, 0.003669066121801734, 0.0011995101813226938, 0.024695079773664474, -0.00046261385432444513, -0.020938562229275703, -0.019443368539214134, -0.01264431606978178, -0.07153832912445068, -0.03725167736411095, -0.012157744728028774, 0.04773182049393654, 0.00804814137518406, 0.039421990513801575, 0.035709597170352936, -0.010835548862814903, 0.0005833992036059499, 0.025031397119164467, -0.08883485943078995, 0.033808279782533646, -0.02282252162694931, -0.008402390405535698, -0.018998196348547935, 0.016074202954769135, -0.00992720015347004, -0.01671263761818409, 0.00892738439142704, -0.006072584539651871, -0.005799341946840286, -0.020155690610408783, -0.006990349851548672, 0.002322186715900898, -0.026728371158242226, 0.023702753707766533, 0.08274902403354645, 0.0006183760706335306, 0.0066062710247933865, 0.03678116202354431, 0.005771314725279808, -0.04385438933968544, 0.0007114798645488918, -0.0035365407820791006, -0.002577634761109948, -0.020136607810854912, 0.01431944128125906, 0.038153886795043945, 0.05421461910009384, -0.023144833743572235, -0.016071723774075508, 0.016281381249427795, 0.05580165982246399, 0.04193968325853348, -0.030736301094293594, 0.021277809515595436, -0.0767865851521492, -0.022541215643286705, -0.014286289922893047, -0.00839226320385933, -0.0014915078645572066, 0.014904186129570007, 0.05566873028874397, 0.03189084306359291, -0.059062227606773376, 0.017471926286816597, 0.06409277021884918, 0.018913185223937035, -0.015707548707723618, -0.06794935464859009, -0.025482317432761192, -0.06640759110450745, 0.02800346165895462, 0.008489235304296017, -0.04002269729971886, -0.02387404441833496, -0.027187258005142212, 0.009918848052620888, -0.01692504622042179, -0.004718239419162273, -0.00809062086045742, 0.002327365567907691, 0.03266218304634094, 0.01588893122971058, -0.021813226863741875, 0.04348255693912506, 0.07021048665046692, -0.0019510351121425629, 0.016969505697488785, 0.004314480349421501, -0.02755269780755043, -0.0056941756047308445, 0.025634268298745155, 0.053758665919303894, -0.03949877619743347, 0.011509537696838379, -0.022217882797122, -0.02030976489186287, 0.03320702537894249, -0.011274987831711769, 0.029854973778128624, 0.01391717977821827, 0.018245501443743706, -0.016025593504309654, -0.020692897960543633, -0.07229290902614594, 0.017467522993683815, -0.016296083107590675, 0.037651848047971725, -0.03647569939494133, 0.014728792943060398, -0.06834138184785843, -0.010150470770895481, 0.06813091039657593, 0.06772884726524353, 0.0020699130836874247, -0.005015093367546797, -0.024961654096841812, 0.019648442044854164, -0.01290151197463274, -0.07378332316875458, 0.05291837453842163, -0.020599644631147385, -0.016291501000523567, 0.005329164210706949, -0.040790800005197525, -0.044552527368068695, 0.069235660135746, 0.0189546886831522, 0.01073594018816948, 0.022901330143213272, -0.03750910609960556, 0.014008003287017345, 0.031153734773397446, -0.030365677550435066, 0.02923872508108616, 0.04133908823132515, -0.0353865921497345, -0.0068004438653588295, -0.005387938115745783, -0.009356620721518993, -0.02011602744460106, -0.0069095962680876255, -0.046258460730314255, -0.0008673054398968816, -0.010198642499744892, 0.011335686780512333, -0.03597097471356392, 0.04536484181880951, 0.02491690404713154, -0.02121272124350071, -0.03625698387622833, 0.05739365145564079, 0.025221969932317734, 0.021441686898469925, 0.026787981390953064, 0.012492797337472439, 0.023267725482583046, -0.0054751248098909855, 0.02865213342010975, -0.013106347061693668, 0.0072235893458127975, 0.003958754241466522, -0.04546158388257027, -0.009329921565949917, -0.027884816750884056, -0.02342342399060726, -0.006052474956959486, -0.02104981243610382, 0.04140188917517662, -0.017503973096609116, 0.012281379662454128, -0.005653055850416422, -0.0430380180478096, -0.014393412508070469, 0.013035490177571774, -0.02875477261841297, 0.04946526139974594, -0.05297674611210823, -0.019965797662734985, -0.007682258728891611, -0.012849702499806881, -0.07716365158557892, -0.04212163761258125, 0.02865820936858654, 0.02060607634484768, -0.020524023100733757, -0.007599004078656435, 0.02155710943043232, -0.016929082572460175, -0.01946019008755684, -0.0018136113649234176, 0.06250479072332382, 0.00751100480556488, 0.005632838234305382, -0.006483842618763447, -0.015937618911266327, 0.04973660409450531, -0.0019767137710005045, -0.025249142199754715, 0.017708763480186462, -0.04326774924993515, -0.0037481386680155993, -0.047895390540361404, 0.018999559804797173, -0.052521269768476486, -0.0009614549926482141, -0.011670725420117378, -0.02261490933597088, 0.01758640818297863, -0.004095076117664576, 0.026418888941407204, -0.02986457571387291, 0.016841357573866844, 0.011222977191209793, -0.02863893285393715, -0.0032373203430324793, 0.016932256519794464, 0.016764776781201363, -0.010714839212596416, -0.012883207760751247, -0.002300627762451768, -0.0020598690025508404, 0.025509068742394447, 0.004094211850315332, -0.004550271201878786, 0.029549740254878998, 0.09405974298715591, 0.002095611533150077, -0.004073915537446737, 0.0007103252573870122, 0.004283333662897348, 0.02260870486497879, 0.00751113798469305, -0.030341986566781998, 0.020952751860022545, 0.01267944648861885, -0.014757919125258923, -0.02610853500664234, -0.03192815184593201, 0.04791617393493652, 0.04902416840195656, -0.022724641487002373, 0.00498539162799716, 0.023139169439673424, 0.022724872455000877, -0.02555624209344387, 0.015193690545856953, -0.01174017321318388, 0.0026027285493910313, 0.003550469409674406, 0.023699302226305008, -0.03256998583674431, 0.006208748556673527, 0.03223272040486336, -0.004941643215715885, -0.008564667776226997, 0.02307320013642311, 0.009105200879275799, -0.005417916923761368, 0.025959964841604233, -0.008062446489930153, -0.015170058235526085, 0.02340853214263916, -0.055824488401412964, -0.0026705360505729914, -0.025549687445163727, -0.07829289138317108, 0.03540146350860596, 0.0112815136089921, 0.03596824035048485, -0.021177850663661957, -0.022861232981085777, 0.005652463994920254, -0.01726074516773224, 0.03198297321796417, 0.0304933600127697, 0.014685549773275852, 0.01566980592906475, 0.008502133190631866, -0.020553726702928543, 0.02539728209376335, 0.004554768092930317, -0.04002257436513901, 0.009688222780823708, -0.05709157884120941, -0.061767853796482086, 0.008212000131607056, 0.009171543642878532, 0.006817555520683527, 0.004832952283322811, -0.023485586047172546, 0.021574711427092552, -0.00500234542414546, 0.01124424859881401, -0.012689393013715744, 0.05185230076313019, 0.014789324253797531, 0.04991259053349495, 0.01801021583378315, -0.03652353212237358, 0.10605800151824951, 0.050931189209222794, 0.0480765737593174, -0.058809731155633926, 0.012441861443221569, -0.006460791919380426, -0.008161489851772785, -0.033592671155929565, 0.01250105258077383, 0.02142285369336605, -0.01118050143122673, 0.0019351185765117407, 0.06411876529455185, -0.022978084161877632, 0.00498236482962966, 0.0436534509062767, -0.040823791176080704, -0.028730209916830063, 0.013837523758411407, 0.0022234299685806036, 0.0074165440164506435, -0.0009394470253027976, -0.03406812623143196, 0.03171927481889725, -0.001202652114443481, -0.039194460958242416, -0.05994150787591934, 0.0003736862854566425, -0.009235166013240814, 0.013962864875793457, -0.03701571002602577, -0.020129993557929993, 0.04902758076786995, -0.010465187020599842, 0.0021053508389741182, 0.01906433515250683, 0.023177405819296837, -0.03789679333567619, 0.031709376722574234, 0.040046196430921555, -0.007538204081356525, 0.02258002571761608, 0.0066878655925393105, 0.003914361819624901, -0.06697850674390793, -0.030557697638869286, -0.038259945809841156, 0.03643597662448883, -0.04919133335351944, 0.02044038102030754, 0.01171933114528656, -0.013963889330625534, -0.04675096645951271, -0.0726633295416832, -0.0029871019069105387, 0.04643086716532707, 0.02108505368232727, -0.03847288340330124, -0.029793912544846535, -0.000665792147628963, 0.0511663444340229, -0.008020351640880108, 0.008072762750089169, -0.007578338496387005, -0.04825897514820099, 0.0069932956248521805, -0.015933362767100334, 0.04337019845843315, -0.01690453663468361, -0.014328466728329659, -0.016494857147336006, 0.021196624264121056, -0.02685730718076229, -0.0060692960396409035, -0.024184929206967354, -0.03178820013999939, 0.04014972969889641, 0.01151701994240284, -0.017294250428676605, 0.02264833077788353, -0.06253635138273239, -0.0033994249533861876, -0.06302903592586517, 0.02796347253024578, -0.061462029814720154, -0.031594663858413696, 0.017687486484646797, 0.020249076187610626, -0.011598157696425915, -0.008195452392101288, 0.008792226202785969, 0.02975338324904442, 0.007471270859241486, -0.018247125670313835, -0.001359828282147646, -0.014904025010764599, -0.03234519809484482, 0.01985527016222477, -0.030835077166557312, 0.02175751142203808, 0.024204036220908165, 0.0063528683967888355, 0.04319749400019646, 0.002106160158291459, -0.01909131370484829, 0.019934214651584625, -0.034678924828767776, -0.0548686720430851, 0.009330754168331623, 0.009841764345765114, 0.014890959486365318, -0.030340248718857765, -0.0048827663995325565, -0.002895018085837364, 0.004757834132760763, -0.010400074534118176, -0.025608103722333908, -0.01241642888635397, -0.024225566536188126, -0.020969102159142494, -0.0056183673441410065, 0.023221807554364204, -0.021183352917432785, -0.015455709770321846, -0.028040913864970207, 0.03524284064769745, -0.008149915374815464, -0.001844890764914453, -0.009194208309054375, 0.00362946349196136, 0.012170112691819668, 0.04409865289926529, 0.058721981942653656, 0.013302028179168701, 0.0038526144344359636, 0.045921631157398224, -0.008579986169934273, 0.060424093157052994, -0.038728564977645874, -0.02194165624678135, 0.05277765169739723, -0.058190636336803436, -0.044992122799158096, 0.045947637408971786, 0.008675911463797092, 0.035155732184648514, 0.010309582576155663, 0.015393596142530441, -0.026624999940395355, 0.01873101480305195, -0.04983760043978691, -0.04702886939048767, 0.010653470642864704, 0.021025381982326508, 0.033941954374313354, -0.0047399490140378475, -0.004366496577858925, -0.0046276915818452835, 0.013787796720862389, -0.007993955165147781, 0.021369794383645058, 0.012403988279402256, 0.0014066939475014806, 0.038448765873909, 0.019266214221715927, 0.0028261328116059303, 0.03075968101620674, -0.012478296644985676, -0.01797356829047203, 0.05398399755358696, -0.02553977631032467, 0.0536859966814518, -0.0029488319996744394, -0.011361450888216496, -0.09722661226987839, 0.009262721054255962, -0.0030412226915359497, 0.013200120069086552, 0.060608383268117905, -0.06448328495025635, 0.02867675945162773, 0.04950365424156189, -0.08606395125389099, 0.0306341964751482, 0.009603563696146011, -0.022244831547141075, -0.04374910518527031, 0.027100296691060066, -0.0033230178523808718, 0.04201066493988037, 0.011420182883739471, 0.0362328365445137, 0.05735161900520325, 0.008465534076094627, -0.007246645167469978, -0.053042810410261154, 0.00767994299530983, 0.058124907314777374, -0.05405617505311966, -0.029971657320857048, 0.045928969979286194, -0.011607917957007885, -0.03607814759016037, 0.016196778044104576, -0.010367682203650475, 0.01939435303211212, -0.0065359026193618774, 0.023578336462378502, 0.0179178174585104, 0.042895227670669556, 0.006261276546865702, -0.008277653716504574, -0.009256471879780293, 0.006751381792128086, 0.001106446492485702, -0.007928811945021152, -0.04046228528022766, 0.013320431113243103, 0.06308099627494812, -0.002470795763656497, -0.04913601279258728, 0.012564079836010933, 0.03145992010831833, -0.053927063941955566, -0.0130922207608819, 0.0027598110027611256, -0.0013487681280821562, -0.0587044358253479, 0.02371019311249256, -0.03277101740241051, -0.001537240226753056, -0.0010439392644912004, 0.006555710453540087, -0.024264303967356682, -0.0024107596836984158, 0.003282461315393448, -0.05787927284836769, 0.010392915457487106, -0.017965253442525864, -0.024503638967871666, -0.026659194380044937, 0.016005946323275566, 0.0038788029924035072, 0.019602704793214798, -0.004658883437514305, -0.038072872906923294, -0.006217889953404665, -0.004126260988414288, -0.02499830722808838, 0.007901536300778389, 0.005880407989025116, -0.032465629279613495, 0.01551769394427538, -0.05087362229824066, 0.04882790520787239, -0.024857047945261, -0.0017650170484557748, -0.006897209212183952, -0.016396857798099518, -0.025196855887770653, -0.045156657695770264, 0.032278094440698624, 0.011782525107264519, -0.004100208170711994, -0.005836858879774809, 0.019586889073252678, 0.028666576370596886, -0.03283897787332535, 0.01935664750635624, -0.03297283500432968, -0.023474624380469322, -0.056862279772758484, -0.0024425648152828217, 0.04663188382983208, 0.030784348025918007, 0.010357296094298363, -0.02690761908888817, -0.004585768096148968, -0.024759288877248764, 0.01463119126856327, 0.019190408289432526, 0.025928981602191925, 0.0006461029406636953, 0.08949499577283859, -0.0153774069622159, 0.012234884314239025, 0.006359926424920559, -0.00785668846219778, -0.039254650473594666, 0.01841377280652523, -0.009546720422804356, -0.05122043937444687, -0.006994379684329033, 0.006758056581020355, -0.01797594130039215, -0.04379480332136154, -0.0016063428483903408, 0.032862696796655655, -0.01344801764935255, -0.041041821241378784, 0.028300022706389427, 0.011522335931658745, 0.06446190178394318, 0.016185952350497246, 0.025548871606588364, 0.028733476996421814, -0.005276424344629049, 0.0026021285448223352, 0.005289276596158743, 0.052133575081825256, -0.011698475107550621, 0.013437431305646896, -0.0036276457831263542, -0.0054182447493076324, 0.0099446726962924, -0.01588921807706356, 0.01674915850162506, 0.02140960842370987, -0.011832409538328648, 0.025625111535191536, -0.03383753448724747, 0.010705552063882351, -0.008122916333377361, -0.0020029323641210794, 0.04484046995639801, -0.011978081427514553, 0.03198673948645592, -0.03213445097208023, -0.0354803204536438, -0.03604675084352493, -0.010952710174024105, 0.014059947803616524, 0.045610543340444565, -0.00917117204517126, -0.05434807389974594, 0.028532600030303, 0.023333098739385605, 0.050902582705020905, -0.017512211576104164, 0.020437531173229218, 0.007110876962542534, -0.018285872414708138, -0.017217153683304787, -0.03477012366056442, -0.0009473758982494473, -0.03202395886182785, 0.0543382428586483, 0.03149094805121422, 0.03825164958834648, 0.024881895631551743, -0.03287602961063385, -0.0023912768810987473, 0.05410986766219139, -0.025937136262655258, -0.00995404738932848, -0.05483021214604378, 0.0028124426025897264, 0.033826570957899094, 0.021133825182914734 ]
<p>I use SPSS, but am forced to use R for exact logistic regression. So I'm brand new to R (and hating it so far) and also new to logistic regression. I've read the original elrm paper and looked at examples of its use. However, I can't find information on the questions below (after the data description).</p> <p>The fit of two models of cognitive processing was compared for each subject in each of 3 conditions. My binary dependent variable is whether the difference in model fits was significant or not (my "Success" variable below). I have three experimental Conditions: 0, 1, and 2. 0 is my reference group. My question is: is there an overall effect of Condition? If so, which conditions differ? The specific alternative hypothesis is that the proportion/probability of "success" should be greater in conditions 0 and 1 than in condition 2. My data look like</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/OAFtP.gif" alt="original data"></p> <p>...and so on. SPSS actually creates the dummy variables for you on the fly but they are easy enough to create explicitly.</p> <p><strong>Question 1:</strong> I have read that to use elrm you have to enter the data such that the response variable represents success/number of trials. And as far as I can tell elrm doesn't create dummy variables automatically. I've seen examples of tables representing this data structure, but can't find any step-by-step examples of getting raw data into that format, espescially given a one-variable 3-levels situation. Is there an example out there that I'm missing? If not, is this what the data should look like? </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/aVxOL.gif" alt="reformated data"></p> <p>I'm not sure how I'd enter the dummy variables into the formula...just as separate variables?</p> <p><strong>Question 2:</strong> I can see how I can get the tests of the coefficients of the dummy variables. But I can't figure out how to get a test of the overall effect of the independent variable. I need to evaluate the overall effect of Condition before looking at individual conditions. Is there a way to get that out of elrm? (I found an example of this done for the aod package which runs regular logistic regression but not exact logistic regression.)</p> <p><strong>Question 3:</strong> I can't find a description of what the p-value for individual coeffeicients represents in elrm. Is this is for the Wald test?</p>
73,660
[ -0.047153767198324203, -0.01646515540778637, -0.006734565831720829, 0.013412819243967533, 0.0012421328574419022, -0.012222602032124996, -0.011987213976681232, -0.031041612848639488, 0.025180451571941376, 0.0056127323769032955, 0.05459496006369591, 0.05333173647522926, 0.032083481550216675, 0.019282348453998566, 0.011439372785389423, 0.01984284818172455, 0.028035806491971016, -0.007201820611953735, -0.032075025141239166, 0.007252112030982971, 0.002080612350255251, -0.012379104271531105, 0.00037821882870048285, 0.01869545318186283, -0.01855655014514923, 0.056114327162504196, 0.026006901636719704, -0.04752490669488907, -0.00786902941763401, 0.04662248119711876, -0.004528441000729799, -0.03515799343585968, 0.004639489576220512, -0.007950988598167896, 0.0004124526458326727, 0.0070356945507228374, -0.018766988068819046, -0.00020430127915460616, -0.006214025430381298, 0.015238432213664055, 0.00305312336422503, -0.011205528862774372, -0.00014351856952998787, 0.06214383989572525, 0.00044735826668329537, 0.018600158393383026, 0.0054382625967264175, -0.020497014746069908, 0.018628884106874466, -0.03486651927232742, 0.049987129867076874, -0.002157825045287609, 0.02333378978073597, 0.07338123023509979, 0.02656666748225689, 0.0011508559109643102, 0.07901345193386078, 0.0463283509016037, 0.0012679538922384381, -0.034056514501571655, -0.020044412463903427, -0.03759006783366203, -0.02204103395342827, 0.0023095724172890186, -0.04429815709590912, 0.019905399531126022, 0.028005218133330345, 0.01753617823123932, 0.060718923807144165, -0.02188197150826454, 0.015098540112376213, -0.01065149437636137, 0.008440983481705189, -0.004336156416684389, 0.023457614704966545, -0.03638925403356552, 0.0028756428509950638, -0.013719671405851841, 0.009625525213778019, 0.07240038365125656, 0.003889869898557663, -0.0037750261835753918, 0.009053349494934082, 0.0432073250412941, -0.00636191526427865, -0.015254228375852108, 0.05599755048751831, -0.04051783308386803, 0.010829189792275429, 0.002389316214248538, -0.03018496371805668, 0.027468470856547356, 0.05552941560745239, 0.016315357759594917, -0.022633317857980728, 0.006971909198909998, -0.010966978035867214, 0.041487500071525574, 0.021748069673776627, 0.020878512412309647, -0.026635929942131042, -0.0415455661714077, 0.00799537543207407, 0.04762037843465805, -0.04586970806121826, 0.028655635192990303, -0.006310738623142242, 0.018801286816596985, -0.024210786446928978, -0.07093026489019394, 0.03497275337576866, 0.051053427159786224, 0.022976862266659737, 0.00812961719930172, 0.018231147900223732, -0.060199204832315445, -0.013012755662202835, -0.05695885792374611, 0.04991495981812477, 0.04638304188847542, 0.028456781059503555, -0.026602135971188545, 0.011270415037870407, -0.02826230227947235, -0.0532107874751091, 0.0221698097884655, 0.0008692815899848938, 0.004516254644840956, -0.01861029863357544, 0.0570603683590889, -0.013303231447935104, -0.015128392726182938, 0.02744385600090027, 0.017084641382098198, -0.0005417800857685506, -0.008142257109284401, -0.07361531257629395, -0.034082744270563126, 0.021356793120503426, -0.009859294630587101, 0.01356023084372282, -0.045051347464323044, -0.022777559235692024, 0.011489162221550941, 0.01771565154194832, -0.03557051718235016, 0.0301650520414114, 0.021369140595197678, 0.014273063279688358, 0.03910871967673302, -0.05187090486288071, 0.01731928624212742, -0.06599222868680954, -0.016484390944242477, 0.003468461101874709, -0.09442224353551865, 0.0561770461499691, 0.02420281432569027, -0.012662781402468681, 0.019216876477003098, 0.04231658950448036, -0.012876204214990139, -0.009377749636769295, 0.0047315857373178005, 0.013471572659909725, 0.0276139285415411, 0.02028256468474865, -0.03766631707549095, 0.0020046939607709646, 0.01306175533682108, -0.01275490690022707, 0.018821261823177338, -0.009625119157135487, 0.02902337908744812, 0.010828441008925438, -0.0594603568315506, 0.006124197505414486, -0.014370367862284184, -0.041823066771030426, -0.008545867167413235, -0.0421861931681633, -0.024699466302990913, -0.014091411605477333, -0.02973000332713127, 0.004358960781246424, 0.05134301260113716, 0.006404068320989609, -0.024899782612919807, 0.0374784953892231, 0.012242214754223824, -0.08791431039571762, -0.06341701000928879, 0.03758666291832924, 0.018527809530496597, -0.05722534656524658, 0.012544349767267704, -0.0232208501547575, 0.024657174944877625, 0.00198340299539268, -0.0057445247657597065, -0.0033938707783818245, -0.010538514703512192, 0.03601010516285896, -0.03739401325583458, 0.01519033219665289, 0.05010571703314781, 0.021297721192240715, -0.019017158076167107, 0.05621984973549843, -0.05211853235960007, -0.027506094425916672, 0.014547813683748245, -0.006751318462193012, 0.061431385576725006, -0.04089302569627762, -0.015209455043077469, 0.022784510627388954, 0.04486497491598129, -0.017073148861527443, 0.029286837205290794, -0.0912318080663681, 0.08272489905357361, 0.06487265229225159, -0.00834018923342228, -0.006492084823548794, 0.024124054238200188, -0.0014365919632837176, 0.023131225258111954, -0.016274111345410347, -0.005819081794470549, -0.067623570561409, -0.0336034782230854, 0.021304279565811157, -0.027792850509285927, -0.03397350385785103, 0.031949520111083984, 0.02919990010559559, 0.0068097468465566635, 0.0100021967664361, 0.03601968288421631, -0.004936398472636938, -0.05403878912329674, 0.0012347265146672726, 0.015133850276470184, -0.0026747058145701885, 0.024555902928113937, 0.004161576274782419, 0.03787149861454964, 0.04110295698046684, 0.026382574811577797, 0.007680624723434448, 0.0520794577896595, -0.003802180290222168, -0.0056869215331971645, -0.03722997382283211, -0.017354007810354233, 0.04414254426956177, -0.047922492027282715, -0.013150126673281193, 0.04580642655491829, 0.03491422161459923, -0.046151403337717056, 0.01361004263162613, 0.004815130028873682, 0.027309073135256767, 0.07776129990816116, -0.010824727825820446, 0.004887870978564024, -0.0009344615391455591, -0.0505734458565712, 0.012356065213680267, 0.002439463045448065, -0.02978886477649212, -0.04426270350813866, 0.0027740257792174816, 0.023487558588385582, -0.027844170108437538, 0.008219840005040169, -0.030293677002191544, 0.0019360280130058527, 0.012628682889044285, 0.023879636079072952, 0.04938643425703049, -0.023030733689665794, -0.08300860971212387, -0.04656929895281792, -0.05946788564324379, -0.024218492209911346, 0.018202396109700203, -0.01264085154980421, -0.049888450652360916, 0.0014876008499413729, 0.003899610135704279, -0.04665887728333473, 0.005437875632196665, -0.04106633737683296, 0.01633625477552414, -0.003360486589372158, -0.01251298189163208, 0.04834628105163574, 0.06527653336524963, -0.04149826243519783, -0.018384873867034912, -0.021951941773295403, -0.012493154965341091, 0.010329268872737885, 0.0039389245212078094, -0.010645410977303982, -0.012718225829303265, 0.002704151440411806, 0.0038402441423386335, -0.022706840187311172, 0.02552087791264057, -0.08579494059085846, -0.02616005204617977, -0.010195690207183361, 0.039837729185819626, 0.05007981136441231, -0.025133900344371796, 0.008107266388833523, 0.0632072389125824, 0.03264469653367996, -0.008163594640791416, -0.09314599633216858, 0.005694156046956778, -0.033083315938711166, -0.017081445083022118, 0.024977875873446465, 0.017959611490368843, -0.004343576729297638, -0.004743106663227081, -0.03820721432566643, 0.02783578261733055, 0.02158202789723873, 0.015022195875644684, 0.0062100947834551334, 0.018248381093144417, -0.008408750407397747, -0.061377715319395065, -0.004273995757102966, 0.03541742265224457, -0.055277515202760696, 0.03288855403661728, -0.007787507493048906, 0.02158363163471222, -0.03577045723795891, -0.03667013719677925, 0.016290731728076935, -0.009330225177109241, -0.0007313180831260979, -0.04830286651849747, 0.024644197896122932, -0.002657858422026038, -0.06307375431060791, 0.006679876241832972, 0.0017193863168358803, 0.016104646027088165, -0.0004992601461708546, 0.027700886130332947, 0.037414953112602234, 0.048266906291246414, -0.03007323667407036, -0.03389855846762657, -0.046384550631046295, -0.00943609420210123, 0.01649564877152443, -0.02837100811302662, -0.019398469477891922, 0.03745593503117561, 0.04748346284031868, 0.035543691366910934, -0.009677756577730179, -0.016672156751155853, 0.003999592736363411, -0.06112019345164299, -0.03036370314657688, -0.017523322254419327, 0.04151827469468117, 0.004042203072458506, 0.07471323013305664, -0.000023601613065693527, -0.02215695194900036, 0.004810332786291838, 0.02956029213964939, -0.03849364072084427, 0.011551727540791035, -0.03501395881175995, -0.0026110915932804346, 0.06129772961139679, -0.004719259217381477, 0.035355500876903534, -0.04713590815663338, -0.025166774168610573, 0.023623107001185417, 0.0627111867070198, 0.0017794809537008405, -0.014466455206274986, 0.011317259632050991, 0.008112102746963501, -0.01438896544277668, 0.030177533626556396, -0.020431512966752052, 0.0162209365516901, -0.004086120519787073, 0.012937167659401894, -0.01333567313849926, 0.014707670547068119, -0.021567070856690407, 0.005137162748724222, 0.04285525530576706, 0.07020968943834305, 0.02159133553504944, -0.009095980785787106, -0.03846750035881996, 0.036601316183805466, 0.02025647461414337, 0.027441609650850296, 0.08247967064380646, -0.006178238429129124, -0.041251737624406815, -0.023734141141176224, -0.004131346940994263, -0.03406604006886482, 0.023049717769026756, -0.005846849177032709, -0.009465350769460201, 0.03899352252483368, 0.047531504184007645, -0.047567643225193024, 0.0013730117352679372, 0.05285443365573883, 0.0299875158816576, 0.009496304206550121, -0.04092167317867279, 0.009471546858549118, -0.004014226607978344, 0.02090330980718136, 0.03722616657614708, 0.020786138251423836, -0.0034845767077058554, 0.0025398717261850834, 0.06350556761026382, -0.020050756633281708, -0.04596320912241936, 0.0011354017769917846, -0.015811393037438393, -0.004778689239174128, 0.012859802693128586, -0.05657532066106796, -0.010400909930467606, 0.06753405183553696, 0.040102019906044006, -0.014753938652575016, -0.03424311801791191, -0.032690998166799545, 0.029807662591338158, 0.03415284678339958, 0.06497311592102051, -0.03378833830356598, 0.01107783429324627, -0.015173252671957016, -0.006749363150447607, 0.007868832908570766, -0.0438995398581028, -0.006310466676950455, 0.0024476381950080395, 0.04157823696732521, -0.05824057385325432, -0.06097831577062607, -0.041433051228523254, 0.018132885918021202, -0.0505373552441597, 0.04289687052369118, -0.012200365774333477, -0.034592404961586, -0.01968911662697792, 0.0032271062955260277, 0.004129414912313223, 0.04494677111506462, -0.04731374233961105, 0.004330963362008333, 0.012404107488691807, -0.01958240568637848, -0.03605878725647926, -0.049700718373060226, -0.0003747914161067456, -0.021350201219320297, 0.011323455721139908, 0.05777055025100708, -0.003071015700697899, -0.021793536841869354, 0.023851055651903152, 0.029099224135279655, -0.026096520945429802, 0.008708016015589237, -0.02953561581671238, 0.04682327061891556, -0.0025386768393218517, -0.0036934888921678066, 0.05625586956739426, 0.005541304592043161, 0.002451441716402769, 0.03637223690748215, -0.010317320004105568, -0.015445548109710217, -0.022707363590598106, -0.032315079122781754, -0.04088132455945015, 0.003586983773857355, -0.002326876623556018, 0.02196739800274372, -0.011143422685563564, 0.04625049978494644, -0.030481936410069466, -0.02254299260675907, 0.026563847437500954, 0.007445523981004953, 0.008764272555708885, 0.006983826402574778, 0.00463597709313035, 0.006878581363707781, -0.024105027318000793, -0.03459304943680763, 0.033178746700286865, -0.030177708715200424, 0.008508330211043358, 0.009142506867647171, -0.050574250519275665, 0.00763472355902195, -0.028249718248844147, -0.03232421353459358, 0.02089465782046318, -0.028045902028679848, 0.01677868142724037, -0.017518775537610054, 0.027767999097704887, -0.01705295220017433, -0.048911694437265396, -0.020343173295259476, 0.0004836054577026516, -0.010019810870289803, 0.0059460741467773914, 0.004940593149513006, -0.0030096753034740686, -0.01686546392738819, 0.0014451576862484217, -0.06140711531043053, -0.02896115556359291, -0.006585580296814442, -0.024931935593485832, -0.0026035460177809, -0.032345566898584366, -0.03107728250324726, -0.010055736638605595, -0.044892679899930954, -0.0016080025816336274, 0.08874880522489548, -0.013261379674077034, 0.019650371745228767, -0.00332077918574214, -0.0016389362281188369, 0.029856862500309944, 0.02424277551472187, -0.02548331767320633, -0.021856261417269707, -0.015557048842310905, -0.01917673461139202, 0.015346533618867397, -0.026885708793997765, -0.009682494215667248, -0.022541910409927368, -0.04848148673772812, 0.002769848331809044, 0.014391783624887466, -0.025691885501146317, -0.0313599668443203, 0.00848845299333334, -0.06099574267864227, 0.02040134370326996, -0.04597451537847519, -0.004073684103786945, -0.02170456200838089, 0.011220935732126236, -0.02026248909533024, 0.01586293801665306, -0.038298025727272034, -0.02487567625939846, 0.013629232533276081, -0.013085542246699333, -0.009861962869763374, 0.027548156678676605, 0.0977647453546524, 0.06298965960741043, 0.037742774933576584, -0.020099619403481483, -0.012500161305069923, 0.03827899694442749, 0.018619444221258163, 0.011532744392752647, 0.011275006458163261, 0.020425613969564438, -0.006591873709112406, -0.013280387967824936, -0.02779303677380085, 0.0144815593957901, 0.03709390014410019, -0.019159948453307152, 0.04004419595003128, 0.04224066436290741, -0.04290778562426567, 0.004459743853658438, -0.03214197978377342, 0.005009917076677084, -0.00808990839868784, 0.022481603547930717, 0.05664406716823578, -0.01180197298526764, 0.006504216697067022, 0.050495732575654984, 0.016444021835923195, 0.03016980178654194, 0.04809898883104324, 0.025296073406934738, 0.0014587092446163297, 0.024665070697665215, -0.04065144807100296, -0.04598254710435867, -0.0003053875407204032, -0.04541745409369469, 0.008698023855686188, -0.021575288847088814, -0.022001322358846664, 0.033984508365392685, 0.07318728417158127, 0.003532880451530218, -0.05270814523100853, -0.041801225394010544, -0.048885561525821686, -0.0048572346568107605, 0.033027227967977524, -0.04459479823708534, 0.02959248051047325, 0.03240404650568962, 0.010682854801416397, 0.003731826785951853, 0.004843621514737606, 0.0009492694516666234, -0.08641815930604935, -0.014729275368154049, -0.01532046590000391, -0.025517737492918968, 0.0352434404194355, -0.006697007920593023, -0.019887486472725868, 0.0316363088786602, -0.04596761614084244, 0.02037910930812359, 0.013257450424134731, 0.024987224489450455, 0.009529548697173595, 0.04361090064048767, -0.005721209105104208, 0.013412220403552055, -0.026630589738488197, -0.013426164165139198, 0.13504910469055176, 0.10786446183919907, 0.024283431470394135, -0.08655616641044617, 0.0193297378718853, 0.05060359835624695, 0.003913416061550379, 0.019008265808224678, -0.0035865060053765774, -0.00027787635917775333, -0.012255221605300903, 0.03214758262038231, 0.05985791236162186, 0.020204322412610054, -0.014125722460448742, 0.03503402695059776, -0.014575325883924961, -0.028126200661063194, 0.025139769539237022, 0.005242917221039534, -0.00997349712997675, -0.03185105696320534, -0.007337844930589199, 0.006858239881694317, -0.0019397065043449402, -0.019775230437517166, -0.013370438478887081, 0.008580826222896576, -0.004191354848444462, -0.010766264982521534, -0.01998467929661274, -0.020819127559661865, 0.01074673980474472, -0.004086675588041544, -0.0033955113030970097, -0.002112969057634473, 0.049338214099407196, -0.05713688209652901, 0.013499113731086254, 0.03812919557094574, -0.04230782017111778, 0.0009199485066346824, -0.01701045036315918, 0.004502582363784313, -0.0517074316740036, -0.03230995684862137, -0.02185073308646679, 0.06723382323980331, -0.028127126395702362, -0.04643787816166878, -0.0149839511141181, 0.01425235252827406, 0.01393947098404169, -0.025845928117632866, -0.014661161229014397, 0.0267297625541687, 0.008062652312219143, -0.028668344020843506, -0.03393397852778435, -0.03795173764228821, -0.0002600557345431298, 0.036402199417352676, 0.03327460214495659, -0.00499935494735837, -0.029775049537420273, -0.017840122804045677, -0.050589319318532944, 0.010193043388426304, 0.019058004021644592, -0.0019166548736393452, 0.018726730719208717, 0.005624151322990656, -0.0076628318056464195, -0.010180785320699215, 0.031144563108682632, 0.04027901217341423, 0.016387125477194786, 0.00935626495629549, -0.004919650964438915, -0.03136233240365982, -0.035214174538850784, -0.006622148212045431, -0.0391848124563694, 0.003759918734431267, -0.04517069086432457, 0.025285819545388222, 0.03978784754872322, 0.015604865737259388, 0.021827571094036102, 0.00182771822437644, 0.01922006346285343, 0.032052747905254364, -0.016986075788736343, -0.06144578009843826, -0.01858903467655182, 0.013774425722658634, -0.046214912086725235, -0.013143855147063732, -0.015935031697154045, 0.06292217969894409, -0.004033831413835287, 0.010980875231325626, -0.023417247459292412, 0.036919500678777695, 0.018090108409523964, -0.009930274449288845, -0.0007110016304068267, -0.023352015763521194, 0.0016445103101432323, 0.016347762197256088, 0.04039973393082619, -0.006244868505746126, 0.002687652362510562, -0.05622326582670212, -0.03936375305056572, 0.012578491121530533, -0.04143231734633446, -0.014658274129033089, 0.04016995429992676, -0.013957379385828972, 0.01876142807304859, -0.005356301553547382, 0.002762389834970236, -0.017366508021950722, -0.004472488071769476, -0.012059366330504417, -0.03462092578411102, 0.016723541542887688, 0.020140739157795906, 0.019664540886878967, 0.0438842698931694, 0.03767232969403267, 0.0143020860850811, -0.005627648904919624, -0.013875016942620277, 0.023374946787953377, 0.004229546524584293, 0.04789324849843979, 0.01666407659649849, -0.02740909345448017, 0.000029133179850759916, -0.026403915137052536, -0.005872425157576799, 0.040717970579862595, -0.020554194226861, 0.04143010079860687, 0.010282734408974648, 0.004499476402997971, -0.03042636439204216, 0.04189278557896614, -0.0013757760170847178, -0.0031518747564405203, -0.017316333949565887, 0.02772478014230728, 0.0503595732152462, 0.024604564532637596, -0.010018398053944111, 0.012869576923549175, -0.023063594475388527, 0.057297397404909134, 0.02757156454026699, 0.02345462515950203, 0.010555480606853962, -0.01462510135024786, -0.053831323981285095, 0.027701612561941147, 0.025291841477155685, -0.0541897676885128, 0.043861210346221924, 0.05600482597947121, 0.01199995819479227, 0.07385548949241638, 0.013472184538841248, 0.0015878588892519474, -0.09135305136442184, -0.015495476312935352, 0.028287407010793686, 0.05102738365530968, 0.03168546035885811, -0.0491110198199749, -0.005292803514748812, 0.024440934881567955, -0.029809625819325447, 0.010388380847871304, 0.05237729102373123, -0.0020646918565034866, -0.02473527565598488, -0.0025858257431536913, 0.002790571190416813, 0.00942915864288807, 0.0012523841578513384, -0.02675742469727993, 0.009828389622271061, 0.02350485883653164, 0.007582439575344324, -0.02339446172118187, -0.029469938948750496, 0.028145911172032356, 0.005618199240416288, -0.051115285605192184, 0.03875722736120224, -0.05053098127245903, -0.01256884727627039, 0.00897149182856083, 0.010308449156582355, 0.014920556917786598, 0.028660858049988747, 0.033614691346883774, 0.004701587371528149, 0.03546169027686119, 0.018760643899440765, 0.00742914667353034, 0.031204383820295334, 0.0092104347422719, 0.02082035131752491, 0.03177937492728233, 0.0017516177613288164, -0.0069887107238173485, 0.029895558953285217, 0.0003132596320938319, -0.02704603038728237, 0.018430598080158234, -0.032697197049856186, -0.006351193878799677, -0.013119470328092575, -0.021870216354727745, -0.004021236672997475, -0.023230599239468575, 0.024758026003837585, -0.07403955608606339, -0.01782311499118805, 0.011374548077583313, -0.015342324040830135, -0.015808671712875366, 0.04538607597351074, -0.01696683280169964, -0.015405697748064995, -0.005383918061852455, -0.022206082940101624, -0.004790846724063158, -0.04524785652756691, -0.007410776801407337, 0.013361621648073196, 0.003344238270074129, -0.004284542053937912, 0.027831466868519783, 0.001534489681944251, 0.023003078997135162, -0.054185397922992706, -0.03211917728185654, 0.029741303995251656, -0.04391304776072502, 0.013311682268977165, -0.08148809522390366, 0.0565340556204319, 0.017605852335691452, -0.045120321214199066, -0.042747173458337784, -0.01512875035405159, -0.03835143893957138, 0.06301748752593994, 0.04283447191119194, -0.006377336103469133, 0.009763417765498161, 0.02169531211256981, 0.05831373855471611, -0.002338643651455641, -0.03851872682571411, 0.04148348793387413, 0.01654590107500553, -0.012422065250575542, -0.023631496354937553, 0.004261170048266649, 0.003646170487627387, 0.002386250998824835, 0.029332449659705162, -0.00776091730222106, -0.004071022383868694, -0.0020663023460656404, 0.011783186346292496, 0.019399866461753845, 0.002462441101670265, -0.016362901777029037, 0.041082095354795456, -0.0014079234097152948, -0.023121122270822525, 0.040455374866724014, 0.011680620722472668, -0.049854740500450134, 0.02451631799340248, -0.016110287979245186, 0.0036121353041380644, 0.03628279268741608, -0.005815526470541954, 0.0013336376287043095, -0.0580907016992569, 0.03636419028043747, 0.013056011870503426, -0.0007330401567742229, 0.0036396319046616554, 0.04514603689312935, 0.03203833848237991, 0.03692016005516052, -0.043705493211746216, 0.02739030495285988, -0.010699950158596039, -0.05079153552651405, 0.03188169375061989, 0.015719814226031303, 0.033489830791950226, -0.010850021615624428, -0.017990965396165848, 0.0453476645052433, -0.018536008894443512, 0.03333013877272606, 0.002230333397164941, 0.04190591722726822, -0.015109984204173088, 0.008341427892446518, 0.03972013294696808, -0.02100103162229061, 0.0020160917192697525, -0.01889880932867527, 0.0009108190424740314, 0.05543186888098717, -0.039036355912685394, -0.01258770003914833, -0.009232171811163425, 0.02400883473455906, -0.035071346908807755, 0.027439279481768608, 0.03349108248949051, 0.03168719261884689, 0.01774423196911812, 0.007799141574651003, 0.00653182715177536, -0.003426973707973957, -0.0033356084022670984, 0.008994813077151775, -0.004206027835607529, 0.02633696421980858, -0.007932203821837902, -0.006167660001665354, -0.02024386264383793, -0.0019015640718862414, -0.025895478203892708, 0.036751482635736465, -0.00817540567368269, -0.004910442046821117, -0.04540638253092766, -0.021247733384370804, 0.01755037158727646, 0.07672547549009323, -0.042691681534051895, -0.037242304533720016, -0.04113616794347763, 0.022866172716021538, 0.0015819794498383999, -0.01111155841499567 ]
<p>I am doing a study of how legal need relates to a number of predictors.</p> <p>Outcome Variable: Legal Need (Yes or No)<br> Possible Predictors: Age, Gender, Race, Ethnicity, Language, Clinic, Insurance Status.<br> Predictors based on bivariate analysis: Age, Language, Clinic, Insurance Status. All ORs were around 1.6 and were significant, typical 95CI between 1.2-2.0.<br> Number of subjects: 8803 </p> <p>I suspect that the one variable that is going to fall out of a multiple regression analysis would be Clinic, as the Asthma Clinic (vs the well-visit clinic) has in general, older children who don't speak English and are more on Medicaid (the other predictors from bivariate analysis). </p> <p>Knowing all of this, I still can't figure out how to run a multiple regression in Excel. </p> <p>I keep getting Pearson's coefficients like 0.06, which it then says is significant. </p> <p>Either way I think I need to go beyond this, maybe a stepwise forward or backward analysis? </p> <p>It's difficult for me to grasp when the outcome is a 0 (no) or 1 (yes), this doesn't really result in anything linear when the percent "yes's" are typically in the 15-30% range. </p> <p>Am I missing something? Besides years of stats training? </p>
36,086
[ -0.03499823436141014, -0.0048485323786735535, 0.039158858358860016, 0.013702834956347942, 0.0780850425362587, -0.013177350163459778, -0.019224273040890694, -0.004669713322073221, 0.028142882511019707, -0.0024318459909409285, 0.0349484384059906, 0.017262455075979233, 0.04914601519703865, -0.0038661325816065073, 0.0049307458102703094, 0.05196671187877655, 0.013610469177365303, 0.004379464779049158, -0.0007078337366692722, 0.019992901012301445, -0.006005391012877226, 0.011062081903219223, 0.013322464190423489, -0.0062251584604382515, -0.011384779587388039, 0.06798974424600601, 0.021483752876520157, -0.020905815064907074, -0.00630559679120779, 0.020068883895874023, -0.021476659923791885, -0.003896935610100627, 0.018304642289876938, 0.00785746518522501, 0.03915761038661003, 0.042295247316360474, -0.017536981031298637, 0.0035165005829185247, 0.03129975497722626, 0.03212210536003113, -0.010679368861019611, -0.037749260663986206, -0.018164068460464478, -0.020441217347979546, -0.01614319160580635, 0.018303174525499344, -0.00041715067345649004, -0.00973564013838768, 0.041752543300390244, -0.0379372239112854, 0.05557547137141228, 0.0164483729749918, 0.03197634220123291, 0.027491426095366478, -0.03733731433749199, -0.030631940811872482, 0.017070161178708076, 0.07253536581993103, 0.03885610029101372, -0.05160481110215187, 0.009151621721684933, -0.006522629410028458, -0.013804302550852299, -0.014110098592936993, -0.020288417115807533, -0.03366900607943535, 0.017987627536058426, 0.02039153315126896, 0.024402780458331108, -0.024719923734664917, 0.03544141724705696, -0.003958604298532009, 0.042222555726766586, -0.021302487701177597, 0.004139624070376158, -0.008652455173432827, -0.027013815939426422, -0.003455554135143757, 0.045171383768320084, 0.03799431025981903, -0.038824379444122314, -0.026001105085015297, -0.0023682110477238894, 0.054249826818704605, -0.0037584465462714434, 0.0029452343005687, 0.06936408579349518, -0.03211485221982002, 0.010104299522936344, 0.012741634622216225, 0.007380982395261526, -0.02417229861021042, 0.08074840158224106, 0.0325847864151001, -0.03520771488547325, 0.036567408591508865, -0.019451338797807693, 0.050340812653303146, 0.012200381606817245, -0.003639800474047661, 0.0016514089656993747, -0.01395271997898817, 0.012552597559988499, 0.05052531883120537, -0.026683902367949486, 0.00348427495919168, -0.02511066198348999, -0.007563261780887842, 0.017712103202939034, -0.012340755201876163, -0.02197842113673687, 0.04903461039066315, -0.015914497897028923, -0.021368080750107765, -0.006620925385504961, -0.020741213113069534, -0.030310621485114098, -0.006611787248402834, 0.058772820979356766, 0.05011983588337898, 0.06268756836652756, -0.022267475724220276, -0.004527029115706682, -0.0016256283270195127, -0.04011662304401398, 0.018066853284835815, -0.03239677473902702, -0.0018159538740292192, -0.0333123542368412, 0.05823676288127899, 0.001384275034070015, 0.0281441081315279, 0.018289554864168167, 0.02535487897694111, 0.012109057046473026, -0.010710940696299076, -0.06315387785434723, -0.05361151322722435, 0.014685719273984432, 0.03422912582755089, -0.01186521165072918, -0.05819492042064667, -0.0018542937468737364, 0.00044726755004376173, 0.08584264665842056, -0.0073183393105864525, 0.022518519312143326, 0.014341524802148342, 0.034003790467977524, 0.010204651392996311, -0.07299560308456421, 0.03964706137776375, -0.014256712980568409, -0.004627606365829706, -0.02991970255970955, -0.1193527802824974, 0.012850938364863396, 0.03879697248339653, 0.023593658581376076, -0.008185499347746372, 0.028024349361658096, -0.0011226886417716742, -0.038648709654808044, -0.07378169149160385, -0.008006159216165543, -0.008319833315908909, 0.03816157951951027, -0.03354477882385254, 0.005200499668717384, 0.034230202436447144, 0.04022201895713806, -0.006782903801649809, 0.02076590433716774, 0.044917862862348557, 0.04100733995437622, 0.016507714986801147, 0.02381172589957714, -0.03000994212925434, 0.008931434713304043, -0.006228330545127392, -0.04376213997602463, -0.004256517626345158, -0.044321008026599884, 0.005891926120966673, -0.0015764778945595026, 0.004228546749800444, -0.02236182428896427, 0.0005146092153154314, 0.031344205141067505, -0.04471135139465332, -0.044176649302244186, -0.08013168722391129, 0.03952183946967125, 0.006536412984132767, -0.0532042570412159, -0.013722989708185196, -0.020753830671310425, 0.012282779440283775, -0.007590060587972403, 0.028176650404930115, -0.01088010985404253, -0.02116851508617401, 0.022372964769601822, -0.029317514970898628, 0.013848092406988144, 0.06286810338497162, 0.029837755486369133, -0.00806126743555069, 0.03853162005543709, -0.054941918700933456, -0.02158176153898239, 0.0037456841673702, -0.01623004674911499, -0.00732222618535161, -0.015398196876049042, 0.0019386018393561244, 0.007877437397837639, -0.008016551844775677, -0.01031044777482748, 0.023070726543664932, -0.04637422040104866, 0.05772438272833824, 0.02786523662507534, 0.0059987581335008144, 0.002251890953630209, -0.0042838747613132, 0.025316821411252022, -0.007803065236657858, 0.01045594085007906, 0.0015713304746896029, -0.038677312433719635, -0.028829650953412056, 0.04297109693288803, -0.013373643159866333, -0.00855198036879301, 0.02327575907111168, 0.03548181802034378, 0.015395491383969784, -0.019104620441794395, -0.00873455312103033, 0.00632847473025322, 0.0018621502676978707, -0.007523788139224052, 0.02646203711628914, 0.01082655694335699, 0.019965343177318573, -0.011980682611465454, 0.0034844877663999796, 0.019202882423996925, 0.04050663858652115, 0.011798721738159657, 0.051053401082754135, 0.021639768034219742, -0.004486230202019215, -0.024222254753112793, 0.0032540527172386646, 0.046327829360961914, -0.04174060374498367, 0.01996276155114174, 0.0349888876080513, 0.005551651120185852, -0.01986326277256012, 0.03787432610988617, -0.04291784390807152, 0.004410597030073404, 0.013097868300974369, -0.02352326549589634, 0.03916434571146965, 0.014213742688298225, -0.04853750392794609, 0.0203422661870718, -0.0157687496393919, -0.03983539715409279, -0.03928873687982559, 0.01218273676931858, 0.02135336771607399, 0.01142601203173399, 0.028833530843257904, -0.008216303773224354, 0.016401266679167747, -0.011580074205994606, 0.008302208036184311, 0.006024929694831371, 0.002451542764902115, -0.03188648447394371, -0.029130762442946434, -0.025011537596583366, -0.008147163316607475, 0.03219415619969368, -0.01102404948323965, -0.04317823424935341, 0.06506606191396713, -0.03003741428256035, -0.06357509642839432, -0.022527305409312248, -0.025730742141604424, -0.006147450767457485, -0.011159398593008518, -0.007162262685596943, 0.016351450234651566, 0.0018865192541852593, -0.04359632357954979, -0.007765477988868952, 0.01694597117602825, -0.007076616864651442, -0.015057533048093319, -0.026643894612789154, 0.0038699721917510033, 0.012730401009321213, 0.0428168959915638, -0.03974055126309395, -0.015336941927671432, -0.01982230693101883, -0.08497872203588486, -0.0644930750131607, 0.03671581670641899, 0.019757013767957687, 0.031592369079589844, -0.0015444244490936399, -0.04320932924747467, 0.04369718208909035, 0.024656744673848152, 0.01153769064694643, -0.045794133096933365, -0.005898216739296913, -0.019515829160809517, -0.05017680674791336, 0.028671124950051308, 0.0602998286485672, 0.011384022422134876, -0.004475157242268324, -0.026433782652020454, 0.056190360337495804, 0.02517899125814438, 0.02192917838692665, 0.006077940110117197, 0.016002653166651726, -0.020921481773257256, -0.004594303667545319, 0.050971582531929016, 0.02192390337586403, -0.03469831123948097, 0.009357044473290443, -0.013355597853660583, 0.03797025606036186, 0.02752159722149372, -0.0679127424955368, -0.02148817852139473, 0.009275464341044426, 0.0031567432451993227, -0.03794015198945999, -0.021188806742429733, 0.021624164655804634, -0.03404204547405243, -0.019172461703419685, 0.0030166669748723507, 0.012877617962658405, -0.02558303251862526, 0.0011083057615906, 0.05644986033439636, 0.006794957909733057, 0.01780637353658676, 0.022758644074201584, -0.04634178429841995, 0.010558648966252804, 0.006344697903841734, -0.025545179843902588, 0.015245349146425724, 0.029354656115174294, 0.05172758549451828, 0.034158628433942795, 0.0037162683438509703, -0.02591831423342228, 0.04514182358980179, -0.05240299180150032, -0.014999071136116982, -0.019405044615268707, 0.02842618152499199, -0.019625719636678696, 0.022272180765867233, -0.029432155191898346, 0.01074268203228712, -0.004859310109168291, 0.010028311051428318, -0.054424870759248734, 0.027266576886177063, -0.011197065003216267, 0.022874334827065468, 0.023840148001909256, -0.060863886028528214, 0.026487668976187706, 0.0009429578785784543, 0.025142524391412735, -0.01709720306098461, 0.04056049510836601, -0.005273323971778154, 0.035471729934215546, -0.009418218396604061, -0.014480801299214363, 0.013643007725477219, -0.020686188712716103, -0.02141335979104042, 0.02614576555788517, 0.0046392702497541904, 0.0318649560213089, 0.023585796356201172, -0.028611546382308006, -0.02352547086775303, -0.019753336906433105, 0.028711115941405296, 0.08010619878768921, 0.00970070157200098, -0.0136300353333354, -0.021798087283968925, -0.0070974756963551044, -0.01912015676498413, 0.02406196855008602, 0.03358552232384682, 0.03321647271513939, -0.026709379628300667, -0.020574605092406273, -0.020520465448498726, 0.0007084249518811703, 0.00929919071495533, 0.0027044801972806454, -0.00690073287114501, 0.048439573496580124, 0.0035813474096357822, -0.05554801598191261, 0.015272309072315693, 0.023124972358345985, 0.02034110762178898, 0.02494075894355774, -0.0018538874574005604, -0.010229234583675861, 0.0031029614619910717, -0.014948509633541107, 0.027441026642918587, 0.019466063007712364, -0.013389208354055882, -0.04880400002002716, 0.03033044934272766, -0.004009265452623367, -0.014904757030308247, 0.03031054139137268, 0.0035427012480795383, 0.03646036982536316, 0.0027467163745313883, -0.052462998777627945, 0.03019139915704727, 0.0723443329334259, 0.0037399400025606155, 0.024370266124606133, 0.04123213142156601, -0.11612623184919357, 0.002579208929091692, 0.04618792608380318, 0.05727462098002434, -0.06711199134588242, -0.01487655472010374, -0.05738413333892822, -0.022814704105257988, 0.017561079934239388, -0.027965128421783447, -0.011720621958374977, 0.0027719102799892426, 0.02774861641228199, -0.02758963592350483, -0.028471659868955612, -0.06980765610933304, -0.007460546679794788, -0.0023707402870059013, 0.0038658410776406527, 0.0050928425043821335, -0.028188029304146767, -0.03299909830093384, 0.0219773817807436, 0.021906763315200806, 0.03390991687774658, -0.0030794492922723293, -0.04173009842634201, -0.0030647211242467165, -0.00603306433185935, -0.007553162518888712, -0.07420723885297775, 0.01884925737977028, -0.027608118951320648, 0.008052670396864414, 0.07364156097173691, -0.001032549305818975, -0.043947044759988785, 0.007957098074257374, -0.0016271655913442373, -0.030197449028491974, -0.0046343374997377396, -0.04384682700037956, 0.031211821362376213, -0.012654950842261314, 0.03669249266386032, 0.021679097786545753, 0.013322449289262295, -0.009259874932467937, 0.01194820087403059, -0.02483491599559784, -0.035980917513370514, 0.008026241324841976, -0.04039865359663963, -0.020029671490192413, -0.017768410965800285, -0.002343643456697464, 0.0022671385668218136, 0.024796105921268463, 0.020354807376861572, -0.037432558834552765, -0.026105478405952454, 0.01387948077172041, 0.02727019414305687, -0.007164486218243837, 0.0028752649668604136, -0.010649511590600014, 0.0061758775264024734, -0.01237654872238636, -0.02730114571750164, 0.06731446087360382, -0.025974370539188385, 0.03990553319454193, 0.06441964954137802, -0.04336673021316528, 0.0038958219811320305, -0.0430457629263401, -0.011385686695575714, 0.0009929914958775043, -0.032989468425512314, 0.0018045972101390362, -0.03177754953503609, 0.03439446538686752, -0.011807379312813282, -0.006521710194647312, -0.006621154956519604, 0.024027178063988686, 0.00028054724680259824, 0.05702861770987511, 0.021569082513451576, 0.013556246645748615, 0.0011164763709530234, -0.022081850096583366, -0.03194202482700348, -0.030998729169368744, -0.02186291106045246, 0.03471633046865463, -0.029062967747449875, -0.022070646286010742, -0.03123164176940918, -0.03752409666776657, -0.05455544963479042, 0.019813651219010353, 0.06596056371927261, -0.03645086660981178, -0.005574224051088095, -0.0013722856529057026, 0.007636220194399357, 0.032661549746990204, -0.03216448798775673, 0.01632623001933098, 0.026607949286699295, -0.0269135944545269, -0.028606515377759933, -0.020734043791890144, 0.019316840916872025, -0.028625639155507088, -0.012106203474104404, -0.06072881072759628, -0.0008078520768322051, 0.027134820818901062, -0.0026304025668650866, -0.016836775466799736, -0.008425513282418251, -0.059123288840055466, 0.02335326001048088, -0.0357380211353302, -0.010560774244368076, 0.0096515491604805, -0.007830294780433178, -0.007267734035849571, 0.022491881623864174, -0.033629294484853745, 0.007589393761008978, -0.005045096855610609, 0.010107767768204212, 0.007504801731556654, 0.0020420465152710676, 0.05802960693836212, -0.010870111174881458, 0.03194817155599594, 0.016490718349814415, -0.019123554229736328, 0.052642203867435455, 0.0274065975099802, -0.006180531810969114, -0.00500831613317132, 0.04370618239045143, -0.027716167271137238, -0.023375077173113823, -0.051892656832933426, 0.0024781886022537947, 0.01973366178572178, 0.01058866549283266, 0.020405346527695656, 0.06282799690961838, -0.01903577148914337, 0.0013639280805364251, -0.02075037732720375, 0.004790876992046833, -0.018888767808675766, 0.026855016127228737, 0.028505917638540268, -0.0017822167137637734, -0.001989164389669895, 0.07128790020942688, -0.0005430859164334834, 0.05014137551188469, -0.0019483817741274834, 0.05917605012655258, -0.00951625220477581, 0.058937426656484604, -0.040999189019203186, -0.05425867810845375, 0.021224062889814377, -0.02780415676534176, 0.017576899379491806, 0.00016089265409391373, -0.04687196761369705, 0.05656338110566139, 0.0884302482008934, -0.003998731728643179, -0.005066831596195698, -0.009638412855565548, -0.0387716218829155, 0.02291090600192547, -0.008532029576599598, -0.03526536747813225, 0.02238823100924492, -0.013234562240540981, 0.04445691779255867, 0.018703298643231392, 0.013062838464975357, -0.039293207228183746, -0.07113152742385864, -0.013910483568906784, -0.00498627033084631, -0.015856990590691566, 0.05239799991250038, 0.009631826542317867, 0.011384345591068268, 0.02211649902164936, -0.05562294274568558, -0.011004770174622536, -0.011403923854231834, 0.018313094973564148, 0.013361470773816109, 0.06470604985952377, -0.0021537537686526775, -0.026835842058062553, 0.002140023745596409, -0.006335783284157515, 0.15785709023475647, 0.06353330612182617, 0.008772830478847027, -0.07370056211948395, 0.04556606337428093, 0.0030836728401482105, -0.011657239869236946, -0.013470496982336044, 0.012683266773819923, -0.0074048419483006, -0.00987482164055109, 0.06280501931905746, 0.055439017713069916, -0.008060170337557793, 0.0165997501462698, 0.04703284054994583, -0.01510861236602068, -0.06136271730065346, 0.01395182404667139, 0.01354297436773777, 0.013579502701759338, -0.028859978541731834, -0.016522426158189774, 0.012660952284932137, 0.027957236394286156, -0.05411827191710472, -0.023357821628451347, -0.024994883686304092, -0.012889486737549305, -0.02092975564301014, -0.02017250470817089, 0.002165895886719227, 0.001980754779651761, 0.037877220660448074, -0.03257567062973976, -0.014535488560795784, 0.021294254809617996, -0.05179016292095184, -0.02922438457608223, 0.06258092075586319, -0.026376904919743538, -0.023072991520166397, 0.011417358182370663, -0.0017038150690495968, -0.04446135833859444, 0.004245708230882883, -0.01978650875389576, 0.04804382100701332, 0.015426784753799438, -0.018465129658579826, -0.03312302380800247, 0.010424846783280373, 0.010353305377066135, -0.044443778693675995, -0.014110331423580647, 0.0355997160077095, 0.04241501912474632, -0.02988602966070175, -0.017111215740442276, 0.012547828257083893, -0.0133803840726614, 0.018302612006664276, -0.01562662608921528, 0.03292126581072807, -0.023516712710261345, -0.030837256461381912, -0.0519154854118824, 0.06130637601017952, 0.012938552536070347, 0.0086414385586977, 0.03958631679415703, -0.004654075484722853, -0.02570299804210663, 0.036385778337717056, 0.021622611209750175, 0.003416401334106922, -0.004536326974630356, -0.0023274889681488276, -0.044213224202394485, -0.03594391793012619, -0.019919145852327347, 0.006453255191445351, -0.03648528829216957, -0.02129717357456684, -0.046414587646722794, -0.0448862724006176, -0.03328702971339226, 0.042683474719524384, 0.014905539341270924, 0.017210235819220543, 0.027335548773407936, 0.07145147770643234, 0.0005585241597145796, -0.044191472232341766, -0.011967187747359276, -0.03769198805093765, -0.04038955271244049, 0.03342948108911514, -0.004204812925308943, 0.0873093232512474, -0.0455327183008194, 0.06314418464899063, 0.009764108806848526, 0.04318596050143242, -0.01957821659743786, -0.00010436736920382828, 0.02016068436205387, -0.04927986115217209, 0.01595991849899292, -0.0003965567157138139, 0.04461827129125595, -0.006764704827219248, 0.03684832155704498, -0.07068467885255814, -0.011026958003640175, -0.0036388493608683348, -0.037409838289022446, -0.009617278352379799, 0.0384063757956028, 0.017423691228032112, 0.049194782972335815, -0.00972707662731409, -0.0018341777613386512, -0.045432135462760925, -0.038271937519311905, 0.01931806653738022, -0.011099038645625114, 0.018861111253499985, 0.0032101315446197987, -0.003358065616339445, 0.00877199973911047, 0.010613521561026573, 0.018850453197956085, 0.00846153311431408, 0.006598010193556547, -0.010628240182995796, 0.00299657485447824, 0.0018506139749661088, -0.0666196346282959, -0.0267740860581398, 0.02823632024228573, -0.020395249128341675, -0.026841022074222565, 0.01092570647597313, 0.004948667716234922, 0.028525924310088158, -0.024322986602783203, -0.006492207292467356, -0.020918093621730804, 0.038434162735939026, 0.0031979656778275967, -0.0024129501543939114, -0.020757285878062248, 0.02261679247021675, 0.03397970646619797, -0.04045214131474495, -0.01733257994055748, 0.031973179429769516, -0.025011345744132996, 0.04033986106514931, 0.04142485186457634, 0.0004952936433255672, -0.01765488274395466, 0.02385231852531433, -0.02163824997842312, -0.02649305947124958, 0.02053006924688816, 0.0037133600562810898, -0.007846425287425518, 0.000049621630751062185, -0.038619689643383026, 0.028317857533693314, -0.016890618950128555, 0.056097377091646194, -0.08888494223356247, -0.04240042343735695, -0.025199219584465027, 0.02335442416369915, 0.028494935482740402, -0.06115163117647171, -0.02179621532559395, 0.027643254026770592, -0.021829163655638695, -0.018107345327734947, -0.0021573135163635015, 0.01535009779036045, -0.019185176119208336, 0.02556684985756874, -0.01776174083352089, 0.003957308828830719, 0.03875140845775604, 0.020518969744443893, 0.020334016531705856, 0.022138025611639023, 0.00024595079594291747, -0.038764212280511856, 0.00025472682318650186, 0.016052167862653732, 0.031877778470516205, -0.04990813136100769, 0.004865495953708887, -0.06414244323968887, 0.010087358765304089, 0.020698636770248413, -0.009944015182554722, 0.04238010197877884, 0.012840144336223602, 0.037455763667821884, 0.02178524062037468, 0.07397250086069107, 0.04406799376010895, 0.006452527362853289, 0.05009844899177551, -0.037508655339479446, -0.00023874161706771702, 0.01807021163403988, -0.04023320972919464, 0.016139911487698555, 0.07410860061645508, 0.014500182121992111, -0.012288663536310196, -0.002134128473699093, -0.023482663556933403, -0.026480527594685555, -0.00034527480602264404, -0.0108279287815094, -0.00885701272636652, -0.011050722561776638, 0.026413127779960632, -0.0709381178021431, -0.02748343162238598, 0.05536971613764763, 0.033683713525533676, -0.025631815195083618, 0.002118488773703575, -0.016016490757465363, -0.015549842268228531, 0.020066112279891968, -0.01843944750726223, -0.019392788410186768, -0.026999706402420998, -0.03084825538098812, -0.02865234762430191, -0.010817321948707104, -0.04947682470083237, 0.051789406687021255, -0.014701868407428265, 0.0019003425259143114, -0.016666118055582047, -0.000025406125132576562, 0.04339572787284851, -0.019547075033187866, 0.031089037656784058, -0.03620224446058273, 0.07673864811658859, 0.05885675922036171, 0.0002911026531364769, -0.039350301027297974, -0.05095912143588066, 0.011090193875133991, -0.013677947223186493, 0.0759824588894844, 0.013836541213095188, 0.02205008640885353, -0.025324571877717972, 0.02188558503985405, 0.0005926102749072015, -0.021332647651433945, 0.05010832101106644, -0.03106190264225006, 0.0006308032316155732, -0.019490204751491547, 0.026596978306770325, 0.06019637733697891, -0.018104851245880127, 0.019459174945950508, -0.018009820953011513, 0.004213906358927488, -0.023673133924603462, -0.018040325492620468, 0.013189995661377907, 0.026199014857411385, -0.03136766329407692, 0.023459983989596367, 0.000811300240457058, -0.0029116820078343153, 0.04593740776181221, -0.015246273018419743, -0.072069451212883, 0.04976506531238556, 0.005084532778710127, -0.029695486649870872, -0.0180215984582901, -0.020097462460398674, -0.0015727964928373694, -0.056039247661828995, 0.004814856685698032, 0.015967508777976036, 0.022810205817222595, -0.006989551708102226, 0.05351788178086281, 0.002292919671162963, 0.004738014191389084, -0.019106213003396988, -0.011110392399132252, 0.010218333452939987, -0.03827716410160065, 0.010312442667782307, 0.0176908690482378, 0.040681060403585434, 0.013625812716782093, -0.0185902900993824, 0.052079327404499054, 0.01007484644651413, 0.02237876132130623, 0.04159605875611305, 0.04138009250164032, -0.0458405427634716, -0.02468424290418625, 0.01961083523929119, 0.018503880128264427, 0.053956687450408936, -0.03364654630422592, -0.003963921219110489, 0.03152313828468323, -0.019907085224986076, -0.03078366629779339, -0.03201265260577202, 0.026927726343274117, -0.029021793976426125, -0.002896537771448493, 0.02652679570019245, 0.030349163338541985, -0.023678282275795937, 0.0017204893520101905, 0.0011401461670175195, -0.00711432658135891, 0.06739157438278198, -0.0495702400803566, -0.010278104804456234, -0.008501320146024227, -0.02432701550424099, -0.015810443088412285, -0.01868404448032379, -0.0010287571931257844, -0.021972663700580597, 0.008391506969928741, 0.05170673504471779, -0.015177102759480476, -0.04525386542081833, -0.007954388856887817, 0.006177282892167568, 0.04726235568523407, -0.05417604371905327, -0.026477966457605362, -0.017823226749897003, -0.015455663204193115, 0.017778469249606133, -0.027034711092710495 ]
<p>I have two variables measured concurrently at 3 time points, let's call them wealth (<code>W1</code>, <code>W2</code>, <code>W3</code>) and anxiety (<code>A1</code>, <code>A2</code>, <code>A3</code>). Suppose that wealth and anxiety are uncorrelated. Now, I'm interested whether <em>change</em> in anxiety is related to <em>change</em> in wealth. What would be the recommended way of testing this? Naively I would just create 4 new variables <code>W2-W1</code>, <code>W3-W2</code>, <code>A2-A1</code> and <code>A3-A2</code> and look at correlation coefficients between <code>W2-W1</code> vs. <code>A2-A1</code> and between <code>W3-W2</code> vs. <code>A3-A2</code>. Somehow this approach seems silly, since I want a single model that would look at the overall change. Should I be looking at mixed/multilevel models? Specifically which model? Thanks!</p>
73,661
[ -0.04535146430134773, -0.005256919655948877, 0.005900554824620485, 0.0022153211757540703, 0.026983557268977165, -0.015612160786986351, -0.03700609132647514, -0.0013776811538264155, 0.041637908667325974, -0.0388372577726841, -0.0028616939671337605, 0.03672294318675995, 0.046734098345041275, -0.00533916475251317, 0.044419050216674805, -0.018134726211428642, -0.007173197343945503, -0.02949674427509308, 0.006149546708911657, -0.03314714506268501, -0.023473799228668213, -0.011123668402433395, -0.009157516062259674, -0.029173623770475388, -0.03031974472105503, 0.04575891047716141, 0.024557052180171013, -0.04643221199512482, -0.007841452024877071, 0.02111130580306053, -0.04121138155460358, -0.003189295530319214, -0.031891949474811554, 0.047830041497945786, 0.002321195090189576, -0.008505607955157757, -0.018531082198023796, -0.029945770278573036, -0.02023099549114704, 0.04458027333021164, -0.01990639790892601, -0.01876823604106903, -0.021825093775987625, -0.006615427788347006, -0.020847298204898834, 0.006182495504617691, -0.020846081897616386, -0.020708579570055008, 0.0358552411198616, -0.033798083662986755, 0.06654752790927887, -0.011823564767837524, 0.04907656088471413, 0.04016183689236641, -0.004634879995137453, -0.0169968344271183, 0.049874886870384216, 0.06007586419582367, 0.012291528284549713, -0.011481394991278648, -0.01599707454442978, 0.021394552662968636, 0.025265736505389214, -0.04965812340378761, -0.02316802740097046, 0.03236074000597, -0.0074768359772861, -0.022032948210835457, 0.037024255841970444, -0.024683291092514992, 0.031219108030200005, 0.024672307074069977, 0.05461341515183449, 0.004491067491471767, 0.015446942299604416, -0.017887061461806297, 0.004264133051037788, 0.04198170080780983, 0.056942034512758255, 0.06768003851175308, -0.01722564361989498, -0.0005570288049057126, -0.0009043539757840335, 0.012911461293697357, 0.031871818006038666, -0.026124127209186554, 0.055969204753637314, 0.008380472660064697, 0.009638029150664806, 0.04047340899705887, -0.004167106468230486, 0.012459796853363514, 0.04411303251981735, 0.02318161353468895, -0.04634479060769081, 0.03597540035843849, -0.04163311421871185, 0.0069829802960157394, 0.0156946312636137, 0.008685313165187836, -0.02373781055212021, -0.022378966212272644, 0.00043638175702653825, 0.02203207276761532, -0.018949877470731735, 0.001093949773348868, -0.0013498911866918206, -0.0189583171159029, -0.008060998283326626, -0.04862657189369202, -0.0230442825704813, 0.021848492324352264, 0.020133046433329582, 0.0010727756889536977, 0.038724735379219055, -0.011544332839548588, -0.002579357475042343, -0.014917030930519104, 0.05971812829375267, 0.08996773511171341, 0.05277421325445175, -0.0445784255862236, 0.018983470275998116, -0.014122527092695236, -0.0304232407361269, -0.0032157073728740215, -0.011293207295238972, -0.029902443289756775, -0.0633627325296402, 0.07393170893192291, 0.031492024660110474, -0.03507718816399574, 0.032258741557598114, -0.020302696153521538, 0.010549111291766167, 0.006776765920221806, -0.11673490703105927, -0.05192647874355316, -0.006860517431050539, -0.004736569710075855, 0.0234045572578907, -0.022586161270737648, -0.01751665212213993, -0.0037150804419070482, 0.09307064861059189, 0.019093146547675133, -0.01203947514295578, 0.017690397799015045, 0.040117837488651276, 0.04985949397087097, -0.05583779513835907, -0.006019769702106714, 0.013142618350684643, 0.017040478065609932, -0.010034088045358658, -0.09204724431037903, 0.014215626753866673, 0.035392798483371735, -0.03223232552409172, 0.026883667334914207, 0.04499174281954765, 0.005337809212505817, -0.03966091573238373, -0.028348112478852272, -0.0014795279130339622, 0.00005009521555621177, 0.053540993481874466, -0.02671877108514309, 0.029582848772406578, -0.012278386391699314, 0.04536890238523483, 0.010586448945105076, 0.008106054738163948, 0.055591922253370285, 0.029797518625855446, -0.01473747193813324, 0.017936376854777336, -0.024984000250697136, -0.01335013285279274, -0.0023607814218848944, -0.0078077237121760845, -0.030228981748223305, -0.0308492723852396, -0.016876859590411186, 0.040393076837062836, 0.01928054541349411, -0.017297053709626198, -0.01936640962958336, 0.025605138391256332, -0.03391528129577637, -0.04916343465447426, -0.06960198283195496, 0.012332173064351082, -0.009052830748260021, -0.03347506374120712, 0.03393485024571419, -0.023082587867975235, 0.053019337356090546, 0.013112141750752926, -0.016845015808939934, -0.0023182060103863478, 0.037123940885066986, 0.05202554166316986, -0.038685522973537445, 0.02117917314171791, 0.03545786812901497, 0.02296552062034607, -0.032349843531847, 0.045142754912376404, -0.033142466098070145, -0.02140115201473236, 0.04696480184793472, -0.044424980878829956, 0.01686996780335903, 0.014131424948573112, -0.011733099818229675, 0.006558502558618784, -0.016384171321988106, -0.012168376706540585, 0.018774861469864845, -0.0661257728934288, 0.09089656919240952, 0.042471833527088165, -0.03440602496266365, 0.007873297668993473, 0.021129172295331955, 0.019271524623036385, 0.028137996792793274, -0.026447314769029617, -0.010101379826664925, -0.04287470877170563, -0.0028029477689415216, 0.012699916027486324, 0.006606082897633314, -0.023338772356510162, 0.04824164882302284, 0.05462008714675903, -0.008955106139183044, 0.012762526050209999, 0.05485767126083374, 0.010875928215682507, -0.01741071045398712, -0.01728466898202896, 0.02018056809902191, -0.0027012901846319437, 0.0328451469540596, 0.008400210179388523, 0.0004309481882955879, 0.011255710385739803, -0.02426769770681858, 0.001715921564027667, 0.03966022655367851, 0.000675154966302216, 0.04615012928843498, -0.04126124456524849, -0.021289430558681488, 0.03098864108324051, -0.04136579856276512, -0.005154217127710581, 0.02561108022928238, 0.008194169029593468, -0.02513721026480198, 0.03395524248480797, -0.0495578832924366, 0.008501914329826832, 0.060610584914684296, -0.04200882837176323, 0.024763796478509903, 0.003069864818826318, -0.028583981096744537, 0.0068024396896362305, 0.0033369141165167093, 0.0070157740265131, -0.055497098714113235, 0.015940574929118156, 0.03101411834359169, -0.0057494156062603, 0.016044551506638527, -0.05137547105550766, -0.03222455456852913, 0.021776467561721802, -0.012404785491526127, 0.03416866064071655, -0.042309992015361786, -0.04408589005470276, 0.01820806972682476, -0.025272779166698456, -0.021868331357836723, 0.009723694995045662, -0.003516160184517503, -0.013137522153556347, 0.038689985871315, 0.0050872983410954475, -0.0393095538020134, -0.005954492371529341, -0.01045626774430275, 0.009363260120153427, -0.010556121356785297, -0.022922273725271225, 0.0715506449341774, -0.03372625261545181, -0.051012955605983734, -0.018898556008934975, -0.0390552319586277, -0.0007227391470223665, -0.003963693045079708, -0.020688986405730247, -0.024307964369654655, 0.01447982806712389, 0.019932789728045464, 0.013181117363274097, -0.038685090839862823, -0.00691191153600812, -0.0741833746433258, -0.06508279591798782, 0.033414311707019806, -0.015965119004249573, 0.013396205380558968, -0.03168701380491257, -0.027326103299856186, 0.03863067179918289, 0.029133103787899017, -0.015127548947930336, -0.04704843461513519, -0.02278095856308937, -0.023955678567290306, -0.0026479389052838087, 0.03729083389043808, 0.0301754679530859, 0.009128125384449959, 0.011865280568599701, -0.004254522267729044, 0.030472300946712494, 0.020494814962148666, 0.02113066427409649, 0.01457072701305151, 0.029630480334162712, -0.015984339639544487, -0.02675742283463478, 0.047109585255384445, -0.022660253569483757, -0.0007208485039882362, -0.00794979277998209, -0.004210358951240778, -0.034163832664489746, 0.011202854104340076, -0.02387929894030094, 0.002773731015622616, -0.005070708226412535, -0.0003046363708563149, -0.05271582305431366, 0.014248212799429893, -0.002971452893689275, -0.015701692551374435, 0.009062733501195908, 0.038361698389053345, 0.03484608978033066, 0.0014918290544301271, 0.007313419599086046, 0.029911832883954048, 0.02818242274224758, -0.03116597793996334, 0.0027887336909770966, -0.03955117613077164, -0.017363714054226875, 0.06183909252285957, -0.029506715014576912, -0.004108845721930265, 0.022692393511533737, 0.012136140838265419, 0.026366446167230606, -0.0024991496466100216, -0.07537256926298141, 0.014277676120400429, -0.07623318582773209, 0.006895867642015219, -0.04240017011761665, 0.047420602291822433, 0.024528678506612778, 0.0432434119284153, 0.021951282396912575, -0.01951388455927372, 0.041864752769470215, -0.01266398373991251, -0.035118263214826584, 0.023109711706638336, -0.009552923031151295, 0.03773415461182594, 0.029835890978574753, -0.003986859228461981, 0.02434464544057846, -0.04261025786399841, 0.003178832121193409, -0.024487381801009178, 0.02233545109629631, -0.0366966538131237, 0.011047962121665478, -0.04016038030385971, -0.03460400551557541, 0.026378467679023743, 0.010672836564481258, 0.015489555895328522, -0.0032044954132288694, 0.005736600607633591, 0.02747972123324871, -0.02066628634929657, -0.022433478385210037, -0.029816213995218277, -0.011113494634628296, 0.041335638612508774, 0.010371014475822449, 0.03653636947274208, 0.002331943716853857, -0.03658392280340195, 0.06867829710245132, 0.01160626020282507, -0.006357451900839806, 0.008194702677428722, -0.010121028870344162, 0.010144377127289772, -0.03772057220339775, -0.0037476292345672846, 0.01903390698134899, 0.00817609392106533, 0.041459403932094574, 0.009312859736382961, 0.017057454213500023, 0.03854352608323097, -0.05757544934749603, 0.006456961389631033, 0.0752025842666626, 0.01007021777331829, 0.01461197342723608, -0.039687320590019226, -0.008985154330730438, 0.012420538812875748, 0.004751303233206272, 0.027118178084492683, 0.0087301479652524, -0.008750533685088158, 0.0052567641250789165, 0.03176280856132507, -0.02721446566283703, -0.01795746386051178, 0.021017571911215782, 0.0229823999106884, 0.053883884102106094, 0.003715727012604475, -0.022519594058394432, 0.035910699516534805, 0.024474168196320534, -0.0011562772560864687, 0.032803162932395935, 0.01277129165828228, -0.1115119457244873, -0.006161410827189684, 0.02710805833339691, 0.007788726594299078, -0.023657798767089844, -0.01548985205590725, -0.028790779411792755, -0.042893875390291214, 0.04422609508037567, -0.01535754930227995, 0.03151160851120949, 0.0037949616089463234, -0.011869285255670547, -0.03463231399655342, -0.015123528428375721, -0.045488134026527405, 0.018651757389307022, -0.006529639475047588, 0.001093038241378963, 0.02185164950788021, -0.01719922199845314, -0.03236077353358269, 0.025422126054763794, 0.022526219487190247, 0.05078786984086037, -0.05262218788266182, -0.0021821740083396435, -0.01767953671514988, -0.008691726252436638, -0.028638092800974846, -0.05422495678067207, 0.02887207455933094, -0.037361182272434235, -0.020185088738799095, 0.07714290916919708, 0.0035326643846929073, -0.034346841275691986, -0.016968965530395508, -0.002026417525485158, -0.03436695411801338, 0.01549613755196333, 0.01958610489964485, 0.09584181010723114, 0.049536556005477905, 0.013644173741340637, 0.037964727729558945, 0.02547679841518402, 0.006317556835711002, 0.029336875304579735, 0.009795324876904488, -0.008555827662348747, -0.01713687554001808, 0.011284304782748222, -0.047778841108083725, 0.01332954503595829, -0.036483678966760635, 0.046764809638261795, -0.03746514022350311, 0.016838567331433296, -0.020596595481038094, -0.021330466493964195, -0.0010580403031781316, 0.0100325308740139, -0.02366812340915203, -0.023786241188645363, -0.0018704984104260802, 0.0010815951973199844, 0.03169131278991699, -0.012112850323319435, 0.006303105503320694, 0.005373563151806593, 0.0005624504992738366, -0.00029380834894254804, -0.03382422402501106, 0.025488778948783875, -0.035235486924648285, -0.011266634799540043, 0.017828775569796562, -0.004951654002070427, 0.035055797547101974, -0.0000820285567897372, 0.019612018018960953, -0.006030561868101358, -0.03890879824757576, 0.010690590366721153, 0.008199390955269337, -0.014521421864628792, 0.01754423789680004, -0.024101389572024345, 0.0409342423081398, -0.0018905692268162966, -0.01685294881463051, -0.06336598098278046, -0.07262161374092102, 0.022873839363455772, 0.0050212363712489605, -0.0005182317108847201, -0.032931115478277206, 0.031936172395944595, -0.00023512807092629373, -0.01106790266931057, -0.017442982643842697, 0.06368054449558258, -0.030897829681634903, 0.013458739966154099, -0.006815443746745586, 0.021918607875704765, 0.04559127986431122, 0.0289811659604311, 0.005251600872725248, 0.01812961883842945, -0.02435663901269436, -0.01164242159575224, -0.011139522306621075, -0.011531722731888294, -0.05397758260369301, 0.005583709571510553, -0.02250136248767376, -0.00933737214654684, 0.08774781227111816, -0.019986465573310852, -0.026357119902968407, 0.0033796324860304594, 0.0030942587181925774, 0.011981544084846973, -0.029791682958602905, 0.016265373677015305, -0.015070895664393902, 0.0043868026696145535, 0.0007305282633751631, -0.0016624287236481905, -0.039763279259204865, -0.035408418625593185, 0.028191175311803818, -0.0005113565712235868, -0.06187435984611511, -0.014996495097875595, 0.053285133093595505, 0.03441881760954857, -0.03355094790458679, -0.017318101599812508, -0.005610339809209108, 0.011918331496417522, -0.017984682694077492, -0.0012912573292851448, 0.002409997396171093, 0.0374600924551487, -0.05177672579884529, -0.04684162139892578, -0.006669051479548216, 0.00454964954406023, 0.07711053639650345, -0.00026416388573125005, 0.055605098605155945, 0.038394391536712646, 0.0041708569042384624, -0.010189826600253582, -0.039856117218732834, -0.018457766622304916, -0.0028796240221709013, 0.014717897400259972, 0.05927293002605438, -0.023028936237096786, 0.02061990648508072, 0.05062510073184967, 0.01568516716361046, 0.002594307530671358, 0.06963370740413666, 0.00906092207878828, 0.013635685667395592, 0.02038862556219101, -0.036001913249492645, -0.020513061434030533, 0.05533607676625252, -0.05775854364037514, 0.008688468486070633, -0.06147543713450432, -0.03392907232046127, 0.05585149675607681, 0.05268723890185356, -0.003854508278891444, -0.04437679052352905, -0.05104931443929672, -0.045296214520931244, 0.024905549362301826, 0.011042480356991291, -0.03421416133642197, 0.028437938541173935, 0.030494989827275276, 0.06046934798359871, 0.008372913114726543, 0.02075033076107502, -0.017841065302491188, -0.09798538684844971, 0.017023619264364243, 0.016080522909760475, -0.01291048526763916, 0.037623774260282516, -0.00955803319811821, -0.026607397943735123, 0.014986520633101463, -0.042917024344205856, -0.011447587981820107, -0.03166716545820236, 0.004682329948991537, -0.009951156564056873, 0.05207917466759682, 0.003792515955865383, 0.024796081706881523, 0.008156292140483856, 0.0035400388296693563, 0.12230184674263, 0.06741320341825485, 0.03882153332233429, -0.08258474618196487, 0.053706880658864975, 0.029280081391334534, 0.03772120550274849, -0.016395283862948418, 0.013893423601984978, -0.010835021734237671, 0.011361589655280113, 0.012514795176684856, 0.08069508522748947, 0.03882092610001564, 0.0060276370495557785, 0.044946759939193726, -0.007807354908436537, -0.016496187075972557, -0.026017392054200172, -0.006968194153159857, -0.005954975727945566, 0.003321911906823516, -0.02419719099998474, 0.033612482249736786, -0.0010189396562054753, -0.00809683557599783, 0.03222429379820824, -0.002599590690806508, 0.014219791628420353, -0.02235349826514721, -0.00488269655033946, 0.02003057673573494, 0.007715344429016113, -0.00309042539447546, -0.025837868452072144, 0.002739372430369258, 0.02755766734480858, -0.030906660482287407, -0.00043623364763334394, 0.027152422815561295, -0.031570710241794586, -0.020993255078792572, -0.027822665870189667, 0.005602290388196707, -0.05317253619432449, -0.050553109496831894, -0.03104105219244957, 0.005980736576020718, 0.00012826152669731528, -0.03529846668243408, -0.02197202667593956, -0.01850413717329502, -0.01746346242725849, -0.04124344512820244, -0.05138501524925232, 0.028731079772114754, 0.00465517770498991, -0.03137112781405449, 0.017400478944182396, 0.003690057434141636, -0.0031699452083557844, 0.025374989956617355, 0.025527236983180046, 0.02351677604019642, -0.02728872187435627, -0.027881687507033348, -0.04747408255934715, 0.032922644168138504, 0.008955328725278378, 0.0061034574173390865, 0.015232466161251068, -0.005174940451979637, -0.047323379665613174, -0.031199699267745018, 0.010555293411016464, -0.015487697906792164, -0.011051226407289505, 0.011502275243401527, -0.02001870796084404, -0.04426109418272972, -0.010981131345033646, -0.006514857057482004, -0.03211519122123718, -0.0018771738978102803, -0.030175717547535896, 0.022243233397603035, 0.04592423141002655, 0.023313775658607483, 0.028688950464129448, -0.010082857683300972, 0.004022890701889992, 0.06673941761255264, 0.04204951971769333, -0.05961005017161369, 0.013785392045974731, 0.0018858197145164013, -0.044978123158216476, -0.01693819835782051, -0.04675028845667839, 0.07556330412626266, -0.009648602455854416, 0.009351381100714207, -0.04441707953810692, 0.017460767179727554, -0.007689553778618574, 0.034879155457019806, 0.04586838185787201, -0.05413833260536194, -0.006783348973840475, 0.0032331703696399927, 0.024147972464561462, 0.025328677147626877, -0.004012410994619131, -0.027388159185647964, 0.0014344998635351658, -0.02002137526869774, -0.0258584413677454, -0.02232292667031288, 0.009488441050052643, 0.014936457388103008, 0.03949987143278122, -0.07214444130659103, -0.028020285069942474, -0.042825110256671906, 0.01735825650393963, 0.0028946110978722572, 0.030766231939196587, 0.02091888338327408, 0.023497743532061577, -0.021219290792942047, 0.009040850214660168, 0.016588162630796432, 0.005463278852403164, -0.03391256928443909, -0.014805284328758717, 0.01251913420855999, 0.015281186439096928, 0.0510341078042984, 0.0165878739207983, -0.051475346088409424, 0.02355373278260231, -0.011543571017682552, -0.021898392587900162, 0.005303902085870504, -0.017812250182032585, 0.042399026453495026, 0.010602179914712906, 0.017686786130070686, -0.020948635414242744, 0.014218690805137157, -0.014418982900679111, -0.012623864226043224, -0.003703639144077897, -0.009962707757949829, 0.009968370199203491, -0.013372976332902908, -0.020375961437821388, 0.045935604721307755, -0.012005457654595375, 0.025013113394379616, 0.04569704458117485, -0.005613856017589569, 0.016442524269223213, 0.0028565649408847094, -0.019608700647950172, 0.061479292809963226, -0.014737996272742748, -0.0596291646361351, 0.07797937840223312, 0.04778838902711868, -0.008180969394743443, 0.019191935658454895, -0.019059188663959503, 0.0006728693260811269, -0.04929066821932793, -0.012804313562810421, 0.01367183867841959, 0.013596453703939915, 0.011408746242523193, -0.04399694502353668, 0.0422990508377552, 0.05096445232629776, -0.025814756751060486, 0.05933168902993202, 0.003332121530547738, 0.028626438230276108, -0.026158103719353676, 0.011428296566009521, -0.02842552214860916, 0.017625760287046432, 0.0005327255930751562, -0.006770770531147718, 0.0033161863684654236, 0.026102924719452858, 0.02551998570561409, -0.01407572627067566, 0.005747703835368156, -0.020277971401810646, 0.016122281551361084, -0.044040706008672714, 0.008947132155299187, -0.07729291915893555, -0.00868998933583498, 0.033567458391189575, -0.01291899848729372, 0.0344911552965641, 0.003324005752801895, 0.05266983434557915, 0.00477025518193841, 0.054348401725292206, 0.02276824600994587, 0.004471257794648409, 0.017127560451626778, -0.01368640922009945, 0.02378648892045021, 0.03352505341172218, -0.012286076322197914, 0.0033322416711598635, -0.007835117168724537, -0.003463681787252426, 0.03215595707297325, 0.0022590274456888437, 0.011148729361593723, 0.018111033365130424, -0.014029685407876968, -0.03164299577474594, 0.00978292990475893, -0.017739010974764824, 0.006489388179033995, -0.001455524587072432, -0.015073759481310844, 0.05076850578188896, 0.05778173357248306, -0.032083287835121155, -0.018474243581295013, 0.00217579142190516, -0.02879997529089451, 0.02178996242582798, -0.013477585278451443, -0.001180310733616352, -0.018387187272310257, -0.04506772384047508, 0.022238511592149734, 0.022044647485017776, -0.031450506299734116, 0.011272779665887356, -0.007023551966995001, 0.026032036170363426, -0.08254428952932358, -0.02932376228272915, -0.0013463543727993965, -0.028741205111145973, 0.010840030387043953, -0.10861828923225403, 0.05311732739210129, -0.012143968604505062, -0.04538032412528992, -0.024084892123937607, 0.02793869748711586, -0.021048974245786667, -0.0031090255361050367, 0.06127754971385002, 0.00033560488373041153, -0.010511654429137707, -0.007472785655409098, 0.05088670179247856, 0.015171580947935581, -0.039408955723047256, 0.05827784910798073, -0.010808238759636879, 0.016482297331094742, -0.02992447093129158, -0.007886386476457119, 0.016894079744815826, 0.004221074283123016, 0.00986574962735176, -0.015311411581933498, -0.004489952232688665, -0.002685768064111471, 0.005137252155691385, 0.008759384974837303, -0.006340469233691692, -0.035115230828523636, 0.02595243602991104, 0.0008194418624043465, 0.010804957710206509, 0.03247561678290367, -0.013029736466705799, -0.02178080752491951, 0.017314380034804344, -0.008749924600124359, -0.030462903901934624, -0.00009921529999701306, 0.012203562073409557, -0.0005141203291714191, -0.07105271518230438, 0.003206835361197591, -0.012937837280333042, -0.04382907226681709, 0.024576300755143166, 0.06178341433405876, 0.007908893749117851, 0.0318208746612072, 0.018280116841197014, 0.0234330166131258, 0.0022059837356209755, -0.021924739703536034, 0.008465023711323738, 0.01653982885181904, 0.07240021973848343, 0.020942410454154015, 0.013225498609244823, 0.04334723576903343, -0.020642785355448723, 0.02213178388774395, -0.01737828552722931, 0.016548408195376396, -0.00952273327857256, -0.03365693241357803, 0.021578069776296616, 0.029973061755299568, 0.03185628354549408, -0.007064859848469496, 0.013918053358793259, 0.051582422107458115, -0.07122069597244263, -0.0011865313863381743, -0.030161544680595398, 0.0024686993565410376, -0.04435684531927109, -0.000458002818049863, 0.031196244060993195, 0.02906693145632744, 0.012025786563754082, -0.005127829033881426, -0.007263908628374338, -0.04884602129459381, 0.011143244802951813, -0.033146873116493225, 0.04260225594043732, -0.03812915086746216, -0.021605221554636955, -0.02623114176094532, -0.012688104063272476, -0.0547403059899807, -0.06141532585024834, 0.02953409217298031, 0.028263870626688004, 0.03970344364643097, -0.008185440674424171, -0.02254626899957657, 0.023840226233005524, 0.06188325583934784, -0.05867118760943413, -0.016910990700125694, -0.045438721776008606, 0.01978164166212082, 0.015503953211009502, -0.01910550147294998 ]
<p>As a little experiment, I am extending a nice, interpretable AR/MA relationship between a security $r$ that is variably influenced by the previous $k$ time points over another security $f$. These relationships ("lags") are represented by $l$. I want to pump up the "realism" by making both securities move with stochastic volatility: </p> <p>$ \begin{bmatrix} r_t \\ f_t \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} l_{r,1} &amp; ... &amp; l_{r,k} \\ l_{f,1} &amp; ... &amp; l_{f,k} \end{bmatrix} \Theta_t + \Sigma_t u $</p> <p>$u \sim N(0,1)$</p> <p>$ \log(\Sigma_t) = \begin{bmatrix} \log(\sigma_{r,t}) \\ \log(\sigma_{f,t}) \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} 1 &amp; \phi_r \\ 1 &amp; \phi_t \end{bmatrix} \begin{bmatrix} \omega_r &amp; \omega_f \\ \log(\sigma_{r,t-1}) &amp; \log(\sigma_{r,t-1}) \end{bmatrix} + \begin{bmatrix} \eta_{r,t} \\ \eta_{f,t}) \end{bmatrix} $</p> <p>$\eta_{i,t} \sim N(0,\sigma_{\eta_i})$</p> <p>$ \Theta_t = \begin{bmatrix} f_t \\ f_{t-1} \\ ... \\ f_{t-k} \end{bmatrix} = I \begin{bmatrix} f_{t-1} \\ f_{t-2} \\ ... \\ f_{t-k-1} \end{bmatrix} + \begin{bmatrix} \sigma_{f,t-1} \\ \sigma_{f,t-2} \\ ... \\ \sigma_{f,t-k-1} \end{bmatrix} $</p> <ol> <li><p>Does this look right to better trained eyes, before I whip out a prototype? Especially, suggestions on parameters that might to be worth consolidating (i.e., params not adding much explanatory "value")? </p></li> <li><p>Any suggestions for how to approach the "lag" selection more rigorously (e.g., model selection procedure)? </p></li> <li><p>Does anyone see shortcuts for consolidating the two transition equations ($\log(\Sigma_t)$ and $\Theta_t$) into the typical "state space representation," i.e., the $\Theta$, $F$, $G$, $V$, $W$ referred to in the literature. For some special cases the equations can be simplified substantially: e.g., traditional MA log volatility models, a log transformation of the master equation simplifies out that pesky $u$ stochastic term.</p></li> </ol>
36,087
[ 0.02031599171459675, 0.016206253319978714, 0.0005048234015703201, -0.012445417232811451, 0.023494575172662735, -0.0031811080407351255, -0.01515922136604786, -0.046519935131073, 0.021838027983903885, -0.06267649680376053, -0.012873749248683453, -0.026451749727129936, 0.031106948852539062, 0.011782253161072731, -0.004032098222523928, 0.019191639497876167, -0.032356519252061844, -0.0022367911878973246, -0.00943905021995306, -0.02397225797176361, 0.0244128480553627, 0.038860566914081573, -0.0010460076155140996, -0.0027363719418644905, -0.033795636147260666, 0.06683662533760071, 0.029814070090651512, -0.025827104225754738, -0.034263335168361664, 0.05021850764751434, -0.07645179331302643, 0.004751107655465603, 0.0016980941873043776, 0.019255392253398895, 0.006361047737300396, 0.028935786336660385, -0.02566612884402275, -0.013217647559940815, 0.006244063377380371, 0.040082696825265884, -0.04592595621943474, 0.018154365941882133, -0.01200369093567133, 0.03022865019738674, 0.008283439092338085, 0.004504603799432516, -0.017354758456349373, 0.004603466019034386, 0.0626942366361618, -0.0057296655140817165, 0.07090505957603455, -0.01605706475675106, -0.007224242202937603, 0.04130296781659126, -0.004084722138941288, -0.01310473307967186, 0.01944201998412609, 0.05480648949742317, 0.016507208347320557, -0.014804009348154068, -0.004574430640786886, 0.0009600560297258198, -0.02040117233991623, -0.031384486705064774, -0.002542514819651842, -0.017997561022639275, 0.028125664219260216, 0.012140453793108463, 0.008248009718954563, -0.03368603065609932, -0.002263742033392191, -0.026164431124925613, 0.04383617639541626, -0.01743263192474842, 0.03682782128453255, -0.01035082247108221, -0.02971438691020012, 0.037702031433582306, 0.041837211698293686, 0.01090865395963192, 0.015200718306005001, 0.01014217920601368, 0.041262347251176834, 0.029771428555250168, 0.030913174152374268, -0.0055242558009922504, 0.07167527824640274, -0.009848537854850292, 0.04985521733760834, 0.06803884357213974, -0.05384472757577896, 0.014999018050730228, 0.05380912497639656, -0.01227924507111311, -0.04841507598757744, 0.024098040536046028, -0.02134034037590027, 0.0038490411825478077, -0.002379859331995249, -0.016649117693305016, -0.04617702215909958, -0.06715692579746246, -0.005110262427479029, 0.04524536058306694, 0.023447372019290924, 0.0010285896714776754, 0.0014927358133718371, -0.03511744737625122, -0.012929344549775124, -0.03260786458849907, -0.05844040960073471, 0.015266386792063713, -0.020125603303313255, 0.0043170154094696045, -0.00814738404005766, -0.02220379188656807, -0.038128361105918884, -0.005577828269451857, 0.03391673415899277, 0.061746761202812195, 0.021591374650597572, -0.010672680102288723, 0.010135600343346596, -0.002409395994618535, -0.04427792504429817, 0.056899525225162506, 0.008074264042079449, -0.03328743577003479, -0.06906796246767044, 0.03358696028590202, 0.01368609070777893, -0.019634777680039406, 0.041451599448919296, 0.008547165431082249, 0.056852955371141434, 0.0035255211405456066, -0.12308389693498611, -0.014356683939695358, 0.05413413792848587, -0.00666688522323966, 0.04987910017371178, -0.07367350906133652, 0.006934202276170254, 0.05103515088558197, 0.09630975872278214, -0.015118506737053394, 0.035491567105054855, 0.033530350774526596, 0.024166524410247803, 0.007407763972878456, -0.011040584184229374, -0.02862866222858429, -0.015469933860003948, 0.013162460178136826, -0.010903820395469666, -0.0545811764895916, 0.02491646073758602, 0.047863829880952835, -0.030625345185399055, 0.008064616471529007, 0.06438171863555908, 0.003203706117346883, -0.002485633594915271, -0.009739384055137634, -0.02331172488629818, -0.062122050672769547, 0.047129686921834946, -0.005701594054698944, 0.021858856081962585, -0.01974424533545971, -0.01669759303331375, -0.02080642618238926, -0.01203755009919405, 0.04069240391254425, 0.03438861668109894, -0.026694143190979958, 0.006317990366369486, -0.019065475091338158, -0.01631532795727253, 0.005003457888960838, -0.031605109572410583, -0.028631871566176414, -0.056590307503938675, -0.015793906524777412, 0.009068497456610203, 0.0017081027617678046, 0.018576232716441154, -0.0011167959310114384, 0.025935214012861252, -0.07195541262626648, -0.02900620363652706, -0.04886091500520706, 0.025247544050216675, 0.008600675500929356, -0.04213075712323189, 0.041761673986911774, -0.024059757590293884, 0.03122982196509838, -0.0003868658095598221, -0.03165554627776146, -0.01021274458616972, 0.0049193729646503925, 0.043520644307136536, -0.03231280669569969, 0.027429524809122086, 0.06213456392288208, 0.04488392546772957, 0.014663846231997013, 0.023237215355038643, -0.03163480758666992, -0.02680261991918087, -0.01723703369498253, -0.02487059310078621, 0.03363910689949989, 0.023699600249528885, 0.002674400107935071, 0.03472304716706276, -0.006984199397265911, 0.03332243114709854, 0.015809325501322746, -0.05364224687218666, 0.014401477761566639, 0.06358712166547775, 0.0012111372780054808, -0.0498526468873024, 0.020320281386375427, 0.006027174182236195, 0.03304615244269371, -0.036946188658475876, -0.020692860707640648, -0.010199397802352905, -0.026081183925271034, 0.06099259480834007, 0.06476979702711105, 0.003958225250244141, 0.017367005348205566, 0.06143936142325401, 0.028350787237286568, 0.010280443355441093, 0.04957913979887962, 0.0012010714272037148, -0.020370911806821823, 0.033987805247306824, -0.04062687233090401, 0.03072993829846382, -0.026744861155748367, 0.034163348376750946, -0.01946289651095867, 0.03355173021554947, -0.007038956042379141, 0.007703706622123718, 0.021011654287576675, -0.0012697578640654683, 0.013422313146293163, -0.02609884738922119, -0.0048430077731609344, 0.02686886675655842, 0.00024002796271815896, -0.011017482727766037, 0.016117284074425697, 0.014100887812674046, -0.0032366239465773106, 0.0018181322375312448, -0.02170279063284397, -0.0021181830670684576, 0.015503243543207645, 0.0291164368391037, -0.015707923099398613, 0.009061065502464771, -0.017204774543642998, 0.0026490811724215746, -0.01492978073656559, -0.010728192515671253, 0.009048321284353733, 0.001844443497247994, 0.027232512831687927, 0.004931641276925802, 0.00911268312484026, -0.02673092670738697, -0.036981917917728424, 0.034925997257232666, 0.01302990224212408, 0.021250763908028603, -0.0013550196308642626, -0.040267545729875565, 0.010767379775643349, 0.006269615143537521, 0.009324545040726662, 0.03748808428645134, 0.002512882463634014, 0.01543104276061058, 0.024946575984358788, 0.00394260510802269, -0.05178450047969818, -0.04311145097017288, -0.0345052033662796, -0.01951570063829422, -0.002069160109385848, -0.013088174164295197, 0.06997973471879959, 0.018015721812844276, -0.07496281713247299, 0.00022344206809066236, -0.017247900366783142, 0.009395699948072433, -0.03938862681388855, -0.008648024871945381, -0.03920723497867584, -0.020428791642189026, 0.028567763045430183, 0.014666601084172726, -0.03894428536295891, -0.004719986114650965, -0.07459753006696701, -0.03133847936987877, -0.003356348490342498, -0.01033194549381733, 0.0019275841768831015, -0.0001129382144426927, -0.03214464709162712, 0.09407977759838104, 0.011314884759485722, 0.02262919582426548, -0.025924429297447205, -0.0015057851560413837, 0.0030429863836616278, -0.08947490155696869, 0.03078058920800686, 0.02289705164730549, -0.009585212916135788, 0.04595164582133293, -0.02258114330470562, 0.012849259190261364, 0.05227178335189819, 0.010884404182434082, 0.009608360938727856, 0.029751060530543327, -0.04245651513338089, 0.007434271741658449, 0.0699668675661087, -0.008916550315916538, 0.014758564531803131, -0.011212070472538471, 0.03896161913871765, 0.027588358148932457, 0.06063714623451233, -0.07000722736120224, 0.04509534314274788, 0.018825005739927292, -0.011708525940775871, 0.0028679955285042524, 0.021629823371767998, 0.019533369690179825, -0.056250039488077164, -0.06204506382346153, 0.00974120944738388, 0.01592867076396942, -0.01614469476044178, 0.01102870050817728, 0.054335471242666245, 0.04267743229866028, 0.00867740623652935, -0.011632340960204601, -0.01080603338778019, -0.03311314061284065, 0.0474039725959301, -0.06017887964844704, -0.025181537494063377, 0.020943988114595413, 0.00263204681687057, 0.02977036125957966, -0.023806091398000717, -0.00901000201702118, -0.032613713294267654, -0.05612775683403015, 0.02864345721900463, -0.049250438809394836, 0.06272861361503601, 0.009451418183743954, 0.045975588262081146, 0.004673288203775883, -0.018063243478536606, 0.007307069841772318, -0.00855154450982809, -0.07305093854665756, 0.018353814259171486, -0.009759710170328617, -0.006513164844363928, 0.007893064990639687, -0.026812836527824402, 0.03067731112241745, -0.029184410348534584, -0.004847411997616291, -0.015680093318223953, 0.014234504662454128, -0.03837145119905472, 0.01963440515100956, -0.02955254726111889, -0.02659638226032257, -0.03536233678460121, -0.0014993870863690972, 0.04197106137871742, -0.018644003197550774, 0.03700247406959534, 0.05053405836224556, 0.022673724219202995, 0.01932585798203945, -0.006036315578967333, 0.028859056532382965, 0.02993633598089218, 0.015971967950463295, 0.04111676663160324, -0.01862717792391777, -0.018554825335741043, 0.08428799360990524, -0.003568510990589857, 0.02943865954875946, 0.04136103019118309, 0.0034224814735352993, 0.00017518477397970855, -0.023080160841345787, -0.04340450093150139, 0.01909751631319523, 0.024646418169140816, 0.00436792615801096, -0.02419007569551468, 0.0571133978664875, 0.009231503121554852, 0.008599810302257538, 0.01013969350606203, 0.04180039465427399, 0.04861149564385414, -0.004962450359016657, -0.023568611592054367, 0.0031702080741524696, 0.028022147715091705, -0.002385971834883094, 0.005300117190927267, 0.04005531221628189, -0.007111721206456423, 0.013234288431704044, 0.014505472034215927, -0.011157304979860783, -0.01319922972470522, 0.011164664290845394, 0.029559116810560226, 0.024391386657953262, 0.024349361658096313, -0.0022752031218260527, 0.024823946878314018, 0.016144705936312675, 0.014845072291791439, 0.03228257969021797, 0.052806317806243896, -0.09294179081916809, 0.012197934091091156, 0.02456715703010559, -0.004392854403704405, -0.008056784979999065, -0.023624971508979797, -0.027780966833233833, -0.04558547958731651, 0.008568735793232918, -0.0034845147747546434, 0.06169315055012703, 0.001936210785061121, 0.0022134464234113693, -0.03602280840277672, -0.0365508496761322, 0.0035757627338171005, 0.03982584923505783, 0.013060085475444794, 0.04304458573460579, -0.01568944938480854, -0.028350144624710083, -0.02767350897192955, -0.009927020408213139, 0.03581271320581436, 0.05356209725141525, -0.009348809719085693, -0.005454649217426777, -0.01624196209013462, 0.04375326260924339, 0.009554360061883926, -0.08536145091056824, 0.021993834525346756, -0.000508352997712791, -0.02333768829703331, 0.024429595097899437, -0.009159091860055923, -0.011582346633076668, 0.0056205568835139275, 0.016547078266739845, 0.01980501413345337, -0.004245918709784746, -0.015427183359861374, 0.0557827465236187, 0.04278058931231499, 0.011650345288217068, 0.06330963224172592, 0.044061318039894104, 0.008585657924413681, 0.02790788933634758, -0.04661896452307701, 0.0003994748985860497, -0.011664791963994503, 0.03894824534654617, -0.04875040426850319, 0.012216511182487011, -0.02688911184668541, 0.026685496792197227, -0.015651298686861992, 0.028781527653336525, -0.029701534658670425, 0.009235485456883907, -0.013530583120882511, 0.010301805101335049, -0.04073300585150719, -0.021867536008358, 0.021418074145913124, -0.03237977623939514, -0.013124199584126472, 0.007972835563123226, 0.016818352043628693, -0.03772954270243645, -0.027645293623209, 0.03335161134600639, -0.026682473719120026, -0.022734325379133224, -0.0034941674675792456, 0.010334481485188007, -0.014789923094213009, -0.009241295047104359, 0.05847810208797455, 0.024610018357634544, 0.04647320881485939, 0.016454745084047318, 0.005964091047644615, 0.01738280989229679, 0.024012500420212746, 0.005210850853472948, -0.001230894704349339, -0.009386692196130753, 0.014152470976114273, 0.010133307427167892, -0.030889810994267464, -0.05956871807575226, -0.030416207388043404, 0.02025151066482067, -0.030578745529055595, -0.04999880492687225, -0.023864855989813805, 0.012994995340704918, -0.028958119451999664, -0.029162194579839706, 0.005168095696717501, 0.030310487374663353, 0.005153164267539978, -0.022036613896489143, 0.004516722168773413, 0.036200907081365585, 0.06991388648748398, -0.018431542441248894, 0.027410056442022324, 0.02143833413720131, -0.02653152495622635, 0.00023545374278910458, -3.8431281268458406e-7, 0.023590536788105965, -0.02360234409570694, 0.016047155484557152, -0.010037215426564217, -0.025656841695308685, 0.011774921789765358, -0.018211163580417633, -0.00011615909897955135, 0.01518204901367426, 0.0037097905296832323, 0.05670981481671333, -0.02061545103788376, -0.00179098395165056, 0.03582227975130081, 0.016214072704315186, -0.015351344831287861, -0.015021937899291515, -0.0057950145564973354, -0.023901036009192467, 0.004365876317024231, -0.015239663422107697, -0.01266215369105339, -0.013691677711904049, 0.06949246674776077, -0.017252309247851372, -0.013545647263526917, -0.002892346354201436, 0.05157066509127617, 0.031005248427391052, -0.022134317085146904, 0.02123536542057991, 0.008580399677157402, -0.008851872757077217, -0.046124622225761414, -0.06643036752939224, -0.03549143299460411, 0.011701904237270355, 0.04479968920350075, -0.0011025945423170924, 0.03926343843340874, 0.0023374459706246853, -0.016750598326325417, 0.0040375120006501675, -0.01747855357825756, 0.0029834737069904804, -0.011215362697839737, -0.018719395622611046, 0.043801676481962204, -0.05690493807196617, -0.0008514575310982764, 0.010287076234817505, 0.006583730224519968, 0.009164433926343918, 0.022544683888554573, 0.010581793263554573, 0.014873038046061993, 0.005097887013107538, -0.026183973997831345, -0.02173835225403309, 0.06726165860891342, -0.05660625174641609, 0.05099717527627945, -0.04409066587686539, -0.012268482707440853, 0.043074484914541245, 0.05135675519704819, -0.0011357635958120227, -0.028130192309617996, 0.017631540074944496, -0.05238586291670799, -0.016608629375696182, 0.0011632171226665378, -0.014960259199142456, 0.05702437087893486, -0.022728919982910156, 0.08009826391935349, -0.02859194204211235, -0.0009250272414647043, -0.008792809210717678, -0.07054600864648819, 0.0004431576235219836, -0.016828812658786774, -0.04452158510684967, 0.03902951627969742, -0.02382437139749527, -0.01593702845275402, 0.004331076517701149, -0.019018258899450302, 0.02040882594883442, -0.008937958627939224, 0.013405418023467064, -0.04656605422496796, 0.09117618948221207, -0.019910475239157677, 0.042439911514520645, -0.010993109084665775, -0.03213554620742798, 0.16638830304145813, 0.039949867874383926, 0.010277033783495426, -0.06143355742096901, -0.0131985517218709, -0.0134697575122118, 0.023005807772278786, -0.048178642988204956, 0.0019960515201091766, 0.014624486677348614, -0.027449047192931175, -0.007470885291695595, 0.0577051043510437, -0.03194526955485344, -0.021060580387711525, 0.017468877136707306, -0.05672210827469826, 0.025349395349621773, -0.034005969762802124, 0.00008095749217318371, -0.00718127703294158, 0.0027084038592875004, -0.046995095908641815, 0.014202537946403027, -0.046003639698028564, 0.00915906485170126, 0.0030440734699368477, -0.022776605561375618, 0.01512972079217434, -0.027600185945630074, -0.018263166770339012, -0.01632564887404442, 0.03829644247889519, 0.005532236769795418, 0.05694229155778885, -0.002485087141394615, 0.024286001920700073, -0.04020650312304497, 0.022066768258810043, 0.03443276509642601, -0.010616100393235683, -0.0015633988659828901, -0.009699276648461819, -0.0013798814034089446, -0.035411398857831955, -0.03975001350045204, -0.0734671950340271, 0.047011762857437134, -0.03276336193084717, -0.013849681243300438, -0.039317358285188675, -0.01064284611493349, 0.013028276152908802, -0.02716357447206974, -0.013724172487854958, 0.04028405249118805, 0.03784244507551193, -0.031833793967962265, 0.009457265958189964, -0.024585958570241928, -0.0007477285107597709, 0.0034356911201030016, 0.06573156267404556, -0.005986393895000219, -0.04042622447013855, -0.029481081292033195, -0.02770954556763172, 0.052261047065258026, -0.03130655363202095, 0.011457528918981552, -0.02645297162234783, 0.022612744942307472, -0.030457012355327606, -0.02184782177209854, 0.012074495665729046, 0.007356131449341774, 0.014631172642111778, -0.0034756390377879143, -0.015615931712090969, -0.01670452207326889, -0.037326715886592865, 0.007449656259268522, 0.0007712833466939628, -0.045286279171705246, -0.050070248544216156, -0.0185408815741539, 0.041487742215394974, 0.010532322339713573, -0.009485656395554543, -0.006199071183800697, -0.022840101271867752, 0.05602557957172394, 0.05484737455844879, -0.06454477459192276, -0.05235143378376961, -0.002292143413797021, -0.0224258191883564, -0.024580389261245728, 0.0015120577299967408, 0.01828807219862938, 0.014703026041388512, -0.0121878357604146, -0.016500407829880714, 0.03629061207175255, -0.011754215694963932, -0.008920246735215187, 0.045304156839847565, 0.000758204550947994, 0.016976747661828995, 0.05511271208524704, -0.004280407447367907, 0.004660509526729584, 0.008198256604373455, 0.008454340510070324, -0.039708495140075684, -0.03125382587313652, -0.03393236920237541, -0.044232334941625595, 0.009075955487787724, -0.02996131405234337, 0.011201402172446251, -0.029860099777579308, -0.00039175566053017974, 0.005701570771634579, 0.012317352928221226, -0.02486059069633484, 0.0009427800541743636, -0.043800245970487595, 0.040007881820201874, -0.02545180171728134, 0.000403308542445302, 0.04663342982530594, -0.0049841455183923244, 0.04359595477581024, -0.05513795465230942, 0.034407105296850204, -0.014884811826050282, -0.004091154783964157, -0.020814916118979454, -0.013673477806150913, 0.0010304112220183015, -0.002836767118424177, -0.01491039153188467, 0.001221829792484641, 0.04132957383990288, 0.04286384582519531, -0.004875540733337402, -0.003905602265149355, -0.04044950753450394, 0.04642913118004799, -0.0069239214062690735, -0.015523591078817844, -0.009682881645858288, 0.00874252337962389, 0.013499517925083637, -0.031110115349292755, 0.024083539843559265, -0.010810678824782372, 0.03060758300125599, -0.06653346866369247, 0.03150089830160141, -0.05543840304017067, -0.0013178798835724592, 0.0091553945094347, -0.0016865162178874016, -0.0007977442583069205, -0.0025618525687605143, -0.019853223115205765, 0.05739564821124077, 0.04019814357161522, 0.008114015683531761, -0.01945549063384533, 0.006355562712997198, -0.0013758348068222404, -0.03971505165100098, -0.015313118696212769, 0.0383039154112339, -0.00022131357400212437, 0.056136906147003174, -0.04004978761076927, -0.00287588476203382, 0.0021488857455551624, -0.04296135902404785, 0.001908523729071021, -0.007865197025239468, 0.024994781240820885, -0.0501415841281414, -0.011590225622057915, -0.0413062609732151, 0.025751903653144836, 0.04240598529577255, -0.002076214412227273, -0.017812252044677734, 0.018438933417201042, 0.029298586770892143, -0.021306117996573448, -0.029299549758434296, 0.0009571457630954683, -0.011143272742629051, -0.007424990180879831, 0.03203360736370087, -0.045531827956438065, 0.007076642010360956, 0.01832997053861618, -0.003508219728246331, 0.03604114428162575, -0.002683496568351984, 0.047844547778367996, 0.031662873923778534, 0.021834013983607292, 0.0228936318308115, 0.0011046143481507897, 0.016381697729229927, -0.02705489844083786, 0.03311801329255104, -0.00526454346254468, -0.005601042415946722, 0.002393967006355524, 0.029348205775022507, -0.039420370012521744, 0.003309252904728055, 0.013346802443265915, -0.031736720353364944, 0.011840607970952988, -0.015028837136924267, -0.04895259812474251, -0.02384335547685623, -0.00457462202757597, 0.04195600375533104, -0.0041335285641252995, -0.030680503696203232, 0.06121624633669853, 0.033069342374801636, -0.027671491727232933, 0.009486092254519463, -0.019945228472352028, -0.03966957703232765, 0.03326835483312607, -0.0010442574275657535, 0.037499383091926575, -0.04602383077144623, -0.046852175146341324, -0.011843443848192692, 0.0019587629940360785, -0.028935516253113747, 0.023922286927700043, -0.006944441236555576, 0.03647667542099953, -0.009571436792612076, 0.011408170685172081, 0.014384056441485882, -0.007185077760368586, 0.022639667615294456, -0.042841389775276184, 0.05650053173303604, -0.024349763989448547, 0.0014840036164969206, 0.014646182768046856, -0.027707591652870178, -0.004058876074850559, 0.035016052424907684, 0.054450780153274536, -0.0059802778996527195, -0.008501969277858734, 0.0199574064463377, 0.03737308084964752, 0.019770251587033272, -0.02542261965572834, 0.026696164160966873, -0.035786986351013184, -0.016369013115763664, -0.010336301289498806, 0.006314686965197325, 0.012811519205570221, -0.0029676277190446854, -0.0024221644271165133, -0.008543310686945915, -0.05396251007914543, 0.020538538694381714, -0.07008173316717148, 0.021052608266472816, -0.03374803066253662, -0.022403204813599586, 0.027124181389808655, 0.04265255108475685, -0.0027654198929667473, 0.020134376361966133, -0.0035767497029155493, -0.05255471542477608, 0.03642472252249718, -0.04330739751458168, -0.02225540205836296, -0.04857182502746582, -0.009430457837879658, 0.024595413357019424, -0.041040726006031036, 0.005938798189163208, 0.051388517022132874, -0.05157042294740677, 0.002416848437860608, 0.056020233780145645, -0.015133865177631378, 0.010250833816826344, 0.02514190599322319, 0.05523636192083359, -0.002047467976808548, 0.005974950734525919, 0.01532350666821003, 0.004390208050608635, 0.012861797586083412, -0.029628198593854904, 0.006760443560779095, 0.022083312273025513, -0.048072848469018936, 0.021581513807177544, -0.0337071567773819, 0.013953573070466518, -0.046255216002464294, -0.007433528546243906, 0.06936544924974442, -0.04156871140003204, 0.011798262596130371, 0.039174314588308334, 0.013389849103987217, 0.043324440717697144, -0.056489426642656326, -0.0020070206373929977, -0.024834882467985153, 0.05988125875592232, -0.010624930262565613, 0.023711472749710083, 0.003525638720020652, 0.03221316263079643, -0.010194393806159496, 0.009677011519670486, -0.010124731808900833, -0.018502753227949142, -0.007555127143859863, -0.061836451292037964, -0.02403470128774643, 0.011455637402832508, -0.009554827585816383, 0.0012754177441820502, -0.060009364038705826, -0.044749584048986435, -0.022220751270651817, 0.026093726977705956, 0.023450210690498352, -0.01627272367477417, -0.043630845844745636, -0.03485437110066414, 0.01300555095076561, 0.05316510796546936, -0.0534893237054348, 0.003533125389367342, -0.0013835271820425987, 0.00414549233391881, 0.008546790108084679, -0.0038022689986974 ]
<p>I have 20 years of data from observing dolphins. When a group is seen, it gets an unique number identifying it, and all identified (marked) dolphins were also registered. So I had a table like</p> <pre><code>Group Dolphin 1 1 1 10 1 14 2 10 2 23 </code></pre> <p>I got about 20,000 groups and 500 dolphins. I made a matrix with groups in rows and dolphins in columns, with 1 where a dolphin is in a group, 0 where it's not. So I've ran a multivariate analysis (prcomp in R), and it gave me two very distinct blocks.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/CjplT.png" alt="PCA"></p> <p>I know that the vertical axis (PC2) is related with the size of the group, the small groups are below, in the bottom of the triangles. But the two blocks are separated in the horizontal axis (PC1), and I didn't figured yet what it's about. I suppose the dolphin population might be separated into two "clans" or something like that, but couldn't discover yet. I colored the points according to group size, water level, place of sight, but all patterns appear equally on both sides. The block on the right has about 2400 points.</p> <p>My questions are: such a separation must mean something, right? What other tools can I use to understand what is going on?</p> <p>Thanks very much!</p>
36,088
[ -0.031566061079502106, -0.0033664533402770758, -0.014249630272388458, -0.0035779851023107767, 0.06980513781309128, -0.0006947929505258799, -0.05420784279704094, 0.0030039579141885042, 0.00019065203377977014, -0.07479441165924072, 0.045764774084091187, 0.048135798424482346, 0.029502004384994507, 0.03137711435556412, 0.04873733967542648, -0.008511114865541458, -0.025265557691454887, 0.009614772163331509, 0.01649628020823002, 0.010527114383876324, 0.005907224025577307, 0.021455179899930954, 0.024596499279141426, -0.037621863186359406, -0.004235250409692526, 0.0691041573882103, 0.01459212601184845, 0.009126384742558002, 0.016519494354724884, 0.03861212730407715, -0.052297335118055344, -0.07114123553037643, 0.01318163052201271, 0.004025246482342482, -0.005506040528416634, -0.006762478034943342, 0.01348311360925436, -0.018778569996356964, -0.0060132467187941074, 0.03984050080180168, -0.029658405110239983, -0.023319177329540253, 0.0050210244953632355, 0.04791124165058136, -0.02544773928821087, -0.008139784447848797, 0.016044188290834427, -0.015178503468632698, 0.05200989916920662, -0.020363999530673027, 0.07048219442367554, 0.0039792656898498535, 0.036001838743686676, 0.022313719615340233, -0.017506953328847885, 0.012548482976853848, 0.042543087154626846, 0.030234167352318764, -0.00918201357126236, -0.04759787395596504, -0.01893036626279354, -0.00010173817281611264, 0.023567140102386475, 0.006320915650576353, -0.0032015391625463963, 0.037689175456762314, -0.022202398627996445, -0.040799304842948914, 0.03164789825677872, -0.019861100241541862, 0.026484038680791855, 0.01710861548781395, 0.05920904129743576, -0.027117406949400902, 0.011358390562236309, -0.03341452032327652, 0.009490696713328362, 0.049991998821496964, 0.04419517517089844, 0.012123152613639832, -0.01489342749118805, 0.03851309046149254, -0.0030264228116720915, -0.011132105253636837, 0.05356485769152641, -0.015417727641761303, 0.04291628673672676, -0.04871620982885361, 0.006510703358799219, 0.0035814177244901657, -0.016092294827103615, 0.01998712867498398, 0.04969003424048424, 0.014610604383051395, -0.06221983581781387, 0.04875827208161354, 0.0010882889619097114, 0.012788359075784683, 0.022954266518354416, -0.026851024478673935, -0.022409630939364433, -0.06458759307861328, -0.0026621161960065365, 0.03488786891102791, -0.04313759133219719, 0.0010727698681876063, -0.08103829622268677, -0.0196820180863142, -0.03721577674150467, -0.012496823444962502, 0.009771876037120819, 0.006139142904430628, 0.008466550149023533, -0.025462286546826363, 0.024569842964410782, 0.008980179205536842, 0.001533306553028524, 0.016728514805436134, 0.0648619756102562, 0.04086223244667053, 0.044425610452890396, -0.0026820246130228043, 0.015185744501650333, -0.02862553298473358, -0.08462002873420715, 0.017358001321554184, -0.006394635885953903, -0.024223390966653824, -0.037697646766901016, 0.07891358435153961, -0.003534024814143777, 0.00846700370311737, 0.03782350569963455, -0.05853302404284477, 0.023896101862192154, -0.0031657565850764513, -0.0648646131157875, -0.02551741525530815, 0.05809713155031204, -0.014242950826883316, 0.02818126417696476, -0.05017198622226715, 0.006675770506262779, 0.007786083500832319, 0.04104232415556908, -0.025275226682424545, -0.005761770065873861, 0.0038696369156241417, 0.027687812224030495, 0.003008221974596381, -0.010656725615262985, -0.005505882669240236, -0.04927820712327957, -0.01899813488125801, -0.021268494427204132, -0.09221110492944717, 0.026686962693929672, 0.015224345959722996, -0.007571790367364883, 0.012060645036399364, 0.05261683464050293, 0.004953569266945124, -0.016724517568945885, -0.020898893475532532, -0.0030271809082478285, -0.012760328128933907, 0.07966968417167664, -0.03670550137758255, 0.018504967913031578, 0.023924821987748146, 0.011798802763223648, 0.05317350849509239, 0.013849364593625069, 0.04974253475666046, 0.04541506618261337, -0.003876190399751067, 0.012549111619591713, 0.016464879736304283, -0.0068399421870708466, 0.005520460195839405, -0.05601020157337189, -0.03388745337724686, -0.03235706686973572, 0.0030311995651572943, 0.07086021453142166, 0.023433826863765717, -0.02253519557416439, -0.04136176407337189, 0.01887972466647625, -0.0301448293030262, -0.04727340117096901, -0.05958212912082672, 0.0017571842763572931, -0.04659745842218399, -0.007503986824303865, 0.01432808581739664, -0.013498557731509209, -0.006837361957877874, 0.009721758775413036, -0.04659228399395943, -0.028711067512631416, -0.013327323831617832, 0.07603488117456436, -0.05236922204494476, -0.013165724463760853, -0.00020837131887674332, 0.022914914414286613, 0.0194868016988039, 0.03693101182579994, -0.022681208327412605, -0.009621766395866871, -0.0017001326195895672, -0.035357631742954254, -0.008720338344573975, -0.019615745171904564, 0.012165050953626633, 0.016792254522442818, 0.02076554484665394, -0.05303915962576866, 0.034886471927165985, -0.02729840576648712, 0.030321218073368073, 0.02460869960486889, -0.007349235936999321, 0.01799808256328106, -0.007683859672397375, 0.007301469333469868, 0.007704806514084339, -0.039032649248838425, -0.03279541805386543, -0.07027207314968109, -0.00046700399252586067, 0.034801628440618515, 0.014198211021721363, -0.021460531279444695, 0.008796836249530315, 0.020629609003663063, 0.06341123580932617, -0.01665503717958927, 0.011795902624726295, 0.0030178276356309652, 0.028076712042093277, 0.025441421195864677, 0.04776521772146225, -0.0185979213565588, 0.012071868404746056, 0.03680795058608055, -0.03305133059620857, 0.05233298987150192, -0.029954206198453903, -0.018478117883205414, 0.028894221410155296, -0.0098950807005167, 0.004408949986100197, -0.027435239404439926, -0.003358010668307543, 0.0713886171579361, -0.01691461354494095, 0.014934287406504154, -0.008112485520541668, 0.02712145820260048, -0.04415873438119888, -0.00808905903249979, -0.004315666854381561, -0.01609841175377369, 0.03241611272096634, -0.04013518616557121, 0.025893574580550194, 0.02433798648416996, -0.02842445857822895, 0.07878994196653366, -0.047397587448358536, -0.04115840792655945, -0.013527683913707733, 0.02501799538731575, 0.06604640185832977, 0.02835283987224102, 0.028730574995279312, -0.07003103196620941, 0.01055553276091814, -0.04715095832943916, 0.014330809935927391, 0.034074220806360245, 0.007892419584095478, -0.07153217494487762, 0.0011469150194898248, -0.02764207497239113, 0.02247728407382965, 0.0012505172053351998, -0.010217977687716484, -0.020241618156433105, 0.018746081739664078, 0.004696611315011978, -0.05179167911410332, -0.05738452449440956, -0.04648734629154205, 0.013093450106680393, -0.04403653368353844, -0.0384218692779541, 0.018835630267858505, 0.015589660964906216, -0.014883158728480339, 0.014142848551273346, -0.06338518857955933, -0.002875224919989705, -0.009102322161197662, 0.0027004918083548546, 0.038187917321920395, -0.009870472364127636, 0.005257280543446541, 0.025959553197026253, -0.002813064493238926, -0.01622459478676319, -0.023120325058698654, -0.06937161833047867, -0.012359537184238434, -0.018348410725593567, 0.016173552721738815, -0.02933908812701702, 0.025199977681040764, 0.05142258107662201, 0.022212885320186615, -0.018420619890093803, -0.041079357266426086, -0.0008806197438389063, -0.07569169253110886, -0.018363088369369507, 0.01727863773703575, 0.030985381454229355, 0.02724488265812397, 0.024271000176668167, -0.02364720217883587, 0.04952077567577362, 0.05789148434996605, -0.040822673588991165, -0.00530095212161541, 0.04292065277695656, -0.029428493231534958, -0.017675161361694336, 0.017563577741384506, 0.015101524069905281, -0.038131073117256165, 0.019406776875257492, 0.011144354939460754, -0.00878065638244152, 0.03262975811958313, -0.04104595258831978, 0.014487974345684052, 0.0009006050531752408, 0.022902345284819603, -0.03009442239999771, 0.018846306949853897, 0.02340071275830269, -0.007912086322903633, -0.0060787508264184, 0.012724080123007298, 0.06805357336997986, -0.034300994127988815, -0.037977829575538635, 0.07956555485725403, 0.01966439187526703, 0.001437402213923633, 0.018023088574409485, -0.02955090068280697, -0.00030163038172759116, -0.006916828919202089, -0.011005472391843796, -0.005874305963516235, 0.027951156720519066, -0.009420792572200298, 0.048475828021764755, 0.027490178123116493, -0.010474265553057194, -0.021453125402331352, -0.04333900287747383, 0.010007533244788647, -0.010489584878087044, 0.011365097016096115, -0.020090628415346146, 0.025057392194867134, -0.011814752593636513, -0.018767118453979492, 0.009835096076130867, -0.00032667312189005315, -0.03481999412178993, -0.00971208419650793, 0.003712565405294299, 0.006131961476057768, 0.009333617985248566, -0.037809330970048904, 0.026731953024864197, 0.01718517765402794, 0.0153465885668993, 0.003565504914149642, 0.035617806017398834, -0.03095761314034462, 0.016100319102406502, -0.013890918344259262, 0.0025244627613574266, -0.01940145716071129, 0.0113361282274127, 0.019949868321418762, 0.016473840922117233, 0.011301737278699875, 0.0157313235104084, -0.00496049365028739, 0.023753460496664047, -0.031020671129226685, -0.03430517762899399, 0.052082210779190063, 0.011452619917690754, -0.0012920934241265059, 0.03784146532416344, -0.01305790152400732, -0.04076211899518967, -0.037121571600437164, 0.022872932255268097, 0.027615098282694817, 0.020409103482961655, 0.0175537820905447, -0.03667652979493141, 0.006712912116199732, 0.01546389702707529, 0.019693523645401, -0.006419106852263212, 0.032025501132011414, 0.0029179975390434265, 0.021098526194691658, -0.04898468032479286, 0.010872891172766685, 0.044005680829286575, 0.06068167835474014, 0.002838892862200737, -0.02779054269194603, -0.025687869638204575, 0.02661268785595894, -0.0051123821176588535, 0.01737511157989502, 0.004505810793489218, -0.0022879710886627436, -0.017807358875870705, 0.038664817810058594, -0.006782545708119869, 0.0010921657085418701, -0.005020806100219488, -0.025037802755832672, 0.026421941816806793, -0.043139733374118805, 0.011217252351343632, -0.014632468111813068, 0.006091487593948841, 0.06700892001390457, 0.005101043730974197, 0.021188784390687943, -0.07117833197116852, -0.029828466475009918, -0.0054641785100102425, 0.02731601893901825, -0.0001556265342514962, -0.004794648382812738, -0.06405122578144073, -0.03691589832305908, -0.002441740594804287, -0.03657669946551323, 0.045075125992298126, 0.006533332634717226, 0.005723471753299236, -0.025146501138806343, 0.009593551978468895, -0.03226621821522713, 0.015981663018465042, 0.025648407638072968, 0.05198059231042862, -0.019016241654753685, -0.03330903500318527, -0.0023877592757344246, 0.02776004560291767, 0.029019761830568314, 0.011890034191310406, -0.023296017199754715, -0.0038441813085228205, 0.009077152237296104, 0.047087229788303375, -0.018157050013542175, -0.04376072436571121, 0.04571118578314781, -0.007656844798475504, 0.011874862015247345, 0.08684280514717102, -0.013959743082523346, -0.051045872271060944, -0.012321125715970993, 0.0026623180601745844, 0.009184570983052254, -0.0174541175365448, -0.008987057954072952, 0.038306958973407745, 0.04939296469092369, 0.01983453892171383, 0.045689672231674194, 0.04164661839604378, -0.013811212964355946, -0.01989595778286457, -0.036870118230581284, 0.013225016184151173, 0.01477167196571827, -0.024656951427459717, -0.013810981996357441, 0.020496631041169167, -0.03978866711258888, 0.028944505378603935, -0.011099542491137981, 0.03346797078847885, -0.014809801243245602, -0.002419154392555356, 0.0318039245903492, 0.05669032409787178, -0.05893436446785927, 0.0032725927885621786, 0.005604439415037632, 0.025768611580133438, 0.016233742237091064, -0.03829620033502579, 0.04628972336649895, -0.01891779713332653, -0.021549738943576813, -0.010184111073613167, -0.0016913216095417738, -0.0027770893648266792, -0.014382502995431423, -0.02145419456064701, 0.01261346135288477, -0.03521182760596275, 0.032776229083538055, -0.037231143563985825, 0.025310637429356575, 0.009077566675841808, -0.03934361785650253, -0.0018840371631085873, -0.006405935622751713, -0.007660468574613333, 0.0480535514652729, -0.035314708948135376, 0.062397051602602005, -0.005261234473437071, -0.0017127831233665347, -0.05161644518375397, -0.05424913391470909, 0.028437631204724312, 0.0417887382209301, -0.041860517114400864, -0.0496441125869751, -0.012459637597203255, 0.02247706986963749, -0.00479381438344717, -0.01203018706291914, 0.0632665827870369, -0.04273638874292374, -0.035436514765024185, -0.010614016093313694, 0.01378667913377285, 0.11639433354139328, -0.0223609060049057, -0.02848329395055771, 0.014655295759439468, -0.027905043214559555, 0.005460415966808796, 0.0006510487874038517, 0.00731962313875556, -0.053672559559345245, -0.0281700287014246, -0.028845367953181267, 0.04924387112259865, 0.03529942408204079, -0.04558560624718666, -0.016446135938167572, -0.020801737904548645, 0.014253529720008373, 0.0446116141974926, -0.01595437526702881, 0.004228405654430389, -0.003167656948789954, -0.011688873171806335, -0.028450241312384605, 0.0207353588193655, 0.016843367367982864, -0.03254866972565651, 0.0284354817122221, -0.005708013661205769, 0.008416843600571156, 0.004215208347886801, 0.07795274257659912, -0.04577123746275902, -0.0192226842045784, 0.013838623650372028, 0.0034736949019134045, 0.05358731374144554, -0.0015825428999960423, 0.015087920241057873, -0.04322318732738495, 0.06110844388604164, -0.05149591341614723, -0.00786123238503933, -0.022623227909207344, -0.00030322966631501913, 0.08819347620010376, 0.020882153883576393, 0.018600083887577057, 0.012449834495782852, -0.016618018969893456, 0.009062085300683975, -0.014168163761496544, -0.007970673032104969, -0.004546335898339748, 0.0020314878784120083, 0.049780964851379395, -0.048349544405937195, -0.03649777173995972, 0.02923000045120716, 0.04460359737277031, 0.04657720401883125, 0.0339348167181015, 0.022792773321270943, 0.008566824719309807, -0.004357967525720596, -0.026072265580296516, -0.04836123436689377, 0.02694035694003105, -0.021362220868468285, 0.010574343614280224, -0.031842317432165146, -0.003457101061940193, 0.05992380529642105, 0.06453739106655121, 0.02210727147758007, -0.06117483600974083, -0.012252294458448887, -0.019449438899755478, 0.0054094004444777966, 0.04452323913574219, 0.019610349088907242, -0.0044244020245969296, 0.01295361015945673, 0.013175924308598042, 0.006635979283601046, -0.011403955519199371, -0.01182730682194233, -0.029261188581585884, -0.028281597420573235, -0.024123268201947212, -0.052132297307252884, 0.05309523269534111, -0.015030167065560818, -0.06198812276124954, 0.00047105553676374257, -0.0339043065905571, -0.011701490730047226, 0.024723075330257416, 0.016372183337807655, -0.037035390734672546, 0.05444767698645592, 0.02736399695277214, 0.036874230951070786, 0.007101952098309994, -0.030088163912296295, 0.11120892316102982, 0.053895700722932816, 0.03849297761917114, -0.04057709500193596, 0.044162262231111526, -0.0018619467737153172, -0.012046598829329014, -0.042139727622270584, 0.0076065827161073685, 0.028751656413078308, 0.016901804134249687, 0.0467967763543129, 0.05936185270547867, 0.04778919741511345, 0.007300680037587881, 0.04747667908668518, -0.02120955102145672, -0.036743808537721634, -0.0234589334577322, 0.011500522494316101, -0.007727154064923525, -0.021816644817590714, -0.021628646180033684, 0.018185794353485107, 0.028951440006494522, -0.012781171128153801, -0.03095681220293045, 0.012875058688223362, 0.003808705834671855, 0.025531254708766937, -0.021319152787327766, 0.005626769736409187, 0.007247501984238625, 0.00437950948253274, -0.05922209843993187, 0.004286865703761578, -0.021580934524536133, -0.017549961805343628, 0.01947961561381817, 0.011118028312921524, -0.010558289475739002, 0.007645272649824619, -0.031257376074790955, -0.008831173181533813, -0.010332876816391945, -0.04731488227844238, -0.020913638174533844, 0.05569421127438545, -0.010446693748235703, -0.057705074548721313, -0.0011117295362055302, 0.01333506777882576, 0.01190459355711937, -0.035699713975191116, -0.018503865227103233, 0.014134365133941174, 0.006495031528174877, 0.0064636413007974625, -0.0025665618013590574, -0.015254366211593151, 0.023238621652126312, -0.0338289774954319, 0.000022048216123948805, 0.011489761993288994, -0.013345583342015743, -0.03725944831967354, -0.015552767552435398, 0.07703210413455963, -0.00665309838950634, 0.025866694748401642, -0.0037071274127811193, -0.021108029410243034, -0.03265935182571411, -0.03264634311199188, -0.03788583725690842, 0.025021081790328026, 0.016373462975025177, 0.018978537991642952, -0.08485465496778488, 0.006568748038262129, -0.035842638462781906, 0.009308652952313423, -0.04461081326007843, -0.011896245181560516, -0.027933862060308456, -0.0059009636752307415, 0.011313892900943756, 0.03207603469491005, -0.0003496179706417024, 0.04547260329127312, -0.01872270740568638, 0.061489515006542206, 0.007272303104400635, -0.011414716951549053, -0.03375020995736122, -0.004411706235259771, -0.022101905196905136, 0.023439906537532806, -0.019987724721431732, 0.05903598666191101, 0.008485326543450356, -0.008587172254920006, 0.020341219380497932, 0.028392519801855087, 0.01701696403324604, 0.006909376475960016, 0.0274940337985754, -0.059515759348869324, 0.01625947840511799, -0.0513058565557003, -0.030899252742528915, -0.01662025973200798, -0.01931293122470379, -0.012343277223408222, -0.011145408265292645, -0.008642018772661686, -0.014432745054364204, -0.030581800267100334, -0.0351528599858284, -0.05458352342247963, 0.02220754884183407, 0.007560860365629196, -0.039419494569301605, -0.08367251604795456, -0.03186534717679024, -0.006473836023360491, -0.0003401832655072212, -0.04401561990380287, -0.02345210500061512, 0.0051483940333127975, 0.010327794589102268, 0.022114958614110947, -0.01508663035929203, 0.021245503798127174, -0.01130667608231306, 0.03700171038508415, 0.017103882506489754, 0.04884476587176323, 0.013154304586350918, -0.02592580020427704, 0.014408331364393234, -0.031020911410450935, -0.06802012026309967, 0.025238532572984695, -0.007951856590807438, 0.025890951976180077, -0.04338208958506584, 0.011409862898290157, -0.015151895582675934, 0.05918065458536148, -0.021262142807245255, -0.04529290646314621, -0.015250101685523987, 0.018846651539206505, -0.001977824606001377, -0.009028052911162376, 0.033072665333747864, 0.03722202032804489, -0.03400954604148865, 0.03173285350203514, 0.021270886063575745, -0.023211704567074776, -0.049718908965587616, -0.03105751797556877, -0.03605841472744942, 0.026805730536580086, 0.0009512463584542274, 0.018385739997029305, 0.020985623821616173, 0.041542377322912216, -0.0033674270380288363, 0.01217062957584858, -0.02409444749355316, 0.01832840032875538, -0.049605485051870346, -0.01376946922391653, -0.007977448403835297, 0.002899595070630312, 0.03057464212179184, -0.05379427969455719, 0.011750807985663414, 0.02846725471317768, -0.06601226329803467, -0.010311437770724297, -0.019604284316301346, 0.01669543795287609, -0.05500747635960579, 0.010553429834544659, -0.03238590434193611, 0.027970662340521812, 0.023680271580815315, -0.005385989788919687, 0.0554494746029377, 0.045064013451337814, -0.011420274153351784, -0.04295054078102112, -0.00846216082572937, 0.00547719607129693, 0.05335182696580887, -0.03347671777009964, 0.027347050607204437, 0.01300171297043562, -0.0015425017336383462, 0.004754264373332262, -0.08983404189348221, 0.009124689735472202, 0.06970972567796707, 0.03727230429649353, 0.0003520740137901157, 0.028959909453988075, 0.008990227244794369, 0.001286181970499456, -0.041009772568941116, 0.012928733602166176, 0.006066903937608004, 0.008402492851018906, 0.023068808019161224, 0.017806682735681534, 0.02597622387111187, -0.02891448140144348, 0.011521579697728157, 0.00024180496984627098, -0.023970577865839005, -0.0017786157550290227, -0.018965981900691986, -0.007889318279922009, 0.02272106520831585, 0.0035740945022553205, 0.03683778643608093, -0.02135336585342884, 0.010879860259592533, 0.015742110088467598, 0.019157806411385536, 0.0027596456930041313, 0.011292492039501667, 0.00827028788626194, -0.05472410097718239, 0.009369606152176857, 0.008411500602960587, -0.012181941419839859, -0.041704073548316956, -0.047902218997478485, 0.01577427238225937, 0.0027266202960163355, -0.027612831443548203, 0.00942277442663908, -0.009573530405759811, 0.07609373331069946, 0.006460449658334255, -0.02150619588792324, 0.03253752365708351, -0.013914143666625023, 0.015961498022079468, -0.05712670832872391, 0.07521653175354004, -0.00607977993786335, 0.0014792211586609483, -0.052009690552949905, -0.028089415282011032, -0.0529266782104969, 0.0103926882147789, 0.04629690200090408, 0.01653548702597618, 0.040650248527526855, -0.015497980639338493, 0.011434362269937992, -0.008418885990977287, -0.0007755095139145851, 0.05256840959191322, 0.014414466917514801, 0.012739262543618679, 0.006345184054225683, -0.015308770351111889, 0.014755815267562866, -0.017480812966823578, 0.033302247524261475, 0.001550290617160499, 0.008057497441768646, 0.0037277790252119303, -0.006391937378793955, 0.03259933367371559, -0.014598552137613297, -0.0052070943638682365, 0.021301988512277603, 0.010311000980436802, 0.008203418925404549, 0.06548019498586655, -0.025227002799510956, -0.04338730499148369, 0.026388386264443398, -0.06337665021419525, -0.032697536051273346, 0.041102100163698196, 0.02813003771007061, 0.014552547596395016, -0.08015195280313492, 0.02539244294166565, -0.002859531668946147, -0.007799833547323942, 0.0002275372389703989, 0.02047562785446644, 0.02161681093275547, -0.018706584349274635, -0.005386639852076769, 0.010817570611834526, -0.004899412859231234, -0.008261402137577534, 0.048826076090335846, 0.04690251126885414, 0.022525357082486153, 0.002890145406126976, 0.004174636676907539, -0.016720470041036606, 0.021815864369273186, 0.03220319375395775, -0.00233512744307518, 0.03718327358365059, -0.0045297942124307156, 0.024644240736961365, 0.027229176834225655, -0.021250024437904358, 0.004368900787085295, 0.014439219608902931, -0.0011088598985224962, 0.06975408643484116, -0.023146292194724083, -0.03775325044989586, -0.016902100294828415, -0.013698972761631012, 0.01791188307106495, -0.004057044163346291, 0.03255828469991684, 0.05430893227458, -0.014428172260522842, 0.010328777134418488, -0.042629681527614594, -0.004573635291308165, 0.04335183650255203, -0.008819515816867352, 0.028914758935570717, 0.020781375467777252, 0.0376465879380703, 0.01525264885276556, -0.007066226564347744, -0.019141437485814095, -0.03364599496126175, 0.04419444873929024, 0.024199604988098145, 0.009325173683464527, -0.009763543494045734, -0.023241855204105377, -0.005197166930884123, 0.023402376100420952, -0.0675974190235138, -0.02964591607451439, -0.02130085788667202, 0.017215294763445854, -0.008039921522140503, -0.006594514474272728 ]
<p>I'm trying to help out a not-for-profit organization and made an error that I'm trying to fix. They've been doing a non scientific survey of their Board of Directors for a number of years regarding board engagement. They asked me to help them convert the survey format from an unfriendly Excel file to something web based, handle the results and do some analysis for them.</p> <p>In past years, they've used what I'm going to call a weighted scale (Very good = 5, Good = 3, Fair = 2, Poor = -1). This year, we mistakenly included an extra level by allowing a 5, 4, 3, 2, or 1 response. (That is, the previous questionnaires had 4 options, but this one has 5.) </p> <p>I'm trying to figure out how to conform the scales to be roughly equivalent. I had been thinking that I could let 5 = 5, 4 = 3, 3 = 2.5, 2 = 2 and 1 = -1. However, I realize that this doesn't work and will skew everything lower.</p> <p>Can anyone recommend a good way to handle this?</p>
73,662
[ -0.02907327003777027, -0.045332904905080795, 0.003295039990916848, 0.00738687627017498, 0.0464680977165699, 0.015322087332606316, 0.012380151078104973, -0.017832549288868904, 0.02880811132490635, -0.01382370200008154, 0.04006093740463257, 0.036030929535627365, 0.026456236839294434, 0.02569044940173626, 0.00875844992697239, -0.005718326661735773, -0.012445748783648014, 0.007714069448411465, -0.039274632930755615, 0.0001867438986664638, 0.01666327938437462, 0.008437996730208397, -0.01706637442111969, -0.0005491414340212941, -0.036906126886606216, 0.019314851611852646, 0.04437527805566788, -0.02757282555103302, -0.0008326775277964771, 0.05465482175350189, -0.04285114258527756, 0.009145467542111874, 0.029756557196378708, 0.02109656296670437, 0.04198312759399414, 0.032531559467315674, -0.011131801642477512, 0.007435894571244717, -0.03376687318086624, 0.05069456622004509, -0.0198284350335598, 0.02307938039302826, -0.0077730934135615826, 0.015787985175848007, 0.011508741416037083, -0.004176069051027298, -0.01238234993070364, -0.02226456068456173, 0.023967724293470383, -0.04437754675745964, 0.09586401283740997, -0.008918246254324913, 0.041566088795661926, 0.011177063919603825, -0.01984882354736328, -0.028171727433800697, 0.048247672617435455, 0.05001728609204292, -0.012627161107957363, -0.027385123074054718, -0.008432501927018166, 0.009540511295199394, -0.007116938009858131, -0.02034340426325798, -0.007901566103100777, 0.017256464809179306, 0.003548170905560255, -0.003246613312512636, 0.06497098505496979, -0.0030503172893077135, 0.018302403390407562, 0.03131894767284393, 0.03641615808010101, -0.030635641887784004, 0.026375820860266685, -0.09542728960514069, 0.012292344123125076, 0.008535763248801231, 0.048435915261507034, 0.06796253472566605, -0.06713538616895676, 0.003916689194738865, 0.025671187788248062, 0.0417710542678833, 0.008023506961762905, -0.04185452684760094, 0.07841858267784119, -0.04652460291981697, 0.03813871368765831, 0.004299555439502001, -0.02724224328994751, -0.02041100338101387, 0.0412423200905323, 0.0028062795754522085, -0.046931084245443344, 0.028361355885863304, -0.007796443533152342, 0.03759576752781868, 0.0143513735383749, 0.002910912735387683, 0.006330836098641157, -0.0165998712182045, 0.012387934140861034, 0.030281009152531624, -0.022573696449398994, 0.0018011763459071517, -0.015638310462236404, -0.019452949985861778, 0.03773397207260132, -0.0329509973526001, 0.026647882536053658, -0.016069024801254272, 0.011166119948029518, -0.010039715096354485, 0.022602325305342674, -0.006998508237302303, -0.03241727128624916, 0.009985658340156078, 0.07514771819114685, 0.0352301150560379, 0.006918731145560741, -0.05232996121048927, 0.04025687649846077, -0.023911794647574425, -0.05853346735239029, 0.008230539038777351, 0.037988871335983276, -0.010735911317169666, -0.002791425446048379, 0.04033752530813217, 0.05272271856665611, 0.017607221379876137, 0.056765906512737274, -0.00879252515733242, 0.022252149879932404, 0.0026065963320434093, -0.06166242063045502, -0.08109191805124283, 0.0036339103244245052, 0.028750263154506683, -0.03346816077828407, -0.07186871021986008, -0.012048241682350636, 0.02733933925628662, 0.058406125754117966, 0.03122767247259617, -0.014469502493739128, 0.04225539416074753, 0.034661274403333664, 0.008395100012421608, -0.004753932356834412, 0.015246241353452206, -0.05302523076534271, -0.04118245467543602, -0.03314819931983948, -0.03530416637659073, 0.017524728551506996, 0.0003940687165595591, -0.010208206251263618, -0.02283496782183647, -0.0004529279249254614, 0.025832630693912506, -0.035920508205890656, 0.005995109211653471, 0.035333845764398575, 0.01730157434940338, 0.04610563442111015, -0.020316489040851593, -0.018517838791012764, -0.002986500971019268, -0.004280020948499441, 0.0031996378675103188, 0.011597856879234314, 0.02184491977095604, 0.056206900626420975, -0.02270614169538021, 0.027320966124534607, -0.0421641543507576, 0.012558400630950928, -0.024890586733818054, -0.028390562161803246, -0.036039743572473526, -0.05188408121466637, -0.003328111954033375, 0.003656866727396846, 0.021691612899303436, -0.014184187166392803, -0.019634315744042397, 0.04180825874209404, -0.049125514924526215, -0.0740346685051918, -0.06425587832927704, 0.002246623858809471, -0.0006874263635836542, -0.008224962279200554, 0.020347779616713524, -0.0162971094250679, 0.014585306867957115, -0.020439116284251213, 0.010627959854900837, 0.009152229875326157, 0.018123099580407143, 0.046875011175870895, -0.06501000374555588, -0.004097756464034319, 0.05466942861676216, 0.05196332186460495, -0.003016278613358736, 0.031968288123607635, -0.03519003465771675, -0.03491344675421715, -0.045836810022592545, -0.033049482852220535, 0.03395455330610275, -0.007851358503103256, -0.021758215501904488, -0.010182511061429977, 0.01299309078603983, -0.009411958046257496, 0.004779210779815912, -0.04817625880241394, 0.08614044636487961, 0.0544695109128952, -0.029338477179408073, 0.013102581724524498, 0.011900065466761589, 0.02009226381778717, 0.033463649451732635, -0.028277823701500893, -0.014513236470520496, -0.04134875163435936, 0.012031921185553074, 0.013093700632452965, -0.027788294479250908, -0.030946236103773117, 0.011027238331735134, 0.07217054814100266, 0.0012743939878419042, -0.014082630164921284, 0.014467989094555378, -0.0018763592233881354, 0.01568928360939026, 0.02537732757627964, -0.032856523990631104, 0.027051560580730438, 0.03760712966322899, -0.02118486352264881, 0.006538630463182926, 0.0029206026811152697, 0.02700810134410858, 0.016092149540781975, 0.02208193950355053, -0.011772481724619865, 0.04666021466255188, -0.013115671463310719, -0.0022111122962087393, 0.06194696202874184, -0.019281180575489998, 0.021331174299120903, 0.05654552951455116, -0.022094110026955605, -0.040445223450660706, 0.04308256879448891, -0.012675020843744278, -0.015503249131143093, 0.026620429009199142, -0.0417434461414814, -0.013526148162782192, 0.02405899204313755, -0.0005593191599473357, 0.004278528969734907, -0.037804778665304184, -0.012840152718126774, -0.025407902896404266, -0.027973797172307968, 0.021862726658582687, 0.008744828402996063, 0.059287913143634796, -0.030210359022021294, 0.01328588929027319, -0.010549011640250683, -0.0005859049852006137, 0.004395520314574242, 0.015102412551641464, -0.04764515534043312, -0.036909956485033035, 0.014821934513747692, 0.011721216142177582, 0.03686685115098953, 0.0075590889900922775, -0.015617758966982365, 0.04184865206480026, 0.030813388526439667, -0.054243285208940506, -0.015610231086611748, -0.04845717176795006, -0.008060925640165806, 0.014175391755998135, -0.016926204785704613, 0.048522356897592545, 0.032995376735925674, -0.05780044570565224, 0.03554309159517288, -0.023280169814825058, -0.02732648327946663, -0.036737263202667236, -0.0005884243291802704, 0.010123686864972115, -0.004187399987131357, 0.01818619668483734, -0.027162523940205574, 0.015475130639970303, 0.007740827742964029, -0.05516617000102997, -0.07431070506572723, 0.020425278693437576, 0.02738477848470211, 0.046970151364803314, 0.012998288497328758, 0.0006241507944650948, 0.05411113426089287, 0.03601678088307381, -0.010485099628567696, -0.07414035499095917, -0.009485420770943165, 0.014808823354542255, -0.01351312454789877, 0.033242784440517426, 0.047271400690078735, 0.01596442237496376, 0.0019008427625522017, -0.01884499005973339, 0.033109717071056366, 0.07104358822107315, -0.02935931645333767, -0.020427899435162544, 0.014499945566058159, -0.01605813018977642, 0.000370533496607095, 0.019157472997903824, 0.0017246251227334142, -0.015621736645698547, 0.020475011318922043, 0.007990455254912376, -0.012941391207277775, -0.0015101900789886713, -0.016174878925085068, -0.004495497792959213, -0.02576364576816559, 0.012074016965925694, -0.01723465509712696, 0.019867917522788048, 0.00977060291916132, 0.0009747185395099223, -0.005543706007301807, 0.022356001660227776, 0.04083734750747681, -0.0006373585783876479, -0.006675581447780132, 0.07296929508447647, 0.014453194104135036, 0.016726255416870117, -0.015722157433629036, 0.006489853840321302, 0.000628344074357301, 0.013284691609442234, -0.0012474124087020755, -0.000972991343587637, 0.05683591216802597, 0.038145747035741806, 0.0476180836558342, -0.008741447702050209, -0.021189948543906212, 0.0067315613850951195, -0.04842539504170418, -0.012570581398904324, -0.059714335948228836, 0.049732282757759094, -0.024561399593949318, 0.002541827969253063, 0.02774142473936081, 0.014943373389542103, 0.023246262222528458, 0.02036503329873085, -0.04410243034362793, 0.027204493060708046, -0.021449221298098564, 0.044380273669958115, -0.001795350108295679, 0.014393859542906284, 0.016368919983506203, -0.02463044412434101, -0.005165124777704477, -0.011539173312485218, 0.018836112692952156, 0.006168301682919264, 0.01880219392478466, -0.0001915465109050274, 0.01966414600610733, 0.014842228032648563, 0.008150181733071804, 0.019165627658367157, -0.009072626940906048, 0.04483719915151596, 0.00422526802867651, 0.018326761201024055, -0.01508091390132904, -0.027994588017463684, -0.02685481123626232, 0.03166055679321289, 0.07876057177782059, -0.003954525571316481, 0.029079435393214226, -0.04641720652580261, 0.037362437695264816, -0.028523892164230347, 0.031121142208576202, 0.06178446486592293, 0.007608986925333738, -0.020937738940119743, -0.039309822022914886, -0.008346331305801868, -0.001561388955451548, 0.022051701322197914, -0.035597063601017, 0.006775772199034691, 0.04747018963098526, 0.01826675422489643, -0.055983517318964005, 0.026142844930291176, 0.04434719681739807, 0.012768290936946869, -0.011438306421041489, -0.022313272580504417, -0.009380963630974293, 0.010916446335613728, -0.03097854182124138, -0.009055856615304947, 0.0440283864736557, 0.0011792626464739442, -0.006416786927729845, 0.06149280443787575, -0.011757800355553627, -0.059231195598840714, 0.023049546405673027, -0.059282153844833374, 0.017077043652534485, -0.01418212242424488, -0.03224055841565132, 0.019778450950980186, 0.02762821689248085, 0.05750291049480438, 0.01242992002516985, 0.009674825705587864, -0.0886039286851883, -0.0315079428255558, 0.036710646003484726, 0.07788936048746109, -0.025065802037715912, -0.011670457199215889, -0.04133898392319679, 0.004722182638943195, 0.01990136131644249, -0.04038359597325325, 0.019960487261414528, -0.01618046686053276, 0.03539736941456795, -0.039830200374126434, -0.013666310347616673, -0.035470545291900635, 0.014726073481142521, -0.012897821143269539, 0.03606976568698883, 0.02421686425805092, -0.01730342209339142, -0.04421451687812805, 0.0018723709508776665, 0.04123120754957199, 0.09011686593294144, -0.02509494684636593, -0.04410979151725769, 0.023352505639195442, -0.005809938535094261, -0.05627373233437538, -0.05145879462361336, -0.006225354969501495, 0.031610261648893356, 0.0092627527192235, 0.05269956961274147, -0.0003912940446753055, -0.01798091270029545, 0.012799468822777271, 0.01598212867975235, 0.02445998415350914, 0.0008322146604768932, -0.04692426696419716, 0.05834374576807022, 0.02953179180622101, 0.034318894147872925, 0.06589581817388535, 0.005714381113648415, -0.04279879480600357, 0.010529722087085247, -0.04732625186443329, -0.007018467877060175, -0.0507362075150013, 0.0008183286408893764, -0.01222677156329155, -0.011231541633605957, -0.0384226068854332, 0.017619380727410316, 0.010971792973577976, 0.03816330060362816, -0.019002581015229225, -0.027569515630602837, -0.009390946477651596, -0.03760169818997383, -0.006496082060039043, 0.01737353764474392, 0.02994154766201973, 0.03430191054940224, 0.010595637373626232, -0.04353153333067894, 0.007102632895112038, -0.02039078250527382, 0.02261490374803543, -0.002885738853365183, -0.04537523165345192, -0.005560665391385555, -0.03169812262058258, -0.00010650151671143249, -0.011761478148400784, -0.033701229840517044, 0.042057085782289505, -0.03813726454973221, 0.02865407057106495, -0.00170138047542423, 0.01212060172110796, -0.01456210296601057, 0.035973671823740005, -0.017993953078985214, -0.01524261012673378, 0.0033968016505241394, 0.02014266699552536, 0.010514520108699799, -0.008093259297311306, -0.061306022107601166, -0.044075604528188705, 0.014488937333226204, 0.015536941587924957, -0.007907158695161343, 0.016776686534285545, -0.01506413146853447, 0.006567946635186672, -0.049037590622901917, -0.007129693403840065, 0.05049695074558258, -0.03735220804810524, -0.01809048466384411, -0.01632148213684559, 0.0005672462866641581, 0.05430935323238373, -0.01026536151766777, 0.008458634838461876, 0.014617455191910267, -0.014632641337811947, -0.03185621649026871, -0.03382045030593872, 0.004243022762238979, -0.05110456421971321, -0.035662733018398285, -0.0018249552231281996, -0.001024613855406642, 0.027846138924360275, -0.02550940215587616, 0.025426223874092102, 0.005210404749959707, -0.04873086139559746, -0.043116308748722076, 0.01079085934907198, 0.04310042783617973, -0.020997606217861176, -0.023762455210089684, -0.03281985595822334, -0.001881589530967176, -0.055888582020998, -0.01997588947415352, 0.018014781177043915, 0.0010560575174167752, -0.03542022779583931, 0.021937966346740723, 0.08456163108348846, 0.005429209675639868, -0.0049199266359210014, 0.007080444134771824, -0.033760908991098404, 0.03324149549007416, -0.0005364183452911675, -0.04540489241480827, -0.013818011619150639, 0.04742885380983353, -0.05248177796602249, -0.02112191915512085, 0.011485801078379154, -0.028930731117725372, 0.053867362439632416, 0.02536640129983425, 0.027746321633458138, 0.02376912347972393, 0.0018698795465752482, -0.044812873005867004, -0.02063239924609661, 0.005211120471358299, -0.013666951097548008, 0.00833860132843256, 0.06759441643953323, -0.0376439094543457, 0.02774588204920292, -0.01489128079265356, 0.043057817965745926, 0.03709547594189644, 0.051346953958272934, 0.06361820548772812, 0.03167785331606865, 0.043682996183633804, -0.03754788637161255, -0.05749072507023811, 0.008109120652079582, 0.0054496475495398045, 0.02347797155380249, 0.008922699838876724, -0.06389931589365005, 0.0290452279150486, 0.04795388504862785, -0.042017146944999695, -0.01629580371081829, -0.0012863542651757598, -0.014680386520922184, 0.006544775795191526, 0.021400226280093193, -0.03154720366001129, 0.014377792365849018, -0.004210832063108683, 0.05691174045205116, -0.008762862533330917, 0.01751593127846718, -0.02415023371577263, -0.06159058213233948, 0.011952516622841358, -0.06693577021360397, -0.06511890888214111, -0.01379337627440691, -0.017005382105708122, 0.013262671418488026, 0.008924659341573715, -0.02798062190413475, -0.025538787245750427, -0.0002607957285363227, 0.0007414879510179162, -0.011344355531036854, 0.02081734873354435, 0.02220955677330494, 0.007620676886290312, -0.030350659042596817, -0.036992259323596954, 0.13734176754951477, 0.07949965447187424, 0.027413468807935715, -0.05205972120165825, 0.04665588214993477, 0.004214204847812653, 0.0319618284702301, -0.009210499934852123, 0.005157721694558859, -0.038848746567964554, -0.026585830375552177, 0.005099826958030462, 0.058468881994485855, 0.05275103449821472, 0.016771025955677032, 0.06179491803050041, -0.025108058005571365, -0.0374283641576767, -0.00026813457952812314, -0.019035862758755684, -0.010629413649439812, -0.04762386158108711, -0.05850446596741676, 0.04520287364721298, 0.0013853969285264611, -0.027852673083543777, 0.005166731309145689, -0.005945403128862381, -0.010366616770625114, 0.019711893051862717, -0.023835323750972748, 0.00014556391397491097, 0.002806328469887376, 0.004931787960231304, -0.01800539903342724, -0.003179237712174654, 0.03074536845088005, -0.03889427334070206, 0.02672925405204296, 0.04923173785209656, 0.0011715779546648264, 0.007359001319855452, 0.007776561193168163, 0.028589366003870964, -0.04378809407353401, -0.034761976450681686, -0.04337073117494583, -0.019491268321871758, 0.034011729061603546, -0.02090258151292801, -0.034589897841215134, 0.004021380562335253, -0.017765559256076813, -0.06106190010905266, 0.029694532975554466, 0.03581564500927925, 0.028828976675868034, -0.004398412071168423, -0.03742377832531929, 0.027180487290024757, -0.00013567933638114482, -0.017695872113108635, 0.042249128222465515, 0.04230460897088051, -0.0307170357555151, -0.027896618470549583, -0.04590039700269699, 0.0184220802038908, 0.012228350155055523, 0.0006708232685923576, 0.031715601682662964, 0.01010574959218502, -0.04324035719037056, -0.01151593029499054, -0.030408520251512527, 0.03760936111211777, 0.01197896245867014, 0.0041355956345796585, 0.04425017163157463, -0.031150639057159424, -0.03317497670650482, 0.04158402979373932, -0.0613054521381855, -0.02018052339553833, -0.029309909790754318, -0.02851906232535839, 0.0068508624099195, 0.0011976321693509817, 0.010245643556118011, 0.04071957990527153, -0.015929056331515312, 0.04637833312153816, 0.01793297380208969, -0.021305782720446587, 0.002953048562631011, 0.020865626633167267, -0.026965927332639694, -0.02477279119193554, 0.04671228677034378, 0.11203012615442276, 0.002547824988141656, 0.0063548521138727665, -0.014136319048702717, 0.0333700068295002, 0.0034155496396124363, -0.0024082493036985397, 0.006724626291543245, -0.0723169669508934, -0.005248174536973238, -0.010648113675415516, -0.015358339063823223, -0.04997054859995842, -0.014294448308646679, -0.045783352106809616, -0.03661489859223366, 0.0037288202438503504, 0.039755359292030334, -0.011374866589903831, -0.020072091370821, -0.035569291561841965, 0.027611877769231796, 0.005321439355611801, -0.012747717089951038, -0.019785134121775627, -0.011707795783877373, -0.04067594185471535, -0.00491216778755188, -0.004268038086593151, -0.009249832481145859, -0.014025302603840828, 0.041275616735219955, 0.02310224436223507, -0.012306922115385532, 0.009862993843853474, 0.014766383916139603, 0.013085867278277874, -0.011484752409160137, 0.023969927802681923, -0.028862930834293365, -0.026676582172513008, 0.03833027556538582, -0.03773822262883186, -0.025210518389940262, 0.02657138742506504, 0.013577469624578953, 0.024790560826659203, -0.00014488557644654065, -0.02715272642672062, -0.026998041197657585, 0.052895091474056244, -0.04936642944812775, -0.0009602084755897522, -0.021995557472109795, 0.013849202543497086, 0.03264312818646431, 0.025443341583013535, -0.013791432604193687, 0.02082890458405018, -0.007022030185908079, 0.03392830491065979, 0.02009468339383602, -0.008915470913052559, -0.023943882435560226, -0.011884473264217377, -0.016990479081869125, 0.012408163398504257, 0.0004437211318872869, 0.0025509167462587357, -0.019086377695202827, 0.01541015226393938, -0.0487295500934124, 0.024381965398788452, -0.006510488223284483, 0.009918225929141045, -0.018712852150201797, -0.009588333778083324, -0.013030573725700378, 0.0040112826973199844, 0.004215993452817202, -0.06583324074745178, 0.009555527940392494, -0.025096455588936806, -0.036246947944164276, 0.018644345924258232, 0.013219033367931843, -0.019383404403924942, -0.02276458404958248, 0.028545834124088287, -0.03803998976945877, -0.013691100291907787, 0.003782748943194747, 0.02341269701719284, -0.03312361612915993, 0.013886803761124611, -0.020450159907341003, -0.013694667257368565, -0.0018627449171617627, 0.017019513994455338, 0.019784007221460342, -0.0754639133810997, 0.020870719105005264, -0.034727275371551514, -0.01889747381210327, 0.05143887549638748, 0.003221488557755947, 0.05424933880567551, 0.01787472516298294, 0.030886778607964516, 0.013662157580256462, 0.044989798218011856, 0.036246299743652344, -0.03860221803188324, -0.014015045948326588, 0.0001709247735561803, 0.04336296766996384, 0.06313300877809525, -0.009067974053323269, 0.03808287903666496, 0.0611601360142231, -0.001396626466885209, 0.007857139222323895, -0.02543679066002369, -0.03909261152148247, 0.02211758680641651, -0.039768680930137634, -0.056913428008556366, 0.03159613534808159, -0.03607366979122162, 0.025445299223065376, -0.04214582219719887, -0.01533487718552351, 0.05035684257745743, -0.035135842859745026, -0.029527956619858742, 0.011739036068320274, -0.0011261120671406388, -0.04031510651111603, -0.018430262804031372, -0.004995622206479311, -0.0015156383160501719, -0.011135448701679707, -0.012425027787685394, -0.01097796019166708, -0.006027242634445429, -0.02186235971748829, 0.003853286150842905, -0.00248912675306201, 0.047637734562158585, -0.0326717309653759, -0.010903683491051197, 0.026141522452235222, -0.009886530227959156, -0.014242442324757576, -0.0646173357963562, 0.04600929468870163, 0.04205101355910301, -0.036726757884025574, 0.0016356536652892828, -0.020275605842471123, -0.009294012561440468, 0.025848975405097008, 0.04593922942876816, -0.009183498099446297, -0.028301341459155083, -0.017979908734560013, 0.001690777949988842, 0.001826002961024642, -0.05894601345062256, 0.04958711937069893, -0.0077965231612324715, -0.01924765110015869, -0.0029898283537477255, 0.006956274155527353, 0.0023105149157345295, -0.02628055028617382, 0.0003226629050914198, -0.016296230256557465, 0.01163425575941801, 0.005266062915325165, -0.0019046890083700418, 0.020979177206754684, -0.003537457436323166, -0.03675773739814758, 0.06450061500072479, 0.00103797169867903, -0.006437997799366713, 0.03675727918744087, 0.007392847444862127, -0.04156449809670448, 0.05235855281352997, -0.04828094691038132, -0.03276478126645088, 0.009850023314356804, 0.0192128736525774, 0.03692606836557388, -0.08831395953893661, 0.008442668244242668, 0.01059036422520876, -0.03985359147191048, 0.0065140025690197945, 0.039889026433229446, 0.002114424016326666, 0.00909394957125187, 0.03550209105014801, -0.005778051912784576, -0.02277003601193428, -0.034464042633771896, 0.023160211741924286, -0.013792458921670914, 0.06116313114762306, 0.04026724398136139, 0.016499558463692665, 0.043909527361392975, -0.023663070052862167, 0.02766544558107853, 0.02561126835644245, 0.046834297478199005, -0.0251355841755867, -0.009730731137096882, 0.03488563746213913, -0.016696052625775337, 0.022795384749770164, 0.013487614691257477, 0.0013426763471215963, 0.04439539834856987, -0.013042817823588848, 0.012565483339130878, -0.058871395885944366, -0.005248735658824444, -0.0307875107973814, 0.035232432186603546, 0.02036339044570923, 0.05256883054971695, -0.013004622422158718, -0.013267877511680126, -0.017782721668481827, -0.009602966718375683, -0.00216389587149024, -0.028616027906537056, 0.03214072808623314, -0.022786622866988182, 0.061267297714948654, 0.009423499926924706, -0.024456987157464027, -0.03418915718793869, 0.005161770619452, -0.0057104043662548065, 0.005849047098308802, 0.006066466215997934, -0.025908155366778374, 0.004953730385750532, 0.016226930543780327, 0.03188277408480644, -0.02333720028400421, -0.029286237433552742, -0.03310184180736542, -0.0002595209516584873, 0.018569279462099075, -0.013302435167133808 ]
<p>I am looking at two populations on which I have measured 4 independent variables ($X_1$, $X_2$, $X_3$, $X_4$) and one dependent variable ($Y$) along with each measurement or observation. I suspect that the two populations are different in the sense that the second population's $Y$ shows a dependence on an additional non-considered factor (I expect $Y$ to be systematically lower, in fact). Considering that:</p> <ul> <li>the dependent variables are highly correlated;</li> <li>the dependence of $Y$ on the $X$'s is unknown and arguably non-parametric;</li> <li>the number of observables/measurements is small (~100 for the first group, ~30 for the second).</li> </ul> <p>I feel that multi linear regression would assume some kind of underlying structure and would bias my analysis, so I would like to avoid it. I tried to use PCA on both and compare the PC's: nothing significant comes out in the sense of dimensionality. Could you suggest a test that would check if the two populations are really different in respect to $Y$ while keeping at a minimum the number of assumptions on its functional dependence?</p> <p>Thank you very much,</p> <p>P.</p>
73,663
[ -0.048186324536800385, 0.022930268198251724, 0.006921770516782999, -0.011258422397077084, 0.026835890486836433, 0.01587960496544838, -0.006031276658177376, -0.021152982488274574, 0.051234714686870575, -0.029312822967767715, 0.026388805359601974, 0.019605329260230064, 0.0576479509472847, -0.01349889487028122, 0.008700340986251831, 0.01770305633544922, -0.036175686866045, 0.01866924576461315, 0.0073045301251113415, 0.0026619520504027605, 0.0022368277423083782, 0.023308493196964264, 0.013770225457847118, -0.01766914129257202, -0.03638994321227074, 0.05022438243031502, -0.000707775354385376, -0.02909775637090206, 0.01695743389427662, 0.06353746354579926, -0.014073383994400501, -0.04902448505163193, -0.03251848742365837, 0.0589325986802578, 0.011239666491746902, 0.005833094473928213, -0.019438067451119423, -0.00812391098588705, 0.009889889508485794, 0.07322078943252563, -0.07036934047937393, -0.038650032132864, 0.0012878695270046592, 0.02920682728290558, 0.006724642124027014, 0.02111181803047657, -0.0027269567362964153, -0.02079489454627037, 0.05205312743782997, -0.019442211836576462, 0.12131596356630325, -0.0027632510755211115, 0.012937876395881176, 0.025065070018172264, -0.029934339225292206, -0.020887624472379684, 0.05892394855618477, 0.08661329746246338, -0.026353975757956505, -0.052424076944589615, -0.04479528218507767, -0.037888750433921814, 0.024881573393940926, -0.05020274594426155, -0.07951147109270096, 0.02679499238729477, -0.010421277023851871, -0.0273035429418087, 0.0346672497689724, -0.025088036432862282, 0.020920423790812492, 0.010813401080667973, 0.041934359818696976, -0.018501605838537216, -0.0058767967857420444, 0.009256755001842976, 0.02276785485446453, 0.019861867651343346, 0.04589620977640152, 0.03789406642317772, 0.0027298606000840664, 0.0014567346079275012, 0.004310955293476582, 0.028910450637340546, 0.027509847655892372, -0.025797616690397263, 0.051205363124608994, -0.0252925306558609, 0.014812832698225975, 0.018868964165449142, -0.001870729960501194, -0.02254941686987877, 0.08319798111915588, 0.034830961376428604, -0.043617211282253265, 0.017767395824193954, -0.01245502196252346, 0.04188593477010727, 0.011753298342227936, -0.004102055449038744, 0.02367636188864708, -0.040072839707136154, 0.02584460936486721, 0.06992561370134354, -0.0070646717213094234, 0.000317088735755533, -0.018233798444271088, 0.01813061349093914, 0.00488929683342576, -0.011973225511610508, 0.008127330802381039, 0.03087095357477665, -0.004552124533802271, -0.020178351551294327, 0.025474876165390015, -0.013333681970834732, -0.014736277982592583, -0.023333784192800522, 0.061794500797986984, 0.06793162226676941, 0.04261324927210808, -0.03174074366688728, 0.004960467107594013, 0.006832543760538101, -0.024679187685251236, 0.027997709810733795, 0.001920670852996409, -0.02928752452135086, -0.03793950751423836, 0.05096748471260071, -0.0002265567018184811, 0.023191066458821297, 0.025817835703492165, -0.01867554895579815, -0.008881164714694023, 0.014270616695284843, -0.07903856784105301, -0.05620944872498512, 0.04217568412423134, -0.012541624717414379, 0.0010470213601365685, -0.025462470948696136, -0.005663268268108368, 0.0030270840507000685, 0.06579815596342087, -0.0420534722507, 0.009456368163228035, 0.011990522034466267, 0.052785687148571014, 0.004440903663635254, -0.00975100789219141, 0.0004527199489530176, -0.039489030838012695, -0.03802020102739334, -0.016081416979432106, -0.0821688249707222, 0.029802968725562096, 0.002112640766426921, -0.0023652706295251846, 0.010585927404463291, 0.037256963551044464, 0.053219735622406006, -0.003544093109667301, -0.007677833084017038, 0.04716726019978523, -0.018059225752949715, 0.039948586374521255, -0.029850928112864494, 0.02710411325097084, 0.01708807982504368, -0.014326969161629677, 0.029383674263954163, 0.017901675775647163, 0.07073692977428436, 0.037452466785907745, -0.036462750285863876, -0.023283688351511955, 0.007470060605555773, -0.002205409575253725, -0.0034004186745733023, -0.046488918364048004, -0.02939094603061676, -0.04023139178752899, -0.0318366102874279, 0.02376421168446541, 0.051158513873815536, 0.0016703694127500057, -0.009610158391296864, 0.03905992582440376, -0.05827505886554718, -0.05257142707705498, -0.06073135882616043, -0.00895828939974308, 0.01894267648458481, -0.06976236402988434, 0.05173857882618904, 0.008826632983982563, 0.008137308992445469, -0.014493306167423725, -0.029862437397241592, 0.0007123954128473997, 0.005700566340237856, 0.04087068885564804, -0.017114685848355293, 0.016993224620819092, 0.016638608649373055, 0.04505398869514465, -0.01504412479698658, 0.0548081174492836, -0.030920352786779404, -0.04621957242488861, 0.021932749077677727, -0.023832108825445175, 0.017825545743107796, -0.006230329163372517, -0.00872812420129776, 0.0008765833918005228, -0.011250665411353111, -0.06021818146109581, 0.05298759415745735, -0.06745145469903946, 0.07155003398656845, 0.04369736090302467, -0.013125252909958363, -0.01785796880722046, -0.004408561624586582, -0.0059944381937384605, -0.003630785271525383, -0.035616759210824966, -0.007639056071639061, -0.07322566211223602, -0.016341185197234154, 0.020730741322040558, 0.022794075310230255, -0.033436600118875504, 0.026165178045630455, 0.06306331604719162, 0.039688590914011, 0.005856231786310673, 0.00355350598692894, 0.012987048365175724, -0.04576333239674568, 0.011268729344010353, 0.04660467058420181, -0.011823184788227081, 0.03467390313744545, 0.009989279322326183, 0.005956021137535572, 0.057045672088861465, -0.008445915766060352, 0.006952655501663685, 0.04168478399515152, -0.028021639212965965, 0.015326643362641335, -0.013502724468708038, -0.009079067036509514, 0.04690046235918999, -0.003840596880763769, 0.012645374983549118, 0.05309368669986725, -0.013299777172505856, -0.00848822109401226, 0.006082544568926096, -0.005198352970182896, 0.028302686288952827, 0.007771473843604326, -0.05535808205604553, 0.01608019508421421, 0.015661979094147682, -0.029675250872969627, -0.009780436754226685, -0.017938248813152313, -0.050821490585803986, -0.015862083062529564, 0.027479948475956917, 0.01772010326385498, 0.03425758332014084, 0.020991984754800797, -0.0426114946603775, 0.002413542475551367, 0.04292580112814903, -0.028413021937012672, 0.02083727903664112, -0.017033223062753677, -0.04895724728703499, -0.0011503610294312239, -0.02818909101188183, 0.011295844800770283, 0.02882569096982479, -0.022290173918008804, 0.0019056511810049415, 0.03335471451282501, -0.014102425426244736, -0.06748635321855545, -0.024113904684782028, -0.030752059072256088, 0.027103928849101067, -0.02455754764378071, -0.04543072357773781, 0.022250743582844734, -0.021645724773406982, -0.044875260442495346, -0.0017574873054400086, -0.0307232066988945, 0.0014234860427677631, -0.006654633674770594, -0.0008097097743302584, -0.008387956768274307, 0.01664987951517105, 0.004419938661158085, 0.04319598153233528, -0.018808970227837563, -0.041546065360307693, -0.06723535805940628, -0.08047443628311157, 0.029363669455051422, 0.00584409199655056, 0.03552139550447464, -0.019208788871765137, -0.04803689569234848, 0.040525346994400024, 0.04178367555141449, 0.012102737091481686, -0.06769628077745438, 0.0012101845350116491, -0.05994940549135208, 0.00785124208778143, 0.04051169753074646, -0.0017098454991355538, 0.013832989148795605, 0.03294701874256134, 0.017882030457258224, -0.0018226249376311898, 0.025122707709670067, 0.00016010727267712355, -0.0012695997720584273, 0.04208038002252579, 0.004717136733233929, -0.017014319077134132, 0.022481093183159828, 0.00040940594044514, -0.026464736089110374, 0.011528891511261463, 0.018301665782928467, -0.013494590297341347, 0.0003138687170576304, -0.029281269758939743, 0.022431951016187668, -0.013235888443887234, -0.005645179655402899, -0.044999249279499054, 0.004284585360437632, -0.0004925154498778284, -0.024460989981889725, 0.00003856838884530589, 0.03799274191260338, 0.02219478227198124, -0.0017169039929285645, 0.01431608758866787, 0.06379298120737076, 0.003557738848030567, 0.0007940808427520096, 0.0064815981313586235, -0.007945173420011997, -0.03979511931538582, 0.022073403000831604, 0.003988188225775957, -0.023624202236533165, 0.03143550083041191, 0.027557259425520897, 0.0404694527387619, -0.013309546746313572, -0.030295196920633316, 0.05029430612921715, -0.07549797743558884, 0.019699441269040108, -0.053808148950338364, 0.0631776824593544, 0.04248908534646034, 0.022068215534090996, 0.002312402008101344, -0.01751381903886795, -0.02275579236447811, -0.00728665292263031, -0.062225230038166046, 0.015109830535948277, -0.005557780619710684, 0.023784132674336433, 0.008545275777578354, 0.0012701686937361956, 0.03415779396891594, -0.008871347643435001, 0.020045898854732513, -0.019215647131204605, 0.03923453763127327, -0.03628416731953621, 0.006388156209141016, -0.030742907896637917, -0.033684998750686646, -0.003510309848934412, 0.02072211541235447, -0.010025404393672943, -0.013731100596487522, 0.02594442293047905, 0.016338739544153214, -0.012149922549724579, -0.005463552661240101, -0.03793925419449806, 0.0009901945013552904, 0.016962269321084023, 0.055388689041137695, -0.01328957173973322, 0.028347497805953026, -0.009535400196909904, 0.01883712038397789, 0.007138774264603853, 0.04938284680247307, 0.02876940369606018, -0.0037170150317251682, -0.0003644910757429898, -0.03891881927847862, -0.03671731427311897, 0.009045317769050598, 0.03862951695919037, 0.004229526501148939, -0.02443646639585495, 0.01595853455364704, 0.025489551946520805, -0.0394836962223053, -0.002837305422872305, 0.03670916333794594, 0.016330281272530556, 0.010441754013299942, -0.0325126126408577, -0.0047419751062989235, -0.007129108067601919, 0.025742175057530403, 0.026597924530506134, -0.0023500171955674887, 0.003546166932210326, -0.04407857358455658, 0.0526847317814827, -0.006797593552619219, -0.011281123384833336, 0.01728542521595955, 0.009239781647920609, 0.0488152951002121, -0.01577937602996826, -0.028942741453647614, 0.03978738188743591, 0.0559278167784214, 0.024778297170996666, 0.037650216370821, 0.010017172433435917, -0.08166337758302689, 0.011205081827938557, 0.03717275708913803, 0.05262940749526024, -0.05744199827313423, -0.003590962616726756, -0.02780756726861, 0.002252965932711959, 0.04513240233063698, -0.014138431288301945, 0.01758703589439392, 0.00543128652498126, 0.02260727435350418, -0.019461510702967644, -0.025161778554320335, -0.06668496131896973, -0.005478536710143089, 0.0055566574446856976, 0.02306332252919674, -0.03588515520095825, -0.03228199854493141, -0.040272895246744156, 0.005672155413776636, 0.015867233276367188, 0.0615653321146965, 0.007923649623990059, -0.03947387635707855, 0.00803053006529808, 0.042319439351558685, -0.023020431399345398, -0.0495992973446846, 0.05590451881289482, 0.019718220457434654, -0.013910959474742413, 0.058944251388311386, -0.006122170016169548, -0.046548642218112946, -0.008430777117609978, -0.046170055866241455, 0.005022561177611351, 0.013914468698203564, -0.00604547094553709, 0.03654494881629944, 0.0187592301517725, 0.02431369386613369, 0.028391974046826363, 0.010326946154236794, -0.008579106070101261, -0.008455912582576275, 0.0014669110532850027, 0.031875960528850555, -0.053913090378046036, -0.02399340644478798, -0.02331942692399025, 0.00250866636633873, -0.0036639247555285692, 0.04031568765640259, -0.03363383933901787, 0.018452638760209084, -0.022852854803204536, -0.02799064666032791, 0.001741095562465489, -0.003138574305921793, -0.004265517462044954, 0.005683446303009987, 0.0047270008362829685, -0.0015901153674349189, -0.02017519436776638, -0.012802429497241974, 0.008063269779086113, -0.018125129863619804, -0.01493834238499403, 0.024361098185181618, -0.0341312550008297, -0.0036616381257772446, -0.020146770402789116, -0.024299219250679016, -0.025131626054644585, -0.019383059814572334, 0.01854981668293476, -0.025935610756278038, 0.06096624583005905, -0.0021557968575507402, -0.04082381725311279, -0.004759856965392828, 0.027134785428643227, 0.02387910895049572, 0.04608522728085518, -0.01725359819829464, 0.025913143530488014, -0.05507580190896988, -0.0009262506500817835, -0.07387647032737732, -0.0434870645403862, -0.005708079319447279, 0.02057238481938839, -0.01019793376326561, -0.06789262592792511, 0.034422196447849274, -0.03469634801149368, -0.0006059656152501702, -0.009328025393188, 0.05382131412625313, -0.04324828460812569, -0.012858852744102478, -0.01233898289501667, 0.005629303399473429, 0.06883352249860764, -0.037582941353321075, -0.008145024068653584, 0.002406345447525382, 0.0038790383841842413, -0.005668196827173233, -0.029350707307457924, -0.014247361570596695, -0.022369295358657837, 0.00750508951023221, -0.0387609601020813, -0.012009313330054283, 0.03388746827840805, -0.05802122503519058, -0.02179117314517498, 0.0006649376591667533, -0.02303607203066349, -0.013279642909765244, -0.03595485910773277, 0.013111627660691738, -0.021572047844529152, -0.009177947416901588, -0.017800360918045044, 0.004364743363112211, -0.018197374418377876, -0.03115885891020298, 0.029185635969042778, 0.003168865805491805, -0.06388802081346512, 0.015326391905546188, 0.07026156038045883, 0.03404022753238678, 0.004704408347606659, -0.013401078060269356, 0.009497476741671562, 0.015879089012742043, -0.003456246806308627, -0.0008256732253357768, 0.005706110969185829, 0.04720040038228035, -0.04839520528912544, -0.037766069173812866, -0.019522707909345627, -0.00697114784270525, 0.04011877626180649, 0.007143975235521793, 0.035865992307662964, 0.10894427448511124, -0.006831476930528879, 0.003807023400440812, -0.0032430223654955626, 0.016889700666069984, 0.042493343353271484, -0.00019833513943012804, 0.0731409341096878, -0.017971221357584, -0.023141833022236824, 0.04895632341504097, 0.014024973846971989, 0.023455101996660233, 0.051124945282936096, 0.003185437759384513, 0.02295614592730999, 0.05949089303612709, -0.04316793009638786, -0.08725535124540329, 0.033115338534116745, -0.041554663330316544, 0.0004587310249917209, -0.027016937732696533, -0.019171586260199547, 0.04395999386906624, 0.06463085114955902, 0.013413297943770885, -0.03824329003691673, -0.028443677350878716, -0.04555727541446686, -0.022801514714956284, 0.027955131605267525, 0.027860047295689583, 0.025184374302625656, -0.01705370470881462, 0.023740798234939575, 0.024769378826022148, 0.03810127079486847, -0.017225880175828934, -0.06662452220916748, -0.019423069432377815, 0.01579376310110092, -0.012534116394817829, 0.047395315021276474, -0.04168032854795456, -0.038634151220321655, 0.020293688401579857, -0.04925436154007912, -0.00017925915017258376, 0.017051003873348236, 0.03359382972121239, -0.004946053959429264, 0.026782333850860596, -0.008749622851610184, -0.010118969716131687, -0.00007982469833223149, -0.020854204893112183, 0.09932541102170944, 0.06667879223823547, 0.04449121281504631, -0.05441565811634064, 0.04306517168879509, -0.014216371811926365, 0.009109514765441418, -0.027897631749510765, 0.023579053580760956, 0.01195979118347168, 0.007935049012303352, 0.03882651776075363, 0.05999013036489487, 0.01750202663242817, -0.004215717781335115, 0.08297081291675568, -0.018612606450915337, 0.011877531185746193, 0.020795147866010666, -0.008781341835856438, 0.005349456798285246, -0.04361503943800926, -0.018809068948030472, 0.022245250642299652, -0.02414306439459324, -0.010444202460348606, -0.034222811460494995, -0.017937254160642624, 0.009299521334469318, -0.012537723407149315, -0.01980075053870678, -0.00016906726523302495, 0.006846747826784849, 0.02075038105249405, -0.040982797741889954, 0.020436575636267662, 0.004606493748724461, -0.06643866747617722, 0.02187495306134224, 0.04816623404622078, -0.02039976976811886, -0.02880435436964035, 0.004210684914141893, 0.007712153252214193, -0.04282543063163757, -0.02588166482746601, -0.046646974980831146, 0.06048178672790527, 0.007086448837071657, -0.018221614882349968, -0.024383338168263435, -0.0023475035559386015, 0.009282294660806656, -0.03186215087771416, -0.026191338896751404, 0.0002523016300983727, 0.035571735352277756, -0.027899514883756638, 0.0006766998558305204, -0.02245131880044937, 0.008993754163384438, -0.010391422547399998, 0.014873065985739231, 0.02103017084300518, -0.014011360704898834, -0.0289178304374218, 0.008401616476476192, 0.04958416894078255, 0.011119021102786064, -0.01473509706556797, 0.016967033967375755, -0.03271954879164696, -0.00380431255325675, 0.0014685493661090732, 0.023662090301513672, 0.0026989567559212446, 0.030036745592951775, 0.03618878871202469, -0.05251462012529373, -0.006870224606245756, -0.04346365109086037, -0.009674481116235256, -0.0217727143317461, 0.03203456476330757, -0.03141526132822037, 0.006689073983579874, 0.0372646190226078, 0.01708115078508854, 0.06338506191968918, 0.012835945002734661, -0.004434381145983934, 0.04682277515530586, -0.0012572230771183968, -0.06780135631561279, -0.027717575430870056, -0.024032751098275185, -0.007631668355315924, -0.031161732971668243, -0.029746877029538155, 0.03315187990665436, 0.019628159701824188, -0.004934071563184261, -0.0028300920967012644, 0.027207262814044952, -0.030449312180280685, -0.0022521279752254486, 0.03591139614582062, -0.04127056524157524, -0.013515678234398365, 0.005097466986626387, 0.01795695535838604, -0.01795051433146, -0.029258856549859047, -0.049730267375707626, -0.022465122863650322, -0.01208809856325388, -0.028650667518377304, 0.0064298780634999275, -0.03165636211633682, 0.006996507290750742, 0.007063352502882481, -0.020780038088560104, 0.0028288732282817364, -0.036181867122650146, -0.009070629253983498, 0.012723165564239025, -0.00013825205678585917, -0.007785383146256208, -0.00019697276002261788, -0.007085889577865601, -0.019448330625891685, 0.06765426695346832, 0.011089536361396313, 0.02439049631357193, 0.002043014857918024, 0.020047934725880623, 0.011248977854847908, 0.03377664461731911, -0.024268584325909615, -0.016211653128266335, 0.03601876273751259, -0.05334111675620079, -0.021361010149121284, 0.02878917194902897, -0.014310350641608238, 0.049088940024375916, 0.016009468585252762, 0.016992080956697464, -0.019250618293881416, 0.039583925157785416, -0.007583340629935265, 0.01659548468887806, -0.009154140949249268, 0.030952543020248413, -0.009031573310494423, 0.007479052525013685, 0.023384101688861847, -0.005347109399735928, -0.01782231032848358, 0.03475818783044815, 0.030191630125045776, -0.009549370035529137, -0.009781120344996452, 0.02271168865263462, -0.025601305067539215, 0.006893475074321032, -0.00416750879958272, -0.006649912800639868, 0.07660520821809769, 0.03371039032936096, -0.020176071673631668, 0.006363871973007917, -0.0033659497275948524, 0.035980235785245895, -0.10168132185935974, -0.013618593104183674, -0.013385655358433723, 0.027370208874344826, 0.04054676741361618, -0.06792428344488144, 0.007336519658565521, 0.02473406121134758, -0.04881567880511284, -0.01042525377124548, -0.0011164514580741525, 0.0012374744983389974, -0.03083924390375614, 0.009931471198797226, -0.009351033717393875, 0.056405842304229736, -0.00433817645534873, 0.030863113701343536, 0.019873972982168198, 0.07128265500068665, -0.020989298820495605, -0.011878096498548985, -0.015583185479044914, -0.005508693400770426, 0.01796261966228485, -0.07449600845575333, 0.035539958626031876, -0.02902613766491413, -0.04401484504342079, 0.047475025057792664, -0.01207268238067627, 0.05515878275036812, 0.0015934270340949297, 0.04416435956954956, 0.015219757333397865, 0.028364945203065872, 0.01572900265455246, -0.0033009848557412624, -0.001514269970357418, -0.022170471027493477, -0.00520138768479228, 0.03261665254831314, -0.030947014689445496, 0.014385250397026539, 0.03291104733943939, -0.020973971113562584, 0.014481401070952415, -0.010268447920680046, -0.006537443492561579, -0.0019912405405193567, -0.003568160580471158, -0.027378693222999573, -0.002557782456278801, -0.022822305560112, 0.018883131444454193, -0.03808068111538887, -0.030299846082925797, 0.02052803710103035, 0.039373982697725296, -0.026780270040035248, 0.0017904768465086818, -0.017958924174308777, -0.03520578518509865, 0.017658589407801628, -0.011366321705281734, 0.05512181669473648, -0.058754581958055496, 0.0005749099655076861, -0.039470069110393524, -0.035914670675992966, -0.04152993857860565, -0.02899877540767193, -0.05789367854595184, 0.028513407334685326, -0.03240121528506279, -0.019060468301177025, -0.002142946235835552, -0.0007561917882412672, -0.016336822882294655, -0.07853444665670395, 0.044486600905656815, 0.03265204280614853, -0.006863507442176342, -0.02721315622329712, 0.008881410583853722, -0.060857389122247696, -0.012744025327265263, 0.059025030583143234, 0.024542128667235374, 0.0244657713919878, 0.002933888928964734, 0.03124340809881687, -0.022578265517950058, -0.05466584861278534, 0.0463634729385376, -0.012435562908649445, 0.0034000403247773647, 0.0029573801439255476, -0.03772866353392601, 0.017892932519316673, -0.019706089049577713, 0.03244509920477867, -0.0406348891556263, -0.018393415957689285, -0.009417925961315632, -0.002364467130973935, 0.03745756670832634, -0.008630678988993168, -0.018060099333524704, 0.020194515585899353, 0.0023147615138441324, 0.035249512642621994, 0.02393355220556259, 0.004924305249005556, -0.0431448258459568, 0.02516154572367668, -0.009990954771637917, -0.008843806572258472, 0.004368681460618973, 0.021497653797268867, -0.03933243080973625, -0.024771541357040405, 0.008166934363543987, 0.012968606315553188, -0.026258958503603935, 0.002366574015468359, 0.06166985630989075, 0.04866471141576767, 0.004174798261374235, -0.007265501655638218, 0.02335624024271965, 0.014830964617431164, -0.011971741914749146, 0.016828762367367744, -0.0075749000534415245, 0.02902187965810299, 0.03004835732281208, 0.0018936312990263104, 0.029933393001556396, -0.031141873449087143, 0.010258376598358154, -0.00963656511157751, 0.0342365987598896, -0.02749958261847496, -0.008172758854925632, 0.02805318869650364, 0.021850889548659325, 0.015000486746430397, -0.017850792035460472, -0.003541284939274192, 0.06763561069965363, -0.020449982956051826, -0.008555388078093529, -0.01972220093011856, 0.023265551775693893, 0.0039437017403542995, 0.01027020812034607, 0.023297330364584923, 0.03688313439488411, -0.018123174086213112, 0.03566286712884903, -0.017963992431759834, -0.028346126899123192, 0.013815169222652912, -0.019808173179626465, 0.003491836367174983, -0.04012832045555115, -0.004831492900848389, -0.0027752353344112635, -0.02749975025653839, -0.034038472920656204, -0.02242809720337391, 0.04710172489285469, 0.0452665276825428, 0.05278579518198967, -0.017863141372799873, -0.04568903148174286, -0.0021678663324564695, 0.05708765238523483, -0.049303218722343445, -0.033507488667964935, 0.006179080344736576, 0.004996574949473143, 0.024442030116915703, -0.016122769564390182 ]
<p>I am trying to model weekly disease counts in 25 different regions within 1 country over a ten year period as influenced by temperature. The data is zero inflated and over dispersed. </p> <p>I am most familiar with Stata but I don't think that there is any option amongst the <code>gee</code>, <code>xtmixed</code>, <code>xtmepoisson</code> etc. commands that allows me to account for the zero inflation and over dispersion issues as well as the autocorrelation. </p> <p>I log transformed the incidence data and used a SARIMA model but the residuals are not quite normal. I think that there are versions of the ARIMA model for integer data like disease counts but I can't find a program for it. </p> <p>I was also thinking that I could create a hierarchical model with random intercepts for each region and random effects of temperature in each region, while also accounting for the regular seasonal disease cycle. I believe that I could model this in R using a package like <a href="http://admb-project.org/examples/r-stuff/glmmadmb" rel="nofollow">glmm.admb</a> but due to my limited statistical and R knowledge I am not entirely sure how to do use it. I am mainly confused about accounting for the autocorrelation and seasonal cycle part of the data using a program like this. </p> <p>Any advice on how to best do this?</p>
36,091
[ -0.015567678026854992, -0.014461060054600239, 0.028458965942263603, 0.0007272741640917957, 0.05002607777714729, -0.012202367186546326, 0.006189638748764992, 0.010938393883407116, 0.04149444028735161, -0.02507905103266239, 0.052464600652456284, 0.043589863926172256, 0.036024853587150574, 0.019417230039834976, 0.03941601887345314, -0.018236849457025528, -0.001480301027186215, -0.009794593788683414, -0.0036430980544537306, -0.008976156823337078, 0.004571857396513224, 0.0023531951010227203, -0.014681719243526459, -0.021871652454137802, -0.029418544843792915, 0.05687791481614113, 0.01779380813241005, -0.012024303898215294, 0.0032108905725181103, 0.06293091177940369, -0.03918738663196564, -0.01641450636088848, -0.0066510941833257675, 0.01951240748167038, 0.02481187880039215, 0.001815300201997161, -0.0009455224499106407, -0.01635318621993065, -0.031464654952287674, 0.020625432953238487, -0.04054512828588486, -0.029436221346259117, 0.0069571444764733315, 0.003221780527383089, -0.029928792268037796, 0.01737869903445244, 0.013306660577654839, 0.007279586512595415, 0.07179398834705353, -0.03950647637248039, 0.045660875737667084, 0.011709215119481087, 0.06060490012168884, 0.04208032414317131, -0.0077866981737315655, -0.04390526935458183, 0.07373332977294922, 0.02829914167523384, 0.008347035385668278, -0.030271030962467194, -0.014670606702566147, -0.025235280394554138, -0.02239963971078396, -0.04663390666246414, -0.04683925211429596, 0.011370091699063778, -0.0037349869962781668, -0.03497123345732689, 0.0413641482591629, 0.0010490529239177704, 0.03300578147172928, 0.018167654052376747, 0.004278756678104401, -0.017546100541949272, 0.03128945827484131, -0.0474737323820591, -0.020944366231560707, 0.0014269776875153184, 0.018765950575470924, 0.037048712372779846, -0.008291405625641346, 0.0198343638330698, 0.012090276926755905, -0.0075588589534163475, 0.025311432778835297, -0.019805487245321274, 0.05243759974837303, -0.004347287118434906, 0.007844427600502968, 0.02876565232872963, -0.033046331256628036, 0.029573144391179085, 0.03628963232040405, 0.03649013116955757, -0.050704509019851685, 0.0379243940114975, -0.016955744475126266, 0.07204534113407135, -0.02331491746008396, 0.027994541451334953, -0.020115124061703682, -0.0247872993350029, 0.013437976129353046, 0.05743018537759781, -0.03641987964510918, -0.020939158275723457, -0.019198760390281677, -0.04330867528915405, 0.002328289905562997, -0.025156861171126366, -0.03721383959054947, 0.023714588955044746, -0.0029560222756117582, -0.037058502435684204, 0.03009028173983097, -0.011442343704402447, 0.013355019502341747, -0.020282333716750145, 0.021059077233076096, 0.06459036469459534, 0.034834664314985275, -0.027658311650156975, 0.028627868741750717, -0.0551174059510231, -0.0652899518609047, 0.01688183657824993, -0.03692564740777016, -0.026497673243284225, -0.05052131041884422, 0.06929228454828262, 0.014387687668204308, -0.042771145701408386, 0.030063671991229057, -0.028465697541832924, 0.0518065020442009, -0.015672851353883743, -0.05429013445973396, -0.07257198542356491, 0.048154059797525406, -0.021021278575062752, 0.03470151871442795, -0.029074106365442276, -0.0054746754467487335, -0.004496347159147263, 0.05365405231714249, 0.009092919528484344, 0.054445333778858185, 0.02126847766339779, 0.024826692417263985, -0.020959867164492607, -0.034018002450466156, -0.013759257271885872, 0.00428842892870307, -0.009724907577037811, -0.02237497828900814, -0.10513570159673691, 0.006829131860285997, 0.03306461125612259, -0.01574922353029251, 0.0007276624091900885, 0.05580286309123039, 0.04327927529811859, -0.006623355206102133, 0.00695960596203804, 0.004075514618307352, -0.010294994339346886, 0.06515423208475113, 0.012793280184268951, 0.0076579623855650425, 0.03660456836223602, -0.007008139975368977, 0.029747938737273216, 0.015658095479011536, 0.0350690521299839, 0.056810006499290466, 0.016707057133316994, 0.034801580011844635, -0.01744077354669571, -0.001920892857015133, 0.051554303616285324, -0.05488567426800728, -0.023737451061606407, 0.01625649817287922, -0.054259929805994034, 0.04139990732073784, -0.0008411899325437844, -0.007929214276373386, 0.007757609244436026, 0.07391703873872757, -0.0788997933268547, -0.05409138649702072, -0.041504569351673126, -0.012688472867012024, -0.02913576178252697, 0.014028802514076233, 0.006042870227247477, -0.019796544685959816, 0.039596252143383026, 0.027770543470978737, -0.028894979506731033, -0.0289359912276268, -0.022058775648474693, 0.06291180849075317, -0.008683252148330212, -0.029363956302404404, 0.021592920646071434, 0.044161438941955566, -0.024950966238975525, 0.05745011195540428, -0.05767202377319336, -0.016667544841766357, -0.04261959344148636, -0.040808893740177155, 0.01970200054347515, -0.026130016893148422, -0.019950982183218002, 0.03085377812385559, 0.015509315766394138, -0.012859701178967953, 0.013776961714029312, -0.05884100869297981, 0.04518160596489906, 0.060589227825403214, 0.013543120585381985, 0.024506911635398865, 0.05364730954170227, 0.023451626300811768, 0.00645238533616066, -0.025312965735793114, -0.01676321029663086, -0.08619365096092224, 0.0027629160322248936, 0.026256704702973366, -0.008023231290280819, -0.006446056999266148, 0.029988884925842285, 0.06993793696165085, 0.04785924777388573, -0.004047372844070196, 0.031782250851392746, 0.004415241535753012, 0.037898898124694824, 0.0012561992043629289, 0.01393873244524002, -0.015257535502314568, 0.006510748993605375, 0.01291118934750557, 0.009078209288418293, 0.03129493445158005, 0.009073994122445583, -0.036288682371377945, 0.055597659200429916, 0.005641744937747717, 0.03385517746210098, -0.02656635269522667, 0.0032185083255171776, 0.061409492045640945, -0.019174765795469284, -0.0016197687946259975, 0.016169097274541855, 0.00039912728243507445, 0.002135718008503318, 0.0035894045140594244, -0.007091422565281391, -0.0014396044425666332, 0.0449213869869709, -0.011809637770056725, -0.01889442466199398, 0.007280332501977682, -0.021861819550395012, 0.002064500004053116, -0.04515017569065094, -0.014586958102881908, -0.06174885481595993, -0.006501617841422558, 0.05473434180021286, 0.03206423670053482, 0.025333460420370102, -0.016415810212492943, -0.0414554700255394, 0.017445525154471397, -0.008841237053275108, 0.030958101153373718, -0.005332232918590307, -0.04514576122164726, 0.01222007442265749, -0.0005692719132639468, -0.01387229934334755, 0.03469330072402954, -0.020768381655216217, -0.020236719399690628, 0.0009537776350043714, -0.0052692946046590805, -0.023211749270558357, -0.01927557773888111, -0.027745412662625313, 0.005719838198274374, -0.07612697780132294, -0.005511460825800896, 0.03813840076327324, 0.0094457371160388, 0.01200246810913086, 0.01836690865457058, -0.06519613415002823, -0.007561908569186926, -0.02797515317797661, 0.030019452795386314, 0.01777547597885132, -0.022502055391669273, -0.007994539104402065, 0.0210258886218071, -0.0362972654402256, 0.0020203874446451664, -0.04562857002019882, -0.04811418056488037, 0.007668446749448776, 0.023187575861811638, 0.015427626669406891, -0.010825129225850105, 0.01507390197366476, 0.0329025536775589, 0.04973467066884041, -0.011370908468961716, -0.03247815743088722, -0.004509837366640568, -0.03580830246210098, -0.031132010743021965, 0.018827032297849655, 0.013926176354289055, 0.00864216685295105, 0.019559824839234352, 0.019691139459609985, 0.013041009195148945, 0.06573222577571869, -0.0004298599960748106, -0.013506843708455563, 0.010996897704899311, 0.0005817987839691341, -0.007182081695646048, 0.0455637127161026, -0.0038094893097877502, -0.014054152183234692, -0.006497333291918039, -0.055318158119916916, -0.013750981539487839, -0.009070171974599361, -0.03635994717478752, 0.01156257838010788, 0.011770944111049175, 0.00013074596063233912, -0.022875629365444183, -0.010677624493837357, -0.006236422806978226, -0.050022851675748825, -0.006653010845184326, -0.011220192536711693, 0.06443557143211365, 0.0002692733833100647, -0.029833341017365456, 0.06365285813808441, 0.05539382994174957, -0.02728673443198204, 0.0048768725246191025, 0.016825834289193153, 0.042224593460559845, -0.002012775279581547, -0.010449731722474098, 0.02388368546962738, 0.02878938987851143, 0.008222906850278378, 0.015304171480238438, -0.015250591561198235, -0.05493827536702156, 0.007107286248356104, -0.0689622312784195, -0.030356576666235924, -0.04178919270634651, 0.06938813626766205, 0.006423596758395433, -0.0033587843645364046, -0.003076672088354826, -0.036567673087120056, 0.04320302978157997, 0.028208941221237183, -0.07963167130947113, 0.030239015817642212, 0.013186824508011341, 0.005160793662071228, 0.050514861941337585, -0.018714753910899162, 0.02284174971282482, 0.01393211167305708, 0.016562288627028465, -0.007417631801217794, 0.0005363560630939901, -0.014604930765926838, 0.016008200123906136, -0.00700188847258687, -0.03546755760908127, -0.00746919633820653, 0.011775309219956398, -0.0010503114899620414, 0.0022807009518146515, -0.009502343833446503, 0.044028282165527344, 0.016897210851311684, -0.006964866537600756, -0.058844517916440964, 0.02896192856132984, 0.043611638247966766, 0.012988264672458172, 0.030184315517544746, 0.008511856198310852, -0.08427910506725311, -0.007738764397799969, 0.028392288833856583, 0.012018381617963314, 0.03317735344171524, 0.014365714974701405, -0.022815557196736336, -0.020607246086001396, -0.009734123945236206, 0.041054386645555496, -0.026947200298309326, 0.03085014410316944, 0.025416843593120575, 0.07998653501272202, 0.023009302094578743, -0.048100974410772324, 0.013376723043620586, 0.05669422075152397, -0.029744740575551987, 0.01537241879850626, -0.002848520176485181, -0.025737829506397247, -0.0038741666357964277, 0.022992683574557304, 0.05179937183856964, -0.003346530254930258, -0.00864442065358162, 0.01824047788977623, 0.043912921100854874, -0.04633168876171112, -0.00945813674479723, 0.00418162252753973, 0.0588529109954834, 0.07376646250486374, 0.0069808331318199635, -0.06638524681329727, 0.027784373611211777, 0.014352419413626194, -0.014779078774154186, 0.04674054682254791, 0.0009591878042556345, -0.08357661217451096, -0.0007013927097432315, 0.04605983942747116, 0.005847550462931395, -0.0031124227680265903, -0.0074831764213740826, -0.05887061357498169, -0.007101263385266066, 0.03603372722864151, -0.014439133927226067, 0.00938305165618658, -0.01847081631422043, -0.017201373353600502, -0.02450541965663433, -0.06154193356633186, 0.003374242689460516, 0.010401406325399876, -0.03651685640215874, 0.016621900722384453, -0.005908073857426643, -0.0346914604306221, -0.029783742502331734, 0.05136436969041824, -0.021764148026704788, 0.03919271007180214, -0.031215999275445938, -0.03194646164774895, 0.031110413372516632, 0.003730569500476122, 0.0028037584852427244, -0.056794267147779465, -0.012365984730422497, 0.008965044282376766, 0.027894016355276108, 0.04469246789813042, -0.014305388554930687, 0.0023309411481022835, 0.0023406504187732935, 0.0007505397661589086, 0.024545816704630852, 0.005533158313483, -0.06257735937833786, 0.048887986689805984, -0.007225906476378441, -0.015296236611902714, 0.033652037382125854, 0.017514128237962723, 0.005687500350177288, 0.0034081332851201296, -0.028774680569767952, 0.009901829995214939, -0.02661238983273506, -0.029337946325540543, -0.06440605968236923, 0.018975110724568367, -0.021892843768000603, 0.0347319096326828, 0.026259247213602066, 0.06245913729071617, -0.02611672319471836, 0.0007951350416988134, -0.00004667954635806382, 0.024702634662389755, -0.030764423310756683, -0.0038478958886116743, -0.004016588442027569, 0.024260835722088814, -0.028305288404226303, -0.038311667740345, 0.035683970898389816, -0.026290008798241615, -0.0032268883660435677, -0.011192729696631432, -0.06756548583507538, 0.008283752016723156, -0.024184327572584152, -0.04052845016121864, -0.010009580291807652, -0.014433315955102444, 0.008552473969757557, -0.009461313486099243, 0.0452541746199131, -0.012348390184342861, -0.04856409877538681, -0.022337591275572777, 0.03528124466538429, 0.021083369851112366, 0.016092369332909584, -0.02896471507847309, 0.00916244462132454, -0.014052356593310833, -0.01655806042253971, -0.06073011830449104, -0.06456884741783142, 0.04346267879009247, -0.016341110691428185, -0.010927294380962849, -0.041994377970695496, 0.019592951983213425, -0.01864182949066162, -0.008824890479445457, 0.012162729166448116, 0.03992672264575958, -0.01968006230890751, 0.04024017974734306, -0.017832398414611816, 0.04394693300127983, 0.07322489470243454, 0.017247579991817474, -0.006351933814585209, 0.026143105700612068, 0.00910557433962822, -0.005432711914181709, 0.007476289756596088, 0.03563840687274933, -0.011473668739199638, 0.017116613686084747, -0.061896275728940964, -0.006398479919880629, 0.02879519946873188, 0.025732669979333878, -0.022558676078915596, 0.010339455679059029, 0.0023631348740309477, 0.008524974808096886, -0.05523226782679558, 0.020060710608959198, 0.0055984146893024445, -0.029775040224194527, -0.037032049149274826, -0.0038104515988379717, -0.01240051630884409, -0.010996534489095211, 0.012242952361702919, -0.027576908469200134, 0.008644395507872105, 0.040408745408058167, 0.04503452777862549, 0.024135928601026535, 0.007572162430733442, -0.0005231181276030838, -0.019770391285419464, 0.037193991243839264, -0.03609543293714523, -0.005580066237598658, 0.007715754676610231, 0.01674804463982582, -0.008623013272881508, -0.053387351334095, -0.017335694283246994, 0.02032388001680374, 0.06379321217536926, -0.010455167852342129, -0.002097649499773979, 0.017826762050390244, 0.015490483492612839, 0.035050272941589355, -0.02591591514647007, -0.014139385893940926, 0.025670263916254044, 0.032696451991796494, 0.06053495779633522, -0.02785031683743, -0.01341375894844532, 0.03139598295092583, 0.033751580864191055, 0.014393928460776806, 0.03468296676874161, 0.02820606902241707, 0.006031458731740713, -0.03546004369854927, -0.025576459243893623, -0.051081445068120956, 0.020160211250185966, -0.01156332902610302, 0.05607179179787636, -0.02046082727611065, -0.02256796322762966, 0.058595601469278336, 0.02750490978360176, 0.007480710279196501, -0.01749252714216709, -0.021174127236008644, -0.0428665466606617, 0.0249117873609066, 0.027898402884602547, 0.011363523080945015, 0.04518716409802437, 0.028865812346339226, 0.04309026524424553, -0.008554783649742603, 0.0071152881719172, -0.01360821258276701, -0.07417173683643341, -0.01730581931769848, -0.02287271060049534, -0.05141206085681915, 0.07117973268032074, -0.002709058579057455, -0.007040996570140123, 0.008135608397424221, -0.027399666607379913, -0.03072962537407875, 0.020108230412006378, 0.03552432358264923, 0.027249984443187714, 0.07880788296461105, -0.010187815874814987, -0.006597568280994892, -0.021478984504938126, 0.023591063916683197, 0.11723392456769943, 0.06243273243308067, 0.0373731404542923, -0.06473395228385925, -0.00040114609873853624, 0.006123651750385761, -0.008325704373419285, -0.015609451569616795, 0.024515965953469276, 0.002901253988966346, -0.06297280639410019, 0.06533882766962051, 0.04497620090842247, 0.00013955662143416703, 0.037256717681884766, 0.06116555631160736, -0.02895238809287548, -0.047316573560237885, -0.002259032102301717, -0.0017746799858286977, -0.0032682816963642836, 0.012481622397899628, -0.058124519884586334, 0.02018889971077442, -0.00823674164712429, -0.042915742844343185, -0.05392313003540039, 0.001968712778761983, -0.023792125284671783, 0.009686603210866451, -0.014190491288900375, -0.006455457303673029, -0.002201456343755126, 0.024041788652539253, 0.010282059200108051, -0.025344695895910263, 0.006244229152798653, -0.04459337517619133, 0.049633223563432693, 0.035677988082170486, -0.015109241008758545, 0.002170177875086665, 0.009605318307876587, -0.002945546992123127, -0.011132492683827877, -0.029743654653429985, -0.004685862455517054, 0.05485590919852257, -0.012021146714687347, -0.002752710832282901, -0.0004005711816716939, 0.035680532455444336, -0.006765278521925211, 0.0038962136022746563, 0.002388333436101675, 0.0026254046242684126, 0.05458947271108627, -0.03685043007135391, -0.02335795946419239, -0.017850613221526146, 0.010287810117006302, 0.0015208469703793526, 0.04009320214390755, 0.037783168256282806, -0.041754066944122314, -0.027565285563468933, -0.04734949395060539, 0.06494946777820587, -0.02559143677353859, -0.0028869493398815393, 0.01802879571914673, -0.018720796331763268, -0.023282049223780632, -0.013528072275221348, -0.013043778948485851, 0.011671318672597408, 0.03210359811782837, -0.019930748268961906, -0.02876637503504753, -0.01571558229625225, -0.019607217982411385, -0.006074525415897369, -0.034066636115312576, -0.015698377043008804, -0.006956029683351517, -0.010128355585038662, -0.0043641808442771435, 0.015832114964723587, -0.006944440770894289, 0.02711024321615696, -0.024770356714725494, 0.032948609441518784, -0.02314717508852482, -0.051791395992040634, -0.030659234151244164, -0.018892444670200348, -0.04128018021583557, -0.004308525938540697, -0.007349911145865917, 0.071693554520607, -0.0010346528142690659, 0.009327858686447144, -0.013382644392549992, 0.05637389048933983, 0.006723752710968256, 0.0010121557861566544, -0.018152380362153053, -0.044043004512786865, 0.010854045860469341, 0.004694739822298288, 0.00007662660209462047, -0.04508906975388527, -0.007687720470130444, -0.004370298236608505, -0.013621697202324867, 0.007677813526242971, 0.004719703923910856, -0.0508299358189106, 0.0292337778955698, -0.030049774795770645, 0.01831098087131977, -0.03555436432361603, 0.011680391617119312, -0.052708886563777924, -0.050973717123270035, 0.01199075486510992, -0.030295860022306442, 0.024603543803095818, 0.019183700904250145, -0.02388390712440014, 0.002176349051296711, 0.06266642361879349, 0.005579930730164051, 0.0025274299550801516, 0.011029702611267567, -0.018187250941991806, 0.017482995986938477, 0.06814872473478317, -0.0140233738347888, -0.03566847741603851, 0.01370441447943449, -0.037079911679029465, -0.03528710454702377, 0.02971072494983673, -0.022915005683898926, 0.03795716166496277, 0.013083773665130138, 0.007829265668988228, 0.0007145288400352001, 0.04557611420750618, -0.018266422674059868, 0.0035543108824640512, -0.037468161433935165, 0.014777378179132938, 0.02925119549036026, 0.023718982934951782, -0.013242599554359913, 0.028612889349460602, -0.026399416849017143, 0.044424187391996384, 0.07193635404109955, 0.03222052380442619, -0.005858083255589008, 0.03819676488637924, -0.014822238124907017, 0.010594485327601433, -0.024508589878678322, -0.03703784942626953, 0.0435173399746418, 0.023332761600613594, -0.026150653138756752, 0.045004259794950485, -0.012238110415637493, -0.004380862228572369, -0.07913544028997421, -0.031807005405426025, 0.005555152893066406, 0.010948783718049526, 0.021779922768473625, -0.026479728519916534, -0.029506193473935127, -0.0035127897281199694, -0.02798164263367653, 0.049205951392650604, 0.010385019704699516, 0.012133760377764702, -0.025927912443876266, -0.018749715760350227, -0.01570136472582817, 0.024377813562750816, 0.02882898971438408, 0.020113686099648476, 0.023581866174936295, 0.045398127287626266, 0.02410351298749447, -0.05814386531710625, -0.023336751386523247, -0.0030221513006836176, 0.03392131254076958, -0.04524654522538185, 0.036342449486255646, -0.04505025967955589, -0.02207065001130104, 0.01555358711630106, -0.04485191032290459, 0.041158437728881836, -0.008972900919616222, 0.0024518719874322414, -0.010847455821931362, 0.07251404225826263, 0.028474856168031693, -0.00693120714277029, 0.01563533954322338, -0.04541920870542526, 0.0493428111076355, 0.03114441968500614, -0.05046146735548973, 0.02384280413389206, 0.0209333673119545, -0.02140602096915245, -0.029641948640346527, -0.0052129533141851425, 0.007342654746025801, -0.0005276784067973495, 0.0038456262554973364, -0.0109653165563941, -0.010752554051578045, -0.014832425862550735, -0.015146133489906788, -0.02797054313123226, 0.03367849439382553, 0.05008797347545624, 0.05025067180395126, -0.018500439822673798, 0.014543706551194191, -0.006106470245867968, -0.039254214614629745, -0.020580926910042763, -0.01767364889383316, -0.043426815420389175, -0.007601635530591011, -0.010333654470741749, -0.02757234498858452, -0.007141685113310814, -0.022592760622501373, 0.023006882518529892, -0.06476571410894394, 0.005509341601282358, -0.060848843306303024, 0.008743646554648876, 0.03239009529352188, -0.029604125767946243, 0.05853690579533577, -0.05298159271478653, 0.046305201947689056, -0.0009072041139006615, 0.0030699782073497772, -0.02318360097706318, -0.013197893276810646, -0.027698015794157982, -0.001619740854948759, 0.04391166567802429, 0.013477263040840626, 0.04010426625609398, -0.00790462363511324, 0.0727977529168129, 0.005199615377932787, -0.005868201609700918, 0.04603350907564163, -0.02344566024839878, -0.03865864500403404, -0.007305550388991833, -0.014415837824344635, 0.001878341194242239, -0.02481738291680813, 0.013099400326609612, -0.03420183062553406, 0.008185614831745625, -0.014573253691196442, -0.03720296546816826, -0.018664972856640816, -0.0057057845406234264, -0.04688121750950813, 0.002222189912572503, 0.0036042167339473963, 0.008081667125225067, 0.055649276822805405, 0.023617800325155258, -0.04033925384283066, 0.03029813803732395, -0.04388152435421944, -0.015974655747413635, 0.03847242891788483, -0.022201398387551308, -0.013339227065443993, -0.07004894316196442, 0.025336919352412224, 0.016455186530947685, 0.003189342562109232, 0.008101294748485088, 0.04442225769162178, 0.0066645266488194466, 0.036659497767686844, -0.011387592181563377, 0.015577603131532669, 0.004079841542989016, -0.0015408728504553437, -0.026150379329919815, 0.018443098291754723, 0.002571877557784319, 0.0074973986484110355, 0.0041793049313127995, 0.0013442672789096832, 0.02495940774679184, 0.0462421290576458, -0.02061106078326702, 0.04709582030773163, -0.0029286486096680164, -0.04576009511947632, -0.010182758793234825, 0.009409391321241856, 0.012757297605276108, 0.004405905958265066, -0.010983741842210293, 0.051214929670095444, -0.005656776484102011, -0.007923953235149384, -0.006547969300299883, -0.04925227910280228, -0.03417164832353592, -0.0024716886691749096, 0.00036538561107590795, 0.020138761028647423, -0.00864387396723032, 0.033258162438869476, 0.005919621326029301, 0.010710659436881542, 0.010652882978320122, -0.02767530269920826, 0.023746836930513382, -0.0201166532933712, -0.01664058119058609, -0.01430343184620142, -0.020919587463140488, -0.008322148583829403, -0.0323643758893013, 0.03723854571580887, 0.053450532257556915, 0.005051929038017988, -0.014443451538681984, -0.014043837785720825, 0.004386423621326685, 0.02421671710908413, -0.058675315231084824, -0.05232132226228714, -0.023945016786456108, -0.013383027166128159, -0.007711105979979038, -0.012370758689939976 ]
<p>I'm new to both R and Bayesian statistics, and I have a problem where I have a normally distributed prior that elicits a mean and standard deviation. The introduced likelihood function is also normally distributed with a mean and standard deviation that can be drawn from a sample.</p> <p>Now I understand that a posterior is formed that will also be normally distributed. I have been asked to generate this in R, but I cannot find an example of R code where the posterior is formed from a normally distributed prior and likelihood function. </p> <p>Could someone please point me in the right direction. Thanks. </p>
73,664
[ -0.02914142981171608, 0.0008723677601665258, 0.02172379195690155, -0.013314904645085335, 0.006508544087409973, 0.002151442924514413, 0.0031502344645559788, -0.010559363290667534, 0.017255514860153198, -0.030676625669002533, 0.016369085758924484, 0.04956654831767082, 0.0777868926525116, 0.011727050878107548, 0.044147394597530365, 0.002557548228651285, -0.010664199478924274, 0.011318151839077473, -0.035945285111665726, -0.026989946141839027, -0.01238161325454712, -0.015333052724599838, 0.03225530683994293, -0.026943042874336243, -0.00485576456412673, 0.03916419669985771, 0.022725839167833328, -0.00722917914390564, -0.011355023831129074, 0.08097875118255615, -0.03362412378191948, -0.034815169870853424, 0.01215530838817358, 0.04778748378157616, -0.007337932009249926, -0.0011837601196020842, -0.022903714329004288, -0.007650385610759258, -0.03763803467154503, 0.049866922199726105, -0.026861436665058136, -0.01976197585463524, 0.02496619150042534, 0.05126090720295906, -0.008048102259635925, 0.020558279007673264, -0.025032123550772667, -0.021035626530647278, 0.00988757610321045, -0.05987522006034851, 0.048139702528715134, 0.01175903994590044, 0.04998002201318741, 0.03293249011039734, -0.0195230171084404, -0.01383247785270214, 0.06046075373888016, 0.06884880363941193, 0.0042105927132070065, -0.09357064962387085, -0.01856273040175438, -0.05810563638806343, -0.014968467876315117, -0.04555913805961609, -0.05091526359319687, 0.002928520319983363, -0.028888633474707603, -0.02957901544868946, 0.037772536277770996, -0.02998500131070614, 0.009172088466584682, 0.025326307862997055, 0.0019079535268247128, -0.0151042016223073, 0.006457442883402109, -0.01501123420894146, -0.013077223673462868, 0.013415343128144741, 0.010645695962011814, 0.02680061012506485, 0.0073843360878527164, -0.01810065656900406, 0.023397857323288918, 0.029196394607424736, -0.007561788894236088, -0.014406549744307995, 0.08538172394037247, -0.027540789917111397, 0.0027327765710651875, -0.00828768964856863, -0.029884791001677513, 0.014887246303260326, 0.06868243217468262, -0.002330925315618515, -0.042026810348033905, 0.05711574852466583, -0.010507618077099323, 0.07738257199525833, 0.001803694642148912, -0.0184000413864851, 0.011391832493245602, -0.043574173003435135, 0.006843505427241325, 0.050726547837257385, -0.027881111949682236, -0.031491316854953766, -0.023827839642763138, -0.0013372788671404123, -0.019466940313577652, -0.017761964350938797, -0.040238119661808014, 0.031640034168958664, -0.014744507148861885, 0.004969033412635326, -0.0045197526924312115, -0.04255719855427742, -0.006194015499204397, -0.022282877936959267, 0.06065153703093529, 0.03297300264239311, 0.02696252427995205, -0.023246893659234047, 0.04911985248327255, -0.04062781482934952, -0.028717510402202606, -0.00793424341827631, -0.02495277114212513, -0.00818491168320179, -0.008155286312103271, 0.0531686432659626, -0.025932839140295982, -0.038797784596681595, 0.055307380855083466, 0.028710447251796722, 0.02749461866915226, -0.023475591093301773, -0.06203687563538551, -0.032294195145368576, 0.024517687037587166, -0.033532485365867615, 0.01158258318901062, -0.08703482151031494, 0.026446646079421043, 0.048951730132102966, 0.006493534427136183, 0.018061939626932144, 0.02795126847922802, 0.03126594051718712, 0.021396726369857788, -0.02639331854879856, -0.03172053024172783, -0.009607985615730286, -0.03847843408584595, 0.010633978061378002, -0.023399487137794495, -0.07955513894557953, 0.01394020114094019, -0.009008649736642838, 0.015763619914650917, -0.00474131666123867, 0.04680804908275604, -0.0033063620794564486, -0.019015448167920113, -0.008506158366799355, 0.019594775512814522, -0.03805270418524742, 0.07994934171438217, 0.009601063095033169, -0.02249692752957344, 0.01338286604732275, -0.01522854808717966, 0.0049419160932302475, 0.012183213606476784, 0.04034188389778137, 0.048494625836610794, -0.03945720195770264, -0.011589993722736835, -0.015488927252590656, 0.05520227551460266, 0.027245284989476204, 0.015490003861486912, 0.029025524854660034, 0.005885211285203695, -0.04739900305867195, 0.0021246103569865227, 0.015552380122244358, 0.02293258346617222, -0.04090268909931183, 0.03808753937482834, -0.0477401539683342, -0.02032260037958622, -0.06478296220302582, -0.01813635043799877, -0.02140672877430916, -0.02535265125334263, 0.02629862166941166, 0.0135947335511446, 0.08167414367198944, 0.003451067488640547, -0.016939276829361916, -0.03961702808737755, -0.038015786558389664, 0.03403497487306595, -0.01003370713442564, 0.0026394499000161886, 0.04435262456536293, 0.07890748232603073, 0.005440598353743553, 0.023694543167948723, 0.0005787923000752926, -0.05446644872426987, -0.004413234069943428, -0.04359400272369385, 0.0028507837560027838, -0.007777645718306303, -0.019885195419192314, 0.018123986199498177, -0.0070936535485088825, 0.0034615318290889263, 0.010554688051342964, -0.048108506947755814, 0.035337336361408234, 0.07329978048801422, 0.01225904282182455, -0.013125129975378513, -0.026126980781555176, 0.030948398634791374, 0.02213827520608902, -0.03612120449542999, -0.0017432059394195676, -0.04542261362075806, -0.005694819614291191, 0.06119069084525108, 0.002606455236673355, -0.032012760639190674, 0.016624730080366135, 0.0035273905377835035, -0.006406791508197784, 0.04007444903254509, 0.07006966322660446, -0.0040398635901510715, -0.030077720060944557, 0.0000578853978367988, -0.012216373346745968, 0.038938768208026886, -0.0002440144307911396, 0.029119053855538368, 0.03518490120768547, 0.05784929543733597, -0.004231369588524103, -0.023238155990839005, 0.04196224361658096, -0.025953173637390137, 0.022843826562166214, -0.03503860533237457, -0.011522194370627403, 0.03612791746854782, -0.003016998991370201, -0.00009656062320573255, 0.0055524203926324844, -0.003389393212273717, -0.046594176441431046, 0.004176046699285507, -0.007126295939087868, 0.03590468689799309, 0.06808511912822723, -0.03060472197830677, 0.034471895545721054, 0.01798408292233944, -0.043747082352638245, 0.03102274425327778, -0.01744048297405243, -0.01615401916205883, -0.03804096207022667, 0.011209099553525448, 0.006947232410311699, 0.007518325001001358, -0.011243795044720173, -0.03286757320165634, -0.049934022128582, 0.003297691233456135, -0.02425471507012844, 0.003925774712115526, -0.004673154093325138, -0.03948988392949104, 0.010332603938877583, -0.019656475633382797, -0.039215777069330215, 0.0023596177343279123, -0.01703275367617607, -0.04351605847477913, 0.020985683426260948, -0.004571478348225355, -0.04122195765376091, -0.006498579401522875, -0.02047763764858246, 0.007741726469248533, -0.020741300657391548, -0.006990059278905392, 0.0009903132449835539, 0.004915482364594936, -0.004091552458703518, 0.01537642627954483, -0.0655989944934845, -0.04331766441464424, -0.03777918219566345, -0.02493031695485115, 0.014683933928608894, 0.006233327090740204, 0.030300315469503403, 0.031121836975216866, -0.06777423620223999, 0.022696055471897125, -0.06254371255636215, -0.020790331065654755, 0.027089005336165428, 0.018738696351647377, 0.02583790011703968, 0.004746223334223032, -0.017286596819758415, 0.0477873720228672, 0.016250550746917725, -0.04715903103351593, -0.026278218254446983, 0.024560697376728058, -0.02990831434726715, -0.01848464459180832, 0.02106814831495285, 0.017985662445425987, -0.018024956807494164, 0.01869233325123787, -0.015074484050273895, -0.010804316028952599, 0.04958660155534744, 0.005656891968101263, -0.0009340564138256013, 0.04385143145918846, -0.021435309201478958, -0.005338568240404129, 0.03871922567486763, 0.013833347707986832, 0.0022935334127396345, 0.010814255103468895, -0.02685478702187538, 0.030717717483639717, -0.0031820684671401978, -0.028017310425639153, 0.007188617251813412, 0.011612827889621258, 0.025901785120368004, -0.0795091763138771, 0.04941790923476219, 0.0014718298334628344, -0.04874752461910248, 0.00750980619341135, 0.007857521064579487, 0.022391976788640022, -0.029018539935350418, 0.00832691416144371, 0.044457998126745224, 0.015202506445348263, -0.041384823620319366, -0.0217477735131979, -0.006791452411562204, 0.0007139162626117468, 0.0012343835551291704, -0.012286670506000519, -0.013887573033571243, 0.056300368160009384, 0.02512536570429802, 0.02989618107676506, 0.014561508782207966, -0.013394386507570744, 0.014648854732513428, -0.03869299590587616, 0.003791003255173564, -0.005513428244739771, 0.005988798104226589, 0.02044869400560856, 0.06153301149606705, 0.019326647743582726, -0.001554802991449833, 0.02774781547486782, -0.027407635003328323, -0.08776985108852386, 0.007179769687354565, -0.02276184968650341, -0.014183223247528076, -0.015926148742437363, -0.0515582412481308, 0.026983225718140602, -0.023952586576342583, 0.027478743344545364, 0.007428192999213934, -0.0005751358112320304, -0.05094673112034798, 0.004060445353388786, -0.013336981646716595, 0.001954947831109166, 0.0016626793658360839, 0.001233177143149078, 0.027966903522610664, 0.008562766015529633, 0.016348067671060562, 0.03972624987363815, 0.020558960735797882, -0.012128657661378384, 0.008128791116178036, 0.0034152325242757797, -0.020061079412698746, 0.02282547578215599, 0.05380339175462723, 0.03209557756781578, -0.0123507771641016, 0.04245642572641373, 0.015010996721684933, 0.07686105370521545, 0.048576220870018005, -0.019587917253375053, -0.002455470385029912, -0.03285537287592888, -0.018436459824442863, 0.01076458115130663, -0.00012022520240861923, -0.014183012768626213, 0.02019355073571205, 0.034748900681734085, 0.03111572377383709, -0.04608175531029701, 0.024812372401356697, 0.06617377698421478, 0.02752172201871872, -0.002375315874814987, -0.017346281558275223, -0.014245801605284214, -0.02198478765785694, -0.018402395769953728, 0.033283963799476624, 0.015194542706012726, -0.015086404047906399, 0.015522580593824387, 0.02221202477812767, -0.043632928282022476, 0.00204497785307467, -0.03234481066465378, 0.015128346160054207, 0.0508774071931839, 0.020278604701161385, -0.023303085938096046, 0.012703565880656242, 0.01110572088509798, 0.01038932055234909, -0.013282300904393196, -0.010648861527442932, -0.10389383882284164, 0.026103075593709946, 0.03494416922330856, 0.01922481879591942, -0.020779166370630264, 0.001548660802654922, -0.06110398843884468, -0.025412200018763542, 0.08192932605743408, -0.029319865629076958, -0.016103094443678856, -0.01765986531972885, 0.00911358930170536, 0.027324875816702843, -0.013704663142561913, -0.04813240468502045, 0.00372974737547338, -0.03441938757896423, -0.006181987002491951, 0.0014609876088798046, -0.02020682953298092, -0.0503874309360981, 0.008589556440711021, 0.011621014215052128, 0.08567696064710617, -0.012930448167026043, -0.03314262628555298, 0.011926496401429176, 0.01534191332757473, 0.006427686661481857, -0.021019872277975082, 0.022216396406292915, 0.020250992849469185, -0.019350672140717506, 0.02022288553416729, -0.012106439098715782, -0.019801311194896698, 0.04723527282476425, 0.010065519250929356, -0.02348238229751587, 0.03210212662816048, -0.00034112707362510264, 0.018201304599642754, 0.02027725800871849, 0.00873504113405943, 0.06526114791631699, -0.006278569344431162, -0.010324920527637005, -0.02287227101624012, -0.07270173728466034, 0.03476737439632416, -0.018291467800736427, -0.020731160417199135, -0.07039979100227356, -0.005367320030927658, -0.009260415099561214, 0.023855770006775856, 0.005567272659391165, 0.022227272391319275, -0.03028295561671257, 0.0007466956740245223, 0.02587910369038582, 0.049326930195093155, 0.014180191792547703, -0.021299932152032852, -0.019280266016721725, -0.025991274043917656, -0.009514911100268364, 0.011358211748301983, 0.030630910769104958, -0.014153522439301014, 0.007309229113161564, -0.04160815849900246, -0.05402979254722595, 0.0335453525185585, -0.012101774103939533, -0.05056093633174896, 0.06036744639277458, -0.06321702897548676, 0.04345254600048065, 0.022565355524420738, 0.05408386513590813, 0.004758741240948439, -0.055095769464969635, -0.015722988173365593, 0.012254456989467144, -0.012925824150443077, 0.03797028586268425, -0.04459559544920921, 0.03728346526622772, -0.04554453492164612, 0.008625638671219349, -0.030034737661480904, -0.027027906849980354, -0.009445792064070702, -0.025195853784680367, -0.013432186096906662, -0.06086929142475128, 0.015897978097200394, -0.012174107134342194, -0.00477289455011487, -0.018411146476864815, 0.026335882022976875, -0.01449571643024683, 0.020508132874965668, -0.021993866190314293, 0.024930711835622787, 0.059276144951581955, 0.03074430115520954, 0.009940414689481258, 0.027721120044589043, -0.007107371464371681, -0.010320973582565784, -0.00727964797988534, 0.03599715977907181, -0.029608113691210747, 0.021003402769565582, -0.019502170383930206, 0.0053621563129127026, 0.03763304650783539, -0.01836126297712326, -0.0024100011214613914, 0.004128826782107353, 0.01759103126823902, 0.006801224313676357, -0.047677554190158844, -0.02120700292289257, -0.026310406625270844, 0.01605474017560482, -0.05741678550839424, -0.027016403153538704, -0.01487871166318655, -0.020407570526003838, 0.04832696169614792, -0.017747381702065468, 0.020829645916819572, 0.01352541334927082, 0.05363323166966438, 0.0023919125087559223, 0.03988581895828247, -0.003797974670305848, 0.0035622590221464634, 0.024761909618973732, 0.018050584942102432, -0.003946076147258282, 0.0416528582572937, -0.028689507395029068, -0.03747730702161789, -0.012817499227821827, -0.058616895228624344, -0.019519543275237083, 0.054502375423908234, -0.01032655406743288, 0.06473616510629654, 0.007496617268770933, 0.004176717717200518, 0.014889393001794815, -0.028242608532309532, -0.027305549010634422, 0.0009210879215970635, 0.043871164321899414, 0.04245435446500778, -0.02717365138232708, 0.01807250827550888, 0.033856283873319626, -0.021733343601226807, 0.037090856581926346, 0.0556289441883564, 0.005005420185625553, 0.02219177782535553, 0.01908213458955288, -0.010860072448849678, -0.00897926650941372, 0.026052899658679962, -0.022104891017079353, 0.037683259695768356, -0.037367552518844604, -0.031369179487228394, 0.051305223256349564, 0.014281563460826874, -0.013321499340236187, -0.053535137325525284, -0.0024690621066838503, -0.020715540274977684, 0.022936910390853882, 0.05792314186692238, -0.01474019419401884, 0.017145853489637375, 0.018936114385724068, 0.027313221246004105, -0.025846054777503014, 0.032574985176324844, -0.03997249901294708, -0.08172844350337982, -0.028335614129900932, -0.028546560555696487, 0.00224431068636477, 0.02556476555764675, 0.011197271756827831, -0.007228475529700518, -0.01424378901720047, -0.03271409869194031, 0.03701653331518173, -0.00036006912705488503, 0.02177479676902294, -0.024077095091342926, 0.09022609889507294, -0.010412297211587429, 0.03991644084453583, -0.03574635833501816, -0.009492620825767517, 0.10887201875448227, 0.08281034976243973, 0.06958752870559692, -0.05789761617779732, 0.025378715246915817, -0.008122049272060394, 0.0033938486594706774, -0.03030705824494362, 0.028581148013472557, 0.017520472407341003, -0.012104110792279243, 0.028552712872624397, 0.047229863703250885, -0.006420135498046875, 0.01143142580986023, 0.04763643071055412, -0.030754081904888153, -0.025699937716126442, -0.002646557055413723, 0.016252221539616585, -0.0482272244989872, -0.017717517912387848, -0.05658133700489998, 0.013086422346532345, -0.019816679880023003, -0.04277869313955307, -0.04498964548110962, 0.013524714857339859, -0.004038846120238304, 0.014551350846886635, 0.02019461803138256, -0.02948559820652008, -0.005806353408843279, -0.012667831964790821, 0.0455414354801178, -0.03104456700384617, 0.028959497809410095, -0.014738967642188072, 0.004256413318216801, 0.030940089374780655, 0.0061290208250284195, -0.0012045293115079403, -0.013507669791579247, 0.008921567350625992, -0.046437863260507584, -0.017553754150867462, -0.015060671605169773, 0.06522055715322495, -0.024300148710608482, 0.03199014440178871, 0.0014813544694334269, 0.013673665001988411, 0.0014010992599651217, -0.022663608193397522, -0.0019367753993719816, 0.03256708011031151, 0.02910432405769825, 0.011103623546659946, 0.028521860018372536, -0.011066323146224022, 0.041440699249506, -0.002447708509862423, 0.04433336481451988, 0.015970323234796524, -0.0012301704846322536, -0.032630834728479385, -0.033133614808321, 0.04231772571802139, -0.029094180092215538, -0.00576979061588645, 0.008251895196735859, -0.019696684554219246, -0.03809657692909241, -0.021256059408187866, 0.03366817906498909, -0.02315286360681057, -0.0014241375029087067, -0.013303270563483238, 0.022297421470284462, 0.0005479843239299953, -0.02438340149819851, 0.02211681380867958, -0.029944168403744698, -0.018033623695373535, -0.031002577394247055, 0.025960156694054604, 0.06986197084188461, 0.04933874309062958, 0.02214895375072956, 0.013972287997603416, -0.02578810416162014, 0.041375067085027695, 0.02553362026810646, -0.06608951836824417, -0.03767079859972, 0.009011728689074516, -0.02839517779648304, 0.001835623406805098, -0.005208759568631649, 0.03677074983716011, 0.04392485320568085, 0.052919596433639526, -0.0063921744003891945, 0.04243696853518486, -0.023200515657663345, 0.024901019409298897, -0.02080276608467102, -0.05631951987743378, 0.006673507392406464, -0.022693118080496788, 0.03261034935712814, -0.015267946757376194, 0.015057559125125408, 0.020552031695842743, -0.03822648152709007, 0.019684989005327225, -0.02324903942644596, -0.03072921186685562, 0.02493947185575962, 0.027254031971096992, 0.013473556376993656, -0.02968912571668625, 0.046217482537031174, 0.03252739831805229, -0.003405354218557477, -0.025562437251210213, -0.02061997540295124, -0.017776548862457275, 0.03227289766073227, -0.04036631062626839, -0.0008302968926727772, 0.01801486313343048, -0.012437717989087105, 0.05460934713482857, 0.010283681564033031, 0.030237752944231033, 0.004545588046312332, 0.032580889761447906, -0.0007713050581514835, -0.026307210326194763, 0.01596200279891491, -0.04850573465228081, -0.024143453687429428, -0.015052063390612602, 0.037483129650354385, 0.021741358563303947, -0.01079536136239767, -0.01306554488837719, 0.0035638376139104366, 0.05142419785261154, -0.029182959347963333, -0.020951785147190094, -0.007250719238072634, -0.011549551039934158, -0.005283633712679148, 0.003355831140652299, 0.002455194015055895, 0.01574152521789074, 0.0010813260450959206, 0.008619404397904873, 0.0479535236954689, -0.0066028982400894165, -0.00790935754776001, 0.024645140394568443, -0.020995520055294037, 0.0010051059070974588, 0.008660314604640007, -0.0018955435371026397, 0.014854978770017624, 0.03833063691854477, 0.0011667166836559772, 0.05600246414542198, -0.0056518446654081345, -0.010479879565536976, -0.1045820489525795, -0.016255134716629982, 0.018259163945913315, 0.005155850201845169, 0.036376163363456726, -0.07100405544042587, 0.0235948096960783, 0.031419787555933, -0.01887137070298195, 0.006580405402928591, 0.011967373080551624, -0.017178718000650406, -0.009798487648367882, -0.006356082856655121, -0.028591567650437355, 0.03233825042843819, 0.007036769762635231, 0.03721759468317032, 0.05105194076895714, -0.007354082074016333, 0.02143155038356781, -0.003214397933334112, -0.008187202736735344, 0.005300145596265793, 0.027671847492456436, -0.06577581912279129, 0.034785736352205276, -0.018470745533704758, -0.021738242357969284, 0.027751704677939415, 0.050643373280763626, 0.017822619527578354, 0.0021828971803188324, 0.04329121485352516, 0.021373189985752106, 0.046470001339912415, 0.019185643643140793, 0.022656070068478584, -0.0074735102243721485, -0.00449340557679534, 0.024722637608647346, 0.0036455115769058466, -0.025026429444551468, -0.005534443538635969, 0.0102548124268651, -0.03569866344332695, -0.02007141336798668, 0.02932818979024887, -0.022497402504086494, -0.02245587483048439, -0.03243089094758034, -0.025763116776943207, 0.0023337299935519695, -0.03481356054544449, 0.008047313429415226, -0.06203727424144745, 0.02824002504348755, 0.08493516594171524, 0.0266304649412632, -0.021185850724577904, 0.043739475309848785, -0.010080402716994286, -0.038626328110694885, 0.0013898086035624146, -0.01854649744927883, -0.0011789785930886865, -0.062092069536447525, 0.01224553119391203, -0.006951016839593649, -0.011638938449323177, -0.005444538779556751, -0.005004843231290579, -0.02818329632282257, 0.027518387883901596, -0.013109911233186722, 0.012520498596131802, 0.008093373849987984, 0.0077572232112288475, -0.0029744745697826147, -0.05481288209557533, 0.08048678189516068, -0.025491010397672653, -0.03645699471235275, -0.04821586236357689, 0.009893922135233879, -0.05563727021217346, 0.0017147805774584413, 0.036567412316799164, -0.0011247523361817002, 0.0006274167681112885, 0.00026152387727051973, 0.04141868278384209, 0.027256309986114502, -0.055336687713861465, 0.028960078954696655, 0.001913060201331973, -0.05647409334778786, -0.006825570948421955, -0.014155463315546513, 0.06477390229701996, 0.04434644803404808, -0.014271277002990246, -0.024745795875787735, -0.010526658035814762, -0.02248617634177208, -0.0277902539819479, 0.011859873309731483, -0.012611902318894863, -0.016060637310147285, 0.03817989304661751, -0.02558600716292858, 0.010254552587866783, 0.03588089719414711, 0.021311059594154358, -0.02981659024953842, 0.011207269504666328, -0.029600679874420166, -0.06232861801981926, 0.023744381964206696, -0.008782323449850082, 0.013862610794603825, -0.07285072654485703, -0.022477800026535988, 0.017581574618816376, -0.04218947887420654, 0.019695622846484184, 0.05164998397231102, -0.0017785649979487062, 0.07454735040664673, -0.003903276054188609, -0.013602071441709995, -0.00039638130692765117, 0.016593478620052338, 0.037252277135849, -0.017047738656401634, 0.0007231953204609454, -0.03282403573393822, 0.0009810093324631453, 0.045447587966918945, -0.04210047423839569, 0.03821490332484245, -0.005317389965057373, 0.060276445001363754, -0.04545135423541069, -0.028163600713014603, 0.009620603173971176, -0.017712468281388283, 0.037937089800834656, -0.02735723927617073, -0.011747264303267002, 0.06132029369473457, -0.026320017874240875, -0.009019382297992706, -0.037071969360113144, 0.014907942153513432, -0.03790287673473358, 0.013329539448022842, -0.024729592725634575, 0.01954379491508007, 0.008952601812779903, 0.017711583524942398, 0.014335153624415398, -0.01989934593439102, 0.024314502254128456, -0.04088587313890457, 0.020374279469251633, 0.00034359630080871284, -0.01814209297299385, 0.004866245202720165, -0.0042116763070225716, -0.022496618330478668, -0.004440191201865673, -0.021312136203050613, 0.04808637872338295, 0.04013053700327873, -0.06054564192891121, 0.00846649520099163, 0.014685388654470444, 0.042142026126384735, -0.058059174567461014, 0.007946060970425606, -0.039994675666093826, 0.0003084204508922994, -0.011296605691313744, -0.009809239767491817 ]
<p>I am new to PCA and wanted to do a bit of experimentation on my data set just to see what it looked like (using R). I am not able to give access to the data here since it is confidential. However, if there is some other kind of statistic/visualization you would like to see that would help you answer my questions please let me know and I will provide it.</p> <p>I found the following information about the explained variance:</p> <pre><code>Component Prop.Var 1 0.911804348 2 0.033618098 3 0.020827269 4 0.011772988 5 0.006611746 6 0.005372772 7 0.004464788 8 0.003436401 9 0.002091589 </code></pre> <p>This raises the following questions:</p> <ol> <li>Am I justified in removing the other 8 principal components? </li> <li>How do I interpret 91% of explained variance on one component?</li> <li>If I only kept one component what would be the best way to visualize the data?</li> </ol> <p>Below is how the graph of the first two principal components looks. The spread of the data like this is not surprising given how little of the variance is on the second component.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/g9wXP.png" alt="Principal Components 1 and 2"></p> <p>As I mentioned, I am new to PCA so I really do not know if there is even any useful information to be found from this kind of dimensional reduction. Any insight would be appreciated.</p>
73,665
[ -0.012456509284675121, 0.03360487520694733, -0.0026919206138700247, -0.013348433189094067, 0.06473573297262192, -0.0142062958329916, -0.014602074399590492, -0.058271780610084534, 0.000036328892747405916, -0.07477905601263046, 0.024531524628400803, 0.03565270081162453, 0.05421707034111023, 0.05512115731835365, 0.004909218288958073, -0.011254461482167244, -0.024415548890829086, 0.009560385718941689, 0.0034474204294383526, 0.016374416649341583, -0.02568843588232994, -0.008618101477622986, 0.030396612361073494, 0.0004425777297001332, -0.013570374809205532, 0.07505176961421967, 0.02818581834435463, -0.01199738122522831, 0.016447195783257484, 0.03883939981460571, -0.030702384188771248, -0.009212461300194263, -0.0017723459750413895, 0.011285878717899323, 0.010085304267704487, -0.006093977950513363, -0.0028885258361697197, -0.02027890272438526, 0.00946207158267498, 0.06608900427818298, 0.0007637077942490578, -0.004994118586182594, 0.007126131560653448, 0.019089460372924805, -0.0008319943444803357, 0.006944695953279734, 0.012802367098629475, -0.006553534418344498, 0.060229793190956116, -0.04926702007651329, 0.09586592763662338, 0.02196214720606804, 0.03899659588932991, 0.028774021193385124, -0.012728694826364517, 0.010394028387963772, 0.03915989771485329, 0.06796883791685104, -0.021508030593395233, -0.07737911492586136, -0.01091792993247509, 0.005523079540580511, -0.011180074885487556, -0.0020630911458283663, -0.02953178994357586, 0.037673283368349075, -0.02090316265821457, -0.03254068270325661, 0.02913508750498295, -0.0056732720695436, 0.01756962202489376, 0.015071617439389229, 0.025602005422115326, -0.0059722778387367725, -0.0008913587080314755, -0.0038331225514411926, 0.025892123579978943, 0.022515486925840378, 0.03777757287025452, 0.028131013736128807, 0.013316166587173939, 0.014730674214661121, 0.018142396584153175, 0.017034847289323807, 0.018480561673641205, -0.0005646441713906825, 0.06934225559234619, -0.03605419769883156, 0.005336220376193523, 0.002494068816304207, -0.0004565772833302617, 0.02669922262430191, 0.03261163830757141, 0.04064977169036865, -0.053134992718696594, 0.01738748326897621, 0.01202391181141138, 0.05067697539925575, 0.0035336746368557215, -0.014624959789216518, -0.018091049045324326, -0.009020712226629257, 0.010874559171497822, 0.01615244522690773, -0.0035497290082275867, -0.014260181225836277, -0.0457165353000164, 0.034357693046331406, -0.01380656473338604, -0.04682043939828873, -0.01847299002110958, 0.00435771094635129, 0.017966194078326225, -0.01798984967172146, 0.02023164927959442, -0.021663052961230278, -0.01476033590734005, 0.01090752612799406, 0.04627695679664612, 0.07577474415302277, 0.024236999452114105, -0.004247021395713091, 0.021775241941213608, 0.008206170052289963, -0.05660988762974739, 0.0017842991510406137, 0.007106618955731392, -0.011757179163396358, -0.035156019032001495, 0.054806239902973175, -0.0217897966504097, -0.026319976896047592, 0.05544225126504898, -0.004361837171018124, 0.010209859348833561, 0.009205516427755356, -0.10561647266149521, -0.04478447511792183, 0.05174718424677849, -0.05411167070269585, 0.028853919357061386, -0.07439621537923813, -0.015285029076039791, 0.012001660652458668, 0.0445895716547966, -0.025132978335022926, 0.008198232389986515, -0.0003244380932301283, 0.027402104809880257, 0.006879585795104504, -0.043902844190597534, 0.008684485219419003, -0.026923267170786858, -0.025147169828414917, -0.024942150339484215, -0.07156994193792343, -0.00954807922244072, 0.057680077850818634, 0.004995598457753658, -0.016932819038629532, 0.01615159958600998, -0.01030260231345892, -0.00501320231705904, -0.016851143911480904, -0.031326595693826675, -0.022352369502186775, 0.07303277403116226, -0.020050421357154846, 0.019735869020223618, 0.008519359864294529, -0.016934171319007874, 0.017491677775979042, 0.01191161572933197, 0.05887288227677345, 0.05203299596905708, 0.019685721024870872, 0.008390136994421482, 0.008183220401406288, 0.011781918816268444, 0.010133271105587482, -0.062270209193229675, -0.03696179389953613, -0.032001692801713943, -0.014564190991222858, 0.030727000907063484, 0.05334997549653053, -0.02689179591834545, -0.05555357038974762, 0.04870710149407387, -0.038670655339956284, -0.07183439284563065, -0.08143781125545502, 0.007948163896799088, -0.004369074944406748, -0.04666281118988991, 0.008025356568396091, 0.023434173315763474, 0.013896851800382137, -0.00854008924216032, -0.009363016113638878, -0.03808033466339111, 0.002549206605181098, 0.024263495579361916, -0.020816024392843246, -0.0048670475371181965, 0.01747472770512104, 0.035092271864414215, -0.007695427630096674, 0.035155244171619415, -0.02916613221168518, -0.038401663303375244, 0.013270539231598377, -0.038414373993873596, 0.003957164939492941, -0.0056051951833069324, -0.013707134872674942, -0.0023469715379178524, 0.03992164880037308, -0.031693235039711, 0.017634499818086624, -0.05511503294110298, 0.056733570992946625, 0.04276139661669731, -0.012308712117373943, 0.0007562055252492428, -0.00042058705003000796, 0.015181249938905239, 0.003339288756251335, -0.017813755199313164, 0.02420583926141262, -0.0038163939025253057, -0.002561283065006137, 0.08108595013618469, 0.03740360960364342, -0.035512540489435196, 0.008738613687455654, 0.04469387233257294, 0.011611951515078545, 0.018845077604055405, 0.005880568642169237, 0.009848898276686668, -0.026706907898187637, -0.021892569959163666, 0.015744056552648544, -0.02244529128074646, 0.022181326523423195, 0.022284602746367455, -0.003522378159686923, 0.05642082542181015, 0.03260035067796707, 0.0030779470689594746, 0.05055202916264534, -0.020611772313714027, 0.013375579379498959, 0.005400583613663912, -0.006508572027087212, 0.08238135278224945, 0.02257300168275833, 0.013752564787864685, 0.040988266468048096, 0.027511559426784515, -0.008782865479588509, -0.002586157526820898, -0.01848244108259678, 0.00817048829048872, 0.03948080167174339, -0.039543021470308304, -0.006721227429807186, 0.00042542917071841657, -0.014914311468601227, 0.02821446768939495, -0.05344492569565773, -0.007054014131426811, -0.039422377943992615, 0.033422522246837616, 0.06869574636220932, 0.005653819069266319, 0.025878790766000748, -0.04670248180627823, -0.04410567134618759, 0.004562028683722019, -0.022427521646022797, 0.02074958197772503, 0.02243817411363125, -0.06115521118044853, -0.004396787844598293, -0.030522484332323074, 0.01606312021613121, 0.007756377570331097, -0.010535183362662792, -0.026543060317635536, 0.030766353011131287, -0.013070579618215561, -0.042868200689554214, -0.026589972898364067, -0.022449055686593056, 0.05322594568133354, -0.026853037998080254, -0.044852275401353836, 0.00640932098031044, -0.0027546328492462635, 0.02168860100209713, -0.021284880116581917, -0.023413505405187607, -0.018466144800186157, 0.016940603032708168, -0.006064076442271471, 0.02873723953962326, 0.01843581534922123, -0.036504004150629044, 0.04425458610057831, -0.03392619639635086, -0.01237706933170557, -0.04652520269155502, -0.05890468880534172, -0.0028965496458113194, 0.03179900348186493, 0.00854610837996006, 0.0010890125995501876, -0.05673539265990257, 0.0814376100897789, 0.025631530210375786, -0.01173511054366827, -0.044139474630355835, -0.00043347530299797654, -0.05178321152925491, -0.027521442621946335, 0.02562817558646202, 0.015185643918812275, 0.019351057708263397, 0.03215651959180832, -0.024865329265594482, 0.037921518087387085, 0.0396442674100399, 0.006968112196773291, -0.013137747533619404, 0.01962209865450859, -0.021680323407053947, -0.020290955901145935, 0.02083141915500164, 0.019141338765621185, -0.021120743826031685, 0.020863723009824753, 0.007650819607079029, 0.03800949454307556, 0.013352255336940289, -0.0365852527320385, 0.01894444040954113, -0.02245369553565979, 0.05023274943232536, -0.03883689269423485, 0.00046597199980169535, 0.019422534853219986, -0.010581822134554386, 0.003138968488201499, -0.008313044905662537, 0.04571930691599846, -0.03884817287325859, 0.00853445753455162, 0.06767221540212631, 0.000010962906344502699, 0.023487264290452003, 0.000954741146415472, 0.0017254850827157497, -0.007837533950805664, 0.04029117524623871, 0.0013859864557161927, -0.006786217913031578, 0.06254497915506363, 0.03570491820573807, 0.05681423470377922, 0.0054849060252308846, -0.050526995211839676, 0.0494115836918354, -0.062397245317697525, 0.039315540343523026, -0.019924163818359375, 0.02248464524745941, -0.0021997825242578983, 0.03841990977525711, 0.013700062409043312, 0.002285637194290757, -0.01842615194618702, -0.009783484041690826, -0.08000839501619339, 0.0036158906295895576, 0.0066900793462991714, 0.007005997933447361, -0.00444674352183938, -0.0013314533280208707, 0.029921075329184532, -0.014087286777794361, 0.026233892887830734, 0.026539204642176628, 0.017669545486569405, -0.038948871195316315, -0.007532418239861727, -0.006230168975889683, 0.021647140383720398, -0.04232119396328926, 0.010750683024525642, 0.031394943594932556, -0.022198671475052834, 0.044319283217191696, 0.03354916721582413, -0.032955363392829895, -0.014563340693712234, -0.028788557276129723, -0.028842400759458542, 0.027803974226117134, 0.016393035650253296, 0.004610338248312473, 0.01844547688961029, -0.006815608125180006, 0.007724761962890625, -0.00741485645994544, 0.053943365812301636, 0.01782412827014923, 0.016386741772294044, 0.01705087162554264, -0.012492221780121326, -0.01593448780477047, -0.028007911518216133, 0.025897612795233727, -0.0167064405977726, 0.010751633904874325, 0.027371324598789215, 0.050836384296417236, -0.04251346364617348, 0.01487058587372303, 0.06943605840206146, 0.03471128270030022, 0.021404266357421875, -0.04239628091454506, -0.010744526982307434, -0.012978474609553814, 0.0035433636512607336, 0.037389256060123444, 0.002739136340096593, -0.01675078645348549, -0.02445579133927822, 0.035856280475854874, -0.025038475170731544, -0.03247025981545448, 0.0010435694130137563, 0.021741587668657303, 0.053174570202827454, 0.011235103011131287, 0.006152509246021509, 0.027868328616023064, 0.043824367225170135, 0.049395278096199036, -0.00240341923199594, -0.01533739548176527, -0.05481010675430298, -0.0020803306251764297, 0.04542304575443268, 0.04384118691086769, -0.027832062914967537, -0.014539281837642193, -0.010429219342768192, -0.017739007249474525, 0.03148450329899788, -0.035489119589328766, 0.025021182373166084, 0.00867033563554287, -0.009360132738947868, -0.043009109795093536, -0.014930563978850842, -0.044957976788282394, -0.0035549388267099857, -0.03418372571468353, 0.020910676568746567, -0.018214726820588112, -0.05122671648859978, -0.04056604206562042, 0.034325771033763885, -0.015945227816700935, 0.06510551273822784, -0.004670820198953152, -0.003787882858887315, 0.0024592382833361626, 0.012161612510681152, -0.02332032285630703, -0.0835246816277504, 0.028081847354769707, 0.011672073975205421, -0.02363261952996254, 0.07870177179574966, -0.021729661151766777, -0.04840872436761856, 0.005981208756566048, 0.016431955620646477, 0.01005527749657631, -0.005643023643642664, -0.023530950769782066, 0.03106463886797428, 0.042398497462272644, -0.03256738558411598, 0.06153354048728943, 0.0012377516832202673, -0.007067275233566761, -0.003336708527058363, -0.04979058355093002, 0.02432546578347683, -0.010734227485954762, -0.0170290507376194, -0.0360330268740654, -0.00016468176909256727, -0.002938989084213972, 0.037545666098594666, 0.006553799379616976, 0.0556022934615612, -0.027621440589427948, -0.007701140828430653, 0.013596379198133945, 0.04263124242424965, 0.004156000446528196, -0.003262594109401107, 0.007040263153612614, 0.02991996891796589, -0.03039577230811119, -0.005698608700186014, 0.003408716293051839, -0.007281981408596039, -0.00804804265499115, 0.040447790175676346, -0.017094071954488754, 0.004598993808031082, -0.039290912449359894, -0.01795690692961216, -0.0017427958082407713, -0.05267467349767685, 0.03436041995882988, -0.02039027400314808, 0.0414775013923645, 0.030589492991566658, -0.06050250306725502, -0.02218080312013626, 0.02017476223409176, -0.013123362325131893, 0.055700019001960754, -0.0456879623234272, 0.06713458150625229, -0.04536930471658707, -0.005483037326484919, -0.06247376650571823, -0.06373874098062515, -0.011178819462656975, 0.0371989831328392, -0.03055531159043312, -0.024337580427527428, -0.04762796312570572, 0.0017811732832342386, -0.02538176067173481, -0.0013676164671778679, 0.03277868777513504, -0.039869554340839386, 0.020438669249415398, 0.009633222594857216, 0.016422118991613388, 0.09906423836946487, -0.04513799399137497, -0.01723167672753334, 0.00474911043420434, -0.06171078607439995, -0.0137998191639781, -0.003588608466088772, 0.03675147145986557, -0.018198007717728615, -0.006158528849482536, -0.05806637927889824, 0.026898764073848724, 0.05690743029117584, -0.009158194065093994, -0.0006363578722812235, -0.011652834713459015, 0.02739546075463295, 0.006567731965333223, -0.030584968626499176, -0.020634451881051064, -0.008033414371311665, 0.020403029397130013, 0.0031812458764761686, 0.01571766845881939, -0.01972070150077343, -0.02117043174803257, 0.01095937192440033, 0.017339129000902176, -0.03089703992009163, 0.02419489435851574, 0.05209238827228546, -0.039566200226545334, 0.011121809482574463, -0.027327625080943108, -0.02391730062663555, 0.008378338068723679, 0.035628512501716614, 0.009970943443477154, 0.017171144485473633, -0.0034782385919243097, -0.026087068021297455, -0.03840978816151619, -0.046383634209632874, 0.005383318290114403, 0.07171620428562164, 0.012837106361985207, 0.013736915774643421, 0.059149883687496185, -0.008134512230753899, 0.022966857999563217, -0.029974132776260376, 0.005184626672416925, 0.00441704923287034, 0.03406098484992981, 0.03769393637776375, -0.024203700944781303, -0.03287171199917793, 0.026810502633452415, 0.02948400191962719, 0.002432632725685835, 0.046830251812934875, 0.016130005940794945, -0.0041320896707475185, 0.01965557225048542, -0.0009653696906752884, -0.04625529423356056, 0.002292484510689974, -0.03655833378434181, 0.01695455238223076, -0.048284515738487244, -0.019578371196985245, 0.05749642476439476, 0.037941984832286835, -0.012779893353581429, -0.04512428492307663, -0.024522369727492332, -0.03131745383143425, -0.011954105459153652, 0.022332552820444107, 0.021366648375988007, 0.03098449669778347, -0.05330151692032814, 0.08087966591119766, 0.006352183874696493, 0.05617259815335274, -0.02926880307495594, -0.0729929506778717, -0.052128806710243225, 0.03609300032258034, -0.012466820888221264, 0.013830257579684258, -0.022498387843370438, -0.050971392542123795, 0.03409348800778389, -0.06989935785531998, 0.012126506306231022, -0.029614649713039398, 0.03795153647661209, 0.0014762660721316934, 0.06831739842891693, 0.01778641901910305, 0.017322130501270294, 0.010164777748286724, -0.02073170617222786, 0.09594987332820892, 0.07508669048547745, 0.018635423853993416, -0.06981606781482697, 0.03614838048815727, 0.025150619447231293, -0.007868803106248379, -0.03737347573041916, 0.019860997796058655, 0.005431986413896084, 0.018974576145410538, 0.031135866418480873, 0.04776255413889885, -0.0008038452942855656, -0.008717025630176067, 0.0286069605499506, -0.0012125663924962282, -0.0230749249458313, -0.00448091933503747, -0.001954062609001994, -0.014687641523778439, -0.032612450420856476, -0.08607882261276245, 0.013758203014731407, -0.009552320465445518, -0.012397154234349728, -0.022661345079541206, -0.009151733480393887, -0.024298788979649544, -0.020480947569012642, -0.0036516059190034866, 0.01980840414762497, 0.03286987543106079, 0.013432512059807777, -0.013584263622760773, 0.008915998972952366, 0.024053843691945076, -0.03164966404438019, 0.010384893976151943, 0.038513362407684326, -0.020241059362888336, -0.025307079777121544, 0.041916366666555405, 0.021428925916552544, -0.051081202924251556, -0.045127954334020615, -0.015518948435783386, 0.06776344776153564, -0.010843665339052677, 0.0005198481376282871, -0.019550353288650513, 0.0018995623104274273, -0.03434985131025314, -0.07260413467884064, -0.022137198597192764, 0.03149351105093956, 0.014686087146401405, 0.002335233148187399, 0.005413982551544905, -0.03918971121311188, -0.01330892276018858, -0.023457244038581848, 0.03857631981372833, -0.013607528991997242, 0.027178656309843063, -0.028815584257245064, -0.040407296270132065, 0.04791000485420227, 0.0129558639600873, 0.007316361181437969, -0.005880165379494429, -0.006237349938601255, 0.010956231504678726, -0.029838377609848976, 0.027382710948586464, 0.0009808948962017894, 0.013266164809465408, -0.007701616734266281, -0.009530450217425823, -0.008019207045435905, -0.04216764494776726, 0.017198700457811356, 0.0024967738427221775, -0.016841482371091843, -0.03807539865374565, -0.0041493624448776245, 0.015961283817887306, 0.025162454694509506, -0.01557515561580658, 0.008448830805718899, 0.01052733976393938, 0.07777465879917145, -0.011297246441245079, -0.04084162414073944, -0.038415390998125076, -0.001802134094759822, -0.013472511433064938, -0.015526489354670048, 0.004964143969118595, 0.07192422449588776, 0.029302280396223068, -0.024510687217116356, -0.002801351947709918, 0.03942755237221718, -0.013430680148303509, -0.020246602594852448, 0.0375555194914341, -0.052695393562316895, 0.03443203121423721, 0.011075198650360107, -0.005467017646878958, -0.039883553981781006, -0.013256849721074104, 0.0025914416182786226, -0.045817404985427856, -0.006452886387705803, 0.00662705022841692, -0.03120475448668003, -0.0008903490961529315, -0.008876349776983261, 0.005992030259221792, -0.03380358964204788, -0.015190714038908482, -0.044750772416591644, 0.0026442380622029305, -0.008291543461382389, -0.021270178258419037, 0.0031689980532974005, 0.027226533740758896, 0.006682439707219601, 0.016363007947802544, 0.05405222624540329, 0.032602034509181976, 0.053586747497320175, -0.04737777262926102, 0.011046327650547028, 0.004522702191025019, 0.036802493035793304, -0.03770328313112259, 0.006081919185817242, 0.06408423185348511, -0.04671866074204445, -0.024830829352140427, 0.018012918531894684, -0.003989741206169128, 0.05157443881034851, -0.012695064768195152, 0.003107732627540827, -0.043931715190410614, 0.03550786152482033, -0.01646430231630802, -0.013507557101547718, -0.019538771361112595, 0.026137692853808403, -0.024650080129504204, -0.012908597476780415, -0.000470073806354776, -0.00639019999653101, -0.007284951861947775, 0.03461790457367897, 0.053416017442941666, -0.015151869505643845, -0.04053451493382454, 0.0021216981112957, -0.02624070830643177, -0.0005922713899053633, 0.018187282606959343, -0.004377496428787708, 0.029012536630034447, 0.024336736649274826, -0.03313975781202316, 0.036213722079992294, -0.038705214858055115, 0.013621378690004349, -0.07627774029970169, -0.037048157304525375, -0.032194167375564575, 0.008242367766797543, 0.019046148285269737, -0.047887686640024185, 0.03093545325100422, 0.0412941500544548, -0.028874972835183144, 0.03230120614171028, 0.00620654970407486, -0.014073589816689491, -0.005389160476624966, 0.010025199502706528, -0.02753790095448494, 0.054664939641952515, 0.02464168332517147, 0.014472275041043758, 0.04446432739496231, 0.04732348024845123, -0.00007840702164685354, -0.04642796516418457, -0.0035608394537121058, 0.03533896058797836, -0.0010195677168667316, -0.07195048034191132, 0.03396736830472946, -0.018116183578968048, -0.02625414915382862, 0.02024080418050289, -0.03666430339217186, 0.03252419829368591, 0.03682459518313408, -0.009559317491948605, 0.007585856132209301, 0.0012670612195506692, 0.04178329557180405, -0.020479854196310043, -0.02360549382865429, -0.022825194522738457, 0.02834639884531498, 0.015560992062091827, 0.015615365467965603, 0.03632758930325508, 0.032402459532022476, -0.006109125446528196, 0.019198095425963402, -0.045295845717191696, -0.03378008306026459, -0.01093362271785736, -0.01726348139345646, -0.013612103648483753, -0.006014200858771801, -0.04205581545829773, 0.02415471524000168, -0.04264605790376663, -0.022823547944426537, 0.042655326426029205, 0.00985099095851183, -0.02225380577147007, 0.02603967860341072, -0.0010868229437619448, -0.04487244039773941, -0.014990301802754402, 0.004070410039275885, 0.007317226845771074, -0.060954656451940536, -0.02374744974076748, 0.012778326869010925, -0.019969526678323746, -0.00812495220452547, -0.023799464106559753, -0.010400530882179737, 0.019556226208806038, 0.007818980142474174, -0.002598882419988513, -0.00028758429107256234, -0.01638374850153923, 0.0035763238556683064, -0.09246892482042313, 0.04822685942053795, 0.0009877982083708048, -0.06169705465435982, -0.02896849252283573, 0.011332593858242035, -0.042412109673023224, 0.050476618111133575, 0.026342855766415596, 0.018741413950920105, 0.0229986272752285, -0.026044320315122604, 0.03825367987155914, 0.015706488862633705, -0.056505512446165085, 0.055860135704278946, 0.0005194185650907457, -0.009413013234734535, -0.00048588195932097733, -0.033158786594867706, 0.034971099346876144, 0.011123999021947384, 0.031018327921628952, 0.0009637713665142655, 0.0027390196919441223, 0.002926414366811514, -0.034690145403146744, 0.025289084762334824, -0.04704194515943527, -0.03185060992836952, 0.03135446831583977, 0.005141668953001499, -0.006275464314967394, 0.0377177968621254, -0.0018557569710537791, -0.021205492317676544, 0.004224812146276236, -0.022855615243315697, 0.00645670760422945, 0.003938187845051289, 0.011580877006053925, 0.026526285335421562, -0.08165927231311798, 0.021086756139993668, -0.0031960445921868086, -0.03867015242576599, 0.0010675926459953189, 0.030720826238393784, 0.013311445713043213, 0.01361000444740057, 0.022395558655261993, 0.018098674714565277, 0.008309688419103622, -0.025486089289188385, 0.02117929607629776, 0.012814341112971306, 0.013015855103731155, -0.0038687840569764376, -0.01246481854468584, 0.029224177822470665, -0.009627616964280605, 0.006222218740731478, -0.01994115300476551, 0.03802163153886795, -0.046330712735652924, 0.013602384366095066, 0.04976709187030792, -0.0197104774415493, 0.015241562388837337, -0.050428036600351334, -0.011030680499970913, 0.04492803290486336, -0.042395442724227905, -0.020291514694690704, -0.032079946249723434, -0.009094679728150368, -0.017341358587145805, -0.006268530618399382, 0.023422829806804657, 0.04764223471283913, 0.007098741363734007, 0.004344182554632425, -0.05289892479777336, -0.020082097500562668, 0.011819724924862385, -0.01573820225894451, 0.03796188905835152, -0.02297229692339897, -0.00029861429356969893, -0.00662453006953001, -0.0330696702003479, -0.01300875935703516, -0.00989870447665453, 0.032587841153144836, 0.030074721202254295, 0.017836518585681915, -0.03163891285657883, -0.034764211624860764, 0.0366193950176239, 0.04988698661327362, -0.04428539797663689, -0.01969507895410061, -0.0362415537238121, 0.003235254669561982, 0.0034791037905961275, 0.020578129217028618 ]
<p>$\newcommand{\E}{\mathrm{E}}$ I don't understand why Baum-Welch algorithm is an instantiation of EM algorithm.</p> <p>Indeed, why computing $\alpha_t(i)$ and $\beta_t(i)$ corresponds to Expectation step. Expectation step corresponds to compute expectation over the latent variable of log-likelihood of observed variable given the parameter: $\E_{Z|X,\theta^{t-1}}[L(X|\theta)]$. </p> <p>I don't understand the link. </p>
73,666
[ -0.025128815323114395, -0.016528410837054253, -0.005847346968948841, -0.04917382448911667, 0.021820688620209694, 0.008679767139256, -0.021507637575268745, -0.005369968246668577, 0.023274756968021393, -0.02446896582841873, 0.02541903220117092, 0.04044949263334274, 0.10679805278778076, 0.045330896973609924, 0.057454656809568405, 0.03689044713973999, 0.007900682277977467, 0.04555271938443184, -0.028599686920642853, 0.0006391712231561542, 0.010609209537506104, 0.044958434998989105, -0.003079095622524619, 0.016349561512470245, -0.009564511477947235, 0.03947756066918373, 0.020754409953951836, -0.0015881771687418222, -0.011140342801809311, 0.05105055123567581, -0.045744817703962326, -0.02315252274274826, 0.00381762464530766, 0.017558502033352852, -0.018001055344939232, -0.00891710352152586, -0.03860313072800636, -0.015336601994931698, 0.023180145770311356, 0.0203841719776392, -0.029097476974129677, -0.0335603728890419, -0.02337775193154812, 0.040161315351724625, -0.001945829251781106, 0.013338768854737282, -0.03705860301852226, -0.010802791453897953, -0.0060525271110236645, -0.036029089242219925, 0.07427127659320831, -0.033456288278102875, 0.0034224584233015776, 0.03223671391606331, 0.001624053344130516, -0.005437987856566906, 0.036008693277835846, 0.058766238391399384, 0.015384047292172909, -0.036648545414209366, -0.02111680805683136, 0.002411222318187356, 0.05284171178936958, -0.014518053270876408, -0.017663555219769478, 0.017025133594870567, 0.02926802821457386, -0.024190247058868408, 0.04205351695418358, 0.009079473093152046, -0.0033579692244529724, 0.043239619582891464, 0.033309709280729294, -0.03145333752036095, 0.027225583791732788, 0.0025777022819966078, -0.010930218733847141, 0.024420827627182007, 0.02821590006351471, 0.019878769293427467, 0.00874388124793768, -0.004510043654590845, 0.04746491089463234, 0.032915014773607254, -0.006672916933894157, -0.012519166804850101, 0.07506955415010452, -0.0437009297311306, -0.003914296627044678, -0.004763292148709297, -0.022609617561101913, 0.03665623068809509, 0.030681410804390907, -0.036660801619291306, -0.02047104761004448, 0.042390692979097366, -0.008245423436164856, 0.027509870007634163, 0.04220208525657654, -0.0196963082998991, 0.011988514102995396, -0.042895447462797165, 0.007140733767300844, 0.02211841754615307, -0.003658044384792447, 0.010528068989515305, -0.026278115808963776, 0.011114542372524738, -0.014560948126018047, -0.04854173958301544, -0.007669463288038969, 0.040905244648456573, -0.01574220135807991, 0.012311547994613647, -0.005384785123169422, -0.02564631775021553, -0.0024279658682644367, -0.01601436734199524, 0.05279242992401123, 0.037723589688539505, 0.02795569971203804, -0.03657862916588783, 0.005173115059733391, -0.04616682976484299, -0.07543618977069855, 0.005261846352368593, -0.008950367569923401, -0.062261827290058136, -0.047598544508218765, 0.04750671610236168, 0.0012422496220096946, -0.05324052274227142, 0.032387781888246536, 0.03538089990615845, -0.0010561024537310004, 0.00991731882095337, -0.08516927808523178, -0.0519263930618763, 0.045933909714221954, -0.0426592193543911, 0.02487623691558838, -0.04086628928780556, 0.030567873269319534, 0.032866138964891434, 0.032114457339048386, 0.01595214195549488, 0.05007429048418999, 0.01663977839052677, 0.032873909920454025, -0.006849188823252916, -0.05246950685977936, -0.03509185463190079, -0.027262596413493156, 0.0215254258364439, 0.0022053555585443974, -0.09898745268583298, 0.04496258124709129, 0.024513522163033485, -0.045629724860191345, 0.009049723856151104, 0.057983558624982834, 0.021198822185397148, -0.040837302803993225, -0.026501767337322235, -0.01224024873226881, -0.045443154871463776, 0.04893886670470238, 0.028638342395424843, 0.06108201667666435, 0.02900495007634163, -0.025797158479690552, 0.020837336778640747, -0.028457114472985268, 0.03182561695575714, 0.04220745712518692, -0.031106961891055107, -0.039315953850746155, -0.017776381224393845, 0.014971739612519741, 0.009522163309156895, -0.01854890212416649, -0.04218986630439758, 0.013717860914766788, -0.006102853920310736, 0.016155874356627464, 0.034850504249334335, 0.010761129669845104, -0.02903665602207184, 0.045718297362327576, -0.04071426019072533, -0.03267427533864975, -0.05216161906719208, 0.023249797523021698, -0.021313738077878952, -0.0030808295123279095, -0.00334699428640306, -0.02711188979446888, 0.005363009870052338, -0.0026654156390577555, -0.0033561529126018286, -0.020385758951306343, 0.016371028497815132, 0.007074151188135147, -0.036447323858737946, 0.009577016346156597, 0.04679176211357117, 0.04760337248444557, -0.01078506838530302, 0.041509609669446945, -0.057332705706357956, -0.05356955900788307, 0.01569773629307747, -0.014407414011657238, 0.0148242749273777, 0.011860559694468975, -0.05770852416753769, -0.00860317051410675, -0.01727759651839733, -0.029163986444473267, 0.02710552327334881, -0.04104992002248764, 0.03830267861485481, 0.07759701460599899, 0.015801096335053444, 0.024417167529463768, 0.04868339002132416, 0.050203658640384674, 0.024475404992699623, 0.013053127564489841, -0.004035827703773975, -0.03797728568315506, -0.020905405282974243, 0.019394049420952797, 0.009585677646100521, -0.03999803587794304, 0.039729516953229904, 0.009295381605625153, 0.02167573943734169, 0.017024442553520203, 0.054970625787973404, -0.007586811203509569, -0.01504593901336193, 0.014993984252214432, 0.022997230291366577, 0.00685968529433012, 0.022679828107357025, -0.0429275706410408, -0.023457253351807594, 0.04815696179866791, -0.03292891010642052, -0.010629920288920403, 0.01129823736846447, 0.012293522246181965, -0.0053259399719536304, -0.03230154141783714, -0.025200625881552696, 0.02899145893752575, -0.02925766259431839, 0.009498577564954758, -0.004864030051976442, -0.00877736322581768, 0.00038509213482029736, 0.002510207472369075, -0.01995052956044674, 0.01060451753437519, 0.041881263256073, -0.029657144099473953, -0.0035170740447938442, 0.02687847428023815, -0.019009599462151527, 0.04533179849386215, -0.03078790009021759, -0.04251311719417572, -0.019949590787291527, 0.050100505352020264, 0.03531792014837265, -0.0011683203047141433, 0.01064452063292265, -0.061826031655073166, -0.05829562619328499, 0.0008025197312235832, -0.02887141704559326, 0.031109878793358803, 0.029182275757193565, -0.015076996758580208, 0.010256950743496418, -0.04475969448685646, -0.011588172055780888, 0.02399463951587677, 0.008123346604406834, -0.003967018332332373, 0.012358298525214195, 0.026991911232471466, -0.048015233129262924, -0.0383659303188324, -0.007377428933978081, -0.007616809103637934, -0.0008894888451322913, -0.037282545119524, 0.045835498720407486, 0.028513438999652863, -0.002538101514801383, 0.027761952951550484, -0.06329571455717087, -0.03684114292263985, -0.04966314136981964, -0.035737376660108566, 0.00913918111473322, -0.0007590007153339684, 0.04428377375006676, 0.018958788365125656, -0.06469444930553436, 0.009404685348272324, -0.07434382289648056, -0.04491858929395676, 0.01987823285162449, -0.009455510415136814, 0.02816709131002426, 0.026895098388195038, -0.05029282718896866, 0.07260534912347794, 0.012850027531385422, -0.02747335471212864, -0.024871567264199257, 0.001222866354510188, -0.011701105162501335, -0.06185004860162735, 0.010636861436069012, 0.02347256988286972, -0.0182613767683506, 0.005192256532609463, -0.011610767804086208, 0.005657415371388197, 0.04648236557841301, 0.004490229766815901, 0.03596371412277222, 0.003915155306458473, 0.014059771783649921, -0.026523694396018982, 0.02980770915746689, -0.013442342169582844, 0.02440318651497364, 0.01811051368713379, 0.02065458707511425, 0.018743854016065598, 0.03157421573996544, -0.04180252552032471, 0.041173338890075684, -0.006824349984526634, 0.0014296097215265036, -0.07639431953430176, 0.0660000592470169, 0.016051556915044785, -0.06743604689836502, 0.010083677247166634, 0.0284398403018713, 0.011371246539056301, -0.0318559855222702, -0.037920981645584106, 0.02702610194683075, 0.022317683324217796, -0.05398818105459213, -0.0582733079791069, -0.019267231225967407, -0.027886785566806793, 0.0062626381404697895, -0.03951150178909302, 0.005509873386472464, 0.04412376135587692, 0.051681555807590485, 0.0009270764421671629, -0.019856631755828857, -0.04525744542479515, -0.06463980674743652, -0.029398376122117043, 0.035417281091213226, 0.006899965461343527, 0.06727774441242218, 0.014442246407270432, 0.07637681812047958, -0.010485116392374039, 0.01440148800611496, 0.019928842782974243, 0.0033802830148488283, -0.09261147677898407, -0.0005321684293448925, -0.03075522929430008, -0.016243651509284973, 0.0032748670782893896, 0.007210149895399809, 0.05378144234418869, -0.005460974294692278, -0.04103388637304306, -0.036170415580272675, 0.027476448565721512, -0.027961671352386475, 0.043237168341875076, -0.04089989513158798, -0.014830449596047401, -0.004721487406641245, 0.01120670698583126, 0.014601107686758041, -0.029872749000787735, 0.01772972382605076, 0.025861503556370735, -0.017586955800652504, 0.005331579130142927, 0.001279817777685821, -0.007254055235534906, 0.028310494497418404, 0.024525165557861328, 0.042475517839193344, 0.010460256598889828, -0.0353877991437912, 0.009253952652215958, 0.03372994810342789, 0.08258447796106339, 0.05539000406861305, -0.02867450751364231, -0.02446218952536583, -0.024422641843557358, -0.020966829732060432, 0.01763993874192238, 0.04093820974230766, 0.019209913909435272, 0.007219322491437197, 0.056514035910367966, 0.024386392906308174, 0.0072000399231910706, 0.0222291462123394, 0.057415351271629333, 0.020720509812235832, -0.004336277022957802, -0.03044794127345085, 0.0019635248463600874, -0.006924922112375498, 0.0026212106458842754, 0.002915334654971957, 0.0322827473282814, -0.0104359220713377, -0.015827670693397522, 0.03517374023795128, -0.02814726158976555, 0.028310416266322136, -0.0050014834851026535, 0.03351230546832085, 0.007195756770670414, 0.020921794697642326, -0.04613480716943741, -0.012221862562000751, 0.014902757480740547, 0.04133579134941101, -0.009251859970390797, 0.012810977175831795, -0.07366953790187836, 0.01909017190337181, 0.025673910975456238, 0.04001836106181145, -0.06337244808673859, 0.011110962368547916, -0.07268944382667542, 0.01267921645194292, 0.014517445117235184, -0.034730613231658936, 0.035967838019132614, -0.04766463488340378, 0.0008309763506986201, -0.025091547518968582, -0.026222670450806618, -0.02154664322733879, 0.025266319513320923, 0.03645307198166847, 0.036028023809194565, -0.023106222972273827, -0.01087193749845028, -0.03313590586185455, -0.0263681523501873, 0.0019692769274115562, 0.04566933959722519, -0.015581874176859856, -0.016461383551359177, 0.01932789571583271, 0.03875872492790222, -0.03845920041203499, -0.06358731538057327, -0.017394933849573135, 0.011656786315143108, -0.015680843964219093, -0.008626497350633144, -0.04815182834863663, -0.060668911784887314, 0.017417732626199722, 0.008252877742052078, -0.005447493866086006, -0.022775588557124138, -0.0014250843087211251, 0.05837452784180641, 0.044672805815935135, -0.01912127062678337, 0.061507515609264374, -0.004331507720053196, -0.03029973991215229, 0.005929074250161648, -0.027850616723299026, 0.014187049120664597, -0.014544757083058357, 0.013982397504150867, -0.05110669881105423, 0.019730277359485626, -0.009025813080370426, 0.046282313764095306, 0.016997072845697403, 0.006239491980522871, -0.03726164996623993, -0.009252548217773438, 0.002128852065652609, 0.038277845829725266, -0.043696533888578415, -0.02308151312172413, -0.00029926473507657647, 0.0405023992061615, -0.016041016206145287, -0.013150274753570557, 0.051032669842243195, -0.037883151322603226, 0.008703991770744324, 0.010191540233790874, 0.017481893301010132, -0.002582770539447665, -0.03803469240665436, -0.025050675496459007, 0.04588991031050682, -0.008501884527504444, 0.04859292507171631, -0.03730154037475586, -0.001678842818364501, 0.010641283355653286, -0.041436828672885895, -0.03051544353365898, -0.04008685052394867, -0.021022098138928413, 0.019578000530600548, -0.04478316381573677, 0.013653208501636982, 0.03769098222255707, -0.03379121795296669, -0.049628909677267075, -0.0363350585103035, 0.026790207251906395, -0.02696947380900383, -0.0030573231633752584, -0.03196629136800766, -0.025391938164830208, -0.02221490629017353, -0.04622446745634079, -0.022621190175414085, 0.07387018948793411, -0.005648852791637182, 0.00343963410705328, 0.003514176467433572, 0.046309638768434525, 0.05570390075445175, 0.04842212796211243, 0.015184266492724419, 0.03446519747376442, -0.016388582065701485, 0.005442528985440731, 0.01013386994600296, 0.03549095243215561, -0.013539737090468407, 0.0059448834508657455, 0.0011419847141951323, 0.0012500239536166191, 0.044786520302295685, -0.008304907940328121, -0.029157930985093117, 0.022962739691138268, 0.01617649756371975, -0.030908728018403053, -0.013209758326411247, -0.007856865413486958, 0.012313444167375565, 0.03428521379828453, 0.005734350997954607, -0.01641855016350746, -0.0026802902575582266, 0.00979354977607727, 0.04258672893047333, -0.02184530720114708, 0.013873857446014881, -0.00449925335124135, 0.08524470776319504, -0.04354560375213623, 0.033747006207704544, 0.02257571741938591, -0.006518308073282242, 0.007840829901397228, 0.0038151757325977087, 0.02511262148618698, 0.00364421377889812, -0.0012341176625341177, -0.024960368871688843, -0.014683546498417854, -0.05730420723557472, 0.043355271220207214, 0.04158299043774605, 0.018514368683099747, 0.03189424052834511, 0.023668387904763222, -0.005500984378159046, 0.010555251501500607, -0.026706958189606667, -0.004037228878587484, 0.009506224654614925, -0.02435125783085823, 0.026616698130965233, 0.00453091599047184, -0.01661146804690361, 0.04988308250904083, 0.005825544707477093, -0.01896558329463005, 0.02854650467634201, 0.018658742308616638, 0.011806442402303219, -0.009988303296267986, 0.015284617431461811, -0.020546143874526024, 0.05430326610803604, -0.03823721408843994, 0.0009296275675296783, -0.03376401588320732, -0.01881972700357437, 0.05371525511145592, 0.057799503207206726, 0.013572882860898972, -0.06968674808740616, 0.01202019676566124, -0.07390111684799194, 0.008678981103003025, -0.002021192805841565, -0.004373365081846714, 0.03052639029920101, -0.010530033148825169, 0.009785964153707027, -0.020194746553897858, 0.009673554450273514, -0.024576542899012566, -0.04766673594713211, -0.029264261946082115, -0.012529442086815834, -0.0519123338162899, 0.056403983384370804, -0.026485275477170944, -0.02423885464668274, -0.009782837703824043, -0.027863144874572754, 0.028758348897099495, -0.0022262067068368196, 0.027348967269062996, -0.010451444424688816, 0.05629243329167366, 0.014456257224082947, 0.04095011204481125, -0.012309848330914974, -0.028232114389538765, 0.12025909870862961, 0.04520086199045181, 0.04628172516822815, -0.057852402329444885, 0.008476926013827324, -0.026711028069257736, 0.0048042964190244675, -0.0040509640239179134, -0.013978928327560425, 0.012920070439577103, 0.006099896039813757, 0.0014555423986166716, 0.030753789469599724, 0.019844427704811096, -0.008100743405520916, 0.020489143207669258, -0.07532485574483871, -0.04386596754193306, 0.009548032656311989, -0.031270187348127365, -0.019762257114052773, 0.004850405268371105, -0.0223993007093668, -0.009338581934571266, -0.027174130082130432, -0.006620008032768965, 0.005520612932741642, -0.018689019605517387, 0.01563895121216774, -0.008670355193316936, -0.03364182263612747, -0.0015333452029153705, -0.015945162624120712, -0.03532923758029938, 0.005711185280233622, 0.025494489818811417, 0.00867579597979784, 0.006473643239587545, 0.029767543077468872, 0.03133681043982506, 0.034361764788627625, -0.009616700001060963, -0.0009259546059183776, 0.026360541582107544, -0.03125275671482086, -0.0050594075582921505, -0.029033103957772255, 0.07364700734615326, -0.03616977483034134, -0.004887702874839306, -0.015608510002493858, -0.03755795955657959, -0.005522473715245724, -0.045126739889383316, 0.010041045024991035, 0.013144412077963352, 0.0161797646433115, -0.037219684571027756, 0.010103540495038033, -0.060311492532491684, -0.012022015638649464, 0.007762220688164234, 0.04904384911060333, 0.029718324542045593, -0.07261636108160019, -0.0011018561199307442, -0.004367270041257143, 0.016477368772029877, -0.007521158084273338, -0.022115357220172882, -0.03298863768577576, -0.014162613078951836, -0.04447184503078461, -0.01755552366375923, 0.009487958624958992, -0.03257594630122185, 0.03534701094031334, -0.015861831605434418, 0.00021316896891221404, 0.0036482643336057663, -0.01643773354589939, -0.01716461032629013, 0.005170715041458607, -0.007018757052719593, -0.05529247224330902, 0.006273824255913496, 0.020085684955120087, 0.03732039034366608, 0.004372690338641405, 0.01136399619281292, -0.011526331305503845, 0.032973941415548325, -0.0018051218939945102, -0.03834839165210724, -0.044622521847486496, 0.02103334479033947, 0.0062245712615549564, 0.01840413361787796, 0.0012387860333546996, 0.035059571266174316, 0.021960075944662094, 0.008476043120026588, -0.054378658533096313, 0.042871225625276566, 0.0005364251555874944, -0.001379549503326416, -0.028160681948065758, -0.011478479951620102, -0.009523705579340458, 0.053508978337049484, -0.004158859606832266, -0.014878013171255589, 0.023952452465891838, -0.04254351928830147, -0.0066054887138307095, 0.0056495643220841885, -0.038132697343826294, -0.04831220954656601, 0.009961286559700966, -0.019877223297953606, 0.038044922053813934, -0.021830162033438683, -0.02926698327064514, -0.000418620475102216, 0.006490414030849934, -0.011264734901487827, 0.007715021725744009, -0.0024435860104858875, 0.013694324530661106, -0.0009906940395012498, -0.03406578302383423, 0.020983150228857994, 0.06398958712816238, 0.015676921233534813, 0.002991427667438984, 0.025956710800528526, -0.004693135619163513, 0.048422180116176605, -0.005712693557143211, -0.021228421479463577, 0.03176341578364372, -0.029313337057828903, -0.03576148673892021, 0.03864966705441475, 0.02903148904442787, 0.005018751602619886, 0.02857205644249916, -0.009317453019320965, -0.015212874859571457, -0.0025463139172643423, -0.03440145030617714, -0.017192864790558815, -0.024360960349440575, 0.003094505751505494, -0.02343723177909851, -0.012084326706826687, 0.01513873040676117, 0.007403678726404905, -0.003356299130246043, 0.024091679602861404, 0.023189976811408997, -0.003586831269785762, -0.03348536416888237, 0.04421432688832283, 0.03969813510775566, 0.04076099395751953, 0.027933234348893166, -0.023732604458928108, 0.04291711375117302, 0.0692645013332367, 0.002423245459794998, 0.05257201939821243, -0.013847989961504936, -0.010985341854393482, -0.06969135254621506, 0.011830783449113369, 0.016854792833328247, 0.009626280516386032, 0.05081620439887047, -0.0591115802526474, -0.0074056657031178474, 0.0109577476978302, -0.04862421005964279, -0.004034494981169701, 0.0014331135898828506, -0.019197870045900345, -0.002226420445367694, 0.01337355189025402, -0.015779035165905952, 0.04694866016507149, 0.01984242908656597, 0.0034728767350316048, 0.014603779651224613, 0.014511303044855595, 0.02608582004904747, -0.030305515974760056, -0.04716755822300911, 0.03015958145260811, 0.0038288873620331287, -0.06526970863342285, 0.06639806926250458, -0.04724614694714546, -0.01796463131904602, 0.01573205180466175, 0.04803675040602684, 0.008855875581502914, 0.0022745286114513874, 0.01628590188920498, 0.018163153901696205, 0.03271666541695595, 0.03863446041941643, -0.029233945533633232, -0.0060796672478318214, 0.03884131833910942, 0.011684795841574669, 0.03236909583210945, 0.00032843631925061345, -0.0020359810441732407, -0.0022457283921539783, 0.006624990608543158, -0.007944797165691853, 0.01969553716480732, 0.022885005921125412, -0.040535181760787964, -0.010741126723587513, -0.024792339652776718, -0.038085296750068665, -0.034826990216970444, 0.01452306192368269, -0.018475933000445366, -0.037748102098703384, 0.02860953100025654, 0.0196587722748518, -0.01316102221608162, 0.010907593183219433, 0.0039007735904306173, -0.062413908541202545, 0.010203994810581207, 0.0212881937623024, -0.004393308889120817, -0.061946846544742584, -0.01578885316848755, 0.018761444836854935, 0.007835141383111477, -0.012685474939644337, 0.010069730691611767, -0.06144043058156967, 0.03823589161038399, -0.006980433128774166, 0.033350620418787, 0.03118123859167099, 0.0001702607551123947, -0.0012316262582316995, -0.07016782462596893, 0.11452201008796692, -0.055450476706027985, -0.03568389639258385, -0.02506852149963379, -0.01203212421387434, -0.01761193387210369, 0.023281719535589218, 0.059633977711200714, 0.012580914422869682, -0.019558221101760864, -0.006854663603007793, 0.040980663150548935, 0.0029994307551532984, -0.05389896407723427, 0.038279905915260315, -0.010743921622633934, 0.0096068624407053, 0.013353056274354458, 0.01021048054099083, -0.00798757653683424, 0.03179357945919037, 0.006849296856671572, -0.038073644042015076, 0.0057157836854457855, -0.015469474717974663, 0.003934637643396854, 0.031247593462467194, 0.007973420433700085, -0.013912489637732506, 0.021961834281682968, -0.005123627372086048, 0.05498267337679863, 0.02147091180086136, -0.0070317648351192474, -0.052253179252147675, 0.03201824426651001, -0.056787461042404175, -0.0319037139415741, -0.011810985393822193, -0.012619730085134506, 0.024821965023875237, -0.030522191897034645, -0.03839869052171707, 0.036498818546533585, -0.02458077110350132, 0.027214348316192627, 0.03193943575024605, 0.004550579469650984, 0.044223956763744354, 0.020114297047257423, 0.04401474818587303, 0.02455044537782669, -0.02059970796108246, 0.010398980230093002, 0.031805865466594696, 0.03535851836204529, -0.02785925194621086, 0.02086324244737625, 0.018951648846268654, -0.01750374399125576, 0.019704028964042664, 0.008599143475294113, 0.003401583293452859, 0.0012224119855090976, -0.04916201904416084, 0.02257198467850685, -0.010320112109184265, -0.009626188315451145, -0.013643440790474415, -0.030676627531647682, 0.08065929263830185, -0.047113336622714996, 0.005497177597135305, 0.007816877216100693, 0.027117151767015457, -0.020484063774347305, 0.017901360988616943, 0.009172296151518822, 0.003267894499003887, 0.04612337797880173, 0.012928614392876625, 0.002212287625297904, -0.0020824135281145573, 0.01617399789392948, 0.0003610108979046345, 0.004193650558590889, 0.006747016683220863, -0.02874460071325302, -0.0051980833522975445, -0.05588458105921745, -0.02299507148563862, -0.03730079531669617, 0.01985625922679901, 0.026387594640254974, 0.03531242534518242, -0.014465999789536, -0.04241764545440674, -0.010727129876613617, 0.06573566049337387, -0.03534633293747902, 0.01432670745998621, -0.008606591261923313, 0.006475695408880711, 0.014117302373051643, -0.016959600150585175 ]
<p>I'm performing a web based a/b test where there is a control and one treatment. The results are not as simple as "converted" or "didn't convert." A user can "convert" anywhere between 0-10 times. I have all of the data from both the control and the treatment (how many times each user converted from both the control and the treatment). The sample sizes aren't the same size (about 1900 vs 2100) and the variances are different (7.12 vs 6.02). The mean of the treatment is about 11% higher than the control.</p> <p>The goal of the experiment is to find out if the treatment can increase converts per user. The numbers are showing an 11% increase in conversions per user. To find out if the result is statistically significant I've been trying to use a Welch's t test. When I use the equation for a Welch's t test found on <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welch%27s_t_test">this wikipedia page</a> I get the following results:</p> <pre><code>t-score: 2.26 degrees of freedom: 4025.82 </code></pre> <p>On the wikipedia page it says I can use a <code>t-distribution</code> to test the null hypothesis (my null hypothesis is that the means of the control and treatment are the same). But I'm not sure how to go about using a <code>t-distribution</code>. I'm guessing it has something to do with using a t distribution table.</p> <p>Questions:</p> <ul> <li>Is using a Welch's t test a good approach for this situation? <ul> <li>If not what other method would you suggest?</li> </ul></li> <li>With my results from the Welch's t test, how do I use a <code>t-distribution</code> to determine if I have a significant result and with how much confidence?</li> </ul>
36,094
[ -0.0438200943171978, -0.028792576864361763, -0.012801277451217175, -0.04076334461569786, 0.05855443701148033, 0.011526726186275482, -0.008204637095332146, 0.013881652615964413, 0.01533722598105669, -0.02634607069194317, 0.04638681560754776, 0.06003446504473686, 0.028816383332014084, 0.013157820329070091, 0.04892561584711075, 0.012296787463128567, -0.029626458883285522, 0.024240408092737198, -0.0029538304079324007, -0.006044055335223675, -0.013468684628605843, -0.025424135848879814, -0.021593812853097916, -0.029145801439881325, 0.011612721718847752, 0.0058080353774130344, 0.0043987673707306385, -0.03076912648975849, 0.0047166054137051105, 0.02770562283694744, -0.03558991849422455, -0.04005046561360359, 0.011271165683865547, 0.008957798592746258, 0.000521113455761224, 0.01837204582989216, -0.035525981336832047, -0.02651298977434635, 0.019969040527939796, 0.011765358969569206, 0.02276148833334446, 0.02364903874695301, -0.01010122336447239, 0.0491931177675724, 0.014649074524641037, 0.031082218512892723, -0.02354421839118004, -0.02231970801949501, 0.038028523325920105, -0.047018639743328094, 0.06025068461894989, 0.00782978255301714, 0.03323047608137131, 0.024663884192705154, 0.013193064369261265, -0.013791314326226711, 0.06489323824644089, 0.03559189662337303, -0.03237650543451309, -0.009480833075940609, -0.02543134242296219, -0.03911059722304344, -0.002153267851099372, -0.02544260397553444, -0.004457603674381971, 0.0023775894660502672, -0.0007287835469469428, -0.006611234042793512, 0.043379466980695724, -0.06932125240564346, 0.028134141117334366, 0.035311657935380936, 0.009223361499607563, 0.009190776385366917, -0.004612477030605078, -0.03906286135315895, 0.0650358498096466, -0.0010009797988459468, 0.04144734889268875, 0.06610038131475449, -0.005274979863315821, 0.017696641385555267, 0.021096983924508095, 0.039137694984674454, 0.031219976022839546, -0.016022447496652603, 0.03923627734184265, -0.011435898020863533, -0.008953463286161423, 0.029907235875725746, -0.03677096590399742, -0.025264253839850426, 0.06593842804431915, 0.008108994923532009, -0.05169972777366638, 0.02606268785893917, -0.004112528171390295, 0.03911245986819267, 0.02633173204958439, -0.015809236094355583, -0.014556244015693665, -0.036790940910577774, 0.029411567375063896, 0.029615046456456184, -0.04514756798744202, -0.033632516860961914, -0.028166526928544044, -0.029847484081983566, -0.02842392958700657, -0.02881477214396, -0.024892864748835564, -0.01701406016945839, 0.006082833278924227, -0.0039559719152748585, 0.020142681896686554, -0.03689367696642876, -0.005877157673239708, 0.004266512580215931, 0.09165021777153015, 0.030894707888364792, 0.09541554003953934, -0.004899401217699051, 0.01824866235256195, -0.035264525562524796, -0.025564879179000854, 0.003775493474677205, -0.023984888568520546, 0.0006158932810649276, -0.030159953981637955, 0.023599164560437202, -0.02259880118072033, -0.03452346846461296, 0.042236920446157455, -0.011611158028244972, 0.02474113181233406, -0.0020496565848588943, -0.06420263648033142, -0.05654512718319893, 0.0555206723511219, -0.016901174560189247, -0.011955992318689823, -0.06733956187963486, -0.003080870257690549, 0.03598743677139282, 0.03027508780360222, 0.013381519354879856, 0.0282705407589674, -0.0350351557135582, 0.02925976738333702, 0.017631404101848602, -0.034017618745565414, 0.011418020352721214, -0.02369404211640358, -0.019166788086295128, -0.022159283980727196, -0.04648016765713692, 0.0036999217700213194, 0.01871393620967865, -0.010808163322508335, -0.0036421632394194603, 0.03925493732094765, 0.004435487557202578, -0.012763937935233116, -0.0067735654301941395, 0.0017481299582868814, -0.01295597292482853, 0.06386109441518784, -0.009136054664850235, 0.029890215024352074, -0.00727874506264925, -0.04210621491074562, 0.00795928668230772, -0.006187824532389641, 0.021014751866459846, 0.0345020666718483, -0.01652715355157852, 0.0038947223220020533, -0.027438616380095482, 0.03008989430963993, -0.010939878411591053, -0.023707501590251923, -0.002045774133875966, -0.03695680946111679, -0.007071079220622778, 0.04935014992952347, 0.04539138823747635, -0.011415098793804646, -0.00017410735017620027, 0.05336945503950119, -0.04322435334324837, -0.061808545142412186, -0.040964897722005844, -0.018120480701327324, -0.012854690663516521, -0.012336170300841331, -0.02211061306297779, -0.005033716093748808, 0.015212664380669594, 0.028399748727679253, 0.026277154684066772, -0.009907207451760769, -0.009920584969222546, 0.032224155962467194, -0.009123475290834904, 0.008354065008461475, 0.03751534968614578, 0.06947252154350281, -0.023615054786205292, 0.048942189663648605, -0.013196819461882114, -0.021217474713921547, 0.0005951101775281131, -0.04008302465081215, 0.00801829807460308, 0.024714544415473938, -0.011639065109193325, -0.006244460120797157, 0.010031634010374546, -0.01937941461801529, 0.023114796727895737, -0.03522434085607529, 0.06894560158252716, 0.06494919210672379, -0.010889275930821896, 0.006720180623233318, 0.021377790719270706, -0.0007277975091710687, 0.018709149211645126, 0.00396536523476243, 0.0035233490634709597, -0.08124353736639023, -0.010472110472619534, 0.029863901436328888, -0.001748607843182981, -0.03896186500787735, 0.013749360106885433, 0.049781911075115204, 0.0021649361588060856, -0.02042987570166588, 0.04058007150888443, -0.019069429486989975, -0.0526779405772686, 0.002235248452052474, 0.02439330890774727, 0.022397499531507492, 0.044379282742738724, -0.0035347342491149902, 0.00045716087333858013, 0.020167609676718712, 0.032657139003276825, 0.01029936783015728, 0.016671976074576378, -0.02365279383957386, -0.022971991449594498, -0.02580851875245571, -0.013806981034576893, 0.03221304714679718, -0.011043536476790905, -0.018393676728010178, 0.04284288361668587, 0.005527071189135313, -0.019563550129532814, 0.006928545422852039, -0.023448584601283073, 0.032297685742378235, 0.015593425370752811, 0.01213756576180458, -0.021964311599731445, 0.012936994433403015, -0.027482306584715843, -0.016399351879954338, -0.016907382756471634, -0.024239784106612206, -0.04187435656785965, 0.0022369460202753544, -0.007781983818858862, 0.01621423289179802, 0.025103891268372536, -0.022917184978723526, -0.034063320606946945, 0.0015323275001719594, -0.02710816264152527, 0.01067523006349802, -0.044851627200841904, -0.07073328644037247, -0.0020358506590127945, -0.029720673337578773, -0.023776499554514885, 0.04905276373028755, -0.006137840449810028, -0.015961864963173866, 0.02882353775203228, 0.03448345512151718, -0.05455450341105461, -0.013297798112034798, -0.030464408919215202, 0.011047967709600925, 0.010116416029632092, -0.005550076719373465, 0.06848796457052231, 0.013253051787614822, -0.0452597439289093, 0.040934234857559204, -0.03398395702242851, -0.027507763355970383, -0.01873229630291462, 0.0018151822732761502, -0.004805783275514841, 0.014432201161980629, 0.03581221401691437, 0.011235040612518787, -0.009935012087225914, 0.0022497058380395174, -0.06898971647024155, -0.03262731805443764, 0.049281712621450424, 0.013821774162352085, 0.07459377497434616, -0.005545339547097683, -0.03573937714099884, 0.08948048204183578, 0.030323795974254608, -0.042599137872457504, -0.03756099194288254, -0.0050784992054104805, -0.031458780169487, -0.015869757160544395, 0.019678054377436638, 0.06029888242483139, -0.012791265733540058, 0.02153102494776249, 0.0005685522337444127, -0.006135128438472748, 0.05430770292878151, -0.0030448208563029766, 0.01736118644475937, 0.01819632388651371, 0.04458024725317955, -0.02218562364578247, 0.034896716475486755, -0.0003960025205742568, -0.027247551828622818, 0.03667902573943138, -0.0185483880341053, 0.03859703615307808, 0.015054663643240929, -0.037731822580099106, 0.012242387048900127, 0.0395161435008049, 0.01669388636946678, -0.05258181691169739, 0.02816818654537201, -0.005820069462060928, -0.03214192017912865, 0.008164948783814907, 0.050630178302526474, 0.019618337973952293, 0.0044248937629163265, 0.006009798962622881, 0.06691142171621323, 0.05314992740750313, -0.026443643495440483, -0.028308330103754997, -0.012770397588610649, -0.02345689944922924, -0.002029271563515067, -0.01694604940712452, -0.03266696259379387, 0.047114767134189606, 0.04830013960599899, 0.02011333778500557, 0.00847286731004715, -0.04714685678482056, -0.008358772844076157, -0.027044005692005157, 0.021853167563676834, -0.04999355971813202, 0.045477233827114105, -0.003895839909091592, 0.027772612869739532, 0.021285872906446457, 0.005279966630041599, 0.00523516908288002, -0.02316674031317234, -0.03241899609565735, 0.0577714629471302, -0.019778013229370117, -0.010086589492857456, 0.013590527698397636, 0.0004155378555878997, 0.034368470311164856, 0.01075043249875307, 0.007525940425693989, 0.0014780149795114994, 0.027912689372897148, -0.012724331580102444, 0.018877599388360977, 0.003912108950316906, 0.014661120250821114, -0.026033297181129456, 0.024821721017360687, -0.026415158063173294, 0.004736532922834158, 0.010222588665783405, 0.03100241906940937, -0.011860379949212074, 0.018564723432064056, -0.011028602719306946, 0.029066845774650574, 0.016021771356463432, 0.021177219226956367, 0.035271238535642624, 0.019560212269425392, -0.06642372906208038, -0.00009641166252549738, 0.005072108469903469, 0.02586604468524456, 0.04318314418196678, -0.013618627563118935, -0.047632403671741486, -0.041587334126234055, -0.016570424661040306, -0.007849715650081635, -0.0003923710610251874, 0.018168190494179726, 0.016980860382318497, 0.025436414405703545, 0.036379072815179825, -0.04765494912862778, 0.030581435188651085, 0.08814119547605515, 0.010075297206640244, 0.009416189976036549, -0.029422353953123093, 0.02558576688170433, 0.024450628086924553, 0.005897548981010914, 0.02361341193318367, 0.06391484290361404, 0.010439944453537464, 0.007356526330113411, 0.06041311100125313, -0.01919797621667385, -0.014431358315050602, 0.029680846258997917, 0.0073677897453308105, 0.04132167622447014, 0.03483215346932411, -0.03421913459897041, -0.005634637549519539, 0.03423486649990082, 0.03177611902356148, 0.00022285134764388204, -0.01823866181075573, -0.09508990496397018, -0.010713547468185425, 0.044239792972803116, 0.07313117384910583, -0.04679037258028984, 0.022450242191553116, -0.025457624346017838, -0.0033302188385277987, 0.035088613629341125, -0.057267528027296066, 0.028601132333278656, -0.02797568030655384, 0.020581144839525223, -0.021028539165854454, -0.0016644776333123446, -0.05245788395404816, 0.005187856033444405, -0.0786602795124054, 0.021320093423128128, -0.03140665218234062, -0.02330382727086544, -0.03232131898403168, -0.008767636492848396, 0.03564732149243355, 0.04738932102918625, -0.05232788994908333, -0.031996697187423706, 0.04049607366323471, -0.011244584806263447, -0.023008543998003006, -0.052015114575624466, -0.006440973840653896, 0.012928963638842106, 0.009378839284181595, 0.058596108108758926, -0.03005531057715416, 0.0031076206360012293, 0.009482611902058125, 0.02539985254406929, -0.0567563958466053, -0.007383162621408701, -0.005476136226207018, 0.014702758751809597, 0.029837941750884056, -0.01731642708182335, 0.06368672847747803, 0.02411508373916149, 0.016698462888598442, 0.008806394413113594, -0.03832516074180603, 0.0019760606810450554, -0.029199844226241112, 0.019318681210279465, -0.06929264217615128, 0.022626882418990135, 0.008367616683244705, 0.0313849002122879, -0.008698498830199242, -0.024201540276408195, -0.05479952692985535, 0.009975871071219444, 0.008839661255478859, 0.032722145318984985, 0.018067533150315285, -0.009367050603032112, 0.02545950561761856, 0.007355330977588892, 0.0033259650226682425, -0.05010606721043587, 0.009385771118104458, -0.03322163596749306, 0.014924276620149612, -0.0061936648562550545, -0.046894658356904984, 0.027928998693823814, -0.013125428929924965, -0.027453618124127388, -0.01691661961376667, -0.051566071808338165, 0.04207998514175415, 0.00896327756345272, 0.03567701578140259, 0.01533599104732275, 0.004557289183139801, -0.026084981858730316, 0.02927786111831665, 0.008887654170393944, 0.02764706127345562, -0.06586921215057373, 0.052029695361852646, 0.0037758403923362494, -0.013384480960667133, -0.04419423267245293, -0.01163182221353054, 0.05088355392217636, 0.022195085883140564, 0.008166168816387653, -0.02158978581428528, -0.040532827377319336, 0.0018839820986613631, -0.024420542642474174, -0.03238070011138916, -0.004490350838750601, -0.017933383584022522, -0.016974421218037605, 0.012547549791634083, 0.015227082185447216, 0.0780050978064537, 0.0263524167239666, -0.03474276140332222, 0.017587656155228615, -0.012723778374493122, -0.023808207362890244, 0.015270265750586987, -0.023184796795248985, -0.056359000504016876, -0.015728481113910675, -0.030930453911423683, 0.04041576385498047, 0.025502314791083336, -0.011296804994344711, -0.008248129859566689, -0.013752751052379608, -0.022385356947779655, 0.00522793410345912, -0.019433477893471718, 0.017317621037364006, -0.024635981768369675, 0.029796607792377472, -0.04398950934410095, 0.018127363175153732, -0.052242837846279144, 0.012101712636649609, 0.03088565170764923, -0.0038799364119768143, -0.03126902133226395, 0.023029739037156105, 0.06062022224068642, -0.019958170130848885, 0.016049323603510857, -0.02021900936961174, -0.0209763552993536, 0.03476712107658386, 0.025979751721024513, -0.027091434225440025, -0.013832740485668182, 0.015537877567112446, -0.05673379451036453, 0.008106917142868042, -0.0403001643717289, -0.02151387929916382, 0.06968958675861359, 0.0004049657436553389, 0.06798721104860306, 0.05950477346777916, 0.0063846530392766, 0.008182874880731106, -0.0009573629358783364, -0.006828196346759796, -0.02651854045689106, 0.03171191364526749, 0.022335831075906754, -0.0007918082410469651, -0.0301530621945858, 0.050612401217222214, 0.01180966105312109, 0.03813541680574417, 0.06597622483968735, 0.06123928725719452, -0.019720887765288353, 0.02311951480805874, -0.053466107696294785, -0.015935342758893967, 0.04495204985141754, -0.07301266491413116, 0.044899944216012955, -0.04592260718345642, 0.014637618325650692, 0.017839647829532623, 0.04660312458872795, 0.004120456520467997, -0.02857806533575058, -0.056930411607027054, -0.0671178475022316, 0.01750069484114647, 0.010105820372700691, -0.020940544083714485, 0.03753738850355148, -0.008885471150279045, 0.05437183380126953, -0.029750145971775055, 0.01591675542294979, -0.03835846111178398, -0.048333656042814255, -0.030073978006839752, -0.06346486508846283, -0.03539900854229927, 0.07500756531953812, 0.005359577480703592, -0.013439098373055458, -0.02247616834938526, -0.06041471287608147, 0.02167433872818947, -0.024147069081664085, 0.027559906244277954, 0.006361647509038448, 0.06503074616193771, -0.020871324464678764, 0.029694348573684692, -0.024274703115224838, -0.04597034305334091, 0.10759756714105606, 0.05710749700665474, 0.009104116819798946, -0.04788792133331299, -0.00452153105288744, 0.020350350067019463, 0.0049203201197087765, -0.02653316967189312, -0.009331072680652142, 0.026983045041561127, 0.01646888628602028, 0.03865955397486687, 0.03588128089904785, 0.054764341562986374, -0.03309381753206253, 0.05252164974808693, -0.021917350590229034, -0.04796016216278076, 0.011721857823431492, 0.004201884847134352, -0.01620202511548996, -0.06090223044157028, -0.05659600347280502, -0.028151145204901695, -0.005495106335729361, -0.013559523969888687, -0.027562754228711128, 0.007362717296928167, -0.046289701014757156, -0.01340444851666689, -0.0030048706103116274, -0.007455989718437195, 0.01420540176331997, 0.003758123842999339, -0.028162049129605293, -0.048707015812397, 0.03408126160502434, -0.017973583191633224, -0.01074274629354477, 0.09229753911495209, -0.017445271834731102, -0.03932841867208481, 0.013616066426038742, 0.027752533555030823, -0.0536123625934124, -0.018641207367181778, -0.0025052407290786505, 0.012209709733724594, 0.002116392133757472, -0.01365856546908617, -0.01689486764371395, 0.0007816067081876099, -0.01941010355949402, -0.02189377322793007, -0.013956088572740555, 0.02003544569015503, 0.00926156435161829, -0.023583682253956795, -0.01799676939845085, -0.033760469406843185, 0.008447959087789059, -0.023860041052103043, 0.011700290255248547, 0.04540549963712692, 0.006566009949892759, -0.01052982546389103, -0.014235378243029118, 0.04949783533811569, -0.018161814659833908, -0.010775348171591759, 0.009040063247084618, -0.046955544501543045, -0.02776401676237583, 0.004072595853358507, -0.008476020768284798, 0.005613092333078384, -0.010138706304132938, -0.008965141139924526, 0.030646249651908875, 0.00035550890606828034, -0.04474174976348877, 0.0178978368639946, -0.010866603814065456, -0.0071918172761797905, -0.02813567966222763, 0.006155379582196474, 0.026169944554567337, 0.03435523435473442, 0.0048963516019284725, -0.0005190722295083106, -0.007230149116367102, 0.023262644186615944, 0.023559244349598885, -0.05153732746839523, -0.02795596607029438, 0.04031124711036682, -0.016492776572704315, -0.0228399820625782, -0.014740102924406528, 0.07469846308231354, 0.06139339134097099, 0.0069929989986121655, 0.0007890372653491795, -0.05301490053534508, 0.0013415711000561714, -0.0034033062402158976, -0.005007309839129448, -0.04722403362393379, -0.02923225238919258, -0.006797424517571926, 0.016546104103326797, -0.02058492600917816, -0.02306635119020939, -0.055567942559719086, -0.01775418035686016, 0.022112473845481873, 0.011857014149427414, -0.012601853348314762, -0.008932297118008137, -0.027219999581575394, 0.000176774658029899, -0.030622687190771103, -0.013479040004312992, 0.0009266652050428092, -0.004206751007586718, 0.01440730132162571, 0.052260078489780426, -0.005417655687779188, 0.035217612981796265, -0.006750262342393398, 0.02082999423146248, 0.02545793168246746, 0.044024135917425156, 0.008424579165875912, 0.014221705496311188, -0.006260494235903025, 0.015814293175935745, 0.0624849796295166, 0.005408718716353178, -0.006759254727512598, 0.06184455752372742, -0.03302024304866791, -0.0033380151726305485, 0.03917420282959938, -0.012291371822357178, 0.016976749524474144, 0.003989014774560928, -0.03424515575170517, 0.0181038286536932, 0.027209240943193436, -0.02420516312122345, -0.008642587810754776, 0.012334996834397316, -0.03946281969547272, 0.028509680181741714, 0.004067585803568363, 0.02316233515739441, 0.026463428512215614, -0.021573815494775772, 0.04764050245285034, 0.06708534806966782, 0.025199171155691147, 0.021274948492646217, -0.02064809948205948, 0.022517165169119835, 0.01659003086388111, 0.005040094722062349, -0.015061129815876484, 0.007063472643494606, 0.06878182291984558, -0.021089475601911545, 0.017496153712272644, -0.029175253584980965, 0.024457385763525963, -0.08158697932958603, -0.020891079679131508, 0.027945024892687798, 0.006549861282110214, 0.06308005005121231, -0.059369493275880814, -0.018733028322458267, 0.01061718724668026, -0.06735958904027939, 0.008194194175302982, -0.002903279149904847, -0.03436408191919327, -0.06781993061304092, 0.00007205006113508716, -0.000011530184565344825, 0.04880582541227341, 0.008854767307639122, 0.05900172144174576, 0.028348522260785103, 0.04816875979304314, -0.01968703418970108, -0.015312744304537773, -0.03060145676136017, 0.018129907548427582, 0.009140281938016415, -0.06679652631282806, 0.03419753164052963, -0.007001666352152824, -0.053304847329854965, 0.021344274282455444, -0.019887171685695648, 0.05503596365451813, -0.03190850466489792, 0.021383432671427727, 0.01878311112523079, 0.05140208825469017, 0.05659307539463043, 0.007153840269893408, -0.013088539242744446, 0.011743088252842426, 0.018521271646022797, 0.04669424518942833, -0.02065296657383442, -0.010801557451486588, 0.019250573590397835, -0.01317600067704916, 0.020016733556985855, 0.021896667778491974, -0.032206229865550995, -0.01819848269224167, -0.01632254384458065, 0.0019359311554580927, 0.029301369562745094, -0.04859013855457306, -0.014038247056305408, -0.05026666447520256, -0.028385698795318604, 0.043492209166288376, 0.015006864443421364, 0.01524870190769434, 0.03282470256090164, -0.017672626301646233, -0.013098834082484245, 0.04118195176124573, -0.014526529237627983, -0.009365368634462357, -0.04308072105050087, -0.026057083159685135, -0.030371075496077538, 0.05424240604043007, 0.0007576266070827842, -0.0036388207226991653, -0.036685749888420105, 0.02139582857489586, -0.002672998933121562, -0.003965294454246759, 0.026314616203308105, -0.008671874180436134, 0.01812828704714775, -0.06202621012926102, 0.035133324563503265, -0.0020349975675344467, -0.01686139777302742, -0.026972347870469093, -0.018230421468615532, -0.038769740611314774, 0.016646703705191612, 0.053420037031173706, 0.021078379824757576, 0.0018841131823137403, -0.014399880543351173, -0.016633592545986176, -0.01708316244184971, -0.11185845732688904, 0.03158196806907654, -0.006341886706650257, -0.04545718431472778, -0.018187547102570534, -0.015733057633042336, -0.01007448136806488, 0.005741598550230265, 0.004167421255260706, -0.014889070764183998, -0.0009931637905538082, -0.009649609215557575, -0.034766439348459244, 0.04848223552107811, 0.0134259769693017, 0.012761205434799194, 0.036909203976392746, 0.022997112944722176, 0.025447089225053787, 0.009186021983623505, 0.007491080556064844, -0.024180099368095398, 0.046096764504909515, -0.04650971665978432, 0.00570254772901535, -0.019617130979895592, -0.0028774691745638847, -0.005918224807828665, -0.03928208723664284, 0.015712298452854156, 0.020993411540985107, -0.0012577750021591783, 0.002133178524672985, 0.0008422997198067605, 0.03405749052762985, 0.03360604867339134, -0.016096172854304314, 0.025614049285650253, 0.00029915987397544086, -0.012700989842414856, 0.018704932183027267, 0.024273715913295746, 0.010806407779455185, -0.05754728987812996, 0.016874093562364578, 0.04424610733985901, -0.03368040919303894, 0.005992874037474394, -0.00834796205163002, 0.023130197077989578, -0.03125014901161194, -0.014005737379193306, 0.015782538801431656, 0.006524389609694481, 0.003642320167273283, 0.04319982975721359, -0.03393426910042763, 0.042414937168359756, -0.042901698499917984, 0.01349702663719654, -0.006843085866421461, 0.012287597171962261, -0.014757088385522366, -0.016368020325899124, 0.017457012087106705, 0.006912782322615385, 0.0037464082706719637, 0.020907806232571602, -0.010328260250389576, -0.02488655038177967, -0.008480604737997055, 0.009941614232957363, 0.04321867227554321, -0.03712831065058708, -0.009966081008315086, -0.014902629889547825, 0.016511065885424614, -0.00988693255931139, -0.038615815341472626, -0.008955379948019981, 0.03436511009931564, 0.011953875422477722, -0.053056299686431885, -0.02764742448925972, 0.018367480486631393, 0.04074253514409065, -0.04281545430421829, -0.0392964743077755, -0.04697233438491821, 0.026311185210943222, 0.022574231028556824, -0.017564116045832634 ]
<p>I have a vector $v=(v_1,...,v_J)$, which is jointly normal. I then need to take the expectation of this vector. This should give me something like this:</p> <p>1)$$E(v)=(E(v_1),...,E(v_J))$$</p> <p>However, I want to write up the integral for this expectation, but I'm unsure how to do this. My guess is something like this: $$E(v)=\int v \phi(v)dv$$</p> <p>How does this relate to the expectation I have in 1)? $\phi(.)$ is the joint pdf, but to compute something like $(E(v_1),...,E(v_J))=$, I guess I need the marginal distribution: $$E(v_1,...,v_J)=(\int v_1 \phi(v_1),\int v_2 \phi(v_2),...,\int v_J \phi(v_J))$$ </p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,667
[ -0.022452259436249733, -0.03052475117146969, 0.005888231098651886, 0.005402157083153725, 0.017757151275873184, 0.04021814465522766, -0.011281520128250122, -0.0005077064852230251, 0.022978177294135094, -0.03387927636504173, 0.036386340856552124, 0.051408324390649796, 0.0795457735657692, 0.012130250222980976, 0.04960979148745537, 0.012135605327785015, -0.012580552138388157, -0.025371136143803596, -0.02001611888408661, -0.017707092687487602, -0.020881088450551033, 0.02158866822719574, 0.03921642154455185, -0.011887566186487675, 0.006683944724500179, 0.04666576907038689, 0.025312747806310654, -0.006741069257259369, 0.03868479281663895, 0.08344938606023788, -0.04981164261698723, -0.035320915281772614, 0.02529231645166874, 0.008131930604577065, -0.005791221279650927, 0.008068671450018883, -0.03972272202372551, -0.024834349751472473, 0.012096038088202477, 0.009791351854801178, -0.06865125149488449, 0.01623864844441414, 0.01419175323098898, 0.037645354866981506, -0.04314230754971504, 0.03205418586730957, 0.005161267705261707, -0.019137058407068253, 0.003598542418330908, -0.05587106570601463, 0.08102110028266907, 0.01953773759305477, 0.055489812046289444, 0.0387861430644989, 0.008143652230501175, 0.00022852544498164207, 0.024943485856056213, 0.06326510012149811, 0.027805408462882042, -0.06632739305496216, -0.012434699572622776, -0.03637320548295975, -0.02219892106950283, -0.045024655759334564, -0.00842329766601324, 0.02112867683172226, -0.02015214040875435, -0.03151307627558708, 0.013781013898551464, -0.01850699819624424, 0.016675593331456184, 0.05064597725868225, 0.046526551246643066, -0.05313188210129738, 0.019677449017763138, -0.006131493486464024, 0.026965603232383728, 0.033373646438121796, 0.015500146895647049, 0.026786495000123978, 0.0014877344947308302, 0.010751921683549881, 0.05312477424740791, 0.044412918388843536, 0.03188126161694527, -0.015763375908136368, 0.10330221056938171, -0.030669061467051506, 0.01101001724600792, 0.038484491407871246, -0.03282312676310539, 0.037949662655591965, 0.019747668877243996, -0.004049082286655903, -0.06619416177272797, 0.031271204352378845, -0.01956259086728096, 0.05577154457569122, -0.010205104947090149, -0.03128921613097191, -0.009155328385531902, -0.003843543119728565, 0.02125079743564129, 0.045301102101802826, -0.023631801828742027, -0.020003439858555794, -0.055691614747047424, -0.0016260044649243355, 0.008330225944519043, -0.012393057346343994, -0.015992041677236557, 0.05194652080535889, -0.013141926378011703, -0.002009174320846796, 0.01850765198469162, -0.011785520240664482, 0.020187990739941597, -0.006793583277612925, 0.04513105750083923, 0.05629453435540199, 0.05352580174803734, -0.04303383827209473, 0.02951090596616268, -0.023165378719568253, -0.059967752546072006, 0.015540800988674164, 0.011097307316958904, 0.015624605119228363, -0.04545458033680916, 0.04807073250412941, -0.026144754141569138, -0.005690596532076597, 0.003403505776077509, 0.005587810184806585, -0.005288823042064905, -0.048409704118967056, -0.07778026908636093, -0.04288798198103905, 0.012431911192834377, -0.04233873635530472, -0.004692572634667158, -0.060527704656124115, 0.025398433208465576, 0.027334047481417656, 0.03759590536355972, 0.004340422339737415, 0.047124914824962616, 0.002478699665516615, 0.024837058037519455, -0.011286349967122078, -0.029036778956651688, -0.035354603081941605, -0.03561810776591301, -0.014601476490497589, 0.013663159683346748, -0.08963076025247574, 0.03768429905176163, 0.010110180824995041, -0.017303531989455223, -0.009418540634214878, 0.06810945272445679, 0.013907152228057384, -0.004482293501496315, -0.01663752645254135, -0.004403764382004738, -0.027749085798859596, 0.05462350696325302, 0.012578186579048634, 0.011673328466713428, 0.0346117839217186, -0.004527971148490906, -0.007033533416688442, -0.014667335897684097, 0.06005822494626045, 0.07667424529790878, -0.02464267984032631, -0.014136150479316711, -0.03513689711689949, 0.04601246118545532, -0.01001745741814375, -0.00020246015628799796, -0.015787789598107338, -0.005833759438246489, 0.011558741331100464, 0.0033485167659819126, 0.024441206827759743, 0.02856471762061119, -0.03158532455563545, -0.02685030736029148, -0.013938138261437416, -0.030757499858736992, -0.06348045915365219, 0.01269992534071207, 0.004862937144935131, -0.045506831258535385, 0.027152525261044502, 0.017089929431676865, 0.05394146963953972, -0.007595567032694817, -0.02047768235206604, -0.025867514312267303, -0.005270255729556084, 0.036572184413671494, -0.04248281195759773, -0.0024635351728647947, 0.0365496501326561, 0.08671534806489944, 0.0007150561432354152, 0.04616899788379669, -0.002718336181715131, -0.042472805827856064, 0.005631929263472557, -0.020664667710661888, 0.022401852533221245, 0.023997973650693893, -0.007458786480128765, 0.021773595362901688, 0.0069801160134375095, 0.01698986440896988, -0.024774271994829178, -0.04191473498940468, 0.03396247699856758, 0.06755063682794571, -0.0006644395762123168, -0.030070334672927856, 0.020112160593271255, 0.00856566522270441, -0.0055296230129897594, -0.019703298807144165, -0.017226407304406166, -0.030402453616261482, 0.011521485634148121, 0.04550796374678612, 0.028132731094956398, -0.034586045891046524, 0.001408079289831221, 0.040296927094459534, 0.020108524709939957, 0.017231609672307968, 0.045403532683849335, 0.0010849693790078163, -0.01255792286247015, 0.025076640769839287, 0.024303188547492027, 0.00579208554700017, -0.005769370123744011, 0.00814422033727169, 0.02102653495967388, 0.03797983378171921, 0.014772027730941772, -0.026702266186475754, 0.0623011514544487, 0.008406425826251507, 0.02379121258854866, 0.00793109554797411, -0.00886007770895958, 0.04034481942653656, -0.013042686507105827, 0.009259029291570187, 0.02135789953172207, -0.0029427367262542248, -0.032780807465314865, 0.005557761061936617, -0.010871578007936478, 0.01844852603971958, 0.060523856431245804, -0.03036029450595379, 0.03292578086256981, 0.014455231837928295, -0.011474190279841423, 0.011997009627521038, -0.015957219526171684, -0.024907294660806656, -0.018999453634023666, -0.0010282463626936078, -0.0249419417232275, -0.007449182216078043, 0.005895825102925301, -0.01280918437987566, -0.04525863751769066, 0.027176154777407646, -0.02868036739528179, 0.030742641538381577, 0.019865330308675766, -0.04570593312382698, 0.0027938708662986755, -0.014880741015076637, -0.05789342522621155, 0.04226268455386162, -0.0009342224802821875, -0.009459528140723705, 0.027483489364385605, -0.016068963333964348, -0.07135839760303497, -0.008391959592700005, 0.0044480799697339535, 0.034129392355680466, -0.033141449093818665, -0.014279469847679138, 0.02426312305033207, 0.017268093302845955, -0.04380428418517113, 0.003908796701580286, -0.026544060558080673, -0.05198937654495239, -0.06463256478309631, 0.020119866356253624, 0.03717607632279396, 0.00986981950700283, 0.01519947312772274, 0.023984147235751152, -0.014993946067988873, -0.02417059987783432, -0.0953211709856987, -0.029616212472319603, 0.006384825333952904, 0.011922257021069527, 0.004725874867290258, 0.015608587302267551, -0.04077966511249542, 0.06131766363978386, 0.010919182561337948, -0.05055521801114082, -0.0013577697100117803, 0.014126710593700409, -0.009640449658036232, 0.001081254449672997, 0.03421521186828613, 0.018080024048686028, 0.0004279747372493148, 0.04577105864882469, -0.0033666477538645267, 0.004456378053873777, 0.027659453451633453, 0.02098979987204075, -0.006958864629268646, 0.029893625527620316, -0.024571187794208527, -0.02393431030213833, 0.04026994854211807, 0.004869137424975634, 0.005122276023030281, -0.014570275321602821, 0.02935122326016426, 0.028216633945703506, 0.01111521665006876, -0.02547222189605236, 0.04516919329762459, -0.00620980653911829, -0.0013038349570706487, -0.0754026398062706, 0.046582262963056564, 0.030390756204724312, -0.05372461676597595, 0.0326019823551178, 0.011955270543694496, 0.015870442613959312, -0.04657955467700958, 0.012311501428484917, 0.05250086262822151, 0.03949950262904167, -0.035949476063251495, -0.05066540464758873, -0.02955915778875351, 0.01462247222661972, 0.0008697571465745568, -0.028319789096713066, -0.02086114138364792, 0.031035957857966423, 0.02960851415991783, 0.00545726902782917, -0.02908795140683651, -0.019219938665628433, 0.01789248362183571, -0.04986408352851868, 0.021348562091588974, 0.010844184085726738, 0.03908901289105415, 0.013393294997513294, 0.06833387166261673, 0.007330236025154591, 0.022381361573934555, 0.043124426156282425, -0.010604015551507473, -0.10101041942834854, 0.027260737493634224, 0.0016600923845544457, -0.007131419610232115, -0.05144038796424866, -0.032455917447805405, 0.04532413184642792, -0.026423564180731773, -0.009026843123137951, -0.008071649819612503, 0.01163408625870943, -0.047746218740940094, -0.005038244649767876, -0.02301546186208725, -0.02464517392218113, 0.012793437577784061, 0.034350983798503876, 0.03840645030140877, -0.011828876100480556, 0.003082982962951064, 0.03718174993991852, 0.0091186398640275, -0.00887120608240366, -0.013827767223119736, -0.01152301300317049, 0.0225350521504879, 0.042524199932813644, 0.015355503186583519, 0.04871295392513275, 0.006598140578716993, 0.03486955538392067, -0.022635571658611298, 0.07869018614292145, 0.05920858308672905, -0.01995144784450531, -0.0015379866817966104, -0.026845186948776245, 0.014916691929101944, -0.03680337592959404, 0.04612189903855324, -0.023734075948596, 0.015079914592206478, 0.04364894703030586, 0.026442090049386024, -0.05764580890536308, 0.01603623852133751, 0.08118181675672531, 0.005132474470883608, -0.014283732511103153, -0.027128538116812706, 0.027097079902887344, -0.021595394238829613, -0.032956600189208984, -0.0003120415785815567, 0.0008351689903065562, -0.03653518855571747, -0.005662204697728157, 0.029479168355464935, -0.04634072631597519, 0.00401014881208539, -0.02813015691936016, 0.0002527671749703586, 0.019259730353951454, 0.028073325753211975, -0.06969405710697174, 0.014730504713952541, 0.04850413650274277, 0.020381037145853043, 0.0028330127242952585, 0.009615928865969181, -0.09367196261882782, 0.018324976786971092, 0.054757989943027496, 0.02314339578151703, -0.03316294774413109, -0.010794946923851967, -0.007042209152132273, 0.01579682156443596, 0.058654945343732834, -0.05110839009284973, -0.026421397924423218, -0.0133326081559062, -0.02334294281899929, -0.005868298001587391, -0.012079672887921333, -0.07286678999662399, 0.030646871775388718, -0.03670855611562729, 0.003693187376484275, -0.023126572370529175, -0.004782133270055056, -0.06619545817375183, 0.03535791113972664, 0.010684650391340256, 0.054914940148591995, -0.024625176563858986, -0.02746524289250374, -0.006311959121376276, 0.044057343155145645, 0.003446569200605154, -0.049714017659425735, 0.02079291082918644, 0.012951978482306004, -0.02477961592376232, 0.05144325643777847, -0.015184210613369942, -0.048290714621543884, 0.05055621266365051, -0.005191065836697817, 0.01662135310471058, 0.030984079465270042, -0.015040883794426918, 0.03356575965881348, 0.007650124374777079, 0.0276650357991457, 0.04155619442462921, 0.006601791828870773, -0.030442994087934494, 0.002923244144767523, -0.05586596950888634, 0.029753215610980988, -0.028791271150112152, -0.017394544556736946, -0.022264957427978516, 0.008614158257842064, -0.007783173117786646, 0.04528036341071129, -0.020220814272761345, 0.021719319745898247, -0.04195550084114075, -0.015546923503279686, -0.010162295773625374, 0.012198993936181068, 0.0032531621400266886, -0.01723616197705269, -0.004260972607880831, 0.0007012521382421255, 0.027377117425203323, -0.012689126655459404, 0.008354755118489265, 0.011964177712798119, -0.024822616949677467, -0.014178285375237465, -0.01510815229266882, 0.010375392623245716, -0.027003830298781395, -0.02486279606819153, 0.03126825764775276, -0.05207473784685135, 0.01792885735630989, -0.013977879658341408, 0.06110796332359314, 0.021353233605623245, -0.025071388110518456, -0.03367982059717178, 0.006174033973366022, 0.002523032482713461, 0.04108450189232826, -0.01922968588769436, 0.025082504376769066, -0.014273745007812977, 0.016038591042160988, -0.056015610694885254, -0.02890631929039955, 0.013579378835856915, -0.021836889907717705, -0.014433329924941063, -0.059574611485004425, 0.02907039411365986, -0.011924856342375278, -0.03764296695590019, 0.001332782907411456, 0.03364933654665947, -0.002402877202257514, -0.013783365488052368, -0.011006719432771206, 0.013318348675966263, 0.04775131866335869, 0.011055838316679, -0.00865519791841507, 0.04442286863923073, -0.02259971760213375, -0.03062298335134983, 0.007126298733055592, 0.011936872266232967, -0.029192371293902397, -0.0022154035978019238, -0.02332156151533127, -0.013538561761379242, 0.022052466869354248, -0.029972584918141365, 0.007387664634734392, 0.006902622990310192, 0.0012766692088916898, -0.013050615787506104, -0.01873772218823433, -0.021647224202752113, 0.026235172525048256, 0.0021709653083235025, -0.01599285751581192, -0.0039043393917381763, -0.013259517960250378, -0.011966384015977383, 0.030179722234606743, -0.011209839023649693, 0.0276018176227808, -0.00790994893759489, 0.06516513228416443, 0.0022105227690190077, 0.028485696762800217, 0.014178509823977947, 0.003010503016412258, 0.011407004669308662, -0.024182843044400215, -0.027584878727793694, 0.04245982691645622, -0.0065755476243793964, -0.03281979635357857, 0.009508209303021431, -0.044355448335409164, -0.004367852583527565, 0.04940246045589447, -0.018520478159189224, 0.04335232824087143, 0.026625851169228554, 0.04056800529360771, -0.004783923737704754, -0.01302507147192955, -0.02721572481095791, 0.00022157040075398982, -0.006789676379412413, 0.04891681671142578, 0.0035567700397223234, 0.015224510803818703, 0.021613318473100662, 0.0024362991098314524, 0.0012251508887857199, 0.022284667938947678, -0.02849358320236206, 0.036376990377902985, 0.041804976761341095, 0.017730260267853737, -0.03447752445936203, 0.03839056193828583, -0.03680199384689331, -0.00985769834369421, -0.0441143698990345, -0.034060172736644745, 0.05889897421002388, 0.04562031477689743, -0.012368882074952126, -0.039418432861566544, -0.020056208595633507, -0.01646694727241993, 0.019284140318632126, 0.02730388566851616, -0.01961594820022583, 0.015026535838842392, 0.03958526626229286, 0.019975872710347176, -0.024756338447332382, 0.014128523878753185, -0.020291246473789215, -0.08085430413484573, -0.023406190797686577, -0.045328278094530106, -0.054919347167015076, -0.0008407089626416564, 0.01324435230344534, -0.007098907604813576, 0.0004946772241964936, -0.044037289917469025, 0.02053261362016201, -0.026322385296225548, 0.004210781306028366, -0.02349950559437275, 0.0873623788356781, 0.010690784081816673, 0.04496164619922638, -0.0074570681899785995, -0.0015421168645843863, 0.09595511853694916, 0.05143086612224579, 0.03157516196370125, -0.06690753251314163, 0.009967816062271595, -0.052480585873126984, -0.009115710854530334, -0.041730619966983795, 0.03862423822283745, -0.013658170588314533, 0.0012336468789726496, 0.013630405068397522, 0.061558883637189865, 0.003518147626891732, -0.005857792682945728, 0.0467430055141449, -0.027679234743118286, -0.024480478838086128, -0.0017019925871863961, 0.0369185209274292, -0.05995018780231476, -0.012059079483151436, -0.04828062653541565, 0.015902908518910408, -0.015887383371591568, -0.0089343236759305, -0.04465031251311302, -0.018276620656251907, 0.018229931592941284, 0.010490979067981243, 0.012898208573460579, -0.013876283541321754, 0.020035553723573685, 0.0005104935262352228, 0.015244037844240665, -0.01171133853495121, 0.02928430400788784, -0.015021578408777714, 0.032248757779598236, 0.009184490889310837, -0.0056105852127075195, 0.01807381957769394, 0.02578779309988022, 0.0006457758136093616, -0.03402434289455414, -0.06268417090177536, -0.03048672527074814, 0.09590422362089157, -0.007065712474286556, 0.011448469012975693, -0.039290543645620346, 0.0023407768458127975, -0.008501946926116943, -0.059265151619911194, -0.038625407963991165, -0.015418903902173042, 0.02672429196536541, -0.000445248355390504, 0.004052896983921528, -0.04972980543971062, 0.0385155975818634, -0.009976992383599281, 0.04674718528985977, -0.024866823107004166, -0.048504967242479324, -0.0025910246185958385, -0.015990879386663437, 0.037179697304964066, -0.02876684069633484, -0.04269234836101532, -0.006888266187161207, -0.03123288042843342, -0.026651088148355484, -0.018655002117156982, -0.0007494002347812057, -0.043373897671699524, 0.03332117944955826, -0.003702754620462656, 0.0026849200949072838, 0.012900297529995441, -0.06987407058477402, 0.026782294735312462, -0.028938595205545425, 0.0015635414747521281, -0.03836168348789215, 0.03423072770237923, 0.022922033444046974, 0.0476594902575016, 0.02318640798330307, -0.011785250157117844, -0.0055062975734472275, 0.048888202756643295, 0.030951915308833122, -0.015794482082128525, -0.025659935548901558, -0.005810348782688379, -0.01602037064731121, 0.000004009123131254455, -0.02971743606030941, 0.03287249803543091, 0.0020353689324110746, 0.02927989885210991, -0.011032622307538986, 0.014122401364147663, -0.01977682299911976, 0.023326676338911057, -0.013503149151802063, -0.056095223873853683, 0.021563639864325523, 0.010306643322110176, 0.030017541721463203, -0.022109322249889374, 0.007560176774859428, 0.006941673345863819, 0.007362494710832834, -0.005881038494408131, -0.0056050606071949005, -0.039726585149765015, -0.00443115783855319, -0.034183014184236526, 0.07289068400859833, -0.013078120537102222, -0.006965368054807186, -0.011465970426797867, 0.01469181664288044, 0.0017816611798480153, 0.015224376693367958, -0.03691452369093895, 0.01336127519607544, -0.027339503169059753, -0.008315023966133595, 0.03104589506983757, 0.032146893441677094, 0.025461290031671524, -0.0001777686848072335, 0.021135950461030006, -0.045293860137462616, 0.032828912138938904, -0.005438453517854214, -0.03291755169630051, 0.03469147905707359, -0.023026131093502045, -0.009753884747624397, -0.00641526747494936, 0.05445275455713272, 0.05755152925848961, 0.0377546064555645, -0.03401322662830353, -0.05040879547595978, 0.053551964461803436, -0.013507659547030926, -0.00022748077753931284, -0.009507490321993828, -0.03478088974952698, -0.02529440075159073, 0.0146670276299119, -0.014831701293587685, 0.03251739963889122, -0.020124902948737144, 0.024216242134571075, 0.004526339005678892, -0.014047951437532902, -0.01806684210896492, 0.025885049253702164, 0.04859417676925659, 0.051123641431331635, 0.006692665163427591, -0.03190223500132561, 0.03677143156528473, 0.06407558172941208, -0.01646655611693859, 0.020938221365213394, -0.0039046986494213343, -0.0048148068599402905, -0.07422152161598206, -0.015048385597765446, 0.012290866114199162, -0.0062470631673932076, -0.0003677183703985065, -0.06972910463809967, -0.00608881376683712, 0.02130749262869358, -0.03505067527294159, 0.008386942557990551, 0.007930909283459187, -0.020752938464283943, -0.01880318857729435, 0.016429271548986435, -0.003146948991343379, 0.053590741008520126, 0.017437398433685303, 0.01182605978101492, 0.019004210829734802, 0.013720972463488579, 0.01144314557313919, -0.01444943342357874, -0.01729448139667511, 0.022135913372039795, 0.00833767931908369, -0.056128691881895065, 0.04747358337044716, -0.04986782371997833, -0.04405214637517929, 0.013300726190209389, 0.034005533903837204, 0.016845272853970528, 0.0177318062633276, 0.03145860135555267, 0.00881659984588623, 0.055588576942682266, 0.012791058048605919, 0.013911389745771885, 0.012994697317481041, -0.009332045912742615, 0.03470972552895546, -0.017506185919046402, -0.03189361095428467, -0.025563547387719154, 0.030473772436380386, 0.000005347193109628279, -0.02603868953883648, 0.04224763438105583, 0.0029322325717657804, -0.04529273509979248, -0.04122070223093033, -0.03239817172288895, 0.0123857157304883, -0.04000283405184746, 0.04285234212875366, -0.06436895579099655, -0.019581880420446396, 0.056606024503707886, -0.0013968992279842496, -0.00467321602627635, 0.019353993237018585, -0.00469282828271389, -0.023459216579794884, 0.0313761867582798, 0.028662068769335747, -0.02853946015238762, -0.0866081565618515, -0.01857180707156658, 0.015473092906177044, 0.003044903976842761, 0.01743500865995884, -0.034230541437864304, -0.054476309567689896, -0.011976457200944424, -0.023720527067780495, 0.019559817388653755, 0.0020667456556111574, -0.0024497220292687416, -0.006528496742248535, -0.044019367545843124, 0.05631975084543228, 0.03806818649172783, -0.045719701796770096, -0.0239228755235672, -0.015732087194919586, -0.013324172236025333, -0.005991516634821892, 0.06124109402298927, 0.04126027598977089, -0.02880244515836239, -0.01868581771850586, 0.037562161684036255, 0.060232508927583694, -0.06440933793783188, 0.0075045395642519, -0.021941760554909706, -0.018852034583687782, 0.005061586853116751, 0.015275932848453522, 0.011855607852339745, 0.006717367563396692, 0.013017906807363033, -0.04090823605656624, -0.0218264851719141, -0.0015446172328665853, -0.0026712685357779264, -0.02431591972708702, -0.010853398591279984, 0.012694375589489937, 0.04993899539113045, -0.03359002247452736, 0.02992362342774868, -0.0022960109636187553, 0.031981296837329865, -0.017074745148420334, 0.009138192981481552, -0.06203408166766167, -0.02857922576367855, -0.017678886651992798, 0.016818121075630188, 0.014882558956742287, -0.07281458377838135, -0.008741650730371475, 0.02051037922501564, -0.04710562154650688, 0.009498052299022675, 0.05887772515416145, 0.018563371151685715, 0.036033909767866135, 0.0033831412438303232, 0.026303889229893684, 0.02520260214805603, -0.01997716724872589, 0.023709602653980255, 0.021563248708844185, 0.035362210124731064, -0.020154744386672974, -0.004112146329134703, 0.03720749542117119, -0.04443318024277687, 0.03309142217040062, -0.015349190682172775, 0.013474442064762115, -0.032825931906700134, 0.0005919940304011106, -0.018267815932631493, -0.006928409915417433, 0.005966539960354567, 0.0028339268174022436, -0.018808921799063683, 0.02962561324238777, -0.020727409049868584, -0.00916849635541439, -0.046626344323158264, 0.0045013721100986, -0.029393797740340233, 0.0033330756705254316, 0.03579380363225937, 0.033959660679101944, 0.009987258352339268, 0.005234394688159227, -0.011949031613767147, -0.014947405084967613, 0.002929019508883357, -0.031190285459160805, 0.017745908349752426, 0.004158921539783478, -0.011493810452520847, 0.0024009961634874344, -0.005688403733074665, -0.02523398958146572, -0.025740066543221474, -0.005148787051439285, 0.04551582410931587, 0.04910893738269806, 0.004517975728958845, -0.01470225676894188, 0.029840895906090736, 0.06160290539264679, -0.06123228743672371, -0.019039403647184372, -0.04237652197480202, -0.0048853629268705845, 0.004814408719539642, 0.0064988769590854645 ]
<p>Suppose that you are running a linear regression model with outcome $Y$ and explanatory variables $X_1$ and $X_2$. You also run a linear regression model with a quadratic transformation of $X_1$: $$E[Y] = \beta_0 + \beta_{1}X_{1}+\beta_{2}X_{1}^{2} + \beta_{3}X_{2}$$ </p> <p>If $|\beta_2| \approx 0$ can we drop it from our model?</p>
73,668
[ -0.024050816893577576, 0.025340227410197258, -0.005703344009816647, 0.006025499198585749, 0.011562258005142212, 0.03420017287135124, -0.009570764377713203, -0.031176790595054626, 0.028355039656162262, -0.052160609513521194, 0.01788506470620632, 0.03997557982802391, 0.06989537924528122, -0.020908605307340622, 0.011399996466934681, 0.028128359466791153, 0.003641323884949088, -0.005140003748238087, -0.01888110116124153, 0.0033286588732153177, 0.0007252309005707502, 0.020168615505099297, 0.03609233349561691, 0.02169685810804367, -0.044700201600790024, 0.05627971887588501, 0.052806541323661804, -0.03189938887953758, -0.018550757318735123, 0.06138046085834503, -0.004045022185891867, 0.0049187541007995605, -0.004084247164428234, 0.024707090109586716, 0.03142305836081505, 0.01345513854175806, -0.007401050999760628, -0.0363643541932106, 0.0377613790333271, 0.001864254823885858, -0.030758917331695557, 0.0016022329218685627, -0.011070849373936653, 0.04286473989486694, 0.00406900467351079, -0.01449216715991497, 0.0009951019892469049, -0.03370558097958565, 0.0018852703506127, 0.010515302419662476, 0.08809572458267212, -0.03163857385516167, 0.021279457956552505, 0.02441488765180111, -0.005456362385302782, -0.00857606716454029, 0.05144302546977997, 0.05755645036697388, 0.009860560297966003, -0.03716675564646721, -0.00930204801261425, 0.021046429872512817, -0.00191630725748837, -0.008989655412733555, -0.02987205795943737, 0.024928607046604156, 0.033247724175453186, 0.00031746545573696494, 0.021694861352443695, -0.02836679294705391, -0.011412566527724266, 0.018320636823773384, 0.00995960459113121, -0.005551883019506931, 0.02840513177216053, -0.022400539368391037, 0.024765707552433014, 0.04019063338637352, 0.03893410414457321, 0.03232363238930702, 0.007227093912661076, -0.002184926997870207, 0.05620887503027916, 0.031055187806487083, 0.02353718876838684, 0.00011701477342285216, 0.05421345680952072, -0.027483364567160606, 0.043526437133550644, 0.056916557252407074, 0.011206420138478279, 0.02986120991408825, 0.03762675076723099, -0.011198455467820168, -0.006756634451448917, 0.03939138352870941, 0.018784083425998688, 0.06954745948314667, 0.00562492897734046, -0.012509804219007492, -0.0007646402227692306, -0.0368189662694931, 0.023693038150668144, 0.03693600744009018, 0.0009951697429642081, -0.01271093264222145, -0.01585383340716362, 0.014354466460645199, -0.018772419542074203, -0.03184748813509941, 0.00657581677660346, 0.03365126997232437, -0.0027926734182983637, -0.010326722636818886, 0.061709970235824585, -0.007634386885911226, -0.007746025919914246, -0.017066258937120438, 0.024585720151662827, 0.051282498985528946, 0.020719166845083237, -0.03255359083414078, 0.018733834847807884, -0.010891289450228214, -0.04108287766575813, 0.000266566697973758, 0.006257685832679272, -0.012965843081474304, -0.08031044155359268, 0.01583685725927353, 0.01415275875478983, -0.028677603229880333, 0.011875624768435955, -0.00007649237522855401, 0.002429966116324067, -0.014142300002276897, -0.05216760188341141, -0.06385349482297897, -0.006122779566794634, -0.037562478333711624, 0.0396406315267086, -0.03807220235466957, -0.011269948445260525, 0.019886501133441925, 0.0686386376619339, -0.005601303651928902, 0.038971301168203354, 0.04884393513202667, 0.015597687102854252, -0.013191482052206993, 0.0014200406149029732, -0.02665916085243225, -0.042617395520210266, -0.03275541216135025, -0.01753423362970352, -0.10772135853767395, 0.024842720478773117, 0.047271862626075745, -0.02561389096081257, -0.0075229438953101635, 0.02570372074842453, -0.014221467077732086, -0.034703195095062256, 0.014564773067831993, -0.008509833365678787, -0.022732652723789215, 0.07923701405525208, 0.0063270037062466145, 0.009805988520383835, 0.01574661396443844, 0.010116561315953732, 0.02879016473889351, 0.007915083318948746, 0.08551527559757233, 0.046548377722501755, 0.0076630692929029465, -0.029857264831662178, -0.047382790595293045, 0.04194854572415352, 0.04380519688129425, -0.07395024597644806, -0.013572817668318748, -0.02196369506418705, 0.026789465919137, 0.02063709683716297, 0.05027393996715546, -0.0010859430767595768, -0.0431266613304615, 0.05274656414985657, -0.02872500941157341, -0.011554148979485035, -0.03932267799973488, 0.023403210565447807, 0.0378800705075264, -0.01145539153367281, 0.015681980177760124, 0.003247783286496997, 0.00800913106650114, -0.04521225765347481, 0.012074366211891174, -0.0015338188968598843, -0.009061397984623909, 0.03819531947374344, -0.04197492077946663, -0.01168384961783886, 0.03893708810210228, 0.06947779655456543, -0.010482418350875378, 0.03509910777211189, -0.03569372370839119, -0.0507315918803215, -0.009810634888708591, 0.0045468308962881565, 0.022309722378849983, -0.04036791995167732, 0.016551077365875244, -0.028411023318767548, -0.03248390555381775, -0.03443469479680061, 0.02155725657939911, -0.06746263802051544, 0.03549094498157501, 0.04445203021168709, -0.0006080258754082024, -0.014677667990326881, -0.003155565820634365, 0.012263381853699684, 0.04482517018914223, -0.010893094353377819, -0.020116165280342102, -0.025741582736372948, 0.005528868641704321, 0.012195178307592869, 0.03206716105341911, -0.03743801265954971, 0.026797739788889885, 0.0524987131357193, 0.02145136520266533, -0.03185480460524559, 0.016479143872857094, 0.023863274604082108, 0.022357795387506485, 0.012011614628136158, -0.030744360759854317, 0.03563558682799339, -0.021388014778494835, 0.01557688508182764, -0.0007340312586165965, 0.020734285935759544, -0.006350382696837187, 0.009640248492360115, 0.02663298323750496, 0.05152622610330582, -0.010222100652754307, 0.03197919577360153, -0.00593935139477253, 0.043638382107019424, -0.010400061495602131, 0.022449100390076637, 0.03176078572869301, -0.005295305047184229, 0.0002560405118856579, 0.008121255785226822, 0.019777517765760422, -0.008405888453125954, 0.028962744399905205, -0.03513661399483681, -0.005567148327827454, 0.024766962975263596, -0.03813258185982704, 0.0037589622661471367, -0.013357479125261307, -0.03863426297903061, -0.04025639593601227, 0.018454773351550102, 0.019353443756699562, 0.00339877069927752, 0.03121854178607464, -0.027320289984345436, -0.014423904940485954, -0.00727170379832387, -0.029307730495929718, 0.018247254192829132, 0.004588410723954439, -0.012663728557527065, 0.05163988843560219, -0.055219393223524094, -0.016087589785456657, 0.04132652282714844, 0.004279101267457008, 0.01644170843064785, 0.037652917206287384, -0.0292726531624794, -0.04945440590381622, -0.039920058101415634, -0.05392763018608093, -0.010881352238357067, -0.020828377455472946, -0.0707918182015419, 0.05140991136431694, 0.01985643431544304, -0.058194782584905624, -0.0026093139313161373, -0.052246034145355225, -0.005548242945224047, -0.02642546407878399, 0.005430605262517929, 0.03563399612903595, 0.016981950029730797, 0.03418365493416786, 0.03475333750247955, -0.033913712948560715, 0.02062402293086052, -0.08094052225351334, -0.0712219625711441, 0.004081971012055874, 0.0073465402238070965, 0.04172700643539429, -0.007543823681771755, -0.0348169207572937, 0.12481685727834702, 0.056883305311203, 0.0011408176505938172, 0.0029241705778986216, -0.002794541884213686, 0.016769137233495712, -0.02329413592815399, 0.010983852669596672, 0.004294433165341616, 0.009849725291132927, 0.025545934215188026, 0.0009171479614451528, 0.03794652223587036, 0.01474301889538765, 0.025236349552869797, -0.00004677330070990138, -0.007503789383918047, 0.01793479546904564, 0.013045650906860828, 0.001773851690813899, 0.03174770250916481, -0.0060825832188129425, 0.054894525557756424, 0.007253963500261307, 0.063893623650074, 0.01369367353618145, -0.04880752041935921, 0.006946257781237364, -0.01396170724183321, 0.014305751770734787, 0.002981633646413684, 0.06834568083286285, 0.0539608933031559, -0.0026120718102902174, -0.014159477315843105, -0.013192815706133842, 0.029396070167422295, -0.017558418214321136, -0.015906628221273422, 0.044758912175893784, 0.021671779453754425, -0.01458029355853796, -0.01093929260969162, -0.003091690829023719, -0.01950192265212536, 0.030617205426096916, -0.018840594217181206, -0.0344046913087368, 0.03612043336033821, 0.03551455959677696, 0.038130104541778564, -0.01797461323440075, -0.011057534255087376, -0.00385793624445796, -0.056521303951740265, -0.010685480199754238, 0.003483348060399294, 0.023181410506367683, 0.03793248534202576, -0.0012633285950869322, 0.006710502319037914, -0.010053236968815327, 0.00017721820040605962, -0.007054200395941734, -0.06195412948727608, -0.0018151836702600121, -0.01797940395772457, -0.005566785577684641, 0.013945750892162323, -0.011098071932792664, 0.05941888689994812, -0.02515527233481407, 0.0028208403382450342, -0.0145263085141778, 0.007244933862239122, -0.04909980669617653, -0.011035123839974403, -0.01241281908005476, -0.03233899548649788, 0.009896498173475266, 0.0019469253020361066, 0.02978692017495632, -0.021270692348480225, 0.0451219342648983, 0.011342301033437252, -0.017211351543664932, 0.007987900637090206, -0.04054781794548035, 0.015022599138319492, 0.037229955196380615, 0.058090273290872574, 0.029915794730186462, 0.003421194851398468, -0.028843022882938385, 0.04283628612756729, 0.012975419871509075, 0.045314278453588486, 0.04304206743836403, -0.002814897336065769, -0.020586756989359856, -0.05213223397731781, -0.03815232589840889, -0.012507619336247444, 0.012678546831011772, -0.01609518751502037, 0.01811528578400612, 0.0279840175062418, 0.038206662982702255, -0.040720123797655106, 0.0025756838731467724, 0.05426347628235817, 0.05017606168985367, 0.027788203209638596, -0.04253596067428589, 0.010226144455373287, 0.006875310558825731, -0.0044237892143428326, -0.00877106748521328, -0.015057610347867012, -0.015904754400253296, -0.040307510644197464, 0.032638754695653915, 0.035851359367370605, -0.013923208229243755, -0.0030541641172021627, 0.03147634491324425, 0.041819822043180466, 0.0013303497107699513, -0.02587204985320568, 0.04168401286005974, 0.02750040404498577, 0.03307024762034416, 0.03162728622555733, 0.02791816182434559, -0.0577366016805172, 0.0013895450392737985, 0.019164003431797028, 0.05048232525587082, 0.003323343815281987, -0.03862481191754341, 0.0057598608545959, -0.007904982194304466, 0.009841066785156727, 0.000019620967577793635, 0.020473169162869453, -0.013818151317536831, 0.01792074739933014, 0.004052070435136557, -0.028927218168973923, -0.0756099671125412, 0.03407293185591698, -0.021483775228261948, 0.036236025393009186, 0.006316283717751503, -0.03750452399253845, -0.034927237778902054, 0.00785956159234047, 0.018155382946133614, 0.06339190155267715, -0.028562501072883606, -0.0182875394821167, 0.0031596561893820763, 0.026610201224684715, -0.037703052163124084, -0.09713151305913925, 0.007953885942697525, 0.016210978850722313, -0.017197920009493828, 0.033596910536289215, -0.018296021968126297, -0.04525437206029892, -0.004068928770720959, 0.01783512532711029, -0.010631091892719269, 0.0205782912671566, -0.03187081217765808, 0.0495167076587677, 0.07228217273950577, 0.011973955668509007, 0.06281722337007523, 0.05755691975355148, 0.008701854385435581, -0.004343072883784771, -0.036242417991161346, -0.0447896271944046, -0.046831682324409485, 0.014450821094214916, -0.05639481171965599, 0.00571137061342597, 0.02019723877310753, 0.022668268531560898, -0.006206132005900145, 0.03382112458348274, 0.016883306205272675, -0.011242776177823544, -0.009024499915540218, 0.01389696728438139, -0.033845819532871246, -0.04108581319451332, -0.060655537992715836, 0.038242679089307785, -0.04219081625342369, -0.04801814258098602, -0.01575983688235283, -0.013424812816083431, 0.011206569150090218, 0.01596047915518284, -0.015300339087843895, 0.02107281982898712, -0.017694806680083275, -0.019410977140069008, -0.03073367476463318, 0.0006732266629114747, 0.017055584117770195, -0.019004041329026222, 0.00532294949516654, -0.02754712663590908, -0.002784324111416936, -0.00899297185242176, 0.038258109241724014, 0.02877183072268963, 0.01219246070832014, -0.04570167884230614, 0.022990556433796883, 0.024574212729930878, 0.004248813726007938, -0.06701292842626572, -0.06798730045557022, 0.026986345648765564, 0.01911787874996662, 0.005644214805215597, 0.0040323007851839066, -0.03051810897886753, -0.04519293084740639, -0.0394553579390049, -0.008150437846779823, 0.04106352478265762, -0.009042944759130478, -0.001158450380899012, 0.002917920472100377, 0.0212730523198843, 0.07298758625984192, -0.007894430309534073, -0.022915620356798172, 0.04535602033138275, -0.023373093456029892, -0.029088888317346573, -0.00020037683134432882, 0.06695978343486786, -0.026543816551566124, 0.028045950457453728, -0.05314183980226517, -0.03271856531500816, 0.04605000466108322, -0.014048716984689236, -0.0431336835026741, 0.011810136958956718, 0.019003963097929955, 0.0019653209019452333, -0.012163328938186169, -0.015358769334852695, 0.003208861453458667, 0.031195465475320816, 0.032864078879356384, 0.014287712052464485, 0.0010329842334613204, -0.024348925799131393, 0.022323161363601685, -0.003097935114055872, -0.013406249694526196, -0.00696554547175765, 0.08092571049928665, -0.007762550842016935, -0.005793140269815922, 0.002290913835167885, 0.0053831180557608604, 0.04050995036959648, -0.0021262920927256346, -0.0067624966613948345, 0.001860323129221797, 0.0447460375726223, -0.04517265781760216, -0.04998528212308884, -0.07459612190723419, 0.009477190673351288, 0.05688275396823883, -0.029098929837346077, 0.01564132794737816, 0.04533342644572258, 0.010557223111391068, -0.012333122082054615, -0.04257841408252716, 0.008207452483475208, -0.023193666711449623, -0.01684701256453991, 0.04610373452305794, 0.035538818687200546, -0.02260228432714939, 0.0429442897439003, 0.024048859253525734, -0.012809905223548412, 0.023632686585187912, 0.013267502188682556, 0.00993151031434536, 0.03533383458852768, -0.02339489385485649, -0.06216544657945633, 0.028463521972298622, -0.050250403583049774, 0.007464546710252762, -0.03941186144948006, -0.041367169469594955, 0.03819872811436653, 0.05200320854783058, 0.005169425625354052, -0.09556815773248672, -0.0542900525033474, -0.04930886998772621, 0.01525167003273964, -0.0021969678346067667, 0.019002191722393036, 0.050592076033353806, -0.03294555842876434, 0.032135751098394394, -0.006629019510000944, 0.040944043546915054, -0.03252900764346123, -0.06909763067960739, -0.031018024310469627, -0.053040243685245514, -0.019160358235239983, 0.025160586461424828, -0.023448284715414047, -0.02572392113506794, 0.028012752532958984, -0.047393687069416046, 0.02627139538526535, -0.0021191295236349106, 0.02935395948588848, -0.00599229522049427, 0.02136174775660038, 0.0037216765340417624, -0.004662541206926107, -0.03972415626049042, -0.0024015596136450768, 0.11575455218553543, 0.06453114748001099, 0.03143972530961037, -0.07419846951961517, -0.007451700512319803, -0.018095336854457855, -0.02248535118997097, -0.008090072311460972, -0.017498601227998734, -0.021455107256770134, 0.0018897788831964135, 0.012234315276145935, 0.06931154429912567, -0.0037872830871492624, -0.03941471129655838, 0.0428314283490181, -0.03972378000617027, -0.0007317019626498222, 0.00027130194939672947, -0.002987104235216975, -0.033447399735450745, -0.009769221767783165, -0.0580829456448555, 0.031784843653440475, -0.0023183939047157764, 0.00860038585960865, -0.010582164861261845, -0.01692647859454155, -0.008481832221150398, -0.03458426892757416, -0.024281572550535202, 0.00689092418178916, 0.03495052084326744, 0.022594116628170013, -0.010719871148467064, 0.008540024980902672, 0.023993615061044693, -0.05733764171600342, -0.02234862931072712, 0.023333076387643814, -0.0021670896094292402, 0.013659226708114147, 0.022052709013223648, -0.024641847237944603, -0.050749216228723526, 0.001869266270659864, -0.03601783141493797, 0.02683909423649311, -0.011518864892423153, -0.02072777785360813, -0.01278715580701828, -0.01057418156415224, 0.006370594259351492, -0.05186080560088158, -0.06055784225463867, 0.02929151989519596, 0.012675696983933449, 0.02728540450334549, 0.004673393908888102, -0.004574683960527182, 0.015928326174616814, 0.002281991532072425, -0.008339034393429756, 0.05368674173951149, -0.03672214224934578, -0.02966449223458767, 0.030807627364993095, 0.06955090910196304, 0.014092552475631237, -0.01992076449096203, -0.0006613382138311863, -0.012933718040585518, -0.01742052100598812, -0.03744904696941376, 0.033215176314115524, -0.004082411993294954, 0.0328679196536541, -0.010519524104893208, -0.002602574648335576, -0.024980861693620682, -0.03437931835651398, -0.006792148109525442, 0.009848084300756454, 0.019695313647389412, -0.055320385843515396, -0.012538114562630653, 0.0049639856442809105, 0.05237752944231033, 0.009324444457888603, -0.04224284738302231, 0.015944544225931168, 0.038549426943063736, -0.005962629336863756, -0.03163706511259079, -0.03577195852994919, 0.026495039463043213, -0.03985721617937088, 0.013041498139500618, 0.005413132254034281, 0.1014484092593193, 0.01445426233112812, 0.03280066326260567, -0.027379171922802925, 0.01985611766576767, -0.0073518892750144005, -0.0003615262103267014, 0.008060942403972149, -0.043976981192827225, 0.004589607939124107, 0.05159589648246765, 0.035629935562610626, -0.00961764995008707, 0.009268585592508316, -0.017966676503419876, -0.021559009328484535, 0.0073464782908558846, 0.015164083801209927, -0.03916972130537033, 0.008991106413304806, -0.02815188467502594, 0.031022831797599792, -0.030822234228253365, -0.01772233285009861, -0.03917313367128372, 0.002176793059334159, 0.024832362309098244, -0.04755678400397301, 0.009995323605835438, 0.006645846646279097, -0.012478142976760864, -0.001873801345936954, 0.027920039370656013, 0.018823381513357162, 0.007967411540448666, -0.02066142112016678, -0.0010378217557445168, -0.047109317034482956, 0.02395070157945156, -0.061997365206480026, -0.017618389800190926, 0.048744913190603256, -0.03207973763346672, 0.00593929085880518, 0.00988081656396389, 0.009825496934354305, 0.0629274919629097, 0.03057231195271015, 0.0005143744638189673, -0.04952581226825714, 0.0022124298848211765, 0.002468621591106057, -0.021575329825282097, -0.01275330875068903, -0.01383156143128872, -0.015113135799765587, 0.001237962394952774, 0.026701994240283966, -0.0008278968161903322, -0.01957017183303833, 0.0344579853117466, 0.032076526433229446, -0.009149999357759953, -0.06003521755337715, -0.005041983909904957, 0.023460956290364265, 0.03652634471654892, -0.009091856889426708, -0.012790948152542114, 0.029928768053650856, 0.03962863236665726, -0.02787555195391178, 0.018743710592389107, 0.006148615386337042, -0.00015336375508923084, -0.09979963302612305, -0.056600358337163925, 0.0311262309551239, 0.0135352136567235, 0.00982676725834608, -0.04534779116511345, 0.03856158256530762, 0.01749880239367485, -0.0717315524816513, -0.006967076566070318, 0.0010362653993070126, 0.0017948041204363108, -0.01586625538766384, 0.05123881623148918, -0.02105787955224514, 0.006512170657515526, 0.05177047476172447, 0.006973825395107269, 0.0028140682261437178, 0.023285306990146637, 0.003813724033534527, -0.008853266946971416, -0.005178363062441349, -0.025751212611794472, -0.021062880754470825, -0.05540244281291962, 0.0021847032476216555, -0.06713312864303589, -0.026197681203484535, 0.032844338566064835, -0.017000829800963402, 0.023117903620004654, -0.0062452214770019054, -0.000155149245983921, -0.0013718133559450507, 0.04216275364160538, 0.02543259598314762, -0.010820921510457993, -0.009995422326028347, 0.0013216312509030104, -0.024758486077189445, 0.020360980182886124, -0.013917019590735435, 0.003343553515151143, 0.007358950562775135, -0.004057161509990692, -0.0039613572880625725, -0.01656435616314411, -0.024005671963095665, -0.01427939347922802, 0.013807039707899094, 0.041810475289821625, -0.05076891928911209, -0.043389562517404556, 0.018028704449534416, -0.003987501375377178, -0.013435740023851395, 0.029947973787784576, 0.04469247907400131, -0.02942446991801262, -0.017582420259714127, -0.018751069903373718, -0.06761855632066727, 0.01520954817533493, 0.03770223259925842, -0.0261666439473629, -0.06368286907672882, -0.007472890894860029, -0.025129355490207672, -0.029219642281532288, -0.021864062175154686, -0.030966799706220627, -0.05824865400791168, 0.02699367143213749, -0.051380179822444916, 0.023438282310962677, -0.0015656487084925175, -0.011623268015682697, -0.0036472794599831104, -0.09821794927120209, 0.07195484638214111, -0.00045228624367155135, 0.0034367467742413282, -0.017101025208830833, 0.013388868421316147, -0.04275095462799072, -0.017425591126084328, 0.06283776462078094, 0.036457519978284836, 0.011968682520091534, -0.003486686386168003, 0.0328657329082489, -0.015815656632184982, -0.024519585072994232, 0.031180215999484062, -0.021609017625451088, -0.011442172341048717, -0.025442223995923996, 0.0026468976866453886, -0.005395350977778435, -0.004395416472107172, 0.004422643221914768, 0.01770036481320858, 0.020307932049036026, -0.010518141090869904, 0.01199252437800169, 0.025556541979312897, 0.0011898085940629244, 0.008611821569502354, 0.0678226500749588, 0.011316823773086071, 0.03862927481532097, -0.011964170262217522, -0.01635921001434326, -0.033206794410943985, 0.018503203988075256, -0.0588681697845459, -0.04960191622376442, -0.0012329262681305408, 0.011122064664959908, 0.00340135395526886, -0.023679981008172035, 0.016560835763812065, 0.03188595175743103, -0.03348700329661369, 0.02290716953575611, 0.009073687717318535, 0.008772133849561214, 0.055777858942747116, -0.005611985456198454, -0.0035571863409131765, 0.006415874697268009, -0.0026835354510694742, 0.04540382698178291, 0.00002279965156049002, 0.006732954178005457, 0.015339268371462822, 0.008537075482308865, 0.03443967550992966, 0.005792966578155756, 0.011874240823090076, 0.002585551468655467, 0.036216869950294495, 0.002229734556749463, -0.025396771728992462, 0.02686743065714836, 0.03827297315001488, -0.004677601624280214, -0.05124663561582565, -0.00972665660083294, 0.019625095650553703, -0.020623506978154182, 0.009356832131743431, -0.04974852129817009, -0.0038948773872107267, -0.022005420178174973, 0.0020328403916209936, 0.018681513145565987, 0.009865541011095047, 0.008521600626409054, -0.04511743783950806, -0.04102856665849686, -0.001640364876948297, 0.0031302885618060827, 0.006135661620646715, 0.016454817727208138, 0.0020724963396787643, -0.022532785311341286, 0.009042822755873203, -0.006273724138736725, -0.011455229483544827, -0.026417555287480354, 0.01748230680823326, 0.049747534096241, 0.03640427067875862, -0.04183173179626465, -0.03598155826330185, 0.002867218106985092, 0.02098819427192211, -0.04027804732322693, -0.016555631533265114, -0.015536323189735413, 0.019084813073277473, -0.0023356801830232143, -0.03675530478358269 ]
<p>Which method would you suggest for estimation an univariate regression ($y = a + bx + e$) which comprise a lot of $0$ values in the dependent variable (actually kind of censored data). My experience hints at the use of the <strong>Tobit model</strong>. But There is a problem connected with the normal distribution and homoscedasticity of the error term. In my case I'm suspecting a <em>violation</em> of these basic assumptions for using Tobit. In particular the behaviour of latent $y$ under the zero is not anticipating. </p> <p>Do you know some method (literature) for handling this kind of problems?</p>
73,669
[ -0.0024989470839500427, -0.027248790487647057, 0.0005374269676394761, 0.010996716096997261, 0.026381606236100197, 0.00981984008103609, -0.004331533331423998, 0.011630096472799778, 0.035654809325933456, -0.057925838977098465, 0.02398417517542839, 0.027445180341601372, 0.030466333031654358, 0.034508686512708664, 0.04818561300635338, 0.005829251371324062, -0.018447453156113625, 0.000516194268129766, -0.016760457307100296, -0.012807550840079784, -0.01305957417935133, -0.001460443832911551, -0.00033908418845385313, 0.010950405150651932, -0.014665491878986359, 0.02564338594675064, 0.012449793517589569, 0.0013255584053695202, 0.008930336683988571, 0.0768878310918808, -0.017379596829414368, -0.04793605953454971, -0.012929745018482208, 0.03647563233971596, 0.03192058578133583, 0.014407237991690636, -0.044577766209840775, -0.04231787472963333, -0.0027013227809220552, -0.00670988205820322, -0.02661817893385887, -0.06450965255498886, 0.021616756916046143, 0.04477204009890556, 0.004763052333146334, -0.004080409184098244, 0.014288665726780891, -0.045350365340709686, 0.07997540384531021, -0.02803327515721321, 0.07301093637943268, -0.0016885080840438604, 0.033178988844156265, 0.0017656884156167507, -0.016751226037740707, -0.017000721767544746, 0.056082844734191895, 0.06388609111309052, -0.009138258174061775, -0.07776850461959839, -0.025429651141166687, -0.04738971218466759, 0.006047775968909264, -0.0009350839536637068, -0.040903057903051376, 0.030286455526947975, -0.02401920035481453, -0.0655767023563385, 0.045946042984724045, -0.027309812605381012, 0.002533494960516691, 0.016483768820762634, -0.004084397107362747, 0.011167295277118683, -0.005898599978536367, -0.00712378928437829, -0.0030036657117307186, 0.030040178447961807, 0.0387735553085804, 0.04954694211483002, 0.002236197469756007, -0.0014274391578510404, 0.04809032753109932, 0.05282796919345856, -0.009114885702729225, -0.01329732220619917, 0.05386100709438324, -0.036539219319820404, 0.05191870778799057, 0.003894590772688389, -0.05028200149536133, -0.0004496905021369457, 0.05403764918446541, -0.006075134500861168, -0.06742146611213684, 0.06956227868795395, -0.004626856185495853, 0.05825410783290863, 0.028287798166275024, 0.0018418112304061651, -0.008187804371118546, -0.03864102438092232, 0.007692920044064522, 0.07490583509206772, 0.004209494683891535, -0.0013766482006758451, 0.004115399904549122, -0.0095325643196702, 0.019974660128355026, -0.04082060232758522, 0.003474785014986992, 0.013741369359195232, 0.03785674273967743, -0.005986600648611784, 0.017956191673874855, 0.005950415041297674, -0.009747423231601715, -0.06243479624390602, 0.048691973090171814, 0.03301654011011124, 0.04894300922751427, -0.04702691733837128, 0.03454926609992981, 0.009712962433695793, -0.049197252839803696, 0.01217527873814106, 0.034239448606967926, -0.017473429441452026, -0.05820046737790108, 0.061352621763944626, 0.019715584814548492, -0.034594908356666565, 0.05002168193459511, 0.006665362510830164, 0.025485113263130188, 0.016097651794552803, -0.061938297003507614, -0.06391254812479019, 0.013987292535603046, -0.016161570325493813, 0.00041324066114611924, -0.05466252565383911, -0.06392037868499756, 0.04858724772930145, 0.047655291855335236, -0.011599247343838215, 0.0571310855448246, 0.020804446190595627, 0.03633694723248482, 0.016257712617516518, 0.00022206742141861469, -0.01203950960189104, -0.025374114513397217, -0.04438595101237297, -0.030490871518850327, -0.06323153525590897, -0.006352199241518974, 0.030868791043758392, -0.020412703976035118, -0.008717670105397701, 0.03661184757947922, 0.009265048429369926, -0.0130613436922431, 0.0002210044622188434, 0.05928904935717583, -0.030100133270025253, 0.07759014517068863, 0.030941437929868698, 0.02863691747188568, 0.03369982913136482, 0.008760232478380203, 0.07677605003118515, 0.029303554445505142, 0.05262701213359833, 0.011334014125168324, -0.03848665580153465, 0.013430310413241386, -0.044173724949359894, 0.012081773020327091, 0.05102236941456795, -0.04905650019645691, -0.005040720570832491, -0.0013603662373498082, -0.03180354833602905, -0.0037777815014123917, 0.04258622229099274, -0.00013827702787239105, -0.0064991554245352745, 0.021958567202091217, -0.02896372601389885, -0.05011269077658653, -0.07854045927524567, 0.01124831847846508, 0.0084005706012249, -0.009072027169167995, 0.02359582856297493, -0.026703376322984695, 0.006001128815114498, -0.01584683358669281, -0.012770996429026127, -0.0037723900750279427, 0.00006740796379745007, 0.022860746830701828, -0.06452931463718414, 0.014995571225881577, 0.026987528428435326, 0.06446479260921478, -0.005221907515078783, 0.04813114553689957, -0.04280899837613106, -0.0449683777987957, -0.01824832335114479, -0.008685287088155746, 0.04559702053666115, -0.018800092861056328, -0.05222314968705177, -0.007811982184648514, -0.03578054532408714, -0.03291523829102516, 0.021669626235961914, -0.06581570953130722, 0.049078475683927536, 0.06932526081800461, 0.014242307282984257, -0.016323722898960114, -0.008452421985566616, 0.01816258393228054, 0.005931371822953224, -0.02375202812254429, -0.03650312125682831, -0.03998085856437683, 0.025014914572238922, 0.018361669033765793, 0.016571661457419395, -0.054598838090896606, 0.0028394791297614574, 0.042377572506666183, -0.0002905687433667481, -0.002660151105374098, -0.010733142495155334, -0.02370459772646427, -0.029496358707547188, 0.032014552503824234, 0.005008518695831299, 0.01567252166569233, 0.002266916213557124, 0.010927067138254642, 0.02146076411008835, 0.05034089460968971, -0.01766882836818695, 0.01567801460623741, -0.003272762056440115, 0.017290765419602394, 0.0023817187175154686, -0.03224791958928108, -0.01119359489530325, 0.020692622289061546, -0.04182808846235275, 0.014099168591201305, 0.0029974705539643764, 0.017201101407408714, -0.01934000477194786, 0.024756427854299545, -0.013992156833410263, 0.02906300313770771, 0.03312268108129501, -0.032373398542404175, 0.009962782263755798, 0.03539922088384628, -0.014883375726640224, 0.012183713726699352, -0.01906249299645424, -0.045859478414058685, -0.045636359602212906, 0.006200553849339485, 0.05861436203122139, 0.019403548911213875, 0.001512860762886703, -0.04748917743563652, -0.023296304047107697, -0.01677151955664158, 0.013422506861388683, 0.011395074427127838, 0.01462890300899744, -0.048034749925136566, 0.012635327875614166, -0.036924563348293304, -0.00932367704808712, 0.040215570479631424, -0.013588763773441315, -0.011054223403334618, 0.03968014195561409, -0.03511851280927658, -0.042336177080869675, -0.04083804786205292, 0.001515791635029018, 0.005875610746443272, -0.02967698685824871, -0.0544976107776165, 0.03433460742235184, -0.0010316172847524285, -0.029923327267169952, 0.024859430268406868, -0.06478927284479141, -0.03658157214522362, -0.05084748566150665, 0.010018102824687958, -0.002384381601586938, -0.0005470419418998063, 0.0492437407374382, 0.0034656806383281946, -0.003114961786195636, -0.01854485087096691, -0.06553944945335388, -0.0485103465616703, 0.0035281425807625055, -0.015271889045834541, 0.023468343541026115, 0.012471729889512062, -0.019421761855483055, 0.0473296232521534, 0.02768181823194027, -0.0052566505037248135, -0.048487115651369095, -0.011495455168187618, -0.002695484319701791, -0.021001487970352173, -0.023719090968370438, -0.021812791004776955, 0.027997763827443123, 0.03237752616405487, -0.04749009385704994, 0.00833818782120943, 0.035916730761528015, 0.06263664364814758, -0.05159832164645195, 0.008054659701883793, -0.0014637308195233345, 0.025362620130181313, -0.004401063080877066, 0.07153066992759705, 0.003615135559812188, 0.023374386131763458, 0.010926916263997555, 0.056830212473869324, 0.031096579506993294, -0.025842009112238884, 0.02505936101078987, -0.029394827783107758, -0.015288680791854858, 0.014369550161063671, 0.014419402927160263, -0.007532437797635794, -0.014167274348437786, -0.029381854459643364, -0.0032274287659674883, -0.013006827794015408, -0.017252415418624878, 0.018420523032546043, 0.013040577992796898, 0.018278522416949272, -0.007690084166824818, -0.032936833798885345, -0.05549496412277222, 0.013102483935654163, 0.02879524976015091, -0.012429742142558098, 0.02460474520921707, 0.007397303357720375, 0.03805818781256676, 0.013618932105600834, -0.0520295649766922, -0.022832797840237617, -0.004787116777151823, -0.059447385370731354, -0.021769635379314423, -0.027118980884552002, 0.059558939188718796, 0.034446023404598236, 0.023920724168419838, -0.019593261182308197, 0.009997028857469559, 0.02734837494790554, 0.008047676645219326, -0.10498809069395065, 0.029897542670369148, -0.03854444622993469, 0.004665914457291365, -0.02124425396323204, 0.038283661007881165, 0.02645084261894226, -0.02690279670059681, 0.0004138579242862761, -0.022386284545063972, 0.029549501836299896, -0.01395987719297409, -0.03266628831624985, -0.025114009156823158, -0.031763121485710144, -0.05258564651012421, -0.03235967084765434, -0.007323474157601595, -0.03681298345327377, 0.0013289253693073988, 0.017978889867663383, -0.027463596314191818, -0.024180173873901367, -0.0338418073952198, -0.0042691160924732685, 0.023773008957505226, 0.017685461789369583, 0.018328512087464333, 0.03576603904366493, -0.027060629799962044, 0.03402424976229668, 0.0010683276923373342, 0.05771251395344734, 0.034995947033166885, 0.012252012267708778, -0.04093930870294571, 0.005404526833444834, -0.03358917683362961, -0.004840665962547064, 0.0490841269493103, 0.009451244957745075, 0.007003139704465866, 0.07053090631961823, 0.043049875646829605, -0.0331791527569294, -0.012551532126963139, 0.060753997415304184, 0.05215835198760033, 0.02159852162003517, 0.010526207275688648, -0.007913723587989807, -0.012240853160619736, 0.030370468273758888, -0.011139955371618271, 0.022013673558831215, 0.0013482103822752833, -0.027768976986408234, 0.04304787144064903, 0.020993199199438095, -0.009399273432791233, -0.018065260723233223, 0.016766531392931938, 0.008924778550863266, 0.011534976772964, -0.092159204185009, 0.03795107454061508, 0.03676781430840492, 0.03391021117568016, 0.03703412041068077, 0.01617310754954815, -0.06324759125709534, 0.0142970597371459, 0.03926270082592964, 0.047002602368593216, -0.015147276222705841, 0.021499043330550194, -0.03444025665521622, -0.0040753972716629505, 0.009934314526617527, -0.037177424877882004, -0.018955452367663383, -0.013085680082440376, -0.008629409596323967, 0.009046955965459347, -0.03690211474895477, -0.07348590344190598, 0.02275897189974785, 0.0019130047876387835, 0.029889700934290886, 0.0009148724493570626, -0.03292008116841316, -0.043822720646858215, 0.0182088203728199, -0.01873955875635147, 0.056445300579071045, -0.016442956402897835, -0.033488161861896515, 0.05307551100850105, 0.024346524849534035, -0.0002461539697833359, -0.06537702679634094, 0.0038162367418408394, 0.03312906250357628, -0.009303558617830276, 0.03412700444459915, -0.015581064857542515, -0.04864131286740303, 0.0670047327876091, -0.008317871950566769, -0.006788205821067095, 0.006413728464394808, -0.034820910543203354, 0.030176576226949692, -0.005305090919137001, 0.031957920640707016, 0.040406908839941025, 0.04269889369606972, 0.006470690947026014, -0.005973100662231445, -0.02298750914633274, -0.0073834378272295, -0.04137640818953514, 0.007724990602582693, -0.044182851910591125, 0.000635947217233479, -0.01672479696571827, 0.012956835329532623, 0.012863353826105595, 0.025378702208399773, -0.037338465452194214, -0.05419599264860153, 0.020661303773522377, 0.020633535459637642, -0.01543229166418314, -0.004292569123208523, -0.0035291071981191635, 0.02591017819941044, -0.011200460605323315, -0.0020339905750006437, 0.009617197327315807, -0.01405294332653284, 0.026190128177404404, 0.029364708811044693, -0.049907658249139786, 0.020973360165953636, -0.0006910139345563948, -0.04022623971104622, 0.02045484445989132, -0.025306005030870438, 0.021636400371789932, -0.0361274853348732, 0.010031023062765598, -0.007940643467009068, -0.046511098742485046, 0.01511305756866932, 0.006425003986805677, 0.020410388708114624, 0.029179664328694344, -0.026317959651350975, 0.045617032796144485, -0.010983338579535484, -0.006241888739168644, -0.06298929452896118, -0.06062891706824303, 0.00736846262589097, -0.005295831710100174, -0.002060436410829425, -0.0355478972196579, -0.008974828757345676, -0.035481687635183334, -0.04318249598145485, -0.016288161277770996, 0.08629410713911057, 0.015394876711070538, -0.005133075639605522, -0.015781713649630547, 0.037374600768089294, 0.04512498527765274, -0.010415686294436455, -0.04361256957054138, 0.03021579422056675, -0.036026470363140106, -0.01545555330812931, 0.0167137011885643, -0.001883459510281682, -0.04525225609540939, 0.020827755331993103, -0.03506091609597206, 0.002287068869918585, 0.024433277547359467, 0.003557265503332019, -0.014004199765622616, 0.03049285151064396, -0.0192328542470932, -0.0268096886575222, -0.005774135235697031, 0.0026020302902907133, -0.014279027469456196, -0.024703746661543846, 0.013951573520898819, -0.03531656041741371, 0.014876383356750011, 0.01624060794711113, 0.038257796317338943, 0.002729959785938263, -0.027122478932142258, -0.006856472231447697, 0.04713316261768341, 0.032243020832538605, -0.0014317730674520135, -0.01237137895077467, -0.02708689495921135, 0.05796482414007187, 0.04219643026590347, -0.010193586349487305, 0.011883893981575966, 0.029498497024178505, -0.03392716124653816, -0.0536625012755394, -0.04410659521818161, 0.009863793849945068, 0.023625029250979424, -0.0019738797564059496, 0.03483041748404503, 0.04830578714609146, 0.007180146872997284, -0.04734146222472191, -0.02535867504775524, -0.02835264801979065, 0.012758331373333931, 0.004013493657112122, 0.01977747306227684, -0.015134901739656925, 0.014328154735267162, 0.024217776954174042, 0.008436577394604683, 0.020665744319558144, 0.03596086427569389, 0.01093353983014822, 0.0036292984150350094, 0.0436866395175457, -0.034128330647945404, -0.028151268139481544, 0.01675243489444256, -0.032504335045814514, 0.03536767140030861, -0.02506268583238125, -0.058110084384679794, 0.01795555278658867, 0.024614444002509117, 0.0456434041261673, -0.027691591531038284, -0.004837892949581146, -0.056003015488386154, -0.008662055246531963, 0.022665949538350105, -0.011920192278921604, 0.04608438163995743, -0.0055268979631364346, 0.003760839579626918, 0.0016196720534935594, 0.04967351630330086, -0.02158834971487522, -0.08674690872430801, 0.002427204279229045, 0.008077128790318966, 0.0041840290650725365, 0.013696539215743542, 0.017892912030220032, -0.000017099948308896273, 0.04597429186105728, -0.029320644214749336, -0.018184691667556763, -0.015590663067996502, 0.06589432060718536, 0.005398706533014774, 0.03189283609390259, -0.006980452686548233, -0.027621697634458542, -0.014510600827634335, -0.021213263273239136, 0.10367739945650101, 0.09216310828924179, 0.03302289918065071, -0.05174129828810692, 0.018012635409832, 0.008145153522491455, -0.009983116760849953, -0.015375123359262943, 0.0025074086152017117, 0.008250858634710312, 0.0024290827568620443, 0.028072666376829147, 0.03878689929842949, -0.013241652399301529, 0.021426819264888763, 0.041333332657814026, -0.04655260220170021, -0.018398115411400795, -0.013103309087455273, 0.020298443734645844, 0.023556191474199295, -0.020684512332081795, -0.0013869218528270721, 0.017798474058508873, 0.0068750339560210705, -0.0362430065870285, -0.02435038983821869, -0.025293169543147087, 0.009418399073183537, -0.008199679665267467, -0.015652451664209366, -0.009229439310729504, 0.02382209151983261, 0.0012926224153488874, 0.02302914671599865, -0.022739730775356293, 0.01597185805439949, -0.046278662979602814, 0.03626213222742081, 0.024889249354600906, -0.03850434347987175, -0.008232680149376392, 0.03876145929098129, 0.006368005648255348, -0.03032867982983589, -0.05304708704352379, -0.016748180612921715, 0.05706845596432686, -0.013356040231883526, 0.005916334688663483, -0.03482503071427345, -0.0055411094799637794, 0.01955134980380535, -0.012606125324964523, -0.04985123872756958, 0.01691553182899952, 0.011509555391967297, -0.021677887067198753, -0.0019909930415451527, -0.008334482088685036, 0.00556459603831172, -0.00443240674212575, 0.04222067445516586, 0.059889525175094604, -0.05314481630921364, 0.01255778782069683, -0.009876912459731102, 0.04374639317393303, 0.004589882213622332, -0.00506359850987792, 0.029651036486029625, -0.022968515753746033, 0.009908808395266533, 0.01552610658109188, 0.024634698405861855, 0.01995159685611725, 0.008444555103778839, -0.00502004474401474, -0.0026515587233006954, -0.03835052624344826, -0.03960870951414108, 0.013575203716754913, -0.045645661652088165, 0.003239547600969672, -0.0566863976418972, 0.00017052216571755707, 0.0058598872274160385, 0.03677874803543091, 0.015229384414851665, -0.014886569231748581, 0.014871095307171345, 0.07184923440217972, 0.02985050529241562, -0.043783847242593765, -0.002740073250606656, -0.022578047588467598, -0.039084404706954956, 0.009323964826762676, 0.010233975015580654, 0.02452746033668518, -0.009413206949830055, 0.0198367889970541, -0.017372461035847664, 0.014274814166128635, -0.010987773537635803, -0.014766817912459373, -0.008071080781519413, -0.06117140129208565, -0.05330091342329979, 0.009255128912627697, 0.036842893809080124, -0.016776783391833305, 0.0008357964688912034, -0.015858817845582962, -0.027481164783239365, 0.016539188101887703, 0.021895505487918854, -0.008530128747224808, 0.05809434875845909, -0.016140282154083252, 0.01373322308063507, -0.02545010671019554, 0.016817286610603333, -0.006985360290855169, -0.0368775948882103, 0.01732305809855461, -0.010978003963828087, 0.0010325851617380977, 0.025164015591144562, 0.020914193242788315, -0.003109386656433344, 0.02344726026058197, 0.02088754251599312, 0.018667973577976227, 0.025657152757048607, 0.028066514059901237, -0.02350701205432415, 0.029568558558821678, -0.0020908808801323175, -0.034382641315460205, 0.01376473717391491, -0.05635926499962807, 0.005338454153388739, 0.019519444555044174, 0.01812382973730564, 0.02792580984532833, 0.003162837354466319, -0.007132380735129118, -0.02051023580133915, 0.013667164370417595, -0.02255174331367016, -0.004484786186367273, 0.02416754700243473, 0.030383478850126266, -0.018031857907772064, 0.02282918617129326, 0.011683733202517033, 0.009088165126740932, -0.00387673731893301, 0.025175204500555992, 0.03094414249062538, 0.020151639357209206, -0.0028817527927458286, 0.047336045652627945, 0.012690247967839241, 0.012367427349090576, 0.01841202937066555, -0.011603718623518944, -0.0005925839650444686, 0.05842893198132515, -0.020240657031536102, 0.04480139538645744, -0.018525488674640656, 0.004771429579705, -0.07316026091575623, -0.021071728318929672, 0.017671233043074608, -0.017122391611337662, 0.023068580776453018, -0.031811755150556564, 0.021174386143684387, 0.05597662553191185, -0.01713060960173607, 0.0011538640828803182, -0.017520232126116753, -0.010160736739635468, -0.008003772236406803, -0.03204505145549774, -0.03372158855199814, 0.011593669652938843, 0.01965494640171528, 0.02525162883102894, 0.039801497012376785, 0.0501677580177784, -0.010312479920685291, -0.020065810531377792, -0.0070396908558905125, 0.018416302278637886, 0.046670008450746536, -0.055617183446884155, 0.07572270929813385, -0.04190477356314659, -0.048188451677560806, 0.03899208828806877, 0.008822106756269932, 0.031992051750421524, 0.027745908126235008, 0.039599038660526276, 0.014573748223483562, 0.06491809338331223, 0.03512341529130936, 0.030426450073719025, 0.017723936587572098, 0.011633317917585373, -0.006467489991337061, -0.004418392200022936, -0.059973347932100296, 0.020844154059886932, 0.027180982753634453, 0.0074300942942500114, -0.03817266598343849, -0.0003375804517418146, 0.0021696663461625576, -0.011874536983668804, 0.011108847334980965, -0.04130150377750397, 0.009606492705643177, -0.061565037816762924, 0.026568247005343437, -0.04840046539902687, -0.008161424659192562, 0.031190982088446617, 0.030369937419891357, -0.015244166366755962, 0.008379909209907055, -0.01701865717768669, -0.04482453688979149, 0.041759148240089417, -0.019848400726914406, -0.011462513357400894, -0.07467744499444962, -0.017979077994823456, -0.017098911106586456, -0.019074534997344017, -0.06300051510334015, -0.027993422001600266, -0.05383388698101044, 0.01931367628276348, -0.041856613010168076, 0.008711901493370533, 0.041776128113269806, -0.003658049274235964, 0.00446171872317791, -0.046434350311756134, 0.06692562252283096, 0.007321460638195276, 0.03792107477784157, 0.013678636401891708, -0.0020666993223130703, -0.032268404960632324, 0.023188842460513115, 0.07056555896997452, -0.005030442029237747, -0.017984773963689804, 0.04684104397892952, 0.03900705277919769, -0.0024384052958339453, -0.03787389025092125, 0.007973803207278252, 0.011303890496492386, -0.022882632911205292, -0.010252503678202629, 0.0020776723977178335, -0.01021525263786316, -0.012914624065160751, 0.03559402376413345, -0.01563118025660515, -0.013228782452642918, 0.016042588278651237, 0.0007429788820445538, 0.04769669845700264, 0.02657053805887699, -0.006452970672398806, 0.056970298290252686, -0.005974318366497755, 0.034260790795087814, 0.028915081173181534, -0.006535571999847889, -0.10565287619829178, 0.02279481664299965, -0.01946013979613781, 0.0059300996363162994, -0.012716464698314667, -0.0012232711305841804, -0.014362247660756111, -0.039566945284605026, -0.0042844489216804504, 0.027772672474384308, -0.023242073133587837, 0.0010927944676950574, 0.04965989664196968, -0.00819934532046318, 0.04589556157588959, 0.012114521116018295, 0.001524406368844211, 0.02143223024904728, 0.002676652278751135, 0.01713487319648266, 0.01627316325902939, 0.025698594748973846, 0.013744821771979332, 0.03800243139266968, -0.024573709815740585, -0.023556021973490715, 0.04802297428250313, -0.027549773454666138, -0.014218161813914776, -0.028066201135516167, -0.01482382696121931, 0.025508366525173187, 0.015283438377082348, -0.01266598142683506, -0.032882776111364365, -0.027209989726543427, 0.053498901426792145, -0.05127939209342003, -0.001279923366382718, -0.0034380012657493353, -0.0003310949541628361, -0.006205433048307896, 0.00858334731310606, -0.01826140470802784, 0.031029243022203445, 0.0016899186884984374, 0.019691310822963715, -0.01891167089343071, -0.0033629131503403187, 0.02125675417482853, 0.005585951264947653, -0.024602536112070084, 0.002010537311434746, -0.015341146849095821, -0.011709168553352356, -0.04530841112136841, -0.01713528297841549, -0.04134010151028633, 0.007058190181851387, 0.05476103350520134, 0.024397945031523705, -0.043216925114393234, -0.005155290476977825, 0.034725405275821686, 0.07213213294744492, -0.04384356364607811, -0.022743303328752518, 0.002770929131656885, -0.026054300367832184, -0.02538425102829933, -0.05808980390429497 ]
<p>I would like to calculate Student's t test of two normal distribution data. However, I do not have the data at all, but only mean and standard deviation of each population. So, how can I simulate those data in R and calculate the t.test among both?</p> <p>These are the values (mean and SD): Population 1: 6,62 +- 0.52 years Population 2: 6.31 +- 0.49 years</p> <p>Thanks in advance Mario</p>
73,670
[ -0.033812761306762695, -0.03464867174625397, -0.015506607480347157, 0.015142302960157394, 0.00025287960306741297, -0.004312809091061354, -0.004874698352068663, -0.022936519235372543, 0.02325124479830265, -0.02243042178452015, 0.02522258646786213, 0.04172734171152115, 0.023030119016766548, 0.011331649497151375, 0.03754956275224686, -0.009435020387172699, -0.039421260356903076, 0.003471638076007366, -0.005215809680521488, -0.022470401600003242, -0.004220266826450825, -0.014957726001739502, 0.021877674385905266, -0.027783753350377083, -0.02421361766755581, 0.05741698294878006, 0.010916601866483688, -0.02997000515460968, -0.005668092984706163, 0.06102968007326126, -0.060748063027858734, -0.060379914939403534, 0.015640661120414734, 0.042281974107027054, 0.00977884978055954, 0.02728649415075779, -0.06458835303783417, -0.005554234609007835, -0.007257926743477583, 0.007496511097997427, -0.04014008119702339, -0.012524458579719067, 0.0022078058682382107, 0.030851759016513824, -0.017027653753757477, 0.028106804937124252, -0.022407827898859978, -0.025677161291241646, 0.010617171414196491, -0.03502959385514259, 0.058465149253606796, -0.0008533808286301792, 0.06450869143009186, 0.022319737821817398, 0.0020908694714307785, 0.003885374404489994, 0.04926137998700142, 0.04970957338809967, -0.002177504589781165, -0.054830700159072876, 0.004335377831012011, -0.03955010324716568, -0.038668278604745865, -0.02007179707288742, -0.046796269714832306, -0.029920360073447227, -0.013327300548553467, -0.008744710125029087, 0.0284188911318779, -0.030124003067612648, 0.05134528502821922, 0.03617241978645325, 0.02919081225991249, -0.014052988030016422, 0.01802370883524418, -0.01650545559823513, 0.038736455142498016, -0.00023874877661000937, 0.03720497712492943, 0.022406380623579025, 0.022639378905296326, 0.02618938311934471, 0.043062057346105576, 0.039791908115148544, 0.019952012225985527, -0.02428155578672886, 0.06521814316511154, 0.009199146181344986, -0.002920665079727769, 0.030922239646315575, -0.00438104709610343, 0.0035680015571415424, 0.06750857830047607, 0.01284544263035059, -0.04559352248907089, 0.04162990301847458, -0.018287358805537224, 0.06626605242490768, -0.011610602028667927, 0.0017693598056212068, 0.005257892422378063, -0.055881842970848083, 0.034377969801425934, 0.057482700794935226, -0.014824130572378635, -0.022336434572935104, -0.008846567012369633, -0.007609898224473, -0.015595964156091213, -0.021280117332935333, -0.020701445639133453, 0.02774421125650406, 0.003964508883655071, -0.018312111496925354, 0.04867508262395859, -0.005569739732891321, -0.011519682593643665, -0.026008138433098793, 0.06764630228281021, 0.0284042339771986, 0.05165642872452736, -0.030404292047023773, 0.025572823360562325, -0.0028939666226506233, -0.04787532612681389, 0.021031294018030167, -0.008645959198474884, -0.01534848753362894, -0.043251749128103256, 0.05013514682650566, -0.029103219509124756, -0.034392084926366806, 0.0456123985350132, 0.00421574292704463, 0.062270063906908035, -0.014495247974991798, -0.06644566357135773, -0.05974584445357323, -0.008687040768563747, -0.03676705062389374, -0.014022467657923698, -0.056963302195072174, -0.001986589515581727, 0.01731116510927677, 0.0028339638374745846, 0.02503131330013275, 0.04067574441432953, 0.003716140054166317, 0.03803881257772446, 0.02477307803928852, -0.022403249517083168, 0.0030377840157598257, -0.01796451397240162, -0.0008216464193537831, -0.00858690869063139, -0.0817081555724144, 0.0019353380193933845, 0.024548664689064026, -0.026644689962267876, -0.008037002757191658, 0.022855345159769058, -0.007964018732309341, -0.00863510463386774, -0.0006057483842596412, 0.04032614454627037, -0.04755817726254463, 0.06556247174739838, 0.00509928772225976, 0.010418127290904522, 0.002867005066946149, -0.04223906621336937, 0.011693066917359829, -0.015981778502464294, 0.04255704581737518, 0.034235306084156036, -0.02247214876115322, -0.011531882919371128, 0.015736863017082214, 0.03551443666219711, 0.03714534267783165, -0.030119620263576508, 0.011134992353618145, 0.0006559128523804247, -0.009541327133774757, 0.014874259009957314, 0.04571633040904999, 0.010695770382881165, -0.018195467069745064, 0.01880968175828457, -0.03734675794839859, -0.043235842138528824, -0.06946537643671036, -0.024326898157596588, -0.002731392392888665, -0.03235399350523949, -0.014611040242016315, 0.02888002246618271, 0.07635517418384552, -0.02176811918616295, -0.021652506664395332, -0.02420288510620594, -0.000046557350287912413, 0.03686434403061867, -0.025730011984705925, 0.008806507103145123, 0.06694421172142029, 0.08497527241706848, -0.027379347011446953, 0.04133841022849083, -0.029859384521842003, -0.02256152592599392, 0.0008873828919604421, -0.05995842069387436, 0.034170474857091904, 0.016592159867286682, -0.02214379794895649, 0.010615009814500809, -0.010693523101508617, 0.00043589810957200825, 0.04007987678050995, -0.039124008268117905, 0.04378256946802139, 0.059135809540748596, 0.020757198333740234, -0.018143676221370697, -0.02322564087808132, 0.005169128533452749, 0.039919547736644745, -0.02091548591852188, 0.0008543285075575113, -0.041250213980674744, -0.021187108010053635, 0.0458688922226429, 0.03482110798358917, -0.03826474770903587, 0.00316985254175961, 0.03622894734144211, -0.014621389098465443, 0.025459425523877144, 0.05434572324156761, 0.0017725781071931124, -0.017781417816877365, -0.025388410314917564, 0.012961558066308498, 0.014783123508095741, 0.01106695830821991, 0.027280190959572792, 0.019976656883955002, 0.03524826094508171, 0.027818037196993828, -0.007026653736829758, 0.07178141176700592, 0.0025880825705826283, 0.023097071796655655, -0.012937409803271294, -0.023236917331814766, 0.02523650974035263, -0.018227364867925644, -0.030045030638575554, 0.04580015316605568, -0.015095256268978119, -0.035003066062927246, 0.02735823020339012, -0.02038242481648922, 0.0009734776103869081, 0.03159467130899429, -0.0028851439710706472, 0.01847381703555584, 0.022500455379486084, -0.04417916759848595, 0.004926173482090235, 0.00863654725253582, -0.03495917469263077, -0.018584292382001877, 0.01888272911310196, 0.0193631611764431, 0.012199942022562027, 0.028078554198145866, -0.02748940885066986, -0.04511018097400665, 0.016146007925271988, -0.012506231665611267, -0.012534881010651588, -0.012680226005613804, -0.07093307375907898, 0.02596125192940235, -0.00029487087158486247, -0.04962179437279701, 0.011397136375308037, 0.008956351317465305, -0.017289752140641212, 0.029350977391004562, -0.024689817801117897, -0.042024265974760056, -0.01734459586441517, -0.025245962664484978, -0.02705811709165573, -0.00011849029397126287, 0.023995254188776016, 0.010183344595134258, 0.027232525870203972, -0.03307927027344704, 0.018895700573921204, -0.05884687229990959, -0.050172626972198486, -0.04973501339554787, 0.0001697111438261345, 0.02451835386455059, -0.013464384712278843, 0.011926488019526005, 0.029394902288913727, -0.03943251073360443, 0.0011130643542855978, -0.07123291492462158, -0.021202849224209785, 0.043828316032886505, 0.03512442111968994, 0.04421970620751381, 0.007082686293870211, -0.03523550555109978, 0.0767533928155899, 0.004479731433093548, -0.019660690799355507, -0.03828303888440132, 0.0002708873071242124, -0.03765425458550453, -0.0012851387728005648, 0.053009241819381714, 0.0219251811504364, -0.02136554755270481, -0.02063012681901455, 0.015738699585199356, -0.017462750896811485, 0.08092591166496277, -0.006852305494248867, -0.002452919725328684, -0.02384663186967373, -0.005030354484915733, -0.01326842326670885, 0.07737431675195694, -0.022274428978562355, -0.03281490132212639, 0.011710947379469872, -0.0039382996037602425, 0.046516209840774536, -0.01769471913576126, -0.024184783920645714, 0.018860600888729095, 0.008581383153796196, 0.015700044110417366, -0.05739893391728401, 0.02680400013923645, 0.02550916187465191, -0.01842588745057583, 0.006339573301374912, 0.03327272832393646, 0.006907833274453878, -0.008116411045193672, -0.004285366274416447, 0.0625978410243988, 0.038969337940216064, -0.021729053929448128, -0.025062695145606995, 0.023350927978754044, -0.007111606653779745, -0.0011112880893051624, -0.03368077799677849, -0.042082998901605606, 0.0562753900885582, 0.031896624714136124, 0.013274844735860825, 0.017758237197995186, -0.02207891084253788, 0.011288609355688095, -0.07106107473373413, 0.019413677975535393, -0.04354602470993996, 0.04702332988381386, 0.0009617781033739448, 0.02666131779551506, 0.010111589916050434, 0.013446714729070663, 0.01509042363613844, -0.028306033462285995, -0.04994533956050873, 0.0607660673558712, -0.011727413162589073, -0.042480841279029846, 0.0006706654094159603, 0.0038931735325604677, 0.032078854739665985, -0.0019545401446521282, 0.03426654636859894, -0.001525869476608932, -0.022352125495672226, -0.03600910305976868, -0.022070253267884254, -0.025317441672086716, -0.002463418524712324, 0.0017001372762024403, 0.03034971095621586, 0.007301453500986099, -0.012278619222342968, -0.013088403269648552, 0.03700168430805206, 0.003031597938388586, -0.0064340755343437195, -0.03186102956533432, -0.01030266284942627, 0.010289253666996956, 0.052013467997312546, 0.06718672066926956, 0.04081830009818077, -0.0403427854180336, 0.029007170349359512, -0.016006045043468475, 0.060252994298934937, 0.06306261569261551, 0.003751434152945876, -0.027799731120467186, -0.05178440734744072, -0.02128322795033455, -0.008784460835158825, 0.005517126061022282, -0.035676565021276474, 0.0014126267051324248, 0.0447126142680645, 0.030924033373594284, -0.04849028214812279, 0.03392551466822624, 0.06387902796268463, 0.012991566210985184, 0.01572989486157894, -0.0258988868445158, -0.008452188223600388, -0.036881960928440094, -0.014349179342389107, 0.045781031250953674, 0.03467385098338127, -0.0026423027738928795, 0.022382915019989014, 0.04153435677289963, 0.005668599158525467, -0.010210481472313404, -0.0003692197205964476, 0.03598630800843239, 0.06572774052619934, 0.0062483991496264935, -0.04204431176185608, 0.005787694361060858, 0.03883622586727142, 0.008300568908452988, -0.016536029055714607, 0.030058478936553, -0.07788166403770447, -0.0005160851287655532, 0.03286369517445564, 0.026901371777057648, -0.029528876766562462, -0.018260138109326363, -0.04220440238714218, 0.003787212772294879, 0.05616696923971176, -0.05114185810089111, 0.005820488557219505, -0.009333614259958267, -0.013282365165650845, -0.011109563522040844, 0.02108907513320446, -0.05353135988116264, 0.022952338680624962, -0.06258208304643631, -0.002633946482092142, -0.02697053924202919, -0.022345608100295067, -0.03450006991624832, -0.006346719339489937, 0.009130953811109066, 0.08854762464761734, -0.015004430897533894, -0.02779959701001644, 0.014218756929039955, 0.036515019834041595, -0.013225581496953964, -0.026894275099039078, 0.0023542887065559626, -0.007384418975561857, -0.01913091540336609, 0.04844174534082413, -0.023249970749020576, 0.007005966734141111, 0.04054439440369606, 0.025970296934247017, -0.008584380149841309, -0.009429584257304668, 0.006944524589926004, 0.012383486144244671, 0.03721611201763153, 0.00018127854855265468, 0.06075778231024742, 0.006432091351598501, 0.023934418335556984, -0.00835572462528944, -0.012674961239099503, 0.026382656767964363, -0.02918362431228161, -0.023505426943302155, -0.05560194328427315, -0.035232920199632645, -0.006240003742277622, 0.005286445375531912, -0.023344160988926888, 0.03282563388347626, -0.045678552240133286, 0.02301340363919735, 0.02853756956756115, 0.035419341176748276, 0.0066938698291778564, 0.004531917627900839, 0.017312580719590187, 0.007687889039516449, -0.010818521492183208, -0.044997092336416245, 0.014384724199771881, -0.0060483673587441444, -0.010236955247819424, 0.005552356131374836, -0.05874469503760338, 0.048901546746492386, -0.0010305405594408512, -0.06990500539541245, 0.007103439886122942, -0.037753961980342865, 0.010993881151080132, -0.03749029338359833, 0.07218404114246368, 0.03598416969180107, -0.020936641842126846, 0.00841954443603754, 0.050495654344558716, 0.010373586788773537, 0.02653229981660843, -0.036954592913389206, 0.08199016004800797, 0.010524551384150982, -0.015976153314113617, -0.06795333325862885, -0.04131288453936577, -0.003520944155752659, 0.009799064137041569, -0.010566189885139465, -0.08419238775968552, 0.0013664045836776495, -0.010324719361960888, 0.017384059727191925, -0.02837064303457737, 0.0458245649933815, 0.009515175595879555, 0.002811111742630601, -0.04106698930263519, -0.011406042613089085, 0.0776350274682045, 0.008367003872990608, 0.029518144205212593, -0.009617224335670471, -0.016981350257992744, -0.03534528985619545, -0.019616998732089996, 0.028951488435268402, -0.019342217594385147, 0.012260534800589085, -0.014911264181137085, -0.00008818718924885616, 0.03258776292204857, -0.014511117711663246, -0.01175414677709341, -0.008017384447157383, 0.011891793459653854, 0.027874857187271118, -0.0539875291287899, 0.015584003180265427, -0.016378600150346756, 0.01622598245739937, -0.07409819215536118, 0.011758651584386826, -0.030836908146739006, 0.017574969679117203, -0.00004682446888182312, 0.006661504041403532, -0.026833483949303627, -0.009961343370378017, 0.07415852695703506, -0.002184003358706832, 0.018361277878284454, -0.03364085406064987, -0.004613690543919802, 0.032730795443058014, 0.022883422672748566, -0.03315691277384758, 0.02342432178556919, 0.0034412320237606764, -0.028632501140236855, -0.0033707807306200266, -0.019372889772057533, -0.006174902431666851, 0.059660620987415314, -0.01840253733098507, 0.05950811505317688, 0.07848229259252548, 0.01916814222931862, 0.022618327289819717, -0.013095439411699772, -0.017244810238480568, 0.009032152593135834, 0.00416482612490654, 0.048764247447252274, 0.0011217425344511867, 0.012204322963953018, 0.035969801247119904, -0.0010426880326122046, 0.010671280324459076, 0.07102100551128387, -0.0016975541366264224, -0.013248995877802372, 0.02618129551410675, 0.002057621954008937, -0.020937850698828697, 0.011996823363006115, -0.026882225647568703, 0.027513789013028145, -0.03219825029373169, -0.0009354809299111366, 0.04398902878165245, 0.0011900885729119182, -0.011230278760194778, -0.026699142530560493, -0.010040711611509323, -0.050011053681373596, 0.015828819945454597, 0.025147339329123497, -0.009344818070530891, 0.02642013318836689, 0.040784433484077454, 0.014277259819209576, -0.02245543710887432, 0.056272901594638824, -0.05228784307837486, -0.056007541716098785, -0.030926551669836044, -0.05642673000693321, -0.030966460704803467, 0.05250122398138046, 0.020839476957917213, -0.01366538554430008, 0.02655784972012043, -0.0417996309697628, 0.033582426607608795, -0.008738851174712181, 0.027332952246069908, -0.01184268482029438, 0.09238901734352112, 0.015893690288066864, 0.041654013097286224, 0.008774388581514359, 0.0035717322025448084, 0.10589009523391724, 0.0359853096306324, 0.02276661992073059, -0.09957505017518997, -0.030455200001597404, -0.020777085795998573, -0.0036930919159203768, 0.0014655194245278835, 0.008398550562560558, 0.03105260245501995, -0.016318343579769135, 0.059936605393886566, 0.04641034081578255, 0.03910094499588013, -0.012880411930382252, 0.055801719427108765, -0.01595054566860199, -0.009610787965357304, 0.011286868713796139, 0.004692296497523785, -0.01732371188700199, -0.027665933594107628, -0.057385336607694626, 0.027691159397363663, -0.028339417651295662, 0.033299271017313004, -0.04839324578642845, -0.010287613607943058, -0.004982504528015852, 0.007474494632333517, -0.043830834329128265, 0.010634981095790863, 0.00908749084919691, 0.014835978858172894, -0.022557320073246956, -0.022061530500650406, -0.0020444944966584444, -0.024403445422649384, 0.024035491049289703, 0.0223318450152874, -0.012439879588782787, 0.009175220504403114, -0.005144471302628517, 0.0012737816432490945, -0.027702011168003082, 0.0005583565216511488, -0.01490903552621603, 0.060770511627197266, -0.006925332825630903, -0.02448944002389908, -0.00018541475583333522, 0.002761996351182461, -0.0002570336509961635, -0.02352253720164299, -0.04270211607217789, -0.00041300812154076993, 0.028197772800922394, -0.03015599399805069, 0.03300977870821953, -0.03188023343682289, 0.01855180226266384, -0.02585889771580696, 0.052235182374715805, 0.021659012883901596, -0.006767775397747755, -0.009500621818006039, -0.05110105499625206, 0.038834426552057266, -0.04538746550679207, -0.014436742290854454, 0.009198591113090515, -0.013871083036065102, -0.02374674379825592, 0.008772584609687328, 0.023940522223711014, 0.01563883386552334, 0.017127614468336105, 0.011007110588252544, 0.0025479712057858706, 0.001699973363429308, -0.026199141517281532, 0.021529870107769966, -0.020936144515872, -0.008264594711363316, -0.024507073685526848, -0.02508385479450226, 0.04792146012187004, 0.05786539241671562, 0.013338260352611542, 0.018573949113488197, 0.01556774415075779, 0.01966436579823494, 0.029372600838541985, -0.07744746655225754, 0.006871528923511505, 0.006660175044089556, -0.028935572132468224, -0.005556821823120117, -0.0457618348300457, 0.04261595383286476, 0.030390039086341858, 0.03261565789580345, -0.03993237763643265, 0.01429925486445427, -0.01417458150535822, 0.003639877075329423, -0.026788080111145973, -0.05971182882785797, -0.0032777120359241962, 0.023521438241004944, 0.02840207889676094, -0.01756097935140133, 0.02048724703490734, -0.02831880934536457, -0.03740810975432396, 0.028020089492201805, -0.024557938799262047, -0.020320678129792213, -0.00774576049298048, -0.012706496752798557, 0.007041700650006533, -0.02195565029978752, 0.03591073676943779, -0.024920159950852394, -0.003753757569938898, -0.009197109378874302, -0.0032857831101864576, -0.034482695162296295, 0.029447244480252266, -0.006161505822092295, 0.01682097464799881, 0.041157711297273636, 0.014628459699451923, 0.01759146712720394, 0.007317880168557167, 0.02494976483285427, -0.013754271902143955, 0.031898707151412964, 0.008380061946809292, 0.010930357500910759, 0.05193231254816055, -0.0553765743970871, -0.010852765291929245, -0.005116250831633806, 0.008872225880622864, 0.04403238743543625, -0.009067232720553875, -0.04028720781207085, -0.012188015505671501, 0.08569878339767456, -0.049947235733270645, -0.023462669923901558, -0.022874057292938232, -0.006356615107506514, -0.00486903777346015, -0.005862021818757057, 0.002517920918762684, 0.020045235753059387, -0.0029607941396534443, 0.012784605845808983, 0.03579927608370781, -0.03181258216500282, 0.030629290267825127, 0.0004738705465570092, 0.019366396591067314, 0.023008868098258972, 0.010858752764761448, -0.02642807364463806, 0.0582737997174263, 0.07225921750068665, 0.004085681866854429, 0.01857162080705166, -0.03409840539097786, -0.004210527520626783, -0.10988380014896393, 0.003864416154101491, 0.024766825139522552, -0.03453400731086731, 0.05709991231560707, -0.039359692484140396, -0.010508202016353607, 0.02416909858584404, -0.042759571224451065, 0.006674259901046753, -0.017092352733016014, -0.04589569568634033, -0.01332031935453415, 0.012932518497109413, 0.010146040469408035, 0.007829300127923489, 0.0052626123651862144, 0.036981403827667236, 0.02469046786427498, 0.019830549135804176, 0.002426593331620097, 0.014513477683067322, -0.05720074847340584, -0.021144451573491096, 0.017768803983926773, -0.0749698281288147, -0.015118344686925411, -0.0343647226691246, -0.029706040397286415, 0.0021746940910816193, 0.007177240680903196, 0.033242564648389816, 0.0021162936463952065, 0.033872537314891815, -0.006706411484628916, 0.046843674033880234, 0.028587907552719116, 0.0015972609398886561, -0.01935471221804619, 0.001795938122086227, 0.023003719747066498, 0.014048161916434765, -0.03266508877277374, -0.016194958239793777, 0.027789024636149406, -0.01393418200314045, -0.005771114490926266, 0.03429379686713219, -0.0002893855853471905, -0.03040739707648754, -0.023234695196151733, -0.009727695025503635, 0.01135030947625637, -0.028795232996344566, -0.018076181411743164, -0.04087051376700401, 0.012577216140925884, 0.05573984980583191, 0.028727401047945023, -0.0016476690070703626, 0.01386129017919302, -0.04326814040541649, -0.0359036847949028, 0.004118986427783966, 0.0051438771188259125, -0.010610830970108509, -0.04257377237081528, -0.005776706151664257, 0.0031222375109791756, -0.01420530304312706, -0.018152955919504166, -0.013995276764035225, -0.0384158231317997, 0.040667977184057236, 0.004031513351947069, 0.01866987720131874, 0.008975877426564693, 0.0004824335628654808, 0.0218843761831522, -0.038115814328193665, 0.05983637273311615, -0.014057142660021782, -0.008622311055660248, -0.03367219120264053, 0.015588455833494663, -0.05817895010113716, 0.007203572429716587, 0.037041373550891876, 0.031186053529381752, 0.0317634716629982, 0.009422508999705315, 0.02626717835664749, 0.007034379988908768, -0.084439218044281, 0.012005623430013657, -0.004945814143866301, -0.05249105766415596, -0.008049208670854568, -0.005727787036448717, 0.03204004094004631, 0.01697930507361889, -0.030087793245911598, -0.018953939899802208, 0.007266170345246792, 0.030180785804986954, -0.004115200135856867, 0.025053109973669052, 0.004319558385759592, -0.027260707691311836, 0.03015553392469883, -0.033750761300325394, 0.01754165254533291, 0.019463926553726196, 0.029531745240092278, -0.009660237468779087, 0.034120336174964905, -0.033176522701978683, -0.03459944203495979, -0.01695600524544716, 0.007351377978920937, -0.029630543664097786, -0.051464568823575974, 0.002177500631660223, 0.005886665545403957, -0.01686200499534607, -0.0025148300919681787, 0.02099376730620861, 0.019180603325366974, 0.04516304284334183, -0.04605422914028168, 0.03285494074225426, -0.0036383233964443207, -0.013830652460455894, 0.020036732777953148, -0.010641803033649921, -0.03351718187332153, -0.03012772835791111, -0.015364907681941986, 0.027080826461315155, -0.02924393303692341, 0.008856169879436493, -0.012992574833333492, 0.03432381898164749, -0.0019888796377927065, -0.04635567590594292, -0.002359259407967329, -0.01597082056105137, 0.05421052128076553, -0.00909020658582449, -0.008911354467272758, 0.06846147030591965, -0.03719383850693703, 0.02474113553762436, -0.0274746622890234, -0.031578969210386276, -0.047156255692243576, 0.008353075012564659, 0.006719300523400307, 0.005452081561088562, -0.018453827127814293, 0.004586134571582079, 0.007789565250277519, -0.014836356975138187, 0.018719913437962532, -0.011107617057859898, 0.018915215507149696, -0.031369976699352264, -0.02710552327334881, -0.025208622217178345, 0.004127505235373974, -0.028286295011639595, -0.013757530599832535, 0.023657185956835747, 0.06377600878477097, 0.02408279851078987, -0.05116979405283928, -0.010133574716746807, 0.03166399896144867, 0.04731054604053497, -0.06640080362558365, -0.021156173199415207, -0.04261693358421326, -0.002550603123381734, -0.01509555708616972, -0.0262758806347847 ]
<p>I am new to Neural Networks and trying to implement RBM. I am stuck on initializing the visible layer's bias value. Is it supposed to initialize to some random number or there is some probabilistic distribution by which it should be initialized. In python I am seeing: </p> <pre><code>&gt; "vbias = theano.shared(value =numpy.zeros(n_visible, &gt; dtype = theano.config.floatX), name='vbias') " </code></pre> <p>but don't know what is happening here in this line.</p>
73,671
[ -0.02543765865266323, -0.025998974218964577, -0.030142394825816154, -0.006732019130140543, 0.021066270768642426, 0.0016946932300925255, -0.015312223695218563, -0.013340981677174568, 0.013903281651437283, -0.04062694311141968, 0.03501100465655327, 0.06140919029712677, 0.03781125694513321, -0.009772478602826595, 0.010446218773722649, -0.007882621139287949, -0.009701026603579521, -0.04407200962305069, 0.02683250978589058, -0.021148234605789185, -0.017301632091403008, 0.05630773305892944, 0.04550740495324135, -0.020359938964247704, -0.03811430558562279, 0.01678241789340973, -0.0010313966777175665, -0.01555118802934885, 0.020522264763712883, 0.03912191465497017, -0.06227266415953636, -0.05068163946270943, -0.008597745560109615, 0.004217852372676134, -0.010222085751593113, 0.004993181210011244, -0.038214437663555145, -0.05613699555397034, -0.03621086850762367, 0.010012919083237648, 0.01615535467863083, -0.004143914207816124, 0.0230232086032629, 0.017172742635011673, 0.03326281160116196, -0.009394414722919464, 0.02574908919632435, -0.024228716269135475, 0.06434975564479828, -0.021391963586211205, 0.07498537749052048, -0.022183716297149658, 0.05716662108898163, 0.05971519276499748, -0.01988728530704975, 0.020407896488904953, 0.040962815284729004, 0.07684186846017838, -0.01397229265421629, -0.01712648943066597, 0.004187328275293112, -0.05001695081591606, -0.02728218212723732, -0.040031034499406815, 0.0005341937649063766, 0.004499256610870361, 0.011663238517940044, -0.030585510656237602, 0.057978615164756775, 0.004036529455333948, 0.014612986706197262, -0.004857141990214586, -0.009174959734082222, -0.04398830235004425, 0.013251936063170433, 0.02244347706437111, 0.002245652722194791, -0.0056786490604281425, -0.008443381637334824, 0.006659666076302528, 0.026059186086058617, 0.02438381314277649, -0.014852163381874561, 0.018420923501253128, -0.0004607768205460161, 0.012804046273231506, 0.05553964152932167, -0.006812446750700474, 0.052114736288785934, 0.017582690343260765, -0.04131358116865158, 0.007647525053471327, 0.014374095015227795, 0.032620299607515335, -0.031592898070812225, 0.06129256635904312, 0.014684595167636871, 0.031001916155219078, -0.007411822210997343, -0.03530270606279373, -0.0049177734181284904, -0.01772451028227806, -0.009001435711979866, 0.063077911734581, -0.05802687630057335, -0.03783126547932625, -0.011578789912164211, 0.018630286678671837, 0.0004732560773845762, -0.008210658095777035, -0.03669220209121704, 0.002506944118067622, 0.0022491617128252983, -0.006482814904302359, 0.02735135145485401, -0.014418352395296097, 0.02589557319879532, 0.01646563783288002, -0.017756493762135506, 0.03659519925713539, 0.009625725448131561, -0.009927007369697094, 0.03882865607738495, -0.00035058334469795227, -0.02752278372645378, -0.0016205995343625546, 0.027796482667326927, -0.034547824412584305, -0.015040225349366665, 0.007659973111003637, -0.015153653919696808, -0.064907006919384, 0.024820303544402122, -0.03198863938450813, 0.0536220408976078, -0.0022771006915718317, -0.06153419241309166, -0.04705916717648506, 0.016052816063165665, -0.050198473036289215, 0.03140716627240181, -0.05788114294409752, 0.004963430110365152, 0.056905169039964676, 0.04154656454920769, -0.019647277891635895, 0.024910639971494675, -0.015770958736538887, 0.008299117907881737, -0.008592565543949604, -0.03115038014948368, -0.003967088647186756, -0.04065876081585884, 0.00015381191042251885, -0.032538291066884995, -0.016977250576019287, 0.012042434886097908, 0.01789049617946148, 0.008214186877012253, -0.03190814331173897, 0.010512012057006359, -0.03221992775797844, 0.05020403116941452, 0.02314276248216629, -0.00042398821096867323, -0.03514959663152695, 0.08320742845535278, 0.013052976690232754, 0.07169719785451889, 0.01924889162182808, -0.020644566044211388, -0.006644882261753082, 0.04075106978416443, 0.010896154679358006, 0.041201479732990265, -0.032750096172094345, -0.015224017202854156, -0.03126255422830582, 0.04906272515654564, 0.034674305468797684, -0.053151898086071014, -0.03442661464214325, 0.0045615434646606445, 0.015569291077554226, -0.019165975973010063, 0.02804701216518879, -0.01136727910488844, -0.008654477074742317, 0.009850145317614079, -0.057632215321063995, 0.0203238595277071, -0.016439223662018776, 0.003674361389130354, -0.030076052993535995, 0.02458343468606472, 0.018078988417983055, -0.014685334637761116, -0.004287020768970251, 0.016050836071372032, -0.0024608732201159, -0.04660599306225777, -0.022613881155848503, 0.05009215697646141, -0.02748076803982258, 0.016054343432188034, 0.056495778262615204, -0.004271846730262041, -0.019708214327692986, 0.04951976612210274, -0.014972365461289883, -0.011281410232186317, 0.01641613245010376, 0.007674213033169508, 0.0028586583212018013, -0.03425204008817673, -0.05534635856747627, -0.00002109433444275055, 0.03548288717865944, 0.0014098959509283304, 0.00575726293027401, -0.07196246087551117, 0.04418937489390373, 0.0681074857711792, 0.04061755910515785, 0.015308378264307976, 0.004651333205401897, 0.003995075821876526, -0.00043557968456298113, -0.020175021141767502, 0.015128851868212223, -0.04346533119678497, -0.00825213547796011, 0.04329806938767433, 0.02480616234242916, -0.0172276571393013, -0.0131571926176548, 0.0671933963894844, 0.025903884321451187, 0.05913218483328819, 0.019115906208753586, -0.013434710912406445, 0.03237202763557434, 0.019153712317347527, 0.028046362102031708, 0.04273447021842003, -0.010433853603899479, 0.0019194588530808687, 0.021663248538970947, 0.024040602147579193, 0.008129975758492947, -0.026966659352183342, 0.049567751586437225, -0.0048980568535625935, 0.01210115384310484, -0.04970315098762512, -0.03957631066441536, 0.026701854541897774, -0.008140210062265396, -0.007995321415364742, 0.04601384699344635, 0.010980085469782352, -0.0292437132447958, 0.01529205683618784, -0.02784585766494274, 0.004321240354329348, 0.013376954942941666, -0.02868286520242691, -0.012312344275414944, 0.030808746814727783, -0.025033555924892426, 0.0036583147011697292, 0.020853010937571526, -0.046820417046546936, -0.043580714613199234, -0.008652547374367714, 0.04742584377527237, 0.0006631247815676033, -0.004805796314030886, -0.03735845535993576, -0.0055120824836194515, -0.029483862221240997, 0.02393914759159088, 0.04757612198591232, 0.022045757621526718, -0.05582883954048157, 0.03841983899474144, -0.0193156935274601, -0.03954732045531273, 0.04441099986433983, -0.02199944294989109, -0.06471448391675949, 0.016481705009937286, -0.040306661278009415, -0.01153017207980156, -0.02465055137872696, -0.016969596967101097, 0.006597430445253849, 0.0008631078526377678, -0.00642134714871645, 0.06844306737184525, -0.02666163444519043, -0.018077855929732323, 0.039766184985637665, -0.018009204417467117, -0.03317921608686447, 0.018521800637245178, -0.01562361791729927, -0.022503318265080452, -0.02128925360739231, 0.02926674857735634, 0.026739781722426414, -0.034268882125616074, 0.015413629822432995, -0.04975660890340805, -0.0720115676522255, 0.032266147434711456, -0.014891310594975948, 0.01312226615846157, 0.006872120779007673, 0.02834898978471756, 0.088624507188797, 0.0301029272377491, 0.00912267342209816, -0.029063435271382332, 0.019070958718657494, -0.010112195275723934, -0.044293247163295746, -0.013444538228213787, 0.005536914337426424, 0.04079578444361687, -0.00481374841183424, -0.008219174109399319, 0.042494986206293106, 0.07188458740711212, -0.02623990923166275, -0.010426808148622513, 0.018026402220129967, 0.00027502398006618023, -0.0354604497551918, 0.03490041196346283, 0.048534367233514786, -0.010288659483194351, 0.008111080154776573, -0.02644123136997223, 0.04107752814888954, 0.0059389653615653515, -0.013224142603576183, 0.05815364420413971, -0.02823582850396633, 0.005687409080564976, -0.047121450304985046, 0.04563874006271362, -0.022680286318063736, -0.015421292744576931, -0.006811037193983793, -0.008914276957511902, 0.04728984087705612, -0.059032224118709564, -0.021063972264528275, 0.03516985476016998, -0.0248819999396801, 0.005145891569554806, -0.007767143659293652, -0.0022101306822150946, -0.0076036578975617886, 0.014694356359541416, -0.010208787396550179, 0.006275419145822525, 0.011877324432134628, 0.03232767432928085, 0.014761650934815407, 0.02592574805021286, -0.038814060389995575, -0.009212261065840721, -0.04304967448115349, -0.013551639392971992, 0.023472996428608894, 0.03216094151139259, 0.010463413782417774, 0.00894390232861042, 0.02637225016951561, 0.015333004295825958, -0.0040684654377400875, -0.016033083200454712, -0.04940885677933693, 0.025704357773065567, -0.009037508629262447, -0.011942820623517036, 0.000658235396258533, -0.06377730518579483, 0.01702500693500042, -0.056617315858602524, -0.02699408121407032, 0.02370089665055275, -0.020204326137900352, -0.027638830244541168, 0.00532882334664464, 0.0035802132915705442, -0.00007710760837653652, -0.0202363058924675, 0.03545519337058067, 0.0138962147757411, 0.03140423074364662, 0.042794764041900635, 0.0011566029861569405, -0.008908234536647797, -0.030229082331061363, -0.015449552796781063, 0.015723904594779015, -0.010654738172888756, 0.0014869343722239137, 0.04402686655521393, -0.00007520002691308036, -0.05549973249435425, -0.0044739581644535065, 0.037965886294841766, 0.074403315782547, 0.037152811884880066, 0.006690816022455692, 0.011204303242266178, -0.07903160154819489, 0.009604629129171371, -0.0060145920142531395, 0.002266220049932599, -0.020007895305752754, -0.0007825235952623188, 0.030717378482222557, -0.008607056923210621, -0.042895905673503876, -0.017901210114359856, 0.07747481018304825, -0.015391671098768711, -0.019517678767442703, -0.026001140475273132, 0.03149566426873207, -0.019730571657419205, 0.027798937633633614, 0.017030876129865646, 0.016028083860874176, -0.024445481598377228, -0.012111916206777096, 0.013596146367490292, -0.029118932783603668, -0.0017854508478194475, -0.00946902483701706, 0.012189708650112152, 0.05300687998533249, -0.010112251155078411, 0.018187737092375755, 0.003387169912457466, 0.03166937455534935, -0.013659334741532803, 0.05410395562648773, -0.03495648875832558, -0.0625811219215393, 0.010052239522337914, 0.02097407355904579, 0.007700671441853046, -0.026859944686293602, -0.04186270758509636, -0.06426840275526047, -0.0029201493598520756, 0.03845886141061783, -0.03403791785240173, 0.041633572429418564, -0.0007500128704123199, 0.015893766656517982, -0.034025683999061584, -0.008453554473817348, -0.02180088311433792, 0.05596093088388443, -0.029588894918560982, 0.06126105412840843, -0.007584287319332361, -0.04060567542910576, -0.01493012998253107, 0.005588935688138008, -0.016535846516489983, 0.09073881804943085, -0.03885064646601677, -0.0018909606151282787, 0.011702985502779484, 0.02589736506342888, -0.015553640201687813, -0.07988079637289047, 0.024605602025985718, -0.018671929836273193, -0.004341591149568558, 0.044240254908800125, 0.009987127967178822, -0.03067316859960556, 0.03440984711050987, 0.011894917115569115, -0.021821238100528717, -0.010651621967554092, -0.057217903435230255, 0.048496879637241364, 0.01411142572760582, -0.02047666534781456, 0.034091830253601074, 0.01999223232269287, 0.01352626457810402, 0.01724637858569622, -0.01982051692903042, 0.01983235962688923, -0.027453314512968063, 0.015184493735432625, -0.05535060167312622, -0.0013537652557715774, 0.020617494359612465, 0.005411183461546898, 0.06012199819087982, 0.04133807495236397, -0.012800129130482674, -0.028406906872987747, 0.0006171852583065629, 0.044294729828834534, 0.017445744946599007, -0.05366694927215576, -0.008386957459151745, -0.0068345507606863976, -0.04113943129777908, -0.0028240825049579144, 0.002888005692511797, -0.03819206357002258, 0.039245862513780594, 0.026546508073806763, -0.008929791860282421, 0.012599757872521877, -0.032249242067337036, -0.017364738509058952, 0.0315994918346405, -0.06420497596263885, 0.00793055072426796, 0.017057061195373535, 0.008053282275795937, 0.02600688487291336, -0.039654847234487534, 0.00428013876080513, -0.01541085448116064, -0.013349337503314018, 0.04389016702771187, -0.04792739450931549, 0.015275541692972183, -0.00400291895493865, 0.009755334816873074, -0.06242431327700615, -0.04382823407649994, 0.010644846595823765, -0.011023732833564281, -0.029930494725704193, -0.026803111657500267, 0.0014998279511928558, 0.01654699444770813, -0.02016298472881317, 0.03369744122028351, 0.04549998790025711, -0.03949004039168358, 0.022940199822187424, -0.03314625099301338, 0.03224056586623192, 0.0495963916182518, -0.04301837086677551, -0.011252536438405514, 0.00388893811032176, -0.015896935015916824, -0.005239356309175491, 0.02915969491004944, 0.008546043187379837, -0.027027569711208344, 0.0034773852676153183, -0.02666006051003933, 0.02260199375450611, 0.060459911823272705, -0.020394930616021156, 0.031202105805277824, 0.005114896688610315, 0.023603050038218498, -0.01850929856300354, -0.0434868298470974, -0.01957918517291546, -0.006297722924500704, -0.030284099280834198, 0.005186252761632204, -0.03829314932227135, -0.013713855296373367, -0.020763300359249115, 0.09311405569314957, 0.026759129017591476, -0.0003129317192360759, 0.003059342270717025, 0.07849530875682831, 0.0012405477464199066, -0.01330859400331974, -0.04292387515306473, -0.04755909740924835, 0.03163234889507294, 0.030383601784706116, -0.024359390139579773, -0.007213374599814415, -0.019642148166894913, -0.043114110827445984, 0.013930094428360462, -0.05802345275878906, 0.016544025391340256, 0.058317217975854874, -0.011066565290093422, 0.048871248960494995, -0.0022078335750848055, -0.016198836266994476, -0.022428205236792564, -0.01011495478451252, -0.06766360998153687, -0.017391126602888107, -0.019873086363077164, 0.0488586351275444, -0.012106489390134811, -0.011752287857234478, 0.0015022695297375321, 0.05747147649526596, 0.0642055943608284, 0.062339190393686295, 0.02112213522195816, -0.01688491553068161, 0.026693010702729225, -0.002681112615391612, 0.006701519712805748, 0.009673547931015491, -0.0008483976707793772, 0.03498788923025131, -0.020763756707310677, -0.0148451067507267, 0.05166749283671379, -0.004219759255647659, 0.008094433695077896, -0.039795853197574615, -0.04691411554813385, 0.004776730202138424, -0.0161725040525198, 0.03538456931710243, -0.005333382170647383, -0.000892604875843972, 0.05477118119597435, 0.007196360267698765, 0.006431505549699068, 0.02875738963484764, -0.03623586893081665, -0.027746399864554405, -0.0451476015150547, -0.01457752101123333, -0.002356132259592414, 0.03742298111319542, 0.031170012429356575, -0.05683666467666626, 0.006152247544378042, -0.03990590199828148, 0.06981370598077774, 0.00019824269111268222, 0.03649101406335831, 0.0283668152987957, 0.06537482142448425, -0.0025562222581356764, 0.03568463400006294, 0.015130103565752506, 0.003323195967823267, 0.11134064197540283, 0.10168290883302689, 0.036570753902196884, -0.07935940474271774, -0.018526332452893257, -0.005838897544890642, -0.0038002210203558207, -0.021278124302625656, 0.008091136813163757, 0.004364383406937122, 0.015875060111284256, 0.028777267783880234, -0.0061538852751255035, 0.009959839284420013, 0.023010052740573883, 0.02256375178694725, 0.004887186456471682, -0.027224520221352577, 0.0020829567220062017, 0.00022848219668958336, 0.0015702452510595322, -0.014414245262742043, -0.09006135165691376, -0.01015247032046318, 0.026838939636945724, -0.054596081376075745, -0.003673149272799492, 0.0039552366361021996, 0.038152698427438736, 0.030244439840316772, -0.016331875696778297, 0.01059040054678917, -0.005955688655376434, -0.008792075328528881, 0.033726777881383896, -0.02264963649213314, 0.03896234184503555, 0.007080188021063805, 0.05781449005007744, 0.010715145617723465, 0.04606761038303375, 0.004783308133482933, -0.01727645844221115, 0.014717056415975094, -0.011165364645421505, -0.021972624585032463, -0.004587823525071144, 0.049678508192300797, -0.02313896082341671, 0.008739180862903595, 0.021116914227604866, 0.025464195758104324, -0.033738330006599426, -0.05798822268843651, 0.016751278191804886, 0.0369376502931118, -0.009331982582807541, -0.01286950334906578, -0.01991964690387249, 0.013990943320095539, 0.0074900365434587, -0.009557956829667091, -0.02188362181186676, 0.03683549538254738, -0.020153963938355446, -0.008621318265795708, -0.06787002086639404, 0.05721064656972885, -0.004480891395360231, 0.006639254745095968, 0.028208136558532715, -0.06222960725426674, -0.017031032592058182, -0.05100336670875549, 0.01114285085350275, -0.03544038534164429, 0.013266308233141899, -0.015698477625846863, -0.02558399736881256, -0.028113234788179398, -0.008877581916749477, -0.0018241871148347855, -0.01416178047657013, -0.03480887785553932, -0.007529065944254398, 0.01681339181959629, 0.004409419372677803, 0.02059813030064106, 0.011839460581541061, -0.010372418910264969, 0.026418881490826607, -0.006795217283070087, 0.017549585551023483, -0.05881909281015396, 0.01467390637844801, 0.042240824550390244, -0.05147124081850052, -0.00041030626744031906, 0.00024344351550098509, 0.01774929091334343, -0.014500084333121777, 0.020844032987952232, 0.008418513461947441, 0.024365030229091644, -0.0029362975619733334, 0.006322440691292286, -0.0017343384679406881, -0.056413475424051285, 0.020366229116916656, -0.017653608694672585, -0.011539841070771217, -0.0939701646566391, -0.01623215340077877, -0.022287635132670403, -0.042093053460121155, -0.032516732811927795, 0.013306723907589912, -0.05426320806145668, -0.02153247967362404, 0.016459334641695023, 0.012084340676665306, 0.006626775488257408, -0.021844247356057167, 0.0017673540860414505, 0.014669407159090042, 0.031404659152030945, -0.00953222718089819, -0.030721088871359825, 0.03754802048206329, 0.028390342369675636, -0.0016507386462762952, 0.015764936804771423, 0.005593748763203621, 0.029898690059781075, -0.006865211296826601, 0.042435240000486374, -0.036178238689899445, 0.034001413732767105, -0.031054280698299408, -0.04224091023206711, -0.0019586796406656504, -0.006732623558491468, -0.029744010418653488, -0.004458646755665541, 0.042774394154548645, 0.06489556282758713, 0.005258765537291765, -0.03620382770895958, -0.0163299348205328, 0.03960534930229187, -0.005524529609829187, -0.00025855511194095016, 0.0012533831177279353, -0.03805865719914436, -0.01064674649387598, 0.013402841985225677, -0.003897134680300951, 0.009660891257226467, 0.018288716673851013, 0.030934059992432594, 0.041661374270915985, -0.040329430252313614, 0.010421465151011944, 0.02258235216140747, 0.011542310006916523, -0.03454003110527992, 0.00698218634352088, -0.0005431108875200152, 0.017176682129502296, 0.0318489633500576, -0.024408215656876564, 0.037202827632427216, -0.02949373982846737, -0.011730125173926353, -0.05576324835419655, -0.028585951775312424, 0.02526557259261608, -0.023626135662198067, 0.03687591850757599, -0.06271098554134369, 0.06474030762910843, 0.04342044144868851, -0.032018352299928665, -0.011454521678388119, 0.02914055436849594, -0.012714500539004803, -0.022189417853951454, 0.04227086156606674, -0.02253805287182331, 0.0005208256188780069, 0.008728250861167908, -0.0013838468585163355, 0.047242630273103714, -0.020100118592381477, -0.0042059412226080894, -0.024453027173876762, -0.012654813937842846, 0.04107524827122688, 0.019750408828258514, 0.008869725279510021, 0.02193022333085537, -0.01895044557750225, -0.025652334094047546, 0.05169210210442543, -0.003548181615769863, -0.038570500910282135, 0.04144669696688652, 0.0603899247944355, 0.01671663671731949, 0.05522643402218819, -0.006638082675635815, 0.01822289638221264, 0.002080457517877221, -0.006904894020408392, 0.0662657842040062, 0.023202719166874886, 0.01831488311290741, -0.011289295740425587, 0.00692471070215106, 0.0017886986024677753, -0.04595750570297241, 0.00359603064134717, -0.01989826187491417, -0.020118167623877525, 0.020069565623998642, -0.06177482753992081, 0.010985348373651505, -0.09066802263259888, 0.0032590748742222786, -0.03438548743724823, 0.016389474272727966, 0.024946685880422592, 0.00872872956097126, -0.006447310093790293, -0.0042999438010156155, -0.0002730971609707922, -0.025903262197971344, -0.01062841434031725, -0.003211689880117774, -0.029408983886241913, -0.001614682492800057, 0.010957318358123302, 0.006899158004671335, -0.04439853876829147, 0.014849373139441013, -0.04636569321155548, -0.035599373281002045, 0.01437522191554308, -0.015263697132468224, 0.011136610992252827, -0.004517467226833105, -0.0349549800157547, 0.006575585808604956, -0.10728299617767334, 0.0666244775056839, -0.011343076825141907, -0.029979178681969643, -0.04191974550485611, 0.01170873362571001, -0.05405203253030777, 0.005028207786381245, 0.02970065362751484, -0.009009095840156078, 0.001393656013533473, -0.029406320303678513, 0.028682613745331764, 0.0032874038442969322, -0.011006792075932026, 0.021881448104977608, 0.0019146481063216925, -0.039028313010931015, -0.013250992633402348, -0.03684509918093681, -0.005957333371043205, 0.013989069499075413, -0.003971107769757509, 0.036521073430776596, 0.006315712351351976, 0.008569339290261269, -0.021955100819468498, 0.005570800509303808, 0.014316700398921967, 0.013285535387694836, 0.045520152896642685, 0.025029046460986137, -0.037431906908750534, 0.035621508955955505, 0.02317812107503414, -0.06591195613145828, 0.030141077935695648, 0.00004860027911490761, -0.03990878164768219, -0.015505698509514332, 0.0009805237641558051, 0.046596914529800415, -0.06519775092601776, -0.027449773624539375, -0.018947212025523186, -0.02998540736734867, 0.011535325087606907, 0.04390991851687431, -0.025587208569049835, 0.02500883676111698, 0.0038070776499807835, 0.03899194672703743, -0.03219100087881088, 0.010328789241611958, 0.012402595020830631, 0.022787244990468025, -0.004398774821311235, 0.008993679657578468, 0.06574168801307678, 0.026425937190651894, -0.03567765653133392, 0.03290427848696709, -0.021959396079182625, 0.04502220079302788, -0.01668025739490986, -0.005007985979318619, 0.011242825537919998, 0.04089140146970749, -0.0011206167982891202, 0.02852148748934269, -0.012903503142297268, 0.09837344288825989, -0.04456654191017151, 0.05247748643159866, -0.020348938181996346, -0.012181652709841728, -0.005322148557752371, 0.020602203905582428, 0.048223353922367096, 0.012953678146004677, -0.008831612765789032, 0.020948192104697227, 0.0016597694484516978, 0.01824302226305008, 0.041546665132045746, -0.08204079419374466, 0.00007142216054489836, 0.004487099591642618, 0.010593482293188572, 0.01120322197675705, 0.020929459482431412, 0.00012990015966352075, -0.007212992291897535, 0.019473273307085037, 0.019307922571897507, 0.021901298314332962, -0.026214128360152245, -0.02917078323662281, -0.00974939577281475, 0.029723623767495155, -0.04340336471796036, -0.01960434764623642, -0.02904566004872322, 0.03333015739917755, 0.008462576195597649, -0.021232472732663155 ]
<p>I have run a logistic regression using several predictor variables (call them p1 p2 p3 p4) to predict a binary dependent variable (call it y). P1 is a significant predictor of y in the regression. However, a Mann-Whitney test of p1 shows no significant difference by category of y.</p> <p>Is it normal to have a significant logistic regression predictor that doesn't significantly differ by groups, or is there potentially something screwy with the data?</p>
73,672
[ -0.03167736902832985, 0.01276356540620327, -0.02242930792272091, -0.009141755290329456, 0.0489315465092659, 0.015831749886274338, -0.013493867591023445, -0.009766967967152596, 0.02303621917963028, -0.04262609779834747, 0.04585199058055878, 0.023393837735056877, 0.0633157342672348, 0.007943366654217243, 0.008904101327061653, -0.029808586463332176, 0.01967749185860157, 0.012521354481577873, 0.03414890542626381, 0.0021504953037947416, -0.022614886984229088, 0.03610895946621895, 0.020078817382454872, 0.0012364037102088332, -0.010944649577140808, 0.060268741101026535, 0.016447406262159348, 0.018882568925619125, 0.013032639399170876, 0.03913674131035805, -0.012494506314396858, -0.02980467490851879, -0.006266768090426922, 0.029157884418964386, 0.007057894021272659, -0.01187292393296957, 0.013410537503659725, -0.03067972883582115, 0.02583887055516243, 0.0012381384149193764, -0.028391264379024506, -0.020685655996203423, -0.0033670910634100437, 0.03146843984723091, -0.026624195277690887, 0.024500537663698196, -0.003330171573907137, -0.019626038148999214, 0.061210017651319504, -0.012771123088896275, 0.05096970498561859, -0.014019315131008625, 0.025199463590979576, 0.027370957657694817, -0.035155054181814194, -0.001957961358129978, 0.041807036846876144, 0.06540312618017197, -0.048354994505643845, -0.045652516186237335, -0.03777781128883362, -0.01404049713164568, -0.024092132225632668, -0.004184062127023935, -0.03895827382802963, 0.02107529528439045, -0.019900072365999222, -0.02853708527982235, 0.054426807910203934, -0.006919216830283403, -0.004047106020152569, -0.015683069825172424, 0.028863171115517616, 0.009877621196210384, 0.01202378235757351, -0.027814721688628197, 0.01948968507349491, 0.01025429554283619, 0.03779563307762146, 0.054920744150877, -0.012792203575372696, 0.005272357724606991, 0.007475039456039667, 0.04201873764395714, 0.010940433479845524, 0.0007707212353125215, 0.01814037747681141, -0.04448021948337555, 0.011203416623175144, 0.0626143142580986, -0.04326355829834938, 0.011986530385911465, 0.04952796548604965, 0.03396185114979744, -0.023467829450964928, 0.020528916269540787, -0.028761010617017746, 0.022141598165035248, 0.02356874942779541, 0.016946660354733467, 0.015951858833432198, -0.043370798230171204, 0.04011182859539986, 0.04721011221408844, -0.024335026741027832, -0.013645069673657417, -0.03957383334636688, -0.011786834336817265, 0.01347853522747755, -0.030883600935339928, -0.0019400158198550344, 0.0008058185921981931, 0.0035672117955982685, -0.025931954383850098, 0.005262146238237619, -0.040455397218465805, -0.023068536072969437, -0.04183444008231163, 0.03439582139253616, 0.026342783123254776, 0.038490429520606995, -0.04587232321500778, 0.03433333709836006, -0.003184328321367502, -0.01443495787680149, 0.024223538115620613, 0.029363024979829788, -0.03184168413281441, -0.031866494566202164, 0.038538385182619095, 0.014542867429554462, 0.003882508259266615, 0.013114781118929386, 0.009206107817590237, 0.016581472009420395, 0.01586851105093956, -0.09389043599367142, -0.048276908695697784, 0.01254450436681509, -0.01286255568265915, 0.013328339904546738, -0.058093179017305374, -0.039737116545438766, 0.028393009677529335, 0.05581602826714516, -0.0019106424879282713, 0.008578161709010601, 0.024872932583093643, 0.018484044820070267, 0.05248793959617615, -0.013037240132689476, 0.013060669414699078, -0.05479317158460617, -0.05746995657682419, -0.02890678122639656, -0.09995295852422714, 0.0322846919298172, 0.010067050345242023, 0.037763647735118866, 0.002319841179996729, 0.011679233983159065, 0.01629708521068096, 0.002490473445504904, -0.022412484511733055, 0.002292099641636014, 0.013066880404949188, 0.050328221172094345, -0.001911634812131524, 0.06407714635133743, 0.014861208386719227, 0.007175672333687544, 0.0006214737659320235, 0.03151145204901695, 0.07486644387245178, 0.024710219353437424, 0.005290594417601824, -0.017239082604646683, -0.04323997721076012, 0.030312705785036087, -0.022332685068249702, -0.0360872745513916, -0.024624312296509743, -0.03172356262803078, -0.0032302376348525286, -0.014916975051164627, 0.04292679578065872, -0.010140140540897846, -0.01102535892277956, 0.0610232912003994, -0.03564413636922836, -0.08588918298482895, -0.017250683158636093, 0.026277804747223854, 0.016903294250369072, -0.023408476263284683, 0.025514161214232445, 0.04703357070684433, 0.053074534982442856, -0.025118259713053703, 0.029573066160082817, -0.03831416741013527, -0.020592378452420235, 0.03071395307779312, -0.03437534719705582, 0.0183174517005682, 0.03798757120966911, 0.04999301955103874, -0.01078140176832676, 0.07405959069728851, -0.05593611299991608, -0.04082323610782623, 0.04052698239684105, -0.00009299467637902126, -0.01124206930398941, -0.02913409098982811, -0.0007980833761394024, 0.019502725452184677, -0.011552214622497559, -0.026629643514752388, 0.055766742676496506, -0.08461548388004303, 0.07560195028781891, 0.006835584528744221, -0.04163375124335289, -0.003213149029761553, -0.002246547257527709, -0.0032490671146661043, -0.010664707981050014, -0.017775120213627815, -0.03357556462287903, -0.06560328602790833, -0.02648903802037239, 0.027477771043777466, 0.006671658717095852, -0.04676062613725662, 0.016228027641773224, 0.02642439305782318, 0.018206767737865448, 0.015935558825731277, 0.035808809101581573, 0.042210277169942856, -0.038545720279216766, 0.019549869000911713, 0.017774082720279694, 0.008534037508070469, 0.031760431826114655, 0.04161032289266586, -0.0012391569325700402, 0.07993225008249283, -0.01156331691890955, -0.0006169668631628156, 0.06738210469484329, -0.009330742061138153, -0.016955355182290077, -0.009184580296278, -0.01588154025375843, 0.05100742354989052, -0.027995804324746132, 0.011490006931126118, 0.061054982244968414, 0.058179814368486404, -0.012492155656218529, -0.0036610879469662905, -0.017270907759666443, 0.012904537841677666, 0.07426267117261887, -0.043840836733579636, 0.02338382601737976, 0.004108727909624577, -0.044089801609516144, 0.023326478898525238, -0.02149004302918911, -0.040057890117168427, -0.033261291682720184, 0.03090137429535389, 0.017855513840913773, 0.00323070609010756, 0.017840031534433365, -0.03496004641056061, -0.02950946055352688, 0.006735954433679581, -0.025846458971500397, 0.03190639242529869, -0.03725752979516983, -0.06922528892755508, -0.048027049750089645, -0.002230940153822303, -0.0002435524365864694, 0.028650125488638878, -0.01817062497138977, -0.03483195602893829, 0.016067776829004288, -0.03581748902797699, -0.038929663598537445, -0.0069552999921143055, -0.05130647122859955, 0.01805506832897663, -0.040465351194143295, -0.05825459584593773, 0.023471176624298096, -0.013125118799507618, -0.01586204580962658, 0.019785596057772636, -0.019603991881012917, 0.01700103096663952, -0.014813491143286228, -0.011023111641407013, 0.007804601453244686, 0.021721230819821358, 0.008000491186976433, 0.013466814532876015, -0.0236261747777462, -0.03217542544007301, -0.03914970904588699, -0.07470403611660004, 0.024685340002179146, -0.011420734226703644, 0.04565001651644707, -0.042823050171136856, 0.011695868335664272, 0.07399969547986984, 0.03127375990152359, 0.00255291978828609, -0.06945423036813736, -0.02537357620894909, -0.06900180131196976, -0.005046207457780838, 0.04290792718529701, 0.018056198954582214, 0.0288504920899868, 0.05140050873160362, -0.01813266985118389, 0.02425120398402214, 0.026048673316836357, -0.00021799802198074758, -0.02508186735212803, 0.06704716384410858, 0.034643519669771194, -0.04540826007723808, 0.026173023506999016, 0.05020000413060188, -0.04723739996552467, 0.02251230925321579, 0.01455280277878046, 0.006311960984021425, 0.005940167233347893, -0.04668782651424408, 0.030260426923632622, -0.01690293475985527, 0.03471570089459419, -0.017685111612081528, -0.005210199858993292, 0.008860246278345585, -0.04196735471487045, -0.011247982271015644, 0.03126193583011627, 0.02304905652999878, 0.021494239568710327, 0.035511620342731476, 0.04054480791091919, 0.03743087127804756, -0.00615399656817317, 0.012957996688783169, -0.003933144733309746, -0.01186568383127451, 0.04189412668347359, -0.012386186048388481, -0.032365649938583374, 0.0389370396733284, -0.0030441544950008392, 0.006064561661332846, -0.006644792854785919, -0.04758458957076073, 0.009910696186125278, -0.06507638841867447, 0.026805199682712555, -0.019206104800105095, 0.02962573431432247, 0.00576112512499094, 0.03568640723824501, 0.016103237867355347, -0.011592552065849304, -0.014936119318008423, 0.0246023740619421, -0.08636625111103058, 0.04940086603164673, -0.03021770529448986, 0.011215132661163807, 0.021390607580542564, -0.03734060749411583, 0.03600951284170151, -0.028569499030709267, 0.004372527822852135, 0.012046894058585167, 0.01833655685186386, -0.026633135974407196, -0.002926900051534176, -0.014248665422201157, -0.04361952096223831, -0.006621357519179583, -0.0021958595607429743, -0.013120541349053383, 0.03864780068397522, 0.014826370403170586, 0.03374234214425087, -0.00566188246011734, 0.024591701105237007, -0.038707002997398376, -0.016743328422307968, 0.02190489135682583, 0.08076231181621552, 0.0043021454475820065, 0.002917128149420023, -0.05213518813252449, 0.005381104536354542, -0.01333608664572239, 0.032441526651382446, 0.03198496997356415, 0.009157112799584866, -0.001117580570280552, -0.02833987958729267, -0.017829665914177895, -0.010675013065338135, -0.009225627407431602, -0.001032545929774642, 0.003666035830974579, 0.03946737200021744, 0.04864618927240372, -0.04283297434449196, -0.006047867704182863, 0.031118525192141533, 0.022728294134140015, -0.008224396035075188, -0.017247021198272705, 0.016453098505735397, 0.0022884656209498644, 0.005641374737024307, 0.0011946106096729636, -0.005547111388295889, -0.02190786600112915, -0.00983799621462822, 0.018920648843050003, -0.031474605202674866, -0.020434699952602386, -0.02894626371562481, -0.003478054655715823, 0.006586409639567137, -0.012813670560717583, -0.0258482675999403, 0.05489640310406685, 0.022999968379735947, 0.02758043259382248, 0.025077324360609055, 0.014484836719930172, -0.08987700194120407, -0.008343808352947235, 0.03688230738043785, 0.07865864783525467, -0.049274664372205734, -0.009065806865692139, -0.004578752908855677, 0.022262489423155785, 0.044750697910785675, -0.019052958115935326, 0.019921021535992622, 0.0027170388493686914, 0.0036775951739400625, -0.01275845617055893, -0.04588952288031578, -0.08965346962213516, -0.001337673282250762, -0.03098619170486927, 0.01166793704032898, -0.008256807923316956, -0.04036594182252884, -0.0672505795955658, 0.011632268317043781, 0.002954216208308935, 0.05796650052070618, 0.0024097831919789314, -0.001376455882564187, 0.02599353715777397, 0.026591971516609192, 0.022092144936323166, -0.05687214806675911, 0.007460060063749552, 0.007226426620036364, -0.045715074986219406, 0.045745160430669785, 0.002380962949246168, -0.021955743432044983, 0.02678837440907955, 0.0216040201485157, -0.007141438778489828, -0.020378584042191505, -0.03560071066021919, 0.0061241197399795055, 0.007828224450349808, -0.010596177540719509, 0.016559133306145668, 0.012670187279582024, 0.001692392397671938, -0.010149828158318996, -0.04228498041629791, 0.0308440700173378, -0.006548458244651556, -0.01655498519539833, -0.014869768172502518, -0.01471822801977396, -0.012655205093324184, 0.04673505946993828, 0.014903956092894077, -0.0071714939549565315, -0.03483337536454201, -0.01045831385999918, 0.005884329788386822, 0.008650497533380985, 0.0035052085295319557, 0.01718848943710327, -0.011102813296020031, 0.01770644634962082, -0.010864288546144962, -0.008733010850846767, 0.02359573170542717, -0.025455841794610023, 0.010064773261547089, 0.021121595054864883, -0.027115462347865105, -0.009525553323328495, -0.03133087605237961, -0.0175278652459383, 0.004557734355330467, -0.008826949633657932, 0.036375630646944046, 0.016217490658164024, 0.03549962118268013, -0.01943172886967659, -0.04728233814239502, -0.010926389135420322, 0.0067914193496108055, 0.019666999578475952, 0.050356317311525345, 0.008238308131694794, 0.02851034142076969, -0.016473503783345222, -0.017171060666441917, -0.08997934311628342, -0.038658201694488525, 0.0010145314736291766, 0.026822851970791817, -0.021103257313370705, -0.029233846813440323, 0.014782403595745564, -0.02972293458878994, -0.03800451382994652, -0.004900139756500721, 0.05005408450961113, -0.027479980140924454, -0.0216993261128664, 0.0004415064468048513, 0.009411639533936977, 0.07749903202056885, -0.00584392249584198, -0.05086405947804451, 0.0005534000811167061, -0.02171425335109234, -0.0037189519498497248, 0.003772565396502614, -0.01619480364024639, -0.018848689272999763, -0.035397060215473175, -0.005525895860046148, 0.008813589811325073, 0.022392170503735542, -0.060781996697187424, 0.0029107823502272367, 0.037215493619441986, -0.02656274475157261, 0.029577849432826042, -0.0007093609892763197, 0.023008650168776512, -0.01653670147061348, -0.0015944833867251873, -0.030639702454209328, 0.005403660237789154, 0.0016218663658946753, -0.02832290530204773, 0.036701690405607224, 0.025802407413721085, 0.003781213192269206, 0.03683532774448395, 0.057580411434173584, 0.027181686833500862, 0.00848682876676321, -0.018682578578591347, -0.04196193441748619, 0.06837774813175201, 0.03309381380677223, -0.029117252677679062, -0.010521527379751205, 0.0646536573767662, -0.01229199767112732, -0.015036480501294136, -0.023203734308481216, -0.017018184065818787, 0.020988162606954575, 0.00027948259958066046, 0.0016811284003779292, 0.06561051309108734, -0.003873123088851571, 0.004164950456470251, -0.03350912034511566, 0.0006471585365943611, -0.002097372431308031, -0.0016503746155649424, 0.025855181738734245, 0.01116616278886795, 0.020747099071741104, 0.041153885424137115, 0.02185971662402153, -0.00372708379290998, 0.007196022663265467, 0.04413897544145584, 0.006157249677926302, 0.028122391551733017, -0.003623610595241189, -0.0750078335404396, 0.05510129779577255, -0.0338786318898201, 0.00255782762542367, -0.035691868513822556, 0.018487771973013878, 0.05016031488776207, 0.039596077054739, 0.005351768806576729, -0.06746897846460342, -0.03769532963633537, -0.0177494827657938, -0.012983467429876328, -0.0006758916424587369, 0.017402194440364838, 0.053118206560611725, 0.014407750219106674, 0.01546096708625555, 0.01597498543560505, 0.0185473021119833, -0.0041772606782615185, -0.09796085208654404, -0.036061856895685196, -0.01648813858628273, -0.024656187742948532, 0.008378525264561176, -0.014283040538430214, -0.029186520725488663, 0.0018526914063841105, -0.08370309323072433, 0.007137636188417673, -0.008978964760899544, 0.028214124962687492, 0.024165403097867966, 0.022122271358966827, -0.004713084548711777, 0.02534204162657261, -0.015956781804561615, 0.0028460421599447727, 0.10667314380407333, 0.059110455214977264, 0.023896347731351852, -0.04930994287133217, 0.020364318042993546, -0.006056684534996748, -0.025017697364091873, 0.011870221234858036, -0.03280933201313019, -0.014565172605216503, -0.009371619671583176, 0.03703049570322037, 0.034027598798274994, 0.03015632927417755, 0.011929824948310852, 0.08037494868040085, -0.05827741697430611, -0.00007675790402572602, 0.043815333396196365, 0.008735544048249722, 0.005585725884884596, -0.02964424155652523, 0.000020074085114174522, 0.022080469876527786, 0.004921067971736193, -0.034271322190761566, -0.01811707206070423, -0.0076389978639781475, -0.003466467373073101, -0.0013954752357676625, -0.0065026795491576195, -0.007046371698379517, 0.027916956692934036, -0.00011426751734688878, -0.006422317586839199, -0.0026260928716510534, 0.021787118166685104, -0.05116376280784607, 0.005287614185363054, 0.0324648916721344, -0.030837539583444595, -0.0055283717811107635, 0.016838639974594116, -0.022570699453353882, -0.05453386902809143, -0.025605734437704086, -0.026606444269418716, 0.04031083360314369, 0.013401981443166733, -0.014277579262852669, -0.0057086399756371975, 0.0004989342414774001, 0.013038737699389458, -0.03843257948756218, -0.047765154391527176, 0.05677230283617973, 0.021918337792158127, -0.03411637246608734, -0.03541611507534981, -0.013959922827780247, 0.03240540623664856, -0.008129744790494442, 0.018667373806238174, 0.009635169990360737, -0.024883238598704338, -0.0126052126288414, -0.00439444649964571, 0.02613806538283825, -0.013852111995220184, -0.0013870139373466372, 0.04381227120757103, -0.03502300754189491, -0.007086458150297403, 0.009526766836643219, -0.036666933447122574, 0.02384958788752556, 0.020304905250668526, 0.004850680939853191, -0.044976815581321716, -0.03500744700431824, -0.03782416507601738, -0.005491594783961773, -0.02208542637526989, 0.022858550772070885, -0.05427321419119835, -0.0035382951609790325, 0.05249948427081108, 0.015338718891143799, 0.054343413561582565, -0.0002677755546756089, 0.01343894936144352, 0.04145751893520355, 0.01253830548375845, -0.03240194916725159, -0.04502984881401062, 0.019381742924451828, -0.030976727604866028, -0.005924628581851721, -0.009369785897433758, 0.06970079243183136, 0.004106162115931511, 0.01590532809495926, -0.006422878708690405, 0.004806669894605875, -0.021376537159085274, 0.043127551674842834, 0.024614498019218445, -0.04235239326953888, -0.003464285284280777, 0.010260353796184063, 0.021183140575885773, -0.012598630040884018, -0.0438685305416584, -0.07167687267065048, -0.04627213627099991, 0.015157043002545834, -0.032035209238529205, -0.015240590088069439, 0.00035209921770729125, 0.018361350521445274, 0.043397895991802216, -0.04408128187060356, -0.04720151424407959, -0.05047966539859772, -0.010613781400024891, 0.023068439215421677, 0.0166409220546484, -0.005607817322015762, 0.015564793720841408, -0.017669430002570152, 0.04565499722957611, 0.05011822655797005, 0.006288821343332529, 0.02397269569337368, -0.00956948846578598, 0.0150078060105443, 0.009905196726322174, 0.03716973960399628, -0.023823585361242294, -0.020774735137820244, 0.026517268270254135, -0.009432102553546429, -0.026568833738565445, 0.046561140567064285, -0.02239212393760681, 0.042042311280965805, 0.010090436786413193, 0.012221341021358967, -0.023408887907862663, 0.06677696108818054, -0.009239624254405499, 0.016462720930576324, -0.007017314434051514, 0.01578141376376152, 0.012449057772755623, 0.006360242143273354, -0.024322262033820152, 0.02125578187406063, -0.026607457548379898, 0.03898308426141739, 0.044969767332077026, 0.015474066138267517, -0.017546091228723526, -0.017292456701397896, 0.003236384829506278, 0.034679025411605835, 0.020557092502713203, -0.0048127551563084126, 0.03556126356124878, 0.04076360911130905, -0.025686856359243393, 0.05040295794606209, 0.007100255228579044, 0.028204990550875664, -0.08526172488927841, -0.07255204021930695, 0.004189703613519669, 0.03350807726383209, 0.03761395439505577, -0.065089151263237, 0.01863780990242958, 0.001020296011120081, -0.03575016185641289, -0.005007862579077482, 0.0008384438697248697, -0.04116729274392128, -0.058824218809604645, -0.019191695377230644, 0.004897217266261578, 0.021183542907238007, 0.04045713692903519, 0.01928688772022724, -0.00035245477920398116, 0.03139210492372513, -0.013694649562239647, -0.02483307756483555, -0.011570612899959087, 0.011682401411235332, -0.0017368311528116465, -0.055158521980047226, 0.016406424343585968, -0.03303464129567146, -0.03793560713529587, 0.047521017491817474, -0.010597052983939648, 0.02164957858622074, 0.06605015695095062, 0.009120607748627663, 0.005649507511407137, 0.04828128218650818, 0.08327944576740265, -0.002788697835057974, 0.021373014897108078, 0.0066039785742759705, 0.008552160114049911, 0.04448039457201958, -0.017202304676175117, -0.041827671229839325, -0.007670966442674398, -0.013572472147643566, 0.0008201260934583843, 0.00916949100792408, -0.01768297515809536, -0.010611454024910927, -0.0032379941549152136, -0.010044326074421406, -0.031334150582551956, -0.012936947867274284, 0.03437377139925957, -0.07064346224069595, -0.02747775800526142, 0.050531115382909775, 0.0356079638004303, -0.03035239316523075, 0.014769181609153748, -0.008436557836830616, -0.02631363458931446, -0.013162762857973576, 0.004838159307837486, 0.016690541058778763, -0.024690870195627213, 0.024940403178334236, -0.010651759803295135, 0.02069290354847908, -0.02682146616280079, -0.0005681445472873747, -0.042162343859672546, 0.01621188595890999, -0.03217274695634842, 0.022207921370863914, 0.018803223967552185, -0.02219468168914318, 0.0011310825357213616, -0.09055372327566147, 0.07516466081142426, 0.03075854666531086, -0.02549387700855732, -0.014723689295351505, -0.0016656991792842746, -0.05949948728084564, 0.008611331693828106, 0.04350031167268753, -0.013146452605724335, 0.012887632474303246, 0.019457465037703514, 0.006727633066475391, -0.024687662720680237, -0.015050951391458511, 0.013706138357520103, -0.02520405501127243, -0.018071232363581657, -0.024183474481105804, -0.010992487892508507, 0.004370457027107477, 0.005923997610807419, 0.015182549133896828, -0.036763790994882584, -0.01981258951127529, 0.0024161245673894882, 0.013515152037143707, 0.0529991015791893, -0.025726864114403725, -0.01934138871729374, 0.03744426369667053, 0.01962275803089142, 0.0013811243698000908, -0.004968858323991299, -0.002375128911808133, -0.07504908740520477, 0.04717741906642914, -0.028688756749033928, -0.012638657353818417, 0.034283705055713654, 0.026612846180796623, -0.004817715846002102, -0.03673366829752922, 0.04508006200194359, 0.012057448737323284, 0.003130565630272031, 0.03060172311961651, 0.036311399191617966, 0.011889957822859287, -0.0027511699590831995, -0.005202800966799259, -0.007520708255469799, -0.004631629679352045, -0.017340634018182755, 0.02253730595111847, 0.015677882358431816, 0.029779085889458656, 0.012302321381866932, 0.003996905870735645, 0.017838073894381523, -0.030721312388777733, 0.02128644473850727, 0.027344053611159325, 0.06191389262676239, -0.05113133043050766, 0.0025777039118111134, -0.00014955121150705963, -0.028541475534439087, 0.06170674413442612, -0.0014503784477710724, 0.015369990840554237, 0.05202828347682953, -0.030716417357325554, -0.015610013157129288, -0.06017224118113518, 0.01003244984894991, 0.0015091560781002045, -0.029936064034700394, 0.029316196218132973, 0.020845599472522736, 0.024350052699446678, 0.01213161926716566, -0.000843120098579675, -0.03397630155086517, -0.007785758003592491, 0.013056216761469841, -0.02589893899857998, -0.03082246147096157, -0.0039815036579966545, -0.002746579237282276, 0.006525013595819473, -0.025282802060246468, -0.04240741953253746, -0.000852335651870817, 0.07164287567138672, 0.034624211490154266, -0.027054954320192337, -0.028665248304605484, -0.0004740118165500462, 0.03687245398759842, -0.04160962626338005, -0.0035326394718140364, -0.025567449629306793, 0.03319528326392174, 0.03183190897107124, -0.03405843302607536 ]
<p>I wonder if it is fair is to compare the gini coefficient of two discrete distributions with different number of elements. If not, how can I adjust the coefficients for a fair comparison. </p> <p>In particular, I'm interested in the case when the sum of values in both distributions are equal. For example, minutes played by players of two teams in a basketball game if they have different number of players (10 players in one team, 12 players in the other team) but for both teams sums plays 48 minutes x 5. </p> <p>Other example, different partitioning of some surface in different regions, how to compare inequality for different partitioning if they have different number of subareas. </p>
22,257
[ -0.02048487588763237, 0.011586572974920273, -0.0629773661494255, -0.030857255682349205, 0.05758604407310486, 0.01578320376574993, -0.00502482894808054, -0.027279552072286606, 0.01774362288415432, -0.03478351607918739, 0.037660013884305954, 0.01323702558875084, 0.03314480185508728, 0.01438184455037117, 0.024511748924851418, -0.005200718063861132, -0.031487077474594116, 0.011687914840877056, 0.009574645198881626, -0.024717099964618683, -0.013921741396188736, 0.016905756667256355, 0.007018912583589554, -0.013147173449397087, -0.03977230191230774, 0.04763699695467949, 0.028401916846632957, 0.0002881342079490423, -0.007081562653183937, 0.08529641479253769, -0.017894979566335678, -0.00699435593560338, 0.016180679202079773, 0.050109267234802246, 0.019212625920772552, 0.007946806028485298, -0.07131538540124893, -0.03816718980669975, -0.01614430733025074, 0.022406557574868202, -0.05389274284243584, -0.0308370478451252, -0.010506399907171726, 0.012059111148118973, 0.006260707043111324, 0.05983820930123329, 0.017140939831733704, -0.04122151434421539, 0.01987728290259838, -0.059528641402721405, 0.05408193916082382, 0.03246820718050003, 0.07190203666687012, 0.0294262133538723, -0.026134347543120384, -0.033433105796575546, 0.009539171122014523, 0.10867983847856522, -0.0017499970272183418, -0.027520745992660522, 0.017533840611577034, -0.00925989169627428, 0.01030680537223816, -0.017034301534295082, -0.0379030816257, 0.01243108231574297, 0.0018212544964626431, -0.014019033871591091, 0.015550055541098118, -0.013754229061305523, -0.007513053715229034, 0.04329920560121536, 0.04668918624520302, -0.029363103210926056, 0.03084465302526951, -0.03544386103749275, 0.03520338982343674, 0.028845185413956642, 0.04189058765769005, 0.01038103923201561, 0.02270333655178547, -0.0025647238362580538, 0.03502611443400383, 0.04979884997010231, 0.026386668905615807, -0.023332584649324417, 0.04513046145439148, -0.018892357125878334, 0.013295499607920647, -0.002129088155925274, -0.027542980387806892, -0.034876998513936996, 0.0454363189637661, 0.01527942530810833, -0.052865512669086456, 0.04116537421941757, -0.01105459127575159, -0.005946746561676264, 0.02116004377603531, -0.020196175202727318, -0.02170524001121521, -0.0355677604675293, 0.04287199676036835, 0.05514981597661972, 0.007033421192318201, 0.00541949737817049, -0.060804951936006546, 0.03475186973810196, 0.021507147699594498, 0.02884862944483757, -0.03733907639980316, 0.024336375296115875, 0.0009535116842016578, 0.00033289645216427743, 0.005476881749927998, 0.007009053137153387, -0.0011299303732812405, -0.0009065214544534683, 0.05118251591920853, 0.0665227547287941, 0.023206094279885292, -0.04577798396348953, 0.0038775682915002108, -0.023059101775288582, -0.062170613557100296, 0.031722117215394974, 0.020386990159749985, -0.0028677182272076607, -0.04858558252453804, 0.051067452877759933, 0.008798599243164062, -0.005629908759146929, 0.023210434243083, -0.032319121062755585, 0.039065342396497726, 0.00960446521639824, -0.07243803143501282, -0.0728563442826271, 0.03415990248322487, 0.0015514134429395199, -0.03748741373419762, -0.029283102601766586, -0.023060785606503487, 0.0006365462322719395, 0.051933273673057556, 0.01755635440349579, 0.07169444859027863, -0.02700687013566494, 0.06041814014315605, 0.03467433899641037, 0.001104407594539225, -0.03575830161571503, -0.020873626694083214, -0.026617811992764473, 0.010977337136864662, -0.05455627664923668, -0.01913096010684967, 0.04080742970108986, -0.023757629096508026, 0.003276403760537505, 0.021703394129872322, 0.04278125613927841, -0.019204823300242424, -0.017103644087910652, -0.0104820029810071, -0.04238516464829445, 0.0634758248925209, -0.004921468440443277, 0.05791369080543518, -0.006836418993771076, -0.02358452044427395, 0.02013227716088295, 0.005089679267257452, 0.025799762457609177, 0.06362027674913406, -0.02394568920135498, 0.018974358215928078, 0.019357118755578995, 0.009590968489646912, 0.0025888700038194656, -0.051546577364206314, 0.0008865438285283744, -0.026038087904453278, -0.011013399809598923, -0.002703883918002248, -0.015575629658997059, 0.01318778283894062, -0.007126804906874895, 0.015431386418640614, -0.05361168831586838, -0.0405159592628479, -0.09306575357913971, -0.019756564870476723, 0.0198720321059227, -0.025311188772320747, 0.043281346559524536, 0.0116534773260355, 0.014575830660760403, -0.02092467062175274, -0.023134874179959297, -0.008881235495209694, 0.020121004432439804, 0.023832889273762703, -0.03147090971469879, -0.00612300680950284, 0.08153872936964035, 0.06995417177677155, -0.008954661898314953, 0.06383026391267776, -0.01585754193365574, -0.07024236023426056, 0.018130864948034286, -0.020044410601258278, 0.03319782763719559, 0.01306127104908228, 0.01979272998869419, 0.019610850140452385, 0.006564224138855934, 0.001987993950024247, 0.03367675840854645, -0.039563149213790894, 0.07545614242553711, 0.07926119863986969, 0.005995374638587236, -0.013481978327035904, 0.023787856101989746, 0.0011504041031002998, 0.012767241336405277, -0.0035125110298395157, -0.029798883944749832, -0.05747362971305847, 0.0040997047908604145, 0.003983892034739256, 0.03975388780236244, -0.019129620864987373, -0.0007917603943496943, 0.07450029253959656, 0.03926093876361847, 0.01840384677052498, 0.00011521924170665443, -0.02264745533466339, -0.0436965636909008, 0.043473221361637115, -0.015113637782633305, 0.033829424530267715, 0.01662452146410942, 0.04143175110220909, -0.013607965782284737, -0.011468606069684029, -0.019419580698013306, 0.008457631804049015, 0.04489194601774216, 0.01263346429914236, 0.02027842402458191, 0.014680212363600731, -0.022978054359555244, 0.014509187079966068, -0.010086040943861008, 0.022748451679944992, 0.04291107878088951, -0.007606178987771273, 0.0002902102132793516, -0.005242486018687487, -0.03175516426563263, 0.0010317827109247446, 0.007586974184960127, -0.02480269782245159, -0.0036103937309235334, 0.031095001846551895, -0.0014007097342982888, 0.015228088945150375, -0.024934329092502594, 0.012351530604064465, -0.045648716390132904, -0.03668089210987091, 0.03755787014961243, 0.0013527987757697701, -0.0037303802091628313, -0.01666400022804737, 0.012352675199508667, -0.02205321006476879, 0.02816997841000557, 0.008967529982328415, 0.02548951841890812, -0.08566771447658539, 0.017960598692297935, -0.00840137992054224, -0.01035971101373434, 0.018349211663007736, -0.012254679575562477, 0.01133756898343563, 0.04685020446777344, -0.01606758125126362, -0.028104711323976517, 0.0026749595999717712, 0.014116968959569931, 0.03396940231323242, -0.04197237268090248, -0.025383006781339645, 0.07364284247159958, 0.020988961681723595, -0.06787099689245224, 0.036076128482818604, -0.013973313383758068, -0.010501962155103683, -0.04229627549648285, -0.014464744366705418, 0.03723173215985298, 0.020448731258511543, -0.002944663632661104, 0.03715312480926514, -0.009686625562608242, -0.04019389674067497, -0.051358893513679504, -0.0916527807712555, 0.033694006502628326, -0.033790621906518936, 0.03721429407596588, -0.011149315163493156, -0.04471055045723915, 0.035585615783929825, 0.05362769961357117, -0.02099565975368023, -0.025909030809998512, 0.003919041715562344, 0.0067018670961260796, 0.009543451480567455, 0.040709786117076874, 0.02873140759766102, -0.0223113801330328, 0.01504957303404808, 0.013471252284944057, 0.04732222110033035, 0.04250315576791763, -0.013744518160820007, -0.03230970352888107, 0.029949452728033066, 0.01657966338098049, -0.015940094366669655, 0.06043325364589691, 0.015887929126620293, -0.03890638425946236, -0.008719869889318943, -0.007398002315312624, 0.019943976774811745, 0.008305718190968037, -0.02148539200425148, 0.012733531184494495, -0.0015837389510124922, 0.006870818790048361, -0.028916414827108383, 0.0313832126557827, 0.03752626106142998, -0.024952996522188187, 0.02248586155474186, 0.008781153708696365, 0.022758571431040764, -0.01226600632071495, -0.012547153048217297, 0.050575464963912964, 0.04941428080201149, -0.00428107799962163, 0.0025602870155125856, -0.003023248864337802, 0.03725329786539078, 0.04847968742251396, -0.05622339993715286, -0.0067694359458982944, 0.00923564750701189, 0.019205555319786072, 0.013126644305884838, -0.02684338204562664, -0.07250876724720001, -0.004274966195225716, -0.07458334416151047, 0.020564816892147064, -0.02865908108651638, 0.08615738153457642, -0.01160858478397131, 0.012722179293632507, -0.01218690536916256, -0.0035286503843963146, 0.00806549470871687, -0.017990075051784515, -0.06507398188114166, 0.03440193831920624, -0.012014752253890038, 0.01726221665740013, -0.03655223920941353, -0.025858337059617043, 0.011910585686564445, -0.03424622491002083, -0.009861661121249199, -0.0012758367229253054, 0.021933745592832565, -0.04943690076470375, 0.008129806257784367, -0.05256422236561775, -0.042396292090415955, 0.041507963091135025, 0.017488162964582443, 0.00594740267843008, -0.013049948960542679, 0.027519267052412033, 0.033357419073581696, -0.013691768981516361, -0.013865165412425995, -0.022748038172721863, 0.01449985895305872, -0.003581357654184103, 0.04738007113337517, -0.0031368578784167767, 0.03088052198290825, -0.03190535679459572, 0.01876816898584366, 0.00847652368247509, 0.03292127326130867, 0.0014000473311170936, -0.02220631204545498, -0.014605322852730751, -0.053581949323415756, -0.04454222694039345, -0.03539546951651573, 0.038223691284656525, -0.017687765881419182, -0.015920458361506462, 0.035430554300546646, 0.06474681943655014, -0.06913526356220245, 0.03276947885751724, 0.05244339630007744, 0.01014135405421257, -0.044884536415338516, -0.04468173161149025, -0.03379039466381073, -0.02230607345700264, -0.011417606845498085, 0.01346561498939991, -0.002703925361856818, -0.014118990860879421, 0.023994827643036842, 0.03230501711368561, -0.0061439089477062225, -0.026890859007835388, -0.02265019342303276, 0.03994036465883255, 0.04294116795063019, -0.008083296939730644, -0.041084252297878265, 0.001211221213452518, 0.03376868739724159, -0.003521723672747612, 0.04182354733347893, 0.005072279367595911, -0.05753519758582115, -0.028199082240462303, 0.02808467485010624, 0.011241594329476357, -0.023635538294911385, 0.013987199403345585, -0.04034358635544777, 0.017382441088557243, 0.033786170184612274, -0.03367374464869499, 0.01747577264904976, -0.0223801601678133, -0.003786416258662939, 0.005559863988310099, 0.006660226732492447, -0.004259380046278238, 0.03189545497298241, 0.01198106911033392, 0.06260809302330017, -0.028561413288116455, -0.013992912136018276, -0.037999071180820465, 0.01315255742520094, 0.02674674615263939, 0.05978488549590111, -0.026001986116170883, -0.018360882997512817, 0.038219187408685684, 0.007859256118535995, -0.003762531327083707, -0.06603603810071945, 0.011368501000106335, 0.020259445533156395, 0.015984810888767242, 0.026655584573745728, -0.02003793977200985, -0.0002538302796892822, -0.0036401778925210238, 0.008319923654198647, 0.003948414698243141, 0.012763528153300285, -0.009650971740484238, 0.06688954681158066, 0.02897469885647297, -0.003383257193490863, 0.04440125450491905, 0.02075745351612568, -0.026024363934993744, 0.012367922812700272, -0.03411749005317688, 0.001607729820534587, -0.02277219295501709, -0.018737446516752243, -0.030429042875766754, -0.04726167395710945, 0.02206329256296158, 0.018636353313922882, -0.027076024562120438, 0.04518674686551094, -0.0008773090085014701, -0.03730376064777374, 0.005545421037822962, 0.015150489285588264, -0.014102998189628124, -0.008463788777589798, 0.006720658857375383, 0.018119104206562042, 0.022890714928507805, -0.014031392522156239, 0.050590772181749344, 0.01676962897181511, -0.012074516154825687, -0.015874499455094337, -0.026711398735642433, 0.033332012593746185, -0.04992065206170082, -0.029407987371087074, -0.021896163001656532, 0.002107287058606744, 0.052751198410987854, -0.004635571502149105, 0.054353270679712296, 0.001929695252329111, -0.03536374866962433, -0.011429608799517155, 0.0016609083395451307, -0.006720756180584431, 0.034114986658096313, -0.03217976540327072, 0.05416009947657585, 0.009198744781315327, -0.023227917030453682, -0.09354247152805328, -0.008781892247498035, -0.008154676295816898, -0.0024213215801864862, 0.006502774078398943, -0.06341273337602615, -0.011419625021517277, -0.003966564312577248, -0.021515484899282455, 0.003257967531681061, 0.04932381212711334, -0.003410519566386938, -0.025239435955882072, 0.0021036386024206877, -0.0027247664984315634, 0.09324486553668976, -0.023058872669935226, 0.004608816932886839, -0.021961329504847527, 0.0020833557937294245, -0.007722544018179178, -0.014109572395682335, -0.00019307926413603127, -0.03089795634150505, -0.026317482814192772, 0.021105317398905754, 0.014613580889999866, 0.030639806762337685, -0.014842626638710499, -0.024679630994796753, -0.012727326713502407, -0.04359116032719612, 0.012698758393526077, -0.042449161410331726, 0.007144676987081766, -0.01636721007525921, -0.004297352395951748, -0.045682862401008606, -0.0020759233739227057, -0.018045471981167793, -0.00700826570391655, 0.009325532242655754, 0.011987652629613876, 0.00161813385784626, -0.003725809045135975, 0.054120879620313644, -0.017437929287552834, -0.028554469347000122, 0.03477494418621063, -0.009995723143219948, 0.07607636600732803, -0.019584381952881813, -0.03355703130364418, 0.02376500703394413, 0.04621468856930733, -0.025419747456908226, -0.028144167736172676, -0.020962104201316833, 0.018631834536790848, 0.0026336978189647198, -0.017226116731762886, 0.03614824265241623, 0.079665906727314, 0.01759655401110649, 0.006821863818913698, -0.039290640503168106, -0.002025424502789974, 0.021846426650881767, 0.0032901279628276825, 0.02537674829363823, -0.031846366822719574, -0.00369510636664927, 0.0247309822589159, 0.021981636062264442, -0.010011042468249798, 0.06193011626601219, 0.0008304763468913734, -0.0061158607713878155, 0.02436837926506996, -0.027496665716171265, -0.046505410224199295, 0.018677223473787308, -0.03729116544127464, 0.016497600823640823, -0.047095075249671936, -0.025176262483000755, 0.05303487926721573, 0.02925887517631054, -0.016145536676049232, -0.047501105815172195, -0.019682183861732483, -0.027194809168577194, 0.014896509237587452, 0.021184543147683144, -0.011213907971978188, 0.053109776228666306, -0.02900317870080471, 0.0335562564432621, -0.015201189555227757, 0.001751178759150207, -0.027908360585570335, -0.06852766126394272, -0.02027870900928974, -0.05670667067170143, -0.042939409613609314, -0.0019355565309524536, 0.00958745926618576, -0.006779014598578215, 0.0356782041490078, -0.0045110974460840225, -0.015131047926843166, -0.007745327893644571, 0.006757268216460943, -0.008316129446029663, 0.08699578046798706, -0.023870917037129402, 0.03281497210264206, 0.0009833162184804678, -0.004238817375153303, 0.09227096289396286, 0.0321369506418705, 0.03477572277188301, -0.016898958012461662, 0.0369449108839035, 0.012038755230605602, -0.004100416321307421, 0.002012112643569708, 0.014681853353977203, 0.03739488869905472, -0.03503255546092987, 0.04179768264293671, 0.048387691378593445, 0.0033979294821619987, -0.027959011495113373, 0.032858945429325104, -0.012720649130642414, 0.007160457782447338, 0.009747284464538097, 0.012256753630936146, 0.017277482897043228, -0.017812415957450867, -0.06878235936164856, 0.010077673010528088, 0.022695215418934822, 0.002626817673444748, -0.032464805990457535, -0.014189614914357662, -0.012285892851650715, 0.04085438698530197, -0.048973001539707184, 0.004917677026242018, 0.04245944321155548, -0.020935963839292526, -0.02335013821721077, -0.032602403312921524, 0.014934430830180645, -0.04365178942680359, -0.0036035957746207714, 0.029389232397079468, 0.008428879082202911, 0.015196491032838821, 0.03228520601987839, 0.035659268498420715, -0.052695225924253464, -0.007369669154286385, -0.0598301887512207, 0.0007838151068426669, -0.02568446658551693, -0.005241017788648605, 0.012313319370150566, -0.003117435146123171, -0.025789126753807068, -0.07743452489376068, -0.04116201028227806, 0.010773737914860249, 0.014262393116950989, 0.011465133167803288, -0.04421992227435112, -0.003584080608561635, 0.04595205560326576, -0.017756104469299316, 0.02867724932730198, -0.02850036881864071, -0.04689789563417435, -0.005614278372377157, -0.00562351755797863, 0.05320662632584572, -0.025885213166475296, -0.0146856177598238, -0.02590913139283657, -0.0038198817055672407, -0.0505191870033741, -0.02168026566505432, -0.032431259751319885, -0.0019263855647295713, 0.02718154899775982, 0.030828144401311874, -0.011042485013604164, 0.0035380939953029156, -0.006832850631326437, 0.0012740776874125004, -0.045988310128450394, 0.009301812388002872, -0.044778335839509964, -0.02320081926882267, 0.05142347887158394, 0.03566894680261612, -0.008017282001674175, 0.0057851229794323444, -0.009141232818365097, 0.03542802855372429, 0.012577464804053307, -0.011184641160070896, -0.004784492775797844, -0.03314109146595001, -0.0603860504925251, 0.03320368006825447, -0.03556229546666145, 0.057948339730501175, 0.022569742053747177, 0.008665457367897034, 0.017913589254021645, 0.02705368958413601, -0.026268549263477325, 0.021254945546388626, -0.02053346112370491, -0.07323801517486572, -0.0010946551337838173, 0.025059964507818222, -0.001983156893402338, -0.01663876324892044, 0.008296935819089413, -0.05797211080789566, -0.041837260127067566, 0.007154672406613827, -0.044524770230054855, -0.030128225684165955, -0.014254789799451828, -0.026393603533506393, 0.000003943555839214241, -0.0006801470299251378, -0.00770083162933588, -0.018513139337301254, -0.025854656472802162, 0.013275803066790104, -0.0007476879982277751, -0.020791707560420036, -0.009620962664484978, -0.018634965643286705, 0.0171729177236557, 0.056328680366277695, 0.00009331815817859024, 0.020666325464844704, -0.019264668226242065, 0.05164489150047302, -0.0014272884000092745, 0.07334207743406296, -0.0243187565356493, -0.049728989601135254, 0.05465418100357056, -0.008736616000533104, -0.042041461914777756, 0.008592939004302025, -0.02973497100174427, 0.04271746799349785, -0.01105797290802002, -0.011678635142743587, -0.03916607424616814, 0.028859300538897514, -0.015847910195589066, 0.01187265757471323, -0.02454305812716484, 0.0028527132235467434, 0.04065689072012901, -0.006578601896762848, 0.01464762818068266, 0.002682772232219577, -0.03847094997763634, 0.022535881027579308, 0.022417645901441574, -0.0037019250448793173, -0.02570609375834465, -0.023458171635866165, 0.011965371668338776, -0.0018998233135789633, 0.004836707841604948, -0.026691729202866554, 0.026129812002182007, 0.04163940250873566, -0.031018512323498726, 0.03359908610582352, -0.01170910894870758, -0.022096561267971992, -0.06017165631055832, -0.019291730597615242, 0.033372946083545685, -0.03429071605205536, 0.015097214840352535, -0.034413862973451614, 0.0027726772241294384, -0.004183352924883366, -0.04992793872952461, 0.06570564210414886, 0.005161357577890158, -0.020259378477931023, -0.07207436859607697, 0.020054467022418976, -0.0023328184615820646, 0.024781305342912674, 0.008777868933975697, 0.040119290351867676, 0.015063908882439137, 0.011687933467328548, -0.014165454544126987, -0.012409325689077377, -0.028134785592556, -0.004298285115510225, -0.03676328808069229, -0.05499919503927231, 0.027735399082303047, -0.044368959963321686, -0.03084241971373558, 0.045849550515413284, -0.001284413505345583, 0.005874331574887037, -0.016901973634958267, -0.004391833208501339, 0.0025309938937425613, 0.0320158451795578, 0.02161312662065029, 0.007298419252038002, 0.005528000183403492, 0.011235079728066921, -0.01056528277695179, -0.012537009082734585, -0.015712184831500053, 0.01230325922369957, 0.05903066322207451, 0.016546769067645073, 0.008516788482666016, 0.035414598882198334, 0.009538477286696434, -0.020950743928551674, 0.004354820586740971, -0.015154599212110043, 0.05820269137620926, 0.005082682706415653, 0.027232099324464798, -0.012023216113448143, 0.012417325749993324, 0.04062053561210632, 0.021860206499695778, -0.025120079517364502, -0.006180741358548403, 0.006458567921072245, -0.05534622073173523, 0.014540345408022404, 0.028961913660168648, -0.00003535139694577083, -0.032960329204797745, 0.011928684078156948, -0.010571366176009178, 0.002285189228132367, -0.03635825216770172, -0.05802391469478607, -0.0296529158949852, -0.006532013416290283, -0.010557303205132484, 0.013715200126171112, 0.006684362422674894, -0.02912650816142559, 0.03540531545877457, -0.07882295548915863, 0.012309647165238857, 0.029354140162467957, -0.011864351108670235, -0.016713576391339302, -0.005095282103866339, -0.06224533170461655, -0.006769905332475901, 0.05861219763755798, 0.023350562900304794, -0.01624218188226223, 0.011849516071379185, 0.018525928258895874, 0.05961499735713005, -0.025025291368365288, 0.016120227053761482, -0.012852532789111137, -0.04349035769701004, -0.003219818929210305, 0.013870387338101864, -0.003627372905611992, 0.007420532405376434, -0.02650044485926628, -0.0031759152188897133, 0.004714095965027809, -0.0027647721581161022, -0.01519800629466772, 0.027193862944841385, -0.01975812017917633, -0.00916206929832697, 0.04960501566529274, 0.000009393592335982248, 0.0423547588288784, 0.003434442915022373, 0.00030896381940692663, -0.029690459370613098, 0.009713434614241123, -0.04476673901081085, -0.03453094884753227, 0.01418434176594019, 0.01774579845368862, 0.005849684122949839, -0.05010463297367096, 0.006371644791215658, 0.040297020226716995, 0.008350308053195477, -0.024510759860277176, 0.026674848049879074, 0.06468098610639572, 0.042853083461523056, -0.021776076406240463, 0.02728266641497612, 0.003065000055357814, -0.010736952535808086, 0.013939978554844856, 0.009850087575614452, 0.0366922952234745, 0.017469167709350586, 0.03419830650091171, 0.04511769115924835, -0.03216234967112541, 0.03305777907371521, 0.018444281071424484, 0.04728350043296814, 0.023570911958813667, -0.006175757851451635, 0.019068283960223198, 0.0005524586304090917, -0.0014811982400715351, 0.034720323979854584, -0.0022748741321265697, 0.040459468960762024, 0.0017089771572500467, 0.02823294885456562, -0.05001860857009888, -0.003696403931826353, -0.045426346361637115, -0.01966044493019581, 0.0027532349340617657, 0.02331545017659664, -0.0020583856385201216, -0.0144378412514925, 0.005414299201220274, -0.011412348598241806, 0.03817591443657875, 0.005518615711480379, 0.042865023016929626, -0.012375537306070328, 0.024324970319867134, -0.0015146525111049414, 0.0000751020124880597, -0.01231536827981472, -0.027592996135354042, 0.05052656680345535, 0.0673537477850914, 0.04849651828408241, 0.009942120872437954, -0.04795264080166817, 0.005833490751683712, 0.05426158756017685, -0.08306917548179626, -0.06175432354211807, -0.05017390847206116, 0.008237801492214203, -0.007696765009313822, 0.006050729658454657 ]
<p>I'm looking to test for equality of means across different sample sizes of data, but know that the data is not normally distributed and heteroscedastic. Can anyone suggest anything?</p>
49,583
[ -0.03849899768829346, 0.004602053668349981, -0.04583640396595001, 0.017231814563274384, 0.027874518185853958, 0.015159178525209427, -0.005799021106213331, -0.029344843700528145, -0.010233963839709759, -0.006748070474714041, 0.07432711869478226, 0.01704532839357853, 0.03625467047095299, 0.004303825553506613, 0.019337745383381844, -0.009428911842405796, -0.04524131491780281, -0.0059369406662881374, 0.005427917931228876, -0.02586653269827366, 0.0008730711415410042, 0.0002537652035243809, 0.02177445776760578, -0.017254693433642387, -0.02567417174577713, 0.0443246066570282, 0.03472965955734253, -0.012925371527671814, 0.01423115935176611, 0.07149100303649902, -0.04210972785949707, -0.042768072336912155, 0.022246751934289932, 0.060393039137125015, -0.003256996162235737, 0.006402966100722551, -0.006304376292973757, -0.03861294314265251, -0.012740383855998516, 0.03978566825389862, -0.03887888789176941, 0.011668690480291843, 0.0033259117044508457, 0.03129391744732857, -0.015605472028255463, 0.03664151579141617, -0.02263994887471199, -0.04332275316119194, 0.026610862463712692, -0.06784023344516754, 0.08576616644859314, 0.022128876298666, 0.05121565982699394, 0.029968103393912315, -0.020953655242919922, -0.015735147520899773, 0.02667923830449581, 0.06219273433089256, -0.00843723677098751, -0.03783285245299339, -0.006320976186543703, -0.04357888177037239, -0.003316686488687992, -0.013289300724864006, -0.031689420342445374, 0.023077817633748055, -0.023485222831368446, -0.01748926378786564, 0.013074024580419064, 0.02198726497590542, 0.012976597994565964, 0.04150797054171562, 0.05890881270170212, -0.001763880834914744, -0.026344208046793938, -0.015009738504886627, 0.01564183458685875, 0.004630195442587137, 0.029911089688539505, 0.03696393966674805, 0.003004756523296237, 0.009086070582270622, 0.017025761306285858, 0.025195281952619553, 0.04485803842544556, -0.02369294874370098, 0.06034431234002113, -0.010986772365868092, 0.0036251794081181288, 0.03614085167646408, -0.014413174241781235, -0.019021427258849144, 0.06912553310394287, 0.015224245376884937, -0.03062290884554386, 0.015260057523846626, -0.03280315920710564, 0.019351307302713394, -0.012834019027650356, 0.014278121292591095, 0.006269099656492472, -0.061193108558654785, 0.04870983213186264, 0.04603077843785286, -0.00027596292784437537, -0.0053825112991034985, -0.031485315412282944, -0.0014208604115992785, 0.008916860446333885, -0.0006721055251546204, 0.008377634920179844, 0.009888328611850739, 0.011401720345020294, 0.014496098272502422, 0.029479872435331345, 0.0015455035027116537, -0.010372490622103214, -0.039444126188755035, 0.05093677341938019, 0.07513979822397232, 0.04844758287072182, -0.010308224707841873, 0.023192888125777245, -0.03308166190981865, -0.039799708873033524, 0.0196030605584383, -0.011441543698310852, -0.016017625108361244, -0.02409493923187256, 0.06085235998034477, 0.00624770438298583, -0.03957747668027878, 0.0010714861564338207, -0.029930150136351585, 0.07519848644733429, -0.0034090066328644753, -0.058625102043151855, -0.053128741681575775, 0.009842738509178162, -0.003959381952881813, -0.035718824714422226, -0.05391356348991394, -0.004599615000188351, 0.006927753333002329, 0.030750559642910957, 0.016634395346045494, 0.05748559162020683, -0.018188601359725, 0.04140559956431389, 0.021180376410484314, -0.008826402947306633, -0.007787165232002735, -0.0050019770860672, -0.01720740646123886, 0.03558778017759323, -0.0848441869020462, -0.016493186354637146, -0.016814496368169785, -0.011382692493498325, 0.008678313344717026, 0.008540899492800236, 0.012788436375558376, -0.005287873558700085, -0.03424905613064766, 0.050711337476968765, -0.01837395317852497, 0.07292207330465317, -0.033748939633369446, 0.027394721284508705, 0.0017295860452577472, -0.0029100067913532257, 0.0002924671280197799, 0.03960816189646721, 0.05233108252286911, 0.05314101278781891, -0.020755473524332047, 0.013656316325068474, -0.004624038003385067, 0.047808513045310974, 0.01883748546242714, -0.020097678527235985, -0.0009910734370350838, -0.015306924469769001, 0.0025346872862428427, 0.020345302298665047, 0.04270799085497856, -0.000018397258827462792, -0.047258831560611725, 0.03549770638346672, -0.0411682054400444, -0.033985670655965805, -0.06174901872873306, 0.0024687866680324078, -0.02803811803460121, -0.02129376493394375, 0.044588759541511536, 0.030796853825449944, 0.051698483526706696, -0.047553543001413345, -0.02962728776037693, -0.0196387879550457, -0.0018531049136072397, 0.04265366494655609, -0.03140275180339813, 0.008184798061847687, 0.034562718123197556, 0.058724239468574524, -0.012882404029369354, 0.039382852613925934, -0.020498070865869522, -0.045013364404439926, 0.016911223530769348, -0.05665756016969681, 0.0018863147124648094, 0.018661702051758766, 0.02683253027498722, 0.008189305663108826, 0.01124597992748022, -0.0159306637942791, 0.059188805520534515, -0.037597525864839554, 0.06547132879495621, 0.03610942140221596, 0.008702365681529045, -0.002949889050796628, -0.02260563150048256, 0.021170588210225105, -0.0027811352629214525, -0.03885633870959282, -0.03143732622265816, -0.04615967348217964, 0.01622694730758667, 0.03800836205482483, -0.008533227257430553, -0.031087851151823997, 0.006750162225216627, 0.08063060790300369, 0.0025934588629752398, 0.01049234252423048, 0.0265284925699234, 0.009003614075481892, -0.030180253088474274, -0.01663268357515335, 0.003854219103232026, 0.02594403550028801, 0.006683172192424536, 0.02140103466808796, 0.013600953854620457, 0.03334591165184975, 0.01344495452940464, -0.010025300085544586, 0.01801784336566925, 0.002210641512647271, 0.010088044218719006, -0.021696262061595917, -0.034634292125701904, 0.02393965795636177, -0.0048181829042732716, 0.01766122691333294, 0.04491683468222618, -0.0024466984905302525, -0.02499963343143463, 0.028278382495045662, -0.03462984040379524, 0.03358498960733414, 0.02800660766661167, -0.020500926300883293, 0.015532655641436577, 0.03819374740123749, -0.03104354813694954, 0.0022445351351052523, -0.03861388564109802, -0.02424720674753189, -0.03113943710923195, -0.02106080763041973, 0.029376374557614326, -0.010777763091027737, 0.03267620876431465, -0.046293117105960846, 0.0004468915576580912, -0.007787629030644894, -0.017616577446460724, -0.004656285513192415, -0.01874111406505108, -0.04198857769370079, 0.014595036394894123, -0.029581699520349503, -0.00587439863011241, 0.02186531201004982, -0.0030249119736254215, 0.0011413743486627936, 0.04994797334074974, 0.010032405145466328, -0.029315460473299026, -0.0003138414758723229, -0.0377645343542099, -0.0033816795330494642, -0.029408970847725868, -0.02444368600845337, 0.06015951931476593, -0.0050154016353189945, -0.04907462000846863, 0.023313861340284348, -0.0322265587747097, -0.018984129652380943, -0.03361395746469498, 0.016086699441075325, 0.005474083591252565, 0.0005919819814153016, 0.03377019986510277, 0.03260461613535881, -0.036639049649238586, -0.027036702260375023, -0.03149556741118431, -0.07927540689706802, 0.0393773652613163, 0.0013606944121420383, 0.04441957175731659, 0.010228397324681282, -0.019471555948257446, 0.02758605033159256, 0.047360312193632126, -0.002463417360559106, -0.03712128475308418, 0.0012259986251592636, -0.035494036972522736, 0.009615969844162464, 0.027878830209374428, 0.014950687065720558, -0.007426165509968996, 0.024223770946264267, 0.026664599776268005, 0.0021272057201713324, 0.055851444602012634, 0.011646573431789875, -0.005083582829684019, -0.002016115700826049, 0.01119841355830431, -0.0035732227843254805, 0.028749527409672737, 0.02286458946764469, -0.06334341317415237, -0.01449856162071228, 0.04669073224067688, 0.013342002406716347, 0.010055582039058208, -0.027858782559633255, 0.012928077951073647, 0.0028920702170580626, 0.005252008326351643, -0.03910290077328682, 0.02572692185640335, 0.0181778222322464, 0.009631494991481304, -0.002242007991299033, 0.029154036194086075, -0.004665356129407883, -0.024595990777015686, 0.01181499008089304, 0.058823492377996445, 0.007371522951871157, -0.03227107599377632, 0.0002143672900274396, -0.017226332798600197, -0.027596425265073776, 0.03157750517129898, -0.02653472125530243, -0.030530335381627083, 0.05091305077075958, 0.035987891256809235, 0.035039301961660385, 0.009895489551126957, -0.04180516302585602, 0.01873498223721981, -0.0716879740357399, 0.022066626697778702, -0.019775036722421646, 0.02836354821920395, 0.011055181734263897, 0.03262241184711456, 0.06901603937149048, 0.0016202912665903568, 0.013092824257910252, -0.01915035955607891, -0.047131460160017014, 0.04033287242054939, -0.048162102699279785, -0.01742628775537014, -0.0010868246899917722, -0.030607666820287704, -0.0001929495920194313, -0.022141221910715103, 0.04355502501130104, -0.0004759721050504595, 0.02683093585073948, -0.01492046657949686, 0.02735738828778267, -0.01685357838869095, -0.014707166701555252, 0.025484008714556694, 0.013993796892464161, -0.010947340168058872, 0.008904701098799706, 0.017738407477736473, 0.019107168540358543, -0.008464768528938293, -0.0409139022231102, -0.009411877952516079, 0.0678279921412468, -0.0003745437425095588, 0.04605519771575928, 0.013409486971795559, 0.030051641166210175, -0.05339985340833664, 0.03322707861661911, -0.018503494560718536, 0.05670110881328583, -0.008893177844583988, -0.003634798340499401, -0.05632922053337097, -0.04792451113462448, -0.034923769533634186, 0.00804385170340538, 0.0052079688757658005, 0.007893725298345089, -0.0156281515955925, 0.04219004511833191, 0.026926694437861443, -0.061137162148952484, 0.004454389680176973, 0.07146640121936798, 0.028508251532912254, -0.010003652423620224, -0.028355058282613754, -0.026838192716240883, -0.029554199427366257, -0.02540738135576248, 0.035142961889505386, 0.012704236432909966, -0.005262012593448162, 0.007351668085902929, 0.042919937521219254, -0.030383877456188202, -0.037240978330373764, -0.010001618415117264, -0.003249633824452758, 0.04265037551522255, 0.0017326120287179947, -0.06105713173747063, -0.00027816841611638665, 0.02797381766140461, 0.015193270519375801, 0.024012591689825058, 0.02015833929181099, -0.07649094611406326, 0.053623732179403305, 0.0583748035132885, 0.029231205582618713, -0.02043655700981617, 0.015382376499474049, -0.03319101780653, 0.010119692422449589, 0.053076136857271194, -0.0336231105029583, 0.015470311045646667, -0.005988652352243662, 0.004466308746486902, -0.031207235530018806, -0.004312864970415831, -0.03794791176915169, 0.0031181571539491415, -0.0017575658857822418, -0.015751469880342484, -0.010931470431387424, -0.01816154457628727, -0.05233703553676605, -0.005032752640545368, 0.03743498772382736, 0.04982127621769905, -0.02793448232114315, -0.008051787503063679, 0.01411524973809719, 0.042604751884937286, -0.026028387248516083, -0.07015867531299591, -0.005930127110332251, 0.005772083066403866, 0.007729923818260431, 0.05504709482192993, -0.012278460897505283, -0.04241825267672539, 0.046673353761434555, -0.030326928943395615, -0.052918411791324615, -0.0012077678693458438, -0.007020147517323494, 0.0556630939245224, 0.015541617758572102, 0.030370190739631653, 0.04906988888978958, -0.0021346299909055233, -0.00148692075163126, 0.002425527200102806, -0.04109276086091995, 0.017452137544751167, -0.06313492357730865, -0.03363799676299095, -0.06993889808654785, -0.013387479819357395, -0.03033071756362915, 0.02377193048596382, -0.033714838325977325, 0.019912641495466232, -0.025616591796278954, 0.00025871593970805407, 0.008899429813027382, -0.004274770617485046, 0.03841233626008034, -0.007667165249586105, 0.0069599938578903675, 0.006749048829078674, -0.02268894575536251, -0.023118289187550545, 0.04643372446298599, 0.00982885342091322, -0.01511443592607975, -0.009216946549713612, -0.0493321567773819, 0.015786176547408104, -0.044186968356370926, -0.022715015336871147, 0.0006672589224763215, -0.02386048249900341, 0.028230920433998108, -0.014905628748238087, 0.04069853201508522, 0.014999623410403728, -0.037107668817043304, 0.004460170399397612, 0.03280576691031456, 0.0022545945830643177, 0.02924252673983574, -0.04751047119498253, 0.05059802532196045, -0.013680140487849712, -0.009059439413249493, -0.07938039302825928, -0.04807078465819359, 0.01412036083638668, 0.00840200949460268, 0.029475415125489235, -0.059447284787893295, 0.009987378492951393, -0.0005386381526477635, 0.002162652090191841, -0.011118719354271889, 0.051788508892059326, 0.01417456567287445, -0.034602753818035126, -0.029252130538225174, 0.012767970561981201, 0.10002662241458893, -0.020846150815486908, -0.00899883359670639, -0.008314625360071659, -0.028522497043013573, -0.01665172167122364, -0.00797458179295063, 0.009685583412647247, -0.04137766733765602, -0.005322542041540146, -0.029708387330174446, -0.0062069944106042385, 0.03568040207028389, -0.055743567645549774, -0.018339665606617928, 0.007990973070263863, -0.0029624204616993666, -0.0012942134635522962, -0.05210638418793678, 0.008377227932214737, -0.0357576385140419, 0.0198462326079607, -0.03658453747630119, -0.004636627156287432, -0.02218506671488285, -0.0008020909735932946, 0.014277995564043522, 0.021827811375260353, -0.023591959848999977, 0.010036775842308998, 0.08756610006093979, 0.015511901117861271, 0.025344625115394592, 0.008797443471848965, -0.026816410943865776, 0.008025974035263062, 0.0032122584525495768, -0.017601145431399345, 0.0008460070239380002, 0.0261912290006876, -0.07477270066738129, -0.05330166593194008, -0.007922245189547539, -0.008858766406774521, 0.03546273708343506, 0.0064639742486178875, 0.08421836793422699, 0.09518332779407501, 0.005593560170382261, 0.01939765177667141, -0.004071975592523813, 0.009469792246818542, 0.0030782180838286877, 0.00905096996575594, 0.046837255358695984, 0.01563558727502823, 0.012087631970643997, 0.03747749328613281, 0.03492359071969986, 0.031252142041921616, 0.05410044267773628, 0.03893144056200981, 0.022746073082089424, 0.031329963356256485, -0.022384673357009888, -0.04423058032989502, 0.049825891852378845, -0.05719362571835518, 0.018348218873143196, -0.04310547187924385, -0.0023063526023179293, 0.04511963576078415, 0.04039480537176132, -0.0013723488664254546, -0.009569752961397171, -0.014654788188636303, -0.04259951412677765, 0.022622540593147278, 0.0007204520516097546, -0.01845109462738037, 0.0067076170817017555, 0.02794010564684868, 0.03652238845825195, -0.02990388497710228, 0.007227765861898661, -0.056372012943029404, -0.07914968580007553, -0.017898833379149437, 0.0016435030847787857, -0.03125486895442009, 0.02169499546289444, 0.00010534151078900322, 0.007985529489815235, 0.009141858667135239, -0.02288493514060974, -0.010359924286603928, -0.026055332273244858, 0.007307399995625019, -0.011522541753947735, 0.045679859817028046, 0.014344344846904278, 0.03023418039083481, 0.007029269356280565, -0.009241611696779728, 0.11863506585359573, 0.06049143522977829, 0.043305445462465286, -0.05274312198162079, 0.027774939313530922, -0.011537037789821625, -0.0014486376894637942, -0.014746223576366901, 0.028770996257662773, -0.022900737822055817, 0.025786373764276505, 0.062002088874578476, 0.0706704705953598, -0.004445631988346577, -0.019050775095820427, 0.09787365794181824, 0.0049171787686645985, -0.005746441427618265, 0.02114436775445938, 0.028527364134788513, 0.020538121461868286, -0.033322181552648544, -0.02806824818253517, 0.06945157796144485, -0.00013906595995649695, -0.012310175225138664, -0.014601246453821659, -0.031775057315826416, 0.01399531401693821, 0.037425264716148376, -0.029007844626903534, 0.0056618452072143555, 0.021520204842090607, 0.019063090905547142, -0.03548522666096687, -0.03576630726456642, 0.0320538729429245, -0.011284620501101017, -0.0064062499441206455, 0.031285516917705536, 0.00289847981184721, 0.005272055976092815, 0.007278807926923037, 0.00034493874409236014, -0.019329849630594254, -0.002729767467826605, -0.034890759736299515, 0.0304790697991848, -0.0007304735481739044, 0.006512380670756102, -0.006697257049381733, 0.025091513991355896, -0.023554252460598946, -0.06334518641233444, -0.02215300127863884, 0.011677567847073078, 0.003830332774668932, -0.03340323641896248, 0.007466215640306473, -0.0401247963309288, 0.03989509865641594, 0.0026248276699334383, 0.03243991360068321, 0.025250589475035667, -0.01242329366505146, 0.005507363472133875, -0.03607363626360893, 0.05172109603881836, -0.01402332354336977, -0.03428373113274574, 0.021066047251224518, -0.011670256964862347, -0.020937366411089897, -0.005245131440460682, 0.0008277502493001521, -0.01263003796339035, 0.050393246114254, -0.0003589025291148573, -0.02153673768043518, -0.015806764364242554, -0.06060543283820152, 0.017859933897852898, -0.02523808553814888, 0.019372250884771347, -0.022366100922226906, -0.027715137228369713, 0.07765210419893265, 0.026484081521630287, 0.03155137598514557, 0.03244064748287201, 0.00225007813423872, 0.05529547855257988, 0.0310287494212389, -0.056271135807037354, -0.027752526104450226, -0.03236842900514603, -0.044103384017944336, -0.010715204291045666, -0.03442162275314331, 0.03502673655748367, 0.02904525026679039, 0.04467306658625603, -0.004166112747043371, 0.015721147879958153, -0.016575995832681656, 0.01312568224966526, -0.033216897398233414, -0.07281958311796188, -0.013299131765961647, -0.003749372437596321, 0.009556269273161888, -0.010792196728289127, -0.004657818470150232, -0.06508041173219681, -0.025600820779800415, 0.017554664984345436, -0.037162862718105316, -0.018477391451597214, 0.002239324152469635, -0.007937425747513771, 0.031723394989967346, -0.018330588936805725, -0.0022446447983384132, -0.012704032473266125, -0.041048187762498856, 0.03604501858353615, -0.008160823956131935, -0.02124302089214325, -0.0006053794641047716, 0.0037148185074329376, 0.0031087929382920265, 0.04972561076283455, 0.0010767190251499414, 0.0019396375864744186, 0.03701333329081535, 0.02512708120048046, 0.011310983449220657, 0.04690374806523323, -0.026995161548256874, 0.002782451920211315, 0.04426516219973564, -0.03340170904994011, 0.0018834243528544903, 0.001267442014068365, -0.0035578429233282804, 0.022637831047177315, 0.027056079357862473, -0.04077254980802536, -0.048148930072784424, 0.03856061398983002, -0.03059731051325798, -0.03856348246335983, -0.02202332578599453, -0.0052516101859509945, 0.03679179400205612, 0.012427479028701782, -0.0015238201012834907, 0.004616009071469307, -0.031937550753355026, 0.017274143174290657, 0.03413849696516991, 0.0030864712316542864, -0.012624625116586685, 0.01429255772382021, 0.02296515181660652, -0.005974502302706242, 0.041588086634874344, -0.02161046862602234, 0.019565636292099953, 0.06783893704414368, -0.03356460481882095, 0.03456803411245346, -0.037876229733228683, 0.007036697585135698, -0.08849820494651794, 0.013607746921479702, 0.0021131790708750486, -0.016836043447256088, 0.034874968230724335, -0.06609291583299637, -0.005807486362755299, -0.004763824865221977, -0.07140371203422546, 0.0006259925430640578, -0.01715412177145481, -0.0349859818816185, -0.04505240172147751, -0.00021540754823945463, 0.001429018215276301, 0.012813283130526543, -0.0013886946253478527, 0.06671158969402313, 0.02478625625371933, 0.028055204078555107, -0.007650434505194426, -0.007604442071169615, 0.005910596344619989, 0.022349996492266655, 0.028028255328536034, -0.07069731503725052, -0.007462827488780022, -0.023860037326812744, -0.06238597258925438, 0.043453507125377655, -0.0041336724534630775, 0.019246451556682587, 0.004987038671970367, 0.01013331487774849, -0.00120695517398417, 0.047309473156929016, 0.0128930089995265, 0.017086436972022057, -0.018453169614076614, -0.009230731055140495, -0.018325068056583405, 0.06101829186081886, -0.01856737956404686, -0.000800010864622891, 0.031047452241182327, -0.027615055441856384, -0.04568365961313248, 0.019455406814813614, -0.020056314766407013, -0.03643828630447388, -0.01661050319671631, -0.0033822241239249706, 0.015729499980807304, -0.005545295774936676, 0.018713707104325294, -0.04924504831433296, -0.003430244280025363, 0.018138814717531204, 0.044372353702783585, -0.021636009216308594, 0.02682713232934475, 0.0016057267785072327, -0.020369837060570717, -0.00017951348854694515, 0.016449809074401855, 0.014172928407788277, -0.04286986589431763, -0.005077730398625135, -0.0066881487146019936, 0.003944048658013344, -0.03530644625425339, -0.03877038508653641, -0.010216579772531986, 0.02843327261507511, -0.00461883470416069, 0.009604256600141525, 0.013650637120008469, -0.013373441994190216, 0.012162258848547935, -0.07136937975883484, 0.050812698900699615, 0.0001324274780927226, -0.009711069986224174, -0.010676597245037556, -0.027985814958810806, -0.04081513360142708, -0.022161435335874557, 0.044713687151670456, 0.026414629071950912, 0.003730342024937272, 0.0013122787931934, -0.0008869357407093048, -0.00033834585337899625, -0.07041601836681366, 0.04643379896879196, -0.01856601983308792, -0.03328376263380051, -0.0250039491802454, -0.03440692275762558, 0.03793350234627724, -0.01063288003206253, 0.009458771906793118, -0.02085496112704277, 0.0024905058089643717, 0.0054167648777365685, 0.010038499720394611, 0.05775322765111923, -0.006234325468540192, -0.033355969935655594, 0.031264662742614746, -0.023364106193184853, -0.007237000856548548, 0.008584258146584034, 0.0023831408470869064, -0.0507245734333992, 0.03395915776491165, -0.032015275210142136, -0.02664989046752453, -0.021898971870541573, 0.057632122188806534, -0.008322348818182945, -0.05128798261284828, 0.022831182926893234, 0.007396353408694267, -0.044508758932352066, 0.00861865933984518, 0.04307037964463234, 0.024763507768511772, 0.021345285698771477, -0.022179778665304184, -0.0010476125171408057, 0.006819655187427998, -0.004824816714972258, -0.005458216182887554, -0.021578878164291382, 0.018633928149938583, 0.019738590344786644, -0.009026584215462208, 0.023336950689554214, -0.04575835168361664, 0.05133204907178879, -0.01050130371004343, 0.03170359507203102, 0.005969893652945757, -0.03781924396753311, -0.002848744159564376, 0.002060130937024951, 0.047600701451301575, 0.00348501349799335, 0.01847815327346325, 0.07650397717952728, -0.019145235419273376, 0.018557995557785034, -0.04644079506397247, -0.009258270263671875, -0.017999334260821342, -0.011235767044126987, 0.016932617872953415, -0.009424128569662571, -0.008069061674177647, 0.010523652657866478, 0.0011081871343776584, -0.012593778781592846, 0.023577958345413208, -0.03989802673459053, 0.03169132396578789, -0.01482568122446537, -0.008292271755635738, -0.021922096610069275, -0.009341034106910229, -0.028431110084056854, -0.01729627326130867, 0.0107911117374897, 0.018892984837293625, 0.00658554257825017, -0.025933025404810905, -0.009179950691759586, 0.005763345863670111, 0.05788471922278404, -0.10347989201545715, -0.043904971331357956, -0.054933156818151474, -0.01876840740442276, 0.0024964662734419107, -0.01422746293246746 ]
<p>Let's say I have two models. One has cumulative lift on test data 4.322578, second 2.84488. The only advantage of the second over the first consists in the quality of having the cumulative lift curve nearly identical for both train and validate sets. </p> <p>For the first model the curve of cumulative lift looks as you can see below.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/GtD7X.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Sorry for non-english elements on the plot, but that's the only SAS Enterprise Miner version I have access to.</p> <p>Mean standard error for the model from the plot - the first one - for train, validate and test sets are: 0.038389, 0.04999 and 0.055314. For the second one: 0.070393, 0.071889 and 0.07727.</p> <p>First model seems to be obviously better in terms of accuracy. But at the same time it is less stable, more sensitive to data changes. </p> <p>My question is whether those stability issues are here big enough to discredit that model in favor of the second one? How to measure instability and at which point it renders a model unusable?</p> <p>If it is important, the models in question are neural networks.</p>
36,103
[ -0.024540290236473083, -0.008446655236184597, -0.041218385100364685, -0.024029621854424477, 0.0270505640655756, -0.028962118551135063, 0.007445081602782011, -0.03577318415045738, 0.035908643156290054, -0.041983649134635925, 0.04700048640370369, 0.04313497990369797, 0.015877965837717056, 0.02063549868762493, -0.014132915064692497, 0.023830702528357506, -0.01566918194293976, 0.01374800130724907, 0.01895146630704403, 0.008511213585734367, -0.029912028461694717, 0.019188376143574715, 0.006771355867385864, -0.0048520793206989765, -0.028860747814178467, 0.05905391648411751, 0.04611067473888397, -0.0478646382689476, 0.020421374589204788, 0.026830624788999557, -0.016634078696370125, -0.02817569673061371, 0.014502540230751038, 0.051547013223171234, 0.0196328554302454, 0.0020522428676486015, 0.00725520821288228, -0.03583962097764015, -0.046152278780937195, 0.043195415288209915, -0.01726187765598297, -0.0077646165154874325, 0.009369980543851852, 0.02250053361058235, -0.0043441844172775745, 0.006115698721259832, -0.027624016627669334, 0.004754830151796341, 0.060222651809453964, -0.011794248595833778, 0.058273881673812866, -0.011209342628717422, 0.017931455746293068, 0.0807793065905571, 0.0013001480838283896, -0.024116940796375275, 0.06319424510002136, 0.050201062113046646, 0.008712667040526867, -0.045678216964006424, -0.02086859941482544, -0.0028019731398671865, -0.015916820615530014, -0.030544281005859375, -0.020756298676133156, 0.03678832948207855, -0.014395841397345066, -0.04526961222290993, 0.00894623901695013, -0.025184674188494682, 0.033284787088632584, 0.0004995297640562057, 0.029995370656251907, -0.015428545884788036, 0.02975531294941902, -0.009283611550927162, 0.004393056500703096, 0.03396863862872124, 0.03603528067469597, 0.041416995227336884, 0.03918096050620079, 0.028028445318341255, 0.013017484918236732, 0.06505582481622696, 0.02165890298783779, -0.037200748920440674, 0.09738224744796753, -0.003418432082980871, 0.04004818573594093, 0.019455954432487488, -0.013038462027907372, 0.01329113356769085, 0.04747025668621063, -0.03064265288412571, -0.014053519815206528, 0.004028386436402798, 0.008445406332612038, 0.004022200126200914, 0.015847953036427498, -0.007972747087478638, -0.01740187779068947, -0.06012335419654846, 0.02198495902121067, 0.02879342809319496, -0.00983990728855133, -0.02163734659552574, 0.00002592971213744022, -0.014050601981580257, -0.02870345674455166, -0.02251797914505005, -0.029425008222460747, -0.0026972841005772352, -0.022929830476641655, 0.030224023386836052, 0.01051868312060833, 0.010972552001476288, -0.016536124050617218, -0.01801574043929577, 0.03875383362174034, 0.05490052327513695, 0.0597175695002079, -0.022588679566979408, 0.023804564028978348, -0.05429737642407417, -0.047834090888500214, -0.032391831278800964, 0.02618848718702793, -0.02708408609032631, -0.033221714198589325, 0.05818868428468704, 0.015753550454974174, -0.014906954020261765, 0.017958300188183784, -0.008183286525309086, 0.0357530452311039, 0.034650467336177826, -0.0771024227142334, -0.051062796264886856, 0.020017243921756744, -0.01334238052368164, 0.042492687702178955, -0.04149021580815315, -0.012024950236082077, 0.0628475546836853, 0.05575091019272804, 0.002040315419435501, 0.06701046973466873, -0.009373737499117851, 0.04145572707056999, -0.013182898052036762, -0.027375584468245506, -0.04602230340242386, -0.0248956847935915, -0.004436552990227938, -0.0718601644039154, -0.08363449573516846, 0.03398115560412407, 0.032860610634088516, -0.04006670415401459, -0.03947127237915993, 0.006204685196280479, -0.000592267606407404, 0.0334896594285965, -0.036598529666662216, 0.011372526176273823, -0.026516109704971313, 0.06552077829837799, -0.0012409246992319822, 0.04614609479904175, 0.030237847939133644, -0.00415464723482728, -0.002423721132799983, 0.02131556160748005, 0.011864032596349716, 0.042426545172929764, -0.005073506385087967, -0.0015258602797985077, -0.04600069671869278, -0.0021922672167420387, 0.024176105856895447, -0.05351153388619423, -0.003439729567617178, -0.03175010159611702, -0.031738635152578354, 0.030922023579478264, 0.05680796876549721, 0.0019310269271954894, -0.00838601216673851, 0.06581757217645645, -0.042809247970581055, -0.023877715691924095, -0.06502602249383926, 0.01181523036211729, -0.02860764041543007, -0.033849846571683884, 0.030838076025247574, -0.0012190850684419274, 0.00899999774992466, 0.006751732435077429, -0.013208495453000069, -0.03155791386961937, -0.003699379740282893, 0.03787248209118843, -0.0353875532746315, 0.017698943614959717, 0.02253715693950653, -0.016745220869779587, -0.010330564342439175, 0.057983655482530594, -0.02511572651565075, -0.05464441329240799, 0.027492737397551537, -0.007830571383237839, -0.010702408850193024, 0.008241061121225357, -0.0375385582447052, 0.012293943203985691, -0.02409406565129757, -0.0019555974286049604, 0.02927689254283905, -0.07005852460861206, 0.05053574591875076, 0.04823248088359833, 0.005184394773095846, -0.0008979741251096129, 0.002897591795772314, 0.005831744521856308, 0.0030472688376903534, -0.015068803913891315, 0.020568495616316795, -0.034900300204753876, 0.011775331571698189, 0.02942267246544361, 0.07902953773736954, -0.025414150208234787, 0.007826772518455982, 0.052941739559173584, 0.023019233718514442, 0.0138467475771904, -0.006983101833611727, -0.017185641452670097, -0.02879609912633896, 0.03261319920420647, 0.04447253420948982, 0.048394907265901566, 0.015588696114718914, 0.008569017983973026, 0.010145978070795536, 0.009969408623874187, 0.018689395859837532, 0.01232767105102539, 0.03656671568751335, 0.0063888318836688995, -0.05063191428780556, -0.01779533550143242, -0.0005414020852185786, 0.039033520966768265, -0.005541213788092136, -0.0013946075923740864, 0.05704731494188309, -0.027719736099243164, -0.015925077721476555, 0.013255770318210125, -0.004958286415785551, 0.07630924135446548, 0.013836085796356201, -0.00416118698194623, -0.03143969550728798, 0.01735815219581127, -0.04142696410417557, 0.01585172489285469, -0.027185169979929924, -0.01896929368376732, -0.01837805099785328, 0.037937410175800323, 0.0612853467464447, 0.01133039128035307, 0.0028606061823666096, -0.015693875029683113, 0.012149632908403873, 0.02166183851659298, -0.009127162396907806, 0.020863940939307213, -0.0041838036850094795, -0.046591512858867645, 0.0050717489793896675, -0.0017627663910388947, -0.0005752837751060724, 0.06414613872766495, 0.01494579203426838, -0.017442233860492706, 0.01564621739089489, -0.00428023049607873, -0.04198240488767624, -0.031648579984903336, -0.028905067592859268, -0.02432795986533165, -0.0304237212985754, -0.06670482456684113, 0.037685226649045944, 0.019243741407990456, -0.018018167465925217, 0.024448787793517113, -0.028621872887015343, 0.017718877643346786, -0.01878349855542183, 0.004060543607920408, 0.009674224071204662, 0.011781074106693268, -0.0009902574820443988, 0.009516993537545204, -0.020461933687329292, -0.015669813379645348, -0.06247241050004959, -0.04796300455927849, 0.008956278674304485, -0.043770331889390945, -0.0020529821049422026, 0.011350838467478752, -0.007760542444884777, 0.09483307600021362, 0.021151356399059296, 0.015132805332541466, -0.03702375292778015, -0.012067449279129505, -0.05161190405488014, -0.018215443938970566, -0.020342392846941948, 0.01554869394749403, 0.04735717549920082, 0.0206402949988842, -0.01954437606036663, 0.025712423026561737, 0.036064594984054565, -0.004961710888892412, 0.014456546865403652, 0.059281885623931885, 0.022621041163802147, -0.032272495329380035, 0.018061159178614616, 0.024146176874637604, 0.006480953190475702, -0.030947932973504066, -0.019725646823644638, 0.031106604263186455, -0.004622541833668947, -0.02002679742872715, 0.016485493630170822, 0.00481621315702796, 0.029137887060642242, -0.0016628247685730457, 0.00004954693213221617, 0.00624924898147583, -0.02117297425866127, -0.036727115511894226, 0.037262726575136185, 0.0383637398481369, -0.02808642014861107, 0.004482743795961142, 0.06078549474477768, 0.01590043120086193, -0.016793327406048775, -0.002522242721170187, -0.023174190893769264, -0.011766267009079456, 0.012515331618487835, -0.0023061558604240417, 0.0033038093242794275, 0.05321092903614044, 0.014023669064044952, 0.04413154721260071, 0.00003562934580259025, -0.022952448576688766, -0.003208610462024808, -0.06501059234142303, 0.033279675990343094, -0.01982141099870205, 0.0654633417725563, 0.04165530577301979, 0.017818370833992958, 0.0019890479743480682, 0.00562768941745162, 0.003057688707485795, -0.023241877555847168, -0.07342085242271423, 0.005065072327852249, 0.018102696165442467, 0.007161082234233618, 0.0028085901867598295, -0.02378835715353489, 0.00832842756062746, -0.026476256549358368, -0.0079046580940485, -0.017030835151672363, 0.018128471449017525, -0.040656086057424545, 0.023543668910861015, -0.038485635071992874, 0.01097063161432743, 0.0027930615469813347, -0.007148664444684982, 0.018741723150014877, -0.01735835149884224, 0.038381315767765045, -0.00353067135438323, 0.018910471349954605, 0.002435155911371112, -0.03206140920519829, -0.0063361506909132, 0.028407009318470955, 0.014596577733755112, 0.025588855147361755, 0.023669956251978874, -0.044007059186697006, 0.03302822262048721, 0.052145037800073624, 0.03968425840139389, 0.0381634347140789, 0.0005924530560150743, -0.02168581634759903, -0.06190020963549614, -0.04168877378106117, 0.039696499705314636, 0.04568831995129585, 0.0420118048787117, -0.003332028165459633, 0.0034441445022821426, -0.00017984308942686766, -0.057023786008358, 0.011460090056061745, 0.061000000685453415, 0.006306041032075882, 0.03706526383757591, -0.015669522807002068, 0.000110266511910595, -0.014948953874409199, -0.018527938053011894, 0.06588303297758102, 0.018052594736218452, 0.017498940229415894, -0.023042811080813408, 0.040232762694358826, -0.03294885531067848, -0.012409643270075321, 0.02180621400475502, 0.05771814286708832, 0.014996678568422794, -0.007796441204845905, 0.007540555205196142, 0.008589447475969791, 0.056303951889276505, 0.04062233120203018, 0.0174728911370039, 0.024401962757110596, -0.08993609249591827, -0.007663325872272253, 0.049770843237638474, -0.0007986036944203079, -0.07892979681491852, -0.0336703285574913, -0.06120898947119713, -0.03924887627363205, 0.0011340491473674774, -0.0246404018253088, 0.07536134123802185, 0.0013333240058273077, 0.053868651390075684, -0.025986816734075546, 0.007744854781776667, -0.006365499924868345, 0.04205573350191116, 0.015155472792685032, 0.048320792615413666, 0.007181125693023205, 0.00292342621833086, 0.010692224837839603, -0.00572094414383173, 0.02574337087571621, 0.06545877456665039, 0.003969195764511824, -0.05054720863699913, 0.016238339245319366, 0.000021806619770359248, -0.005154600832611322, -0.062014807015657425, -0.028925692662596703, -0.025624031201004982, -0.028463387861847878, 0.028045108541846275, -0.00008335072197951376, -0.05131596326828003, 0.01563112996518612, 0.015215625055134296, -0.031660933047533035, -0.01509857177734375, -0.0005984238814562559, 0.06208069249987602, 0.03791345655918121, 0.014448118396103382, 0.05919879302382469, 0.035619862377643585, 0.01673661731183529, 0.01895858719944954, -0.006963758729398251, 0.0064962562173604965, -0.01501559279859066, -0.035757001489400864, -0.029905959963798523, 0.016711421310901642, -0.027361631393432617, 0.02989572286605835, 0.01788860745728016, 0.04772625118494034, -0.0044056992046535015, 0.013971875421702862, 0.04730597138404846, 0.031831447035074234, -0.010707403533160686, -0.02309117466211319, 0.005590707994997501, 0.02790670096874237, -0.028646195307374, -0.023659540340304375, 0.015391412191092968, 0.0074861119501292706, -0.02199932187795639, 0.025455456227064133, -0.05436639115214348, 0.009944699704647064, -0.023952443152666092, -0.0112466961145401, -0.011567561887204647, 0.019664768129587173, 0.04253973066806793, 0.01902114599943161, 0.061517711728811264, 0.0045100548304617405, -0.04166572540998459, 0.013640494085848331, 0.028186285868287086, 0.01650673896074295, 0.006953355856239796, -0.06329585611820221, 0.028867250308394432, -0.004259932320564985, -0.02132461406290531, -0.0775599330663681, -0.01900365762412548, 0.03223167732357979, -0.012965529225766659, -0.04865342378616333, -0.028181349858641624, 0.009961302392184734, -0.0019633222837001085, -0.03481218218803406, -0.029210472479462624, 0.07760290801525116, -0.032799288630485535, 0.00583901209756732, 0.02703021839261055, -0.0027919986750930548, 0.07265247404575348, 0.012755048461258411, 0.037203099578619, 0.007605502847582102, -0.0060961684212088585, -0.037828780710697174, 0.020454104989767075, 0.047150783240795135, -0.027861453592777252, -0.048245713114738464, -0.019230717793107033, -0.017808707430958748, 0.031663164496421814, -0.0003426940238568932, -0.013475201092660427, -0.025537749752402306, -0.019562264904379845, 0.010595561005175114, 0.006207424681633711, -0.03328933194279671, -0.03145844116806984, 0.03309226036071777, -0.03318170830607414, 0.012602678500115871, 0.02725486271083355, -0.035764653235673904, 0.028426392003893852, 0.010886437259614468, -0.004977795761078596, 0.02686125971376896, 0.07192544639110565, -0.036571674048900604, -0.005404288414865732, -0.014916953630745411, -0.0181953813880682, 0.0363931767642498, 0.010124966502189636, 0.05245101451873779, 0.005130233243107796, 0.005560440476983786, -0.035581689327955246, -0.020604858174920082, -0.01978166587650776, 0.0054668947122991085, 0.05106852203607559, -0.002572618657723069, 0.014823378063738346, -0.005274304188787937, -0.021043118089437485, -0.020680928602814674, -0.05653718486428261, -0.022539285942912102, -0.03309858962893486, -0.02689416892826557, 0.04971982166171074, -0.02422325871884823, -0.0412038117647171, 0.004753490444272757, 0.00839212816208601, 0.06406383961439133, 0.04226546362042427, -0.022907450795173645, 0.01100702490657568, 0.0071844011545181274, -0.03260914981365204, -0.04586673155426979, 0.07468697428703308, -0.05254712328314781, 0.01853386126458645, -0.004867358598858118, -0.004085525870323181, 0.02109953574836254, 0.010273624211549759, 0.0011901885736733675, -0.06291068345308304, -0.05870405212044716, -0.06844323128461838, 0.011266114190220833, -0.01931026764214039, -0.04626389965415001, 0.01945844478905201, 0.017861224710941315, 0.0007536018965765834, 0.0023082538973540068, 0.024258490651845932, -0.038997724652290344, -0.08215434849262238, -0.02984938956797123, 0.027135545387864113, -0.018258899450302124, 0.034197572618722916, -0.014485882595181465, -0.05021807178854942, 0.024177419021725655, -0.05243953317403793, 0.026211809366941452, -0.027386480942368507, 0.004927344620227814, -0.0020858801435679197, 0.05705449730157852, -0.04808174818754196, 0.01957385614514351, -0.0053526870906353, 0.015370179899036884, 0.1354215294122696, 0.06755393743515015, 0.03923572972416878, -0.03767300397157669, 0.010590370744466782, 0.009591521695256233, 0.017969686537981033, -0.026446707546710968, -0.0032895859330892563, 0.03460591286420822, -0.01703251525759697, 0.02842051535844803, 0.010424498468637466, 0.02103833295404911, -0.016486160457134247, 0.010910898447036743, -0.0037668992299586535, 0.007834541611373425, -0.004414943978190422, 0.0377897173166275, -0.014420794323086739, -0.03655492886900902, -0.005309175234287977, 0.004086786415427923, -0.00002241801848867908, -0.02336892858147621, -0.009850306436419487, -0.00695429602637887, 0.017984971404075623, 0.0007836272125132382, -0.004256899934262037, -0.006612309254705906, -0.003003442659974098, -0.004114493727684021, -0.0027624410577118397, 0.004272397141903639, -0.040993090718984604, -0.05151527002453804, 0.03367823362350464, 0.0459071509540081, 0.03414371237158775, -0.0241178460419178, -0.013829134404659271, 0.041193172335624695, -0.052267782390117645, -0.03287854045629501, -0.07256989926099777, 0.002505165059119463, 0.000329964910633862, 0.011844911612570286, 0.040000759065151215, -0.0015564380446448922, 0.011565088294446468, -0.023541562259197235, -0.06843402236700058, -0.010796625167131424, -0.005503938067704439, 0.010269016958773136, -0.023720046505331993, -0.020302308723330498, 0.02543126977980137, 0.024579688906669617, 0.02309269830584526, 0.009756321087479591, -0.05368731543421745, -0.017258480191230774, -0.018339209258556366, 0.07281605899333954, 0.022349072620272636, 0.012545601464807987, -0.0178843904286623, -0.03445177525281906, -0.03562074527144432, -0.01551631186157465, 0.02941214106976986, 0.01204311940819025, 0.003291550325229764, 0.017789654433727264, -0.022926131263375282, 0.012687916867434978, -0.03879421949386597, -0.00002031016265391372, 0.0014649243094027042, 0.023599820211529732, -0.05411788076162338, -0.034274931997060776, 0.011047878302633762, 0.004201678093522787, -0.01148474682122469, 0.02052989974617958, -0.006211951375007629, 0.051833100616931915, 0.018197905272245407, -0.06574743241071701, -0.0009803437860682607, -0.02627968229353428, -0.025409985333681107, 0.050492942333221436, -0.038907021284103394, 0.05202616751194, -0.009806784801185131, -0.020064162090420723, -0.03655606508255005, 0.0392676442861557, -0.007042194716632366, 0.018893495202064514, 0.006841798312962055, -0.013188788667321205, 0.025696663185954094, 0.016037652269005775, 0.006508185528218746, -0.029425224289298058, -0.020481957122683525, -0.06741943955421448, -0.04501132294535637, -0.013031252659857273, -0.008477240800857544, -0.04840363934636116, 0.011577587574720383, 0.012307762168347836, 0.020549839362502098, -0.015260648913681507, -0.007041457574814558, -0.049578431993722916, -0.007508826442062855, -0.01939554512500763, -0.020757140591740608, 0.021729666739702225, -0.012178339064121246, 0.012274710461497307, -0.0211025383323431, 0.03188984468579292, -0.0074840751476585865, 0.022211097180843353, -0.04674588888883591, -0.00008274404535768554, 0.0012137927114963531, 0.058191608637571335, -0.02735048532485962, -0.017279241234064102, 0.04389514401555061, -0.005198877304792404, -0.03480226546525955, 0.009864531457424164, -0.014946659095585346, 0.00037552634603343904, -0.0158904567360878, -0.008834799751639366, 0.005662580952048302, 0.043093614280223846, -0.017745641991496086, -0.01104511134326458, -0.008125209249556065, -0.029118120670318604, -0.019395658746361732, 0.037279028445482254, 0.03800986334681511, 0.00537002831697464, -0.004624024033546448, 0.025331798940896988, 0.045841846615076065, 0.00024734807084314525, -0.038526490330696106, -0.016030240803956985, -0.04630737751722336, 0.011132380925118923, -0.012833304703235626, 0.042618367820978165, 0.037028852850198746, 0.01842566952109337, -0.02200600691139698, -0.018742870539426804, -0.01096374075859785, 0.025125401094555855, -0.09715133160352707, -0.03475189581513405, 0.027483858168125153, 0.01495359092950821, -0.02308555506169796, -0.03543630987405777, 0.02751387469470501, 0.02525937743484974, -0.030310427770018578, -0.003503606654703617, -0.047479402273893356, -0.011385293677449226, -0.02840576320886612, -0.011111726984381676, -0.04792017117142677, -0.009306619875133038, -0.0033907422330230474, 0.004014499951153994, 0.011943185701966286, 0.01119498535990715, -0.01807926781475544, 0.019586095586419106, -0.05309053882956505, 0.02051064930856228, 0.032261986285448074, -0.0156534593552351, 0.013471769168972969, -0.024359429255127907, 0.0005588665371760726, 0.04467330873012543, -0.018507611006498337, 0.018219148740172386, 0.02238319255411625, 0.005326215643435717, 0.010636303573846817, 0.027893776074051857, 0.023346811532974243, -0.018199123442173004, 0.0052217901684343815, -0.018494591116905212, -0.0010816921712830663, 0.01925443485379219, 0.010033969767391682, -0.00607242900878191, 0.003647890407592058, 0.00020348354883026332, -0.004354451783001423, 0.021276986226439476, -0.012784643098711967, 0.001084593590348959, -0.04001426324248314, -0.002904224907979369, 0.03907235339283943, -0.02627759799361229, 0.026105796918272972, -0.016818193718791008, 0.0024326778948307037, 0.017380382865667343, 0.028565462678670883, -0.021214619278907776, 0.008439892902970314, 0.002630189061164856, -0.02594170905649662, -0.006263370160013437, 0.03212428092956543, -0.0019489637343212962, -0.027263103052973747, -0.01355509739369154, -0.0006470592343248427, -0.008282979018986225, -0.019119398668408394, -0.0039666383527219296, -0.04747443646192551, 0.0900786817073822, -0.020469000563025475, 0.05977148562669754, 0.026224972680211067, -0.04718463495373726, 0.022038888186216354, -0.10951066762208939, 0.055573295801877975, 0.01746390387415886, -0.01884358562529087, -0.02615993469953537, -0.0011781126959249377, -0.009786302223801613, -0.010624508373439312, 0.07388895004987717, 0.014889905229210854, -0.012143971398472786, -0.00416520657017827, 0.03404415771365166, -0.026989510282874107, -0.03556985408067703, 0.017343953251838684, -0.01573304831981659, -0.017011446878314018, -0.024002719670534134, -0.04381995275616646, -0.0022437928710132837, 0.05509065091609955, -0.005892657674849033, 0.007807958871126175, 0.006416515912860632, 0.03804440796375275, 0.0056115067563951015, -0.007066737860441208, -0.016295546665787697, -0.035989001393318176, 0.06648120284080505, -0.013306516222655773, -0.008867856115102768, -0.01382999774068594, 0.012162539176642895, -0.021997526288032532, 0.061378296464681625, -0.02360973320901394, 0.0048714131116867065, -0.0042809690348804, 0.02319534495472908, -0.03422759100794792, -0.04355244338512421, -0.0213584303855896, -0.014404604211449623, -0.033314138650894165, 0.005783491767942905, -0.014391821809113026, 0.02830447629094124, 0.04593011736869812, -0.014645344577729702, 0.017380621284246445, -0.01151442714035511, 0.04035210236907005, 0.032059188932180405, -0.010217664763331413, 0.034761425107717514, 0.038481537252664566, 0.012689835391938686, 0.011025267653167248, -0.04314632713794708, 0.026125069707632065, -0.037032414227724075, 0.019754791632294655, -0.018710698932409286, -0.04714211821556091, 0.030201071873307228, -0.007421939633786678, -0.024475688114762306, 0.011101174168288708, -0.03522429242730141, 0.042837001383304596, -0.028149081394076347, 0.005048984196037054, -0.015226704999804497, -0.013675710186362267, 0.039753276854753494, 0.017684249207377434, 0.025462064892053604, 0.0131114786490798, 0.016887767240405083, -0.019193395972251892, 0.02516506053507328, 0.004890667740255594, 0.016415121033787727, -0.0016573176253587008, -0.0005279959877952933, -0.03834082558751106, 0.03600383922457695, -0.034741442650556564, -0.04747091606259346, -0.04742646962404251, 0.012126101180911064, 0.03277231380343437, 0.04013282433152199, 0.03398852422833443, 0.007367996033281088, -0.0267415139824152, -0.0024845446459949017, 0.034631483256816864, -0.06385884433984756, -0.011232143267989159, -0.04730475693941116, 0.016227269545197487, -0.00531362509354949, -0.04093698412179947 ]
<p>I did some research and didn't find what I was looking for: I have a data set x = 10,100,1000 and y1, y2, y3 respectively, and I want to plot those points. </p> <p>But what is happening is that in the x axis the values that are appearing are 10, 200, 400, 600, 800 and 1000. How can I set the scale so that it only appears the values I specified above? What I'm doing is:</p> <pre><code>y_values &lt;- c(9, 9.6, 9.7, 9.8) x_values &lt;- c(10,100,1000) plot(x_values, y_values) </code></pre> <p>Thank you.</p>
73,673
[ -0.03132415562868118, -0.012147324159741402, -0.012647503986954689, 0.0022285382729023695, 0.032964255660772324, 0.02651081793010235, -0.04072090983390808, -0.0142920957878232, 0.02882406860589981, -0.03658740222454071, 0.053308919072151184, 0.035561610013246536, 0.05210078880190849, 0.004359796177595854, 0.04791656509041786, -0.012228167615830898, -0.022901562973856926, 0.008224822580814362, -0.01859191246330738, -0.040204375982284546, -0.012157200835645199, 0.001510637579485774, 0.037339113652706146, -0.02299640327692032, 0.010489103384315968, 0.03421306610107422, 0.05516767501831055, 0.053627945482730865, 0.016426336020231247, 0.05989881604909897, -0.03840991109609604, -0.028208928182721138, 0.046370845288038254, 0.02583126351237297, 0.016102952882647514, -0.006268576253205538, -0.005558951757848263, -0.02620583027601242, -0.008381644263863564, 0.0020379868801683187, -0.01646486669778824, 0.010248529724776745, 0.01446207519620657, 0.01690773479640484, 0.006087801419198513, 0.012348462827503681, -0.004521714057773352, 0.004808833356946707, 0.03777284175157547, -0.020512795075774193, 0.08707688003778458, -0.020933272317051888, 0.030703537166118622, 0.03092687390744686, -0.027076715603470802, -0.0020931705366820097, 0.07510340958833694, 0.04924936592578888, -0.054595448076725006, -0.05841658636927605, 0.0023927357979118824, -0.03083905018866062, 0.009993263520300388, -0.012040304020047188, -0.023810794577002525, 0.02313118800520897, -0.0293252132833004, -0.00480220653116703, 0.004340338055044413, -0.02885851450264454, -0.0010442909551784396, 0.029753826558589935, 0.018436437472701073, -0.026980608701705933, 0.011356420814990997, -0.056944340467453, 0.04180009663105011, -0.009581285528838634, 0.09013067185878754, 0.055939797312021255, 0.015126107260584831, 0.0463244654238224, 0.028134437277913094, 0.002816186985000968, 0.004206829704344273, -0.0080282436683774, 0.05258027836680412, -0.0010706244502216578, 0.03894096612930298, 0.05902375280857086, -0.004611394368112087, 0.017477942630648613, 0.0550837479531765, 0.02207428775727749, -0.01323759462684393, 0.03218373656272888, -0.002841412089765072, 0.014222904108464718, -0.024840522557497025, -0.0281857717782259, -0.0159548781812191, -0.043871305882930756, 0.040349483489990234, 0.021375393494963646, -0.04141739755868912, 0.014680693857371807, -0.041050899773836136, -0.013273509219288826, -0.014493046328425407, 0.009697827510535717, 0.02939257025718689, -0.005861349403858185, 0.032673969864845276, -0.01581004448235035, 0.0652126744389534, -0.02594311162829399, 0.010168411768972874, 0.037117600440979004, 0.031998734921216965, 0.022623395547270775, 0.019713176414370537, -0.018206795677542686, 0.04075347259640694, 0.026823479682207108, -0.030336463823914528, -0.00799962505698204, 0.004569424316287041, 0.012849045917391777, -0.01466082502156496, 0.033098846673965454, -0.038094229996204376, -0.011751030571758747, 0.0484895259141922, -0.024321874603629112, 0.030907709151506424, -0.003030309220775962, -0.07405727356672287, -0.024937130510807037, 0.026726316660642624, -0.011783472262322903, 0.026250680908560753, -0.03499775379896164, 0.021588856354355812, 0.026845742017030716, 0.014544755220413208, -0.006509981583803892, -0.024896245449781418, 0.02049580216407776, 0.005763945169746876, -0.006915109697729349, -0.03652812913060188, -0.017553802579641342, -0.017751801759004593, -0.030107159167528152, 0.00723289093002677, -0.04248877987265587, 0.022190595045685768, 0.02924581803381443, -0.021007126197218895, -0.03235085681080818, 0.01840728148818016, -0.020033832639455795, 0.029208306223154068, -0.034684013575315475, -0.007771666161715984, -0.020784925669431686, 0.07124057412147522, -0.011910730041563511, 0.022015364840626717, 0.02883978560566902, -0.01967090368270874, 0.049023959785699844, 0.0111318314447999, 0.03928159177303314, 0.036258548498153687, -0.007933386601507664, -0.016955768689513206, -0.031728774309158325, 0.03618308901786804, 0.0895812138915062, -0.01942325010895729, -0.042067088186740875, -0.001482318970374763, -0.019275441765785217, 0.03647937998175621, 0.03699455037713051, -0.02102019265294075, -0.05164758116006851, 0.017461977899074554, -0.041259679943323135, -0.009860709309577942, -0.060006726533174515, -0.004296517930924892, -0.014763749204576015, -0.018494142219424248, 0.005180582404136658, 0.008210905827581882, -0.007133941166102886, -0.011132108978927135, -0.010271294042468071, -0.001056217704899609, 0.0019273703219369054, 0.08875666558742523, -0.030008763074874878, -0.017016880214214325, 0.05701350048184395, 0.07682455331087112, -0.01773432455956936, 0.05515047162771225, -0.016759103164076805, -0.0014560081763193011, 0.018962103873491287, -0.024107113480567932, -0.0023419680073857307, -0.03793783858418465, -0.015287291258573532, -0.003945353906601667, 0.02431216835975647, -0.035272859036922455, 0.04568716511130333, -0.07402906566858292, 0.048173993825912476, 0.054394207894802094, -0.020616622641682625, 0.0058005694299936295, -0.02854909747838974, 0.022910194471478462, 0.038352854549884796, -0.03727501630783081, -0.011809978634119034, -0.06070645526051521, -0.003863249672576785, 0.03608136996626854, 0.03041309490799904, -0.05440425127744675, -0.008633133955299854, 0.054837536066770554, 0.033034004271030426, 0.023499494418501854, 0.056309301406145096, 0.004656387493014336, 0.010323919355869293, 0.008219735696911812, -0.014442365616559982, 0.0399230420589447, -0.007243267260491848, 0.0525958351790905, 0.019828038290143013, 0.059742897748947144, -0.014486139640212059, -0.007332686334848404, 0.014180049300193787, -0.012860681861639023, 0.028179705142974854, 0.015803763642907143, -0.01413877122104168, 0.04557306692004204, -0.012776050716638565, -0.00023700804740656167, 0.00471159815788269, 0.015044190920889378, -0.016295410692691803, 0.01029568538069725, 0.025694619864225388, -0.015996092930436134, 0.067815862596035, -0.0563226081430912, -0.018967749550938606, 0.004228458274155855, -0.03062381036579609, 0.010504252277314663, -0.04866989701986313, -0.028152527287602425, -0.08648233115673065, 0.0365137979388237, 0.04899406433105469, 0.032403357326984406, 0.011347511783242226, -0.06675393879413605, -0.05885334685444832, -0.007314348127692938, -0.03440941125154495, 0.0032021517399698496, -0.01737220026552677, -0.02465645968914032, -0.0011589047499001026, -0.008441816084086895, -0.015069105662405491, 0.03303193673491478, -0.006824681535363197, -0.03440700098872185, -0.001354806823655963, -0.021186934784054756, -0.0435246042907238, -0.006323318928480148, -0.03652361407876015, 0.03136979788541794, -0.004422891419380903, 0.0026214527897536755, 0.06329384446144104, -0.0033757928758859634, -0.017439881339669228, 0.02369396947324276, -0.032557953149080276, 0.011192452162504196, -0.025197258219122887, 0.014605280011892319, 0.016003428027033806, -0.013323078863322735, -0.0036106521729379892, 0.031007083132863045, -0.04781085625290871, -0.030101794749498367, -0.03684106841683388, -0.04865093156695366, 0.0007793984841555357, 0.006756368558853865, 0.02501858025789261, -0.009459003806114197, -0.00785804819315672, 0.05235131457448006, 0.046725980937480927, -0.021163210272789, -0.06179628521203995, -0.010172924026846886, -0.0038426253013312817, -0.028098542243242264, 0.012982264161109924, 0.013902334496378899, 0.03486460819840431, 0.008885487914085388, 0.0026573401410132647, 0.02330045960843563, 0.058132924139499664, -0.004222095012664795, -0.00037915410939604044, -0.024790626019239426, -0.018419869244098663, -0.013479141518473625, 0.025815896689891815, 0.03858776018023491, -0.006769776809960604, 0.025606071576476097, 0.01698976941406727, 0.04759432002902031, -0.014127897098660469, -0.028113288804888725, -0.0039869630709290504, -0.010135691612958908, 0.05151521414518356, -0.02310963161289692, 0.011956611648201942, 0.02644347958266735, -0.0009492073440924287, 0.014664610847830772, 0.021224670112133026, 0.06486476957798004, -0.039691295474767685, -0.02461964264512062, 0.04356742277741432, 0.015497022308409214, -0.0383165180683136, 0.01984480209648609, 0.01711256429553032, -0.0068642194382846355, 0.024891111999750137, -0.03720413148403168, -0.021165169775485992, 0.022526053711771965, 0.0036877000238746405, 0.014436572790145874, 0.053395017981529236, -0.020285947248339653, 0.04440096765756607, -0.05261639133095741, -0.006243485026061535, -0.01976226083934307, 0.055660177022218704, 0.03645974025130272, 0.03103543072938919, 0.05356615036725998, -0.0023884123656898737, -0.014301235787570477, 0.0044826180674135685, -0.044277630746364594, 0.0666438490152359, -0.008154064416885376, 0.017750876024365425, -0.012735200114548206, -0.0067338948138058186, -0.004826605319976807, -0.030170464888215065, 0.030507253482937813, 0.012386410497128963, 0.0021068756468594074, -0.019642261788249016, -0.02701287902891636, -0.004865632392466068, -0.0026939627714455128, -0.04871514067053795, 0.04846170172095299, 0.020966200157999992, -0.014559509232640266, 0.07244327664375305, 0.0348588190972805, -0.026999685913324356, -0.018744997680187225, -0.03232422098517418, 0.02172727696597576, 0.012275549583137035, 0.030970918014645576, 0.011871304363012314, 0.002787934150546789, -0.0045592994429171085, 0.01772969961166382, 0.005754161160439253, 0.05029050260782242, 0.04727187007665634, -0.015998519957065582, -0.024941712617874146, -0.03515854850411415, -0.00457198079675436, 0.015318906866014004, 0.012640353292226791, -0.026883350685238838, -0.025343645364046097, 0.061873115599155426, 0.010988021269440651, -0.05213746801018715, 0.046355463564395905, 0.07238839566707611, 0.0419018380343914, -0.022184647619724274, -0.04282365366816521, 0.009569492191076279, -0.017975805327296257, 0.02402041107416153, -0.010241877287626266, 0.026813054457306862, -0.0021999471355229616, -0.007297460921108723, 0.023644136264920235, -0.03037641942501068, -0.034006018191576004, -0.02335590496659279, 0.03543727099895477, 0.04814566671848297, -0.022557351738214493, -0.030991656705737114, 0.03322368860244751, 0.018257271498441696, 0.000011364972124283668, -0.02086942084133625, -0.018951628357172012, -0.10292897373437881, -0.022091388702392578, 0.031710390001535416, 0.025799041613936424, -0.02742449939250946, -0.06068197265267372, -0.020690126344561577, 0.0065251621417701244, 0.022702932357788086, -0.07465522736310959, 0.033273082226514816, -0.05448942258954048, 0.004669932648539543, -0.03057100623846054, -0.014761356636881828, -0.08262086659669876, 0.0058907377533614635, -0.07246169447898865, 0.017992399632930756, -0.04507801681756973, -0.017381127923727036, -0.04819919541478157, 0.02070763148367405, -0.005040373653173447, 0.05235360935330391, 0.0020268154330551624, -0.024072427302598953, 0.016150597482919693, -0.005545911379158497, -0.028256036341190338, -0.045201029628515244, 0.022620076313614845, 0.015219466760754585, 0.020108263939619064, 0.05105094611644745, 0.01883518323302269, -0.0067060948349535465, 0.023587465286254883, 0.02234085090458393, 0.029184482991695404, 0.0008746896055527031, 0.007644665893167257, 0.034586675465106964, 0.045395851135253906, -0.0036045375745743513, 0.005307788494974375, 0.012017287313938141, -0.005844168830662966, -0.015141663141548634, -0.045089609920978546, 0.03689839690923691, -0.014519143849611282, -0.01009241584688425, -0.07945449650287628, 0.022328069433569908, -0.0012067396892234683, 0.024234255775809288, -0.01484985463321209, -0.003984132315963507, -0.03817353770136833, -0.012817088514566422, 0.02229022979736328, 0.021751394495368004, 0.02958504855632782, -0.01495148055255413, 0.011039459146559238, 0.02928628958761692, -0.0005785173270851374, 0.013278079219162464, 0.025120234116911888, 0.010695426724851131, -0.028025198727846146, 0.013707073405385017, -0.021786687895655632, 0.030959120020270348, -0.03481858968734741, 0.02090478502213955, -0.010371064767241478, -0.05537880212068558, 0.0006717123324051499, 0.005693658255040646, 0.018307605758309364, 0.03054875135421753, -0.02688121795654297, -0.002749053528532386, 0.006341028027236462, 0.01527294609695673, 0.016026239842176437, -0.06405432522296906, 0.049391552805900574, 0.0006896762060932815, 0.020353417843580246, -0.052445441484451294, -0.06750072538852692, 0.03148168697953224, 0.01647220179438591, 0.024080762639641762, -0.021184474229812622, -0.006692524533718824, -0.013494569808244705, 0.025300895795226097, -0.013559291139245033, 0.00022890673426445574, -0.017448870465159416, 0.005781892221421003, -0.007800919935107231, 0.01687210611999035, 0.07509362697601318, -0.012152728624641895, -0.008661240339279175, 0.0246598944067955, 0.02630249783396721, -0.01585720293223858, -0.009965689852833748, 0.04054512083530426, -0.03296559303998947, -0.022242045029997826, -0.0194734875112772, -0.03075833059847355, 0.031662214547395706, -0.000678681768476963, 0.003953609149903059, -0.024664076045155525, 0.026078300550580025, 0.025384103879332542, -0.02503754012286663, -0.010999202728271484, -0.02271701954305172, -0.006808239966630936, -0.03222234174609184, -0.020999889820814133, -0.03245636075735092, -0.013385707512497902, 0.012274160981178284, 0.014412902295589447, -0.0028528543189167976, 0.022681275382637978, 0.0867379680275917, 0.028162837028503418, -0.006789173930883408, -0.04651832953095436, -0.0036781770177185535, 0.03847040235996246, 0.014235972426831722, -0.01941968873143196, 0.0012882285518571734, 0.01583571545779705, -0.028650382533669472, 0.01642797514796257, -0.02032647840678692, -0.002902618143707514, 0.0347277894616127, 0.002284233458340168, 0.048680633306503296, 0.04280327633023262, 0.023057563230395317, 0.0002766434336081147, -0.06269727647304535, -0.012849588878452778, -0.03762165457010269, 0.025715243071317673, 0.06428642570972443, -0.01033507939428091, -0.01988135278224945, 0.025074465200304985, 0.0065080588683485985, 0.0397142693400383, 0.034613512456417084, -0.0019690284971147776, -0.0225808247923851, -0.013955625705420971, -0.004078743048012257, -0.026128195226192474, 0.003496416611596942, -0.008836491964757442, 0.006304898764938116, -0.005758087616413832, -0.06040176749229431, 0.011413428001105785, 0.006567702628672123, -0.02279888279736042, 0.004384543281048536, -0.03238113224506378, -0.05342249572277069, -0.02797008864581585, 0.03254154697060585, -0.011985444463789463, 0.025646556168794632, 0.019649311900138855, 0.05030066519975662, -0.010922861285507679, 0.024384839460253716, -0.02195512130856514, -0.04655231535434723, -0.028885185718536377, -0.032489508390426636, -0.015465385280549526, 0.01509469747543335, 0.0013202396221458912, -0.009565644897520542, 0.0050087664276361465, -0.06389344483613968, 0.031676746904850006, 0.0010564650874584913, 0.0349428728222847, -0.0035938885994255543, 0.03986506909132004, 0.005654510110616684, -0.004280343186110258, 0.002358171856030822, -0.01133765745908022, 0.09755218029022217, 0.0890301764011383, -0.00045311226858757436, -0.06945186108350754, 0.034082334488630295, 0.014585931785404682, -0.0063415346667170525, -0.005011019762605429, 0.0020920387469232082, 0.035414427518844604, 0.01596757397055626, 0.011152842082083225, 0.05863112211227417, 0.02256617322564125, 0.03758610039949417, 0.055467285215854645, -0.012171950191259384, -0.022617723792791367, 0.012329166755080223, 0.022079043090343475, -0.0022174660116434097, -0.03567270189523697, -0.08634762465953827, 0.027756717056035995, -0.005480847787111998, -0.02707558497786522, -0.037300605326890945, -0.041600145399570465, -0.001091275247745216, 0.04964157193899155, -0.012762024998664856, 0.01783605106174946, 0.025391262024641037, 0.014236259274184704, -0.03456687554717064, -0.022064832970499992, -0.0016524620587006211, -0.024028878659009933, 0.040367864072322845, 0.027938049286603928, -0.020218564197421074, 0.006893036887049675, -0.053438495844602585, 0.0115975895896554, -0.02476821094751358, -0.0636984333395958, -0.03537227585911751, 0.017862888053059578, 0.009480210021138191, -0.025257360190153122, 0.0018390752375125885, 0.042695220559835434, -0.018503708764910698, -0.08329548686742783, -0.007208855357021093, 0.025997605174779892, -0.004047064110636711, 0.019093843176960945, -0.022349879145622253, -0.01089492253959179, 0.012891901656985283, -0.0365002378821373, 0.019639870151877403, 0.034704599529504776, 0.0004997965297661722, 0.014712226577103138, -0.039879702031612396, 0.05618922412395477, 0.006057528778910637, 0.015313347801566124, 0.04742008075118065, -0.022871356457471848, -0.01918124221265316, -0.02317965216934681, 0.020016085356473923, 0.013884393498301506, -0.012031090445816517, 0.025554325431585312, -0.01232939213514328, -0.022459065541625023, 0.0299239419400692, 0.031017638742923737, -0.02527855709195137, -0.0037505091167986393, -0.009547303430736065, 0.006690292153507471, 0.025988878682255745, 0.04430348053574562, 0.03393107280135155, -0.018729545176029205, -0.03741038590669632, 0.028737664222717285, 0.02433278225362301, -0.01708092726767063, -0.02205559052526951, 0.06364067643880844, -0.022395478561520576, -0.010761805810034275, 0.006100939586758614, 0.09516642987728119, 0.014070502482354641, 0.004972745664417744, 0.00012435995449777693, 0.018980851396918297, -0.018427975475788116, -0.012541871517896652, 0.029494762420654297, -0.05310450866818428, 0.026422258466482162, -0.013100902549922466, -0.025941461324691772, -0.02439132146537304, -0.026622287929058075, -0.039926204830408096, -0.014465958811342716, -0.00857519544661045, 0.006496100220829248, 0.005574700888246298, 0.023100171238183975, -0.023447511717677116, -0.005953548941761255, -0.04511742666363716, -0.02475360594689846, -0.03754311800003052, -0.0034158292692154646, -0.02421686053276062, -0.02609247714281082, -0.03621932864189148, 0.0037540988996624947, -0.05163811519742012, 0.015895187854766846, -0.00018648675177246332, -0.012952657416462898, 0.007617643103003502, -0.012128157541155815, 0.026157652959227562, 0.026735929772257805, 0.04757101461291313, -0.041941579431295395, -0.01840434968471527, 0.031816624104976654, -0.07065163552761078, -0.016876865178346634, 0.028702644631266594, -0.0319744236767292, 0.0451701283454895, 0.027303585782647133, -0.00875147059559822, -0.013952233828604221, 0.04155556857585907, 0.014380821958184242, -0.01662772335112095, -0.012095997110009193, 0.01733635738492012, 0.018955091014504433, 0.04766608774662018, -0.019166085869073868, -0.03726609796285629, 0.010993832722306252, 0.024563521146774292, 0.048391781747341156, 0.014611048623919487, -0.015129909850656986, -0.01661437191069126, 0.013896687887609005, 0.021152883768081665, 0.0464584119617939, -0.016845649108290672, 0.03522958233952522, 0.03244556486606598, -0.043057143688201904, 0.03406278043985367, -0.033538173884153366, 0.009650896303355694, -0.06576715409755707, -0.016240743920207024, -0.04092388600111008, -0.02481686696410179, 0.013775840401649475, -0.03704947605729103, -0.019276157021522522, 0.0049794395454227924, -0.060876332223415375, 0.00981232337653637, -0.012050416320562363, 0.0008955849334597588, 0.010577640496194363, 0.03901263698935509, -0.016333719715476036, 0.026181837543845177, 0.05746510252356529, 0.02601005882024765, 0.029637599363923073, -0.014329120516777039, 0.00163822784088552, -0.028185397386550903, 0.00777909392490983, 0.011037370190024376, -0.012813137844204903, -0.08568648248910904, -0.006671402137726545, -0.022273514419794083, -0.002415579045191407, 0.015719370916485786, -0.014996812678873539, 0.013895311392843723, 0.0240397360175848, 0.016598431393504143, 0.021758509799838066, 0.06586991995573044, 0.0029803223442286253, -0.008336055092513561, -0.021861497312784195, 0.014577183872461319, 0.0041807349771261215, 0.013444638811051846, 0.01045428216457367, -0.01593032479286194, 0.04467960074543953, -0.027492258697748184, -0.009640919044613838, -0.008920866064727306, -0.04702085629105568, -0.020411137491464615, -0.02188217081129551, 0.0281123798340559, 0.009798360988497734, -0.06132475659251213, 0.007988139986991882, -0.020897826179862022, -0.04443536326289177, 0.04992659389972687, 0.0013360159937292337, 0.03093469887971878, 0.00038850921555422246, 0.010699090547859669, -0.03862956911325455, -0.019200418144464493, 0.013432659208774567, -0.0038769731763750315, -0.06527426093816757, 0.0031207557767629623, 0.012310211546719074, -0.018949411809444427, -0.012325748801231384, 0.0033134890254586935, -0.021039027720689774, 0.05023155361413956, -0.030789021402597427, -0.007951878011226654, 0.009013733826577663, -0.006737699266523123, 0.008995890617370605, -0.10294636338949203, 0.05938731133937836, 0.035826146602630615, -0.009842525236308575, -0.06295643746852875, -0.010572127066552639, -0.05893835052847862, 0.0505681149661541, 0.02739502303302288, 0.03471136838197708, 0.008408961817622185, -0.028003109619021416, 0.034980013966560364, 0.03048432618379593, -0.05591186508536339, 0.03158144652843475, 0.01868910901248455, -0.018953640013933182, -0.019058791920542717, -0.009257211349904537, 0.009110033512115479, 0.011211861856281757, 0.01001541968435049, -0.006294870749115944, 0.00578695721924305, -0.011196688748896122, -0.04131712764501572, 0.006776026915758848, 0.005573205184191465, -0.008999609388411045, 0.02745598368346691, 0.017383702099323273, 0.003829068038612604, 0.07535285502672195, 0.007325662765651941, -0.035926882177591324, 0.018015410751104355, -0.04347305744886398, -0.02603442594408989, 0.015062104910612106, -0.013635637238621712, 0.005825115367770195, -0.04602551832795143, 0.02732888050377369, -0.015787718817591667, -0.012712296098470688, -0.04399358108639717, 0.045400284230709076, 0.013332021422684193, 0.048549868166446686, 0.020154941827058792, 0.013082913123071194, -0.01094049122184515, -0.014624024741351604, 0.047918614000082016, 0.010751037858426571, 0.006423408631235361, 0.023958314210176468, 0.007239424157887697, 0.027037858963012695, -0.010580250062048435, 0.009534881450235844, -0.023107072338461876, 0.09962663799524307, 0.022370725870132446, -0.03811074420809746, -0.008429869078099728, -0.037546541541814804, 0.018436597660183907, -0.013651792891323566, -0.011708696372807026, -0.004061738029122353, -0.06539426743984222, -0.009471083991229534, -0.04251900315284729, -0.07691732794046402, -0.018481338396668434, 0.013623167760670185, -0.017310839146375656, 0.03946685045957565, -0.04053850471973419, -0.007250538095831871, 0.02385449782013893, 0.0009867773624137044, 0.019017836079001427, 0.0014296015724539757, 0.013572250492870808, -0.05997909978032112, 0.016546372324228287, 0.012964215129613876, 0.0051058204844594, -0.016346126794815063, -0.005955479107797146, 0.006682210601866245, -0.032816216349601746, 0.022825952619314194, -0.04580696299672127, -0.025258846580982208, -0.028898123651742935, 0.0038089004810899496, -0.07015637308359146, -0.04421012103557587, -0.017687566578388214, 0.02111266553401947, 0.003023476107046008, -0.03729092702269554 ]
<p>Please help me proving this:</p> <p>Suppose that $Y_1,\ldots,Y_n$ are i.i.d. nonnegative RV's with CDF $F$ and $E(Y_i)=\mu&lt;\infty$. Let $y_1,\ldots,y_n$ be a realization from which an EDF $\hat{F}$ is defined: $$ \hat{F}(y)=\frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^nI(y_i\leq y). $$ <strong>Want to show</strong>: $$ \text{plim}_{n\to\infty}\left(n^{1/2}\int_0^\infty y(\hat{F}(y)-F(y))d(\hat{F}-F)(y)\right)=0. $$ Please state any further necessary assumptions.</p> <hr> <p>EDIT responding to GUNG'S comment:</p> <p>This result is a small step in a bigger argument in Russell Davidson 2009's paper on the Gini index. The author must have considered it obvious because he mentions it without proof. </p> <p>I have some understanding of asymptotic theory such as some laws of large numbers, some variants of the CLT, various modes of convergence, Slutsky Theorem, measure theory in general and probability theory in particular, and some stochastic calculus.</p> <p>My problem is I've been learning asymptotic theory on my own and I haven't done a lot of exercises in this. So while I want to understand the author's reasoning, I don't know where to start with this one.</p>
73,674
[ -0.01367102563381195, -0.020917590707540512, 0.06928882747888565, -0.014878764748573303, 0.02412422187626362, 0.008569234050810337, 0.007044302765280008, -0.03455684334039688, -0.021078800782561302, -0.040989410132169724, 0.02401158958673477, 0.03695378825068474, 0.08512838184833527, 0.05220308154821396, 0.031846556812524796, 0.02470647171139717, -0.05042675882577896, 0.005454895086586475, -0.03378729522228241, -0.04500625282526016, -0.012432809919118881, 0.04487234354019165, -0.0037711940240114927, -0.024679584428668022, -0.07143636047840118, -0.013189003802835941, 0.002836131025105715, 0.021308787167072296, -0.016220318153500557, 0.10200179368257523, -0.033938415348529816, -0.02177884615957737, -0.01912836730480194, 0.02364739589393139, 0.011125698685646057, 0.028659896925091743, -0.03401557356119156, -0.022107422351837158, 0.022242752835154533, 0.016202624887228012, -0.002511688508093357, -0.022349394857883453, 0.02366255596280098, 0.05338562652468681, -0.0073366109281778336, 0.04183783009648323, 0.01874578185379505, 0.002490707440301776, 0.051115550100803375, -0.08972789347171783, 0.09253417700529099, 0.007632271386682987, 0.04227255657315254, 0.03817985951900482, 0.004251524806022644, -0.015192757360637188, 0.005393684841692448, 0.08198943734169006, -0.017462419345974922, 0.005965808406472206, -0.016478851437568665, -0.047413431107997894, 0.009951513260602951, -0.033474598079919815, -0.025918541476130486, 0.0066082654520869255, 0.012770208530128002, -0.05363355576992035, -0.024694498628377914, -0.023691892623901367, -0.007118939887732267, 0.01463258732110262, 0.015299651771783829, 0.0010265604360029101, 0.02005350962281227, 0.005213125143200159, 0.017248883843421936, -0.02106403559446335, 0.036644041538238525, 0.023879149928689003, 0.007205794099718332, 0.04165497049689293, 0.02238740772008896, 0.04564276710152626, 0.022010182961821556, 0.003846854669973254, 0.06798353046178818, 0.006545874755829573, 0.07808850705623627, 0.034757256507873535, -0.026162074878811836, -0.03580976650118828, 0.04622703045606613, -0.04214397072792053, -0.04213583841919899, 0.027826696634292603, -0.03265409916639328, 0.03886471316218376, 0.004338840954005718, -0.004065515473484993, -0.009993833489716053, -0.06604941934347153, 0.0021067296620458364, 0.03693964704871178, 0.007348222192376852, -0.039721570909023285, -0.008991487324237823, 0.05048205703496933, -0.016181450337171555, -0.018323326483368874, -0.03995385020971298, 0.02536892518401146, -0.02359199896454811, -0.035813502967357635, 0.021209072321653366, 0.04828275367617607, 0.0014133239164948463, 0.0065395827405154705, 0.017424458637833595, 0.08346670866012573, 0.04800643399357796, -0.004209278151392937, 0.007508733309805393, -0.051037974655628204, -0.05423108860850334, 0.050442326813936234, 0.012877540662884712, -0.019498025998473167, -0.06206469237804413, 0.022302499040961266, 0.012554190121591091, -0.03500639274716377, 0.02948218211531639, 0.04066099599003792, 0.026522623375058174, -0.0019494418520480394, -0.05212243273854256, -0.06472399085760117, 0.07719996571540833, -0.012560299597680569, 0.0030659569893032312, -0.08686485886573792, 0.02456096187233925, 0.04504299908876419, 0.05554603412747383, -0.016655195504426956, 0.02588122896850109, -0.00876962672919035, 0.02416997402906418, 0.012878780253231525, -0.04117043316364288, -0.05825061351060867, -0.01101455558091402, -0.05605582520365715, -0.013307148590683937, -0.0660330206155777, 0.05720842257142067, 0.03493370860815048, -0.033059898763895035, -0.03865579143166542, 0.08075312525033951, 0.00917432364076376, -0.01892479881644249, -0.02574489451944828, 0.02739797718822956, -0.02782415971159935, 0.08652499318122864, 0.0013393405824899673, 0.01768716610968113, 0.02027575857937336, -0.0006388137699104846, 0.05471266061067581, -0.0049743372946977615, 0.0830966979265213, 0.023375332355499268, -0.068358413875103, -0.028122199699282646, -0.048027779906988144, 0.0010234522633254528, -0.0075640128925442696, -0.012465779669582844, -0.03509695082902908, -0.04885861277580261, -0.013149060308933258, 0.026379555463790894, 0.03588273376226425, -0.02169719710946083, -0.0029421807266771793, 0.043896738439798355, -0.05993974953889847, -0.041402366012334824, -0.06723843514919281, -0.012852293439209461, 0.013711267150938511, -0.04468044266104698, 0.03903910517692566, -0.039024468511343, 0.015713952481746674, 0.0033738133497536182, 0.002048540860414505, -0.0368766151368618, -0.012745668180286884, 0.03849092125892639, 0.005659501068294048, 0.011261604726314545, 0.029659485444426537, 0.049591466784477234, 0.006119321100413799, 0.03609107807278633, -0.07139845192432404, -0.02228371985256672, 0.02370378188788891, -0.005650689825415611, 0.017879890277981758, 0.012491220608353615, 0.006538049783557653, 0.0480070561170578, -0.03418467938899994, 0.023202121257781982, 0.044740352779626846, -0.0467253215610981, 0.029144538566470146, 0.06064792722463608, 0.003380443435162306, 0.008775255642831326, 0.03386441990733147, 0.0482439249753952, -0.030821261927485466, -0.004633874632418156, 0.0021253267768770456, -0.031928639858961105, -0.016430377960205078, 0.02346111088991165, 0.05268377438187599, -0.001894465065561235, -0.015064594335854053, 0.08043654263019562, 0.04395603761076927, 0.005782995373010635, 0.04847545176744461, 0.002600551350042224, -0.0056197140365839005, 0.010740814730525017, 0.0020963409915566444, -0.0036965308245271444, -0.006313882302492857, 0.0041589015163481236, -0.00925484113395214, 0.028303237631917, 0.04578493908047676, -0.012040995992720127, 0.016889696940779686, 0.023473158478736877, -0.006074344273656607, -0.010300364345312119, 0.022307364270091057, 0.026294613257050514, -0.030976897105574608, -0.0010417139856144786, 0.011944864876568317, -0.003988643176853657, 0.002496948931366205, -0.022327018901705742, -0.01049474161118269, 0.04747505858540535, -0.014108785428106785, -0.06498954445123672, -0.04374237731099129, 0.027739129960536957, -0.02337004616856575, 0.01100941002368927, 0.005955444648861885, -0.040872376412153244, -0.024431917816400528, 0.006286717485636473, 0.015738118439912796, 0.01381076592952013, -0.0008956377278082073, -0.051869917660951614, 0.011274181306362152, -0.022935017943382263, -0.00870624091476202, 0.034738220274448395, -0.01722654514014721, -0.03729252144694328, -0.022699924185872078, -0.029749630019068718, -0.014829392544925213, 0.036121658980846405, -0.006496450863778591, 0.00804960634559393, 0.0024087983183562756, -0.01425021979957819, -0.03424183651804924, -0.019309889525175095, -0.02488664723932743, 0.011587657034397125, -0.03214089944958687, -0.03204509615898132, 0.059070784598588943, 0.004064470995217562, -0.04867749288678169, 0.013288217596709728, -0.018690282478928566, -0.011114452965557575, -0.03074231930077076, -0.002856993582099676, 0.03970927372574806, -0.012075715698301792, 0.030270524322986603, -0.007399345748126507, 0.007066692691296339, -0.020094912499189377, -0.05606451258063316, -0.035815730690956116, 0.02255481667816639, 0.019283942878246307, 0.012220670469105244, 0.013930258341133595, -0.04705991595983505, 0.030590595677495003, 0.025005266070365906, -0.027070503681898117, -0.02233019657433033, 0.02455119788646698, -0.011416998691856861, -0.032686591148376465, 0.0084612388163805, 0.02089790254831314, -0.017867928370833397, 0.0459640696644783, 0.03171999752521515, -0.008347450755536556, 0.04842793196439743, 0.0035382795613259077, 0.01919761300086975, -0.014799520373344421, -0.029002580791711807, 0.025889355689287186, 0.024899547919631004, 0.04932123050093651, -0.0007253672811202705, 0.015501451678574085, -0.010740910656750202, 0.013204728253185749, 0.013737563975155354, -0.031015390530228615, 0.04711928963661194, -0.01649499498307705, -0.00971208419650793, -0.04445994272828102, 0.03802870959043503, 0.012432942166924477, -0.0228072851896286, -0.008013921789824963, -0.010423120111227036, 0.02972434274852276, -0.016049066558480263, 0.025644194334745407, 0.016750389710068703, -0.0012564355274662375, 0.00648322980850935, -0.008542434312403202, -0.030562948435544968, -0.037021271884441376, 0.008371002040803432, -0.028821833431720734, -0.0005381250521168113, 0.04251696914434433, 0.02533694915473461, 0.008474222384393215, -0.03970755636692047, -0.004467460792511702, -0.007745356298983097, -0.0464620403945446, 0.008504691533744335, -0.02369195595383644, 0.057614393532276154, 0.01958027482032776, 0.041718095541000366, -0.0010223444551229477, -0.010529380291700363, 0.0035097855143249035, 0.004777175839990377, -0.0739436075091362, -0.003014368936419487, -0.004240145441144705, 0.02255607582628727, -0.014881922863423824, 0.011441655457019806, 0.06332449615001678, 0.008573625236749649, 0.003389765741303563, -0.027201447635889053, 0.00964471697807312, -0.03512750193476677, -0.014127735048532486, -0.021117834374308586, -0.06268138438463211, -0.010485437698662281, 0.02206418849527836, 0.01600096933543682, -0.05605761706829071, 0.00252014328725636, 0.03792668879032135, -0.04820729047060013, 0.015987878665328026, -0.03167199343442917, 0.05361858755350113, 0.019843271002173424, 0.01871984265744686, -0.0019347884226590395, 0.006699118297547102, 0.0015729404985904694, 0.021226199343800545, 0.023220602422952652, 0.032020047307014465, 0.05624726414680481, -0.029824040830135345, -0.013827699236571789, -0.022853732109069824, -0.01837514340877533, 0.009697675704956055, 0.038721129298210144, 0.040579553693532944, 0.0019342603627592325, 0.06832677125930786, 0.020639605820178986, -0.02529693953692913, 0.029591029509902, 0.05329779163002968, -0.0055473800748586655, 0.027485709637403488, -0.026727251708507538, -0.005044484045356512, -0.0006656690966337919, 0.022031502798199654, 0.01364720705896616, -0.0161906685680151, -0.011340252123773098, -0.0336306206882, 0.05775143951177597, -0.006212789565324783, -0.0012920842273160815, -0.025649432092905045, 0.004147742874920368, 0.05416111275553703, -0.00874374806880951, -0.010956570506095886, 0.03303993493318558, 0.024412907660007477, 0.027327537536621094, 0.03922002390027046, -0.03178613632917404, -0.03738328441977501, 0.008449711836874485, 0.05529986321926117, 0.032158952206373215, -0.026836158707737923, 0.05010132119059563, -0.04961032792925835, -0.0253645870834589, 0.04372487962245941, -0.022626107558608055, 0.008022328838706017, -0.009199660271406174, -0.02816775254905224, -0.011458477936685085, -0.05719853192567825, -0.03075302392244339, -0.006150395143777132, 0.006750565487891436, 0.05110633000731468, -0.022956524044275284, -0.053260400891304016, -0.05299357324838638, -0.028385421261191368, 0.007893450558185577, 0.0617641881108284, -0.02127072587609291, -0.007946029305458069, 0.011232112534344196, 0.02918461710214615, 0.011792470701038837, -0.07671283185482025, 0.04029887542128563, 0.002644532360136509, 0.004172100685536861, 0.018943145871162415, -0.03640421852469444, -0.07262657582759857, -0.0016368943033739924, -0.015145606361329556, -0.015589103102684021, 0.041145410388708115, -0.038621723651885986, 0.05433298274874687, 0.01751052588224411, 0.012435841374099255, 0.01501861959695816, 0.004262873902916908, 0.04054632410407066, 0.024641916155815125, -0.01941327005624771, -0.0020497171208262444, -0.03166113793849945, 0.0013652500929310918, -0.01626238040626049, -0.020046185702085495, -0.03259472921490669, 0.028655756264925003, 0.040740083903074265, 0.044917117804288864, -0.021918823942542076, -0.02093845047056675, 0.015246887691318989, 0.01631864532828331, 0.007364625111222267, -0.020877545699477196, -0.006287864875048399, 0.021032173186540604, 0.058535557240247726, -0.035915080457925797, 0.05406983569264412, -0.001056396635249257, -0.0003683159302454442, 0.02334544062614441, 0.024758942425251007, 0.015266292728483677, -0.038332097232341766, -0.005691600032150745, -0.034599434584379196, 0.004276081454008818, 0.04032781347632408, -0.027731899172067642, 0.007778333965688944, -0.0061377109959721565, 0.015800824388861656, -0.038682129234075546, 0.01296325121074915, -0.009659942239522934, 0.013324843719601631, -0.03434992581605911, -0.0024250594433397055, 0.012441664934158325, -0.029005834832787514, -0.09014564007520676, -0.005826296750456095, 0.0038779177702963352, 0.012835239060223103, -0.0012460880680009723, -0.044499073177576065, -0.00003887458296958357, -0.04040041193366051, -0.0131723303347826, 0.023202644661068916, 0.035698436200618744, -0.0031074457801878452, -0.007477360777556896, -0.007284868974238634, 0.02197105623781681, 0.06756133586168289, -0.013742626644670963, -0.034868814051151276, 0.024151459336280823, -0.010494560934603214, -0.009639494121074677, -0.01084136962890625, 0.025543879717588425, -0.009191562421619892, 0.01298641599714756, -0.008098316378891468, -0.031711265444755554, 0.013770206831395626, -0.04543215036392212, -0.006640366278588772, 0.01867487281560898, -0.017127564176917076, 0.013721131719648838, -0.016816267743706703, -0.023420043289661407, -0.0345667228102684, 0.006405117455869913, -0.005518957041203976, -0.0199136920273304, 0.020235152915120125, -0.0328245535492897, 0.015568392351269722, -0.02147618681192398, 0.020043134689331055, 0.010342037305235863, 0.07050121575593948, -0.009619275107979774, -0.011217592284083366, -0.006687183864414692, -0.0042546596378088, 0.016003308817744255, 0.0013505450915545225, -0.006418928038328886, -0.027693605050444603, -0.016840895637869835, -0.03226402774453163, -0.02967948466539383, -0.047067541629076004, 0.04153970628976822, 0.05065743252635002, 0.009879973717033863, -0.00151253049261868, -0.02037467435002327, -0.0015237170737236738, -0.009372546337544918, -0.02655060589313507, 0.012128304690122604, -0.03649096563458443, -0.03279276192188263, 0.05712475627660751, -0.009860498830676079, -0.0031619276851415634, 0.04141430929303169, 0.04292567819356918, 0.017828434705734253, 0.04262043908238411, 0.019196996465325356, 0.006014647893607616, 0.0342814065515995, -0.011643846519291401, -0.03657013177871704, 0.060809649527072906, -0.022540073841810226, -0.005342466756701469, -0.045204147696495056, -0.028248073533177376, 0.03276119381189346, 0.03709280490875244, 0.0018887999467551708, -0.010781126096844673, -0.03612172231078148, -0.03607975319027901, -0.011710893362760544, 0.05244798585772514, -0.010959257371723652, 0.04526583477854729, 0.01172133069485426, -0.015869075432419777, 0.016180936247110367, 0.0035338019952178, 0.005178241059184074, -0.04347602650523186, -0.028725750744342804, -0.0540689118206501, -0.02055313065648079, -0.024584855884313583, -0.0011009800946339965, -0.03177174553275108, 0.011498946696519852, -0.026942195370793343, -0.031677812337875366, 0.03330472484230995, 0.021900173276662827, 0.0072327833622694016, 0.07924143224954605, 0.010946305468678474, 0.0788605585694313, -0.02353529818356037, -0.007563759572803974, 0.09977754205465317, 0.07408619672060013, 0.030834492295980453, -0.04263880103826523, -0.03355996683239937, -0.004342670552432537, 0.010125054977834225, -0.017455551773309708, 0.0013920040801167488, 0.017514439299702644, -0.028622379526495934, 0.036335401237010956, 0.07877238094806671, -0.0045046210289001465, 0.010315795429050922, -0.0005875437636859715, -0.05038732290267944, -0.009506484493613243, 0.00830867514014244, -0.0016794586554169655, -0.012923873960971832, -0.057173535227775574, -0.04531406611204147, 0.014414757490158081, 0.01436634548008442, -0.007250393275171518, -0.012032602913677692, -0.006494529079645872, -0.004375589080154896, 0.03414371982216835, -0.022289669141173363, -0.02851026877760887, 0.026549361646175385, -0.027601206675171852, 0.01855960674583912, -0.022430509328842163, 0.028896955773234367, -0.005803510081022978, 0.024045955389738083, 0.03387508541345596, 0.028081141412258148, -0.004112553782761097, 0.008682739920914173, 0.0036412847694009542, -0.03526320680975914, -0.0402667336165905, -0.017599966377019882, 0.03237331658601761, -0.009167702868580818, -0.01566210761666298, -0.009047308936715126, 0.005691678263247013, -0.044531919062137604, -0.046042896807193756, 0.006120613310486078, 0.023068692535161972, 0.03003932535648346, -0.02261519804596901, -0.007704112678766251, -0.02266656421124935, -0.0036007242742925882, -0.013788576237857342, 0.018733974546194077, 0.006567110773175955, -0.06863385438919067, -0.030512716621160507, 0.0010275642853230238, 0.02639550343155861, 0.02525123581290245, -0.018705235794186592, -0.00483406987041235, -0.002018064260482788, -0.028057167306542397, -0.03491353988647461, -0.022650007158517838, -0.03345571458339691, 0.03506701439619064, 0.003290741005912423, 0.021567432209849358, -0.030474616214632988, -0.04603565111756325, 0.009504014626145363, -0.024033917114138603, -0.042706478387117386, -0.009874019771814346, -0.0510641410946846, -0.0016258994583040476, 0.03869550675153732, -0.011910732835531235, 0.0005552134825848043, 0.0036672470159828663, 0.05845775082707405, -0.003743198234587908, -0.03659433126449585, -0.027663467451930046, -0.010266381315886974, -0.001952704624272883, 0.005984756164252758, -0.015283158048987389, 0.03681277111172676, 0.03132498636841774, 0.023882072418928146, -0.005042325705289841, 0.005523194558918476, -0.04541265219449997, 0.0009479478467255831, -0.020876364782452583, -0.044098228216171265, 0.03303562104701996, 0.050509463995695114, 0.016478998586535454, -0.04022316634654999, -0.02613658644258976, -0.020237578079104424, 0.004978660028427839, 0.003532341681420803, 0.0016249907203018665, -0.054038435220718384, -0.01832490786910057, 0.03781009465456009, 0.0371745340526104, -0.02915075048804283, -0.0385560505092144, -0.028975339606404305, -0.025883736088871956, 0.010327620431780815, 0.005699710454791784, 0.012844872660934925, 0.018199052661657333, -0.021752100437879562, -0.03018832579255104, 0.04190332815051079, 0.02467256225645542, -0.03522608056664467, -0.024093439802527428, -0.0017172996886074543, -0.022988665848970413, 0.05306302383542061, -0.0035261146258562803, -0.023149458691477776, 0.04460454732179642, -0.029298080131411552, -0.059839919209480286, 0.02111012674868107, -0.00700387405231595, 0.02161305770277977, 0.023858413100242615, 0.004117143806070089, -0.04117440804839134, 0.01795976795256138, 0.001622659619897604, 0.014559682458639145, -0.005045948084443808, -0.013063253834843636, 0.03281527757644653, -0.03171706572175026, 0.012602342292666435, -0.011203620582818985, 0.011498978361487389, 0.032158263027668, 0.03190706670284271, 0.024197101593017578, -0.008732003159821033, -0.004379859659820795, 0.01731424778699875, 0.0007856041193008423, -0.014052589423954487, -0.009213106706738472, 0.03235689550638199, 0.020400408655405045, -0.045032307505607605, 0.03818467631936073, -0.06593599170446396, -0.008007718250155449, -0.05673506483435631, -0.037651922553777695, -0.0032324448693543673, 0.03178206458687782, 0.06527718156576157, -0.052051883190870285, -0.007021050900220871, -0.0065395827405154705, -0.05193507298827171, 0.007375543005764484, -0.011380025185644627, 0.031269196420907974, -0.029286431148648262, 0.013058224692940712, -0.02019285038113594, -0.01744183711707592, 0.039968784898519516, 0.060353390872478485, 0.028437772765755653, 0.03637539595365524, 0.028153907507658005, -0.04422418400645256, -0.002899245359003544, 0.00442487234249711, -0.014148038811981678, -0.024783004075288773, 0.06471153348684311, 0.003088967641815543, 0.011046930216252804, 0.039019323885440826, -0.010605722665786743, -0.0046772342175245285, 0.00488236965611577, 0.04385010898113251, 0.022458605468273163, 0.009229402989149094, 0.004125069826841354, 0.017560454085469246, 0.01073364820331335, -0.01649646833539009, 0.04636313393712044, 0.0060577052645385265, -0.010459104552865028, -0.013861754909157753, 0.03662627562880516, -0.0027699735946953297, -0.0040383669547736645, 0.021163783967494965, 0.0036118868738412857, -0.02419210411608219, 0.02664680778980255, -0.03377717360854149, 0.026227019727230072, -0.014034726656973362, 0.07588253170251846, -0.011245561763644218, -0.054683614522218704, 0.018783215433359146, 0.023994309827685356, 0.005962699186056852, 0.01862126775085926, -0.005348076578229666, -0.05643368512392044, 0.021113615483045578, 0.034379784017801285, -0.006460643373429775, -0.03304049000144005, 0.023486746475100517, 0.00979701429605484, -0.0118172075599432, -0.008929063566029072, -0.034258827567100525, -0.06477530300617218, -0.0014644153416156769, -0.01947084628045559, 0.007540520746260881, 0.033322468400001526, -0.015925059095025063, 0.004646275192499161, -0.09429655224084854, 0.05100962892174721, 0.033904459327459335, -0.007176768034696579, -0.019231529906392097, -0.00897009763866663, 0.01299937255680561, -0.037064239382743835, 0.06353923678398132, -0.011516328901052475, -0.022067023441195488, 0.019037656486034393, 0.006748678628355265, 0.0199271347373724, -0.06012545898556709, 0.023719457909464836, -0.027583012357354164, 0.029348842799663544, 0.005654477048665285, 0.0007988493889570236, -0.0006486697820946574, -0.004577059298753738, 0.02581961266696453, 0.011867144145071507, -0.002756789093837142, 0.015855776146054268, -0.022260533645749092, 0.013531241565942764, 0.014888706617057323, 0.016335923224687576, 0.05901957303285599, 0.012173411436378956, 0.0055560944601893425, 0.016940278932452202, -0.031186465173959732, -0.08696885406970978, 0.02136843279004097, -0.02048015594482422, -0.021882332861423492, -0.024043114855885506, 0.0005244752974249423, -0.011103684082627296, -0.03186345472931862, -0.009907877072691917, 0.04295529052615166, -0.010303737595677376, -0.04393748566508293, -0.0015592569252476096, 0.04411066696047783, 0.07930862158536911, 0.021866928786039352, -0.016936257481575012, 0.013723185285925865, 0.014902886003255844, 0.027287732809782028, 0.016708770766854286, 0.030916323885321617, -0.022484172135591507, 0.03362053632736206, -0.004692258313298225, -0.017472553998231888, 0.0414789542555809, 0.01573450118303299, 0.05049853399395943, -0.03541170805692673, -0.01882687583565712, 0.026094047352671623, -0.03780407831072807, -0.027662230655550957, 0.012360981665551662, -0.02871064282953739, 0.06024749204516411, -0.0037023627664893866, 0.022174425423145294, 0.0035516880452632904, -0.011885099112987518, -0.03066338784992695, 0.012187754735350609, 0.003476796904578805, 0.009259430691599846, -0.03330831974744797, 0.013404854573309422, -0.007814384065568447, -0.006403014063835144, 0.024029819294810295, -0.021831315010786057, 0.012158290483057499, 0.02977059781551361, -0.027991073206067085, 0.014143912121653557, -0.041833437979221344, 0.03656217083334923, -0.00731815118342638, -0.005946122109889984, 0.04008607938885689, 0.02542865090072155, 0.0055918884463608265, -0.0018638536566868424, 0.019590144976973534, 0.0756441280245781, -0.0755128338932991, 0.0034979532938450575, -0.03569952771067619, -0.010918576270341873, 0.010698219761252403, -0.03000665456056595 ]
<p>149 students each sat two tests. My null hypothesis is that the product-moment correlation coefficient is 1, because each test should be an accurate indicator of current attainment. The actual PMCC for the data is 0.912152856.</p> <p>Please could you show (and explain) how to test if this is a significant result?</p>
73,675
[ -0.03290726989507675, -0.030108649283647537, -0.027668045833706856, -0.006181207485496998, 0.06208358332514763, 0.031107963994145393, 0.0360855758190155, 0.0015261761145666242, -0.009695046581327915, -0.029672155156731606, 0.0659165307879448, 0.041728876531124115, 0.027204280719161034, -0.005658168811351061, 0.026144372299313545, 0.047222789376974106, 0.009961851872503757, 0.030503245070576668, 0.0037297122180461884, -0.001629220205359161, -0.03098895773291588, 0.03577345237135887, 0.051368724554777145, -0.013784690760076046, -0.0033746748231351376, 0.014694713056087494, 0.019232606515288353, -0.038727305829524994, 0.016420751810073853, 0.04830454662442207, -0.042340345680713654, -0.015449006110429764, 0.03430820256471634, 0.012174906209111214, 0.02158387005329132, -0.002501328010112047, -0.0186330433934927, -0.01464561466127634, 0.007624804507941008, 0.038196954876184464, -0.013589674606919289, -0.04379440099000931, 0.00850357860326767, 0.03802834451198578, -0.0046784887090325356, 0.003702121088281274, -0.021483879536390305, -0.04619433730840683, 0.045163825154304504, -0.013049393892288208, 0.05777962878346443, 0.026307478547096252, 0.04827587679028511, -0.011267619207501411, -0.03612854331731796, -0.04122384265065193, 0.030247308313846588, 0.06995482742786407, -0.03865491971373558, -0.05477118119597435, 0.00807921215891838, -0.061012182384729385, 0.006342070177197456, 0.02496500127017498, -0.05913575738668442, 0.02016576938331127, 0.012158861383795738, -0.006903833709657192, 0.04930698871612549, -0.009022977203130722, 0.006343845743685961, 0.03206063434481621, 0.052258800715208054, -0.022080715745687485, -0.00006783014396205544, -0.05357218533754349, 0.020606189966201782, 0.0098761897534132, 0.04024575278162956, 0.07153083384037018, 0.001993517391383648, -0.010375474579632282, 0.04219478368759155, 0.048597682267427444, 0.03997853770852089, -0.024224331602454185, 0.06458023935556412, -0.021571552380919456, -0.00033335332409478724, -0.008425561711192131, -0.008753611706197262, -0.04653777554631233, 0.05057230591773987, 0.016222357749938965, -0.012346755713224411, 0.04284469783306122, -0.050765261054039, 0.05603579804301262, 0.025041168555617332, -0.013648763298988342, -0.01969970390200615, -0.022569436579942703, 0.044698234647512436, 0.05474968999624252, -0.027737656608223915, -0.012899858877062798, -0.021689822897315025, 0.0016668734606355429, -0.017919432371854782, -0.046751391142606735, 0.004614786244928837, 0.03741830214858055, 0.02572152577340603, 0.016409749165177345, 0.024695299565792084, 0.01217969786375761, -0.021417822688817978, -0.0007649759645573795, 0.04623729735612869, 0.05488137528300285, 0.033862482756376266, -0.01774822175502777, 0.027416734024882317, -0.017336571589112282, -0.02811269462108612, 0.005702586378902197, -0.02450883947312832, -0.02779758907854557, -0.023084674030542374, 0.050417955964803696, -0.023286644369363785, -0.012355029582977295, 0.019206026569008827, -0.030990028753876686, 0.033751800656318665, 0.02422993816435337, -0.06975863128900528, -0.01642698422074318, 0.0453077033162117, -0.04039229080080986, -0.044234078377485275, -0.05200502276420593, -0.0017310554394498467, 0.02425222657620907, 0.07034613192081451, 0.00866567064076662, 0.04914509132504463, -0.03747505322098732, 0.02361833117902279, 0.03592830151319504, -0.032719794660806656, -0.013044155202805996, -0.018632983788847923, -0.03410927951335907, 0.0013964582467451692, -0.11476346105337143, -0.001168512855656445, 0.03684914484620094, 0.02458377741277218, -0.024118613451719284, 0.02594529092311859, 0.02155359648168087, -0.01810898445546627, -0.03688105568289757, 0.020047076046466827, 0.04240560531616211, 0.06080937013030052, 0.01815657690167427, 0.011727506294846535, -0.003076176391914487, 0.004693867173045874, 0.00007902533980086446, 0.027047444134950638, 0.04044671729207039, 0.016148705035448074, -0.019834578037261963, 0.04153299704194069, -0.010757812298834324, 0.029028790071606636, -0.020365742966532707, -0.04359012097120285, 0.0016410547541454434, -0.03109927475452423, 0.00904693454504013, 0.017720524221658707, 0.024476192891597748, 0.00836143922060728, -0.016852179542183876, 0.00417544599622488, -0.014742960222065449, -0.01948441192507744, -0.07475433498620987, 0.02332063764333725, -0.0002631882671266794, -0.04540707916021347, 0.014243930578231812, -0.0064884694293141365, 0.04656986519694328, -0.020848682150244713, -0.02032897062599659, -0.028820056468248367, -0.039269398897886276, -0.001833910821005702, -0.017042338848114014, 0.011929702945053577, 0.02670653536915779, 0.08132636547088623, -0.021356254816055298, -0.014357641339302063, -0.016642263159155846, -0.00963541679084301, 0.011222327128052711, -0.023690758273005486, 0.01398466993123293, -0.002555012470111251, 0.006617357023060322, 0.006155722308903933, -0.014426985755562782, -0.009024517610669136, 0.03561432287096977, -0.04547126591205597, 0.07164236903190613, 0.05318661034107208, -0.008340243250131607, 0.015860548242926598, -0.01359970960766077, 0.023480834439396858, 0.009484395384788513, -0.03029976598918438, -0.020961513742804527, -0.03886828199028969, -0.028683345764875412, 0.015750184655189514, 0.007955970242619514, -0.03292340785264969, 0.016258662566542625, 0.07723619788885117, 0.020212719216942787, -0.004841823596507311, 0.015084906481206417, 0.019211463630199432, -0.010364477522671223, 0.004242139868438244, 0.008773868903517723, -0.005145018454641104, -0.012375426478683949, 0.005487069021910429, 0.042092710733413696, 0.009703686460852623, 0.024958377704024315, 0.01741388998925686, 0.0255493875592947, 0.013258845545351505, 0.007061209995299578, -0.02270413748919964, -0.00963954720646143, 0.048596665263175964, -0.016548527404665947, -0.0013819998130202293, 0.04437143728137016, 0.030866019427776337, -0.007620219606906176, -0.0065330518409609795, -0.034325696527957916, 0.014165964908897877, 0.027015380561351776, -0.03273377940058708, -0.0292450450360775, 0.02483442611992359, -0.053300708532333374, -0.00035496745840646327, -0.016307156533002853, -0.030989736318588257, 0.003113506594672799, 0.016689088195562363, 0.0542505607008934, 0.018541531637310982, 0.05156240612268448, -0.05014603212475777, -0.03476022183895111, 0.004696407355368137, -0.021542849019169807, -0.003849208354949951, -0.01069718785583973, -0.06207596883177757, -0.014663814567029476, 0.001264580525457859, -0.004303512163460255, 0.01754561997950077, -0.018468283116817474, -0.03433455899357796, 0.05060674995183945, -0.0029313734266906977, -0.015995416790246964, -0.06176071986556053, -0.044329773634672165, -0.024410076439380646, -0.06049586459994316, -0.012284107506275177, 0.04804779216647148, -0.006310969591140747, -0.04056518152356148, 0.029058462008833885, -0.0011423969408497214, -0.004204504191875458, -0.01114810910075903, -0.009865637868642807, -0.0010197415249422193, -0.020825397223234177, 0.0018845355371013284, -0.005360247101634741, -0.01986726000905037, -0.01456552091985941, -0.049326054751873016, -0.0674431249499321, 0.029521629214286804, 0.0013727841433137655, 0.035274140536785126, -0.01535009779036045, -0.06474854052066803, 0.04398656636476517, 0.0063032666221261024, -0.017999235540628433, -0.05053474009037018, -0.0031888072844594717, -0.033993303775787354, -0.03288974612951279, 0.03907070308923721, 0.032147154211997986, -0.03245742991566658, 0.04218778386712074, -0.006926524452865124, 0.011793099343776703, 0.006428647320717573, 0.01935577765107155, -0.0001595823123352602, 0.029972748830914497, 0.004681022837758064, -0.006380164995789528, 0.02471943199634552, 0.0051604690961539745, -0.061617717146873474, 0.019489789381623268, 0.008566910400986671, -0.0010992081370204687, -0.003317208494991064, -0.031907107681035995, 0.04810790717601776, -0.010278784669935703, 0.01428279746323824, -0.043382804840803146, 0.025012793019413948, 0.025117771700024605, -0.026913167908787727, -0.001294901710934937, 0.0013149642618373036, -0.01663035713136196, 0.014066191390156746, 0.01990455761551857, 0.0490616075694561, 0.020760148763656616, 0.019448615610599518, -0.013380930759012699, -0.012746157124638557, 0.020296260714530945, 0.03157022222876549, -0.04733686521649361, -0.03341059759259224, 0.0625164657831192, 0.0326492004096508, -0.0010092867305502295, -0.0007212156779132783, -0.04752514883875847, 0.0004087757261004299, -0.06456669420003891, 0.015353988856077194, -0.015989460051059723, 0.03320658951997757, 0.0038574044592678547, 0.02671622484922409, 0.02914087288081646, -0.02527305670082569, 0.02943861298263073, 0.011838782578706741, -0.060036733746528625, 0.011493803933262825, 0.015503497794270515, 0.00722217932343483, -0.004493723623454571, -0.03384968638420105, 0.006022950168699026, -0.05059134215116501, 0.016746748238801956, 0.019564863294363022, 0.03133218362927437, -0.014887338504195213, 0.03182821720838547, -0.03511233627796173, -0.003790289629250765, 0.03553212434053421, 0.03627226501703262, 0.018763141706585884, 0.005578887648880482, 0.04401372745633125, 0.06183305382728577, -0.029362039640545845, -0.03764735534787178, -0.04101916030049324, 0.030362002551555634, 0.019998330622911453, 0.03545200824737549, 0.03270779922604561, 0.0033419423270970583, -0.04348672181367874, 0.0711757242679596, 0.004926810506731272, 0.04666410759091377, 0.07139113545417786, -0.009008621796965599, -0.02307848259806633, -0.010393659584224224, -0.00906902365386486, 0.003545725718140602, -0.017613602802157402, 0.023551220074295998, -0.01429673470556736, 0.058468036353588104, 0.03859243914484978, -0.03586282208561897, 0.026326915249228477, 0.06103767827153206, -0.004259396810084581, 0.02478438802063465, -0.026689190417528152, 0.009429700672626495, 0.006012036930769682, -0.03964880108833313, 0.02416628785431385, 0.01685066521167755, 0.0027552552055567503, -0.035830527544021606, 0.0205403920263052, -0.02770823799073696, -0.02338266372680664, 0.011123433709144592, -0.02917119488120079, 0.04898161068558693, 0.04208364337682724, -0.030076267197728157, 0.02155414968729019, 0.05063613876700401, 0.01293544378131628, 0.016858644783496857, 0.024585282430052757, -0.05096123740077019, 0.020657414570450783, 0.019326498731970787, 0.04165581986308098, -0.0030818493105471134, -0.01859290525317192, -0.02027004584670067, 0.029363660141825676, 0.0573018416762352, -0.04069671407341957, 0.022608067840337753, 0.03930172696709633, 0.046818796545267105, -0.04061322659254074, -0.04803544655442238, -0.08305932581424713, 0.009367304854094982, -0.05927980691194534, -0.010016907006502151, -0.04106549546122551, -0.029254617169499397, -0.041310619562864304, 0.02272828482091427, 0.028465082868933678, 0.0672847330570221, -0.030057178810238838, -0.009142509661614895, 0.01756579428911209, -0.011260421946644783, -0.004364390391856432, -0.05151735991239548, 0.032238464802503586, -0.02955290675163269, -0.0068017118610441685, 0.04586503282189369, -0.04169055074453354, -0.0436372347176075, 0.008647644892334938, -0.011622645892202854, -0.04357600584626198, -0.013743608258664608, -0.03351781144738197, 0.04144761711359024, 0.024665281176567078, 0.0018001316348090768, 0.04083355516195297, -0.013758726418018341, -0.0021532170940190554, -0.004224891308695078, -0.012536255642771721, 0.0017068508313968778, -0.008404809050261974, -0.015026399865746498, -0.02142113633453846, -0.019350575283169746, -0.018496723845601082, 0.012306098826229572, -0.027016151696443558, 0.03130919486284256, -0.03950183838605881, 0.01177552342414856, -0.00801469199359417, 0.011228003539144993, -0.021512318402528763, 0.013072674162685871, -0.012825517915189266, -0.007819757796823978, -0.010114633478224277, -0.031082259491086006, 0.00408211350440979, -0.03867906332015991, -0.005050221458077431, -0.012741402722895145, 0.011209027841687202, 0.028116431087255478, -0.011816291138529778, -0.007660774979740381, -0.03466610610485077, -0.025030342862010002, 0.018151793628931046, -0.020991994068026543, 0.04439663887023926, 0.007574018090963364, -0.0173867866396904, -0.03011803887784481, 0.03402194008231163, 0.026782957836985588, 0.040444254875183105, -0.0006318118539638817, 0.0020945058204233646, -0.014607385732233524, 0.004314401652663946, -0.052509862929582596, -0.0669780746102333, -0.00961263570934534, 0.03020744025707245, 0.020635711029171944, 0.01793033629655838, -0.02014334499835968, 0.01880520023405552, -0.037175361067056656, -0.0052232760936021805, 0.03520209342241287, -0.03201376274228096, -0.020000431686639786, -0.009267701767385006, 0.010730259120464325, 0.07446324080228806, -0.025081034749746323, -0.031059090048074722, 0.032401006668806076, -0.01877462863922119, -0.03802971914410591, 0.02460004948079586, 0.006515846122056246, -0.034611597657203674, -0.02557378262281418, -0.011555857956409454, 0.006601310800760984, 0.05430884659290314, -0.033321935683488846, -0.026357552036643028, 0.012930473312735558, -0.001921877614222467, 0.009121342562139034, -0.0263229850679636, 0.0009787128074094653, 0.0006863671587780118, 0.020774584263563156, 0.0168807003647089, 0.039445661008358, -0.026911204680800438, -0.029613353312015533, 0.0358743816614151, 0.05126439034938812, -0.02469717711210251, -0.009337176568806171, 0.0809275433421135, -0.0037081020418554544, 0.01014639250934124, -0.01781347393989563, -0.04494611173868179, 0.017962876707315445, 0.05153138190507889, -0.0006349722971208394, -0.008195941336452961, 0.03003656305372715, -0.028656775131821632, -0.0005667017539963126, -0.02467453107237816, -0.0160853061825037, 0.06476371735334396, 0.013451769948005676, 0.04170392453670502, 0.04855402931571007, 0.009281751699745655, 0.004393449984490871, -0.006779342889785767, 0.013896102085709572, 0.015794523060321808, 0.006011581514030695, 0.030384277924895287, -0.06747505813837051, -0.01959148794412613, 0.03457808122038841, 0.027192261070013046, 0.0024381750263273716, 0.01867237314581871, 0.027317335829138756, -0.013454033993184566, 0.05043795704841614, -0.008539834059774876, -0.03177746757864952, -0.006380113773047924, -0.03184209391474724, 0.017553487792611122, -0.04540928453207016, 0.006167801097035408, 0.03757025673985481, 0.025386393070220947, -0.007727857679128647, -0.039807651191949844, -0.03228117153048515, -0.03169913962483406, -0.025566814467310905, 0.026619022712111473, -0.023603234440088272, 0.0564965084195137, -0.0019447671948000789, 0.054647047072649, 0.006503306329250336, 0.060704294592142105, -0.040618374943733215, -0.04716156795620918, -0.002443926641717553, -0.009488962590694427, -0.03894829750061035, 0.026334894821047783, -0.03922148048877716, -0.013796558603644371, 0.01228155568242073, -0.034299228340387344, -0.009942962788045406, -0.02338915318250656, 0.02708721160888672, -0.043570633977651596, 0.05789417400956154, -0.0035827220417559147, 0.013294492848217487, 0.008049475029110909, -0.0356266014277935, 0.10835963487625122, 0.0366508886218071, 0.018264947459101677, -0.03329410403966904, -0.00035344480420462787, 0.005691123194992542, 0.006378849036991596, -0.02737349085509777, -0.006872864905744791, 0.006474568508565426, -0.015977246686816216, 0.052547063678503036, 0.07221496850252151, -0.01547939982265234, 0.01362802367657423, 0.01975412480533123, -0.01231273915618658, -0.030255381017923355, 0.008021143265068531, -0.0015911707887426019, -0.003173010190948844, -0.008695844560861588, -0.003037789836525917, 0.007420400623232126, -0.016274135559797287, -0.02769666165113449, -0.024119457229971886, -0.01249674428254366, 0.011550748720765114, -0.026062197983264923, 0.003973611164838076, 0.0019393513211980462, 0.013590516522526741, 0.0011893678456544876, -0.026142973452806473, -0.032971348613500595, 0.00953944306820631, -0.029988188296556473, 0.0028556156903505325, 0.05839648097753525, -0.011776614002883434, -0.03770299628376961, 0.0236775241792202, -0.010453026741743088, -0.069560706615448, -0.015546138398349285, -0.017761511728167534, 0.056698817759752274, -0.022585414350032806, -0.04873047396540642, -0.020279178395867348, 0.004220874048769474, -0.01795170269906521, -0.052484627813100815, -0.060087013989686966, 0.023025888949632645, 0.013338461518287659, -0.07626518607139587, 0.01838076114654541, -0.012151719070971012, -0.002708744490519166, 0.003659660927951336, 0.032170619815588, -0.014645267277956009, -0.019888920709490776, -0.020334789529442787, -0.030498966574668884, 0.06680288910865784, 0.033143218606710434, -0.011808793060481548, 0.037418611347675323, -0.003993489779531956, -0.050076279789209366, -0.0032980458345264196, 0.028145812451839447, -0.03126484900712967, 0.02381470426917076, 0.027542248368263245, 0.009571517817676067, -0.012076095677912235, -0.030361687764525414, 0.016293557360768318, -0.01725802570581436, 0.0035188428591936827, -0.057044945657253265, -0.024160712957382202, 0.03121240623295307, 0.05413296818733215, 0.0308694951236248, 0.01078606117516756, 0.020414238795638084, 0.07150956243276596, 0.03308912739157677, -0.014698348008096218, -0.007286204490810633, -0.006955992896109819, -0.020265864208340645, 0.01747169718146324, -0.012038014829158783, 0.08241287618875504, 0.018661677837371826, -0.006508904974907637, -0.012083613313734531, -0.002907518297433853, -0.016204286366701126, 0.021623259410262108, 0.018853358924388885, -0.035398080945014954, -0.036621276289224625, 0.008843946270644665, -0.007891062647104263, -0.002739036688581109, 0.00875151064246893, -0.03758535534143448, -0.014849533326923847, 0.0007580698002129793, 0.00008279931353172287, -0.01832995004951954, 0.025841474533081055, 0.02031254954636097, 0.003383341711014509, -0.036263540387153625, -0.005127316806465387, -0.051126714795827866, -0.018042171373963356, 0.021271858364343643, 0.03411242738366127, -0.0008821735391393304, 0.025480125099420547, -0.03275629132986069, 0.028661323711276054, 0.08379039168357849, 0.0029699739534407854, 0.013507884927093983, -0.027475953102111816, -0.006025969050824642, 0.004371085204184055, 0.03451509773731232, -0.03940403088927269, 0.013011429458856583, 0.06447973847389221, -0.03525158390402794, -0.029422638937830925, 0.013654464855790138, 0.018284568563103676, 0.05284936726093292, -0.0052844746969640255, -0.009118442423641682, -0.04838103428483009, 0.013056392781436443, -0.02963169291615486, -0.00865973811596632, -0.010946391150355339, -0.003451928962022066, 0.02964962273836136, 0.003089631674811244, -0.014051475562155247, -0.009731109254062176, -0.01133829727768898, 0.014232882298529148, 0.09819991141557693, 0.024726716801524162, 0.044102270156145096, -0.024803826585412025, -0.02429937571287155, 0.026336433365941048, 0.021867722272872925, -0.015906810760498047, 0.01607314683496952, 0.022450033575296402, -0.031906161457300186, 0.017426814883947372, -0.012379352934658527, 0.0013886773958802223, -0.07251106202602386, -0.04969562962651253, 0.010192109271883965, 0.012808417901396751, 0.05865868180990219, -0.032482728362083435, -0.027620766311883926, 0.06134520471096039, -0.033127959817647934, 0.030458780005574226, -0.02466057986021042, -0.02179930917918682, -0.029505686834454536, -0.00670194486156106, -0.017933158203959465, 0.04267985373735428, 0.01995563879609108, 0.03149927407503128, 0.021326124668121338, 0.050391100347042084, 0.002101022517308593, -0.012790721841156483, -0.020290270447731018, -0.03942118585109711, -0.018269656226038933, -0.03977786377072334, 0.01333168800920248, -0.026841197162866592, -0.024156592786312103, 0.039623990654945374, -0.025923000648617744, 0.018322167918086052, 0.03741183876991272, 0.012147258967161179, 0.016000963747501373, 0.07372051477432251, 0.029503175988793373, -0.02841630019247532, -0.0346112884581089, -0.019479166716337204, 0.02566373348236084, 0.05521492660045624, -0.008522805757820606, -0.016836510971188545, 0.00578915374353528, -0.0019719572737812996, -0.043419890105724335, 0.025173867121338844, -0.0058098058216273785, -0.018588507547974586, -0.005310920532792807, -0.032700154930353165, -0.019950080662965775, -0.02044077217578888, -0.008595393039286137, -0.05319330841302872, -0.01687951758503914, 0.05787137895822525, 0.04547775536775589, -0.04482119902968407, -0.008374289609491825, -0.013334222137928009, -0.01839844323694706, 0.009997587651014328, -0.00179739436134696, -0.005448115058243275, -0.023510755971074104, -0.009729474782943726, 0.019871452823281288, -0.0020560657139867544, -0.00705174682661891, -0.05573750287294388, 0.002564231865108013, 0.02278347685933113, 0.006200307514518499, -0.0042041814886033535, -0.006522177252918482, -0.0218130424618721, 0.004318426828831434, -0.07152213901281357, 0.05162850767374039, -0.005447696894407272, -0.002953742863610387, -0.026053594425320625, -0.022748935967683792, -0.029249759390950203, 0.02273833565413952, 0.06688183546066284, -0.018470482900738716, 0.012805838137865067, -0.005021640099585056, -0.017413919791579247, 0.008659041486680508, -0.06361708045005798, 0.07019499689340591, -0.031532444059848785, -0.05167601257562637, -0.027551522478461266, 0.004927400499582291, 0.05870148167014122, 0.01238888967782259, 0.006012254860252142, -0.0455966517329216, 0.027227822691202164, -0.0008697520825080574, 0.009408055804669857, 0.030464833602309227, 0.006628044415265322, -0.030138224363327026, 0.05294819548726082, -0.002785741351544857, 0.03099983185529709, 0.009100524708628654, -0.006167559418827295, -0.08840133994817734, 0.02620563842356205, -0.008433657698333263, -0.029147718101739883, 0.0008272204431705177, 0.04404299706220627, -0.03460968658328056, -0.06558413058519363, 0.000037878871808061376, -0.00554536422714591, -0.05795874074101448, -0.008834201842546463, 0.046579279005527496, 0.022348614409565926, 0.01288375910371542, -0.013606860302388668, 0.05077723413705826, 0.0006046615890227258, -0.030112477019429207, 0.03362906351685524, 0.05428948625922203, 0.04347549006342888, 0.00468794908374548, 0.025417815893888474, 0.04481849819421768, -0.011738246306777, -0.01406705379486084, 0.012125584296882153, 0.03097589872777462, -0.027455894276499748, 0.018337586894631386, 0.020597854629158974, -0.025768745690584183, 0.04544554650783539, -0.023575833067297935, 0.0015956650022417307, 0.07924521714448929, -0.04596106335520744, -0.03199739381670952, -0.030412547290325165, -0.01626778393983841, -0.028583914041519165, 0.0030289969872683287, 0.04262053221464157, 0.016145411878824234, 0.004546226467937231, -0.038973573595285416, 0.004835187457501888, 0.005102116614580154, 0.003478244412690401, 0.0035139787942171097, 0.002862075809389353, -0.010246354155242443, -0.0314084030687809, -0.00888332724571228, -0.005230253096669912, -0.03664608672261238, -0.03536205366253853, 0.02681196667253971, 0.04505843669176102, 0.015585833229124546, -0.04133167117834091, -0.009164143353700638, 0.01893569715321064, 0.08312547206878662, -0.03697417676448822, -0.016085010021924973, -0.06196887791156769, 0.035232946276664734, 0.00304990541189909, -0.019575662910938263 ]
<p>I recently came across a predicting problem (0-1 outcome, with more than 80 variables), I decided to use GBM (Gradient Boosting Machine by Friedman)to handle this job. I let the GBM use only 70% of the dataset, and within this training set, 60% are used at each iteration. </p> <p>During this process I found a big problem of GBM: there was one predictor (AAA) that was so important (nearly causal) that this single predictor can predict the outcome with precision=40% at recall=40% (0-1 unevenly distributed, with 0: 80%, and 1: 20%), and this single predictor model was better than the GBM with 80 predictors including it (AAA). I wonder why this could happen, I would like to hear you thought on it. </p> <p>From a 'linear regression' perspective, I suspect multicollinearity, that GBM splits many other spurious predictors that correlated to AAA, gradually missing the predictive power of AAA. Additionally, I found GBM cut each of my predictor in a very 'overfitting' way (predictor sometime positive, sometime negative affect the fitted value). To tackle this problem, my strategy was to use a parameter of GBM called 'var.monotone' (it takes three values, 1 for positive correlation, -1 for negative, 0 for arbitrary). I selected 22 out of the original 80 predictors based on there association with the outcome, and used var.monotone to force their relationship with the outcome. the model was slightly better. </p> <p>I would like to know if force each predictors relationship with the outcome is a good strategy to mitigate overfitting, what's the better way from your perspective? More importantly, do you think a blackbox with 80 predictors really work? how about a logistic regression, or a L1 regularized one, with only 5 highly important (or causal) predictors?</p> <p>Thanks, Hicham Hu</p>
36,513
[ -0.012491951696574688, 0.008980310522019863, 0.03779608756303787, -0.034082915633916855, 0.050384461879730225, -0.027412276715040207, -0.006800714414566755, -0.03816106915473938, 0.021607257425785065, -0.03281388059258461, 0.03174764662981033, 0.0245185699313879, 0.04165930673480034, 0.015487697906792164, 0.01296013779938221, -0.02546818181872368, 0.010585944168269634, 0.011956212110817432, 0.03924824669957161, 0.00844371784478426, -0.009652262553572655, 0.021335938945412636, -0.015525410883128643, -0.00731150945648551, -0.003373119281604886, 0.050855621695518494, 0.03214859217405319, 0.009955663233995438, 0.009725595824420452, 0.03148404136300087, -0.03810543566942215, -0.0006430022185668349, -0.0020542480051517487, 0.03606562316417694, 0.0433102585375309, 0.00401935214176774, -0.0038944671396166086, -0.01180676743388176, -0.015549617819488049, 0.0302300862967968, -0.017862649634480476, -0.012895811349153519, -0.0069942050613462925, 0.0367770753800869, -0.008281108923256397, 0.0019383905455470085, -0.019937099888920784, -0.02141461707651615, 0.04693657159805298, -0.025154544040560722, 0.07934006303548813, -0.0002996798721142113, 0.038231272250413895, 0.05463719740509987, -0.01761322095990181, -0.02610902674496174, 0.051025960594415665, 0.07472704350948334, 0.006262452807277441, -0.03218076005578041, -0.011237174272537231, -0.012181012891232967, 0.007521484512835741, -0.001976780127733946, -0.0011747239623218775, 0.06605534255504608, -0.0039478205144405365, -0.07297106832265854, 0.01383641641587019, -0.021392809227108955, 0.017002727836370468, -0.0073440768755972385, 0.03408832848072052, 0.008673925884068012, 0.015918906778097153, -0.00842173770070076, -0.03758150711655617, 0.00728576397523284, 0.05244692414999008, 0.018137814477086067, -0.009447100572288036, -0.001794470357708633, 0.014969823881983757, 0.0403791181743145, 0.018573729321360588, -0.001014730310998857, 0.0462050586938858, -0.043668732047080994, 0.021016987040638924, 0.008664073422551155, -0.05268615111708641, 0.02018195018172264, 0.04260029271245003, 0.04117458686232567, -0.06052573025226593, 0.06305702775716782, -0.01997941918671131, 0.020237745717167854, 0.04674755781888962, 0.01915724016726017, -0.04021517559885979, 0.0011759217595681548, -0.006939672864973545, 0.0758097916841507, -0.032245196402072906, -0.007106664590537548, -0.03743626922369003, -0.034493084996938705, -0.02209135890007019, -0.029131438583135605, -0.012600885704159737, -0.00573979364708066, -0.005556069314479828, -0.01968267560005188, 0.01829511485993862, -0.026385143399238586, -0.009934072382748127, -0.016591869294643402, 0.042489685118198395, 0.07395657896995544, 0.027466369792819023, -0.04652447998523712, 0.03998840972781181, -0.021446548402309418, -0.034498147666454315, -0.013295521959662437, 0.017216157168149948, -0.015366019681096077, -0.03105717897415161, 0.05089915916323662, 0.0411461666226387, -0.033845964819192886, 0.008280260488390923, -0.0052125356160104275, 0.03726109117269516, -0.009099718183279037, -0.10466744005680084, -0.06877607107162476, 0.050065938383340836, -0.021906208246946335, 0.06171749532222748, -0.032657377421855927, -0.033701926469802856, 0.04593103751540184, 0.0848473310470581, 0.029834380373358727, 0.015995169058442116, 0.008484255522489548, 0.0054392144083976746, -0.020091675221920013, -0.008709401823580265, -0.023561758920550346, -0.03264348581433296, -0.009883417747914791, -0.04919988662004471, -0.10996795445680618, -0.008899763226509094, 0.01735824905335903, 0.006304190028458834, -0.00273475656285882, 0.037871427834033966, -0.0010819904273375869, 0.008248545229434967, -0.018223043531179428, -0.02122466452419758, -0.029872365295886993, 0.058007292449474335, 0.03828302025794983, 0.05248630791902542, 0.023236000910401344, -0.045052118599414825, 0.0004312164383009076, 0.04858491197228432, 0.018272804096341133, 0.03111911378800869, 0.01489599421620369, 0.02433193475008011, -0.0664573684334755, 0.017201563343405724, -0.002407702151685953, -0.01660924218595028, -0.04423585161566734, 0.008953562006354332, -0.002065455075353384, 0.004290470853447914, 0.007434379775077105, 0.007475603837519884, 0.004902285989373922, 0.06813857704401016, -0.04332756623625755, -0.07895570993423462, -0.04216976836323738, -0.011165001429617405, -0.0024336630012840033, 0.003412341931834817, 0.017971539869904518, -0.009697441011667252, 0.045029424130916595, -0.000589403382036835, -0.006575329229235649, 0.011327620595693588, 0.018479613587260246, 0.02073138952255249, -0.04511379078030586, 0.022585414350032806, 0.03159132972359657, -0.03231414407491684, -0.040479954332113266, 0.05591458082199097, -0.04242537170648575, -0.09472453594207764, 0.0294666551053524, -0.004960041493177414, 0.014848660677671432, -0.03991876170039177, -0.019573429599404335, 0.01533172745257616, -0.026251913979649544, -0.037687234580516815, 0.033027708530426025, -0.08816926926374435, 0.08827917277812958, 0.05790708214044571, 0.011082527227699757, -0.007584798149764538, 0.009296259842813015, 0.021248502656817436, 0.017755400389432907, -0.03849594295024872, 0.02656574174761772, -0.04331783205270767, -0.005625981837511063, 0.0355391725897789, 0.01702173985540867, -0.003059355542063713, 0.008629003539681435, 0.04114355519413948, 0.024814849719405174, 0.015572496689856052, 0.024677829816937447, 0.03965401276946068, -0.004531527403742075, 0.011323824524879456, 0.033821094781160355, 0.021426089107990265, 0.009736384265124798, -0.010953963734209538, 0.008357078768312931, 0.016542881727218628, 0.0002502341230865568, -0.018423691391944885, 0.05071980133652687, 0.05026352033019066, -0.003191610099747777, -0.014848366379737854, 0.0018690936267375946, 0.03455799072980881, -0.007718031294643879, 0.014335008338093758, 0.047531697899103165, 0.026018423959612846, -0.025767626240849495, -0.02731241285800934, -0.02773127518594265, 0.006483116652816534, 0.03979043290019035, -0.03924824297428131, -0.001058664871379733, 0.021919289603829384, -0.0581049919128418, -0.007230376824736595, -0.02597568929195404, -0.002259590430185199, -0.054990917444229126, 0.006033748853951693, 0.04845646396279335, 0.02188531681895256, 0.04253421351313591, -0.04194268584251404, -0.03149166330695152, -0.008090510033071041, 0.0026215261314064264, 0.008340350352227688, -0.012162654660642147, -0.049328308552503586, 0.007809145376086235, -0.04273495078086853, 0.024888506159186363, 0.031254418194293976, -0.012352241203188896, -0.001960286172106862, 0.01637573353946209, 0.001564783975481987, -0.04779224470257759, -0.06590888649225235, -0.04576047137379646, 0.0039067682810127735, -0.006210020277649164, -0.04769258201122284, 0.041724178940057755, 0.03934456780552864, -0.06516703218221664, 0.022559557110071182, 0.002651906805112958, -0.013074188493192196, -0.01790657825767994, 0.005231962073594332, 0.037551816552877426, 0.010527643375098705, -0.0162145234644413, 0.009076247923076153, -0.005262424703687429, 0.015151501633226871, -0.08247227221727371, -0.0647723376750946, 0.02144380658864975, 0.00018762407125905156, 0.002733065513893962, 0.0013281465508043766, -0.00010613380436552688, 0.0657319575548172, 0.04433891922235489, -0.013934874907135963, -0.06806428730487823, -0.016668055206537247, -0.011558318510651588, -0.013605461455881596, 0.030229827389121056, 0.018157754093408585, 0.03605930879712105, 0.0235254168510437, -0.04033305123448372, 0.032146554440259933, 0.04976695030927658, 0.031134339049458504, -0.023355519399046898, 0.027904609218239784, 0.007573912385851145, -0.020268214866518974, 0.008115655742585659, 0.042422082275152206, -0.01832602359354496, 0.02503868192434311, -0.033134303987026215, 0.010988778434693813, 0.0009806562447920442, -0.02667514607310295, 0.01314788032323122, 0.005289899650961161, 0.06006942316889763, -0.012384478002786636, -0.024287531152367592, -0.00203251326456666, -0.043294716626405716, -0.030652090907096863, 0.005926165264099836, 0.03150317817926407, -0.01398774329572916, -0.0069190324284136295, 0.04000220447778702, 0.04285931587219238, -0.014281176961958408, 0.0009961117757484317, -0.007423951290547848, -0.029242293909192085, 0.020347649231553078, -0.008176456205546856, -0.0013046847889199853, 0.009755549021065235, 0.033656325191259384, -0.01507871225476265, 0.005769386887550354, -0.03922218456864357, 0.03022930957376957, -0.07866000384092331, -0.003013334469869733, -0.037309251725673676, 0.07957647740840912, -0.0017435782356187701, 0.02259461209177971, 0.009603314101696014, 0.010389710776507854, -0.0015839404659345746, 0.0262069683521986, -0.05227378383278847, 0.05246793106198311, 0.031115956604480743, 0.02052043005824089, -0.0002634598349686712, -0.024246297776699066, 0.05793130397796631, -0.016962295398116112, -0.017017005011439323, -0.0022364521864801645, 0.045195844024419785, -0.050987355411052704, 0.0396522656083107, -0.05139746516942978, -0.025462066754698753, -0.025480210781097412, -0.003445954993367195, -0.02180025354027748, -0.01334474328905344, 0.01998736709356308, 0.039071641862392426, -0.011484600603580475, -0.0404575951397419, -0.01755557581782341, 0.005905564874410629, 0.04064863547682762, 0.042978622019290924, 0.003353910753503442, 0.035518940538167953, -0.07761245220899582, 0.029051337391138077, 0.020071595907211304, 0.00483254948630929, -0.006217107642441988, -0.015343952924013138, 0.03234276920557022, -0.03196573629975319, -0.04987214505672455, 0.032921724021434784, -0.009198560379445553, 0.005791672505438328, 0.022842705249786377, 0.059004511684179306, 0.025698749348521233, -0.03417046368122101, 0.009685633704066277, 0.08046941459178925, 0.008508721366524696, -0.021207235753536224, -0.07943709194660187, -0.03279999643564224, 0.033294301480054855, 0.02307632938027382, 0.028403179720044136, -0.023413924500346184, -0.04640776664018631, -0.019130300730466843, 0.045715197920799255, -0.006210105959326029, -0.01606052741408348, -0.00682888925075531, 0.02247178554534912, 0.05111810564994812, -0.008430329151451588, -0.023979132995009422, -0.0032055301126092672, 0.04837781935930252, 0.04115857928991318, 0.053826361894607544, 0.019742731004953384, -0.07927548885345459, -0.014010780490934849, 0.06547863036394119, 0.03823642432689667, -0.02745862677693367, 0.010056420229375362, -0.013482581824064255, -0.033278170973062515, 0.022208116948604584, -0.028567982837557793, -0.012430066242814064, 0.03213281184434891, 0.040057048201560974, -0.0009672021260485053, -0.06721694767475128, -0.03854316100478172, 0.03771983087062836, -0.04620202258229256, 0.04189877212047577, 0.005175410769879818, -0.03738667815923691, -0.007029531989246607, 0.024499110877513885, -0.02605360932648182, 0.09331846982240677, -0.0316278412938118, -0.05441519618034363, 0.022704651579260826, 0.010904516093432903, 0.019243882969021797, -0.08451845496892929, 0.017974557355046272, -0.02077554725110531, -0.04580186307430267, 0.05040501058101654, 0.005967625882476568, -0.03134298697113991, -0.00045489059993997216, 0.04766874760389328, -0.02140042930841446, -0.03679864481091499, -0.05968654155731201, 0.021842001006007195, 0.0068187532015144825, -0.028831079602241516, 0.04702029004693031, -0.021228794008493423, -0.03589341789484024, -0.00398996053263545, -0.06416337192058563, 0.00729352468624711, -0.0026286302600055933, 0.0044013746082782745, -0.016086507588624954, -0.03135775402188301, -0.030593322589993477, 0.046517204493284225, 0.05352160334587097, 0.04866461083292961, 0.006927603390067816, -0.006434217095375061, 0.009803724475204945, 0.023387528955936432, -0.02426183596253395, -0.026372969150543213, 0.008743148297071457, 0.015587445348501205, -0.002481915522366762, -0.006190146319568157, -0.0098778260871768, -0.013651642948389053, 0.035383302718400955, 0.04276631399989128, -0.041215989738702774, -0.02909550815820694, -0.012346838600933552, 0.0019017434678971767, -0.008512319065630436, -0.011764953844249249, 0.04304330796003342, 0.01517445407807827, 0.034168791025877, 0.00693226745352149, -0.04881029576063156, -0.017204344272613525, 0.03514542058110237, -0.014540490694344044, 0.027698703110218048, -0.03246806561946869, 0.00860294047743082, -0.011523925699293613, 0.009663761593401432, -0.03695094585418701, -0.04651078209280968, 0.00995721761137247, -0.02259182184934616, 0.004802451003342867, -0.021674014627933502, 0.02758600190281868, -0.00282076233997941, -0.03472079709172249, -0.004589148331433535, 0.044944606721401215, 0.018491286784410477, -0.009778966195881367, 0.0072881076484918594, 0.016191767528653145, 0.03311316296458244, 0.001836622366681695, -0.011267408728599548, 0.0055638207122683525, 0.010465338826179504, -0.033658821135759354, 0.017694588750600815, -0.015157965011894703, -0.049770377576351166, -0.017111117020249367, -0.016651209443807602, -0.014916235581040382, 0.0179789699614048, 0.0049531119875609875, -0.014840688556432724, 0.033917129039764404, -0.03289538249373436, 0.03606926649808884, -0.02417020872235298, 0.025365473702549934, 0.019415561109781265, -0.026996726170182228, 0.028593234717845917, 0.004452273715287447, -0.017350364476442337, -0.020476382225751877, 0.04068388789892197, 0.022082917392253876, -0.03294091671705246, 0.005756258964538574, 0.044980328530073166, 0.02807840332388878, 0.02019822970032692, -0.004407227970659733, -0.04178962484002113, 0.07100020349025726, 0.032083410769701004, 0.002171903382986784, 0.005558202508836985, 0.04202886298298836, -0.03565467149019241, -0.013548105023801327, -0.01783534325659275, -0.01705828122794628, 0.06378454715013504, 0.010662606917321682, 0.028880130499601364, 0.02661707065999508, 0.005039879120886326, -0.007690863683819771, -0.0269691813737154, 0.012548143975436687, 0.022021064534783363, -0.005702989641577005, 0.03014611452817917, -0.03132959082722664, 0.01408932451158762, 0.012806715443730354, 0.00038117889198474586, 0.007730814162641764, -0.008952326141297817, -0.0069857994094491005, 0.036330267786979675, 0.05716922506690025, -0.05450606346130371, -0.04236011579632759, 0.03372272849082947, -0.011741416528820992, 0.008300230838358402, -0.01710975170135498, -0.0005449842428788543, 0.052565354853868484, 0.05363104119896889, 0.02311001718044281, -0.04326891899108887, -0.0068009523674845695, -0.02808959223330021, 0.0022745048627257347, 0.02593076415359974, -0.05345667526125908, 0.028241153806447983, 0.003562173107638955, 0.0015224425587803125, 0.01792801544070244, 0.02902962639927864, -0.034823961555957794, -0.11463327705860138, -0.04228097200393677, 0.008816797286272049, -0.0176650732755661, 0.004687164444476366, 0.015370703302323818, -0.03441663831472397, 0.009458933025598526, -0.023404261097311974, -0.001673300750553608, -0.01007332094013691, -0.004733606707304716, 0.026529628783464432, 0.03653363138437271, -0.009131679311394691, -0.005505199544131756, 0.02351217530667782, -0.0009087488288059831, 0.13447780907154083, 0.05527259036898613, 0.024990100413560867, -0.0709930807352066, -0.0015524175250902772, 0.009802612476050854, -0.00508857099339366, -0.014048285782337189, -0.021733980625867844, -0.001226753112860024, -0.019399981945753098, 0.009078243747353554, -0.0026345858350396156, 0.03216233104467392, 0.005642931442707777, 0.052866797894239426, -0.06721998006105423, 0.013123777695000172, -0.008285237476229668, 0.015484679490327835, 0.024190431460738182, -0.013936479575932026, -0.02374418079853058, 0.009456095285713673, -0.015216818079352379, -0.019931821152567863, -0.006374795455485582, -0.011592952534556389, -0.03063984401524067, 0.03904746100306511, 0.017208144068717957, 0.009912582114338875, -0.011627019383013248, 0.0027187324594706297, 0.026217037811875343, 0.0020969845354557037, 0.02256036177277565, -0.013985734432935715, -0.01362802553921938, -0.006018911022692919, 0.0023928042501211166, -0.0068641966208815575, -0.015218820422887802, -0.014724849723279476, -0.033058375120162964, -0.02460561878979206, -0.04181772097945213, 0.042699698358774185, 0.024476489052176476, 0.001405271701514721, -0.01697571389377117, 0.015481935814023018, 0.014419324696063995, -0.03653497248888016, -0.023201381787657738, 0.03370187431573868, 0.044066283851861954, -0.05071836709976196, -0.06340669095516205, 0.02656560391187668, 0.030134767293930054, 0.008756152354180813, 0.024927781894803047, 0.011999796144664288, -0.02072286605834961, 0.0038642778526991606, -0.013382471166551113, 0.032445695251226425, 0.018990611657500267, -0.005727721378207207, 0.010491176508367062, -0.00012155980948591605, -0.03895534202456474, 0.013603880070149899, 0.007510628085583448, -0.015267042443156242, 0.04539685696363449, -0.030824163928627968, -0.013503671623766422, -0.05887993052601814, -0.03054019808769226, 0.013219865970313549, -0.03686705604195595, -0.005265870131552219, -0.018275953829288483, -0.01817549392580986, -0.007566316984593868, 0.035757940262556076, 0.014155558310449123, 0.020489228889346123, 0.01239148247987032, 0.03250683844089508, 0.008076532743871212, -0.022988514974713326, -0.045607540756464005, -0.013565571047365665, -0.07398032397031784, 0.013278184458613396, 0.010154918767511845, 0.05604980140924454, -0.00043479117448441684, 0.02720712684094906, -0.01679306849837303, 0.052465714514255524, 0.017122652381658554, 0.007535128854215145, 0.031208472326397896, -0.04862317442893982, 0.01821184530854225, 0.010218913666903973, -0.028074221685528755, -0.04000106826424599, -0.041024234145879745, -0.02996557578444481, -0.040306784212589264, 0.037519846111536026, 0.004939083941280842, -0.03563082963228226, 0.014426465146243572, 0.04789780080318451, 0.042818158864974976, -0.024733643978834152, -0.020383337512612343, -0.01796114258468151, -0.017675045877695084, -0.010823968797922134, -0.05706864967942238, 0.000550274970009923, 0.030761776491999626, -0.003685491159558296, 0.005363036412745714, 0.017744893208146095, 0.02121688425540924, -0.003077288856729865, -0.031903162598609924, 0.021800803020596504, 0.00927228294312954, 0.05845095217227936, -0.026691295206546783, 0.004767252132296562, 0.02167721651494503, -0.01828509010374546, -0.009076641872525215, 0.017215237021446228, -0.014994069933891296, 0.0187673456966877, 0.000756715249735862, 0.0010592089965939522, -0.020677099004387856, 0.07393797487020493, -0.008141773752868176, 0.0043464782647788525, -0.0005861357203684747, 0.018263647332787514, -0.027107907459139824, -0.0032374300062656403, -0.00778226787224412, 0.010845400393009186, -0.005538513418287039, -0.005971495993435383, 0.036283835768699646, 0.018757298588752747, -0.008695373311638832, 0.012380165979266167, 0.004585479851812124, -0.006537603680044413, -0.023755142465233803, 0.006702064536511898, 0.010689845308661461, 0.04285837709903717, -0.03011312149465084, 0.050669677555561066, 0.02237381413578987, 0.0014901028480380774, -0.08051848411560059, -0.022220665588974953, -0.005799268838018179, 0.013573741540312767, 0.03994608670473099, -0.05179349333047867, 0.011695749126374722, 0.001683054375462234, -0.03870979696512222, -0.00426145875826478, -0.01996096968650818, -0.004055079072713852, -0.03085397370159626, -0.025973783805966377, -0.02983860857784748, -0.005498990882188082, 0.0450027696788311, 0.012538420967757702, 0.006806519813835621, 0.02732725813984871, -0.011037101037800312, -0.03150457143783569, -0.05750177055597305, -0.000852155324537307, -0.01467377133667469, -0.01403066236525774, 0.039444584399461746, -0.02475469745695591, -0.0164212454110384, 0.023342659696936607, -0.024370763450860977, -0.0007011695997789502, 0.022333739325404167, 0.03724541887640953, 0.008366064168512821, 0.046393878757953644, 0.041633348912000656, -0.03405708074569702, -0.0021399420220404863, -0.005826460663229227, 0.005184544716030359, 0.011078743264079094, -0.022575214505195618, 0.01760595478117466, 0.002567773452028632, 0.013107179664075375, -0.039866894483566284, 0.011476283892989159, 0.006604649126529694, 0.023167597129940987, -0.002065691165626049, 0.012777849100530148, -0.02628546766936779, -0.029366739094257355, 0.012546614743769169, -0.014713826589286327, 0.002376183168962598, 0.06022510677576065, 0.038183558732271194, -0.036416102200746536, -0.020430296659469604, -0.040867142379283905, -0.04575653001666069, -0.028471946716308594, -0.002109254477545619, -0.013379042036831379, -0.0324014313519001, 0.004294561687856913, -0.007737359963357449, -0.011605741456151009, -0.015043833293020725, -0.01553657092154026, -0.029547950252890587, 0.024314913898706436, -0.0063283187337219715, 0.045703060925006866, 0.018481889739632607, -0.04938343167304993, 0.014437398873269558, -0.07937798649072647, 0.08266306668519974, 0.005862371996045113, 0.010610191151499748, 0.011456732638180256, -0.03389214724302292, -0.009703188203275204, -0.022522911429405212, 0.0687800943851471, -0.016928473487496376, 0.0146846454590559, -0.028771307319402695, 0.0007061220239847898, -0.0166407972574234, -0.00287438603118062, 0.03726759925484657, 0.011642592027783394, -0.010962928645312786, -0.019501857459545135, 0.001591149833984673, 0.0088384123519063, 0.003616554895415902, 0.007241230458021164, -0.04497022554278374, -0.003189475741237402, -0.016191843897104263, 0.015056961216032505, 0.04049152508378029, 0.00012401535059325397, -0.0010205761063843966, 0.0473395474255085, -0.004812718369066715, -0.009087514132261276, 0.043104276061058044, -0.019502105191349983, -0.10291651636362076, 0.012823297642171383, 0.002855454571545124, 0.00771902734413743, -0.013113033026456833, 0.023142322897911072, 0.006098276935517788, -0.01529631856828928, 0.005166123155504465, 0.01973208226263523, -0.032086726278066635, 0.019496066495776176, 0.03624767065048218, 0.0021712309680879116, 0.007485840003937483, -0.01013215072453022, -0.009362459182739258, -0.013928798958659172, 0.0016664351569488645, -0.01808326691389084, 0.017322471365332603, 0.001911026076413691, 0.05618308112025261, 0.021832605823874474, 0.02761172689497471, -0.0046341982670128345, 0.03559911996126175, -0.0009339501266367733, 0.025437716394662857, -0.06562156975269318, -0.020326638594269753, 0.004622040782123804, 0.021259987726807594, 0.010179569944739342, -0.024118490517139435, -0.00485153729096055, 0.04624816030263901, -0.055389512330293655, -0.012948007322847843, -0.050950732082128525, -0.0017377643380314112, -0.020255787298083305, 0.011599058285355568, 0.001282092067413032, 0.04725325107574463, 0.0427035391330719, 0.0022061835043132305, -0.006860521622002125, -0.009022900834679604, 0.03991139680147171, -0.023985661566257477, -0.00404333183541894, -0.016728293150663376, 0.006526163779199123, 0.01835758611559868, -0.0430893637239933, 0.004109608940780163, -0.039096783846616745, 0.024298816919326782, 0.05858105421066284, 0.015211290679872036, -0.036333344876766205, 0.01899769715964794, -0.015252319164574146, 0.02791033871471882, -0.04732277989387512, 0.00017229278455488384, -0.02569839544594288, -0.013680960051715374, -0.001496751792728901, 0.02613399364054203 ]
<p>I have to validate the data in one database by comparing it to data from a validated application system. The solution I came up with was (at least in theory) creating a statistical method that would define the number of random samples needed to check on a table of the database, in order to say, that with a 95% chance the number of errors is representative for that table. Then, with the probability of the errors I could consider if the data is valid or not.</p> <p>The binomial distribution doesn't help, since I don't have any knowledge about the probability at which an error could be found. My statistical knowledge is pretty rusty and I can't figure it out right now.</p> <p>Just to clarify again: Given N the number of entries in a table I want to know what number n for random samples I have to chose in order to be able to say after testing, that the probability of the error is p, at a 95% accurateness.</p> <p>I would be very helpful for every helping idea I could get. Any references to literature or sites covering this would also be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance!</p>
73,676
[ -0.028537126258015633, -0.02163730375468731, 0.0017082317499443889, -0.008470823988318443, 0.03547174856066704, -0.0014462615363299847, 0.026308853179216385, -0.01220760028809309, 0.015516068786382675, 0.0010785398771986365, 0.07625283300876617, 0.058261822909116745, 0.020054394379258156, 0.04595276713371277, -0.010448034852743149, 0.022285493090748787, -0.022982442751526833, 0.004100842867046595, -0.003911323845386505, -0.021038871258497238, 0.022284001111984253, 0.0007235000375658274, 0.009352029301226139, -0.05064738914370537, -0.03135780245065689, 0.00010960784857161343, 0.04310038685798645, -0.03425409644842148, 0.016299983486533165, 0.06991692632436752, -0.05826834589242935, -0.024108733981847763, 0.007915674708783627, 0.07089202105998993, 0.021995531395077705, 0.0178589578717947, -0.02692496031522751, -0.01886109635233879, -0.02895866334438324, 0.006034914404153824, -0.023060088977217674, -0.007550240959972143, 0.021398236975073814, 0.013505537994205952, -0.009828159585595131, 0.0073966155759990215, -0.004545480478554964, -0.034693337976932526, 0.018430104479193687, -0.04054735228419304, 0.06778314709663391, -0.011797011829912663, 0.041099391877651215, 0.03920210897922516, -0.004256745800375938, 0.0016049972036853433, 0.04893743619322777, 0.04628918319940567, -0.015701118856668472, -0.02676781825721264, -0.025425827130675316, -0.05087454617023468, -0.020529355853796005, -0.029935546219348907, -0.020554622635245323, 0.011111730709671974, -0.038817740976810455, -0.034556012600660324, 0.0133868008852005, 0.017042696475982666, 0.014036967419087887, 0.03236190602183342, 0.05204491317272186, -0.03388537839055061, 0.0070480043068528175, -0.03436587378382683, 0.02849961444735527, -0.018267853185534477, 0.024327421560883522, 0.022827746346592903, 0.009126040153205395, 0.00856848619878292, 0.0269013624638319, 0.05984595790505409, 0.020445959642529488, -0.03883885219693184, 0.034145500510931015, -0.04299113154411316, 0.014764420688152313, -0.0037764019798487425, 0.0005397197674028575, -0.04466691240668297, 0.03325308859348297, 0.009213179349899292, -0.049411341547966, 0.0026661299634724855, -0.015259004198014736, 0.05981196463108063, 0.004275000188499689, 0.009869505651295185, 0.03238016739487648, -0.023352332413196564, 0.01894782856106758, 0.04994285851716995, -0.0615127868950367, -0.003354083513841033, -0.00017192770610563457, -0.023534605279564857, 0.0115955900400877, -0.01021791622042656, 0.017269328236579895, 0.0490201860666275, 0.05542733892798424, 0.028188560158014297, 0.014212843030691147, 0.0021135066635906696, 0.000872346805408597, -0.04572552815079689, 0.04838024452328682, 0.05184235796332359, 0.03359568119049072, -0.010623574256896973, 0.05113960802555084, -0.020009715110063553, -0.03850199282169342, 0.015030093491077423, -0.00846826657652855, -0.02386312372982502, -0.04716222733259201, 0.05300581827759743, -0.03493478149175644, -0.007541914936155081, 0.0380396768450737, -0.0039068553596735, 0.049715690314769745, -0.01114258449524641, -0.07542742788791656, -0.05430211126804352, -0.005553449038416147, 0.01536602433770895, -0.026970727369189262, -0.056921739131212234, 0.03439313918352127, 0.03965459764003754, 0.02976849116384983, 0.004613805096596479, 0.037352800369262695, -0.03309622406959534, 0.014217707328498363, 0.01746252551674843, -0.0420614518225193, -0.01721740886569023, -0.011570660397410393, 0.0011474665952846408, -0.020032361149787903, -0.08682938665151596, 0.05640481784939766, -0.019888827577233315, -0.006119661033153534, -0.047554437071084976, -0.01705184206366539, -0.016264325007796288, -0.003170286538079381, -0.03445488587021828, 0.043173808604478836, -0.014938552863895893, 0.09388232231140137, 0.011276066303253174, 0.017268823459744453, 0.014376920647919178, -0.018630674108862877, 0.01619221270084381, 0.03369491547346115, 0.022092269733548164, 0.052246835082769394, -0.04313155263662338, 0.024129919707775116, -0.0045531997457146645, 0.05154769867658615, -0.002120641525834799, -0.013256879523396492, 0.020599620416760445, 0.0074075995944440365, -0.013053596951067448, 0.021600592881441116, 0.023702405393123627, 0.007211850490421057, -0.019176103174686432, 0.009967547841370106, -0.036689288914203644, -0.036878958344459534, -0.06612245738506317, 0.017234740778803825, -0.028787102550268173, -0.03293435275554657, 0.05878254398703575, 0.019663047045469284, -0.02471196837723255, -0.03637506067752838, -0.015369382686913013, -0.05472346767783165, -0.04822471737861633, 0.02371651493012905, -0.06027286872267723, -0.012724977917969227, 0.04948974773287773, 0.018544288352131844, 0.004614732228219509, 0.06677967309951782, -0.03531031683087349, -0.06283886730670929, -0.038694433867931366, -0.045845840126276016, -0.017975686118006706, 0.0009135625441558659, -0.023721715435385704, 0.03334443271160126, -0.002810167381539941, 0.006699622143059969, 0.0001964005350600928, -0.05460982769727707, 0.0518743097782135, 0.04079778119921684, 0.02287946082651615, 0.027667077258229256, -0.00787020567804575, 0.006877953186631203, 0.007158529944717884, 0.006926137953996658, -0.022596998140215874, -0.060772623866796494, 0.012274183332920074, 0.04005676507949829, -0.003260582685470581, -0.031437043100595474, -0.007966754026710987, 0.0782751515507698, -0.009897997602820396, 0.023552000522613525, 0.051343243569135666, -0.03948812559247017, 0.013251693919301033, -0.02013329043984413, 0.011797799728810787, -0.0005067472229711711, 0.0441480316221714, 0.0004025484959129244, 0.027615392580628395, 0.04509138688445091, -0.003004788188263774, -0.010437743738293648, 0.013215537182986736, 0.008774040266871452, 0.01879972405731678, -0.006345546338707209, -0.003726021619513631, 0.04337077587842941, -0.013381203636527061, 0.00644602719694376, 0.01275559887290001, -0.016685403883457184, 0.02844681777060032, 0.004246822092682123, -0.018713250756263733, 0.022185049951076508, 0.018787553533911705, -0.037899989634752274, 0.0015650419518351555, 0.016288917511701584, -0.031841687858104706, 0.0044012051075696945, -0.01717996411025524, -0.024287203326821327, -0.01621672324836254, 0.008828306570649147, 0.02741425670683384, -0.0000943555060075596, 0.04334357753396034, 0.006969664711505175, -0.022575760260224342, -0.01685567945241928, -0.024248715490102768, -0.00879155658185482, -0.014022492803633213, -0.05868499353528023, -0.02657504566013813, 0.015387697145342827, -0.02410155162215233, 0.03637130185961723, -0.018181495368480682, -0.002489381702616811, 0.022123180329799652, 0.016309401020407677, -0.03154010325670242, -0.00565440533682704, -0.018819382414221764, 0.009422105737030506, -0.04544100537896156, -0.01720205321907997, -0.0008014452760107815, 0.02908174879848957, -0.017756378278136253, 0.056363556534051895, -0.030822282657027245, -0.024406036362051964, -0.040156904608011246, 0.019120674580335617, 0.01716819405555725, -0.032969266176223755, 0.009312569163739681, 0.028198804706335068, 0.022288676351308823, -0.022752679884433746, -0.0593399703502655, -0.09062609076499939, -0.025959329679608345, 0.01082692015916109, 0.04887102544307709, 0.012481615878641605, -0.02063441090285778, 0.08357205241918564, 0.04618597775697708, -0.03096081130206585, 0.008950387127697468, -0.0077734170481562614, -0.037475813180208206, -0.011509939096868038, 0.043021056801080704, 0.005193733610212803, -0.03946302458643913, 0.02207234315574169, -0.011131850071251392, 0.00469073373824358, 0.03951023891568184, -0.011676604859530926, 0.023027770221233368, 0.01493825949728489, 0.005569385830312967, -0.016724124550819397, 0.021216653287410736, 0.0016309370985254645, -0.06608205288648605, -0.00003580008342396468, -0.029744578525424004, 0.010104943066835403, 0.013211018405854702, -0.0484919473528862, -0.00482745049521327, -0.037176117300987244, 0.013621601276099682, -0.04038068652153015, 0.03665098547935486, -0.013202574104070663, -0.025629466399550438, 0.018239468336105347, 0.060536593198776245, 0.022881291806697845, -0.014729415066540241, -0.001000768388621509, 0.058832816779613495, 0.04426822438836098, -0.02934945374727249, -0.024331245571374893, -0.007645709440112114, 0.0045323497615754604, 0.004943891428411007, -0.0018706942209973931, -0.012389371171593666, 0.03666423633694649, 0.026383837684988976, 0.0505228228867054, -0.03764402121305466, -0.022396601736545563, 0.012187270447611809, -0.049341775476932526, 0.012151449918746948, -0.037866007536649704, 0.05320064350962639, -0.009635440073907375, 0.060880932956933975, 0.020221492275595665, -0.033816687762737274, 0.0036954935640096664, 0.03016972355544567, -0.05416565015912056, 0.04008467495441437, -0.023182561621069908, -0.04099284112453461, -0.0028365275356918573, -0.031183382496237755, 0.00853531900793314, -0.03610621392726898, 0.02216297946870327, 0.02757089026272297, 0.03341568633913994, -0.015461952425539494, 0.020272281020879745, -0.029966207221150398, -0.021712765097618103, 0.024196287617087364, 0.036707162857055664, -0.011860095895826817, 0.04279068484902382, 0.014079593122005463, 0.015219380147755146, -0.004647393710911274, -0.04314872622489929, -0.03974350541830063, 0.014691444113850594, 0.012718932703137398, 0.05788693204522133, 0.017335323616862297, 0.03295106813311577, -0.03645184636116028, 0.012162492610514164, -0.01506937574595213, 0.03944113850593567, 0.06389536708593369, 0.027706054970622063, -0.01210213266313076, -0.05535425990819931, -0.005332260858267546, -0.0084571223706007, 0.0062057385221123695, -0.004662604071199894, -0.022977730259299278, 0.04766906425356865, 0.004040804225951433, -0.0848175510764122, -0.011003813706338406, 0.08686817437410355, 0.017771722748875618, 0.039708491414785385, -0.025549013167619705, -0.018838416785001755, 0.008435316383838654, -0.015580265782773495, -0.013586015440523624, 0.039374660700559616, -0.014292583800852299, -0.0037629480939358473, 0.043724700808525085, -0.0261857770383358, -0.0420532263815403, 0.006698414217680693, 0.03187662363052368, 0.0594206228852272, 0.00020970171317458153, -0.008998407982289791, 0.04112333059310913, 0.015288866125047207, 0.04156804829835892, 0.025316700339317322, -0.014722383581101894, -0.05723315849900246, 0.017887191846966743, 0.06604455411434174, 0.03312816470861435, -0.04526720568537712, -0.007913562469184399, -0.04296882078051567, -0.0061533888801932335, 0.06299767643213272, -0.024433637037873268, 0.029423480853438377, 0.021432051435112953, 0.030290920287370682, -0.016739921644330025, -0.005759328603744507, -0.030533159151673317, -0.03410998731851578, -0.05109274387359619, 0.045004237443208694, -0.02644685097038746, -0.02337905950844288, -0.060349658131599426, -0.00442113820463419, 0.03930606320500374, 0.06476262956857681, -0.025288894772529602, -0.00529610738158226, -0.005629236809909344, 0.01709822565317154, -0.01957647316157818, -0.03203354775905609, 0.014675025828182697, -0.028076576068997383, 0.005146395415067673, 0.011529028415679932, 0.0012701069936156273, -0.03209651634097099, 0.03791781887412071, -0.011040007695555687, -0.0386502705514431, 0.0015957501018419862, -0.011580849066376686, 0.013605794869363308, 0.009634354151785374, 0.03348282724618912, 0.050516676157712936, -0.007509208749979734, 0.008983897976577282, -0.004455834627151489, -0.03209324926137924, 0.014070097357034683, -0.009373374283313751, 0.004546757787466049, -0.060160886496305466, 0.0056943707168102264, -0.04720350354909897, 0.017587237060070038, 0.034761570394039154, 0.02667938359081745, 0.0023863278329372406, -0.024432668462395668, -0.0036599976010620594, 0.01818927749991417, 0.025388872250914574, -0.014755700714886189, 0.00731061864644289, 0.014879600144922733, -0.007547928020358086, -0.004898896906524897, 0.03014162741601467, -0.007447298616170883, -0.004737113136798143, -0.018321773037314415, -0.03498302772641182, 0.019550101831555367, -0.059650272130966187, -0.03614392504096031, 0.035156164318323135, -0.006047959439456463, 0.04196451976895332, 0.012714221142232418, 0.059655893594026566, -0.027832267805933952, -0.03585372492671013, -0.02704186737537384, 0.051403023302555084, -0.009658606722950935, 0.05466267094016075, -0.03111833706498146, 0.013941209763288498, -0.047774188220500946, 0.006606442853808403, -0.08025447279214859, -0.02533138357102871, 0.046951211988925934, -0.005246040411293507, -0.02217322587966919, -0.05580112338066101, -0.01726684160530567, -0.004494000691920519, -0.018281975761055946, 0.0005981959402561188, 0.04985600337386131, 0.015023930929601192, -0.05072278156876564, 0.01139085553586483, -0.013858224265277386, 0.06934148073196411, -0.007435535080730915, -0.007886189967393875, 0.008834393694996834, -0.023039430379867554, -0.02161877043545246, 0.009150292724370956, 0.0010052676079794765, -0.028863336890935898, -0.020188864320516586, -0.05276981368660927, 0.02125232107937336, 0.021848611533641815, -0.05807530879974365, 0.015622537583112717, -0.0022509710397571325, 0.020088890567421913, -0.008817339316010475, -0.032423362135887146, 0.02184051275253296, 0.008036783896386623, -0.003353254171088338, -0.015119730494916439, 0.015265392139554024, -0.015823006629943848, 0.022085778415203094, 0.019827289506793022, 0.0028513141442090273, -0.007761575747281313, 0.024767935276031494, 0.08368406444787979, -0.009522556327283382, -0.03055664710700512, 0.0007286398904398084, -0.017841482535004616, 0.024629956111311913, 0.015444332733750343, -0.03751877322793007, 0.02323966845870018, 0.007371323183178902, -0.04815245792269707, -0.031222300603985786, -0.015642434358596802, -0.01001368835568428, 0.04385612532496452, 0.012027367018163204, 0.043539416044950485, 0.014447529800236225, 0.033289503306150436, -0.023127542808651924, 0.011601485311985016, -0.014021244831383228, -0.006975866854190826, 0.010699059814214706, 0.03458871319890022, 0.011624898761510849, -0.006014389451593161, 0.0036742317024618387, 0.01244413759559393, 0.023555584251880646, 0.07144042104482651, 0.03038085252046585, 0.019038405269384384, 0.032130733132362366, -0.035441815853118896, -0.020795485004782677, 0.034320902079343796, -0.07468721270561218, 0.033454570919275284, -0.004097453318536282, -0.02469794638454914, 0.05109800398349762, 0.02689308486878872, -0.00978588592261076, -0.0056849210523068905, -0.022779816761612892, -0.02109394408762455, -0.0006933758850209415, 0.018429327756166458, 0.009630335494875908, 0.0330876000225544, -0.022502124309539795, 0.024953855201601982, 0.011708877049386501, 0.039816372096538544, 0.002430351683869958, -0.07336084544658661, -0.015931110829114914, -0.02743532322347164, -0.04184833914041519, 0.03830496966838837, 0.027489498257637024, -0.016118446364998817, 0.0015493044629693031, -0.0037821626756340265, 0.0370866023004055, 0.0201761145144701, 0.058334507048130035, -0.03337086737155914, 0.06552708148956299, 0.019421035423874855, 0.04220598563551903, 0.012083739042282104, -0.002085905522108078, 0.10497256368398666, 0.08669459074735641, 0.047868236899375916, -0.04622193053364754, 0.013568704016506672, 0.0016837562434375286, 0.004919383209198713, 0.002760773291811347, 0.03747063875198364, 0.004985417705029249, -0.010256458073854446, 0.04892454296350479, 0.016402842476963997, -0.01684059575200081, 0.017947865650057793, 0.07079662382602692, -0.01858919858932495, -0.02956554666161537, 0.02683105319738388, 0.024521872401237488, -0.0014151707291603088, -0.049572769552469254, -0.004285774659365416, 0.02922057919204235, 0.005338391289114952, -0.039756741374731064, -0.017968179658055305, -0.005853181704878807, 0.015650568529963493, -0.002234052401036024, 0.0027766963467001915, -0.009862625040113926, -0.0031582603696733713, 0.013784085400402546, -0.021765172481536865, -0.01619061641395092, 0.0010958834318444133, -0.008461665362119675, 0.01370096206665039, 0.060711152851581573, 0.0009078175644390285, -0.012946252711117268, -0.0215306356549263, 0.04472361505031586, -0.04700428619980812, -0.03095153532922268, -0.05666555091738701, 0.0223725326359272, -0.007431125268340111, -0.0009712002938613296, -0.01634501852095127, 0.003641844494268298, 0.00929141417145729, -0.03483441844582558, 0.002786593744531274, 0.03162073716521263, 0.022983556613326073, -0.03672253340482712, -0.024525703862309456, -0.00046488887164741755, 0.016711821779608727, -0.010849952697753906, 0.01475632842630148, 0.02833976037800312, -0.0290831346064806, -0.011097530834376812, -0.02944541908800602, 0.036418747156858444, -0.011861193925142288, 0.011435267515480518, 0.0023878077045083046, -0.02578124962747097, -0.03618786856532097, 0.022820470854640007, -0.003766622394323349, 0.01373443752527237, 0.020401664078235626, -0.014724652282893658, 0.0038720741868019104, 0.031707946211099625, -0.017570005729794502, 0.03230316564440727, -0.0468217134475708, -0.00522858090698719, -0.024000555276870728, 0.004360499791800976, 0.016802411526441574, 0.015482788905501366, 0.017158305272459984, 0.012957751750946045, -0.00009389939805259928, 0.003778128419071436, 0.019160877913236618, -0.06050765886902809, 0.006345959380269051, -0.029481349512934685, -0.05075816065073013, 0.01905287429690361, -0.00968923419713974, 0.06189855560660362, 0.018606573343276978, 0.034089863300323486, 0.034154944121837616, 0.02281230129301548, -0.013581820763647556, 0.012140077538788319, -0.009307283908128738, -0.05014253407716751, -0.02837545797228813, 0.008274662308394909, -0.023714309558272362, -0.01862023025751114, -0.02239956334233284, -0.03802977874875069, -0.0381789430975914, 0.013080930337309837, 0.01648200862109661, -0.01253171544522047, -0.01300354115664959, 0.005858500488102436, -0.03165998309850693, -0.005448757670819759, 0.014479382894933224, -0.009966404177248478, -0.03372086584568024, 0.014570819213986397, 0.005264210514724255, -0.021601317450404167, -0.02289058268070221, 0.0013586260611191392, 0.0006942233303561807, 0.03167863190174103, -0.0015235727187246084, 0.02736993320286274, -0.02568507008254528, -0.010394818149507046, 0.016451429575681686, 0.04658002033829689, -0.07126881927251816, 0.016563186421990395, 0.0561571940779686, -0.06749078631401062, -0.03688636049628258, 0.03902599960565567, -0.015710514038801193, 0.032212838530540466, -0.0038961677346378565, -0.011524315923452377, -0.014997785910964012, 0.06216173991560936, -0.05502654239535332, -0.06681117415428162, -0.030494142323732376, 0.027418602257966995, 0.02714836411178112, 0.010521844029426575, 0.03430435433983803, 0.005133762955665588, 0.002758494345471263, 0.01770198903977871, 0.05262326821684837, 0.014141572639346123, -0.0030607173684984446, 0.021307865157723427, 0.024136776104569435, 0.006589505821466446, 0.02829360030591488, -0.007661186158657074, -0.009043028578162193, 0.05856400728225708, -0.03668295592069626, 0.04313294589519501, -0.002951571252197027, 0.011973591521382332, -0.08322908729314804, -0.03777691349387169, 0.016002856194972992, 0.009562613442540169, 0.029048360884189606, -0.047619663178920746, -0.017996709793806076, 0.03371698781847954, -0.0387263260781765, 0.020005187019705772, 0.007733840495347977, -0.00693023344501853, -0.05552757903933525, 0.020392145961523056, -0.034439779818058014, 0.013471347279846668, 0.019282981753349304, -0.018111301586031914, 0.032135847955942154, 0.03931804746389389, -0.01498168520629406, -0.026230089366436005, -0.02190159074962139, 0.04745839908719063, 0.03094722516834736, -0.041691288352012634, 0.001829740358516574, -0.028144579380750656, -0.04417159780859947, 0.01667684130370617, -0.0070578972809016705, 0.0212527047842741, -0.003852659137919545, 0.0077599589712917805, 0.01195080392062664, 0.0445079505443573, 0.02937064878642559, -0.015446702018380165, -0.006593071389943361, -0.009124236181378365, 0.04329662770032883, 0.04554446041584015, -0.033425938338041306, 0.008760863915085793, 0.03670330345630646, -0.01889035478234291, -0.06398548930883408, 0.02210993692278862, 0.021111436188220978, 0.005067224148660898, -0.007664484437555075, -0.011168061755597591, 0.0009212204022333026, -0.03371540829539299, 0.02591560408473015, -0.05067407712340355, 0.014344209805130959, 0.039639946073293686, 0.032601840794086456, -0.018116572871804237, 0.0259499903768301, -0.023889876902103424, -0.021920038387179375, -0.012405975721776485, 0.005505125503987074, -0.03709026053547859, -0.07735095173120499, 0.008996847085654736, -0.03879097104072571, 0.006640989799052477, -0.006559919565916061, 0.004448549821972847, -0.022952402010560036, 0.02446039579808712, -0.0041697025299072266, -0.009955912828445435, 0.02922712080180645, -0.01660604029893875, -0.011600748635828495, -0.06977763026952744, 0.06494546681642532, 0.011827490292489529, -0.028132641687989235, -0.044882502406835556, -0.01821988634765148, -0.031016333028674126, 0.024703653529286385, 0.020557817071676254, 0.02762068435549736, -0.02093631774187088, -0.02460722252726555, -0.011179395951330662, 0.002927841152995825, -0.08424044400453568, 0.04791251942515373, -0.056143343448638916, -0.044705167412757874, -0.03805391117930412, -0.01786818541586399, 0.02549380622804165, -0.017084460705518723, -0.02897511050105095, -0.001649118377827108, -0.001007784972898662, 0.010179542005062103, -0.03192593902349472, 0.04909653961658478, 0.008725544437766075, 0.0008290124824270606, 0.02729540318250656, -0.021480999886989594, -0.008927123621106148, 0.016708342358469963, 0.010540333576500416, -0.06181379780173302, 0.031279269605875015, -0.03795859217643738, -0.02636535093188286, -0.013567237183451653, 0.03582431375980377, -0.023724524304270744, -0.06146909296512604, 0.02718333713710308, 0.015990549698472023, -0.058282408863306046, 0.02416304685175419, 0.01870833709836006, 0.03717243671417236, 0.05663803964853287, -0.033060524612665176, 0.038053032010793686, -0.010651537217199802, -0.03665135055780411, -0.019648520275950432, 0.003094807965680957, 0.009676441550254822, -0.023951666429638863, 0.04297420755028725, 0.03834861144423485, -0.002581917680799961, 0.03344937786459923, 0.012075318023562431, 0.03044065274298191, -0.051459431648254395, 0.004879077896475792, 0.04031801223754883, -0.014717327430844307, 0.030982010066509247, 0.02718493901193142, -0.022650601342320442, 0.0863570049405098, 0.01797238551080227, -0.0014991305069997907, -0.05723084509372711, -0.022540008649230003, 0.0006534323911182582, -0.012779357843101025, 0.011626947671175003, 0.02069643884897232, -0.024269793182611465, 0.049305375665426254, 0.02543848380446434, 0.04601581022143364, 0.04392671585083008, -0.009979048743844032, 0.011712689884006977, 0.0010569500736892223, -0.007180800661444664, -0.06585866212844849, -0.0005408309516496956, -0.031603697687387466, 0.025463629513978958, 0.017862146720290184, 0.030001018196344376, 0.025830453261733055, 0.04781220480799675, -0.040081363171339035, 0.014928418211638927, 0.018199019134044647, -0.016134364530444145, -0.010156353935599327, -0.04555080831050873, 0.02425694465637207, -0.033552832901477814, -0.025491761043667793 ]
<p>I am applying a linear model to my data: $$ y_{i}=\beta_{0}+\beta_{1}x_{i}+\epsilon_{i}, \quad\epsilon_{i} \sim N(0,\sigma^{2}). $$</p> <p>I would like to estimate the confidence interval (CI) of the coefficients ($\beta_{0}$, $\beta_{1}$) using bootstrap method. There are two ways that I can apply the bootstrap method:</p> <ol> <li><p>Sample paired response-predictor: Randomly resample pairs of $y_{i}-x_{i}$, and apply linear regression to each run. After $m$ runs, we obtain a collection of estimated coefficients ${\hat{\beta_{j}}}, j=1,...m$. Finally, compute the quantile of ${\hat{\beta_{j}}}$.</p></li> <li><p>Sample error: First apply linear regression on the original observed data, from this model we obtain $\hat{\beta_{o}}$ and the error $\epsilon_{i}$. Afterwards, randomly resample the error $\epsilon^{*}_{i}$ and compute the new data with $\hat{\beta_{o}}$ and $y^{*}_{i}=\hat{\beta_{o}}x_{i}+\epsilon^{*}_{i}$. Apply once again linear regression. After $m$ runs, we obtain a collection of estimated coefficeints ${\hat{\beta_{j}}}, j=1,...,m$. Finally, compute the quantile of ${\hat{\beta_{j}}}$. </p></li> </ol> <p>My questions are:</p> <ul> <li><strong>How are these two methods different?</strong></li> <li><strong>Under which assumption are these two methods giving the same result?</strong></li> </ul>
73,677
[ -0.032579343765974045, 0.0011504008434712887, 0.031487587839365005, -0.01854766346514225, 0.02552490308880806, 0.027588428929448128, 0.02046837843954563, -0.028273936361074448, 0.048439204692840576, -0.021390307694673538, 0.04890720173716545, 0.03006788343191147, 0.08165725320577621, 0.01158221997320652, 0.020555859431624413, 0.009021516889333725, -0.021194659173488617, 0.022286569699645042, -0.013452738523483276, 0.025043023750185966, 0.011614564806222916, 0.058131568133831024, 0.007144256494939327, 0.0076014092192053795, -0.04103487730026245, 0.04890472814440727, 0.01904205046594143, -0.04333042353391647, -0.02375420555472374, 0.03716118261218071, -0.026757381856441498, -0.02639746107161045, 0.035681430250406265, 0.01748739741742611, -0.016117269173264503, -0.02175203338265419, -0.021870119497179985, -0.06290032714605331, 0.011223242618143559, 0.024192478507757187, -0.030860790982842445, -0.004347919952124357, -0.012065952643752098, -0.012130715884268284, 0.028154605999588966, 0.022452985867857933, -0.009956260211765766, -0.0278920978307724, 0.002191186649724841, -0.02601591683924198, 0.054666128009557724, -0.02452651411294937, 0.011140130460262299, 0.044411566108465195, -0.041918713599443436, 0.007524173241108656, 0.013257180340588093, 0.04363948106765747, -0.007335166912525892, -0.046909935772418976, -0.008784164674580097, -0.006709334906190634, 0.001554992632009089, 0.010897011496126652, -0.03136599436402321, 0.011043978855013847, -0.008262981660664082, -0.0011427650460973382, -0.013157689943909645, -0.018989214673638344, 0.0442197285592556, 0.00932034570723772, 0.05651651322841644, -0.0007165602874010801, 0.00613347627222538, 0.00580649683251977, -0.019982950761914253, 0.02052597887814045, 0.05266985297203064, 0.03557027876377106, 0.02002021111547947, 0.0030539522413164377, 0.012151720002293587, 0.0210739653557539, 0.03264698013663292, -0.014213652350008488, 0.04167690500617027, -0.02267291769385338, 0.02404353953897953, 0.004286888986825943, 0.0060348487459123135, -0.007108892314136028, 0.026957161724567413, -0.03315813094377518, -0.04528677836060524, 0.014832481741905212, 0.03287230432033539, 0.006928174290806055, -0.002207012614235282, -0.015120601281523705, 0.002961404388770461, -0.044563669711351395, 0.010449245572090149, 0.046684253960847855, 0.0066152880899608135, -0.029106540605425835, -0.013628522865474224, -0.023413747549057007, -0.02853427827358246, -0.05868765711784363, -0.01625746861100197, 0.04091457277536392, -0.005750004202127457, 0.013777811080217361, -0.009961183182895184, 0.018690796568989754, 0.0221305713057518, -0.020432502031326294, 0.06986348330974579, 0.061721522361040115, 0.013956291601061821, -0.013565774075686932, -0.038698889315128326, -0.01268624048680067, -0.008056175895035267, 0.02256893739104271, 0.02774406038224697, -0.03576841577887535, -0.026631740853190422, 0.03771943598985672, 0.016557538881897926, 0.0055592674762010574, 0.005571888759732246, 0.03365008160471916, 0.0133875897154212, -0.003523139515891671, -0.11288920044898987, -0.06344851851463318, 0.015377327799797058, -0.0089570302516222, 0.0027621432673186064, -0.01031691674143076, 0.0025888215750455856, 0.006971456576138735, 0.050576016306877136, 0.028526965528726578, 0.0702316164970398, 0.024060377851128578, 0.007785774301737547, 0.059197816997766495, -0.019412437453866005, -0.0019319632556289434, -0.04067140817642212, 0.0009880412835627794, -0.025770867243409157, -0.0887194350361824, 0.007518315687775612, -0.001925374730490148, -0.008265074342489243, 0.012970670126378536, 0.04068682715296745, 0.027374377474188805, -0.0096936896443367, -0.008638506755232811, 0.0021479774732142687, -0.04633661359548569, 0.03793419525027275, 0.009918980300426483, 0.06594143062829971, 0.013254978694021702, -0.02018299698829651, -0.010621689260005951, 0.02977108210325241, 0.045886434614658356, 0.02342800982296467, -0.051776643842458725, 0.0036898120306432247, -0.04278004169464111, -0.0036270676646381617, 0.026021156460046768, -0.06562188267707825, -0.018006425350904465, -0.030443822965025902, 0.014268831349909306, 0.006529336795210838, 0.014115785248577595, 0.019073259085416794, -0.0193040631711483, 0.011869040317833424, -0.05076023191213608, -0.04986393824219704, -0.07106048613786697, -0.03883883357048035, -0.008589817211031914, -0.01765969768166542, 0.03892522305250168, -0.008386626839637756, -0.009939619340002537, 0.005740748252719641, -0.008209409192204475, -0.04167265444993973, 0.023790203034877777, 0.042677175253629684, -0.03158470615744591, 0.026124119758605957, 0.03986369073390961, 0.05315113440155983, -0.0022985534742474556, 0.04830043017864227, -0.03957556188106537, -0.032271504402160645, 0.018735017627477646, -0.03652237728238106, -0.014658098109066486, -0.006933975964784622, -0.013883098028600216, 0.011211720295250416, -0.022730089724063873, -0.03361913189291954, 0.027522968128323555, -0.06159509718418121, 0.031871113926172256, 0.081572525203228, -0.011825763620436192, -0.034311238676309586, 0.030028030276298523, -0.024106444790959358, 0.02990051917731762, -0.025687430053949356, -0.013596849516034126, -0.036975663155317307, -0.01299646683037281, 0.03340557590126991, 0.053327176719903946, -0.034805115312337875, 0.012753674760460854, 0.07662517577409744, -0.012584410607814789, -0.002695501083508134, 0.0348268486559391, -0.03141695261001587, -0.0020720132160931826, 0.0008308525430038571, -0.02851570025086403, 0.03444249555468559, -0.0016978055937215686, -0.029279418289661407, 0.00029444671235978603, 0.02853955700993538, -0.024748384952545166, 0.011768135242164135, 0.0602639764547348, 0.010330296121537685, -0.026009451597929, -0.04226451739668846, -0.03150589019060135, 0.03691762313246727, -0.007690363097935915, 0.007639831863343716, 0.02778417244553566, -0.005562132224440575, 0.019860530272126198, 0.006820198614150286, 0.010340822860598564, 0.008028686977922916, 0.03745710849761963, -0.029555171728134155, -0.01651242934167385, 0.020106205716729164, -0.03229190409183502, 0.009502936154603958, -0.03398523107171059, -0.02273070253431797, -0.02452484332025051, 0.011657293885946274, 0.015365304425358772, 0.01940612494945526, 0.03241848945617676, -0.024481510743498802, 0.00021556434512604028, 0.007675881497561932, -0.0014592852676287293, 0.03943449258804321, 0.007980276830494404, -0.031336262822151184, -0.006016815081238747, -0.0632757842540741, 0.001556757721118629, 0.031799159944057465, 0.048446957021951675, -0.04479852318763733, 0.02445056661963463, 0.01268026977777481, -0.06563355773687363, -0.06266029179096222, -0.025998735800385475, -0.005446862895041704, -0.00801494438201189, -0.036264076828956604, 0.07337699830532074, 0.02848787233233452, -0.05074391886591911, 0.0375223346054554, -0.0021717874333262444, -0.004057418089359999, -0.024404995143413544, -0.0020406043622642756, 0.018847910687327385, -0.006232761312276125, 0.006089175119996071, 0.02333059348165989, 0.02912946045398712, -0.02059464156627655, -0.08209840953350067, -0.02846357226371765, 0.02200564555823803, 0.014933757483959198, 0.03868284076452255, 0.017190255224704742, -0.030158299952745438, 0.09861685335636139, 0.039605166763067245, 0.018189314752817154, -0.032434843480587006, -0.002056864555925131, -0.046266037970781326, 0.027897978201508522, 0.004729047883301973, -0.0184315238147974, 0.0004463644581846893, 0.029064906761050224, -0.03285319358110428, 0.02397232875227928, 0.045927323400974274, -0.026609333232045174, 0.018938126042485237, -0.009521282278001308, 0.005932344123721123, -0.011973707936704159, 0.05230966582894325, -0.02632795460522175, 0.0021600271575152874, -0.03287481144070625, 0.011201847344636917, 0.011131704784929752, 0.028997506946325302, -0.06028854846954346, 0.007408305071294308, -0.018605362623929977, -0.022861532866954803, -0.04717085510492325, 0.06140568479895592, 0.026510635390877724, -0.05272839218378067, -0.01486855000257492, 0.016816435381770134, 0.03898637369275093, -0.02024703472852707, 0.006182690151035786, 0.030724525451660156, 0.05801812559366226, -0.025741590186953545, -0.0169193334877491, -0.004608477465808392, -0.0003859447024296969, 0.02191730961203575, -0.06264065206050873, 0.0031281106639653444, -0.006926410831511021, 0.050205133855342865, 0.01687834970653057, -0.003217441728338599, 0.001814675168134272, -0.01670026034116745, -0.008133296854794025, 0.03572997450828552, -0.021228594705462456, 0.0740036815404892, 0.006240525748580694, 0.07630927115678787, -0.034566909074783325, -0.025578463450074196, 0.013762008398771286, -0.021353714168071747, -0.05391792953014374, 0.03725996986031532, 0.009666072204709053, -0.04414849355816841, 0.03344172611832619, -0.031945012509822845, 0.06022615730762482, -0.026600999757647514, 0.01813170500099659, -0.029421672224998474, 0.02241702564060688, -0.0022670964244753122, 0.03758088871836662, -0.04260912537574768, -0.031625401228666306, 0.009348202496767044, 0.014051564037799835, -0.002112522255629301, -0.040803976356983185, 0.01919686049222946, 0.024773137643933296, -0.0003567477688193321, 0.035968903452157974, -0.014640828594565392, 0.02070319466292858, 0.026670686900615692, 0.034561701118946075, 0.0420847162604332, 0.0382845476269722, -0.04005306214094162, 0.005086942575871944, 0.022581880912184715, 0.05446348339319229, 0.06299256533384323, -0.014436088502407074, -0.01659206487238407, -0.01211419515311718, -0.005086290650069714, 0.0021040495485067368, -0.000701577344443649, 0.01828494481742382, -0.01350456289947033, 0.05559134855866432, 0.01951436512172222, -0.043374158442020416, 0.01889679953455925, 0.030906977131962776, 0.01652872934937477, 0.05054232105612755, -0.018150221556425095, 0.008383280597627163, -0.0018103825859725475, -0.004299964755773544, 0.03902995213866234, -0.0024510102812200785, -0.0026913986075669527, -0.021592317149043083, 0.07610944658517838, 0.026589410379529, -0.041115932166576385, 0.05465444177389145, 0.053338684141635895, 0.015794042497873306, 0.01928044855594635, -0.044808678328990936, -0.012174153700470924, 0.022699283435940742, 0.034166041761636734, -0.003810635069385171, 0.01083703525364399, -0.06440158188343048, -0.03609508275985718, 0.027759168297052383, 0.0017764257499948144, -0.0700811818242073, 0.0021600336767733097, -0.04890482500195503, -0.01096280850470066, 0.01451949868351221, -0.028177518397569656, 0.03164152055978775, 0.03096713125705719, 0.002503908472135663, -0.02424398623406887, 0.007123270072042942, -0.08913341164588928, 0.01937064714729786, -0.020853957161307335, 0.017832310870289803, -0.02854449488222599, -0.047803450375795364, -0.02258896641433239, -0.003105543088167906, 0.023045770823955536, 0.0757264792919159, -0.055499784648418427, -0.031822558492422104, -0.003982861060649157, -0.0013182254042476416, -0.00400021905079484, -0.06357074528932571, 0.008089624345302582, 0.025977177545428276, -0.007230519317090511, 0.05503571778535843, -0.0027663768269121647, -0.047710467129945755, 0.021354973316192627, 0.010988124646246433, -0.021842150017619133, -0.02132110856473446, -0.024899087846279144, 0.022659936919808388, 0.021425889804959297, 0.014126021414995193, 0.06268511712551117, 0.010449588298797607, -0.018683047965168953, 0.019811267033219337, -0.05014360323548317, -0.028615253046154976, -0.028999539092183113, -0.013519616797566414, -0.07455934584140778, 0.016202446073293686, -0.04592590779066086, 0.0276320930570364, -0.008960388600826263, 0.03191979229450226, 0.000015168262507359032, -0.033152174204587936, 0.017642902210354805, 0.05494941025972366, -0.03821065276861191, 0.014239720068871975, -0.023772219195961952, 0.019748443737626076, -0.014212078414857388, 0.004021549131721258, 0.006836299784481525, 0.0010106592671945691, -0.009726851247251034, 0.027881434187293053, -0.06140934303402901, 0.010898821987211704, -0.025752700865268707, -0.007720625959336758, -0.02205653488636017, -0.004351786337792873, 0.013825835660099983, 0.024046730250120163, 0.020663723349571228, -0.004446463659405708, -0.02228105440735817, -0.014398065395653248, -0.005305345635861158, -0.012384232133626938, 0.02110588364303112, -0.007720177061855793, 0.02395666018128395, 0.03425642102956772, -0.01024039275944233, -0.06353900581598282, -0.024395236745476723, 0.012772136367857456, -0.0010198913514614105, -0.019644543528556824, -0.013709232211112976, 0.017896175384521484, 0.017239227890968323, -0.044756930321455, 0.002395079704001546, 0.050240978598594666, -0.02199721336364746, -0.012966776266694069, -0.00460688304156065, 0.04262813553214073, 0.0445605032145977, -0.025941794738173485, 0.023007448762655258, -0.0051853954792022705, -0.014303844422101974, -0.014540313743054867, 0.015046254731714725, 0.00014755276788491756, -0.03822886198759079, -0.03754636272788048, -0.05763625726103783, -0.006301776971668005, 0.033184219151735306, 0.006203736178576946, -0.010638202540576458, 0.02626100182533264, 0.03417762368917465, -0.01566723920404911, -0.04071274399757385, -0.05609649792313576, 0.0011292585404589772, 0.016156792640686035, -0.02275785617530346, 0.0046917712315917015, -0.00427594967186451, 0.0151444086804986, 0.037291716784238815, 0.002889504423364997, -0.024822236970067024, 0.012881370261311531, 0.07548592984676361, -0.021867502480745316, -0.0006908584618940949, -0.002087637083604932, -0.04412535950541496, 0.0330599844455719, 0.023514339700341225, -0.014653879217803478, 0.04225064814090729, 0.014020067639648914, -0.040029898285865784, -0.013182203285396099, -0.03036138415336609, 0.010412738658487797, 0.03821738436818123, 0.0011180220171809196, 0.01727503165602684, 0.03491108492016792, -0.0023448793217539787, -0.007993626408278942, -0.01625785231590271, -0.0069183544255793095, -0.013699175789952278, -0.0006938365404494107, 0.021528976038098335, 0.03312886133790016, -0.04075237736105919, 0.039251554757356644, 0.016956597566604614, -0.00957147590816021, 0.01693841442465782, 0.001532218768261373, 0.037970270961523056, 0.024111250415444374, -0.03002891317009926, -0.01631416752934456, 0.03516027331352234, -0.04124821349978447, 0.005843939259648323, -0.043370701372623444, -0.027429068461060524, 0.01766001619398594, 0.07534033060073853, 0.014978926628828049, -0.05421365797519684, -0.01667959801852703, -0.06290396302938461, -0.005073418375104666, -0.0015285903355106711, -0.0077203926630318165, 0.02282230742275715, 0.0132314907386899, 0.033897124230861664, -0.018090439960360527, 0.04841332137584686, -0.03347389027476311, -0.07556331902742386, 0.005173219833523035, -0.0023976454976946115, -0.04044785350561142, 0.047481659799814224, -0.030457276850938797, -0.017065707594156265, 0.040164850652217865, -0.043558333069086075, 0.04376302659511566, 0.02915634773671627, 0.013106301426887512, -0.028415586799383163, 0.05377404764294624, 0.013750758022069931, -0.0044884649105370045, 0.006115125957876444, -0.019374128431081772, 0.12575870752334595, 0.08653143793344498, 0.02945207618176937, -0.0637449249625206, 0.008849781937897205, 0.016896052286028862, 0.006090896669775248, -0.01124196220189333, 0.0020497343502938747, 0.029626499861478806, -0.012448232620954514, 0.03742150589823723, 0.02813795953989029, -0.023032162338495255, -0.002963908715173602, 0.034876443445682526, -0.022067135199904442, 0.017652373760938644, -0.025222323834896088, -0.0014700526371598244, -0.003850922454148531, 0.006183345802128315, -0.013204879127442837, -0.016008153557777405, -0.04342629387974739, -0.0015109332744032145, -0.007519346196204424, -0.022221025079488754, -0.007731134537607431, 0.00006873541133245453, -0.05099702626466751, -0.0008565617026761174, 0.007842816412448883, 0.012367376126348972, -0.0010274179512634873, 0.05321186035871506, 0.007198397070169449, -0.017040260136127472, 0.029947299510240555, 0.04787304252386093, -0.012095881626009941, 0.012389691546559334, 0.010857897810637951, -0.008887766860425472, -0.035253316164016724, -0.043598584830760956, -0.06583222001791, 0.05010208860039711, -0.010687400586903095, -0.03068609908223152, -0.015220526605844498, -0.0077986037358641624, 0.011437606997787952, -0.019584378227591515, 0.00430758111178875, 0.04584379121661186, -0.008462846279144287, -0.05806494131684303, -0.028662025928497314, -0.02952096238732338, 0.02043209597468376, 0.0055139134638011456, 0.028932416811585426, 0.02536933310329914, -0.05482226610183716, -0.06147022545337677, 0.0143005745485425, 0.024209754541516304, 0.01783037930727005, 0.009616955183446407, 0.005972403101623058, 0.004381598439067602, -0.017274999991059303, -0.03895403817296028, 0.017050981521606445, -0.009958566166460514, 0.05217243731021881, -0.0282242763787508, -0.0008531798957847059, -0.03262363374233246, -0.04160922020673752, 0.0262981615960598, -0.01345568522810936, 0.026416270062327385, -0.050205424427986145, -0.015084846876561642, -0.008129126392304897, 0.03076067753136158, 0.01800386980175972, -0.009398508816957474, 0.022647330537438393, 0.05083492025732994, 0.02120589092373848, -0.07373397797346115, -0.05295690521597862, 0.009340615943074226, -0.014034486375749111, -0.009277023375034332, -0.02112790197134018, 0.05269310623407364, 0.0428072065114975, 0.047181904315948486, -0.018815316259860992, 0.020990794524550438, 0.006922612432390451, 0.02660263516008854, 0.006001332774758339, -0.024485120549798012, -0.004713875707238913, 0.047278307378292084, 0.017242304980754852, -0.0007558792713098228, 0.008418967016041279, -0.024727225303649902, -0.06811905652284622, -0.015244847163558006, -0.035843342542648315, -0.01121195126324892, -0.007627369835972786, -0.03497208654880524, 0.024252239614725113, -0.021955514326691628, -0.051357120275497437, -0.004045919980853796, 0.028473801910877228, 0.025486251339316368, 0.010974726639688015, -0.019735194742679596, -0.00671938294544816, -0.03597245365381241, -0.010391836985945702, 0.031738150864839554, 0.027741704136133194, 0.020168133080005646, 0.005806251894682646, 0.011992257088422775, 0.0014557689428329468, 0.0057822889648377895, -0.0054066856391727924, -0.01495382096618414, 0.04523632675409317, -0.015365946106612682, -0.03516378253698349, 0.03129486367106438, -0.0025767190381884575, 0.05811091884970665, 0.025233691558241844, 0.01003590039908886, -0.030735736712813377, 0.021052084863185883, -0.03913342207670212, -0.005759584717452526, -0.05693681165575981, 0.005212229210883379, -0.007235780358314514, -0.020301220938563347, 0.00793504435569048, 0.023616019636392593, 0.022023407742381096, 0.026416106149554253, 0.03605261817574501, -0.011877099983394146, -0.009167781099677086, 0.016080789268016815, -0.01855507306754589, 0.025216443464159966, 0.006760345306247473, 0.019496753811836243, 0.0023728522937744856, 0.032098278403282166, -0.026738241314888, 0.04017750918865204, -0.016825055703520775, -0.008120584301650524, -0.0978030189871788, -0.046565230935811996, 0.00284455600194633, 0.02368742972612381, 0.03766297176480293, -0.02318384312093258, -0.03183577209711075, 0.02149450220167637, 0.0002831851306837052, 0.025570938363671303, -0.0022804448381066322, 0.010289126075804234, -0.0074733891524374485, 0.03643916919827461, -0.031891513615846634, -0.023319214582443237, 0.04106999188661575, 0.0025022877380251884, 0.021767910569906235, 0.050273265689611435, 0.03012777678668499, 0.00034749164478853345, -0.011352204717695713, -0.009687963873147964, 0.03142424672842026, -0.05748654529452324, 0.05259071663022041, -0.047821324318647385, -0.019265396520495415, 0.05370904505252838, 0.013803881593048573, 0.02528851479291916, 0.0029628807678818703, 0.0014023927506059408, -0.009235811419785023, 0.02077661082148552, 0.007335057947784662, -0.0005525622400455177, 0.002641713945195079, -0.028439674526453018, 0.02182362787425518, 0.02948312647640705, 0.006231328472495079, 0.03863820806145668, 0.04378907382488251, -0.008226875215768814, -0.018783561885356903, 0.05757831037044525, 0.025296494364738464, -0.037683434784412384, 0.027627060189843178, 0.040699802339076996, -0.0190263781696558, -0.01161223091185093, 0.008743420243263245, -0.044466789811849594, 0.004065605346113443, 0.03271186351776123, 0.026410629972815514, -0.038424793630838394, 0.02244575321674347, -0.022968372330069542, -0.04194631427526474, 0.05202464759349823, -0.01790853589773178, -0.003296205075457692, -0.08162791281938553, -0.01741068996489048, 0.027947664260864258, 0.01482807844877243, -0.01480631809681654, -0.007705962285399437, -0.02439533732831478, 0.038426488637924194, -0.024097872897982597, -0.007103797048330307, -0.015377338975667953, 0.015555963851511478, -0.015273593366146088, -0.07343822717666626, 0.08166482299566269, -0.0025860609021037817, -0.06223994120955467, -0.020727070048451424, -0.006314278580248356, -0.033891141414642334, 0.007493147626519203, 0.029810918495059013, 0.05791438743472099, -0.022847963497042656, -0.029958326369524002, 0.0493130162358284, 0.022614337503910065, -0.07030376046895981, 0.04405713081359863, -0.003966073971241713, 0.011511645279824734, -0.02368190325796604, 0.002863794332370162, -0.001127318711951375, 0.025090238079428673, 0.026943495497107506, -0.035941626876592636, 0.04546205326914787, 0.0256173238158226, 0.01588289439678192, 0.026353443041443825, 0.0019088252447545528, 0.022574935108423233, 0.07871995866298676, 0.008488721214234829, 0.031488459557294846, 0.0008405361440964043, -0.0049276454374194145, -0.047027792781591415, 0.002748888684436679, 0.007564876694232225, -0.04061977565288544, -0.026087302714586258, -0.027064431458711624, -0.014322159811854362, -0.056751325726509094, -0.029980160295963287, 0.021860511973500252, -0.013140260241925716, 0.018836883828043938, 0.019577203318476677, 0.033346232026815414, 0.025433242321014404, 0.004148881882429123, 0.015345457009971142, -0.0009871200891211629, -0.03736959025263786, -0.0018978731241077185, 0.004100481513887644, 0.025906285271048546, 0.006677114870399237, 0.014508550986647606, 0.03558573126792908, -0.003300627926364541, -0.0031857036519795656, -0.022372359409928322, 0.035115595906972885, -0.010409090667963028, -0.03079005517065525, 0.06913367658853531, -0.024505240842700005, -0.006620029453188181, -0.010897775180637836, -0.0118195079267025, 0.05085120350122452, -0.05126971751451492, 0.009309506043791771, -0.023623041808605194, -0.006796082481741905, -0.03933681175112724, 0.010320623405277729, -0.022557081654667854, 0.015954377129673958, 0.037852782756090164, 0.03054806962609291, -0.000632238807156682, -0.03176446631550789, 0.012798895128071308, -0.02734457515180111, -0.0024660665076225996, 0.049592357128858566, -0.011881434358656406, -0.019285645335912704, -0.06113790348172188, 0.0009169188560917974, -0.069610096514225, 0.04573352262377739, 0.025966938585042953, 0.007140265312045813, -0.0389016754925251, -0.04720177873969078, -0.0008739575860090554, 0.04882871359586716, -0.03642575070261955, -0.000030430850529228337, -0.00047674321103841066, 0.03255387768149376, -0.0133304912596941, -0.06253466010093689 ]
<p>Presumably this has been discussed already, but I wanted to get some sense of how prevalent is the use of R for biostatistics publications. On PubMed I did find a number of research papers that were conducted using R (as mentioned in the Methods or Statistical Analysis sections of the documents). However, the majority were done using SAS/SPSS and also an appreciable number using Stata.</p> <p>There has been a lot of talk about R in recent years and I am looking for some data that can corroborate the fact that R has been rising in popularity in the commercial area. In my experience, however, I have been seeing some resistance for firms to switch to R from SAS, even though there is so much more that you can do with R compared to SAS. There is also the concern that FDA "prefers results in SAS" ... although I have not seen anything officially mentioned by FDA to this effect.</p> <p>I understand that SAS has been there for decades, it is what many R&amp;D departments are most comfortable working with, etc., etc., ... and am looking for real-world examples of who are instead using R for professional research and/or publications.</p>
73,678
[ -0.016269737854599953, 0.021872369572520256, -0.020883353427052498, -0.03423234820365906, 0.010846221819519997, 0.016637500375509262, 0.003425030969083309, -0.005453477613627911, 0.02430301159620285, -0.0393529087305069, 0.017106207087635994, 0.05142303183674812, 0.036403588950634, 0.015157015062868595, 0.008708215318620205, 0.009235926903784275, -0.00789934117347002, 0.026651374995708466, -0.012903380207717419, 0.03227154165506363, 0.04725754261016846, 0.008250715211033821, 0.0032008218113332987, -0.02053101919591427, -0.01925070397555828, 0.0423487089574337, -0.016099341213703156, -0.04723767191171646, 0.0008317452156916261, 0.04091499745845795, -0.02335132099688053, 0.002436608774587512, 0.005932564847171307, 0.028998641297221184, 0.02898751012980938, -0.0024663943331688643, -0.0028988386038690805, -0.051246341317892075, -0.012597189284861088, 0.06673026829957962, -0.07190901041030884, -0.0022118641063570976, -0.001558097661472857, 0.008109118789434433, -0.017728721722960472, 0.030547214671969414, -0.007771700620651245, -0.01111376378685236, 0.02125457674264908, -0.054813988506793976, 0.06314633041620255, 0.0023959209211170673, 0.028293265029788017, 0.01624600775539875, -0.030149800702929497, 0.03261304646730423, 0.03843565285205841, 0.007881305180490017, 0.03274836391210556, -0.05479764938354492, -0.006634259130805731, -0.01556171290576458, -0.0011225034249946475, -0.014266500249505043, -0.03703393414616585, -0.013167214579880238, -0.00394770922139287, -0.004778733476996422, 0.04552140459418297, -0.02974572405219078, 0.03455687686800957, 0.021036546677350998, 0.011319709941744804, 0.03409726545214653, -0.008315964601933956, -0.0372268445789814, -0.0011049520689994097, -0.009025354869663715, 0.041551146656274796, 0.045864664018154144, -0.014188162051141262, -0.00699120108038187, 0.02288426086306572, 0.03638894110918045, -0.014886999502778053, -0.041228894144296646, 0.05106966197490692, -0.030399024486541748, 0.013567689806222916, 0.008134479634463787, 0.025360921397805214, -0.013257551938295364, 0.0695415809750557, 0.02885998785495758, -0.028318019583821297, 0.03194500505924225, -0.018101735040545464, 0.08226132392883301, -0.02091558836400509, -0.014823123812675476, -0.0016116033075377345, -0.04253846034407616, 0.0148574598133564, 0.06935448944568634, -0.0392179898917675, -0.06321431696414948, -0.0003501628234516829, -0.02937493287026882, -0.0059427316300570965, -0.02386794053018093, -0.04572805389761925, 0.0014161837752908468, 0.02821812778711319, 0.0001989504526136443, 0.009229282848536968, -0.01938096061348915, -0.0013178266817703843, 0.004207140300422907, 0.06866105645895004, 0.1033177375793457, 0.04355184733867645, -0.008136376738548279, 0.021607408300042152, 0.006766559090465307, -0.01781364157795906, 0.029891571030020714, 0.015449577942490578, -0.04858564957976341, -0.06121399998664856, 0.054271914064884186, -0.004599756561219692, -0.038838859647512436, 0.03827110305428505, 0.0056714266538619995, 0.01937139593064785, -0.003601222997531295, -0.07968892902135849, -0.0621749646961689, 0.03908068314194679, 0.0111243212595582, 0.017730940133333206, -0.05134906992316246, 0.016774090006947517, 0.005088204517960548, 0.03598715737462044, -0.010530445724725723, 0.028790520504117012, 0.03725990653038025, 0.0406113862991333, -0.021035917103290558, -0.017139142379164696, -0.028736507520079613, 0.00442504370585084, -0.0276578851044178, -0.017660923302173615, -0.056556932628154755, 0.018876640126109123, 0.0040243882685899734, -0.011887635104358196, -0.02549733594059944, 0.004145372658967972, 0.015424223616719246, -0.014153561554849148, -0.007325398735702038, -0.0033403304405510426, -0.013245516456663609, 0.05456224083900452, -0.047895316034555435, 0.02437352016568184, 0.005825090687721968, 0.00945245660841465, 0.0325249545276165, 0.04167277365922928, 0.011870650574564934, 0.030534515157341957, -0.031151525676250458, 0.027283165603876114, 0.03938783332705498, -0.017132651060819626, 0.008741124533116817, -0.04980790615081787, -0.0060998424887657166, 0.0036886525340378284, -0.047655314207077026, 0.037384506314992905, 0.050598978996276855, -0.006871784571558237, -0.008899114094674587, 0.087916299700737, -0.05377025157213211, -0.02306962199509144, -0.05560080707073212, -0.022694455459713936, -0.03258076310157776, -0.031309157609939575, -0.004892157390713692, 0.024871932342648506, -0.0017934320494532585, 0.006832879036664963, -0.016476688906550407, -0.0015127805527299643, -0.026218082755804062, 0.041553791612386703, -0.014835190959274769, -0.027035806328058243, 0.03328812122344971, 0.00763970660045743, -0.048776183277368546, 0.005468251183629036, -0.04039652645587921, -0.07720701396465302, 0.004415904171764851, -0.02850591391324997, 0.03680489584803581, -0.0008139843703247607, -0.05176260322332382, 0.0022683884017169476, -0.007894488982856274, -0.0675090029835701, 0.05075876787304878, -0.05701972916722298, 0.032876089215278625, 0.03520655632019043, 0.03653330355882645, 0.009432169608771801, 0.06479557603597641, 0.011314994655549526, 0.0016093321610242128, 0.0015121271135285497, -0.017339322715997696, -0.042424120008945465, 0.003891855012625456, 0.0717703178524971, 0.02544834092259407, -0.029525863006711006, 0.022515468299388885, 0.04970134049654007, 0.021642470732331276, 0.027099447324872017, 0.04461107403039932, -0.006135388743132353, -0.052903227508068085, 0.017943283542990685, -0.0006355665973387659, 0.02596602402627468, -0.013147733174264431, -0.01658717915415764, 0.009053099900484085, 0.07871584594249725, 0.05731598660349846, -0.02921995334327221, 0.06573669612407684, 0.011688466183841228, -0.012442021630704403, 0.01042449101805687, -0.016046101227402687, 0.06406047940254211, -0.053960930556058884, 0.0032026784028857946, 0.031284574419260025, 0.030154699459671974, 0.01437113806605339, 0.020233286544680595, -0.027638958767056465, 0.010663348250091076, 0.023314164951443672, -0.019008856266736984, 0.011172773316502571, -0.007157465908676386, -0.039640530943870544, -0.005262314807623625, -0.05971311405301094, -0.009733662940561771, -0.01926003396511078, 0.005729481112211943, -0.02232413925230503, -0.01953711546957493, 0.017792191356420517, 0.001319080125540495, 0.0122121162712574, 0.03346090391278267, -0.034947801381349564, 0.015410427004098892, -0.0013369785156100988, -0.03870278596878052, 0.0140494704246521, -0.02385692298412323, -0.027972320094704628, 0.02909705601632595, -0.05388319864869118, -0.05387716367840767, 0.0009261798113584518, -0.0033152075484395027, -0.07916340231895447, -0.010782807134091854, 0.02217733860015869, 0.0062654223293066025, -0.007070525549352169, -0.020665494725108147, 0.02308192476630211, 0.0014441835228353739, -0.004235588014125824, -0.005587687250226736, -0.004769584629684687, -0.009958982467651367, -0.017048578709363937, 0.02762734331190586, 0.017873696982860565, 0.009357016533613205, -0.023524662479758263, 0.037477802485227585, -0.04339214786887169, -0.03203161060810089, -0.03744184598326683, -0.046031735837459564, 0.025843210518360138, -0.0038029414135962725, 0.051796574145555496, -0.0189727284014225, 0.0037464387714862823, 0.06634943187236786, 0.012477667070925236, -0.023054201155900955, -0.02637133188545704, -0.01425084751099348, -0.04362519457936287, -0.03358176350593567, 0.04090768098831177, 0.01694231666624546, 0.006329780910164118, 0.015284094959497452, -0.01011561881750822, 0.011502068489789963, 0.037197452038526535, 0.01138334721326828, 0.014743929728865623, 0.01312060933560133, 0.016753453761339188, -0.0108475461602211, 0.02568359486758709, 0.032266050577163696, -0.001949124038219452, -0.00878111645579338, -0.015267177484929562, 0.004308538511395454, 0.0028563914820551872, -0.036613766103982925, -0.006904060952365398, -0.03133048489689827, 0.021206332370638847, 0.0012881818693131208, -0.030421601608395576, 0.02035706676542759, 0.009008266031742096, 0.005409957375377417, 0.053137294948101044, 0.01068027876317501, -0.02729671075940132, -0.0004942312370985746, 0.02594129741191864, 0.021735724061727524, -0.006746746599674225, 0.013933394104242325, -0.021468067541718483, -0.01664348691701889, 0.03948114439845085, -0.01583251729607582, -0.02752162702381611, 0.03804580122232437, 0.028819648548960686, 0.021876582875847816, -0.038400404155254364, -0.06031521409749985, 0.019987257197499275, -0.05711033195257187, -0.014306379482150078, -0.046753305941820145, 0.05757766216993332, -0.0018964214250445366, 0.06480225920677185, -0.027376268059015274, -0.018250182271003723, -0.0011234221747145057, -0.024648750200867653, -0.0440172478556633, -0.015216931700706482, -0.05274203047156334, 0.036831021308898926, 0.015841437503695488, 0.010425426065921783, 0.02679290808737278, 0.034301575273275375, -0.007733907550573349, -0.03963654488325119, 0.02984352596104145, -0.02438463270664215, 0.002690688008442521, 0.01876872405409813, -0.02294081635773182, -0.011884178034961224, -0.010621024295687675, -0.02938600815832615, -0.027338188141584396, 0.01710369437932968, 0.020873310044407845, 0.005868704989552498, -0.027103710919618607, -0.03263942524790764, 0.02874251827597618, 0.032208893448114395, 0.04272637516260147, 0.025186797603964806, 0.007116357795894146, -0.03949291631579399, 0.06285545974969864, 0.0022480785846710205, 0.035292476415634155, 0.01133022177964449, -0.01962868683040142, -0.025467664003372192, -0.05000703036785126, -0.0192483551800251, -0.0025852001272141933, 0.0012718291254714131, 0.010751361027359962, -0.017905371263623238, 0.05080871284008026, 0.01403831783682108, -0.040834348648786545, -0.017339924350380898, 0.062256406992673874, 0.015614297240972519, 0.030787762254476547, -0.007240319158881903, -0.014352286234498024, -0.0036508699413388968, -0.014203179627656937, 0.04816403612494469, 0.0346919447183609, 0.00159051816444844, 0.022504590451717377, 0.0030041332356631756, -0.0033409674651920795, -0.028618382290005684, 0.0017070460598915815, 0.033605024218559265, 0.04666683450341225, 0.015979159623384476, -0.018128925934433937, 0.012939478270709515, 0.059080418199300766, 0.05024733394384384, 0.035734836012125015, 0.014323175884783268, -0.05026654899120331, 0.03249247372150421, 0.05598288029432297, 0.03971092030405998, -0.057265251874923706, -0.011426279321312904, -0.021768536418676376, 0.010057918727397919, 0.045888885855674744, -0.020383669063448906, 0.006283990573137999, -0.05197678506374359, 0.0025205868296325207, -0.007554262410849333, -0.041332174092531204, 0.004748388193547726, -0.030646223574876785, -0.0035217306576669216, 0.00794060155749321, 0.01843087188899517, -0.01874392479658127, -0.02846967987716198, -0.02416807971894741, 0.01338222622871399, 0.03528951480984688, -0.015128927305340767, -0.02604772336781025, 0.03690636530518532, 0.06224270910024643, -0.02079549804329872, -0.03778109699487686, -0.0018962712492793798, 0.046342913061380386, 0.013952340930700302, 0.0652168020606041, -0.007981695234775543, -0.030807992443442345, 0.0014145511668175459, -0.011756970547139645, -0.023130135610699654, 0.012041011825203896, -0.003657449269667268, 0.01193732675164938, 0.051964666694402695, -0.018201444298028946, 0.05151432380080223, 0.032999638468027115, 0.042216621339321136, -0.004100157879292965, -0.03240833431482315, 0.004788369871675968, -0.022052189335227013, -0.04719279333949089, -0.028597742319107056, -0.006109611131250858, -0.03203027322888374, 0.0016822331817820668, 0.006043901201337576, 0.037909649312496185, -0.04840071499347687, 0.002190918894484639, 0.010580935515463352, 0.01762722060084343, -0.020106127485632896, -0.005732722580432892, 0.02848062478005886, 0.018929975107312202, -0.005760618951171637, -0.013271193020045757, 0.0240144245326519, 0.013538211584091187, -0.028590908274054527, 0.03617378696799278, -0.04797421395778656, -0.003892212873324752, -0.013043135404586792, -0.04657474160194397, 0.017196422442793846, -0.026304088532924652, 0.038942381739616394, -0.02843153290450573, 0.034592535346746445, -0.008014481514692307, -0.060475196689367294, -0.01745707541704178, 0.033166781067848206, 0.0027044075541198254, -0.0022410873789340258, -0.052620045840740204, 0.04249186813831329, -0.07491184026002884, -0.010436912067234516, -0.05318780615925789, -0.0662597119808197, 0.024971742182970047, 0.0010909154079854488, -0.014994866214692593, 0.0003858002310153097, 0.05893914774060249, -0.010496404021978378, -0.021760473027825356, -0.024122396484017372, 0.053911179304122925, -0.03453461825847626, 0.013338727876543999, -0.016351154074072838, 0.03059864044189453, 0.07131562381982803, -0.03460531309247017, 0.005437138956040144, 0.007144259754568338, 0.01364967506378889, 0.02349063754081726, 0.0035960185341537, 0.04356047883629799, -0.026672150939702988, 0.0073618413880467415, -0.028812898322939873, -0.028877148404717445, 0.018935855478048325, 0.002032672520726919, 0.034540869295597076, 0.026495283469557762, -0.02874523214995861, 0.020125210285186768, -0.020027751103043556, 0.027151059359312057, -0.027530737221240997, 0.01856960915029049, -0.04478132724761963, 0.0058796703815460205, -0.01476737204939127, 0.018917137756943703, 0.019745949655771255, 0.013453913852572441, 0.026208799332380295, 0.013396332040429115, 0.06388194113969803, 0.02875472791492939, 0.023999957367777824, -0.013010128401219845, -0.020509449765086174, 0.019569382071495056, -0.002593897981569171, 0.0303596630692482, -0.003888373961672187, -0.0008643432520329952, -0.03316737338900566, -0.06562545150518417, -0.013072237372398376, -0.02139991894364357, 0.04335879534482956, -0.002225290983915329, 0.009636417031288147, 0.04074699431657791, -0.06180029734969139, -0.017440032213926315, -0.05826400965452194, 0.01958329975605011, -0.03484734147787094, 0.009478729218244553, 0.045608799904584885, 0.037009064108133316, -0.012027207762002945, 0.008607073687016964, 0.0125637361779809, 0.02983645163476467, 0.024328209459781647, 0.015562119893729687, 0.050036560744047165, -0.014816882088780403, -0.047185078263282776, -0.04414435476064682, 0.02332446165382862, -0.047646865248680115, 0.0314970463514328, -0.00986897386610508, -0.04215668514370918, 0.05026719719171524, -0.01677127182483673, 0.004761468153446913, -0.06584039330482483, -0.010925253853201866, -0.020522242411971092, 0.012175993993878365, -0.007591872941702604, -0.04712650552392006, 0.04101162776350975, -0.028675168752670288, 0.01807372458279133, -0.02472837269306183, 0.03750789165496826, -0.030228717252612114, -0.05606357008218765, -0.009386113844811916, -0.019459838047623634, -0.027240293100476265, 0.06304442882537842, 0.006582082714885473, -0.00495506776496768, -0.021068526431918144, -0.04066434130072594, 0.023943567648530006, 0.002456873655319214, 0.045320622622966766, 0.00432302663102746, 0.09222611039876938, -0.02739689312875271, 0.04020001366734505, -0.029769938439130783, -0.011591424234211445, 0.14260941743850708, 0.08135871589183807, 0.0513870045542717, -0.07063432037830353, 0.008425038307905197, -0.013161765411496162, 0.04329121485352516, 0.00008022258407436311, -0.004256168380379677, 0.006510891951620579, -0.013941837474703789, 0.040232911705970764, 0.06871853023767471, 0.0515507310628891, -0.012383283115923405, 0.0456940159201622, -0.04189768806099892, -0.03164314478635788, -0.004429827444255352, 0.020740076899528503, -0.00023759790929034352, -0.02271307446062565, -0.018249504268169403, 0.02436963841319084, -0.008141652680933475, -0.056657057255506516, -0.02657993882894516, -0.01328128669410944, -0.020719124004244804, -0.02185637503862381, 0.014865873381495476, -0.03878028318285942, -0.0013173476327210665, 0.04274889826774597, -0.033373210579156876, -0.030514385551214218, 0.005180621985346079, -0.060271576046943665, -0.018040474504232407, 0.044998250901699066, 0.007684533949941397, 0.0027684830129146576, -0.02718885987997055, 0.04024018347263336, -0.04605070874094963, 0.014897267334163189, 0.007712767459452152, 0.004479499533772469, -0.017756067216396332, 0.011872592382133007, -0.015357723459601402, 0.007332130800932646, 0.004943545907735825, -0.029921922832727432, -0.01572815515100956, 0.02911100536584854, 0.0004738208372145891, -0.010893803089857101, -0.005250478163361549, -0.015591425821185112, 0.032360922545194626, -0.02456628531217575, 0.03399982303380966, 0.027325432747602463, -0.023657985031604767, -0.03663729131221771, -0.03981080651283264, 0.0013014196883887053, -0.02157764695584774, 0.025096865370869637, -0.02878538705408573, 0.036949075758457184, -0.04518425464630127, -0.007283391430974007, 0.0072054690681397915, -0.011022893711924553, 0.03592444956302643, -0.03627721592783928, -0.0026212050579488277, -0.025105923414230347, -0.06439442932605743, 0.030467119067907333, -0.03622126951813698, 0.00028931660926900804, -0.04927632957696915, -0.013724304735660553, 0.03403325006365776, 0.005416002590209246, -0.0281350277364254, 0.003057928988710046, -0.032413460314273834, 0.02605900540947914, 0.0051798028871417046, -0.052873920649290085, 0.0069956290535628796, 0.0005262375343590975, -0.028644179925322533, 0.007674950174987316, -0.0056632631458342075, 0.011305724270641804, 0.022114116698503494, 0.031101278960704803, -0.019053088501095772, 0.04218614473938942, 0.012371749617159367, 0.00444234162569046, 0.013216136954724789, -0.0594097301363945, 0.012027810327708721, -0.01990145817399025, 0.005223667714744806, -0.0395183302462101, -0.029343143105506897, -0.06401517987251282, -0.010439599864184856, -0.014862830750644207, -0.028673343360424042, -0.03140337020158768, 0.02653631754219532, -0.006524995900690556, 0.010737985372543335, -0.013576957397162914, -0.001131521537899971, -0.014917218126356602, -0.03705967217683792, -0.001562176737934351, -0.008648217655718327, 0.004988395143300295, 0.0007136514759622514, 0.005392759572714567, 0.01570724882185459, 0.027320129796862602, -0.0147938197478652, -0.0006060515297576785, 0.05617059767246246, -0.013491135090589523, 0.0007691641221754253, 0.007337633520364761, -0.05997025594115257, 0.004349590744823217, 0.038646966218948364, -0.03214997798204422, -0.03397567197680473, -0.0026561198756098747, -0.02019454725086689, -0.016443626955151558, -0.015278970822691917, 0.004012953490018845, -0.010553454980254173, 0.04085930809378624, -0.020327776670455933, 0.005546571686863899, -0.004429301247000694, 0.019079793244600296, 0.001941596157848835, 0.0175895094871521, 0.015899736434221268, 0.014944583177566528, -0.00932511780411005, 0.053167641162872314, 0.036823589354753494, 0.004098010249435902, 0.022694766521453857, 0.026395102962851524, -0.04447190463542938, 0.026304157450795174, 0.02756805531680584, 0.0031872219406068325, 0.07529520243406296, 0.028385289013385773, -0.02490129880607128, 0.04746778681874275, 0.009505950845777988, 0.03202494978904724, -0.07308048754930496, -0.016076084226369858, 0.020777877420186996, -0.001274139154702425, 0.00035382749047130346, -0.046129532158374786, -0.00074367894558236, 0.015482275746762753, -0.08613979071378708, 0.02564549632370472, -0.013333171606063843, -0.03558783233165741, -0.03540864959359169, 0.007181411609053612, -0.014840077608823776, 0.009023669175803661, -0.012197714298963547, 0.0006094426498748362, 0.02435888908803463, 0.01982143707573414, 0.03672970458865166, 0.013656726107001305, -0.044618986546993256, 0.04737699031829834, 0.015307560563087463, -0.03576520085334778, 0.03371798247098923, -0.026865605264902115, -0.020851586014032364, 0.01785644143819809, 0.027319233864545822, 0.048554107546806335, 0.02492670901119709, -0.0034739230759441853, -0.017815155908465385, 0.05556713044643402, 0.07545424997806549, -0.03221302479505539, -0.00802039634436369, -0.031157024204730988, -0.004093050491064787, 0.023419968783855438, -0.02139844000339508, 0.05031389370560646, 0.02044571563601494, -0.029646135866642, -0.0030323045793920755, -0.010583889670670033, -0.02807631902396679, -0.022929169237613678, -0.005966403055936098, 0.013804339803755283, -0.012297345325350761, -0.005846323445439339, 0.03432725369930267, -0.0461810901761055, 0.03204203024506569, 0.02436792105436325, 0.033425651490688324, 0.0016395833808928728, 0.051190994679927826, -0.0009871487272903323, -0.01973697543144226, -0.004673963878303766, -0.03484240546822548, -0.003782164305448532, -0.06948252022266388, -0.0018616331508383155, -0.000933759321924299, 0.0056062848307192326, -0.035309989005327225, 0.036263689398765564, -0.015934210270643234, 0.04401890188455582, -0.01435641199350357, 0.014683732762932777, 0.04330744221806526, 0.002052195370197296, 0.013542049564421177, -0.06346995383501053, 0.07621190696954727, 0.009075814858078957, 0.006562413647770882, -0.038330692797899246, 0.0013873196439817548, -0.029468348249793053, -0.024797406047582626, 0.04529246315360069, -0.009803046472370625, 0.00007662332791369408, -0.043457359075546265, 0.052852705121040344, -0.003652886487543583, -0.043709658086299896, 0.06894830614328384, -0.01010974496603012, -0.02606048807501793, -0.0631958469748497, -0.014713260345160961, 0.018223961815238, 0.023341387510299683, 0.007053755689412355, 0.003801825689151883, 0.03565523773431778, 0.011620322242379189, -0.003552535315975547, 0.047072045505046844, 0.02717556059360504, -0.04623851552605629, 0.04692855849862099, -0.0049124350771307945, -0.0025082766078412533, 0.03299888223409653, 0.005116723943501711, 0.005440192762762308, 0.05326903611421585, -0.00890035554766655, -0.04664023220539093, 0.02138671837747097, -0.007605052087455988, -0.019154582172632217, -0.05668378993868828, 0.02010698989033699, -0.003527047112584114, -0.0633779987692833, 0.006772073917090893, 0.02179509773850441, 0.04033077508211136, 0.026074271649122238, 0.018155859783291817, -0.0011739651672542095, 0.009798682294785976, 0.020435767248272896, -0.010016107000410557, 0.003165427129715681, 0.028650544583797455, -0.029602400958538055, 0.006034942343831062, 0.05832113325595856, -0.03647437319159508, 0.03700372576713562, 0.005350576713681221, 0.06087105721235275, -0.06497620046138763, 0.0013527683913707733, 0.006902369204908609, -0.03925735130906105, 0.021114619448781013, 0.025836022570729256, -0.03356877341866493, 0.08560211211442947, -0.0060156420804560184, -0.004971495363861322, -0.021822020411491394, -0.017670467495918274, -0.020945865660905838, -0.030875135213136673, -0.018712399527430534, 0.036636605858802795, -0.004339014180004597, 0.02362997829914093, -0.011035922914743423, 0.01655745878815651, 0.029623331502079964, 0.0026322382036596537, 0.026192227378487587, -0.027360938489437103, 0.017213759943842888, -0.049543268978595734, -0.016755005344748497, -0.007609931752085686, 0.00856066308915615, 0.01722601428627968, 0.01715172827243805, 0.01111907884478569, 0.004170022904872894, -0.016068236902356148, 0.010758460499346256, 0.05506428703665733, -0.04352637007832527, -0.0023655963595956564, -0.016639795154333115, -0.006246481090784073, -0.02511371485888958, -0.002520152600482106 ]
<p>Hi i am trying to use AIC value for comparing logit and probit model where in each model the data and the number of covariates are same (say, covariate= 3 for each model)</p> <p>Does AIC value increases while increasing sample size?</p> <p>Which one better to use as a tool for comparing logit and probit, AIC or MSPE?</p>
73,679
[ -0.06582286953926086, 0.008025560528039932, -0.02391820028424263, 0.009075932204723358, 0.052909497171640396, 0.03845743462443352, -0.02550448849797249, -0.03778962790966034, 0.04678027704358101, -0.023836389183998108, 0.017082611098885536, 0.03396417945623398, 0.055009081959724426, 0.00923659186810255, 0.024463152512907982, 0.017361637204885483, -0.015044194646179676, 0.024691680446267128, 0.0023688815999776125, 0.0037486180663108826, -0.023807799443602562, -0.005296277813613415, 0.0606207437813282, -0.012756277807056904, -0.03472097963094711, 0.055386871099472046, 0.03597551956772804, -0.03206717222929001, 0.021269626915454865, 0.03757619112730026, -0.04882940649986267, 0.003455981146544218, 0.026771139353513718, 0.03333910554647446, 0.002722409786656499, 0.00890421774238348, -0.023388750851154327, -0.04068617895245552, 0.005363745149224997, 0.01150982640683651, -0.03736772760748863, -0.029434069991111755, 0.014996894635260105, -0.005407118704169989, -0.012811891734600067, 0.006046073045581579, -0.014592836610972881, -0.05558863282203674, 0.016135606914758682, -0.024074522778391838, 0.07538598775863647, -0.027820350602269173, 0.02368738129734993, 0.033145368099212646, -0.012158838100731373, -0.02114524133503437, 0.0303310789167881, 0.06438799202442169, -0.05258402228355408, -0.029141969978809357, 0.017131350934505463, -0.01644604466855526, 0.005950404331088066, -0.030031610280275345, -0.051560837775468826, 0.0351492241024971, -0.011922902427613735, -0.0005690412945114076, 0.03960764408111572, -0.0036192068364471197, 0.03725634887814522, 0.006054348312318325, 0.0319645069539547, 0.009822831489145756, 0.01534923817962408, -0.0486111044883728, 0.0021977133583277464, -0.010695255361497402, 0.053390588611364365, 0.056450530886650085, 0.020509393885731697, 0.036985721439123154, 0.013749465346336365, 0.008370012044906616, 0.051511574536561966, -0.03716275468468666, 0.0489615760743618, -0.027709275484085083, 0.00928316731005907, 0.014610236510634422, -0.053006067872047424, -0.012322697788476944, 0.057740405201911926, -0.008100823499262333, -0.03194933012127876, 0.023482657968997955, -0.05646255239844322, 0.05009201914072037, 0.012452439405024052, 0.028986521065235138, -0.044761449098587036, -0.059667207300662994, 0.017529796808958054, 0.020428204908967018, -0.012788228690624237, -0.01583370938897133, -0.021797053515911102, -0.020334526896476746, 0.021448954939842224, -0.03698389232158661, -0.024114949628710747, 0.01704433746635914, 0.0068207657895982265, 0.027847101911902428, 0.02414897084236145, -0.010882250033318996, 0.01243247278034687, -0.0246672872453928, 0.04728912562131882, 0.05123402550816536, 0.05675198882818222, -0.005830307956784964, 0.032873138785362244, -0.038777679204940796, -0.03890841454267502, 0.014069528318941593, 0.0016740995924919844, -0.017654675990343094, -0.046946603804826736, 0.0646054595708847, -0.01521748024970293, -0.01798505149781704, 0.016591565683484077, -0.005501268897205591, 0.004246406257152557, 0.015714598819613457, -0.062285445630550385, -0.010902218520641327, 0.014609098434448242, -0.029312219470739365, 0.030396508052945137, -0.06775525212287903, 0.019039126113057137, 0.012284494936466217, 0.035444438457489014, 0.04422875493764877, 0.05984293669462204, 0.02155194617807865, 0.010790652595460415, 0.028818879276514053, -0.03340914100408554, -0.005447281990200281, -0.024514948949217796, -0.0008710160618647933, 0.007428474258631468, -0.11322163045406342, -0.01194495428353548, 0.014802812598645687, 0.011855208314955235, -0.012976979836821556, 0.04433274641633034, -0.006530413869768381, -0.04254743829369545, -0.021441616117954254, 0.009019972756505013, -0.015329415909945965, 0.035537105053663254, -0.020412102341651917, 0.0011862916871905327, -0.010658911429345608, 0.010012946091592312, 0.025542279705405235, -0.005715285427868366, 0.046241749078035355, 0.051052745431661606, -0.006581523921340704, 0.00839172676205635, -0.030476579442620277, 0.02915453165769577, 0.04477739334106445, -0.03931966796517372, 0.0059464117512106895, -0.05785874277353287, -0.015041685663163662, 0.022403789684176445, 0.020662782713770866, -0.0017638501012697816, 0.005131189711391926, 0.03299177438020706, -0.029732657596468925, -0.028167443349957466, -0.08919975161552429, 0.014165094122290611, -0.001520084566436708, -0.02447465807199478, 0.02509448491036892, 0.023586131632328033, 0.004731135442852974, -0.018524903804063797, 0.011749611236155033, -0.042789358645677567, 0.006445872597396374, 0.04140026122331619, -0.03747250884771347, 0.03429176285862923, -0.008102890104055405, 0.004367255140095949, -0.03887487202882767, 0.0408024787902832, -0.030628226697444916, -0.018930934369564056, 0.04817971587181091, -0.017940806224942207, 0.0002334789460292086, -0.011027386412024498, 0.0009373250650241971, -0.011149976402521133, 0.02100740559399128, -0.03839896246790886, 0.08257731050252914, -0.04274449497461319, 0.11552534252405167, 0.052813928574323654, -0.027348188683390617, 0.0052262539975345135, -0.011282478459179401, 0.017349164932966232, 0.02566739171743393, -0.04637429863214493, -0.01624884456396103, -0.06652823835611343, -0.011343893595039845, -0.004775304347276688, -0.006164074409753084, -0.0342903770506382, -0.003950873855501413, 0.027896512299776077, -0.017085732892155647, 0.022387942299246788, 0.01565735973417759, 0.03262481093406677, -0.015922820195555687, 0.02439403533935547, 0.04564486816525459, 0.024802744388580322, -0.02702280320227146, 0.017754899337887764, -0.007004398386925459, 0.0581771619617939, -0.019885817542672157, 0.006078886799514294, 0.037765149027109146, -0.007358791772276163, -0.014256021939218044, -0.01832779310643673, -0.016121702268719673, 0.005487786140292883, -0.040030673146247864, -0.0017590905772522092, 0.06039638817310333, 0.015014614909887314, -0.016461998224258423, 0.023276224732398987, -0.01267687976360321, 0.04256671294569969, 0.035329669713974, -0.02443372830748558, -0.0028242161497473717, 0.0010271803475916386, -0.024317042902112007, 0.020831329748034477, 0.0058287326246500015, -0.03967776894569397, -0.057641323655843735, 0.002106386935338378, 0.05234850198030472, -0.03600958734750748, 0.028607994318008423, -0.023284099996089935, -0.011173071339726448, -0.022361114621162415, 0.0017954041250050068, 0.010026677511632442, -0.019486363977193832, -0.07204030454158783, 0.01905079372227192, 0.005677945911884308, -0.042537134140729904, 0.014341077767312527, -0.0013073087902739644, 0.007231920957565308, 0.013739324174821377, 0.0043650404550135136, -0.03556482866406441, -0.016735991463065147, 0.016149386763572693, 0.010409627109766006, -0.015360976569354534, -0.029577231034636497, 0.04477713257074356, -0.018616383895277977, -0.05862665921449661, 0.013872437179088593, -0.04286637529730797, -0.011783012188971043, -0.03538663685321808, 0.016405219212174416, -0.003924830816686153, -0.016397127881646156, 0.012195129878818989, 0.03407612070441246, -0.005013897083699703, -0.03579103574156761, -0.05534844473004341, -0.052502915263175964, 0.008343201130628586, 0.028236117213964462, 0.029699912294745445, -0.01367010734975338, -0.040856294333934784, 0.04130459949374199, 0.06970774382352829, -0.041642360389232635, -0.05839390307664871, -0.00007537833153037354, -0.019807076081633568, -0.015590343624353409, 0.03261018171906471, 0.014310212805867195, -0.014499092474579811, 0.015670767053961754, -0.010508889332413673, 0.025178229436278343, 0.04579026997089386, 0.01693517155945301, 0.016755562275648117, 0.019788285717368126, 0.0131283113732934, -0.04547909274697304, 0.03413685783743858, 0.04660161957144737, -0.06888745725154877, -0.021337224170565605, 0.003921191673725843, 0.025863608345389366, -0.0036067261826246977, -0.026852449402213097, 0.03049619309604168, -0.015591000206768513, 0.008298790082335472, -0.03386576846241951, 0.019474804401397705, 0.03508736938238144, -0.02168830670416355, -0.03892013058066368, 0.018694914877414703, 0.00585669232532382, -0.0436708927154541, 0.01136617548763752, 0.057675331830978394, 0.005068379454314709, -0.048934586346149445, 0.018010098487138748, -0.03133191540837288, -0.0225844606757164, 0.005710427649319172, -0.03566281124949455, -0.018664954230189323, 0.010608382523059845, 0.02056140825152397, 0.00905610527843237, -0.03540315479040146, -0.04769599437713623, 0.015833813697099686, -0.06281372159719467, -0.00015285298286471516, -0.028732553124427795, 0.0560220330953598, 0.016375217586755753, 0.04407665506005287, 0.03638554364442825, -0.003527536755427718, 0.03926510363817215, -0.010083937086164951, -0.05068686977028847, 0.02409401349723339, -0.032865505665540695, 0.01198156550526619, 0.02407948113977909, -0.012952575460076332, 0.05281120538711548, -0.03986167162656784, 0.0029963257256895304, 0.010446270927786827, 0.023030219599604607, 0.002239020075649023, 0.01682470552623272, -0.0305488184094429, 0.011799396015703678, 0.026039201766252518, 0.023820025846362114, 0.004021555185317993, 0.008206713944673538, 0.027185378596186638, 0.04850052669644356, -0.005559571553021669, -0.020293718203902245, 0.01846380904316902, 0.023455463349819183, 0.013492529280483723, 0.0309408288449049, 0.03968614712357521, 0.029541388154029846, -0.01291715633124113, 0.03671543300151825, 0.006388862617313862, 0.026866121217608452, 0.01835036836564541, -0.013643940910696983, -0.029229523614048958, -0.04334122687578201, -0.03169364109635353, 0.01684163324534893, 0.017182985320687294, 0.011358647607266903, -0.03889911621809006, 0.029288113117218018, 0.018637266010046005, -0.04453554376959801, 0.036830686032772064, 0.050403617322444916, 0.02307874523103237, -0.011659206822514534, -0.036060500890016556, 0.02897847816348076, -0.006687992252409458, -0.012598978355526924, 0.025109022855758667, 0.024634018540382385, -0.04447096958756447, 0.0037395451217889786, 0.015990743413567543, -0.04435133561491966, -0.038497187197208405, -0.003653072752058506, 0.02541554532945156, 0.009225216694176197, 0.04147244617342949, -0.07963956892490387, -0.0379866324365139, 0.026231495663523674, -0.0027974657714366913, 0.038207683712244034, 0.032154109328985214, -0.06438072770833969, 0.005520114675164223, 0.0031503899954259396, 0.015581779181957245, -0.05750634893774986, 0.015966881066560745, -0.028371291235089302, -0.0254207793623209, -0.012895630672574043, -0.045359864830970764, 0.016127023845911026, -0.016340095549821854, 0.012822361662983894, -0.0254152100533247, 0.005749471485614777, -0.07871079444885254, 0.017556805163621902, -0.020654665306210518, -0.020165953785181046, -0.02485409379005432, 0.00018665350216906518, -0.022728340700268745, 0.015189685858786106, 0.01603724993765354, 0.07618482410907745, -0.06624679267406464, 0.007974044419825077, 0.04234161972999573, 0.043987978249788284, -0.026342611759901047, -0.016813654452562332, 0.006194713991135359, 0.008209280669689178, -0.0007698608096688986, -0.01707376167178154, -0.012675423175096512, -0.04088791087269783, 0.005207395646721125, 0.01707528904080391, -0.03846774995326996, 0.013310802169144154, -0.03361959382891655, 0.03885558247566223, 0.006212374195456505, -0.008799302391707897, 0.04402337223291397, 0.016434280201792717, -0.012806147336959839, 0.027580207213759422, -0.03691352903842926, -0.01515393890440464, -0.025107525289058685, -0.05462198331952095, -0.04946999251842499, 0.010706432163715363, -0.006582718342542648, 0.02117656171321869, -0.013716557994484901, 0.04344096779823303, -0.058337029069662094, -0.015336900018155575, 0.03474835678935051, -0.018245762214064598, 0.0255227442830801, -0.00497801648452878, -0.0016693826764822006, -0.004238004796206951, 0.019540464505553246, -0.02068762667477131, 0.008047783747315407, -0.03258432820439339, -0.009275786578655243, -0.007921190932393074, -0.054804228246212006, 0.024975046515464783, -0.03132348507642746, -0.03143340349197388, 0.007007282227277756, -0.004701466765254736, 0.002731046639382839, 0.012020810507237911, -0.024181321263313293, -0.009951582178473473, -0.045949120074510574, 0.009455522522330284, 0.027010280638933182, -0.01224594283849001, 0.042881906032562256, -0.00918407179415226, 0.03514346852898598, -0.019986679777503014, 0.00825626403093338, -0.07638897746801376, -0.04561728239059448, 0.015180565416812897, -0.04152549430727959, -0.04098594933748245, 0.014223559759557247, -0.03326137363910675, -0.00413229875266552, -0.02321331948041916, 0.01525242067873478, 0.0474441722035408, -0.02504849247634411, 0.008676867000758648, -0.006475577596575022, 0.024059565737843513, 0.05152672156691551, 0.02245156653225422, -0.013957821764051914, -0.03469300642609596, -0.02359461970627308, -0.014410381205379963, 0.019449973478913307, 0.038887105882167816, -0.03367549926042557, -0.01858820952475071, -0.007339032366871834, -0.039711810648441315, 0.04639829322695732, 0.00031723445863462985, -0.036469630897045135, -0.014864226803183556, -0.011959956027567387, -0.018985362723469734, -0.04704659804701805, -0.005882874131202698, 0.0073970165103673935, 0.029190288856625557, -0.0242875088006258, 0.007817751727998257, -0.025928327813744545, -0.014427279122173786, 0.028100790455937386, 0.02757197804749012, -0.013713439926505089, 0.010336019098758698, 0.08301404863595963, -0.03264471888542175, 0.034729164093732834, -0.030319515615701675, -0.011201251298189163, 0.03175817430019379, -0.014305619522929192, 0.00915436539798975, 0.01491432636976242, 0.04069416597485542, -0.019887980073690414, -0.031029727309942245, -0.006762451957911253, 0.030163800343871117, 0.060484662652015686, -0.0038949709851294756, 0.06264439970254898, 0.09717046469449997, -0.001689571188762784, 0.0009996243752539158, -0.01589067466557026, -0.03142519295215607, -0.003117256099358201, -0.0012075731065124273, 0.08158565312623978, -0.022522546350955963, -0.028298264369368553, 0.037442274391651154, -0.0047699385322630405, -0.0063825948163867, 0.03852757066488266, 0.027284493669867516, 0.01744941808283329, 0.01357921864837408, -0.006952797528356314, -0.04417746514081955, 0.019322125241160393, -0.03244037926197052, 0.03814489394426346, -0.05528150871396065, -0.03353775665163994, 0.022039825096726418, 0.04626847803592682, 0.025021836161613464, -0.07752569019794464, -0.017082588747143745, -0.04481222480535507, 0.0005351226427592337, 0.007220940198749304, -0.005777408834546804, -0.004126663785427809, 0.012636222876608372, 0.011745055206120014, -0.009775917045772076, 0.024790693074464798, -0.02286023087799549, -0.10346675664186478, -0.025539256632328033, 0.005593691952526569, -0.005211342126131058, 0.004075533710420132, 0.02031872794032097, -0.0116001321002841, -0.010748730972409248, -0.0012471408117562532, 0.01874440349638462, -0.005400943569839001, 0.016200607642531395, -0.010171022266149521, 0.07947264611721039, -0.017124716192483902, 0.010388752445578575, 0.03337204456329346, 0.03433883935213089, 0.12487086653709412, 0.06986528635025024, -0.006383410654962063, -0.06459274888038635, 0.046931762248277664, 0.016818922013044357, -0.0274772047996521, 0.013508684933185577, -0.011333643458783627, 0.0026684259064495564, -0.0025241633411496878, 0.06101728230714798, 0.028588712215423584, -0.02549191378057003, -0.007502044551074505, 0.05875297635793686, -0.022306008264422417, -0.029817407950758934, -0.0033572909887880087, 0.007019934244453907, 0.01599554903805256, -0.0050506433472037315, -0.012485310435295105, 0.03689446300268173, -0.002650850685313344, -0.016906365752220154, -0.021264148876070976, -0.021750614047050476, 0.026828035712242126, 0.0015358799137175083, -0.015738289803266525, 0.0010198464151471853, 0.006840434391051531, 0.021878959611058235, -0.030279284343123436, -0.022804835811257362, 0.005681818816810846, -0.03983211889863014, -0.003291623666882515, 0.05795242637395859, -0.007596495561301708, -0.01804276369512081, -0.023829909041523933, 0.012524592690169811, -0.020060667768120766, -0.02610870636999607, -0.014314346946775913, 0.021039359271526337, -0.0009453824604861438, 0.017157644033432007, -0.06248573586344719, 0.00605678278952837, -0.004409277345985174, -0.037532709538936615, -0.03808384761214256, 0.0229498241096735, -0.01030920259654522, -0.0299240555614233, -0.020520713180303574, -0.06821821630001068, -0.02087113820016384, -0.012840078212320805, 0.013106252998113632, 0.0001794103009160608, -0.03052671253681183, -0.015752244740724564, -0.01906650699675083, 0.04730226472020149, 0.018333720043301582, 0.013896741904318333, 0.020478535443544388, -0.005625312216579914, -0.04958261176943779, -0.03968149423599243, 0.008871526457369328, 0.05502227693796158, 0.0030122690368443727, -0.01096935011446476, -0.006185288541018963, -0.020063430070877075, -0.040297701954841614, -0.008835378102958202, -0.008739033713936806, 0.016973646357655525, -0.025608738884329796, -0.012912839651107788, 0.022428587079048157, 0.029425563290715218, 0.010537528432905674, 0.004552595783025026, 0.005316723603755236, 0.053635671734809875, 0.004338617902249098, -0.06915439665317535, 0.004053866025060415, 0.017803452908992767, -0.07764731347560883, 0.003924712538719177, -0.02431698888540268, 0.0586371123790741, 0.009586920030415058, 0.015580139122903347, 0.012089903466403484, 0.0008185175247490406, -0.019918490201234818, 0.022758204489946365, 0.0020498435478657484, -0.019944733008742332, 0.006351040676236153, 0.02756030485033989, 0.022854695096611977, -0.034266985952854156, 0.017541106790304184, -0.024387210607528687, -0.014087988063693047, 0.03342398628592491, -0.02803885191679001, -0.018048465251922607, 0.02916538156569004, -0.01263427734375, 0.011470917612314224, -0.038455307483673096, -0.0016464275540784001, -0.02886301465332508, -0.0073545160703361034, 0.024923250079154968, -0.004057819023728371, -0.0028205786366015673, 0.017929650843143463, -0.03801789879798889, -0.018432674929499626, 0.05896064266562462, 0.0009233637829311192, -0.013329903595149517, -0.005390184000134468, 0.03264383599162102, 0.010154004208743572, 0.09348553419113159, -0.03303394466638565, 0.00029986354638822377, 0.052266865968704224, -0.0650346502661705, -0.0011253549018874764, 0.018489284440875053, -0.04338338226079941, 0.02760538086295128, 0.037093814462423325, 0.028637554496526718, 0.005039047449827194, 0.05080246180295944, -0.0008323591900989413, -0.02445095032453537, -0.03624378889799118, -0.025006286799907684, 0.038383472710847855, 0.002875408623367548, -0.005370986647903919, 0.01544125284999609, -0.022201435640454292, 0.053367406129837036, 0.043553803116083145, 0.003913586959242821, 0.004335425328463316, -0.004630923271179199, 0.013124348595738411, -0.01594376750290394, 0.039156556129455566, -0.03396565094590187, 0.02032836340367794, 0.05501260608434677, -0.0005202809697948396, 0.021047573536634445, -0.0054553416557610035, 0.0170065276324749, -0.09107363969087601, -0.00034900655737146735, 0.007363286800682545, 0.003289198037236929, 0.0042900098487734795, -0.01840510033071041, -0.008633791469037533, 0.043491680175065994, -0.05490632727742195, 0.02510305866599083, 0.0005620569572784007, 0.014241919852793217, -0.047139205038547516, -0.006126660853624344, -0.015987752005457878, 0.025576332584023476, -0.0138847716152668, 0.03221563249826431, 0.022089602425694466, 0.010937327519059181, 0.002578678773716092, 0.001219513243995607, -0.0302270520478487, 0.032851360738277435, 0.0032642094884067774, -0.05422848463058472, 0.00527307391166687, -0.04645593836903572, -0.031138751655817032, 0.05968732014298439, 0.00933871604502201, 0.01460281666368246, 0.03437164053320885, 0.018033403903245926, 0.00320420297794044, 0.03088819608092308, 0.025153791531920433, 0.02772253379225731, -0.005075038410723209, 0.009916754439473152, 0.007257879711687565, 0.02710973471403122, 0.02615523897111416, 0.019517863169312477, 0.054857343435287476, 0.009373193606734276, -0.003405230352655053, 0.0029586406890302896, 0.0022134340833872557, -0.05909503251314163, -0.04637698829174042, -0.03375300019979477, -0.013677036389708519, 0.0016787336207926273, 0.0013242483837530017, -0.024304211139678955, -0.00786762498319149, 0.04801756516098976, 0.026248419657349586, 0.020204564556479454, 0.01068198587745428, -0.02990916557610035, -0.0211618822067976, 0.03465614095330238, 0.01595943607389927, 0.005041512195020914, -0.01986502669751644, 0.015395899303257465, 0.04508281126618385, 0.014100749045610428, -0.026949983090162277, 0.00804361142218113, -0.04200255870819092, 0.02001567743718624, -0.04376649484038353, -0.006632295902818441, 0.05446088686585426, 0.0006136891315691173, 0.023035680875182152, -0.10024569928646088, 0.08269211649894714, 0.0013036043383181095, -0.029781872406601906, -0.06997504085302353, -0.017858577892184258, -0.03178275749087334, 0.038340870290994644, 0.04934850335121155, 0.022392936050891876, 0.021770324558019638, -0.006207180209457874, 0.02890794724225998, 0.02410902827978134, -0.019829560071229935, 0.039086129516363144, 0.011178750544786453, 0.004752003587782383, -0.005608391482383013, 0.036744531244039536, 0.009652011096477509, 0.016448697075247765, -0.0060843778774142265, -0.023889809846878052, 0.038239091634750366, -0.00787148904055357, -0.02245834656059742, 0.015103531070053577, -0.004939299542456865, -0.027144966647028923, 0.06543458998203278, -0.0493394173681736, 0.01796177588403225, -0.01518983393907547, 0.02379722148180008, -0.05268110707402229, 0.011380916461348534, -0.0041290633380413055, -0.01841839589178562, 0.003730361582711339, 0.006562274880707264, -0.00047937536146491766, -0.041542898863554, 0.019673967733979225, 0.016476042568683624, -0.029853908345103264, 0.0017505546566098928, 0.016753334552049637, 0.04660480096936226, 0.05740370228886604, -0.034950919449329376, 0.05395358428359032, -0.005983696784824133, -0.014381627552211285, -0.0005584029713645577, 0.0397002249956131, 0.011304671876132488, 0.009764646179974079, 0.007441584020853043, 0.021111823618412018, 0.01774788461625576, 0.01229408010840416, -0.004849050659686327, 0.04301271215081215, 0.022025739774107933, -0.01995241641998291, 0.043605439364910126, 0.017876988276839256, 0.05397602170705795, 0.024999123066663742, 0.0132484445348382, 0.053386226296424866, -0.04037372022867203, -0.000316204153932631, 0.00849122554063797, -0.022215792909264565, -0.05920813977718353, -0.01895846053957939, 0.0013012969866394997, 0.041720911860466, 0.046726830303668976, -0.029810024425387383, 0.029139358550310135, -0.02428773231804371, 0.003955740947276354, -0.05569595843553543, 0.005162951070815325, 0.011678856797516346, 0.03204813227057457, -0.03852688521146774, -0.029953181743621826, -0.02828785590827465, -0.015847576782107353, 0.03656057268381119, 0.00367677747271955, 0.048258889466524124, -0.004098336677998304, -0.0465286560356617, 0.015267135575413704, 0.0709582194685936, -0.047397393733263016, -0.004650231916457415, -0.03403930738568306, 0.0041336980648338795, 0.005933280568569899, -0.0028762719593942165 ]
<p>Logistic regression essentially means taking the logit of your response proportions, p, and then doing standard regression. Consider the case where one p is 1. </p> <p>logit(1) = log(1/(1-1)) = infinity. How can you do regression with infinity?</p> <p>That is, if one of your observed proportions p is 1, then you are trying to find the line that minimises the sum of squared differences from a set of points that include infinity. How does this not drive the regression line to always have infinite slope?</p>
36,114
[ -0.012058661319315434, 0.014681108295917511, -0.00763712776824832, 0.021424543112516403, 0.02554427832365036, 0.022170059382915497, -0.010768642649054527, 0.004096439108252525, 0.01060989685356617, -0.029024070128798485, -0.0033247023820877075, 0.003511073999106884, 0.024274295195937157, 0.008852241560816765, 0.035652466118335724, 0.016648145392537117, 0.02632991224527359, 0.026867853477597237, 0.001211421680636704, -0.01281581912189722, 0.009622671641409397, 0.014358009211719036, 0.04706653952598572, 0.013282649219036102, -0.033194176852703094, 0.046402934938669205, 0.05195600911974907, 0.012454821728169918, 0.024293044582009315, 0.058020953088998795, -0.01179142203181982, -0.019205912947654724, 0.015871256589889526, 0.06520219892263412, 0.051067572087049484, 0.0034478111192584038, -0.009411197155714035, -0.007878167554736137, 0.008358269929885864, 0.011763633228838444, -0.002122232224792242, -0.04238615185022354, 0.011327337473630905, 0.010909880511462688, -0.022952770814299583, 0.031207330524921417, -0.025616873055696487, -0.041587986052036285, 0.048154447227716446, -0.03864529728889465, 0.04739353805780411, 0.007924907840788364, 0.032924048602581024, 0.01908622309565544, 0.02180558629333973, 0.005840441212058067, 0.061894550919532776, 0.06989908963441849, -0.019904691725969315, -0.08346926420927048, -0.024735432118177414, -0.013008547015488148, -0.019543863832950592, -0.005936807952821255, -0.014660128392279148, 0.04374900460243225, 0.015528563410043716, 0.0053141238167881966, 0.026474550366401672, -0.005053231492638588, 0.010774684138596058, 0.031734663993120193, 0.04001108184456825, -0.009373955428600311, 0.011581221595406532, -0.0131980637088418, -0.00853438675403595, 0.022579552605748177, 0.038399673998355865, 0.052185747772455215, 0.021157851442694664, -0.010768228210508823, 0.04556040093302727, 0.03390456363558769, 0.02236996963620186, -0.018679602071642876, 0.05458861589431763, 0.007402027491480112, 0.02522895485162735, 0.05937931686639786, -0.027068721130490303, 0.012182358652353287, 0.028467390686273575, -0.012219265103340149, -0.013188326731324196, 0.04980010911822319, -0.019870612770318985, 0.024230673909187317, 0.04224877059459686, 0.010250363498926163, 0.008904027752578259, -0.04615585133433342, -0.02140580676496029, 0.01226110477000475, -0.015369398519396782, 0.012462761253118515, -0.008346827700734138, 0.03549885004758835, -0.013350483030080795, -0.037593383342027664, -0.01101857889443636, 0.023449871689081192, 0.017092036083340645, 0.019285138696432114, 0.021227331832051277, -0.024683309718966484, -0.0008819117792882025, -0.04740344360470772, 0.05144063010811806, 0.042337775230407715, 0.006376710720360279, -0.04501372575759888, -0.001390526769682765, -0.0044594393111765385, -0.04768107086420059, 0.003031059866771102, 0.006569552700966597, -0.003420461667701602, -0.028226139023900032, -0.0014569441555067897, -0.02573130652308464, -0.0054336776956915855, 0.009840277954936028, 0.03921877592802048, 0.03489186242222786, 0.041836608201265335, -0.08537957072257996, -0.05095167085528374, 0.0002981188299600035, 0.004141862504184246, 0.010629151947796345, -0.05066815763711929, -0.00006802607094869018, 0.05377733334898949, 0.05081453174352646, -0.003744442481547594, 0.040774039924144745, 0.025467975065112114, -0.01685551553964615, -0.00499256094917655, -0.005257072392851114, 0.003026064019650221, -0.015340226702392101, -0.028408529236912727, 0.01719399355351925, -0.06956662237644196, 0.045293938368558884, 0.037507571280002594, 0.00505637563765049, -0.020474372431635857, 0.01845407672226429, -0.026218753308057785, -0.013491449877619743, 0.01978492923080921, -0.03464580699801445, 0.004902997985482216, 0.07303430140018463, -0.012424656189978123, 0.031170355156064034, 0.04859086871147156, -0.0029236667323857546, 0.006736351642757654, 0.017456047236919403, 0.0417267344892025, 0.03446441888809204, -0.025313470512628555, -0.025009697303175926, -0.05503925308585167, 0.014758254401385784, 0.03699823468923569, -0.05103300139307976, 0.004537071567028761, -0.0015328435692936182, 0.022741565480828285, 0.015565446577966213, 0.06838401407003403, -0.00013495111488737166, 0.0018251898000016809, 0.048431240022182465, -0.047085147351026535, -0.06122095137834549, -0.04765482246875763, 0.026362769305706024, 0.0010586874559521675, -0.0031509546097368, -0.0086219422519207, 0.022098978981375694, 0.0034497547894716263, -0.07314072549343109, -0.01638639159500599, -0.006379132624715567, 0.0027987640351057053, 0.05251463130116463, -0.04341597482562065, 0.010556166060268879, 0.05763993039727211, 0.046130403876304626, 0.008207276463508606, 0.039834532886743546, -0.07491117715835571, -0.05247972533106804, 0.017502380535006523, -0.017093222588300705, 0.02104397863149643, -0.022177821025252342, -0.02651473693549633, -0.0009753233753144741, 0.00003250083318562247, -0.041489481925964355, 0.03862817957997322, -0.06613756716251373, 0.07707994431257248, 0.05872904136776924, 0.01540166512131691, -0.028952449560165405, -0.0260727908462286, -0.023154305294156075, -0.03281424939632416, -0.02604326792061329, -0.032018497586250305, -0.058417294174432755, -0.0466742068529129, 0.011245451867580414, 0.022920625284314156, -0.00196880497969687, -0.022400973364710808, 0.03360430896282196, 0.053425516933202744, 0.0018740430241450667, 0.008279914036393166, -0.03493563085794449, -0.0007171538891270757, 0.0031582482624799013, -0.022117802873253822, 0.0031765911262482405, -0.011239930987358093, 0.042547330260276794, 0.010508029721677303, 0.018734551966190338, 0.025128155946731567, -0.022088127210736275, 0.04319145530462265, -0.004046955611556768, -0.03183424100279808, 0.020475341007113457, -0.0077351415529847145, 0.018274934962391853, -0.02098994143307209, 0.008439509198069572, 0.016860701143741608, 0.03023936226963997, -0.008200839161872864, -0.014314142987132072, 0.01073306705802679, 0.009720738045871258, 0.07609106600284576, -0.05638424679636955, 0.008816935122013092, 0.03124554641544819, -0.05091334879398346, 0.01893097162246704, -0.04139043018221855, -0.06667567044496536, -0.02430284582078457, 0.00028366752667352557, 0.024037044495344162, 0.01610025390982628, 0.02249528467655182, -0.020508725196123123, -0.031892329454422, 0.031159674748778343, -0.03438117355108261, -0.004673942923545837, -0.002972677117213607, -0.0466141477227211, -0.014371640980243683, -0.0218888558447361, -0.010732377879321575, 0.011038282886147499, 0.0008767521940171719, 0.03873429819941521, 0.001489091431722045, -0.022760173305869102, -0.05704981088638306, -0.0428861640393734, -0.06500159949064255, 0.02058878168463707, 0.01336827501654625, -0.004768557846546173, 0.029556291177868843, -0.019036971032619476, -0.05244438350200653, 0.03905012831091881, -0.06097698211669922, -0.007474927231669426, -0.04373164102435112, -0.0025541570503264666, 0.019091956317424774, 0.024296903982758522, 0.001389873679727316, 0.0019495702581480145, -0.04855681210756302, 0.002748308703303337, -0.08806779235601425, -0.07255819439888, 0.017753994092345238, -0.01063872966915369, 0.011489407159388065, -0.007871179841458797, -0.024605022743344307, 0.0814773216843605, 0.0515696220099926, -0.004342586733400822, -0.06902258843183517, 0.008780897594988346, -0.018965302035212517, -0.02009769156575203, 0.02728164568543434, 0.0040816948749125, 0.018516363576054573, 0.018411384895443916, -0.012099061161279678, 0.05082883685827255, 0.035070326179265976, 0.02432875521481037, 0.02017790637910366, 0.01096818782389164, -0.004965689033269882, -0.0156265739351511, -0.010726549662649632, 0.024585973471403122, -0.02510765567421913, 0.015095344744622707, 0.020805442705750465, 0.04910602793097496, -0.000951166613958776, -0.0493893027305603, -0.005457759834825993, -0.004921518266201019, 0.008789066225290298, -0.018179625272750854, 0.011708665639162064, 0.02203613519668579, -0.03386335447430611, -0.013951541855931282, 0.022721197456121445, 0.02816655859351158, -0.026446212083101273, 0.03415043279528618, 0.01162174716591835, 0.06413059681653976, -0.03463376685976982, -0.040789179503917694, 0.015398298390209675, -0.0011773973237723112, 0.018409421667456627, -0.012196682393550873, -0.016870198771357536, 0.055910054594278336, 0.027127183973789215, -0.01867290399968624, -0.02137652412056923, -0.05232381075620651, -0.009102774783968925, -0.0643853023648262, -0.004981109406799078, -0.01495350431650877, 0.055902592837810516, -0.007107105106115341, 0.039036042988300323, -0.0008085345616564155, 0.012612879276275635, 0.027337538078427315, 0.05109823867678642, -0.09833165258169174, 0.015237831510603428, -0.0501844584941864, -0.022604133933782578, -0.004841668531298637, -0.020839257165789604, 0.029412610456347466, -0.047651343047618866, 0.007536557503044605, 0.009809846058487892, -0.029643261805176735, -0.004733277019113302, -0.009829716756939888, -0.014099493622779846, -0.038221076130867004, -0.006678971461951733, -0.030546393245458603, 0.0125462356954813, -0.0190715529024601, 0.014540149830281734, 0.06930017471313477, 0.01615024544298649, 0.0007244800217449665, -0.018478529527783394, 0.004644553177058697, 0.03687123954296112, 0.07617242634296417, 0.0056420015171170235, 0.010015049017965794, -0.04170200228691101, 0.05886860564351082, 0.001649698126129806, 0.036378681659698486, 0.02656438946723938, 0.02545199729502201, -0.026896292343735695, -0.015190500766038895, -0.009291020222008228, 0.021544236689805984, -0.000677286006975919, -0.004068344831466675, 0.0009496542625129223, 0.06717417389154434, 0.030695682391524315, -0.0387653224170208, -0.014168920926749706, 0.05083571746945381, 0.010698270052671432, -0.03735833615064621, -0.03139184042811394, -0.009415396489202976, -0.017383292317390442, 0.024731282144784927, 0.0018370547331869602, 0.037264347076416016, -0.0022898600436747074, 0.0020808603148907423, 0.06359966099262238, 0.004428330808877945, -0.0026960372924804688, -0.014489836990833282, 0.023118147626519203, 0.020761573687195778, -0.003528804052621126, -0.05955362319946289, 0.015215694904327393, 0.034613050520420074, 0.04996104538440704, 0.017879031598567963, 0.006117925047874451, -0.08343446999788284, -0.009989888407289982, 0.025097697973251343, 0.01972915045917034, -0.005143824033439159, -0.01163763552904129, -0.0166625939309597, 0.01842884160578251, 0.02713802643120289, -0.031542740762233734, 0.003938739653676748, -0.04637014865875244, 0.024263473227620125, -0.026083368808031082, -0.04476812109351158, -0.06584024429321289, 0.050687070935964584, -0.01236557774245739, -0.0038913742173463106, 0.004727320745587349, -0.008373367600142956, -0.07585829496383667, 0.04812929779291153, -0.021869318559765816, 0.07449083775281906, -0.022360477596521378, 0.005998867563903332, 0.024981321766972542, 0.019473936408758163, 0.023058971390128136, -0.04042772948741913, 0.015132586471736431, 0.021958451718091965, -0.03040431998670101, 0.03190351277589798, 0.016348451375961304, -0.053052328526973724, 0.04111635312438011, 0.021340811625123024, -0.021614355966448784, 0.0017875443445518613, -0.02852083183825016, 0.03375229239463806, 0.011199023574590683, 0.019469112157821655, 0.0764303058385849, 0.05451991781592369, -0.014034583233296871, -0.028210990130901337, -0.06436947733163834, 0.016593407839536667, 0.011112482286989689, -0.04075699299573898, -0.0023153042420744896, -0.004295100457966328, -0.024045055732131004, -0.005540130194276571, 0.038584161549806595, -0.011367537081241608, -0.009242252446711063, -0.00835872907191515, -0.02305266447365284, 0.018656188622117043, 0.003563296515494585, 0.023722145706415176, 0.0017630407819524407, 0.014665551483631134, 0.003752866294234991, -0.014543644152581692, 0.031530942767858505, -0.0058244518004357815, 0.009075501933693886, 0.025359999388456345, -0.02745969034731388, 0.00007517987251048908, 0.013643808662891388, -0.033603280782699585, 0.03959619998931885, -0.01149572804570198, 0.03834807127714157, -0.028257321566343307, 0.007284565828740597, -0.0004512907180469483, -0.025704078376293182, -0.02027258649468422, -0.0012918231077492237, -0.021960366517305374, 0.005385255441069603, -0.042305320501327515, 0.014530971646308899, -0.020182903856039047, 0.004226984456181526, -0.058973897248506546, -0.037808578461408615, 0.02883036993443966, 0.004194246605038643, -0.04648027569055557, -0.020129254087805748, -0.0017613477539271116, 0.00020212223171256483, -0.025724319741129875, -0.009004594758152962, 0.04993996024131775, -0.04684031382203102, -0.009814208373427391, -0.03369693085551262, 0.03562359884381294, 0.05243328586220741, 0.01794905960559845, -0.03259709104895592, 0.010896720923483372, -0.022167818620800972, -0.017491236329078674, 0.01265245582908392, 0.019459489732980728, -0.02244691364467144, -0.005970330908894539, -0.00985274650156498, -0.0017045388231053948, 0.0037755602970719337, -0.02383192628622055, -0.03187542408704758, -0.012668623588979244, -0.02073061838746071, 0.012123729102313519, -0.012453400529921055, 0.004176422953605652, 0.003050154307857156, 0.02853463962674141, -0.0016070982674136758, -0.03739115595817566, -0.00045252032577991486, -0.00395782757550478, 0.0478077158331871, 0.021665384992957115, -0.0037386182229965925, 0.017887359485030174, 0.05607154220342636, 0.0003615044697653502, -0.014115571044385433, -0.013676812872290611, -0.03359389305114746, 0.0823577418923378, 0.01925988495349884, -0.013775140978395939, 0.0071416893042624, 0.031491998583078384, -0.032553404569625854, -0.029166145250201225, -0.024149341508746147, -0.005062628071755171, 0.01703157275915146, 0.007352737244218588, 0.03218759596347809, 0.03290121257305145, -0.009449559263885021, -0.009707554243505001, -0.016173018142580986, -0.025735288858413696, -0.03297068178653717, -0.013791837729513645, 0.04516395926475525, 0.0004119933000765741, -0.0073051778599619865, 0.035243939608335495, -0.00261788722127676, 0.01577155664563179, 0.013813908211886883, 0.00148084107786417, 0.005768180824816227, 0.048439204692840576, -0.008480601944029331, -0.030095288529992104, 0.03518685698509216, -0.06835294514894485, 0.004628647118806839, -0.02123056910932064, -0.035965144634246826, 0.055719826370477676, 0.0008209971711039543, 0.03296656161546707, -0.06733870506286621, -0.008498938754200935, -0.01951860636472702, 0.015485059469938278, 0.008931589312851429, 0.003981835674494505, 0.04470245912671089, -0.0029444601386785507, -0.02423729933798313, -0.016907574608922005, -0.003001644043251872, 0.004130059853196144, -0.08296698331832886, -0.052251849323511124, -0.023651594296097755, -0.039930474013090134, -0.005205389577895403, 0.017389537766575813, -0.06161859631538391, 0.015042933635413647, -0.05784601718187332, 0.01998547837138176, 0.023324867710471153, 0.015368390828371048, -0.0019755600951611996, 0.03506932780146599, 0.016323385760188103, 0.051067568361759186, -0.02173295058310032, 0.0030864032451063395, 0.12803272902965546, 0.0866059958934784, 0.0323873907327652, -0.07652702927589417, 0.030647695064544678, -0.0058716363273561, 0.0148057471960783, -0.018677596002817154, -0.021336421370506287, 0.020167334005236626, 0.0008619873551651835, 0.06494414806365967, 0.010789635591208935, 0.02215237356722355, -0.015698278322815895, 0.06643116474151611, -0.08721788227558136, -0.014477843418717384, -0.0020858384668827057, -0.008356722071766853, 0.020221039652824402, 0.006779952440410852, -0.04181526601314545, 0.01645502820611, 0.016744941473007202, -0.023625588044524193, -0.012463637627661228, -0.02478206716477871, 0.02202427200973034, -0.0027240992058068514, -0.03287584334611893, -0.01815781742334366, 0.03209460899233818, -0.02013363689184189, -0.01857285015285015, -0.004879470448940992, 0.008253505453467369, -0.04385768249630928, -0.02875860594213009, 0.053189609199762344, 0.005558518227189779, 0.0007607683073729277, 0.005573183298110962, 0.00916608702391386, -0.012930543161928654, -0.00799093209207058, -0.03850293904542923, 0.026139022782444954, -0.028202680870890617, -0.004818736109882593, -0.016887743026018143, 0.017824355512857437, 0.010328405536711216, -0.03597716987133026, -0.032987695187330246, 0.03224200755357742, 0.017266279086470604, -0.019584499299526215, -0.026819167658686638, 0.013171368278563023, -0.012055161409080029, 0.02226017788052559, 0.04910324513912201, 0.04093146324157715, -0.035401590168476105, -0.02073417231440544, -0.01631246693432331, 0.049026746302843094, -0.01645292527973652, 0.013139322400093079, 0.022547492757439613, -0.007479419466108084, -0.03106537275016308, 0.008176085539162159, 0.000947922351770103, -0.005800632294267416, 0.0037219671066850424, -0.03645513579249382, -0.009621567092835903, -0.04746875911951065, -0.014012107625603676, 0.013871418312191963, -0.04175766929984093, 0.01456731092184782, -0.0444318950176239, -0.0011813777964562178, 0.03215567022562027, 0.04270845279097557, -0.0009242645464837551, 0.024666111916303635, -0.0014984533190727234, 0.0315198190510273, -0.01854672096669674, -0.05265641584992409, -0.020477984100580215, -0.004510498605668545, -0.05932565778493881, -0.0050692083314061165, 0.00746117252856493, 0.07094291597604752, 0.041441965848207474, 0.03847890719771385, 0.013771827332675457, 0.022733476012945175, -0.04789731651544571, 0.031347621232271194, 0.02362930029630661, -0.005161603447049856, -0.0030739244539290667, 0.031599801033735275, 0.03245190531015396, -0.011598845943808556, -0.029672715812921524, -0.0443091057240963, -0.04546568915247917, 0.00823377724736929, -0.006744334939867258, -0.04670575261116028, 0.00794114638119936, 0.01338721439242363, 0.034299030900001526, -0.04068044573068619, -0.021308017894625664, -0.04738817363977432, 0.0025829412043094635, 0.007695023901760578, -0.024192774668335915, 0.005868988111615181, -0.009129716083407402, -0.003965763375163078, -0.010314404964447021, 0.025673406198620796, 0.020277708768844604, 0.020955750718712807, 0.017893875017762184, 0.044132862240076065, 0.0021681946236640215, 0.013473819009959698, -0.04780079051852226, -0.03254404291510582, 0.006749562919139862, -0.018836313858628273, -0.06595310568809509, 0.011585380882024765, -0.02487659640610218, 0.013883374631404877, 0.01848163641989231, 0.009794415906071663, -0.025269828736782074, 0.033005084842443466, -0.001940669841133058, -0.002969445427879691, -0.04233741760253906, 0.015580322593450546, 0.012676038779318333, -0.009125501848757267, -0.009095066227018833, -0.020103417336940765, -0.01451938133686781, 0.006197411101311445, 0.058838579803705215, -0.00042915079393424094, -0.01051650382578373, 0.01460644043982029, 0.013747136108577251, 0.025950146839022636, 0.005846290849149227, 0.021372126415371895, 0.05479656904935837, 0.05394716188311577, -0.030892672017216682, 0.01694003865122795, -0.006926456931978464, 0.02899278700351715, -0.08882755786180496, -0.04693739116191864, -0.001521882601082325, 0.007444563787430525, -0.0015012506628409028, -0.02797437086701393, -0.029137348756194115, 0.03321922570466995, -0.05570477247238159, 0.03216302767395973, 0.010124461725354195, -0.027185413986444473, -0.048617951571941376, -0.0021502776071429253, 0.008531040512025356, 0.052360523492097855, 0.042682647705078125, 0.04101601615548134, 0.011258593760430813, 0.004188947379589081, 0.024660738185048103, -0.013658296316862106, -0.0016162715619429946, 0.00934530608355999, -0.04440157115459442, -0.03958519548177719, 0.028569048270583153, -0.027655651792883873, -0.0001703721354715526, 0.02971065603196621, 0.021476801484823227, 0.03817123547196388, 0.08005241304636002, 0.05437442287802696, 0.035235241055488586, 0.037758201360702515, 0.012671418488025665, 0.01682240143418312, -0.05709337070584297, 0.013199315406382084, 0.03277524933218956, 0.02167876996099949, -0.04686848446726799, 0.011213897727429867, 0.0037557417526841164, -0.016773667186498642, -0.012519929558038712, 0.017949549481272697, -0.00022845763305667788, -0.014428582042455673, -0.012084870599210262, -0.0010518437484279275, -0.03128408268094063, -0.030620601028203964, -0.000242448368226178, -0.06546894460916519, -0.01588554121553898, 0.04538622871041298, 0.011755960993468761, -0.04204001650214195, -0.011408386752009392, -0.022596752271056175, -0.0007034396985545754, 0.02642880380153656, -0.00047033748705871403, 0.0059469640254974365, -0.040385156869888306, 0.039558183401823044, 0.024422675371170044, -0.02585741877555847, 0.022393830120563507, 0.005657984409481287, -0.05275304988026619, 0.015332086943089962, 0.014786437153816223, 0.009084932506084442, 0.021535061299800873, -0.04492591321468353, 0.009090125560760498, -0.09733154624700546, 0.11292984336614609, -0.001932737766765058, -0.021505193784832954, -0.04106208309531212, 0.01099510956555605, -0.036906372755765915, -0.005828017368912697, 0.08774738013744354, 0.0010364436311647296, 0.007339265197515488, 0.01478093396872282, 0.07129211723804474, -0.005227960180491209, -0.020164266228675842, 0.018680712208151817, 0.012551292777061462, -0.043951600790023804, -0.022716332226991653, -0.010506770573556423, -0.009998166933655739, 0.020731817930936813, 0.018624786287546158, -0.007099083624780178, 0.022048544138669968, 0.006497680209577084, -0.03550824522972107, 0.01159691996872425, -0.024133261293172836, -0.017995841801166534, 0.04916592687368393, -0.007292155642062426, 0.012545024044811726, 0.021825212985277176, 0.0018539010779932141, -0.07867876440286636, 0.010186082683503628, -0.027724243700504303, 0.011649183928966522, -0.044949937611818314, 0.003216818440705538, 0.0211923960596323, -0.037020035088062286, 0.026900233700871468, 0.05247519910335541, -0.04228435456752777, -0.007623784244060516, 0.0013314193347468972, -0.003577109193429351, 0.043266426771879196, -0.02259761467576027, -0.003960016183555126, -0.0064693717285990715, -0.020283475518226624, 0.028152527287602425, 0.010166812688112259, 0.019158853217959404, 0.0022905736695975065, 0.015857163816690445, 0.021517788991332054, 0.025108538568019867, 0.053523167967796326, 0.00014216585259418935, 0.04851008206605911, -0.039582304656505585, -0.0019177754875272512, -0.00040246598655357957, -0.035086244344711304, 0.01801113225519657, -0.0031867583747953176, 0.024481862783432007, 0.07962223887443542, -0.015837013721466064, 0.01678120158612728, -0.008905097842216492, -0.006586140021681786, -0.032881177961826324, -0.04027516394853592, 0.031709861010313034, 0.0048274993896484375, 0.0024586094077676535, -0.012696410529315472, 0.015479860827326775, -0.005598722957074642, -0.010366966016590595, -0.019488777965307236, 0.0030774823389947414, -0.0068145208060741425, -0.006445886101573706, -0.022602936252951622, -0.013956474140286446, -0.029398953542113304, -0.045244429260492325, 0.03343414515256882, 0.027317799627780914, 0.039727430790662766, 0.01306905783712864, -0.009782419539988041, -0.03538891300559044, 0.03602506220340729, -0.059170085936784744, -0.023455265909433365, -0.030536450445652008, 0.027148442342877388, 0.0034621162340044975, -0.04121876880526543 ]
<p>I have a data set of recorded elephant locations for the span of 6 years (elephantdata). Some of the entries are duplicates of the same day. I want to create a subset of my 'elephantdata' and create a new matrix that only has one data point before noon and one data point after noon for each day. I would like that data point to be selected randomly from the data points offered.</p> <p>For example:</p> <pre><code>elephantdata Row Date Time Breeding_H E1 E2 E3 1 11/01/06 08:38 1 0 0 0 2 11/01/06 18:00 1 0 0 0 3 12/01/06 05:38 1 0 0 0 4 02/02/06 08:58 1 0 0 0 5 02/02/06 16:30 1 1 1 1 6 02/02/06 17:15 1 1 1 1 7 03/02/06 08:45 1 0 0 0 </code></pre> <p>For Breeding_H I want to find that if the 'Date' is a duplicate AND two entries are in the morning (before 12:00) or in the evening (after noon) I want R to randomly chose one of the entries. So Row 6 and 7 are both after noon and on the same day, so I would like to only have one of those data entries.</p> <p>Any suggestions? Would really appreciate any help you've got. I've looked up the 'unique' and 'duplicated' function but I don't know how to write the actual code to make this happen. </p>
73,680
[ -0.03757653757929802, -0.021731218323111534, 0.03047027811408043, 0.00826209969818592, 0.009026382118463516, -0.005894034169614315, -0.01930372416973114, -0.015333292074501514, 0.013321097940206528, -0.022628076374530792, 0.018454888835549355, 0.05706305801868439, 0.021703217178583145, 0.05989161133766174, 0.058329567313194275, -0.015578938648104668, 0.010435527190566063, 0.007397366221994162, -0.008504687808454037, -0.03649018332362175, 0.005655967630445957, -0.01654941216111183, 0.023242371156811714, -0.0068863253109157085, -0.026271209120750427, 0.03268801420927048, 0.040922585874795914, 0.0004565272538457066, 0.002990467008203268, 0.08983762562274933, -0.06853100657463074, -0.08507890999317169, 0.06060945242643356, 0.04062732681632042, 0.045617446303367615, -0.009364387951791286, -0.021124154329299927, -0.033620916306972504, -0.014337766915559769, 0.0017176258843392134, -0.017999544739723206, 0.007242816034704447, -0.004323028959333897, 0.03528444841504097, 0.006128381006419659, 0.04932025447487831, -0.023522179573774338, -0.01758427731692791, 0.03048836812376976, -0.055182550102472305, 0.0705503597855568, -0.02705361321568489, 0.00938432291150093, 0.01685563288629055, -0.026269657537341118, 0.0037475554272532463, 0.012178964912891388, 0.0627230629324913, 0.014470807276666164, -0.011960569769144058, -0.02285091206431389, -0.034699663519859314, -0.010788917541503906, 0.012342404574155807, -0.03540942445397377, -0.01470747496932745, -0.0294874906539917, 0.004421756137162447, 0.02350187487900257, -0.056900572031736374, 0.003576329443603754, 0.022861290723085403, 0.03589630872011185, -0.00790073536336422, 0.009485693648457527, -0.05699463561177254, 0.04083322733640671, 0.014719094149768353, 0.06174776703119278, -0.0054238238371908665, 0.00570097379386425, 0.031470488756895065, 0.03311648592352867, 0.02929641865193844, 0.05479009449481964, -0.013518468476831913, 0.019523002207279205, -0.06663689762353897, 0.024323448538780212, 0.026045246049761772, -0.016374478116631508, 0.022342173382639885, 0.05405493080615997, 0.05361313372850418, -0.06631828099489212, 0.046525683254003525, 0.026040038093924522, 0.0157469492405653, 0.014213972724974155, 0.016523921862244606, -0.016367068514227867, -0.05717109516263008, 0.03243810310959816, 0.0354374535381794, -0.03565629571676254, -0.007704081479460001, -0.01377082895487547, -0.013786839321255684, 0.02123369090259075, -0.023656342178583145, -0.012285981327295303, 0.02056146413087845, 0.03356894105672836, -0.02734098583459854, -0.0023869811557233334, -0.04787826165556908, -0.012335214763879776, 0.034129682928323746, 0.05983097851276398, 0.07078326493501663, 0.02223413623869419, 0.01741959899663925, 0.04061920568346977, -0.07559321820735931, -0.06565453857183456, 0.005469641648232937, -0.007050320040434599, 0.019237354397773743, -0.020652316510677338, 0.06445976346731186, -0.032004594802856445, -0.015745483338832855, 0.060690462589263916, -0.02421412616968155, 0.041142068803310394, 0.007221100851893425, -0.09430000931024551, -0.02988850697875023, 0.031786348670721054, -0.04901678115129471, 0.006321375723928213, -0.017648274078965187, 0.039010483771562576, -0.028066998347640038, 0.007144523784518242, 0.003932525869458914, 0.027501465752720833, 0.020331209525465965, -0.025832680985331535, 0.030676688998937607, -0.025362268090248108, -0.005932989995926619, 0.006270954385399818, -0.01004528347402811, 0.004702034406363964, -0.07495906203985214, -0.005654570180922747, -0.004729812033474445, -0.021201349794864655, -0.019809555262327194, 0.04421854019165039, -0.0285318773239851, -0.0023301958572119474, -0.009707785211503506, 0.004310834687203169, -0.04583386704325676, 0.05870293453335762, 0.016931118443608284, 0.015984799712896347, 0.0390683114528656, -0.03378479182720184, 0.02857133373618126, -0.0137703912332654, 0.04773254692554474, 0.03698236867785454, 0.004113640636205673, 0.016607141122221947, 0.004321512300521135, 0.03308027982711792, 0.02459755912423134, -0.01074843667447567, -0.0055884490720927715, -0.00510899955406785, -0.03072231262922287, 0.041515760123729706, 0.042696788907051086, -0.005670890212059021, -0.01788300648331642, 0.010588166303932667, -0.04432256147265434, -0.04144274815917015, -0.057208746671676636, 0.007573549635708332, -0.001374207902699709, -0.02935006655752659, -0.005679248366504908, 0.01683599129319191, 0.024702871218323708, -0.002250255551189184, -0.02955458126962185, -0.04451870173215866, -0.02283031865954399, 0.045921795070171356, -0.05240258574485779, -0.04713096097111702, 0.061642326414585114, 0.02962987869977951, -0.010586670599877834, 0.01976740173995495, -0.020809262990951538, 0.0056791044771671295, -0.00631696218624711, -0.06322351843118668, 0.01220093946903944, -0.04560689628124237, 0.06552978605031967, 0.05767429992556572, 0.03389716520905495, -0.015586039051413536, 0.008067766204476357, -0.04040597006678581, 0.008233490400016308, 0.04845362529158592, 0.015128279104828835, 0.015890656039118767, -0.02045036107301712, 0.01799711585044861, 0.014806789346039295, 0.012879064306616783, -0.036194056272506714, -0.015792036429047585, 0.013936479575932026, 0.023020315915346146, -0.0008623182657174766, 0.005419692490249872, 0.021547812968492508, 0.08336104452610016, 0.004054663702845573, 0.024745579808950424, 0.07986441999673843, -0.017694490030407906, 0.07024562358856201, 0.013460908085107803, -0.023182762786746025, 0.031262271106243134, 0.031838558614254, 0.0423932820558548, -0.010497869923710823, 0.041413161903619766, -0.0007208309834823012, -0.01000408548861742, 0.06580940634012222, 0.0052175140008330345, 0.01392260380089283, -0.00798182561993599, -0.03645879030227661, 0.04042269289493561, -0.00968144927173853, 0.002835941966623068, 0.049732137471437454, 0.011630956083536148, -0.015207139775156975, -0.010486789047718048, -0.06489581614732742, -0.017044808715581894, 0.01761559024453163, -0.04104866832494736, -0.011040637269616127, 0.016405295580625534, -0.03569246083498001, 0.027293317019939423, -0.02589992620050907, 0.0008099919650703669, -0.032889094203710556, 0.0504780113697052, 0.046874117106199265, -0.013394210487604141, 0.01829703524708748, -0.037162765860557556, -0.019007936120033264, -0.04522256553173065, -0.005965835880488157, 0.010989664122462273, -0.013241620734333992, -0.07481224089860916, 0.014268516562879086, -0.022060902789235115, -0.028636975213885307, 0.054426904767751694, -0.003425656585022807, -0.058591123670339584, -0.0018270100699737668, 0.007774041034281254, -0.014032664708793163, 0.003961628768593073, -0.013677840121090412, 0.019990261644124985, -0.022411515936255455, 0.002672228729352355, 0.02917194366455078, 0.03482719138264656, -0.009762664325535297, -0.017742455005645752, -0.04461490735411644, 0.006348075810819864, -0.01772771030664444, -0.0038837504107505083, 0.02662353776395321, -0.019290806725621223, 0.0083268191665411, 0.042189259082078934, 0.00898039061576128, 0.013967711478471756, -0.04473813250660896, -0.05162719264626503, -0.024570079520344734, -0.0025928376708179712, 0.003885900368914008, 0.005613141227513552, 0.005595187656581402, 0.013673323206603527, 0.04088270664215088, -0.041309889405965805, -0.02440127544105053, -0.003341559786349535, -0.05054003745317459, -0.050116539001464844, 0.026606520637869835, 0.008609076030552387, 0.00041882460936903954, -0.010257677175104618, 0.0029651063960045576, 0.0304162185639143, 0.05315255746245384, 0.0021879528649151325, -0.015213822945952415, -0.003286386141553521, -0.017706384882330894, -0.035876963287591934, 0.019651534035801888, 0.02496790699660778, -0.04189733788371086, 0.006062530446797609, -0.040682874619960785, -0.01028217189013958, -0.0013655881630256772, -0.03586481884121895, -0.01147164311259985, -0.009317555464804173, 0.07985927164554596, -0.003116571344435215, 0.01032054703682661, 0.0016585352132096887, -0.011033479124307632, -0.015646839514374733, -0.015136622823774815, 0.0739302858710289, -0.04127422347664833, -0.011168001219630241, 0.07950989902019501, 0.04648451507091522, -0.0021885023452341557, 0.03516023978590965, -0.007654402870684862, 0.04989312216639519, 0.025159504264593124, -0.036825694143772125, -0.015572011470794678, 0.010478110983967781, 0.021167291328310966, 0.015650542452931404, -0.0035528161097317934, -0.023078231140971184, 0.0033985143527388573, -0.03830258175730705, 0.0019857098814100027, 0.00001849424370448105, 0.05423752963542938, 0.0028659335803240538, 0.05322875455021858, 0.03314698487520218, -0.04490020498633385, 0.02451983466744423, -0.01136822160333395, -0.06177259981632233, 0.02341977134346962, 0.006944966968148947, -0.022411184385418892, 0.008948574773967266, -0.017641309648752213, 0.0199284628033638, -0.024985941126942635, -0.01869584433734417, 0.03489957004785538, 0.027061402797698975, -0.029761897400021553, 0.015267914161086082, -0.021796323359012604, 0.00046352390199899673, -0.03963660076260567, 0.01598617434501648, 0.04912756383419037, 0.012675193138420582, 0.04921804741024971, 0.03150515630841255, 0.009043022990226746, 0.010210974141955376, 0.019795719534158707, -0.019305964931845665, -0.020162859931588173, 0.020957324653863907, 0.001553945243358612, 0.04561178386211395, -0.005426855757832527, 0.006640947423875332, -0.013393671251833439, 0.02938566729426384, 0.045481618493795395, 0.020210741087794304, 0.003585581900551915, 0.00772787444293499, 0.027783572673797607, 0.010254674591124058, 0.011899210512638092, -0.036265768110752106, -0.015124529600143433, 0.0327768437564373, 0.025065133348107338, -0.07175905257463455, -0.015209914185106754, 0.09948555380105972, 0.0289737768471241, 0.0005006103310734034, -0.049851272255182266, 0.0038132101763039827, -0.0012369309552013874, -0.0001326736091868952, 0.005319945979863405, 0.00021189507970120758, 0.01414045225828886, -0.012003744952380657, 0.0019559769425541162, -0.040478892624378204, 0.02998051792383194, 0.004616808146238327, -0.014618095010519028, 0.05384945124387741, -0.0075243571773171425, -0.022800344973802567, -0.01834305003285408, 0.017038922756910324, 0.042019426822662354, 0.02522686868906021, 0.0008569880155846477, -0.05353064090013504, -0.015712788328528404, 0.035390034317970276, 0.042496129870414734, -0.025201428681612015, -0.010491766035556793, -0.0574411079287529, -0.0025527121033519506, 0.02739865891635418, -0.047790832817554474, 0.03352590277791023, -0.00016217913071159273, -0.016015566885471344, -0.03860575705766678, -0.0024825334548950195, -0.02764933370053768, 0.009132555685937405, -0.015821615234017372, 0.0551612451672554, -0.03131527453660965, -0.04848502203822136, -0.018457306548953056, 0.026903733611106873, 0.009874307550489902, 0.0433121882379055, -0.031931322067976, -0.016916640102863312, 0.03318068012595177, -0.002736384281888604, -0.019720567390322685, -0.05392564460635185, 0.0158334132283926, -0.0014559357659891248, -0.01202955562621355, 0.04327309876680374, -0.03274373337626457, 0.015166421420872211, 0.01588205248117447, 0.03201432153582573, 0.0004916628822684288, -0.001871666288934648, -0.022721679881215096, -0.00581850903108716, 0.003928197082132101, 0.003049261402338743, 0.047306787222623825, 0.046034056693315506, -0.0073601724579930305, -0.0022727632895112038, -0.04334118217229843, 0.006342980545014143, 0.020908569917082787, -0.0017119733383879066, -0.0722135528922081, 0.025383301079273224, -0.024315176531672478, -0.0012970573734492064, -0.0071076760068535805, 0.02715134061872959, -0.008473113179206848, 0.0180678628385067, -0.028591347858309746, 0.054755620658397675, -0.031228799372911453, -0.0375470332801342, -0.0010765197221189737, 0.0005749246338382363, -0.028912756592035294, 0.01936350017786026, 0.019924921914935112, -0.026975074782967567, -0.0174716766923666, 0.019445383921265602, -0.007641208823770285, 0.017351742833852768, 0.0018899329006671906, -0.008409049361944199, 0.044015008956193924, -0.055146604776382446, 0.002827512566000223, -0.03608540818095207, 0.033296138048172, 0.024367963895201683, -0.04394674301147461, 0.010720840655267239, 0.032352689653635025, -0.00455970736220479, -0.004134621005505323, -0.012418027967214584, 0.0607413575053215, -0.008901790715754032, 0.006923867389559746, -0.05936390534043312, -0.02880077250301838, -0.0058580730110406876, 0.004861700348556042, -0.03359527140855789, -0.06248435005545616, -0.03420243039727211, -0.036524102091789246, -0.013451175764203072, -0.03666049242019653, 0.028440702706575394, -0.005977622698992491, 0.004000224173069, 0.0014363351510837674, 0.034191153943538666, 0.0733199268579483, 0.05629149079322815, 0.023905374109745026, 0.04524124786257744, -0.013430329971015453, -0.001142085762694478, 0.016796637326478958, 0.012360348366200924, -0.02402174472808838, -0.036351751536130905, -0.011934117414057255, 0.03418321534991264, 0.026555374264717102, -0.022182434797286987, 0.0007714270032010972, 0.00401791837066412, 0.025591909885406494, 0.004992322996258736, -0.05732514336705208, 0.0371723510324955, -0.010574945248663425, -0.019791115075349808, -0.027533436194062233, 0.035651013255119324, -0.003259993391111493, -0.027283789590001106, 0.015535932034254074, -0.03855106607079506, 0.005771423690021038, 0.02045992575585842, 0.07462809234857559, -0.026811735704541206, -0.014650949276983738, -0.010317993350327015, -0.03931371122598648, 0.0252120029181242, 0.013795588165521622, -0.0007490778807550669, -0.004628610331565142, 0.0005809636786580086, -0.022756721824407578, -0.009256311692297459, -0.010064747184515, -0.00460043316707015, 0.054076410830020905, -0.020666029304265976, 0.019188785925507545, 0.0602433942258358, 0.03764190152287483, -0.03225291147828102, -0.021727148443460464, 0.008649871684610844, -0.01160885114222765, 0.012293160893023014, 0.06784404069185257, 0.026171114295721054, -0.003075143788009882, 0.034142639487981796, 0.0032420314382761717, 0.05826331675052643, 0.036870960146188736, 0.026312556117773056, 0.01669071428477764, 0.028915969654917717, 0.005081080365926027, -0.024330951273441315, -0.015084815211594105, -0.028285907581448555, 0.035231877118349075, -0.03362986445426941, -0.055514320731163025, 0.037916287779808044, 0.021878821775317192, -0.03799867630004883, -0.027901889756321907, -0.05152834206819534, -0.07343043386936188, 0.011329247616231441, 0.012298726476728916, -0.025398002937436104, 0.02534271962940693, 0.06392264366149902, 0.03979945927858353, 0.002640210557729006, -0.00037127791438251734, -0.012254645116627216, -0.06548792123794556, 0.010628213174641132, -0.059717386960983276, -0.03361779823899269, 0.054597195237874985, 0.0061607020907104015, -0.040423035621643066, 0.043116454035043716, -0.024245059117674828, -0.009318418800830841, 0.02590925619006157, 0.060463111847639084, 0.024039898067712784, 0.07913213968276978, -0.014200856909155846, -0.00917632132768631, 0.022898497059941292, -0.0016161211533471942, 0.11058832705020905, 0.0969180315732956, 0.02943366765975952, -0.059479206800460815, 0.004007618874311447, 0.02503870241343975, -0.016559865325689316, -0.05425463244318962, -0.00969968643039465, -0.005888507701456547, 0.024341268464922905, 0.06289747357368469, -0.0043681468814611435, 0.05846119672060013, -0.007410035468637943, 0.039217520505189896, -0.03032113052904606, -0.022995850071310997, -0.005189725663512945, 0.04641430452466011, 0.013803189620375633, -0.013331329450011253, -0.033944062888622284, -0.0034127288963645697, 0.042920034378767014, -0.004540394060313702, -0.046060387045145035, -0.05874743312597275, -0.029769621789455414, 0.03326219692826271, 0.017609013244509697, 0.018501758575439453, -0.005678244400769472, 0.03882025554776192, 0.0264192596077919, 0.0009166066301986575, 0.015476766042411327, -0.04011211171746254, -0.006071075797080994, 0.031654536724090576, 0.020861681550741196, -0.0255047008395195, 0.008519047871232033, 0.016236508265137672, -0.04028733819723129, -0.020007196813821793, -0.028940176591277122, 0.035153526812791824, -0.023798497393727303, -0.026683123782277107, -0.0024243632797151804, 0.012912963517010212, 0.018219372257590294, -0.0584874153137207, -0.025027329102158546, 0.008490825071930885, 0.06556869298219681, -0.03803021088242531, 0.010509328916668892, -0.006715818773955107, 0.02237066440284252, -0.027586307376623154, 0.011664423160254955, 0.0005669273086823523, -0.017941785976290703, -0.013552405871450901, -0.05928686261177063, 0.05701456964015961, -0.016682680696249008, 0.0037878933362662792, -0.012840863317251205, -0.023208925500512123, -0.012721013277769089, 0.0036835854407399893, 0.007443762384355068, -0.029394757002592087, -0.0029238404240459204, -0.025364337489008904, -0.02841869369149208, 0.010167906992137432, -0.024805638939142227, 0.03331894800066948, 0.01068207435309887, -0.0064568775705993176, -0.016674159094691277, 0.019811954349279404, 0.03473805636167526, 0.018020614981651306, 0.04758099466562271, -0.0049534747377038, -0.033078525215387344, 0.044268518686294556, -0.014758721925318241, -0.030582420527935028, -0.025917883962392807, 0.004358937963843346, -0.00010670780466170982, 0.007312208414077759, -0.027388010174036026, 0.06158612668514252, -0.006690018344670534, -0.0138248885050416, -0.022585878148674965, 0.004673417657613754, 0.00755317835137248, 0.016873300075531006, 0.027431990951299667, -0.055515680462121964, -0.01189423818141222, -0.003521575126796961, -0.013657810166478157, -0.035237833857536316, -0.02801266871392727, -0.026347193866968155, -0.046111125499010086, -0.010761053301393986, -0.022540194913744926, -0.033625610172748566, -0.02063813805580139, -0.02922009490430355, 0.017185747623443604, -0.029327386990189552, 0.0319170281291008, -0.006802982650697231, -0.019884198904037476, -0.006411445792764425, -0.021782631054520607, -0.03063117526471615, 0.0007236803066916764, -0.0035645663738250732, 0.004434620961546898, 0.01509303878992796, -0.012006031349301338, -0.008129572495818138, -0.02170744352042675, 0.03251773118972778, -0.012968895025551319, 0.07978766411542892, 0.011827198788523674, -0.02642996981739998, 0.03645201399922371, -0.05040790140628815, -0.046178411692380905, 0.01958107016980648, 0.022865599021315575, 0.0397040918469429, 0.02102760411798954, -0.019773080945014954, 0.0325033962726593, 0.046934861689805984, -0.031058859080076218, -0.01816047728061676, 0.01573793962597847, 0.015994148328900337, 0.0418749675154686, 0.015660692006349564, -0.014679113402962685, -0.021472761407494545, -0.03456031531095505, 0.028124975040555, 0.07293743640184402, 0.005116878543049097, -0.021518977358937263, -0.011467644944787025, 0.020106051117181778, 0.019778944551944733, 0.01363646611571312, -0.033058010041713715, 0.027392307296395302, 0.031307853758335114, -0.010713049210608006, 0.02030196227133274, -0.004528800491243601, -0.03975103795528412, -0.04587783291935921, -0.016891151666641235, 0.009239749051630497, -0.05349750071763992, 0.04991116374731064, -0.03838510811328888, -0.014245525002479553, 0.04053498059511185, -0.050377119332551956, 0.019452746957540512, 0.04649456962943077, 0.0024407042656093836, -0.004214733373373747, 0.042080268263816833, -0.024789001792669296, -0.014160874299705029, 0.038285985589027405, -0.019704412668943405, 0.06273576617240906, 0.011655992828309536, 0.026249142363667488, -0.06223110854625702, -0.011992215178906918, 0.035228431224823, 0.008346467278897762, -0.04690645635128021, 0.0010250888299196959, -0.026953017339110374, 0.001571766333654523, 0.0010749318171292543, -0.05033864825963974, 0.012332497164607048, 0.015936892479658127, 0.015213322825729847, 0.008428061380982399, 0.02973984368145466, 0.014852453023195267, 0.04467083886265755, -0.05425247550010681, 0.038621578365564346, 0.007542431354522705, 0.005220871418714523, 0.02557237260043621, 0.032845061272382736, -0.007923166267573833, -0.031540460884571075, -0.02978535182774067, 0.05028415843844414, -0.0200345516204834, -0.017352016642689705, -0.008390086703002453, -0.00021333538461476564, 0.00853848084807396, -0.024073513224720955, -0.018192341551184654, -0.016870170831680298, 0.008085647597908974, 0.04548445716500282, 0.015830617398023605, -0.013597511686384678, 0.005886348430067301, -0.04083108901977539, -0.03576738387346268, 0.003823614213615656, 0.01688176579773426, 0.026535550132393837, -0.058532364666461945, -0.035623714327812195, -0.008662926964461803, 0.021878445520997047, -0.010591357946395874, -0.008166481740772724, -0.009234759956598282, 0.02505800500512123, -0.006498136557638645, -0.008976029232144356, 0.022559145465493202, -0.011792652308940887, 0.03881148248910904, -0.04984813183546066, 0.04910537227988243, -0.0027080534491688013, -0.0012757055228576064, -0.04809406399726868, -0.034973178058862686, -0.062165215611457825, 0.06593518704175949, 0.02715168707072735, 0.011815987527370453, 0.018769346177577972, -0.008170229382812977, 0.03532112017273903, -0.00625753216445446, -0.06098618358373642, 0.06881166994571686, 0.022070441395044327, -0.004505964927375317, 0.006709192879498005, -0.032376885414123535, 0.021363770589232445, 0.014819168485701084, -0.011769100092351437, 0.005424984265118837, 0.004844615235924721, 0.028402408584952354, -0.016324428841471672, 0.008393541909754276, -0.02793247438967228, -0.012576132081449032, -0.007581143639981747, -0.017973767593503, -0.02176397107541561, 0.020432330667972565, -0.004674138501286507, -0.030553461983799934, 0.019018802791833878, -0.08472005277872086, -0.03856595605611801, 0.014205902814865112, -0.009423854760825634, 0.00577147351577878, -0.08118405193090439, 0.0008729176479391754, -0.029895734041929245, -0.019368378445506096, -0.01757185347378254, 0.019126860424876213, 0.003980256617069244, 0.04546869173645973, -0.03464347869157791, 0.007796041667461395, -0.025706544518470764, -0.01581445522606373, -0.00899563543498516, 0.004037807695567608, -0.007263802457600832, -0.030256027355790138, -0.01590578816831112, 0.004858320578932762, 0.04853478819131851, 0.058086883276700974, -0.007451649755239487, 0.045810211449861526, 0.011229855939745903, -0.016978684812784195, 0.02544551156461239, -0.0011009855661541224, 0.017974313348531723, -0.01837962493300438, 0.010128190740942955, 0.026555249467492104, -0.004504411481320858, -0.004390866030007601, -0.00903300940990448, -0.04002438485622406, -0.016017112880945206, 0.03688827529549599, 0.03264867141842842, 0.016052307561039925, -0.02879105880856514, 0.005633788648992777, -0.01520790159702301, 0.009206941351294518, 0.020743638277053833, -0.039658546447753906, 0.02509094960987568, -0.027067452669143677, 0.003399297595024109, -0.03231426328420639, -0.010180768556892872, -0.011051004752516747, -0.025700639933347702, -0.010021284222602844, 0.026348769664764404, 0.017744986340403557, -0.0478573739528656, -0.019932284951210022, -0.0032197299879044294, 0.01871119812130928, -0.06378689408302307, -0.03169267997145653, -0.04232850298285484, 0.004026863723993301, -0.04451603814959526, 0.001147485920228064 ]
<p>Good evening everyeone,</p> <p>I am currently working on a set of self-study questions which relate to true/false answers. I am currently faced with a question where the answer claims for it to be false, but I find it true. Not sure if there is an error in the answer. Appreciate some help and advice please.</p> <blockquote> <p>A confidence interval is an estimate for which there is a specified degree of certainty that the sample statistic will be in the interval. </p> </blockquote> <p>My take is that the above <strong>statement is true</strong> as the confidence interval tells us with a specific degree of confidence how likely a value will fall within the range. </p> <p>Appreciate some advice please.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/mzKSx.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
36,116
[ -0.008926852606236935, -0.06413308531045914, -0.0012354180216789246, 0.01396816223859787, 0.029193496331572533, 0.021572517231106758, 0.005234322044998407, -0.007251347880810499, 0.019549839198589325, -0.02550852671265602, 0.048154763877391815, 0.02866392955183983, 0.041581589728593826, 0.014059229753911495, -0.008668870665133, 0.05255848169326782, -0.01583004929125309, -0.0013437370071187615, -0.012933076359331608, 0.0033949194476008415, -0.0006348688621073961, 0.03689127415418625, -0.015361781232059002, -0.02786191552877426, -0.037214722484350204, 0.017513079568743706, 0.04452093318104744, -0.01126941666007042, 0.015676818788051605, 0.08245287090539932, -0.07526732236146927, -0.03735252469778061, 0.023838408291339874, 0.06643659621477127, 0.022368425503373146, -0.007978872396051884, -0.026008957996964455, -0.006728765554726124, 0.009966474026441574, 0.04345574229955673, -0.03237973898649216, -0.007271773647516966, 0.015736818313598633, 0.05349516496062279, -0.0007805190980434418, 0.009153470396995544, -0.02121245115995407, -0.047704100608825684, 0.0213076900690794, -0.018274009227752686, 0.0814836323261261, -0.018244296312332153, 0.05286724120378494, 0.040591415017843246, 0.001968417316675186, -0.022347940132021904, 0.06339723616838455, 0.048424601554870605, -0.039064522832632065, -0.05580375716090202, -0.0037316158413887024, -0.03745361790060997, -0.00023034846526570618, 0.005976231303066015, -0.028891418129205704, 0.007712440099567175, -0.0351279079914093, 0.0043997750617563725, 0.008209049701690674, 0.006916289683431387, 0.005002749618142843, 0.031366296112537384, 0.022041775286197662, -0.0016916533932089806, 0.02511613443493843, -0.05930589139461517, 0.03731571510434151, 0.035923395305871964, 0.033780213445425034, 0.05181218311190605, -0.017992017790675163, 0.018348833546042442, 0.0362907350063324, 0.018500078469514847, 0.031444333493709564, -0.02690788544714451, 0.056298620998859406, -0.02413938380777836, 0.02434028685092926, 0.02149941772222519, -0.003805712331086397, 0.016622895374894142, 0.00327221374027431, -0.012908163480460644, 0.004669425543397665, 0.0337558388710022, -0.0373372808098793, 0.030151983723044395, 0.008283630013465881, -0.008397995494306087, -0.004873223602771759, -0.02927728183567524, 0.06072048470377922, 0.05308185890316963, -0.02567017823457718, -0.00939710158854723, 0.0025222869589924812, -0.015384376049041748, 0.02518131025135517, -0.017204374074935913, 0.015616076067090034, 0.029767882078886032, 0.02271950989961624, 0.011453735642135143, 0.026123695075511932, -0.01652172952890396, 0.004621413070708513, -0.013539616018533707, 0.04362894967198372, 0.011499636806547642, 0.014860494993627071, -0.017602836713194847, 0.002803390845656395, -0.0157951507717371, -0.02278612181544304, 0.004876602441072464, -0.006279573775827885, 0.006763530429452658, -0.03318096324801445, 0.038609579205513, -0.020467523485422134, 0.0020895591005682945, 0.0307921152561903, 0.024780964478850365, 0.04252186790108681, -0.030965017154812813, -0.08872014284133911, -0.05740285664796829, 0.03017870895564556, 0.017632581293582916, -0.01466559711843729, -0.06038763374090195, 0.021942537277936935, 0.030581466853618622, 0.02932436391711235, 0.0012134311255067587, 0.0427224300801754, -0.011261397041380405, 0.012009749189019203, 0.0072798579931259155, -0.041160184890031815, 0.005114930681884289, -0.02114848420023918, -0.031730420887470245, -0.001997061539441347, -0.07506377249956131, 0.044242680072784424, -0.010758883319795132, 0.005703898146748543, -0.05098724737763405, 0.009111237712204456, -0.027485501021146774, 0.0025748959742486477, -0.0011983742006123066, 0.04237833991646767, -0.017381737008690834, 0.08238030970096588, 0.009165210649371147, 0.00234705931507051, 0.013231677934527397, 0.003201879793778062, 0.013743930496275425, 0.029052510857582092, 0.014340221881866455, 0.0815921351313591, -0.06041847914457321, -0.016825446859002113, -0.06377074122428894, 0.009599180892109871, -0.018580565229058266, -0.0447051078081131, -0.014474577270448208, -0.02471502684056759, 0.002384369494393468, 0.01996634155511856, 0.05041787773370743, -0.0037164073437452316, -0.04920225590467453, 0.016239510849118233, -0.023949583992362022, -0.027490289881825447, -0.06850939244031906, 0.005809123627841473, 0.0021283836103975773, -0.02505088411271572, -0.011859764344990253, 0.0026410771533846855, 0.009533229283988476, -0.04024262726306915, 0.003184702480211854, -0.030307024717330933, -0.02371974103152752, 0.02726074680685997, -0.05160105600953102, 0.039898354560136795, 0.07400481402873993, 0.04908805713057518, -0.027438854798674583, 0.03172687813639641, -0.029054006561636925, -0.06394258141517639, 0.0011640621814876795, -0.03487782180309296, 0.011425322853028774, 0.014054502360522747, -0.032175321131944656, 0.019970068708062172, -0.006483348086476326, -0.020925411954522133, 0.033127881586551666, -0.04423867166042328, 0.07825967669487, 0.0298262108117342, -0.017504127696156502, -0.01218168344348669, -0.018544647842645645, 0.044058047235012054, -0.004196750000119209, -0.01868852972984314, -0.03501865267753601, -0.07670938968658447, 0.00556016294285655, 0.02200371026992798, 0.007833403535187244, -0.03774414584040642, -0.0039039121475070715, 0.0569985993206501, 0.009087612852454185, -0.0009556188597343862, 0.032375309616327286, 0.00854966789484024, -0.010198782198131084, 0.005279892589896917, 0.038967542350292206, 0.023730315268039703, 0.025385018438100815, -0.014815879985690117, 0.037350136786699295, 0.046356383711099625, 0.011460022069513798, 0.018143370747566223, 0.056836314499378204, -0.005048577673733234, 0.018849432468414307, -0.001323040691204369, -0.023419784381985664, 0.04502252861857414, -0.03653811290860176, -0.002486253622919321, 0.01805112324655056, -0.0187970157712698, 0.005911452230066061, 0.022489946335554123, -0.00903109461069107, 0.0209738090634346, 0.060092855244874954, -0.0762166976928711, -0.004404059611260891, 0.023985300213098526, -0.026232952252030373, -0.03002086468040943, -0.0672069787979126, -0.031170647591352463, 0.00852341391146183, -0.0015829456970095634, 0.03775220364332199, 0.011503112502396107, 0.016522027552127838, -0.020982475951313972, -0.000912352348677814, -0.04591706022620201, -0.02140612155199051, -0.009131953120231628, -0.010197978466749191, -0.08838076144456863, -0.02353900671005249, -0.005863201338797808, -0.051285646855831146, 0.015817923471331596, -0.017231976613402367, -0.001194993732497096, 0.024276500567793846, -0.0071210116147994995, -0.03901326656341553, -0.010884405113756657, -0.027301974594593048, 0.012923487462103367, -0.028823411092162132, -0.03346925601363182, 0.049459632486104965, -0.0069467052817344666, -0.026800308376550674, 0.0540776364505291, 0.00278969993814826, -0.030668409541249275, -0.04904528707265854, 0.02239178493618965, -0.0025041019544005394, -0.014113209210336208, 0.017250530421733856, 0.014253893867135048, 0.02626478485763073, -0.0051759760826826096, -0.06726036965847015, -0.05802120640873909, 0.023362351581454277, 0.0021458573173731565, 0.042277947068214417, -0.004519514739513397, -0.012549945153295994, 0.117100790143013, 0.031729720532894135, -0.024923423305153847, 0.0021234762389212847, -0.02518194541335106, -0.03406985476613045, -0.018219882622361183, -0.013630978763103485, -0.010162655264139175, 0.013345549814403057, 0.019584896042943, -0.0025830052327364683, 0.04843662679195404, 0.006477345712482929, 0.003314337460324168, -0.006008728872984648, -0.007893810048699379, 0.0030211841221898794, -0.028178559616208076, 0.05235222354531288, 0.019757473841309547, -0.01833590865135193, -0.002247569849714637, -0.01748545467853546, 0.056588973850011826, 0.00359202828258276, -0.07614651322364807, 0.0601343959569931, -0.05910171568393707, 0.008469699881970882, -0.039289604872465134, 0.06983210891485214, 0.02623564563691616, 0.024091782048344612, -0.004784929100424051, -0.014595923945307732, 0.03720012307167053, -0.002409727079793811, -0.013698591850697994, 0.040798820555210114, 0.03643610700964928, -0.0036722838412970304, -0.01658395119011402, -0.014375261962413788, -0.01470228098332882, 0.004756938200443983, -0.013923351652920246, -0.04377888888120651, 0.027821892872452736, 0.06492673605680466, 0.01804867759346962, -0.00438303966075182, -0.041361548006534576, 0.005589385982602835, -0.04267994314432144, 0.0021056891418993473, -0.006419768091291189, 0.03254961967468262, -0.011664135381579399, 0.0683659166097641, 0.05274989455938339, -0.038310740143060684, 0.012870559468865395, 0.03863377496600151, -0.03879211097955704, 0.0475127212703228, -0.04094766452908516, -0.013941713608801365, -0.01446201466023922, -0.04661299288272858, 0.007981915958225727, -0.006705726962536573, 0.0016664351569488645, -0.028902802616357803, 0.025601709261536598, -0.01781122386455536, 0.008896906860172749, -0.01897324062883854, 0.0030948033090680838, -0.006363764870911837, 0.006594660226255655, -0.012460430152714252, -0.008630743250250816, 0.08096220344305038, 0.03945884481072426, -0.0011730247642844915, -0.001669654855504632, 0.0014954740181565285, 0.020046044141054153, 0.05147172883152962, 0.03941614553332329, 0.031394653022289276, 0.0013585002161562443, -0.02316904067993164, 0.016814226284623146, -0.018889442086219788, 0.06388219445943832, 0.03932075947523117, -0.050244469195604324, -0.015119998715817928, -0.016667716205120087, -0.01904623582959175, 0.020712541416287422, -0.008058690465986729, -0.0186285600066185, 0.03353971987962723, 0.06241957098245621, 0.0064602685160934925, -0.06218365579843521, 0.030089830979704857, 0.09018290042877197, 0.027620084583759308, 0.00947665236890316, -0.05684811994433403, -0.007690814323723316, -0.02636900171637535, -0.012358705513179302, 0.024296166375279427, -0.003123007481917739, -0.006202416494488716, -0.025793887674808502, 0.05188044533133507, -0.0020234344992786646, -0.07122847437858582, 0.03720466420054436, -0.030267011374235153, 0.020429721102118492, 0.01650273986160755, -0.028160545974969864, 0.04582229256629944, -0.014792145229876041, 0.028612446039915085, 0.008250470273196697, 0.0014098508981987834, -0.06625721603631973, -0.013363269157707691, 0.03559831529855728, 0.06055415794253349, -0.033218201249837875, 0.002963005332276225, -0.03810378536581993, 0.022726120427250862, 0.04124520719051361, -0.05410110205411911, 0.035258181393146515, -0.028521712869405746, 0.01799231953918934, -0.020647894591093063, -0.034828219562768936, -0.02792971022427082, -0.0014052442274987698, -0.009441903792321682, 0.016861988231539726, -0.03508181869983673, -0.018442394211888313, -0.02191338688135147, -0.012910403311252594, 0.04659724608063698, 0.07567321509122849, -0.012773987837135792, -0.009752270765602589, -0.014740503393113613, 0.0025028607342392206, -0.020247889682650566, -0.06359697133302689, 0.019405413419008255, -0.02168119139969349, 0.015154103748500347, 0.020724590867757797, -0.028926953673362732, -0.05461964011192322, 0.041350092738866806, 0.0014320033369585872, -0.020323704928159714, -0.0001988798176171258, -0.030484305694699287, 0.030920740216970444, 0.04425596818327904, -0.004128331318497658, 0.05070839822292328, 0.03468718379735947, -0.013397040776908398, 0.011763975024223328, -0.034997664391994476, 0.014020444825291634, -0.04909267649054527, 0.01135281566530466, -0.0217359010130167, -0.017634468153119087, -0.03930923715233803, -0.005611953791230917, 0.022980669513344765, 0.012756804004311562, 0.005187428090721369, -0.01064575370401144, -0.00623346259817481, -0.012217951938509941, 0.0345614068210125, 0.03807999938726425, -0.0315275639295578, 0.02219230867922306, -0.01127287931740284, -0.018472574651241302, 0.024415241554379463, -0.008595643565058708, -0.005402609705924988, 0.04141572117805481, -0.04597704857587814, 0.018124740570783615, -0.03232548385858536, -0.049743324518203735, -0.027252985164523125, -0.06891842186450958, 0.024455023929476738, -0.040755320340394974, -0.027189919725060463, -0.013785673305392265, -0.012445633299648762, -0.030681421980261803, 0.02250533737242222, 0.024052903056144714, 0.04469143599271774, -0.012288695201277733, 0.03379230201244354, 0.02987360954284668, 0.013624067418277264, -0.08054449409246445, -0.052565935999155045, 0.026990897953510284, 0.06568461656570435, -0.02396935038268566, -0.015178694389760494, -0.018768908455967903, -0.01563103124499321, -0.004539787769317627, -0.03165404871106148, 0.024244964122772217, -0.0006894277757965028, -0.050522781908512115, 0.004852897021919489, -0.00926910899579525, 0.05590509623289108, 0.013277992606163025, -0.007137684151530266, 0.017841683700680733, -0.015522862784564495, -0.027192363515496254, -0.006531084422022104, 0.023112766444683075, -0.043288085609674454, -0.024491628631949425, -0.023427989333868027, 0.019169524312019348, 0.06510960310697556, 0.004484210163354874, -0.040167130529880524, 0.020795725286006927, -0.011761742644011974, -0.0008381055667996407, -0.00043802798609249294, 0.010708324611186981, -0.006820454727858305, 0.003248872235417366, -0.0005881795077584684, 0.01928204484283924, -0.006957484874874353, 0.00048450121539644897, 0.034484732896089554, -0.03224143758416176, -0.003814459778368473, -0.000661947822663933, 0.08458089828491211, -0.038276270031929016, 0.02832067385315895, -0.025627657771110535, -0.020492026582360268, 0.02043314464390278, 0.023417284712195396, -0.007705494295805693, 0.020918723195791245, 0.023756442591547966, -0.03680151700973511, -0.003937790635973215, -0.025589637458324432, 0.008843202143907547, 0.04715942591428757, -0.011755933985114098, 0.02378891035914421, 0.014689088799059391, 0.009524605236947536, -0.012655835598707199, 0.0018799689132720232, -0.01789218559861183, -0.015587441623210907, 0.011453518643975258, 0.02721744403243065, -0.01099673192948103, 0.004758026916533709, 0.028254767879843712, 0.001030236715450883, 0.012412461452186108, 0.020958617329597473, 0.03464755788445473, -0.012938602827489376, 0.013531344942748547, 0.0361020490527153, -0.02553803101181984, 0.02423170767724514, -0.04124974086880684, 0.01098713930696249, -0.012160573154687881, -0.0038267611525952816, 0.01979750208556652, -0.023117993026971817, 0.017663434147834778, 0.006634770892560482, 0.005611892323940992, 0.002696433337405324, 0.015986867249011993, -0.011303557083010674, 0.017720915377140045, 0.02457614429295063, -0.019655033946037292, 0.0028141343500465155, 0.014389495365321636, 0.029336217790842056, -0.01935592107474804, -0.04704098775982857, 0.013525311835110188, -0.022737428545951843, -0.04409420117735863, 0.0034643623512238264, -0.006099494639784098, -0.028392011299729347, 0.022769374772906303, -0.03904793784022331, -0.0097888745367527, 0.03015260398387909, 0.0400836281478405, 0.001565685961395502, 0.0916018858551979, 0.0377814881503582, 0.03353223204612732, -0.0008428165456280112, -0.006396183744072914, 0.12020032107830048, 0.09150558710098267, -0.015324353240430355, -0.059433288872241974, 0.027245741337537766, -0.0022355832625180483, -0.00932946614921093, -0.009362459182739258, -0.0034631730522960424, 0.014605456031858921, -0.0012111931573599577, 0.04019901156425476, 0.04465869814157486, -0.008338160812854767, -0.028131399303674698, 0.04073828086256981, -0.01895030587911606, -0.03661475330591202, -0.02717454917728901, 0.02095719240605831, -0.02421548217535019, -0.03976469114422798, -0.0008025525603443384, 0.012760324403643608, -0.012611143290996552, -0.0038896207697689533, 0.0013074410380795598, -0.01963413506746292, -0.022384144365787506, 0.022468091920018196, -0.03971097990870476, -0.019626211374998093, 0.02276306413114071, -0.021487170830368996, -0.04923514276742935, -0.02960725501179695, 0.009479322470724583, -0.00008801797230262309, -0.01461368054151535, 0.03523889183998108, -0.027480024844408035, -0.008118228055536747, 0.008012853562831879, 0.02536791004240513, -0.06307503581047058, -0.03546835109591484, -0.06529063731431961, 0.0022706252057105303, 0.007844347506761551, 0.01729760318994522, -0.010953716933727264, -0.004065698478370905, -0.02040768787264824, -0.05717727541923523, 0.0069675566628575325, 0.007983698509633541, 0.0052419137209653854, -0.031957317143678665, -0.04320243373513222, -0.0578172504901886, 0.0009238819475285709, -0.014740423299372196, 0.011310593225061893, 0.05386402830481529, -0.031811319291591644, -0.010992354713380337, -0.010042659007012844, 0.0315830335021019, 0.0024285223335027695, 0.012468507513403893, 0.019698230549693108, -0.011444758623838425, -0.05204680934548378, 0.01747814752161503, 0.0109506044536829, -0.00638183718547225, 0.04353408142924309, 0.01601155288517475, 0.005211437586694956, 0.015830177813768387, -0.054477330297231674, 0.010243302211165428, -0.028269512578845024, -0.004846407566219568, -0.05179956182837486, 0.005653757601976395, -0.002211802639067173, 0.02623922936618328, -0.005437804851680994, 0.04115478694438934, -0.02686934359371662, 0.05409269407391548, 0.014960123226046562, -0.0574558861553669, -0.026986531913280487, -0.0019001587061211467, -0.06849119812250137, 0.01756516471505165, 0.0299262423068285, 0.040394376963377, 0.03029063530266285, 0.052769143134355545, 0.016507383435964584, -0.017142869532108307, 0.0024040495045483112, 0.01972518116235733, -0.005177385173738003, -0.047402702271938324, -0.022648850455880165, 0.023797079920768738, 0.003358512418344617, -0.03066984936594963, -0.018656309694051743, -0.030848093330860138, -0.011979456059634686, 0.028105799108743668, -0.005776559468358755, -0.012722109444439411, 0.025716030970215797, 0.022928163409233093, -0.017187263816595078, -0.013922874815762043, -0.02333075739443302, -0.037349432706832886, -0.02152973599731922, 0.034830931574106216, 0.006072856020182371, -0.004424222279340029, 0.008348115719854832, -0.011171555146574974, 0.012376776896417141, 0.05855507031083107, 0.005315415095537901, -0.0002855459460988641, -0.0318959578871727, 0.04730500653386116, 0.007578497752547264, 0.044172029942274094, -0.041213907301425934, -0.010354188270866871, 0.06356829404830933, -0.03165457397699356, -0.017745887860655785, 0.03164741396903992, -0.003615416819229722, 0.01891208626329899, 0.005076802801340818, 0.010582084767520428, 0.013024749234318733, 0.020119115710258484, -0.023681245744228363, -0.007606150582432747, 0.00770055316388607, 0.007338914554566145, 0.026277713477611542, 0.006362943910062313, -0.026543838903307915, 0.03545737266540527, 0.018199816346168518, 0.024473685771226883, 0.030061010271310806, 0.012352684512734413, -0.022024592384696007, 0.002630294533446431, -0.003316215006634593, -0.0020243837498128414, 0.0015298807993531227, 0.0005532095674425364, 0.0107760950922966, 0.021072285249829292, -0.011480928398668766, 0.06447470933198929, -0.025570809841156006, -0.0121725182980299, -0.07340916246175766, -0.012193236500024796, 0.01708013191819191, 0.028820818290114403, 0.03380914404988289, -0.041317399591207504, 0.00788541603833437, 0.046746548265218735, -0.061519086360931396, -0.027587709948420525, 0.0013908670516684651, 0.011645225808024406, -0.026683947071433067, -0.022247491404414177, -0.03690425306558609, -0.0069571612402796745, 0.01878095045685768, 0.02467305399477482, 0.029910828918218613, 0.02887575700879097, 0.002000453881919384, -0.030171627178788185, -0.008123661391437054, 0.04955893009901047, -0.0024864529259502888, -0.060327909886837006, 0.021276338025927544, -0.02278471551835537, -0.023866254836320877, 0.0523424968123436, -0.014076920226216316, 0.02730623632669449, 0.03083072230219841, 0.027809374034404755, -0.009053826332092285, 0.03840300068259239, 0.05743243917822838, 0.03199773281812668, -0.004003891721367836, 0.006530210841447115, 0.0033040407579392195, 0.03657158091664314, -0.027921827509999275, -0.03191594034433365, 0.02515810914337635, -0.05132633447647095, -0.04627358540892601, 0.043683260679244995, -0.030408354476094246, 0.017768288031220436, 0.005946211516857147, -0.013895177282392979, -0.03554455563426018, -0.059848301112651825, 0.040080826729536057, -0.044959113001823425, -0.02679467387497425, 0.051170818507671356, 0.018255166709423065, -0.022514766082167625, -0.021389160305261612, 0.006354638375341892, -0.03571067377924919, 0.020919645205140114, 0.011173714883625507, -0.035345226526260376, -0.04268458113074303, 0.028805585578083992, -0.010895137675106525, 0.025289881974458694, 0.01283292006701231, -0.017509160563349724, -0.03569216653704643, 0.05822645500302315, -0.007385731674730778, -0.0068475776351988316, 0.027596784755587578, 0.0017543911235406995, -0.02373446151614189, -0.0926167294383049, 0.07711612433195114, -0.008136759512126446, -0.03663525730371475, -0.0592995323240757, 0.006800102535635233, -0.00623852526769042, -0.018065322190523148, -0.011224858462810516, 0.047295816242694855, -0.015242861583828926, 0.020459983497858047, 0.020651506260037422, 0.0321417935192585, -0.05560798570513725, 0.014119729399681091, -0.01977715641260147, -0.00205752020701766, -0.0115221431478858, -0.005761495791375637, -0.010398619808256626, 0.013347801752388477, 0.0047171954065561295, -0.014634011313319206, 0.0431424044072628, 0.014787096530199051, 0.013609678484499454, 0.04025530442595482, 0.006671939976513386, -0.020276589319109917, 0.07985571026802063, -0.004813618957996368, -0.0016936298925429583, 0.03774383291602135, -0.00038018127088434994, -0.05788226053118706, 0.02154430001974106, -0.012258538976311684, -0.01302691362798214, 0.019861649721860886, 0.029276162385940552, -0.005471497308462858, -0.062186338007450104, -0.026823166757822037, 0.034966301172971725, -0.030952343717217445, 0.009088964201509953, 0.023614006116986275, 0.017036063596606255, 0.04038378968834877, -0.006416221149265766, 0.0338677279651165, 0.02564825490117073, -0.04373008757829666, 0.003745277412235737, 0.010879069566726685, 0.037085022777318954, -0.043448951095342636, 0.024849940091371536, 0.0379185788333416, 0.006152340676635504, -0.010846029035747051, 0.01820438914000988, 0.03791311755776405, -0.027099233120679855, -0.02614268660545349, 0.02293078415095806, 0.002829199191182852, 0.0080762580037117, 0.018457947298884392, -0.006317186169326305, 0.03223559632897377, -0.04004380851984024, 0.01945900358259678, -0.033355921506881714, -0.00631764717400074, -0.037927404046058655, 0.005317794159054756, 0.05146024003624916, -0.036928754299879074, 0.026409318670630455, -0.010285011492669582, 0.03270893171429634, 0.007992113940417767, 0.02775692008435726, -0.03602462261915207, 0.008860133588314056, -0.0056983958929777145, 0.011097341775894165, -0.0756964311003685, 0.009071152657270432, -0.002511553233489394, -0.008363725617527962, 0.006105322856456041, 0.015327812172472477, 0.004853192716836929, 0.025727584958076477, -0.03294283524155617, 0.005206335801631212, 0.07221123576164246, -0.04180201515555382, -0.008265558630228043, -0.0397912859916687, 0.023096757009625435, 0.006152067333459854, -0.060342349112033844 ]
<p>According to the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Approximate_Bayesian_computation" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia article</a>, we have the scenario shown below, but how can ABC generate simulation datasets from samples of $\theta$ without knowing or evaluating the likelihood function?</p> <p>For example, how would this method work for a normal $N(\mu, \sigma)$ distribution? Assuming that the parameter to estimate is $\mu$ and that $\sigma$ is known, how would it generate the simulations without evaluating $N(\mu, \sigma)$?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/pkpG0.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
36,117
[ -0.023901019245386124, -0.04756254702806473, -0.0013506878167390823, -0.038270726799964905, 0.03113011084496975, 0.023214874789118767, -0.018181607127189636, -0.004773912951350212, 0.02627592533826828, -0.0424322634935379, -0.004891789518296719, 0.0532502606511116, 0.08130530267953873, 0.03130016103386879, 0.014298147521913052, 0.007736605126410723, -0.031971003860235214, 0.050255414098501205, -0.03393306955695152, -0.024007698521018028, 0.03577003628015518, 0.020384205505251884, 0.015881866216659546, -0.06003875285387039, 0.00818618480116129, 0.016095802187919617, 0.047928545624017715, -0.05045574530959129, -0.042089659720659256, 0.06947177648544312, -0.030492335557937622, -0.013512344099581242, -0.004801873583346605, 0.028750132769346237, 0.0055368756875395775, -0.031502459198236465, -0.05516374856233597, -0.02650836855173111, 0.030614571645855904, 0.038952864706516266, -0.050754815340042114, -0.013750460930168629, -0.022056039422750473, 0.05153920128941536, -0.032871685922145844, -0.008357828482985497, -0.03130515292286873, -0.018376963213086128, 0.011072085238993168, -0.04100676253437996, 0.010937770828604698, -0.0023672229144722223, 0.018246961757540703, 0.048252951353788376, 0.014940468594431877, -0.030943913385272026, 0.027530604973435402, 0.06643765419721603, -0.030417924746870995, -0.04576929658651352, 0.011440806090831757, -0.01808123290538788, 0.006017342675477266, -0.04199576377868652, -0.03659050166606903, 0.017991602420806885, 0.019716031849384308, -0.009932556189596653, 0.03517887741327286, 0.007262175437062979, 0.00995213259011507, 0.04296424984931946, 0.01956702210009098, 0.0016818250296637416, 0.011916810646653175, -0.0005769786657765508, 0.0004876056918874383, 0.012170237489044666, 0.023751618340611458, 0.01948367804288864, -0.01738884113729, 0.004492928273975849, 0.029419394209980965, 0.04048062115907669, -0.022176917642354965, -0.00562282232567668, 0.05886925384402275, -0.02272609807550907, 0.012860682792961597, 0.0025941221974790096, -0.03820477053523064, 0.04731180891394615, 0.02410205267369747, -0.06850215047597885, -0.05370406433939934, 0.07090659439563751, -0.010559000074863434, 0.07585389912128448, -0.017854267731308937, -0.05233520269393921, -0.0020991037599742413, -0.05288863554596901, 0.005205674096941948, 0.049837108701467514, -0.025186577811837196, -0.022577669471502304, 0.007688852492719889, 0.013134240172803402, -0.021406831219792366, -0.02321755513548851, 0.005222261417657137, 0.031090907752513885, 0.006539354100823402, -0.000014261616342992056, 0.015320442616939545, 0.00208740564994514, 0.02606557123363018, -0.03184542804956436, 0.03062203712761402, 0.06664326041936874, 0.01809917576611042, -0.01702757552266121, 0.028732184320688248, -0.030564719811081886, -0.05430380627512932, -0.009785070084035397, -0.021627994254231453, -0.04463578015565872, -0.042473744601011276, 0.02740047127008438, -0.02231760323047638, -0.011572455987334251, 0.06100739538669586, 0.031364280730485916, 0.005608975421637297, 0.001624944736249745, -0.08800867944955826, -0.04335934668779373, 0.026735780760645866, -0.036997195333242416, 0.027069296687841415, -0.06376741081476212, 0.02009817771613598, 0.04971080645918846, 0.012507951818406582, 0.02505102939903736, 0.045351650565862656, 0.025896096602082253, 0.04631144925951958, 0.02996746264398098, 0.006361645180732012, 0.0027347553987056017, -0.017660219222307205, 0.017027661204338074, -0.02925148606300354, -0.09225224703550339, 0.046856846660375595, 0.001920668059028685, -0.010840586386620998, -0.041727520525455475, 0.05861799046397209, -0.018896376714110374, -0.038501717150211334, -0.03446445241570473, 0.04359481483697891, -0.025664741173386574, 0.07218124717473984, 0.019183626398444176, 0.004484566394239664, 0.012162460014224052, -0.04103902727365494, 0.0005223802872933447, 0.014406719245016575, 0.051686860620975494, 0.08027969300746918, -0.0360199511051178, 0.00897134281694889, -0.0070149037055671215, 0.05709752067923546, 0.011315032839775085, 0.007082361727952957, 0.02560553140938282, -0.008608633652329445, 0.007959199137985706, 0.029373766854405403, 0.04266390949487686, 0.009122069925069809, -0.023613419383764267, 0.027722874656319618, -0.0657077431678772, -0.038733091205358505, -0.08564630150794983, 0.016688890755176544, 0.00036630238173529506, -0.0015179301844909787, 0.03709885850548744, -0.010523498058319092, 0.0225455854088068, 0.0129707595333457, -0.020597152411937714, -0.022657375782728195, -0.013091647066175938, 0.025626687332987785, -0.024951696395874023, 0.015840711072087288, 0.053292032331228256, 0.06602124124765396, -0.010090310126543045, 0.03308400139212608, -0.022035960108041763, -0.06614649295806885, 0.0033209421671926975, -0.0635388195514679, 0.0009164788061752915, 0.0016740629216656089, 0.000055243177484953776, 0.00382417649962008, -0.0030325709376484156, -0.00665257778018713, 0.011843816377222538, -0.047969311475753784, 0.054083451628685, 0.07038965076208115, 0.013702691532671452, 0.011746147647500038, 0.029167892411351204, 0.029973872005939484, -0.01349206455051899, 0.007419474422931671, -0.007477357052266598, -0.07840743660926819, -0.012012355029582977, 0.08632949739694595, -0.023323774337768555, -0.04316750541329384, 0.022037595510482788, -0.002306573558598757, 0.017868705093860626, 0.05484936013817787, 0.045184727758169174, -0.008230987004935741, 0.0009583802311681211, 0.03241051360964775, 0.02331920899450779, 0.008784613572061062, 0.012618687003850937, 0.022858181968331337, -0.001171019859611988, 0.024307891726493835, -0.022038044407963753, -0.00738076027482748, 0.06226796656847, -0.031703606247901917, -0.02153058536350727, -0.03841027617454529, -0.01755923219025135, 0.013438314199447632, -0.04174724966287613, 0.005736266262829304, -0.01063423603773117, 0.018418656662106514, 0.006839704234153032, 0.03277032822370529, -0.025117237120866776, 0.04172027111053467, 0.037660811096429825, -0.012940218672156334, -0.011462071910500526, 0.015855440869927406, -0.016747500747442245, 0.028095364570617676, -0.022834589704871178, -0.03164137527346611, -0.0163686815649271, 0.007466546259820461, 0.015037447214126587, 0.0019779165741056204, -0.0020427696872502565, -0.029908742755651474, -0.07429532706737518, -0.018791809678077698, -0.001265142229385674, 0.020381685346364975, 0.055026862770318985, -0.04013458639383316, 0.001162489759735763, -0.002590089337900281, -0.037016622722148895, -0.008924117311835289, -0.020849397405982018, -0.028733810409903526, 0.008958257734775543, -0.005708233453333378, -0.052404481917619705, -0.002882883185520768, 0.00443965382874012, -0.03446424379944801, -0.02454111911356449, -0.010041732341051102, 0.02269844524562359, 0.07289813458919525, -0.00940140150487423, 0.02618361823260784, -0.03480694442987442, -0.04252612218260765, -0.011331211775541306, 0.02218382991850376, -0.005061186850070953, -0.05289595201611519, 0.06484931707382202, 0.027375783771276474, -0.054056767374277115, 0.006017162464559078, -0.04909846559166908, -0.055752139538526535, -0.0017716104630380869, -0.010553140193223953, 0.006260978989303112, -0.0017253479454666376, -0.017886558547616005, 0.0923401415348053, -0.01131664589047432, -0.05791346728801727, 0.01060399878770113, 0.0029776727315038443, -0.005820451304316521, -0.055229708552360535, -0.003198666498064995, 0.030734200030565262, -0.025369761511683464, 0.004777404014021158, 0.01602538675069809, 0.004652088508009911, 0.05379335582256317, 0.012799061834812164, 0.021272633224725723, 0.011585399508476257, -0.0163275133818388, 0.0028200342785567045, 0.023996597155928612, 0.004770546220242977, -0.030284669250249863, 0.015248090028762817, -0.019251221790909767, 0.01784594915807247, 0.043611519038677216, -0.055308129638433456, 0.014547877945005894, -0.02185801789164543, -0.026524929329752922, -0.055754441767930984, 0.027593761682510376, 0.01559790875762701, -0.04945561662316322, -0.011448088102042675, 0.03405673801898956, 0.021494656801223755, -0.012115812860429287, -0.029477110132575035, 0.030712900683283806, 0.020894471555948257, -0.04363479092717171, -0.019774865359067917, -0.014398525469005108, -0.014082630164921284, 0.0029884662944823503, 0.003655120963230729, -0.007485501002520323, 0.021666329354047775, 0.0607612244784832, 0.013371998444199562, -0.003349430626258254, -0.0077415695413947105, -0.017098519951105118, -0.04341163486242294, -0.001306047081016004, -0.049260858446359634, 0.029599066823720932, 0.007932196371257305, 0.059484537690877914, 0.00502598425373435, 0.0083477096632123, -0.0031933027785271406, 0.004896261729300022, -0.07863003760576248, 0.018281012773513794, 0.009404223412275314, -0.04696280509233475, 0.026709744706749916, -0.032510243356227875, 0.07771094888448715, -0.01195052731782198, 0.009193872101604939, -0.035479817539453506, 0.008268900215625763, -0.029801759868860245, -0.013464382849633694, -0.0447043851017952, -0.005860910750925541, -0.01941036246716976, 0.037976548075675964, 0.041496142745018005, -0.0362577922642231, 0.009481825865805149, 0.037826087325811386, 0.014408880844712257, -0.007014689967036247, -0.03514890745282173, 0.02422131411731243, -0.03396028280258179, 0.02670552209019661, 0.057399798184633255, 0.03573112189769745, -0.02600671350955963, -0.0024357642978429794, 0.02079600840806961, 0.09332277625799179, 0.061028141528367996, 0.020838698372244835, -0.028412533923983574, -0.014866120181977749, -0.014391237869858742, -0.0005766249378211796, 0.019039936363697052, 0.005707280244678259, 0.002306630602106452, 0.0647657960653305, 0.023783063516020775, -0.028329314664006233, 0.015859147533774376, 0.036055874079465866, 0.01368408277630806, -0.00048333051381632686, -0.036222122609615326, -0.0053970166482031345, -0.026830194517970085, -0.020301003009080887, 0.0443904884159565, 0.005835165269672871, 0.0033233005087822676, 0.01696029305458069, 0.012316669337451458, -0.00974372960627079, -0.019068699330091476, 0.002764385659247637, 0.031246332451701164, 0.043874114751815796, 0.05422719940543175, -0.007132465019822121, 0.008859775960445404, 0.031346388161182404, 0.0341896116733551, 0.00840892642736435, 0.009726371616125107, -0.07094648480415344, 0.0013017180608585477, -0.004169557709246874, 0.0021365778520703316, -0.0009723221301101148, 0.006065966561436653, -0.0790431946516037, -0.005553419701755047, 0.05459893122315407, -0.014204734936356544, 0.002418023534119129, -0.034570008516311646, 0.011186372488737106, -0.022662559524178505, 0.002420509932562709, -0.029188062995672226, -0.016784867271780968, -0.04342680796980858, 0.019572792574763298, -0.029578372836112976, 0.0017514661885797977, -0.010036850348114967, 0.006706816144287586, 0.018064532428979874, 0.06891100853681564, -0.020351523533463478, -0.020356662571430206, -0.0007281450089067221, 0.008135415613651276, 0.0075436607003211975, -0.035161182284355164, 0.014009295962750912, -0.012191995978355408, -0.008235692046582699, 0.012221495620906353, -0.043704841285943985, -0.03557952120900154, 0.033451151102781296, -0.008130078203976154, 0.016638556495308876, -0.006189084146171808, -0.0321522019803524, 0.03396526351571083, 0.026734674349427223, -0.0071298605762422085, 0.06571736931800842, 0.025206053629517555, 0.009974521584808826, -0.001078697619959712, -0.058376334607601166, -0.01120859943330288, -0.02456655539572239, -0.015592029318213463, -0.05560098960995674, 0.018635328859090805, 0.0003237480123061687, -0.0019889597315341234, 0.0077256327494978905, 0.022680487483739853, 0.0015522969188168645, -0.04103465750813484, -0.006487073376774788, 0.06249425932765007, 0.03821585327386856, 0.013279971666634083, -0.02983376756310463, 0.021540187299251556, 0.00982144195586443, 0.005326713901013136, -0.0065156263299286366, -0.024990251287817955, 0.018691416829824448, -0.002885294146835804, -0.03734162822365761, 0.013505506329238415, -0.06481298804283142, -0.013815761543810368, 0.05214396119117737, -0.05477264150977135, 0.04447333887219429, -0.00482500996440649, 0.029160751029849052, -0.0006774970679543912, -0.07917912304401398, -0.026504812762141228, 0.003440831322222948, -0.006493764463812113, 0.045319560915231705, -0.027434058487415314, 0.006289646029472351, -0.017839983105659485, 0.027691233903169632, -0.04108274728059769, -0.03733965754508972, -0.0013880468904972076, -0.0020960145629942417, -0.008967997506260872, -0.034577809274196625, -0.015224148519337177, 0.0022948398254811764, -0.01841592788696289, -0.008381880819797516, 0.05954333394765854, 0.005274221301078796, -0.021864842623472214, -0.002358989557251334, 0.015834607183933258, 0.04644789919257164, 0.03335573151707649, 0.012722419574856758, 0.04724162817001343, -0.03995498642325401, 0.012383447960019112, 0.014723318628966808, 0.017991751432418823, -0.03699512034654617, 0.008674277924001217, -0.001537177013233304, 0.0197242833673954, 0.01908187009394169, -0.014760279096662998, -0.013069161213934422, 0.0006171936984173954, 0.040556035935878754, 0.0074660819955170155, -0.005712142679840326, -0.021652819588780403, -0.01400960236787796, 0.032801464200019836, -0.05207112804055214, -0.019156331196427345, -0.0067965504713356495, 0.02398419938981533, 0.04546574503183365, 0.0006912709795869887, 0.002367307897657156, 0.03697075694799423, 0.06738568097352982, -0.035132553428411484, -0.01876973919570446, 0.005257702898234129, 0.01966322399675846, 0.041256364434957504, 0.0240219384431839, 0.02610383741557598, 0.02904036082327366, 0.023859642446041107, -0.012520150281488895, -0.0001217298413394019, -0.07912681251764297, -0.013121701776981354, 0.06511865556240082, -0.004457848612219095, 0.08183488994836807, 0.02052110992372036, -0.0013366348575800657, -0.00755595788359642, -0.055024802684783936, -0.014279646798968315, -0.0051647997461259365, -0.0015241700457409024, 0.0206932220607996, -0.004698554985225201, -0.012895191088318825, 0.015810871496796608, -0.0018247946863994002, 0.02298172563314438, 0.018092472106218338, 0.02162228710949421, 0.03588346764445305, 0.0025501272175461054, -0.025825511664152145, -0.03454706817865372, 0.03977946192026138, -0.03364499285817146, 0.03298944607377052, -0.02404163032770157, -0.03829120472073555, 0.05773845687508583, 0.009520894847810268, 0.012774351984262466, -0.04230490326881409, 0.02360660396516323, -0.025777993723750114, 0.024038370698690414, 0.014788467437028885, 0.005508830770850182, 0.03204931318759918, -0.013120176270604134, 0.007137857377529144, -0.03425899147987366, 0.02120278589427471, -0.005619881208986044, -0.09226693212985992, -0.047202952206134796, -0.0034104641526937485, -0.007171302102506161, 0.04202026501297951, 0.022696956992149353, -0.019639380276203156, 0.02482118271291256, -0.02550974301993847, 0.059498172253370285, -0.004857826046645641, 0.012643430382013321, -0.032623402774333954, 0.07013461738824844, -0.01745026372373104, 0.07325390726327896, -0.024213524535298347, -0.02522137388586998, 0.11272978037595749, 0.04916755110025406, 0.03774721547961235, -0.04635007306933403, 0.013248764909803867, -0.04865201190114021, 0.015781473368406296, -0.02561592310667038, 0.02124645747244358, 0.034946125000715256, -0.017510004341602325, -0.013140996918082237, 0.038498878479003906, 0.001463265740312636, 0.01155391801148653, 0.04350250959396362, -0.028508683666586876, -0.05332856997847557, -0.002353884279727936, 0.000673799542710185, -0.013896196149289608, -0.030958330258727074, -0.04616820439696312, 0.002875116653740406, -0.018613917753100395, -0.049518946558237076, -0.010114178992807865, -0.03744552657008171, -0.022539479658007622, 0.005219766870141029, -0.023617584258317947, 0.00948391668498516, 0.0260417889803648, 0.005608682055026293, 0.01371764950454235, 0.006276125553995371, -0.007196455262601376, 0.0021306893322616816, 0.017971642315387726, 0.051147185266017914, -0.00794591847807169, -0.009542143903672695, -0.009158286266028881, 0.009454251267015934, -0.031150255352258682, -0.007411375641822815, -0.05266764760017395, 0.048400238156318665, -0.05183766782283783, -0.015654606744647026, -0.031519096344709396, -0.012682324275374413, 0.0015480051515623927, 0.00871772225946188, 0.025406422093510628, 0.006595904938876629, 0.005302883218973875, -0.03439878299832344, 0.009389587678015232, 0.0033474487718194723, 0.029147792607545853, 0.010785732418298721, 0.04868638515472412, 0.014358981512486935, -0.03444000333547592, -0.01697336882352829, -0.0050109862349927425, 0.007265734486281872, -0.012933599762618542, -0.019421333447098732, 0.0006295813946053386, -0.018518740311264992, -0.04942219704389572, -0.008853518404066563, 0.026118749752640724, -0.02370985969901085, 0.02693392150104046, -0.007024950347840786, 0.023848101496696472, 0.01602390594780445, -0.03216075524687767, -0.012676676735281944, -0.05777232348918915, -0.009710768237709999, -0.037333887070417404, -0.012534051202237606, 0.01988336071372032, 0.04072308912873268, 0.02549598179757595, 0.007801305968314409, 0.0019639027304947376, 0.02889406681060791, 0.03193402662873268, -0.02496139332652092, -0.04097459465265274, 0.0004155716160312295, -0.013521688058972359, 0.013370433822274208, 0.00532491086050868, 0.03746764734387398, 0.025910159572958946, 0.041849467903375626, 0.0012664548121392727, 0.030587581917643547, 0.0023970776237547398, 0.03414412587881088, -0.027412816882133484, -0.03878629580140114, 0.03121485561132431, 0.042339153587818146, 0.023500848561525345, -0.009560728445649147, -0.011624504812061787, 0.0066407728008925915, -0.01495016273111105, 0.01603417657315731, -0.014515374787151814, -0.06208301708102226, -0.0016887858510017395, -0.0015217922627925873, 0.012776496820151806, -0.0005769676063209772, 0.027830272912979126, 0.03116675093770027, -0.015399114228785038, -0.044612787663936615, 0.015942126512527466, -0.006617644801735878, 0.011983169242739677, -0.025417763739824295, -0.0033522474113851786, 0.02517406828701496, 0.004729006439447403, -0.0012696278281509876, 0.015078681521117687, 0.012468171305954456, -0.006203826051205397, 0.003387426258996129, -0.0177728533744812, -0.04583137109875679, 0.02864815853536129, -0.06216889247298241, -0.03443476930260658, 0.03627791628241539, -0.011028717271983624, 0.05182033032178879, 0.026839828118681908, -0.035823553800582886, -0.00722877960652113, 0.03365634009242058, -0.08392562717199326, -0.002984943799674511, -0.005841270554810762, 0.0369032584130764, 0.011120562441647053, -0.008259874768555164, 0.009841724298894405, 0.012070891447365284, 0.023641038686037064, 0.05426042899489403, 0.02395292930305004, 0.004569671116769314, -0.040326058864593506, 0.00040981805068440735, 0.030767221003770828, 0.009119691327214241, 0.0015382273122668266, 0.008092106319963932, 0.0070389858447015285, 0.07521403580904007, 0.001347597106359899, 0.0417327843606472, -0.03939438983798027, -0.015442433767020702, -0.10684050619602203, -0.008541314862668514, 0.024182435125112534, -0.015455094166100025, 0.05370079353451729, -0.03363972529768944, 0.024245547130703926, 0.031012551859021187, -0.04754428192973137, 0.018807636573910713, 0.007134956773370504, -0.00041620898991823196, -0.037114616483449936, -0.019076727330684662, -0.03565775603055954, 0.022426757961511612, 0.03158268332481384, 0.01067277416586876, 0.029826097190380096, -0.050982728600502014, -0.001986535033211112, 0.001857699709944427, 0.008150521665811539, 0.02134544402360916, 0.02699199877679348, -0.03018512949347496, 0.026017919182777405, -0.022559763863682747, -0.046251051127910614, 0.007012016139924526, 0.02855193242430687, 0.007281281519681215, 0.012180821970105171, 0.014989425428211689, -0.004956667311489582, 0.04313380643725395, 0.04566638544201851, -0.016365477815270424, 0.019130120053887367, 0.023578176274895668, 0.02081858552992344, 0.04595671594142914, -0.017420513555407524, 0.012892761267721653, -0.0009186156094074249, 0.013607652857899666, -0.07254735380411148, 0.03142022714018822, -0.01006943266838789, -0.03964640200138092, 0.01166883111000061, -0.020929232239723206, -0.008014463819563389, 0.008879998698830605, 0.02261134423315525, -0.03602271527051926, 0.025233926251530647, 0.04461042210459709, 0.020038945600390434, -0.005399361252784729, 0.014668986201286316, -0.043367888778448105, -0.05052201449871063, 0.0016815676353871822, -0.014917690306901932, -0.05986614525318146, -0.01804208755493164, -0.01572945900261402, 0.015920506790280342, 0.00006907565693836659, -0.02239452861249447, 0.009256732650101185, -0.0202278271317482, 0.04922566935420036, -0.01587378792464733, 0.006286116316914558, 0.021167919039726257, -0.025902358815073967, -0.008800975047051907, -0.058694709092378616, 0.0852293074131012, -0.03616788238286972, -0.02122564986348152, -0.030250322073698044, -0.014243017882108688, 0.0009886485058814287, -0.027170879766345024, 0.051143158227205276, -0.0138664236292243, 0.016328511759638786, -0.007050254847854376, 0.047333624213933945, 0.005705788265913725, -0.005420618690550327, 0.044169604778289795, -0.01572992652654648, -0.03323904052376747, -0.019977783784270287, -0.0002849609008990228, 0.021610477939248085, 0.02701514959335327, -0.017507756128907204, 0.0009928237413987517, -0.007986116223037243, -0.0012998676393181086, -0.023865701630711555, 0.033444683998823166, 0.002257640939205885, 0.0036806014832109213, 0.04796117916703224, 0.008387361653149128, 0.016519714146852493, 0.03421560674905777, 0.012066577561199665, -0.044632669538259506, 0.042893726378679276, -0.01738964021205902, -0.023766392841935158, -0.01488447654992342, -0.012408574111759663, 0.01713450253009796, -0.04634593054652214, -0.02461451292037964, 0.007187587209045887, -0.020459208637475967, 0.026874054223299026, 0.02585332840681076, -0.00482712360098958, 0.04621287062764168, 0.02460695430636406, 0.022717075422406197, -0.007640657015144825, 0.018890565261244774, 0.012909186072647572, 0.025170646607875824, 0.02148926444351673, -0.05129861831665039, 0.017343726009130478, 0.0573701411485672, -0.015359046868979931, -0.002063847379758954, -0.0258236862719059, 0.02877509780228138, -0.008651308715343475, -0.04031028971076012, 0.013025745749473572, -0.029763342812657356, 0.024266716092824936, -0.013803470879793167, -0.009809461422264576, 0.11924869567155838, -0.02795333042740822, -0.025409631431102753, -0.021662702783942223, 0.018117651343345642, -0.04679083451628685, 0.0035554259084165096, -0.04207705333828926, 0.002696015639230609, 0.01204171497374773, -0.02486082725226879, -0.009626463986933231, -0.006097399163991213, 0.02956417202949524, -0.026148103177547455, -0.008614907041192055, 0.018509050831198692, 0.0021506601478904486, -0.01790687069296837, -0.023294180631637573, -0.03453369438648224, -0.009291544556617737, 0.024212313815951347, 0.013002460822463036, 0.021131332963705063, -0.01195137482136488, -0.032725121825933456, 0.005720987915992737, 0.03303150087594986, -0.06711449474096298, 0.007111826911568642, -0.018200865015387535, -0.005163668654859066, 0.011494315229356289, -0.019672788679599762 ]